id sid tid token lemma pos www-bis-org-8025 1 1 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 1 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 1 3 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 4 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 6 " " `` www-bis-org-8025 1 7 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 1 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 1 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 1 11 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 1 12 " " '' www-bis-org-8025 1 13 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 1 14 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 15 BIS bis VBP www-bis-org-8025 1 16 Working work VBG www-bis-org-8025 1 17 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 1 18 No no DT www-bis-org-8025 1 19 765 765 CD www-bis-org-8025 1 20 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 1 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 1 22 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 23 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 25 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 1 26 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 1 27 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 1 28 of- of- CD www-bis-org-8025 1 29 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 1 30 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 1 31 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 1 32 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 33 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 1 34 Raphael Raphael NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 35 Auer Auer NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 36 Monetary Monetary NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 37 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 1 38 Economic Economic NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 39 Department Department NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 40 January January NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 41 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 1 42 JEL JEL NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 43 classification classification NN www-bis-org-8025 1 44 : : : www-bis-org-8025 1 45 D40 D40 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 46 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 47 D20 D20 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 48 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 49 E42 E42 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 50 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 51 E51 E51 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 52 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 53 F31 F31 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 54 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 55 G12 G12 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 56 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 57 G28 G28 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 58 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 59 G32 G32 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 60 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 61 G38 G38 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 62 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 63 L10 L10 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 64 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 65 L50 L50 NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 66 Keywords Keywords NNPS www-bis-org-8025 1 67 : : : www-bis-org-8025 1 68 Cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 69 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 70 cryptoassets cryptoasset NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 71 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 72 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 1 73 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 74 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 75 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 76 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 77 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 1 78 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 1 79 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 80 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 1 81 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 1 82 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 83 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 1 84 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 1 85 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 86 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 1 87 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 1 88 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 89 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 1 90 ledger ledger NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 91 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 1 92 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 93 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 1 94 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 95 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 1 96 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 97 ethereum ethereum NN www-bis-org-8025 1 98 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 99 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 1 100 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 101 digitalisation digitalisation NN www-bis-org-8025 1 102 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 103 finance finance NN www-bis-org-8025 1 104 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 105 history history NN www-bis-org-8025 1 106 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 107 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 1 108 BIS BIS NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 109 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 110 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 1 111 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 1 112 written write VBN www-bis-org-8025 1 113 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 1 114 members member NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 115 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 116 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 1 117 Monetary Monetary NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 118 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 1 119 Economic Economic NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 120 Department Department NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 121 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 1 122 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 1 123 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 124 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 1 125 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 126 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 127 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 128 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 1 129 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 1 130 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 1 131 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 1 132 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 1 133 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 1 134 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 1 135 economists economist NNS www-bis-org-8025 1 136 , , , www-bis-org-8025 1 137 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 1 138 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 1 139 published publish VBN www-bis-org-8025 1 140 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 1 141 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 1 142 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 1 143 . . . www-bis-org-8025 2 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 2 2 papers paper NNS www-bis-org-8025 2 3 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 2 4 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 2 5 subjects subject NNS www-bis-org-8025 2 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 2 7 topical topical JJ www-bis-org-8025 2 8 interest interest NN www-bis-org-8025 2 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 2 10 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 2 11 technical technical JJ www-bis-org-8025 2 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 2 13 character character NN www-bis-org-8025 2 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 3 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 3 2 views view NNS www-bis-org-8025 3 3 expressed express VBN www-bis-org-8025 3 4 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 3 5 them -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 3 6 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 3 7 those those DT www-bis-org-8025 3 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 3 9 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 3 10 authors author NNS www-bis-org-8025 3 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 3 12 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 3 13 necessarily necessarily RB www-bis-org-8025 3 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 3 15 views view NNS www-bis-org-8025 3 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 3 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 3 18 BIS BIS NNP www-bis-org-8025 3 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 4 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 4 2 publication publication NN www-bis-org-8025 4 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 4 4 available available JJ www-bis-org-8025 4 5 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 4 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 4 7 BIS BIS NNP www-bis-org-8025 4 8 website website NN www-bis-org-8025 4 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 4 10 www.bis.org www.bis.org NNP www-bis-org-8025 4 11 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 4 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 5 1 © © NNP www-bis-org-8025 5 2 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 5 3 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 5 4 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 5 5 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 5 6 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 5 7 . . . www-bis-org-8025 6 1 All all DT www-bis-org-8025 6 2 rights right NNS www-bis-org-8025 6 3 reserved reserve VBD www-bis-org-8025 6 4 . . . www-bis-org-8025 7 1 Brief brief JJ www-bis-org-8025 7 2 excerpts excerpt NNS www-bis-org-8025 7 3 may may MD www-bis-org-8025 7 4 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 7 5 reproduced reproduce VBN www-bis-org-8025 7 6 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 7 7 translated translate VBN www-bis-org-8025 7 8 provided provide VBD www-bis-org-8025 7 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 7 10 source source NN www-bis-org-8025 7 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 7 12 stated state VBN www-bis-org-8025 7 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 8 1 ISSN ISSN NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 2 1020 1020 CD www-bis-org-8025 8 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 8 4 0959 0959 CD www-bis-org-8025 8 5 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 8 6 print print NN www-bis-org-8025 8 7 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 8 8 ISSN ISSN NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 9 1682 1682 CD www-bis-org-8025 8 10 - - SYM www-bis-org-8025 8 11 7678 7678 CD www-bis-org-8025 8 12 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 8 13 online online NN www-bis-org-8025 8 14 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 8 15 http://www.bis.org/ http://www.bis.org/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 16 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 17 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 8 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 8 19 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 20 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 8 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 8 22 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 8 23 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 8 24 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 8 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 8 26 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 8 27 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 8 28 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 8 29 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 8 30 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 8 31 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 8 32 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 8 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 8 34 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 35 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 8 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 8 37 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 8 38 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 8 39 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 8 40 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 8 41 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 8 42 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 8 43 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 8 44 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 8 45 cryptocurrencies1 cryptocurrencies1 JJ www-bis-org-8025 8 46 Raphael Raphael NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 47 Auer Auer NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 48 Abstract Abstract NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 49 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 8 50 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 8 51 discusses discuss VBZ www-bis-org-8025 8 52 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 8 53 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 8 54 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 8 55 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 8 56 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 8 57 achieves achieve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 8 58 data data NN www-bis-org-8025 8 59 immutability immutability NN www-bis-org-8025 8 60 , , , www-bis-org-8025 8 61 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 8 62 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 8 63 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 8 64 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 8 65 , , , www-bis-org-8025 8 66 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 8 67 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 8 68 computations computation NNS www-bis-org-8025 8 69 , , , www-bis-org-8025 8 70 ie ie FW www-bis-org-8025 8 71 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 8 72 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 8 73 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 8 74 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 8 75 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 8 76 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 8 77 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 8 78 . . . www-bis-org-8025 9 1 Further further RB www-bis-org-8025 9 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 9 3 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 9 4 explores explore VBZ www-bis-org-8025 9 5 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 9 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 9 7 future future NN www-bis-org-8025 9 8 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 9 9 hold hold VB www-bis-org-8025 9 10 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 9 11 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 9 12 modelled model VBN www-bis-org-8025 9 13 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 9 14 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 9 15 type type NN www-bis-org-8025 9 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 9 17 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 9 18 algorithm algorithm NN www-bis-org-8025 9 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 10 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 10 2 conclusions conclusion NNS www-bis-org-8025 10 3 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 10 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 10 5 first first RB www-bis-org-8025 10 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 10 7 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 10 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 10 9 counterfeiting counterfeiting NN www-bis-org-8025 10 10 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 10 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 10 12 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 10 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 10 14 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 10 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 10 16 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 10 17 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 10 18 inherently inherently RB www-bis-org-8025 10 19 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 10 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 10 21 making make VBG www-bis-org-8025 10 22 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 10 23 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 10 24 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 10 25 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 10 26 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 10 27 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 10 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 10 29 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 10 30 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 10 31 extremely extremely RB www-bis-org-8025 10 32 expensive expensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 10 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 11 1 Second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 11 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 11 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 11 4 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 11 5 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 11 6 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 11 7 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 11 8 generate generate VB www-bis-org-8025 11 9 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 11 10 adequate adequate JJ www-bis-org-8025 11 11 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 11 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 11 13 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 11 14 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 11 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 11 16 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 11 17 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 11 18 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 11 19 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 11 20 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 11 21 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 11 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 11 23 ride ride NN www-bis-org-8025 11 24 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 11 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 11 26 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 11 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 11 28 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 11 29 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 11 30 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 11 31 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 11 32 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 11 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 11 34 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 11 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 11 36 subsequent subsequent JJ www-bis-org-8025 11 37 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 11 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 12 1 Instead instead RB www-bis-org-8025 12 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 12 3 newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 12 4 minted mint VBN www-bis-org-8025 12 5 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 12 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 12 7 known know VBN www-bis-org-8025 12 8 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 12 9 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 12 10 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 12 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 12 12 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 12 13 made make VBN www-bis-org-8025 12 14 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 12 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 12 16 bulk bulk NN www-bis-org-8025 12 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 12 18 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 12 19 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 12 20 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 12 21 date date NN www-bis-org-8025 12 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 13 1 Looking look VBG www-bis-org-8025 13 2 ahead ahead RB www-bis-org-8025 13 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 13 4 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 13 5 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 13 6 limitations limitation NNS www-bis-org-8025 13 7 imply imply VBP www-bis-org-8025 13 8 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 13 9 liquidity liquidity NN www-bis-org-8025 13 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 13 11 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 13 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 13 13 fall fall VB www-bis-org-8025 13 14 dramatically dramatically RB www-bis-org-8025 13 15 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 13 16 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 13 17 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 13 18 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 13 19 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 13 20 phased phase VBN www-bis-org-8025 13 21 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 13 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 14 1 Simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 14 2 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 14 3 suggest suggest VBP www-bis-org-8025 14 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 14 5 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 14 6 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 14 7 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 14 8 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 14 9 zero zero CD www-bis-org-8025 14 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 14 11 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 14 12 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 14 13 take take VB www-bis-org-8025 14 14 months month NNS www-bis-org-8025 14 15 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 14 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 14 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 14 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 14 19 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 14 20 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 14 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 14 22 unless unless IN www-bis-org-8025 14 23 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 14 24 technologies technology NNS www-bis-org-8025 14 25 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 14 26 deployed deploy VBN www-bis-org-8025 14 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 14 28 speed speed VB www-bis-org-8025 14 29 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 14 30 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 14 31 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 14 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 15 1 Second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 15 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 15 3 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 15 4 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 15 5 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 15 6 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 15 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 15 8 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 15 9 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 15 10 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 15 11 help help VB www-bis-org-8025 15 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 15 13 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 15 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 15 15 only only JJ www-bis-org-8025 15 16 fundamental fundamental JJ www-bis-org-8025 15 17 remedy remedy NN www-bis-org-8025 15 18 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 15 19 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 15 20 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 15 21 depart depart VB www-bis-org-8025 15 22 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 15 23 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 15 24 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 15 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 15 26 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 15 27 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 15 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 15 29 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 15 30 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 15 31 probably probably RB www-bis-org-8025 15 32 require require VB www-bis-org-8025 15 33 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 15 34 form form NN www-bis-org-8025 15 35 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 15 36 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 15 37 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 15 38 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 15 39 institutionalisation institutionalisation NN www-bis-org-8025 15 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 16 1 JEL JEL NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 2 classification classification NN www-bis-org-8025 16 3 : : : www-bis-org-8025 16 4 D40 D40 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 6 D20 D20 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 8 E42 E42 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 10 E51 E51 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 12 F31 F31 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 14 G12 G12 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 16 G28 G28 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 18 G32 G32 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 20 G38 G38 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 22 L10 L10 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 16 24 L50 L50 NNP www-bis-org-8025 16 25 . . . www-bis-org-8025 17 1 Keywords keyword NNS www-bis-org-8025 17 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 17 3 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 17 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 5 crypto crypto NN www-bis-org-8025 17 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 17 7 assets asset NNS www-bis-org-8025 17 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 9 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 17 10 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 17 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 12 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 17 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 14 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 17 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 17 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 17 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 17 18 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 17 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 20 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 17 21 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 17 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 17 23 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 17 24 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 17 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 26 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 17 27 ledger ledger NNP www-bis-org-8025 17 28 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 17 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 30 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 17 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 32 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 17 33 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 34 ethereum ethereum NN www-bis-org-8025 17 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 36 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 17 37 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 38 digitalisation digitalisation NN www-bis-org-8025 17 39 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 40 finance finance NN www-bis-org-8025 17 41 , , , www-bis-org-8025 17 42 history history NN www-bis-org-8025 17 43 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 17 44 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 17 45 . . . www-bis-org-8025 18 1 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 18 2 Email email NN www-bis-org-8025 18 3 : : : www-bis-org-8025 18 4 Raphael.auer@bis.org Raphael.auer@bis.org NNP www-bis-org-8025 18 5 . . . www-bis-org-8025 19 1 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 19 2 earlier early JJR www-bis-org-8025 19 3 version version NN www-bis-org-8025 19 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 19 5 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 19 6 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 19 7 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 19 8 titled title VBN www-bis-org-8025 19 9 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 19 10 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 19 11 mechanics mechanic NNS www-bis-org-8025 19 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 19 13 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 19 14 trust trust NN www-bis-org-8025 19 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 19 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 19 17 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 19 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 19 19 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 19 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 19 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 20 1 I -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 20 2 thank thank VBP www-bis-org-8025 20 3 David David NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 4 Archer Archer NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 20 6 Morten Morten NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 7 Bech Bech NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 20 9 Stijn Stijn NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 10 Claessens Claessens NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 20 12 Jon Jon NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 13 Frost Frost NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 20 15 Giulio Giulio NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 16 Cornelli Cornelli NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 20 18 Henry Henry NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 19 Holden Holden NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 20 21 Krista Krista NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 22 Hughes Hughes NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 20 24 Paul Paul NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 25 Wong Wong NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 26 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 20 27 comments comment NNS www-bis-org-8025 20 28 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 20 29 seminar seminar NN www-bis-org-8025 20 30 participants participant NNS www-bis-org-8025 20 31 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 20 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 20 33 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 34 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 20 35 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 36 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 37 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 20 38 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 20 39 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 20 40 Annual Annual NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 41 Meeting Meeting NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 20 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 20 44 Central Central NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 45 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 46 Research Research NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 47 Association Association NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 48 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 20 49 comments comment NNS www-bis-org-8025 20 50 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 20 51 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 20 52 Codruta Codruta NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 53 Boar Boar NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 54 , , , www-bis-org-8025 20 55 Alan Alan NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 56 Villegas Villegas NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 57 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 20 58 Giulio Giulio NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 59 Cornelli Cornelli NNP www-bis-org-8025 20 60 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 20 61 outstanding outstanding JJ www-bis-org-8025 20 62 research research NN www-bis-org-8025 20 63 support support NN www-bis-org-8025 20 64 . . . www-bis-org-8025 21 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 21 2 views view NNS www-bis-org-8025 21 3 expressed express VBN www-bis-org-8025 21 4 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 21 5 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 21 6 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 21 7 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 21 8 those those DT www-bis-org-8025 21 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 21 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 21 11 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 21 12 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 21 13 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 21 14 necessarily necessarily RB www-bis-org-8025 21 15 those those DT www-bis-org-8025 21 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 21 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 21 18 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 21 19 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 21 20 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 21 21 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 21 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 22 1 mailto:Raphael.auer@bis.org mailto:raphael.auer@bis.org NN www-bis-org-8025 22 2 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 22 3 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 22 4 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 22 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 22 6 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 22 7 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 22 9 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 22 10 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 22 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 22 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 22 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 22 14 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 22 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 22 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 22 17 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 18 Introduction introduction NN www-bis-org-8025 22 19 Judged judge VBN www-bis-org-8025 22 20 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 22 21 internet internet NN www-bis-org-8025 22 22 searches search NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 22 24 popular popular JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 25 fascination fascination NN www-bis-org-8025 22 26 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 22 27 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 22 28 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 22 29 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 30 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 31 soared soar VBD www-bis-org-8025 22 32 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 22 33 late late JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 34 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 22 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 22 36 outstripping outstrip VBG www-bis-org-8025 22 37 interest interest NN www-bis-org-8025 22 38 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 22 39 sovereign sovereign JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 40 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 41 , , , www-bis-org-8025 22 42 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 22 43 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 22 44 gold gold NN www-bis-org-8025 22 45 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 22 46 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 22 47 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 22 48 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 22 49 , , , www-bis-org-8025 22 50 left left JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 51 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 22 52 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 22 53 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 22 54 centre centre NN www-bis-org-8025 22 55 panels).2 panels).2 NNP www-bis-org-8025 22 56 Yet yet CC www-bis-org-8025 22 57 few few JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 58 people people NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 59 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 22 60 actually actually RB www-bis-org-8025 22 61 using use VBG www-bis-org-8025 22 62 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 22 63 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 22 64 buy buy VB www-bis-org-8025 22 65 things thing NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 66 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 22 67 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 22 68 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 22 69 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 22 70 , , , www-bis-org-8025 22 71 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 72 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 22 73 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 22 74 panel).3 panel).3 NN www-bis-org-8025 22 75 Much much JJ www-bis-org-8025 22 76 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 22 77 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 22 78 allure allure NN www-bis-org-8025 22 79 surrounding surround VBG www-bis-org-8025 22 80 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 22 81 stems stem VBZ www-bis-org-8025 22 82 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 22 83 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 22 84 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 22 85 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 22 86 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 22 87 government government NN www-bis-org-8025 22 88 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 22 89 needed need VBN www-bis-org-8025 22 90 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 22 91 issue issue VB www-bis-org-8025 22 92 them -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 22 93 . . . www-bis-org-8025 23 1 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 23 2 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 23 3 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 23 4 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 23 5 held hold VBN www-bis-org-8025 23 6 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 23 7 traded trade VBN www-bis-org-8025 23 8 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 23 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 23 10 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 23 11 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 23 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 24 1 Instead instead RB www-bis-org-8025 24 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 24 3 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 24 4 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 24 5 exchanged exchange VBN www-bis-org-8025 24 6 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 24 7 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 24 8 technical technical JJ www-bis-org-8025 24 9 protocols protocol NNS www-bis-org-8025 24 10 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 24 11 communication communication NN www-bis-org-8025 24 12 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 24 13 participants participant NNS www-bis-org-8025 24 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 24 15 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 24 16 well well RB www-bis-org-8025 24 17 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 24 18 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 24 19 publicly publicly RB www-bis-org-8025 24 20 shared share VBN www-bis-org-8025 24 21 ledger ledger NN www-bis-org-8025 24 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 24 23 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 24 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 24 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 24 26 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 24 27 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 24 28 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 24 29 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 24 30 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 24 31 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 24 32 updated update VBN www-bis-org-8025 24 33 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 24 34 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 24 35 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 24 36 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 24 37 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 24 38 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 24 39 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 24 40 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 24 41 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 24 42 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 24 43 computations computation NNS www-bis-org-8025 24 44 , , , www-bis-org-8025 24 45 ie ie FW www-bis-org-8025 24 46 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 24 47 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 24 48 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 24 49 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 24 50 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 24 51 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 24 52 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 24 53 . . . www-bis-org-8025 25 1 What what WP www-bis-org-8025 25 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 25 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 25 4 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 25 5 potential potential NN www-bis-org-8025 25 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 25 7 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 25 8 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 25 9 means mean NNS www-bis-org-8025 25 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 25 11 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 25 12 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 26 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 26 2 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 26 3 analyses analyse VBZ www-bis-org-8025 26 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 26 5 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 26 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 26 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 26 8 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 26 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 26 10 achieves achieve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 26 11 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 26 12 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 26 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 26 14 ie ie VBZ www-bis-org-8025 26 15 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 26 16 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 26 17 seeks seek VBZ www-bis-org-8025 26 18 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 26 19 make make VB www-bis-org-8025 26 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 26 21 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 26 22 unalterable unalterable JJ www-bis-org-8025 26 23 once once RB www-bis-org-8025 26 24 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 26 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 26 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 26 27 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 26 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 26 29 so so IN www-bis-org-8025 26 30 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 26 31 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 26 32 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 26 33 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 26 34 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 26 35 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 26 36 irrevocable irrevocable JJ www-bis-org-8025 26 37 . . . www-bis-org-8025 27 1 It -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 27 2 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 27 3 discusses discuss VBZ www-bis-org-8025 27 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 27 5 future future NN www-bis-org-8025 27 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 27 7 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 27 8 type type NN www-bis-org-8025 27 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 27 10 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 27 11 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 27 12 general general JJ www-bis-org-8025 27 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 28 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 28 2 focus focus NN www-bis-org-8025 28 3 lies lie VBZ www-bis-org-8025 28 4 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 28 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 28 6 technical technical JJ www-bis-org-8025 28 7 elements element NNS www-bis-org-8025 28 8 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 28 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 28 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 28 11 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 28 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 28 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 28 14 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 28 15 devised devise VBN www-bis-org-8025 28 16 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 28 17 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 28 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 28 19 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 28 20 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 28 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 29 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 29 2 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 29 3 conclusions conclusion NNS www-bis-org-8025 29 4 extend extend VBP www-bis-org-8025 29 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 29 6 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 29 7 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 29 8 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 29 9 slightly slightly RB www-bis-org-8025 29 10 modified modify VBN www-bis-org-8025 29 11 clones clone NNS www-bis-org-8025 29 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 29 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 29 15 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 17 Cash Cash NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 29 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 20 SV SV NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 29 22 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 29 23 Litecoin Litecoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 24 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 29 25 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 29 26 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 29 27 tokens token NNS www-bis-org-8025 29 28 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 29 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 29 30 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 29 31 far far RB www-bis-org-8025 29 32 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 29 33 least least RBS www-bis-org-8025 29 34 , , , www-bis-org-8025 29 35 share share VB www-bis-org-8025 29 36 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 29 37 crucial crucial JJ www-bis-org-8025 29 38 reliance reliance NN www-bis-org-8025 29 39 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 29 40 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 29 41 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 29 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 29 43 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 29 44 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 29 45 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 29 46 underpin underpin VB www-bis-org-8025 29 47 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 29 48 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 29 49 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 29 50 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 29 51 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 52 Ethereum Ethereum NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 53 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 29 54 Monero Monero NNP www-bis-org-8025 29 55 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 29 56 . . . www-bis-org-8025 30 1 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 30 2 International international JJ www-bis-org-8025 30 3 bodies body NNS www-bis-org-8025 30 4 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 30 5 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 30 6 turned turn VBN www-bis-org-8025 30 7 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 30 8 attention attention NN www-bis-org-8025 30 9 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 30 10 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 30 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 12 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 30 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 30 15 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 30 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 17 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 18 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 30 19 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 20 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 21 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 22 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 30 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 25 Carstens Carstens NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 26 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 27 2018a 2018a CD www-bis-org-8025 30 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 29 b b NN www-bis-org-8025 30 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 31 c c NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 32 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 33 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 34 Committee Committee NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 35 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 30 36 Payments Payments NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 37 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 30 38 Market market NN www-bis-org-8025 30 39 Infrastructures infrastructure NNS www-bis-org-8025 30 40 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 41 CPMI CPMI NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 42 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 43 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 44 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 30 45 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 46 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 30 47 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 48 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 49 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 50 Action Action NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 51 Task Task NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 52 Force Force NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 53 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 54 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 30 55 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 56 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 57 Carney Carney NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 58 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 59 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 30 60 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 61 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 62 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 63 Stability Stability NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 64 Board Board NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 65 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 66 2018a 2018a CD www-bis-org-8025 30 67 , , , www-bis-org-8025 30 68 b b NN www-bis-org-8025 30 69 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 70 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 30 71 G20 G20 NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 72 Finance Finance NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 73 Ministers Ministers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 30 74 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 30 75 Central Central NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 76 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 30 77 Governors Governors NNPS www-bis-org-8025 30 78 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 79 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 30 80 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 30 81 . . . www-bis-org-8025 31 1 3 3 LS www-bis-org-8025 31 2 To to TO www-bis-org-8025 31 3 put put VB www-bis-org-8025 31 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 31 5 magnitudes magnitude NNS www-bis-org-8025 31 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 31 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 31 8 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 31 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 31 10 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 31 11 panel panel NN www-bis-org-8025 31 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 31 13 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 31 14 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 31 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 31 16 context context NN www-bis-org-8025 31 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 31 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 31 19 peak peak NN www-bis-org-8025 31 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 31 21 USD USD NNP www-bis-org-8025 31 22 400 400 CD www-bis-org-8025 31 23 million million CD www-bis-org-8025 31 24 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 31 25 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 31 26 processed process VBD www-bis-org-8025 31 27 compares compare VBZ www-bis-org-8025 31 28 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 31 29 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 31 30 USD USD NNP www-bis-org-8025 31 31 500 500 CD www-bis-org-8025 31 32 billion billion CD www-bis-org-8025 31 33 processed process VBN www-bis-org-8025 31 34 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 31 35 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 31 36 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 31 37 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 31 38 month month NN www-bis-org-8025 31 39 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 31 40 just just RB www-bis-org-8025 31 41 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 31 42 conventional conventional JJ www-bis-org-8025 31 43 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 31 44 processor processor NN www-bis-org-8025 31 45 , , , www-bis-org-8025 31 46 VISA VISA NNP www-bis-org-8025 31 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 32 1 Global global JJ www-bis-org-8025 32 2 interest interest NN www-bis-org-8025 32 3 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 32 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 32 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 32 6 valuations valuation NNS www-bis-org-8025 32 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 32 8 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 32 9 use use VB www-bis-org-8025 32 10 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 32 11 retail retail JJ www-bis-org-8025 32 12 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 32 13 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 32 14 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 32 15 Interest Interest NNP www-bis-org-8025 32 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 32 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 32 18 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 32 19 exceeded exceed VBN www-bis-org-8025 32 20 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 32 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 32 22 sovereign sovereign JJ www-bis-org-8025 32 23 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 32 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 32 25 gold1 gold1 NN www-bis-org-8025 32 26 Valuations valuation NNS www-bis-org-8025 32 27 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 32 28 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 32 29 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 32 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 32 31 roller roller NN www-bis-org-8025 32 32 coaster coaster NN www-bis-org-8025 32 33 Actual actual JJ www-bis-org-8025 32 34 usage usage NN www-bis-org-8025 32 35 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 32 36 retail retail JJ www-bis-org-8025 32 37 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 32 38 remained remain VBD www-bis-org-8025 32 39 small3 small3 JJ www-bis-org-8025 32 40 Interest interest NN www-bis-org-8025 32 41 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 32 42 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 32 43 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 32 44 USD USD NNP www-bis-org-8025 32 45 mn mn NNP www-bis-org-8025 32 46 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 32 47 month month NN www-bis-org-8025 32 48 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 32 49 Numbers number NNS www-bis-org-8025 32 50 represent represent VBP www-bis-org-8025 32 51 search search NN www-bis-org-8025 32 52 interest interest NN www-bis-org-8025 32 53 relative relative JJ www-bis-org-8025 32 54 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 32 55 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 32 56 highest high JJS www-bis-org-8025 32 57 point point NN www-bis-org-8025 32 58 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 32 59 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 32 60 chart chart NN www-bis-org-8025 32 61 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 32 62 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 32 63 given give VBN www-bis-org-8025 32 64 search search NN www-bis-org-8025 32 65 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 32 66 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 32 67 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 32 68 . . . www-bis-org-8025 33 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 33 2 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 33 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 33 4 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 33 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 33 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 33 7 peak peak NN www-bis-org-8025 33 8 popularity popularity NN www-bis-org-8025 33 9 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 33 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 33 11 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 33 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 34 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 34 2 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 34 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 34 4 50 50 CD www-bis-org-8025 34 5 means mean NNS www-bis-org-8025 34 6 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 34 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 34 8 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 34 9 attracts attract VBZ www-bis-org-8025 34 10 half half RB www-bis-org-8025 34 11 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 34 12 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 34 13 searches search NNS www-bis-org-8025 34 14 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 34 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 34 16 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 34 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 34 18 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 34 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 35 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 35 2 score score NN www-bis-org-8025 35 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 35 4 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 35 5 means mean NNS www-bis-org-8025 35 6 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 35 7 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 35 8 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 35 9 enough enough JJ www-bis-org-8025 35 10 data datum NNS www-bis-org-8025 35 11 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 35 12 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 35 13 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 35 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 36 1 Google Google NNP www-bis-org-8025 36 2 trends trend NNS www-bis-org-8025 36 3 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 36 4 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 36 5 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 36 6 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 36 7 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 36 8 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 36 9 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 36 10 searches search NNS www-bis-org-8025 36 11 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 36 12 bitcoin bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 36 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 36 14 euro euro NNP www-bis-org-8025 36 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 36 16 gold gold NN www-bis-org-8025 36 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 36 18 usd usd NN www-bis-org-8025 36 19 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 36 20 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 36 21 search search NN www-bis-org-8025 36 22 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 36 23 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 36 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 36 25 worldwide worldwide JJ www-bis-org-8025 36 26 search search NN www-bis-org-8025 36 27 interest interest NN www-bis-org-8025 36 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 36 29 respectively respectively RB www-bis-org-8025 36 30 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 36 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 37 1 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 37 2 Data datum NNS www-bis-org-8025 37 3 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 37 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 37 5 CoinDesk CoinDesk NNP www-bis-org-8025 37 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 37 7 Price Price NNP www-bis-org-8025 37 8 Index Index NNP www-bis-org-8025 37 9 . . . www-bis-org-8025 38 1 BPI BPI NNP www-bis-org-8025 38 2 value value NNP www-bis-org-8025 38 3 data datum NNS www-bis-org-8025 38 4 returned return VBD www-bis-org-8025 38 5 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 38 6 USD USD NNP www-bis-org-8025 38 7 . . . www-bis-org-8025 39 1 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 39 2 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 39 3 displayed display VBN www-bis-org-8025 39 4 line line NN www-bis-org-8025 39 5 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 39 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 39 7 monthly monthly JJ www-bis-org-8025 39 8 volume volume NN www-bis-org-8025 39 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 39 10 global global JJ www-bis-org-8025 39 11 retail retail JJ www-bis-org-8025 39 12 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 39 13 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 39 14 made make VBN www-bis-org-8025 39 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 39 16 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 39 17 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 39 18 handled handle VBN www-bis-org-8025 39 19 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 39 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 39 21 major major JJ www-bis-org-8025 39 22 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 39 23 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 39 24 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 39 25 processing processing NN www-bis-org-8025 39 26 firms firm NNS www-bis-org-8025 39 27 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 39 28 volumes volume NNS www-bis-org-8025 39 29 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 39 30 expressed express VBN www-bis-org-8025 39 31 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 39 32 dollars dollar NNS www-bis-org-8025 39 33 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 39 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 40 1 Sources source NNS www-bis-org-8025 40 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 40 3 CoinDesk CoinDesk NNP www-bis-org-8025 40 4 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 40 5 Google Google NNP www-bis-org-8025 40 6 trends trend NNS www-bis-org-8025 40 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 40 8 site site NN www-bis-org-8025 40 9 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 40 10 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 40 11 05.11.2018 05.11.2018 NNP www-bis-org-8025 40 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 40 13 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 40 14 chainanalysis.com chainanalysis.com ADD www-bis-org-8025 40 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 40 16 site site NN www-bis-org-8025 40 17 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 40 18 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 40 19 05.11.2018 05.11.2018 NNP www-bis-org-8025 40 20 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 40 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 41 1 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 2 75 75 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 3 50 50 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 4 25 25 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 5 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 6 Q4 q4 NN www-bis-org-8025 41 7 18Q2 18q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 8 18Q4 18q4 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 9 17Q2 17q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 10 17 17 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 12 Gold Gold NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 13 Euro Euro NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 14 US US NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 15 dollar dollar NN www-bis-org-8025 41 16 16,000 16,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 17 12,000 12,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 18 8,000 8,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 19 4,000 4,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 20 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 21 2018201720162015 2018201720162015 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 22 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 23 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 41 24 index2 index2 NN www-bis-org-8025 41 25 400 400 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 26 300 300 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 27 200 200 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 28 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 29 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 30 2018201720162015 2018201720162015 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 31 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 41 32 Monthly monthly JJ www-bis-org-8025 41 33 volume volume NN www-bis-org-8025 41 34 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 41 35 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 41 36 http://www.chainanalysis.com/ http://www.chainanalysis.com/ NN www-bis-org-8025 41 37 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 38 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 41 39 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 41 40 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 41 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 41 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 41 43 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 41 44 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 41 45 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 41 46 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 41 47 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 41 48 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 41 49 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 41 50 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 41 51 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 41 52 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 41 53 Nakamoto’s4 Nakamoto’s4 NNP www-bis-org-8025 41 54 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 41 55 innovation innovation NN www-bis-org-8025 41 56 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 41 57 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 41 58 balance balance VB www-bis-org-8025 41 59 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 41 60 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 41 61 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 41 62 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 41 63 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 41 64 updating update VBG www-bis-org-8025 41 65 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 41 66 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 41 67 , , , www-bis-org-8025 41 68 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 41 69 creating create VBG www-bis-org-8025 41 70 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 41 71 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 41 72 ensure ensure VB www-bis-org-8025 41 73 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 41 74 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 41 75 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 41 76 correct correct JJ www-bis-org-8025 41 77 . . . www-bis-org-8025 42 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 42 2 updating updating JJ www-bis-org-8025 42 3 process process NN www-bis-org-8025 42 4 deters deter VBZ www-bis-org-8025 42 5 forgeries forgery NNS www-bis-org-8025 42 6 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 42 7 imposing impose VBG www-bis-org-8025 42 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 42 9 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 42 10 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 42 11 updating update VBG www-bis-org-8025 42 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 42 13 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 42 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 43 1 At at IN www-bis-org-8025 43 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 43 3 same same JJ www-bis-org-8025 43 4 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 43 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 43 6 accurate accurate JJ www-bis-org-8025 43 7 updating updating NN www-bis-org-8025 43 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 43 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 43 10 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 43 11 confers confer NNS www-bis-org-8025 43 12 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 43 13 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 43 14 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 43 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 43 16 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 43 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 43 18 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 43 19 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 43 20 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 43 21 do do VBP www-bis-org-8025 43 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 43 23 updating updating NN www-bis-org-8025 43 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 44 1 Miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 44 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 44 3 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 44 4 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 44 5 computers computer NNS www-bis-org-8025 44 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 44 7 effectively effectively RB www-bis-org-8025 44 8 compete compete VBP www-bis-org-8025 44 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 44 10 solve solve VB www-bis-org-8025 44 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 44 12 mathematical mathematical JJ www-bis-org-8025 44 13 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 44 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 45 1 Presenting present VBG www-bis-org-8025 45 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 45 3 solution solution NN www-bis-org-8025 45 4 proves prove VBZ www-bis-org-8025 45 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 45 6 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 45 7 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 45 8 done do VBN www-bis-org-8025 45 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 45 10 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 45 11 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 45 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 45 13 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 45 14 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 45 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 46 1 Such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 46 2 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 46 3 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 46 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 46 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 46 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 46 7 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 46 8 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 46 9 allows allow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 46 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 46 11 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 46 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 46 13 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 46 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 46 15 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 46 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 46 17 newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 46 18 processed process VBN www-bis-org-8025 46 19 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 46 20 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 46 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 46 22 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 46 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 46 24 collecting collect VBG www-bis-org-8025 46 25 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 46 26 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 46 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 46 28 subject subject JJ www-bis-org-8025 46 29 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 46 30 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 46 31 well well RB www-bis-org-8025 46 32 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 46 33 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 46 34 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 46 35 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 46 36 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 46 37 – – : www-bis-org-8025 46 38 newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 46 39 minted mint VBN www-bis-org-8025 46 40 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 46 41 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 46 42 increase increase VBP www-bis-org-8025 46 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 46 44 outstanding outstanding JJ www-bis-org-8025 46 45 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 46 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 47 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 47 2 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 47 3 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 47 4 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 47 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 47 6 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 47 7 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 47 8 updating updating JJ www-bis-org-8025 47 9 process process NN www-bis-org-8025 47 10 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 47 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 47 12 focus focus NN www-bis-org-8025 47 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 47 14 our -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 47 15 discussion discussion NN www-bis-org-8025 47 16 here here RB www-bis-org-8025 47 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 48 1 Two two CD www-bis-org-8025 48 2 questions question NNS www-bis-org-8025 48 3 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 48 4 raised raise VBN www-bis-org-8025 48 5 . . . www-bis-org-8025 49 1 First first RB www-bis-org-8025 49 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 49 3 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 49 4 efficient efficient JJ www-bis-org-8025 49 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 49 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 49 7 fundamental fundamental JJ www-bis-org-8025 49 8 architecture architecture NN www-bis-org-8025 49 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 49 10 deterring deter VBG www-bis-org-8025 49 11 forgeries forgery NNS www-bis-org-8025 49 12 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 49 13 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 49 14 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 49 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 49 16 of- of- CD www-bis-org-8025 49 17 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 49 18 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 50 1 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 50 2 second second RB www-bis-org-8025 50 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 50 4 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 50 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 50 6 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 50 7 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 50 8 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 50 9 actually actually RB www-bis-org-8025 50 10 generate generate VBP www-bis-org-8025 50 11 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 50 12 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 50 13 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 50 14 valuable valuable JJ www-bis-org-8025 50 15 enough enough RB www-bis-org-8025 50 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 50 17 ensure ensure VB www-bis-org-8025 50 18 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 50 19 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 50 20 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 50 21 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 50 22 really really RB www-bis-org-8025 50 23 achieved achieve VBN www-bis-org-8025 50 24 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 51 1 Analysing analyse VBG www-bis-org-8025 51 2 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 51 3 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 51 4 elements element NNS www-bis-org-8025 51 5 uncovers uncover NNS www-bis-org-8025 51 6 fundamental fundamental JJ www-bis-org-8025 51 7 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 51 8 limitations limitation NNS www-bis-org-8025 51 9 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 51 10 cloud cloud VBP www-bis-org-8025 51 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 51 12 future future NN www-bis-org-8025 51 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 51 14 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 51 15 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 51 16 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 51 17 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 51 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 51 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 51 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 51 21 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 51 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 52 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 52 2 sum sum NN www-bis-org-8025 52 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 52 4 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 52 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 52 6 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 52 7 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 52 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 52 9 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 52 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 52 11 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 52 12 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 52 13 clear clear JJ www-bis-org-8025 52 14 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 52 15 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 52 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 52 17 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 52 18 keep keep VB www-bis-org-8025 52 19 functioning function VBG www-bis-org-8025 52 20 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 52 21 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 52 22 do do VBP www-bis-org-8025 52 23 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 52 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 52 25 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 52 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 52 27 writing writing NN www-bis-org-8025 52 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 53 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 53 2 statement statement NN www-bis-org-8025 53 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 53 4 unrelated unrelated JJ www-bis-org-8025 53 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 53 6 well well RB www-bis-org-8025 53 7 known know VBN www-bis-org-8025 53 8 restrictions restriction NNS www-bis-org-8025 53 9 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 53 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 53 11 scale scale NN www-bis-org-8025 53 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 53 13 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 53 14 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 53 15 systems system NNS www-bis-org-8025 53 16 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 53 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 53 18 volatility volatility NN www-bis-org-8025 53 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 53 20 cryptocurrencies.5 cryptocurrencies.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 53 21 Rather rather RB www-bis-org-8025 53 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 53 23 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 53 24 concerns concern VBZ www-bis-org-8025 53 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 53 26 fundamentals fundamental NNS www-bis-org-8025 53 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 53 28 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 53 29 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 53 30 updating updating NN www-bis-org-8025 53 31 process process NN www-bis-org-8025 53 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 53 33 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 53 34 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 53 35 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 53 36 limitations limitation NNS www-bis-org-8025 53 37 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 53 38 interact interact VBP www-bis-org-8025 53 39 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 53 40 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 53 41 fateful fateful JJ www-bis-org-8025 53 42 manner manner NN www-bis-org-8025 53 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 54 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 54 2 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 54 3 limitation limitation NN www-bis-org-8025 54 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 54 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 54 6 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 54 7 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 54 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 54 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 54 10 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 54 11 axiomatically axiomatically RB www-bis-org-8025 54 12 requires require VBZ www-bis-org-8025 54 13 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 54 14 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 54 15 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 54 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 54 17 ensure ensure VB www-bis-org-8025 54 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 54 19 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 54 20 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 54 21 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 54 22 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 54 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 54 24 important important JJ www-bis-org-8025 54 25 contribution contribution NN www-bis-org-8025 54 26 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 54 27 Budish Budish NNP www-bis-org-8025 54 28 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 54 29 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 54 30 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 54 31 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 54 32 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 54 33 issue issue NN www-bis-org-8025 54 34 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 54 35 . . . www-bis-org-8025 55 1 Counterfeiters counterfeiter NNS www-bis-org-8025 55 2 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 55 3 attack attack VB www-bis-org-8025 55 4 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 55 5 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 55 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 55 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 55 8 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 55 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 55 10 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 55 11 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 55 12 strategy strategy NN www-bis-org-8025 55 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 55 14 ie ie VBZ www-bis-org-8025 55 15 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 55 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 55 17 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 55 18 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 55 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 55 20 later later RB www-bis-org-8025 55 21 undoing undo VBG www-bis-org-8025 55 22 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 55 23 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 55 24 releasing release VBG www-bis-org-8025 55 25 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 55 26 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 55 27 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 55 28 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 55 29 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 55 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 55 31 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 55 32 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 55 33 erased erase VBN www-bis-org-8025 55 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 56 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 56 2 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 56 3 starts start VBZ www-bis-org-8025 56 4 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 56 5 introducing introduce VBG www-bis-org-8025 56 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 56 7 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 56 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 56 9 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 56 10 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 56 11 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 56 12 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 56 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 56 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 56 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 56 16 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 56 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 57 1 That that RB www-bis-org-8025 57 2 is is RB www-bis-org-8025 57 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 57 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 57 5 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 57 6 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 57 7 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 57 8 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 57 9 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 57 10 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 57 11 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 57 12 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 57 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 57 14 unprofitable unprofitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 57 15 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 57 16 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 57 17 potential potential JJ www-bis-org-8025 57 18 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 57 19 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 57 20 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 57 21 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 57 22 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 57 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 57 24 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 57 25 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 57 26 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 57 27 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 57 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 58 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 58 2 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 58 3 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 58 4 differs differ VBZ www-bis-org-8025 58 5 starkly starkly RB www-bis-org-8025 58 6 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 58 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 58 8 operational operational JJ www-bis-org-8025 58 9 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 58 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 58 11 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 58 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 58 13 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 58 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 58 15 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 58 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 58 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 58 18 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 58 19 examines examine VBZ www-bis-org-8025 58 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 58 21 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 58 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 58 23 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 58 24 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 58 25 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 58 26 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 58 27 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 58 28 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 58 29 controlling control VBG www-bis-org-8025 58 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 58 31 significant significant JJ www-bis-org-8025 58 32 fraction fraction NN www-bis-org-8025 58 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 58 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 58 35 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 58 36 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 58 37 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 58 38 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 58 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 59 1 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 59 2 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 59 3 definition definition NN www-bis-org-8025 59 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 59 5 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 59 6 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 59 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 59 8 although although IN www-bis-org-8025 59 9 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 59 10 explicitly explicitly RB www-bis-org-8025 59 11 spelled spell VBN www-bis-org-8025 59 12 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 59 13 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 59 14 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 59 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 59 16 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 59 17 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 59 18 operational operational JJ www-bis-org-8025 59 19 : : : www-bis-org-8025 59 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 59 21 deeper deep JJR www-bis-org-8025 59 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 59 23 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 59 24 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 59 25 buried bury VBN www-bis-org-8025 59 26 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 59 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 59 28 ledger ledger NNP www-bis-org-8025 59 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 59 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 59 31 less less RBR www-bis-org-8025 59 32 likely likely JJ www-bis-org-8025 59 33 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 59 34 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 59 35 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 59 36 given give VBN www-bis-org-8025 59 37 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 59 38 resources resource NNS www-bis-org-8025 59 39 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 59 40 succeed succeed VB www-bis-org-8025 59 41 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 59 42 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 59 43 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 59 44 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 59 45 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 59 46 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 59 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 60 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 60 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 60 3 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 60 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 60 5 potential potential JJ www-bis-org-8025 60 6 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 60 7 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 60 8 analysed analyse VBN www-bis-org-8025 60 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 60 10 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 60 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 60 12 clear clear JJ www-bis-org-8025 60 13 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 60 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 60 15 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 60 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 60 17 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 60 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 60 19 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 60 20 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 60 21 extreme extreme JJ www-bis-org-8025 60 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 61 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 61 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 61 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 61 4 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 61 5 achieve achieve VB www-bis-org-8025 61 6 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 61 7 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 61 8 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 61 9 within within IN www-bis-org-8025 61 10 six six CD www-bis-org-8025 61 11 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 61 12 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 61 13 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 61 14 hour hour NN www-bis-org-8025 61 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 61 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 61 17 back back RB www-bis-org-8025 61 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 61 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 61 20 envelope envelope NNP www-bis-org-8025 61 21 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 61 22 suggest suggest VBP www-bis-org-8025 61 23 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 61 24 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 61 25 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 61 26 must must MD www-bis-org-8025 61 27 amount amount VB www-bis-org-8025 61 28 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 61 29 8.3 8.3 CD www-bis-org-8025 61 30 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 61 31 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 61 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 61 33 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 61 34 volume volume NN www-bis-org-8025 61 35 – – : www-bis-org-8025 61 36 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 61 37 multiple multiple NN www-bis-org-8025 61 38 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 61 39 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 61 40 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 61 41 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 61 42 today today NN www-bis-org-8025 61 43 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 61 44 mainstream mainstream JJ www-bis-org-8025 61 45 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 61 46 services service NNS www-bis-org-8025 61 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 62 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 62 2 underlying underlying JJ www-bis-org-8025 62 3 intuition intuition NN www-bis-org-8025 62 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 62 5 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 62 6 : : : www-bis-org-8025 62 7 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 62 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 62 9 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 62 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 62 11 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 62 12 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 62 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 63 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 63 2 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 63 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 63 4 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 63 5 stand stand VBP www-bis-org-8025 63 6 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 63 7 gain gain VB www-bis-org-8025 63 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 63 9 much much RB www-bis-org-8025 63 10 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 63 11 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 63 12 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 63 13 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 63 14 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 63 15 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 63 16 honest honest JJ www-bis-org-8025 63 17 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 63 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 64 1 While while IN www-bis-org-8025 64 2 honest honest JJ www-bis-org-8025 64 3 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 64 4 simply simply RB www-bis-org-8025 64 5 collect collect VBP www-bis-org-8025 64 6 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 64 7 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 64 8 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 64 9 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 64 10 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 64 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 64 12 counterfeiters counterfeiter NNS www-bis-org-8025 64 13 collect collect VBP www-bis-org-8025 64 14 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 64 15 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 64 16 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 64 17 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 64 18 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 64 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 64 20 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 64 21 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 64 22 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 64 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 64 24 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 64 25 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 64 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 64 27 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 64 28 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 64 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 64 30 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 64 31 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 64 32 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 64 33 double double RB www-bis-org-8025 64 34 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 64 35 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 64 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 64 37 ie ie IN www-bis-org-8025 64 38 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 64 39 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 64 40 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 64 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 64 42 voided voided JJ www-bis-org-8025 64 43 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 64 44 . . . www-bis-org-8025 65 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 65 2 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 65 3 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 65 4 advantage advantage NN www-bis-org-8025 65 5 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 65 6 ultimately ultimately RB www-bis-org-8025 65 7 translates translate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 65 8 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 65 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 65 10 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 65 11 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 65 12 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 65 13 ratio ratio NN www-bis-org-8025 65 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 65 15 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 65 16 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 65 17 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 65 18 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 65 19 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 65 20 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 65 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 65 22 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 65 23 volume volume NN www-bis-org-8025 65 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 65 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 65 26 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 65 27 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 65 28 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 65 29 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 65 30 double double RB www-bis-org-8025 65 31 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 65 32 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 65 33 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 65 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 66 1 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 66 2 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 66 3 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 66 4 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 66 5 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 66 6 – – : www-bis-org-8025 66 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 66 8 pseudonym pseudonym NN www-bis-org-8025 66 9 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 66 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 66 11 hitherto hitherto JJ www-bis-org-8025 66 12 unknown unknown JJ www-bis-org-8025 66 13 person person NN www-bis-org-8025 66 14 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 66 15 group group NN www-bis-org-8025 66 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 66 17 persons person NNS www-bis-org-8025 66 18 – – : www-bis-org-8025 66 19 did do VBD www-bis-org-8025 66 20 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 66 21 invent invent VB www-bis-org-8025 66 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 66 23 individual individual JJ www-bis-org-8025 66 24 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 66 25 elements element NNS www-bis-org-8025 66 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 66 27 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 66 28 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 66 29 rather rather RB www-bis-org-8025 66 30 made make VBD www-bis-org-8025 66 31 use use NN www-bis-org-8025 66 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 66 33 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 66 34 novel novel JJ www-bis-org-8025 66 35 combination combination NN www-bis-org-8025 66 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 66 37 existing exist VBG www-bis-org-8025 66 38 technologies technology NNS www-bis-org-8025 66 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 67 1 Proposals proposal NNS www-bis-org-8025 67 2 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 67 3 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 67 4 forms form NNS www-bis-org-8025 67 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 67 6 cash cash NN www-bis-org-8025 67 7 date date NN www-bis-org-8025 67 8 include include VBP www-bis-org-8025 67 9 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 67 10 Chaum Chaum NNP www-bis-org-8025 67 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 67 12 1983 1983 CD www-bis-org-8025 67 13 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 67 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 68 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 68 2 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 68 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 68 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 68 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 68 6 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 68 7 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 68 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 68 9 commonly commonly RB www-bis-org-8025 68 10 attributed attribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 68 11 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 68 12 Dwork Dwork NNP www-bis-org-8025 68 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 68 14 Naor Naor NNP www-bis-org-8025 68 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 68 16 1992 1992 CD www-bis-org-8025 68 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 68 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 68 19 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 68 20 Szabo Szabo NNP www-bis-org-8025 68 21 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 68 22 2005 2005 CD www-bis-org-8025 68 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 68 24 too too RB www-bis-org-8025 68 25 recognised recognise VBD www-bis-org-8025 68 26 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 68 27 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 68 28 principle principle NN www-bis-org-8025 68 29 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 68 30 initially initially RB www-bis-org-8025 68 31 developed develop VBN www-bis-org-8025 68 32 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 68 33 deter deter VB www-bis-org-8025 68 34 spam spam NN www-bis-org-8025 68 35 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 68 36 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 68 37 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 68 38 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 68 39 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 68 40 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 68 41 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 68 42 systems system NNS www-bis-org-8025 68 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 69 1 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 69 2 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 69 3 limited limited JJ www-bis-org-8025 69 4 scale scale NN www-bis-org-8025 69 5 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 69 6 volatility volatility NN www-bis-org-8025 69 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 69 8 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 69 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 69 10 particular particular JJ www-bis-org-8025 69 11 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 69 12 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 69 13 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 69 14 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 69 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 69 16 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 69 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 69 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 70 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 70 2 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 70 3 limitations limitation NNS www-bis-org-8025 70 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 70 5 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 70 6 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 7 Biais Biais NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 8 et et NN www-bis-org-8025 70 9 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 11 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 70 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 70 14 Huberman Huberman NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 15 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 16 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 18 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 70 19 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 70 21 Budish Budish NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 23 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 70 24 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 70 26 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 70 27 Morris Morris NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 28 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 70 29 Shin Shin NNP www-bis-org-8025 70 30 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 31 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 70 32 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 70 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 71 1 4 4 LS www-bis-org-8025 71 2 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 71 3 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 71 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 71 5 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 71 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 71 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 71 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 71 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 71 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 71 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 71 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 71 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 71 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 71 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 71 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 71 17 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 71 18 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 71 19 fundamental fundamental JJ www-bis-org-8025 71 20 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 71 21 limitation limitation NN www-bis-org-8025 71 22 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 71 23 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 71 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 71 25 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 71 26 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 71 27 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 71 28 generate generate VB www-bis-org-8025 71 29 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 71 30 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 71 31 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 71 32 line line NN www-bis-org-8025 71 33 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 71 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 71 35 goal goal NN www-bis-org-8025 71 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 71 37 guaranteeing guarantee VBG www-bis-org-8025 71 38 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 71 39 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 71 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 72 1 Either either CC www-bis-org-8025 72 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 72 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 72 4 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 72 5 works work VBZ www-bis-org-8025 72 6 below below IN www-bis-org-8025 72 7 capacity capacity NN www-bis-org-8025 72 8 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 72 9 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 72 10 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 72 11 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 72 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 72 13 set set VB www-bis-org-8025 72 14 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 72 15 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 72 16 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 72 17 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 72 18 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 72 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 72 20 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 72 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 72 22 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 72 23 becomes become VBZ www-bis-org-8025 72 24 congested congested JJ www-bis-org-8025 72 25 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 72 26 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 72 27 Huberman Huberman NNP www-bis-org-8025 72 28 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 72 29 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 72 30 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 72 31 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 72 32 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 72 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 72 34 Easley Easley NNP www-bis-org-8025 72 35 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 72 36 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 72 37 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 72 38 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 72 39 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 72 40 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 72 41 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 72 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 72 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 72 44 case case NN www-bis-org-8025 72 45 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 72 46 congestion congestion NN www-bis-org-8025 72 47 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 72 48 associated associate VBD www-bis-org-8025 72 49 queuing queuing NN www-bis-org-8025 72 50 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 72 51 . . . www-bis-org-8025 73 1 Underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 73 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 73 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 73 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 73 5 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 73 6 externality externality NN www-bis-org-8025 73 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 73 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 73 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 73 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 73 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 73 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 73 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 73 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 73 15 hence hence RB www-bis-org-8025 73 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 73 17 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 73 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 73 19 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 73 20 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 73 21 determined determine VBN www-bis-org-8025 73 22 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 73 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 73 24 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 73 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 73 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 73 27 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 73 28 one one NNP www-bis-org-8025 73 29 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 73 30 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 73 31 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 73 32 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 73 33 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 73 34 , , , www-bis-org-8025 73 35 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 73 36 protection protection NN www-bis-org-8025 73 37 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 73 38 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 73 39 provided provide VBN www-bis-org-8025 73 40 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 73 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 73 42 proofs proofs JJ www-bis-org-8025 73 43 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 73 44 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 73 45 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 73 46 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 73 47 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 73 48 subsequent subsequent JJ www-bis-org-8025 73 49 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 73 50 . . . www-bis-org-8025 74 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 74 2 contrast contrast NN www-bis-org-8025 74 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 74 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 74 5 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 74 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 74 7 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 74 8 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 74 9 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 74 10 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 74 11 privately privately RB www-bis-org-8025 74 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 74 13 hence hence RB www-bis-org-8025 74 14 creating create VBG www-bis-org-8025 74 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 74 16 classical classical JJ www-bis-org-8025 74 17 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 74 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 74 19 rider rider NN www-bis-org-8025 74 20 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 74 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 74 22 amounting amount VBG www-bis-org-8025 74 23 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 74 24 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 74 25 veritable veritable JJ www-bis-org-8025 74 26 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 74 27 tragedy tragedy NN www-bis-org-8025 74 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 74 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 74 30 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 74 31 chain”.6 chain”.6 : www-bis-org-8025 74 32 While while IN www-bis-org-8025 74 33 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 74 34 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 74 35 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 74 36 benefit benefit VB www-bis-org-8025 74 37 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 74 38 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 74 39 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 74 40 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 74 41 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 74 42 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 74 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 74 44 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 74 45 , , , www-bis-org-8025 74 46 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 74 47 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 74 48 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 74 49 contribute contribute VB www-bis-org-8025 74 50 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 74 51 one one PRP www-bis-org-8025 74 52 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 74 53 own own JJ www-bis-org-8025 74 54 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 74 55 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 74 56 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 74 57 . . . www-bis-org-8025 75 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 75 2 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 75 3 takeaway takeaway NN www-bis-org-8025 75 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 75 5 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 75 6 paper7 paper7 NN www-bis-org-8025 75 7 concerns concern VBZ www-bis-org-8025 75 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 75 9 interaction interaction NN www-bis-org-8025 75 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 75 11 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 75 12 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 75 13 limitations limitation NNS www-bis-org-8025 75 14 : : : www-bis-org-8025 75 15 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 75 16 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 75 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 75 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 75 19 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 75 20 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 75 21 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 75 22 achieve achieve VB www-bis-org-8025 75 23 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 75 24 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 75 25 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 75 26 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 75 27 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 75 28 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 75 29 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 75 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 75 31 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 75 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 75 33 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 75 34 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 75 35 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 75 36 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 75 37 generate generate VB www-bis-org-8025 75 38 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 75 39 adequate adequate JJ www-bis-org-8025 75 40 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 75 41 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 75 42 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 75 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 76 1 As as IN www-bis-org-8025 76 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 76 3 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 76 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 76 5 liquidity liquidity NN www-bis-org-8025 76 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 76 7 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 76 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 76 9 deteriorate deteriorate VB www-bis-org-8025 76 10 substantially substantially RB www-bis-org-8025 76 11 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 76 12 years year NNS www-bis-org-8025 76 13 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 76 14 come come VB www-bis-org-8025 76 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 77 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 77 2 backdrop backdrop NN www-bis-org-8025 77 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 77 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 77 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 77 6 bulk bulk NN www-bis-org-8025 77 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 77 8 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 77 9 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 77 10 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 77 11 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 77 12 consists consist VBZ www-bis-org-8025 77 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 77 14 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 77 15 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 77 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 78 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 78 2 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 78 3 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 78 4 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 78 5 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 78 6 phased phase VBN www-bis-org-8025 78 7 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 78 8 . . . www-bis-org-8025 79 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 79 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 79 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 79 4 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 79 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 79 6 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 79 7 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 79 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 79 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 79 10 clones clone NNS www-bis-org-8025 79 11 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 79 12 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 79 13 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 79 14 forked fork VBN www-bis-org-8025 79 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 79 16 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 79 17 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 79 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 79 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 79 20 next next JJ www-bis-org-8025 79 21 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 79 22 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 79 23 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 79 24 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 79 25 halve halve VB www-bis-org-8025 79 26 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 79 27 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 79 28 2020 2020 CD www-bis-org-8025 79 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 80 1 Whenever whenever WRB www-bis-org-8025 80 2 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 80 3 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 80 4 decrease decrease NN www-bis-org-8025 80 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 80 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 80 7 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 80 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 80 9 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 80 10 decreases decrease VBZ www-bis-org-8025 80 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 80 12 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 80 13 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 80 14 become become VBP www-bis-org-8025 80 15 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 80 16 important important JJ www-bis-org-8025 80 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 80 18 guarantee guarantee VB www-bis-org-8025 80 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 80 20 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 80 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 80 22 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 80 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 81 1 However however RB www-bis-org-8025 81 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 81 3 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 81 4 design design NN www-bis-org-8025 81 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 81 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 81 7 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 81 8 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 81 9 fails fail VBZ www-bis-org-8025 81 10 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 