id sid tid token lemma pos 40288 1 1 images image NNS 40288 1 2 of of IN 40288 1 3 public public JJ 40288 1 4 domain domain NN 40288 1 5 material material NN 40288 1 6 from from IN 40288 1 7 the the DT 40288 1 8 Google Google NNP 40288 1 9 Print Print NNP 40288 1 10 project project NN 40288 1 11 . . . 40288 1 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 2 1 THE the DT 40288 2 2 MODES MODES NNP 40288 2 3 OF of IN 40288 2 4 ANCIENT ANCIENT NNP 40288 2 5 GREEK GREEK NNP 40288 2 6 MUSIC MUSIC NNP 40288 2 7 _ _ NNP 40288 2 8 MONRO MONRO NNP 40288 2 9 _ _ NNP 40288 2 10 London London NNP 40288 2 11 HENRY HENRY NNP 40288 2 12 FROWDE FROWDE VBD 40288 2 13 OXFORD oxford NN 40288 2 14 UNIVERSITY university NN 40288 2 15 PRESS press NN 40288 2 16 WAREHOUSE WAREHOUSE MD 40288 2 17 AMEN AMEN NNP 40288 2 18 CORNER CORNER NNP 40288 2 19 , , , 40288 2 20 E.C. E.C. NNP 40288 3 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 3 2 Illustration illustration NN 40288 3 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 3 4 New New NNP 40288 3 5 York York NNP 40288 3 6 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 40288 3 7 & & CC 40288 3 8 CO CO NNP 40288 3 9 . . NNP 40288 3 10 , , , 40288 3 11 66 66 CD 40288 3 12 , , , 40288 3 13 FIFTH FIFTH NNP 40288 3 14 AVENUE AVENUE NNP 40288 3 15 _ _ NNP 40288 3 16 The the DT 40288 3 17 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 3 18 of of IN 40288 3 19 Ancient Ancient NNP 40288 3 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 3 21 Music Music NNP 40288 3 22 _ _ NNP 40288 3 23 BY by IN 40288 3 24 D. D. NNP 40288 3 25 B. B. NNP 40288 3 26 MONRO MONRO NNP 40288 3 27 , , , 40288 3 28 M.A. M.A. NNP 40288 4 1 PROVOST PROVOST NNP 40288 4 2 OF of IN 40288 4 3 ORIEL ORIEL NNP 40288 4 4 COLLEGE COLLEGE NNP 40288 4 5 , , , 40288 4 6 OXFORD OXFORD NNP 40288 4 7 HONORARY HONORARY NNP 40288 4 8 DOCTOR DOCTOR NNP 40288 4 9 OF of IN 40288 4 10 LETTERS letter NNS 40288 4 11 IN in IN 40288 4 12 THE the DT 40288 4 13 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 40288 4 14 OF of IN 40288 4 15 DUBLIN DUBLIN NNP 40288 4 16 Oxford Oxford NNP 40288 4 17 AT AT NNP 40288 4 18 THE the DT 40288 4 19 CLARENDON clarendon NN 40288 4 20 PRESS press NN 40288 4 21 1894 1894 CD 40288 4 22 Oxford Oxford NNP 40288 4 23 PRINTED PRINTED NNP 40288 4 24 AT AT NNP 40288 4 25 THE the DT 40288 4 26 CLARENDON clarendon NN 40288 4 27 PRESS press NN 40288 4 28 BY by IN 40288 4 29 HORACE HORACE NNP 40288 4 30 HART HART NNP 40288 4 31 , , , 40288 4 32 PRINTER PRINTER NNP 40288 4 33 TO to IN 40288 4 34 THE the DT 40288 4 35 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 40288 4 36 DEDICATED dedicate VBN 40288 4 37 TO to IN 40288 4 38 THE the DT 40288 4 39 PROVOST PROVOST NNS 40288 4 40 AND and CC 40288 4 41 FELLOWS fellows NN 40288 4 42 OF of IN 40288 4 43 TRINITY trinity NN 40288 4 44 COLLEGE college NN 40288 4 45 DUBLIN DUBLIN NNS 40288 4 46 [ [ -LRB- 40288 4 47 Greek Greek NNP 40288 4 48 : : : 40288 4 49 xeinosynês xeinosynês NNP 40288 4 50 heneka heneka NN 40288 4 51 ] ] -RRB- 40288 4 52 [ [ -LRB- 40288 4 53 Blank Blank NNP 40288 4 54 Page Page NNP 40288 4 55 ] ] -RRB- 40288 4 56 PREFACE preface VB 40288 4 57 The the DT 40288 4 58 present present JJ 40288 4 59 essay essay NN 40288 4 60 is be VBZ 40288 4 61 the the DT 40288 4 62 sequel sequel NN 40288 4 63 of of IN 40288 4 64 an an DT 40288 4 65 article article NN 40288 4 66 on on IN 40288 4 67 Greek greek JJ 40288 4 68 music music NN 40288 4 69 which which WDT 40288 4 70 the the DT 40288 4 71 author author NN 40288 4 72 contributed contribute VBD 40288 4 73 to to IN 40288 4 74 the the DT 40288 4 75 new new JJ 40288 4 76 edition edition NN 40288 4 77 of of IN 40288 4 78 _ _ NNP 40288 4 79 Smith Smith NNP 40288 4 80 's 's POS 40288 4 81 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 40288 4 82 of of IN 40288 4 83 Greek Greek NNP 40288 4 84 and and CC 40288 4 85 Roman Roman NNP 40288 4 86 Antiquities Antiquities NNPS 40288 4 87 _ _ NNP 40288 4 88 ( ( -LRB- 40288 4 89 London London NNP 40288 4 90 , , , 40288 4 91 1890 1890 CD 40288 4 92 - - SYM 40288 4 93 91 91 CD 40288 4 94 , , , 40288 4 95 art art NN 40288 4 96 . . . 40288 5 1 MUSICA MUSICA NNP 40288 5 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 5 3 . . . 40288 6 1 In in IN 40288 6 2 that that DT 40288 6 3 article article NN 40288 6 4 the the DT 40288 6 5 long long RB 40288 6 6 - - HYPH 40288 6 7 standing stand VBG 40288 6 8 controversy controversy NN 40288 6 9 regarding regard VBG 40288 6 10 the the DT 40288 6 11 nature nature NN 40288 6 12 of of IN 40288 6 13 the the DT 40288 6 14 ancient ancient JJ 40288 6 15 musical musical JJ 40288 6 16 Modes Modes NNP 40288 6 17 was be VBD 40288 6 18 briefly briefly RB 40288 6 19 noticed notice VBN 40288 6 20 , , , 40288 6 21 and and CC 40288 6 22 some some DT 40288 6 23 reasons reason NNS 40288 6 24 were be VBD 40288 6 25 given give VBN 40288 6 26 for for IN 40288 6 27 dissenting dissent VBG 40288 6 28 from from IN 40288 6 29 the the DT 40288 6 30 views view NNS 40288 6 31 maintained maintain VBN 40288 6 32 by by IN 40288 6 33 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 6 34 , , , 40288 6 35 and and CC 40288 6 36 now now RB 40288 6 37 very very RB 40288 6 38 generally generally RB 40288 6 39 accepted accept VBN 40288 6 40 . . . 40288 7 1 A a DT 40288 7 2 full full JJ 40288 7 3 discussion discussion NN 40288 7 4 of of IN 40288 7 5 the the DT 40288 7 6 subject subject NN 40288 7 7 would would MD 40288 7 8 have have VB 40288 7 9 taken take VBN 40288 7 10 up up RP 40288 7 11 more more JJR 40288 7 12 space space NN 40288 7 13 than than IN 40288 7 14 was be VBD 40288 7 15 then then RB 40288 7 16 at at IN 40288 7 17 the the DT 40288 7 18 author author NN 40288 7 19 's 's POS 40288 7 20 disposal disposal NN 40288 7 21 , , , 40288 7 22 and and CC 40288 7 23 he -PRON- PRP 40288 7 24 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 7 25 proposed propose VBD 40288 7 26 to to IN 40288 7 27 the the DT 40288 7 28 Delegates Delegates NNPS 40288 7 29 of of IN 40288 7 30 the the DT 40288 7 31 Clarendon Clarendon NNP 40288 7 32 Press Press NNP 40288 7 33 to to TO 40288 7 34 treat treat VB 40288 7 35 the the DT 40288 7 36 question question NN 40288 7 37 in in IN 40288 7 38 a a DT 40288 7 39 separate separate JJ 40288 7 40 form form NN 40288 7 41 . . . 40288 8 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 8 2 has have VBZ 40288 8 3 now now RB 40288 8 4 to to TO 40288 8 5 thank thank VB 40288 8 6 them -PRON- PRP 40288 8 7 for for IN 40288 8 8 undertaking undertake VBG 40288 8 9 the the DT 40288 8 10 publication publication NN 40288 8 11 of of IN 40288 8 12 a a DT 40288 8 13 work work NN 40288 8 14 which which WDT 40288 8 15 is be VBZ 40288 8 16 necessarily necessarily RB 40288 8 17 addressed address VBN 40288 8 18 to to IN 40288 8 19 a a DT 40288 8 20 very very RB 40288 8 21 limited limited JJ 40288 8 22 circle circle NN 40288 8 23 . . . 40288 9 1 The the DT 40288 9 2 progress progress NN 40288 9 3 of of IN 40288 9 4 the the DT 40288 9 5 work work NN 40288 9 6 has have VBZ 40288 9 7 been be VBN 40288 9 8 more more JJR 40288 9 9 than than IN 40288 9 10 once once RB 40288 9 11 delayed delay VBN 40288 9 12 by by IN 40288 9 13 the the DT 40288 9 14 accession accession NN 40288 9 15 of of IN 40288 9 16 materials material NNS 40288 9 17 . . . 40288 10 1 Much much JJ 40288 10 2 of of IN 40288 10 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 10 4 was be VBD 40288 10 5 written write VBN 40288 10 6 before before IN 40288 10 7 the the DT 40288 10 8 author author NN 40288 10 9 had have VBD 40288 10 10 the the DT 40288 10 11 opportunity opportunity NN 40288 10 12 of of IN 40288 10 13 studying study VBG 40288 10 14 two two CD 40288 10 15 very very RB 40288 10 16 interesting interesting JJ 40288 10 17 documents document NNS 40288 10 18 first first RB 40288 10 19 made make VBN 40288 10 20 known known JJ 40288 10 21 in in IN 40288 10 22 the the DT 40288 10 23 course course NN 40288 10 24 of of IN 40288 10 25 last last JJ 40288 10 26 year year NN 40288 10 27 in in IN 40288 10 28 the the DT 40288 10 29 _ _ NNP 40288 10 30 Bulletin Bulletin NNP 40288 10 31 de de IN 40288 10 32 correspondance correspondance NN 40288 10 33 hellénique hellénique NNP 40288 10 34 _ _ NNP 40288 10 35 and and CC 40288 10 36 the the DT 40288 10 37 _ _ NNP 40288 10 38 Philologus Philologus NNP 40288 10 39 _ _ NNP 40288 10 40 , , , 40288 10 41 viz viz NN 40288 10 42 . . . 40288 11 1 the the DT 40288 11 2 so so RB 40288 11 3 - - HYPH 40288 11 4 called call VBN 40288 11 5 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 11 6 inscription inscription NN 40288 11 7 from from IN 40288 11 8 Tralles Tralles NNPS 40288 11 9 , , , 40288 11 10 and and CC 40288 11 11 a a DT 40288 11 12 fragment fragment NN 40288 11 13 of of IN 40288 11 14 the the DT 40288 11 15 _ _ NNP 40288 11 16 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 11 17 _ _ NNP 40288 11 18 of of IN 40288 11 19 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 11 20 . . . 40288 12 1 But but CC 40288 12 2 a a DT 40288 12 3 much much RB 40288 12 4 greater great JJR 40288 12 5 surprise surprise NN 40288 12 6 was be VBD 40288 12 7 in in IN 40288 12 8 store store NN 40288 12 9 . . . 40288 13 1 The the DT 40288 13 2 book book NN 40288 13 3 was be VBD 40288 13 4 nearly nearly RB 40288 13 5 ready ready JJ 40288 13 6 for for IN 40288 13 7 publication publication NN 40288 13 8 last last JJ 40288 13 9 November November NNP 40288 13 10 , , , 40288 13 11 when when WRB 40288 13 12 the the DT 40288 13 13 newspapers newspaper NNS 40288 13 14 reported report VBD 40288 13 15 that that IN 40288 13 16 the the DT 40288 13 17 French french JJ 40288 13 18 scholars scholar NNS 40288 13 19 engaged engage VBD 40288 13 20 in in IN 40288 13 21 excavating excavating NN 40288 13 22 on on IN 40288 13 23 the the DT 40288 13 24 site site NN 40288 13 25 of of IN 40288 13 26 Delphi Delphi NNP 40288 13 27 had have VBD 40288 13 28 found find VBN 40288 13 29 several several JJ 40288 13 30 pieces piece NNS 40288 13 31 of of IN 40288 13 32 musical musical JJ 40288 13 33 notation notation NN 40288 13 34 , , , 40288 13 35 in in IN 40288 13 36 particular particular JJ 40288 13 37 a a DT 40288 13 38 hymn hymn NN 40288 13 39 to to IN 40288 13 40 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 13 41 dating date VBG 40288 13 42 from from IN 40288 13 43 the the DT 40288 13 44 third third JJ 40288 13 45 century century NN 40288 13 46 B.C. B.C. NNP 40288 14 1 As as IN 40288 14 2 the the DT 40288 14 3 known know VBN 40288 14 4 remains remain NNS 40288 14 5 of of IN 40288 14 6 Greek greek JJ 40288 14 7 music music NN 40288 14 8 were be VBD 40288 14 9 either either CC 40288 14 10 miserably miserably RB 40288 14 11 brief brief JJ 40288 14 12 , , , 40288 14 13 or or CC 40288 14 14 so so RB 40288 14 15 late late RB 40288 14 16 as as IN 40288 14 17 hardly hardly RB 40288 14 18 to to TO 40288 14 19 belong belong VB 40288 14 20 to to IN 40288 14 21 classical classical JJ 40288 14 22 antiquity antiquity NN 40288 14 23 , , , 40288 14 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 14 25 was be VBD 40288 14 26 thought think VBN 40288 14 27 best well RBS 40288 14 28 to to TO 40288 14 29 wait wait VB 40288 14 30 for for IN 40288 14 31 the the DT 40288 14 32 publication publication NN 40288 14 33 of of IN 40288 14 34 the the DT 40288 14 35 new new JJ 40288 14 36 material material NN 40288 14 37 . . . 40288 15 1 The the DT 40288 15 2 French French NNP 40288 15 3 School School NNP 40288 15 4 of of IN 40288 15 5 Athens Athens NNP 40288 15 6 must must MD 40288 15 7 be be VB 40288 15 8 congratulated congratulate VBN 40288 15 9 upon upon IN 40288 15 10 the the DT 40288 15 11 good good JJ 40288 15 12 fortune fortune NN 40288 15 13 which which WDT 40288 15 14 has have VBZ 40288 15 15 attended attend VBN 40288 15 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 15 17 enterprise enterprise NN 40288 15 18 , , , 40288 15 19 and and CC 40288 15 20 also also RB 40288 15 21 upon upon IN 40288 15 22 the the DT 40288 15 23 excellent excellent JJ 40288 15 24 form form NN 40288 15 25 in in IN 40288 15 26 which which WDT 40288 15 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 15 28 results result NNS 40288 15 29 have have VBP 40288 15 30 been be VBN 40288 15 31 placed place VBN 40288 15 32 , , , 40288 15 33 within within IN 40288 15 34 a a DT 40288 15 35 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 15 36 short short JJ 40288 15 37 time time NN 40288 15 38 , , , 40288 15 39 at at IN 40288 15 40 the the DT 40288 15 41 service service NN 40288 15 42 of of IN 40288 15 43 students student NNS 40288 15 44 . . . 40288 16 1 The the DT 40288 16 2 writer writer NN 40288 16 3 of of IN 40288 16 4 these these DT 40288 16 5 pages page NNS 40288 16 6 , , , 40288 16 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 16 8 will will MD 40288 16 9 be be VB 40288 16 10 readily readily RB 40288 16 11 understood understand VBN 40288 16 12 , , , 40288 16 13 had have VBD 40288 16 14 especial especial JJ 40288 16 15 reason reason NN 40288 16 16 to to TO 40288 16 17 be be VB 40288 16 18 interested interested JJ 40288 16 19 in in IN 40288 16 20 the the DT 40288 16 21 announcement announcement NN 40288 16 22 of of IN 40288 16 23 a a DT 40288 16 24 discovery discovery NN 40288 16 25 which which WDT 40288 16 26 might may MD 40288 16 27 give give VB 40288 16 28 an an DT 40288 16 29 entirely entirely RB 40288 16 30 new new JJ 40288 16 31 complexion complexion NN 40288 16 32 to to IN 40288 16 33 the the DT 40288 16 34 whole whole JJ 40288 16 35 argument argument NN 40288 16 36 . . . 40288 17 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 17 2 will will MD 40288 17 3 be be VB 40288 17 4 for for IN 40288 17 5 the the DT 40288 17 6 reader reader NN 40288 17 7 to to TO 40288 17 8 determine determine VB 40288 17 9 whether whether IN 40288 17 10 the the DT 40288 17 11 main main JJ 40288 17 12 thesis thesis NN 40288 17 13 of of IN 40288 17 14 the the DT 40288 17 15 book book NN 40288 17 16 has have VBZ 40288 17 17 gained gain VBN 40288 17 18 or or CC 40288 17 19 lost lose VBN 40288 17 20 by by IN 40288 17 21 the the DT 40288 17 22 new new JJ 40288 17 23 evidence evidence NN 40288 17 24 . . . 40288 18 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 18 2 Hubert Hubert NNP 40288 18 3 Parry Parry NNP 40288 18 4 prefaces preface VBZ 40288 18 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 18 6 suggestive suggestive JJ 40288 18 7 treatment treatment NN 40288 18 8 of of IN 40288 18 9 Greek greek JJ 40288 18 10 music music NN 40288 18 11 by by IN 40288 18 12 some some DT 40288 18 13 remarks remark NNS 40288 18 14 on on IN 40288 18 15 the the DT 40288 18 16 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 18 17 of of IN 40288 18 18 the the DT 40288 18 19 subject subject NN 40288 18 20 . . . 40288 19 1 ' ' `` 40288 19 2 It -PRON- PRP 40288 19 3 still still RB 40288 19 4 seems seem VBZ 40288 19 5 possible possible JJ 40288 19 6 , , , 40288 19 7 ' ' '' 40288 19 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 19 9 observes observe VBZ 40288 19 10 , , , 40288 19 11 ' ' '' 40288 19 12 that that IN 40288 19 13 a a DT 40288 19 14 large large JJ 40288 19 15 portion portion NN 40288 19 16 of of IN 40288 19 17 what what WP 40288 19 18 has have VBZ 40288 19 19 passed pass VBN 40288 19 20 into into IN 40288 19 21 the the DT 40288 19 22 domain domain NN 40288 19 23 of of IN 40288 19 24 " " `` 40288 19 25 well well RB 40288 19 26 - - HYPH 40288 19 27 authenticated authenticate VBN 40288 19 28 fact fact NN 40288 19 29 " " `` 40288 19 30 is be VBZ 40288 19 31 complete complete JJ 40288 19 32 misapprehension misapprehension NN 40288 19 33 , , , 40288 19 34 as as IN 40288 19 35 Greek greek JJ 40288 19 36 scholars scholar NNS 40288 19 37 have have VBP 40288 19 38 not not RB 40288 19 39 time time NN 40288 19 40 for for IN 40288 19 41 a a DT 40288 19 42 thorough thorough JJ 40288 19 43 study study NN 40288 19 44 of of IN 40288 19 45 music music NN 40288 19 46 up up IN 40288 19 47 to to IN 40288 19 48 the the DT 40288 19 49 standard standard NN 40288 19 50 required require VBN 40288 19 51 to to TO 40288 19 52 judge judge VB 40288 19 53 securely securely RB 40288 19 54 of of IN 40288 19 55 the the DT 40288 19 56 matters matter NNS 40288 19 57 in in IN 40288 19 58 question question NN 40288 19 59 , , , 40288 19 60 and and CC 40288 19 61 musicians musician NNS 40288 19 62 as as IN 40288 19 63 a a DT 40288 19 64 rule rule NN 40288 19 65 are be VBP 40288 19 66 not not RB 40288 19 67 extremely extremely RB 40288 19 68 intimate intimate JJ 40288 19 69 with with IN 40288 19 70 Greek Greek NNP 40288 19 71 ' ' '' 40288 19 72 ( ( -LRB- 40288 19 73 _ _ NNP 40288 19 74 The the DT 40288 19 75 Art Art NNP 40288 19 76 of of IN 40288 19 77 Music Music NNP 40288 19 78 _ _ NNP 40288 19 79 , , , 40288 19 80 p. p. NN 40288 19 81 24 24 CD 40288 19 82 ) ) -RRB- 40288 19 83 . . . 40288 20 1 To to IN 40288 20 2 the the DT 40288 20 3 present present JJ 40288 20 4 writer writer NN 40288 20 5 , , , 40288 20 6 who who WP 40288 20 7 has have VBZ 40288 20 8 no no DT 40288 20 9 claim claim NN 40288 20 10 to to IN 40288 20 11 the the DT 40288 20 12 title title NN 40288 20 13 of of IN 40288 20 14 musician musician NN 40288 20 15 , , , 40288 20 16 the the DT 40288 20 17 scepticism scepticism NN 40288 20 18 expressed express VBN 40288 20 19 in in IN 40288 20 20 these these DT 40288 20 21 words word NNS 40288 20 22 appears appear VBZ 40288 20 23 to to TO 40288 20 24 be be VB 40288 20 25 well well RB 40288 20 26 founded found VBN 40288 20 27 . . . 40288 21 1 If if IN 40288 21 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 21 3 interpretation interpretation NN 40288 21 4 of of IN 40288 21 5 the the DT 40288 21 6 ancient ancient JJ 40288 21 7 texts text NNS 40288 21 8 furnishes furnish VBZ 40288 21 9 musicians musician NNS 40288 21 10 like like IN 40288 21 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 21 12 Parry Parry NNP 40288 21 13 with with IN 40288 21 14 a a DT 40288 21 15 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 21 16 more more RBR 40288 21 17 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 40288 21 18 basis basis NN 40288 21 19 for for IN 40288 21 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 21 21 criticism criticism NN 40288 21 22 of of IN 40288 21 23 Greek greek JJ 40288 21 24 music music NN 40288 21 25 as as IN 40288 21 26 an an DT 40288 21 27 art art NN 40288 21 28 , , , 40288 21 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 21 30 object object NN 40288 21 31 will will MD 40288 21 32 be be VB 40288 21 33 fully fully RB 40288 21 34 attained attain VBN 40288 21 35 . . . 40288 22 1 TABLE TABLE NNS 40288 22 2 OF of IN 40288 22 3 CONTENTS content NNS 40288 22 4 § § CD 40288 22 5 1 1 CD 40288 22 6 . . . 40288 23 1 _ _ NNP 40288 23 2 Introductory Introductory NNP 40288 23 3 . . . 40288 23 4 _ _ NNP 40288 23 5 PAGE PAGE NNP 40288 23 6 Musical musical JJ 40288 23 7 forms form NNS 40288 23 8 called call VBD 40288 23 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 23 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 23 11 : : : 40288 23 12 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 23 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 23 14 or or CC 40288 23 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 23 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 23 17 : : : 40288 23 18 tropoi tropoi NNP 40288 23 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 23 20 1 1 CD 40288 23 21 § § CD 40288 23 22 2 2 CD 40288 23 23 . . . 40288 24 1 _ _ NNP 40288 24 2 Statement Statement NNP 40288 24 3 of of IN 40288 24 4 the the DT 40288 24 5 question question NN 40288 24 6 . . . 40288 24 7 _ _ NNP 40288 24 8 The the DT 40288 24 9 terms term NNS 40288 24 10 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 24 11 , , , 40288 24 12 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 24 13 , , , 40288 24 14 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 24 15 , , , 40288 24 16 & & CC 40288 24 17 c. c. NNP 40288 24 18 3 3 CD 40288 24 19 § § CD 40288 24 20 3 3 CD 40288 24 21 . . . 40288 25 1 _ _ NNP 40288 25 2 The the DT 40288 25 3 Authorities Authorities NNPS 40288 25 4 . . . 40288 25 5 _ _ NNP 40288 25 6 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 25 7 -- -- : 40288 25 8 Plato Plato NNP 40288 25 9 -- -- : 40288 25 10 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 25 11 -- -- . 40288 25 12 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 25 13 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 25 14 -- -- : 40288 25 15 the the DT 40288 25 16 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 25 17 _ _ NNP 40288 25 18 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 25 19 _ _ NNP 40288 25 20 4 4 CD 40288 25 21 § § CD 40288 25 22 4 4 CD 40288 25 23 . . . 40288 26 1 _ _ NNP 40288 26 2 The the DT 40288 26 3 Early early JJ 40288 26 4 Poets Poets NNPS 40288 26 5 . . . 40288 26 6 _ _ NNP 40288 26 7 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 26 8 -- -- : 40288 26 9 Telestes Telestes NNP 40288 26 10 -- -- : 40288 26 11 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40288 26 12 5 5 CD 40288 26 13 § § CD 40288 26 14 5 5 CD 40288 26 15 . . . 40288 27 1 _ _ NNP 40288 27 2 Plato Plato NNP 40288 27 3 . . . 40288 27 4 _ _ NNP 40288 27 5 The the DT 40288 27 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 27 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 27 8 : : : 40288 27 9 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 27 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 27 11 in in IN 40288 27 12 the the DT 40288 27 13 _ _ NNP 40288 27 14 Republic_--The Republic_--The NNP 40288 27 15 _ _ NNP 40288 27 16 Laches Laches NNP 40288 27 17 _ _ NNP 40288 27 18 7 7 CD 40288 27 19 § § CD 40288 27 20 6 6 CD 40288 27 21 . . . 40288 28 1 _ _ NNP 40288 28 2 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 28 3 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 28 4 . . . 40288 28 5 _ _ NNP 40288 28 6 The the DT 40288 28 7 three three CD 40288 28 8 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 40288 28 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 28 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 28 11 : : : 40288 28 12 harmoniai]--the harmoniai]--the JJ 40288 28 13 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 28 14 and and CC 40288 28 15 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 28 16 -- -- : 40288 28 17 the the DT 40288 28 18 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 28 19 - - HYPH 40288 28 20 dorian dorian NNP 40288 28 21 , , , 40288 28 22 & & CC 40288 28 23 c. c. NNP 40288 28 24 9 9 CD 40288 28 25 § § CD 40288 28 26 7 7 CD 40288 28 27 . . . 40288 29 1 _ _ NNP 40288 29 2 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 29 3 -- -- . 40288 29 4 The the DT 40288 29 5 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 29 6 . . . 40288 29 7 _ _ NNP 40288 29 8 The the DT 40288 29 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 29 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 29 11 : : : 40288 29 12 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 29 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 29 14 in in IN 40288 29 15 the the DT 40288 29 16 _ _ NNP 40288 29 17 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 29 18 _ _ NNP 40288 29 19 12 12 CD 40288 29 20 § § CD 40288 29 21 8 8 CD 40288 29 22 . . . 40288 30 1 _ _ NNP 40288 30 2 The the DT 40288 30 3 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 30 4 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 30 5 . . . 40288 30 6 _ _ NNP 40288 30 7 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 30 8 - - HYPH 40288 30 9 dorian dorian NNP 40288 30 10 and and CC 40288 30 11 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 30 12 - - HYPH 40288 30 13 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 30 14 14 14 CD 40288 30 15 § § CD 40288 30 16 9 9 CD 40288 30 17 . . . 40288 31 1 _ _ NNP 40288 31 2 The the DT 40288 31 3 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40288 31 4 . . . 40288 31 5 _ _ NNP 40288 31 6 The the DT 40288 31 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 31 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 31 9 : : : 40288 31 10 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 31 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 31 12 of of IN 40288 31 13 oratory oratory NNP 40288 31 14 15 15 CD 40288 31 15 § § CD 40288 31 16 10 10 CD 40288 31 17 . . . 40288 32 1 _ _ NNP 40288 32 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 32 3 . . . 40288 32 4 _ _ NNP 40288 32 5 The the DT 40288 32 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 32 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 32 8 : : : 40288 32 9 topoi topoi NNP 40288 32 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 32 11 or or CC 40288 32 12 keys key NNS 40288 32 13 16 16 CD 40288 32 14 § § CD 40288 32 15 11 11 CD 40288 32 16 . . . 40288 33 1 _ _ NNP 40288 33 2 Names Names NNPS 40288 33 3 of of IN 40288 33 4 keys key NNS 40288 33 5 . . . 40288 33 6 _ _ NNP 40288 33 7 The the DT 40288 33 8 prefix prefix JJ 40288 33 9 Hypo- hypo- VB 40288 33 10 --the --the HYPH 40288 33 11 term term NN 40288 33 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 33 13 Greek greek NN 40288 33 14 : : : 40288 33 15 tonos tonos NN 40288 33 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 33 17 19 19 CD 40288 33 18 § § CD 40288 33 19 12 12 CD 40288 33 20 . . . 40288 34 1 _ _ NNP 40288 34 2 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 34 3 's 's POS 40288 34 4 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40288 34 5 on on IN 40288 34 6 Music Music NNP 40288 34 7 . . . 40288 34 8 _ _ NNP 40288 34 9 The the DT 40288 34 10 Platonic Platonic NNP 40288 34 11 modes mode NNS 40288 34 12 -- -- : 40288 34 13 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 34 14 -- -- : 40288 34 15 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 34 16 - - HYPH 40288 34 17 lydian lydian JJ 40288 34 18 and and CC 40288 34 19 Syntono syntono JJ 40288 34 20 - - HYPH 40288 34 21 lydian lydian NNP 40288 34 22 -- -- : 40288 34 23 the the DT 40288 34 24 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 34 25 - - HYPH 40288 34 26 lydian lydian JJ 40288 34 27 octave octave NN 40288 34 28 -- -- : 40288 34 29 the the DT 40288 34 30 keys key NNS 40288 34 31 of of IN 40288 34 32 Sacadas--[Greek Sacadas--[Greek NNP 40288 34 33 : : : 40288 34 34 tonos tonos NN 40288 34 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 34 36 and and CC 40288 34 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 34 38 Greek Greek NNP 40288 34 39 : : : 40288 34 40 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 34 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 34 42 20 20 CD 40288 34 43 § § CD 40288 34 44 13 13 CD 40288 34 45 . . . 40288 35 1 _ _ NNP 40288 35 2 Modes Modes NNP 40288 35 3 employed employ VBN 40288 35 4 on on IN 40288 35 5 different different JJ 40288 35 6 instruments instrument NNS 40288 35 7 . . . 40288 35 8 _ _ NNP 40288 35 9 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 35 10 on on IN 40288 35 11 wind wind NN 40288 35 12 - - HYPH 40288 35 13 instruments instrument NNS 40288 35 14 -- -- : 40288 35 15 on on IN 40288 35 16 the the DT 40288 35 17 water water NN 40288 35 18 - - HYPH 40288 35 19 organ organ NN 40288 35 20 -- -- : 40288 35 21 on on IN 40288 35 22 the the DT 40288 35 23 cithara cithara NNP 40288 35 24 -- -- : 40288 35 25 on on IN 40288 35 26 the the DT 40288 35 27 flute flute NN 40288 35 28 27 27 CD 40288 35 29 § § CD 40288 35 30 14 14 CD 40288 35 31 . . . 40288 36 1 _ _ NNP 40288 36 2 Recapitulation Recapitulation NNP 40288 36 3 . . . 40288 36 4 _ _ NNP 40288 36 5 Equivalence equivalence NN 40288 36 6 of of IN 40288 36 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 36 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 36 9 : : : 40288 36 10 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 36 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 36 12 and and CC 40288 36 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 36 14 Greek greek NN 40288 36 15 : : : 40288 36 16 tonos tonos NN 40288 36 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 36 18 28 28 CD 40288 36 19 § § CD 40288 36 20 15 15 CD 40288 36 21 . . . 40288 36 22 _ _ NNP 40288 36 23 The the DT 40288 36 24 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 36 25 of of IN 40288 36 26 Greek greek JJ 40288 36 27 music music NN 40288 36 28 . . . 40288 36 29 _ _ NNP 40288 36 30 The the DT 40288 36 31 musical musical JJ 40288 36 32 System system NN 40288 36 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 36 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 36 35 Greek greek JJ 40288 36 36 : : : 40288 36 37 systêma systêma NN 40288 36 38 emmeles emmele NNS 40288 36 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 36 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 36 41 30 30 CD 40288 36 42 § § CD 40288 36 43 16 16 CD 40288 36 44 . . . 40288 37 1 _ _ NNP 40288 37 2 The the DT 40288 37 3 standard standard JJ 40288 37 4 Octachord Octachord NNP 40288 37 5 System System NNP 40288 37 6 . . . 40288 37 7 _ _ NNP 40288 37 8 The the DT 40288 37 9 scale scale NN 40288 37 10 in in IN 40288 37 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 37 12 and and CC 40288 37 13 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 37 14 31 31 CD 40288 37 15 § § CD 40288 37 16 17 17 CD 40288 37 17 . . . 40288 38 1 _ _ NNP 40288 38 2 Earlier early RBR 40288 38 3 Heptachord Heptachord NNP 40288 38 4 Scales Scales NNP 40288 38 5 . . . 40288 38 6 _ _ NNP 40288 38 7 Seven Seven NNP 40288 38 8 - - HYPH 40288 38 9 stringed string VBN 40288 38 10 scales scale NNS 40288 38 11 in in IN 40288 38 12 the the DT 40288 38 13 _ _ NNP 40288 38 14 Problems_--Nicomachus Problems_--Nicomachus NNP 40288 38 15 33 33 CD 40288 38 16 § § CD 40288 38 17 18 18 CD 40288 38 18 . . . 40288 39 1 _ _ NNP 40288 39 2 The the DT 40288 39 3 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 39 4 System System NNP 40288 39 5 . . . 40288 39 6 _ _ NNP 40288 39 7 The the DT 40288 39 8 Greater Greater NNP 40288 39 9 and and CC 40288 39 10 Lesser Lesser NNP 40288 39 11 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 39 12 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 39 13 -- -- : 40288 39 14 Aristoxenus aristoxenus JJ 40288 39 15 -- -- : 40288 39 16 enlargement enlargement NN 40288 39 17 of of IN 40288 39 18 the the DT 40288 39 19 scale scale NN 40288 39 20 -- -- : 40288 39 21 Timotheus Timotheus NNP 40288 39 22 -- -- : 40288 39 23 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 39 24 -- -- : 40288 39 25 the the DT 40288 39 26 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 39 27 -- -- : 40288 39 28 the the DT 40288 39 29 Hyperhypatê Hyperhypatê NNP 40288 39 30 35 35 CD 40288 39 31 § § CD 40288 39 32 19 19 CD 40288 39 33 . . . 40288 40 1 _ _ NNP 40288 40 2 Relation Relation NNP 40288 40 3 of of IN 40288 40 4 System System NNP 40288 40 5 and and CC 40288 40 6 Key Key NNP 40288 40 7 . . . 40288 40 8 _ _ NNP 40288 40 9 The the DT 40288 40 10 standard standard JJ 40288 40 11 System System NNP 40288 40 12 and and CC 40288 40 13 the the DT 40288 40 14 ' ' `` 40288 40 15 modes'--the modes'--the NN 40288 40 16 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40288 40 17 of of IN 40288 40 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 40 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 40 20 : : : 40288 40 21 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 40 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 40 23 40 40 CD 40288 40 24 § § CD 40288 40 25 20 20 CD 40288 40 26 . . . 40288 41 1 _ _ NNP 40288 41 2 Tonality Tonality NNP 40288 41 3 of of IN 40288 41 4 the the DT 40288 41 5 Greek greek JJ 40288 41 6 musical musical JJ 40288 41 7 scale scale NN 40288 41 8 . . . 40288 41 9 _ _ NNP 40288 41 10 The the DT 40288 41 11 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 41 12 as as IN 40288 41 13 a a DT 40288 41 14 key key JJ 40288 41 15 - - HYPH 40288 41 16 note note NN 40288 41 17 -- -- : 40288 41 18 the the DT 40288 41 19 close close NN 40288 41 20 on on IN 40288 41 21 the the DT 40288 41 22 Hypatê--[Greek hypatê--[greek NN 40288 41 23 : : : 40288 41 24 archê archê NNP 40288 41 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 41 26 in in IN 40288 41 27 the the DT 40288 41 28 _ _ NNP 40288 41 29 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 40288 41 30 _ _ NNP 40288 41 31 42 42 CD 40288 41 32 § § CD 40288 41 33 21 21 CD 40288 41 34 . . . 40288 42 1 _ _ NNP 40288 42 2 The the DT 40288 42 3 Species Species NNPS 40288 42 4 of of IN 40288 42 5 a a DT 40288 42 6 Scale Scale NNP 40288 42 7 . . . 40288 42 8 _ _ NNP 40288 42 9 The the DT 40288 42 10 seven seven CD 40288 42 11 Species specie NNS 40288 42 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 42 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 42 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 42 15 : : : 40288 42 16 schêmata schêmata NN 40288 42 17 , , , 40288 42 18 eidê eidê NN 40288 42 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 42 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 42 21 of of IN 40288 42 22 the the DT 40288 42 23 Octave Octave NNP 40288 42 24 -- -- : 40288 42 25 connexion connexion NN 40288 42 26 with with IN 40288 42 27 the the DT 40288 42 28 Modes Modes NNP 40288 42 29 47 47 CD 40288 42 30 § § CD 40288 42 31 22 22 CD 40288 42 32 . . . 40288 43 1 _ _ NNP 40288 43 2 The the DT 40288 43 3 Scales Scales NNP 40288 43 4 as as IN 40288 43 5 treated treat VBN 40288 43 6 by by IN 40288 43 7 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 43 8 . . . 40288 43 9 _ _ NNP 40288 43 10 Advance Advance NNP 40288 43 11 made make VBN 40288 43 12 by by IN 40288 43 13 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 43 14 -- -- : 40288 43 15 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 43 16 of of IN 40288 43 17 the the DT 40288 43 18 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 43 19 genus genus NN 40288 43 20 -- -- : 40288 43 21 reference reference NN 40288 43 22 in in IN 40288 43 23 Plato Plato NNP 40288 43 24 's 's POS 40288 43 25 _ _ NNP 40288 43 26 Republic_--Aristides Republic_--Aristides NNP 40288 43 27 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 43 28 -- -- : 40288 43 29 the the DT 40288 43 30 _ _ NNP 40288 43 31 Philebus Philebus NNP 40288 43 32 _ _ NNP 40288 43 33 48 48 CD 40288 43 34 § § CD 40288 43 35 23 23 CD 40288 43 36 . . . 40288 44 1 _ _ NNP 40288 44 2 The the DT 40288 44 3 Seven Seven NNP 40288 44 4 Species Species NNPS 40288 44 5 . . . 40288 44 6 _ _ NNP 40288 44 7 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 44 8 -- -- : 40288 44 9 the the DT 40288 44 10 _ _ NNP 40288 44 11 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 44 12 Harmonica Harmonica NNP 40288 44 13 _ _ NNP 40288 44 14 56 56 CD 40288 44 15 § § CD 40288 44 16 24 24 CD 40288 44 17 . . . 40288 45 1 _ _ NNP 40288 45 2 Relation Relation NNP 40288 45 3 of of IN 40288 45 4 the the DT 40288 45 5 Species Species NNPS 40288 45 6 to to IN 40288 45 7 the the DT 40288 45 8 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 45 9 . . . 40288 45 10 _ _ NNP 40288 45 11 Use Use NNP 40288 45 12 of of IN 40288 45 13 the the DT 40288 45 14 names name NNS 40288 45 15 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 45 16 , , , 40288 45 17 & & CC 40288 45 18 c.--treatment c.--treatment NN 40288 45 19 of of IN 40288 45 20 musical musical JJ 40288 45 21 scales scale NNS 40288 45 22 in in IN 40288 45 23 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 45 24 -- -- : 40288 45 25 Species Species NNPS 40288 45 26 in in IN 40288 45 27 the the DT 40288 45 28 different different JJ 40288 45 29 genera genera NNP 40288 45 30 58 58 CD 40288 45 31 § § CD 40288 45 32 25 25 CD 40288 45 33 . . . 40288 46 1 _ _ NNP 40288 46 2 The the DT 40288 46 3 Ethos Ethos NNP 40288 46 4 of of IN 40288 46 5 Music Music NNP 40288 46 6 . . . 40288 46 7 _ _ NNP 40288 46 8 Regions Regions NNPS 40288 46 9 of of IN 40288 46 10 the the DT 40288 46 11 voice voice NN 40288 46 12 -- -- : 40288 46 13 branches branch NNS 40288 46 14 of of IN 40288 46 15 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 46 16 poetry poetry NN 40288 46 17 -- -- : 40288 46 18 kinds kind NNS 40288 46 19 of of IN 40288 46 20 ethos ethos NN 40288 46 21 62 62 CD 40288 46 22 § § CD 40288 46 23 26 26 CD 40288 46 24 . . . 40288 47 1 _ _ NNP 40288 47 2 The the DT 40288 47 3 Ethos Ethos NNP 40288 47 4 of of IN 40288 47 5 the the DT 40288 47 6 Genera Genera NNP 40288 47 7 and and CC 40288 47 8 Species Species NNP 40288 47 9 . . . 40288 47 10 _ _ NNP 40288 47 11 Ethos Ethos NNP 40288 47 12 depending depend VBG 40288 47 13 on on IN 40288 47 14 pitch pitch NN 40288 47 15 -- -- : 40288 47 16 on on IN 40288 47 17 the the DT 40288 47 18 genus genus JJ 40288 47 19 66 66 CD 40288 47 20 § § CD 40288 47 21 27 27 CD 40288 47 22 . . . 40288 48 1 _ _ NNP 40288 48 2 The the DT 40288 48 3 Musical Musical NNP 40288 48 4 Notation Notation NNP 40288 48 5 . . . 40288 48 6 _ _ NNP 40288 48 7 The the DT 40288 48 8 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 48 9 notes note NNS 40288 48 10 -- -- : 40288 48 11 original original JJ 40288 48 12 form form NN 40288 48 13 and and CC 40288 48 14 date date NN 40288 48 15 67 67 CD 40288 48 16 § § CD 40288 48 17 28 28 CD 40288 48 18 . . . 40288 49 1 _ _ NNP 40288 49 2 Traces Traces NNPS 40288 49 3 of of IN 40288 49 4 the the DT 40288 49 5 Species Species NNPS 40288 49 6 in in IN 40288 49 7 the the DT 40288 49 8 Notation Notation NNP 40288 49 9 . . . 40288 49 10 _ _ NNP 40288 49 11 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 49 12 's 's POS 40288 49 13 theory theory NN 40288 49 14 75 75 CD 40288 49 15 § § CD 40288 49 16 29 29 CD 40288 49 17 . . . 40288 50 1 _ _ NNP 40288 50 2 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 50 3 's 's POS 40288 50 4 Scheme Scheme NNP 40288 50 5 of of IN 40288 50 6 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 50 7 . . . 40288 50 8 _ _ NNP 40288 50 9 Reduction Reduction NNP 40288 50 10 of of IN 40288 50 11 the the DT 40288 50 12 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 50 13 to to IN 40288 50 14 seven seven CD 40288 50 15 -- -- : 40288 50 16 nomenclature nomenclature JJ 40288 50 17 according accord VBG 40288 50 18 to to IN 40288 50 19 _ _ NNP 40288 50 20 value value NN 40288 50 21 _ _ NNP 40288 50 22 and and CC 40288 50 23 according accord VBG 40288 50 24 to to IN 40288 50 25 _ _ NNP 40288 50 26 position position NN 40288 50 27 _ _ NNP 40288 50 28 78 78 CD 40288 50 29 § § CD 40288 50 30 30 30 CD 40288 50 31 . . . 40288 51 1 _ _ NNP 40288 51 2 Nomenclature Nomenclature NNP 40288 51 3 by by IN 40288 51 4 Position Position NNP 40288 51 5 . . . 40288 51 6 _ _ NNP 40288 51 7 The the DT 40288 51 8 term term NN 40288 51 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 51 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 51 11 : : : 40288 51 12 thesis thesis NN 40288 51 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 51 14 in in IN 40288 51 15 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 51 16 -- -- : 40288 51 17 in in IN 40288 51 18 the the DT 40288 51 19 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 51 20 _ _ NNP 40288 51 21 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 51 22 _ _ NNP 40288 51 23 81 81 CD 40288 51 24 § § CD 40288 51 25 31 31 CD 40288 51 26 . . . 40288 52 1 _ _ NNP 40288 52 2 Scales Scales NNP 40288 52 3 of of IN 40288 52 4 the the DT 40288 52 5 Lyre Lyre NNP 40288 52 6 and and CC 40288 52 7 Cithara Cithara NNP 40288 52 8 . . . 40288 52 9 _ _ NNP 40288 52 10 The the DT 40288 52 11 scales scale NNS 40288 52 12 on on IN 40288 52 13 the the DT 40288 52 14 lyre lyre NN 40288 52 15 -- -- : 40288 52 16 on on IN 40288 52 17 the the DT 40288 52 18 cithara cithara NNP 40288 52 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 52 20 viz viz NN 40288 52 21 . . . 40288 53 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 53 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 53 3 : : : 40288 53 4 tritai tritai NNP 40288 53 5 , , , 40288 53 6 tropoi tropoi NNP 40288 53 7 , , , 40288 53 8 parypatai parypatai NNP 40288 53 9 , , , 40288 53 10 lydia lydia NNP 40288 53 11 , , , 40288 53 12 hypertropa hypertropa NNP 40288 53 13 , , , 40288 53 14 iastiaioliaia iastiaioliaia NN 40288 53 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 53 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 53 17 83 83 CD 40288 53 18 § § CD 40288 53 19 32 32 CD 40288 53 20 . . . 40288 54 1 _ _ NNP 40288 54 2 Remains Remains NNPS 40288 54 3 of of IN 40288 54 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 54 5 Music Music NNP 40288 54 6 . . . 40288 54 7 _ _ NNP 40288 54 8 The the DT 40288 54 9 hymns hymn NNS 40288 54 10 of of IN 40288 54 11 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 54 12 and and CC 40288 54 13 Mesomedes Mesomedes NNPS 40288 54 14 -- -- : 40288 54 15 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 54 16 passages passage NNS 40288 54 17 in in IN 40288 54 18 the the DT 40288 54 19 _ _ NNP 40288 54 20 Anonymus_--Mr Anonymus_--Mr NNP 40288 54 21 . . . 40288 54 22 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 54 23 's 's POS 40288 54 24 inscription inscription NN 40288 54 25 -- -- : 40288 54 26 melody melody NN 40288 54 27 and and CC 40288 54 28 accent accent NN 40288 54 29 -- -- : 40288 54 30 fragment fragment NN 40288 54 31 of of IN 40288 54 32 the the DT 40288 54 33 _ _ NNP 40288 54 34 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 54 35 _ _ NNP 40288 54 36 87 87 CD 40288 54 37 § § CD 40288 54 38 33 33 CD 40288 54 39 . . . 40288 55 1 _ _ NNP 40288 55 2 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 55 3 of of IN 40288 55 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 55 5 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 55 6 . . . 40288 55 7 _ _ NNP 40288 55 8 The the DT 40288 55 9 six six CD 40288 55 10 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 55 11 of of IN 40288 55 12 Plato Plato NNP 40288 55 13 's 's POS 40288 55 14 _ _ NNP 40288 55 15 Republic Republic NNP 40288 55 16 _ _ NNP 40288 55 17 94 94 CD 40288 55 18 § § CD 40288 55 19 34 34 CD 40288 55 20 . . . 40288 56 1 _ _ NNP 40288 56 2 Credibility Credibility NNP 40288 56 3 of of IN 40288 56 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 56 5 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 56 6 . . . 40288 56 7 _ _ NNP 40288 56 8 Date date NN 40288 56 9 of of IN 40288 56 10 Aristides Aristides NNPS 40288 56 11 -- -- : 40288 56 12 genuineness genuineness NN 40288 56 13 of of IN 40288 56 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 56 15 scales scale NNS 40288 56 16 95 95 CD 40288 56 17 § § CD 40288 56 18 35 35 CD 40288 56 19 . . . 40288 57 1 _ _ NNP 40288 57 2 Evidence evidence NN 40288 57 3 for for IN 40288 57 4 Scales scale NNS 40288 57 5 of of IN 40288 57 6 different different JJ 40288 57 7 species specie NNS 40288 57 8 . . . 40288 57 9 _ _ NNP 40288 57 10 The the DT 40288 57 11 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 57 12 - - HYPH 40288 57 13 dorian dorian JJ 40288 57 14 or or CC 40288 57 15 common common JJ 40288 57 16 species specie NNS 40288 57 17 -- -- : 40288 57 18 the the DT 40288 57 19 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 57 20 -- -- : 40288 57 21 the the DT 40288 57 22 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 57 23 - - HYPH 40288 57 24 lydian lydian NNP 40288 57 25 -- -- : 40288 57 26 the the DT 40288 57 27 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 57 28 and and CC 40288 57 29 the the DT 40288 57 30 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 57 31 - - HYPH 40288 57 32 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 57 33 -- -- : 40288 57 34 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 57 35 on on IN 40288 57 36 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 57 37 and and CC 40288 57 38 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 57 39 -- -- : 40288 57 40 the the DT 40288 57 41 dithyramb dithyramb NNP 40288 57 42 101 101 CD 40288 57 43 § § CD 40288 57 44 36 36 CD 40288 57 45 . . . 40288 58 1 _ _ NNP 40288 58 2 Conclusion Conclusion NNP 40288 58 3 . . . 40288 58 4 _ _ NNP 40288 58 5 Early early JJ 40288 58 6 importance importance NN 40288 58 7 of of IN 40288 58 8 genus genus NN 40288 58 9 and and CC 40288 58 10 key key JJ 40288 58 11 only only RB 40288 58 12 -- -- : 40288 58 13 change change NN 40288 58 14 in in IN 40288 58 15 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 58 16 's 's POS 40288 58 17 time time NN 40288 58 18 in in IN 40288 58 19 the the DT 40288 58 20 direction direction NN 40288 58 21 of of IN 40288 58 22 the the DT 40288 58 23 mediaeval mediaeval JJ 40288 58 24 Tones Tones NNP 40288 58 25 108 108 CD 40288 58 26 § § CD 40288 58 27 37 37 CD 40288 58 28 . . . 40288 59 1 _ _ NNP 40288 59 2 Epilogue Epilogue NNP 40288 59 3 -- -- : 40288 59 4 Speech Speech NNP 40288 59 5 and and CC 40288 59 6 Song Song NNP 40288 59 7 . . . 40288 59 8 _ _ NNP 40288 59 9 Musical musical JJ 40288 59 10 nature nature NN 40288 59 11 of of IN 40288 59 12 Greek greek JJ 40288 59 13 accent accent NN 40288 59 14 -- -- : 40288 59 15 relation relation NN 40288 59 16 of of IN 40288 59 17 musical musical JJ 40288 59 18 and and CC 40288 59 19 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 59 20 utterance utterance NN 40288 59 21 -- -- : 40288 59 22 agreement agreement NN 40288 59 23 of of IN 40288 59 24 melody melody NN 40288 59 25 and and CC 40288 59 26 accent accent NN 40288 59 27 in in IN 40288 59 28 the the DT 40288 59 29 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 59 30 inscription inscription NN 40288 59 31 -- -- : 40288 59 32 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 59 33 of of IN 40288 59 34 music music NN 40288 59 35 and and CC 40288 59 36 of of IN 40288 59 37 prose prose NN 40288 59 38 -- -- : 40288 59 39 the the DT 40288 59 40 stress stress NN 40288 59 41 accent accent NN 40288 59 42 ( ( -LRB- 40288 59 43 _ _ NNP 40288 59 44 ictus_)--music ictus_)--music NN 40288 59 45 influenced influence VBN 40288 59 46 by by IN 40288 59 47 language language NN 40288 59 48 -- -- : 40288 59 49 words word NNS 40288 59 50 and and CC 40288 59 51 melody melody NN 40288 59 52 -- -- : 40288 59 53 want want VBP 40288 59 54 of of IN 40288 59 55 harmony harmony NN 40288 59 56 -- -- : 40288 59 57 the the DT 40288 59 58 non non JJ 40288 59 59 - - JJ 40288 59 60 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 59 61 scales scale VBZ 40288 59 62 113 113 CD 40288 59 63 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 40288 59 64 . . . 40288 60 1 Table table NN 40288 60 2 I. I. NNP 40288 60 3 Scales Scales NNP 40288 60 4 of of IN 40288 60 5 the the DT 40288 60 6 seven seven CD 40288 60 7 oldest old JJS 40288 60 8 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 60 9 , , , 40288 60 10 with with IN 40288 60 11 the the DT 40288 60 12 species specie NNS 40288 60 13 of of IN 40288 60 14 the the DT 40288 60 15 same same JJ 40288 60 16 name name NN 40288 60 17 127 127 CD 40288 60 18 Table Table NNP 40288 60 19 II II NNP 40288 60 20 . . . 40288 61 1 The the DT 40288 61 2 fifteen fifteen CD 40288 61 3 Keys Keys NNP 40288 61 4 128 128 CD 40288 61 5 Music Music NNP 40288 61 6 of of IN 40288 61 7 the the DT 40288 61 8 _ _ NNP 40288 61 9 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 61 10 _ _ NNP 40288 61 11 of of IN 40288 61 12 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 61 13 130 130 CD 40288 61 14 Musical musical JJ 40288 61 15 part part NN 40288 61 16 of of IN 40288 61 17 the the DT 40288 61 18 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 61 19 inscription inscription NN 40288 61 20 133 133 CD 40288 61 21 The the DT 40288 61 22 hymns hymn NNS 40288 61 23 recently recently RB 40288 61 24 discovered discover VBD 40288 61 25 at at IN 40288 61 26 Delphi Delphi NNP 40288 61 27 : : : 40288 61 28 Hymn Hymn NNP 40288 61 29 to to IN 40288 61 30 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 61 31 -- -- : 40288 61 32 the the DT 40288 61 33 scale scale NN 40288 61 34 -- -- : 40288 61 35 the the DT 40288 61 36 changes change NNS 40288 61 37 of of IN 40288 61 38 genus genus NN 40288 61 39 and and CC 40288 61 40 key key NN 40288 61 41 -- -- : 40288 61 42 the the DT 40288 61 43 ' ' `` 40288 61 44 mode mode NN 40288 61 45 ' ' '' 40288 61 46 identical identical JJ 40288 61 47 with with IN 40288 61 48 the the DT 40288 61 49 modern modern JJ 40288 61 50 Minor Minor NNP 40288 61 51 -- -- : 40288 61 52 the the DT 40288 61 53 other other JJ 40288 61 54 fragments fragment NNS 40288 61 55 -- -- : 40288 61 56 the the DT 40288 61 57 agreement agreement NN 40288 61 58 of of IN 40288 61 59 melody melody NN 40288 61 60 and and CC 40288 61 61 accent accent JJ 40288 61 62 134 134 CD 40288 61 63 Index Index NNP 40288 61 64 of of IN 40288 61 65 passages passage NNS 40288 61 66 discussed discuss VBN 40288 61 67 or or CC 40288 61 68 referred refer VBD 40288 61 69 to to IN 40288 61 70 142 142 CD 40288 61 71 THE the DT 40288 61 72 MODES MODES NNP 40288 61 73 OF of IN 40288 61 74 ANCIENT ancient NN 40288 61 75 GREEK GREEK NNP 40288 61 76 MUSIC music NN 40288 61 77 . . . 40288 62 1 § § ADD 40288 62 2 1 1 CD 40288 62 3 . . . 40288 63 1 _ _ NNP 40288 63 2 Introductory Introductory NNP 40288 63 3 . . . 40288 63 4 _ _ NNP 40288 63 5 The the DT 40288 63 6 modes mode NNS 40288 63 7 of of IN 40288 63 8 ancient ancient JJ 40288 63 9 Greek greek JJ 40288 63 10 music music NN 40288 63 11 are be VBP 40288 63 12 of of IN 40288 63 13 interest interest NN 40288 63 14 to to IN 40288 63 15 us -PRON- PRP 40288 63 16 , , , 40288 63 17 not not RB 40288 63 18 only only RB 40288 63 19 as as IN 40288 63 20 the the DT 40288 63 21 forms form NNS 40288 63 22 under under IN 40288 63 23 which which WDT 40288 63 24 the the DT 40288 63 25 Fine Fine NNP 40288 63 26 Art Art NNP 40288 63 27 of of IN 40288 63 28 Music Music NNP 40288 63 29 was be VBD 40288 63 30 developed develop VBN 40288 63 31 by by IN 40288 63 32 a a DT 40288 63 33 people people NNS 40288 63 34 of of IN 40288 63 35 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 40288 63 36 artistic artistic JJ 40288 63 37 capability capability NN 40288 63 38 , , , 40288 63 39 but but CC 40288 63 40 also also RB 40288 63 41 on on IN 40288 63 42 account account NN 40288 63 43 of of IN 40288 63 44 the the DT 40288 63 45 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 63 46 ethical ethical JJ 40288 63 47 influence influence NN 40288 63 48 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 63 49 to to IN 40288 63 50 them -PRON- PRP 40288 63 51 by by IN 40288 63 52 the the DT 40288 63 53 greatest great JJS 40288 63 54 ancient ancient JJ 40288 63 55 philosophers philosopher NNS 40288 63 56 . . . 40288 64 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 64 2 appears appear VBZ 40288 64 3 from from IN 40288 64 4 a a DT 40288 64 5 well well RB 40288 64 6 - - HYPH 40288 64 7 known know VBN 40288 64 8 passage passage NN 40288 64 9 in in IN 40288 64 10 the the DT 40288 64 11 _ _ NNP 40288 64 12 Republic Republic NNP 40288 64 13 _ _ NNP 40288 64 14 of of IN 40288 64 15 Plato Plato NNP 40288 64 16 , , , 40288 64 17 as as RB 40288 64 18 well well RB 40288 64 19 as as IN 40288 64 20 from from IN 40288 64 21 many many JJ 40288 64 22 other other JJ 40288 64 23 references reference NNS 40288 64 24 , , , 40288 64 25 that that IN 40288 64 26 in in IN 40288 64 27 ancient ancient JJ 40288 64 28 Greece Greece NNP 40288 64 29 there there EX 40288 64 30 were be VBD 40288 64 31 certain certain JJ 40288 64 32 kinds kind NNS 40288 64 33 or or CC 40288 64 34 forms form NNS 40288 64 35 of of IN 40288 64 36 music music NN 40288 64 37 , , , 40288 64 38 which which WDT 40288 64 39 were be VBD 40288 64 40 known know VBN 40288 64 41 by by IN 40288 64 42 national national JJ 40288 64 43 or or CC 40288 64 44 tribal tribal JJ 40288 64 45 names name NNS 40288 64 46 -- -- : 40288 64 47 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 64 48 , , , 40288 64 49 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 64 50 , , , 40288 64 51 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 64 52 , , , 40288 64 53 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 64 54 and and CC 40288 64 55 the the DT 40288 64 56 like like JJ 40288 64 57 : : : 40288 64 58 that that IN 40288 64 59 each each DT 40288 64 60 of of IN 40288 64 61 these these DT 40288 64 62 was be VBD 40288 64 63 believed believe VBN 40288 64 64 to to TO 40288 64 65 be be VB 40288 64 66 capable capable JJ 40288 64 67 , , , 40288 64 68 not not RB 40288 64 69 only only RB 40288 64 70 of of IN 40288 64 71 expressing express VBG 40288 64 72 particular particular JJ 40288 64 73 emotions emotion NNS 40288 64 74 , , , 40288 64 75 but but CC 40288 64 76 of of IN 40288 64 77 reacting react VBG 40288 64 78 on on IN 40288 64 79 the the DT 40288 64 80 sensibility sensibility NN 40288 64 81 in in IN 40288 64 82 such such PDT 40288 64 83 a a DT 40288 64 84 way way NN 40288 64 85 as as IN 40288 64 86 to to TO 40288 64 87 exercise exercise VB 40288 64 88 a a DT 40288 64 89 powerful powerful JJ 40288 64 90 and and CC 40288 64 91 specific specific JJ 40288 64 92 influence influence NN 40288 64 93 in in IN 40288 64 94 the the DT 40288 64 95 formation formation NN 40288 64 96 of of IN 40288 64 97 character character NN 40288 64 98 : : : 40288 64 99 and and CC 40288 64 100 consequently consequently RB 40288 64 101 that that IN 40288 64 102 the the DT 40288 64 103 choice choice NN 40288 64 104 , , , 40288 64 105 among among IN 40288 64 106 these these DT 40288 64 107 varieties variety NNS 40288 64 108 , , , 40288 64 109 of of IN 40288 64 110 the the DT 40288 64 111 musical musical JJ 40288 64 112 forms form NNS 40288 64 113 to to TO 40288 64 114 be be VB 40288 64 115 admitted admit VBN 40288 64 116 into into IN 40288 64 117 the the DT 40288 64 118 education education NN 40288 64 119 of of IN 40288 64 120 the the DT 40288 64 121 state state NN 40288 64 122 , , , 40288 64 123 was be VBD 40288 64 124 a a DT 40288 64 125 matter matter NN 40288 64 126 of of IN 40288 64 127 the the DT 40288 64 128 most most RBS 40288 64 129 serious serious JJ 40288 64 130 practical practical JJ 40288 64 131 concern concern NN 40288 64 132 . . . 40288 65 1 If if IN 40288 65 2 on on IN 40288 65 3 a a DT 40288 65 4 question question NN 40288 65 5 of of IN 40288 65 6 this this DT 40288 65 7 kind kind NN 40288 65 8 we -PRON- PRP 40288 65 9 are be VBP 40288 65 10 inclined inclined JJ 40288 65 11 to to TO 40288 65 12 distrust distrust VB 40288 65 13 the the DT 40288 65 14 imaginative imaginative JJ 40288 65 15 temper temper NN 40288 65 16 of of IN 40288 65 17 Plato Plato NNP 40288 65 18 we -PRON- PRP 40288 65 19 have have VBP 40288 65 20 only only RB 40288 65 21 to to TO 40288 65 22 turn turn VB 40288 65 23 to to IN 40288 65 24 the the DT 40288 65 25 discussion discussion NN 40288 65 26 of of IN 40288 65 27 the the DT 40288 65 28 same same JJ 40288 65 29 subject subject NN 40288 65 30 in in IN 40288 65 31 the the DT 40288 65 32 _ _ NNP 40288 65 33 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 65 34 _ _ NNP 40288 65 35 of of IN 40288 65 36 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 65 37 , , , 40288 65 38 and and CC 40288 65 39 we -PRON- PRP 40288 65 40 shall shall MD 40288 65 41 find find VB 40288 65 42 the the DT 40288 65 43 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 65 44 view view NN 40288 65 45 criticised criticise VBN 40288 65 46 in in IN 40288 65 47 some some DT 40288 65 48 important important JJ 40288 65 49 details detail NNS 40288 65 50 , , , 40288 65 51 but but CC 40288 65 52 treated treat VBN 40288 65 53 in in IN 40288 65 54 the the DT 40288 65 55 main main JJ 40288 65 56 as as IN 40288 65 57 being be VBG 40288 65 58 beyond beyond IN 40288 65 59 controversy controversy NN 40288 65 60 . . . 40288 66 1 The the DT 40288 66 2 word word NN 40288 66 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 66 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 66 5 : : : 40288 66 6 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 66 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 66 8 , , , 40288 66 9 ' ' `` 40288 66 10 harmony harmony NN 40288 66 11 , , , 40288 66 12 ' ' '' 40288 66 13 applied apply VBN 40288 66 14 to to IN 40288 66 15 these these DT 40288 66 16 forms form NNS 40288 66 17 of of IN 40288 66 18 music music NN 40288 66 19 by by IN 40288 66 20 Plato Plato NNP 40288 66 21 and and CC 40288 66 22 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 66 23 , , , 40288 66 24 means mean VBZ 40288 66 25 literally literally RB 40288 66 26 ' ' `` 40288 66 27 fitting fitting JJ 40288 66 28 ' ' '' 40288 66 29 or or CC 40288 66 30 ' ' `` 40288 66 31 adjustment adjustment NN 40288 66 32 , , , 40288 66 33 ' ' '' 40288 66 34 hence hence RB 40288 66 35 the the DT 40288 66 36 ' ' `` 40288 66 37 tuning tuning NN 40288 66 38 ' ' '' 40288 66 39 of of IN 40288 66 40 a a DT 40288 66 41 series series NN 40288 66 42 of of IN 40288 66 43 notes note NNS 40288 66 44 on on IN 40288 66 45 any any DT 40288 66 46 principle principle NN 40288 66 47 , , , 40288 66 48 the the DT 40288 66 49 formation formation NN 40288 66 50 of of IN 40288 66 51 a a DT 40288 66 52 ' ' `` 40288 66 53 scale scale NN 40288 66 54 ' ' '' 40288 66 55 or or CC 40288 66 56 ' ' '' 40288 66 57 gamut gamut NN 40288 66 58 . . . 40288 66 59 ' ' '' 40288 67 1 Other other JJ 40288 67 2 ancient ancient JJ 40288 67 3 writers writer NNS 40288 67 4 use use VBP 40288 67 5 the the DT 40288 67 6 word word NN 40288 67 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 67 8 Greek greek JJ 40288 67 9 : : : 40288 67 10 tropos tropos NN 40288 67 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 67 12 , , , 40288 67 13 whence whence NN 40288 67 14 the the DT 40288 67 15 Latin Latin NNP 40288 67 16 _ _ NNP 40288 67 17 modus modus NN 40288 67 18 _ _ NNP 40288 67 19 and and CC 40288 67 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 67 21 mood mood NN 40288 67 22 or or CC 40288 67 23 ' ' `` 40288 67 24 mode mode NN 40288 67 25 , , , 40288 67 26 ' ' '' 40288 67 27 generally generally RB 40288 67 28 employed employ VBN 40288 67 29 in in IN 40288 67 30 this this DT 40288 67 31 sense sense NN 40288 67 32 by by IN 40288 67 33 English english JJ 40288 67 34 scholars scholar NNS 40288 67 35 . . . 40288 68 1 The the DT 40288 68 2 word word NN 40288 68 3 ' ' `` 40288 68 4 mode mode NN 40288 68 5 ' ' '' 40288 68 6 is be VBZ 40288 68 7 open open JJ 40288 68 8 to to IN 40288 68 9 the the DT 40288 68 10 objection objection NN 40288 68 11 that that IN 40288 68 12 in in IN 40288 68 13 modern modern JJ 40288 68 14 music music NN 40288 68 15 it -PRON- PRP 40288 68 16 has have VBZ 40288 68 17 a a DT 40288 68 18 meaning meaning NN 40288 68 19 which which WDT 40288 68 20 assumes assume VBZ 40288 68 21 just just RB 40288 68 22 what what WP 40288 68 23 it -PRON- PRP 40288 68 24 is be VBZ 40288 68 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 68 26 present present JJ 40288 68 27 business business NN 40288 68 28 to to TO 40288 68 29 prove prove VB 40288 68 30 or or CC 40288 68 31 disprove disprove VB 40288 68 32 about about IN 40288 68 33 the the DT 40288 68 34 ' ' `` 40288 68 35 modes mode NNS 40288 68 36 ' ' '' 40288 68 37 of of IN 40288 68 38 Greek greek JJ 40288 68 39 music music NN 40288 68 40 . . . 40288 69 1 The the DT 40288 69 2 word word NN 40288 69 3 ' ' `` 40288 69 4 harmony harmony NN 40288 69 5 , , , 40288 69 6 ' ' '' 40288 69 7 however however RB 40288 69 8 , , , 40288 69 9 is be VBZ 40288 69 10 still still RB 40288 69 11 more more RBR 40288 69 12 misleading misleading JJ 40288 69 13 , , , 40288 69 14 and and CC 40288 69 15 on on IN 40288 69 16 the the DT 40288 69 17 whole whole NN 40288 69 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 69 19 seems seem VBZ 40288 69 20 best good JJS 40288 69 21 to to TO 40288 69 22 abide abide VB 40288 69 23 by by IN 40288 69 24 the the DT 40288 69 25 established establish VBN 40288 69 26 use use NN 40288 69 27 of of IN 40288 69 28 ' ' `` 40288 69 29 mode mode NN 40288 69 30 ' ' '' 40288 69 31 as as IN 40288 69 32 a a DT 40288 69 33 translation translation NN 40288 69 34 of of IN 40288 69 35 [ [ -LRB- 40288 69 36 Greek Greek NNP 40288 69 37 : : : 40288 69 38 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 69 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 69 40 , , , 40288 69 41 trusting trust VBG 40288 69 42 that that IN 40288 69 43 the the DT 40288 69 44 context context NN 40288 69 45 will will MD 40288 69 46 show show VB 40288 69 47 when when WRB 40288 69 48 the the DT 40288 69 49 word word NN 40288 69 50 has have VBZ 40288 69 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 69 52 distinctively distinctively RB 40288 69 53 modern modern JJ 40288 69 54 sense sense NN 40288 69 55 , , , 40288 69 56 and and CC 40288 69 57 when when WRB 40288 69 58 it -PRON- PRP 40288 69 59 simply simply RB 40288 69 60 denotes denote VBZ 40288 69 61 a a DT 40288 69 62 musical musical JJ 40288 69 63 scale scale NN 40288 69 64 of of IN 40288 69 65 some some DT 40288 69 66 particular particular JJ 40288 69 67 kind kind NN 40288 69 68 . . . 40288 70 1 The the DT 40288 70 2 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 70 3 of of IN 40288 70 4 music music NN 40288 70 5 is be VBZ 40288 70 6 also also RB 40288 70 7 recognized recognize VBN 40288 70 8 by by IN 40288 70 9 both both CC 40288 70 10 Plato Plato NNP 40288 70 11 and and CC 40288 70 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 70 13 as as IN 40288 70 14 an an DT 40288 70 15 important important JJ 40288 70 16 element element NN 40288 70 17 in in IN 40288 70 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 70 19 moral moral JJ 40288 70 20 value value NN 40288 70 21 . . . 40288 71 1 On on IN 40288 71 2 this this DT 40288 71 3 part part NN 40288 71 4 of of IN 40288 71 5 the the DT 40288 71 6 subject subject NN 40288 71 7 , , , 40288 71 8 however however RB 40288 71 9 , , , 40288 71 10 we -PRON- PRP 40288 71 11 have have VBP 40288 71 12 much much RB 40288 71 13 less less JJR 40288 71 14 material material NN 40288 71 15 for for IN 40288 71 16 a a DT 40288 71 17 judgement judgement NN 40288 71 18 . . . 40288 72 1 Plato Plato NNP 40288 72 2 goes go VBZ 40288 72 3 on on RP 40288 72 4 to to IN 40288 72 5 the the DT 40288 72 6 rhythms rhythm NNS 40288 72 7 after after IN 40288 72 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 72 9 has have VBZ 40288 72 10 done do VBN 40288 72 11 with with IN 40288 72 12 the the DT 40288 72 13 modes mode NNS 40288 72 14 , , , 40288 72 15 and and CC 40288 72 16 lays lay VBZ 40288 72 17 down down IN 40288 72 18 the the DT 40288 72 19 principle principle NN 40288 72 20 that that IN 40288 72 21 they -PRON- PRP 40288 72 22 must must MD 40288 72 23 not not RB 40288 72 24 be be VB 40288 72 25 complex complex JJ 40288 72 26 or or CC 40288 72 27 varied varied JJ 40288 72 28 , , , 40288 72 29 but but CC 40288 72 30 must must MD 40288 72 31 be be VB 40288 72 32 the the DT 40288 72 33 rhythms rhythm NNS 40288 72 34 of of IN 40288 72 35 a a DT 40288 72 36 sober sober JJ 40288 72 37 and and CC 40288 72 38 brave brave JJ 40288 72 39 life life NN 40288 72 40 . . . 40288 73 1 But but CC 40288 73 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 73 3 confesses confess VBZ 40288 73 4 that that IN 40288 73 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 73 6 can can MD 40288 73 7 not not RB 40288 73 8 tell tell VB 40288 73 9 which which WDT 40288 73 10 these these DT 40288 73 11 are be VBP 40288 73 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 73 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 73 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 73 15 : : : 40288 73 16 poia poia NNP 40288 73 17 de de NNP 40288 73 18 poiou poiou NNP 40288 73 19 biou biou NNP 40288 73 20 mimêmata mimêmata NNP 40288 73 21 ouk ouk NNP 40288 73 22 echô echô NNP 40288 73 23 legein legein NNP 40288 73 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 73 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 73 26 , , , 40288 73 27 and and CC 40288 73 28 leaves leave VBZ 40288 73 29 the the DT 40288 73 30 matter matter NN 40288 73 31 for for IN 40288 73 32 future future JJ 40288 73 33 inquiry[1 inquiry[1 NNP 40288 73 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 73 35 . . . 40288 74 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 74 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 74 3 1 1 CD 40288 74 4 : : : 40288 74 5 Plato Plato NNP 40288 74 6 , , , 40288 74 7 _ _ NNP 40288 74 8 Rep. Rep. NNP 40288 74 9 _ _ NNP 40288 74 10 p. p. NN 40288 74 11 400 400 CD 40288 74 12 _ _ NNP 40288 74 13 b b NNP 40288 74 14 _ _ NNP 40288 74 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 74 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 74 17 : : : 40288 74 18 alla alla NN 40288 74 19 tauta tauta NN 40288 74 20 men man NNS 40288 74 21 , , , 40288 74 22 ên ên NNP 40288 74 23 d d NNP 40288 74 24 ' ' `` 40288 74 25 egô egô NNP 40288 74 26 , , , 40288 74 27 kai kai NNP 40288 74 28 meta meta JJ 40288 74 29 Damônos Damônos NNP 40288 74 30 bouleusometha bouleusometha NN 40288 74 31 , , , 40288 74 32 tines tin VBZ 40288 74 33 te te NNP 40288 74 34 aneleutherias aneleutherias NNP 40288 74 35 kai kai NNP 40288 74 36 hybreôs hybreôs NNP 40288 74 37 ê ê NNP 40288 74 38 manias manias NNP 40288 74 39 kai kai NNP 40288 74 40 allês allês NNP 40288 74 41 kakias kakias NNP 40288 74 42 prepousai prepousai NNP 40288 74 43 baseis baseis NNP 40288 74 44 , , , 40288 74 45 kai kai NNP 40288 74 46 tinas tinas NNP 40288 74 47 tois tois NNP 40288 74 48 enantiois enantiois NNP 40288 74 49 leipteon leipteon NNP 40288 74 50 rhythmous rhythmous NNP 40288 74 51 . . . 40288 74 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 74 53 ] ] -RRB- 40288 75 1 § § ADD 40288 75 2 2 2 CD 40288 75 3 . . . 40288 76 1 _ _ NNP 40288 76 2 Statement Statement NNP 40288 76 3 of of IN 40288 76 4 the the DT 40288 76 5 question question NN 40288 76 6 . . . 40288 76 7 _ _ NNP 40288 76 8 What what WP 40288 76 9 then then RB 40288 76 10 are be VBP 40288 76 11 the the DT 40288 76 12 musical musical JJ 40288 76 13 forms form NNS 40288 76 14 to to TO 40288 76 15 which which WDT 40288 76 16 Plato Plato NNP 40288 76 17 and and CC 40288 76 18 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 76 19 ascribe ascribe VBP 40288 76 20 this this DT 40288 76 21 remarkable remarkable JJ 40288 76 22 efficacy efficacy NN 40288 76 23 ? ? . 40288 77 1 And and CC 40288 77 2 what what WP 40288 77 3 is be VBZ 40288 77 4 the the DT 40288 77 5 source source NN 40288 77 6 of of IN 40288 77 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 77 8 influence influence NN 40288 77 9 on on IN 40288 77 10 human human JJ 40288 77 11 emotion emotion NN 40288 77 12 and and CC 40288 77 13 character character NN 40288 77 14 ? ? . 40288 78 1 There there EX 40288 78 2 are be VBP 40288 78 3 two two CD 40288 78 4 obvious obvious JJ 40288 78 5 relations relation NNS 40288 78 6 in in IN 40288 78 7 which which WDT 40288 78 8 the the DT 40288 78 9 scales scale NNS 40288 78 10 employed employ VBN 40288 78 11 in in IN 40288 78 12 any any DT 40288 78 13 system system NN 40288 78 14 of of IN 40288 78 15 music music NN 40288 78 16 may may MD 40288 78 17 stand stand VB 40288 78 18 to to IN 40288 78 19 each each DT 40288 78 20 other other JJ 40288 78 21 . . . 40288 79 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 79 2 may may MD 40288 79 3 be be VB 40288 79 4 related relate VBN 40288 79 5 as as IN 40288 79 6 two two CD 40288 79 7 keys key NNS 40288 79 8 of of IN 40288 79 9 the the DT 40288 79 10 same same JJ 40288 79 11 mode mode NN 40288 79 12 in in IN 40288 79 13 modern modern JJ 40288 79 14 music music NN 40288 79 15 : : : 40288 79 16 that that DT 40288 79 17 is be VBZ 40288 79 18 to to TO 40288 79 19 say say VB 40288 79 20 , , , 40288 79 21 we -PRON- PRP 40288 79 22 may may MD 40288 79 23 have have VB 40288 79 24 to to TO 40288 79 25 do do VB 40288 79 26 with with IN 40288 79 27 a a DT 40288 79 28 scale scale NN 40288 79 29 consisting consisting NN 40288 79 30 of of IN 40288 79 31 a a DT 40288 79 32 fixed fix VBN 40288 79 33 succession succession NN 40288 79 34 of of IN 40288 79 35 intervals interval NNS 40288 79 36 , , , 40288 79 37 which which WDT 40288 79 38 may may MD 40288 79 39 vary vary VB 40288 79 40 in in IN 40288 79 41 pitch pitch NN 40288 79 42 -- -- : 40288 79 43 may may MD 40288 79 44 be be VB 40288 79 45 ' ' `` 40288 79 46 transposed transpose VBN 40288 79 47 , , , 40288 79 48 ' ' '' 40288 79 49 as as IN 40288 79 50 we -PRON- PRP 40288 79 51 say say VBP 40288 79 52 , , , 40288 79 53 from from IN 40288 79 54 one one CD 40288 79 55 pitch pitch NN 40288 79 56 or or CC 40288 79 57 key key NN 40288 79 58 to to IN 40288 79 59 another another DT 40288 79 60 . . . 40288 80 1 Or or CC 40288 80 2 the the DT 40288 80 3 scales scale NNS 40288 80 4 may may MD 40288 80 5 differ differ VB 40288 80 6 as as IN 40288 80 7 the the DT 40288 80 8 Major major JJ 40288 80 9 mode mode NN 40288 80 10 differs differ VBZ 40288 80 11 from from IN 40288 80 12 the the DT 40288 80 13 Minor Minor NNP 40288 80 14 , , , 40288 80 15 namely namely RB 40288 80 16 in in IN 40288 80 17 the the DT 40288 80 18 order order NN 40288 80 19 in in IN 40288 80 20 which which WDT 40288 80 21 the the DT 40288 80 22 intervals interval NNS 40288 80 23 follow follow VBP 40288 80 24 each each DT 40288 80 25 other other JJ 40288 80 26 . . . 40288 81 1 In in IN 40288 81 2 modern modern JJ 40288 81 3 music music NN 40288 81 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 81 5 have have VBP 40288 81 6 these these DT 40288 81 7 two two CD 40288 81 8 modes mode NNS 40288 81 9 , , , 40288 81 10 and and CC 40288 81 11 each each DT 40288 81 12 of of IN 40288 81 13 them -PRON- PRP 40288 81 14 may may MD 40288 81 15 be be VB 40288 81 16 in in IN 40288 81 17 any any DT 40288 81 18 one one CD 40288 81 19 of of IN 40288 81 20 twelve twelve CD 40288 81 21 keys key NNS 40288 81 22 . . . 40288 82 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 82 2 is be VBZ 40288 82 3 evidently evidently RB 40288 82 4 possible possible JJ 40288 82 5 , , , 40288 82 6 also also RB 40288 82 7 , , , 40288 82 8 that that IN 40288 82 9 a a DT 40288 82 10 name name NN 40288 82 11 such such JJ 40288 82 12 as as IN 40288 82 13 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 82 14 or or CC 40288 82 15 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 82 16 might may MD 40288 82 17 denote denote VB 40288 82 18 a a DT 40288 82 19 particular particular JJ 40288 82 20 mode mode NN 40288 82 21 taken take VBN 40288 82 22 in in RP 40288 82 23 a a DT 40288 82 24 particular particular JJ 40288 82 25 key key NN 40288 82 26 -- -- : 40288 82 27 that that IN 40288 82 28 the the DT 40288 82 29 scale scale NN 40288 82 30 so so RB 40288 82 31 called call VBD 40288 82 32 should should MD 40288 82 33 possess possess VB 40288 82 34 a a DT 40288 82 35 definite definite JJ 40288 82 36 pitch pitch NN 40288 82 37 as as RB 40288 82 38 well well RB 40288 82 39 as as IN 40288 82 40 a a DT 40288 82 41 definite definite JJ 40288 82 42 series series NN 40288 82 43 of of IN 40288 82 44 intervals interval NNS 40288 82 45 . . . 40288 83 1 According accord VBG 40288 83 2 to to IN 40288 83 3 the the DT 40288 83 4 theory theory NN 40288 83 5 which which WDT 40288 83 6 appears appear VBZ 40288 83 7 now now RB 40288 83 8 to to TO 40288 83 9 prevail prevail VB 40288 83 10 among among IN 40288 83 11 students student NNS 40288 83 12 of of IN 40288 83 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 83 14 music music NN 40288 83 15 , , , 40288 83 16 these these DT 40288 83 17 famous famous JJ 40288 83 18 names name NNS 40288 83 19 had have VBD 40288 83 20 a a DT 40288 83 21 double double JJ 40288 83 22 application application NN 40288 83 23 . . . 40288 84 1 There there EX 40288 84 2 was be VBD 40288 84 3 a a DT 40288 84 4 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 84 5 mode mode NN 40288 84 6 as as RB 40288 84 7 well well RB 40288 84 8 as as IN 40288 84 9 a a DT 40288 84 10 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 84 11 key key NN 40288 84 12 , , , 40288 84 13 a a DT 40288 84 14 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 84 15 mode mode NN 40288 84 16 and and CC 40288 84 17 a a DT 40288 84 18 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 84 19 key key NN 40288 84 20 , , , 40288 84 21 and and CC 40288 84 22 so so RB 40288 84 23 on on RB 40288 84 24 . . . 40288 85 1 This this DT 40288 85 2 is be VBZ 40288 85 3 the the DT 40288 85 4 view view NN 40288 85 5 set set VBN 40288 85 6 forth forth RP 40288 85 7 by by IN 40288 85 8 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40288 85 9 in in IN 40288 85 10 the the DT 40288 85 11 treatise treatise NN 40288 85 12 which which WDT 40288 85 13 may may MD 40288 85 14 be be VB 40288 85 15 said say VBN 40288 85 16 to to TO 40288 85 17 have have VB 40288 85 18 laid lay VBN 40288 85 19 the the DT 40288 85 20 foundations foundation NNS 40288 85 21 of of IN 40288 85 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 85 23 knowledge knowledge NN 40288 85 24 of of IN 40288 85 25 Greek greek JJ 40288 85 26 music music NN 40288 85 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 85 28 _ _ NNP 40288 85 29 De De NNP 40288 85 30 Metris Metris NNP 40288 85 31 Pindari Pindari NNP 40288 85 32 _ _ NNP 40288 85 33 , , , 40288 85 34 lib lib NNP 40288 85 35 . . . 40288 86 1 III iii CD 40288 86 2 . . . 40288 87 1 cc cc NNP 40288 87 2 . . . 40288 88 1 vii vii NN 40288 88 2 - - HYPH 40288 88 3 xii xii NNP 40288 88 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 88 5 . . . 40288 89 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 89 2 is be VBZ 40288 89 3 expounded expound VBN 40288 89 4 , , , 40288 89 5 along along IN 40288 89 6 with with IN 40288 89 7 much much JJ 40288 89 8 subsidiary subsidiary JJ 40288 89 9 speculation speculation NN 40288 89 10 , , , 40288 89 11 in in IN 40288 89 12 the the DT 40288 89 13 successive successive JJ 40288 89 14 volumes volume NNS 40288 89 15 which which WDT 40288 89 16 we -PRON- PRP 40288 89 17 owe owe VBP 40288 89 18 to to IN 40288 89 19 the the DT 40288 89 20 fertile fertile JJ 40288 89 21 pen pen NN 40288 89 22 of of IN 40288 89 23 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 89 24 ; ; : 40288 89 25 and and CC 40288 89 26 it -PRON- PRP 40288 89 27 has have VBZ 40288 89 28 been be VBN 40288 89 29 adopted adopt VBN 40288 89 30 in in IN 40288 89 31 the the DT 40288 89 32 learned learned JJ 40288 89 33 and and CC 40288 89 34 excellent excellent JJ 40288 89 35 _ _ NNP 40288 89 36 Histoire Histoire NNP 40288 89 37 et et NNP 40288 89 38 Théorie Théorie NNP 40288 89 39 de de NNP 40288 89 40 la la NNP 40288 89 41 Musique Musique NNP 40288 89 42 de de NNP 40288 89 43 l'Antiquité l'Antiquité NNP 40288 89 44 _ _ NNP 40288 89 45 of of IN 40288 89 46 M. M. NNP 40288 89 47 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 89 48 . . . 40288 90 1 According accord VBG 40288 90 2 to to IN 40288 90 3 these these DT 40288 90 4 high high JJ 40288 90 5 authorities authority NNS 40288 90 6 the the DT 40288 90 7 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 90 8 had have VBD 40288 90 9 a a DT 40288 90 10 system system NN 40288 90 11 of of IN 40288 90 12 key key NN 40288 90 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 90 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 90 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 90 16 : : : 40288 90 17 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 90 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 90 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 90 20 , , , 40288 90 21 and and CC 40288 90 22 also also RB 40288 90 23 a a DT 40288 90 24 system system NN 40288 90 25 of of IN 40288 90 26 modes mode NNS 40288 90 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 90 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 90 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 90 30 : : : 40288 90 31 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 90 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 90 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 90 34 , , , 40288 90 35 the the DT 40288 90 36 former former JJ 40288 90 37 being being NN 40288 90 38 based base VBN 40288 90 39 solely solely RB 40288 90 40 upon upon IN 40288 90 41 difference difference NN 40288 90 42 of of IN 40288 90 43 pitch pitch NN 40288 90 44 , , , 40288 90 45 the the DT 40288 90 46 latter latter JJ 40288 90 47 upon upon IN 40288 90 48 the the DT 40288 90 49 ' ' `` 40288 90 50 form form NN 40288 90 51 ' ' '' 40288 90 52 or or CC 40288 90 53 species specie NNS 40288 90 54 ( ( -LRB- 40288 90 55 [ [ -LRB- 40288 90 56 Greek Greek NNP 40288 90 57 : : : 40288 90 58 eidos eidos NN 40288 90 59 ] ] -RRB- 40288 90 60 ) ) -RRB- 40288 90 61 of of IN 40288 90 62 the the DT 40288 90 63 octave octave NN 40288 90 64 scale scale NN 40288 90 65 , , , 40288 90 66 that that DT 40288 90 67 is be VBZ 40288 90 68 to to TO 40288 90 69 say say VB 40288 90 70 , , , 40288 90 71 upon upon IN 40288 90 72 the the DT 40288 90 73 order order NN 40288 90 74 of of IN 40288 90 75 the the DT 40288 90 76 intervals interval NNS 40288 90 77 which which WDT 40288 90 78 compose compose VBP 40288 90 79 it -PRON- PRP 40288 90 80 . . . 40288 91 1 § § ADD 40288 91 2 3 3 CD 40288 91 3 . . . 40288 92 1 _ _ NNP 40288 92 2 The the DT 40288 92 3 Authorities Authorities NNPS 40288 92 4 . . . 40288 92 5 _ _ NNP 40288 92 6 The the DT 40288 92 7 sources source NNS 40288 92 8 of of IN 40288 92 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 92 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40288 92 11 are be VBP 40288 92 12 the the DT 40288 92 13 various various JJ 40288 92 14 systematic systematic JJ 40288 92 15 treatises treatise NNS 40288 92 16 upon upon IN 40288 92 17 music music NN 40288 92 18 which which WDT 40288 92 19 have have VBP 40288 92 20 come come VBN 40288 92 21 down down RP 40288 92 22 to to IN 40288 92 23 us -PRON- PRP 40288 92 24 from from IN 40288 92 25 Greek greek JJ 40288 92 26 antiquity antiquity NN 40288 92 27 , , , 40288 92 28 together together RB 40288 92 29 with with IN 40288 92 30 incidental incidental JJ 40288 92 31 references reference NNS 40288 92 32 in in IN 40288 92 33 other other JJ 40288 92 34 authors author NNS 40288 92 35 , , , 40288 92 36 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 92 37 poets poet NNS 40288 92 38 and and CC 40288 92 39 philosophers philosopher NNS 40288 92 40 . . . 40288 93 1 Of of IN 40288 93 2 the the DT 40288 93 3 systematic systematic JJ 40288 93 4 or or CC 40288 93 5 ' ' `` 40288 93 6 technical technical JJ 40288 93 7 ' ' '' 40288 93 8 writers writer NNS 40288 93 9 the the DT 40288 93 10 earliest early JJS 40288 93 11 and and CC 40288 93 12 most most RBS 40288 93 13 important important JJ 40288 93 14 is be VBZ 40288 93 15 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 93 16 , , , 40288 93 17 a a DT 40288 93 18 pupil pupil NN 40288 93 19 of of IN 40288 93 20 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 93 21 . . . 40288 94 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40288 94 2 treatise treatise NN 40288 94 3 on on IN 40288 94 4 _ _ NNP 40288 94 5 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 94 6 _ _ NNP 40288 94 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 94 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 94 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 94 10 : : : 40288 94 11 harmonikê harmonikê NNP 40288 94 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 94 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 94 14 has have VBZ 40288 94 15 reached reach VBN 40288 94 16 us -PRON- PRP 40288 94 17 in in IN 40288 94 18 a a DT 40288 94 19 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 40288 94 20 condition condition NN 40288 94 21 , , , 40288 94 22 but but CC 40288 94 23 may may MD 40288 94 24 be be VB 40288 94 25 supplemented supplement VBN 40288 94 26 to to IN 40288 94 27 some some DT 40288 94 28 extent extent NN 40288 94 29 from from IN 40288 94 30 later later JJ 40288 94 31 works work NNS 40288 94 32 of of IN 40288 94 33 the the DT 40288 94 34 same same JJ 40288 94 35 school school NN 40288 94 36 . . . 40288 95 1 Among among IN 40288 95 2 the the DT 40288 95 3 incidental incidental JJ 40288 95 4 notices notice NNS 40288 95 5 of of IN 40288 95 6 music music NN 40288 95 7 the the DT 40288 95 8 most most RBS 40288 95 9 considerable considerable JJ 40288 95 10 are be VBP 40288 95 11 the the DT 40288 95 12 passages passage NNS 40288 95 13 in in IN 40288 95 14 the the DT 40288 95 15 _ _ NNP 40288 95 16 Republic Republic NNP 40288 95 17 _ _ NNP 40288 95 18 and and CC 40288 95 19 the the DT 40288 95 20 _ _ NNP 40288 95 21 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 95 22 _ _ NNP 40288 95 23 already already RB 40288 95 24 referred refer VBD 40288 95 25 to to IN 40288 95 26 . . . 40288 96 1 To to IN 40288 96 2 these these DT 40288 96 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 96 4 have have VBP 40288 96 5 to to TO 40288 96 6 add add VB 40288 96 7 a a DT 40288 96 8 few few JJ 40288 96 9 other other JJ 40288 96 10 references reference NNS 40288 96 11 in in IN 40288 96 12 Plato Plato NNP 40288 96 13 and and CC 40288 96 14 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 96 15 ; ; : 40288 96 16 a a DT 40288 96 17 long long JJ 40288 96 18 fragment fragment NN 40288 96 19 from from IN 40288 96 20 the the DT 40288 96 21 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 96 22 philosopher philosopher NN 40288 96 23 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 96 24 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 96 25 , , , 40288 96 26 containing contain VBG 40288 96 27 some some DT 40288 96 28 interesting interesting JJ 40288 96 29 quotations quotation NNS 40288 96 30 from from IN 40288 96 31 earlier early JJR 40288 96 32 poets poet NNS 40288 96 33 ; ; : 40288 96 34 a a DT 40288 96 35 number number NN 40288 96 36 of of IN 40288 96 37 detached detach VBN 40288 96 38 observations observation NNS 40288 96 39 collected collect VBN 40288 96 40 in in IN 40288 96 41 the the DT 40288 96 42 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 40288 96 43 section section NN 40288 96 44 of of IN 40288 96 45 the the DT 40288 96 46 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 96 47 _ _ NNP 40288 96 48 Problems Problems NNP 40288 96 49 _ _ NNP 40288 96 50 ; ; : 40288 96 51 and and CC 40288 96 52 one one CD 40288 96 53 or or CC 40288 96 54 two two CD 40288 96 55 notices notice NNS 40288 96 56 preserved preserve VBN 40288 96 57 in in IN 40288 96 58 lexicographical lexicographical JJ 40288 96 59 works work NNS 40288 96 60 , , , 40288 96 61 such such JJ 40288 96 62 as as IN 40288 96 63 the the DT 40288 96 64 _ _ NNP 40288 96 65 Onomasticon Onomasticon NNP 40288 96 66 _ _ NNP 40288 96 67 of of IN 40288 96 68 Pollux Pollux NNP 40288 96 69 . . . 40288 97 1 In in IN 40288 97 2 these these DT 40288 97 3 groups group NNS 40288 97 4 of of IN 40288 97 5 authorities authority NNS 40288 97 6 the the DT 40288 97 7 scholars scholar NNS 40288 97 8 above above IN 40288 97 9 mentioned mention VBD 40288 97 10 find find VBP 40288 97 11 the the DT 40288 97 12 double double JJ 40288 97 13 use use NN 40288 97 14 which which WDT 40288 97 15 they -PRON- PRP 40288 97 16 believe believe VBP 40288 97 17 to to TO 40288 97 18 have have VB 40288 97 19 been be VBN 40288 97 20 made make VBN 40288 97 21 of of IN 40288 97 22 the the DT 40288 97 23 names name NNS 40288 97 24 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 97 25 , , , 40288 97 26 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 97 27 , , , 40288 97 28 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 97 29 and and CC 40288 97 30 the the DT 40288 97 31 rest rest NN 40288 97 32 . . . 40288 98 1 In in IN 40288 98 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 98 3 they -PRON- PRP 40288 98 4 recognise recognise VBP 40288 98 5 that that IN 40288 98 6 these these DT 40288 98 7 names name NNS 40288 98 8 are be VBP 40288 98 9 applied apply VBN 40288 98 10 to to IN 40288 98 11 a a DT 40288 98 12 series series NN 40288 98 13 of of IN 40288 98 14 keys key NNS 40288 98 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 98 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 98 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 98 18 : : : 40288 98 19 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 98 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 98 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 98 22 , , , 40288 98 23 which which WDT 40288 98 24 differed differ VBD 40288 98 25 in in IN 40288 98 26 pitch pitch NN 40288 98 27 only only RB 40288 98 28 . . . 40288 99 1 In in IN 40288 99 2 Plato Plato NNP 40288 99 3 and and CC 40288 99 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 99 5 they -PRON- PRP 40288 99 6 find find VBP 40288 99 7 the the DT 40288 99 8 same same JJ 40288 99 9 names name NNS 40288 99 10 applied apply VBN 40288 99 11 to to IN 40288 99 12 scales scale NNS 40288 99 13 called call VBN 40288 99 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 99 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 99 16 : : : 40288 99 17 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 99 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 99 19 , , , 40288 99 20 and and CC 40288 99 21 these these DT 40288 99 22 scales scale NNS 40288 99 23 , , , 40288 99 24 they -PRON- PRP 40288 99 25 maintain maintain VBP 40288 99 26 , , , 40288 99 27 differed differ VBN 40288 99 28 primarily primarily RB 40288 99 29 in in IN 40288 99 30 the the DT 40288 99 31 order order NN 40288 99 32 of of IN 40288 99 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 99 34 intervals interval NNS 40288 99 35 . . . 40288 100 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 100 2 shall shall MD 40288 100 3 endeavour endeavour VB 40288 100 4 to to TO 40288 100 5 show show VB 40288 100 6 that that IN 40288 100 7 there there EX 40288 100 8 was be VBD 40288 100 9 no no DT 40288 100 10 such such JJ 40288 100 11 double double JJ 40288 100 12 use use NN 40288 100 13 : : : 40288 100 14 that that IN 40288 100 15 in in IN 40288 100 16 the the DT 40288 100 17 earlier early JJR 40288 100 18 periods period NNS 40288 100 19 of of IN 40288 100 20 Greek greek JJ 40288 100 21 music music NN 40288 100 22 the the DT 40288 100 23 scales scale NNS 40288 100 24 in in IN 40288 100 25 use use NN 40288 100 26 , , , 40288 100 27 whether whether IN 40288 100 28 called call VBN 40288 100 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 100 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 100 31 : : : 40288 100 32 tonoi tonoi NNS 40288 100 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 100 34 or or CC 40288 100 35 [ [ -LRB- 40288 100 36 Greek Greek NNP 40288 100 37 : : : 40288 100 38 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 100 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 100 40 , , , 40288 100 41 differed differ VBN 40288 100 42 primarily primarily RB 40288 100 43 in in IN 40288 100 44 _ _ NNP 40288 100 45 pitch pitch NN 40288 100 46 _ _ NNP 40288 100 47 : : : 40288 100 48 that that IN 40288 100 49 the the DT 40288 100 50 statements statement NNS 40288 100 51 of of IN 40288 100 52 ancient ancient JJ 40288 100 53 authors author NNS 40288 100 54 about about IN 40288 100 55 them -PRON- PRP 40288 100 56 , , , 40288 100 57 down down RB 40288 100 58 to to IN 40288 100 59 and and CC 40288 100 60 including include VBG 40288 100 61 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 100 62 , , , 40288 100 63 agree agree VBP 40288 100 64 as as RB 40288 100 65 closely closely RB 40288 100 66 as as IN 40288 100 67 there there EX 40288 100 68 is be VBZ 40288 100 69 reason reason NN 40288 100 70 to to TO 40288 100 71 expect expect VB 40288 100 72 : : : 40288 100 73 and and CC 40288 100 74 that that IN 40288 100 75 the the DT 40288 100 76 passages passage NNS 40288 100 77 on on IN 40288 100 78 which which WDT 40288 100 79 the the DT 40288 100 80 opposite opposite JJ 40288 100 81 view view NN 40288 100 82 is be VBZ 40288 100 83 based base VBN 40288 100 84 -- -- : 40288 100 85 all all DT 40288 100 86 of of IN 40288 100 87 them -PRON- PRP 40288 100 88 drawn draw VBN 40288 100 89 from from IN 40288 100 90 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 100 91 late late JJ 40288 100 92 writers writer NNS 40288 100 93 -- -- : 40288 100 94 either either CC 40288 100 95 do do VBP 40288 100 96 not not RB 40288 100 97 relate relate VB 40288 100 98 to to IN 40288 100 99 these these DT 40288 100 100 ancient ancient JJ 40288 100 101 scales scale NNS 40288 100 102 at at RB 40288 100 103 all all RB 40288 100 104 , , , 40288 100 105 or or CC 40288 100 106 point point NN 40288 100 107 to to IN 40288 100 108 the the DT 40288 100 109 emergence emergence NN 40288 100 110 in in IN 40288 100 111 post post JJ 40288 100 112 - - JJ 40288 100 113 classical classical JJ 40288 100 114 times time NNS 40288 100 115 of of IN 40288 100 116 some some DT 40288 100 117 new new JJ 40288 100 118 forms form NNS 40288 100 119 or or CC 40288 100 120 tendencies tendency NNS 40288 100 121 of of IN 40288 100 122 musical musical JJ 40288 100 123 art art NN 40288 100 124 . . . 40288 101 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 101 2 propose propose VBP 40288 101 3 in in IN 40288 101 4 any any DT 40288 101 5 case case NN 40288 101 6 to to TO 40288 101 7 adhere adhere VB 40288 101 8 as as RB 40288 101 9 closely closely RB 40288 101 10 as as IN 40288 101 11 possible possible JJ 40288 101 12 to to IN 40288 101 13 a a DT 40288 101 14 chronological chronological JJ 40288 101 15 treatment treatment NN 40288 101 16 of of IN 40288 101 17 the the DT 40288 101 18 evidence evidence NN 40288 101 19 which which WDT 40288 101 20 is be VBZ 40288 101 21 at at IN 40288 101 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 101 23 command command NN 40288 101 24 , , , 40288 101 25 and and CC 40288 101 26 I -PRON- PRP 40288 101 27 hope hope VBP 40288 101 28 to to TO 40288 101 29 make make VB 40288 101 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 101 31 probable probable JJ 40288 101 32 that that IN 40288 101 33 the the DT 40288 101 34 difficulties difficulty NNS 40288 101 35 of of IN 40288 101 36 the the DT 40288 101 37 question question NN 40288 101 38 may may MD 40288 101 39 be be VB 40288 101 40 best well RBS 40288 101 41 dealt deal VBN 40288 101 42 with with IN 40288 101 43 on on IN 40288 101 44 this this DT 40288 101 45 method method NN 40288 101 46 . . . 40288 102 1 § § ADD 40288 102 2 4 4 CD 40288 102 3 . . . 40288 103 1 _ _ NNP 40288 103 2 The the DT 40288 103 3 Early early JJ 40288 103 4 Poets Poets NNPS 40288 103 5 . . . 40288 103 6 _ _ NNP 40288 103 7 The the DT 40288 103 8 earliest early JJS 40288 103 9 of of IN 40288 103 10 the the DT 40288 103 11 passages passage NNS 40288 103 12 now now RB 40288 103 13 in in IN 40288 103 14 question question NN 40288 103 15 comes come VBZ 40288 103 16 from from IN 40288 103 17 the the DT 40288 103 18 poet poet NN 40288 103 19 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 103 20 , , , 40288 103 21 a a DT 40288 103 22 contemporary contemporary NN 40288 103 23 of of IN 40288 103 24 Aeschylus Aeschylus NNP 40288 103 25 . . . 40288 104 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 104 2 is be VBZ 40288 104 3 quoted quote VBN 40288 104 4 by by IN 40288 104 5 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 104 6 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 104 7 , , , 40288 104 8 in in IN 40288 104 9 the the DT 40288 104 10 course course NN 40288 104 11 of of IN 40288 104 12 a a DT 40288 104 13 long long JJ 40288 104 14 fragment fragment NN 40288 104 15 preserved preserve VBN 40288 104 16 by by IN 40288 104 17 Athenaeus Athenaeus NNP 40288 104 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 104 19 xiv xiv NNP 40288 104 20 . . . 40288 105 1 cc cc NNP 40288 105 2 . . . 40288 106 1 19 19 CD 40288 106 2 - - SYM 40288 106 3 21 21 CD 40288 106 4 , , , 40288 106 5 p. p. NN 40288 106 6 624 624 CD 40288 106 7 _ _ NNP 40288 106 8 c_-626 c_-626 NNS 40288 106 9 _ _ NNP 40288 106 10 a a DT 40288 106 11 _ _ NNP 40288 106 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 106 13 . . . 40288 107 1 The the DT 40288 107 2 words word NNS 40288 107 3 are be VBP 40288 107 4 : : : 40288 107 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 107 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 107 7 : : : 40288 107 8 mête mête NNP 40288 107 9 syntonon syntonon NNP 40288 107 10 diôke diôke NNP 40288 107 11 mête mête NNP 40288 107 12 tan tan NNP 40288 107 13 aneimenan aneimenan JJ 40288 107 14 Iasti Iasti NNP 40288 107 15 mousan mousan NNP 40288 107 16 , , , 40288 107 17 alla alla NNP 40288 107 18 tan tan NNP 40288 107 19 messan messan NNP 40288 107 20 neôn neôn NNP 40288 107 21 arouran arouran NNP 40288 107 22 aiolize aiolize NNP 40288 107 23 tô tô NNP 40288 107 24 melei melei NNP 40288 107 25 . . . 40288 107 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 108 1 ' ' `` 40288 108 2 Follow follow VB 40288 108 3 neither neither CC 40288 108 4 a a DT 40288 108 5 highly highly RB 40288 108 6 - - HYPH 40288 108 7 strung string VBN 40288 108 8 music music NN 40288 108 9 nor nor CC 40288 108 10 the the DT 40288 108 11 low low RB 40288 108 12 - - HYPH 40288 108 13 pitched pitch VBN 40288 108 14 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 108 15 , , , 40288 108 16 but but CC 40288 108 17 turning turn VBG 40288 108 18 over over RP 40288 108 19 the the DT 40288 108 20 middle middle JJ 40288 108 21 plough plough NN 40288 108 22 - - HYPH 40288 108 23 land land NN 40288 108 24 be be VB 40288 108 25 an an DT 40288 108 26 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 108 27 in in IN 40288 108 28 your -PRON- PRP$ 40288 108 29 melody melody NN 40288 108 30 . . . 40288 108 31 ' ' '' 40288 109 1 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 109 2 takes take VBZ 40288 109 3 the the DT 40288 109 4 word word NN 40288 109 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 109 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 109 7 : : : 40288 109 8 ' ' '' 40288 109 9 Iasti iasti NN 40288 109 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 109 11 with with IN 40288 109 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 109 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 109 14 : : : 40288 109 15 syntonon syntonon NN 40288 109 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 109 17 as as RB 40288 109 18 well well RB 40288 109 19 as as IN 40288 109 20 with with IN 40288 109 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 109 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 109 23 : : : 40288 109 24 aneimenan aneimenan NNP 40288 109 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 109 26 , , , 40288 109 27 and and CC 40288 109 28 infers infer NNS 40288 109 29 that that IN 40288 109 30 there there EX 40288 109 31 were be VBD 40288 109 32 two two CD 40288 109 33 kinds kind NNS 40288 109 34 of of IN 40288 109 35 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 109 36 , , , 40288 109 37 a a DT 40288 109 38 ' ' `` 40288 109 39 highly highly RB 40288 109 40 - - HYPH 40288 109 41 strung strung JJ 40288 109 42 ' ' '' 40288 109 43 and and CC 40288 109 44 a a DT 40288 109 45 ' ' `` 40288 109 46 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 109 47 ' ' '' 40288 109 48 or or CC 40288 109 49 low low RB 40288 109 50 - - HYPH 40288 109 51 pitched pitch VBN 40288 109 52 . . . 40288 110 1 But but CC 40288 110 2 this this DT 40288 110 3 is be VBZ 40288 110 4 not not RB 40288 110 5 required require VBN 40288 110 6 by by IN 40288 110 7 the the DT 40288 110 8 words word NNS 40288 110 9 , , , 40288 110 10 and and CC 40288 110 11 seems seem VBZ 40288 110 12 less less RBR 40288 110 13 natural natural JJ 40288 110 14 than than IN 40288 110 15 the the DT 40288 110 16 interpretation interpretation NN 40288 110 17 which which WDT 40288 110 18 I -PRON- PRP 40288 110 19 have have VBP 40288 110 20 given give VBN 40288 110 21 . . . 40288 111 1 All all DT 40288 111 2 that that WDT 40288 111 3 the the DT 40288 111 4 passage passage NN 40288 111 5 proves prove VBZ 40288 111 6 is be VBZ 40288 111 7 that that IN 40288 111 8 in in IN 40288 111 9 the the DT 40288 111 10 time time NN 40288 111 11 of of IN 40288 111 12 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 111 13 a a DT 40288 111 14 composer composer NN 40288 111 15 had have VBD 40288 111 16 the the DT 40288 111 17 choice choice NN 40288 111 18 of of IN 40288 111 19 at at RB 40288 111 20 least least RBS 40288 111 21 three three CD 40288 111 22 scales scale NNS 40288 111 23 : : : 40288 111 24 one one CD 40288 111 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 111 26 or or CC 40288 111 27 more more JJR 40288 111 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 111 29 of of IN 40288 111 30 which which WDT 40288 111 31 the the DT 40288 111 32 pitch pitch NN 40288 111 33 was be VBD 40288 111 34 high high JJ 40288 111 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 111 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 111 37 Greek greek JJ 40288 111 38 : : : 40288 111 39 syntonos syntonos JJ 40288 111 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 111 41 ) ) -RRB- 40288 111 42 ; ; : 40288 111 43 another another DT 40288 111 44 of of IN 40288 111 45 low low JJ 40288 111 46 pitch pitch NN 40288 111 47 ( ( -LRB- 40288 111 48 [ [ -LRB- 40288 111 49 Greek Greek NNP 40288 111 50 : : : 40288 111 51 aneimenê aneimenê NN 40288 111 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 111 53 ) ) -RRB- 40288 111 54 , , , 40288 111 55 which which WDT 40288 111 56 was be VBD 40288 111 57 called call VBN 40288 111 58 _ _ NNP 40288 111 59 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 111 60 _ _ NNP 40288 111 61 ; ; : 40288 111 62 and and CC 40288 111 63 a a DT 40288 111 64 third third JJ 40288 111 65 , , , 40288 111 66 intermediate intermediate JJ 40288 111 67 between between IN 40288 111 68 the the DT 40288 111 69 others other NNS 40288 111 70 , , , 40288 111 71 and and CC 40288 111 72 known know VBN 40288 111 73 as as IN 40288 111 74 _ _ NNP 40288 111 75 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 111 76 _ _ NNP 40288 111 77 . . . 40288 112 1 Later later RB 40288 112 2 in in IN 40288 112 3 the the DT 40288 112 4 same same JJ 40288 112 5 passage passage NN 40288 112 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 112 7 are be VBP 40288 112 8 told tell VBN 40288 112 9 that that IN 40288 112 10 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 112 11 spoke speak VBD 40288 112 12 of of IN 40288 112 13 the the DT 40288 112 14 ' ' `` 40288 112 15 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 112 16 harmony harmony NN 40288 112 17 ' ' '' 40288 112 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 112 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 112 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 112 21 : : : 40288 112 22 prepei prepei NNP 40288 112 23 toi toi NNP 40288 112 24 pasin pasin NN 40288 112 25 aoidolabraktais aoidolabraktais NNP 40288 112 26 Aiolis Aiolis NNP 40288 112 27 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 112 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 112 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 112 30 . . . 40288 113 1 And and CC 40288 113 2 the the DT 40288 113 3 term term NN 40288 113 4 is be VBZ 40288 113 5 also also RB 40288 113 6 found find VBN 40288 113 7 , , , 40288 113 8 with with IN 40288 113 9 the the DT 40288 113 10 epithet epithet NN 40288 113 11 ' ' `` 40288 113 12 deep deep NN 40288 113 13 - - HYPH 40288 113 14 sounding sound VBG 40288 113 15 , , , 40288 113 16 ' ' '' 40288 113 17 in in IN 40288 113 18 a a DT 40288 113 19 passage passage NN 40288 113 20 quoted quote VBN 40288 113 21 from from IN 40288 113 22 the the DT 40288 113 23 hymn hymn NN 40288 113 24 to to IN 40288 113 25 Demeter Demeter NNP 40288 113 26 of of IN 40288 113 27 a a DT 40288 113 28 contemporary contemporary JJ 40288 113 29 poet poet NN 40288 113 30 , , , 40288 113 31 Lasus Lasus NNP 40288 113 32 of of IN 40288 113 33 Hermione Hermione NNP 40288 113 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 113 35 Athen Athen NNP 40288 113 36 . . . 40288 114 1 xiv xiv NNP 40288 114 2 . . . 40288 115 1 624 624 CD 40288 115 2 _ _ NNP 40288 115 3 e e NNP 40288 115 4 _ _ NNP 40288 115 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 115 6 : : : 40288 115 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 115 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 115 9 : : : 40288 115 10 Damatra Damatra NNP 40288 115 11 melpô melpô NNS 40288 115 12 Koran Koran NNP 40288 115 13 te te NNP 40288 115 14 Klymenoio Klymenoio NNP 40288 115 15 alochon alochon NN 40288 115 16 Meliboian Meliboian NNP 40288 115 17 , , , 40288 115 18 hymnôn hymnôn NN 40288 115 19 anagôn anagôn VBZ 40288 115 20 Aiolid Aiolid NNP 40288 115 21 ' ' POS 40288 115 22 hama hama NNP 40288 115 23 barybromon barybromon NN 40288 115 24 harmonian harmonian NNP 40288 115 25 . . . 40288 115 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 116 1 With with IN 40288 116 2 regard regard NN 40288 116 3 to to IN 40288 116 4 the the DT 40288 116 5 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 116 6 and and CC 40288 116 7 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 116 8 scales scale NNS 40288 116 9 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 116 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 116 11 _ _ NNP 40288 116 12 l l NN 40288 116 13 . . . 40288 117 1 c. c. NNP 40288 117 2 _ _ NNP 40288 117 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 117 4 quotes quote VBZ 40288 117 5 an an DT 40288 117 6 interesting interesting JJ 40288 117 7 passage passage NN 40288 117 8 from from IN 40288 117 9 Telestes Telestes NNP 40288 117 10 of of IN 40288 117 11 Selinus Selinus NNP 40288 117 12 , , , 40288 117 13 in in IN 40288 117 14 which which WDT 40288 117 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 117 16 introduction introduction NN 40288 117 17 is be VBZ 40288 117 18 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 117 19 to to IN 40288 117 20 the the DT 40288 117 21 colony colony NN 40288 117 22 that that WDT 40288 117 23 was be VBD 40288 117 24 said say VBN 40288 117 25 to to TO 40288 117 26 have have VB 40288 117 27 followed follow VBN 40288 117 28 Pelops Pelops NNP 40288 117 29 from from IN 40288 117 30 Asia Asia NNP 40288 117 31 Minor Minor NNP 40288 117 32 to to IN 40288 117 33 the the DT 40288 117 34 Peloponnesus Peloponnesus NNP 40288 117 35 : : : 40288 117 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 117 37 Greek Greek NNP 40288 117 38 : : : 40288 117 39 prôtoi prôtoi NNP 40288 117 40 para para NNP 40288 117 41 kratêras kratêras NNP 40288 117 42 Hellênôn Hellênôn NNP 40288 117 43 en en IN 40288 117 44 aulois aulois FW 40288 117 45 synopadoi synopadoi RB 40288 117 46 Pelopos Pelopos NNP 40288 117 47 matros matro VBZ 40288 117 48 oreias oreia NNS 40288 117 49 phrygion phrygion NNP 40288 117 50 aeison aeison NNP 40288 117 51 nomon nomon NNP 40288 117 52 ; ; : 40288 117 53 toi toi NNP 40288 117 54 d d NNP 40288 117 55 ' ' POS 40288 117 56 oxyphônois oxyphônois NNP 40288 117 57 pêktidôn pêktidôn NNP 40288 117 58 psalmois psalmois NNP 40288 117 59 krekon krekon NNP 40288 117 60 Dydion Dydion NNP 40288 117 61 hymnon hymnon NNP 40288 117 62 . . . 40288 117 63 ] ] -RRB- 40288 118 1 ' ' `` 40288 118 2 The the DT 40288 118 3 comrades comrade NNS 40288 118 4 of of IN 40288 118 5 Pelops pelop NNS 40288 118 6 were be VBD 40288 118 7 the the DT 40288 118 8 first first JJ 40288 118 9 who who WP 40288 118 10 beside beside IN 40288 118 11 the the DT 40288 118 12 Grecian grecian JJ 40288 118 13 cups cup NNS 40288 118 14 sang sing VBD 40288 118 15 with with IN 40288 118 16 the the DT 40288 118 17 flute flute NN 40288 118 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 118 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 118 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 118 21 : : : 40288 118 22 aulos aulos NNP 40288 118 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 118 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 118 25 the the DT 40288 118 26 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 118 27 measure measure NN 40288 118 28 of of IN 40288 118 29 the the DT 40288 118 30 Great Great NNP 40288 118 31 Mother Mother NNP 40288 118 32 ; ; , 40288 118 33 and and CC 40288 118 34 these these DT 40288 118 35 again again RB 40288 118 36 by by IN 40288 118 37 shrill shrill NNP 40288 118 38 - - HYPH 40288 118 39 voiced voice VBN 40288 118 40 notes note NNS 40288 118 41 of of IN 40288 118 42 the the DT 40288 118 43 _ _ NNP 40288 118 44 pectis pectis NN 40288 118 45 _ _ NNP 40288 118 46 sounded sound VBD 40288 118 47 a a DT 40288 118 48 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 118 49 hymn hymn NN 40288 118 50 . . . 40288 118 51 ' ' '' 40288 119 1 The the DT 40288 119 2 epithet epithet NN 40288 119 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 119 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 119 5 : : : 40288 119 6 oxyphônos oxyphônos NN 40288 119 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 119 8 is be VBZ 40288 119 9 worth worth JJ 40288 119 10 notice notice NN 40288 119 11 in in IN 40288 119 12 connexion connexion NN 40288 119 13 with with IN 40288 119 14 other other JJ 40288 119 15 evidence evidence NN 40288 119 16 of of IN 40288 119 17 the the DT 40288 119 18 high high JJ 40288 119 19 pitch pitch NN 40288 119 20 of of IN 40288 119 21 the the DT 40288 119 22 music music NN 40288 119 23 known know VBN 40288 119 24 as as IN 40288 119 25 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 119 26 . . . 40288 120 1 The the DT 40288 120 2 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 120 3 mode mode NN 40288 120 4 is be VBZ 40288 120 5 mentioned mention VBN 40288 120 6 by by IN 40288 120 7 Pindar Pindar NNP 40288 120 8 , , , 40288 120 9 _ _ NNP 40288 120 10 Nem Nem NNP 40288 120 11 . . NNP 40288 120 12 _ _ NNP 40288 120 13 4 4 CD 40288 120 14 . . . 40288 121 1 45 45 CD 40288 121 2 : : : 40288 121 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 121 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 121 5 : : : 40288 121 6 exyphaine exyphaine JJ 40288 121 7 glykeia glykeia VBP 40288 121 8 kai kai NNP 40288 121 9 tod tod NNP 40288 121 10 ' ' POS 40288 121 11 autika autika NNS 40288 121 12 phorminx phorminx NNP 40288 121 13 Lydia Lydia NNP 40288 121 14 syn syn NNP 40288 121 15 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 121 16 melos melos NNP 40288 121 17 pephilêmenon pephilêmenon NNP 40288 121 18 . . . 40288 121 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 122 1 The the DT 40288 122 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 122 3 is be VBZ 40288 122 4 the the DT 40288 122 5 subject subject NN 40288 122 6 of of IN 40288 122 7 an an DT 40288 122 8 elaborate elaborate JJ 40288 122 9 jest jest NN 40288 122 10 made make VBN 40288 122 11 at at IN 40288 122 12 the the DT 40288 122 13 expense expense NN 40288 122 14 of of IN 40288 122 15 Cleon Cleon NNP 40288 122 16 in in IN 40288 122 17 the the DT 40288 122 18 _ _ NNP 40288 122 19 Knights Knights NNPS 40288 122 20 _ _ NNP 40288 122 21 of of IN 40288 122 22 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40288 122 23 , , , 40288 122 24 ll will VBD 40288 122 25 . . . 40288 123 1 985 985 CD 40288 123 2 - - HYPH 40288 123 3 996 996 CD 40288 123 4 : : : 40288 123 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 123 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 123 7 : : : 40288 123 8 alla alla NN 40288 123 9 kai kai NNP 40288 123 10 tod tod NNP 40288 123 11 ' ' POS 40288 123 12 egô egô NNP 40288 123 13 ge ge NNP 40288 123 14 thaumazô thaumazô NNP 40288 123 15 tês tês NNP 40288 123 16 hyomousias hyomousias NNP 40288 123 17 autou autou NNP 40288 123 18 phasi phasi NNP 40288 123 19 gar gar NNP 40288 123 20 auton auton NNP 40288 123 21 hoi hoi NNP 40288 123 22 paides paide VBZ 40288 123 23 hoi hoi NNP 40288 123 24 xynephoitôn xynephoitôn NN 40288 123 25 tên tên NNP 40288 123 26 Dôristi Dôristi NNP 40288 123 27 monên monên NN 40288 123 28 enarmottesthai enarmottesthai NN 40288 123 29 thama thama NN 40288 123 30 tên tên NNP 40288 123 31 lyran lyran NNP 40288 123 32 , , , 40288 123 33 allên allên NNP 40288 123 34 d d NNP 40288 123 35 ' ' POS 40288 123 36 ouk ouk NNP 40288 123 37 ethelein ethelein NNP 40288 123 38 labein labein NNP 40288 123 39 ; ; : 40288 123 40 kata kata NNP 40288 123 41 ton ton NNP 40288 123 42 kitharistên kitharistên NNP 40288 123 43 orgisthent orgisthent NNP 40288 123 44 ' ' POS 40288 123 45 apagein apagein NNP 40288 123 46 keleuein keleuein NNP 40288 123 47 , , , 40288 123 48 hôs hôs NNP 40288 123 49 harmonian harmonian JJ 40288 123 50 ho ho NNP 40288 123 51 pais pais NNP 40288 123 52 outos outo NNS 40288 123 53 ou ou NNP 40288 123 54 dynatai dynatai NNP 40288 123 55 mathein mathein NNP 40288 123 56 ên ên NNP 40288 123 57 mê mê NNP 40288 123 58 Dôrodokêsti Dôrodokêsti NNP 40288 123 59 . . . 40288 123 60 ] ] -RRB- 40288 124 1 § § ADD 40288 124 2 5 5 CD 40288 124 3 . . . 40288 125 1 _ _ NNP 40288 125 2 Plato Plato NNP 40288 125 3 . . . 40288 125 4 _ _ NNP 40288 125 5 Following follow VBG 40288 125 6 the the DT 40288 125 7 order order NN 40288 125 8 of of IN 40288 125 9 time time NN 40288 125 10 , , , 40288 125 11 we -PRON- PRP 40288 125 12 come come VBP 40288 125 13 next next RB 40288 125 14 to to IN 40288 125 15 the the DT 40288 125 16 passage passage NN 40288 125 17 in in IN 40288 125 18 the the DT 40288 125 19 _ _ NNP 40288 125 20 Republic Republic NNP 40288 125 21 _ _ NNP 40288 125 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 125 23 p. p. NN 40288 125 24 398 398 CD 40288 125 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 125 26 , , , 40288 125 27 where where WRB 40288 125 28 Socrates Socrates NNP 40288 125 29 is be VBZ 40288 125 30 endeavouring endeavour VBG 40288 125 31 to to TO 40288 125 32 determine determine VB 40288 125 33 the the DT 40288 125 34 kinds kind NNS 40288 125 35 of of IN 40288 125 36 music music NN 40288 125 37 to to TO 40288 125 38 be be VB 40288 125 39 admitted admit VBN 40288 125 40 for for IN 40288 125 41 the the DT 40288 125 42 use use NN 40288 125 43 of of IN 40288 125 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 125 45 future future NN 40288 125 46 ' ' `` 40288 125 47 guardians guardian NNS 40288 125 48 , , , 40288 125 49 ' ' '' 40288 125 50 in in IN 40288 125 51 accordance accordance NN 40288 125 52 with with IN 40288 125 53 the the DT 40288 125 54 general general JJ 40288 125 55 principles principle NNS 40288 125 56 which which WDT 40288 125 57 are be VBP 40288 125 58 to to TO 40288 125 59 govern govern VB 40288 125 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 125 61 education education NN 40288 125 62 . . . 40288 126 1 First first RB 40288 126 2 among among IN 40288 126 3 these these DT 40288 126 4 principles principle NNS 40288 126 5 is be VBZ 40288 126 6 the the DT 40288 126 7 condemnation condemnation NN 40288 126 8 of of IN 40288 126 9 all all DT 40288 126 10 undue undue JJ 40288 126 11 expression expression NN 40288 126 12 of of IN 40288 126 13 grief grief NN 40288 126 14 . . . 40288 127 1 ' ' `` 40288 127 2 What what WP 40288 127 3 modes mode NNS 40288 127 4 of of IN 40288 127 5 music music NN 40288 127 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 127 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 127 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 127 9 : : : 40288 127 10 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 127 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 127 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 127 13 , , , 40288 127 14 ' ' '' 40288 127 15 he -PRON- PRP 40288 127 16 asks ask VBZ 40288 127 17 , , , 40288 127 18 are be VBP 40288 127 19 plaintive plaintive JJ 40288 127 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 127 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 127 22 Greek greek JJ 40288 127 23 : : : 40288 127 24 thrênôdeis thrênôdeis NN 40288 127 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 127 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 127 27 ? ? . 40288 127 28 ' ' '' 40288 128 1 ' ' `` 40288 128 2 The the DT 40288 128 3 _ _ NNP 40288 128 4 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 128 5 - - HYPH 40288 128 6 lydian lydian NNP 40288 128 7 _ _ NNP 40288 128 8 , , , 40288 128 9 ' ' '' 40288 128 10 Glaucon glaucon NN 40288 128 11 replies reply VBZ 40288 128 12 , , , 40288 128 13 ' ' '' 40288 128 14 and and CC 40288 128 15 the the DT 40288 128 16 _ _ NNP 40288 128 17 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 128 18 - - HYPH 40288 128 19 lydian lydian NNP 40288 128 20 _ _ NNP 40288 128 21 , , , 40288 128 22 and and CC 40288 128 23 such such JJ 40288 128 24 - - HYPH 40288 128 25 like like JJ 40288 128 26 . . . 40288 128 27 ' ' '' 40288 129 1 These these DT 40288 129 2 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 129 3 Socrates socrate VBZ 40288 129 4 excludes exclude NNS 40288 129 5 . . . 40288 130 1 ' ' `` 40288 130 2 But but CC 40288 130 3 again again RB 40288 130 4 , , , 40288 130 5 drunkenness drunkenness NN 40288 130 6 and and CC 40288 130 7 slothfulness slothfulness NN 40288 130 8 are be VBP 40288 130 9 no no RB 40288 130 10 less less RBR 40288 130 11 forbidden forbidden JJ 40288 130 12 to to IN 40288 130 13 the the DT 40288 130 14 guardians guardian NNS 40288 130 15 ; ; : 40288 130 16 which which WDT 40288 130 17 of of IN 40288 130 18 the the DT 40288 130 19 modes mode NNS 40288 130 20 are be VBP 40288 130 21 soft soft JJ 40288 130 22 and and CC 40288 130 23 convivial convivial JJ 40288 130 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 130 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 130 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 130 27 : : : 40288 130 28 malakai malakai NNP 40288 130 29 te te NNP 40288 130 30 kai kai NNP 40288 130 31 sympotikai sympotikai NNP 40288 130 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 130 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 130 34 ? ? . 40288 130 35 ' ' '' 40288 131 1 ' ' `` 40288 131 2 _ _ NNP 40288 131 3 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 131 4 _ _ NNP 40288 131 5 , , , 40288 131 6 ' ' '' 40288 131 7 says say VBZ 40288 131 8 Glaucon Glaucon NNP 40288 131 9 , , , 40288 131 10 ' ' '' 40288 131 11 and and CC 40288 131 12 _ _ NNP 40288 131 13 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 131 14 _ _ NNP 40288 131 15 , , , 40288 131 16 those those DT 40288 131 17 which which WDT 40288 131 18 are be VBP 40288 131 19 called call VBN 40288 131 20 slack slack NN 40288 131 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 131 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 131 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 131 24 : : : 40288 131 25 chalarai chalarai NN 40288 131 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 131 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 131 28 . . . 40288 131 29 ' ' '' 40288 132 1 ' ' `` 40288 132 2 Which which WDT 40288 132 3 then then RB 40288 132 4 remain remain VBP 40288 132 5 ? ? . 40288 132 6 ' ' '' 40288 133 1 ' ' `` 40288 133 2 Seemingly seemingly RB 40288 133 3 _ _ NNP 40288 133 4 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 133 5 _ _ NNP 40288 133 6 and and CC 40288 133 7 _ _ NNP 40288 133 8 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 133 9 _ _ NNP 40288 133 10 . . . 40288 133 11 ' ' '' 40288 134 1 ' ' `` 40288 134 2 I -PRON- PRP 40288 134 3 do do VBP 40288 134 4 not not RB 40288 134 5 know know VB 40288 134 6 the the DT 40288 134 7 modes mode NNS 40288 134 8 , , , 40288 134 9 ' ' '' 40288 134 10 says say VBZ 40288 134 11 Socrates Socrates NNP 40288 134 12 , , , 40288 134 13 ' ' '' 40288 134 14 but but CC 40288 134 15 leave leave VB 40288 134 16 me -PRON- PRP 40288 134 17 one one NN 40288 134 18 that that WDT 40288 134 19 will will MD 40288 134 20 imitate imitate VB 40288 134 21 the the DT 40288 134 22 tones tone NNS 40288 134 23 and and CC 40288 134 24 accents accent NNS 40288 134 25 of of IN 40288 134 26 a a DT 40288 134 27 brave brave JJ 40288 134 28 man man NN 40288 134 29 enduring endure VBG 40288 134 30 danger danger NN 40288 134 31 or or CC 40288 134 32 distress distress NN 40288 134 33 , , , 40288 134 34 fighting fight VBG 40288 134 35 with with IN 40288 134 36 constancy constancy NN 40288 134 37 against against IN 40288 134 38 fortune fortune NN 40288 134 39 : : : 40288 134 40 and and CC 40288 134 41 also also RB 40288 134 42 one one CD 40288 134 43 fitted fit VBD 40288 134 44 for for IN 40288 134 45 the the DT 40288 134 46 work work NN 40288 134 47 of of IN 40288 134 48 peace peace NN 40288 134 49 , , , 40288 134 50 for for IN 40288 134 51 prayer prayer NN 40288 134 52 heard hear VBN 40288 134 53 by by IN 40288 134 54 the the DT 40288 134 55 gods god NNS 40288 134 56 , , , 40288 134 57 for for IN 40288 134 58 the the DT 40288 134 59 successful successful JJ 40288 134 60 persuasion persuasion NN 40288 134 61 or or CC 40288 134 62 exhortation exhortation NN 40288 134 63 of of IN 40288 134 64 men man NNS 40288 134 65 , , , 40288 134 66 and and CC 40288 134 67 generally generally RB 40288 134 68 for for IN 40288 134 69 the the DT 40288 134 70 sober sober JJ 40288 134 71 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40288 134 72 of of IN 40288 134 73 ease ease NN 40288 134 74 and and CC 40288 134 75 prosperity prosperity NN 40288 134 76 . . . 40288 134 77 ' ' '' 40288 135 1 Two two CD 40288 135 2 such such JJ 40288 135 3 modes mode NNS 40288 135 4 , , , 40288 135 5 one one CD 40288 135 6 for for IN 40288 135 7 Courage Courage NNP 40288 135 8 and and CC 40288 135 9 one one CD 40288 135 10 for for IN 40288 135 11 Temperance Temperance NNP 40288 135 12 , , , 40288 135 13 are be VBP 40288 135 14 declared declare VBN 40288 135 15 by by IN 40288 135 16 Glaucon Glaucon NNP 40288 135 17 to to TO 40288 135 18 be be VB 40288 135 19 found find VBN 40288 135 20 in in IN 40288 135 21 the the DT 40288 135 22 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 135 23 and and CC 40288 135 24 the the DT 40288 135 25 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 135 26 . . . 40288 136 1 In in IN 40288 136 2 the the DT 40288 136 3 _ _ NNP 40288 136 4 Laches Laches NNP 40288 136 5 _ _ NNP 40288 136 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 136 7 p. p. NN 40288 136 8 188 188 CD 40288 136 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 136 10 there there EX 40288 136 11 is be VBZ 40288 136 12 a a DT 40288 136 13 passing pass VBG 40288 136 14 reference reference NN 40288 136 15 in in IN 40288 136 16 which which WDT 40288 136 17 a a DT 40288 136 18 similar similar JJ 40288 136 19 view view NN 40288 136 20 is be VBZ 40288 136 21 expressed express VBN 40288 136 22 . . . 40288 137 1 Plato Plato NNP 40288 137 2 is be VBZ 40288 137 3 speaking speak VBG 40288 137 4 of of IN 40288 137 5 the the DT 40288 137 6 character character NN 40288 137 7 of of IN 40288 137 8 a a DT 40288 137 9 brave brave JJ 40288 137 10 man man NN 40288 137 11 as as IN 40288 137 12 being be VBG 40288 137 13 metaphorically metaphorically RB 40288 137 14 a a DT 40288 137 15 ' ' `` 40288 137 16 harmony harmony NN 40288 137 17 , , , 40288 137 18 ' ' '' 40288 137 19 by by IN 40288 137 20 which which WDT 40288 137 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 137 22 life life NN 40288 137 23 is be VBZ 40288 137 24 made make VBN 40288 137 25 consonant consonant JJ 40288 137 26 to to TO 40288 137 27 reason--'a reason--'a VB 40288 137 28 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 137 29 harmony harmony NN 40288 137 30 , , , 40288 137 31 ' ' '' 40288 137 32 he -PRON- PRP 40288 137 33 adds add VBZ 40288 137 34 -- -- : 40288 137 35 playing play VBG 40288 137 36 upon upon IN 40288 137 37 the the DT 40288 137 38 musical musical JJ 40288 137 39 sense sense NN 40288 137 40 of of IN 40288 137 41 the the DT 40288 137 42 word--'not word--'not NN 40288 137 43 an an DT 40288 137 44 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 137 45 , , , 40288 137 46 certainly certainly RB 40288 137 47 not not RB 40288 137 48 a a DT 40288 137 49 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 137 50 or or CC 40288 137 51 a a DT 40288 137 52 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 137 53 , , , 40288 137 54 but but CC 40288 137 55 that that IN 40288 137 56 one one NN 40288 137 57 which which WDT 40288 137 58 only only RB 40288 137 59 is be VBZ 40288 137 60 truly truly RB 40288 137 61 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40288 137 62 ' ' '' 40288 137 63 ( ( -LRB- 40288 137 64 [ [ -LRB- 40288 137 65 Greek greek JJ 40288 137 66 : : : 40288 137 67 atechnôs atechnôs NN 40288 137 68 Dôristi Dôristi NNP 40288 137 69 , , , 40288 137 70 all all DT 40288 137 71 ' ' '' 40288 137 72 ouk ouk NNP 40288 137 73 Iasti Iasti NNP 40288 137 74 , , , 40288 137 75 oiomai oiomai NNP 40288 137 76 de de NNP 40288 137 77 oude oude NN 40288 137 78 Phrygisti Phrygisti NNP 40288 137 79 oude oude NN 40288 137 80 Lydisti Lydisti NNP 40288 137 81 , , , 40288 137 82 all all DT 40288 137 83 ' ' '' 40288 137 84 hê hê VB 40288 137 85 per per IN 40288 137 86 monê monê NN 40288 137 87 Hellênikê Hellênikê NNP 40288 137 88 estin estin NNP 40288 137 89 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 137 90 ] ] -RRB- 40288 137 91 ) ) -RRB- 40288 137 92 . . . 40288 138 1 The the DT 40288 138 2 exclusion exclusion NN 40288 138 3 of of IN 40288 138 4 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 138 5 may may MD 40288 138 6 be be VB 40288 138 7 due due IN 40288 138 8 to to IN 40288 138 9 the the DT 40288 138 10 fact fact NN 40288 138 11 that that IN 40288 138 12 the the DT 40288 138 13 virtue virtue NN 40288 138 14 discussed discuss VBN 40288 138 15 in in IN 40288 138 16 the the DT 40288 138 17 _ _ NNP 40288 138 18 Laches Laches NNP 40288 138 19 _ _ NNP 40288 138 20 is be VBZ 40288 138 21 courage courage NN 40288 138 22 ; ; : 40288 138 23 but but CC 40288 138 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 138 25 is be VBZ 40288 138 26 in in IN 40288 138 27 agreement agreement NN 40288 138 28 with with IN 40288 138 29 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 138 30 's 's POS 40288 138 31 opinion opinion NN 40288 138 32 . . . 40288 139 1 The the DT 40288 139 2 absence absence NN 40288 139 3 of of IN 40288 139 4 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 139 5 from from IN 40288 139 6 both both CC 40288 139 7 the the DT 40288 139 8 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 139 9 passages passage NNS 40288 139 10 seems seem VBZ 40288 139 11 to to TO 40288 139 12 show show VB 40288 139 13 that that IN 40288 139 14 it -PRON- PRP 40288 139 15 had have VBD 40288 139 16 gone go VBN 40288 139 17 out out IN 40288 139 18 of of IN 40288 139 19 use use NN 40288 139 20 in in IN 40288 139 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 139 22 time time NN 40288 139 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 139 24 but but CC 40288 139 25 cp cp NNP 40288 139 26 . . . 40288 140 1 p. p. NN 40288 140 2 11 11 CD 40288 140 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 140 4 . . . 40288 141 1 The the DT 40288 141 2 point point NN 40288 141 3 of of IN 40288 141 4 view view NN 40288 141 5 from from IN 40288 141 6 which which WDT 40288 141 7 Plato Plato NNP 40288 141 8 professes profess VBZ 40288 141 9 to to TO 40288 141 10 determine determine VB 40288 141 11 the the DT 40288 141 12 right right JJ 40288 141 13 modes mode NNS 40288 141 14 to to TO 40288 141 15 be be VB 40288 141 16 used use VBN 40288 141 17 in in IN 40288 141 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 141 19 ideal ideal JJ 40288 141 20 education education NN 40288 141 21 appears appear VBZ 40288 141 22 clearly clearly RB 40288 141 23 in in IN 40288 141 24 the the DT 40288 141 25 passage passage NN 40288 141 26 of of IN 40288 141 27 the the DT 40288 141 28 _ _ NNP 40288 141 29 Republic Republic NNP 40288 141 30 _ _ NNP 40288 141 31 . . . 40288 142 1 The the DT 40288 142 2 modes mode NNS 40288 142 3 first first RB 40288 142 4 rejected reject VBN 40288 142 5 are be VBP 40288 142 6 those those DT 40288 142 7 which which WDT 40288 142 8 are be VBP 40288 142 9 high high JJ 40288 142 10 in in IN 40288 142 11 pitch pitch NN 40288 142 12 . . . 40288 143 1 The the DT 40288 143 2 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 143 3 - - HYPH 40288 143 4 lydian lydian NNP 40288 143 5 or or CC 40288 143 6 ' ' `` 40288 143 7 high high JJ 40288 143 8 - - HYPH 40288 143 9 strung strung NN 40288 143 10 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 143 11 ' ' POS 40288 143 12 is be VBZ 40288 143 13 shown show VBN 40288 143 14 by by IN 40288 143 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 143 16 name name NN 40288 143 17 to to TO 40288 143 18 be be VB 40288 143 19 of of IN 40288 143 20 this this DT 40288 143 21 class class NN 40288 143 22 . . . 40288 144 1 The the DT 40288 144 2 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 144 3 - - HYPH 40288 144 4 lydian lydian NNP 40288 144 5 is be VBZ 40288 144 6 similar similar JJ 40288 144 7 , , , 40288 144 8 as as IN 40288 144 9 we -PRON- PRP 40288 144 10 shall shall MD 40288 144 11 see see VB 40288 144 12 from from IN 40288 144 13 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 144 14 and and CC 40288 144 15 other other JJ 40288 144 16 writers writer NNS 40288 144 17 . . . 40288 145 1 The the DT 40288 145 2 second second JJ 40288 145 3 group group NN 40288 145 4 which which WDT 40288 145 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 145 6 condemns condemn VBZ 40288 145 7 is be VBZ 40288 145 8 that that DT 40288 145 9 of of IN 40288 145 10 the the DT 40288 145 11 ' ' `` 40288 145 12 slack slack NN 40288 145 13 ' ' '' 40288 145 14 or or CC 40288 145 15 low low RB 40288 145 16 - - HYPH 40288 145 17 pitched pitch VBN 40288 145 18 . . . 40288 146 1 Thus thus RB 40288 146 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 146 3 is be VBZ 40288 146 4 on on IN 40288 146 5 the the DT 40288 146 6 profoundly profoundly RB 40288 146 7 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40288 146 8 principle principle NN 40288 146 9 of of IN 40288 146 10 choosing choose VBG 40288 146 11 the the DT 40288 146 12 mean mean NN 40288 146 13 between between IN 40288 146 14 opposite opposite JJ 40288 146 15 extremes extreme NNS 40288 146 16 that that WDT 40288 146 17 he -PRON- PRP 40288 146 18 approves approve VBZ 40288 146 19 of of IN 40288 146 20 the the DT 40288 146 21 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 146 22 and and CC 40288 146 23 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 146 24 pitch pitch NN 40288 146 25 . . . 40288 147 1 The the DT 40288 147 2 application application NN 40288 147 3 of of IN 40288 147 4 this this DT 40288 147 5 principle principle NN 40288 147 6 was be VBD 40288 147 7 not not RB 40288 147 8 a a DT 40288 147 9 new new JJ 40288 147 10 one one NN 40288 147 11 , , , 40288 147 12 for for IN 40288 147 13 it -PRON- PRP 40288 147 14 had have VBD 40288 147 15 been be VBN 40288 147 16 already already RB 40288 147 17 laid lay VBN 40288 147 18 down down RP 40288 147 19 by by IN 40288 147 20 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 147 21 : : : 40288 147 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 147 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 147 24 : : : 40288 147 25 mête mête NNP 40288 147 26 syntonon syntonon NNP 40288 147 27 diôke diôke NNP 40288 147 28 mête mête NNP 40288 147 29 tan tan NNP 40288 147 30 aneimenan aneimenan NNP 40288 147 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 147 32 . . . 40288 148 1 The the DT 40288 148 2 three three CD 40288 148 3 chapters chapter NNS 40288 148 4 which which WDT 40288 148 5 Aristotle aristotle VBP 40288 148 6 devotes devote VBZ 40288 148 7 to to IN 40288 148 8 a a DT 40288 148 9 discussion discussion NN 40288 148 10 of of IN 40288 148 11 the the DT 40288 148 12 use use NN 40288 148 13 of of IN 40288 148 14 music music NN 40288 148 15 in in IN 40288 148 16 the the DT 40288 148 17 state state NN 40288 148 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 148 19 _ _ NNP 40288 148 20 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 148 21 _ _ NNP 40288 148 22 viii viii NNS 40288 148 23 . . . 40288 149 1 cc cc NNP 40288 149 2 . . . 40288 150 1 5 5 CD 40288 150 2 - - SYM 40288 150 3 7 7 CD 40288 150 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 150 5 , , , 40288 150 6 and and CC 40288 150 7 in in IN 40288 150 8 which which WDT 40288 150 9 he -PRON- PRP 40288 150 10 reviews review VBZ 40288 150 11 and and CC 40288 150 12 criticises criticise VBZ 40288 150 13 the the DT 40288 150 14 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 150 15 treatment treatment NN 40288 150 16 of of IN 40288 150 17 the the DT 40288 150 18 same same JJ 40288 150 19 subject subject NN 40288 150 20 , , , 40288 150 21 will will MD 40288 150 22 be be VB 40288 150 23 found find VBN 40288 150 24 entirely entirely RB 40288 150 25 to to TO 40288 150 26 bear bear VB 40288 150 27 out out RP 40288 150 28 the the DT 40288 150 29 view view NN 40288 150 30 now now RB 40288 150 31 taken take VBN 40288 150 32 . . . 40288 151 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 151 2 is be VBZ 40288 151 3 also also RB 40288 151 4 supported support VBN 40288 151 5 by by IN 40288 151 6 the the DT 40288 151 7 commentary commentary NN 40288 151 8 of of IN 40288 151 9 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 151 10 , , , 40288 151 11 in in IN 40288 151 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 151 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40288 151 14 on on IN 40288 151 15 Music Music NNP 40288 151 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 151 17 cc cc NNP 40288 151 18 . . . 40288 152 1 15 15 CD 40288 152 2 - - SYM 40288 152 3 17 17 CD 40288 152 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 152 5 , , , 40288 152 6 of of IN 40288 152 7 which which WDT 40288 152 8 we -PRON- PRP 40288 152 9 shall shall MD 40288 152 10 have have VB 40288 152 11 something something NN 40288 152 12 to to TO 40288 152 13 say say VB 40288 152 14 hereafter hereafter RB 40288 152 15 . . . 40288 153 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 40288 153 2 , , , 40288 153 3 following follow VBG 40288 153 4 the the DT 40288 153 5 chronological chronological JJ 40288 153 6 order order NN 40288 153 7 of of IN 40288 153 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 153 9 authorities authority NNS 40288 153 10 , , , 40288 153 11 we -PRON- PRP 40288 153 12 come come VBP 40288 153 13 next next RB 40288 153 14 to to IN 40288 153 15 the the DT 40288 153 16 fragment fragment NN 40288 153 17 of of IN 40288 153 18 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 153 19 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 153 20 already already RB 40288 153 21 mentioned mention VBD 40288 153 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 153 23 Athen Athen NNP 40288 153 24 . . . 40288 154 1 xiv xiv NNP 40288 154 2 . . . 40288 155 1 p. p. NN 40288 155 2 624 624 CD 40288 155 3 _ _ NNP 40288 155 4 c_-626 c_-626 NNS 40288 155 5 _ _ NNP 40288 155 6 a a DT 40288 155 7 _ _ NNP 40288 155 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 155 9 . . . 40288 156 1 § § ADD 40288 156 2 6 6 CD 40288 156 3 . . . 40288 157 1 _ _ NNP 40288 157 2 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 157 3 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 157 4 . . . 40288 157 5 _ _ NNP 40288 157 6 The the DT 40288 157 7 chief chief JJ 40288 157 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40288 157 9 maintained maintain VBN 40288 157 10 by by IN 40288 157 11 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 157 12 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 157 13 is be VBZ 40288 157 14 that that IN 40288 157 15 there there EX 40288 157 16 are be VBP 40288 157 17 three three CD 40288 157 18 modes mode NNS 40288 157 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 157 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 157 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 157 22 : : : 40288 157 23 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 157 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 157 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 157 26 , , , 40288 157 27 belonging belong VBG 40288 157 28 to to IN 40288 157 29 the the DT 40288 157 30 three three CD 40288 157 31 Greek greek JJ 40288 157 32 races race NNS 40288 157 33 -- -- : 40288 157 34 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 157 35 , , , 40288 157 36 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 157 37 , , , 40288 157 38 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 157 39 . . . 40288 158 1 The the DT 40288 158 2 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 158 3 and and CC 40288 158 4 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 158 5 , , , 40288 158 6 in in IN 40288 158 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 158 8 view view NN 40288 158 9 , , , 40288 158 10 had have VBD 40288 158 11 no no DT 40288 158 12 right right NN 40288 158 13 to to IN 40288 158 14 the the DT 40288 158 15 name name NN 40288 158 16 of of IN 40288 158 17 mode mode NN 40288 158 18 or or CC 40288 158 19 ' ' `` 40288 158 20 harmony harmony NN 40288 158 21 ' ' '' 40288 158 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 158 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 158 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 158 25 : : : 40288 158 26 oud oud JJ 40288 158 27 ' ' '' 40288 158 28 harmonian harmonian NNP 40288 158 29 phêsi phêsi NN 40288 158 30 dein dein NNP 40288 158 31 kaleisthai kaleisthai NNP 40288 158 32 tên tên NNP 40288 158 33 Phrygion Phrygion NNP 40288 158 34 , , , 40288 158 35 kathaper kathaper VB 40288 158 36 oude oude NN 40288 158 37 tên tên NN 40288 158 38 Lydion Lydion NNP 40288 158 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 158 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 158 41 . . . 40288 159 1 The the DT 40288 159 2 three three CD 40288 159 3 which which WDT 40288 159 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 159 5 recognized recognize VBD 40288 159 6 had have VBD 40288 159 7 each each DT 40288 159 8 a a DT 40288 159 9 marked marked JJ 40288 159 10 ethos ethos NN 40288 159 11 . . . 40288 160 1 The the DT 40288 160 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 160 3 reflected reflect VBD 40288 160 4 the the DT 40288 160 5 military military JJ 40288 160 6 traditions tradition NNS 40288 160 7 and and CC 40288 160 8 temper temper NN 40288 160 9 of of IN 40288 160 10 Sparta Sparta NNP 40288 160 11 . . . 40288 161 1 The the DT 40288 161 2 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 161 3 , , , 40288 161 4 which which WDT 40288 161 5 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 161 6 identified identify VBD 40288 161 7 with with IN 40288 161 8 the the DT 40288 161 9 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 161 10 - - HYPH 40288 161 11 dorian dorian NNP 40288 161 12 of of IN 40288 161 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 161 14 own own JJ 40288 161 15 time time NN 40288 161 16 , , , 40288 161 17 answered answer VBD 40288 161 18 to to IN 40288 161 19 the the DT 40288 161 20 national national JJ 40288 161 21 character character NN 40288 161 22 of of IN 40288 161 23 the the DT 40288 161 24 Thessalians Thessalians NNPS 40288 161 25 , , , 40288 161 26 which which WDT 40288 161 27 was be VBD 40288 161 28 bold bold JJ 40288 161 29 and and CC 40288 161 30 gay gay JJ 40288 161 31 , , , 40288 161 32 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 161 33 overweening overweening JJ 40288 161 34 and and CC 40288 161 35 self self NN 40288 161 36 - - HYPH 40288 161 37 indulgent indulgent JJ 40288 161 38 , , , 40288 161 39 but but CC 40288 161 40 hospitable hospitable JJ 40288 161 41 and and CC 40288 161 42 chivalrous chivalrous JJ 40288 161 43 . . . 40288 162 1 Some some DT 40288 162 2 said say VBD 40288 162 3 that that IN 40288 162 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 162 5 was be VBD 40288 162 6 called call VBN 40288 162 7 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 162 8 - - HYPH 40288 162 9 dorian dorian JJ 40288 162 10 because because IN 40288 162 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 162 12 was be VBD 40288 162 13 below below IN 40288 162 14 the the DT 40288 162 15 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 162 16 on on IN 40288 162 17 the the DT 40288 162 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 162 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 162 20 : : : 40288 162 21 aulos aulos NNP 40288 162 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 162 23 or or CC 40288 162 24 flute flute VB 40288 162 25 ; ; : 40288 162 26 but but CC 40288 162 27 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 162 28 thinks think VBZ 40288 162 29 that that IN 40288 162 30 the the DT 40288 162 31 name name NN 40288 162 32 merely merely RB 40288 162 33 expressed express VBD 40288 162 34 likeness likeness NN 40288 162 35 to to IN 40288 162 36 the the DT 40288 162 37 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 162 38 character character NN 40288 162 39 ( ( -LRB- 40288 162 40 [ [ -LRB- 40288 162 41 Greek Greek NNP 40288 162 42 : : : 40288 162 43 Dôrion dôrion NN 40288 162 44 men man NNS 40288 162 45 autên autên VBP 40288 162 46 ou ou NNP 40288 162 47 nomizein nomizein NNP 40288 162 48 , , , 40288 162 49 prosempherê prosempherê NN 40288 162 50 de de NNP 40288 162 51 pôs pôs NNP 40288 162 52 ekeinê ekeinê NNP 40288 162 53 ] ] -RRB- 40288 162 54 ) ) -RRB- 40288 162 55 . . . 40288 163 1 The the DT 40288 163 2 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 163 3 , , , 40288 163 4 again again RB 40288 163 5 , , , 40288 163 6 was be VBD 40288 163 7 harsh harsh JJ 40288 163 8 and and CC 40288 163 9 severe severe JJ 40288 163 10 , , , 40288 163 11 expressive expressive JJ 40288 163 12 of of IN 40288 163 13 the the DT 40288 163 14 unkindly unkindly JJ 40288 163 15 disposition disposition NN 40288 163 16 fostered foster VBN 40288 163 17 amid amid IN 40288 163 18 the the DT 40288 163 19 pride pride NN 40288 163 20 and and CC 40288 163 21 material material JJ 40288 163 22 welfare welfare NN 40288 163 23 of of IN 40288 163 24 Miletus Miletus NNP 40288 163 25 . . . 40288 164 1 Heraclides heraclide NNS 40288 164 2 is be VBZ 40288 164 3 inclined inclined JJ 40288 164 4 to to TO 40288 164 5 say say VB 40288 164 6 that that IN 40288 164 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 164 8 was be VBD 40288 164 9 not not RB 40288 164 10 properly properly RB 40288 164 11 a a DT 40288 164 12 distinct distinct JJ 40288 164 13 musical musical JJ 40288 164 14 scale scale NN 40288 164 15 or or CC 40288 164 16 ' ' `` 40288 164 17 harmony harmony NN 40288 164 18 , , , 40288 164 19 ' ' '' 40288 164 20 but but CC 40288 164 21 a a DT 40288 164 22 strange strange JJ 40288 164 23 aberration aberration NN 40288 164 24 in in IN 40288 164 25 the the DT 40288 164 26 form form NN 40288 164 27 of of IN 40288 164 28 the the DT 40288 164 29 musical musical JJ 40288 164 30 scale scale NN 40288 164 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 164 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 164 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 164 34 : : : 40288 164 35 tropon tropon NNP 40288 164 36 de de NNP 40288 164 37 tina tina NNP 40288 164 38 thaumaston thaumaston NNP 40288 164 39 schêmatos schêmatos NNP 40288 164 40 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 164 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 164 42 ) ) -RRB- 40288 164 43 . . . 40288 165 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 165 2 goes go VBZ 40288 165 3 on on RP 40288 165 4 to to TO 40288 165 5 protest protest VB 40288 165 6 against against IN 40288 165 7 those those DT 40288 165 8 who who WP 40288 165 9 do do VBP 40288 165 10 not not RB 40288 165 11 appreciate appreciate VB 40288 165 12 differences difference NNS 40288 165 13 of of IN 40288 165 14 kind kind NN 40288 165 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 165 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 165 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 165 18 : : : 40288 165 19 tas tas NNP 40288 165 20 kat kat NNP 40288 165 21 ' ' POS 40288 165 22 eidos eidos NNP 40288 165 23 diaphoras diaphoras NNP 40288 165 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 165 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 165 26 , , , 40288 165 27 and and CC 40288 165 28 are be VBP 40288 165 29 guided guide VBN 40288 165 30 only only RB 40288 165 31 by by IN 40288 165 32 the the DT 40288 165 33 high high JJ 40288 165 34 or or CC 40288 165 35 low low JJ 40288 165 36 pitch pitch NN 40288 165 37 of of IN 40288 165 38 the the DT 40288 165 39 notes note NNS 40288 165 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 165 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 165 42 Greek Greek NNP 40288 165 43 : : : 40288 165 44 tê tê DT 40288 165 45 tôn tôn NNP 40288 165 46 phthongôn phthongôn NNPS 40288 165 47 exytêti exytêti NNP 40288 165 48 kai kai NNP 40288 165 49 barytêti barytêti NNP 40288 165 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 165 51 ) ) -RRB- 40288 165 52 ; ; : 40288 165 53 so so IN 40288 165 54 that that IN 40288 165 55 they -PRON- PRP 40288 165 56 make make VBP 40288 165 57 a a DT 40288 165 58 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 165 59 - - HYPH 40288 165 60 mixolydian mixolydian NNP 40288 165 61 , , , 40288 165 62 and and CC 40288 165 63 another another DT 40288 165 64 again again RB 40288 165 65 above above IN 40288 165 66 that that DT 40288 165 67 . . . 40288 166 1 ' ' `` 40288 166 2 I -PRON- PRP 40288 166 3 do do VBP 40288 166 4 not not RB 40288 166 5 see see VB 40288 166 6 , , , 40288 166 7 ' ' '' 40288 166 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 166 9 adds add VBZ 40288 166 10 , , , 40288 166 11 ' ' `` 40288 166 12 that that IN 40288 166 13 the the DT 40288 166 14 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 166 15 - - HYPH 40288 166 16 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 166 17 has have VBZ 40288 166 18 a a DT 40288 166 19 distinct distinct JJ 40288 166 20 ethos ethos NN 40288 166 21 ; ; : 40288 166 22 and and CC 40288 166 23 yet yet RB 40288 166 24 some some DT 40288 166 25 say say VBP 40288 166 26 that that IN 40288 166 27 they -PRON- PRP 40288 166 28 have have VBP 40288 166 29 discovered discover VBN 40288 166 30 a a DT 40288 166 31 new new JJ 40288 166 32 mode mode NN 40288 166 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 166 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 166 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 166 36 : : : 40288 166 37 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 166 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 166 39 ) ) -RRB- 40288 166 40 , , , 40288 166 41 the the DT 40288 166 42 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 166 43 - - HYPH 40288 166 44 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 166 45 . . . 40288 167 1 But but CC 40288 167 2 a a DT 40288 167 3 mode mode NN 40288 167 4 ought ought MD 40288 167 5 to to TO 40288 167 6 have have VB 40288 167 7 a a DT 40288 167 8 distinct distinct JJ 40288 167 9 moral moral JJ 40288 167 10 or or CC 40288 167 11 emotional emotional JJ 40288 167 12 character character NN 40288 167 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 167 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 167 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 167 16 : : : 40288 167 17 eidos eidos NNP 40288 167 18 echein echein NNP 40288 167 19 ethous ethous JJ 40288 167 20 hê hê NNP 40288 167 21 pathous pathous JJ 40288 167 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 167 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 167 24 , , , 40288 167 25 as as IN 40288 167 26 the the DT 40288 167 27 Locrian Locrian NNP 40288 167 28 , , , 40288 167 29 which which WDT 40288 167 30 was be VBD 40288 167 31 in in IN 40288 167 32 use use NN 40288 167 33 in in IN 40288 167 34 the the DT 40288 167 35 time time NN 40288 167 36 of of IN 40288 167 37 Simonides Simonides NNP 40288 167 38 and and CC 40288 167 39 Pindar Pindar NNP 40288 167 40 , , , 40288 167 41 but but CC 40288 167 42 went go VBD 40288 167 43 out out IN 40288 167 44 of of IN 40288 167 45 fashion fashion NN 40288 167 46 again again RB 40288 167 47 . . . 40288 167 48 ' ' '' 40288 168 1 The the DT 40288 168 2 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 168 3 and and CC 40288 168 4 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 168 5 , , , 40288 168 6 as as IN 40288 168 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 168 8 have have VBP 40288 168 9 seen see VBN 40288 168 10 , , , 40288 168 11 were be VBD 40288 168 12 said say VBN 40288 168 13 to to TO 40288 168 14 have have VB 40288 168 15 been be VBN 40288 168 16 brought bring VBN 40288 168 17 to to IN 40288 168 18 the the DT 40288 168 19 Peloponnesus Peloponnesus NNP 40288 168 20 by by IN 40288 168 21 the the DT 40288 168 22 followers follower NNS 40288 168 23 of of IN 40288 168 24 Pelops Pelops NNP 40288 168 25 . . . 40288 169 1 The the DT 40288 169 2 tone tone NN 40288 169 3 as as RB 40288 169 4 well well RB 40288 169 5 as as IN 40288 169 6 the the DT 40288 169 7 substance substance NN 40288 169 8 of of IN 40288 169 9 this this DT 40288 169 10 extract extract NN 40288 169 11 makes make VBZ 40288 169 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 169 13 evident evident JJ 40288 169 14 that that IN 40288 169 15 the the DT 40288 169 16 opinions opinion NNS 40288 169 17 of of IN 40288 169 18 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 169 19 on on IN 40288 169 20 questions question NNS 40288 169 21 of of IN 40288 169 22 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 169 23 music music NN 40288 169 24 must must MD 40288 169 25 be be VB 40288 169 26 accepted accept VBN 40288 169 27 with with IN 40288 169 28 considerable considerable JJ 40288 169 29 reserve reserve NN 40288 169 30 . . . 40288 170 1 The the DT 40288 170 2 notion notion NN 40288 170 3 that that IN 40288 170 4 the the DT 40288 170 5 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 170 6 and and CC 40288 170 7 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 170 8 scales scale NNS 40288 170 9 were be VBD 40288 170 10 ' ' `` 40288 170 11 barbarous barbarous JJ 40288 170 12 ' ' '' 40288 170 13 and and CC 40288 170 14 opposed oppose VBD 40288 170 15 to to IN 40288 170 16 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 40288 170 17 ethos ethos NN 40288 170 18 was be VBD 40288 170 19 apparently apparently RB 40288 170 20 common common JJ 40288 170 21 enough enough RB 40288 170 22 , , , 40288 170 23 though though IN 40288 170 24 largely largely RB 40288 170 25 due due JJ 40288 170 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 170 27 as as IN 40288 170 28 we -PRON- PRP 40288 170 29 may may MD 40288 170 30 gather gather VB 40288 170 31 from from IN 40288 170 32 several several JJ 40288 170 33 indications indication NNS 40288 170 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 170 35 to to IN 40288 170 36 national national JJ 40288 170 37 prejudice prejudice NN 40288 170 38 . . . 40288 171 1 But but CC 40288 171 2 no no DT 40288 171 3 one one NN 40288 171 4 , , , 40288 171 5 except except IN 40288 171 6 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 171 7 , , , 40288 171 8 goes go VBZ 40288 171 9 so so RB 40288 171 10 far far RB 40288 171 11 as as IN 40288 171 12 to to TO 40288 171 13 deny deny VB 40288 171 14 them -PRON- PRP 40288 171 15 the the DT 40288 171 16 name name NN 40288 171 17 of of IN 40288 171 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 171 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 171 20 : : : 40288 171 21 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 171 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 171 23 . . . 40288 172 1 The the DT 40288 172 2 threefold threefold JJ 40288 172 3 division division NN 40288 172 4 into into IN 40288 172 5 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 172 6 , , , 40288 172 7 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 172 8 and and CC 40288 172 9 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 172 10 must must MD 40288 172 11 also also RB 40288 172 12 be be VB 40288 172 13 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 40288 172 14 . . . 40288 173 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 173 2 is be VBZ 40288 173 3 to to TO 40288 173 4 be be VB 40288 173 5 observed observe VBN 40288 173 6 that that IN 40288 173 7 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 173 8 obtains obtain VBZ 40288 173 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 173 10 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 173 11 by by IN 40288 173 12 identifying identify VBG 40288 173 13 the the DT 40288 173 14 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 173 15 of of IN 40288 173 16 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 173 17 and and CC 40288 173 18 other other JJ 40288 173 19 early early JJ 40288 173 20 poets poet NNS 40288 173 21 with with IN 40288 173 22 the the DT 40288 173 23 mode mode NN 40288 173 24 called call VBN 40288 173 25 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 173 26 - - HYPH 40288 173 27 dorian dorian NNP 40288 173 28 in in IN 40288 173 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 173 30 own own JJ 40288 173 31 time time NN 40288 173 32 . . . 40288 174 1 The the DT 40288 174 2 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 174 3 that that WDT 40288 174 4 Plato Plato NNP 40288 174 5 mentions mention NNS 40288 174 6 neither neither CC 40288 174 7 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 174 8 nor nor CC 40288 174 9 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 174 10 - - HYPH 40288 174 11 dorian dorian NNP 40288 174 12 suggests suggest VBZ 40288 174 13 rather rather RB 40288 174 14 that that IN 40288 174 15 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 174 16 had have VBD 40288 174 17 gone go VBN 40288 174 18 out out IN 40288 174 19 of of IN 40288 174 20 use use NN 40288 174 21 before before IN 40288 174 22 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 174 23 - - HYPH 40288 174 24 dorian dorian NNP 40288 174 25 came come VBD 40288 174 26 in in RP 40288 174 27 . . . 40288 175 1 The the DT 40288 175 2 conjecture conjecture NN 40288 175 3 of of IN 40288 175 4 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40288 175 5 that that IN 40288 175 6 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 175 7 was be VBD 40288 175 8 the the DT 40288 175 9 same same JJ 40288 175 10 as as IN 40288 175 11 the the DT 40288 175 12 later later JJ 40288 175 13 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 175 14 - - HYPH 40288 175 15 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 175 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 175 17 _ _ NNP 40288 175 18 De De NNP 40288 175 19 Metr Metr NNP 40288 175 20 . . . 40288 176 1 Pind Pind NNP 40288 176 2 . . . 40288 176 3 _ _ NNP 40288 176 4 iii iii NNP 40288 176 5 . . . 40288 177 1 8) 8) CD 40288 177 2 is be VBZ 40288 177 3 open open JJ 40288 177 4 to to IN 40288 177 5 a a DT 40288 177 6 similar similar JJ 40288 177 7 objection objection NN 40288 177 8 . . . 40288 178 1 The the DT 40288 178 2 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 178 3 mode mode NN 40288 178 4 was be VBD 40288 178 5 at at IN 40288 178 6 least least JJS 40288 178 7 as as RB 40288 178 8 old old JJ 40288 178 9 as as IN 40288 178 10 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 178 11 , , , 40288 178 12 whereas whereas IN 40288 178 13 the the DT 40288 178 14 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 178 15 - - HYPH 40288 178 16 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 178 17 was be VBD 40288 178 18 a a DT 40288 178 19 novelty novelty NN 40288 178 20 in in IN 40288 178 21 the the DT 40288 178 22 time time NN 40288 178 23 of of IN 40288 178 24 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 178 25 . . . 40288 179 1 The the DT 40288 179 2 protest protest NN 40288 179 3 which which WDT 40288 179 4 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 179 5 makes make VBZ 40288 179 6 against against IN 40288 179 7 classifying classify VBG 40288 179 8 modes mode NNS 40288 179 9 merely merely RB 40288 179 10 according accord VBG 40288 179 11 to to IN 40288 179 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 179 13 pitch pitch NN 40288 179 14 is be VBZ 40288 179 15 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 179 16 valuable valuable JJ 40288 179 17 as as IN 40288 179 18 proving prove VBG 40288 179 19 that that IN 40288 179 20 the the DT 40288 179 21 modes mode NNS 40288 179 22 were be VBD 40288 179 23 as as IN 40288 179 24 a a DT 40288 179 25 matter matter NN 40288 179 26 of of IN 40288 179 27 fact fact NN 40288 179 28 usually usually RB 40288 179 29 classified classify VBD 40288 179 30 from from IN 40288 179 31 that that DT 40288 179 32 point point NN 40288 179 33 of of IN 40288 179 34 view view NN 40288 179 35 . . . 40288 180 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 180 2 is be VBZ 40288 180 3 far far RB 40288 180 4 from from IN 40288 180 5 proving prove VBG 40288 180 6 that that IN 40288 180 7 there there EX 40288 180 8 was be VBD 40288 180 9 any any DT 40288 180 10 other other JJ 40288 180 11 principle principle NN 40288 180 12 which which WDT 40288 180 13 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 180 14 wished wish VBD 40288 180 15 to to TO 40288 180 16 adopt adopt VB 40288 180 17 -- -- : 40288 180 18 such such JJ 40288 180 19 , , , 40288 180 20 for for IN 40288 180 21 example example NN 40288 180 22 , , , 40288 180 23 as as IN 40288 180 24 difference difference NN 40288 180 25 in in IN 40288 180 26 the the DT 40288 180 27 intervals interval NNS 40288 180 28 employed employ VBN 40288 180 29 , , , 40288 180 30 or or CC 40288 180 31 in in IN 40288 180 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 180 33 succession succession NN 40288 180 34 . . . 40288 181 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40288 181 2 ' ' `` 40288 181 3 differences difference NNS 40288 181 4 of of IN 40288 181 5 kind kind NN 40288 181 6 ' ' '' 40288 181 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 181 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 181 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 181 10 : : : 40288 181 11 tas tas NNP 40288 181 12 kat kat NNP 40288 181 13 ' ' POS 40288 181 14 eidos eidos NNP 40288 181 15 diaphoras diaphoras NNP 40288 181 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 181 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 181 18 are be VBP 40288 181 19 not not RB 40288 181 20 necessarily necessarily RB 40288 181 21 to to TO 40288 181 22 be be VB 40288 181 23 explained explain VBN 40288 181 24 from from IN 40288 181 25 the the DT 40288 181 26 technical technical JJ 40288 181 27 use use NN 40288 181 28 of of IN 40288 181 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 181 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 181 31 : : : 40288 181 32 eidos eidos NN 40288 181 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 181 34 for for IN 40288 181 35 the the DT 40288 181 36 ' ' `` 40288 181 37 species specie NNS 40288 181 38 ' ' '' 40288 181 39 of of IN 40288 181 40 the the DT 40288 181 41 octave octave NN 40288 181 42 . . . 40288 182 1 What what WP 40288 182 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 182 3 complains complain VBZ 40288 182 4 of of IN 40288 182 5 seems seem VBZ 40288 182 6 to to TO 40288 182 7 be be VB 40288 182 8 the the DT 40288 182 9 multiplication multiplication NN 40288 182 10 of of IN 40288 182 11 modes mode NNS 40288 182 12 -- -- : 40288 182 13 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 182 14 - - NN 40288 182 15 mixolydian mixolydian NNP 40288 182 16 , , , 40288 182 17 Hyper hyper JJ 40288 182 18 - - NN 40288 182 19 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 182 20 , , , 40288 182 21 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 182 22 - - HYPH 40288 182 23 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 182 24 -- -- : 40288 182 25 beyond beyond IN 40288 182 26 the the DT 40288 182 27 legitimate legitimate JJ 40288 182 28 requirements requirement NNS 40288 182 29 of of IN 40288 182 30 the the DT 40288 182 31 art art NN 40288 182 32 . . . 40288 183 1 The the DT 40288 183 2 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 183 3 - - HYPH 40288 183 4 lydian lydian NNP 40288 183 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 183 6 _ _ NNP 40288 183 7 e.g. e.g. NNP 40288 183 8 _ _ NNP 40288 183 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 183 10 is be VBZ 40288 183 11 high high RB 40288 183 12 - - HYPH 40288 183 13 pitched pitched JJ 40288 183 14 and and CC 40288 183 15 plaintive plaintive NN 40288 183 16 : : : 40288 183 17 what what WP 40288 183 18 more more JJR 40288 183 19 can can MD 40288 183 20 the the DT 40288 183 21 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 183 22 - - HYPH 40288 183 23 mixolydian mixolydian NNP 40288 183 24 be be VB 40288 183 25 ? ? . 40288 184 1 The the DT 40288 184 2 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 184 3 - - HYPH 40288 184 4 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 184 5 is be VBZ 40288 184 6 a a DT 40288 184 7 new new JJ 40288 184 8 mode mode NN 40288 184 9 : : : 40288 184 10 Heraclides heraclide NNS 40288 184 11 denies deny VBZ 40288 184 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 184 13 a a DT 40288 184 14 distinctive distinctive JJ 40288 184 15 ethos ethos NN 40288 184 16 . . . 40288 185 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40288 185 2 view view NN 40288 185 3 seems seem VBZ 40288 185 4 to to TO 40288 185 5 be be VB 40288 185 6 that that IN 40288 185 7 the the DT 40288 185 8 number number NN 40288 185 9 of of IN 40288 185 10 modes mode NNS 40288 185 11 should should MD 40288 185 12 not not RB 40288 185 13 be be VB 40288 185 14 greater great JJR 40288 185 15 than than IN 40288 185 16 the the DT 40288 185 17 number number NN 40288 185 18 of of IN 40288 185 19 varieties variety NNS 40288 185 20 in in IN 40288 185 21 temper temper NN 40288 185 22 or or CC 40288 185 23 emotion emotion NN 40288 185 24 of of IN 40288 185 25 which which WDT 40288 185 26 music music NN 40288 185 27 is be VBZ 40288 185 28 capable capable JJ 40288 185 29 . . . 