id sid tid token lemma pos clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 1 Measuring measure VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 2 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 3 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 4 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 5 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 6 Measuring measure VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 7 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 8 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 9 Crawler Crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 10 Ethics Ethics NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 11 C. C. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 12 Lee Lee NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 13 Giles Giles NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 14 College College NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 15 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 16 Information Information NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 17 Sciences Sciences NNPS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 18 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 19 Technology Technology NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 20 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 21 State State NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 22 University University NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 23 University University NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 24 Park Park NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 25 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 26 PA PA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 27 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 28 USA USA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 29 giles@ist.psu.edu giles@ist.psu.edu NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 30 Yang Yang NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 31 Sun Sun NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 32 AOL AOL NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 33 Research Research NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 34 888 888 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 35 Villa Villa NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 36 St St NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 37 Mountain Mountain NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 38 View View NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 39 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 40 CA CA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 41 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 42 USA USA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 43 yang.sun@corp.aol.com yang.sun@corp.aol.com NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 44 Isaac Isaac NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 45 G. G. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 46 Councill Councill NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 47 Google Google NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 48 Inc. Inc. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 49 76 76 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 50 Ninth Ninth NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 51 Avenue Avenue NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 52 4th 4th NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 53 Floor Floor NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 54 New New NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 55 York York NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 56 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 57 NY NY NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 58 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 59 USA USA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 60 icouncill@gmail.com icouncill@gmail.com ADD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 61 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 62 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 63 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 64 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 65 highly highly RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 66 automated automate VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 67 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 68 seldom seldom RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 69 regulated regulate VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 70 manually manually RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 1 71 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 2 diversity diversity NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 3 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 4 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 5 activities activity NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 6 often often RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 7 leads lead VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 8 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 9 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 10 problems problem NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 11 such such JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 12 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 13 spam spam NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 14 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 15 service service NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 16 attacks attack NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 2 17 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 1 In in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 2 this this DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 3 research research NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 4 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 5 quantitative quantitative JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 6 models model NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 7 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 8 proposed propose VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 9 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 10 measure measure VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 11 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 12 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 13 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 14 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 15 based base VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 16 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 17 their -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 18 behaviors behavior NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 19 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 20 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 21 servers server NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 3 22 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 1 We -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 2 investigate investigate VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 3 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 4 define define VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 5 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 6 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 7 measure measure VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 8 crawler crawler JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 9 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 10 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 11 referring refer VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 12 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 13 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 14 extent extent NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 15 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 16 which which WDT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 17 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 18 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 19 respect respect VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 20 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 21 regulations regulation NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 22 set set VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 23 forth forth RP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 24 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 25 robots.txt robots.txt CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 26 configuration configuration NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 27 files file NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 4 28 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 1 We -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 2 propose propose VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 3 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 4 vector vector NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 5 space space NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 6 model model NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 7 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 8 represent represent VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 9 crawler crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 10 behav- behav- NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 11 ior ior NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 12 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 13 measure measure VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 14 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 15 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 16 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 17 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 18 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 19 based base VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 20 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 21 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 22 behavior behavior NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 23 vectors vector NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 5 24 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 2 results result NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 3 show show VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 4 that that IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 5 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 6 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 7 vary vary VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 8 significantly significantly RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 9 among among IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 10 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 6 11 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 1 Most Most JJS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 2 commercial commercial JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 3 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 4 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 5 ’ ’ POS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 6 behaviors behavior NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 7 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 8 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 7 9 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 1 However however RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 2 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 3 many many JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 4 commer- commer- JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 5 cial cial JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 6 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 7 still still RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 8 consistently consistently RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 9 violate violate VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 10 or or CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 11 misinterpret misinterpret VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 12 certain certain JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 13 robots.txt robots.txt NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 14 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 8 15 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 1 We -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 2 also also RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 3 measure measure VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 4 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 5 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 6 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 7 big big JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 8 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 9 engine engine NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 10 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 11 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 12 terms term NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 13 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 14 return return NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 15 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 16 investment investment NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 9 17 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 2 re- re- JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 3 sults sult NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 4 show show VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 5 that that IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 6 Google Google NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 7 has have VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 8 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 9 higher high JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 10 score score NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 11 than than IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 12 other other JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 13 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 14 engines engine NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 15 