81 11 generate generate VB www-bis-org-8025 81 12 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 81 13 enough enough JJ www-bis-org-8025 81 14 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 81 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 82 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 82 2 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 82 3 model model NN www-bis-org-8025 82 4 suggests suggest VBZ www-bis-org-8025 82 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 82 6 ultimately ultimately RB www-bis-org-8025 82 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 82 8 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 82 9 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 82 10 take take VB www-bis-org-8025 82 11 nearly nearly RB www-bis-org-8025 82 12 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 82 13 year year NN www-bis-org-8025 82 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 82 15 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 82 16 50,000 50,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 82 17 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 82 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 82 19 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 82 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 82 21 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 82 22 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 82 23 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 82 24 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 82 25 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 82 26 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 82 27 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 82 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 83 1 Given give VBN www-bis-org-8025 83 2 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 83 3 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 83 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 83 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 83 6 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 83 7 concludes conclude VBZ www-bis-org-8025 83 8 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 83 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 83 10 discussion discussion NN www-bis-org-8025 83 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 83 12 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 83 13 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 83 14 progress progress NN www-bis-org-8025 83 15 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 83 16 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 83 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 83 18 affect affect VB www-bis-org-8025 83 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 83 20 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 83 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 83 22 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 83 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 83 24 related related JJ www-bis-org-8025 83 25 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 83 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 84 1 So so RB www-bis-org-8025 84 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 84 3 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 84 4 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 84 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 84 6 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 84 7 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 84 8 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 84 9 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 84 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 84 11 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 84 12 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 84 13 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 84 14 improve improve VB www-bis-org-8025 84 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 84 16 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 84 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 84 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 84 19 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 84 20 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 84 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 84 22 addition addition NN www-bis-org-8025 84 23 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 84 24 mitigating mitigate VBG www-bis-org-8025 84 25 scaling scale VBG www-bis-org-8025 84 26 limits limit NNS www-bis-org-8025 84 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 84 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 85 1 However however RB www-bis-org-8025 85 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 85 3 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 85 4 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 85 5 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 85 6 magic magic JJ www-bis-org-8025 85 7 bullets bullet NNS www-bis-org-8025 85 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 85 9 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 85 10 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 85 11 face face VBP www-bis-org-8025 85 12 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 85 13 own own JJ www-bis-org-8025 85 14 scaling scaling NN www-bis-org-8025 85 15 issues issue NNS www-bis-org-8025 85 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 86 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 86 2 order order NN www-bis-org-8025 86 3 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 86 4 prevent prevent VB www-bis-org-8025 86 5 liquidity liquidity NN www-bis-org-8025 86 6 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 86 7 ebbing ebb VBG www-bis-org-8025 86 8 away away RB www-bis-org-8025 86 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 86 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 86 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 86 12 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 86 13 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 86 14 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 86 15 need need VB www-bis-org-8025 86 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 86 17 depart depart VB www-bis-org-8025 86 18 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 86 19 using use VBG www-bis-org-8025 86 20 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 86 21 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 86 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 86 23 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 86 24 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 86 25 – – : www-bis-org-8025 86 26 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 86 27 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 86 28 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 86 29 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 86 30 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 86 31 sustainable sustainable JJ www-bis-org-8025 86 32 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 86 33 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 86 34 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 86 35 – – : www-bis-org-8025 86 36 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 86 37 embrace embrace VB www-bis-org-8025 86 38 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 86 39 methods method NNS www-bis-org-8025 86 40 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 86 41 achieving achieve VBG www-bis-org-8025 86 42 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 86 43 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 86 44 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 86 45 updates updates NNPS www-bis-org-8025 86 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 87 1 Among among IN www-bis-org-8025 87 2 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 87 3 proposed propose VBN www-bis-org-8025 87 4 developments development NNS www-bis-org-8025 87 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 87 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 87 7 most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 87 8 prominent prominent JJ www-bis-org-8025 87 9 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 87 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 87 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 87 12 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 87 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 87 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 87 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 87 16 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 87 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 87 18 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 87 19 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 87 20 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 87 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 87 22 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 87 23 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 87 24 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 87 25 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 87 26 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 87 27 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 87 28 enforced enforce VBN www-bis-org-8025 87 29 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 87 30 ensuring ensure VBG www-bis-org-8025 87 31 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 87 32 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 87 33 verifiers verifier NNS www-bis-org-8025 87 34 pledge pledge VBP www-bis-org-8025 87 35 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 87 36 coin coin NN www-bis-org-8025 87 37 holdings holding NNS www-bis-org-8025 87 38 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 87 39 guarantees guarantee NNS www-bis-org-8025 87 40 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 87 41 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 87 42 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 87 43 confirmations confirmation NNS www-bis-org-8025 87 44 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 87 45 accurate accurate JJ www-bis-org-8025 87 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 88 1 Yet yet RB www-bis-org-8025 88 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 88 3 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 88 4 such such PDT www-bis-org-8025 88 5 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 88 6 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 88 7 lacks lack VBZ www-bis-org-8025 88 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 88 9 solid solid JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 10 grounding grounding NN www-bis-org-8025 88 11 offered offer VBN www-bis-org-8025 88 12 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 88 13 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 88 14 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 88 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 88 16 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 88 17 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 88 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 19 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 88 20 proves prove VBZ www-bis-org-8025 88 21 actual actual JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 22 offline offline NN www-bis-org-8025 88 23 activity activity NN www-bis-org-8025 88 24 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 88 26 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 88 27 success success NN www-bis-org-8025 88 28 may may MD www-bis-org-8025 88 29 rest rest VB www-bis-org-8025 88 30 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 88 31 additional additional JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 32 overarching overarching JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 33 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 88 34 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-bis-org-8025 88 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 88 36 ie ie NN www-bis-org-8025 88 37 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 88 38 degree degree NN www-bis-org-8025 88 39 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 88 40 implicit implicit JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 41 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 88 42 explicit explicit JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 43 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 88 44 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 88 45 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 88 46 institution.8 institution.8 NNP www-bis-org-8025 88 47 Judging judging NN www-bis-org-8025 88 48 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 88 49 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 88 50 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 88 51 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 52 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 88 53 , , , www-bis-org-8025 88 54 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 88 55 overall overall JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 56 conclusion conclusion NN www-bis-org-8025 88 57 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 88 58 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 88 59 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 88 60 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 88 61 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 62 age age NN www-bis-org-8025 88 63 too too RB www-bis-org-8025 88 64 , , , www-bis-org-8025 88 65 good good JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 66 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 88 67 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 88 68 likely likely JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 69 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 88 70 remain remain VB www-bis-org-8025 88 71 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 88 72 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 73 rather rather RB www-bis-org-8025 88 74 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 88 75 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 88 76 purely purely RB www-bis-org-8025 88 77 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 88 78 construct construct NN www-bis-org-8025 88 79 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 80 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 88 81 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 88 82 Carstens Carstens NNP www-bis-org-8025 88 83 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 84 2018a 2018a CD www-bis-org-8025 88 85 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 86 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 88 87 Borio Borio NNP www-bis-org-8025 88 88 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 89 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 88 90 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 91 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 88 92 . . . www-bis-org-8025 89 1 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 89 2 That that IN www-bis-org-8025 89 3 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 89 4 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 89 5 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 89 6 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 89 7 profit profit NN www-bis-org-8025 89 8 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 89 9 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 89 10 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 89 11 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 89 12 institutions institution NNS www-bis-org-8025 89 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 89 14 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 89 15 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 89 16 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 89 17 tragedy tragedy NN www-bis-org-8025 89 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 89 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 89 20 commons common NNS www-bis-org-8025 89 21 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 89 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 89 23 frequently frequently RB www-bis-org-8025 89 24 encountered encounter VBN www-bis-org-8025 89 25 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 89 26 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 89 27 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 89 28 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 89 29 individuals individual NNS www-bis-org-8025 89 30 try try VBP www-bis-org-8025 89 31 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 89 32 reap reap VB www-bis-org-8025 89 33 benefits benefit NNS www-bis-org-8025 89 34 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 89 35 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 89 36 commonly commonly RB www-bis-org-8025 89 37 accessible accessible JJ www-bis-org-8025 89 38 resource resource NN www-bis-org-8025 89 39 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 89 40 fixed fix VBN www-bis-org-8025 89 41 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 89 42 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 89 43 taking take VBG www-bis-org-8025 89 44 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 89 45 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 89 46 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 89 47 effect effect NN www-bis-org-8025 89 48 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 89 49 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 89 50 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 89 51 consumption consumption NN www-bis-org-8025 89 52 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 89 53 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 89 54 well well NN www-bis-org-8025 89 55 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 89 56 being being NN www-bis-org-8025 89 57 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 89 58 others other NNS www-bis-org-8025 89 59 . . . www-bis-org-8025 90 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 90 2 name name NN www-bis-org-8025 90 3 originates originate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 90 4 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 90 5 over over RB www-bis-org-8025 90 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 90 7 grazing grazing NN www-bis-org-8025 90 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 90 9 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 90 10 land land NN www-bis-org-8025 90 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 90 12 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 90 13 Lloyd Lloyd NNP www-bis-org-8025 90 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 90 15 1833 1833 CD www-bis-org-8025 90 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 90 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 90 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 91 1 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 91 2 Note note NN www-bis-org-8025 91 3 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 91 4 Huberman Huberman NNP www-bis-org-8025 91 5 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 91 6 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 91 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 91 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 91 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 91 10 examine examine VB www-bis-org-8025 91 11 congestion congestion NN www-bis-org-8025 91 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 91 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 91 14 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 91 15 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 91 16 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 91 17 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 91 18 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 91 19 assuming assume VBG www-bis-org-8025 91 20 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 91 21 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 91 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 91 23 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 91 24 resources resource NNS www-bis-org-8025 91 25 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 91 26 sufficient sufficient JJ www-bis-org-8025 91 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 91 28 guarantee guarantee VB www-bis-org-8025 91 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 91 30 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 91 31 's 's POS www-bis-org-8025 91 32 reliability reliability NN www-bis-org-8025 91 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 91 34 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 91 35 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 91 36 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 91 37 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 91 38 p p NNP www-bis-org-8025 91 39 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 91 40 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 91 41 , , , www-bis-org-8025 91 42 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 91 43 focus focus NN www-bis-org-8025 91 44 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 91 45 similar similar JJ www-bis-org-8025 91 46 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 91 47 Easley Easley NNP www-bis-org-8025 91 48 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 91 49 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 91 50 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 91 51 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 91 52 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 91 53 . . . www-bis-org-8025 92 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 92 2 contrast contrast NN www-bis-org-8025 92 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 92 4 Budish Budish NNP www-bis-org-8025 92 5 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 92 6 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 92 7 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 92 8 examines examine VBZ www-bis-org-8025 92 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 92 10 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 92 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 92 12 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 92 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 92 14 ie ie IN www-bis-org-8025 92 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 92 16 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 92 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 92 18 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 92 19 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 92 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 92 21 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 92 22 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 92 23 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 92 24 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 92 25 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 92 26 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 92 27 determined determine VBN www-bis-org-8025 92 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 93 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 93 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 93 3 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 93 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 93 5 I -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 93 6 combine combine VBP www-bis-org-8025 93 7 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 93 8 approaches approach NNS www-bis-org-8025 93 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 93 10 show show VB www-bis-org-8025 93 11 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 93 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 93 13 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 93 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 93 15 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 93 16 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 93 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 93 18 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 93 19 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 93 20 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 93 21 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 93 22 interact interact VBP www-bis-org-8025 93 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 93 24 ie ie VBZ www-bis-org-8025 93 25 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 93 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 93 27 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 93 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 93 29 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 93 30 determines determine VBZ www-bis-org-8025 93 31 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 93 32 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 93 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 93 34 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 93 35 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 93 36 implies imply VBZ www-bis-org-8025 93 37 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 93 38 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 93 39 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 93 40 liquidity liquidity NN www-bis-org-8025 93 41 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 93 42 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 93 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 94 1 8 8 CD www-bis-org-8025 94 2 Other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 94 3 proposals proposal NNS www-bis-org-8025 94 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 94 5 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 94 6 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 94 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 94 8 delegated delegate VBD www-bis-org-8025 94 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 94 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 94 11 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 94 12 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 94 13 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 94 14 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 94 15 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 94 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 94 17 importance importance NN www-bis-org-8025 94 18 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 94 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 94 20 directly directly RB www-bis-org-8025 94 21 aim aim VBP www-bis-org-8025 94 22 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 94 23 implementing implement VBG www-bis-org-8025 94 24 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 94 25 institutionalisation institutionalisation NN www-bis-org-8025 94 26 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 94 27 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 94 28 variety variety NN www-bis-org-8025 94 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 94 30 voting voting NN www-bis-org-8025 94 31 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-bis-org-8025 94 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 95 1 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 95 2 Certainly certainly RB www-bis-org-8025 95 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 95 4 above above IN www-bis-org-8025 95 5 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 95 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 95 7 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 95 8 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 95 9 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 95 10 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 95 11 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 95 12 day day NN www-bis-org-8025 95 13 become become VB www-bis-org-8025 95 14 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 95 15 economically economically RB www-bis-org-8025 95 16 efficient efficient JJ www-bis-org-8025 95 17 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 95 18 means mean NNS www-bis-org-8025 95 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 95 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 95 21 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 95 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 95 23 ethical ethical JJ www-bis-org-8025 95 24 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 95 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 95 26 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 95 27 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 95 28 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 95 29 actually actually RB www-bis-org-8025 95 30 desirable desirable JJ www-bis-org-8025 95 31 remains remain NNS www-bis-org-8025 95 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 96 1 Given give VBN www-bis-org-8025 96 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 96 3 impossibility impossibility NN www-bis-org-8025 96 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 96 5 dealing deal VBG www-bis-org-8025 96 6 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 96 7 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 96 8 issue issue NN www-bis-org-8025 96 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 96 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 96 11 few few JJ www-bis-org-8025 96 12 pages page NNS www-bis-org-8025 96 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 96 14 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 96 15 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 96 16 sidesteps sidestep VBZ www-bis-org-8025 96 17 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 96 18 entirely entirely RB www-bis-org-8025 96 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 97 1 One one CD www-bis-org-8025 97 2 aspect aspect NN www-bis-org-8025 97 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 97 4 illicit illicit JJ www-bis-org-8025 97 5 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 97 6 . . . www-bis-org-8025 98 1 Landau Landau NNS www-bis-org-8025 98 2 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 98 3 Genais Genais NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 5 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 98 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 98 8 Auer Auer NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 98 10 Claessens Claessens NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 12 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 98 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 98 14 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 98 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 98 17 Clayton Clayton NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 19 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 98 20 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 98 22 Fanusie Fanusie NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 98 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 98 25 Robinson Robinson NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 26 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 27 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 98 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 29 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 98 30 Foley Foley NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 31 et et FW www-bis-org-8025 98 32 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 33 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 34 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 98 35 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 98 36 discuss discuss VBP www-bis-org-8025 98 37 cases case NNS www-bis-org-8025 98 38 where where WRB www-bis-org-8025 98 39 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 98 40 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 98 41 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 98 42 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 98 43 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 98 44 illicit illicit JJ www-bis-org-8025 98 45 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 98 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 99 1 Another another DT www-bis-org-8025 99 2 aspect aspect NN www-bis-org-8025 99 3 regards regard VBZ www-bis-org-8025 99 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 99 5 macroeconomic macroeconomic JJ www-bis-org-8025 99 6 implications implication NNS www-bis-org-8025 99 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 99 8 privately privately RB www-bis-org-8025 99 9 issued issue VBN www-bis-org-8025 99 10 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 99 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 12 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 99 13 Amihud Amihud NNP www-bis-org-8025 99 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 99 15 Cukierman Cukierman NNP www-bis-org-8025 99 16 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 17 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 99 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 99 20 Fernández Fernández NNP www-bis-org-8025 99 21 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 99 22 Villaverde Villaverde NNP www-bis-org-8025 99 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 99 24 Sanches Sanches NNP www-bis-org-8025 99 25 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 26 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 99 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 99 29 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 99 30 Schilling Schilling NNP www-bis-org-8025 99 31 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 99 32 Uhlig Uhlig NNP www-bis-org-8025 99 33 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 34 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 99 35 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 36 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 99 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 99 38 implications implication NNS www-bis-org-8025 99 39 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 99 40 currency currency NN www-bis-org-8025 99 41 competition competition NN www-bis-org-8025 99 42 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 99 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 100 1 http://www.bis.org/ http://www.bis.org/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 100 2 WP765 wp765 NN www-bis-org-8025 100 3 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 100 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 100 5 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 100 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 100 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 100 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 100 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 100 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 100 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 100 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 100 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 100 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 100 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 100 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 100 17 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 100 18 highlighted highlight VBN www-bis-org-8025 100 19 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 100 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 100 21 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 100 22 same same JJ www-bis-org-8025 100 23 algebra algebra NN www-bis-org-8025 100 24 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 100 25 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 100 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 100 27 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 100 28 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 100 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 100 30 pure pure JJ www-bis-org-8025 100 31 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 100 32 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 100 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 100 34 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 100 35 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 100 36 . . . www-bis-org-8025 101 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 101 2 point point NN www-bis-org-8025 101 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 101 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 101 5 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 101 6 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 101 7 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 101 8 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 101 9 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 101 10 greatly greatly RB www-bis-org-8025 101 11 improved improve VBN www-bis-org-8025 101 12 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 101 13 introducing introduce VBG www-bis-org-8025 101 14 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 101 15 institutional institutional JJ www-bis-org-8025 101 16 underpinning underpinning NN www-bis-org-8025 101 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 101 18 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 101 19 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 101 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 101 21 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 101 22 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 101 23 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 101 24 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 101 25 occur occur VB www-bis-org-8025 101 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 102 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 102 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 102 3 light light NN www-bis-org-8025 102 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 102 5 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 102 6 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 102 7 question question NN www-bis-org-8025 102 8 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 102 9 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 102 10 research research NN www-bis-org-8025 102 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 102 12 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 102 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 102 14 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 102 15 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 102 16 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 102 17 supported support VBN www-bis-org-8025 102 18 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 102 19 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 102 20 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 102 21 complement complement VB www-bis-org-8025 102 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 102 23 existing exist VBG www-bis-org-8025 102 24 monetary monetary JJ www-bis-org-8025 102 25 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 102 26 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 102 27 infrastructure infrastructure NN www-bis-org-8025 102 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 103 1 Technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 103 2 basics basic NNS www-bis-org-8025 103 3 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 103 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 103 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 103 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 103 7 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 103 8 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 103 9 section section NN www-bis-org-8025 103 10 starts start VBZ www-bis-org-8025 103 11 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 103 12 giving give VBG www-bis-org-8025 103 13 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 103 14 overview overview NN www-bis-org-8025 103 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 103 16 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 103 17 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 103 18 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 103 19 work work VBP www-bis-org-8025 103 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 104 1 It -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 104 2 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 104 3 zooms zoom VBZ www-bis-org-8025 104 4 in in RP www-bis-org-8025 104 5 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 104 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 104 7 basic basic JJ www-bis-org-8025 104 8 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 104 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 104 10 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 104 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 104 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 104 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 104 14 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 104 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 104 16 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 104 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 104 18 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 104 19 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 104 20 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 104 21 difficulty”.10 difficulty”.10 NNP www-bis-org-8025 104 22 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 104 23 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 104 24 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 104 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 104 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 104 27 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 104 28 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 104 29 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 104 30 : : : www-bis-org-8025 104 31 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 104 32 overview overview NN www-bis-org-8025 104 33 At at IN www-bis-org-8025 104 34 face face NN www-bis-org-8025 104 35 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 104 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 104 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 104 38 idea idea NN www-bis-org-8025 104 39 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 104 40 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 104 41 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 104 42 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 104 43 : : : www-bis-org-8025 104 44 instead instead RB www-bis-org-8025 104 45 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 104 46 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 104 47 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 104 48 centrally centrally RB www-bis-org-8025 104 49 recording record VBG www-bis-org-8025 104 50 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 104 51 , , , www-bis-org-8025 104 52 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 104 53 publicly publicly RB www-bis-org-8025 104 54 shared share VBN www-bis-org-8025 104 55 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 104 56 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 104 57 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 104 58 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 104 59 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 104 60 files file NNS www-bis-org-8025 104 61 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 104 62 records record VBZ www-bis-org-8025 104 63 successive successive JJ www-bis-org-8025 104 64 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 104 65 . . . www-bis-org-8025 105 1 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 105 2 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 105 3 depicts depict VBZ www-bis-org-8025 105 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 105 5 basic basic JJ www-bis-org-8025 105 6 concepts concept NNS www-bis-org-8025 105 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 105 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 105 9 purchase purchase NN www-bis-org-8025 105 10 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 105 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 105 12 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 105 13 ledger ledger NN www-bis-org-8025 105 14 updated update VBN www-bis-org-8025 105 15 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 105 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 105 17 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 105 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 105 19 left left JJ www-bis-org-8025 105 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 105 21 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 105 22 panel panel NN www-bis-org-8025 105 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 105 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 105 25 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 105 26 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 105 27 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 105 28 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 105 29 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 105 30 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 105 31 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 105 32 panel panel NN www-bis-org-8025 105 33 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 105 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 106 1 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 2 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 106 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 106 4 introductions introduction NNS www-bis-org-8025 106 5 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 106 6 economists economist NNS www-bis-org-8025 106 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 8 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 106 9 Andalfatto Andalfatto NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 11 2013 2013 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 14 Böhme Böhme NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 15 et et FW www-bis-org-8025 106 16 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 18 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 19 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 21 Athey Athey NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 22 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 23 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 25 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 26 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 28 Bolt Bolt NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 29 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 30 van van NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 31 Oordt Oordt NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 32 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 33 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 34 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 36 Bech Bech NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 37 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 38 Garrat Garrat NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 39 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 40 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 41 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 42 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 43 Catlini Catlini NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 44 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 45 Gans Gans NNPS www-bis-org-8025 106 46 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 47 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 48 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 49 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 50 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 51 Chiu Chiu NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 52 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 53 Koeppl Koeppl NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 54 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 55 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 56 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 57 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 58 Andalfatto Andalfatto NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 59 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 60 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 61 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 62 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 63 Berentsen Berentsen NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 64 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 65 Schaer Schaer NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 66 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 67 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 68 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 69 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 70 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 71 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 72 Pichler Pichler NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 73 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 74 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 75 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 76 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 77 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 78 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 79 Abadi Abadi NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 80 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 81 Brunnermeier Brunnermeier NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 82 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 83 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 84 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 85 , , , www-bis-org-8025 106 86 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 106 87 Lewis Lewis NNP www-bis-org-8025 106 88 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 89 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 106 90 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 106 91 . . . www-bis-org-8025 107 1 Making make VBG www-bis-org-8025 107 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 107 3 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 107 4 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 107 5 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 107 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 107 7 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 107 8 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 107 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 107 10 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 107 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 107 12 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 107 13 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 107 14 Centralised centralise VBN www-bis-org-8025 107 15 ledger ledger NN www-bis-org-8025 107 16 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 107 17 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 107 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 107 19 Distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 107 20 ledger ledger RB www-bis-org-8025 107 21 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 107 22 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 107 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 107 24 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 107 25 buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 107 26 purchases purchase VBZ www-bis-org-8025 107 27 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 107 28 good good NN www-bis-org-8025 107 29 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 107 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 107 31 seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 107 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 107 33 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 107 34 initiates initiate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 107 35 shipment shipment NN www-bis-org-8025 107 36 upon upon IN www-bis-org-8025 107 37 perceived perceive VBN www-bis-org-8025 107 38 confirmation confirmation NN www-bis-org-8025 107 39 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 107 40 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 107 41 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 107 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 108 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 108 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 108 3 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 108 4 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 108 5 place place NN www-bis-org-8025 108 6 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 108 7 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 108 8 accounts account NNS www-bis-org-8025 108 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 108 10 left left JJ www-bis-org-8025 108 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 108 12 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 108 13 panel panel NN www-bis-org-8025 108 14 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 108 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 108 16 buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 108 17 sends send VBZ www-bis-org-8025 108 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 108 19 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 108 20 instruction instruction NN www-bis-org-8025 108 21 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 108 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 108 23 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 108 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 108 25 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 108 26 adjusts adjust VBZ www-bis-org-8025 108 27 account account VBP www-bis-org-8025 108 28 balances balance NNS www-bis-org-8025 108 29 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 108 30 debiting debit VBG www-bis-org-8025 108 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 108 32 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 108 33 paid pay VBN www-bis-org-8025 108 34 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 108 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 108 36 buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 108 37 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 108 38 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 108 39 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 108 40 crediting credit VBG www-bis-org-8025 108 41 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 108 42 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 108 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 108 44 seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 108 45 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 108 46 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 108 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 109 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 109 2 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 109 3 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 109 4 confirms confirm VBZ www-bis-org-8025 109 5 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 109 6 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 109 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 109 8 seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 109 9 . . . www-bis-org-8025 110 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 110 2 contrast contrast NN www-bis-org-8025 110 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 110 4 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 110 5 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 110 6 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 110 7 place place NN www-bis-org-8025 110 8 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 110 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 110 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 110 11 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 110 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 110 13 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 110 14 panel panel NN www-bis-org-8025 110 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 110 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 110 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 110 18 buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 110 19 first first RB www-bis-org-8025 110 20 publicly publicly RB www-bis-org-8025 110 21 announces announce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 110 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 110 23 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 110 24 instruction instruction NN www-bis-org-8025 110 25 stating state VBG www-bis-org-8025 110 26 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 110 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 110 28 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 110 29 holdings holding NNS www-bis-org-8025 110 30 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 110 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 110 32 buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 110 33 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 110 34 reduced reduce VBN www-bis-org-8025 110 35 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 110 36 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 110 37 , , , www-bis-org-8025 110 38 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 110 39 those those DT www-bis-org-8025 110 40 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 110 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 110 42 seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 110 43 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 110 44 increased increase VBN www-bis-org-8025 110 45 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 110 46 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 110 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 111 1 After after IN www-bis-org-8025 111 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 111 3 delay delay NN www-bis-org-8025 111 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 111 5 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 111 6 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 111 7 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 111 8 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 111 9 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 111 10 includes include VBZ www-bis-org-8025 111 11 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 111 12 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 111 13 information information NN www-bis-org-8025 111 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 111 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 111 16 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 111 17 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 111 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 111 19 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 111 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 111 21 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 111 22 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 111 23 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 111 24 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 111 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 111 26 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 111 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 112 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 112 2 updated updated JJ www-bis-org-8025 112 3 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 112 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 112 5 subsequently subsequently RB www-bis-org-8025 112 6 shared share VBN www-bis-org-8025 112 7 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 112 8 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 112 9 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 112 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 112 11 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 112 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 112 13 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 112 14 verifying verify VBG www-bis-org-8025 112 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 112 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 112 17 newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 112 18 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 112 19 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 112 20 instruction instruction NN www-bis-org-8025 112 21 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 112 22 authorised authorise VBN www-bis-org-8025 112 23 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 112 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 112 25 buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 112 26 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 112 27 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 112 28 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 112 29 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 112 30 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 112 31 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 112 32 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 112 33 attempt attempt NN www-bis-org-8025 112 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 113 1 Finally finally RB www-bis-org-8025 113 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 113 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 113 4 seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 113 5 observes observe VBZ www-bis-org-8025 113 6 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 113 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 113 8 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 113 9 including include VBG www-bis-org-8025 113 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 113 11 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 113 12 instruction instruction NN www-bis-org-8025 113 13 emerges emerge VBZ www-bis-org-8025 113 14 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 113 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 113 16 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 113 17 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 113 18 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 113 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 113 20 entire entire JJ www-bis-org-8025 113 21 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 113 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 113 23 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 113 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 113 25 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 113 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 114 1 Source source NN www-bis-org-8025 114 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 114 3 Author author NN www-bis-org-8025 114 4 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 114 5 elaboration elaboration NN www-bis-org-8025 114 6 . . . www-bis-org-8025 115 1 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 2 Buyer Buyer NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 3 authorises authorise VBZ www-bis-org-8025 115 4 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 115 5 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 6 informs inform VBZ www-bis-org-8025 115 7 seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 115 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 115 9 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 115 10 Buyer Buyer NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 11 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 115 12 balance balance NN www-bis-org-8025 115 13 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 115 14 – – : www-bis-org-8025 115 15 Seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 115 16 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 115 17 balance balance NN www-bis-org-8025 115 18 +1 +1 VBZ www-bis-org-8025 115 19 $ $ $ www-bis-org-8025 115 20 Ship ship NN www-bis-org-8025 115 21 goods good NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 22 Buyer Buyer NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 23 announces announce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 115 24 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 115 25 Blockchain Blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 26 update update NN www-bis-org-8025 115 27 : : : www-bis-org-8025 115 28 Buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 115 29 holdings holding NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 30 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 115 31 – – : www-bis-org-8025 115 32 Seller seller NN www-bis-org-8025 115 33 holdings holding NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 34 +1 +1 NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 35 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 36 Sees see VBZ www-bis-org-8025 115 37 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 115 38 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 115 39 Multiple multiple JJ www-bis-org-8025 115 40 verifications verification NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 41 Ship Ship NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 42 goods good NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 43 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 44 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 45 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 46 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 47 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 48 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 49 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 50 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 51 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 52 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 53 mailto:Robert.McCauley@bis.org mailto:Robert.McCauley@bis.org NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 54 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 115 55 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 56 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 115 57 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 115 58 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 59 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 60 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 115 61 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 115 62 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 115 63 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 115 64 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 115 65 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 115 66 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 115 67 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 115 68 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 115 69 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 115 70 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 115 71 more more JJR www-bis-org-8025 115 72 detail detail NN www-bis-org-8025 115 73 , , , www-bis-org-8025 115 74 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 115 75 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 115 76 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 115 77 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 115 78 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 115 79 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 115 80 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 115 81 side side NN www-bis-org-8025 115 82 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 115 83 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 115 84 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 115 85 plays play VBZ www-bis-org-8025 115 86 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 115 87 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 115 88 follows follow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 115 89 : : : www-bis-org-8025 115 90 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 115 91 . . . www-bis-org-8025 116 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 116 2 buyer buyer NN www-bis-org-8025 116 3 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 116 4 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 116 5 cryptographic cryptographic JJ www-bis-org-8025 116 6 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 116 7 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 116 8 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 116 9 publicly publicly RB www-bis-org-8025 116 10 announces announce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 116 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 116 12 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 116 13 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 116 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 116 15 including include VBG www-bis-org-8025 116 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 116 17 payee payee NN www-bis-org-8025 116 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 116 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 116 20 paid pay VBN www-bis-org-8025 116 21 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 116 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 116 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 116 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 116 25 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 116 26 fee fee VBP www-bis-org-8025 116 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 116 28 payer payer NN www-bis-org-8025 116 29 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 116 30 willing willing JJ www-bis-org-8025 116 31 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 116 32 pay pay VB www-bis-org-8025 116 33 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 116 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 116 35 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 116 36 . . . www-bis-org-8025 117 1 2 2 LS www-bis-org-8025 117 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 118 1 Miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 118 2 select select VBP www-bis-org-8025 118 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 118 4 unprocessed unprocessed JJ www-bis-org-8025 118 5 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 118 6 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 118 7 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 118 8 maximise maximise VB www-bis-org-8025 118 9 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 118 10 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 118 11 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 118 12 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 118 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 118 14 engage engage VB www-bis-org-8025 118 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 118 16 computations computation NNS www-bis-org-8025 118 17 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 118 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 118 19 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 118 20 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 118 21 emerges emerge VBZ www-bis-org-8025 118 22 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 118 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 118 24 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 118 25 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 118 26 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 118 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 118 28 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 118 29 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 118 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 119 1 3 3 LS www-bis-org-8025 119 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 120 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 120 2 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 120 3 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 120 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 120 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 120 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 120 7 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 120 8 allows allow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 120 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 120 10 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 120 11 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 120 12 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 120 13 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 120 14 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 120 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 120 16 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 120 17 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 120 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 120 19 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 120 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 120 21 collecting collect VBG www-bis-org-8025 120 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 120 23 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 120 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 120 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 120 26 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 120 27 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 120 28 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 120 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 120 30 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 120 31 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 120 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 121 1 4 4 LS www-bis-org-8025 121 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 122 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 122 2 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 122 3 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 122 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 122 5 shared share VBN www-bis-org-8025 122 6 among among IN www-bis-org-8025 122 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 122 8 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 122 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 122 10 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 122 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 122 12 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 122 13 uses use NNS www-bis-org-8025 122 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 122 15 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 122 16 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 122 17 verify verify VBP www-bis-org-8025 122 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 122 19 update update NN www-bis-org-8025 122 20 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 122 21 verify verify VB www-bis-org-8025 122 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 122 23 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 122 24 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 122 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 122 26 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 122 27 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 122 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 122 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 122 30 signatures signature NNS www-bis-org-8025 122 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 122 32 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 122 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 122 34 absence absence NN www-bis-org-8025 122 35 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 122 36 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 122 37 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 122 38 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 122 39 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 122 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 123 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 123 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 123 3 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 123 4 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 123 5 emerges emerge VBZ www-bis-org-8025 123 6 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 123 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 123 8 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 123 9 version version NN www-bis-org-8025 123 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 123 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 123 12 majority majority NN www-bis-org-8025 123 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 123 14 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 123 15 keep keep VBP www-bis-org-8025 123 16 on on RP www-bis-org-8025 123 17 adding add VBG www-bis-org-8025 123 18 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 123 19 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 123 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 124 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 124 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 124 3 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 124 4 steps step NNS www-bis-org-8025 124 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 124 6 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 124 7 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 124 8 owner owner NN www-bis-org-8025 124 9 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 124 10 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 124 11 able able JJ www-bis-org-8025 124 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 124 13 spend spend VB www-bis-org-8025 124 14 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 124 15 funds fund NNS www-bis-org-8025 124 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 124 17 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 124 18 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 124 19 once once RB www-bis-org-8025 124 20 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 124 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 125 1 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 125 2 Cryptographic cryptographic JJ www-bis-org-8025 125 3 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 125 4 signatures signature NNS www-bis-org-8025 125 5 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 125 6 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 125 7 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 125 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 125 9 verify verify VB www-bis-org-8025 125 10 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 125 11 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 125 12 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 125 13 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 125 14 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 125 15 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 125 16 pays pay VBZ www-bis-org-8025 125 17 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 125 18 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 125 19 S. S. NNP www-bis-org-8025 125 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 125 21 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 125 22 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 125 23 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 125 24 proves prove VBZ www-bis-org-8025 125 25 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 125 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 125 27 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 125 28 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 125 29 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 125 30 authorised authorise VBN www-bis-org-8025 125 31 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 125 32 whoever whoever WP www-bis-org-8025 125 33 controls control VBZ www-bis-org-8025 125 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 125 35 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 125 36 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 125 37 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 125 38 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 125 39 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 125 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 126 1 That that DT www-bis-org-8025 126 2 leaves leave VBZ www-bis-org-8025 126 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 126 4 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 126 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 126 6 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 126 7 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 126 8 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 126 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 126 10 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 126 11 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 126 12 occur occur VB www-bis-org-8025 126 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 126 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 126 15 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 126 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 126 17 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 126 18 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 126 19 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 126 20 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 126 21 simultaneously simultaneously RB www-bis-org-8025 126 22 broadcast broadcast VB www-bis-org-8025 126 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 126 24 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 126 25 instructions instruction NNS www-bis-org-8025 126 26 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 126 27 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 126 28 pays pay VBZ www-bis-org-8025 126 29 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 126 30 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 126 31 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 126 32 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 126 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 126 34 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 126 35 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 126 36 pays pay VBZ www-bis-org-8025 126 37 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 126 38 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 126 39 Y Y NNP www-bis-org-8025 126 40 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 126 41 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 126 42 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 126 43 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 126 44 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 126 45 same same JJ www-bis-org-8025 126 46 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 126 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 127 1 Because because IN www-bis-org-8025 127 2 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 127 3 uses use VBZ www-bis-org-8025 127 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 127 5 correct correct JJ www-bis-org-8025 127 6 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 127 7 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 127 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 127 9 sign sign VB www-bis-org-8025 127 10 both both DT www-bis-org-8025 127 11 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 127 12 messages message NNS www-bis-org-8025 127 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 127 14 both both DT www-bis-org-8025 127 15 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 127 16 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 127 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 128 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 128 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 128 3 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 128 4 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 128 5 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 128 6 compromised compromise VBN www-bis-org-8025 128 7 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 128 8 both both DT www-bis-org-8025 128 9 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 128 10 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 128 11 entered enter VBN www-bis-org-8025 128 12 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 128 13 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 128 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 128 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 128 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 128 17 way way NN www-bis-org-8025 128 18 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 128 19 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 128 20 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 128 21 found find VBN www-bis-org-8025 128 22 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 128 23 stop stop VB www-bis-org-8025 128 24 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 128 25 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 128 26 happening happen VBG www-bis-org-8025 128 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 129 1 One one CD www-bis-org-8025 129 2 part part NN www-bis-org-8025 129 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 129 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 129 5 solution solution NN www-bis-org-8025 129 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 129 7 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 129 8 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 129 9 check check VBP www-bis-org-8025 129 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 129 11 public public NNP www-bis-org-8025 129 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 129 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 129 14 verifying verify VBG www-bis-org-8025 129 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 129 16 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 129 17 counterparties counterpartie NNS www-bis-org-8025 129 18 actually actually RB www-bis-org-8025 129 19 own own VBP www-bis-org-8025 129 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 129 21 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 129 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 129 23 funds fund NNS www-bis-org-8025 129 24 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 129 25 claim claim VBP www-bis-org-8025 129 26 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 129 27 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 129 28 transferring transfer VBG www-bis-org-8025 129 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 130 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 130 2 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 130 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 130 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 130 5 crucial crucial JJ www-bis-org-8025 130 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 130 7 part part NN www-bis-org-8025 130 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 130 9 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 130 10 algorithm algorithm NN www-bis-org-8025 130 11 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 130 12 incentivises incentivise VBZ www-bis-org-8025 130 13 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 130 14 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 130 15 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 130 16 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 130 17 correct correct JJ www-bis-org-8025 130 18 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 130 19 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 130 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 130 21 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 130 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 131 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 131 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 131 3 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 131 4 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 131 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 131 6 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 131 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 131 8 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 131 9 reputation reputation NN www-bis-org-8025 131 10 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 131 11 lose lose VB www-bis-org-8025 131 12 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 131 13 laws law NNS www-bis-org-8025 131 14 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 131 15 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 131 16 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 131 17 enforced enforce VBN www-bis-org-8025 131 18 easily easily RB www-bis-org-8025 131 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 132 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 132 2 risk risk NN www-bis-org-8025 132 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 132 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 132 5 counterfeiters counterfeiter NNS www-bis-org-8025 132 6 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 132 7 spend spend VB www-bis-org-8025 132 8 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 132 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 132 10 simultaneously simultaneously RB www-bis-org-8025 132 11 disseminate disseminate VBP www-bis-org-8025 132 12 fake fake JJ www-bis-org-8025 132 13 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 132 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 132 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 132 16 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 132 17 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 132 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 132 19 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 132 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 132 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 132 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 132 23 hope hope NN www-bis-org-8025 132 24 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 132 25 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 132 26 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 132 27 accept accept VB www-bis-org-8025 132 28 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 132 29 fake fake JJ www-bis-org-8025 132 30 blockchain blockchain JJ www-bis-org-8025 132 31 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 132 32 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 132 33 transfer transfer VB www-bis-org-8025 132 34 goods good NNS www-bis-org-8025 132 35 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 132 36 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 132 37 counterfeiters counterfeiter NNS www-bis-org-8025 132 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 133 1 Hence hence RB www-bis-org-8025 133 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 133 3 updating update VBG www-bis-org-8025 133 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 133 5 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 133 6 must must MD www-bis-org-8025 133 7 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 133 8 expensive expensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 133 9 enough enough RB www-bis-org-8025 133 10 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 133 11 deter deter VB www-bis-org-8025 133 12 fake fake JJ www-bis-org-8025 133 13 updating update VBG www-bis-org-8025 133 14 attempts attempt NNS www-bis-org-8025 133 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 134 1 Yet yet CC www-bis-org-8025 134 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 134 3 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 134 4 updating update VBG www-bis-org-8025 134 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 134 6 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 134 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 134 8 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 134 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 134 10 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 134 11 must must MD www-bis-org-8025 134 12 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 134 13 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 134 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 134 15 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 134 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 134 17 place place NN www-bis-org-8025 134 18 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 134 19 incentivise incentivise VB www-bis-org-8025 134 20 truthful truthful JJ www-bis-org-8025 134 21 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 134 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 135 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 135 2 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 135 3 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 135 4 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 135 5 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 135 6 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 135 7 creating create VBG www-bis-org-8025 135 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 135 9 class class NN www-bis-org-8025 135 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 135 11 agents agent NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 12 known know VBN www-bis-org-8025 135 13 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 135 14 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 135 16 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 135 17 update update VBP www-bis-org-8025 135 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 135 19 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 135 20 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 135 21 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 135 22 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 135 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 135 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 135 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 135 26 return return NN www-bis-org-8025 135 27 receive receive JJ www-bis-org-8025 135 28 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 135 29 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 30 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 135 31 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 135 32 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 33 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 135 34 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 135 35 add add VBP www-bis-org-8025 135 36 batches batch NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 37 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 135 38 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 135 39 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 40 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 135 41 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 135 42 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 43 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 135 44 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 135 45 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 135 46 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 135 47 blockchain.11 blockchain.11 NNP www-bis-org-8025 135 48 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 135 49 3 3 NNP www-bis-org-8025 135 50 gives give VBZ www-bis-org-8025 135 51 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 135 52 schematic schematic JJ www-bis-org-8025 135 53 overview overview NN www-bis-org-8025 135 54 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 135 55 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 135 56 resulting result VBG www-bis-org-8025 135 57 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 135 58 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 135 59 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 135 60 main main JJ www-bis-org-8025 135 61 elements element NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 62 : : : www-bis-org-8025 135 63 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 135 64 publicly publicly RB www-bis-org-8025 135 65 available available JJ www-bis-org-8025 135 66 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 135 67 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 135 68 updated update VBN www-bis-org-8025 135 69 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 135 70 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 71 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 135 72 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 135 73 . . . www-bis-org-8025 136 1 Each each DT www-bis-org-8025 136 2 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 136 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 136 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 136 5 small small JJ www-bis-org-8025 136 6 file file NN www-bis-org-8025 136 7 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 136 8 includes include VBZ www-bis-org-8025 136 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 136 10 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 136 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 136 12 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 136 13 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 136 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 136 15 stating state VBG www-bis-org-8025 136 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 136 17 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 136 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 136 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 136 20 payer payer NN www-bis-org-8025 136 21 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 136 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 136 23 payee payee NN www-bis-org-8025 136 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 137 1 Blocks Blocks NNP www-bis-org-8025 137 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 137 3 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 137 4 turn turn NN www-bis-org-8025 137 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 137 6 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 137 7 chained chain VBN www-bis-org-8025 137 8 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 137 9 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 137 10 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 137 11 sequentially sequentially RB www-bis-org-8025 137 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 137 13 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 137 14 forming form VBG www-bis-org-8025 137 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 137 16 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 137 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 138 1 11 11 CD www-bis-org-8025 138 2 Miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 138 3 face face VBP www-bis-org-8025 138 4 strong strong JJ www-bis-org-8025 138 5 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 138 6 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 138 7 check check VB www-bis-org-8025 138 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 138 9 validity validity NN www-bis-org-8025 138 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 138 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 138 12 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 138 13 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 138 14 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 138 15 include include VBP www-bis-org-8025 138 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 138 17 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 138 18 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 138 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 138 20 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 138 21 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 138 22 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 138 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 138 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 138 25 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 138 26 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 138 27 turns turn VBZ www-bis-org-8025 138 28 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 138 29 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 138 30 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 138 31 invalid invalid JJ www-bis-org-8025 138 32 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 138 33 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 138 34 either either CC www-bis-org-8025 138 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 138 36 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 138 37 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 138 38 invalid invalid JJ www-bis-org-8025 138 39 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 138 40 somebody somebody NN www-bis-org-8025 138 41 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 138 42 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 138 43 funds fund NNS www-bis-org-8025 138 44 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 138 45 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 138 46 do do VBP www-bis-org-8025 138 47 n’t not RB www-bis-org-8025 138 48 actually actually RB www-bis-org-8025 138 49 own own VB www-bis-org-8025 138 50 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 138 51 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 138 52 entire entire JJ www-bis-org-8025 138 53 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 138 54 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 138 55 invalid invalid JJ www-bis-org-8025 138 56 , , , www-bis-org-8025 138 57 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 138 58 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 138 59 invalidating invalidate VBG www-bis-org-8025 138 60 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 138 61 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 138 62 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 138 63 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 138 64 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 138 65 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 138 66 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 138 67 . . . www-bis-org-8025 139 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 139 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 139 3 validation validation NN www-bis-org-8025 139 4 itself -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 139 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 139 6 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 139 7 computationally computationally RB www-bis-org-8025 139 8 intensive intensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 139 9 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 139 10 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 139 11 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 139 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 139 13 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 139 14 effort effort NN www-bis-org-8025 139 15 involved involve VBN www-bis-org-8025 139 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 139 17 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 139 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 139 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 139 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 139 21 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 139 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 140 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 140 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 140 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 140 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 140 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 140 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 140 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 140 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 140 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 140 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 140 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 140 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 140 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 140 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 140 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 140 16 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 140 17 Proof Proof NNP www-bis-org-8025 140 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 140 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 140 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 140 21 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 140 22 : : : www-bis-org-8025 140 23 rolling roll VBG www-bis-org-8025 140 24 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 140 25 dice dice NN www-bis-org-8025 140 26 Proof Proof NNP www-bis-org-8025 140 27 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 140 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 140 29 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 140 30 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 140 31 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 140 32 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 140 33 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 140 34 cryptographic cryptographic JJ www-bis-org-8025 140 35 tool tool NN www-bis-org-8025 140 36 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 140 37 allows allow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 140 38 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 140 39 send send VB www-bis-org-8025 140 40 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 140 41 credible credible JJ www-bis-org-8025 140 42 signal signal NN www-bis-org-8025 140 43 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 140 44 others other NNS www-bis-org-8025 140 45 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 140 46 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 140 47 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 140 48 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 140 49 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 140 50 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 140 51 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 140 52 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 140 53 wasted waste VBN www-bis-org-8025 140 54 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 140 55 electricity electricity NN www-bis-org-8025 140 56 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 140 57 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 140 58 . . . www-bis-org-8025 141 1 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 141 2 analogy analogy NN www-bis-org-8025 141 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 141 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 141 5 dice dice NN www-bis-org-8025 141 6 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 141 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 141 8 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 141 9 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 141 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 141 11 sides side NNS www-bis-org-8025 141 12 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 141 13 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 141 14 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 141 15 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 141 16 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 141 17 probability probability NN www-bis-org-8025 141 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 141 19 coming come VBG www-bis-org-8025 141 20 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 141 21 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 141 22 top top NN www-bis-org-8025 141 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 142 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 142 2 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 142 3 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 142 4 1,000 1,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 142 5 sides side NNS www-bis-org-8025 142 6 numbered number VBN www-bis-org-8025 142 7 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 142 8 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 142 9 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 142 10 1,000 1,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 142 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 142 12 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 142 13 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 142 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 142 15 one one PRP www-bis-org-8025 142 16 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 142 17 have have VB www-bis-org-8025 142 18 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 142 19 roll roll VB www-bis-org-8025 142 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 142 21 dice dice NN www-bis-org-8025 142 22 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 142 23 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 142 24 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 142 25 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 142 26 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 142 27 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 142 28 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 142 29 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 142 30 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 142 31 comes come VBZ www-bis-org-8025 142 32 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 142 33 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 142 34 top top NN www-bis-org-8025 142 35 . . . www-bis-org-8025 143 1 Showing show VBG www-bis-org-8025 143 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 143 3 dice dice NN www-bis-org-8025 143 4 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 143 5 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 143 6 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 143 7 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 143 8 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 143 9 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 143 10 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 143 11 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 143 12 top top NN www-bis-org-8025 143 13 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 143 14 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 143 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 143 16 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 143 17 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 143 18 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 143 19 likelihood likelihood NN www-bis-org-8025 143 20 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 143 21 rolled roll VBN www-bis-org-8025 143 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 143 23 dice dice NN www-bis-org-8025 143 24 about about RB www-bis-org-8025 143 25 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 143 26 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 143 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 144 1 Proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 144 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 144 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 144 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 144 5 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 144 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 144 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 144 8 mathematical mathematical JJ www-bis-org-8025 144 9 equivalent equivalent NN www-bis-org-8025 144 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 144 11 credibly credibly RB www-bis-org-8025 144 12 rolling roll VBG www-bis-org-8025 144 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 144 14 dice dice NN www-bis-org-8025 144 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 145 1 It -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 145 2 relies rely VBZ www-bis-org-8025 145 3 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 145 4 asymmetrical asymmetrical JJ www-bis-org-8025 145 5 mathematical mathematical JJ www-bis-org-8025 145 6 problems problem NNS www-bis-org-8025 145 7 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 145 8 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 145 9 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 145 10 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 145 11 difficult difficult JJ www-bis-org-8025 145 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 145 13 come come VB www-bis-org-8025 145 14 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 145 15 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 145 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 145 17 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 145 18 easy easy JJ www-bis-org-8025 145 19 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 145 20 verify verify VB www-bis-org-8025 145 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 146 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 146 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 146 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 146 4 process process NN www-bis-org-8025 146 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 146 6 hashing hash VBG www-bis-org-8025 146 7 . . . www-bis-org-8025 147 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 147 2 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 147 3 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 147 4 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 147 5 function function NN www-bis-org-8025 147 6 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 147 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 147 8 random random JJ www-bis-org-8025 147 9 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 147 10 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 147 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 147 12 produces produce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 147 13 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 147 14 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 147 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 147 16 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 147 17 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 147 18 according accord VBG www-bis-org-8025 147 19 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 147 20 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 147 21 rules.12 rules.12 NNP www-bis-org-8025 147 22 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 147 23 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 147 24 function function NN www-bis-org-8025 147 25 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 147 26 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 147 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 147 28 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 147 29 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 147 30 – – : www-bis-org-8025 147 31 known know VBN www-bis-org-8025 147 32 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 147 33 SHA256 SHA256 NNP www-bis-org-8025 147 34 – – : www-bis-org-8025 147 35 satisfies satisfy VBZ www-bis-org-8025 147 36 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 147 37 property property NN www-bis-org-8025 147 38 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 147 39 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 147 40 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 147 41 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 147 42 possible possible JJ www-bis-org-8025 147 43 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 147 44 deduce deduce VB www-bis-org-8025 147 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 147 46 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 147 47 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 147 48 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 147 49 specific specific JJ www-bis-org-8025 147 50 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 147 51 output.13 output.13 NNP www-bis-org-8025 147 52 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 147 53 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 147 54 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 147 55 , , , www-bis-org-8025 147 56 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 147 57 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 147 58 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 147 59 function function NN www-bis-org-8025 147 60 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 147 61 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 147 62 take take VB www-bis-org-8025 147 63 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 147 64 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 147 65 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 147 66 fourth fourth JJ www-bis-org-8025 147 67 letter letter NN www-bis-org-8025 147 68 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 147 69 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 147 70 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 147 71 . . . www-bis-org-8025 148 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 148 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 148 3 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 148 4 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 148 5 ABcDSEFfdfff abcdseffdfff NN www-bis-org-8025 148 6 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 148 7 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 148 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 148 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 148 10 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 148 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 148 12 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 148 13 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 148 14 function function NN www-bis-org-8025 148 15 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 148 16 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 148 17 BD BD NNP www-bis-org-8025 148 18 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 148 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 149 1 13 13 CD www-bis-org-8025 149 2 Note note VBP www-bis-org-8025 149 3 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 149 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 149 5 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 149 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 149 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 149 8 SHA256 SHA256 NNP www-bis-org-8025 149 9 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 149 10 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 149 11 guaranteed guarantee VBN www-bis-org-8025 149 12 axiomatically axiomatically RB www-bis-org-8025 149 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 150 1 Other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 150 2 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 150 3 functions function NNS www-bis-org-8025 150 4 once once RB www-bis-org-8025 150 5 thought think VBD www-bis-org-8025 150 6 safe safe JJ www-bis-org-8025 150 7 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 150 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 150 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 150 10 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 150 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 150 12 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 150 13 broken break VBN www-bis-org-8025 150 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 151 1 Cryptographically cryptographically RB www-bis-org-8025 151 2 chained chain VBN www-bis-org-8025 151 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 151 4 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 151 5 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 151 7 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 8 form form NN www-bis-org-8025 151 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 151 10 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 151 11 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 151 12 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 151 13 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 151 14 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 151 15 publicly publicly RB www-bis-org-8025 151 16 available available JJ www-bis-org-8025 151 17 ledger ledger NNP www-bis-org-8025 151 18 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 151 19 updated update VBN www-bis-org-8025 151 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 151 21 bunches bunche NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 151 23 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 151 25 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 151 26 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 151 27 update update NN www-bis-org-8025 151 28 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 151 29 termed term VBN www-bis-org-8025 151 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 151 31 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 151 32 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 151 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 151 34 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 151 35 Blocks Blocks NNP www-bis-org-8025 151 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 151 37 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 151 38 turn turn NN www-bis-org-8025 151 39 , , , www-bis-org-8025 151 40 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 151 41 chained chain VBN www-bis-org-8025 151 42 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 151 43 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 151 44 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 151 45 sequentially sequentially RB www-bis-org-8025 151 46 , , , www-bis-org-8025 151 47 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 151 48 forming form VBG www-bis-org-8025 151 49 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 151 50 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 151 51 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 151 52 . . . www-bis-org-8025 151 53 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 151 54 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 151 55 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 151 56 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 151 57 updated update VBN www-bis-org-8025 151 58 much much RB www-bis-org-8025 151 59 like like IN www-bis-org-8025 151 60 adding add VBG www-bis-org-8025 151 61 individual individual JJ www-bis-org-8025 151 62 pages page NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 63 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 151 64 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 151 65 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 66 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 151 67 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 151 68 ledger ledger NN www-bis-org-8025 151 69 , , , www-bis-org-8025 151 70 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 151 71 page page NN www-bis-org-8025 151 72 numbers number NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 73 determining determine VBG www-bis-org-8025 151 74 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 151 75 order order NN www-bis-org-8025 151 76 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 151 77 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 151 78 individual individual JJ www-bis-org-8025 151 79 pages page NNS www-bis-org-8025 151 80 . . . www-bis-org-8025 152 1 Each each DT www-bis-org-8025 152 2 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 152 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 152 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 152 5 small small JJ www-bis-org-8025 152 6 file file NN www-bis-org-8025 152 7 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 152 8 includes include VBZ www-bis-org-8025 152 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 152 10 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 152 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 152 12 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 152 13 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 152 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 152 15 stating state VBG www-bis-org-8025 152 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 152 17 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 152 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 152 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 152 20 payer payer NN www-bis-org-8025 152 21 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 152 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 152 23 payee payee NN www-bis-org-8025 152 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 152 25 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 152 26 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 152 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 152 28 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 152 29 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 152 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 153 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 153 2 original original JJ www-bis-org-8025 153 3 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 153 4 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 153 5 restricts restrict VBZ www-bis-org-8025 153 6 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 153 7 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 153 8 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 153 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 153 10 maximum maximum JJ www-bis-org-8025 153 11 file file NN www-bis-org-8025 153 12 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 153 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 153 14 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 153 15 MB mb NN www-bis-org-8025 153 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 153 17 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 153 18 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 153 19 practice practice NN www-bis-org-8025 153 20 implies imply VBZ www-bis-org-8025 153 21 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 153 22 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 153 23 2,000 2,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 153 24 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 153 25 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 153 26 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 153 27 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 153 28 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 153 29 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 153 30 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 153 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 154 1 Only only RB www-bis-org-8025 154 2 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 154 3 including include VBG www-bis-org-8025 154 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 154 5 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 154 6 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 154 7 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 154 8 associated associate VBN www-bis-org-8025 154 9 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 154 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 154 11 transferred transfer VBN www-bis-org-8025 154 12 funds fund NNS www-bis-org-8025 154 13 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 154 14 accepted accept VBN www-bis-org-8025 154 15 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 154 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 154 17 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 154 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 155 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 155 2 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 155 3 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 155 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 155 5 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 155 6 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 155 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 155 8 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 155 9 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 155 10 about about IN www-bis-org-8025 155 11 once once RB www-bis-org-8025 155 12 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 155 13 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 155 14 minutes minute NNS www-bis-org-8025 155 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 156 1 Adding add VBG www-bis-org-8025 156 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 156 3 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 156 4 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 156 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 156 6 existing exist VBG www-bis-org-8025 156 7 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 156 8 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 156 9 requires require VBZ www-bis-org-8025 156 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 156 11 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 156 12 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 156 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 156 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 156 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 156 16 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 156 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 156 18 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 156 19 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 156 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 156 21 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 156 22 nonce nonce NN www-bis-org-8025 156 23 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 156 24 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 156 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 156 26 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 156 27 involves involve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 156 28 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 156 29 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 156 30 function function NN www-bis-org-8025 156 31 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 156 32 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 156 33 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 156 34 random random JJ www-bis-org-8025 156 35 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 156 36 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 156 37 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 156 38 produces produce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 156 39 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 156 40 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 156 41 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 156 42 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 156 43 according accord VBG www-bis-org-8025 156 44 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 156 45 set set NN www-bis-org-8025 156 46 rules rule NNS www-bis-org-8025 156 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 157 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 157 2 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 157 3 property property NN www-bis-org-8025 157 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 157 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 157 6 SHA256 SHA256 NNP www-bis-org-8025 157 7 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 157 8 function function NN www-bis-org-8025 157 9 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 157 10 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 157 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 157 12 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 