id sid tid token lemma pos work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 1 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 2 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 3 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 4 419 419 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 5 APPRENDICITIS apprendicitis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 6 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 7 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 8 TROUBLING troubling NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 9 DIAGNOSIS diagnosi NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 10 FOR for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 11 THE the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 12 SENTENCING sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 13 OF of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 14 HACKERS hacker NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 16 THIEVES THIEVES NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 18 FRAUDSTERS fraudster NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 20 AND and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 21 TAX tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 22 CHEATS CHEATS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 23 Justin Justin NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 24 A. A. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 25 Thornton Thornton NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 26 * * NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 27 Mark Mark NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 28 H. H. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 29 Allenbaugh Allenbaugh NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 30 * * NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 31 * * NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 32 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 33 T]he T]he NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 34 immediate immediate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 35 aim aim NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 37 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 38 legislation legislation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 39 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 40 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 41 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 42 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 43 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 45 things thing NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 46 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 47 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 48 usually usually RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 49 mentioned mention VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 50 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 51 justifying justify VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 52 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 53 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 54 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 55 until until IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 56 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 57 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 58 settled settle VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 59 what what WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 60 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 61 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 62 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 63 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 64 legally legally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 65 denounced denounce VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 66 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 67 discouraged discourage VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 68 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 69 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 70 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 71 settled settle VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 72 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 73 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 74 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 75 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 76 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 77 deter deter VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 78 people people NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 79 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 80 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 81 who who WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 82 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 83 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 84 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 85 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 86 criminals criminal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 87 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 88 whom whom WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 89 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 90 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 91 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 92 exact exact VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 93 retribution retribution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 94 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 95 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 96 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 97 whom whom WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 98 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 99 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 100 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 101 wreak wreak VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 102 vengeance vengeance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 103 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 104 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 105 whom whom WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 106 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 107 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 108 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 109 reform reform VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 110 .1 .1 . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 111 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 112 difficulty difficulty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 113 I -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 114 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 115 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 116 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 117 nowhere nowhere RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 118 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 119 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 120 defined define VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 121 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 122 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 123 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 124 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 125 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 126 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 127 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 128 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 129 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 130 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 131 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 132 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 133 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 134 factor.2 factor.2 UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 135 It -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 136 ’s ’ VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 137 just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 138 drafting draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 1 139 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 1 Is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 2 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 3 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 4 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 5 is?3 is?3 VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 6 INTRODUCTION introduction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 7 On on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 8 June June NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 9 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 11 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 14 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 15 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 16 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 17 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 18 issued issue VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 19 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 20 momentous momentous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 22 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 23 nearly nearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 24 overlooked overlook VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 26 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 27 regarding regard VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 28 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 29 * * NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 30 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 31 Thornton Thornton NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 32 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 33 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 34 white white JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 35 collar collar NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 36 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 37 defense defense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 38 attorney attorney NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 39 practicing practicing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 40 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 41 Washington Washington NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 43 D.C. D.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 44 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 45 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 46 Department Department NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 47 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 48 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 49 trial trial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 50 attorney attorney NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 51 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 52 ten ten CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 53 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 54 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 55 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 56 Thornton Thornton NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 57 successfully successfully RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 58 prosecuted prosecute VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 59 throughout throughout IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 60 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 61 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 62 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 63 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 64 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 65 75 75 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 66 complex complex JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 67 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 68 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 69 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 2 70 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 1 He -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 2 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 4 recipient recipient NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 7 Tax Tax NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 8 Division Division NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 9 ’s ’s NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 10 Outstanding Outstanding NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 11 Attorney Attorney NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 12 Award Award NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 15 IRS IRS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 16 Assistant Assistant NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 17 Commissioner Commissioner NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 18 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 19 Award Award NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 3 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 2 private private JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 3 practice practice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 4 since since IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 5 1987 1987 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 7 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 8 Thornton Thornton NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 9 now now RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 10 represents represent VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 11 individuals individual NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 12 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 13 businesses business NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 14 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 15 investigation investigation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 16 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 17 prosecution prosecution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 18 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 19 whit whit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 20 e e NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 21 collar collar NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 22 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 23 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 25 including include VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 26 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 27 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 28 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 29 related related JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 30 matters matter NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 4 31 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 1 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 2 Thornton Thornton NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 3 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 4 co co VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 5 - - NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 6 chairs chair VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 8 Tax Tax NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 9 Enforcement Enforcement NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 10 Subcommittee Subcommittee NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 13 ABA ABA NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 14 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 15 White White NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 16 Collar Collar NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 17 Crime Crime NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 18 Committee Committee NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 20 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 21 serves serve VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 22 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 23 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 24 advisor advisor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 25 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 27 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 28 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 29 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 30 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 5 31 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 1 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 2 Thornton Thornton NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 3 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 4 e e NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 5 - - NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 6 mail mail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 7 address address NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 8 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 9 JAT@ThorntonLaw.com jat@thorntonlaw.com ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 6 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 1 * * NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 2 * * NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 3 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 4 Allenbaugh Allenbaugh NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 5 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 6 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 7 staff staff NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 8 attorney attorney NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 11 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 12 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 13 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 14 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 15 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 16 serves serve VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 17 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 19 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 20 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 21 Economic Economic NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 22 Crimes Crimes NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 23 Policy Policy NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 24 Team Team NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 7 25 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 1 He -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 2 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 4 graduate graduate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 6 American American NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 7 University University NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 8 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 9 Washington Washington NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 10 College College NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 12 Law Law NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 13 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 14 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 15 served serve VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 16 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 18 Associate Associate NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 19 Articles Articles NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 20 Editor Editor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 21 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 23 American American NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 24 University University NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 25 Law Law NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 26 Review Review NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 8 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 1 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 2 Allenbaugh Allenbaugh NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 3 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 4 lectures lecture VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 5 courses course NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 7 philosophy philosophy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 9 logic logic NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 11 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 12 business business NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 14 professional professional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 15 ethics ethic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 17 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 19 George George NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 20 Washington Washington NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 21 University University NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 23 Washington Washington NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 25 D.C. D.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 26 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 27 Allenbaugh Allenbaugh NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 28 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 29 e e NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 30 - - NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 31 mail mail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 32 address address NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 33 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 34 MAllenbaugh@ussc.gov MAllenbaugh@ussc.gov NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 9 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 2 authors author NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 3 extend extend VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 4 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 5 gratitude gratitude NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 6 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 7 Dr. Dr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 8 Nicholas Nicholas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 9 Kittrie Kittrie NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 11 American American NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 12 University University NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 13 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 14 Washington Washington NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 15 College College NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 16 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 17 Law Law NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 18 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 19 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 20 helpful helpful JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 21 comments comment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 23 suggestions suggestion NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 25 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 26 insight insight NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 10 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 2 views view NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 3 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 4 arguments argument NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 5 expressed express VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 6 herein herein NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 7 solely solely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 8 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 10 authors author NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 11 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 12 do do VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 13 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 14 necessarily necessarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 15 reflect reflect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 17 official official JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 18 views view NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 19 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 20 opinions opinion NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 23 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 24 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 25 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 26 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 28 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 29 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 31 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 32 staff staff NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 11 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 12 1 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 12 2 H.L.A. H.L.A. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 1 HART HART NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 3 P p NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 4 UNISHMENT unishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 5 AND and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 6 RESPONSIBILITY responsibility NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 7 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 8 ESSAYS essay NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 9 IN in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 10 THE the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 11 P p NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 12 HILOSOPHY HILOSOPHY NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 13 OF of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 14 LAW law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 15 8 8 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 17 1968 1968 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 18 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 13 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 1 2 2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 2 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 3 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 5 Transcript Transcript NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 7 Oral Oral NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 8 Argument Argument NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 10 44 44 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 12 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 13 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 14 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 15 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 17 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 14 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 15 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 15 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 15 3 478 478 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 15 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 15 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 1 3 3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 2 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 3 Breyer Breyer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 5 Transcript Transcript NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 7 Oral Oral NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 8 Argument Argument NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 10 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 12 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 13 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 14 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 15 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 17 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 16 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 17 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 17 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 17 3 478 478 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 17 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 17 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 18 1 420 420 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 18 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 18 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 19 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 19 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 19 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 19 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 19 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 20 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 20 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 20 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 2 limitations limitation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 3 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 5 imposition imposition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 7 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 8 enhancements.4 enhancements.4 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 9 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 10 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 11 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 12 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 13 Jersey,5 Jersey,5 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 15 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 16 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 17 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 18 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 19 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 20 o]ther o]ther NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 21 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 23 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 25 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 26 prior prior JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 27 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 29 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 30 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 31 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 32 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 34 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 35 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 37 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 38 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 39 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 40 prescribed prescribe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 41 statutory statutory NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 42 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 43 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 44 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 45 submitted submit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 46 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 47 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 48 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 49 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 50 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 51 proved prove VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 52 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 53 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 54 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 55 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 56 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 57 ”6 ”6 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 58 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 59 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 60 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 61 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 62 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 63 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 64 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 65 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 66 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 67 much much RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 68 limit limit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 70 type type NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 71 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 72 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 73 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 74 factor”7 factor”7 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 75 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 76 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 77 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 78 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 79 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 80 enhancing enhance VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 81 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 82 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 83 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 84 much much RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 85 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 86 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 87 limits limit VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 88 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 89 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 90 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 91 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 92 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 21 93 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 1 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 3 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 4 noted note VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 8 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 10 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 11 inquiry inquiry NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 13 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 14 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 16 form form NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 18 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 20 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 21 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 22 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 24 required require VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 25 finding finding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 26 expose expose VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 28 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 29 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 30 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 31 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 32 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 33 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 34 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 35 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 36 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 38 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 39 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 40 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 41 verdict?”8 verdict?”8 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 42 Post Post NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 43 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 44 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 45 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 46 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 47 decisions decision NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 48 indicate indicate VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 49 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 50 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 51 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 52 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 53 circuits circuit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 54 read read VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 55 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 56 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 57 providing provide VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 58 nothing nothing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 59 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 60 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 61 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 62 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 63 ceiling ceiling NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 64 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 65 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 66 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 67 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 68 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 69 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 70 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 71 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 72 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 73 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 22 74 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 1 Courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 2 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 3 enhance enhance VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 4 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 5 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 6 up up IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 7 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 9 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 10 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 11 over over RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 14 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 15 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 16 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 17 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 19 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 21 conviction.9 conviction.9 JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 22 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 23 focus focus NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 24 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 26 literal literal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 27 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 28 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 29 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 31 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 32 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 33 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 34 overly overly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 35 formalistic formalistic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 37 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 38 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 39 implications implication NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 40 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 41 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 42 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 43 rationale rationale NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 44 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 45 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 46 far far RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 47 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 48 reaching reaching JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 23 49 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 1 That that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 3 signals signal VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 4 something something NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 5 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 6 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 7 indicated indicate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 8 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 10 avalanche avalanche NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 12 motions motion NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 14 appeals appeal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 15 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 16 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 17 inundated inundate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 18 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 20 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 21 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 22 regarding regard VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 24 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 25 validity validity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 26 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 27 potentially potentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 28 thousands thousand NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 29 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 30 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 24 31 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 1 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 2 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 3 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 4 writing writing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 6 well well RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 7 over over IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 8 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 9 hundred hundred CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 10 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 11 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 12 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 13 Courts Courts NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 15 Appeals Appeals NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 16 decisions decision NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 17 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 18 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 19 issued issue VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 20 discussing discuss VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 21 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 22 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 23 impact impact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 24 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 25 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 26 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 28 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 29 many many JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 30 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 31 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 32 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 33 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 34 follow follow VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 25 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 1 So so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 2 quickly quickly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 3 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 4 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 5 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 6 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 7 infected infect VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 9 federal federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 10 appellate appellate NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 11 4 4 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 12 On on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 14 same same JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 15 day day NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 16 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 18 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 19 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 22 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 23 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 24 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 25 issued issue VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 26 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 27 highly highly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 28 anticipated anticipate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 29 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 30 rega rega NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 31 rding rde VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 32 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 33 Miranda Miranda NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 34 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 35 Arizona Arizona NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 37 383 383 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 38 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 39 903 903 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 40 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 41 1966 1966 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 42 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 43 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 44 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 45 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 46 overruled overrule VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 47 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 48 1968 1968 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 49 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 50 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 26 51 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 27 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 27 2 3501 3501 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 27 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 5 Dickerson Dickerson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 7 530 530 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 8 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 9 428 428 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 11 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 12 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 28 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 2 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 3 likelihood likelihood NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 5 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 8 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 9 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 10 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 11 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 12 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 13 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 14 remembered remember VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 15 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 16 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 17 reaffirming reaffirm VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 18 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 19 suspect suspect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 20 ’s ’s NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 21 Miranda Miranda NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 22 rights right NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 24 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 25 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 27 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 28 discussed discuss VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 29 below below RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 31 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 32 ushering usher VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 33 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 34 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 35 revolution revolution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 36 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 37 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 38 reform reform NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 39 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 40 seen see VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 41 since since IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 42 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 43 implementation implementation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 44 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 45 determinate determinate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 46 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 47 schemes scheme NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 48 nearly nearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 49 two two CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 50 decades decade NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 51 ago ago RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 29 52 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 1 Ironically ironically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 3 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 4 second second JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 5 revolution revolution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 6 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 7 signal signal VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 9 demise demise NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 12 first first JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 30 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 1 5 5 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 2 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 3 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 4 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 5 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 6 2348 2348 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 8 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 31 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 32 1 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 32 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 33 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 33 2 2362 2362 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 33 3 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 33 4 63 63 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 33 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 1 7 7 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 2 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 3 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 5 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 8 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 11 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 12 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 13 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 14 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 15 described describe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 16 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 17 follows follow VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 18 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 19 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 20 circumstance circumstance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 22 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 23 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 24 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 25 either either CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 26 aggravating aggravating JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 27 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 28 mitigating mitigate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 29 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 30 character character NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 32 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 33 supports support VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 34 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 35 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 36 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 37 wit wit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 38 hin hin VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 39 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 40 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 41 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 42 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 44 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 45 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 46 finding find VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 47 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 48 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 49 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 50 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 51 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 52 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 53 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 54 particular particular JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 55 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 34 56 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 2 However however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 3 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 5 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 7 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 8 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 9 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 10 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 11 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 13 used use VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 14 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 15 describe describe VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 16 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 17 increase increase NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 18 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 20 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 21 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 22 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 23 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 25 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 26 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 28 functional functional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 29 equivalent equivalent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 31 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 32 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 34 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 35 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 36 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 37 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 38 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 39 one one NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 40 covered cover VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 41 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 42 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 43 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 44 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 45 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 46 verdict verdict NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 35 47 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 1 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 3 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 4 fits fit VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 5 squarely squarely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 6 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 8 usual usual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 9 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 11 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 12 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 13 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 14 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 17 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 36 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 37 1 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 38 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 38 2 2365 2365 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 38 3 n.19 n.19 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 38 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 39 1 8 8 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 39 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 40 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 40 2 2365 2365 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 40 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 40 4 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 40 5 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 40 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 40 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 1 9 9 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 2 Compare Compare NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 3 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 4 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 5 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 6 Hernandez Hernandez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 8 228 228 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 9 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 10 1017 1017 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 11 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 12 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 13 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 41 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 4 holding hold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 5 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 6 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 7 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 8 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 9 did do VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 10 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 11 exceed exceed VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 12 ten ten CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 13 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 14 year year NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 15 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 16 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 17 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 18 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 19 conspiracy conspiracy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 22 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 23 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 24 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 25 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 26 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 27 violated violate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 28 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 30 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 31 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 32 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 33 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 34 Nordby Nordby NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 35 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 36 225 225 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 37 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 38 1053 1053 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 39 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 40 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 41 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 42 42 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 4 holding hold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 5 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 6 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 7 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 8 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 9 exceeded exceed VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 10 five five CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 11 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 12 year year NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 13 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 14 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 15 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 16 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 17 trafficking trafficking NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 18 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 19 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 20 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 21 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 22 specified specify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 23 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 25 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 27 rule rule VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 28 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 29 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 30 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 31 violated violate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 32 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 43 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 1 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 2 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 3 summary summary NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 5 selected select VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 6 post post JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 7 -Apprendi -apprendi JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 8 decisions decision NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 10 see see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 11 Carmen Carmen NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 12 D. D. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 13 Hernande Hernande NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 14 z z NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 16 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 17 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 18 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 19 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 20 -Lower -Lower NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 21 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 22 Decisions Decisions NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 23 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 24 Nov. November NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 25 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 26 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 27 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 28 unpublished unpublished JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 29 manuscript manuscript NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 30 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 32 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 33 http://www.dcfpd.org/fdtg/apprendi/apprendi.htm http://www.dcfpd.org/fdtg/apprendi/apprendi.htm NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 44 34 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 4 421 421 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 5 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 6 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 7 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 8 appeals appeal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 9 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 10 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 11 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 12 appellate appellate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 13 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 14 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 15 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 16 implored implore VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 17 both both DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 18 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 20 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 21 defendants defendant NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 22 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 23 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 24 hold hold VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 25 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 26 horses horse NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 27 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 28 stop stop VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 29 wasting waste VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 30 everyone everyone NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 31 ’s ’s , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 32 time time NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 33 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 34 futile futile JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 35 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 36 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 37 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 38 applications application NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 39 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 40 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 41 leave leave NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 42 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 43 commence commence VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 44 successive successive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 45 collateral collateral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 46 attacks attack NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 47 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 48 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 49 sentences.10 sentences.10 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 50 Needless Needless NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 51 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 52 say say VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 53 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 54 Judge Judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 55 Easterbrook Easterbrook NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 56 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 57 plea plea NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 58 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 59 fallen fall VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 60 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 61 deaf deaf JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 62 ears ear NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 63 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 64 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 65 horses horse NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 66 continue continue VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 67 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 68 haul haul VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 69 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 70 appeals appeal VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 71 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 72 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 73 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 74 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 75 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 76 doors door NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 45 77 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 2 onslaught onslaught NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 4 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 5 appeals appeal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 6 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 7 come come VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 8 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 9 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 10 surprise surprise NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 46 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 1 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 2 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 3 anticipated anticipate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 4 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 5 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 6 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 7 she -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 8 stated state VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 9 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 10 her -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 11 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 12 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 13 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 14 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 15 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 16 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 17 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 18 i]n i]n NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 19 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 20 bold bold JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 21 stroke stroke NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 23 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 24 today today NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 25 casts cast VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 26 aside aside RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 27 our -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 28 traditional traditional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 29 cautious cautious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 30 approach approach NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 31 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 32 instead instead RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 33 embraces embrace VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 34 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 35 universal universal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 36 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 37 seemingly seemingly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 38 bright bright JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 39 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 40 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 41 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 42 limiting limit VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 44 power power NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 45 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 46 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 47 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 48 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 49 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 50 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 51 define define VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 52 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 53 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 54 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 56 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 57 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 58 follow follow VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 59 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 60 convictions conviction NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 61 thereunder thereunder NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 62 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 63 ”11 ”11 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 64 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 65 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 66 emphasized emphasize VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 67 further further RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 68 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 70 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 71 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 72 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 73 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 74 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 75 well well RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 76 apply apply VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 77 “ " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 78 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 79 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 80 determinate determinate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 81 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 82 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 83 schemes scheme NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 84 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 85 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 86 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 87 length length NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 88 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 89 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 90 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 91 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 92 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 93 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 94 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 95 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 96 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 97 turns turn VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 98 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 99 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 100 factual factual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 101 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 102 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 103 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 104 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 105 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 106 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 107 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 108 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 109 Guidelines).”12 Guidelines).”12 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 110 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 111 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 112 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 113 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 114 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 115 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 116 infecting infect VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 117 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 118 dockets docket NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 119 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 120 both both DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 121 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 122 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 123 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 124 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 125 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 126 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 127 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 128 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 129 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 130 infect infect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 131 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 132 very very JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 133 foundations foundation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 134 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 135 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 136 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 137 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 47 138 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 1 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 2 Article article NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 3 discusses discuss VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 4 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 5 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 6 implications implication NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 7 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 9 Federal Federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 10 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 11 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 13 Guidelines Guidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 16 specifically specifically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 17 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 18 respect respect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 19 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 20 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 21 offenders offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 22 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 24 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 25 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 48 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 1 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 3 authors author NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 4 discuss discuss VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 5 below below RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 7 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 8 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 9 conduct”13 conduct”13 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 10 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 11 made make VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 12 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 13 judges judge NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 14 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 15 enhance enhance VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 16 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 17 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 18 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 19 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 21 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 22 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 24 nature nature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 27 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 29 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 30 drive”14 drive”14 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 32 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 33 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 34 offenders offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 35 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 37 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 38 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 39 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 49 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 1 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 3 impacts impact VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 4 most most RBS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 5 directly directly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 6 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 7 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 8 whose whose WP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 9 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 10 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 11 driven drive VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 12 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 13 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 14 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 18 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 19 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 20 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 21 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 22 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 23 driven drive VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 24 almost almost RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 25 entirely entirely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 26 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 27 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 28 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 31 authors author NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 32 contend contend VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 33 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 34 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 35 necessarily necessarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 36 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 37 infect infect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 38 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 39 perhaps perhaps RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 40 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 41 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 42 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 43 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 44 type type NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 45 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 46 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 47 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 48 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 49 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 50 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 51 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 52 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 53 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 54 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 50 55 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 2 authors author NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 3 conclude conclude VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 4 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 6 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 8 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 9 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 10 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 11 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 14 cure cure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 15 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 16 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 17 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 18 require require VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 19 overhauling overhaul VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 21 current current JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 22 Guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 23 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 24 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 25 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 27 especially especially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 28 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 29 regard regard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 30 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 32 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 33 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 34 near near RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 35 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 36 exclusive exclusive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 37 reliance reliance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 38 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 39 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 40 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 41 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 42 10 10 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 43 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 44 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 45 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 46 State State NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 47 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 48 Indiana Indiana NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 49 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 50 226 226 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 51 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 52 866 866 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 53 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 54 867 867 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 55 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 56 7th 7th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 57 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 51 58 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 4 Easterbrook Easterbrook NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 6 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 52 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 1 Writing write VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 2 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 4 unanimous unanimous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 5 panel panel NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 7 Judge Judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 8 Easterbrook Easterbrook NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 9 stated state VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 10 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 11 Richard Richard NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 12 Talbott Talbott NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 13 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 14 among among IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 16 throngs throng NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 17 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 18 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 20 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 21 prisoners prisoner NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 22 who who WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 23 believe believe VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 24 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 25 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 26 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 27 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 28 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 29 undermines undermine VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 30 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 31 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 53 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 54 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 55 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 56 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 1 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 3 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 4 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 5 ultimately ultimately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 6 declares declare VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 7 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 8 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 9 applies apply VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 10 retroactively retroactively RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 11 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 12 collateral collateral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 13 attack attack NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 15 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 16 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 17 authorize authorize VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 18 successive successive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 19 collateral collateral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 20 review review NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 22 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 23 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 24 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 25 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 26 applies apply VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 57 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 1 Until until IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 2 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 3 prisoners prisoner NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 4 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 5 hold hold VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 6 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 7 horses horse NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 8 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 9 stop stop VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 10 wasting waste VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 11 everyone everyone NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 12 ’s ’s , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 13 time time NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 14 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 15 futile futile JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 16 applications application NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 58 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 59 1 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 2 868 868 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 4 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 5 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 8 internal internal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 9 citatio citatio NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 10 ns ns IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 11 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 12 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 60 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 1 11 11 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 4 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 5 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 6 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 8 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 9 2381 2381 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 11 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 13 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 15 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 61 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 1 12 12 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 4 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 5 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 6 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 8 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 9 2391 2391 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 11 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 13 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 15 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 62 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 63 1 13 13 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 63 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 63 3 infra infra NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 63 4 Pt Pt NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 63 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 64 1 II.A. ii.a. LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 65 1 14 14 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 65 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 65 3 infra infra NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 65 4 Pt Pt NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 65 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 66 1 III iii CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 66 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 67 1 422 422 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 67 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 67 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 68 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 68 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 68 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 68 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 68 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 69 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 69 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 69 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 70 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 70 2 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 70 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 70 4 determinative determinative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 70 5 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 70 6 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 70 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 71 1 I. I. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 72 1 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 72 2 BRIEF brief NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 72 3 HISTORY history NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 72 4 OF of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 72 5 SENTENCING sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 72 6 FACTORS FACTORS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 72 7 A. a. NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 2 Move move NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 3 Away away RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 4 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 5 Unfettered unfettered JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 6 Sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 7 Discretion Discretion NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 8 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 9 1972 1972 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 11 Judge Judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 12 Marvin Marvin NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 13 Frankel Frankel NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 16 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 17 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 18 District District NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 19 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 20 Judge Judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 21 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 23 Southern Southern NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 24 District District NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 26 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 27 York York NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 29 famously famously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 30 articulated articulate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 32 need need NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 33 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 34 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 35 guidelines.15 guidelines.15 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 36 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 37 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 38 Judge Judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 39 Frankel Frankel NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 40 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 41 judges judge NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 42 were be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 43 being be VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 44 afforded afford VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 45 too too RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 46 much much JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 47 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 48 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 49 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 50 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 51 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 52 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 53 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 54 minimums minimum NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 55 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 56 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 57 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 58 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 59 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 60 maximums maximum NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 61 bounded bound VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 62 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 63 discretion.16 discretion.16 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 64 Additionally additionally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 65 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 66 judicial judicial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 67 exercise exercise NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 68 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 69 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 70 broad broad JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 71 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 72 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 73 essentially essentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 74 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 75 placed place VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 76 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 77 appellate appellate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 78 review.17 review.17 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 79 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 80 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 81 even even RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 82 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 83 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 84 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 85 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 86 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 87 Judge Judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 88 Frankel Frankel NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 89 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 90 acknowledged acknowledge VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 91 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 92 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 93 while while IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 94 judges judge NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 95 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 96 required require VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 97 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 98 explain explain VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 99 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 100 rulings ruling NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 101 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 73 102 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 74 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 75 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 1 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 2 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 3 t]here t]here NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 4 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 5 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 6 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 7 requirement requirement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 8 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 10 announcement announcement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 12 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 13 prison prison NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 14 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 16 ’”18 ’”18 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 17 Not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 18 surprisingly surprisingly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 21 de de FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 22 facto facto FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 23 unfettered unfettered JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 24 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 25 afforded afford VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 26 judges judge NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 27 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 28 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 29 led lead VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 30 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 31 enormous enormous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 32 disparities disparity NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 33 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 35 penalties penalty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 36 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 37 offenders offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 38 received receive VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 39 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 40 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 41 offenses.19 offenses.19 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 42 On on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 43 October October NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 44 12 12 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 45 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 46 1984 1984 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 47 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 48 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 49 response response NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 50 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 52 growing grow VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 53 presence presence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 54 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 55 unwarranted unwarranted JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 56 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 57 disparities disparity NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 58 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 59 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 60 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 61 justice justice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 62 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 63 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 64 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 65 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 66 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 67 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 68 passed pass VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 69 bipartisan bipartisan JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 70 legislation legislation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 71 intended intend VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 72 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 73 make make VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 74 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 75 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 76 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 77 uniform uniform JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 78 among among IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 79 offenders offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 80 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 81 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 82 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 83 proportional proportional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 84 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 85 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 86 seriousness seriousness NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 87 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 88 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 89 various various JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 90 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 91 offenses.20 offenses.20 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 92 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 93 legislation legislation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 94 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 95 known know VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 96 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 97 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 98 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 99 Reform Reform NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 100 Act Act NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 101 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 102 1984—created 1984—create VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 103 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 104 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 105 independent independent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 106 commission commission NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 107 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 108 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 109 judicial judicial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 110 branch branch NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 111 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 112 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 113 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 114 States,”21 States,”21 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 115 whose whose WP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 116 purpose purpose NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 117 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 118 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 119 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 120 establish establish VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 121 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 122 policies policy NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 123 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 124 practices practice NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 125 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 126 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 127 Federal Federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 128 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 129 justice justice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 130 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 131 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 76 132 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 77 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 78 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 1 provide provide VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 2 certainty certainty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 3 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 4 fairness fairness NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 6 meeting meet VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 8 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 12 avoid avoid VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 13 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 14 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 15 unwarranted unwarranted JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 16 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 17 disparities disparity NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 18 among among IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 19 defendants defendant NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 20 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 21 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 22 records record NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 79 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 80 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 81 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 1 while while IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 2 maintaining maintain VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 3 sufficient sufficient JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 4 flexibility flexibility NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 5 15 15 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 6 See see VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 7 generally generally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 8 MARVIN MARVIN NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 9 E. E. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 10 FRANKEL FRANKEL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 12 CRIMINAL criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 13 SENTENCES sentences NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 14 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 15 LAW law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 16 WITHOUT without IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 17 ORDER ORDER NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 18 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 19 1972 1972 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 20 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 82 21 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 83 1 16 16 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 83 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 83 3 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 83 4 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 2 3581 3581 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 4 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 7 setting set VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 8 forth forth RP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 10 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 11 terms term NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 13 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 14 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 15 felony felony NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 17 misdemeanor misdemeanor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 18 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 19 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 84 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 1 17 17 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 3 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 4 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 5 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 6 Tucker Tucker NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 8 404 404 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 9 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 10 443 443 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 12 447 447 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 14 1972 1972 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 17 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 18 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 19 A a NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 20 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 21 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 22 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 23 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 24 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 25 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 26 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 27 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 29 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 30 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 31 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 32 limits limit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 34 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 35 generally generally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 36 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 37 subject subject JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 38 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 39 review review NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 41 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 42 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 85 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 1 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 3 Dorszynski Dorszynski NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 4 v. v. NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 5 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 6 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 8 418 418 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 9 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 10 424 424 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 12 441 441 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 13 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 14 42 42 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 15 n.15 n.15 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 17 1974 1974 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 18 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 19 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 20 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 21 Marvin Marvin NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 22 E. E. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 23 Frankel Frankel NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 25 Lawlessness Lawlessness NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 26 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 27 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 29 41 41 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 30 U. u. NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 31 CIN CIN NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 86 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 87 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 87 2 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 87 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 1 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 3 9 9 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 5 1972 1972 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 88 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 1 19 19 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 3 Boyce Boyce NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 4 F. F. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 5 Martin Martin NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 7 Jr. Jr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 9 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 10 Cornerstone Cornerstone NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 11 Has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 12 No No NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 13 Foundation Foundation NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 14 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 15 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 16 Conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 17 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 18 Sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 21 Requirements requirement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 23 Due Due NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 24 Process Process NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 26 3 3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 27 SETON SETON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 28 HALL HALL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 29 CONST CONST NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 89 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 90 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 90 2 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 1 25 25 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 3 27 27 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 4 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 5 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 7 1993 1993 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 10 describing describe VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 11 various various JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 12 studies study NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 13 illustrating illustrate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 14 gross gross JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 15 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 16 disparities disparity NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 17 among among IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 18 judges judge NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 19 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 20 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 21 offenders offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 22 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 23 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 24 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 25 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 91 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 92 1 20 20 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 92 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 92 3 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 92 4 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 2 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 3 991 991 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 4 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 5 998 998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 7 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 9 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 10 William William NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 11 W. W. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 12 Wilkins Wilkins NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 13 & & CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 14 John John NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 15 R. R. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 16 Steer Steer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 18 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 19 Conduct Conduct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 20 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 21 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 22 Cornerstone Cornerstone NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 25 Federal Federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 26 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 27 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 29 41 41 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 30 S.C. South Carolina NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 31 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 32 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 93 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 1 495 495 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 3 495 495 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 5 1990 1990 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 7 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 8 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 9 Ch Ch NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 94 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 95 1 1 1 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 95 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 96 1 Pt pt UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 96 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 1 A(2 a(2 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 4 noting note VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 5 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 6 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 7 delegation delegation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 10 broad broad JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 11 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 12 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 14 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 15 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 16 review review VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 17 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 18 rationalize rationalize VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 20 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 21 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 22 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 23 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 24 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 97 25 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 98 1 21 21 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 98 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 98 3 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 98 4 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 99 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 99 2 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 99 3 991(a 991(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 99 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 99 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 4 423 423 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 5 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 6 permit permit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 7 individualized individualized JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 8 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 9 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 10 warranted warrant VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 100 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 101 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 102 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 1 .”22 .”22 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 2 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 3 policies policy NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 4 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 5 practices practice NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 6 developed develop VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 7 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 9 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 10 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 11 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 12 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 14 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 16 first first RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 17 took take VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 18 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 19 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 20 November November NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 21 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 23 1987.23 1987.23 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 24 Pursuant pursuant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 25 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 27 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 28 Reform Reform NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 29 Act Act NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 31 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 32 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 34 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 35 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 36 subject subject JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 37 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 38 periodic periodic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 39 review review NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 40 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 41 revision revision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 42 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 43 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 44 consideration consideration NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 45 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 46 comments comment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 47 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 48 data datum NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 49 coming come VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 50 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 51 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 52 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 53 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 54 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 55 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 56 attention attention NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 57 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 58 ”24 ”24 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 103 59 B. B. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 1 Mandatory mandatory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 2 Federal Federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 3 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 4 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 5 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 6 Statutory Statutory NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 7 Co Co NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 8 nstraints nstraint NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 9 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 10 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 11 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 12 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 13 discretionary discretionary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 104 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 1 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 2 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 3 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 6 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 8 particular particular JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 9 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 10 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 11 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 12 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 14 shall shall MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 15 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 105 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 106 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 107 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 1 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 2 kind kind NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 4 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 5 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 7 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 8 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 9 established establish VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 10 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 12 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 13 category category NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 15 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 16 committed commit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 17 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 19 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 20 category category NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 22 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 23 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 24 set set VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 25 forth forth RP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 26 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 28 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 29 issued issue VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 30 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 32 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 33 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 108 34 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 109 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 110 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 1 .”25 .”25 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 2 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 3 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 4 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 5 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 7 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 8 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 9 w]hile w]hile IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 11 products product NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 14 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 15 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 16 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 17 labors labor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 18 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 19 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 20 given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 22 modest modest JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 23 name name NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 24 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 25 Guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 27 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 28 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 29 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 31 force force NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 32 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 33 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 35 laws law NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 37 prescribing prescribe VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 38 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 39 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 40 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 41 defendants defendant NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 42 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 43 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 44 receive receive VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 111 45 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 1 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 2 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 3 who who WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 4 disregards disregard VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 5 them -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 6 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 7 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 8 reversed reverse VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 10 ”26 ”26 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 11 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 14 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 15 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 16 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 17 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 18 depart depart VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 19 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 21 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 22 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 23 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 25 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 26 finds find VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 27 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 28 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 29 exists exist VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 30 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 31 aggravating aggravating JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 32 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 33 mitigating mitigate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 34 circumstance circumstance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 37 kind kind NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 38 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 39 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 40 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 41 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 42 degree degree NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 43 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 44 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 45 adequately adequately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 46 taken take VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 47 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 48 consideration consideration NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 49 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 50 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 51 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 52 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 53 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 54 formulating formulate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 56 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 57 G]uidelines G]uidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 58 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 59 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 60 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 61 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 62 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 63 different different JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 64 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 65 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 66 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 67 warranted warrant VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 112 68 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 1 27 27 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 2 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 4 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 5 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 6 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 7 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 8 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 9 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 10 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 11 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 12 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 14 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 15 incorrect incorrect JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 16 application application NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 17 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 19 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 20 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 21 G]uidelines G]uidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 23 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 24 either either CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 26 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 27 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 29 government government NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 30 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 31 appeal appeal VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 33 sentence.28 sentence.28 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 34 On on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 35 appeal appeal NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 37 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 38 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 39 i]f i]f NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 41 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 43 appeals appeal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 44 determines determine VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 45 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 46 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 47 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 48 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 49 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 50 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 51 violation violation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 52 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 53 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 54 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 55 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 56 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 57 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 58 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 59 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 60 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 61 incorrect incorrect JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 62 application application NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 63 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 64 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 65 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 66 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 67 G]uidelines G]uidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 68 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 70 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 71 shall shall MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 72 remand remand VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 73 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 74 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 75 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 76 further further JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 77 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 78 proceedings proceeding NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 113 79 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 114 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 115 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 1 .”29 .”29 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 2 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 4 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 5 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 6 f]rom f]rom IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 7 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 8 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 9 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 10 perspective perspective NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 13 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 14 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 15 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 16 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 17 cap cap VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 19 possible possible JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 20 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 22 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 23 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 24 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 25 statutorily statutorily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 26 prescribed prescribe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 27 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 28 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 29 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 30 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 31 affect affect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 33 actual actual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 34 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 35 imposed impose VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 36 no no RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 37 differently differently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 38 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 39 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 40 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 41 commission commission NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 42 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 43 22 22 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 116 44 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 117 1 § § NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 117 2 991(b)(1)(B 991(b)(1)(b CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 117 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 117 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 118 1 23 23 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 118 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 118 3 Pub Pub NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 118 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 119 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 119 2 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 119 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 1 98 98 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 3 473 473 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 5 Title Title NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 6 II II NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 8 98 98 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 9 Stat Stat NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 120 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 1 1987 1987 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 2 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 3 1984 1984 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 6 codified codify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 8 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 121 9 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 2 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 3 3551 3551 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 4 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 5 3559 3559 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 7 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 9 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 10 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 122 11 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 2 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 3 991 991 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 4 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 5 998 998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 7 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 11 § § -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 12 235(a)(1 235(a)(1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 15 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 16 amended amend VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 17 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 18 Pub Pub NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 123 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 124 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 124 2 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 124 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 3 217 217 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 5 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 6 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 7 2 2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 9 4 4 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 11 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 12 Stat stat JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 125 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 1 1728 1728 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 2 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 3 Dec. December NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 4 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 6 1985 1985 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 8 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 9 Pub Pub NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 126 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 127 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 127 2 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 127 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 3 646 646 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 5 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 6 35 35 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 8 100 100 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 9 Stat stat JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 128 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 1 3599 3599 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 2 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 3 Nov. November NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 4 10 10 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 6 1986 1986 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 8 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 9 Pub Pub NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 129 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 130 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 130 2 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 130 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 1 100- 100- CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 2 182 182 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 5 2 2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 7 101 101 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 8 Stat stat JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 131 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 1 1266 1266 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 2 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 3 Dec. December NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 4 7 7 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 6 1987 1987 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 132 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 133 1 24 24 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 133 2 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 133 3 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 2 3553(o 3553(o CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 5 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 6 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 134 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 135 1 25 25 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 135 2 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 135 3 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 2 3553(a 3553(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 6 4)(A 4)(a NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 136 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 1 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 2 Mistretta Mistretta NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 3 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 7 488 488 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 8 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 9 361 361 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 11 413 413 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 13 1986 1986 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 15 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 16 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 18 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 20 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 21 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 22 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 23 citations citation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 24 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 25 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 137 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 138 1 27 27 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 138 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 138 3 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 138 4 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 139 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 139 2 3553(b 3553(b CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 139 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 139 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 140 1 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 140 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 140 3 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 140 4 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 2 3742 3742 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 4 a)(2 a)(2 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 8 b)(2 b)(2 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 11 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 12 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 141 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 142 1 29 29 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 142 2 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 142 3 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 2 3742(f)(1 3742(f)(1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 5 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 6 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 143 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 144 1 424 424 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 144 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 144 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 145 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 145 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 145 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 145 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 145 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 146 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 146 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 146 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 2 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 3 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 4 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 5 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 6 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 7 ’s ’s , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 9 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 10 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 12 ”30 ”30 RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 13 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 14 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 17 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 18 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 20 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 21 essentially essentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 22 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 23 laws law NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 25 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 26 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 27 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 28 contended contend VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 29 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 31 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 32 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 33 really really RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 34 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 35 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 37 sort sort NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 38 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 39 junior junior JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 40 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 41 varsity varsity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 42 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 44 ”31 ”31 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 45 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 46 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 47 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 48 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 49 themselves -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 50 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 51 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 52 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 53 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 54 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 55 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 56 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 57 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 58 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 59 point point NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 60 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 61 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 62 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 63 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 64 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 65 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 66 provided provide VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 67 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 68 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 69 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 70 1 1 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 71 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 72 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 73 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 74 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 75 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 76 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 77 statutorily statutorily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 78 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 79 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 80 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 81 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 82 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 83 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 84 2 2 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 85 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 86 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 87 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 88 less less JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 89 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 90 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 91 statutorily statutorily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 92 required require VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 93 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 94 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 95 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 96 ”32 ”32 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 97 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 98 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 99 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 100 require require VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 101 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 102 imposition imposition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 103 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 104 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 105 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 106 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 107 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 108 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 109 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 110 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 111 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 112 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 113 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 114 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 115 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 116 becomes become VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 117 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 118 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 119 sentence.33 sentence.33 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 120 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 121 same same JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 122 holds hold VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 123 true true JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 124 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 125 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 126 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 127 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 128 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 129 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 130 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 131 impose impose VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 132 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 133 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 134 below below IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 135 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 136 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 137 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 138 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 139 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 140 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 141 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 142 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 143 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 144 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 145 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 146 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 147 minimum minimum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 148 becomes become VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 149 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 150 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 151 sentence.34 sentence.34 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 152 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 153 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 154 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 155 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 156 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 157 i]f i]f NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 158 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 159 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 160 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 161 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 162 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 163 51 51 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 164 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 165 63 63 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 166 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 167 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 168 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 169 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 170 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 171 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 172 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 173 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 174 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 175 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 176 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 177 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 178 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 179 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 180 60 60 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 181 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 182 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 183 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 184 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 185 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 186 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 187 restricted restrict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 188 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 189 51 51 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 190 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 191 60 60 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 192 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 193 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 194 ”35 ”35 IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 195 Under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 196 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 197 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 198 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 199 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 200 therefore therefore RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 201 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 202 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 203 Guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 204 play play VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 205 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 206 much much RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 207 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 208 important important JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 209 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 210 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 211 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 212 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 213 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 214 maximums maximum NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 215 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 216 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 217 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 218 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 219 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 220 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 221 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 222 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 223 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 224 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 225 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 226 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 227 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 228 maximums maximum NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 229 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 230 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 231 ultimately ultimately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 232 determine determine VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 233 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 234 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 235 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 236 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 237 terms term NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 238 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 239 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 147 240 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 1 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 3 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 4 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 5 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 6 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 7 terms term NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 9 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 10 set set VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 11 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 13 outer outer JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 14 bounds bound NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 15 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 16 valid valid JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 17 Guidelines Guidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 18 application application NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 20 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 21 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 22 do do VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 23 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 24 affect affect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 26 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 27 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 28 application application NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 29 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 31 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 32 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 33 status status NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 34 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 35 de de FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 36 facto facto FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 37 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 38 laws.36 laws.36 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 39 C. C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 40 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 41 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 42 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 43 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 44 Distinguishing distinguish VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 45 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 46 Factors Factors NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 47 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 48 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 49 Elements Elements NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 50 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 51 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 52 Crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 53 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 54 1986 1986 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 55 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 56 just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 57 prior prior RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 58 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 59 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 60 enactment enactment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 61 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 62 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 63 first first JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 64 version version NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 65 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 66 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 67 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 68 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 70 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 71 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 72 enunciated enunciate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 73 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 74 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 75 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 76 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 77 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 78 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 79 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 80 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 81 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 82 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 83 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 148 84 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 2 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 3 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 4 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 7 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 8 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 9 upheld uphold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 11 constitutionality constitutionality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 14 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 15 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 16 providing provide VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 17 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 18 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 19 mandatory mandatory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 20 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 21 five five CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 22 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 23 year year NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 24 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 25 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 26 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 28 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 29 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 30 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 31 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 32 considering consider VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 34 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 35 introduced introduce VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 36 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 38 trial trial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 39 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 40 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 41 additional additional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 42 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 43 offered offer VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 44 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 45 either either CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 46 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 47 30 30 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 48 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 49 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 50 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 51 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 52 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 53 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 54 S.Ct s.ct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 149 55 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 1 2348 2348 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 3 2401 2401 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 5 Breyer Breyer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 7 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 9 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 10 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 150 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 1 31 31 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 2 Mistretta Mistretta NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 4 488 488 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 7 427 427 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 151 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 152 1 32 32 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 152 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 152 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 152 4 5G1.1(c 5g1.1(c CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 152 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 152 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 153 1 33 33 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 153 2 See see UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 153 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 153 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 153 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 154 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 154 2 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 154 3 5G1.1(b 5g1.1(b CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 154 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 154 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 155 1 34 34 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 155 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 155 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 155 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 155 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 156 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 156 2 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 156 3 5G1.1(b 5g1.1(b CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 156 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 156 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 157 1 35 35 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 157 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 2 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 3 5G1.1 5g1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 5 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 8 backg’d backg’d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 158 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 1 36 36 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 2 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 3 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 4 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 5 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 7 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 8 specified specified JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 9 contexts contexts NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 11 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 14 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 15 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 16 sentence sentence VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 17 below below IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 19 mandatory mandatory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 20 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 21 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 22 via via IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 24 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 25 safety safety NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 26 valve valve NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 27 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 28 provision provision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 159 29 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 160 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 160 2 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 160 3 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 2 3553(f)(1)-(5 3553(f)(1)-(5 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 4 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 5 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 6 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 7 5C1.2 5c1.2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 161 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 3 APPRENDICITIS apprendicitis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 4 425 425 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 5 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 6 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 8 Commonwealth Commonwealth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 11 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 12 hearing hearing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 13 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 14 finds find NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 16 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 17 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 18 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 21 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 23 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 25 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 26 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 27 visibly visibly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 28 possessed possess VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 29 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 30 firearm firearm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 31 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 32 during during IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 34 commission commission NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 37 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 39 ”37 ”37 RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 40 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 41 acknowledging acknowledge VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 42 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 43 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 45 Due Due NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 46 Process Process NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 47 Clause Clause NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 48 protects protect VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 49 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 50 accused accuse VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 51 against against IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 52 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 53 except except IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 54 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 55 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 56 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 57 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 58 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 59 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 60 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 61 every every DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 62 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 63 necessary necessary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 64 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 65 constitute constitute VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 66 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 67 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 68 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 69 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 70 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 71 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 72 charged,”38 charged,”38 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 73 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 74 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 75 specifically specifically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 76 rejected reject VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 77 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 78 claim claim NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 79 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 80 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 81 whenever whenever WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 82 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 83 State state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 84 links link VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 85 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 86 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 87 severity severity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 88 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 89 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 90 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 91 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 92 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 93 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 94 presence presence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 95 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 96 absence absence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 97 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 98 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 99 identified identify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 100 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 101 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 102 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 103 State State NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 104 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 105 prove prove VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 106 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 107 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 108 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 109 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 110 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 111 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 112 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 113 ”39 ”39 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 114 Instead instead RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 115 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 116 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 117 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 118 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 119 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 120 states state NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 121 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 122 broad broad JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 123 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 124 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 125 defining define VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 126 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 127 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 128 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 129 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 130 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 131 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 132 defining define VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 133 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 134 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 135 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 136 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 137 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 138 enhance enhance VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 139 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 140 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 141 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 142 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 143 crimes.40 crimes.40 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 144 Moreover moreover RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 145 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 146 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 147 states state NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 148 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 149 as as RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 150 well well RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 151 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 152 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 153 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 154 government government NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 155 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 156 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 157 delegate delegate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 158 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 159 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 160 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 161 define define VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 162 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 163 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 164 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 165 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 166 commissions.41 commissions.41 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 167 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 168 only only JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 169 check check NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 170 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 171 states state NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 172 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 173 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 174 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 175 defining define VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 176 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 177 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 178 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 179 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 180 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 181 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 182 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 183 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 184 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 185 Due Due NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 186 Process Process NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 187 Clause Clause NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 188 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 189 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 190 Fifth Fifth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 191 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 192 Fourteenth Fourteenth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 193 Amendments Amendments NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 162 194 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 1 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 2 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 3 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 5 states state NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 6 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 7 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 8 define define VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 10 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 12 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 13 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 14 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 16 attendant attendant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 17 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 18 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 19 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 20 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 21 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 22 manner manner NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 23 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 24 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 25 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 26 offend offend VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 27 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 28 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 29 some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 30 principle principle NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 31 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 32 justice justice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 33 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 34 rooted root VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 35 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 37 traditions tradition NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 38 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 39 conscience conscience NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 40 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 41 our -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 42 people people NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 43 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 44 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 45 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 46 ranked rank VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 47 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 48 fundamental fundamental JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 49 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 50 ”42 ”42 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 51 Quite quite RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 52 famously famously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 53 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 54 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 55 Associate Associate NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 56 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 57 Rehnquist Rehnquist NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 58 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 59 writing write VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 60 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 61 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 62 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 63 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 64 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 65 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 66 offered offer VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 67 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 68 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 69 respect respect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 70 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 71 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 72 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 73 particular particular JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 74 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 75 construction construction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 76 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 77 offend offend VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 78 fundamental fundamental JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 79 traditions tradition NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 80 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 81 justice justice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 82 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 83 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 84 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 85 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 86 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 87 t]he t]he NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 88 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 89 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 90 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 91 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 92 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 93 give give VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 94 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 95 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 96 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 97 impression impression NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 98 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 99 having have VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 100 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 101 tailored tailor VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 102 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 103 permit permit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 104 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 105 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 106 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 107 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 108 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 109 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 110 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 111 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 112 tail tail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 113 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 114 wags wag VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 115 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 116 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 117 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 118 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 119 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 120 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 121 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 122 ”43 ”43 VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 123 Just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 124 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 125 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 126 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 127 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 128 tail tail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 129 begins begin VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 130 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 131 wag wag VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 132 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 133 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 134 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 135 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 136 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 137 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 138 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 139 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 140 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 141 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 142 never never RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 143 clearly clearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 144 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 145 explained explain VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 146 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 147 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 148 Court.44 Court.44 . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 149 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 150 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 151 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 152 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 153 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 154 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 155 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 156 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 157 believed believe VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 158 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 159 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 160 appropriate appropriate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 161 balance balance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 162 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 163 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 164 struck strike VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 165 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 166 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 167 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 168 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 169 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 170 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 171 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 172 making make VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 173 up up RP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 174 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 175 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 176 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 177 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 178 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 179 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 180 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 181 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 182 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 183 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 184 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 185 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 186 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 187 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 188 plus plus CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 189 additional additional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 190 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 191 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 192 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 193 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 194 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 195 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 196 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 197 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 198 hearing hearing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 163 199 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 2 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 3 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 4 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 6 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 8 essentially essentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 9 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 10 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 11 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 12 judge- judge- NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 13 37 37 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 14 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 15 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 16 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 18 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 19 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 20 79 79 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 22 81 81 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 23 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 24 1986 1986 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 25 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 26 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 27 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 28 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 29 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 164 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 165 1 38 38 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 165 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 2 84 84 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 4 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 5 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 6 re re NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 7 Winship Winship NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 9 397 397 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 10 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 11 358 358 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 13 364 364 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 15 1970 1970 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 17 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 18 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 19 internal internal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 20 quotations quotation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 21 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 22 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 166 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 167 1 39 39 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 167 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 2 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 3 Patterson Patterson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 5 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 6 York York NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 8 432 432 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 9 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 10 197 197 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 12 214 214 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 14 1977 1977 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 168 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 169 1 40 40 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 169 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 170 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 170 2 85 85 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 170 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 1 41 41 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 3 Mistretta Mistretta NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 5 488 488 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 6 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 7 361 361 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 9 389 389 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 11 holding hold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 12 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 14 Constitution Constitution NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 15 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 16 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 17 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 18 prohibit prohibit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 19 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 20 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 21 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 22 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 23 assigning assigning NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 24 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 25 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 26 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 27 auxiliary auxiliary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 28 bodies body NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 29 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 31 Judicial Judicial NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 32 Branch Branch NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 33 administrative administrative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 34 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 35 rulemaking rulemaking JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 36 duties duty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 37 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 38 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 39 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 40 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 41 d d VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 171 42 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 2 374 374 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 4 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 6 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 7 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 8 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 9 delegation delegation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 11 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 12 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 14 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 15 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 16 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 17 sufficiently sufficiently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 18 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 20 detailed detailed JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 21 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 22 meet meet VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 23 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 24 requirements requirement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 25 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 26 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 172 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 1 42 42 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 2 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 4 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 7 85 85 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 9 citations citation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 10 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 11 internal internal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 12 quotations quotation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 13 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 173 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 174 1 43 43 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 174 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 2 88 88 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 4 see see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 5 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 6 Tot Tot NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 7 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 8 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 9 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 11 319 319 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 12 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 13 463 463 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 15 1943 1943 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 17 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 18 invalidating invalidate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 19 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 20 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 21 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 22 created create VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 23 presumption presumption NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 24 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 25 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 26 felon felon NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 27 who who WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 28 possessed possess VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 29 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 30 weapon weapon NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 31 obtained obtain VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 32 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 33 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 34 interstate interstate NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 35 commerce commerce NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 36 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 175 37 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 176 1 44 44 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 176 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 176 3 infra infra NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 176 4 note note NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 176 5 109 109 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 176 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 177 1 426 426 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 177 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 177 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 178 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 178 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 178 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 178 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 178 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 179 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 179 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 179 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 2 determined determine VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 3 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 4 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 6 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 7 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 8 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 9 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 10 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 11 convicting convicting NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 12 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 14 primarily primarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 15 determine determine VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 17 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 19 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 20 fundamental fundamental JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 21 principles principle NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 23 justice justice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 24 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 25 compromised compromise VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 180 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 2 diagram diagram NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 3 below below RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 4 illustrates illustrate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 6 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 7 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 8 universe universe NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 9 after after IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 10 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 181 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 2 black black JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 3 disc disc NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 4 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 6 middle middle NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 9 diagram diagram NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 10 represents represent VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 12 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 14 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 15 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 16 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 17 either either DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 18 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 19 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 20 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 21 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 22 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 23 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 24 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 25 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 26 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 27 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 29 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 30 stipulated stipulate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 31 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 32 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 34 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 35 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 37 plea plea NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 38 agreement agreement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 182 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 1 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 3 overwhelming overwhelming JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 4 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 6 convictions conviction NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 7 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 9 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 11 plea plea NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 12 agreements,45 agreements,45 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 13 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 14 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 16 brevity brevity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 18 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 19 denominate denominate VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 20 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 21 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 22 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 23 jury- jury- NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 24 determined determined JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 25 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 183 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 2 contrast contrast NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 3 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 5 black black JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 6 inner inner JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 7 disc disc NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 10 white white JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 11 area area NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 12 surrounding surround VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 14 disc disc NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 15 represents represent VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 16 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 17 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 18 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 19 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 20 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 21 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 22 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 23 enhancing enhance VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 25 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 184 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 1 We -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 2 denominate denominate VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 3 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 4 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 5 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 6 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 7 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 8 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 9 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 185 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 1 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 2 both both DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 3 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 4 factual factual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 5 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 6 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 7 opposed oppose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 8 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 9 legal legal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 10 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 11 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 13 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 14 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 15 set set VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 16 forth forth RP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 18 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 19 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 20 both both CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 21 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 22 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 23 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 24 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 25 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 26 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 27 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 28 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 29 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 30 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 31 contribute contribute VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 32 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 34 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 36 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 37 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 38 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 39 ultimate ultimate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 40 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 41 without without IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 42 offending offend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 43 Constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 44 principles principle NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 186 45 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 1 Figure figure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 2 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 3 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 4 Sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 5 Universe Universe NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 6 after after IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 7 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 8 D. D. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 9 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 10 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 11 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 12 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 13 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 14 Reining rein VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 15 in in RP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 16 Sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 17 Enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 18 More more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 19 recently recently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 21 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 22 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 23 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 24 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 25 States,46 States,46 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 27 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 28 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 30 echoing echo VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 31 Chief Chief NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 32 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 33 Rehnquist Rehnquist NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 34 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 35 caveat caveat NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 36 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 37 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 38 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 39 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 40 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 41 45 45 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 42 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 43 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 44 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 45 statistics statistic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 46 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 47 fiscal fiscal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 48 year year NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 49 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 50 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 51 over over IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 52 94 94 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 53 % % NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 54 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 55 approximately approximately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 56 55,000 55,000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 57 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 58 convictions conviction NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 59 were be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 60 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 61 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 62 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 63 plea plea NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 64 agreements agreement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 187 65 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 2 UNITED UNITED NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 3 STATES STATES NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 4 SENTENCING SENTENCING NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 5 COMMISSION COMMISSION NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 7 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 8 SOURCE SOURCE NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 9 BOOK BOOK NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 10 OF of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 11 FEDERAL federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 12 SENTENCING sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 13 STATISTICS statistic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 14 20 20 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 188 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 1 46 46 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 2 526 526 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 3 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 4 227 227 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 6 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 189 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 4 427 427 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 5 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 6 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 7 tail tail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 8 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 9 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 10 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 11 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 12 wag wag VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 13 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 14 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 16 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 17 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 19 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 20 offense,”47 offense,”47 NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 21 emphasized emphasize VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 22 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 23 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 24 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 25 m]uch m]uch NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 26 turns turn VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 27 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 29 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 30 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 31 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 32 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 33 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 34 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 35 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 37 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 38 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 39 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 40 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 41 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 42 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 43 consideration consideration NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 44 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 45 ”48 ”48 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 46 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 47 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 48 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 49 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 50 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 51 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 52 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 53 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 54 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 55 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 56 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 57 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 58 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 59 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 60 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 61 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 62 paramount paramount JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 63 importance importance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 64 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 65 procedural procedural JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 66 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 67 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 190 68 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 2 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 4 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 5 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 6 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 7 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 8 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 9 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 11 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 12 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 13 proven prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 14 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 15 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 16 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 17 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 18 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 19 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 20 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 21 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 23 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 25 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 27 need nee MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 28 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 29 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 30 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 31 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 32 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 33 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 34 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 36 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 37 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 38 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 39 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 40 standard.49 standard.49 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 41 Still still RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 43 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 45 question question NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 46 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 47 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 48 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 49 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 50 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 51 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 52 normally normally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 53 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 54 matter matter NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 55 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 56 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 57 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 58 ”50 ”50 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 59 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 60 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 61 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 62 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 63 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 64 found find VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 65 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 66 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 67 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 68 carjacking carjacking NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 69 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 70 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 71 specifically specifically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 72 provided provide VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 73 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 74 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 75 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 76 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 77 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 78 bodily bodily JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 79 injury injury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 80 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 81 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 82 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 83 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 84 enhancement.51 enhancement.51 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 85 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 86 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 87 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 88 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 89 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 90 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 91 reiterated reiterate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 92 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 93 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 94 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 95 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 96 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 97 limitations limitation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 98 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 99 as as RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 100 well well RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 101 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 102 notice notice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 103 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 104 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 105 trial trial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 106 limitations limitation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 107 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 108 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 109 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 110 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 111 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 112 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 113 define define VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 114 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 115 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 116 crime.52 crime.52 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 117 Likewise Likewise NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 118 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 119 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 120 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 121 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 122 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 123 these these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 124 same same JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 125 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 126 limitations limitation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 127 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 128 apply apply VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 129 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 130 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 131 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 132 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 133 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 134 define define VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 135 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 136 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 137 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 138 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 191 139 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 1 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 2 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 4 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 6 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 8 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 9 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 10 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 11 notable notable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 12 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 13 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 14 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 15 acknowledging acknowledge VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 17 question question NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 19 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 20 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 21 requirements requirement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 22 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 23 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 24 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 25 finding finding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 26 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 27 raises raise VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 28 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 29 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 30 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 32 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 33 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 34 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 35 disposing dispose VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 37 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 38 claim claim NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 39 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 41 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 42 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 43 violated violate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 45 Sixth Sixth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 46 Amendment Amendment NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 47 right right NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 48 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 49 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 50 trial trial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 51 as as RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 52 well well RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 53 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 54 ”53 ”53 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 55 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 56 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 57 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 58 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 59 recognized recognize VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 60 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 61 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 62 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 63 danger danger NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 64 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 65 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 66 arise arise VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 67 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 68 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 69 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 70 being be VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 71 afforded afford VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 72 too too RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 73 much much JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 74 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 75 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 76 denominating denominate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 77 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 78 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 79 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 80 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 81 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 82 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 83 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 84 others other NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 85 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 86 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 87 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 192 88 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 1 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 2 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 4 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 5 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 6 potential potential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 7 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 8 might may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 9 rise rise VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 10 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 11 15 15 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 12 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 13 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 14 life life NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 15 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 16 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 17 non non JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 18 - - JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 19 jury jury JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 20 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 22 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 25 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 26 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 27 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 28 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 29 relevance relevance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 30 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 31 correspondingly correspondingly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 32 shrink shrink VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 33 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 35 significance significance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 36 usually usually RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 37 carried carry VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 38 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 39 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 40 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 41 guilt guilt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 42 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 43 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 44 low low JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 45 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 46 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 47 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 48 marginally marginally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 49 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 50 gate gate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 51 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 52 keeping keeping NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 53 function.54 function.54 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 54 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 55 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 56 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 57 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 58 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 59 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 60 finding find VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 61 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 62 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 63 necessary necessary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 64 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 65 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 66 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 67 15-year 15-year CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 68 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 69 simply simply RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 70 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 71 open open VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 72 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 73 door door NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 74 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 75 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 76 judicial judicial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 77 finding finding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 78 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 79 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 80 sufficient sufficient JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 81 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 82 life life NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 83 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 193 84 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 1 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 2 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 3 illustrates illustrate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 4 how how WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 5 unlimited unlimited JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 6 legislative legislative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 7 power power NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 8 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 9 articulate articulate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 11 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 15 weight weight NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 16 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 17 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 18 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 19 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 21 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 23 invites invite VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 24 erosion erosion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 27 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 28 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 29 function function NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 30 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 31 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 32 point point NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 33 against against IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 34 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 35 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 36 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 37 necessarily necessarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 38 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 39 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 40 drawn.55 drawn.55 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 41 Such Such NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 42 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 44 problem problem NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 45 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 46 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 47 sought seek VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 48 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 49 address address VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 50 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 51 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 194 52 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 1 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 2 Kennedy Kennedy NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 3 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 4 dissent dissent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 6 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 7 noted note VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 8 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 10 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 11 t]he t]he : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 12 rationale rationale NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 15 47 47 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 16 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 18 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 19 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 20 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 21 88 88 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 195 22 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 1 48 48 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 2 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 3 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 7 526 526 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 8 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 9 227 227 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 11 232 232 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 13 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 196 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 197 1 49 49 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 197 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 197 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 197 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 197 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 1 50 50 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 4 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 5 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 6 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 7 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 9 523 523 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 10 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 11 224 224 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 13 228 228 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 15 1998 1998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 198 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 1 51 51 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 3 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 5 526 526 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 6 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 8 236 236 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 10 noting note VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 11 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 12 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 13 Congress Congress NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 14 probably probably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 15 intended intend VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 16 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 17 bodily bodily JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 18 injury injury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 19 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 20 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 21 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 22 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 23 defining define VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 24 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 25 aggravated aggravate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 26 form form NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 29 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 30 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 31 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 199 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 200 1 52 52 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 200 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 200 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 200 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 200 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 201 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 201 2 242 242 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 201 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 202 1 53 53 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 202 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 1 54 54 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 3 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 5 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 6 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 8 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 9 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 10 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 11 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 12 2348 2348 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 14 2359 2359 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 15 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 16 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 17 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 203 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 204 1 55 55 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 204 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 205 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 205 2 243 243 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 205 3 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 205 4 44 44 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 205 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 206 1 428 428 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 206 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 206 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 207 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 207 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 207 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 207 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 207 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 208 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 208 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 208 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 1 9:2 9:2 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 2 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 3 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 4 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 5 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 6 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 7 makes make VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 8 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 9 difficult difficult JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 10 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 11 predict predict VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 13 full full JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 14 consequences consequence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 16 today today NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 17 ’s ’s , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 18 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 20 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 21 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 22 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 23 likely likely JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 24 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 25 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 26 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 27 cause cause VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 28 disproportion disproportion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 29 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 30 uncertainty uncertainty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 31 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 33 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 34 systems system NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 37 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 39 ”56 ”56 IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 40 Justic Justic NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 41 e e NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 42 Kennedy Kennedy NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 43 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 44 concerned concern VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 45 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 46 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 47 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 48 words word NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 49 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 50 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 52 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 53 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 54 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 55 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 56 confront confront VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 57 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 58 states state NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 59 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 60 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 61 adopted adopt VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 62 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 63 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 64 regimes regime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 65 “ " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 66 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 67 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 68 unexpected unexpected JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 69 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 70 mandating mandate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 71 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 72 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 73 were be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 74 once once RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 75 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 76 bearing bear VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 77 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 78 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 79 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 80 now now RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 81 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 82 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 83 treated treat VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 84 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 85 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 86 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 87 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 88 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 89 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 90 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 91 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 92 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 93 ”57 ”57 VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 94 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 95 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 96 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 97 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 98 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 99 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 100 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 101 least least JJS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 102 some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 103 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 104 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 105 Justices Justices NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 106 believed believe VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 107 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 108 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 109 principle principle NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 110 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 111 distinguishing distinguish VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 112 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 113 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 114 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 115 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 116 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 117 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 118 needed need VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 119 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 120 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 121 articulated articulate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 209 122 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 1 E. E. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 3 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 4 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 5 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 6 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 7 Toward toward IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 8 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 9 Principled Principled NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 10 Distinction Distinction NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 12 Elements Elements NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 14 Enhancements Enhancements NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 15 Close close RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 16 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 18 heels heel NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 20 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 23 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 24 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 25 decided decide VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 26 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 27 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 28 New new JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 29 Jersey.58 jersey.58 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 30 Charles Charles NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 31 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 32 pleaded plead VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 33 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 34 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 35 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 36 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 37 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 38 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 39 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 40 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 41 felony felony VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 42 firearm firearm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 43 possession.59 possession.59 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 44 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 45 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 46 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 47 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 48 felony felony NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 49 firearm firearm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 50 possession possession NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 51 carries carry VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 52 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 53 10-year 10-year CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 54 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 55 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 56 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 57 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 58 imprisonment.60 imprisonment.60 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 59 Pursuant Pursuant NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 60 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 61 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 62 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 63 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 64 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 65 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 66 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 67 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 68 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 69 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 70 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 71 finding finding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 72 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 73 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 74 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 75 racial racial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 76 bias bias NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 77 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 78 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 79 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 80 felony felony NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 81 firearm firearm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 82 possession possession NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 83 increased increase VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 84 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 85 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 86 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 87 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 88 10 10 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 89 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 90 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 91 20 20 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 92 years.61 years.61 NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 93 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 94 prosecutor prosecutor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 95 moved move VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 96 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 97 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 98 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 99 enhance enhance VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 100 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 101 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 102 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 103 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 104 pursuant pursuant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 105 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 106 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 107 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 108 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 109 statute.62 statute.62 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 110 At at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 111 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 112 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 113 hearing hearing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 114 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 115 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 116 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 117 found find VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 118 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 119 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 120 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 121 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 122 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 123 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 124 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 125 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 126 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 127 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 128 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 129 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 130 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 131 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 132 felony felony NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 133 firearm firearm NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 134 possession possession NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 135 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 136 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 137 conducted conduct VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 138 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 139 racial racial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 140 bias.63 bias.63 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 141 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 142 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 143 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 144 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 145 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 146 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 147 pursuant pursuant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 148 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 149 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 150 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 151 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 152 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 153 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 154 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 155 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 156 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 157 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 158 sentenced sentence VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 159 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 160 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 161 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 162 12 12 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 163 year year NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 164 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 165 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 166 imprisonment.64 imprisonment.64 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 167 56 56 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 210 168 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 2 271 271 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 4 Kennedy Kennedy NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 6 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 8 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 211 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 212 1 57 57 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 212 2 Id. Idaho XX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 1 58 58 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 2 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 3 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 4 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 5 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 6 2348 2348 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 8 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 213 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 214 1 59 59 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 214 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 215 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 215 2 2352 2352 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 215 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 1 60 60 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 2 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 3 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 4 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 5 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 7 question question NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 8 classifies classify VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 10 possession possession NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 12 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 13 firearm firearm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 14 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 15 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 16 unlawful unlawful JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 17 purpose purpose NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 18 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 19 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 20 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 21 second second JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 22 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 23 degree degree NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 24 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 25 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 216 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 217 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 217 2 N.J. New Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 217 3 Stat Stat NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 217 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 218 1 Ann Ann NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 218 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 2 2C:39 2c:39 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 3 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 4 4(a 4(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 7 West West NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 8 1995 1995 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 219 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 1 Such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 2 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 3 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 4 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 5 punishable punishable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 6 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 7 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 8 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 10 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 11 five five CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 12 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 14 10 10 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 15 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 17 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 18 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 19 2C:43 2c:43 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 20 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 21 6(a)(2 6(a)(2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 22 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 220 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 221 1 61 61 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 221 2 N.J. New Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 221 3 Stat Stat NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 221 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 222 1 Ann Ann NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 222 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 2 2C:44 2c:44 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 3 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 4 3(e 3(e CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 7 West West NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 8 Supp.2000 Supp.2000 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 223 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 1 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 2 separate separate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 3 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 5 described describe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 6 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 7 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 8 State State NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 9 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 10 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 11 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 12 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 14 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 15 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 16 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 17 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 18 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 20 provides provide VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 21 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 22 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 23 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 24 extended extended JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 25 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 26 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 28 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 29 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 31 trial trial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 32 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 33 finds find VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 35 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 37 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 38 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 39 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 40 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 42 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 43 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 44 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 45 t]he t]he : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 46 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 47 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 48 committing commit VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 49 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 50 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 51 acted act VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 52 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 53 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 54 purpose purpose NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 55 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 56 intimidate intimidate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 57 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 58 individual individual NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 59 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 60 group group NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 61 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 62 individuals individual NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 63 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 64 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 65 race race NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 66 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 67 color color NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 68 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 69 gender gender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 70 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 71 handicap handicap NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 72 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 73 religion religion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 74 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 75 sexual sexual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 76 orientation orientation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 77 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 78 ethnicity ethnicity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 79 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 80 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 81 N.J. New Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 82 Stat Stat NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 224 83 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 225 1 Ann Ann NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 225 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 2 2C:44 2c:44 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 3 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 4 3(e 3(e CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 7 West West NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 8 Supp.2000 Supp.2000 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 226 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 2 extended extended JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 3 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 4 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 5 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 7 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 8 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 9 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 10 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 11 second second JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 12 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 13 degree degree NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 14 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 15 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 16 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 17 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 18 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 19 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 20 10 10 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 21 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 22 20 20 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 23 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 24 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 25 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 26 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 27 2C:43 2c:43 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 28 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 29 7(a)(3 7(a)(3 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 30 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 227 31 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 1 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 3 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 4 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 5 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 8 2351 2351 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 228 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 229 1 62 62 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 229 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 229 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 229 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 229 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 230 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 230 2 2352 2352 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 230 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 231 1 63 63 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 231 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 232 1 64 64 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 232 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 232 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 232 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 232 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 4 429 429 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 5 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 7 appealed appeal VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 8 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 9 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 10 arguing argue VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 11 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 13 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 14 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 15 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 16 violated violate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 17 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 18 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 19 right right NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 20 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 21 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 22 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 24 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 26 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 27 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 29 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 30 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 31 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 32 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 33 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 34 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 35 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 36 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 37 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 38 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 39 separate separate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 40 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 41 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 42 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 43 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 44 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 45 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 46 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 47 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 48 included include VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 49 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 50 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 51 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 52 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 53 proved prove VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 54 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 55 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 56 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 57 doubt.65 doubt.65 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 58 Both both CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 59 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 60 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 61 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 62 appellate appellate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 63 court66 court66 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 64 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 65 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 66 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 67 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 68 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 69 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 70 affirmed affirm VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 71 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 72 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 73 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 74 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 75 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 76 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 77 ultimate ultimate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 78 sentence.67 sentence.67 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 79 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 80 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 81 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 82 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 83 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 84 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 85 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 86 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 87 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 88 Legislature Legislature NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 89 simply simply RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 90 took take VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 91 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 92 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 93 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 94 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 95 always always RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 96 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 97 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 98 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 99 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 100 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 101 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 102 bear bear VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 103 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 104 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 105 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 106 dic dic NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 107 tated tat VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 108 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 109 weight weight NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 110 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 111 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 112 given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 113 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 114 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 115 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 116 ”68 ”68 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 117 Therefore therefore RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 118 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 119 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 120 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 121 view view NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 122 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 123 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 124 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 125 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 126 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 127 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 128 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 129 both both CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 130 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 131 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 132 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 133 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 134 hate hate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 135 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 136 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 137 were be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 138 constitutionally constitutionally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 139 valid valid JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 233 140 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 4 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 5 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 6 granted grant VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 7 certiorari certiorari NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 8 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 9 November November NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 10 29 29 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 12 1999,69 1999,69 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 13 heard hear VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 14 oral oral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 15 arguments argument NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 16 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 17 March March NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 18 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 20 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 22 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 23 issued issue VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 24 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 25 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 26 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 27 June June NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 28 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 30 2000,70 2000,70 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 31 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 32 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 33 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 34 reversed reverse VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 36 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 37 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 38 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 39 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 40 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 41 remanded remand VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 42 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 43 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 44 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 45 resentencing.71 resentencing.71 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 46 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 47 doing do VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 48 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 49 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 50 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 51 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 52 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 53 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 54 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 55 previously previously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 56 noted note VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 57 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 58 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 59 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 60 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 61 o]ther o]ther NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 62 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 63 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 64 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 65 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 66 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 67 prior prior JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 68 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 69 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 70 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 71 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 72 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 73 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 74 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 75 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 76 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 77 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 78 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 79 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 80 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 81 prescribed prescribe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 82 statutory statutory NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 83 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 84 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 85 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 86 submitted submit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 87 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 88 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 89 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 90 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 91 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 92 proved prove VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 93 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 94 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 95 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 96 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 97 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 98 ”72 ”72 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 99 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 100 essence essence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 101 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 102 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 103 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 104 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 105 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 106 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 107 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 108 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 109 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 110 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 111 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 112 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 113 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 114 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 115 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 116 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 117 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 118 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 119 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 120 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 121 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 122 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 123 following follow VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 124 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 125 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 126 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 127 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 128 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 129 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 130 become become VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 131 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 132 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 133 tail tail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 134 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 135 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 136 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 137 wags wag VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 138 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 139 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 140 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 141 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 142 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 143 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 144 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 145 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 146 i.e. i.e. FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 147 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 148 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 149 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 150 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 151 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 152 become become VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 153 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 154 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 155 functional functional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 156 equivalent equivalent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 157 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 158 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 159 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 160 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 161 element.73 element.73 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 162 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 163 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 164 following follow VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 165 65 65 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 166 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 167 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 168 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 234 169 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 1 66 66 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 3 State State NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 5 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 7 698 698 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 8 A.2d a.2d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 9 1265 1265 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 11 N.J. New Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 12 Super Super NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 235 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 236 1 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 236 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 236 3 App App NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 236 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 237 1 Div Div NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 237 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 238 1 1997 1997 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 238 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 238 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 1 67 67 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 3 State State NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 5 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 7 731 731 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 8 A.2d A.2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 9 485 485 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 11 N.J. New Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 12 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 239 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 240 1 68 68 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 240 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 241 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 241 2 494 494 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 241 3 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 241 4 495 495 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 241 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 1 69 69 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 2 See see VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 3 State State NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 5 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 7 731 731 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 8 A.2d A.2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 9 485 485 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 11 N.J. New Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 12 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 242 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 1 70 70 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 3 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 5 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 6 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 7 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 10 2348 2348 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 243 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 244 1 71 71 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 244 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 245 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 245 2 2367 2367 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 245 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 246 1 72 72 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 246 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 247 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 247 2 2362 2362 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 247 3 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 247 4 63 63 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 247 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 2 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 3 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 4 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 5 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 6 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 7 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 9 523 523 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 10 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 11 224 224 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 13 1998 1998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 15 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 16 5 5 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 17 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 18 4 4 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 19 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 22 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 23 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 24 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 25 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 26 prior prior JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 27 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 28 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 29 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 30 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 31 treated treat VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 32 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 33 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 34 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 35 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 36 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 37 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 38 constitutionally constitutionally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 39 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 41 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 42 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 43 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 44 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 45 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 46 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 47 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 48 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 49 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 50 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 51 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 52 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 53 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 248 54 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 249 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 249 2 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 249 3 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 249 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 4 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 6 although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 7 declining decline VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 8 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 9 overrule overrule VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 10 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 11 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 12 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 15 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 16 did do VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 17 note note VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 18 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 19 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 20 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 21 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 22 arguable arguable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 23 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 24 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 25 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 26 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 27 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 28 incorrectly incorrectly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 29 decided decide VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 31 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 32 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 34 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 35 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 36 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 37 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 38 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 39 2362 2362 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 250 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 1 Furthermore furthermore RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 3 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 4 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 6 who who WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 7 sided side VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 8 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 10 bare bare JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 11 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 12 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 13 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 14 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 15 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 17 stated state VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 18 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 19 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 20 concurrence concurrence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 21 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 22 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 23 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 24 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 25 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 26 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 27 succumbed succumb VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 28 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 29 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 30 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 31 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 32 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 34 chief chief JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 35 errors error NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 37 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 38 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 39 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 40 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 41 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 42 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 43 attempt[ing attempt[ing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 44 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 45 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 46 discern discern VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 47 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 48 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 49 particular particular JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 50 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 51 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 52 traditionally traditionally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 53 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 54 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 55 typically typically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 56 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 57 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 58 basis basis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 59 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 60 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 61 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 62 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 63 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 64 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 65 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 66 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 67 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 68 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 69 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 70 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 71 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 72 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 73 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 74 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 75 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 76 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 77 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 78 2379 2379 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 79 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 80 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 81 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 82 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 83 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 84 concurring concur VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 85 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 251 86 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 2 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 5 bare bare JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 6 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 7 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 8 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 9 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 10 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 12 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 13 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 14 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 15 concurrence concurrence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 16 suggests suggest VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 17 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 18 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 19 Almendarez Almendarez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 20 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 21 Torres Torres NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 22 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 23 decided decide VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 24 today today NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 26 even even RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 27 prior prior JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 28 convictions conviction NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 29 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 30 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 31 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 32 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 34 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 252 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 1 73 73 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 4 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 5 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 6 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 8 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 9 2365 2365 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 10 n.19 n.19 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 11 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 12 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 13 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 14 W]hen w]hen RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 16 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 17 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 18 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 19 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 20 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 21 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 22 used use VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 23 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 24 describe describe VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 25 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 26 increase increase NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 27 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 29 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 30 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 31 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 32 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 34 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 35 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 37 functional functional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 38 equivalent equivalent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 39 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 40 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 41 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 43 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 44 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 45 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 46 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 47 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 48 one one NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 49 covered cover VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 50 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 52 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 53 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 54 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 55 verdict verdict NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 56 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 57 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 58 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 253 59 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 254 1 430 430 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 254 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 254 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 255 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 255 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 255 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 255 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 255 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 256 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 256 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 256 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 2 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 4 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 5 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 6 legislatively legislatively RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 7 ordained ordain VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 8 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 9 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 10 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 12 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 13 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 14 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 17 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 18 ’s ’s , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 19 Fifth Fifth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 20 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 21 Fourteenth Fourteenth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 22 Amendment Amendment NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 23 rights right NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 24 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 25 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 26 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 28 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 29 Sixth Sixth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 30 Amendment Amendment NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 31 right right RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 32 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 33 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 34 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 35 trial trial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 37 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 38 violated violate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 39 inasmuch inasmuch JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 40 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 41 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 42 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 43 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 44 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 45 question question NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 46 really really RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 47 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 48 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 49 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 50 element.74 element.74 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 51 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 52 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 53 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 54 clarified clarify VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 56 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 57 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 58 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 59 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 60 expanded expand VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 61 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 62 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 63 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 64 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 65 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 66 enunciating enunciate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 67 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 68 new new JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 69 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 70 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 71 rule”75 rule”75 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 72 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 73 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 74 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 75 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 76 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 77 sets set VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 78 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 79 outer outer JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 80 bounds bound VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 81 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 82 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 83 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 84 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 85 play play VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 86 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 87 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 88 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 89 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 90 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 91 ultimate ultimate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 92 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 257 93 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 1 Figure Figure NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 2 Two two CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 4 below below RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 6 indicates indicate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 7 how how WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 8 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 9 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 10 changed change VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 12 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 13 landscape landscape NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 14 since since IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 15 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 17 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 258 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 1 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 2 before before RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 5 black black JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 6 center center NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 7 represents represent VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 9 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 11 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 12 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 13 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 14 either either DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 15 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 16 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 17 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 18 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 19 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 20 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 21 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 22 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 23 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 24 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 26 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 27 pleaded plead VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 28 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 29 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 31 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 259 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 2 dark dark JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 3 gray gray JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 4 area area NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 5 surrounding surround VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 7 black black JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 8 center center NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 9 indicates indicate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 10 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 11 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 12 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 13 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 14 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 15 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 16 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 17 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 18 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 19 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 20 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 21 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 23 enhancing enhance VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 24 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 25 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 260 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 1 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 2 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 3 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 4 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 5 increase increase VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 7 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 8 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 9 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 10 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 11 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 13 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 14 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 15 exposed expose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 17 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 18 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 19 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 20 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 21 become become VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 22 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 24 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 25 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 26 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 27 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 29 accordingly accordingly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 31 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 32 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 33 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 34 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 35 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 36 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 37 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 38 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 39 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 40 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 261 41 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 1 Figure figure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 2 2 2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 3 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 4 Sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 5 Factor Factor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 6 Universe Universe NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 7 after after IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 8 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 9 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 10 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 11 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 12 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 13 noted note VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 14 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 16 novelty novelty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 17 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 18 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 19 legislative legislative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 20 scheme scheme NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 21 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 22 removes remove VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 24 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 25 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 27 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 28 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 29 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 30 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 31 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 32 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 33 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 34 found find VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 35 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 36 exposes expose VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 38 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 39 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 40 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 41 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 42 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 43 exceeding exceed VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 45 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 46 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 47 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 48 receive receive VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 49 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 50 punished punish VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 51 according accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 52 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 53 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 54 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 55 reflected reflect VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 56 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 57 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 58 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 59 verdict verdict NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 60 74 74 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 61 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 62 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 63 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 262 64 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 263 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 263 2 2355 2355 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 263 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 264 1 75 75 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 264 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 264 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 264 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 264 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 265 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 265 2 2363 2363 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 265 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 4 431 431 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 5 alone alone JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 7 ”76 ”76 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 8 Especially especially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 9 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 10 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 12 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 13 novelty novelty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 15 legislative legislative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 16 schemes scheme NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 17 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 18 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 20 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 21 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 22 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 23 remain remain VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 24 true true JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 25 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 27 principles principle NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 28 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 29 emerged emerge VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 30 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 32 Framers Framers NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 33 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 34 fears fear NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 35 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 36 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 38 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 39 right right RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 40 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 41 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 42 lost lose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 43 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 44 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 45 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 46 gross gross JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 47 denial denial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 48 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 49 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 50 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 51 erosion erosion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 52 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 53 ’”77 ’”77 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 54 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 55 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 56 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 57 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 58 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 59 t]he t]he NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 60 judge judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 61 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 62 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 63 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 64 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 65 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 66 constrained constrain VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 67 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 68 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 69 outer outer JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 70 limits limit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 71 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 72 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 73 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 74 alleged allege VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 75 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 76 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 77 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 78 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 79 found find VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 80 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 81 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 82 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 266 83 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 1 Put put VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 2 simply simply RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 4 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 5 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 6 expose expose VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 7 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 8 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 9 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 10 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 11 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 12 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 13 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 14 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 15 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 16 legally legally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 17 prescribed prescribe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 18 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 19 ar]e ar]e NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 20 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 21 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 22 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 23 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 24 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 26 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 27 separate separate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 28 legal legal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 29 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 31 ”78 ”78 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 32 Unfortunately unfortunately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 34 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 35 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 36 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 37 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 38 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 39 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 40 seems seem VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 41 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 42 place place VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 44 cart cart NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 45 before before IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 46 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 47 horse horse NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 48 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 49 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 50 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 51 appears appear VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 52 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 53 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 54 limit limit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 56 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 57 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 58 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 59 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 60 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 61 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 62 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 63 enhancing enhance VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 64 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 65 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 66 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 67 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 68 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 69 provide provide VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 70 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 71 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 72 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 73 distinguishing distinguish VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 74 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 75 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 76 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 77 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 78 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 267 79 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 1 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 2 sentiment sentiment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 3 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 4 articulated articulate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 5 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 6 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 7 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 8 during during IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 9 oral oral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 10 argument argument NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 11 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 12 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 13 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 14 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 15 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 16 t]he t]he NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 17 difficulty difficulty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 18 I -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 19 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 20 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 21 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 22 nowhere nowhere RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 23 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 24 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 25 defined define VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 26 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 28 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 29 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 30 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 31 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 32 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 35 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 36 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 37 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 38 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 39 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 41 ”79 ”79 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 42 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 43 short short RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 44 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 45 coming coming JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 46 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 47 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 48 already already RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 49 appears appear VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 50 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 51 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 52 creating create VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 53 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 54 split split NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 55 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 56 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 57 circuits circuit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 268 58 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 1 F. F. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 5 Garcia Garcia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 6 -Guizar -Guizar VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 7 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 8 Expanding expand VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 9 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 10 Shortly shortly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 11 after after IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 13 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 14 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 15 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 16 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 17 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 20 Eighth Eighth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 21 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 22 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 24 Appeals Appeals NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 25 decided decide VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 26 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 27 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 28 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 29 Aguayo Aguayo NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 30 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 31 Delgado.80 Delgado.80 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 32 There there RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 35 Eighth Eighth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 36 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 37 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 38 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 39 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 40 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 42 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 43 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 45 government government NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 46 wishes wish VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 47 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 48 seek seek VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 49 penalties penalty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 50 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 51 excess excess NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 52 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 53 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 54 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 55 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 56 virtue virtue NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 57 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 58 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 59 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 60 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 61 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 62 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 63 alone alone RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 64 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 65 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 66 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 67 government government NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 68 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 69 charge charge VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 70 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 71 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 72 giving give VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 73 rise rise NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 74 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 75 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 76 increased increase VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 77 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 78 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 79 ”81 ”81 XX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 80 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 81 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 82 government government NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 83 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 84 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 85 seek seek VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 86 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 87 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 88 increase increase NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 89 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 90 excess excess NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 91 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 92 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 93 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 94 maximum maximum NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 95 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 96 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 97 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 98 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 99 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 100 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 101 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 102 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 103 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 104 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 105 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 106 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 107 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 108 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 109 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 110 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 111 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 112 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 113 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 114 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 115 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 116 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 117 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 118 limit limit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 119 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 120 provided provide VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 121 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 122 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 123 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 124 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 125 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 126 use use VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 127 76 76 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 269 128 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 270 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 270 2 2359 2359 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 270 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 271 1 77 77 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 271 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 272 1 78 78 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 272 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 2 2359 2359 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 3 n.10 n.10 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 5 emphasis emphasis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 6 original original JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 273 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 2 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 3 concurrence concurrence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 5 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 6 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 7 reiterated reiterate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 8 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 9 point point NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 10 regarding regard VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 12 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 13 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 14 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 16 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 17 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 18 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 19 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 20 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 22 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 23 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 24 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 25 slightly slightly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 26 different different JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 27 flavor flavor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 28 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 29 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 30 What what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 31 matters matter VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 32 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 34 way way NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 35 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 36 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 37 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 38 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 39 enters enter VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 40 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 41 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 42 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 274 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 1 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 2 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 3 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 4 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 5 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 6 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 8 basis basis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 9 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 10 imposing impose VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 11 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 12 increasing increase VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 13 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 14 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 15 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 16 establishing establish VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 17 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 18 increasing increase VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 20 prosecution prosecution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 21 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 22 entitlement entitlement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 23 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 24 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 25 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 26 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 27 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 29 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 30 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 32 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 33 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 34 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 36 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 37 2379 2379 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 38 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 39 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 40 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 41 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 43 concurring concur VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 44 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 275 45 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 1 Presumably presumably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 3 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 4 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 5 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 6 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 8 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 9 constitutes constitute VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 10 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 11 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 13 far far RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 14 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 15 encompassing encompassing JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 16 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 18 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 19 ’s ’ VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 20 insofar insofar RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 21 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 22 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 23 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 24 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 25 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 26 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 27 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 28 incorporate incorporate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 29 reference reference NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 30 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 31 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 32 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 33 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 34 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 35 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 36 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 37 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 38 legally legally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 39 prescribed prescribe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 40 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 41 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 42 i.e. i.e. FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 43 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 45 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 46 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 47 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 276 48 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 1 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 3 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 4 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 5 face face NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 7 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 8 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 9 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 10 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 12 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 13 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 14 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 15 subsume subsume VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 16 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 17 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 18 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 19 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 20 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 21 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 22 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 23 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 24 basis basis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 25 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 277 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 278 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 279 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 1 increasing increase VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 2 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 3 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 4 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 5 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 6 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 7 increasing increase VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 9 prosecution prosecution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 10 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 11 entitlement entitlement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 12 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 280 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 281 1 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 1 79 79 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 2 Transcript Transcript NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 4 Oral Oral NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 5 Argument Argument NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 8 48 48 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 10 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 11 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 12 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 13 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 15 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 282 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 3 478 478 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 6 available available JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 8 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 9 WL WL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 10 349724 349724 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 11 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 12 Edward Edward NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 13 C. C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 14 DuMont DuMont NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 16 Esq Esq NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 17 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 19 Assistant Assistant NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 20 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 22 Solicitor Solicitor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 23 General General NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 25 Department Department NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 26 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 27 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 29 Washington Washington NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 31 D.C. D.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 32 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 33 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 34 behalf behalf NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 37 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 38 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 39 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 40 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 41 amicus amicus JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 42 curiae curiae NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 43 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 44 supporting support VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 45 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 46 Respondent Respondent NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 47 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 283 48 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 1 80 80 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 2 220 220 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 3 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 4 926 926 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 6 8th 8th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 7 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 284 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 285 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 285 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 285 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 286 1 81 81 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 286 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 287 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 287 2 933 933 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 287 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 288 1 432 432 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 288 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 288 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 289 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 289 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 289 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 289 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 289 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 290 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 290 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 290 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 2 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 3 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 4 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 5 exceed exceed VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 7 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 8 limit.82 limit.82 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 9 Soon soon RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 10 after after IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 12 Eighth Eighth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 13 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 14 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 15 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 17 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 20 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 21 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 22 expanded expand VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 23 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 24 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 25 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 291 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 5 Garcia Garcia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 6 -Guiza,83 -Guiza,83 : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 8 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 9 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 10 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 11 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 12 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 14 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 15 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 16 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 17 finding finding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 19 made make VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 20 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 21 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 22 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 23 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 25 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 27 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 28 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 29 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 31 increased increase VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 33 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 34 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 35 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 36 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 37 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 38 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 39 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 40 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 41 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 42 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 43 exposed expose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 44 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 45 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 46 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 292 47 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 293 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 294 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 1 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 2 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 3 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 4 recognized recognize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 5 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 7 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 8 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 9 violated].”84 violated].”84 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 10 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 13 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 14 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 15 appears appear VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 16 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 17 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 18 indicating indicate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 19 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 20 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 21 types type NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 23 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 24 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 25 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 26 merely merely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 27 expose expose VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 28 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 29 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 30 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 31 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 32 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 33 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 34 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 35 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 36 violate violate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 37 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 295 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 2 contrast contrast NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 5 Eighth Eighth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 6 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 7 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 8 Aguayo Aguayo NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 9 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 10 Delgado Delgado NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 11 clearly clearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 12 states state VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 13 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 14 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 15 exposure exposure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 16 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 17 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 18 enough enough JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 19 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 20 violate violate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 21 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 22 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 23 actual actual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 24 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 25 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 26 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 27 given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 28 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 29 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 30 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 31 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 32 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 33 order order NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 34 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 35 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 36 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 37 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 38 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 39 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 40 violation violation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 296 41 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 1 Figure figure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 2 Three three CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 3 below below RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 4 indicates indicate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 5 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 6 additional additional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 7 realm realm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 8 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 11 universe universe NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 12 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 13 articulated articulate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 14 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 16 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 17 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 18 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 19 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 21 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 22 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 23 merely merely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 24 exposes expose VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 25 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 26 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 27 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 28 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 29 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 30 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 32 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 33 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 34 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 36 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 37 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 38 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 39 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 40 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 41 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 42 violates violate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 44 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 45 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 46 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 47 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 297 48 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 2 medium medium JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 3 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 4 gray gray JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 5 ring ring NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 6 indicates indicate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 7 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 8 additional additional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 9 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 10 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 11 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 12 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 13 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 14 affected affect VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 15 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 16 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 17 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 19 Garcia Garcia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 20 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 21 Guizar Guizar NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 22 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 23 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 24 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 25 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 26 merely merely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 27 expose expose VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 28 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 29 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 30 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 31 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 32 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 33 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 34 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 35 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 36 really really RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 37 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 38 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 39 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 298 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 1 Figure figure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 2 3 3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 3 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 4 Sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 5 Universe Universe NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 6 after after IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 7 Garcia Garcia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 8 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 9 Guiza Guiza NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 10 82 82 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 299 11 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 2 934 934 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 4 see see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 5 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 6 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 7 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 8 Nordby Nordby NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 10 225 225 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 11 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 12 1053 1053 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 14 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 15 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 300 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 301 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 301 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 301 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 1 83 83 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 2 227 227 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 3 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 4 1125 1125 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 6 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 7 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 302 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 303 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 303 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 303 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 304 1 84 84 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 304 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 2 1129 1129 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 4 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 5 Nordby Nordby NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 7 225 225 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 8 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 10 1058 1058 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 11 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 12 59 59 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 305 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 2 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 3 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 5 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 7 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 8 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 9 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 11 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 12 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 13 failed fail VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 14 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 15 object object VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 16 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 18 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 19 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 21 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 22 hearing hearing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 25 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 26 violation violation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 27 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 28 subject subject JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 29 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 30 plain plain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 31 error error NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 32 review review NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 306 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 2 Nordby Nordby NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 4 225 225 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 5 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 7 1060 1060 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 307 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 1 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 3 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 4 error error NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 5 did do VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 6 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 7 affect affect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 9 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 10 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 11 substantial substantial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 12 rights right NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 15 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 16 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 17 did do VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 18 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 19 take take VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 20 notice notice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 22 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 308 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 309 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 309 2 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 309 3 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 309 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 3 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 5 de de FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 6 fendant fendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 7 timely timely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 8 objected object VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 9 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 11 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 14 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 15 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 16 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 17 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 18 reviewed review VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 20 error error NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 21 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 23 less less RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 24 deferential deferential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 25 de de FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 26 novo novo NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 27 standard standard NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 310 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 1 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 3 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 4 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 6 absence absence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 8 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 9 objection objection NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 11 Garcia Garcia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 12 -Guizar -Guizar NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 13 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 14 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 15 resulted result VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 16 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 17 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 18 substantially substantially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 19 different different JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 20 outcome outcome NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 21 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 23 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 311 24 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 312 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 312 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 312 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 312 4 433 433 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 312 5 II ii CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 312 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 1 SENTENCING sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 2 FACTORS factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 3 AND and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 4 CRIMINAL criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 5 ELEMENTS element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 6 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 7 IS be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 8 IT it PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 9 JUST just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 10 DRAFTING draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 313 11 ? ? . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 314 1 A. A. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 2 Role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 4 Relevant Relevant NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 5 Conduct Conduct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 6 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 7 concerned concern VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 9 extent extent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 10 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 11 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 12 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 13 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 14 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 15 delegate delegate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 16 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 17 decisions decision NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 18 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 19 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 20 judiciary judiciary NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 315 21 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 1 To to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 2 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 3 sure sure JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 6 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 7 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 8 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 9 affirmed affirm VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 11 constitutionality constitutionality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 13 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 14 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 17 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 18 reaffirmed reaffirm VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 20 constitutionality constitutionality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 22 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 23 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 24 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 25 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 26 consideration consideration NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 28 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 29 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 30 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 31 characteristics characteristic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 32 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 33 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 34 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 35 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 36 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 37 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 38 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 39 reject reject VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 40 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 41 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 42 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 43 claim claim NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 44 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 45 whenever whenever WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 46 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 47 State state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 48 links link VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 49 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 50 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 51 severity severity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 52 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 53 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 54 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 55 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 56 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 57 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 58 presence presence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 59 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 60 absence absence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 61 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 62 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 63 identified identify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 64 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 65 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 66 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 67 State State NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 68 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 69 prove prove VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 70 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 71 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 72 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 73 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 74 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 75 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 76 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 77 ”85 ”85 PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 78 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 79 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 80 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 81 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 82 State state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 83 need nee MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 84 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 85 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 86 prove prove VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 87 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 88 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 89 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 90 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 91 every every DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 92 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 93 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 94 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 95 existence existence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 96 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 97 nonexistence nonexistence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 98 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 99 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 100 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 101 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 102 willing willing JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 103 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 104 recognize recognize VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 105 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 106 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 107 exculpatory exculpatory NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 108 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 109 mitigating mitigate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 110 circumstance circumstance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 111 affecting affect VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 112 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 113 degree degree NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 114 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 115 culpability culpability NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 116 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 117 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 118 severity severity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 119 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 120 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 121 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 122 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 123 ’”86 ’”86 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 124 Rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 125 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 126 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 127 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 128 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 129 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 130 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 131 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 132 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 133 standard standard JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 134 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 135 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 136 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 137 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 138 sufficient sufficient JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 139 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 140 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 141 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 142 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 143 process.87 process.87 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 144 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 145 contemplated contemplate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 146 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 147 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 148 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 149 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 150 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 151 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 152 characteristics characteristic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 153 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 154 nothing nothing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 155 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 156 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 157 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 158 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 159 identified identify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 160 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 161 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 162 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 163 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 164 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 165 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 166 existence existence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 167 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 168 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 169 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 170 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 171 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 172 recognizes recognize VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 173 either either CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 174 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 175 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 176 aggravating aggravating NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 177 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 178 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 179 mitigating mitigating JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 180 circumstance circumstance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 181 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 182 affecting affect VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 183 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 184 degree degree NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 185 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 186 culpability culpability NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 187 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 188 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 189 severity severity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 190 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 191 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 192 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 193 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 194 ”88 ”88 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 195 Aggravating aggravate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 196 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 197 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 198 characteristics characteristic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 199 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 200 sometimes sometimes RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 201 known know VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 202 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 203 adjustments adjustment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 204 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 205 include include VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 206 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 207 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 208 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 209 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 210 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 211 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 212 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 213 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 214 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 215 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 216 presence presence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 217 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 218 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 219 gun gun NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 220 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 221 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 222 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 223 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 224 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 225 money money NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 226 actually actually RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 227 taken take VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 228 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 229 ”89 ”89 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 230 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 231 contrast contrast NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 232 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 233 mitigating mitigate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 234 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 235 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 236 characteristics characteristic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 237 consist consist VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 238 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 239 acceptance acceptance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 240 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 241 responsibility,90 responsibility,90 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 242 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 243 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 244 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 245 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 246 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 247 organizational organizational JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 248 defendants defendant NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 249 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 250 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 251 presence presence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 252 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 253 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 254 compliance compliance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 255 program.91 program.91 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 256 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 257 already already RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 258 noted note VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 259 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 260 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 261 constituting constitute VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 262 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 263 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 264 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 265 i.e. i.e. FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 266 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 267 conduct conduct VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 268 identified identify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 269 either either CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 270 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 271 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 272 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 273 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 274 characteristic characteristic NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 275 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 276 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 277 grounds ground NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 278 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 279 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 280 adjustment adjustment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 281 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 282 often often RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 283 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 284 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 285 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 286 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 287 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 288 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 289 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 290 inasmuch inasmuch JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 291 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 292 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 293 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 294 do do VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 295 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 296 constitute constitute VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 297 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 298 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 299 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 300 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 301 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 302 charged charge VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 316 303 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 317 1 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 317 2 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 317 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 317 4 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 317 5 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 2 7201 7201 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 3 provides provide VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 4 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 5 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 6 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 7 a]ny a]ny : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 8 person person NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 9 who who WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 10 willfully willfully RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 11 85 85 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 12 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 14 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 15 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 16 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 17 84 84 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 18 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 19 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 20 Patterson Patterson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 21 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 22 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 23 York York NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 25 432 432 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 26 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 27 197 197 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 29 214 214 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 30 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 31 1977 1977 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 32 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 33 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 318 34 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 1 86 86 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 2 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 4 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 7 84 84 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 9 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 10 Patterson Patterson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 12 432 432 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 13 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 14 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 15 207 207 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 319 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 1 87 87 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 3 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 5 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 6 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 8 91 91 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 320 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 321 1 88 88 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 321 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 322 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 322 2 84 84 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 322 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 322 4 quotations quotation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 322 5 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 322 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 322 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 323 1 89 89 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 323 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 323 3 Ch.1 ch.1 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 323 4 Pt Pt NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 323 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 324 1 A(4)(a)(3 a(4)(a)(3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 324 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 324 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 1 90 90 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 5 3E1.1(a 3e1.1(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 8 providing provide VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 9 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 10 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 11 mitigation mitigation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 12 “ " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 13 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 14 i]f i]f NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 16 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 17 clearly clearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 18 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 19 acceptance acceptance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 21 responsibility responsibility NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 22 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 23 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 24 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 25 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 26 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 325 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 1 91 91 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 4 § § -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 5 8C2.5(f 8c2.5(f CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 8 providing provide VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 9 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 10 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 11 mitigation mitigation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 12 “ " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 13 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 14 I]f I]f NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 16 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 17 occurred occur VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 18 despite despite IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 19 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 20 effective effective JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 21 program program NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 22 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 23 prevent prevent VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 24 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 25 detect detect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 26 violations violation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 28 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 29 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 30 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 31 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 32 see see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 33 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 34 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 35 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 326 36 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 2 8C2.5(g 8c2.5(g LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 5 providing provide VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 6 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 7 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 8 mitigation mitigation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 9 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 10 organization organization NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 11 self self NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 12 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 13 reported report VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 14 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 15 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 16 government government NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 17 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 18 timely timely JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 19 manner manner NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 20 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 21 prior prior RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 22 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 23 commencement commencement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 25 investigation investigation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 26 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 327 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 328 1 434 434 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 328 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 328 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 329 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 329 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 329 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 329 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 329 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 330 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 330 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 330 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 2 attempts attempt NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 3 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 4 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 5 manner manner NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 6 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 7 evade evade VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 8 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 9 defeat defeat VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 10 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 11 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 12 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 13 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 14 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 15 title title NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 16 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 18 payment payment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 19 thereof thereof RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 20 shall shall MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 331 21 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 332 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 333 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 1 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 2 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 4 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 5 felony felony NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 7 ”92 ”92 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 8 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 11 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 12 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 14 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 15 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 16 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 17 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 18 attempted attempt VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 19 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 20 evade evade VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 21 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 22 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 23 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 24 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 27 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 28 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 29 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 30 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 31 evasion.93 evasion.93 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 32 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 33 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 35 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 36 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 37 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 38 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 39 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 40 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 41 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 42 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 43 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 44 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 45 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 46 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 47 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 48 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 49 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 50 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 51 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 52 taxes taxis NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 53 evaded evade VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 54 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 56 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 57 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 58 punishment.94 punishment.94 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 59 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 60 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 61 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 62 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 63 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 64 taxes taxis NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 65 evaded evade VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 66 serves serve VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 67 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 68 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 69 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 70 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 71 characteristic characteristic NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 72 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 73 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 74 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 75 provable provable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 76 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 77 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 78 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 79 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 80 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 81 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 82 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 83 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 84 even even RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 85 though though IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 86 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 87 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 88 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 89 taxes taxis NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 90 evaded evade VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 91 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 92 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 93 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 94 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 95 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 96 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 97 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 98 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 99 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 100 evasion evasion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 334 101 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 1 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 2 additional additional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 3 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 4 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 5 conduct conduct VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 6 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 7 alleged allege VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 8 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 10 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 11 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 12 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 14 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 15 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 16 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 17 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 18 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 19 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 20 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 21 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 22 denominated denominate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 23 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 24 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 25 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 26 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 27 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 29 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 335 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 1 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 2 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 3 consists consist VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 5 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 6 acts act NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 7 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 8 omissions omission NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 9 committed commit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 11 aided aid VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 13 abetted abet VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 15 counseled counseled JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 17 commanded command VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 19 induced induce VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 21 procured procured JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 23 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 24 willfully willfully RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 25 caused cause VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 26 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 28 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 29 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 30 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 31 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 33 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 35 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 36 jointly jointly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 37 undertaken undertake VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 38 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 39 activity activity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 336 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 337 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 338 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 1 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 2 reasonably reasonably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 3 foreseeable foreseeable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 4 acts act NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 5 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 6 omissions omission NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 8 others other NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 9 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 10 furtherance furtherance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 13 jointly jointly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 14 undertaken undertake VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 15 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 16 activity activity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 18 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 19 occurred occur VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 20 during during IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 22 commission commission NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 25 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 26 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 27 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 29 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 30 preparation preparation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 31 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 32 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 33 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 35 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 36 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 38 course course NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 39 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 40 attempting attempt VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 41 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 42 avoid avoid VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 43 detection detection NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 44 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 45 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 46 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 47 responsibility responsibility NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 48 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 49 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 50 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 51 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 52 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 53 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 54 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 339 55 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 340 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 341 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 1 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 2 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 3 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 4 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 6 object object NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 8 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 9 acts act NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 10 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 11 omission.95 omission.95 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 12 Just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 13 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 15 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 16 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 17 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 18 required require VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 19 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 21 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 24 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 25 standard standard JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 26 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 27 prove prove VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 29 existence existence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 31 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 32 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 33 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 35 so so CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 37 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 38 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 39 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 40 adopted adopt VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 41 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 42 position position NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 43 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 44 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 45 use use NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 46 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 47 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 48 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 49 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 50 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 51 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 52 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 53 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 54 appropriate appropriate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 55 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 56 meet meet VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 57 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 58 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 59 requirements requirement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 60 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 61 policy policy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 62 concerns concern NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 63 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 64 resolving resolve VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 65 disputes dispute NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 66 regarding regard VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 67 application application NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 68 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 70 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 71 G]uidelines G]uidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 72 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 73 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 74 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 75 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 76 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 77 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 78 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 79 ”96 ”96 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 80 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 81 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 82 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 83 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 84 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 85 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 86 uniformly uniformly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 87 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 88 held hold VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 89 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 90 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 91 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 92 burden burden NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 93 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 94 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 95 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 96 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 97 factual factual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 98 92 92 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 99 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 342 100 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 343 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 343 2 7201 7201 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 343 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 343 4 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 343 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 343 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 1 93 93 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 2 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 3 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 4 explicitly explicitly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 5 enunciated enunciate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 7 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 344 8 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 2 7201 7201 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 4 numerous numerous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 5 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 6 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 8 appeals appeal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 9 require require VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 10 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 12 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 13 substantial substantial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 14 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 15 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 17 owing owe VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 18 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 19 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 20 evasion evasion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 21 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 345 22 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 2 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 7 Citron Citron NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 9 783 783 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 10 F.2d F.2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 11 307 307 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 13 314 314 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 14 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 15 15 15 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 17 2d 2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 18 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 346 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 1 1986 1986 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 5 Stat Stat NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 6 es es NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 7 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 8 Marcus Marcus NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 10 401 401 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 11 F.2d F.2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 12 563 563 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 14 565 565 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 15 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 16 2d 2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 17 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 347 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 348 1 1968 1968 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 348 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 348 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 3 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 4 exact exact JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 5 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 7 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 8 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 9 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 10 owing owing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 11 need nee MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 12 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 13 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 14 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 349 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 2 Citron Citron NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 4 783 783 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 5 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 7 314- 314- CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 8 15 15 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 9 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 10 Marcus Marcus NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 12 401 401 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 13 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 14 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 15 565 565 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 350 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 2 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 3 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 4 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 5 held hold VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 7 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 9 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 10 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 11 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 13 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 14 substantiality substantiality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 15 requirement requirement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 16 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 17 26 26 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 351 18 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 2 7201 7201 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 4 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 5 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 6 some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 7 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 8 deficiency deficiency NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 9 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 10 needs need VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 11 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 12 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 13 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 14 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 15 warrant warrant VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 16 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 352 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 4 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 5 Marashi Marashi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 7 913 913 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 8 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 9 724 724 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 11 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 12 Cir Cir NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 353 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 354 1 1990 1990 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 354 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 354 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 1 Still still RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 3 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 4 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 5 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 6 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 8 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 9 circuits circuit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 10 require require VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 11 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 12 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 13 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 15 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 16 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 17 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 18 alleged allege VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 19 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 20 order order NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 21 sustain sustain VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 22 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 23 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 24 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 25 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 26 evasion evasion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 355 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 356 1 94 94 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 356 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 356 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 356 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 356 5 2T1.4 2t1.4 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 356 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 1 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 2 section section NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 5 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 6 sets set NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 7 forth forth RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 10 Tax Tax NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 11 Table table NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 12 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 13 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 14 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 15 Tax Tax NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 16 Table table NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 17 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 19 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 21 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 22 according accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 23 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 25 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 26 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 27 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 28 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 29 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 30 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 31 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 357 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 1 Tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 2 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 3 simply simply RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 4 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 5 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 7 total total JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 8 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 10 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 11 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 12 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 14 object object NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 17 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 18 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 19 i.e. i.e. FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 22 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 23 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 24 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 25 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 26 resulted result VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 27 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 29 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 30 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 31 successfully successfully RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 32 completed complete VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 33 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 34 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 35 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 36 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 37 § § -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 38 2T1.1(c)(1 2T1.1(c)(1 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 39 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 358 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 1 So so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 3 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 4 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 6 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 7 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 8 individual individual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 9 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 10 underreports underreport VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 11 $ $ $ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 12 100,000 100,000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 13 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 14 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 15 personal personal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 16 income income NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 17 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 18 return return NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 21 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 22 presume presume VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 23 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 25 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 26 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 27 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 28 had have VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 29 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 30 pay pay VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 31 income income NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 32 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 33 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 34 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 35 rate rate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 37 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 38 % % NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 39 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 40 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 41 unreported unreported JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 42 income income NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 359 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 360 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 360 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 360 3 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 360 4 2T1.1(c)(1)(A 2t1.1(c)(1)(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 360 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 360 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 1 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 3 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 4 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 5 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 8 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 9 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 10 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 11 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 12 $ $ $ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 13 28,000 28,000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 15 unless unless IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 16 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 17 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 18 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 19 accurate accurate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 20 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 23 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 24 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 25 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 26 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 27 made make VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 29 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 30 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 31 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 32 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 33 2T1.1(c)(2 2t1.1(c)(2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 34 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 361 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 1 95 95 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 2 USSG ussg NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 4 1B1.3(a)(1 1b1.3(a)(1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 5 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 6 3 3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 10 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 11 Conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 13 Factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 14 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 15 Determine determine VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 17 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 18 Range Range NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 19 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 20 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 21 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 362 22 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 363 1 96 96 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 363 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 363 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 363 4 6A1.3 6a1.3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 363 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 363 6 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 363 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 2 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 3 added add VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 4 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 5 language language NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 6 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 8 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 9 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 10 commentary commentary NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 11 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 12 amendment amendment NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 13 387 387 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 15 effective effective JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 16 November November NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 17 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 19 1991 1991 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 364 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 365 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 365 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 365 3 App App NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 365 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 1 C. C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 2 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 3 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 4 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 5 435 435 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 6 matters matter NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 8 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 9 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 10 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 13 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 15 ”97 ”97 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 16 When when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 17 applying apply VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 19 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 23 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 24 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 25 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 26 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 27 conduct.98 conduct.98 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 28 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 29 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 30 represents represent VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 31 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 32 purposeful purposeful JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 33 policy policy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 34 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 35 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 37 part part NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 38 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 39 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 40 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 41 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 42 incorporate incorporate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 43 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 44 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 45 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 46 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 47 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 48 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 49 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 50 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 51 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 52 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 53 charge charge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 54 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 55 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 56 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 