40288 186 1 But but CC 40288 186 2 there there EX 40288 186 3 is be VBZ 40288 186 4 nothing nothing NN 40288 186 5 to to TO 40288 186 6 show show VB 40288 186 7 that that IN 40288 186 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 186 9 did do VBD 40288 186 10 not not RB 40288 186 11 regard regard VB 40288 186 12 pitch pitch NN 40288 186 13 as as IN 40288 186 14 the the DT 40288 186 15 chief chief JJ 40288 186 16 element element NN 40288 186 17 , , , 40288 186 18 or or CC 40288 186 19 one one CD 40288 186 20 of of IN 40288 186 21 the the DT 40288 186 22 chief chief JJ 40288 186 23 elements element NNS 40288 186 24 , , , 40288 186 25 of of IN 40288 186 26 musical musical JJ 40288 186 27 expression expression NN 40288 186 28 . . . 40288 187 1 The the DT 40288 187 2 absence absence NN 40288 187 3 of of IN 40288 187 4 the the DT 40288 187 5 name name NN 40288 187 6 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 187 7 - - HYPH 40288 187 8 lydian lydian NNP 40288 187 9 , , , 40288 187 10 taken take VBN 40288 187 11 with with IN 40288 187 12 the the DT 40288 187 13 description description NN 40288 187 14 of of IN 40288 187 15 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 187 16 - - HYPH 40288 187 17 dorian dorian JJ 40288 187 18 as as IN 40288 187 19 ' ' '' 40288 187 20 below below IN 40288 187 21 the the DT 40288 187 22 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 187 23 , , , 40288 187 24 ' ' '' 40288 187 25 would would MD 40288 187 26 indicate indicate VB 40288 187 27 that that IN 40288 187 28 the the DT 40288 187 29 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 187 30 - - HYPH 40288 187 31 dorian dorian JJ 40288 187 32 of of IN 40288 187 33 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 187 34 was be VBD 40288 187 35 not not RB 40288 187 36 the the DT 40288 187 37 later later JJ 40288 187 38 mode mode NN 40288 187 39 of of IN 40288 187 40 that that DT 40288 187 41 name name NN 40288 187 42 , , , 40288 187 43 but but CC 40288 187 44 was be VBD 40288 187 45 a a DT 40288 187 46 semitone semitone NN 40288 187 47 below below IN 40288 187 48 the the DT 40288 187 49 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 187 50 , , , 40288 187 51 in in IN 40288 187 52 the the DT 40288 187 53 place place NN 40288 187 54 afterwards afterwards RB 40288 187 55 occupied occupy VBN 40288 187 56 by by IN 40288 187 57 the the DT 40288 187 58 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 187 59 - - HYPH 40288 187 60 lydian lydian NNP 40288 187 61 . . . 40288 188 1 This this DT 40288 188 2 is be VBZ 40288 188 3 confirmed confirm VBN 40288 188 4 , , , 40288 188 5 as as IN 40288 188 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 188 7 shall shall MD 40288 188 8 see see VB 40288 188 9 , , , 40288 188 10 by by IN 40288 188 11 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 188 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 188 13 p. p. NN 40288 188 14 18 18 CD 40288 188 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 188 16 . . . 40288 189 1 § § ADD 40288 189 2 7 7 CD 40288 189 3 . . . 40288 190 1 _ _ NNP 40288 190 2 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 190 3 -- -- : 40288 190 4 the the DT 40288 190 5 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 190 6 . . . 40288 190 7 _ _ XX 40288 190 8 Of of IN 40288 190 9 the the DT 40288 190 10 writers writer NNS 40288 190 11 who who WP 40288 190 12 deal deal VBP 40288 190 13 with with IN 40288 190 14 music music NN 40288 190 15 from from IN 40288 190 16 the the DT 40288 190 17 point point NN 40288 190 18 of of IN 40288 190 19 view view NN 40288 190 20 of of IN 40288 190 21 the the DT 40288 190 22 cultivated cultivate VBN 40288 190 23 layman layman NN 40288 190 24 , , , 40288 190 25 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 190 26 is be VBZ 40288 190 27 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40288 190 28 the the DT 40288 190 29 most most RBS 40288 190 30 instructive instructive JJ 40288 190 31 . . . 40288 191 1 The the DT 40288 191 2 chapters chapter NNS 40288 191 3 in in IN 40288 191 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 191 5 _ _ NNP 40288 191 6 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 191 7 _ _ NNP 40288 191 8 which which WDT 40288 191 9 treat treat NN 40288 191 10 of of IN 40288 191 11 music music NN 40288 191 12 in in IN 40288 191 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 191 14 relation relation NN 40288 191 15 to to IN 40288 191 16 the the DT 40288 191 17 state state NN 40288 191 18 and and CC 40288 191 19 to to TO 40288 191 20 morality morality NN 40288 191 21 go go VB 40288 191 22 much much RB 40288 191 23 more more RBR 40288 191 24 deeply deeply RB 40288 191 25 than than IN 40288 191 26 Plato Plato NNP 40288 191 27 does do VBZ 40288 191 28 into into IN 40288 191 29 the the DT 40288 191 30 grounds ground NNS 40288 191 31 of of IN 40288 191 32 the the DT 40288 191 33 influence influence NN 40288 191 34 which which WDT 40288 191 35 musical musical JJ 40288 191 36 forms form NNS 40288 191 37 exert exert VBP 40288 191 38 upon upon IN 40288 191 39 temper temper NN 40288 191 40 and and CC 40288 191 41 feeling feeling NN 40288 191 42 . . . 40288 192 1 Moreover moreover RB 40288 192 2 , , , 40288 192 3 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 192 4 's 's POS 40288 192 5 scope scope NN 40288 192 6 is be VBZ 40288 192 7 wider wide JJR 40288 192 8 , , , 40288 192 9 not not RB 40288 192 10 being be VBG 40288 192 11 confined confine VBN 40288 192 12 to to IN 40288 192 13 the the DT 40288 192 14 education education NN 40288 192 15 of of IN 40288 192 16 the the DT 40288 192 17 young young JJ 40288 192 18 ; ; : 40288 192 19 and and CC 40288 192 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 192 21 treatment treatment NN 40288 192 22 is be VBZ 40288 192 23 evidently evidently RB 40288 192 24 a a DT 40288 192 25 more more RBR 40288 192 26 faithful faithful JJ 40288 192 27 reflexion reflexion NN 40288 192 28 of of IN 40288 192 29 the the DT 40288 192 30 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 192 31 Greek greek JJ 40288 192 32 notions notion NNS 40288 192 33 and and CC 40288 192 34 sentiment sentiment NN 40288 192 35 . . . 40288 193 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 193 2 begins begin VBZ 40288 193 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 193 4 _ _ NNP 40288 193 5 Pol Pol NNP 40288 193 6 . . . 40288 193 7 _ _ NNP 40288 193 8 viii viii NN 40288 193 9 . . . 40288 194 1 5 5 CD 40288 194 2 , , , 40288 194 3 p. p. NN 40288 194 4 1340 1340 CD 40288 194 5 _ _ NNP 40288 194 6 a a DT 40288 194 7 _ _ NNP 40288 194 8 38 38 CD 40288 194 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 194 10 by by IN 40288 194 11 agreeing agree VBG 40288 194 12 with with IN 40288 194 13 Plato Plato NNP 40288 194 14 as as IN 40288 194 15 to to IN 40288 194 16 the the DT 40288 194 17 great great JJ 40288 194 18 importance importance NN 40288 194 19 of of IN 40288 194 20 the the DT 40288 194 21 subject subject NN 40288 194 22 for for IN 40288 194 23 practical practical JJ 40288 194 24 politics politic NNS 40288 194 25 . . . 40288 195 1 Musical musical JJ 40288 195 2 forms form NNS 40288 195 3 , , , 40288 195 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 195 5 holds hold VBZ 40288 195 6 , , , 40288 195 7 are be VBP 40288 195 8 not not RB 40288 195 9 mere mere JJ 40288 195 10 _ _ NNP 40288 195 11 symbols symbol NNS 40288 195 12 _ _ NNP 40288 195 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 195 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 195 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 195 16 : : : 40288 195 17 sêmeia sêmeia NNP 40288 195 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 195 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 195 20 , , , 40288 195 21 acting act VBG 40288 195 22 through through IN 40288 195 23 association association NN 40288 195 24 , , , 40288 195 25 but but CC 40288 195 26 are be VBP 40288 195 27 an an DT 40288 195 28 actual actual JJ 40288 195 29 _ _ NNP 40288 195 30 copy copy NN 40288 195 31 _ _ NNP 40288 195 32 or or CC 40288 195 33 reflex reflex NN 40288 195 34 of of IN 40288 195 35 the the DT 40288 195 36 forms form NNS 40288 195 37 of of IN 40288 195 38 moral moral JJ 40288 195 39 temper temper NN 40288 195 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 195 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 195 42 Greek Greek NNP 40288 195 43 : : : 40288 195 44 en en NNP 40288 195 45 de de NNP 40288 195 46 tois tois NNP 40288 195 47 melesin melesin NNP 40288 195 48 autois autois NNP 40288 195 49 esti esti NNP 40288 195 50 mimêmata mimêmata NNP 40288 195 51 tôn tôn NNP 40288 195 52 êthôn êthôn NNP 40288 195 53 ] ] -RRB- 40288 195 54 ) ) -RRB- 40288 195 55 ; ; : 40288 195 56 and and CC 40288 195 57 this this DT 40288 195 58 is be VBZ 40288 195 59 the the DT 40288 195 60 ground ground NN 40288 195 61 of of IN 40288 195 62 the the DT 40288 195 63 different different JJ 40288 195 64 moral moral JJ 40288 195 65 influence influence NN 40288 195 66 exercised exercise VBN 40288 195 67 by by IN 40288 195 68 different different JJ 40288 195 69 modes mode NNS 40288 195 70 ( ( -LRB- 40288 195 71 [ [ -LRB- 40288 195 72 Greek Greek NNP 40288 195 73 : : : 40288 195 74 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 195 75 ] ] -RRB- 40288 195 76 ) ) -RRB- 40288 195 77 . . . 40288 196 1 By by IN 40288 196 2 some some DT 40288 196 3 of of IN 40288 196 4 them -PRON- PRP 40288 196 5 , , , 40288 196 6 especially especially RB 40288 196 7 by by IN 40288 196 8 the the DT 40288 196 9 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 196 10 - - HYPH 40288 196 11 lydian lydian NNP 40288 196 12 , , , 40288 196 13 we -PRON- PRP 40288 196 14 are be VBP 40288 196 15 moved move VBN 40288 196 16 to to IN 40288 196 17 a a DT 40288 196 18 plaintive plaintive JJ 40288 196 19 and and CC 40288 196 20 depressed depressed JJ 40288 196 21 temper temper NN 40288 196 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 196 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 196 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 196 25 : : : 40288 196 26 diatithesthai diatithesthai NNP 40288 196 27 odyrtikôterôs odyrtikôterô VBZ 40288 196 28 kai kai NNP 40288 196 29 synestêkotôs synestêkotôs NNP 40288 196 30 mallon mallon NNP 40288 196 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 196 32 ) ) -RRB- 40288 196 33 ; ; : 40288 196 34 by by IN 40288 196 35 others other NNS 40288 196 36 , , , 40288 196 37 such such JJ 40288 196 38 as as IN 40288 196 39 those those DT 40288 196 40 which which WDT 40288 196 41 are be VBP 40288 196 42 called call VBN 40288 196 43 the the DT 40288 196 44 ' ' `` 40288 196 45 relaxed relax VBN 40288 196 46 ' ' '' 40288 196 47 ( ( -LRB- 40288 196 48 [ [ -LRB- 40288 196 49 Greek Greek NNP 40288 196 50 : : : 40288 196 51 aneimenai aneimenai NN 40288 196 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 196 53 ) ) -RRB- 40288 196 54 , , , 40288 196 55 we -PRON- PRP 40288 196 56 are be VBP 40288 196 57 disposed disposed JJ 40288 196 58 to to IN 40288 196 59 ' ' `` 40288 196 60 softness softness VB 40288 196 61 ' ' '' 40288 196 62 of of IN 40288 196 63 mind mind NN 40288 196 64 ( ( -LRB- 40288 196 65 [ [ -LRB- 40288 196 66 Greek Greek NNP 40288 196 67 : : : 40288 196 68 malakôterôs malakôterôs NNP 40288 196 69 tên tên NNP 40288 196 70 dianoian dianoian NNP 40288 196 71 ] ] -RRB- 40288 196 72 ) ) -RRB- 40288 196 73 . . . 40288 197 1 The the DT 40288 197 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 197 3 , , , 40288 197 4 again again RB 40288 197 5 , , , 40288 197 6 is be VBZ 40288 197 7 the the DT 40288 197 8 only only JJ 40288 197 9 one one CD 40288 197 10 under under IN 40288 197 11 whose whose WP$ 40288 197 12 influence influence NN 40288 197 13 men man NNS 40288 197 14 are be VBP 40288 197 15 in in IN 40288 197 16 a a DT 40288 197 17 middle middle NN 40288 197 18 and and CC 40288 197 19 settled settled JJ 40288 197 20 mood mood NN 40288 197 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 197 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 197 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 197 24 : : : 40288 197 25 mesôs mesôs NNP 40288 197 26 kai kai NNP 40288 197 27 kathestêkotôs kathestêkotôs NNP 40288 197 28 malista malista NNP 40288 197 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 197 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 197 31 : : : 40288 197 32 while while IN 40288 197 33 the the DT 40288 197 34 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 197 35 makes make VBZ 40288 197 36 them -PRON- PRP 40288 197 37 excited excite VBN 40288 197 38 ( ( -LRB- 40288 197 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 197 40 Greek Greek NNP 40288 197 41 : : : 40288 197 42 enthousiastikous enthousiastikous JJ 40288 197 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 197 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 197 45 . . . 40288 198 1 In in IN 40288 198 2 a a DT 40288 198 3 later later JJ 40288 198 4 chapter chapter NN 40288 198 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 198 6 Pol Pol NNP 40288 198 7 . . . 40288 199 1 viii viii RB 40288 199 2 . . . 40288 200 1 7 7 CD 40288 200 2 , , , 40288 200 3 p. p. NN 40288 200 4 1342 1342 CD 40288 200 5 _ _ NNP 40288 200 6 a a DT 40288 200 7 _ _ NNP 40288 200 8 32 32 CD 40288 200 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 200 10 , , , 40288 200 11 he -PRON- PRP 40288 200 12 returns return VBZ 40288 200 13 to to IN 40288 200 14 the the DT 40288 200 15 subject subject NN 40288 200 16 of of IN 40288 200 17 the the DT 40288 200 18 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 200 19 . . . 40288 201 1 Socrates socrate NNS 40288 201 2 , , , 40288 201 3 he -PRON- PRP 40288 201 4 thinks think VBZ 40288 201 5 , , , 40288 201 6 ought ought MD 40288 201 7 not not RB 40288 201 8 to to TO 40288 201 9 have have VB 40288 201 10 left leave VBN 40288 201 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 201 12 with with IN 40288 201 13 the the DT 40288 201 14 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 201 15 , , , 40288 201 16 especially especially RB 40288 201 17 since since IN 40288 201 18 he -PRON- PRP 40288 201 19 condemned condemn VBD 40288 201 20 the the DT 40288 201 21 flute flute NN 40288 201 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 201 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 201 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 201 25 : : : 40288 201 26 aulos aulos NNP 40288 201 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 201 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 201 29 , , , 40288 201 30 which which WDT 40288 201 31 has have VBZ 40288 201 32 the the DT 40288 201 33 same same JJ 40288 201 34 character character NN 40288 201 35 among among IN 40288 201 36 instruments instrument NNS 40288 201 37 as as IN 40288 201 38 the the DT 40288 201 39 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 201 40 among among IN 40288 201 41 modes mode NNS 40288 201 42 , , , 40288 201 43 both both DT 40288 201 44 being be VBG 40288 201 45 orgiastic orgiastic JJ 40288 201 46 and and CC 40288 201 47 emotional emotional JJ 40288 201 48 . . . 40288 202 1 The the DT 40288 202 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 202 3 , , , 40288 202 4 as as IN 40288 202 5 all all DT 40288 202 6 agree agree VBP 40288 202 7 , , , 40288 202 8 is be VBZ 40288 202 9 the the DT 40288 202 10 most most RBS 40288 202 11 steadfast steadfast JJ 40288 202 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 202 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 202 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 202 15 : : : 40288 202 16 stasimôtatê stasimôtatê NN 40288 202 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 202 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 202 19 , , , 40288 202 20 and and CC 40288 202 21 has have VBZ 40288 202 22 most most JJS 40288 202 23 of of IN 40288 202 24 the the DT 40288 202 25 ethos ethos NN 40288 202 26 of of IN 40288 202 27 courage courage NN 40288 202 28 ; ; : 40288 202 29 and and CC 40288 202 30 , , , 40288 202 31 as as IN 40288 202 32 compared compare VBN 40288 202 33 with with IN 40288 202 34 other other JJ 40288 202 35 modes mode NNS 40288 202 36 , , , 40288 202 37 it -PRON- PRP 40288 202 38 has have VBZ 40288 202 39 the the DT 40288 202 40 character character NN 40288 202 41 which which WDT 40288 202 42 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 202 43 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 202 44 regards regard VBZ 40288 202 45 as as IN 40288 202 46 the the DT 40288 202 47 universal universal JJ 40288 202 48 criterion criterion NN 40288 202 49 of of IN 40288 202 50 excellence excellence NN 40288 202 51 , , , 40288 202 52 viz viz NN 40288 202 53 . . . 40288 203 1 that that DT 40288 203 2 of of IN 40288 203 3 being be VBG 40288 203 4 the the DT 40288 203 5 mean mean NN 40288 203 6 between between IN 40288 203 7 opposite opposite JJ 40288 203 8 excesses excess NNS 40288 203 9 . . . 40288 204 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 204 2 , , , 40288 204 3 therefore therefore RB 40288 204 4 , , , 40288 204 5 certainly certainly RB 40288 204 6 understood understand VBD 40288 204 7 Plato Plato NNP 40288 204 8 to to TO 40288 204 9 have have VB 40288 204 10 approved approve VBN 40288 204 11 the the DT 40288 204 12 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 204 13 and and CC 40288 204 14 the the DT 40288 204 15 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 204 16 as as IN 40288 204 17 representing represent VBG 40288 204 18 the the DT 40288 204 19 mean mean NN 40288 204 20 in in IN 40288 204 21 respect respect NN 40288 204 22 of of IN 40288 204 23 pitch pitch NN 40288 204 24 , , , 40288 204 25 while while IN 40288 204 26 other other JJ 40288 204 27 modes mode NNS 40288 204 28 were be VBD 40288 204 29 either either RB 40288 204 30 too too RB 40288 204 31 high high JJ 40288 204 32 or or CC 40288 204 33 too too RB 40288 204 34 low low JJ 40288 204 35 . . . 40288 205 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 205 2 goes go VBZ 40288 205 3 on on RP 40288 205 4 to to TO 40288 205 5 defend defend VB 40288 205 6 the the DT 40288 205 7 use use NN 40288 205 8 of of IN 40288 205 9 the the DT 40288 205 10 ' ' `` 40288 205 11 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 205 12 ' ' '' 40288 205 13 modes mode NNS 40288 205 14 on on IN 40288 205 15 the the DT 40288 205 16 ground ground NN 40288 205 17 that that IN 40288 205 18 they -PRON- PRP 40288 205 19 furnish furnish VBP 40288 205 20 a a DT 40288 205 21 music music NN 40288 205 22 that that WDT 40288 205 23 is be VBZ 40288 205 24 still still RB 40288 205 25 within within IN 40288 205 26 the the DT 40288 205 27 powers power NNS 40288 205 28 of of IN 40288 205 29 those those DT 40288 205 30 whose whose WP$ 40288 205 31 voice voice NN 40288 205 32 has have VBZ 40288 205 33 failed fail VBN 40288 205 34 from from IN 40288 205 35 age age NN 40288 205 36 , , , 40288 205 37 and and CC 40288 205 38 who who WP 40288 205 39 therefore therefore RB 40288 205 40 are be VBP 40288 205 41 not not RB 40288 205 42 able able JJ 40288 205 43 to to TO 40288 205 44 sing sing VB 40288 205 45 the the DT 40288 205 46 high high RB 40288 205 47 - - HYPH 40288 205 48 pitched pitch VBN 40288 205 49 modes mode NNS 40288 205 50 ( ( -LRB- 40288 205 51 [ [ -LRB- 40288 205 52 Greek Greek NNP 40288 205 53 : : : 40288 205 54 oion oion NN 40288 205 55 tois tois NNP 40288 205 56 apeirêkosi apeirêkosi NNP 40288 205 57 dia dia NNP 40288 205 58 chronon chronon NNP 40288 205 59 ou ou NNP 40288 205 60 rhadion rhadion NN 40288 205 61 adein adein NNP 40288 205 62 tas tas NNP 40288 205 63 syntonous syntonous JJ 40288 205 64 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 205 65 , , , 40288 205 66 alla alla NNP 40288 205 67 tas tas NNP 40288 205 68 aneimenas aneimenas NNP 40288 205 69 hê hê NNP 40288 205 70 physis physis NNP 40288 205 71 hypoballei hypoballei NNP 40288 205 72 tois tois NNP 40288 205 73 têlikoutois têlikoutois NNP 40288 205 74 ] ] -RRB- 40288 205 75 ) ) -RRB- 40288 205 76 . . . 40288 206 1 In in IN 40288 206 2 this this DT 40288 206 3 passage passage NN 40288 206 4 the the DT 40288 206 5 meaning meaning NN 40288 206 6 of of IN 40288 206 7 the the DT 40288 206 8 words word NNS 40288 206 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 206 10 Greek greek JJ 40288 206 11 : : : 40288 206 12 syntonos syntonos JJ 40288 206 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 206 14 and and CC 40288 206 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 206 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 206 17 : : : 40288 206 18 aneimenos aneimenos NN 40288 206 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 206 20 is be VBZ 40288 206 21 especially especially RB 40288 206 22 clear clear JJ 40288 206 23 . . . 40288 207 1 In in IN 40288 207 2 the the DT 40288 207 3 same same JJ 40288 207 4 discussion discussion NN 40288 207 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 207 6 c. c. NNP 40288 207 7 6 6 CD 40288 207 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 207 9 , , , 40288 207 10 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 207 11 refers refer VBZ 40288 207 12 to to IN 40288 207 13 the the DT 40288 207 14 distinction distinction NN 40288 207 15 between between IN 40288 207 16 music music NN 40288 207 17 that that WDT 40288 207 18 is be VBZ 40288 207 19 ethical ethical JJ 40288 207 20 , , , 40288 207 21 music music NN 40288 207 22 suited suit VBN 40288 207 23 to to IN 40288 207 24 action action NN 40288 207 25 , , , 40288 207 26 and and CC 40288 207 27 music music NN 40288 207 28 that that WDT 40288 207 29 inspires inspire VBZ 40288 207 30 religious religious JJ 40288 207 31 excitement excitement NN 40288 207 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 207 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 207 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 207 35 : : : 40288 207 36 ta ta NNP 40288 207 37 men man NNS 40288 207 38 êthika êthika NNP 40288 207 39 , , , 40288 207 40 ta ta NNP 40288 207 41 de de NNP 40288 207 42 praktika praktika NNP 40288 207 43 , , , 40288 207 44 ta ta NNP 40288 207 45 ho ho NNP 40288 207 46 enthousiastika enthousiastika NNP 40288 207 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 207 48 ) ) -RRB- 40288 207 49 . . . 40288 208 1 The the DT 40288 208 2 last last JJ 40288 208 3 of of IN 40288 208 4 these these DT 40288 208 5 kinds kind NNS 40288 208 6 serves serve VBZ 40288 208 7 as as IN 40288 208 8 a a DT 40288 208 9 ' ' `` 40288 208 10 purification purification NN 40288 208 11 ' ' '' 40288 208 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 208 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 208 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 208 15 : : : 40288 208 16 katharsis katharsis NN 40288 208 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 208 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 208 19 . . . 40288 209 1 The the DT 40288 209 2 excitement excitement NN 40288 209 3 is be VBZ 40288 209 4 calmed calm VBN 40288 209 5 by by IN 40288 209 6 giving give VBG 40288 209 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 209 8 vent vent NN 40288 209 9 ; ; : 40288 209 10 and and CC 40288 209 11 the the DT 40288 209 12 morbid morbid NN 40288 209 13 condition condition NN 40288 209 14 of of IN 40288 209 15 the the DT 40288 209 16 ethos ethos NN 40288 209 17 is be VBZ 40288 209 18 met meet VBN 40288 209 19 by by IN 40288 209 20 music music NN 40288 209 21 of of IN 40288 209 22 high high JJ 40288 209 23 pitch pitch NN 40288 209 24 and and CC 40288 209 25 exceptional exceptional JJ 40288 209 26 ' ' `` 40288 209 27 colour colour NN 40288 209 28 ' ' '' 40288 209 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 209 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 209 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 209 32 : : : 40288 209 33 tôn tôn NNP 40288 209 34 harmoniôn harmoniôn NNP 40288 209 35 parekbaseis parekbaseis NNP 40288 209 36 kai kai NNP 40288 209 37 tôn tôn NNP 40288 209 38 melôn melôn NNP 40288 209 39 ta ta NNP 40288 209 40 syntona syntona NNP 40288 209 41 kai kai NNP 40288 209 42 parakechrôsmena parakechrôsmena NNP 40288 209 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 209 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 209 45 . . . 40288 210 1 In in IN 40288 210 2 a a DT 40288 210 3 different different JJ 40288 210 4 connexion connexion NN 40288 210 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 210 6 _ _ NNP 40288 210 7 Pol Pol NNP 40288 210 8 . . . 40288 210 9 _ _ NNP 40288 210 10 iv iv NNP 40288 210 11 . . . 40288 211 1 3 3 CD 40288 211 2 , , , 40288 211 3 p. p. NN 40288 211 4 1290 1290 CD 40288 211 5 _ _ NNP 40288 211 6 a a DT 40288 211 7 _ _ NNP 40288 211 8 20 20 CD 40288 211 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 211 10 , , , 40288 211 11 dealing deal VBG 40288 211 12 with with IN 40288 211 13 the the DT 40288 211 14 opinion opinion NN 40288 211 15 that that IN 40288 211 16 all all DT 40288 211 17 forms form NNS 40288 211 18 of of IN 40288 211 19 government government NN 40288 211 20 are be VBP 40288 211 21 ultimately ultimately RB 40288 211 22 reducible reducible JJ 40288 211 23 to to IN 40288 211 24 two two CD 40288 211 25 , , , 40288 211 26 viz viz NN 40288 211 27 . . . 40288 212 1 oligarchy oligarchy JJ 40288 212 2 and and CC 40288 212 3 democracy democracy NN 40288 212 4 , , , 40288 212 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 212 6 compares compare VBZ 40288 212 7 the the DT 40288 212 8 view view NN 40288 212 9 of of IN 40288 212 10 some some DT 40288 212 11 who who WP 40288 212 12 held hold VBD 40288 212 13 that that IN 40288 212 14 there there EX 40288 212 15 are be VBP 40288 212 16 properly properly RB 40288 212 17 only only RB 40288 212 18 two two CD 40288 212 19 musical musical JJ 40288 212 20 modes mode NNS 40288 212 21 , , , 40288 212 22 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 212 23 and and CC 40288 212 24 Phrygian,--the phrygian,--the NN 40288 212 25 other other JJ 40288 212 26 scales scale NNS 40288 212 27 being be VBG 40288 212 28 mere mere JJ 40288 212 29 varieties variety NNS 40288 212 30 of of IN 40288 212 31 these these DT 40288 212 32 two two CD 40288 212 33 . . . 40288 213 1 Rather rather RB 40288 213 2 , , , 40288 213 3 he -PRON- PRP 40288 213 4 says say VBZ 40288 213 5 , , , 40288 213 6 there there EX 40288 213 7 is be VBZ 40288 213 8 in in IN 40288 213 9 each each DT 40288 213 10 case case NN 40288 213 11 a a DT 40288 213 12 right right JJ 40288 213 13 form form NN 40288 213 14 , , , 40288 213 15 or or CC 40288 213 16 two two CD 40288 213 17 right right JJ 40288 213 18 forms form NNS 40288 213 19 at at IN 40288 213 20 most most RBS 40288 213 21 , , , 40288 213 22 from from IN 40288 213 23 which which WDT 40288 213 24 the the DT 40288 213 25 rest rest NN 40288 213 26 are be VBP 40288 213 27 declensions declension NNS 40288 213 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 213 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 213 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 213 31 : : : 40288 213 32 parekbaseis]),--on parekbaseis]),--on NN 40288 213 33 one one CD 40288 213 34 side side NN 40288 213 35 to to IN 40288 213 36 ' ' '' 40288 213 37 high high RB 40288 213 38 - - HYPH 40288 213 39 pitched pitched JJ 40288 213 40 ' ' '' 40288 213 41 and and CC 40288 213 42 imperious imperious JJ 40288 213 43 oligarchies oligarchy NNS 40288 213 44 , , , 40288 213 45 on on IN 40288 213 46 the the DT 40288 213 47 other other JJ 40288 213 48 to to IN 40288 213 49 ' ' `` 40288 213 50 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 213 51 ' ' '' 40288 213 52 and and CC 40288 213 53 ' ' `` 40288 213 54 soft soft JJ 40288 213 55 ' ' '' 40288 213 56 forms form NNS 40288 213 57 of of IN 40288 213 58 popular popular JJ 40288 213 59 government government NN 40288 213 60 ( ( -LRB- 40288 213 61 [ [ -LRB- 40288 213 62 Greek Greek NNP 40288 213 63 : : : 40288 213 64 oligarchikas oligarchikas NNP 40288 213 65 men man NNS 40288 213 66 tas tas NNP 40288 213 67 syntonôteras syntonôteras NNP 40288 213 68 kai kai NNP 40288 213 69 despotikônteras despotikônteras NNP 40288 213 70 , , , 40288 213 71 tas tas NNP 40288 213 72 d d NNP 40288 213 73 ' ' POS 40288 213 74 aneimenas aneimenas NNP 40288 213 75 kai kai NNP 40288 213 76 malakas malakas NNP 40288 213 77 dêmotikas dêmotikas NNP 40288 213 78 ] ] -RRB- 40288 213 79 ) ) -RRB- 40288 213 80 . . . 40288 214 1 This this DT 40288 214 2 is be VBZ 40288 214 3 obviously obviously RB 40288 214 4 the the DT 40288 214 5 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 214 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40288 214 7 of of IN 40288 214 8 two two CD 40288 214 9 right right JJ 40288 214 10 keys key NNS 40288 214 11 , , , 40288 214 12 holding hold VBG 40288 214 13 the the DT 40288 214 14 mean mean NN 40288 214 15 between between IN 40288 214 16 high high JJ 40288 214 17 and and CC 40288 214 18 low low JJ 40288 214 19 . . . 40288 215 1 § § ADD 40288 215 2 8 8 CD 40288 215 3 . . . 40288 216 1 _ _ NNP 40288 216 2 The the DT 40288 216 3 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 216 4 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 216 5 . . . 40288 216 6 _ _ NNP 40288 216 7 Some some DT 40288 216 8 further further JJ 40288 216 9 notices notice NNS 40288 216 10 of of IN 40288 216 11 the the DT 40288 216 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 216 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 216 14 : : : 40288 216 15 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 216 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 216 17 or or CC 40288 216 18 modes mode NNS 40288 216 19 are be VBP 40288 216 20 contained contain VBN 40288 216 21 in in IN 40288 216 22 the the DT 40288 216 23 so so RB 40288 216 24 - - HYPH 40288 216 25 called call VBN 40288 216 26 _ _ NNP 40288 216 27 Problems_,--a Problems_,--a NNS 40288 216 28 collection collection NN 40288 216 29 which which WDT 40288 216 30 is be VBZ 40288 216 31 probably probably RB 40288 216 32 not not RB 40288 216 33 the the DT 40288 216 34 work work NN 40288 216 35 of of IN 40288 216 36 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 216 37 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 216 38 , , , 40288 216 39 but but CC 40288 216 40 can can MD 40288 216 41 hardly hardly RB 40288 216 42 be be VB 40288 216 43 later later RB 40288 216 44 than than IN 40288 216 45 the the DT 40288 216 46 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40288 216 47 age age NN 40288 216 48 . . . 40288 217 1 What what WP 40288 217 2 is be VBZ 40288 217 3 said say VBN 40288 217 4 in in IN 40288 217 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 217 6 of of IN 40288 217 7 the the DT 40288 217 8 modes mode NNS 40288 217 9 is be VBZ 40288 217 10 clearly clearly RB 40288 217 11 of of IN 40288 217 12 the the DT 40288 217 13 period period NN 40288 217 14 before before IN 40288 217 15 the the DT 40288 217 16 reform reform NN 40288 217 17 of of IN 40288 217 18 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 217 19 . . . 40288 218 1 In in IN 40288 218 2 one one CD 40288 218 3 place place NN 40288 218 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 218 5 _ _ NNP 40288 218 6 Probl Probl NNP 40288 218 7 . . . 40288 218 8 _ _ NNP 40288 218 9 xix xix NNP 40288 218 10 . . . 40288 219 1 48 48 LS 40288 219 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 219 3 the the DT 40288 219 4 question question NN 40288 219 5 is be VBZ 40288 219 6 asked ask VBN 40288 219 7 why why WRB 40288 219 8 the the DT 40288 219 9 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 219 10 - - HYPH 40288 219 11 dorian dorian NNP 40288 219 12 and and CC 40288 219 13 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 219 14 - - HYPH 40288 219 15 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 219 16 are be VBP 40288 219 17 not not RB 40288 219 18 used use VBN 40288 219 19 in in IN 40288 219 20 the the DT 40288 219 21 _ _ NNP 40288 219 22 chorus chorus NNP 40288 219 23 _ _ NNP 40288 219 24 of of IN 40288 219 25 tragedy tragedy NN 40288 219 26 . . . 40288 220 1 One one CD 40288 220 2 answer answer NN 40288 220 3 is be VBZ 40288 220 4 that that IN 40288 220 5 the the DT 40288 220 6 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 220 7 - - HYPH 40288 220 8 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 220 9 has have VBZ 40288 220 10 the the DT 40288 220 11 ethos ethos NN 40288 220 12 of of IN 40288 220 13 action action NN 40288 220 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 220 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 220 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 220 17 : : : 40288 220 18 êthos êthos VB 40288 220 19 echei echei NNP 40288 220 20 praktikon praktikon NNP 40288 220 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 220 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 220 23 , , , 40288 220 24 and and CC 40288 220 25 that that IN 40288 220 26 the the DT 40288 220 27 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 220 28 - - HYPH 40288 220 29 dorian dorian NNP 40288 220 30 is be VBZ 40288 220 31 the the DT 40288 220 32 expression expression NN 40288 220 33 of of IN 40288 220 34 a a DT 40288 220 35 lofty lofty JJ 40288 220 36 and and CC 40288 220 37 unshaken unshaken JJ 40288 220 38 character character NN 40288 220 39 ; ; , 40288 220 40 both both DT 40288 220 41 of of IN 40288 220 42 these these DT 40288 220 43 things thing NNS 40288 220 44 being be VBG 40288 220 45 proper proper JJ 40288 220 46 to to IN 40288 220 47 the the DT 40288 220 48 heroic heroic JJ 40288 220 49 personages personage NNS 40288 220 50 on on IN 40288 220 51 the the DT 40288 220 52 stage stage NN 40288 220 53 , , , 40288 220 54 but but CC 40288 220 55 not not RB 40288 220 56 to to IN 40288 220 57 the the DT 40288 220 58 chorus chorus NN 40288 220 59 , , , 40288 220 60 which which WDT 40288 220 61 represents represent VBZ 40288 220 62 the the DT 40288 220 63 average average JJ 40288 220 64 spectator spectator NN 40288 220 65 , , , 40288 220 66 and and CC 40288 220 67 takes take VBZ 40288 220 68 no no DT 40288 220 69 part part NN 40288 220 70 in in IN 40288 220 71 the the DT 40288 220 72 action action NN 40288 220 73 . . . 40288 221 1 Hence hence RB 40288 221 2 the the DT 40288 221 3 music music NN 40288 221 4 suited suit VBN 40288 221 5 to to IN 40288 221 6 the the DT 40288 221 7 chorus chorus NN 40288 221 8 is be VBZ 40288 221 9 that that DT 40288 221 10 of of IN 40288 221 11 emotion emotion NN 40288 221 12 venting vent VBG 40288 221 13 itself -PRON- PRP 40288 221 14 in in IN 40288 221 15 passive passive JJ 40288 221 16 complaint:--a complaint:--a NN 40288 221 17 description description NN 40288 221 18 which which WDT 40288 221 19 fits fit VBZ 40288 221 20 the the DT 40288 221 21 other other JJ 40288 221 22 modes mode NNS 40288 221 23 , , , 40288 221 24 but but CC 40288 221 25 least least JJS 40288 221 26 of of IN 40288 221 27 all all PDT 40288 221 28 the the DT 40288 221 29 exciting exciting JJ 40288 221 30 and and CC 40288 221 31 orgiastic orgiastic JJ 40288 221 32 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 221 33 - - HYPH 40288 221 34 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 221 35 . . . 40288 222 1 On on IN 40288 222 2 the the DT 40288 222 3 contrary contrary NN 40288 222 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 222 5 the the DT 40288 222 6 writer writer NN 40288 222 7 adds add VBZ 40288 222 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 222 9 the the DT 40288 222 10 passive passive JJ 40288 222 11 attitude attitude NN 40288 222 12 is be VBZ 40288 222 13 especially especially RB 40288 222 14 expressed express VBN 40288 222 15 by by IN 40288 222 16 the the DT 40288 222 17 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 222 18 - - HYPH 40288 222 19 lydian lydian NNP 40288 222 20 . . . 40288 223 1 The the DT 40288 223 2 view view NN 40288 223 3 here here RB 40288 223 4 taken take VBN 40288 223 5 of of IN 40288 223 6 the the DT 40288 223 7 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 223 8 - - HYPH 40288 223 9 dorian dorian NNP 40288 223 10 evidently evidently RB 40288 223 11 agrees agree VBZ 40288 223 12 with with IN 40288 223 13 that that DT 40288 223 14 of of IN 40288 223 15 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 223 16 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 223 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 223 18 _ _ NNP 40288 223 19 supra supra NNP 40288 223 20 _ _ NNP 40288 223 21 , , , 40288 223 22 p. p. NN 40288 223 23 10 10 CD 40288 223 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 223 25 . . . 40288 224 1 The the DT 40288 224 2 relation relation NN 40288 224 3 which which WDT 40288 224 4 Plato Plato NNP 40288 224 5 assumes assume VBZ 40288 224 6 between between IN 40288 224 7 high high JJ 40288 224 8 pitch pitch NN 40288 224 9 and and CC 40288 224 10 the the DT 40288 224 11 excitement excitement NN 40288 224 12 of of IN 40288 224 13 passion passion NN 40288 224 14 , , , 40288 224 15 and and CC 40288 224 16 again again RB 40288 224 17 between between IN 40288 224 18 lowness lowness NN 40288 224 19 of of IN 40288 224 20 pitch pitch NN 40288 224 21 and and CC 40288 224 22 ' ' `` 40288 224 23 softness softness NN 40288 224 24 ' ' '' 40288 224 25 or or CC 40288 224 26 self self NN 40288 224 27 - - HYPH 40288 224 28 indulgence indulgence NN 40288 224 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 224 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 224 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 224 32 : : : 40288 224 33 malakia malakia NNP 40288 224 34 kai kai NNP 40288 224 35 argia argia NNP 40288 224 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 224 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 224 38 , , , 40288 224 39 is be VBZ 40288 224 40 recognized recognize VBN 40288 224 41 in in IN 40288 224 42 the the DT 40288 224 43 _ _ NNP 40288 224 44 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 224 45 _ _ NNP 40288 224 46 , , , 40288 224 47 xix xix NNP 40288 224 48 . . . 40288 225 1 49 49 CD 40288 225 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 225 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 225 4 : : : 40288 225 5 epei epei NNP 40288 225 6 de de NNP 40288 225 7 ho ho NNP 40288 225 8 men man NNS 40288 225 9 barys barys NNP 40288 225 10 phthongos phthongos NNP 40288 225 11 malakos malakos NNP 40288 225 12 kai kai NNP 40288 225 13 êremaios êremaios NNPS 40288 225 14 estin estin NNP 40288 225 15 , , , 40288 225 16 ho ho NNP 40288 225 17 de de NNP 40288 225 18 oxys oxys NNP 40288 225 19 kinêtikos kinêtikos NNP 40288 225 20 , , , 40288 225 21 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 225 22 . . . 40288 226 1 ] ] -RRB- 40288 226 2 : : : 40288 226 3 ' ' `` 40288 226 4 since since IN 40288 226 5 a a DT 40288 226 6 deep deep JJ 40288 226 7 note note NN 40288 226 8 is be VBZ 40288 226 9 soft soft JJ 40288 226 10 and and CC 40288 226 11 calm calm JJ 40288 226 12 , , , 40288 226 13 and and CC 40288 226 14 a a DT 40288 226 15 high high JJ 40288 226 16 note note NN 40288 226 17 is be VBZ 40288 226 18 exciting exciting JJ 40288 226 19 , , , 40288 226 20 & & CC 40288 226 21 c. c. NNP 40288 226 22 ' ' POS 40288 226 23 § § CD 40288 226 24 9 9 CD 40288 226 25 . . . 40288 227 1 _ _ NNP 40288 227 2 The the DT 40288 227 3 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40288 227 4 . . . 40288 227 5 _ _ NNP 40288 227 6 The the DT 40288 227 7 word word NN 40288 227 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 227 9 Greek greek NN 40288 227 10 : : : 40288 227 11 tonos tonos NN 40288 227 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 227 13 occurs occur VBZ 40288 227 14 several several JJ 40288 227 15 times time NNS 40288 227 16 in in IN 40288 227 17 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 227 18 with with IN 40288 227 19 the the DT 40288 227 20 sense sense NN 40288 227 21 of of IN 40288 227 22 ' ' `` 40288 227 23 pitch pitch NN 40288 227 24 , , , 40288 227 25 ' ' '' 40288 227 26 but but CC 40288 227 27 is be VBZ 40288 227 28 not not RB 40288 227 29 applied apply VBN 40288 227 30 by by IN 40288 227 31 him -PRON- PRP 40288 227 32 to to IN 40288 227 33 the the DT 40288 227 34 keys key NNS 40288 227 35 of of IN 40288 227 36 music music NN 40288 227 37 . . . 40288 228 1 The the DT 40288 228 2 nearest near JJS 40288 228 3 approach approach NN 40288 228 4 to to IN 40288 228 5 such such PDT 40288 228 6 a a DT 40288 228 7 use use NN 40288 228 8 may may MD 40288 228 9 be be VB 40288 228 10 found find VBN 40288 228 11 in in IN 40288 228 12 a a DT 40288 228 13 passage passage NN 40288 228 14 of of IN 40288 228 15 the the DT 40288 228 16 _ _ NNP 40288 228 17 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40288 228 18 _ _ NNP 40288 228 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 228 20 iii iii NNP 40288 228 21 . . . 40288 229 1 1 1 CD 40288 229 2 , , , 40288 229 3 p. p. NN 40288 229 4 1403 1403 CD 40288 229 5 _ _ NNP 40288 229 6 b b NNP 40288 229 7 _ _ NNP 40288 229 8 27 27 CD 40288 229 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 229 10 . . . 40288 230 1 Speaking speak VBG 40288 230 2 of of IN 40288 230 3 the the DT 40288 230 4 rise rise NN 40288 230 5 of of IN 40288 230 6 acting act VBG 40288 230 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 230 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 230 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 230 10 : : : 40288 230 11 hypokrisis hypokrisis NN 40288 230 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 230 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 230 14 , , , 40288 230 15 which which WDT 40288 230 16 was be VBD 40288 230 17 originally originally RB 40288 230 18 the the DT 40288 230 19 business business NN 40288 230 20 of of IN 40288 230 21 the the DT 40288 230 22 poet poet NN 40288 230 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 230 24 , , , 40288 230 25 but but CC 40288 230 26 had have VBD 40288 230 27 grown grow VBN 40288 230 28 into into IN 40288 230 29 a a DT 40288 230 30 distinct distinct JJ 40288 230 31 art art NN 40288 230 32 , , , 40288 230 33 capable capable JJ 40288 230 34 of of IN 40288 230 35 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 230 36 as as RB 40288 230 37 well well RB 40288 230 38 as as IN 40288 230 39 practical practical JJ 40288 230 40 treatment treatment NN 40288 230 41 , , , 40288 230 42 he -PRON- PRP 40288 230 43 observes observe VBZ 40288 230 44 that that IN 40288 230 45 a a DT 40288 230 46 similar similar JJ 40288 230 47 art art NN 40288 230 48 might may MD 40288 230 49 be be VB 40288 230 50 formed form VBN 40288 230 51 for for IN 40288 230 52 oratory oratory NN 40288 230 53 . . . 40288 231 1 ' ' `` 40288 231 2 Such such PDT 40288 231 3 an an DT 40288 231 4 art art NN 40288 231 5 would would MD 40288 231 6 lay lay VB 40288 231 7 down down RP 40288 231 8 rules rule NNS 40288 231 9 directing direct VBG 40288 231 10 how how WRB 40288 231 11 to to TO 40288 231 12 use use VB 40288 231 13 the the DT 40288 231 14 voice voice NN 40288 231 15 so so IN 40288 231 16 as as IN 40288 231 17 to to TO 40288 231 18 suit suit VB 40288 231 19 each each DT 40288 231 20 variety variety NN 40288 231 21 of of IN 40288 231 22 feeling,--when feeling,--when NNP 40288 231 23 it -PRON- PRP 40288 231 24 should should MD 40288 231 25 be be VB 40288 231 26 loud loud JJ 40288 231 27 , , , 40288 231 28 when when WRB 40288 231 29 low low JJ 40288 231 30 , , , 40288 231 31 when when WRB 40288 231 32 intermediate;--and intermediate;--and VBG 40288 231 33 how how WRB 40288 231 34 to to TO 40288 231 35 use use VB 40288 231 36 the the DT 40288 231 37 keys key NNS 40288 231 38 , , , 40288 231 39 when when WRB 40288 231 40 the the DT 40288 231 41 pitch pitch NN 40288 231 42 of of IN 40288 231 43 the the DT 40288 231 44 voice voice NN 40288 231 45 should should MD 40288 231 46 be be VB 40288 231 47 high high JJ 40288 231 48 or or CC 40288 231 49 low low JJ 40288 231 50 or or CC 40288 231 51 middle middle JJ 40288 231 52 ( ( -LRB- 40288 231 53 [ [ -LRB- 40288 231 54 Greek Greek NNP 40288 231 55 : : : 40288 231 56 kai kai NNP 40288 231 57 pôs pôs NNP 40288 231 58 tois tois NNP 40288 231 59 tonois tonois NNP 40288 231 60 , , , 40288 231 61 oion oion NN 40288 231 62 oxeia oxeia VBP 40288 231 63 kai kai NNP 40288 231 64 bareia bareia NN 40288 231 65 kai kai NNP 40288 231 66 mesê mesê NNP 40288 231 67 ] ] -RRB- 40288 231 68 , , , 40288 231 69 sc sc RB 40288 231 70 . . . 40288 232 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 232 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 232 3 : : : 40288 232 4 phônê phônê NN 40288 232 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 232 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 232 7 ; ; : 40288 232 8 and and CC 40288 232 9 the the DT 40288 232 10 rhythms rhythm NNS 40288 232 11 , , , 40288 232 12 which which WDT 40288 232 13 to to TO 40288 232 14 use use VB 40288 232 15 for for IN 40288 232 16 each each DT 40288 232 17 case case NN 40288 232 18 . . . 40288 233 1 For for IN 40288 233 2 there there EX 40288 233 3 are be VBP 40288 233 4 three three CD 40288 233 5 things thing NNS 40288 233 6 which which WDT 40288 233 7 men man NNS 40288 233 8 study study VBP 40288 233 9 , , , 40288 233 10 viz viz NN 40288 233 11 . . . 40288 234 1 quantity quantity NNP 40288 234 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 234 3 _ _ NNP 40288 234 4 i i PRP 40288 234 5 . . . 40288 235 1 e. e. NNP 40288 235 2 _ _ NNP 40288 235 3 loudness loudness NN 40288 235 4 of of IN 40288 235 5 sound sound NN 40288 235 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 235 7 , , , 40288 235 8 tune tune NN 40288 235 9 , , , 40288 235 10 and and CC 40288 235 11 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 235 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 235 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 235 14 tria tria NNP 40288 235 15 gar gar NNP 40288 235 16 esti esti NNP 40288 235 17 peri peri NNP 40288 235 18 hôn hôn NNP 40288 235 19 skopousi skopousi NNP 40288 235 20 , , , 40288 235 21 tauta tauta NNP 40288 235 22 d d NNP 40288 235 23 ' ' POS 40288 235 24 esti esti NN 40288 235 25 megethos megethos NNP 40288 235 26 , , , 40288 235 27 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 235 28 , , , 40288 235 29 rhythmos rhythmos NNP 40288 235 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 235 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 235 32 . . . 40288 235 33 ' ' '' 40288 236 1 The the DT 40288 236 2 passage passage NN 40288 236 3 is be VBZ 40288 236 4 interesting interesting JJ 40288 236 5 as as IN 40288 236 6 showing show VBG 40288 236 7 the the DT 40288 236 8 value value NN 40288 236 9 which which WDT 40288 236 10 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 236 11 set set VBD 40288 236 12 upon upon IN 40288 236 13 pitch pitch NN 40288 236 14 as as IN 40288 236 15 an an DT 40288 236 16 element element NN 40288 236 17 of of IN 40288 236 18 effect effect NN 40288 236 19 . . . 40288 237 1 And and CC 40288 237 2 the the DT 40288 237 3 use use NN 40288 237 4 of of IN 40288 237 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 237 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 237 7 : : : 40288 237 8 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 237 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 237 10 in in IN 40288 237 11 reference reference NN 40288 237 12 to to IN 40288 237 13 the the DT 40288 237 14 pitch pitch NN 40288 237 15 of of IN 40288 237 16 the the DT 40288 237 17 voice voice NN 40288 237 18 , , , 40288 237 19 and and CC 40288 237 20 as as IN 40288 237 21 virtually virtually RB 40288 237 22 equivalent equivalent JJ 40288 237 23 to to IN 40288 237 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 237 25 Greek greek NN 40288 237 26 : : : 40288 237 27 tonos tonos NN 40288 237 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 237 29 , , , 40288 237 30 is be VBZ 40288 237 31 especially especially RB 40288 237 32 worthy worthy JJ 40288 237 33 of of IN 40288 237 34 note note NN 40288 237 35 . . . 40288 238 1 § § ADD 40288 238 2 10 10 CD 40288 238 3 . . . 40288 239 1 _ _ NNP 40288 239 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 239 3 . . . 40288 239 4 _ _ NNP 40288 239 5 Our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 239 6 next next JJ 40288 239 7 source source NN 40288 239 8 of of IN 40288 239 9 information information NN 40288 239 10 is be VBZ 40288 239 11 the the DT 40288 239 12 technical technical JJ 40288 239 13 writer writer NN 40288 239 14 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 239 15 , , , 40288 239 16 a a DT 40288 239 17 contemporary contemporary JJ 40288 239 18 and and CC 40288 239 19 pupil pupil NN 40288 239 20 of of IN 40288 239 21 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 239 22 . . . 40288 240 1 Of of IN 40288 240 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 240 3 many many JJ 40288 240 4 works work NNS 40288 240 5 on on IN 40288 240 6 the the DT 40288 240 7 subject subject NN 40288 240 8 of of IN 40288 240 9 music music NN 40288 240 10 three three CD 40288 240 11 books book NNS 40288 240 12 only only RB 40288 240 13 have have VBP 40288 240 14 survived survive VBN 40288 240 15 , , , 40288 240 16 bearing bear VBG 40288 240 17 the the DT 40288 240 18 title title NN 40288 240 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 240 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 240 21 : : : 40288 240 22 harmonika harmonika NNP 40288 240 23 otoicheia][1 otoicheia][1 NNP 40288 240 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 240 25 . . . 40288 241 1 In in IN 40288 241 2 the the DT 40288 241 3 treatment treatment NN 40288 241 4 adopted adopt VBN 40288 241 5 by by IN 40288 241 6 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 241 7 the the DT 40288 241 8 chapter chapter NN 40288 241 9 on on IN 40288 241 10 keys key NNS 40288 241 11 follows follow VBZ 40288 241 12 the the DT 40288 241 13 chapter chapter NN 40288 241 14 on on IN 40288 241 15 ' ' `` 40288 241 16 systems system NNS 40288 241 17 ' ' '' 40288 241 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 241 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 241 20 Greek greek JJ 40288 241 21 : : : 40288 241 22 systêmata systêmata NN 40288 241 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 241 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 241 25 . . . 40288 242 1 By by IN 40288 242 2 a a DT 40288 242 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 242 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 242 5 : : : 40288 242 6 systêma systêma NN 40288 242 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 242 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 242 9 means mean VBZ 40288 242 10 a a DT 40288 242 11 scale scale NN 40288 242 12 consisting consist VBG 40288 242 13 of of IN 40288 242 14 a a DT 40288 242 15 certain certain JJ 40288 242 16 succession succession NN 40288 242 17 of of IN 40288 242 18 intervals interval NNS 40288 242 19 : : : 40288 242 20 in in IN 40288 242 21 other other JJ 40288 242 22 words word NNS 40288 242 23 , , , 40288 242 24 a a DT 40288 242 25 series series NN 40288 242 26 of of IN 40288 242 27 notes note NNS 40288 242 28 whose whose WP$ 40288 242 29 relative relative JJ 40288 242 30 pitch pitch NN 40288 242 31 is be VBZ 40288 242 32 determined determine VBN 40288 242 33 . . . 40288 243 1 Such such PDT 40288 243 2 a a DT 40288 243 3 system system NN 40288 243 4 may may MD 40288 243 5 vary vary VB 40288 243 6 in in IN 40288 243 7 absolute absolute JJ 40288 243 8 pitch pitch NN 40288 243 9 , , , 40288 243 10 and and CC 40288 243 11 the the DT 40288 243 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 243 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 243 14 : : : 40288 243 15 tonoi tonoi NNS 40288 243 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 243 17 or or CC 40288 243 18 keys key NNS 40288 243 19 are be VBP 40288 243 20 simply simply RB 40288 243 21 the the DT 40288 243 22 different different JJ 40288 243 23 degrees degree NNS 40288 243 24 of of IN 40288 243 25 pitch pitch NN 40288 243 26 at at IN 40288 243 27 which which WDT 40288 243 28 a a DT 40288 243 29 particular particular JJ 40288 243 30 system system NN 40288 243 31 is be VBZ 40288 243 32 taken take VBN 40288 243 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 243 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 243 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 243 36 : : : 40288 243 37 tous tous JJ 40288 243 38 tonous tonous JJ 40288 243 39 eph eph NNP 40288 243 40 ' ' '' 40288 243 41 ôn ôn NNP 40288 243 42 tithemena tithemena NNP 40288 243 43 ta ta NNP 40288 243 44 systêmata systêmata NNP 40288 243 45 melôdeitai melôdeitai NNP 40288 243 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 243 47 ) ) -RRB- 40288 243 48 . . . 40288 244 1 When when WRB 40288 244 2 the the DT 40288 244 3 system system NN 40288 244 4 and and CC 40288 244 5 the the DT 40288 244 6 key key NN 40288 244 7 are be VBP 40288 244 8 both both DT 40288 244 9 given give VBN 40288 244 10 it -PRON- PRP 40288 244 11 is be VBZ 40288 244 12 evident evident JJ 40288 244 13 that that IN 40288 244 14 the the DT 40288 244 15 whole whole JJ 40288 244 16 series series NN 40288 244 17 of of IN 40288 244 18 notes note NNS 40288 244 19 is be VBZ 40288 244 20 determined determine VBN 40288 244 21 . . . 40288 245 1 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 245 2 is be VBZ 40288 245 3 the the DT 40288 245 4 chief chief JJ 40288 245 5 authority authority NN 40288 245 6 on on IN 40288 245 7 the the DT 40288 245 8 keys key NNS 40288 245 9 of of IN 40288 245 10 Greek greek JJ 40288 245 11 music music NN 40288 245 12 . . . 40288 246 1 In in IN 40288 246 2 this this DT 40288 246 3 department department NN 40288 246 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 246 5 is be VBZ 40288 246 6 considered consider VBN 40288 246 7 to to TO 40288 246 8 have have VB 40288 246 9 done do VBN 40288 246 10 for for IN 40288 246 11 Greece Greece NNP 40288 246 12 what what WP 40288 246 13 Bach Bach NNP 40288 246 14 's 's POS 40288 246 15 _ _ NNP 40288 246 16 Wohltemperirtes Wohltemperirtes NNP 40288 246 17 Clavier Clavier NNP 40288 246 18 _ _ NNP 40288 246 19 did do VBD 40288 246 20 for for IN 40288 246 21 modern modern JJ 40288 246 22 Europe Europe NNP 40288 246 23 . . . 40288 247 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 247 2 is be VBZ 40288 247 3 true true JJ 40288 247 4 that that IN 40288 247 5 the the DT 40288 247 6 scheme scheme NN 40288 247 7 of of IN 40288 247 8 keys key NNS 40288 247 9 which which WDT 40288 247 10 later later JJ 40288 247 11 writers writer NNS 40288 247 12 ascribe ascribe VBP 40288 247 13 to to IN 40288 247 14 him -PRON- PRP 40288 247 15 is be VBZ 40288 247 16 not not RB 40288 247 17 given give VBN 40288 247 18 in in IN 40288 247 19 the the DT 40288 247 20 _ _ NNP 40288 247 21 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 247 22 _ _ NNP 40288 247 23 which which WDT 40288 247 24 we -PRON- PRP 40288 247 25 have have VBP 40288 247 26 : : : 40288 247 27 but but CC 40288 247 28 we -PRON- PRP 40288 247 29 find find VBP 40288 247 30 there there RB 40288 247 31 what what WP 40288 247 32 is be VBZ 40288 247 33 in in IN 40288 247 34 some some DT 40288 247 35 respects respect NNS 40288 247 36 more more RBR 40288 247 37 valuable valuable JJ 40288 247 38 , , , 40288 247 39 namely namely RB 40288 247 40 , , , 40288 247 41 a a DT 40288 247 42 vivid vivid JJ 40288 247 43 account account NN 40288 247 44 of of IN 40288 247 45 the the DT 40288 247 46 state state NN 40288 247 47 of of IN 40288 247 48 things thing NNS 40288 247 49 in in IN 40288 247 50 respect respect NN 40288 247 51 of of IN 40288 247 52 tonality tonality NN 40288 247 53 which which WDT 40288 247 54 he -PRON- PRP 40288 247 55 observed observe VBD 40288 247 56 in in IN 40288 247 57 the the DT 40288 247 58 music music NN 40288 247 59 of of IN 40288 247 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 247 61 time time NN 40288 247 62 . . . 40288 248 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 248 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 248 3 1 1 CD 40288 248 4 : : : 40288 248 5 It -PRON- PRP 40288 248 6 is be VBZ 40288 248 7 foreign foreign JJ 40288 248 8 to to IN 40288 248 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 248 10 purpose purpose NN 40288 248 11 to to TO 40288 248 12 discuss discuss VB 40288 248 13 the the DT 40288 248 14 critical critical JJ 40288 248 15 problems problem NNS 40288 248 16 presented present VBN 40288 248 17 by by IN 40288 248 18 the the DT 40288 248 19 text text NN 40288 248 20 of of IN 40288 248 21 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 248 22 . . . 40288 249 1 Of of IN 40288 249 2 the the DT 40288 249 3 three three CD 40288 249 4 extant extant JJ 40288 249 5 books book NNS 40288 249 6 the the DT 40288 249 7 first first JJ 40288 249 8 is be VBZ 40288 249 9 obviously obviously RB 40288 249 10 a a DT 40288 249 11 distinct distinct JJ 40288 249 12 treatise treatise NN 40288 249 13 , , , 40288 249 14 and and CC 40288 249 15 should should MD 40288 249 16 probably probably RB 40288 249 17 be be VB 40288 249 18 entitled entitle VBN 40288 249 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 249 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 249 21 : : : 40288 249 22 peri peri NN 40288 249 23 archôn archôn NN 40288 249 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 249 25 . . . 40288 250 1 The the DT 40288 250 2 other other JJ 40288 250 3 two two CD 40288 250 4 books book NNS 40288 250 5 will will MD 40288 250 6 then then RB 40288 250 7 bear bear VB 40288 250 8 the the DT 40288 250 9 old old JJ 40288 250 10 title title NN 40288 250 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 250 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 250 13 : : : 40288 250 14 harmonika harmonika NNP 40288 250 15 stoicheia stoicheia NNP 40288 250 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 250 17 . . . 40288 251 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 251 2 deal deal VBP 40288 251 3 with with IN 40288 251 4 the the DT 40288 251 5 same same JJ 40288 251 6 subjects subject NNS 40288 251 7 , , , 40288 251 8 for for IN 40288 251 9 the the DT 40288 251 10 most most JJS 40288 251 11 part part NN 40288 251 12 , , , 40288 251 13 as as IN 40288 251 14 the the DT 40288 251 15 first first JJ 40288 251 16 book book NN 40288 251 17 , , , 40288 251 18 and and CC 40288 251 19 in in IN 40288 251 20 the the DT 40288 251 21 same same JJ 40288 251 22 order,--a order,--a JJ 40288 251 23 species specie NNS 40288 251 24 of of IN 40288 251 25 repetition repetition NN 40288 251 26 of of IN 40288 251 27 which which WDT 40288 251 28 there there EX 40288 251 29 are be VBP 40288 251 30 well well RB 40288 251 31 - - HYPH 40288 251 32 known know VBN 40288 251 33 instances instance NNS 40288 251 34 in in IN 40288 251 35 the the DT 40288 251 36 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40288 251 37 writings writing NNS 40288 251 38 . . . 40288 252 1 The the DT 40288 252 2 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 252 3 is be VBZ 40288 252 4 abrupt abrupt JJ 40288 252 5 , , , 40288 252 6 and and CC 40288 252 7 some some DT 40288 252 8 important important JJ 40288 252 9 topics topic NNS 40288 252 10 are be VBP 40288 252 11 omitted omit VBN 40288 252 12 . . . 40288 253 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 253 2 seems seem VBZ 40288 253 3 an an DT 40288 253 4 exaggeration exaggeration NN 40288 253 5 , , , 40288 253 6 however however RB 40288 253 7 , , , 40288 253 8 to to TO 40288 253 9 describe describe VB 40288 253 10 the the DT 40288 253 11 _ _ NNP 40288 253 12 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 253 13 _ _ NNP 40288 253 14 of of IN 40288 253 15 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 253 16 as as IN 40288 253 17 a a DT 40288 253 18 mere mere JJ 40288 253 19 collection collection NN 40288 253 20 of of IN 40288 253 21 excerpts excerpt NNS 40288 253 22 , , , 40288 253 23 which which WDT 40288 253 24 is be VBZ 40288 253 25 the the DT 40288 253 26 view view NN 40288 253 27 taken take VBN 40288 253 28 by by IN 40288 253 29 Marquard Marquard NNP 40288 253 30 ( ( -LRB- 40288 253 31 _ _ NNP 40288 253 32 Die Die NNP 40288 253 33 harmonischen harmonischen NNP 40288 253 34 Fragmente Fragmente NNP 40288 253 35 des des NNP 40288 253 36 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 253 37 _ _ NNP 40288 253 38 , , , 40288 253 39 pp pp NNP 40288 253 40 . . . 40288 254 1 359 359 CD 40288 254 2 - - SYM 40288 254 3 393 393 CD 40288 254 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 254 5 . . . 40288 255 1 See see VB 40288 255 2 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 255 3 's 's POS 40288 255 4 _ _ NNP 40288 255 5 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 255 6 und und NN 40288 255 7 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 255 8 der der NN 40288 255 9 Griechen Griechen NNP 40288 255 10 _ _ NNP 40288 255 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 255 12 p. p. NN 40288 255 13 41 41 CD 40288 255 14 , , , 40288 255 15 ed ed NNP 40288 255 16 . . . 40288 256 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 256 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 256 3 , , , 40288 256 4 and and CC 40288 256 5 the the DT 40288 256 6 reply reply NN 40288 256 7 to to IN 40288 256 8 Marquard Marquard NNP 40288 256 9 in in IN 40288 256 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 256 11 _ _ NNP 40288 256 12 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 256 13 von von NNP 40288 256 14 Tarent Tarent NNP 40288 256 15 _ _ NNP 40288 256 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 256 17 pp pp NNP 40288 256 18 . . . 40288 257 1 165 165 CD 40288 257 2 - - SYM 40288 257 3 170 170 CD 40288 257 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 257 5 . . . 40288 257 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 258 1 ' ' `` 40288 258 2 No no DT 40288 258 3 one one NN 40288 258 4 , , , 40288 258 5 ' ' '' 40288 258 6 says say VBZ 40288 258 7 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 258 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 258 9 p. p. NN 40288 258 10 37 37 CD 40288 258 11 Meib Meib NNP 40288 258 12 . . . 40288 259 1 ) ) -RRB- 40288 259 2 , , , 40288 259 3 ' ' '' 40288 259 4 has have VBZ 40288 259 5 told tell VBN 40288 259 6 us -PRON- PRP 40288 259 7 a a DT 40288 259 8 word word NN 40288 259 9 about about IN 40288 259 10 the the DT 40288 259 11 keys key NNS 40288 259 12 , , , 40288 259 13 either either CC 40288 259 14 how how WRB 40288 259 15 they -PRON- PRP 40288 259 16 are be VBP 40288 259 17 to to TO 40288 259 18 be be VB 40288 259 19 arrived arrive VBN 40288 259 20 at at IN 40288 259 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 259 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 259 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 259 24 : : : 40288 259 25 tina tina NNP 40288 259 26 tropon tropon NNP 40288 259 27 lêpteon lêpteon NNP 40288 259 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 259 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 259 30 , , , 40288 259 31 or or CC 40288 259 32 from from IN 40288 259 33 what what WDT 40288 259 34 point point NN 40288 259 35 of of IN 40288 259 36 view view NN 40288 259 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 259 38 number number NN 40288 259 39 is be VBZ 40288 259 40 to to TO 40288 259 41 be be VB 40288 259 42 determined determine VBN 40288 259 43 . . . 40288 260 1 Musicians musician NNS 40288 260 2 assign assign VBP 40288 260 3 the the DT 40288 260 4 place place NN 40288 260 5 of of IN 40288 260 6 the the DT 40288 260 7 keys key NNS 40288 260 8 very very RB 40288 260 9 much much RB 40288 260 10 as as IN 40288 260 11 the the DT 40288 260 12 different different JJ 40288 260 13 cities city NNS 40288 260 14 regulate regulate VBP 40288 260 15 the the DT 40288 260 16 days day NNS 40288 260 17 of of IN 40288 260 18 the the DT 40288 260 19 month month NN 40288 260 20 . . . 40288 261 1 The the DT 40288 261 2 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 40288 261 3 , , , 40288 261 4 for for IN 40288 261 5 example example NN 40288 261 6 , , , 40288 261 7 will will MD 40288 261 8 be be VB 40288 261 9 found find VBN 40288 261 10 counting count VBG 40288 261 11 a a DT 40288 261 12 day day NN 40288 261 13 as as IN 40288 261 14 the the DT 40288 261 15 tenth tenth NN 40288 261 16 of of IN 40288 261 17 the the DT 40288 261 18 month month NN 40288 261 19 , , , 40288 261 20 while while IN 40288 261 21 with with IN 40288 261 22 the the DT 40288 261 23 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40288 261 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 261 25 is be VBZ 40288 261 26 the the DT 40288 261 27 fifth fifth JJ 40288 261 28 , , , 40288 261 29 and and CC 40288 261 30 in in IN 40288 261 31 some some DT 40288 261 32 other other JJ 40288 261 33 place place NN 40288 261 34 the the DT 40288 261 35 eighth eighth JJ 40288 261 36 . . . 40288 262 1 Some some DT 40288 262 2 authorities authority NNS 40288 262 3 on on IN 40288 262 4 music music NN 40288 262 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 262 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 262 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 262 8 : : : 40288 262 9 harmonikoi harmonikoi NNP 40288 262 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 262 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 262 12 say say VBP 40288 262 13 that that IN 40288 262 14 the the DT 40288 262 15 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 262 16 - - HYPH 40288 262 17 dorian dorian NNP 40288 262 18 is be VBZ 40288 262 19 the the DT 40288 262 20 lowest low JJS 40288 262 21 key key NN 40288 262 22 , , , 40288 262 23 the the DT 40288 262 24 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 262 25 - - HYPH 40288 262 26 lydian lydian NNP 40288 262 27 a a DT 40288 262 28 semitone semitone NN 40288 262 29 higher higher RBR 40288 262 30 , , , 40288 262 31 the the DT 40288 262 32 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 262 33 again again RB 40288 262 34 a a DT 40288 262 35 semitone semitone NN 40288 262 36 higher high JJR 40288 262 37 , , , 40288 262 38 the the DT 40288 262 39 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 262 40 a a DT 40288 262 41 tone tone NN 40288 262 42 above above IN 40288 262 43 the the DT 40288 262 44 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 262 45 , , , 40288 262 46 and and CC 40288 262 47 similarly similarly RB 40288 262 48 the the DT 40288 262 49 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 262 50 a a DT 40288 262 51 tone tone NN 40288 262 52 above above IN 40288 262 53 the the DT 40288 262 54 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 262 55 . . . 40288 263 1 Others other NNS 40288 263 2 add add VBP 40288 263 3 the the DT 40288 263 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 263 5 - - HYPH 40288 263 6 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 263 7 flute flute NN 40288 263 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 263 9 _ _ NNP 40288 263 10 i i PRP 40288 263 11 . . . 40288 264 1 e. e. NNP 40288 264 2 _ _ NNP 40288 264 3 the the DT 40288 264 4 scale scale NN 40288 264 5 of of IN 40288 264 6 the the DT 40288 264 7 flute flute NN 40288 264 8 so so RB 40288 264 9 called call VBN 40288 264 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 264 11 at at IN 40288 264 12 the the DT 40288 264 13 lower low JJR 40288 264 14 end end NN 40288 264 15 of of IN 40288 264 16 the the DT 40288 264 17 list list NN 40288 264 18 . . . 40288 265 1 Others other NNS 40288 265 2 , , , 40288 265 3 again again RB 40288 265 4 , , , 40288 265 5 looking look VBG 40288 265 6 to to IN 40288 265 7 the the DT 40288 265 8 holes hole NNS 40288 265 9 of of IN 40288 265 10 the the DT 40288 265 11 flute flute NN 40288 265 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 265 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 265 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 265 15 : : : 40288 265 16 pros pro NNS 40288 265 17 tên tên NNP 40288 265 18 tôn tôn NNP 40288 265 19 aulôn aulôn NNP 40288 265 20 trupêsin trupêsin NNP 40288 265 21 blepontes blepontes NNP 40288 265 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 265 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 265 24 , , , 40288 265 25 separate separate VB 40288 265 26 the the DT 40288 265 27 three three CD 40288 265 28 lowest low JJS 40288 265 29 keys key NNS 40288 265 30 , , , 40288 265 31 viz viz NN 40288 265 32 . . . 40288 266 1 the the DT 40288 266 2 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 266 3 - - HYPH 40288 266 4 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 266 5 , , , 40288 266 6 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 266 7 - - HYPH 40288 266 8 dorian dorian NNP 40288 266 9 , , , 40288 266 10 and and CC 40288 266 11 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 266 12 , , , 40288 266 13 by by IN 40288 266 14 the the DT 40288 266 15 interval interval NN 40288 266 16 of of IN 40288 266 17 three three CD 40288 266 18 - - HYPH 40288 266 19 quarters quarter NNS 40288 266 20 of of IN 40288 266 21 a a DT 40288 266 22 tone tone NN 40288 266 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 266 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 266 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 266 26 : : : 40288 266 27 trisi trisi RB 40288 266 28 diesesin diesesin NN 40288 266 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 266 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 266 31 , , , 40288 266 32 but but CC 40288 266 33 the the DT 40288 266 34 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 266 35 from from IN 40288 266 36 the the DT 40288 266 37 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 266 38 by by IN 40288 266 39 a a DT 40288 266 40 tone tone NN 40288 266 41 , , , 40288 266 42 the the DT 40288 266 43 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 266 44 from from IN 40288 266 45 the the DT 40288 266 46 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 266 47 again again RB 40288 266 48 by by IN 40288 266 49 three three CD 40288 266 50 - - HYPH 40288 266 51 quarters quarter NNS 40288 266 52 of of IN 40288 266 53 a a DT 40288 266 54 tone tone NN 40288 266 55 , , , 40288 266 56 and and CC 40288 266 57 the the DT 40288 266 58 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 266 59 - - HYPH 40288 266 60 lydian lydian NNP 40288 266 61 from from IN 40288 266 62 the the DT 40288 266 63 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 266 64 by by IN 40288 266 65 a a DT 40288 266 66 like like JJ 40288 266 67 interval interval NN 40288 266 68 . . . 40288 267 1 But but CC 40288 267 2 as as IN 40288 267 3 to to IN 40288 267 4 what what WP 40288 267 5 determines determine VBZ 40288 267 6 the the DT 40288 267 7 interval interval NN 40288 267 8 between between IN 40288 267 9 one one CD 40288 267 10 key key NN 40288 267 11 and and CC 40288 267 12 another another DT 40288 267 13 they -PRON- PRP 40288 267 14 have have VBP 40288 267 15 told tell VBN 40288 267 16 us -PRON- PRP 40288 267 17 nothing nothing NN 40288 267 18 . . . 40288 267 19 ' ' '' 40288 268 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 268 2 will will MD 40288 268 3 be be VB 40288 268 4 seen see VBN 40288 268 5 that that DT 40288 268 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 268 7 with with IN 40288 268 8 one one CD 40288 268 9 marked mark VBN 40288 268 10 exception exception NN 40288 268 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 268 12 there there EX 40288 268 13 was be VBD 40288 268 14 agreement agreement NN 40288 268 15 about about IN 40288 268 16 the the DT 40288 268 17 order order NN 40288 268 18 of of IN 40288 268 19 the the DT 40288 268 20 keys key NNS 40288 268 21 in in IN 40288 268 22 respect respect NN 40288 268 23 of of IN 40288 268 24 pitch pitch NN 40288 268 25 , , , 40288 268 26 and and CC 40288 268 27 that that IN 40288 268 28 some some DT 40288 268 29 at at RB 40288 268 30 least least RBS 40288 268 31 had have VBD 40288 268 32 reduced reduce VBN 40288 268 33 the the DT 40288 268 34 intervals interval NNS 40288 268 35 to to IN 40288 268 36 the the DT 40288 268 37 succession succession NN 40288 268 38 of of IN 40288 268 39 tones tone NNS 40288 268 40 and and CC 40288 268 41 semitones semitone NNS 40288 268 42 which which WDT 40288 268 43 characterises characterise VBZ 40288 268 44 the the DT 40288 268 45 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 268 46 scale scale NN 40288 268 47 . . . 40288 269 1 The the DT 40288 269 2 exception exception NN 40288 269 3 is be VBZ 40288 269 4 the the DT 40288 269 5 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 269 6 - - HYPH 40288 269 7 lydian lydian NNP 40288 269 8 , , , 40288 269 9 which which WDT 40288 269 10 some some DT 40288 269 11 ranked rank VBD 40288 269 12 immediately immediately RB 40288 269 13 below below IN 40288 269 14 the the DT 40288 269 15 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 269 16 , , , 40288 269 17 others other NNS 40288 269 18 above above IN 40288 269 19 the the DT 40288 269 20 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 269 21 . . . 40288 270 1 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 270 2 attributes attribute VBZ 40288 270 3 this this DT 40288 270 4 strange strange JJ 40288 270 5 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40288 270 6 to to IN 40288 270 7 the the DT 40288 270 8 accidental accidental JJ 40288 270 9 displacing displacing NN 40288 270 10 of of IN 40288 270 11 some some DT 40288 270 12 words word NNS 40288 270 13 in in IN 40288 270 14 the the DT 40288 270 15 MSS MSS NNP 40288 270 16 . . . 40288 271 1 of of IN 40288 271 2 Aristoxenus[1 Aristoxenus[1 NNP 40288 271 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 271 4 . . . 40288 272 1 However however RB 40288 272 2 this this DT 40288 272 3 may may MD 40288 272 4 be be VB 40288 272 5 , , , 40288 272 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 272 7 is be VBZ 40288 272 8 plain plain JJ 40288 272 9 that that IN 40288 272 10 in in IN 40288 272 11 the the DT 40288 272 12 time time NN 40288 272 13 of of IN 40288 272 14 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 272 15 considerable considerable JJ 40288 272 16 progress progress NN 40288 272 17 had have VBD 40288 272 18 been be VBN 40288 272 19 made make VBN 40288 272 20 towards towards IN 40288 272 21 the the DT 40288 272 22 scheme scheme NN 40288 272 23 of of IN 40288 272 24 keys key NNS 40288 272 25 which which WDT 40288 272 26 was be VBD 40288 272 27 afterwards afterwards RB 40288 272 28 connected connect VBN 40288 272 29 with with IN 40288 272 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 272 31 name name NN 40288 272 32 . . . 40288 273 1 This this DT 40288 273 2 may may MD 40288 273 3 be be VB 40288 273 4 represented represent VBN 40288 273 5 by by IN 40288 273 6 the the DT 40288 273 7 following follow VBG 40288 273 8 table table NN 40288 273 9 , , , 40288 273 10 in in IN 40288 273 11 which which WDT 40288 273 12 for for IN 40288 273 13 the the DT 40288 273 14 sake sake NN 40288 273 15 of of IN 40288 273 16 comparison comparison NN 40288 273 17 the the DT 40288 273 18 later later JJ 40288 273 19 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 273 20 - - HYPH 40288 273 21 lydian lydian NNP 40288 273 22 and and CC 40288 273 23 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 273 24 - - HYPH 40288 273 25 dorian dorian NNP 40288 273 26 are be VBP 40288 273 27 added add VBN 40288 273 28 in in IN 40288 273 29 brackets bracket NNS 40288 273 30 : : : 40288 273 31 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 273 32 - - HYPH 40288 273 33 lydian lydian JJ 40288 273 34 semitone semitone NN 40288 273 35 - - : 40288 273 36 { { -LRB- 40288 273 37 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 273 38 tone tone NN 40288 273 39 - - : 40288 273 40 { { -LRB- 40288 273 41 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 273 42 tone tone NN 40288 273 43 - - : 40288 273 44 { { -LRB- 40288 273 45 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 273 46 semitone semitone NN 40288 273 47 - - : 40288 273 48 { { -LRB- 40288 273 49 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 273 50 - - HYPH 40288 273 51 dorian dorian NNP 40288 273 52 [ [ -LRB- 40288 273 53 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 273 54 - - HYPH 40288 273 55 lydian lydian NNP 40288 273 56 ] ] -RRB- 40288 273 57 tone tone NN 40288 273 58 - - : 40288 273 59 { { -LRB- 40288 273 60 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 273 61 - - HYPH 40288 273 62 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 273 63 tone tone NN 40288 273 64 - - : 40288 273 65 { { -LRB- 40288 273 66 [ [ -LRB- 40288 273 67 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 273 68 - - HYPH 40288 273 69 dorian dorian NNP 40288 273 70 ] ] -RRB- 40288 273 71 [ [ -LRB- 40288 273 72 Footnote footnote NN 40288 273 73 1 1 CD 40288 273 74 : : : 40288 273 75 _ _ NNP 40288 273 76 Harm Harm NNP 40288 273 77 . . . 40288 273 78 _ _ NNP 40288 273 79 p. p. NN 40288 273 80 37 37 CD 40288 273 81 , , , 40288 273 82 19 19 CD 40288 273 83 Meib Meib NNP 40288 273 84 . . . 40288 274 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 274 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 274 3 : : : 40288 274 4 houtô houtô NNP 40288 274 5 gar gar NNP 40288 274 6 hoi hoi NNP 40288 274 7 men man NNS 40288 274 8 tôn tôn NNP 40288 274 9 harmonikôn harmonikôn NNP 40288 274 10 legousi legousi NNP 40288 274 11 barytaton barytaton NN 40288 274 12 men man NNS 40288 274 13 ton ton VBD 40288 274 14 Hypodôrion Hypodôrion NNP 40288 274 15 tôn tôn NNP 40288 274 16 tonôn tonôn NN 40288 274 17 , , , 40288 274 18 hêmitoniô hêmitoniô NNP 40288 274 19 de de NNP 40288 274 20 oxyteron oxyteron NNP 40288 274 21 toutou toutou NNP 40288 274 22 ton ton NNP 40288 274 23 Mixolydion Mixolydion NNP 40288 274 24 , , , 40288 274 25 toutou toutou NNP 40288 274 26 de de NNP 40288 274 27 hêmitoniô hêmitoniô NNP 40288 274 28 ton ton NN 40288 274 29 Dôrion Dôrion NNP 40288 274 30 , , , 40288 274 31 tou tou NNP 40288 274 32 de de NNP 40288 274 33 Dôriou Dôriou NNP 40288 274 34 tonô tonô NNP 40288 274 35 ton ton NN 40288 274 36 Phrygion Phrygion NNP 40288 274 37 : : : 40288 274 38 hôsautôs hôsautôs NNP 40288 274 39 de de NNP 40288 274 40 kai kai NNP 40288 274 41 tou tou NNP 40288 274 42 Phrygiou Phrygiou NNP 40288 274 43 ton ton NN 40288 274 44 Lydion Lydion NNP 40288 274 45 heterô heterô RB 40288 274 46 tonô tonô NNP 40288 274 47 . . . 40288 274 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 275 1 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 275 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 275 3 _ _ NNP 40288 275 4 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 275 5 und und NN 40288 275 6 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 275 7 _ _ NNP 40288 275 8 p. p. NN 40288 275 9 165 165 CD 40288 275 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 275 11 would would MD 40288 275 12 transfer transfer VB 40288 275 13 the the DT 40288 275 14 words word NNS 40288 275 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 275 16 Greek greek JJ 40288 275 17 : : : 40288 275 18 hêmitoniô hêmitoniô NN 40288 275 19 ... ... : 40288 275 20 Mixolydion Mixolydion NNP 40288 275 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 275 22 to to IN 40288 275 23 the the DT 40288 275 24 end end NN 40288 275 25 of of IN 40288 275 26 the the DT 40288 275 27 sentence sentence NN 40288 275 28 , , , 40288 275 29 and and CC 40288 275 30 insert insert VB 40288 275 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 275 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 275 33 : : : 40288 275 34 oxyteron oxyteron NN 40288 275 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 275 36 before before IN 40288 275 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 275 38 Greek Greek NNP 40288 275 39 : : : 40288 275 40 ton ton NN 40288 275 41 Dôrion dôrion NN 40288 275 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 275 43 . . . 40288 276 1 The the DT 40288 276 2 necessity necessity NN 40288 276 3 for for IN 40288 276 4 this this DT 40288 276 5 insertion insertion NN 40288 276 6 shows show VBZ 40288 276 7 that that IN 40288 276 8 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 276 9 's 's POS 40288 276 10 transposition transposition NN 40288 276 11 is be VBZ 40288 276 12 not not RB 40288 276 13 in in IN 40288 276 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40288 276 15 an an DT 40288 276 16 easy easy JJ 40288 276 17 one one NN 40288 276 18 . . . 40288 277 1 The the DT 40288 277 2 only only JJ 40288 277 3 reason reason NN 40288 277 4 for for IN 40288 277 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 277 6 is be VBZ 40288 277 7 the the DT 40288 277 8 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 277 9 of of IN 40288 277 10 supposing suppose VBG 40288 277 11 that that IN 40288 277 12 there there EX 40288 277 13 could could MD 40288 277 14 have have VB 40288 277 15 been be VBN 40288 277 16 so so RB 40288 277 17 great great JJ 40288 277 18 a a DT 40288 277 19 difference difference NN 40288 277 20 in in IN 40288 277 21 the the DT 40288 277 22 pitch pitch NN 40288 277 23 of of IN 40288 277 24 the the DT 40288 277 25 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 277 26 - - HYPH 40288 277 27 lydian lydian JJ 40288 277 28 scale scale NN 40288 277 29 . . . 40288 278 1 As as IN 40288 278 2 to to IN 40288 278 3 this this DT 40288 278 4 , , , 40288 278 5 however however RB 40288 278 6 , , , 40288 278 7 see see UH 40288 278 8 p. p. NN 40288 278 9 23 23 CD 40288 278 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 278 11 note note NN 40288 278 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 278 13 . . . 40288 279 1 The the DT 40288 279 2 words word NNS 40288 279 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 279 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 279 5 : : : 40288 279 6 Hypophrygion hypophrygion NN 40288 279 7 aulon aulon NN 40288 279 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 279 9 have have VBP 40288 279 10 also also RB 40288 279 11 been be VBN 40288 279 12 condemned condemn VBN 40288 279 13 by by IN 40288 279 14 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 279 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 279 16 _ _ NNP 40288 279 17 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 279 18 _ _ NNP 40288 279 19 , , , 40288 279 20 p. p. NN 40288 279 21 453 453 CD 40288 279 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 279 23 . . . 40288 280 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 280 2 points point VBZ 40288 280 3 out out RP 40288 280 4 the the DT 40288 280 5 curious curious JJ 40288 280 6 contradiction contradiction NN 40288 280 7 between between IN 40288 280 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 280 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 280 10 : : : 40288 280 11 pros pro NNS 40288 280 12 tên tên NNP 40288 280 13 tôn tôn NNP 40288 280 14 aulôn aulôn NNP 40288 280 15 trypêsin trypêsin NNP 40288 280 16 blepontes blepontes NNP 40288 280 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 280 18 and and CC 40288 280 19 the the DT 40288 280 20 complaint complaint NN 40288 280 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 280 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 280 23 : : : 40288 280 24 ti ti NNP 40288 280 25 d d NN 40288 280 26 ' ' `` 40288 280 27 esti esti NN 40288 280 28 pros pro NNS 40288 280 29 ho ho VBP 40288 280 30 blepontes bleponte NNS 40288 280 31 ... ... : 40288 280 32 ouden ouden VBN 40288 280 33 eirêkasin eirêkasin NN 40288 280 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 280 35 . . . 40288 281 1 But but CC 40288 281 2 if if IN 40288 281 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 281 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 281 5 : : : 40288 281 6 pros pro NNS 40288 281 7 tên tên NN 40288 281 8 ... ... NFP 40288 281 9 blepontes bleponte NNS 40288 281 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 281 11 was be VBD 40288 281 12 a a DT 40288 281 13 marginal marginal JJ 40288 281 14 gloss gloss NN 40288 281 15 , , , 40288 281 16 as as IN 40288 281 17 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 281 18 suggests suggest VBZ 40288 281 19 , , , 40288 281 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 281 21 was be VBD 40288 281 22 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 281 23 a a DT 40288 281 24 gloss gloss NN 40288 281 25 on on IN 40288 281 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 281 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 281 28 : : : 40288 281 29 aulon aulon NN 40288 281 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 281 31 , , , 40288 281 32 and and CC 40288 281 33 if if IN 40288 281 34 so so RB 40288 281 35 , , , 40288 281 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 281 37 Greek greek JJ 40288 281 38 : : : 40288 281 39 aulon aulon NN 40288 281 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 281 41 is be VBZ 40288 281 42 presumably presumably RB 40288 281 43 sound sound JJ 40288 281 44 . . . 40288 282 1 Since since IN 40288 282 2 the the DT 40288 282 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 282 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 282 5 : : : 40288 282 6 aulos aulos NNP 40288 282 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 282 8 was be VBD 40288 282 9 especially especially RB 40288 282 10 a a DT 40288 282 11 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 282 12 instrument instrument NN 40288 282 13 , , , 40288 282 14 and and CC 40288 282 15 regularly regularly RB 40288 282 16 associated associate VBN 40288 282 17 with with IN 40288 282 18 the the DT 40288 282 19 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 282 20 mode mode NN 40288 282 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 282 22 as as IN 40288 282 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 282 24 know know VBP 40288 282 25 from from IN 40288 282 26 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 282 27 , , , 40288 282 28 see see VB 40288 282 29 p. p. NN 40288 282 30 13 13 CD 40288 282 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 282 32 , , , 40288 282 33 nothing nothing NN 40288 282 34 is be VBZ 40288 282 35 more more RBR 40288 282 36 probable probable JJ 40288 282 37 than than IN 40288 282 38 that that IN 40288 282 39 there there EX 40288 282 40 was be VBD 40288 282 41 a a DT 40288 282 42 variety variety NN 40288 282 43 of of IN 40288 282 44 flute flute NN 40288 282 45 called call VBN 40288 282 46 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 282 47 - - HYPH 40288 282 48 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 282 49 , , , 40288 282 50 because because IN 40288 282 51 tuned tune VBN 40288 282 52 so so IN 40288 282 53 as as IN 40288 282 54 to to TO 40288 282 55 yield yield VB 40288 282 56 the the DT 40288 282 57 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 282 58 - - HYPH 40288 282 59 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 282 60 key key NN 40288 282 61 , , , 40288 282 62 either either CC 40288 282 63 by by IN 40288 282 64 itself -PRON- PRP 40288 282 65 or or CC 40288 282 66 as as IN 40288 282 67 a a DT 40288 282 68 modulation modulation NN 40288 282 69 from from IN 40288 282 70 the the DT 40288 282 71 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 282 72 . . . 40288 282 73 ] ] -RRB- 40288 283 1 In in IN 40288 283 2 this this DT 40288 283 3 scheme scheme NN 40288 283 4 the the DT 40288 283 5 important important JJ 40288 283 6 feature feature NN 40288 283 7 -- -- : 40288 283 8 that that IN 40288 283 9 which which WDT 40288 283 10 marks mark VBZ 40288 283 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 283 12 as as IN 40288 283 13 an an DT 40288 283 14 advance advance NN 40288 283 15 on on IN 40288 283 16 the the DT 40288 283 17 others other NNS 40288 283 18 referred refer VBD 40288 283 19 to to IN 40288 283 20 by by IN 40288 283 21 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 283 22 -- -- : 40288 283 23 is be VBZ 40288 283 24 the the DT 40288 283 25 conformity conformity NN 40288 283 26 which which WDT 40288 283 27 it -PRON- PRP 40288 283 28 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40288 283 29 with with IN 40288 283 30 the the DT 40288 283 31 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 283 32 scale scale NN 40288 283 33 . . . 40288 284 1 The the DT 40288 284 2 result result NN 40288 284 3 of of IN 40288 284 4 this this DT 40288 284 5 conformity conformity NN 40288 284 6 is be VBZ 40288 284 7 that that IN 40288 284 8 the the DT 40288 284 9 keys key NNS 40288 284 10 stand stand VBP 40288 284 11 in in IN 40288 284 12 a a DT 40288 284 13 certain certain JJ 40288 284 14 relation relation NN 40288 284 15 to to IN 40288 284 16 each each DT 40288 284 17 other other JJ 40288 284 18 . . . 40288 285 1 Taking take VBG 40288 285 2 any any DT 40288 285 3 two two CD 40288 285 4 , , , 40288 285 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 285 6 find find VBP 40288 285 7 that that IN 40288 285 8 certain certain JJ 40288 285 9 notes note NNS 40288 285 10 are be VBP 40288 285 11 common common JJ 40288 285 12 to to IN 40288 285 13 them -PRON- PRP 40288 285 14 . . . 40288 286 1 So so RB 40288 286 2 long long RB 40288 286 3 as as IN 40288 286 4 the the DT 40288 286 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 286 6 of of IN 40288 286 7 pitch pitch NN 40288 286 8 were be VBD 40288 286 9 quite quite RB 40288 286 10 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 40288 286 11 , , , 40288 286 12 or or CC 40288 286 13 were be VBD 40288 286 14 practically practically RB 40288 286 15 irrational irrational JJ 40288 286 16 quantities quantity NNS 40288 286 17 , , , 40288 286 18 such such JJ 40288 286 19 as as IN 40288 286 20 three three CD 40288 286 21 - - HYPH 40288 286 22 quarters quarter NNS 40288 286 23 of of IN 40288 286 24 a a DT 40288 286 25 tone tone NN 40288 286 26 , , , 40288 286 27 no no DT 40288 286 28 such such JJ 40288 286 29 relation relation NN 40288 286 30 could could MD 40288 286 31 exist exist VB 40288 286 32 . . . 40288 287 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 287 2 now now RB 40288 287 3 became become VBD 40288 287 4 possible possible JJ 40288 287 5 to to TO 40288 287 6 pass pass VB 40288 287 7 from from IN 40288 287 8 one one CD 40288 287 9 key key NN 40288 287 10 to to IN 40288 287 11 another another DT 40288 287 12 , , , 40288 287 13 _ _ NNP 40288 287 14 i. i. NNP 40288 288 1 e. e. NNP 40288 288 2 _ _ NNP 40288 288 3 to to TO 40288 288 4 employ employ VB 40288 288 5 _ _ NNP 40288 288 6 modulation modulation NN 40288 288 7 _ _ NNP 40288 288 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 288 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 288 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 288 11 : : : 40288 288 12 metabolê metabolê NN 40288 288 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 288 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 288 15 as as IN 40288 288 16 a a DT 40288 288 17 source source NN 40288 288 18 of of IN 40288 288 19 musical musical JJ 40288 288 20 effect effect NN 40288 288 21 . . . 40288 289 1 This this DT 40288 289 2 new new JJ 40288 289 3 system system NN 40288 289 4 had have VBD 40288 289 5 evidently evidently RB 40288 289 6 made make VBN 40288 289 7 some some DT 40288 289 8 progress progress NN 40288 289 9 when when WRB 40288 289 10 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 289 11 wrote write VBD 40288 289 12 , , , 40288 289 13 though though IN 40288 289 14 it -PRON- PRP 40288 289 15 was be VBD 40288 289 16 not not RB 40288 289 17 perfected perfect VBN 40288 289 18 , , , 40288 289 19 and and CC 40288 289 20 had have VBD 40288 289 21 not not RB 40288 289 22 passed pass VBN 40288 289 23 into into IN 40288 289 24 general general JJ 40288 289 25 use use NN 40288 289 26 . . . 40288 290 1 § § ADD 40288 290 2 11 11 CD 40288 290 3 . . . 40288 291 1 _ _ NNP 40288 291 2 Names Names NNPS 40288 291 3 of of IN 40288 291 4 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 291 5 _ _ NNP 40288 291 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 291 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 291 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 291 9 : : : 40288 291 10 hypo- hypo- NN 40288 291 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 291 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 291 13 . . . 40288 292 1 A a DT 40288 292 2 point point NN 40288 292 3 that that WDT 40288 292 4 deserves deserve VBZ 40288 292 5 special special JJ 40288 292 6 notice notice NN 40288 292 7 at at IN 40288 292 8 this this DT 40288 292 9 place place NN 40288 292 10 is be VBZ 40288 292 11 the the DT 40288 292 12 use use NN 40288 292 13 of of IN 40288 292 14 the the DT 40288 292 15 prefix prefix NN 40288 292 16 _ _ NNP 40288 292 17 Hypo- Hypo- NNP 40288 292 18 _ _ NNP 40288 292 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 292 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 292 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 292 22 : : : 40288 292 23 hypo- hypo- NN 40288 292 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 292 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 292 26 in in IN 40288 292 27 the the DT 40288 292 28 names name NNS 40288 292 29 of of IN 40288 292 30 keys key NNS 40288 292 31 . . . 40288 293 1 In in IN 40288 293 2 the the DT 40288 293 3 final final JJ 40288 293 4 Aristoxenean aristoxenean JJ 40288 293 5 system system NN 40288 293 6 _ _ NNP 40288 293 7 Hypo- Hypo- NNP 40288 293 8 _ _ NNP 40288 293 9 implies imply VBZ 40288 293 10 that that IN 40288 293 11 a a DT 40288 293 12 key key NN 40288 293 13 is be VBZ 40288 293 14 lower low JJR 40288 293 15 by by IN 40288 293 16 the the DT 40288 293 17 interval interval NN 40288 293 18 of of IN 40288 293 19 a a DT 40288 293 20 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 293 21 than than IN 40288 293 22 the the DT 40288 293 23 key key NN 40288 293 24 to to IN 40288 293 25 whose whose WP$ 40288 293 26 name name NN 40288 293 27 it -PRON- PRP 40288 293 28 is be VBZ 40288 293 29 prefixed prefix VBN 40288 293 30 . . . 40288 294 1 This this DT 40288 294 2 convention convention NN 40288 294 3 served serve VBD 40288 294 4 to to TO 40288 294 5 bring bring VB 40288 294 6 out out RP 40288 294 7 the the DT 40288 294 8 special special JJ 40288 294 9 relation relation NN 40288 294 10 between between IN 40288 294 11 the the DT 40288 294 12 two two CD 40288 294 13 keys key NNS 40288 294 14 , , , 40288 294 15 viz viz NN 40288 294 16 . . . 40288 295 1 to to TO 40288 295 2 show show VB 40288 295 3 that that IN 40288 295 4 they -PRON- PRP 40288 295 5 are be VBP 40288 295 6 related relate VBN 40288 295 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 295 8 to to TO 40288 295 9 use use VB 40288 295 10 modern modern JJ 40288 295 11 language language NN 40288 295 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 295 13 as as IN 40288 295 14 the the DT 40288 295 15 keys key NNS 40288 295 16 of of IN 40288 295 17 a a DT 40288 295 18 tonic tonic NN 40288 295 19 and and CC 40288 295 20 dominant dominant JJ 40288 295 21 . . . 40288 296 1 In in IN 40288 296 2 the the DT 40288 296 3 scheme scheme NN 40288 296 4 of of IN 40288 296 5 keys key NNS 40288 296 6 now now RB 40288 296 7 in in IN 40288 296 8 question question NN 40288 296 9 there there EX 40288 296 10 is be VBZ 40288 296 11 only only RB 40288 296 12 one one CD 40288 296 13 instance instance NN 40288 296 14 of of IN 40288 296 15 this this DT 40288 296 16 use use NN 40288 296 17 of of IN 40288 296 18 _ _ NNP 40288 296 19 Hypo- Hypo- NNP 40288 296 20 _ _ NNP 40288 296 21 , , , 40288 296 22 namely namely RB 40288 296 23 in in IN 40288 296 24 the the DT 40288 296 25 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 296 26 - - HYPH 40288 296 27 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 296 28 , , , 40288 296 29 the the DT 40288 296 30 most most RBS 40288 296 31 recently recently RB 40288 296 32 introduced introduce VBN 40288 296 33 . . . 40288 297 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 297 2 must must MD 40288 297 3 have have VB 40288 297 4 been be VBN 40288 297 5 on on IN 40288 297 6 the the DT 40288 297 7 analogy analogy NN 40288 297 8 of of IN 40288 297 9 this this DT 40288 297 10 name name NN 40288 297 11 that that WDT 40288 297 12 the the DT 40288 297 13 term term NN 40288 297 14 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 297 15 - - HYPH 40288 297 16 dorian dorian NNP 40288 297 17 was be VBD 40288 297 18 shifted shift VBN 40288 297 19 from from IN 40288 297 20 the the DT 40288 297 21 key key NN 40288 297 22 immediately immediately RB 40288 297 23 below below IN 40288 297 24 the the DT 40288 297 25 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 297 26 to to IN 40288 297 27 the the DT 40288 297 28 new new JJ 40288 297 29 key key NN 40288 297 30 a a DT 40288 297 31 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 297 32 below below IN 40288 297 33 it -PRON- PRP 40288 297 34 , , , 40288 297 35 and and CC 40288 297 36 that that IN 40288 297 37 the the DT 40288 297 38 new new JJ 40288 297 39 term term NN 40288 297 40 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 297 41 - - HYPH 40288 297 42 lydian lydian NNP 40288 297 43 was be VBD 40288 297 44 given give VBN 40288 297 45 to to IN 40288 297 46 the the DT 40288 297 47 old old JJ 40288 297 48 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 297 49 - - HYPH 40288 297 50 dorian dorian JJ 40288 297 51 in in IN 40288 297 52 accordance accordance NN 40288 297 53 with with IN 40288 297 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 297 55 similar similar JJ 40288 297 56 relation relation NN 40288 297 57 to to IN 40288 297 58 the the DT 40288 297 59 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 297 60 . . . 40288 298 1 In in IN 40288 298 2 the the DT 40288 298 3 time time NN 40288 298 4 of of IN 40288 298 5 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 298 6 , , , 40288 298 7 then then RB 40288 298 8 , , , 40288 298 9 this this DT 40288 298 10 technical technical JJ 40288 298 11 sense sense NN 40288 298 12 of of IN 40288 298 13 _ _ NNP 40288 298 14 Hypo- Hypo- NNP 40288 298 15 _ _ NNP 40288 298 16 had have VBD 40288 298 17 not not RB 40288 298 18 yet yet RB 40288 298 19 been be VBN 40288 298 20 established establish VBN 40288 298 21 , , , 40288 298 22 but but CC 40288 298 23 was be VBD 40288 298 24 coming come VBG 40288 298 25 into into IN 40288 298 26 use use NN 40288 298 27 . . . 40288 299 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 299 2 led lead VBD 40288 299 3 naturally naturally RB 40288 299 4 to to IN 40288 299 5 the the DT 40288 299 6 employment employment NN 40288 299 7 of of IN 40288 299 8 _ _ NNP 40288 299 9 Hyper- Hyper- NNP 40288 299 10 _ _ NNP 40288 299 11 in in IN 40288 299 12 the the DT 40288 299 13 inverse inverse NN 40288 299 14 sense sense NN 40288 299 15 , , , 40288 299 16 viz viz NN 40288 299 17 . . . 40288 300 1 to to TO 40288 300 2 denote denote VB 40288 300 3 a a DT 40288 300 4 key key NN 40288 300 5 a a DT 40288 300 6 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 300 7 higher high JJR 40288 300 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 300 9 the the DT 40288 300 10 key key NN 40288 300 11 of of IN 40288 300 12 the the DT 40288 300 13 sub sub JJ 40288 300 14 - - JJ 40288 300 15 dominant dominant JJ 40288 300 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 300 17 . . . 40288 301 1 By by IN 40288 301 2 further further JJ 40288 301 3 steps step NNS 40288 301 4 , , , 40288 301 5 of of IN 40288 301 6 which which WDT 40288 301 7 there there EX 40288 301 8 is be VBZ 40288 301 9 no no DT 40288 301 10 record record NN 40288 301 11 , , , 40288 301 12 the the DT 40288 301 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 301 14 musicians musician NNS 40288 301 15 arrived arrive VBD 40288 301 16 at at IN 40288 301 17 the the DT 40288 301 18 idea idea NN 40288 301 19 of of IN 40288 301 20 a a DT 40288 301 21 key key NN 40288 301 22 for for IN 40288 301 23 every every DT 40288 301 24 semitone semitone NN 40288 301 25 in in IN 40288 301 26 the the DT 40288 301 27 octave octave NN 40288 301 28 ; ; : 40288 301 29 and and CC 40288 301 30 thus thus RB 40288 301 31 was be VBD 40288 301 32 formed form VBN 40288 301 33 the the DT 40288 301 34 system system NN 40288 301 35 of of IN 40288 301 36 thirteen thirteen CD 40288 301 37 keys key NNS 40288 301 38 , , , 40288 301 39 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 301 40 to to IN 40288 301 41 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 301 42 by by IN 40288 301 43 later later JJ 40288 301 44 writers writer NNS 40288 301 45 . . . 40288 302 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 302 2 See see VB 40288 302 3 the the DT 40288 302 4 scheme scheme NN 40288 302 5 at at IN 40288 302 6 the the DT 40288 302 7 end end NN 40288 302 8 of of IN 40288 302 9 this this DT 40288 302 10 book book NN 40288 302 11 , , , 40288 302 12 Table Table NNP 40288 302 13 II II NNP 40288 302 14 . . . 40288 302 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 303 1 Whether whether IN 40288 303 2 in in IN 40288 303 3 fact fact NN 40288 303 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 303 5 was be VBD 40288 303 6 entirely entirely RB 40288 303 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 303 8 work work NN 40288 303 9 may may MD 40288 303 10 be be VB 40288 303 11 doubted doubt VBN 40288 303 12 . . . 40288 304 1 In in IN 40288 304 2 any any DT 40288 304 3 case case NN 40288 304 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 304 5 had have VBD 40288 304 6 formed form VBN 40288 304 7 a a DT 40288 304 8 clear clear JJ 40288 304 9 conception conception NN 40288 304 10 -- -- : 40288 304 11 the the DT 40288 304 12 want want NN 40288 304 13 of of IN 40288 304 14 which which WDT 40288 304 15 he -PRON- PRP 40288 304 16 noted note VBD 40288 304 17 in in IN 40288 304 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 304 19 predecessors predecessor NNS 40288 304 20 -- -- : 40288 304 21 of of IN 40288 304 22 the the DT 40288 304 23 principles principle NNS 40288 304 24 on on IN 40288 304 25 which which WDT 40288 304 26 a a DT 40288 304 27 theoretically theoretically RB 40288 304 28 complete complete JJ 40288 304 29 scheme scheme NN 40288 304 30 of of IN 40288 304 31 keys key NNS 40288 304 32 should should MD 40288 304 33 be be VB 40288 304 34 constructed construct VBN 40288 304 35 . . . 40288 305 1 In in IN 40288 305 2 the the DT 40288 305 3 discussions discussion NNS 40288 305 4 to to TO 40288 305 5 which which WDT 40288 305 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 305 7 have have VBP 40288 305 8 been be VBN 40288 305 9 referring refer VBG 40288 305 10 , , , 40288 305 11 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 305 12 invariably invariably RB 40288 305 13 employs employ VBZ 40288 305 14 the the DT 40288 305 15 word word NN 40288 305 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 305 17 Greek greek NN 40288 305 18 : : : 40288 305 19 tonos tonos NN 40288 305 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 305 21 in in IN 40288 305 22 the the DT 40288 305 23 sense sense NN 40288 305 24 of of IN 40288 305 25 ' ' `` 40288 305 26 key key NN 40288 305 27 . . . 40288 305 28 ' ' '' 40288 306 1 The the DT 40288 306 2 word word NN 40288 306 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 306 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 306 5 : : : 40288 306 6 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 306 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 306 8 in in IN 40288 306 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 306 10 writings writing NNS 40288 306 11 is be VBZ 40288 306 12 equivalent equivalent JJ 40288 306 13 to to IN 40288 306 14 ' ' `` 40288 306 15 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 306 16 genus genus NN 40288 306 17 ' ' '' 40288 306 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 306 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 306 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 306 21 : : : 40288 306 22 genos genos NNP 40288 306 23 enarmonion enarmonion NN 40288 306 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 306 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 306 26 , , , 40288 306 27 the the DT 40288 306 28 _ _ NNP 40288 306 29 genus genus NNP 40288 306 30 _ _ NNP 40288 306 31 of of IN 40288 306 32 music music NN 40288 306 33 which which WDT 40288 306 34 made make VBD 40288 306 35 use use NN 40288 306 36 of of IN 40288 306 37 the the DT 40288 306 38 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 306 39 _ _ NNP 40288 306 40 diësis diësis NN 40288 306 41 _ _ NNP 40288 306 42 or or CC 40288 306 43 quarter quarter NN 40288 306 44 - - HYPH 40288 306 45 tone tone NN 40288 306 46 . . . 40288 307 1 Thus thus RB 40288 307 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 307 3 never never RB 40288 307 4 speaks speak VBZ 40288 307 5 , , , 40288 307 6 as as IN 40288 307 7 Plato Plato NNP 40288 307 8 and and CC 40288 307 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 307 10 do do VBP 40288 307 11 , , , 40288 307 12 of of IN 40288 307 13 the the DT 40288 307 14 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 307 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 307 16 or or CC 40288 307 17 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 307 18 or or CC 40288 307 19 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 307 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 307 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 307 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 307 23 : : : 40288 307 24 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 307 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 307 26 , , , 40288 307 27 but but CC 40288 307 28 only only RB 40288 307 29 of of IN 40288 307 30 the the DT 40288 307 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 307 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 307 33 : : : 40288 307 34 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 307 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 307 36 so so RB 40288 307 37 named name VBN 40288 307 38 . . . 40288 308 1 There there EX 40288 308 2 is be VBZ 40288 308 3 indeed indeed RB 40288 308 4 one one CD 40288 308 5 passage passage NN 40288 308 6 in in IN 40288 308 7 which which WDT 40288 308 8 certain certain JJ 40288 308 9 octave octave NN 40288 308 10 scales scale NNS 40288 308 11 are be VBP 40288 308 12 said say VBN 40288 308 13 by by IN 40288 308 14 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 308 15 to to TO 40288 308 16 have have VB 40288 308 17 been be VBN 40288 308 18 called call VBN 40288 308 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 308 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 308 21 : : : 40288 308 22 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 308 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 308 24 : : : 40288 308 25 but but CC 40288 308 26 this this DT 40288 308 27 , , , 40288 308 28 as as IN 40288 308 29 will will MD 40288 308 30 be be VB 40288 308 31 shown show VBN 40288 308 32 , , , 40288 308 33 is be VBZ 40288 308 34 a a DT 40288 308 35 use use NN 40288 308 36 which which WDT 40288 308 37 is be VBZ 40288 308 38 to to TO 40288 308 39 be be VB 40288 308 40 otherwise otherwise RB 40288 308 41 explained explain VBN 40288 308 42 ( ( -LRB- 40288 308 43 see see VB 40288 308 44 p. p. NN 40288 308 45 54 54 CD 40288 308 46 ) ) -RRB- 40288 308 47 . . . 40288 309 1 § § ADD 40288 309 2 12 12 CD 40288 309 3 . . . 40288 310 1 _ _ NNP 40288 310 2 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 310 3 's 's POS 40288 310 4 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40288 310 5 on on IN 40288 310 6 Music Music NNP 40288 310 7 . . . 40288 310 8 _ _ XX 40288 310 9 After after IN 40288 310 10 the the DT 40288 310 11 time time NN 40288 310 12 of of IN 40288 310 13 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 310 14 the the DT 40288 310 15 technical technical JJ 40288 310 16 writers writer NNS 40288 310 17 on on IN 40288 310 18 music music NN 40288 310 19 make make VBP 40288 310 20 little little JJ 40288 310 21 or or CC 40288 310 22 no no DT 40288 310 23 use use NN 40288 310 24 of of IN 40288 310 25 the the DT 40288 310 26 term term NN 40288 310 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 310 28 Greek Greek NNP 40288 310 29 : : : 40288 310 30 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 310 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 310 32 . . . 40288 311 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 311 2 word word NN 40288 311 3 for for IN 40288 311 4 ' ' `` 40288 311 5 key key NN 40288 311 6 ' ' '' 40288 311 7 is be VBZ 40288 311 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 311 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 311 10 : : : 40288 311 11 tonos tonos NN 40288 311 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 311 13 ; ; : 40288 311 14 and and CC 40288 311 15 the the DT 40288 311 16 octachord octachord NNP 40288 311 17 scales scale NNS 40288 311 18 which which WDT 40288 311 19 are be VBP 40288 311 20 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 311 21 by by IN 40288 311 22 the the DT 40288 311 23 succession succession NN 40288 311 24 of of IN 40288 311 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 311 26 intervals interval NNS 40288 311 27 are be VBP 40288 311 28 called call VBN 40288 311 29 ' ' '' 40288 311 30 species specie NNS 40288 311 31 of of IN 40288 311 32 the the DT 40288 311 33 octave octave NN 40288 311 34 ' ' '' 40288 311 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 311 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 311 37 Greek Greek NNP 40288 311 38 : : : 40288 311 39 eidê eidê NNP 40288 311 40 tou tou NNP 40288 311 41 dia dia NNP 40288 311 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 311 43 [ [ -LRB- 40288 311 44 Greek Greek NNP 40288 311 45 : : : 40288 311 46 pasôn pasôn NN 40288 311 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 311 48 ) ) -RRB- 40288 311 49 . . . 40288 312 1 The the DT 40288 312 2 modes mode NNS 40288 312 3 of of IN 40288 312 4 the the DT 40288 312 5 classical classical JJ 40288 312 6 period period NN 40288 312 7 , , , 40288 312 8 however however RB 40288 312 9 , , , 40288 312 10 were be VBD 40288 312 11 still still RB 40288 312 12 objects object NNS 40288 312 13 of of IN 40288 312 14 antiquarian antiquarian JJ 40288 312 15 and and CC 40288 312 16 philosophic philosophic JJ 40288 312 17 interest interest NN 40288 312 18 , , , 40288 312 19 and and CC 40288 312 20 authors author NNS 40288 312 21 who who WP 40288 312 22 treated treat VBD 40288 312 23 them -PRON- PRP 40288 312 24 from from IN 40288 312 25 this this DT 40288 312 26 point point NN 40288 312 27 of of IN 40288 312 28 view view NN 40288 312 29 naturally naturally RB 40288 312 30 kept keep VBD 40288 312 31 up up RP 40288 312 32 the the DT 40288 312 33 old old JJ 40288 312 34 designation designation NN 40288 312 35 . . . 40288 313 1 A a DT 40288 313 2 good good JJ 40288 313 3 specimen speciman NNS 40288 313 4 of of IN 40288 313 5 the the DT 40288 313 6 writings writing NNS 40288 313 7 of of IN 40288 313 8 this this DT 40288 313 9 class class NN 40288 313 10 has have VBZ 40288 313 11 survived survive VBN 40288 313 12 in in IN 40288 313 13 the the DT 40288 313 14 _ _ NNP 40288 313 15 dialogus dialogus NNP 40288 313 16 de de NNP 40288 313 17 musicâ musicâ NNP 40288 313 18 _ _ NNP 40288 313 19 of of IN 40288 313 20 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 313 21 . . . 40288 314 1 Like like IN 40288 314 2 most most JJS 40288 314 3 productions production NNS 40288 314 4 of of IN 40288 314 5 the the DT 40288 314 6 time time NN 40288 314 7 , , , 40288 314 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 314 9 is be VBZ 40288 314 10 mainly mainly RB 40288 314 11 a a DT 40288 314 12 compilation compilation NN 40288 314 13 from from IN 40288 314 14 earlier early JJR 40288 314 15 works work NNS 40288 314 16 now now RB 40288 314 17 lost lose VBN 40288 314 18 . . . 40288 315 1 Much much JJ 40288 315 2 of of IN 40288 315 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 315 4 comes come VBZ 40288 315 5 from from IN 40288 315 6 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 315 7 , , , 40288 315 8 and and CC 40288 315 9 there there EX 40288 315 10 is be VBZ 40288 315 11 therefore therefore RB 40288 315 12 a a DT 40288 315 13 special special JJ 40288 315 14 fitness fitness NN 40288 315 15 in in IN 40288 315 16 dealing deal VBG 40288 315 17 with with IN 40288 315 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 315 19 in in IN 40288 315 20 this this DT 40288 315 21 place place NN 40288 315 22 , , , 40288 315 23 by by IN 40288 315 24 way way NN 40288 315 25 of of IN 40288 315 26 supplement supplement NN 40288 315 27 to to IN 40288 315 28 the the DT 40288 315 29 arguments argument NNS 40288 315 30 drawn draw VBN 40288 315 31 directly directly RB 40288 315 32 from from IN 40288 315 33 the the DT 40288 315 34 Aristoxenean Aristoxenean NNP 40288 315 35 _ _ NNP 40288 315 36 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 315 37 _ _ NNP 40288 315 38 . . . 40288 316 1 The the DT 40288 316 2 following follow VBG 40288 316 3 are be VBP 40288 316 4 the the DT 40288 316 5 chief chief JJ 40288 316 6 passages passage NNS 40288 316 7 bearing bear VBG 40288 316 8 on on IN 40288 316 9 the the DT 40288 316 10 subject subject NN 40288 316 11 of of IN 40288 316 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 316 13 enquiry enquiry NN 40288 316 14 : : : 40288 316 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 316 16 1 1 LS 40288 316 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 316 18 In in IN 40288 316 19 cc cc NNP 40288 316 20 . . . 40288 317 1 15 15 CD 40288 317 2 - - SYM 40288 317 3 17 17 CD 40288 317 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 317 5 find find VBP 40288 317 6 a a DT 40288 317 7 commentary commentary NN 40288 317 8 of of IN 40288 317 9 some some DT 40288 317 10 interest interest NN 40288 317 11 on on IN 40288 317 12 the the DT 40288 317 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 317 14 treatment treatment NN 40288 317 15 of of IN 40288 317 16 the the DT 40288 317 17 modes mode NNS 40288 317 18 . . . 40288 318 1 Plutarch plutarch NN 40288 318 2 is be VBZ 40288 318 3 dwelling dwell VBG 40288 318 4 on on IN 40288 318 5 the the DT 40288 318 6 superiority superiority NN 40288 318 7 of of IN 40288 318 8 the the DT 40288 318 9 older old JJR 40288 318 10 and and CC 40288 318 11 simpler simple JJR 40288 318 12 music music NN 40288 318 13 , , , 40288 318 14 and and CC 40288 318 15 appeals appeal NNS 40288 318 16 to to IN 40288 318 17 the the DT 40288 318 18 opinion opinion NN 40288 318 19 of of IN 40288 318 20 Plato Plato NNP 40288 318 21 . . . 40288 319 1 ' ' `` 40288 319 2 The the DT 40288 319 3 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 319 4 mode mode NN 40288 319 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 319 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 319 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 319 8 : : : 40288 319 9 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 319 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 319 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 319 12 Plato Plato NNP 40288 319 13 objects object VBZ 40288 319 14 to to TO 40288 319 15 because because IN 40288 319 16 it -PRON- PRP 40288 319 17 is be VBZ 40288 319 18 high high JJ 40288 319 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 319 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 319 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 319 22 : : : 40288 319 23 oxeia oxeia NN 40288 319 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 319 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 319 26 and and CC 40288 319 27 suited suit VBN 40288 319 28 to to IN 40288 319 29 lamentation lamentation NN 40288 319 30 . . . 40288 320 1 Indeed indeed RB 40288 320 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 320 3 is be VBZ 40288 320 4 said say VBN 40288 320 5 to to TO 40288 320 6 have have VB 40288 320 7 been be VBN 40288 320 8 originally originally RB 40288 320 9 devised devise VBN 40288 320 10 for for IN 40288 320 11 that that DT 40288 320 12 purpose purpose NN 40288 320 13 : : : 40288 320 14 for for IN 40288 320 15 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 320 16 tells tell VBZ 40288 320 17 us -PRON- PRP 40288 320 18 , , , 40288 320 19 in in IN 40288 320 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 320 21 first first JJ 40288 320 22 book book NN 40288 320 23 on on IN 40288 320 24 Music Music NNP 40288 320 25 , , , 40288 320 26 that that IN 40288 320 27 Olympus Olympus NNP 40288 320 28 first first RB 40288 320 29 employed employ VBD 40288 320 30 the the DT 40288 320 31 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 320 32 mode mode NN 40288 320 33 on on IN 40288 320 34 the the DT 40288 320 35 flute flute NN 40288 320 36 in in IN 40288 320 37 a a DT 40288 320 38 dirge dirge NN 40288 320 39 ( ( -LRB- 40288 320 40 [ [ -LRB- 40288 320 41 Greek Greek NNP 40288 320 42 : : : 40288 320 43 epikêdeion epikêdeion NN 40288 320 44 aulêsai aulêsai NN 40288 320 45 Lydisti Lydisti NNP 40288 320 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 320 47 ) ) -RRB- 40288 320 48 over over IN 40288 320 49 the the DT 40288 320 50 Python Python NNP 40288 320 51 . . . 40288 321 1 But but CC 40288 321 2 some some DT 40288 321 3 say say VBP 40288 321 4 that that IN 40288 321 5 Melanippides Melanippides NNP 40288 321 6 began begin VBD 40288 321 7 this this DT 40288 321 8 kind kind NN 40288 321 9 of of IN 40288 321 10 music music NN 40288 321 11 . . . 40288 322 1 And and CC 40288 322 2 Pindar Pindar NNP 40288 322 3 in in IN 40288 322 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 322 5 paeans paean NNS 40288 322 6 says say VBZ 40288 322 7 that that IN 40288 322 8 the the DT 40288 322 9 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 322 10 mode mode NN 40288 322 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 322 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 322 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 322 14 : : : 40288 322 15 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 322 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 322 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 322 18 was be VBD 40288 322 19 first first RB 40288 322 20 brought bring VBN 40288 322 21 in in RP 40288 322 22 by by IN 40288 322 23 Anthippus Anthippus NNP 40288 322 24 in in IN 40288 322 25 an an DT 40288 322 26 ode ode NN 40288 322 27 on on IN 40288 322 28 the the DT 40288 322 29 marriage marriage NN 40288 322 30 of of IN 40288 322 31 Niobe Niobe NNP 40288 322 32 . . . 40288 323 1 But but CC 40288 323 2 others other NNS 40288 323 3 say say VBP 40288 323 4 that that IN 40288 323 5 Torrhebus Torrhebus NNP 40288 323 6 first first RB 40288 323 7 used use VBD 40288 323 8 that that DT 40288 323 9 mode mode NN 40288 323 10 , , , 40288 323 11 as as IN 40288 323 12 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 323 13 the the DT 40288 323 14 Iambus Iambus NNP 40288 323 15 relates relate VBZ 40288 323 16 . . . 40288 323 17 ' ' '' 40288 324 1 ' ' `` 40288 324 2 The the DT 40288 324 3 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 324 4 - - HYPH 40288 324 5 lydian lydian NNP 40288 324 6 , , , 40288 324 7 too too RB 40288 324 8 , , , 40288 324 9 is be VBZ 40288 324 10 pathetic pathetic JJ 40288 324 11 and and CC 40288 324 12 suitable suitable JJ 40288 324 13 to to IN 40288 324 14 tragedy tragedy NN 40288 324 15 . . . 40288 325 1 And and CC 40288 325 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 325 3 says say VBZ 40288 325 4 that that IN 40288 325 5 Sappho Sappho NNP 40288 325 6 was be VBD 40288 325 7 the the DT 40288 325 8 inventor inventor NN 40288 325 9 of of IN 40288 325 10 the the DT 40288 325 11 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 325 12 - - HYPH 40288 325 13 lydian lydian NNP 40288 325 14 , , , 40288 325 15 and and CC 40288 325 16 that that IN 40288 325 17 from from IN 40288 325 18 her -PRON- PRP 40288 325 19 the the DT 40288 325 20 tragic tragic JJ 40288 325 21 poets poet NNS 40288 325 22 learned learn VBD 40288 325 23 it -PRON- PRP 40288 325 24 . . . 40288 326 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 326 2 combined combine VBD 40288 326 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 326 4 with with IN 40288 326 5 the the DT 40288 326 6 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 326 7 , , , 40288 326 8 since since IN 40288 326 9 that that DT 40288 326 10 mode mode NN 40288 326 11 gives give VBZ 40288 326 12 grandeur grandeur NN 40288 326 13 and and CC 40288 326 14 dignity dignity NN 40288 326 15 , , , 40288 326 16 and and CC 40288 326 17 the the DT 40288 326 18 other other JJ 40288 326 19 pathos pathos NN 40288 326 20 , , , 40288 326 21 and and CC 40288 326 22 these these DT 40288 326 23 are be VBP 40288 326 24 the the DT 40288 326 25 two two CD 40288 326 26 elements element NNS 40288 326 27 of of IN 40288 326 28 tragedy tragedy NN 40288 326 29 . . . 40288 327 1 But but CC 40288 327 2 in in IN 40288 327 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 327 4 Historical Historical NNP 40288 327 5 Treatise Treatise NNP 40288 327 6 on on IN 40288 327 7 Music music NN 40288 327 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 327 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 327 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 327 11 : : : 40288 327 12 historika historika NNP 40288 327 13 tês tês NNP 40288 327 14 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 327 15 hypomnêmata hypomnêmata NNP 40288 327 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 327 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 327 18 he -PRON- PRP 40288 327 19 says say VBZ 40288 327 20 that that IN 40288 327 21 Pythoclides Pythoclides NNP 40288 327 22 the the DT 40288 327 23 flute flute NN 40288 327 24 - - HYPH 40288 327 25 player player NN 40288 327 26 was be VBD 40288 327 27 the the DT 40288 327 28 discoverer discoverer NN 40288 327 29 of of IN 40288 327 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 327 31 . . . 40288 328 1 And and CC 40288 328 2 Lysis Lysis NNP 40288 328 3 says say VBZ 40288 328 4 that that IN 40288 328 5 Lamprocles Lamprocles NNP 40288 328 6 the the DT 40288 328 7 Athenian Athenian NNP 40288 328 8 , , , 40288 328 9 perceiving perceive VBG 40288 328 10 that that IN 40288 328 11 in in IN 40288 328 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 328 13 the the DT 40288 328 14 disjunctive disjunctive JJ 40288 328 15 tone tone NN 40288 328 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 328 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 328 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 328 19 : : : 40288 328 20 diazeuxis diazeuxis NNP 40288 328 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 328 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 328 23 is be VBZ 40288 328 24 not not RB 40288 328 25 where where WRB 40288 328 26 it -PRON- PRP 40288 328 27 was be VBD 40288 328 28 generally generally RB 40288 328 29 supposed suppose VBN 40288 328 30 to to TO 40288 328 31 be be VB 40288 328 32 , , , 40288 328 33 but but CC 40288 328 34 is be VBZ 40288 328 35 at at IN 40288 328 36 the the DT 40288 328 37 upper upper JJ 40288 328 38 end end NN 40288 328 39 of of IN 40288 328 40 the the DT 40288 328 41 scale scale NN 40288 328 42 , , , 40288 328 43 made make VBD 40288 328 44 the the DT 40288 328 45 form form NN 40288 328 46 of of IN 40288 328 47 it -PRON- PRP 40288 328 48 to to TO 40288 328 49 be be VB 40288 328 50 that that DT 40288 328 51 of of IN 40288 328 52 the the DT 40288 328 53 octave octave NN 40288 328 54 from from IN 40288 328 55 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 328 56 to to IN 40288 328 57 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 328 58 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 328 59 ( ( -LRB- 40288 328 60 [ [ -LRB- 40288 328 61 Greek Greek NNP 40288 328 62 : : : 40288 328 63 toiouton toiouton NNP 40288 328 64 autês autês NNP 40288 328 65 apergasasthai apergasasthai NNP 40288 328 66 to to TO 40288 328 67 schêma schêma VB 40288 328 68 hoion hoion NN 40288 328 69 to to TO 40288 328 70 apo apo VB 40288 328 71 paramesês paramesês NNP 40288 328 72 epi epi NNP 40288 328 73 hypatên hypatên NNP 40288 328 74 hypatôn hypatôn NNP 40288 328 75 ] ] -RRB- 40288 328 76 ) ) -RRB- 40288 328 77 . . . 40288 329 1 Moreover moreover RB 40288 329 2 , , , 40288 329 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 329 4 is be VBZ 40288 329 5 said say VBN 40288 329 6 that that IN 40288 329 7 the the DT 40288 329 8 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 329 9 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 329 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 329 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 329 12 Greek greek JJ 40288 329 13 : : : 40288 329 14 epaneimenên epaneimenên NN 40288 329 15 Lydisti Lydisti NNP 40288 329 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 329 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 329 18 , , , 40288 329 19 which which WDT 40288 329 20 is be VBZ 40288 329 21 the the DT 40288 329 22 opposite opposite NN 40288 329 23 of of IN 40288 329 24 the the DT 40288 329 25 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 329 26 - - HYPH 40288 329 27 lydian lydian NNP 40288 329 28 , , , 40288 329 29 being be VBG 40288 329 30 similar similar JJ 40288 329 31 to to IN 40288 329 32 the the DT 40288 329 33 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 329 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 329 35 [ [ -LRB- 40288 329 36 Greek Greek NNP 40288 329 37 : : : 40288 329 38 paraplêsian paraplêsian JJ 40288 329 39 ousan ousan NN 40288 329 40 tê tê NNP 40288 329 41 Iadi Iadi NNP 40288 329 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 329 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 329 44 , , , 40288 329 45 was be VBD 40288 329 46 invented invent VBN 40288 329 47 by by IN 40288 329 48 Damon Damon NNP 40288 329 49 the the DT 40288 329 50 Athenian Athenian NNP 40288 329 51 . . . 40288 329 52 ' ' '' 40288 330 1 ' ' `` 40288 330 2 These these DT 40288 330 3 modes mode NNS 40288 330 4 then then RB 40288 330 5 , , , 40288 330 6 the the DT 40288 330 7 one one CD 40288 330 8 plaintive plaintive NN 40288 330 9 , , , 40288 330 10 the the DT 40288 330 11 other other JJ 40288 330 12 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 330 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 330 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 330 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 330 16 : : : 40288 330 17 eklelymenê eklelymenê NN 40288 330 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 330 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 330 20 , , , 40288 330 21 Plato Plato NNP 40288 330 22 properly properly RB 40288 330 23 rejected reject VBD 40288 330 24 , , , 40288 330 25 and and CC 40288 330 26 chose choose VBD 40288 330 27 the the DT 40288 330 28 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 330 29 , , , 40288 330 30 as as IN 40288 330 31 befitting befit VBG 40288 330 32 warlike warlike RB 40288 330 33 and and CC 40288 330 34 temperate temperate VB 40288 330 35 men man NNS 40288 330 36 . . . 40288 330 37 ' ' '' 40288 331 1 In in IN 40288 331 2 this this DT 40288 331 3 passage passage NN 40288 331 4 the the DT 40288 331 5 ' ' `` 40288 331 6 high high RB 40288 331 7 - - HYPH 40288 331 8 pitched pitch VBN 40288 331 9 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 331 10 ' ' '' 40288 331 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 331 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 331 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 331 14 : : : 40288 331 15 Syntonolydisti Syntonolydisti NNP 40288 331 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 331 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 331 18 of of IN 40288 331 19 Plato Plato NNP 40288 331 20 is be VBZ 40288 331 21 called call VBN 40288 331 22 simply simply RB 40288 331 23 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 331 24 . . . 40288 332 1 There there EX 40288 332 2 is be VBZ 40288 332 3 every every DT 40288 332 4 reason reason NN 40288 332 5 to to TO 40288 332 6 suppose suppose VB 40288 332 7 that that IN 40288 332 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 332 9 is be VBZ 40288 332 10 the the DT 40288 332 11 mode mode NN 40288 332 12 called call VBN 40288 332 13 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 332 14 by by IN 40288 332 15 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 332 16 and and CC 40288 332 17 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 332 18 Ponticus[1 Ponticus[1 NNP 40288 332 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 332 20 . . . 40288 333 1 If if IN 40288 333 2 this this DT 40288 333 3 is be VBZ 40288 333 4 so so RB 40288 333 5 , , , 40288 333 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 333 7 follows follow VBZ 40288 333 8 almost almost RB 40288 333 9 of of IN 40288 333 10 necessity necessity NN 40288 333 11 that that IN 40288 333 12 the the DT 40288 333 13 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 333 14 of of IN 40288 333 15 Plato Plato NNP 40288 333 16 , , , 40288 333 17 called call VBN 40288 333 18 slack slack NN 40288 333 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 333 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 333 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 333 22 : : : 40288 333 23 chalara chalara NN 40288 333 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 333 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 333 26 by by IN 40288 333 27 him -PRON- PRP 40288 333 28 -- -- : 40288 333 29 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 333 30 's 's POS 40288 333 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 333 32 Greek greek JJ 40288 333 33 : : : 40288 333 34 epaneimenê epaneimenê NN 40288 333 35 Lydisti]--is Lydisti]--is NNP 40288 333 36 to to TO 40288 333 37 be be VB 40288 333 38 identified identify VBN 40288 333 39 with with IN 40288 333 40 the the DT 40288 333 41 later later JJ 40288 333 42 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 333 43 - - HYPH 40288 333 44 lydian lydian NNP 40288 333 45 . . . 40288 334 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 334 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 334 3 1 1 CD 40288 334 4 : : : 40288 334 5 An an DT 40288 334 6 objection objection NN 40288 334 7 to to IN 40288 334 8 this this DT 40288 334 9 identification identification NN 40288 334 10 has have VBZ 40288 334 11 been be VBN 40288 334 12 based base VBN 40288 334 13 on on IN 40288 334 14 the the DT 40288 334 15 words word NNS 40288 334 16 of of IN 40288 334 17 Pollux Pollux NNP 40288 334 18 , , , 40288 334 19 _ _ NNP 40288 334 20 Onom Onom NNP 40288 334 21 . . . 40288 334 22 _ _ NNP 40288 334 23 iv iv NNP 40288 334 24 . . . 40288 335 1 78 78 CD 40288 335 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 335 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 335 4 : : : 40288 335 5 kai kai NNP 40288 335 6 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 335 7 men man NNS 40288 335 8 aulêtikê aulêtikê VBP 40288 335 9 Dôristi Dôristi NNP 40288 335 10 , , , 40288 335 11 Phrygisti Phrygisti NNP 40288 335 12 , , , 40288 335 13 Lydios Lydios NNPS 40288 335 14 kai kai NNP 40288 335 15 Iônikê Iônikê NNP 40288 335 16 , , , 40288 335 17 kai kai NNP 40288 335 18 syntonos syntonos JJ 40288 335 19 Lydisti Lydisti NNP 40288 335 20 ên ên DT 40288 335 21 Anthippos Anthippos NNP 40288 335 22 exeure exeure NN 40288 335 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 335 24 . . . 40288 336 1 The the DT 40288 336 2 source source NN 40288 336 3 of of IN 40288 336 4 this this DT 40288 336 5 statement statement NN 40288 336 6 , , , 40288 336 7 or or CC 40288 336 8 at at IN 40288 336 9 least least JJS 40288 336 10 of of IN 40288 336 11 the the DT 40288 336 12 latter latter JJ 40288 336 13 part part NN 40288 336 14 of of IN 40288 336 15 it -PRON- PRP 40288 336 16 , , , 40288 336 17 is be VBZ 40288 336 18 evidently evidently RB 40288 336 19 the the DT 40288 336 20 same same JJ 40288 336 21 as as IN 40288 336 22 that that DT 40288 336 23 of of IN 40288 336 24 the the DT 40288 336 25 notice notice NN 40288 336 26 in in IN 40288 336 27 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 336 28 . . . 40288 337 1 The the DT 40288 337 2 agreement agreement NN 40288 337 3 with with IN 40288 337 4 Plato Plato NNP 40288 337 5 's 's POS 40288 337 6 list list NN 40288 337 7 makes make VBZ 40288 337 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 337 9 probable probable JJ 40288 337 10 that that IN 40288 337 11 this this DT 40288 337 12 source source NN 40288 337 13 was be VBD 40288 337 14 some some DT 40288 337 15 comment comment NN 40288 337 16 on on IN 40288 337 17 the the DT 40288 337 18 passage passage NN 40288 337 19 in in IN 40288 337 20 the the DT 40288 337 21 _ _ NNP 40288 337 22 Republic Republic NNP 40288 337 23 _ _ NNP 40288 337 24 . . . 40288 338 1 If if IN 40288 338 2 so so RB 40288 338 3 , , , 40288 338 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 338 5 can can MD 40288 338 6 hardly hardly RB 40288 338 7 be be VB 40288 338 8 doubted doubt VBN 40288 338 9 that that IN 40288 338 10 Pollux Pollux NNP 40288 338 11 gives give VBZ 40288 338 12 the the DT 40288 338 13 original original JJ 40288 338 14 terms term NNS 40288 338 15 , , , 40288 338 16 the the DT 40288 338 17 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 338 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 338 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 338 20 : : : 40288 338 21 Lydisti lydisti NN 40288 338 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 338 23 and and CC 40288 338 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 338 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 338 26 : : : 40288 338 27 Syntonolydisti Syntonolydisti NNP 40288 338 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 338 29 , , , 40288 338 30 and and CC 40288 338 31 consequently consequently RB 40288 338 32 that that IN 40288 338 33 the the DT 40288 338 34 later later JJ 40288 338 35 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 338 36 is be VBZ 40288 338 37 not not RB 40288 338 38 to to TO 40288 338 39 be be VB 40288 338 40 found find VBN 40288 338 41 in in IN 40288 338 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 338 43 [ [ -LRB- 40288 338 44 Greek Greek NNP 40288 338 45 : : : 40288 338 46 Lydios Lydios NNPS 40288 338 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 338 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 338 49 which which WDT 40288 338 50 is be VBZ 40288 338 51 a a DT 40288 338 52 ' ' `` 40288 338 53 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 338 54 ' ' '' 40288 338 55 mode mode NN 40288 338 56 ) ) -RRB- 40288 338 57 , , , 40288 338 58 but but CC 40288 338 59 in in IN 40288 338 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 338 61 [ [ -LRB- 40288 338 62 Greek Greek NNP 40288 338 63 : : : 40288 338 64 syntonos syntonos JJ 40288 338 65 Lydisti Lydisti NNP 40288 338 66 ] ] -RRB- 40288 338 67 . . . 40288 339 1 There there EX 40288 339 2 is be VBZ 40288 339 3 no no DT 40288 339 4 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 339 5 in in IN 40288 339 6 supposing suppose VBG 40288 339 7 that that IN 40288 339 8 the the DT 40288 339 9 mode mode NN 40288 339 10 was be VBD 40288 339 11 called call VBN 40288 339 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 339 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 339 14 : : : 40288 339 15 syntonos syntonos JJ 40288 339 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 339 17 merely merely RB 40288 339 18 in in IN 40288 339 19 contrast contrast NN 40288 339 20 to to IN 40288 339 21 the the DT 40288 339 22 other other JJ 40288 339 23 . . . 40288 339 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 340 1 The the DT 40288 340 2 point point NN 40288 340 3 , , , 40288 340 4 however however RB 40288 340 5 , , , 40288 340 6 is be VBZ 40288 340 7 not not RB 40288 340 8 free free JJ 40288 340 9 from from IN 40288 340 10 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 340 11 : : : 40288 340 12 for for IN 40288 340 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 340 14 as as IN 40288 340 15 we -PRON- PRP 40288 340 16 have have VBP 40288 340 17 seen see VBN 40288 340 18 , , , 40288 340 19 p. p. NN 40288 340 20 18 18 CD 40288 340 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 340 22 , , , 40288 340 23 the the DT 40288 340 24 name name NN 40288 340 25 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 340 26 - - HYPH 40288 340 27 lydian lydian NNP 40288 340 28 is be VBZ 40288 340 29 not not RB 40288 340 30 in in IN 40288 340 31 the the DT 40288 340 32 list list NN 40288 340 33 of of IN 40288 340 34 keys key NNS 40288 340 35 given give VBN 40288 340 36 by by IN 40288 340 37 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 340 38 -- -- : 40288 340 39 the the DT 40288 340 40 key key NN 40288 340 41 which which WDT 40288 340 42 was be VBD 40288 340 43 ultimately ultimately RB 40288 340 44 called call VBN 40288 340 45 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 340 46 - - HYPH 40288 340 47 lydian lydian NNP 40288 340 48 being be VBG 40288 340 49 known know VBN 40288 340 50 to to IN 40288 340 51 him -PRON- PRP 40288 340 52 as as IN 40288 340 53 the the DT 40288 340 54 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 340 55 - - HYPH 40288 340 56 dorian dorian NNP 40288 340 57 . . . 40288 341 1 If if IN 40288 341 2 , , , 40288 341 3 however however RB 40288 341 4 , , , 40288 341 5 the the DT 40288 341 6 confusion confusion NN 40288 341 7 in in IN 40288 341 8 the the DT 40288 341 9 nomenclature nomenclature NN 40288 341 10 of of IN 40288 341 11 the the DT 40288 341 12 keys key NNS 40288 341 13 was be VBD 40288 341 14 as as RB 40288 341 15 great great JJ 40288 341 16 as as IN 40288 341 17 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 341 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 341 19 describes describe VBZ 40288 341 20 , , , 40288 341 21 such such PDT 40288 341 22 a a DT 40288 341 23 contradiction contradiction NN 40288 341 24 as as IN 40288 341 25 this this DT 40288 341 26 can can MD 40288 341 27 not not RB 40288 341 28 be be VB 40288 341 29 taken take VBN 40288 341 30 to to TO 40288 341 31 prove prove VB 40288 341 32 much[1 much[1 NNS 40288 341 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 341 34 . . . 40288 342 1 The the DT 40288 342 2 statement statement NN 40288 342 3 that that IN 40288 342 4 the the DT 40288 342 5 ' ' `` 40288 342 6 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 342 7 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 342 8 ' ' '' 40288 342 9 was be VBD 40288 342 10 the the DT 40288 342 11 opposite opposite NN 40288 342 12 of of IN 40288 342 13 the the DT 40288 342 14 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 342 15 - - HYPH 40288 342 16 lydian lydian NNP 40288 342 17 , , , 40288 342 18 and and CC 40288 342 19 similar similar JJ 40288 342 20 to to IN 40288 342 21 the the DT 40288 342 22 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 342 23 , , , 40288 342 24 has have VBZ 40288 342 25 given give VBN 40288 342 26 rise rise NN 40288 342 27 to to IN 40288 342 28 much much JJ 40288 342 29 speculation speculation NN 40288 342 30 . . . 40288 343 1 In in IN 40288 343 2 what what WDT 40288 343 3 sense sense NN 40288 343 4 , , , 40288 343 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 343 6 naturally naturally RB 40288 343 7 ask ask VBP 40288 343 8 , , , 40288 343 9 can can MD 40288 343 10 a a DT 40288 343 11 key key NN 40288 343 12 or or CC 40288 343 13 a a DT 40288 343 14 mode mode NN 40288 343 15 be be VB 40288 343 16 said say VBN 40288 343 17 to to TO 40288 343 18 be be VB 40288 343 19 ' ' `` 40288 343 20 opposite opposite JJ 40288 343 21 ' ' '' 40288 343 22 or or CC 40288 343 23 ' ' `` 40288 343 24 similar similar JJ 40288 343 25 ' ' '' 40288 343 26 to to IN 40288 343 27 another another DT 40288 343 28 ? ? . 40288 344 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 344 2 venture venture VBP 40288 344 3 to to TO 40288 344 4 think think VB 40288 344 5 that that IN 40288 344 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 344 7 is be VBZ 40288 344 8 evidently evidently RB 40288 344 9 a a DT 40288 344 10 mere mere JJ 40288 344 11 paraphrase paraphrase NN 40288 344 12 of of IN 40288 344 13 Plato Plato NNP 40288 344 14 's 's POS 40288 344 15 language language NN 40288 344 16 . . . 40288 345 1 The the DT 40288 345 2 relaxed relaxed JJ 40288 345 3 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 345 4 is be VBZ 40288 345 5 opposed oppose VBN 40288 345 6 to to IN 40288 345 7 the the DT 40288 345 8 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 345 9 - - HYPH 40288 345 10 lydian lydian NNP 40288 345 11 because because IN 40288 345 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 345 13 is be VBZ 40288 345 14 at at IN 40288 345 15 the the DT 40288 345 16 other other JJ 40288 345 17 end end NN 40288 345 18 of of IN 40288 345 19 the the DT 40288 345 20 scale scale NN 40288 345 21 in in IN 40288 345 22 pitch pitch NN 40288 345 23 ; ; : 40288 345 24 and and CC 40288 345 25 it -PRON- PRP 40288 345 26 is be VBZ 40288 345 27 similar similar JJ 40288 345 28 to to IN 40288 345 29 the the DT 40288 345 30 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 345 31 because because IN 40288 345 32 the the DT 40288 345 33 two two CD 40288 345 34 are be VBP 40288 345 35 classed class VBN 40288 345 36 together together RB 40288 345 37 ( ( -LRB- 40288 345 38 as as IN 40288 345 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 345 40 Greek Greek NNP 40288 345 41 : : : 40288 345 42 chalarai chalarai NN 40288 345 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 345 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 345 45 by by IN 40288 345 46 Plato Plato NNP 40288 345 47 . . . 40288 346 1 The the DT 40288 346 2 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 346 3 - - HYPH 40288 346 4 lydian lydian NNP 40288 346 5 , , , 40288 346 6 according accord VBG 40288 346 7 to to IN 40288 346 8 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 346 9 , , , 40288 346 10 was be VBD 40288 346 11 employed employ VBN 40288 346 12 by by IN 40288 346 13 the the DT 40288 346 14 tragic tragic JJ 40288 346 15 poets poet NNS 40288 346 16 in in IN 40288 346 17 close close JJ 40288 346 18 union union NN 40288 346 19 with with IN 40288 346 20 the the DT 40288 346 21 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 346 22 mode mode NN 40288 346 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 346 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 346 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 346 26 : : : 40288 346 27 labontas labonta NNS 40288 346 28 syzeuxai syzeuxai VBD 40288 346 29 tê tê NNP 40288 346 30 Dôristi Dôristi NNP 40288 346 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 346 32 ) ) -RRB- 40288 346 33 . . . 40288 347 1 The the DT 40288 347 2 fact fact NN 40288 347 3 that that IN 40288 347 4 the the DT 40288 347 5 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 347 6 - - HYPH 40288 347 7 lydian lydian NNP 40288 347 8 was be VBD 40288 347 9 just just RB 40288 347 10 a a DT 40288 347 11 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 347 12 higher high JJR 40288 347 13 than than IN 40288 347 14 the the DT 40288 347 15 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 347 16 must must MD 40288 347 17 have have VB 40288 347 18 made make VBN 40288 347 19 the the DT 40288 347 20 transition transition NN 40288 347 21 from from IN 40288 347 22 the the DT 40288 347 23 one one NN 40288 347 24 to to IN 40288 347 25 the the DT 40288 347 26 other other JJ 40288 347 27 a a DT 40288 347 28 natural natural JJ 40288 347 29 and and CC 40288 347 30 melodious melodious JJ 40288 347 31 one one CD 40288 347 32 . . . 40288 348 1 As as IN 40288 348 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 348 3 suggested suggest VBD 40288 348 4 , , , 40288 348 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 348 6 would would MD 40288 348 7 be be VB 40288 348 8 especially especially RB 40288 348 9 used use VBN 40288 348 10 to to TO 40288 348 11 mark mark VB 40288 348 12 the the DT 40288 348 13 passage passage NN 40288 348 14 from from IN 40288 348 15 grandeur grandeur NN 40288 348 16 and and CC 40288 348 17 dignity dignity NN 40288 348 18 to to TO 40288 348 19 pathos pathos VB 40288 348 20 which which WDT 40288 348 21 is be VBZ 40288 348 22 the the DT 40288 348 23 chief chief JJ 40288 348 24 characteristic characteristic NN 40288 348 25 of of IN 40288 348 26 tragedy tragedy NN 40288 348 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 348 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 348 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 348 30 : : : 40288 348 31 hê hê VB 40288 348 32 men man NNS 40288 348 33 to to IN 40288 348 34 megaloprepes megaloprepe NNS 40288 348 35 kai kai NNP 40288 348 36 axiômatikon axiômatikon NNP 40288 348 37 apodidôsin apodidôsin NNP 40288 348 38 , , , 40288 348 39 hê hê NNP 40288 348 40 de de NNP 40288 348 41 to to IN 40288 348 42 pathêtikon pathêtikon NNP 40288 348 43 , , , 40288 348 44 memiktai memiktai NNP 40288 348 45 de de NNP 40288 348 46 dia dia NNP 40288 348 47 toutôn toutôn NNP 40288 348 48 tragôdia tragôdia NNP 40288 348 49 ] ] -RRB- 40288 348 50 ) ) -RRB- 40288 348 51 . . . 40288 349 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 349 2 is be VBZ 40288 349 3 worth worth JJ 40288 349 4 noticing notice VBG 40288 349 5 that that IN 40288 349 6 this this DT 40288 349 7 relation relation NN 40288 349 8 obtained obtain VBN 40288 349 9 in in IN 40288 349 10 the the DT 40288 349 11 scheme scheme NN 40288 349 12 of of IN 40288 349 13 the the DT 40288 349 14 musicians musician NNS 40288 349 15 who who WP 40288 349 16 did do VBD 40288 349 17 not not RB 40288 349 18 arrange arrange VB 40288 349 19 the the DT 40288 349 20 keys key NNS 40288 349 21 according accord VBG 40288 349 22 to to IN 40288 349 23 the the DT 40288 349 24 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 349 25 scale scale NN 40288 349 26 , , , 40288 349 27 but but CC 40288 349 28 in in IN 40288 349 29 some some DT 40288 349 30 way way NN 40288 349 31 suggested suggest VBN 40288 349 32 by by IN 40288 349 33 the the DT 40288 349 34 form form NN 40288 349 35 of of IN 40288 349 36 the the DT 40288 349 37 flute flute NN 40288 349 38 ( ( -LRB- 40288 349 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 349 40 Greek Greek NNP 40288 349 41 : : : 40288 349 42 hoi hoi NNP 40288 349 43 pros pros NNP 40288 349 44 tên tên NNP 40288 349 45 tôn tôn NNP 40288 349 46 aulôn aulôn NNP 40288 349 47 trypêsin trypêsin NNP 40288 349 48 blepontes blepontes NNP 40288 349 49 ] ] -RRB- 40288 349 50 ) ) -RRB- 40288 349 51 . . . 40288 350 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 350 2 may may MD 40288 350 3 therefore therefore RB 40288 350 4 be be VB 40288 350 5 supposed suppose VBN 40288 350 6 to to TO 40288 350 7 have have VB 40288 350 8 been be VBN 40288 350 9 established establish VBN 40288 350 10 before before IN 40288 350 11 the the DT 40288 350 12 relative relative JJ 40288 350 13 pitch pitch NN 40288 350 14 of of IN 40288 350 15 other other JJ 40288 350 16 keys key NNS 40288 350 17 had have VBD 40288 350 18 been be VBN 40288 350 19 settled settle VBN 40288 350 20 . . . 40288 351 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 351 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 351 3 1 1 CD 40288 351 4 : : : 40288 351 5 It -PRON- PRP 40288 351 6 seems seem VBZ 40288 351 7 not not RB 40288 351 8 impossible impossible JJ 40288 351 9 that that IN 40288 351 10 this this DT 40288 351 11 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 351 12 with with IN 40288 351 13 regard regard NN 40288 351 14 to to IN 40288 351 15 the the DT 40288 351 16 ' ' `` 40288 351 17 slack slack NN 40288 351 18 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 351 19 ' ' '' 40288 351 20 and and CC 40288 351 21 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 351 22 - - HYPH 40288 351 23 lydian lydian NNP 40288 351 24 may may MD 40288 351 25 be be VB 40288 351 26 connected connect VBN 40288 351 27 with with IN 40288 351 28 the the DT 40288 351 29 contradiction contradiction NN 40288 351 30 in in IN 40288 351 31 the the DT 40288 351 32 statement statement NN 40288 351 33 of of IN 40288 351 34 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 351 35 about about IN 40288 351 36 the the DT 40288 351 37 schemes scheme NNS 40288 351 38 of of IN 40288 351 39 keys key NNS 40288 351 40 in in IN 40288 351 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 351 42 time time NN 40288 351 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 351 44 p. p. NN 40288 351 45 18 18 CD 40288 351 46 ) ) -RRB- 40288 351 47 . . . 40288 352 1 According accord VBG 40288 352 2 to to IN 40288 352 3 that that DT 40288 352 4 account account NN 40288 352 5 , , , 40288 352 6 if if IN 40288 352 7 the the DT 40288 352 8 text text NN 40288 352 9 is be VBZ 40288 352 10 sound sound JJ 40288 352 11 , , , 40288 352 12 some some DT 40288 352 13 musicians musician NNS 40288 352 14 placed place VBD 40288 352 15 the the DT 40288 352 16 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 352 17 - - HYPH 40288 352 18 lydian lydian NNP 40288 352 19 a a DT 40288 352 20 semitone semitone NN 40288 352 21 below below IN 40288 352 22 the the DT 40288 352 23 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 352 24 -- -- : 40288 352 25 the the DT 40288 352 26 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 352 27 - - HYPH 40288 352 28 dorian dorian NNP 40288 352 29 being be VBG 40288 352 30 again again RB 40288 352 31 a a DT 40288 352 32 semitone semitone NN 40288 352 33 lower lower RBR 40288 352 34 . . . 40288 353 1 In in IN 40288 353 2 this this DT 40288 353 3 scheme scheme NN 40288 353 4 , , , 40288 353 5 then then RB 40288 353 6 , , , 40288 353 7 the the DT 40288 353 8 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 353 9 - - HYPH 40288 353 10 lydian lydian NNP 40288 353 11 held hold VBD 40288 353 12 the the DT 40288 353 13 place place NN 40288 353 14 of of IN 40288 353 15 the the DT 40288 353 16 later later JJ 40288 353 17 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 353 18 - - HYPH 40288 353 19 lydian lydian NNP 40288 353 20 . . . 40288 354 1 The the DT 40288 354 2 conjecture conjecture NN 40288 354 3 may may MD 40288 354 4 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 354 5 be be VB 40288 354 6 hazarded hazard VBN 40288 354 7 , , , 40288 354 8 that that IN 40288 354 9 this this DT 40288 354 10 lower low JJR 40288 354 11 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 354 12 - - HYPH 40288 354 13 lydian lydian NNP 40288 354 14 somehow somehow RB 40288 354 15 represents represent VBZ 40288 354 16 Plato Plato NNP 40288 354 17 's 's POS 40288 354 18 ' ' `` 40288 354 19 slack slack NN 40288 354 20 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 354 21 , , , 40288 354 22 ' ' '' 40288 354 23 and and CC 40288 354 24 eventually eventually RB 40288 354 25 passed pass VBD 40288 354 26 into into IN 40288 354 27 the the DT 40288 354 28 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 354 29 - - HYPH 40288 354 30 lydian lydian NNP 40288 354 31 . . . 40288 354 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 355 1 So so RB 40288 355 2 far far RB 40288 355 3 the the DT 40288 355 4 passage passage NN 40288 355 5 of of IN 40288 355 6 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 355 7 goes go VBZ 40288 355 8 to to TO 40288 355 9 confirm confirm VB 40288 355 10 the the DT 40288 355 11 view view NN 40288 355 12 of of IN 40288 355 13 the the DT 40288 355 14 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 355 15 modes mode NNS 40288 355 16 according accord VBG 40288 355 17 to to IN 40288 355 18 which which WDT 40288 355 19 they -PRON- PRP 40288 355 20 were be VBD 40288 355 21 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 355 22 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 355 23 , , , 40288 355 24 if if IN 40288 355 25 not not RB 40288 355 26 wholly wholly RB 40288 355 27 , , , 40288 355 28 by by IN 40288 355 29 difference difference NN 40288 355 30 of of IN 40288 355 31 pitch pitch NN 40288 355 32 . . . 40288 356 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 356 2 come come VBP 40288 356 3 now now RB 40288 356 4 , , , 40288 356 5 however however RB 40288 356 6 , , , 40288 356 7 to to IN 40288 356 8 a a DT 40288 356 9 statement statement NN 40288 356 10 which which WDT 40288 356 11 apparently apparently RB 40288 356 12 tends tend VBZ 40288 356 13 in in IN 40288 356 14 the the DT 40288 356 15 opposite opposite JJ 40288 356 16 direction direction NN 40288 356 17 , , , 40288 356 18 viz viz NN 40288 356 19 . . . 40288 357 1 that that IN 40288 357 2 a a DT 40288 357 3 certain certain JJ 40288 357 4 Lamprocles Lamprocles NNPS 40288 357 5 of of IN 40288 357 6 Athens Athens NNP 40288 357 7 noticed notice VBD 40288 357 8 that that IN 40288 357 9 in in IN 40288 357 10 the the DT 40288 357 11 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 357 12 - - HYPH 40288 357 13 lydian lydian JJ 40288 357 14 mode mode NN 40288 357 15 the the DT 40288 357 16 Disjunctive Disjunctive NNP 40288 357 17 Tone Tone NNP 40288 357 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 357 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 357 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 357 21 : : : 40288 357 22 diazeuxis diazeuxis NNP 40288 357 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 357 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 357 25 was be VBD 40288 357 26 at at IN 40288 357 27 the the DT 40288 357 28 upper upper JJ 40288 357 29 end end NN 40288 357 30 of of IN 40288 357 31 the the DT 40288 357 32 scale scale NN 40288 357 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 357 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 357 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 357 36 : : : 40288 357 37 epi epi JJ 40288 357 38 to to IN 40288 357 39 oxy oxy NN 40288 357 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 357 41 ) ) -RRB- 40288 357 42 , , , 40288 357 43 and and CC 40288 357 44 reformed reform VBD 40288 357 45 the the DT 40288 357 46 scale scale NN 40288 357 47 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 357 48 . . . 40288 358 1 This this DT 40288 358 2 must must MD 40288 358 3 refer refer VB 40288 358 4 to to IN 40288 358 5 an an DT 40288 358 6 octave octave JJ 40288 358 7 scale scale NN 40288 358 8 of of IN 40288 358 9 the the DT 40288 358 10 form form NN 40288 358 11 _ _ NNP 40288 358 12 b b NNP 40288 358 13 c c NNP 40288 358 14 d d NNP 40288 358 15 e e NNP 40288 358 16 f f NNP 40288 358 17 g g NNP 40288 358 18 a a DT 40288 358 19 b b NN 40288 358 20 _ _ NN 40288 358 21 , , , 40288 358 22 consisting consist VBG 40288 358 23 of of IN 40288 358 24 the the DT 40288 358 25 two two CD 40288 358 26 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 358 27 _ _ NNP 40288 358 28 b b NNP 40288 358 29 - - HYPH 40288 358 30 e e NNP 40288 358 31 _ _ NNP 40288 358 32 and and CC 40288 358 33 _ _ NNP 40288 358 34 e e NNP 40288 358 35 - - : 40288 358 36 a a DT 40288 358 37 _ _ NNP 40288 358 38 , , , 40288 358 39 and and CC 40288 358 40 the the DT 40288 358 41 tone tone NN 40288 358 42 _ _ NNP 40288 358 43 a a DT 40288 358 44 - - HYPH 40288 358 45 b b NNP 40288 358 46 _ _ NNP 40288 358 47 . . . 40288 359 1 Such such PDT 40288 359 2 an an DT 40288 359 3 octave octave NN 40288 359 4 may may MD 40288 359 5 or or CC 40288 359 6 may may MD 40288 359 7 not not RB 40288 359 8 be be VB 40288 359 9 in in IN 40288 359 10 the the DT 40288 359 11 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 359 12 - - HYPH 40288 359 13 lydian lydian JJ 40288 359 14 key key NN 40288 359 15 : : : 40288 359 16 it -PRON- PRP 40288 359 17 is be VBZ 40288 359 18 certainly certainly RB 40288 359 19 of of IN 40288 359 20 the the DT 40288 359 21 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 359 22 - - HYPH 40288 359 23 lydian lydian JJ 40288 359 24 species specie NNS 40288 359 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 359 26 p. p. NN 40288 359 27 57 57 CD 40288 359 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 359 29 . . . 40288 360 1 In in IN 40288 360 2 estimating estimate VBG 40288 360 3 the the DT 40288 360 4 value value NN 40288 360 5 of of IN 40288 360 6 this this DT 40288 360 7 piece piece NN 40288 360 8 of of IN 40288 360 9 evidence evidence NN 40288 360 10 it -PRON- PRP 40288 360 11 is be VBZ 40288 360 12 necessary necessary JJ 40288 360 13 to to TO 40288 360 14 remark remark VB 40288 360 15 , , , 40288 360 16 in in IN 40288 360 17 the the DT 40288 360 18 first first JJ 40288 360 19 place place NN 40288 360 20 , , , 40288 360 21 that that IN 40288 360 22 the the DT 40288 360 23 authority authority NN 40288 360 24 is be VBZ 40288 360 25 no no RB 40288 360 26 longer long RBR 40288 360 27 that that DT 40288 360 28 of of IN 40288 360 29 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 360 30 , , , 40288 360 31 but but CC 40288 360 32 of of IN 40288 360 33 a a DT 40288 360 34 certain certain JJ 40288 360 35 Lysis lysis NN 40288 360 36 , , , 40288 360 37 of of IN 40288 360 38 whom whom WP 40288 360 39 nothing nothing NN 40288 360 40 else else RB 40288 360 41 seems seem VBZ 40288 360 42 to to TO 40288 360 43 be be VB 40288 360 44 known know VBN 40288 360 45 . . . 40288 361 1 That that IN 40288 361 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 361 3 was be VBD 40288 361 4 later later RB 40288 361 5 than than IN 40288 361 6 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 361 7 is be VBZ 40288 361 8 made make VBN 40288 361 9 probable probable JJ 40288 361 10 by by IN 40288 361 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 361 12 way way NN 40288 361 13 of of IN 40288 361 14 describing describe VBG 40288 361 15 the the DT 40288 361 16 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 361 17 - - HYPH 40288 361 18 lydian lydian JJ 40288 361 19 octave octave NN 40288 361 20 , , , 40288 361 21 viz viz NN 40288 361 22 . . . 