157 13 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 157 14 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 157 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 157 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 157 17 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 157 18 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 157 19 unpredictable unpredictable JJ www-bis-org-8025 157 20 : : : www-bis-org-8025 157 21 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 157 22 get get VB www-bis-org-8025 157 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 157 24 desired desire VBN www-bis-org-8025 157 25 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 157 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 157 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 157 28 only only JJ www-bis-org-8025 157 29 solution solution NN www-bis-org-8025 157 30 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 157 31 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 157 32 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 157 33 try try VB www-bis-org-8025 157 34 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 157 35 starting start VBG www-bis-org-8025 157 36 values value NNS www-bis-org-8025 157 37 randomly randomly RB www-bis-org-8025 157 38 , , , www-bis-org-8025 157 39 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 157 40 creates create VBZ www-bis-org-8025 157 41 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 157 42 computing computing NN www-bis-org-8025 157 43 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 157 44 . . . www-bis-org-8025 158 1 Cryptographic cryptographic JJ www-bis-org-8025 158 2 chaining chaining NN www-bis-org-8025 158 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 158 4 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 158 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 158 6 achieved achieve VBN www-bis-org-8025 158 7 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 158 8 including include VBG www-bis-org-8025 158 9 summary summary NN www-bis-org-8025 158 10 information information NN www-bis-org-8025 158 11 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 158 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 158 13 previous previous JJ www-bis-org-8025 158 14 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 158 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 158 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 158 17 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 158 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 158 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 158 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 158 21 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 158 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 158 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 158 24 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 158 25 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 158 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 159 1 Source source NN www-bis-org-8025 159 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 159 3 Author author NN www-bis-org-8025 159 4 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 159 5 elaboration elaboration NN www-bis-org-8025 159 6 . . . www-bis-org-8025 160 1 Hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 160 2 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 160 3 previous previous JJ www-bis-org-8025 160 4 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 160 5 Proof Proof NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 160 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 160 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 160 9 work/ work/ NN www-bis-org-8025 160 10 Nonce Nonce NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 11 970ba0c43 970ba0c43 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 12 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 13 2b12fcf 2b12fcf CD www-bis-org-8025 160 14 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 15 93fe37f69 93fe37f69 LS www-bis-org-8025 160 16 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 17 b09288f b09288f UH www-bis-org-8025 160 18 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 19 7cf037547 7cf037547 NN www-bis-org-8025 160 20 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 21 aff797d aff797d NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 22 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 23 8ead53e77 8ead53e77 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 24 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 25 e950e71 e950e71 NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 26 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 27 171352a4b 171352a4b NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 28 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 29 e42b91i e42b91i XX www-bis-org-8025 160 30 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 31 No no DT www-bis-org-8025 160 32 Details detail NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 33 Signatures signature VBZ www-bis-org-8025 160 34 No no DT www-bis-org-8025 160 35 Details detail NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 36 Signatures signature VBZ www-bis-org-8025 160 37 No no DT www-bis-org-8025 160 38 Details detail NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 39 Signatures signature VBZ www-bis-org-8025 160 40 No no DT www-bis-org-8025 160 41 Details detail NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 42 Signatures signature VBZ www-bis-org-8025 160 43 No no DT www-bis-org-8025 160 44 Details detail NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 45 Signatures signature NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 46 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 47 0.45 0.45 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 48 ... ... : www-bis-org-8025 160 49 po7x po7x NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 50 ... ... : www-bis-org-8025 160 51 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 52 0.63 0.63 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 53 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 54 mGp0 mGp0 NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 55 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 56 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 57 0.3400BTC 0.3400btc NN www-bis-org-8025 160 58 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 160 59 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 160 60 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 160 61 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 62 Xsfsdl1f xsfsdl1f NN www-bis-org-8025 160 63 sdfsdfas sdfsdfa NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 64 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 65 0.18 0.18 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 66 … … SYM www-bis-org-8025 160 67 2Mzf 2mzf CD www-bis-org-8025 160 68 ... ... SYM www-bis-org-8025 160 69 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 70 0.06 0.06 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 71 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 72 lbvI lbvI NNS www-bis-org-8025 160 73 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 74 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 75 0.08 0.08 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 76 ... ... NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 77 lteU lteu CD www-bis-org-8025 160 78 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 79 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 80 0.78 0.78 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 81 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 82 QgWt QgWt NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 83 ... ... NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 84 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 85 0.001BTC 0.001btc CD www-bis-org-8025 160 86 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 160 87 D d NN www-bis-org-8025 160 88 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 160 89 G g NN www-bis-org-8025 160 90 Df32m4 Df32m4 NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 91 bsg3451 bsg3451 NN www-bis-org-8025 160 92 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 93 0.32 0.32 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 94 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 95 tNZ4 tnz4 NN www-bis-org-8025 160 96 ... ... : www-bis-org-8025 160 97 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 98 0.41 0.41 CD www-bis-org-8025 160 99 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 100 F9ly f9ly NN www-bis-org-8025 160 101 ... ... NFP www-bis-org-8025 160 102 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 103 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 104 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 105 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 106 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 107 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 108 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 109 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 110 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 111 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 112 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 113 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 114 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 115 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 116 ⋮ ⋮ NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 117 ≈2,000 ≈2,000 NNP www-bis-org-8025 160 118 . . . www-bis-org-8025 161 1 . . . www-bis-org-8025 162 1 ≈2,000 ≈2,000 NNP www-bis-org-8025 162 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 163 1 . . . www-bis-org-8025 164 1 ≈2,000 ≈2,000 NNP www-bis-org-8025 164 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 165 1 . . . www-bis-org-8025 166 1 ≈2,000 ≈2,000 NNP www-bis-org-8025 166 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 167 1 . . . www-bis-org-8025 168 1 ≈2,000 ≈2,000 NNP www-bis-org-8025 168 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 169 1 . . . www-bis-org-8025 170 1 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 170 2 MB mb NN www-bis-org-8025 170 3 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 170 4 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 170 5 limit limit NN www-bis-org-8025 170 6 allows allow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 170 7 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 170 8 about about RB www-bis-org-8025 170 9 2000 2000 CD www-bis-org-8025 170 10 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 170 11 8 8 CD www-bis-org-8025 170 12 WP765 wp765 NN www-bis-org-8025 170 13 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 170 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 170 15 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 170 16 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 170 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 170 18 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 170 19 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 170 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 170 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 170 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 170 23 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 170 24 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 170 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 170 26 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 170 27 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 170 28 specific specific JJ www-bis-org-8025 170 29 SHA256 SHA256 NNP www-bis-org-8025 170 30 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 170 31 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 170 32 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 170 33 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 170 34 found find VBN www-bis-org-8025 170 35 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 170 36 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 170 37 trial trial NN www-bis-org-8025 170 38 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 170 39 error error NN www-bis-org-8025 170 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 170 41 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 170 42 proves prove VBZ www-bis-org-8025 170 43 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 170 44 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 170 45 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 170 46 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 170 47 done do VBN www-bis-org-8025 170 48 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 170 49 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 170 50 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 170 51 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 170 52 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 170 53 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 170 54 . . . www-bis-org-8025 171 1 Conceptually conceptually RB www-bis-org-8025 171 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 171 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 171 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 171 5 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 171 6 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 171 7 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 171 8 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 171 9 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 171 10 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 171 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 171 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 171 13 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 171 14 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 171 15 accompanied accompany VBN www-bis-org-8025 171 16 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 171 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 171 18 rare rare JJ www-bis-org-8025 171 19 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 171 20 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 171 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 172 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 172 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 172 3 defined define VBN www-bis-org-8025 172 4 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 172 5 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 172 6 starting start VBG www-bis-org-8025 172 7 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 172 8 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 172 9 0s 0 NNS www-bis-org-8025 172 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 172 11 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 172 12 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 172 13 precisely precisely RB www-bis-org-8025 172 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 172 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 172 16 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 172 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 172 18 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 172 19 expressed express VBN www-bis-org-8025 172 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 172 21 binary binary JJ www-bis-org-8025 172 22 numbers number NNS www-bis-org-8025 172 23 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 172 24 below below IN www-bis-org-8025 172 25 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 172 26 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 172 27 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 172 28 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 172 29 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 172 30 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 172 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 173 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 173 2 expected expected JJ www-bis-org-8025 173 3 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 173 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 173 5 hashes hash NNS www-bis-org-8025 173 6 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 173 7 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 173 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 173 9 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 173 10 performed perform VBN www-bis-org-8025 173 11 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 173 12 obtain obtain VB www-bis-org-8025 173 13 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 173 14 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 173 15 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 173 16 below below IN www-bis-org-8025 173 17 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 173 18 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 173 19 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 173 20 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 173 21 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 173 22 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 173 23 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 173 24 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 173 25 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 173 26 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 173 27 proportional proportional JJ www-bis-org-8025 173 28 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 173 29 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 173 30 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 173 31 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 173 32 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 173 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 174 1 By by IN www-bis-org-8025 174 2 adjusting adjust VBG www-bis-org-8025 174 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 174 4 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 174 5 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 174 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 174 7 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 174 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 174 9 possible possible JJ www-bis-org-8025 174 10 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 174 11 change change VB www-bis-org-8025 174 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 174 13 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 174 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 174 15 adding add VBG www-bis-org-8025 174 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 174 17 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 174 18 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 174 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 174 20 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 174 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 175 1 To to TO www-bis-org-8025 175 2 translate translate VB www-bis-org-8025 175 3 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 175 4 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 175 5 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 175 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 7 expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 175 8 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 175 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 175 10 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 175 11 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 175 12 b b NNP www-bis-org-8025 175 13 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 175 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 15 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 175 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 175 17 one one PRP www-bis-org-8025 175 18 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 175 19 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 175 20 know know VB www-bis-org-8025 175 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 22 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 175 23 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 175 24 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 175 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 175 26 ie ie IN www-bis-org-8025 175 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 28 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 175 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 175 30 performing perform VBG www-bis-org-8025 175 31 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 175 32 SHA256 SHA256 NNP www-bis-org-8025 175 33 computation computation NN www-bis-org-8025 175 34 : : : www-bis-org-8025 175 35 = = NFP www-bis-org-8025 175 36 ℎℎ ℎℎ IN www-bis-org-8025 175 37 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 175 38 ℎ ℎ XX www-bis-org-8025 175 39 ∗ ∗ . www-bis-org-8025 175 40 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 41 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 175 42 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 175 43 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 175 44 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 175 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 46 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 175 47 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 175 48 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 49 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 175 50 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 175 51 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 175 52 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 175 53 perform perform VB www-bis-org-8025 175 54 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 55 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 175 56 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 175 57 , , , www-bis-org-8025 175 58 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 175 59 well well RB www-bis-org-8025 175 60 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 175 61 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 175 62 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 175 63 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 175 64 electricity electricity NN www-bis-org-8025 175 65 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 175 66 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 175 67 operating operating NN www-bis-org-8025 175 68 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 175 69 . . . www-bis-org-8025 176 1 To to TO www-bis-org-8025 176 2 get get VB www-bis-org-8025 176 3 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 176 4 sense sense NN www-bis-org-8025 176 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 176 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 176 7 magnitudes magnitude NNS www-bis-org-8025 176 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 176 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 176 10 mid-2018 mid-2018 NN www-bis-org-8025 176 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 176 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 176 13 Antminer Antminer NNP www-bis-org-8025 176 14 S9 s9 NN www-bis-org-8025 176 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 176 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 176 17 frequently frequently RB www-bis-org-8025 176 18 purchased purchase VBN www-bis-org-8025 176 19 item item NN www-bis-org-8025 176 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 176 21 mining mine VBG www-bis-org-8025 176 22 hardware hardware NN www-bis-org-8025 176 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 176 24 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 176 25 perform perform VB www-bis-org-8025 176 26 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 176 27 advertised advertise VBN www-bis-org-8025 176 28 13.5 13.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 176 29 x x SYM www-bis-org-8025 176 30 1012 1012 CD www-bis-org-8025 176 31 SHA256 SHA256 NNP www-bis-org-8025 176 32 hashes hash NNS www-bis-org-8025 176 33 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 176 34 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 176 35 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 176 36 using use VBG www-bis-org-8025 176 37 around around RB www-bis-org-8025 176 38 1,300 1,300 CD www-bis-org-8025 176 39 watts watt NNS www-bis-org-8025 176 40 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 176 41 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 176 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 177 1 Assuming assume VBG www-bis-org-8025 177 2 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 177 3 electricity electricity NN www-bis-org-8025 177 4 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 177 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 177 6 0.05 0.05 CD www-bis-org-8025 177 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 177 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 177 9 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 177 10 tag tag NN www-bis-org-8025 177 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 177 12 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 177 13 1,000 1,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 177 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 177 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 177 16 hardware hardware NN www-bis-org-8025 177 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 177 18 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 177 19 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 177 20 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 177 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 177 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 177 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 177 24 life life NN www-bis-org-8025 177 25 expectancy expectancy NN www-bis-org-8025 177 26 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 177 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 177 28 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 177 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 177 30 three three CD www-bis-org-8025 177 31 years year NNS www-bis-org-8025 177 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 177 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 177 34 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 177 35 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 177 36 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 177 37 emerges emerge NNS www-bis-org-8025 177 38 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 177 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 178 1 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 178 2 . . . www-bis-org-8025 179 1 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 179 2 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 179 3 . . . www-bis-org-8025 180 1 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 180 2 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 180 3 ≈ ≈ NNP www-bis-org-8025 180 4 2.12 2.12 CD www-bis-org-8025 180 5 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 180 6 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 180 7 /ℎ /ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 180 8 ℎ ℎ NNP www-bis-org-8025 180 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 180 10 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 180 11 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 180 12 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 180 13 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 180 14 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 180 15 comes come VBZ www-bis-org-8025 180 16 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 180 17 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 180 18 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 180 19 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 180 20 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 180 21 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 180 22 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 180 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 180 24 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 180 25 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 180 26 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 180 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 180 28 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 180 29 signals signal VBZ www-bis-org-8025 180 30 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 180 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 180 32 person person NN www-bis-org-8025 180 33 , , , www-bis-org-8025 180 34 group group NN www-bis-org-8025 180 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 180 36 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 180 37 company company NN www-bis-org-8025 180 38 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 180 39 done do VBN www-bis-org-8025 180 40 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 180 41 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 180 42 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 180 43 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 180 44 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 180 45 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 180 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 181 1 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 181 2 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 181 3 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 181 4 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 181 5 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 181 6 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 181 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 181 8 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 181 9 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 181 10 below below IN www-bis-org-8025 181 11 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 181 12 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 181 13 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 181 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 181 15 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 181 16 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 181 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 181 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 181 19 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 181 20 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 181 21 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 181 22 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 181 23 nonce nonce NN www-bis-org-8025 181 24 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 181 25 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 181 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 181 27 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 181 28 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 181 29 allows allow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 181 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 181 31 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 181 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 181 33 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 181 34 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 181 35 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 181 36 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 181 37 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 181 38 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 181 39 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 181 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 182 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 182 2 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 182 3 piece piece NN www-bis-org-8025 182 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 182 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 182 6 updating updating JJ www-bis-org-8025 182 7 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 182 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 182 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 182 10 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 182 11 algorithm algorithm NN www-bis-org-8025 182 12 ensuring ensure VBG www-bis-org-8025 182 13 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 182 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 182 15 unique unique JJ www-bis-org-8025 182 16 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 182 17 emerges emerge VBZ www-bis-org-8025 182 18 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 182 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 182 20 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 182 21 actors actor NNS www-bis-org-8025 182 22 exchanging exchange VBG www-bis-org-8025 182 23 information information NN www-bis-org-8025 182 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 183 1 Note note VB www-bis-org-8025 183 2 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 183 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 183 4 although although IN www-bis-org-8025 183 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 183 6 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 183 7 elements element NNS www-bis-org-8025 183 8 show show VBP www-bis-org-8025 183 9 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 183 10 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 183 11 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 183 12 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 183 13 updated update VBN www-bis-org-8025 183 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 183 15 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 183 16 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 183 17 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 183 18 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 183 19 taken take VBN www-bis-org-8025 183 20 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 183 21 granted grant VBN www-bis-org-8025 183 22 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 183 23 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 183 24 exists exist VBZ www-bis-org-8025 183 25 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 183 26 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 183 27 version version NN www-bis-org-8025 183 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 183 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 183 30 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 183 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 184 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 184 2 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 184 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 184 4 due due IN www-bis-org-8025 184 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 184 6 errors error NNS www-bis-org-8025 184 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 184 8 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 184 9 issues issue NNS www-bis-org-8025 184 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 184 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 184 12 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 184 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 184 14 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 184 15 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 184 16 often often RB www-bis-org-8025 184 17 competing compete VBG www-bis-org-8025 184 18 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 184 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 185 1 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 185 2 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 185 3 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 185 4 issue issue NN www-bis-org-8025 185 5 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 185 6 adopting adopt VBG www-bis-org-8025 185 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 185 8 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 185 9 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 185 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 185 11 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 185 12 competing compete VBG www-bis-org-8025 185 13 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 185 14 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 185 15 observed observe VBN www-bis-org-8025 185 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 185 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 185 18 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 185 19 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 185 20 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 185 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 185 22 most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 185 23 expensive expensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 185 24 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 185 25 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 185 26 continues continue VBZ www-bis-org-8025 185 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 185 28 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 185 29 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 185 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 186 1 Since since IN www-bis-org-8025 186 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 186 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 186 4 generally generally RB www-bis-org-8025 186 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 186 6 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 186 7 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 186 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 186 9 most most JJS www-bis-org-8025 186 10 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 186 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 186 12 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 186 13 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 186 14 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 186 15 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 186 16 summarised summarise VBN www-bis-org-8025 186 17 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 186 18 : : : www-bis-org-8025 186 19 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 186 20 follow follow VB www-bis-org-8025 186 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 186 22 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 186 23 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 186 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 186 25 ”14 ”14 NNP www-bis-org-8025 186 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 186 27 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 186 28 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 186 29 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 186 30 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 186 31 issue issue NN www-bis-org-8025 186 32 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 186 33 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 186 34 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 186 35 approach approach NN www-bis-org-8025 186 36 : : : www-bis-org-8025 186 37 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 186 38 coordinates coordinate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 186 39 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 186 40 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 186 41 version version NN www-bis-org-8025 186 42 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 186 43 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 186 44 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 186 45 most most JJS www-bis-org-8025 186 46 resources resource NNS www-bis-org-8025 186 47 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 186 48 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 186 49 invested.15 invested.15 NNP www-bis-org-8025 186 50 Mining Mining NNP www-bis-org-8025 186 51 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 186 52 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 186 53 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 186 54 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 186 55 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 186 56 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 186 57 How how WRB www-bis-org-8025 186 58 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 186 59 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 186 60 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 186 61 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 186 62 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 186 63 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 186 64 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 186 65 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 186 66 determined determine VBN www-bis-org-8025 186 67 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 187 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 187 2 formal formal JJ www-bis-org-8025 187 3 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 187 4 requires require VBZ www-bis-org-8025 187 5 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 187 6 notation notation NN www-bis-org-8025 187 7 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 187 8 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 187 9 introduced introduce VBN www-bis-org-8025 187 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 188 1 Let let VB www-bis-org-8025 188 2 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 188 3 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 188 4 represented represent VBN www-bis-org-8025 188 5 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 188 6 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 188 7 integer integer NN www-bis-org-8025 188 8 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 188 9 b b NN www-bis-org-8025 188 10 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 188 11 starts start VBZ www-bis-org-8025 188 12 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 188 13 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 188 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 188 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 188 16 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 188 17 genesis genesis NNP www-bis-org-8025 188 18 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 188 19 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 188 20 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 188 21 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 188 22 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 188 23 increases increase VBZ www-bis-org-8025 188 24 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 188 25 steps step NNS www-bis-org-8025 188 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 188 27 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 188 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 189 1 Each each DT www-bis-org-8025 189 2 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 189 3 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 189 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 189 5 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 189 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 189 7 indexed index VBN www-bis-org-8025 189 8 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 189 9 t. t. NN www-bis-org-8025 189 10 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 11 revenue revenue NN www-bis-org-8025 189 12 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 189 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 14 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 189 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 189 16 denoted denote VBN www-bis-org-8025 189 17 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 189 18 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 189 19 expressed express VBN www-bis-org-8025 189 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 189 21 bitcoin bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 189 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 189 23 BTC BTC NNP www-bis-org-8025 189 24 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 189 25 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 189 26 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 189 27 coming come VBG www-bis-org-8025 189 28 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 189 29 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 189 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 31 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 189 32 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 189 33 of- of- CD www-bis-org-8025 189 34 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 189 35 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 189 36 block block NNP www-bis-org-8025 189 37 b b NNP www-bis-org-8025 189 38 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 189 39 : : : www-bis-org-8025 189 40 = = NFP www-bis-org-8025 189 41 + + ADD www-bis-org-8025 189 42 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 189 43 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 189 44 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 189 45 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 189 46 14 14 CD www-bis-org-8025 189 47 Calling call VBG www-bis-org-8025 189 48 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 189 49 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 50 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 189 51 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 189 52 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 189 53 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 54 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 189 55 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 189 56 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 189 57 slightly slightly RB www-bis-org-8025 189 58 misleading misleading JJ www-bis-org-8025 189 59 : : : www-bis-org-8025 189 60 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 61 actual actual JJ www-bis-org-8025 189 62 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 189 63 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 189 64 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 189 65 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 189 66 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 67 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 189 68 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 189 69 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 189 70 continue continue VB www-bis-org-8025 189 71 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 189 72 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 189 73 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 189 74 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 189 75 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 76 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 189 77 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 189 78 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 189 79 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 189 80 most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 189 81 difficult difficult JJ www-bis-org-8025 189 82 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 189 83 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 189 84 . . . www-bis-org-8025 190 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 190 2 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 190 3 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 190 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 190 5 small small JJ www-bis-org-8025 190 6 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 190 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 190 8 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 190 9 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 190 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 190 11 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 190 12 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 190 13 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 190 14 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 190 15 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 190 16 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 190 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 190 18 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 190 19 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 190 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 190 21 long long JJ www-bis-org-8025 190 22 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 190 23 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 190 24 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 190 25 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 190 26 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 190 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 191 1 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 191 2 Note note NN www-bis-org-8025 191 3 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 191 4 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 191 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 191 6 theoretic theoretic NN www-bis-org-8025 191 7 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 191 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 191 9 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 191 10 presented present VBN www-bis-org-8025 191 11 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 191 12 Biais Biais NNP www-bis-org-8025 191 13 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 191 14 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 191 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 191 16 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 191 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 191 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 191 19 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 191 20 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 191 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 191 22 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 191 23 mechanism mechanism NN www-bis-org-8025 191 24 developed develop VBN www-bis-org-8025 191 25 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 191 26 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 191 27 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 191 28 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 191 29 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 191 30 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 191 31 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 191 32 unique unique JJ www-bis-org-8025 191 33 : : : www-bis-org-8025 191 34 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 191 35 equilibria equilibria NN www-bis-org-8025 191 36 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 191 37 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 191 38 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 191 39 coordinate coordinate VBP www-bis-org-8025 191 40 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 191 41 random random JJ www-bis-org-8025 191 42 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 191 43 sunspot sunspot NN www-bis-org-8025 191 44 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 191 45 events event NNS www-bis-org-8025 191 46 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 191 47 branch branch NN www-bis-org-8025 191 48 off off RP www-bis-org-8025 191 49 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 191 50 ie ie FW www-bis-org-8025 191 51 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 191 52 fork fork NN www-bis-org-8025 191 53 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 191 54 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 191 55 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 191 56 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 191 57 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 191 58 emerge emerge VB www-bis-org-8025 191 59 . . . www-bis-org-8025 192 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 192 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 192 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 192 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 192 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 192 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 192 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 192 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 192 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 192 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 192 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 192 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 192 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 192 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 192 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 192 16 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 192 17 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 192 18 evolution evolution NN www-bis-org-8025 192 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 192 20 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 192 21 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 192 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 192 25 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 192 26 specified specify VBN www-bis-org-8025 192 27 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 192 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 192 29 outset outset NN www-bis-org-8025 192 30 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 192 31 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 192 32 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 33 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 192 34 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 35 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 36 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 192 37 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 192 38 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 192 39 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 192 40 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 192 41 path path NN www-bis-org-8025 192 42 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 43 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 192 44 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 192 45 given give VBN www-bis-org-8025 192 46 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 192 47 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 192 48 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 192 49 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 192 50 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 192 51 : : : www-bis-org-8025 192 52 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 192 53 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 192 54 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 192 55 originally originally RB www-bis-org-8025 192 56 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 192 57 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 192 58 50 50 CD www-bis-org-8025 192 59 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 192 60 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 192 61 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 192 62 , , , www-bis-org-8025 192 63 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 192 64 halve halve NN www-bis-org-8025 192 65 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 192 66 210,000 210,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 192 67 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 192 68 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 69 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 192 70 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 192 71 four four CD www-bis-org-8025 192 72 years year NNS www-bis-org-8025 192 73 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 192 74 . . . www-bis-org-8025 193 1 They -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 193 2 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 193 3 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 193 4 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 193 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 193 6 zero zero CD www-bis-org-8025 193 7 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 193 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 193 9 halving halving NN www-bis-org-8025 193 10 results result NNS www-bis-org-8025 193 11 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 193 12 less less JJR www-bis-org-8025 193 13 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 193 14 1/100,000,000 1/100,000,000 NNP www-bis-org-8025 193 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 193 16 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 193 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 193 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 193 19 smallest small JJS www-bis-org-8025 193 20 denomination denomination NN www-bis-org-8025 193 21 possible possible JJ www-bis-org-8025 193 22 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 193 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 194 1 By by IN www-bis-org-8025 194 2 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 194 3 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 194 4 probably probably RB www-bis-org-8025 194 5 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 194 6 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 194 7 point point NN www-bis-org-8025 194 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 194 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 194 10 year year NN www-bis-org-8025 194 11 2140 2140 CD www-bis-org-8025 194 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 194 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 194 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 194 15 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 194 16 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 194 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 194 18 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 194 19 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 194 20 reach reach VB www-bis-org-8025 194 21 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 194 22 upper upper JJ www-bis-org-8025 194 23 limit limit NN www-bis-org-8025 194 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 194 25 21,000,000 21,000,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 194 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 195 1 Miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 195 2 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 195 3 collect collect VBP www-bis-org-8025 195 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 195 5 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 195 6 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 195 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 195 8 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 195 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 195 10 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 195 11 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 195 12 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 195 13 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 195 14 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 195 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 195 16 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 195 17 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 195 18 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 195 19 currently currently RB www-bis-org-8025 195 20 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 195 21 meagre meagre JJ www-bis-org-8025 195 22 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 195 23 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 195 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 195 25 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 195 26 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 195 27 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 195 28 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 195 29 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 195 30 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 195 31 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 195 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 196 1 Fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 196 2 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 196 3 determined determine VBN www-bis-org-8025 196 4 endogenously endogenously RB www-bis-org-8025 196 5 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 196 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 196 7 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 196 8 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 196 9 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 196 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 196 11 section section NN www-bis-org-8025 196 12 below below RB www-bis-org-8025 196 13 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 196 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 196 15 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 196 16 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 196 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 196 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 197 1 Importantly importantly RB www-bis-org-8025 197 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 197 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 197 4 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 197 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 197 6 adding add VBG www-bis-org-8025 197 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 197 8 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 197 9 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 197 10 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 197 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 197 12 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 197 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 197 14 self self NN www-bis-org-8025 197 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 197 16 calibrating calibrate VBG www-bis-org-8025 197 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 198 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 198 2 ensures ensure VBZ www-bis-org-8025 198 3 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 198 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 198 5 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 198 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 198 7 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 198 8 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 198 9 tends tend VBZ www-bis-org-8025 198 10 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 198 11 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 198 12 stable stable JJ www-bis-org-8025 198 13 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 198 14 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 198 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 199 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 199 2 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 199 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 199 4 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 199 5 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 199 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 199 7 may may MD www-bis-org-8025 199 8 fluctuate fluctuate VB www-bis-org-8025 199 9 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 199 10 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 199 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 199 12 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 199 13 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 199 14 advances advance NNS www-bis-org-8025 199 15 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 199 16 likely likely JJ www-bis-org-8025 199 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 199 18 reduce reduce VB www-bis-org-8025 199 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 199 20 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 199 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 199 22 hashing hash VBG www-bis-org-8025 199 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 200 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 200 2 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 200 3 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 200 4 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 200 5 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 200 6 in- in- JJ www-bis-org-8025 200 7 built build VBN www-bis-org-8025 200 8 formula formula NN www-bis-org-8025 200 9 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 200 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 200 11 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 200 12 2,016 2,016 CD www-bis-org-8025 200 13 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 200 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 200 15 about about RB www-bis-org-8025 200 16 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 200 17 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 200 18 weeks week NNS www-bis-org-8025 200 19 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 200 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 200 21 adjusts adjust VBZ www-bis-org-8025 200 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 200 23 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 200 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 200 25 finding find VBG www-bis-org-8025 200 26 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 200 27 rare rare JJ www-bis-org-8025 200 28 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 200 29 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 200 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 201 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 201 2 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 201 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 201 4 increased increase VBN www-bis-org-8025 201 5 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 201 6 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 201 7 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 201 8 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 201 9 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 201 10 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 201 11 quickly quickly RB www-bis-org-8025 201 12 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 201 13 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 201 14 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 201 15 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 201 16 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 201 17 minutes minute NNS www-bis-org-8025 201 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 201 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 201 20 reduces reduce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 201 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 201 22 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 201 23 otherwise otherwise RB www-bis-org-8025 201 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 202 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 202 2 means mean VBZ www-bis-org-8025 202 3 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 202 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 202 5 implicit implicit JJ www-bis-org-8025 202 6 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 202 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 202 8 finding find VBG www-bis-org-8025 202 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 202 10 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 202 11 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 202 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 202 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 202 14 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 202 15 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 202 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 202 17 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 202 18 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 202 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 202 20 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 202 21 break break NN www-bis-org-8025 202 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 202 23 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 202 24 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 202 25 revenue revenue NN www-bis-org-8025 202 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 202 27 fluctuate fluctuate VBP www-bis-org-8025 202 28 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 202 29 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 202 30 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 202 31 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 202 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 202 33 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 202 34 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 202 35 exit exit NN www-bis-org-8025 202 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 202 37 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 202 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 203 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 203 2 we -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 203 3 assume assume VBP www-bis-org-8025 203 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 203 5 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 203 6 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 203 7 risk risk NN www-bis-org-8025 203 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 203 9 neutral neutral JJ www-bis-org-8025 203 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 203 11 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 203 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 203 13 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 203 14 process process NN www-bis-org-8025 203 15 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 203 16 competitive competitive JJ www-bis-org-8025 203 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 203 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 203 19 break break NN www-bis-org-8025 203 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 203 21 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 203 22 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 203 23 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 203 24 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 203 25 condition condition NN www-bis-org-8025 203 26 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 203 27 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 203 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 203 29 expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 203 30 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 203 31 revenue revenue NN www-bis-org-8025 203 32 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 203 33 block block NNP www-bis-org-8025 203 34 b b NNP www-bis-org-8025 203 35 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 203 36 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 203 37 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 203 38 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 203 39 expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 203 40 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 203 41 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 203 42 : : : www-bis-org-8025 203 43 = = NFP www-bis-org-8025 203 44 Expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 203 45 where where WRB www-bis-org-8025 203 46 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 203 47 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 203 48 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 203 49 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 203 50 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 203 51 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 203 52 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 203 53 US US NNP www-bis-org-8025 203 54 dollars dollar NNS www-bis-org-8025 203 55 . . . www-bis-org-8025 204 1 Taking take VBG www-bis-org-8025 204 2 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 204 3 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 204 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 204 5 above above IN www-bis-org-8025 204 6 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 204 7 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 204 8 condition condition NN www-bis-org-8025 204 9 together together RB www-bis-org-8025 204 10 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 204 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 204 12 determinants determinant NNS www-bis-org-8025 204 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 204 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 204 15 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 204 16 revenue revenue NN www-bis-org-8025 204 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 204 18 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 204 19 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 204 20 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 204 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 204 22 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 204 23 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 204 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 204 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 204 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 205 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 205 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 205 3 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 205 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 205 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 6 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 205 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 205 8 updating update VBG www-bis-org-8025 205 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 10 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 205 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 13 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 205 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 205 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 16 updating update VBG www-bis-org-8025 205 17 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 205 18 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 20 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 205 21 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 205 22 produce produce VB www-bis-org-8025 205 23 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 205 24 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 205 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 205 26 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 205 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 205 28 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 205 29 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 205 30 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 205 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 32 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 205 33 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 205 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 35 sum sum NN www-bis-org-8025 205 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 205 37 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 205 38 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 205 39 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 40 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 205 41 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 205 42 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 43 plus plus CC www-bis-org-8025 205 44 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 45 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 46 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 205 47 , , , www-bis-org-8025 205 48 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 205 49 all all PDT www-bis-org-8025 205 50 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 205 51 multiplied multiply VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 52 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 205 53 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 54 USD USD NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 55 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 205 56 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 205 57 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 205 58 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 205 59 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 205 60 : : : www-bis-org-8025 205 61 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 62 ℎ ℎ NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 63 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 205 64 + + SYM www-bis-org-8025 205 65 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 205 66 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 205 67 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 205 68 3 3 LS www-bis-org-8025 205 69 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 205 70 Block Block NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 71 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 72 , , , www-bis-org-8025 205 73 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 205 74 circulation circulation NN www-bis-org-8025 205 75 , , , www-bis-org-8025 205 76 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 205 77 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 205 78 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 205 79 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 80 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 205 81 Bitcoins Bitcoins NNPS www-bis-org-8025 205 82 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 205 83 brought bring VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 84 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 205 85 circulation circulation NN www-bis-org-8025 205 86 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 205 87 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 88 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 89 , , , www-bis-org-8025 205 90 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 205 91 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 205 92 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 205 93 decelerating decelerating JJ www-bis-org-8025 205 94 speed speed NN www-bis-org-8025 205 95 Miners Miners NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 96 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 205 97 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 205 98 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 205 99 made make VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 100 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 205 101 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 205 102 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 103 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 104 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 205 105 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 205 106 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 107 BTC BTC NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 108 mn mn NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 109 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 205 110 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 205 111 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 112 All all DT www-bis-org-8025 205 113 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 114 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 205 115 existence existence NN www-bis-org-8025 205 116 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 205 117 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 118 issued issue VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 119 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 205 120 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 205 121 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 122 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 123 . . . www-bis-org-8025 205 124 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 205 125 Every every DT www-bis-org-8025 205 126 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 205 127 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 128 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 129 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 205 130 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 131 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 132 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 205 133 increases increase VBZ www-bis-org-8025 205 134 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 135 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 205 136 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 205 137 , , , www-bis-org-8025 205 138 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 205 139 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 140 newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 205 141 created create VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 142 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 205 143 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 205 144 credited credit VBN www-bis-org-8025 205 145 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 205 146 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 147 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 205 148 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 205 149 adds add VBZ www-bis-org-8025 205 150 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 205 151 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 205 152 . . . www-bis-org-8025 206 1 Block Block NNP www-bis-org-8025 206 2 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 206 3 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 206 4 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 206 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 206 6 50 50 CD www-bis-org-8025 206 7 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 206 8 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 206 9 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 206 10 initially initially RB www-bis-org-8025 206 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 206 12 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 206 13 halving halve VBG www-bis-org-8025 206 14 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 206 15 210,000 210,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 206 16 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 206 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 207 1 They -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 207 2 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 207 3 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 207 4 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 207 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 207 6 zero zero CD www-bis-org-8025 207 7 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 207 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 207 9 halving halving NN www-bis-org-8025 207 10 results result NNS www-bis-org-8025 207 11 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 207 12 less less JJR www-bis-org-8025 207 13 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 207 14 1/100,000,000 1/100,000,000 NNP www-bis-org-8025 207 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 207 16 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 207 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 207 18 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 207 19 Satoshi Satoshi NNP www-bis-org-8025 207 20 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 207 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 207 22 meaning mean VBG www-bis-org-8025 207 23 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 207 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 207 25 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 207 26 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 207 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 207 28 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 207 29 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 207 30 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 207 31 21,000,000 21,000,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 207 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 208 1 Miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 208 2 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 208 3 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 208 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 208 5 made make VBN www-bis-org-8025 208 6 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 208 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 208 8 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 208 9 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 208 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 208 11 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 208 12 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 208 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 209 1 Dashed dash VBN www-bis-org-8025 209 2 pattern pattern NN www-bis-org-8025 209 3 indicates indicate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 209 4 estimated estimate VBN www-bis-org-8025 209 5 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 209 6 values value NNS www-bis-org-8025 209 7 . . . www-bis-org-8025 210 1 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 210 2 Thirty thirty CD www-bis-org-8025 210 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 210 4 day day NN www-bis-org-8025 210 5 moving move VBG www-bis-org-8025 210 6 average average NN www-bis-org-8025 210 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 210 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 210 9 sum sum NN www-bis-org-8025 210 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 210 11 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 210 12 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 210 13 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 210 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 210 15 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 210 16 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 210 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 210 18 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 210 19 bitcoin bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 210 20 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 210 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 211 1 Source source NN www-bis-org-8025 211 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 211 3 https://bitinfocharts.com https://bitinfocharts.com ADD www-bis-org-8025 211 4 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 211 5 https://coinmetrics.io https://coinmetrics.io NNP www-bis-org-8025 211 6 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 211 7 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 211 8 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 211 9 calculation calculation NN www-bis-org-8025 211 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 212 1 18.0 18.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 2 13.5 13.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 3 9.0 9.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 4 4.5 4.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 5 0.0 0.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 6 2024202220202018201620142012 2024202220202018201620142012 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 212 8 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 212 9 50.0 50.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 10 37.5 37.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 11 25.0 25.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 12 12.5 12.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 13 0.0 0.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 14 2024202220202018201620142012 2024202220202018201620142012 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 15 Block Block NNP www-bis-org-8025 212 16 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 212 17 Transaction Transaction NNP www-bis-org-8025 212 18 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 212 19 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 212 20 block1 block1 NN www-bis-org-8025 212 21 https://coinmetrics.io/ https://coinmetrics.io/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 212 22 https://bitinfocharts.com/ https://bitinfocharts.com/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 212 23 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 212 24 WP765 wp765 NN www-bis-org-8025 212 25 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 212 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 212 27 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 212 28 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 212 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 212 30 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 212 31 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 212 32 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 212 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 212 34 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 212 35 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 212 36 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 212 37 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 212 38 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 212 39 Equation Equation NNP www-bis-org-8025 212 40 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 212 41 3 3 LS www-bis-org-8025 212 42 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 212 43 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 212 44 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 212 45 , , , www-bis-org-8025 212 46 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 212 47 endogenous endogenous JJ www-bis-org-8025 212 48 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 212 49 , , , www-bis-org-8025 212 50 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 212 51 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 212 52 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 212 53 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 212 54 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 212 55 becomes become VBZ www-bis-org-8025 212 56 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 212 57 purely purely RB www-bis-org-8025 212 58 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 212 59 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 212 60 . . . www-bis-org-8025 213 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 213 2 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 213 3 adjusts adjust VBZ www-bis-org-8025 213 4 so so IN www-bis-org-8025 213 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 213 6 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 213 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 213 8 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 213 9 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 213 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 213 11 break break VBP www-bis-org-8025 213 12 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 213 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 213 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 213 15 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 213 16 expenses expense NNS www-bis-org-8025 213 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 213 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 213 19 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 213 20 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 213 21 equal equal VB www-bis-org-8025 213 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 213 23 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 213 24 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 213 25 plus plus CC www-bis-org-8025 213 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 213 27 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 213 28 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 213 29 times time VBZ www-bis-org-8025 213 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 213 31 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 213 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 213 33 bitcoin.16 bitcoin.16 NNP www-bis-org-8025 213 34 Developments Developments NNPS www-bis-org-8025 213 35 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 213 36 late late JJ www-bis-org-8025 213 37 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 213 38 offer offer NN www-bis-org-8025 213 39 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 213 40 window window NN www-bis-org-8025 213 41 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 213 42 opportunity opportunity NN www-bis-org-8025 213 43 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 213 44 study study VB www-bis-org-8025 213 45 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 213 46 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 213 47 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 213 48 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 213 49 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 213 50 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 213 51 3 3 LS www-bis-org-8025 213 52 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 213 53 play play VB www-bis-org-8025 213 54 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 213 55 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 213 56 practice practice NN www-bis-org-8025 213 57 . . . www-bis-org-8025 214 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 214 2 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 214 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 214 4 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 214 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 214 6 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 214 7 had have VBD www-bis-org-8025 214 8 fluctuated fluctuate VBN www-bis-org-8025 214 9 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 214 10 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 214 11 6,000–6,500 6,000–6,500 CD www-bis-org-8025 214 12 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 214 13 April April NNP www-bis-org-8025 214 14 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 214 15 early early JJ www-bis-org-8025 214 16 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 214 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 214 18 collapsed collapse VBD www-bis-org-8025 214 19 first first RB www-bis-org-8025 214 20 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 214 21 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 214 22 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 214 23 4,500 4,500 CD www-bis-org-8025 214 24 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 214 25 late late JJ www-bis-org-8025 214 26 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 214 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 214 28 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 214 29 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 214 30 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 214 31 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 214 32 3,500 3,500 CD www-bis-org-8025 214 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 214 34 below below RB www-bis-org-8025 214 35 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 214 36 mid mid NNP www-bis-org-8025 214 37 - - NN www-bis-org-8025 214 38 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 214 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 215 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 215 2 resulted result VBD www-bis-org-8025 215 3 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 215 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 215 5 massive massive JJ www-bis-org-8025 215 6 exodus exodus NN www-bis-org-8025 215 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 215 8 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 215 9 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 215 10 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 215 11 no no RB www-bis-org-8025 215 12 longer long RBR www-bis-org-8025 215 13 able able JJ www-bis-org-8025 215 14 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 215 15 recover recover VB www-bis-org-8025 215 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 215 17 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 215 18 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 215 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 215 20 running run VBG www-bis-org-8025 215 21 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 215 22 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 215 23 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 215 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 216 1 As as IN www-bis-org-8025 216 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 216 3 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 216 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 216 5 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 216 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 216 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 216 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 216 9 works work NNS www-bis-org-8025 216 10 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 216 11 discovered discover VBN www-bis-org-8025 216 12 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 216 13 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 216 14 speed speed NN www-bis-org-8025 216 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 216 16 less less JJR www-bis-org-8025 216 17 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 216 18 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 216 19 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 216 20 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 216 21 minutes minute NNS www-bis-org-8025 216 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 216 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 216 24 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 216 25 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 216 26 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 216 27 decreased decrease VBD www-bis-org-8025 216 28 substantially substantially RB www-bis-org-8025 216 29 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 216 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 216 31 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 32 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 216 33 condition condition NN www-bis-org-8025 216 34 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 216 35 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 216 36 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 216 37 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 216 38 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 216 39 restored.17 restored.17 NNP www-bis-org-8025 216 40 Attacker Attacker NNP www-bis-org-8025 216 41 advantage advantage NN www-bis-org-8025 216 42 : : : www-bis-org-8025 216 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 216 44 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 45 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 216 46 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 216 47 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 48 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 216 49 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 216 50 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 216 51 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 216 52 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 216 53 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 216 54 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 216 55 How how WRB www-bis-org-8025 216 56 good good JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 57 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 216 58 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 216 59 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 216 60 provided provide VBN www-bis-org-8025 216 61 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 216 62 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 216 63 specific specific JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 64 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 216 65 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 216 66 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 216 67 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 216 68 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 216 69 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 216 70 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 216 71 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 72 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 216 73 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 216 74 achieving achieve VBG www-bis-org-8025 216 75 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 216 76 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 216 77 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 78 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 216 79 signals signal NNS www-bis-org-8025 216 80 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 217 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 217 2 section section NN www-bis-org-8025 217 3 starts start VBZ www-bis-org-8025 217 4 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 217 5 introducing introduce VBG www-bis-org-8025 217 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 217 7 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 217 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 217 9 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 217 10 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 217 11 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 217 12 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 217 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 217 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 217 15 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 217 16 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 217 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 217 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 217 19 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 217 20 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 217 21 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 217 22 irrevocable irrevocable JJ www-bis-org-8025 217 23 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 217 24 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 217 25 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 217 26 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 217 27 unprofitable unprofitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 217 28 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 217 29 reverse reverse VB www-bis-org-8025 217 30 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 217 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 218 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 218 2 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 218 3 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 218 4 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 218 5 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 218 6 starting starting NN www-bis-org-8025 218 7 point point NN www-bis-org-8025 218 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 218 9 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 218 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 218 11 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 218 12 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 218 13 outlined outline VBN www-bis-org-8025 218 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 218 15 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 218 16 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 218 17 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 218 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 218 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 219 1 However however RB www-bis-org-8025 219 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 219 3 16 16 CD www-bis-org-8025 219 4 Equation Equation NNP www-bis-org-8025 219 5 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 219 6 3 3 LS www-bis-org-8025 219 7 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 219 8 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 219 9 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 219 10 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 219 11 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 219 12 progress progress NN www-bis-org-8025 219 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 219 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 219 15 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 219 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 219 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 219 18 form form NN www-bis-org-8025 219 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 219 20 cheaper cheap JJR www-bis-org-8025 219 21 computing computing NN www-bis-org-8025 219 22 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 219 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 219 24 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 219 25 lower low JJR www-bis-org-8025 219 26 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 219 27 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 219 28 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 219 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 219 30 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 219 31 simply simply RB www-bis-org-8025 219 32 offset offset VBN www-bis-org-8025 219 33 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 219 34 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 219 35 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 219 36 : : : www-bis-org-8025 219 37 self self NN www-bis-org-8025 219 38 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 219 39 calibrating calibrate VBG www-bis-org-8025 219 40 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 219 41 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 219 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 219 43 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 219 44 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 219 45 ultimately ultimately RB www-bis-org-8025 219 46 proves prove VBZ www-bis-org-8025 219 47 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 219 48 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 219 49 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 219 50 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 219 51 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 219 52 actual actual JJ www-bis-org-8025 219 53 resources resource NNS www-bis-org-8025 219 54 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 219 55 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 219 56 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 219 57 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 219 58 , , , www-bis-org-8025 219 59 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 219 60 balance balance NN www-bis-org-8025 219 61 , , , www-bis-org-8025 219 62 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 219 63 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 219 64 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 219 65 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 219 66 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 219 67 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 219 68 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 219 69 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 219 70 expected expected JJ www-bis-org-8025 219 71 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 219 72 . . . www-bis-org-8025 220 1 17 17 CD www-bis-org-8025 220 2 Note note NN www-bis-org-8025 220 3 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 220 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 220 5 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 220 6 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 220 7 still still RB www-bis-org-8025 220 8 increasing increase VBG www-bis-org-8025 220 9 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 220 10 August August NNP www-bis-org-8025 220 11 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 220 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 220 13 despite despite IN www-bis-org-8025 220 14 prices price NNS www-bis-org-8025 220 15 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 220 16 much much RB www-bis-org-8025 220 17 below below IN www-bis-org-8025 220 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 220 19 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 220 20 peak peak NN www-bis-org-8025 220 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 221 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 221 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 221 3 evidence evidence NN www-bis-org-8025 221 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 221 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 221 6 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 221 7 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 221 8 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 221 9 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 221 10 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 221 11 accumulate accumulate VB www-bis-org-8025 221 12 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 221 13 stock stock NN www-bis-org-8025 221 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 221 15 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 221 16 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 221 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 222 1 Prat Prat NNP www-bis-org-8025 222 2 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 222 3 Benjamin Benjamin NNP www-bis-org-8025 222 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 222 5 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 222 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 222 7 provide provide VB www-bis-org-8025 222 8 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 222 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 222 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 222 11 depth depth NN www-bis-org-8025 222 12 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 222 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 222 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 222 15 dynamics dynamic NNS www-bis-org-8025 222 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 222 17 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 222 18 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 222 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 222 20 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 222 21 industry industry NN www-bis-org-8025 222 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 223 1 Bitcoin bitcoin JJ www-bis-org-8025 223 2 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 223 3 developments development NNS www-bis-org-8025 223 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 223 5 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 223 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 223 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 223 8 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 223 9 discovery discovery NN www-bis-org-8025 223 10 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 223 11 during during IN www-bis-org-8025 223 12 late late JJ www-bis-org-8025 223 13 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 223 14 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 223 15 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 223 16 Proof Proof NNP www-bis-org-8025 223 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 223 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 223 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 223 20 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 223 21 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 223 22 follows follow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 223 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 223 24 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 223 25 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 223 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 223 27 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 223 28 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 223 29 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 223 30 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 223 31 falling fall VBG www-bis-org-8025 223 32 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 223 33 prices price NNS www-bis-org-8025 223 34 cause cause VBP www-bis-org-8025 223 35 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 223 36 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 223 37 shut shut VB www-bis-org-8025 223 38 down down RP www-bis-org-8025 223 39 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 223 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 223 41 resulting result VBG www-bis-org-8025 223 42 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 223 43 fewer few JJR www-bis-org-8025 223 44 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 223 45 discoveries discovery NNS www-bis-org-8025 223 46 , , , www-bis-org-8025 223 47 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 223 48 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 223 49 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 223 50 downward downward JJ www-bis-org-8025 223 51 re re NN www-bis-org-8025 223 52 - - NN www-bis-org-8025 223 53 calibration calibration NN www-bis-org-8025 223 54 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 223 55 difficulty2 difficulty2 NN www-bis-org-8025 223 56 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 223 57 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 223 58 ^ ^ SYM www-bis-org-8025 223 59 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 223 60 Minutes minute NNS www-bis-org-8025 223 61 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 223 62 Data datum NNS www-bis-org-8025 223 63 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 223 64 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 223 65 CoinDesk CoinDesk NNP www-bis-org-8025 223 66 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 223 67 Price Price NNP www-bis-org-8025 223 68 Index Index NNP www-bis-org-8025 223 69 . . . www-bis-org-8025 224 1 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 224 2 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 224 3 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 224 4 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 224 5 adjusts adjust VBZ www-bis-org-8025 224 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 224 7 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 224 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 224 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 224 10 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 224 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 224 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 224 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 224 14 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 224 15 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 224 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 224 17 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 224 18 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 224 19 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 224 20 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 224 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 224 22 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 224 23 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 224 24 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 224 25 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 224 26 keep keep VB www-bis-org-8025 224 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 224 28 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 224 29 arrival arrival NN www-bis-org-8025 224 30 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 224 31 steady steady JJ www-bis-org-8025 224 32 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 224 33 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 224 34 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 224 35 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 224 36 minutes minute NNS www-bis-org-8025 224 37 . . . www-bis-org-8025 225 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 225 2 adjustment adjustment NN www-bis-org-8025 225 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 225 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 225 5 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 225 6 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 225 7 place place NN www-bis-org-8025 225 8 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 225 9 2,016 2,016 CD www-bis-org-8025 225 10 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 225 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 225 12 ie ie NNS www-bis-org-8025 225 13 around around RB www-bis-org-8025 225 14 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 225 15 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 225 16 weeks week NNS www-bis-org-8025 225 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 225 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 226 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 226 2 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 226 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 226 4 most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 226 5 recent recent JJ www-bis-org-8025 226 6 2,016 2,016 CD www-bis-org-8025 226 7 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 226 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 226 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 226 10 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 226 11 arrival arrival NN www-bis-org-8025 226 12 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 226 13 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 226 14 faster fast JJR www-bis-org-8025 226 15 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 226 16 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 226 17 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 226 18 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 226 19 minutes minute NNS www-bis-org-8025 226 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 226 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 226 22 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 226 23 increases increase VBZ www-bis-org-8025 226 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 227 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 227 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 227 3 arrival arrival NN www-bis-org-8025 227 4 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 227 5 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 227 6 slower slow JJR www-bis-org-8025 227 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 227 8 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 227 9 eases ease VBZ www-bis-org-8025 227 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 228 1 During during IN www-bis-org-8025 228 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 228 3 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 228 4 collapse collapse NN www-bis-org-8025 228 5 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 228 6 late late JJ www-bis-org-8025 228 7 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 228 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 228 9 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 228 10 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 228 11 shut shut VBD www-bis-org-8025 228 12 down down RP www-bis-org-8025 228 13 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 228 14 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 228 15 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 228 16 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 228 17 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 228 18 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 228 19 recover recover VB www-bis-org-8025 228 20 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 228 21 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 228 22 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 228 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 229 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 229 2 lead lead NN www-bis-org-8025 229 3 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 229 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 229 5 decline decline NN www-bis-org-8025 229 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 229 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 229 8 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 229 9 arrival arrival NN www-bis-org-8025 229 10 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 229 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 229 12 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 229 13 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 229 14 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 229 15 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 229 16 panel panel NN www-bis-org-8025 229 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 229 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 229 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 229 20 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 229 21 eventually eventually RB www-bis-org-8025 229 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 229 23 decline decline NN www-bis-org-8025 229 24 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 229 25 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 229 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 230 1 Sources source NNS www-bis-org-8025 230 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 230 3 bitcoinwisdom.com bitcoinwisdom.com ADD www-bis-org-8025 230 4 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 230 5 CoinDesk CoinDesk NNP www-bis-org-8025 230 6 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 230 7 data.bitcoinity.org data.bitcoinity.org NNP www-bis-org-8025 230 8 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 230 9 site site NN www-bis-org-8025 230 10 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 230 11 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 230 12 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 230 13 Jan Jan NNP www-bis-org-8025 230 14 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 230 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 230 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 231 1 7,000 7,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 2 6,000 6,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 3 5,000 5,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 4 4,000 4,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 5 3,000 3,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 6 7.0 7.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 7 6.5 6.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 8 6.0 6.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 9 5.5 5.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 10 5.0 5.