57 scheme.99 scheme.99 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 58 So- So- NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 59 called call VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 60 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 61 pure pure JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 62 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 63 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 64 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 65 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 66 bases basis NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 67 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 68 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 69 “ " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 70 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 71 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 72 actual actual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 73 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 74 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 75 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 76 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 77 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 78 engaged engage VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 79 regardless regardless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 80 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 81 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 82 charges charge NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 83 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 84 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 85 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 86 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 87 indicted indict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 88 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 89 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 366 90 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 367 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 368 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 1 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 2 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 3 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 5 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 6 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 7 constitutes constitute VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 9 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 12 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 13 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 14 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 16 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 17 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 18 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 21 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 22 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 23 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 24 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 369 25 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 370 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 371 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 1 .”100 .”100 NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 2 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 3 contrast contrast NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 5 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 6 pure pure JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 7 charge charge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 8 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 9 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 11 considers consider NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 12 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 14 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 15 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 16 constituted constitute VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 18 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 21 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 22 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 23 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 25 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 26 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 27 convicted.101 convicted.101 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 28 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 30 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 31 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 32 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 33 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 34 pure pure JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 35 charge charge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 36 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 37 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 38 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 39 overlook overlook VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 40 some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 41 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 42 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 43 harms harm NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 44 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 45 did do VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 46 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 47 constitute constitute VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 48 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 49 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 50 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 52 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 53 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 54 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 56 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 57 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 58 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 59 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 60 ”102 ”102 UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 61 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 62 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 63 ultimately ultimately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 64 opted opt VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 65 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 66 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 67 hybrid hybrid JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 68 approach approach NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 69 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 70 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 71 moved move VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 72 closer close RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 73 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 74 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 75 charge charge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 76 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 77 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 78 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 79 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 80 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 81 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 82 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 83 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 372 84 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 373 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 374 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 1 contain[ed contain[ed NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 4 significant significant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 5 number number NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 7 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 8 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 9 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 11 ”103 ”103 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 12 Some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 14 these these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 15 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 16 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 17 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 18 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 19 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 20 include include VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 22 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 23 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 24 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 25 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 26 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 28 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 31 presence presence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 32 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 33 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 34 gun gun NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 35 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 36 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 38 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 39 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 40 money money NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 41 actually actually RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 42 taken take VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 44 ”104 ”104 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 45 These these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 46 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 47 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 48 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 49 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 50 codified codify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 51 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 52 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 53 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 54 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 55 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 56 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 57 characteristics characteristic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 58 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 59 adjustments adjustment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 375 60 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 2 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 3 justified justify VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 4 incorporating incorporate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 5 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 6 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 7 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 8 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 9 considerations consideration NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 10 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 12 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 13 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 14 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 15 structure structure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 16 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 17 emphasizing emphasize VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 19 fundamental fundamental JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 20 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 21 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 23 assessment assessment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 25 guilt guilt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 26 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 27 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 28 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 29 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 31 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 32 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 33 penalties penalty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 34 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 35 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 36 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 376 37 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 2 principles principle NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 3 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 4 limits limit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 6 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 7 accountability accountability NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 377 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 378 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 379 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 1 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 2 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 3 always always RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 5 same same JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 6 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 8 principles principle NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 9 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 10 limits limit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 12 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 13 liability liability NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 380 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 1 Under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 2 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 4 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 5 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 6 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 9 focus focus NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 10 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 11 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 13 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 14 acts act NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 15 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 16 omissions omission NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 17 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 18 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 20 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 21 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 22 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 23 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 24 held hold VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 25 accountable accountable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 26 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 27 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 29 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 30 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 31 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 32 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 33 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 34 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 35 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 36 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 38 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 39 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 40 criminally criminally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 41 liable liable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 42 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 43 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 44 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 45 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 46 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 47 principal principal NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 48 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 49 accomplice accomplice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 50 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 51 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 52 conspirator.105 conspirator.105 $ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 53 97 97 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 54 FEDERAL federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 55 JUDICIAL JUDICIAL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 56 CENTER center NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 57 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 58 GUIDELINE GUIDELINE NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 59 SENTENCING SENTENCING , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 60 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 61 AN an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 62 OUTLINE OUTLINE NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 63 OF of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 64 APPELLATE APPELLATE NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 65 CASE case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 66 LAW LAW NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 67 ON ON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 68 SELECTED select VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 69 ISSUES ISSUES NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 70 287 287 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 71 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 72 Sept. September NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 73 1998)(citations 1998)(citations NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 74 omitted omit VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 75 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 381 76 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 382 1 98 98 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 382 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 382 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 382 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 382 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 2 stating state VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 3 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 5 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 6 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 7 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 8 shall shall MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 9 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 10 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 11 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 13 basis basis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 15 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 16 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 17 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 18 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 19 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 20 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 21 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 22 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 23 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 24 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 383 25 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 384 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 384 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 384 3 Ch.1 ch.1 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 384 4 Pt Pt NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 384 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 385 1 A(4)(a A(4)(a NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 385 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 385 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 385 4 p.s p.s NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 385 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 386 1 100 100 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 386 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 387 1 101 101 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 387 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 388 1 102 102 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 388 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 389 1 103 103 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 389 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 390 1 104 104 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 390 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 391 1 105 105 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 391 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 391 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 391 4 1B1.3 1b1.3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 391 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 391 6 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 391 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 392 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 392 2 n.1 n.1 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 392 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 392 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 393 1 436 436 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 393 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 393 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 394 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 394 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 394 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 394 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 394 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 395 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 395 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 395 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 396 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 396 2 B. B. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 2 Limits limit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 4 Legislative Legislative NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 5 Authority Authority NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 6 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 7 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 8 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 9 Factors Factors NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 10 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 11 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 12 long long RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 13 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 14 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 15 given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 16 considerable considerable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 17 importance importance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 18 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 19 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 20 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 397 21 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 1 Over over IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 2 fifty fifty CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 3 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 4 ago ago RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 7 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 8 stated state VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 9 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 10 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 11 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 12 h]ighly h]ighly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 13 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 14 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 16 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 17 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 18 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 19 essential essential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 20 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 21 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 23 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 24 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 26 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 27 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 28 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 29 selection selection NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 31 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 32 appropriate appropriate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 33 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 34 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 36 possession possession NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 37 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 38 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 39 fullest full JJS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 40 information information NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 41 possible possible JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 42 concerning concern VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 44 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 45 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 46 life life NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 47 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 48 characteristics characteristic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 49 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 50 ”106 ”106 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 51 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 52 sentiment sentiment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 53 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 54 codified codify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 55 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 56 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 398 57 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 2 3661 3661 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 3 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 4 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 5 No no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 6 limitation limitation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 7 shall shall MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 8 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 9 placed place VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 10 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 12 information information NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 13 concerning concern VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 15 background background NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 17 character character NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 20 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 22 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 23 person person NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 24 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 26 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 27 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 28 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 29 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 30 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 31 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 33 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 34 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 35 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 36 receive receive VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 37 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 38 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 39 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 41 purpose purpose NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 43 imposing impose VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 44 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 45 appropriate appropriate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 46 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 47 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 48 ”107 ”107 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 49 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 50 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 52 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 53 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 54 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 55 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 56 merely merely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 57 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 58 corresponds correspond VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 59 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 60 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 61 actions action NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 62 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 63 circumstances circumstance NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 64 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 65 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 66 typically typically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 67 took take VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 68 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 69 account account NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 70 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 71 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 72 prior prior RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 73 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 74 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 75 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 76 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 77 enactment enactment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 78 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 79 ”108 ”108 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 80 Perhaps perhaps RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 81 most most RBS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 82 important important JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 83 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 84 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 85 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 86 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 87 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 88 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 89 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 90 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 91 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 92 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 93 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 94 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 95 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 96 need nee MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 97 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 98 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 99 established establish VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 100 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 101 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 102 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 103 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 104 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 105 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 399 106 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 1 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 2 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 3 Judge Judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 4 William William NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 5 W. W. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 6 Wilkins Wilkins NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 8 Jr. Jr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 10 first first JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 11 Chair Chair NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 14 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 17 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 18 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 19 Vice Vice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 20 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 21 Chair Chair NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 22 John John NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 23 R. R. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 24 Steer Steer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 25 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 26 former former JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 27 General General NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 28 Counsel Counsel NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 29 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 31 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 32 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 34 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 35 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 37 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 38 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 39 standard standard JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 40 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 41 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 42 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 43 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 44 provides provide VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 45 sufficient sufficient JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 46 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 47 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 48 protection protection NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 400 49 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 1 Pre pre JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 2 - - JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 3 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 4 pronouncements pronouncement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 5 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 7 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 8 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 9 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 10 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 11 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 12 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 13 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 14 indicate indicate VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 15 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 16 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 17 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 20 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 21 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 22 comports comport VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 23 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 24 fifth fifth JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 25 amendment amendment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 26 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 27 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 28 requirements requirement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 29 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 30 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 31 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 32 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 33 including include VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 34 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 35 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 37 ambit ambit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 38 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 39 Relevant Relevant NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 40 Conduct Conduct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 42 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 43 contested contest VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 401 44 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 402 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 403 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 404 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 2 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 3 enhance enhance VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 4 procedural procedural JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 5 fairness fairness NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 6 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 7 largely largely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 8 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 10 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 11 according accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 12 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 13 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 15 identified identify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 16 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 18 each each DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 20 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 21 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 22 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 23 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 24 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 25 opportunity opportunity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 26 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 27 contest contest VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 29 through through IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 30 evidentiary evidentiary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 31 presentation presentation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 32 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 33 allocution allocution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 35 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 37 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 38 hearing hearing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 405 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 2 advent advent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 4 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 5 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 6 thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 7 presents present VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 8 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 9 convincing convincing JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 10 reason reason NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 11 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 12 conclude conclude VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 13 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 14 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 15 standards standard NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 16 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 17 somehow somehow RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 18 stricter strict JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 19 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 20 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 21 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 22 used use VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 23 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 24 assist assist VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 25 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 26 fashioning fashion VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 28 appropriate appropriate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 29 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 31 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 32 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 33 policy policy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 34 considerations consideration NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 35 compel compel VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 36 use use NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 37 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 38 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 39 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 40 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 406 41 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 1 Hence hence RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 3 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 4 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 5 apply apply VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 7 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 8 adjustments adjustment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 9 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 11 realm realm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 13 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 14 Conduct Conduct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 15 wh wh VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 16 en en IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 17 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 18 adjustments adjustment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 19 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 20 established establish VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 21 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 23 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 26 evidence.109 evidence.109 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 27 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 29 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 30 noted note VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 31 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 32 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 34 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 35 generally generally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 36 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 37 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 38 defer defer VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 39 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 41 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 42 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 43 making make VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 44 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 45 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 46 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 47 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 48 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 49 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 50 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 51 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 52 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 53 whatever whatever WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 54 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 55 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 56 says say VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 57 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 58 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 59 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 60 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 61 likewise likewise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 62 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 63 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 64 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 65 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 66 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 67 designees designee NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 68 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 69 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 70 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 71 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 72 commissions commission NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 73 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 74 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 75 determine determine VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 76 what what WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 77 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 78 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 79 count count VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 80 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 81 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 82 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 83 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 84 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 85 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 86 weight weight NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 87 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 88 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 89 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 90 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 91 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 92 given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 407 93 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 3 even even RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 5 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 6 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 7 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 8 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 9 unfettered unfettere VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 10 106 106 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 11 Williams Williams NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 12 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 13 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 14 York York NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 16 337 337 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 17 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 18 241 241 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 20 247 247 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 21 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 22 1949 1949 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 23 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 24 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 25 quoted quote VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 26 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 27 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 28 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 29 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 30 Watts Watts NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 32 519 519 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 33 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 34 148 148 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 35 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 36 151 151 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 37 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 38 52 52 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 39 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 40 1997 1997 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 41 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 42 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 408 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 409 1 107 107 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 409 2 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 409 3 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 410 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 410 2 3661 3661 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 410 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 410 4 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 410 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 410 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 1 108 108 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 2 Watts Watts NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 4 519 519 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 7 152 152 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 9 internal internal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 10 quotations quotation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 11 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 12 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 411 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 1 109 109 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 2 Wilkins Wilkins NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 3 & & CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 4 Steer Steer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 6 supra supra NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 7 note note NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 8 20 20 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 10 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 11 518 518 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 12 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 13 19 19 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 15 footnotes footnote NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 16 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 17 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 412 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 4 437 437 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 5 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 7 drafting draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 8 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 9 legislation.110 legislation.110 . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 10 Articulating articulate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 11 exactly exactly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 12 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 13 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 14 draw draw VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 16 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 17 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 18 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 19 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 21 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 22 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 23 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 24 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 25 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 26 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 27 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 28 difficult difficult JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 30 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 31 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 32 impossible impossible JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 33 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 34 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 35 identify identify VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 413 36 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 3 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 4 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 5 important important JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 6 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 7 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 8 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 9 recognize recognize VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 10 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 11 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 13 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 14 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 15 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 16 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 17 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 18 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 19 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 20 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 22 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 23 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 24 understand understand VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 26 necessity necessity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 29 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 414 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 1 Without without IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 2 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 3 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 4 conceptual conceptual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 5 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 6 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 7 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 9 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 10 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 11 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 12 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 14 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 15 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 16 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 17 reason reason NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 18 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 19 principle principle NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 20 why why WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 21 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 22 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 23 simply simply RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 24 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 25 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 26 recognize recognize VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 27 just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 28 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 29 general general JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 30 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 31 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 32 wrong wrong NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 33 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 34 doing doing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 35 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 36 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 37 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 38 proceed proceed VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 39 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 40 enunciate enunciate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 41 dozens dozen NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 43 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 44 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 45 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 46 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 47 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 48 ranging range VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 49 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 50 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 51 jay jay NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 52 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 53 walking walk VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 54 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 55 homicide.111 homicide.111 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 56 Under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 57 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 58 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 59 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 60 scheme scheme NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 61 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 62 even even RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 63 jaywalkers jaywalker NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 64 conceivably conceivably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 65 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 66 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 67 exposed expose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 68 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 69 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 70 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 71 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 72 life life NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 73 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 74 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 75 depending depend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 76 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 77 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 78 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 79 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 80 imposed impose VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 415 81 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 3 language language NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 5 Chief Chief NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 6 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 7 Rehnquist Rehnquist NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 9 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 10 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 11 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 12 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 13 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 14 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 15 impermissibly impermissibly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 16 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 17 tailored tailor VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 18 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 19 permit permit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 21 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 23 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 24 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 25 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 26 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 27 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 28 tail tail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 29 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 30 wags wag VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 32 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 35 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 36 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 37 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 38 ”112 ”112 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 39 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 40 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 41 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 42 essential essential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 43 problem problem NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 44 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 45 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 46 single single JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 47 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 48 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 49 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 50 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 51 wrong wrong RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 52 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 53 doing doing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 54 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 55 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 56 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 57 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 58 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 59 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 60 dozens dozen NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 61 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 62 associated associate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 63 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 64 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 65 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 66 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 67 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 68 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 69 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 70 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 71 drive drive VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 72 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 73 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 74 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 75 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 76 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 77 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 78 nature nature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 79 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 80 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 81 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 82 itself -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 416 83 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 1 Under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 2 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 4 regime regime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 7 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 8 associated associate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 9 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 11 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 13 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 14 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 15 penalized penalize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 17 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 18 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 20 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 21 associated associate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 22 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 23 110 110 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 24 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 27 following follow VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 28 excerpt excerpt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 29 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 30 oral oral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 31 argument argument NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 32 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 33 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 34 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 35 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 36 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 37 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 38 Respondent Respondent NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 39 Lisa Lisa NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 40 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 41 Gocham Gocham NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 43 Deputy Deputy NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 44 At at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 45 torney torney NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 46 General General NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 47 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 48 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 49 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 50 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 51 illustrates illustrate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 52 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 53 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 54 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 55 legislative legislative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 56 over over RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 57 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 58 reaching reaching NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 59 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 60 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 61 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 62 notes note VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 63 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 64 remaining remain VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 65 problem problem NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 66 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 67 identifying identify VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 68 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 69 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 70 over over IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 71 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 72 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 73 legislation legislation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 74 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 75 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 76 pass pass VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 417 77 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 1 QUESTION QUESTION VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 2 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 3 What what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 4 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 5 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 6 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 7 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 8 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 9 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 10 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 11 authorized authorize VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 12 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 13 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 14 called call VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 15 wrongdoing wrongdoing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 17 just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 18 prove prove VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 19 anything anything NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 20 wrong wrong JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 22 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 23 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 24 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 25 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 26 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 27 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 28 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 29 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 30 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 31 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 32 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 33 find find VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 35 wrong wrong NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 37 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 38 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 39 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 40 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 41 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 42 directed direct VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 43 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 44 impose impose VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 45 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 46 whole whole JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 47 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 48 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 49 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 50 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 51 depending depend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 52 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 53 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 54 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 55 wrong wrong NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 56 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 57 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 58 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 59 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 60 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 61 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 62 do do VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 63 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 64 just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 65 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 66 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 67 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 68 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 70 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 418 71 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 1 I -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 2 suppose suppose VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 3 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 4 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 5 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 6 perfectly perfectly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 7 okay okay JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 419 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 420 1 MS MS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 420 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 420 3 GOCHMAN GOCHMAN NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 420 4 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 420 5 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 420 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 1 That that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 2 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 3 probably probably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 4 go go VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 5 way way RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 6 too too RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 7 far far RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 421 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 422 1 That that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 422 2 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 422 3 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 422 4 too too RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 422 5 extreme extreme JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 422 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 423 1 It -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 423 2 's be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 423 3 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 423 4 vague vague JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 423 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 424 1 It -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 424 2 's be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 424 3 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 424 4 overbroad overbroad JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 424 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 1 It -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 2 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 3 n't not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 4 give give VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 5 notice notice NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 6 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 7 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 8 defendants defendant NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 10 exactly exactly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 11 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 12 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 13 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 14 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 16 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 18 requisite requisite NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 19 mens men NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 20 rea rea NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 21 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 425 22 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 1 QUESTION QUESTION VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 2 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 3 Well well UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 5 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 6 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 7 perhaps perhaps RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 8 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 9 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 10 checklist checklist NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 11 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 12 95 95 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 13 different different JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 14 things thing NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 15 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 16 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 17 qualify qualify VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 18 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 19 wrongdoing wrongdoing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 426 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 1 Any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 2 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 4 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 5 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 6 found find VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 8 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 9 you -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 10 turn turn VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 11 over over RP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 13 matter matter NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 14 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 16 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 18 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 19 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 20 there there RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 21 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 22 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 23 's be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 24 up up IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 25 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 27 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 28 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 29 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 30 basis basis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 31 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 33 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 36 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 37 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 38 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 39 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 40 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 41 required require VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 427 42 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 1 MS MS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 3 GOCHMAN GOCHMAN NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 4 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 5 Well well UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 7 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 8 're be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 9 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 10 suggesting suggest VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 11 at at RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 12 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 13 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 14 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 15 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 16 take take VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 17 away away RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 18 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 20 prosecutor prosecutor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 21 's 's POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 22 burden burden NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 23 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 24 prove prove VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 25 mens men NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 26 rea rea VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 27 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 28 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 29 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 30 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 32 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 33 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 36 traditional traditional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 37 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 38 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 39 traditional traditional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 40 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 428 41 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 1 That that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 2 's be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 3 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 4 at at RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 5 all all RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 6 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 7 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 8 're be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 9 arguing argue VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 10 here here RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 12 so so IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 13 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 14 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 15 hypothetical hypothetical NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 16 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 19 course course NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 20 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 21 QUESTION question NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 22 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 23 Well well UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 25 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 26 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 28 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 29 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 31 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 32 your -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 33 view view NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 35 about about IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 36 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 37 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 38 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 39 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 40 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 42 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 43 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 44 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 45 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 46 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 47 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 48 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 429 49 ? ? . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 430 1 What what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 430 2 's be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 430 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 430 4 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 430 5 ? ? . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 1 Transcript Transcript NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 2 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 3 Oral Oral NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 4 Argument Argument NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 5 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 6 29 29 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 7 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 8 30 30 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 10 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 11 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 12 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 13 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 15 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 431 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 3 478 478 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 6 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 7 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 432 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 1 111 111 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 2 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 3 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 4 posed pose VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 5 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 6 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 7 hypothetical hypothetical NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 8 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 9 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 10 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 11 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 12 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 13 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 14 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 15 California California NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 17 524 524 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 18 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 19 721 721 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 21 738 738 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 22 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 23 1998 1998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 24 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 25 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 26 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 28 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 30 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 31 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 433 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 1 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 2 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 3 California California NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 4 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 5 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 6 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 7 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 8 nearly nearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 9 that that RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 10 sinister sinister NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 12 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 13 takes take VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 15 first first JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 16 steps step NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 17 down down IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 18 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 19 road road NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 434 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 2 California California NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 3 Code Code NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 4 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 5 full full JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 7 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 8 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 9 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 10 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 11 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 12 look look VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 13 exactly exactly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 14 like like IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 15 separate separate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 16 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 18 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 19 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 20 expose expose VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 22 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 23 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 24 additional additional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 25 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 26 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 28 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 435 29 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 436 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 436 2 739 739 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 436 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 1 112 112 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 2 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 4 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 7 88 88 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 437 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 438 1 438 438 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 438 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 438 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 439 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 439 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 439 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 439 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 439 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 440 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 440 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 440 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 441 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 441 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 441 3 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 441 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 441 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 441 6 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 441 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 1 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 2 situation situation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 3 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 4 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 6 unpalatable unpalatable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 7 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 9 turning turn VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 11 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 12 essentially essentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 13 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 14 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 15 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 16 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 17 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 18 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 20 moreover moreover RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 22 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 23 need nee MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 24 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 25 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 26 convinced convince VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 27 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 28 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 29 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 32 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 442 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 1 Somewhere somewhere RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 2 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 3 drafting draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 4 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 5 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 6 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 7 dozens dozen NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 9 associated associated JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 10 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 11 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 12 drafting draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 14 different different JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 15 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 16 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 17 cover cover VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 18 every every DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 19 possible possible JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 20 permutation permutation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 22 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 23 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 24 lies lie VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 25 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 26 practical practical JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 27 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 28 just just JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 29 reality reality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 443 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 1 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 2 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 3 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 4 well well RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 5 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 6 settled settle VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 7 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 8 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 9 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 11 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 12 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 13 draft draft VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 14 legislation legislation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 15 criminalizing criminalize VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 16 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 17 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 20 likewise likewise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 22 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 23 identify identify VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 24 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 25 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 26 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 27 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 29 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 30 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 31 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 32 limitations limitation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 33 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 35 exercise exercise NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 37 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 38 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 444 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 1 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 3 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 4 response response NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 5 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 6 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 7 Breyer Breyer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 8 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 9 query query NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 10 during during IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 11 oral oral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 12 argument argument NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 13 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 14 Apprendi—“It apprendi—“it CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 15 ’s ’s , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 16 just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 17 drafting draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 445 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 1 Is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 2 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 3 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 4 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 5 is?”113—the is?”113—the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 6 answer answer NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 9 course course NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 11 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 12 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 13 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 14 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 16 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 17 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 19 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 21 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 22 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 23 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 24 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 26 legislative legislative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 27 fiat fiat NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 28 alone alone RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 29 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 30 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 31 dictate dictate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 33 validity validity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 35 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 36 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 37 factor.114 factor.114 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 38 After after RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 39 all all RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 40 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 41 according accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 42 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 43 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 44 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 45 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 46 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 47 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 48 California California NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 49 115—a 115—a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 50 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 51 addressing address VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 52 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 53 constitutionality constitutionality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 54 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 55 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 56 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 57 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 58 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 59 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 60 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 61 prior prior JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 62 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 63 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 64 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 65 “ " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 66 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 67 i]f i]f NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 68 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 69 protections protection NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 70 extended extend VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 71 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 72 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 73 defendants defendant NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 74 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 75 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 76 Bill Bill NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 77 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 78 Rights Rights NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 79 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 80 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 81 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 82 easily easily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 83 circumvented circumvent VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 84 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 85 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 86 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 87 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 88 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 89 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 90 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 91 most most JJS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 92 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 93 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 94 rights right NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 95 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 96 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 97 nothing nothing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 98 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 99 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 100 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 101 vain vain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 102 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 103 idle idle JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 104 enactment[s enactment[s NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 105 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 106 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 107 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 108 accomplished accomplish VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 109 nothing nothing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 110 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 111 ”116 ”116 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 112 Accordingly accordingly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 113 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 114 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 115 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 116 t]he t]he : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 117 fundamental fundamental JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 118 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 119 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 120 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 121 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 122 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 123 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 124 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 125 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 126 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 127 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 128 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 129 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 130 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 131 go go VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 132 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 133 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 134 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 135 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 446 136 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 447 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 448 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 449 1 delimits delimit VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 449 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 449 3 boundaries boundary NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 449 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 449 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 450 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 451 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 1 important important JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 2 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 3 rights right NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 5 like like IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 7 Sixth Sixth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 8 Amendment Amendment NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 9 right right NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 10 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 11 trial trial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 12 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 13 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 14 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 16 right right NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 17 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 18 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 19 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 21 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 22 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 24 ”117 ”117 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 25 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 26 order order NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 27 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 28 avoid avoid VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 29 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 30 flouting flout VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 31 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 32 common common JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 33 morality morality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 34 “ " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 35 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 36 bringing bring VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 37 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 38 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 39 contempt contempt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 40 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 41 through through IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 42 ad ad FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 43 hoc hoc FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 44 drafting drafting NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 45 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 46 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 47 statutes statute NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 48 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 49 Professor Professor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 50 Hart Hart NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 51 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 52 suggested suggest VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 53 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 54 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 55 concepts concept NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 56 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 57 proportionality proportionality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 58 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 59 uniformity uniformity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 60 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 61 inform inform VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 62 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 63 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 64 distinguishing distinguish VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 65 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 66 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 67 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 68 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 69 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 70 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 71 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 72 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 73 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 74 guiding guide VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 75 principle principle NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 76 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 77 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 78 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 79 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 80 proportion proportion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 81 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 82 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 83 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 84 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 85 penalties penalty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 86 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 87 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 88 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 89 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 90 different different JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 91 offences offence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 92 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 93 these these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 94 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 95 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 96 distinct distinct JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 97 place place NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 98 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 99 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 100 commonsense commonsense JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 101 scale scale NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 102 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 103 gravity gravity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 104 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 105 ”118 ”118 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 106 So so IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 107 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 108 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 109 maintain maintain VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 110 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 111 integrity integrity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 112 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 113 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 114 system system NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 115 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 116 penalties penalty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 117 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 118 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 119 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 120 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 121 commissions commission NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 122 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 123 avoid avoid VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 124 filling fill VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 125 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 126 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 127 codes code NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 128 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 129 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 130 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 131 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 132 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 133 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 134 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 135 look look VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 136 exactly exactly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 137 like like IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 138 separate separate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 139 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 140 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 141 ”119 ”119 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 142 With with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 143 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 144 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 145 mind mind NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 146 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 147 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 148 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 149 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 150 foreshadowing foreshadow VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 151 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 152 issue issue NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 153 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 154 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 155 later later RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 156 confront confront VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 157 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 158 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 159 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 160 noted note VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 161 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 162 following following NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 163 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 164 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 165 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 166 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 167 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 168 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 452 169 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 1 113 113 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 2 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 3 Breyer Breyer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 5 Transcript Transcript NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 7 Oral Oral NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 8 Argument Argument NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 10 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 12 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 13 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 14 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 15 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 17 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 453 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 454 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 454 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 454 3 478 478 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 454 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 454 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 1 114 114 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 3 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 5 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 6 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 8 86 86 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 455 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 1 115 115 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 2 524 524 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 3 U.S. U.S. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 4 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 5 738 738 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 7 1998 1998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 456 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 1 116 116 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 2 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 4 524 524 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 7 738 738 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 9 1998 1998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 10 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 11 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 12 internal internal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 13 quotations quotation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 14 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 17 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 18 Slaughter Slaughter NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 19 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 20 House House NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 21 Cases Cases NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 23 83 83 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 24 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 25 36 36 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 27 96 96 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 28 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 29 1872 1872 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 30 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 31 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 457 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 1 117 117 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 2 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 4 524 524 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 7 738 738 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 9 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 11 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 13 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 458 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 1 118 118 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 3 HART HART NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 5 supra supra NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 6 note note NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 7 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 9 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 10 24 24 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 11 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 12 25 25 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 459 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 1 119 119 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 2 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 4 524 524 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 7 738 738 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 460 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 4 439 439 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 5 Today today NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 7 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 8 holds hold VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 9 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 10 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 11 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 12 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 13 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 14 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 15 define define VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 17 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 18 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 19 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 21 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 22 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 23 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 24 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 26 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 27 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 28 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 29 authoritatively authoritatively RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 30 determine determine VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 31 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 33 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 34 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 35 described describe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 36 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 37 i.e i.e NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 38 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 39 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 41 prohibited prohibit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 42 activity activity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 43 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 44 subjects subject VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 45 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 46 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 47 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 48 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 49 sanctions sanction NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 50 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 51 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 52 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 53 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 54 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 55 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 56 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 57 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 58 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 59 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 60 Due Due NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 61 Process Process NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 62 Clause Clause NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 63 requires require VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 64 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 65 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 66 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 67 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 68 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 69 prosecution prosecution NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 70 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 71 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 72 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 73 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 461 74 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 1 However however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 4 st st NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 5 ate ate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 6 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 7 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 8 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 9 dispense dispense VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 10 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 12 requirement requirement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 14 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 15 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 16 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 17 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 18 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 19 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 20 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 21 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 22 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 23 targets target VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 24 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 25 severe severe JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 26 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 27 penalties penalty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 462 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 1 Because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 3 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 4 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 5 challenged challenge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 7 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 8 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 9 describes describe VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 10 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 11 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 13 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 14 Legislat Legislat NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 15 ure ure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 16 obviously obviously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 17 intended intend VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 18 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 19 prohibit prohibit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 21 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 22 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 23 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 24 mandates mandate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 25 lengthy lengthy JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 26 incarceration incarceration NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 27 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 29 same same JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 32 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 33 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 34 described describe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 35 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 36 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 37 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 38 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 39 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 40 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 41 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 42 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 43 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 44 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 45 requiring require VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 46 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 47 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 48 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 49 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 50 doubt.120 doubt.120 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 51 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 52 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 53 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 54 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 55 potential potential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 56 impact impact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 57 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 58 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 59 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 60 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 61 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 62 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 63 applicability applicability NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 64 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 65 fundamental fundamental JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 66 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 67 rights right NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 68 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 69 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 70 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 71 i]t i]t NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 72 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 73 critical critical JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 74 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 75 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 76 moral moral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 77 force force NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 78 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 79 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 80 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 81 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 82 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 83 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 84 diluted dilute VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 85 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 86 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 87 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 88 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 89 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 90 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 91 leaves leave VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 92 people people NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 93 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 94 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 95 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 96 innocent innocent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 97 men man NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 98 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 99 being be VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 100 condemned condemn VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 101 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 102 ”121 ”121 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 103 Certainly certainly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 104 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 105 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 106 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 107 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 108 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 109 punished punish VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 110 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 111 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 112 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 113 properly properly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 114 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 115 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 116 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 117 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 118 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 119 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 120 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 121 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 122 proved prove VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 123 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 124 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 125 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 126 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 127 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 128 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 129 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 130 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 131 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 132 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 133 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 134 indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 135 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 136 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 137 moral moral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 138 force force NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 139 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 140 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 141 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 142 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 143 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 144 left leave VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 145 open open JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 146 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 147 question.122 question.122 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 148 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 149 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 150 situations situation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 151 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 152 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 153 imposition imposition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 154 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 155 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 156 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 157 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 158 becomes become VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 159 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 160 de de FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 161 facto facto FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 162 conviction conviction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 163 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 164 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 165 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 166 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 167 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 168 become become VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 169 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 170 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 463 171 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 1 Given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 2 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 3 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 4 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 5 dissent dissent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 7 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 8 coupled couple VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 9 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 10 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 11 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 12 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 13 dissent dissent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 14 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 15 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 17 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 18 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 19 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 20 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 21 concern concern NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 22 expressed express VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 23 during during IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 24 oral oral JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 25 argument argument NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 26 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 27 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 28 regarding regard VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 29 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 31 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 32 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 464 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 465 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 466 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 2 dividing divide VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 3 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 4 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 5 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 6 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 7 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 8 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 10 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 11 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 12 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 13 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 14 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 15 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 16 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 17 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 18 factor,”123 factor,”123 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 19 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 20 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 21 telling tell VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 22 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 23 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 24 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 25 authored author VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 27 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 28 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 29 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 30 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 32 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 33 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 34 both both DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 35 Justices Justices NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 36 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 37 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 38 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 39 joined join VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 467 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 1 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 3 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 4 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 5 enunciated enunciate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 6 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 7 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 8 appears appear VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 10 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 11 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 12 face face NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 14 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 15 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 16 concern concern VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 17 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 18 situations situation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 19 wherein wherein WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 20 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 21 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 22 increased increase VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 24 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 25 maximum maximum NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 26 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 29 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 30 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 31 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 32 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 33 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 34 read read VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 35 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 36 expansively expansively RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 37 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 38 especially especially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 39 considering consider VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 41 constituents constituent NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 44 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 468 45 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 1 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 2 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 4 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 7 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 8 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 9 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 10 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 11 situations situation NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 12 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 14 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 15 maximum maximum NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 16 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 17 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 18 increased increase VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 20 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 21 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 23 words word NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 25 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 26 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 29 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 30 amounts amount VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 31 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 32 nothing nothing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 33 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 34 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 35 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 36 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 37 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 38 formalism formalism NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 40 ”124 ”124 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 41 Legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 42 easily easily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 43 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 44 comply comply VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 45 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 46 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 47 purported purport VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 48 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 49 simply simply RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 50 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 51 making make VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 52 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 53 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 54 subject subject JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 55 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 56 high high JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 57 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 58 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 59 penalties.125 penalties.125 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 60 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 61 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 62 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 63 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 64 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 65 formalistic formalistic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 66 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 67 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 68 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 70 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 71 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 72 principle principle NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 73 amounts amount VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 74 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 75 nothing nothing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 76 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 77 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 78 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 79 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 80 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 81 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 82 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 83 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 84 96 96 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 85 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 86 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 87 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 88 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 89 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 90 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 91 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 469 92 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 1 121 121 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 2 Boyce Boyce NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 3 F. F. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 4 Martin Martin NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 6 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 7 Cornerstone Cornerstone NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 8 Has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 9 No No NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 10 Foundation Foundation NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 11 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 12 Relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 13 Conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 14 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 15 Sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 18 Requirements requirement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 20 Due Due NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 21 Process Process NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 23 3 3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 24 SETON SETON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 25 HALL HALL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 26 CONST CONST NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 470 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 471 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 471 2 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 1 25 25 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 3 37 37 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 5 1993 1993 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 8 citing cite VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 9 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 10 re re IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 11 Winship Winship NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 12 397 397 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 13 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 14 358 358 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 16 363 363 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 17 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 18 64 64 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 19 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 20 1970 1970 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 21 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 22 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 472 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 1 122 122 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 3 HART HART NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 5 supra supra NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 6 note note NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 7 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 473 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 1 123 123 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 2 Transcript Transcript NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 4 Oral Oral NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 5 Argument Argument NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 7 29 29 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 8 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 9 30 30 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 11 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 12 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 13 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 14 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 15 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 16 No no UH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 474 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 475 1 99 99 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 475 2 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 475 3 478 478 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 475 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 475 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 2 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 3 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 4 California California NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 6 524 524 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 7 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 8 721 721 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 10 1998 1998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 11 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 13 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 14 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 15 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 16 expressed express VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 17 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 18 concern concern NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 19 regarding regard VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 21 limits limit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 22 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 23 legislative legislative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 24 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 25 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 26 drafting draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 27 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 28 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 476 29 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 1 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 2 Monge Monge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 4 524 524 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 7 738 738 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 9 Scalia Scalia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 11 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 13 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 477 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 1 124 124 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 4 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 5 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 6 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 8 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 9 2389 2389 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 11 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 13 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 14 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 478 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 479 1 125 125 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 479 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 479 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 479 4 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 479 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 480 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 480 2 2390 2390 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 480 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 481 1 440 440 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 481 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 481 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 482 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 482 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 482 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 482 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 482 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 483 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 483 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 483 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 2 chastising chastise VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 3 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 5 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 6 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 7 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 8 failing fail VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 9 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 10 use use VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 12 approved approve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 13 phrasing phrasing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 14 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 15 expressing express VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 16 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 17 intent intent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 18 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 19 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 20 how how WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 21 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 23 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 24 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 25 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 26 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 27 punished punish VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 29 ”126 ”126 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 30 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 32 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 33 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 36 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 37 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 38 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 39 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 40 accords accord NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 42 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 43 best good JJS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 44 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 45 marginal marginal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 46 protection protection NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 47 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 48 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 49 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 50 rights right NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 51 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 52 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 53 seeks seek VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 54 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 55 effectuate effectuate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 56 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 57 ”127 ”127 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 58 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 59 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 60 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 61 noted note VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 62 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 63 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 64 given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 65 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 66 pure pure JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 67 formalism formalism NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 68 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 69 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 70 above above JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 71 reading read VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 72 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 73 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 74 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 75 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 76 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 77 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 78 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 79 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 80 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 81 suspects suspect VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 82 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 83 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 84 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 85 principle principle NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 86 underlying underlie VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 87 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 88 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 89 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 90 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 91 far far RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 92 reaching reach VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 93 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 94 ”128 ”128 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 95 Certainly certainly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 96 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 97 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 98 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 99 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 484 100 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 1 Rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 2 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 3 reading read VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 4 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 5 formalistically formalistically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 8 holding holding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 9 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 10 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 11 read read VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 12 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 14 clarification clarification NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 16 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 17 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 18 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 19 albeit albeit IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 21 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 22 still still RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 23 somewhat somewhat RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 24 vague vague JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 26 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 27 perhaps perhaps RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 28 incomplete incomplete JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 29 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 30 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 31 delineating delineate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 33 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 34 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 35 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 36 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 37 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 38 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 39 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 40 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 41 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 485 42 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 1 Under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 2 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 3 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 5 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 8 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 9 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 10 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 11 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 12 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 13 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 15 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 16 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 17 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 18 serves serve VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 19 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 20 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 21 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 22 indicator indicator NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 23 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 25 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 26 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 27 being be VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 28 violated violate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 30 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 31 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 32 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 33 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 34 read read VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 35 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 37 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 38 itself -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 486 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 1 Rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 4 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 7 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 8 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 9 read read VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 10 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 11 requiring require VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 12 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 13 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 14 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 15 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 16 legislature legislature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 17 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 18 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 19 dispense dispense VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 20 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 22 requirement requirement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 24 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 25 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 26 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 27 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 28 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 29 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 30 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 31 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 32 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 33 targets target VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 34 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 35 severe severe JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 36 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 37 penalties penalty NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 39 ”129 ”129 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 40 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 41 essence essence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 44 substantive substantive NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 45 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 46 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 47 opposed oppose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 48 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 49 formalistic formalistic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 50 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 51 rule rule VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 52 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 53 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 54 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 55 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 56 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 57 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 58 severe severe JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 59 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 60 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 61 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 62 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 63 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 64 particular particular JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 65 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 66 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 67 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 68 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 69 likely likely JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 70 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 71 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 72 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 73 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 74 question question NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 75 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 76 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 77 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 78 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 79 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 80 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 81 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 82 crime.130 crime.130 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 83 Whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 84 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 85 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 86 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 87 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 88 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 89 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 90 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 91 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 92 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 93 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 94 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 95 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 96 exposed expose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 97 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 98 irrelevant irrelevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 487 99 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 1 Support support NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 2 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 3 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 4 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 5 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 7 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 8 recently recently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 9 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 10 provided provide VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 11 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 13 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 14 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 15 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 16 summarily summarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 17 vacated vacate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 18 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 19 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 20 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 21 Valensia.131 Valensia.131 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 22 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 23 Valensia Valensia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 26 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 27 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 28 pleaded plead VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 29 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 30 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 31 possession possession NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 32 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 33 intent intent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 34 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 35 distribute distribute VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 37 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 38 conspiracy conspiracy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 39 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 40 distribute distribute VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 42 35.71 35.71 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 43 kilograms kilogram NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 44 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 45 methamphetamine.132 methamphetamine.132 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 46 Pursuant pursuant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 47 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 48 21 21 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 488 49 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 2 841(b)(viii 841(b)(viii CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 6 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 7 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 8 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 9 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 10 conspiracy conspiracy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 11 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 12 manufacture manufacture VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 14 possess possess VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 15 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 16 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 17 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 19 methamphetamine methamphetamine NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 20 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 21 ten ten CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 22 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 24 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 26 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 27 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 28 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 29 life life NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 489 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 1 Based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 2 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 4 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 6 drugs drug NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 7 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 10 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 11 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 12 calculated calculate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 14 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 15 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 16 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 17 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 18 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 19 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 20 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 21 38 38 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 23 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 24 translated translate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 25 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 26 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 27 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 28 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 29 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 31 235 235 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 32 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 33 293 293 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 34 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 35 imprisonment.133 imprisonment.133 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 36 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 37 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 38 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 39 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 40 enhanced enhance VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 41 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 42 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 43 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 44 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 45 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 46 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 47 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 48 four four CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 49 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 50 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 51 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 52 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 53 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 54 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 55 leadership leadership NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 56 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 57 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 58 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 59 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 60 conspiracy conspiracy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 61 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 62 126 126 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 490 63 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 2 quoting quote VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 3 Jones Jones NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 5 526 526 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 6 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 8 267 267 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 10 Kennedy Kennedy NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 12 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 14 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 491 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 492 1 127 127 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 492 2 I -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 492 3 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 492 4 .. .. NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 492 5 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 492 6 2389 2389 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 492 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 493 1 128 128 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 493 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 2 2391 2391 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 4 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 6 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 8 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 494 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 1 129 129 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 2 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 4 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 5 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 6 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 7 96 96 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 9 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 11 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 13 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 495 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 1 130 130 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 2 Of of RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 3 course course RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 5 precisely precisely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 6 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 8 severity severity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 10 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 11 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 12 turns turn VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 13 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 14 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 15 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 16 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 17 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 18 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 21 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 22 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 23 uncertain uncertain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 496 24 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 3 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 4 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 5 argue argue VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 6 below below IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 8 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 9 some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 10 instances instance NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 12 answer answer NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 13 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 14 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 497 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 1 131 131 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 2 222 222 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 3 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 4 1173 1173 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 6 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 7 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 498 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 4 vacated vacate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 6 121 121 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 7 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 8 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 9 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 10 1222 1222 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 11 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 12 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 15 Mem Mem NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 17 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 499 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 500 1 132 132 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 500 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 500 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 500 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 500 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 501 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 501 2 1181 1181 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 501 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 502 1 133 133 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 502 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 502 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 502 4 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 502 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 4 441 441 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 5 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 6 possession possession NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 8 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 9 firearm firearm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 10 during during IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 12 course course NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 15 conspiracy conspiracy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 17 bringing bring VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 19 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 20 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 21 adjusted adjusted JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 22 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 23 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 24 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 25 42.134 42.134 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 26 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 27 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 28 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 29 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 30 deducted deduct VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 31 three three CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 32 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 33 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 35 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 36 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 37 acceptance acceptance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 38 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 39 responsibility responsibility NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 40 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 41 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 42 reduced reduce VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 44 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 45 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 46 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 47 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 48 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 49 39 39 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 50 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 51 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 52 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 53 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 54 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 55 262 262 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 56 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 57 327 327 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 58 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 59 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 503 60 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 1 Had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 3 four four CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 4 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 5 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 6 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 7 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 8 applied apply VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 10 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 12 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 14 three three CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 15 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 16 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 17 reduction reduction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 18 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 19 acceptance acceptance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 21 responsibility responsibility NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 22 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 23 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 24 reduced reduce VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 26 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 27 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 28 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 29 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 30 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 31 38 38 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 32 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 33 35 35 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 35 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 36 down down RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 37 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 38 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 39 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 40 guideline guideline NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 41 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 43 168 168 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 44 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 45 210 210 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 46 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 47 imprisonment.135 imprisonment.135 NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 48 On on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 49 appeal appeal NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 50 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 52 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 53 argued argue VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 54 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 56 four four CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 57 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 58 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 59 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 60 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 61 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 62 increased increase VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 63 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 64 minimum minimum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 65 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 66 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 67 94 94 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 68 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 69 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 70 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 71 nearly nearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 72 eight eight CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 73 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 74 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 75 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 76 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 77 extremely extremely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 78 disproportionate disproportionate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 79 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 80 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 81 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 82 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 83 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 84 unless unless IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 85 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 86 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 87 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 88 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 89 applied apply VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 90 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 91 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 92 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 93 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 94 convincing convincing JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 95 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 96 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 97 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 98 ”136 ”136 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 99 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 100 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 101 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 102 disagreed disagree VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 103 noting note VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 104 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 105 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 106 part part NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 107 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 108 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 109 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 110 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 111 enhanced enhanced JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 112 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 113 f[e]ll f[e]ll NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 114 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 115 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 116 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 117 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 118 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 119 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 120 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 121 alleged allege VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 122 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 123 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 124 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 125 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 126 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 127 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 128 therefore therefore RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 129 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 130 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 131 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 132 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 133 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 134 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 135 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 136 sufficient.137 sufficient.137 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 137 Moreover moreover RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 138 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 139 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 140 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 141 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 142 cited cite VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 143 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 144 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 145 support support NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 146 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 147 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 148 rationale rationale NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 149 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 150 refusing refuse VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 151 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 152 require require VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 153 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 154 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 155 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 156 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 157 apply apply VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 158 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 159 standard standard JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 160 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 161 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 162 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 163 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 164 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 165 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 166 evidence.138 evidence.138 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 167 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 168 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 169 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 170 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 171 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 172 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 173 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 174 Valensia Valensia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 175 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 176 life life NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 177 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 178 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 179 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 180 formalistic formalistic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 181 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 182 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 183 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 184 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 185 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 186 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 187 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 188 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 189 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 190 violated violate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 191 inasmuch inasmuch JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 192 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 193 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 194 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 195 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 196 possibly possibly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 197 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 198 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 199 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 200 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 201 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 202 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 203 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 204 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 205 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 206 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 504 207 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 1 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 3 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 4 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 5 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 6 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 7 appeared appear VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 8 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 9 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 10 consistent consistent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 11 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 12 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 13 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 14 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 16 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 17 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 18 every every DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 19 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 20 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 22 appeals appeal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 23 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 24 interpreting interpret VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 25 Apprendi,139 apprendi,139 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 26 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 27 March March NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 28 5 5 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 30 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 33 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 34 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 35 summarily summarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 36 vacated vacate VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 37 Valensia.140 Valensia.140 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 38 Ironically Ironically NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 39 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 41 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 42 remanded remand VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 44 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 45 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 46 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 47 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 48 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 49 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 50 instructions instruction NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 51 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 52 reconsider reconsider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 53 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 54 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 55 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 56 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 57 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 58 Apprendi.141 Apprendi.141 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 59 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 60 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 61 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 62 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 63 appears appear VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 64 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 65 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 66 Ninth Ninth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 67 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 68 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 69 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 70 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 71 Valensia Valensia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 72 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 73 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 74 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 75 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 76 formalistic formalistic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 77 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 78 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 79 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 80 rule rule NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 81 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 82 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 83 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 84 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 85 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 86 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 87 decision decision NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 88 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 89 vacate vacate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 90 Valensia Valensia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 91 signals signal VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 92 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 93 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 94 indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 95 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 96 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 97 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 98 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 99 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 100 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 101 134 134 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 102 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 103 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 104 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 505 105 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 506 1 135 135 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 506 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 506 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 506 4 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 506 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 507 1 136 136 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 507 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 508 1 137 137 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 508 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 509 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 509 2 1182 1182 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 509 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 510 1 138 138 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 510 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 510 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 510 4 d d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 510 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 511 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 511 2 1182 1182 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 511 3 n.4 n.4 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 511 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 1 139 139 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 3 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 4 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 5 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 6 Robinson Robinson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 8 241 241 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 9 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 10 115 115 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 12 119 119 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 14 1st 1st JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 15 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 512 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 1 2001 2001 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 4 holding hold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 6 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 7 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 8 violation violation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 9 occurs occur VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 10 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 11 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 13 below below IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 14 default default NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 15 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 16 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 17 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 18 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 19 accord accord NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 20 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 21 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 22 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 23 Houle Houle NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 25 237 237 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 26 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 27 71 71 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 29 79 79 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 30 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 31 80 80 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 32 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 33 1st 1st NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 34 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 513 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 1 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 7 Garcia Garcia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 9 240 240 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 10 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 11 180 180 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 13 184 184 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 15 2d 2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 16 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 514 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 1 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 7 Thompson Thompson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 9 237 237 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 10 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 11 1258 1258 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 13 1262 1262 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 14 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 15 63 63 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 17 10th 10th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 18 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 515 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 1 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 7 Williams Williams NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 9 235 235 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 10 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 11 858 858 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 13 863 863 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 15 3d 3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 16 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 516 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 7 Kinter Kinter NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 9 235 235 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 10 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 11 192 192 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 13 202 202 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 15 4th 4th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 16 Cir Cir NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 517 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 7 Keith Keith NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 9 230 230 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 10 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 11 784 784 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 13 787 787 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 15 5th 5th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 16 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 518 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 4 per per IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 5 curiam curiam NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 8 cert cert NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 519 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 1 denied deny VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 3 121 121 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 4 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 5 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 6 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 7 1163 1163 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 9 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 10 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 11 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 12 Hernandez Hernandez NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 13 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 14 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 15 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 17 226 226 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 18 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 19 839 839 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 21 841 841 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 22 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 23 42 42 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 24 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 25 7th 7th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 26 Cir Cir NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 520 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 7 Aguayo Aguayo NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 8 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 9 Delgado Delgado NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 11 220 220 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 12 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 13 926 926 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 15 933 933 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 16 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 17 34 34 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 18 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 19 8th 8th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 20 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 521 21 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 522 1 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 522 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 522 3 cert cert NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 522 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 1 denied deny VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 3 121 121 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 4 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 5 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 7 600 600 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 9 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 10 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 11 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 12 see see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 13 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 14 discussion discussion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 15 supra supra IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 16 Part Part NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 523 17 I.F. I.F. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 1 140 140 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 3 Valensia Valensia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 5 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 6 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 8 121 121 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 9 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 10 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 11 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 12 1222 1222 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 14 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 17 Mem Mem NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 19 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 524 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 525 1 141 141 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 525 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 525 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 525 4 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 525 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 526 1 442 442 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 526 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 526 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 527 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 527 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 527 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 527 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 527 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 528 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 528 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 528 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 529 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 529 2 formalism formalism NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 529 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 1 C. C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 2 Two Two NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 3 Roads Roads NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 4 Converged converge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 6 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 7 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 8 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 9 Wood Wood NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 11 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 12 That that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 13 Is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 14 Making make VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 15 All all PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 17 Difference Difference NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 18 There there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 19 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 20 two two CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 21 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 22 roads road NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 23 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 24 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 26 history history NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 28 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 29 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 30 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 31 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 32 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 33 lead lead VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 34 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 35 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 530 36 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 1 One one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 2 road road NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 3 regards regard VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 5 constitutionality constitutionality NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 6 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 7 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 9 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 10 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 11 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 12 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 13 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 531 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 1 Along along IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 2 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 3 road road NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 6 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 7 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 8 recognized recognize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 9 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 10 legitimized legitimize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 12 distinct distinct JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 13 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 15 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 16 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 17 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 19 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 20 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 532 21 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 1 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 2 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 4 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 5 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 6 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 7 enhance enhance VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 8 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 9 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 11 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 12 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 13 consider consider VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 14 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 15 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 16 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 17 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 18 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 19 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 20 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 21 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 22 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 23 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 24 included include VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 25 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 27 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 533 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 1 Furthermore furthermore RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 4 Constitution Constitution NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 5 permits permit VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 6 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 7 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 8 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 9 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 10 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 11 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 12 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 13 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 14 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 17 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 19 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 20 only only JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 21 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 23 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 24 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 25 need need NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 26 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 27 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 28 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 29 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 30 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 31 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 32 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 33 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 34 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 35 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 534 36 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 2 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 3 road road NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 4 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 5 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 6 regards regard VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 8 constitutional constitutional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 9 limit limit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 10 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 11 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 12 legislative legislative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 13 discretion discretion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 14 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 15 drafting draft VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 16 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 17 statutes statute NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 535 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 1 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 2 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 3 generally generally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 4 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 5 free free JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 6 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 7 identify identify VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 9 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 11 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 12 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 15 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 16 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 17 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 18 enhance enhance VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 19 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 20 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 21 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 22 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 24 recent recent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 25 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 26 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 27 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 28 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 29 suggests suggest VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 30 strongly strongly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 31 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 32 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 33 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 34 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 35 draft draft VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 36 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 37 statutes statute NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 38 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 39 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 40 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 41 way way NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 42 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 43 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 44 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 45 trump trump VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 46 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 47 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 536 48 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 2 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 3 words word NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 5 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 6 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 7 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 8 draft draft VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 9 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 10 statutes statute NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 11 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 12 make make VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 14 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 15 underlying underlie VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 17 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 18 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 20 focus focus NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 22 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 24 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 25 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 27 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 28 constituting constitute VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 29 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 30 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 31 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 33 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 34 offense.142 offense.142 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 35 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 36 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 37 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 38 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 39 delegate delegate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 40 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 41 another another DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 42 body body NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 43 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 44 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 45 themselves -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 46 do do VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 47 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 48 possess possess VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 49 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 50 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 51 follows follow VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 52 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 53 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 54 commissions commission NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 55 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 56 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 57 whom whom WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 58 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 59 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 60 delegated delegate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 61 authority authority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 62 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 63 promulgate promulgate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 64 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 65 guidelines,143 guidelines,143 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 66 likewise likewise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 67 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 68 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 69 draft draft VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 70 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 71 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 72 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 73 include include VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 74 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 75 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 76 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 77 trump trump VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 78 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 79 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 80 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 81 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 82 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 537 83 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 2 tension tension NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 3 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 5 impact impact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 6 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 7 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 8 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 9 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 10 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 11 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 12 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 13 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 14 hand hand NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 18 integrity integrity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 20 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 21 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 22 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 24 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 26 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 27 exemplified exemplify VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 28 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 29 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 30 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 31 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 32 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 33 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 35 appeals appeal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 36 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 37 upholding uphold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 38 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 39 standards standard NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 40 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 41 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 42 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 43 severe severe JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 44 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 45 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 538 46 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 2 these these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 3 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 6 appellate appellate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 7 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 8 favored favor VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 9 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 10 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 11 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 12 convincing convincing JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 13 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 15 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 16 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 17 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 18 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 19 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 21 significant significant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 22 impact impact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 23 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 25 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 26 ’s ’s NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 27 sentence.144 sentence.144 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 28 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 29 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 30 