40288 362 1 by by IN 40288 362 2 reference reference NN 40288 362 3 to to IN 40288 362 4 the the DT 40288 362 5 notes note NNS 40288 362 6 in in IN 40288 362 7 the the DT 40288 362 8 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 362 9 System System NNP 40288 362 10 by by IN 40288 362 11 which which WDT 40288 362 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 362 13 is be VBZ 40288 362 14 exemplified exemplify VBN 40288 362 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 362 16 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 362 17 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 362 18 to to IN 40288 362 19 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 362 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 362 21 . . . 40288 363 1 In in IN 40288 363 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 363 3 , , , 40288 363 4 as as IN 40288 363 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 363 6 shall shall MD 40288 363 7 see see VB 40288 363 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 363 9 p. p. NN 40288 363 10 31 31 CD 40288 363 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 363 12 , , , 40288 363 13 the the DT 40288 363 14 primitive primitive JJ 40288 363 15 octave octave NN 40288 363 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 363 17 from from IN 40288 363 18 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 363 19 to to IN 40288 363 20 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 363 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 363 22 is be VBZ 40288 363 23 the the DT 40288 363 24 only only JJ 40288 363 25 scale scale NN 40288 363 26 the the DT 40288 363 27 notes note NNS 40288 363 28 of of IN 40288 363 29 which which WDT 40288 363 30 are be VBP 40288 363 31 mentioned mention VBN 40288 363 32 by by IN 40288 363 33 name name NN 40288 363 34 . . . 40288 364 1 But but CC 40288 364 2 even even RB 40288 364 3 if if IN 40288 364 4 the the DT 40288 364 5 notice notice NN 40288 364 6 is be VBZ 40288 364 7 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 364 8 early early JJ 40288 364 9 , , , 40288 364 10 it -PRON- PRP 40288 364 11 is be VBZ 40288 364 12 worth worth JJ 40288 364 13 observing observe VBG 40288 364 14 that that IN 40288 364 15 the the DT 40288 364 16 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 364 17 - - HYPH 40288 364 18 lydian lydian JJ 40288 364 19 scale scale NN 40288 364 20 thus thus RB 40288 364 21 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 364 22 to to IN 40288 364 23 Lamprocles Lamprocles NNP 40288 364 24 consists consist VBZ 40288 364 25 of of IN 40288 364 26 two two CD 40288 364 27 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 364 28 of of IN 40288 364 29 the the DT 40288 364 30 normal normal JJ 40288 364 31 type type NN 40288 364 32 , , , 40288 364 33 viz viz NN 40288 364 34 . . . 40288 365 1 with with IN 40288 365 2 the the DT 40288 365 3 semitone semitone NN 40288 365 4 or or CC 40288 365 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 365 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 365 7 : : : 40288 365 8 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 365 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 365 10 at at IN 40288 365 11 the the DT 40288 365 12 lower low JJR 40288 365 13 end end NN 40288 365 14 of of IN 40288 365 15 the the DT 40288 365 16 scale scale NN 40288 365 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 365 18 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 365 19 _ _ NNP 40288 365 20 e e NNP 40288 365 21 f f NNP 40288 365 22 g g NNP 40288 365 23 a a DT 40288 365 24 _ _ NNP 40288 365 25 , , , 40288 365 26 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 365 27 _ _ NNP 40288 365 28 e e NNP 40288 365 29 e e NNP 40288 365 30 * * NNP 40288 365 31 f f NNP 40288 365 32 a a DT 40288 365 33 _ _ NNP 40288 365 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 365 35 . . . 40288 366 1 The the DT 40288 366 2 difference difference NN 40288 366 3 is be VBZ 40288 366 4 that that IN 40288 366 5 they -PRON- PRP 40288 366 6 are be VBP 40288 366 7 conjunct conjunct JJ 40288 366 8 , , , 40288 366 9 whereas whereas IN 40288 366 10 in in IN 40288 366 11 the the DT 40288 366 12 primitive primitive JJ 40288 366 13 standard standard JJ 40288 366 14 octave octave NN 40288 366 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 366 16 _ _ NNP 40288 366 17 e e NNP 40288 366 18 - - HYPH 40288 366 19 e e NNP 40288 366 20 _ _ NNP 40288 366 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 366 22 the the DT 40288 366 23 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 366 24 are be VBP 40288 366 25 disjunct disjunct JJ 40288 366 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 366 27 _ _ NNP 40288 366 28 e e NNP 40288 366 29 - - : 40288 366 30 a a DT 40288 366 31 b b NN 40288 366 32 - - HYPH 40288 366 33 e e NNP 40288 366 34 _ _ NNP 40288 366 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 366 36 . . . 40288 367 1 This this DT 40288 367 2 , , , 40288 367 3 however however RB 40288 367 4 , , , 40288 367 5 is be VBZ 40288 367 6 a a DT 40288 367 7 variety variety NN 40288 367 8 which which WDT 40288 367 9 is be VBZ 40288 367 10 provided provide VBN 40288 367 11 for for IN 40288 367 12 by by IN 40288 367 13 the the DT 40288 367 14 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 367 15 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 367 16 in in IN 40288 367 17 the the DT 40288 367 18 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 367 19 System System NNP 40288 367 20 , , , 40288 367 21 and and CC 40288 367 22 which which WDT 40288 367 23 may may MD 40288 367 24 have have VB 40288 367 25 been be VBN 40288 367 26 allowed allow VBN 40288 367 27 in in IN 40288 367 28 the the DT 40288 367 29 less less RBR 40288 367 30 complete complete JJ 40288 367 31 scales scale NNS 40288 367 32 of of IN 40288 367 33 earlier early JJR 40288 367 34 times time NNS 40288 367 35 . . . 40288 368 1 In in IN 40288 368 2 any any DT 40288 368 3 case case NN 40288 368 4 the the DT 40288 368 5 existence existence NN 40288 368 6 of of IN 40288 368 7 a a DT 40288 368 8 scale scale NN 40288 368 9 of of IN 40288 368 10 this this DT 40288 368 11 particular particular JJ 40288 368 12 form form NN 40288 368 13 does do VBZ 40288 368 14 not not RB 40288 368 15 prove prove VB 40288 368 16 that that IN 40288 368 17 the the DT 40288 368 18 octaves octave NNS 40288 368 19 of of IN 40288 368 20 other other JJ 40288 368 21 species specie NNS 40288 368 22 were be VBD 40288 368 23 recognised recognise VBN 40288 368 24 in in IN 40288 368 25 the the DT 40288 368 26 same same JJ 40288 368 27 way way NN 40288 368 28 . . . 40288 369 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 369 2 2 2 LS 40288 369 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 369 4 In in IN 40288 369 5 another another DT 40288 369 6 passage passage NN 40288 369 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 369 8 c. c. NN 40288 369 9 6 6 CD 40288 369 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 369 11 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 369 12 says say VBZ 40288 369 13 of of IN 40288 369 14 the the DT 40288 369 15 ancient ancient JJ 40288 369 16 music music NN 40288 369 17 of of IN 40288 369 18 the the DT 40288 369 19 cithara cithara NN 40288 369 20 that that IN 40288 369 21 it -PRON- PRP 40288 369 22 was be VBD 40288 369 23 characterised characterise VBN 40288 369 24 by by IN 40288 369 25 perfect perfect JJ 40288 369 26 simplicity simplicity NN 40288 369 27 . . . 40288 370 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 370 2 was be VBD 40288 370 3 not not RB 40288 370 4 allowed allow VBN 40288 370 5 , , , 40288 370 6 he -PRON- PRP 40288 370 7 tells tell VBZ 40288 370 8 us -PRON- PRP 40288 370 9 , , , 40288 370 10 to to TO 40288 370 11 change change VB 40288 370 12 the the DT 40288 370 13 mode mode NN 40288 370 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 370 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 370 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 370 17 : : : 40288 370 18 metapherein metapherein NNP 40288 370 19 tas tas NNP 40288 370 20 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 370 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 370 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 370 23 or or CC 40288 370 24 the the DT 40288 370 25 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 370 26 : : : 40288 370 27 for for IN 40288 370 28 in in IN 40288 370 29 the the DT 40288 370 30 primitive primitive JJ 40288 370 31 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 370 32 compositions composition NNS 40288 370 33 called call VBN 40288 370 34 ' ' `` 40288 370 35 Nomes nome NNS 40288 370 36 ' ' '' 40288 370 37 ( ( -LRB- 40288 370 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 370 39 Greek Greek NNP 40288 370 40 : : : 40288 370 41 nomoi nomoi NNP 40288 370 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 370 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 370 44 they -PRON- PRP 40288 370 45 preserved preserve VBD 40288 370 46 in in IN 40288 370 47 each each DT 40288 370 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 370 49 proper proper JJ 40288 370 50 pitch pitch NN 40288 370 51 ( ( -LRB- 40288 370 52 [ [ -LRB- 40288 370 53 Greek Greek NNP 40288 370 54 : : : 40288 370 55 tên tên NNP 40288 370 56 oikeian oikeian NNP 40288 370 57 tasin tasin NNP 40288 370 58 ] ] -RRB- 40288 370 59 ) ) -RRB- 40288 370 60 . . . 40288 371 1 Here here RB 40288 371 2 the the DT 40288 371 3 word word NN 40288 371 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 371 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 371 6 : : : 40288 371 7 tasis tasis NN 40288 371 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 371 9 indicates indicate VBZ 40288 371 10 that that IN 40288 371 11 by by IN 40288 371 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 371 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 371 14 : : : 40288 371 15 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 371 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 371 17 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 371 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 371 19 or or CC 40288 371 20 the the DT 40288 371 21 older old JJR 40288 371 22 author author NN 40288 371 23 from from IN 40288 371 24 whom whom WP 40288 371 25 he -PRON- PRP 40288 371 26 was be VBD 40288 371 27 quoting quote VBG 40288 371 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 371 29 meant mean VBN 40288 371 30 particular particular JJ 40288 371 31 _ _ NNP 40288 371 32 keys key NNS 40288 371 33 _ _ NNP 40288 371 34 . . . 40288 372 1 This this DT 40288 372 2 is be VBZ 40288 372 3 fully fully RB 40288 372 4 confirmed confirm VBN 40288 372 5 by by IN 40288 372 6 the the DT 40288 372 7 use use NN 40288 372 8 of of IN 40288 372 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 372 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 372 11 : : : 40288 372 12 tonos tonos NN 40288 372 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 372 14 in in IN 40288 372 15 a a DT 40288 372 16 passage passage NN 40288 372 17 a a DT 40288 372 18 little little JJ 40288 372 19 further far RBR 40288 372 20 on on IN 40288 372 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 372 22 c. c. NNP 40288 372 23 8) 8) CD 40288 372 24 , , , 40288 372 25 where where WRB 40288 372 26 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 372 27 gives give VBZ 40288 372 28 an an DT 40288 372 29 account account NN 40288 372 30 of of IN 40288 372 31 an an DT 40288 372 32 innovation innovation NN 40288 372 33 in in IN 40288 372 34 this this DT 40288 372 35 matter matter NN 40288 372 36 made make VBN 40288 372 37 by by IN 40288 372 38 Sacadas Sacadas NNP 40288 372 39 of of IN 40288 372 40 Argos Argos NNP 40288 372 41 ( ( -LRB- 40288 372 42 fl fl NN 40288 372 43 . . . 40288 373 1 590 590 CD 40288 373 2 B.C. B.C. NNP 40288 373 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 373 4 . . . 40288 374 1 ' ' `` 40288 374 2 There there EX 40288 374 3 being be VBG 40288 374 4 three three CD 40288 374 5 keys key NNS 40288 374 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 374 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 374 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 374 9 : : : 40288 374 10 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 374 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 374 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 374 13 in in IN 40288 374 14 the the DT 40288 374 15 time time NN 40288 374 16 of of IN 40288 374 17 Polymnastus Polymnastus NNP 40288 374 18 and and CC 40288 374 19 Sacadas Sacadas NNP 40288 374 20 , , , 40288 374 21 viz viz NN 40288 374 22 . . . 40288 375 1 the the DT 40288 375 2 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 375 3 , , , 40288 375 4 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 375 5 and and CC 40288 375 6 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 375 7 , , , 40288 375 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 375 9 is be VBZ 40288 375 10 said say VBN 40288 375 11 that that IN 40288 375 12 Sacadas Sacadas NNP 40288 375 13 composed compose VBD 40288 375 14 a a DT 40288 375 15 strophe strophe NN 40288 375 16 in in IN 40288 375 17 each each DT 40288 375 18 of of IN 40288 375 19 these these DT 40288 375 20 keys key NNS 40288 375 21 , , , 40288 375 22 and and CC 40288 375 23 taught teach VBD 40288 375 24 the the DT 40288 375 25 chorus chorus NN 40288 375 26 to to TO 40288 375 27 sing sing VB 40288 375 28 them -PRON- PRP 40288 375 29 , , , 40288 375 30 the the DT 40288 375 31 first first JJ 40288 375 32 in in IN 40288 375 33 the the DT 40288 375 34 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 375 35 , , , 40288 375 36 the the DT 40288 375 37 second second JJ 40288 375 38 in in IN 40288 375 39 the the DT 40288 375 40 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 375 41 , , , 40288 375 42 and and CC 40288 375 43 the the DT 40288 375 44 third third JJ 40288 375 45 in in IN 40288 375 46 the the DT 40288 375 47 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 375 48 key key NN 40288 375 49 : : : 40288 375 50 and and CC 40288 375 51 this this DT 40288 375 52 composition composition NN 40288 375 53 was be VBD 40288 375 54 called call VBN 40288 375 55 the the DT 40288 375 56 " " `` 40288 375 57 three three CD 40288 375 58 - - HYPH 40288 375 59 part part NN 40288 375 60 Nome Nome NNP 40288 375 61 " " '' 40288 375 62 ( ( -LRB- 40288 375 63 [ [ -LRB- 40288 375 64 Greek Greek NNP 40288 375 65 : : : 40288 375 66 nomos nomos NNP 40288 375 67 trimerês trimerês NNP 40288 375 68 ] ] -RRB- 40288 375 69 ) ) -RRB- 40288 375 70 on on IN 40288 375 71 account account NN 40288 375 72 of of IN 40288 375 73 the the DT 40288 375 74 change change NN 40288 375 75 of of IN 40288 375 76 key key NN 40288 375 77 . . . 40288 375 78 ' ' '' 40288 376 1 In in IN 40288 376 2 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 376 3 's 's POS 40288 376 4 _ _ NNP 40288 376 5 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 376 6 und und NN 40288 376 7 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 376 8 _ _ NNP 40288 376 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 376 10 ed ed NNP 40288 376 11 . . . 40288 377 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 377 2 , , , 40288 377 3 p. p. NN 40288 377 4 76 76 CD 40288 377 5 , , , 40288 377 6 cp cp NNP 40288 377 7 . . . 40288 378 1 p. p. NN 40288 378 2 62 62 CD 40288 378 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 378 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 378 5 explains explain VBZ 40288 378 6 this this DT 40288 378 7 notice notice NN 40288 378 8 of of IN 40288 378 9 the the DT 40288 378 10 ancient ancient JJ 40288 378 11 modes mode NNS 40288 378 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 378 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 378 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 378 15 : : : 40288 378 16 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 378 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 378 18 , , , 40288 378 19 _ _ NNP 40288 378 20 Tonarten Tonarten NNP 40288 378 21 _ _ NNP 40288 378 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 378 23 , , , 40288 378 24 observing observe VBG 40288 378 25 that that IN 40288 378 26 the the DT 40288 378 27 word word NN 40288 378 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 378 29 Greek greek NN 40288 378 30 : : : 40288 378 31 tonos tonos NN 40288 378 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 378 33 is be VBZ 40288 378 34 there there EX 40288 378 35 used use VBN 40288 378 36 improperly improperly RB 40288 378 37 for for IN 40288 378 38 what what WP 40288 378 39 the the DT 40288 378 40 technical technical JJ 40288 378 41 writers writer NNS 40288 378 42 call call VBP 40288 378 43 [ [ -LRB- 40288 378 44 Greek Greek NNP 40288 378 45 : : : 40288 378 46 eidos eidos NNP 40288 378 47 tou tou NNP 40288 378 48 dia dia NNP 40288 378 49 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 378 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 378 51 . . . 40288 379 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 379 2 3 3 LS 40288 379 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 379 4 In in IN 40288 379 5 a a DT 40288 379 6 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 379 7 similar similar JJ 40288 379 8 passage passage NN 40288 379 9 of of IN 40288 379 10 the the DT 40288 379 11 same same JJ 40288 379 12 work work NN 40288 379 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 379 14 c. c. NNP 40288 379 15 19 19 CD 40288 379 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 379 17 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 379 18 is be VBZ 40288 379 19 contending contend VBG 40288 379 20 that that IN 40288 379 21 the the DT 40288 379 22 fewness fewness NN 40288 379 23 of of IN 40288 379 24 the the DT 40288 379 25 notes note NNS 40288 379 26 in in IN 40288 379 27 the the DT 40288 379 28 scales scale NNS 40288 379 29 used use VBN 40288 379 30 by by IN 40288 379 31 the the DT 40288 379 32 early early JJ 40288 379 33 musicians musician NNS 40288 379 34 did do VBD 40288 379 35 not not RB 40288 379 36 arise arise VB 40288 379 37 from from IN 40288 379 38 ignorance ignorance NN 40288 379 39 , , , 40288 379 40 but but CC 40288 379 41 was be VBD 40288 379 42 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 379 43 of of IN 40288 379 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 379 45 art art NN 40288 379 46 , , , 40288 379 47 and and CC 40288 379 48 necessary necessary JJ 40288 379 49 to to IN 40288 379 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 379 51 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 379 52 ethos ethos NN 40288 379 53 . . . 40288 380 1 Among among IN 40288 380 2 other other JJ 40288 380 3 points point NNS 40288 380 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 380 5 notices notice VBZ 40288 380 6 that that IN 40288 380 7 the the DT 40288 380 8 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 380 9 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 380 10 was be VBD 40288 380 11 not not RB 40288 380 12 used use VBN 40288 380 13 in in IN 40288 380 14 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 380 15 music music NN 40288 380 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 380 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 380 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 380 19 : : : 40288 380 20 en en IN 40288 380 21 tois tois NN 40288 380 22 Dôriois Dôriois NNP 40288 380 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 380 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 380 25 , , , 40288 380 26 and and CC 40288 380 27 this this DT 40288 380 28 , , , 40288 380 29 he -PRON- PRP 40288 380 30 says say VBZ 40288 380 31 , , , 40288 380 32 was be VBD 40288 380 33 not not RB 40288 380 34 because because IN 40288 380 35 they -PRON- PRP 40288 380 36 did do VBD 40288 380 37 not not RB 40288 380 38 know know VB 40288 380 39 of of IN 40288 380 40 that that DT 40288 380 41 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 380 42 -- -- : 40288 380 43 for for IN 40288 380 44 they -PRON- PRP 40288 380 45 used use VBD 40288 380 46 it -PRON- PRP 40288 380 47 in in IN 40288 380 48 other other JJ 40288 380 49 keys key NNS 40288 380 50 ( ( -LRB- 40288 380 51 [ [ -LRB- 40288 380 52 Greek Greek NNP 40288 380 53 : : : 40288 380 54 tonoi])--but tonoi])--but CC 40288 380 55 they -PRON- PRP 40288 380 56 left leave VBD 40288 380 57 it -PRON- PRP 40288 380 58 out out RP 40288 380 59 in in IN 40288 380 60 the the DT 40288 380 61 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 380 62 key key NN 40288 380 63 for for IN 40288 380 64 the the DT 40288 380 65 sake sake NN 40288 380 66 of of IN 40288 380 67 preserving preserve VBG 40288 380 68 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 380 69 ethos ethos NN 40288 380 70 , , , 40288 380 71 the the DT 40288 380 72 beauty beauty NN 40288 380 73 of of IN 40288 380 74 which which WDT 40288 380 75 they -PRON- PRP 40288 380 76 valued value VBD 40288 380 77 ( ( -LRB- 40288 380 78 [ [ -LRB- 40288 380 79 Greek Greek NNP 40288 380 80 : : : 40288 380 81 dia dia NNP 40288 380 82 dê dê NNP 40288 380 83 tên tên NNP 40288 380 84 tou tou NNP 40288 380 85 êthous êthous NNP 40288 380 86 phylakên phylakên NNP 40288 380 87 aphêroun aphêroun NNP 40288 380 88 tou tou NNP 40288 380 89 Dôriou Dôriou NNP 40288 380 90 tonou tonou NNP 40288 380 91 , , , 40288 380 92 timôntes timônte VBZ 40288 380 93 to to TO 40288 380 94 kalon kalon VB 40288 380 95 autou autou NNP 40288 380 96 ] ] -RRB- 40288 380 97 ) ) -RRB- 40288 380 98 . . . 40288 381 1 Here here RB 40288 381 2 again again RB 40288 381 3 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 381 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 381 5 _ _ NNP 40288 381 6 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 381 7 _ _ NNP 40288 381 8 , , , 40288 381 9 p. p. NN 40288 381 10 476 476 CD 40288 381 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 381 12 has have VBZ 40288 381 13 to to TO 40288 381 14 take take VB 40288 381 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 381 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 381 17 : : : 40288 381 18 tonos tonos NN 40288 381 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 381 20 to to TO 40288 381 21 mean mean VB 40288 381 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 381 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 381 24 : : : 40288 381 25 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 381 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 381 27 or or CC 40288 381 28 ' ' `` 40288 381 29 mode mode NN 40288 381 30 ' ' '' 40288 381 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 381 32 in in IN 40288 381 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 381 34 language language NN 40288 381 35 _ _ NNP 40288 381 36 Tonart Tonart NNP 40288 381 37 _ _ NNP 40288 381 38 , , , 40288 381 39 not not RB 40288 381 40 _ _ NNP 40288 381 41 Transpositionsscala Transpositionsscala NNP 40288 381 42 _ _ NNP 40288 381 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 381 44 . . . 40288 382 1 For for IN 40288 382 2 in in IN 40288 382 3 the the DT 40288 382 4 view view NN 40288 382 5 of of IN 40288 382 6 those those DT 40288 382 7 who who WP 40288 382 8 distinguish distinguish VBP 40288 382 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 382 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 382 11 : : : 40288 382 12 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 382 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 382 14 from from IN 40288 382 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 382 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 382 17 : : : 40288 382 18 tonos tonos LS 40288 382 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 382 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 382 21 is be VBZ 40288 382 22 the the DT 40288 382 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 382 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 382 25 : : : 40288 382 26 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 382 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 382 28 upon upon IN 40288 382 29 which which WDT 40288 382 30 the the DT 40288 382 31 ethos ethos NN 40288 382 32 of of IN 40288 382 33 music music NN 40288 382 34 depends depend VBZ 40288 382 35 . . . 40288 383 1 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 383 2 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 383 3 had have VBD 40288 383 4 just just RB 40288 383 5 been be VBN 40288 383 6 saying say VBG 40288 383 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 383 8 in in IN 40288 383 9 c. c. NNP 40288 383 10 17 17 CD 40288 383 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 383 12 that that IN 40288 383 13 Plato Plato NNP 40288 383 14 preferred prefer VBD 40288 383 15 the the DT 40288 383 16 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 383 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 383 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 383 19 : : : 40288 383 20 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 383 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 383 22 on on IN 40288 383 23 account account NN 40288 383 24 of of IN 40288 383 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 383 26 grave grave NN 40288 383 27 and and CC 40288 383 28 elevated elevated JJ 40288 383 29 character character NN 40288 383 30 ( ( -LRB- 40288 383 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 383 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 383 33 : : : 40288 383 34 epei epei NNP 40288 383 35 poly poly NNP 40288 383 36 to to TO 40288 383 37 semnon semnon NNP 40288 383 38 estin estin NNP 40288 383 39 en en NNP 40288 383 40 tê tê DT 40288 383 41 Dôristi Dôristi NNP 40288 383 42 , , , 40288 383 43 tautên tautên VB 40288 383 44 proutimêsen proutimêsen VBN 40288 383 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 383 46 ) ) -RRB- 40288 383 47 . . . 40288 384 1 On on IN 40288 384 2 the the DT 40288 384 3 other other JJ 40288 384 4 hand hand NN 40288 384 5 the the DT 40288 384 6 usual usual JJ 40288 384 7 sense sense NN 40288 384 8 of of IN 40288 384 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 384 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 384 11 : : : 40288 384 12 tonos tonos NN 40288 384 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 384 14 is be VBZ 40288 384 15 supported support VBN 40288 384 16 by by IN 40288 384 17 the the DT 40288 384 18 consideration consideration NN 40288 384 19 that that IN 40288 384 20 the the DT 40288 384 21 want want NN 40288 384 22 of of IN 40288 384 23 the the DT 40288 384 24 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 384 25 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 384 26 would would MD 40288 384 27 affect affect VB 40288 384 28 the the DT 40288 384 29 pitch pitch NN 40288 384 30 of of IN 40288 384 31 the the DT 40288 384 32 scale scale NN 40288 384 33 rather rather RB 40288 384 34 than than IN 40288 384 35 the the DT 40288 384 36 succession succession NN 40288 384 37 of of IN 40288 384 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 384 39 intervals interval NNS 40288 384 40 . . . 40288 385 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 385 2 seems seem VBZ 40288 385 3 to to TO 40288 385 4 follow follow VB 40288 385 5 from from IN 40288 385 6 a a DT 40288 385 7 comparison comparison NN 40288 385 8 of of IN 40288 385 9 these these DT 40288 385 10 three three CD 40288 385 11 passages passage NNS 40288 385 12 that that WDT 40288 385 13 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 385 14 was be VBD 40288 385 15 not not RB 40288 385 16 aware aware JJ 40288 385 17 of of IN 40288 385 18 any any DT 40288 385 19 difference difference NN 40288 385 20 of of IN 40288 385 21 meaning meaning NN 40288 385 22 between between IN 40288 385 23 the the DT 40288 385 24 words word NNS 40288 385 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 385 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 385 27 : : : 40288 385 28 tonos tonos NN 40288 385 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 385 30 and and CC 40288 385 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 385 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 385 33 : : : 40288 385 34 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 385 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 385 36 , , , 40288 385 37 or or CC 40288 385 38 any any DT 40288 385 39 distinction distinction NN 40288 385 40 in in IN 40288 385 41 the the DT 40288 385 42 scales scale NNS 40288 385 43 of of IN 40288 385 44 Greek greek JJ 40288 385 45 music music NN 40288 385 46 such such JJ 40288 385 47 as as IN 40288 385 48 has have VBZ 40288 385 49 been be VBN 40288 385 50 supposed suppose VBN 40288 385 51 to to TO 40288 385 52 be be VB 40288 385 53 conveyed convey VBN 40288 385 54 by by IN 40288 385 55 these these DT 40288 385 56 words word NNS 40288 385 57 . . . 40288 386 1 Another another DT 40288 386 2 synonym synonym NN 40288 386 3 of of IN 40288 386 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 386 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 386 6 : : : 40288 386 7 tonos tonos NN 40288 386 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 386 9 which which WDT 40288 386 10 becomes become VBZ 40288 386 11 very very RB 40288 386 12 common common JJ 40288 386 13 in in IN 40288 386 14 the the DT 40288 386 15 later later JJ 40288 386 16 writers writer NNS 40288 386 17 on on IN 40288 386 18 music music NN 40288 386 19 is be VBZ 40288 386 20 the the DT 40288 386 21 word word NN 40288 386 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 386 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 386 24 : : : 40288 386 25 tropos][1 tropos][1 NNP 40288 386 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 386 27 . . . 40288 387 1 In in IN 40288 387 2 the the DT 40288 387 3 course course NN 40288 387 4 of of IN 40288 387 5 the the DT 40288 387 6 passage passage NN 40288 387 7 of of IN 40288 387 8 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 387 9 already already RB 40288 387 10 referred refer VBD 40288 387 11 to to IN 40288 387 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 387 13 _ _ NNP 40288 387 14 De De NNP 40288 387 15 Mus Mus NNP 40288 387 16 . . . 40288 387 17 _ _ NNP 40288 387 18 c. c. NNP 40288 387 19 17 17 CD 40288 387 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 387 21 it -PRON- PRP 40288 387 22 is be VBZ 40288 387 23 applied apply VBN 40288 387 24 to to IN 40288 387 25 the the DT 40288 387 26 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 387 27 mode mode NN 40288 387 28 , , , 40288 387 29 which which WDT 40288 387 30 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 387 31 has have VBZ 40288 387 32 just just RB 40288 387 33 called call VBN 40288 387 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 387 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 387 36 : : : 40288 387 37 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 387 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 387 39 . . . 40288 388 1 As as IN 40288 388 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 388 3 Greek greek JJ 40288 388 4 : : : 40288 388 5 tropos tropos NN 40288 388 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 388 7 is be VBZ 40288 388 8 always always RB 40288 388 9 used use VBN 40288 388 10 in in IN 40288 388 11 the the DT 40288 388 12 later later JJ 40288 388 13 writers writer NNS 40288 388 14 of of IN 40288 388 15 the the DT 40288 388 16 keys key NNS 40288 388 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 388 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 388 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 388 20 : : : 40288 388 21 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 388 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 388 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 388 24 of of IN 40288 388 25 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 388 26 , , , 40288 388 27 this this DT 40288 388 28 may may MD 40288 388 29 be be VB 40288 388 30 added add VBN 40288 388 31 to to IN 40288 388 32 the the DT 40288 388 33 places place NNS 40288 388 34 in in IN 40288 388 35 which which WDT 40288 388 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 388 37 Greek Greek NNP 40288 388 38 : : : 40288 388 39 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 388 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 388 41 has have VBZ 40288 388 42 the the DT 40288 388 43 same same JJ 40288 388 44 meaning meaning NN 40288 388 45 . . . 40288 389 1 § § ADD 40288 389 2 13 13 CD 40288 389 3 . . . 40288 390 1 _ _ NNP 40288 390 2 Modes Modes NNP 40288 390 3 employed employ VBN 40288 390 4 on on IN 40288 390 5 different different JJ 40288 390 6 Instruments Instruments NNPS 40288 390 7 . . . 40288 390 8 _ _ NNP 40288 390 9 In in IN 40288 390 10 the the DT 40288 390 11 anonymous anonymous JJ 40288 390 12 treatise treatise NN 40288 390 13 on on IN 40288 390 14 music music NN 40288 390 15 published publish VBN 40288 390 16 by by IN 40288 390 17 Bellermann[2 Bellermann[2 NNP 40288 390 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 390 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 390 20 c. c. NNP 40288 390 21 28 28 CD 40288 390 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 390 23 , , , 40288 390 24 we -PRON- PRP 40288 390 25 find find VBP 40288 390 26 the the DT 40288 390 27 following follow VBG 40288 390 28 statement statement NN 40288 390 29 regarding regard VBG 40288 390 30 the the DT 40288 390 31 use use NN 40288 390 32 of of IN 40288 390 33 the the DT 40288 390 34 modes mode NNS 40288 390 35 or or CC 40288 390 36 keys key NNS 40288 390 37 in in IN 40288 390 38 the the DT 40288 390 39 scales scale NNS 40288 390 40 of of IN 40288 390 41 different different JJ 40288 390 42 instruments instrument NNS 40288 390 43 : : : 40288 390 44 ' ' '' 40288 390 45 The the DT 40288 390 46 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 390 47 mode mode NN 40288 390 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 390 49 [ [ -LRB- 40288 390 50 Greek Greek NNP 40288 390 51 : : : 40288 390 52 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 390 53 ] ] -RRB- 40288 390 54 ) ) -RRB- 40288 390 55 has have VBZ 40288 390 56 the the DT 40288 390 57 first first JJ 40288 390 58 place place NN 40288 390 59 on on IN 40288 390 60 wind wind NN 40288 390 61 - - HYPH 40288 390 62 instruments instrument NNS 40288 390 63 : : : 40288 390 64 witness witness VB 40288 390 65 the the DT 40288 390 66 first first JJ 40288 390 67 discoverers discoverer NNS 40288 390 68 -- -- : 40288 390 69 Marsyas Marsyas NNP 40288 390 70 , , , 40288 390 71 Hyagnis Hyagnis NNP 40288 390 72 , , , 40288 390 73 Olympus Olympus NNP 40288 390 74 -- -- : 40288 390 75 who who WP 40288 390 76 were be VBD 40288 390 77 Phrygians Phrygians NNPS 40288 390 78 . . . 40288 391 1 Players player NNS 40288 391 2 on on IN 40288 391 3 the the DT 40288 391 4 water water NN 40288 391 5 - - HYPH 40288 391 6 organ organ NN 40288 391 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 391 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 391 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 391 10 : : : 40288 391 11 hydraulai hydraulai NN 40288 391 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 391 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 391 14 use use VBP 40288 391 15 only only RB 40288 391 16 six six CD 40288 391 17 modes mode NNS 40288 391 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 391 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 391 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 391 21 : : : 40288 391 22 tropoi tropoi NNP 40288 391 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 391 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 391 25 , , , 40288 391 26 viz viz NN 40288 391 27 . . . 40288 392 1 Hyper hyper JJ 40288 392 2 - - HYPH 40288 392 3 lydian lydian NNP 40288 392 4 , , , 40288 392 5 Hyper hyper JJ 40288 392 6 - - HYPH 40288 392 7 ionian ionian JJ 40288 392 8 , , , 40288 392 9 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 392 10 , , , 40288 392 11 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 392 12 , , , 40288 392 13 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 392 14 - - HYPH 40288 392 15 lydian lydian NNP 40288 392 16 , , , 40288 392 17 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 392 18 - - HYPH 40288 392 19 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 392 20 . . . 40288 393 1 Players player NNS 40288 393 2 on on IN 40288 393 3 the the DT 40288 393 4 cithara cithara NNP 40288 393 5 tune tune NN 40288 393 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 393 7 instrument instrument NN 40288 393 8 to to IN 40288 393 9 these these DT 40288 393 10 four four CD 40288 393 11 , , , 40288 393 12 viz viz NN 40288 393 13 . . . 40288 394 1 Hyper hyper JJ 40288 394 2 - - HYPH 40288 394 3 ionian ionian JJ 40288 394 4 , , , 40288 394 5 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 394 6 , , , 40288 394 7 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 394 8 - - HYPH 40288 394 9 lydian lydian NNP 40288 394 10 , , , 40288 394 11 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 394 12 . . . 40288 395 1 Flute flute NN 40288 395 2 - - HYPH 40288 395 3 players player NNS 40288 395 4 employ employ VBP 40288 395 5 seven seven CD 40288 395 6 , , , 40288 395 7 viz viz NN 40288 395 8 . . . 40288 396 1 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 396 2 - - HYPH 40288 396 3 aeolian aeolian NNP 40288 396 4 , , , 40288 396 5 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 396 6 - - HYPH 40288 396 7 ionian ionian NNP 40288 396 8 , , , 40288 396 9 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 396 10 - - HYPH 40288 396 11 lydian lydian NNP 40288 396 12 , , , 40288 396 13 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 396 14 , , , 40288 396 15 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 396 16 , , , 40288 396 17 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 396 18 , , , 40288 396 19 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 396 20 - - HYPH 40288 396 21 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 396 22 . . . 40288 397 1 Musicians musician NNS 40288 397 2 who who WP 40288 397 3 concern concern VBP 40288 397 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 40288 397 5 with with IN 40288 397 6 orchestic orchestic JJ 40288 397 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 397 8 choral choral JJ 40288 397 9 music music NN 40288 397 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 397 11 use use VBP 40288 397 12 seven seven CD 40288 397 13 , , , 40288 397 14 viz viz NN 40288 397 15 . . . 40288 398 1 Hyper hyper JJ 40288 398 2 - - HYPH 40288 398 3 dorian dorian JJ 40288 398 4 , , , 40288 398 5 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 398 6 , , , 40288 398 7 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 398 8 , , , 40288 398 9 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 398 10 , , , 40288 398 11 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 398 12 - - HYPH 40288 398 13 lydian lydian NNP 40288 398 14 , , , 40288 398 15 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 398 16 - - HYPH 40288 398 17 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 398 18 , , , 40288 398 19 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 398 20 - - HYPH 40288 398 21 dorian dorian NNP 40288 398 22 . . . 40288 399 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 399 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 399 3 1 1 CD 40288 399 4 : : : 40288 399 5 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 399 6 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 399 7 uses use VBZ 40288 399 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 399 9 Greek greek JJ 40288 399 10 : : : 40288 399 11 tropos tropos NN 40288 399 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 399 13 as as IN 40288 399 14 the the DT 40288 399 15 regular regular JJ 40288 399 16 word word NN 40288 399 17 for for IN 40288 399 18 ' ' `` 40288 399 19 key key NN 40288 399 20 : : : 40288 399 21 ' ' '' 40288 399 22 e.g. e.g. RB 40288 400 1 in in IN 40288 400 2 p. p. NN 40288 400 3 136 136 CD 40288 400 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 400 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 400 6 : : : 40288 400 7 en en IN 40288 400 8 tê tê DT 40288 400 9 tôn tôn NNP 40288 400 10 tropôn tropôn NNP 40288 400 11 , , , 40288 400 12 hous hous NNP 40288 400 13 kai kai NNP 40288 400 14 tonous tonous JJ 40288 400 15 ekalesamen ekalesaman NNS 40288 400 16 , , , 40288 400 17 ekthesei ekthesei NNP 40288 400 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 400 19 . . . 40288 401 1 So so RB 40288 401 2 Alypius Alypius NNP 40288 401 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 401 4 p. p. NN 40288 401 5 2 2 CD 40288 401 6 Meib Meib NNP 40288 401 7 . . . 40288 401 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 402 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 402 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 402 3 : : : 40288 402 4 dielein dielein NNP 40288 402 5 eis eis NNP 40288 402 6 tous tous NNP 40288 402 7 legomenous legomenous JJ 40288 402 8 tropous tropous NNP 40288 402 9 te te NNP 40288 402 10 kai kai NNP 40288 402 11 tonous tonous JJ 40288 402 12 , , , 40288 402 13 ontas ontas NNP 40288 402 14 pentekaideka pentekaideka NNP 40288 402 15 ton ton NNP 40288 402 16 arithmon arithmon NNP 40288 402 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 402 18 . . . 40288 403 1 Also also RB 40288 403 2 Bacchius Bacchius NNP 40288 403 3 in in IN 40288 403 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 403 5 catechism catechism NN 40288 403 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 403 7 p. p. NN 40288 403 8 12 12 CD 40288 403 9 Meib Meib NNP 40288 403 10 . . . 40288 403 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 404 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 404 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 404 3 : : : 40288 404 4 hoi hoi DT 40288 404 5 tous tous JJ 40288 404 6 treis treis JJ 40288 404 7 tropous tropous JJ 40288 404 8 adontes adontes NNP 40288 404 9 tinas tinas NNP 40288 404 10 adousi adousi NN 40288 404 11 ; ; : 40288 404 12 Lydion Lydion NNP 40288 404 13 , , , 40288 404 14 Phrygion Phrygion NNP 40288 404 15 , , , 40288 404 16 Dôrion Dôrion NNP 40288 404 17 ; ; : 40288 404 18 hoi hoi NNP 40288 404 19 de de NNP 40288 404 20 tous tous JJ 40288 404 21 hepta hepta NNP 40288 404 22 tinas tina NNS 40288 404 23 ; ; : 40288 404 24 Mixolydion Mixolydion NNP 40288 404 25 , , , 40288 404 26 Lydion Lydion NNP 40288 404 27 , , , 40288 404 28 Phrygion Phrygion NNP 40288 404 29 , , , 40288 404 30 Dôrion Dôrion NNP 40288 404 31 , , , 40288 404 32 Hypolydion Hypolydion NNP 40288 404 33 , , , 40288 404 34 Hypophrygion Hypophrygion NNP 40288 404 35 , , , 40288 404 36 Hypodôrion Hypodôrion NNP 40288 404 37 , , , 40288 404 38 toutôn toutôn NNP 40288 404 39 poios poio NNS 40288 404 40 estin estin NNP 40288 404 41 oxyteros oxyteros NNP 40288 404 42 ? ? . 40288 405 1 ho ho NNP 40288 405 2 Mixolydios Mixolydios NNP 40288 405 3 , , , 40288 405 4 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 405 5 . . . 40288 405 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 406 1 And and CC 40288 406 2 Gaudentius Gaudentius NNP 40288 406 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 406 4 p. p. NN 40288 406 5 21 21 CD 40288 406 6 , , , 40288 406 7 l. l. NNP 40288 406 8 2 2 CD 40288 406 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 406 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 406 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 406 12 : : : 40288 406 13 kath kath NNP 40288 406 14 ' ' POS 40288 406 15 hekaston hekaston NNP 40288 406 16 tropon tropon NNP 40288 406 17 hê hê NNP 40288 406 18 tonon tonon NNP 40288 406 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 406 20 . . . 40288 407 1 Cp cp RB 40288 407 2 . . . 40288 408 1 Dionys dionys NN 40288 408 2 . . . 40288 409 1 Hal hal UH 40288 409 2 . . . 40288 410 1 _ _ NNP 40288 410 2 De De NNP 40288 410 3 Comp Comp NNP 40288 410 4 . . . 40288 411 1 Verb Verb NNP 40288 411 2 . . . 40288 411 3 _ _ NNP 40288 411 4 c. c. NNP 40288 412 1 19 19 CD 40288 412 2 . . . 40288 412 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 413 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 413 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 413 3 2 2 CD 40288 413 4 : : : 40288 413 5 _ _ NNP 40288 413 6 Anonymi Anonymi NNP 40288 413 7 scriptio scriptio NN 40288 413 8 de de NNP 40288 413 9 Musica Musica NNP 40288 413 10 _ _ NNP 40288 413 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 413 12 Berlin Berlin NNP 40288 413 13 . . . 40288 414 1 1841 1841 CD 40288 414 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 414 3 . . . 40288 414 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 415 1 In in IN 40288 415 2 this this DT 40288 415 3 passage passage NN 40288 415 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 415 5 is be VBZ 40288 415 6 evident evident JJ 40288 415 7 that that IN 40288 415 8 we -PRON- PRP 40288 415 9 have have VBP 40288 415 10 to to TO 40288 415 11 do do VB 40288 415 12 with with IN 40288 415 13 keys key NNS 40288 415 14 of of IN 40288 415 15 the the DT 40288 415 16 scheme scheme NN 40288 415 17 attributed attribute VBN 40288 415 18 to to IN 40288 415 19 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 415 20 , , , 40288 415 21 including include VBG 40288 415 22 the the DT 40288 415 23 two two CD 40288 415 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 415 25 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 415 26 - - HYPH 40288 415 27 aeolian aeolian NNP 40288 415 28 and and CC 40288 415 29 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 415 30 - - HYPH 40288 415 31 lydian lydian NNP 40288 415 32 ) ) -RRB- 40288 415 33 which which WDT 40288 415 34 were be VBD 40288 415 35 said say VBN 40288 415 36 to to TO 40288 415 37 have have VB 40288 415 38 been be VBN 40288 415 39 added add VBN 40288 415 40 after after IN 40288 415 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 415 42 time time NN 40288 415 43 . . . 40288 416 1 The the DT 40288 416 2 number number NN 40288 416 3 of of IN 40288 416 4 scales scale NNS 40288 416 5 mentioned mention VBN 40288 416 6 is be VBZ 40288 416 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 40288 416 8 to to TO 40288 416 9 prove prove VB 40288 416 10 that that IN 40288 416 11 the the DT 40288 416 12 reference reference NN 40288 416 13 is be VBZ 40288 416 14 not not RB 40288 416 15 to to IN 40288 416 16 the the DT 40288 416 17 seven seven CD 40288 416 18 species specie NNS 40288 416 19 of of IN 40288 416 20 the the DT 40288 416 21 octave octave NN 40288 416 22 . . . 40288 417 1 Yet yet CC 40288 417 2 the the DT 40288 417 3 word word NN 40288 417 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 417 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 417 6 : : : 40288 417 7 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 417 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 417 9 is be VBZ 40288 417 10 used use VBN 40288 417 11 of of IN 40288 417 12 these these DT 40288 417 13 keys key NNS 40288 417 14 , , , 40288 417 15 and and CC 40288 417 16 with with IN 40288 417 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 417 18 , , , 40288 417 19 seemingly seemingly RB 40288 417 20 as as IN 40288 417 21 an an DT 40288 417 22 equivalent equivalent NN 40288 417 23 , , , 40288 417 24 the the DT 40288 417 25 word word NN 40288 417 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 417 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 417 28 : : : 40288 417 29 tropos tropos NN 40288 417 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 417 31 . . . 40288 418 1 Pollux Pollux NNP 40288 418 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 418 3 _ _ NNP 40288 418 4 Onom Onom NNP 40288 418 5 . . . 40288 418 6 _ _ NNP 40288 418 7 iv iv NNP 40288 418 8 . . . 40288 419 1 78 78 LS 40288 419 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 419 3 gives give VBZ 40288 419 4 a a DT 40288 419 5 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 419 6 different different JJ 40288 419 7 account account NN 40288 419 8 of of IN 40288 419 9 the the DT 40288 419 10 modes mode NNS 40288 419 11 used use VBN 40288 419 12 on on IN 40288 419 13 the the DT 40288 419 14 flute flute NN 40288 419 15 : : : 40288 419 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 419 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 419 18 : : : 40288 419 19 kai kai NNP 40288 419 20 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 419 21 men man NNS 40288 419 22 aulêtikê aulêtikê VBP 40288 419 23 Dôristi Dôristi NNP 40288 419 24 , , , 40288 419 25 Phrygisti Phrygisti NNP 40288 419 26 , , , 40288 419 27 Lydios Lydios NNPS 40288 419 28 kai kai NNP 40288 419 29 Iônikê Iônikê NNP 40288 419 30 , , , 40288 419 31 kai kai NNP 40288 419 32 syntonos syntonos JJ 40288 419 33 Lydisti Lydisti NNP 40288 419 34 hên hên NN 40288 419 35 Anthippos Anthippos NNP 40288 419 36 exeure exeure NN 40288 419 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 419 38 . . . 40288 420 1 But but CC 40288 420 2 this this DT 40288 420 3 statement statement NN 40288 420 4 , , , 40288 420 5 as as IN 40288 420 6 has have VBZ 40288 420 7 been be VBN 40288 420 8 already already RB 40288 420 9 pointed point VBN 40288 420 10 out out RP 40288 420 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 420 12 p. p. NN 40288 420 13 22 22 CD 40288 420 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 420 15 , , , 40288 420 16 is be VBZ 40288 420 17 a a DT 40288 420 18 piece piece NN 40288 420 19 of of IN 40288 420 20 antiquarian antiquarian JJ 40288 420 21 learning learning NN 40288 420 22 , , , 40288 420 23 and and CC 40288 420 24 therefore therefore RB 40288 420 25 takes take VBZ 40288 420 26 no no DT 40288 420 27 notice notice NN 40288 420 28 of of IN 40288 420 29 the the DT 40288 420 30 more more RBR 40288 420 31 recent recent JJ 40288 420 32 keys key NNS 40288 420 33 , , , 40288 420 34 as as IN 40288 420 35 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 420 36 - - HYPH 40288 420 37 aeolian aeolian NNP 40288 420 38 and and CC 40288 420 39 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 420 40 - - HYPH 40288 420 41 ionian ionian NNP 40288 420 42 , , , 40288 420 43 or or CC 40288 420 44 even even RB 40288 420 45 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 420 46 - - HYPH 40288 420 47 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 420 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 420 49 unless unless IN 40288 420 50 that that DT 40288 420 51 is be VBZ 40288 420 52 the the DT 40288 420 53 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 420 54 of of IN 40288 420 55 Pollux Pollux NNP 40288 420 56 ) ) -RRB- 40288 420 57 . . . 40288 421 1 The the DT 40288 421 2 absence absence NN 40288 421 3 of of IN 40288 421 4 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 421 5 from from IN 40288 421 6 the the DT 40288 421 7 list list NN 40288 421 8 given give VBN 40288 421 9 by by IN 40288 421 10 the the DT 40288 421 11 _ _ NNP 40288 421 12 Anonymus Anonymus NNP 40288 421 13 _ _ NNP 40288 421 14 is be VBZ 40288 421 15 curious curious JJ 40288 421 16 : : : 40288 421 17 but but CC 40288 421 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 421 19 seems seem VBZ 40288 421 20 that that IN 40288 421 21 at at IN 40288 421 22 that that DT 40288 421 23 time time NN 40288 421 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 421 25 was be VBD 40288 421 26 equally equally RB 40288 421 27 unknown unknown JJ 40288 421 28 to to IN 40288 421 29 the the DT 40288 421 30 cithara cithara NNP 40288 421 31 and and CC 40288 421 32 the the DT 40288 421 33 water water NN 40288 421 34 - - HYPH 40288 421 35 organ organ NN 40288 421 36 . . . 40288 422 1 There there EX 40288 422 2 is be VBZ 40288 422 3 therefore therefore RB 40288 422 4 no no DT 40288 422 5 reason reason NN 40288 422 6 to to TO 40288 422 7 think think VB 40288 422 8 that that IN 40288 422 9 the the DT 40288 422 10 two two CD 40288 422 11 lists list NNS 40288 422 12 are be VBP 40288 422 13 framed frame VBN 40288 422 14 with with IN 40288 422 15 reference reference NN 40288 422 16 to to IN 40288 422 17 different different JJ 40288 422 18 things thing NNS 40288 422 19 . . . 40288 423 1 That that DT 40288 423 2 is be VBZ 40288 423 3 to to TO 40288 423 4 say say VB 40288 423 5 , , , 40288 423 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 423 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 423 8 : : : 40288 423 9 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 423 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 423 11 in in IN 40288 423 12 Pollux Pollux NNP 40288 423 13 has have VBZ 40288 423 14 the the DT 40288 423 15 same same JJ 40288 423 16 meaning meaning NN 40288 423 17 as as IN 40288 423 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 423 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 423 20 : : : 40288 423 21 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 423 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 423 23 in in IN 40288 423 24 the the DT 40288 423 25 _ _ NNP 40288 423 26 Anonymus Anonymus NNP 40288 423 27 _ _ NNP 40288 423 28 , , , 40288 423 29 and and CC 40288 423 30 is be VBZ 40288 423 31 equivalent equivalent JJ 40288 423 32 to to IN 40288 423 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 423 34 Greek greek NN 40288 423 35 : : : 40288 423 36 tonos tonos NN 40288 423 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 423 38 . . . 40288 424 1 § § ADD 40288 424 2 14 14 CD 40288 424 3 . . . 40288 425 1 _ _ NNP 40288 425 2 Recapitulation--[Greek Recapitulation--[Greek NNP 40288 425 3 : : : 40288 425 4 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 425 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 425 6 and and CC 40288 425 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 425 8 Greek greek NN 40288 425 9 : : : 40288 425 10 tonos tonos NN 40288 425 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 425 12 . . . 40288 425 13 _ _ NNP 40288 425 14 The the DT 40288 425 15 inquiry inquiry NN 40288 425 16 has have VBZ 40288 425 17 now now RB 40288 425 18 reached reach VBN 40288 425 19 a a DT 40288 425 20 stage stage NN 40288 425 21 at at IN 40288 425 22 which which WDT 40288 425 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 425 24 may may MD 40288 425 25 stop stop VB 40288 425 26 to to TO 40288 425 27 consider consider VB 40288 425 28 what what WDT 40288 425 29 result result NN 40288 425 30 has have VBZ 40288 425 31 been be VBN 40288 425 32 reached reach VBN 40288 425 33 , , , 40288 425 34 especially especially RB 40288 425 35 in in IN 40288 425 36 regard regard NN 40288 425 37 to to IN 40288 425 38 the the DT 40288 425 39 question question NN 40288 425 40 whether whether IN 40288 425 41 the the DT 40288 425 42 two two CD 40288 425 43 words word NNS 40288 425 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 425 45 Greek Greek NNP 40288 425 46 : : : 40288 425 47 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 425 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 425 49 and and CC 40288 425 50 [ [ -LRB- 40288 425 51 Greek greek NN 40288 425 52 : : : 40288 425 53 tonos tonos NN 40288 425 54 ] ] -RRB- 40288 425 55 denote denote VB 40288 425 56 two two CD 40288 425 57 sets set NNS 40288 425 58 of of IN 40288 425 59 musical musical JJ 40288 425 60 forms form NNS 40288 425 61 , , , 40288 425 62 or or CC 40288 425 63 are be VBP 40288 425 64 merely merely RB 40288 425 65 two two CD 40288 425 66 different different JJ 40288 425 67 names name NNS 40288 425 68 for for IN 40288 425 69 the the DT 40288 425 70 same same JJ 40288 425 71 thing thing NN 40288 425 72 . . . 40288 426 1 The the DT 40288 426 2 latter latter JJ 40288 426 3 alternative alternative NN 40288 426 4 appears appear VBZ 40288 426 5 to to TO 40288 426 6 be be VB 40288 426 7 supported support VBN 40288 426 8 by by IN 40288 426 9 several several JJ 40288 426 10 considerations consideration NNS 40288 426 11 . . . 40288 427 1 1 1 LS 40288 427 2 . . . 40288 428 1 From from IN 40288 428 2 various various JJ 40288 428 3 passages passage NNS 40288 428 4 , , , 40288 428 5 especially especially RB 40288 428 6 in in IN 40288 428 7 Plato Plato NNP 40288 428 8 and and CC 40288 428 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 428 10 , , , 40288 428 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 428 12 has have VBZ 40288 428 13 been be VBN 40288 428 14 shown show VBN 40288 428 15 that that IN 40288 428 16 the the DT 40288 428 17 modes mode NNS 40288 428 18 anciently anciently RB 40288 428 19 called call VBD 40288 428 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 428 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 428 22 : : : 40288 428 23 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 428 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 428 25 differed differ VBN 40288 428 26 in in IN 40288 428 27 pitch pitch NN 40288 428 28 , , , 40288 428 29 and and CC 40288 428 30 that that IN 40288 428 31 this this DT 40288 428 32 difference difference NN 40288 428 33 in in IN 40288 428 34 pitch pitch NN 40288 428 35 was be VBD 40288 428 36 regarded regard VBN 40288 428 37 as as IN 40288 428 38 the the DT 40288 428 39 chief chief JJ 40288 428 40 source source NN 40288 428 41 of of IN 40288 428 42 the the DT 40288 428 43 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 428 44 ethical ethical JJ 40288 428 45 character character NN 40288 428 46 of of IN 40288 428 47 the the DT 40288 428 48 modes mode NNS 40288 428 49 . . . 40288 429 1 2 2 LS 40288 429 2 . . . 40288 430 1 The the DT 40288 430 2 list list NN 40288 430 3 of of IN 40288 430 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 430 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 430 6 : : : 40288 430 7 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 430 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 430 9 as as IN 40288 430 10 gathered gather VBN 40288 430 11 from from IN 40288 430 12 the the DT 40288 430 13 writers writer NNS 40288 430 14 who who WP 40288 430 15 treat treat VBP 40288 430 16 of of IN 40288 430 17 them -PRON- PRP 40288 430 18 , , , 40288 430 19 viz viz NN 40288 430 20 . . . 40288 431 1 Plato Plato NNP 40288 431 2 , , , 40288 431 3 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 431 4 , , , 40288 431 5 and and CC 40288 431 6 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 431 7 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 431 8 , , , 40288 431 9 is be VBZ 40288 431 10 substantially substantially RB 40288 431 11 the the DT 40288 431 12 same same JJ 40288 431 13 as as IN 40288 431 14 the the DT 40288 431 15 list list NN 40288 431 16 of of IN 40288 431 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 431 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 431 19 : : : 40288 431 20 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 431 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 431 22 described describe VBN 40288 431 23 by by IN 40288 431 24 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 431 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 431 26 p. p. NN 40288 431 27 18 18 CD 40288 431 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 431 29 : : : 40288 431 30 and and CC 40288 431 31 moreover moreover RB 40288 431 32 , , , 40288 431 33 there there EX 40288 431 34 is be VBZ 40288 431 35 an an DT 40288 431 36 agreement agreement NN 40288 431 37 in in IN 40288 431 38 detail detail NN 40288 431 39 between between IN 40288 431 40 the the DT 40288 431 41 two two CD 40288 431 42 lists list NNS 40288 431 43 which which WDT 40288 431 44 can can MD 40288 431 45 not not RB 40288 431 46 be be VB 40288 431 47 purely purely RB 40288 431 48 accidental accidental JJ 40288 431 49 . . . 40288 432 1 Thus thus RB 40288 432 2 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 432 3 says say VBZ 40288 432 4 that that IN 40288 432 5 certain certain JJ 40288 432 6 people people NNS 40288 432 7 had have VBD 40288 432 8 found find VBN 40288 432 9 out out RP 40288 432 10 a a DT 40288 432 11 new new JJ 40288 432 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 432 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 432 14 : : : 40288 432 15 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 432 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 432 17 , , , 40288 432 18 the the DT 40288 432 19 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 432 20 - - HYPH 40288 432 21 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 432 22 ; ; : 40288 432 23 and and CC 40288 432 24 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 432 25 speaks speak VBZ 40288 432 26 of of IN 40288 432 27 the the DT 40288 432 28 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 432 29 - - HYPH 40288 432 30 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 432 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 432 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 432 33 : : : 40288 432 34 tonos tonos NN 40288 432 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 432 36 as as IN 40288 432 37 a a DT 40288 432 38 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 432 39 new new JJ 40288 432 40 one one CD 40288 432 41 . . . 40288 433 1 Again again RB 40288 433 2 , , , 40288 433 3 the the DT 40288 433 4 account account NN 40288 433 5 which which WDT 40288 433 6 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 433 7 gives give VBZ 40288 433 8 of of IN 40288 433 9 the the DT 40288 433 10 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 433 11 - - HYPH 40288 433 12 dorian dorian JJ 40288 433 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 433 14 Greek greek NN 40288 433 15 : : : 40288 433 16 tonos tonos NN 40288 433 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 433 18 as as IN 40288 433 19 a a DT 40288 433 20 key key NN 40288 433 21 immediately immediately RB 40288 433 22 below below IN 40288 433 23 the the DT 40288 433 24 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 433 25 agrees agree VBZ 40288 433 26 with with IN 40288 433 27 what what WP 40288 433 28 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 433 29 says say VBZ 40288 433 30 of of IN 40288 433 31 the the DT 40288 433 32 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 433 33 - - HYPH 40288 433 34 dorian dorian JJ 40288 433 35 [ [ -LRB- 40288 433 36 Greek Greek NNP 40288 433 37 : : : 40288 433 38 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 433 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 433 40 , , , 40288 433 41 and and CC 40288 433 42 also also RB 40288 433 43 with with IN 40288 433 44 the the DT 40288 433 45 mention mention NN 40288 433 46 of of IN 40288 433 47 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 433 48 - - HYPH 40288 433 49 dorian dorian NNP 40288 433 50 and and CC 40288 433 51 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 433 52 - - HYPH 40288 433 53 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 433 54 ( ( -LRB- 40288 433 55 but but CC 40288 433 56 not not RB 40288 433 57 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 433 58 - - HYPH 40288 433 59 lydian lydian NNP 40288 433 60 ) ) -RRB- 40288 433 61 in in IN 40288 433 62 the the DT 40288 433 63 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 433 64 _ _ NNP 40288 433 65 Problems Problems NNP 40288 433 66 _ _ NNP 40288 433 67 . . . 40288 434 1 Once once RB 40288 434 2 more more JJR 40288 434 3 , , , 40288 434 4 the the DT 40288 434 5 absence absence NN 40288 434 6 of of IN 40288 434 7 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 434 8 from from IN 40288 434 9 the the DT 40288 434 10 list list NN 40288 434 11 of of IN 40288 434 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 434 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 434 14 : : : 40288 434 15 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 434 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 434 17 in in IN 40288 434 18 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 434 19 is be VBZ 40288 434 20 an an DT 40288 434 21 exception exception NN 40288 434 22 which which WDT 40288 434 23 proves prove VBZ 40288 434 24 the the DT 40288 434 25 rule rule NN 40288 434 26 : : : 40288 434 27 since since IN 40288 434 28 the the DT 40288 434 29 name name NN 40288 434 30 of of IN 40288 434 31 the the DT 40288 434 32 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 434 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 434 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 434 35 : : : 40288 434 36 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 434 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 434 38 is be VBZ 40288 434 39 similarly similarly RB 40288 434 40 absent absent JJ 40288 434 41 from from IN 40288 434 42 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 434 43 . . . 40288 435 1 3 3 LS 40288 435 2 . . . 40288 436 1 The the DT 40288 436 2 usage usage NN 40288 436 3 of of IN 40288 436 4 the the DT 40288 436 5 words word NNS 40288 436 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 436 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 436 8 : : : 40288 436 9 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 436 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 436 11 and and CC 40288 436 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 436 13 Greek greek NN 40288 436 14 : : : 40288 436 15 tonos tonos NN 40288 436 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 436 17 is be VBZ 40288 436 18 never never RB 40288 436 19 such such JJ 40288 436 20 as as IN 40288 436 21 to to TO 40288 436 22 suggest suggest VB 40288 436 23 that that IN 40288 436 24 they -PRON- PRP 40288 436 25 refer refer VBP 40288 436 26 to to IN 40288 436 27 different different JJ 40288 436 28 things thing NNS 40288 436 29 . . . 40288 437 1 In in IN 40288 437 2 the the DT 40288 437 3 earlier early JJR 40288 437 4 writers writer NNS 40288 437 5 , , , 40288 437 6 down down RB 40288 437 7 to to IN 40288 437 8 and and CC 40288 437 9 including include VBG 40288 437 10 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 437 11 , , , 40288 437 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 437 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 437 14 : : : 40288 437 15 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 437 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 437 17 is be VBZ 40288 437 18 used use VBN 40288 437 19 , , , 40288 437 20 never never RB 40288 437 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 437 22 Greek greek NN 40288 437 23 : : : 40288 437 24 tonos tonos NN 40288 437 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 437 26 . . . 40288 438 1 In in IN 40288 438 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 438 3 and and CC 40288 438 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 438 5 school school NN 40288 438 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 438 7 find find VBP 40288 438 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 438 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 438 10 : : : 40288 438 11 tonos tonos NN 40288 438 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 438 13 , , , 40288 438 14 and and CC 40288 438 15 in in IN 40288 438 16 later late JJR 40288 438 17 writers writer NNS 40288 438 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 438 19 Greek greek JJ 40288 438 20 : : : 40288 438 21 tropos tropos NN 40288 438 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 438 23 , , , 40288 438 24 but but CC 40288 438 25 not not RB 40288 438 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 438 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 438 28 : : : 40288 438 29 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 438 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 438 31 . . . 40288 439 1 The the DT 40288 439 2 few few JJ 40288 439 3 writers writer NNS 40288 439 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 439 5 such such JJ 40288 439 6 as as IN 40288 439 7 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 439 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 439 9 who who WP 40288 439 10 use use VBP 40288 439 11 both both DT 40288 439 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 439 13 Greek greek NN 40288 439 14 : : : 40288 439 15 tonos tonos NN 40288 439 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 439 17 and and CC 40288 439 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 439 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 439 20 : : : 40288 439 21 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 439 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 439 23 do do VB 40288 439 24 not not RB 40288 439 25 observe observe VB 40288 439 26 any any DT 40288 439 27 consistent consistent JJ 40288 439 28 distinction distinction NN 40288 439 29 between between IN 40288 439 30 them -PRON- PRP 40288 439 31 . . . 40288 440 1 Those those DT 40288 440 2 who who WP 40288 440 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 440 4 like like UH 40288 440 5 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 440 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 440 7 believe believe VBP 40288 440 8 that that IN 40288 440 9 there there EX 40288 440 10 was be VBD 40288 440 11 a a DT 40288 440 12 distinction distinction NN 40288 440 13 , , , 40288 440 14 are be VBP 40288 440 15 obliged oblige VBN 40288 440 16 to to TO 40288 440 17 admit admit VB 40288 440 18 that that IN 40288 440 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 440 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 440 21 : : : 40288 440 22 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 440 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 440 24 is be VBZ 40288 440 25 occasionally occasionally RB 40288 440 26 used use VBN 40288 440 27 for for IN 40288 440 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 440 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 440 30 : : : 40288 440 31 tonos tonos NN 40288 440 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 440 33 and and CC 40288 440 34 conversely conversely RB 40288 440 35 . . . 40288 441 1 4 4 LS 40288 441 2 . . . 40288 442 1 If if IN 40288 442 2 a a DT 40288 442 3 series series NN 40288 442 4 of of IN 40288 442 5 names name NNS 40288 442 6 such such JJ 40288 442 7 as as IN 40288 442 8 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 442 9 , , , 40288 442 10 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 442 11 , , , 40288 442 12 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 442 13 and and CC 40288 442 14 the the DT 40288 442 15 rest rest NN 40288 442 16 were be VBD 40288 442 17 applied apply VBN 40288 442 18 to to IN 40288 442 19 two two CD 40288 442 20 sets set NNS 40288 442 21 of of IN 40288 442 22 things thing NNS 40288 442 23 so so RB 40288 442 24 distinct distinct JJ 40288 442 25 from from IN 40288 442 26 each each DT 40288 442 27 other other JJ 40288 442 28 , , , 40288 442 29 and and CC 40288 442 30 at at IN 40288 442 31 the the DT 40288 442 32 same same JJ 40288 442 33 time time NN 40288 442 34 so so RB 40288 442 35 important important JJ 40288 442 36 in in IN 40288 442 37 the the DT 40288 442 38 practice practice NN 40288 442 39 of of IN 40288 442 40 music music NN 40288 442 41 , , , 40288 442 42 as as IN 40288 442 43 what what WP 40288 442 44 we -PRON- PRP 40288 442 45 now now RB 40288 442 46 call call VBP 40288 442 47 modes mode NNS 40288 442 48 and and CC 40288 442 49 keys key NNS 40288 442 50 , , , 40288 442 51 it -PRON- PRP 40288 442 52 is be VBZ 40288 442 53 incredible incredible JJ 40288 442 54 that that IN 40288 442 55 there there EX 40288 442 56 should should MD 40288 442 57 be be VB 40288 442 58 no no DT 40288 442 59 trace trace NN 40288 442 60 of of IN 40288 442 61 the the DT 40288 442 62 double double JJ 40288 442 63 usage usage NN 40288 442 64 . . . 40288 443 1 Yet yet CC 40288 443 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 443 3 authors author NNS 40288 443 4 show show VBP 40288 443 5 no no DT 40288 443 6 sense sense NN 40288 443 7 even even RB 40288 443 8 of of IN 40288 443 9 possible possible JJ 40288 443 10 ambiguity ambiguity NN 40288 443 11 . . . 40288 444 1 Indeed indeed RB 40288 444 2 , , , 40288 444 3 they -PRON- PRP 40288 444 4 seem seem VBP 40288 444 5 to to TO 40288 444 6 prefer prefer VB 40288 444 7 , , , 40288 444 8 in in IN 40288 444 9 referring refer VBG 40288 444 10 to to IN 40288 444 11 modes mode NNS 40288 444 12 or or CC 40288 444 13 keys key NNS 40288 444 14 , , , 40288 444 15 to to TO 40288 444 16 use use VB 40288 444 17 the the DT 40288 444 18 adverbial adverbial JJ 40288 444 19 forms form NNS 40288 444 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 444 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 444 22 : : : 40288 444 23 dôristi dôristi NN 40288 444 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 444 25 , , , 40288 444 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 444 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 444 28 : : : 40288 444 29 phrygisti phrygisti NN 40288 444 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 444 31 , , , 40288 444 32 & & CC 40288 444 33 c. c. NNP 40288 444 34 , , , 40288 444 35 or or CC 40288 444 36 the the DT 40288 444 37 neuter neuter NN 40288 444 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 444 39 Greek Greek NNP 40288 444 40 : : : 40288 444 41 ta ta NNP 40288 444 42 dôria dôria NN 40288 444 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 444 44 , , , 40288 444 45 [ [ -LRB- 40288 444 46 Greek Greek NNP 40288 444 47 : : : 40288 444 48 ta ta NNP 40288 444 49 phrygia phrygia NNP 40288 444 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 444 51 , , , 40288 444 52 & & CC 40288 444 53 c. c. NNP 40288 444 54 , , , 40288 444 55 where where WRB 40288 444 56 there there EX 40288 444 57 is be VBZ 40288 444 58 nothing nothing NN 40288 444 59 to to TO 40288 444 60 show show VB 40288 444 61 whether whether IN 40288 444 62 ' ' `` 40288 444 63 mode mode NN 40288 444 64 ' ' '' 40288 444 65 or or CC 40288 444 66 ' ' `` 40288 444 67 key key NN 40288 444 68 , , , 40288 444 69 ' ' '' 40288 444 70 [ [ -LRB- 40288 444 71 Greek Greek NNP 40288 444 72 : : : 40288 444 73 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 444 74 ] ] -RRB- 40288 444 75 or or CC 40288 444 76 [ [ -LRB- 40288 444 77 Greek greek NN 40288 444 78 : : : 40288 444 79 tonos tonos NN 40288 444 80 ] ] -RRB- 40288 444 81 , , , 40288 444 82 is be VBZ 40288 444 83 intended intend VBN 40288 444 84 . . . 40288 445 1 § § ADD 40288 445 2 15 15 CD 40288 445 3 . . . 40288 446 1 _ _ NNP 40288 446 2 The the DT 40288 446 3 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 446 4 of of IN 40288 446 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 446 6 Music Music NNP 40288 446 7 . . . 40288 446 8 _ _ NNP 40288 446 9 The the DT 40288 446 10 arguments argument NNS 40288 446 11 in in IN 40288 446 12 favour favour NN 40288 446 13 of of IN 40288 446 14 identifying identify VBG 40288 446 15 the the DT 40288 446 16 primitive primitive JJ 40288 446 17 national national JJ 40288 446 18 Modes mode NNS 40288 446 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 446 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 446 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 446 22 : : : 40288 446 23 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 446 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 446 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 446 26 with with IN 40288 446 27 the the DT 40288 446 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 446 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 446 30 : : : 40288 446 31 tonoi tonoi NNS 40288 446 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 446 33 or or CC 40288 446 34 keys key NNS 40288 446 35 may may MD 40288 446 36 be be VB 40288 446 37 reinforced reinforce VBN 40288 446 38 by by IN 40288 446 39 some some DT 40288 446 40 considerations consideration NNS 40288 446 41 drawn draw VBN 40288 446 42 from from IN 40288 446 43 the the DT 40288 446 44 history history NN 40288 446 45 and and CC 40288 446 46 use use NN 40288 446 47 of of IN 40288 446 48 another another DT 40288 446 49 ancient ancient JJ 40288 446 50 term term NN 40288 446 51 , , , 40288 446 52 namely namely RB 40288 446 53 [ [ -LRB- 40288 446 54 Greek Greek NNP 40288 446 55 : : : 40288 446 56 systêma systêma NN 40288 446 57 ] ] -RRB- 40288 446 58 . . . 40288 447 1 A a DT 40288 447 2 System system NN 40288 447 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 447 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 447 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 447 6 : : : 40288 447 7 systêma systêma NN 40288 447 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 447 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 447 10 is be VBZ 40288 447 11 defined define VBN 40288 447 12 by by IN 40288 447 13 the the DT 40288 447 14 Greek greek JJ 40288 447 15 technical technical JJ 40288 447 16 writers writer NNS 40288 447 17 as as IN 40288 447 18 a a DT 40288 447 19 group group NN 40288 447 20 or or CC 40288 447 21 complex complex NN 40288 447 22 of of IN 40288 447 23 intervals interval NNS 40288 447 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 447 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 447 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 447 27 : : : 40288 447 28 to to TO 40288 447 29 ek ek NNP 40288 447 30 pleionôn pleionôn NNP 40288 447 31 ê ê NNP 40288 447 32 henos henos NNP 40288 447 33 diastêmatôn diastêmatôn NNP 40288 447 34 synkeimenon synkeimenon VB 40288 447 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 447 36 Ps Ps NNP 40288 447 37 . . . 40288 448 1 Eucl Eucl NNP 40288 448 2 . . . 40288 448 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 448 4 . . . 40288 449 1 That that DT 40288 449 2 is be VBZ 40288 449 3 to to TO 40288 449 4 say say VB 40288 449 5 , , , 40288 449 6 any any DT 40288 449 7 three three CD 40288 449 8 or or CC 40288 449 9 more more JJR 40288 449 10 notes note NNS 40288 449 11 whose whose WP$ 40288 449 12 _ _ NNP 40288 449 13 relative relative JJ 40288 449 14 _ _ NNP 40288 449 15 pitch pitch NN 40288 449 16 is be VBZ 40288 449 17 fixed fix VBN 40288 449 18 may may MD 40288 449 19 be be VB 40288 449 20 regarded regard VBN 40288 449 21 as as IN 40288 449 22 forming form VBG 40288 449 23 a a DT 40288 449 24 particular particular JJ 40288 449 25 System system NN 40288 449 26 . . . 40288 450 1 If if IN 40288 450 2 the the DT 40288 450 3 notes note NNS 40288 450 4 are be VBP 40288 450 5 such such JJ 40288 450 6 as as IN 40288 450 7 might may MD 40288 450 8 be be VB 40288 450 9 used use VBN 40288 450 10 in in IN 40288 450 11 the the DT 40288 450 12 same same JJ 40288 450 13 melody melody NN 40288 450 14 , , , 40288 450 15 they -PRON- PRP 40288 450 16 are be VBP 40288 450 17 said say VBN 40288 450 18 to to TO 40288 450 19 form form VB 40288 450 20 a a DT 40288 450 21 _ _ NNP 40288 450 22 musical musical JJ 40288 450 23 _ _ NNP 40288 450 24 System System NNP 40288 450 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 450 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 450 27 Greek greek JJ 40288 450 28 : : : 40288 450 29 systêma systêma NN 40288 450 30 emmeles emmele NNS 40288 450 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 450 32 ) ) -RRB- 40288 450 33 . . . 40288 451 1 As as IN 40288 451 2 a a DT 40288 451 3 matter matter NN 40288 451 4 of of IN 40288 451 5 abstract abstract JJ 40288 451 6 theory theory NN 40288 451 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 451 8 is be VBZ 40288 451 9 evident evident JJ 40288 451 10 that that IN 40288 451 11 there there EX 40288 451 12 are be VBP 40288 451 13 very very RB 40288 451 14 many many JJ 40288 451 15 combinations combination NNS 40288 451 16 of of IN 40288 451 17 intervals interval NNS 40288 451 18 which which WDT 40288 451 19 in in IN 40288 451 20 this this DT 40288 451 21 sense sense NN 40288 451 22 form form VBP 40288 451 23 a a DT 40288 451 24 musical musical JJ 40288 451 25 System system NN 40288 451 26 . . . 40288 452 1 In in IN 40288 452 2 fact fact NN 40288 452 3 , , , 40288 452 4 however however RB 40288 452 5 , , , 40288 452 6 the the DT 40288 452 7 variety variety NN 40288 452 8 of of IN 40288 452 9 systems system NNS 40288 452 10 recognised recognise VBN 40288 452 11 in in IN 40288 452 12 the the DT 40288 452 13 theory theory NN 40288 452 14 of of IN 40288 452 15 Greek greek JJ 40288 452 16 music music NN 40288 452 17 was be VBD 40288 452 18 strictly strictly RB 40288 452 19 limited limit VBN 40288 452 20 . . . 40288 453 1 The the DT 40288 453 2 notion notion NN 40288 453 3 of of IN 40288 453 4 a a DT 40288 453 5 small small JJ 40288 453 6 number number NN 40288 453 7 of of IN 40288 453 8 scales scale NNS 40288 453 9 , , , 40288 453 10 of of IN 40288 453 11 a a DT 40288 453 12 particular particular JJ 40288 453 13 compass compass NN 40288 453 14 , , , 40288 453 15 available available JJ 40288 453 16 for for IN 40288 453 17 the the DT 40288 453 18 use use NN 40288 453 19 of of IN 40288 453 20 the the DT 40288 453 21 musician musician NN 40288 453 22 , , , 40288 453 23 was be VBD 40288 453 24 naturally naturally RB 40288 453 25 suggested suggest VBN 40288 453 26 by by IN 40288 453 27 the the DT 40288 453 28 ancient ancient JJ 40288 453 29 lyre lyre NN 40288 453 30 , , , 40288 453 31 with with IN 40288 453 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 453 33 fixed fixed JJ 40288 453 34 and and CC 40288 453 35 conventional conventional JJ 40288 453 36 number number NN 40288 453 37 of of IN 40288 453 38 strings string NNS 40288 453 39 . . . 40288 454 1 The the DT 40288 454 2 word word NN 40288 454 3 for for IN 40288 454 4 _ _ NNP 40288 454 5 string string NN 40288 454 6 _ _ NNP 40288 454 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 454 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 454 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 454 10 : : : 40288 454 11 chordê chordê NNP 40288 454 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 454 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 454 14 came come VBD 40288 454 15 to to TO 40288 454 16 be be VB 40288 454 17 used use VBN 40288 454 18 with with IN 40288 454 19 the the DT 40288 454 20 general general JJ 40288 454 21 sense sense NN 40288 454 22 of of IN 40288 454 23 a a DT 40288 454 24 _ _ NNP 40288 454 25 note note NN 40288 454 26 _ _ NNP 40288 454 27 of of IN 40288 454 28 music music NN 40288 454 29 ; ; : 40288 454 30 and and CC 40288 454 31 in in IN 40288 454 32 this this DT 40288 454 33 way way NN 40288 454 34 the the DT 40288 454 35 several several JJ 40288 454 36 strings string NNS 40288 454 37 of of IN 40288 454 38 the the DT 40288 454 39 lyre lyre NN 40288 454 40 gave give VBD 40288 454 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 454 42 names name NNS 40288 454 43 to to IN 40288 454 44 the the DT 40288 454 45 notes note NNS 40288 454 46 of of IN 40288 454 47 the the DT 40288 454 48 Greek Greek NNP 40288 454 49 gamut[1 gamut[1 NNP 40288 454 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 454 51 . . . 40288 455 1 § § ADD 40288 455 2 16 16 CD 40288 455 3 . . . 40288 456 1 _ _ NNP 40288 456 2 The the DT 40288 456 3 Standard Standard NNP 40288 456 4 Octachord Octachord NNP 40288 456 5 System System NNP 40288 456 6 . . . 40288 456 7 _ _ NNP 40288 456 8 In in IN 40288 456 9 the the DT 40288 456 10 age age NN 40288 456 11 of of IN 40288 456 12 the the DT 40288 456 13 great great JJ 40288 456 14 melic melic JJ 40288 456 15 poets poet NNS 40288 456 16 the the DT 40288 456 17 lyre lyre NN 40288 456 18 had have VBD 40288 456 19 no no DT 40288 456 20 more more JJR 40288 456 21 than than IN 40288 456 22 seven seven CD 40288 456 23 strings string NNS 40288 456 24 : : : 40288 456 25 but but CC 40288 456 26 the the DT 40288 456 27 octave octave NN 40288 456 28 was be VBD 40288 456 29 completed complete VBN 40288 456 30 in in IN 40288 456 31 the the DT 40288 456 32 earliest early JJS 40288 456 33 times time NNS 40288 456 34 of of IN 40288 456 35 which which WDT 40288 456 36 we -PRON- PRP 40288 456 37 have have VBP 40288 456 38 accurate accurate JJ 40288 456 39 information information NN 40288 456 40 . . . 40288 457 1 The the DT 40288 457 2 scale scale NN 40288 457 3 which which WDT 40288 457 4 is be VBZ 40288 457 5 assumed assume VBN 40288 457 6 as as IN 40288 457 7 matter matter NN 40288 457 8 of of IN 40288 457 9 common common JJ 40288 457 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40288 457 11 in in IN 40288 457 12 the the DT 40288 457 13 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 457 14 _ _ NNP 40288 457 15 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 457 16 _ _ NNP 40288 457 17 and and CC 40288 457 18 the the DT 40288 457 19 _ _ NNP 40288 457 20 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 457 21 _ _ NNP 40288 457 22 of of IN 40288 457 23 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 457 24 consists consist VBZ 40288 457 25 of of IN 40288 457 26 eight eight CD 40288 457 27 notes note NNS 40288 457 28 , , , 40288 457 29 named name VBN 40288 457 30 as as IN 40288 457 31 follows follow VBZ 40288 457 32 from from IN 40288 457 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 457 34 place place NN 40288 457 35 on on IN 40288 457 36 the the DT 40288 457 37 lyre lyre NN 40288 457 38 : : . 40288 457 39 Nêtê nêtê JJ 40288 457 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 457 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 457 42 Greek Greek NNP 40288 457 43 : : : 40288 457 44 neatê neatê NN 40288 457 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 457 46 or or CC 40288 457 47 [ [ -LRB- 40288 457 48 Greek greek JJ 40288 457 49 : : : 40288 457 50 nêtê nêtê JJ 40288 457 51 ] ] -RRB- 40288 457 52 , , , 40288 457 53 lit light VBD 40288 457 54 . . . 40288 458 1 ' ' `` 40288 458 2 lowest low JJS 40288 458 3 , , , 40288 458 4 ' ' '' 40288 458 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 458 6 ' ' `` 40288 458 7 highest high JJS 40288 458 8 ' ' '' 40288 458 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 458 10 . . . 40288 459 1 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 459 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 459 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 459 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 459 5 : : : 40288 459 6 paranêtê paranêtê JJ 40288 459 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 459 8 , , , 40288 459 9 ' ' '' 40288 459 10 next next RB 40288 459 11 to to IN 40288 459 12 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 459 13 ' ' '' 40288 459 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 459 15 . . . 40288 460 1 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 460 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 460 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 460 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 460 5 : : : 40288 460 6 tritê tritê JJ 40288 460 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 460 8 , , , 40288 460 9 _ _ NNP 40288 460 10 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 460 11 _ _ NNP 40288 460 12 ' ' `` 40288 460 13 third third JJ 40288 460 14 ' ' '' 40288 460 15 string string NN 40288 460 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 460 17 . . . 40288 461 1 Paramesê Paramesê NNS 40288 461 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 461 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 461 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 461 5 : : : 40288 461 6 paramesê paramesê NNS 40288 461 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 461 8 or or CC 40288 461 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 461 10 Greek greek JJ 40288 461 11 : : : 40288 461 12 paramesos paramesos NN 40288 461 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 461 14 , , , 40288 461 15 ' ' '' 40288 461 16 next next RB 40288 461 17 to to IN 40288 461 18 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 461 19 ' ' POS 40288 461 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 461 21 . . . 40288 462 1 Mesê Mesê NNS 40288 462 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 462 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 462 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 462 5 : : : 40288 462 6 mesê mesê NNS 40288 462 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 462 8 , , , 40288 462 9 ' ' `` 40288 462 10 middle middle JJ 40288 462 11 string string NN 40288 462 12 ' ' '' 40288 462 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 462 14 . . . 40288 463 1 Lichanos lichano NNS 40288 463 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 463 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 463 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 463 5 : : : 40288 463 6 lichanos lichanos LS 40288 463 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 463 8 , , , 40288 463 9 _ _ NNP 40288 463 10 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 463 11 _ _ NNP 40288 463 12 ' ' `` 40288 463 13 forefinger forefinger NN 40288 463 14 ' ' '' 40288 463 15 string string NN 40288 463 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 463 17 . . . 40288 464 1 Parhypatê parhypatê NN 40288 464 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 464 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 464 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 464 5 : : : 40288 464 6 parypatê parypatê NN 40288 464 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 464 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 464 9 . . . 40288 465 1 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 465 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 465 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 465 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 465 5 : : : 40288 465 6 hypatê hypatê NNP 40288 465 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 465 8 , , , 40288 465 9 lit light VBD 40288 465 10 . . . 40288 466 1 ' ' `` 40288 466 2 uppermost uppermost NNS 40288 466 3 , , , 40288 466 4 ' ' '' 40288 466 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 466 6 ' ' `` 40288 466 7 lowest low JJS 40288 466 8 ' ' '' 40288 466 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 466 10 . . . 40288 467 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 467 2 will will MD 40288 467 3 be be VB 40288 467 4 seen see VBN 40288 467 5 that that IN 40288 467 6 the the DT 40288 467 7 conventional conventional JJ 40288 467 8 sense sense NN 40288 467 9 of of IN 40288 467 10 high high JJ 40288 467 11 and and CC 40288 467 12 low low JJ 40288 467 13 in in IN 40288 467 14 the the DT 40288 467 15 words word NNS 40288 467 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 467 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 467 18 : : : 40288 467 19 hypatê hypatê NNP 40288 467 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 467 21 and and CC 40288 467 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 467 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 467 24 : : : 40288 467 25 neatê neatê NN 40288 467 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 467 27 was be VBD 40288 467 28 the the DT 40288 467 29 reverse reverse NN 40288 467 30 of of IN 40288 467 31 the the DT 40288 467 32 modern modern JJ 40288 467 33 usage usage NN 40288 467 34 . . . 40288 468 1 The the DT 40288 468 2 musical musical JJ 40288 468 3 scale scale NN 40288 468 4 formed form VBN 40288 468 5 by by IN 40288 468 6 these these DT 40288 468 7 eight eight CD 40288 468 8 notes note NNS 40288 468 9 consists consist VBZ 40288 468 10 of of IN 40288 468 11 two two CD 40288 468 12 _ _ NNP 40288 468 13 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 468 14 _ _ NNP 40288 468 15 or or CC 40288 468 16 scales scale NNS 40288 468 17 of of IN 40288 468 18 four four CD 40288 468 19 notes note NNS 40288 468 20 , , , 40288 468 21 and and CC 40288 468 22 a a DT 40288 468 23 major major JJ 40288 468 24 tone tone NN 40288 468 25 . . . 40288 469 1 The the DT 40288 469 2 lower low JJR 40288 469 3 of of IN 40288 469 4 the the DT 40288 469 5 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 469 6 consists consist VBZ 40288 469 7 of of IN 40288 469 8 the the DT 40288 469 9 notes note NNS 40288 469 10 from from IN 40288 469 11 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 469 12 to to IN 40288 469 13 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 469 14 , , , 40288 469 15 the the DT 40288 469 16 higher high JJR 40288 469 17 of of IN 40288 469 18 those those DT 40288 469 19 from from IN 40288 469 20 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 469 21 to to IN 40288 469 22 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 469 23 : : : 40288 469 24 the the DT 40288 469 25 interval interval NN 40288 469 26 between between IN 40288 469 27 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 469 28 and and CC 40288 469 29 Paramesê Paramesê NNPS 40288 469 30 being be VBG 40288 469 31 the the DT 40288 469 32 so so RB 40288 469 33 - - HYPH 40288 469 34 called call VBN 40288 469 35 _ _ NNP 40288 469 36 Disjunctive Disjunctive NNP 40288 469 37 Tone Tone NNP 40288 469 38 _ _ NNP 40288 469 39 ( ( -LRB- 40288 469 40 [ [ -LRB- 40288 469 41 Greek Greek NNP 40288 469 42 : : : 40288 469 43 tonos tonos NN 40288 469 44 diazeuktikos diazeuktikos NN 40288 469 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 469 46 ) ) -RRB- 40288 469 47 . . . 40288 470 1 Within within IN 40288 470 2 each each DT 40288 470 3 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 470 4 the the DT 40288 470 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 470 6 depend depend VBP 40288 470 7 upon upon IN 40288 470 8 the the DT 40288 470 9 _ _ NNP 40288 470 10 Genus Genus NNP 40288 470 11 _ _ NNP 40288 470 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 470 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 470 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 470 15 : : : 40288 470 16 genos genos NNP 40288 470 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 470 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 470 19 . . . 40288 471 1 Thus thus RB 40288 471 2 the the DT 40288 471 3 four four CD 40288 471 4 notes note NNS 40288 471 5 just just RB 40288 471 6 mentioned mention VBN 40288 471 7 -- -- : 40288 471 8 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 471 9 , , , 40288 471 10 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 471 11 , , , 40288 471 12 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 471 13 , , , 40288 471 14 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 471 15 -- -- : 40288 471 16 are be VBP 40288 471 17 the the DT 40288 471 18 same same JJ 40288 471 19 for for IN 40288 471 20 every every DT 40288 471 21 genus genus NN 40288 471 22 , , , 40288 471 23 and and CC 40288 471 24 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 471 25 are be VBP 40288 471 26 called call VBN 40288 471 27 the the DT 40288 471 28 ' ' `` 40288 471 29 standing standing NN 40288 471 30 ' ' '' 40288 471 31 or or CC 40288 471 32 ' ' `` 40288 471 33 immoveable immoveable JJ 40288 471 34 ' ' '' 40288 471 35 notes note NNS 40288 471 36 ( ( -LRB- 40288 471 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 471 38 Greek Greek NNP 40288 471 39 : : : 40288 471 40 phthongoi phthongoi NN 40288 471 41 hestôtes hestôte NNS 40288 471 42 , , , 40288 471 43 akinêtoi akinêtoi NNP 40288 471 44 ] ] -RRB- 40288 471 45 ) ) -RRB- 40288 471 46 , , , 40288 471 47 while while IN 40288 471 48 the the DT 40288 471 49 others other NNS 40288 471 50 vary vary VBP 40288 471 51 with with IN 40288 471 52 the the DT 40288 471 53 genus genus NN 40288 471 54 , , , 40288 471 55 and and CC 40288 471 56 are be VBP 40288 471 57 therefore therefore RB 40288 471 58 ' ' `` 40288 471 59 moveable moveable JJ 40288 471 60 ' ' '' 40288 471 61 ( ( -LRB- 40288 471 62 [ [ -LRB- 40288 471 63 Greek Greek NNP 40288 471 64 : : : 40288 471 65 pheromenoi pheromenoi NN 40288 471 66 ] ] -RRB- 40288 471 67 ) ) -RRB- 40288 471 68 . . . 40288 472 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 472 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 472 3 1 1 CD 40288 472 4 : : : 40288 472 5 This this DT 40288 472 6 is be VBZ 40288 472 7 especially especially RB 40288 472 8 evident evident JJ 40288 472 9 in in IN 40288 472 10 the the DT 40288 472 11 case case NN 40288 472 12 of of IN 40288 472 13 the the DT 40288 472 14 Lichanos Lichanos NNPS 40288 472 15 ; ; : 40288 472 16 as as IN 40288 472 17 was be VBD 40288 472 18 observed observe VBN 40288 472 19 by by IN 40288 472 20 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 472 21 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 472 22 , , , 40288 472 23 who who WP 40288 472 24 says say VBZ 40288 472 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 472 26 p. p. NN 40288 472 27 10 10 CD 40288 472 28 Meib Meib NNP 40288 472 29 . . . 40288 473 1 ): ): NNP 40288 473 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 473 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 473 4 : : : 40288 473 5 hai hai NNP 40288 473 6 kai kai NNP 40288 473 7 tô tô NNP 40288 473 8 genei genei NNP 40288 473 9 lichanoi lichanoi NNP 40288 473 10 prosêgoreuthêsan prosêgoreuthêsan NNP 40288 473 11 , , , 40288 473 12 homônymôs homônymôs NNP 40288 473 13 tô tô NNP 40288 473 14 plêttonti plêttonti NNP 40288 473 15 daktylô daktylô NNP 40288 473 16 tên tên NNP 40288 473 17 êchousan êchousan NNP 40288 473 18 autas autas NNP 40288 473 19 chordên chordên NNP 40288 473 20 onomastheisai onomastheisai NNP 40288 473 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 473 22 . . . 40288 474 1 But but CC 40288 474 2 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 474 3 also also RB 40288 474 4 is be VBZ 40288 474 5 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 474 6 originally originally RB 40288 474 7 the the DT 40288 474 8 ' ' `` 40288 474 9 third third JJ 40288 474 10 string string NN 40288 474 11 ' ' '' 40288 474 12 rather rather RB 40288 474 13 than than IN 40288 474 14 the the DT 40288 474 15 ' ' `` 40288 474 16 third third JJ 40288 474 17 note note NN 40288 474 18 . . . 40288 474 19 ' ' '' 40288 474 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 475 1 In in IN 40288 475 2 the the DT 40288 475 3 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 475 4 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 475 5 genus genus NN 40288 475 6 the the DT 40288 475 7 intervals interval NNS 40288 475 8 of of IN 40288 475 9 the the DT 40288 475 10 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 475 11 are be VBP 40288 475 12 , , , 40288 475 13 in in IN 40288 475 14 the the DT 40288 475 15 ascending ascend VBG 40288 475 16 order order NN 40288 475 17 , , , 40288 475 18 semitone semitone NN 40288 475 19 + + CC 40288 475 20 tone tone NN 40288 475 21 + + CC 40288 475 22 tone tone NN 40288 475 23 : : : 40288 475 24 _ _ NNP 40288 475 25 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 475 26 _ _ NNP 40288 475 27 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 475 28 is be VBZ 40288 475 29 a a DT 40288 475 30 semitone semitone NN 40288 475 31 above above IN 40288 475 32 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 475 33 , , , 40288 475 34 and and CC 40288 475 35 Lichanos lichanos VB 40288 475 36 a a DT 40288 475 37 tone tone NN 40288 475 38 above above IN 40288 475 39 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 475 40 . . . 40288 476 1 In in IN 40288 476 2 the the DT 40288 476 3 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 476 4 genus genus NN 40288 476 5 the the DT 40288 476 6 intervals interval NNS 40288 476 7 are be VBP 40288 476 8 two two CD 40288 476 9 successive successive JJ 40288 476 10 quarter quarter NN 40288 476 11 - - HYPH 40288 476 12 tones tone NNS 40288 476 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 476 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 476 15 Greek greek JJ 40288 476 16 : : : 40288 476 17 diesis diesis NN 40288 476 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 476 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 476 20 followed follow VBN 40288 476 21 by by IN 40288 476 22 a a DT 40288 476 23 ditone ditone NN 40288 476 24 or or CC 40288 476 25 major major JJ 40288 476 26 Third third JJ 40288 476 27 : : : 40288 476 28 consequently consequently RB 40288 476 29 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 476 30 is be VBZ 40288 476 31 only only RB 40288 476 32 a a DT 40288 476 33 quarter quarter NN 40288 476 34 of of IN 40288 476 35 a a DT 40288 476 36 tone tone NN 40288 476 37 above above IN 40288 476 38 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 476 39 , , , 40288 476 40 and and CC 40288 476 41 Lichanos lichanos VB 40288 476 42 again again RB 40288 476 43 a a DT 40288 476 44 quarter quarter NN 40288 476 45 of of IN 40288 476 46 a a DT 40288 476 47 tone tone NN 40288 476 48 above above IN 40288 476 49 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 476 50 . . . 40288 477 1 The the DT 40288 477 2 group group NN 40288 477 3 of of IN 40288 477 4 three three CD 40288 477 5 notes note NNS 40288 477 6 separated separate VBN 40288 477 7 in in IN 40288 477 8 this this DT 40288 477 9 way way NN 40288 477 10 by by IN 40288 477 11 small small JJ 40288 477 12 intervals interval NNS 40288 477 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 477 14 viz viz NN 40288 477 15 . . . 40288 478 1 two two CD 40288 478 2 successive successive JJ 40288 478 3 quarter quarter NN 40288 478 4 - - HYPH 40288 478 5 tones tone NNS 40288 478 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 478 7 is be VBZ 40288 478 8 called call VBN 40288 478 9 a a DT 40288 478 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 478 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 478 12 : : : 40288 478 13 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 478 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 478 15 . . . 40288 479 1 If if IN 40288 479 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 479 3 use use VBP 40288 479 4 an an DT 40288 479 5 asterisk asterisk NN 40288 479 6 to to TO 40288 479 7 denote denote VB 40288 479 8 that that IN 40288 479 9 a a DT 40288 479 10 note note NN 40288 479 11 is be VBZ 40288 479 12 raised raise VBN 40288 479 13 a a DT 40288 479 14 quarter quarter NN 40288 479 15 of of IN 40288 479 16 a a DT 40288 479 17 tone tone NN 40288 479 18 , , , 40288 479 19 these these DT 40288 479 20 two two CD 40288 479 21 scales scale NNS 40288 479 22 may may MD 40288 479 23 be be VB 40288 479 24 represented represent VBN 40288 479 25 in in IN 40288 479 26 modern modern JJ 40288 479 27 notation notation NN 40288 479 28 as as IN 40288 479 29 follows follow VBZ 40288 479 30 : : : 40288 479 31 _ _ NNP 40288 479 32 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 479 33 . . . 40288 479 34 _ _ NNP 40288 479 35 _ _ NNP 40288 479 36 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 479 37 . . . 40288 479 38 _ _ NNP 40288 479 39 e e NNP 40288 479 40 = = SYM 40288 479 41 Nêtê= nêtê= NN 40288 479 42 \ \ NNP 40288 479 43 e e NNP 40288 479 44 = = SYM 40288 479 45 Nêtê= nêtê= CD 40288 479 46 \ \ NNP 40288 479 47 d d NNP 40288 479 48 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 479 49 } } -RRB- 40288 479 50 ( ( -LRB- 40288 479 51 c c NNP 40288 479 52 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 479 53 } } -RRB- 40288 479 54 c c NNP 40288 479 55 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 479 56 } } -RRB- 40288 479 57 + + ADD 40288 479 58 --- --- : 40288 479 59 ( ( -LRB- 40288 479 60 b b LS 40288 479 61 * * NFP 40288 479 62 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 479 63 } } -RRB- 40288 479 64 b b NN 40288 479 65 = = SYM 40288 479 66 Paramesê= paramesê= NN 40288 479 67 / / SYM 40288 479 68 | | NNS 40288 479 69 ( ( -LRB- 40288 479 70 b b NN 40288 479 71 = = SYM 40288 479 72 Paramesê= paramesê= NN 40288 479 73 / / SYM 40288 479 74 a a NN 40288 479 75 = = SYM 40288 479 76 Mesê= mesê= CD 40288 479 77 \ \ NN 40288 479 78 | | NNP 40288 479 79 a a NN 40288 479 80 = = SYM 40288 479 81 Mesê= mesê= NN 40288 479 82 \ \ NN 40288 479 83 g g NN 40288 479 84 Lichanos lichanos JJ 40288 479 85 } } -RRB- 40288 479 86 | | NN 40288 479 87 ( ( -LRB- 40288 479 88 f f NN 40288 479 89 Lichanos lichanos NN 40288 479 90 } } -RRB- 40288 479 91 f f NNP 40288 479 92 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 479 93 } } -RRB- 40288 479 94 | | NNP 40288 479 95 + + SYM 40288 479 96 - - HYPH 40288 479 97 ( ( -LRB- 40288 479 98 e e LS 40288 479 99 * * NFP 40288 479 100 Parhypatê parhypatê NN 40288 479 101 } } -RRB- 40288 479 102 e e NNP 40288 479 103 = = SYM 40288 479 104 Hypatê= Hypatê= NNS 40288 479 105 / / SYM 40288 479 106 | | CD 40288 479 107 | | NNS 40288 479 108 ( ( -LRB- 40288 479 109 e e NNP 40288 479 110 = = SYM 40288 479 111 Hypatê= Hypatê= NNP 40288 479 112 / / SYM 40288 479 113 | | CD 40288 479 114 | | CD 40288 479 115 [ [ -LRB- 40288 479 116 Greek Greek NNP 40288 479 117 : : : 40288 479 118 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 479 119 ] ] -RRB- 40288 479 120 [ [ -LRB- 40288 479 121 Greek Greek NNP 40288 479 122 : : : 40288 479 123 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 479 124 ] ] -RRB- 40288 479 125 In in IN 40288 479 126 the the DT 40288 479 127 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 479 128 genus genus NN 40288 479 129 and and CC 40288 479 130 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 479 131 varieties variety NNS 40288 479 132 the the DT 40288 479 133 division division NN 40288 479 134 is be VBZ 40288 479 135 of of IN 40288 479 136 an an DT 40288 479 137 intermediate intermediate JJ 40288 479 138 kind kind NN 40288 479 139 . . . 40288 480 1 The the DT 40288 480 2 interval interval NN 40288 480 3 between between IN 40288 480 4 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 480 5 and and CC 40288 480 6 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 480 7 is be VBZ 40288 480 8 more more JJR 40288 480 9 than than IN 40288 480 10 one one CD 40288 480 11 tone tone NN 40288 480 12 , , , 40288 480 13 but but CC 40288 480 14 less less JJR 40288 480 15 than than IN 40288 480 16 two two CD 40288 480 17 : : : 40288 480 18 and and CC 40288 480 19 the the DT 40288 480 20 two two CD 40288 480 21 other other JJ 40288 480 22 intervals interval NNS 40288 480 23 , , , 40288 480 24 as as IN 40288 480 25 in in IN 40288 480 26 the the DT 40288 480 27 enharmonic enharmonic NN 40288 480 28 , , , 40288 480 29 are be VBP 40288 480 30 equal equal JJ 40288 480 31 . . . 40288 481 1 The the DT 40288 481 2 most most RBS 40288 481 3 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 481 4 feature feature NN 40288 481 5 of of IN 40288 481 6 this this DT 40288 481 7 scale scale NN 40288 481 8 , , , 40288 481 9 in in IN 40288 481 10 contrast contrast NN 40288 481 11 to to IN 40288 481 12 those those DT 40288 481 13 of of IN 40288 481 14 the the DT 40288 481 15 modern modern JJ 40288 481 16 Major Major NNP 40288 481 17 and and CC 40288 481 18 Minor Minor NNP 40288 481 19 , , , 40288 481 20 is be VBZ 40288 481 21 the the DT 40288 481 22 place place NN 40288 481 23 of of IN 40288 481 24 the the DT 40288 481 25 small small JJ 40288 481 26 intervals interval NNS 40288 481 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 481 28 semitone semitone NN 40288 481 29 or or CC 40288 481 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 481 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 481 32 : : : 40288 481 33 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 481 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 481 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 481 36 , , , 40288 481 37 which which WDT 40288 481 38 are be VBP 40288 481 39 always always RB 40288 481 40 the the DT 40288 481 41 lowest low JJS 40288 481 42 intervals interval NNS 40288 481 43 of of IN 40288 481 44 a a DT 40288 481 45 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 481 46 . . . 40288 482 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 482 2 is be VBZ 40288 482 3 hardly hardly RB 40288 482 4 necessary necessary JJ 40288 482 5 to to TO 40288 482 6 quote quote VB 40288 482 7 passages passage NNS 40288 482 8 from from IN 40288 482 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 482 10 and and CC 40288 482 11 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 482 12 to to TO 40288 482 13 show show VB 40288 482 14 that that IN 40288 482 15 this this DT 40288 482 16 is be VBZ 40288 482 17 the the DT 40288 482 18 succession succession NN 40288 482 19 of of IN 40288 482 20 intervals interval NNS 40288 482 21 assumed assume VBN 40288 482 22 by by IN 40288 482 23 them -PRON- PRP 40288 482 24 . . . 40288 483 1 The the DT 40288 483 2 question question NN 40288 483 3 is be VBZ 40288 483 4 asked ask VBN 40288 483 5 in in IN 40288 483 6 the the DT 40288 483 7 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 483 8 _ _ NNP 40288 483 9 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 483 10 _ _ NNP 40288 483 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 483 12 xix xix NNP 40288 483 13 . . . 40288 484 1 4 4 LS 40288 484 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 484 3 , , , 40288 484 4 why why WRB 40288 484 5 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 484 6 is be VBZ 40288 484 7 difficult difficult JJ 40288 484 8 to to TO 40288 484 9 sing sing VB 40288 484 10 , , , 40288 484 11 while while IN 40288 484 12 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 484 13 is be VBZ 40288 484 14 easy easy JJ 40288 484 15 , , , 40288 484 16 although although IN 40288 484 17 there there EX 40288 484 18 is be VBZ 40288 484 19 only only RB 40288 484 20 a a DT 40288 484 21 diesis diesis NN 40288 484 22 between between IN 40288 484 23 them -PRON- PRP 40288 484 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 484 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 484 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 484 27 : : : 40288 484 28 kaitoi kaitoi NNP 40288 484 29 diesis diesis NNP 40288 484 30 hekateras hekateras NNP 40288 484 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 484 32 ) ) -RRB- 40288 484 33 . . . 40288 485 1 Again again RB 40288 485 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 485 3 _ _ NNP 40288 485 4 Probl Probl NNP 40288 485 5 . . . 40288 485 6 _ _ NNP 40288 485 7 xix xix NNP 40288 485 8 . . . 40288 486 1 47 47 CD 40288 486 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 486 3 , , , 40288 486 4 speaking speak VBG 40288 486 5 of of IN 40288 486 6 the the DT 40288 486 7 old old JJ 40288 486 8 heptachord heptachord NN 40288 486 9 scale scale NN 40288 486 10 , , , 40288 486 11 the the DT 40288 486 12 writer writer NN 40288 486 13 says say VBZ 40288 486 14 that that IN 40288 486 15 the the DT 40288 486 16 Paramesê Paramesê NNPS 40288 486 17 was be VBD 40288 486 18 left leave VBN 40288 486 19 out out RP 40288 486 20 , , , 40288 486 21 and and CC 40288 486 22 consequently consequently RB 40288 486 23 the the DT 40288 486 24 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 486 25 became become VBD 40288 486 26 the the DT 40288 486 27 lowest low JJS 40288 486 28 note note NN 40288 486 29 of of IN 40288 486 30 the the DT 40288 486 31 upper upper JJ 40288 486 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 486 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 486 34 : : : 40288 486 35 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 486 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 486 37 , , , 40288 486 38 _ _ NNP 40288 486 39 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 486 40 _ _ NNP 40288 486 41 the the DT 40288 486 42 group group NN 40288 486 43 of of IN 40288 486 44 ' ' `` 40288 486 45 close close JJ 40288 486 46 ' ' '' 40288 486 47 notes note NNS 40288 486 48 consisting consist VBG 40288 486 49 of of IN 40288 486 50 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 486 51 , , , 40288 486 52 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 486 53 , , , 40288 486 54 and and CC 40288 486 55 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 486 56 . . . 40288 487 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 487 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 487 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 487 4 _ _ NNP 40288 487 5 Harm Harm NNP 40288 487 6 . . . 40288 487 7 _ _ NNP 40288 487 8 p. p. NN 40288 487 9 23 23 CD 40288 487 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 487 11 observes observe VBZ 40288 487 12 that that IN 40288 487 13 the the DT 40288 487 14 ' ' `` 40288 487 15 space space NN 40288 487 16 ' ' '' 40288 487 17 of of IN 40288 487 18 the the DT 40288 487 19 Lichanos Lichanos NNPS 40288 487 20 , , , 40288 487 21 _ _ NNP 40288 487 22 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 487 23 _ _ NNP 40288 487 24 the the DT 40288 487 25 limit limit NN 40288 487 26 within within IN 40288 487 27 which which WDT 40288 487 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 487 29 varies vary VBZ 40288 487 30 in in IN 40288 487 31 the the DT 40288 487 32 different different JJ 40288 487 33 genera genera NN 40288 487 34 , , , 40288 487 35 is be VBZ 40288 487 36 a a DT 40288 487 37 tone tone NN 40288 487 38 while while IN 40288 487 39 the the DT 40288 487 40 space space NN 40288 487 41 of of IN 40288 487 42 the the DT 40288 487 43 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 487 44 is be VBZ 40288 487 45 only only RB 40288 487 46 a a DT 40288 487 47 diesis diesis NN 40288 487 48 , , , 40288 487 49 for for IN 40288 487 50 it -PRON- PRP 40288 487 51 is be VBZ 40288 487 52 never never RB 40288 487 53 nearer nearer VB 40288 487 54 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 487 55 than than IN 40288 487 56 a a DT 40288 487 57 diesis diesis NN 40288 487 58 or or CC 40288 487 59 further further RB 40288 487 60 off off RB 40288 487 61 than than IN 40288 487 62 a a DT 40288 487 63 semitone semitone NN 40288 487 64 . . . 40288 488 1 § § ADD 40288 488 2 17 17 CD 40288 488 3 . . . 40288 489 1 _ _ NNP 40288 489 2 Earlier early RBR 40288 489 3 Heptachord Heptachord NNP 40288 489 4 Scales Scales NNP 40288 489 5 . . . 40288 489 6 _ _ NNP 40288 489 7 Regarding regard VBG 40288 489 8 the the DT 40288 489 9 earlier early JJR 40288 489 10 seven seven CD 40288 489 11 - - HYPH 40288 489 12 stringed string VBN 40288 489 13 scales scale NNS 40288 489 14 which which WDT 40288 489 15 preceded precede VBD 40288 489 16 this this DT 40288 489 17 octave octave NN 40288 489 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 489 19 information information NN 40288 489 20 is be VBZ 40288 489 21 scanty scanty NN 40288 489 22 and and CC 40288 489 23 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 489 24 obscure obscure JJ 40288 489 25 . . . 40288 490 1 The the DT 40288 490 2 chief chief JJ 40288 490 3 notice notice NN 40288 490 4 on on IN 40288 490 5 the the DT 40288 490 6 subject subject NN 40288 490 7 is be VBZ 40288 490 8 the the DT 40288 490 9 following follow VBG 40288 490 10 passage passage NN 40288 490 11 of of IN 40288 490 12 the the DT 40288 490 13 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 490 14 _ _ NNP 40288 490 15 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 490 16 _ _ NNP 40288 490 17 : : : 40288 490 18 _ _ NNP 40288 490 19 Probl Probl NNP 40288 490 20 . . . 40288 490 21 _ _ NNP 40288 490 22 xix xix NNP 40288 490 23 . . . 40288 491 1 47 47 CD 40288 491 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 491 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 491 4 : : : 40288 491 5 dia dia VB 40288 491 6 ti ti IN 40288 491 7 hoi hoi NNP 40288 491 8 archaioi archaioi NNP 40288 491 9 heptachordous heptachordous JJ 40288 491 10 poiountes poiountes NNP 40288 491 11 tas tas NNP 40288 491 12 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 491 13 tên tên NNP 40288 491 14 hypatên hypatên NNP 40288 491 15 all all DT 40288 491 16 ' ' '' 40288 491 17 ou ou NNP 40288 491 18 tên tên NNP 40288 491 19 nêtên nêtên NNP 40288 491 20 katelipon katelipon NNP 40288 491 21 : : : 40288 491 22 hê hê NNP 40288 491 23 ou ou NNP 40288 491 24 tên tên NNP 40288 491 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 491 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 491 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 491 28 : : : 40288 491 29 hypatên hypatên NN 40288 491 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 491 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 491 32 leg leg NN 40288 491 33 . . . 40288 492 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 492 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 492 3 : : : 40288 492 4 nêtên nêtên NNP 40288 492 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 492 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 492 7 , , , 40288 492 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 492 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 492 10 : : : 40288 492 11 alla alla NN 40288 492 12 tên tên NNP 40288 492 13 nyn nyn NNP 40288 492 14 paramesên paramesên NNP 40288 492 15 kaloumenên kaloumenên NNP 40288 492 16 aphêroun aphêroun NNP 40288 492 17 kai kai NNP 40288 492 18 to to IN 40288 492 19 toniaion toniaion NN 40288 492 20 diastêma diastêma NN 40288 492 21 ; ; : 40288 492 22 echrônto echrônto IN 40288 492 23 de de NNP 40288 492 24 tê tê NNP 40288 492 25 eschatê eschatê NNP 40288 492 26 mesê mesê NNP 40288 492 27 tou tou NNP 40288 492 28 epi epi NNP 40288 492 29 to to IN 40288 492 30 oxy oxy NN 40288 492 31 pyknou pyknou NN 40288 492 32 ; ; , 40288 492 33 did do VBD 40288 492 34 kai kai NNP 40288 492 35 mesên mesên NNP 40288 492 36 autên autên NNP 40288 492 37 prosêloreusan prosêloreusan NNP 40288 492 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 492 39 hê hê NNP 40288 492 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 492 41 oti oti NNP 40288 492 42 ên ên NNP 40288 492 43 tou tou NNP 40288 492 44 men men NNP 40288 492 45 anô anô VBD 40288 492 46 tetrachordon tetrachordon NNP 40288 492 47 teleutê teleutê NNP 40288 492 48 , , , 40288 492 49 tou tou NNP 40288 492 50 de de NNP 40288 492 51 katô katô NNP 40288 492 52 archê archê NNP 40288 492 53 , , , 40288 492 54 kai kai NNP 40288 492 55 meson meson NNP 40288 492 56 eiche eiche NNP 40288 492 57 logon logon NNP 40288 492 58 tonô tonô NNP 40288 492 59 tôn tôn NNP 40288 492 60 akrôn akrôn NN 40288 492 61 ? ? . 40288 492 62 ] ] -RRB- 40288 493 1 ' ' `` 40288 493 2 Why why WRB 40288 493 3 did do VBD 40288 493 4 the the DT 40288 493 5 ancient ancient JJ 40288 493 6 seven seven CD 40288 493 7 - - HYPH 40288 493 8 stringed stringed JJ 40288 493 9 scales scale NNS 40288 493 10 include include VBP 40288 493 11 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 493 12 but but CC 40288 493 13 not not RB 40288 493 14 Nêtê nêtê JJ 40288 493 15 ? ? . 40288 494 1 Or or CC 40288 494 2 should should MD 40288 494 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 494 4 say say VB 40288 494 5 that that IN 40288 494 6 the the DT 40288 494 7 note note NN 40288 494 8 omitted omit VBD 40288 494 9 was be VBD 40288 494 10 not not RB 40288 494 11 Nêtê nêtê JJ 40288 494 12 , , , 40288 494 13 but but CC 40288 494 14 the the DT 40288 494 15 present present JJ 40288 494 16 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 494 17 and and CC 40288 494 18 the the DT 40288 494 19 interval interval NN 40288 494 20 of of IN 40288 494 21 a a DT 40288 494 22 tone tone NN 40288 494 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 494 24 _ _ NNP 40288 494 25 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 494 26 _ _ NNP 40288 494 27 the the DT 40288 494 28 disjunctive disjunctive JJ 40288 494 29 tone tone NN 40288 494 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 494 31 ? ? . 40288 495 1 The the DT 40288 495 2 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 495 3 , , , 40288 495 4 then then RB 40288 495 5 , , , 40288 495 6 was be VBD 40288 495 7 the the DT 40288 495 8 lowest low JJS 40288 495 9 note note NN 40288 495 10 of of IN 40288 495 11 the the DT 40288 495 12 upper upper JJ 40288 495 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 495 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 495 15 : : : 40288 495 16 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 495 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 495 18 : : : 40288 495 19 whence whence IN 40288 495 20 the the DT 40288 495 21 name name NN 40288 495 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 495 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 495 24 : : : 40288 495 25 mesê mesê NNS 40288 495 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 495 27 , , , 40288 495 28 because because IN 40288 495 29 it -PRON- PRP 40288 495 30 was be VBD 40288 495 31 the the DT 40288 495 32 end end NN 40288 495 33 of of IN 40288 495 34 the the DT 40288 495 35 upper upper JJ 40288 495 36 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 495 37 and and CC 40288 495 38 beginning beginning NN 40288 495 39 of of IN 40288 495 40 the the DT 40288 495 41 lower low JJR 40288 495 42 one one CD 40288 495 43 , , , 40288 495 44 and and CC 40288 495 45 was be VBD 40288 495 46 in in IN 40288 495 47 pitch pitch NN 40288 495 48 the the DT 40288 495 49 middle middle NN 40288 495 50 between between IN 40288 495 51 the the DT 40288 495 52 extremes extreme NNS 40288 495 53 . . . 40288 495 54 ' ' '' 40288 496 1 This this DT 40288 496 2 clearly clearly RB 40288 496 3 implies imply VBZ 40288 496 4 two two CD 40288 496 5 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 496 6 tetrachords-- tetrachords-- CD 40288 496 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 496 8 Music music NN 40288 496 9 : : : 40288 496 10 _ _ NNP 40288 496 11 e e NNP 40288 496 12 f f NNP 40288 496 13 g g NNP 40288 496 14 a a DT 40288 496 15 a a NN 40288 496 16 # # $ 40288 496 17 c c NN 40288 496 18 d d NN 40288 496 19 _ _ NNP 40288 496 20 \---- \---- NNP 40288 496 21 /\----- /\----- NNP 40288 496 22 / / NFP 40288 496 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 496 24 In in IN 40288 496 25 another another DT 40288 496 26 place place NN 40288 496 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 496 28 _ _ NNP 40288 496 29 Probl Probl NNP 40288 496 30 . . . 40288 496 31 _ _ NNP 40288 496 32 xix xix NNP 40288 496 33 . . . 40288 497 1 32 32 LS 40288 497 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 497 3 the the DT 40288 497 4 question question NN 40288 497 5 is be VBZ 40288 497 6 asked ask VBN 40288 497 7 , , , 40288 497 8 why why WRB 40288 497 9 the the DT 40288 497 10 interval interval NN 40288 497 11 of of IN 40288 497 12 the the DT 40288 497 13 octave octave NN 40288 497 14 is be VBZ 40288 497 15 called call VBN 40288 497 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 497 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 497 18 : : : 40288 497 19 dia dia NNP 40288 497 20 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 497 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 497 22 , , , 40288 497 23 not not RB 40288 497 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 497 25 Greek greek NN 40288 497 26 : : : 40288 497 27 di di LS 40288 497 28 ' ' '' 40288 497 29 oktô],--as oktô],--as NNP 40288 497 30 the the DT 40288 497 31 Fourth fourth JJ 40288 497 32 is be VBZ 40288 497 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 497 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 497 35 : : : 40288 497 36 dia dia NNP 40288 497 37 tessarôn tessarôn NNP 40288 497 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 497 39 , , , 40288 497 40 the the DT 40288 497 41 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 497 42 [ [ -LRB- 40288 497 43 Greek Greek NNP 40288 497 44 : : : 40288 497 45 dia dia NNP 40288 497 46 pente pente NNP 40288 497 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 497 48 . . . 40288 498 1 The the DT 40288 498 2 answer answer NN 40288 498 3 suggested suggest VBD 40288 498 4 is be VBZ 40288 498 5 that that IN 40288 498 6 there there EX 40288 498 7 were be VBD 40288 498 8 anciently anciently RB 40288 498 9 seven seven CD 40288 498 10 strings string NNS 40288 498 11 , , , 40288 498 12 and and CC 40288 498 13 that that IN 40288 498 14 Terpander Terpander NNP 40288 498 15 left leave VBD 40288 498 16 out out RP 40288 498 17 the the DT 40288 498 18 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 498 19 and and CC 40288 498 20 added add VBD 40288 498 21 the the DT 40288 498 22 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 498 23 . . . 40288 499 1 That that DT 40288 499 2 is be VBZ 40288 499 3 to to TO 40288 499 4 say say VB 40288 499 5 , , , 40288 499 6 Terpander Terpander NNP 40288 499 7 increased increase VBD 40288 499 8 the the DT 40288 499 9 compass compass NN 40288 499 10 of of IN 40288 499 11 the the DT 40288 499 12 scale scale NN 40288 499 13 from from IN 40288 499 14 the the DT 40288 499 15 ancient ancient JJ 40288 499 16 two two CD 40288 499 17 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 499 18 to to IN 40288 499 19 a a DT 40288 499 20 full full JJ 40288 499 21 Octave octave NN 40288 499 22 ; ; : 40288 499 23 but but CC 40288 499 24 he -PRON- PRP 40288 499 25 did do VBD 40288 499 26 not not RB 40288 499 27 increase increase VB 40288 499 28 the the DT 40288 499 29 number number NN 40288 499 30 of of IN 40288 499 31 strings string NNS 40288 499 32 to to IN 40288 499 33 eight eight CD 40288 499 34 . . . 40288 500 1 Thus thus RB 40288 500 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 500 3 produced produce VBD 40288 500 4 a a DT 40288 500 5 scale scale NN 40288 500 6 like like IN 40288 500 7 the the DT 40288 500 8 standard standard JJ 40288 500 9 octave octave NN 40288 500 10 , , , 40288 500 11 but but CC 40288 500 12 with with IN 40288 500 13 one one CD 40288 500 14 note note NN 40288 500 15 wanting want VBG 40288 500 16 ; ; : 40288 500 17 so so IN 40288 500 18 that that IN 40288 500 19 the the DT 40288 500 20 term term NN 40288 500 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 500 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 500 23 : : : 40288 500 24 di di NNP 40288 500 25 oktô oktô NN 40288 500 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 500 27 was be VBD 40288 500 28 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 40288 500 29 . . . 40288 501 1 Among among IN 40288 501 2 later later JJ 40288 501 3 writers writer NNS 40288 501 4 who who WP 40288 501 5 confirm confirm VBP 40288 501 6 this this DT 40288 501 7 account account NN 40288 501 8 we -PRON- PRP 40288 501 9 may may MD 40288 501 10 notice notice VB 40288 501 11 Nicomachus Nicomachus NNP 40288 501 12 , , , 40288 501 13 p. p. NN 40288 501 14 7 7 CD 40288 501 15 Meib Meib NNP 40288 501 16 . . . 40288 502 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 502 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 502 3 : : : 40288 502 4 mesê mesê NNS 40288 502 5 dia dia NNP 40288 502 6 tessarôn tessarôn NNP 40288 502 7 pros pro NNS 40288 502 8 amphotera amphotera NNP 40288 502 9 en en NNP 40288 502 10 tê tê DT 40288 502 11 heptachordô heptachordô NNS 40288 502 12 kata kata NN 40288 502 13 to to IN 40288 502 14 palaion palaion NN 40288 502 15 diestôsa diestôsa NNP 40288 502 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 502 17 : : : 40288 502 18 and and CC 40288 502 19 p. p. NN 40288 502 20 20 20 CD 40288 502 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 502 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 502 23 : : : 40288 502 24 tê tê NNP 40288 502 25 toinyn toinyn NNP 40288 502 26 archaiotropô archaiotropô NNP 40288 502 27 lyra lyra NNP 40288 502 28 toutesti toutesti NNP 40288 502 29 tê tê DT 40288 502 30 heptachordô heptachordô NNP 40288 502 31 , , , 40288 502 32 kata kata NNP 40288 502 33 synaphên synaphên NNP 40288 502 34 ek ek NNP 40288 502 35 duo duo NNP 40288 502 36 tetrachordôn tetrachordôn NNP 40288 502 37 synestôsê synestôsê NNP 40288 502 38 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 502 39 . . . 40288 502 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 503 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 503 2 appears appear VBZ 40288 503 3 then then RB 40288 503 4 that that IN 40288 503 5 two two CD 40288 503 6 kinds kind NNS 40288 503 7 of of IN 40288 503 8 seven seven CD 40288 503 9 - - HYPH 40288 503 10 stringed string VBN 40288 503 11 scales scale NNS 40288 503 12 were be VBD 40288 503 13 known know VBN 40288 503 14 , , , 40288 503 15 at at IN 40288 503 16 least least JJS 40288 503 17 by by IN 40288 503 18 tradition tradition NN 40288 503 19 : : : 40288 503 20 viz viz NN 40288 503 21 . . . 40288 504 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 504 2 1 1 LS 40288 504 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 504 4 a a DT 40288 504 5 scale scale NN 40288 504 6 composed compose VBN 40288 504 7 of of IN 40288 504 8 two two CD 40288 504 9 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 504 10 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 504 11 , , , 40288 504 12 and and CC 40288 504 13 therefore therefore RB 40288 504 14 of of IN 40288 504 15 a a DT 40288 504 16 compass compass NN 40288 504 17 less less JJR 40288 504 18 than than IN 40288 504 19 an an DT 40288 504 20 octave octave NN 40288 504 21 by by IN 40288 504 22 one one CD 40288 504 23 tone tone NN 40288 504 24 ; ; : 40288 504 25 and and CC 40288 504 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 504 27 2 2 LS 40288 504 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 504 29 a a DT 40288 504 30 scale scale NN 40288 504 31 of of IN 40288 504 32 the the DT 40288 504 33 compass compass NN 40288 504 34 of of IN 40288 504 35 an an DT 40288 504 36 octave octave NN 40288 504 37 , , , 40288 504 38 but but CC 40288 504 39 wanting want VBG 40288 504 40 a a DT 40288 504 41 note note NN 40288 504 42 , , , 40288 504 43 viz viz NN 40288 504 44 . . . 40288 505 1 the the DT 40288 505 2 note note NN 40288 505 3 above above IN 40288 505 4 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 505 5 . . . 40288 506 1 The the DT 40288 506 2 existence existence NN 40288 506 3 of of IN 40288 506 4 this this DT 40288 506 5 incomplete incomplete JJ 40288 506 6 scale scale NN 40288 506 7 is be VBZ 40288 506 8 interesting interesting JJ 40288 506 9 as as IN 40288 506 10 a a DT 40288 506 11 testimony testimony NN 40288 506 12 to to IN 40288 506 13 the the DT 40288 506 14 force force NN 40288 506 15 of of IN 40288 506 16 the the DT 40288 506 17 tradition tradition NN 40288 506 18 which which WDT 40288 506 19 limited limit VBD 40288 506 20 the the DT 40288 506 21 number number NN 40288 506 22 of of IN 40288 506 23 strings string NNS 40288 506 24 to to IN 40288 506 25 seven seven CD 40288 506 26 . . . 40288 507 1 § § ADD 40288 507 2 18 18 CD 40288 507 3 . . . 40288 508 1 _ _ NNP 40288 508 2 The the DT 40288 508 3 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 508 4 System System NNP 40288 508 5 . . . 40288 508 6 _ _ NNP 40288 508 7 The the DT 40288 508 8 term term NN 40288 508 9 ' ' `` 40288 508 10 Perfect perfect JJ 40288 508 11 System system NN 40288 508 12 ' ' '' 40288 508 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 508 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 508 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 508 16 : : : 40288 508 17 systêma systêma NN 40288 508 18 teleion teleion NN 40288 508 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 508 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 508 21 is be VBZ 40288 508 22 applied apply VBN 40288 508 23 by by IN 40288 508 24 the the DT 40288 508 25 technical technical JJ 40288 508 26 writers writer NNS 40288 508 27 to to IN 40288 508 28 a a DT 40288 508 29 scale scale NN 40288 508 30 which which WDT 40288 508 31 is be VBZ 40288 508 32 evidently evidently RB 40288 508 33 formed form VBN 40288 508 34 by by IN 40288 508 35 successive successive JJ 40288 508 36 additions addition NNS 40288 508 37 to to IN 40288 508 38 the the DT 40288 508 39 heptachord heptachord NNP 40288 508 40 and and CC 40288 508 41 octachord octachord NNP 40288 508 42 scales scales NNP 40288 508 43 explained explain VBN 40288 508 44 in in IN 40288 508 45 the the DT 40288 508 46 preceding precede VBG 40288 508 47 chapter chapter NN 40288 508 48 . . . 40288 509 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 509 2 may may MD 40288 509 3 be be VB 40288 509 4 described describe VBN 40288 509 5 as as IN 40288 509 6 a a DT 40288 509 7 combination combination NN 40288 509 8 of of IN 40288 509 9 two two CD 40288 509 10 scales scale NNS 40288 509 11 , , , 40288 509 12 called call VBN 40288 509 13 the the DT 40288 509 14 Greater Greater NNP 40288 509 15 and and CC 40288 509 16 Lesser Lesser NNP 40288 509 17 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 509 18 System System NNP 40288 509 19 . . . 40288 510 1 The the DT 40288 510 2 Greater Greater NNP 40288 510 3 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 510 4 System System NNP 40288 510 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 510 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 510 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 510 8 : : : 40288 510 9 systêma systêma NN 40288 510 10 teleion teleion NN 40288 510 11 meizon meizon NNP 40288 510 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 510 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 510 14 consists consist VBZ 40288 510 15 of of IN 40288 510 16 two two CD 40288 510 17 octaves octave NNS 40288 510 18 formed form VBN 40288 510 19 from from IN 40288 510 20 the the DT 40288 510 21 primitive primitive JJ 40288 510 22 octachord octachord NN 40288 510 23 System System NNP 40288 510 24 by by IN 40288 510 25 adding add VBG 40288 510 26 a a DT 40288 510 27 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 510 28 at at IN 40288 510 29 each each DT 40288 510 30 end end NN 40288 510 31 of of IN 40288 510 32 the the DT 40288 510 33 scale scale NN 40288 510 34 . . . 40288 511 1 The the DT 40288 511 2 new new JJ 40288 511 3 notes note NNS 40288 511 4 are be VBP 40288 511 5 named name VBN 40288 511 6 like like IN 40288 511 7 those those DT 40288 511 8 of of IN 40288 511 9 the the DT 40288 511 10 adjoining adjoining JJ 40288 511 11 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 511 12 of of IN 40288 511 13 the the DT 40288 511 14 original original JJ 40288 511 15 octave octave NN 40288 511 16 , , , 40288 511 17 but but CC 40288 511 18 with with IN 40288 511 19 the the DT 40288 511 20 name name NN 40288 511 21 of of IN 40288 511 22 the the DT 40288 511 23 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 511 24 added add VBN 40288 511 25 by by IN 40288 511 26 way way NN 40288 511 27 of of IN 40288 511 28 distinction distinction NN 40288 511 29 . . . 40288 512 1 Thus thus RB 40288 512 2 below below IN 40288 512 3 the the DT 40288 512 4 original original JJ 40288 512 5 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 512 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 512 7 have have VBP 40288 512 8 a a DT 40288 512 9 new new JJ 40288 512 10 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 512 11 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 512 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 512 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 512 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 512 15 : : : 40288 512 16 tetrachordon tetrachordon NNP 40288 512 17 hypatôn hypatôn NNP 40288 512 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 512 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 512 20 , , , 40288 512 21 the the DT 40288 512 22 notes note NNS 40288 512 23 of of IN 40288 512 24 which which WDT 40288 512 25 are be VBP 40288 512 26 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 512 27 called call VBN 40288 512 28 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 512 29 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 512 30 , , , 40288 512 31 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 512 32 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 512 33 , , , 40288 512 34 and and CC 40288 512 35 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 512 36 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 512 37 : : : 40288 512 38 and and CC 40288 512 39 similarly similarly RB 40288 512 40 above above IN 40288 512 41 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 512 42 we -PRON- PRP 40288 512 43 have have VBP 40288 512 44 a a DT 40288 512 45 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 512 46 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 512 47 . . . 40288 513 1 Finally finally RB 40288 513 2 the the DT 40288 513 3 octave octave NN 40288 513 4 downwards downwards RB 40288 513 5 from from IN 40288 513 6 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 513 7 is be VBZ 40288 513 8 completed complete VBN 40288 513 9 by by IN 40288 513 10 the the DT 40288 513 11 addition addition NN 40288 513 12 of of IN 40288 513 13 a a DT 40288 513 14 note note NN 40288 513 15 appropriately appropriately RB 40288 513 16 called call VBN 40288 513 17 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 513 18 . . . 40288 514 1 The the DT 40288 514 2 Lesser Lesser NNP 40288 514 3 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 514 4 System system NN 40288 514 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 514 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 514 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 514 8 : : : 40288 514 9 systêma systêma NN 40288 514 10 teleion teleion NN 40288 514 11 elasson elasson NN 40288 514 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 514 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 514 14 is be VBZ 40288 514 15 apparently apparently RB 40288 514 16 based base VBN 40288 514 17 upon upon IN 40288 514 18 the the DT 40288 514 19 ancient ancient JJ 40288 514 20 heptachord heptachord NN 40288 514 21 which which WDT 40288 514 22 consisted consist VBD 40288 514 23 of of IN 40288 514 24 two two CD 40288 514 25 ' ' `` 40288 514 26 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 514 27 ' ' '' 40288 514 28 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 514 29 meeting meet VBG 40288 514 30 in in IN 40288 514 31 the the DT 40288 514 32 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 514 33 . . . 40288 515 1 This this DT 40288 515 2 scale scale NN 40288 515 3 was be VBD 40288 515 4 extended extend VBN 40288 515 5 downwards downwards RB 40288 515 6 in in IN 40288 515 7 the the DT 40288 515 8 same same JJ 40288 515 9 way way NN 40288 515 10 as as IN 40288 515 11 the the DT 40288 515 12 Greater Greater NNP 40288 515 13 System System NNP 40288 515 14 , , , 40288 515 15 and and CC 40288 515 16 thus thus RB 40288 515 17 became become VBD 40288 515 18 a a DT 40288 515 19 scale scale NN 40288 515 20 of of IN 40288 515 21 three three CD 40288 515 22 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 515 23 and and CC 40288 515 24 a a DT 40288 515 25 tone tone NN 40288 515 26 . . . 40288 516 1 These these DT 40288 516 2 two two CD 40288 516 3 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 516 4 together together RB 40288 516 5 constitute constitute VBP 40288 516 6 the the DT 40288 516 7 Perfect perfect JJ 40288 516 8 and and CC 40288 516 9 ' ' `` 40288 516 10 unmodulating unmodulating JJ 40288 516 11 ' ' '' 40288 516 12 System system NN 40288 516 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 516 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 516 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 516 16 : : : 40288 516 17 systêma systêma NN 40288 516 18 teleion teleion NN 40288 516 19 ametabolon ametabolon NN 40288 516 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 516 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 516 22 , , , 40288 516 23 which which WDT 40288 516 24 may may MD 40288 516 25 be be VB 40288 516 26 represented represent VBN 40288 516 27 in in IN 40288 516 28 modern modern JJ 40288 516 29 notation[1 notation[1 NNP 40288 516 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 516 31 as as IN 40288 516 32 follows follow VBZ 40288 516 33 : : : 40288 516 34 a a DT 40288 516 35 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 516 36 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 516 37 \ \ NN 40288 516 38 Tetrachord Tetrachord NNP 40288 516 39 g g NNP 40288 516 40 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 516 41 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 516 42 } } -RRB- 40288 516 43 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 516 44 f f NNP 40288 516 45 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 516 46 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 516 47 / / SYM 40288 516 48 e e NNP 40288 516 49 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 516 50 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 516 51 d d NNP 40288 516 52 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 516 53 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 516 54 \ \ NNP 40288 516 55 Tetrachord Tetrachord NNP 40288 516 56 c c NNP 40288 516 57 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 516 58 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 516 59 } } -RRB- 40288 516 60 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 516 61 b b NNP 40288 516 62 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 516 63 / / SYM 40288 516 64 d d NNP 40288 516 65 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 516 66 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 516 67 \ \ NNP 40288 516 68 Tetrachord Tetrachord NNP 40288 516 69 c c NNP 40288 516 70 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 516 71 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 516 72 } } -RRB- 40288 516 73 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 516 74 b b NNP 40288 516 75 flat flat JJ 40288 516 76 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 516 77 Synêmmenôn/ Synêmmenôn/ NNS 40288 516 78 a a DT 40288 516 79 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 516 80 \ \ NN 40288 516 81 g g NNP 40288 516 82 Lichanos lichanos JJ 40288 516 83 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 516 84 } } -RRB- 40288 516 85 Tetrachord Tetrachord NNP 40288 516 86 f f NNP 40288 516 87 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 516 88 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 516 89 } } -RRB- 40288 516 90 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 516 91 e e NNP 40288 516 92 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 516 93 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 516 94 / / SYM 40288 516 95 d d NNP 40288 516 96 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 516 97 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 516 98 \ \ RB 40288 516 99 Tetrachord Tetrachord NNP 40288 516 100 c c NNP 40288 516 101 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 516 102 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 516 103 } } -RRB- 40288 516 104 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 516 105 b b NN 40288 516 106 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 516 107 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 516 108 / / SYM 40288 516 109 a a DT 40288 516 110 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 516 111 [ [ -LRB- 40288 516 112 Footnote footnote NN 40288 516 113 1 1 CD 40288 516 114 : : : 40288 516 115 The the DT 40288 516 116 correspondence correspondence NN 40288 516 117 between between IN 40288 516 118 ancient ancient JJ 40288 516 119 and and CC 40288 516 120 modern modern JJ 40288 516 121 musical musical JJ 40288 516 122 notation notation NN 40288 516 123 was be VBD 40288 516 124 first first RB 40288 516 125 determined determine VBN 40288 516 126 in in IN 40288 516 127 a a DT 40288 516 128 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40288 516 129 way way NN 40288 516 130 by by IN 40288 516 131 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 516 132 ( ( -LRB- 40288 516 133 _ _ NNP 40288 516 134 Die Die NNP 40288 516 135 Tonleitern Tonleitern NNP 40288 516 136 und und NN 40288 516 137 Musiknoten Musiknoten NNP 40288 516 138 der der NN 40288 516 139 Griechen Griechen NNP 40288 516 140 _ _ NNP 40288 516 141 ) ) -RRB- 40288 516 142 , , , 40288 516 143 and and CC 40288 516 144 Fortlage Fortlage NNP 40288 516 145 ( ( -LRB- 40288 516 146 _ _ NNP 40288 516 147 Das Das NNP 40288 516 148 musicalische musicalische NN 40288 516 149 System System NNP 40288 516 150 der der VBD 40288 516 151 Griechen Griechen NNP 40288 516 152 _ _ NNP 40288 516 153 ) ) -RRB- 40288 516 154 . . . 40288 516 155 ] ] -RRB- 40288 517 1 No no DT 40288 517 2 account account NN 40288 517 3 of of IN 40288 517 4 the the DT 40288 517 5 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 517 6 System System NNP 40288 517 7 is be VBZ 40288 517 8 given give VBN 40288 517 9 by by IN 40288 517 10 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 517 11 , , , 40288 517 12 and and CC 40288 517 13 there there EX 40288 517 14 is be VBZ 40288 517 15 no no DT 40288 517 16 trace trace NN 40288 517 17 in in IN 40288 517 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 517 19 writings writing NNS 40288 517 20 of of IN 40288 517 21 an an DT 40288 517 22 extension extension NN 40288 517 23 of of IN 40288 517 24 the the DT 40288 517 25 standard standard JJ 40288 517 26 scale scale NN 40288 517 27 beyond beyond IN 40288 517 28 the the DT 40288 517 29 limits limit NNS 40288 517 30 of of IN 40288 517 31 the the DT 40288 517 32 original original JJ 40288 517 33 octave octave NN 40288 517 34 . . . 40288 518 1 In in IN 40288 518 2 one one CD 40288 518 3 place place NN 40288 518 4 indeed indeed RB 40288 518 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 518 6 _ _ NNP 40288 518 7 Harm Harm NNP 40288 518 8 . . . 40288 518 9 _ _ NNP 40288 518 10 p. p. NN 40288 518 11 8 8 CD 40288 518 12 , , , 40288 518 13 12 12 CD 40288 518 14 Meib Meib NNP 40288 518 15 . . . 40288 518 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 519 1 Aristoxenus aristoxenus JJ 40288 519 2 promises promise NNS 40288 519 3 to to TO 40288 519 4 treat treat VB 40288 519 5 of of IN 40288 519 6 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 519 7 , , , 40288 519 8 ' ' '' 40288 519 9 and and CC 40288 519 10 among among IN 40288 519 11 them -PRON- PRP 40288 519 12 of of IN 40288 519 13 the the DT 40288 519 14 perfect perfect JJ 40288 519 15 System system NN 40288 519 16 ' ' '' 40288 519 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 519 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 519 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 519 20 : : : 40288 519 21 peri peri NNP 40288 519 22 te te NNP 40288 519 23 tôn tôn NNP 40288 519 24 allôn allôn NNP 40288 519 25 kai kai NNP 40288 519 26 tou tou NNP 40288 519 27 teleiou teleiou NNP 40288 519 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 519 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 519 30 . . . 40288 520 1 But but CC 40288 520 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 520 3 can can MD 40288 520 4 not not RB 40288 520 5 assume assume VB 40288 520 6 that that IN 40288 520 7 the the DT 40288 520 8 phrase phrase NN 40288 520 9 here here RB 40288 520 10 had have VBD 40288 520 11 the the DT 40288 520 12 technical technical JJ 40288 520 13 sense sense NN 40288 520 14 which which WDT 40288 520 15 it -PRON- PRP 40288 520 16 bore bear VBD 40288 520 17 in in RP 40288 520 18 later late JJR 40288 520 19 writers writer NNS 40288 520 20 . . . 40288 521 1 More more RBR 40288 521 2 probably probably RB 40288 521 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 521 4 meant mean VBD 40288 521 5 simply simply RB 40288 521 6 the the DT 40288 521 7 octave octave NN 40288 521 8 scale scale NN 40288 521 9 , , , 40288 521 10 in in IN 40288 521 11 contrast contrast NN 40288 521 12 to to IN 40288 521 13 the the DT 40288 521 14 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 521 15 and and CC 40288 521 16 pentachord pentachord NNP 40288 521 17 -- -- : 40288 521 18 a a DT 40288 521 19 sense sense NN 40288 521 20 in in IN 40288 521 21 which which WDT 40288 521 22 it -PRON- PRP 40288 521 23 is be VBZ 40288 521 24 used use VBN 40288 521 25 by by IN 40288 521 26 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 521 27 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 521 28 , , , 40288 521 29 p. p. NN 40288 521 30 11 11 CD 40288 521 31 Meib Meib NNP 40288 521 32 . . . 40288 522 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 522 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 522 3 : : : 40288 522 4 synêmmenôn synêmmenôn NN 40288 522 5 de de IN 40288 522 6 eklêthê eklêthê NNP 40288 522 7 to to IN 40288 522 8 holon holon NNP 40288 522 9 systêma systêma NNP 40288 522 10 hoti hoti NNP 40288 522 11 tô tô NNP 40288 522 12 prokeimenô prokeimenô NNP 40288 522 13 teleiô teleiô NNP 40288 522 14 tô tô NNP 40288 522 15 mechri mechri NNP 40288 522 16 mesês mesês NNP 40288 522 17 synêptai synêptai NNP 40288 522 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 522 19 , , , 40288 522 20 ' ' '' 40288 522 21 the the DT 40288 522 22 whole whole JJ 40288 522 23 scale scale NN 40288 522 24 was be VBD 40288 522 25 called call VBN 40288 522 26 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 522 27 because because IN 40288 522 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 522 29 is be VBZ 40288 522 30 conjoined conjoin VBN 40288 522 31 to to IN 40288 522 32 the the DT 40288 522 33 complete complete JJ 40288 522 34 scale scale NN 40288 522 35 that that WDT 40288 522 36 reaches reach VBZ 40288 522 37 up up RP 40288 522 38 to to IN 40288 522 39 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 522 40 ' ' '' 40288 522 41 ( ( -LRB- 40288 522 42 _ _ NNP 40288 522 43 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 522 44 _ _ NNP 40288 522 45 the the DT 40288 522 46 octave octave NN 40288 522 47 extending extend VBG 40288 522 48 from from IN 40288 522 49 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 522 50 to to IN 40288 522 51 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 522 52 ) ) -RRB- 40288 522 53 . . . 40288 523 1 So so CC 40288 523 2 p. p. NN 40288 523 3 16 16 CD 40288 523 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 523 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 523 6 : : : 40288 523 7 kai kai NNP 40288 523 8 ha ha NNP 40288 523 9 men man NNS 40288 523 10 autôn autôn RB 40288 523 11 esti esti NNP 40288 523 12 teleia teleia NNP 40288 523 13 , , , 40288 523 14 ha ha UH 40288 523 15 d d NNP 40288 523 16 ' ' `` 40288 523 17 ou ou NNP 40288 523 18 , , , 40288 523 19 atelê atelê NN 40288 523 20 men man NNS 40288 523 21 tetrachordon tetrachordon NNP 40288 523 22 , , , 40288 523 23 pentachordon pentachordon NNP 40288 523 24 , , , 40288 523 25 teleion teleion NN 40288 523 26 de de NNP 40288 523 27 oktachordon oktachordon NNP 40288 523 28 . . . 40288 523 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 524 1 This this DT 40288 524 2 is be VBZ 40288 524 3 a a DT 40288 524 4 use use NN 40288 524 5 of of IN 40288 524 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 524 7 Greek greek JJ 40288 524 8 : : : 40288 524 9 teleios teleio NNS 40288 524 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 524 11 which which WDT 40288 524 12 is be VBZ 40288 524 13 likely likely JJ 40288 524 14 enough enough RB 40288 524 15 to to TO 40288 524 16 have have VB 40288 524 17 come come VBN 40288 524 18 from from IN 40288 524 19 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 524 20 . . . 40288 525 1 The the DT 40288 525 2 word word NN 40288 525 3 was be VBD 40288 525 4 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 525 5 applied apply VBN 40288 525 6 in in IN 40288 525 7 each each DT 40288 525 8 period period NN 40288 525 9 to to IN 40288 525 10 the the DT 40288 525 11 most most RBS 40288 525 12 complete complete JJ 40288 525 13 scale scale NN 40288 525 14 which which WDT 40288 525 15 musical musical JJ 40288 525 16 theory theory NN 40288 525 17 had have VBD 40288 525 18 then then RB 40288 525 19 recognised recognise VBN 40288 525 20 . . . 40288 526 1 Little little JJ 40288 526 2 is be VBZ 40288 526 3 known know VBN 40288 526 4 of of IN 40288 526 5 the the DT 40288 526 6 steps step NNS 40288 526 7 by by IN 40288 526 8 which which WDT 40288 526 9 this this DT 40288 526 10 enlargement enlargement NN 40288 526 11 of of IN 40288 526 12 the the DT 40288 526 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 526 14 scale scale NN 40288 526 15 was be VBD 40288 526 16 brought bring VBN 40288 526 17 about about RP 40288 526 18 . . . 40288 527 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 527 2 shall shall MD 40288 527 3 not not RB 40288 527 4 be be VB 40288 527 5 wrong wrong JJ 40288 527 6 in in IN 40288 527 7 conjecturing conjecture VBG 40288 527 8 that that IN 40288 527 9 it -PRON- PRP 40288 527 10 was be VBD 40288 527 11 connected connect VBN 40288 527 12 with with IN 40288 527 13 the the DT 40288 527 14 advance advance NN 40288 527 15 made make VBN 40288 527 16 from from IN 40288 527 17 time time NN 40288 527 18 to to IN 40288 527 19 time time NN 40288 527 20 in in IN 40288 527 21 the the DT 40288 527 22 form form NN 40288 527 23 and and CC 40288 527 24 compass compass NN 40288 527 25 of of IN 40288 527 26 musical musical JJ 40288 527 27 instruments[1 instruments[1 NNP 40288 527 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 527 29 . . . 40288 528 1 Along along IN 40288 528 2 with with IN 40288 528 3 the the DT 40288 528 4 lyre lyre NN 40288 528 5 , , , 40288 528 6 which which WDT 40288 528 7 kept keep VBD 40288 528 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 528 9 primitive primitive JJ 40288 528 10 simplicity simplicity NN 40288 528 11 as as IN 40288 528 12 the the DT 40288 528 13 instrument instrument NN 40288 528 14 of of IN 40288 528 15 education education NN 40288 528 16 and and CC 40288 528 17 everyday everyday JJ 40288 528 18 use use NN 40288 528 19 , , , 40288 528 20 the the DT 40288 528 21 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 528 22 had have VBD 40288 528 23 the the DT 40288 528 24 cithara cithara NN 40288 528 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 528 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 528 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 528 28 : : : 40288 528 29 kithara kithara NNP 40288 528 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 528 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 528 32 , , , 40288 528 33 an an DT 40288 528 34 enlarged enlarged JJ 40288 528 35 and and CC 40288 528 36 improved improved JJ 40288 528 37 lyre lyre NN 40288 528 38 , , , 40288 528 39 which which WDT 40288 528 40 , , , 40288 528 41 to to TO 40288 528 42 judge judge VB 40288 528 43 from from IN 40288 528 44 the the DT 40288 528 45 representations representation NNS 40288 528 46 on on IN 40288 528 47 ancient ancient JJ 40288 528 48 monuments monument NNS 40288 528 49 , , , 40288 528 50 was be VBD 40288 528 51 generally generally RB 40288 528 52 seen see VBN 40288 528 53 in in IN 40288 528 54 the the DT 40288 528 55 hands hand NNS 40288 528 56 of of IN 40288 528 57 professional professional JJ 40288 528 58 players player NNS 40288 528 59 ( ( -LRB- 40288 528 60 [ [ -LRB- 40288 528 61 Greek Greek NNP 40288 528 62 : : : 40288 528 63 kitharôdoi kitharôdoi NNP 40288 528 64 ] ] -RRB- 40288 528 65 ) ) -RRB- 40288 528 66 . . . 40288 529 1 The the DT 40288 529 2 development development NN 40288 529 3 of of IN 40288 529 4 the the DT 40288 529 5 cithara cithara NNP 40288 529 6 showed show VBD 40288 529 7 itself -PRON- PRP 40288 529 8 in in IN 40288 529 9 the the DT 40288 529 10 increase increase NN 40288 529 11 , , , 40288 529 12 of of IN 40288 529 13 which which WDT 40288 529 14 we -PRON- PRP 40288 529 15 have have VBP 40288 529 16 good good JJ 40288 529 17 evidence evidence NN 40288 529 18 even even RB 40288 529 19 before before IN 40288 529 20 the the DT 40288 529 21 time time NN 40288 529 22 of of IN 40288 529 23 Plato Plato NNP 40288 529 24 , , , 40288 529 25 in in IN 40288 529 26 the the DT 40288 529 27 number number NN 40288 529 28 of of IN 40288 529 29 the the DT 40288 529 30 strings string NNS 40288 529 31 . . . 40288 530 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 530 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 530 3 1 1 CD 40288 530 4 : : : 40288 530 5 This this DT 40288 530 6 observation observation NN 40288 530 7 was be VBD 40288 530 8 made make VBN 40288 530 9 by by IN 40288 530 10 ancient ancient JJ 40288 530 11 writers writer NNS 40288 530 12 , , , 40288 530 13 _ _ NNP 40288 530 14 e.g. e.g. RB 40288 530 15 _ _ NNP 40288 530 16 by by IN 40288 530 17 Adrastus Adrastus NNP 40288 530 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 530 19 Peripatetic peripatetic JJ 40288 530 20 philosopher philosopher NN 40288 530 21 of of IN 40288 530 22 the the DT 40288 530 23 second second JJ 40288 530 24 cent cent NN 40288 530 25 . . . 40288 531 1 A.D. A.D. NNP 40288 531 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 531 3 : : : 40288 531 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 531 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 531 6 : : : 40288 531 7 epêuxêmenês epêuxêmenês NNP 40288 531 8 de de NNP 40288 531 9 tês tês NNP 40288 531 10 mousikês mousikês NNP 40288 531 11 kai kai NNP 40288 531 12 polychordôn polychordôn NNP 40288 531 13 kai kai NNP 40288 531 14 polyphthongôn polyphthongôn NNP 40288 531 15 gegonotôn gegonotôn NNP 40288 531 16 organôn organôn NNP 40288 531 17 tô tô NNP 40288 531 18 proslêphthênai proslêphthênai NNP 40288 531 19 kai kai NNP 40288 531 20 epi epi NNP 40288 531 21 to to IN 40288 531 22 bary bary NNP 40288 531 23 kai kai NNP 40288 531 24 epi epi NNP 40288 531 25 to to IN 40288 531 26 oxy oxy NNP 40288 531 27 tois tois NNP 40288 531 28 pro[:y]parchousin pro[:y]parchousin NNP 40288 531 29 oktô oktô NNP 40288 531 30 phthongois phthongois NNP 40288 531 31 allous allous JJ 40288 531 32 pleionas pleiona NNS 40288 531 33 , , , 40288 531 34 homôs homôs NNP 40288 531 35 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 531 36 . . . 40288 532 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 532 2 Theon Theon NNP 40288 532 3 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 40288 532 4 . . . 40288 533 1 c. c. NNP 40288 534 1 6 6 LS 40288 534 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 534 3 . . . 