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 16 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 17 US US NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 18 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 19 but but CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 20 has have VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 21 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 22 lower low JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 23 score score NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 24 than than IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 25 Baidu Baidu NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 26 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 27 Chinese chinese JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 28 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 10 29 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 1 Categories category NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 2 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 3 Subject Subject NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 4 Descriptors descriptor NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 5 K.4.1 K.4.1 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 6 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 7 Public Public NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 8 Policy Policy NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 9 Issues Issues NNPS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 10 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 11 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 12 Ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 13 ; ; : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 14 K.4.1 K.4.1 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 15 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 16 Public public JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 17 Pol- Pol- NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 18 icy icy NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 19 Issues issue NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 20 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 21 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 22 Privacy Privacy NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 23 General General NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 24 Terms Terms NNPS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 25 Measurement Measurement NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 26 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 27 Design Design NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 28 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 29 Experimentation experimentation NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 30 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 31 Algorithms Algorithms NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 32 Keywords Keywords NNPS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 33 robots.txt robots.txt NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 34 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 35 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 36 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 37 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 38 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 39 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 40 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 41 privacy privacy NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 42 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 11 43 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 1 INTRODUCTION introduction NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 2 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 3 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 4 have have VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 5 been be VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 6 widely widely RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 7 used use VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 8 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 9 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 10 engines engine NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 11 as as RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 12 well well RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 13 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 14 many many JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 15 other other JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 16 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 17 applications application NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 18 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 19 collect collect VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 20 content content NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 21 from from IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 22 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 23 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 12 24 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 1 These these DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 2 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 3 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 4 highly highly RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 5 automated automate VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 6 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 7 seldom seldom RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 8 regulated regulate VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 9 manually manually RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 13 10 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 1 With with IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 2 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 3 fast fast JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 4 growing grow VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 5 online online JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 6 services service NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 7 relying rely VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 8 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 9 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 10 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 11 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 12 collect collect VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 13 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 14 pages page NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 15 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 16 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 17 function- function- NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 18 alities alitie NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 19 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 20 activities activity NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 21 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 22 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 23 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 24 have have VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 25 become become VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 26 extremely extremely RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 27 diverse diverse JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 14 28 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 1 Crawler Crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 2 activities activity NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 3 typically typically RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 4 include include VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 5 requests request NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 6 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 7 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 8 pages page NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 9 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 10 general general JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 11 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 12 purpose purpose NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 13 text text NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 14 indexing indexing NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 15 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 16 searching searching NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 17 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 18 ex- ex- XX clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 19 traction traction NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 20 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 21 email email NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 22 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 23 personal personal JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 24 identity identity NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 25 information information NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 26 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 27 busi- busi- JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 28 ness ness NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 29 purposes purpose NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 30 as as RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 31 well well RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 32 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 33 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 34 malicious malicious JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 35 purposes purpose NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 15 36 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 1 Accessing access VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 2 Copyright Copyright NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 3 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 4 held hold VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 5 by by IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 6 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 7 author author NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 8 / / , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 9 owner(s owner(s NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 10 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 16 11 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 1 WWW WWW NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 2 2010 2010 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 3 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 4 April April NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 5 26–30 26–30 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 6 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 7 2010 2010 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 8 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 9 Raleigh Raleigh NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 10 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 11 North North NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 12 Carolina Carolina NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 13 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 14 USA USA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 17 15 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 1 ACM ACM NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 2 978 978 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 3 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 4 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 5 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 6 60558 60558 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 7 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 8 799 799 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 9 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 10 8/10/04 8/10/04 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 18 11 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 1 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 2 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 3 information information NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 4 with with IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 5 automated automate VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 6 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 7 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 8 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 9 lead lead VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 10 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 11 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 12 problems problem NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 13 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 14 privacy privacy NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 15 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 16 security security NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 19 17 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 1 For for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 2 example example NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 3 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 4 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 5 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 6 extract extract VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 7 personal personal JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 8 contact contact NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 9 information information NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 10 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 11 spam spam NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 12 purposes purpose NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 13 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 14 identity identity NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 15 theft theft NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 20 16 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 1 Crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 2 may may MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 3 also also RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 4 overload overload VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 5 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 6 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 7 such such JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 8 that that IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 9 normal normal JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 10 user user NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 11 access access NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 12 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 13 impeded impede VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 21 14 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 1 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 2 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 3 activities activity NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 4 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 5 be be VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 6 regulated regulate VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 7 from from IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 8 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 9 server server NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 10 side side NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 11 by by IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 12 deploying deploy VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 13 Robots Robots NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 14 Exclusion Exclusion NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 15 Protocol Protocol NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 16 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 17 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 18 set set NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 19 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 20 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 21 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 22 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 23 file file NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 24 called call VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 25 robots.txt robots.txt NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 26 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 27 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 28 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 29 root root NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 30 directory directory NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 31 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 32 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 33 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 34 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 35 allow- allow- CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 36 ing e VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 37 webmasters webmaster NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 38 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 39 indicate indicate VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 40 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 41 visiting visit VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 42 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 43 which which WDT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 44 parts part NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 45 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 46 their -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 47 sites site NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 48 should should MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 49 not not RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 50 be be VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 51 visited visit VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 52 as as RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 53 well well RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 54 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 55 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 56 minimum minimum JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 57 time time NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 58 interval interval NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 59 between between IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 60 visits visit NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 22 61 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 1 A a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 2 recent recent JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 3 study study NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 4 shows show VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 5 more more JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 6 than than IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 7 30 30 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 8 % % NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 9 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 10 active active JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 11 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 12 employ employ VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 13 this this DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 14 standard standard NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 15 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 16 reg- reg- VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 17 ulate ulate VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 18 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 19 activities activity NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 20 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 21 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 22 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 23 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 24 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 23 25 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 1 However however RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 2 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 3 since since IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 4 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 5 Robots Robots NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 6 Exclusion Exclusion NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 7 Protocol Protocol NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 8 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 9 REP REP NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 10 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 11 serves serve VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 12 only only RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 13 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 14 an an DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 15 unenforced unenforced JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 16 ad- ad- CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 17 visory visory JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 18 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 19 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 20 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 21 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 22 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 23 may may MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 24 ignore ignore VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 25 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 26 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 27 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 28 access access NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 29 part part NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 30 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 31 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 32 forbidden forbidden JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 33 information information NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 34 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 35 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 36 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 24 37 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 1 Vi- vi- VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 2 olating olate VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 3 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 4 robots.txt robots.txt NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 5 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 6 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 7 lead lead VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 8 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 9 serious serious JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 10 privacy privacy NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 11 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 12 security security NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 13 concerns concern NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 25 14 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 1 Thus thus RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 2 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 3 measuring measure VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 4 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 5 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 6 becomes become VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 7 an an DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 8 important important JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 9 task task NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 10 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 11 help help VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 12 detecting detect VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 13 improper improper JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 14 crawler crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 15 behav- behav- NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 16 ior ior NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 17 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 18 early early JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 19 stages stage NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 20 as as RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 21 well well RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 22 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 23 identifying identify VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 24 unethical unethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 25 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 26 26 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 2 issues issue NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 3 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 4 crawler crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 5 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 6 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 7 however however RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 8 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 9 did do VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 10 not not RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 11 bring bring VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 12 enough enough JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 13 attention attention NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 14 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 15 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 16 research research NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 17 community community NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 18 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 19 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 20 under under IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 21 studied study VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 27 22 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 1 Crawler Crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 2 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 3 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 4 not not RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 5 limited limited JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 6 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 7 whether whether IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 8 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 9 obeying obey VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 10 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 11 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 12 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 13 but but CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 14 also also RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 15 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 16 be be VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 17 studied study VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 18 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 19 terms term NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 20 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 21 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 22 value value NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 23 provide provide VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 24 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 25 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 28 26 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 1 If if IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 2 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 3 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 4 provides provide VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 5 zero zero CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 6 value value NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 7 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 8 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 9 crawled crawled JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 