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 11 Dec Dec NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 12 2018Nov 2018Nov NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 13 2018Oct 2018oct CD www-bis-org-8025 231 14 2018Sep 2018sep CD www-bis-org-8025 231 15 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 17 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 231 18 index1Lhs index1lhs NN www-bis-org-8025 231 19 : : : www-bis-org-8025 231 20 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 21 difficultyRhs difficultyRhs NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 22 : : : www-bis-org-8025 231 23 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 24 11 11 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 25 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 26 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 27 8 8 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 28 Dec Dec NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 29 2018Nov 2018Nov NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 30 2018Oct 2018oct CD www-bis-org-8025 231 31 2018Sep 2018sep CD www-bis-org-8025 231 32 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 33 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 34 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 35 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 36 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 37 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 38 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 231 39 decreases decrease VBZ www-bis-org-8025 231 40 Slow slow JJ www-bis-org-8025 231 41 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 231 42 arrival arrival NN www-bis-org-8025 231 43 means mean VBZ www-bis-org-8025 231 44 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 45 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 46 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 47 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 48 _ _ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 49 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 231 50 increases increase VBZ www-bis-org-8025 231 51 Fast fast JJ www-bis-org-8025 231 52 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 231 53 arrival arrival NN www-bis-org-8025 231 54 means mean VBZ www-bis-org-8025 231 55 Average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 231 56 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 231 57 discovery discovery NN www-bis-org-8025 231 58 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 231 59 https://data.bitcoinity.org/ https://data.bitcoinity.org/ ADD www-bis-org-8025 231 60 https://www.bitcoinwisdom.com/ https://www.bitcoinwisdom.com/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 61 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 62 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 231 63 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 231 64 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 65 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 231 66 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 231 67 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 231 68 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 231 69 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 231 70 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 231 71 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 231 72 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 231 73 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 231 74 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 231 75 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 231 76 11 11 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 77 instead instead RB www-bis-org-8025 231 78 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 231 79 asking ask VBG www-bis-org-8025 231 80 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 231 81 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 231 82 chances chance NNS www-bis-org-8025 231 83 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 231 84 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 231 85 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 231 86 succeeding succeed VBG www-bis-org-8025 231 87 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 231 88 , , , www-bis-org-8025 231 89 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 231 90 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 91 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 231 92 , , , www-bis-org-8025 231 93 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 231 94 raises raise VBZ www-bis-org-8025 231 95 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 231 96 question question NN www-bis-org-8025 231 97 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 231 98 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 231 99 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 231 100 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 231 101 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 231 102 potential potential JJ www-bis-org-8025 231 103 adversaries adversary NNS www-bis-org-8025 231 104 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 231 105 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 231 106 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 231 107 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 231 108 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 231 109 Budish Budish NNP www-bis-org-8025 231 110 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 231 111 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 231 112 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 231 113 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 231 114 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 231 115 closely closely RB www-bis-org-8025 231 116 related related JJ www-bis-org-8025 231 117 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 231 118 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 231 119 . . . www-bis-org-8025 232 1 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 232 2 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 232 3 definition definition NN www-bis-org-8025 232 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 232 5 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 232 6 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 232 7 Finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 232 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 232 9 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 232 10 generally generally RB www-bis-org-8025 232 11 means mean VBZ www-bis-org-8025 232 12 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 232 13 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 232 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 232 15 transfer transfer NN www-bis-org-8025 232 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 232 17 funds fund NNS www-bis-org-8025 232 18 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 232 19 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 232 20 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 232 21 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 232 22 transfer transfer NN www-bis-org-8025 232 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 232 24 securities security NNS www-bis-org-8025 232 25 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 232 26 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 232 27 become become VBN www-bis-org-8025 232 28 irrevocable irrevocable JJ www-bis-org-8025 232 29 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 232 30 unconditional unconditional JJ www-bis-org-8025 232 31 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 232 32 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 232 33 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 232 34 CPSS CPSS NNP www-bis-org-8025 232 35 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 232 36 2003 2003 CD www-bis-org-8025 232 37 , , , www-bis-org-8025 232 38 p p NNP www-bis-org-8025 232 39 496 496 CD www-bis-org-8025 232 40 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 232 41 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 232 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 233 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 233 2 key key NN www-bis-org-8025 233 3 here here RB www-bis-org-8025 233 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 233 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 233 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 233 7 traditional traditional JJ www-bis-org-8025 233 8 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 233 9 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 233 10 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 233 11 transfer transfer NN www-bis-org-8025 233 12 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 233 13 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 233 14 protected protect VBN www-bis-org-8025 233 15 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 233 16 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 233 17 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-bis-org-8025 233 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 233 19 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 233 20 rather rather RB www-bis-org-8025 233 21 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 233 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 233 23 legal legal JJ www-bis-org-8025 233 24 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 233 25 : : : www-bis-org-8025 233 26 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 233 27 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 233 28 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 233 29 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 233 30 made make VBN www-bis-org-8025 233 31 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 233 32 way way NN www-bis-org-8025 233 33 through through IN www-bis-org-8025 233 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 233 35 national national JJ www-bis-org-8025 233 36 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 233 37 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 233 38 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 233 39 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 233 40 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 233 41 books book NNS www-bis-org-8025 233 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 233 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 233 44 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 233 45 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 233 46 , , , www-bis-org-8025 233 47 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 233 48 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 233 49 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 233 50 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 233 51 law law NN www-bis-org-8025 233 52 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 233 53 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 233 54 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 233 55 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 233 56 revoked.18 revoked.18 NNP www-bis-org-8025 233 57 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 233 58 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 233 59 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 233 60 , , , www-bis-org-8025 233 61 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 233 62 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 233 63 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 233 64 starkly starkly RB www-bis-org-8025 233 65 different different JJ www-bis-org-8025 233 66 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 233 67 . . . www-bis-org-8025 234 1 Broadly broadly RB www-bis-org-8025 234 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 234 3 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 234 4 signifies signify VBZ www-bis-org-8025 234 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 234 6 once once RB www-bis-org-8025 234 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 234 8 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 234 9 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 234 10 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 234 11 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 234 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 234 13 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 234 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 234 15 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 234 16 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 234 17 certainty certainty NN www-bis-org-8025 234 18 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 234 19 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 234 20 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 234 21 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 234 22 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 234 23 undone undo VBN www-bis-org-8025 234 24 later later RB www-bis-org-8025 234 25 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 234 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 234 27 emergence emergence NN www-bis-org-8025 234 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 234 29 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 234 30 alternative alternative NN www-bis-org-8025 234 31 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 234 32 longer long JJR www-bis-org-8025 234 33 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 234 34 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 234 35 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 234 36 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 234 37 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 234 38 include include VB www-bis-org-8025 234 39 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 234 40 subject subject JJ www-bis-org-8025 234 41 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 234 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 235 1 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 235 2 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 235 3 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 235 4 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 235 5 considers consider VBZ www-bis-org-8025 235 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 235 7 change change NN www-bis-org-8025 235 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 235 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 235 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 235 11 history history NN www-bis-org-8025 235 12 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 235 13 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 235 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 235 15 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 235 16 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 235 17 controlling control VBG www-bis-org-8025 235 18 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 235 19 significant significant JJ www-bis-org-8025 235 20 fraction fraction NN www-bis-org-8025 235 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 235 22 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 235 23 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 235 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 235 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 235 26 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 235 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 236 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 236 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 236 3 type type NN www-bis-org-8025 236 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 236 5 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 236 6 operational operational JJ www-bis-org-8025 236 7 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 236 8 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 236 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 236 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 236 11 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 236 12 spends spend VBZ www-bis-org-8025 236 13 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 236 14 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 236 15 simultaneously simultaneously RB www-bis-org-8025 236 16 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 236 17 covertly covertly RB www-bis-org-8025 236 18 mining mine VBG www-bis-org-8025 236 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 236 20 building build VBG www-bis-org-8025 236 21 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 236 22 alternative alternative NN www-bis-org-8025 236 23 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 236 24 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 236 25 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 236 26 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 236 27 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 236 28 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 236 29 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 236 30 include include VB www-bis-org-8025 236 31 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 236 32 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 236 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 237 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 237 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 237 3 scenario scenario NN www-bis-org-8025 237 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 237 5 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 237 6 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 237 7 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 237 8 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 237 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 237 10 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 237 11 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 237 12 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 237 13 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 237 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 237 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 237 16 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 237 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 237 18 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 237 19 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 237 20 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 237 21 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 237 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 237 23 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 237 24 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 237 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 237 26 subsequent subsequent JJ www-bis-org-8025 237 27 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 237 28 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 237 29 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 237 30 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 237 31 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 237 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 237 33 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 237 34 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 237 35 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 237 36 additional additional JJ www-bis-org-8025 237 37 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 237 38 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 237 39 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 237 40 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 237 41 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 237 42 confirmation confirmation NN www-bis-org-8025 237 43 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 237 44 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 237 45 . . . www-bis-org-8025 238 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 238 2 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 238 3 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 238 4 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 238 5 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 238 6 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 238 7 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 238 8 accept accept VBP www-bis-org-8025 238 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 238 10 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 238 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 238 12 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 238 13 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 238 14 release release VB www-bis-org-8025 238 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 238 16 secretly secretly RB www-bis-org-8025 238 17 mined mined JJ www-bis-org-8025 238 18 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 238 19 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 238 20 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 238 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 238 22 original original JJ www-bis-org-8025 238 23 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 238 24 instructions instruction NNS www-bis-org-8025 238 25 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 238 26 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 238 27 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 238 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 239 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 239 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 239 3 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 239 4 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 239 5 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 239 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 239 7 outmining outmine VBG www-bis-org-8025 239 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 239 9 rest rest NN www-bis-org-8025 239 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 239 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 239 12 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 239 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 239 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 239 15 secret secret JJ www-bis-org-8025 239 16 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 239 17 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 239 18 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 239 19 accepted accept VBN www-bis-org-8025 239 20 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 239 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 239 22 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 239 23 upon upon IN www-bis-org-8025 239 24 release release NN www-bis-org-8025 239 25 . . . www-bis-org-8025 240 1 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 240 2 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 240 3 definition definition NN www-bis-org-8025 240 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 240 5 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 240 6 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 240 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 240 8 although although IN www-bis-org-8025 240 9 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 240 10 explicitly explicitly RB www-bis-org-8025 240 11 spelled spell VBN www-bis-org-8025 240 12 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 240 13 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 240 14 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 240 15 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 240 16 probabilistic probabilistic JJ www-bis-org-8025 240 17 : : : www-bis-org-8025 240 18 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 240 19 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 240 20 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 240 21 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 240 22 buried bury VBN www-bis-org-8025 240 23 deep deep RB www-bis-org-8025 240 24 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 240 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 240 26 ledger ledger NN www-bis-org-8025 240 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 240 28 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 240 29 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 240 30 unlikely unlikely JJ www-bis-org-8025 240 31 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 240 32 though though IN www-bis-org-8025 240 33 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 240 34 impossible impossible JJ www-bis-org-8025 240 35 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 240 36 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 240 37 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 240 38 longer long JJR www-bis-org-8025 240 39 rival rival JJ www-bis-org-8025 240 40 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 240 41 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 240 42 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 240 43 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 240 44 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 240 45 exists exist VBZ www-bis-org-8025 240 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 241 1 Thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 241 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 241 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 241 4 probability probability NN www-bis-org-8025 241 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 241 6 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 241 7 operational operational JJ www-bis-org-8025 241 8 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 241 9 succeeding succeed VBG www-bis-org-8025 241 10 depends depend VBZ www-bis-org-8025 241 11 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 241 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 241 13 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 241 14 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 241 15 share share NN www-bis-org-8025 241 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 241 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 241 18 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 241 19 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 241 20 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 241 21 available available JJ www-bis-org-8025 241 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 241 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 241 24 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 241 25 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 241 26 fast fast JJ www-bis-org-8025 241 27 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 241 28 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 241 29 accepted accept VBN www-bis-org-8025 241 30 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 241 31 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 241 32 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 241 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 242 1 It -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 242 2 declines decline VBZ www-bis-org-8025 242 3 exponentially exponentially RB www-bis-org-8025 242 4 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 242 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 242 6 length length NN www-bis-org-8025 242 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 242 8 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 242 9 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 242 10 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 242 11 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 242 12 willing willing JJ www-bis-org-8025 242 13 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 242 14 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 242 15 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 242 16 releasing release VBG www-bis-org-8025 242 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 242 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 242 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 243 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 243 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 243 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 243 4 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 243 5 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 243 6 follow follow VBP www-bis-org-8025 243 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 243 8 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 243 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 243 10 release release VB www-bis-org-8025 243 11 merchandise merchandise NN www-bis-org-8025 243 12 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 243 13 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 243 14 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 243 15 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 243 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 243 17 n n NN www-bis-org-8025 243 18 confirmations confirmation NNS www-bis-org-8025 243 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 243 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 243 21 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 243 22 controls control VBZ www-bis-org-8025 243 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 243 24 share share NN www-bis-org-8025 243 25 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 243 26 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 243 27 x<0.5 x<0.5 NNP www-bis-org-8025 243 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 243 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 243 30 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 243 31 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 243 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 243 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 243 34 chance chance NN www-bis-org-8025 243 35 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 243 36 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 243 37 type type NN www-bis-org-8025 243 38 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 243 39 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 243 40 succeeding succeed VBG www-bis-org-8025 243 41 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 243 42 related relate VBN www-bis-org-8025 243 43 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 243 44 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 243 45 x x NN www-bis-org-8025 243 46 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 243 47 x-1)n+1.19 x-1)n+1.19 . www-bis-org-8025 243 48 By by IN www-bis-org-8025 243 49 contrast contrast NN www-bis-org-8025 243 50 , , , www-bis-org-8025 243 51 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 243 52 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 243 53 notion notion NN www-bis-org-8025 243 54 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 243 55 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 243 56 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 243 57 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 243 58 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 243 59 defined define VBN www-bis-org-8025 243 60 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 243 61 follows follow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 243 62 : : : www-bis-org-8025 243 63 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 243 64 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 243 65 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 243 66 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 243 67 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 243 68 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 243 69 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 243 70 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 243 71 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 243 72 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 243 73 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 243 74 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 243 75 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 243 76 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 243 77 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 243 78 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 243 79 moment moment NN www-bis-org-8025 243 80 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 243 81 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 243 82 onwards onwards RB www-bis-org-8025 243 83 , , , www-bis-org-8025 243 84 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 243 85 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 243 86 never never RB www-bis-org-8025 243 87 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 243 88 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 243 89 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 243 90 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 243 91 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 243 92 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 243 93 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 243 94 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 243 95 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 243 96 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 243 97 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 243 98 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 243 99 . . . www-bis-org-8025 244 1 Thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 244 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 244 3 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 244 4 establish establish VB www-bis-org-8025 244 5 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 244 6 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 244 7 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 244 8 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 244 9 way way NN www-bis-org-8025 244 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 244 11 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 244 12 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 244 13 necessary necessary JJ www-bis-org-8025 244 14 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 244 15 evaluate evaluate VB www-bis-org-8025 244 16 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 244 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 244 18 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 244 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 244 20 gains gain NNS www-bis-org-8025 244 21 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 244 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 244 23 potential potential JJ www-bis-org-8025 244 24 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 244 25 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 244 26 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 244 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 245 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 245 2 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 245 3 words word NNS www-bis-org-8025 245 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 245 5 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 245 6 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 245 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 245 8 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 245 9 safe safe JJ www-bis-org-8025 245 10 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 245 11 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 245 12 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 245 13 soon soon RB www-bis-org-8025 245 14 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 245 15 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 245 16 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 245 17 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 245 18 no no RB www-bis-org-8025 245 19 longer longer RB www-bis-org-8025 245 20 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 245 21 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 245 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 246 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 246 2 perspective perspective NN www-bis-org-8025 246 3 gives give VBZ www-bis-org-8025 246 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 246 5 radically radically RB www-bis-org-8025 246 6 different different JJ www-bis-org-8025 246 7 answer answer NN www-bis-org-8025 246 8 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 246 9 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 246 10 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 246 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 246 12 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 246 13 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 246 14 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 246 15 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 246 16 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 246 17 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 246 18 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 246 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 246 20 operational operational JJ www-bis-org-8025 246 21 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 246 22 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 246 23 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 246 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 246 25 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 246 26 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 246 27 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 246 28 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 246 29 Table table NN www-bis-org-8025 246 30 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 246 31 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 246 32 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 246 33 overview overview NN www-bis-org-8025 246 34 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 246 35 . . . www-bis-org-8025 247 1 To to TO www-bis-org-8025 247 2 exemplify exemplify VB www-bis-org-8025 247 3 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 247 4 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 247 5 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 247 6 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 247 7 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 247 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 247 9 take take VB www-bis-org-8025 247 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 247 11 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 247 12 stylised stylise VBN www-bis-org-8025 247 13 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 247 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 247 15 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 247 16 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 247 17 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 247 18 rents rent VBZ www-bis-org-8025 247 19 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 247 20 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 247 21 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 247 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 247 23 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 247 24 period period NN www-bis-org-8025 247 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 247 26 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 247 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 247 28 conduct conduct VB www-bis-org-8025 247 29 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 247 30 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 247 31 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 247 32 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 247 33 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 247 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 248 1 Consider consider VB www-bis-org-8025 248 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 248 3 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 248 4 strategy strategy NN www-bis-org-8025 248 5 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 248 6 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 248 7 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 248 8 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 248 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 248 10 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 248 11 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 248 12 b b NN www-bis-org-8025 248 13 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 248 14 renting rent VBG www-bis-org-8025 248 15 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 248 16 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 248 17 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 248 18 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 248 19 faster fast RBR www-bis-org-8025 248 20 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 248 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 248 22 rest rest NN www-bis-org-8025 248 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 248 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 248 25 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 248 26 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 248 27 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 248 28 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 248 29 b+waittime b+waittime NNS www-bis-org-8025 248 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 248 31 where where WRB www-bis-org-8025 248 32 waittime waittime NN www-bis-org-8025 248 33 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 248 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 248 35 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 248 36 expressed express VBN www-bis-org-8025 248 37 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 248 38 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 248 39 18 18 CD www-bis-org-8025 248 40 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 248 41 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 248 42 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 248 43 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 248 44 say say VB www-bis-org-8025 248 45 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 248 46 errors error NNS www-bis-org-8025 248 47 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 248 48 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 248 49 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 248 50 corrected correct VBN www-bis-org-8025 248 51 ex ex FW www-bis-org-8025 248 52 post post NN www-bis-org-8025 248 53 . . . www-bis-org-8025 249 1 Erroneous erroneous JJ www-bis-org-8025 249 2 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 249 3 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 249 4 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 249 5 reversed reverse VBN www-bis-org-8025 249 6 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 249 7 legal legal JJ www-bis-org-8025 249 8 challenge challenge NN www-bis-org-8025 249 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 249 10 associated associated JJ www-bis-org-8025 249 11 re re NNS www-bis-org-8025 249 12 - - NNS www-bis-org-8025 249 13 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 249 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 249 15 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 249 16 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 249 17 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 249 18 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 249 19 invalidate invalidate VB www-bis-org-8025 249 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 249 21 original original JJ www-bis-org-8025 249 22 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 249 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 250 1 19 19 CD www-bis-org-8025 250 2 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 250 3 chance chance NN www-bis-org-8025 250 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 250 5 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 250 6 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 250 7 succeeding succeed VBG www-bis-org-8025 250 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 250 9 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 250 10 exactly exactly RB www-bis-org-8025 250 11 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 250 12 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 250 13 xn xn NNP www-bis-org-8025 250 14 +1 +1 NNP www-bis-org-8025 250 15 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 250 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 250 17 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 250 18 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 250 19 lose lose VB www-bis-org-8025 250 20 ground ground NN www-bis-org-8025 250 21 against against IN www-bis-org-8025 250 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 250 23 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 250 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 250 25 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 250 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 250 27 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 250 28 eventually eventually RB www-bis-org-8025 250 29 catch catch VBP www-bis-org-8025 250 30 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 250 31 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 250 32 out out RB www-bis-org-8025 250 33 - - : www-bis-org-8025 250 34 mine -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 250 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 250 36 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 250 37 later later RB www-bis-org-8025 250 38 on on RB www-bis-org-8025 250 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 251 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 251 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 251 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 251 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 251 5 chance chance NN www-bis-org-8025 251 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 251 7 successfully successfully RB www-bis-org-8025 251 8 out out RB www-bis-org-8025 251 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 251 10 mining mine VBG www-bis-org-8025 251 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 251 12 rest rest NN www-bis-org-8025 251 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 251 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 251 15 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 251 16 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 251 17 six six CD www-bis-org-8025 251 18 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 251 19 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 251 20 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 251 21 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 251 22 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 251 23 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 251 24 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 251 25 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 251 26 controlling control VBG www-bis-org-8025 251 27 25 25 CD www-bis-org-8025 251 28 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 251 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 251 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 251 31 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 251 32 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 251 33 CPU cpu NN www-bis-org-8025 251 34 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 251 35 . . . www-bis-org-8025 252 1 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 252 2 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 252 3 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 252 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 252 5 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 252 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 252 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 252 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 252 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 252 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 252 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 252 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 252 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 252 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 252 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 252 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 252 17 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 252 18 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 252 19 irreversibly irreversibly RB www-bis-org-8025 252 20 release release VBP www-bis-org-8025 252 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 252 22 merchandise merchandise NN www-bis-org-8025 252 23 plus plus CC www-bis-org-8025 252 24 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 252 25 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 252 26 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 252 27 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 252 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 252 29 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 252 30 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 252 31 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 252 32 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 252 33 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 252 34 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 252 35 longer long JJR www-bis-org-8025 252 36 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 252 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 252 38 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 252 39 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 252 40 rest rest NN www-bis-org-8025 252 41 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 252 42 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 252 43 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 252 44 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 252 45 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 252 46 mining mine VBG www-bis-org-8025 252 47 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 252 48 . . . www-bis-org-8025 253 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 2 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 253 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 253 4 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 253 5 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 253 6 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 253 7 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 253 8 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 253 9 follows follow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 253 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 253 11 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 253 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 13 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 253 14 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 253 15 able able JJ www-bis-org-8025 253 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 253 17 rent rent VB www-bis-org-8025 253 18 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 253 19 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 253 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 253 21 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 253 22 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 253 23 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 253 24 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 253 25 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 253 26 likely likely RB www-bis-org-8025 253 27 exceed exceed VB www-bis-org-8025 253 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 29 previously previously RB www-bis-org-8025 253 30 introduced introduce VBN www-bis-org-8025 253 31 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 253 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 253 33 normal normal JJ www-bis-org-8025 253 34 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 253 35 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 253 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 253 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 38 expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 253 39 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 253 40 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 253 41 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 253 42 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 253 43 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 253 44 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 253 45 block block NNP www-bis-org-8025 253 46 b b NNP www-bis-org-8025 253 47 onwards onwards RB www-bis-org-8025 253 48 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 253 49 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 253 50 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 253 51 b+waittime b+waittime NNS www-bis-org-8025 253 52 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 253 53 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 253 54 to20 to20 NN www-bis-org-8025 253 55 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 253 56 ℎ ℎ FW www-bis-org-8025 253 57 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 253 58 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 253 59 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 253 60 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 253 61 4 4 LS www-bis-org-8025 253 62 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 253 63 Inserting insert VBG www-bis-org-8025 253 64 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 65 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 253 66 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 253 67 condition condition NN www-bis-org-8025 253 68 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 253 69 3 3 LS www-bis-org-8025 253 70 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 253 71 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 253 72 relates relate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 253 73 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 74 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 253 75 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 253 76 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 253 77 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 253 78 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 253 79 yields yield NNS www-bis-org-8025 253 80 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 253 81 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 82 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 253 83 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 253 84 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 253 85 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 253 86 increases increase VBZ www-bis-org-8025 253 87 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 253 88 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 253 89 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 253 90 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 253 91 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 253 92 ie ie PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 253 93 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 253 94 long long RB www-bis-org-8025 253 95 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 253 96 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 253 97 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 253 98 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 253 99 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 253 100 have have VB www-bis-org-8025 253 101 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 253 102 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 253 103 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 253 104 20 20 CD www-bis-org-8025 253 105 Note note VB www-bis-org-8025 253 106 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 253 107 , , , www-bis-org-8025 253 108 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 253 109 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 253 110 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 253 111 vector vector NN www-bis-org-8025 253 112 , , , www-bis-org-8025 253 113 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 253 114 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 253 115 crucially crucially RB www-bis-org-8025 253 116 assumed assume VBN www-bis-org-8025 253 117 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 253 118 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 253 119 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 253 120 rent rent VB www-bis-org-8025 253 121 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 253 122 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 253 123 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 253 124 want want VBP www-bis-org-8025 253 125 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 253 126 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 253 127 stated stated JJ www-bis-org-8025 253 128 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 253 129 . . . www-bis-org-8025 254 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 254 2 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 254 3 vector vector NN www-bis-org-8025 254 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 254 5 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 254 6 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 254 7 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 254 8 succeed succeed VB www-bis-org-8025 254 9 . . . www-bis-org-8025 255 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 255 2 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 255 3 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 255 4 assume assume VBP www-bis-org-8025 255 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 255 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 255 7 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 255 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 255 9 determined determine VBN www-bis-org-8025 255 10 instantaneously instantaneously RB www-bis-org-8025 255 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 255 12 constantly constantly RB www-bis-org-8025 255 13 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 255 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 255 15 subsequent subsequent JJ www-bis-org-8025 255 16 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 255 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 256 1 Approaches approach NNS www-bis-org-8025 256 2 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 256 3 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 256 4 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 256 5 : : : www-bis-org-8025 256 6 legal legal JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 256 8 operational operational JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 256 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 256 11 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 12 definitions definition NNS www-bis-org-8025 256 13 Table table NN www-bis-org-8025 256 14 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 256 15 Legal legal JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 16 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 256 17 Concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 256 18 : : : www-bis-org-8025 256 19 Legal legal JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 20 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 256 21 procedural procedural JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 22 definition definition NN www-bis-org-8025 256 23 Logic logic NN www-bis-org-8025 256 24 : : : www-bis-org-8025 256 25 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 256 26 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 256 27 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 256 28 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 256 29 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 30 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 256 31 specific specific JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 32 legal legal JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 33 requirements requirement NNS www-bis-org-8025 256 34 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 256 35 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 256 36 met meet VBN www-bis-org-8025 256 37 implying imply VBG www-bis-org-8025 256 38 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 256 39 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 256 40 transfer transfer NN www-bis-org-8025 256 41 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 256 42 unconditional unconditional JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 43 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 256 44 irrevocable irrevocable JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 45 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 256 46 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 256 47 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 256 48 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 256 49 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 256 50 involved involved JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 51 parties party NNS www-bis-org-8025 256 52 becomes become VBZ www-bis-org-8025 256 53 insolvent insolvent JJ www-bis-org-8025 256 54 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 256 55 enters enter VBZ www-bis-org-8025 256 56 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 256 57 bankruptcy bankruptcy NN www-bis-org-8025 256 58 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 256 59 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 256 60 CPMI CPMI NNP www-bis-org-8025 256 61 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 256 62 IOSCO IOSCO NNP www-bis-org-8025 256 63 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 256 64 2012 2012 CD www-bis-org-8025 256 65 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 256 66 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 256 67 . . . www-bis-org-8025 257 1 Criterion criterion NN www-bis-org-8025 257 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 257 3 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 257 4 specific specific JJ www-bis-org-8025 257 5 criteria criterion NNS www-bis-org-8025 257 6 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 257 7 settlement settlement NN www-bis-org-8025 257 8 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 257 9 differ differ VBP www-bis-org-8025 257 10 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 257 11 jurisdiction jurisdiction NN www-bis-org-8025 257 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 257 13 involved involved JJ www-bis-org-8025 257 14 counterparties counterpartie NNS www-bis-org-8025 257 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 257 16 mode mode NN www-bis-org-8025 257 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 257 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 257 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 257 20 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 257 21 asset asset NN www-bis-org-8025 257 22 class class NN www-bis-org-8025 257 23 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 257 24 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 257 25 CPMI CPMI NNP www-bis-org-8025 257 26 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 257 27 2012 2012 CD www-bis-org-8025 257 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 257 29 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 257 30 examples example NNS www-bis-org-8025 257 31 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 257 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 258 1 Operational operational JJ www-bis-org-8025 258 2 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 258 3 probabilistic probabilistic JJ www-bis-org-8025 258 4 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 258 5 Concept Concept NNP www-bis-org-8025 258 6 : : : www-bis-org-8025 258 7 Probabilistic probabilistic NN www-bis-org-8025 258 8 – – : www-bis-org-8025 258 9 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 258 10 formal formal JJ www-bis-org-8025 258 11 definition definition NN www-bis-org-8025 258 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 258 13 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 258 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 258 15 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 258 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 258 17 idea idea NN www-bis-org-8025 258 18 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 258 19 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 258 20 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 258 21 buried bury VBN www-bis-org-8025 258 22 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 258 23 deep deep JJ www-bis-org-8025 258 24 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 258 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 258 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 258 27 ledger ledger NNP www-bis-org-8025 258 28 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 258 29 unlikely unlikely JJ www-bis-org-8025 258 30 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 258 31 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 258 32 reversed reverse VBN www-bis-org-8025 258 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 259 1 Logic logic NN www-bis-org-8025 259 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 259 3 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 259 4 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 259 5 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 259 6 controls control VBZ www-bis-org-8025 259 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 259 8 given give VBN www-bis-org-8025 259 9 share share NN www-bis-org-8025 259 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 259 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 259 12 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 259 13 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 259 14 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 259 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 259 16 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 259 17 wait wait VBP www-bis-org-8025 259 18 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 259 19 Waittime Waittime NNP www-bis-org-8025 259 20 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 259 21 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 259 22 shipping shipping NN www-bis-org-8025 259 23 goods good NNS www-bis-org-8025 259 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 259 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 259 26 probability probability NN www-bis-org-8025 259 27 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 259 28 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 259 29 calculated calculate VBN www-bis-org-8025 259 30 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 259 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 259 32 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 259 33 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 259 34 mine mine VB www-bis-org-8025 259 35 enough enough JJ www-bis-org-8025 259 36 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 259 37 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 259 38 overtake overtake VB www-bis-org-8025 259 39 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 259 40 rest rest NN www-bis-org-8025 259 41 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 259 42 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 259 43 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 259 44 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 259 45 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 259 46 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 259 47 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 259 48 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 259 49 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 259 50 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 259 51 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 259 52 release release NN www-bis-org-8025 259 53 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 259 54 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 259 55 longer long JJR www-bis-org-8025 259 56 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 259 57 . . . www-bis-org-8025 260 1 Formula formula NN www-bis-org-8025 260 2 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 260 3 likelihood likelihood NN www-bis-org-8025 260 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 260 5 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 260 6 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 260 7 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 260 8 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 260 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 260 10 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 260 11 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 260 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 260 13 : : : www-bis-org-8025 260 14 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 260 15 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 260 16 ! ! . www-bis-org-8025 261 1 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 261 2 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 261 3 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 261 4 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 261 5 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 261 6 Parameters parameter NNS www-bis-org-8025 261 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 261 8 - - : www-bis-org-8025 261 9 Share share VB www-bis-org-8025 261 10 x x NNS www-bis-org-8025 261 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 261 12 0 0 NFP www-bis-org-8025 261 13 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 261 14 x<50 x<50 NNP www-bis-org-8025 261 15 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 261 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 261 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 261 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 261 19 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 261 20 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 261 21 hashing hash VBG www-bis-org-8025 261 22 capacity capacity NN www-bis-org-8025 261 23 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 261 24 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 261 25 controlled control VBN www-bis-org-8025 261 26 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 261 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 261 28 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 261 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 262 1 - - : www-bis-org-8025 262 2 Merchants Merchants NNPS www-bis-org-8025 262 3 wait wait VBP www-bis-org-8025 262 4 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 262 5 Waittime Waittime NNP www-bis-org-8025 262 6 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 262 7 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 262 8 goods good NNS www-bis-org-8025 262 9 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 262 10 shipped ship VBN www-bis-org-8025 262 11 . . . www-bis-org-8025 263 1 Economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 263 2 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 263 3 Concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 263 4 : : : www-bis-org-8025 263 5 Incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 263 6 – – : www-bis-org-8025 263 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 263 8 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 263 9 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 263 10 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 263 11 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 263 12 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 263 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 263 14 no no RB www-bis-org-8025 263 15 longer long RBR www-bis-org-8025 263 16 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 263 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 263 18 reverse reverse VB www-bis-org-8025 263 19 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 263 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 264 1 Logic logic NN www-bis-org-8025 264 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 264 3 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 264 4 potential potential JJ www-bis-org-8025 264 5 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 264 6 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 264 7 rent rent VB www-bis-org-8025 264 8 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 264 9 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 264 10 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 264 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 264 12 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 264 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 264 14 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 264 15 basis basis NN www-bis-org-8025 264 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 264 17 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 264 18 long long RB www-bis-org-8025 264 19 do do VBP www-bis-org-8025 264 20 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 264 21 have have VB www-bis-org-8025 264 22 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 264 23 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 264 24 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 264 25 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 264 26 unprofitable unprofitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 264 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 264 28 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 264 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 264 30 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 264 31 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 264 32 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 264 33 double- double- NN www-bis-org-8025 264 34 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 264 35 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 264 36 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 265 1 Formula formula NN www-bis-org-8025 265 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 265 3 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 265 4 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 265 5 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 265 6 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 265 7 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 265 8 : : : www-bis-org-8025 265 9 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 265 10 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 265 11 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 265 12 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 265 13 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 265 14 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 265 15 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 265 16 Π π CD www-bis-org-8025 265 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 265 18 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 265 19 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 265 20 Parameters parameter NNS www-bis-org-8025 265 21 : : : www-bis-org-8025 265 22 - - : www-bis-org-8025 265 23 Ratio ratio NN www-bis-org-8025 265 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 265 25 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 265 26 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 265 27 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 265 28 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 265 29 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 265 30 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 265 31 volume volume NN www-bis-org-8025 265 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 266 1 - - : www-bis-org-8025 266 2 Adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 266 3 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 266 4 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 266 5 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 266 6 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 266 7 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 266 8 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 266 9 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 266 10 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 266 11 rentals rental NNS www-bis-org-8025 266 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 267 1 - - : www-bis-org-8025 267 2 Price price NN www-bis-org-8025 267 3 decline decline NN www-bis-org-8025 267 4 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 267 5 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 267 6 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 267 7 . . . www-bis-org-8025 268 1 - - : www-bis-org-8025 268 2 Probability probability NN www-bis-org-8025 268 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 268 4 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 268 5 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 268 6 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 268 7 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 268 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 268 9 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 268 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 268 11 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 268 12 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 268 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 269 1 Sources source NNS www-bis-org-8025 269 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 269 3 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 269 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 269 5 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 269 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 269 7 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 269 8 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 269 9 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 269 10 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 269 11 . . . www-bis-org-8025 270 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 270 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 270 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 270 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 270 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 270 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 270 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 270 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 270 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 270 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 270 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 270 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 270 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 270 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 270 16 13 13 CD www-bis-org-8025 270 17 convince convince NN www-bis-org-8025 270 18 counterparties counterpartie NNS www-bis-org-8025 270 19 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 270 20 release release VB www-bis-org-8025 270 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 22 merchandise merchandise NN www-bis-org-8025 270 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 270 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 270 25 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 270 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 27 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 270 28 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 270 29 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 270 30 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 270 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 270 32 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 270 33 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 270 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 35 revenues revenue NNS www-bis-org-8025 270 36 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 270 37 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 270 38 : : : www-bis-org-8025 270 39 = = NFP www-bis-org-8025 270 40 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 270 41 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 270 42 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 270 43 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 270 44 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 270 45 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 270 46 Equation Equation NNP www-bis-org-8025 270 47 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 270 48 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 270 49 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 270 50 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 270 51 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 270 52 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 53 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 270 54 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 55 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 270 56 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 270 57 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 270 58 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 270 59 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 270 60 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 270 61 , , , www-bis-org-8025 270 62 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 63 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 270 64 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 270 65 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 66 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 270 67 expenses expense NNS www-bis-org-8025 270 68 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 270 69 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 270 70 adversary adversary NN www-bis-org-8025 270 71 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 270 72 need need VB www-bis-org-8025 270 73 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 270 74 incur incur VB www-bis-org-8025 270 75 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 270 76 order order NN www-bis-org-8025 270 77 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 270 78 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 270 79 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 270 80 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 270 81 . . . www-bis-org-8025 271 1 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 271 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 271 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 271 4 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 271 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 271 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 271 7 gain gain NN www-bis-org-8025 271 8 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 271 9 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 271 10 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 271 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 271 12 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 271 13 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 271 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 271 15 double double RB www-bis-org-8025 271 16 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 271 17 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 271 18 coins coin NNS www-bis-org-8025 271 19 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 271 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 271 21 sum sum NN www-bis-org-8025 271 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 271 23 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 271 24 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 271 25 t t NNP www-bis-org-8025 271 26 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 271 27 block block NNP www-bis-org-8025 271 28 b b NNP www-bis-org-8025 271 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 271 30 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 271 31 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 271 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 271 33 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 271 34 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 271 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 271 36 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 271 37 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 271 38 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 271 39 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 271 40 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 271 41 plus plus CC www-bis-org-8025 271 42 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 271 43 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 271 44 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 271 45 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 271 46 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 271 47 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 271 48 wait wait NN www-bis-org-8025 271 49 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 271 50 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 271 51 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 271 52 . . . www-bis-org-8025 272 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 272 2 gain gain NN www-bis-org-8025 272 3 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 272 4 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 272 5 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 272 6 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 272 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 272 8 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 272 9 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 272 10 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 272 11 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 272 12 Π π CD www-bis-org-8025 272 13 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 272 14 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 272 15 + + XX www-bis-org-8025 272 16 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 272 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 272 18 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 272 19 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 272 20 One one CD www-bis-org-8025 272 21 important important JJ www-bis-org-8025 272 22 thing thing NN www-bis-org-8025 272 23 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 272 24 note note VB www-bis-org-8025 272 25 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 272 26 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 272 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 272 28 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 272 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 272 30 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 272 31 forging forge VBG www-bis-org-8025 272 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 272 33 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 272 34 collects collect VBZ www-bis-org-8025 272 35 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 272 36 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 272 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 272 38 double double RB www-bis-org-8025 272 39 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 272 40 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 272 41 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 272 42 , , , www-bis-org-8025 272 43 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 272 44 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 272 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 272 46 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 272 47 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 272 48 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 272 49 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 272 50 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 272 51 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 272 52 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 272 53 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 272 54 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 272 55 , , , www-bis-org-8025 272 56 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 272 57 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 272 58 collects collect VBZ www-bis-org-8025 272 59 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 272 60 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 272 61 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 272 62 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 272 63 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 272 64 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 272 65 honest honest JJ www-bis-org-8025 272 66 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 272 67 . . . www-bis-org-8025 273 1 However however RB www-bis-org-8025 273 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 273 3 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 273 4 offsetting offset VBG www-bis-org-8025 273 5 force force NN www-bis-org-8025 273 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 273 7 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 273 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 273 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 273 10 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 273 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 273 12 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 273 13 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 273 14 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 273 15 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 273 16 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 273 17 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 273 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 273 19 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 273 20 potentially potentially RB www-bis-org-8025 273 21 much much RB www-bis-org-8025 273 22 lower low JJR www-bis-org-8025 273 23 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 273 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 273 25 pre pre JJ www-bis-org-8025 273 26 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 273 27 attack attack JJ www-bis-org-8025 273 28 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 273 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 274 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 274 2 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 274 3 drop drop NN www-bis-org-8025 274 4 reflects reflect VBZ www-bis-org-8025 274 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 274 6 collapse collapse NN www-bis-org-8025 274 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 274 8 confidence confidence NN www-bis-org-8025 274 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 274 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 274 11 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 274 12 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 274 13 probably probably RB www-bis-org-8025 274 14 ensue ensue VB www-bis-org-8025 274 15 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 274 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 274 17 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 274 18 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 274 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 274 20 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 274 21 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 274 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 275 1 Also also RB www-bis-org-8025 275 2 overarching overarch VBG www-bis-org-8025 275 3 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 275 4 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-bis-org-8025 275 5 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 275 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 275 7 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 275 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 275 9 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 275 10 provide provide VBP www-bis-org-8025 275 11 protection protection NN www-bis-org-8025 275 12 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 275 13 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 275 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 275 15 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 275 16 more more JJR www-bis-org-8025 275 17 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 275 18 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 275 19 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 275 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 275 21 conclusion conclusion NN www-bis-org-8025 275 22 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 275 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 276 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 276 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 276 3 captured capture VBN www-bis-org-8025 276 4 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 276 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 276 6 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 276 7 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 276 8 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 276 9 Π Π NNP www-bis-org-8025 276 10 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 276 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 276 12 where where WRB www-bis-org-8025 276 13 Π π PRP www-bis-org-8025 276 14 represents represent VBZ www-bis-org-8025 276 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 276 16 probability probability NN www-bis-org-8025 276 17 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 276 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 276 19 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 276 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 276 21 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 276 22 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 276 23 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 276 24 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 276 25 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 276 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 276 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 276 28 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 276 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 276 30 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 276 31 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 276 32 collaborate collaborate VB www-bis-org-8025 276 33 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 276 34 ignore ignore VB www-bis-org-8025 276 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 276 36 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 276 37 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 276 38 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 276 39 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 276 40 though though IN www-bis-org-8025 276 41 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 276 42 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 276 43 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 276 44 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 276 45 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 276 46 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 276 47 , , , www-bis-org-8025 276 48 ie ie FW www-bis-org-8025 276 49 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 276 50 initiating initiate VBG www-bis-org-8025 276 51 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 276 52 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 276 53 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 276 54 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 276 55 hard hard JJ www-bis-org-8025 276 56 fork fork NN www-bis-org-8025 276 57 . . . www-bis-org-8025 277 1 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 277 2 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 277 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 277 4 unprofitable unprofitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 5 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 277 6 long long RB www-bis-org-8025 277 7 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 277 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 277 9 expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 277 10 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 277 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 277 12 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 277 13 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 277 14 exceeds exceed VBZ www-bis-org-8025 277 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 277 16 expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 277 17 gain gain NN www-bis-org-8025 277 18 : : : www-bis-org-8025 277 19 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 277 20 We -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 277 21 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 277 22 rearrange rearrange VB www-bis-org-8025 277 23 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 277 24 expression expression NN www-bis-org-8025 277 25 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 277 26 show show VB www-bis-org-8025 277 27 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 277 28 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 277 29 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 277 30 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 277 31 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 32 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 277 33 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 277 34 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 277 35 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 277 36 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 277 37 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 277 38 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 277 39 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 277 40 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 277 41 safe safe JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 42 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 277 43 such such PDT www-bis-org-8025 277 44 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 277 45 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 277 46 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 277 47 long long RB www-bis-org-8025 277 48 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 277 49 : : : www-bis-org-8025 277 50 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 277 51 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 277 52 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 277 53 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 277 54 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 277 55 7 7 LS www-bis-org-8025 277 56 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 277 57 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 277 58 left left JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 59 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 277 60 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 277 61 side side NN www-bis-org-8025 277 62 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 277 63 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 277 64 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 277 65 7 7 LS www-bis-org-8025 277 66 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 277 67 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 277 68 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 277 69 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 277 70 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 277 71 safe safe JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 72 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 277 73 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 277 74 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 75 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 277 76 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 277 77 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 277 78 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 277 79 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 277 80 forging forge VBG www-bis-org-8025 277 81 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 277 82 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 277 83 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 277 84 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 85 , , , www-bis-org-8025 277 86 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 277 87 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 277 88 either either CC www-bis-org-8025 277 89 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 277 90 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 277 91 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 277 92 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 277 93 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 277 94 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 277 95 coming come VBG www-bis-org-8025 277 96 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 277 97 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 98 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 277 99 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 277 100 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 277 101 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 277 102 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 277 103 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 277 104 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 277 105 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 277 106 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 277 107 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 277 108 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 277 109 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 277 110 need need VBP www-bis-org-8025 277 111 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 277 112 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 277 113 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 277 114 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 277 115 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 116 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 277 117 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 277 118 waittime waittime NN www-bis-org-8025 277 119 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 277 120 . . . www-bis-org-8025 278 1 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 278 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 4 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 278 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 278 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 7 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 8 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 278 9 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 278 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 11 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 278 13 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 278 14 side side NN www-bis-org-8025 278 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 278 16 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 278 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 278 18 7 7 LS www-bis-org-8025 278 19 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 278 20 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 21 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 278 22 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 278 23 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 24 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 278 25 susceptible susceptible JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 26 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 278 27 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 278 28 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 278 29 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 278 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 31 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 32 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 278 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 278 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 35 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 278 36 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 278 37 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 278 38 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 278 39 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 278 40 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 41 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 42 , , , www-bis-org-8025 278 43 ie ie NFP www-bis-org-8025 278 44 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 278 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 46 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 278 47 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 278 48 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 278 49 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 278 50 double double RB www-bis-org-8025 278 51 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 278 52 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 278 53 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 54 large.21 large.21 NNP www-bis-org-8025 278 55 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 56 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 57 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 278 58 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 278 59 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 60 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 61 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 278 62 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 278 63 side side NN www-bis-org-8025 278 64 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 278 65 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 278 66 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 278 67 7 7 LS www-bis-org-8025 278 68 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 278 69 summarises summarise VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 70 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 278 71 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 278 72 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 278 73 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 74 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 278 75 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 278 76 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 278 77 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 278 78 : : : www-bis-org-8025 278 79 renting rent VBG www-bis-org-8025 278 80 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 278 81 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 278 82 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 278 83 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 84 notice notice NN www-bis-org-8025 278 85 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 86 expensive expensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 87 , , , www-bis-org-8025 278 88 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 278 89 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 278 90 likely likely JJ www-bis-org-8025 278 91 above above IN www-bis-org-8025 278 92 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 278 93 . . . www-bis-org-8025 279 1 Offering offer VBG www-bis-org-8025 279 2 further further JJ www-bis-org-8025 279 3 protection protection NN www-bis-org-8025 279 4 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 279 5 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 279 6 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 279 7 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 279 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 279 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 279 10 consideration consideration NN www-bis-org-8025 279 11 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 279 12 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 279 13 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 279 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 279 15 ie ie VBZ www-bis-org-8025 279 16 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 279 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 279 18 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 279 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 279 20 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 279 21 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 279 22 collapse collapse VB www-bis-org-8025 279 23 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 279 24 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 279 25 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 279 26 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 279 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 280 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 280 2 proceeds proceed VBZ www-bis-org-8025 280 3 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 280 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 280 5 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 280 6 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 280 7 part part NN www-bis-org-8025 280 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 280 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 280 10 gains gain NNS www-bis-org-8025 280 11 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 280 12 21 21 CD www-bis-org-8025 280 13 Note note NN www-bis-org-8025 280 14 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 280 15 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 280 16 guidelines guideline NNS www-bis-org-8025 280 17 regarding regard VBG www-bis-org-8025 280 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 280 19 safe safe JJ www-bis-org-8025 280 20 use use NN www-bis-org-8025 280 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 280 22 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 280 23 recommend recommend NN www-bis-org-8025 280 24 making make VBG www-bis-org-8025 280 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 280 26 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 280 27 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 280 28 dependent dependent JJ www-bis-org-8025 280 29 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 280 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 280 31 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 280 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 280 33 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 280 34 , , , www-bis-org-8025 280 35 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 280 36 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 280 37 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 280 38 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 280 39 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 280 40 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 280 41 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 280 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 280 43 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 280 44 individual individual JJ www-bis-org-8025 280 45 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 280 46 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 280 47 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 280 48 relevant relevant JJ www-bis-org-8025 280 49 . . . www-bis-org-8025 281 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 281 2 maximal maximal JJ www-bis-org-8025 281 3 gain gain NN www-bis-org-8025 281 4 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 281 5 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 281 6 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 281 7 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 281 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 281 9 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 281 10 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 281 11 depends depend VBZ www-bis-org-8025 281 12 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 281 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 281 14 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 281 15 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 281 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 281 17 all all PDT www-bis-org-8025 281 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 281 19 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 281 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 281 21 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 281 22 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 281 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 282 1 Thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 282 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 282 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 282 4 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 282 5 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 282 6 depends depend VBZ www-bis-org-8025 282 7 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 282 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 282 9 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 282 10 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 282 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 282 12 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 282 13 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 282 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 282 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 282 16 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 282 17 rather rather RB www-bis-org-8025 282 18 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 282 19 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 282 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 282 21 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 282 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 282 23 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 282 24 individual individual JJ www-bis-org-8025 282 25 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 282 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 283 1 14 14 CD www-bis-org-8025 283 2 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 283 3 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 283 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 283 5 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 283 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 283 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 283 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 283 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 283 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 283 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 283 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 283 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 283 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 283 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 283 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 283 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 283 18 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 283 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 283 20 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 283 21 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 283 22 come come VBN www-bis-org-8025 283 23 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 283 24 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 283 25 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 283 26 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 283 27 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 283 28 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 283 29 unspent unspent JJ www-bis-org-8025 283 30 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 283 31 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 283 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 283 33 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 283 34 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 283 35 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 283 36 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 283 37 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 283 38 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 283 39 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 283 40 again again RB www-bis-org-8025 283 41 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 283 42 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 283 43 future future NN www-bis-org-8025 283 44 . . . www-bis-org-8025 284 1 Yet yet RB www-bis-org-8025 284 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 284 3 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 284 4 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 284 5 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 284 6 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 284 7 lose lose VB www-bis-org-8025 284 8 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 284 9 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 284 10 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 284 11 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 284 12 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 284 13 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 284 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 284 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 284 16 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 284 17 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 284 18 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 284 19 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 284 20 point point NN www-bis-org-8025 284 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 284 22 attacking attack VBG www-bis-org-8025 284 23 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 284 24 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 284 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 284 26 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 284 27 place place NN www-bis-org-8025 284 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 285 1 While while IN www-bis-org-8025 285 2 nobody nobody NN www-bis-org-8025 285 3 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 285 4 say say VB www-bis-org-8025 285 5 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 285 6 sure sure JJ www-bis-org-8025 285 7 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 285 8 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 285 9 happen happen VB www-bis-org-8025 285 10 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 285 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 285 12 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 285 13 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 285 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 285 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 285 16 series series NN www-bis-org-8025 285 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 285 18 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 285 19 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 285 20 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 285 21 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 285 22 Gold Gold NNP www-bis-org-8025 285 23 “ " '' www-bis-org-8025 285 24 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 285 25 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 285 26 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 285 27 happen happen VB www-bis-org-8025 285 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 286 1 After after IN www-bis-org-8025 286 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 286 3 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 286 4 took take VBD www-bis-org-8025 286 5 place place NN www-bis-org-8025 286 6 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 286 7 10–20 10–20 CD www-bis-org-8025 286 8 May May NNP www-bis-org-8025 286 9 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 286 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 286 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 286 12 cumulative cumulative JJ www-bis-org-8025 286 13 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 286 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 286 15 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 286 16 smaller small JJR www-bis-org-8025 286 17 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 286 18 fell fall VBD www-bis-org-8025 286 19 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 286 20 more more JJR www-bis-org-8025 286 21 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 286 22 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 286 23 fifth fifth NN www-bis-org-8025 286 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 287 1 Last last JJ www-bis-org-8025 287 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 287 3 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 287 4 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 287 5 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 287 6 harder hard JJR www-bis-org-8025 287 7 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 287 8 attack attack VB www-bis-org-8025 287 9 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 287 10 Π π CD www-bis-org-8025 287 11 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 287 12 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 287 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 287 14 ie ie NN www-bis-org-8025 287 15 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 287 16 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 287 17 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 287 18 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 287 19 persuaded persuade VBN www-bis-org-8025 287 20 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 287 21 ignore ignore VB www-bis-org-8025 287 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 287 23 rules rule NNS www-bis-org-8025 287 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 287 25 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 287 26 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 287 27 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 287 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 287 29 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 287 30 case case NN www-bis-org-8025 287 31 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 287 32 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 287 33 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 287 34 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 287 35 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 287 36 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 287 37 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 287 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 288 1 It -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 288 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 288 3 noteworthy noteworthy JJ www-bis-org-8025 288 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 288 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 288 6 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 288 7 nobody nobody NN www-bis-org-8025 288 8 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 288 9 say say VB www-bis-org-8025 288 10 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 288 11 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 288 12 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 288 13 actually actually RB www-bis-org-8025 288 14 happen happen VB www-bis-org-8025 288 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 288 16 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 288 17 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 288 18 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 288 19 instances instance NNS www-bis-org-8025 288 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 288 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 288 22 past past NN www-bis-org-8025 288 23 where where WRB www-bis-org-8025 288 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 288 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 288 26 community community NN www-bis-org-8025 288 27 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 288 28 ignored ignore VBN www-bis-org-8025 288 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 288 30 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 288 31 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 288 32 follow follow VB www-bis-org-8025 288 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 288 34 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 288 35 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 288 36 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 288 37 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 288 38 below below RB www-bis-org-8025 288 39 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 288 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 289 1 Equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 289 2 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 289 3 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 289 4 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 289 5 offers offer VBZ www-bis-org-8025 289 6 three three CD www-bis-org-8025 289 7 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 289 8 insights insight NNS www-bis-org-8025 289 9 regarding regard VBG www-bis-org-8025 289 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 289 11 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 289 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 289 13 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 289 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 289 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 289 16 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 289 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 290 1 First first RB www-bis-org-8025 290 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 290 3 assuming assume VBG www-bis-org-8025 290 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 290 5 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 290 6 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 290 7 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 290 8 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 290 9 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 290 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 290 11 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 290 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 290 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 290 14 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 290 15 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 290 16 initiate initiate VB www-bis-org-8025 290 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 290 18 hard hard JJ www-bis-org-8025 290 19 fork fork NN www-bis-org-8025 290 20 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 290 21 Π π NN www-bis-org-8025 290 22 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 290 23 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 290 24 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 290 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 290 26 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 290 27 assuming assume VBG www-bis-org-8025 290 28 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 290 29 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 290 30 revenue revenue NN www-bis-org-8025 290 31 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 290 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 290 33 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 290 34 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 290 35 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 290 36 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 290 37 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 290 38 constant constant JJ www-bis-org-8025 290 39 , , , www-bis-org-8025 290 40 rewriting rewrite VBG www-bis-org-8025 290 41 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 290 42 7 7 LS www-bis-org-8025 290 43 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 290 44 highlights highlight VBZ www-bis-org-8025 290 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 290 46 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 290 47 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 290 48 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 290 49 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 290 50 : : : www-bis-org-8025 290 51 ∑ ∑ LS www-bis-org-8025 290 52 . . . www-bis-org-8025 291 1 % % NNP www-bis-org-8025 291 2 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 291 3 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 291 4 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 291 5 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 291 6 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 291 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 291 8 8) 8) CD www-bis-org-8025 291 9 Equation Equation NNP www-bis-org-8025 291 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 291 11 8) 8) CD www-bis-org-8025 291 12 documents document NNS www-bis-org-8025 291 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 291 14 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 291 15 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 291 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 291 17 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 291 18 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 291 19 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 291 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 292 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 292 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 292 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 292 4 say say VBP www-bis-org-8025 292 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 292 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 292 7 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 292 8 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 292 9 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 292 10 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 292 11 prepared prepare VBN www-bis-org-8025 292 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 292 13 pay pay VB www-bis-org-8025 292 14 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 292 15 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 292 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 292 17 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 292 18 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 292 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 292 20 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 292 21 rented rent VBD www-bis-org-8025 292 22 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 292 23 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 292 24 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 292 25 twice twice RB www-bis-org-8025 292 26 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 292 27 expensive expensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 292 28 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 292 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 292 30 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 292 31 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 292 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 292 33 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 292 34 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 292 35 electricity electricity NN www-bis-org-8025 292 36 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 292 37 honest honest JJ www-bis-org-8025 292 38 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 292 39 , , , www-bis-org-8025 292 40 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 292 41 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 292 42 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 292 43 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 292 44 lose lose VB www-bis-org-8025 292 45 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 292 46 third third NN www-bis-org-8025 292 47 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 292 48 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 292 49 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 292 50 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 292 51 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 292 52 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 292 53 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 292 54 . . . www-bis-org-8025 293 1 Then then RB www-bis-org-8025 293 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 293 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 293 4 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 293 5 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 293 6 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 293 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 293 8 50 50 CD www-bis-org-8025 293 9 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 293 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 293 11 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 293 12 eight eight CD www-bis-org-8025 293 13 hours hour NNS www-bis-org-8025 293 14 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 293 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 294 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 294 2 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 294 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 294 4 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 294 5 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 294 6 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 294 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 294 8 0.1 0.1 CD www-bis-org-8025 294 9 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 294 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 294 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 294 12 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 294 13 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 294 14 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 294 15 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 294 16 500 500 CD www-bis-org-8025 294 17 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 294 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 294 19 ie ie FW www-bis-org-8025 294 20 around around RB www-bis-org-8025 294 21 three three CD www-bis-org-8025 294 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 294 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 294 24 half half NN www-bis-org-8025 294 25 days day NNS www-bis-org-8025 294 26 ! ! . www-bis-org-8025 295 1 Equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 295 2 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 295 3 8) 8) CD www-bis-org-8025 295 4 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 295 5 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 295 6 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 295 7 one one PRP www-bis-org-8025 295 8 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 295 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 295 10 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 295 11 quite quite RB www-bis-org-8025 295 12 wary wary JJ www-bis-org-8025 295 13 about about IN www-bis-org-8025 295 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 295 15 recommendation recommendation NN www-bis-org-8025 295 16 seen see VBN www-bis-org-8025 295 17 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 295 18 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 295 19 websites website NNS www-bis-org-8025 295 20 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 295 21 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 295 22 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 295 23 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 295 24 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 295 25 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 295 26 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 295 27 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 295 28 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 295 29 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 295 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 295 31 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 295 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 295 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 295 34 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 295 35 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 295 36 at at RB www-bis-org-8025 295 37 least least RBS www-bis-org-8025 295 38 five five CD www-bis-org-8025 295 39 additional additional JJ www-bis-org-8025 295 40 subsequent subsequent JJ www-bis-org-8025 295 41 confirmations confirmation NNS www-bis-org-8025 295 42 , , , www-bis-org-8025 295 43 implying imply VBG www-bis-org-8025 295 44 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 295 45 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 295 46 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 295 47 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 295 48 about about RB www-bis-org-8025 295 49 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 295 50 hour hour NN www-bis-org-8025 295 51 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 295 52 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 295 53 . . . www-bis-org-8025 296 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 296 2 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 296 3 wait wait VBP www-bis-org-8025 296 4 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 296 5 six six CD www-bis-org-8025 296 6 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 296 7 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 296 8 fewer few JJR www-bis-org-8025 296 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 296 10 about about RB www-bis-org-8025 296 11 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 296 12 hour hour NN www-bis-org-8025 296 13 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 296 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 296 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 296 16 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 296 17 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 296 18 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 296 19 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 296 20 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 296 21 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 296 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 296 23 percentage percentage NN www-bis-org-8025 296 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 296 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 296 26 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 296 27 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 296 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 296 29 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 296 30 about about RB www-bis-org-8025 296 31 8.3 8.3 CD www-bis-org-8025 296 32 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 296 33 ! ! . www-bis-org-8025 297 1 Note note VB www-bis-org-8025 297 2 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 297 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 297 4 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 297 5 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 297 6 vector vector NN www-bis-org-8025 297 7 outlined outline VBN www-bis-org-8025 297 8 above above IN www-bis-org-8025 297 9 crucially crucially RB www-bis-org-8025 297 10 assumes assume VBZ www-bis-org-8025 297 11 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 297 12 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 297 13 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 297 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 297 15 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 297 16 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 297 17 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 297 18 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 297 19 rented rent VBN www-bis-org-8025 297 20 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 297 21 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 297 22 notice notice NN www-bis-org-8025 297 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 298 1 Up up IN www-bis-org-8025 298 2 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 298 3 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 298 4 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 298 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 6 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 298 7 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 298 8 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 298 9 have have VB www-bis-org-8025 298 10 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 298 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 298 12 realistic realistic JJ www-bis-org-8025 298 13 possibility possibility NN www-bis-org-8025 298 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 298 