40288 534 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 535 1 The the DT 40288 535 2 poet poet NN 40288 535 3 Ion Ion NNP 40288 535 4 , , , 40288 535 5 the the DT 40288 535 6 contemporary contemporary NN 40288 535 7 of of IN 40288 535 8 Sophocles Sophocles NNPS 40288 535 9 , , , 40288 535 10 was be VBD 40288 535 11 the the DT 40288 535 12 author author NN 40288 535 13 of of IN 40288 535 14 an an DT 40288 535 15 epigram epigram NN 40288 535 16 on on IN 40288 535 17 a a DT 40288 535 18 certain certain JJ 40288 535 19 ten ten CD 40288 535 20 - - HYPH 40288 535 21 stringed string VBN 40288 535 22 lyre lyre NN 40288 535 23 , , , 40288 535 24 which which WDT 40288 535 25 seems seem VBZ 40288 535 26 to to TO 40288 535 27 have have VB 40288 535 28 had have VBN 40288 535 29 a a DT 40288 535 30 scale scale NN 40288 535 31 closely closely RB 40288 535 32 approaching approach VBG 40288 535 33 that that DT 40288 535 34 of of IN 40288 535 35 the the DT 40288 535 36 Lesser Lesser NNP 40288 535 37 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 535 38 System[1 System[1 NNP 40288 535 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 535 40 . . . 40288 536 1 A a DT 40288 536 2 little little JJ 40288 536 3 later later RB 40288 536 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 536 5 hear hear VBP 40288 536 6 of of IN 40288 536 7 the the DT 40288 536 8 comic comic JJ 40288 536 9 poet poet NN 40288 536 10 Pherecrates Pherecrates NNPS 40288 536 11 attacking attack VBG 40288 536 12 the the DT 40288 536 13 musician musician JJ 40288 536 14 Timotheus Timotheus NNP 40288 536 15 for for IN 40288 536 16 various various JJ 40288 536 17 innovations innovation NNS 40288 536 18 tending tend VBG 40288 536 19 to to IN 40288 536 20 the the DT 40288 536 21 loss loss NN 40288 536 22 of of IN 40288 536 23 primitive primitive JJ 40288 536 24 simplicity simplicity NN 40288 536 25 , , , 40288 536 26 in in IN 40288 536 27 particular particular JJ 40288 536 28 the the DT 40288 536 29 use use NN 40288 536 30 of of IN 40288 536 31 twelve twelve CD 40288 536 32 strings[2 strings[2 '' 40288 536 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 536 34 . . . 40288 537 1 According accord VBG 40288 537 2 to to IN 40288 537 3 a a DT 40288 537 4 tradition tradition NN 40288 537 5 mentioned mention VBN 40288 537 6 by by IN 40288 537 7 Pausanias Pausanias NNP 40288 537 8 , , , 40288 537 9 the the DT 40288 537 10 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40288 537 11 condemned condemn VBD 40288 537 12 Timotheus Timotheus NNP 40288 537 13 because because IN 40288 537 14 in in IN 40288 537 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 537 16 cithara cithara NN 40288 537 17 he -PRON- PRP 40288 537 18 had have VBD 40288 537 19 added add VBN 40288 537 20 four four CD 40288 537 21 strings string NNS 40288 537 22 to to IN 40288 537 23 the the DT 40288 537 24 ancient ancient JJ 40288 537 25 seven seven CD 40288 537 26 . . . 40288 538 1 The the DT 40288 538 2 offending offend VBG 40288 538 3 instrument instrument NN 40288 538 4 was be VBD 40288 538 5 hung hang VBN 40288 538 6 up up RP 40288 538 7 in in IN 40288 538 8 the the DT 40288 538 9 Scias Scias NNP 40288 538 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 538 11 the the DT 40288 538 12 place place NN 40288 538 13 of of IN 40288 538 14 meeting meeting NN 40288 538 15 of of IN 40288 538 16 the the DT 40288 538 17 Spartan Spartan NNP 40288 538 18 assembly assembly NN 40288 538 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 538 20 , , , 40288 538 21 and and CC 40288 538 22 apparently apparently RB 40288 538 23 was be VBD 40288 538 24 seen see VBN 40288 538 25 there there RB 40288 538 26 by by IN 40288 538 27 Pausanias Pausanias NNP 40288 538 28 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 538 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 538 30 Paus Paus NNP 40288 538 31 . . . 40288 539 1 iii iii NNP 40288 539 2 . . . 40288 540 1 12 12 CD 40288 540 2 , , , 40288 540 3 8) 8) CD 40288 540 4 . . . 40288 541 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 541 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 541 3 1 1 CD 40288 541 4 : : : 40288 541 5 The the DT 40288 541 6 epigram epigram NN 40288 541 7 is be VBZ 40288 541 8 quoted quote VBN 40288 541 9 in in IN 40288 541 10 the the DT 40288 541 11 pseudo pseudo NN 40288 541 12 - - JJ 40288 541 13 Euclidean Euclidean NNP 40288 541 14 _ _ NNP 40288 541 15 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 541 16 _ _ NNP 40288 541 17 , , , 40288 541 18 p. p. NN 40288 541 19 19 19 CD 40288 541 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 541 21 Meib Meib NNP 40288 541 22 . . . 40288 542 1 ): ): NNP 40288 542 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 542 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 542 4 : : : 40288 542 5 ho ho NNP 40288 542 6 de de NNP 40288 542 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 542 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 542 9 sc sc IN 40288 542 10 . . . 40288 543 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 543 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 543 3 : : : 40288 543 4 Iôn Iôn NNP 40288 543 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 543 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 543 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 543 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 543 9 : : : 40288 543 10 en en XX 40288 543 11 dekachordô dekachordô NNS 40288 543 12 lyra lyra NN 40288 543 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 543 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 543 15 _ _ NNP 40288 543 16 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 543 17 _ _ NNP 40288 543 18 in in IN 40288 543 19 a a DT 40288 543 20 poem poem NN 40288 543 21 on on IN 40288 543 22 the the DT 40288 543 23 subject subject NN 40288 543 24 of of IN 40288 543 25 the the DT 40288 543 26 ten ten CD 40288 543 27 - - HYPH 40288 543 28 stringed string VBN 40288 543 29 lyre):-- lyre):-- NN 40288 543 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 543 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 543 32 : : : 40288 543 33 tên tên NNP 40288 543 34 dekabamona dekabamona NNP 40288 543 35 taxin taxin NNP 40288 543 36 echousa echousa NNP 40288 543 37 tas tas NNP 40288 543 38 symphônousas symphônousas NNP 40288 543 39 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 543 40 triodous triodous JJ 40288 543 41 ; ; : 40288 543 42 prin prin NN 40288 543 43 men man NNS 40288 543 44 s s NNP 40288 543 45 ' ' POS 40288 543 46 heptatonon heptatonon NNP 40288 543 47 psallon psallon NNP 40288 543 48 dia dia NNP 40288 543 49 tessara tessara NNP 40288 543 50 pantes pant VBZ 40288 543 51 Hellênes Hellênes NNP 40288 543 52 , , , 40288 543 53 spanian spanian JJ 40288 543 54 mousan mousan NNP 40288 543 55 aeiramenoi aeiramenoi NNP 40288 543 56 . . . 40288 543 57 ] ] -RRB- 40288 544 1 ' ' `` 40288 544 2 The the DT 40288 544 3 triple triple JJ 40288 544 4 ways way NNS 40288 544 5 of of IN 40288 544 6 music music NN 40288 544 7 that that WDT 40288 544 8 are be VBP 40288 544 9 in in IN 40288 544 10 concord concord NN 40288 544 11 ' ' '' 40288 544 12 must must MD 40288 544 13 be be VB 40288 544 14 the the DT 40288 544 15 three three CD 40288 544 16 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 544 17 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 544 18 that that WDT 40288 544 19 can can MD 40288 544 20 be be VB 40288 544 21 formed form VBN 40288 544 22 with with IN 40288 544 23 ten ten CD 40288 544 24 notes note NNS 40288 544 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 544 26 _ _ NNP 40288 544 27 b b NNP 40288 544 28 c c NNP 40288 544 29 d d NNP 40288 544 30 e e NNP 40288 544 31 f f NNP 40288 544 32 g g NNP 40288 544 33 a a DT 40288 544 34 b b NN 40288 544 35 - - HYPH 40288 544 36 flat flat NN 40288 544 37 c c NNP 40288 544 38 d d XX 40288 544 39 _ _ NN 40288 544 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 544 41 . . . 40288 545 1 This this DT 40288 545 2 is be VBZ 40288 545 3 the the DT 40288 545 4 scale scale NN 40288 545 5 of of IN 40288 545 6 the the DT 40288 545 7 Lesser Lesser NNP 40288 545 8 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 545 9 System System NNP 40288 545 10 before before IN 40288 545 11 the the DT 40288 545 12 addition addition NN 40288 545 13 of of IN 40288 545 14 the the DT 40288 545 15 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 545 16 . . . 40288 545 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 546 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 546 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 546 3 2 2 CD 40288 546 4 : : : 40288 546 5 Pherecrates pherecrate NNS 40288 546 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 546 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 546 8 : : : 40288 546 9 cheirôn cheirôn NNS 40288 546 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 546 11 fr fr NN 40288 546 12 . . . 40288 547 1 1 1 LS 40288 547 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 547 3 quoted quote VBN 40288 547 4 by by IN 40288 547 5 Plut Plut NNP 40288 547 6 . . . 40288 548 1 _ _ NNP 40288 548 2 de de NNP 40288 548 3 Mus Mus NNP 40288 548 4 . . . 40288 548 5 _ _ NNP 40288 548 6 c. c. NNP 40288 548 7 30 30 CD 40288 548 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 548 9 . . . 40288 549 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 549 2 is be VBZ 40288 549 3 needless needless JJ 40288 549 4 to to TO 40288 549 5 refer refer VB 40288 549 6 to to IN 40288 549 7 the the DT 40288 549 8 other other JJ 40288 549 9 traditions tradition NNS 40288 549 10 on on IN 40288 549 11 the the DT 40288 549 12 subject subject NN 40288 549 13 , , , 40288 549 14 such such JJ 40288 549 15 as as IN 40288 549 16 we -PRON- PRP 40288 549 17 find find VBP 40288 549 18 in in IN 40288 549 19 Nicomachus Nicomachus NNP 40288 549 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 549 21 _ _ NNP 40288 549 22 Harm Harm NNP 40288 549 23 . . . 40288 549 24 _ _ NNP 40288 549 25 p. p. NN 40288 549 26 35 35 CD 40288 549 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 549 28 and and CC 40288 549 29 Boethius Boethius NNP 40288 549 30 . . . 40288 549 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 550 1 A a DT 40288 550 2 similar similar JJ 40288 550 3 or or CC 40288 550 4 still still RB 40288 550 5 more more RBR 40288 550 6 rapid rapid JJ 40288 550 7 development development NN 40288 550 8 took take VBD 40288 550 9 place place NN 40288 550 10 in in IN 40288 550 11 the the DT 40288 550 12 flute flute NN 40288 550 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 550 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 550 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 550 16 : : : 40288 550 17 aulos aulos NNP 40288 550 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 550 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 550 20 . . . 40288 551 1 The the DT 40288 551 2 flute flute NN 40288 551 3 - - HYPH 40288 551 4 player player NN 40288 551 5 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 551 6 of of IN 40288 551 7 Thebes Thebes NNP 40288 551 8 , , , 40288 551 9 who who WP 40288 551 10 was be VBD 40288 551 11 said say VBN 40288 551 12 to to TO 40288 551 13 have have VB 40288 551 14 been be VBN 40288 551 15 one one CD 40288 551 16 of of IN 40288 551 17 the the DT 40288 551 18 instructors instructor NNS 40288 551 19 of of IN 40288 551 20 Alcibiades Alcibiades NNPS 40288 551 21 , , , 40288 551 22 invented invent VBD 40288 551 23 a a DT 40288 551 24 flute flute NN 40288 551 25 on on IN 40288 551 26 which which WDT 40288 551 27 it -PRON- PRP 40288 551 28 was be VBD 40288 551 29 possible possible JJ 40288 551 30 to to TO 40288 551 31 play play VB 40288 551 32 in in IN 40288 551 33 all all PDT 40288 551 34 the the DT 40288 551 35 modes mode NNS 40288 551 36 . . . 40288 552 1 ' ' `` 40288 552 2 Up up IN 40288 552 3 to to IN 40288 552 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 552 5 time time NN 40288 552 6 , , , 40288 552 7 ' ' '' 40288 552 8 says say VBZ 40288 552 9 Pausanias Pausanias NNP 40288 552 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 552 11 ix ix IN 40288 552 12 . . . 40288 553 1 12 12 CD 40288 553 2 , , , 40288 553 3 5 5 CD 40288 553 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 553 5 , , , 40288 553 6 ' ' `` 40288 553 7 flute flute NN 40288 553 8 - - HYPH 40288 553 9 players player NNS 40288 553 10 had have VBD 40288 553 11 three three CD 40288 553 12 forms form NNS 40288 553 13 of of IN 40288 553 14 flute flute NN 40288 553 15 : : : 40288 553 16 with with IN 40288 553 17 one one CD 40288 553 18 they -PRON- PRP 40288 553 19 played play VBD 40288 553 20 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 553 21 music music NN 40288 553 22 ; ; : 40288 553 23 a a DT 40288 553 24 different different JJ 40288 553 25 set set NN 40288 553 26 of of IN 40288 553 27 flutes flute NNS 40288 553 28 served serve VBN 40288 553 29 for for IN 40288 553 30 the the DT 40288 553 31 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 553 32 mode mode NN 40288 553 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 553 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 553 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 553 36 : : : 40288 553 37 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 553 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 553 39 ) ) -RRB- 40288 553 40 ; ; : 40288 553 41 and and CC 40288 553 42 the the DT 40288 553 43 so so RB 40288 553 44 - - HYPH 40288 553 45 called call VBN 40288 553 46 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 553 47 was be VBD 40288 553 48 played play VBN 40288 553 49 on on IN 40288 553 50 another another DT 40288 553 51 kind kind NN 40288 553 52 again again RB 40288 553 53 . . . 40288 554 1 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 554 2 was be VBD 40288 554 3 the the DT 40288 554 4 first first JJ 40288 554 5 who who WP 40288 554 6 devised devise VBD 40288 554 7 flutes flute NNS 40288 554 8 fitted fit VBD 40288 554 9 for for IN 40288 554 10 every every DT 40288 554 11 sort sort NN 40288 554 12 of of IN 40288 554 13 mode mode NN 40288 554 14 , , , 40288 554 15 and and CC 40288 554 16 played play VBN 40288 554 17 melodies melody NNS 40288 554 18 different different JJ 40288 554 19 in in IN 40288 554 20 mode mode NN 40288 554 21 on on IN 40288 554 22 the the DT 40288 554 23 same same JJ 40288 554 24 flute flute NN 40288 554 25 . . . 40288 554 26 ' ' '' 40288 555 1 The the DT 40288 555 2 use use NN 40288 555 3 of of IN 40288 555 4 the the DT 40288 555 5 new new JJ 40288 555 6 invention invention NN 40288 555 7 soon soon RB 40288 555 8 became become VBD 40288 555 9 general general JJ 40288 555 10 , , , 40288 555 11 since since IN 40288 555 12 in in IN 40288 555 13 Plato Plato NNP 40288 555 14 's 's POS 40288 555 15 time time NN 40288 555 16 the the DT 40288 555 17 flute flute NN 40288 555 18 was be VBD 40288 555 19 the the DT 40288 555 20 instrument instrument NN 40288 555 21 most most RBS 40288 555 22 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 555 23 by by IN 40288 555 24 the the DT 40288 555 25 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40288 555 26 of of IN 40288 555 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 555 28 notes note NNS 40288 555 29 : : : 40288 555 30 cp cp NNP 40288 555 31 . . . 40288 556 1 Rep. Rep. NNP 40288 556 2 p. p. NN 40288 556 3 399 399 CD 40288 556 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 556 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 556 6 : : : 40288 556 7 ti ti NNP 40288 556 8 de de IN 40288 556 9 ? ? . 40288 557 1 aulopoious aulopoious JJ 40288 557 2 ê ê NNP 40288 557 3 aulêtas aulêtas NNP 40288 557 4 paradexei paradexei NNP 40288 557 5 eis eis NNP 40288 557 6 tên tên NNP 40288 557 7 polin polin NNP 40288 557 8 ? ? . 40288 558 1 ê ê NNP 40288 558 2 ou ou NNP 40288 558 3 touto touto NNP 40288 558 4 polychordotaton polychordotaton NNP 40288 558 5 ? ? . 40288 558 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 559 1 Plato Plato NNP 40288 559 2 may may MD 40288 559 3 have have VB 40288 559 4 had have VBN 40288 559 5 the the DT 40288 559 6 invention invention NN 40288 559 7 of of IN 40288 559 8 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 559 9 in in IN 40288 559 10 mind mind NN 40288 559 11 when when WRB 40288 559 12 he -PRON- PRP 40288 559 13 wrote write VBD 40288 559 14 these these DT 40288 559 15 words word NNS 40288 559 16 . . . 40288 560 1 With with IN 40288 560 2 regard regard NN 40288 560 3 to to IN 40288 560 4 the the DT 40288 560 5 order order NN 40288 560 6 in in IN 40288 560 7 which which WDT 40288 560 8 the the DT 40288 560 9 new new JJ 40288 560 10 notes note NNS 40288 560 11 obtained obtain VBD 40288 560 12 a a DT 40288 560 13 place place NN 40288 560 14 in in IN 40288 560 15 the the DT 40288 560 16 schemes scheme NNS 40288 560 17 of of IN 40288 560 18 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 560 19 musicians musician NNS 40288 560 20 we -PRON- PRP 40288 560 21 have have VBP 40288 560 22 no no DT 40288 560 23 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 40288 560 24 information information NN 40288 560 25 . . . 40288 561 1 The the DT 40288 561 2 name name NN 40288 561 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 561 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 561 5 : : : 40288 561 6 proslambanomenos proslambanomenos NN 40288 561 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 561 8 , , , 40288 561 9 applied apply VBD 40288 561 10 to to IN 40288 561 11 the the DT 40288 561 12 lowest low JJS 40288 561 13 note note NN 40288 561 14 of of IN 40288 561 15 the the DT 40288 561 16 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 561 17 System System NNP 40288 561 18 , , , 40288 561 19 points point VBZ 40288 561 20 to to IN 40288 561 21 a a DT 40288 561 22 time time NN 40288 561 23 when when WRB 40288 561 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 561 25 was be VBD 40288 561 26 the the DT 40288 561 27 last last JJ 40288 561 28 new new JJ 40288 561 29 addition addition NN 40288 561 30 to to IN 40288 561 31 the the DT 40288 561 32 scale scale NN 40288 561 33 . . . 40288 562 1 Plutarch plutarch NN 40288 562 2 in in IN 40288 562 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 562 4 work work NN 40288 562 5 on on IN 40288 562 6 the the DT 40288 562 7 _ _ NNP 40288 562 8 Timaeus Timaeus NNP 40288 562 9 _ _ NNP 40288 562 10 of of IN 40288 562 11 Plato Plato NNP 40288 562 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 562 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 562 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 562 15 : : : 40288 562 16 peri peri NN 40288 562 17 tês tês UH 40288 562 18 en en NNP 40288 562 19 Timaiô Timaiô NNP 40288 562 20 psychogonias psychogonias NNP 40288 562 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 562 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 562 23 speaks speak VBZ 40288 562 24 of of IN 40288 562 25 the the DT 40288 562 26 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 562 27 as as IN 40288 562 28 having have VBG 40288 562 29 been be VBN 40288 562 30 added add VBN 40288 562 31 in in IN 40288 562 32 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 562 33 recent recent JJ 40288 562 34 times time NNS 40288 562 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 562 36 p. p. NN 40288 562 37 1029 1029 CD 40288 562 38 _ _ NNP 40288 562 39 c c NNP 40288 562 40 _ _ NNP 40288 562 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 562 42 Greek Greek NNP 40288 562 43 : : : 40288 562 44 hoi hoi NNP 40288 562 45 de de NNP 40288 562 46 neôteroi neôteroi NNP 40288 562 47 ton ton NN 40288 562 48 proslambanomenon proslambanomenon NNP 40288 562 49 tonô tonô NNP 40288 562 50 diapheronta diapheronta NNP 40288 562 51 tês tês NNP 40288 562 52 hypatês hypatês NNP 40288 562 53 epi epi NNP 40288 562 54 to to IN 40288 562 55 bary bary JJ 40288 562 56 taxantes taxante NNS 40288 562 57 to to IN 40288 562 58 men man NNS 40288 562 59 holon holon NNP 40288 562 60 diastêma diastêma VB 40288 562 61 dis dis NNP 40288 562 62 dia dia NNP 40288 562 63 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 562 64 epoiêsan epoiêsan NNP 40288 562 65 ] ] -RRB- 40288 562 66 ) ) -RRB- 40288 562 67 . . . 40288 563 1 The the DT 40288 563 2 rest rest NN 40288 563 3 of of IN 40288 563 4 the the DT 40288 563 5 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 563 6 System System NNP 40288 563 7 he -PRON- PRP 40288 563 8 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40288 563 9 to to IN 40288 563 10 ' ' '' 40288 563 11 the the DT 40288 563 12 ancients ancient NNS 40288 563 13 ' ' POS 40288 563 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 563 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 563 16 Greek greek JJ 40288 563 17 : : : 40288 563 18 tous tous JJ 40288 563 19 palaious palaious JJ 40288 563 20 ismen isman NNS 40288 563 21 hypatas hypatas NNP 40288 563 22 men man NNS 40288 563 23 dyo dyo VBP 40288 563 24 , , , 40288 563 25 treis treis NNP 40288 563 26 de de NNP 40288 563 27 nêtas nêtas NNP 40288 563 28 , , , 40288 563 29 mian mian NNP 40288 563 30 de de NNP 40288 563 31 mesên mesên NNP 40288 563 32 kai kai NNP 40288 563 33 mian mian NNP 40288 563 34 paramesên paramesên NNP 40288 563 35 tithemenous tithemenous JJ 40288 563 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 563 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 563 38 . . . 40288 564 1 An an DT 40288 564 2 earlier early JJR 40288 564 3 addition addition NN 40288 564 4 -- -- : 40288 564 5 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 564 6 the the DT 40288 564 7 first first JJ 40288 564 8 made make VBN 40288 564 9 to to IN 40288 564 10 the the DT 40288 564 11 primitive primitive JJ 40288 564 12 octave octave NN 40288 564 13 -- -- : 40288 564 14 was be VBD 40288 564 15 a a DT 40288 564 16 note note NN 40288 564 17 called call VBN 40288 564 18 Hyperhypatê Hyperhypatê NNP 40288 564 19 , , , 40288 564 20 which which WDT 40288 564 21 was be VBD 40288 564 22 a a DT 40288 564 23 tone tone NN 40288 564 24 below below IN 40288 564 25 the the DT 40288 564 26 old old JJ 40288 564 27 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 564 28 , , , 40288 564 29 in in IN 40288 564 30 the the DT 40288 564 31 place place NN 40288 564 32 afterwards afterwards RB 40288 564 33 occupied occupy VBN 40288 564 34 on on IN 40288 564 35 the the DT 40288 564 36 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 564 37 scale scale NN 40288 564 38 by by IN 40288 564 39 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 564 40 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 564 41 . . . 40288 565 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 565 2 naturally naturally RB 40288 565 3 disappeared disappear VBD 40288 565 4 when when WRB 40288 565 5 the the DT 40288 565 6 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 565 7 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 565 8 came come VBD 40288 565 9 into into IN 40288 565 10 use use NN 40288 565 11 . . . 40288 566 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 566 2 is be VBZ 40288 566 3 only only RB 40288 566 4 mentioned mention VBN 40288 566 5 by by IN 40288 566 6 one one CD 40288 566 7 author author NN 40288 566 8 , , , 40288 566 9 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40288 566 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 566 11 quoted quote VBN 40288 566 12 by by IN 40288 566 13 Theon Theon NNP 40288 566 14 Smyrnaeus Smyrnaeus NNP 40288 566 15 , , , 40288 566 16 cc cc NNP 40288 566 17 . . . 40288 567 1 35 35 CD 40288 567 2 - - SYM 40288 567 3 36[1 36[1 NN 40288 567 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 567 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 567 6 . . . 40288 568 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 568 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 568 3 1 1 CD 40288 568 4 : : : 40288 568 5 The the DT 40288 568 6 term term NN 40288 568 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 568 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 568 9 : : : 40288 568 10 hyperypatê hyperypatê NN 40288 568 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 568 12 had have VBD 40288 568 13 all all DT 40288 568 14 but but CC 40288 568 15 disappeared disappear VBD 40288 568 16 from from IN 40288 568 17 the the DT 40288 568 18 text text NN 40288 568 19 of of IN 40288 568 20 Theon Theon NNP 40288 568 21 Smyrnaeus Smyrnaeus NNP 40288 568 22 in in IN 40288 568 23 the the DT 40288 568 24 edition edition NN 40288 568 25 of of IN 40288 568 26 Bullialdus Bullialdus NNP 40288 568 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 568 28 Paris Paris NNP 40288 568 29 , , , 40288 568 30 1644 1644 CD 40288 568 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 568 32 , , , 40288 568 33 having have VBG 40288 568 34 been be VBN 40288 568 35 corrupted corrupt VBN 40288 568 36 into into IN 40288 568 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 568 38 Greek Greek NNP 40288 568 39 : : : 40288 568 40 hypatê hypatê NNP 40288 568 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 568 42 or or CC 40288 568 43 [ [ -LRB- 40288 568 44 Greek greek JJ 40288 568 45 : : : 40288 568 46 parypatê parypatê NN 40288 568 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 568 48 in in IN 40288 568 49 every every DT 40288 568 50 place place NN 40288 568 51 except except IN 40288 568 52 one one CD 40288 568 53 ( ( -LRB- 40288 568 54 p. p. NN 40288 568 55 141 141 CD 40288 568 56 , , , 40288 568 57 3 3 CD 40288 568 58 ) ) -RRB- 40288 568 59 . . . 40288 569 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 569 2 has have VBZ 40288 569 3 been be VBN 40288 569 4 restored restore VBN 40288 569 5 from from IN 40288 569 6 MSS MSS NNP 40288 569 7 . . . 40288 570 1 in in IN 40288 570 2 the the DT 40288 570 3 edition edition NN 40288 570 4 of of IN 40288 570 5 Hiller Hiller NNP 40288 570 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 570 7 Teubner Teubner NNP 40288 570 8 , , , 40288 570 9 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 40288 570 10 , , , 40288 570 11 1878 1878 CD 40288 570 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 570 13 . . . 40288 571 1 The the DT 40288 571 2 word word NN 40288 571 3 occurs occur VBZ 40288 571 4 also also RB 40288 571 5 in in IN 40288 571 6 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 571 7 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 571 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 571 9 p. p. NN 40288 571 10 10 10 CD 40288 571 11 Meib Meib NNP 40288 571 12 . . . 40288 572 1 ) ) -RRB- 40288 572 2 , , , 40288 572 3 where where WRB 40288 572 4 the the DT 40288 572 5 plural plural JJ 40288 572 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 572 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 572 8 : : : 40288 572 9 hyperypatai hyperypatai NN 40288 572 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 572 11 is be VBZ 40288 572 12 used use VBN 40288 572 13 for for IN 40288 572 14 the the DT 40288 572 15 notes note NNS 40288 572 16 below below IN 40288 572 17 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 572 18 , , , 40288 572 19 and and CC 40288 572 20 in in IN 40288 572 21 Boethius Boethius NNP 40288 572 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 572 23 _ _ NNP 40288 572 24 Mus Mus NNP 40288 572 25 . . . 40288 572 26 _ _ NNP 40288 572 27 i. i. NNP 40288 573 1 20 20 CD 40288 573 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 573 3 . . . 40288 574 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 574 2 may may MD 40288 574 3 be be VB 40288 574 4 worth worth JJ 40288 574 5 noticing notice VBG 40288 574 6 also also RB 40288 574 7 that that IN 40288 574 8 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40288 574 9 uses use VBZ 40288 574 10 the the DT 40288 574 11 words word NNS 40288 574 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 574 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 574 14 : : : 40288 574 15 diezeugmenê diezeugmenê NN 40288 574 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 574 17 and and CC 40288 574 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 574 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 574 20 : : : 40288 574 21 hyperbolaia hyperbolaia NNP 40288 574 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 574 23 in in IN 40288 574 24 the the DT 40288 574 25 sense sense NN 40288 574 26 of of IN 40288 574 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 574 28 Greek greek JJ 40288 574 29 : : : 40288 574 30 nêtê nêtê JJ 40288 574 31 diezeugmenôn diezeugmenôn NN 40288 574 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 574 33 and and CC 40288 574 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 574 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 574 36 : : : 40288 574 37 nêtê nêtê NNP 40288 574 38 hyperbolaiôn hyperbolaiôn NN 40288 574 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 574 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 574 41 Theon Theon NNP 40288 574 42 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 40288 574 43 . . . 40288 575 1 _ _ NNP 40288 575 2 l. l. NNP 40288 576 1 c. c. NNP 40288 576 2 _ _ NNP 40288 576 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 576 4 . . . 40288 576 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 577 1 The the DT 40288 577 2 notes note NNS 40288 577 3 of of IN 40288 577 4 the the DT 40288 577 5 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 577 6 System System NNP 40288 577 7 , , , 40288 577 8 with with IN 40288 577 9 the the DT 40288 577 10 intervals interval NNS 40288 577 11 of of IN 40288 577 12 the the DT 40288 577 13 scale scale NN 40288 577 14 which which WDT 40288 577 15 they -PRON- PRP 40288 577 16 formed form VBD 40288 577 17 , , , 40288 577 18 are be VBP 40288 577 19 fully fully RB 40288 577 20 set set VBN 40288 577 21 out out RP 40288 577 22 in in IN 40288 577 23 the the DT 40288 577 24 two two CD 40288 577 25 treatises treatise NNS 40288 577 26 that that WDT 40288 577 27 pass pass VBP 40288 577 28 under under IN 40288 577 29 the the DT 40288 577 30 name name NN 40288 577 31 of of IN 40288 577 32 the the DT 40288 577 33 geometer geometer NN 40288 577 34 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 577 35 , , , 40288 577 36 viz viz NN 40288 577 37 . . . 40288 578 1 the the DT 40288 578 2 _ _ NNP 40288 578 3 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 578 4 Harmonica Harmonica NNP 40288 578 5 _ _ NNP 40288 578 6 and and CC 40288 578 7 the the DT 40288 578 8 _ _ NNP 40288 578 9 Sectio Sectio NNP 40288 578 10 Canonis Canonis NNP 40288 578 11 _ _ NNP 40288 578 12 . . . 40288 579 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 40288 579 2 the the DT 40288 579 3 authorship authorship NN 40288 579 4 of of IN 40288 579 5 both both PDT 40288 579 6 these these DT 40288 579 7 works work NNS 40288 579 8 is be VBZ 40288 579 9 doubtful[1 doubtful[1 NNPS 40288 579 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 579 11 . . . 40288 580 1 All all DT 40288 580 2 that that WDT 40288 580 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 580 4 can can MD 40288 580 5 say say VB 40288 580 6 is be VBZ 40288 580 7 that that IN 40288 580 8 if if IN 40288 580 9 the the DT 40288 580 10 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 580 11 System System NNP 40288 580 12 was be VBD 40288 580 13 elaborated elaborate VBN 40288 580 14 in in IN 40288 580 15 the the DT 40288 580 16 brief brief JJ 40288 580 17 interval interval NN 40288 580 18 between between IN 40288 580 19 the the DT 40288 580 20 time time NN 40288 580 21 of of IN 40288 580 22 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 580 23 and and CC 40288 580 24 that that DT 40288 580 25 of of IN 40288 580 26 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 580 27 , , , 40288 580 28 the the DT 40288 580 29 materials material NNS 40288 580 30 for for IN 40288 580 31 it -PRON- PRP 40288 580 32 must must MD 40288 580 33 have have VB 40288 580 34 already already RB 40288 580 35 existed exist VBN 40288 580 36 in in IN 40288 580 37 musical musical JJ 40288 580 38 practice practice NN 40288 580 39 . . . 40288 581 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 581 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 581 3 1 1 CD 40288 581 4 : : : 40288 581 5 _ _ NNP 40288 581 6 The the DT 40288 581 7 Introduction Introduction NNP 40288 581 8 to to IN 40288 581 9 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 581 10 _ _ NNP 40288 581 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 581 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 581 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 581 14 : : : 40288 581 15 eisagôgê eisagôgê NNP 40288 581 16 harmonikê harmonikê NNP 40288 581 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 581 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 581 19 which which WDT 40288 581 20 bears bear VBZ 40288 581 21 the the DT 40288 581 22 name name NN 40288 581 23 of of IN 40288 581 24 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 581 25 in in IN 40288 581 26 modern modern JJ 40288 581 27 editions edition NNS 40288 581 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 581 29 beginning begin VBG 40288 581 30 with with IN 40288 581 31 J. J. NNP 40288 581 32 Pena Pena NNP 40288 581 33 , , , 40288 581 34 Paris Paris NNP 40288 581 35 , , , 40288 581 36 1557 1557 CD 40288 581 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 581 38 can can MD 40288 581 39 not not RB 40288 581 40 be be VB 40288 581 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 581 42 work work NN 40288 581 43 . . . 40288 582 1 In in IN 40288 582 2 some some DT 40288 582 3 MSS MSS NNP 40288 582 4 . . . 40288 583 1 it -PRON- PRP 40288 583 2 is be VBZ 40288 583 3 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 583 4 to to IN 40288 583 5 Cleonides Cleonides NNP 40288 583 6 , , , 40288 583 7 in in IN 40288 583 8 others other NNS 40288 583 9 to to IN 40288 583 10 Pappus Pappus NNP 40288 583 11 , , , 40288 583 12 who who WP 40288 583 13 was be VBD 40288 583 14 probably probably RB 40288 583 15 of of IN 40288 583 16 the the DT 40288 583 17 fourth fourth JJ 40288 583 18 century century NN 40288 583 19 A.D. A.D. NNP 40288 584 1 The the DT 40288 584 2 author author NN 40288 584 3 is be VBZ 40288 584 4 one one CD 40288 584 5 of of IN 40288 584 6 the the DT 40288 584 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 584 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 584 9 : : : 40288 584 10 harmonikoi harmonikoi NN 40288 584 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 584 12 or or CC 40288 584 13 Aristoxeneans Aristoxeneans NNPS 40288 584 14 , , , 40288 584 15 who who WP 40288 584 16 adopt adopt VBP 40288 584 17 the the DT 40288 584 18 method method NN 40288 584 19 of of IN 40288 584 20 equal equal JJ 40288 584 21 temperament temperament NN 40288 584 22 . . . 40288 585 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 585 2 may may MD 40288 585 3 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 585 4 be be VB 40288 585 5 assigned assign VBN 40288 585 6 to to IN 40288 585 7 a a DT 40288 585 8 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 585 9 early early JJ 40288 585 10 period period NN 40288 585 11 on on IN 40288 585 12 the the DT 40288 585 13 ground ground NN 40288 585 14 that that IN 40288 585 15 he -PRON- PRP 40288 585 16 recognises recognise VBZ 40288 585 17 only only RB 40288 585 18 the the DT 40288 585 19 thirteen thirteen CD 40288 585 20 keys key NNS 40288 585 21 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 585 22 to to IN 40288 585 23 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 585 24 -- -- : 40288 585 25 not not RB 40288 585 26 the the DT 40288 585 27 fifteen fifteen JJ 40288 585 28 keys key NNS 40288 585 29 given give VBN 40288 585 30 by by IN 40288 585 31 most most RBS 40288 585 32 later later JJ 40288 585 33 writers writer NNS 40288 585 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 585 35 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 585 36 Quint Quint NNP 40288 585 37 . . . 40288 585 38 , , , 40288 585 39 p. p. NN 40288 585 40 22 22 CD 40288 585 41 Meib Meib NNP 40288 585 42 . . . 40288 585 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 585 44 . . . 40288 586 1 For for IN 40288 586 2 some some DT 40288 586 3 curious curious JJ 40288 586 4 evidence evidence NN 40288 586 5 connecting connect VBG 40288 586 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 586 7 with with IN 40288 586 8 the the DT 40288 586 9 name name NN 40288 586 10 of of IN 40288 586 11 the the DT 40288 586 12 otherwise otherwise RB 40288 586 13 unknown unknown JJ 40288 586 14 writer writer NN 40288 586 15 Cleonides Cleonides NNP 40288 586 16 , , , 40288 586 17 see see VB 40288 586 18 K. K. NNP 40288 586 19 von von NNP 40288 586 20 Jan Jan NNP 40288 586 21 , , , 40288 586 22 _ _ NNP 40288 586 23 Die Die NNP 40288 586 24 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 586 25 des des NNP 40288 586 26 Aristoxenianers Aristoxenianers NNP 40288 586 27 Kleonides Kleonides NNPS 40288 586 28 _ _ NNP 40288 586 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 586 30 Landsberg Landsberg NNP 40288 586 31 , , , 40288 586 32 1870 1870 CD 40288 586 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 586 34 . . . 40288 587 1 The the DT 40288 587 2 _ _ NNP 40288 587 3 Section Section NNP 40288 587 4 of of IN 40288 587 5 the the DT 40288 587 6 Canon Canon NNP 40288 587 7 _ _ NNP 40288 587 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 587 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 587 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 587 11 : : : 40288 587 12 kanonos kanonos NNP 40288 587 13 katatomê katatomê NNP 40288 587 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 587 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 587 16 belongs belong VBZ 40288 587 17 to to IN 40288 587 18 the the DT 40288 587 19 mathematical mathematical JJ 40288 587 20 or or CC 40288 587 21 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 587 22 school school NN 40288 587 23 , , , 40288 587 24 dividing divide VBG 40288 587 25 the the DT 40288 587 26 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 587 27 into into IN 40288 587 28 two two CD 40288 587 29 major major JJ 40288 587 30 tones tone NNS 40288 587 31 and and CC 40288 587 32 a a DT 40288 587 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 587 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 587 35 : : : 40288 587 36 leimma leimma NN 40288 587 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 587 38 which which WDT 40288 587 39 is be VBZ 40288 587 40 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 587 41 less less JJR 40288 587 42 than than IN 40288 587 43 a a DT 40288 587 44 semitone semitone NN 40288 587 45 . . . 40288 588 1 In in IN 40288 588 2 point point NN 40288 588 3 of of IN 40288 588 4 form form NN 40288 588 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 588 6 is be VBZ 40288 588 7 decidedly decidedly RB 40288 588 8 Euclidean euclidean JJ 40288 588 9 : : : 40288 588 10 but but CC 40288 588 11 we -PRON- PRP 40288 588 12 do do VBP 40288 588 13 not not RB 40288 588 14 find find VB 40288 588 15 it -PRON- PRP 40288 588 16 referred refer VBN 40288 588 17 to to IN 40288 588 18 by by IN 40288 588 19 any any DT 40288 588 20 writer writer NN 40288 588 21 before before IN 40288 588 22 the the DT 40288 588 23 third third JJ 40288 588 24 century century NN 40288 588 25 A.D.--the a.d.--the DT 40288 588 26 earliest early JJS 40288 588 27 testimony testimony NN 40288 588 28 being be VBG 40288 588 29 that that DT 40288 588 30 of of IN 40288 588 31 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 40288 588 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 588 33 pp pp NNP 40288 588 34 . . . 40288 589 1 272 272 CD 40288 589 2 - - SYM 40288 589 3 276 276 CD 40288 589 4 in in IN 40288 589 5 Wallis Wallis NNP 40288 589 6 ' ' POS 40288 589 7 edition edition NN 40288 589 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 589 9 . . . 40288 589 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 590 1 § § ADD 40288 590 2 19 19 CD 40288 590 3 . . . 40288 591 1 _ _ NNP 40288 591 2 Relation Relation NNP 40288 591 3 of of IN 40288 591 4 System System NNP 40288 591 5 and and CC 40288 591 6 Key Key NNP 40288 591 7 . . . 40288 591 8 _ _ NNP 40288 591 9 Let let VB 40288 591 10 us -PRON- PRP 40288 591 11 now now RB 40288 591 12 consider consider VB 40288 591 13 the the DT 40288 591 14 relation relation NN 40288 591 15 between between IN 40288 591 16 this this DT 40288 591 17 fixed fixed JJ 40288 591 18 or or CC 40288 591 19 standard standard JJ 40288 591 20 scale scale NN 40288 591 21 and and CC 40288 591 22 the the DT 40288 591 23 varieties variety NNS 40288 591 24 denoted denote VBN 40288 591 25 by by IN 40288 591 26 the the DT 40288 591 27 terms term NNS 40288 591 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 591 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 591 30 : : : 40288 591 31 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 591 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 591 33 and and CC 40288 591 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 591 35 Greek greek NN 40288 591 36 : : : 40288 591 37 tonos tonos NN 40288 591 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 591 39 . . . 40288 592 1 With with IN 40288 592 2 regard regard NN 40288 592 3 to to IN 40288 592 4 the the DT 40288 592 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 592 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 592 7 : : : 40288 592 8 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 592 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 592 10 or or CC 40288 592 11 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 592 12 of of IN 40288 592 13 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 592 14 we -PRON- PRP 40288 592 15 are be VBP 40288 592 16 not not RB 40288 592 17 left leave VBN 40288 592 18 in in IN 40288 592 19 doubt doubt NN 40288 592 20 . . . 40288 593 1 A a DT 40288 593 2 system system NN 40288 593 3 , , , 40288 593 4 as as IN 40288 593 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 593 6 have have VBP 40288 593 7 seen see VBN 40288 593 8 , , , 40288 593 9 is be VBZ 40288 593 10 a a DT 40288 593 11 series series NN 40288 593 12 of of IN 40288 593 13 notes note NNS 40288 593 14 whose whose WP$ 40288 593 15 _ _ NNP 40288 593 16 relative relative JJ 40288 593 17 _ _ NNP 40288 593 18 pitch pitch NN 40288 593 19 is be VBZ 40288 593 20 fixed fix VBN 40288 593 21 . . . 40288 594 1 The the DT 40288 594 2 key key NN 40288 594 3 in in IN 40288 594 4 which which WDT 40288 594 5 the the DT 40288 594 6 System System NNP 40288 594 7 is be VBZ 40288 594 8 taken take VBN 40288 594 9 fixes fix NNS 40288 594 10 the the DT 40288 594 11 absolute absolute JJ 40288 594 12 pitch pitch NN 40288 594 13 of of IN 40288 594 14 the the DT 40288 594 15 series series NN 40288 594 16 . . . 40288 595 1 As as IN 40288 595 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 595 3 expresses express VBZ 40288 595 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 595 5 , , , 40288 595 6 the the DT 40288 595 7 Systems system NNS 40288 595 8 are be VBP 40288 595 9 melodies melody NNS 40288 595 10 set set VBN 40288 595 11 at at IN 40288 595 12 the the DT 40288 595 13 pitch pitch NN 40288 595 14 of of IN 40288 595 15 the the DT 40288 595 16 different different JJ 40288 595 17 keys key NNS 40288 595 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 595 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 595 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 595 21 : : : 40288 595 22 tous tous JJ 40288 595 23 tonous tonous JJ 40288 595 24 , , , 40288 595 25 eph eph NNP 40288 595 26 ' ' POS 40288 595 27 hôn hôn NNP 40288 595 28 tithemena tithemena NNP 40288 595 29 ta ta NNP 40288 595 30 systêmata systêmata NNP 40288 595 31 melôdeitai melôdeitai NNP 40288 595 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 595 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 595 34 . . . 40288 596 1 If if IN 40288 596 2 then then RB 40288 596 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 596 4 speak speak VBP 40288 596 5 of of IN 40288 596 6 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 596 7 or or CC 40288 596 8 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 596 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 596 10 just just RB 40288 596 11 as as IN 40288 596 12 when when WRB 40288 596 13 we -PRON- PRP 40288 596 14 speak speak VBP 40288 596 15 of of IN 40288 596 16 a a DT 40288 596 17 moveable moveable JJ 40288 596 18 Do do NN 40288 596 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 596 20 , , , 40288 596 21 we -PRON- PRP 40288 596 22 mean mean VBP 40288 596 23 as as RB 40288 596 24 many many JJ 40288 596 25 different different JJ 40288 596 26 notes note NNS 40288 596 27 as as IN 40288 596 28 there there EX 40288 596 29 are be VBP 40288 596 30 keys key NNS 40288 596 31 : : : 40288 596 32 but but CC 40288 596 33 the the DT 40288 596 34 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 596 35 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 596 36 or or CC 40288 596 37 the the DT 40288 596 38 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 596 39 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 596 40 has have VBZ 40288 596 41 an an DT 40288 596 42 ascertained ascertained JJ 40288 596 43 pitch pitch NN 40288 596 44 . . . 40288 597 1 The the DT 40288 597 2 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 597 3 of of IN 40288 597 4 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 597 5 , , , 40288 597 6 in in IN 40288 597 7 short short JJ 40288 597 8 , , , 40288 597 9 are be VBP 40288 597 10 so so RB 40288 597 11 many many JJ 40288 597 12 transpositions transposition NNS 40288 597 13 of of IN 40288 597 14 the the DT 40288 597 15 scale scale NN 40288 597 16 called call VBN 40288 597 17 the the DT 40288 597 18 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 597 19 System System NNP 40288 597 20 . . . 40288 598 1 Such such JJ 40288 598 2 being be VBG 40288 598 3 the the DT 40288 598 4 relation relation NN 40288 598 5 of of IN 40288 598 6 the the DT 40288 598 7 standard standard JJ 40288 598 8 System System NNP 40288 598 9 to to IN 40288 598 10 the the DT 40288 598 11 key key NN 40288 598 12 , , , 40288 598 13 can can MD 40288 598 14 we -PRON- PRP 40288 598 15 suppose suppose VB 40288 598 16 any any DT 40288 598 17 different different JJ 40288 598 18 relation relation NN 40288 598 19 to to TO 40288 598 20 have have VB 40288 598 21 subsisted subsist VBN 40288 598 22 between between IN 40288 598 23 the the DT 40288 598 24 standard standard JJ 40288 598 25 System System NNP 40288 598 26 and and CC 40288 598 27 the the DT 40288 598 28 ancient ancient JJ 40288 598 29 ' ' `` 40288 598 30 modes mode NNS 40288 598 31 ' ' '' 40288 598 32 known know VBN 40288 598 33 to to IN 40288 598 34 Plato Plato NNP 40288 598 35 and and CC 40288 598 36 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 598 37 under under IN 40288 598 38 the the DT 40288 598 39 name name NN 40288 598 40 of of IN 40288 598 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 598 42 Greek Greek NNP 40288 598 43 : : : 40288 598 44 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 598 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 598 46 ? ? . 40288 599 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 599 2 appears appear VBZ 40288 599 3 from from IN 40288 599 4 the the DT 40288 599 5 language language NN 40288 599 6 used use VBN 40288 599 7 by by IN 40288 599 8 Plato Plato NNP 40288 599 9 in in IN 40288 599 10 the the DT 40288 599 11 _ _ NNP 40288 599 12 Republic Republic NNP 40288 599 13 _ _ NNP 40288 599 14 that that DT 40288 599 15 Greek greek JJ 40288 599 16 musical musical JJ 40288 599 17 instruments instrument NNS 40288 599 18 differed differ VBD 40288 599 19 very very RB 40288 599 20 much much RB 40288 599 21 in in IN 40288 599 22 the the DT 40288 599 23 variety variety NN 40288 599 24 of of IN 40288 599 25 modes mode NNS 40288 599 26 or or CC 40288 599 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 599 28 Greek Greek NNP 40288 599 29 : : : 40288 599 30 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 599 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 599 32 of of IN 40288 599 33 which which WDT 40288 599 34 they -PRON- PRP 40288 599 35 were be VBD 40288 599 36 susceptible susceptible JJ 40288 599 37 . . . 40288 600 1 After after IN 40288 600 2 Socrates Socrates NNP 40288 600 3 has have VBZ 40288 600 4 determined determine VBN 40288 600 5 , , , 40288 600 6 in in IN 40288 600 7 the the DT 40288 600 8 passage passage NN 40288 600 9 quoted quote VBN 40288 600 10 above above RB 40288 600 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 600 12 p. p. NN 40288 600 13 7 7 CD 40288 600 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 600 15 , , , 40288 600 16 that that IN 40288 600 17 he -PRON- PRP 40288 600 18 will will MD 40288 600 19 admit admit VB 40288 600 20 only only RB 40288 600 21 two two CD 40288 600 22 modes mode NNS 40288 600 23 , , , 40288 600 24 the the DT 40288 600 25 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 600 26 and and CC 40288 600 27 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 600 28 , , , 40288 600 29 he -PRON- PRP 40288 600 30 goes go VBZ 40288 600 31 on on RP 40288 600 32 to to TO 40288 600 33 observe observe VB 40288 600 34 that that IN 40288 600 35 the the DT 40288 600 36 music music NN 40288 600 37 of of IN 40288 600 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 600 39 state state NN 40288 600 40 will will MD 40288 600 41 not not RB 40288 600 42 need need VB 40288 600 43 a a DT 40288 600 44 multitude multitude NN 40288 600 45 of of IN 40288 600 46 strings string NNS 40288 600 47 , , , 40288 600 48 or or CC 40288 600 49 an an DT 40288 600 50 instrument instrument NN 40288 600 51 of of IN 40288 600 52 all all PDT 40288 600 53 the the DT 40288 600 54 modes mode NNS 40288 600 55 ( ( -LRB- 40288 600 56 [ [ -LRB- 40288 600 57 Greek Greek NNP 40288 600 58 : : : 40288 600 59 panarmonion])[1 panarmonion])[1 NN 40288 600 60 ] ] -RRB- 40288 600 61 . . . 40288 601 1 ' ' `` 40288 601 2 There there EX 40288 601 3 will will MD 40288 601 4 be be VB 40288 601 5 no no DT 40288 601 6 custom custom NN 40288 601 7 therefore therefore RB 40288 601 8 for for IN 40288 601 9 craftsmen craftsman NNS 40288 601 10 who who WP 40288 601 11 make make VBP 40288 601 12 triangles triangle NNS 40288 601 13 and and CC 40288 601 14 harps harp NNS 40288 601 15 and and CC 40288 601 16 other other JJ 40288 601 17 instruments instrument NNS 40288 601 18 of of IN 40288 601 19 many many JJ 40288 601 20 notes note NNS 40288 601 21 and and CC 40288 601 22 many many JJ 40288 601 23 modes mode NNS 40288 601 24 . . . 40288 602 1 How how WRB 40288 602 2 then then RB 40288 602 3 about about IN 40288 602 4 makers maker NNS 40288 602 5 of of IN 40288 602 6 the the DT 40288 602 7 flute flute NN 40288 602 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 602 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 602 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 602 11 : : : 40288 602 12 aulos aulos NNP 40288 602 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 602 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 602 15 and and CC 40288 602 16 players player NNS 40288 602 17 on on IN 40288 602 18 the the DT 40288 602 19 flute flute NN 40288 602 20 ? ? . 40288 603 1 Has have VBZ 40288 603 2 not not RB 40288 603 3 the the DT 40288 603 4 flute flute NN 40288 603 5 the the DT 40288 603 6 greatest great JJS 40288 603 7 number number NN 40288 603 8 of of IN 40288 603 9 notes note NNS 40288 603 10 , , , 40288 603 11 and and CC 40288 603 12 are be VBP 40288 603 13 not not RB 40288 603 14 the the DT 40288 603 15 scales scale NNS 40288 603 16 which which WDT 40288 603 17 admit admit VBP 40288 603 18 all all PDT 40288 603 19 the the DT 40288 603 20 modes mode NNS 40288 603 21 simply simply RB 40288 603 22 imitations imitation NNS 40288 603 23 of of IN 40288 603 24 the the DT 40288 603 25 flute flute NN 40288 603 26 ? ? . 40288 604 1 There there EX 40288 604 2 remain remain VBP 40288 604 3 then then RB 40288 604 4 the the DT 40288 604 5 lyre lyre NN 40288 604 6 and and CC 40288 604 7 the the DT 40288 604 8 cithara cithara NN 40288 604 9 for for IN 40288 604 10 use use NN 40288 604 11 in in IN 40288 604 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 604 13 city city NN 40288 604 14 ; ; : 40288 604 15 and and CC 40288 604 16 for for IN 40288 604 17 shepherds shepherd NNS 40288 604 18 in in IN 40288 604 19 the the DT 40288 604 20 country country NN 40288 604 21 a a DT 40288 604 22 syrinx syrinx JJ 40288 604 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 604 24 pan pan NNP 40288 604 25 's 's POS 40288 604 26 pipes pipe NNS 40288 604 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 604 28 . . . 40288 604 29 ' ' '' 40288 605 1 The the DT 40288 605 2 lyre lyre NN 40288 605 3 , , , 40288 605 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 605 5 is be VBZ 40288 605 6 plain plain JJ 40288 605 7 , , , 40288 605 8 did do VBD 40288 605 9 not not RB 40288 605 10 admit admit VB 40288 605 11 of of IN 40288 605 12 changes change NNS 40288 605 13 of of IN 40288 605 14 mode mode NN 40288 605 15 . . . 40288 606 1 The the DT 40288 606 2 seven seven CD 40288 606 3 or or CC 40288 606 4 eight eight CD 40288 606 5 strings string NNS 40288 606 6 were be VBD 40288 606 7 tuned tune VBN 40288 606 8 to to TO 40288 606 9 furnish furnish VB 40288 606 10 the the DT 40288 606 11 scale scale NN 40288 606 12 of of IN 40288 606 13 one one CD 40288 606 14 mode mode NN 40288 606 15 , , , 40288 606 16 not not RB 40288 606 17 of of IN 40288 606 18 more more JJR 40288 606 19 . . . 40288 607 1 What what WP 40288 607 2 then then RB 40288 607 3 is be VBZ 40288 607 4 the the DT 40288 607 5 relation relation NN 40288 607 6 between between IN 40288 607 7 the the DT 40288 607 8 mode mode NN 40288 607 9 or or CC 40288 607 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 607 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 607 12 : : : 40288 607 13 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 607 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 607 15 of of IN 40288 607 16 a a DT 40288 607 17 lyre lyre NN 40288 607 18 and and CC 40288 607 19 the the DT 40288 607 20 standard standard JJ 40288 607 21 scale scale NN 40288 607 22 or or CC 40288 607 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 607 24 Greek greek JJ 40288 607 25 : : : 40288 607 26 systêma systêma NN 40288 607 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 607 28 which which WDT 40288 607 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 607 30 as as IN 40288 607 31 we -PRON- PRP 40288 607 32 have have VBP 40288 607 33 seen see VBN 40288 607 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 607 35 was be VBD 40288 607 36 based base VBN 40288 607 37 upon upon IN 40288 607 38 the the DT 40288 607 39 lyre lyre NN 40288 607 40 and and CC 40288 607 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 607 42 primitive primitive JJ 40288 607 43 gamut gamut NN 40288 607 44 ? ? . 40288 608 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 608 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 608 3 1 1 CD 40288 608 4 : : : 40288 608 5 Plato Plato NNP 40288 608 6 , , , 40288 608 7 Rep. Rep. NNP 40288 608 8 p. p. NN 40288 608 9 399 399 CD 40288 608 10 : : : 40288 608 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 608 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 608 13 : : : 40288 608 14 ouk ouk NNP 40288 608 15 ara ara NNP 40288 608 16 , , , 40288 608 17 ên ên NNP 40288 608 18 d d NNP 40288 608 19 ' ' `` 40288 608 20 egô egô NNP 40288 608 21 , , , 40288 608 22 polychordias polychordias NNP 40288 608 23 ge ge NNP 40288 608 24 oude oude NNP 40288 608 25 panarmoniou panarmoniou NNP 40288 608 26 hêmin hêmin NNP 40288 608 27 deêsei deêsei NNP 40288 608 28 en en IN 40288 608 29 tais tais NNP 40288 608 30 ôdais ôdais NNP 40288 608 31 te te NNP 40288 608 32 kai kai NNP 40288 608 33 melesin melesin NNP 40288 608 34 . . . 40288 609 1 Ou Ou NNP 40288 609 2 moi moi NN 40288 609 3 , , , 40288 609 4 ephê ephê NNP 40288 609 5 , , , 40288 609 6 phainetai phainetai NNP 40288 609 7 . . . 40288 610 1 Trigônôn Trigônôn NNP 40288 610 2 ara ara NNP 40288 610 3 kai kai NNP 40288 610 4 pêktidôn pêktidôn NNP 40288 610 5 kai kai NNP 40288 610 6 pantôn pantôn NNP 40288 610 7 organôn organôn NNP 40288 610 8 hosa hosa NNP 40288 610 9 polychorda polychorda NNP 40288 610 10 kai kai NNP 40288 610 11 polyarmonia polyarmonia NNP 40288 610 12 dêmiourgous dêmiourgous JJ 40288 610 13 ou ou NNP 40288 610 14 threpsomen threpsoman NNS 40288 610 15 . . . 40288 611 1 Ou Ou NNP 40288 611 2 phainometha phainometha NN 40288 611 3 . . . 40288 612 1 Ti Ti NNP 40288 612 2 de de NNP 40288 612 3 ? ? . 40288 613 1 aulopoious aulopoious JJ 40288 613 2 ê ê NNP 40288 613 3 aulêtas aulêtas NNP 40288 613 4 paradexei paradexei NNP 40288 613 5 eis eis NNP 40288 613 6 tên tên NNP 40288 613 7 polin polin NNP 40288 613 8 ? ? . 40288 614 1 ê ê NNP 40288 614 2 ou ou NNP 40288 614 3 touto touto NNP 40288 614 4 polychordotaton polychordotaton NNP 40288 614 5 , , , 40288 614 6 kai kai NNP 40288 614 7 auta auta NNP 40288 614 8 ta ta NNP 40288 614 9 panarmonia panarmonia NNP 40288 614 10 aulou aulou NNP 40288 614 11 tynchanei tynchanei NNP 40288 614 12 onta onta NNP 40288 614 13 mimêma mimêma NNP 40288 614 14 ? ? . 40288 615 1 Dêla dêla JJ 40288 615 2 dê dê NN 40288 615 3 , , , 40288 615 4 ê ê NNP 40288 615 5 d d NNP 40288 615 6 ' ' POS 40288 615 7 hos hos NN 40288 615 8 . . . 40288 616 1 Lyra lyra NN 40288 616 2 dê dê NN 40288 616 3 soi soi NN 40288 616 4 , , , 40288 616 5 ên ên NNP 40288 616 6 d d NNP 40288 616 7 ' ' `` 40288 616 8 egô egô NNP 40288 616 9 , , , 40288 616 10 kai kai NNP 40288 616 11 kithara kithara NNP 40288 616 12 leipetai leipetai NNP 40288 616 13 , , , 40288 616 14 kai kai NNP 40288 616 15 kata kata NNP 40288 616 16 polin polin NNP 40288 616 17 chrêsima chrêsima NNP 40288 616 18 ; ; : 40288 616 19 kai kai NNP 40288 616 20 au au NNP 40288 616 21 kat kat NNP 40288 616 22 ' ' POS 40288 616 23 agrous agrous JJ 40288 616 24 tois tois NN 40288 616 25 nomeusi nomeusi NN 40288 616 26 syrinx syrinx VBD 40288 616 27 an an DT 40288 616 28 tis tis NN 40288 616 29 eiê eiê NN 40288 616 30 . . . 40288 616 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 617 1 The the DT 40288 617 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 617 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 617 4 : : : 40288 617 5 aulos aulos NNP 40288 617 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 617 7 was be VBD 40288 617 8 not not RB 40288 617 9 exactly exactly RB 40288 617 10 a a DT 40288 617 11 flute flute NN 40288 617 12 . . . 40288 618 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 618 2 had have VBD 40288 618 3 a a DT 40288 618 4 mouthpiece mouthpiece NN 40288 618 5 which which WDT 40288 618 6 gave give VBD 40288 618 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 618 8 the the DT 40288 618 9 character character NN 40288 618 10 rather rather RB 40288 618 11 of of IN 40288 618 12 the the DT 40288 618 13 modern modern JJ 40288 618 14 oboe oboe NN 40288 618 15 or or CC 40288 618 16 clarinet clarinet NN 40288 618 17 : : : 40288 618 18 see see VB 40288 618 19 the the DT 40288 618 20 _ _ NNP 40288 618 21 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 40288 618 22 of of IN 40288 618 23 Antiquities Antiquities NNPS 40288 618 24 _ _ NNP 40288 618 25 , , , 40288 618 26 S. S. NNP 40288 618 27 V. V. NNP 40288 618 28 TIBIA TIBIA NNP 40288 618 29 . . . 40288 619 1 The the DT 40288 619 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 619 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 619 4 : : : 40288 619 5 panarmonion panarmonion NN 40288 619 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 619 7 is be VBZ 40288 619 8 not not RB 40288 619 9 otherwise otherwise RB 40288 619 10 known know VBN 40288 619 11 , , , 40288 619 12 and and CC 40288 619 13 the the DT 40288 619 14 passage passage NN 40288 619 15 in in IN 40288 619 16 Plato Plato NNP 40288 619 17 does do VBZ 40288 619 18 not not RB 40288 619 19 enable enable VB 40288 619 20 us -PRON- PRP 40288 619 21 to to TO 40288 619 22 decide decide VB 40288 619 23 whether whether IN 40288 619 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 619 25 was be VBD 40288 619 26 a a DT 40288 619 27 real real JJ 40288 619 28 instrument instrument NN 40288 619 29 or or CC 40288 619 30 only only RB 40288 619 31 a a DT 40288 619 32 scale scale NN 40288 619 33 or or CC 40288 619 34 arrangement arrangement NN 40288 619 35 of of IN 40288 619 36 notes note NNS 40288 619 37 . . . 40288 619 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 620 1 If if IN 40288 620 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 620 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 620 4 : : : 40288 620 5 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 620 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 620 7 means mean VBZ 40288 620 8 ' ' '' 40288 620 9 key key NN 40288 620 10 , , , 40288 620 11 ' ' '' 40288 620 12 there there EX 40288 620 13 is be VBZ 40288 620 14 no no DT 40288 620 15 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 620 16 . . . 40288 621 1 The the DT 40288 621 2 scale scale NN 40288 621 3 of of IN 40288 621 4 a a DT 40288 621 5 lyre lyre NN 40288 621 6 was be VBD 40288 621 7 usually usually RB 40288 621 8 the the DT 40288 621 9 standard standard JJ 40288 621 10 octave octave NN 40288 621 11 from from IN 40288 621 12 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 621 13 to to IN 40288 621 14 Nêtê nêtê NN 40288 621 15 : : : 40288 621 16 and and CC 40288 621 17 that that IN 40288 621 18 octave octave NN 40288 621 19 might may MD 40288 621 20 be be VB 40288 621 21 in in IN 40288 621 22 any any DT 40288 621 23 one one CD 40288 621 24 key key NN 40288 621 25 . . . 40288 622 1 But but CC 40288 622 2 if if IN 40288 622 3 a a DT 40288 622 4 mode mode NN 40288 622 5 is be VBZ 40288 622 6 somehow somehow RB 40288 622 7 characterised characterise VBN 40288 622 8 by by IN 40288 622 9 a a DT 40288 622 10 particular particular JJ 40288 622 11 succession succession NN 40288 622 12 of of IN 40288 622 13 intervals interval NNS 40288 622 14 , , , 40288 622 15 what what WP 40288 622 16 becomes become VBZ 40288 622 17 of of IN 40288 622 18 the the DT 40288 622 19 standard standard JJ 40288 622 20 octave octave NN 40288 622 21 ? ? . 40288 623 1 No no DT 40288 623 2 one one CD 40288 623 3 succession succession NN 40288 623 4 of of IN 40288 623 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 623 6 can can MD 40288 623 7 then then RB 40288 623 8 be be VB 40288 623 9 singled single VBN 40288 623 10 out out RP 40288 623 11 . . . 40288 624 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 624 2 may may MD 40288 624 3 be be VB 40288 624 4 said say VBN 40288 624 5 that that IN 40288 624 6 the the DT 40288 624 7 standard standard JJ 40288 624 8 octave octave NN 40288 624 9 is be VBZ 40288 624 10 in in IN 40288 624 11 fact fact NN 40288 624 12 the the DT 40288 624 13 scale scale NN 40288 624 14 of of IN 40288 624 15 a a DT 40288 624 16 particular particular JJ 40288 624 17 mode mode NN 40288 624 18 , , , 40288 624 19 which which WDT 40288 624 20 had have VBD 40288 624 21 come come VBN 40288 624 22 to to TO 40288 624 23 be be VB 40288 624 24 regarded regard VBN 40288 624 25 as as IN 40288 624 26 the the DT 40288 624 27 type type NN 40288 624 28 , , , 40288 624 29 viz viz NN 40288 624 30 . . . 40288 625 1 the the DT 40288 625 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 625 3 . . . 40288 626 1 But but CC 40288 626 2 there there EX 40288 626 3 is be VBZ 40288 626 4 no no DT 40288 626 5 trace trace NN 40288 626 6 of of IN 40288 626 7 any any DT 40288 626 8 such such JJ 40288 626 9 prominence prominence NN 40288 626 10 of of IN 40288 626 11 the the DT 40288 626 12 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 626 13 mode mode NN 40288 626 14 as as IN 40288 626 15 this this DT 40288 626 16 would would MD 40288 626 17 necessitate necessitate VB 40288 626 18 . . . 40288 627 1 The the DT 40288 627 2 philosophers philosopher NNS 40288 627 3 who who WP 40288 627 4 recognise recognise VBP 40288 627 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 627 6 elevation elevation NN 40288 627 7 and and CC 40288 627 8 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40288 627 9 purity purity NN 40288 627 10 are be VBP 40288 627 11 very very RB 40288 627 12 far far RB 40288 627 13 from from IN 40288 627 14 implying imply VBG 40288 627 15 that that IN 40288 627 16 it -PRON- PRP 40288 627 17 had have VBD 40288 627 18 the the DT 40288 627 19 chief chief JJ 40288 627 20 place place NN 40288 627 21 in in IN 40288 627 22 popular popular JJ 40288 627 23 regard regard NN 40288 627 24 . . . 40288 628 1 Indeed indeed RB 40288 628 2 the the DT 40288 628 3 contrary contrary NN 40288 628 4 was be VBD 40288 628 5 evidently evidently RB 40288 628 6 the the DT 40288 628 7 case[1 case[1 NNP 40288 628 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 628 9 . . . 40288 629 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 629 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 629 3 1 1 CD 40288 629 4 : : : 40288 629 5 The the DT 40288 629 6 passage passage NN 40288 629 7 quoted quote VBN 40288 629 8 above above RB 40288 629 9 from from IN 40288 629 10 the the DT 40288 629 11 _ _ NNP 40288 629 12 Knights Knights NNPS 40288 629 13 _ _ NNP 40288 629 14 of of IN 40288 629 15 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40288 629 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 629 17 p. p. NN 40288 629 18 7 7 CD 40288 629 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 629 20 is be VBZ 40288 629 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 40288 629 22 to to TO 40288 629 23 show show VB 40288 629 24 that that IN 40288 629 25 a a DT 40288 629 26 marked marked JJ 40288 629 27 preference preference NN 40288 629 28 for for IN 40288 629 29 the the DT 40288 629 30 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 629 31 mode mode NN 40288 629 32 would would MD 40288 629 33 be be VB 40288 629 34 a a DT 40288 629 35 matter matter NN 40288 629 36 for for IN 40288 629 37 jest jest NN 40288 629 38 . . . 40288 629 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 630 1 § § ADD 40288 630 2 20 20 CD 40288 630 3 . . . 40288 631 1 _ _ NNP 40288 631 2 Tonality Tonality NNP 40288 631 3 of of IN 40288 631 4 the the DT 40288 631 5 Greek greek JJ 40288 631 6 musical musical JJ 40288 631 7 scale scale NN 40288 631 8 . . . 40288 631 9 _ _ NNP 40288 631 10 It -PRON- PRP 40288 631 11 may may MD 40288 631 12 be be VB 40288 631 13 said say VBN 40288 631 14 here here RB 40288 631 15 that that IN 40288 631 16 the the DT 40288 631 17 value value NN 40288 631 18 of of IN 40288 631 19 a a DT 40288 631 20 series series NN 40288 631 21 of of IN 40288 631 22 notes note NNS 40288 631 23 as as IN 40288 631 24 the the DT 40288 631 25 basis basis NN 40288 631 26 of of IN 40288 631 27 a a DT 40288 631 28 distinct distinct JJ 40288 631 29 mode mode NN 40288 631 30 -- -- : 40288 631 31 in in IN 40288 631 32 the the DT 40288 631 33 modern modern JJ 40288 631 34 sense sense NN 40288 631 35 of of IN 40288 631 36 the the DT 40288 631 37 word word NN 40288 631 38 -- -- : 40288 631 39 depends depend VBZ 40288 631 40 essentially essentially RB 40288 631 41 upon upon IN 40288 631 42 the the DT 40288 631 43 _ _ NNP 40288 631 44 tonality tonality NN 40288 631 45 _ _ NNP 40288 631 46 . . . 40288 632 1 A a DT 40288 632 2 single single JJ 40288 632 3 scale scale NN 40288 632 4 might may MD 40288 632 5 yield yield VB 40288 632 6 music music NN 40288 632 7 of of IN 40288 632 8 different different JJ 40288 632 9 modes mode NNS 40288 632 10 if if IN 40288 632 11 the the DT 40288 632 12 key key NN 40288 632 13 - - HYPH 40288 632 14 note note NN 40288 632 15 were be VBD 40288 632 16 different different JJ 40288 632 17 . . . 40288 633 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 633 2 is be VBZ 40288 633 3 necessary necessary JJ 40288 633 4 therefore therefore RB 40288 633 5 to to TO 40288 633 6 collect collect VB 40288 633 7 the the DT 40288 633 8 scanty scanty NN 40288 633 9 notices notice NNS 40288 633 10 which which WDT 40288 633 11 we -PRON- PRP 40288 633 12 possess possess VBP 40288 633 13 bearing bear VBG 40288 633 14 upon upon IN 40288 633 15 the the DT 40288 633 16 tonality tonality NN 40288 633 17 of of IN 40288 633 18 Greek greek JJ 40288 633 19 music music NN 40288 633 20 . . . 40288 634 1 The the DT 40288 634 2 chief chief JJ 40288 634 3 evidence evidence NN 40288 634 4 on on IN 40288 634 5 the the DT 40288 634 6 subject subject NN 40288 634 7 is be VBZ 40288 634 8 a a DT 40288 634 9 passage passage NN 40288 634 10 of of IN 40288 634 11 the the DT 40288 634 12 _ _ NNP 40288 634 13 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 634 14 _ _ NNP 40288 634 15 , , , 40288 634 16 the the DT 40288 634 17 importance importance NN 40288 634 18 of of IN 40288 634 19 which which WDT 40288 634 20 was be VBD 40288 634 21 first first RB 40288 634 22 pointed point VBN 40288 634 23 out out RP 40288 634 24 by by IN 40288 634 25 Helmholtz[1 Helmholtz[1 NNP 40288 634 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 634 27 . . . 40288 635 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 635 2 is be VBZ 40288 635 3 as as IN 40288 635 4 follows follow VBZ 40288 635 5 : : : 40288 635 6 Arist arist NN 40288 635 7 . . . 40288 636 1 _ _ NNP 40288 636 2 Probl Probl NNP 40288 636 3 . . . 40288 636 4 _ _ NNP 40288 636 5 xix xix NNP 40288 636 6 . . . 40288 637 1 20 20 CD 40288 637 2 : : : 40288 637 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 637 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 637 5 : : : 40288 637 6 Dia Dia VBN 40288 637 7 ti ti IN 40288 637 8 ean ean NNP 40288 637 9 men man NNS 40288 637 10 tis tis NNP 40288 637 11 tên tên NNP 40288 637 12 mesên mesên NNP 40288 637 13 kinêsê kinêsê NNP 40288 637 14 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 40288 637 15 , , , 40288 637 16 harmosas harmosas NNP 40288 637 17 tas tas NNP 40288 637 18 allas allas NNP 40288 637 19 chordas chordas NNP 40288 637 20 , , , 40288 637 21 kai kai NNP 40288 637 22 chrêtai chrêtai NNP 40288 637 23 tô tô NNP 40288 637 24 organô organô NNP 40288 637 25 , , , 40288 637 26 ou ou NNP 40288 637 27 monon monon NNP 40288 637 28 hotan hotan NNP 40288 637 29 kata kata NNP 40288 637 30 ton ton NNP 40288 637 31 tês tês NNP 40288 637 32 mesês mesês NNP 40288 637 33 genêtai genêtai NNP 40288 637 34 phthongon phthongon NNP 40288 637 35 lypei lypei NNP 40288 637 36 kai kai NNP 40288 637 37 phainetai phainetai NNP 40288 637 38 anarmoston anarmoston NNP 40288 637 39 , , , 40288 637 40 alla alla NNP 40288 637 41 kai kai NNP 40288 637 42 kata kata NNP 40288 637 43 tên tên NNP 40288 637 44 allên allên NNP 40288 637 45 melôdian melôdian NNP 40288 637 46 , , , 40288 637 47 ean ean NNP 40288 637 48 de de NNP 40288 637 49 tên tên NNP 40288 637 50 lichanon lichanon NNP 40288 637 51 ê ê NNP 40288 637 52 tina tina NNP 40288 637 53 allon allon NNP 40288 637 54 phthongon phthongon NNP 40288 637 55 , , , 40288 637 56 tote tote NNP 40288 637 57 phainetai phainetai NNP 40288 637 58 diapherein diapherein NNP 40288 637 59 monon monon NNP 40288 637 60 hotan hotan NNP 40288 637 61 kakeinê kakeinê NNP 40288 637 62 tis tis NNP 40288 637 63 chrêtai chrêtai NN 40288 637 64 ? ? . 40288 638 1 ê ê NNP 40288 638 2 eulogôs eulogôs NNP 40288 638 3 touto touto NN 40288 638 4 symbainei symbainei NNP 40288 638 5 ? ? . 40288 639 1 panta panta NNP 40288 639 2 gar gar NNP 40288 639 3 ta ta NNP 40288 639 4 chrêsta chrêsta NNP 40288 639 5 melê melê NNP 40288 639 6 pollakis pollakis NNP 40288 639 7 tê tê DT 40288 639 8 mesê mesê NNP 40288 639 9 chrêtai chrêtai NNP 40288 639 10 , , , 40288 639 11 kai kai NNP 40288 639 12 pantes pant VBZ 40288 639 13 hoi hoi NNP 40288 639 14 agathoi agathoi NNP 40288 639 15 poiêtai poiêtai NNP 40288 639 16 pykna pykna NNP 40288 639 17 pros pros NNP 40288 639 18 tên tên NNP 40288 639 19 mesên mesên NNP 40288 639 20 apantôsi apantôsi NNP 40288 639 21 , , , 40288 639 22 kan kan NNP 40288 639 23 apelthôsi apelthôsi NNP 40288 639 24 tachy tachy NNP 40288 639 25 epanerchontai epanerchontai NNP 40288 639 26 , , , 40288 639 27 pros pros NNP 40288 639 28 de de NNP 40288 639 29 allên allên NNP 40288 639 30 houtôs houtôs NNP 40288 639 31 oudemian oudemian NNP 40288 639 32 . . . 40288 640 1 kathaper kathaper NNP 40288 640 2 ek ek NNP 40288 640 3 tôn tôn NNP 40288 640 4 logôn logôn NNP 40288 640 5 eniôn eniôn NNP 40288 640 6 exairethentôn exairethentôn NNP 40288 640 7 syndesmôn syndesmôn NNP 40288 640 8 ouk ouk NNP 40288 640 9 estin estin NNP 40288 640 10 ho ho NNP 40288 640 11 logos logos NNP 40288 640 12 Hellênikos Hellênikos NNP 40288 640 13 , , , 40288 640 14 hoion hoion NN 40288 640 15 to to IN 40288 640 16 te te NNP 40288 640 17 kai kai NNP 40288 640 18 to to IN 40288 640 19 kai kai NNP 40288 640 20 , , , 40288 640 21 enioi enioi NNP 40288 640 22 de de NNP 40288 640 23 outhen outhen NNP 40288 640 24 lypousi lypousi NNP 40288 640 25 , , , 40288 640 26 dia dia VB 40288 640 27 to to IN 40288 640 28 tois tois NNP 40288 640 29 men man NNS 40288 640 30 anankaion anankaion NN 40288 640 31 einai einai NNP 40288 640 32 chrêsthai chrêsthai NNP 40288 640 33 pollakis pollakis NNP 40288 640 34 , , , 40288 640 35 ei ei NNP 40288 640 36 estai estai NNP 40288 640 37 logos logos NNP 40288 640 38 , , , 40288 640 39 tois tois NNP 40288 640 40 de de NNP 40288 640 41 mê mê NNP 40288 640 42 , , , 40288 640 43 houtô houtô NNP 40288 640 44 kai kai NNP 40288 640 45 tôn tôn NNP 40288 640 46 phthongôn phthongôn NNPS 40288 640 47 hê hê NNP 40288 640 48 mesê mesê NNP 40288 640 49 hôsper hôsper NNP 40288 640 50 syndesmos syndesmos NNP 40288 640 51 esti esti NNP 40288 640 52 , , , 40288 640 53 kai kai NNP 40288 640 54 malista malista NNP 40288 640 55 tôn tôn NNP 40288 640 56 kalôn kalôn NNP 40288 640 57 , , , 40288 640 58 dia dia NNP 40288 640 59 to to IN 40288 640 60 pleistakis pleistakis NNP 40288 640 61 enyparchein enyparchein NNP 40288 640 62 ton ton NNP 40288 640 63 phthongon phthongon NNP 40288 640 64 autês autês NNP 40288 640 65 . . . 40288 640 66 ] ] -RRB- 40288 641 1 ' ' `` 40288 641 2 Why why WRB 40288 641 3 is be VBZ 40288 641 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 641 5 that that IN 40288 641 6 if if IN 40288 641 7 the the DT 40288 641 8 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 641 9 is be VBZ 40288 641 10 altered alter VBN 40288 641 11 , , , 40288 641 12 after after IN 40288 641 13 the the DT 40288 641 14 other other JJ 40288 641 15 strings string NNS 40288 641 16 have have VBP 40288 641 17 been be VBN 40288 641 18 tuned tune VBN 40288 641 19 , , , 40288 641 20 the the DT 40288 641 21 instrument instrument NN 40288 641 22 is be VBZ 40288 641 23 felt feel VBN 40288 641 24 to to TO 40288 641 25 be be VB 40288 641 26 out out IN 40288 641 27 of of IN 40288 641 28 tune tune NN 40288 641 29 , , , 40288 641 30 not not RB 40288 641 31 only only RB 40288 641 32 when when WRB 40288 641 33 the the DT 40288 641 34 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 641 35 is be VBZ 40288 641 36 sounded sound VBN 40288 641 37 , , , 40288 641 38 but but CC 40288 641 39 through through IN 40288 641 40 the the DT 40288 641 41 whole whole NN 40288 641 42 of of IN 40288 641 43 the the DT 40288 641 44 music,--whereas music,--whereas NNP 40288 641 45 if if IN 40288 641 46 the the DT 40288 641 47 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 641 48 or or CC 40288 641 49 any any DT 40288 641 50 other other JJ 40288 641 51 note note NN 40288 641 52 is be VBZ 40288 641 53 out out IN 40288 641 54 of of IN 40288 641 55 tune tune NN 40288 641 56 , , , 40288 641 57 it -PRON- PRP 40288 641 58 seems seem VBZ 40288 641 59 to to TO 40288 641 60 be be VB 40288 641 61 perceived perceive VBN 40288 641 62 only only RB 40288 641 63 when when WRB 40288 641 64 that that DT 40288 641 65 note note NN 40288 641 66 is be VBZ 40288 641 67 struck strike VBN 40288 641 68 ? ? . 40288 642 1 Is be VBZ 40288 642 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 642 3 to to TO 40288 642 4 be be VB 40288 642 5 explained explain VBN 40288 642 6 on on IN 40288 642 7 the the DT 40288 642 8 ground ground NN 40288 642 9 that that IN 40288 642 10 all all DT 40288 642 11 good good JJ 40288 642 12 melodies melody NNS 40288 642 13 often often RB 40288 642 14 use use VBP 40288 642 15 the the DT 40288 642 16 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 642 17 , , , 40288 642 18 and and CC 40288 642 19 all all DT 40288 642 20 good good JJ 40288 642 21 composers composer NNS 40288 642 22 resort resort VBP 40288 642 23 to to IN 40288 642 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 642 25 frequently frequently RB 40288 642 26 , , , 40288 642 27 and and CC 40288 642 28 if if IN 40288 642 29 they -PRON- PRP 40288 642 30 leave leave VBP 40288 642 31 it -PRON- PRP 40288 642 32 soon soon RB 40288 642 33 return return VB 40288 642 34 again again RB 40288 642 35 , , , 40288 642 36 but but CC 40288 642 37 do do VBP 40288 642 38 not not RB 40288 642 39 make make VB 40288 642 40 the the DT 40288 642 41 same same JJ 40288 642 42 use use NN 40288 642 43 of of IN 40288 642 44 any any DT 40288 642 45 other other JJ 40288 642 46 note note NN 40288 642 47 ? ? . 40288 643 1 just just RB 40288 643 2 as as IN 40288 643 3 language language NN 40288 643 4 can can MD 40288 643 5 not not RB 40288 643 6 be be VB 40288 643 7 Greek greek JJ 40288 643 8 if if IN 40288 643 9 certain certain JJ 40288 643 10 conjunctions conjunction NNS 40288 643 11 are be VBP 40288 643 12 omitted omit VBN 40288 643 13 , , , 40288 643 14 such such JJ 40288 643 15 as as IN 40288 643 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 643 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 643 18 : : : 40288 643 19 te te NNP 40288 643 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 643 21 and and CC 40288 643 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 643 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 643 24 : : : 40288 643 25 kai kai NNP 40288 643 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 643 27 , , , 40288 643 28 while while IN 40288 643 29 others other NNS 40288 643 30 may may MD 40288 643 31 be be VB 40288 643 32 dispensed dispense VBN 40288 643 33 with with IN 40288 643 34 , , , 40288 643 35 because because IN 40288 643 36 the the DT 40288 643 37 one one CD 40288 643 38 class class NN 40288 643 39 is be VBZ 40288 643 40 necessary necessary JJ 40288 643 41 for for IN 40288 643 42 language language NN 40288 643 43 , , , 40288 643 44 but but CC 40288 643 45 not not RB 40288 643 46 the the DT 40288 643 47 other other JJ 40288 643 48 : : : 40288 643 49 so so RB 40288 643 50 with with IN 40288 643 51 musical musical JJ 40288 643 52 sounds sound VBZ 40288 643 53 the the DT 40288 643 54 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 643 55 is be VBZ 40288 643 56 a a DT 40288 643 57 kind kind NN 40288 643 58 of of IN 40288 643 59 ' ' `` 40288 643 60 conjunction conjunction NN 40288 643 61 , , , 40288 643 62 ' ' '' 40288 643 63 especially especially RB 40288 643 64 of of IN 40288 643 65 beautiful beautiful JJ 40288 643 66 sounds sound NNS 40288 643 67 , , , 40288 643 68 since since IN 40288 643 69 it -PRON- PRP 40288 643 70 is be VBZ 40288 643 71 most most RBS 40288 643 72 often often RB 40288 643 73 heard hear VBN 40288 643 74 among among IN 40288 643 75 these these DT 40288 643 76 . . . 40288 643 77 ' ' '' 40288 644 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 644 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 644 3 1 1 CD 40288 644 4 : : : 40288 644 5 _ _ NNP 40288 644 6 Die Die NNP 40288 644 7 Lehre Lehre NNP 40288 644 8 von von NNP 40288 644 9 den den NN 40288 644 10 Tonempfindungen Tonempfindungen NNP 40288 644 11 _ _ NNP 40288 644 12 , , , 40288 644 13 p. p. NN 40288 644 14 367 367 CD 40288 644 15 , , , 40288 644 16 ed ed NN 40288 644 17 . . . 40288 645 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 645 2 . . . 40288 645 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 646 1 In in IN 40288 646 2 another another DT 40288 646 3 place place NN 40288 646 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 646 5 xix xix NNP 40288 646 6 . . . 40288 647 1 36 36 LS 40288 647 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 647 3 the the DT 40288 647 4 question question NN 40288 647 5 is be VBZ 40288 647 6 answered answer VBN 40288 647 7 by by IN 40288 647 8 saying say VBG 40288 647 9 that that IN 40288 647 10 the the DT 40288 647 11 notes note NNS 40288 647 12 of of IN 40288 647 13 a a DT 40288 647 14 scale scale NN 40288 647 15 stand stand NN 40288 647 16 in in IN 40288 647 17 a a DT 40288 647 18 certain certain JJ 40288 647 19 relation relation NN 40288 647 20 to to IN 40288 647 21 the the DT 40288 647 22 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 647 23 , , , 40288 647 24 which which WDT 40288 647 25 determines determine VBZ 40288 647 26 them -PRON- PRP 40288 647 27 with with IN 40288 647 28 reference reference NN 40288 647 29 to to IN 40288 647 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 647 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 647 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 647 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 647 34 : : : 40288 647 35 hê hê VB 40288 647 36 taxis taxi NNS 40288 647 37 hê hê VB 40288 647 38 hekastês hekastês NNP 40288 647 39 êdê êdê NNP 40288 647 40 di di NNP 40288 647 41 ' ' '' 40288 647 42 ekeinên ekeinên NN 40288 647 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 647 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 647 45 : : : 40288 647 46 so so IN 40288 647 47 that that IN 40288 647 48 the the DT 40288 647 49 loss loss NN 40288 647 50 of of IN 40288 647 51 the the DT 40288 647 52 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 647 53 means mean VBZ 40288 647 54 the the DT 40288 647 55 loss loss NN 40288 647 56 of of IN 40288 647 57 the the DT 40288 647 58 ground ground NN 40288 647 59 and and CC 40288 647 60 unifying unifying NN 40288 647 61 element element NN 40288 647 62 of of IN 40288 647 63 the the DT 40288 647 64 scale scale NN 40288 647 65 ( ( -LRB- 40288 647 66 [ [ -LRB- 40288 647 67 Greek Greek NNP 40288 647 68 : : : 40288 647 69 arthentos arthentos NNP 40288 647 70 tou tou NNP 40288 647 71 aitiou aitiou NNP 40288 647 72 tou tou NNP 40288 647 73 hêrmosthai hêrmosthai NNP 40288 647 74 kai kai NNP 40288 647 75 tou tou NNP 40288 647 76 synechontos])[1 synechontos])[1 NNP 40288 647 77 ] ] -RRB- 40288 647 78 . . . 40288 648 1 These these DT 40288 648 2 passages passage NNS 40288 648 3 imply imply VBP 40288 648 4 that that IN 40288 648 5 in in IN 40288 648 6 the the DT 40288 648 7 scale scale NN 40288 648 8 known know VBN 40288 648 9 to to IN 40288 648 10 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 648 11 , , , 40288 648 12 viz viz NN 40288 648 13 . . . 40288 649 1 the the DT 40288 649 2 octave octave NN 40288 649 3 _ _ NNP 40288 649 4 e e NNP 40288 649 5 - - HYPH 40288 649 6 e e NNP 40288 649 7 _ _ NNP 40288 649 8 , , , 40288 649 9 the the DT 40288 649 10 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 649 11 _ _ NNP 40288 649 12 a a DT 40288 649 13 _ _ NNP 40288 649 14 had have VBD 40288 649 15 the the DT 40288 649 16 character character NN 40288 649 17 of of IN 40288 649 18 a a DT 40288 649 19 Tonic Tonic NNP 40288 649 20 or or CC 40288 649 21 key key NN 40288 649 22 - - HYPH 40288 649 23 note note NN 40288 649 24 . . . 40288 650 1 This this DT 40288 650 2 must must MD 40288 650 3 have have VB 40288 650 4 been be VBN 40288 650 5 true true JJ 40288 650 6 _ _ NNP 40288 650 7 a a DT 40288 650 8 fortiori fortiori NN 40288 650 9 _ _ NNP 40288 650 10 of of IN 40288 650 11 the the DT 40288 650 12 older old JJR 40288 650 13 seven seven CD 40288 650 14 - - HYPH 40288 650 15 stringed string VBN 40288 650 16 scale scale NN 40288 650 17 , , , 40288 650 18 in in IN 40288 650 19 which which WDT 40288 650 20 the the DT 40288 650 21 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 650 22 united unite VBD 40288 650 23 the the DT 40288 650 24 two two CD 40288 650 25 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 650 26 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 650 27 . . . 40288 651 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 651 2 was be VBD 40288 651 3 quite quite RB 40288 651 4 in in IN 40288 651 5 accordance accordance NN 40288 651 6 with with IN 40288 651 7 this this DT 40288 651 8 state state NN 40288 651 9 of of IN 40288 651 10 things thing NNS 40288 651 11 that that WDT 40288 651 12 the the DT 40288 651 13 later later JJ 40288 651 14 enlargement enlargement NN 40288 651 15 completed complete VBD 40288 651 16 the the DT 40288 651 17 octaves octave NNS 40288 651 18 from from IN 40288 651 19 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 651 20 downwards downward NNS 40288 651 21 and and CC 40288 651 22 upwards upwards RB 40288 651 23 , , , 40288 651 24 so so IN 40288 651 25 that that IN 40288 651 26 the the DT 40288 651 27 scale scale NN 40288 651 28 consisted consist VBD 40288 651 29 of of IN 40288 651 30 two two CD 40288 651 31 octaves octave NNS 40288 651 32 of of IN 40288 651 33 the the DT 40288 651 34 form form NN 40288 651 35 _ _ NNP 40288 651 36 a a DT 40288 651 37 - - : 40288 651 38 a a FW 40288 651 39 _ _ NN 40288 651 40 . . . 40288 652 1 As as IN 40288 652 2 to to IN 40288 652 3 the the DT 40288 652 4 question question NN 40288 652 5 how how WRB 40288 652 6 the the DT 40288 652 7 Tonic Tonic NNP 40288 652 8 character character NN 40288 652 9 of of IN 40288 652 10 the the DT 40288 652 11 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 652 12 was be VBD 40288 652 13 shown show VBN 40288 652 14 , , , 40288 652 15 in in IN 40288 652 16 what what WP 40288 652 17 parts part NNS 40288 652 18 of of IN 40288 652 19 the the DT 40288 652 20 melody melody NN 40288 652 21 it -PRON- PRP 40288 652 22 was be VBD 40288 652 23 necessarily necessarily RB 40288 652 24 heard hear VBN 40288 652 25 , , , 40288 652 26 and and CC 40288 652 27 the the DT 40288 652 28 like like JJ 40288 652 29 , , , 40288 652 30 we -PRON- PRP 40288 652 31 can can MD 40288 652 32 but but CC 40288 652 33 guess guess VB 40288 652 34 . . . 40288 653 1 The the DT 40288 653 2 statement statement NN 40288 653 3 of of IN 40288 653 4 the the DT 40288 653 5 _ _ NNP 40288 653 6 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 653 7 _ _ NNP 40288 653 8 is be VBZ 40288 653 9 not not RB 40288 653 10 repeated repeat VBN 40288 653 11 by by IN 40288 653 12 any any DT 40288 653 13 technical technical JJ 40288 653 14 writer writer NN 40288 653 15 , , , 40288 653 16 and and CC 40288 653 17 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 653 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 653 19 does do VBZ 40288 653 20 not not RB 40288 653 21 appear appear VB 40288 653 22 that that IN 40288 653 23 any any DT 40288 653 24 rules rule NNS 40288 653 25 on on IN 40288 653 26 the the DT 40288 653 27 subject subject NN 40288 653 28 had have VBD 40288 653 29 been be VBN 40288 653 30 arrived arrive VBN 40288 653 31 at at IN 40288 653 32 . . . 40288 654 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 654 2 is be VBZ 40288 654 3 significant significant JJ 40288 654 4 , , , 40288 654 5 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 654 6 , , , 40288 654 7 that that IN 40288 654 8 the the DT 40288 654 9 frequent frequent JJ 40288 654 10 use use NN 40288 654 11 of of IN 40288 654 12 the the DT 40288 654 13 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 654 14 is be VBZ 40288 654 15 spoken speak VBN 40288 654 16 of of IN 40288 654 17 as as IN 40288 654 18 characteristic characteristic NN 40288 654 19 of of IN 40288 654 20 _ _ NNP 40288 654 21 good good JJ 40288 654 22 _ _ NNP 40288 654 23 melody melody NN 40288 654 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 654 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 654 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 654 27 : : : 40288 654 28 panta panta NNP 40288 654 29 ta ta NNP 40288 654 30 chrêsta chrêsta NNP 40288 654 31 melê melê NNP 40288 654 32 pollakis pollakis NNP 40288 654 33 tê tê DT 40288 654 34 mesê mesê NNP 40288 654 35 chrêtai chrêtai NNP 40288 654 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 654 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 654 38 , , , 40288 654 39 as as IN 40288 654 40 though though IN 40288 654 41 tonality tonality NN 40288 654 42 were be VBD 40288 654 43 a a DT 40288 654 44 merit merit NN 40288 654 45 rather rather RB 40288 654 46 than than IN 40288 654 47 a a DT 40288 654 48 necessity necessity NN 40288 654 49 . . . 40288 655 1 Another another DT 40288 655 2 passage passage NN 40288 655 3 of of IN 40288 655 4 the the DT 40288 655 5 _ _ NNP 40288 655 6 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 655 7 _ _ NNP 40288 655 8 has have VBZ 40288 655 9 been be VBN 40288 655 10 thought think VBN 40288 655 11 to to TO 40288 655 12 show show VB 40288 655 13 that that IN 40288 655 14 in in IN 40288 655 15 Greek greek JJ 40288 655 16 music music NN 40288 655 17 the the DT 40288 655 18 melody melody NN 40288 655 19 ended end VBD 40288 655 20 on on IN 40288 655 21 the the DT 40288 655 22 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 655 23 . . . 40288 656 1 The the DT 40288 656 2 words word NNS 40288 656 3 are be VBP 40288 656 4 these these DT 40288 656 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 656 6 _ _ NNP 40288 656 7 Probl Probl NNP 40288 656 8 . . . 40288 656 9 _ _ NNP 40288 656 10 xix xix NNP 40288 656 11 . . . 40288 657 1 33 33 CD 40288 657 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 657 3 : : : 40288 657 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 657 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 657 6 : : : 40288 657 7 Dia Dia NNP 40288 657 8 ti ti IN 40288 657 9 euarmostoteron euarmostoteron NNP 40288 657 10 apo apo NNP 40288 657 11 tou tou NNP 40288 657 12 oxeos oxeos NNP 40288 657 13 epi epi NNP 40288 657 14 to to IN 40288 657 15 bary bary NNP 40288 657 16 ê ê NNP 40288 657 17 apo apo NNP 40288 657 18 tou tou NNP 40288 657 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 657 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 657 21 Footnote footnote NN 40288 657 22 1 1 CD 40288 657 23 : : : 40288 657 24 So so RB 40288 657 25 in in IN 40288 657 26 the the DT 40288 657 27 Euclidean Euclidean NNP 40288 657 28 _ _ NNP 40288 657 29 Sectio Sectio NNP 40288 657 30 Canonis Canonis NNP 40288 657 31 _ _ NNP 40288 657 32 the the DT 40288 657 33 propositions proposition NNS 40288 657 34 which which WDT 40288 657 35 deal deal VBP 40288 657 36 with with IN 40288 657 37 the the DT 40288 657 38 ' ' `` 40288 657 39 movable movable JJ 40288 657 40 ' ' '' 40288 657 41 notes note NNS 40288 657 42 , , , 40288 657 43 viz viz NN 40288 657 44 . . . 40288 658 1 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 658 2 and and CC 40288 658 3 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 658 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 658 5 Theor Theor NNP 40288 658 6 . . . 40288 659 1 xvii xvii NN 40288 659 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 659 3 and and CC 40288 659 4 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 659 5 and and CC 40288 659 6 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 659 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 659 8 Theor Theor NNP 40288 659 9 . . . 40288 660 1 xviii xviii NNP 40288 660 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 660 3 , , , 40288 660 4 begin begin VB 40288 660 5 by by IN 40288 660 6 postulating postulate VBG 40288 660 7 the the DT 40288 660 8 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 660 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 660 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 660 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 660 12 : : : 40288 660 13 estô estô NN 40288 660 14 gar gar NN 40288 660 15 mesê mesê NNP 40288 660 16 ho ho NNP 40288 660 17 B B NNP 40288 660 18 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 660 19 . . . 40288 660 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 660 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 660 22 . . . 40288 660 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 661 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 661 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 661 3 : : : 40288 661 4 bareos bareos JJ 40288 661 5 epi epi NNP 40288 661 6 to to IN 40288 661 7 oxy oxy NN 40288 661 8 ; ; : 40288 661 9 poteron poteron NN 40288 661 10 hoti hoti NNP 40288 661 11 to to TO 40288 661 12 apo apo VB 40288 661 13 tês tês NNP 40288 661 14 archês archês NNP 40288 661 15 ginetai ginetai NNP 40288 661 16 archesthai archesthai NNP 40288 661 17 ? ? . 40288 662 1 hê hê NNP 40288 662 2 gar gar NNP 40288 662 3 mesê mesê NNP 40288 662 4 kai kai NNP 40288 662 5 hêgemôn hêgemôn NNP 40288 662 6 oxytatê oxytatê NNP 40288 662 7 tou tou NNP 40288 662 8 tetrachordou tetrachordou NNP 40288 662 9 ; ; : 40288 662 10 to to IN 40288 662 11 de de NNP 40288 662 12 ouk ouk NNP 40288 662 13 ap ap NNP 40288 662 14 ' ' `` 40288 662 15 archês archê VBD 40288 662 16 all all DT 40288 662 17 ' ' '' 40288 662 18 apo apo NNP 40288 662 19 teleutês teleutês NN 40288 662 20 . . . 40288 662 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 663 1 ' ' `` 40288 663 2 Why why WRB 40288 663 3 is be VBZ 40288 663 4 a a DT 40288 663 5 descending descend VBG 40288 663 6 scale scale NN 40288 663 7 more more RBR 40288 663 8 musical musical JJ 40288 663 9 than than IN 40288 663 10 an an DT 40288 663 11 ascending ascend VBG 40288 663 12 one one CD 40288 663 13 ? ? . 40288 664 1 Is be VBZ 40288 664 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 664 3 that that DT 40288 664 4 in in IN 40288 664 5 this this DT 40288 664 6 order order NN 40288 664 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 664 8 begin begin VBP 40288 664 9 with with IN 40288 664 10 the the DT 40288 664 11 beginning,--since beginning,--since NNP 40288 664 12 the the DT 40288 664 13 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 664 14 or or CC 40288 664 15 leading lead VBG 40288 664 16 note[1 note[1 NNP 40288 664 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 664 18 is be VBZ 40288 664 19 the the DT 40288 664 20 highest high JJS 40288 664 21 of of IN 40288 664 22 the the DT 40288 664 23 tetrachord,--but tetrachord,--but NNP 40288 664 24 with with IN 40288 664 25 the the DT 40288 664 26 reverse reverse JJ 40288 664 27 order order NN 40288 664 28 we -PRON- PRP 40288 664 29 begin begin VBP 40288 664 30 with with IN 40288 664 31 the the DT 40288 664 32 end end NN 40288 664 33 ? ? . 40288 664 34 ' ' '' 40288 665 1 There there EX 40288 665 2 is be VBZ 40288 665 3 here here RB 40288 665 4 no no DT 40288 665 5 explicit explicit JJ 40288 665 6 statement statement NN 40288 665 7 that that IN 40288 665 8 the the DT 40288 665 9 melody melody NN 40288 665 10 ended end VBD 40288 665 11 on on IN 40288 665 12 the the DT 40288 665 13 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 665 14 , , , 40288 665 15 or or CC 40288 665 16 even even RB 40288 665 17 that that IN 40288 665 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 665 19 began begin VBD 40288 665 20 with with IN 40288 665 21 the the DT 40288 665 22 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 665 23 . . . 40288 666 1 In in IN 40288 666 2 what what WDT 40288 666 3 sense sense NN 40288 666 4 , , , 40288 666 5 then then RB 40288 666 6 , , , 40288 666 7 was be VBD 40288 666 8 the the DT 40288 666 9 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 666 10 a a DT 40288 666 11 ' ' `` 40288 666 12 beginning beginning NN 40288 666 13 ' ' '' 40288 666 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 666 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 666 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 666 17 : : : 40288 666 18 archê archê NNP 40288 666 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 666 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 666 21 , , , 40288 666 22 and and CC 40288 666 23 the the DT 40288 666 24 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 666 25 an an DT 40288 666 26 ' ' `` 40288 666 27 end end NN 40288 666 28 ' ' '' 40288 666 29 ? ? . 40288 667 1 In in IN 40288 667 2 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40288 667 3 language language NN 40288 667 4 the the DT 40288 667 5 word word NN 40288 667 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 667 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 667 8 : : : 40288 667 9 archê archê NNP 40288 667 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 667 11 has have VBZ 40288 667 12 various various JJ 40288 667 13 senses sense NNS 40288 667 14 . . . 40288 668 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 668 2 might may MD 40288 668 3 be be VB 40288 668 4 used use VBN 40288 668 5 to to TO 40288 668 6 express express VB 40288 668 7 the the DT 40288 668 8 relation relation NN 40288 668 9 of of IN 40288 668 10 the the DT 40288 668 11 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 668 12 to to IN 40288 668 13 the the DT 40288 668 14 other other JJ 40288 668 15 notes note NNS 40288 668 16 as as IN 40288 668 17 the the DT 40288 668 18 basis basis NN 40288 668 19 or or CC 40288 668 20 ground ground NN 40288 668 21 - - HYPH 40288 668 22 work work NN 40288 668 23 of of IN 40288 668 24 the the DT 40288 668 25 scale scale NN 40288 668 26 . . . 40288 669 1 Other other JJ 40288 669 2 passages passage NNS 40288 669 3 , , , 40288 669 4 however however RB 40288 669 5 , , , 40288 669 6 point point VBP 40288 669 7 to to IN 40288 669 8 a a DT 40288 669 9 simpler simple JJR 40288 669 10 explanation explanation NN 40288 669 11 , , , 40288 669 12 viz viz NN 40288 669 13 . . . 40288 670 1 that that IN 40288 670 2 the the DT 40288 670 3 order order NN 40288 670 4 in in IN 40288 670 5 question question NN 40288 670 6 was be VBD 40288 670 7 merely merely RB 40288 670 8 conventional conventional JJ 40288 670 9 . . . 40288 671 1 In in IN 40288 671 2 _ _ NNP 40288 671 3 Probl Probl NNP 40288 671 4 . . . 40288 671 5 _ _ NNP 40288 671 6 xix xix NNP 40288 671 7 . . . 40288 672 1 44 44 CD 40288 672 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 672 3 is be VBZ 40288 672 4 said say VBN 40288 672 5 that that IN 40288 672 6 the the DT 40288 672 7 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 672 8 is be VBZ 40288 672 9 the the DT 40288 672 10 beginning beginning NN 40288 672 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 672 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 672 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 672 14 : : : 40288 672 15 archê archê NNP 40288 672 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 672 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 672 18 of of IN 40288 672 19 one one CD 40288 672 20 of of IN 40288 672 21 the the DT 40288 672 22 two two CD 40288 672 23 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 672 24 which which WDT 40288 672 25 form form VBP 40288 672 26 the the DT 40288 672 27 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 672 28 octave octave NN 40288 672 29 scale scale NN 40288 672 30 ( ( -LRB- 40288 672 31 viz viz NN 40288 672 32 . . . 40288 673 1 the the DT 40288 673 2 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 673 3 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 673 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 673 5 ; ; : 40288 673 6 and and CC 40288 673 7 again again RB 40288 673 8 in in IN 40288 673 9 _ _ NNP 40288 673 10 Probl Probl NNP 40288 673 11 . . . 40288 673 12 _ _ NNP 40288 673 13 xix xix NNP 40288 673 14 . . . 40288 674 1 47 47 CD 40288 674 2 that that IN 40288 674 3 in in IN 40288 674 4 the the DT 40288 674 5 old old JJ 40288 674 6 heptachord heptachord NN 40288 674 7 which which WDT 40288 674 8 consisted consist VBD 40288 674 9 of of IN 40288 674 10 two two CD 40288 674 11 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 674 12 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 674 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 674 14 _ _ NNP 40288 674 15 e e NNP 40288 674 16 - - HYPH 40288 674 17 a a DT 40288 674 18 - - HYPH 40288 674 19 d d NNP 40288 674 20 _ _ NN 40288 674 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 674 22 the the DT 40288 674 23 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 674 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 674 25 _ _ NNP 40288 674 26 a a DT 40288 674 27 _ _ NNP 40288 674 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 674 29 was be VBD 40288 674 30 the the DT 40288 674 31 end end NN 40288 674 32 of of IN 40288 674 33 the the DT 40288 674 34 upper upper JJ 40288 674 35 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 674 36 and and CC 40288 674 37 the the DT 40288 674 38 beginning beginning NN 40288 674 39 of of IN 40288 674 40 the the DT 40288 674 41 lower low JJR 40288 674 42 one one NN 40288 674 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 674 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 674 45 Greek Greek NNP 40288 674 46 : : : 40288 674 47 hoti hoti NNP 40288 674 48 ên ên NNP 40288 674 49 tou tou NNP 40288 674 50 men men NNP 40288 674 51 anô anô NNP 40288 674 52 tetrachordou tetrachordou NNP 40288 674 53 teleutê teleutê NNP 40288 674 54 , , , 40288 674 55 tou tou NNP 40288 674 56 de de NNP 40288 674 57 katô katô NNP 40288 674 58 archê archê NNP 40288 674 59 ] ] -RRB- 40288 674 60 ) ) -RRB- 40288 674 61 . . . 40288 675 1 In in IN 40288 675 2 this this DT 40288 675 3 last last JJ 40288 675 4 passage passage NN 40288 675 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 675 6 is be VBZ 40288 675 7 evident evident JJ 40288 675 8 that that IN 40288 675 9 there there EX 40288 675 10 is be VBZ 40288 675 11 no no DT 40288 675 12 reference reference NN 40288 675 13 to to IN 40288 675 14 the the DT 40288 675 15 beginning beginning NN 40288 675 16 or or CC 40288 675 17 end end NN 40288 675 18 of of IN 40288 675 19 the the DT 40288 675 20 melody melody NN 40288 675 21 . . . 40288 676 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 676 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 676 3 1 1 CD 40288 676 4 : : : 40288 676 5 The the DT 40288 676 6 term term NN 40288 676 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 676 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 676 9 : : : 40288 676 10 hêgemôn hêgemôn NNP 40288 676 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 676 12 or or CC 40288 676 13 ' ' `` 40288 676 14 leading leading JJ 40288 676 15 note note NN 40288 676 16 ' ' '' 40288 676 17 of of IN 40288 676 18 the the DT 40288 676 19 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 676 20 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 676 21 , , , 40288 676 22 here here RB 40288 676 23 applied apply VBD 40288 676 24 to to IN 40288 676 25 the the DT 40288 676 26 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 676 27 , , , 40288 676 28 is be VBZ 40288 676 29 found find VBN 40288 676 30 in in IN 40288 676 31 the the DT 40288 676 32 same same JJ 40288 676 33 sense sense NN 40288 676 34 in in IN 40288 676 35 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 676 36 , , , 40288 676 37 _ _ NNP 40288 676 38 De De NNP 40288 676 39 Mus Mus NNP 40288 676 40 . . . 40288 676 41 _ _ NNP 40288 676 42 c. c. NNP 40288 676 43 11 11 CD 40288 676 44 , , , 40288 676 45 where where WRB 40288 676 46 [ [ -LRB- 40288 676 47 Greek Greek NNP 40288 676 48 : : : 40288 676 49 ho ho NNP 40288 676 50 peri peri NNP 40288 676 51 ton ton NNP 40288 676 52 hêgemona hêgemona NNP 40288 676 53 keimenos keimenos NNP 40288 676 54 tonos tonos , 40288 676 55 ] ] -RRB- 40288 676 56 means mean VBZ 40288 676 57 the the DT 40288 676 58 disjunctive disjunctive JJ 40288 676 59 tone tone NN 40288 676 60 . . . 40288 677 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 677 2 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 677 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 677 4 _ _ NNP 40288 677 5 Harm Harm NNP 40288 677 6 . . . 40288 677 7 _ _ NNP 40288 677 8 i. i. NNP 40288 678 1 16 16 LS 40288 678 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 678 3 speaks speak VBZ 40288 678 4 of of IN 40288 678 5 the the DT 40288 678 6 tones tone NNS 40288 678 7 in in IN 40288 678 8 a a DT 40288 678 9 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 678 10 scale scale NN 40288 678 11 as as IN 40288 678 12 being be VBG 40288 678 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 678 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 678 15 : : : 40288 678 16 en en NNP 40288 678 17 tois tois NNP 40288 678 18 hêgoumenois hêgoumenois NNP 40288 678 19 topois topois NNP 40288 678 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 678 21 , , , 40288 678 22 the the DT 40288 678 23 semitones semitone NNS 40288 678 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 678 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 678 26 : : : 40288 678 27 en en NNP 40288 678 28 tois tois NNP 40288 678 29 hepomenois hepomenois NNP 40288 678 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 678 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 678 32 sc sc IN 40288 678 33 . . . 40288 679 1 of of IN 40288 679 2 the the DT 40288 679 3 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 679 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 679 5 : : : 40288 679 6 and and CC 40288 679 7 again again RB 40288 679 8 of of IN 40288 679 9 the the DT 40288 679 10 ratio ratio NN 40288 679 11 5:4 5:4 CD 40288 679 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 679 13 the the DT 40288 679 14 major major JJ 40288 679 15 Third Third NNP 40288 679 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 679 17 as as IN 40288 679 18 the the DT 40288 679 19 ' ' `` 40288 679 20 leading lead VBG 40288 679 21 ' ' '' 40288 679 22 one one CD 40288 679 23 of of IN 40288 679 24 an an DT 40288 679 25 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 679 26 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 679 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 679 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 679 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 679 30 : : : 40288 679 31 ton ton NN 40288 679 32 epitetarton epitetarton NNP 40288 679 33 hos hos NNP 40288 679 34 estin estin NNP 40288 679 35 hêgoumenos hêgoumenos NNP 40288 679 36 tou tou NNP 40288 679 37 enarmoniou enarmoniou NNP 40288 679 38 genous genous NNP 40288 679 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 679 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 679 41 . . . 40288 679 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 680 1 Another another DT 40288 680 2 instance instance NN 40288 680 3 of of IN 40288 680 4 the the DT 40288 680 5 use use NN 40288 680 6 of of IN 40288 680 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 680 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 680 9 : : : 40288 680 10 archê archê NNP 40288 680 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 680 12 in in IN 40288 680 13 connexion connexion NN 40288 680 14 with with IN 40288 680 15 the the DT 40288 680 16 musical musical JJ 40288 680 17 scale scale NN 40288 680 18 is be VBZ 40288 680 19 to to TO 40288 680 20 be be VB 40288 680 21 found find VBN 40288 680 22 in in IN 40288 680 23 the the DT 40288 680 24 _ _ NNP 40288 680 25 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 40288 680 26 _ _ NNP 40288 680 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 680 28 iv iv UH 40288 680 29 . . . 40288 681 1 11 11 CD 40288 681 2 , , , 40288 681 3 p. p. NN 40288 681 4 1018 1018 CD 40288 681 5 _ _ NNP 40288 681 6 b b NNP 40288 681 7 _ _ NNP 40288 681 8 26 26 CD 40288 681 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 681 10 , , , 40288 681 11 where where WRB 40288 681 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 681 13 is be VBZ 40288 681 14 speaking speak VBG 40288 681 15 of of IN 40288 681 16 the the DT 40288 681 17 different different JJ 40288 681 18 senses sense NNS 40288 681 19 in in IN 40288 681 20 which which WDT 40288 681 21 things thing NNS 40288 681 22 may may MD 40288 681 23 be be VB 40288 681 24 prior prior RB 40288 681 25 and and CC 40288 681 26 posterior posterior RB 40288 681 27 : : : 40288 681 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 681 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 681 30 : : : 40288 681 31 Ta Ta NNP 40288 681 32 de de NNP 40288 681 33 kata kata NNP 40288 681 34 taxin taxin NNP 40288 681 35 ; ; : 40288 681 36 tauta tauta NNP 40288 681 37 d d NNP 40288 681 38 ' ' POS 40288 681 39 estin estin NNP 40288 681 40 hosa hosa NNP 40288 681 41 pros pros NNP 40288 681 42 ti ti NNP 40288 681 43 hen hen NNP 40288 681 44 hôrismenon hôrismenon NNP 40288 681 45 diestêke diestêke NNP 40288 681 46 kata kata NNP 40288 681 47 ton ton NNP 40288 681 48 logon logon NNP 40288 681 49 , , , 40288 681 50 hoion hoion NN 40288 681 51 parastatês parastatês NN 40288 681 52 tritostatou tritostatou NNP 40288 681 53 proteron proteron NNP 40288 681 54 , , , 40288 681 55 kai kai NNP 40288 681 56 paranêtê paranêtê NNP 40288 681 57 nêtês nêtês NNP 40288 681 58 ; ; : 40288 681 59 entha entha NN 40288 681 60 men man NNS 40288 681 61 gar gar VBP 40288 681 62 ho ho FW 40288 681 63 koryphaios koryphaios NNP 40288 681 64 , , , 40288 681 65 entha entha NNP 40288 681 66 de de FW 40288 681 67 hê hê NNP 40288 681 68 mesê mesê NNP 40288 681 69 archê archê NNP 40288 681 70 . . . 40288 681 71 ] ] -RRB- 40288 682 1 ' ' `` 40288 682 2 Other other JJ 40288 682 3 things thing NNS 40288 682 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 682 5 are be VBP 40288 682 6 prior prior JJ 40288 682 7 and and CC 40288 682 8 posterior posterior JJ 40288 682 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 682 10 in in IN 40288 682 11 _ _ NNP 40288 682 12 order order NN 40288 682 13 _ _ NNP 40288 682 14 : : : 40288 682 15 viz viz NN 40288 682 16 . . . 40288 683 1 those those DT 40288 683 2 which which WDT 40288 683 3 are be VBP 40288 683 4 at at IN 40288 683 5 a a DT 40288 683 6 varying varying NN 40288 683 7 interval interval NN 40288 683 8 from from IN 40288 683 9 some some DT 40288 683 10 one one CD 40288 683 11 definite definite JJ 40288 683 12 thing thing NN 40288 683 13 ; ; : 40288 683 14 as as IN 40288 683 15 the the DT 40288 683 16 second second JJ 40288 683 17 man man NN 40288 683 18 in in IN 40288 683 19 the the DT 40288 683 20 rank rank NN 40288 683 21 is be VBZ 40288 683 22 prior prior JJ 40288 683 23 to to IN 40288 683 24 the the DT 40288 683 25 third third JJ 40288 683 26 man man NN 40288 683 27 , , , 40288 683 28 and and CC 40288 683 29 the the DT 40288 683 30 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 683 31 to to IN 40288 683 32 the the DT 40288 683 33 Nêtê nêtê NN 40288 683 34 : : : 40288 683 35 for for IN 40288 683 36 in in IN 40288 683 37 the the DT 40288 683 38 one one CD 40288 683 39 case case NN 40288 683 40 the the DT 40288 683 41 coryphaeus coryphaeus NN 40288 683 42 is be VBZ 40288 683 43 the the DT 40288 683 44 starting starting NN 40288 683 45 - - HYPH 40288 683 46 point point NN 40288 683 47 , , , 40288 683 48 in in IN 40288 683 49 the the DT 40288 683 50 other other JJ 40288 683 51 the the DT 40288 683 52 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 683 53 . . . 40288 683 54 ' ' '' 40288 684 1 Here here RB 40288 684 2 the the DT 40288 684 3 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 684 4 is be VBZ 40288 684 5 again again RB 40288 684 6 the the DT 40288 684 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 684 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 684 9 : : : 40288 684 10 archê archê NN 40288 684 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 684 12 or or CC 40288 684 13 beginning beginning NN 40288 684 14 , , , 40288 684 15 but but CC 40288 684 16 the the DT 40288 684 17 order order NN 40288 684 18 is be VBZ 40288 684 19 the the DT 40288 684 20 ascending ascend VBG 40288 684 21 one one CD 40288 684 22 , , , 40288 684 23 and and CC 40288 684 24 consequently consequently RB 40288 684 25 the the DT 40288 684 26 Nêtê nêtê JJ 40288 684 27 is be VBZ 40288 684 28 the the DT 40288 684 29 end end NN 40288 684 30 . . . 40288 685 1 The the DT 40288 685 2 passage passage NN 40288 685 3 confirms confirm VBZ 40288 685 4 what what WP 40288 685 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 685 6 have have VBP 40288 685 7 learned learn VBN 40288 685 8 of of IN 40288 685 9 the the DT 40288 685 10 relative relative JJ 40288 685 11 importance importance NN 40288 685 12 of of IN 40288 685 13 the the DT 40288 685 14 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 685 15 : : : 40288 685 16 but but CC 40288 685 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 685 18 certainly certainly RB 40288 685 19 negatives negative VBZ 40288 685 20 any any DT 40288 685 21 inference inference NN 40288 685 22 regarding regard VBG 40288 685 23 the the DT 40288 685 24 note note NN 40288 685 25 on on IN 40288 685 26 which which WDT 40288 685 27 the the DT 40288 685 28 melody melody NN 40288 685 29 ended end VBD 40288 685 30 . . . 40288 686 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 686 2 appears appear VBZ 40288 686 3 , , , 40288 686 4 then then RB 40288 686 5 , , , 40288 686 6 that that IN 40288 686 7 the the DT 40288 686 8 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 686 9 of of IN 40288 686 10 the the DT 40288 686 11 Greek greek JJ 40288 686 12 standard standard NN 40288 686 13 System System NNP 40288 686 14 had have VBD 40288 686 15 the the DT 40288 686 16 functions function NNS 40288 686 17 of of IN 40288 686 18 a a DT 40288 686 19 key key JJ 40288 686 20 - - HYPH 40288 686 21 note note NN 40288 686 22 in in IN 40288 686 23 that that DT 40288 686 24 System system NN 40288 686 25 . . . 40288 687 1 In in IN 40288 687 2 other other JJ 40288 687 3 words word NNS 40288 687 4 , , , 40288 687 5 the the DT 40288 687 6 music music NN 40288 687 7 was be VBD 40288 687 8 in in IN 40288 687 9 the the DT 40288 687 10 _ _ NNP 40288 687 11 mode mode NN 40288 687 12 _ _ NNP 40288 687 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 687 14 using use VBG 40288 687 15 that that DT 40288 687 16 term term NN 40288 687 17 in in IN 40288 687 18 the the DT 40288 687 19 modern modern JJ 40288 687 20 sense sense NN 40288 687 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 687 22 represented represent VBN 40288 687 23 by by IN 40288 687 24 the the DT 40288 687 25 octave octave NN 40288 687 26 _ _ NNP 40288 687 27 a a DT 40288 687 28 - - : 40288 687 29 a a DT 40288 687 30 _ _ NNP 40288 687 31 of of IN 40288 687 32 the the DT 40288 687 33 natural natural JJ 40288 687 34 key key NN 40288 687 35 -- -- : 40288 687 36 the the DT 40288 687 37 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 687 38 - - HYPH 40288 687 39 dorian dorian JJ 40288 687 40 or or CC 40288 687 41 Common Common NNP 40288 687 42 Species Species NNPS 40288 687 43 . . . 40288 688 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 688 2 do do VBP 40288 688 3 not not RB 40288 688 4 indeed indeed RB 40288 688 5 know know VB 40288 688 6 how how WRB 40288 688 7 the the DT 40288 688 8 predominant predominant JJ 40288 688 9 character character NN 40288 688 10 of of IN 40288 688 11 the the DT 40288 688 12 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 688 13 was be VBD 40288 688 14 shown show VBN 40288 688 15 -- -- : 40288 688 16 whether whether IN 40288 688 17 , , , 40288 688 18 for for IN 40288 688 19 example example NN 40288 688 20 , , , 40288 688 21 the the DT 40288 688 22 melody melody NN 40288 688 23 ended end VBD 40288 688 24 on on IN 40288 688 25 the the DT 40288 688 26 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 688 27 . . . 40288 689 1 The the DT 40288 689 2 supposed suppose VBN 40288 689 3 evidence evidence NN 40288 689 4 for for IN 40288 689 5 an an DT 40288 689 6 ending ending NN 40288 689 7 on on IN 40288 689 8 the the DT 40288 689 9 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 689 10 has have VBZ 40288 689 11 been be VBN 40288 689 12 shown show VBN 40288 689 13 to to TO 40288 689 14 be be VB 40288 689 15 insufficient insufficient JJ 40288 689 16 . . . 40288 690 1 But but CC 40288 690 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 690 3 may may MD 40288 690 4 at at IN 40288 690 5 least least JJS 40288 690 6 hold hold VB 40288 690 7 that that IN 40288 690 8 as as RB 40288 690 9 far far RB 40288 690 10 as as IN 40288 690 11 the the DT 40288 690 12 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 690 13 was be VBD 40288 690 14 a a DT 40288 690 15 key key NN 40288 690 16 - - HYPH 40288 690 17 note note NN 40288 690 18 , , , 40288 690 19 so so RB 40288 690 20 far far RB 40288 690 21 the the DT 40288 690 22 Greek greek JJ 40288 690 23 scale scale NN 40288 690 24 was be VBD 40288 690 25 that that DT 40288 690 26 of of IN 40288 690 27 the the DT 40288 690 28 modern modern JJ 40288 690 29 Minor minor JJ 40288 690 30 mode mode NN 40288 690 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 690 32 descending descending NN 40288 690 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 690 34 . . . 40288 691 1 The the DT 40288 691 2 only only JJ 40288 691 3 way way NN 40288 691 4 of of IN 40288 691 5 escape escape NN 40288 691 6 from from IN 40288 691 7 this this DT 40288 691 8 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 691 9 is be VBZ 40288 691 10 to to TO 40288 691 11 deny deny VB 40288 691 12 that that IN 40288 691 13 the the DT 40288 691 14 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 691 15 of of IN 40288 691 16 _ _ NNP 40288 691 17 Probl Probl NNP 40288 691 18 . . . 40288 691 19 _ _ NNP 40288 691 20 xix xix NNP 40288 691 21 . . . 40288 692 1 20 20 CD 40288 692 2 was be VBD 40288 692 3 the the DT 40288 692 4 note note NN 40288 692 5 which which WDT 40288 692 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 692 7 have have VBP 40288 692 8 understood understand VBN 40288 692 9 by by IN 40288 692 10 the the DT 40288 692 11 term term NN 40288 692 12 -- -- : 40288 692 13 the the DT 40288 692 14 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 692 15 of of IN 40288 692 16 the the DT 40288 692 17 standard standard JJ 40288 692 18 System system NN 40288 692 19 . . . 40288 693 1 This this DT 40288 693 2 , , , 40288 693 3 as as IN 40288 693 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 693 5 shall shall MD 40288 693 6 presently presently RB 40288 693 7 see see VB 40288 693 8 , , , 40288 693 9 is be VBZ 40288 693 10 the the DT 40288 693 11 plea plea NN 40288 693 12 to to IN 40288 693 13 which which WDT 40288 693 14 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 693 15 has have VBZ 40288 693 16 recourse recourse JJ 40288 693 17 . . . 40288 694 1 § § ADD 40288 694 2 21 21 CD 40288 694 3 . . . 40288 695 1 _ _ NNP 40288 695 2 The the DT 40288 695 3 Species Species NNPS 40288 695 4 of of IN 40288 695 5 a a DT 40288 695 6 Scale Scale NNP 40288 695 7 . . . 40288 695 8 _ _ NNP 40288 695 9 The the DT 40288 695 10 object object NN 40288 695 11 of of IN 40288 695 12 the the DT 40288 695 13 preceding precede VBG 40288 695 14 discussion discussion NN 40288 695 15 has have VBZ 40288 695 16 been be VBN 40288 695 17 to to TO 40288 695 18 make make VB 40288 695 19 it -PRON- PRP 40288 695 20 clear clear JJ 40288 695 21 that that IN 40288 695 22 the the DT 40288 695 23 theory theory NN 40288 695 24 of of IN 40288 695 25 a a DT 40288 695 26 system system NN 40288 695 27 of of IN 40288 695 28 modes mode NNS 40288 695 29 -- -- : 40288 695 30 in in IN 40288 695 31 the the DT 40288 695 32 modern modern JJ 40288 695 33 sense sense NN 40288 695 34 of of IN 40288 695 35 the the DT 40288 695 36 word word NN 40288 695 37 -- -- : 40288 695 38 finds find VBZ 40288 695 39 no no DT 40288 695 40 support support NN 40288 695 41 from from IN 40288 695 42 the the DT 40288 695 43 earlier early JJR 40288 695 44 authorities authority NNS 40288 695 45 on on IN 40288 695 46 Greek greek JJ 40288 695 47 music music NN 40288 695 48 . . . 40288 696 1 There there EX 40288 696 2 is be VBZ 40288 696 3 , , , 40288 696 4 however however RB 40288 696 5 , , , 40288 696 6 evidence evidence NN 40288 696 7 to to TO 40288 696 8 show show VB 40288 696 9 that that IN 40288 696 10 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 696 11 , , , 40288 696 12 and and CC 40288 696 13 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 696 14 other other JJ 40288 696 15 writers writer NNS 40288 696 16 of of IN 40288 696 17 the the DT 40288 696 18 time time NN 40288 696 19 , , , 40288 696 20 gave give VBD 40288 696 21 much much JJ 40288 696 22 thought thought NN 40288 696 23 to to IN 40288 696 24 the the DT 40288 696 25 varieties variety NNS 40288 696 26 to to TO 40288 696 27 be be VB 40288 696 28 obtained obtain VBN 40288 696 29 by by IN 40288 696 30 taking take VBG 40288 696 31 the the DT 40288 696 32 intervals interval NNS 40288 696 33 of of IN 40288 696 34 a a DT 40288 696 35 scale scale NN 40288 696 36 in in IN 40288 696 37 different different JJ 40288 696 38 order order NN 40288 696 39 . . . 40288 697 1 These these DT 40288 697 2 varieties variety NNS 40288 697 3 they -PRON- PRP 40288 697 4 spoke speak VBD 40288 697 5 of of IN 40288 697 6 as as IN 40288 697 7 the the DT 40288 697 8 _ _ NNP 40288 697 9 forms form NNS 40288 697 10 _ _ NNP 40288 697 11 or or CC 40288 697 12 _ _ NNP 40288 697 13 species specie NNS 40288 697 14 _ _ NNP 40288 697 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 697 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 697 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 697 18 : : : 40288 697 19 schêmata schêmata NN 40288 697 20 , , , 40288 697 21 eidê eidê NN 40288 697 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 697 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 697 24 of of IN 40288 697 25 the the DT 40288 697 26 interval interval NN 40288 697 27 which which WDT 40288 697 28 measured measure VBD 40288 697 29 the the DT 40288 697 30 compass compass NN 40288 697 31 of of IN 40288 697 32 the the DT 40288 697 33 scale scale NN 40288 697 34 in in IN 40288 697 35 question question NN 40288 697 36 . . . 40288 698 1 Thus thus RB 40288 698 2 , , , 40288 698 3 the the DT 40288 698 4 interval interval NN 40288 698 5 of of IN 40288 698 6 the the DT 40288 698 7 Octave Octave NNP 40288 698 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 698 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 698 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 698 11 : : : 40288 698 12 dia dia NNP 40288 698 13 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 698 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 698 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 698 16 is be VBZ 40288 698 17 divided divide VBN 40288 698 18 into into IN 40288 698 19 seven seven CD 40288 698 20 intervals interval NNS 40288 698 21 , , , 40288 698 22 and and CC 40288 698 23 these these DT 40288 698 24 are be VBP 40288 698 25 , , , 40288 698 26 in in IN 40288 698 27 the the DT 40288 698 28 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 698 29 genus genus NN 40288 698 30 , , , 40288 698 31 five five CD 40288 698 32 tones tone NNS 40288 698 33 and and CC 40288 698 34 two two CD 40288 698 35 semitones semitone NNS 40288 698 36 , , , 40288 698 37 in in IN 40288 698 38 the the DT 40288 698 39 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 698 40 two two CD 40288 698 41 ditones ditone NNS 40288 698 42 , , , 40288 698 43 four four CD 40288 698 44 quarter quarter NN 40288 698 45 - - HYPH 40288 698 46 tones tone NNS 40288 698 47 , , , 40288 698 48 and and CC 40288 698 49 a a DT 40288 698 50 tone tone NN 40288 698 51 . . . 40288 699 1 As as IN 40288 699 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 699 3 shall shall MD 40288 699 4 presently presently RB 40288 699 5 see see VB 40288 699 6 in in IN 40288 699 7 detail detail NN 40288 699 8 , , , 40288 699 9 there there EX 40288 699 10 are be VBP 40288 699 11 seven seven CD 40288 699 12 species specie NNS 40288 699 13 of of IN 40288 699 14 the the DT 40288 699 15 Octave Octave NNP 40288 699 16 in in IN 40288 699 17 each each DT 40288 699 18 genus genus NN 40288 699 19 . . . 40288 700 1 That that DT 40288 700 2 is be VBZ 40288 700 3 to to TO 40288 700 4 say say VB 40288 700 5 , , , 40288 700 6 there there EX 40288 700 7 are be VBP 40288 700 8 seven seven CD 40288 700 9 admissible admissible JJ 40288 700 10 octachord octachord NNP 40288 700 11 scales scale NNS 40288 700 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 700 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 700 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 700 15 : : : 40288 700 16 systêmata systêmata NNP 40288 700 17 emmelê emmelê NNP 40288 700 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 700 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 700 20 , , , 40288 700 21 differing differ VBG 40288 700 22 only only RB 40288 700 23 in in IN 40288 700 24 the the DT 40288 700 25 succession succession NN 40288 700 26 of of IN 40288 700 27 the the DT 40288 700 28 intervals interval NNS 40288 700 29 which which WDT 40288 700 30 compose compose VBD 40288 700 31 them -PRON- PRP 40288 700 32 . . . 40288 701 1 Further further RB 40288 701 2 , , , 40288 701 3 there there EX 40288 701 4 is be VBZ 40288 701 5 evidence evidence NN 40288 701 6 which which WDT 40288 701 7 goes go VBZ 40288 701 8 to to TO 40288 701 9 connect connect VB 40288 701 10 the the DT 40288 701 11 seven seven CD 40288 701 12 species specie NNS 40288 701 13 of of IN 40288 701 14 the the DT 40288 701 15 Octave Octave NNP 40288 701 16 with with IN 40288 701 17 the the DT 40288 701 18 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 701 19 or or CC 40288 701 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 701 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 701 22 : : : 40288 701 23 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 701 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 701 25 . . . 40288 702 1 In in IN 40288 702 2 some some DT 40288 702 3 writers writer NNS 40288 702 4 these these DT 40288 702 5 species specie NNS 40288 702 6 are be VBP 40288 702 7 described describe VBN 40288 702 8 under under IN 40288 702 9 names name NNS 40288 702 10 which which WDT 40288 702 11 are be VBP 40288 702 12 familiar familiar JJ 40288 702 13 to to IN 40288 702 14 us -PRON- PRP 40288 702 15 in in IN 40288 702 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 702 17 application application NN 40288 702 18 to to IN 40288 702 19 the the DT 40288 702 20 modes mode NNS 40288 702 21 . . . 40288 703 1 A a DT 40288 703 2 certain certain JJ 40288 703 3 succession succession NN 40288 703 4 of of IN 40288 703 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 703 6 is be VBZ 40288 703 7 called call VBN 40288 703 8 the the DT 40288 703 9 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 703 10 species specie NNS 40288 703 11 of of IN 40288 703 12 the the DT 40288 703 13 Octave Octave NNP 40288 703 14 , , , 40288 703 15 another another DT 40288 703 16 succession succession NN 40288 703 17 is be VBZ 40288 703 18 called call VBN 40288 703 19 the the DT 40288 703 20 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 703 21 species specie NNS 40288 703 22 , , , 40288 703 23 and and CC 40288 703 24 so so RB 40288 703 25 on on RB 40288 703 26 for for IN 40288 703 27 the the DT 40288 703 28 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 703 29 , , , 40288 703 30 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 703 31 - - HYPH 40288 703 32 lydian lydian NNP 40288 703 33 , , , 40288 703 34 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 703 35 - - HYPH 40288 703 36 dorian dorian NNP 40288 703 37 , , , 40288 703 38 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 703 39 - - HYPH 40288 703 40 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 703 41 , , , 40288 703 42 and and CC 40288 703 43 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 703 44 - - HYPH 40288 703 45 lydian lydian NNP 40288 703 46 . . . 40288 704 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 704 2 seems seem VBZ 40288 704 3 natural natural JJ 40288 704 4 to to TO 40288 704 5 conclude conclude VB 40288 704 6 that that IN 40288 704 7 the the DT 40288 704 8 species specie NNS 40288 704 9 or or CC 40288 704 10 successions succession NNS 40288 704 11 of of IN 40288 704 12 intervals interval NNS 40288 704 13 so so RB 40288 704 14 named name VBN 40288 704 15 were be VBD 40288 704 16 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 704 17 in in IN 40288 704 18 some some DT 40288 704 19 way way NN 40288 704 20 of of IN 40288 704 21 the the DT 40288 704 22 modes mode NNS 40288 704 23 which which WDT 40288 704 24 bore bear VBD 40288 704 25 the the DT 40288 704 26 same same JJ 40288 704 27 names name NNS 40288 704 28 , , , 40288 704 29 consequently consequently RB 40288 704 30 that that IN 40288 704 31 the the DT 40288 704 32 modes mode NNS 40288 704 33 were be VBD 40288 704 34 not not RB 40288 704 35 keys key NNS 40288 704 36 , , , 40288 704 37 but but CC 40288 704 38 modes mode NNS 40288 704 39 in in IN 40288 704 40 the the DT 40288 704 41 modern modern JJ 40288 704 42 sense sense NN 40288 704 43 of of IN 40288 704 44 the the DT 40288 704 45 term term NN 40288 704 46 . . . 40288 705 1 In in IN 40288 705 2 order order NN 40288 705 3 to to TO 40288 705 4 estimate estimate VB 40288 705 5 the the DT 40288 705 6 value value NN 40288 705 7 of of IN 40288 705 8 this this DT 40288 705 9 argument argument NN 40288 705 10 , , , 40288 705 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 705 12 is be VBZ 40288 705 13 necessary necessary JJ 40288 705 14 to to TO 40288 705 15 ask ask VB 40288 705 16 , , , 40288 705 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 705 18 1 1 LS 40288 705 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 705 20 how how WRB 40288 705 21 far far RB 40288 705 22 back back RB 40288 705 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 705 24 can can MD 40288 705 25 date date VB 40288 705 26 the the DT 40288 705 27 use use NN 40288 705 28 of of IN 40288 705 29 these these DT 40288 705 30 names name NNS 40288 705 31 for for IN 40288 705 32 the the DT 40288 705 33 species specie NNS 40288 705 34 of of IN 40288 705 35 the the DT 40288 705 36 Octave Octave NNP 40288 705 37 , , , 40288 705 38 and and CC 40288 705 39 ( ( -LRB- 40288 705 40 2 2 LS 40288 705 41 ) ) -RRB- 40288 705 42 in in IN 40288 705 43 what what WDT 40288 705 44 degree degree NN 40288 705 45 the the DT 40288 705 46 species specie NNS 40288 705 47 of of IN 40288 705 48 the the DT 40288 705 49 Octave Octave NNP 40288 705 50 can can MD 40288 705 51 be be VB 40288 705 52 shown show VBN 40288 705 53 to to TO 40288 705 54 have have VB 40288 705 55 entered enter VBN 40288 705 56 into into IN 40288 705 57 the the DT 40288 705 58 practice practice NN 40288 705 59 of of IN 40288 705 60 music music NN 40288 705 61 at at IN 40288 705 62 any any DT 40288 705 63 period period NN 40288 705 64 . . . 40288 706 1 The the DT 40288 706 2 answer answer NN 40288 706 3 to to IN 40288 706 4 these these DT 40288 706 5 questions question NNS 40288 706 6 must must MD 40288 706 7 be be VB 40288 706 8 gathered gather VBN 40288 706 9 from from IN 40288 706 10 a a DT 40288 706 11 careful careful JJ 40288 706 12 examination examination NN 40288 706 13 of of IN 40288 706 14 all all DT 40288 706 15 that that DT 40288 706 16 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 706 17 and and CC 40288 706 18 other other JJ 40288 706 19 early early JJ 40288 706 20 writers writer NNS 40288 706 21 say say VBP 40288 706 22 of of IN 40288 706 23 the the DT 40288 706 24 different different JJ 40288 706 25 musical musical JJ 40288 706 26 scales scale NNS 40288 706 27 in in IN 40288 706 28 reference reference NN 40288 706 29 to to IN 40288 706 30 the the DT 40288 706 31 order order NN 40288 706 32 of of IN 40288 706 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 706 34 intervals interval NNS 40288 706 35 . . . 40288 707 1 § § ADD 40288 707 2 22 22 CD 40288 707 3 . . . 40288 708 1 _ _ NNP 40288 708 2 The the DT 40288 708 3 Scales Scales NNP 40288 708 4 as as IN 40288 708 5 treated treat VBN 40288 708 6 by by IN 40288 708 7 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 708 8 . . . 40288 708 9 _ _ NNP 40288 708 10 The the DT 40288 708 11 subject subject NN 40288 708 12 of of IN 40288 708 13 the the DT 40288 708 14 musical musical JJ 40288 708 15 scales scale NNS 40288 708 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 708 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 708 18 Greek greek JJ 40288 708 19 : : : 40288 708 20 systêmata systêmata NN 40288 708 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 708 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 708 23 is be VBZ 40288 708 24 treated treat VBN 40288 708 25 by by IN 40288 708 26 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 708 27 as as IN 40288 708 28 a a DT 40288 708 29 general general JJ 40288 708 30 problem problem NN 40288 708 31 , , , 40288 708 32 without without IN 40288 708 33 reference reference NN 40288 708 34 to to IN 40288 708 35 the the DT 40288 708 36 scales scale NNS 40288 708 37 in in IN 40288 708 38 actual actual JJ 40288 708 39 use use NN 40288 708 40 . . . 40288 709 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 709 2 complains complain VBZ 40288 709 3 that that IN 40288 709 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 709 5 predecessors predecessor NNS 40288 709 6 dealt deal VBD 40288 709 7 only only RB 40288 709 8 with with IN 40288 709 9 the the DT 40288 709 10 octave octave NN 40288 709 11 scale scale NN 40288 709 12 , , , 40288 709 13 and and CC 40288 709 14 only only RB 40288 709 15 with with IN 40288 709 16 the the DT 40288 709 17 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 709 18 genus genus NN 40288 709 19 , , , 40288 709 20 and and CC 40288 709 21 did do VBD 40288 709 22 not not RB 40288 709 23 address address VB 40288 709 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 40288 709 25 to to IN 40288 709 26 the the DT 40288 709 27 real real JJ 40288 709 28 question question NN 40288 709 29 of of IN 40288 709 30 the the DT 40288 709 31 melodious melodious JJ 40288 709 32 sequence sequence NN 40288 709 33 of of IN 40288 709 34 intervals interval NNS 40288 709 35 . . . 40288 710 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40288 710 2 , , , 40288 710 3 instead instead RB 40288 710 4 of of IN 40288 710 5 beginning begin VBG 40288 710 6 with with IN 40288 710 7 a a DT 40288 710 8 particular particular JJ 40288 710 9 scale scale NN 40288 710 10 , , , 40288 710 11 such such JJ 40288 710 12 as as IN 40288 710 13 the the DT 40288 710 14 octave octave NN 40288 710 15 , , , 40288 710 16 he -PRON- PRP 40288 710 17 supposes suppose VBZ 40288 710 18 a a DT 40288 710 19 scale scale NN 40288 710 20 of of IN 40288 710 21 indefinite indefinite JJ 40288 710 22 compass,--just compass,--just NNP 40288 710 23 as as IN 40288 710 24 a a DT 40288 710 25 mathematician mathematician JJ 40288 710 26 postulates postulate VBZ 40288 710 27 lines line NNS 40288 710 28 and and CC 40288 710 29 surfaces surface NNS 40288 710 30 of of IN 40288 710 31 unlimited unlimited JJ 40288 710 32 magnitude magnitude NN 40288 710 33 . . . 40288 711 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40288 711 2 problem problem NN 40288 711 3 virtually virtually RB 40288 711 4 is be VBZ 40288 711 5 , , , 40288 711 6 given give VBN 40288 711 7 any any DT 40288 711 8 interval interval NN 40288 711 9 known know VBN 40288 711 10 to to IN 40288 711 11 the the DT 40288 711 12 particular particular JJ 40288 711 13 genus genus NN 40288 711 14 supposed suppose VBN 40288 711 15 , , , 40288 711 16 to to TO 40288 711 17 determine determine VB 40288 711 18 what what WDT 40288 711 19 intervals interval NNS 40288 711 20 can can MD 40288 711 21 follow follow VB 40288 711 22 it -PRON- PRP 40288 711 23 on on IN 40288 711 24 a a DT 40288 711 25 musical musical JJ 40288 711 26 scale scale NN 40288 711 27 , , , 40288 711 28 either either CC 40288 711 29 ascending ascending NN 40288 711 30 or or CC 40288 711 31 descending descend VBG 40288 711 32 . . . 40288 712 1 In in IN 40288 712 2 the the DT 40288 712 3 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 712 4 genus genus NN 40288 712 5 , , , 40288 712 6 for for IN 40288 712 7 example example NN 40288 712 8 , , , 40288 712 9 a a DT 40288 712 10 semitone semitone NN 40288 712 11 must must MD 40288 712 12 be be VB 40288 712 13 followed follow VBN 40288 712 14 by by IN 40288 712 15 two two CD 40288 712 16 tones tone NNS 40288 712 17 , , , 40288 712 18 so so IN 40288 712 19 as as IN 40288 712 20 to to TO 40288 712 21 make make VB 40288 712 22 up up RP 40288 712 23 the the DT 40288 712 24 interval interval NN 40288 712 25 of of IN 40288 712 26 a a DT 40288 712 27 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 712 28 . . . 40288 713 1 In in IN 40288 713 2 the the DT 40288 713 3 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 713 4 genus genus NN 40288 713 5 the the DT 40288 713 6 dieses diesis NNS 40288 713 7 or or CC 40288 713 8 quarter quarter NN 40288 713 9 - - HYPH 40288 713 10 tones tone NNS 40288 713 11 can can MD 40288 713 12 only only RB 40288 713 13 occur occur VB 40288 713 14 two two CD 40288 713 15 together together RB 40288 713 16 , , , 40288 713 17 and and CC 40288 713 18 every every DT 40288 713 19 such such JJ 40288 713 20 pair pair NN 40288 713 21 of of IN 40288 713 22 dieses diesis NNS 40288 713 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 713 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 713 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 713 26 : : : 40288 713 27 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 713 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 713 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 713 30 must must MD 40288 713 31 be be VB 40288 713 32 followed follow VBN 40288 713 33 in in IN 40288 713 34 the the DT 40288 713 35 ascending ascend VBG 40288 713 36 order order NN 40288 713 37 by by IN 40288 713 38 a a DT 40288 713 39 ditone ditone NN 40288 713 40 , , , 40288 713 41 in in IN 40288 713 42 the the DT 40288 713 43 descending descend VBG 40288 713 44 order order NN 40288 713 45 by by IN 40288 713 46 a a DT 40288 713 47 ditone ditone NN 40288 713 48 or or CC 40288 713 49 a a DT 40288 713 50 tone tone NN 40288 713 51 . . . 40288 714 1 By by IN 40288 714 2 these these DT 40288 714 3 and and CC 40288 714 4 similar similar JJ 40288 714 5 rules rule NNS 40288 714 6 , , , 40288 714 7 which which WDT 40288 714 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 714 9 deduces deduce VBZ 40288 714 10 mathematically mathematically RB 40288 714 11 from from IN 40288 714 12 one one CD 40288 714 13 or or CC 40288 714 14 two two CD 40288 714 15 general general JJ 40288 714 16 principles principle NNS 40288 714 17 of of IN 40288 714 18 melody melody NN 40288 714 19 , , , 40288 714 20 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 714 21 in in IN 40288 714 22 effect effect NN 40288 714 23 determines determine VBZ 40288 714 24 all all PDT 40288 714 25 the the DT 40288 714 26 possible possible JJ 40288 714 27 scales scale NNS 40288 714 28 of of IN 40288 714 29 each each DT 40288 714 30 genus genus JJ 40288 714 31 , , , 40288 714 32 without without IN 40288 714 33 restriction restriction NN 40288 714 34 of of IN 40288 714 35 compass compass NN 40288 714 36 or or CC 40288 714 37 pitch[1 pitch[1 NNP 40288 714 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 714 39 . . . 40288 715 1 But but CC 40288 715 2 whenever whenever WRB 40288 715 3 he -PRON- PRP 40288 715 4 refers refer VBZ 40288 715 5 for for IN 40288 715 6 the the DT 40288 715 7 purpose purpose NN 40288 715 8 of of IN 40288 715 9 illustration illustration NN 40288 715 10 to to IN 40288 715 11 a a DT 40288 715 12 scale scale NN 40288 715 13 in in IN 40288 715 14 actual actual JJ 40288 715 15 use use NN 40288 715 16 , , , 40288 715 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 715 18 is be VBZ 40288 715 19 always always RB 40288 715 20 the the DT 40288 715 21 standard standard JJ 40288 715 22 octave octave NN 40288 715 23 already already RB 40288 715 24 described describe VBN 40288 715 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 715 26 from from IN 40288 715 27 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 715 28 to to IN 40288 715 29 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 715 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 715 31 , , , 40288 715 32 or or CC 40288 715 33 a a DT 40288 715 34 part part NN 40288 715 35 of of IN 40288 715 36 it -PRON- PRP 40288 715 37 . . . 40288 716 1 Thus thus RB 40288 716 2 nothing nothing NN 40288 716 3 can can MD 40288 716 4 be be VB 40288 716 5 clearer clear JJR 40288 716 6 than than IN 40288 716 7 the the DT 40288 716 8 distinction distinction NN 40288 716 9 which which WDT 40288 716 10 he -PRON- PRP 40288 716 11 makes make VBZ 40288 716 12 between between IN 40288 716 13 the the DT 40288 716 14 theoretically theoretically RB 40288 716 15 infinite infinite JJ 40288 716 16 scale scale NN 40288 716 17 , , , 40288 716 18 subject subject JJ 40288 716 19 only only RB 40288 716 20 to to IN 40288 716 21 certain certain JJ 40288 716 22 principles principle NNS 40288 716 23 or or CC 40288 716 24 laws law NNS 40288 716 25 determining determine VBG 40288 716 26 the the DT 40288 716 27 succession succession NN 40288 716 28 of of IN 40288 716 29 intervals interval NNS 40288 716 30 , , , 40288 716 31 and and CC 40288 716 32 the the DT 40288 716 33 eight eight CD 40288 716 34 notes note NNS 40288 716 35 , , , 40288 716 36 of of IN 40288 716 37 fixed fix VBN 40288 716 38 relative relative JJ 40288 716 39 pitch pitch NN 40288 716 40 , , , 40288 716 41 which which WDT 40288 716 42 constituted constitute VBD 40288 716 43 the the DT 40288 716 44 gamut gamut NN 40288 716 45 of of IN 40288 716 46 practical practical JJ 40288 716 47 music music NN 40288 716 48 . . . 40288 717 1 The the DT 40288 717 2 passages passage NNS 40288 717 3 in in IN 40288 717 4 which which WDT 40288 717 5 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 717 6 dwells dwell NNS 40288 717 7 upon upon IN 40288 717 8 the the DT 40288 717 9 advance advance NN 40288 717 10 which which WDT 40288 717 11 he -PRON- PRP 40288 717 12 has have VBZ 40288 717 13 made make VBN 40288 717 14 upon upon IN 40288 717 15 the the DT 40288 717 16 methods method NNS 40288 717 17 of of IN 40288 717 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 717 19 predecessors predecessor NNS 40288 717 20 are be VBP 40288 717 21 of of IN 40288 717 22 considerable considerable JJ 40288 717 23 importance importance NN 40288 717 24 for for IN 40288 717 25 the the DT 40288 717 26 whole whole JJ 40288 717 27 question question NN 40288 717 28 of of IN 40288 717 29 the the DT 40288 717 30 species specie NNS 40288 717 31 of of IN 40288 717 32 the the DT 40288 717 33 Octave Octave NNP 40288 717 34 . . . 40288 718 1 There there EX 40288 718 2 are be VBP 40288 718 3 three three CD 40288 718 4 or or CC 40288 718 5 four four CD 40288 718 6 places place NNS 40288 718 7 which which WDT 40288 718 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 718 9 will will MD 40288 718 10 be be VB 40288 718 11 worth worth JJ 40288 718 12 while while IN 40288 718 13 to to TO 40288 718 14 quote quote VB 40288 718 15 . . . 40288 719 1 1 1 LS 40288 719 2 . . . 40288 720 1 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 720 2 , , , 40288 720 3 _ _ NNP 40288 720 4 Harm Harm NNP 40288 720 5 . . . 40288 720 6 _ _ NNP 40288 720 7 p. p. NN 40288 720 8 2 2 CD 40288 720 9 , , , 40288 720 10 15 15 CD 40288 720 11 Meib Meib NNP 40288 720 12 . . . 40288 721 1 : : : 40288 721 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 721 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 721 4 : : : 40288 721 5 ta ta NNP 40288 721 6 gar gar NNP 40288 721 7 diagrammata diagrammata NNP 40288 721 8 autois autois NNP 40288 721 9 tôn tôn NNP 40288 721 10 enarmoniôn enarmoniôn NNP 40288 721 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 721 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 721 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 721 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 721 15 : : : 40288 721 16 harmoniôn harmoniôn NNP 40288 721 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 721 18 MSS MSS NNP 40288 721 19 . . . 40288 721 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 722 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 722 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 722 3 : : : 40288 722 4 ekkeitai ekkeitai NNP 40288 722 5 monon monon NNP 40288 722 6 systêmatôn systêmatôn NNP 40288 722 7 , , , 40288 722 8 diatonôn diatonôn NNP 40288 722 9 d d NNP 40288 722 10 ' ' POS 40288 722 11 ê ê NNP 40288 722 12 chrômatikôn chrômatikôn NNP 40288 722 13 oudeis oudeis NNP 40288 722 14 pôpoth pôpoth NNP 40288 722 15 ' ' '' 40288 722 16 heôraken heôraken NNP 40288 722 17 ; ; : 40288 722 18 kaitoi kaitoi NNP 40288 722 19 ta ta NNP 40288 722 20 diagrammata diagrammata NNP 40288 722 21 g g NNP 40288 722 22 ' ' '' 40288 722 23 autôn autôn NNP 40288 722 24 edêlou edêlou NNP 40288 722 25 tên tên NNP 40288 722 26 pasan pasan NNP 40288 722 27 tês tês NNP 40288 722 28 melôdias melôdias NNP 40288 722 29 taxin taxin NNP 40288 722 30 , , , 40288 722 31 en en NNP 40288 722 32 hois hois NNP 40288 722 33 peri peri NNP 40288 722 34 systêmatôn systêmatôn NNP 40288 722 35 oktachordôn oktachordôn NNP 40288 722 36 enarmoniôn enarmoniôn NNP 40288 722 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 722 38 ( ( -LRB- 40288 722 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 722 40 Greek Greek NNP 40288 722 41 : : : 40288 722 42 harmoniôn harmoniôn NNP 40288 722 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 722 44 MSS MSS NNP 40288 722 45 . . . 40288 722 46 ) ) -RRB- 40288 723 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 723 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 723 3 : : : 40288 723 4 monon monon NNP 40288 723 5 elegon elegon NNP 40288 723 6 , , , 40288 723 7 peri peri NNP 40288 723 8 de de NNP 40288 723 9 tôn tôn NNP 40288 723 10 allôn allôn NNP 40288 723 11 genôn genôn NNP 40288 723 12 te te NNP 40288 723 13 kai kai NNP 40288 723 14 schêmatôn schêmatôn NNP 40288 723 15 en en NNP 40288 723 16 autô autô NNP 40288 723 17 te te NNP 40288 723 18 tô tô NNP 40288 723 19 genei genei NNP 40288 723 20 tontô tontô NNP 40288 723 21 kai kai NNP 40288 723 22 tois tois NNP 40288 723 23 loipois loipois NNP 40288 723 24 oud oud NNP 40288 723 25 ' ' '' 40288 723 26 epecheirei epecheirei NNP 40288 723 27 oudeis oudeis NNP 40288 723 28 katamanthanein katamanthanein NNP 40288 723 29 . . . 40288 723 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 724 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 724 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 724 3 1 1 CD 40288 724 4 : : : 40288 724 5 The the DT 40288 724 6 investigation investigation NN 40288 724 7 occupies occupy VBZ 40288 724 8 a a DT 40288 724 9 considerable considerable JJ 40288 724 10 space space NN 40288 724 11 in in IN 40288 724 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 724 13 _ _ NNP 40288 724 14 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 724 15 _ _ NNP 40288 724 16 , , , 40288 724 17 viz viz NN 40288 724 18 . . . 40288 725 1 pp pp NNP 40288 725 2 . . . 40288 726 1 27 27 CD 40288 726 2 - - SYM 40288 726 3 29 29 CD 40288 726 4 Meib Meib NNP 40288 726 5 . . . 40288 727 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 727 2 from from IN 40288 727 3 the the DT 40288 727 4 words word NNS 40288 727 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 727 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 727 7 : : : 40288 727 8 peri peri NNP 40288 727 9 de de IN 40288 727 10 synecheias synecheias NNP 40288 727 11 kai kai NNP 40288 727 12 tou tou NNP 40288 727 13 hexês hexês NNP 40288 727 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 727 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 727 16 , , , 40288 727 17 and and CC 40288 727 18 again again RB 40288 727 19 pp pp NNP 40288 727 20 . . . 40288 728 1 58 58 CD 40288 728 2 - - SYM 40288 728 3 72 72 CD 40288 728 4 Meib Meib NNP 40288 728 5 . . . 40288 728 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 729 1 ' ' `` 40288 729 2 The the DT 40288 729 3 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 729 4 of of IN 40288 729 5 the the DT 40288 729 6 earlier early JJR 40288 729 7 writers writer NNS 40288 729 8 set set VBD 40288 729 9 forth forth RP 40288 729 10 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 729 11 in in IN 40288 729 12 the the DT 40288 729 13 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 729 14 genus genus NN 40288 729 15 only only RB 40288 729 16 , , , 40288 729 17 never never RB 40288 729 18 in in IN 40288 729 19 the the DT 40288 729 20 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 729 21 or or CC 40288 729 22 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 729 23 : : : 40288 729 24 and and CC 40288 729 25 yet yet RB 40288 729 26 these these DT 40288 729 27 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 729 28 professed profess VBD 40288 729 29 to to TO 40288 729 30 give give VB 40288 729 31 the the DT 40288 729 32 whole whole JJ 40288 729 33 scheme scheme NN 40288 729 34 of of IN 40288 729 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 729 36 music music NN 40288 729 37 , , , 40288 729 38 and and CC 40288 729 39 in in IN 40288 729 40 them -PRON- PRP 40288 729 41 they -PRON- PRP 40288 729 42 treated treat VBD 40288 729 43 of of IN 40288 729 44 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 729 45 octave octave NN 40288 729 46 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 729 47 only only RB 40288 729 48 ; ; : 40288 729 49 of of IN 40288 729 50 other other JJ 40288 729 51 genera genera NN 40288 729 52 and and CC 40288 729 53 other other JJ 40288 729 54 forms form NNS 40288 729 55 of of IN 40288 729 56 this this DT 40288 729 57 or or CC 40288 729 58 any any DT 40288 729 59 genus genus JJ 40288 729 60 no no DT 40288 729 61 one one NN 40288 729 62 attempted attempt VBD 40288 729 63 to to TO 40288 729 64 discover discover VB 40288 729 65 anything anything NN 40288 729 66 . . . 40288 729 67 ' ' '' 40288 730 1 2 2 LS 40288 730 2 . . . 40288 731 1 Ibid ibid RB 40288 731 2 . . . 40288 732 1 p. p. NN 40288 732 2 6 6 CD 40288 732 3 , , , 40288 732 4 20 20 CD 40288 732 5 Meib Meib NNP 40288 732 6 . . . 40288 733 1 : : : 40288 733 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 733 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 733 4 : : : 40288 733 5 tôn tôn NNP 40288 733 6 d d LS 40288 733 7 ' ' `` 40288 733 8 allôn allôn NN 40288 733 9 katholou katholou NNP 40288 733 10 men man NNS 40288 733 11 kathaper kathaper VBP 40288 733 12 emprosthen emprosthen NNP 40288 733 13 eipomen eipomen NNP 40288 733 14 oudeis oudeis NNP 40288 733 15 hêptai hêptai NNP 40288 733 16 , , , 40288 733 17 henos henos NNP 40288 733 18 de de NNP 40288 733 19 systêmatos systêmatos FW 40288 733 20 Eratoklês Eratoklês NNP 40288 733 21 epecheirêse epecheirêse NNP 40288 733 22 kath kath NNP 40288 733 23 ' ' '' 40288 733 24 hen hen NNP 40288 733 25 genos genos NNP 40288 733 26 exarithmêsai exarithmêsai NNP 40288 733 27 ta ta NNP 40288 733 28 schêmata schêmata NNP 40288 733 29 tou tou NNP 40288 733 30 dia dia NNP 40288 733 31 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 733 32 apodeiktikôs apodeiktikôs NNP 40288 733 33 tê tê NNP 40288 733 34 periphora periphora NNP 40288 733 35 tôn tôn NNP 40288 733 36 diastêmatôn diastêmatôn NNP 40288 733 37 deiknys deiknys NNP 40288 733 38 ; ; : 40288 733 39 ou ou NNP 40288 733 40 katamathôn katamathôn NNP 40288 733 41 hoti hoti NNP 40288 733 42 , , , 40288 733 43 mê mê NNP 40288 733 44 prosapodeichthentôn prosapodeichthentôn NNP 40288 733 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 733 46 ( ( -LRB- 40288 733 47 qu qu NNP 40288 733 48 . . . 40288 734 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 734 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 734 3 : : : 40288 734 4 proapod proapod NN 40288 734 5 . . . 40288 734 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 734 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 735 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 735 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 735 3 : : : 40288 735 4 tôn tôn NNP 40288 735 5 de de NNP 40288 735 6 tou tou NNP 40288 735 7 dia dia NNP 40288 735 8 pente pente NNP 40288 735 9 schêmatôn schêmatôn NNS 40288 735 10 kai kai NNP 40288 735 11 tôn tôn NNP 40288 735 12 tou tou NNP 40288 735 13 dia dia NNP 40288 735 14 tessarôn tessarôn NNP 40288 735 15 pros pros NNP 40288 735 16 de de NNP 40288 735 17 toutois toutois NNP 40288 735 18 kai kai NNP 40288 735 19 tês tês NNP 40288 735 20 syntheseôs syntheseôs NNP 40288 735 21 autôn autôn NNP 40288 735 22 tis tis NNP 40288 735 23 pot pot NN 40288 735 24 ' ' `` 40288 735 25 esti esti NNP 40288 735 26 kath kath NNP 40288 735 27 ' ' '' 40288 735 28 hên hên NNP 40288 735 29 emmelôs emmelôs NNP 40288 735 30 syntithentai syntithentai NNP 40288 735 31 , , , 40288 735 32 pollaplasia pollaplasia NNP 40288 735 33 tôn tôn NNP 40288 735 34 hepta hepta NNP 40288 735 35 symbainein symbainein NNP 40288 735 36 gignesthai gignesthai NNP 40288 735 37 deiknytai deiknytai NNP 40288 735 38 . . . 40288 735 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 736 1 ' ' `` 40288 736 2 The the DT 40288 736 3 other other JJ 40288 736 4 Systems system NNS 40288 736 5 no no DT 40288 736 6 one one NN 40288 736 7 has have VBZ 40288 736 8 dealt deal VBN 40288 736 9 with with IN 40288 736 10 by by IN 40288 736 11 a a DT 40288 736 12 general general JJ 40288 736 13 method method NN 40288 736 14 : : : 40288 736 15 but but CC 40288 736 16 Eratocles Eratocles NNPS 40288 736 17 has have VBZ 40288 736 18 attempted attempt VBN 40288 736 19 in in IN 40288 736 20 the the DT 40288 736 21 case case NN 40288 736 22 of of IN 40288 736 23 one one CD 40288 736 24 System System NNP 40288 736 25 , , , 40288 736 26 in in IN 40288 736 27 one one CD 40288 736 28 genus genus NN 40288 736 29 , , , 40288 736 30 to to TO 40288 736 31 enumerate enumerate VB 40288 736 32 the the DT 40288 736 33 forms form NNS 40288 736 34 or or CC 40288 736 35 _ _ NNP 40288 736 36 species specie NNS 40288 736 37 _ _ NNP 40288 736 38 of of IN 40288 736 39 the the DT 40288 736 40 Octave Octave NNP 40288 736 41 , , , 40288 736 42 and and CC 40288 736 43 to to TO 40288 736 44 determine determine VB 40288 736 45 them -PRON- PRP 40288 736 46 mathematically mathematically RB 40288 736 47 by by IN 40288 736 48 the the DT 40288 736 49 periodic periodic JJ 40288 736 50 recurrence recurrence NN 40288 736 51 of of IN 40288 736 52 the the DT 40288 736 53 intervals interval NNS 40288 736 54 : : : 40288 736 55 not not RB 40288 736 56 perceiving perceive VBG 40288 736 57 that that IN 40288 736 58 unless unless IN 40288 736 59 we -PRON- PRP 40288 736 60 have have VBP 40288 736 61 first first RB 40288 736 62 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 40288 736 63 the the DT 40288 736 64 forms form NNS 40288 736 65 of of IN 40288 736 66 the the DT 40288 736 67 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 736 68 and and CC 40288 736 69 the the DT 40288 736 70 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 736 71 , , , 40288 736 72 and and CC 40288 736 73 the the DT 40288 736 74 manner manner NN 40288 736 75 of of IN 40288 736 76 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 736 77 melodious melodious JJ 40288 736 78 combination combination NN 40288 736 79 , , , 40288 736 80 the the DT 40288 736 81 forms form NNS 40288 736 82 of of IN 40288 736 83 the the DT 40288 736 84 Octave Octave NNP 40288 736 85 will will MD 40288 736 86 come come VB 40288 736 87 to to TO 40288 736 88 be be VB 40288 736 89 many many RB 40288 736 90 more more JJR 40288 736 91 than than IN 40288 736 92 seven seven CD 40288 736 93 . . . 40288 736 94 ' ' '' 40288 737 1 The the DT 40288 737 2 ' ' `` 40288 737 3 periodic periodic JJ 40288 737 4 recurrence recurrence NN 40288 737 5 of of IN 40288 737 6 intervals interval NNS 40288 737 7 ' ' POS 40288 737 8 here here RB 40288 737 9 spoken speak VBN 40288 737 10 of of IN 40288 737 11 may may MD 40288 737 12 be be VB 40288 737 13 illustrated illustrate VBN 40288 737 14 on on IN 40288 737 15 the the DT 40288 737 16 key key JJ 40288 737 17 - - HYPH 40288 737 18 board board NN 40288 737 19 of of IN 40288 737 20 a a DT 40288 737 21 piano piano NN 40288 737 22 . . . 40288 738 1 If if IN 40288 738 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 738 3 take take VBP 40288 738 4 successive successive JJ 40288 738 5 octaves octave NNS 40288 738 6 of of IN 40288 738 7 white white JJ 40288 738 8 notes note NNS 40288 738 9 , , , 40288 738 10 _ _ NNP 40288 738 11 a a DT 40288 738 12 - - : 40288 738 13 a a DT 40288 738 14 _ _ NNP 40288 738 15 , , , 40288 738 16 _ _ NNP 40288 738 17 b b NNP 40288 738 18 - - HYPH 40288 738 19 b b NNP 40288 738 20 _ _ NNP 40288 738 21 , , , 40288 738 22 and and CC 40288 738 23 so so RB 40288 738 24 on on RB 40288 738 25 , , , 40288 738 26 we -PRON- PRP 40288 738 27 obtain obtain VBP 40288 738 28 each each DT 40288 738 29 time time NN 40288 738 30 a a DT 40288 738 31 different different JJ 40288 738 32 order order NN 40288 738 33 of of IN 40288 738 34 intervals interval NNS 40288 738 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 738 36 _ _ NNP 40288 738 37 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 738 38 _ _ NNP 40288 738 39 the the DT 40288 738 40 semitones semitone NNS 40288 738 41 occur occur VBP 40288 738 42 in in IN 40288 738 43 different different JJ 40288 738 44 places place NNS 40288 738 45 ) ) -RRB- 40288 738 46 , , , 40288 738 47 until until IN 40288 738 48 we -PRON- PRP 40288 738 49 reach reach VBP 40288 738 50 _ _ NNP 40288 738 51 a a DT 40288 738 52 - - : 40288 738 53 a a DT 40288 738 54 _ _ NN 40288 738 55 again again RB 40288 738 56 , , , 40288 738 57 when when WRB 40288 738 58 the the DT 40288 738 59 series series NN 40288 738 60 begins begin VBZ 40288 738 61 afresh afresh JJ 40288 738 62 . . . 