10 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 11 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 12 it -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 13 should should MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 14 also also RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 15 be be VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 16 considered consider VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 17 less less RBR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 18 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 19 than than IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 20 those those DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 21 who who WP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 22 provide provide VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 23 positive positive JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 24 values value NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 29 25 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 1 In in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 2 this this DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 3 research research NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 4 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 5 we -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 6 propose propose VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 7 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 8 vector vector NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 9 space space NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 10 model model NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 11 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 12 mea- mea- NNPS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 13 suring suring NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 14 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 15 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 16 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 17 based base VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 18 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 19 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 20 Robots Robots NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 21 Exclusion Exclusion NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 22 Protocol Protocol NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 30 23 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 1 We -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 2 define define VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 3 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 4 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 5 metric metric JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 6 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 7 measure measure VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 8 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 9 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 10 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 31 11 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 1 We -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 2 also also RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 3 study study VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 4 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 5 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 6 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 7 big big JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 8 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 9 engine engine NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 10 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 11 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 12 terms term NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 13 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 14 return return NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 15 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 16 investment investment NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 17 where where WRB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 18 crawler crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 19 vis- vis- VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 20 its -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 21 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 22 considered consider VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 23 investments investment NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 24 from from IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 25 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 26 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 27 correspond- correspond- JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 28 ing ing NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 29 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 30 engine engine NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 31 traffic traffic NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 32 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 33 considered consider VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 34 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 35 returns return NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 32 36 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 2 results result NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 3 show show VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 4 that that IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 5 Google Google NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 6 has have VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 7 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 8 much much RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 9 higher high JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 10 score score NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 11 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 12 US US NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 13 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 14 but but CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 15 has have VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 16 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 17 lower low JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 18 score score NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 19 than than IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 20 Baidu Baidu NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 21 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 22 Chinese chinese JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 23 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 33 24 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 34 1 2 2 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 34 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 1 RELATED related JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 2 WORK work NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 3 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 4 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 5 factors factor NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 6 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 7 examined examine VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 8 from from IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 9 three three CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 10 perspectives perspective NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 11 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 12 4 4 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 13 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 14 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 15 denial denial NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 16 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 17 service service NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 18 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 19 cost cost NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 20 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 21 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 22 privacy privacy NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 35 23 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 1 An an DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 2 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 3 crawl crawl NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 4 guideline guideline NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 5 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 6 described describe VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 7 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 8 crawler crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 9 owners owner NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 10 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 11 follow follow VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 36 12 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 1 This this DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 2 guideline guideline NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 3 suggests suggest VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 4 taking take VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 5 legal legal JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 6 action action NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 7 or or CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 8 initiating initiate VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 9 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 10 profes- profes- NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 11 sional sional JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 12 organization organization NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 13 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 14 regulate regulate VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 15 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 16 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 37 17 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 2 research research NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 3 adopts adopt VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 4 these these DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 5 perspectives perspective NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 6 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 7 crawler crawler JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 8 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 9 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 10 expands expand VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 11 it -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 12 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 13 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 14 computational computational JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 15 measure measure NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 38 16 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 2 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 3 issues issue NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 4 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 5 administrat- administrat- NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 6 ing ing NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 7 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 8 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 9 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 10 discussed discuss VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 11 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 12 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 13 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 14 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 39 15 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 1 It -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 2 provides provide VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 3 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 4 guideline guideline NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 5 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 6 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 7 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 8 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 9 follow follow VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 40 10 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 2 guideline guideline NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 3 also also RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 4 gives give VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 5 great great JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 6 insights insight NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 7 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 8 our -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 9 research research NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 10 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 11 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 12 measurements measurement NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 41 13 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 1 However however RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 2 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 3 WWW WWW NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 4 2010 2010 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 5 • • NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 6 Poster poster NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 7 April April NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 8 26 26 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 9 - - SYM clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 10 30 30 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 11 • • NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 12 Raleigh Raleigh NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 13 • • NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 14 NC NC NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 15 • • NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 