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 31 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 32 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 33 yet yet RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 34 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 35 address address VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 37 issue issue NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 38 142 142 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 39 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 40 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 42 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 43 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 44 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 45 88 88 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 539 46 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 1 143 143 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 3 Mistretta Mistretta NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 5 488 488 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 6 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 8 371 371 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 540 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 1 144 144 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 2 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 3 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 4 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 5 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 6 Kikumura Kikumura NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 8 918 918 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 9 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 10 1084 1084 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 12 1098 1098 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 13 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 14 1102 1102 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 15 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 16 3d 3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 17 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 541 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 1 1990 1990 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 5 Third Third NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 6 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 7 upheld uphold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 8 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 9 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 10 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 11 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 12 use use NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 15 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 17 convincing convincing JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 18 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 20 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 21 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 542 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 1 Likewise likewise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 4 Second Second NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 5 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 6 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 7 held hold VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 8 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 10 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 11 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 12 rigorous rigorous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 13 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 14 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 15 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 16 used use VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 17 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 18 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 19 disputed dispute VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 20 aspects aspect NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 22 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 23 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 24 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 25 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 26 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 28 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 29 proven prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 31 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 32 significantly significantly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 33 enhance enhance VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 34 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 35 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 36 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 37 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 38 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 39 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 40 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 41 Shonubi Shonubi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 43 103 103 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 44 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 45 1085 1085 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 46 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 47 1089 1089 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 48 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 49 2d 2d CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 50 Cir.1997 Cir.1997 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 51 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 543 52 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 1 Two two CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 2 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 3 circuits circuit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 4 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 5 suggested suggest VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 7 same same JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 544 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 5 Townley Townley NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 7 929 929 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 8 F.2d F.2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 9 365 365 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 11 369 369 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 12 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 13 370 370 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 15 8th 8th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 16 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 545 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 1 1991 1991 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 7 Restrepo Restrepo NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 9 946 946 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 10 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 11 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 12 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 13 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 14 443 443 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 15 directly directly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 17 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 18 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 20 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 21 recent recent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 23 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 24 discussed discuss VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 25 above above RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 27 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 28 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 29 likely likely JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 30 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 32 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 33 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 34 side side VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 35 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 36 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 37 circuit circuit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 38 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 39 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 40 opt opt VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 41 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 42 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 43 standards standard NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 44 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 45 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 46 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 47 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 48 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 49 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 50 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 51 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 52 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 53 dramatically dramatically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 54 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 55 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 56 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 57 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 58 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 59 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 60 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 61 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 62 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 63 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 64 stated state VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 65 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 66 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 67 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 68 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 69 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 70 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 71 faces face VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 72 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 73 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 74 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 75 provided provide VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 76 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 77 statute statute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 78 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 79 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 80 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 81 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 82 committed commit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 83 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 84 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 85 circumstances circumstance NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 86 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 87 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 88 others other NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 89 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 90 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 91 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 92 obvious obvious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 93 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 94 both both CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 95 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 96 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 97 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 98 liberty liberty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 99 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 100 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 101 stigma stigma NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 102 attaching attach VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 103 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 104 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 105 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 106 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 107 heightened heighten VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 108 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 109 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 110 necessarily necessarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 111 follows follow VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 112 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 113 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 114 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 115 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 116 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 117 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 118 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 119 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 120 moment moment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 121 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 122 State state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 123 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 124 put put VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 125 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 126 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 127 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 128 those those DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 129 circumstances circumstance NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 130 -- -- : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 131 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 132 deprived deprive VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 133 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 134 protections protection NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 135 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 136 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 137 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 138 until until IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 139 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 140 point point NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 141 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 142 unquestionably unquestionably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 143 attached attach VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 546 144 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 1 145 145 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 2 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 3 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 6 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 7 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 8 like like JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 9 nature nature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 12 Guidelines146 Guidelines146 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 14 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 15 non- non- NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 16 formalistic formalistic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 17 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 19 Apprendi,147 apprendi,147 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 20 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 21 follows follow VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 22 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 23 potentially potentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 24 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 25 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 26 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 27 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 28 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 29 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 30 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 31 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 32 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 33 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 34 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 35 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 36 depending depend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 37 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 38 how how WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 39 much much JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 41 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 42 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 43 enhances enhance VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 44 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 45 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 547 46 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 1 To to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 2 paraphrase paraphrase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 4 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 6 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 7 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 8 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 9 increase increase VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 10 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 11 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 13 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 15 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 16 both both CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 18 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 20 liberty liberty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 21 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 22 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 23 stigma stigma NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 24 attaching attach VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 25 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 27 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 28 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 29 heightened heighten VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 31 ”148 ”148 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 32 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 33 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 34 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 35 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 37 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 38 rigorous rigorous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 39 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 40 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 41 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 42 appropriate appropriate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 548 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 2 Figure figure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 3 Four four CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 4 below below RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 7 remainder remainder NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 11 universe universe NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 13 shaded shaded JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 14 light light JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 15 gray gray NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 16 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 17 indicate indicate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 19 potential potential NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 20 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 21 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 23 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 24 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 25 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 26 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 27 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 28 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 29 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 30 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 31 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 32 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 34 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 35 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 36 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 37 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 38 dramatically dramatically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 39 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 41 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 549 42 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 1 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 3 increase increase NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 4 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 5 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 6 dramatic dramatic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 7 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 9 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 10 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 11 tail tail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 12 wags wag NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 14 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 15 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 17 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 18 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 21 enhancement enhancement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 22 becomes become VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 23 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 24 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 27 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 550 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 1 654 654 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 3 661 661 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 5 n.12 n.12 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 7 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 8 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 551 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 1 1991 1991 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 4 en en IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 5 banc banc NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 8 cert cert NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 552 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 1 denied deny VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 3 503 503 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 4 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 5 961 961 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 7 1992 1992 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 9 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 10 Restrepo Restrepo NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 12 946 946 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 13 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 15 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 16 661- 661- CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 17 663 663 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 18 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 19 Tang Tang NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 21 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 23 concurring concur VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 24 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 26 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 27 d d VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 553 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 2 664 664 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 3 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 4 679 679 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 6 Norris Norris NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 8 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 10 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 11 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 12 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 13 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 14 d d VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 554 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 2 663 663 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 3 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 4 664 664 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 6 Pregerson Pregerson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 8 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 10 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 11 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 13 advocating advocate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 15 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 16 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 17 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 18 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 19 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 20 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 21 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 22 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 23 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 555 24 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 1 Specifically specifically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 2 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 4 context context NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 6 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 7 Federal Federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 8 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 9 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 12 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 13 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 14 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 15 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 16 acknowledged acknowledge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 17 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 18 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 19 line line NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 21 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 22 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 23 require require VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 24 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 25 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 26 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 28 proof proof NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 29 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 30 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 31 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 32 significantly significantly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 33 enhances enhance VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 35 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 556 36 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 4 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 5 Watts Watts NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 8 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 9 noted note VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 11 following follow VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 12 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 13 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 14 Guidelines Guidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 15 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 16 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 17 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 18 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 19 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 20 appropriate appropriate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 21 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 22 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 23 facts fact VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 24 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 25 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 26 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 27 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 28 proved prove VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 29 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 30 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 31 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 32 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 34 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 35 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 36 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 37 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 38 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 39 held hold VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 40 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 41 application application NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 44 preponderance preponderance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 45 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 46 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 47 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 48 generally generally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 49 satisfies satisfie NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 50 due due JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 51 process process NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 557 52 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 1 We -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 2 acknowledge acknowledge VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 4 divergence divergence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 6 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 7 among among IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 9 Circuits Circuits NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 10 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 11 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 12 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 14 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 15 extreme extreme JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 16 circumstances circumstance NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 18 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 19 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 20 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 21 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 22 dramatically dramatically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 23 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 25 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 26 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 27 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 28 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 29 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 30 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 31 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 32 convin convin JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 33 cing ce VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 34 evidence evidence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 558 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 1 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 2 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 3 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 4 Watts Watts NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 6 519 519 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 7 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 8 148 148 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 10 156 156 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 11 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 12 1997 1997 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 14 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 15 citing cite VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 16 Kikumura Kikumura NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 18 918 918 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 19 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 20 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 21 1102 1102 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 23 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 24 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 25 proposition proposition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 26 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 27 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 28 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 29 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 30 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 31 clear clear JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 32 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 33 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 34 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 35 convincing convincing JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 36 standard standard NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 37 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 38 implicit implicit JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 39 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 40 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 559 41 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 2 3553(b 3553(b CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 5 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 6 requires require VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 7 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 8 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 9 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 10 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 11 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 12 find find VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 13 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 14 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 15 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 16 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 17 order order NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 18 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 19 justify justify VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 20 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 21 large large JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 22 upward upward JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 23 departures departure NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 24 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 25 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 560 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 1 145 145 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 4 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 5 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 6 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 8 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 9 2359 2359 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 561 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 562 1 146 146 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 562 2 See see VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 562 3 supra supra IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 562 4 Part Part NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 562 5 I.B. I.B. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 563 1 147 147 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 563 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 563 3 supra supra FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 563 4 Part Part NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 563 5 II.B. II.B. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 1 148 148 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 4 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 5 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 6 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 8 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 9 2359 2359 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 564 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 565 1 444 444 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 565 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 565 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 566 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 566 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 566 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 566 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 566 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 567 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 567 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 567 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 2 Figure figure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 3 4 4 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 4 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 5 Present present JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 6 Sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 7 Universe Universe NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 8 III III NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 568 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 1 APPRENDI APPRENDI NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 2 ’S ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 3 IMPACT impact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 4 ON on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 5 SENTENCING sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 6 OFFENDERS offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 7 CONVICTED convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 8 OF of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 9 ECONOMIC economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 10 CRIMES crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 11 Although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 13 current current JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 14 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 15 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 16 largely largely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 17 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 18 focused focus VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 19 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 20 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 21 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 22 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 23 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 24 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 25 sentences,149 sentences,149 VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 27 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 28 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 29 rationale rationale NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 30 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 31 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 32 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 33 just just RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 34 as as RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 35 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 36 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 37 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 38 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 569 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 1 Applying apply VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 3 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 5 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 6 regime regime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 7 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 8 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 9 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 10 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 11 significant significant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 12 inasmuch inasmuch NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 13 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 14 roughly roughly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 15 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 16 quarter quarter NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 17 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 18 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 19 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 20 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 21 sentenced sentence VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 22 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 24 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 25 concern concern NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 26 some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 27 form form NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 28 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 29 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 30 crime.150 crime.150 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 31 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 32 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 35 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 36 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 37 called call VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 38 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 39 new new JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 40 technology technology NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 41 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 42 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 43 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 44 e.g e.g NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 45 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 46 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 47 hacking hacking NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 48 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 49 distributed distribute VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 50 denial denial NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 51 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 52 service service NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 53 attacks attack NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 54 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 55 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 56 computer computer NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 57 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 58 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 59 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 60 pump pump NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 61 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 62 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 63 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 64 dump dump NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 65 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 66 securities security NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 67 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 68 schemes,151 schemes,151 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 69 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 70 proportion proportion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 71 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 72 likely likely JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 73 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 74 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 570 75 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 1 Unlike unlike IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 2 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 3 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 4 virtually virtually RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 5 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 6 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 7 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 8 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 10 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 11 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 13 most most RBS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 14 common common JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 15 forms form NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 16 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 17 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 18 crimes152 crimes152 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 19 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 20 driven drive VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 21 entirely entirely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 22 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 23 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 24 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 571 25 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 2 contrast contrast NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 3 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 4 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 5 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 7 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 8 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 9 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 10 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 12 such such JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 13 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 14 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 15 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 16 violent violent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 17 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 19 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 20 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 21 predominately predominately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 22 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 23 149 149 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 24 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 26 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 28 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 29 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 30 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 31 LaFreniere LaFreniere NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 32 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 33 236 236 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 34 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 35 41 41 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 36 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 37 1st 1st NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 38 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 572 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 1 2001 2001 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 4 holding hold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 7 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 8 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 9 require require VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 10 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 11 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 12 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 13 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 14 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 15 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 16 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 17 when when WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 18 district district NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 19 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 20 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 21 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 22 within within IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 23 statutory statutory NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 24 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 25 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 26 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 27 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 28 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 29 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 30 Angle Angle NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 32 230 230 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 33 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 34 113 113 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 35 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 36 4th 4th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 37 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 573 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 4 holding hold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 7 requires require VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 8 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 9 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 10 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 11 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 12 charged charge VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 13 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 14 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 15 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 16 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 17 increases increase VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 18 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 19 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 20 penalty penalty NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 21 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 22 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 23 accord accord NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 24 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 25 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 26 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 27 Doggett Doggett NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 29 230 230 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 30 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 31 160 160 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 32 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 33 5th 5th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 34 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 574 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 7 Flowal Flowal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 9 234 234 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 10 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 11 932 932 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 13 6th 6th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 14 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 575 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 4 Aguyao Aguyao NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 5 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 6 Delagado Delagado NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 8 220 220 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 9 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 10 926 926 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 11 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 12 8th 8th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 13 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 576 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 3 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 4 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 5 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 6 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 7 Nordby Nordby NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 9 225 225 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 10 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 11 1053 1053 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 13 9th 9th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 14 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 577 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 578 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 578 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 578 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 1 150 150 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 3 UNITED UNITED NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 4 STATES STATES NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 5 SENTENCING SENTENCING NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 6 COMMISSION COMMISSION NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 8 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 9 9 9 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 10 9 9 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 11 9 9 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 12 SOURCEBOOK sourcebook NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 13 OF of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 14 FEDERAL federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 15 SENTENCING sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 16 STATISTICS statistic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 17 12 12 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 579 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 1 151 151 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 4 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 6 Vogel Vogel NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 7 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 8 Sands Sands NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 9 Bros. Bros. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 10 & & CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 11 Co. Co. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 13 126 126 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 14 F. F. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 15 Supp.2d Supp.2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 16 730 730 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 17 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 580 18 S.D.N.Y. S.D.N.Y. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 1 2001 2001 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 4 involving involve VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 5 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 6 pump pump VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 7 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 8 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 9 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 10 dump dump NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 11 scheme scheme NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 12 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 13 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 14 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 15 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 16 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 17 Zeneski Zeneski NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 19 912 912 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 20 F. F. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 21 Supp Supp NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 22 43 43 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 23 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 581 24 E.D.N.Y. E.D.N.Y. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 582 1 1996 1996 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 582 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 582 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 582 4 involving involve VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 582 5 hacking hacking NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 582 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 582 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 1 152 152 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 2 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 3 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 5 most most RBS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 6 recent recent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 7 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 8 data datum NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 9 available available JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 11 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 13 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 15 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 16 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 17 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 18 constitute constitute VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 20 vast vast JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 21 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 23 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 24 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 25 sentenced sentence VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 26 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 28 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 583 29 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 584 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 584 2 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 584 3 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 584 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 4 445 445 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 5 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 6 nature nature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 9 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 11 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 12 severity severity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 14 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 15 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 16 reflected reflect VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 17 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 18 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 19 respective respective JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 20 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 21 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 22 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 23 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 24 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 25 ”153 ”153 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 26 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 27 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 28 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 29 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 30 represents represent VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 32 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 33 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 34 assessment assessment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 37 relative relative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 38 severity severity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 39 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 40 particular particular JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 41 crimes,154 crimes,154 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 42 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 43 serves serve VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 44 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 45 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 46 initial initial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 47 starting starting NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 48 point point NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 49 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 50 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 51 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 52 adjustments.155 adjustments.155 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 53 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 54 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 55 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 56 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 57 range range VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 58 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 59 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 60 low low NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 61 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 62 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 63 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 64 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 65 corresponds correspond VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 66 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 67 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 68 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 69 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 70 zero zero CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 71 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 72 six six CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 73 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 74 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 75 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 76 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 77 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 78 high high NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 79 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 80 43 43 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 81 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 82 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 83 corresponds correspond VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 84 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 85 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 86 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 87 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 88 life life NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 89 imprisonment.156 imprisonment.156 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 90 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 91 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 92 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 93 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 94 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 95 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 96 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 97 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 98 ranges range VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 99 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 100 six six CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 101 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 102 38 38 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 103 depending depend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 104 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 105 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 106 type type NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 107 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 108 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 109 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 110 drug drug NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 111 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 112 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 113 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 114 offense.157 offense.157 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 115 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 116 violent violent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 117 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 118 resulting result VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 119 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 120 death death NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 121 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 122 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 123 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 124 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 125 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 126 ranges range VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 127 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 128 10 10 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 129 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 130 43 43 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 131 depending depend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 132 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 133 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 134 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 135 homicide homicide NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 136 constituted constitute VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 137 involuntary involuntary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 138 manslaughter manslaughter NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 139 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 140 first first JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 141 degree degree NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 142 murder.158 murder.158 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 143 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 144 contrast contrast NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 145 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 146 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 147 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 148 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 149 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 150 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 151 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 152 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 153 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 154 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 155 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 156 six,159 six,159 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 157 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 158 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 159 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 160 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 161 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 162 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 163 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 164 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 165 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 166 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 167 four.160 four.160 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 168 No no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 169 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 170 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 171 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 172 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 173 required require VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 174 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 175 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 176 corresponding correspond VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 177 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 178 these these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 179 low low JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 180 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 181 levels.161 levels.161 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 182 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 183 these these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 184 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 185 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 186 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 187 indicate indicate VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 188 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 189 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 190 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 191 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 192 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 193 view view VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 194 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 195 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 196 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 197 being be VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 198 necessarily necessarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 199 as as RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 200 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 201 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 202 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 203 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 204 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 205 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 206 violent violent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 207 offenses.162 offenses.162 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 208 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 209 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 210 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 211 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 212 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 213 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 214 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 215 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 216 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 217 little little JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 218 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 219 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 220 153 153 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 221 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 222 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 223 assign assign VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 224 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 225 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 226 base base JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 227 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 228 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 229 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 230 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 231 each each DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 232 class class NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 233 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 234 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 235 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 585 236 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 4 1B1.2(a 1b1.2(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 6 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 7 28 28 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 586 8 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 2 994(m 994(m CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 5 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 6 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 7 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 8 shall shall NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 587 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 588 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 589 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 1 independently independently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 2 develop develop VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 3 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 4 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 5 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 6 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 7 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 8 consistent consistent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 9 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 11 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 13 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 14 described describe VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 15 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 16 section section NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 17 3553(a)(2 3553(a)(2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 18 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 20 Title Title NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 21 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 23 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 24 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 25 Code Code NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 27 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 28 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 29 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 30 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 590 31 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 2 3553(a)(2 3553(a)(2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 5 articulating articulate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 7 inter inter NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 8 alia alia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 10 need need VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 11 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 12 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 13 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 14 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 15 reflect reflect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 17 seriousness seriousness NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 20 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 22 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 23 promote promote VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 24 respect respect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 25 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 27 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 29 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 30 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 31 provide provide VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 32 just just JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 33 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 34 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 35 t t NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 36 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 37 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 38 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 39 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 591 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 1 154 154 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 3 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 4 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 5 v. v. CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 6 Gurgiolo Gurgiolo NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 8 894 894 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 9 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 10 56 56 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 12 57 57 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 14 3d 3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 15 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 592 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 593 1 1990 1990 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 593 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 593 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 594 1 155 155 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 594 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 594 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 594 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 594 5 1B1.1(a 1b1.1(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 594 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 594 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 595 1 156 156 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 595 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 595 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 595 4 Ch Ch NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 595 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 596 1 5 5 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 596 2 Pt Pt NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 596 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 1 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 2 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 3 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 4 Sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 5 Table table NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 6 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 597 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 1 157 157 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 5 2D1.1(c 2d1.1(c CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 8 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 9 Drug Drug NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 10 Quantity quantity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 11 Table table NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 12 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 598 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 1 158 158 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 3 generally generally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 5 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 6 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 7 2A1.1 2a1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 8 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 9 2A1.4 2a1.4 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 599 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 600 1 159 159 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 600 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 600 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 600 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 600 5 2F1.1(a 2f1.1(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 600 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 600 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 1 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 2 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 3 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 4 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 5 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 6 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 9 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 10 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 11 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 12 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 13 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 14 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 15 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 16 six six CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 601 17 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 602 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 602 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 602 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 602 4 2T1.1(a)(2 2t1.1(a)(2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 602 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 602 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 1 Unlike unlike IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 3 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 4 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 6 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 8 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 9 contain contain VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 10 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 11 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 12 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 13 table table NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 14 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 15 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 17 specific specific JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 18 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 19 characteristic characteristic NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 20 section section NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 22 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 23 see see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 24 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 25 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 26 2F1.1(b)(1 2f1.1(b)(1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 27 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 28 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 29 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 30 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 31 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 32 provide provide VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 33 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 34 alternative alternative JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 35 base base JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 36 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 37 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 38 depending depend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 39 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 41 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 43 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 44 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 603 45 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 5 2T1.1(a)(1 2t1.1(a)(1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 8 2T4.1 2t4.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 604 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 2 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 3 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 4 unimportant unimportant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 5 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 6 our -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 7 purposes purpose NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 8 inasmuch inasmuch VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 9 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 10 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 11 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 12 determines determine VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 14 ultimate ultimate JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 15 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 16 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 17 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 18 through through IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 19 adjustments adjustment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 21 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 22 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 24 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 25 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 27 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 28 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 30 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 31 through through IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 32 selection selection NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 35 initial initial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 36 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 37 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 38 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 39 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 40 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 41 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 42 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 43 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 44 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 45 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 605 46 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 606 1 160 160 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 606 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 606 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 606 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 606 5 2B1.1(a 2b1.1(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 606 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 606 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 607 1 161 161 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 607 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 607 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 607 4 Ch Ch NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 607 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 608 1 5 5 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 608 2 Pt Pt NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 608 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 1 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 2 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 5 5B1.1 5b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 7 authorizing authorizing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 9 generally generally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 11 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 13 probation probation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 14 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 15 low low JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 16 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 17 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 18 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 609 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 1 162 162 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 2 This this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 3 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 4 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 5 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 6 say say VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 7 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 9 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 10 views view VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 11 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 12 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 13 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 14 minor minor JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 15 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 16 per per IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 17 se se FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 610 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 611 1 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 611 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 611 3 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 611 4 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 611 5 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 611 6 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 3 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 5 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 6 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 7 2T1.1 2t1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 9 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 12 backg’d backg’d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 13 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 14 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 15 Tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 16 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 18 in in RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 21 themselves -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 23 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 24 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 25 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 26 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 27 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 28 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 612 29 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 1 Rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 4 point point NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 5 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 6 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 7 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 8 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 9 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 10 range range VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 11 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 12 relatively relatively RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 13 minor minor JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 14 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 16 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 18 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 19 $ $ $ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 20 500 500 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 21 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 22 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 24 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 25 extremely extremely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 26 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 27 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 28 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 29 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 31 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 32 $ $ $ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 33 500 500 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 34 million million CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 35 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 36 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 613 37 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 614 1 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 614 2 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 614 3 d d VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 614 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 2 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 3 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 4 A a NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 5 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 6 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 7 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 8 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 9 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 10 obviously obviously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 11 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 12 harmful harmful JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 13 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 15 treasury treasury NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 17 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 18 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 19 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 21 smaller small JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 22 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 23 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 24 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 25 similar similar JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 26 characteristics characteristic NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 28 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 29 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 615 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 1 Hence hence RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 3 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 4 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 5 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 6 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 7 inherently inherently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 8 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 9 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 10 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 12 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 13 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 14 well well RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 15 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 16 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 17 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 18 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 19 often often RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 20 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 21 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 616 22 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 2 contrast contrast NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 4 inasmuch inasmuch JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 5 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 6 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 7 aggravated aggravate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 8 assaults assault NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 9 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 10 inherently inherently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 11 dangerous dangerous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 13 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 14 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 15 inherently inherently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 16 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 17 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 18 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 20 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 21 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 22 why why WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 24 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 25 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 26 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 27 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 28 aggravated aggravated JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 29 assault assault NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 30 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 31 higher high JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 32 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 33 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 34 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 35 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 36 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 37 evasion evasion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 617 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 1 Compare compare VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 4 2A2.2(a 2a2.2(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 7 setting set VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 8 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 9 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 10 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 11 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 12 15 15 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 13 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 14 aggravated aggravate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 15 assault assault NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 16 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 18 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 19 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 20 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 21 2T1.1(a)(2 2T1.1(a)(2 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 22 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 23 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 24 setting set VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 25 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 26 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 27 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 28 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 29 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 30 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 31 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 32 evasion evasion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 33 resulting result VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 34 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 35 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 36 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 37 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 38 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 618 39 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 1 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 4 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 5 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 6 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 7 reflect reflect VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 8 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 9 aggravated aggravate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 10 assault assault NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 11 simpliciter simpliciter NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 13 viewed view VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 14 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 15 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 16 serious serious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 17 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 18 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 19 evasion evasion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 20 simpliciter simpliciter NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 619 21 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 620 1 446 446 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 620 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 620 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 621 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 621 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 621 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 621 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 621 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 622 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 622 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 622 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 2 anything anything NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 4 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 5 do do VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 6 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 7 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 8 nature nature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 11 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 12 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 14 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 15 practically practically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 16 everything everything NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 17 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 18 do do VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 19 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 21 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 23 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 24 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 25 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 26 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 28 i.e. i.e. FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 30 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 32 value value NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 35 property property NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 36 taken take VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 37 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 38 damaged damage VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 39 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 40 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 41 destroyed,”163 destroyed,”163 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 42 including include VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 44 value value NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 45 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 46 any any DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 47 money money NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 48 taken164 taken164 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 49 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 50 taxes taxis NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 51 evaded.165 evaded.165 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 52 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 53 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 54 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 55 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 56 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 57 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 58 own own JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 59 background background NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 60 commentary commentary NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 61 states state NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 62 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 63 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 64 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 65 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 66 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 67 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 68 G]uideline G]uideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 69 relies rely VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 70 most most RBS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 71 heavily heavily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 72 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 73 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 74 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 75 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 76 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 77 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 78 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 79 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 80 object object NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 81 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 82 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 83 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 84 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 85 ”166 ”166 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 86 Similarly similarly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 87 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 88 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 89 background background NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 90 commentary commentary NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 91 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 92 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 93 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 94 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 95 provides provide VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 96 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 97 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 98 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 99 primary primary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 100 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 101 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 102 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 103 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 104 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 105 G]uideline G]uideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 106 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 107 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 108 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 109 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 110 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 111 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 112 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 113 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 114 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 115 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 116 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 117 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 118 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 119 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 120 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 121 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 122 isolated isolated JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 123 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 124 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 125 opportunity opportunity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 126 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 127 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 128 sophisticated sophisticated JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 129 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 130 repeated repeat VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 131 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 132 ”167 ”167 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 133 Finally finally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 134 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 135 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 136 background background NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 137 commentary commentary NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 138 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 139 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 140 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 141 Guidelines Guidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 142 states state VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 143 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 144 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 145 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 146 t]he t]he NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 147 value value NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 148 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 149 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 150 property property NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 151 stolen steal VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 152 plays play VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 153 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 154 important important JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 155 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 156 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 157 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 158 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 159 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 160 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 161 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 162 other other JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 163 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 164 involving involve VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 165 stolen steal VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 166 property property NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 167 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 168 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 169 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 170 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 171 indicator indicator NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 172 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 173 both both PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 174 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 175 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 176 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 177 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 178 victim victim NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 179 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 180 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 181 gain gain NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 182 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 183 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 184 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 185 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 186 ”168 ”168 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 187 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 188 example example NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 189 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 190 depending depend VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 191 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 192 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 193 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 194 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 195 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 196 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 197 involved involve VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 198 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 199 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 200 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 201 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 202 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 203 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 204 pursuant pursuant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 205 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 206 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 623 207 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 2 1001 1001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 4 although although IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 5 he -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 6 initially initially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 7 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 8 receive receive VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 9 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 10 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 11 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 12 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 13 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 14 six six CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 15 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 16 zero zero CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 17 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 18 six six CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 19 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 20 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 21 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 23 theoretically theoretically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 24 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 25 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 26 his -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 27 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 28 increased increase VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 29 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 30 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 31 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 32 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 34 23 23 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 35 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 36 46 46 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 37 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 38 57 57 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 39 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 40 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 41 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 624 42 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 625 1 Pursuant pursuant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 625 2 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 625 3 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 625 4 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 2 1001 1001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 5 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 6 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 7 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 8 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 9 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 10 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 11 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 13 five five CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 14 years.169 years.169 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 15 Thus thus RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 17 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 18 upon upon IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 19 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 20 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 21 alone alone RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 23 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 24 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 25 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 26 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 27 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 28 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 29 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 30 potentially potentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 31 zero zero CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 32 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 33 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 35 up up IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 36 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 37 almost almost RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 38 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 39 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 40 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 41 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 43 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 626 44 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 1 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 3 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 4 appears appear VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 6 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 7 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 8 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 10 only only JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 11 sorts sort NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 13 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 14 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 15 can can MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 16 swing swing VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 17 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 18 potentially potentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 19 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 20 prison prison NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 21 time time NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 22 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 23 close close VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 24 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 25 100 100 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 26 % % NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 27 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 29 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 30 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 31 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 32 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 33 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 34 based base VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 35 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 36 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 37 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 38 determinations determination NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 39 alone alone RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 627 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 1 Clearly clearly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 4 expression expression NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 6 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 7 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 8 drives drive NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 9 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 11 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 12 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 13 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 14 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 15 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 16 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 17 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 18 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 19 accurate.170 accurate.170 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 20 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 21 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 23 our -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 24 analysis analysis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 26 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 28 therefore therefore RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 29 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 30 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 31 consider consider VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 32 whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 33 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 34 wags wag VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 36 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 37 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 38 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 39 substantive substantive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 40 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 41 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 628 42 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 1 163 163 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 4 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 6 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 7 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 8 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 10 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 12 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 13 n.2 n.2 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 629 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 1 164 164 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 5 2F1.1 2f1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 7 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 10 n.8 n.8 ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 630 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 631 1 165 165 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 631 2 See see JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 631 3 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 631 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 631 5 2T1.1(c)(1 2T1.1(c)(1 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 631 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 631 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 1 166 166 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 4 2T1.1 2t1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 6 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 9 backg’d backg’d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 632 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 1 167 167 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 4 2F1.1 2f1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 6 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 9 backg’d backg’d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 633 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 1 168 168 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 2 USSG USSG NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 3 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 4 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 6 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 9 backg’d backg’d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 634 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 1 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 2 ROGER ROGER NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 3 W. W. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 4 HAINES HAINES NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 6 JR JR NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 7 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 9 ET ET NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 635 10 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 1 AL AL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 4 FEDERAL FEDERAL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 5 SENTENCING sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 6 GUIDELINES GUIDELINES NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 7 HANDBOOK HANDBOOK NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 8 220 220 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 10 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 11 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 13 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 14 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 15 principal principal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 16 determinant determinant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 17 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 18 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 19 length length NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 20 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 21 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 23 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 25 embezzlement embezzlement NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 27 receipt receipt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 28 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 29 stolen steal VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 30 property property NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 31 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 32 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 33 property property NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 34 destruction destruction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 35 sentenced sentence VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 36 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 37 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 38 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 39 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 40 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 41 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 43 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 44 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 45 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 46 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 47 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 48 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 49 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 636 50 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 637 1 169 169 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 637 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 637 3 18 18 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 637 4 U.S.C. U.S.C. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 638 1 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 638 2 1001(a 1001(a CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 638 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 638 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 638 5 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 638 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 638 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 1 170 170 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 3 Bruce Bruce NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 4 Zucker Zucker NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 5 & & CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 6 Michelle Michelle NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 7 Carey Carey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 9 Capturing capture VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 11 Harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 12 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 13 Defining define VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 14 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 15 Tax Tax NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 16 Loss Loss NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 17 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 18 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 19 use use NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 20 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 21 Federal Federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 22 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 24 15 15 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 25 AKRON AKRON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 26 T T NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 27 AX ax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 639 28 J. j. NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 1 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 3 5 5 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 5 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 8 referring refer VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 9 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 11 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 12 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 13 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 14 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 15 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 16 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 17 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 18 driven drive VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 19 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 20 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 21 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 22 Frank Frank NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 640 23 O. O. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 1 Bowman Bowman NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 3 Coping cope VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 4 With with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 5 Loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 6 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 7 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 8 Reexamination reexamination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 10 Sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 11 Federal Federal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 12 Economic Economic NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 13 Crimes Crimes NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 14 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 16 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 17 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 18 51 51 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 19 VAND vand NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 641 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 642 1 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 642 2 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 642 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 1 461 461 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 3 464 464 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 5 1998 1998 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 7 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 8 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 9 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 10 primary primary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 11 determinant determinant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 13 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 14 length length NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 15 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 16 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 17 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 18 criminals criminal NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 19 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 20 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 21 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 23 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 24 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 25 ’ ' '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 26 resulting result VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 27 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 28 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 29 offender offender NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 30 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 31 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 32 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 33 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 34 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 643 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 4 447 447 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 5 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 6 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 7 Mark Mark NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 8 Knoll Knoll NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 9 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 10 Professor Professor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 11 Richard Richard NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 12 Singer Singer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 15 traditional traditional JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 16 methods method NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 17 used use VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 18 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 20 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 21 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 22 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 23 find find VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 24 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 25 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 26 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 27 were be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 28 relatively relatively RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 29 straightforward straightforward JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 644 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 1 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 2 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 4 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 5 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 6 dispute dispute NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 7 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 8 part part NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 11 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 12 scheme scheme NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 14 directly directly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 15 related relate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 16 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 18 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 19 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 20 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 22 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 24 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 25 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 26 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 27 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 28 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 29 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 30 1 1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 31 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 32 alleged allege VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 33 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 34 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 35 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 37 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 38 2 2 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 39 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 40 proved prove VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 41 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 42 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 43 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 44 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 45 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 46 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 47 3 3 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 48 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 49 proved prove VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 50 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 51 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 52 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 53 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 54 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 55 order order NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 56 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 57 sustain sustain VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 58 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 59 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 60 imposed impose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 61 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 62 ”171 ”171 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 63 Given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 64 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 65 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 66 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 67 inextricably inextricably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 68 intertwined intertwine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 69 both both DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 70 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 71 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 72 nature nature NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 73 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 74 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 75 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 76 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 77 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 78 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 79 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 80 provisions provision NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 81 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 82 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 83 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 84 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 85 there there EX work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 86 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 87 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 88 obvious obvious JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 89 reason reason NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 90 why why WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 91 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 92 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 93 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 94 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 95 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 96 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 97 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 98 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 99 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 100 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 101 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 645 102 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 1 According accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 2 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 3 Mr. Mr. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 4 Knoll Knoll NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 5 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 6 Professor Professor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 7 Singer Singer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 8 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 10 prior prior RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 11 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 12 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 13 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 15 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 16 Guidelines Guidelines NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 17 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 19 value value NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 20 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 21 considered consider VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 22 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 23 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 24 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 25 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 26 courts court NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 27 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 28 ”172 ”172 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 29 Indeed indeed RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 30 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 31 thirty thirty CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 32 years year NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 33 ago ago RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 36 Second Second NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 37 Circuit Circuit NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 38 held hold VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 39 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 40 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 41 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 42 a]lthough a]lthough NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 646 43 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 647 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 648 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 1 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 2 section section NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 4 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 5 Criminal Criminal NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 6 Code Code NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 7 here here RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 8 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 9 question question NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 10 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 11 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 12 make make VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 13 value value NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 14 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 15 excess excess NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 16 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 17 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 18 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 19 figure figure NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 20 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 21 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 22 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 24 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 25 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 26 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 27 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 28 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 29 going go VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 30 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 31 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 33 degree degree NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 34 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 35 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 36 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 37 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 38 assume assume VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 39 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 40 Sixth Sixth NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 41 Amendment Amendment NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 42 entitles entitle VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 43 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 44 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 45 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 46 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 47 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 48 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 49 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 50 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 52 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 53 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 54 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 55 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 56 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 57 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 58 judge judge NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 59 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 60 ”173 ”173 VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 61 At at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 62 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 63 very very RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 64 least least JJS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 65 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 66 recalling recall VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 67 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 68 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 69 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 70 dissent dissent NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 71 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 72 McMillan,174 McMillan,174 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 73 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 74 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 75 operates operate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 76 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 77 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 78 dramatically dramatically RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 79 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 80 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 81 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 82 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 83 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 84 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 85 high high JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 86 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 87 amount amount NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 88 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 89 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 90 treated treat VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 91 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 92 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 93 element element NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 94 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 95 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 96 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 649 97 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 1 Merely merely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 2 because because IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 3 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 4 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 5 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 6 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 7 increase increase VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 8 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 9 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 10 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 11 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 12 above above IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 13 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 14 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 15 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 16 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 17 maximum maximum JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 18 term term NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 20 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 22 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 24 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 25 consequence consequence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 26 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 27 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 28 tail tail NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 29 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 30 still still RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 31 wag wag VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 33 dog dog NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 34 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 35 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 37 statutory statutory JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 38 maximum maximum NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 39 table table NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 650 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 1 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 2 non non JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 3 - - JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 4 formalistic formalistic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 5 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 6 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 7 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 8 advocated advocate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 9 earlier early RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 10 still still RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 11 speaks speak VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 12 against against IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 13 allowing allow VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 14 large large JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 15 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 16 amounts amount NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 17 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 18 remain remain VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 19 mere mere JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 20 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 21 factors.175 factors.175 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 22 After after RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 23 all all RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 25 according accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 26 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 27 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 28 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 29 ’ ’ POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 30 majority majority NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 31 opinion opinion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 32 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 33 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 34 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 35 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 37 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 38 inquiry inquiry NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 39 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 40 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 41 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 42 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 43 form form NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 44 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 45 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 46 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 47 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 48 - - : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 49 does do VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 50 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 51 required require VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 52 finding finding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 53 expose expose VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 54 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 55 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 56 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 57 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 58 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 59 punishment punishment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 60 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 61 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 62 authorized authorize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 63 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 64 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 65 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 66 's 's POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 67 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 68 verdict?”176 verdict?”176 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 69 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 70 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 71 if if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 72 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 73 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 74 t]he t]he NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 75 judge judge NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 76 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 77 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 78 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 79 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 80 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 81 constrained constrain VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 82 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 83 its -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 84 outer outer JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 85 limits limit NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 86 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 87 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 88 facts fact NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 89 alleged allege VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 90 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 91 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 92 indictment indictment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 93 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 94 found find VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 95 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 96 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 97 jury,”177 jury,”177 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 98 then then RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 99 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 100 jury jury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 101 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 102 guilty guilty JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 103 verdict verdict NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 104 authorizes authorize VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 105 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 106 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 107 consistent consistent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 108 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 109 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 110 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 111 base base NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 112 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 113 level level NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 114 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 115 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 116 applicable applicable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 117 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 118 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 119 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 120 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 121 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 122 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 123 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 124 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 125 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 126 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 127 equivalent equivalent JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 128 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 129 zero zero CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 130 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 131 six six CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 132 months month NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 133 imprisonment imprisonment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 651 134 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 1 If if IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 3 according accord VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 4 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 5 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 6 Thomas,178 Thomas,178 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 7 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 8 literally literally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 9 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 10 171 171 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 11 Mark Mark NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 12 D. D. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 13 Knoll Knoll NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 14 & & CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 15 Richard Richard NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 16 G. G. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 17 Singer Singer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 19 Searching search VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 20 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 22 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 23 Tail Tail NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 25 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 26 Dog Dog NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 27 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 28 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 29 Finding find VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 30 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 31 Elements Elements NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 32 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 33 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 34 Crimes Crimes NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 35 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 36 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 37 Wake Wake NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 38 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 39 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 40 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 41 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 43 22 22 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 44 SEATTLE SEATTLE NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 45 U. U. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 46 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 47 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 652 48 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 653 1 1057 1057 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 653 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 653 3 1078 1078 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 653 4 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 653 5 1999 1999 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 653 6 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 653 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 654 1 172 172 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 654 2 See see VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 654 3 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 655 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 655 2 1079 1079 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 655 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 1 173 173 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 2 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 3 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 4 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 5 Kramer Kramer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 7 289 289 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 8 F.2d F.2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 9 909 909 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 11 921 921 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 13 2d 2d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 14 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 656 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 1 1961 1961 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 4 Friendly Friendly NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 6 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 7 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 657 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 1 174 174 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 3 McMillan McMillan NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 5 477 477 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 6 U.S. U.S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 7 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 8 96 96 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 10 Stevens Stevens NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 12 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 13 dissenting dissent VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 658 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 659 1 175 175 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 659 2 See see VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 659 3 supra supra FW work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 659 4 Part Part NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 659 5 II.B. II.B. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 1 176 176 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 4 120 120 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 5 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 6 Ct Ct NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 7 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 8 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 9 2365 2365 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 11 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 12 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 13 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 660 14 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 661 1 177 177 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 661 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 662 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 662 2 2359 2359 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 662 3 n.10 n.10 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 662 4 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 663 1 178 178 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 663 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 2 2369 2369 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 4 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 6 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 8 concurring concur VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 9 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 10 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 11 arguing argue VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 12 against against IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 13 validity validity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 15 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 16 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 17 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 664 18 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 665 1 448 448 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 665 2 GEO GEO NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 665 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 666 1 M M NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 666 2 ASON ASON NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 666 3 L. L. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 666 4 REV REV NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 666 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 667 1 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 667 2 VOL VOL NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 667 3 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 1 9:2 9:2 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 2 true true JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 3 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 4 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 5 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 6 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 7 includes include VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 8 every every DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 9 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 10 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 11 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 12 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 13 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 14 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 15 basis basis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 16 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 17 imposing impose VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 18 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 19 increasing increase VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 20 punishment,”179 punishment,”179 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 21 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 22 upshot upshot NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 23 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 25 course course NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 26 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 27 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 28 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 29 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 30 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 31 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 32 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 33 must must MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 34 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 35 determined determine VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 36 beyond beyond IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 37 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 38 reasonable reasonable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 39 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 40 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 41 which which WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 42 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 43 eviscerate eviscerate VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 44 real real JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 45 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 46 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 47 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 668 48 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 1 Concededly concededly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 3 such such PDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 4 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 5 literal literal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 6 reading reading NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 7 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 8 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 9 extreme extreme JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 10 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 11 likely likely JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 12 untenable untenable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 13 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 14 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 15 era era NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 16 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 17 determinate determinate NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 18 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 19 schemes scheme NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 669 20 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 3 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 4 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 5 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 6 what what WP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 7 we -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 8 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 9 argued argue VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 11 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 12 suggests suggest VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 13 strongly strongly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 14 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 15 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 16 days day NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 17 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 18 numbered number VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 19 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 20 least least JJS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 21 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 22 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 23 factors factor NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 24 like like IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 25 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 26 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 28 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 29 where where WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 30 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 31 essentially essentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 32 function function VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 33 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 34 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 36 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 37 crime crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 670 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 1 CONCLUSION CONCLUSION NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 2 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 3 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 4 New New NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 5 Jersey Jersey NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 6 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 7 irrevocably irrevocably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 8 altered alter VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 9 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 10 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 11 landscape landscape NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 12 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 13 both both CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 15 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 16 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 17 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 18 levels level NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 671 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 1 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 2 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 3 impact impact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 4 likely likely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 5 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 6 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 7 felt feel VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 8 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 9 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 10 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 11 legislatures legislature NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 12 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 13 terms term NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 14 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 15 how how WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 16 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 17 draft draft VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 18 new new JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 19 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 20 statutes statute NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 22 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 23 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 24 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 25 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 26 commissions commission NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 27 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 28 terms term NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 29 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 30 how how WRB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 31 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 32 draft draft VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 33 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 34 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 672 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 1 Justice Justice NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 2 O’Connor O’Connor NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 3 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 4 fear fear NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 6 Apprendi Apprendi NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 7 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 8 placed place VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 9 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 10 jeopardy jeopardy NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 11 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 12 determinate determinate VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 13 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 14 schemes scheme NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 15 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 16 including include VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 17 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 18 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 19 — — : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 20 remains remain VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 21 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 22 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 23 seen see VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 24 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 25 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 27 prognosis prognosis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 28 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 29 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 30 demise demise NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 31 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 32 unlikely unlikely JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 673 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 1 Whether whether IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 2 particular particular JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 3 Guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 4 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 5 sufficiently sufficiently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 6 immunized immunize VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 7 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 8 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 10 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 12 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 13 another another DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 14 matter matter NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 674 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 1 We -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 2 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 3 argued argue VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 4 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 5 given give VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 6 their -PRON- PRP$ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 7 near near JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 8 - - HYPH work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 9 exclusive exclusive JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 10 reliance reliance NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 11 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 12 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 13 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 14 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 15 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 17 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 20 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 21 Guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 22 are be VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 23 so so RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 24 vulnerable vulnerable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 25 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 26 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 28 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 29 they -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 30 likely likely RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 31 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 32 require require VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 33 substantial substantial JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 34 modification modification NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 675 35 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 1 For for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 3 time time NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 4 being being NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 6 federal federal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 7 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 8 state state NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 9 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 10 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 11 law law NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 12 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 13 continue continue VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 14 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 15 exhibit exhibit VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 16 symptoms symptom NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 17 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 18 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 676 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 1 Until until IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 2 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 3 Supreme Supreme NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 4 Court Court NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 5 articulates articulate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 6 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 7 principled principle VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 8 distinction distinction NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 9 between between IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 10 criminal criminal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 11 elements element NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 12 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 13 sentencing sentence VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 14 enhancements enhancement NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 16 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 17 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 18 continue continue VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 19 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 20 spread spread VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 21 unchecked unchecked JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 677 22 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 1 ADDENDUM ADDENDUM NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 2 On on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 3 April April NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 4 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 6 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 8 shortly shortly RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 9 before before IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 11 publication publication NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 13 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 14 Article Article NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 15 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 17 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 18 voted vote VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 19 unanimously unanimously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 20 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 21 adopt adopt VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 22 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 23 group group NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 24 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 25 proposed propose VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 26 amendments amendment NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 27 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 29 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 30 collectively collectively RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 31 known know VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 32 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 33 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 34 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 35 Economic Economic NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 36 Crime Crime NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 37 Package Package NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 39 ”180 ”180 '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 40 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 41 Package Package NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 42 fundamentally fundamentally RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 43 alters alter VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 44 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 45 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 46 offenders offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 47 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 48 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 49 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 50 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 51 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 52 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 53 inter inter NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 54 alia alia NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 55 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 56 consolidating consolidate VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 57 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 58 one one CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 59 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 60 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 61 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 62 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 63 theft,181 theft,181 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 64 fraud,182 fraud,182 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 65 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 66 property property NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 67 destruction,183 destruction,183 NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 68 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 69 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 70 179 179 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 678 71 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 1 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 2 2372 2372 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 4 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 6 J. J. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 7 concurring concur VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 9 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 10 emphasis emphasis NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 11 added add VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 12 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 679 13 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 1 180 180 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 3 UNITED UNITED NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 4 STATES STATES NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 5 SENTENCING SENTENCING NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 6 COMMISSION COMMISSION NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 8 FOURTH FOURTH NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 9 REVISED REVISED NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 10 P p NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 11 ROPOSED roposed NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 12 AMENDMENT amendment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 13 : : : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 14 ECONOMIC economic NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 15 CRIME crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 16 P p NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 17 ACKAGE ackage NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 18 § § NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 19 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 20 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 21 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 680 22 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 2 n.2(A)(i n.2(A)(i NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 6 4th 4th NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 7 rev rev NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 681 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 682 1 ed ed NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 682 2 . . NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 682 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 682 4 Apr. April NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 1 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 3 2001 2001 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 5 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 6 hereinafter hereinafter NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 7 ECONOMIC ECONOMIC NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 8 CRIME crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 9 P p NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 10 ACKAGE ackage NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 11 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 683 12 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 1 181 181 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 3 USSC ussc RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 5 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 7 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 684 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 1 182 182 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 2 See see VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 3 USSC ussc RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 5 2F1.1 2f1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 7 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 685 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 1 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 2 ] ] -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 3 APPRENDICITIS APPRENDICITIS NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 4 449 449 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 5 adopting adopt VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 6 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 7 new new JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 8 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 9 table.184 table.184 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 10 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 11 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 12 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 13 case case NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 14 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 15 respect respect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 16 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 17 each each DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 18 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 19 these these DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 20 individual individual JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 21 Guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 22 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 23 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 24 loss”185 loss”185 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 25 remains remain VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 26 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 27 principal principal JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 28 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 29 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 30 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 31 determining determine VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 32 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 33 sentence sentence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 34 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 36 new new JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 37 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 38 consolidated consolidate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 39 Guideline Guideline NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 686 40 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 1 Loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 2 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 3 however however RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 5 has have VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 6 taken take VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 7 on on RP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 8 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 9 altogether altogether RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 10 new new JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 11 meaning meaning NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 687 12 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 1 Whereas whereas IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 2 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 3 previously previously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 4 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 5 thought think VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 6 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 7 include include VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 8 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 10 direct direct JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 11 damages”186 damages”186 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 12 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 13 exclude exclude VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 14 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 15 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 16 damages,”187 damages,”187 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 17 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 18 now now RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 19 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 20 defined define VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 21 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 22 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 23 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 24 reasonably reasonably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 25 foreseeable foreseeable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 26 pecuniary pecuniary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 27 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 28 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 29 resulted result VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 30 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 31 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 32 offense,”188 offense,”188 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 33 with with IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 34 pecuniary pecuniary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 35 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 36 defined define VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 37 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 38 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 39 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 40 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 41 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 42 monetary monetary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 43 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 44 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 45 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 46 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 47 readily readily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 48 measurable measurable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 49 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 50 money money NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 51 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 52 ”189 ”189 NFP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 53 Reasonably reasonably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 54 foreseeable foreseeable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 55 pecuniary pecuniary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 56 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 57 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 58 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 59 turn turn NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 60 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 61 simply simply RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 62 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 63 means mean VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 64 pecuniary pecuniary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 65 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 66 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 67 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 68 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 69 knew know VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 70 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 71 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 72 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 73 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 74 circumstances circumstance NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 75 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 76 reasonably reasonably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 77 should should MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 78 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 79 known know VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 80 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 81 was be VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 82 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 83 potential potential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 84 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 85 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 86 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 87 offense offense NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 88 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 89 ”190 ”190 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 90 Consequently consequently RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 91 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 92 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 93 reasonably reasonably RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 94 foreseeable foreseeable JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 95 pecuniary pecuniary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 96 harm harm NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 97 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 98 include include VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 99 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 100 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 101 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 102 otherwise otherwise RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 103 indirect indirect JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 104 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 105 damages,191 damages,191 NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 106 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 107 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 108 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 109 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 110 now now RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 111 encompasses encompass VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 112 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 113 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 114 range range NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 115 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 116 pecuniary pecuniary JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 117 harms harm NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 688 118 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 1 As as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 2 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 3 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 4 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 5 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 7 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 8 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 9 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 10 factor factor NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 12 will will MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 13 play play VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 14 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 15 even even RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 16 greater great JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 17 role role NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 18 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 19 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 20 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 21 have have VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 22 more more JJR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 24 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 25 effect effect NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 26 on on IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 27 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 29 determination determination NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 31 sentences sentence NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 32 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 33 offenders offender NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 34 convicted convict VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 35 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 36 economic economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 37 crimes crime NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 689 38 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 1 In in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 2 light light NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 3 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 4 this this DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 5 modification modification NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 7 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 8 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 9 now now RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 10 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 11 even even RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 12 more more RBR work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 13 susceptible susceptible JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 14 to to IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 15 Apprendicitis Apprendicitis NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 16 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 17 ever ever RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 18 before before RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 690 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 1 183 183 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 3 USSC ussc RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 4 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 5 2B1.3 2b1.3 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 7 2000 2000 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 8 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 691 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 1 184 184 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 3 ECONOMIC economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 4 CRIME crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 5 P p NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 6 ACKAGE ackage NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 8 supra supra NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 9 note note NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 10 180 180 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 12 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 13 2B1.1(b)(1 2b1.1(b)(1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 14 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 692 15 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 1 185 185 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 3 supra supra NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 4 notes note VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 5 163 163 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 6 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 7 165 165 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 8 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 9 defining define VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 10 previous previous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 11 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 13 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 14 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 15 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 16 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 17 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 18 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 19 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 20 tax tax NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 21 offenses offense NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 22 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 693 23 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 1 186 186 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 2 See See NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 3 Fred Fred NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 4 S. S. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 5 Tryles Tryles NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 7 A a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 8 Critique Critique NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 9 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 11 Operation Operation NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 13 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 14 Theft Theft NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 15 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 16 Fraud Fraud NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 17 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 18 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 20 Perspective Perspective NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 21 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 22 One One NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 23 Probation Probation NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 24 Officer Officer NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 26 10 10 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 27 FED FED NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 694 28 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 695 1 SENT send VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 695 2 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 1 R. R. NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 2 131 131 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 4 1997 1997 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 5 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 6 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 7 stating state VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 8 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 9 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 10 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 11 t]he t]he CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 12 current current JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 13 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 14 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 15 fraud fraud NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 16 guidelines guideline NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 17 limit limit VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 18 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 19 functioning functioning NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 20 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 21 relevant relevant JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 22 conduct conduct NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 23 by by IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 24 counting count VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 25 only only RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 26 direct direct JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 27 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 28 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 29 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 696 30 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 1 187 187 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 4 e.g. e.g. RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 5 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 6 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 7 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 8 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 9 Thomas Thomas NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 10 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 11 62 62 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 12 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 13 1332 1332 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 15 1346 1346 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 16 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 17 11th 11th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 18 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 697 19 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 1 1995 1995 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 4 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 5 The the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 6 fact fact NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 7 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 8 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 9 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 10 deliberately deliberately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 11 allowed allow VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 12 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 13 increase increase NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 14 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 15 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 16 damages damage NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 17 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 18 some some DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 19 but but CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 20 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 21 all all DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 22 types type NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 23 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 24 frauds fraud NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 25 indicates indicate VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 26 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 27 ‘ ' `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 28 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 29 absence absence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 30 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 31 an an DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 32 increase increase NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 698 33 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 699 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 700 1 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 1 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 2 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 3 result result NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 4 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 5 design design NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 6 rather rather RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 7 than than IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 8 inadvertence inadvertence NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 9 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 10 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 11 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 12 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 13 citation citation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 14 omitted omit VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 15 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 16 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 17 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 18 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 19 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 20 Newman Newman NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 21 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 22 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 23 F.3d F.3d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 24 623 623 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 25 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 26 630 630 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 27 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 28 9th 9th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 29 Cir.1993 Cir.1993 NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 30 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 31 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 32 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 33 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 34 i]f i]f NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 35 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 36 Sentencing Sentencing NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 37 Commission Commission NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 38 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 39 intended intend VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 40 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 41 include include VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 42 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 43 losses loss NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 44 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 45 it -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 46 could could MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 47 have have VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 48 included include VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 49 them -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 50 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 51 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 52 definition definition NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 53 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 54 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 55 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 56 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 57 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 58 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 59 see see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 60 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 61 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 62 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 63 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 64 Marlatt Marlatt NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 65 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 66 24 24 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 67 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 68 1005 1005 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 69 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 70 1007 1007 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 71 - - SYM work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 72 1008 1008 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 73 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 74 7th 7th JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 75 Cir Cir NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 701 76 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 1 1994 1994 LS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 4 suggesting suggest VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 5 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 6 exclusion exclusion NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 7 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 8 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 9 damages damage NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 10 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 11 loss loss NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 12 calculation calculation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 13 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 14 is be VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 15 no no DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 16 doubt doubt NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 17 to to TO work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 18 prevent prevent VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 19 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 20 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 21 hearing hearing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 22 from from IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 23 turning turn VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 24 into into IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 25 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 26 tort tort NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 27 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 28 contract contract NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 29 suit suit NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 30 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 31 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 32 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 33 United United NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 34 States States NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 35 v. v. IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 36 Wilson Wilson NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 37 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 38 993 993 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 39 F.2d F.2d NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 40 214 214 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 41 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 42 217 217 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 43 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 44 11th 11th NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 45 Cir cir NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 702 46 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 1 1993 1993 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 2 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 3 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 4 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 5 [ [ -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 6 W]e W]e NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 7 note note VBP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 8 that that IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 9 avoiding avoid VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 10 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 11 calculation calculation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 12 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 13 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 14 injury injury NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 15 relieves relieve VBZ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 16 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 17 district district NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 18 court court NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 19 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 20 a a DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 21 potentially potentially RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 22 onerous onerous JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 23 factfinding factfinding NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 24 burde burde NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 25 n n NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 26 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 27 may may MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 28 also also RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 29 promote promote VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 30 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 31 objective objective NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 32 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 33 uniformity uniformity NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 34 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 35 sentencing sentencing NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 36 outcomes outcome NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 37 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 38 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 39 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 40 ; ; : work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 41 Newman Newman NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 42 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 43 6 6 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 44 F.3d f.3d NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 45 at at IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 46 630 630 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 47 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 48 holding hold VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 49 that that DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 50 calculation calculation NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 51 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 52 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 53 damages damage NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 54 for for IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 55 arson arson NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 56 or or CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 57 theft theft NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 58 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 59 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 60 be be VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 61 too too RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 62 complex complex JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 63 and and CC work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 64 would would MD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 65 not not RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 66 necessarily necessarily RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 67 reflect reflect VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 68 the the DT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 69 defendant defendant NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 70 ’s ’s POS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 71 culpability culpability NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 72 accurately accurately RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 73 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 74 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 703 75 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 1 188 188 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 2 See see VB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 3 ECONOMIC economic JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 4 CRIME crime NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 5 P p NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 6 ACKAGE ackage NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 7 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 8 supra supra NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 9 note note NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 10 180 180 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 11 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 12 § § CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 13 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 14 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 15 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 704 16 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 705 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 705 2 n.2(A)(i n.2(A)(i NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 705 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 705 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 705 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 1 189 189 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 4 § § -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 5 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 7 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 706 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 707 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 707 2 n.2(A)(iii n.2(A)(iii NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 707 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 707 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 707 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 1 190 190 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 2 Id. Idaho NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 3 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 4 § § -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 5 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 7 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 708 8 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 709 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 709 2 n.2(A)(iv n.2(A)(iv NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 709 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 709 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 709 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 1 191 191 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 2 See see NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 3 i -PRON- PRP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 4 d d NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 5 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 6 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 7 § § ADD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 8 2B1.1 2b1.1 CD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 9 , , , work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 10 comment comment NN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 710 11 . . . work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 1 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 2 n.2(A)(v n.2(A)(v NNP work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 3 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 4 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 5 ( ( -LRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 6 including include VBG work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 7 in in IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 8 certain certain JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 9 types type NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 10 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 11 cases case NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 12 losses loss NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 13 that that WDT work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 14 previously previously RB work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 15 had have VBD work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 16 been be VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 17 denominated denominate VBN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 18 as as IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 19 “ " `` work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 20 consequential consequential JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 21 damages damage NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 22 ” " '' work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 23 under under IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 24 prior prior JJ work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 25 versions version NNS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 26 of of IN work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 27 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 28 ) ) -RRB- work_yvspegftdvchbfvlpysxj46cua 711 29 . . .