40288 739 1 In in IN 40288 739 2 this this DT 40288 739 3 way way NN 40288 739 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 739 5 is be VBZ 40288 739 6 shown show VBN 40288 739 7 that that IN 40288 739 8 only only RB 40288 739 9 seven seven CD 40288 739 10 species specie NNS 40288 739 11 of of IN 40288 739 12 the the DT 40288 739 13 Octave Octave NNP 40288 739 14 can can MD 40288 739 15 be be VB 40288 739 16 found find VBN 40288 739 17 on on IN 40288 739 18 any any DT 40288 739 19 particular particular JJ 40288 739 20 scale scale NN 40288 739 21 . . . 40288 740 1 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 740 2 shows show VBZ 40288 740 3 how how WRB 40288 740 4 to to TO 40288 740 5 prove prove VB 40288 740 6 this this DT 40288 740 7 from from IN 40288 740 8 first first JJ 40288 740 9 principles principle NNS 40288 740 10 , , , 40288 740 11 viz viz NN 40288 740 12 . . . 40288 741 1 by by IN 40288 741 2 analysing analyse VBG 40288 741 3 the the DT 40288 741 4 Octave Octave NNP 40288 741 5 as as IN 40288 741 6 the the DT 40288 741 7 combination combination NN 40288 741 8 of of IN 40288 741 9 a a DT 40288 741 10 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 741 11 with with IN 40288 741 12 a a DT 40288 741 13 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 741 14 . . . 40288 742 1 3 3 LS 40288 742 2 . . . 40288 743 1 Ibid ibid RB 40288 743 2 . . . 40288 744 1 p. p. NN 40288 744 2 36 36 CD 40288 744 3 , , , 40288 744 4 29 29 CD 40288 744 5 Meib Meib NNP 40288 744 6 . . . 40288 745 1 : : : 40288 745 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 745 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 745 4 : : : 40288 745 5 tôn tôn NNP 40288 745 6 de de NNP 40288 745 7 systêmatôn systêmatôn NNP 40288 745 8 tas tas NNP 40288 745 9 diaphoras diaphoras NNP 40288 745 10 hoi hoi NNP 40288 745 11 men man NNS 40288 745 12 holôs holôs NNP 40288 745 13 ouk ouk NNP 40288 745 14 epecheiroun epecheiroun NNP 40288 745 15 exarithmein exarithmein NNP 40288 745 16 , , , 40288 745 17 alla alla NNP 40288 745 18 peri peri NNP 40288 745 19 autôn autôn NNP 40288 745 20 monon monon NNP 40288 745 21 tôn tôn NNP 40288 745 22 heptachordôn heptachordôn NNP 40288 745 23 ha ha NNP 40288 745 24 ekaloun ekaloun NNP 40288 745 25 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 745 26 tên tên NNP 40288 745 27 episkepsin episkepsin NNP 40288 745 28 epoiounto epoiounto NNP 40288 745 29 , , , 40288 745 30 hoi hoi NNP 40288 745 31 de de NNP 40288 745 32 epicheirêsantes epicheirêsante VBZ 40288 745 33 oudena oudena NNP 40288 745 34 tropon tropon NNP 40288 745 35 exêrithmounto exêrithmounto NNP 40288 745 36 . . . 40288 745 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 746 1 For for IN 40288 746 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 746 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 746 4 : : : 40288 746 5 heptachordôn heptachordôn NN 40288 746 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 746 7 Meibomius Meibomius NNP 40288 746 8 and and CC 40288 746 9 other other JJ 40288 746 10 editors editor NNS 40288 746 11 read read VBP 40288 746 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 746 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 746 14 : : : 40288 746 15 hepta hepta NNP 40288 746 16 oktachordôn]--a oktachordôn]--a NNP 40288 746 17 correction correction NN 40288 746 18 strongly strongly RB 40288 746 19 suggested suggest VBN 40288 746 20 by by IN 40288 746 21 the the DT 40288 746 22 parallel parallel JJ 40288 746 23 words word NNS 40288 746 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 746 25 Greek greek JJ 40288 746 26 : : : 40288 746 27 systêmatôn systêmatôn NNP 40288 746 28 oktachordôn oktachordôn NN 40288 746 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 746 30 in in IN 40288 746 31 the the DT 40288 746 32 first first JJ 40288 746 33 passage passage NN 40288 746 34 quoted quote VBD 40288 746 35 . . . 40288 747 1 ' ' `` 40288 747 2 Some some DT 40288 747 3 did do VBD 40288 747 4 not not RB 40288 747 5 attempt attempt VB 40288 747 6 to to TO 40288 747 7 enumerate enumerate VB 40288 747 8 the the DT 40288 747 9 differences difference NNS 40288 747 10 of of IN 40288 747 11 the the DT 40288 747 12 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 747 13 , , , 40288 747 14 but but CC 40288 747 15 confined confine VBD 40288 747 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 747 17 view view NN 40288 747 18 to to IN 40288 747 19 the the DT 40288 747 20 seven seven CD 40288 747 21 octachord octachord NNP 40288 747 22 Systems Systems NNP 40288 747 23 which which WDT 40288 747 24 they -PRON- PRP 40288 747 25 called call VBD 40288 747 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 747 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 747 28 : : : 40288 747 29 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 747 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 747 31 ; ; : 40288 747 32 others other NNS 40288 747 33 who who WP 40288 747 34 did do VBD 40288 747 35 make make VB 40288 747 36 the the DT 40288 747 37 attempt attempt NN 40288 747 38 did do VBD 40288 747 39 not not RB 40288 747 40 succeed succeed VB 40288 747 41 . . . 40288 747 42 ' ' '' 40288 748 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 748 2 appears appear VBZ 40288 748 3 from from IN 40288 748 4 these these DT 40288 748 5 passages passage NNS 40288 748 6 that that WDT 40288 748 7 before before IN 40288 748 8 the the DT 40288 748 9 time time NN 40288 748 10 of of IN 40288 748 11 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 748 12 musicians musician NNS 40288 748 13 had have VBD 40288 748 14 framed frame VBN 40288 748 15 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 748 16 or or CC 40288 748 17 tables table NNS 40288 748 18 showing show VBG 40288 748 19 the the DT 40288 748 20 division division NN 40288 748 21 of of IN 40288 748 22 the the DT 40288 748 23 octave octave NN 40288 748 24 scale scale NN 40288 748 25 according accord VBG 40288 748 26 to to IN 40288 748 27 the the DT 40288 748 28 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 748 29 genus genus NN 40288 748 30 : : : 40288 748 31 and and CC 40288 748 32 that that IN 40288 748 33 a a DT 40288 748 34 certain certain JJ 40288 748 35 Eratocles Eratocles NNPS 40288 748 36 -- -- : 40288 748 37 of of IN 40288 748 38 whom whom WP 40288 748 39 nothing nothing NN 40288 748 40 else else RB 40288 748 41 is be VBZ 40288 748 42 known know VBN 40288 748 43 -- -- : 40288 748 44 had have VBD 40288 748 45 recognised recognise VBN 40288 748 46 seven seven CD 40288 748 47 forms form NNS 40288 748 48 or or CC 40288 748 49 species specie NNS 40288 748 50 of of IN 40288 748 51 the the DT 40288 748 52 octachord octachord NNP 40288 748 53 scale scale NN 40288 748 54 , , , 40288 748 55 and and CC 40288 748 56 had have VBD 40288 748 57 shown show VBN 40288 748 58 how how WRB 40288 748 59 the the DT 40288 748 60 order order NN 40288 748 61 of of IN 40288 748 62 the the DT 40288 748 63 intervals interval NNS 40288 748 64 in in IN 40288 748 65 the the DT 40288 748 66 several several JJ 40288 748 67 species specie NNS 40288 748 68 passes pass VBZ 40288 748 69 through through IN 40288 748 70 a a DT 40288 748 71 sort sort NN 40288 748 72 of of IN 40288 748 73 cycle cycle NN 40288 748 74 . . . 40288 749 1 Finally finally RB 40288 749 2 , , , 40288 749 3 if if IN 40288 749 4 the the DT 40288 749 5 correction correction NN 40288 749 6 proposed propose VBD 40288 749 7 in in IN 40288 749 8 the the DT 40288 749 9 third third JJ 40288 749 10 passage passage NN 40288 749 11 is be VBZ 40288 749 12 right right JJ 40288 749 13 , , , 40288 749 14 the the DT 40288 749 15 seven seven CD 40288 749 16 species specie NNS 40288 749 17 of of IN 40288 749 18 the the DT 40288 749 19 Octave Octave NNP 40288 749 20 were be VBD 40288 749 21 somehow somehow RB 40288 749 22 shown show VBN 40288 749 23 in in IN 40288 749 24 the the DT 40288 749 25 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 749 26 of of IN 40288 749 27 which which WDT 40288 749 28 the the DT 40288 749 29 first first JJ 40288 749 30 passage passage NN 40288 749 31 speaks speak VBZ 40288 749 32 . . . 40288 750 1 In in IN 40288 750 2 what what WDT 40288 750 3 respect respect NN 40288 750 4 Eratocles Eratocles NNPS 40288 750 5 failed fail VBD 40288 750 6 in in IN 40288 750 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 750 8 treatment treatment NN 40288 750 9 of of IN 40288 750 10 the the DT 40288 750 11 seven seven CD 40288 750 12 species specie NNS 40288 750 13 can can MD 40288 750 14 hardly hardly RB 40288 750 15 be be VB 40288 750 16 conjectured conjecture VBN 40288 750 17 . . . 40288 751 1 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 40288 751 2 the the DT 40288 751 3 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 751 4 are be VBP 40288 751 5 described describe VBN 40288 751 6 by by IN 40288 751 7 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 751 8 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 751 9 differently differently RB 40288 751 10 , , , 40288 751 11 as as IN 40288 751 12 though though IN 40288 751 13 they -PRON- PRP 40288 751 14 exhibited exhibit VBD 40288 751 15 a a DT 40288 751 16 division division NN 40288 751 17 into into IN 40288 751 18 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 751 19 dieses diesis NNS 40288 751 20 or or CC 40288 751 21 quarter quarter NN 40288 751 22 - - HYPH 40288 751 23 tones tone NNS 40288 751 24 , , , 40288 751 25 without without IN 40288 751 26 reference reference NN 40288 751 27 to to IN 40288 751 28 the the DT 40288 751 29 melodious melodious JJ 40288 751 30 character character NN 40288 751 31 of of IN 40288 751 32 the the DT 40288 751 33 scale scale NN 40288 751 34 . . . 40288 752 1 Thus thus RB 40288 752 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 752 3 find find VBP 40288 752 4 him -PRON- PRP 40288 752 5 saying-- saying-- JJ 40288 752 6 . . . 40288 753 1 _ _ NNP 40288 753 2 Harm Harm NNP 40288 753 3 . . . 40288 753 4 _ _ NNP 40288 753 5 p. p. NN 40288 753 6 28 28 CD 40288 753 7 Meib Meib NNP 40288 753 8 . . . 40288 754 1 : : : 40288 754 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 754 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 754 4 : : : 40288 754 5 zêtêteon zêtêteon NNP 40288 754 6 de de NNP 40288 754 7 to to IN 40288 754 8 syneches syneche NNS 40288 754 9 ouch ouch NNP 40288 754 10 hôs hôs NNP 40288 754 11 hoi hoi NNP 40288 754 12 harmonikoi harmonikoi NNP 40288 754 13 en en IN 40288 754 14 tais tais NNP 40288 754 15 tôn tôn NNP 40288 754 16 diagrammatôn diagrammatôn NNP 40288 754 17 katapyknôsesin katapyknôsesin NNP 40288 754 18 apodidonai apodidonai NNP 40288 754 19 peirôntai peirôntai NNP 40288 754 20 , , , 40288 754 21 toutous toutous JJ 40288 754 22 apophainontes apophainonte NNS 40288 754 23 tôn tôn NNP 40288 754 24 phthongôn phthongôn NNPS 40288 754 25 hexês hexês NNP 40288 754 26 allêlôn allêlôn NNP 40288 754 27 keisthai keisthai NNP 40288 754 28 hois hois NNP 40288 754 29 symbebêke symbebêke NNP 40288 754 30 to to TO 40288 754 31 elachiston elachiston VB 40288 754 32 diastêma diastêma NNP 40288 754 33 diechein diechein NNP 40288 754 34 aph aph NNP 40288 754 35 ' ' `` 40288 754 36 hautôn hautôn NNS 40288 754 37 . . . 40288 755 1 ou ou NNP 40288 755 2 gar gar NNP 40288 755 3 to to IN 40288 755 4 mê mê NNP 40288 755 5 dynasthai dynasthai NNP 40288 755 6 dieseis dieseis NNP 40288 755 7 oktô oktô RB 40288 755 8 kai kai NNP 40288 755 9 eikosin eikosin NNP 40288 755 10 hexês hexês NNP 40288 755 11 melôdeisthai melôdeisthai NNP 40288 755 12 tês tês NNP 40288 755 13 phônês phônês NNP 40288 755 14 estin estin NNP 40288 755 15 , , , 40288 755 16 alla alla NN 40288 755 17 tên tên NNP 40288 755 18 tritên tritên NNP 40288 755 19 diesin diesin NNP 40288 755 20 panta panta NNP 40288 755 21 poiousa poiousa NNP 40288 755 22 ouch ouch NNP 40288 755 23 hoia hoia NNP 40288 755 24 t t NNP 40288 755 25 ' ' '' 40288 755 26 esti esti NN 40288 755 27 prostithenai prostithenai NN 40288 755 28 . . . 40288 755 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 756 1 ' ' `` 40288 756 2 We -PRON- PRP 40288 756 3 must must MD 40288 756 4 seek seek VB 40288 756 5 continuity continuity NN 40288 756 6 of of IN 40288 756 7 succession succession NN 40288 756 8 , , , 40288 756 9 not not RB 40288 756 10 as as IN 40288 756 11 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 756 12 musicians musician NNS 40288 756 13 do do VBP 40288 756 14 in in IN 40288 756 15 filling fill VBG 40288 756 16 up up RP 40288 756 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 756 18 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 756 19 with with IN 40288 756 20 small small JJ 40288 756 21 intervals interval NNS 40288 756 22 , , , 40288 756 23 making make VBG 40288 756 24 those those DT 40288 756 25 notes note NNS 40288 756 26 successive successive JJ 40288 756 27 which which WDT 40288 756 28 are be VBP 40288 756 29 separated separate VBN 40288 756 30 from from IN 40288 756 31 each each DT 40288 756 32 other other JJ 40288 756 33 by by IN 40288 756 34 the the DT 40288 756 35 least least JJS 40288 756 36 interval interval NN 40288 756 37 . . . 40288 757 1 For for IN 40288 757 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 757 3 is be VBZ 40288 757 4 not not RB 40288 757 5 merely merely RB 40288 757 6 that that IN 40288 757 7 the the DT 40288 757 8 voice voice NN 40288 757 9 can can MD 40288 757 10 not not RB 40288 757 11 sing sing VB 40288 757 12 twenty twenty CD 40288 757 13 - - HYPH 40288 757 14 eight eight CD 40288 757 15 successive successive JJ 40288 757 16 dieses diesis NNS 40288 757 17 : : : 40288 757 18 with with IN 40288 757 19 all all DT 40288 757 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 757 21 efforts effort NNS 40288 757 22 it -PRON- PRP 40288 757 23 can can MD 40288 757 24 not not RB 40288 757 25 sing sing VB 40288 757 26 a a DT 40288 757 27 third third JJ 40288 757 28 diesis[1 diesis[1 NNP 40288 757 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 757 30 . . . 40288 757 31 ' ' '' 40288 758 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 758 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 758 3 1 1 CD 40288 758 4 : : : 40288 758 5 This this DT 40288 758 6 point point NN 40288 758 7 is be VBZ 40288 758 8 one one CD 40288 758 9 which which WDT 40288 758 10 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 758 11 is be VBZ 40288 758 12 fond fond JJ 40288 758 13 of of IN 40288 758 14 insisting insist VBG 40288 758 15 upon upon IN 40288 758 16 : : : 40288 758 17 cp cp NNP 40288 758 18 . . . 40288 759 1 p. p. NN 40288 759 2 10 10 CD 40288 759 3 , , , 40288 759 4 16 16 CD 40288 759 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 759 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 759 7 : : : 40288 759 8 ou ou NNP 40288 759 9 pros pro NNS 40288 759 10 tên tên NNP 40288 759 11 katapyknôsin katapyknôsin NNP 40288 759 12 blepontas blepontas NNP 40288 759 13 hôsper hôsper NNP 40288 759 14 hoi hoi NNP 40288 759 15 harmonikoi harmonikoi NNP 40288 759 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 759 17 : : : 40288 759 18 p. p. NN 40288 759 19 38 38 CD 40288 759 20 , , , 40288 759 21 3 3 CD 40288 759 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 759 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 759 24 : : : 40288 759 25 hoti hoti NNP 40288 759 26 de de NNP 40288 759 27 estin estin NNP 40288 759 28 hê hê NNP 40288 759 29 katapyknôsis katapyknôsis NNP 40288 759 30 ekmelês ekmelês NNP 40288 759 31 kai kai NNP 40288 759 32 panta panta NNP 40288 759 33 tropon tropon NNP 40288 759 34 achrêstos achrêstos NNP 40288 759 35 phaneron phaneron NNP 40288 759 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 759 37 : : : 40288 759 38 p. p. NN 40288 759 39 53 53 CD 40288 759 40 , , , 40288 759 41 3 3 CD 40288 759 42 [ [ -LRB- 40288 759 43 Greek Greek NNP 40288 759 44 : : : 40288 759 45 kata kata NNP 40288 759 46 tên tên NNP 40288 759 47 tou tou NNP 40288 759 48 melous melous JJ 40288 759 49 physin physin NNP 40288 759 50 zêtêteon zêtêteon NNP 40288 759 51 to to IN 40288 759 52 hexês hexês NNP 40288 759 53 kai kai NNP 40288 759 54 ouch ouch NNP 40288 759 55 hôs hôs NNP 40288 759 56 hoi hoi NNP 40288 759 57 eis eis NNP 40288 759 58 tên tên NNP 40288 759 59 katapyknôsin katapyknôsin NNP 40288 759 60 blepontes blepontes NNP 40288 759 61 eiôthasin eiôthasin NNP 40288 759 62 apodidonai apodidonai NNP 40288 759 63 to to IN 40288 759 64 hexês hexês NNP 40288 759 65 ] ] -RRB- 40288 759 66 . . . 40288 760 1 The the DT 40288 760 2 statement statement NN 40288 760 3 that that IN 40288 760 4 the the DT 40288 760 5 ancient ancient JJ 40288 760 6 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 760 7 gave give VBD 40288 760 8 a a DT 40288 760 9 series series NN 40288 760 10 of of IN 40288 760 11 twenty twenty CD 40288 760 12 - - HYPH 40288 760 13 eight eight CD 40288 760 14 successive successive JJ 40288 760 15 dieses diesis NNS 40288 760 16 or or CC 40288 760 17 quarter quarter NN 40288 760 18 - - HYPH 40288 760 19 tones tone NNS 40288 760 20 has have VBZ 40288 760 21 not not RB 40288 760 22 been be VBN 40288 760 23 explained explain VBN 40288 760 24 . . . 40288 761 1 The the DT 40288 761 2 number number NN 40288 761 3 of of IN 40288 761 4 quarter quarter NN 40288 761 5 - - HYPH 40288 761 6 tones tone NNS 40288 761 7 in in IN 40288 761 8 an an DT 40288 761 9 octave octave NN 40288 761 10 is be VBZ 40288 761 11 only only RB 40288 761 12 twenty twenty CD 40288 761 13 - - HYPH 40288 761 14 four four CD 40288 761 15 . . . 40288 762 1 Possibly possibly RB 40288 762 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 762 3 is be VBZ 40288 762 4 a a DT 40288 762 5 mere mere JJ 40288 762 6 error error NN 40288 762 7 of of IN 40288 762 8 transcription transcription NN 40288 762 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 762 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 762 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 762 12 : : : 40288 762 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 762 14 = = NFP 40288 762 15 kê kê XX 40288 762 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 762 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 762 18 for for IN 40288 762 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 762 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 762 21 : : : 40288 762 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 762 23 = = SYM 40288 762 24 kd kd NNP 40288 762 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 762 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 762 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 762 28 . . . 40288 763 1 If if IN 40288 763 2 not not RB 40288 763 3 , , , 40288 763 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 763 5 may may MD 40288 763 6 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 763 7 connect connect VB 40288 763 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 763 9 with with IN 40288 763 10 the the DT 40288 763 11 seven seven CD 40288 763 12 intervals interval NNS 40288 763 13 of of IN 40288 763 14 the the DT 40288 763 15 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 763 16 octave octave NN 40288 763 17 scale scale NN 40288 763 18 , , , 40288 763 19 and and CC 40288 763 20 the the DT 40288 763 21 simple simple JJ 40288 763 22 method method NN 40288 763 23 by by IN 40288 763 24 which which WDT 40288 763 25 the the DT 40288 763 26 enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 763 27 intervals interval NNS 40288 763 28 were be VBD 40288 763 29 expressed express VBN 40288 763 30 in in IN 40288 763 31 the the DT 40288 763 32 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 763 33 notation notation NN 40288 763 34 . . . 40288 764 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 764 2 has have VBZ 40288 764 3 been be VBN 40288 764 4 explained explain VBN 40288 764 5 that that IN 40288 764 6 raising raise VBG 40288 764 7 a a DT 40288 764 8 note note NN 40288 764 9 a a DT 40288 764 10 quarter quarter NN 40288 764 11 of of IN 40288 764 12 a a DT 40288 764 13 tone tone NN 40288 764 14 was be VBD 40288 764 15 shown show VBN 40288 764 16 by by IN 40288 764 17 turning turn VBG 40288 764 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 764 19 through through IN 40288 764 20 a a DT 40288 764 21 quarter quarter NN 40288 764 22 of of IN 40288 764 23 a a DT 40288 764 24 circle circle NN 40288 764 25 . . . 40288 765 1 Thus thus RB 40288 765 2 , , , 40288 765 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 765 4 _ _ NNP 40288 765 5 c c NNP 40288 765 6 _ _ NNP 40288 765 7 being be VBG 40288 765 8 denoted denote VBN 40288 765 9 by by IN 40288 765 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 765 11 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 765 12 : : : 40288 765 13 E e NN 40288 765 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 765 15 , , , 40288 765 16 _ _ NNP 40288 765 17 c c NNP 40288 765 18 _ _ NNP 40288 765 19 * * NFP 40288 765 20 was be VBD 40288 765 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 765 22 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 765 23 : : : 40288 765 24 w w LS 40288 765 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 765 26 , , , 40288 765 27 and and CC 40288 765 28 _ _ NNP 40288 765 29 c_[Symbols c_[Symbols NNPS 40288 765 30 : : : 40288 765 31 c c LS 40288 765 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 765 33 was be VBD 40288 765 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 765 35 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 765 36 : : : 40288 765 37 3 3 LS 40288 765 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 765 39 . . . 40288 766 1 Now now RB 40288 766 2 the the DT 40288 766 3 ancient ancient JJ 40288 766 4 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 766 5 , , , 40288 766 6 which which WDT 40288 766 7 divided divide VBD 40288 766 8 every every DT 40288 766 9 tone tone NN 40288 766 10 into into IN 40288 766 11 four four CD 40288 766 12 parts part NNS 40288 766 13 , , , 40288 766 14 must must MD 40288 766 15 have have VB 40288 766 16 had have VBN 40288 766 17 a a DT 40288 766 18 character character NN 40288 766 19 for for IN 40288 766 20 _ _ NNP 40288 766 21 c_[Symbols c_[Symbols NNPS 40288 766 22 : : : 40288 766 23 S s NN 40288 766 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 766 25 * * NFP 40288 766 26 , , , 40288 766 27 or or CC 40288 766 28 the the DT 40288 766 29 note note NN 40288 766 30 three three CD 40288 766 31 - - HYPH 40288 766 32 quarters quarter NNS 40288 766 33 of of IN 40288 766 34 a a DT 40288 766 35 tone tone NN 40288 766 36 above above IN 40288 766 37 _ _ NNP 40288 766 38 c c NNP 40288 766 39 _ _ NNP 40288 766 40 . . . 40288 767 1 Naturally naturally RB 40288 767 2 this this DT 40288 767 3 would would MD 40288 767 4 be be VB 40288 767 5 the the DT 40288 767 6 remaining remain VBG 40288 767 7 position position NN 40288 767 8 of of IN 40288 767 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 767 10 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 767 11 : : : 40288 767 12 E e NN 40288 767 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 767 14 , , , 40288 767 15 namely namely RB 40288 767 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 767 17 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 767 18 : : : 40288 767 19 m m LS 40288 767 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 767 21 . . . 40288 768 1 Again again RB 40288 768 2 , , , 40288 768 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 768 4 have have VBP 40288 768 5 seen see VBN 40288 768 6 that that IN 40288 768 7 when when WRB 40288 768 8 the the DT 40288 768 9 interval interval NN 40288 768 10 between between IN 40288 768 11 two two CD 40288 768 12 notes note NNS 40288 768 13 on on IN 40288 768 14 the the DT 40288 768 15 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 768 16 scale scale NN 40288 768 17 is be VBZ 40288 768 18 only only RB 40288 768 19 a a DT 40288 768 20 semitone semitone NN 40288 768 21 , , , 40288 768 22 the the DT 40288 768 23 result result NN 40288 768 24 of of IN 40288 768 25 the the DT 40288 768 26 notation notation NN 40288 768 27 is be VBZ 40288 768 28 to to TO 40288 768 29 produce produce VB 40288 768 30 a a DT 40288 768 31 certain certain JJ 40288 768 32 number number NN 40288 768 33 of of IN 40288 768 34 duplicates duplicate NNS 40288 768 35 , , , 40288 768 36 so so RB 40288 768 37 to to TO 40288 768 38 speak speak VB 40288 768 39 . . . 40288 769 1 Thus thus RB 40288 769 2 : : : 40288 769 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 769 4 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 769 5 : : : 40288 769 6 K K NNP 40288 769 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 769 8 stands stand VBZ 40288 769 9 for for IN 40288 769 10 _ _ NNP 40288 769 11 b b NNP 40288 769 12 _ _ NNP 40288 769 13 , , , 40288 769 14 and and CC 40288 769 15 therefore therefore RB 40288 769 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 769 17 Symbols:)1 symbols:)1 NN 40288 769 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 769 19 for for IN 40288 769 20 _ _ NNP 40288 769 21 c c NNP 40288 769 22 _ _ NNP 40288 769 23 : : : 40288 769 24 but but CC 40288 769 25 _ _ NNP 40288 769 26 c c NNP 40288 769 27 _ _ NNP 40288 769 28 is be VBZ 40288 769 29 a a DT 40288 769 30 note note NN 40288 769 31 of of IN 40288 769 32 the the DT 40288 769 33 original original JJ 40288 769 34 scale scale NN 40288 769 35 , , , 40288 769 36 and and CC 40288 769 37 as as IN 40288 769 38 such such JJ 40288 769 39 is be VBZ 40288 769 40 written write VBN 40288 769 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 769 42 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 769 43 : : : 40288 769 44 q q NNP 40288 769 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 769 46 . . . 40288 770 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 770 2 may may MD 40288 770 3 be be VB 40288 770 4 that that IN 40288 770 5 the the DT 40288 770 6 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 770 7 to to TO 40288 770 8 which which WDT 40288 770 9 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 770 10 refers refer NNS 40288 770 11 made make VBD 40288 770 12 use use NN 40288 770 13 of of IN 40288 770 14 these these DT 40288 770 15 duplicates duplicate NNS 40288 770 16 : : : 40288 770 17 that that DT 40288 770 18 is be VBZ 40288 770 19 to to TO 40288 770 20 say say VB 40288 770 21 , , , 40288 770 22 they -PRON- PRP 40288 770 23 may may MD 40288 770 24 have have VB 40288 770 25 made make VBN 40288 770 26 use use NN 40288 770 27 of of IN 40288 770 28 all all DT 40288 770 29 four four CD 40288 770 30 positions position NNS 40288 770 31 of of IN 40288 770 32 a a DT 40288 770 33 character character NN 40288 770 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 770 35 such such JJ 40288 770 36 as as IN 40288 770 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 770 38 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 770 39 : : : 40288 770 40 K K NNP 40288 770 41 7 7 CD 40288 770 42 g g NNP 40288 770 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 770 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 770 45 whether whether IN 40288 770 46 the the DT 40288 770 47 interval interval NN 40288 770 48 to to TO 40288 770 49 be be VB 40288 770 50 filled fill VBN 40288 770 51 was be VBD 40288 770 52 a a DT 40288 770 53 tone tone NN 40288 770 54 or or CC 40288 770 55 a a DT 40288 770 56 semitone semitone NN 40288 770 57 . . . 40288 771 1 If if IN 40288 771 2 so so RB 40288 771 3 , , , 40288 771 4 the the DT 40288 771 5 seven seven CD 40288 771 6 intervals interval NNS 40288 771 7 would would MD 40288 771 8 give give VB 40288 771 9 twenty twenty CD 40288 771 10 - - HYPH 40288 771 11 eight eight CD 40288 771 12 characters character NNS 40288 771 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 771 14 besides besides IN 40288 771 15 the the DT 40288 771 16 upper upper JJ 40288 771 17 octave octave NN 40288 771 18 - - HYPH 40288 771 19 note note NN 40288 771 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 771 21 , , , 40288 771 22 and and CC 40288 771 23 apparently apparently RB 40288 771 24 therefore therefore RB 40288 771 25 twenty twenty CD 40288 771 26 - - HYPH 40288 771 27 eight eight CD 40288 771 28 dieses diesis NNS 40288 771 29 . . . 40288 772 1 Some some DT 40288 772 2 traces trace NNS 40288 772 3 of of IN 40288 772 4 this this DT 40288 772 5 use use NN 40288 772 6 of of IN 40288 772 7 characters character NNS 40288 772 8 in in IN 40288 772 9 four four CD 40288 772 10 positions position NNS 40288 772 11 have have VBP 40288 772 12 been be VBN 40288 772 13 noticed notice VBN 40288 772 14 by by IN 40288 772 15 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 772 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 772 17 _ _ NNP 40288 772 18 Tonleitern Tonleitern NNP 40288 772 19 _ _ NNP 40288 772 20 , , , 40288 772 21 p. p. NN 40288 773 1 65 65 CD 40288 773 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 773 3 . . . 40288 773 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 774 1 This this DT 40288 774 2 representation representation NN 40288 774 3 of of IN 40288 774 4 the the DT 40288 774 5 musical musical JJ 40288 774 6 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 774 7 is be VBZ 40288 774 8 borne bear VBN 40288 774 9 out out RP 40288 774 10 by by IN 40288 774 11 the the DT 40288 774 12 passage passage NN 40288 774 13 in in IN 40288 774 14 the the DT 40288 774 15 _ _ NNP 40288 774 16 Republic Republic NNP 40288 774 17 _ _ NNP 40288 774 18 in in IN 40288 774 19 which which WDT 40288 774 20 Plato Plato NNP 40288 774 21 derides deride VBZ 40288 774 22 the the DT 40288 774 23 experimental experimental JJ 40288 774 24 study study NN 40288 774 25 of of IN 40288 774 26 music music NN 40288 774 27 : : : 40288 774 28 _ _ NNP 40288 774 29 Rep. Rep. NNP 40288 774 30 _ _ NNP 40288 774 31 p. p. NN 40288 774 32 531 531 CD 40288 774 33 a a DT 40288 774 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 774 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 774 36 : : : 40288 774 37 tas tas NNP 40288 774 38 gar gar NNP 40288 774 39 akouomenas akouomenas NNP 40288 774 40 au au NNP 40288 774 41 symphônias symphônias NNP 40288 774 42 kai kai NNP 40288 774 43 phthongous phthongous JJ 40288 774 44 allêlois allêlois NNP 40288 774 45 anametrountes anametrounte VBZ 40288 774 46 anênyta anênyta JJ 40288 774 47 , , , 40288 774 48 hôsper hôsper NNP 40288 774 49 hoi hoi NNP 40288 774 50 astronomoi astronomoi NNP 40288 774 51 , , , 40288 774 52 ponousin ponousin NNP 40288 774 53 . . . 40288 775 1 Nê nê IN 40288 775 2 tous tous JJ 40288 775 3 theous theous JJ 40288 775 4 , , , 40288 775 5 ephê ephê JJ 40288 775 6 , , , 40288 775 7 kai kai NNP 40288 775 8 geloiôs geloiôs NNP 40288 775 9 ge ge NNP 40288 775 10 , , , 40288 775 11 pyknômat pyknômat NN 40288 775 12 ' ' `` 40288 775 13 atta atta NN 40288 775 14 onomazontes onomazonte NNS 40288 775 15 kai kai NNP 40288 775 16 paraballontes paraballonte NNS 40288 775 17 ta ta NNP 40288 775 18 ôta ôta NNP 40288 775 19 , , , 40288 775 20 hoion hoion NN 40288 775 21 ek ek NNP 40288 775 22 geitonôn geitonôn JJ 40288 775 23 phônên phônên NN 40288 775 24 thêreuomenoi thêreuomenoi NNS 40288 775 25 , , , 40288 775 26 hoi hoi NNP 40288 775 27 men man NNS 40288 775 28 phasin phasin VBP 40288 775 29 eti eti NNP 40288 775 30 katakouein katakouein NNP 40288 775 31 en en IN 40288 775 32 mesô mesô NNP 40288 775 33 tina tina NNP 40288 775 34 êchên êchên NNP 40288 775 35 kai kai NNP 40288 775 36 smikrotaton smikrotaton NNP 40288 775 37 einai einai NNP 40288 775 38 touto touto NNP 40288 775 39 diastêma diastêma NNP 40288 775 40 , , , 40288 775 41 hô hô NNP 40288 775 42 metrêteon metrêteon NNP 40288 775 43 , , , 40288 775 44 hoi hoi NNP 40288 775 45 de de NNP 40288 775 46 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 775 47 . . . 40288 775 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 776 1 Here here RB 40288 776 2 Socrates Socrates NNP 40288 776 3 is be VBZ 40288 776 4 insisting insist VBG 40288 776 5 that that IN 40288 776 6 the the DT 40288 776 7 theory theory NN 40288 776 8 of of IN 40288 776 9 music music NN 40288 776 10 should should MD 40288 776 11 be be VB 40288 776 12 studied study VBN 40288 776 13 as as IN 40288 776 14 a a DT 40288 776 15 branch branch NN 40288 776 16 of of IN 40288 776 17 mathematics mathematic NNS 40288 776 18 , , , 40288 776 19 not not RB 40288 776 20 by by IN 40288 776 21 observation observation NN 40288 776 22 of of IN 40288 776 23 the the DT 40288 776 24 sounds sound NNS 40288 776 25 and and CC 40288 776 26 concords concord NNS 40288 776 27 actually actually RB 40288 776 28 heard hear VBN 40288 776 29 , , , 40288 776 30 about about IN 40288 776 31 which which WDT 40288 776 32 musicians musician NNS 40288 776 33 spend spend VBP 40288 776 34 toil toil NN 40288 776 35 in in IN 40288 776 36 vain vain JJ 40288 776 37 . . . 40288 777 1 ' ' `` 40288 777 2 Yes yes UH 40288 777 3 , , , 40288 777 4 ' ' '' 40288 777 5 says say VBZ 40288 777 6 Glaucon Glaucon NNP 40288 777 7 , , , 40288 777 8 ' ' '' 40288 777 9 they -PRON- PRP 40288 777 10 talk talk VBP 40288 777 11 of of IN 40288 777 12 the the DT 40288 777 13 close close RB 40288 777 14 - - HYPH 40288 777 15 fitting fitting JJ 40288 777 16 of of IN 40288 777 17 intervals interval NNS 40288 777 18 , , , 40288 777 19 and and CC 40288 777 20 put put VB 40288 777 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 777 22 ears ear NNS 40288 777 23 down down RP 40288 777 24 to to TO 40288 777 25 listen listen VB 40288 777 26 for for IN 40288 777 27 the the DT 40288 777 28 smallest small JJS 40288 777 29 possible possible JJ 40288 777 30 interval interval NN 40288 777 31 , , , 40288 777 32 which which WDT 40288 777 33 is be VBZ 40288 777 34 then then RB 40288 777 35 to to TO 40288 777 36 be be VB 40288 777 37 the the DT 40288 777 38 measure measure NN 40288 777 39 . . . 40288 777 40 ' ' '' 40288 778 1 The the DT 40288 778 2 smallest small JJS 40288 778 3 interval interval NN 40288 778 4 was be VBD 40288 778 5 of of IN 40288 778 6 course course NN 40288 778 7 the the DT 40288 778 8 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 778 9 diesis diesis NN 40288 778 10 or or CC 40288 778 11 quarter quarter NN 40288 778 12 of of IN 40288 778 13 a a DT 40288 778 14 tone tone NN 40288 778 15 , , , 40288 778 16 and and CC 40288 778 17 this this DT 40288 778 18 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 778 19 was be VBD 40288 778 20 the the DT 40288 778 21 measure measure NN 40288 778 22 or or CC 40288 778 23 unit unit NN 40288 778 24 into into IN 40288 778 25 which which WDT 40288 778 26 the the DT 40288 778 27 scale scale NN 40288 778 28 was be VBD 40288 778 29 divided divide VBN 40288 778 30 . . . 40288 779 1 A a DT 40288 779 2 group group NN 40288 779 3 of of IN 40288 779 4 notes note NNS 40288 779 5 separated separate VBN 40288 779 6 by by IN 40288 779 7 a a DT 40288 779 8 diesis diesis NN 40288 779 9 was be VBD 40288 779 10 called call VBN 40288 779 11 ' ' `` 40288 779 12 close close RB 40288 779 13 ' ' '' 40288 779 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 779 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 779 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 779 17 : : : 40288 779 18 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 779 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 779 20 , , , 40288 779 21 or or CC 40288 779 22 a a DT 40288 779 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 779 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 779 25 : : : 40288 779 26 pyknôma pyknôma NNP 40288 779 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 779 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 779 29 , , , 40288 779 30 and and CC 40288 779 31 the the DT 40288 779 32 filling filling NN 40288 779 33 up up RP 40288 779 34 of of IN 40288 779 35 the the DT 40288 779 36 scale scale NN 40288 779 37 in in IN 40288 779 38 that that DT 40288 779 39 way way NN 40288 779 40 was be VBD 40288 779 41 therefore therefore RB 40288 779 42 a a DT 40288 779 43 [ [ -LRB- 40288 779 44 Greek Greek NNP 40288 779 45 : : : 40288 779 46 katapyknôsis katapyknôsis NN 40288 779 47 tou tou NNP 40288 779 48 diagrammatos]--a diagrammatos]--a NNP 40288 779 49 filling fill VBG 40288 779 50 up up RP 40288 779 51 with with IN 40288 779 52 ' ' `` 40288 779 53 close close JJ 40288 779 54 - - HYPH 40288 779 55 set set NN 40288 779 56 ' ' '' 40288 779 57 notes note NNS 40288 779 58 , , , 40288 779 59 by by IN 40288 779 60 the the DT 40288 779 61 division division NN 40288 779 62 of of IN 40288 779 63 every every DT 40288 779 64 tone tone NN 40288 779 65 into into IN 40288 779 66 four four CD 40288 779 67 equal equal JJ 40288 779 68 parts part NNS 40288 779 69 . . . 40288 780 1 An an DT 40288 780 2 example example NN 40288 780 3 of of IN 40288 780 4 a a DT 40288 780 5 diagram diagram NN 40288 780 6 of of IN 40288 780 7 this this DT 40288 780 8 kind kind NN 40288 780 9 has have VBZ 40288 780 10 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 780 11 survived survive VBN 40288 780 12 in in IN 40288 780 13 a a DT 40288 780 14 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 780 15 late late JJ 40288 780 16 writer writer NN 40288 780 17 , , , 40288 780 18 viz viz NN 40288 780 19 . . . 40288 781 1 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 781 2 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 781 3 , , , 40288 781 4 who who WP 40288 781 5 gives give VBZ 40288 781 6 a a DT 40288 781 7 scale scale NN 40288 781 8 of of IN 40288 781 9 two two CD 40288 781 10 octaves octave NNS 40288 781 11 , , , 40288 781 12 one one CD 40288 781 13 divided divide VBD 40288 781 14 into into IN 40288 781 15 twenty twenty CD 40288 781 16 - - HYPH 40288 781 17 four four CD 40288 781 18 dieses diesis NNS 40288 781 19 , , , 40288 781 20 the the DT 40288 781 21 next next JJ 40288 781 22 into into IN 40288 781 23 twelve twelve CD 40288 781 24 semitones semitone NNS 40288 781 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 781 26 _ _ NNP 40288 781 27 De De NNP 40288 781 28 Mus Mus NNP 40288 781 29 . . . 40288 781 30 _ _ NNP 40288 781 31 p. p. NN 40288 781 32 15 15 CD 40288 781 33 Meib Meib NNP 40288 781 34 . . . 40288 781 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 781 36 . . . 40288 782 1 The the DT 40288 782 2 characters character NNS 40288 782 3 used use VBN 40288 782 4 are be VBP 40288 782 5 not not RB 40288 782 6 otherwise otherwise RB 40288 782 7 known know VBN 40288 782 8 , , , 40288 782 9 being be VBG 40288 782 10 quite quite RB 40288 782 11 different different JJ 40288 782 12 from from IN 40288 782 13 the the DT 40288 782 14 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 782 15 notation notation NN 40288 782 16 : : : 40288 782 17 but but CC 40288 782 18 the the DT 40288 782 19 nature nature NN 40288 782 20 of of IN 40288 782 21 the the DT 40288 782 22 diagram diagram NN 40288 782 23 is be VBZ 40288 782 24 plain plain JJ 40288 782 25 from from IN 40288 782 26 the the DT 40288 782 27 accompanying accompany VBG 40288 782 28 words word NNS 40288 782 29 : : : 40288 782 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 782 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 782 32 : : : 40288 782 33 hautê hautê NNP 40288 782 34 estin estin NNP 40288 782 35 hê hê NNP 40288 782 36 para para NNP 40288 782 37 tois tois NNP 40288 782 38 archaiois archaiois NNP 40288 782 39 kata kata NNP 40288 782 40 dieseis dieseis NNP 40288 782 41 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 782 42 , , , 40288 782 43 heôs heôs NNP 40288 782 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 782 45 = = SYM 40288 782 46 kd kd NNP 40288 782 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 782 48 dieseôn dieseôn NNP 40288 782 49 to to TO 40288 782 50 proteron proteron VB 40288 782 51 diagousa diagousa NNP 40288 782 52 dia dia NNP 40288 782 53 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 782 54 , , , 40288 782 55 to to IN 40288 782 56 deuteron deuteron NNP 40288 782 57 dia dia NNP 40288 782 58 tôn tôn NNP 40288 782 59 hêmitoniôn hêmitoniôn NNP 40288 782 60 auxêsasa auxêsasa NNP 40288 782 61 ] ] -RRB- 40288 782 62 : : : 40288 782 63 ' ' `` 40288 782 64 this this DT 40288 782 65 is be VBZ 40288 782 66 the the DT 40288 782 67 [ [ -LRB- 40288 782 68 Greek Greek NNP 40288 782 69 : : : 40288 782 70 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 782 71 ] ] -RRB- 40288 782 72 ( ( -LRB- 40288 782 73 division division NN 40288 782 74 of of IN 40288 782 75 the the DT 40288 782 76 scale scale NN 40288 782 77 ) ) -RRB- 40288 782 78 according accord VBG 40288 782 79 to to IN 40288 782 80 dieses diesis NNS 40288 782 81 in in IN 40288 782 82 use use NN 40288 782 83 among among IN 40288 782 84 the the DT 40288 782 85 ancients ancient NNS 40288 782 86 , , , 40288 782 87 carried carry VBN 40288 782 88 in in IN 40288 782 89 the the DT 40288 782 90 case case NN 40288 782 91 of of IN 40288 782 92 the the DT 40288 782 93 first first JJ 40288 782 94 octave octave NN 40288 782 95 as as RB 40288 782 96 far far RB 40288 782 97 as as IN 40288 782 98 twenty twenty CD 40288 782 99 - - HYPH 40288 782 100 four four CD 40288 782 101 dieses diesis NNS 40288 782 102 , , , 40288 782 103 and and CC 40288 782 104 dividing divide VBG 40288 782 105 the the DT 40288 782 106 second second JJ 40288 782 107 into into IN 40288 782 108 semitones[1 semitones[1 NNP 40288 782 109 ] ] -RRB- 40288 782 110 . . . 40288 782 111 ' ' '' 40288 783 1 The the DT 40288 783 2 phrase phrase NN 40288 783 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 783 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 783 5 : : : 40288 783 6 hê hê NNP 40288 783 7 kata kata NNP 40288 783 8 dieseis dieseis NNP 40288 783 9 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 783 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 783 11 , , , 40288 783 12 used use VBN 40288 783 13 for for IN 40288 783 14 the the DT 40288 783 15 division division NN 40288 783 16 of of IN 40288 783 17 an an DT 40288 783 18 octave octave JJ 40288 783 19 scale scale NN 40288 783 20 into into IN 40288 783 21 quarter quarter NN 40288 783 22 - - HYPH 40288 783 23 tones tone NNS 40288 783 24 , , , 40288 783 25 serves serve VBZ 40288 783 26 to to TO 40288 783 27 explain explain VB 40288 783 28 the the DT 40288 783 29 statement statement NN 40288 783 30 of of IN 40288 783 31 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 783 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 783 33 in in IN 40288 783 34 the the DT 40288 783 35 third third NN 40288 783 36 of of IN 40288 783 37 the the DT 40288 783 38 passages passage NNS 40288 783 39 above above IN 40288 783 40 quoted quote VBD 40288 783 41 ) ) -RRB- 40288 783 42 that that IN 40288 783 43 the the DT 40288 783 44 writers writer NNS 40288 783 45 who who WP 40288 783 46 treated treat VBD 40288 783 47 of of IN 40288 783 48 octave octave NN 40288 783 49 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 783 50 called call VBD 40288 783 51 them -PRON- PRP 40288 783 52 ' ' `` 40288 783 53 harmonies harmony NNS 40288 783 54 ' ' '' 40288 783 55 ( ( -LRB- 40288 783 56 [ [ -LRB- 40288 783 57 Greek Greek NNP 40288 783 58 : : : 40288 783 59 ha ha UH 40288 783 60 ekaloun ekaloun NNP 40288 783 61 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 783 62 ] ] -RRB- 40288 783 63 ) ) -RRB- 40288 783 64 . . . 40288 784 1 That that DT 40288 784 2 statement statement NN 40288 784 3 has have VBZ 40288 784 4 usually usually RB 40288 784 5 been be VBN 40288 784 6 taken take VBN 40288 784 7 to to TO 40288 784 8 refer refer VB 40288 784 9 to to IN 40288 784 10 the the DT 40288 784 11 ancient ancient JJ 40288 784 12 Modes mode NNS 40288 784 13 called call VBN 40288 784 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 784 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 784 16 : : : 40288 784 17 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 784 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 784 19 by by IN 40288 784 20 Plato Plato NNP 40288 784 21 and and CC 40288 784 22 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 784 23 , , , 40288 784 24 and and CC 40288 784 25 has have VBZ 40288 784 26 been be VBN 40288 784 27 used use VBN 40288 784 28 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 784 29 as as IN 40288 784 30 proof proof NN 40288 784 31 that that IN 40288 784 32 the the DT 40288 784 33 scales scale NNS 40288 784 34 of of IN 40288 784 35 these these DT 40288 784 36 Modes mode NNS 40288 784 37 were be VBD 40288 784 38 based base VBN 40288 784 39 upon upon IN 40288 784 40 the the DT 40288 784 41 different different JJ 40288 784 42 species specie NNS 40288 784 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 784 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 784 45 Greek greek JJ 40288 784 46 : : : 40288 784 47 eidê eidê NN 40288 784 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 784 49 ) ) -RRB- 40288 784 50 of of IN 40288 784 51 the the DT 40288 784 52 Octave Octave NNP 40288 784 53 . . . 40288 785 1 But but CC 40288 785 2 the the DT 40288 785 3 form form NN 40288 785 4 of of IN 40288 785 5 the the DT 40288 785 6 reference--'which reference--'which NNP 40288 785 7 _ _ NNP 40288 785 8 they -PRON- PRP 40288 785 9 called call VBD 40288 785 10 _ _ NNP 40288 785 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 785 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 785 13 : : : 40288 785 14 harmoniai]'--implies harmoniai]'--implies VB 40288 785 15 some some DT 40288 785 16 forgotten forgotten JJ 40288 785 17 or or CC 40288 785 18 at at IN 40288 785 19 least least JJS 40288 785 20 unfamiliar unfamiliar JJ 40288 785 21 use use NN 40288 785 22 of of IN 40288 785 23 the the DT 40288 785 24 word word NN 40288 785 25 by by IN 40288 785 26 the the DT 40288 785 27 older old JJR 40288 785 28 technical technical JJ 40288 785 29 writers writer NNS 40288 785 30 . . . 40288 786 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 786 2 is be VBZ 40288 786 3 very very RB 40288 786 4 much much RB 40288 786 5 more more RBR 40288 786 6 probable probable JJ 40288 786 7 that that IN 40288 786 8 the the DT 40288 786 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 786 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 786 11 : : : 40288 786 12 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 786 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 786 14 in in IN 40288 786 15 question question NN 40288 786 16 are be VBP 40288 786 17 divisions division NNS 40288 786 18 of of IN 40288 786 19 the the DT 40288 786 20 octave octave NN 40288 786 21 scale scale NN 40288 786 22 , , , 40288 786 23 as as IN 40288 786 24 shown show VBN 40288 786 25 in in IN 40288 786 26 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 786 27 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 786 28 , , , 40288 786 29 and and CC 40288 786 30 had have VBD 40288 786 31 no no DT 40288 786 32 necessary necessary JJ 40288 786 33 connexion connexion NN 40288 786 34 with with IN 40288 786 35 the the DT 40288 786 36 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 786 37 . . . 40288 787 1 Apparently apparently RB 40288 787 2 some some DT 40288 787 3 at at IN 40288 787 4 least least JJS 40288 787 5 of of IN 40288 787 6 these these DT 40288 787 7 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 787 8 were be VBD 40288 787 9 not not RB 40288 787 10 musical musical JJ 40288 787 11 scales scale NNS 40288 787 12 , , , 40288 787 13 but but CC 40288 787 14 tables table NNS 40288 787 15 of of IN 40288 787 16 all all PDT 40288 787 17 the the DT 40288 787 18 notes note NNS 40288 787 19 in in IN 40288 787 20 the the DT 40288 787 21 compass compass NN 40288 787 22 of of IN 40288 787 23 an an DT 40288 787 24 octave octave NN 40288 787 25 ; ; : 40288 787 26 and and CC 40288 787 27 the the DT 40288 787 28 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 787 29 diesis diesis NN 40288 787 30 was be VBD 40288 787 31 used use VBN 40288 787 32 , , , 40288 787 33 not not RB 40288 787 34 merely merely RB 40288 787 35 on on IN 40288 787 36 account account NN 40288 787 37 of of IN 40288 787 38 the the DT 40288 787 39 importance importance NN 40288 787 40 of of IN 40288 787 41 that that DT 40288 787 42 genus genus NN 40288 787 43 , , , 40288 787 44 but but CC 40288 787 45 because because IN 40288 787 46 it -PRON- PRP 40288 787 47 was be VBD 40288 787 48 the the DT 40288 787 49 smallest small JJS 40288 787 50 interval interval NN 40288 787 51 , , , 40288 787 52 and and CC 40288 787 53 therefore therefore RB 40288 787 54 the the DT 40288 787 55 natural natural JJ 40288 787 56 unit unit NN 40288 787 57 of of IN 40288 787 58 measurement[2 measurement[2 NNP 40288 787 59 ] ] -RRB- 40288 787 60 . . . 40288 788 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 788 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 788 3 1 1 CD 40288 788 4 : : : 40288 788 5 The the DT 40288 788 6 fullest full JJS 40288 788 7 account account NN 40288 788 8 of of IN 40288 788 9 this this DT 40288 788 10 curious curious JJ 40288 788 11 fragment fragment NN 40288 788 12 of of IN 40288 788 13 notation notation NN 40288 788 14 is be VBZ 40288 788 15 that that DT 40288 788 16 given give VBN 40288 788 17 by by IN 40288 788 18 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 788 19 in in IN 40288 788 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 788 21 admirable admirable JJ 40288 788 22 book book NN 40288 788 23 , , , 40288 788 24 _ _ NNP 40288 788 25 Die Die NNP 40288 788 26 Tonleitern Tonleitern NNP 40288 788 27 und und NN 40288 788 28 Musiknoten Musiknoten NNP 40288 788 29 der der NN 40288 788 30 Griechen Griechen NNP 40288 788 31 _ _ NNP 40288 788 32 , , , 40288 788 33 pp pp NNP 40288 788 34 . . . 40288 789 1 61 61 CD 40288 789 2 - - SYM 40288 789 3 65 65 CD 40288 789 4 . . . 40288 790 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40288 790 2 conjectures conjecture NNS 40288 790 3 as as IN 40288 790 4 to to IN 40288 790 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 790 6 origin origin NN 40288 790 7 do do VBP 40288 790 8 not not RB 40288 790 9 claim claim VB 40288 790 10 a a DT 40288 790 11 high high JJ 40288 790 12 degree degree NN 40288 790 13 of of IN 40288 790 14 probability probability NN 40288 790 15 . . . 40288 791 1 See see VB 40288 791 2 the the DT 40288 791 3 remarks remark NNS 40288 791 4 on on IN 40288 791 5 pp pp NNP 40288 791 6 . . . 40288 792 1 97 97 CD 40288 792 2 - - SYM 40288 792 3 99 99 CD 40288 792 4 . . . 40288 792 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 793 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 793 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 793 3 2 2 CD 40288 793 4 : : : 40288 793 5 Cp cp RB 40288 793 6 . . . 40288 794 1 Plato Plato NNP 40288 794 2 , , , 40288 794 3 _ _ NNP 40288 794 4 Rep. Rep. NNP 40288 794 5 _ _ NNP 40288 794 6 p. p. NN 40288 794 7 531 531 CD 40288 794 8 : : : 40288 794 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 794 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 794 11 : : : 40288 794 12 kai kai NNP 40288 794 13 smikrotaton smikrotaton NNP 40288 794 14 einai einai NNP 40288 794 15 touto touto NNP 40288 794 16 diastêma diastêma NNP 40288 794 17 , , , 40288 794 18 hô hô NNP 40288 794 19 metrêteon metrêteon NNP 40288 794 20 . . . 40288 794 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 795 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 795 2 may may MD 40288 795 3 even even RB 40288 795 4 be be VB 40288 795 5 that that IN 40288 795 6 this this DT 40288 795 7 sense sense NN 40288 795 8 of of IN 40288 795 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 795 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 795 11 : : : 40288 795 12 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 795 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 795 14 was be VBD 40288 795 15 connected connect VBN 40288 795 16 with with IN 40288 795 17 the the DT 40288 795 18 use use NN 40288 795 19 for for IN 40288 795 20 the the DT 40288 795 21 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 795 22 genus genus NN 40288 795 23 . . . 40288 796 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 796 2 is be VBZ 40288 796 3 at at IN 40288 796 4 least least JJS 40288 796 5 worth worth JJ 40288 796 6 notice notice NN 40288 796 7 that that IN 40288 796 8 the the DT 40288 796 9 phrase phrase NN 40288 796 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 796 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 796 12 : : : 40288 796 13 ha ha UH 40288 796 14 ekaloun ekaloun NNP 40288 796 15 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 796 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 796 17 in in IN 40288 796 18 this this DT 40288 796 19 passage passage NN 40288 796 20 answers answer NNS 40288 796 21 to to IN 40288 796 22 the the DT 40288 796 23 adjective adjective NN 40288 796 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 796 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 796 26 : : : 40288 796 27 enarmoniôn enarmoniôn NN 40288 796 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 796 29 in in IN 40288 796 30 the the DT 40288 796 31 passage passage NN 40288 796 32 first first RB 40288 796 33 quoted quote VBN 40288 796 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 796 35 compare compare VB 40288 796 36 the the DT 40288 796 37 words word NNS 40288 796 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 796 39 Greek Greek NNP 40288 796 40 : : : 40288 796 41 peri peri NNP 40288 796 42 autôn autôn NNP 40288 796 43 monon monon NNP 40288 796 44 tôn tôn NNP 40288 796 45 hepta hepta NNP 40288 796 46 oktachordôn oktachordôn NNP 40288 796 47 ha ha NNP 40288 796 48 ekaloun ekaloun NNP 40288 796 49 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 796 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 796 51 with with IN 40288 796 52 [ [ -LRB- 40288 796 53 Greek Greek NNP 40288 796 54 : : : 40288 796 55 peri peri NN 40288 796 56 systêmatôn systêmatôn NNS 40288 796 57 oktachordôn oktachordôn NNP 40288 796 58 enarmoniôn enarmoniôn NNP 40288 796 59 monon monon NNP 40288 796 60 ] ] -RRB- 40288 796 61 ) ) -RRB- 40288 796 62 . . . 40288 796 63 ] ] -RRB- 40288 797 1 The the DT 40288 797 2 use use NN 40288 797 3 of of IN 40288 797 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 797 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 797 6 : : : 40288 797 7 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 797 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 797 9 as as IN 40288 797 10 an an DT 40288 797 11 equivalent equivalent NN 40288 797 12 for for IN 40288 797 13 ' ' `` 40288 797 14 System system NN 40288 797 15 ' ' '' 40288 797 16 or or CC 40288 797 17 ' ' '' 40288 797 18 division division NN 40288 797 19 of of IN 40288 797 20 the the DT 40288 797 21 scale scale NN 40288 797 22 ' ' `` 40288 797 23 appears appear VBZ 40288 797 24 in in IN 40288 797 25 an an DT 40288 797 26 important important JJ 40288 797 27 passage passage NN 40288 797 28 in in IN 40288 797 29 Plato Plato NNP 40288 797 30 's 's POS 40288 797 31 _ _ NNP 40288 797 32 Philebus Philebus NNP 40288 797 33 _ _ NNP 40288 797 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 797 35 p. p. NN 40288 797 36 17 17 CD 40288 797 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 797 38 : : : 40288 797 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 797 40 Greek Greek NNP 40288 797 41 : : : 40288 797 42 all all DT 40288 797 43 ' ' '' 40288 797 44 , , , 40288 797 45 ô ô NNP 40288 797 46 phile phile NN 40288 797 47 , , , 40288 797 48 epeidan epeidan NNP 40288 797 49 labês labês NNP 40288 797 50 ta ta NNP 40288 797 51 diastêmata diastêmata NNP 40288 797 52 hoposa hoposa NNP 40288 797 53 esti esti NNP 40288 797 54 ton ton NNP 40288 797 55 arithmon arithmon NNP 40288 797 56 tês tês NNP 40288 797 57 phônês phônês NNP 40288 797 58 oxytêtos oxytêtos NNP 40288 797 59 te te NNP 40288 797 60 peri peri NNP 40288 797 61 kai kai NNP 40288 797 62 barytêtos barytêtos NNP 40288 797 63 , , , 40288 797 64 kai kai NNP 40288 797 65 hopoia hopoia NNP 40288 797 66 , , , 40288 797 67 kai kai NNP 40288 797 68 tous tous JJ 40288 797 69 horous horous NNP 40288 797 70 tôn tôn NNP 40288 797 71 diastêmatôn diastêmatôn NNP 40288 797 72 , , , 40288 797 73 kai kai NNP 40288 797 74 ta ta NNP 40288 797 75 ek ek NNP 40288 797 76 toutôn toutôn NNP 40288 797 77 hosa hosa NNP 40288 797 78 systêmata systêmata NNP 40288 797 79 gegonen gegonen NNP 40288 797 80 , , , 40288 797 81 ha ha UH 40288 797 82 katidontes katidontes NNP 40288 797 83 hoi hoi NNP 40288 797 84 prosthen prosthen NNP 40288 797 85 paredosan paredosan NNP 40288 797 86 hêmin hêmin NNP 40288 797 87 tois tois NNP 40288 797 88 hepomenois hepomenois NNP 40288 797 89 ekeinois ekeinois NNP 40288 797 90 kalein kalein NNP 40288 797 91 auta auta NNP 40288 797 92 harmonias harmonias NNP 40288 797 93 , , , 40288 797 94 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 797 95 . . . 40288 797 96 ] ] -RRB- 40288 798 1 In in IN 40288 798 2 this this DT 40288 798 3 passage,--which passage,--which NNP 40288 798 4 has have VBZ 40288 798 5 an an DT 40288 798 6 air air NN 40288 798 7 of of IN 40288 798 8 technical technical JJ 40288 798 9 accuracy accuracy NN 40288 798 10 not not RB 40288 798 11 usual usual JJ 40288 798 12 in in IN 40288 798 13 Plato Plato NNP 40288 798 14 's 's POS 40288 798 15 references reference NNS 40288 798 16 to to IN 40288 798 17 music music NN 40288 798 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 798 19 though though IN 40288 798 20 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 798 21 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 798 22 of of IN 40288 798 23 the the DT 40288 798 24 _ _ NNP 40288 798 25 Philebus_),--there Philebus_),--there NNP 40288 798 26 is be VBZ 40288 798 27 a a DT 40288 798 28 close close JJ 40288 798 29 agreement agreement NN 40288 798 30 with with IN 40288 798 31 the the DT 40288 798 32 technical technical JJ 40288 798 33 writers writer NNS 40288 798 34 , , , 40288 798 35 especially especially RB 40288 798 36 Aristoxenus aristoxenus JJ 40288 798 37 . . . 40288 799 1 The the DT 40288 799 2 main main JJ 40288 799 3 thought thought NN 40288 799 4 is be VBZ 40288 799 5 the the DT 40288 799 6 application application NN 40288 799 7 of of IN 40288 799 8 limit limit NN 40288 799 9 or or CC 40288 799 10 measure measure NN 40288 799 11 to to TO 40288 799 12 matter matter VB 40288 799 13 which which WDT 40288 799 14 is be VBZ 40288 799 15 given give VBN 40288 799 16 as as IN 40288 799 17 unlimited unlimited JJ 40288 799 18 or or CC 40288 799 19 indefinite indefinite RB 40288 799 20 -- -- : 40288 799 21 the the DT 40288 799 22 distinction distinction NN 40288 799 23 drawn draw VBN 40288 799 24 out out RP 40288 799 25 by by IN 40288 799 26 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 799 27 in in IN 40288 799 28 a a DT 40288 799 29 passage passage NN 40288 799 30 quoted quote VBN 40288 799 31 below below RB 40288 799 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 799 33 p. p. NN 40288 799 34 81 81 CD 40288 799 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 799 36 . . . 40288 800 1 The the DT 40288 800 2 treatment treatment NN 40288 800 3 of of IN 40288 800 4 the the DT 40288 800 5 term term NN 40288 800 6 ' ' `` 40288 800 7 System system NN 40288 800 8 ' ' '' 40288 800 9 is be VBZ 40288 800 10 notably notably RB 40288 800 11 Aristoxenean aristoxenean JJ 40288 800 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 800 13 cp cp NNP 40288 800 14 . . . 40288 801 1 _ _ NNP 40288 801 2 Harm Harm NNP 40288 801 3 . . . 40288 801 4 _ _ NNP 40288 801 5 p. p. NN 40288 801 6 36 36 CD 40288 801 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 801 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 801 9 : : : 40288 801 10 ta ta NNP 40288 801 11 systêmata systêmata NNP 40288 801 12 theôrêsai theôrêsai NNP 40288 801 13 posa posa NNP 40288 801 14 te te NNP 40288 801 15 esti esti NNP 40288 801 16 kai kai NNP 40288 801 17 poia poia NNP 40288 801 18 atta atta NNP 40288 801 19 , , , 40288 801 20 kai kai NNP 40288 801 21 pôs pôs NNP 40288 801 22 ek ek NNP 40288 801 23 te te NNP 40288 801 24 tôn tôn NNP 40288 801 25 diastêmatôn diastêmatôn NNP 40288 801 26 kai kai NNP 40288 801 27 phthongôn phthongôn NNPS 40288 801 28 synestêkota synestêkota NNP 40288 801 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 801 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 801 31 . . . 40288 802 1 Further further RB 40288 802 2 , , , 40288 802 3 the the DT 40288 802 4 use use NN 40288 802 5 of of IN 40288 802 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 802 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 802 8 : : : 40288 802 9 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 802 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 802 11 for for IN 40288 802 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 802 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 802 14 : : : 40288 802 15 systêma systêma NN 40288 802 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 802 17 , , , 40288 802 18 or or CC 40288 802 19 rather rather RB 40288 802 20 of of IN 40288 802 21 the the DT 40288 802 22 plural plural JJ 40288 802 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 802 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 802 25 : : : 40288 802 26 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 802 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 802 28 for for IN 40288 802 29 the the DT 40288 802 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 802 31 Greek greek JJ 40288 802 32 : : : 40288 802 33 systêmata systêmata NN 40288 802 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 802 35 observed observe VBN 40288 802 36 by by IN 40288 802 37 the the DT 40288 802 38 older old JJR 40288 802 39 musical musical JJ 40288 802 40 theorists theorist NNS 40288 802 41 , , , 40288 802 42 is be VBZ 40288 802 43 exactly exactly RB 40288 802 44 what what WP 40288 802 45 is be VBZ 40288 802 46 noticed notice VBN 40288 802 47 by by IN 40288 802 48 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 802 49 as as IN 40288 802 50 if if IN 40288 802 51 it -PRON- PRP 40288 802 52 were be VBD 40288 802 53 more more RBR 40288 802 54 or or CC 40288 802 55 less less RBR 40288 802 56 antiquated antiquated JJ 40288 802 57 . . . 40288 803 1 Even even RB 40288 803 2 in in IN 40288 803 3 the the DT 40288 803 4 time time NN 40288 803 5 of of IN 40288 803 6 Plato Plato NNP 40288 803 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 803 8 appears appear VBZ 40288 803 9 as as IN 40288 803 10 a a DT 40288 803 11 word word NN 40288 803 12 of of IN 40288 803 13 traditional traditional JJ 40288 803 14 character character NN 40288 803 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 803 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 803 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 803 18 : : : 40288 803 19 hoi hoi NNP 40288 803 20 prosthen prosthen NNP 40288 803 21 paredosan paredosan NNP 40288 803 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 803 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 803 24 , , , 40288 803 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 803 26 own own JJ 40288 803 27 word word NN 40288 803 28 being be VBG 40288 803 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 803 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 803 31 : : : 40288 803 32 systêma systêma NN 40288 803 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 803 34 . . . 40288 804 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 804 2 need nee MD 40288 804 3 not not RB 40288 804 4 be be VB 40288 804 5 said say VBN 40288 804 6 that that IN 40288 804 7 there there EX 40288 804 8 is be VBZ 40288 804 9 no no DT 40288 804 10 such such JJ 40288 804 11 hesitation hesitation NN 40288 804 12 , , , 40288 804 13 either either CC 40288 804 14 in in IN 40288 804 15 Plato Plato NNP 40288 804 16 or or CC 40288 804 17 in in IN 40288 804 18 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 804 19 , , , 40288 804 20 about about IN 40288 804 21 the the DT 40288 804 22 use use NN 40288 804 23 of of IN 40288 804 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 804 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 804 26 : : : 40288 804 27 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 804 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 804 29 for for IN 40288 804 30 the the DT 40288 804 31 modes mode NNS 40288 804 32 . . . 40288 805 1 The the DT 40288 805 2 same same JJ 40288 805 3 use use NN 40288 805 4 of of IN 40288 805 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 805 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 805 7 : : : 40288 805 8 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 805 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 805 10 is be VBZ 40288 805 11 found find VBN 40288 805 12 in in IN 40288 805 13 the the DT 40288 805 14 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 805 15 _ _ NNP 40288 805 16 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 805 17 _ _ NNP 40288 805 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 805 19 xix xix NNP 40288 805 20 . . . 40288 806 1 26 26 CD 40288 806 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 806 3 , , , 40288 806 4 where where WRB 40288 806 5 the the DT 40288 806 6 question question NN 40288 806 7 is be VBZ 40288 806 8 asked ask VBN 40288 806 9 , , , 40288 806 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 806 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 806 12 : : : 40288 806 13 dia dia VB 40288 806 14 ti ti NNP 40288 806 15 mesê mesê NNP 40288 806 16 kaleitai kaleitai NNP 40288 806 17 en en IN 40288 806 18 tais tais NNP 40288 806 19 harmoniais harmoniais NNP 40288 806 20 , , , 40288 806 21 tôn tôn NNP 40288 806 22 de de NNP 40288 806 23 oktô oktô NNP 40288 806 24 ouk ouk NNP 40288 806 25 esti esti NNP 40288 806 26 meson meson NNP 40288 806 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 806 28 , , , 40288 806 29 _ _ NNP 40288 806 30 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 806 31 _ _ NNP 40288 806 32 how how WRB 40288 806 33 can can MD 40288 806 34 we -PRON- PRP 40288 806 35 speak speak VB 40288 806 36 of of IN 40288 806 37 the the DT 40288 806 38 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 806 39 or or CC 40288 806 40 ' ' `` 40288 806 41 middle middle JJ 40288 806 42 note note NN 40288 806 43 ' ' '' 40288 806 44 of of IN 40288 806 45 a a DT 40288 806 46 scale scale NN 40288 806 47 of of IN 40288 806 48 eight eight CD 40288 806 49 notes note NNS 40288 806 50 ? ? . 40288 807 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 807 2 have have VBP 40288 807 3 now now RB 40288 807 4 reviewed review VBN 40288 807 5 all all PDT 40288 807 6 the the DT 40288 807 7 passages passage NNS 40288 807 8 in in IN 40288 807 9 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 807 10 which which WDT 40288 807 11 can can MD 40288 807 12 be be VB 40288 807 13 thought think VBN 40288 807 14 to to TO 40288 807 15 bear bear VB 40288 807 16 upon upon IN 40288 807 17 the the DT 40288 807 18 question question NN 40288 807 19 whether whether IN 40288 807 20 the the DT 40288 807 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 807 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 807 23 : : : 40288 807 24 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 807 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 807 26 or or CC 40288 807 27 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 807 28 of of IN 40288 807 29 early early JJ 40288 807 30 Greek greek JJ 40288 807 31 music music NN 40288 807 32 are be VBP 40288 807 33 the the DT 40288 807 34 same same JJ 40288 807 35 as as IN 40288 807 36 the the DT 40288 807 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 807 38 Greek Greek NNP 40288 807 39 : : : 40288 807 40 tonoi tonoi NN 40288 807 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 807 42 or or CC 40288 807 43 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 807 44 discussed discuss VBN 40288 807 45 by by IN 40288 807 46 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 807 47 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 807 48 . . . 40288 808 1 The the DT 40288 808 2 result result NN 40288 808 3 seems seem VBZ 40288 808 4 to to TO 40288 808 5 be be VB 40288 808 6 that that IN 40288 808 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 808 8 have have VBP 40288 808 9 found find VBN 40288 808 10 nothing nothing NN 40288 808 11 to to TO 40288 808 12 set set VB 40288 808 13 against against IN 40288 808 14 the the DT 40288 808 15 positive positive JJ 40288 808 16 arguments argument NNS 40288 808 17 for for IN 40288 808 18 the the DT 40288 808 19 identification identification NN 40288 808 20 already already RB 40288 808 21 urged urge VBD 40288 808 22 . . . 40288 809 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 809 2 may may MD 40288 809 3 be be VB 40288 809 4 thought think VBN 40288 809 5 , , , 40288 809 6 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 809 7 , , , 40288 809 8 that that IN 40288 809 9 the the DT 40288 809 10 variety variety NN 40288 809 11 of of IN 40288 809 12 senses sense NNS 40288 809 13 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 809 14 to to IN 40288 809 15 the the DT 40288 809 16 word word NN 40288 809 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 809 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 809 19 : : : 40288 809 20 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 809 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 809 22 goes go VBZ 40288 809 23 beyond beyond IN 40288 809 24 what what WP 40288 809 25 is be VBZ 40288 809 26 probable probable JJ 40288 809 27 . . . 40288 810 1 In in IN 40288 810 2 itself -PRON- PRP 40288 810 3 however however RB 40288 810 4 the the DT 40288 810 5 word word NN 40288 810 6 meant mean VBD 40288 810 7 simply simply RB 40288 810 8 ' ' `` 40288 810 9 musical musical JJ 40288 810 10 scale[1 scale[1 NNP 40288 810 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 810 12 . . . 40288 810 13 ' ' '' 40288 811 1 The the DT 40288 811 2 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 811 3 use use NN 40288 811 4 of of IN 40288 811 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 811 6 in in IN 40288 811 7 the the DT 40288 811 8 sense sense NN 40288 811 9 of of IN 40288 811 10 ' ' `` 40288 811 11 octave octave NN 40288 811 12 scale scale NN 40288 811 13 , , , 40288 811 14 ' ' '' 40288 811 15 and and CC 40288 811 16 the the DT 40288 811 17 very very RB 40288 811 18 similar similar JJ 40288 811 19 use use NN 40288 811 20 in in IN 40288 811 21 reference reference NN 40288 811 22 to to IN 40288 811 23 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 811 24 which which WDT 40288 811 25 represented represent VBD 40288 811 26 the the DT 40288 811 27 division division NN 40288 811 28 of of IN 40288 811 29 that that DT 40288 811 30 scale scale NN 40288 811 31 , , , 40288 811 32 were be VBD 40288 811 33 antiquated antiquated JJ 40288 811 34 in in IN 40288 811 35 the the DT 40288 811 36 time time NN 40288 811 37 of of IN 40288 811 38 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 811 39 . . . 40288 812 1 The the DT 40288 812 2 sense sense NN 40288 812 3 of of IN 40288 812 4 ' ' `` 40288 812 5 key key NN 40288 812 6 ' ' '' 40288 812 7 was be VBD 40288 812 8 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 812 9 limited limit VBN 40288 812 10 in in IN 40288 812 11 the the DT 40288 812 12 first first JJ 40288 812 13 instance instance NN 40288 812 14 to to IN 40288 812 15 the the DT 40288 812 16 use use NN 40288 812 17 in in IN 40288 812 18 conjunction conjunction NN 40288 812 19 with with IN 40288 812 20 the the DT 40288 812 21 names name NNS 40288 812 22 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 812 23 , , , 40288 812 24 & & CC 40288 812 25 c. c. NNP 40288 812 26 , , , 40288 812 27 which which WDT 40288 812 28 suggested suggest VBD 40288 812 29 a a DT 40288 812 30 distinction distinction NN 40288 812 31 of of IN 40288 812 32 pitch pitch NN 40288 812 33 . . . 40288 813 1 From from IN 40288 813 2 the the DT 40288 813 3 meaning meaning NN 40288 813 4 ' ' `` 40288 813 5 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 813 6 scale scale NN 40288 813 7 ' ' '' 40288 813 8 to to IN 40288 813 9 ' ' '' 40288 813 10 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 813 11 key key NN 40288 813 12 ' ' '' 40288 813 13 is be VBZ 40288 813 14 an an DT 40288 813 15 easy easy JJ 40288 813 16 step step NN 40288 813 17 . . . 40288 814 1 Finally finally RB 40288 814 2 , , , 40288 814 3 in in IN 40288 814 4 reference reference NN 40288 814 5 to to IN 40288 814 6 genus genus NN 40288 814 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 814 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 814 9 : : : 40288 814 10 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 814 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 814 12 meant mean VBD 40288 814 13 the the DT 40288 814 14 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 814 15 scale scale NN 40288 814 16 . . . 40288 815 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 815 2 is be VBZ 40288 815 3 not not RB 40288 815 4 surprising surprising JJ 40288 815 5 that that IN 40288 815 6 a a DT 40288 815 7 word word NN 40288 815 8 with with IN 40288 815 9 so so RB 40288 815 10 many many JJ 40288 815 11 meanings meaning NNS 40288 815 12 did do VBD 40288 815 13 not not RB 40288 815 14 keep keep VB 40288 815 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 815 16 place place NN 40288 815 17 in in IN 40288 815 18 technical technical JJ 40288 815 19 language language NN 40288 815 20 , , , 40288 815 21 but but CC 40288 815 22 was be VBD 40288 815 23 replaced replace VBN 40288 815 24 by by IN 40288 815 25 unambiguous unambiguous JJ 40288 815 26 words word NNS 40288 815 27 , , , 40288 815 28 viz viz NN 40288 815 29 . . . 40288 816 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 816 2 Greek greek NN 40288 816 3 : : : 40288 816 4 tonos tonos NN 40288 816 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 816 6 in in IN 40288 816 7 one one CD 40288 816 8 sense sense NN 40288 816 9 , , , 40288 816 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 816 11 Greek greek JJ 40288 816 12 : : : 40288 816 13 systêma systêma NN 40288 816 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 816 15 in in IN 40288 816 16 another another DT 40288 816 17 , , , 40288 816 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 816 19 Greek greek JJ 40288 816 20 : : : 40288 816 21 genos genos NNP 40288 816 22 enarmonion enarmonion NN 40288 816 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 816 24 in in IN 40288 816 25 a a DT 40288 816 26 third third NN 40288 816 27 . . . 40288 817 1 Naturally naturally RB 40288 817 2 , , , 40288 817 3 too too RB 40288 817 4 , , , 40288 817 5 the the DT 40288 817 6 more more RBR 40288 817 7 precise precise JJ 40288 817 8 terms term NNS 40288 817 9 would would MD 40288 817 10 be be VB 40288 817 11 first first RB 40288 817 12 employed employ VBN 40288 817 13 by by IN 40288 817 14 technical technical JJ 40288 817 15 writers writer NNS 40288 817 16 . . . 40288 818 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 818 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 818 3 1 1 CD 40288 818 4 : : : 40288 818 5 So so CC 40288 818 6 in in IN 40288 818 7 Plato Plato NNP 40288 818 8 , , , 40288 818 9 _ _ NNP 40288 818 10 Leg Leg NNP 40288 818 11 . . . 40288 818 12 _ _ NNP 40288 818 13 p. p. NN 40288 818 14 665 665 CD 40288 818 15 a a NN 40288 818 16 : : : 40288 818 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 818 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 818 19 : : : 40288 818 20 tê tê NN 40288 818 21 dê dê NNP 40288 818 22 tês tês NNP 40288 818 23 kinêseôs kinêseôs NNP 40288 818 24 taxei taxei NNP 40288 818 25 rhythmos rhythmos NNP 40288 818 26 onoma onoma NNP 40288 818 27 eiê eiê NNP 40288 818 28 , , , 40288 818 29 tê tê NNP 40288 818 30 d d NNP 40288 818 31 ' ' '' 40288 818 32 au au NNP 40288 818 33 tês tês NNP 40288 818 34 phônês phônês NNP 40288 818 35 , , , 40288 818 36 tou tou NNP 40288 818 37 te te NNP 40288 818 38 oxeos oxeos NNP 40288 818 39 hama hama NNP 40288 818 40 kai kai NNP 40288 818 41 bareos bareos NNP 40288 818 42 synkerannymenôn synkerannymenôn NNP 40288 818 43 , , , 40288 818 44 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 818 45 onoma onoma NNP 40288 818 46 prosagoreuoito prosagoreuoito NNP 40288 818 47 . . . 40288 818 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 818 49 ] ] -RRB- 40288 819 1 § § ADD 40288 819 2 23 23 CD 40288 819 3 . . . 40288 820 1 _ _ NNP 40288 820 2 The the DT 40288 820 3 Seven Seven NNP 40288 820 4 Species Species NNPS 40288 820 5 . . . 40288 820 6 _ _ NNP 40288 820 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 820 8 See see VB 40288 820 9 the the DT 40288 820 10 Appendix Appendix NNP 40288 820 11 , , , 40288 820 12 Table table NN 40288 820 13 I. i. NN 40288 820 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 821 1 In in IN 40288 821 2 the the DT 40288 821 3 _ _ NNP 40288 821 4 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 821 5 _ _ NNP 40288 821 6 of of IN 40288 821 7 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 821 8 an an DT 40288 821 9 account account NN 40288 821 10 of of IN 40288 821 11 the the DT 40288 821 12 seven seven CD 40288 821 13 species specie NNS 40288 821 14 of of IN 40288 821 15 the the DT 40288 821 16 Octave Octave NNP 40288 821 17 followed follow VBD 40288 821 18 the the DT 40288 821 19 elaborate elaborate JJ 40288 821 20 theory theory NN 40288 821 21 of of IN 40288 821 22 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 821 23 already already RB 40288 821 24 referred refer VBD 40288 821 25 to to IN 40288 821 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 821 27 p. p. NN 40288 821 28 48 48 CD 40288 821 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 821 30 , , , 40288 821 31 and and CC 40288 821 32 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 821 33 exhibited exhibit VBD 40288 821 34 the the DT 40288 821 35 application application NN 40288 821 36 of of IN 40288 821 37 that that DT 40288 821 38 general general JJ 40288 821 39 theory theory NN 40288 821 40 to to IN 40288 821 41 the the DT 40288 821 42 particular particular JJ 40288 821 43 cases case NNS 40288 821 44 of of IN 40288 821 45 the the DT 40288 821 46 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 821 47 , , , 40288 821 48 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 821 49 , , , 40288 821 50 and and CC 40288 821 51 Octave Octave NNP 40288 821 52 . . . 40288 822 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 40288 822 2 the the DT 40288 822 3 existing exist VBG 40288 822 4 manuscripts manuscript NNS 40288 822 5 have have VBP 40288 822 6 only only RB 40288 822 7 preserved preserve VBN 40288 822 8 the the DT 40288 822 9 first first JJ 40288 822 10 few few JJ 40288 822 11 lines line NNS 40288 822 12 of of IN 40288 822 13 this this DT 40288 822 14 chapter chapter NN 40288 822 15 of of IN 40288 822 16 the the DT 40288 822 17 Aristoxenean aristoxenean JJ 40288 822 18 work work NN 40288 822 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 822 20 p. p. NN 40288 822 21 74 74 CD 40288 822 22 , , , 40288 822 23 ll will VBD 40288 822 24 . . . 40288 823 1 10 10 CD 40288 823 2 - - SYM 40288 823 3 24 24 CD 40288 823 4 Meib Meib NNP 40288 823 5 . . . 40288 823 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 823 7 . . . 40288 824 1 The the DT 40288 824 2 next next JJ 40288 824 3 source source NN 40288 824 4 from from IN 40288 824 5 which which WDT 40288 824 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 824 7 learn learn VBP 40288 824 8 anything anything NN 40288 824 9 of of IN 40288 824 10 this this DT 40288 824 11 part part NN 40288 824 12 of of IN 40288 824 13 the the DT 40288 824 14 subject subject NN 40288 824 15 is be VBZ 40288 824 16 the the DT 40288 824 17 pseudo pseudo JJ 40288 824 18 - - JJ 40288 824 19 Euclidean euclidean JJ 40288 824 20 _ _ NNP 40288 824 21 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 824 22 Harmonica Harmonica NNP 40288 824 23 _ _ NNP 40288 824 24 . . . 40288 825 1 The the DT 40288 825 2 writer writer NN 40288 825 3 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40288 825 4 the the DT 40288 825 5 species specie NNS 40288 825 6 of of IN 40288 825 7 the the DT 40288 825 8 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 825 9 , , , 40288 825 10 the the DT 40288 825 11 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 825 12 , , , 40288 825 13 and and CC 40288 825 14 the the DT 40288 825 15 Octave Octave NNP 40288 825 16 , , , 40288 825 17 first first RB 40288 825 18 in in IN 40288 825 19 the the DT 40288 825 20 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 825 21 and and CC 40288 825 22 then then RB 40288 825 23 in in IN 40288 825 24 the the DT 40288 825 25 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 825 26 genus genus NN 40288 825 27 . . . 40288 826 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 826 2 shows show VBZ 40288 826 3 that that IN 40288 826 4 if if IN 40288 826 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 826 6 take take VBP 40288 826 7 Fourths fourth NNS 40288 826 8 on on IN 40288 826 9 a a DT 40288 826 10 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 826 11 scale scale NN 40288 826 12 , , , 40288 826 13 beginning begin VBG 40288 826 14 with with IN 40288 826 15 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 826 16 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 826 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 826 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 826 19 _ _ NNP 40288 826 20 b b NNP 40288 826 21 _ _ NNP 40288 826 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 826 23 , , , 40288 826 24 we -PRON- PRP 40288 826 25 get get VBP 40288 826 26 successively successively RB 40288 826 27 _ _ NNP 40288 826 28 b b NNP 40288 826 29 c c NNP 40288 826 30 d d NNP 40288 826 31 e e NNP 40288 826 32 _ _ NNP 40288 826 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 826 34 a a DT 40288 826 35 scale scale NN 40288 826 36 with with IN 40288 826 37 the the DT 40288 826 38 intervals interval NNS 40288 826 39 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 826 40 1 1 CD 40288 826 41 1 1 CD 40288 826 42 ) ) -RRB- 40288 826 43 , , , 40288 826 44 _ _ NNP 40288 826 45 c c NNP 40288 826 46 d d NNP 40288 826 47 e e NNP 40288 826 48 f f NNP 40288 826 49 _ _ NNP 40288 826 50 ( ( -LRB- 40288 826 51 1 1 CD 40288 826 52 1 1 CD 40288 826 53 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 826 54 ) ) -RRB- 40288 826 55 and and CC 40288 826 56 _ _ NNP 40288 826 57 d d NNP 40288 826 58 e e NNP 40288 826 59 f f NNP 40288 826 60 g g NNP 40288 826 61 _ _ NNP 40288 826 62 ( ( -LRB- 40288 826 63 1 1 CD 40288 826 64 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 826 65 1 1 CD 40288 826 66 ) ) -RRB- 40288 826 67 . . . 40288 827 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 827 2 on on IN 40288 827 3 the the DT 40288 827 4 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 827 5 scale scale NN 40288 827 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 827 7 get-- get-- VBP 40288 827 8 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 827 9 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 827 10 to to IN 40288 827 11 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 827 12 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 827 13 _ _ NNP 40288 827 14 b b NNP 40288 827 15 b b NNP 40288 827 16 * * NN 40288 827 17 c c NN 40288 827 18 e e NNP 40288 827 19 _ _ NNP 40288 827 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 827 21 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 827 22 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 827 23 2 2 CD 40288 827 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 827 25 Parhypatê parhypatê NN 40288 827 26 " " '' 40288 827 27 " " `` 40288 827 28 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 827 29 " " '' 40288 827 30 _ _ NNP 40288 827 31 b b NNP 40288 827 32 * * NFP 40288 827 33 c c NN 40288 827 34 e e NNP 40288 827 35 e e NNP 40288 827 36 * * NFP 40288 827 37 _ _ NNP 40288 827 38 ( ( -LRB- 40288 827 39 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 827 40 2 2 CD 40288 827 41 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 827 42 ) ) -RRB- 40288 827 43 Lichanos lichanos NN 40288 827 44 " " '' 40288 827 45 " " `` 40288 827 46 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 827 47 " " '' 40288 827 48 _ _ NNP 40288 827 49 c c NNP 40288 827 50 e e NNP 40288 827 51 e e NNP 40288 827 52 * * NNP 40288 827 53 f f NNP 40288 827 54 _ _ NNP 40288 827 55 ( ( -LRB- 40288 827 56 2 2 CD 40288 827 57 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 827 58 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 827 59 ) ) -RRB- 40288 827 60 In in IN 40288 827 61 the the DT 40288 827 62 case case NN 40288 827 63 of of IN 40288 827 64 the the DT 40288 827 65 Octave Octave NNP 40288 827 66 the the DT 40288 827 67 species species NN 40288 827 68 is be VBZ 40288 827 69 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 827 70 on on IN 40288 827 71 the the DT 40288 827 72 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 827 73 scale scale NN 40288 827 74 by by IN 40288 827 75 the the DT 40288 827 76 place place NN 40288 827 77 of of IN 40288 827 78 the the DT 40288 827 79 tone tone NN 40288 827 80 which which WDT 40288 827 81 separates separate VBZ 40288 827 82 the the DT 40288 827 83 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 827 84 , , , 40288 827 85 the the DT 40288 827 86 so so RB 40288 827 87 - - HYPH 40288 827 88 called call VBN 40288 827 89 Disjunctive Disjunctive NNP 40288 827 90 Tone tone NN 40288 827 91 ( ( -LRB- 40288 827 92 [ [ -LRB- 40288 827 93 Greek Greek NNP 40288 827 94 : : : 40288 827 95 tonos tonos NN 40288 827 96 diazeuktikos diazeuktikos NN 40288 827 97 ] ] -RRB- 40288 827 98 ) ) -RRB- 40288 827 99 . . . 40288 828 1 Thus thus RB 40288 828 2 in in IN 40288 828 3 the the DT 40288 828 4 octave octave NN 40288 828 5 from from IN 40288 828 6 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 828 7 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 828 8 to to IN 40288 828 9 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 828 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 828 11 _ _ NNP 40288 828 12 b b NNP 40288 828 13 - - HYPH 40288 828 14 b b NNP 40288 828 15 _ _ NNP 40288 828 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 828 17 this this DT 40288 828 18 tone tone NN 40288 828 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 828 20 _ _ NNP 40288 828 21 a a NNP 40288 828 22 - - HYPH 40288 828 23 b b NNP 40288 828 24 _ _ NN 40288 828 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 828 26 is be VBZ 40288 828 27 the the DT 40288 828 28 highest high JJS 40288 828 29 interval interval NN 40288 828 30 ; ; : 40288 828 31 in in IN 40288 828 32 the the DT 40288 828 33 next next JJ 40288 828 34 octave octave NN 40288 828 35 , , , 40288 828 36 from from IN 40288 828 37 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 828 38 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 828 39 to to IN 40288 828 40 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 828 41 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 828 42 ( ( -LRB- 40288 828 43 _ _ NNP 40288 828 44 c c NNP 40288 828 45 - - HYPH 40288 828 46 c c NNP 40288 828 47 _ _ NNP 40288 828 48 ) ) -RRB- 40288 828 49 , , , 40288 828 50 it -PRON- PRP 40288 828 51 is be VBZ 40288 828 52 the the DT 40288 828 53 second second JJ 40288 828 54 highest high JJS 40288 828 55 ; ; : 40288 828 56 and and CC 40288 828 57 so so RB 40288 828 58 on on RB 40288 828 59 . . . 40288 829 1 These these DT 40288 829 2 octaves octave NNS 40288 829 3 , , , 40288 829 4 or or CC 40288 829 5 species specie NNS 40288 829 6 of of IN 40288 829 7 the the DT 40288 829 8 Octave Octave NNP 40288 829 9 , , , 40288 829 10 the the DT 40288 829 11 writer writer NN 40288 829 12 goes go VBZ 40288 829 13 on on RP 40288 829 14 to to TO 40288 829 15 tell tell VB 40288 829 16 us -PRON- PRP 40288 829 17 , , , 40288 829 18 were be VBD 40288 829 19 anciently anciently RB 40288 829 20 called call VBN 40288 829 21 by by IN 40288 829 22 the the DT 40288 829 23 same same JJ 40288 829 24 names name NNS 40288 829 25 as as IN 40288 829 26 the the DT 40288 829 27 seven seven CD 40288 829 28 oldest old JJS 40288 829 29 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 829 30 , , , 40288 829 31 as as IN 40288 829 32 follows follow VBZ 40288 829 33 : : : 40288 829 34 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 829 35 - - HYPH 40288 829 36 lydian lydian NNP 40288 829 37 _ _ NNP 40288 829 38 b b NNP 40288 829 39 - - HYPH 40288 829 40 b b NNP 40288 829 41 _ _ NNP 40288 829 42 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 43 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 44 2 2 CD 40288 829 45 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 46 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 47 2 2 CD 40288 829 48 1 1 CD 40288 829 49 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 829 50 _ _ NNP 40288 829 51 b*- b*- NNP 40288 829 52 b b LS 40288 829 53 * * NFP 40288 829 54 _ _ NNP 40288 829 55 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 56 2 2 CD 40288 829 57 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 58 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 59 2 2 CD 40288 829 60 1 1 CD 40288 829 61 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 62 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 829 63 _ _ NNP 40288 829 64 c c NNP 40288 829 65 - - HYPH 40288 829 66 c c NNP 40288 829 67 _ _ NNP 40288 829 68 2 2 CD 40288 829 69 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 70 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 71 2 2 CD 40288 829 72 1 1 CD 40288 829 73 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 74 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 75 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 829 76 _ _ NNP 40288 829 77 e e NNP 40288 829 78 - - HYPH 40288 829 79 e e NNP 40288 829 80 _ _ NNP 40288 829 81 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 82 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 83 2 2 CD 40288 829 84 1 1 CD 40288 829 85 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 86 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 87 2 2 CD 40288 829 88 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 829 89 - - HYPH 40288 829 90 lydian lydian NNP 40288 829 91 _ _ NNP 40288 829 92 e*- e*- NNP 40288 829 93 e e LS 40288 829 94 * * NFP 40288 829 95 _ _ NNP 40288 829 96 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 97 2 2 CD 40288 829 98 1 1 CD 40288 829 99 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 100 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 101 2 2 CD 40288 829 102 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 103 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 829 104 - - HYPH 40288 829 105 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 829 106 _ _ NNP 40288 829 107 f f NNP 40288 829 108 - - HYPH 40288 829 109 f f NNP 40288 829 110 _ _ NNP 40288 829 111 2 2 CD 40288 829 112 1 1 CD 40288 829 113 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 114 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 115 2 2 CD 40288 829 116 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 117 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 118 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 829 119 - - HYPH 40288 829 120 dorian dorian NNP 40288 829 121 _ _ NNP 40288 829 122 a a DT 40288 829 123 - - : 40288 829 124 a a NN 40288 829 125 _ _ NNP 40288 829 126 1 1 CD 40288 829 127 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 128 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 129 2 2 CD 40288 829 130 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 131 1/4 1/4 CD 40288 829 132 2 2 CD 40288 829 133 On on IN 40288 829 134 the the DT 40288 829 135 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 829 136 scale scale NN 40288 829 137 , , , 40288 829 138 according accord VBG 40288 829 139 to to IN 40288 829 140 the the DT 40288 829 141 same same JJ 40288 829 142 writer writer NN 40288 829 143 , , , 40288 829 144 the the DT 40288 829 145 species specie NNS 40288 829 146 of of IN 40288 829 147 an an DT 40288 829 148 Octave Octave NNP 40288 829 149 is be VBZ 40288 829 150 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 829 151 by by IN 40288 829 152 the the DT 40288 829 153 places place NNS 40288 829 154 of of IN 40288 829 155 the the DT 40288 829 156 two two CD 40288 829 157 semitones semitone NNS 40288 829 158 . . . 40288 830 1 Thus thus RB 40288 830 2 in in IN 40288 830 3 the the DT 40288 830 4 first first JJ 40288 830 5 species specie NNS 40288 830 6 , , , 40288 830 7 _ _ NNP 40288 830 8 b b NNP 40288 830 9 - - HYPH 40288 830 10 b b NNP 40288 830 11 _ _ NNP 40288 830 12 , , , 40288 830 13 the the DT 40288 830 14 semitones semitone NNS 40288 830 15 are be VBP 40288 830 16 the the DT 40288 830 17 first first JJ 40288 830 18 and and CC 40288 830 19 fourth fourth JJ 40288 830 20 intervals interval NNS 40288 830 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 830 22 _ _ NNP 40288 830 23 b b NNP 40288 830 24 - - HYPH 40288 830 25 c c NNP 40288 830 26 _ _ NNP 40288 830 27 and and CC 40288 830 28 _ _ NNP 40288 830 29 e e NNP 40288 830 30 - - HYPH 40288 830 31 f f NNP 40288 830 32 _ _ NNP 40288 830 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 830 34 : : : 40288 830 35 in in IN 40288 830 36 the the DT 40288 830 37 second second JJ 40288 830 38 , , , 40288 830 39 _ _ NNP 40288 830 40 c c NNP 40288 830 41 - - HYPH 40288 830 42 c c NNP 40288 830 43 _ _ NNP 40288 830 44 , , , 40288 830 45 they -PRON- PRP 40288 830 46 are be VBP 40288 830 47 the the DT 40288 830 48 third third JJ 40288 830 49 and and CC 40288 830 50 the the DT 40288 830 51 seventh seventh JJ 40288 830 52 , , , 40288 830 53 and and CC 40288 830 54 so so RB 40288 830 55 on on RB 40288 830 56 . . . 40288 831 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 831 2 does do VBZ 40288 831 3 not not RB 40288 831 4 however however RB 40288 831 5 say say VB 40288 831 6 , , , 40288 831 7 as as IN 40288 831 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 831 9 does do VBZ 40288 831 10 in in IN 40288 831 11 the the DT 40288 831 12 case case NN 40288 831 13 of of IN 40288 831 14 the the DT 40288 831 15 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 831 16 scale scale NN 40288 831 17 , , , 40288 831 18 that that IN 40288 831 19 these these DT 40288 831 20 species specie NNS 40288 831 21 were be VBD 40288 831 22 known know VBN 40288 831 23 by by IN 40288 831 24 the the DT 40288 831 25 names name NNS 40288 831 26 of of IN 40288 831 27 the the DT 40288 831 28 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 831 29 . . . 40288 832 1 This this DT 40288 832 2 statement statement NN 40288 832 3 is be VBZ 40288 832 4 first first RB 40288 832 5 made make VBN 40288 832 6 by by IN 40288 832 7 Gaudentius Gaudentius NNP 40288 832 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 832 9 p. p. NN 40288 832 10 20 20 CD 40288 832 11 Meib Meib NNP 40288 832 12 . . . 40288 833 1 ) ) -RRB- 40288 833 2 , , , 40288 833 3 a a DT 40288 833 4 writer writer NN 40288 833 5 of of IN 40288 833 6 unknown unknown JJ 40288 833 7 date date NN 40288 833 8 . . . 40288 834 1 If if IN 40288 834 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 834 3 adopt adopt VBP 40288 834 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 834 5 provisionally provisionally RB 40288 834 6 , , , 40288 834 7 the the DT 40288 834 8 species specie NNS 40288 834 9 of of IN 40288 834 10 the the DT 40288 834 11 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 834 12 octave octave NN 40288 834 13 will will MD 40288 834 14 be be VB 40288 834 15 as as IN 40288 834 16 follows follow VBZ 40288 834 17 : : : 40288 834 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 834 19 Mixo mixo NN 40288 834 20 - - HYPH 40288 834 21 lydian lydian NNP 40288 834 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 834 23 _ _ NNP 40288 834 24 b b NNP 40288 834 25 - - HYPH 40288 834 26 b b NNP 40288 834 27 _ _ NNP 40288 834 28 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 29 1 1 CD 40288 834 30 1 1 CD 40288 834 31 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 32 1 1 CD 40288 834 33 1 1 CD 40288 834 34 1 1 CD 40288 834 35 [ [ -LRB- 40288 834 36 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 834 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 834 38 _ _ NNP 40288 834 39 c c NNP 40288 834 40 - - HYPH 40288 834 41 c c NNP 40288 834 42 _ _ NNP 40288 834 43 1 1 CD 40288 834 44 1 1 CD 40288 834 45 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 46 1 1 CD 40288 834 47 1 1 CD 40288 834 48 1 1 CD 40288 834 49 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 50 [ [ -LRB- 40288 834 51 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 834 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 834 53 _ _ NNP 40288 834 54 d d NNP 40288 834 55 - - HYPH 40288 834 56 d d NNP 40288 834 57 _ _ NNP 40288 834 58 1 1 CD 40288 834 59 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 60 1 1 CD 40288 834 61 1 1 CD 40288 834 62 1 1 CD 40288 834 63 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 64 1 1 CD 40288 834 65 [ [ -LRB- 40288 834 66 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 834 67 ] ] -RRB- 40288 834 68 _ _ NNP 40288 834 69 e e NNP 40288 834 70 - - HYPH 40288 834 71 e e NNP 40288 834 72 _ _ NNP 40288 834 73 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 74 1 1 CD 40288 834 75 1 1 CD 40288 834 76 1 1 CD 40288 834 77 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 78 1 1 CD 40288 834 79 1 1 CD 40288 834 80 [ [ -LRB- 40288 834 81 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 834 82 - - HYPH 40288 834 83 lydian lydian NNP 40288 834 84 ] ] -RRB- 40288 834 85 _ _ NNP 40288 834 86 f f NNP 40288 834 87 - - HYPH 40288 834 88 f f NNP 40288 834 89 _ _ NNP 40288 834 90 1 1 CD 40288 834 91 1 1 CD 40288 834 92 1 1 CD 40288 834 93 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 94 1 1 CD 40288 834 95 1 1 CD 40288 834 96 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 97 [ [ -LRB- 40288 834 98 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 834 99 - - HYPH 40288 834 100 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 834 101 ] ] -RRB- 40288 834 102 _ _ NNP 40288 834 103 g g NNP 40288 834 104 - - HYPH 40288 834 105 g g NNP 40288 834 106 _ _ NNP 40288 834 107 1 1 CD 40288 834 108 1 1 CD 40288 834 109 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 110 1 1 CD 40288 834 111 1 1 CD 40288 834 112 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 113 1 1 CD 40288 834 114 [ [ -LRB- 40288 834 115 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 834 116 - - HYPH 40288 834 117 dorian dorian NNP 40288 834 118 ] ] -RRB- 40288 834 119 _ _ NNP 40288 834 120 a a DT 40288 834 121 - - : 40288 834 122 a a NN 40288 834 123 _ _ NNP 40288 834 124 1 1 CD 40288 834 125 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 126 1 1 CD 40288 834 127 1 1 CD 40288 834 128 1/2 1/2 CD 40288 834 129 1 1 CD 40288 834 130 1 1 CD 40288 834 131 § § CD 40288 834 132 24 24 CD 40288 834 133 . . . 40288 835 1 _ _ NNP 40288 835 2 Relation Relation NNP 40288 835 3 of of IN 40288 835 4 the the DT 40288 835 5 Species Species NNPS 40288 835 6 to to IN 40288 835 7 the the DT 40288 835 8 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 835 9 . . . 40288 835 10 _ _ NNP 40288 835 11 Looking look VBG 40288 835 12 at at IN 40288 835 13 the the DT 40288 835 14 octaves octave NNS 40288 835 15 which which WDT 40288 835 16 on on IN 40288 835 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 835 18 key key JJ 40288 835 19 - - HYPH 40288 835 20 board board NN 40288 835 21 , , , 40288 835 22 as as IN 40288 835 23 on on IN 40288 835 24 the the DT 40288 835 25 Greek greek JJ 40288 835 26 scale scale NN 40288 835 27 , , , 40288 835 28 exhibit exhibit VB 40288 835 29 the the DT 40288 835 30 several several JJ 40288 835 31 species specie NNS 40288 835 32 , , , 40288 835 33 we -PRON- PRP 40288 835 34 can can MD 40288 835 35 not not RB 40288 835 36 but but CC 40288 835 37 be be VB 40288 835 38 struck strike VBN 40288 835 39 with with IN 40288 835 40 the the DT 40288 835 41 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 835 42 relation relation NN 40288 835 43 in in IN 40288 835 44 which which WDT 40288 835 45 they -PRON- PRP 40288 835 46 stand stand VBP 40288 835 47 to to IN 40288 835 48 the the DT 40288 835 49 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 835 50 . . . 40288 836 1 In in IN 40288 836 2 the the DT 40288 836 3 tables table NNS 40288 836 4 given give VBN 40288 836 5 above above IN 40288 836 6 the the DT 40288 836 7 keys key NNS 40288 836 8 stand stand VBP 40288 836 9 in in IN 40288 836 10 the the DT 40288 836 11 order order NN 40288 836 12 of of IN 40288 836 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 836 14 pitch pitch NN 40288 836 15 , , , 40288 836 16 from from IN 40288 836 17 the the DT 40288 836 18 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 836 19 - - HYPH 40288 836 20 lydian lydian NNP 40288 836 21 down down RP 40288 836 22 to to IN 40288 836 23 the the DT 40288 836 24 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 836 25 - - HYPH 40288 836 26 dorian dorian NNP 40288 836 27 : : : 40288 836 28 the the DT 40288 836 29 species specie NNS 40288 836 30 of of IN 40288 836 31 the the DT 40288 836 32 same same JJ 40288 836 33 names name NNS 40288 836 34 follow follow VBP 40288 836 35 the the DT 40288 836 36 reverse reverse JJ 40288 836 37 order order NN 40288 836 38 , , , 40288 836 39 from from IN 40288 836 40 _ _ NNP 40288 836 41 b b NNP 40288 836 42 - - HYPH 40288 836 43 b b NNP 40288 836 44 _ _ NNP 40288 836 45 upwards upwards RB 40288 836 46 to to IN 40288 836 47 _ _ NNP 40288 836 48 a a DT 40288 836 49 - - : 40288 836 50 a a FW 40288 836 51 _ _ NN 40288 836 52 . . . 40288 837 1 This this DT 40288 837 2 , , , 40288 837 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 837 4 is be VBZ 40288 837 5 obvious obvious JJ 40288 837 6 , , , 40288 837 7 can can MD 40288 837 8 not not RB 40288 837 9 be be VB 40288 837 10 an an DT 40288 837 11 accidental accidental JJ 40288 837 12 coincidence coincidence NN 40288 837 13 . . . 40288 838 1 The the DT 40288 838 2 two two CD 40288 838 3 uses use NNS 40288 838 4 of of IN 40288 838 5 this this DT 40288 838 6 famous famous JJ 40288 838 7 series series NN 40288 838 8 of of IN 40288 838 9 names name NNS 40288 838 10 can can MD 40288 838 11 not not RB 40288 838 12 have have VB 40288 838 13 originated originate VBN 40288 838 14 independently independently RB 40288 838 15 . . . 40288 839 1 Either either CC 40288 839 2 the the DT 40288 839 3 naming naming NN 40288 839 4 of of IN 40288 839 5 the the DT 40288 839 6 species specie NNS 40288 839 7 was be VBD 40288 839 8 founded found VBN 40288 839 9 on on IN 40288 839 10 that that DT 40288 839 11 of of IN 40288 839 12 the the DT 40288 839 13 keys key NNS 40288 839 14 , , , 40288 839 15 or or CC 40288 839 16 the the DT 40288 839 17 converse converse NN 40288 839 18 relation relation NN 40288 839 19 obtained obtain VBN 40288 839 20 between between IN 40288 839 21 them -PRON- PRP 40288 839 22 . . . 40288 840 1 Which which WDT 40288 840 2 of of IN 40288 840 3 these these DT 40288 840 4 two two CD 40288 840 5 uses use NNS 40288 840 6 , , , 40288 840 7 then then RB 40288 840 8 , , , 40288 840 9 was be VBD 40288 840 10 the the DT 40288 840 11 original original JJ 40288 840 12 and and CC 40288 840 13 which which WDT 40288 840 14 the the DT 40288 840 15 derived derive VBN 40288 840 16 one one NN 40288 840 17 ? ? . 40288 841 1 Those those DT 40288 841 2 who who WP 40288 841 3 hold hold VBP 40288 841 4 that that IN 40288 841 5 the the DT 40288 841 6 species specie NNS 40288 841 7 were be VBD 40288 841 8 the the DT 40288 841 9 basis basis NN 40288 841 10 of of IN 40288 841 11 the the DT 40288 841 12 ancient ancient JJ 40288 841 13 Modes mode NNS 40288 841 14 or or CC 40288 841 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 841 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 841 17 : : : 40288 841 18 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 841 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 841 20 must must MD 40288 841 21 regard regard VB 40288 841 22 the the DT 40288 841 23 keys key NNS 40288 841 24 as as IN 40288 841 25 derivative derivative JJ 40288 841 26 . . . 40288 842 1 Now now RB 40288 842 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 842 3 tells tell VBZ 40288 842 4 us -PRON- PRP 40288 842 5 , , , 40288 842 6 in in IN 40288 842 7 one one CD 40288 842 8 of of IN 40288 842 9 the the DT 40288 842 10 passages passage NNS 40288 842 11 just just RB 40288 842 12 quoted quote VBN 40288 842 13 , , , 40288 842 14 that that IN 40288 842 15 the the DT 40288 842 16 seven seven CD 40288 842 17 species specie NNS 40288 842 18 had have VBD 40288 842 19 long long RB 40288 842 20 been be VBN 40288 842 21 recognised recognise VBN 40288 842 22 by by IN 40288 842 23 theorists theorist NNS 40288 842 24 . . . 40288 843 1 If if IN 40288 843 2 the the DT 40288 843 3 scheme scheme NN 40288 843 4 of of IN 40288 843 5 keys key NNS 40288 843 6 was be VBD 40288 843 7 founded found VBN 40288 843 8 upon upon IN 40288 843 9 the the DT 40288 843 10 seven seven CD 40288 843 11 species specie NNS 40288 843 12 , , , 40288 843 13 it -PRON- PRP 40288 843 14 would would MD 40288 843 15 at at IN 40288 843 16 once once RB 40288 843 17 have have VBP 40288 843 18 been be VBN 40288 843 19 complete complete JJ 40288 843 20 , , , 40288 843 21 both both CC 40288 843 22 in in IN 40288 843 23 the the DT 40288 843 24 number number NN 40288 843 25 of of IN 40288 843 26 the the DT 40288 843 27 keys key NNS 40288 843 28 and and CC 40288 843 29 in in IN 40288 843 30 the the DT 40288 843 31 determination determination NN 40288 843 32 of of IN 40288 843 33 the the DT 40288 843 34 intervals interval NNS 40288 843 35 between between IN 40288 843 36 them -PRON- PRP 40288 843 37 . . . 40288 844 1 But but CC 40288 844 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 844 3 also also RB 40288 844 4 tells tell VBZ 40288 844 5 us -PRON- PRP 40288 844 6 that that IN 40288 844 7 down down RP 40288 844 8 to to IN 40288 844 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 844 10 time time NN 40288 844 11 there there EX 40288 844 12 were be VBD 40288 844 13 only only RB 40288 844 14 six six CD 40288 844 15 keys,--one keys,--one NNS 40288 844 16 of of IN 40288 844 17 them -PRON- PRP 40288 844 18 not not RB 40288 844 19 yet yet RB 40288 844 20 generally generally RB 40288 844 21 recognised,--and recognised,--and JJ 40288 844 22 that that IN 40288 844 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 844 24 relative relative JJ 40288 844 25 pitch pitch NN 40288 844 26 was be VBD 40288 844 27 not not RB 40288 844 28 settled settle VBN 40288 844 29 . . . 40288 845 1 Evidently evidently RB 40288 845 2 then then RB 40288 845 3 the the DT 40288 845 4 keys key NNS 40288 845 5 , , , 40288 845 6 which which WDT 40288 845 7 were be VBD 40288 845 8 scales scale NNS 40288 845 9 in in IN 40288 845 10 practical practical JJ 40288 845 11 use use NN 40288 845 12 , , , 40288 845 13 were be VBD 40288 845 14 still still RB 40288 845 15 incomplete incomplete JJ 40288 845 16 when when WRB 40288 845 17 the the DT 40288 845 18 species specie NNS 40288 845 19 of of IN 40288 845 20 the the DT 40288 845 21 Octave Octave NNP 40288 845 22 had have VBD 40288 845 23 been be VBN 40288 845 24 worked work VBN 40288 845 25 out out RP 40288 845 26 in in IN 40288 845 27 the the DT 40288 845 28 theory theory NN 40288 845 29 of of IN 40288 845 30 music music NN 40288 845 31 . . . 40288 846 1 If if IN 40288 846 2 on on IN 40288 846 3 the the DT 40288 846 4 other other JJ 40288 846 5 hand hand NN 40288 846 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 846 7 regard regard VBP 40288 846 8 the the DT 40288 846 9 names name NNS 40288 846 10 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 846 11 , , , 40288 846 12 & & CC 40288 846 13 c. c. NNP 40288 846 14 as as RB 40288 846 15 originally originally RB 40288 846 16 applied apply VBN 40288 846 17 to to IN 40288 846 18 keys key NNS 40288 846 19 , , , 40288 846 20 we -PRON- PRP 40288 846 21 have have VBP 40288 846 22 only only RB 40288 846 23 to to TO 40288 846 24 suppose suppose VB 40288 846 25 that that IN 40288 846 26 these these DT 40288 846 27 names name NNS 40288 846 28 were be VBD 40288 846 29 extended extend VBN 40288 846 30 to to IN 40288 846 31 the the DT 40288 846 32 species specie NNS 40288 846 33 after after IN 40288 846 34 the the DT 40288 846 35 number number NN 40288 846 36 of of IN 40288 846 37 seven seven CD 40288 846 38 keys key NNS 40288 846 39 had have VBD 40288 846 40 been be VBN 40288 846 41 completed complete VBN 40288 846 42 . . . 40288 847 1 This this DT 40288 847 2 supposition supposition NN 40288 847 3 is be VBZ 40288 847 4 borne bear VBN 40288 847 5 out out RP 40288 847 6 by by IN 40288 847 7 the the DT 40288 847 8 fact fact NN 40288 847 9 that that IN 40288 847 10 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 847 11 , , , 40288 847 12 who who WP 40288 847 13 mentions mention VBZ 40288 847 14 the the DT 40288 847 15 seven seven CD 40288 847 16 species specie NNS 40288 847 17 as as RB 40288 847 18 well well RB 40288 847 19 known know VBN 40288 847 20 , , , 40288 847 21 does do VBZ 40288 847 22 not not RB 40288 847 23 give give VB 40288 847 24 them -PRON- PRP 40288 847 25 names name NNS 40288 847 26 , , , 40288 847 27 or or CC 40288 847 28 connect connect VB 40288 847 29 them -PRON- PRP 40288 847 30 with with IN 40288 847 31 the the DT 40288 847 32 keys key NNS 40288 847 33 . . . 40288 848 1 This this DT 40288 848 2 step step NN 40288 848 3 was be VBD 40288 848 4 apparently apparently RB 40288 848 5 taken take VBN 40288 848 6 by by IN 40288 848 7 some some DT 40288 848 8 follower follower NN 40288 848 9 of of IN 40288 848 10 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 848 11 , , , 40288 848 12 who who WP 40288 848 13 wished wish VBD 40288 848 14 to to TO 40288 848 15 connect connect VB 40288 848 16 the the DT 40288 848 17 species specie NNS 40288 848 18 of of IN 40288 848 19 the the DT 40288 848 20 older old JJR 40288 848 21 theorists theorist NNS 40288 848 22 with with IN 40288 848 23 the the DT 40288 848 24 system system NN 40288 848 25 of of IN 40288 848 26 keys key NNS 40288 848 27 which which WDT 40288 848 28 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 848 29 had have VBD 40288 848 30 perfected perfect VBN 40288 848 31 . . . 40288 849 1 The the DT 40288 849 2 view view NN 40288 849 3 now now RB 40288 849 4 taken take VBN 40288 849 5 of of IN 40288 849 6 the the DT 40288 849 7 seven seven CD 40288 849 8 species specie NNS 40288 849 9 is be VBZ 40288 849 10 supported support VBN 40288 849 11 by by IN 40288 849 12 the the DT 40288 849 13 whole whole JJ 40288 849 14 treatment treatment NN 40288 849 15 of of IN 40288 849 16 musical musical JJ 40288 849 17 scales scale NNS 40288 849 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 849 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 849 20 Greek greek JJ 40288 849 21 : : : 40288 849 22 systêmata systêmata NN 40288 849 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 849 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 849 25 as as IN 40288 849 26 we -PRON- PRP 40288 849 27 find find VBP 40288 849 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 849 29 in in IN 40288 849 30 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 849 31 . . . 40288 850 1 That that DT 40288 850 2 treatment treatment NN 40288 850 3 from from IN 40288 850 4 first first RB 40288 850 5 to to IN 40288 850 6 last last JJ 40288 850 7 is be VBZ 40288 850 8 purely purely RB 40288 850 9 abstract abstract JJ 40288 850 10 and and CC 40288 850 11 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 850 12 . . . 40288 851 1 The the DT 40288 851 2 rules rule NNS 40288 851 3 which which WDT 40288 851 4 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 851 5 lays lay VBZ 40288 851 6 down down RB 40288 851 7 serve serve VBP 40288 851 8 to to TO 40288 851 9 determine determine VB 40288 851 10 the the DT 40288 851 11 sequence sequence NN 40288 851 12 of of IN 40288 851 13 intervals interval NNS 40288 851 14 , , , 40288 851 15 but but CC 40288 851 16 are be VBP 40288 851 17 not not RB 40288 851 18 confined confine VBN 40288 851 19 to to IN 40288 851 20 scales scale NNS 40288 851 21 of of IN 40288 851 22 any any DT 40288 851 23 particular particular JJ 40288 851 24 compass compass NN 40288 851 25 . . . 40288 852 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40288 852 2 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 852 3 , , , 40288 852 4 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 852 5 , , , 40288 852 6 are be VBP 40288 852 7 not not RB 40288 852 8 scales scale NNS 40288 852 9 in in IN 40288 852 10 practical practical JJ 40288 852 11 use use NN 40288 852 12 : : : 40288 852 13 they -PRON- PRP 40288 852 14 are be VBP 40288 852 15 parts part NNS 40288 852 16 taken take VBN 40288 852 17 anywhere anywhere RB 40288 852 18 on on IN 40288 852 19 an an DT 40288 852 20 ideal ideal JJ 40288 852 21 unlimited unlimited JJ 40288 852 22 scale scale NN 40288 852 23 . . . 40288 853 1 And and CC 40288 853 2 the the DT 40288 853 3 seven seven CD 40288 853 4 species specie NNS 40288 853 5 of of IN 40288 853 6 the the DT 40288 853 7 Octave Octave NNP 40288 853 8 are be VBP 40288 853 9 regarded regard VBN 40288 853 10 by by IN 40288 853 11 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 853 12 as as IN 40288 853 13 a a DT 40288 853 14 scheme scheme NN 40288 853 15 of of IN 40288 853 16 the the DT 40288 853 17 same same JJ 40288 853 18 abstract abstract JJ 40288 853 19 order order NN 40288 853 20 . . . 40288 854 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 854 2 represent represent VBP 40288 854 3 the the DT 40288 854 4 earlier early JJR 40288 854 5 teaching teaching NN 40288 854 6 on on IN 40288 854 7 which which WDT 40288 854 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 854 9 had have VBD 40288 854 10 improved improve VBN 40288 854 11 . . . 40288 855 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 855 2 condemned condemn VBD 40288 855 3 that that DT 40288 855 4 teaching teaching NN 40288 855 5 for for IN 40288 855 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 855 7 want want NN 40288 855 8 of of IN 40288 855 9 generality generality NN 40288 855 10 , , , 40288 855 11 because because IN 40288 855 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 855 13 was be VBD 40288 855 14 confined confine VBN 40288 855 15 to to IN 40288 855 16 the the DT 40288 855 17 compass compass NN 40288 855 18 of of IN 40288 855 19 the the DT 40288 855 20 Octave Octave NNP 40288 855 21 and and CC 40288 855 22 to to IN 40288 855 23 the the DT 40288 855 24 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 855 25 genus genus NN 40288 855 26 , , , 40288 855 27 and and CC 40288 855 28 also also RB 40288 855 29 because because IN 40288 855 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 855 31 rested rest VBD 40288 855 32 on on IN 40288 855 33 no no DT 40288 855 34 principles principle NNS 40288 855 35 that that WDT 40288 855 36 would would MD 40288 855 37 necessarily necessarily RB 40288 855 38 limit limit VB 40288 855 39 the the DT 40288 855 40 species specie NNS 40288 855 41 of of IN 40288 855 42 the the DT 40288 855 43 Octave Octave NNP 40288 855 44 to to IN 40288 855 45 seven seven CD 40288 855 46 . . . 40288 856 1 On on IN 40288 856 2 the the DT 40288 856 3 other other JJ 40288 856 4 hand hand NN 40288 856 5 the the DT 40288 856 6 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 856 7 of of IN 40288 856 8 the the DT 40288 856 9 earlier early JJR 40288 856 10 musicians musician NNS 40288 856 11 were be VBD 40288 856 12 unscientific unscientific JJ 40288 856 13 , , , 40288 856 14 in in IN 40288 856 15 the the DT 40288 856 16 opinion opinion NN 40288 856 17 of of IN 40288 856 18 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 856 19 , , , 40288 856 20 on on IN 40288 856 21 the the DT 40288 856 22 ground ground NN 40288 856 23 that that IN 40288 856 24 they -PRON- PRP 40288 856 25 divided divide VBD 40288 856 26 the the DT 40288 856 27 scale scale NN 40288 856 28 into into IN 40288 856 29 a a DT 40288 856 30 succession succession NN 40288 856 31 of of IN 40288 856 32 quarter quarter NN 40288 856 33 - - HYPH 40288 856 34 tones tone NNS 40288 856 35 . . . 40288 857 1 Such such PDT 40288 857 2 a a DT 40288 857 3 division division NN 40288 857 4 , , , 40288 857 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 857 6 urged urge VBD 40288 857 7 , , , 40288 857 8 is be VBZ 40288 857 9 impossible impossible JJ 40288 857 10 in in IN 40288 857 11 practice practice NN 40288 857 12 and and CC 40288 857 13 musically musically RB 40288 857 14 wrong wrong JJ 40288 857 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 857 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 857 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 857 18 : : : 40288 857 19 ekmeles ekmele NNS 40288 857 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 857 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 857 22 . . . 40288 858 1 All all PDT 40288 858 2 this this DT 40288 858 3 goes go VBZ 40288 858 4 to to TO 40288 858 5 show show VB 40288 858 6 that that IN 40288 858 7 the the DT 40288 858 8 earlier early JJR 40288 858 9 treatment treatment NN 40288 858 10 of of IN 40288 858 11 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 858 12 , , , 40288 858 13 including include VBG 40288 858 14 the the DT 40288 858 15 seven seven CD 40288 858 16 Species Species NNPS 40288 858 17 , , , 40288 858 18 had have VBD 40288 858 19 the the DT 40288 858 20 same same JJ 40288 858 21 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 858 22 character character NN 40288 858 23 as as IN 40288 858 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 858 25 own own JJ 40288 858 26 exposition exposition NN 40288 858 27 . . . 40288 859 1 The the DT 40288 859 2 only only JJ 40288 859 3 System system NN 40288 859 4 which which WDT 40288 859 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 859 6 recognises recognise VBZ 40288 859 7 for for IN 40288 859 8 practical practical JJ 40288 859 9 purposes purpose NNS 40288 859 10 is be VBZ 40288 859 11 the the DT 40288 859 12 old old JJ 40288 859 13 standard standard JJ 40288 859 14 octave octave NN 40288 859 15 , , , 40288 859 16 from from IN 40288 859 17 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 859 18 to to IN 40288 859 19 Nêtê nêtê NN 40288 859 20 : : : 40288 859 21 and and CC 40288 859 22 that that DT 40288 859 23 System System NNP 40288 859 24 , , , 40288 859 25 with with IN 40288 859 26 the the DT 40288 859 27 enlargements enlargement NNS 40288 859 28 which which WDT 40288 859 29 turned turn VBD 40288 859 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 859 31 into into IN 40288 859 32 the the DT 40288 859 33 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 859 34 System System NNP 40288 859 35 , , , 40288 859 36 kept keep VBD 40288 859 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 859 38 ground ground NN 40288 859 39 with with IN 40288 859 40 all all DT 40288 859 41 writers writer NNS 40288 859 42 of of IN 40288 859 43 the the DT 40288 859 44 Aristoxenean aristoxenean JJ 40288 859 45 school school NN 40288 859 46 . . . 40288 860 1 Even even RB 40288 860 2 in in IN 40288 860 3 the the DT 40288 860 4 accounts account NNS 40288 860 5 of of IN 40288 860 6 the the DT 40288 860 7 pseudo pseudo NNP 40288 860 8 - - NNP 40288 860 9 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 860 10 and and CC 40288 860 11 the the DT 40288 860 12 later later JJ 40288 860 13 writers writer NNS 40288 860 14 , , , 40288 860 15 who who WP 40288 860 16 treat treat VBP 40288 860 17 of of IN 40288 860 18 the the DT 40288 860 19 Species Species NNPS 40288 860 20 of of IN 40288 860 21 the the DT 40288 860 22 Octave Octave NNP 40288 860 23 under under IN 40288 860 24 the the DT 40288 860 25 names name NNS 40288 860 26 of of IN 40288 860 27 the the DT 40288 860 28 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 860 29 , , , 40288 860 30 there there EX 40288 860 31 is be VBZ 40288 860 32 much much JJ 40288 860 33 to to TO 40288 860 34 show show VB 40288 860 35 that that IN 40288 860 36 the the DT 40288 860 37 species specie NNS 40288 860 38 existed exist VBD 40288 860 39 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 860 40 or or CC 40288 860 41 wholly wholly RB 40288 860 42 in in IN 40288 860 43 musical musical JJ 40288 860 44 theory theory NN 40288 860 45 . . . 40288 861 1 The the DT 40288 861 2 seven seven CD 40288 861 3 species specie NNS 40288 861 4 of of IN 40288 861 5 the the DT 40288 861 6 Octave Octave NNP 40288 861 7 are be VBP 40288 861 8 given give VBN 40288 861 9 along along RP 40288 861 10 with with IN 40288 861 11 the the DT 40288 861 12 three three CD 40288 861 13 species specie NNS 40288 861 14 of of IN 40288 861 15 the the DT 40288 861 16 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 861 17 and and CC 40288 861 18 the the DT 40288 861 19 four four CD 40288 861 20 species specie NNS 40288 861 21 of of IN 40288 861 22 the the DT 40288 861 23 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 861 24 , , , 40288 861 25 neither neither DT 40288 861 26 of of IN 40288 861 27 which which WDT 40288 861 28 appear appear VBP 40288 861 29 to to TO 40288 861 30 have have VB 40288 861 31 had have VBN 40288 861 32 any any DT 40288 861 33 practical practical JJ 40288 861 34 application application NN 40288 861 35 . . . 40288 862 1 Another another DT 40288 862 2 indication indication NN 40288 862 3 of of IN 40288 862 4 this this DT 40288 862 5 may may MD 40288 862 6 be be VB 40288 862 7 seen see VBN 40288 862 8 in in IN 40288 862 9 the the DT 40288 862 10 seventh seventh JJ 40288 862 11 or or CC 40288 862 12 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 862 13 - - HYPH 40288 862 14 dorian dorian JJ 40288 862 15 species specie NNS 40288 862 16 , , , 40288 862 17 which which WDT 40288 862 18 was be VBD 40288 862 19 also also RB 40288 862 20 called call VBN 40288 862 21 Locrian locrian JJ 40288 862 22 and and CC 40288 862 23 Common common JJ 40288 862 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 862 25 ps ps UH 40288 862 26 . . . 40288 863 1 Eucl eucl VB 40288 863 2 . . . 40288 864 1 p. p. NN 40288 864 2 16 16 CD 40288 864 3 Meib Meib NNP 40288 864 4 . . . 40288 864 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 864 6 . . . 40288 865 1 Why why WRB 40288 865 2 should should MD 40288 865 3 this this DT 40288 865 4 species specie NNS 40288 865 5 have have VB 40288 865 6 more more JJR 40288 865 7 than than IN 40288 865 8 one one CD 40288 865 9 name name NN 40288 865 10 ? ? . 40288 866 1 In in IN 40288 866 2 the the DT 40288 866 3 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 866 4 System System NNP 40288 866 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 866 6 is be VBZ 40288 866 7 singular singular JJ 40288 866 8 in in IN 40288 866 9 being be VBG 40288 866 10 exemplified exemplify VBN 40288 866 11 by by IN 40288 866 12 two two CD 40288 866 13 different different JJ 40288 866 14 octaves octave NNS 40288 866 15 , , , 40288 866 16 viz viz NN 40288 866 17 . . . 40288 867 1 that that IN 40288 867 2 from from IN 40288 867 3 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 867 4 to to IN 40288 867 5 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 867 6 , , , 40288 867 7 and and CC 40288 867 8 that that IN 40288 867 9 from from IN 40288 867 10 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 867 11 to to IN 40288 867 12 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 867 13 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 867 14 . . . 40288 868 1 Now now RB 40288 868 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 868 3 have have VBP 40288 868 4 seen see VBN 40288 868 5 that that IN 40288 868 6 the the DT 40288 868 7 higher high JJR 40288 868 8 the the DT 40288 868 9 octave octave NN 40288 868 10 which which WDT 40288 868 11 represents represent VBZ 40288 868 12 a a DT 40288 868 13 species species NN 40288 868 14 , , , 40288 868 15 the the DT 40288 868 16 lower low JJR 40288 868 17 the the DT 40288 868 18 key key NN 40288 868 19 of of IN 40288 868 20 the the DT 40288 868 21 same same JJ 40288 868 22 name name NN 40288 868 23 . . . 40288 869 1 In in IN 40288 869 2 this this DT 40288 869 3 case case NN 40288 869 4 , , , 40288 869 5 then then RB 40288 869 6 , , , 40288 869 7 the the DT 40288 869 8 upper upper JJ 40288 869 9 of of IN 40288 869 10 the the DT 40288 869 11 two two CD 40288 869 12 octaves octave NNS 40288 869 13 answers answer NNS 40288 869 14 to to IN 40288 869 15 the the DT 40288 869 16 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 869 17 - - HYPH 40288 869 18 dorian dorian JJ 40288 869 19 key key NN 40288 869 20 , , , 40288 869 21 and and CC 40288 869 22 the the DT 40288 869 23 lower low JJR 40288 869 24 to to IN 40288 869 25 the the DT 40288 869 26 Locrian Locrian NNP 40288 869 27 . . . 40288 870 1 But but CC 40288 870 2 if if IN 40288 870 3 the the DT 40288 870 4 species specie NNS 40288 870 5 has have VBZ 40288 870 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 870 7 two two CD 40288 870 8 names name NNS 40288 870 9 from from IN 40288 870 10 these these DT 40288 870 11 two two CD 40288 870 12 keys key NNS 40288 870 13 , , , 40288 870 14 it -PRON- PRP 40288 870 15 follows follow VBZ 40288 870 16 that that IN 40288 870 17 the the DT 40288 870 18 names name NNS 40288 870 19 of of IN 40288 870 20 the the DT 40288 870 21 species specie NNS 40288 870 22 are be VBP 40288 870 23 derived derive VBN 40288 870 24 from from IN 40288 870 25 the the DT 40288 870 26 keys key NNS 40288 870 27 . . . 40288 871 1 The the DT 40288 871 2 fact fact NN 40288 871 3 that that IN 40288 871 4 the the DT 40288 871 5 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 871 6 - - HYPH 40288 871 7 dorian dorian JJ 40288 871 8 or or CC 40288 871 9 Locrian locrian JJ 40288 871 10 species specie NNS 40288 871 11 was be VBD 40288 871 12 also also RB 40288 871 13 called call VBN 40288 871 14 Common Common NNP 40288 871 15 is be VBZ 40288 871 16 a a DT 40288 871 17 further further JJ 40288 871 18 argument argument NN 40288 871 19 to to IN 40288 871 20 the the DT 40288 871 21 same same JJ 40288 871 22 purpose purpose NN 40288 871 23 . . . 40288 872 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 872 2 was be VBD 40288 872 3 doubtless doubtless JJ 40288 872 4 ' ' `` 40288 872 5 common common JJ 40288 872 6 ' ' '' 40288 872 7 in in IN 40288 872 8 the the DT 40288 872 9 sense sense NN 40288 872 10 that that IN 40288 872 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 872 12 characterised characterise VBD 40288 872 13 the the DT 40288 872 14 two two CD 40288 872 15 octaves octave NNS 40288 872 16 which which WDT 40288 872 17 made make VBD 40288 872 18 up up RP 40288 872 19 the the DT 40288 872 20 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 872 21 System System NNP 40288 872 22 . . . 40288 873 1 Thus thus RB 40288 873 2 the the DT 40288 873 3 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 873 4 System System NNP 40288 873 5 was be VBD 40288 873 6 recognised recognise VBN 40288 873 7 as as IN 40288 873 8 the the DT 40288 873 9 really really RB 40288 873 10 important important JJ 40288 873 11 scale scale NN 40288 873 12 . . . 40288 874 1 Another another DT 40288 874 2 consideration consideration NN 40288 874 3 , , , 40288 874 4 which which WDT 40288 874 5 has have VBZ 40288 874 6 been be VBN 40288 874 7 overlooked overlook VBN 40288 874 8 by by IN 40288 874 9 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 874 10 and and CC 40288 874 11 those those DT 40288 874 12 who who WP 40288 874 13 follow follow VBP 40288 874 14 him -PRON- PRP 40288 874 15 , , , 40288 874 16 is be VBZ 40288 874 17 the the DT 40288 874 18 difference difference NN 40288 874 19 between between IN 40288 874 20 the the DT 40288 874 21 species specie NNS 40288 874 22 of of IN 40288 874 23 the the DT 40288 874 24 Octave Octave NNP 40288 874 25 in in IN 40288 874 26 the the DT 40288 874 27 several several JJ 40288 874 28 genera genera NN 40288 874 29 , , , 40288 874 30 especially especially RB 40288 874 31 the the DT 40288 874 32 difference difference NN 40288 874 33 between between IN 40288 874 34 the the DT 40288 874 35 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 874 36 and and CC 40288 874 37 the the DT 40288 874 38 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 874 39 . . . 40288 875 1 This this DT 40288 875 2 is be VBZ 40288 875 3 not not RB 40288 875 4 felt feel VBN 40288 875 5 as as IN 40288 875 6 a a DT 40288 875 7 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 875 8 with with IN 40288 875 9 all all PDT 40288 875 10 the the DT 40288 875 11 species specie NNS 40288 875 12 . . . 40288 876 1 Thus thus RB 40288 876 2 the the DT 40288 876 3 so so RB 40288 876 4 - - HYPH 40288 876 5 called call VBN 40288 876 6 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 876 7 octave octave NN 40288 876 8 _ _ NNP 40288 876 9 e e NNP 40288 876 10 - - HYPH 40288 876 11 e e NNP 40288 876 12 _ _ NNP 40288 876 13 is be VBZ 40288 876 14 in in IN 40288 876 15 the the DT 40288 876 16 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 876 17 genus genus NN 40288 876 18 _ _ NNP 40288 876 19 e e NNP 40288 876 20 e e NNP 40288 876 21 * * NNP 40288 876 22 f f NNP 40288 876 23 a a DT 40288 876 24 b b NNP 40288 876 25 b b NN 40288 876 26 * * NN 40288 876 27 c c NN 40288 876 28 e e NNP 40288 876 29 _ _ NNP 40288 876 30 , , , 40288 876 31 a a DT 40288 876 32 scale scale NN 40288 876 33 which which WDT 40288 876 34 may may MD 40288 876 35 be be VB 40288 876 36 regarded regard VBN 40288 876 37 as as IN 40288 876 38 the the DT 40288 876 39 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 876 40 with with IN 40288 876 41 _ _ NNP 40288 876 42 g g NNP 40288 876 43 _ _ NNP 40288 876 44 and and CC 40288 876 45 _ _ NNP 40288 876 46 d d NNP 40288 876 47 _ _ NNP 40288 876 48 omitted omit VBD 40288 876 49 , , , 40288 876 50 and and CC 40288 876 51 the the DT 40288 876 52 semitones semitone NNS 40288 876 53 divided divide VBN 40288 876 54 . . . 40288 877 1 But but CC 40288 877 2 the the DT 40288 877 3 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 877 4 _ _ NNP 40288 877 5 d d NNP 40288 877 6 - - HYPH 40288 877 7 d d NNP 40288 877 8 _ _ NNP 40288 877 9 can can MD 40288 877 10 not not RB 40288 877 11 pass pass VB 40288 877 12 in in RP 40288 877 13 any any DT 40288 877 14 such such JJ 40288 877 15 way way NN 40288 877 16 into into IN 40288 877 17 the the DT 40288 877 18 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 877 19 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 877 20 _ _ NNP 40288 877 21 c c NNP 40288 877 22 e e NNP 40288 877 23 e e NNP 40288 877 24 * * NNP 40288 877 25 f f NNP 40288 877 26 a a DT 40288 877 27 b b NNP 40288 877 28 b b NN 40288 877 29 * * NN 40288 877 30 c c NNP 40288 877 31 _ _ NNP 40288 877 32 , , , 40288 877 33 which which WDT 40288 877 34 answers answer VBZ 40288 877 35 rather rather RB 40288 877 36 to to IN 40288 877 37 the the DT 40288 877 38 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 877 39 scale scale NN 40288 877 40 of of IN 40288 877 41 the the DT 40288 877 42 species specie NNS 40288 877 43 _ _ NNP 40288 877 44 c c NNP 40288 877 45 - - HYPH 40288 877 46 c c NNP 40288 877 47 _ _ NNP 40288 877 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 877 49 the the DT 40288 877 50 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 877 51 ) ) -RRB- 40288 877 52 . . . 40288 878 1 The the DT 40288 878 2 scholars scholar NNS 40288 878 3 who who WP 40288 878 4 connect connect VBP 40288 878 5 the the DT 40288 878 6 ancient ancient JJ 40288 878 7 Modes mode NNS 40288 878 8 with with IN 40288 878 9 the the DT 40288 878 10 species specie NNS 40288 878 11 generally generally RB 40288 878 12 confine confine VBP 40288 878 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 40288 878 14 to to IN 40288 878 15 octaves octave NNS 40288 878 16 of of IN 40288 878 17 the the DT 40288 878 18 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 878 19 genus genus NN 40288 878 20 . . . 40288 879 1 In in IN 40288 879 2 this this DT 40288 879 3 they -PRON- PRP 40288 879 4 are be VBP 40288 879 5 supported support VBN 40288 879 6 by by IN 40288 879 7 later later JJ 40288 879 8 Greek greek JJ 40288 879 9 writers writer NNS 40288 879 10 -- -- : 40288 879 11 notably notably RB 40288 879 12 , , , 40288 879 13 as as IN 40288 879 14 we -PRON- PRP 40288 879 15 shall shall MD 40288 879 16 see see VB 40288 879 17 , , , 40288 879 18 by by IN 40288 879 19 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 879 20 -- -- : 40288 879 21 and and CC 40288 879 22 by by IN 40288 879 23 the the DT 40288 879 24 analogy analogy NN 40288 879 25 of of IN 40288 879 26 the the DT 40288 879 27 mediaeval mediaeval JJ 40288 879 28 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 879 29 or or CC 40288 879 30 Tones Tones NNPS 40288 879 31 . . . 40288 880 1 But but CC 40288 880 2 on on IN 40288 880 3 the the DT 40288 880 4 other other JJ 40288 880 5 side side NN 40288 880 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 880 7 have have VBP 40288 880 8 the the DT 40288 880 9 repeated repeat VBN 40288 880 10 complaints complaint NNS 40288 880 11 of of IN 40288 880 12 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 880 13 that that IN 40288 880 14 the the DT 40288 880 15 earlier early JJR 40288 880 16 theorists theorist NNS 40288 880 17 confined confine VBD 40288 880 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 40288 880 19 to to IN 40288 880 20 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 880 21 octave octave NN 40288 880 22 scales scale NNS 40288 880 23 . . . 40288 881 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 881 2 have have VBP 40288 881 3 also also RB 40288 881 4 the the DT 40288 881 5 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 881 6 that that WDT 40288 881 7 the the DT 40288 881 8 writer writer NN 40288 881 9 or or CC 40288 881 10 compiler compiler NN 40288 881 11 of of IN 40288 881 12 the the DT 40288 881 13 pseudo pseudo JJ 40288 881 14 - - JJ 40288 881 15 Euclidean euclidean JJ 40288 881 16 treatise treatise NN 40288 881 17 , , , 40288 881 18 who who WP 40288 881 19 is be VBZ 40288 881 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 881 21 earliest early JJS 40288 881 22 authority authority NN 40288 881 23 for for IN 40288 881 24 the the DT 40288 881 25 names name NNS 40288 881 26 of of IN 40288 881 27 the the DT 40288 881 28 species specie NNS 40288 881 29 , , , 40288 881 30 gives give VBZ 40288 881 31 these these DT 40288 881 32 names name NNS 40288 881 33 for for IN 40288 881 34 the the DT 40288 881 35 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 881 36 genus genus NN 40288 881 37 only only RB 40288 881 38 . . . 40288 882 1 Here here RB 40288 882 2 , , , 40288 882 3 once once RB 40288 882 4 more more JJR 40288 882 5 , , , 40288 882 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 882 7 feel feel VBP 40288 882 8 the the DT 40288 882 9 difference difference NN 40288 882 10 between between IN 40288 882 11 theory theory NN 40288 882 12 and and CC 40288 882 13 practice practice NN 40288 882 14 . . . 40288 883 1 To to IN 40288 883 2 a a DT 40288 883 3 theorist theorist NN 40288 883 4 there there EX 40288 883 5 is be VBZ 40288 883 6 no no DT 40288 883 7 great great JJ 40288 883 8 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 883 9 in in IN 40288 883 10 the the DT 40288 883 11 terms term NNS 40288 883 12 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 883 13 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 883 14 and and CC 40288 883 15 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 883 16 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 883 17 meaning mean VBG 40288 883 18 essentially essentially RB 40288 883 19 different different JJ 40288 883 20 things thing NNS 40288 883 21 . . . 40288 884 1 But but CC 40288 884 2 the the DT 40288 884 3 ' ' `` 40288 884 4 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 884 5 Mode Mode NNP 40288 884 6 ' ' '' 40288 884 7 in in IN 40288 884 8 practical practical JJ 40288 884 9 music music NN 40288 884 10 must must MD 40288 884 11 have have VB 40288 884 12 been be VBN 40288 884 13 a a DT 40288 884 14 tolerably tolerably RB 40288 884 15 definite definite JJ 40288 884 16 musical musical JJ 40288 884 17 form form NN 40288 884 18 . . . 40288 885 1 § § ADD 40288 885 2 25 25 CD 40288 885 3 . . . 40288 886 1 _ _ NNP 40288 886 2 The the DT 40288 886 3 Ethos Ethos NNP 40288 886 4 of of IN 40288 886 5 Music music NN 40288 886 6 . . . 40288 886 7 _ _ NNP 40288 886 8 From from IN 40288 886 9 Plato Plato NNP 40288 886 10 and and CC 40288 886 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 886 12 we -PRON- PRP 40288 886 13 have have VBP 40288 886 14 learned learn VBN 40288 886 15 some some DT 40288 886 16 elements element NNS 40288 886 17 of of IN 40288 886 18 what what WP 40288 886 19 may may MD 40288 886 20 be be VB 40288 886 21 called call VBN 40288 886 22 the the DT 40288 886 23 gamut gamut NN 40288 886 24 of of IN 40288 886 25 sensibility sensibility NN 40288 886 26 . . . 40288 887 1 Between between IN 40288 887 2 the the DT 40288 887 3 higher high JJR 40288 887 4 keys key NNS 40288 887 5 which which WDT 40288 887 6 in in IN 40288 887 7 Greece Greece NNP 40288 887 8 , , , 40288 887 9 as as IN 40288 887 10 in in IN 40288 887 11 Oriental oriental JJ 40288 887 12 countries country NNS 40288 887 13 generally generally RB 40288 887 14 , , , 40288 887 15 were be VBD 40288 887 16 the the DT 40288 887 17 familiar familiar JJ 40288 887 18 vehicle vehicle NN 40288 887 19 of of IN 40288 887 20 passion passion NN 40288 887 21 , , , 40288 887 22 especially especially RB 40288 887 23 of of IN 40288 887 24 the the DT 40288 887 25 passion passion NN 40288 887 26 of of IN 40288 887 27 grief grief NN 40288 887 28 , , , 40288 887 29 and and CC 40288 887 30 the the DT 40288 887 31 lower low JJR 40288 887 32 keys key NNS 40288 887 33 which which WDT 40288 887 34 were be VBD 40288 887 35 regarded regard VBN 40288 887 36 , , , 40288 887 37 by by IN 40288 887 38 Plato Plato NNP 40288 887 39 at at IN 40288 887 40 least least RBS 40288 887 41 , , , 40288 887 42 as as IN 40288 887 43 the the DT 40288 887 44 natural natural JJ 40288 887 45 language language NN 40288 887 46 of of IN 40288 887 47 ease ease NN 40288 887 48 and and CC 40288 887 49 license license NN 40288 887 50 , , , 40288 887 51 there there EX 40288 887 52 were be VBD 40288 887 53 keys key NNS 40288 887 54 expressive expressive JJ 40288 887 55 of of IN 40288 887 56 calm calm JJ 40288 887 57 and and CC 40288 887 58 balanced balanced JJ 40288 887 59 states state NNS 40288 887 60 of of IN 40288 887 61 mind mind NN 40288 887 62 , , , 40288 887 63 free free JJ 40288 887 64 from from IN 40288 887 65 the the DT 40288 887 66 violent violent JJ 40288 887 67 extremes extreme NNS 40288 887 68 of of IN 40288 887 69 pain pain NN 40288 887 70 and and CC 40288 887 71 pleasure pleasure NN 40288 887 72 . . . 40288 888 1 In in IN 40288 888 2 some some DT 40288 888 3 later later JJ 40288 888 4 writers writer NNS 40288 888 5 on on IN 40288 888 6 music music NN 40288 888 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 888 8 find find VBP 40288 888 9 this this DT 40288 888 10 classification classification NN 40288 888 11 reduced reduce VBN 40288 888 12 to to IN 40288 888 13 a a DT 40288 888 14 more more RBR 40288 888 15 regular regular JJ 40288 888 16 form form NN 40288 888 17 , , , 40288 888 18 and and CC 40288 888 19 clothed clothe VBN 40288 888 20 in in IN 40288 888 21 technical technical JJ 40288 888 22 language language NN 40288 888 23 . . . 40288 889 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 889 2 find find VBP 40288 889 3 also also RB 40288 889 4 , , , 40288 889 5 what what WP 40288 889 6 is be VBZ 40288 889 7 still still RB 40288 889 8 more more JJR 40288 889 9 to to IN 40288 889 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 889 11 purpose purpose NN 40288 889 12 , , , 40288 889 13 an an DT 40288 889 14 attempt attempt NN 40288 889 15 to to TO 40288 889 16 define define VB 40288 889 17 more more RBR 40288 889 18 precisely precisely RB 40288 889 19 the the DT 40288 889 20 musical musical JJ 40288 889 21 forms form NNS 40288 889 22 which which WDT 40288 889 23 answered answer VBD 40288 889 24 to to IN 40288 889 25 the the DT 40288 889 26 several several JJ 40288 889 27 states state NNS 40288 889 28 of of IN 40288 889 29 temper temper NN 40288 889 30 or or CC 40288 889 31 emotion emotion NN 40288 889 32 . . . 40288 890 1 Among among IN 40288 890 2 the the DT 40288 890 3 writers writer NNS 40288 890 4 in in IN 40288 890 5 question question NN 40288 890 6 the the DT 40288 890 7 most most RBS 40288 890 8 instructive instructive JJ 40288 890 9 is be VBZ 40288 890 10 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 890 11 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 890 12 . . . 40288 891 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 891 2 discusses discuss VBZ 40288 891 3 the the DT 40288 891 4 subject subject NN 40288 891 5 of of IN 40288 891 6 musical musical JJ 40288 891 7 ethos ethos NN 40288 891 8 under under IN 40288 891 9 the the DT 40288 891 10 first first JJ 40288 891 11 of of IN 40288 891 12 the the DT 40288 891 13 usual usual JJ 40288 891 14 seven seven CD 40288 891 15 heads head NNS 40288 891 16 , , , 40288 891 17 that that IN 40288 891 18 which which WDT 40288 891 19 deals deal VBZ 40288 891 20 with with IN 40288 891 21 sounds sound NNS 40288 891 22 or or CC 40288 891 23 notes note NNS 40288 891 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 891 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 891 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 891 27 : : : 40288 891 28 peri peri NN 40288 891 29 phthongôn phthongôn NNPS 40288 891 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 891 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 891 32 . . . 40288 892 1 Among among IN 40288 892 2 the the DT 40288 892 3 distinctions distinction NNS 40288 892 4 to to TO 40288 892 5 be be VB 40288 892 6 drawn draw VBN 40288 892 7 in in IN 40288 892 8 regard regard NN 40288 892 9 to to IN 40288 892 10 notes note NNS 40288 892 11 he -PRON- PRP 40288 892 12 reckons reckon VBZ 40288 892 13 that that DT 40288 892 14 of of IN 40288 892 15 ethos ethos NN 40288 892 16 : : : 40288 892 17 the the DT 40288 892 18 ethos ethos NN 40288 892 19 of of IN 40288 892 20 notes note NNS 40288 892 21 , , , 40288 892 22 he -PRON- PRP 40288 892 23 says say VBZ 40288 892 24 , , , 40288 892 25 is be VBZ 40288 892 26 different different JJ 40288 892 27 as as IN 40288 892 28 they -PRON- PRP 40288 892 29 are be VBP 40288 892 30 higher high JJR 40288 892 31 or or CC 40288 892 32 lower low JJR 40288 892 33 , , , 40288 892 34 and and CC 40288 892 35 also also RB 40288 892 36 as as IN 40288 892 37 they -PRON- PRP 40288 892 38 are be VBP 40288 892 39 in in IN 40288 892 40 the the DT 40288 892 41 place place NN 40288 892 42 of of IN 40288 892 43 a a DT 40288 892 44 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 892 45 or or CC 40288 892 46 in in IN 40288 892 47 the the DT 40288 892 48 place place NN 40288 892 49 of of IN 40288 892 50 a a DT 40288 892 51 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 892 52 ( ( -LRB- 40288 892 53 p. p. NN 40288 892 54 13 13 CD 40288 892 55 Meib Meib NNP 40288 892 56 . . . 40288 893 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 893 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 893 3 : : : 40288 893 4 hetera hetera NNP 40288 893 5 gar gar NNP 40288 893 6 êthê êthê NNP 40288 893 7 tois tois NNP 40288 893 8 oxyterois oxyterois NNP 40288 893 9 , , , 40288 893 10 hetera hetera NNP 40288 893 11 tois tois NNP 40288 893 12 baryterois baryterois NNP 40288 893 13 epitrechei epitrechei NNP 40288 893 14 , , , 40288 893 15 kai kai NNP 40288 893 16 hetera hetera NNP 40288 893 17 men men NNP 40288 893 18 parypatoeidesin parypatoeidesin NNP 40288 893 19 , , , 40288 893 20 hetera hetera NNP 40288 893 21 de de NNP 40288 893 22 lichanoeidesin lichanoeidesin NNP 40288 893 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 893 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 893 25 . . . 40288 894 1 Again again RB 40288 894 2 , , , 40288 894 3 under under IN 40288 894 4 the the DT 40288 894 5 seventh seventh JJ 40288 894 6 head head NN 40288 894 7 , , , 40288 894 8 that that DT 40288 894 9 of of IN 40288 894 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 894 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 894 12 : : : 40288 894 13 melopoiia melopoiia NN 40288 894 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 894 15 or or CC 40288 894 16 composition composition NN 40288 894 17 , , , 40288 894 18 he -PRON- PRP 40288 894 19 treats treat VBZ 40288 894 20 of of IN 40288 894 21 the the DT 40288 894 22 ' ' '' 40288 894 23 regions region NNS 40288 894 24 of of IN 40288 894 25 the the DT 40288 894 26 voice voice NN 40288 894 27 ' ' '' 40288 894 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 894 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 894 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 894 31 : : : 40288 894 32 topoi topoi NNP 40288 894 33 tês tês NNP 40288 894 34 phônês phônês NNP 40288 894 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 894 36 ) ) -RRB- 40288 894 37 . . . 40288 895 1 There there EX 40288 895 2 are be VBP 40288 895 3 three three CD 40288 895 4 kinds kind NNS 40288 895 5 of of IN 40288 895 6 composition composition NN 40288 895 7 , , , 40288 895 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 895 9 tells tell VBZ 40288 895 10 us -PRON- PRP 40288 895 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 895 12 p. p. NN 40288 895 13 28 28 CD 40288 895 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 895 15 , , , 40288 895 16 viz viz NN 40288 895 17 . . . 40288 896 1 that that DT 40288 896 2 which which WDT 40288 896 3 is be VBZ 40288 896 4 akin akin JJ 40288 896 5 to to IN 40288 896 6 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 896 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 896 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 896 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 896 10 : : : 40288 896 11 hypatoeidês hypatoeidês NN 40288 896 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 896 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 896 14 , , , 40288 896 15 that that IN 40288 896 16 which which WDT 40288 896 17 is be VBZ 40288 896 18 akin akin JJ 40288 896 19 to to IN 40288 896 20 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 896 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 896 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 896 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 896 24 : : : 40288 896 25 mesoeidês mesoeidês NN 40288 896 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 896 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 896 28 , , , 40288 896 29 and and CC 40288 896 30 that that IN 40288 896 31 which which WDT 40288 896 32 is be VBZ 40288 896 33 akin akin JJ 40288 896 34 to to IN 40288 896 35 Nêtê nêtê JJ 40288 896 36 ( ( -LRB- 40288 896 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 896 38 Greek Greek NNP 40288 896 39 : : : 40288 896 40 nêtoeidês nêtoeidês NN 40288 896 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 896 42 ) ) -RRB- 40288 896 43 . . . 40288 897 1 The the DT 40288 897 2 first first JJ 40288 897 3 part part NN 40288 897 4 of of IN 40288 897 5 the the DT 40288 897 6 art art NN 40288 897 7 of of IN 40288 897 8 composition composition NN 40288 897 9 is be VBZ 40288 897 10 the the DT 40288 897 11 choice choice NN 40288 897 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 897 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 897 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 897 15 : : : 40288 897 16 lêpsis lêpsis NN 40288 897 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 897 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 897 19 which which WDT 40288 897 20 the the DT 40288 897 21 musician musician NN 40288 897 22 is be VBZ 40288 897 23 able able JJ 40288 897 24 to to TO 40288 897 25 make make VB 40288 897 26 of of IN 40288 897 27 the the DT 40288 897 28 region region NN 40288 897 29 of of IN 40288 897 30 the the DT 40288 897 31 voice voice NN 40288 897 32 to to TO 40288 897 33 be be VB 40288 897 34 employed employ VBN 40288 897 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 897 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 897 37 Greek Greek NNP 40288 897 38 : : : 40288 897 39 lêpsis lêpsis NN 40288 897 40 men man NNS 40288 897 41 di di NNP 40288 897 42 ' ' `` 40288 897 43 hês hês NNP 40288 897 44 heuriskein heuriskein NNP 40288 897 45 tô tô NNP 40288 897 46 mousikô mousikô NNP 40288 897 47 perigignetai perigignetai NNP 40288 897 48 apo apo NNP 40288 897 49 poiou poiou NNP 40288 897 50 tês tês NNP 40288 897 51 phônês phônês NNP 40288 897 52 to to TO 40288 897 53 systêma systêma VB 40288 897 54 topou topou NNP 40288 897 55 poiêteon poiêteon NN 40288 897 56 , , , 40288 897 57 poteron poteron NN 40288 897 58 hypatoeidous hypatoeidous NNP 40288 897 59 ê ê NNP 40288 897 60 tôn tôn NNP 40288 897 61 loipôn loipôn NNP 40288 897 62 tinos tinos NNP 40288 897 63 ] ] -RRB- 40288 897 64 ) ) -RRB- 40288 897 65 . . . 40288 898 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 898 2 then then RB 40288 898 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 40288 898 4 to to TO 40288 898 5 connect connect VB 40288 898 6 these these DT 40288 898 7 regions region NNS 40288 898 8 , , , 40288 898 9 or or CC 40288 898 10 different different JJ 40288 898 11 parts part NNS 40288 898 12 of of IN 40288 898 13 the the DT 40288 898 14 musical musical JJ 40288 898 15 scale scale NN 40288 898 16 , , , 40288 898 17 with with IN 40288 898 18 different different JJ 40288 898 19 branches branch NNS 40288 898 20 of of IN 40288 898 21 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 898 22 poetry poetry NN 40288 898 23 . . . 40288 899 1 ' ' `` 40288 899 2 There there EX 40288 899 3 are be VBP 40288 899 4 three three CD 40288 899 5 styles style NNS 40288 899 6 of of IN 40288 899 7 musical musical JJ 40288 899 8 composition composition NN 40288 899 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 899 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 899 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 899 12 : : : 40288 899 13 tropoi tropoi NNP 40288 899 14 tês tês NNP 40288 899 15 melopoiias melopoiias NNP 40288 899 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 899 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 899 18 , , , 40288 899 19 viz viz NN 40288 899 20 . . . 40288 900 1 the the DT 40288 900 2 Nomic Nomic NNP 40288 900 3 , , , 40288 900 4 the the DT 40288 900 5 Dithyrambic dithyrambic JJ 40288 900 6 , , , 40288 900 7 and and CC 40288 900 8 the the DT 40288 900 9 Tragic tragic JJ 40288 900 10 ; ; : 40288 900 11 and and CC 40288 900 12 of of IN 40288 900 13 these these DT 40288 900 14 the the DT 40288 900 15 Nomic Nomic NNP 40288 900 16 is be VBZ 40288 900 17 netoid netoid JJ 40288 900 18 , , , 40288 900 19 the the DT 40288 900 20 Dithyrambic Dithyrambic NNP 40288 900 21 is be VBZ 40288 900 22 mesoid mesoid JJ 40288 900 23 , , , 40288 900 24 and and CC 40288 900 25 the the DT 40288 900 26 Tragic Tragic NNP 40288 900 27 is be VBZ 40288 900 28 hypatoid hypatoid NN 40288 900 29 .... .... . 40288 901 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 901 2 are be VBP 40288 901 3 called call VBN 40288 901 4 styles style NNS 40288 901 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 901 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 901 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 901 8 : : : 40288 901 9 tropoi tropoi LS 40288 901 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 901 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 901 12 because because IN 40288 901 13 according accord VBG 40288 901 14 to to IN 40288 901 15 the the DT 40288 901 16 melody melody NN 40288 901 17 adopted adopt VBN 40288 901 18 they -PRON- PRP 40288 901 19 express express VBP 40288 901 20 the the DT 40288 901 21 ethos ethos NN 40288 901 22 of of IN 40288 901 23 the the DT 40288 901 24 mind mind NN 40288 901 25 . . . 40288 902 1 Thus thus RB 40288 902 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 902 3 happens happen VBZ 40288 902 4 that that IN 40288 902 5 composition composition NN 40288 902 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 902 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 902 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 902 9 : : : 40288 902 10 melopoiia melopoiia NN 40288 902 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 902 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 902 13 may may MD 40288 902 14 differ differ VB 40288 902 15 in in IN 40288 902 16 _ _ NNP 40288 902 17 genus genus NNP 40288 902 18 _ _ NNP 40288 902 19 , , , 40288 902 20 as as IN 40288 902 21 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 902 22 , , , 40288 902 23 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 902 24 : : : 40288 902 25 in in IN 40288 902 26 _ _ NNP 40288 902 27 System System NNP 40288 902 28 _ _ NNP 40288 902 29 , , , 40288 902 30 as as IN 40288 902 31 Hypatoid Hypatoid NNP 40288 902 32 , , , 40288 902 33 Mesoid Mesoid NNP 40288 902 34 , , , 40288 902 35 Netoid Netoid NNP 40288 902 36 : : : 40288 902 37 in in IN 40288 902 38 _ _ NNP 40288 902 39 key key JJ 40288 902 40 _ _ NNP 40288 902 41 , , , 40288 902 42 as as IN 40288 902 43 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 902 44 , , , 40288 902 45 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 902 46 : : : 40288 902 47 in in IN 40288 902 48 _ _ NNP 40288 902 49 style style NN 40288 902 50 _ _ NNP 40288 902 51 , , , 40288 902 52 as as IN 40288 902 53 Nomic Nomic NNP 40288 902 54 , , , 40288 902 55 Dithyrambic dithyrambic JJ 40288 902 56 : : : 40288 902 57 in in IN 40288 902 58 _ _ NNP 40288 902 59 ethos ethos NN 40288 902 60 _ _ NNP 40288 902 61 , , , 40288 902 62 as as IN 40288 902 63 we -PRON- PRP 40288 902 64 call call VBP 40288 902 65 one one CD 40288 902 66 kind kind NN 40288 902 67 of of IN 40288 902 68 composition composition NN 40288 902 69 " " `` 40288 902 70 contracting contracting NN 40288 902 71 " " '' 40288 902 72 ( ( -LRB- 40288 902 73 [ [ -LRB- 40288 902 74 Greek Greek NNP 40288 902 75 : : : 40288 902 76 systaltikê systaltikê NN 40288 902 77 ] ] -RRB- 40288 902 78 ) ) -RRB- 40288 902 79 , , , 40288 902 80 viz viz NN 40288 902 81 . . . 40288 903 1 that that IN 40288 903 2 by by IN 40288 903 3 which which WDT 40288 903 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 903 5 move move VBP 40288 903 6 painful painful JJ 40288 903 7 feelings feeling NNS 40288 903 8 ; ; : 40288 903 9 another another DT 40288 903 10 " " `` 40288 903 11 expanding expand VBG 40288 903 12 " " '' 40288 903 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 903 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 903 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 903 16 : : : 40288 903 17 diastaltikê diastaltikê NNP 40288 903 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 903 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 903 20 , , , 40288 903 21 that that IN 40288 903 22 by by IN 40288 903 23 which which WDT 40288 903 24 we -PRON- PRP 40288 903 25 arouse arouse VBP 40288 903 26 the the DT 40288 903 27 spirit spirit NN 40288 903 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 903 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 903 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 903 31 : : : 40288 903 32 thymos thymo NNS 40288 903 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 903 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 903 35 ; ; : 40288 903 36 and and CC 40288 903 37 another another DT 40288 903 38 " " `` 40288 903 39 middle middle JJ 40288 903 40 " " '' 40288 903 41 ( ( -LRB- 40288 903 42 [ [ -LRB- 40288 903 43 Greek greek JJ 40288 903 44 : : : 40288 903 45 mesê mesê NNS 40288 903 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 903 47 ) ) -RRB- 40288 903 48 , , , 40288 903 49 that that IN 40288 903 50 by by IN 40288 903 51 which which WDT 40288 903 52 we -PRON- PRP 40288 903 53 bring bring VBP 40288 903 54 round round RB 40288 903 55 the the DT 40288 903 56 soul soul NN 40288 903 57 to to TO 40288 903 58 calmness calmness VB 40288 903 59 . . . 40288 903 60 ' ' '' 40288 904 1 This this DT 40288 904 2 passage passage NN 40288 904 3 does do VBZ 40288 904 4 not not RB 40288 904 5 quite quite RB 40288 904 6 explicitly explicitly RB 40288 904 7 connect connect VB 40288 904 8 the the DT 40288 904 9 three three CD 40288 904 10 kinds kind NNS 40288 904 11 of of IN 40288 904 12 ethos ethos NN 40288 904 13 -- -- : 40288 904 14 the the DT 40288 904 15 diastaltic diastaltic NN 40288 904 16 , , , 40288 904 17 the the DT 40288 904 18 systaltic systaltic JJ 40288 904 19 , , , 40288 904 20 the the DT 40288 904 21 intermediate intermediate JJ 40288 904 22 -- -- : 40288 904 23 with with IN 40288 904 24 the the DT 40288 904 25 three three CD 40288 904 26 regions region NNS 40288 904 27 of of IN 40288 904 28 the the DT 40288 904 29 voice voice NN 40288 904 30 ; ; : 40288 904 31 but but CC 40288 904 32 the the DT 40288 904 33 connexion connexion NN 40288 904 34 was be VBD 40288 904 35 evidently evidently RB 40288 904 36 implied imply VBN 40288 904 37 , , , 40288 904 38 and and CC 40288 904 39 is be VBZ 40288 904 40 laid lay VBN 40288 904 41 down down RP 40288 904 42 in in IN 40288 904 43 express express JJ 40288 904 44 terms term NNS 40288 904 45 in in IN 40288 904 46 the the DT 40288 904 47 pseudo pseudo NN 40288 904 48 - - JJ 40288 904 49 Euclidean euclidean JJ 40288 904 50 _ _ NNP 40288 904 51 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 904 52 _ _ NNP 40288 904 53 ( ( -LRB- 40288 904 54 p. p. NN 40288 904 55 21 21 CD 40288 904 56 Meib Meib NNP 40288 904 57 . . . 40288 904 58 ) ) -RRB- 40288 904 59 . . . 