16 USA USA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 17 1101 1101 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 18 none none NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 19 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 20 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 21 above above RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 22 mentioned mention VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 23 work work NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 24 provides provide VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 25 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 26 quantitative quantitative JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 27 measure measure NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 28 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 29 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 30 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 31 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 42 32 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 43 1 3 3 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 43 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 1 CRAWLER CRAWLER NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 2 BEHAVIOR BEHAVIOR NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 3 MODEL MODEL NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 4 In in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 5 our -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 6 research research NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 7 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 8 each each DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 9 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 10 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 11 ’s ’s POS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 12 behavior behavior NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 13 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 14 modeled model VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 15 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 16 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 17 vector vector NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 18 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 19 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 20 rule rule NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 21 space space NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 22 where where WRB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 23 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 24 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 25 specified specify VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 26 by by IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 27 Robots Robots NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 28 Exclusion Exclusion NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 29 Protocol Protocol NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 30 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 31 regulate regulate VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 32 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 33 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 34 behavior behavior NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 44 35 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 1 If if IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 2 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 3 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 4 violates violate VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 5 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 6 rule rule NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 7 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 8 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 9 corresponding correspond VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 10 vector vector NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 11 element element NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 12 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 13 larger large JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 14 than than IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 15 0 0 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 45 16 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 1 Websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 2 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 3 also also RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 4 be be VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 5 modeled model VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 6 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 7 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 8 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 9 space space NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 10 that that IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 11 if if IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 12 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 13 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 14 includes include VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 15 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 16 rule rule NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 17 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 18 its -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 19 robots.txt robots.txt NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 20 file file NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 21 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 22 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 23 corresponding correspond VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 24 vector vector NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 25 element element NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 26 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 27 larger large JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 28 than than IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 29 0 0 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 46 30 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 2 ac- ac- DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 3 tual tual JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 4 value value NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 5 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 6 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 7 rule rule NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 8 element element NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 9 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 10 be be VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 11 defined define VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 12 based base VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 13 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 14 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 15 consequences consequence NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 16 or or CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 17 cost cost NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 18 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 19 violating violate VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 20 such such JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 21 rule rule NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 47 22 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 1 We -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 2 define define VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 3 content content NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 4 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 5 Ec Ec NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 6 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 7 access access NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 8 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 9 Ea Ea NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 10 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 11 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 12 evaluate evaluate VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 13 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 14 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 15 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 48 16 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 1 In in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 2 content content NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 3 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 4 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 5 cost cost NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 6 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 7 defined define VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 8 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 9 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 10 number number NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 11 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 12 restricted restrict VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 13 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 14 pages page NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 15 or or CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 16 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 17 directories directory NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 18 being be VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 19 unethically unethically RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 20 accessed access VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 21 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 22 see see VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 23 Eq Eq NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 49 24 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 50 1 1 1 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 50 2 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 50 3 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 1 Ec(C Ec(C NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 2 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 3 = = NFP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 4 ∑ ∑ . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 5 wi∈W wi∈w XX clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 6 ||VC(wi)|| ||VC(wi)|| NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 7 ||D(wi)|| ||d(wi)|| NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 51 8 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 1 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 2 1 1 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 3 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 4 Access access NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 5 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 6 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 7 defined define VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 8 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 9 how how WRB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 10 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 11 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 12 respects respect VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 13 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 14 desired desire VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 15 visit visit NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 16 interval interval NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 17 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 18 crawl crawl NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 19 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 20 delay delay NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 21 rule rule NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 22 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 23 robots.txt robots.txt CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 24 file file NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 25 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 26 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 27 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 28 website(see website(see . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 29 Eq eq RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 52 30 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 53 1 2 2 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 53 2 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 53 3 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 1 Ea(r Ea(r NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 2 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 3 = = NFP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 4 ∑ ∑ NFP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 5 wi∈W wi∈W NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 6 e−(intervalC(wi)−delay(wi e−(intervalC(wi)−delay(wi NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 7 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 8 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 9 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 10 + + SYM clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 11 e−(intervalC(wi)−delay(wi e−(intervalc(wi)−delay(wi ADD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 12 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 13 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 14 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 15 2 2 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 16 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 17 A a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 18 major major JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 19 advantage advantage NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 20 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 21 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 22 allowing allow VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 23 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 24 engine engine NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 25 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 26 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 27 crawl crawl VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 28 their -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 29 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 30 pages page NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 31 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 32 that that IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 33 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 34 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 35 engines engine NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 36 bring bring VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 37 traffic traffic NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 38 back back RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 39 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 40 them -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 54 41 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 1 From from IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 2 this this DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 3 perspective perspective NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 4 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 5 being be VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 6 ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 7 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 8 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 9 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 10 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 11 means mean VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 12 bringing bring VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 13 more more JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 14 visits visit NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 15 back back RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 16 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 17 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 18 crawled crawled JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 19 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 55 20 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 2 effective effective JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 3 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 4 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 5 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 6 engine engine NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 7 S s NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 8 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 9 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 10 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 11 can can MD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 12 be be VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 13 defined define VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 14 as as IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 15 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 16 ratio ratio NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 17 between between IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 18 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 19 user user NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 20 visits visit NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 21 referred refer VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 22 by by IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 23 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 24 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 25 engine engine NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 26 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 27 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 28 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 29 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 30 visits visit NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 31 generated generate VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 32 by by IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 33 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 34 crawler crawler NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 35 r r NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 36 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 37 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 38 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 39 engine engine NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 40 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 41 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 42 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 43 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 44 see see VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 45 Eq Eq NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 56 46 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 57 1 3 3 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 57 2 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 57 3 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 1 Eeffective(r eeffective(r ADD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 2 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 3 = = NFP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 4 Referenced(S Referenced(S NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 5 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 6 Crawled(r crawled(r NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 7 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 8 ( ( -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 9 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 10 ) ) -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 11 4 4 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 58 12 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 1 EXPERIMENTS EXPERIMENTS NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 2 Rank Rank NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 3 User user NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 4 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 5 agent agent NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 6 Content Content NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 7 Ethicality Ethicality NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 8 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 9 hyperestraier/1.4.9 hyperestraier/1.4.9 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 10 0.95621 0.95621 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 11 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 12 Teemer teemer NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 13 0.01942 0.01942 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 14 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 15 msnbot msnbot NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 16 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 17 media/1.0 media/1.0 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 18 0.00632 0.00632 DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 19 4 4 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 20 Yahoo Yahoo NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 59 21 ! ! . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 1 Slurp Slurp NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 2 0.00417 0.00417 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 3 5 5 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 4 charlotte/1.0b charlotte/1.0b CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 5 0.00394 0.00394 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 6 6 6 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 7 gigabot/3.0 gigabot/3.0 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 8 0.00370 0.00370 IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 9 7 7 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 10 nutch nutch NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 11 test test NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 12 / / SYM clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 13 nutch-0.9 nutch-0.9 NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 14 0.00316 0.00316 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 15 8 8 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 16 googlebot googlebot NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 17 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 18 image/1.0 image/1.0 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 19 0.00315 0.00315 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 20 9 9 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 21 Ask Ask NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 22 Jeeves Jeeves NNPS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 23 / / SYM clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 24 Teoma Teoma NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 25 0.00302 0.00302 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 26 10 10 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 27 googlebot/2.1 googlebot/2.1 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 28 0.00282 0.00282 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 29 Table table NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 30 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 31 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 32 Content content NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 33 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 34 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 35 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 36 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 37 vis- vis- NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 38 ited ite VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 39 our -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 40 test test NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 41 site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 60 42 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 1 Table table NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 2 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 3 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 4 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 5 list list NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 6 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 7 content content NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 8 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 9 access access NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 10 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 11 results result NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 12 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 13 top top JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 14 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 15 that that WDT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 16 visited visit VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 17 our -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 18 test test NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 19 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 20 during during IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 21 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 22 time time NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 23 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 24 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 25 study study NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 61 26 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 62 1 Higher high JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 62 2 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 62 3 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 62 4 represent represent VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 62 5 unethical unethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 62 6 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 62 7 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 2 effective effective JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 3 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 4 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 5 Google Google NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 6 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 7 Yahoo Yahoo NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 8 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 9 MSN MSN NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 10 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 11 Baidu Baidu NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 12 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 13 shown show VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 14 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 15 Table table NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 16 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 63 17 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 2 data data NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 3 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 4 collected collect VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 5 between between IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 6 2008/05/13 2008/05/13 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 7 Rank Rank NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 8 User User NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 9 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 10 agent agent NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 11 Access Access NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 12 Ethicality Ethicality NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 13 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 14 msnbot msnbot NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 15 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 16 media/1.0 media/1.0 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 17 0.3317 0.3317 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 18 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 19 hyperestraier/1.4.9 hyperestraier/1.4.9 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 20 0.3278 0.3278 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 21 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 22 Yahoo Yahoo NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 64 23 ! ! . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 1 Slurp/3.0 Slurp/3.0 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 2 0.2949 0.2949 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 3 4 4 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 4 Teemer Teemer NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 5 0.2744 0.2744 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 6 5 5 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 7 Arietis Arietis NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 8 / / SYM clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 9 Nutch-0.9 Nutch-0.9 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 10 0.0984 0.0984 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 11 6 6 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 12 msnbot/1.0 msnbot/1.0 NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 13 0.098 0.098 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 14 7 7 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 15 disco disco NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 16 / / SYM clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 17 Nutch-1.0-dev Nutch-1.0-dev NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 18 0.0776 0.0776 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 19 8 8 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 20 ia ia NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 21 archiver archiver NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 22 0.077 0.077 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 23 9 9 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 24 gigabot/3.0 gigabot/3.0 $ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 25 0.0079 0.0079 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 26 10 10 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 27 googlebot/2.1 googlebot/2.1 NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 28 0.0075 0.0075 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 29 Table table NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 30 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 31 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 32 Access access NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 33 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 34 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 35 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 36 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 37 visited visit VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 38 our -PRON- PRP$ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 39 test test NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 40 site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 65 41 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 66 1 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 66 2 2008/06/21 2008/06/21 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 66 3 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 1 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 2 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 3 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 4 CiteSeerx CiteSeerx NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 5 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 6 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 7 large large JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 8 scale scale NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 9 academic academic JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 10 digital digital JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 11 library library NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 12 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 13 computer computer NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 14 science science NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 67 15 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 1 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 2 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 3 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 4 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 5 Chinese chinese JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 6 movie movie NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 7 information information NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 8 website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 68 9 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 1 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 2 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 3 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 4 guopi.com guopi.com ADD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 5 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 6 an an DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 7 online online JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 8 makeup makeup NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 9 retail retail JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 10 store store NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 69 11 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 70 1 5 5 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 70 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 1 CONCLUSIONS conclusion NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 2 We -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 3 formally formally RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 4 defined define VBD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 5 three three CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 6 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 7 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 8 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 9 measure measure VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 10 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 11 crawler crawler NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 12 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 71 13 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 1 Results result NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 2 show show VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 3 that that IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 4 most most JJS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 5 commercial commercial JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 6 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 7 receive receive VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 8 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 9 good good JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 10 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 11 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 72 12 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 1 However however RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 2 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 3 it -PRON- PRP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 4 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 5 surprising surprising JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 6 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 7 see see VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 8 commercial commercial JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 9 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 10 constantly constantly RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 11 disobeying disobey VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 12 or or CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 13 misin- misin- JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 14 terpreting terprete VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 15 some some DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 16 robots.txt robots.txt CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 17 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 73 18 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 2 crawling crawl VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 3 algorithms algorithm NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 4 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 5 policies policy NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 6 that that WDT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 7 lead lead VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 8 to to IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 9 such such JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 10 behaviors behavior NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 11 are be VBP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 12 unknown unknown JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 74 13 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 1 How- How- NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 2 ever ever RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 3 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 4 obtaining obtain VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 5 more more JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 6 content content NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 7 is be VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 8 an an DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 9 obvious obvious JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 10 reason reason NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 11 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 12 most most JJS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 13 crawlers crawler NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 14 failing fail VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 15 to to TO clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 16 obey obey VB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 17 certain certain JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 18 rules rule NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 75 19 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 1 Website website NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 2 Crawled Crawled NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 3 Referenced Referenced NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 4 Ereturn Ereturn NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 5 google google NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 6 Site Site NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 7 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 8 16799253 16799253 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 9 260898 260898 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 10 0.01553 0.01553 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 11 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 12 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 13 872001 872001 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 14 46469 46469 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 15 0.05329 0.05329 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 16 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 17 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 18 368417 368417 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 19 145115 145115 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 20 0.39389 0.39389 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 21 yahoo yahoo NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 22 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 23 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 24 17375962 17375962 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 25 3919 3919 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 26 0.00023 0.00023 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 27 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 28 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 29 502584 502584 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 30 1249 1249 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 31 0.00249 0.00249 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 32 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 33 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 34 315119 315119 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 35 11819 11819 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 36 0.03751 0.03751 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 37 msn msn NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 38 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 39 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 40 677181 677181 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 41 362 362 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 42 0.00054 0.00054 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 43 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 44 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 45 16330 16330 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 46 5448 5448 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 47 0.33362 0.33362 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 48 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 49 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 50 51128 51128 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 51 3801 3801 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 52 0.07434 0.07434 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 53 baidu baidu JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 54 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 55 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 56 27 27 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 57 37 37 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 58 1.37037 1.37037 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 59 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 60 2 2 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 61 622667 622667 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 62 61964 61964 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 63 0.09951 0.09951 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 64 Site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 65 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 66 1830847 1830847 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 67 844786 844786 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 68 0.46142 0.46142 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 69 Table table NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 70 