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 298 16 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 298 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 298 18 modest modest JJ www-bis-org-8025 298 19 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 298 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 298 21 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 298 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 298 23 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 298 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 298 25 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 298 26 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 298 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 28 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 298 29 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 298 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 31 attacked attack VBN www-bis-org-8025 298 32 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 298 33 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 34 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 298 35 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 298 36 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 298 37 Bitcoin.22 bitcoin.22 NN www-bis-org-8025 298 38 Since since IN www-bis-org-8025 298 39 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 298 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 41 however however RB www-bis-org-8025 298 42 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 43 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 298 44 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 298 45 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 298 46 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 298 47 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 298 48 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 298 49 collapsed collapse VBN www-bis-org-8025 298 50 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 51 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 298 52 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 298 53 located locate VBN www-bis-org-8025 298 54 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 298 55 countries country NNS www-bis-org-8025 298 56 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 298 57 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 298 58 energy energy NN www-bis-org-8025 298 59 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 298 60 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 298 61 no no RB www-bis-org-8025 298 62 longer longer RB www-bis-org-8025 298 63 recover recover VB www-bis-org-8025 298 64 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 298 65 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 298 66 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 298 67 electricity electricity NN www-bis-org-8025 298 68 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 298 69 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 298 70 turned turn VBN www-bis-org-8025 298 71 off off RP www-bis-org-8025 298 72 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 298 73 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 298 74 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 75 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 298 76 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 298 77 evident evident JJ www-bis-org-8025 298 78 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 298 79 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 298 80 decline decline NN www-bis-org-8025 298 81 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 298 82 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 298 83 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 298 84 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 298 85 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 298 86 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 298 87 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 298 88 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 298 89 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 298 90 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 298 91 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 298 92 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 298 93 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 298 94 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 298 95 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 298 96 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 97 left left JJ www-bis-org-8025 298 98 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 298 99 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 298 100 side side NN www-bis-org-8025 298 101 , , , www-bis-org-8025 298 102 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 298 103 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 298 104 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 298 105 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 298 106 above above RB www-bis-org-8025 298 107 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 298 108 . . . www-bis-org-8025 299 1 As as IN www-bis-org-8025 299 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 299 3 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 299 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 299 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 299 6 surplus surplus NN www-bis-org-8025 299 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 299 8 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 299 9 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 299 10 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 299 11 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 299 12 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 299 13 switched switch VBN www-bis-org-8025 299 14 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 299 15 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 299 16 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 299 17 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 299 18 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 299 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 299 20 return return NN www-bis-org-8025 299 21 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 299 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 299 23 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 299 24 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 299 25 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 299 26 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 299 27 bring bring VB www-bis-org-8025 299 28 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 299 29 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 299 30 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 299 31 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 299 32 within within IN www-bis-org-8025 299 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 299 34 realms realm NNS www-bis-org-8025 299 35 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 299 36 possibility possibility NN www-bis-org-8025 299 37 . . . www-bis-org-8025 300 1 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 300 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 300 3 issue issue NN www-bis-org-8025 300 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 300 5 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 300 6 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 300 7 intensify intensify VB www-bis-org-8025 300 8 during during IN www-bis-org-8025 300 9 mid-2020 mid-2020 NN www-bis-org-8025 300 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 300 11 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 300 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 300 13 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 300 14 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 300 15 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 300 16 halved halve VBN www-bis-org-8025 300 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 300 18 pushing push VBG www-bis-org-8025 300 19 further further JJ www-bis-org-8025 300 20 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 300 21 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 300 22 out out IN www-bis-org-8025 300 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 300 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 300 25 regular regular JJ www-bis-org-8025 300 26 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 300 27 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 300 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 301 1 Furthermore furthermore RB www-bis-org-8025 301 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 301 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 301 4 forms form NNS www-bis-org-8025 301 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 301 6 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 301 7 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 301 8 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 301 9 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 301 10 become become VBN www-bis-org-8025 301 11 substantially substantially RB www-bis-org-8025 301 12 cheaper cheap JJR www-bis-org-8025 301 13 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 301 14 recent recent JJ www-bis-org-8025 301 15 months month NNS www-bis-org-8025 301 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 302 1 As as IN www-bis-org-8025 302 2 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 302 3 extreme extreme JJ www-bis-org-8025 302 4 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 302 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 302 6 consider consider VB www-bis-org-8025 302 7 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 302 8 expensive expensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 302 9 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 302 10 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 302 11 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 302 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 302 13 amass amass VB www-bis-org-8025 302 14 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 302 15 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 302 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 302 17 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 302 18 total total NN www-bis-org-8025 302 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 302 20 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 302 21 wield wield VB www-bis-org-8025 302 22 101 101 CD www-bis-org-8025 302 23 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 302 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 302 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 302 26 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 302 27 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 302 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 302 29 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 302 30 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 302 31 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 302 32 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 302 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 303 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 303 2 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 303 3 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 303 4 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 303 5 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 303 6 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 303 7 launch launch VB www-bis-org-8025 303 8 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 303 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 303 10 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 303 11 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 303 12 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 303 13 essentially essentially RB www-bis-org-8025 303 14 hold hold VB www-bis-org-8025 303 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 303 16 hostage hostage NN www-bis-org-8025 303 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 304 1 Although although IN www-bis-org-8025 304 2 substantial substantial JJ www-bis-org-8025 304 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 304 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 304 5 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 304 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 304 7 doing do VBG www-bis-org-8025 304 8 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 304 9 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 304 10 come come VBN www-bis-org-8025 304 11 down down RP www-bis-org-8025 304 12 dramatically dramatically RB www-bis-org-8025 304 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 304 14 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 304 15 just just RB www-bis-org-8025 304 16 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 304 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 304 18 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 304 19 rate rate NN www-bis-org-8025 304 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 304 21 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 304 22 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 304 23 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 304 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 304 25 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 304 26 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 304 27 peaked peak VBN www-bis-org-8025 304 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 304 29 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 304 30 thanks thank NNS www-bis-org-8025 304 31 mainly mainly RB www-bis-org-8025 304 32 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 304 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 304 34 steep steep JJ www-bis-org-8025 304 35 recent recent JJ www-bis-org-8025 304 36 fall fall NN www-bis-org-8025 304 37 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 304 38 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 304 39 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 304 40 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 304 41 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 304 42 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 304 43 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 304 44 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 304 45 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 304 46 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 304 47 , , , www-bis-org-8025 304 48 centre centre NN www-bis-org-8025 304 49 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 304 50 right right JJ www-bis-org-8025 304 51 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 304 52 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 304 53 panels panel NNS www-bis-org-8025 304 54 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 304 55 . . . www-bis-org-8025 305 1 Aside aside RB www-bis-org-8025 305 2 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 305 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 305 4 discussion discussion NN www-bis-org-8025 305 5 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 305 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 305 7 type type NN www-bis-org-8025 305 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 305 9 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 305 10 vector vector NN www-bis-org-8025 305 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 305 12 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 305 13 fundamental fundamental JJ www-bis-org-8025 305 14 insights insight NNS www-bis-org-8025 305 15 emerge emerge VBP www-bis-org-8025 305 16 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 305 17 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 305 18 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 305 19 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 305 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 305 21 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 305 22 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 305 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 306 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 306 2 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 306 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 306 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 306 5 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 306 6 gain gain VBP www-bis-org-8025 306 7 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 306 8 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 306 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 306 10 double double RB www-bis-org-8025 306 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 306 12 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 306 13 coins coin NNS www-bis-org-8025 306 14 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 306 15 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 306 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 306 17 like like IN www-bis-org-8025 306 18 regular regular JJ www-bis-org-8025 306 19 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 306 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 306 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 306 22 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 306 23 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 306 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 306 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 306 26 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 306 27 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 306 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 307 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 307 2 makes make VBZ www-bis-org-8025 307 3 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 307 4 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 307 5 inherently inherently RB www-bis-org-8025 307 6 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 307 7 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 307 8 22 22 CD www-bis-org-8025 307 9 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 307 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 307 11 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 307 12 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 307 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 307 14 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 307 15 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 307 16 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 307 17 noted note VBN www-bis-org-8025 307 18 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 307 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 307 20 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 307 21 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 307 22 describes describe VBZ www-bis-org-8025 307 23 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 307 24 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 307 25 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 307 26 basic basic JJ www-bis-org-8025 307 27 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 307 28 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 307 29 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 307 30 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 307 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 307 32 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 307 33 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 307 34 undone undo VBN www-bis-org-8025 307 35 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 307 36 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 307 37 single single JJ www-bis-org-8025 307 38 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 307 39 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 307 40 legitimate legitimate JJ www-bis-org-8025 307 41 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 307 42 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 307 43 mined mine VBN www-bis-org-8025 307 44 thereafter thereafter RB www-bis-org-8025 307 45 . . . www-bis-org-8025 308 1 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 308 2 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 308 3 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 308 4 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 308 5 strategy strategy NN www-bis-org-8025 308 6 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 308 7 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 308 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 308 9 spend spend VB www-bis-org-8025 308 10 coins coin NNS www-bis-org-8025 308 11 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 308 12 several several JJ www-bis-org-8025 308 13 successive successive JJ www-bis-org-8025 308 14 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 308 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 308 16 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 308 17 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 308 18 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 308 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 308 20 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 308 21 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 308 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 309 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 309 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 309 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 309 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 309 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 309 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 309 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 309 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 309 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 309 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 309 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 309 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 309 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 309 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 309 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 309 16 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 309 17 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 309 18 honest honest JJ www-bis-org-8025 309 19 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 309 20 unless unless IN www-bis-org-8025 309 21 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 309 22 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 309 23 strong strong JJ www-bis-org-8025 309 24 disadvantages disadvantage NNS www-bis-org-8025 309 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 309 26 terms term NNS www-bis-org-8025 309 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 309 28 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 309 29 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 309 30 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 309 31 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 309 32 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 309 33 rentals rental NNS www-bis-org-8025 309 34 , , , www-bis-org-8025 309 35 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 309 36 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 309 37 collapse collapse NN www-bis-org-8025 309 38 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 309 39 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 309 40 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 309 41 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 309 42 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 309 43 , , , www-bis-org-8025 309 44 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 309 45 deterrence deterrence NN www-bis-org-8025 309 46 through through IN www-bis-org-8025 309 47 overarching overarching JJ www-bis-org-8025 309 48 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 309 49 . . . www-bis-org-8025 310 1 Second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 310 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 310 3 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 310 4 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 310 5 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 310 6 point point NN www-bis-org-8025 310 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 310 8 view view NN www-bis-org-8025 310 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 310 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 310 11 consideration consideration NN www-bis-org-8025 310 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 310 13 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 310 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 310 15 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 310 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 310 17 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 310 18 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 310 19 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 310 20 adds add VBZ www-bis-org-8025 310 21 exponentially exponentially RB www-bis-org-8025 310 22 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 310 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 310 24 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 310 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 310 26 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 310 27 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 310 28 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 310 29 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 310 30 hold hold VB www-bis-org-8025 310 31 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 310 32 : : : www-bis-org-8025 310 33 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 310 34 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 310 35 8) 8) CD www-bis-org-8025 310 36 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 310 37 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 310 38 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 310 39 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 310 40 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 310 41 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 310 42 linearly linearly RB www-bis-org-8025 310 43 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 310 44 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 310 45 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 310 46 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 310 47 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 310 48 forgery forgery NN www-bis-org-8025 310 49 , , , www-bis-org-8025 310 50 so so IN www-bis-org-8025 310 51 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 310 52 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 310 53 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 310 54 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 310 55 sustain sustain VB www-bis-org-8025 310 56 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 310 57 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 310 58 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 310 59 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 310 60 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 310 61 means mean NNS www-bis-org-8025 310 62 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 310 63 extremely extremely RB www-bis-org-8025 310 64 long long JJ www-bis-org-8025 310 65 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 310 66 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 310 67 . . . www-bis-org-8025 311 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 311 2 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 311 3 consideration consideration NN www-bis-org-8025 311 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 311 5 crucial crucial JJ www-bis-org-8025 311 6 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 311 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 311 8 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 311 9 future future NN www-bis-org-8025 311 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 311 11 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 311 12 explained explain VBN www-bis-org-8025 311 13 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 311 14 detail detail NN www-bis-org-8025 311 15 below below RB www-bis-org-8025 311 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 312 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 312 2 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 312 3 tragedy tragedy NN www-bis-org-8025 312 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 312 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 312 6 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 7 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 312 8 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 312 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 312 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 312 11 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 312 12 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 312 13 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 312 14 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 312 15 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 16 main main JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 17 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 18 limitation limitation NN www-bis-org-8025 312 19 relates relate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 312 20 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 312 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 312 22 inability inability NN www-bis-org-8025 312 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 312 24 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 312 25 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 312 26 generate generate VB www-bis-org-8025 312 27 non non JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 28 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 29 negligible negligible JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 30 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 312 31 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 312 32 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 312 33 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 312 34 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 312 35 congestion congestion NN www-bis-org-8025 312 36 . . . www-bis-org-8025 313 1 That that RB www-bis-org-8025 313 2 is is RB www-bis-org-8025 313 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 313 4 although although IN www-bis-org-8025 313 5 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 313 6 compete compete VBP www-bis-org-8025 313 7 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 313 8 update update VB www-bis-org-8025 313 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 313 10 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 313 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 313 12 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 313 13 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 313 14 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 313 15 affect affect VB www-bis-org-8025 313 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 313 17 maximum maximum JJ www-bis-org-8025 313 18 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 313 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 313 20 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 313 21 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 313 22 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 313 23 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 313 24 processed.23 processed.23 NNP www-bis-org-8025 313 25 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 313 26 basics basic NNS www-bis-org-8025 313 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 313 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 313 29 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 313 30 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 313 31 Each each DT www-bis-org-8025 313 32 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 313 33 owner owner NN www-bis-org-8025 313 34 wanting want VBG www-bis-org-8025 313 35 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 313 36 transact transact NN www-bis-org-8025 313 37 sets set NNS www-bis-org-8025 313 38 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 313 39 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 313 40 fee.24 fee.24 NNP www-bis-org-8025 313 41 Miners Miners NNPS www-bis-org-8025 313 42 see see VBP www-bis-org-8025 313 43 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 313 44 pending pende VBG www-bis-org-8025 313 45 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 313 46 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 313 47 choose choose VB www-bis-org-8025 313 48 those those DT www-bis-org-8025 313 49 maximising maximise VBG www-bis-org-8025 313 50 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 313 51 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 313 52 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 313 53 , , , www-bis-org-8025 313 54 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 313 55 generating generate VBG www-bis-org-8025 313 56 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 313 57 endogenous endogenous JJ www-bis-org-8025 313 58 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 313 59 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 313 60 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 313 61 . . . www-bis-org-8025 314 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 314 2 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 314 3 long long RB www-bis-org-8025 314 4 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 314 5 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 314 6 still still RB www-bis-org-8025 314 7 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 314 8 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 314 9 space space NN www-bis-org-8025 314 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 314 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 314 12 marginal marginal JJ www-bis-org-8025 314 13 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 314 14 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 314 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 314 16 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 314 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 314 18 include include VB www-bis-org-8025 314 19 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 314 20 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 314 21 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 314 22 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 314 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 314 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 314 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 314 26 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 314 27 include include VBP www-bis-org-8025 314 28 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 314 29 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 314 30 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 314 31 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 314 32 non non JJ www-bis-org-8025 314 33 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 314 34 zero zero JJ www-bis-org-8025 314 35 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 314 36 . . . www-bis-org-8025 315 1 Because because IN www-bis-org-8025 315 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 315 3 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 315 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 315 5 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 315 6 throughput throughput NN www-bis-org-8025 315 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 315 8 fixed fix VBN www-bis-org-8025 315 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 315 10 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 315 11 demand demand NN www-bis-org-8025 315 12 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 315 13 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 315 14 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 315 15 fluctuated fluctuate VBN www-bis-org-8025 315 16 substantially substantially RB www-bis-org-8025 315 17 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 315 18 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 315 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 315 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 315 21 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 315 22 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 315 23 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 315 24 fluctuates fluctuate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 315 25 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 315 26 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 315 27 extremes extreme NNS www-bis-org-8025 315 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 315 29 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 315 30 seen see VBN www-bis-org-8025 315 31 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 315 32 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 315 33 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 315 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 316 1 23 23 CD www-bis-org-8025 316 2 Although although IN www-bis-org-8025 316 3 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 316 4 nuance nuance NN www-bis-org-8025 316 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 316 6 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 316 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 316 8 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 316 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 316 10 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 316 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 316 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 316 13 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 316 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 316 15 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 316 16 adjusts adjust NNS www-bis-org-8025 316 17 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 316 18 once once RB www-bis-org-8025 316 19 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 316 20 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 316 21 weeks week NNS www-bis-org-8025 316 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 316 23 rapid rapid JJ www-bis-org-8025 316 24 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 316 25 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 316 26 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 316 27 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 316 28 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 316 29 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 316 30 affect affect VB www-bis-org-8025 316 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 316 32 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 316 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 316 34 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 316 35 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 316 36 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 316 37 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 316 38 processed process VBN www-bis-org-8025 316 39 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 316 40 up up IN www-bis-org-8025 316 41 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 316 42 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 316 43 weeks week NNS www-bis-org-8025 316 44 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 316 45 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 316 46 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 316 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 317 1 24 24 CD www-bis-org-8025 317 2 Any any DT www-bis-org-8025 317 3 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 317 4 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 317 5 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 317 6 includes include VBZ www-bis-org-8025 317 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 317 8 separate separate JJ www-bis-org-8025 317 9 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 317 10 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 317 11 payable payable JJ www-bis-org-8025 317 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 317 13 whomever whomever VB www-bis-org-8025 317 14 successfully successfully RB www-bis-org-8025 317 15 mines mine VBZ www-bis-org-8025 317 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 317 17 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 317 18 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 317 19 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 317 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 317 21 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 317 22 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 317 23 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 317 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 318 1 Overall overall JJ www-bis-org-8025 318 2 hashing hashing NN www-bis-org-8025 318 3 rate rate NN www-bis-org-8025 318 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 318 5 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 318 6 prices price NNS www-bis-org-8025 318 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 318 8 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 318 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 318 10 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 318 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 318 12 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 318 13 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 318 14 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 318 15 scale scale NN www-bis-org-8025 318 16 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 318 17 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 18 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 318 19 Total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 318 20 hashing hash VBG www-bis-org-8025 318 21 rate rate NN www-bis-org-8025 318 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 318 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 318 24 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 25 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 318 26 peaked peak VBD www-bis-org-8025 318 27 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 318 28 August August NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 29 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 318 30 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 318 31 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 318 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 318 33 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 318 34 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 318 35 dropped drop VBD www-bis-org-8025 318 36 substantially1 substantially1 NN www-bis-org-8025 318 37 As as IN www-bis-org-8025 318 38 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 318 39 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 318 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 318 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 318 42 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 318 43 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 318 44 acquiring acquire VBG www-bis-org-8025 318 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 318 46 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 318 47 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 318 48 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 318 49 rate rate NN www-bis-org-8025 318 50 collapsed2 collapsed2 NN www-bis-org-8025 318 51 Millions Millions NNPS www-bis-org-8025 318 52 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 318 53 terahash terahash NN www-bis-org-8025 318 54 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 318 55 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 318 56 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 318 57 USD USD NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 58 bn bn NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 59 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 318 60 Price price NN www-bis-org-8025 318 61 history history NN www-bis-org-8025 318 62 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 318 63 Antminer Antminer NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 64 S9 s9 NN www-bis-org-8025 318 65 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 318 66 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 318 67 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 318 68 advertised advertise VBN www-bis-org-8025 318 69 capacity capacity NN www-bis-org-8025 318 70 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 318 71 13.5 13.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 318 72 tera tera NN www-bis-org-8025 318 73 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 318 74 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 318 75 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 318 76 second second NN www-bis-org-8025 318 77 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 318 78 Geizhals.de Geizhals.de NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 79 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 318 80 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 318 81 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 318 82 Germany Germany NNP www-bis-org-8025 318 83 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 318 84 . . . www-bis-org-8025 319 1 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 319 2 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 319 3 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 319 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 319 5 acquiring acquire VBG www-bis-org-8025 319 6 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 319 7 capable capable JJ www-bis-org-8025 319 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 319 9 performing perform VBG www-bis-org-8025 319 10 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 319 11 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 319 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 319 13 same same JJ www-bis-org-8025 319 14 rate rate NN www-bis-org-8025 319 15 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 319 16 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 319 17 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 319 18 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 319 19 hashing hash VBG www-bis-org-8025 319 20 rate rate NN www-bis-org-8025 319 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 320 1 Calculated calculate VBN www-bis-org-8025 320 2 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 320 3 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 320 4 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 320 5 hashing hash VBG www-bis-org-8025 320 6 rate rate NN www-bis-org-8025 320 7 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 320 8 TH TH NNP www-bis-org-8025 320 9 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 320 10 S s NN www-bis-org-8025 320 11 * * NFP www-bis-org-8025 320 12 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 320 13 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 320 14 Antminer Antminer NNP www-bis-org-8025 320 15 S9 s9 NN www-bis-org-8025 320 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 320 17 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 320 18 13.5 13.5 CD www-bis-org-8025 320 19 TH TH NNP www-bis-org-8025 320 20 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 320 21 s s NN www-bis-org-8025 320 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 321 1 Sources source NNS www-bis-org-8025 321 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 321 3 https://bitinfocharts.com https://bitinfocharts.com ADD www-bis-org-8025 321 4 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 321 5 https://geizhals.de/bitmain-antminer-s9-a1768361.html https://geizhals.de/bitmain-antminer-s9-a1768361.html NN www-bis-org-8025 321 6 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 321 7 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 321 8 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 321 9 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 321 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 322 1 60 60 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 2 45 45 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 3 30 30 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 4 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 5 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 6 20182017 20182017 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 7 Hashrate hashrate NN www-bis-org-8025 322 8 5,000 5,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 9 3,750 3,750 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 10 2,500 2,500 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 11 1,250 1,250 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 12 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 13 Q4 q4 NN www-bis-org-8025 322 14 2018Q3 2018q3 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 15 2018Q2 2018q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 16 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 17 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 18 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 19 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 20 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 21 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 22 Q4 q4 NN www-bis-org-8025 322 23 2018Q3 2018q3 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 24 2018Q2 2018q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 25 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 26 https://geizhals.de/bitmain-antminer-s9-a1768361.html https://geizhals.de/bitmain-antminer-s9-a1768361.html NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 27 https://bitinfocharts.com/ https://bitinfocharts.com/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 28 16 16 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 29 WP765 wp765 NN www-bis-org-8025 322 30 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 322 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 322 32 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 33 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 322 34 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 322 35 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 322 36 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 322 37 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 322 38 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 322 39 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 322 40 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 322 41 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 322 42 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 322 43 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 322 44 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 322 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 322 46 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 322 47 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 322 48 , , , www-bis-org-8025 322 49 positive positive JJ www-bis-org-8025 322 50 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 322 51 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 322 52 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 322 53 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 322 54 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 322 55 result result VB www-bis-org-8025 322 56 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 322 57 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 322 58 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 322 59 gets get VBZ www-bis-org-8025 322 60 congested congest VBN www-bis-org-8025 322 61 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 322 62 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 322 63 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 322 64 case case NN www-bis-org-8025 322 65 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 322 66 congestion congestion NN www-bis-org-8025 322 67 , , , www-bis-org-8025 322 68 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 322 69 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 322 70 particular particular JJ www-bis-org-8025 322 71 Easley Easley NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 72 et et FW www-bis-org-8025 322 73 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 74 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 322 75 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 76 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 322 77 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 322 78 Huberman Huberman NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 79 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 80 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 322 81 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 322 82 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 322 83 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 322 84 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 322 85 . . . www-bis-org-8025 323 1 When when WRB www-bis-org-8025 323 2 newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 323 3 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 323 4 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 323 5 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 323 6 already already RB www-bis-org-8025 323 7 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 323 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 323 9 maximum maximum JJ www-bis-org-8025 323 10 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 323 11 permitted permit VBN www-bis-org-8025 323 12 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 323 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 323 14 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 323 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 323 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 323 17 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 323 18 congests congest VBZ www-bis-org-8025 323 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 323 20 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 323 21 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 323 22 go go VBP www-bis-org-8025 323 23 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 323 24 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 323 25 queue queue NN www-bis-org-8025 323 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 324 1 Users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 324 2 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 324 3 want want VBP www-bis-org-8025 324 4 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 324 5 have have VB www-bis-org-8025 324 6 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 324 7 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 324 8 transacted transact VBN www-bis-org-8025 324 9 immediately immediately RB www-bis-org-8025 324 10 start start VBP www-bis-org-8025 324 11 setting set VBG www-bis-org-8025 324 12 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 324 13 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 324 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 325 1 During during IN www-bis-org-8025 325 2 peak peak NN www-bis-org-8025 325 3 crypto crypto NN www-bis-org-8025 325 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 325 5 hype hype NN www-bis-org-8025 325 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 325 7 late late JJ www-bis-org-8025 325 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 325 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 325 10 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 325 11 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 325 12 spiked spike VBN www-bis-org-8025 325 13 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 325 14 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 325 15 way way NN www-bis-org-8025 325 16 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 325 17 more more JJR www-bis-org-8025 325 18 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 325 19 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 325 20 50 50 CD www-bis-org-8025 325 21 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 325 22 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 325 23 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 325 24 ! ! . www-bis-org-8025 326 1 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 326 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 326 3 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 326 4 situation situation NN www-bis-org-8025 326 5 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 326 6 persisted persist VBD www-bis-org-8025 326 7 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 326 8 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 326 9 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 326 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 326 11 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 326 12 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 326 13 8) 8) CD www-bis-org-8025 326 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 327 1 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 327 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 327 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 327 4 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 327 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 327 6 whenever whenever WRB www-bis-org-8025 327 7 demand demand NN www-bis-org-8025 327 8 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 327 9 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 327 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 327 11 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 327 12 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 327 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 327 14 even even RB www-bis-org-8025 327 15 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 327 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 327 17 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 327 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 327 19 zero zero CD www-bis-org-8025 327 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 327 21 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 327 22 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 327 23 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 327 24 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 327 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 327 26 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 327 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 327 28 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 327 29 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 327 30 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 327 31 remained remain VBN www-bis-org-8025 327 32 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 327 33 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 327 34 zero zero CD www-bis-org-8025 327 35 . . . www-bis-org-8025 328 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 328 2 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 328 3 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 328 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 328 5 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 328 6 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 328 7 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 328 8 Transaction Transaction NNP www-bis-org-8025 328 9 demand demand NN www-bis-org-8025 328 10 fluctuates fluctuate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 328 11 widely1 widely1 NN www-bis-org-8025 328 12 With with IN www-bis-org-8025 328 13 capped cap VBN www-bis-org-8025 328 14 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 328 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 328 16 demand demand NN www-bis-org-8025 328 17 fluctuations fluctuation NNS www-bis-org-8025 328 18 shift shift NN www-bis-org-8025 328 19 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 328 20 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 328 21 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 328 22 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 328 23 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 328 24 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 328 25 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 328 26 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 328 27 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 328 28 explains explain VBZ www-bis-org-8025 328 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 328 30 kinked kinked JJ www-bis-org-8025 328 31 relationship relationship NN www-bis-org-8025 328 32 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 328 33 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 328 34 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 328 35 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 328 36 fees fee VBZ www-bis-org-8025 328 37 MB mb NN www-bis-org-8025 328 38 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 328 39 Thirty thirty CD www-bis-org-8025 328 40 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 328 41 day day NN www-bis-org-8025 328 42 moving moving NN www-bis-org-8025 328 43 average average NN www-bis-org-8025 328 44 . . . www-bis-org-8025 329 1 2 2 LS www-bis-org-8025 329 2 Transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 329 3 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 329 4 paid pay VBN www-bis-org-8025 329 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 329 6 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 329 7 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 329 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 329 9 period period NN www-bis-org-8025 329 10 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 329 11 Aug Aug NNP www-bis-org-8025 329 12 2010–22 2010–22 . www-bis-org-8025 329 13 Oct Oct NNP www-bis-org-8025 329 14 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 329 15 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 329 16 daily daily JJ www-bis-org-8025 329 17 averages average NNS www-bis-org-8025 329 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 330 1 Sources source NNS www-bis-org-8025 330 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 330 3 www.bitinfocharts.com www.bitinfocharts.com ADD www-bis-org-8025 330 4 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 330 5 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 330 6 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 330 7 elaboration elaboration NN www-bis-org-8025 330 8 . . . www-bis-org-8025 331 1 Spiking spiking NN www-bis-org-8025 331 2 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 331 3 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 331 4 congestion congestion NN www-bis-org-8025 331 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 331 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 331 7 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 331 8 process process NN www-bis-org-8025 331 9 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 331 10 8 8 CD www-bis-org-8025 331 11 As as IN www-bis-org-8025 331 12 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 331 13 spike spike VBP www-bis-org-8025 331 14 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 331 15 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 331 16 … … NFP www-bis-org-8025 331 17 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 331 18 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 331 19 lengthen2 lengthen2 VBP www-bis-org-8025 331 20 USD USD NNP www-bis-org-8025 331 21 Hours hour NNS www-bis-org-8025 331 22 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 331 23 Average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 331 24 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 331 25 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 331 26 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 331 27 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 331 28 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 331 29 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 331 30 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 331 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 332 1 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 332 2 Seven seven CD www-bis-org-8025 332 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 332 4 day day NN www-bis-org-8025 332 5 moving move VBG www-bis-org-8025 332 6 average average NN www-bis-org-8025 332 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 332 8 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 332 9 long long RB www-bis-org-8025 332 10 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 332 11 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 332 12 take take VB www-bis-org-8025 332 13 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 332 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 332 15 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 332 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 332 17 process process VB www-bis-org-8025 332 18 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 332 19 pending pende VBG www-bis-org-8025 332 20 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 332 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 333 1 Source source NN www-bis-org-8025 333 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 333 3 www.bitinfocharts.com www.bitinfocharts.com ADD www-bis-org-8025 333 4 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 333 5 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 333 6 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 333 7 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 333 8 . . . www-bis-org-8025 334 1 0.8 0.8 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 2 0.6 0.6 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 3 0.4 0.4 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 4 0.2 0.2 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 5 0.0 0.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 6 1817161514131211 1817161514131211 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 7 BTC BTC NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 8 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 334 9 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 334 10 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 334 11 F F NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 12 e e NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 13 e e NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 14 T T NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 15 max max NN www-bis-org-8025 334 16 throughput throughput NN www-bis-org-8025 334 17 Transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 334 18 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 19 D d NN www-bis-org-8025 334 20 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 21 D d NN www-bis-org-8025 334 22 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 23 Demand demand NN www-bis-org-8025 334 24 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 334 25 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 26 Supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 334 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 334 28 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 29 60 60 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 30 45 45 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 31 30 30 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 32 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 33 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 34 3.3 3.3 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 35 trans tran NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 36 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 334 37 sec sec NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 38 1.67 1.67 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 39 trans tran NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 40 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 334 41 sec sec NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 42 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 43 MB0.5 MB0.5 NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 44 MB MB NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 45 ≈ ≈ NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 46 ≈ ≈ NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 47 Block Block NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 48 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 334 49 Tr Tr NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 50 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 334 51 sa sa NN www-bis-org-8025 334 52 ct ct FW www-bis-org-8025 334 53 io io NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 54 n n NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 55 fe fe FW www-bis-org-8025 334 56 e e FW www-bis-org-8025 334 57 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 334 58 U U NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 59 SD SD NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 60 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 334 61 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 62 45 45 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 63 30 30 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 64 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 65 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 66 Q2 q2 NN www-bis-org-8025 334 67 18Q4 18q4 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 68 17Q2 17q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 69 17Q4 17q4 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 70 16Q2 16q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 71 16 16 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 72 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 73 8 8 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 74 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 75 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 76 Q2 q2 NN www-bis-org-8025 334 77 18Q4 18q4 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 78 17Q2 17q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 79 17Q4 17q4 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 80 16 16 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 81 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 82 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 334 83 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 334 84 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 334 85 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 86 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 334 87 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 334 88 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 334 89 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 334 90 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 334 91 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 334 92 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 334 93 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 334 94 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 334 95 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 96 17 17 CD www-bis-org-8025 334 97 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 334 98 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 334 99 model model NN www-bis-org-8025 334 100 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 334 101 free free RB www-bis-org-8025 334 102 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 334 103 riding riding NN www-bis-org-8025 334 104 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 334 105 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 334 106 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 334 107 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 334 108 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 109 Underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 334 110 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 334 111 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 334 112 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 334 113 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 334 114 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 334 115 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 334 116 externality externality NN www-bis-org-8025 334 117 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 334 118 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 334 119 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 334 120 termed term VBN www-bis-org-8025 334 121 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 334 122 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 334 123 tragedy tragedy NN www-bis-org-8025 334 124 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 334 125 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 334 126 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 334 127 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 334 128 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 334 129 . . . www-bis-org-8025 335 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 335 2 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 335 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 335 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 335 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 335 6 although although IN www-bis-org-8025 335 7 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 335 8 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 335 9 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 335 10 offer offer VBP www-bis-org-8025 335 11 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 335 12 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 335 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 335 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 335 15 benefits benefit NNS www-bis-org-8025 335 16 accrue accrue RB www-bis-org-8025 335 17 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 335 18 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 335 19 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 335 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 335 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 335 22 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 335 23 equally equally RB www-bis-org-8025 335 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 335 25 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 335 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 335 27 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 335 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 335 29 counterfeiting counterfeiting NN www-bis-org-8025 335 30 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 335 31 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 335 32 reproduce reproduce VB www-bis-org-8025 335 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 335 34 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 335 35 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 335 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 335 37 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 335 38 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 335 39 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 335 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 335 41 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 335 42 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 335 43 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 335 44 accrues accrue VBZ www-bis-org-8025 335 45 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 335 46 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 335 47 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 335 48 individually individually RB www-bis-org-8025 335 49 . . . www-bis-org-8025 336 1 Even even RB www-bis-org-8025 336 2 worse bad JJR www-bis-org-8025 336 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 336 4 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 336 5 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 336 6 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 336 7 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 336 8 ’s ’s '' www-bis-org-8025 336 9 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 336 10 depend depend VB www-bis-org-8025 336 11 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 336 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 336 13 sum sum NN www-bis-org-8025 336 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 336 15 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 336 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 336 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 336 18 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 336 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 336 20 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 336 21 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 336 22 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 336 23 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 336 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 336 25 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 336 26 one one PRP www-bis-org-8025 336 27 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 336 28 affect affect VB www-bis-org-8025 336 29 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 336 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 336 31 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 336 32 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 336 33 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 336 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 336 35 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 336 36 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 336 37 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 336 38 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 336 39 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 336 40 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 336 41 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 336 42 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 336 43 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 336 44 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 336 45 control control NN www-bis-org-8025 336 46 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 336 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 337 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 337 2 sum sum NN www-bis-org-8025 337 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 337 4 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 337 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 337 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 337 7 classical classical JJ www-bis-org-8025 337 8 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 337 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 337 10 rider rider NN www-bis-org-8025 337 11 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 337 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 338 1 To to TO www-bis-org-8025 338 2 put put VB www-bis-org-8025 338 3 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 338 4 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 338 6 rider rider NN www-bis-org-8025 338 7 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 338 8 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 338 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 10 formal formal JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 11 context context NN www-bis-org-8025 338 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 13 consider consider VB www-bis-org-8025 338 14 again again RB www-bis-org-8025 338 15 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 338 16 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 17 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 338 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 21 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 338 22 simplicity simplicity NN www-bis-org-8025 338 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 24 assume assume VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 25 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 338 26 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 338 27 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 28 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 29 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 30 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 31 so so IN www-bis-org-8025 338 32 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 338 33 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 34 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 35 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 36 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 338 37 only only JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 38 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 338 39 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 41 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 338 42 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 338 43 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 44 N n CD www-bis-org-8025 338 45 pending pende VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 46 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 47 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 338 48 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 49 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 338 50 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 338 51 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 52 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 338 53 S s NN www-bis-org-8025 338 54 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 55 so so IN www-bis-org-8025 338 56 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 338 57 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 58 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 59 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 338 60 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 61 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 338 62 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 338 63 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 64 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 338 65 SN SN NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 66 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 67 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 68 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 338 69 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 338 70 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 71 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 72 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 73 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 338 74 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 338 75 processed process VBN www-bis-org-8025 338 76 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 77 impatient impatient JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 78 : : : www-bis-org-8025 338 79 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 338 80 additional additional JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 81 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 338 82 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 338 83 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 338 84 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 338 85 need need VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 86 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 338 87 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 338 88 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 338 89 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 90 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 338 91 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 338 92 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 338 93 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 338 94 final25 final25 NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 95 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 338 96 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 97 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 338 98 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 338 99 µ µ NN www-bis-org-8025 338 100 S. S. NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 101 Rewriting Rewriting NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 102 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 338 103 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 104 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 105 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 106 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 338 107 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 338 108 assumptions assumption NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 109 yields yield NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 110 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 338 111 ∑ ∑ . www-bis-org-8025 338 112 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 338 113 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 114 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 115 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 116 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 117 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 118 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 119 Let let VB www-bis-org-8025 338 120 us -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 338 121 first first RB www-bis-org-8025 338 122 consider consider VB www-bis-org-8025 338 123 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 124 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 338 125 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 338 126 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 338 127 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 128 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 338 129 wanting want VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 130 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 338 131 transact transact NN www-bis-org-8025 338 132 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 338 133 coordinate coordinate VB www-bis-org-8025 338 134 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 338 135 agree agree VB www-bis-org-8025 338 136 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 338 137 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 138 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 139 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 338 140 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 141 resulting result VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 142 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 338 143 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 144 waittime waittime NN www-bis-org-8025 338 145 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 338 146 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 338 147 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 148 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 149 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 150 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 151 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 152 Users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 153 reduce reduce VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 154 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 338 155 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 156 minimum minimum NN www-bis-org-8025 338 157 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 158 sum sum NN www-bis-org-8025 338 159 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 338 160 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 161 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 162 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 338 163 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 338 164 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 165 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 338 166 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 338 167 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 168 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 169 μ μ NN www-bis-org-8025 338 170 : : : www-bis-org-8025 338 171 min min NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 172 + + SYM www-bis-org-8025 338 173 μ μ NN www-bis-org-8025 338 174 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 175 Optimisation Optimisation NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 176 results result VBZ www-bis-org-8025 338 177 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 338 178 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 338 179 optimal optimal JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 180 fee26 fee26 NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 181 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 182 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 338 183 μ μ NN www-bis-org-8025 338 184 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 185 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 338 186 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 187 ie ie IN www-bis-org-8025 338 188 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 189 optimal optimal JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 190 choice choice NN www-bis-org-8025 338 191 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 338 192 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 338 193 pay pay VB www-bis-org-8025 338 194 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 195 fraction fraction NN www-bis-org-8025 338 196 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 338 197 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 198 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 338 199 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 338 200 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 201 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 202 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 338 203 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 338 204 increasing increase VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 205 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 338 206 impatience impatience NN www-bis-org-8025 338 207 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 208 high high NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 209 μ μ NNP www-bis-org-8025 338 210 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 211 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 338 212 increasing increase VBG www-bis-org-8025 338 213 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 338 214 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 338 215 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 216 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 338 217 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 338 218 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 219 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 338 220 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 221 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 222 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 338 223 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 338 224 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 225 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 338 226 , , , www-bis-org-8025 338 227 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 338 228 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 338 229 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 338 230 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 338 231 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 338 232 . . . www-bis-org-8025 339 1 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 339 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 339 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 339 4 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 339 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 339 6 consider consider VB www-bis-org-8025 339 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 339 8 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 339 9 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 339 10 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 339 11 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 339 12 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 339 13 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 339 14 sets set VBZ www-bis-org-8025 339 15 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 339 16 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 339 17 privately privately RB www-bis-org-8025 339 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 339 19 taking take VBG www-bis-org-8025 339 20 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 339 21 account account NN www-bis-org-8025 339 22 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 339 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 339 24 benefit benefit NN www-bis-org-8025 339 25 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 339 26 themselves -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 339 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 340 1 Users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 340 2 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 340 3 symmetrical symmetrical JJ www-bis-org-8025 340 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 340 5 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 340 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 340 7 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 340 8 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 340 9 too too RB www-bis-org-8025 340 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 340 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 340 12 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 340 13 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 340 14 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 340 15 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 340 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 340 17 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 340 18 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 340 19 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 340 20 post post VBP www-bis-org-8025 340 21 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 340 22 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 340 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 341 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 341 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 341 3 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 341 4 setting set VBG www-bis-org-8025 341 5 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 341 6 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 341 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 341 8 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 341 9 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 341 10 considers consider VBZ www-bis-org-8025 341 11 deviating deviate VBG www-bis-org-8025 341 12 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 341 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 341 14 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 341 15 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 341 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 342 1 Denote denote VB www-bis-org-8025 342 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 342 3 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 342 4 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 342 5 individual individual JJ www-bis-org-8025 342 6 j j NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 8 paying pay VBG www-bis-org-8025 342 9 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 342 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 342 11 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 342 12 everyone everyone NN www-bis-org-8025 342 13 else else RB www-bis-org-8025 342 14 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 15 paying pay VBG www-bis-org-8025 342 16 by by RB www-bis-org-8025 342 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 342 18 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 342 19 holds hold VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 20 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 342 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 342 22 waittime waittime NN www-bis-org-8025 342 23 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 24 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 342 25 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 342 26 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 342 27 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 342 28 + + SYM www-bis-org-8025 342 29 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 30 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 342 31 ∗ ∗ NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 32 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 342 33 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 342 34 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 342 35 ℎ ℎ NN www-bis-org-8025 342 36 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 37 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 342 38 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 342 39 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 342 40 minimisation minimisation NN www-bis-org-8025 342 41 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 342 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 342 43 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 342 44 individual individual NN www-bis-org-8025 342 45 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 46 min min NN www-bis-org-8025 342 47 + + SYM www-bis-org-8025 342 48 μ μ NN www-bis-org-8025 342 49 , , , www-bis-org-8025 342 50 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 342 51 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 52 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 342 53 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 342 54 peculiar peculiar JJ www-bis-org-8025 342 55 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 342 56 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 342 57 order order NN www-bis-org-8025 342 58 condition condition NN www-bis-org-8025 342 59 : : : www-bis-org-8025 342 60 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 342 61 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 342 62 − − NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 63 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 342 64 11 11 CD www-bis-org-8025 342 65 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 342 66 25 25 CD www-bis-org-8025 342 67 Note note VBP www-bis-org-8025 342 68 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 342 69 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 342 70 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 342 71 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 342 72 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 73 distinct distinct JJ www-bis-org-8025 342 74 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 342 75 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 342 76 congestion congestion NN www-bis-org-8025 342 77 games game NNS www-bis-org-8025 342 78 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 342 79 Easley Easley NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 80 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 81 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 82 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 342 83 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 342 84 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 342 85 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 342 86 Huberman Huberman NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 87 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 88 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 342 89 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 342 90 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 342 91 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 342 92 , , , www-bis-org-8025 342 93 where where WRB www-bis-org-8025 342 94 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 342 95 may may MD www-bis-org-8025 342 96 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 342 97 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 342 98 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 342 99 maximum maximum JJ www-bis-org-8025 342 100 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 342 101 , , , www-bis-org-8025 342 102 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 342 103 resulting result VBG www-bis-org-8025 342 104 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 342 105 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 342 106 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 342 107 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 342 108 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 342 109 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 342 110 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 342 111 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 112 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 342 113 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 342 114 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 342 115 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 342 116 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 342 117 , , , www-bis-org-8025 342 118 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 342 119 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 342 120 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 342 121 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 122 happened happen VBN www-bis-org-8025 342 123 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 342 124 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 342 125 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 342 126 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 342 127 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 342 128 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 342 129 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 342 130 . . . www-bis-org-8025 343 1 Here here RB www-bis-org-8025 343 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 343 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 343 4 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 343 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 343 6 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 343 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 343 8 assumed assume VBN www-bis-org-8025 343 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 343 10 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 343 11 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 343 12 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 343 13 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 343 14 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 343 15 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 343 16 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 343 17 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 343 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 343 19 next next JJ www-bis-org-8025 343 20 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 343 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 343 22 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 343 23 those those DT www-bis-org-8025 343 24 receiving receive VBG www-bis-org-8025 343 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 343 26 funds fund NNS www-bis-org-8025 343 27 need need VBP www-bis-org-8025 343 28 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 343 29 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 343 30 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 343 31 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 343 32 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 343 33 until until IN www-bis-org-8025 343 34 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 343 35 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 343 36 consider consider VB www-bis-org-8025 343 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 343 38 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 343 39 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 343 40 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 343 41 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 343 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 344 1 26 26 CD www-bis-org-8025 344 2 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 344 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 344 4 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 344 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 344 6 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 344 7 optimum optimum NN www-bis-org-8025 344 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 344 9 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 344 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 344 11 constrained constrained JJ www-bis-org-8025 344 12 optimum optimum JJ www-bis-org-8025 344 13 satisfying satisfy VBG www-bis-org-8025 344 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 344 15 condition condition NN www-bis-org-8025 344 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 344 17 deterring deter VBG www-bis-org-8025 344 18 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 344 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 345 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 345 2 calculation calculation NN www-bis-org-8025 345 3 below below IN www-bis-org-8025 345 4 ignores ignore VBZ www-bis-org-8025 345 5 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 345 6 integer integer NN www-bis-org-8025 345 7 constraints constraint NNS www-bis-org-8025 345 8 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 345 9 waittimes waittime NNS www-bis-org-8025 345 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 346 1 18 18 CD www-bis-org-8025 346 2 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 346 3 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 346 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 346 5 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 346 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 346 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 346 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 346 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 346 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 346 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 346 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 346 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 346 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 346 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 346 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 346 17 Consider consider VBP www-bis-org-8025 346 18 first first RB www-bis-org-8025 346 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 346 20 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 346 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 346 22 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 346 23 j j NNP www-bis-org-8025 346 24 taking take VBG www-bis-org-8025 346 25 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 346 26 given give VBN www-bis-org-8025 346 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 346 28 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 346 29 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 346 30 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 346 31 others other NNS www-bis-org-8025 346 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 347 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 2 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 347 4 order order NN www-bis-org-8025 347 5 condition condition NN www-bis-org-8025 347 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 347 7 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 8 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 347 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 347 10 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 347 11 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 347 12 individual individual NN www-bis-org-8025 347 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 347 14 impatient impatient JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 347 16 high high NNP www-bis-org-8025 347 17 μ μ NNP www-bis-org-8025 347 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 347 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 347 20 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 347 21 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 347 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 23 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 24 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 347 25 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 347 26 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 347 27 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 347 28 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 29 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 347 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 31 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 347 32 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 347 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 34 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 347 35 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 347 36 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 347 37 N n CD www-bis-org-8025 347 38 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 347 39 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 40 others other NNS www-bis-org-8025 347 41 pay pay VBP www-bis-org-8025 347 42 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 347 43 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 44 , , , www-bis-org-8025 347 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 46 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 347 47 anticipates anticipate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 347 48 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 347 49 , , , www-bis-org-8025 347 50 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 347 51 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 52 absence absence NN www-bis-org-8025 347 53 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 347 54 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 347 55 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 56 own own JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 57 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 347 58 , , , www-bis-org-8025 347 59 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 347 60 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 347 61 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 347 62 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 347 63 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 347 64 extremely extremely RB www-bis-org-8025 347 65 long long JJ www-bis-org-8025 347 66 . . . www-bis-org-8025 348 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 348 2 μ μ NNP www-bis-org-8025 348 3 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 348 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 348 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 348 6 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 348 7 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 348 8 decides decide VBZ www-bis-org-8025 348 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 348 10 set set VB www-bis-org-8025 348 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 348 12 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 348 13 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 348 14 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 348 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 348 16 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 348 17 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 348 18 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 348 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 348 20 minimum minimum JJ www-bis-org-8025 348 21 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 348 22 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 348 23 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 348 24 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 348 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 348 26 essentially essentially RB www-bis-org-8025 348 27 putting put VBG www-bis-org-8025 348 28 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 348 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 348 30 entire entire JJ www-bis-org-8025 348 31 bill bill NN www-bis-org-8025 348 32 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 348 33 themselves -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 348 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 349 1 Another another DT www-bis-org-8025 349 2 extreme extreme NN www-bis-org-8025 349 3 – – : www-bis-org-8025 349 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 349 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 349 6 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 349 7 set set VBD www-bis-org-8025 349 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 349 9 lowest low JJS www-bis-org-8025 349 10 non non JJ www-bis-org-8025 349 11 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 349 12 zero zero JJ www-bis-org-8025 349 13 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 349 14 possible possible JJ www-bis-org-8025 349 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 349 16 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 349 17 Satoshi Satoshi NNP www-bis-org-8025 349 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 349 19 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 349 20 1/100’000’000 1/100’000’000 CD www-bis-org-8025 349 21 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 349 22 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 349 23 – – : www-bis-org-8025 349 24 results result NNS www-bis-org-8025 349 25 whenever whenever WRB www-bis-org-8025 349 26 μ μ NNP www-bis-org-8025 349 27 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 349 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 350 1 Of of RB www-bis-org-8025 350 2 course course RB www-bis-org-8025 350 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 350 4 everybody everybody NN www-bis-org-8025 350 5 else else RB www-bis-org-8025 350 6 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 350 7 making make VBG www-bis-org-8025 350 8 just just RB www-bis-org-8025 350 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 350 10 same same JJ www-bis-org-8025 350 11 calculation calculation NN www-bis-org-8025 350 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 350 13 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 350 14 regulates regulate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 350 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 350 16 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 350 17 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 350 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 351 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 351 2 everybody everybody NN www-bis-org-8025 351 3 else else RB www-bis-org-8025 351 4 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 351 5 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 351 6 set set VB www-bis-org-8025 351 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 351 8 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 351 9 just just RB www-bis-org-8025 351 10 marginally marginally RB www-bis-org-8025 351 11 above above IN www-bis-org-8025 351 12 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 351 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 351 14 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 351 15 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 351 16 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 351 17 provide provide VB www-bis-org-8025 351 18 almost almost RB www-bis-org-8025 351 19 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 351 20 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 351 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 351 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 351 23 j j NNP www-bis-org-8025 351 24 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 351 25 decide decide VB www-bis-org-8025 351 26 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 351 27 set set VB www-bis-org-8025 351 28 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 351 29 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 351 30 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 351 31 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 351 32 protect protect VB www-bis-org-8025 351 33 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 351 34 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 351 35 . . . www-bis-org-8025 352 1 Vice Vice NNP www-bis-org-8025 352 2 versa versa RB www-bis-org-8025 352 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 352 4 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 352 5 everybody everybody NN www-bis-org-8025 352 6 else else RB www-bis-org-8025 352 7 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 352 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 352 9 set set VB www-bis-org-8025 352 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 352 11 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 352 12 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 352 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 352 14 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 352 15 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 352 16 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 352 17 provide provide VB www-bis-org-8025 352 18 ample ample JJ www-bis-org-8025 352 19 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 352 20 anyway anyway RB www-bis-org-8025 352 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 352 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 352 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 352 24 since since IN www-bis-org-8025 352 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 352 26 expected expect VBN www-bis-org-8025 352 27 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 352 28 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 352 29 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 352 30 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 352 31 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 352 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 352 33 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 352 34 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 352 35 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 352 36 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 352 37 j j NNP www-bis-org-8025 352 38 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 352 39 set set VB www-bis-org-8025 352 40 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 352 41 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 352 42 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 352 43 close close JJ www-bis-org-8025 352 44 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 352 45 possible possible JJ www-bis-org-8025 352 46 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 352 47 zero zero CD www-bis-org-8025 352 48 . . . www-bis-org-8025 353 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 353 2 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 353 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 353 4 agents agent NNS www-bis-org-8025 353 5 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 353 6 symmetrical symmetrical JJ www-bis-org-8025 353 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 353 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 353 9 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 353 10 adjusts adjust NNS www-bis-org-8025 353 11 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 353 12 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 353 13 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 353 14 = = SYM www-bis-org-8025 353 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 354 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 354 2 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 354 3 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 354 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 354 5 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 354 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 354 7 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 354 8 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 354 9 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 354 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 354 11 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 354 12 basis basis NN www-bis-org-8025 354 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 354 14 much much RB www-bis-org-8025 354 15 lower low JJR www-bis-org-8025 354 16 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 354 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 354 18 optimal optimal JJ www-bis-org-8025 354 19 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 354 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 354 21 resulting result VBG www-bis-org-8025 354 22 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 354 23 extreme extreme JJ www-bis-org-8025 354 24 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 354 25 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 354 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 355 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 355 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 355 3 simply simply RB www-bis-org-8025 355 4 due due JJ www-bis-org-8025 355 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 355 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 355 7 presence presence NN www-bis-org-8025 355 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 355 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 355 10 typically typically RB www-bis-org-8025 355 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 355 12 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 355 13 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 355 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 355 15 up up IN www-bis-org-8025 355 16 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 355 17 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 355 18 2,000 2,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 355 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 355 20 due due IN www-bis-org-8025 355 21 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 355 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 355 23 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 355 24 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 355 25 limit limit NN www-bis-org-8025 355 26 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 355 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 355 28 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 355 29 well well RB www-bis-org-8025 355 30 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 355 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 355 32 presence presence NN www-bis-org-8025 355 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 355 34 μ μ NNP www-bis-org-8025 355 35 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 355 36 instead instead RB www-bis-org-8025 355 37 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 355 38 √μ √μ NNP www-bis-org-8025 355 39 a a NN www-bis-org-8025 355 40 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 355 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 355 42 centralised centralise VBN www-bis-org-8025 355 43 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 355 44 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 355 45 , , , www-bis-org-8025 355 46 typically typically RB www-bis-org-8025 355 47 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 355 48 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 355 49 low low JJ www-bis-org-8025 355 50 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 355 51 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 355 52 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 355 53 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 355 54 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 355 55 wait wait VB www-bis-org-8025 355 56 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 355 57 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 355 58 additional additional JJ www-bis-org-8025 355 59 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 355 60 – – : www-bis-org-8025 355 61 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 355 62 minutes minute NNS www-bis-org-8025 355 63 – – : www-bis-org-8025 355 64 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 355 65 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 355 66 small small JJ www-bis-org-8025 355 67 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 355 68 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 355 69 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 355 70 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 355 71 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 355 72 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 355 73 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 355 74 . . . www-bis-org-8025 356 1 With with IN www-bis-org-8025 356 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 356 3 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 356 4 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 356 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 356 6 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 356 7 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 356 8 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 356 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 356 10 ½ ½ NNP www-bis-org-8025 356 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 356 12 1,000 1,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 356 13 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 356 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 356 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 356 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 356 17 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 356 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 356 19 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 356 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 356 21 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 356 22 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 356 23 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 356 24 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 356 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 356 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 356 27 optimal optimal JJ www-bis-org-8025 356 28 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 356 29 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 356 30 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 356 31 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 356 32 7.07 7.07 CD www-bis-org-8025 356 33 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 356 34 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 356 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 356 36 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 356 37 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 356 38 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 356 39 resulting result VBG www-bis-org-8025 356 40 waittime waittime RB www-bis-org-8025 356 41 around around IN www-bis-org-8025 356 42 seven seven CD www-bis-org-8025 356 43 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 356 44 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 356 45 , , , www-bis-org-8025 356 46 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 356 47 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 356 48 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 356 49 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 356 50 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 356 51 1%/1000=0.001 1%/1000=0.001 NNP www-bis-org-8025 356 52 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 356 53 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 356 54 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 356 55 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 356 56 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 356 57 . . . www-bis-org-8025 357 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 357 2 resulting result VBG www-bis-org-8025 357 3 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 357 4 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 357 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 357 6 50,000 50,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 357 7 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 357 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 357 9 equivalent equivalent JJ www-bis-org-8025 357 10 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 357 11 almost almost RB www-bis-org-8025 357 12 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 357 13 year year NN www-bis-org-8025 357 14 ! ! . www-bis-org-8025 358 1 Some some DT www-bis-org-8025 358 2 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 358 3 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 358 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 358 5 road road NN www-bis-org-8025 358 6 ahead ahead RB www-bis-org-8025 358 7 Ingenious ingenious JJ www-bis-org-8025 358 8 though though IN www-bis-org-8025 358 9 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 358 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 358 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 358 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 358 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 358 14 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 358 15 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 358 16 severe severe JJ www-bis-org-8025 358 17 limitations limitation NNS www-bis-org-8025 358 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 358 19 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 358 20 revealed reveal VBN www-bis-org-8025 358 21 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 358 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 358 23 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 358 24 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 358 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 358 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 358 27 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 358 28 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 358 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 359 1 What what WP www-bis-org-8025 359 2 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 359 3 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 359 4 imply imply VB www-bis-org-8025 359 5 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 359 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 359 7 road road NN www-bis-org-8025 359 8 ahead ahead RB www-bis-org-8025 359 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 359 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 359 11 outlook outlook NN www-bis-org-8025 359 12 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 359 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 359 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 359 15 related related JJ www-bis-org-8025 359 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 359 17 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 360 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 360 2 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 360 3 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 360 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 360 5 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 360 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 360 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 360 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 