40288 905 1 According accord VBG 40288 905 2 to to IN 40288 905 3 this this DT 40288 905 4 Aristoxenean aristoxenean JJ 40288 905 5 writer writer NN 40288 905 6 , , , 40288 905 7 ' ' '' 40288 905 8 the the DT 40288 905 9 diastaltic diastaltic JJ 40288 905 10 ethos ethos NN 40288 905 11 of of IN 40288 905 12 musical musical JJ 40288 905 13 composition composition NN 40288 905 14 is be VBZ 40288 905 15 that that IN 40288 905 16 which which WDT 40288 905 17 expresses express VBZ 40288 905 18 grandeur grandeur NN 40288 905 19 and and CC 40288 905 20 manly manly JJ 40288 905 21 elevation elevation NN 40288 905 22 of of IN 40288 905 23 soul soul NN 40288 905 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 905 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 905 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 905 27 : : : 40288 905 28 megaloprepeia megaloprepeia NNP 40288 905 29 kai kai NNP 40288 905 30 diarma diarma NNP 40288 905 31 psychês psychês NNP 40288 905 32 andrôdes andrôde NNS 40288 905 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 905 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 905 35 , , , 40288 905 36 and and CC 40288 905 37 heroic heroic JJ 40288 905 38 actions action NNS 40288 905 39 ; ; : 40288 905 40 and and CC 40288 905 41 these these DT 40288 905 42 are be VBP 40288 905 43 employed employ VBN 40288 905 44 by by IN 40288 905 45 tragedy tragedy NN 40288 905 46 and and CC 40288 905 47 all all DT 40288 905 48 poetry poetry NN 40288 905 49 that that WDT 40288 905 50 approaches approach VBZ 40288 905 51 the the DT 40288 905 52 tragic tragic JJ 40288 905 53 type type NN 40288 905 54 . . . 40288 906 1 The the DT 40288 906 2 systaltic systaltic JJ 40288 906 3 ethos ethos NN 40288 906 4 is be VBZ 40288 906 5 that that IN 40288 906 6 by by IN 40288 906 7 which which WDT 40288 906 8 the the DT 40288 906 9 soul soul NN 40288 906 10 is be VBZ 40288 906 11 brought bring VBN 40288 906 12 down down RP 40288 906 13 into into IN 40288 906 14 a a DT 40288 906 15 humble humble JJ 40288 906 16 and and CC 40288 906 17 unmanly unmanly JJ 40288 906 18 frame frame NN 40288 906 19 ; ; , 40288 906 20 and and CC 40288 906 21 such such PDT 40288 906 22 a a DT 40288 906 23 disposition disposition NN 40288 906 24 will will MD 40288 906 25 be be VB 40288 906 26 fitting fitting JJ 40288 906 27 for for IN 40288 906 28 amatory amatory JJ 40288 906 29 effusions effusion NNS 40288 906 30 and and CC 40288 906 31 dirges dirge NNS 40288 906 32 and and CC 40288 906 33 lamentations lamentation NNS 40288 906 34 and and CC 40288 906 35 the the DT 40288 906 36 like like JJ 40288 906 37 . . . 40288 907 1 And and CC 40288 907 2 the the DT 40288 907 3 hesychastic hesychastic JJ 40288 907 4 or or CC 40288 907 5 tranquilly tranquilly RB 40288 907 6 disposed disposed JJ 40288 907 7 ethos ethos NN 40288 907 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 907 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 907 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 907 11 : : : 40288 907 12 hêsychastikon hêsychastikon JJ 40288 907 13 êthos êthos NN 40288 907 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 907 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 907 16 of of IN 40288 907 17 musical musical JJ 40288 907 18 composition composition NN 40288 907 19 is be VBZ 40288 907 20 that that DT 40288 907 21 which which WDT 40288 907 22 is be VBZ 40288 907 23 followed follow VBN 40288 907 24 by by IN 40288 907 25 calmness calmness NN 40288 907 26 of of IN 40288 907 27 soul soul NN 40288 907 28 and and CC 40288 907 29 a a DT 40288 907 30 liberal liberal JJ 40288 907 31 and and CC 40288 907 32 peaceful peaceful JJ 40288 907 33 disposition disposition NN 40288 907 34 : : : 40288 907 35 and and CC 40288 907 36 this this DT 40288 907 37 temper temper NN 40288 907 38 will will MD 40288 907 39 fit fit VB 40288 907 40 hymns hymn NNS 40288 907 41 , , , 40288 907 42 paeans paeans NNPS 40288 907 43 , , , 40288 907 44 laudations laudation NNS 40288 907 45 , , , 40288 907 46 didactic didactic JJ 40288 907 47 poetry poetry NN 40288 907 48 and and CC 40288 907 49 the the DT 40288 907 50 like like JJ 40288 907 51 . . . 40288 907 52 ' ' '' 40288 908 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 908 2 appears appear VBZ 40288 908 3 then then RB 40288 908 4 that that DT 40288 908 5 difference difference NN 40288 908 6 in in IN 40288 908 7 the the DT 40288 908 8 ' ' `` 40288 908 9 place place NN 40288 908 10 ' ' '' 40288 908 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 908 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 908 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 908 14 : : : 40288 908 15 topos topos NN 40288 908 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 908 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 908 18 of of IN 40288 908 19 the the DT 40288 908 20 notes note NNS 40288 908 21 employed employ VBN 40288 908 22 in in IN 40288 908 23 a a DT 40288 908 24 composition composition NN 40288 908 25 -- -- : 40288 908 26 difference difference NN 40288 908 27 , , , 40288 908 28 that that DT 40288 908 29 is be VBZ 40288 908 30 to to TO 40288 908 31 say say VB 40288 908 32 , , , 40288 908 33 of of IN 40288 908 34 pitch pitch NN 40288 908 35 -- -- : 40288 908 36 was be VBD 40288 908 37 the the DT 40288 908 38 element element NN 40288 908 39 which which WDT 40288 908 40 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 908 41 determined determine VBD 40288 908 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 908 43 ethos ethos NN 40288 908 44 , , , 40288 908 45 and and CC 40288 908 46 ( ( -LRB- 40288 908 47 by by IN 40288 908 48 consequence consequence NNP 40288 908 49 ) ) -RRB- 40288 908 50 which which WDT 40288 908 51 distinguished distinguish VBD 40288 908 52 the the DT 40288 908 53 music music NN 40288 908 54 appropriate appropriate JJ 40288 908 55 to to IN 40288 908 56 the the DT 40288 908 57 several several JJ 40288 908 58 kinds kind NNS 40288 908 59 of of IN 40288 908 60 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 908 61 poetry poetry NN 40288 908 62 . . . 40288 909 1 A a DT 40288 909 2 slightly slightly RB 40288 909 3 different different JJ 40288 909 4 version version NN 40288 909 5 of of IN 40288 909 6 this this DT 40288 909 7 piece piece NN 40288 909 8 of of IN 40288 909 9 theory theory NN 40288 909 10 is be VBZ 40288 909 11 preserved preserve VBN 40288 909 12 in in IN 40288 909 13 the the DT 40288 909 14 anonymous anonymous JJ 40288 909 15 treatise treatise NN 40288 909 16 edited edit VBN 40288 909 17 by by IN 40288 909 18 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 909 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 909 20 § § CD 40288 909 21 § § CD 40288 909 22 63 63 CD 40288 909 23 , , , 40288 909 24 64 64 CD 40288 909 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 909 26 , , , 40288 909 27 where where WRB 40288 909 28 the the DT 40288 909 29 ' ' `` 40288 909 30 regions region NNS 40288 909 31 of of IN 40288 909 32 the the DT 40288 909 33 voice voice NN 40288 909 34 ' ' '' 40288 909 35 are be VBP 40288 909 36 said say VBN 40288 909 37 to to TO 40288 909 38 be be VB 40288 909 39 four four CD 40288 909 40 in in IN 40288 909 41 number number NN 40288 909 42 , , , 40288 909 43 viz viz NN 40288 909 44 . . . 40288 910 1 the the DT 40288 910 2 three three CD 40288 910 3 already already RB 40288 910 4 mentioned mention VBN 40288 910 5 , , , 40288 910 6 and and CC 40288 910 7 a a DT 40288 910 8 fourth fourth JJ 40288 910 9 which which WDT 40288 910 10 takes take VBZ 40288 910 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 910 12 name name NN 40288 910 13 from from IN 40288 910 14 the the DT 40288 910 15 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 910 16 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 910 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 910 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 910 19 Greek greek JJ 40288 910 20 : : : 40288 910 21 topos topos CD 40288 910 22 hyperboloeidês hyperboloeidês NN 40288 910 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 910 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 910 25 . . . 40288 911 1 In in IN 40288 911 2 the the DT 40288 911 3 same same JJ 40288 911 4 passage passage NN 40288 911 5 the the DT 40288 911 6 boundaries boundary NNS 40288 911 7 of of IN 40288 911 8 the the DT 40288 911 9 several several JJ 40288 911 10 regions region NNS 40288 911 11 are be VBP 40288 911 12 laid lay VBN 40288 911 13 down down RP 40288 911 14 by by IN 40288 911 15 reference reference NN 40288 911 16 to to IN 40288 911 17 the the DT 40288 911 18 keys key NNS 40288 911 19 . . . 40288 912 1 ' ' `` 40288 912 2 The the DT 40288 912 3 lowest low JJS 40288 912 4 or or CC 40288 912 5 hypatoid hypatoid NN 40288 912 6 region region NN 40288 912 7 reaches reach VBZ 40288 912 8 from from IN 40288 912 9 the the DT 40288 912 10 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 912 11 - - HYPH 40288 912 12 dorian dorian JJ 40288 912 13 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 912 14 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 912 15 to to IN 40288 912 16 the the DT 40288 912 17 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 912 18 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 912 19 ; ; : 40288 912 20 the the DT 40288 912 21 intermediate intermediate JJ 40288 912 22 or or CC 40288 912 23 mesoid mesoid JJ 40288 912 24 region region NN 40288 912 25 from from IN 40288 912 26 the the DT 40288 912 27 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 912 28 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 912 29 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 912 30 to to IN 40288 912 31 the the DT 40288 912 32 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 912 33 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 912 34 ; ; : 40288 912 35 the the DT 40288 912 36 netoid netoid JJ 40288 912 37 region region NN 40288 912 38 from from IN 40288 912 39 the the DT 40288 912 40 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 912 41 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 912 42 to to IN 40288 912 43 the the DT 40288 912 44 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 912 45 Synemmenôn Synemmenôn NNP 40288 912 46 ; ; : 40288 912 47 the the DT 40288 912 48 hyperboloid hyperboloid NN 40288 912 49 region region NN 40288 912 50 embracing embrace VBG 40288 912 51 all all DT 40288 912 52 above above IN 40288 912 53 the the DT 40288 912 54 last last JJ 40288 912 55 point point NN 40288 912 56 . . . 40288 912 57 ' ' '' 40288 913 1 The the DT 40288 913 2 text text NN 40288 913 3 of of IN 40288 913 4 this this DT 40288 913 5 passage passage NN 40288 913 6 is be VBZ 40288 913 7 uncertain uncertain JJ 40288 913 8 ; ; : 40288 913 9 but but CC 40288 913 10 the the DT 40288 913 11 general general JJ 40288 913 12 character character NN 40288 913 13 of of IN 40288 913 14 the the DT 40288 913 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 913 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 913 17 : : : 40288 913 18 topoi topoi NNP 40288 913 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 913 20 or or CC 40288 913 21 regions region NNS 40288 913 22 of of IN 40288 913 23 the the DT 40288 913 24 voice voice NN 40288 913 25 is be VBZ 40288 913 26 clearly clearly RB 40288 913 27 enough enough RB 40288 913 28 indicated indicate VBN 40288 913 29 . . . 40288 914 1 The the DT 40288 914 2 three three CD 40288 914 3 regions region NNS 40288 914 4 are be VBP 40288 914 5 mentioned mention VBN 40288 914 6 in in IN 40288 914 7 the the DT 40288 914 8 catechism catechism NN 40288 914 9 of of IN 40288 914 10 Bacchius Bacchius NNP 40288 914 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 914 12 p. p. NN 40288 914 13 11 11 CD 40288 914 14 Meib Meib NNP 40288 914 15 . . . 40288 915 1 ): ): NNP 40288 915 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 915 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 915 4 : : : 40288 915 5 topous topous JJ 40288 915 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 915 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 915 8 MSS MSS NNP 40288 915 9 . . . 40288 916 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 916 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 916 3 : : : 40288 916 4 tropous tropous JJ 40288 916 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 916 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 916 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 916 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 916 9 : : : 40288 916 10 de de NNP 40288 916 11 tês tês NNP 40288 916 12 phônês phônês NNP 40288 916 13 posous posous JJ 40288 916 14 legomen legoman NNS 40288 916 15 einai einai VB 40288 916 16 ? ? . 40288 917 1 treis treis NNP 40288 917 2 . . . 40288 918 1 tinas tinas NNP 40288 918 2 ? ? . 40288 919 1 toutous toutous JJ 40288 919 2 ; ; : 40288 919 3 oxyn oxyn NNP 40288 919 4 , , , 40288 919 5 meson meson NNP 40288 919 6 , , , 40288 919 7 baryn baryn NNP 40288 919 8 . . . 40288 919 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 920 1 The the DT 40288 920 2 varieties variety NNS 40288 920 3 of of IN 40288 920 4 ethos ethos NN 40288 920 5 also also RB 40288 920 6 appear appear VBP 40288 920 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 920 8 p. p. NN 40288 920 9 14 14 CD 40288 920 10 Meib Meib NNP 40288 920 11 . . . 40288 921 1 ): ): NNP 40288 921 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 921 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 921 4 : : : 40288 921 5 hê hê NNP 40288 921 6 de de NNP 40288 921 7 metabolê metabolê NNP 40288 921 8 kata kata NNP 40288 921 9 êthos êthos VB 40288 921 10 ? ? . 40288 922 1 hotan hotan NNP 40288 922 2 ek ek NNP 40288 922 3 tapeinou tapeinou NNP 40288 922 4 eis eis NNP 40288 922 5 megaloprepes megaloprepe NNS 40288 922 6 ; ; : 40288 922 7 ê ê NNP 40288 922 8 ex ex NNP 40288 922 9 hêsychou hêsychou NNP 40288 922 10 kai kai NNP 40288 922 11 synnou synnou NNP 40288 922 12 eis eis NNP 40288 922 13 parakekinêkos parakekinêkos NNP 40288 922 14 . . . 40288 922 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 923 1 ' ' `` 40288 923 2 What what WP 40288 923 3 is be VBZ 40288 923 4 change change NN 40288 923 5 of of IN 40288 923 6 ethos ethos NN 40288 923 7 ? ? . 40288 924 1 when when WRB 40288 924 2 a a DT 40288 924 3 change change NN 40288 924 4 is be VBZ 40288 924 5 made make VBN 40288 924 6 from from IN 40288 924 7 the the DT 40288 924 8 humble humble JJ 40288 924 9 to to IN 40288 924 10 the the DT 40288 924 11 magnificent magnificent JJ 40288 924 12 ; ; : 40288 924 13 or or CC 40288 924 14 from from IN 40288 924 15 the the DT 40288 924 16 tranquil tranquil NN 40288 924 17 and and CC 40288 924 18 sober sober JJ 40288 924 19 to to IN 40288 924 20 violent violent JJ 40288 924 21 emotion emotion NN 40288 924 22 . . . 40288 924 23 ' ' '' 40288 925 1 When when WRB 40288 925 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 925 3 compare compare VBP 40288 925 4 the the DT 40288 925 5 doctrine doctrine NN 40288 925 6 of of IN 40288 925 7 musical musical JJ 40288 925 8 ethos ethos NN 40288 925 9 as as IN 40288 925 10 we -PRON- PRP 40288 925 11 find find VBP 40288 925 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 925 13 in in IN 40288 925 14 these these DT 40288 925 15 later later JJ 40288 925 16 writers writer NNS 40288 925 17 with with IN 40288 925 18 the the DT 40288 925 19 indications indication NNS 40288 925 20 to to TO 40288 925 21 be be VB 40288 925 22 gathered gather VBN 40288 925 23 from from IN 40288 925 24 Plato Plato NNP 40288 925 25 and and CC 40288 925 26 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 925 27 , , , 40288 925 28 the the DT 40288 925 29 chief chief JJ 40288 925 30 difference difference NN 40288 925 31 appears appear VBZ 40288 925 32 to to TO 40288 925 33 be be VB 40288 925 34 that that IN 40288 925 35 we -PRON- PRP 40288 925 36 no no RB 40288 925 37 longer longer RB 40288 925 38 hear hear VBP 40288 925 39 of of IN 40288 925 40 the the DT 40288 925 41 ethos ethos NN 40288 925 42 of of IN 40288 925 43 particular particular JJ 40288 925 44 modes mode NNS 40288 925 45 , , , 40288 925 46 but but CC 40288 925 47 only only RB 40288 925 48 of of IN 40288 925 49 that that DT 40288 925 50 of of IN 40288 925 51 three three CD 40288 925 52 or or CC 40288 925 53 ( ( -LRB- 40288 925 54 at at IN 40288 925 55 the the DT 40288 925 56 most most RBS 40288 925 57 ) ) -RRB- 40288 925 58 four four CD 40288 925 59 portions portion NNS 40288 925 60 of of IN 40288 925 61 the the DT 40288 925 62 scale scale NN 40288 925 63 . . . 40288 926 1 The the DT 40288 926 2 principle principle NN 40288 926 3 of of IN 40288 926 4 the the DT 40288 926 5 division division NN 40288 926 6 , , , 40288 926 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 926 8 is be VBZ 40288 926 9 evident evident JJ 40288 926 10 , , , 40288 926 11 is be VBZ 40288 926 12 simply simply RB 40288 926 13 difference difference NN 40288 926 14 of of IN 40288 926 15 pitch pitch NN 40288 926 16 . . . 40288 927 1 But but CC 40288 927 2 if if IN 40288 927 3 that that DT 40288 927 4 was be VBD 40288 927 5 the the DT 40288 927 6 basis basis NN 40288 927 7 of of IN 40288 927 8 the the DT 40288 927 9 ethical ethical JJ 40288 927 10 effect effect NN 40288 927 11 of of IN 40288 927 12 music music NN 40288 927 13 in in IN 40288 927 14 later later JJ 40288 927 15 times time NNS 40288 927 16 , , , 40288 927 17 the the DT 40288 927 18 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 927 19 goes go VBZ 40288 927 20 far far RB 40288 927 21 to to TO 40288 927 22 confirm confirm VB 40288 927 23 us -PRON- PRP 40288 927 24 in in IN 40288 927 25 the the DT 40288 927 26 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 927 27 that that IN 40288 927 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 927 29 was be VBD 40288 927 30 the the DT 40288 927 31 pitch pitch NN 40288 927 32 of of IN 40288 927 33 the the DT 40288 927 34 music music NN 40288 927 35 , , , 40288 927 36 rather rather RB 40288 927 37 than than IN 40288 927 38 any any DT 40288 927 39 difference difference NN 40288 927 40 in in IN 40288 927 41 the the DT 40288 927 42 succession succession NN 40288 927 43 of of IN 40288 927 44 the the DT 40288 927 45 intervals interval NNS 40288 927 46 , , , 40288 927 47 that that WDT 40288 927 48 principally principally RB 40288 927 49 determined determine VBD 40288 927 50 the the DT 40288 927 51 ethical ethical JJ 40288 927 52 character character NN 40288 927 53 of of IN 40288 927 54 the the DT 40288 927 55 older old JJR 40288 927 56 modes mode NNS 40288 927 57 . . . 40288 928 1 § § ADD 40288 928 2 26 26 CD 40288 928 3 . . . 40288 929 1 _ _ NNP 40288 929 2 The the DT 40288 929 3 Ethos Ethos NNP 40288 929 4 of of IN 40288 929 5 the the DT 40288 929 6 Genera Genera NNP 40288 929 7 and and CC 40288 929 8 Species Species NNP 40288 929 9 . . . 40288 929 10 _ _ NNP 40288 929 11 Although although IN 40288 929 12 the the DT 40288 929 13 pitch pitch NN 40288 929 14 of of IN 40288 929 15 a a DT 40288 929 16 musical musical JJ 40288 929 17 composition composition NN 40288 929 18 -- -- : 40288 929 19 as as IN 40288 929 20 these these DT 40288 929 21 passages passage NNS 40288 929 22 confirm confirm VBP 40288 929 23 us -PRON- PRP 40288 929 24 in in IN 40288 929 25 believing believe VBG 40288 929 26 -- -- : 40288 929 27 was be VBD 40288 929 28 the the DT 40288 929 29 chief chief JJ 40288 929 30 ground ground NN 40288 929 31 of of IN 40288 929 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 929 33 ethical ethical JJ 40288 929 34 character character NN 40288 929 35 , , , 40288 929 36 it -PRON- PRP 40288 929 37 can can MD 40288 929 38 not not RB 40288 929 39 be be VB 40288 929 40 said say VBN 40288 929 41 that that IN 40288 929 42 no no DT 40288 929 43 other other JJ 40288 929 44 element element NN 40288 929 45 entered enter VBD 40288 929 46 into into IN 40288 929 47 the the DT 40288 929 48 case case NN 40288 929 49 . . . 40288 930 1 In in IN 40288 930 2 the the DT 40288 930 3 passage passage NN 40288 930 4 quoted quote VBN 40288 930 5 above above RB 40288 930 6 from from IN 40288 930 7 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 930 8 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 930 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 930 10 p. p. NN 40288 930 11 13 13 CD 40288 930 12 Meib Meib NNP 40288 930 13 . . . 40288 930 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 931 1 it -PRON- PRP 40288 931 2 is be VBZ 40288 931 3 said say VBN 40288 931 4 that that IN 40288 931 5 ethos ethos NN 40288 931 6 depends depend VBZ 40288 931 7 first first RB 40288 931 8 on on IN 40288 931 9 pitch pitch NN 40288 931 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 931 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 931 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 931 13 : : : 40288 931 14 hetera hetera NNP 40288 931 15 êthê êthê NNP 40288 931 16 tois tois NNP 40288 931 17 oxyterois oxyterois NNP 40288 931 18 , , , 40288 931 19 hetera hetera NNP 40288 931 20 tois tois NNP 40288 931 21 baryterois baryterois NNP 40288 931 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 931 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 931 24 , , , 40288 931 25 and and CC 40288 931 26 secondly secondly RB 40288 931 27 on on IN 40288 931 28 the the DT 40288 931 29 moveable moveable JJ 40288 931 30 notes note NNS 40288 931 31 , , , 40288 931 32 that that DT 40288 931 33 is be VBZ 40288 931 34 to to TO 40288 931 35 say say VB 40288 931 36 , , , 40288 931 37 on on IN 40288 931 38 the the DT 40288 931 39 _ _ NNP 40288 931 40 genus genus NN 40288 931 41 _ _ NNP 40288 931 42 . . . 40288 932 1 For for IN 40288 932 2 that that DT 40288 932 3 is be VBZ 40288 932 4 evidently evidently RB 40288 932 5 involved involve VBN 40288 932 6 in in IN 40288 932 7 the the DT 40288 932 8 words word NNS 40288 932 9 that that WDT 40288 932 10 follow follow VBP 40288 932 11 : : : 40288 932 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 932 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 932 14 : : : 40288 932 15 kai kai NNP 40288 932 16 hetera hetera NNP 40288 932 17 men men NNP 40288 932 18 parypatoeidesin parypatoeidesin NNP 40288 932 19 , , , 40288 932 20 hetera hetera NNP 40288 932 21 de de NNP 40288 932 22 lichanoeidesin lichanoeidesin NNP 40288 932 23 . . . 40288 932 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 933 1 By by IN 40288 933 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 933 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 933 4 : : : 40288 933 5 parypatoeideis parypatoeideis NNP 40288 933 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 933 7 and and CC 40288 933 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 933 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 933 10 : : : 40288 933 11 lichanoeideis lichanoeideis NN 40288 933 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 933 13 he -PRON- PRP 40288 933 14 means mean VBZ 40288 933 15 all all PDT 40288 933 16 the the DT 40288 933 17 moveable moveable JJ 40288 933 18 notes note NNS 40288 933 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 933 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 933 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 933 22 : : : 40288 933 23 phthongoi phthongoi NNP 40288 933 24 pheromenoi pheromenoi NNP 40288 933 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 933 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 933 27 : : : 40288 933 28 the the DT 40288 933 29 first first JJ 40288 933 30 are be VBP 40288 933 31 those those DT 40288 933 32 which which WDT 40288 933 33 hold hold VBP 40288 933 34 the the DT 40288 933 35 place place NN 40288 933 36 of of IN 40288 933 37 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 933 38 in in IN 40288 933 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 933 40 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 933 41 , , , 40288 933 42 viz viz NN 40288 933 43 . . . 40288 934 1 the the DT 40288 934 2 notes note NNS 40288 934 3 called call VBD 40288 934 4 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 934 5 or or CC 40288 934 6 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 934 7 : : : 40288 934 8 the the DT 40288 934 9 second second JJ 40288 934 10 are be VBP 40288 934 11 similarly similarly RB 40288 934 12 the the DT 40288 934 13 notes note NNS 40288 934 14 called call VBN 40288 934 15 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 934 16 or or CC 40288 934 17 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 934 18 . . . 40288 935 1 These these DT 40288 935 2 moveable moveable JJ 40288 935 3 notes note NNS 40288 935 4 , , , 40288 935 5 then then RB 40288 935 6 , , , 40288 935 7 give give VB 40288 935 8 an an DT 40288 935 9 ethos ethos NN 40288 935 10 to to IN 40288 935 11 the the DT 40288 935 12 music music NN 40288 935 13 because because IN 40288 935 14 they -PRON- PRP 40288 935 15 determine determine VBP 40288 935 16 the the DT 40288 935 17 genus genus NN 40288 935 18 of of IN 40288 935 19 the the DT 40288 935 20 scale scale NN 40288 935 21 . . . 40288 936 1 Regarding regard VBG 40288 936 2 the the DT 40288 936 3 particular particular JJ 40288 936 4 ethos ethos NN 40288 936 5 belonging belong VBG 40288 936 6 to to IN 40288 936 7 the the DT 40288 936 8 different different JJ 40288 936 9 genera genera NN 40288 936 10 , , , 40288 936 11 there there EX 40288 936 12 is be VBZ 40288 936 13 a a DT 40288 936 14 statement statement NN 40288 936 15 of of IN 40288 936 16 the the DT 40288 936 17 same same JJ 40288 936 18 author author NN 40288 936 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 936 20 p. p. NN 40288 936 21 111 111 CD 40288 936 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 936 23 to to IN 40288 936 24 the the DT 40288 936 25 effect effect NN 40288 936 26 that that WDT 40288 936 27 the the DT 40288 936 28 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 936 29 is be VBZ 40288 936 30 masculine masculine JJ 40288 936 31 and and CC 40288 936 32 austere austere JJ 40288 936 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 936 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 936 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 936 36 : : : 40288 936 37 arrhenôpon arrhenôpon NNP 40288 936 38 d d NNP 40288 936 39 ' ' '' 40288 936 40 esti esti NNP 40288 936 41 kai kai NNP 40288 936 42 austêroteron austêroteron NNP 40288 936 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 936 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 936 45 , , , 40288 936 46 the the DT 40288 936 47 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 936 48 sweet sweet JJ 40288 936 49 and and CC 40288 936 50 plaintive plaintive JJ 40288 936 51 ( ( -LRB- 40288 936 52 [ [ -LRB- 40288 936 53 Greek Greek NNP 40288 936 54 : : : 40288 936 55 hêdiston hêdiston NNP 40288 936 56 te te NNP 40288 936 57 kai kai NNP 40288 936 58 goeron goeron NNP 40288 936 59 ] ] -RRB- 40288 936 60 ) ) -RRB- 40288 936 61 , , , 40288 936 62 the the DT 40288 936 63 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 936 64 stirring stir VBG 40288 936 65 and and CC 40288 936 66 pleasing pleasing JJ 40288 936 67 ( ( -LRB- 40288 936 68 [ [ -LRB- 40288 936 69 Greek Greek NNP 40288 936 70 : : : 40288 936 71 diegertikon diegertikon NN 40288 936 72 d d NNP 40288 936 73 ' ' POS 40288 936 74 esti esti NN 40288 936 75 touto touto NNP 40288 936 76 kai kai NNP 40288 936 77 êpion êpion NNP 40288 936 78 ] ] -RRB- 40288 936 79 ) ) -RRB- 40288 936 80 . . . 40288 937 1 The the DT 40288 937 2 criticism criticism NN 40288 937 3 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 937 4 came come VBD 40288 937 5 from from IN 40288 937 6 some some DT 40288 937 7 earlier early JJR 40288 937 8 source source NN 40288 937 9 . . . 40288 938 1 Do do VBP 40288 938 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 938 3 ever ever RB 40288 938 4 find find VB 40288 938 5 ethos ethos NN 40288 938 6 attributed attribute VBN 40288 938 7 to to IN 40288 938 8 this this DT 40288 938 9 or or CC 40288 938 10 that that IN 40288 938 11 _ _ NNP 40288 938 12 species specie NNS 40288 938 13 _ _ NNP 40288 938 14 of of IN 40288 938 15 the the DT 40288 938 16 Octave Octave NNP 40288 938 17 ? ? . 40288 939 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 939 2 can can MD 40288 939 3 find find VB 40288 939 4 no no DT 40288 939 5 passage passage NN 40288 939 6 in in IN 40288 939 7 which which WDT 40288 939 8 this this DT 40288 939 9 source source NN 40288 939 10 of of IN 40288 939 11 ethos ethos NN 40288 939 12 is be VBZ 40288 939 13 indicated indicate VBN 40288 939 14 . . . 40288 940 1 Even even RB 40288 940 2 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 940 3 , , , 40288 940 4 who who WP 40288 940 5 is be VBZ 40288 940 6 the the DT 40288 940 7 chief chief JJ 40288 940 8 authority authority NN 40288 940 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 940 10 as as IN 40288 940 11 we -PRON- PRP 40288 940 12 shall shall MD 40288 940 13 see see VB 40288 940 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 940 15 for for IN 40288 940 16 the the DT 40288 940 17 value value NN 40288 940 18 of of IN 40288 940 19 the the DT 40288 940 20 species specie NNS 40288 940 21 , , , 40288 940 22 and and CC 40288 940 23 who who WP 40288 940 24 makes make VBZ 40288 940 25 least least JJS 40288 940 26 of of IN 40288 940 27 mere mere JJ 40288 940 28 difference difference NN 40288 940 29 of of IN 40288 940 30 pitch pitch NN 40288 940 31 , , , 40288 940 32 recognises recognise VBZ 40288 940 33 only only RB 40288 940 34 two two CD 40288 940 35 forms form NNS 40288 940 36 of of IN 40288 940 37 modulation modulation NN 40288 940 38 in in IN 40288 940 39 the the DT 40288 940 40 course course NN 40288 940 41 of of IN 40288 940 42 a a DT 40288 940 43 melody melody NN 40288 940 44 , , , 40288 940 45 viz viz NN 40288 940 46 . . . 40288 941 1 change change NN 40288 941 2 of of IN 40288 941 3 genus genus NN 40288 941 4 and and CC 40288 941 5 change change NN 40288 941 6 of of IN 40288 941 7 pitch[1 pitch[1 NNP 40288 941 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 941 9 . . . 40288 942 1 § § NFP 40288 942 2 27 27 CD 40288 942 3 . . . 40288 943 1 _ _ NNP 40288 943 2 The the DT 40288 943 3 Musical Musical NNP 40288 943 4 Notation Notation NNP 40288 943 5 . . . 40288 943 6 _ _ NNP 40288 943 7 As as IN 40288 943 8 the the DT 40288 943 9 preceding precede VBG 40288 943 10 argument argument NN 40288 943 11 turns turn VBZ 40288 943 12 very very RB 40288 943 13 much much RB 40288 943 14 upon upon IN 40288 943 15 the the DT 40288 943 16 practical practical JJ 40288 943 17 importance importance NN 40288 943 18 of of IN 40288 943 19 the the DT 40288 943 20 scale scale NN 40288 943 21 which which WDT 40288 943 22 we -PRON- PRP 40288 943 23 have have VBP 40288 943 24 been be VBN 40288 943 25 discussing discuss VBG 40288 943 26 , , , 40288 943 27 first first RB 40288 943 28 as as IN 40288 943 29 the the DT 40288 943 30 single single JJ 40288 943 31 octave octave NN 40288 943 32 from from IN 40288 943 33 the the DT 40288 943 34 original original JJ 40288 943 35 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 943 36 to to IN 40288 943 37 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 943 38 , , , 40288 943 39 then then RB 40288 943 40 in in IN 40288 943 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 943 42 enlarged enlarged JJ 40288 943 43 form form NN 40288 943 44 as as IN 40288 943 45 the the DT 40288 943 46 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 943 47 System System NNP 40288 943 48 , , , 40288 943 49 it -PRON- PRP 40288 943 50 may may MD 40288 943 51 be be VB 40288 943 52 worth worth JJ 40288 943 53 while while IN 40288 943 54 to to TO 40288 943 55 show show VB 40288 943 56 that that IN 40288 943 57 some some DT 40288 943 58 such such JJ 40288 943 59 scale scale NN 40288 943 60 is be VBZ 40288 943 61 implied imply VBN 40288 943 62 in in IN 40288 943 63 the the DT 40288 943 64 history history NN 40288 943 65 of of IN 40288 943 66 the the DT 40288 943 67 Greek greek JJ 40288 943 68 musical musical JJ 40288 943 69 notation notation NN 40288 943 70 . . . 40288 944 1 The the DT 40288 944 2 use use NN 40288 944 3 of of IN 40288 944 4 written write VBN 40288 944 5 characters character NNS 40288 944 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 944 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 944 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 944 9 : : : 40288 944 10 sêmeia sêmeia NNP 40288 944 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 944 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 944 13 to to TO 40288 944 14 represent represent VB 40288 944 15 the the DT 40288 944 16 sounds sound NNS 40288 944 17 of of IN 40288 944 18 music music NN 40288 944 19 appears appear VBZ 40288 944 20 to to IN 40288 944 21 date date NN 40288 944 22 from from IN 40288 944 23 a a DT 40288 944 24 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 944 25 early early JJ 40288 944 26 period period NN 40288 944 27 in in IN 40288 944 28 Greece Greece NNP 40288 944 29 . . . 40288 945 1 In in IN 40288 945 2 the the DT 40288 945 3 time time NN 40288 945 4 of of IN 40288 945 5 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 945 6 the the DT 40288 945 7 art art NN 40288 945 8 of of IN 40288 945 9 writing write VBG 40288 945 10 down down RP 40288 945 11 a a DT 40288 945 12 melody melody NN 40288 945 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 945 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 945 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 945 16 : : : 40288 945 17 parasêmantikê parasêmantikê NNS 40288 945 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 945 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 945 20 had have VBD 40288 945 21 come come VBN 40288 945 22 to to TO 40288 945 23 be be VB 40288 945 24 considered consider VBN 40288 945 25 by by IN 40288 945 26 some some DT 40288 945 27 persons person NNS 40288 945 28 identical identical JJ 40288 945 29 with with IN 40288 945 30 the the DT 40288 945 31 science science NN 40288 945 32 of of IN 40288 945 33 music music NN 40288 945 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 945 35 [ [ -LRB- 40288 945 36 Greek Greek NNP 40288 945 37 : : : 40288 945 38 harmonikê]),--an harmonikê]),--an NNS 40288 945 39 error error NN 40288 945 40 which which WDT 40288 945 41 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 945 42 is be VBZ 40288 945 43 at at IN 40288 945 44 some some DT 40288 945 45 pains pain NNS 40288 945 46 to to TO 40288 945 47 refute refute VB 40288 945 48 . . . 40288 946 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 946 2 is be VBZ 40288 946 3 true true JJ 40288 946 4 that that IN 40288 946 5 the the DT 40288 946 6 authorities authority NNS 40288 946 7 from from IN 40288 946 8 whom whom WP 40288 946 9 we -PRON- PRP 40288 946 10 derive derive VBP 40288 946 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 946 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40288 946 13 of of IN 40288 946 14 the the DT 40288 946 15 Greek greek JJ 40288 946 16 notation notation NN 40288 946 17 are be VBP 40288 946 18 post post JJ 40288 946 19 - - JJ 40288 946 20 classical classical JJ 40288 946 21 . . . 40288 947 1 But but CC 40288 947 2 the the DT 40288 947 3 characters character NNS 40288 947 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 40288 947 5 , , , 40288 947 6 as as IN 40288 947 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 947 8 shall shall MD 40288 947 9 presently presently RB 40288 947 10 see see VB 40288 947 11 , , , 40288 947 12 furnish furnish JJ 40288 947 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 40288 947 14 evidence evidence NN 40288 947 15 of of IN 40288 947 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 947 17 antiquity antiquity NN 40288 947 18 . . . 40288 948 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 948 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 948 3 1 1 CD 40288 948 4 : : : 40288 948 5 Ptol Ptol NNP 40288 948 6 . . . 40288 949 1 _ _ NNP 40288 949 2 Harm Harm NNP 40288 949 3 . . . 40288 949 4 _ _ NNP 40288 949 5 ii ii NNP 40288 949 6 . . . 40288 950 1 6 6 CD 40288 950 2 . . . 40288 951 1 After after IN 40288 951 2 drawing draw VBG 40288 951 3 a a DT 40288 951 4 distinction distinction NN 40288 951 5 between between IN 40288 951 6 difference difference NN 40288 951 7 of of IN 40288 951 8 key key NN 40288 951 9 as as IN 40288 951 10 affecting affect VBG 40288 951 11 the the DT 40288 951 12 whole whole NN 40288 951 13 of of IN 40288 951 14 a a DT 40288 951 15 melody melody NN 40288 951 16 or or CC 40288 951 17 piece piece NN 40288 951 18 of of IN 40288 951 19 music music NN 40288 951 20 and and CC 40288 951 21 as as IN 40288 951 22 a a DT 40288 951 23 means means NN 40288 951 24 of of IN 40288 951 25 change change NN 40288 951 26 in in IN 40288 951 27 the the DT 40288 951 28 course course NN 40288 951 29 of of IN 40288 951 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 951 31 -- -- : 40288 951 32 the the DT 40288 951 33 distinction distinction NN 40288 951 34 , , , 40288 951 35 in in IN 40288 951 36 short short JJ 40288 951 37 , , , 40288 951 38 between between IN 40288 951 39 transposition transposition NN 40288 951 40 and and CC 40288 951 41 modulation modulation NN 40288 951 42 proper proper JJ 40288 951 43 -- -- : 40288 951 44 he -PRON- PRP 40288 951 45 says say VBZ 40288 951 46 of of IN 40288 951 47 the the DT 40288 951 48 latter latter JJ 40288 951 49 : : : 40288 951 50 [ [ -LRB- 40288 951 51 Greek Greek NNP 40288 951 52 : : : 40288 951 53 hautê hautê NN 40288 951 54 de de NNP 40288 951 55 hôsper hôsper NNP 40288 951 56 ekpiptein ekpiptein NNP 40288 951 57 autên autên NN 40288 951 58 ] ] -RRB- 40288 951 59 ( ( -LRB- 40288 951 60 sc sc IN 40288 951 61 . . . 40288 952 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 952 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 952 3 : : : 40288 952 4 tên tên NNP 40288 952 5 aisthêsin aisthêsin NNP 40288 952 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 952 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 952 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 952 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 952 10 : : : 40288 952 11 poiei poiei NN 40288 952 12 tou tou NNP 40288 952 13 synêthous synêthous JJ 40288 952 14 kai kai NNP 40288 952 15 prosdokômenou prosdokômenou NNP 40288 952 16 melous melous JJ 40288 952 17 , , , 40288 952 18 hotan hotan NNP 40288 952 19 epi epi NNP 40288 952 20 pleon pleon NNP 40288 952 21 men man NNS 40288 952 22 syneirêtai syneirêtai NNP 40288 952 23 to to IN 40288 952 24 akolouthon akolouthon NNP 40288 952 25 , , , 40288 952 26 metabainê metabainê NNP 40288 952 27 de de NNP 40288 952 28 pê pê NNP 40288 952 29 pros pros NNP 40288 952 30 heteron heteron NNP 40288 952 31 eidos eidos NNP 40288 952 32 , , , 40288 952 33 êtoi êtoi NNP 40288 952 34 kata kata NNP 40288 952 35 to to IN 40288 952 36 genos genos NNP 40288 952 37 ê ê NNP 40288 952 38 kata kata NNP 40288 952 39 tên tên NNP 40288 952 40 tasin tasin NNP 40288 952 41 . . . 40288 952 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 953 1 That that DT 40288 953 2 is be VBZ 40288 953 3 to to TO 40288 953 4 say say VB 40288 953 5 , , , 40288 953 6 the the DT 40288 953 7 sense sense NN 40288 953 8 of of IN 40288 953 9 change change NN 40288 953 10 is be VBZ 40288 953 11 produced produce VBN 40288 953 12 by by IN 40288 953 13 a a DT 40288 953 14 change change NN 40288 953 15 of of IN 40288 953 16 genus genus NN 40288 953 17 or or CC 40288 953 18 of of IN 40288 953 19 pitch pitch NN 40288 953 20 . . . 40288 954 1 A a DT 40288 954 2 change change NN 40288 954 3 of of IN 40288 954 4 _ _ NNP 40288 954 5 species specie NNS 40288 954 6 _ _ NNP 40288 954 7 is be VBZ 40288 954 8 not not RB 40288 954 9 suggested suggest VBN 40288 954 10 . . . 40288 955 1 So so CC 40288 955 2 Dionys Dionys NNP 40288 955 3 . . . 40288 956 1 Hal hal UH 40288 956 2 . . . 40288 957 1 _ _ NNP 40288 957 2 De De NNP 40288 957 3 Comp Comp NNP 40288 957 4 . . . 40288 958 1 Verb Verb NNP 40288 958 2 . . . 40288 958 3 _ _ NNP 40288 958 4 c. c. NNP 40288 958 5 19 19 CD 40288 958 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 958 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 958 8 : : : 40288 958 9 hoi hoi NNP 40288 958 10 de de FW 40288 958 11 ge ge NNP 40288 958 12 dithyrambopoioi dithyrambopoioi NNP 40288 958 13 kai kai NNP 40288 958 14 tous tous NNP 40288 958 15 tropous tropous NNP 40288 958 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 958 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 958 18 keys key NNS 40288 958 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 958 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 958 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 958 22 : : : 40288 958 23 meteballon meteballon NN 40288 958 24 , , , 40288 958 25 Dôrikous dôrikous JJ 40288 958 26 te te NNP 40288 958 27 kai kai NNP 40288 958 28 Phrygious Phrygious NNP 40288 958 29 kai kai NNP 40288 958 30 Lydious Lydious NNP 40288 958 31 en en IN 40288 958 32 tô tô NNP 40288 958 33 autô autô NNP 40288 958 34 asmati asmati NNP 40288 958 35 poiountes poiounte NNS 40288 958 36 ; ; : 40288 958 37 kai kai NNP 40288 958 38 tas tas NNP 40288 958 39 melôdias melôdias NNP 40288 958 40 exêllatton exêllatton NNP 40288 958 41 , , , 40288 958 42 tote tote NNP 40288 958 43 men man NNS 40288 958 44 enarmonious enarmonious JJ 40288 958 45 poiountes poiounte NNS 40288 958 46 , , , 40288 958 47 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 958 48 . . . 40288 958 49 ] ] -RRB- 40288 958 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 959 1 The the DT 40288 959 2 Greek greek JJ 40288 959 3 musical musical JJ 40288 959 4 notation notation NN 40288 959 5 is be VBZ 40288 959 6 curiously curiously RB 40288 959 7 complicated complicate VBN 40288 959 8 . . . 40288 960 1 There there EX 40288 960 2 is be VBZ 40288 960 3 a a DT 40288 960 4 double double JJ 40288 960 5 set set NN 40288 960 6 of of IN 40288 960 7 characters character NNS 40288 960 8 , , , 40288 960 9 one one CD 40288 960 10 for for IN 40288 960 11 the the DT 40288 960 12 note note NN 40288 960 13 assigned assign VBN 40288 960 14 to to IN 40288 960 15 the the DT 40288 960 16 singer singer NN 40288 960 17 , , , 40288 960 18 the the DT 40288 960 19 other other JJ 40288 960 20 for for IN 40288 960 21 those those DT 40288 960 22 of of IN 40288 960 23 the the DT 40288 960 24 lyre lyre NN 40288 960 25 or or CC 40288 960 26 other other JJ 40288 960 27 instrument instrument NN 40288 960 28 . . . 40288 961 1 The the DT 40288 961 2 notes note NNS 40288 961 3 for for IN 40288 961 4 the the DT 40288 961 5 voice voice NN 40288 961 6 are be VBP 40288 961 7 obviously obviously RB 40288 961 8 derived derive VBN 40288 961 9 from from IN 40288 961 10 the the DT 40288 961 11 letters letter NNS 40288 961 12 of of IN 40288 961 13 the the DT 40288 961 14 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 961 15 Ionic ionic JJ 40288 961 16 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 961 17 , , , 40288 961 18 multiplied multiply VBN 40288 961 19 by by IN 40288 961 20 the the DT 40288 961 21 use use NN 40288 961 22 of of IN 40288 961 23 accents accent NNS 40288 961 24 and and CC 40288 961 25 other other JJ 40288 961 26 diacritical diacritical JJ 40288 961 27 marks mark NNS 40288 961 28 . . . 40288 962 1 The the DT 40288 962 2 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 962 3 notes note NNS 40288 962 4 were be VBD 40288 962 5 first first RB 40288 962 6 explained explain VBN 40288 962 7 less less JJR 40288 962 8 than than IN 40288 962 9 thirty thirty CD 40288 962 10 years year NNS 40288 962 11 ago ago RB 40288 962 12 by by IN 40288 962 13 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 962 14 . . . 40288 963 1 In in IN 40288 963 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 963 3 work work NN 40288 963 4 _ _ NNP 40288 963 5 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 963 6 und und NN 40288 963 7 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 963 8 der der NN 40288 963 9 Griechen Griechen NNP 40288 963 10 _ _ NNP 40288 963 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 963 12 c. c. NNP 40288 963 13 viii viii NNP 40288 963 14 _ _ NNP 40288 963 15 Die Die NNP 40288 963 16 Semantik Semantik NNP 40288 963 17 _ _ NNP 40288 963 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 963 19 he -PRON- PRP 40288 963 20 showed show VBD 40288 963 21 , , , 40288 963 22 in in IN 40288 963 23 a a DT 40288 963 24 manner manner NN 40288 963 25 as as RB 40288 963 26 conclusive conclusive JJ 40288 963 27 as as IN 40288 963 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 963 29 is be VBZ 40288 963 30 ingenious ingenious JJ 40288 963 31 , , , 40288 963 32 that that IN 40288 963 33 they -PRON- PRP 40288 963 34 were be VBD 40288 963 35 originally originally RB 40288 963 36 taken take VBN 40288 963 37 from from IN 40288 963 38 the the DT 40288 963 39 first first JJ 40288 963 40 fourteen fourteen CD 40288 963 41 letters letter NNS 40288 963 42 of of IN 40288 963 43 an an DT 40288 963 44 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 963 45 of of IN 40288 963 46 archaic archaic NN 40288 963 47 type type NN 40288 963 48 , , , 40288 963 49 akin akin JJ 40288 963 50 to to IN 40288 963 51 the the DT 40288 963 52 alphabets alphabet NNS 40288 963 53 found find VBN 40288 963 54 in in IN 40288 963 55 certain certain JJ 40288 963 56 parts part NNS 40288 963 57 of of IN 40288 963 58 Peloponnesus Peloponnesus NNP 40288 963 59 . . . 40288 964 1 Among among IN 40288 964 2 the the DT 40288 964 3 letters letter NNS 40288 964 4 which which WDT 40288 964 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 964 6 traces trace VBZ 40288 964 7 , , , 40288 964 8 and and CC 40288 964 9 which which WDT 40288 964 10 point point VBP 40288 964 11 to to IN 40288 964 12 this this DT 40288 964 13 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 964 14 , , , 40288 964 15 the the DT 40288 964 16 most most RBS 40288 964 17 - - HYPH 40288 964 18 significant significant JJ 40288 964 19 are be VBP 40288 964 20 the the DT 40288 964 21 digamma digamma NN 40288 964 22 , , , 40288 964 23 the the DT 40288 964 24 primitive primitive JJ 40288 964 25 crooked crooked JJ 40288 964 26 iota iota NNP 40288 964 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 964 28 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 964 29 : : : 40288 964 30 Li Li NNP 40288 964 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 964 32 , , , 40288 964 33 and and CC 40288 964 34 two two CD 40288 964 35 forms form NNS 40288 964 36 of of IN 40288 964 37 lambda lambda NN 40288 964 38 , , , 40288 964 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 964 40 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 964 41 : : : 40288 964 42 < < XX 40288 964 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 964 44 and and CC 40288 964 45 [ [ -LRB- 40288 964 46 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 964 47 : : : 40288 964 48 F f NN 40288 964 49 ] ] -RRB- 40288 964 50 , , , 40288 964 51 the the DT 40288 964 52 latter latter NN 40288 964 53 of of IN 40288 964 54 which which WDT 40288 964 55 is be VBZ 40288 964 56 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 964 57 to to IN 40288 964 58 the the DT 40288 964 59 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 964 60 of of IN 40288 964 61 Argos Argos NNP 40288 964 62 . . . 40288 965 1 Of of IN 40288 965 2 the the DT 40288 965 3 other other JJ 40288 965 4 characters character NNS 40288 965 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 965 6 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 965 7 : : : 40288 965 8 M m NN 40288 965 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 965 10 , , , 40288 965 11 which which WDT 40288 965 12 stands stand VBZ 40288 965 13 for for IN 40288 965 14 alpha alpha NN 40288 965 15 , , , 40288 965 16 is be VBZ 40288 965 17 best well RBS 40288 965 18 derived derive VBN 40288 965 19 from from IN 40288 965 20 the the DT 40288 965 21 archaic archaic NN 40288 965 22 form form NN 40288 965 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 965 24 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 965 25 : : : 40288 965 26 NJ NJ NNP 40288 965 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 965 28 . . . 40288 966 1 For for IN 40288 966 2 beta beta NN 40288 966 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 966 4 find find VBP 40288 966 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 966 6 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 966 7 : : : 40288 966 8 c c LS 40288 966 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 966 10 , , , 40288 966 11 which which WDT 40288 966 12 may may MD 40288 966 13 come come VB 40288 966 14 from from IN 40288 966 15 an an DT 40288 966 16 archaic archaic NN 40288 966 17 form form NN 40288 966 18 of of IN 40288 966 19 the the DT 40288 966 20 letter[1 letter[1 NNP 40288 966 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 966 22 . . . 40288 967 1 The the DT 40288 967 2 character character NN 40288 967 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 967 4 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 967 5 : : : 40288 967 6 El El NNP 40288 967 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 967 8 , , , 40288 967 9 as as IN 40288 967 10 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 967 11 shows show VBZ 40288 967 12 , , , 40288 967 13 is be VBZ 40288 967 14 for for IN 40288 967 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 967 16 Symbols:7 symbols:7 NN 40288 967 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 967 18 , , , 40288 967 19 or or CC 40288 967 20 delta delta NN 40288 967 21 with with IN 40288 967 22 part part NN 40288 967 23 of of IN 40288 967 24 one one CD 40288 967 25 side side NN 40288 967 26 left leave VBD 40288 967 27 out out RP 40288 967 28 . . . 40288 968 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 968 2 the the DT 40288 968 3 ancient ancient JJ 40288 968 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 968 5 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 968 6 : : : 40288 968 7 O o UH 40288 968 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 968 9 , , , 40288 968 10 when when WRB 40288 968 11 the the DT 40288 968 12 circle circle NN 40288 968 13 was be VBD 40288 968 14 incomplete incomplete JJ 40288 968 15 , , , 40288 968 16 yielded yield VBD 40288 968 17 the the DT 40288 968 18 character character NN 40288 968 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 968 20 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 968 21 : : : 40288 968 22 C C NNP 40288 968 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 968 24 . . . 40288 969 1 The the DT 40288 969 2 crooked crooked JJ 40288 969 3 iota iota NN 40288 969 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 969 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 969 6 Symbols:'-i Symbols:'-i NNP 40288 969 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 969 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 969 9 appears appear VBZ 40288 969 10 as as IN 40288 969 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 969 12 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 969 13 : : : 40288 969 14 h h LS 40288 969 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 969 16 . . . 40288 970 1 The the DT 40288 970 2 two two CD 40288 970 3 forms form NNS 40288 970 4 of of IN 40288 970 5 lambda lambda NN 40288 970 6 serve serve VBP 40288 970 7 for for IN 40288 970 8 different different JJ 40288 970 9 notes note NNS 40288 970 10 , , , 40288 970 11 thus thus RB 40288 970 12 bringing bring VBG 40288 970 13 the the DT 40288 970 14 number number NN 40288 970 15 of of IN 40288 970 16 symbols symbol NNS 40288 970 17 up up IN 40288 970 18 to to IN 40288 970 19 fifteen fifteen CD 40288 970 20 . . . 40288 971 1 Besides besides IN 40288 971 2 these these DT 40288 971 3 there there EX 40288 971 4 are be VBP 40288 971 5 two two CD 40288 971 6 characters character NNS 40288 971 7 , , , 40288 971 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 971 9 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 971 10 : : : 40288 971 11 O o UH 40288 971 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 971 13 and and CC 40288 971 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 971 15 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 971 16 : : : 40288 971 17 6 6 LS 40288 971 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 971 19 , , , 40288 971 20 which which WDT 40288 971 21 can can MD 40288 971 22 not not RB 40288 971 23 be be VB 40288 971 24 derived derive VBN 40288 971 25 in in IN 40288 971 26 the the DT 40288 971 27 same same JJ 40288 971 28 way way NN 40288 971 29 from from IN 40288 971 30 any any DT 40288 971 31 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 971 32 . . . 40288 972 1 As as IN 40288 972 2 they -PRON- PRP 40288 972 3 stand stand VBP 40288 972 4 for for IN 40288 972 5 the the DT 40288 972 6 lowest low JJS 40288 972 7 notes note NNS 40288 972 8 of of IN 40288 972 9 the the DT 40288 972 10 scale scale NN 40288 972 11 , , , 40288 972 12 they -PRON- PRP 40288 972 13 are be VBP 40288 972 14 probably probably RB 40288 972 15 an an DT 40288 972 16 addition addition NN 40288 972 17 , , , 40288 972 18 later later RB 40288 972 19 than than IN 40288 972 20 the the DT 40288 972 21 rest rest NN 40288 972 22 of of IN 40288 972 23 the the DT 40288 972 24 system system NN 40288 972 25 . . . 40288 973 1 At at IN 40288 973 2 the the DT 40288 973 3 upper upper JJ 40288 973 4 end end NN 40288 973 5 , , , 40288 973 6 again again RB 40288 973 7 , , , 40288 973 8 the the DT 40288 973 9 scale scale NN 40288 973 10 is be VBZ 40288 973 11 extended extend VBN 40288 973 12 by by IN 40288 973 13 the the DT 40288 973 14 simple simple JJ 40288 973 15 device device NN 40288 973 16 of of IN 40288 973 17 using use VBG 40288 973 18 the the DT 40288 973 19 same same JJ 40288 973 20 characters character NNS 40288 973 21 for for IN 40288 973 22 notes note NNS 40288 973 23 an an DT 40288 973 24 octave octave NN 40288 973 25 higher high JJR 40288 973 26 , , , 40288 973 27 distinguishing distinguish VBG 40288 973 28 them -PRON- PRP 40288 973 29 in in IN 40288 973 30 this this DT 40288 973 31 use use NN 40288 973 32 by by IN 40288 973 33 an an DT 40288 973 34 accent accent NN 40288 973 35 . . . 40288 974 1 The the DT 40288 974 2 original original JJ 40288 974 3 fifteen fifteen JJ 40288 974 4 characters character NNS 40288 974 5 , , , 40288 974 6 with with IN 40288 974 7 the the DT 40288 974 8 letters letter NNS 40288 974 9 from from IN 40288 974 10 which which WDT 40288 974 11 they -PRON- PRP 40288 974 12 are be VBP 40288 974 13 derived derive VBN 40288 974 14 , , , 40288 974 15 and and CC 40288 974 16 the the DT 40288 974 17 corresponding correspond VBG 40288 974 18 notes note NNS 40288 974 19 in in IN 40288 974 20 the the DT 40288 974 21 modern modern JJ 40288 974 22 musical musical JJ 40288 974 23 scale scale NN 40288 974 24 , , , 40288 974 25 are be VBP 40288 974 26 as as IN 40288 974 27 follows follow VBZ 40288 974 28 : : : 40288 974 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 974 30 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 974 31 : : : 40288 974 32 H h NN 40288 974 33 h h NN 40288 974 34 E e NN 40288 974 35 r r NN 40288 974 36 P p NN 40288 974 37 F F NNP 40288 974 38 C C NNP 40288 974 39 K K NNP 40288 974 40 r r NN 40288 974 41 l l NN 40288 974 42 < < XX 40288 974 43 E e NN 40288 974 44 N n NN 40288 974 45 Z z NN 40288 974 46 M m NN 40288 974 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 974 48 [ [ -LRB- 40288 974 49 Greek Greek NNP 40288 974 50 : : : 40288 974 51 ê ê NNP 40288 974 52 i i NN 40288 974 53 e e NNP 40288 974 54 l^1 l^1 NNP 40288 974 55 g g NN 40288 974 56 m m NNP 40288 974 57 [ [ -LRB- 40288 974 58 digamma digamma NN 40288 974 59 ] ] -RRB- 40288 974 60 th th NNP 40288 974 61 k k NNP 40288 974 62 d d NNP 40288 974 63 l^2 l^2 NNP 40288 974 64 b b NNP 40288 974 65 n n CC 40288 974 66 z z NNP 40288 974 67 a a NN 40288 974 68 ] ] -RRB- 40288 974 69 _ _ NNP 40288 974 70 a a DT 40288 974 71 b b NN 40288 974 72 c c NN 40288 974 73 d d NNP 40288 974 74 e e NNP 40288 974 75 f f NNP 40288 974 76 g g NNP 40288 974 77 a a DT 40288 974 78 b b NN 40288 974 79 c c NN 40288 974 80 d d NNP 40288 974 81 e e NNP 40288 974 82 f f NNP 40288 974 83 g g NNP 40288 974 84 a a DT 40288 974 85 _ _ NNP 40288 974 86 [ [ -LRB- 40288 974 87 Footnote Footnote NNP 40288 974 88 1 1 CD 40288 974 89 : : : 40288 974 90 Since since IN 40288 974 91 this this DT 40288 974 92 was be VBD 40288 974 93 written write VBN 40288 974 94 I -PRON- PRP 40288 974 95 have have VBP 40288 974 96 learned learn VBN 40288 974 97 from from IN 40288 974 98 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 974 99 H. H. NNP 40288 974 100 S. S. NNP 40288 974 101 Jones Jones NNP 40288 974 102 that that IN 40288 974 103 the the DT 40288 974 104 form form NN 40288 974 105 [ [ -LRB- 40288 974 106 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 974 107 : : : 40288 974 108 E e LS 40288 974 109 ] ] -RRB- 40288 974 110 for for IN 40288 974 111 beta beta NN 40288 974 112 occurs occur VBZ 40288 974 113 on on IN 40288 974 114 an an DT 40288 974 115 inscription inscription NN 40288 974 116 dated date VBN 40288 974 117 about about IN 40288 974 118 500 500 CD 40288 974 119 B.C. B.C. NNP 40288 974 120 , , , 40288 974 121 viz viz NN 40288 974 122 . . . 40288 975 1 Count Count NNP 40288 975 2 Tyszkiewicz Tyszkiewicz NNP 40288 975 3 's 's POS 40288 975 4 bronze bronze NN 40288 975 5 plate plate NN 40288 975 6 , , , 40288 975 7 published publish VBN 40288 975 8 simultaneously simultaneously RB 40288 975 9 by by IN 40288 975 10 Robert Robert NNP 40288 975 11 in in IN 40288 975 12 the the DT 40288 975 13 _ _ NNP 40288 975 14 Monumenti Monumenti NNP 40288 975 15 Antichi Antichi NNP 40288 975 16 pubblicati pubblicati RB 40288 975 17 per per IN 40288 975 18 cura cura FW 40288 975 19 della della NNP 40288 975 20 reale reale NNP 40288 975 21 Accademia Accademia NNP 40288 975 22 dei dei NNP 40288 975 23 Lincei Lincei NNP 40288 975 24 _ _ NNP 40288 975 25 , , , 40288 975 26 i. i. NNP 40288 975 27 pp pp NNP 40288 975 28 . . . 40288 976 1 593 593 CD 40288 976 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 976 3 with with IN 40288 976 4 plate plate NN 40288 976 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 976 6 , , , 40288 976 7 and and CC 40288 976 8 Fröhner Fröhner NNP 40288 976 9 in in IN 40288 976 10 the the DT 40288 976 11 _ _ NNP 40288 976 12 Revue Revue NNP 40288 976 13 Archéologique Archéologique NNP 40288 976 14 _ _ NNP 40288 976 15 , , , 40288 976 16 1891 1891 CD 40288 976 17 July July NNP 40288 976 18 - - HYPH 40288 976 19 August August NNP 40288 976 20 , , , 40288 976 21 pp pp NNP 40288 976 22 . . . 40288 977 1 51 51 CD 40288 977 2 ff ff NN 40288 977 3 . . . 40288 978 1 Pl Pl NNP 40288 978 2 . . . 40288 979 1 xix xix NNP 40288 979 2 . . . 40288 980 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 980 2 Jones Jones NNP 40288 980 3 points point VBZ 40288 980 4 out out RP 40288 980 5 that that IN 40288 980 6 this this DT 40288 980 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 980 8 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 980 9 : : : 40288 980 10 E e NN 40288 980 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 980 12 connects connect VBZ 40288 980 13 the the DT 40288 980 14 crescent crescent JJ 40288 980 15 beta beta NN 40288 980 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 980 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 980 18 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 980 19 : : : 40288 980 20 C C NNP 40288 980 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 980 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 980 23 of of IN 40288 980 24 Naxos Naxos NNP 40288 980 25 , , , 40288 980 26 Delos Delos NNP 40288 980 27 , , , 40288 980 28 & & CC 40288 980 29 c. c. NNP 40288 980 30 with with IN 40288 980 31 the the DT 40288 980 32 common common JJ 40288 980 33 form form NN 40288 980 34 , , , 40288 980 35 and and CC 40288 980 36 is be VBZ 40288 980 37 evidently evidently RB 40288 980 38 therefore therefore RB 40288 980 39 an an DT 40288 980 40 early early JJ 40288 980 41 form form NN 40288 980 42 of of IN 40288 980 43 the the DT 40288 980 44 letter letter NN 40288 980 45 . . . 40288 981 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 981 2 take take VBP 40288 981 3 this this DT 40288 981 4 opportunity opportunity NN 40288 981 5 of of IN 40288 981 6 thanking thank VBG 40288 981 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 981 8 Jones Jones NNP 40288 981 9 for for IN 40288 981 10 other other JJ 40288 981 11 help help NN 40288 981 12 , , , 40288 981 13 especially especially RB 40288 981 14 in in IN 40288 981 15 regard regard NN 40288 981 16 to to IN 40288 981 17 the the DT 40288 981 18 subject subject NN 40288 981 19 of of IN 40288 981 20 this this DT 40288 981 21 section section NN 40288 981 22 . . . 40288 981 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 982 1 These these DT 40288 982 2 notes note NNS 40288 982 3 , , , 40288 982 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 982 5 will will MD 40288 982 6 be be VB 40288 982 7 seen see VBN 40288 982 8 , , , 40288 982 9 compose compose VB 40288 982 10 two two CD 40288 982 11 octaves octave NNS 40288 982 12 of of IN 40288 982 13 the the DT 40288 982 14 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 982 15 scale scale NN 40288 982 16 , , , 40288 982 17 identical identical JJ 40288 982 18 with with IN 40288 982 19 the the DT 40288 982 20 two two CD 40288 982 21 octaves octave NNS 40288 982 22 of of IN 40288 982 23 the the DT 40288 982 24 Greater Greater NNP 40288 982 25 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 982 26 System System NNP 40288 982 27 . . . 40288 983 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 983 2 may may MD 40288 983 3 be be VB 40288 983 4 regarded regard VBN 40288 983 5 as as IN 40288 983 6 answering answer VBG 40288 983 7 to to IN 40288 983 8 the the DT 40288 983 9 white white JJ 40288 983 10 notes note NNS 40288 983 11 of of IN 40288 983 12 the the DT 40288 983 13 modern modern JJ 40288 983 14 keyboard,--those keyboard,--those NNP 40288 983 15 which which WDT 40288 983 16 form form VBP 40288 983 17 the the DT 40288 983 18 complete complete JJ 40288 983 19 scale scale NN 40288 983 20 in in IN 40288 983 21 the the DT 40288 983 22 so so RB 40288 983 23 - - HYPH 40288 983 24 called call VBN 40288 983 25 ' ' `` 40288 983 26 natural natural JJ 40288 983 27 ' ' '' 40288 983 28 key key NN 40288 983 29 . . . 40288 984 1 The the DT 40288 984 2 other other JJ 40288 984 3 notes note NNS 40288 984 4 , , , 40288 984 5 viz viz NN 40288 984 6 . . . 40288 985 1 those those DT 40288 985 2 which which WDT 40288 985 3 are be VBP 40288 985 4 required require VBN 40288 985 5 not not RB 40288 985 6 only only RB 40288 985 7 in in IN 40288 985 8 different different JJ 40288 985 9 keys key NNS 40288 985 10 of of IN 40288 985 11 the the DT 40288 985 12 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 985 13 scale scale NN 40288 985 14 , , , 40288 985 15 but but CC 40288 985 16 also also RB 40288 985 17 in in IN 40288 985 18 all all DT 40288 985 19 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 985 20 and and CC 40288 985 21 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 985 22 scales scale NNS 40288 985 23 , , , 40288 985 24 are be VBP 40288 985 25 represented represent VBN 40288 985 26 by by IN 40288 985 27 the the DT 40288 985 28 same same JJ 40288 985 29 characters character NNS 40288 985 30 modified modify VBN 40288 985 31 in in IN 40288 985 32 some some DT 40288 985 33 simple simple JJ 40288 985 34 way way NN 40288 985 35 . . . 40288 986 1 Usually usually RB 40288 986 2 a a DT 40288 986 3 character character NN 40288 986 4 is be VBZ 40288 986 5 turned turn VBN 40288 986 6 half half RB 40288 986 7 round round NN 40288 986 8 backwards backwards RB 40288 986 9 to to TO 40288 986 10 raise raise VB 40288 986 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 986 12 by by IN 40288 986 13 one one CD 40288 986 14 small small JJ 40288 986 15 interval interval NN 40288 986 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 986 17 as as IN 40288 986 18 from from IN 40288 986 19 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 986 20 to to IN 40288 986 21 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 986 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 986 23 , , , 40288 986 24 and and CC 40288 986 25 reversed reverse VBD 40288 986 26 to to TO 40288 986 27 raise raise VB 40288 986 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 986 29 by by IN 40288 986 30 both both DT 40288 986 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 986 32 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 986 33 to to TO 40288 986 34 Lichanos lichanos VB 40288 986 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 986 36 . . . 40288 987 1 Thus thus RB 40288 987 2 the the DT 40288 987 3 letter letter NN 40288 987 4 epsilon epsilon NN 40288 987 5 , , , 40288 987 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 7 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 987 8 : : : 40288 987 9 E e NN 40288 987 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 11 , , , 40288 987 12 stands stand VBZ 40288 987 13 for for IN 40288 987 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 987 15 _ _ NNP 40288 987 16 c c NNP 40288 987 17 _ _ NNP 40288 987 18 : : : 40288 987 19 and and CC 40288 987 20 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 987 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 22 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 987 23 : : : 40288 987 24 W w NN 40288 987 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 987 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 28 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 987 29 : : : 40288 987 30 E E NNS 40288 987 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 987 34 : : : 40288 987 35 anestrammenon anestrammenon NNP 40288 987 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 37 or or CC 40288 987 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 39 Greek greek JJ 40288 987 40 : : : 40288 987 41 hyption hyption NN 40288 987 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 987 44 stands stand VBZ 40288 987 45 for for IN 40288 987 46 _ _ NNP 40288 987 47 c c NNP 40288 987 48 * * NFP 40288 987 49 _ _ NNP 40288 987 50 , , , 40288 987 51 and and CC 40288 987 52 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 53 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 987 54 : : : 40288 987 55 3 3 LS 40288 987 56 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 57 ( ( -LRB- 40288 987 58 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 59 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 987 60 : : : 40288 987 61 E E NNS 40288 987 62 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 63 [ [ -LRB- 40288 987 64 Greek Greek NNP 40288 987 65 : : : 40288 987 66 apestrammenon apestrammenon NNP 40288 987 67 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 68 ) ) -RRB- 40288 987 69 for for IN 40288 987 70 _ _ NNP 40288 987 71 c[Symbols c[Symbols NNP 40288 987 72 : : : 40288 987 73 # # $ 40288 987 74 ] ] -RRB- 40288 987 75 _ _ NNP 40288 987 76 . . . 40288 988 1 The the DT 40288 988 2 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 988 3 scale scale NN 40288 988 4 _ _ NNP 40288 988 5 c c NN 40288 988 6 - - HYPH 40288 988 7 c*-c[Symbols c*-c[symbol NNS 40288 988 8 : : : 40288 988 9 # # $ 40288 988 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 988 11 -f -f : 40288 988 12 _ _ NNP 40288 988 13 is be VBZ 40288 988 14 therefore therefore RB 40288 988 15 written write VBN 40288 988 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 988 17 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 988 18 : : : 40288 988 19 E E NNP 40288 988 20 W w NN 40288 988 21 3 3 CD 40288 988 22 f f NN 40288 988 23 ' ' '' 40288 988 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 988 25 , , , 40288 988 26 the the DT 40288 988 27 two two CD 40288 988 28 modifications modification NNS 40288 988 29 of of IN 40288 988 30 the the DT 40288 988 31 letter letter NN 40288 988 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 988 33 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 988 34 : : : 40288 988 35 E e NN 40288 988 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 988 37 representing represent VBG 40288 988 38 the the DT 40288 988 39 two two CD 40288 988 40 ' ' `` 40288 988 41 moveable moveable JJ 40288 988 42 ' ' '' 40288 988 43 notes note NNS 40288 988 44 of of IN 40288 988 45 the the DT 40288 988 46 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 988 47 . . . 40288 989 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 989 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 989 3 have have VBP 40288 989 4 the the DT 40288 989 5 triads triad NNS 40288 989 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 989 7 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 989 8 : : : 40288 989 9 h h LS 40288 989 10 I -PRON- PRP 40288 989 11 rl rl VBP 40288 989 12 , , , 40288 989 13 F F NNP 40288 989 14 " " '' 40288 989 15 q q NNP 40288 989 16 , , , 40288 989 17 Cup Cup NNP 40288 989 18 , , , 40288 989 19 KY>1 KY>1 NNP 40288 989 20 , , , 40288 989 21 < < XX 40288 989 22 V V NNP 40288 989 23 > > XX 40288 989 24 , , , 40288 989 25 CUm CUm NNP 40288 989 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 989 27 . . . 40288 990 1 As as IN 40288 990 2 some some DT 40288 990 3 letters letter NNS 40288 990 4 do do VBP 40288 990 5 not not RB 40288 990 6 admit admit VB 40288 990 7 of of IN 40288 990 8 this this DT 40288 990 9 kind kind NN 40288 990 10 of of IN 40288 990 11 differentiation differentiation NN 40288 990 12 , , , 40288 990 13 other other JJ 40288 990 14 methods method NNS 40288 990 15 are be VBP 40288 990 16 employed employ VBN 40288 990 17 . . . 40288 991 1 Thus thus RB 40288 991 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 3 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 4 : : : 40288 991 5 D d NN 40288 991 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 7 is be VBZ 40288 991 8 made make VBN 40288 991 9 to to TO 40288 991 10 yield yield VB 40288 991 11 the the DT 40288 991 12 forms form NNS 40288 991 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 14 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 15 : : : 40288 991 16 ri ri LS 40288 991 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 991 19 for for IN 40288 991 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 21 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 22 : : : 40288 991 23 7 7 LS 40288 991 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 991 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 27 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 28 : : : 40288 991 29 L L NNP 40288 991 30 A A NNP 40288 991 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 32 : : : 40288 991 33 from from IN 40288 991 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 35 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 36 : : : 40288 991 37 H h NN 40288 991 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 39 ( ( -LRB- 40288 991 40 or or CC 40288 991 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 42 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 43 : : : 40288 991 44 B b NN 40288 991 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 46 ) ) -RRB- 40288 991 47 are be VBP 40288 991 48 obtained obtain VBN 40288 991 49 the the DT 40288 991 50 forms form NNS 40288 991 51 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 52 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 53 : : : 40288 991 54 Li Li NNP 40288 991 55 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 56 and and CC 40288 991 57 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 58 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 59 : : : 40288 991 60 R r NN 40288 991 61 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 62 : : : 40288 991 63 and and CC 40288 991 64 from from IN 40288 991 65 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 66 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 67 : : : 40288 991 68 Z z NN 40288 991 69 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 70 ( ( -LRB- 40288 991 71 or or CC 40288 991 72 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 73 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 74 : : : 40288 991 75 i i PRP 40288 991 76 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 77 ) ) -RRB- 40288 991 78 the the DT 40288 991 79 forms form NNS 40288 991 80 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 81 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 82 : : : 40288 991 83 A a NN 40288 991 84 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 85 and and CC 40288 991 86 [ [ -LRB- 40288 991 87 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 991 88 : : : 40288 991 89 A a NN 40288 991 90 ] ] -RRB- 40288 991 91 . . . 40288 992 1 The the DT 40288 992 2 modifications modification NNS 40288 992 3 of of IN 40288 992 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 992 5 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 992 6 : : : 40288 992 7 N n NN 40288 992 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 992 9 are be VBP 40288 992 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 992 11 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 992 12 : : : 40288 992 13 / / SYM 40288 992 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 992 15 and and CC 40288 992 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 992 17 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 992 18 : : : 40288 992 19 \ \ LS 40288 992 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 992 21 : : : 40288 992 22 those those DT 40288 992 23 of of IN 40288 992 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 992 25 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 992 26 : : : 40288 992 27 ' ' '' 40288 992 28 I -PRON- PRP 40288 992 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 992 30 are be VBP 40288 992 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 992 32 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 992 33 : : : 40288 992 34 A a NN 40288 992 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 992 36 and and CC 40288 992 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 992 38 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 992 39 : : : 40288 992 40 N n NN 40288 992 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 992 42 . . . 40288 993 1 The the DT 40288 993 2 method method NN 40288 993 3 of of IN 40288 993 4 writing write VBG 40288 993 5 a a DT 40288 993 6 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 993 7 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 993 8 is be VBZ 40288 993 9 the the DT 40288 993 10 same same JJ 40288 993 11 , , , 40288 993 12 except except IN 40288 993 13 that that IN 40288 993 14 the the DT 40288 993 15 higher high JJR 40288 993 16 of of IN 40288 993 17 the the DT 40288 993 18 two two CD 40288 993 19 moveable moveable JJ 40288 993 20 notes note NNS 40288 993 21 is be VBZ 40288 993 22 marked mark VBN 40288 993 23 by by IN 40288 993 24 a a DT 40288 993 25 bar bar NN 40288 993 26 or or CC 40288 993 27 accent accent NN 40288 993 28 . . . 40288 994 1 Thus thus RB 40288 994 2 the the DT 40288 994 3 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 994 4 _ _ NNP 40288 994 5 c c NNP 40288 994 6 c[Symbols c[symbols XX 40288 994 7 : : : 40288 994 8 # # NN 40288 994 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 994 10 d d NNP 40288 994 11 f f NNP 40288 994 12 _ _ NNP 40288 994 13 is be VBZ 40288 994 14 written write VBN 40288 994 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 994 16 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 994 17 : : : 40288 994 18 E E NNP 40288 994 19 W w NN 40288 994 20 3 3 CD 40288 994 21 ' ' '' 40288 994 22 / / : 40288 994 23 ` ` '' 40288 994 24 ' ' '' 40288 994 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 994 26 . . . 40288 995 1 In in IN 40288 995 2 the the DT 40288 995 3 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 995 4 genus genus NN 40288 995 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 995 6 should should MD 40288 995 7 have have VB 40288 995 8 expected expect VBN 40288 995 9 that that IN 40288 995 10 the the DT 40288 995 11 original original JJ 40288 995 12 characters character NNS 40288 995 13 would would MD 40288 995 14 have have VB 40288 995 15 been be VBN 40288 995 16 used use VBN 40288 995 17 for for IN 40288 995 18 the the DT 40288 995 19 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 995 20 _ _ NNP 40288 995 21 b b NNP 40288 995 22 c c NNP 40288 995 23 d d NNP 40288 995 24 e e NNP 40288 995 25 _ _ NNP 40288 995 26 and and CC 40288 995 27 _ _ NNP 40288 995 28 e e NNP 40288 995 29 f f NNP 40288 995 30 g g NNP 40288 995 31 a a DT 40288 995 32 _ _ NNP 40288 995 33 ; ; : 40288 995 34 and and CC 40288 995 35 that that IN 40288 995 36 in in IN 40288 995 37 other other JJ 40288 995 38 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 995 39 the the DT 40288 995 40 second second JJ 40288 995 41 note note NN 40288 995 42 , , , 40288 995 43 being be VBG 40288 995 44 a a DT 40288 995 45 semitone semitone NN 40288 995 46 above above IN 40288 995 47 the the DT 40288 995 48 first first JJ 40288 995 49 , , , 40288 995 50 would would MD 40288 995 51 have have VB 40288 995 52 been be VBN 40288 995 53 represented represent VBN 40288 995 54 by by IN 40288 995 55 a a DT 40288 995 56 reversed reversed JJ 40288 995 57 letter letter NN 40288 995 58 ( ( -LRB- 40288 995 59 [ [ -LRB- 40288 995 60 Greek Greek NNP 40288 995 61 : : : 40288 995 62 gramma gramma NNP 40288 995 63 apestrammenon apestrammenon NN 40288 995 64 ] ] -RRB- 40288 995 65 ) ) -RRB- 40288 995 66 . . . 40288 996 1 In in IN 40288 996 2 fact fact NN 40288 996 3 , , , 40288 996 4 however however RB 40288 996 5 , , , 40288 996 6 the the DT 40288 996 7 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 996 8 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 996 9 and and CC 40288 996 10 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 996 11 are be VBP 40288 996 12 written write VBN 40288 996 13 with with IN 40288 996 14 the the DT 40288 996 15 same same JJ 40288 996 16 character character NN 40288 996 17 as as IN 40288 996 18 the the DT 40288 996 19 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 996 20 . . . 40288 997 1 That that DT 40288 997 2 is be VBZ 40288 997 3 to to TO 40288 997 4 say say VB 40288 997 5 , , , 40288 997 6 the the DT 40288 997 7 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 997 8 _ _ NNP 40288 997 9 b b NNP 40288 997 10 c c NNP 40288 997 11 d d NNP 40288 997 12 e e NNP 40288 997 13 _ _ NNP 40288 997 14 is be VBZ 40288 997 15 not not RB 40288 997 16 written write VBN 40288 997 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 997 18 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 997 19 : : : 40288 997 20 h h LS 40288 997 21 E e NN 40288 997 22 H h NN 40288 997 23 r r NN 40288 997 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 997 25 , , , 40288 997 26 but but CC 40288 997 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 997 28 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 997 29 : : : 40288 997 30 Fix Fix NNP 40288 997 31 I I NNP 40288 997 32 - - HYPH 40288 997 33 r r NNP 40288 997 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 997 35 : : : 40288 997 36 and and CC 40288 997 37 _ _ NNP 40288 997 38 d d NNP 40288 997 39 e[Symbols e[symbols ADD 40288 997 40 : : : 40288 997 41 b b LS 40288 997 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 997 43 f f NNP 40288 997 44 g g NNP 40288 997 45 _ _ NNP 40288 997 46 is be VBZ 40288 997 47 not not RB 40288 997 48 [ [ -LRB- 40288 997 49 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 997 50 : : : 40288 997 51 I -PRON- PRP 40288 997 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 997 53 , , , 40288 997 54 but but CC 40288 997 55 [ [ -LRB- 40288 997 56 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 997 57 : : : 40288 997 58 I -PRON- PRP 40288 997 59 - - HYPH 40288 997 60 tl tl NNP 40288 997 61 F f NN 40288 997 62 ] ] -RRB- 40288 997 63 . . . 40288 998 1 Let let VB 40288 998 2 us -PRON- PRP 40288 998 3 now now RB 40288 998 4 consider consider VB 40288 998 5 how how WRB 40288 998 6 this this DT 40288 998 7 scheme scheme NN 40288 998 8 of of IN 40288 998 9 symbols symbol NNS 40288 998 10 is be VBZ 40288 998 11 related relate VBN 40288 998 12 to to IN 40288 998 13 the the DT 40288 998 14 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 998 15 already already RB 40288 998 16 described describe VBN 40288 998 17 and and CC 40288 998 18 the the DT 40288 998 19 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 998 20 in in IN 40288 998 21 which which WDT 40288 998 22 those those DT 40288 998 23 Systems system NNS 40288 998 24 may may MD 40288 998 25 be be VB 40288 998 26 set set VBN 40288 998 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 998 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 998 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 998 30 : : : 40288 998 31 tonoi tonoi NNP 40288 998 32 eph eph NNP 40288 998 33 ' ' POS 40288 998 34 hôn hôn NNP 40288 998 35 tithemena tithemena NNP 40288 998 36 ta ta NNP 40288 998 37 systêmata systêmata NNP 40288 998 38 melôdeitai melôdeitai NNP 40288 998 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 998 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 998 41 . . . 40288 999 1 The the DT 40288 999 2 fifteen fifteen CD 40288 999 3 characters character NNS 40288 999 4 , , , 40288 999 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 999 6 has have VBZ 40288 999 7 been be VBN 40288 999 8 noticed notice VBN 40288 999 9 , , , 40288 999 10 form form VB 40288 999 11 two two CD 40288 999 12 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 999 13 octaves octave NNS 40288 999 14 . . . 40288 1000 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1000 2 will will MD 40288 1000 3 appear appear VB 40288 1000 4 on on IN 40288 1000 5 a a DT 40288 1000 6 little little JJ 40288 1000 7 further further JJ 40288 1000 8 examination examination NN 40288 1000 9 that that IN 40288 1000 10 the the DT 40288 1000 11 scheme scheme NN 40288 1000 12 must must MD 40288 1000 13 have have VB 40288 1000 14 been be VBN 40288 1000 15 constructed construct VBN 40288 1000 16 with with IN 40288 1000 17 a a DT 40288 1000 18 view view NN 40288 1000 19 to to IN 40288 1000 20 these these DT 40288 1000 21 two two CD 40288 1000 22 octaves octave NNS 40288 1000 23 . . . 40288 1001 1 The the DT 40288 1001 2 successive successive JJ 40288 1001 3 notes note NNS 40288 1001 4 are be VBP 40288 1001 5 not not RB 40288 1001 6 expressed express VBN 40288 1001 7 by by IN 40288 1001 8 the the DT 40288 1001 9 letters letter NNS 40288 1001 10 of of IN 40288 1001 11 the the DT 40288 1001 12 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1001 13 in in IN 40288 1001 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1001 15 usual usual JJ 40288 1001 16 order order NN 40288 1001 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1001 18 as as IN 40288 1001 19 is be VBZ 40288 1001 20 done do VBN 40288 1001 21 in in IN 40288 1001 22 the the DT 40288 1001 23 case case NN 40288 1001 24 of of IN 40288 1001 25 the the DT 40288 1001 26 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1001 27 notes note NNS 40288 1001 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1001 29 . . . 40288 1002 1 The the DT 40288 1002 2 highest high JJS 40288 1002 3 note note NN 40288 1002 4 is be VBZ 40288 1002 5 represented represent VBN 40288 1002 6 by by IN 40288 1002 7 the the DT 40288 1002 8 first first JJ 40288 1002 9 letter letter NN 40288 1002 10 , , , 40288 1002 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1002 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1002 13 : : : 40288 1002 14 A a NN 40288 1002 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1002 16 : : : 40288 1002 17 and and CC 40288 1002 18 then then RB 40288 1002 19 the the DT 40288 1002 20 remaining remain VBG 40288 1002 21 fourteen fourteen CD 40288 1002 22 notes note NNS 40288 1002 23 are be VBP 40288 1002 24 taken take VBN 40288 1002 25 in in IN 40288 1002 26 pairs pair NNS 40288 1002 27 , , , 40288 1002 28 each each DT 40288 1002 29 with with IN 40288 1002 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1002 31 octave octave NN 40288 1002 32 : : : 40288 1002 33 and and CC 40288 1002 34 each each DT 40288 1002 35 of of IN 40288 1002 36 the the DT 40288 1002 37 pairs pair NNS 40288 1002 38 of of IN 40288 1002 39 notes note NNS 40288 1002 40 is be VBZ 40288 1002 41 represented represent VBN 40288 1002 42 by by IN 40288 1002 43 two two CD 40288 1002 44 successive successive JJ 40288 1002 45 letters letter NNS 40288 1002 46 -- -- : 40288 1002 47 the the DT 40288 1002 48 two two CD 40288 1002 49 forms form NNS 40288 1002 50 of of IN 40288 1002 51 lambda lambda NN 40288 1002 52 counting counting NN 40288 1002 53 as as IN 40288 1002 54 one one CD 40288 1002 55 such such JJ 40288 1002 56 pair pair NN 40288 1002 57 of of IN 40288 1002 58 letters letter NNS 40288 1002 59 . . . 40288 1003 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1003 2 : : : 40288 1003 3 The the DT 40288 1003 4 higher high JJR 40288 1003 5 and and CC 40288 1003 6 lower low JJR 40288 1003 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 8 e e NNP 40288 1003 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 10 are be VBP 40288 1003 11 denoted denote VBN 40288 1003 12 by by IN 40288 1003 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 15 : : : 40288 1003 16 b b LS 40288 1003 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 18 and and CC 40288 1003 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 21 : : : 40288 1003 22 g g LS 40288 1003 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 24 " " `` 40288 1003 25 " " '' 40288 1003 26 " " '' 40288 1003 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 28 c c NNP 40288 1003 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 30 " " '' 40288 1003 31 " " '' 40288 1003 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 34 : : : 40288 1003 35 d d LS 40288 1003 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 37 " " `` 40288 1003 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 39 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 40 : : : 40288 1003 41 e e LS 40288 1003 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 43 " " `` 40288 1003 44 " " '' 40288 1003 45 " " '' 40288 1003 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 47 g g NNP 40288 1003 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 49 " " '' 40288 1003 50 " " `` 40288 1003 51 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 52 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1003 53 : : : 40288 1003 54 digamma digamma NN 40288 1003 55 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 56 " " `` 40288 1003 57 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 58 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 59 : : : 40288 1003 60 z z LS 40288 1003 61 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 62 " " `` 40288 1003 63 " " '' 40288 1003 64 " " '' 40288 1003 65 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 66 a a DT 40288 1003 67 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 68 " " '' 40288 1003 69 " " '' 40288 1003 70 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 71 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 72 : : : 40288 1003 73 ê ê NN 40288 1003 74 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 75 " " `` 40288 1003 76 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 77 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 78 : : : 40288 1003 79 th th XX 40288 1003 80 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 81 " " `` 40288 1003 82 " " '' 40288 1003 83 " " '' 40288 1003 84 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 85 b b NNP 40288 1003 86 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 87 " " '' 40288 1003 88 " " `` 40288 1003 89 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 90 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 91 : : : 40288 1003 92 i i PRP 40288 1003 93 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 94 " " `` 40288 1003 95 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 96 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 97 : : : 40288 1003 98 k k LS 40288 1003 99 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 100 " " `` 40288 1003 101 " " '' 40288 1003 102 " " '' 40288 1003 103 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 104 d d NNP 40288 1003 105 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 106 " " '' 40288 1003 107 " " `` 40288 1003 108 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 109 Greek greek JJ 40288 1003 110 : : : 40288 1003 111 l^1 l^1 NNP 40288 1003 112 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 113 " " `` 40288 1003 114 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 115 Greek greek JJ 40288 1003 116 : : : 40288 1003 117 l^2 l^2 ADD 40288 1003 118 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 119 " " `` 40288 1003 120 " " '' 40288 1003 121 " " '' 40288 1003 122 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 123 f f NNP 40288 1003 124 _ _ NNP 40288 1003 125 " " '' 40288 1003 126 " " `` 40288 1003 127 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 128 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1003 129 : : : 40288 1003 130 m m LS 40288 1003 131 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 132 " " `` 40288 1003 133 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1003 134 Greek greek JJ 40288 1003 135 : : : 40288 1003 136 n n LS 40288 1003 137 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1003 138 On on IN 40288 1003 139 this this DT 40288 1003 140 plan plan NN 40288 1003 141 the the DT 40288 1003 142 alphabetical alphabetical JJ 40288 1003 143 order order NN 40288 1003 144 of of IN 40288 1003 145 the the DT 40288 1003 146 letters letter NNS 40288 1003 147 serves serve VBZ 40288 1003 148 as as IN 40288 1003 149 a a DT 40288 1003 150 series series NN 40288 1003 151 of of IN 40288 1003 152 links link NNS 40288 1003 153 connecting connect VBG 40288 1003 154 the the DT 40288 1003 155 highest high JJS 40288 1003 156 and and CC 40288 1003 157 lowest low JJS 40288 1003 158 notes note NNS 40288 1003 159 of of IN 40288 1003 160 every every DT 40288 1003 161 one one CD 40288 1003 162 of of IN 40288 1003 163 the the DT 40288 1003 164 seven seven CD 40288 1003 165 octaves octave NNS 40288 1003 166 that that WDT 40288 1003 167 can can MD 40288 1003 168 be be VB 40288 1003 169 taken take VBN 40288 1003 170 on on IN 40288 1003 171 the the DT 40288 1003 172 scale scale NN 40288 1003 173 . . . 40288 1004 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1004 2 is be VBZ 40288 1004 3 evident evident JJ 40288 1004 4 that that IN 40288 1004 5 the the DT 40288 1004 6 scheme scheme NN 40288 1004 7 can can MD 40288 1004 8 not not RB 40288 1004 9 have have VB 40288 1004 10 grown grow VBN 40288 1004 11 up up RP 40288 1004 12 by by IN 40288 1004 13 degrees degree NNS 40288 1004 14 , , , 40288 1004 15 but but CC 40288 1004 16 is be VBZ 40288 1004 17 the the DT 40288 1004 18 work work NN 40288 1004 19 of of IN 40288 1004 20 an an DT 40288 1004 21 inventor inventor NN 40288 1004 22 who who WP 40288 1004 23 contrived contrive VBD 40288 1004 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1004 25 for for IN 40288 1004 26 the the DT 40288 1004 27 practical practical JJ 40288 1004 28 requirements requirement NNS 40288 1004 29 of of IN 40288 1004 30 the the DT 40288 1004 31 music music NN 40288 1004 32 of of IN 40288 1004 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1004 34 time time NN 40288 1004 35 . . . 40288 1005 1 Two two CD 40288 1005 2 questions question NNS 40288 1005 3 now now RB 40288 1005 4 arise arise VBP 40288 1005 5 , , , 40288 1005 6 which which WDT 40288 1005 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1005 8 is be VBZ 40288 1005 9 impossible impossible JJ 40288 1005 10 to to TO 40288 1005 11 separate separate VB 40288 1005 12 . . . 40288 1006 1 What what WP 40288 1006 2 is be VBZ 40288 1006 3 the the DT 40288 1006 4 scale scale NN 40288 1006 5 or or CC 40288 1006 6 System system NN 40288 1006 7 for for IN 40288 1006 8 which which WDT 40288 1006 9 the the DT 40288 1006 10 notation notation NN 40288 1006 11 was be VBD 40288 1006 12 originally originally RB 40288 1006 13 devised devise VBN 40288 1006 14 ? ? . 40288 1007 1 And and CC 40288 1007 2 how how WRB 40288 1007 3 and and CC 40288 1007 4 when when WRB 40288 1007 5 was be VBD 40288 1007 6 the the DT 40288 1007 7 notation notation NN 40288 1007 8 adapted adapt VBN 40288 1007 9 to to TO 40288 1007 10 exhibit exhibit VB 40288 1007 11 the the DT 40288 1007 12 several several JJ 40288 1007 13 keys key NNS 40288 1007 14 in in IN 40288 1007 15 which which WDT 40288 1007 16 any any DT 40288 1007 17 such such JJ 40288 1007 18 System system NN 40288 1007 19 might may MD 40288 1007 20 be be VB 40288 1007 21 set set VBN 40288 1007 22 ? ? . 40288 1008 1 The the DT 40288 1008 2 enquiry enquiry NN 40288 1008 3 must must MD 40288 1008 4 start start VB 40288 1008 5 from from IN 40288 1008 6 the the DT 40288 1008 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 40288 1008 8 fact fact NN 40288 1008 9 that that IN 40288 1008 10 the the DT 40288 1008 11 two two CD 40288 1008 12 octaves octave NNS 40288 1008 13 represented represent VBN 40288 1008 14 by by IN 40288 1008 15 the the DT 40288 1008 16 fifteen fifteen CD 40288 1008 17 original original JJ 40288 1008 18 letters letter NNS 40288 1008 19 are be VBP 40288 1008 20 in in IN 40288 1008 21 the the DT 40288 1008 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1008 23 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1008 24 - - HYPH 40288 1008 25 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1008 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1008 27 key key NN 40288 1008 28 -- -- : 40288 1008 29 the the DT 40288 1008 30 key key NN 40288 1008 31 which which WDT 40288 1008 32 down down RB 40288 1008 33 to to IN 40288 1008 34 the the DT 40288 1008 35 time time NN 40288 1008 36 of of IN 40288 1008 37 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1008 38 was be VBD 40288 1008 39 called call VBN 40288 1008 40 the the DT 40288 1008 41 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1008 42 - - HYPH 40288 1008 43 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1008 44 . . . 40288 1009 1 Are be VBP 40288 1009 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1009 3 to to TO 40288 1009 4 suppose suppose VB 40288 1009 5 that that IN 40288 1009 6 the the DT 40288 1009 7 scheme scheme NN 40288 1009 8 was be VBD 40288 1009 9 devised devise VBN 40288 1009 10 in in IN 40288 1009 11 the the DT 40288 1009 12 first first JJ 40288 1009 13 instance instance NN 40288 1009 14 for for IN 40288 1009 15 that that DT 40288 1009 16 key key NN 40288 1009 17 only only RB 40288 1009 18 ? ? . 40288 1010 1 This this DT 40288 1010 2 assumption assumption NN 40288 1010 3 forms form VBZ 40288 1010 4 the the DT 40288 1010 5 basis basis NN 40288 1010 6 of of IN 40288 1010 7 the the DT 40288 1010 8 ingenious ingenious JJ 40288 1010 9 and and CC 40288 1010 10 elaborate elaborate JJ 40288 1010 11 theory theory NN 40288 1010 12 by by IN 40288 1010 13 which which WDT 40288 1010 14 M. M. NNP 40288 1010 15 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 1010 16 explains explain VBZ 40288 1010 17 the the DT 40288 1010 18 development development NN 40288 1010 19 of of IN 40288 1010 20 the the DT 40288 1010 21 notation notation NN 40288 1010 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1010 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1010 24 Musique Musique NNP 40288 1010 25 de de NNP 40288 1010 26 l'Antiquité l'Antiquité NNP 40288 1010 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1010 28 , , , 40288 1010 29 t. t. NNP 40288 1010 30 I. I. NNP 40288 1010 31 pp pp NNP 40288 1010 32 . . . 40288 1011 1 244 244 CD 40288 1011 2 ff ff NNS 40288 1011 3 . . . 40288 1011 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1011 5 . . . 40288 1012 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1012 2 is be VBZ 40288 1012 3 open open JJ 40288 1012 4 to to IN 40288 1012 5 the the DT 40288 1012 6 obvious obvious JJ 40288 1012 7 objection objection NN 40288 1012 8 that that WDT 40288 1012 9 the the DT 40288 1012 10 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1012 11 - - HYPH 40288 1012 12 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1012 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1012 14 or or CC 40288 1012 15 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1012 16 - - HYPH 40288 1012 17 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1012 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1012 19 can can MD 40288 1012 20 not not RB 40288 1012 21 have have VB 40288 1012 22 been be VBN 40288 1012 23 the the DT 40288 1012 24 oldest old JJS 40288 1012 25 key key NN 40288 1012 26 . . . 40288 1013 1 M. M. NNP 40288 1013 2 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 1013 3 meets meet VBZ 40288 1013 4 this this DT 40288 1013 5 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 1013 6 by by IN 40288 1013 7 supposing suppose VBG 40288 1013 8 that that IN 40288 1013 9 the the DT 40288 1013 10 original original JJ 40288 1013 11 scale scale NN 40288 1013 12 was be VBD 40288 1013 13 in in IN 40288 1013 14 the the DT 40288 1013 15 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1013 16 key key NN 40288 1013 17 , , , 40288 1013 18 and and CC 40288 1013 19 that that IN 40288 1013 20 subsequently subsequently RB 40288 1013 21 , , , 40288 1013 22 from from IN 40288 1013 23 some some DT 40288 1013 24 cause cause NN 40288 1013 25 the the DT 40288 1013 26 nature nature NN 40288 1013 27 of of IN 40288 1013 28 which which WDT 40288 1013 29 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1013 30 can can MD 40288 1013 31 not not RB 40288 1013 32 guess guess VB 40288 1013 33 , , , 40288 1013 34 a a DT 40288 1013 35 change change NN 40288 1013 36 of of IN 40288 1013 37 pitch pitch NN 40288 1013 38 took take VBD 40288 1013 39 place place NN 40288 1013 40 by by IN 40288 1013 41 which which WDT 40288 1013 42 the the DT 40288 1013 43 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1013 44 scale scale NN 40288 1013 45 became become VBD 40288 1013 46 a a DT 40288 1013 47 semitone semitone NN 40288 1013 48 higher higher RBR 40288 1013 49 . . . 40288 1014 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1014 2 is be VBZ 40288 1014 3 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 1014 4 simpler simple JJR 40288 1014 5 to to TO 40288 1014 6 conjecture conjecture VB 40288 1014 7 that that IN 40288 1014 8 the the DT 40288 1014 9 original original JJ 40288 1014 10 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1014 11 became become VBD 40288 1014 12 split split VBN 40288 1014 13 up up RP 40288 1014 14 , , , 40288 1014 15 so so RB 40288 1014 16 to to TO 40288 1014 17 speak speak VB 40288 1014 18 , , , 40288 1014 19 into into IN 40288 1014 20 two two CD 40288 1014 21 keys key NNS 40288 1014 22 by by IN 40288 1014 23 difference difference NN 40288 1014 24 of of IN 40288 1014 25 local local JJ 40288 1014 26 usage usage NN 40288 1014 27 , , , 40288 1014 28 and and CC 40288 1014 29 that that IN 40288 1014 30 the the DT 40288 1014 31 lower low JJR 40288 1014 32 of of IN 40288 1014 33 the the DT 40288 1014 34 two two CD 40288 1014 35 came come VBD 40288 1014 36 to to TO 40288 1014 37 be be VB 40288 1014 38 called call VBN 40288 1014 39 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1014 40 - - HYPH 40288 1014 41 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1014 42 , , , 40288 1014 43 but but CC 40288 1014 44 kept keep VBD 40288 1014 45 the the DT 40288 1014 46 original original JJ 40288 1014 47 notation notation NN 40288 1014 48 . . . 40288 1015 1 A a DT 40288 1015 2 more more RBR 40288 1015 3 serious serious JJ 40288 1015 4 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 1015 5 is be VBZ 40288 1015 6 raised raise VBN 40288 1015 7 by by IN 40288 1015 8 the the DT 40288 1015 9 high high JJ 40288 1015 10 antiquity antiquity NN 40288 1015 11 which which WDT 40288 1015 12 M. M. NNP 40288 1015 13 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 1015 14 assigns assign VBZ 40288 1015 15 to to IN 40288 1015 16 the the DT 40288 1015 17 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1015 18 System System NNP 40288 1015 19 . . . 40288 1016 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1016 2 supposes suppose VBZ 40288 1016 3 that that IN 40288 1016 4 the the DT 40288 1016 5 inventor inventor NN 40288 1016 6 of of IN 40288 1016 7 the the DT 40288 1016 8 notation notation NN 40288 1016 9 made make VBD 40288 1016 10 use use NN 40288 1016 11 of of IN 40288 1016 12 an an DT 40288 1016 13 instrument instrument NN 40288 1016 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1016 15 the the DT 40288 1016 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1016 17 magadis magadis NNP 40288 1016 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1016 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1016 20 which which WDT 40288 1016 21 ' ' `` 40288 1016 22 magadised magadise VBD 40288 1016 23 ' ' '' 40288 1016 24 or or CC 40288 1016 25 repeated repeat VBD 40288 1016 26 the the DT 40288 1016 27 notes note NNS 40288 1016 28 an an DT 40288 1016 29 octave octave NN 40288 1016 30 higher high JJR 40288 1016 31 . . . 40288 1017 1 But but CC 40288 1017 2 this this DT 40288 1017 3 would would MD 40288 1017 4 give give VB 40288 1017 5 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1017 6 a a DT 40288 1017 7 repetition repetition NN 40288 1017 8 of of IN 40288 1017 9 the the DT 40288 1017 10 primitive primitive JJ 40288 1017 11 octave octave NN 40288 1017 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1017 13 e e NNP 40288 1017 14 - - HYPH 40288 1017 15 e e NNP 40288 1017 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1017 17 , , , 40288 1017 18 rather rather RB 40288 1017 19 than than IN 40288 1017 20 an an DT 40288 1017 21 enlargement enlargement NN 40288 1017 22 by by IN 40288 1017 23 the the DT 40288 1017 24 addition addition NN 40288 1017 25 of of IN 40288 1017 26 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1017 27 at at IN 40288 1017 28 both both DT 40288 1017 29 ends end NNS 40288 1017 30 . . . 40288 1018 1 M. M. NNP 40288 1018 2 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 1018 3 regards regard VBZ 40288 1018 4 the the DT 40288 1018 5 adaptation adaptation NN 40288 1018 6 of of IN 40288 1018 7 the the DT 40288 1018 8 scheme scheme NN 40288 1018 9 to to IN 40288 1018 10 the the DT 40288 1018 11 other other JJ 40288 1018 12 keys key NNS 40288 1018 13 as as IN 40288 1018 14 the the DT 40288 1018 15 result result NN 40288 1018 16 of of IN 40288 1018 17 a a DT 40288 1018 18 gradual gradual JJ 40288 1018 19 process process NN 40288 1018 20 of of IN 40288 1018 21 extension extension NN 40288 1018 22 . . . 40288 1019 1 Here here RB 40288 1019 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1019 3 may may MD 40288 1019 4 distinguish distinguish VB 40288 1019 5 between between IN 40288 1019 6 the the DT 40288 1019 7 recourse recourse NN 40288 1019 8 to to IN 40288 1019 9 the the DT 40288 1019 10 modified modify VBN 40288 1019 11 characters character NNS 40288 1019 12 -- -- : 40288 1019 13 which which WDT 40288 1019 14 served serve VBD 40288 1019 15 essentially essentially RB 40288 1019 16 the the DT 40288 1019 17 same same JJ 40288 1019 18 purpose purpose NN 40288 1019 19 as as IN 40288 1019 20 the the DT 40288 1019 21 ' ' `` 40288 1019 22 sharps sharps NN 40288 1019 23 ' ' '' 40288 1019 24 and and CC 40288 1019 25 ' ' `` 40288 1019 26 flats flat NNS 40288 1019 27 ' ' '' 40288 1019 28 in in IN 40288 1019 29 the the DT 40288 1019 30 signature signature NN 40288 1019 31 of of IN 40288 1019 32 a a DT 40288 1019 33 modern modern JJ 40288 1019 34 key key NN 40288 1019 35 -- -- : 40288 1019 36 and and CC 40288 1019 37 the the DT 40288 1019 38 additional additional JJ 40288 1019 39 notes note NNS 40288 1019 40 obtained obtain VBD 40288 1019 41 either either CC 40288 1019 42 by by IN 40288 1019 43 means mean NNS 40288 1019 44 of of IN 40288 1019 45 new new JJ 40288 1019 46 characters character NNS 40288 1019 47 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1019 48 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1019 49 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1019 50 : : : 40288 1019 51 a a LS 40288 1019 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1019 53 and and CC 40288 1019 54 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1019 55 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1019 56 : : : 40288 1019 57 e e LS 40288 1019 58 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1019 59 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1019 60 , , , 40288 1019 61 or or CC 40288 1019 62 by by IN 40288 1019 63 the the DT 40288 1019 64 use use NN 40288 1019 65 of of IN 40288 1019 66 accents accent NNS 40288 1019 67 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1019 68 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1019 69 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1019 70 : : : 40288 1019 71 ? ? . 40288 1020 1 ' ' `` 40288 1020 2 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1020 3 , , , 40288 1020 4 & & CC 40288 1020 5 c. c. NNP 40288 1020 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1020 7 . . . 40288 1021 1 The the DT 40288 1021 2 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1021 3 - - HYPH 40288 1021 4 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1021 5 and and CC 40288 1021 6 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1021 7 - - HYPH 40288 1021 8 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1021 9 , , , 40288 1021 10 which which WDT 40288 1021 11 employ employ VBP 40288 1021 12 the the DT 40288 1021 13 new new JJ 40288 1021 14 characters character NNS 40288 1021 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1021 16 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1021 17 : : : 40288 1021 18 a a LS 40288 1021 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1021 20 and and CC 40288 1021 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1021 22 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1021 23 : : : 40288 1021 24 e e LS 40288 1021 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1021 26 , , , 40288 1021 27 are be VBP 40288 1021 28 known know VBN 40288 1021 29 to to TO 40288 1021 30 be be VB 40288 1021 31 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 1021 32 recent recent JJ 40288 1021 33 . . . 40288 1022 1 The the DT 40288 1022 2 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1022 3 and and CC 40288 1022 4 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1022 5 , , , 40288 1022 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1022 7 is be VBZ 40288 1022 8 true true JJ 40288 1022 9 , , , 40288 1022 10 employ employ VB 40288 1022 11 the the DT 40288 1022 12 accented accented JJ 40288 1022 13 notes note NNS 40288 1022 14 ; ; : 40288 1022 15 but but CC 40288 1022 16 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1022 17 do do VBP 40288 1022 18 so so RB 40288 1022 19 only only RB 40288 1022 20 in in IN 40288 1022 21 the the DT 40288 1022 22 highest high JJS 40288 1022 23 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1022 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1022 25 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 1022 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1022 27 , , , 40288 1022 28 which which WDT 40288 1022 29 may may MD 40288 1022 30 not not RB 40288 1022 31 have have VB 40288 1022 32 been be VBN 40288 1022 33 originally originally RB 40288 1022 34 used use VBN 40288 1022 35 in in IN 40288 1022 36 these these DT 40288 1022 37 high high JJ 40288 1022 38 keys key NNS 40288 1022 39 . . . 40288 1023 1 The the DT 40288 1023 2 modified modify VBN 40288 1023 3 characters character NNS 40288 1023 4 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 1023 5 belong belong VBP 40288 1023 6 to to IN 40288 1023 7 an an DT 40288 1023 8 earlier early JJR 40288 1023 9 period period NN 40288 1023 10 . . . 40288 1024 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1024 2 are be VBP 40288 1024 3 needed need VBN 40288 1024 4 for for IN 40288 1024 5 the the DT 40288 1024 6 three three CD 40288 1024 7 oldest old JJS 40288 1024 8 keys key NNS 40288 1024 9 -- -- : 40288 1024 10 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1024 11 , , , 40288 1024 12 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1024 13 , , , 40288 1024 14 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1024 15 -- -- : 40288 1024 16 and and CC 40288 1024 17 also also RB 40288 1024 18 for for IN 40288 1024 19 the the DT 40288 1024 20 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1024 21 and and CC 40288 1024 22 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1024 23 genera genera NN 40288 1024 24 . . . 40288 1025 1 If if IN 40288 1025 2 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1025 3 are be VBP 40288 1025 4 not not RB 40288 1025 5 part part NN 40288 1025 6 of of IN 40288 1025 7 the the DT 40288 1025 8 original original JJ 40288 1025 9 scheme scheme NN 40288 1025 10 , , , 40288 1025 11 the the DT 40288 1025 12 musician musician NN 40288 1025 13 who who WP 40288 1025 14 devised devise VBD 40288 1025 15 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1025 16 may may MD 40288 1025 17 fairly fairly RB 40288 1025 18 be be VB 40288 1025 19 counted count VBN 40288 1025 20 as as IN 40288 1025 21 the the DT 40288 1025 22 second second JJ 40288 1025 23 inventor inventor NN 40288 1025 24 of of IN 40288 1025 25 the the DT 40288 1025 26 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1025 27 notation notation NN 40288 1025 28 . . . 40288 1026 1 In in IN 40288 1026 2 setting set VBG 40288 1026 3 out out RP 40288 1026 4 the the DT 40288 1026 5 scales scale NNS 40288 1026 6 of of IN 40288 1026 7 the the DT 40288 1026 8 several several JJ 40288 1026 9 keys key NNS 40288 1026 10 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1026 11 will will MD 40288 1026 12 be be VB 40288 1026 13 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 40288 1026 14 to to TO 40288 1026 15 give give VB 40288 1026 16 more more JJR 40288 1026 17 than than IN 40288 1026 18 the the DT 40288 1026 19 standing stand VBG 40288 1026 20 notes note NNS 40288 1026 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1026 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1026 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1026 24 : : : 40288 1026 25 phthongoi phthongoi NNP 40288 1026 26 hestôtes hestôte NNS 40288 1026 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1026 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1026 29 , , , 40288 1026 30 which which WDT 40288 1026 31 are be VBP 40288 1026 32 nearly nearly RB 40288 1026 33 all all DT 40288 1026 34 represented represent VBN 40288 1026 35 by by IN 40288 1026 36 original original JJ 40288 1026 37 or or CC 40288 1026 38 unmodified unmodified JJ 40288 1026 39 letters letter NNS 40288 1026 40 -- -- : 40288 1026 41 the the DT 40288 1026 42 moveable moveable JJ 40288 1026 43 notes note NNS 40288 1026 44 being be VBG 40288 1026 45 represented represent VBN 40288 1026 46 by by IN 40288 1026 47 the the DT 40288 1026 48 modified modify VBN 40288 1026 49 forms form NNS 40288 1026 50 described describe VBN 40288 1026 51 above above RB 40288 1026 52 . . . 40288 1027 1 The the DT 40288 1027 2 following following JJ 40288 1027 3 list list NN 40288 1027 4 includes include VBZ 40288 1027 5 the the DT 40288 1027 6 standing stand VBG 40288 1027 7 notes note NNS 40288 1027 8 , , , 40288 1027 9 viz viz NN 40288 1027 10 . . . 40288 1028 1 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 1028 2 , , , 40288 1028 3 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1028 4 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 1028 5 , , , 40288 1028 6 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1028 7 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1028 8 , , , 40288 1028 9 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1028 10 , , , 40288 1028 11 Paramesê Paramesê NNP 40288 1028 12 , , , 40288 1028 13 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1028 14 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1028 15 and and CC 40288 1028 16 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1028 17 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 1028 18 in in IN 40288 1028 19 the the DT 40288 1028 20 seven seven CD 40288 1028 21 oldest old JJS 40288 1028 22 keys key NNS 40288 1028 23 : : : 40288 1028 24 the the DT 40288 1028 25 two two CD 40288 1028 26 lowest low JJS 40288 1028 27 are be VBP 40288 1028 28 marked mark VBN 40288 1028 29 as as IN 40288 1028 30 doubtful:-- doubtful:-- CD 40288 1028 31 TABLE TABLE NNP 40288 1028 32 LEGEND legend NN 40288 1028 33 : : : 40288 1028 34 Column Column NNP 40288 1028 35 A a NN 40288 1028 36 = = -RRB- 40288 1028 37 Prosl Prosl NNP 40288 1028 38 . . . 40288 1029 1 Column Column NNP 40288 1029 2 B B NNP 40288 1029 3 = = SYM 40288 1029 4 Hyp Hyp NNP 40288 1029 5 . . . 40288 1030 1 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 1030 2 . . . 40288 1031 1 Column column NN 40288 1031 2 C C NNP 40288 1031 3 = = SYM 40288 1031 4 Hyp Hyp NNP 40288 1031 5 . . . 40288 1032 1 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1032 2 . . . 40288 1033 1 Column column NN 40288 1033 2 D d NN 40288 1033 3 = = SYM 40288 1033 4 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1033 5 . . . 40288 1034 1 Column column NN 40288 1034 2 E e NN 40288 1034 3 = = NN 40288 1034 4 Par Par NNP 40288 1034 5 . . . 40288 1035 1 Column Column NNP 40288 1035 2 F F NNP 40288 1035 3 = = SYM 40288 1035 4 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1035 5 Diez Diez NNP 40288 1035 6 . . . 40288 1036 1 Column column NN 40288 1036 2 G g NN 40288 1036 3 = = SYM 40288 1036 4 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1036 5 Hyperb Hyperb NNP 40288 1036 6 . . . 40288 1037 1 A a DT 40288 1037 2 B b NN 40288 1037 3 C c NN 40288 1037 4 D d NN 40288 1037 5 E e NN 40288 1037 6 F f NN 40288 1037 7 G G NNP 40288 1037 8 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1037 9 - - HYPH 40288 1037 10 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1037 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 12 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1037 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 14 4 4 CD 40288 1037 15 i -PRON- PRP 40288 1037 16 d d NN 40288 1037 17 D d NN 40288 1037 18 > > NN 40288 1037 19 N n NN 40288 1037 20 \ \ NNP 40288 1037 21 = = SYM 40288 1037 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 23 e[Symbol e[symbol NN 40288 1037 24 : : : 40288 1037 25 b b LS 40288 1037 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 27 - - : 40288 1037 28 e[Symbol e[symbol NN 40288 1037 29 : : : 40288 1037 30 b b LS 40288 1037 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 33 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1037 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 35 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1037 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 37 I- i- NN 40288 1037 38 r r NN 40288 1037 39 c c NN 40288 1037 40 < < XX 40288 1037 41 c c NNP 40288 1037 42 m m NNP 40288 1037 43 = = SYM 40288 1037 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 45 d d NNP 40288 1037 46 - - HYPH 40288 1037 47 d d NNP 40288 1037 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 49 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1037 50 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 51 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1037 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 53 E E NNP 40288 1037 54 I- i- NN 40288 1037 55 F f NN 40288 1037 56 11 11 CD 40288 1037 57 < < XX 40288 1037 58 Z Z NNP 40288 1037 59 = = SYM 40288 1037 60 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 61 c c NNP 40288 1037 62 - - HYPH 40288 1037 63 c c NNP 40288 1037 64 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 65 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1037 66 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 67 Symbols Symbols NNPS 40288 1037 68 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 69 R r NN 40288 1037 70 E e NN 40288 1037 71 I i NN 40288 1037 72 ' ' '' 40288 1037 73 D d NN 40288 1037 74 ri ri NN 40288 1037 75 N n NN 40288 1037 76 \ \ NNP 40288 1037 77 = = SYM 40288 1037 78 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 79 b[Symbol b[symbol XX 40288 1037 80 : : : 40288 1037 81 b b LS 40288 1037 82 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 83 - - : 40288 1037 84 b[Symbol b[symbol NN 40288 1037 85 : : : 40288 1037 86 b b LS 40288 1037 87 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 88 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 89 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1037 90 - - HYPH 40288 1037 91 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1037 92 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 93 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1037 94 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 95 H h NN 40288 1037 96 h h NN 40288 1037 97 r r NN 40288 1037 98 C c NN 40288 1037 99 I i NN 40288 1037 100 < < XX 40288 1037 101 c c NN 40288 1037 102 M M NNP 40288 1037 103 = = SYM 40288 1037 104 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 105 a a DT 40288 1037 106 - - : 40288 1037 107 a a DT 40288 1037 108 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 109 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 110 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1037 111 - - HYPH 40288 1037 112 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1037 113 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 114 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1037 115 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 116 H H NNP 40288 1037 117 I- i- NN 40288 1037 118 F F NNP 40288 1037 119 C C NNP 40288 1037 120 < < XX 40288 1037 121 Z Z NNP 40288 1037 122 = = SYM 40288 1037 123 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 124 g g NNP 40288 1037 125 - - HYPH 40288 1037 126 g g NNP 40288 1037 127 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 128 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 129 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1037 130 - - HYPH 40288 1037 131 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1037 132 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1037 133 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1037 134 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1037 135 E E NNP 40288 1037 136 /4 /4 NNP 40288 1037 137 F f NN 40288 1037 138 11 11 CD 40288 1037 139 N N NNP 40288 1037 140 = = SYM 40288 1037 141 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 142 f f NNP 40288 1037 143 - - HYPH 40288 1037 144 f f NNP 40288 1037 145 _ _ NNP 40288 1037 146 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1037 147 will will MD 40288 1037 148 be be VB 40288 1037 149 evident evident JJ 40288 1037 150 that that IN 40288 1037 151 this this DT 40288 1037 152 scheme scheme NN 40288 1037 153 of of IN 40288 1037 154 notation notation NN 40288 1037 155 tallies tally NNS 40288 1037 156 fairly fairly RB 40288 1037 157 well well RB 40288 1037 158 with with IN 40288 1037 159 what what WP 40288 1037 160 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1037 161 know know VBP 40288 1037 162 of of IN 40288 1037 163 the the DT 40288 1037 164 compass compass NN 40288 1037 165 of of IN 40288 1037 166 Greek greek JJ 40288 1037 167 instruments instrument NNS 40288 1037 168 about about IN 40288 1037 169 the the DT 40288 1037 170 end end NN 40288 1037 171 of of IN 40288 1037 172 the the DT 40288 1037 173 fifth fifth JJ 40288 1037 174 century century NN 40288 1037 175 , , , 40288 1037 176 and and CC 40288 1037 177 also also RB 40288 1037 178 with with IN 40288 1037 179 the the DT 40288 1037 180 account account NN 40288 1037 181 which which WDT 40288 1037 182 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1037 183 gives give VBZ 40288 1037 184 of of IN 40288 1037 185 the the DT 40288 1037 186 keys key NNS 40288 1037 187 in in IN 40288 1037 188 use use NN 40288 1037 189 up up IN 40288 1037 190 to to IN 40288 1037 191 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1037 192 time time NN 40288 1037 193 . . . 40288 1038 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1038 2 need need VBP 40288 1038 3 only only RB 40288 1038 4 refer refer VB 40288 1038 5 to to IN 40288 1038 6 what what WP 40288 1038 7 has have VBZ 40288 1038 8 been be VBN 40288 1038 9 said say VBN 40288 1038 10 above above RB 40288 1038 11 on on IN 40288 1038 12 p. p. NN 40288 1038 13 17 17 CD 40288 1038 14 and and CC 40288 1038 15 p. p. NN 40288 1038 16 37 37 CD 40288 1038 17 . . . 40288 1039 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1039 2 would would MD 40288 1039 3 be be VB 40288 1039 4 beyond beyond IN 40288 1039 5 the the DT 40288 1039 6 scope scope NN 40288 1039 7 of of IN 40288 1039 8 this this DT 40288 1039 9 essay essay NN 40288 1039 10 to to TO 40288 1039 11 discuss discuss VB 40288 1039 12 the the DT 40288 1039 13 date date NN 40288 1039 14 of of IN 40288 1039 15 the the DT 40288 1039 16 Greek greek JJ 40288 1039 17 musical musical JJ 40288 1039 18 notation notation NN 40288 1039 19 . . . 40288 1040 1 A a DT 40288 1040 2 few few JJ 40288 1040 3 remarks remark NNS 40288 1040 4 , , , 40288 1040 5 however however RB 40288 1040 6 , , , 40288 1040 7 may may MD 40288 1040 8 be be VB 40288 1040 9 made make VBN 40288 1040 10 , , , 40288 1040 11 especially especially RB 40288 1040 12 with with IN 40288 1040 13 reference reference NN 40288 1040 14 to to IN 40288 1040 15 the the DT 40288 1040 16 high high JJ 40288 1040 17 antiquity antiquity NN 40288 1040 18 assigned assign VBN 40288 1040 19 to to IN 40288 1040 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1040 21 by by IN 40288 1040 22 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1040 23 . . . 40288 1041 1 The the DT 40288 1041 2 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1041 3 from from IN 40288 1041 4 which which WDT 40288 1041 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1041 6 was be VBD 40288 1041 7 derived derive VBN 40288 1041 8 was be VBD 40288 1041 9 certainly certainly RB 40288 1041 10 an an DT 40288 1041 11 archaic archaic NN 40288 1041 12 one one CD 40288 1041 13 . . . 40288 1042 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1042 2 contained contain VBD 40288 1042 3 several several JJ 40288 1042 4 characters character NNS 40288 1042 5 , , , 40288 1042 6 in in IN 40288 1042 7 particular particular JJ 40288 1042 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1042 9 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1042 10 : : : 40288 1042 11 F f NN 40288 1042 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1042 13 for for IN 40288 1042 14 digamma digamma NN 40288 1042 15 , , , 40288 1042 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1042 17 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1042 18 : : : 40288 1042 19 LI LI NNP 40288 1042 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1042 21 for for IN 40288 1042 22 iota iota NN 40288 1042 23 , , , 40288 1042 24 and and CC 40288 1042 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1042 26 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1042 27 : : : 40288 1042 28 I- i- LS 40288 1042 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1042 30 for for IN 40288 1042 31 lambda lambda NN 40288 1042 32 , , , 40288 1042 33 which which WDT 40288 1042 34 belong belong VBP 40288 1042 35 to to IN 40288 1042 36 the the DT 40288 1042 37 period period NN 40288 1042 38 before before IN 40288 1042 39 the the DT 40288 1042 40 introduction introduction NN 40288 1042 41 of of IN 40288 1042 42 the the DT 40288 1042 43 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1042 44 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1042 45 . . . 40288 1043 1 Indeed indeed RB 40288 1043 2 if if IN 40288 1043 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1043 4 were be VBD 40288 1043 5 to to TO 40288 1043 6 judge judge VB 40288 1043 7 from from IN 40288 1043 8 these these DT 40288 1043 9 letters letter NNS 40288 1043 10 alone alone RB 40288 1043 11 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1043 12 should should MD 40288 1043 13 be be VB 40288 1043 14 led lead VBN 40288 1043 15 to to TO 40288 1043 16 assign assign VB 40288 1043 17 the the DT 40288 1043 18 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1043 19 notation notation NN 40288 1043 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1043 21 as as IN 40288 1043 22 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1043 23 does do VBZ 40288 1043 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1043 25 to to IN 40288 1043 26 the the DT 40288 1043 27 time time NN 40288 1043 28 of of IN 40288 1043 29 Solon Solon NNP 40288 1043 30 . . . 40288 1044 1 The the DT 40288 1044 2 three three CD 40288 1044 3 - - HYPH 40288 1044 4 stroke stroke NN 40288 1044 5 iota iota NN 40288 1044 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1044 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1044 8 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1044 9 : : : 40288 1044 10 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1044 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1044 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1044 13 , , , 40288 1044 14 in in IN 40288 1044 15 particular particular JJ 40288 1044 16 , , , 40288 1044 17 does do VBZ 40288 1044 18 not not RB 40288 1044 19 occur occur VB 40288 1044 20 in in IN 40288 1044 21 any any DT 40288 1044 22 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1044 23 later later RB 40288 1044 24 than than IN 40288 1044 25 the the DT 40288 1044 26 sixth sixth JJ 40288 1044 27 century century NN 40288 1044 28 B.C. B.C. NNP 40288 1045 1 On on IN 40288 1045 2 the the DT 40288 1045 3 other other JJ 40288 1045 4 hand hand NN 40288 1045 5 , , , 40288 1045 6 when when WRB 40288 1045 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1045 8 find find VBP 40288 1045 9 that that IN 40288 1045 10 the the DT 40288 1045 11 notation notation NN 40288 1045 12 implies imply VBZ 40288 1045 13 the the DT 40288 1045 14 use use NN 40288 1045 15 of of IN 40288 1045 16 a a DT 40288 1045 17 musical musical JJ 40288 1045 18 System system NN 40288 1045 19 in in IN 40288 1045 20 advance advance NN 40288 1045 21 of of IN 40288 1045 22 any any DT 40288 1045 23 scale scale NN 40288 1045 24 recognised recognise VBN 40288 1045 25 in in IN 40288 1045 26 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1045 27 , , , 40288 1045 28 or or CC 40288 1045 29 even even RB 40288 1045 30 in in IN 40288 1045 31 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1045 32 , , , 40288 1045 33 such such PDT 40288 1045 34 a a DT 40288 1045 35 date date NN 40288 1045 36 becomes become VBZ 40288 1045 37 incredible incredible JJ 40288 1045 38 . . . 40288 1046 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1046 2 can can MD 40288 1046 3 only only RB 40288 1046 4 suppose suppose VB 40288 1046 5 either either DT 40288 1046 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1046 7 1 1 CD 40288 1046 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1046 9 that that IN 40288 1046 10 the the DT 40288 1046 11 use use NN 40288 1046 12 of of IN 40288 1046 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1046 14 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1046 15 : : : 40288 1046 16 Li Li NNP 40288 1046 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1046 18 in in IN 40288 1046 19 the the DT 40288 1046 20 fifth fifth JJ 40288 1046 21 century century NN 40288 1046 22 was be VBD 40288 1046 23 confined confine VBN 40288 1046 24 to to IN 40288 1046 25 localities locality NNS 40288 1046 26 of of IN 40288 1046 27 which which WDT 40288 1046 28 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1046 29 have have VBP 40288 1046 30 no no DT 40288 1046 31 complete complete JJ 40288 1046 32 epigraphic epigraphic JJ 40288 1046 33 record record NN 40288 1046 34 , , , 40288 1046 35 or or CC 40288 1046 36 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1046 37 2 2 LS 40288 1046 38 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1046 39 that that IN 40288 1046 40 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1046 41 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1046 42 : : : 40288 1046 43 i i PRP 40288 1046 44 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1046 45 as as IN 40288 1046 46 a a DT 40288 1046 47 form form NN 40288 1046 48 of of IN 40288 1046 49 iota iota NN 40288 1046 50 was be VBD 40288 1046 51 still still RB 40288 1046 52 known know VBN 40288 1046 53 -- -- : 40288 1046 54 as as IN 40288 1046 55 archaic archaic JJ 40288 1046 56 forms form NNS 40288 1046 57 must must MD 40288 1046 58 have have VB 40288 1046 59 been be VBN 40288 1046 60 -- -- : 40288 1046 61 from from IN 40288 1046 62 the the DT 40288 1046 63 older old JJR 40288 1046 64 public public JJ 40288 1046 65 inscriptions inscription NNS 40288 1046 66 , , , 40288 1046 67 and and CC 40288 1046 68 was be VBD 40288 1046 69 adopted adopt VBN 40288 1046 70 by by IN 40288 1046 71 the the DT 40288 1046 72 inventor inventor NN 40288 1046 73 of of IN 40288 1046 74 the the DT 40288 1046 75 notation notation NN 40288 1046 76 as as IN 40288 1046 77 being be VBG 40288 1046 78 better well RBR 40288 1046 79 suited suited JJ 40288 1046 80 to to IN 40288 1046 81 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1046 82 purpose purpose NN 40288 1046 83 than than IN 40288 1046 84 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1046 85 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1046 86 : : : 40288 1046 87 1 1 LS 40288 1046 88 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1046 89 . . . 40288 1047 1 With with IN 40288 1047 2 regard regard NN 40288 1047 3 to to IN 40288 1047 4 the the DT 40288 1047 5 place place NN 40288 1047 6 of of IN 40288 1047 7 origin origin NN 40288 1047 8 of of IN 40288 1047 9 the the DT 40288 1047 10 notation notation NN 40288 1047 11 the the DT 40288 1047 12 chief chief JJ 40288 1047 13 fact fact NN 40288 1047 14 which which WDT 40288 1047 15 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1047 16 have have VBP 40288 1047 17 to to TO 40288 1047 18 deal deal VB 40288 1047 19 with with IN 40288 1047 20 is be VBZ 40288 1047 21 the the DT 40288 1047 22 use use NN 40288 1047 23 of of IN 40288 1047 24 the the DT 40288 1047 25 character character NN 40288 1047 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1047 27 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1047 28 : : : 40288 1047 29 I- i- LS 40288 1047 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1047 31 for for IN 40288 1047 32 lambda lambda NN 40288 1047 33 , , , 40288 1047 34 which which WDT 40288 1047 35 is be VBZ 40288 1047 36 distinctive distinctive JJ 40288 1047 37 of of IN 40288 1047 38 the the DT 40288 1047 39 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1047 40 of of IN 40288 1047 41 Argos Argos NNP 40288 1047 42 , , , 40288 1047 43 along along IN 40288 1047 44 with with IN 40288 1047 45 the the DT 40288 1047 46 commoner commoner NN 40288 1047 47 form form NN 40288 1047 48 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1047 49 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1047 50 : : : 40288 1047 51 < < XX 40288 1047 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1047 53 . . . 40288 1048 1 Westphal westphal NN 40288 1048 2 indeed indeed RB 40288 1048 3 asserts assert VBZ 40288 1048 4 that that IN 40288 1048 5 both both CC 40288 1048 6 these these DT 40288 1048 7 forms form NNS 40288 1048 8 are be VBP 40288 1048 9 found find VBN 40288 1048 10 in in IN 40288 1048 11 the the DT 40288 1048 12 Argive argive JJ 40288 1048 13 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1048 14 . . . 40288 1049 1 But but CC 40288 1049 2 the the DT 40288 1049 3 inscription inscription NN 40288 1049 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1049 5 C. C. NNP 40288 1049 6 I. I. NNP 40288 1050 1 1 1 LS 40288 1050 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1050 3 which which WDT 40288 1050 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1050 5 quotes[1 quotes[1 NNP 40288 1050 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1050 7 for for IN 40288 1050 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1050 9 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1050 10 : : : 40288 1050 11 < < XX 40288 1050 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1050 13 really really RB 40288 1050 14 contains contain VBZ 40288 1050 15 only only RB 40288 1050 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1050 17 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1050 18 : : : 40288 1050 19 t- t- XX 40288 1050 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1050 21 in in IN 40288 1050 22 a a DT 40288 1050 23 slightly slightly RB 40288 1050 24 different different JJ 40288 1050 25 form form NN 40288 1050 26 . . . 40288 1051 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1051 2 can can MD 40288 1051 3 not not RB 40288 1051 4 therefore therefore RB 40288 1051 5 say say VB 40288 1051 6 that that IN 40288 1051 7 the the DT 40288 1051 8 inventor inventor NN 40288 1051 9 of of IN 40288 1051 10 the the DT 40288 1051 11 notation notation NN 40288 1051 12 derived derive VBD 40288 1051 13 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1051 14 entirely entirely RB 40288 1051 15 from from IN 40288 1051 16 the the DT 40288 1051 17 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1051 18 of of IN 40288 1051 19 Argos Argos NNP 40288 1051 20 , , , 40288 1051 21 but but CC 40288 1051 22 only only RB 40288 1051 23 that that IN 40288 1051 24 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1051 25 shows show VBZ 40288 1051 26 an an DT 40288 1051 27 acquaintance acquaintance NN 40288 1051 28 with with IN 40288 1051 29 that that DT 40288 1051 30 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1051 31 . . . 40288 1052 1 This this DT 40288 1052 2 is be VBZ 40288 1052 3 confirmed confirm VBN 40288 1052 4 by by IN 40288 1052 5 the the DT 40288 1052 6 fact fact NN 40288 1052 7 that that IN 40288 1052 8 the the DT 40288 1052 9 form form NN 40288 1052 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1052 11 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1052 12 : : : 40288 1052 13 Li Li NNP 40288 1052 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1052 15 for for IN 40288 1052 16 iota iota NNP 40288 1052 17 is be VBZ 40288 1052 18 not not RB 40288 1052 19 found find VBN 40288 1052 20 at at IN 40288 1052 21 Argos Argos NNP 40288 1052 22 . . . 40288 1053 1 Probably probably RB 40288 1053 2 therefore therefore RB 40288 1053 3 the the DT 40288 1053 4 inventor inventor NN 40288 1053 5 drew draw VBD 40288 1053 6 upon upon IN 40288 1053 7 more more JJR 40288 1053 8 than than IN 40288 1053 9 one one CD 40288 1053 10 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1053 11 for for IN 40288 1053 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1053 13 purpose purpose NN 40288 1053 14 , , , 40288 1053 15 the the DT 40288 1053 16 Argive argive JJ 40288 1053 17 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1053 18 being be VBG 40288 1053 19 one one CD 40288 1053 20 . . . 40288 1054 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1054 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1054 3 1 1 CD 40288 1054 4 : : : 40288 1054 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1054 6 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 1054 7 und und NN 40288 1054 8 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 1054 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1054 10 , , , 40288 1054 11 p. p. NN 40288 1054 12 286 286 CD 40288 1054 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1054 14 ed ed NN 40288 1054 15 . . . 40288 1055 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 1055 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1055 3 . . . 40288 1056 1 The the DT 40288 1056 2 true true JJ 40288 1056 3 form form NN 40288 1056 4 of of IN 40288 1056 5 the the DT 40288 1056 6 letter letter NN 40288 1056 7 is be VBZ 40288 1056 8 given give VBN 40288 1056 9 by by IN 40288 1056 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1056 11 Roberts Roberts NNP 40288 1056 12 , , , 40288 1056 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1056 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1056 15 Epigraphy Epigraphy NNP 40288 1056 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1056 17 , , , 40288 1056 18 p. p. NN 40288 1057 1 109 109 CD 40288 1057 2 . . . 40288 1057 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1058 1 The the DT 40288 1058 2 special special JJ 40288 1058 3 fitness fitness NN 40288 1058 4 of of IN 40288 1058 5 the the DT 40288 1058 6 notation notation NN 40288 1058 7 for for IN 40288 1058 8 the the DT 40288 1058 9 scales scale NNS 40288 1058 10 of of IN 40288 1058 11 the the DT 40288 1058 12 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1058 13 genus genus NN 40288 1058 14 may may MD 40288 1058 15 be be VB 40288 1058 16 regarded regard VBN 40288 1058 17 as as IN 40288 1058 18 a a DT 40288 1058 19 further further JJ 40288 1058 20 indication indication NN 40288 1058 21 of of IN 40288 1058 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1058 23 date date NN 40288 1058 24 . . . 40288 1059 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1059 2 shall shall MD 40288 1059 3 see see VB 40288 1059 4 presently presently RB 40288 1059 5 that that IN 40288 1059 6 that that IN 40288 1059 7 genus genus NN 40288 1059 8 held hold VBD 40288 1059 9 a a DT 40288 1059 10 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 1059 11 predominance predominance NN 40288 1059 12 in in IN 40288 1059 13 the the DT 40288 1059 14 earliest early JJS 40288 1059 15 period period NN 40288 1059 16 of of IN 40288 1059 17 musical musical JJ 40288 1059 18 theory theory NN 40288 1059 19 -- -- : 40288 1059 20 that that IN 40288 1059 21 , , , 40288 1059 22 namely namely RB 40288 1059 23 , , , 40288 1059 24 which which WDT 40288 1059 25 was be VBD 40288 1059 26 brought bring VBN 40288 1059 27 to to IN 40288 1059 28 an an DT 40288 1059 29 end end NN 40288 1059 30 by by IN 40288 1059 31 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1059 32 . . . 40288 1060 1 If if IN 40288 1060 2 the the DT 40288 1060 3 author author NN 40288 1060 4 of of IN 40288 1060 5 the the DT 40288 1060 6 notation notation NN 40288 1060 7 -- -- : 40288 1060 8 or or CC 40288 1060 9 the the DT 40288 1060 10 second second JJ 40288 1060 11 author author NN 40288 1060 12 , , , 40288 1060 13 inventor inventor NN 40288 1060 14 of of IN 40288 1060 15 the the DT 40288 1060 16 modified modify VBN 40288 1060 17 characters character NNS 40288 1060 18 -- -- : 40288 1060 19 was be VBD 40288 1060 20 one one CD 40288 1060 21 of of IN 40288 1060 22 the the DT 40288 1060 23 musicians musician NNS 40288 1060 24 whose whose WP$ 40288 1060 25 names name NNS 40288 1060 26 have have VBP 40288 1060 27 come come VBN 40288 1060 28 down down RP 40288 1060 29 to to IN 40288 1060 30 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1060 31 , , , 40288 1060 32 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1060 33 would would MD 40288 1060 34 be be VB 40288 1060 35 difficult difficult JJ 40288 1060 36 to to TO 40288 1060 37 find find VB 40288 1060 38 a a DT 40288 1060 39 more more RBR 40288 1060 40 probable probable JJ 40288 1060 41 one one NN 40288 1060 42 than than IN 40288 1060 43 that that DT 40288 1060 44 of of IN 40288 1060 45 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 1060 46 of of IN 40288 1060 47 Thebes Thebes NNP 40288 1060 48 . . . 40288 1061 1 One one CD 40288 1061 2 of of IN 40288 1061 3 the the DT 40288 1061 4 most most RBS 40288 1061 5 striking striking JJ 40288 1061 6 features feature NNS 40288 1061 7 of of IN 40288 1061 8 the the DT 40288 1061 9 notation notation NN 40288 1061 10 , , , 40288 1061 11 at at IN 40288 1061 12 the the DT 40288 1061 13 time time NN 40288 1061 14 when when WRB 40288 1061 15 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1061 16 was be VBD 40288 1061 17 framed frame VBN 40288 1061 18 , , , 40288 1061 19 must must MD 40288 1061 20 have have VB 40288 1061 21 been be VBN 40288 1061 22 the the DT 40288 1061 23 adjustment adjustment NN 40288 1061 24 of of IN 40288 1061 25 the the DT 40288 1061 26 keys key NNS 40288 1061 27 . . . 40288 1062 1 Even even RB 40288 1062 2 in in IN 40288 1062 3 the the DT 40288 1062 4 time time NN 40288 1062 5 of of IN 40288 1062 6 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1062 7 , , , 40288 1062 8 as as IN 40288 1062 9 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1062 10 know know VBP 40288 1062 11 from from IN 40288 1062 12 the the DT 40288 1062 13 passage passage NN 40288 1062 14 so so RB 40288 1062 15 often often RB 40288 1062 16 quoted quote VBN 40288 1062 17 , , , 40288 1062 18 that that DT 40288 1062 19 adjustment adjustment NN 40288 1062 20 was be VBD 40288 1062 21 not not RB 40288 1062 22 universal universal JJ 40288 1062 23 . . . 40288 1063 1 But but CC 40288 1063 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1063 3 is be VBZ 40288 1063 4 precisely precisely RB 40288 1063 5 what what WP 40288 1063 6 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 1063 7 of of IN 40288 1063 8 Thebes Thebes NNP 40288 1063 9 is be VBZ 40288 1063 10 said say VBN 40288 1063 11 to to TO 40288 1063 12 have have VB 40288 1063 13 done do VBN 40288 1063 14 for for IN 40288 1063 15 the the DT 40288 1063 16 music music NN 40288 1063 17 of of IN 40288 1063 18 the the DT 40288 1063 19 flute flute NN 40288 1063 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1063 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1063 22 supra supra NNP 40288 1063 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1063 24 , , , 40288 1063 25 p. p. NN 40288 1063 26 38 38 CD 40288 1063 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1063 28 . . . 40288 1064 1 The the DT 40288 1064 2 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 1064 3 that that WDT 40288 1064 4 the the DT 40288 1064 5 system system NN 40288 1064 6 was be VBD 40288 1064 7 only only RB 40288 1064 8 used use VBN 40288 1064 9 for for IN 40288 1064 10 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1064 11 music music NN 40288 1064 12 is be VBZ 40288 1064 13 at at IN 40288 1064 14 least least JJS 40288 1064 15 in in IN 40288 1064 16 harmony harmony NN 40288 1064 17 with with IN 40288 1064 18 this this DT 40288 1064 19 conjecture conjecture NN 40288 1064 20 . . . 40288 1065 1 If if IN 40288 1065 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1065 3 is be VBZ 40288 1065 4 thought think VBN 40288 1065 5 that that IN 40288 1065 6 Thebes Thebes NNP 40288 1065 7 is be VBZ 40288 1065 8 too too RB 40288 1065 9 far far RB 40288 1065 10 from from IN 40288 1065 11 Argos Argos NNP 40288 1065 12 , , , 40288 1065 13 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1065 14 may may MD 40288 1065 15 fall fall VB 40288 1065 16 back back RB 40288 1065 17 upon upon IN 40288 1065 18 the the DT 40288 1065 19 notice notice NN 40288 1065 20 that that IN 40288 1065 21 Sacadas Sacadas NNP 40288 1065 22 of of IN 40288 1065 23 Argos Argos NNP 40288 1065 24 was be VBD 40288 1065 25 the the DT 40288 1065 26 chief chief JJ 40288 1065 27 composer composer NN 40288 1065 28 for for IN 40288 1065 29 the the DT 40288 1065 30 flute flute NN 40288 1065 31 before before IN 40288 1065 32 the the DT 40288 1065 33 time time NN 40288 1065 34 of of IN 40288 1065 35 Pronomus[1 pronomus[1 NN 40288 1065 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1065 37 , , , 40288 1065 38 and and CC 40288 1065 39 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 1065 40 Argos Argos NNP 40288 1065 41 was be VBD 40288 1065 42 one one CD 40288 1065 43 of of IN 40288 1065 44 the the DT 40288 1065 45 first first JJ 40288 1065 46 cities city NNS 40288 1065 47 to to TO 40288 1065 48 share share VB 40288 1065 49 in in IN 40288 1065 50 the the DT 40288 1065 51 advance advance NN 40288 1065 52 which which WDT 40288 1065 53 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 1065 54 made make VBD 40288 1065 55 in in IN 40288 1065 56 the the DT 40288 1065 57 technique technique NN 40288 1065 58 of of IN 40288 1065 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1065 60 art art NN 40288 1065 61 . . . 40288 1066 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1066 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1066 3 1 1 CD 40288 1066 4 : : : 40288 1066 5 Pausanias Pausanias NNP 40288 1066 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1066 7 iv iv UH 40288 1066 8 . . . 40288 1067 1 27 27 CD 40288 1067 2 , , , 40288 1067 3 4 4 CD 40288 1067 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1067 5 says say VBZ 40288 1067 6 of of IN 40288 1067 7 the the DT 40288 1067 8 founding founding NN 40288 1067 9 of of IN 40288 1067 10 Messene Messene NNP 40288 1067 11 : : : 40288 1067 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1067 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1067 14 : : : 40288 1067 15 eirgazonto eirgazonto NNP 40288 1067 16 de de NNP 40288 1067 17 kai kai NNP 40288 1067 18 hypo hypo NNP 40288 1067 19 mousuiês mousuiês NNP 40288 1067 20 allês allês NNP 40288 1067 21 men man NNS 40288 1067 22 oudemias oudemias NNP 40288 1067 23 , , , 40288 1067 24 aulôn aulôn NNP 40288 1067 25 de de NNP 40288 1067 26 Boiôtiôn Boiôtiôn NNP 40288 1067 27 kai kai NNP 40288 1067 28 Argeiôn Argeiôn NNP 40288 1067 29 ; ; : 40288 1067 30 ta ta NNP 40288 1067 31 te te NNP 40288 1067 32 Sakada Sakada NNP 40288 1067 33 kai kai NNP 40288 1067 34 Pronomou Pronomou NNP 40288 1067 35 melê melê NN 40288 1067 36 tote tote NN 40288 1067 37 dê dê NNP 40288 1067 38 proêchthê proêchthê NNP 40288 1067 39 malista malista NNP 40288 1067 40 eis eis NNP 40288 1067 41 hamillan hamillan NNP 40288 1067 42 . . . 40288 1067 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1067 44 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1068 1 § § ADD 40288 1068 2 28 28 CD 40288 1068 3 . . . 40288 1069 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1069 2 Traces Traces NNPS 40288 1069 3 of of IN 40288 1069 4 the the DT 40288 1069 5 Species Species NNPS 40288 1069 6 in in IN 40288 1069 7 the the DT 40288 1069 8 Notation Notation NNP 40288 1069 9 . . . 40288 1069 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1069 11 Before before IN 40288 1069 12 leaving leave VBG 40288 1069 13 this this DT 40288 1069 14 part part NN 40288 1069 15 of of IN 40288 1069 16 the the DT 40288 1069 17 subject subject NN 40288 1069 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1069 19 will will MD 40288 1069 20 be be VB 40288 1069 21 well well JJ 40288 1069 22 to to TO 40288 1069 23 notice notice VB 40288 1069 24 the the DT 40288 1069 25 attempt attempt NN 40288 1069 26 which which WDT 40288 1069 27 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1069 28 makes make VBZ 40288 1069 29 to to TO 40288 1069 30 connect connect VB 40288 1069 31 the the DT 40288 1069 32 species specie NNS 40288 1069 33 of of IN 40288 1069 34 the the DT 40288 1069 35 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1069 36 with with IN 40288 1069 37 the the DT 40288 1069 38 form form NN 40288 1069 39 of of IN 40288 1069 40 the the DT 40288 1069 41 musical musical JJ 40288 1069 42 notation notation NN 40288 1069 43 . . . 40288 1070 1 The the DT 40288 1070 2 basis basis NN 40288 1070 3 of of IN 40288 1070 4 the the DT 40288 1070 5 notation notation NN 40288 1070 6 , , , 40288 1070 7 as as IN 40288 1070 8 has have VBZ 40288 1070 9 been be VBN 40288 1070 10 explained explain VBN 40288 1070 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1070 12 p. p. NN 40288 1070 13 69 69 CD 40288 1070 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1070 15 , , , 40288 1070 16 is be VBZ 40288 1070 17 formed form VBN 40288 1070 18 by by IN 40288 1070 19 two two CD 40288 1070 20 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1070 21 octaves octave NNS 40288 1070 22 , , , 40288 1070 23 denoted denote VBN 40288 1070 24 by by IN 40288 1070 25 the the DT 40288 1070 26 letters letter NNS 40288 1070 27 of of IN 40288 1070 28 the the DT 40288 1070 29 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1070 30 from from IN 40288 1070 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1070 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1070 33 : : : 40288 1070 34 a a LS 40288 1070 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1070 36 to to IN 40288 1070 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1070 38 Greek greek JJ 40288 1070 39 : : : 40288 1070 40 n n LS 40288 1070 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1070 42 , , , 40288 1070 43 as as IN 40288 1070 44 follows follow VBZ 40288 1070 45 : : : 40288 1070 46 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1070 47 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1070 48 : : : 40288 1070 49 ê ê NNP 40288 1070 50 i i NN 40288 1070 51 e e NNP 40288 1070 52 l l NN 40288 1070 53 g g NN 40288 1070 54 m m NN 40288 1070 55 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1070 56 digamma digamma NN 40288 1070 57 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1070 58 th th NNP 40288 1070 59 k k NNP 40288 1070 60 d d NNP 40288 1070 61 l l NNP 40288 1070 62 b b NNP 40288 1070 63 n n CC 40288 1070 64 z z NNP 40288 1070 65 a a NN 40288 1070 66 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1070 67 _ _ NNP 40288 1070 68 a a DT 40288 1070 69 b b NN 40288 1070 70 c c NN 40288 1070 71 d d NNP 40288 1070 72 e e NNP 40288 1070 73 f f NNP 40288 1070 74 g g NNP 40288 1070 75 a a DT 40288 1070 76 b b NN 40288 1070 77 c c NN 40288 1070 78 d d NNP 40288 1070 79 e e NNP 40288 1070 80 f f NNP 40288 1070 81 g g NNP 40288 1070 82 a a NNP 40288 1070 83 _ _ NNP 40288 1070 84 In in IN 40288 1070 85 this this DT 40288 1070 86 scale scale NN 40288 1070 87 , , , 40288 1070 88 as as IN 40288 1070 89 has have VBZ 40288 1070 90 been be VBN 40288 1070 91 pointed point VBN 40288 1070 92 out out RP 40288 1070 93 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1070 94 p. p. NN 40288 1070 95 71 71 CD 40288 1070 96 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1070 97 , , , 40288 1070 98 the the DT 40288 1070 99 notes note NNS 40288 1070 100 which which WDT 40288 1070 101 are be VBP 40288 1070 102 at at IN 40288 1070 103 the the DT 40288 1070 104 distance distance NN 40288 1070 105 of of IN 40288 1070 106 an an DT 40288 1070 107 octave octave NN 40288 1070 108 from from IN 40288 1070 109 each each DT 40288 1070 110 other other JJ 40288 1070 111 are be VBP 40288 1070 112 always always RB 40288 1070 113 expressed express VBN 40288 1070 114 by by IN 40288 1070 115 two two CD 40288 1070 116 _ _ NNP 40288 1070 117 successive successive JJ 40288 1070 118 _ _ NNP 40288 1070 119 letters letter NNS 40288 1070 120 of of IN 40288 1070 121 the the DT 40288 1070 122 alphabet alphabet NN 40288 1070 123 . . . 40288 1071 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1071 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1071 3 find-- find-- VBP 40288 1071 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1071 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1071 6 : : : 40288 1071 7 b b LS 40288 1071 8 - - HYPH 40288 1071 9 g g NN 40288 1071 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1071 11 is be VBZ 40288 1071 12 the the DT 40288 1071 13 octave octave NN 40288 1071 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1071 15 e e NNP 40288 1071 16 - - HYPH 40288 1071 17 e e NNP 40288 1071 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1071 19 , , , 40288 1071 20 the the DT 40288 1071 21 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1071 22 species specie NNS 40288 1071 23 . . . 40288 1072 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1072 2 Greek greek JJ 40288 1072 3 : : : 40288 1072 4 d d LS 40288 1072 5 - - HYPH 40288 1072 6 e e NN 40288 1072 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1072 8 " " '' 40288 1072 9 " " `` 40288 1072 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1072 11 c c NNP 40288 1072 12 - - HYPH 40288 1072 13 c c NNP 40288 1072 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1072 15 , , , 40288 1072 16 the the DT 40288 1072 17 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1072 18 species specie NNS 40288 1072 19 . . . 40288 1073 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1073 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1073 3 : : : 40288 1073 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1073 5 digamma digamma NN 40288 1073 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1073 7 - - : 40288 1073 8 z z NN 40288 1073 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1073 10 " " '' 40288 1073 11 " " `` 40288 1073 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1073 13 g g NNP 40288 1073 14 - - HYPH 40288 1073 15 g g NNP 40288 1073 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1073 17 , , , 40288 1073 18 the the DT 40288 1073 19 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1073 20 - - HYPH 40288 1073 21 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1073 22 species specie NNS 40288 1073 23 . . . 40288 1074 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1074 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1074 3 : : : 40288 1074 4 ê ê NN 40288 1074 5 - - HYPH 40288 1074 6 th th NNP 40288 1074 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1074 8 " " '' 40288 1074 9 " " `` 40288 1074 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1074 11 a a DT 40288 1074 12 - - : 40288 1074 13 a a DT 40288 1074 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1074 15 , , , 40288 1074 16 the the DT 40288 1074 17 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1074 18 - - HYPH 40288 1074 19 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1074 20 species specie NNS 40288 1074 21 . . . 40288 1075 1 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1075 2 adopts adopt VBZ 40288 1075 3 the the DT 40288 1075 4 theory theory NN 40288 1075 5 of of IN 40288 1075 6 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40288 1075 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1075 8 as as IN 40288 1075 9 to to TO 40288 1075 10 which which WDT 40288 1075 11 see see VB 40288 1075 12 p. p. NN 40288 1075 13 11 11 CD 40288 1075 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1075 15 that that IN 40288 1075 16 the the DT 40288 1075 17 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1075 18 - - HYPH 40288 1075 19 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1075 20 and and CC 40288 1075 21 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 1075 22 - - HYPH 40288 1075 23 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1075 24 species specie NNS 40288 1075 25 answered answer VBD 40288 1075 26 to to IN 40288 1075 27 the the DT 40288 1075 28 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1075 29 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1075 30 and and CC 40288 1075 31 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 1075 32 modes mode NNS 40288 1075 33 . . . 40288 1076 1 On on IN 40288 1076 2 this this DT 40288 1076 3 assumption assumption NN 40288 1076 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1076 5 argues argue VBZ 40288 1076 6 that that IN 40288 1076 7 the the DT 40288 1076 8 order order NN 40288 1076 9 of of IN 40288 1076 10 the the DT 40288 1076 11 pairs pair NNS 40288 1076 12 of of IN 40288 1076 13 letters letter NNS 40288 1076 14 representing represent VBG 40288 1076 15 the the DT 40288 1076 16 species specie NNS 40288 1076 17 agrees agree VBZ 40288 1076 18 with with IN 40288 1076 19 the the DT 40288 1076 20 order order NN 40288 1076 21 of of IN 40288 1076 22 the the DT 40288 1076 23 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1076 24 in in IN 40288 1076 25 the the DT 40288 1076 26 historical historical JJ 40288 1076 27 development development NN 40288 1076 28 of of IN 40288 1076 29 Greek greek JJ 40288 1076 30 music music NN 40288 1076 31 . . . 40288 1077 1 For for IN 40288 1077 2 the the DT 40288 1077 3 priority priority NN 40288 1077 4 of of IN 40288 1077 5 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1077 6 , , , 40288 1077 7 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1077 8 , , , 40288 1077 9 and and CC 40288 1077 10 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 1077 11 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1077 12 appeals appeal VBZ 40288 1077 13 to to IN 40288 1077 14 the the DT 40288 1077 15 authority authority NN 40288 1077 16 of of IN 40288 1077 17 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 1077 18 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 1077 19 , , , 40288 1077 20 quoted quote VBN 40288 1077 21 above above RB 40288 1077 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1077 23 p. p. NN 40288 1077 24 9 9 CD 40288 1077 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1077 26 . . . 40288 1078 1 The the DT 40288 1078 2 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1078 3 , , , 40288 1078 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1078 5 supposes suppose VBZ 40288 1078 6 , , , 40288 1078 7 was be VBD 40288 1078 8 interposed interpose VBN 40288 1078 9 in in IN 40288 1078 10 the the DT 40288 1078 11 second second JJ 40288 1078 12 place place NN 40288 1078 13 on on IN 40288 1078 14 account account NN 40288 1078 15 of of IN 40288 1078 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1078 17 importance importance NN 40288 1078 18 in in IN 40288 1078 19 education,--recognised education,--recognised NNP 40288 1078 20 , , , 40288 1078 21 as as IN 40288 1078 22 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1078 23 have have VBP 40288 1078 24 seen see VBN 40288 1078 25 , , , 40288 1078 26 by by IN 40288 1078 27 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1078 28 in in IN 40288 1078 29 the the DT 40288 1078 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1078 31 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 1078 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1078 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1078 34 viii viii NNP 40288 1078 35 . . . 