PowerPoint Presentation Tri-Agency Research Data Management Policy Development Research Data Management Summit for Canadian Colleges, Institutes and Polytechnics Centennial College December 7, 2018 Presented by Kevin Fitzgibbons Executive Director, Corporate Planning and Policy, NSERC PRESENTATION OUTLINE 2 • Rationale for Research Data Management (RDM) • Tri-Agency RDM Policy Development • Stakeholder Engagement and Consultation WHAT ARE RESEARCH DATA? 3 Research data are contents that are used as primary sources to support research, scholarship, artistic activity or research-creation, and that are used as evidence in the research process and commonly accepted in the research community as necessary to validate research findings and results. WHY DATA MANAGEMENT? 4 Research Excellence Research Dissemination Research Impact Research Best Practice RESEARCH EXCELLENCE 5 Project Management Support Reproducibility Avoid Duplication Journal Guidelines RESEARCH DISSEMINATION 6 Data Sharing Citation Interdisciplinarity RESEARCH IMPACT 7 Within Science Social Impact Policy Impact RESEARCH BEST PRACTICE 8 Transparency Trust Ethics Responsible Use of Public Funds INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENTS 9 Research Funders • National Science Foundation • National Endowment for the Humanities – ODH • National Institutes of Health • UK Research Councils • European Commission • National Natural Science Foundation of China Foundations and Charities • American Heart Association • Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation • Alfred P Sloan Foundation • Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation • Open Society Foundations • Royal Society • Wellcome Trust • Cancer Research UK Research Institutions 10 CAGS Libraries IT Ethics Grad Studies Researchers RSO Courtesy of Chuck Humphrey, former Director, Portage GOVERNMENT OF CANADA DIRECTIVE ON OPEN GOVERNMENT 11 TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DEVELOPMENT BACKGROUND 12 2013 Capitalizing on Big Data: Toward a Policy Framework for Advancing Digital Scholarship in Canada 2016 Tri-Agency Statement of Principles on Digital Data Management 2017-2018 Draft Tri-Agency Research Data Management Policy INTENDED IMPACT OF A TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 13 The agencies aim to contribute to a future research culture that sees: • strong data management as an accepted signifier of research excellence across disciplines, and a regular feature in the conduct of research; • more Canadian datasets cited, and valued as a product of research in tenure, promotion and peer review processes; • Canadian researchers equipped and ready to engage in international research collaboration where data management requirements are becoming the norm; • Canadian research institutions ready to support the management of the data their researchers produce; and • increased ability for research data to be archived, found and responsibly reused, to fuel new discovery and innovation. DRAFT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 14 • Consultation feedback will inform final policy • Proposed policy includes 3 possible requirements: 1. Institutional Strategy (institutions) 2. Data Management Plans (researchers) 3. Data Deposit (researchers) • Implementation: Phased, incremental DRAFT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 15 1. Institutional Strategy • Each institution administering tri-agency funds could be required to create an institutional research data management strategy. The strategy could outline how the institution will provide its researchers with an environment that enables and supports world class research data management practices. • The strategy could be posted and made publicly available on the institution’s website, with contact information to direct inquiries about the strategy. DRAFT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 16 Why Require Institutional Strategies? • Recognizes the role of institutions in providing supports for data management; • Provides an opportunity for institutions to think through where gaps exist, and how to address them from a campus-wide perspective; • Could aid institutions in developing an approach that works for them, while encouraging alignment and collaboration with other institutions; • Could provide information to agencies about data management capacity; and • Serves as foundation for the potential requirements that follow. Example Support Portage Institutional Strategy Template DRAFT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 17 2. Data Management Plans • Grant recipients could be required to create data management plans (DMPs) for research projects supported wholly or in part by tri-agency funds. Grant recipients could submit these plans to their institution’s research office as a condition of the release of grant funds. • For specific funding opportunities, the agencies could require DMPs to be submitted to the appropriate agency at time of application; in these cases, they may be considered in the adjudication process. DRAFT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 18 Why Require Data Management Plans? • DMPs are an emerging international best practice; • DMPs are an excellent way for researchers to identify opportunities and challenges in managing their data, well before those opportunities and challenges emerge; • Researchers claim that the process of developing a DMP helps them to improve their research plans and methodologies; • DMPs could serve the responsible conduct of research and the research ethics approval process; and • DMPs help identify and mitigate issues related to ownership of data, potential for data sharing, etc. Example Support Portage DMP Assistant DRAFT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 19 3. Data Deposit • For all research data and code that support journal publications, pre-prints and other research outputs that arise from agency-supported research, grant recipients could be required to deposit these data and code in an appropriate public repository or other platform that will ensure safe storage, preservation, curation, and (if applicable) access to the data. DRAFT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY 20 Why Require Data Deposit? • Methods, expectations and online security will change – storing in a secure location provides better chance for data to be safe and of use to the creator in the future; • Data deposit helps ensure proper use of public funds; • Facilitates reproducibility of results; and • Facilitates data sharing. Example Support CARL-Portage-Compute Canada’s Federated Research Data Repository (FRDR) COMMUNITY FEEDBACK IS KEY 21 Research community feedback is essential to inform the final design of the policy and the mode of its implementation. The agencies consider the draft RDM policy as a proposal through which to advance discussion with stakeholders in the research community, with a tri-agency RDM policy as the desired end product. STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT 22 • Regional stakeholder meetings • Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto, Montréal and Halifax; • revealed excitement and optimism about the potential for data management to contribute to research excellence; and • also demonstrated concern over challenges, such as researcher awareness, capacity and funding. • Online consultation on draft policy June-September 2018 • Continued discussions with broad array of stakeholders • Researchers, scholarly and scientific associations, data management advocacy and support organizations, funding agency colleagues around the globe. Online consultation June - September 2018 • approx. 150 responses, mostly from colleges & universities • areas of feedback: • strength of policy • ethics and privacy • implications of the policy • capacity • supports for education • feedback will inform further development of the policy over winter 2018-19 ONLINE CONSULTATION FEEDBACK THANK YOU! 24 Questions or feedback? Contact: NSERC: ResearchData-Donneesderecherche@nserc-crsng.gc.ca SSHRC: ResearchData-Donneesderecherche@sshrc-crsh.gc.ca CIHR: ResearchData-Donneesderecherche@cihr-irsc.gc.ca Slide Number 1 PRESENTATION OUTLINE WHAT ARE RESEARCH DATA? WHY DATA MANAGEMENT? RESEARCH EXCELLENCE RESEARCH DISSEMINATION RESEARCH IMPACT RESEARCH BEST PRACTICE INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENTS Slide Number 10 GOVERNMENT OF CANADA�DIRECTIVE ON OPEN GOVERNMENT TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DEVELOPMENT �BACKGROUND �INTENDED IMPACT OF A�TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY� DRAFT �TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DRAFT �TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DRAFT �TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DRAFT �TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DRAFT �TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DRAFT �TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY DRAFT �TRI-AGENCY RDM POLICY COMMUNITY FEEDBACK IS KEY STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT ONLINE CONSULTATION FEEDBACK THANK YOU!