360 9 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 360 10 Putting put VBG www-bis-org-8025 360 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 360 12 pieces piece NNS www-bis-org-8025 360 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 360 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 360 15 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 360 16 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 360 17 together together RB www-bis-org-8025 360 18 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 360 19 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 360 20 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 360 21 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 360 22 liquidity liquidity NN www-bis-org-8025 360 23 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 360 24 fall fall VB www-bis-org-8025 360 25 substantially substantially RB www-bis-org-8025 360 26 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 360 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 360 28 years year NNS www-bis-org-8025 360 29 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 360 30 come come VB www-bis-org-8025 360 31 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 360 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 360 33 absence absence NN www-bis-org-8025 360 34 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 360 35 relevant relevant JJ www-bis-org-8025 360 36 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 360 37 advances advance NNS www-bis-org-8025 360 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 361 1 One one PRP www-bis-org-8025 361 2 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 361 3 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 361 4 keep keep VB www-bis-org-8025 361 5 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 361 6 mind mind NN www-bis-org-8025 361 7 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 361 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 361 9 together together RB www-bis-org-8025 361 10 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 361 11 self self NN www-bis-org-8025 361 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 361 13 calibrating calibrate VBG www-bis-org-8025 361 14 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 361 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 361 16 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 361 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 361 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 361 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 361 20 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 361 21 becomes become VBZ www-bis-org-8025 361 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 361 23 deeply deeply RB www-bis-org-8025 361 24 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 361 25 concept concept NN www-bis-org-8025 361 26 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 361 27 ultimately ultimately RB www-bis-org-8025 361 28 proves prove VBZ www-bis-org-8025 361 29 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 361 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 361 31 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 361 32 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 361 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 361 34 real real JJ www-bis-org-8025 361 35 resources resource NNS www-bis-org-8025 361 36 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 361 37 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 361 38 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 361 39 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 361 40 computations computation NNS www-bis-org-8025 361 41 . . . www-bis-org-8025 362 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 362 2 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 362 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 362 4 insensitive insensitive JJ www-bis-org-8025 362 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 362 6 general general JJ www-bis-org-8025 362 7 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 362 8 progress progress NN www-bis-org-8025 362 9 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 362 10 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 362 11 very very JJ www-bis-org-8025 362 12 design design NN www-bis-org-8025 362 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 363 1 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 363 2 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 363 3 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 363 4 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 363 5 – – : www-bis-org-8025 363 6 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 363 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 363 8 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 363 9 present present NN www-bis-org-8025 363 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 363 11 represent represent VB www-bis-org-8025 363 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 363 13 vast vast JJ www-bis-org-8025 363 14 majority majority NN www-bis-org-8025 363 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 363 16 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 363 17 ’ ’ POS www-bis-org-8025 363 18 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 363 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 363 20 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 363 21 underpin underpin VBZ www-bis-org-8025 363 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 363 23 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 363 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 363 25 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 363 26 – – : www-bis-org-8025 363 27 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 363 28 gradually gradually RB www-bis-org-8025 363 29 phased phase VBN www-bis-org-8025 363 30 out out RP www-bis-org-8025 363 31 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 363 32 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 363 33 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 363 34 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 363 35 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 363 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 363 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 363 38 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 363 39 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 363 40 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 363 41 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 363 42 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 363 43 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 363 44 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 363 45 deteriorate deteriorate VB www-bis-org-8025 363 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 364 1 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 364 2 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 364 3 gives give VBZ www-bis-org-8025 364 4 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 364 5 outlook outlook NN www-bis-org-8025 364 6 regarding regard VBG www-bis-org-8025 364 7 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 364 8 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 364 9 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 364 10 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 364 11 increase increase VB www-bis-org-8025 364 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 364 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 364 14 years year NNS www-bis-org-8025 364 15 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 364 16 come come VB www-bis-org-8025 364 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 364 18 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 364 19 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 364 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 364 21 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 364 22 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 364 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 364 24 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 364 25 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 364 26 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 364 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 364 28 deter deter VB www-bis-org-8025 364 29 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 364 30 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 364 31 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 364 32 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 364 33 , , , www-bis-org-8025 364 34 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 364 35 particular particular JJ www-bis-org-8025 364 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 364 37 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 364 38 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 364 39 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 364 40 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 364 41 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 364 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 365 1 Against against IN www-bis-org-8025 365 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 365 3 dire dire JJ www-bis-org-8025 365 4 backdrop backdrop NN www-bis-org-8025 365 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 365 6 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 365 7 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 365 8 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 365 9 noted note VBN www-bis-org-8025 365 10 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 365 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 365 12 code code NN www-bis-org-8025 365 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 365 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 365 15 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 365 16 far far RB www-bis-org-8025 365 17 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 365 18 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 365 19 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 365 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 365 21 stone stone NN www-bis-org-8025 365 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 366 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 366 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 366 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 366 4 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 366 5 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 366 6 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 366 7 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 366 8 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 366 9 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 366 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 366 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 366 12 leading lead VBG www-bis-org-8025 366 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 366 14 software software NN www-bis-org-8025 366 15 client client NN www-bis-org-8025 366 16 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 366 17 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 366 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 366 19 Core Core NNP www-bis-org-8025 366 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 366 21 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 366 22 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 366 23 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 366 24 introduced introduce VBN www-bis-org-8025 366 25 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 366 26 adopted adopt VBN www-bis-org-8025 366 27 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 366 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 366 29 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 366 30 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 366 31 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 366 32 nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 366 33 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 366 34 time.27 time.27 NNP www-bis-org-8025 366 35 These these DT www-bis-org-8025 366 36 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 366 37 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 366 38 mostly mostly RB www-bis-org-8025 366 39 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 366 40 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 366 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 366 42 spirit spirit NN www-bis-org-8025 366 43 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 366 44 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 366 45 original original JJ www-bis-org-8025 366 46 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 366 47 developed develop VBN www-bis-org-8025 366 48 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 366 49 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 366 50 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 366 51 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 366 52 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 366 53 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 366 54 although although IN www-bis-org-8025 366 55 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 366 56 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 366 57 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 366 58 controversies controversy NNS www-bis-org-8025 366 59 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 366 60 , , , www-bis-org-8025 366 61 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 366 62 improve improve VB www-bis-org-8025 366 63 technical technical JJ www-bis-org-8025 366 64 aspects aspect NNS www-bis-org-8025 366 65 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 366 66 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 366 67 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 366 68 nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 366 69 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 366 70 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 366 71 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 366 72 communicate communicate VBP www-bis-org-8025 366 73 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 366 74 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 366 75 another another DT www-bis-org-8025 366 76 . . . www-bis-org-8025 367 1 27 27 CD www-bis-org-8025 367 2 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 367 3 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 367 4 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 367 5 node node NN www-bis-org-8025 367 6 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 367 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 367 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 367 9 computer computer NN www-bis-org-8025 367 10 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 367 11 server server NN www-bis-org-8025 367 12 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 367 13 maintains maintain VBZ www-bis-org-8025 367 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 367 15 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 367 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 367 17 up up RB www-bis-org-8025 367 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 367 19 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 367 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 367 21 date date NN www-bis-org-8025 367 22 copy copy NN www-bis-org-8025 367 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 367 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 367 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 367 26 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 367 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 368 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 368 2 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 368 3 node node NN www-bis-org-8025 368 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 368 5 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 368 6 reachable reachable JJ www-bis-org-8025 368 7 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 368 8 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 368 9 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 368 10 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 368 11 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 368 12 receives receive VBZ www-bis-org-8025 368 13 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 368 14 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 368 15 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 368 16 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 368 17 reachable reachable JJ www-bis-org-8025 368 18 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 368 19 nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 368 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 368 21 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 368 22 propagates propagate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 368 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 368 24 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 368 25 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 368 26 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 368 27 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 368 28 nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 368 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 369 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 369 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 369 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 369 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 369 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 369 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 369 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 369 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 369 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 369 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 369 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 369 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 369 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 369 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 369 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 369 16 19 19 CD www-bis-org-8025 369 17 While while IN www-bis-org-8025 369 18 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 369 19 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 369 20 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 369 21 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 369 22 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 369 23 developments development NNS www-bis-org-8025 369 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 369 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 369 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 369 27 context context NN www-bis-org-8025 369 28 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 369 29 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 369 30 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 369 31 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 369 32 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 369 33 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 369 34 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 369 35 noted note VBN www-bis-org-8025 369 36 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 369 37 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 369 38 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 369 39 aimed aim VBN www-bis-org-8025 369 40 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 369 41 boosting boost VBG www-bis-org-8025 369 42 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 369 43 volume volume NN www-bis-org-8025 369 44 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 369 45 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 369 46 rather rather RB www-bis-org-8025 369 47 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 369 48 improving improve VBG www-bis-org-8025 369 49 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 369 50 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 369 51 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 369 52 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 369 53 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 369 54 . . . www-bis-org-8025 370 1 28 28 CD www-bis-org-8025 370 2 So so RB www-bis-org-8025 370 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 370 4 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 370 5 pruning pruning NN www-bis-org-8025 370 6 replaces replace NNS www-bis-org-8025 370 7 older old JJR www-bis-org-8025 370 8 parts part NNS www-bis-org-8025 370 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 370 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 370 11 history history NN www-bis-org-8025 370 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 370 13 past past JJ www-bis-org-8025 370 14 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 370 15 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 370 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 370 17 netted net VBN www-bis-org-8025 370 18 representation representation NN www-bis-org-8025 370 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 370 20 ownership ownership NN www-bis-org-8025 370 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 370 22 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 370 23 reduces reduce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 370 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 370 25 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 370 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 370 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 370 28 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 370 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 371 1 Other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 371 2 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 371 3 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 371 4 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 371 5 store store VB www-bis-org-8025 371 6 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 371 7 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 371 8 efficiently efficiently RB www-bis-org-8025 371 9 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 371 10 shifting shift VBG www-bis-org-8025 371 11 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 371 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 371 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 371 14 information information NN www-bis-org-8025 371 15 off off IN www-bis-org-8025 371 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 371 17 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 371 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 371 19 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 371 20 particular particular JJ www-bis-org-8025 371 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 371 22 28 28 CD www-bis-org-8025 371 23 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 371 24 discussing discuss VBG www-bis-org-8025 371 25 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 371 26 innovations innovation NNS www-bis-org-8025 371 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 371 28 one one PRP www-bis-org-8025 371 29 must must MD www-bis-org-8025 371 30 move move VB www-bis-org-8025 371 31 beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 371 32 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 371 33 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 371 34 most most JJS www-bis-org-8025 371 35 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 371 36 technologies technology NNS www-bis-org-8025 371 37 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 371 38 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 371 39 developed develop VBN www-bis-org-8025 371 40 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 371 41 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 371 42 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 371 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 372 1 However however RB www-bis-org-8025 372 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 372 3 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 372 4 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 372 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 372 6 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 372 7 technologies technology NNS www-bis-org-8025 372 8 demonstrate demonstrate VBP www-bis-org-8025 372 9 substantial substantial JJ www-bis-org-8025 372 10 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 372 11 gains gain NNS www-bis-org-8025 372 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 372 13 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 372 14 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 372 15 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 372 16 adopted adopt VBN www-bis-org-8025 372 17 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 372 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 372 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 373 1 Substantially substantially RB www-bis-org-8025 373 2 longer long RBR www-bis-org-8025 373 3 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 373 4 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 373 5 result result VBP www-bis-org-8025 373 6 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 373 7 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 373 8 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 373 9 decline decline VBP www-bis-org-8025 373 10 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 373 11 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 373 12 Hours hour NNS www-bis-org-8025 373 13 Dashed dash VBN www-bis-org-8025 373 14 pattern pattern NN www-bis-org-8025 373 15 indicates indicate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 373 16 predicted predict VBN www-bis-org-8025 373 17 values value NNS www-bis-org-8025 373 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 374 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 374 2 lines line NNS www-bis-org-8025 374 3 displayed display VBD www-bis-org-8025 374 4 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 374 5 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 374 6 graph graph NN www-bis-org-8025 374 7 show show VBP www-bis-org-8025 374 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 374 9 implied imply VBN www-bis-org-8025 374 10 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 374 11 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 374 12 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 374 13 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 374 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 374 15 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 374 16 confirmations confirmation NNS www-bis-org-8025 374 17 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 374 18 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 374 19 assume assume VBP www-bis-org-8025 374 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 374 21 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 374 22 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 374 23 irreversible irreversible JJ www-bis-org-8025 374 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 374 25 release release VB www-bis-org-8025 374 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 374 27 merchandise merchandise NN www-bis-org-8025 374 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 374 29 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 374 30 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 374 31 make make VB www-bis-org-8025 374 32 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 374 33 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 374 34 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 374 35 unprofitable unprofitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 374 36 : : : www-bis-org-8025 374 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 374 38 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 374 39 rents rent NNS www-bis-org-8025 374 40 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 374 41 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 374 42 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 374 43 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 374 44 short- short- JJ www-bis-org-8025 374 45 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 374 46 basis basis NN www-bis-org-8025 374 47 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 374 48 executes execute VBZ www-bis-org-8025 374 49 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 374 50 change change NN www-bis-org-8025 374 51 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 374 52 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 374 53 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 374 54 history history NN www-bis-org-8025 374 55 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 374 56 . . . www-bis-org-8025 375 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 375 2 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 375 3 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 375 4 depends depend VBZ www-bis-org-8025 375 5 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 375 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 375 7 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 375 8 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 375 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 375 10 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 375 11 consists consist VBZ www-bis-org-8025 375 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 375 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 375 14 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 375 15 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 375 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 375 17 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 375 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 375 19 term term NN www-bis-org-8025 375 20 rentals rental NNS www-bis-org-8025 375 21 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 375 22 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 375 23 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 375 24 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 375 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 375 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 375 27 likelihood likelihood NN www-bis-org-8025 375 28 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 375 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 375 30 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 375 31 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 375 32 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 375 33 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 375 34 collapse collapse VB www-bis-org-8025 375 35 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 375 36 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 375 37 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 375 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 376 1 Calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 376 2 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 376 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 376 4 implied imply VBN www-bis-org-8025 376 5 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 376 6 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 376 7 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 376 8 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 376 9 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 376 10 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 376 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 376 12 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 376 13 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 376 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 376 15 assume assume VB www-bis-org-8025 376 16 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 376 17 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 376 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 376 19 0.18 0.18 CD www-bis-org-8025 376 20 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 376 21 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 376 22 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 376 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 376 24 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 376 25 corresponds correspond VBZ www-bis-org-8025 376 26 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 376 27 average average VB www-bis-org-8025 376 28 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 376 29 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 376 30 during during IN www-bis-org-8025 376 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 376 32 period period NN www-bis-org-8025 376 33 30 30 CD www-bis-org-8025 376 34 Apr Apr NNP www-bis-org-8025 376 35 2018–31 2018–31 NN www-bis-org-8025 376 36 Oct Oct NNP www-bis-org-8025 376 37 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 376 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 377 1 Sources source NNS www-bis-org-8025 377 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 377 3 https://bitinfocharts.com https://bitinfocharts.com ADD www-bis-org-8025 377 4 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 377 5 https://coinmetrics.io https://coinmetrics.io NNP www-bis-org-8025 377 6 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 377 7 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 377 8 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 377 9 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 377 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 378 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 378 2 evolution evolution NN www-bis-org-8025 378 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 378 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 378 5 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 378 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 378 7 node node NN www-bis-org-8025 378 8 clients client NNS www-bis-org-8025 378 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 378 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 378 11 Core Core NNP www-bis-org-8025 378 12 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 378 13 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 378 14 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 378 15 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 378 16 Number number NN www-bis-org-8025 378 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 378 18 nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 378 19 Distribution distribution NN www-bis-org-8025 378 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 378 21 reachable reachable JJ www-bis-org-8025 378 22 full full JJ www-bis-org-8025 378 23 nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 378 24 across across IN www-bis-org-8025 378 25 leading lead VBG www-bis-org-8025 378 26 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 378 27 agents agent NNS www-bis-org-8025 378 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 379 1 Source source NN www-bis-org-8025 379 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 379 3 bitnodes.earn.com bitnodes.earn.com NNP www-bis-org-8025 379 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 379 5 site site NN www-bis-org-8025 379 6 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 379 7 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 379 8 18.05.2018 18.05.2018 NNP www-bis-org-8025 379 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 379 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 380 1 500 500 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 2 250 250 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 3 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 4 20322030202820262024202220202018201620142012 20322030202820262024202220202018201620142012 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 5 Attacker Attacker NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 6 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 380 7 1/2 1/2 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 8 Attacker Attacker NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 9 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 380 10 1/9 1/9 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 11 12,500 12,500 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 12 10,000 10,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 13 7,500 7,500 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 14 5,000 5,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 15 2,500 2,500 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 16 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 17 Q2 q2 NN www-bis-org-8025 380 18 2018Q1 2018q1 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 19 2018Q4 2018q4 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 20 2017Q3 2017q3 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 21 2017Q2 2017q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 22 2017Q1 2017q1 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 23 2017Q4 2017q4 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 24 2016Q3 2016q3 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 25 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 26 Other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 380 27 Satoshi132 Satoshi132 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 28 Satoshi150 Satoshi150 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 29 Satoshi121 Satoshi121 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 30 Satoshi1699 Satoshi1699 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 31 Satoshi1501 Satoshi1501 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 32 Satoshi142 Satoshi142 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 33 Satoshi151 Satoshi151 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 34 Satoshi16 Satoshi16 NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 35 https://bitnodes.earn.com/dashboard/ https://bitnodes.earn.com/dashboard/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 36 https://coinmetrics.io/ https://coinmetrics.io/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 37 https://bitinfocharts.com/ https://bitinfocharts.com/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 38 20 20 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 39 WP765 wp765 NN www-bis-org-8025 380 40 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 380 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 380 42 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 43 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 380 44 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 380 45 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 380 46 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 380 47 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 380 48 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 380 49 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 380 50 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 380 51 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 380 52 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 380 53 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 380 54 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 380 55 capacity capacity NN www-bis-org-8025 380 56 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 380 57 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 380 58 boosted boost VBN www-bis-org-8025 380 59 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 380 60 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 380 61 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 380 62 Segwit Segwit NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 63 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 380 64 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 380 65 signatures signature NNS www-bis-org-8025 380 66 , , , www-bis-org-8025 380 67 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 380 68 available available JJ www-bis-org-8025 380 69 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 380 70 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 71 Core Core NNP www-bis-org-8025 380 72 clients client NNS www-bis-org-8025 380 73 16.0 16.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 380 74 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 380 75 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 380 76 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 380 77 . . . www-bis-org-8025 381 1 Last last RB www-bis-org-8025 381 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 381 3 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 381 4 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 381 5 proposals proposal NNS www-bis-org-8025 381 6 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 381 7 do do VB www-bis-org-8025 381 8 away away RB www-bis-org-8025 381 9 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 381 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 381 11 strictly strictly RB www-bis-org-8025 381 12 linear linear JJ www-bis-org-8025 381 13 database database NN www-bis-org-8025 381 14 structure structure NN www-bis-org-8025 381 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 381 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 381 17 blockchain29 blockchain29 NNS www-bis-org-8025 381 18 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 381 19 partition partition VB www-bis-org-8025 381 20 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 381 21 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 381 22 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 381 23 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 381 24 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 381 25 sharding sharding NN www-bis-org-8025 381 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 382 1 Second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 382 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 382 3 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 382 4 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 382 5 One one CD www-bis-org-8025 382 6 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 382 7 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 382 8 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 382 9 improve improve VB www-bis-org-8025 382 10 upon upon IN www-bis-org-8025 382 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 382 12 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 382 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 382 14 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 382 15 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 382 16 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 382 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 382 18 development development NN www-bis-org-8025 382 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 382 20 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 382 21 second- second- NNP www-bis-org-8025 382 22 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 382 23 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 382 24 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 382 25 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 382 26 essentially essentially RB www-bis-org-8025 382 27 aim aim VBP www-bis-org-8025 382 28 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 382 29 add add VB www-bis-org-8025 382 30 liquid liquid JJ www-bis-org-8025 382 31 methods method NNS www-bis-org-8025 382 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 382 33 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 382 34 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 382 35 top top NN www-bis-org-8025 382 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 382 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 382 38 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 382 39 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 382 40 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 382 41 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 382 42 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 382 43 serves serve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 382 44 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 382 45 evidence evidence VB www-bis-org-8025 382 46 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 382 47 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 382 48 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 382 49 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 382 50 . . . www-bis-org-8025 383 1 Most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 383 2 prominent prominent JJ www-bis-org-8025 383 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 383 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 383 5 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 383 6 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 383 7 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 383 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 383 9 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 383 10 proposed propose VBN www-bis-org-8025 383 11 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 383 12 Poon Poon NNP www-bis-org-8025 383 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 383 14 Dryja Dryja NNP www-bis-org-8025 383 15 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 383 16 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 383 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 383 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 384 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 384 2 idea idea NN www-bis-org-8025 384 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 384 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 384 5 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 384 6 parties party NNS www-bis-org-8025 384 7 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 384 8 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 384 9 B b NN www-bis-org-8025 384 10 jointly jointly RB www-bis-org-8025 384 11 lock lock VB www-bis-org-8025 384 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 384 13 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 384 14 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 384 15 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 384 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 384 17 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 384 18 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 384 19 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 384 20 joint joint JJ www-bis-org-8025 384 21 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 384 22 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 384 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 385 1 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 385 2 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 385 3 B b NN www-bis-org-8025 385 4 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 385 5 then then RB www-bis-org-8025 385 6 run run VB www-bis-org-8025 385 7 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 385 8 side side NN www-bis-org-8025 385 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 385 10 contract contract NN www-bis-org-8025 385 11 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 385 12 keeps keep VBZ www-bis-org-8025 385 13 track track NN www-bis-org-8025 385 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 385 15 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 385 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 385 17 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 385 18 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 385 19 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 385 20 split split VBN www-bis-org-8025 385 21 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 385 22 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 385 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 385 24 B. B. NNP www-bis-org-8025 386 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 386 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 386 3 side side NN www-bis-org-8025 386 4 contract contract NN www-bis-org-8025 386 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 386 6 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 386 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 386 8 B b NN www-bis-org-8025 386 9 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 386 10 shift shift VB www-bis-org-8025 386 11 funds fund NNS www-bis-org-8025 386 12 back back RB www-bis-org-8025 386 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 386 14 forth forth RB www-bis-org-8025 386 15 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 386 16 digitally digitally RB www-bis-org-8025 386 17 signing sign VBG www-bis-org-8025 386 18 off off RP www-bis-org-8025 386 19 changes change NNS www-bis-org-8025 386 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 386 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 386 22 balance balance NN www-bis-org-8025 386 23 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 386 24 creating create VBG www-bis-org-8025 386 25 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 386 26 traffic traffic NN www-bis-org-8025 386 27 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 386 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 386 29 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 386 30 itself -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 386 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 387 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 387 2 subcontract subcontract NN www-bis-org-8025 387 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 387 4 netted net VBN www-bis-org-8025 387 5 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 387 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 387 7 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 387 8 only only RB www-bis-org-8025 387 9 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 387 10 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 387 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 387 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 387 13 parties party NNS www-bis-org-8025 387 14 wants want VBZ www-bis-org-8025 387 15 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 387 16 settle settle VB www-bis-org-8025 387 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 388 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 388 2 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 388 3 element element NN www-bis-org-8025 388 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 388 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 388 6 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 388 7 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 388 8 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 388 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 388 10 connect connect VB www-bis-org-8025 388 11 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 388 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 388 13 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 388 14 prefunded prefunde VBN www-bis-org-8025 388 15 bilateral bilateral JJ www-bis-org-8025 388 16 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 388 17 channels channel NNS www-bis-org-8025 388 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 388 19 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 388 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 388 21 goal goal NN www-bis-org-8025 388 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 388 23 scaling scale VBG www-bis-org-8025 388 24 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 388 25 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 388 26 working work VBG www-bis-org-8025 388 27 micro micro JJ www-bis-org-8025 388 28 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 388 29 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 388 30 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 388 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 389 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 389 2 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 389 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 389 4 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 389 5 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 389 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 389 7 let let VB www-bis-org-8025 389 8 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 389 9 route route VB www-bis-org-8025 389 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 389 11 micro micro JJ www-bis-org-8025 389 12 - - NN www-bis-org-8025 389 13 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 389 14 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 389 15 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 389 16 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 389 17 B. B. NNP www-bis-org-8025 390 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 390 2 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 390 3 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 390 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 390 5 already already RB www-bis-org-8025 390 6 working work VBG www-bis-org-8025 390 7 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 390 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 390 9 test test NN www-bis-org-8025 390 10 environment environment NN www-bis-org-8025 390 11 . . . www-bis-org-8025 391 1 As as IN www-bis-org-8025 391 2 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 391 3 early early JJ www-bis-org-8025 391 4 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 391 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 391 6 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 391 7 500 500 CD www-bis-org-8025 391 8 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 391 9 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 391 10 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 391 11 committed commit VBN www-bis-org-8025 391 12 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 391 13 bilateral bilateral JJ www-bis-org-8025 391 14 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 391 15 channels channel NNS www-bis-org-8025 391 16 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 391 17 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 391 18 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 391 19 11 11 CD www-bis-org-8025 391 20 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 391 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 391 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 391 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 391 24 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 391 25 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 391 26 able able JJ www-bis-org-8025 391 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 391 28 route route VB www-bis-org-8025 391 29 small small JJ www-bis-org-8025 391 30 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 391 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 392 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 392 2 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 392 3 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 392 4 opens open VBZ www-bis-org-8025 392 5 up up RP www-bis-org-8025 392 6 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 392 7 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 392 8 options option NNS www-bis-org-8025 392 9 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 392 10 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 392 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 392 12 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 392 13 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 392 14 theoretically theoretically RB www-bis-org-8025 392 15 allows allow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 392 16 bilateral bilateral JJ www-bis-org-8025 392 17 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 392 18 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 392 19 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 392 20 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 392 21 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 392 22 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 392 23 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 392 24 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 392 25 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 392 26 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 392 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 392 28 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 392 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 393 1 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 393 2 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 393 3 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 393 4 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 393 5 occur occur VBP www-bis-org-8025 393 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 393 7 separate separate JJ www-bis-org-8025 393 8 bilateral bilateral JJ www-bis-org-8025 393 9 contracts contract NNS www-bis-org-8025 393 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 393 11 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 393 12 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 393 13 somewhat somewhat RB www-bis-org-8025 393 14 reduce reduce VB www-bis-org-8025 393 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 393 16 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 393 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 393 18 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 393 19 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 393 20 : : : www-bis-org-8025 393 21 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 393 22 both both DT www-bis-org-8025 393 23 opening opening NN www-bis-org-8025 393 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 393 25 netting net VBG www-bis-org-8025 393 26 bilateral bilateral JJ www-bis-org-8025 393 27 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 393 28 channels channel NNS www-bis-org-8025 393 29 creates create VBZ www-bis-org-8025 393 30 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 393 31 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 393 32 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 393 33 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 393 34 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 393 35 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 393 36 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 393 37 requiring require VBG www-bis-org-8025 393 38 entries entry NNS www-bis-org-8025 393 39 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 393 40 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 393 41 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 393 42 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 393 43 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 393 44 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 393 45 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 393 46 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 393 47 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 393 48 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 393 49 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 393 50 , , , www-bis-org-8025 393 51 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 393 52 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 393 53 themselves -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 393 54 occur occur VBP www-bis-org-8025 393 55 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 393 56 off off IN www-bis-org-8025 393 57 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 393 58 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 393 59 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 393 60 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 393 61 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 393 62 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 393 63 corresponding correspond VBG www-bis-org-8025 393 64 entry entry NN www-bis-org-8025 393 65 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 393 66 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 393 67 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 393 68 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 393 69 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 393 70 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 393 71 do do VBP www-bis-org-8025 393 72 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 393 73 directly directly RB www-bis-org-8025 393 74 require require VB www-bis-org-8025 393 75 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 393 76 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 393 77 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 393 78 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 393 79 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 393 80 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 393 81 . . . www-bis-org-8025 394 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 394 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 394 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 4 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 394 5 every every DT www-bis-org-8025 394 6 channel channel NN www-bis-org-8025 394 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 394 8 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 394 9 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 394 10 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 394 11 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 394 12 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 394 13 opening open VBG www-bis-org-8025 394 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 394 15 netting netting JJ www-bis-org-8025 394 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 17 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 394 18 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 394 19 offer offer VB www-bis-org-8025 394 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 394 21 scaling scale VBG www-bis-org-8025 394 22 factor factor NN www-bis-org-8025 394 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 394 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 394 25 very very RB www-bis-org-8025 394 26 roughly roughly RB www-bis-org-8025 394 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 394 28 five five CD www-bis-org-8025 394 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 30 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 394 31 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 394 32 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 394 33 purely purely RB www-bis-org-8025 394 34 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 394 35 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 394 36 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 394 37 transactions.30 transactions.30 NNP www-bis-org-8025 394 38 It -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 394 39 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 394 40 unclear unclear JJ www-bis-org-8025 394 41 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 42 however however RB www-bis-org-8025 394 43 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 44 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 394 45 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 394 46 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 394 47 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 394 48 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 394 49 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 394 50 themselves -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 394 51 scale scale VB www-bis-org-8025 394 52 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 53 ie ie IN www-bis-org-8025 394 54 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 394 55 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 394 56 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 394 57 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 394 58 restricted restrict VBN www-bis-org-8025 394 59 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 394 60 serving serve VBG www-bis-org-8025 394 61 small small JJ www-bis-org-8025 394 62 subnetworks subnetwork NNS www-bis-org-8025 394 63 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 394 64 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 394 65 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 394 66 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 67 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 394 68 envisioned envision VBN www-bis-org-8025 394 69 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 394 70 Poon Poon NNP www-bis-org-8025 394 71 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 394 72 Dryja Dryja NNP www-bis-org-8025 394 73 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 394 74 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 394 75 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 394 76 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 77 scale scale VBP www-bis-org-8025 394 78 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 394 79 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 394 80 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 394 81 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 394 82 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 83 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 394 84 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 394 85 law law NN www-bis-org-8025 394 86 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 394 87 six six CD www-bis-org-8025 394 88 degrees degree NNS www-bis-org-8025 394 89 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 394 90 separation separation NN www-bis-org-8025 394 91 , , , www-bis-org-8025 394 92 connects connect VBZ www-bis-org-8025 394 93 everyone everyone NN www-bis-org-8025 394 94 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 394 95 everyone everyone NN www-bis-org-8025 394 96 else else RB www-bis-org-8025 394 97 . . . www-bis-org-8025 395 1 There there EX www-bis-org-8025 395 2 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 395 3 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 395 4 sets set NNS www-bis-org-8025 395 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 395 6 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 395 7 concerns concern NNS www-bis-org-8025 395 8 . . . www-bis-org-8025 396 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 396 2 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 396 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 396 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 396 5 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 396 6 technical technical JJ www-bis-org-8025 396 7 nature nature NN www-bis-org-8025 396 8 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 396 9 beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 396 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 396 11 scope scope NN www-bis-org-8025 396 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 396 13 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 396 14 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 396 15 – – : www-bis-org-8025 396 16 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 396 17 relates relate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 396 18 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 396 19 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 396 20 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 396 21 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 396 22 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 396 23 deter deter VB www-bis-org-8025 396 24 potential potential JJ www-bis-org-8025 396 25 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 396 26 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 396 27 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 396 28 specific specific JJ www-bis-org-8025 396 29 architecture architecture NN www-bis-org-8025 396 30 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 396 31 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 396 32 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 396 33 participants participant NNS www-bis-org-8025 396 34 need need VBP www-bis-org-8025 396 35 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 396 36 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 396 37 online online RB www-bis-org-8025 396 38 all all PDT www-bis-org-8025 396 39 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 396 40 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 396 41 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 396 42 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 396 43 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 396 44 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 396 45 routable routable JJ www-bis-org-8025 396 46 . . . www-bis-org-8025 397 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 397 2 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 397 3 concern concern NN www-bis-org-8025 397 4 relates relate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 397 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 397 6 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 397 7 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 397 8 theory theory NN www-bis-org-8025 397 9 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 397 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 397 11 trade trade NN www-bis-org-8025 397 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 397 13 off off NN www-bis-org-8025 397 14 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 397 15 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 397 16 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 397 17 centralisation centralisation NN www-bis-org-8025 397 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 398 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 398 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 398 3 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 398 4 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 398 5 remains remain VBZ www-bis-org-8025 398 6 truly truly RB www-bis-org-8025 398 7 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 398 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 398 9 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 398 10 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 398 11 require require VB www-bis-org-8025 398 12 substantial substantial JJ www-bis-org-8025 398 13 pre pre NN www-bis-org-8025 398 14 - - NN www-bis-org-8025 398 15 funding funding NN www-bis-org-8025 398 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 399 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 399 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 399 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 399 4 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 399 5 routing route VBG www-bis-org-8025 399 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 399 7 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 399 8 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 399 9 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 399 10 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 399 11 B b NN www-bis-org-8025 399 12 typically typically RB www-bis-org-8025 399 13 involves involve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 399 14 four four CD www-bis-org-8025 399 15 intermediate intermediate JJ www-bis-org-8025 399 16 channels channel NNS www-bis-org-8025 399 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 399 18 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 399 19 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 399 20 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 399 21 total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 399 22 require require VB www-bis-org-8025 399 23 preloaded preloade VBN www-bis-org-8025 399 24 values value NNS www-bis-org-8025 399 25 five five CD www-bis-org-8025 399 26 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 399 27 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 399 28 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 399 29 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 399 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 399 31 actual actual JJ www-bis-org-8025 399 32 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 399 33 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 399 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 400 1 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 400 2 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 400 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 400 4 uncertain uncertain JJ www-bis-org-8025 400 5 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 400 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 400 7 typical typical JJ www-bis-org-8025 400 8 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 400 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 400 10 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 400 11 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 400 12 upload upload VB www-bis-org-8025 400 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 400 14 say say VB www-bis-org-8025 400 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 400 16 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 400 17 200 200 CD www-bis-org-8025 400 18 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 400 19 finance finance VB www-bis-org-8025 400 20 small small JJ www-bis-org-8025 400 21 expenses expense NNS www-bis-org-8025 400 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 400 23 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 400 24 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 400 25 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 400 26 willing willing JJ www-bis-org-8025 400 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 400 28 foot foot VB www-bis-org-8025 400 29 another another DT www-bis-org-8025 400 30 USD usd NN www-bis-org-8025 400 31 800 800 CD www-bis-org-8025 400 32 just just RB www-bis-org-8025 400 33 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 400 34 support support VB www-bis-org-8025 400 35 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 400 36 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 400 37 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 400 38 routing routing NN www-bis-org-8025 400 39 capacity capacity NN www-bis-org-8025 400 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 401 1 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 401 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 401 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 401 4 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 401 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 401 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 401 7 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 401 8 efficient efficient JJ www-bis-org-8025 401 9 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 401 10 structure structure NN www-bis-org-8025 401 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 401 12 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 401 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 401 14 hub hub NN www-bis-org-8025 401 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 401 16 spoke speak VBD www-bis-org-8025 401 17 : : : www-bis-org-8025 401 18 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 401 19 normal normal JJ www-bis-org-8025 401 20 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 401 21 connects connect NNS www-bis-org-8025 401 22 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 401 23 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 401 24 larger large JJR www-bis-org-8025 401 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 401 26 highly highly RB www-bis-org-8025 401 27 interconnected interconnected JJ www-bis-org-8025 401 28 intermediary intermediary NN www-bis-org-8025 401 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 401 30 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 401 31 allowing allow VBG www-bis-org-8025 401 32 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 401 33 shorter short JJR www-bis-org-8025 401 34 routes route NNS www-bis-org-8025 401 35 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 401 36 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 401 37 netting netting JJ www-bis-org-8025 401 38 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 401 39 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 401 40 flows flow NNS www-bis-org-8025 401 41 . . . www-bis-org-8025 402 1 Such such PDT www-bis-org-8025 402 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 402 3 hub hub NN www-bis-org-8025 402 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 402 5 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 402 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 402 7 spoke speak VBD www-bis-org-8025 402 8 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 9 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 10 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 402 11 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 402 12 look look VB www-bis-org-8025 402 13 too too RB www-bis-org-8025 402 14 different different JJ www-bis-org-8025 402 15 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 402 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 402 17 setup setup NN www-bis-org-8025 402 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 402 19 today today NN www-bis-org-8025 402 20 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 402 21 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 402 22 infrastructure.31 infrastructure.31 NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 23 Recent recent JJ www-bis-org-8025 402 24 developments development NNS www-bis-org-8025 402 25 indeed indeed RB www-bis-org-8025 402 26 show show VBP www-bis-org-8025 402 27 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 402 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 402 29 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 30 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 31 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 402 32 prone prone JJ www-bis-org-8025 402 33 29 29 CD www-bis-org-8025 402 34 See see VBP www-bis-org-8025 402 35 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 36 Sompolinsky Sompolinsky NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 37 et et FW www-bis-org-8025 402 38 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 39 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 402 40 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 402 41 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 402 42 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 402 43 Sompolinsky Sompolinsky NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 44 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 402 45 Zohar Zohar NNP www-bis-org-8025 402 46 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 402 47 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 402 48 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 402 49 . . . www-bis-org-8025 403 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 403 2 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 403 3 IOTA IOTA NNP www-bis-org-8025 403 4 employs employ VBZ www-bis-org-8025 403 5 such such PDT www-bis-org-8025 403 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 403 7 non non JJ www-bis-org-8025 403 8 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 403 9 linear linear JJ www-bis-org-8025 403 10 ledger ledger NN www-bis-org-8025 403 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 403 12 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 403 13 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 403 14 far far RB www-bis-org-8025 403 15 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 403 16 requires require VBZ www-bis-org-8025 403 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 403 18 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 403 19 coordinator coordinator NN www-bis-org-8025 403 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 404 1 30 30 CD www-bis-org-8025 404 2 Dryja Dryja NNP www-bis-org-8025 404 3 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 404 4 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 404 5 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 404 6 presents present VBZ www-bis-org-8025 404 7 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 404 8 back back RB www-bis-org-8025 404 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 404 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 404 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 404 12 envelope envelope NNP www-bis-org-8025 404 13 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 404 14 arguing argue VBG www-bis-org-8025 404 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 404 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 404 17 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 404 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 404 19 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 404 20 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 404 21 size size NN www-bis-org-8025 404 22 limit limit NN www-bis-org-8025 404 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 404 24 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 404 25 MB mb NN www-bis-org-8025 404 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 404 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 404 28 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 404 29 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 404 30 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 404 31 serve serve VB www-bis-org-8025 404 32 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 404 33 20,000 20,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 404 34 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 404 35 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 404 36 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 404 37 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 404 38 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 404 39 150 150 CD www-bis-org-8025 404 40 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 404 41 channels channel NNS www-bis-org-8025 404 42 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 404 43 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 404 44 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 404 45 year year NN www-bis-org-8025 404 46 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 404 47 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 404 48 8.3 8.3 CD www-bis-org-8025 404 49 million million CD www-bis-org-8025 404 50 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 404 51 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 404 52 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 404 53 assuming assume VBG www-bis-org-8025 404 54 six six CD www-bis-org-8025 404 55 channels channel NNS www-bis-org-8025 404 56 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 404 57 year year NN www-bis-org-8025 404 58 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 404 59 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 404 60 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 404 61 while while IN www-bis-org-8025 404 62 consuming consume VBG www-bis-org-8025 404 63 half half PDT www-bis-org-8025 404 64 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 404 65 blocksize blocksize NN www-bis-org-8025 404 66 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 404 67 average average JJ www-bis-org-8025 404 68 . . . www-bis-org-8025 405 1 31 31 CD www-bis-org-8025 405 2 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 405 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 405 4 taxonomy taxonomy NN www-bis-org-8025 405 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 405 6 Buterin Buterin NNP www-bis-org-8025 405 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 405 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 405 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 405 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 405 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 405 12 hub hub NN www-bis-org-8025 405 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 405 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 405 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 405 16 spoke speak VBD www-bis-org-8025 405 17 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 405 18 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 405 19 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 405 20 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 405 21 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 405 22 decentralised decentralise VBN www-bis-org-8025 405 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 405 24 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 405 25 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 405 26 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 405 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 406 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 406 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 406 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 406 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 406 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 406 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 406 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 406 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 406 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 406 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 406 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 406 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 406 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 406 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 406 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 406 16 21 21 CD www-bis-org-8025 406 17 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 406 18 centralisation centralisation NN www-bis-org-8025 406 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 406 20 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 406 21 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 406 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 406 23 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 406 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 406 25 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 406 26 January January NNP www-bis-org-8025 406 27 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 406 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 406 29 362 362 CD www-bis-org-8025 406 30 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 406 31 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 406 32 total total NN www-bis-org-8025 406 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 406 34 544 544 CD www-bis-org-8025 406 35 committed committed JJ www-bis-org-8025 406 36 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 406 37 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 406 38 associated associate VBN www-bis-org-8025 406 39 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 406 40 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 406 41 single single JJ www-bis-org-8025 406 42 website website NN www-bis-org-8025 406 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 407 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 407 2 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 407 3 words word NNS www-bis-org-8025 407 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 407 5 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 407 6 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 407 7 point point NN www-bis-org-8025 407 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 407 9 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 407 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 407 11 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 407 12 thirds third NNS www-bis-org-8025 407 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 407 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 407 15 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 407 16 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 407 17 capacity capacity NN www-bis-org-8025 407 18 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 407 19 controlled control VBN www-bis-org-8025 407 20 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 407 21 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 407 22 single single JJ www-bis-org-8025 407 23 entity entity NN www-bis-org-8025 407 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 408 1 Proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 408 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 408 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 408 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 408 5 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 408 6 : : : www-bis-org-8025 408 7 gambling gamble VBG www-bis-org-8025 408 8 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 408 9 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 408 10 institutionalising institutionalise VBG www-bis-org-8025 408 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 408 12 truth truth NN www-bis-org-8025 408 13 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 409 1 Above above IN www-bis-org-8025 409 2 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 409 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 409 4 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 409 5 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 409 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 409 7 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 409 8 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 409 9 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 409 10 highlight highlight VBP www-bis-org-8025 409 11 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 409 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 409 13 vital vital JJ www-bis-org-8025 409 14 technical technical JJ www-bis-org-8025 409 15 development development NN www-bis-org-8025 409 16 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 409 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 409 18 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 409 19 related related JJ www-bis-org-8025 409 20 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 409 21 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 409 22 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 409 23 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 409 24 do do VB www-bis-org-8025 409 25 away away RB www-bis-org-8025 409 26 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 409 27 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 409 28 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 409 29 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 409 30 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 409 31 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 409 32 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 409 33 embrace embrace VB www-bis-org-8025 409 34 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 409 35 different different JJ www-bis-org-8025 409 36 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 409 37 model model NN www-bis-org-8025 409 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 410 1 While while IN www-bis-org-8025 410 2 several several JJ www-bis-org-8025 410 3 alternatives alternative NNS www-bis-org-8025 410 4 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 410 5 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 410 6 put put VBN www-bis-org-8025 410 7 forward forward RB www-bis-org-8025 410 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 410 9 conceptually conceptually RB www-bis-org-8025 410 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 410 11 most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 410 12 important important JJ www-bis-org-8025 410 13 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 410 14 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 410 15 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 410 16 replace replace VB www-bis-org-8025 410 17 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 410 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 410 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 410 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 410 21 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 410 22 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 410 23 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 410 24 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 410 25 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 410 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 410 27 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 410 28 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 410 29 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 410 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 410 31 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 410 32 scheme scheme NN www-bis-org-8025 410 33 whereby whereby WRB www-bis-org-8025 410 34 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 410 35 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 410 36 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 410 37 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 410 38 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 410 39 achieved achieve VBN www-bis-org-8025 410 40 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 410 41 staking stake VBG www-bis-org-8025 410 42 claims claim NNS www-bis-org-8025 410 43 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 410 44 particular particular JJ www-bis-org-8025 410 45 coin coin NN www-bis-org-8025 410 46 holdings holding NNS www-bis-org-8025 410 47 . . . www-bis-org-8025 411 1 There there EX www-bis-org-8025 411 2 exist exist VBP www-bis-org-8025 411 3 multiple multiple JJ www-bis-org-8025 411 4 proposed propose VBN www-bis-org-8025 411 5 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 411 6 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 411 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 411 8 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 411 9 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 411 10 protocols protocol NNS www-bis-org-8025 411 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 411 12 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 411 13 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 411 15 Ouroboros Ouroboros NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 16 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 411 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 411 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 411 19 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 411 20 Caradano Caradano NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 21 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 22 Kiayias Kiayias NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 23 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 24 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 25 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 26 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 411 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 411 30 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 411 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 411 32 Casper Casper NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 33 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 411 34 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 411 35 Ethereum Ethereum NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 36 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 37 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 411 38 Buterin Buterin NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 39 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 411 40 Griffith Griffith NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 41 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 42 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 411 43 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 44 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 411 45 Zamfir Zamfir NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 46 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 47 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 411 48 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 49 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 411 50 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 51 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 411 52 . . . www-bis-org-8025 412 1 One one CD www-bis-org-8025 412 2 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 412 3 implementation implementation NN www-bis-org-8025 412 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 412 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 412 6 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 412 7 possible possible JJ www-bis-org-8025 412 8 ones one NNS www-bis-org-8025 412 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 412 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 412 11 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 412 12 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 412 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 412 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 412 15 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 412 16 newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 412 17 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 412 18 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 412 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 412 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 412 21 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 412 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 412 23 holders holder NNS www-bis-org-8025 412 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 412 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 412 26 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 412 27 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 412 28 randomly randomly RB www-bis-org-8025 412 29 selected select VBN www-bis-org-8025 412 30 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 412 31 verify verify VB www-bis-org-8025 412 32 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 412 33 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 412 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 413 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 413 2 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 413 3 order order NN www-bis-org-8025 413 4 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 413 5 do do VB www-bis-org-8025 413 6 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 413 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 413 8 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 413 9 must must MD www-bis-org-8025 413 10 pledge pledge VB www-bis-org-8025 413 11 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 413 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 413 13 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 413 14 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 413 15 holdings holding NNS www-bis-org-8025 413 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 414 1 Cheating cheating NN www-bis-org-8025 414 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 414 3 deterred deter VBN www-bis-org-8025 414 4 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 414 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 414 6 threat threat NN www-bis-org-8025 414 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 414 8 losing lose VBG www-bis-org-8025 414 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 414 10 pledged pledge VBN www-bis-org-8025 414 11 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 414 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 414 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 414 14 case case NN www-bis-org-8025 414 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 414 16 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 414 17 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 414 18 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 414 19 verified verify VBD www-bis-org-8025 414 20 update update NN www-bis-org-8025 414 21 differs differ VBZ www-bis-org-8025 414 22 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 414 23 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 414 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 414 25 others other NNS www-bis-org-8025 414 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 415 1 There there EX www-bis-org-8025 415 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 415 3 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 415 4 big big JJ www-bis-org-8025 415 5 caveat caveat NN www-bis-org-8025 415 6 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 415 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 415 8 idea idea NN www-bis-org-8025 415 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 415 10 replacing replace VBG www-bis-org-8025 415 11 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 415 12 computations computation NNS www-bis-org-8025 415 13 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 415 14 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 415 15 essentially essentially RB www-bis-org-8025 415 16 resource resource NN www-bis-org-8025 415 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 415 18 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 415 19 betting betting NN www-bis-org-8025 415 20 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 415 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 415 22 sometimes sometimes RB www-bis-org-8025 415 23 termed term VBD www-bis-org-8025 415 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 415 25 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 415 26 nothing nothing NN www-bis-org-8025 415 27 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 415 28 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 415 29 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 415 30 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 415 31 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 415 32 problem problem NN www-bis-org-8025 415 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 416 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 416 2 caveat caveat NN www-bis-org-8025 416 3 concerns concern VBZ www-bis-org-8025 416 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 416 5 lack lack NN www-bis-org-8025 416 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 416 7 clear clear JJ www-bis-org-8025 416 8 criteria criterion NNS www-bis-org-8025 416 9 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 416 10 distinguishing distinguish VBG www-bis-org-8025 416 11 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 416 12 different different JJ www-bis-org-8025 416 13 blockchains blockchain NNS www-bis-org-8025 416 14 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 416 15 alternative alternative JJ www-bis-org-8025 416 16 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 416 17 histories history NNS www-bis-org-8025 416 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 416 19 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 416 20 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 416 21 Poelstra Poelstra NNP www-bis-org-8025 416 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 416 23 2014 2014 CD www-bis-org-8025 416 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 416 25 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 416 26 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 416 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 416 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 417 1 With with IN www-bis-org-8025 417 2 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 417 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 417 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 417 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 417 6 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 417 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 417 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 417 9 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 417 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 417 11 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 417 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 417 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 417 14 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 417 15 longest longest NN www-bis-org-8025 417 16 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 417 17 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 417 18 allows allow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 417 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 417 20 winning win VBG www-bis-org-8025 417 21 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 417 22 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 417 23 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 417 24 selected select VBN www-bis-org-8025 417 25 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 417 26 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 417 27 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 417 28 hard hard JJ www-bis-org-8025 417 29 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 417 30 externally externally RB www-bis-org-8025 417 31 verifiable verifiable JJ www-bis-org-8025 417 32 criterion criterion NN www-bis-org-8025 417 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 418 1 With with IN www-bis-org-8025 418 2 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 418 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 418 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 418 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 418 6 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 418 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 418 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 418 9 absence absence NN www-bis-org-8025 418 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 418 11 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 418 12 actual actual JJ www-bis-org-8025 418 13 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 418 14 means mean NNS www-bis-org-8025 418 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 418 16 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 418 17 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 418 18 secretly secretly RB www-bis-org-8025 418 19 bet bet VB www-bis-org-8025 418 20 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 418 21 alternative alternative JJ www-bis-org-8025 418 22 blockchain blockchain JJ www-bis-org-8025 418 23 histories history NNS www-bis-org-8025 418 24 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 418 25 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 418 26 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 418 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 419 1 And and CC www-bis-org-8025 419 2 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 419 3 alternative alternative JJ www-bis-org-8025 419 4 blockchain blockchain JJ www-bis-org-8025 419 5 histories history NNS www-bis-org-8025 419 6 ever ever RB www-bis-org-8025 419 7 emerge emerge VBP www-bis-org-8025 419 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 419 9 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 419 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 419 11 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 419 12 hard hard JJ www-bis-org-8025 419 13 criterion criterion NN www-bis-org-8025 419 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 419 15 choosing choose VBG www-bis-org-8025 419 16 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 419 17 them -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 419 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 419 19 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 419 20 requiring require VBG www-bis-org-8025 419 21 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 419 22 overarching overarching JJ www-bis-org-8025 419 23 selection selection NN www-bis-org-8025 419 24 mechanism mechanism NN www-bis-org-8025 419 25 . . . www-bis-org-8025 420 1 These these DT www-bis-org-8025 420 2 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 420 3 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 420 4 led lead VBN www-bis-org-8025 420 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 420 6 ample ample JJ www-bis-org-8025 420 7 discussion discussion NN www-bis-org-8025 420 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 420 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 420 10 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 420 11 developer developer NN www-bis-org-8025 420 12 community community NN www-bis-org-8025 420 13 regarding regard VBG www-bis-org-8025 420 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 420 15 feasibility feasibility NN www-bis-org-8025 420 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 420 17 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 420 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 420 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 420 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 420 21 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 420 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 420 23 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 420 24 eg eg NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 420 26 discussion discussion NN www-bis-org-8025 420 27 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 420 28 Muneeb Muneeb NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 29 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 30 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 31 ’s ’s NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 32 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 420 33 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 420 34 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 420 35 review review NN www-bis-org-8025 420 36 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 420 37 Zamfir Zamfir NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 38 et et NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 39 al al NNP www-bis-org-8025 420 40 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 420 41 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 420 42 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 420 43 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 420 44 . . . www-bis-org-8025 421 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 421 2 nothing nothing NN www-bis-org-8025 421 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 421 4 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 421 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 421 6 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 421 7 caveat caveat NN www-bis-org-8025 421 8 may may MD www-bis-org-8025 421 9 mean mean VB www-bis-org-8025 421 10 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 421 11 successful successful JJ www-bis-org-8025 421 12 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 421 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 421 14 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 421 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 421 16 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 421 17 implementation implementation NN www-bis-org-8025 421 18 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 421 19 indeed indeed RB www-bis-org-8025 421 20 rest rest VB www-bis-org-8025 421 21 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 421 22 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 421 23 degree degree NN www-bis-org-8025 421 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 421 25 institutionalisation institutionalisation NN www-bis-org-8025 421 26 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 421 27 reliance reliance NN www-bis-org-8025 421 28 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 421 29 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 421 30 conventions convention NNS www-bis-org-8025 421 31 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 421 32 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 421 33 indicated indicate VBN www-bis-org-8025 421 34 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 421 35 Buterin Buterin NNP www-bis-org-8025 421 36 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 421 37 2014 2014 CD www-bis-org-8025 421 38 a a NN www-bis-org-8025 421 39 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 421 40 b b LS www-bis-org-8025 421 41 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 421 42 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 421 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 422 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 422 2 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 3 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 4 : : : www-bis-org-8025 422 5 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 422 6 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 422 7 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 422 8 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 422 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 10 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 11 11 11 CD www-bis-org-8025 422 12 Representation Representation NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 422 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 422 15 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 16 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 17 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 18 beta beta NN www-bis-org-8025 422 19 version version NN www-bis-org-8025 422 20 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 422 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 422 22 use use NN www-bis-org-8025 422 23 Committed Committed NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 24 BTC BTC NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 25 Number Number NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 422 27 nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 422 28 Source source NN www-bis-org-8025 422 29 : : : www-bis-org-8025 422 30 https://bitcoinvisuals.com/lightning https://bitcoinvisuals.com/lightning ADD www-bis-org-8025 422 31 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 422 32 site site NN www-bis-org-8025 422 33 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 422 34 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 422 35 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 422 36 Jan Jan NNP www-bis-org-8025 422 37 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 422 38 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 422 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 423 1 500 500 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 2 400 400 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 3 300 300 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 4 200 200 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 5 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 6 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 7 2,000 2,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 8 1,600 1,600 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 9 1,200 1,200 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 10 800 800 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 11 400 400 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 12 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 13 Q4 Q4 NNP www-bis-org-8025 423 14 18Q3 18q3 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 15 18Q2 18q2 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 16 18Q1 18q1 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 17 18 18 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 18 Total total JJ www-bis-org-8025 423 19 committed committed JJ www-bis-org-8025 423 20 bitcoinLhs bitcoinlh NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 21 : : : www-bis-org-8025 423 22 Nodes node NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 23 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 423 24 channelsRhs channelsrh NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 25 : : : www-bis-org-8025 423 26 https://bitcoinvisuals.com/lightning https://bitcoinvisuals.com/lightning $ www-bis-org-8025 423 27 22 22 CD www-bis-org-8025 423 28 WP765 wp765 NN www-bis-org-8025 423 29 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 423 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 423 31 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 423 32 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 423 34 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 423 35 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 423 36 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 423 37 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 423 38 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 423 39 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 423 40 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 423 41 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 423 42 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 43 Other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 423 44 proposed propose VBN www-bis-org-8025 423 45 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 423 46 algorithms algorithm NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 47 , , , www-bis-org-8025 423 48 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 423 49 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 423 50 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 423 51 delegated delegate VBD www-bis-org-8025 423 52 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 423 53 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 423 54 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 423 55 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 423 56 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 423 57 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 423 58 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 423 59 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 423 60 importance importance NN www-bis-org-8025 423 61 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 423 62 , , , www-bis-org-8025 423 63 aim aim VBP www-bis-org-8025 423 64 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 423 65 guarantee guarantee VB www-bis-org-8025 423 66 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 423 67 directly directly RB www-bis-org-8025 423 68 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 423 69 additional additional JJ www-bis-org-8025 423 70 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 423 71 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 423 72 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 73 , , , www-bis-org-8025 423 74 eg eg VB www-bis-org-8025 423 75 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 423 76 range range NN www-bis-org-8025 423 77 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 423 78 voting voting NN www-bis-org-8025 423 79 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 80 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 423 81 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 423 82 coin coin NN www-bis-org-8025 423 83 holders holder NNS www-bis-org-8025 423 84 . . . www-bis-org-8025 424 1 Whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 424 2 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 424 3 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 424 4 moving move VBG www-bis-org-8025 424 5 beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 424 6 pure pure JJ www-bis-org-8025 424 7 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 424 8 proof proof JJ www-bis-org-8025 424 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 424 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 424 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 424 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 424 13 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 424 14 require require VB www-bis-org-8025 424 15 overarching overarching JJ www-bis-org-8025 424 16 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 424 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 424 18 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 424 19 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 424 20 noteworthy noteworthy JJ www-bis-org-8025 424 21 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 424 22 much much JJ www-bis-org-8025 424 23 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 424 24 already already RB www-bis-org-8025 424 25 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 424 26 done do VBN www-bis-org-8025 424 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 424 28 protect protect VB www-bis-org-8025 424 29 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 424 30 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 424 31 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 424 32 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 424 33 beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 424 34 just just RB www-bis-org-8025 424 35 applying apply VBG www-bis-org-8025 424 36 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 424 37 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 424 38 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 424 39 follow follow VB www-bis-org-8025 424 40 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 424 41 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 424 42 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 424 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 425 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 425 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 425 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 425 4 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 425 5 March March NNP www-bis-org-8025 425 6 2013 2013 CD www-bis-org-8025 425 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 425 8 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 425 9 erroneous erroneous JJ www-bis-org-8025 425 10 software software NN www-bis-org-8025 425 11 update update NN www-bis-org-8025 425 12 caused cause VBD www-bis-org-8025 425 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 425 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 425 15 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 425 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 425 17 fork fork VB www-bis-org-8025 425 18 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 425 19 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 425 20 branches branch NNS www-bis-org-8025 425 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 426 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 426 2 latter latter JJ www-bis-org-8025 426 3 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 426 4 undone undo VBN www-bis-org-8025 426 5 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 426 6 coordinated coordinate VBN www-bis-org-8025 426 7 action action NN www-bis-org-8025 426 8 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 426 9 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 426 10 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 426 11 pools pool NNS www-bis-org-8025 426 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 426 13 ignore ignore VB www-bis-org-8025 426 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 426 15 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 426 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 426 17 follow follow VB www-bis-org-8025 426 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 426 19 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 426 20 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 426 21 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 426 22 instead instead RB www-bis-org-8025 426 23 coordinate coordinate VB www-bis-org-8025 426 24 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 426 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 426 26 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 426 27 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 426 28 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 426 29 reunite reunite VB www-bis-org-8025 426 30 all all DT www-bis-org-8025 426 31 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 426 32 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 426 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 427 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 427 2 second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 427 3 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 427 4 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 427 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 427 6 failed fail VBN www-bis-org-8025 427 7 introduction introduction NN www-bis-org-8025 427 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 427 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 427 10 so so RB www-bis-org-8025 427 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 427 12 called call VBN www-bis-org-8025 427 13 Segwit2X Segwit2X HYPH www-bis-org-8025 427 14 protocol protocol NNP www-bis-org-8025 427 15 update update NN www-bis-org-8025 427 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 427 17 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 427 18 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 427 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 427 20 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 427 21 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 427 22 change change NN www-bis-org-8025 427 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 427 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 427 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 427 26 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 427 27 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 427 28 implemented implement VBN www-bis-org-8025 427 29 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 427 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 427 31 majority majority NN www-bis-org-8025 427 32 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 427 33 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 427 34 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 427 35 failed fail VBD www-bis-org-8025 427 36 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 427 37 convince convince VB www-bis-org-8025 427 38 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 427 39 stakeholders stakeholder NNS www-bis-org-8025 427 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 428 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 428 2 led lead VBD www-bis-org-8025 428 3 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 428 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 428 5 situation situation NN www-bis-org-8025 428 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 428 7 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 428 8 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 428 9 ultimately ultimately RB www-bis-org-8025 428 10 abandoned abandon VBD www-bis-org-8025 428 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 428 12 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 428 13 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 428 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 428 15 because because IN www-bis-org-8025 428 16 nobody nobody NN www-bis-org-8025 428 17 was be VBD www-bis-org-8025 428 18 willing willing JJ www-bis-org-8025 428 19 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 428 20 transact transact VB www-bis-org-8025 428 21 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 428 22 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 428 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 428 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 429 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 429 2 third third JJ www-bis-org-8025 429 3 instance instance NN www-bis-org-8025 429 4 occurred occur VBD www-bis-org-8025 429 5 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 429 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 429 7 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 429 8 Ethereum Ethereum NNP www-bis-org-8025 429 9 split split VBD www-bis-org-8025 429 10 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 429 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 429 12 undoing undoing NN www-bis-org-8025 429 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 429 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 429 15 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 429 16 DAO DAO NNP www-bis-org-8025 429 17 hack hack NN www-bis-org-8025 429 18 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 429 19 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 429 20 mid-2016 mid-2016 NN www-bis-org-8025 429 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 430 1 At at IN www-bis-org-8025 430 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 430 3 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 430 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 430 5 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 430 6 application application NN www-bis-org-8025 430 7 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 430 8 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 430 9 Ethereum Ethereum NNP www-bis-org-8025 430 10 protocol protocol NN www-bis-org-8025 430 11 proved prove VBD www-bis-org-8025 430 12 faulty faulty JJ www-bis-org-8025 430 13 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 430 14 but but CC www-bis-org-8025 430 15 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 430 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 430 17 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 430 18 itself -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 430 19 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 430 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 430 21 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 430 22 allowed allow VBD www-bis-org-8025 430 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 430 24 hacker hacker NN www-bis-org-8025 430 25 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 430 26 successfully successfully RB www-bis-org-8025 430 27 steal steal VB www-bis-org-8025 430 28 ether ether NN www-bis-org-8025 430 29 tokens token NNS www-bis-org-8025 430 30 worth worth JJ www-bis-org-8025 430 31 roughly roughly RB www-bis-org-8025 430 32 USD usd $ www-bis-org-8025 430 33 70 70 CD www-bis-org-8025 430 34 million million CD www-bis-org-8025 430 35 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 430 36 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 430 37 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 430 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 431 1 Following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 431 2 heated heated JJ www-bis-org-8025 431 3 discussion discussion NN www-bis-org-8025 431 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 431 5 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 431 6 online online JJ www-bis-org-8025 431 7 forums forum NNS www-bis-org-8025 431 8 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 431 9 elsewhere elsewhere RB www-bis-org-8025 431 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 431 11 most most JJS www-bis-org-8025 431 12 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 431 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 431 14 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 431 15 decided decide VBD www-bis-org-8025 431 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 431 17 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 431 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 431 19 hack hack NN www-bis-org-8025 431 20 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 431 21 creating create VBG www-bis-org-8025 431 22 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 431 23 alternative alternative JJ www-bis-org-8025 431 24 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 431 25 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 431 26 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 431 27 start start VB www-bis-org-8025 431 28 just just RB www-bis-org-8025 431 29 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 431 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 