40288 1079 1 7 7 CD 40288 1079 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1079 3 ad ad NN 40288 1079 4 fin fin NN 40288 1079 5 . . . 40288 1079 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1079 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1079 8 . . . 40288 1080 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1080 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1080 3 regards regard VBZ 40288 1080 4 the the DT 40288 1080 5 notation notation NN 40288 1080 6 as as IN 40288 1080 7 confirming confirm VBG 40288 1080 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1080 9 theory theory NN 40288 1080 10 of of IN 40288 1080 11 the the DT 40288 1080 12 nature nature NN 40288 1080 13 and and CC 40288 1080 14 history history NN 40288 1080 15 of of IN 40288 1080 16 the the DT 40288 1080 17 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1080 18 . . . 40288 1081 1 The the DT 40288 1081 2 weakness weakness NN 40288 1081 3 of of IN 40288 1081 4 this this DT 40288 1081 5 reasoning reasoning NN 40288 1081 6 is be VBZ 40288 1081 7 manifold manifold JJ 40288 1081 8 . . . 40288 1082 1 Granting grant VBG 40288 1082 2 that that IN 40288 1082 3 the the DT 40288 1082 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1082 5 - - HYPH 40288 1082 6 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1082 7 and and CC 40288 1082 8 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 1082 9 - - HYPH 40288 1082 10 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1082 11 answer answer NN 40288 1082 12 to to IN 40288 1082 13 the the DT 40288 1082 14 old old JJ 40288 1082 15 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 1082 16 and and CC 40288 1082 17 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1082 18 respectively respectively RB 40288 1082 19 , , , 40288 1082 20 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1082 21 have have VBP 40288 1082 22 to to TO 40288 1082 23 ask ask VB 40288 1082 24 what what WP 40288 1082 25 is be VBZ 40288 1082 26 the the DT 40288 1082 27 nature nature NN 40288 1082 28 of of IN 40288 1082 29 the the DT 40288 1082 30 priority priority NN 40288 1082 31 which which WDT 40288 1082 32 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 1082 33 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 1082 34 claims claim VBZ 40288 1082 35 for for IN 40288 1082 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1082 37 three three CD 40288 1082 38 modes mode NNS 40288 1082 39 , , , 40288 1082 40 and and CC 40288 1082 41 what what WP 40288 1082 42 is be VBZ 40288 1082 43 the the DT 40288 1082 44 value value NN 40288 1082 45 of of IN 40288 1082 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1082 47 testimony testimony NN 40288 1082 48 . . . 40288 1083 1 What what WP 40288 1083 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1083 3 says say VBZ 40288 1083 4 is be VBZ 40288 1083 5 , , , 40288 1083 6 in in IN 40288 1083 7 substance substance NN 40288 1083 8 , , , 40288 1083 9 that that IN 40288 1083 10 these these DT 40288 1083 11 are be VBP 40288 1083 12 the the DT 40288 1083 13 only only JJ 40288 1083 14 kinds kind NNS 40288 1083 15 of of IN 40288 1083 16 music music NN 40288 1083 17 that that WDT 40288 1083 18 are be VBP 40288 1083 19 truly truly RB 40288 1083 20 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40288 1083 21 , , , 40288 1083 22 and and CC 40288 1083 23 worthy worthy JJ 40288 1083 24 of of IN 40288 1083 25 the the DT 40288 1083 26 name name NN 40288 1083 27 of of IN 40288 1083 28 modes mode NNS 40288 1083 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1083 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1083 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1083 32 : : : 40288 1083 33 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1083 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1083 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1083 36 . . . 40288 1084 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1084 2 can can MD 40288 1084 3 hardly hardly RB 40288 1084 4 be be VB 40288 1084 5 thought think VBN 40288 1084 6 that that IN 40288 1084 7 this this DT 40288 1084 8 is be VBZ 40288 1084 9 a a DT 40288 1084 10 criticism criticism NN 40288 1084 11 likely likely JJ 40288 1084 12 to to TO 40288 1084 13 have have VB 40288 1084 14 weighed weigh VBN 40288 1084 15 with with IN 40288 1084 16 the the DT 40288 1084 17 inventor inventor NN 40288 1084 18 of of IN 40288 1084 19 the the DT 40288 1084 20 notation notation NN 40288 1084 21 . . . 40288 1085 1 But but CC 40288 1085 2 if if IN 40288 1085 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1085 4 did do VBD 40288 1085 5 , , , 40288 1085 6 why why WRB 40288 1085 7 did do VBD 40288 1085 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1085 9 give give VB 40288 1085 10 an an DT 40288 1085 11 equally equally RB 40288 1085 12 prominent prominent JJ 40288 1085 13 place place NN 40288 1085 14 to to IN 40288 1085 15 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1085 16 , , , 40288 1085 17 one one CD 40288 1085 18 of of IN 40288 1085 19 the the DT 40288 1085 20 modes mode NNS 40288 1085 21 which which WDT 40288 1085 22 Heraclides heraclide NNS 40288 1085 23 condemned condemn VBD 40288 1085 24 ? ? . 40288 1086 1 In in IN 40288 1086 2 fact fact NN 40288 1086 3 , , , 40288 1086 4 the the DT 40288 1086 5 introduction introduction NN 40288 1086 6 of of IN 40288 1086 7 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1086 8 goes go VBZ 40288 1086 9 far far RB 40288 1086 10 to to TO 40288 1086 11 show show VB 40288 1086 12 that that IN 40288 1086 13 the the DT 40288 1086 14 coincidence coincidence NN 40288 1086 15 -- -- : 40288 1086 16 such such JJ 40288 1086 17 as as IN 40288 1086 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1086 19 is be VBZ 40288 1086 20 -- -- : 40288 1086 21 with with IN 40288 1086 22 the the DT 40288 1086 23 views view NNS 40288 1086 24 of of IN 40288 1086 25 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 1086 26 is be VBZ 40288 1086 27 mere mere JJ 40288 1086 28 accident accident NN 40288 1086 29 . . . 40288 1087 1 Apart apart RB 40288 1087 2 , , , 40288 1087 3 however however RB 40288 1087 4 , , , 40288 1087 5 from from IN 40288 1087 6 these these DT 40288 1087 7 difficulties difficulty NNS 40288 1087 8 , , , 40288 1087 9 there there EX 40288 1087 10 are be VBP 40288 1087 11 at at RB 40288 1087 12 least least RBS 40288 1087 13 two two CD 40288 1087 14 considerations consideration NNS 40288 1087 15 which which WDT 40288 1087 16 seem seem VBP 40288 1087 17 fatal fatal JJ 40288 1087 18 to to IN 40288 1087 19 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1087 20 's 's POS 40288 1087 21 theory theory NN 40288 1087 22 : : : 40288 1087 23 1 1 LS 40288 1087 24 . . . 40288 1088 1 The the DT 40288 1088 2 notation notation NN 40288 1088 3 , , , 40288 1088 4 so so RB 40288 1088 5 far far RB 40288 1088 6 as as IN 40288 1088 7 the the DT 40288 1088 8 original original JJ 40288 1088 9 two two CD 40288 1088 10 octaves octave NNS 40288 1088 11 are be VBP 40288 1088 12 concerned concern VBN 40288 1088 13 , , , 40288 1088 14 must must MD 40288 1088 15 have have VB 40288 1088 16 been be VBN 40288 1088 17 devised devise VBN 40288 1088 18 and and CC 40288 1088 19 worked work VBN 40288 1088 20 out out RP 40288 1088 21 at at IN 40288 1088 22 some some DT 40288 1088 23 one one CD 40288 1088 24 time time NN 40288 1088 25 . . . 40288 1089 1 No no DT 40288 1089 2 part part NN 40288 1089 3 of of IN 40288 1089 4 these these DT 40288 1089 5 two two CD 40288 1089 6 octaves octave NNS 40288 1089 7 can can MD 40288 1089 8 have have VB 40288 1089 9 been be VBN 40288 1089 10 completed complete VBN 40288 1089 11 before before IN 40288 1089 12 the the DT 40288 1089 13 rest rest NN 40288 1089 14 . . . 40288 1090 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1090 2 the the DT 40288 1090 3 order order NN 40288 1090 4 in in IN 40288 1090 5 which which WDT 40288 1090 6 the the DT 40288 1090 7 letters letter NNS 40288 1090 8 are be VBP 40288 1090 9 taken take VBN 40288 1090 10 for for IN 40288 1090 11 the the DT 40288 1090 12 several several JJ 40288 1090 13 notes note NNS 40288 1090 14 has have VBZ 40288 1090 15 no no DT 40288 1090 16 historical historical JJ 40288 1090 17 importance importance NN 40288 1090 18 . . . 40288 1091 1 2 2 LS 40288 1091 2 . . . 40288 1092 1 The the DT 40288 1092 2 notation notation NN 40288 1092 3 does do VBZ 40288 1092 4 not not RB 40288 1092 5 represent represent VB 40288 1092 6 only only RB 40288 1092 7 the the DT 40288 1092 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1092 9 species specie NNS 40288 1092 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1092 11 of of IN 40288 1092 12 a a DT 40288 1092 13 scale scale NN 40288 1092 14 , , , 40288 1092 15 that that DT 40288 1092 16 is be VBZ 40288 1092 17 to to TO 40288 1092 18 say say VB 40288 1092 19 , , , 40288 1092 20 the the DT 40288 1092 21 relative relative JJ 40288 1092 22 pitch pitch NN 40288 1092 23 of of IN 40288 1092 24 the the DT 40288 1092 25 notes note NNS 40288 1092 26 which which WDT 40288 1092 27 compose compose VBP 40288 1092 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1092 29 , , , 40288 1092 30 but but CC 40288 1092 31 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1092 32 represents represent VBZ 40288 1092 33 also also RB 40288 1092 34 the the DT 40288 1092 35 absolute absolute JJ 40288 1092 36 pitch pitch NN 40288 1092 37 of of IN 40288 1092 38 each each DT 40288 1092 39 note note NN 40288 1092 40 . . . 40288 1093 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1093 2 the the DT 40288 1093 3 octaves octave NNS 40288 1093 4 which which WDT 40288 1093 5 are be VBP 40288 1093 6 defined define VBN 40288 1093 7 by by IN 40288 1093 8 the the DT 40288 1093 9 successive successive JJ 40288 1093 10 pairs pair NNS 40288 1093 11 of of IN 40288 1093 12 letters letter NNS 40288 1093 13 , , , 40288 1093 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1093 15 Greek greek NN 40288 1093 16 : : : 40288 1093 17 b b LS 40288 1093 18 - - HYPH 40288 1093 19 g g NNP 40288 1093 20 , , , 40288 1093 21 d d NNP 40288 1093 22 - - HYPH 40288 1093 23 e e NNP 40288 1093 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1093 25 , , , 40288 1093 26 and and CC 40288 1093 27 the the DT 40288 1093 28 rest rest NN 40288 1093 29 , , , 40288 1093 30 are be VBP 40288 1093 31 octaves octave NNS 40288 1093 32 of of IN 40288 1093 33 definite definite JJ 40288 1093 34 notes note NNS 40288 1093 35 . . . 40288 1094 1 If if IN 40288 1094 2 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1094 3 were be VBD 40288 1094 4 framed frame VBN 40288 1094 5 with with IN 40288 1094 6 a a DT 40288 1094 7 view view NN 40288 1094 8 to to IN 40288 1094 9 the the DT 40288 1094 10 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1094 11 modes mode NNS 40288 1094 12 , , , 40288 1094 13 as as IN 40288 1094 14 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1094 15 thinks think VBZ 40288 1094 16 , , , 40288 1094 17 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1094 18 must must MD 40288 1094 19 be be VB 40288 1094 20 the the DT 40288 1094 21 actual actual JJ 40288 1094 22 scales scale NNS 40288 1094 23 employed employ VBN 40288 1094 24 in in IN 40288 1094 25 these these DT 40288 1094 26 modes mode NNS 40288 1094 27 . . . 40288 1095 1 If if IN 40288 1095 2 so so RB 40288 1095 3 , , , 40288 1095 4 the the DT 40288 1095 5 modes mode NNS 40288 1095 6 followed follow VBD 40288 1095 7 each each DT 40288 1095 8 other other JJ 40288 1095 9 , , , 40288 1095 10 in in IN 40288 1095 11 respect respect NN 40288 1095 12 of of IN 40288 1095 13 pitch pitch NN 40288 1095 14 , , , 40288 1095 15 in in IN 40288 1095 16 an an DT 40288 1095 17 order order NN 40288 1095 18 exactly exactly RB 40288 1095 19 the the DT 40288 1095 20 reverse reverse NN 40288 1095 21 of of IN 40288 1095 22 the the DT 40288 1095 23 order order NN 40288 1095 24 observed observe VBN 40288 1095 25 in in IN 40288 1095 26 the the DT 40288 1095 27 keys key NNS 40288 1095 28 . . . 40288 1096 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1096 2 need nee MD 40288 1096 3 hardly hardly RB 40288 1096 4 be be VB 40288 1096 5 said say VBN 40288 1096 6 that that IN 40288 1096 7 this this DT 40288 1096 8 is be VBZ 40288 1096 9 quite quite RB 40288 1096 10 impossible impossible JJ 40288 1096 11 . . . 40288 1097 1 § § ADD 40288 1097 2 29 29 CD 40288 1097 3 . . . 40288 1098 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1098 2 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1098 3 's 's POS 40288 1098 4 Scheme Scheme NNP 40288 1098 5 of of IN 40288 1098 6 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1098 7 . . . 40288 1098 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1098 9 The the DT 40288 1098 10 first first JJ 40288 1098 11 writer writer NN 40288 1098 12 who who WP 40288 1098 13 takes take VBZ 40288 1098 14 the the DT 40288 1098 15 Species Species NNPS 40288 1098 16 of of IN 40288 1098 17 the the DT 40288 1098 18 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1098 19 as as IN 40288 1098 20 the the DT 40288 1098 21 basis basis NN 40288 1098 22 of of IN 40288 1098 23 the the DT 40288 1098 24 musical musical JJ 40288 1098 25 scales scale NNS 40288 1098 26 is be VBZ 40288 1098 27 the the DT 40288 1098 28 mathematician mathematician JJ 40288 1098 29 Claudius Claudius NNP 40288 1098 30 Ptolemaeus Ptolemaeus NNP 40288 1098 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1098 32 fl fl NN 40288 1098 33 . . . 40288 1099 1 140 140 CD 40288 1099 2 - - SYM 40288 1099 3 160 160 CD 40288 1099 4 A.D. A.D. NNP 40288 1099 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1099 6 . . . 40288 1100 1 In in IN 40288 1100 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1100 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1100 4 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 1100 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1100 6 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1100 7 virtually virtually RB 40288 1100 8 sets set VBZ 40288 1100 9 aside aside RB 40288 1100 10 the the DT 40288 1100 11 scheme scheme NN 40288 1100 12 of of IN 40288 1100 13 keys key NNS 40288 1100 14 elaborated elaborate VBN 40288 1100 15 by by IN 40288 1100 16 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1100 17 and and CC 40288 1100 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1100 19 school school NN 40288 1100 20 , , , 40288 1100 21 and and CC 40288 1100 22 adopts adopt VBZ 40288 1100 23 in in IN 40288 1100 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1100 25 place place NN 40288 1100 26 a a DT 40288 1100 27 system system NN 40288 1100 28 of of IN 40288 1100 29 scales scale NNS 40288 1100 30 answering answer VBG 40288 1100 31 in in IN 40288 1100 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1100 33 main main JJ 40288 1100 34 features feature NNS 40288 1100 35 to to IN 40288 1100 36 the the DT 40288 1100 37 mediaeval mediaeval JJ 40288 1100 38 Tones Tones NNPS 40288 1100 39 or or CC 40288 1100 40 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1100 41 . . . 40288 1101 1 The the DT 40288 1101 2 object object NN 40288 1101 3 of of IN 40288 1101 4 difference difference NN 40288 1101 5 of of IN 40288 1101 6 key key NN 40288 1101 7 , , , 40288 1101 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1101 9 says say VBZ 40288 1101 10 , , , 40288 1101 11 is be VBZ 40288 1101 12 not not RB 40288 1101 13 that that IN 40288 1101 14 the the DT 40288 1101 15 music music NN 40288 1101 16 as as IN 40288 1101 17 a a DT 40288 1101 18 whole whole NN 40288 1101 19 may may MD 40288 1101 20 be be VB 40288 1101 21 of of IN 40288 1101 22 a a DT 40288 1101 23 higher high JJR 40288 1101 24 or or CC 40288 1101 25 lower low JJR 40288 1101 26 pitch pitch NN 40288 1101 27 , , , 40288 1101 28 but but CC 40288 1101 29 that that IN 40288 1101 30 a a DT 40288 1101 31 melody melody NN 40288 1101 32 may may MD 40288 1101 33 be be VB 40288 1101 34 brought bring VBN 40288 1101 35 within within IN 40288 1101 36 a a DT 40288 1101 37 certain certain JJ 40288 1101 38 compass compass NN 40288 1101 39 . . . 40288 1102 1 For for IN 40288 1102 2 this this DT 40288 1102 3 purpose purpose NN 40288 1102 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1102 5 is be VBZ 40288 1102 6 necessary necessary JJ 40288 1102 7 to to TO 40288 1102 8 vary vary VB 40288 1102 9 the the DT 40288 1102 10 succession succession NN 40288 1102 11 of of IN 40288 1102 12 intervals interval NNS 40288 1102 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1102 14 as as IN 40288 1102 15 a a DT 40288 1102 16 modern modern JJ 40288 1102 17 musician musician NN 40288 1102 18 does do VBZ 40288 1102 19 by by IN 40288 1102 20 changing change VBG 40288 1102 21 the the DT 40288 1102 22 signature signature NN 40288 1102 23 of of IN 40288 1102 24 the the DT 40288 1102 25 clef clef NNS 40288 1102 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1102 27 . . . 40288 1103 1 If if IN 40288 1103 2 , , , 40288 1103 3 for for IN 40288 1103 4 example example NN 40288 1103 5 , , , 40288 1103 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1103 7 take take VBP 40288 1103 8 the the DT 40288 1103 9 Perfect perfect JJ 40288 1103 10 System system NN 40288 1103 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1103 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1103 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1103 14 : : : 40288 1103 15 systêma systêma NN 40288 1103 16 ametabolon ametabolon NN 40288 1103 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1103 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1103 19 in in IN 40288 1103 20 the the DT 40288 1103 21 key key NN 40288 1103 22 of of IN 40288 1103 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 24 a a DT 40288 1103 25 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 26 minor minor NN 40288 1103 27 -- -- : 40288 1103 28 which which WDT 40288 1103 29 is be VBZ 40288 1103 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1103 31 natural natural JJ 40288 1103 32 key,--and key,--and NNP 40288 1103 33 transpose transpose VB 40288 1103 34 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1103 35 to to IN 40288 1103 36 the the DT 40288 1103 37 key key NN 40288 1103 38 of of IN 40288 1103 39 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 40 d d NNP 40288 1103 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 42 minor minor NN 40288 1103 43 , , , 40288 1103 44 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1103 45 do do VBP 40288 1103 46 so so RB 40288 1103 47 , , , 40288 1103 48 according accord VBG 40288 1103 49 to to IN 40288 1103 50 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1103 51 , , , 40288 1103 52 not not RB 40288 1103 53 in in IN 40288 1103 54 order order NN 40288 1103 55 to to TO 40288 1103 56 raise raise VB 40288 1103 57 the the DT 40288 1103 58 general general JJ 40288 1103 59 pitch pitch NN 40288 1103 60 of of IN 40288 1103 61 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1103 62 music music NN 40288 1103 63 by by IN 40288 1103 64 a a DT 40288 1103 65 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1103 66 , , , 40288 1103 67 but but CC 40288 1103 68 because because IN 40288 1103 69 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1103 70 wish wish VBP 40288 1103 71 to to TO 40288 1103 72 have have VB 40288 1103 73 a a DT 40288 1103 74 scale scale NN 40288 1103 75 with with IN 40288 1103 76 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 77 b b NNP 40288 1103 78 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 79 flat flat JJ 40288 1103 80 instead instead RB 40288 1103 81 of of IN 40288 1103 82 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 83 b b NNP 40288 1103 84 _ _ NNP 40288 1103 85 natural natural NN 40288 1103 86 . . . 40288 1104 1 The the DT 40288 1104 2 flattening flattening NN 40288 1104 3 of of IN 40288 1104 4 this this DT 40288 1104 5 note note NN 40288 1104 6 , , , 40288 1104 7 however however RB 40288 1104 8 , , , 40288 1104 9 means mean VBZ 40288 1104 10 that that IN 40288 1104 11 the the DT 40288 1104 12 two two CD 40288 1104 13 octaves octave NNS 40288 1104 14 change change VBP 40288 1104 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1104 16 species specie NNS 40288 1104 17 . . . 40288 1105 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1105 2 are be VBP 40288 1105 3 now now RB 40288 1105 4 of of IN 40288 1105 5 the the DT 40288 1105 6 species specie NNS 40288 1105 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1105 8 e e NNP 40288 1105 9 - - HYPH 40288 1105 10 e e NNP 40288 1105 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1105 12 . . . 40288 1106 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1106 2 , , , 40288 1106 3 instead instead RB 40288 1106 4 of of IN 40288 1106 5 transposing transpose VBG 40288 1106 6 the the DT 40288 1106 7 Perfect perfect JJ 40288 1106 8 System System NNP 40288 1106 9 into into IN 40288 1106 10 different different JJ 40288 1106 11 keys key NNS 40288 1106 12 , , , 40288 1106 13 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1106 14 arrive arrive VBP 40288 1106 15 more more RBR 40288 1106 16 directly directly RB 40288 1106 17 at at IN 40288 1106 18 the the DT 40288 1106 19 desired desire VBN 40288 1106 20 result result NN 40288 1106 21 by by IN 40288 1106 22 changing change VBG 40288 1106 23 the the DT 40288 1106 24 species specie NNS 40288 1106 25 of of IN 40288 1106 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1106 27 octaves octave NNS 40288 1106 28 . . . 40288 1107 1 And and CC 40288 1107 2 as as IN 40288 1107 3 there there EX 40288 1107 4 are be VBP 40288 1107 5 seven seven CD 40288 1107 6 possible possible JJ 40288 1107 7 species specie NNS 40288 1107 8 of of IN 40288 1107 9 the the DT 40288 1107 10 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1107 11 , , , 40288 1107 12 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1107 13 obtain obtain VBP 40288 1107 14 seven seven CD 40288 1107 15 different different JJ 40288 1107 16 Systems system NNS 40288 1107 17 or or CC 40288 1107 18 scales scale NNS 40288 1107 19 . . . 40288 1108 1 From from IN 40288 1108 2 these these DT 40288 1108 3 assumptions assumption NNS 40288 1108 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1108 5 follows follow VBZ 40288 1108 6 , , , 40288 1108 7 as as IN 40288 1108 8 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1108 9 shows show VBZ 40288 1108 10 in in IN 40288 1108 11 some some DT 40288 1108 12 detail detail NN 40288 1108 13 , , , 40288 1108 14 that that IN 40288 1108 15 any any DT 40288 1108 16 greater great JJR 40288 1108 17 number number NN 40288 1108 18 of of IN 40288 1108 19 keys key NNS 40288 1108 20 is be VBZ 40288 1108 21 useless useless JJ 40288 1108 22 . . . 40288 1109 1 If if IN 40288 1109 2 a a DT 40288 1109 3 key key NN 40288 1109 4 is be VBZ 40288 1109 5 an an DT 40288 1109 6 octave octave NN 40288 1109 7 higher high JJR 40288 1109 8 than than IN 40288 1109 9 another another DT 40288 1109 10 , , , 40288 1109 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1109 12 is be VBZ 40288 1109 13 superfluous superfluous JJ 40288 1109 14 because because IN 40288 1109 15 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1109 16 gives give VBZ 40288 1109 17 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1109 18 a a DT 40288 1109 19 mere mere JJ 40288 1109 20 repetition repetition NN 40288 1109 21 of of IN 40288 1109 22 the the DT 40288 1109 23 same same JJ 40288 1109 24 intervals[1 intervals[1 NNP 40288 1109 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1109 26 . . . 40288 1110 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1110 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1110 3 1 1 CD 40288 1110 4 : : : 40288 1110 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1110 6 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1110 7 . . . 40288 1110 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1110 9 ii ii NNP 40288 1110 10 . . . 40288 1111 1 8 8 LS 40288 1111 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1111 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1111 4 : : : 40288 1111 5 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1111 6 de de NNP 40288 1111 7 hyperekpiptontes hyperekpiptontes NNP 40288 1111 8 tou tou NNP 40288 1111 9 dia dia NNP 40288 1111 10 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 1111 11 tous tous NNP 40288 1111 12 ap ap NNP 40288 1111 13 ' ' '' 40288 1111 14 autou autou NNP 40288 1111 15 tou tou NNP 40288 1111 16 dia dia NNP 40288 1111 17 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 1111 18 apôterô apôterô NNP 40288 1111 19 parelkontôs parelkontôs NNP 40288 1111 20 hypotithentai hypotithentai NNP 40288 1111 21 , , , 40288 1111 22 tous tous JJ 40288 1111 23 autous autous JJ 40288 1111 24 aei aei CC 40288 1111 25 ginomenous ginomenous JJ 40288 1111 26 tois tois NNP 40288 1111 27 proeilêmmenois proeilêmmenois NNP 40288 1111 28 . . . 40288 1111 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1111 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1112 1 If if IN 40288 1112 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1112 3 interpose interpose VBP 40288 1112 4 a a DT 40288 1112 5 key key NN 40288 1112 6 between between IN 40288 1112 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1112 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1112 9 e.g. e.g. NNP 40288 1112 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1112 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1112 12 the the DT 40288 1112 13 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1112 14 - - HYPH 40288 1112 15 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1112 16 and and CC 40288 1112 17 the the DT 40288 1112 18 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1112 19 - - HYPH 40288 1112 20 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1112 21 , , , 40288 1112 22 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1112 23 must must MD 40288 1112 24 give give VB 40288 1112 25 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1112 26 over over RP 40288 1112 27 again again RB 40288 1112 28 either either CC 40288 1112 29 the the DT 40288 1112 30 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1112 31 - - HYPH 40288 1112 32 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1112 33 or or CC 40288 1112 34 the the DT 40288 1112 35 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1112 36 - - HYPH 40288 1112 37 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1112 38 scale[1 scale[1 NNP 40288 1112 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1112 40 . . . 40288 1113 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1113 2 the the DT 40288 1113 3 fifteen fifteen CD 40288 1113 4 keys key NNS 40288 1113 5 of of IN 40288 1113 6 the the DT 40288 1113 7 Aristoxeneans Aristoxeneans NNPS 40288 1113 8 are be VBP 40288 1113 9 reduced reduce VBN 40288 1113 10 to to IN 40288 1113 11 seven seven CD 40288 1113 12 , , , 40288 1113 13 and and CC 40288 1113 14 these these DT 40288 1113 15 seven seven CD 40288 1113 16 are be VBP 40288 1113 17 not not RB 40288 1113 18 transpositions transposition NNS 40288 1113 19 of of IN 40288 1113 20 a a DT 40288 1113 21 single single JJ 40288 1113 22 scale scale NN 40288 1113 23 , , , 40288 1113 24 but but CC 40288 1113 25 are be VBP 40288 1113 26 all all DT 40288 1113 27 of of IN 40288 1113 28 the the DT 40288 1113 29 same same JJ 40288 1113 30 pitch pitch NN 40288 1113 31 . . . 40288 1114 1 See see VB 40288 1114 2 the the DT 40288 1114 3 table table NN 40288 1114 4 at at IN 40288 1114 5 the the DT 40288 1114 6 end end NN 40288 1114 7 of of IN 40288 1114 8 the the DT 40288 1114 9 book book NN 40288 1114 10 . . . 40288 1115 1 With with IN 40288 1115 2 this this DT 40288 1115 3 scheme scheme NN 40288 1115 4 of of IN 40288 1115 5 Keys Keys NNP 40288 1115 6 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1115 7 combined combine VBD 40288 1115 8 a a DT 40288 1115 9 new new JJ 40288 1115 10 method method NN 40288 1115 11 of of IN 40288 1115 12 naming name VBG 40288 1115 13 the the DT 40288 1115 14 individual individual JJ 40288 1115 15 notes note NNS 40288 1115 16 . . . 40288 1116 1 The the DT 40288 1116 2 old old JJ 40288 1116 3 method method NN 40288 1116 4 , , , 40288 1116 5 by by IN 40288 1116 6 which which WDT 40288 1116 7 a a DT 40288 1116 8 note note NN 40288 1116 9 was be VBD 40288 1116 10 named name VBN 40288 1116 11 from from IN 40288 1116 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1116 13 relative relative JJ 40288 1116 14 place place NN 40288 1116 15 in in IN 40288 1116 16 the the DT 40288 1116 17 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1116 18 System System NNP 40288 1116 19 , , , 40288 1116 20 must must MD 40288 1116 21 evidently evidently RB 40288 1116 22 have have VB 40288 1116 23 become become VBN 40288 1116 24 inconvenient inconvenient JJ 40288 1116 25 . . . 40288 1117 1 The the DT 40288 1117 2 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1117 3 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1117 4 , , , 40288 1117 5 for for IN 40288 1117 6 example example NN 40288 1117 7 , , , 40288 1117 8 was be VBD 40288 1117 9 two two CD 40288 1117 10 tones tone NNS 40288 1117 11 higher high JJR 40288 1117 12 than than IN 40288 1117 13 the the DT 40288 1117 14 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1117 15 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1117 16 , , , 40288 1117 17 because because IN 40288 1117 18 the the DT 40288 1117 19 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1117 20 scale scale NN 40288 1117 21 as as IN 40288 1117 22 a a DT 40288 1117 23 whole whole NN 40288 1117 24 was be VBD 40288 1117 25 two two CD 40288 1117 26 tones tone NNS 40288 1117 27 higher high JJR 40288 1117 28 than than IN 40288 1117 29 the the DT 40288 1117 30 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1117 31 . . . 40288 1118 1 But but CC 40288 1118 2 when when WRB 40288 1118 3 the the DT 40288 1118 4 two two CD 40288 1118 5 scales scale NNS 40288 1118 6 were be VBD 40288 1118 7 reduced reduce VBN 40288 1118 8 to to IN 40288 1118 9 the the DT 40288 1118 10 same same JJ 40288 1118 11 compass compass NN 40288 1118 12 , , , 40288 1118 13 the the DT 40288 1118 14 old old JJ 40288 1118 15 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1118 16 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1118 17 was be VBD 40288 1118 18 no no RB 40288 1118 19 longer long RBR 40288 1118 20 in in IN 40288 1118 21 the the DT 40288 1118 22 middle middle NN 40288 1118 23 of of IN 40288 1118 24 the the DT 40288 1118 25 scale scale NN 40288 1118 26 , , , 40288 1118 27 and and CC 40288 1118 28 the the DT 40288 1118 29 name name NN 40288 1118 30 ceased cease VBD 40288 1118 31 to to TO 40288 1118 32 have have VB 40288 1118 33 a a DT 40288 1118 34 meaning meaning NN 40288 1118 35 . . . 40288 1119 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1119 2 is be VBZ 40288 1119 3 as as IN 40288 1119 4 though though IN 40288 1119 5 the the DT 40288 1119 6 term term NN 40288 1119 7 ' ' `` 40288 1119 8 dominant dominant NN 40288 1119 9 ' ' '' 40288 1119 10 when when WRB 40288 1119 11 applied apply VBN 40288 1119 12 to to IN 40288 1119 13 a a DT 40288 1119 14 Minor minor JJ 40288 1119 15 key key NN 40288 1119 16 were be VBD 40288 1119 17 made make VBN 40288 1119 18 to to TO 40288 1119 19 mean mean VB 40288 1119 20 the the DT 40288 1119 21 dominant dominant NN 40288 1119 22 of of IN 40288 1119 23 the the DT 40288 1119 24 relative relative JJ 40288 1119 25 Major major JJ 40288 1119 26 key key NN 40288 1119 27 . . . 40288 1120 1 On on IN 40288 1120 2 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1120 3 's 's POS 40288 1120 4 method method NN 40288 1120 5 the the DT 40288 1120 6 notes note NNS 40288 1120 7 of of IN 40288 1120 8 each each DT 40288 1120 9 scale scale NN 40288 1120 10 were be VBD 40288 1120 11 named name VBN 40288 1120 12 from from IN 40288 1120 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1120 14 places place NNS 40288 1120 15 in in IN 40288 1120 16 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1120 17 . . . 40288 1121 1 The the DT 40288 1121 2 old old JJ 40288 1121 3 names name NNS 40288 1121 4 were be VBD 40288 1121 5 used use VBN 40288 1121 6 , , , 40288 1121 7 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 1121 8 for for IN 40288 1121 9 the the DT 40288 1121 10 lowest low JJS 40288 1121 11 , , , 40288 1121 12 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1121 13 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 1121 14 for for IN 40288 1121 15 the the DT 40288 1121 16 next next JJ 40288 1121 17 , , , 40288 1121 18 and and CC 40288 1121 19 so so RB 40288 1121 20 on on RB 40288 1121 21 , , , 40288 1121 22 but but CC 40288 1121 23 without without IN 40288 1121 24 regard regard NN 40288 1121 25 to to IN 40288 1121 26 the the DT 40288 1121 27 intervals interval NNS 40288 1121 28 between between IN 40288 1121 29 the the DT 40288 1121 30 notes note NNS 40288 1121 31 . . . 40288 1122 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1122 2 there there EX 40288 1122 3 were be VBD 40288 1122 4 two two CD 40288 1122 5 methods method NNS 40288 1122 6 of of IN 40288 1122 7 naming naming NN 40288 1122 8 , , , 40288 1122 9 that that WDT 40288 1122 10 which which WDT 40288 1122 11 had have VBD 40288 1122 12 been be VBN 40288 1122 13 in in IN 40288 1122 14 use use NN 40288 1122 15 hitherto hitherto JJ 40288 1122 16 , , , 40288 1122 17 termed term VBN 40288 1122 18 ' ' '' 40288 1122 19 nomenclature nomenclature NN 40288 1122 20 according accord VBG 40288 1122 21 to to IN 40288 1122 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1122 23 value value NN 40288 1122 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1122 25 ' ' '' 40288 1122 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1122 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1122 28 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1122 29 : : : 40288 1122 30 onomasia onomasia NNP 40288 1122 31 kata kata NNP 40288 1122 32 dynamin dynamin NNP 40288 1122 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1122 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1122 35 , , , 40288 1122 36 and and CC 40288 1122 37 the the DT 40288 1122 38 new new JJ 40288 1122 39 method method NN 40288 1122 40 of of IN 40288 1122 41 naming name VBG 40288 1122 42 from from IN 40288 1122 43 the the DT 40288 1122 44 various various JJ 40288 1122 45 scales scale NNS 40288 1122 46 , , , 40288 1122 47 termed term VBN 40288 1122 48 ' ' '' 40288 1122 49 nomenclature nomenclature NN 40288 1122 50 according accord VBG 40288 1122 51 to to IN 40288 1122 52 _ _ NNP 40288 1122 53 position position NN 40288 1122 54 _ _ NNP 40288 1122 55 ' ' '' 40288 1122 56 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1122 57 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1122 58 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1122 59 : : : 40288 1122 60 onomasia onomasia NNP 40288 1122 61 kata kata NNP 40288 1122 62 thesin thesin NNP 40288 1122 63 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1122 64 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1122 65 . . . 40288 1123 1 The the DT 40288 1123 2 former former JJ 40288 1123 3 was be VBD 40288 1123 4 in in IN 40288 1123 5 effect effect NN 40288 1123 6 a a DT 40288 1123 7 retention retention NN 40288 1123 8 of of IN 40288 1123 9 the the DT 40288 1123 10 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1123 11 System System NNP 40288 1123 12 and and CC 40288 1123 13 the the DT 40288 1123 14 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 1123 15 : : : 40288 1123 16 the the DT 40288 1123 17 latter latter JJ 40288 1123 18 put put NN 40288 1123 19 in in IN 40288 1123 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1123 21 place place NN 40288 1123 22 a a DT 40288 1123 23 scheme scheme NN 40288 1123 24 of of IN 40288 1123 25 seven seven CD 40288 1123 26 different different JJ 40288 1123 27 standard standard JJ 40288 1123 28 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 1123 29 . . . 40288 1124 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1124 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1124 3 1 1 CD 40288 1124 4 : : : 40288 1124 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1124 6 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1124 7 . . . 40288 1124 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1124 9 ii ii NNP 40288 1124 10 . . . 40288 1125 1 11 11 CD 40288 1125 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1125 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1125 4 : : : 40288 1125 5 hôste hôste NN 40288 1125 6 mêd mêd NN 40288 1125 7 ' ' '' 40288 1125 8 an an DT 40288 1125 9 heteron heteron NNP 40288 1125 10 eti eti NNP 40288 1125 11 doxai doxai VBD 40288 1125 12 tô tô NNP 40288 1125 13 eidei eidei NNP 40288 1125 14 ton ton NNP 40288 1125 15 tonon tonon NNP 40288 1125 16 para para NNP 40288 1125 17 ton ton NNP 40288 1125 18 proteron proteron NN 40288 1125 19 , , , 40288 1125 20 all all DT 40288 1125 21 ' ' `` 40288 1125 22 hypodôrion hypodôrion NN 40288 1125 23 palin palin NNP 40288 1125 24 , , , 40288 1125 25 ê ê NNP 40288 1125 26 ton ton VBD 40288 1125 27 auton auton NNP 40288 1125 28 hypophrygion hypophrygion NN 40288 1125 29 , , , 40288 1125 30 oxyphônoteron oxyphônoteron NNP 40288 1125 31 tinos tinos NNP 40288 1125 32 ê ê NNP 40288 1125 33 baryphônoteron baryphônoteron NNP 40288 1125 34 monon monon NNP 40288 1125 35 . . . 40288 1125 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1125 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1126 1 In in IN 40288 1126 2 illustration illustration NN 40288 1126 3 of of IN 40288 1126 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1126 5 theory theory NN 40288 1126 6 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1126 7 gives give VBZ 40288 1126 8 tables table NNS 40288 1126 9 showing show VBG 40288 1126 10 in in IN 40288 1126 11 numbers number NNS 40288 1126 12 the the DT 40288 1126 13 intervals interval NNS 40288 1126 14 of of IN 40288 1126 15 the the DT 40288 1126 16 octaves octave NNS 40288 1126 17 used use VBN 40288 1126 18 in in IN 40288 1126 19 the the DT 40288 1126 20 different different JJ 40288 1126 21 keys key NNS 40288 1126 22 and and CC 40288 1126 23 genera genera NN 40288 1126 24 . . . 40288 1127 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1127 2 shows show VBZ 40288 1127 3 two two CD 40288 1127 4 octaves octave NNS 40288 1127 5 in in IN 40288 1127 6 each each DT 40288 1127 7 key key NN 40288 1127 8 , , , 40288 1127 9 viz viz NN 40288 1127 10 . . . 40288 1128 1 that that IN 40288 1128 2 from from IN 40288 1128 3 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1128 4 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1128 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1128 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1128 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1128 8 : : : 40288 1128 9 kata kata NNP 40288 1128 10 thesin thesin NNP 40288 1128 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1128 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1128 13 to to IN 40288 1128 14 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1128 15 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1128 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1128 17 called call VBN 40288 1128 18 the the DT 40288 1128 19 octave octave NN 40288 1128 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1128 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1128 22 : : : 40288 1128 23 apo apo NNP 40288 1128 24 nêtês nêtês NNP 40288 1128 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1128 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1128 27 , , , 40288 1128 28 and and CC 40288 1128 29 that that IN 40288 1128 30 from from IN 40288 1128 31 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 1128 32 to to IN 40288 1128 33 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1128 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1128 35 the the DT 40288 1128 36 octave octave NN 40288 1128 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1128 38 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1128 39 : : : 40288 1128 40 apo apo NNP 40288 1128 41 mesês mesês NN 40288 1128 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1128 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1128 44 . . . 40288 1129 1 As as IN 40288 1129 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1129 3 also also RB 40288 1129 4 gives give VBZ 40288 1129 5 the the DT 40288 1129 6 divisions division NNS 40288 1129 7 of of IN 40288 1129 8 five five CD 40288 1129 9 different different JJ 40288 1129 10 ' ' '' 40288 1129 11 colours colour NNS 40288 1129 12 ' ' '' 40288 1129 13 or or CC 40288 1129 14 varieties variety NNS 40288 1129 15 of of IN 40288 1129 16 genus genus NNP 40288 1129 17 , , , 40288 1129 18 the the DT 40288 1129 19 whole whole JJ 40288 1129 20 number number NN 40288 1129 21 of of IN 40288 1129 22 octaves octave NNS 40288 1129 23 is be VBZ 40288 1129 24 no no RB 40288 1129 25 less less JJR 40288 1129 26 than than IN 40288 1129 27 seventy seventy CD 40288 1129 28 . . . 40288 1130 1 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1130 2 does do VBZ 40288 1130 3 not not RB 40288 1130 4 exclude exclude VB 40288 1130 5 difference difference NN 40288 1130 6 of of IN 40288 1130 7 pitch pitch NN 40288 1130 8 altogether altogether RB 40288 1130 9 . . . 40288 1131 1 The the DT 40288 1131 2 whole whole JJ 40288 1131 3 instrument instrument NN 40288 1131 4 , , , 40288 1131 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1131 6 says say VBZ 40288 1131 7 , , , 40288 1131 8 may may MD 40288 1131 9 be be VB 40288 1131 10 tuned tune VBN 40288 1131 11 higher higher RBR 40288 1131 12 or or CC 40288 1131 13 lower low JJR 40288 1131 14 at at IN 40288 1131 15 pleasure[1 pleasure[1 NNP 40288 1131 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1131 17 . . . 40288 1132 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1132 2 the the DT 40288 1132 3 pitch pitch NN 40288 1132 4 is be VBZ 40288 1132 5 treated treat VBN 40288 1132 6 by by IN 40288 1132 7 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1132 8 as as IN 40288 1132 9 modern modern JJ 40288 1132 10 notation notation NN 40288 1132 11 treats treat VBZ 40288 1132 12 the the DT 40288 1132 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1132 14 tempo tempo NN 40288 1132 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1132 16 , , , 40288 1132 17 viz viz NN 40288 1132 18 . . . 40288 1133 1 as as IN 40288 1133 2 something something NN 40288 1133 3 which which WDT 40288 1133 4 is be VBZ 40288 1133 5 not not RB 40288 1133 6 absolutely absolutely RB 40288 1133 7 given give VBN 40288 1133 8 , , , 40288 1133 9 but but CC 40288 1133 10 has have VBZ 40288 1133 11 to to TO 40288 1133 12 be be VB 40288 1133 13 supplied supply VBN 40288 1133 14 by by IN 40288 1133 15 the the DT 40288 1133 16 individual individual JJ 40288 1133 17 performer performer NN 40288 1133 18 . . . 40288 1134 1 Although although IN 40288 1134 2 the the DT 40288 1134 3 language language NN 40288 1134 4 of of IN 40288 1134 5 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1134 6 's 's POS 40288 1134 7 exposition exposition NN 40288 1134 8 is be VBZ 40288 1134 9 studiously studiously RB 40288 1134 10 impersonal impersonal JJ 40288 1134 11 , , , 40288 1134 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1134 13 may may MD 40288 1134 14 be be VB 40288 1134 15 gathered gather VBN 40288 1134 16 that that IN 40288 1134 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1134 18 reduction reduction NN 40288 1134 19 of of IN 40288 1134 20 the the DT 40288 1134 21 number number NN 40288 1134 22 of of IN 40288 1134 23 keys key NNS 40288 1134 24 from from IN 40288 1134 25 fifteen fifteen CD 40288 1134 26 to to IN 40288 1134 27 seven seven CD 40288 1134 28 was be VBD 40288 1134 29 an an DT 40288 1134 30 innovation innovation NN 40288 1134 31 proposed propose VBN 40288 1134 32 by by IN 40288 1134 33 himself[2 himself[2 NNP 40288 1134 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1134 35 . . . 40288 1135 1 If if IN 40288 1135 2 this this DT 40288 1135 3 is be VBZ 40288 1135 4 so so RB 40288 1135 5 , , , 40288 1135 6 the the DT 40288 1135 7 rest rest NN 40288 1135 8 of of IN 40288 1135 9 the the DT 40288 1135 10 scheme,--the scheme,--the NNP 40288 1135 11 elimination elimination NN 40288 1135 12 of of IN 40288 1135 13 the the DT 40288 1135 14 element element NN 40288 1135 15 of of IN 40288 1135 16 pitch pitch NN 40288 1135 17 , , , 40288 1135 18 and and CC 40288 1135 19 the the DT 40288 1135 20 ' ' `` 40288 1135 21 nomenclature nomenclature JJ 40288 1135 22 by by IN 40288 1135 23 position,'--must position,'--must NNS 40288 1135 24 also also RB 40288 1135 25 be be VB 40288 1135 26 due due JJ 40288 1135 27 to to IN 40288 1135 28 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1135 29 . . . 40288 1136 1 Here here RB 40288 1136 2 , , , 40288 1136 3 however however RB 40288 1136 4 , , , 40288 1136 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1136 6 find find VBP 40288 1136 7 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40288 1136 8 at at IN 40288 1136 9 issue issue NN 40288 1136 10 with with IN 40288 1136 11 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1136 12 and and CC 40288 1136 13 those those DT 40288 1136 14 who who WP 40288 1136 15 agree agree VBP 40288 1136 16 with with IN 40288 1136 17 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1136 18 on on IN 40288 1136 19 the the DT 40288 1136 20 main main JJ 40288 1136 21 question question NN 40288 1136 22 of of IN 40288 1136 23 the the DT 40288 1136 24 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1136 25 . . . 40288 1137 1 According accord VBG 40288 1137 2 to to IN 40288 1137 3 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1137 4 the the DT 40288 1137 5 nomenclature nomenclature NN 40288 1137 6 by by IN 40288 1137 7 position position NN 40288 1137 8 is be VBZ 40288 1137 9 mentioned mention VBN 40288 1137 10 by by IN 40288 1137 11 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1137 12 , , , 40288 1137 13 and and CC 40288 1137 14 is be VBZ 40288 1137 15 implied imply VBN 40288 1137 16 in in IN 40288 1137 17 at at RB 40288 1137 18 least least RBS 40288 1137 19 one one CD 40288 1137 20 important important JJ 40288 1137 21 passage passage NN 40288 1137 22 of of IN 40288 1137 23 the the DT 40288 1137 24 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 1137 25 _ _ NNP 40288 1137 26 Problems Problems NNP 40288 1137 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1137 28 . . . 40288 1138 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1138 2 have have VBP 40288 1138 3 now now RB 40288 1138 4 to to TO 40288 1138 5 examine examine VB 40288 1138 6 the the DT 40288 1138 7 evidence evidence NN 40288 1138 8 which which WDT 40288 1138 9 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1138 10 adduces adduce VBZ 40288 1138 11 to to TO 40288 1138 12 support support VB 40288 1138 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1138 14 contention contention NN 40288 1138 15 . . . 40288 1139 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1139 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1139 3 1 1 CD 40288 1139 4 : : : 40288 1139 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1139 6 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1139 7 . . . 40288 1139 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1139 9 ii ii NNP 40288 1139 10 . . . 40288 1140 1 7 7 LS 40288 1140 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1140 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1140 4 : : : 40288 1140 5 pros pro NNS 40288 1140 6 tên tên NNP 40288 1140 7 toiautên toiautên NNP 40288 1140 8 diaphoran diaphoran NNP 40288 1140 9 hê hê NNP 40288 1140 10 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1140 11 organôn organôn NNP 40288 1140 12 holôn holôn NNP 40288 1140 13 epitasis epitasis NNP 40288 1140 14 ê ê NNP 40288 1140 15 palin palin NNP 40288 1140 16 anesis anesis NN 40288 1140 17 aparkei aparkei NNS 40288 1140 18 . . . 40288 1140 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1140 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1141 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1141 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1141 3 2 2 CD 40288 1141 4 : : : 40288 1141 5 This this DT 40288 1141 6 may may MD 40288 1141 7 be be VB 40288 1141 8 traced trace VBN 40288 1141 9 in in IN 40288 1141 10 the the DT 40288 1141 11 occasionally occasionally RB 40288 1141 12 controversial controversial JJ 40288 1141 13 tone tone NN 40288 1141 14 ; ; : 40288 1141 15 as as IN 40288 1141 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1141 17 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1141 18 . . . 40288 1141 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1141 20 ii ii NNP 40288 1141 21 . . . 40288 1142 1 7 7 LS 40288 1142 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1142 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1142 4 : : : 40288 1142 5 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1142 6 men man NNS 40288 1142 7 ep ep IN 40288 1142 8 ' ' '' 40288 1142 9 elatton elatton NNP 40288 1142 10 tou tou NNP 40288 1142 11 dia dia NNP 40288 1142 12 pasôn pasôn NNP 40288 1142 13 phthasantes phthasante NNS 40288 1142 14 , , , 40288 1142 15 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1142 16 d d NNP 40288 1142 17 ' ' `` 40288 1142 18 ep ep NNP 40288 1142 19 ' ' '' 40288 1142 20 auto auto NN 40288 1142 21 monon monon NNP 40288 1142 22 , , , 40288 1142 23 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1142 24 de de NNP 40288 1142 25 epi epi NNP 40288 1142 26 to to IN 40288 1142 27 meizon meizon NNP 40288 1142 28 toutou toutou NNP 40288 1142 29 , , , 40288 1142 30 prokopên prokopên NNP 40288 1142 31 tina tina NNP 40288 1142 32 schedon schedon NNP 40288 1142 33 toiautên toiautên NNP 40288 1142 34 aei aei NNP 40288 1142 35 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1142 36 neôterôn neôterôn NNP 40288 1142 37 para para NNP 40288 1142 38 tous tous NNP 40288 1142 39 palaioterous palaioterous JJ 40288 1142 40 thêrômenôn thêrômenôn NNP 40288 1142 41 , , , 40288 1142 42 anoikeion anoikeion NNP 40288 1142 43 tês tês NNP 40288 1142 44 peri peri NNP 40288 1142 45 to to TO 40288 1142 46 hêrmosmenon hêrmosmenon NNP 40288 1142 47 physeôs physeôs NNP 40288 1142 48 te te NNP 40288 1142 49 kai kai NNP 40288 1142 50 apokatastaseôs apokatastaseôs NNP 40288 1142 51 ; ; : 40288 1142 52 hê hê NNP 40288 1142 53 monê monê NNP 40288 1142 54 perainein perainein NN 40288 1142 55 anankaion anankaion NNP 40288 1142 56 esti esti NNP 40288 1142 57 tên tên NNP 40288 1142 58 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1142 59 esomenôn esomenôn NNP 40288 1142 60 akrôn akrôn NNP 40288 1142 61 tonôn tonôn NNP 40288 1142 62 diastasin diastasin NNP 40288 1142 63 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1142 64 . . . 40288 1143 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1143 2 may may MD 40288 1143 3 compare compare VB 40288 1143 4 c. c. NN 40288 1144 1 11 11 CD 40288 1144 2 . . . 40288 1144 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1145 1 § § ADD 40288 1145 2 30 30 CD 40288 1145 3 . . . 40288 1146 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1146 2 Nomenclature Nomenclature NNP 40288 1146 3 by by IN 40288 1146 4 Position Position NNP 40288 1146 5 . . . 40288 1146 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1146 7 Two two CD 40288 1146 8 passages passage NNS 40288 1146 9 of of IN 40288 1146 10 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1146 11 are be VBP 40288 1146 12 quoted quote VBN 40288 1146 13 by by IN 40288 1146 14 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1146 15 in in IN 40288 1146 16 support support NN 40288 1146 17 of of IN 40288 1146 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1146 19 contention contention NN 40288 1146 20 . . . 40288 1147 1 The the DT 40288 1147 2 first first JJ 40288 1147 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1147 4 p. p. NN 40288 1147 5 6 6 CD 40288 1147 6 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1147 7 . . . 40288 1147 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1148 1 is be VBZ 40288 1148 2 one one CD 40288 1148 3 in in IN 40288 1148 4 which which WDT 40288 1148 5 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1148 6 announces announce VBZ 40288 1148 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1148 8 intention intention NN 40288 1148 9 to to TO 40288 1148 10 treat treat VB 40288 1148 11 of of IN 40288 1148 12 Systems Systems NNPS 40288 1148 13 , , , 40288 1148 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1148 15 number number NN 40288 1148 16 and and CC 40288 1148 17 nature nature NN 40288 1148 18 : : : 40288 1148 19 ' ' '' 40288 1148 20 setting set VBG 40288 1148 21 out out RP 40288 1148 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1148 23 differences difference NNS 40288 1148 24 in in IN 40288 1148 25 respect respect NN 40288 1148 26 of of IN 40288 1148 27 compass compass NN 40288 1148 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1148 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1148 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1148 31 : : : 40288 1148 32 megethos megethos NN 40288 1148 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1148 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1148 35 , , , 40288 1148 36 and and CC 40288 1148 37 for for IN 40288 1148 38 each each DT 40288 1148 39 compass compass NN 40288 1148 40 the the DT 40288 1148 41 differences difference NNS 40288 1148 42 in in IN 40288 1148 43 form form NN 40288 1148 44 and and CC 40288 1148 45 composition composition NN 40288 1148 46 and and CC 40288 1148 47 position position NN 40288 1148 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1148 49 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1148 50 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1148 51 : : : 40288 1148 52 tas tas NNP 40288 1148 53 te te NNP 40288 1148 54 kata kata NNP 40288 1148 55 schêma schêma NNP 40288 1148 56 kai kai NNP 40288 1148 57 kata kata NNP 40288 1148 58 synthesin synthesin NNP 40288 1148 59 kai kai NNP 40288 1148 60 kata kata NNP 40288 1148 61 thesin thesin NNP 40288 1148 62 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1148 63 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1148 64 , , , 40288 1148 65 so so IN 40288 1148 66 that that IN 40288 1148 67 no no DT 40288 1148 68 element element NN 40288 1148 69 of of IN 40288 1148 70 melody,--either melody,--either NN 40288 1148 71 compass compass NN 40288 1148 72 or or CC 40288 1148 73 form form NN 40288 1148 74 or or CC 40288 1148 75 composition composition NN 40288 1148 76 or or CC 40288 1148 77 position,--may position,--may NNP 40288 1148 78 be be VB 40288 1148 79 unexplained unexplained JJ 40288 1148 80 . . . 40288 1148 81 ' ' '' 40288 1149 1 But but CC 40288 1149 2 the the DT 40288 1149 3 word word NN 40288 1149 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1149 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1149 6 : : : 40288 1149 7 thesis thesis NN 40288 1149 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1149 9 , , , 40288 1149 10 when when WRB 40288 1149 11 applied apply VBN 40288 1149 12 to to IN 40288 1149 13 Systems Systems NNP 40288 1149 14 , , , 40288 1149 15 does do VBZ 40288 1149 16 not not RB 40288 1149 17 mean mean VB 40288 1149 18 the the DT 40288 1149 19 ' ' `` 40288 1149 20 position position NN 40288 1149 21 ' ' '' 40288 1149 22 of of IN 40288 1149 23 single single JJ 40288 1149 24 notes note NNS 40288 1149 25 , , , 40288 1149 26 but but CC 40288 1149 27 of of IN 40288 1149 28 groups group NNS 40288 1149 29 of of IN 40288 1149 30 notes note NNS 40288 1149 31 . . . 40288 1150 1 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 40288 1150 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1150 3 p. p. NN 40288 1150 4 54 54 CD 40288 1150 5 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1150 6 . . . 40288 1150 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1151 1 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1151 2 speaks speak VBZ 40288 1151 3 of of IN 40288 1151 4 the the DT 40288 1151 5 position position NN 40288 1151 6 of of IN 40288 1151 7 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1151 8 towards towards IN 40288 1151 9 each each DT 40288 1151 10 other other JJ 40288 1151 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1151 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1151 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1151 14 : : : 40288 1151 15 tas tas NNP 40288 1151 16 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1151 17 tetrachordôn tetrachordôn NN 40288 1151 18 pros pro NNS 40288 1151 19 allêla allêla JJ 40288 1151 20 theseis theseis NNP 40288 1151 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1151 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1151 23 , , , 40288 1151 24 laying lay VBG 40288 1151 25 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1151 26 down down RP 40288 1151 27 that that IN 40288 1151 28 any any DT 40288 1151 29 two two CD 40288 1151 30 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1151 31 in in IN 40288 1151 32 the the DT 40288 1151 33 same same JJ 40288 1151 34 System system NN 40288 1151 35 must must MD 40288 1151 36 be be VB 40288 1151 37 consonant consonant JJ 40288 1151 38 either either CC 40288 1151 39 with with IN 40288 1151 40 each each DT 40288 1151 41 other other JJ 40288 1151 42 or or CC 40288 1151 43 with with IN 40288 1151 44 some some DT 40288 1151 45 third third JJ 40288 1151 46 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1151 47 . . . 40288 1152 1 The the DT 40288 1152 2 other other JJ 40288 1152 3 passage passage NN 40288 1152 4 quoted quote VBN 40288 1152 5 by by IN 40288 1152 6 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1152 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1152 8 p. p. NN 40288 1152 9 69 69 CD 40288 1152 10 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1152 11 . . . 40288 1152 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1153 1 is be VBZ 40288 1153 2 also also RB 40288 1153 3 in in IN 40288 1153 4 the the DT 40288 1153 5 discussion discussion NN 40288 1153 6 of of IN 40288 1153 7 Systems Systems NNP 40288 1153 8 . . . 40288 1154 1 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1154 2 is be VBZ 40288 1154 3 pointing point VBG 40288 1154 4 out out RP 40288 1154 5 the the DT 40288 1154 6 necessity necessity NN 40288 1154 7 of of IN 40288 1154 8 recognising recognise VBG 40288 1154 9 that that IN 40288 1154 10 some some DT 40288 1154 11 elements element NNS 40288 1154 12 of of IN 40288 1154 13 melodious melodious JJ 40288 1154 14 succession succession NN 40288 1154 15 are be VBP 40288 1154 16 fixed fix VBN 40288 1154 17 and and CC 40288 1154 18 limited limit VBN 40288 1154 19 , , , 40288 1154 20 others other NNS 40288 1154 21 are be VBP 40288 1154 22 unlimited unlimited JJ 40288 1154 23 : : : 40288 1154 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1154 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1154 26 : : : 40288 1154 27 kata kata NNP 40288 1154 28 men man NNS 40288 1154 29 oun oun NNP 40288 1154 30 ta ta NNP 40288 1154 31 megethê megethê NNP 40288 1154 32 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1154 33 diastêmatôn diastêmatôn NNP 40288 1154 34 kai kai NNP 40288 1154 35 tas tas NNP 40288 1154 36 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1154 37 phthongôn phthongôn NNP 40288 1154 38 taseis taseis NNP 40288 1154 39 apeira apeira NNP 40288 1154 40 pôs pôs NNP 40288 1154 41 phainetai phainetai NNP 40288 1154 42 einai einai NNP 40288 1154 43 ta ta NNP 40288 1154 44 peri peri NNP 40288 1154 45 melos melos NNP 40288 1154 46 , , , 40288 1154 47 kata kata NNP 40288 1154 48 de de NNP 40288 1154 49 tas tas NNP 40288 1154 50 dynameis dynameis NNP 40288 1154 51 kai kai NNP 40288 1154 52 kata kata NNP 40288 1154 53 ta ta NNP 40288 1154 54 eidê eidê NNP 40288 1154 55 kai kai NNP 40288 1154 56 kata kata NNP 40288 1154 57 tas tas NNP 40288 1154 58 theseis theseis NNP 40288 1154 59 peperasmena peperasmena NNP 40288 1154 60 te te NNP 40288 1154 61 kai kai NNP 40288 1154 62 tetagmena tetagmena NNP 40288 1154 63 . . . 40288 1154 64 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1155 1 ' ' `` 40288 1155 2 In in IN 40288 1155 3 the the DT 40288 1155 4 size size NN 40288 1155 5 of of IN 40288 1155 6 the the DT 40288 1155 7 intervals interval NNS 40288 1155 8 and and CC 40288 1155 9 the the DT 40288 1155 10 pitch pitch NN 40288 1155 11 of of IN 40288 1155 12 the the DT 40288 1155 13 notes note NNS 40288 1155 14 the the DT 40288 1155 15 elements element NNS 40288 1155 16 of of IN 40288 1155 17 melody melody NN 40288 1155 18 seem seem VBP 40288 1155 19 to to TO 40288 1155 20 be be VB 40288 1155 21 infinite infinite JJ 40288 1155 22 ; ; : 40288 1155 23 but but CC 40288 1155 24 in in IN 40288 1155 25 respect respect NN 40288 1155 26 of of IN 40288 1155 27 the the DT 40288 1155 28 values value NNS 40288 1155 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1155 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1155 31 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 1155 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1155 33 the the DT 40288 1155 34 relative relative JJ 40288 1155 35 places place NNS 40288 1155 36 of of IN 40288 1155 37 the the DT 40288 1155 38 notes note NNS 40288 1155 39 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1155 40 and and CC 40288 1155 41 in in IN 40288 1155 42 respect respect NN 40288 1155 43 of of IN 40288 1155 44 the the DT 40288 1155 45 forms form NNS 40288 1155 46 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1155 47 _ _ NNP 40288 1155 48 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 1155 49 _ _ NNP 40288 1155 50 the the DT 40288 1155 51 succession succession NN 40288 1155 52 of of IN 40288 1155 53 the the DT 40288 1155 54 intervals interval NNS 40288 1155 55 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1155 56 and and CC 40288 1155 57 in in IN 40288 1155 58 respect respect NN 40288 1155 59 of of IN 40288 1155 60 the the DT 40288 1155 61 positions position NNS 40288 1155 62 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1155 63 are be VBP 40288 1155 64 limited limit VBN 40288 1155 65 and and CC 40288 1155 66 settled settle VBN 40288 1155 67 . . . 40288 1155 68 ' ' '' 40288 1156 1 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1156 2 goes go VBZ 40288 1156 3 on on RP 40288 1156 4 to to TO 40288 1156 5 illustrate illustrate VB 40288 1156 6 this this DT 40288 1156 7 by by IN 40288 1156 8 supposing suppose VBG 40288 1156 9 that that IN 40288 1156 10 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1156 11 wish wish VBP 40288 1156 12 to to TO 40288 1156 13 continue continue VB 40288 1156 14 a a DT 40288 1156 15 scale scale NN 40288 1156 16 downwards downwards RB 40288 1156 17 from from IN 40288 1156 18 a a DT 40288 1156 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1156 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1156 21 : : : 40288 1156 22 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 1156 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1156 24 or or CC 40288 1156 25 pair pair NN 40288 1156 26 of of IN 40288 1156 27 small small JJ 40288 1156 28 intervals interval NNS 40288 1156 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1156 30 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1156 31 or or CC 40288 1156 32 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1156 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1156 34 . . . 40288 1157 1 In in IN 40288 1157 2 this this DT 40288 1157 3 case case NN 40288 1157 4 , , , 40288 1157 5 as as IN 40288 1157 6 the the DT 40288 1157 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1157 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1157 9 : : : 40288 1157 10 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 1157 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1157 12 forms form VBZ 40288 1157 13 the the DT 40288 1157 14 lower low JJR 40288 1157 15 part part NN 40288 1157 16 of of IN 40288 1157 17 a a DT 40288 1157 18 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1157 19 , , , 40288 1157 20 there there EX 40288 1157 21 are be VBP 40288 1157 22 two two CD 40288 1157 23 possibilities possibility NNS 40288 1157 24 . . . 40288 1158 1 If if IN 40288 1158 2 the the DT 40288 1158 3 next next JJ 40288 1158 4 lower low JJR 40288 1158 5 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1158 6 is be VBZ 40288 1158 7 disjunct disjunct JJ 40288 1158 8 , , , 40288 1158 9 the the DT 40288 1158 10 next next JJ 40288 1158 11 interval interval NN 40288 1158 12 is be VBZ 40288 1158 13 a a DT 40288 1158 14 tone tone NN 40288 1158 15 ; ; : 40288 1158 16 if if IN 40288 1158 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1158 18 is be VBZ 40288 1158 19 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 1158 20 , , , 40288 1158 21 the the DT 40288 1158 22 next next JJ 40288 1158 23 interval interval NN 40288 1158 24 is be VBZ 40288 1158 25 the the DT 40288 1158 26 large large JJ 40288 1158 27 interval interval NN 40288 1158 28 of of IN 40288 1158 29 the the DT 40288 1158 30 genus genus NN 40288 1158 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1158 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1158 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1158 34 : : : 40288 1158 35 hê hê NN 40288 1158 36 men man NNS 40288 1158 37 gar gar NNP 40288 1158 38 kata kata NNP 40288 1158 39 tonon tonon NNP 40288 1158 40 eis eis NNP 40288 1158 41 diazeuxin diazeuxin NNP 40288 1158 42 agei agei NNP 40288 1158 43 to to IN 40288 1158 44 tou tou NNP 40288 1158 45 systêmatos systêmatos NNP 40288 1158 46 eidos eidos NNP 40288 1158 47 , , , 40288 1158 48 hê hê NNP 40288 1158 49 de de NNP 40288 1158 50 kata kata NNP 40288 1158 51 thateron thateron NNP 40288 1158 52 diastêma diastêma NNP 40288 1158 53 ho ho NNP 40288 1158 54 ti ti IN 40288 1158 55 dêpot dêpot NNP 40288 1158 56 ' ' POS 40288 1158 57 echei echei NNP 40288 1158 58 megethos megethos NNP 40288 1158 59 eis eis NNP 40288 1158 60 synaphên synaphên NNP 40288 1158 61 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1158 62 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1158 63 . . . 40288 1159 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1159 2 the the DT 40288 1159 3 succession succession NN 40288 1159 4 of of IN 40288 1159 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 1159 6 is be VBZ 40288 1159 7 determined determine VBN 40288 1159 8 by by IN 40288 1159 9 the the DT 40288 1159 10 relative relative JJ 40288 1159 11 position position NN 40288 1159 12 of of IN 40288 1159 13 the the DT 40288 1159 14 two two CD 40288 1159 15 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1159 16 , , , 40288 1159 17 as as IN 40288 1159 18 to to TO 40288 1159 19 which which WDT 40288 1159 20 there there EX 40288 1159 21 is be VBZ 40288 1159 22 a a DT 40288 1159 23 choice choice NN 40288 1159 24 between between IN 40288 1159 25 two two CD 40288 1159 26 definite definite JJ 40288 1159 27 alternatives alternative NNS 40288 1159 28 . . . 40288 1160 1 This this DT 40288 1160 2 then then RB 40288 1160 3 is be VBZ 40288 1160 4 evidently evidently RB 40288 1160 5 what what WP 40288 1160 6 is be VBZ 40288 1160 7 meant mean VBN 40288 1160 8 by by IN 40288 1160 9 the the DT 40288 1160 10 words word NNS 40288 1160 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1160 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1160 13 : : : 40288 1160 14 kata kata NNP 40288 1160 15 tas tas NNP 40288 1160 16 theseis][1 theseis][1 NNP 40288 1160 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1160 18 . . . 40288 1161 1 On on IN 40288 1161 2 the the DT 40288 1161 3 other other JJ 40288 1161 4 hand hand NN 40288 1161 5 the the DT 40288 1161 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1161 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1161 8 : : : 40288 1161 9 thesis thesis NN 40288 1161 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1161 11 of of IN 40288 1161 12 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1161 13 's 's POS 40288 1161 14 nomenclature nomenclature NN 40288 1161 15 is be VBZ 40288 1161 16 the the DT 40288 1161 17 absolute absolute JJ 40288 1161 18 pitch pitch NN 40288 1161 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1161 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1161 21 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1161 22 . . . 40288 1161 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1161 24 ii ii NNP 40288 1161 25 . . . 40288 1162 1 5 5 LS 40288 1162 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1162 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1162 4 : : : 40288 1162 5 pote pote NN 40288 1162 6 men man NNS 40288 1162 7 par par IN 40288 1162 8 ' ' `` 40288 1162 9 autên autên NN 40288 1162 10 tên tên NN 40288 1162 11 thesin thesin NNP 40288 1162 12 , , , 40288 1162 13 to to IN 40288 1162 14 oxyteron oxyteron NNP 40288 1162 15 haplôs haplôs NNP 40288 1162 16 ê ê NNP 40288 1162 17 baryteron baryteron NNP 40288 1162 18 , , , 40288 1162 19 onomazomen onomazomen NNP 40288 1162 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1162 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1162 22 , , , 40288 1162 23 and and CC 40288 1162 24 this this DT 40288 1162 25 is be VBZ 40288 1162 26 one one CD 40288 1162 27 of of IN 40288 1162 28 the the DT 40288 1162 29 elements element NNS 40288 1162 30 which which WDT 40288 1162 31 according accord VBG 40288 1162 32 to to IN 40288 1162 33 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1162 34 are be VBP 40288 1162 35 indefinite indefinite JJ 40288 1162 36 . . . 40288 1163 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1163 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1163 3 1 1 CD 40288 1163 4 : : : 40288 1163 5 So so RB 40288 1163 6 Bacch Bacch NNP 40288 1163 7 . . . 40288 1164 1 p. p. NN 40288 1164 2 19 19 CD 40288 1164 3 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1164 4 . . . 40288 1165 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1165 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1165 3 : : : 40288 1165 4 theseis theseis NNP 40288 1165 5 de de NNP 40288 1165 6 tetrachordôn tetrachordôn NNP 40288 1165 7 hois hois NNP 40288 1165 8 to to IN 40288 1165 9 melos melos NNP 40288 1165 10 horizetai horizetai NNP 40288 1165 11 eisin eisin NNP 40288 1165 12 hepta hepta NNP 40288 1165 13 ? ? . 40288 1166 1 synaphê synaphê NNP 40288 1166 2 , , , 40288 1166 3 diazeuxis diazeuxis NNP 40288 1166 4 , , , 40288 1166 5 hypodiazeuxis hypodiazeuxis NNP 40288 1166 6 , , , 40288 1166 7 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1166 8 . . . 40288 1166 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1167 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1167 2 see see VB 40288 1167 3 the the DT 40288 1167 4 whole whole JJ 40288 1167 5 passage passage NN 40288 1167 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1167 7 . . . 40288 1167 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1168 1 Westphal westphal NN 40288 1168 2 also also RB 40288 1168 3 finds find VBZ 40288 1168 4 the the DT 40288 1168 5 nomenclature nomenclature NN 40288 1168 6 by by IN 40288 1168 7 position position NN 40288 1168 8 implied imply VBN 40288 1168 9 in in IN 40288 1168 10 the the DT 40288 1168 11 passage passage NN 40288 1168 12 of of IN 40288 1168 13 the the DT 40288 1168 14 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 1168 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1168 16 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1168 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1168 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1168 19 xix xix NNP 40288 1168 20 . . . 40288 1169 1 20 20 CD 40288 1169 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1169 3 which which WDT 40288 1169 4 deals deal VBZ 40288 1169 5 with with IN 40288 1169 6 the the DT 40288 1169 7 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 1169 8 relation relation NN 40288 1169 9 of of IN 40288 1169 10 the the DT 40288 1169 11 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1169 12 to to IN 40288 1169 13 the the DT 40288 1169 14 rest rest NN 40288 1169 15 of of IN 40288 1169 16 the the DT 40288 1169 17 musical musical JJ 40288 1169 18 scale scale NN 40288 1169 19 . . . 40288 1170 1 The the DT 40288 1170 2 passage passage NN 40288 1170 3 has have VBZ 40288 1170 4 already already RB 40288 1170 5 been be VBN 40288 1170 6 quoted quote VBN 40288 1170 7 and and CC 40288 1170 8 discussed discuss VBN 40288 1170 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1170 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1170 11 supra supra NNP 40288 1170 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1170 13 , , , 40288 1170 14 p. p. NN 40288 1170 15 43 43 CD 40288 1170 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1170 17 , , , 40288 1170 18 and and CC 40288 1170 19 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1170 20 has have VBZ 40288 1170 21 been be VBN 40288 1170 22 pointed point VBN 40288 1170 23 out out RP 40288 1170 24 that that IN 40288 1170 25 if if IN 40288 1170 26 the the DT 40288 1170 27 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1170 28 of of IN 40288 1170 29 the the DT 40288 1170 30 Perfect perfect JJ 40288 1170 31 System System NNP 40288 1170 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1170 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1170 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1170 35 : : : 40288 1170 36 mesê mesê NNS 40288 1170 37 kata kata NNP 40288 1170 38 dynamin dynamin NNP 40288 1170 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1170 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1170 41 is be VBZ 40288 1170 42 the the DT 40288 1170 43 key key NN 40288 1170 44 - - HYPH 40288 1170 45 note note NN 40288 1170 46 , , , 40288 1170 47 the the DT 40288 1170 48 scale scale NN 40288 1170 49 must must MD 40288 1170 50 have have VB 40288 1170 51 been be VBN 40288 1170 52 an an DT 40288 1170 53 octave octave NN 40288 1170 54 of of IN 40288 1170 55 the the DT 40288 1170 56 _ _ NNP 40288 1170 57 a_-species a_-species NNP 40288 1170 58 . . . 40288 1171 1 If if IN 40288 1171 2 octaves octave NNS 40288 1171 3 of of IN 40288 1171 4 other other JJ 40288 1171 5 species specie NNS 40288 1171 6 were be VBD 40288 1171 7 used use VBN 40288 1171 8 , , , 40288 1171 9 as as IN 40288 1171 10 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1171 11 maintains maintain VBZ 40288 1171 12 , , , 40288 1171 13 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1171 14 becomes become VBZ 40288 1171 15 necessary necessary JJ 40288 1171 16 to to TO 40288 1171 17 take take VB 40288 1171 18 the the DT 40288 1171 19 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1171 20 of of IN 40288 1171 21 this this DT 40288 1171 22 passage passage NN 40288 1171 23 to to TO 40288 1171 24 be be VB 40288 1171 25 the the DT 40288 1171 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1171 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1171 28 : : : 40288 1171 29 mesê mesê NNS 40288 1171 30 kata kata NNP 40288 1171 31 thesin thesin NNP 40288 1171 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1171 33 , , , 40288 1171 34 or or CC 40288 1171 35 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1171 36 by by IN 40288 1171 37 position position NN 40288 1171 38 . . . 40288 1172 1 That that DT 40288 1172 2 is is RB 40288 1172 3 , , , 40288 1172 4 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1172 5 is be VBZ 40288 1172 6 obliged oblige VBN 40288 1172 7 by by IN 40288 1172 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1172 9 theory theory NN 40288 1172 10 of of IN 40288 1172 11 the the DT 40288 1172 12 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1172 13 to to TO 40288 1172 14 take take VB 40288 1172 15 the the DT 40288 1172 16 term term NN 40288 1172 17 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1172 18 in in IN 40288 1172 19 a a DT 40288 1172 20 sense sense NN 40288 1172 21 of of IN 40288 1172 22 which which WDT 40288 1172 23 there there EX 40288 1172 24 is be VBZ 40288 1172 25 no no DT 40288 1172 26 other other JJ 40288 1172 27 trace trace NN 40288 1172 28 before before IN 40288 1172 29 the the DT 40288 1172 30 time time NN 40288 1172 31 of of IN 40288 1172 32 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1172 33 . . . 40288 1173 1 But-- but-- XX 40288 1173 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1173 3 1 1 LS 40288 1173 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1173 5 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1173 6 is be VBZ 40288 1173 7 highly highly RB 40288 1173 8 improbable improbable JJ 40288 1173 9 that that IN 40288 1173 10 the the DT 40288 1173 11 names name NNS 40288 1173 12 of of IN 40288 1173 13 the the DT 40288 1173 14 notes note NNS 40288 1173 15 -- -- : 40288 1173 16 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1173 17 , , , 40288 1173 18 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1173 19 , , , 40288 1173 20 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1173 21 and and CC 40288 1173 22 the the DT 40288 1173 23 rest rest NN 40288 1173 24 -- -- : 40288 1173 25 should should MD 40288 1173 26 have have VB 40288 1173 27 had have VBD 40288 1173 28 two two CD 40288 1173 29 distinct distinct JJ 40288 1173 30 meanings meaning NNS 40288 1173 31 . . . 40288 1174 1 Such such PDT 40288 1174 2 an an DT 40288 1174 3 ambiguity ambiguity NN 40288 1174 4 would would MD 40288 1174 5 have have VB 40288 1174 6 been be VBN 40288 1174 7 intolerable intolerable JJ 40288 1174 8 , , , 40288 1174 9 and and CC 40288 1174 10 only only RB 40288 1174 11 to to TO 40288 1174 12 be be VB 40288 1174 13 compared compare VBN 40288 1174 14 with with IN 40288 1174 15 the the DT 40288 1174 16 similar similar JJ 40288 1174 17 ambiguity ambiguity NN 40288 1174 18 which which WDT 40288 1174 19 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1174 20 's 's POS 40288 1174 21 theory theory NN 40288 1174 22 implies imply VBZ 40288 1174 23 in in IN 40288 1174 24 the the DT 40288 1174 25 use use NN 40288 1174 26 of of IN 40288 1174 27 the the DT 40288 1174 28 terms term NNS 40288 1174 29 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1174 30 , , , 40288 1174 31 & & CC 40288 1174 32 c. c. NNP 40288 1174 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1174 34 2 2 LS 40288 1174 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1174 36 If if IN 40288 1174 37 the the DT 40288 1174 38 different different JJ 40288 1174 39 species specie NNS 40288 1174 40 of of IN 40288 1174 41 the the DT 40288 1174 42 octave octave NN 40288 1174 43 were be VBD 40288 1174 44 the the DT 40288 1174 45 practically practically RB 40288 1174 46 important important JJ 40288 1174 47 scales scale NNS 40288 1174 48 , , , 40288 1174 49 as as IN 40288 1174 50 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1174 51 maintains maintain VBZ 40288 1174 52 , , , 40288 1174 53 the the DT 40288 1174 54 position position NN 40288 1174 55 of of IN 40288 1174 56 the the DT 40288 1174 57 notes note NNS 40288 1174 58 in in IN 40288 1174 59 these these DT 40288 1174 60 scales scale NNS 40288 1174 61 must must MD 40288 1174 62 have have VB 40288 1174 63 been be VBN 40288 1174 64 correspondingly correspondingly RB 40288 1174 65 important important JJ 40288 1174 66 . . . 40288 1175 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1175 2 the the DT 40288 1175 3 nomenclature nomenclature NN 40288 1175 4 by by IN 40288 1175 5 position position NN 40288 1175 6 must must MD 40288 1175 7 have have VB 40288 1175 8 been be VBN 40288 1175 9 the the DT 40288 1175 10 more more RBR 40288 1175 11 usual usual JJ 40288 1175 12 and and CC 40288 1175 13 familiar familiar JJ 40288 1175 14 one one CD 40288 1175 15 . . . 40288 1176 1 Yet yet RB 40288 1176 2 , , , 40288 1176 3 as as IN 40288 1176 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1176 5 have have VBP 40288 1176 6 shown show VBN 40288 1176 7 , , , 40288 1176 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1176 9 is be VBZ 40288 1176 10 not not RB 40288 1176 11 found find VBN 40288 1176 12 in in IN 40288 1176 13 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1176 14 , , , 40288 1176 15 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1176 16 or or CC 40288 1176 17 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 1176 18 -- -- : 40288 1176 19 to to TO 40288 1176 20 say say VB 40288 1176 21 nothing nothing NN 40288 1176 22 of of IN 40288 1176 23 later later JJ 40288 1176 24 writers writer NNS 40288 1176 25 . . . 40288 1177 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1177 2 3 3 LS 40288 1177 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1177 4 The the DT 40288 1177 5 nomenclature nomenclature JJ 40288 1177 6 by by IN 40288 1177 7 position position NN 40288 1177 8 is be VBZ 40288 1177 9 an an DT 40288 1177 10 essential essential JJ 40288 1177 11 part part NN 40288 1177 12 of of IN 40288 1177 13 the the DT 40288 1177 14 scheme scheme NN 40288 1177 15 of of IN 40288 1177 16 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 1177 17 proposed propose VBN 40288 1177 18 by by IN 40288 1177 19 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1177 20 . . . 40288 1178 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1178 2 bears bear VBZ 40288 1178 3 the the DT 40288 1178 4 same same JJ 40288 1178 5 relation relation NN 40288 1178 6 to to IN 40288 1178 7 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1178 8 's 's POS 40288 1178 9 octaves octave NNS 40288 1178 10 as as IN 40288 1178 11 the the DT 40288 1178 12 nomenclature nomenclature JJ 40288 1178 13 by by IN 40288 1178 14 ' ' `` 40288 1178 15 value value NN 40288 1178 16 ' ' '' 40288 1178 17 bears bear VBZ 40288 1178 18 to to IN 40288 1178 19 the the DT 40288 1178 20 old old JJ 40288 1178 21 standard standard JJ 40288 1178 22 octave octave NN 40288 1178 23 and and CC 40288 1178 24 the the DT 40288 1178 25 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1178 26 System System NNP 40288 1178 27 . . . 40288 1179 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1179 2 was be VBD 40288 1179 3 probably probably RB 40288 1179 4 therefore therefore RB 40288 1179 5 devised devise VBN 40288 1179 6 about about IN 40288 1179 7 the the DT 40288 1179 8 time time NN 40288 1179 9 of of IN 40288 1179 10 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1179 11 , , , 40288 1179 12 if if IN 40288 1179 13 not not RB 40288 1179 14 actually actually RB 40288 1179 15 by by IN 40288 1179 16 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1179 17 . . . 40288 1180 1 § § ADD 40288 1180 2 31 31 CD 40288 1180 3 . . . 40288 1181 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1181 2 Scales Scales NNP 40288 1181 3 of of IN 40288 1181 4 the the DT 40288 1181 5 Lyre Lyre NNP 40288 1181 6 and and CC 40288 1181 7 Cithara Cithara NNP 40288 1181 8 . . . 40288 1181 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1181 10 The the DT 40288 1181 11 earliest early JJS 40288 1181 12 evidence evidence NN 40288 1181 13 in in IN 40288 1181 14 practical practical JJ 40288 1181 15 music music NN 40288 1181 16 of of IN 40288 1181 17 any any DT 40288 1181 18 octaves octave NNS 40288 1181 19 other other JJ 40288 1181 20 than than IN 40288 1181 21 those those DT 40288 1181 22 of of IN 40288 1181 23 the the DT 40288 1181 24 standard standard JJ 40288 1181 25 System System NNP 40288 1181 26 is be VBZ 40288 1181 27 to to TO 40288 1181 28 be be VB 40288 1181 29 found find VBN 40288 1181 30 in in IN 40288 1181 31 the the DT 40288 1181 32 account account NN 40288 1181 33 given give VBN 40288 1181 34 by by IN 40288 1181 35 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1181 36 of of IN 40288 1181 37 certain certain JJ 40288 1181 38 scales scale NNS 40288 1181 39 employed employ VBN 40288 1181 40 on on IN 40288 1181 41 the the DT 40288 1181 42 lyre lyre NN 40288 1181 43 and and CC 40288 1181 44 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1181 45 . . . 40288 1182 1 According accord VBG 40288 1182 2 to to IN 40288 1182 3 this this DT 40288 1182 4 account account NN 40288 1182 5 the the DT 40288 1182 6 scales scale NNS 40288 1182 7 of of IN 40288 1182 8 the the DT 40288 1182 9 lyre lyre NN 40288 1182 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1182 11 the the DT 40288 1182 12 simpler simple JJR 40288 1182 13 and and CC 40288 1182 14 commoner commoner NN 40288 1182 15 instrument instrument NN 40288 1182 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1182 17 were be VBD 40288 1182 18 of of IN 40288 1182 19 two two CD 40288 1182 20 kinds kind NNS 40288 1182 21 . . . 40288 1183 1 One one CD 40288 1183 2 was be VBD 40288 1183 3 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1183 4 , , , 40288 1183 5 of of IN 40288 1183 6 the the DT 40288 1183 7 ' ' `` 40288 1183 8 colour colour NN 40288 1183 9 ' ' '' 40288 1183 10 or or CC 40288 1183 11 variety variety NN 40288 1183 12 which which WDT 40288 1183 13 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1183 14 recognises recognise VBZ 40288 1183 15 as as IN 40288 1183 16 the the DT 40288 1183 17 prevailing prevail VBG 40288 1183 18 one one CD 40288 1183 19 , , , 40288 1183 20 viz viz NN 40288 1183 21 . . . 40288 1184 1 the the DT 40288 1184 2 ' ' `` 40288 1184 3 Middle Middle NNP 40288 1184 4 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1184 5 ' ' '' 40288 1184 6 or or CC 40288 1184 7 ' ' `` 40288 1184 8 Tonic Tonic NNP 40288 1184 9 ' ' '' 40288 1184 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1184 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1184 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1184 13 : : : 40288 1184 14 diatonon diatonon NNP 40288 1184 15 toniaion])[1 toniaion])[1 NNP 40288 1184 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1184 17 . . . 40288 1185 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1185 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1185 3 1 1 CD 40288 1185 4 : : : 40288 1185 5 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1185 6 may may MD 40288 1185 7 think think VB 40288 1185 8 of of IN 40288 1185 9 this this DT 40288 1185 10 as as IN 40288 1185 11 a a DT 40288 1185 12 scale scale NN 40288 1185 13 in in IN 40288 1185 14 which which WDT 40288 1185 15 the the DT 40288 1185 16 semitones semitone NNS 40288 1185 17 are be VBP 40288 1185 18 considerably considerably RB 40288 1185 19 smaller small JJR 40288 1185 20 , , , 40288 1185 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1185 22 i.e. i.e. FW 40288 1185 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1185 24 in in IN 40288 1185 25 which which WDT 40288 1185 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1185 27 c c NNP 40288 1185 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1185 29 and and CC 40288 1185 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1185 31 f f NNP 40288 1185 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1185 33 are be VBP 40288 1185 34 nearly nearly RB 40288 1185 35 a a DT 40288 1185 36 quarter quarter NN 40288 1185 37 of of IN 40288 1185 38 a a DT 40288 1185 39 tone tone NN 40288 1185 40 flat flat NN 40288 1185 41 . . . 40288 1185 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1186 1 The the DT 40288 1186 2 other other JJ 40288 1186 3 was be VBD 40288 1186 4 a a DT 40288 1186 5 ' ' `` 40288 1186 6 mixture mixture NN 40288 1186 7 ' ' '' 40288 1186 8 of of IN 40288 1186 9 this this DT 40288 1186 10 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1186 11 with with IN 40288 1186 12 the the DT 40288 1186 13 standard standard JJ 40288 1186 14 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1186 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1186 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1186 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1186 18 : : : 40288 1186 19 chrôma chrôma NNP 40288 1186 20 suntonon suntonon NNP 40288 1186 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1186 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1186 23 : : : 40288 1186 24 that that DT 40288 1186 25 is be VBZ 40288 1186 26 to to TO 40288 1186 27 say say VB 40288 1186 28 , , , 40288 1186 29 the the DT 40288 1186 30 octave octave NN 40288 1186 31 consisted consist VBD 40288 1186 32 of of IN 40288 1186 33 a a DT 40288 1186 34 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1186 35 of of IN 40288 1186 36 each each DT 40288 1186 37 genus genus NN 40288 1186 38 . . . 40288 1187 1 These these DT 40288 1187 2 octaves octave NNS 40288 1187 3 apparently apparently RB 40288 1187 4 might may MD 40288 1187 5 be be VB 40288 1187 6 of of IN 40288 1187 7 any any DT 40288 1187 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1187 9 species specie NNS 40288 1187 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1187 11 , , , 40288 1187 12 according accord VBG 40288 1187 13 to to IN 40288 1187 14 the the DT 40288 1187 15 key key JJ 40288 1187 16 chosen[1 chosen[1 NNS 40288 1187 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1187 18 . . . 40288 1188 1 On on IN 40288 1188 2 the the DT 40288 1188 3 cithara,--which cithara,--which NNP 40288 1188 4 was be VBD 40288 1188 5 a a DT 40288 1188 6 more more RBR 40288 1188 7 elaborate elaborate JJ 40288 1188 8 form form NN 40288 1188 9 of of IN 40288 1188 10 lyre lyre NN 40288 1188 11 , , , 40288 1188 12 confined confine VBN 40288 1188 13 in in IN 40288 1188 14 practice practice NN 40288 1188 15 to to IN 40288 1188 16 professional professional JJ 40288 1188 17 musicians,--six musicians,--six NNP 40288 1188 18 different different JJ 40288 1188 19 octave octave NN 40288 1188 20 scales scale NNS 40288 1188 21 were be VBD 40288 1188 22 employed employ VBN 40288 1188 23 , , , 40288 1188 24 each each DT 40288 1188 25 of of IN 40288 1188 26 a a DT 40288 1188 27 particular particular JJ 40288 1188 28 species species NN 40288 1188 29 and and CC 40288 1188 30 key key NN 40288 1188 31 . . . 40288 1189 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1189 2 are be VBP 40288 1189 3 enumerated enumerate VBN 40288 1189 4 and and CC 40288 1189 5 described describe VBN 40288 1189 6 by by IN 40288 1189 7 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1189 8 in in IN 40288 1189 9 two two CD 40288 1189 10 passages passage NNS 40288 1189 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1189 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1189 13 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1189 14 . . . 40288 1189 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1189 16 i. i. NNP 40288 1190 1 16 16 CD 40288 1190 2 and and CC 40288 1190 3 ii ii NNP 40288 1190 4 . . . 40288 1191 1 16 16 CD 40288 1191 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1191 3 , , , 40288 1191 4 which which WDT 40288 1191 5 in in IN 40288 1191 6 some some DT 40288 1191 7 points point NNS 40288 1191 8 serve serve VBP 40288 1191 9 to to TO 40288 1191 10 correct correct VB 40288 1191 11 each each DT 40288 1191 12 other other JJ 40288 1191 13 . . . 40288 1192 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1192 2 2 2 CD 40288 1192 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1192 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1192 5 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1192 6 1 1 CD 40288 1192 7 : : : 40288 1192 8 Ptol Ptol NNP 40288 1192 9 . . . 40288 1193 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1193 2 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1193 3 . . . 40288 1193 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1193 5 ii ii NNP 40288 1193 6 . . . 40288 1194 1 16 16 CD 40288 1194 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1194 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1194 4 : : : 40288 1194 5 periechetai periechetai NNP 40288 1194 6 de de FW 40288 1194 7 ta ta NNP 40288 1194 8 men man NNS 40288 1194 9 en en NNP 40288 1194 10 tê tê DT 40288 1194 11 lyra lyra NNP 40288 1194 12 kaloumena kaloumena NNP 40288 1194 13 sterea sterea NNP 40288 1194 14 tonou tonou NNP 40288 1194 15 tinos tinos NN 40288 1194 16 hypo hypo NNP 40288 1194 17 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1194 18 tou tou NNP 40288 1194 19 toniaiou toniaiou NNP 40288 1194 20 diatonou diatonou NNP 40288 1194 21 arithmôn arithmôn NNP 40288 1194 22 tou tou NNP 40288 1194 23 autou autou NNP 40288 1194 24 tonou tonou NNP 40288 1194 25 , , , 40288 1194 26 ta ta NNP 40288 1194 27 de de NNP 40288 1194 28 malaka malaka NNP 40288 1194 29 hypo hypo NNP 40288 1194 30 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1194 31 en en NNP 40288 1194 32 tô tô NNP 40288 1194 33 migmati migmati NNP 40288 1194 34 tou tou NNP 40288 1194 35 malakou malakou NNP 40288 1194 36 chrômatos chrômatos NNP 40288 1194 37 apithmôn apithmôn NNP 40288 1194 38 tou tou NNP 40288 1194 39 autou autou NNP 40288 1194 40 tonou tonou NNP 40288 1194 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1194 42 . . . 40288 1195 1 Here here RB 40288 1195 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1195 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1195 4 : : : 40288 1195 5 tonou tonou JJ 40288 1195 6 tinos tinos NN 40288 1195 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1195 8 evidently evidently RB 40288 1195 9 means mean VBZ 40288 1195 10 ' ' '' 40288 1195 11 of of IN 40288 1195 12 any any DT 40288 1195 13 given give VBN 40288 1195 14 key key NN 40288 1195 15 , , , 40288 1195 16 ' ' '' 40288 1195 17 and and CC 40288 1195 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1195 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1195 20 : : : 40288 1195 21 tou tou NNP 40288 1195 22 autou autou NNP 40288 1195 23 tonou tonou NNP 40288 1195 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1195 25 ' ' NN 40288 1195 26 of of IN 40288 1195 27 that that DT 40288 1195 28 key key NN 40288 1195 29 . . . 40288 1195 30 ' ' '' 40288 1196 1 There there EX 40288 1196 2 is be VBZ 40288 1196 3 either either CC 40288 1196 4 no no DT 40288 1196 5 restriction restriction NN 40288 1196 6 , , , 40288 1196 7 or or CC 40288 1196 8 none none NN 40288 1196 9 that that WDT 40288 1196 10 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1196 11 thought think VBD 40288 1196 12 worth worth JJ 40288 1196 13 mentioning mention VBG 40288 1196 14 , , , 40288 1196 15 in in IN 40288 1196 16 the the DT 40288 1196 17 choice choice NN 40288 1196 18 of of IN 40288 1196 19 the the DT 40288 1196 20 key key NN 40288 1196 21 and and CC 40288 1196 22 species specie NNS 40288 1196 23 . . . 40288 1196 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1197 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1197 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1197 3 2 2 CD 40288 1197 4 : : : 40288 1197 5 The the DT 40288 1197 6 two two CD 40288 1197 7 passages passage NNS 40288 1197 8 enumerate enumerate VBP 40288 1197 9 the the DT 40288 1197 10 scales scale NNS 40288 1197 11 in in IN 40288 1197 12 a a DT 40288 1197 13 slightly slightly RB 40288 1197 14 different different JJ 40288 1197 15 manner manner NN 40288 1197 16 . . . 40288 1198 1 In in IN 40288 1198 2 i. i. NN 40288 1199 1 16 16 CD 40288 1199 2 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1199 3 are be VBP 40288 1199 4 arranged arrange VBN 40288 1199 5 in in IN 40288 1199 6 view view NN 40288 1199 7 of of IN 40288 1199 8 the the DT 40288 1199 9 genus genus NN 40288 1199 10 or or CC 40288 1199 11 colour colour NN 40288 1199 12 into-- into-- NNP 40288 1199 13 Pure Pure NNP 40288 1199 14 Middle Middle NNP 40288 1199 15 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1199 16 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1199 17 , , , 40288 1199 18 viz.-- viz.-- NFP 40288 1199 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1199 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1199 21 : : : 40288 1199 22 sterea sterea NNP 40288 1199 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1199 24 , , , 40288 1199 25 of of IN 40288 1199 26 the the DT 40288 1199 27 lyre lyre NN 40288 1199 28 . . . 40288 1200 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1200 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1200 3 : : : 40288 1200 4 tritai tritai NNP 40288 1200 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1200 6 } } -RRB- 40288 1200 7 of of IN 40288 1200 8 the the DT 40288 1200 9 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1200 10 . . . 40288 1201 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1201 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1201 3 : : : 40288 1201 4 hypertropa hypertropa NN 40288 1201 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1201 6 } } -RRB- 40288 1201 7 Mixture Mixture NNP 40288 1201 8 of of IN 40288 1201 9 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1201 10 , , , 40288 1201 11 viz.-- viz.-- NFP 40288 1201 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1201 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1201 14 : : : 40288 1201 15 malaka malaka NN 40288 1201 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1201 17 , , , 40288 1201 18 of of IN 40288 1201 19 the the DT 40288 1201 20 lyre lyre NN 40288 1201 21 . . . 40288 1202 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1202 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1202 3 : : : 40288 1202 4 tropika tropika NN 40288 1202 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1202 6 , , , 40288 1202 7 of of IN 40288 1202 8 the the DT 40288 1202 9 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1202 10 . . . 40288 1203 1 Mixture mixture NN 40288 1203 2 of of IN 40288 1203 3 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1203 4 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1203 5 , , , 40288 1203 6 viz.-- viz.-- NFP 40288 1203 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1203 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1203 9 : : : 40288 1203 10 parypatai parypatai NN 40288 1203 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1203 12 , , , 40288 1203 13 of of IN 40288 1203 14 the the DT 40288 1203 15 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1203 16 . . . 40288 1204 1 Mixture mixture NN 40288 1204 2 of of IN 40288 1204 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1204 4 Greek greek JJ 40288 1204 5 : : : 40288 1204 6 diatonon diatonon NNP 40288 1204 7 syntonon syntonon NNP 40288 1204 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1204 9 , , , 40288 1204 10 viz.-- viz.-- NFP 40288 1204 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1204 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1204 13 : : : 40288 1204 14 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1204 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1204 16 } } -RRB- 40288 1204 17 of of IN 40288 1204 18 the the DT 40288 1204 19 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1204 20 . . . 40288 1205 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1205 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1205 3 : : : 40288 1205 4 iastia iastia NNP 40288 1205 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1205 6 } } -RRB- 40288 1205 7 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1205 8 is be VBZ 40288 1205 9 added add VBN 40288 1205 10 , , , 40288 1205 11 however however RB 40288 1205 12 , , , 40288 1205 13 that that IN 40288 1205 14 in in IN 40288 1205 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1205 16 use use NN 40288 1205 17 of of IN 40288 1205 18 this this DT 40288 1205 19 last last JJ 40288 1205 20 ' ' `` 40288 1205 21 mixture mixture NN 40288 1205 22 ' ' '' 40288 1205 23 musicians musician NNS 40288 1205 24 are be VBP 40288 1205 25 in in IN 40288 1205 26 the the DT 40288 1205 27 habit habit NN 40288 1205 28 of of IN 40288 1205 29 tuning tune VBG 40288 1205 30 the the DT 40288 1205 31 cithara cithara NN 40288 1205 32 in in IN 40288 1205 33 the the DT 40288 1205 34 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1205 35 manner manner NN 40288 1205 36 , , , 40288 1205 37 with with IN 40288 1205 38 two two CD 40288 1205 39 Major major JJ 40288 1205 40 tones tone NNS 40288 1205 41 and and CC 40288 1205 42 a a DT 40288 1205 43 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1205 44 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1205 45 : : : 40288 1205 46 leimma leimma NN 40288 1205 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1205 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1205 49 called call VBN 40288 1205 50 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1205 51 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1205 52 : : : 40288 1205 53 diatonon diatonon VB 40288 1205 54 ditoniaion ditoniaion NN 40288 1205 55 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1205 56 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1205 57 . . . 40288 1206 1 In in IN 40288 1206 2 the the DT 40288 1206 3 second second JJ 40288 1206 4 passage passage NN 40288 1206 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1206 6 ii ii PRP 40288 1206 7 . . . 40288 1207 1 16 16 LS 40288 1207 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1207 3 the the DT 40288 1207 4 scales scale NNS 40288 1207 5 of of IN 40288 1207 6 the the DT 40288 1207 7 lyre lyre NN 40288 1207 8 are be VBP 40288 1207 9 given give VBN 40288 1207 10 first first RB 40288 1207 11 , , , 40288 1207 12 then then RB 40288 1207 13 those those DT 40288 1207 14 of of IN 40288 1207 15 the the DT 40288 1207 16 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1207 17 with with IN 40288 1207 18 the the DT 40288 1207 19 key key NN 40288 1207 20 of of IN 40288 1207 21 each each DT 40288 1207 22 . . . 40288 1208 1 The the DT 40288 1208 2 order order NN 40288 1208 3 is be VBZ 40288 1208 4 the the DT 40288 1208 5 same same JJ 40288 1208 6 , , , 40288 1208 7 except except IN 40288 1208 8 that that IN 40288 1208 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1208 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1208 11 : : : 40288 1208 12 parypatai parypatai NN 40288 1208 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1208 14 comes come VBZ 40288 1208 15 before before RB 40288 1208 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1208 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1208 18 : : : 40288 1208 19 tropika tropika NN 40288 1208 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1208 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1208 22 now now RB 40288 1208 23 called call VBN 40288 1208 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1208 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1208 26 : : : 40288 1208 27 tropoi tropoi NNP 40288 1208 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1208 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1208 30 , , , 40288 1208 31 and and CC 40288 1208 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1208 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1208 34 : : : 40288 1208 35 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1208 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1208 37 is be VBZ 40288 1208 38 placed place VBN 40288 1208 39 last last RB 40288 1208 40 . . . 40288 1209 1 The the DT 40288 1209 2 words word NNS 40288 1209 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1209 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1209 5 : : : 40288 1209 6 ta ta NNP 40288 1209 7 de de NNP 40288 1209 8 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1209 9 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1209 10 tou tou NNP 40288 1209 11 toniaiou toniaiou NNP 40288 1209 12 diatonou diatonou NNP 40288 1209 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1209 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1209 15 sc sc IN 40288 1209 16 . . . 40288 1210 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1210 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1210 3 : : : 40288 1210 4 arithmoi arithmoi NNP 40288 1210 5 periechousi periechousi NNP 40288 1210 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1210 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1210 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1210 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1210 10 : : : 40288 1210 11 tou tou NNP 40288 1210 12 dôriou dôriou NNP 40288 1210 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1210 14 can can MD 40288 1210 15 not not RB 40288 1210 16 be be VB 40288 1210 17 correct correct JJ 40288 1210 18 , , , 40288 1210 19 not not RB 40288 1210 20 merely merely RB 40288 1210 21 because because IN 40288 1210 22 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1210 23 contradict contradict VBP 40288 1210 24 the the DT 40288 1210 25 statement statement NN 40288 1210 26 of of IN 40288 1210 27 the the DT 40288 1210 28 earlier early JJR 40288 1210 29 passage passage NN 40288 1210 30 that that WDT 40288 1210 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1210 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1210 33 : : : 40288 1210 34 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1210 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1210 36 denoted denote VBD 40288 1210 37 a a DT 40288 1210 38 mixture mixture NN 40288 1210 39 with with IN 40288 1210 40 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1210 41 Greek greek JJ 40288 1210 42 : : : 40288 1210 43 diatonon diatonon NNP 40288 1210 44 syntonon syntonon NN 40288 1210 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1210 46 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1210 47 or or CC 40288 1210 48 in in IN 40288 1210 49 practice practice NN 40288 1210 50 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1210 51 Greek greek JJ 40288 1210 52 : : : 40288 1210 53 diatonon diatonon VB 40288 1210 54 ditoniaion ditoniaion NN 40288 1210 55 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1210 56 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1210 57 , , , 40288 1210 58 but but CC 40288 1210 59 also also RB 40288 1210 60 because because IN 40288 1210 61 the the DT 40288 1210 62 scales scale NNS 40288 1210 63 that that WDT 40288 1210 64 do do VBP 40288 1210 65 not not RB 40288 1210 66 admit admit VB 40288 1210 67 mixture mixture NN 40288 1210 68 are be VBP 40288 1210 69 placed place VBN 40288 1210 70 first first RB 40288 1210 71 in in IN 40288 1210 72 the the DT 40288 1210 73 list list NN 40288 1210 74 in in IN 40288 1210 75 both both DT 40288 1210 76 passages passage NNS 40288 1210 77 . . . 40288 1211 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1211 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1211 3 should should MD 40288 1211 4 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 1211 5 read read VB 40288 1211 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1211 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1211 8 : : : 40288 1211 9 ta ta NNP 40288 1211 10 de de NNP 40288 1211 11 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1211 12 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1211 13 < < XX 40288 1211 14 tou tou NNP 40288 1211 15 migmatos migmatos NNP 40288 1211 16 > > XX 40288 1211 17 tou tou NNP 40288 1211 18 < < XX 40288 1211 19 di di NNP 40288 1211 20 > > XX 40288 1211 21 toniaiou toniaiou NNP 40288 1211 22 diatonou diatonou NNP 40288 1211 23 tou tou NNP 40288 1211 24 Dôriou Dôriou NNP 40288 1211 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1211 26 . . . 40288 1211 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1212 1 Of of IN 40288 1212 2 the the DT 40288 1212 3 six six CD 40288 1212 4 scales scale NNS 40288 1212 5 two two CD 40288 1212 6 are be VBP 40288 1212 7 of of IN 40288 1212 8 the the DT 40288 1212 9 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1212 10 - - HYPH 40288 1212 11 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1212 12 or or CC 40288 1212 13 Common common JJ 40288 1212 14 species specie NNS 40288 1212 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1212 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1212 17 a a DT 40288 1212 18 - - : 40288 1212 19 a a DT 40288 1212 20 _ _ NN 40288 1212 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1212 22 . . . 40288 1213 1 One one CD 40288 1213 2 of of IN 40288 1213 3 these these DT 40288 1213 4 , , , 40288 1213 5 called call VBN 40288 1213 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1213 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1213 8 : : : 40288 1213 9 tritai tritai NNP 40288 1213 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1213 11 , , , 40288 1213 12 is be VBZ 40288 1213 13 purely purely RB 40288 1213 14 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1213 15 of of IN 40288 1213 16 the the DT 40288 1213 17 Middle Middle NNP 40288 1213 18 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1213 19 variety variety NN 40288 1213 20 ; ; : 40288 1213 21 the the DT 40288 1213 22 intervals interval NNS 40288 1213 23 expressed express VBN 40288 1213 24 by by IN 40288 1213 25 fractions fraction NNS 40288 1213 26 are be VBP 40288 1213 27 as as IN 40288 1213 28 follows follow VBZ 40288 1213 29 : : : 40288 1213 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 31 a a DT 40288 1213 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 33 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1213 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 35 b b NNP 40288 1213 36 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 37 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1213 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 39 c c NNP 40288 1213 40 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 41 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1213 42 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 43 d d NNP 40288 1213 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 45 9/8 9/8 NNP 40288 1213 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 47 e e NNP 40288 1213 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 49 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1213 50 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 51 f f NNP 40288 1213 52 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 53 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1213 54 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 55 g g NNP 40288 1213 56 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 57 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1213 58 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 59 a a DT 40288 1213 60 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 61 The the DT 40288 1213 62 other other JJ 40288 1213 63 , , , 40288 1213 64 called call VBN 40288 1213 65 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1213 66 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1213 67 : : : 40288 1213 68 tropoi tropoi LS 40288 1213 69 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1213 70 or or CC 40288 1213 71 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1213 72 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1213 73 : : : 40288 1213 74 tropika tropika NN 40288 1213 75 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1213 76 , , , 40288 1213 77 is be VBZ 40288 1213 78 a a DT 40288 1213 79 mixture mixture NN 40288 1213 80 , , , 40288 1213 81 Middle Middle NNP 40288 1213 82 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1213 83 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1213 84 in in IN 40288 1213 85 the the DT 40288 1213 86 upper upper JJ 40288 1213 87 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1213 88 , , , 40288 1213 89 and and CC 40288 1213 90 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1213 91 in in IN 40288 1213 92 the the DT 40288 1213 93 lower low JJR 40288 1213 94 : : : 40288 1213 95 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 96 a a DT 40288 1213 97 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 98 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1213 99 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 100 b b NNP 40288 1213 101 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 102 22/21 22/21 CD 40288 1213 103 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 104 c c NNP 40288 1213 105 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 106 12/11 12/11 CD 40288 1213 107 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 108 c_[Symbols c_[Symbols NNPS 40288 1213 109 : : : 40288 1213 110 sharp sharp JJ 40288 1213 111 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1213 112 7/6 7/6 CD 40288 1213 113 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 114 e e NNP 40288 1213 115 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 116 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1213 117 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 118 f f NNP 40288 1213 119 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 120 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1213 121 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 122 g g NNP 40288 1213 123 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 124 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1213 125 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 126 a a DT 40288 1213 127 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 128 Two Two NNP 40288 1213 129 scales scale NNS 40288 1213 130 are be VBP 40288 1213 131 of of IN 40288 1213 132 the the DT 40288 1213 133 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1213 134 or or CC 40288 1213 135 _ _ NNP 40288 1213 136 e_-species e_-species NNP 40288 1213 137 , , , 40288 1213 138 viz viz NN 40288 1213 139 . . . 40288 1214 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1214 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1214 3 : : : 40288 1214 4 parypatai parypatai NN 40288 1214 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1214 6 , , , 40288 1214 7 a a DT 40288 1214 8 combination combination NN 40288 1214 9 of of IN 40288 1214 10 Soft soft JJ 40288 1214 11 and and CC 40288 1214 12 Middle middle JJ 40288 1214 13 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1214 14 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1214 15 : : : 40288 1214 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 17 e e NNP 40288 1214 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 19 21/20 21/20 CD 40288 1214 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 21 f f NNP 40288 1214 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 23 10/9 10/9 NNP 40288 1214 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 25 g g NNP 40288 1214 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 27 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1214 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 29 a a DT 40288 1214 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 31 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1214 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 33 b b NNP 40288 1214 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 35 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1214 36 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 37 c c NNP 40288 1214 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 39 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1214 40 d d NNP 40288 1214 41 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1214 42 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 43 e e NNP 40288 1214 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 45 and and CC 40288 1214 46 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1214 47 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1214 48 : : : 40288 1214 49 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1214 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1214 51 , , , 40288 1214 52 in in IN 40288 1214 53 which which WDT 40288 1214 54 the the DT 40288 1214 55 upper upper JJ 40288 1214 56 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1214 57 is be VBZ 40288 1214 58 of of IN 40288 1214 59 the the DT 40288 1214 60 strict strict JJ 40288 1214 61 or or CC 40288 1214 62 ' ' `` 40288 1214 63 highly highly RB 40288 1214 64 strung strung JJ 40288 1214 65 ' ' '' 40288 1214 66 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1214 67 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1214 68 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1214 69 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1214 70 : : : 40288 1214 71 diatonon diatonon VB 40288 1214 72 syntonon]--our syntonon]--our NN 40288 1214 73 ' ' `` 40288 1214 74 natural natural JJ 40288 1214 75 ' ' '' 40288 1214 76 temperament temperament NN 40288 1214 77 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1214 78 : : : 40288 1214 79 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 80 e e NNP 40288 1214 81 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 82 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1214 83 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 84 f f NNP 40288 1214 85 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 86 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1214 87 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 88 g g NNP 40288 1214 89 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 90 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1214 91 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 92 a a DT 40288 1214 93 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 94 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1214 95 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 96 b b NNP 40288 1214 97 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 98 16/15 16/15 CD 40288 1214 99 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 100 c c NNP 40288 1214 101 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 102 9/8 9/8 NNP 40288 1214 103 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 104 d d NNP 40288 1214 105 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 106 10/9 10/9 NNP 40288 1214 107 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 108 e e NNP 40288 1214 109 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 110 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1214 111 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1214 112 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 113 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 1214 114 und und NN 40288 1214 115 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 1214 116 _ _ NNP 40288 1214 117 , , , 40288 1214 118 1863 1863 CD 40288 1214 119 , , , 40288 1214 120 p. p. NN 40288 1214 121 255 255 CD 40288 1214 122 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1214 123 supposes suppose VBZ 40288 1214 124 a a DT 40288 1214 125 much much RB 40288 1214 126 deeper deep JJR 40288 1214 127 corruption corruption NN 40288 1214 128 . . . 40288 1215 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1215 2 would would MD 40288 1215 3 restore restore VB 40288 1215 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1215 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1215 6 : : : 40288 1215 7 ta ta NNP 40288 1215 8 de de NNP 40288 1215 9 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1215 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1215 11 kai kai NNP 40288 1215 12 iastia iastia NNP 40288 1215 13 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1215 14 tou tou NNP 40288 1215 15 migmatos migmatos NNP 40288 1215 16 tou tou NNP 40288 1215 17 syntonou syntonou NNP 40288 1215 18 diatonou diatonou NNP 40288 1215 19 tou tou NNP 40288 1215 20 ... ... NFP 40288 1215 21 ta ta NNP 40288 1215 22 de de NNP 40288 1215 23 ... ... NFP 40288 1215 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1215 25 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1215 26 tou tou NNP 40288 1215 27 toniaiou toniaiou NNP 40288 1215 28 diatonou diatonou NNP 40288 1215 29 tou tou NNP 40288 1215 30 Dôriou Dôriou NNP 40288 1215 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1215 32 . . . 40288 1216 1 This this DT 40288 1216 2 introduces introduce VBZ 40288 1216 3 a a DT 40288 1216 4 serious serious JJ 40288 1216 5 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40288 1216 6 between between IN 40288 1216 7 the the DT 40288 1216 8 two two CD 40288 1216 9 passages passage NNS 40288 1216 10 , , , 40288 1216 11 as as IN 40288 1216 12 the the DT 40288 1216 13 number number NN 40288 1216 14 of of IN 40288 1216 15 scales scale NNS 40288 1216 16 in in IN 40288 1216 17 the the DT 40288 1216 18 second second JJ 40288 1216 19 list list NN 40288 1216 20 is be VBZ 40288 1216 21 raised raise VBN 40288 1216 22 to to IN 40288 1216 23 eight eight CD 40288 1216 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1216 25 Westphal westphal JJ 40288 1216 26 making make VBG 40288 1216 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1216 28 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1216 29 : : : 40288 1216 30 iastia iastia NN 40288 1216 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1216 32 and and CC 40288 1216 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1216 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1216 35 : : : 40288 1216 36 iastiaioliaia iastiaioliaia NN 40288 1216 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1216 38 distinct distinct JJ 40288 1216 39 scales scale NNS 40288 1216 40 , , , 40288 1216 41 and and CC 40288 1216 42 furthermore furthermore RB 40288 1216 43 inserting insert VBG 40288 1216 44 a a DT 40288 1216 45 new new JJ 40288 1216 46 scale scale NN 40288 1216 47 , , , 40288 1216 48 of of IN 40288 1216 49 unknown unknown JJ 40288 1216 50 name name NN 40288 1216 51 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1216 52 . . . 40288 1217 1 Moreover moreover RB 40288 1217 2 the the DT 40288 1217 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1217 4 unknown unknown JJ 40288 1217 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1217 6 scale scale NN 40288 1217 7 of of IN 40288 1217 8 unmixed unmixed JJ 40288 1217 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1217 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1217 11 : : : 40288 1217 12 diatonon diatonon NNP 40288 1217 13 toniaion toniaion NN 40288 1217 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1217 15 is be VBZ 40288 1217 16 out out IN 40288 1217 17 of of IN 40288 1217 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1217 19 place place NN 40288 1217 20 at at IN 40288 1217 21 the the DT 40288 1217 22 end end NN 40288 1217 23 of of IN 40288 1217 24 the the DT 40288 1217 25 list list NN 40288 1217 26 . . . 40288 1218 1 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1218 2 's 's POS 40288 1218 3 objection objection NN 40288 1218 4 to to IN 40288 1218 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1218 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1218 7 : : : 40288 1218 8 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1218 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1218 10 as as IN 40288 1218 11 the the DT 40288 1218 12 name name NN 40288 1218 13 of of IN 40288 1218 14 a a DT 40288 1218 15 scale scale NN 40288 1218 16 of of IN 40288 1218 17 the the DT 40288 1218 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1218 19 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1218 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1218 21 species species NN 40288 1218 22 of of IN 40288 1218 23 course course NN 40288 1218 24 only only RB 40288 1218 25 holds hold VBZ 40288 1218 26 good good JJ 40288 1218 27 on on IN 40288 1218 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1218 29 theory theory NN 40288 1218 30 of of IN 40288 1218 31 the the DT 40288 1218 32 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1218 33 . . . 40288 1219 1 The the DT 40288 1219 2 only only JJ 40288 1219 3 other other JJ 40288 1219 4 differences difference NNS 40288 1219 5 between between IN 40288 1219 6 the the DT 40288 1219 7 two two CD 40288 1219 8 passages passage NNS 40288 1219 9 are be VBP 40288 1219 10 : : : 40288 1219 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1219 12 1 1 LS 40288 1219 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1219 14 In in IN 40288 1219 15 the the DT 40288 1219 16 scales scale NNS 40288 1219 17 of of IN 40288 1219 18 the the DT 40288 1219 19 lyre lyre NN 40288 1219 20 called call VBN 40288 1219 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1219 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1219 23 : : : 40288 1219 24 malaka malaka NN 40288 1219 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1219 26 the the DT 40288 1219 27 admixture admixture NN 40288 1219 28 , , , 40288 1219 29 according accord VBG 40288 1219 30 to to IN 40288 1219 31 i. i. NNP 40288 1220 1 16 16 CD 40288 1220 2 , , , 40288 1220 3 is be VBZ 40288 1220 4 one one CD 40288 1220 5 of of IN 40288 1220 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1220 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1220 8 : : : 40288 1220 9 chrômatikon chrômatikon NNP 40288 1220 10 syntonon syntonon NN 40288 1220 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1220 12 , , , 40288 1220 13 according accord VBG 40288 1220 14 to to IN 40288 1220 15 ii ii NNP 40288 1220 16 . . . 40288 1221 1 16 16 CD 40288 1221 2 of of IN 40288 1221 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1221 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1221 5 : : : 40288 1221 6 chr chr NNP 40288 1221 7 . . . 40288 1222 1 malakon malakon NNP 40288 1222 2 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1222 3 . . . 40288 1223 1 But but CC 40288 1223 2 , , , 40288 1223 3 as as IN 40288 1223 4 Westphal westphal NN 40288 1223 5 shows show VBZ 40288 1223 6 , , , 40288 1223 7 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1223 8 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1223 9 is be VBZ 40288 1223 10 not not RB 40288 1223 11 admitted admit VBN 40288 1223 12 by by IN 40288 1223 13 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1223 14 as as IN 40288 1223 15 in in IN 40288 1223 16 practical practical JJ 40288 1223 17 use use NN 40288 1223 18 . . . 40288 1224 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1224 2 would would MD 40288 1224 3 seem seem VB 40288 1224 4 that that IN 40288 1224 5 in in IN 40288 1224 6 the the DT 40288 1224 7 second second JJ 40288 1224 8 passage passage NN 40288 1224 9 the the DT 40288 1224 10 copyist copyist NN 40288 1224 11 was be VBD 40288 1224 12 led lead VBN 40288 1224 13 astray astray RB 40288 1224 14 by by IN 40288 1224 15 the the DT 40288 1224 16 word word NN 40288 1224 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1224 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1224 19 : : : 40288 1224 20 malaka malaka NN 40288 1224 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1224 22 just just RB 40288 1224 23 before before RB 40288 1224 24 . . . 40288 1225 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1225 2 2 2 LS 40288 1225 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1225 4 The the DT 40288 1225 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1225 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1225 7 : : : 40288 1225 8 iastia iastia NNP 40288 1225 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1225 10 of of IN 40288 1225 11 i. i. NNP 40288 1226 1 16 16 CD 40288 1226 2 is be VBZ 40288 1226 3 called call VBN 40288 1226 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1226 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1226 6 : : : 40288 1226 7 iastiaioliaia iastiaioliaia NN 40288 1226 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1226 9 in in IN 40288 1226 10 ii ii NNP 40288 1226 11 . . . 40288 1227 1 16 16 CD 40288 1227 2 . . . 40288 1228 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1228 2 need need VBP 40288 1228 3 not not RB 40288 1228 4 suppose suppose VB 40288 1228 5 the the DT 40288 1228 6 text text NN 40288 1228 7 to to TO 40288 1228 8 be be VB 40288 1228 9 faulty faulty JJ 40288 1228 10 , , , 40288 1228 11 since since IN 40288 1228 12 the the DT 40288 1228 13 two two CD 40288 1228 14 forms form NNS 40288 1228 15 may may MD 40288 1228 16 have have VB 40288 1228 17 been be VBN 40288 1228 18 both both DT 40288 1228 19 in in IN 40288 1228 20 use use NN 40288 1228 21 . . . 40288 1229 1 Another another DT 40288 1229 2 point point NN 40288 1229 3 overlooked overlook VBD 40288 1229 4 in in IN 40288 1229 5 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1229 6 's 's POS 40288 1229 7 treatment treatment NN 40288 1229 8 is be VBZ 40288 1229 9 that that IN 40288 1229 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1229 11 Greek greek JJ 40288 1229 12 : : : 40288 1229 13 diatonon diatonon NNP 40288 1229 14 syntonon syntonon NN 40288 1229 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1229 16 and and CC 40288 1229 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1229 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1229 19 : : : 40288 1229 20 d. d. NNP 40288 1229 21 ditoniaion ditoniaion NNP 40288 1229 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1229 23 are be VBP 40288 1229 24 not not RB 40288 1229 25 really really RB 40288 1229 26 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 1229 27 by by IN 40288 1229 28 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1229 29 . . . 40288 1230 1 In in IN 40288 1230 2 one one CD 40288 1230 3 passage passage NN 40288 1230 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1230 5 i. i. NN 40288 1231 1 16 16 LS 40288 1231 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1231 3 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1231 4 gives give VBZ 40288 1231 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1231 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1231 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1231 8 : : : 40288 1231 9 lydia lydia NNP 40288 1231 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1231 11 and and CC 40288 1231 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1231 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1231 14 : : : 40288 1231 15 iastia iastia NNP 40288 1231 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1231 17 as as IN 40288 1231 18 a a DT 40288 1231 19 mixture mixture NN 40288 1231 20 with with IN 40288 1231 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1231 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1231 23 : : : 40288 1231 24 d. d. NNP 40288 1231 25 syntonon syntonon NNP 40288 1231 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1231 27 , , , 40288 1231 28 adding add VBG 40288 1231 29 that that IN 40288 1231 30 in in IN 40288 1231 31 practice practice NN 40288 1231 32 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1231 33 was be VBD 40288 1231 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1231 35 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1231 36 : : : 40288 1231 37 d. d. NNP 40288 1231 38 ditoniaion ditoniaion NNP 40288 1231 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1231 40 . . . 40288 1232 1 In in IN 40288 1232 2 the the DT 40288 1232 3 other other JJ 40288 1232 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1232 5 ii ii PRP 40288 1232 6 . . . 40288 1233 1 16 16 LS 40288 1233 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1233 3 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1233 4 speaks speak VBZ 40288 1233 5 at at IN 40288 1233 6 once once RB 40288 1233 7 of of IN 40288 1233 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1233 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1233 10 : : : 40288 1233 11 d. d. NNP 40288 1233 12 ditoniaion ditoniaion NNP 40288 1233 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1233 14 . . . 40288 1234 1 This this DT 40288 1234 2 consideration consideration NN 40288 1234 3 brings bring VBZ 40288 1234 4 the the DT 40288 1234 5 two two CD 40288 1234 6 places place NNS 40288 1234 7 into into IN 40288 1234 8 such such JJ 40288 1234 9 close close JJ 40288 1234 10 agreement agreement NN 40288 1234 11 that that WDT 40288 1234 12 any any DT 40288 1234 13 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40288 1234 14 involving involve VBG 40288 1234 15 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40288 1234 16 is be VBZ 40288 1234 17 most most RBS 40288 1234 18 improbable improbable JJ 40288 1234 19 . . . 40288 1235 1 In in IN 40288 1235 2 practice practice NN 40288 1235 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1235 4 appears appear VBZ 40288 1235 5 that that IN 40288 1235 6 musicians musician NNS 40288 1235 7 tuned tune VBD 40288 1235 8 the the DT 40288 1235 9 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1235 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1235 11 b b NNP 40288 1235 12 - - HYPH 40288 1235 13 e e NNP 40288 1235 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1235 15 of of IN 40288 1235 16 this this DT 40288 1235 17 scale scale NN 40288 1235 18 with with IN 40288 1235 19 the the DT 40288 1235 20 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1235 21 two two CD 40288 1235 22 Major major JJ 40288 1235 23 tones tone NNS 40288 1235 24 and and CC 40288 1235 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1235 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1235 27 : : : 40288 1235 28 leimma leimma NN 40288 1235 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1235 30 . . . 40288 1236 1 Of of IN 40288 1236 2 the the DT 40288 1236 3 remaining remain VBG 40288 1236 4 scales scale NNS 40288 1236 5 one one CD 40288 1236 6 , , , 40288 1236 7 called call VBN 40288 1236 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1236 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1236 10 : : : 40288 1236 11 hypertropa hypertropa NN 40288 1236 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1236 13 , , , 40288 1236 14 is be VBZ 40288 1236 15 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1236 16 in in IN 40288 1236 17 species specie NNS 40288 1236 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1236 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 20 d d NNP 40288 1236 21 - - HYPH 40288 1236 22 d d NNP 40288 1236 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1236 25 , , , 40288 1236 26 and and CC 40288 1236 27 of of IN 40288 1236 28 the the DT 40288 1236 29 standard standard JJ 40288 1236 30 genus genus NN 40288 1236 31 : : : 40288 1236 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 33 d d NNP 40288 1236 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 35 9/8 9/8 NNP 40288 1236 36 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 37 e e NNP 40288 1236 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 39 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1236 40 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 41 f f NNP 40288 1236 42 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 43 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1236 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 45 g g NNP 40288 1236 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 47 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1236 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 49 a a DT 40288 1236 50 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 51 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1236 52 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 53 b b NNP 40288 1236 54 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 55 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1236 56 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 57 c c NNP 40288 1236 58 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 59 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1236 60 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 61 d d NNP 40288 1236 62 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 63 One One NNP 40288 1236 64 , , , 40288 1236 65 called call VBN 40288 1236 66 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1236 67 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1236 68 : : : 40288 1236 69 iastia iastia NNP 40288 1236 70 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1236 71 , , , 40288 1236 72 or or CC 40288 1236 73 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1236 74 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1236 75 : : : 40288 1236 76 iastiaioliaia iastiaioliaia NN 40288 1236 77 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1236 78 , , , 40288 1236 79 is be VBZ 40288 1236 80 of of IN 40288 1236 81 the the DT 40288 1236 82 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1236 83 - - HYPH 40288 1236 84 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1236 85 or or CC 40288 1236 86 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 87 g_-species g_-species NNP 40288 1236 88 , , , 40288 1236 89 the the DT 40288 1236 90 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1236 91 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 92 b b NNP 40288 1236 93 - - HYPH 40288 1236 94 e e NNP 40288 1236 95 _ _ NNP 40288 1236 96 being be VBG 40288 1236 97 ' ' `` 40288 1236 98 highly highly RB 40288 1236 99 strung string VBN 40288 1236 100 ' ' '' 40288 1236 101 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1236 102 or or CC 40288 1236 103 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1236 104 in in IN 40288 1236 105 practice practice NN 40288 1236 106 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1236 107 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1236 108 , , , 40288 1236 109 viz viz NN 40288 1236 110 . . . 40288 1237 1 : : : 40288 1237 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 3 g g NNP 40288 1237 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 5 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1237 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 7 a a DT 40288 1237 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 9 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1237 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 11 b b NNP 40288 1237 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 13 256/243 256/243 NN 40288 1237 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 15 c c NNP 40288 1237 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 17 9/8 9/8 NNP 40288 1237 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 19 d d NNP 40288 1237 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 21 9/8 9/8 NNP 40288 1237 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 23 e e NNP 40288 1237 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 25 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1237 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 27 f f NNP 40288 1237 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 29 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1237 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 31 g g NNP 40288 1237 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1237 33 Regarding regard VBG 40288 1237 34 the the DT 40288 1237 35 tonality tonality NN 40288 1237 36 of of IN 40288 1237 37 these these DT 40288 1237 38 scales scale NNS 40288 1237 39 there there EX 40288 1237 40 is be VBZ 40288 1237 41 not not RB 40288 1237 42 very very RB 40288 1237 43 much much JJ 40288 1237 44 to to TO 40288 1237 45 be be VB 40288 1237 46 said say VBN 40288 1237 47 . . . 40288 1238 1 In in IN 40288 1238 2 the the DT 40288 1238 3 case case NN 40288 1238 4 of of IN 40288 1238 5 the the DT 40288 1238 6 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1238 7 - - HYPH 40288 1238 8 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1238 9 and and CC 40288 1238 10 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1238 11 octaves octave NNS 40288 1238 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1238 13 will will MD 40288 1238 14 be be VB 40288 1238 15 generally generally RB 40288 1238 16 thought think VBN 40288 1238 17 probable probable JJ 40288 1238 18 that that IN 40288 1238 19 the the DT 40288 1238 20 key key JJ 40288 1238 21 - - HYPH 40288 1238 22 note note NN 40288 1238 23 is be VBZ 40288 1238 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1238 25 a a DT 40288 1238 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1238 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1238 28 the the DT 40288 1238 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1238 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1238 31 : : : 40288 1238 32 mesê mesê NNS 40288 1238 33 kata kata NNP 40288 1238 34 dynamin dynamin NNP 40288 1238 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1238 36 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1238 37 . . . 40288 1239 1 If if IN 40288 1239 2 so so RB 40288 1239 3 , , , 40288 1239 4 the the DT 40288 1239 5 difference difference NN 40288 1239 6 between between IN 40288 1239 7 the the DT 40288 1239 8 two two CD 40288 1239 9 species specie NNS 40288 1239 10 is be VBZ 40288 1239 11 not not RB 40288 1239 12 one one CD 40288 1239 13 of of IN 40288 1239 14 ' ' '' 40288 1239 15 mode,'--in mode,'--in VBD 40288 1239 16 the the DT 40288 1239 17 modern modern JJ 40288 1239 18 sense,--but sense,--but NNP 40288 1239 19 consists consist VBZ 40288 1239 20 in in IN 40288 1239 21 the the DT 40288 1239 22 fact fact NN 40288 1239 23 that that IN 40288 1239 24 in in IN 40288 1239 25 the the DT 40288 1239 26 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1239 27 - - HYPH 40288 1239 28 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1239 29 the the DT 40288 1239 30 compass compass NN 40288 1239 31 of of IN 40288 1239 32 the the DT 40288 1239 33 melody melody NN 40288 1239 34 is be VBZ 40288 1239 35 from from IN 40288 1239 36 the the DT 40288 1239 37 key key JJ 40288 1239 38 - - HYPH 40288 1239 39 note note NN 40288 1239 40 upwards upwards RB 40288 1239 41 , , , 40288 1239 42 while while IN 40288 1239 43 in in IN 40288 1239 44 the the DT 40288 1239 45 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1239 46 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1239 47 extends extend VBZ 40288 1239 48 a a DT 40288 1239 49 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1239 50 below below IN 40288 1239 51 the the DT 40288 1239 52 key key NN 40288 1239 53 - - HYPH 40288 1239 54 note note NN 40288 1239 55 . . . 40288 1240 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1240 2 is be VBZ 40288 1240 3 possible possible JJ 40288 1240 4 , , , 40288 1240 5 however however RB 40288 1240 6 , , , 40288 1240 7 that that IN 40288 1240 8 the the DT 40288 1240 9 lowest low JJS 40288 1240 10 note note NN 40288 1240 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1240 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1240 13 e e NNP 40288 1240 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1240 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1240 16 of of IN 40288 1240 17 the the DT 40288 1240 18 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1240 19 octave octave NN 40288 1240 20 was be VBD 40288 1240 21 sometimes sometimes RB 40288 1240 22 the the DT 40288 1240 23 key key JJ 40288 1240 24 - - HYPH 40288 1240 25 note note NN 40288 1240 26 : : : 40288 1240 27 in in IN 40288 1240 28 which which WDT 40288 1240 29 case case NN 40288 1240 30 the the DT 40288 1240 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1240 32 mode mode NN 40288 1240 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1240 34 was be VBD 40288 1240 35 properly properly RB 40288 1240 36 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1240 37 . . . 40288 1241 1 In in IN 40288 1241 2 the the DT 40288 1241 3 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1241 4 octave octave NN 40288 1241 5 of of IN 40288 1241 6 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1241 7 's 's POS 40288 1241 8 description description NN 40288 1241 9 the the DT 40288 1241 10 key key NN 40288 1241 11 - - HYPH 40288 1241 12 note note NN 40288 1241 13 can can MD 40288 1241 14 not not RB 40288 1241 15 be be VB 40288 1241 16 the the DT 40288 1241 17 Fourth fourth JJ 40288 1241 18 or or CC 40288 1241 19 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1241 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1241 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1241 22 : : : 40288 1241 23 kata kata NNP 40288 1241 24 thesin thesin NN 40288 1241 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1241 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1241 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1241 28 g g NNP 40288 1241 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1241 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1241 31 , , , 40288 1241 32 since since IN 40288 1241 33 the the DT 40288 1241 34 interval interval NN 40288 1241 35 _ _ NNP 40288 1241 36 g g NNP 40288 1241 37 - - HYPH 40288 1241 38 c c NNP 40288 1241 39 _ _ NNP 40288 1241 40 is be VBZ 40288 1241 41 not not RB 40288 1241 42 consonant consonant JJ 40288 1241 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1241 44 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1241 45 × × NN 40288 1241 46 9/8 9/8 CD 40288 1241 47 × × NN 40288 1241 48 28/27 28/27 CD 40288 1241 49 being be VBG 40288 1241 50 less less JJR 40288 1241 51 than than IN 40288 1241 52 4/3 4/3 CD 40288 1241 53 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1241 54 . . . 40288 1242 1 Possibly possibly RB 40288 1242 2 the the DT 40288 1242 3 lowest low JJS 40288 1242 4 note note NN 40288 1242 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1242 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1242 7 d d NNP 40288 1242 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1242 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1242 10 is be VBZ 40288 1242 11 the the DT 40288 1242 12 key key JJ 40288 1242 13 - - HYPH 40288 1242 14 note note NN 40288 1242 15 ; ; : 40288 1242 16 if if IN 40288 1242 17 so so RB 40288 1242 18 the the DT 40288 1242 19 scale scale NN 40288 1242 20 is be VBZ 40288 1242 21 of of IN 40288 1242 22 the the DT 40288 1242 23 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1242 24 mode mode NN 40288 1242 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1242 26 in in IN 40288 1242 27 the the DT 40288 1242 28 modern modern JJ 40288 1242 29 sense sense NN 40288 1242 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1242 31 . . . 40288 1243 1 In in IN 40288 1243 2 the the DT 40288 1243 3 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1243 4 - - HYPH 40288 1243 5 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1243 6 octave octave NN 40288 1243 7 there there EX 40288 1243 8 is be VBZ 40288 1243 9 a a DT 40288 1243 10 similar similar JJ 40288 1243 11 objection objection NN 40288 1243 12 to to IN 40288 1243 13 regarding regard VBG 40288 1243 14 the the DT 40288 1243 15 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1243 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1243 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1243 18 : : : 40288 1243 19 kata kata NNP 40288 1243 20 thesin thesin NN 40288 1243 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1243 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1243 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1243 24 c c NNP 40288 1243 25 _ _ NNP 40288 1243 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1243 27 as as IN 40288 1243 28 the the DT 40288 1243 29 key key NN 40288 1243 30 - - HYPH 40288 1243 31 note note NN 40288 1243 32 , , , 40288 1243 33 and and CC 40288 1243 34 some some DT 40288 1243 35 probability probability NN 40288 1243 36 in in IN 40288 1243 37 favour favour NN 40288 1243 38 of of IN 40288 1243 39 the the DT 40288 1243 40 lowest low JJS 40288 1243 41 note note NN 40288 1243 42 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1243 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1243 44 g g NNP 40288 1243 45 _ _ NNP 40288 1243 46 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1243 47 . . . 40288 1244 1 If if IN 40288 1244 2 the the DT 40288 1244 3 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1244 4 division division NN 40288 1244 5 of of IN 40288 1244 6 the the DT 40288 1244 7 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1244 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 9 g g NNP 40288 1244 10 - - HYPH 40288 1244 11 c c NNP 40288 1244 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 13 were be VBD 40288 1244 14 replaced replace VBN 40288 1244 15 by by IN 40288 1244 16 the the DT 40288 1244 17 natural natural JJ 40288 1244 18 temperament temperament NN 40288 1244 19 , , , 40288 1244 20 which which WDT 40288 1244 21 the the DT 40288 1244 22 language language NN 40288 1244 23 used use VBN 40288 1244 24 by by IN 40288 1244 25 Ptolemy[1 Ptolemy[1 NNP 40288 1244 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1244 27 leads lead VBZ 40288 1244 28 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1244 29 to to TO 40288 1244 30 regard regard VB 40288 1244 31 as as IN 40288 1244 32 the the DT 40288 1244 33 true true JJ 40288 1244 34 division division NN 40288 1244 35 , , , 40288 1244 36 the the DT 40288 1244 37 scale scale NN 40288 1244 38 would would MD 40288 1244 39 exhibit exhibit VB 40288 1244 40 the the DT 40288 1244 41 intervals-- intervals-- NN 40288 1244 42 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 43 g g NNP 40288 1244 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 45 5/4 5/4 CD 40288 1244 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 47 b b NNP 40288 1244 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 49 6/5 6/5 NNP 40288 1244 50 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 51 d d NNP 40288 1244 52 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 53 7/6 7/6 NNP 40288 1244 54 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 55 f f NNP 40288 1244 56 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 57 8/7 8/7 CD 40288 1244 58 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 59 g g NNP 40288 1244 60 _ _ NNP 40288 1244 61 which which WDT 40288 1244 62 give give VBP 40288 1244 63 the the DT 40288 1244 64 natural natural JJ 40288 1244 65 chord chord NN 40288 1244 66 of of IN 40288 1244 67 the the DT 40288 1244 68 Seventh Seventh NNP 40288 1244 69 . . . 40288 1245 1 This this DT 40288 1245 2 however however RB 40288 1245 3 is be VBZ 40288 1245 4 no no DT 40288 1245 5 more more JJR 40288 1245 6 than than IN 40288 1245 7 a a DT 40288 1245 8 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40288 1245 9 . . . 40288 1246 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1246 2 evidently evidently RB 40288 1246 3 follows follow VBZ 40288 1246 4 from from IN 40288 1246 5 all all PDT 40288 1246 6 this this DT 40288 1246 7 that that IN 40288 1246 8 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1246 9 's 's POS 40288 1246 10 octaves octave NNS 40288 1246 11 do do VBP 40288 1246 12 not not RB 40288 1246 13 constitute constitute VB 40288 1246 14 a a DT 40288 1246 15 system system NN 40288 1246 16 of of IN 40288 1246 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1246 18 modes modes NNPS 40288 1246 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1246 20 . . . 40288 1247 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1247 2 are be VBP 40288 1247 3 merely merely RB 40288 1247 4 the the DT 40288 1247 5 groups group NNS 40288 1247 6 of of IN 40288 1247 7 notes note NNS 40288 1247 8 , , , 40288 1247 9 of of IN 40288 1247 10 the the DT 40288 1247 11 compass compass NN 40288 1247 12 of of IN 40288 1247 13 an an DT 40288 1247 14 octave octave NN 40288 1247 15 , , , 40288 1247 16 which which WDT 40288 1247 17 are be VBP 40288 1247 18 most most RBS 40288 1247 19 likely likely JJ 40288 1247 20 to to TO 40288 1247 21 be be VB 40288 1247 22 used use VBN 40288 1247 23 in in IN 40288 1247 24 the the DT 40288 1247 25 several several JJ 40288 1247 26 keys key NNS 40288 1247 27 , , , 40288 1247 28 and and CC 40288 1247 29 which which WDT 40288 1247 30 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1247 31 or or CC 40288 1247 32 some some DT 40288 1247 33 earlier early JJR 40288 1247 34 theorist theorist NN 40288 1247 35 chose choose VBD 40288 1247 36 to to TO 40288 1247 37 call call VB 40288 1247 38 by by IN 40288 1247 39 the the DT 40288 1247 40 names name NNS 40288 1247 41 of of IN 40288 1247 42 those those DT 40288 1247 43 keys key NNS 40288 1247 44 . . . 40288 1248 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1248 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1248 3 1 1 CD 40288 1248 4 : : : 40288 1248 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1248 6 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1248 7 . . . 40288 1248 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1248 9 i. i. NNP 40288 1249 1 16 16 CD 40288 1249 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1249 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1249 4 : : : 40288 1249 5 plên plên NNP 40288 1249 6 kathoson kathoson NNP 40288 1249 7 adousi adousi NNP 40288 1249 8 men man NNS 40288 1249 9 akolouthôs akolouthôs VBP 40288 1249 10 tô tô NNP 40288 1249 11 dedeigmenô dedeigmenô NNP 40288 1249 12 syntonô syntonô NNP 40288 1249 13 diatonikô diatonikô NNP 40288 1249 14 , , , 40288 1249 15 kathaper kathaper NNP 40288 1249 16 exestai exestai NNP 40288 1249 17 skopein skopein NNP 40288 1249 18 apo apo NNP 40288 1249 19 tês tês NNP 40288 1249 20 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1249 21 oikeiôn oikeiôn NNP 40288 1249 22 autou autou NNP 40288 1249 23 logôn logôn VBZ 40288 1249 24 parabolês parabolê NNS 40288 1249 25 , , , 40288 1249 26 harmozontai harmozontai NNP 40288 1249 27 de de NNP 40288 1249 28 heteron heteron NNP 40288 1249 29 ti ti NNP 40288 1249 30 genos genos NNP 40288 1249 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1249 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1249 33 sc sc IN 40288 1249 34 . . . 40288 1250 1 the the DT 40288 1250 2 Pythagorean Pythagorean NNP 40288 1250 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1250 4 , , , 40288 1250 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1250 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1250 7 : : : 40288 1250 8 xynengizon xynengizon NNP 40288 1250 9 men man NNS 40288 1250 10 ekeinô ekeinô NNP 40288 1250 11 , , , 40288 1250 12 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1250 13 . . . 40288 1250 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1250 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1251 1 § § ADD 40288 1251 2 32 32 CD 40288 1251 3 . . . 40288 1252 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1252 2 Remains Remains NNPS 40288 1252 3 of of IN 40288 1252 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1252 5 Music Music NNP 40288 1252 6 . . . 40288 1252 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1252 8 The the DT 40288 1252 9 extant extant JJ 40288 1252 10 specimens specimen NNS 40288 1252 11 of of IN 40288 1252 12 Greek greek JJ 40288 1252 13 music music NN 40288 1252 14 are be VBP 40288 1252 15 mostly mostly RB 40288 1252 16 of of IN 40288 1252 17 the the DT 40288 1252 18 second second JJ 40288 1252 19 century century NN 40288 1252 20 A.D. A.D. NNP 40288 1252 21 , , , 40288 1252 22 and and CC 40288 1252 23 therefore therefore RB 40288 1252 24 nearly nearly RB 40288 1252 25 contemporary contemporary JJ 40288 1252 26 with with IN 40288 1252 27 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1252 28 . . . 40288 1253 1 The the DT 40288 1253 2 most most RBS 40288 1253 3 considerable considerable JJ 40288 1253 4 are be VBP 40288 1253 5 the the DT 40288 1253 6 melodies melody NNS 40288 1253 7 of of IN 40288 1253 8 three three CD 40288 1253 9 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 1253 10 pieces piece NNS 40288 1253 11 or or CC 40288 1253 12 hymns hymn NNS 40288 1253 13 , , , 40288 1253 14 viz viz NN 40288 1253 15 . . . 40288 1254 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1254 2 1 1 LS 40288 1254 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1254 4 a a DT 40288 1254 5 hymn hymn NN 40288 1254 6 to to IN 40288 1254 7 Calliope Calliope NNP 40288 1254 8 , , , 40288 1254 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1254 10 2 2 LS 40288 1254 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1254 12 a a DT 40288 1254 13 hymn hymn NN 40288 1254 14 to to IN 40288 1254 15 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 1254 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1254 17 or or CC 40288 1254 18 Helios),--both Helios),--both NNP 40288 1254 19 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 1254 20 to to IN 40288 1254 21 a a DT 40288 1254 22 certain certain JJ 40288 1254 23 Dionysius,--and Dionysius,--and NNP 40288 1254 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1254 25 3 3 LS 40288 1254 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1254 27 a a DT 40288 1254 28 hymn hymn NN 40288 1254 29 to to IN 40288 1254 30 Nemesis Nemesis NNP 40288 1254 31 , , , 40288 1254 32 ascribed ascribe VBN 40288 1254 33 to to IN 40288 1254 34 Mesomedes[2 mesomedes[2 NN 40288 1254 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1254 36 . . . 40288 1255 1 Besides besides IN 40288 1255 2 these these DT 40288 1255 3 there there EX 40288 1255 4 are be VBP 40288 1255 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1255 6 4 4 LS 40288 1255 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1255 8 some some DT 40288 1255 9 short short JJ 40288 1255 10 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1255 11 passages passage NNS 40288 1255 12 or or CC 40288 1255 13 exercises exercise NNS 40288 1255 14 given give VBN 40288 1255 15 by by IN 40288 1255 16 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 1255 17 's 's POS 40288 1255 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1255 19 Anonymus Anonymus NNP 40288 1255 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1255 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1255 22 pp pp NNP 40288 1255 23 . . . 40288 1256 1 94 94 CD 40288 1256 2 - - SYM 40288 1256 3 96 96 CD 40288 1256 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1256 5 . . . 