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 71 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 72 Comparison comparison NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 73 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 74 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 75 effectiveness effectiveness NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 76 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 77 Google Google NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 78 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 79 Yahoo Yahoo NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 80 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 81 MSN MSN NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 82 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 83 Baidu Baidu NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 76 84 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 1 The the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 2 effective effective JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 3 ethicality ethicality NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 4 scores score NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 5 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 6 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 7 engines engine NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 8 varies vary VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 9 sig- sig- RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 10 nificantly nificantly RB clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 11 for for IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 12 different different JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 13 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 77 14 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 1 Ranking rank VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 2 by by IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 3 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 4 referenced referenced JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 5 visits visit NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 6 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 7 Google Google NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 8 plays play VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 9 a a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 10 dominating dominating JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 11 role role NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 12 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 13 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 14 US US NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 15 based base VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 16 site site NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 17 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 18 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 19 ranks rank VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 20 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 21 2nd 2nd JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 22 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 23 3rd 3rd NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 24 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 25 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 26 two two CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 27 China China NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 28 based base VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 29 websites website NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 78 30 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 1 Baidu Baidu NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 2 leads lead VBZ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 3 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 4 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 5 search search NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 6 market market NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 7 in in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 8 China China NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 79 9 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 80 1 6 6 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 80 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 81 1 REFERENCES reference NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 81 2 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 81 3 1 1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 81 4 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 81 5 D. D. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 81 6 Eichmann Eichmann NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 81 7 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 82 1 Ethical ethical JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 82 2 web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 82 3 agents agent NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 82 4 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 1 Computer Computer NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 2 Networks Networks NNPS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 3 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 4 ISDN ISDN NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 5 Systems Systems NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 6 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 7 28(1 28(1 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 8 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 9 2):127–136 2):127–136 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 10 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 11 1995 1995 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 83 12 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 1 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 2 2 2 LS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 3 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 4 S. S. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 5 Kolay Kolay NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 6 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 7 P. P. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 8 D’Alberto D’Alberto NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 9 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 10 A. A. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 11 Dasdan Dasdan NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 12 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 13 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 14 A. A. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 15 Bhattacharjee Bhattacharjee NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 84 16 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 85 1 A a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 85 2 larger large JJR clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 85 3 scale scale NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 85 4 study study NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 85 5 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 85 6 robots.txt robots.txt NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 85 7 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 1 In in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 2 WWW WWW NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 3 ’ ' '' clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 4 08 08 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 5 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 6 Proceeding proceed VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 7 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 8 the the DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 9 17th 17th JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 10 international international JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 11 conference conference NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 12 on on IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 13 World World NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 14 Wide Wide NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 15 Web Web NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 16 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 17 pages page NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 18 1171–1172 1171–1172 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 19 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 20 New New NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 21 York York NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 22 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 23 NY NY NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 24 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 25 USA USA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 26 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 27 2008 2008 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 86 28 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 87 1 ACM ACM NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 87 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 88 1 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 88 2 3 3 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 88 3 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 88 4 Y. y. NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 1 Sun Sun NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 2 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 3 Z. Z. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 4 Zhuang Zhuang NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 5 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 6 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 7 C. C. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 8 L. L. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 9 Giles Giles NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 89 10 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 1 A a DT clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 2 large large JJ clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 3 - - HYPH clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 4 scale scale NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 5 study study NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 6 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 7 robots.txt robots.txt NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 90 8 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 91 1 In in IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 91 2 WWW WWW NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 91 3 ’ ' '' clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 91 4 07 07 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 91 5 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 91 6 2007 2007 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 91 7 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 1 [ [ -LRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 2 4 4 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 3 ] ] -RRB- clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 4 M. M. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 5 Thelwall Thelwall NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 6 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 7 D. D. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 8 Stuart Stuart NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 92 9 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 1 Web web NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 2 crawling crawl VBG clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 3 ethics ethic NNS clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 4 revisited revisit VBN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 5 : : : clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 6 Cost cost NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 7 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 8 privacy privacy NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 9 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 10 and and CC clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 11 denial denial NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 12 of of IN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 13 service service NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 93 14 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 94 1 J. J. NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 95 1 Am Am NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 95 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 96 1 Soc Soc NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 96 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 97 1 Inf inf NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 97 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 98 1 Sci Sci NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 98 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 1 Technol Technol NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 2 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 3 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 4 57(13):1771–1779 57(13):1771–1779 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 5 , , , clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 6 November November NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 7 2006 2006 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 99 8 . . . clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 1 WWW WWW NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 2 2010 2010 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 3 • • NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 4 Poster poster NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 5 April April NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 6 26 26 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 7 - - SYM clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 8 30 30 CD clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 9 • • NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 10 Raleigh Raleigh NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 11 • • NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 12 NC NC NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 13 • • NN clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 14 USA USA NNP clgiles-ist-psu-edu-8875 100 15 1102 1102 CD