431 31 hack hack NN www-bis-org-8025 431 32 occurred occur VBD www-bis-org-8025 431 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 432 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 432 2 minority minority NN www-bis-org-8025 432 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 432 4 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 432 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 432 6 however however RB www-bis-org-8025 432 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 432 8 decided decide VBD www-bis-org-8025 432 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 432 10 stay stay VB www-bis-org-8025 432 11 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 432 12 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 432 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 432 14 rule rule NN www-bis-org-8025 432 15 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 432 16 follow follow VB www-bis-org-8025 432 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 432 18 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 432 19 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 432 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 432 21 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 432 22 giving give VBG www-bis-org-8025 432 23 rise rise NN www-bis-org-8025 432 24 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 432 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 432 26 Ethereum Ethereum NNP www-bis-org-8025 432 27 Classic Classic NNP www-bis-org-8025 432 28 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 432 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 433 1 These these DT www-bis-org-8025 433 2 three three CD www-bis-org-8025 433 3 episodes episode NNS www-bis-org-8025 433 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 433 5 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 433 6 others other NNS www-bis-org-8025 433 7 like like IN www-bis-org-8025 433 8 them -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 433 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 433 10 show show VBP www-bis-org-8025 433 11 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 433 12 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 433 13 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 433 14 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 433 15 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 433 16 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 433 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 433 18 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 433 19 element element NN www-bis-org-8025 433 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 433 21 smoothly smoothly RB www-bis-org-8025 433 22 functioning function VBG www-bis-org-8025 433 23 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 433 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 434 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 434 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 434 3 future future NN www-bis-org-8025 434 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 434 5 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 434 6 novel novel JJ www-bis-org-8025 434 7 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 434 8 concepts concept NNS www-bis-org-8025 434 9 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 434 10 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 434 11 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 434 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 434 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 434 14 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 434 15 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 434 16 gain gain NN www-bis-org-8025 434 17 momentum momentum NN www-bis-org-8025 434 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 434 19 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 434 20 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 434 21 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 434 22 may may MD www-bis-org-8025 434 23 take take VB www-bis-org-8025 434 24 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 434 25 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 434 26 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 434 27 role role NN www-bis-org-8025 434 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 434 29 so so IN www-bis-org-8025 434 30 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 434 31 effective effective JJ www-bis-org-8025 434 32 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 434 33 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 434 34 ultimately ultimately RB www-bis-org-8025 434 35 require require VB www-bis-org-8025 434 36 institutional institutional JJ www-bis-org-8025 434 37 backing backing NN www-bis-org-8025 434 38 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 434 39 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 434 40 form form NN www-bis-org-8025 434 41 . . . www-bis-org-8025 435 1 How how WRB www-bis-org-8025 435 2 readily readily RB www-bis-org-8025 435 3 institutional institutional JJ www-bis-org-8025 435 4 backing backing NN www-bis-org-8025 435 5 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 435 6 improve improve VB www-bis-org-8025 435 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 435 8 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 435 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 435 10 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 435 11 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 435 12 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 435 13 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 435 14 shown show VBN www-bis-org-8025 435 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 435 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 435 17 above above JJ www-bis-org-8025 435 18 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 435 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 435 20 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 435 21 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 435 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 435 23 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 435 24 particular particular JJ www-bis-org-8025 435 25 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 435 26 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 435 27 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 435 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 435 29 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 435 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 436 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 436 2 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 436 3 were be VBD www-bis-org-8025 436 4 possible possible JJ www-bis-org-8025 436 5 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 436 6 pre pre VB www-bis-org-8025 436 7 - - VB www-bis-org-8025 436 8 commit commit VB www-bis-org-8025 436 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 436 10 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 436 11 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 436 12 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 436 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 436 14 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 436 15 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 436 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 436 17 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 436 18 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 436 19 negate negate VB www-bis-org-8025 436 20 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 436 21 incentives incentive NNS www-bis-org-8025 436 22 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 436 23 attack attack VB www-bis-org-8025 436 24 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 436 25 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 436 26 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 436 27 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 436 28 place place NN www-bis-org-8025 436 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 437 1 More more RBR www-bis-org-8025 437 2 generally generally RB www-bis-org-8025 437 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 437 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 437 5 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 437 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 437 7 probability probability NN www-bis-org-8025 437 8 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 437 9 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 437 10 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 437 11 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 437 12 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 437 13 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 437 14 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 437 15 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 437 16 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 437 17 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 437 18 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 437 19 captured capture VBN www-bis-org-8025 437 20 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 437 21 Π π PRP www-bis-org-8025 437 22 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 437 23 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 437 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 437 25 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 437 26 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 437 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 437 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 437 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 437 30 lower low JJR www-bis-org-8025 437 31 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 437 32 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 437 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 437 34 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 437 35 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 437 36 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 437 37 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 437 38 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 437 39 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 437 40 order order NN www-bis-org-8025 437 41 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 437 42 deter deter VB www-bis-org-8025 437 43 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 437 44 . . . www-bis-org-8025 438 1 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 438 2 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 438 3 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 438 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 438 5 quantitative quantitative JJ www-bis-org-8025 438 6 impact impact NN www-bis-org-8025 438 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 438 8 greater great JJR www-bis-org-8025 438 9 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 438 10 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 438 11 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 438 12 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 438 13 Π π NN www-bis-org-8025 438 14 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 438 15 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 438 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 438 17 trade trade NN www-bis-org-8025 438 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 438 19 off off NN www-bis-org-8025 438 20 between between IN www-bis-org-8025 438 21 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 438 22 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 438 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 438 24 waittime waittime NN www-bis-org-8025 438 25 . . . www-bis-org-8025 439 1 Institutionalisation institutionalisation NN www-bis-org-8025 439 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 439 3 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 439 4 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 439 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 439 6 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 439 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 439 8 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 439 9 Graph Graph NNP www-bis-org-8025 439 10 12 12 CD www-bis-org-8025 439 11 Logarithmic Logarithmic NNP www-bis-org-8025 439 12 scale scale NN www-bis-org-8025 439 13 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 439 14 graph graph NN www-bis-org-8025 439 15 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 439 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 439 17 impact impact NN www-bis-org-8025 439 18 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 439 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 439 20 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 439 21 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 439 22 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 439 23 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 439 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 439 25 case case NN www-bis-org-8025 439 26 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 439 27 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 439 28 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 439 29 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 439 30 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 439 31 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 439 32 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 439 33 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 439 34 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 439 35 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 439 36 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 439 37 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 439 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 440 1 Calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 440 2 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 440 3 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 440 4 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 440 5 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 440 6 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 440 7 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 440 8 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 440 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 440 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 440 11 main main JJ www-bis-org-8025 440 12 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 440 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 440 14 assuming assume VBG www-bis-org-8025 440 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 440 16 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 440 17 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 440 18 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 440 19 0 0 CD www-bis-org-8025 440 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 441 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 441 2 horizontal horizontal JJ www-bis-org-8025 441 3 axis axi NNS www-bis-org-8025 441 4 denotes denote VBZ www-bis-org-8025 441 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 441 6 probability probability NN www-bis-org-8025 441 7 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 441 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 441 9 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 441 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 441 11 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 441 12 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 441 13 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 441 14 coordinate coordinate VB www-bis-org-8025 441 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 441 16 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 441 17 any any DT www-bis-org-8025 441 18 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 441 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 441 20 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 441 21 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 441 22 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 441 23 Π π NN www-bis-org-8025 441 24 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 441 25 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 441 26 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 441 27 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 441 28 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 441 29 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 441 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 442 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 442 2 vertical vertical JJ www-bis-org-8025 442 3 axis axi NNS www-bis-org-8025 442 4 shows show VBZ www-bis-org-8025 442 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 442 6 resultant resultant NN www-bis-org-8025 442 7 required require VBN www-bis-org-8025 442 8 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 442 9 times time NNS www-bis-org-8025 442 10 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 442 11 various various JJ www-bis-org-8025 442 12 levels level NNS www-bis-org-8025 442 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 442 14 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 442 15 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 442 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 443 1 Source source NN www-bis-org-8025 443 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 443 3 Author author NN www-bis-org-8025 443 4 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 443 5 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 443 6 . . . www-bis-org-8025 444 1 1,000 1,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 2 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 3 10 10 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 4 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 5 100%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%20%10 100%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%20%10 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 6 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 444 7 Probability Probability NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 444 9 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 444 10 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 444 11 R R NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 12 eq eq NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 13 ui ui NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 14 re re NN www-bis-org-8025 444 15 d d NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 16 w w NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 17 ai ai NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 18 t t NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 19 tim tim NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 20 e e NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 444 22 b b NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 23 lo lo NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 24 ck ck NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 25 s s NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 26 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 27 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 444 28 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 444 29 0.1 0.1 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 30 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 444 31 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 444 32 0.01 0.01 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 33 % % NN www-bis-org-8025 444 34 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 444 35 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 36 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 444 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 444 38 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 444 39 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 444 40 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 444 41 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 444 42 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 444 43 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 444 44 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 444 45 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 444 46 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 444 47 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 444 48 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 444 49 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 444 50 23 23 CD www-bis-org-8025 444 51 Conclusion conclusion NN www-bis-org-8025 444 52 : : : www-bis-org-8025 444 53 towards towards IN www-bis-org-8025 444 54 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 444 55 world world NN www-bis-org-8025 444 56 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 444 57 semi semi JJ www-bis-org-8025 444 58 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 444 59 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 444 60 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 444 61 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 445 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 445 2 overall overall JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 3 conclusion conclusion NN www-bis-org-8025 445 4 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 445 5 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 445 6 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 445 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 445 8 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 445 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 445 10 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 445 11 least least JJS www-bis-org-8025 445 12 judging judging NN www-bis-org-8025 445 13 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 445 14 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 445 15 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 16 technologies technology NNS www-bis-org-8025 445 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 445 18 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 445 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 445 20 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 21 age age NN www-bis-org-8025 445 22 too too RB www-bis-org-8025 445 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 445 24 good good JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 25 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 445 26 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 445 27 likely likely JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 28 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 445 29 remain remain VB www-bis-org-8025 445 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 445 31 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 32 construct construct NN www-bis-org-8025 445 33 rather rather RB www-bis-org-8025 445 34 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 445 35 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 445 36 purely purely RB www-bis-org-8025 445 37 technological technological JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 38 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 445 39 : : : www-bis-org-8025 445 40 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 445 41 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 445 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 445 43 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 44 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 445 45 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 445 46 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 445 47 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 445 48 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 445 49 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 445 50 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 445 51 exclusively exclusively RB www-bis-org-8025 445 52 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 445 53 much much RB www-bis-org-8025 445 54 lower low JJR www-bis-org-8025 445 55 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 445 56 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 445 57 appear appear VB www-bis-org-8025 445 58 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 445 59 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 60 sight sight NN www-bis-org-8025 445 61 , , , www-bis-org-8025 445 62 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 445 63 alternative alternative JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 64 technologies technology NNS www-bis-org-8025 445 65 still still RB www-bis-org-8025 445 66 need need VBP www-bis-org-8025 445 67 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 445 68 demonstrate demonstrate VB www-bis-org-8025 445 69 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 445 70 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 445 71 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 445 72 function function VB www-bis-org-8025 445 73 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 445 74 institutional institutional JJ www-bis-org-8025 445 75 backing backing NN www-bis-org-8025 445 76 . . . www-bis-org-8025 446 1 But but CC www-bis-org-8025 446 2 claiming claim VBG www-bis-org-8025 446 3 that that DT www-bis-org-8025 446 4 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 446 5 alone alone RB www-bis-org-8025 446 6 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 446 7 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 446 8 do do VB www-bis-org-8025 446 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 446 10 trick trick NN www-bis-org-8025 446 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 446 12 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 446 13 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 446 14 say say VB www-bis-org-8025 446 15 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 446 16 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 446 17 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 446 18 useless useless JJ www-bis-org-8025 446 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 447 1 It -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 447 2 simply simply RB www-bis-org-8025 447 3 means mean VBZ www-bis-org-8025 447 4 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 447 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 447 6 focus focus NN www-bis-org-8025 447 7 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 447 8 shift shift VB www-bis-org-8025 447 9 away away RB www-bis-org-8025 447 10 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 447 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 447 12 issue issue NN www-bis-org-8025 447 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 447 14 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 447 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 447 16 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 447 17 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 447 18 replace replace VB www-bis-org-8025 447 19 traditional traditional JJ www-bis-org-8025 447 20 sovereign sovereign JJ www-bis-org-8025 447 21 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 447 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 447 23 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 447 24 institutions institution NNS www-bis-org-8025 447 25 . . . www-bis-org-8025 448 1 One one CD www-bis-org-8025 448 2 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 448 3 question question NN www-bis-org-8025 448 4 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 448 5 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 448 6 research research NN www-bis-org-8025 448 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 448 8 whether whether IN www-bis-org-8025 448 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 448 10 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 448 11 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 448 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 448 13 supported support VBN www-bis-org-8025 448 14 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 448 15 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 448 16 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 448 17 complement complement VB www-bis-org-8025 448 18 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 448 19 improve improve VB www-bis-org-8025 448 20 upon upon IN www-bis-org-8025 448 21 existing exist VBG www-bis-org-8025 448 22 monetary monetary JJ www-bis-org-8025 448 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 448 24 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 448 25 infrastructure infrastructure NN www-bis-org-8025 448 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 449 1 For for IN www-bis-org-8025 449 2 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 449 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 449 4 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 449 5 mixed mix VBN www-bis-org-8025 449 6 systems system NNS www-bis-org-8025 449 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 449 8 normal normal JJ www-bis-org-8025 449 9 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 449 10 functioning functioning NN www-bis-org-8025 449 11 could could MD www-bis-org-8025 449 12 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 449 13 guaranteed guarantee VBN www-bis-org-8025 449 14 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 449 15 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 449 16 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 449 17 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 449 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 449 19 yet yet RB www-bis-org-8025 449 20 should should MD www-bis-org-8025 449 21 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 449 22 fail fail VB www-bis-org-8025 449 23 there there EX www-bis-org-8025 449 24 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 449 25 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 449 26 overarching overarching JJ www-bis-org-8025 449 27 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 449 28 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-bis-org-8025 449 29 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 449 30 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 449 31 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 449 32 tied tie VBN www-bis-org-8025 449 33 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 449 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 449 35 legal legal JJ www-bis-org-8025 449 36 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 449 37 . . . www-bis-org-8025 450 1 What what WP www-bis-org-8025 450 2 would would MD www-bis-org-8025 450 3 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 450 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 450 5 gains gain NNS www-bis-org-8025 450 6 regarding regard VBG www-bis-org-8025 450 7 efficiency efficiency NN www-bis-org-8025 450 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 450 9 transparency transparency NN www-bis-org-8025 450 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 450 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 450 12 resilience resilience NN www-bis-org-8025 450 13 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 450 14 such such JJ www-bis-org-8025 450 15 semi semi JJ www-bis-org-8025 450 16 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 450 17 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 450 18 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 450 19 compared compare VBN www-bis-org-8025 450 20 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 450 21 current current JJ www-bis-org-8025 450 22 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 450 23 designs design NNS www-bis-org-8025 450 24 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 451 1 Outside outside IN www-bis-org-8025 451 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 451 3 world world NN www-bis-org-8025 451 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 451 5 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 451 6 aficionados aficionado NNS www-bis-org-8025 451 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 451 8 answering answer VBG www-bis-org-8025 451 9 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 451 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 451 11 related related JJ www-bis-org-8025 451 12 questions question NNS www-bis-org-8025 451 13 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 451 14 require require VB www-bis-org-8025 451 15 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 451 16 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 451 17 widely widely RB www-bis-org-8025 451 18 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 451 19 understanding understanding NN www-bis-org-8025 451 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 451 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 451 22 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 451 23 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 451 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 451 25 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 451 26 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 451 27 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 451 28 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 451 29 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 451 30 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 451 31 existing exist VBG www-bis-org-8025 451 32 markets market NNS www-bis-org-8025 451 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 452 1 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 452 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 452 3 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 452 4 hand hand NN www-bis-org-8025 452 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 6 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 452 7 those those DT www-bis-org-8025 452 8 already already RB www-bis-org-8025 452 9 involved involve VBN www-bis-org-8025 452 10 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 452 11 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 452 12 ledger ledger JJ www-bis-org-8025 452 13 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 452 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 15 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 452 16 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 452 17 needed need VBN www-bis-org-8025 452 18 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 452 19 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 452 20 awareness awareness NN www-bis-org-8025 452 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 452 22 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 452 23 institutions institution NNS www-bis-org-8025 452 24 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 452 25 sustained sustain VBN www-bis-org-8025 452 26 trust trust NN www-bis-org-8025 452 27 throughout throughout IN www-bis-org-8025 452 28 mankind mankind NN www-bis-org-8025 452 29 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 452 30 history history NN www-bis-org-8025 452 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 32 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 452 33 issue issue NN www-bis-org-8025 452 34 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 452 35 lies lie VBZ www-bis-org-8025 452 36 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 452 37 heart heart NN www-bis-org-8025 452 38 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 452 39 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 452 40 banking banking NN www-bis-org-8025 452 41 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 452 42 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 452 43 regulation regulation NN www-bis-org-8025 452 44 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 45 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 452 46 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 47 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 452 48 example example NN www-bis-org-8025 452 49 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 50 Lewis Lewis NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 51 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 52 1969 1969 CD www-bis-org-8025 452 53 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 54 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 55 Giannini Giannini NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 56 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 57 2011 2011 CD www-bis-org-8025 452 58 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 59 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 60 Graeber Graeber NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 61 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 62 2011 2011 CD www-bis-org-8025 452 63 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 64 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 65 Schnabel Schnabel NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 66 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 452 67 Shin Shin NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 68 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 69 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 452 70 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 71 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 72 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 73 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 452 74 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 75 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 76 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 77 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 452 78 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 79 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 80 Carstens Carstens NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 81 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 82 2018a 2018a CD www-bis-org-8025 452 83 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 84 , , , www-bis-org-8025 452 85 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 452 86 Borio Borio NNP www-bis-org-8025 452 87 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 88 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 452 89 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 90 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 452 91 . . . www-bis-org-8025 453 1 All all PDT www-bis-org-8025 453 2 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 453 3 aside aside RB www-bis-org-8025 453 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 453 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 453 6 societal societal JJ www-bis-org-8025 453 7 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 453 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 453 9 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 453 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 453 11 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 453 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 453 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 453 14 his -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 453 15 followers follower NNS www-bis-org-8025 453 16 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 453 17 substantial substantial JJ www-bis-org-8025 453 18 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 453 19 reasons reason NNS www-bis-org-8025 453 20 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 453 21 extend extend VBP www-bis-org-8025 453 22 well well RB www-bis-org-8025 453 23 beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 453 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 453 25 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 453 26 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 453 27 use use NN www-bis-org-8025 453 28 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 453 29 means mean NNS www-bis-org-8025 453 30 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 453 31 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 453 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 454 1 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 454 2 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 454 3 developers developer NNS www-bis-org-8025 454 4 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 454 5 created create VBN www-bis-org-8025 454 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 454 7 backbone backbone NN www-bis-org-8025 454 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 454 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 454 10 first first JJ www-bis-org-8025 454 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 454 12 generation generation NN www-bis-org-8025 454 13 decentralised decentralise VBN www-bis-org-8025 454 14 infrastructure infrastructure NN www-bis-org-8025 454 15 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 454 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 454 17 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 454 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 454 19 past past JJ www-bis-org-8025 454 20 decade decade NN www-bis-org-8025 454 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 454 22 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 454 23 survived survive VBN www-bis-org-8025 454 24 many many JJ www-bis-org-8025 454 25 attacks attack NNS www-bis-org-8025 454 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 455 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 455 2 addition addition NN www-bis-org-8025 455 3 , , , www-bis-org-8025 455 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 455 5 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 455 6 inspired inspire VBN www-bis-org-8025 455 7 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 455 8 entire entire JJ www-bis-org-8025 455 9 cohort cohort NN www-bis-org-8025 455 10 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 455 11 study study VB www-bis-org-8025 455 12 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 455 13 underlying underlie VBG www-bis-org-8025 455 14 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 455 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 455 16 spotlighting spotlighting NN www-bis-org-8025 455 17 fields field NNS www-bis-org-8025 455 18 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 455 19 diverse diverse JJ www-bis-org-8025 455 20 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 455 21 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 455 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 455 23 cryptography cryptography NN www-bis-org-8025 455 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 455 25 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 455 26 database database NN www-bis-org-8025 455 27 management management NN www-bis-org-8025 455 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 456 1 In in IN www-bis-org-8025 456 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 456 3 long long JJ www-bis-org-8025 456 4 run run NN www-bis-org-8025 456 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 456 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 456 7 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 456 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 456 9 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 456 10 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 456 11 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 456 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 456 13 catalyse catalyse VB www-bis-org-8025 456 14 our -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 456 15 thinking thinking NN www-bis-org-8025 456 16 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 456 17 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 456 18 society society NN www-bis-org-8025 456 19 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 456 20 handle handle VB www-bis-org-8025 456 21 access access NN www-bis-org-8025 456 22 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 456 23 data datum NNS www-bis-org-8025 456 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 456 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 456 26 right right NN www-bis-org-8025 456 27 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 456 28 edit edit VB www-bis-org-8025 456 29 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 456 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 456 31 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 456 32 much much RB www-bis-org-8025 456 33 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 456 34 needed need VBN www-bis-org-8025 456 35 impulse impulse NN www-bis-org-8025 456 36 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 456 37 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 456 38 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 456 39 characterised characterise VBN www-bis-org-8025 456 40 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 456 41 loss loss NN www-bis-org-8025 456 42 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 456 43 privacy privacy NN www-bis-org-8025 456 44 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 456 45 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 456 46 rise rise NN www-bis-org-8025 456 47 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 456 48 technology- technology- NN www-bis-org-8025 456 49 driven drive VBN www-bis-org-8025 456 50 disinformation disinformation NN www-bis-org-8025 456 51 campaigns campaign NNS www-bis-org-8025 456 52 . . . www-bis-org-8025 457 1 24 24 CD www-bis-org-8025 457 2 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 3 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 457 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 457 5 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 457 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 457 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 457 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 457 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 457 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 457 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 457 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 457 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 457 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 457 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 457 17 References References NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 18 Abadi Abadi NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 457 20 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 21 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 457 22 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 23 Brunnermeier Brunnermeier NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 457 25 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 457 26 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 457 27 : : : www-bis-org-8025 457 28 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 457 29 Blockchain Blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 30 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 457 31 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 457 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 457 33 Princeton Princeton NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 34 University University NNP www-bis-org-8025 457 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 457 36 mimeo mimeo VBD www-bis-org-8025 457 37 , , , www-bis-org-8025 457 38 May. May NNP www-bis-org-8025 458 1 Amihud Amihud NNP www-bis-org-8025 458 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 458 3 Y Y NNP www-bis-org-8025 458 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 458 5 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 458 6 Cukierman Cukierman NNP www-bis-org-8025 458 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 458 8 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 458 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 458 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 458 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 458 12 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 458 13 macroeconomic macroeconomic JJ www-bis-org-8025 458 14 perils peril NNS www-bis-org-8025 458 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 458 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 458 17 world world NN www-bis-org-8025 458 18 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 458 19 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 458 20 private private JJ www-bis-org-8025 458 21 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 458 22 currency currency NN www-bis-org-8025 458 23 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 458 24 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 458 25 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 458 26 address address VB www-bis-org-8025 458 27 them -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 458 28 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 458 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 458 30 VoxEU.org VoxEU.org NNP www-bis-org-8025 458 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 458 32 9 9 CD www-bis-org-8025 458 33 October October NNP www-bis-org-8025 458 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 459 1 Andalfatto Andalfatto NNP www-bis-org-8025 459 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 459 3 D D NNP www-bis-org-8025 459 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 459 5 2013 2013 CD www-bis-org-8025 459 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 459 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 459 8 Why why WRB www-bis-org-8025 459 9 gold gold NN www-bis-org-8025 459 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 459 11 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 459 12 make make VBP www-bis-org-8025 459 13 lousy lousy JJ www-bis-org-8025 459 14 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 459 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 459 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 459 17 Wednesday Wednesday NNP www-bis-org-8025 459 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 459 19 24 24 CD www-bis-org-8025 459 20 April April NNP www-bis-org-8025 459 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 459 22 2013 2013 CD www-bis-org-8025 459 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 459 24 MacroMania MacroMania NNP www-bis-org-8025 459 25 Blog Blog NNP www-bis-org-8025 459 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 460 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 460 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 460 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 460 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 460 5 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 460 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 460 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 460 8 My -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 460 9 perspective perspective NN www-bis-org-8025 460 10 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 460 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 460 12 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 460 13 Project Project NNP www-bis-org-8025 460 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 460 15 collected collect VBN www-bis-org-8025 460 16 works work NNS www-bis-org-8025 460 17 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 460 18 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 460 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 460 20 21 21 CD www-bis-org-8025 460 21 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 460 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 460 23 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 460 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 460 25 MacroMania MacroMania NNP www-bis-org-8025 460 26 Blog Blog NNP www-bis-org-8025 460 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 461 1 Athey athey UH www-bis-org-8025 461 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 3 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 5 I -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 461 6 Parashkevov parashkevov VBP www-bis-org-8025 461 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 8 V V NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 9 Sarukkai Sarukkai NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 461 12 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 13 Xia Xia NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 461 15 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 461 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 461 17 : : : www-bis-org-8025 461 18 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 461 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 20 pricing pricing NN www-bis-org-8025 461 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 22 adoption adoption NN www-bis-org-8025 461 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 24 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 461 25 usage usage NN www-bis-org-8025 461 26 : : : www-bis-org-8025 461 27 theory theory NN www-bis-org-8025 461 28 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 461 29 evidence evidence NN www-bis-org-8025 461 30 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 461 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 32 SIEPR SIEPR NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 33 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 461 34 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 461 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 461 36 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 461 37 17 17 CD www-bis-org-8025 461 38 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 461 39 033 033 CD www-bis-org-8025 461 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 462 1 Muneeb muneeb RB www-bis-org-8025 462 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 462 3 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 462 5 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 6 Nelson Nelson NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 462 8 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 462 9 Blankstein Blankstein NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 462 11 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 462 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 462 13 : : : www-bis-org-8025 462 14 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 462 15 Peer Peer NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 16 Review Review NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 17 : : : www-bis-org-8025 462 18 CBC CBC NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 19 Casper Casper NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 462 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 462 22 Medium.com Medium.com NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 462 24 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 462 25 Dec. December NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 26 Auer Auer NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 462 28 R r NN www-bis-org-8025 462 29 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 462 30 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 31 Claessens Claessens NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 32 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 462 33 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 462 34 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 462 35 : : : www-bis-org-8025 462 36 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 462 37 Regulating regulating NN www-bis-org-8025 462 38 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 462 39 : : : www-bis-org-8025 462 40 Assessing assess VBG www-bis-org-8025 462 41 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 462 42 reactions reaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 462 43 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 462 44 , , , www-bis-org-8025 462 45 BIS BIS NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 46 Quarterly Quarterly NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 47 Review Review NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 48 , , , www-bis-org-8025 462 49 September September NNP www-bis-org-8025 462 50 . . . www-bis-org-8025 463 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 463 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 463 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 463 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 463 5 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 463 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 463 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 463 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 463 9 Cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 463 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 463 11 why why WRB www-bis-org-8025 463 12 not not RB www-bis-org-8025 463 13 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 463 14 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 463 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 463 16 regulate regulate VB www-bis-org-8025 463 17 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 463 18 “ " '' www-bis-org-8025 463 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 463 20 VoxEU VoxEU NNP www-bis-org-8025 463 21 EBook EBook NNP www-bis-org-8025 463 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 463 23 February February NNP www-bis-org-8025 463 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 464 1 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 464 2 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 464 3 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 464 4 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 464 5 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 464 6 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 464 7 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 464 8 : : : www-bis-org-8025 464 9 Annual Annual NNP www-bis-org-8025 464 10 Economic Economic NNP www-bis-org-8025 464 11 Report Report NNP www-bis-org-8025 464 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 464 13 June June NNP www-bis-org-8025 464 14 . . . www-bis-org-8025 465 1 Bech Bech NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 465 3 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 465 5 R R NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 6 Garratt Garratt NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 465 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 465 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 465 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 465 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 465 12 Central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 465 13 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 465 14 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 465 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 465 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 465 17 BIS BIS NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 18 Quarterly Quarterly NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 19 Review Review NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 465 21 September September NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 22 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 465 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 465 24 pp pp NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 25 55–70 55–70 NNP www-bis-org-8025 465 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 466 1 Berentsen Berentsen NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 466 3 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 466 5 F F NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 6 Schär Schär NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 466 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 466 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 466 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 466 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 466 13 Blockchain Blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 14 und und VBP www-bis-org-8025 466 15 Kryptoassets Kryptoassets NNPS www-bis-org-8025 466 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 466 17 Universität Universität NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 18 Basel Basel NNP www-bis-org-8025 466 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 467 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 467 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 467 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 467 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 467 5 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 467 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 467 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 467 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 467 9 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 467 10 short short JJ www-bis-org-8025 467 11 introduction introduction NN www-bis-org-8025 467 12 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 467 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 467 14 world world NN www-bis-org-8025 467 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 467 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 467 17 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 467 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 467 19 Federal Federal NNP www-bis-org-8025 467 20 Reserve Reserve NNP www-bis-org-8025 467 21 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 467 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 467 23 St St NNP www-bis-org-8025 467 24 Louis Louis NNP www-bis-org-8025 467 25 Review Review NNP www-bis-org-8025 467 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 467 27 vol vol NNP www-bis-org-8025 467 28 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 467 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 467 30 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 467 31 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 467 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 468 1 Biais Biais NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 468 3 B b NN www-bis-org-8025 468 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 468 5 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 6 Bisière Bisière NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 468 8 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 9 Bouvard Bouvard NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 468 11 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 12 Casamatta Casamatta NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 13 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 468 14 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 468 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 468 16 : : : www-bis-org-8025 468 17 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 468 18 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 468 19 blockchain blockchain JJ www-bis-org-8025 468 20 folk folk NN www-bis-org-8025 468 21 theorem theorem NN www-bis-org-8025 468 22 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 468 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 468 24 TSE TSE NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 25 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 468 26 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 468 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 468 28 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 468 29 17 17 CD www-bis-org-8025 468 30 - - SYM www-bis-org-8025 468 31 817 817 CD www-bis-org-8025 468 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 469 1 Biais Biais NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 469 3 B b NN www-bis-org-8025 469 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 469 5 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 6 Bisière Bisière NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 469 8 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 9 Bouvard Bouvard NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 469 11 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 12 Casamatta Casamatta NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 469 14 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 469 15 Menkveld Menkveld NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 16 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 469 17 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 469 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 469 19 : : : www-bis-org-8025 469 20 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 469 21 Equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 469 22 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 469 23 pricing pricing NN www-bis-org-8025 469 24 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 469 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 469 26 TSE TSE NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 27 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 28 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 469 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 469 30 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 469 31 18 18 CD www-bis-org-8025 469 32 - - SYM www-bis-org-8025 469 33 973 973 CD www-bis-org-8025 469 34 , , , www-bis-org-8025 469 35 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 469 36 . . . www-bis-org-8025 470 1 Böhme Böhme NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 3 R r NN www-bis-org-8025 470 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 5 N N NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 6 Christin Christin NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 8 B B NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 9 Edelman Edelman NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 470 12 T T NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 13 Moore Moore NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 470 15 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 470 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 470 17 : : : www-bis-org-8025 470 18 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 470 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 20 : : : www-bis-org-8025 470 21 economics economics NN www-bis-org-8025 470 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 23 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 470 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 25 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 470 26 governance governance NN www-bis-org-8025 470 27 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 470 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 29 Journal Journal NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 30 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 470 31 Economic Economic NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 32 Perspectives Perspectives NNPS www-bis-org-8025 470 33 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 34 vol vol NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 35 29 29 CD www-bis-org-8025 470 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 37 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 470 38 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 470 39 , , , www-bis-org-8025 470 40 pp pp NNP www-bis-org-8025 470 41 213–38 213–38 CD www-bis-org-8025 470 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 471 1 Bolt Bolt NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 471 3 W W NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 471 5 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 6 van van NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 7 Oordt Oordt NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 8 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 471 9 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 471 10 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 471 11 : : : www-bis-org-8025 471 12 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 471 13 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 471 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 471 15 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 471 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 471 17 virtual virtual JJ www-bis-org-8025 471 18 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 471 19 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 471 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 471 21 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 471 23 Canada Canada NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 24 Staff Staff NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 25 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 471 26 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 471 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 471 28 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 471 29 42 42 CD www-bis-org-8025 471 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 471 31 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 471 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 472 1 Borio Borio NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 2 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 472 3 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 472 4 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 472 5 : : : www-bis-org-8025 472 6 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 472 7 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 472 8 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 472 9 , , , www-bis-org-8025 472 10 debt debt NN www-bis-org-8025 472 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 472 12 trust trust NN www-bis-org-8025 472 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 472 14 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 472 15 banking banking NN www-bis-org-8025 472 16 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 472 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 472 18 keynote keynote JJ www-bis-org-8025 472 19 speech speech NN www-bis-org-8025 472 20 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 472 21 36th 36th JJ www-bis-org-8025 472 22 Annual Annual NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 23 Monetary Monetary NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 24 Conference Conference NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 472 26 Cato Cato NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 27 Institute Institute NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 472 29 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 472 30 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 472 32 Washington Washington NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 33 DC DC NNP www-bis-org-8025 472 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 473 1 Budish budish JJ www-bis-org-8025 473 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 473 3 E E NNS www-bis-org-8025 473 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 473 5 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 473 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 473 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 473 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 473 9 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 473 10 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 473 11 limits limit NNS www-bis-org-8025 473 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 473 13 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 473 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 473 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 473 16 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 473 17 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 473 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 473 19 NBER NBER NNP www-bis-org-8025 473 20 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 473 21 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 473 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 473 23 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 473 24 24717 24717 CD www-bis-org-8025 473 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 473 26 June June NNP www-bis-org-8025 473 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 474 1 Buterin Buterin NNP www-bis-org-8025 474 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 474 3 V v NN www-bis-org-8025 474 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 474 5 2014a 2014a CD www-bis-org-8025 474 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 474 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 474 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 474 9 Proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 474 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 474 11 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 474 12 : : : www-bis-org-8025 474 13 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 474 14 I -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 474 15 learned learn VBD www-bis-org-8025 474 16 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 474 17 love love VB www-bis-org-8025 474 18 weak weak JJ www-bis-org-8025 474 19 subjectivity subjectivity NN www-bis-org-8025 474 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 474 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 474 22 25 25 CD www-bis-org-8025 474 23 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 474 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 475 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 475 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 475 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 475 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 475 5 2014b 2014b CD www-bis-org-8025 475 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 475 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 475 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 475 9 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 475 10 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 475 11 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 475 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 475 13 ethereum.org ethereum.org NNP www-bis-org-8025 475 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 475 15 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 475 16 July July NNP www-bis-org-8025 475 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 476 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 476 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 476 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 476 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 476 5 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 476 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 476 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 476 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 476 9 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 476 10 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 476 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 476 12 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 476 13 design design NN www-bis-org-8025 476 14 philosophy philosophy NN www-bis-org-8025 476 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 476 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 476 17 Medium.com Medium.com NNP www-bis-org-8025 476 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 476 19 30 30 CD www-bis-org-8025 476 20 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 476 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 477 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 477 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 477 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 477 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 477 5 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 477 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 477 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 477 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 477 9 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 477 10 meaning meaning NN www-bis-org-8025 477 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 477 12 decentralization decentralization NN www-bis-org-8025 477 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 477 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 477 15 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 477 16 February February NNP www-bis-org-8025 477 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 478 1 Buterin Buterin NNP www-bis-org-8025 478 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 478 3 V v NN www-bis-org-8025 478 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 478 5 V V NNP www-bis-org-8025 478 6 Griffith Griffith NNP www-bis-org-8025 478 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 478 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 478 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 478 12 Casper casper VB www-bis-org-8025 478 13 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 478 14 friendly friendly JJ www-bis-org-8025 478 15 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 478 16 gadget gadget NN www-bis-org-8025 478 17 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 478 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 19 submitted submit VBN www-bis-org-8025 478 20 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 478 21 25 25 CD www-bis-org-8025 478 22 Oct Oct NNP www-bis-org-8025 478 23 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 478 24 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 25 v1 v1 NNP www-bis-org-8025 478 26 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 478 28 last last RB www-bis-org-8025 478 29 revised revise VBD www-bis-org-8025 478 30 22 22 CD www-bis-org-8025 478 31 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 478 32 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 478 33 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 34 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 478 35 version version NN www-bis-org-8025 478 36 , , , www-bis-org-8025 478 37 v3 v3 NN www-bis-org-8025 478 38 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 39 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 478 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 478 41 arXiv:1710.09437 arXiv:1710.09437 NNP www-bis-org-8025 478 42 . . . www-bis-org-8025 479 1 Carney Carney NNP www-bis-org-8025 479 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 479 3 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 479 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 479 5 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 479 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 479 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 479 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 479 9 FSB FSB NNP www-bis-org-8025 479 10 Chair Chair NNP www-bis-org-8025 479 11 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 479 12 letter letter NN www-bis-org-8025 479 13 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 479 14 G20 G20 NNP www-bis-org-8025 479 15 finance finance NN www-bis-org-8025 479 16 ministers minister NNS www-bis-org-8025 479 17 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 479 18 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 479 19 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 479 20 Governors Governors NNPS www-bis-org-8025 479 21 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 479 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 479 23 13 13 CD www-bis-org-8025 479 24 March March NNP www-bis-org-8025 479 25 . . . www-bis-org-8025 480 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 480 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 480 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 480 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 480 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 480 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 480 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 480 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 480 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 480 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 480 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 480 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 480 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 480 16 25 25 CD www-bis-org-8025 480 17 Carstens Carstens NNPS www-bis-org-8025 480 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 480 19 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 480 20 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 480 21 2018a 2018a CD www-bis-org-8025 480 22 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 480 23 : : : www-bis-org-8025 480 24 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 480 25 Money money NN www-bis-org-8025 480 26 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 480 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 480 28 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 480 29 age age NN www-bis-org-8025 480 30 : : : www-bis-org-8025 480 31 what what WDT www-bis-org-8025 480 32 role role NN www-bis-org-8025 480 33 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 480 34 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 480 35 banks bank NNS www-bis-org-8025 480 36 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 480 37 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 480 38 , , , www-bis-org-8025 480 39 lecture lecture NN www-bis-org-8025 480 40 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 480 41 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 480 42 House House NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 43 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 480 44 Finance Finance NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 45 , , , www-bis-org-8025 480 46 Goethe Goethe NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 47 University University NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 48 , , , www-bis-org-8025 480 49 Frankfurt Frankfurt NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 50 , , , www-bis-org-8025 480 51 6 6 CD www-bis-org-8025 480 52 February February NNP www-bis-org-8025 480 53 . . . www-bis-org-8025 481 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 481 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 481 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 481 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 481 5 2018b 2018b CD www-bis-org-8025 481 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 481 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 481 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 481 9 Central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 481 10 banks bank NNS www-bis-org-8025 481 11 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 481 12 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 481 13 : : : www-bis-org-8025 481 14 guarding guard VBG www-bis-org-8025 481 15 trust trust NN www-bis-org-8025 481 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 481 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 481 18 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 481 19 age age NN www-bis-org-8025 481 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 481 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 481 22 remarks remark VBZ www-bis-org-8025 481 23 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 481 24 Brookings Brookings NNP www-bis-org-8025 481 25 Institution Institution NNP www-bis-org-8025 481 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 481 27 Washington Washington NNP www-bis-org-8025 481 28 DC DC NNP www-bis-org-8025 481 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 481 30 17 17 CD www-bis-org-8025 481 31 April April NNP www-bis-org-8025 481 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 482 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 482 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 482 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 482 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 482 5 2018c 2018c CD www-bis-org-8025 482 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 482 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 482 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 482 9 Technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 482 10 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 482 11 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 482 12 substitute substitute NN www-bis-org-8025 482 13 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 482 14 trust trust NN www-bis-org-8025 482 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 482 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 482 17 Börsen Börsen NNP www-bis-org-8025 482 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 482 19 Zeitung Zeitung NNP www-bis-org-8025 482 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 482 21 23 23 CD www-bis-org-8025 482 22 May. May NNP www-bis-org-8025 483 1 Catalini Catalini NNP www-bis-org-8025 483 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 483 3 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 483 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 483 5 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 483 6 Gans Gans NNPS www-bis-org-8025 483 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 483 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 483 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 483 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 483 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 483 12 Some some DT www-bis-org-8025 483 13 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 483 14 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 483 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 483 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 483 17 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 483 18 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 483 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 483 20 MIT MIT NNP www-bis-org-8025 483 21 Sloan Sloan NNP www-bis-org-8025 483 22 Research Research NNP www-bis-org-8025 483 23 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 483 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 483 25 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 483 26 5191 5191 CD www-bis-org-8025 483 27 - - SYM www-bis-org-8025 483 28 16 16 CD www-bis-org-8025 483 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 484 1 Chaum Chaum NNP www-bis-org-8025 484 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 484 3 D D NNP www-bis-org-8025 484 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 484 5 1983 1983 CD www-bis-org-8025 484 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 484 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 484 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 484 9 Blind blind JJ www-bis-org-8025 484 10 signatures signature NNS www-bis-org-8025 484 11 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 484 12 untraceable untraceable JJ www-bis-org-8025 484 13 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 484 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 484 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 484 16 Proceedings proceeding NNS www-bis-org-8025 484 17 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 484 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 484 19 Springer Springer NNP www-bis-org-8025 484 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 484 21 Verlag Verlag NNP www-bis-org-8025 484 22 Crypto’82 Crypto’82 : www-bis-org-8025 484 23 conference conference NN www-bis-org-8025 484 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 484 25 vol vol NNP www-bis-org-8025 484 26 82 82 CD www-bis-org-8025 484 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 484 28 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 484 29 3 3 CD www-bis-org-8025 484 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 484 31 pp pp NNP www-bis-org-8025 484 32 199–203 199–203 CD www-bis-org-8025 484 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 485 1 Clayton Clayton NNP www-bis-org-8025 485 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 485 3 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 485 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 485 5 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 485 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 485 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 485 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 485 9 Chairman chairman NN www-bis-org-8025 485 10 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 485 11 testimony testimony NN www-bis-org-8025 485 12 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 485 13 virtual virtual JJ www-bis-org-8025 485 14 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 485 15 : : : www-bis-org-8025 485 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 485 17 roles role NNS www-bis-org-8025 485 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 485 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 485 20 SEC SEC NNP www-bis-org-8025 485 21 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 485 22 CFTC CFTC NNP www-bis-org-8025 485 23 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 485 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 486 1 Chiu Chiu NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 3 Jonathan Jonathan NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 486 5 Koeppl Koeppl NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 7 Thorsten Thorsten NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 486 10 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 486 11 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 486 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 13 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 486 14 Economics Economics NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 486 16 Cryptocurrencies Cryptocurrencies NNPS www-bis-org-8025 486 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 486 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 486 20 Beyond Beyond NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 22 No no DT www-bis-org-8025 486 23 1389 1389 CD www-bis-org-8025 486 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 25 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 26 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 486 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 28 Queen Queen NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 29 's 's POS www-bis-org-8025 486 30 University University NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 32 Department Department NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 33 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 486 34 Economics Economics NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 36 Committee Committee NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 37 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 486 38 Payments Payments NNPS www-bis-org-8025 486 39 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 486 40 Market Market NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 41 Infrastructures Infrastructures NNPS www-bis-org-8025 486 42 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 486 43 2012 2012 CD www-bis-org-8025 486 44 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 486 45 : : : www-bis-org-8025 486 46 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 486 47 Payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 486 48 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 49 clearing clearing NN www-bis-org-8025 486 50 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 486 51 settlement settlement NN www-bis-org-8025 486 52 systems system NNS www-bis-org-8025 486 53 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 486 54 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 486 55 CPSS CPSS NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 56 countries country NNS www-bis-org-8025 486 57 – – : www-bis-org-8025 486 58 Volume volume NN www-bis-org-8025 486 59 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 486 60 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 486 61 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 62 CPMI CPMI NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 63 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 486 64 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 65 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 486 66 105 105 CD www-bis-org-8025 486 67 , , , www-bis-org-8025 486 68 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 486 69 . . . www-bis-org-8025 487 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 487 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 487 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 487 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 487 5 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 487 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 487 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 487 8 Digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 487 9 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 487 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 487 11 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 487 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 488 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 488 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 488 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 488 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 488 5 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 488 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 488 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 488 8 Statistics statistic NNS www-bis-org-8025 488 9 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 488 10 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 488 11 , , , www-bis-org-8025 488 12 clearing clearing NN www-bis-org-8025 488 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 488 14 settlement settlement NN www-bis-org-8025 488 15 systems system NNS www-bis-org-8025 488 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 488 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 488 18 CPMI CPMI NNP www-bis-org-8025 488 19 countries country NNS www-bis-org-8025 488 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 488 21 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 488 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 489 1 Committee Committee NNP www-bis-org-8025 489 2 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 489 3 Payments Payments NNP www-bis-org-8025 489 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 489 5 Market Market NNP www-bis-org-8025 489 6 Infrastructures Infrastructures NNPS www-bis-org-8025 489 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 489 8 Markets Markets NNPS www-bis-org-8025 489 9 Committee Committee NNP www-bis-org-8025 489 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 489 11 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 489 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 489 13 : : : www-bis-org-8025 489 14 Central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 489 15 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 489 16 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 489 17 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 489 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 489 19 March March NNP www-bis-org-8025 489 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 490 1 Committee Committee NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 2 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 490 3 Payments Payments NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 490 5 Market Market NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 6 Infrastructures Infrastructures NNPS www-bis-org-8025 490 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 490 8 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 9 Organization Organization NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 490 11 Securities Securities NNPS www-bis-org-8025 490 12 Commissions Commissions NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 13 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 490 14 2012 2012 CD www-bis-org-8025 490 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 490 16 : : : www-bis-org-8025 490 17 CPMI CPMI NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 490 19 IOSCO IOSCO NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 20 Principles Principles NNPS www-bis-org-8025 490 21 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 490 22 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 490 23 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 490 24 infrastructures infrastructure NNS www-bis-org-8025 490 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 490 26 April April NNP www-bis-org-8025 490 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 491 1 Committee Committee NNP www-bis-org-8025 491 2 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 491 3 Payment Payment NNP www-bis-org-8025 491 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 491 5 Settlement Settlement NNP www-bis-org-8025 491 6 Systems Systems NNPS www-bis-org-8025 491 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 491 8 2003 2003 CD www-bis-org-8025 491 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 491 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 491 11 Payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 491 12 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 491 13 settlement settlement NN www-bis-org-8025 491 14 systems system NNS www-bis-org-8025 491 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 491 16 selected select VBN www-bis-org-8025 491 17 countries country NNS www-bis-org-8025 491 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 491 19 April April NNP www-bis-org-8025 491 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 492 1 Dryja dryja NN www-bis-org-8025 492 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 492 3 T T NNP www-bis-org-8025 492 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 492 5 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 492 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 492 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 492 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 492 9 Scalability scalability NN www-bis-org-8025 492 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 492 11 lightning lightning NN www-bis-org-8025 492 12 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 492 13 different different JJ www-bis-org-8025 492 14 BIPs bip NNS www-bis-org-8025 492 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 492 16 some some DT www-bis-org-8025 492 17 back back JJ www-bis-org-8025 492 18 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 492 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 492 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 492 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 492 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 492 23 envelope envelope NN www-bis-org-8025 492 24 calculations calculation NNS www-bis-org-8025 492 25 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 492 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 492 27 https://scalingbitcoin.org/hongkong2015/presentations/DAY2/1_layer2_2_dryja.pdf https://scalingbitcoin.org/hongkong2015/presentations/day2/1_layer2_2_dryja.pdf ADD www-bis-org-8025 492 28 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 492 29 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 492 30 19.11.2018 19.11.2018 NNP www-bis-org-8025 492 31 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 492 32 . . . www-bis-org-8025 493 1 Dwork Dwork NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 493 3 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 493 5 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 6 Naor Naor NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 493 8 1992 1992 CD www-bis-org-8025 493 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 493 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 493 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 493 12 Pricing pricing NN www-bis-org-8025 493 13 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 493 14 processing processing NN www-bis-org-8025 493 15 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 493 16 combatting combat VBG www-bis-org-8025 493 17 junk junk NN www-bis-org-8025 493 18 mail mail NN www-bis-org-8025 493 19 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 493 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 493 21 Proceedings Proceedings NNPS www-bis-org-8025 493 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 493 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 493 24 Annual Annual NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 25 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 26 Cryptology Cryptology NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 27 Conference Conference NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 493 29 Springer Springer NNP www-bis-org-8025 493 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 494 1 Easley Easley NNP www-bis-org-8025 494 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 494 3 D. D. NNP www-bis-org-8025 494 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 494 5 O'Hara O'Hara NNP www-bis-org-8025 494 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 494 7 M. M. NNP www-bis-org-8025 494 8 , , , www-bis-org-8025 494 9 Basu Basu NNP www-bis-org-8025 494 10 , , , www-bis-org-8025 494 11 S. S. NNP www-bis-org-8025 494 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 494 13 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 494 14 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 494 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 494 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 495 1 From from IN www-bis-org-8025 495 2 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 495 3 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 495 4 markets market NNS www-bis-org-8025 495 5 : : : www-bis-org-8025 495 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 495 7 evolution evolution NN www-bis-org-8025 495 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 495 9 bitcoin bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 10 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 495 11 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 495 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 495 13 Forthcoming Forthcoming NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 495 15 Journal Journal NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 495 17 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 18 Economics Economics NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 19 Fanusie Fanusie NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 495 21 Y Y NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 495 23 T T NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 24 Robinson Robinson NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 25 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 495 26 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 495 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 495 28 : : : www-bis-org-8025 495 29 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 495 30 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 31 laundering laundering NN www-bis-org-8025 495 32 : : : www-bis-org-8025 495 33 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 495 34 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 495 35 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 495 36 illicit illicit NN www-bis-org-8025 495 37 flows flow VBZ www-bis-org-8025 495 38 into into IN www-bis-org-8025 495 39 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 495 40 currency currency NN www-bis-org-8025 495 41 services service NNS www-bis-org-8025 495 42 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 495 43 , , , www-bis-org-8025 495 44 Center Center NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 45 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 495 46 Sanctions Sanctions NNPS www-bis-org-8025 495 47 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 495 48 Illicit Illicit NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 49 Finance Finance NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 50 memorandum memorandum NN www-bis-org-8025 495 51 , , , www-bis-org-8025 495 52 January January NNP www-bis-org-8025 495 53 . . . www-bis-org-8025 496 1 Fernández Fernández NNP www-bis-org-8025 496 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 496 3 Villaverde Villaverde NNP www-bis-org-8025 496 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 496 5 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 496 6 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 496 7 D D NNP www-bis-org-8025 496 8 Sanches Sanches NNP www-bis-org-8025 496 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 496 10 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 496 11 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 496 12 : : : www-bis-org-8025 496 13 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 496 14 Can Can MD www-bis-org-8025 496 15 currency currency NN www-bis-org-8025 496 16 competition competition NN www-bis-org-8025 496 17 work work VB www-bis-org-8025 496 18 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 496 19 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 496 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 496 21 CEPR CEPR NNP www-bis-org-8025 496 22 Discussion Discussion NNP www-bis-org-8025 496 23 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 496 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 496 25 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 496 26 11095 11095 CD www-bis-org-8025 496 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 497 1 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 497 2 Action Action NNP www-bis-org-8025 497 3 Task Task NNP www-bis-org-8025 497 4 Force Force NNP www-bis-org-8025 497 5 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 497 6 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 497 7 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 497 8 : : : www-bis-org-8025 497 9 Guidance guidance NN www-bis-org-8025 497 10 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 497 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 497 12 risk risk NN www-bis-org-8025 497 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 497 14 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 497 15 approach approach NN www-bis-org-8025 497 16 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 497 17 virtual virtual JJ www-bis-org-8025 497 18 currencies currency NNS www-bis-org-8025 497 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 497 20 June June NNP www-bis-org-8025 497 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 498 1 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 498 2 Stability Stability NNP www-bis-org-8025 498 3 Board Board NNP www-bis-org-8025 498 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 498 5 2018a 2018a CD www-bis-org-8025 498 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 498 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 498 8 Crypto crypto NN www-bis-org-8025 498 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 498 10 assets asset NNS www-bis-org-8025 498 11 : : : www-bis-org-8025 498 12 report report VB www-bis-org-8025 498 13 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 498 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 498 15 G20 G20 NNP www-bis-org-8025 498 16 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 498 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 498 18 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 498 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 498 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 498 21 FSB FSB NNP www-bis-org-8025 498 22 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 498 23 standard- standard- JJ www-bis-org-8025 498 24 setting setting NN www-bis-org-8025 498 25 bodies body NNS www-bis-org-8025 498 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 498 27 July July NNP www-bis-org-8025 498 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 499 1 — — : www-bis-org-8025 499 2 — — : www-bis-org-8025 499 3 — — : www-bis-org-8025 499 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 499 5 2018b 2018b CD www-bis-org-8025 499 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 499 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 499 8 Crypto crypto NN www-bis-org-8025 499 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 499 10 asset asset NN www-bis-org-8025 499 11 markets market NNS www-bis-org-8025 499 12 Potential potential JJ www-bis-org-8025 499 13 channels channel NNS www-bis-org-8025 499 14 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 499 15 future future JJ www-bis-org-8025 499 16 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 499 17 stability stability NN www-bis-org-8025 499 18 implications implication NNS www-bis-org-8025 499 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 499 20 October October NNP www-bis-org-8025 499 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 500 1 Foley Foley NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 500 3 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 500 5 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 6 Karlsen Karlsen NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 500 8 T T NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 9 Putniņš Putniņš NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 500 11 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 500 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 500 13 : : : www-bis-org-8025 500 14 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 500 15 Sex sex NN www-bis-org-8025 500 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 500 17 drugs drug NNS www-bis-org-8025 500 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 500 19 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 500 20 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 500 21 : : : www-bis-org-8025 500 22 how how WRB www-bis-org-8025 500 23 much much JJ www-bis-org-8025 500 24 illegal illegal JJ www-bis-org-8025 500 25 activity activity NN www-bis-org-8025 500 26 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 500 27 financed finance VBN www-bis-org-8025 500 28 through through IN www-bis-org-8025 500 29 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 500 30 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 500 31 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 500 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 500 33 Review Review NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 34 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 500 35 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 500 36 Studies Studies NNPS www-bis-org-8025 500 37 , , , www-bis-org-8025 500 38 forthcoming forthcoming JJ www-bis-org-8025 500 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 501 1 Lloyd Lloyd NNP www-bis-org-8025 501 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 501 3 W W NNP www-bis-org-8025 501 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 501 5 1833 1833 CD www-bis-org-8025 501 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 501 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 501 8 Two two CD www-bis-org-8025 501 9 Lectures lecture NNS www-bis-org-8025 501 10 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 501 11 Population Population NNP www-bis-org-8025 501 12 , , , www-bis-org-8025 501 13 unpublished unpublished JJ www-bis-org-8025 501 14 manuscript manuscript NN www-bis-org-8025 501 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 502 1 G20 G20 NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 2 Finance Finance NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 3 Ministers Ministers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 502 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 502 5 Central Central NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 6 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 7 Governors Governors NNPS www-bis-org-8025 502 8 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 502 9 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 502 10 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 502 11 : : : www-bis-org-8025 502 12 Buenos Buenos NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 13 Aires Aires NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 14 Summit Summit NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 15 communiqué communiqué NN www-bis-org-8025 502 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 502 17 19–20 19–20 CD www-bis-org-8025 502 18 March March NNP www-bis-org-8025 502 19 . . . www-bis-org-8025 503 1 https://scalingbitcoin.org/hongkong2015/presentations/DAY2/1_layer2_2_dryja.pdf https://scalingbitcoin.org/hongkong2015/presentations/DAY2/1_layer2_2_dryja.pdf NNP www-bis-org-8025 503 2 26 26 CD www-bis-org-8025 503 3 WP765 wp765 NN www-bis-org-8025 503 4 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 503 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 503 6 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 503 7 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 503 8 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 503 9 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 503 10 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 503 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 503 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 503 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 503 14 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 503 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 503 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 503 17 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 503 18 Giannini Giannini NNP www-bis-org-8025 503 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 503 20 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 503 21 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 503 22 2011 2011 CD www-bis-org-8025 503 23 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 503 24 : : : www-bis-org-8025 503 25 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 503 26 age age NN www-bis-org-8025 503 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 503 28 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 503 29 banks bank NNS www-bis-org-8025 503 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 503 31 Edward Edward NNP www-bis-org-8025 503 32 Elgar Elgar NNP www-bis-org-8025 503 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 504 1 Graeber Graeber NNP www-bis-org-8025 504 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 504 3 D d NN www-bis-org-8025 504 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 504 5 2011 2011 CD www-bis-org-8025 504 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 504 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 504 8 Debt debt NN www-bis-org-8025 504 9 : : : www-bis-org-8025 504 10 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 504 11 First first JJ www-bis-org-8025 504 12 5,000 5,000 CD www-bis-org-8025 504 13 Years year NNS www-bis-org-8025 504 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 504 15 Melville Melville NNP www-bis-org-8025 504 16 House House NNP www-bis-org-8025 504 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 505 1 Huberman Huberman NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 505 3 G G NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 505 5 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 6 Leshno Leshno NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 505 8 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 9 Moellemi Moellemi NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 505 11 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 505 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 505 13 : : : www-bis-org-8025 505 14 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 505 15 Monopoly monopoly NN www-bis-org-8025 505 16 without without IN www-bis-org-8025 505 17 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 505 18 monopolist monopolist NN www-bis-org-8025 505 19 : : : www-bis-org-8025 505 20 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 505 21 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 505 22 analysis analysis NN www-bis-org-8025 505 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 505 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 505 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 26 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 505 27 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 505 28 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 505 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 505 30 Columbia Columbia NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 31 Business Business NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 32 School School NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 33 Research Research NNP www-bis-org-8025 505 34 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 505 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 505 36 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 505 37 17 17 CD www-bis-org-8025 505 38 - - SYM www-bis-org-8025 505 39 92 92 CD www-bis-org-8025 505 40 . . . www-bis-org-8025 506 1 Kiayias Kiayias NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 506 3 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 506 5 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 506 6 Russell Russell NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 506 8 B B NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 9 David David NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 506 11 R R NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 12 Oliynykov Oliynykov NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 13 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 506 14 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 506 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 506 16 : : : www-bis-org-8025 506 17 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 506 18 Ouroboros Ouroboros NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 19 : : : www-bis-org-8025 506 20 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 506 21 provably provably RB www-bis-org-8025 506 22 secure secure JJ www-bis-org-8025 506 23 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 506 24 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 506 25 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 506 26 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 506 27 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 506 28 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 29 protocol protocol NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 30 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 506 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 506 32 EPrint EPrint NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 33 Archive Archive NNP www-bis-org-8025 506 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 507 1 Landau Landau NNS www-bis-org-8025 507 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 507 3 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 507 5 P P NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 6 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 507 7 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 8 Genais Genais NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 9 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 507 10 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 507 11 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 507 12 : : : www-bis-org-8025 507 13 Les Les NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 14 crypto crypto NN www-bis-org-8025 507 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 507 16 monnaies monnaies NN www-bis-org-8025 507 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 507 18 rapport rapport NN www-bis-org-8025 507 19 au au NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 20 Ministre Ministre NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 21 de de NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 22 l’Économie l’Économie NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 23 et et FW www-bis-org-8025 507 24 des des FW www-bis-org-8025 507 25 Finances Finances NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 507 27 4 4 CD www-bis-org-8025 507 28 July July NNP www-bis-org-8025 507 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 508 1 Lewis Lewis NNP www-bis-org-8025 508 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 508 3 D d NN www-bis-org-8025 508 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 508 5 1969 1969 CD www-bis-org-8025 508 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 508 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 508 8 Convention convention NN www-bis-org-8025 508 9 : : : www-bis-org-8025 508 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 508 11 philosophical philosophical JJ www-bis-org-8025 508 12 study study NN www-bis-org-8025 508 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 508 14 Blackwell Blackwell NNP www-bis-org-8025 508 15 Publishing Publishing NNP www-bis-org-8025 508 16 . . . www-bis-org-8025 509 1 Lewis Lewis NNP www-bis-org-8025 509 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 509 3 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 509 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 509 5 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 509 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 509 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 509 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 509 9 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 509 10 seven seven CD www-bis-org-8025 509 11 deadly deadly JJ www-bis-org-8025 509 12 paradoxes paradox NNS www-bis-org-8025 509 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 509 14 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 509 15 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 509 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 509 17 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 509 18 Underground Underground NNP www-bis-org-8025 509 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 509 20 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 509 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 509 22 England England NNP www-bis-org-8025 509 23 , , , www-bis-org-8025 509 24 13 13 CD www-bis-org-8025 509 25 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 509 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 510 1 Morris Morris NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 510 3 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 510 5 H H NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 6 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 7 Shin Shin NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 8 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 510 9 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 510 10 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 510 11 : : : www-bis-org-8025 510 12 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 510 13 Distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 510 14 ledger ledger JJ www-bis-org-8025 510 15 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 510 16 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 510 17 large large JJ www-bis-org-8025 510 18 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 510 19 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 510 20 : : : www-bis-org-8025 510 21 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 510 22 global global JJ www-bis-org-8025 510 23 game game NN www-bis-org-8025 510 24 approach approach NN www-bis-org-8025 510 25 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 510 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 510 27 mimeo mimeo NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 510 29 Princeton Princeton NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 30 University University NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 510 32 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 510 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 511 1 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-bis-org-8025 511 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 511 3 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 511 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 511 5 2008 2008 CD www-bis-org-8025 511 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 511 7 : : : www-bis-org-8025 511 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 511 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 511 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 511 11 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 511 12 peer peer NN www-bis-org-8025 511 13 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 511 14 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 511 15 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 511 16 peer peer NN www-bis-org-8025 511 17 electronic electronic JJ www-bis-org-8025 511 18 cash cash NN www-bis-org-8025 511 19 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 511 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 511 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 511 22 white white JJ www-bis-org-8025 511 23 paper paper NNP www-bis-org-8025 511 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 511 25 https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf NNP www-bis-org-8025 511 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 512 1 Pichler Pichler NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 512 3 P p NN www-bis-org-8025 512 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 512 5 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 512 6 Schierlinger Schierlinger NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 7 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 512 8 Brandmayr Brandmayr NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 512 10 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 11 Summer Summer NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 12 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 512 13 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 512 14 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 512 15 : : : www-bis-org-8025 512 16 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 512 17 Digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 512 18 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 512 19 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 512 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 512 21 Monetary Monetary NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 22 Policy Policy NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 23 & & CC www-bis-org-8025 512 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 512 25 Economy Economy NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 26 , , , www-bis-org-8025 512 27 Oesterreichische Oesterreichische NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 28 Nationalbank Nationalbank NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 512 30 Q3/18 Q3/18 NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 512 32 pp pp NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 33 23–35 23–35 NNP www-bis-org-8025 512 34 . . . www-bis-org-8025 513 1 Poelstra Poelstra NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 3 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 513 4 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 5 2014 2014 CD www-bis-org-8025 513 6 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 513 8 Distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 513 9 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 513 10 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 513 11 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 513 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 513 13 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 513 14 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 513 15 impossible impossible JJ www-bis-org-8025 513 16 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 513 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 18 2014 2014 CD www-bis-org-8025 513 19 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 20 https:// https:// NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 21 download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/old-pos.pdf download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/old-pos.pdf NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 23 May May NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 24 — — : www-bis-org-8025 513 25 — — : www-bis-org-8025 513 26 — — : www-bis-org-8025 513 27 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 28 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 513 29 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 30 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 513 31 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 513 32 Stake Stake NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 33 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 513 34 Consensus Consensus NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 35 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 513 36 https://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/pos.pdf https://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/pos.pdf NN www-bis-org-8025 513 37 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 38 March March NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 39 Poon Poon NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 40 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 41 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 42 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 513 43 T T NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 44 Dryja Dryja NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 45 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 46 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 513 47 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 48 : : : www-bis-org-8025 513 49 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 513 50 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 513 51 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 52 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 53 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 54 : : : www-bis-org-8025 513 55 Scalable scalable VB www-bis-org-8025 513 56 off off IN www-bis-org-8025 513 57 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 513 58 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 513 59 instant instant NN www-bis-org-8025 513 60 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 513 61 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 513 62 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 63 DRAFT DRAFT NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 64 Version Version NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 65 0.5.9.2 0.5.9.2 CD www-bis-org-8025 513 66 , , , www-bis-org-8025 513 67 www.lightning.network www.lightning.network ADD www-bis-org-8025 513 68 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 69 accessed access VBN www-bis-org-8025 513 70 19.11.2018 19.11.2018 NNP www-bis-org-8025 513 71 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 513 72 . . . www-bis-org-8025 514 1 Prat Prat NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 514 3 J J NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 514 5 W W NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 6 Benjamin Benjamin NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 514 8 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 514 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 514 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 514 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 514 12 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 514 13 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 514 14 model model NN www-bis-org-8025 514 15 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 514 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 514 17 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 514 18 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 514 19 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 514 20 mining mining NN www-bis-org-8025 514 21 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 514 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 514 23 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 24 Paper Paper NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 25 , , , www-bis-org-8025 514 26 2017 2017 CD www-bis-org-8025 514 27 - - SYM www-bis-org-8025 514 28 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 514 29 , , , www-bis-org-8025 514 30 Center Center NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 31 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 514 32 Research Research NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 33 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 514 34 Economics Economics NNP www-bis-org-8025 514 35 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 514 36 Statistics Statistics NNPS www-bis-org-8025 514 37 . . . www-bis-org-8025 515 1 Schilling schilling NN www-bis-org-8025 515 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 515 3 L l NN www-bis-org-8025 515 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 515 5 H H NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 6 Uhlig Uhlig NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 515 8 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 515 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 515 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 515 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 515 12 Some some DT www-bis-org-8025 515 13 Simple Simple NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 15 Economics Economics NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 16 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 515 17 , , , www-bis-org-8025 515 18 NBER NBER NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 19 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 20 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 515 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 515 22 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 515 23 24483 24483 CD www-bis-org-8025 515 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 515 25 National National NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 26 Bureau Bureau NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 515 28 Economic Economic NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 29 Research Research NNP www-bis-org-8025 515 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 516 1 Schnabel Schnabel NNP www-bis-org-8025 516 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 516 3 I -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 516 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 516 5 H H NNP www-bis-org-8025 516 6 S S NNP www-bis-org-8025 516 7 Shin Shin NNP www-bis-org-8025 516 8 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 516 9 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 516 10 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 516 11 : : : www-bis-org-8025 516 12 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 516 13 Money money NN www-bis-org-8025 516 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 516 15 trust trust NN www-bis-org-8025 516 16 : : : www-bis-org-8025 516 17 lessons lesson NNS www-bis-org-8025 516 18 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 516 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 516 20 1620s 1620s CD www-bis-org-8025 516 21 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 516 22 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 516 23 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 516 24 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 516 25 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 516 26 age age NN www-bis-org-8025 516 27 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 516 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 516 29 BIS BIS NNP www-bis-org-8025 516 30 Working Working NNP www-bis-org-8025 516 31 Papers Papers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 516 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 516 33 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 516 34 698 698 CD www-bis-org-8025 516 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 516 36 February February NNP www-bis-org-8025 516 37 . . . www-bis-org-8025 517 1 Sompolinsky Sompolinsky NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 517 3 Y Y NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 517 5 Y Y NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 6 Lewenberg Lewenberg NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 517 8 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 9 Zohar Zohar NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 10 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 517 11 2016 2016 CD www-bis-org-8025 517 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 517 13 : : : www-bis-org-8025 517 14 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 517 15 SPECTRE spectre NN www-bis-org-8025 517 16 : : : www-bis-org-8025 517 17 Serialization serialization NN www-bis-org-8025 517 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 517 19 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 517 20 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 517 21 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 517 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 517 23 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 517 24 events event NNS www-bis-org-8025 517 25 : : : www-bis-org-8025 517 26 confirming confirm VBG www-bis-org-8025 517 27 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 517 28 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 517 29 recursive recursive JJ www-bis-org-8025 517 30 elections election NNS www-bis-org-8025 517 31 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 517 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 517 33 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 517 34 1159 1159 CD www-bis-org-8025 517 35 , , , www-bis-org-8025 517 36 Cryptology Cryptology NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 37 ePrint ePrint NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 38 Archive Archive NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 39 , , , www-bis-org-8025 517 40 IACR IACR NNP www-bis-org-8025 517 41 . . . www-bis-org-8025 518 1 Sompolinsky Sompolinsky NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 518 3 Y Y NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 518 5 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 6 Zohar Zohar NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 518 8 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 518 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 518 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 518 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 518 12 PHANTOM PHANTOM NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 518 14 GHOSTDAG GHOSTDAG NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 15 : : : www-bis-org-8025 518 16 Two two CD www-bis-org-8025 518 17 Scalable Scalable NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 18 BlockDAG BlockDAG '' www-bis-org-8025 518 19 protocols protocol NNS www-bis-org-8025 518 20 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 518 21 , , , www-bis-org-8025 518 22 no no DT www-bis-org-8025 518 23 1004 1004 CD www-bis-org-8025 518 24 , , , www-bis-org-8025 518 25 Cryptology Cryptology NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 26 ePrint ePrint NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 27 Archive Archive NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 518 29 IACR IACR NNP www-bis-org-8025 518 30 . . . www-bis-org-8025 519 1 Sompolinsky Sompolinsky NNP www-bis-org-8025 519 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 519 3 Y Y NNP www-bis-org-8025 519 4 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 519 5 A A NNP www-bis-org-8025 519 6 Zohar Zohar NNP www-bis-org-8025 519 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 519 8 2005 2005 CD www-bis-org-8025 519 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 519 10 : : : www-bis-org-8025 519 11 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 519 12 Bit bit VB www-bis-org-8025 519 13 Gold gold NN www-bis-org-8025 519 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 519 15 , , , www-bis-org-8025 519 16 Unenumerated unenumerated JJ www-bis-org-8025 519 17 blog blog NN www-bis-org-8025 519 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 519 19 http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2005/12/bit-gold.html http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2005/12/bit-gold.html NN www-bis-org-8025 519 20 , , , www-bis-org-8025 519 21 retrieved retrieve VBD www-bis-org-8025 519 22 25 25 CD www-bis-org-8025 519 23 October October NNP www-bis-org-8025 519 24 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 519 25 . . . www-bis-org-8025 520 1 Zamfir Zamfir NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 2 , , , www-bis-org-8025 520 3 V v NN www-bis-org-8025 520 4 , , , www-bis-org-8025 520 5 N N NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 6 Rush Rush NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 7 , , , www-bis-org-8025 520 8 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 520 9 Asgaonkar Asgaonkar NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 520 11 G G NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 12 Piliouras Piliouras NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 13 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 520 14 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 520 15 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 520 16 : : : www-bis-org-8025 520 17 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 520 18 Introducing introduce VBG www-bis-org-8025 520 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 520 20 minimal minimal JJ www-bis-org-8025 520 21 CBC CBC NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 22 Casper Casper NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 23 family family NN www-bis-org-8025 520 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 520 25 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 520 26 protocols protocol NNS www-bis-org-8025 520 27 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 520 28 , , , www-bis-org-8025 520 29 DRAFT DRAFT NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 30 v1.0 v1.0 NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 31 , , , www-bis-org-8025 520 32 5 5 CD www-bis-org-8025 520 33 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 34 , , , www-bis-org-8025 520 35 Ethereum Ethereum NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 36 Research Research NNP www-bis-org-8025 520 37 . . . www-bis-org-8025 521 1 http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2005/12/bit-gold.html http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2005/12/bit-gold.html NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 2 https://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/pos.pdf https://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/pos.pdf NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 3 https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 4 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 5 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 521 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 521 7 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 8 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 521 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 521 10 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 521 11 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 521 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 521 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 521 14 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 521 15 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 521 16 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 521 17 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 521 18 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 521 19 27 27 CD www-bis-org-8025 521 20 Appendix Appendix NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 21 : : : www-bis-org-8025 521 22 glossary glossary JJ www-bis-org-8025 521 23 Glossary Glossary NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 24 Table Table NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 25 A1 A1 NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 26 Attacker Attacker NNP www-bis-org-8025 521 27 advantage advantage NN www-bis-org-8025 521 28 Advantage advantage NN www-bis-org-8025 521 29 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 521 30 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 521 31 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 521 32 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 521 33 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 521 34 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 521 35 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 36 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 521 37 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 521 38 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 39 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 521 40 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 41 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 521 42 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 521 43 main main JJ www-bis-org-8025 521 44 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 521 45 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 46 deriving derive VBG www-bis-org-8025 521 47 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 521 48 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 521 49 fact fact NN www-bis-org-8025 521 50 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 521 51 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 521 52 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 521 53 profits profit VBZ www-bis-org-8025 521 54 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 521 55 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 521 56 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 521 57 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 521 58 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 521 59 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 60 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 521 61 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 521 62 , , , www-bis-org-8025 521 63 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 521 64 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 521 65 , , , www-bis-org-8025 521 66 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 521 67 double double RB www-bis-org-8025 521 68 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 521 69 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 521 70 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 521 71 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 72 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 521 73 does do VBZ www-bis-org-8025 521 74 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 521 75 honest honest JJ www-bis-org-8025 521 76 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 521 77 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 78 collecting collect VBG www-bis-org-8025 521 79 only only JJ www-bis-org-8025 521 80 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 521 81 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 521 82 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 521 83 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 521 84 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 521 85 . . . www-bis-org-8025 522 1 Attacker Attacker NNP www-bis-org-8025 522 2 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 522 3 Counterforce Counterforce NNP www-bis-org-8025 522 4 advantages advantage NNS www-bis-org-8025 522 5 over over IN www-bis-org-8025 522 6 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 522 7 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 522 8 : : : www-bis-org-8025 522 9 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 522 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 522 11 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 522 12 attackers attacker NNS www-bis-org-8025 522 13 likely likely RB www-bis-org-8025 522 14 have have VBP www-bis-org-8025 522 15 higher high JJR www-bis-org-8025 522 16 costs cost NNS www-bis-org-8025 522 17 than than IN www-bis-org-8025 522 18 regular regular JJ www-bis-org-8025 522 19 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 522 20 do do VBP www-bis-org-8025 522 21 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 522 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 522 23 price price NN www-bis-org-8025 522 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 522 25 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 522 26 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 522 27 collapses collapse NNS www-bis-org-8025 522 28 following follow VBG www-bis-org-8025 522 29 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 522 30 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 522 31 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 522 32 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 522 33 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 522 34 ; ; , www-bis-org-8025 522 35 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 522 36 social social JJ www-bis-org-8025 522 37 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 522 38 might may MD www-bis-org-8025 522 39 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 522 40 such such PDT www-bis-org-8025 522 41 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 522 42 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 522 43 . . . www-bis-org-8025 523 1 Attacker Attacker NNP www-bis-org-8025 523 2 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-bis-org-8025 523 3 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 523 4 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 523 5 equation equation NN www-bis-org-8025 523 6 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 523 7 7 7 CD www-bis-org-8025 523 8 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 523 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 523 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 523 11 main main JJ www-bis-org-8025 523 12 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 523 13 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 523 14 summarises summarise VBZ www-bis-org-8025 523 15 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 523 16 three three CD www-bis-org-8025 523 17 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 523 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 524 1 Block Block NNP www-bis-org-8025 524 2 reward reward NN www-bis-org-8025 524 3 Newly newly RB www-bis-org-8025 524 4 minted mint VBD www-bis-org-8025 524 5 bitcoins bitcoin NNS www-bis-org-8025 524 6 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 524 7 increase increase VBP www-bis-org-8025 524 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 524 9 outstanding outstanding JJ www-bis-org-8025 524 10 supply supply NN www-bis-org-8025 524 11 whenever whenever WRB www-bis-org-8025 524 12 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 524 13 new new JJ www-bis-org-8025 524 14 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 524 15 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 524 16 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 524 17 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 524 18 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 524 19 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 524 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 525 1 Confirmation confirmation NN www-bis-org-8025 525 2 Each each DT www-bis-org-8025 525 3 additional additional JJ www-bis-org-8025 525 4 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 525 5 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 525 6 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 525 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 525 8 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 525 9 after after IN www-bis-org-8025 525 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 525 11 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 525 12 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 525 13 contains contain VBZ www-bis-org-8025 525 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 525 15 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 525 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 525 17 question question NN www-bis-org-8025 525 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 526 1 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 526 2 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 526 3 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 526 4 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 526 5 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 526 6 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 526 7 block block NNP www-bis-org-8025 526 8 b b NNP www-bis-org-8025 526 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 526 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 526 11 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 526 12 currently currently RB www-bis-org-8025 526 13 includes include VBZ www-bis-org-8025 526 14 b+2 b+2 NNP www-bis-org-8025 526 15 blocks blocks NNP www-bis-org-8025 526 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 526 17 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 526 18 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 526 19 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 526 20 said say VBN www-bis-org-8025 526 21 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 526 22 have have VB www-bis-org-8025 526 23 three three CD www-bis-org-8025 526 24 confirmations confirmation NNS www-bis-org-8025 526 25 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 526 26 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 526 27 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 526 28 waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 526 29 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 526 30 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 526 31 . . . www-bis-org-8025 527 1 Consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 527 2 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 527 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 4 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 527 5 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 527 6 Economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 527 7 consensus consensus NN www-bis-org-8025 527 8 algorithm algorithm NN www-bis-org-8025 527 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 527 10 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 527 11 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 527 12 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 527 13 based base VBN www-bis-org-8025 527 14 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 527 15 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 527 16 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 527 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 527 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 527 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 527 20 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 527 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 527 22 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 527 23 If if IN www-bis-org-8025 527 24 conflicting conflicting JJ www-bis-org-8025 527 25 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 527 26 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 527 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 28 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 527 29 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 527 30 ever ever RB www-bis-org-8025 527 31 observed observe VBN www-bis-org-8025 527 32 , , , www-bis-org-8025 527 33 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 34 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 527 35 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 527 36 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 527 37 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 38 most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 527 39 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 527 40 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 527 41 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 527 42 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 527 43 often often RB www-bis-org-8025 527 44 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 45 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 527 46 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 527 47 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 48 most most JJS www-bis-org-8025 527 49 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 527 50 , , , www-bis-org-8025 527 51 ie ie IN www-bis-org-8025 527 52 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 53 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 527 54 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 527 55 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 527 56 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 527 57 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 58 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 527 59 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 527 60 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 527 61 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 527 62 coordinates coordinate VBZ www-bis-org-8025 527 63 on on RP www-bis-org-8025 527 64 . . . www-bis-org-8025 528 1 Crypto crypto NN www-bis-org-8025 528 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 528 3 asset asset NN www-bis-org-8025 528 4 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 528 5 type type NN www-bis-org-8025 528 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 528 7 private private JJ www-bis-org-8025 528 8 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 528 9 asset asset NN www-bis-org-8025 528 10 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 528 11 depends depend VBZ www-bis-org-8025 528 12 primarily primarily RB www-bis-org-8025 528 13 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 528 14 cryptography cryptography NN www-bis-org-8025 528 15 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 528 16 distributed distribute VBN www-bis-org-8025 528 17 ledger ledger JJ www-bis-org-8025 528 18 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 528 19 similar similar JJ www-bis-org-8025 528 20 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 528 21 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 528 22 part part NN www-bis-org-8025 528 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 528 24 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 528 25 perceived perceive VBN www-bis-org-8025 528 26 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 528 27 inherent inherent JJ www-bis-org-8025 528 28 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 528 29 . . . www-bis-org-8025 529 1 Cryptocurrency Cryptocurrency NNP www-bis-org-8025 529 2 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 529 3 crypto crypto NN www-bis-org-8025 529 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 529 5 asset asset NN www-bis-org-8025 529 6 used use VBD www-bis-org-8025 529 7 exclusively exclusively RB www-bis-org-8025 529 8 / / , www-bis-org-8025 529 9 primarily primarily RB www-bis-org-8025 529 10 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 529 11 payments payment NNS www-bis-org-8025 529 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 530 1 Cryptographic cryptographic JJ www-bis-org-8025 530 2 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 530 3 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 530 4 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 530 5 public public JJ www-bis-org-8025 530 6 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 530 7 private private JJ www-bis-org-8025 530 8 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 530 9 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 530 10 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 530 11 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 530 12 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 530 13 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 530 14 verify verify VB www-bis-org-8025 530 15 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 530 16 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 530 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 531 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 531 2 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 531 3 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 531 4 verifiably verifiably RB www-bis-org-8025 531 5 proves prove VBZ www-bis-org-8025 531 6 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 531 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 531 8 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 531 9 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 531 10 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 531 11 authorised authorise VBN www-bis-org-8025 531 12 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 531 13 whoever whoever WP www-bis-org-8025 531 14 controls control VBZ www-bis-org-8025 531 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 531 16 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 531 17 units unit NNS www-bis-org-8025 531 18 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 531 19 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 531 20 being be VBG www-bis-org-8025 531 21 spent spend VBN www-bis-org-8025 531 22 . . . www-bis-org-8025 532 1 Difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 532 2 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 532 3 expected expected JJ www-bis-org-8025 532 4 number number NN www-bis-org-8025 532 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 532 6 hashes hash NNS www-bis-org-8025 532 7 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 532 8 needs need VBZ www-bis-org-8025 532 9 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 532 10 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 532 11 performed perform VBN www-bis-org-8025 532 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 532 13 obtain obtain VB www-bis-org-8025 532 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 532 15 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 532 16 result result NN www-bis-org-8025 532 17 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 532 18 find find VB www-bis-org-8025 532 19 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 532 20 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 532 21 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 532 22 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 532 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 532 24 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 532 25 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 532 26 . . . www-bis-org-8025 533 1 Double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 533 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 533 3 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 533 4 Strategy Strategy NNP www-bis-org-8025 533 5 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 533 6 consist consist VBP www-bis-org-8025 533 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 533 8 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 533 9 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 533 10 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 533 11 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 533 12 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 533 13 later later RB www-bis-org-8025 533 14 undoing undo VBG www-bis-org-8025 533 15 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 533 16 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 533 17 releasing release VBG www-bis-org-8025 533 18 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 533 19 forged forge VBN www-bis-org-8025 533 20 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 533 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 533 22 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 533 23 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 533 24 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 533 25 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 533 26 erased erase VBN www-bis-org-8025 533 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 534 1 Requires require VBZ www-bis-org-8025 534 2 access access NN www-bis-org-8025 534 3 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 534 4 enough enough JJ www-bis-org-8025 534 5 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 534 6 power power NN www-bis-org-8025 534 7 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 534 8 overwhelm overwhelm VB www-bis-org-8025 534 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 534 10 rest rest NN www-bis-org-8025 534 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 534 12 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 534 13 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 534 14 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 534 15 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 534 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 534 17 miners miner NNS www-bis-org-8025 534 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 535 1 Economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 535 2 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 535 3 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 535 4 Definition definition NN www-bis-org-8025 535 5 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 535 6 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 535 7 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 535 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 535 9 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 535 10 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 535 11 developed develop VBN www-bis-org-8025 535 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 535 13 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 535 14 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 535 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 536 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 536 2 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 536 3 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 536 4 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 536 5 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 536 6 considered consider VBN www-bis-org-8025 536 7 as as RB www-bis-org-8025 536 8 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 536 9 once once IN www-bis-org-8025 536 10 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 536 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 536 12 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 536 13 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 536 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 536 15 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 536 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 536 17 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 536 18 moment moment NN www-bis-org-8025 536 19 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 536 20 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 536 21 onwards onwards RB www-bis-org-8025 536 22 , , , www-bis-org-8025 536 23 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 536 24 will will MD www-bis-org-8025 536 25 never never RB www-bis-org-8025 536 26 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 536 27 profitable profitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 536 28 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 536 29 undo undo VB www-bis-org-8025 536 30 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 536 31 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 536 32 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 536 33 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 536 34 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 536 35 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 536 36 spending spending NN www-bis-org-8025 536 37 attack attack NN www-bis-org-8025 536 38 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 536 39 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 536 40 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 536 41 Table table NN www-bis-org-8025 536 42 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 536 43 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 536 44 . . . www-bis-org-8025 537 1 Follow follow VB www-bis-org-8025 537 2 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 537 3 longest long JJS www-bis-org-8025 537 4 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 537 5 Rule Rule NNP www-bis-org-8025 537 6 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 537 7 establishes establish VBZ www-bis-org-8025 537 8 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 537 9 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 537 10 competing compete VBG www-bis-org-8025 537 11 versions version NNS www-bis-org-8025 537 12 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 537 13 observed observe VBN www-bis-org-8025 537 14 , , , www-bis-org-8025 537 15 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 537 16 one one NN www-bis-org-8025 537 17 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 537 18 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 537 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 537 20 most most RBS www-bis-org-8025 537 21 expensive expensive JJ www-bis-org-8025 537 22 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 537 23 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 537 24 continues continue VBZ www-bis-org-8025 537 25 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 537 26 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 537 27 used use VBN www-bis-org-8025 537 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 538 1 This this DT www-bis-org-8025 538 2 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 538 3 generally generally RB www-bis-org-8025 538 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 538 5 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 538 6 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 538 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 538 8 most most JJS www-bis-org-8025 538 9 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 538 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 539 1 Hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 539 2 function function NN www-bis-org-8025 539 3 Function Function NNP www-bis-org-8025 539 4 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 539 5 takes take VBZ www-bis-org-8025 539 6 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 539 7 random random JJ www-bis-org-8025 539 8 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 539 9 input input NN www-bis-org-8025 539 10 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 539 11 produces produce VBZ www-bis-org-8025 539 12 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 539 13 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 539 14 an an DT www-bis-org-8025 539 15 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 539 16 according accord VBG www-bis-org-8025 539 17 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 539 18 set set NN www-bis-org-8025 539 19 rules rule NNS www-bis-org-8025 539 20 . . . www-bis-org-8025 540 1 Lightning Lightning NNP www-bis-org-8025 540 2 Network Network NNP www-bis-org-8025 540 3 Second Second NNP www-bis-org-8025 540 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 540 5 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 540 6 solution solution NN www-bis-org-8025 540 7 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 540 8 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 540 9 two two CD www-bis-org-8025 540 10 parties party NNS www-bis-org-8025 540 11 A a NN www-bis-org-8025 540 12 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 540 13 B b NN www-bis-org-8025 540 14 jointly jointly RB www-bis-org-8025 540 15 lock lock VB www-bis-org-8025 540 16 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 540 17 one one CD www-bis-org-8025 540 18 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-bis-org-8025 540 19 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 540 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 540 21 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 540 22 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 540 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 540 24 joint joint JJ www-bis-org-8025 540 25 digital digital JJ www-bis-org-8025 540 26 signature signature NN www-bis-org-8025 540 27 . . . www-bis-org-8025 541 1 Miner Miner NNP www-bis-org-8025 541 2 Class Class NNP www-bis-org-8025 541 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 541 4 agents agent NNS www-bis-org-8025 541 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 541 6 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 541 7 update update VBP www-bis-org-8025 541 8 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 541 9 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 541 10 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 541 11 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 541 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 541 13 , , , www-bis-org-8025 541 14 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 541 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 541 16 return return NN www-bis-org-8025 541 17 receive receive JJ www-bis-org-8025 541 18 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 541 19 rewards reward NNS www-bis-org-8025 541 20 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 541 21 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 541 22 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 541 23 when when WRB www-bis-org-8025 541 24 they -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 541 25 add add VBP www-bis-org-8025 541 26 batches batch NNS www-bis-org-8025 541 27 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 541 28 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 541 29 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 541 30 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 541 31 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 541 32 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 541 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 542 1 Proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 542 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 542 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 542 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 542 5 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 542 6 Mathematical mathematical JJ www-bis-org-8025 542 7 evidence evidence NN www-bis-org-8025 542 8 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 542 9 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 542 10 certain certain JJ www-bis-org-8025 542 11 amount amount NN www-bis-org-8025 542 12 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 542 13 computational computational JJ www-bis-org-8025 542 14 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 542 15 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 542 16 been be VBN www-bis-org-8025 542 17 done do VBN www-bis-org-8025 542 18 , , , www-bis-org-8025 542 19 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 542 20 turn turn NN www-bis-org-8025 542 21 calling call VBG www-bis-org-8025 542 22 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 542 23 costly costly JJ www-bis-org-8025 542 24 equipment equipment NN www-bis-org-8025 542 25 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 542 26 electricity electricity NN www-bis-org-8025 542 27 use use NN www-bis-org-8025 542 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 543 1 Proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 543 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 543 3 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 543 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 543 5 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 543 6 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 543 7 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 543 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 543 9 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 543 10 coordination coordination NN www-bis-org-8025 543 11 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 543 12 blockchain blockchain NNP www-bis-org-8025 543 13 updates update NNS www-bis-org-8025 543 14 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 543 15 enforced enforce VBN www-bis-org-8025 543 16 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 543 17 ensuring ensure VBG www-bis-org-8025 543 18 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 543 19 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 543 20 verifiers verifier NNS www-bis-org-8025 543 21 pledge pledge VBP www-bis-org-8025 543 22 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 543 23 coin coin NN www-bis-org-8025 543 24 holdings holding NNS www-bis-org-8025 543 25 as as IN www-bis-org-8025 543 26 guarantees guarantee NNS www-bis-org-8025 543 27 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 543 28 their -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 543 29 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 543 30 confirmations confirmation NNS www-bis-org-8025 543 31 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 543 32 accurate accurate JJ www-bis-org-8025 543 33 . . . www-bis-org-8025 544 1 Protocol Protocol NNP www-bis-org-8025 544 2 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 544 3 coded code VBN www-bis-org-8025 544 4 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 544 5 laws law NNS www-bis-org-8025 544 6 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 544 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 544 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 544 9 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-bis-org-8025 544 10 . . . www-bis-org-8025 545 1 Set set NN www-bis-org-8025 545 2 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 545 3 rules rule NNS www-bis-org-8025 545 4 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 545 5 governs govern VBZ www-bis-org-8025 545 6 what what WP www-bis-org-8025 545 7 constitutes constitute VBZ www-bis-org-8025 545 8 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 545 9 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 545 10 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 545 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 545 12 accepted accept VBN www-bis-org-8025 545 13 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 545 14 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 545 15 network network NN www-bis-org-8025 545 16 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 545 17 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 545 18 . . . www-bis-org-8025 546 1 Second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 546 2 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 546 3 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 546 4 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 546 5 technology technology NN www-bis-org-8025 546 6 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 546 7 aims aim VBZ www-bis-org-8025 546 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 546 9 improve improve VB www-bis-org-8025 546 10 upon upon IN www-bis-org-8025 546 11 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 546 12 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 546 13 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 546 14 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 546 15 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 546 16 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 546 17 adding add VBG www-bis-org-8025 546 18 liquid liquid JJ www-bis-org-8025 546 19 methods method NNS www-bis-org-8025 546 20 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 546 21 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 546 22 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 546 23 top top NN www-bis-org-8025 546 24 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 546 25 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 546 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 546 27 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 546 28 . . . www-bis-org-8025 547 1 28 28 CD www-bis-org-8025 547 2 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 547 3 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 547 4 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 547 5 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 547 6 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 547 7 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 547 8 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 547 9 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 547 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 547 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 547 12 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 547 13 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 547 14 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 547 15 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 547 16 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 547 17 Target Target NNP www-bis-org-8025 547 18 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 547 19 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 547 20 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 547 21 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 547 22 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 547 23 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 547 24 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 547 25 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 547 26 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 547 27 if if IN www-bis-org-8025 547 28 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 547 29 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 547 30 solves solve VBZ www-bis-org-8025 547 31 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 547 32 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 547 33 hash hash NN www-bis-org-8025 547 34 output output NN www-bis-org-8025 547 35 below below IN www-bis-org-8025 547 36 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 547 37 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 547 38 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 547 39 . . . www-bis-org-8025 548 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 548 2 lower low JJR www-bis-org-8025 548 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 548 4 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 548 5 value value NN www-bis-org-8025 548 6 , , , www-bis-org-8025 548 7 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 548 8 more more RBR www-bis-org-8025 548 9 difficult difficult JJ www-bis-org-8025 548 10 it -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 548 11 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 548 12 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 548 13 find find VB www-bis-org-8025 548 14 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 548 15 valid valid JJ www-bis-org-8025 548 16 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 548 17 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 548 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 548 19 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 548 20 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 548 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 549 1 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 549 2 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 549 3 also also RB www-bis-org-8025 549 4 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 549 5 , , , www-bis-org-8025 549 6 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 549 7 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 549 8 proportional proportional JJ www-bis-org-8025 549 9 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 549 10 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 549 11 / / SYM www-bis-org-8025 549 12 target target NN www-bis-org-8025 549 13 . . . www-bis-org-8025 549 14 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 550 1 Tragedy Tragedy NNP www-bis-org-8025 550 2 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 550 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 550 4 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 550 5 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 550 6 Concept Concept NNP www-bis-org-8025 550 7 developed develop VBD www-bis-org-8025 550 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 550 9 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 550 10 paper paper NN www-bis-org-8025 550 11 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 550 12 users user NNS www-bis-org-8025 550 13 free free JJ www-bis-org-8025 550 14 ride ride NN www-bis-org-8025 550 15 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 550 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 550 17 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 550 18 provided provide VBN www-bis-org-8025 550 19 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 550 20 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 550 21 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 550 22 fees fee NNS www-bis-org-8025 550 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 550 24 other other JJ www-bis-org-8025 550 25 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 550 26 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 550 27 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 550 28 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 550 29 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 550 30 see see VB www-bis-org-8025 550 31 equations equation NNS www-bis-org-8025 550 32 9–11 9–11 CD www-bis-org-8025 550 33 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 550 34 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 550 35 main main JJ www-bis-org-8025 550 36 text text NN www-bis-org-8025 550 37 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 550 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 551 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 551 2 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 551 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 551 4 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 551 5 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 551 6 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 551 7 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 551 8 hence hence RB www-bis-org-8025 551 9 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 551 10 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 551 11 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 551 12 security security NN www-bis-org-8025 551 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 551 14 determined determine VBN www-bis-org-8025 551 15 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 551 16 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 551 17 level level NN www-bis-org-8025 551 18 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 551 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 551 20 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 551 21 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 551 22 which which WDT www-bis-org-8025 551 23 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 551 24 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 551 25 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 551 26 included include VBN www-bis-org-8025 551 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 551 28 whereas whereas IN www-bis-org-8025 551 29 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 551 30 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 551 31 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 551 32 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 551 33 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 551 34 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 551 35 each each DT www-bis-org-8025 551 36 user user NN www-bis-org-8025 551 37 privately privately RB www-bis-org-8025 551 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 552 1 Transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 552 2 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 552 3 Fee Fee NNP www-bis-org-8025 552 4 set set VBN www-bis-org-8025 552 5 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 552 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 552 7 paying pay VBG www-bis-org-8025 552 8 party party NN www-bis-org-8025 552 9 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 552 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 552 11 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 552 12 . . . www-bis-org-8025 553 1 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 553 2 fee fee NN www-bis-org-8025 553 3 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 553 4 paid pay VBN www-bis-org-8025 553 5 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 553 6 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 553 7 miner miner NN www-bis-org-8025 553 8 who who WP www-bis-org-8025 553 9 includes include VBZ www-bis-org-8025 553 10 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 553 11 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 553 12 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 553 13 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 553 14 block block NN www-bis-org-8025 553 15 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 553 16 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 553 17 added add VBN www-bis-org-8025 553 18 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 553 19 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 553 20 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 553 21 . . . www-bis-org-8025 554 1 Waiting wait VBG www-bis-org-8025 554 2 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 554 3 One one CD www-bis-org-8025 554 4 plus plus CC www-bis-org-8025 554 5 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 554 6 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 554 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 554 8 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 554 9 blocks block NNS www-bis-org-8025 554 10 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 554 11 that that IN www-bis-org-8025 554 12 merchants merchant NNS www-bis-org-8025 554 13 wait wait VBP www-bis-org-8025 554 14 before before IN www-bis-org-8025 554 15 assuming assume VBG www-bis-org-8025 554 16 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 554 17 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 554 18 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 554 19 final final JJ www-bis-org-8025 554 20 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 554 21 releasing release VBG www-bis-org-8025 554 22 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 554 23 merchandise merchandise NN www-bis-org-8025 554 24 . . . www-bis-org-8025 555 1 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 555 2 double double JJ www-bis-org-8025 555 3 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 555 4 spending spend VBG www-bis-org-8025 555 5 attacker attacker NN www-bis-org-8025 555 6 thus thus RB www-bis-org-8025 555 7 has have VBZ www-bis-org-8025 555 8 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 555 9 forge forge VB www-bis-org-8025 555 10 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 555 11 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 555 12 that that WDT www-bis-org-8025 555 13 is be VBZ www-bis-org-8025 555 14 at at IN www-bis-org-8025 555 15 least least JJS www-bis-org-8025 555 16 equal equal JJ www-bis-org-8025 555 17 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 555 18 length length NN www-bis-org-8025 555 19 to to IN www-bis-org-8025 555 20 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 555 21 waiting waiting NN www-bis-org-8025 555 22 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 555 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 556 1 Sources source NNS www-bis-org-8025 556 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 556 3 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 556 4 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 556 5 International International NNP www-bis-org-8025 556 6 Settlements Settlements NNP www-bis-org-8025 556 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 556 8 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 556 9 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 556 10 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 556 11 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 556 12 Stability Stability NNP www-bis-org-8025 556 13 Board Board NNP www-bis-org-8025 556 14 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 556 15 2018a 2018a CD www-bis-org-8025 556 16 , , , www-bis-org-8025 556 17 b b NN www-bis-org-8025 556 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 556 19 ; ; : www-bis-org-8025 556 20 author author NN www-bis-org-8025 556 21 ’s ’s POS www-bis-org-8025 556 22 elaboration elaboration NN www-bis-org-8025 556 23 . . . www-bis-org-8025 557 1 WP765 WP765 NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 557 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 557 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 557 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 557 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 557 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 557 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 557 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 557 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 557 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 557 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 557 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 16 29 29 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 17 Previous previous JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 18 volumes volume NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 19 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 557 20 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 557 21 series series NN www-bis-org-8025 557 22 764 764 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 23 January January NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 24 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 25 Global Global NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 26 Banking Banking NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 27 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 28 Financial Financial NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 29 Spillovers Spillovers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 557 30 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 31 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 32 Macroprudential Macroprudential NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 33 Policy Policy NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 34 Coordination Coordination NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 35 Pierre Pierre NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 36 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 557 37 Richard Richard NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 38 Agénor Agénor NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 39 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 40 Luiz Luiz NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 41 A. A. NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 42 Pereira Pereira NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 43 da da NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 44 Silva Silva NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 45 763 763 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 46 January January NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 47 2019 2019 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 48 On on IN www-bis-org-8025 557 49 money money NN www-bis-org-8025 557 50 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 51 debt debt NN www-bis-org-8025 557 52 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 53 trust trust NN www-bis-org-8025 557 54 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 55 central central JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 56 banking banking NN www-bis-org-8025 557 57 Claudio Claudio NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 58 Borio Borio NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 59 762 762 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 60 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 61 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 62 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 557 63 key key JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 64 currency currency NN www-bis-org-8025 557 65 view view NN www-bis-org-8025 557 66 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 557 67 global global JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 68 imbalances imbalance NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 69 Hiro Hiro NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 70 Ito Ito NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 71 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 72 Robert Robert NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 73 N N NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 74 McCauley McCauley NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 75 761 761 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 76 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 77 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 78 Non Non NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 79 - - NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 80 Monetary Monetary NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 81 News News NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 82 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 557 83 Central Central NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 84 Bank Bank NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 85 Communication Communication NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 86 Anna Anna NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 87 Cieslak Cieslak NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 88 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 89 Andreas Andreas NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 90 Schrimpf Schrimpf NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 91 760 760 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 92 December December NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 93 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 94 Gross Gross NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 95 Capital Capital NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 96 Flows flow NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 97 by by IN www-bis-org-8025 557 98 Banks Banks NNPS www-bis-org-8025 557 99 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 100 Corporates Corporates NNPS www-bis-org-8025 557 101 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 102 Sovereigns Sovereigns NNPS www-bis-org-8025 557 103 Stefan Stefan NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 104 Avdjiev Avdjiev NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 105 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 106 Bryan Bryan NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 107 Hardy Hardy NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 108 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 109 Şebnem Şebnem NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 110 Kalemli Kalemli NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 111 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 557 112 Özcan Özcan NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 113 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 114 Luis Luis NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 115 Servén Servén NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 116 759 759 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 117 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 118 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 119 Assessing assess VBG www-bis-org-8025 557 120 inflation inflation NN www-bis-org-8025 557 121 expectations expectation NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 122 anchoring anchor VBG www-bis-org-8025 557 123 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 557 124 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 125 agents agent NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 126 : : : www-bis-org-8025 557 127 analysts analyst NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 128 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 129 businesses business NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 130 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 131 trade trade NN www-bis-org-8025 557 132 unions union NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 133 Ken Ken NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 134 Miyajima Miyajima NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 135 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 136 James James NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 137 Yetman Yetman NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 138 758 758 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 139 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 140 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 141 Foreign foreign JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 142 currency currency NN www-bis-org-8025 557 143 borrowing borrowing NN www-bis-org-8025 557 144 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 145 balance balance NN www-bis-org-8025 557 146 sheet sheet NN www-bis-org-8025 557 147 shocks shock NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 148 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 149 real real JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 150 outcomes outcome NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 151 Bryan Bryan NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 152 Hardy Hardy NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 153 757 757 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 154 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 155 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 156 Explaining explain VBG www-bis-org-8025 557 157 Monetary Monetary NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 158 Spillovers Spillovers NNPS www-bis-org-8025 557 159 : : : www-bis-org-8025 557 160 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 557 161 Matrix matrix NN www-bis-org-8025 557 162 Reloaded Reloaded NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 163 Jonathan Jonathan NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 164 Kearns Kearns NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 165 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 166 Andreas Andreas NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 167 Schrimpf Schrimpf NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 168 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 169 Fan Fan NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 170 Dora Dora NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 171 Xia Xia NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 172 756 756 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 173 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 174 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 175 Financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 176 structure structure NN www-bis-org-8025 557 177 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 178 income income NN www-bis-org-8025 557 179 inequality inequality NN www-bis-org-8025 557 180 Michael Michael NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 181 Brei Brei NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 182 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 183 Giovanni Giovanni NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 184 Ferri Ferri NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 185 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 186 Leonardo Leonardo NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 187 Gambacorta Gambacorta NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 188 755 755 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 189 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 190 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 191 Measuring measure VBG www-bis-org-8025 557 192 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 193 cycle cycle NN www-bis-org-8025 557 194 time time NN www-bis-org-8025 557 195 Andrew Andrew NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 196 Filardo Filardo NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 197 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 198 Marco Marco NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 199 Lombardi Lombardi NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 200 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 201 Marek Marek NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 202 Raczko Raczko NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 203 754 754 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 204 November November NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 205 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 206 Euro Euro NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 207 area area NN www-bis-org-8025 557 208 unconventional unconventional JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 209 monetary monetary JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 210 policy policy NN www-bis-org-8025 557 211 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 212 bank bank NN www-bis-org-8025 557 213 resilience resilience NN www-bis-org-8025 557 214 Fernando Fernando NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 215 Avalos Avalos NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 216 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 217 Emmanuel Emmanuel NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 218 C C NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 219 Mamatzakis Mamatzakis NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 220 753 753 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 221 October October NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 222 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 223 Currency Currency NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 224 depreciation depreciation NN www-bis-org-8025 557 225 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 226 emerging emerge VBG www-bis-org-8025 557 227 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 557 228 corporate corporate JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 229 distress distress NN www-bis-org-8025 557 230 Valentina Valentina NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 231 Bruno Bruno NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 232 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 233 Hyun Hyun NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 234 Song Song NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 235 Shin Shin NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 236 752 752 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 237 October October NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 238 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 239 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 557 240 effects effect NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 241 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 557 242 prudential prudential JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 243 regulation regulation NN www-bis-org-8025 557 244 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 245 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 246 development development NN www-bis-org-8025 557 247 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 248 financial financial JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 249 openness openness NN www-bis-org-8025 557 250 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 557 251 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 252 growth growth NN www-bis-org-8025 557 253 Pierre Pierre NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 254 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 557 255 Richard Richard NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 256 Agénor Agénor NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 257 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 258 Leonardo Leonardo NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 259 Gambacorta Gambacorta NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 260 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 261 Enisse Enisse NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 262 Kharroubi Kharroubi NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 263 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 264 Luiz Luiz NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 265 Awazu Awazu NNPS www-bis-org-8025 557 266 Pereira Pereira NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 267 da da NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 268 Silva Silva NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 269 751 751 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 270 October October NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 271 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 272 Exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 557 273 rates rate NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 274 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 275 prices price NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 276 : : : www-bis-org-8025 557 277 evidence evidence NN www-bis-org-8025 557 278 from from IN www-bis-org-8025 557 279 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 557 280 2015 2015 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 281 Swiss swiss JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 282 franc franc NN www-bis-org-8025 557 283 appreciation appreciation NN www-bis-org-8025 557 284 Raphael Raphael NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 285 Auer Auer NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 286 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 287 Ariel Ariel NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 288 Burstein Burstein NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 289 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 290 Sarah Sarah NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 291 M M NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 292 Lein Lein NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 293 750 750 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 294 October October NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 295 2018 2018 CD www-bis-org-8025 557 296 Forward forward RB www-bis-org-8025 557 297 guidance guidance NN www-bis-org-8025 557 298 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 299 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 300 beliefs belief NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 301 Philippe Philippe NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 302 Andrade Andrade NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 303 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 304 Gaetano Gaetano NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 305 Gaballo Gaballo NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 306 , , , www-bis-org-8025 557 307 Eric Eric NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 308 Mengus Mengus NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 309 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 557 310 Benoit Benoit NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 311 Mojon Mojon NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 312 All all DT www-bis-org-8025 557 313 volumes volume NNS www-bis-org-8025 557 314 are be VBP www-bis-org-8025 557 315 available available JJ www-bis-org-8025 557 316 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 557 317 our -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 557 318 website website NN www-bis-org-8025 557 319 www.bis.org www.bis.org NNP www-bis-org-8025 557 320 . . . www-bis-org-8025 558 1 http://www.bis.org/ http://www.bis.org/ NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 2 Beyond beyond IN www-bis-org-8025 558 3 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 4 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 5 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 7 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 558 8 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 558 9 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 10 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 11 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 12 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 558 13 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 558 14 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 558 15 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 16 Abstract Abstract NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 17 Introduction Introduction NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 18 Technology Technology NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 19 basics basic NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 20 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 558 21 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 22 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 23 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 24 mining mine VBG www-bis-org-8025 558 25 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 558 26 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 558 27 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 558 28 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 558 29 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 30 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 558 31 its -PRON- PRP$ www-bis-org-8025 558 32 blockchain blockchain NN www-bis-org-8025 558 33 : : : www-bis-org-8025 558 34 system system NN www-bis-org-8025 558 35 overview overview NN www-bis-org-8025 558 36 Proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 558 37 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 38 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 39 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 40 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 558 41 : : : www-bis-org-8025 558 42 rolling roll VBG www-bis-org-8025 558 43 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 558 44 dice dice NN www-bis-org-8025 558 45 Mining Mining NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 46 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 47 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 558 48 equilibrium equilibrium NN www-bis-org-8025 558 49 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 558 50 difficulty difficulty NN www-bis-org-8025 558 51 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 558 52 Attacker Attacker NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 53 advantage advantage NN www-bis-org-8025 558 54 : : : www-bis-org-8025 558 55 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 56 high high JJ www-bis-org-8025 558 57 cost cost NN www-bis-org-8025 558 58 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 59 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 558 60 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 558 61 via via IN www-bis-org-8025 558 62 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 558 63 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 64 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 65 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 66 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 558 67 An an DT www-bis-org-8025 558 68 economic economic JJ www-bis-org-8025 558 69 definition definition NN www-bis-org-8025 558 70 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 71 payment payment NN www-bis-org-8025 558 72 finality finality NN www-bis-org-8025 558 73 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 74 “ " `` www-bis-org-8025 558 75 tragedy tragedy NN www-bis-org-8025 558 76 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 77 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 78 common common JJ www-bis-org-8025 558 79 chain chain NN www-bis-org-8025 558 80 ” " '' www-bis-org-8025 558 81 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 558 82 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 83 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 558 84 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 558 85 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 86 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 87 basics basic NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 88 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 89 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 90 transaction transaction NN www-bis-org-8025 558 91 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 558 92 A a DT www-bis-org-8025 558 93 simple simple JJ www-bis-org-8025 558 94 model model NN www-bis-org-8025 558 95 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 96 free free RB www-bis-org-8025 558 97 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 98 riding riding NN www-bis-org-8025 558 99 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 558 100 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 101 market market NN www-bis-org-8025 558 102 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 558 103 transactions transaction NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 104 Some some DT www-bis-org-8025 558 105 considerations consideration NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 106 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 558 107 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 108 road road NN www-bis-org-8025 558 109 ahead ahead RB www-bis-org-8025 558 110 The the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 111 doomsday doomsday NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 112 economics economic NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 113 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 114 proof proof NN www-bis-org-8025 558 115 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 116 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 117 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 118 work work NN www-bis-org-8025 558 119 Second second JJ www-bis-org-8025 558 120 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 121 layer layer NN www-bis-org-8025 558 122 solutions solution NNS www-bis-org-8025 558 123 Proof Proof NNP www-bis-org-8025 558 124 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 125 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 558 126 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 558 127 stake stake NN www-bis-org-8025 558 128 : : : www-bis-org-8025 558 129 gambling gamble VBG www-bis-org-8025 558 130 on on IN www-bis-org-8025 558 131 or or CC www-bis-org-8025 558 132 institutionalising institutionalise VBG www-bis-org-8025 558 133 the the DT www-bis-org-8025 558 134 truth truth NN www-bis-org-8025 558 135 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 559 1 Conclusion conclusion NN www-bis-org-8025 559 2 : : : www-bis-org-8025 559 3 towards towards IN www-bis-org-8025 559 4 a a DT www-bis-org-8025 559 5 world world NN www-bis-org-8025 559 6 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 559 7 semi semi JJ www-bis-org-8025 559 8 - - JJ www-bis-org-8025 559 9 decentralised decentralised JJ www-bis-org-8025 559 10 exchange exchange NN www-bis-org-8025 559 11 ? ? . www-bis-org-8025 560 1 References References NNPS www-bis-org-8025 560 2 Appendix Appendix NNP www-bis-org-8025 560 3 : : : www-bis-org-8025 560 4 glossary glossary JJ www-bis-org-8025 560 5 Previous previous JJ www-bis-org-8025 560 6 volumes volume NNS www-bis-org-8025 560 7 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 560 8 this this DT www-bis-org-8025 560 9 series series NN www-bis-org-8025 560 10 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 560 11 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 560 12 /ASCII85EncodePages /ASCII85EncodePages , www-bis-org-8025 560 13 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 560 14 /AllowTransparency /allowtransparency NN www-bis-org-8025 560 15 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 560 16 /AutoPositionEPSFiles /AutoPositionEPSFiles . www-bis-org-8025 560 17 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 560 18 /AutoRotatePages /autorotatepage NNS www-bis-org-8025 560 19 /PageByPage /PageByPage NFP www-bis-org-8025 560 20 /Binding /Binding . www-bis-org-8025 560 21 /Left /Left . www-bis-org-8025 560 22 /CalGrayProfile /CalGrayProfile . www-bis-org-8025 560 23 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 560 24 Gray Gray NNP www-bis-org-8025 560 25 Gamma Gamma NNP www-bis-org-8025 560 26 2.2 2.2 CD www-bis-org-8025 560 27 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 560 28 /CalRGBProfile /CalRGBProfile . www-bis-org-8025 560 29 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 560 30 sRGB srgb NN www-bis-org-8025 560 31 IEC61966 IEC61966 NNP www-bis-org-8025 560 32 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 560 33 2.1 2.1 CD www-bis-org-8025 560 34 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 560 35 /CalCMYKProfile /CalCMYKProfile . www-bis-org-8025 560 36 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 560 37 U.S. U.S. NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 1 Web web NN www-bis-org-8025 561 2 Coated Coated NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 3 \050SWOP\051 \050SWOP\051 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 4 v2 v2 NN www-bis-org-8025 561 5 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 6 /sRGBProfile /sRGBProfile . www-bis-org-8025 561 7 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 8 sRGB srgb NN www-bis-org-8025 561 9 IEC61966 IEC61966 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 10 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 561 11 2.1 2.1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 12 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 13 /CannotEmbedFontPolicy /CannotEmbedFontPolicy . www-bis-org-8025 561 14 /Warning /Warning NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 15 /CompatibilityLevel /CompatibilityLevel NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 16 1.6 1.6 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 17 /CompressObjects /compressobjects CD www-bis-org-8025 561 18 /Tags /Tags . www-bis-org-8025 561 19 /CompressPages /CompressPages , www-bis-org-8025 561 20 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 21 /ConvertImagesToIndexed /ConvertImagesToIndexed . www-bis-org-8025 561 22 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 23 /PassThroughJPEGImages /PassThroughJPEGImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 24 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 25 /CreateJobTicket /createjobticket NN www-bis-org-8025 561 26 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 27 /DefaultRenderingIntent /DefaultRenderingIntent NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 28 /Default /Default . www-bis-org-8025 561 29 /DetectBlends /DetectBlends NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 30 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 31 /DetectCurves /DetectCurves . www-bis-org-8025 561 32 0.1000 0.1000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 33 /ColorConversionStrategy /ColorConversionStrategy . www-bis-org-8025 561 34 /LeaveColorUnchanged /LeaveColorUnchanged . www-bis-org-8025 561 35 /DoThumbnails /DoThumbnails NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 36 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 37 /EmbedAllFonts /embedallfont NNS www-bis-org-8025 561 38 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 39 /EmbedOpenType /EmbedOpenType . www-bis-org-8025 561 40 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 41 /ParseICCProfilesInComments /ParseICCProfilesInComments . www-bis-org-8025 561 42 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 43 /EmbedJobOptions /embedjoboption NNS www-bis-org-8025 561 44 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 45 /DSCReportingLevel /DSCReportingLevel . www-bis-org-8025 561 46 0 0 NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 47 /EmitDSCWarnings /EmitDSCWarnings . www-bis-org-8025 561 48 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 49 /EndPage /endpage NN www-bis-org-8025 561 50 -1 -1 . www-bis-org-8025 561 51 /ImageMemory /imagememory NN www-bis-org-8025 561 52 1048576 1048576 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 53 /LockDistillerParams /LockDistillerParams . www-bis-org-8025 561 54 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 55 /MaxSubsetPct /MaxSubsetPct . www-bis-org-8025 561 56 100 100 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 57 /Optimize /optimize VBP www-bis-org-8025 561 58 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 59 /OPM /OPM . www-bis-org-8025 561 60 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 61 /ParseDSCComments /ParseDSCComments . www-bis-org-8025 561 62 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 63 /ParseDSCCommentsForDocInfo /parsedsccommentsfordocinfo SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 64 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 65 /PreserveCopyPage /preservecopypage NN www-bis-org-8025 561 66 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 67 /PreserveDICMYKValues /PreserveDICMYKValues . www-bis-org-8025 561 68 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 69 /PreserveEPSInfo /PreserveEPSInfo : www-bis-org-8025 561 70 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 71 /PreserveFlatness /preserveflatness NN www-bis-org-8025 561 72 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 73 /PreserveHalftoneInfo /preservehalftoneinfo CD www-bis-org-8025 561 74 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 75 /PreserveOPIComments /PreserveOPIComments , www-bis-org-8025 561 76 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 77 /PreserveOverprintSettings /PreserveOverprintSettings . www-bis-org-8025 561 78 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 79 /StartPage /StartPage : www-bis-org-8025 561 80 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 81 /SubsetFonts /subsetfonts CD www-bis-org-8025 561 82 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 83 /TransferFunctionInfo /TransferFunctionInfo . www-bis-org-8025 561 84 /Apply /apply JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 85 /UCRandBGInfo /UCRandBGInfo . www-bis-org-8025 561 86 /Remove /Remove NNS www-bis-org-8025 561 87 /UsePrologue /UsePrologue , www-bis-org-8025 561 88 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 89 /ColorSettingsFile /ColorSettingsFile . www-bis-org-8025 561 90 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 91 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 92 /AlwaysEmbed /AlwaysEmbed NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 93 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 94 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 95 /SymbolMT /SymbolMT NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 96 /Wingdings /wingding NNS www-bis-org-8025 561 97 - - : www-bis-org-8025 561 98 Regular regular JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 99 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 100 /NeverEmbed /neverembe VBN www-bis-org-8025 561 101 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 102 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 103 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 104 /AntiAliasColorImages /AntiAliasColorImages NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 105 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 106 /CropColorImages /cropcolorimage NNS www-bis-org-8025 561 107 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 108 /ColorImageMinResolution /colorimageminresolution NN www-bis-org-8025 561 109 150 150 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 110 /ColorImageMinResolutionPolicy /ColorImageMinResolutionPolicy NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 111 /OK /OK . www-bis-org-8025 561 112 /DownsampleColorImages /DownsampleColorImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 113 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 114 /ColorImageDownsampleType /ColorImageDownsampleType . www-bis-org-8025 561 115 /Bicubic /Bicubic . www-bis-org-8025 561 116 /ColorImageResolution /ColorImageResolution NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 117 150 150 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 118 /ColorImageDepth /ColorImageDepth NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 119 -1 -1 : www-bis-org-8025 561 120 /ColorImageMinDownsampleDepth /colorimagemindownsampledepth NN www-bis-org-8025 561 121 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 122 /ColorImageDownsampleThreshold /colorimagedownsamplethreshold SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 123 1.00000 1.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 124 /EncodeColorImages /EncodeColorImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 125 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 126 /ColorImageFilter /ColorImageFilter . www-bis-org-8025 561 127 /DCTEncode /DCTEncode NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 128 /AutoFilterColorImages /AutoFilterColorImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 129 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 130 /ColorImageAutoFilterStrategy /ColorImageAutoFilterStrategy NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 131 /JPEG /JPEG . www-bis-org-8025 561 132 /ColorACSImageDict /ColorACSImageDict NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 133 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 134 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 135 /QFactor /QFactor NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 136 0.76 0.76 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 137 /HSamples /HSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 138 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 139 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 140 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 141 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 142 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 143 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 144 /VSamples /VSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 145 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 146 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 147 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 148 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 149 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 150 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 151 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 152 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 153 /ColorImageDict /ColorImageDict . www-bis-org-8025 561 154 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 155 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 156 /QFactor /QFactor NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 157 0.76 0.76 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 158 /HSamples /HSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 159 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 160 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 161 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 162 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 163 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 164 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 165 /VSamples /VSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 166 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 167 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 168 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 169 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 170 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 171 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 172 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 173 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 174 /JPEG2000ColorACSImageDict /JPEG2000ColorACSImageDict NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 175 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 176 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 177 /TileWidth /TileWidth NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 178 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 179 /TileHeight /tileheight SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 180 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 181 /Quality /quality SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 182 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 183 > > FW www-bis-org-8025 561 184 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 185 /JPEG2000ColorImageDict /JPEG2000ColorImageDict NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 186 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 187 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 188 /TileWidth /TileWidth NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 189 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 190 /TileHeight /tileheight SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 191 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 192 /Quality /quality SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 193 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 194 > > FW www-bis-org-8025 561 195 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 196 /AntiAliasGrayImages /antialiasgrayimages CD www-bis-org-8025 561 197 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 198 /CropGrayImages /CropGrayImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 199 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 200 /GrayImageMinResolution /GrayImageMinResolution NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 201 150 150 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 202 /GrayImageMinResolutionPolicy /grayimageminresolutionpolicy CD www-bis-org-8025 561 203 /OK /OK . www-bis-org-8025 561 204 /DownsampleGrayImages /DownsampleGrayImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 205 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 206 /GrayImageDownsampleType /GrayImageDownsampleType . www-bis-org-8025 561 207 /Bicubic /Bicubic NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 208 /GrayImageResolution /GrayImageResolution NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 209 150 150 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 210 /GrayImageDepth /grayimagedepth SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 211 -1 -1 . www-bis-org-8025 561 212 /GrayImageMinDownsampleDepth /GrayImageMinDownsampleDepth NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 213 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 214 /GrayImageDownsampleThreshold /grayimagedownsamplethreshold CD www-bis-org-8025 561 215 1.00000 1.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 216 /EncodeGrayImages /encodegrayimages CD www-bis-org-8025 561 217 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 218 /GrayImageFilter /GrayImageFilter . www-bis-org-8025 561 219 /DCTEncode /dctencode SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 220 /AutoFilterGrayImages /autofiltergrayimages CD www-bis-org-8025 561 221 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 222 /GrayImageAutoFilterStrategy /grayimageautofilterstrategy CD www-bis-org-8025 561 223 /JPEG /JPEG NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 224 /GrayACSImageDict /GrayACSImageDict NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 225 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 226 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 227 /QFactor /QFactor NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 228 0.76 0.76 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 229 /HSamples /HSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 230 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 231 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 232 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 233 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 234 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 235 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 236 /VSamples /VSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 237 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 238 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 239 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 240 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 241 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 242 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 243 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 244 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 245 /GrayImageDict /GrayImageDict NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 246 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 247 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 248 /QFactor /QFactor NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 249 0.76 0.76 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 250 /HSamples /HSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 251 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 252 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 253 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 254 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 255 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 256 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 257 /VSamples /VSamples . www-bis-org-8025 561 258 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 259 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 260 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 261 1 1 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 262 2 2 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 263 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 264 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 265 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 266 /JPEG2000GrayACSImageDict /JPEG2000GrayACSImageDict NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 267 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 268 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 269 /TileWidth /TileWidth NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 270 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 271 /TileHeight /tileheight SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 272 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 273 /Quality /quality SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 274 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 275 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 276 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 277 /JPEG2000GrayImageDict /JPEG2000GrayImageDict NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 278 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 279 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 280 /TileWidth /TileWidth NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 281 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 282 /TileHeight /tileheight SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 283 256 256 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 284 /Quality /quality SYM www-bis-org-8025 561 285 15 15 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 286 > > FW www-bis-org-8025 561 287 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 288 /AntiAliasMonoImages /AntiAliasMonoImages : www-bis-org-8025 561 289 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 290 /CropMonoImages /CropMonoImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 291 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 292 /MonoImageMinResolution /MonoImageMinResolution NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 293 1200 1200 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 294 /MonoImageMinResolutionPolicy /MonoImageMinResolutionPolicy NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 295 /OK /OK . www-bis-org-8025 561 296 /DownsampleMonoImages /DownsampleMonoImages NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 297 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 298 /MonoImageDownsampleType /MonoImageDownsampleType . www-bis-org-8025 561 299 /Bicubic /bicubic JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 300 /MonoImageResolution /MonoImageResolution NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 301 600 600 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 302 /MonoImageDepth /MonoImageDepth NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 303 -1 -1 . www-bis-org-8025 561 304 /MonoImageDownsampleThreshold /MonoImageDownsampleThreshold NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 305 1.00000 1.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 306 /EncodeMonoImages /EncodeMonoImages . www-bis-org-8025 561 307 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 308 /MonoImageFilter /MonoImageFilter NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 309 /CCITTFaxEncode /CCITTFaxEncode . www-bis-org-8025 561 310 /MonoImageDict /MonoImageDict NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 311 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 312 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 313 /K /K . www-bis-org-8025 561 314 -1 -1 . www-bis-org-8025 561 315 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 316 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 317 /AllowPSXObjects /AllowPSXObjects : www-bis-org-8025 561 318 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 319 /CheckCompliance /CheckCompliance NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 320 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 321 /None /None NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 322 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 323 /PDFX1aCheck /PDFX1aCheck NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 324 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 325 /PDFX3Check /PDFX3Check NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 326 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 327 /PDFXCompliantPDFOnly /PDFXCompliantPDFOnly , www-bis-org-8025 561 328 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 329 /PDFXNoTrimBoxError /PDFXNoTrimBoxError . www-bis-org-8025 561 330 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 331 /PDFXTrimBoxToMediaBoxOffset /PDFXTrimBoxToMediaBoxOffset . www-bis-org-8025 561 332 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 333 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 334 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 335 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 336 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 337 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 338 /PDFXSetBleedBoxToMediaBox /PDFXSetBleedBoxToMediaBox . www-bis-org-8025 561 339 true true JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 340 /PDFXBleedBoxToTrimBoxOffset /PDFXBleedBoxToTrimBoxOffset . www-bis-org-8025 561 341 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 342 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 343 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 344 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 345 0.00000 0.00000 CD www-bis-org-8025 561 346 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 347 /PDFXOutputIntentProfile /PDFXOutputIntentProfile . www-bis-org-8025 561 348 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 349 None none NN www-bis-org-8025 561 350 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 351 /PDFXOutputConditionIdentifier /PDFXOutputConditionIdentifier NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 352 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 353 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 354 /PDFXOutputCondition /PDFXOutputCondition . www-bis-org-8025 561 355 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 356 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 357 /PDFXRegistryName /PDFXRegistryName NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 358 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 359 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 360 /PDFXTrapped /PDFXTrapped NFP www-bis-org-8025 561 361 /False /False : www-bis-org-8025 561 362 /CreateJDFFile /CreateJDFFile , www-bis-org-8025 561 363 false false JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 364 /Description /description NN www-bis-org-8025 561 365 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 366 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 367 /ARA /ARA . www-bis-org-8025 561 368 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 561 370 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 371 /BGR /BGR . www-bis-org-8025 561 372 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 373 FEFF04180437043F043E043B043704320430043904420435002004420435043704380020043D0430044104420440043E0439043A0438002C00200437043000200434043000200441044A0437043404300432043004420435002000410064006F00620065002000500044004600200434043E043A0443043C0435043D04420438002C0020043F043E04340445043E0434044F044904380020043704300020043D04300434043504360434043D043E00200440043004370433043B0435043604340430043D0435002004380020043F04350447043004420430043D04350020043D04300020043104380437043D0435044100200434043E043A0443043C0435043D04420438002E00200421044A04370434043004340435043D043804420435002000500044004600200434043E043A0443043C0435043D044204380020043C043E0433043004420020043404300020044104350020043E0442043204300440044F0442002004410020004100630072006F00620061007400200438002000410064006F00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002E0030002004380020043F043E002D043D043E043204380020043204350440044104380438002E FEFF04180437043F043E043B043704320430043904420435002004420435043704380020043D0430044104420440043E0439043A0438002C00200437043000200434043000200441044A0437043404300432043004420435002000410064006F00620065002000500044004600200434043E043A0443043C0435043D04420438002C0020043F043E04340445043E0434044F044904380020043704300020043D04300434043504360434043D043E00200440043004370433043B0435043604340430043D0435002004380020043F04350447043004420430043D04350020043D04300020043104380437043D0435044100200434043E043A0443043C0435043D04420438002E00200421044A04370434043004340435043D043804420435002000500044004600200434043E043A0443043C0435043D044204380020043C043E0433043004420020043404300020044104350020043E0442043204300440044F0442002004410020004100630072006F00620061007400200438002000410064006F00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002E0030002004380020043F043E002D043D043E043204380020043204350440044104380438002E NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 374 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 375 /CHS /CHS NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 376 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 377 FEFF4f7f75288fd94e9b8bbe5b9a521b5efa7684002000410064006f006200650020005000440046002065876863900275284e8e55464e1a65876863768467e5770b548c62535370300260a853ef4ee54f7f75280020004100630072006f0062006100740020548c002000410064006f00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002e003000204ee553ca66f49ad87248672c676562535f00521b5efa768400200050004400460020658768633002 FEFF4f7f75288fd94e9b8bbe5b9a521b5efa7684002000410064006f006200650020005000440046002065876863900275284e8e55464e1a65876863768467e5770b548c62535370300260a853ef4ee54f7f75280020004100630072006f0062006100740020548c002000410064006f00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002e003000204ee553ca66f49ad87248672c676562535f00521b5efa768400200050004400460020658768633002 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 378 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 379 /CHT /CHT . www-bis-org-8025 561 380 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 381 FEFF4f7f752890194e9b8a2d7f6e5efa7acb7684002000410064006f006200650020005000440046002065874ef69069752865bc666e901a554652d965874ef6768467e5770b548c52175370300260a853ef4ee54f7f75280020004100630072006f0062006100740020548c002000410064006f00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002e003000204ee553ca66f49ad87248672c4f86958b555f5df25efa7acb76840020005000440046002065874ef63002 FEFF4f7f752890194e9b8a2d7f6e5efa7acb7684002000410064006f006200650020005000440046002065874ef69069752865bc666e901a554652d965874ef6768467e5770b548c52175370300260a853ef4ee54f7f75280020004100630072006f0062006100740020548c002000410064006f00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002e003000204ee553ca66f49ad87248672c4f86958b555f5df25efa7acb76840020005000440046002065874ef63002 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 382 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 383 /CZE /CZE . www-bis-org-8025 561 384 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 385 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 386 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 387 /DAN /DAN . www-bis-org-8025 561 388 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 389 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 JJ www-bis-org-8025 561 390 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 391 /DEU /DEU . www-bis-org-8025 561 392 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 393 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 394 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 395 /ESP /ESP . www-bis-org-8025 561 396 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 397 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 398 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 399 /ETI /ETI . www-bis-org-8025 561 400 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 401 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 402 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 403 /FRA /FRA . www-bis-org-8025 561 404 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 405 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 406 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 407 /GRE /GRE . www-bis-org-8025 561 408 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 561 410 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 411 /HEB /HEB . www-bis-org-8025 561 412 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 561 414 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 415 /HRV /HRV . www-bis-org-8025 561 416 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 561 418 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 419 /HUN /HUN . www-bis-org-8025 561 420 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 561 421 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 422 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 561 423 /ITA /ITA . www-bis-org-8025 561 424 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 561 425 Utilizzare Utilizzare NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 426 queste queste NN www-bis-org-8025 561 427 impostazioni impostazioni VBP www-bis-org-8025 561 428 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 561 429 creare creare NN www-bis-org-8025 561 430 documenti documenti NN www-bis-org-8025 561 431 Adobe Adobe NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 432 PDF PDF NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 433 adatti adatti NN www-bis-org-8025 561 434 per per IN www-bis-org-8025 561 435 visualizzare visualizzare NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 436 e e NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 437 stampare stampare NN www-bis-org-8025 561 438 documenti documenti NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 439 aziendali aziendali NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 440 in in IN www-bis-org-8025 561 441 modo modo NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 442 affidabile affidabile NNP www-bis-org-8025 561 443 . . . www-bis-org-8025 562 1 I -PRON- PRP www-bis-org-8025 562 2 documenti documenti VBP www-bis-org-8025 562 3 PDF PDF NNP www-bis-org-8025 562 4 creati creati NNS www-bis-org-8025 562 5 possono possono NNP www-bis-org-8025 562 6 essere essere JJ www-bis-org-8025 562 7 aperti aperti NNP www-bis-org-8025 562 8 con con NNP www-bis-org-8025 562 9 Acrobat Acrobat NNP www-bis-org-8025 562 10 e e VBZ www-bis-org-8025 562 11 Adobe Adobe NNP www-bis-org-8025 562 12 Reader Reader NNP www-bis-org-8025 562 13 6.0 6.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 562 14 e e NN www-bis-org-8025 562 15 versioni versioni JJ www-bis-org-8025 562 16 successive successive JJ www-bis-org-8025 562 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 562 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 563 1 /JPN /JPN NFP www-bis-org-8025 563 2 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 563 3 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 4 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 563 5 /KOR /KOR . www-bis-org-8025 563 6 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 563 7 FEFFc7740020c124c815c7440020c0acc6a9d558c5ec0020be44c988b2c8c2a40020bb38c11cb97c0020c548c815c801c73cb85c0020bcf4ace00020c778c1c4d558b2940020b3700020ac00c7a50020c801d569d55c002000410064006f0062006500200050004400460020bb38c11cb97c0020c791c131d569b2c8b2e4002e0020c774b807ac8c0020c791c131b41c00200050004400460020bb38c11cb2940020004100630072006f0062006100740020bc0f002000410064006f00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002e00300020c774c0c1c5d0c11c0020c5f40020c2180020c788c2b5b2c8b2e4002e FEFFc7740020c124c815c7440020c0acc6a9d558c5ec0020be44c988b2c8c2a40020bb38c11cb97c0020c548c815c801c73cb85c0020bcf4ace00020c778c1c4d558b2940020b3700020ac00c7a50020c801d569d55c002000410064006f0062006500200050004400460020bb38c11cb97c0020c791c131d569b2c8b2e4002e0020c774b807ac8c0020c791c131b41c00200050004400460020bb38c11cb2940020004100630072006f0062006100740020bc0f002000410064006f00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002e00300020c774c0c1c5d0c11c0020c5f40020c2180020c788c2b5b2c8b2e4002e NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 8 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 563 9 /LTH /LTH . www-bis-org-8025 563 10 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 563 11 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 12 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 563 13 /LVI /LVI . www-bis-org-8025 563 14 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 563 15 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 16 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 563 17 /NLD /NLD . www-bis-org-8025 563 18 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 563 19 Gebruik Gebruik NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 20 deze deze JJ www-bis-org-8025 563 21 instellingen instellingen NN www-bis-org-8025 563 22 om om NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 23 Adobe Adobe NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 24 PDF PDF NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 25 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 563 26 documenten documenten VBN www-bis-org-8025 563 27 te te NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 28 maken maken VBN www-bis-org-8025 563 29 waarmee waarmee NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 30 zakelijke zakelijke NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 31 documenten documenten NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 32 betrouwbaar betrouwbaar NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 33 kunnen kunnen NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 34 worden worden NNP www-bis-org-8025 563 35 weergegeven weergegeven RB www-bis-org-8025 563 36 en en IN www-bis-org-8025 563 37 afgedrukt afgedrukt NN www-bis-org-8025 563 38 . . . www-bis-org-8025 564 1 De De NNP www-bis-org-8025 564 2 gemaakte gemaakte NNP www-bis-org-8025 564 3 PDF PDF NNP www-bis-org-8025 564 4 - - HYPH www-bis-org-8025 564 5 documenten documenten VBN www-bis-org-8025 564 6 kunnen kunnen NNP www-bis-org-8025 564 7 worden worden JJ www-bis-org-8025 564 8 geopend geopend NN www-bis-org-8025 564 9 met meet VBD www-bis-org-8025 564 10 Acrobat Acrobat NNP www-bis-org-8025 564 11 en en IN www-bis-org-8025 564 12 Adobe Adobe NNP www-bis-org-8025 564 13 Reader Reader NNP www-bis-org-8025 564 14 6.0 6.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 564 15 en en NN www-bis-org-8025 564 16 hoger hoger NN www-bis-org-8025 564 17 . . . www-bis-org-8025 564 18 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 565 1 /NOR /NOR NFP www-bis-org-8025 565 2 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 565 3 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 4 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 5 /POL /POL . www-bis-org-8025 565 6 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 565 7 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 FEFF004b006f0072007a0079007300740061006a010500630020007a00200074007900630068002000750073007400610077006900650144002c0020006d006f017c006e0061002000740077006f0072007a0079010700200064006f006b0075006d0065006e00740079002000410064006f00620065002000500044004600200070006f007a00770061006c0061006a01050063006500200077002000730070006f007300f300620020006e00690065007a00610077006f0064006e0079002000770079015b0077006900650074006c00610107002000690020006400720075006b006f00770061010700200064006f006b0075006d0065006e007400790020006600690072006d006f00770065002e00200020005500740077006f0072007a006f006e006500200064006f006b0075006d0065006e0074007900200050004400460020006d006f017c006e00610020006f007400770069006500720061010700200077002000700072006f006700720061006d0061006300680020004100630072006f00620061007400200069002000410064006f0062006500200052006500610064006500720020007700200077006500720073006a006900200036002e00300020006f00720061007a002000770020006e006f00770073007a00790063006800200077006500720073006a00610063006800200074007900630068002000700072006f006700720061006d00f30077002e004b006f0072007a0079007300740061006a010500630020007a00200074007900630068002000750073007400610077006900650144002c0020006d006f017c006e0061002000740077006f0072007a0079010700200064006f006b0075006d0065006e00740079002000410064006f00620065002000500044004600200070006f007a00770061006c0061006a01050063006500200077002000730070006f007300f300620020006e00690065007a00610077006f0064006e0079002000770079015b0077006900650074006c00610107002000690020006400720075006b006f00770061010700200064006f006b0075006d0065006e007400790020006600690072006d006f00770065002e00200020005500740077006f0072007a006f006e006500200064006f006b0075006d0065006e0074007900200050004400460020006d006f017c006e00610020006f007400770069006500720061010700200077002000700072006f006700720061006d0061006300680020004100630072006f00620061007400200069002000410064006f0062006500200052006500610064006500720020007700200077006500720073006a006900200036002e00300020006f00720061007a002000770020006e006f00770073007a00790063006800200077006500720073006a00610063006800200074007900630068002000700072006f006700720061006d00f30077002e NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 8 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 9 /PTB /PTB . www-bis-org-8025 565 10 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 565 11 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 JJ www-bis-org-8025 565 12 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 13 /RUM /RUM . www-bis-org-8025 565 14 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 565 16 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 17 /RUS /RUS . www-bis-org-8025 565 18 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 565 20 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 21 /SKY /SKY NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 22 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 565 23 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 24 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 25 /SLV /SLV . www-bis-org-8025 565 26 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 565 28 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 29 /SUO /SUO . www-bis-org-8025 565 30 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 565 31 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 32 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 33 /SVE /SVE . www-bis-org-8025 565 34 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 565 35 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 FEFF0041006e007600e4006e00640020006400650020006800e4007200200069006e0073007400e4006c006c006e0069006e006700610072006e00610020006f006d002000640075002000760069006c006c00200073006b006100700061002000410064006f006200650020005000440046002d0064006f006b0075006d0065006e007400200073006f006d00200070006100730073006100720020006600f60072002000740069006c006c006600f60072006c00690074006c006900670020007600690073006e0069006e00670020006f006300680020007500740073006b007200690066007400650072002000610076002000610066006600e4007200730064006f006b0075006d0065006e0074002e002000200053006b006100700061006400650020005000440046002d0064006f006b0075006d0065006e00740020006b0061006e002000f600700070006e00610073002000690020004100630072006f0062006100740020006f00630068002000410064006f00620065002000520065006100640065007200200036002e00300020006f00630068002000730065006e006100720065002e NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 36 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 37 /TUR /TUR . www-bis-org-8025 565 38 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 565 39 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 NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 40 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 41 /UKR /UKR NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 42 < < XX www-bis-org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www-bis-org-8025 565 44 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 565 45 /ENU /ENU . www-bis-org-8025 565 46 ( ( -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 565 47 Use use VB www-bis-org-8025 565 48 these these DT www-bis-org-8025 565 49 settings setting NNS www-bis-org-8025 565 50 to to TO www-bis-org-8025 565 51 create create VB www-bis-org-8025 565 52 Adobe Adobe NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 53 PDF PDF NNP www-bis-org-8025 565 54 documents document NNS www-bis-org-8025 565 55 suitable suitable JJ www-bis-org-8025 565 56 for for IN www-bis-org-8025 565 57 reliable reliable JJ www-bis-org-8025 565 58 viewing viewing NN www-bis-org-8025 565 59 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 565 60 printing printing NN www-bis-org-8025 565 61 of of IN www-bis-org-8025 565 62 business business NN www-bis-org-8025 565 63 documents document NNS www-bis-org-8025 565 64 . . . www-bis-org-8025 566 1 Created create VBN www-bis-org-8025 566 2 PDF PDF NNP www-bis-org-8025 566 3 documents document NNS www-bis-org-8025 566 4 can can MD www-bis-org-8025 566 5 be be VB www-bis-org-8025 566 6 opened open VBN www-bis-org-8025 566 7 with with IN www-bis-org-8025 566 8 Acrobat Acrobat NNP www-bis-org-8025 566 9 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 566 10 Adobe Adobe NNP www-bis-org-8025 566 11 Reader Reader NNP www-bis-org-8025 566 12 6.0 6.0 CD www-bis-org-8025 566 13 and and CC www-bis-org-8025 566 14 later later RB www-bis-org-8025 566 15 . . . www-bis-org-8025 566 16 ) ) -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 567 1 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 567 2 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 567 3 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 567 4 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 567 5 setdistillerparams setdistillerparam NNS www-bis-org-8025 567 6 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 567 7 < < XX www-bis-org-8025 567 8 /HWResolution /HWResolution . www-bis-org-8025 567 9 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 567 10 600 600 CD www-bis-org-8025 567 11 600 600 CD www-bis-org-8025 567 12 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 567 13 /PageSize /PageSize NNP www-bis-org-8025 567 14 [ [ -LRB- www-bis-org-8025 567 15 595.276 595.276 CD www-bis-org-8025 567 16 841.890 841.890 CD www-bis-org-8025 567 17 ] ] -RRB- www-bis-org-8025 567 18 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 567 19 > > XX www-bis-org-8025 567 20 setpagedevice setpagedevice NN