40288 1257 1 And and CC 40288 1257 2 quite quite RB 40288 1257 3 recently recently RB 40288 1257 4 the the DT 40288 1257 5 list list NN 40288 1257 6 has have VBZ 40288 1257 7 been be VBN 40288 1257 8 increased increase VBN 40288 1257 9 by by IN 40288 1257 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1257 11 5 5 LS 40288 1257 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1257 13 an an DT 40288 1257 14 inscription inscription NN 40288 1257 15 discovered discover VBN 40288 1257 16 by by IN 40288 1257 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1257 18 W. W. NNP 40288 1257 19 M. M. NNP 40288 1257 20 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1257 21 , , , 40288 1257 22 which which WDT 40288 1257 23 gives give VBZ 40288 1257 24 a a DT 40288 1257 25 musical musical JJ 40288 1257 26 setting setting NN 40288 1257 27 of of IN 40288 1257 28 four four CD 40288 1257 29 short short JJ 40288 1257 30 gnomic gnomic JJ 40288 1257 31 sentences sentence NNS 40288 1257 32 , , , 40288 1257 33 and and CC 40288 1257 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1257 35 6 6 LS 40288 1257 36 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1257 37 a a DT 40288 1257 38 papyrus papyrus JJ 40288 1257 39 fragment fragment NN 40288 1257 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1257 41 now now RB 40288 1257 42 in in IN 40288 1257 43 the the DT 40288 1257 44 collection collection NN 40288 1257 45 of of IN 40288 1257 46 the the DT 40288 1257 47 Arch Arch NNP 40288 1257 48 - - HYPH 40288 1257 49 duke duke NNP 40288 1257 50 Rainer Rainer NNP 40288 1257 51 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1257 52 of of IN 40288 1257 53 the the DT 40288 1257 54 music music NN 40288 1257 55 of of IN 40288 1257 56 a a DT 40288 1257 57 chorus chorus NN 40288 1257 58 in in IN 40288 1257 59 the the DT 40288 1257 60 _ _ NNP 40288 1257 61 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1257 62 _ _ NNP 40288 1257 63 of of IN 40288 1257 64 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1257 65 . . . 40288 1258 1 These these DT 40288 1258 2 two two CD 40288 1258 3 last last JJ 40288 1258 4 additions addition NNS 40288 1258 5 to to IN 40288 1258 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1258 7 scanty scanty NN 40288 1258 8 stock stock NN 40288 1258 9 of of IN 40288 1258 10 Greek greek JJ 40288 1258 11 music music NN 40288 1258 12 are be VBP 40288 1258 13 set set VBN 40288 1258 14 out out RP 40288 1258 15 and and CC 40288 1258 16 discussed discuss VBN 40288 1258 17 by by IN 40288 1258 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1258 19 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1258 20 of of IN 40288 1258 21 Vienna Vienna NNP 40288 1258 22 and and CC 40288 1258 23 M. M. NNP 40288 1258 24 Ruelle Ruelle NNP 40288 1258 25 in in IN 40288 1258 26 the the DT 40288 1258 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1258 28 Revue Revue NNP 40288 1258 29 des des NNP 40288 1258 30 Études Études NNP 40288 1258 31 Grecques Grecques NNP 40288 1258 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1258 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1258 34 V. V. NNP 40288 1258 35 1892 1892 CD 40288 1258 36 , , , 40288 1258 37 pp pp NNP 40288 1258 38 . . . 40288 1259 1 265 265 CD 40288 1259 2 - - SYM 40288 1259 3 280 280 CD 40288 1259 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1259 5 , , , 40288 1259 6 also also RB 40288 1259 7 by by IN 40288 1259 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1259 9 Otto Otto NNP 40288 1259 10 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1259 11 in in IN 40288 1259 12 the the DT 40288 1259 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1259 14 Philologus Philologus NNP 40288 1259 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1259 16 , , , 40288 1259 17 Vol Vol NNP 40288 1259 18 . . . 40288 1260 1 LII LII NNP 40288 1260 2 , , , 40288 1260 3 pp pp NNP 40288 1260 4 . . . 40288 1261 1 160 160 CD 40288 1261 2 - - SYM 40288 1261 3 200[1 200[1 CD 40288 1261 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1261 5 . . . 40288 1262 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1262 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1262 3 2 2 CD 40288 1262 4 : : : 40288 1262 5 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1262 6 seems seem VBZ 40288 1262 7 needless needless JJ 40288 1262 8 to to TO 40288 1262 9 set set VB 40288 1262 10 out out RP 40288 1262 11 these these DT 40288 1262 12 melodies melody NNS 40288 1262 13 here here RB 40288 1262 14 . . . 40288 1263 1 The the DT 40288 1263 2 first first JJ 40288 1263 3 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40288 1263 4 edition edition NN 40288 1263 5 of of IN 40288 1263 6 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1263 7 is be VBZ 40288 1263 8 that that DT 40288 1263 9 of of IN 40288 1263 10 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 1263 11 , , , 40288 1263 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1263 13 Die Die NNP 40288 1263 14 Hymnen Hymnen NNP 40288 1263 15 des des FW 40288 1263 16 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1263 17 und und NN 40288 1263 18 Mesomedes Mesomedes NNP 40288 1263 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1263 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1263 21 Berlin Berlin NNP 40288 1263 22 , , , 40288 1263 23 1840 1840 CD 40288 1263 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1263 25 . . . 40288 1264 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1264 2 are be VBP 40288 1264 3 given give VBN 40288 1264 4 by by IN 40288 1264 5 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1264 6 in in IN 40288 1264 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1264 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1264 9 Musik Musik NNP 40288 1264 10 des des FW 40288 1264 11 griechischen griechischen NNP 40288 1264 12 Alterthumes Alterthumes NNP 40288 1264 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1264 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1264 15 1883 1883 CD 40288 1264 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1264 17 , , , 40288 1264 18 and and CC 40288 1264 19 by by IN 40288 1264 20 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 1264 21 , , , 40288 1264 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1264 23 Musique Musique NNP 40288 1264 24 de de NNP 40288 1264 25 l'Antiquité l'Antiquité NNP 40288 1264 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1264 27 , , , 40288 1264 28 vol vol NNP 40288 1264 29 . . . 40288 1265 1 i. i. NNP 40288 1265 2 pp pp NNP 40288 1265 3 . . . 40288 1266 1 445 445 CD 40288 1266 2 ff ff NNS 40288 1266 3 . . . 40288 1267 1 ; ; : 40288 1267 2 also also RB 40288 1267 3 in in IN 40288 1267 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1267 5 W. W. NNP 40288 1267 6 Chappell Chappell NNP 40288 1267 7 's 's POS 40288 1267 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1267 9 History History NNP 40288 1267 10 of of IN 40288 1267 11 Music Music NNP 40288 1267 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1267 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1267 14 London London NNP 40288 1267 15 , , , 40288 1267 16 1874 1874 CD 40288 1267 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1267 18 , , , 40288 1267 19 where where WRB 40288 1267 20 the the DT 40288 1267 21 melodies melody NNS 40288 1267 22 of of IN 40288 1267 23 the the DT 40288 1267 24 first first JJ 40288 1267 25 and and CC 40288 1267 26 third third JJ 40288 1267 27 hymns hymn NNS 40288 1267 28 will will MD 40288 1267 29 be be VB 40288 1267 30 found find VBN 40288 1267 31 harmonised harmonise VBN 40288 1267 32 by by IN 40288 1267 33 the the DT 40288 1267 34 late late JJ 40288 1267 35 Sir Sir NNP 40288 1267 36 George George NNP 40288 1267 37 Macfarren Macfarren NNP 40288 1267 38 . . . 40288 1268 1 The the DT 40288 1268 2 melody melody NN 40288 1268 3 published publish VBN 40288 1268 4 by by IN 40288 1268 5 Kircher Kircher NNP 40288 1268 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1268 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1268 8 Musurgia Musurgia NNP 40288 1268 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1268 10 , , , 40288 1268 11 i. i. NNP 40288 1268 12 p. p. NN 40288 1268 13 541 541 CD 40288 1268 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1268 15 as as IN 40288 1268 16 a a DT 40288 1268 17 fragment fragment NN 40288 1268 18 of of IN 40288 1268 19 the the DT 40288 1268 20 first first JJ 40288 1268 21 Pythian pythian JJ 40288 1268 22 ode ode NN 40288 1268 23 of of IN 40288 1268 24 Pindar Pindar NNP 40288 1268 25 has have VBZ 40288 1268 26 no no DT 40288 1268 27 attestation attestation NN 40288 1268 28 , , , 40288 1268 29 and and CC 40288 1268 30 is be VBZ 40288 1268 31 generally generally RB 40288 1268 32 regarded regard VBN 40288 1268 33 as as IN 40288 1268 34 a a DT 40288 1268 35 forgery forgery NN 40288 1268 36 . . . 40288 1268 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1269 1 The the DT 40288 1269 2 music music NN 40288 1269 3 of of IN 40288 1269 4 the the DT 40288 1269 5 three three CD 40288 1269 6 hymns hymn NNS 40288 1269 7 is be VBZ 40288 1269 8 noted note VBN 40288 1269 9 in in IN 40288 1269 10 the the DT 40288 1269 11 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1269 12 key key NN 40288 1269 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1269 14 answering answer VBG 40288 1269 15 to to IN 40288 1269 16 the the DT 40288 1269 17 modern modern JJ 40288 1269 18 scale scale NN 40288 1269 19 with with IN 40288 1269 20 one one CD 40288 1269 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1269 22 symbol symbol NN 40288 1269 23 : : : 40288 1269 24 flat flat LS 40288 1269 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1269 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1269 27 . . . 40288 1270 1 The the DT 40288 1270 2 melody melody NN 40288 1270 3 of of IN 40288 1270 4 the the DT 40288 1270 5 second second JJ 40288 1270 6 hymn hymn NN 40288 1270 7 is be VBZ 40288 1270 8 of of IN 40288 1270 9 the the DT 40288 1270 10 compass compass NN 40288 1270 11 of of IN 40288 1270 12 an an DT 40288 1270 13 octave octave NN 40288 1270 14 , , , 40288 1270 15 the the DT 40288 1270 16 notes note NNS 40288 1270 17 being be VBG 40288 1270 18 those those DT 40288 1270 19 of of IN 40288 1270 20 the the DT 40288 1270 21 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1270 22 System System NNP 40288 1270 23 from from IN 40288 1270 24 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 1270 25 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 1270 26 to to IN 40288 1270 27 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 1270 28 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1270 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1270 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1270 31 f f NNP 40288 1270 32 - - HYPH 40288 1270 33 f f NNP 40288 1270 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1270 35 with with IN 40288 1270 36 one one CD 40288 1270 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1270 38 symbol symbol NN 40288 1270 39 : : : 40288 1270 40 flat flat LS 40288 1270 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1270 42 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1270 43 . . . 40288 1271 1 The the DT 40288 1271 2 first first JJ 40288 1271 3 employs employ VBZ 40288 1271 4 the the DT 40288 1271 5 same same JJ 40288 1271 6 octave octave NN 40288 1271 7 with with IN 40288 1271 8 a a DT 40288 1271 9 lower low JJR 40288 1271 10 note note NN 40288 1271 11 added add VBN 40288 1271 12 , , , 40288 1271 13 viz viz NN 40288 1271 14 . . . 40288 1272 1 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1272 2 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 1272 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1272 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1272 5 e e NNP 40288 1272 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1272 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1272 8 : : : 40288 1272 9 the the DT 40288 1272 10 third third JJ 40288 1272 11 adds add VBZ 40288 1272 12 the the DT 40288 1272 13 next next JJ 40288 1272 14 higher high JJR 40288 1272 15 note note NN 40288 1272 16 , , , 40288 1272 17 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 1272 18 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1272 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1272 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1272 21 g g NNP 40288 1272 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1272 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1272 24 . . . 40288 1273 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1273 2 the the DT 40288 1273 3 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1273 4 key key NN 40288 1273 5 may may MD 40288 1273 6 be be VB 40288 1273 7 said say VBN 40288 1273 8 , , , 40288 1273 9 in in IN 40288 1273 10 the the DT 40288 1273 11 case case NN 40288 1273 12 of of IN 40288 1273 13 the the DT 40288 1273 14 second second JJ 40288 1273 15 hymn hymn NN 40288 1273 16 , , , 40288 1273 17 and and CC 40288 1273 18 less less RBR 40288 1273 19 exactly exactly RB 40288 1273 20 in in IN 40288 1273 21 the the DT 40288 1273 22 case case NN 40288 1273 23 of of IN 40288 1273 24 the the DT 40288 1273 25 two two CD 40288 1273 26 others other NNS 40288 1273 27 , , , 40288 1273 28 to to TO 40288 1273 29 give give VB 40288 1273 30 the the DT 40288 1273 31 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1273 32 or or CC 40288 1273 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1273 34 c_-species c_-species NNP 40288 1273 35 of of IN 40288 1273 36 the the DT 40288 1273 37 octave octave NN 40288 1273 38 in in IN 40288 1273 39 the the DT 40288 1273 40 most most RBS 40288 1273 41 convenient convenient JJ 40288 1273 42 part part NN 40288 1273 43 of of IN 40288 1273 44 the the DT 40288 1273 45 scale scale NN 40288 1273 46 ; ; : 40288 1273 47 just just RB 40288 1273 48 as as IN 40288 1273 49 on on IN 40288 1273 50 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1273 51 's 's POS 40288 1273 52 system system NN 40288 1273 53 of of IN 40288 1273 54 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1273 55 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1273 56 should should MD 40288 1273 57 expect expect VB 40288 1273 58 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1273 59 to to TO 40288 1273 60 do do VB 40288 1273 61 . . . 40288 1274 1 This this DT 40288 1274 2 octave octave NN 40288 1274 3 , , , 40288 1274 4 however however RB 40288 1274 5 , , , 40288 1274 6 represents represent VBZ 40288 1274 7 merely merely RB 40288 1274 8 the the DT 40288 1274 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 10 compass compass NN 40288 1274 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1274 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 14 ambitus ambitus NNP 40288 1274 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 16 or or CC 40288 1274 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 18 tessitura tessitura NNP 40288 1274 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1274 21 of of IN 40288 1274 22 the the DT 40288 1274 23 melody melody NN 40288 1274 24 : : : 40288 1274 25 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1274 26 has have VBZ 40288 1274 27 nothing nothing NN 40288 1274 28 to to TO 40288 1274 29 do do VB 40288 1274 30 with with IN 40288 1274 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1274 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 33 tonality tonality NN 40288 1274 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1274 35 . . . 40288 1275 1 In in IN 40288 1275 2 the the DT 40288 1275 3 first first JJ 40288 1275 4 two two CD 40288 1275 5 hymns hymn NNS 40288 1275 6 , , , 40288 1275 7 as as IN 40288 1275 8 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 1275 9 pointed point VBD 40288 1275 10 out out RP 40288 1275 11 , , , 40288 1275 12 the the DT 40288 1275 13 key key NN 40288 1275 14 - - HYPH 40288 1275 15 note note NN 40288 1275 16 is be VBZ 40288 1275 17 the the DT 40288 1275 18 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1275 19 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1275 20 ; ; : 40288 1275 21 and and CC 40288 1275 22 the the DT 40288 1275 23 mode mode NN 40288 1275 24 -- -- : 40288 1275 25 in in IN 40288 1275 26 the the DT 40288 1275 27 modern modern JJ 40288 1275 28 sense sense NN 40288 1275 29 of of IN 40288 1275 30 that that DT 40288 1275 31 word word NN 40288 1275 32 -- -- : 40288 1275 33 is be VBZ 40288 1275 34 that that DT 40288 1275 35 of of IN 40288 1275 36 the the DT 40288 1275 37 octave octave NN 40288 1275 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1275 39 e e NNP 40288 1275 40 - - HYPH 40288 1275 41 e e NNP 40288 1275 42 _ _ NNP 40288 1275 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1275 44 the the DT 40288 1275 45 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1275 46 mode mode NN 40288 1275 47 of of IN 40288 1275 48 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1275 49 's 's POS 40288 1275 50 theory theory NN 40288 1275 51 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1275 52 . . . 40288 1276 1 In in IN 40288 1276 2 the the DT 40288 1276 3 third third JJ 40288 1276 4 hymn hymn NN 40288 1276 5 the the DT 40288 1276 6 key key JJ 40288 1276 7 - - HYPH 40288 1276 8 note note NN 40288 1276 9 appears appear VBZ 40288 1276 10 to to TO 40288 1276 11 be be VB 40288 1276 12 the the DT 40288 1276 13 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1276 14 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1276 15 , , , 40288 1276 16 so so IN 40288 1276 17 that that IN 40288 1276 18 the the DT 40288 1276 19 mode mode NN 40288 1276 20 is be VBZ 40288 1276 21 that that DT 40288 1276 22 of of IN 40288 1276 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1276 24 g g NNP 40288 1276 25 - - HYPH 40288 1276 26 g g NNP 40288 1276 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1276 28 , , , 40288 1276 29 viz viz NN 40288 1276 30 . . . 40288 1277 1 the the DT 40288 1277 2 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1277 3 - - HYPH 40288 1277 4 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1277 5 . . . 40288 1278 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1278 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1278 3 1 1 CD 40288 1278 4 : : : 40288 1278 5 Of of IN 40288 1278 6 the the DT 40288 1278 7 discovery discovery NN 40288 1278 8 made make VBN 40288 1278 9 at at IN 40288 1278 10 Delphi Delphi NNP 40288 1278 11 , , , 40288 1278 12 after after IN 40288 1278 13 most most JJS 40288 1278 14 of of IN 40288 1278 15 this this DT 40288 1278 16 book book NN 40288 1278 17 was be VBD 40288 1278 18 in in IN 40288 1278 19 type type NN 40288 1278 20 , , , 40288 1278 21 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1278 22 hope hope VBP 40288 1278 23 to to TO 40288 1278 24 say say VB 40288 1278 25 something something NN 40288 1278 26 in in IN 40288 1278 27 the the DT 40288 1278 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1278 29 Appendix Appendix NNP 40288 1278 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1278 31 . . . 40288 1278 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1279 1 Of of IN 40288 1279 2 the the DT 40288 1279 3 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1279 4 passages passage NNS 40288 1279 5 given give VBN 40288 1279 6 by by IN 40288 1279 7 the the DT 40288 1279 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1279 9 Anonymus Anonymus NNP 40288 1279 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1279 11 three three CD 40288 1279 12 are be VBP 40288 1279 13 clearly clearly RB 40288 1279 14 in in IN 40288 1279 15 the the DT 40288 1279 16 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1279 17 - - HYPH 40288 1279 18 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1279 19 or or CC 40288 1279 20 common common JJ 40288 1279 21 mode mode NN 40288 1279 22 , , , 40288 1279 23 the the DT 40288 1279 24 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1279 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1279 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1279 27 a a DT 40288 1279 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1279 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1279 30 being be VBG 40288 1279 31 the the DT 40288 1279 32 key key NN 40288 1279 33 - - HYPH 40288 1279 34 note note NN 40288 1279 35 . . . 40288 1280 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1280 2 See see VB 40288 1280 3 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 1280 4 , , , 40288 1280 5 i. i. NNP 40288 1280 6 p. p. NN 40288 1281 1 141 141 CD 40288 1281 2 . . . 40288 1281 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1282 1 A a DT 40288 1282 2 fourth fourth JJ 40288 1282 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1282 4 § § NFP 40288 1282 5 104 104 CD 40288 1282 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1282 7 also also RB 40288 1282 8 ends end VBZ 40288 1282 9 on on IN 40288 1282 10 the the DT 40288 1282 11 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1282 12 , , , 40288 1282 13 but but CC 40288 1282 14 the the DT 40288 1282 15 key key JJ 40288 1282 16 - - HYPH 40288 1282 17 note note NN 40288 1282 18 appears appear VBZ 40288 1282 19 to to TO 40288 1282 20 be be VB 40288 1282 21 the the DT 40288 1282 22 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 1282 23 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1282 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1282 25 _ _ NNP 40288 1282 26 f f NNP 40288 1282 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1282 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1282 29 . . . 40288 1283 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40288 1283 2 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1283 3 and and CC 40288 1283 4 Gevaert Gevaert NNP 40288 1283 5 assign assign VBP 40288 1283 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1283 7 to to IN 40288 1283 8 the the DT 40288 1283 9 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 1283 10 - - HYPH 40288 1283 11 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1283 12 species specie NNS 40288 1283 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1283 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1283 15 f f NNP 40288 1283 16 - - HYPH 40288 1283 17 f f NNP 40288 1283 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1283 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1283 20 . . . 40288 1284 1 In in IN 40288 1284 2 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1284 3 's 's POS 40288 1284 4 view view NN 40288 1284 5 the the DT 40288 1284 6 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 1284 7 of of IN 40288 1284 8 the the DT 40288 1284 9 end end NN 40288 1284 10 of of IN 40288 1284 11 the the DT 40288 1284 12 melody melody NN 40288 1284 13 falling fall VBG 40288 1284 14 , , , 40288 1284 15 not not RB 40288 1284 16 on on IN 40288 1284 17 the the DT 40288 1284 18 key key NN 40288 1284 19 - - HYPH 40288 1284 20 note note NN 40288 1284 21 , , , 40288 1284 22 but but CC 40288 1284 23 on on IN 40288 1284 24 the the DT 40288 1284 25 Third third JJ 40288 1284 26 or or CC 40288 1284 27 Mediant mediant JJ 40288 1284 28 of of IN 40288 1284 29 the the DT 40288 1284 30 octave octave NN 40288 1284 31 , , , 40288 1284 32 was be VBD 40288 1284 33 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 1284 34 of of IN 40288 1284 35 the the DT 40288 1284 36 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1284 37 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 1284 38 by by IN 40288 1284 39 the the DT 40288 1284 40 prefix prefix NN 40288 1284 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1284 42 syntono- syntono- NN 40288 1284 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1284 44 , , , 40288 1284 45 and and CC 40288 1284 46 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 1284 47 the the DT 40288 1284 48 passage passage NN 40288 1284 49 in in IN 40288 1284 50 question question NN 40288 1284 51 is be VBZ 40288 1284 52 pronounced pronounce VBN 40288 1284 53 by by IN 40288 1284 54 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1284 55 to to TO 40288 1284 56 be be VB 40288 1284 57 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 1284 58 - - HYPH 40288 1284 59 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1284 60 . . . 40288 1285 1 All all PDT 40288 1285 2 those those DT 40288 1285 3 passages passage NNS 40288 1285 4 , , , 40288 1285 5 however however RB 40288 1285 6 , , , 40288 1285 7 are be VBP 40288 1285 8 mere mere JJ 40288 1285 9 fragments fragment NNS 40288 1285 10 of of IN 40288 1285 11 two two CD 40288 1285 12 or or CC 40288 1285 13 three three CD 40288 1285 14 bars bar NNS 40288 1285 15 each each DT 40288 1285 16 , , , 40288 1285 17 and and CC 40288 1285 18 are be VBP 40288 1285 19 quoted quote VBN 40288 1285 20 as as IN 40288 1285 21 examples example NNS 40288 1285 22 of of IN 40288 1285 23 certain certain JJ 40288 1285 24 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 40288 1285 25 of of IN 40288 1285 26 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1285 27 . . . 40288 1286 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1286 2 can can MD 40288 1286 3 hardly hardly RB 40288 1286 4 be be VB 40288 1286 5 made make VBN 40288 1286 6 to to TO 40288 1286 7 lend lend VB 40288 1286 8 much much JJ 40288 1286 9 support support NN 40288 1286 10 to to IN 40288 1286 11 any any DT 40288 1286 12 theory theory NN 40288 1286 13 of of IN 40288 1286 14 the the DT 40288 1286 15 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1286 16 . . . 40288 1287 1 The the DT 40288 1287 2 music music NN 40288 1287 3 of of IN 40288 1287 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1287 5 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1287 6 's 's POS 40288 1287 7 inscription inscription NN 40288 1287 8 labours labour VBZ 40288 1287 9 under under IN 40288 1287 10 the the DT 40288 1287 11 same same JJ 40288 1287 12 defect defect NN 40288 1287 13 of of IN 40288 1287 14 excessive excessive JJ 40288 1287 15 shortness shortness NN 40288 1287 16 . . . 40288 1288 1 If if IN 40288 1288 2 , , , 40288 1288 3 however however RB 40288 1288 4 , , , 40288 1288 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1288 6 regard regard VBP 40288 1288 7 the the DT 40288 1288 8 four four CD 40288 1288 9 brief brief JJ 40288 1288 10 sentences sentence NNS 40288 1288 11 as as IN 40288 1288 12 set set VBN 40288 1288 13 to to IN 40288 1288 14 a a DT 40288 1288 15 continuous continuous JJ 40288 1288 16 melody melody NN 40288 1288 17 , , , 40288 1288 18 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1288 19 obtain obtain VBP 40288 1288 20 a a DT 40288 1288 21 passage passage NN 40288 1288 22 consisting consist VBG 40288 1288 23 of of IN 40288 1288 24 thirty thirty CD 40288 1288 25 - - HYPH 40288 1288 26 six six CD 40288 1288 27 notes note NNS 40288 1288 28 in in IN 40288 1288 29 all all DT 40288 1288 30 , , , 40288 1288 31 with with IN 40288 1288 32 a a DT 40288 1288 33 compass compass NN 40288 1288 34 of of IN 40288 1288 35 less less JJR 40288 1288 36 than than IN 40288 1288 37 an an DT 40288 1288 38 octave octave NN 40288 1288 39 , , , 40288 1288 40 and and CC 40288 1288 41 ending end VBG 40288 1288 42 on on IN 40288 1288 43 the the DT 40288 1288 44 lowest low JJS 40288 1288 45 note note NN 40288 1288 46 of of IN 40288 1288 47 that that DT 40288 1288 48 compass compass NN 40288 1288 49 . . . 40288 1289 1 Unlike unlike IN 40288 1289 2 the the DT 40288 1289 3 other other JJ 40288 1289 4 extant extant JJ 40288 1289 5 specimens specimen NNS 40288 1289 6 of of IN 40288 1289 7 Greek greek JJ 40288 1289 8 music music NN 40288 1289 9 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1289 10 is be VBZ 40288 1289 11 written write VBN 40288 1289 12 in in IN 40288 1289 13 the the DT 40288 1289 14 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1289 15 key key NN 40288 1289 16 -- -- : 40288 1289 17 a a DT 40288 1289 18 curious curious JJ 40288 1289 19 fact fact NN 40288 1289 20 which which WDT 40288 1289 21 has have VBZ 40288 1289 22 not not RB 40288 1289 23 been be VBN 40288 1289 24 noticed notice VBN 40288 1289 25 by by IN 40288 1289 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1289 27 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1289 28 . . . 40288 1290 1 INSCRIPTION inscription NN 40288 1290 2 WITH with IN 40288 1290 3 MUSICAL MUSICAL NNP 40288 1290 4 NOTES note NNS 40288 1290 5 . . . 40288 1291 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1291 2 Music music NN 40288 1291 3 : : : 40288 1291 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1291 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1291 6 : : : 40288 1291 7 hos hos LS 40288 1291 8 - - HYPH 40288 1291 9 on on RP 40288 1291 10 zês zês NNP 40288 1291 11 phai phai NNP 40288 1291 12 - - HYPH 40288 1291 13 nou nou NNP 40288 1291 14 . . . 40288 1292 1 mê mê NNP 40288 1292 2 - - HYPH 40288 1292 3 den den NNP 40288 1292 4 hol hol NNP 40288 1292 5 - - HYPH 40288 1292 6 ôs ôs NNP 40288 1292 7 sy sy NNP 40288 1292 8 ly ly NNP 40288 1292 9 - - HYPH 40288 1292 10 pou pou NNP 40288 1292 11 . . . 40288 1293 1 pros pros NNP 40288 1293 2 o o NNP 40288 1293 3 - - HYPH 40288 1293 4 li li NNP 40288 1293 5 - - HYPH 40288 1293 6 gon gon NNP 40288 1293 7 es es NNP 40288 1293 8 - - HYPH 40288 1293 9 ti ti NNP 40288 1293 10 to to IN 40288 1293 11 zên zên NNP 40288 1293 12 . . . 40288 1294 1 to to IN 40288 1294 2 te te NNP 40288 1294 3 - - HYPH 40288 1294 4 los los NNP 40288 1294 5 ho ho NNP 40288 1294 6 chro chro NNP 40288 1294 7 - - HYPH 40288 1294 8 nos nos NNP 40288 1294 9 a a DT 40288 1294 10 - - HYPH 40288 1294 11 pai pai NNP 40288 1294 12 - - HYPH 40288 1294 13 tei tei NN 40288 1294 14 . . . 40288 1294 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1295 1 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1295 2 The the DT 40288 1295 3 notes note NNS 40288 1295 4 which which WDT 40288 1295 5 enter enter VBP 40288 1295 6 into into IN 40288 1295 7 this this DT 40288 1295 8 melody melody NN 40288 1295 9 form form VB 40288 1295 10 the the DT 40288 1295 11 scale scale NN 40288 1295 12 _ _ NN 40288 1295 13 f[Symbols f[symbols NN 40288 1295 14 : : : 40288 1295 15 sharp]-g sharp]-g VB 40288 1295 16 - - HYPH 40288 1295 17 a a DT 40288 1295 18 - - HYPH 40288 1295 19 b b NN 40288 1295 20 - - HYPH 40288 1295 21 c[Symbols c[symbols NN 40288 1295 22 : : : 40288 1295 23 sharp]-d sharp]-d NNP 40288 1295 24 - - HYPH 40288 1295 25 e[-f[Symbols e[-f[symbol NNS 40288 1295 26 : : : 40288 1295 27 sharp sharp JJ 40288 1295 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1295 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1295 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1295 31 , , , 40288 1295 32 which which WDT 40288 1295 33 is be VBZ 40288 1295 34 an an DT 40288 1295 35 octave octave NN 40288 1295 36 of of IN 40288 1295 37 the the DT 40288 1295 38 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1295 39 species specie NNS 40288 1295 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1295 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1295 42 e e NNP 40288 1295 43 - - HYPH 40288 1295 44 e e NNP 40288 1295 45 _ _ NNP 40288 1295 46 on on IN 40288 1295 47 the the DT 40288 1295 48 white white JJ 40288 1295 49 notes note NNS 40288 1295 50 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1295 51 . . . 40288 1296 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1296 2 if if IN 40288 1296 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1296 4 f_[Symbols f_[symbol VBZ 40288 1296 5 : : : 40288 1296 6 sharp sharp JJ 40288 1296 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1296 8 , , , 40288 1296 9 on on IN 40288 1296 10 which which WDT 40288 1296 11 the the DT 40288 1296 12 melody melody NN 40288 1296 13 ends end VBZ 40288 1296 14 , , , 40288 1296 15 is be VBZ 40288 1296 16 the the DT 40288 1296 17 key key NN 40288 1296 18 - - HYPH 40288 1296 19 note note NN 40288 1296 20 , , , 40288 1296 21 the the DT 40288 1296 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1296 23 mode mode NN 40288 1296 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1296 25 is be VBZ 40288 1296 26 the the DT 40288 1296 27 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1296 28 . . . 40288 1297 1 On on IN 40288 1297 2 the the DT 40288 1297 3 other other JJ 40288 1297 4 hand hand NN 40288 1297 5 the the DT 40288 1297 6 predominant predominant JJ 40288 1297 7 notes note NNS 40288 1297 8 are be VBP 40288 1297 9 those those DT 40288 1297 10 of of IN 40288 1297 11 the the DT 40288 1297 12 triad triad NNP 40288 1297 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1297 14 a a NNP 40288 1297 15 - - HYPH 40288 1297 16 c[Symbols c[symbols NN 40288 1297 17 : : : 40288 1297 18 sharp]-e sharp]-e NNP 40288 1297 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1297 20 , , , 40288 1297 21 which which WDT 40288 1297 22 point point VBP 40288 1297 23 to to IN 40288 1297 24 the the DT 40288 1297 25 key key NN 40288 1297 26 of of IN 40288 1297 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1297 28 a a DT 40288 1297 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1297 30 major major NN 40288 1297 31 , , , 40288 1297 32 with with IN 40288 1297 33 the the DT 40288 1297 34 difference difference NN 40288 1297 35 that that WDT 40288 1297 36 the the DT 40288 1297 37 Seventh Seventh NNP 40288 1297 38 is be VBZ 40288 1297 39 flat flat JJ 40288 1297 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1297 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1297 42 g g NNP 40288 1297 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1297 44 instead instead RB 40288 1297 45 of of IN 40288 1297 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1297 47 g_[Symbols g_[Symbols NNP 40288 1297 48 : : : 40288 1297 49 sharp sharp JJ 40288 1297 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1297 51 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1297 52 . . . 40288 1298 1 On on IN 40288 1298 2 this this DT 40288 1298 3 view view NN 40288 1298 4 the the DT 40288 1298 5 music music NN 40288 1298 6 would would MD 40288 1298 7 be be VB 40288 1298 8 in in IN 40288 1298 9 the the DT 40288 1298 10 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1298 11 - - HYPH 40288 1298 12 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1298 13 mode mode NN 40288 1298 14 . . . 40288 1299 1 However however RB 40288 1299 2 this this DT 40288 1299 3 may may MD 40288 1299 4 be be VB 40288 1299 5 , , , 40288 1299 6 the the DT 40288 1299 7 most most RBS 40288 1299 8 singular singular JJ 40288 1299 9 feature feature NN 40288 1299 10 of of IN 40288 1299 11 this this DT 40288 1299 12 fragment fragment NN 40288 1299 13 remains remain VBZ 40288 1299 14 to to TO 40288 1299 15 be be VB 40288 1299 16 mentioned mention VBN 40288 1299 17 , , , 40288 1299 18 viz viz NN 40288 1299 19 . . . 40288 1300 1 the the DT 40288 1300 2 agreement agreement NN 40288 1300 3 between between IN 40288 1300 4 the the DT 40288 1300 5 musical musical JJ 40288 1300 6 notes note NNS 40288 1300 7 and and CC 40288 1300 8 the the DT 40288 1300 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1300 10 accentuation accentuation NN 40288 1300 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1300 12 of of IN 40288 1300 13 the the DT 40288 1300 14 words word NNS 40288 1300 15 . . . 40288 1301 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1301 2 know know VBP 40288 1301 3 from from IN 40288 1301 4 the the DT 40288 1301 5 grammarians grammarian NNS 40288 1301 6 that that WDT 40288 1301 7 an an DT 40288 1301 8 acute acute JJ 40288 1301 9 accent accent NN 40288 1301 10 signified signify VBD 40288 1301 11 that that IN 40288 1301 12 the the DT 40288 1301 13 vowel vowel NN 40288 1301 14 was be VBD 40288 1301 15 sounded sound VBN 40288 1301 16 with with IN 40288 1301 17 a a DT 40288 1301 18 rise rise NN 40288 1301 19 in in IN 40288 1301 20 the the DT 40288 1301 21 pitch pitch NN 40288 1301 22 of of IN 40288 1301 23 the the DT 40288 1301 24 voice voice NN 40288 1301 25 , , , 40288 1301 26 and and CC 40288 1301 27 that that IN 40288 1301 28 a a DT 40288 1301 29 circumflex circumflex NN 40288 1301 30 denoted denote VBD 40288 1301 31 a a DT 40288 1301 32 rise rise NN 40288 1301 33 followed follow VBN 40288 1301 34 on on IN 40288 1301 35 the the DT 40288 1301 36 same same JJ 40288 1301 37 syllable syllable NN 40288 1301 38 by by IN 40288 1301 39 a a DT 40288 1301 40 lower low JJR 40288 1301 41 note note NN 40288 1301 42 -- -- : 40288 1301 43 every every DT 40288 1301 44 such such JJ 40288 1301 45 rise rise NN 40288 1301 46 and and CC 40288 1301 47 fall fall VB 40288 1301 48 being be VBG 40288 1301 49 quite quite RB 40288 1301 50 independent independent JJ 40288 1301 51 both both DT 40288 1301 52 of of IN 40288 1301 53 syllabic syllabic JJ 40288 1301 54 quantity quantity NN 40288 1301 55 and and CC 40288 1301 56 of of IN 40288 1301 57 stress stress NN 40288 1301 58 or or CC 40288 1301 59 _ _ NNP 40288 1301 60 ictus ictus NN 40288 1301 61 _ _ NNP 40288 1301 62 . . . 40288 1302 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1302 2 in in IN 40288 1302 3 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1302 4 speech speech NN 40288 1302 5 the the DT 40288 1302 6 accents accent NNS 40288 1302 7 formed form VBD 40288 1302 8 a a DT 40288 1302 9 species species NN 40288 1302 10 of of IN 40288 1302 11 melody,--[Greek melody,--[Greek NNP 40288 1302 12 : : : 40288 1302 13 logôdes logôdes NNP 40288 1302 14 ti ti NNP 40288 1302 15 melos melos NNP 40288 1302 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1302 17 , , , 40288 1302 18 as as IN 40288 1302 19 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1302 20 is be VBZ 40288 1302 21 called call VBN 40288 1302 22 by by IN 40288 1302 23 Aristoxenus[1 Aristoxenus[1 NNP 40288 1302 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1302 25 . . . 40288 1303 1 When when WRB 40288 1303 2 words word NNS 40288 1303 3 were be VBD 40288 1303 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1303 5 sung sung JJ 40288 1303 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1303 7 this this DT 40288 1303 8 ' ' `` 40288 1303 9 spoken speak VBN 40288 1303 10 melody melody NN 40288 1303 11 ' ' '' 40288 1303 12 was be VBD 40288 1303 13 no no RB 40288 1303 14 longer long RBR 40288 1303 15 heard hear VBN 40288 1303 16 , , , 40288 1303 17 being be VBG 40288 1303 18 superseded supersede VBN 40288 1303 19 by by IN 40288 1303 20 the the DT 40288 1303 21 melody melody NN 40288 1303 22 proper proper JJ 40288 1303 23 . . . 40288 1304 1 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1304 2 of of IN 40288 1304 3 Halicarnassus Halicarnassus NNP 40288 1304 4 is be VBZ 40288 1304 5 at at IN 40288 1304 6 pains pain NNS 40288 1304 7 to to TO 40288 1304 8 explain explain VB 40288 1304 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1304 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1304 11 De De NNP 40288 1304 12 Comp Comp NNP 40288 1304 13 . . . 40288 1305 1 Verb Verb NNP 40288 1305 2 . . . 40288 1305 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1305 4 , , , 40288 1305 5 c. c. NNP 40288 1305 6 11 11 CD 40288 1305 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1305 8 , , , 40288 1305 9 that that IN 40288 1305 10 the the DT 40288 1305 11 melody melody NN 40288 1305 12 to to TO 40288 1305 13 which which WDT 40288 1305 14 words word NNS 40288 1305 15 are be VBP 40288 1305 16 set set VBN 40288 1305 17 does do VBZ 40288 1305 18 not not RB 40288 1305 19 usually usually RB 40288 1305 20 follow follow VB 40288 1305 21 or or CC 40288 1305 22 resemble resemble VB 40288 1305 23 the the DT 40288 1305 24 quasi quasi JJ 40288 1305 25 - - HYPH 40288 1305 26 melody melody NN 40288 1305 27 of of IN 40288 1305 28 the the DT 40288 1305 29 accents accent NNS 40288 1305 30 , , , 40288 1305 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1305 32 e.g. e.g. RB 40288 1305 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1305 34 in in IN 40288 1305 35 the the DT 40288 1305 36 following follow VBG 40288 1305 37 words word NNS 40288 1305 38 of of IN 40288 1305 39 a a DT 40288 1305 40 chorus chorus NN 40288 1305 41 in in IN 40288 1305 42 the the DT 40288 1305 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1305 44 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1305 45 _ _ NNP 40288 1305 46 of of IN 40288 1305 47 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1305 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1305 49 ll will NN 40288 1305 50 . . . 40288 1306 1 140 140 CD 40288 1306 2 - - SYM 40288 1306 3 142):-- 142):-- CD 40288 1306 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1306 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1306 6 : : : 40288 1306 7 siga siga NNP 40288 1306 8 siga siga VBZ 40288 1306 9 leukon leukon NNP 40288 1306 10 ichnos ichnos NNP 40288 1306 11 arbylês arbylê NNS 40288 1306 12 tithete tithete NNP 40288 1306 13 , , , 40288 1306 14 mê mê NNP 40288 1306 15 ktypeite ktypeite NNP 40288 1306 16 ; ; : 40288 1306 17 apoprobat apoprobat NNP 40288 1306 18 ' ' `` 40288 1306 19 ekeis ekeis NNP 40288 1306 20 ' ' '' 40288 1306 21 apopro apopro NNP 40288 1306 22 moi moi NNP 40288 1306 23 koitas koitas NNP 40288 1306 24 , , , 40288 1306 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1306 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1306 27 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1306 28 1 1 CD 40288 1306 29 : : : 40288 1306 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1306 31 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1306 32 . . . 40288 1306 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1306 34 p. p. NN 40288 1306 35 18 18 CD 40288 1306 36 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1306 37 . . . 40288 1307 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1307 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1307 3 : : : 40288 1307 4 legetai legetai NNP 40288 1307 5 gar gar NNP 40288 1307 6 dê dê NNP 40288 1307 7 kai kai NNP 40288 1307 8 logôdes logôde NNS 40288 1307 9 ti ti NNP 40288 1307 10 melos melos NNP 40288 1307 11 , , , 40288 1307 12 to to TO 40288 1307 13 synkeimenon synkeimenon VB 40288 1307 14 ek ek NNP 40288 1307 15 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1307 16 prosôdiôn prosôdiôn NNP 40288 1307 17 , , , 40288 1307 18 to to IN 40288 1307 19 en en NNP 40288 1307 20 tois tois NNP 40288 1307 21 onomasi onomasi NNP 40288 1307 22 ; ; : 40288 1307 23 physikon physikon NNP 40288 1307 24 gar gar NNP 40288 1307 25 to to IN 40288 1307 26 epiteinein epiteinein NNP 40288 1307 27 kai kai NNP 40288 1307 28 anienai anienai NNP 40288 1307 29 en en NNP 40288 1307 30 tô tô NNP 40288 1307 31 dialegesthai dialegesthai NNP 40288 1307 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1307 33 . . . 40288 1307 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1308 1 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1308 2 notices notice VBZ 40288 1308 3 that that IN 40288 1308 4 the the DT 40288 1308 5 melody melody NN 40288 1308 6 differs differ VBZ 40288 1308 7 in in IN 40288 1308 8 several several JJ 40288 1308 9 points point NNS 40288 1308 10 from from IN 40288 1308 11 the the DT 40288 1308 12 spoken spoken JJ 40288 1308 13 accents accent NNS 40288 1308 14 : : : 40288 1308 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1308 16 1 1 LS 40288 1308 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1308 18 the the DT 40288 1308 19 three three CD 40288 1308 20 first first JJ 40288 1308 21 words word NNS 40288 1308 22 are be VBP 40288 1308 23 all all RB 40288 1308 24 on on IN 40288 1308 25 the the DT 40288 1308 26 same same JJ 40288 1308 27 note note NN 40288 1308 28 , , , 40288 1308 29 in in IN 40288 1308 30 spite spite NN 40288 1308 31 of of IN 40288 1308 32 the the DT 40288 1308 33 accents accent NNS 40288 1308 34 ; ; , 40288 1308 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1308 36 2 2 LS 40288 1308 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1308 38 the the DT 40288 1308 39 last last JJ 40288 1308 40 syllable syllable NN 40288 1308 41 of of IN 40288 1308 42 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1308 43 Greek greek JJ 40288 1308 44 : : : 40288 1308 45 arbylês arbylê NNS 40288 1308 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1308 47 is be VBZ 40288 1308 48 as as RB 40288 1308 49 high high JJ 40288 1308 50 as as IN 40288 1308 51 the the DT 40288 1308 52 second second JJ 40288 1308 53 , , , 40288 1308 54 though though IN 40288 1308 55 that that DT 40288 1308 56 is be VBZ 40288 1308 57 the the DT 40288 1308 58 only only JJ 40288 1308 59 accented accented JJ 40288 1308 60 syllable syllable NN 40288 1308 61 : : : 40288 1308 62 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1308 63 3 3 LS 40288 1308 64 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1308 65 the the DT 40288 1308 66 first first JJ 40288 1308 67 syllable syllable NN 40288 1308 68 of of IN 40288 1308 69 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1308 70 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1308 71 : : : 40288 1308 72 tithete tithete NN 40288 1308 73 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1308 74 is be VBZ 40288 1308 75 lower low JJR 40288 1308 76 than than IN 40288 1308 77 the the DT 40288 1308 78 two two CD 40288 1308 79 others other NNS 40288 1308 80 , , , 40288 1308 81 instead instead RB 40288 1308 82 of of IN 40288 1308 83 being be VBG 40288 1308 84 higher high JJR 40288 1308 85 : : : 40288 1308 86 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1308 87 4 4 LS 40288 1308 88 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1308 89 the the DT 40288 1308 90 circumflex circumflex NN 40288 1308 91 of of IN 40288 1308 92 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1308 93 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1308 94 : : : 40288 1308 95 ktypeite ktypeite NN 40288 1308 96 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1308 97 is be VBZ 40288 1308 98 lost lose VBN 40288 1308 99 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1308 100 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1308 101 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1308 102 : : : 40288 1308 103 êphanistai êphanistai NN 40288 1308 104 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1308 105 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1308 106 , , , 40288 1308 107 because because IN 40288 1308 108 the the DT 40288 1308 109 word word NN 40288 1308 110 is be VBZ 40288 1308 111 all all RB 40288 1308 112 on on IN 40288 1308 113 the the DT 40288 1308 114 same same JJ 40288 1308 115 pitch pitch NN 40288 1308 116 ; ; : 40288 1308 117 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1308 118 5 5 LS 40288 1308 119 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1308 120 the the DT 40288 1308 121 fourth fourth JJ 40288 1308 122 syllable syllable NN 40288 1308 123 of of IN 40288 1308 124 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1308 125 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1308 126 : : : 40288 1308 127 apoprobate apoprobate NN 40288 1308 128 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1308 129 is be VBZ 40288 1308 130 higher high JJR 40288 1308 131 in in IN 40288 1308 132 pitch pitch NN 40288 1308 133 , , , 40288 1308 134 instead instead RB 40288 1308 135 of of IN 40288 1308 136 the the DT 40288 1308 137 third third JJ 40288 1308 138 . . . 40288 1309 1 In in IN 40288 1309 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1309 3 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1309 4 's 's POS 40288 1309 5 inscription inscription NN 40288 1309 6 , , , 40288 1309 7 however however RB 40288 1309 8 , , , 40288 1309 9 the the DT 40288 1309 10 music music NN 40288 1309 11 follows follow VBZ 40288 1309 12 the the DT 40288 1309 13 accents accent NNS 40288 1309 14 as as RB 40288 1309 15 closely closely RB 40288 1309 16 as as IN 40288 1309 17 possible possible JJ 40288 1309 18 . . . 40288 1310 1 Every every DT 40288 1310 2 acute acute JJ 40288 1310 3 accent accent NN 40288 1310 4 coincides coincide VBZ 40288 1310 5 with with IN 40288 1310 6 a a DT 40288 1310 7 rise rise NN 40288 1310 8 of of IN 40288 1310 9 pitch pitch NN 40288 1310 10 , , , 40288 1310 11 except except IN 40288 1310 12 in in IN 40288 1310 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1310 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1310 15 : : : 40288 1310 16 hoson hoson NNP 40288 1310 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1310 18 , , , 40288 1310 19 which which WDT 40288 1310 20 begins begin VBZ 40288 1310 21 the the DT 40288 1310 22 melody melody NN 40288 1310 23 , , , 40288 1310 24 and and CC 40288 1310 25 in in IN 40288 1310 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1310 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1310 28 : : : 40288 1310 29 esti esti NN 40288 1310 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1310 31 , , , 40288 1310 32 for for IN 40288 1310 33 which which WDT 40288 1310 34 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1310 35 should should MD 40288 1310 36 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 1310 37 read read VB 40288 1310 38 the the DT 40288 1310 39 orthotone orthotone NN 40288 1310 40 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1310 41 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1310 42 : : : 40288 1310 43 esti esti NN 40288 1310 44 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1310 45 . . . 40288 1311 1 Of of IN 40288 1311 2 the the DT 40288 1311 3 four four CD 40288 1311 4 instances instance NNS 40288 1311 5 of of IN 40288 1311 6 the the DT 40288 1311 7 circumflex circumflex NN 40288 1311 8 accent accent JJ 40288 1311 9 three three CD 40288 1311 10 exhibit exhibit NN 40288 1311 11 the the DT 40288 1311 12 two two CD 40288 1311 13 notes note NNS 40288 1311 14 and and CC 40288 1311 15 the the DT 40288 1311 16 falling fall VBG 40288 1311 17 pitch pitch NN 40288 1311 18 which which WDT 40288 1311 19 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1311 20 expect expect VBP 40288 1311 21 . . . 40288 1312 1 The the DT 40288 1312 2 interval interval NN 40288 1312 3 is be VBZ 40288 1312 4 either either CC 40288 1312 5 a a DT 40288 1312 6 major major JJ 40288 1312 7 or or CC 40288 1312 8 a a DT 40288 1312 9 minor minor JJ 40288 1312 10 Third third NN 40288 1312 11 . . . 40288 1313 1 In in IN 40288 1313 2 the the DT 40288 1313 3 other other JJ 40288 1313 4 case case NN 40288 1313 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1313 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1313 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1313 8 : : : 40288 1313 9 zês zês NNP 40288 1313 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1313 11 the the DT 40288 1313 12 next next JJ 40288 1313 13 note note NN 40288 1313 14 is be VBZ 40288 1313 15 a a DT 40288 1313 16 Third third JJ 40288 1313 17 lower low JJR 40288 1313 18 : : : 40288 1313 19 but but CC 40288 1313 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1313 21 does do VBZ 40288 1313 22 not not RB 40288 1313 23 seem seem VB 40288 1313 24 to to TO 40288 1313 25 belong belong VB 40288 1313 26 to to IN 40288 1313 27 the the DT 40288 1313 28 circumflexed circumflexed JJ 40288 1313 29 syllable syllable NN 40288 1313 30 . . . 40288 1314 1 All all DT 40288 1314 2 this this DT 40288 1314 3 can can MD 40288 1314 4 not not RB 40288 1314 5 be be VB 40288 1314 6 accidental accidental JJ 40288 1314 7 . . . 40288 1315 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1315 2 leads lead VBZ 40288 1315 3 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1315 4 to to IN 40288 1315 5 the the DT 40288 1315 6 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 1315 7 that that IN 40288 1315 8 the the DT 40288 1315 9 musical musical JJ 40288 1315 10 notes note NNS 40288 1315 11 represent represent VBP 40288 1315 12 a a DT 40288 1315 13 kind kind NN 40288 1315 14 of of IN 40288 1315 15 recitative recitative JJ 40288 1315 16 , , , 40288 1315 17 or or CC 40288 1315 18 imitation imitation NN 40288 1315 19 of of IN 40288 1315 20 spoken speak VBN 40288 1315 21 words word NNS 40288 1315 22 , , , 40288 1315 23 rather rather RB 40288 1315 24 than than IN 40288 1315 25 a a DT 40288 1315 26 melody melody NN 40288 1315 27 in in IN 40288 1315 28 the the DT 40288 1315 29 proper proper JJ 40288 1315 30 sense sense NN 40288 1315 31 of of IN 40288 1315 32 the the DT 40288 1315 33 term term NN 40288 1315 34 . . . 40288 1316 1 If if IN 40288 1316 2 any any DT 40288 1316 3 considerable considerable JJ 40288 1316 4 specimen speciman NNS 40288 1316 5 of of IN 40288 1316 6 the the DT 40288 1316 7 music music NN 40288 1316 8 of of IN 40288 1316 9 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1316 10 had have VBD 40288 1316 11 survived survive VBN 40288 1316 12 , , , 40288 1316 13 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1316 14 might may MD 40288 1316 15 have have VB 40288 1316 16 solved solve VBN 40288 1316 17 many many JJ 40288 1316 18 of of IN 40288 1316 19 the the DT 40288 1316 20 problems problem NNS 40288 1316 21 with with IN 40288 1316 22 which which WDT 40288 1316 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1316 24 have have VBP 40288 1316 25 been be VBN 40288 1316 26 dealing deal VBG 40288 1316 27 . . . 40288 1317 1 The the DT 40288 1317 2 fragment fragment NN 40288 1317 3 before before IN 40288 1317 4 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1317 5 extends extend VBZ 40288 1317 6 over over RB 40288 1317 7 about about RB 40288 1317 8 six six CD 40288 1317 9 lines line NNS 40288 1317 10 in in IN 40288 1317 11 dochmiac dochmiac NNP 40288 1317 12 metre metre NNP 40288 1317 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1317 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1317 15 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1317 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1317 17 338 338 CD 40288 1317 18 - - SYM 40288 1317 19 343 343 CD 40288 1317 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1317 21 , , , 40288 1317 22 with with IN 40288 1317 23 the the DT 40288 1317 24 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1317 25 notation notation NN 40288 1317 26 : : : 40288 1317 27 but but CC 40288 1317 28 no no DT 40288 1317 29 single single JJ 40288 1317 30 line line NN 40288 1317 31 is be VBZ 40288 1317 32 entire entire JJ 40288 1317 33 . . . 40288 1318 1 The the DT 40288 1318 2 key key NN 40288 1318 3 is be VBZ 40288 1318 4 the the DT 40288 1318 5 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1318 6 . . . 40288 1319 1 The the DT 40288 1319 2 genus genus NN 40288 1319 3 is be VBZ 40288 1319 4 either either CC 40288 1319 5 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1319 6 or or CC 40288 1319 7 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1319 8 . . . 40288 1320 1 Assuming assume VBG 40288 1320 2 that that IN 40288 1320 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1320 4 is be VBZ 40288 1320 5 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1320 6 -- -- : 40288 1320 7 the the DT 40288 1320 8 alternative alternative NN 40288 1320 9 adopted adopt VBN 40288 1320 10 by by IN 40288 1320 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1320 12 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1320 13 -- -- : 40288 1320 14 the the DT 40288 1320 15 characters character NNS 40288 1320 16 which which WDT 40288 1320 17 are be VBP 40288 1320 18 still still RB 40288 1320 19 legible legible JJ 40288 1320 20 may may MD 40288 1320 21 be be VB 40288 1320 22 represented represent VBN 40288 1320 23 in in IN 40288 1320 24 modern modern JJ 40288 1320 25 notation notation NN 40288 1320 26 as as IN 40288 1320 27 follows follow VBZ 40288 1320 28 : : : 40288 1320 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1320 30 Music music NN 40288 1320 31 : : : 40288 1320 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1320 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1320 34 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1320 35 _ _ NNP 40288 1320 36 , , , 40288 1320 37 _ _ NNP 40288 1320 38 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1320 39 338 338 CD 40288 1320 40 - - SYM 40288 1320 41 344 344 CD 40288 1320 42 _ _ NNP 40288 1320 43 . . . 40288 1321 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1321 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1321 3 : : : 40288 1321 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1321 5 katolo)phy katolo)phy NNP 40288 1321 6 - - HYPH 40288 1321 7 ro ro NNP 40288 1321 8 - - HYPH 40288 1321 9 mai mai NNP 40288 1321 10 ; ; : 40288 1321 11 ma ma NNP 40288 1321 12 - - HYPH 40288 1321 13 te te NNP 40288 1321 14 - - HYPH 40288 1321 15 ros ros NNP 40288 1321 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1321 17 haima haima NNP 40288 1321 18 sas sas NNP 40288 1321 19 ho ho NNP 40288 1321 20 d d NNP 40288 1321 21 ' ' `` 40288 1321 22 ana)bak ana)bak NNP 40288 1321 23 - - HYPH 40288 1321 24 cheu cheu NNP 40288 1321 25 - - HYPH 40288 1321 26 ei ei NNP 40288 1321 27 ; ; : 40288 1321 28 ho ho IN 40288 1321 29 me -PRON- PRP 40288 1321 30 - - HYPH 40288 1321 31 gas gas NN 40288 1321 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1321 33 olbos olbos NNP 40288 1321 34 ou ou NNP 40288 1321 35 monimo)s monimo)s NNP 40288 1321 36 en en IN 40288 1321 37 bro bro NNP 40288 1321 38 - - HYPH 40288 1321 39 tois tois NN 40288 1321 40 ; ; : 40288 1321 41 a a LS 40288 1321 42 - - HYPH 40288 1321 43 na na FW 40288 1321 44 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1321 45 de de FW 40288 1321 46 laiphos laiphos NNP 40288 1321 47 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1321 48 ti)s ti)s CD 40288 1321 49 a a DT 40288 1321 50 - - HYPH 40288 1321 51 ka ka NNP 40288 1321 52 - - HYPH 40288 1321 53 tou tou NNP 40288 1321 54 tho tho NN 40288 1321 55 - - : 40288 1321 56 as as IN 40288 1321 57 ti ti NNP 40288 1321 58 - - HYPH 40288 1321 59 na(xas na(xas NNP 40288 1321 60 daimôn daimôn NN 40288 1321 61 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1321 62 kat kat NNP 40288 1321 63 - - HYPH 40288 1321 64 e e NNP 40288 1321 65 - - HYPH 40288 1321 66 kly kly NNP 40288 1321 67 - - HYPH 40288 1321 68 sen sen NNP 40288 1321 69 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1321 70 deinôn deinôn NNP 40288 1321 71 ponon ponon NNP 40288 1321 72 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1321 73 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1321 74 pon pon NNP 40288 1321 75 - - HYPH 40288 1321 76 tou tou NNP 40288 1321 77 labrois labrois NNP 40288 1321 78 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1321 79 . . . 40288 1321 80 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1322 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1322 2 should should MD 40288 1322 3 be be VB 40288 1322 4 observed observe VBN 40288 1322 5 that that IN 40288 1322 6 in in IN 40288 1322 7 the the DT 40288 1322 8 fragment fragment NN 40288 1322 9 the the DT 40288 1322 10 line line NN 40288 1322 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1322 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1322 13 : : : 40288 1322 14 katolophyromai katolophyromai NNP 40288 1322 15 katolophyromai katolophyromai NNP 40288 1322 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1322 17 comes come VBZ 40288 1322 18 before before IN 40288 1322 19 338 338 CD 40288 1322 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1322 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1322 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1322 23 : : : 40288 1322 24 materos materos NNP 40288 1322 25 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1322 26 . . . 40288 1323 1 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1323 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1323 3 , , , 40288 1323 4 not not RB 40288 1323 5 after after IN 40288 1323 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1323 7 , , , 40288 1323 8 as as IN 40288 1323 9 in in IN 40288 1323 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1323 11 texts[1 texts[1 NN 40288 1323 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1323 13 . . . 40288 1324 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1324 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1324 3 1 1 CD 40288 1324 4 : : : 40288 1324 5 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1324 6 need need VBP 40288 1324 7 not not RB 40288 1324 8 repeat repeat VB 40288 1324 9 what what WP 40288 1324 10 is be VBZ 40288 1324 11 said say VBN 40288 1324 12 by by IN 40288 1324 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1324 14 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1324 15 and and CC 40288 1324 16 M. M. NNP 40288 1324 17 Ruelle Ruelle NNP 40288 1324 18 in in IN 40288 1324 19 defence defence NN 40288 1324 20 of of IN 40288 1324 21 the the DT 40288 1324 22 genuineness genuineness NN 40288 1324 23 of of IN 40288 1324 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1324 25 fragment fragment NN 40288 1324 26 . . . 40288 1325 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1325 2 justly justly RB 40288 1325 3 point point VBP 40288 1325 4 to to IN 40288 1325 5 the the DT 40288 1325 6 remarkable remarkable JJ 40288 1325 7 coincidence coincidence NN 40288 1325 8 that that IN 40288 1325 9 the the DT 40288 1325 10 music music NN 40288 1325 11 of of IN 40288 1325 12 this this DT 40288 1325 13 very very JJ 40288 1325 14 play play NN 40288 1325 15 is be VBZ 40288 1325 16 quoted quote VBN 40288 1325 17 by by IN 40288 1325 18 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1325 19 of of IN 40288 1325 20 Halicarnassus Halicarnassus NNP 40288 1325 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1325 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1325 23 l l NNP 40288 1325 24 . . . 40288 1326 1 c. c. NNP 40288 1326 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1326 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1326 4 . . . 40288 1327 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1327 2 would would MD 40288 1327 3 almost almost RB 40288 1327 4 seem seem VB 40288 1327 5 as as IN 40288 1327 6 if if IN 40288 1327 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1327 8 was be VBD 40288 1327 9 the the DT 40288 1327 10 only only JJ 40288 1327 11 well well RB 40288 1327 12 - - HYPH 40288 1327 13 known know VBN 40288 1327 14 specimen speciman NNS 40288 1327 15 of of IN 40288 1327 16 music music NN 40288 1327 17 of of IN 40288 1327 18 the the DT 40288 1327 19 classical classical JJ 40288 1327 20 period period NN 40288 1327 21 of of IN 40288 1327 22 tragedy tragedy NN 40288 1327 23 . . . 40288 1328 1 The the DT 40288 1328 2 transcription transcription NN 40288 1328 3 of of IN 40288 1328 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1328 5 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1328 6 , , , 40288 1328 7 with with IN 40288 1328 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1328 9 conjectural conjectural JJ 40288 1328 10 restorations restoration NNS 40288 1328 11 , , , 40288 1328 12 will will MD 40288 1328 13 be be VB 40288 1328 14 found find VBN 40288 1328 15 in in IN 40288 1328 16 the the DT 40288 1328 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1328 18 Appendix Appendix NNP 40288 1328 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1328 20 . . . 40288 1329 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1329 2 have have VBP 40288 1329 3 only only RB 40288 1329 4 introduced introduce VBN 40288 1329 5 one one CD 40288 1329 6 of of IN 40288 1329 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1329 8 corrections correction NNS 40288 1329 9 here here RB 40288 1329 10 , , , 40288 1329 11 viz viz NN 40288 1329 12 . . . 40288 1330 1 the the DT 40288 1330 2 note note NN 40288 1330 3 on on IN 40288 1330 4 the the DT 40288 1330 5 second second JJ 40288 1330 6 syllable syllable NN 40288 1330 7 of of IN 40288 1330 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1330 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1330 10 : : : 40288 1330 11 kateklysen kateklysen NNP 40288 1330 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1330 13 . . . 40288 1330 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1331 1 The the DT 40288 1331 2 notes note NNS 40288 1331 3 employed employ VBD 40288 1331 4 , , , 40288 1331 5 according accord VBG 40288 1331 6 to to IN 40288 1331 7 the the DT 40288 1331 8 interpretation interpretation NN 40288 1331 9 given give VBN 40288 1331 10 above above RB 40288 1331 11 , , , 40288 1331 12 give give VB 40288 1331 13 the the DT 40288 1331 14 scale scale NN 40288 1331 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1331 16 g g NNP 40288 1331 17 - - HYPH 40288 1331 18 a a DT 40288 1331 19 - - HYPH 40288 1331 20 a*-a#-d a*-a#-d NNP 40288 1331 21 - - HYPH 40288 1331 22 e e NN 40288 1331 23 - - HYPH 40288 1331 24 e e NNP 40288 1331 25 * * NFP 40288 1331 26 _ _ XX 40288 1331 27 . . . 40288 1332 1 If if IN 40288 1332 2 the the DT 40288 1332 3 genus genus NN 40288 1332 4 is be VBZ 40288 1332 5 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1332 6 , , , 40288 1332 7 as as IN 40288 1332 8 M. M. NNP 40288 1332 9 Ruelle Ruelle NNP 40288 1332 10 is be VBZ 40288 1332 11 disposed disposed JJ 40288 1332 12 to to TO 40288 1332 13 think think VB 40288 1332 14 , , , 40288 1332 15 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1332 16 are be VBP 40288 1332 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1332 18 g g NNP 40288 1332 19 - - HYPH 40288 1332 20 a a DT 40288 1332 21 - - HYPH 40288 1332 22 a#-b a#-b NNP 40288 1332 23 - - HYPH 40288 1332 24 d d NNP 40288 1332 25 - - HYPH 40288 1332 26 e e NNP 40288 1332 27 - - HYPH 40288 1332 28 f f NNP 40288 1332 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1332 30 . . . 40288 1333 1 When when WRB 40288 1333 2 these these DT 40288 1333 3 scales scale NNS 40288 1333 4 are be VBP 40288 1333 5 compared compare VBN 40288 1333 6 with with IN 40288 1333 7 the the DT 40288 1333 8 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1333 9 System System NNP 40288 1333 10 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1333 11 find find VBP 40288 1333 12 that that IN 40288 1333 13 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1333 14 do do VBP 40288 1333 15 not not RB 40288 1333 16 entirely entirely RB 40288 1333 17 agree agree VB 40288 1333 18 with with IN 40288 1333 19 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1333 20 . . . 40288 1334 1 Whether whether IN 40288 1334 2 the the DT 40288 1334 3 genus genus NN 40288 1334 4 is be VBZ 40288 1334 5 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1334 6 or or CC 40288 1334 7 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1334 8 the the DT 40288 1334 9 notes note NNS 40288 1334 10 from from IN 40288 1334 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1334 12 a a DT 40288 1334 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1334 14 to to IN 40288 1334 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1334 16 e e NNP 40288 1334 17 * * NFP 40288 1334 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1334 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1334 20 or or CC 40288 1334 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1334 22 f f NNP 40288 1334 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1334 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1334 25 answer answer VB 40288 1334 26 to to IN 40288 1334 27 those those DT 40288 1334 28 of of IN 40288 1334 29 the the DT 40288 1334 30 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1334 31 System System NNP 40288 1334 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1334 33 of of IN 40288 1334 34 the the DT 40288 1334 35 same same JJ 40288 1334 36 genus genus NN 40288 1334 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1334 38 from from IN 40288 1334 39 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1334 40 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1334 41 to to IN 40288 1334 42 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 1334 43 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1334 44 . . . 40288 1335 1 But but CC 40288 1335 2 in in IN 40288 1335 3 either either DT 40288 1335 4 case case NN 40288 1335 5 the the DT 40288 1335 6 lowest low JJS 40288 1335 7 note note NN 40288 1335 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1335 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1335 10 g g NNP 40288 1335 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1335 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1335 13 finds find VBZ 40288 1335 14 no no DT 40288 1335 15 place place NN 40288 1335 16 in in IN 40288 1335 17 the the DT 40288 1335 18 System System NNP 40288 1335 19 , , , 40288 1335 20 since since IN 40288 1335 21 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1335 22 can can MD 40288 1335 23 only only RB 40288 1335 24 be be VB 40288 1335 25 the the DT 40288 1335 26 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1335 27 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1335 28 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 1335 29 . . . 40288 1336 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1336 2 is be VBZ 40288 1336 3 possible possible JJ 40288 1336 4 , , , 40288 1336 5 however however RB 40288 1336 6 , , , 40288 1336 7 that that IN 40288 1336 8 the the DT 40288 1336 9 scale scale NN 40288 1336 10 belongs belong VBZ 40288 1336 11 to to IN 40288 1336 12 the the DT 40288 1336 13 period period NN 40288 1336 14 when when WRB 40288 1336 15 the the DT 40288 1336 16 original original JJ 40288 1336 17 octave octave NN 40288 1336 18 had have VBD 40288 1336 19 been be VBN 40288 1336 20 extended extend VBN 40288 1336 21 by by IN 40288 1336 22 the the DT 40288 1336 23 addition addition NN 40288 1336 24 of of IN 40288 1336 25 a a DT 40288 1336 26 tone tone NN 40288 1336 27 below below IN 40288 1336 28 the the DT 40288 1336 29 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1336 30 -- -- : 40288 1336 31 the the DT 40288 1336 32 note note NN 40288 1336 33 , , , 40288 1336 34 in in IN 40288 1336 35 fact fact NN 40288 1336 36 , , , 40288 1336 37 which which WDT 40288 1336 38 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1336 39 have have VBP 40288 1336 40 already already RB 40288 1336 41 met meet VBN 40288 1336 42 with with IN 40288 1336 43 under under IN 40288 1336 44 the the DT 40288 1336 45 name name NN 40288 1336 46 of of IN 40288 1336 47 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 1336 48 - - HYPH 40288 1336 49 hypatê hypatê NNP 40288 1336 50 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1336 51 p. p. NN 40288 1336 52 39 39 CD 40288 1336 53 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1336 54 . . . 40288 1337 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1337 2 the the DT 40288 1337 3 complete complete JJ 40288 1337 4 scale scale NN 40288 1337 5 may may MD 40288 1337 6 have have VB 40288 1337 7 consisted consist VBN 40288 1337 8 of of IN 40288 1337 9 the the DT 40288 1337 10 disjunct disjunct JJ 40288 1337 11 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1337 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1337 13 a a DT 40288 1337 14 - - HYPH 40288 1337 15 d d NNP 40288 1337 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1337 17 and and CC 40288 1337 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1337 19 e e NNP 40288 1337 20 - - : 40288 1337 21 a a DT 40288 1337 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1337 23 , , , 40288 1337 24 with with IN 40288 1337 25 the the DT 40288 1337 26 tone tone NN 40288 1337 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1337 28 g g NNP 40288 1337 29 - - : 40288 1337 30 a a FW 40288 1337 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1337 32 . . . 40288 1338 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1338 2 may may MD 40288 1338 3 be be VB 40288 1338 4 observed observe VBN 40288 1338 5 here here RB 40288 1338 6 that that IN 40288 1338 7 although although IN 40288 1338 8 the the DT 40288 1338 9 scale scale NN 40288 1338 10 in in IN 40288 1338 11 question question NN 40288 1338 12 does do VBZ 40288 1338 13 not not RB 40288 1338 14 fit fit VB 40288 1338 15 into into IN 40288 1338 16 the the DT 40288 1338 17 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1338 18 System System NNP 40288 1338 19 , , , 40288 1338 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1338 21 conforms conform VBZ 40288 1338 22 to to IN 40288 1338 23 the the DT 40288 1338 24 general general JJ 40288 1338 25 rules rule NNS 40288 1338 26 laid lay VBN 40288 1338 27 down down RP 40288 1338 28 by by IN 40288 1338 29 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1338 30 for for IN 40288 1338 31 the the DT 40288 1338 32 melodious melodious JJ 40288 1338 33 succession succession NN 40288 1338 34 of of IN 40288 1338 35 intervals interval NNS 40288 1338 36 . . . 40288 1339 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1339 2 is be VBZ 40288 1339 3 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 40288 1339 4 therefore therefore RB 40288 1339 5 to to TO 40288 1339 6 suppose suppose VB 40288 1339 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1339 8 as as IN 40288 1339 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1339 10 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1339 11 and and CC 40288 1339 12 M. M. NNP 40288 1339 13 Ruelle Ruelle NNP 40288 1339 14 do do VBP 40288 1339 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1339 16 that that IN 40288 1339 17 the the DT 40288 1339 18 scale scale NN 40288 1339 19 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40288 1339 20 a a DT 40288 1339 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1339 22 mixture mixture NN 40288 1339 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1339 24 of of IN 40288 1339 25 different different JJ 40288 1339 26 genera genera NN 40288 1339 27 . . . 40288 1340 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1340 2 must must MD 40288 1340 3 be be VB 40288 1340 4 vain vain JJ 40288 1340 5 to to TO 40288 1340 6 attempt attempt VB 40288 1340 7 to to TO 40288 1340 8 discover discover VB 40288 1340 9 the the DT 40288 1340 10 tonality tonality NN 40288 1340 11 of of IN 40288 1340 12 a a DT 40288 1340 13 short short JJ 40288 1340 14 fragment fragment NN 40288 1340 15 which which WDT 40288 1340 16 has have VBZ 40288 1340 17 neither neither CC 40288 1340 18 beginning beginning NN 40288 1340 19 nor nor CC 40288 1340 20 end end NN 40288 1340 21 . . . 40288 1341 1 The the DT 40288 1341 2 only only JJ 40288 1341 3 group group NN 40288 1341 4 of of IN 40288 1341 5 notes note NNS 40288 1341 6 which which WDT 40288 1341 7 has have VBZ 40288 1341 8 the the DT 40288 1341 9 character character NN 40288 1341 10 of of IN 40288 1341 11 a a DT 40288 1341 12 cadence cadence NN 40288 1341 13 is be VBZ 40288 1341 14 that that IN 40288 1341 15 on on IN 40288 1341 16 the the DT 40288 1341 17 word word NN 40288 1341 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1341 19 Greek:(olo)phypomai Greek:(olo)phypomai NNP 40288 1341 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1341 21 , , , 40288 1341 22 and and CC 40288 1341 23 again again RB 40288 1341 24 on on IN 40288 1341 25 the the DT 40288 1341 26 words word NNS 40288 1341 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1341 28 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1341 29 : : : 40288 1341 30 en en NNP 40288 1341 31 brotois brotois NNP 40288 1341 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1341 33 , , , 40288 1341 34 viz viz NN 40288 1341 35 . . . 40288 1342 1 the the DT 40288 1342 2 notes note NNS 40288 1342 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1342 4 a a DT 40288 1342 5 # # $ 40288 1342 6 a a NN 40288 1342 7 * * NFP 40288 1342 8 a a DT 40288 1342 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1342 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1342 11 if if IN 40288 1342 12 the the DT 40288 1342 13 genus genus NN 40288 1342 14 is be VBZ 40288 1342 15 the the DT 40288 1342 16 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1342 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1342 18 . . . 40288 1343 1 The the DT 40288 1343 2 same same JJ 40288 1343 3 notes note NNS 40288 1343 4 occur occur VBP 40288 1343 5 in in IN 40288 1343 6 reversed reversed JJ 40288 1343 7 order order NN 40288 1343 8 on on IN 40288 1343 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1343 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1343 11 : : : 40288 1343 12 akatou akatou NN 40288 1343 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1343 14 and and CC 40288 1343 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1343 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1343 17 : : : 40288 1343 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1343 19 kat)eklusen kat)eklusen NNP 40288 1343 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1343 21 . . . 40288 1344 1 This this DT 40288 1344 2 seems seem VBZ 40288 1344 3 to to TO 40288 1344 4 bear bear VB 40288 1344 5 out out RP 40288 1344 6 the the DT 40288 1344 7 common common JJ 40288 1344 8 view view NN 40288 1344 9 of of IN 40288 1344 10 the the DT 40288 1344 11 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1344 12 as as IN 40288 1344 13 produced produce VBN 40288 1344 14 by by IN 40288 1344 15 the the DT 40288 1344 16 introduction introduction NN 40288 1344 17 of of IN 40288 1344 18 an an DT 40288 1344 19 ' ' `` 40288 1344 20 accidental accidental NN 40288 1344 21 ' ' '' 40288 1344 22 or or CC 40288 1344 23 passing pass VBG 40288 1344 24 note note NN 40288 1344 25 . . . 40288 1345 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1345 2 will will MD 40288 1345 3 be be VB 40288 1345 4 seen see VBN 40288 1345 5 , , , 40288 1345 6 in in IN 40288 1345 7 fact fact NN 40288 1345 8 , , , 40288 1345 9 that that IN 40288 1345 10 the the DT 40288 1345 11 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1345 12 notes note NNS 40288 1345 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1345 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 15 a a DT 40288 1345 16 * * NFP 40288 1345 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 18 and and CC 40288 1345 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 20 e e NNP 40288 1345 21 * * NFP 40288 1345 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1345 24 only only RB 40288 1345 25 occur occur VBP 40288 1345 26 before before IN 40288 1345 27 or or CC 40288 1345 28 after after IN 40288 1345 29 the the DT 40288 1345 30 ' ' `` 40288 1345 31 standing standing NN 40288 1345 32 ' ' '' 40288 1345 33 notes note NNS 40288 1345 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1345 35 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 36 a a DT 40288 1345 37 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 38 and and CC 40288 1345 39 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 40 e e NNP 40288 1345 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1345 42 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1345 43 . . . 40288 1346 1 Relying rely VBG 40288 1346 2 on on IN 40288 1346 3 the the DT 40288 1346 4 fact fact NN 40288 1346 5 that that IN 40288 1346 6 the the DT 40288 1346 7 lowest low JJS 40288 1346 8 note note NN 40288 1346 9 is be VBZ 40288 1346 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1346 11 g g NNP 40288 1346 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1346 13 , , , 40288 1346 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1346 15 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1346 16 and and CC 40288 1346 17 M. M. NNP 40288 1346 18 Ruelle Ruelle NNP 40288 1346 19 pronounce pronounce NN 40288 1346 20 the the DT 40288 1346 21 mode mode NN 40288 1346 22 to to TO 40288 1346 23 be be VB 40288 1346 24 the the DT 40288 1346 25 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1346 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1346 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1346 28 g g NNP 40288 1346 29 - - HYPH 40288 1346 30 g g NNP 40288 1346 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1346 32 in in IN 40288 1346 33 the the DT 40288 1346 34 key key NN 40288 1346 35 with with IN 40288 1346 36 one one CD 40288 1346 37 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1346 38 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1346 39 : : : 40288 1346 40 flat flat JJ 40288 1346 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1346 42 , , , 40288 1346 43 or or CC 40288 1346 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1346 45 d d NNP 40288 1346 46 - - HYPH 40288 1346 47 d d NNP 40288 1346 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1346 49 in in IN 40288 1346 50 the the DT 40288 1346 51 natural natural JJ 40288 1346 52 key key NN 40288 1346 53 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1346 54 . . . 40288 1347 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1347 2 have have VBP 40288 1347 3 already already RB 40288 1347 4 put put VBN 40288 1347 5 forward forward RP 40288 1347 6 a a DT 40288 1347 7 different different JJ 40288 1347 8 explanation explanation NN 40288 1347 9 of of IN 40288 1347 10 this this DT 40288 1347 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1347 12 g g NNP 40288 1347 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1347 14 , , , 40288 1347 15 and and CC 40288 1347 16 will will MD 40288 1347 17 only only RB 40288 1347 18 add add VB 40288 1347 19 here here RB 40288 1347 20 that that IN 40288 1347 21 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1347 22 occurs occur VBZ 40288 1347 23 twice twice RB 40288 1347 24 in in IN 40288 1347 25 the the DT 40288 1347 26 fragment fragment NN 40288 1347 27 , , , 40288 1347 28 both both DT 40288 1347 29 times time NNS 40288 1347 30 on on IN 40288 1347 31 a a DT 40288 1347 32 short short JJ 40288 1347 33 syllable[1 syllable[1 NNP 40288 1347 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1347 35 . . . 40288 1348 1 The the DT 40288 1348 2 important important JJ 40288 1348 3 notes note NNS 40288 1348 4 , , , 40288 1348 5 so so RB 40288 1348 6 far far RB 40288 1348 7 as as IN 40288 1348 8 the the DT 40288 1348 9 evidence evidence NN 40288 1348 10 goes go VBZ 40288 1348 11 , , , 40288 1348 12 are be VBP 40288 1348 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1348 14 a a DT 40288 1348 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1348 16 , , , 40288 1348 17 which which WDT 40288 1348 18 twice twice RB 40288 1348 19 comes come VBZ 40288 1348 20 at at IN 40288 1348 21 the the DT 40288 1348 22 end end NN 40288 1348 23 of of IN 40288 1348 24 a a DT 40288 1348 25 verse verse NN 40288 1348 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1348 27 with with IN 40288 1348 28 a a DT 40288 1348 29 pause pause NN 40288 1348 30 in in IN 40288 1348 31 the the DT 40288 1348 32 sense sense NN 40288 1348 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1348 34 , , , 40288 1348 35 and and CC 40288 1348 36 _ _ NNP 40288 1348 37 e e NNP 40288 1348 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1348 39 , , , 40288 1348 40 which which WDT 40288 1348 41 once once RB 40288 1348 42 has have VBZ 40288 1348 43 that that DT 40288 1348 44 position position NN 40288 1348 45 . . . 40288 1349 1 If if IN 40288 1349 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1349 3 a a DT 40288 1349 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1349 5 is be VBZ 40288 1349 6 the the DT 40288 1349 7 key key NN 40288 1349 8 - - HYPH 40288 1349 9 note note NN 40288 1349 10 , , , 40288 1349 11 the the DT 40288 1349 12 mode mode NN 40288 1349 13 -- -- : 40288 1349 14 in in IN 40288 1349 15 the the DT 40288 1349 16 modern modern JJ 40288 1349 17 sense sense NN 40288 1349 18 -- -- : 40288 1349 19 is be VBZ 40288 1349 20 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1349 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1349 22 the the DT 40288 1349 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1349 24 e_-species e_-species NNP 40288 1349 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1349 26 . . . 40288 1350 1 If if IN 40288 1350 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1350 3 e e NNP 40288 1350 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1350 5 is be VBZ 40288 1350 6 the the DT 40288 1350 7 key key NN 40288 1350 8 - - HYPH 40288 1350 9 note note NN 40288 1350 10 , , , 40288 1350 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1350 12 is be VBZ 40288 1350 13 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1350 14 - - HYPH 40288 1350 15 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1350 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1350 17 the the DT 40288 1350 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1350 19 b_-species b_-species NNP 40288 1350 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1350 21 . . . 40288 1351 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1351 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1351 3 1 1 CD 40288 1351 4 : : : 40288 1351 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1351 6 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1351 7 , , , 40288 1351 8 however however RB 40288 1351 9 , , , 40288 1351 10 detects detect VBZ 40288 1351 11 a a DT 40288 1351 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1351 13 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1351 14 : : : 40288 1351 15 phi phi NNP 40288 1351 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1351 17 ; ; , 40288 1351 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1351 19 the the DT 40288 1351 20 sign sign NN 40288 1351 21 for for IN 40288 1351 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1351 23 g g NNP 40288 1351 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1351 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1351 26 over over IN 40288 1351 27 the the DT 40288 1351 28 first first JJ 40288 1351 29 syllable syllable NN 40288 1351 30 of of IN 40288 1351 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1351 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1351 33 : : : 40288 1351 34 kateklusen kateklusen NNP 40288 1351 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1351 36 and and CC 40288 1351 37 the the DT 40288 1351 38 second second JJ 40288 1351 39 syllable syllable NN 40288 1351 40 of of IN 40288 1351 41 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1351 42 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1351 43 : : : 40288 1351 44 pontou pontou NN 40288 1351 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1351 46 . . . 40288 1352 1 There there EX 40288 1352 2 is be VBZ 40288 1352 3 little little JJ 40288 1352 4 trace trace NN 40288 1352 5 of of IN 40288 1352 6 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1352 7 in in IN 40288 1352 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1352 9 facsimile facsimile NN 40288 1352 10 . . . 40288 1352 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1353 1 § § ADD 40288 1353 2 33 33 CD 40288 1353 3 . . . 40288 1354 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1354 2 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1354 3 of of IN 40288 1354 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1354 5 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 1354 6 . . . 40288 1354 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1354 8 The the DT 40288 1354 9 most most RBS 40288 1354 10 direct direct JJ 40288 1354 11 testimony testimony NN 40288 1354 12 in in IN 40288 1354 13 support support NN 40288 1354 14 of of IN 40288 1354 15 the the DT 40288 1354 16 view view NN 40288 1354 17 that that IN 40288 1354 18 the the DT 40288 1354 19 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1354 20 Modes mode NNS 40288 1354 21 were be VBD 40288 1354 22 differentiated differentiate VBN 40288 1354 23 by by IN 40288 1354 24 the the DT 40288 1354 25 succession succession NN 40288 1354 26 of of IN 40288 1354 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1354 28 intervals interval NNS 40288 1354 29 has have VBZ 40288 1354 30 still still RB 40288 1354 31 to to TO 40288 1354 32 be be VB 40288 1354 33 considered consider VBN 40288 1354 34 . . . 40288 1355 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1355 2 is be VBZ 40288 1355 3 the the DT 40288 1355 4 account account NN 40288 1355 5 given give VBN 40288 1355 6 by by IN 40288 1355 7 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1355 8 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 1355 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1355 10 p. p. NN 40288 1355 11 21 21 CD 40288 1355 12 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1355 13 . . . 40288 1355 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1356 1 of of IN 40288 1356 2 the the DT 40288 1356 3 six six CD 40288 1356 4 Modes mode NNS 40288 1356 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1356 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1356 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1356 8 : : : 40288 1356 9 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1356 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1356 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1356 12 of of IN 40288 1356 13 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1356 14 's 's POS 40288 1356 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1356 16 Republic Republic NNP 40288 1356 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1356 18 . . . 40288 1357 1 After after IN 40288 1357 2 describing describe VBG 40288 1357 3 the the DT 40288 1357 4 genera genera NN 40288 1357 5 and and CC 40288 1357 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1357 7 varieties variety NNS 40288 1357 8 the the DT 40288 1357 9 ' ' `` 40288 1357 10 colours colour NNS 40288 1357 11 , , , 40288 1357 12 ' ' '' 40288 1357 13 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1357 14 goes go VBZ 40288 1357 15 on on RP 40288 1357 16 to to TO 40288 1357 17 say say VB 40288 1357 18 that that IN 40288 1357 19 there there EX 40288 1357 20 were be VBD 40288 1357 21 other other JJ 40288 1357 22 divisions division NNS 40288 1357 23 of of IN 40288 1357 24 the the DT 40288 1357 25 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1357 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1357 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1357 28 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1357 29 : : : 40288 1357 30 tetrachordikai tetrachordikai NNP 40288 1357 31 diaireseis diaireseis NNP 40288 1357 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1357 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1357 34 which which WDT 40288 1357 35 the the DT 40288 1357 36 most most RBS 40288 1357 37 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1357 38 musicians musician NNS 40288 1357 39 used use VBN 40288 1357 40 for for IN 40288 1357 41 the the DT 40288 1357 42 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1357 43 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1357 44 : : : 40288 1357 45 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1357 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1357 47 , , , 40288 1357 48 and and CC 40288 1357 49 that that IN 40288 1357 50 these these DT 40288 1357 51 were be VBD 40288 1357 52 sometimes sometimes RB 40288 1357 53 greater great JJR 40288 1357 54 in in IN 40288 1357 55 compass compass NN 40288 1357 56 than than IN 40288 1357 57 the the DT 40288 1357 58 octave octave NN 40288 1357 59 , , , 40288 1357 60 sometimes sometimes RB 40288 1357 61 less less JJR 40288 1357 62 . . . 40288 1358 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1358 2 then then RB 40288 1358 3 gives give VBZ 40288 1358 4 the the DT 40288 1358 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 1358 6 of of IN 40288 1358 7 the the DT 40288 1358 8 scale scale NN 40288 1358 9 for for IN 40288 1358 10 each each DT 40288 1358 11 of of IN 40288 1358 12 the the DT 40288 1358 13 six six CD 40288 1358 14 Modes mode NNS 40288 1358 15 mentioned mention VBN 40288 1358 16 by by IN 40288 1358 17 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1358 18 , , , 40288 1358 19 and and CC 40288 1358 20 adds add VBZ 40288 1358 21 the the DT 40288 1358 22 scales scale NNS 40288 1358 23 in in IN 40288 1358 24 the the DT 40288 1358 25 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1358 26 notation notation NN 40288 1358 27 . . . 40288 1359 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1359 2 are be VBP 40288 1359 3 of of IN 40288 1359 4 the the DT 40288 1359 5 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1359 6 genus genus NN 40288 1359 7 , , , 40288 1359 8 and and CC 40288 1359 9 may may MD 40288 1359 10 be be VB 40288 1359 11 represented represent VBN 40288 1359 12 by by IN 40288 1359 13 modern modern JJ 40288 1359 14 notes note NNS 40288 1359 15 as as IN 40288 1359 16 follows:-- follows:-- NNP 40288 1359 17 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1359 18 - - HYPH 40288 1359 19 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1359 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 21 b b NNP 40288 1359 22 - - HYPH 40288 1359 23 b*-c b*-c NNP 40288 1359 24 - - HYPH 40288 1359 25 d d NNP 40288 1359 26 - - HYPH 40288 1359 27 e e NNP 40288 1359 28 - - HYPH 40288 1359 29 e*-f e*-f NNP 40288 1359 30 - - HYPH 40288 1359 31 b b NNP 40288 1359 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 33 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 1359 34 - - HYPH 40288 1359 35 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1359 36 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 37 e e NNP 40288 1359 38 - - HYPH 40288 1359 39 e*-f e*-f VB 40288 1359 40 - - HYPH 40288 1359 41 a a DT 40288 1359 42 - - HYPH 40288 1359 43 c c NN 40288 1359 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 45 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1359 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 47 d d NNP 40288 1359 48 - - HYPH 40288 1359 49 e e NNP 40288 1359 50 - - HYPH 40288 1359 51 e*-f e*-f VB 40288 1359 52 - - HYPH 40288 1359 53 a a DT 40288 1359 54 - - HYPH 40288 1359 55 b b NNP 40288 1359 56 - - HYPH 40288 1359 57 b*-c b*-c NNP 40288 1359 58 - - HYPH 40288 1359 59 d d NNP 40288 1359 60 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 61 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1359 62 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 63 d d NNP 40288 1359 64 - - HYPH 40288 1359 65 e e NNP 40288 1359 66 - - HYPH 40288 1359 67 e*-f e*-f VB 40288 1359 68 - - HYPH 40288 1359 69 a a DT 40288 1359 70 - - HYPH 40288 1359 71 b b NNP 40288 1359 72 - - HYPH 40288 1359 73 b*-c b*-c NNP 40288 1359 74 - - HYPH 40288 1359 75 e e NNP 40288 1359 76 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 77 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1359 78 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 79 e*-f e*-f NNP 40288 1359 80 - - HYPH 40288 1359 81 a a DT 40288 1359 82 - - HYPH 40288 1359 83 b b NNP 40288 1359 84 - - HYPH 40288 1359 85 b*-c b*-c NNP 40288 1359 86 - - HYPH 40288 1359 87 e e NNP 40288 1359 88 - - HYPH 40288 1359 89 e e NN 40288 1359 90 * * NFP 40288 1359 91 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 92 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 1359 93 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 94 e e NNP 40288 1359 95 - - HYPH 40288 1359 96 e*-f e*-f VB 40288 1359 97 - - HYPH 40288 1359 98 a a DT 40288 1359 99 - - HYPH 40288 1359 100 c c NN 40288 1359 101 - - HYPH 40288 1359 102 d d NNP 40288 1359 103 _ _ NNP 40288 1359 104 Comparing compare VBG 40288 1359 105 these these DT 40288 1359 106 scales scale NNS 40288 1359 107 with with IN 40288 1359 108 the the DT 40288 1359 109 Species Species NNPS 40288 1359 110 of of IN 40288 1359 111 the the DT 40288 1359 112 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1359 113 , , , 40288 1359 114 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1359 115 find find VBP 40288 1359 116 a a DT 40288 1359 117 certain certain JJ 40288 1359 118 amount amount NN 40288 1359 119 of of IN 40288 1359 120 correspondence correspondence NN 40288 1359 121 . . . 40288 1360 1 As as IN 40288 1360 2 has have VBZ 40288 1360 3 been be VBN 40288 1360 4 already already RB 40288 1360 5 noticed notice VBN 40288 1360 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1360 7 p. p. NN 40288 1360 8 22 22 CD 40288 1360 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1360 10 , , , 40288 1360 11 the the DT 40288 1360 12 names name NNS 40288 1360 13 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 1360 14 - - HYPH 40288 1360 15 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1360 16 and and CC 40288 1360 17 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1360 18 answer answer NN 40288 1360 19 to to IN 40288 1360 20 the the DT 40288 1360 21 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1360 22 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1360 23 and and CC 40288 1360 24 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1360 25 - - HYPH 40288 1360 26 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1360 27 respectively respectively RB 40288 1360 28 . . . 40288 1361 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40288 1361 2 the the DT 40288 1361 3 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1361 4 of of IN 40288 1361 5 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1361 6 agrees agree VBZ 40288 1361 7 with with IN 40288 1361 8 the the DT 40288 1361 9 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 1361 10 - - HYPH 40288 1361 11 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1361 12 species specie NNS 40288 1361 13 as as IN 40288 1361 14 given give VBN 40288 1361 15 in in IN 40288 1361 16 the the DT 40288 1361 17 pseudo pseudo NN 40288 1361 18 - - JJ 40288 1361 19 Euclidean Euclidean NNP 40288 1361 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1361 21 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 1361 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1361 23 . . . 40288 1362 1 The the DT 40288 1362 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1362 3 of of IN 40288 1362 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1362 5 is be VBZ 40288 1362 6 the the DT 40288 1362 7 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1362 8 species specie NNS 40288 1362 9 of of IN 40288 1362 10 the the DT 40288 1362 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1362 12 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 1362 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1362 14 , , , 40288 1362 15 but but CC 40288 1362 16 with with IN 40288 1362 17 an an DT 40288 1362 18 additional additional JJ 40288 1362 19 note note NN 40288 1362 20 , , , 40288 1362 21 a a DT 40288 1362 22 tone tone NN 40288 1362 23 below below IN 40288 1362 24 the the DT 40288 1362 25 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1362 26 . . . 40288 1363 1 The the DT 40288 1363 2 Phrygian phrygian NN 40288 1363 3 of of IN 40288 1363 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1363 5 is be VBZ 40288 1363 6 not not RB 40288 1363 7 the the DT 40288 1363 8 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1363 9 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1363 10 species specie NNS 40288 1363 11 ; ; : 40288 1363 12 but but CC 40288 1363 13 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1363 14 is be VBZ 40288 1363 15 derived derive VBN 40288 1363 16 from from IN 40288 1363 17 the the DT 40288 1363 18 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1363 19 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1363 20 octave octave NN 40288 1363 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 22 d d NNP 40288 1363 23 - - HYPH 40288 1363 24 e e NNP 40288 1363 25 - - HYPH 40288 1363 26 f f NNP 40288 1363 27 - - HYPH 40288 1363 28 g g NNP 40288 1363 29 - - HYPH 40288 1363 30 a a DT 40288 1363 31 - - HYPH 40288 1363 32 b b NN 40288 1363 33 - - HYPH 40288 1363 34 c c NNP 40288 1363 35 - - HYPH 40288 1363 36 d d NNP 40288 1363 37 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 38 by by IN 40288 1363 39 inserting insert VBG 40288 1363 40 the the DT 40288 1363 41 enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1363 42 notes note NNS 40288 1363 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 44 e e NNP 40288 1363 45 * * NFP 40288 1363 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 47 and and CC 40288 1363 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 49 b b NNP 40288 1363 50 * * NFP 40288 1363 51 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 52 , , , 40288 1363 53 and and CC 40288 1363 54 omitting omit VBG 40288 1363 55 the the DT 40288 1363 56 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1363 57 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 58 g g NNP 40288 1363 59 _ _ NNP 40288 1363 60 . . . 40288 1364 1 By by IN 40288 1364 2 a a DT 40288 1364 3 similar similar JJ 40288 1364 4 process process NN 40288 1364 5 the the DT 40288 1364 6 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1364 7 - - HYPH 40288 1364 8 lydian lydian NN 40288 1364 9 of of IN 40288 1364 10 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1364 11 may may MD 40288 1364 12 be be VB 40288 1364 13 derived derive VBN 40288 1364 14 from from IN 40288 1364 15 the the DT 40288 1364 16 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1364 17 octave octave NN 40288 1364 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 19 b b NNP 40288 1364 20 - - HYPH 40288 1364 21 b b NNP 40288 1364 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 23 , , , 40288 1364 24 except except IN 40288 1364 25 that that IN 40288 1364 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 27 a a DT 40288 1364 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 29 as as RB 40288 1364 30 well well RB 40288 1364 31 as as IN 40288 1364 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 33 g g NNP 40288 1364 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 35 is be VBZ 40288 1364 36 omitted omit VBN 40288 1364 37 , , , 40288 1364 38 and and CC 40288 1364 39 on on IN 40288 1364 40 the the DT 40288 1364 41 other other JJ 40288 1364 42 hand hand NN 40288 1364 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 44 d d NNP 40288 1364 45 _ _ NNP 40288 1364 46 is be VBZ 40288 1364 47 retained retain VBN 40288 1364 48 . . . 40288 1365 1 If if IN 40288 1365 2 the the DT 40288 1365 3 scale scale NN 40288 1365 4 of of IN 40288 1365 5 the the DT 40288 1365 6 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 1365 7 - - HYPH 40288 1365 8 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1365 9 is be VBZ 40288 1365 10 completed complete VBN 40288 1365 11 by by IN 40288 1365 12 the the DT 40288 1365 13 lower low JJR 40288 1365 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1365 15 c c NNP 40288 1365 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1365 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1365 18 as as IN 40288 1365 19 analogy analogy NN 40288 1365 20 would would MD 40288 1365 21 require require VB 40288 1365 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1365 23 , , , 40288 1365 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1365 25 will will MD 40288 1365 26 answer answer VB 40288 1365 27 similarly similarly RB 40288 1365 28 to to IN 40288 1365 29 the the DT 40288 1365 30 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1365 31 species specie NNS 40288 1365 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1365 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1365 34 c c NNP 40288 1365 35 - - HYPH 40288 1365 36 c c NNP 40288 1365 37 _ _ NNP 40288 1365 38 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1365 39 . . . 40288 1366 1 § § ADD 40288 1366 2 34 34 CD 40288 1366 3 . . . 40288 1367 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1367 2 Credibility Credibility NNP 40288 1367 3 of of IN 40288 1367 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1367 5 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 1367 6 . . . 40288 1367 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1367 8 But but CC 40288 1367 9 what what WP 40288 1367 10 weight weight NN 40288 1367 11 can can MD 40288 1367 12 be be VB 40288 1367 13 given give VBN 40288 1367 14 to to IN 40288 1367 15 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1367 16 as as IN 40288 1367 17 an an DT 40288 1367 18 authority authority NN 40288 1367 19 on on IN 40288 1367 20 the the DT 40288 1367 21 music music NN 40288 1367 22 of of IN 40288 1367 23 the the DT 40288 1367 24 time time NN 40288 1367 25 of of IN 40288 1367 26 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1367 27 ? ? . 40288 1368 1 The the DT 40288 1368 2 answer answer NN 40288 1368 3 to to IN 40288 1368 4 this this DT 40288 1368 5 question question NN 40288 1368 6 depends depend VBZ 40288 1368 7 upon upon IN 40288 1368 8 several several JJ 40288 1368 9 considerations consideration NNS 40288 1368 10 . . . 40288 1369 1 1 1 LS 40288 1369 2 . . . 40288 1370 1 The the DT 40288 1370 2 date date NN 40288 1370 3 of of IN 40288 1370 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1370 5 is be VBZ 40288 1370 6 unknown unknown JJ 40288 1370 7 . . . 40288 1371 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1371 2 is be VBZ 40288 1371 3 certainly certainly RB 40288 1371 4 later later RB 40288 1371 5 than than IN 40288 1371 6 Cicero Cicero NNP 40288 1371 7 , , , 40288 1371 8 since since IN 40288 1371 9 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1371 10 quotes quote VBZ 40288 1371 11 the the DT 40288 1371 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1371 13 De De NNP 40288 1371 14 Republica Republica NNP 40288 1371 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1371 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1371 17 p. p. NN 40288 1371 18 70 70 CD 40288 1371 19 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1371 20 . . . 40288 1371 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1371 22 . . . 40288 1372 1 From from IN 40288 1372 2 the the DT 40288 1372 3 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 1372 4 that that WDT 40288 1372 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1372 6 makes make VBZ 40288 1372 7 no no DT 40288 1372 8 reference reference NN 40288 1372 9 to to IN 40288 1372 10 the the DT 40288 1372 11 musical musical JJ 40288 1372 12 innovations innovation NNS 40288 1372 13 of of IN 40288 1372 14 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1372 15 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1372 16 has have VBZ 40288 1372 17 been be VBN 40288 1372 18 supposed suppose VBN 40288 1372 19 that that IN 40288 1372 20 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1372 21 was be VBD 40288 1372 22 earlier early JJR 40288 1372 23 than than IN 40288 1372 24 that that DT 40288 1372 25 writer writer NN 40288 1372 26 . . . 40288 1373 1 But but CC 40288 1373 2 , , , 40288 1373 3 as as IN 40288 1373 4 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1373 5 usually usually RB 40288 1373 6 confines confine VBZ 40288 1373 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 1373 8 to to IN 40288 1373 9 the the DT 40288 1373 10 theory theory NN 40288 1373 11 of of IN 40288 1373 12 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1373 13 and and CC 40288 1373 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1373 15 school school NN 40288 1373 16 , , , 40288 1373 17 the the DT 40288 1373 18 argument argument NN 40288 1373 19 from from IN 40288 1373 20 silence silence NN 40288 1373 21 is be VBZ 40288 1373 22 not not RB 40288 1373 23 of of IN 40288 1373 24 much much JJ 40288 1373 25 value value NN 40288 1373 26 . . . 40288 1374 1 On on IN 40288 1374 2 the the DT 40288 1374 3 other other JJ 40288 1374 4 hand hand NN 40288 1374 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1374 6 gives give VBZ 40288 1374 7 a a DT 40288 1374 8 scheme scheme NN 40288 1374 9 of of IN 40288 1374 10 notation notation NN 40288 1374 11 containing contain VBG 40288 1374 12 two two CD 40288 1374 13 characters character NNS 40288 1374 14 , , , 40288 1374 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1374 16 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1374 17 : : : 40288 1374 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1374 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1374 20 and and CC 40288 1374 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1374 22 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1374 23 : : : 40288 1374 24 * * NFP 40288 1374 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1374 26 , , , 40288 1374 27 which which WDT 40288 1374 28 extend extend VBP 40288 1374 29 the the DT 40288 1374 30 scale scale NN 40288 1374 31 two two CD 40288 1374 32 successive successive JJ 40288 1374 33 semi semi NN 40288 1374 34 - - NNS 40288 1374 35 tones tone NNS 40288 1374 36 beyond beyond IN 40288 1374 37 the the DT 40288 1374 38 lowest low JJS 40288 1374 39 point point NN 40288 1374 40 of of IN 40288 1374 41 the the DT 40288 1374 42 notation notation NN 40288 1374 43 given give VBN 40288 1374 44 by by IN 40288 1374 45 Alypius[1 Alypius[1 NNP 40288 1374 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1374 47 . . . 40288 1375 1 For for IN 40288 1375 2 this this DT 40288 1375 3 reason reason NN 40288 1375 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1375 5 is be VBZ 40288 1375 6 probable probable JJ 40288 1375 7 that that IN 40288 1375 8 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1375 9 is be VBZ 40288 1375 10 one one CD 40288 1375 11 of of IN 40288 1375 12 the the DT 40288 1375 13 latest late JJS 40288 1375 14 of of IN 40288 1375 15 the the DT 40288 1375 16 writers writer NNS 40288 1375 17 on on IN 40288 1375 18 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1375 19 music music NN 40288 1375 20 . . . 40288 1376 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1376 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1376 3 1 1 CD 40288 1376 4 : : : 40288 1376 5 This this DT 40288 1376 6 argument argument NN 40288 1376 7 is be VBZ 40288 1376 8 used use VBN 40288 1376 9 , , , 40288 1376 10 along along IN 40288 1376 11 with with IN 40288 1376 12 some some DT 40288 1376 13 others other NNS 40288 1376 14 not not RB 40288 1376 15 so so RB 40288 1376 16 cogent cogent JJ 40288 1376 17 , , , 40288 1376 18 in in IN 40288 1376 19 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1376 20 W. W. NNP 40288 1376 21 Chappell Chappell NNP 40288 1376 22 's 's POS 40288 1376 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1376 24 History History NNP 40288 1376 25 of of IN 40288 1376 26 Music Music NNP 40288 1376 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1376 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1376 29 p. p. NN 40288 1377 1 130 130 CD 40288 1377 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1377 3 . . . 40288 1377 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1378 1 2 2 LS 40288 1378 2 . . . 40288 1379 1 The the DT 40288 1379 2 manner manner NN 40288 1379 3 in in IN 40288 1379 4 which which WDT 40288 1379 5 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1379 6 introduces introduce VBZ 40288 1379 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1379 8 information information NN 40288 1379 9 about about IN 40288 1379 10 the the DT 40288 1379 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40288 1379 12 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1379 13 is be VBZ 40288 1379 14 highly highly RB 40288 1379 15 suspicious suspicious JJ 40288 1379 16 . . . 40288 1380 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1380 2 has have VBZ 40288 1380 3 been be VBN 40288 1380 4 describing describe VBG 40288 1380 5 the the DT 40288 1380 6 various various JJ 40288 1380 7 divisions division NNS 40288 1380 8 of of IN 40288 1380 9 the the DT 40288 1380 10 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1380 11 according accord VBG 40288 1380 12 to to IN 40288 1380 13 the the DT 40288 1380 14 theory theory NN 40288 1380 15 of of IN 40288 1380 16 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1380 17 , , , 40288 1380 18 and and CC 40288 1380 19 adds add VBZ 40288 1380 20 that that IN 40288 1380 21 there there EX 40288 1380 22 were be VBD 40288 1380 23 anciently anciently RB 40288 1380 24 other other JJ 40288 1380 25 divisions division NNS 40288 1380 26 in in IN 40288 1380 27 use use NN 40288 1380 28 . . . 40288 1381 1 So so RB 40288 1381 2 far far RB 40288 1381 3 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1381 4 is be VBZ 40288 1381 5 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 1381 6 right right JJ 40288 1381 7 , , , 40288 1381 8 since since IN 40288 1381 9 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1381 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 1381 11 says say VBZ 40288 1381 12 that that IN 40288 1381 13 the the DT 40288 1381 14 divisions division NNS 40288 1381 15 of of IN 40288 1381 16 the the DT 40288 1381 17 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1381 18 are be VBP 40288 1381 19 theoretically theoretically RB 40288 1381 20 infinite infinite JJ 40288 1381 21 in in IN 40288 1381 22 number number NN 40288 1381 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1381 24 p. p. NN 40288 1381 25 26 26 CD 40288 1381 26 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1381 27 . . . 40288 1382 1 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1382 2 , , , 40288 1382 3 --that --that VBP 40288 1382 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1382 5 is be VBZ 40288 1382 6 possible possible JJ 40288 1382 7 , , , 40288 1382 8 for for IN 40288 1382 9 example example NN 40288 1382 10 , , , 40288 1382 11 to to TO 40288 1382 12 combine combine VB 40288 1382 13 the the DT 40288 1382 14 Parhypatê Parhypatê NNP 40288 1382 15 of of IN 40288 1382 16 the the DT 40288 1382 17 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1382 18 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1382 19 with with IN 40288 1382 20 the the DT 40288 1382 21 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1382 22 of of IN 40288 1382 23 the the DT 40288 1382 24 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1382 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1382 26 p. p. NN 40288 1382 27 52 52 CD 40288 1382 28 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1382 29 . . . 40288 1382 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1382 31 . . . 40288 1383 1 But but CC 40288 1383 2 all all PDT 40288 1383 3 this this DT 40288 1383 4 concerns concern VBZ 40288 1383 5 the the DT 40288 1383 6 genus genus NN 40288 1383 7 of of IN 40288 1383 8 the the DT 40288 1383 9 scale scale NN 40288 1383 10 , , , 40288 1383 11 and and CC 40288 1383 12 has have VBZ 40288 1383 13 nothing nothing NN 40288 1383 14 to to TO 40288 1383 15 do do VB 40288 1383 16 with with IN 40288 1383 17 the the DT 40288 1383 18 species specie NNS 40288 1383 19 of of IN 40288 1383 20 the the DT 40288 1383 21 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1383 22 , , , 40288 1383 23 with with IN 40288 1383 24 which which WDT 40288 1383 25 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1383 26 proceeds proceed VBZ 40288 1383 27 to to TO 40288 1383 28 connect connect VB 40288 1383 29 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1383 30 . . . 40288 1384 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1384 2 follows follow VBZ 40288 1384 3 either either CC 40288 1384 4 that that IN 40288 1384 5 there there EX 40288 1384 6 is be VBZ 40288 1384 7 some some DT 40288 1384 8 confusion confusion NN 40288 1384 9 in in IN 40288 1384 10 the the DT 40288 1384 11 text text NN 40288 1384 12 , , , 40288 1384 13 or or CC 40288 1384 14 that that IN 40288 1384 15 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1384 16 was be VBD 40288 1384 17 compiling compile VBG 40288 1384 18 from from IN 40288 1384 19 sources source NNS 40288 1384 20 which which WDT 40288 1384 21 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1384 22 did do VBD 40288 1384 23 not not RB 40288 1384 24 understand understand VB 40288 1384 25 . . . 40288 1385 1 3 3 LS 40288 1385 2 . . . 40288 1386 1 The the DT 40288 1386 2 Platonic Platonic NNP 40288 1386 3 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1386 4 were be VBD 40288 1386 5 a a DT 40288 1386 6 subject subject NN 40288 1386 7 of of IN 40288 1386 8 interest interest NN 40288 1386 9 to to IN 40288 1386 10 the the DT 40288 1386 11 early early JJ 40288 1386 12 musical musical JJ 40288 1386 13 writers writer NNS 40288 1386 14 , , , 40288 1386 15 and and CC 40288 1386 16 were be VBD 40288 1386 17 discussed discuss VBN 40288 1386 18 by by IN 40288 1386 19 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1386 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 1386 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1386 22 Plut Plut NNP 40288 1386 23 . . . 40288 1387 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1387 2 de de NNP 40288 1387 3 Mus Mus NNP 40288 1387 4 . . . 40288 1387 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1387 6 c. c. NNP 40288 1387 7 17 17 CD 40288 1387 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1387 9 . . . 40288 1388 1 If if IN 40288 1388 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1388 3 had have VBD 40288 1388 4 had have VBN 40288 1388 5 access access NN 40288 1388 6 to to IN 40288 1388 7 such such PDT 40288 1388 8 an an DT 40288 1388 9 account account NN 40288 1388 10 as as IN 40288 1388 11 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1388 12 have have VBP 40288 1388 13 in in IN 40288 1388 14 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1388 15 , , , 40288 1388 16 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1388 17 must must MD 40288 1388 18 have have VB 40288 1388 19 found find VBN 40288 1388 20 some some DT 40288 1388 21 trace trace NN 40288 1388 22 of of IN 40288 1388 23 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1388 24 , , , 40288 1388 25 either either CC 40288 1388 26 in in IN 40288 1388 27 the the DT 40288 1388 28 extant extant JJ 40288 1388 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1388 30 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 1388 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1388 32 or or CC 40288 1388 33 in in IN 40288 1388 34 the the DT 40288 1388 35 quotations quotation NNS 40288 1388 36 of of IN 40288 1388 37 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 1388 38 and and CC 40288 1388 39 other other JJ 40288 1388 40 compilers compiler NNS 40288 1388 41 . . . 40288 1389 1 4 4 LS 40288 1389 2 . . . 40288 1390 1 Of of IN 40288 1390 2 the the DT 40288 1390 3 four four CD 40288 1390 4 scales scale NNS 40288 1390 5 which which WDT 40288 1390 6 extend extend VBP 40288 1390 7 to to IN 40288 1390 8 the the DT 40288 1390 9 compass compass NN 40288 1390 10 of of IN 40288 1390 11 an an DT 40288 1390 12 octave octave NN 40288 1390 13 , , , 40288 1390 14 only only RB 40288 1390 15 one one CD 40288 1390 16 , , , 40288 1390 17 viz viz NN 40288 1390 18 . . . 40288 1391 1 the the DT 40288 1391 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1391 3 , , , 40288 1391 4 conforms conform VBZ 40288 1391 5 to to IN 40288 1391 6 the the DT 40288 1391 7 rules rule NNS 40288 1391 8 which which WDT 40288 1391 9 are be VBP 40288 1391 10 said say VBN 40288 1391 11 by by IN 40288 1391 12 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1391 13 to to TO 40288 1391 14 have have VB 40288 1391 15 prevailed prevail VBN 40288 1391 16 in in IN 40288 1391 17 early early JJ 40288 1391 18 Greek greek JJ 40288 1391 19 music music NN 40288 1391 20 . . . 40288 1392 1 The the DT 40288 1392 2 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1392 3 divides divide VBZ 40288 1392 4 the the DT 40288 1392 5 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1392 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1392 7 a a NN 40288 1392 8 - - HYPH 40288 1392 9 d d NNP 40288 1392 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1392 11 into into IN 40288 1392 12 four four CD 40288 1392 13 intervals interval NNS 40288 1392 14 instead instead RB 40288 1392 15 of of IN 40288 1392 16 three three CD 40288 1392 17 , , , 40288 1392 18 by by IN 40288 1392 19 the the DT 40288 1392 20 sequence sequence NN 40288 1392 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1392 22 a a DT 40288 1392 23 b b NN 40288 1392 24 b b NN 40288 1392 25 * * NN 40288 1392 26 c c NN 40288 1392 27 d d NNP 40288 1392 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1392 29 . . . 40288 1393 1 As as IN 40288 1393 2 has have VBZ 40288 1393 3 been be VBN 40288 1393 4 observed observe VBN 40288 1393 5 , , , 40288 1393 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1393 7 is be VBZ 40288 1393 8 neither neither CC 40288 1393 9 the the DT 40288 1393 10 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1393 11 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1393 12 species specie NNS 40288 1393 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1393 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1393 15 c c NNP 40288 1393 16 e e NNP 40288 1393 17 e e NNP 40288 1393 18 * * NNP 40288 1393 19 f f NNP 40288 1393 20 a a DT 40288 1393 21 b b NNP 40288 1393 22 b b NN 40288 1393 23 * * NN 40288 1393 24 c c NNP 40288 1393 25 _ _ NNP 40288 1393 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1393 27 , , , 40288 1393 28 nor nor CC 40288 1393 29 the the DT 40288 1393 30 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1393 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1393 32 d d NNP 40288 1393 33 - - HYPH 40288 1393 34 d d NNP 40288 1393 35 _ _ NNP 40288 1393 36 , , , 40288 1393 37 but but CC 40288 1393 38 a a DT 40288 1393 39 mixture mixture NN 40288 1393 40 of of IN 40288 1393 41 the the DT 40288 1393 42 two two CD 40288 1393 43 . . . 40288 1394 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 1394 2 the the DT 40288 1394 3 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1394 4 - - HYPH 40288 1394 5 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1394 6 divides divide VBZ 40288 1394 7 the the DT 40288 1394 8 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1394 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1394 10 b_-_e b_-_e NN 40288 1394 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1394 12 into into IN 40288 1394 13 four four CD 40288 1394 14 intervals interval NNS 40288 1394 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1394 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1394 17 b b NNP 40288 1394 18 b b NNP 40288 1394 19 * * NN 40288 1394 20 c c NN 40288 1394 21 d d NNP 40288 1394 22 e e NNP 40288 1394 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1394 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1394 25 , , , 40288 1394 26 by by IN 40288 1394 27 introducing introduce VBG 40288 1394 28 the the DT 40288 1394 29 purely purely RB 40288 1394 30 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1394 31 note note NN 40288 1394 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1394 33 d d NNP 40288 1394 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1394 35 . . . 40288 1395 1 The the DT 40288 1395 2 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1395 3 is be VBZ 40288 1395 4 certainly certainly RB 40288 1395 5 the the DT 40288 1395 6 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1395 7 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1395 8 species specie NNS 40288 1395 9 of of IN 40288 1395 10 the the DT 40288 1395 11 pseudo pseudo NN 40288 1395 12 - - : 40288 1395 13 Euclid euclid NN 40288 1395 14 ; ; : 40288 1395 15 but but CC 40288 1395 16 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1395 17 can can MD 40288 1395 18 hardly hardly RB 40288 1395 19 suppose suppose VB 40288 1395 20 that that IN 40288 1395 21 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1395 22 existed exist VBD 40288 1395 23 in in IN 40288 1395 24 practical practical JJ 40288 1395 25 music music NN 40288 1395 26 . . . 40288 1396 1 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1396 2 lays lay VBZ 40288 1396 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1396 4 down down RP 40288 1396 5 emphatically emphatically RB 40288 1396 6 that that IN 40288 1396 7 a a DT 40288 1396 8 quarter quarter NN 40288 1396 9 - - HYPH 40288 1396 10 tone tone NN 40288 1396 11 is be VBZ 40288 1396 12 always always RB 40288 1396 13 followed follow VBN 40288 1396 14 by by IN 40288 1396 15 another another DT 40288 1396 16 : : : 40288 1396 17 and and CC 40288 1396 18 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1396 19 can can MD 40288 1396 20 not not RB 40288 1396 21 imagine imagine VB 40288 1396 22 a a DT 40288 1396 23 scale scale NN 40288 1396 24 in in IN 40288 1396 25 which which WDT 40288 1396 26 the the DT 40288 1396 27 highest high JJS 40288 1396 28 and and CC 40288 1396 29 lowest low JJS 40288 1396 30 notes note NNS 40288 1396 31 are be VBP 40288 1396 32 in in IN 40288 1396 33 no no DT 40288 1396 34 harmonic harmonic JJ 40288 1396 35 relation relation NN 40288 1396 36 to to IN 40288 1396 37 the the DT 40288 1396 38 rest rest NN 40288 1396 39 . . . 40288 1397 1 5 5 CD 40288 1397 2 . . . 40288 1398 1 Two two CD 40288 1398 2 of of IN 40288 1398 3 the the DT 40288 1398 4 scales scale NNS 40288 1398 5 are be VBP 40288 1398 6 incomplete incomplete JJ 40288 1398 7 , , , 40288 1398 8 viz viz NN 40288 1398 9 . . . 40288 1399 1 the the DT 40288 1399 2 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 1399 3 , , , 40288 1399 4 which which WDT 40288 1399 5 has have VBZ 40288 1399 6 six six CD 40288 1399 7 notes note NNS 40288 1399 8 and and CC 40288 1399 9 the the DT 40288 1399 10 compass compass NN 40288 1399 11 of of IN 40288 1399 12 a a DT 40288 1399 13 Seventh Seventh NNP 40288 1399 14 , , , 40288 1399 15 and and CC 40288 1399 16 the the DT 40288 1399 17 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 1399 18 - - HYPH 40288 1399 19 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1399 20 , , , 40288 1399 21 which which WDT 40288 1399 22 consists consist VBZ 40288 1399 23 of of IN 40288 1399 24 five five CD 40288 1399 25 notes note NNS 40288 1399 26 , , , 40288 1399 27 with with IN 40288 1399 28 the the DT 40288 1399 29 compass compass NN 40288 1399 30 of of IN 40288 1399 31 a a DT 40288 1399 32 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1399 33 Sixth Sixth NNP 40288 1399 34 . . . 40288 1400 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1400 2 naturally naturally RB 40288 1400 3 look look VBP 40288 1400 4 for for IN 40288 1400 5 parallels parallel NNS 40288 1400 6 among among IN 40288 1400 7 the the DT 40288 1400 8 defective defective JJ 40288 1400 9 scales scale NNS 40288 1400 10 noticed notice VBN 40288 1400 11 in in IN 40288 1400 12 the the DT 40288 1400 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1400 14 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1400 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1400 16 and and CC 40288 1400 17 in in IN 40288 1400 18 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 1400 19 's 's POS 40288 1400 20 dialogues dialogue NNS 40288 1400 21 . . . 40288 1401 1 But but CC 40288 1401 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1401 3 find find VBP 40288 1401 4 little little JJ 40288 1401 5 that that IN 40288 1401 6 even even RB 40288 1401 7 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40288 1401 8 the the DT 40288 1401 9 modes mode NNS 40288 1401 10 of of IN 40288 1401 11 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1401 12 . . . 40288 1402 1 The the DT 40288 1402 2 scales scale NNS 40288 1402 3 noticed notice VBN 40288 1402 4 in in IN 40288 1402 5 the the DT 40288 1402 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1402 7 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1402 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1402 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1402 10 xix xix NNP 40288 1402 11 . . . 40288 1403 1 7 7 CD 40288 1403 2 , , , 40288 1403 3 32 32 CD 40288 1403 4 , , , 40288 1403 5 47 47 CD 40288 1403 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1403 7 are be VBP 40288 1403 8 hepta hepta NNP 40288 1403 9 - - HYPH 40288 1403 10 chord chord NNP 40288 1403 11 , , , 40288 1403 12 and and CC 40288 1403 13 generally generally RB 40288 1403 14 of of IN 40288 1403 15 the the DT 40288 1403 16 compass compass NN 40288 1403 17 of of IN 40288 1403 18 an an DT 40288 1403 19 octave octave NN 40288 1403 20 . . . 40288 1404 1 In in IN 40288 1404 2 one one CD 40288 1404 3 passage passage NN 40288 1404 4 of of IN 40288 1404 5 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 1404 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1404 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1404 8 De De NNP 40288 1404 9 Mus Mus NNP 40288 1404 10 . . . 40288 1404 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1404 12 c. c. NNP 40288 1404 13 11 11 CD 40288 1404 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1404 15 there there EX 40288 1404 16 is be VBZ 40288 1404 17 a a DT 40288 1404 18 description description NN 40288 1404 19 -- -- : 40288 1404 20 quoted quote VBN 40288 1404 21 from from IN 40288 1404 22 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1404 23 -- -- : 40288 1404 24 of of IN 40288 1404 25 an an DT 40288 1404 26 older old JJR 40288 1404 27 kind kind NN 40288 1404 28 of of IN 40288 1404 29 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1404 30 , , , 40288 1404 31 in in IN 40288 1404 32 which which WDT 40288 1404 33 the the DT 40288 1404 34 semitones semitone NNS 40288 1404 35 had have VBD 40288 1404 36 not not RB 40288 1404 37 yet yet RB 40288 1404 38 been be VBN 40288 1404 39 divided divide VBN 40288 1404 40 into into IN 40288 1404 41 quarter quarter NN 40288 1404 42 - - HYPH 40288 1404 43 tones tone NNS 40288 1404 44 . . . 40288 1405 1 In in IN 40288 1405 2 another another DT 40288 1405 3 chapter chapter NN 40288 1405 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1405 5 c. c. NNP 40288 1405 6 19 19 CD 40288 1405 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1405 8 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1405 9 speaks speak VBZ 40288 1405 10 of of IN 40288 1405 11 the the DT 40288 1405 12 omission omission NN 40288 1405 13 of of IN 40288 1405 14 the the DT 40288 1405 15 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 1405 16 and and CC 40288 1405 17 also also RB 40288 1405 18 of of IN 40288 1405 19 the the DT 40288 1405 20 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1405 21 as as IN 40288 1405 22 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 1405 23 of of IN 40288 1405 24 a a DT 40288 1405 25 form form NN 40288 1405 26 of of IN 40288 1405 27 music music NN 40288 1405 28 called call VBN 40288 1405 29 the the DT 40288 1405 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1405 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1405 32 : : : 40288 1405 33 spondeiakos spondeiakos NNP 40288 1405 34 tropos tropos NNP 40288 1405 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1405 36 . . . 40288 1406 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1406 2 may may MD 40288 1406 3 be be VB 40288 1406 4 said say VBN 40288 1406 5 that that IN 40288 1406 6 in in IN 40288 1406 7 the the DT 40288 1406 8 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1406 9 and and CC 40288 1406 10 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 1406 11 - - HYPH 40288 1406 12 lydian lydian NN 40288 1406 13 of of IN 40288 1406 14 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1406 15 the the DT 40288 1406 16 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1406 17 Tritê Tritê NNP 40288 1406 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1406 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1406 20 b b NNP 40288 1406 21 * * NFP 40288 1406 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1406 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1406 24 and and CC 40288 1406 25 the the DT 40288 1406 26 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1406 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1406 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1406 29 e e NNP 40288 1406 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1406 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1406 32 are be VBP 40288 1406 33 wanting want VBG 40288 1406 34 . . . 40288 1407 1 But but CC 40288 1407 2 the the DT 40288 1407 3 Paramesê Paramesê NNPS 40288 1407 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1407 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1407 6 b b NNP 40288 1407 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1407 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1407 9 is be VBZ 40288 1407 10 also also RB 40288 1407 11 wanting want VBG 40288 1407 12 in in IN 40288 1407 13 both both PDT 40288 1407 14 these these DT 40288 1407 15 modes mode NNS 40288 1407 16 . . . 40288 1408 1 And and CC 40288 1408 2 the the DT 40288 1408 3 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 1408 4 is be VBZ 40288 1408 5 open open JJ 40288 1408 6 to to IN 40288 1408 7 the the DT 40288 1408 8 observation observation NN 40288 1408 9 already already RB 40288 1408 10 made make VBN 40288 1408 11 with with IN 40288 1408 12 regard regard NN 40288 1408 13 to to IN 40288 1408 14 the the DT 40288 1408 15 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1408 16 , , , 40288 1408 17 viz viz NN 40288 1408 18 . . . 40288 1409 1 that that IN 40288 1409 2 the the DT 40288 1409 3 two two CD 40288 1409 4 highest high JJS 40288 1409 5 notes note NNS 40288 1409 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1409 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1409 8 c c NNP 40288 1409 9 d d NNP 40288 1409 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1409 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1409 12 involve involve VBP 40288 1409 13 a a DT 40288 1409 14 mixture mixture NN 40288 1409 15 of of IN 40288 1409 16 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1409 17 with with IN 40288 1409 18 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1409 19 scale scale NN 40288 1409 20 . . . 40288 1410 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1410 2 may may MD 40288 1410 3 add add VB 40288 1410 4 that that DT 40288 1410 5 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 1410 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1410 7 who who WP 40288 1410 8 evidently evidently RB 40288 1410 9 wrote write VBD 40288 1410 10 with with IN 40288 1410 11 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1410 12 before before IN 40288 1410 13 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1410 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1410 15 gives give VBZ 40288 1410 16 no no DT 40288 1410 17 hint hint NN 40288 1410 18 that that IN 40288 1410 19 the the DT 40288 1410 20 omission omission NN 40288 1410 21 of of IN 40288 1410 22 these these DT 40288 1410 23 notes note NNS 40288 1410 24 was be VBD 40288 1410 25 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 1410 26 of of IN 40288 1410 27 any any DT 40288 1410 28 particular particular JJ 40288 1410 29 modes mode NNS 40288 1410 30 . . . 40288 1411 1 6 6 CD 40288 1411 2 . . . 40288 1412 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1412 2 is be VBZ 40288 1412 3 impossible impossible JJ 40288 1412 4 to to TO 40288 1412 5 decide decide VB 40288 1412 6 the the DT 40288 1412 7 question question NN 40288 1412 8 of of IN 40288 1412 9 the the DT 40288 1412 10 modes mode NNS 40288 1412 11 of of IN 40288 1412 12 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1412 13 without without IN 40288 1412 14 some some DT 40288 1412 15 reference reference NN 40288 1412 16 to to IN 40288 1412 17 another another DT 40288 1412 18 statement statement NN 40288 1412 19 of of IN 40288 1412 20 the the DT 40288 1412 21 same same JJ 40288 1412 22 author author NN 40288 1412 23 . . . 40288 1413 1 In in IN 40288 1413 2 the the DT 40288 1413 3 chapter chapter NN 40288 1413 4 which which WDT 40288 1413 5 treats treat NNS 40288 1413 6 of of IN 40288 1413 7 Intervals Intervals NNPS 40288 1413 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1413 9 pp pp NNP 40288 1413 10 . . . 40288 1414 1 13 13 CD 40288 1414 2 - - SYM 40288 1414 3 15 15 CD 40288 1414 4 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1414 5 . . . 40288 1414 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1415 1 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1415 2 gives give VBZ 40288 1415 3 the the DT 40288 1415 4 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1415 5 division division NN 40288 1415 6 of of IN 40288 1415 7 two two CD 40288 1415 8 octaves octave NNS 40288 1415 9 , , , 40288 1415 10 the the DT 40288 1415 11 first first JJ 40288 1415 12 into into IN 40288 1415 13 dieses diesis NNS 40288 1415 14 or or CC 40288 1415 15 quarter quarter NN 40288 1415 16 - - HYPH 40288 1415 17 tones tone NNS 40288 1415 18 , , , 40288 1415 19 the the DT 40288 1415 20 second second JJ 40288 1415 21 into into IN 40288 1415 22 semitones semitone NNS 40288 1415 23 . . . 40288 1416 1 The the DT 40288 1416 2 former former JJ 40288 1416 3 of of IN 40288 1416 4 these these DT 40288 1416 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1416 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1416 7 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1416 8 : : : 40288 1416 9 hê hê NNP 40288 1416 10 para para NNP 40288 1416 11 tois tois NNP 40288 1416 12 archaiois archaiois NNP 40288 1416 13 kata kata NNP 40288 1416 14 dieseis dieseis NNP 40288 1416 15 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 1416 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1416 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1416 18 is be VBZ 40288 1416 19 as as IN 40288 1416 20 follows follow VBZ 40288 1416 21 : : : 40288 1416 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1416 23 1 1 CD 40288 1416 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1416 25 2 2 CD 40288 1416 26 3 3 CD 40288 1416 27 4 4 CD 40288 1416 28 5 5 CD 40288 1416 29 6 6 CD 40288 1416 30 7 7 CD 40288 1416 31 8 8 CD 40288 1416 32 9 9 CD 40288 1416 33 10 10 CD 40288 1416 34 11 11 CD 40288 1416 35 12 12 CD 40288 1416 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1416 37 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1416 38 : : : 40288 1416 39 -o -o NFP 40288 1416 40 < < XX 40288 1416 41 6 6 CD 40288 1416 42 1 1 CD 40288 1416 43 - - SYM 40288 1416 44 1 1 CD 40288 1416 45 9 9 CD 40288 1416 46 L l NN 40288 1416 47 J J NNP 40288 1416 48 A A NNP 40288 1416 49 V v NN 40288 1416 50 E e NN 40288 1416 51 3 3 CD 40288 1416 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1416 53 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1416 54 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1416 55 : : : 40288 1416 56 o- o- XX 40288 1416 57 > > XX 40288 1416 58 9 9 CD 40288 1416 59 n n CD 40288 1416 60 6 6 CD 40288 1416 61 J J NNP 40288 1416 62 r- r- XX 40288 1416 63 v v NN 40288 1416 64 0 0 CD 40288 1416 65 3 3 CD 40288 1416 66 E e NN 40288 1416 67 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1416 68 13 13 CD 40288 1416 69 14 14 CD 40288 1416 70 15 15 CD 40288 1416 71 16 16 CD 40288 1416 72 17 17 CD 40288 1416 73 18 18 CD 40288 1416 74 19 19 CD 40288 1416 75 20 20 CD 40288 1416 76 21 21 CD 40288 1416 77 22 22 CD 40288 1416 78 23 23 CD 40288 1416 79 24 24 CD 40288 1416 80 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1416 81 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1416 82 : : : 40288 1416 83 3 3 LS 40288 1416 84 .. .. . 40288 1416 85 N n CD 40288 1416 86 1 1 CD 40288 1416 87 - - SYM 40288 1416 88 1 1 CD 40288 1416 89 3 3 CD 40288 1416 90 E e NN 40288 1416 91 , , , 40288 1416 92 ' ' '' 40288 1416 93 - - : 40288 1416 94 cc cc NN 40288 1416 95 > > XX 40288 1416 96 < < XX 40288 1416 97 Y Y NNP 40288 1416 98 Y y NN 40288 1416 99 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1416 100 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1416 101 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1416 102 : : : 40288 1416 103 r r LS 40288 1416 104 a a NN 40288 1416 105 .. .. NFP 40288 1416 106 1 1 CD 40288 1416 107 - - SYM 40288 1416 108 1 1 CD 40288 1416 109 E e NN 40288 1416 110 3 3 CD 40288 1416 111 A a NN 40288 1416 112 , , , 40288 1416 113 ' ' '' 40288 1416 114 - - SYM 40288 1416 115 33 33 CD 40288 1416 116 < < XX 40288 1416 117 Y Y NNP 40288 1416 118 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1416 119 After after IN 40288 1416 120 every every DT 40288 1416 121 allowance allowance NN 40288 1416 122 has have VBZ 40288 1416 123 been be VBN 40288 1416 124 made make VBN 40288 1416 125 for for IN 40288 1416 126 the the DT 40288 1416 127 probability probability NN 40288 1416 128 that that IN 40288 1416 129 these these DT 40288 1416 130 signs sign NNS 40288 1416 131 or or CC 40288 1416 132 some some DT 40288 1416 133 of of IN 40288 1416 134 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1416 135 have have VBP 40288 1416 136 reached reach VBN 40288 1416 137 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1416 138 in in IN 40288 1416 139 a a DT 40288 1416 140 corrupt corrupt JJ 40288 1416 141 form form NN 40288 1416 142 , , , 40288 1416 143 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1416 144 is be VBZ 40288 1416 145 impossible impossible JJ 40288 1416 146 to to TO 40288 1416 147 reduce reduce VB 40288 1416 148 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1416 149 to to IN 40288 1416 150 the the DT 40288 1416 151 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1416 152 notation notation NN 40288 1416 153 , , , 40288 1416 154 as as IN 40288 1416 155 Meibomius Meibomius NNP 40288 1416 156 sought seek VBD 40288 1416 157 to to TO 40288 1416 158 do do VB 40288 1416 159 . . . 40288 1417 1 The the DT 40288 1417 2 scholar scholar NN 40288 1417 3 who who WP 40288 1417 4 first first RB 40288 1417 5 published publish VBD 40288 1417 6 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1417 7 as as IN 40288 1417 8 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1417 9 stand stand VBP 40288 1417 10 in in IN 40288 1417 11 the the DT 40288 1417 12 MSS MSS NNP 40288 1417 13 . . . 40288 1418 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1418 2 F. F. NNP 40288 1418 3 L. L. NNP 40288 1418 4 Perne Perne NNP 40288 1418 5 , , , 40288 1418 6 see see VB 40288 1418 7 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 1418 8 , , , 40288 1418 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1418 10 Tonleitern Tonleitern NNP 40288 1418 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1418 12 , , , 40288 1418 13 p. p. NN 40288 1418 14 62 62 CD 40288 1418 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1418 16 regarded regard VBD 40288 1418 17 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1418 18 as as IN 40288 1418 19 a a DT 40288 1418 20 relic relic NN 40288 1418 21 of of IN 40288 1418 22 a a DT 40288 1418 23 much much RB 40288 1418 24 older old JJR 40288 1418 25 system system NN 40288 1418 26 of of IN 40288 1418 27 notation notation NN 40288 1418 28 . . . 40288 1419 1 This this DT 40288 1419 2 is be VBZ 40288 1419 3 in in IN 40288 1419 4 accordance accordance NN 40288 1419 5 with with IN 40288 1419 6 the the DT 40288 1419 7 language language NN 40288 1419 8 of of IN 40288 1419 9 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1419 10 , , , 40288 1419 11 and and CC 40288 1419 12 indeed indeed RB 40288 1419 13 is be VBZ 40288 1419 14 the the DT 40288 1419 15 only only JJ 40288 1419 16 view view NN 40288 1419 17 consistent consistent JJ 40288 1419 18 with with IN 40288 1419 19 a a DT 40288 1419 20 belief belief NN 40288 1419 21 in in IN 40288 1419 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1419 23 genuineness genuineness NN 40288 1419 24 . . . 40288 1420 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1420 2 are be VBP 40288 1420 3 too too RB 40288 1420 4 like like IN 40288 1420 5 the the DT 40288 1420 6 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1420 7 notation notation NN 40288 1420 8 to to TO 40288 1420 9 be be VB 40288 1420 10 quite quite RB 40288 1420 11 independent independent JJ 40288 1420 12 , , , 40288 1420 13 and and CC 40288 1420 14 can can MD 40288 1420 15 not not RB 40288 1420 16 have have VB 40288 1420 17 been be VBN 40288 1420 18 put put VBN 40288 1420 19 forward forward RB 40288 1420 20 as as IN 40288 1420 21 an an DT 40288 1420 22 improvement improvement NN 40288 1420 23 upon upon IN 40288 1420 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1420 25 . . . 40288 1421 1 Are be VBP 40288 1421 2 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1421 3 , , , 40288 1421 4 then then RB 40288 1421 5 , , , 40288 1421 6 earlier early RBR 40288 1421 7 ? ? . 40288 1422 1 Bellermann Bellermann NNP 40288 1422 2 has have VBZ 40288 1422 3 called call VBN 40288 1422 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1422 5 attention attention NN 40288 1422 6 to to IN 40288 1422 7 a a DT 40288 1422 8 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40288 1422 9 which which WDT 40288 1422 10 seems seem VBZ 40288 1422 11 fatal fatal JJ 40288 1422 12 to to IN 40288 1422 13 any any DT 40288 1422 14 such such JJ 40288 1422 15 claim claim NN 40288 1422 16 . . . 40288 1423 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1423 2 consist consist VBP 40288 1423 3 , , , 40288 1423 4 like like IN 40288 1423 5 the the DT 40288 1423 6 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1423 7 signs sign NNS 40288 1423 8 , , , 40288 1423 9 of of IN 40288 1423 10 two two CD 40288 1423 11 sets set NNS 40288 1423 12 , , , 40288 1423 13 one one PRP 40288 1423 14 written write VBN 40288 1423 15 above above IN 40288 1423 16 the the DT 40288 1423 17 other other JJ 40288 1423 18 , , , 40288 1423 19 and and CC 40288 1423 20 in in IN 40288 1423 21 every every DT 40288 1423 22 instance instance NN 40288 1423 23 one one CD 40288 1423 24 of of IN 40288 1423 25 the the DT 40288 1423 26 pair pair NN 40288 1423 27 is be VBZ 40288 1423 28 simply simply RB 40288 1423 29 a a DT 40288 1423 30 reversed reversed JJ 40288 1423 31 or or CC 40288 1423 32 inverted invert VBN 40288 1423 33 form form NN 40288 1423 34 of of IN 40288 1423 35 the the DT 40288 1423 36 other other JJ 40288 1423 37 . . . 40288 1424 1 With with IN 40288 1424 2 the the DT 40288 1424 3 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1424 4 signs sign NNS 40288 1424 5 this this DT 40288 1424 6 is be VBZ 40288 1424 7 not not RB 40288 1424 8 generally generally RB 40288 1424 9 the the DT 40288 1424 10 case case NN 40288 1424 11 , , , 40288 1424 12 since since IN 40288 1424 13 the the DT 40288 1424 14 two two CD 40288 1424 15 sets set NNS 40288 1424 16 , , , 40288 1424 17 the the DT 40288 1424 18 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1424 19 and and CC 40288 1424 20 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1424 21 notes note NNS 40288 1424 22 , , , 40288 1424 23 are be VBP 40288 1424 24 originally originally RB 40288 1424 25 independent independent JJ 40288 1424 26 . . . 40288 1425 1 But but CC 40288 1425 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1425 3 is be VBZ 40288 1425 4 the the DT 40288 1425 5 case case NN 40288 1425 6 with with IN 40288 1425 7 the the DT 40288 1425 8 three three CD 40288 1425 9 lowest low JJS 40288 1425 10 notes note NNS 40288 1425 11 , , , 40288 1425 12 viz viz NN 40288 1425 13 . . . 40288 1426 1 those those DT 40288 1426 2 which which WDT 40288 1426 3 were be VBD 40288 1426 4 added add VBN 40288 1426 5 to to IN 40288 1426 6 the the DT 40288 1426 7 series series NN 40288 1426 8 at at IN 40288 1426 9 a a DT 40288 1426 10 later later JJ 40288 1426 11 time time NN 40288 1426 12 . . . 40288 1427 1 When when WRB 40288 1427 2 these these DT 40288 1427 3 additional additional JJ 40288 1427 4 signs sign NNS 40288 1427 5 were be VBD 40288 1427 6 invented invent VBN 40288 1427 7 the the DT 40288 1427 8 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1427 9 and and CC 40288 1427 10 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1427 11 notes note NNS 40288 1427 12 had have VBD 40288 1427 13 come come VBN 40288 1427 14 to to TO 40288 1427 15 be be VB 40288 1427 16 employed employ VBN 40288 1427 17 together together RB 40288 1427 18 . . . 40288 1428 1 The the DT 40288 1428 2 inventor inventor NN 40288 1428 3 therefore therefore RB 40288 1428 4 devised devise VBD 40288 1428 5 a a DT 40288 1428 6 pair pair NN 40288 1428 7 of of IN 40288 1428 8 signs sign NNS 40288 1428 9 in in IN 40288 1428 10 each each DT 40288 1428 11 case case NN 40288 1428 12 , , , 40288 1428 13 and and CC 40288 1428 14 not not RB 40288 1428 15 unnaturally unnaturally RB 40288 1428 16 made make VBD 40288 1428 17 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1428 18 correspond correspond VB 40288 1428 19 in in IN 40288 1428 20 form form NN 40288 1428 21 . . . 40288 1429 1 In in IN 40288 1429 2 the the DT 40288 1429 3 scale scale NN 40288 1429 4 given give VBN 40288 1429 5 by by IN 40288 1429 6 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1429 7 this this DT 40288 1429 8 correspondence correspondence NN 40288 1429 9 runs run VBZ 40288 1429 10 through through IN 40288 1429 11 the the DT 40288 1429 12 whole whole JJ 40288 1429 13 series series NN 40288 1429 14 , , , 40288 1429 15 which which WDT 40288 1429 16 must must MD 40288 1429 17 therefore therefore RB 40288 1429 18 be be VB 40288 1429 19 of of IN 40288 1429 20 later later JJ 40288 1429 21 date date NN 40288 1429 22 . . . 40288 1430 1 But but CC 40288 1430 2 if if IN 40288 1430 3 this this DT 40288 1430 4 is be VBZ 40288 1430 5 so so RB 40288 1430 6 , , , 40288 1430 7 the the DT 40288 1430 8 characters character NNS 40288 1430 9 can can MD 40288 1430 10 hardly hardly RB 40288 1430 11 represent represent VB 40288 1430 12 a a DT 40288 1430 13 genuine genuine JJ 40288 1430 14 system system NN 40288 1430 15 of of IN 40288 1430 16 notation notation NN 40288 1430 17 . . . 40288 1431 1 In in IN 40288 1431 2 other other JJ 40288 1431 3 words word NNS 40288 1431 4 , , , 40288 1431 5 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1431 6 must must MD 40288 1431 7 have have VB 40288 1431 8 been be VBN 40288 1431 9 imposed impose VBN 40288 1431 10 upon upon IN 40288 1431 11 by by IN 40288 1431 12 a a DT 40288 1431 13 species species NN 40288 1431 14 of of IN 40288 1431 15 forgery forgery NN 40288 1431 16 . . . 40288 1432 1 7 7 LS 40288 1432 2 . . . 40288 1433 1 Does do VBZ 40288 1433 2 the the DT 40288 1433 3 fragment fragment NN 40288 1433 4 of of IN 40288 1433 5 the the DT 40288 1433 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1433 7 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1433 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1433 9 tell tell VBP 40288 1433 10 for for IN 40288 1433 11 or or CC 40288 1433 12 against against IN 40288 1433 13 the the DT 40288 1433 14 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1433 15 described describe VBN 40288 1433 16 by by IN 40288 1433 17 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1433 18 ? ? . 40288 1434 1 The the DT 40288 1434 2 scale scale NN 40288 1434 3 which which WDT 40288 1434 4 is be VBZ 40288 1434 5 formed form VBN 40288 1434 6 by by IN 40288 1434 7 the the DT 40288 1434 8 notes note NNS 40288 1434 9 of of IN 40288 1434 10 the the DT 40288 1434 11 fragment fragment NN 40288 1434 12 agrees agree VBZ 40288 1434 13 , , , 40288 1434 14 so so RB 40288 1434 15 far far RB 40288 1434 16 as as IN 40288 1434 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1434 18 extends extend VBZ 40288 1434 19 , , , 40288 1434 20 with with IN 40288 1434 21 two two CD 40288 1434 22 of of IN 40288 1434 23 the the DT 40288 1434 24 scales scale NNS 40288 1434 25 now now RB 40288 1434 26 in in IN 40288 1434 27 question question NN 40288 1434 28 , , , 40288 1434 29 viz viz NN 40288 1434 30 . . . 40288 1435 1 the the DT 40288 1435 2 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1435 3 and and CC 40288 1435 4 the the DT 40288 1435 5 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1435 6 . . . 40288 1436 1 Taking take VBG 40288 1436 2 the the DT 40288 1436 3 view view NN 40288 1436 4 of of IN 40288 1436 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1436 6 tonality tonality NN 40288 1436 7 expressed express VBN 40288 1436 8 in in IN 40288 1436 9 the the DT 40288 1436 10 last last JJ 40288 1436 11 chapter chapter NN 40288 1436 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1436 13 p. p. NN 40288 1436 14 93 93 CD 40288 1436 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1436 16 , , , 40288 1436 17 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1436 18 should should MD 40288 1436 19 describe describe VB 40288 1436 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1436 21 as as IN 40288 1436 22 the the DT 40288 1436 23 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1436 24 scale scale NN 40288 1436 25 of of IN 40288 1436 26 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1436 27 with with IN 40288 1436 28 the the DT 40288 1436 29 two two CD 40288 1436 30 highest high JJS 40288 1436 31 notes note NNS 40288 1436 32 omitted omit VBD 40288 1436 33 . . . 40288 1437 1 The the DT 40288 1437 2 omission omission NN 40288 1437 3 , , , 40288 1437 4 in in IN 40288 1437 5 so so RB 40288 1437 6 short short JJ 40288 1437 7 a a DT 40288 1437 8 fragment fragment NN 40288 1437 9 , , , 40288 1437 10 is be VBZ 40288 1437 11 of of IN 40288 1437 12 little little JJ 40288 1437 13 weight weight NN 40288 1437 14 ; ; : 40288 1437 15 and and CC 40288 1437 16 the the DT 40288 1437 17 agreement agreement NN 40288 1437 18 in in IN 40288 1437 19 the the DT 40288 1437 20 use use NN 40288 1437 21 of of IN 40288 1437 22 an an DT 40288 1437 23 additional additional JJ 40288 1437 24 lower low JJR 40288 1437 25 note note NN 40288 1437 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1437 27 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 1437 28 - - HYPH 40288 1437 29 hypatê hypatê NNP 40288 1437 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1437 31 is be VBZ 40288 1437 32 certainly certainly RB 40288 1437 33 worth worth JJ 40288 1437 34 notice notice NN 40288 1437 35 . . . 40288 1438 1 On on IN 40288 1438 2 the the DT 40288 1438 3 other other JJ 40288 1438 4 hand hand NN 40288 1438 5 , , , 40288 1438 6 the the DT 40288 1438 7 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1438 8 is be VBZ 40288 1438 9 precisely precisely RB 40288 1438 10 the the DT 40288 1438 11 mode mode NN 40288 1438 12 , , , 40288 1438 13 of of IN 40288 1438 14 those those DT 40288 1438 15 given give VBN 40288 1438 16 in in IN 40288 1438 17 the the DT 40288 1438 18 list list NN 40288 1438 19 of of IN 40288 1438 20 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1438 21 , , , 40288 1438 22 which which WDT 40288 1438 23 least least JJS 40288 1438 24 needs need VBZ 40288 1438 25 defence defence NN 40288 1438 26 , , , 40288 1438 27 as as IN 40288 1438 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1438 29 is be VBZ 40288 1438 30 the the DT 40288 1438 31 most most RBS 40288 1438 32 faithful faithful JJ 40288 1438 33 copy copy NN 40288 1438 34 of of IN 40288 1438 35 the the DT 40288 1438 36 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1438 37 System System NNP 40288 1438 38 . . . 40288 1439 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1439 2 the the DT 40288 1439 3 fact fact NN 40288 1439 4 that that IN 40288 1439 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1439 6 is be VBZ 40288 1439 7 verified verify VBN 40288 1439 8 by by IN 40288 1439 9 an an DT 40288 1439 10 actual actual JJ 40288 1439 11 piece piece NN 40288 1439 12 of of IN 40288 1439 13 music music NN 40288 1439 14 does do VBZ 40288 1439 15 not not RB 40288 1439 16 go go VB 40288 1439 17 far far RB 40288 1439 18 in in IN 40288 1439 19 support support NN 40288 1439 20 of of IN 40288 1439 21 the the DT 40288 1439 22 other other JJ 40288 1439 23 scales scale NNS 40288 1439 24 in in IN 40288 1439 25 the the DT 40288 1439 26 same same JJ 40288 1439 27 list list NN 40288 1439 28 . . . 40288 1440 1 If if IN 40288 1440 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1440 3 suspicions suspicion NNS 40288 1440 4 are be VBP 40288 1440 5 well well RB 40288 1440 6 - - HYPH 40288 1440 7 founded found VBN 40288 1440 8 , , , 40288 1440 9 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1440 10 is be VBZ 40288 1440 11 evident evident JJ 40288 1440 12 that that IN 40288 1440 13 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1440 14 seriously seriously RB 40288 1440 15 affect affect VBP 40288 1440 16 the the DT 40288 1440 17 genuineness genuineness NN 40288 1440 18 of of IN 40288 1440 19 all all PDT 40288 1440 20 the the DT 40288 1440 21 antiquarian antiquarian JJ 40288 1440 22 learning learning NN 40288 1440 23 which which WDT 40288 1440 24 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1440 25 sets set VBZ 40288 1440 26 before before IN 40288 1440 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1440 28 readers reader NNS 40288 1440 29 , , , 40288 1440 30 and and CC 40288 1440 31 in in IN 40288 1440 32 particular particular JJ 40288 1440 33 of of IN 40288 1440 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1440 35 account account NN 40288 1440 36 of of IN 40288 1440 37 the the DT 40288 1440 38 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 1440 39 modes mode NNS 40288 1440 40 . . . 40288 1441 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1441 2 venture venture VBP 40288 1441 3 to to TO 40288 1441 4 think think VB 40288 1441 5 that that IN 40288 1441 6 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1441 7 go go VBP 40288 1441 8 far far RB 40288 1441 9 to to TO 40288 1441 10 deprive deprive VB 40288 1441 11 that that DT 40288 1441 12 account account NN 40288 1441 13 of of IN 40288 1441 14 the the DT 40288 1441 15 value value NN 40288 1441 16 which which WDT 40288 1441 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1441 18 has have VBZ 40288 1441 19 been be VBN 40288 1441 20 supposed suppose VBN 40288 1441 21 to to TO 40288 1441 22 have have VB 40288 1441 23 for for IN 40288 1441 24 the the DT 40288 1441 25 history history NN 40288 1441 26 of of IN 40288 1441 27 the the DT 40288 1441 28 earliest early JJS 40288 1441 29 Greek greek JJ 40288 1441 30 music music NN 40288 1441 31 . . . 40288 1442 1 For for IN 40288 1442 2 the the DT 40288 1442 3 later later JJ 40288 1442 4 period period NN 40288 1442 5 , , , 40288 1442 6 however however RB 40288 1442 7 , , , 40288 1442 8 to to TO 40288 1442 9 which which WDT 40288 1442 10 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1442 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 1442 12 belongs belong VBZ 40288 1442 13 , , , 40288 1442 14 these these DT 40288 1442 15 apocryphal apocryphal NN 40288 1442 16 scales scale NNS 40288 1442 17 are be VBP 40288 1442 18 a a DT 40288 1442 19 document document NN 40288 1442 20 of of IN 40288 1442 21 some some DT 40288 1442 22 importance importance NN 40288 1442 23 . . . 40288 1443 1 The the DT 40288 1443 2 fact fact NN 40288 1443 3 that that IN 40288 1443 4 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1443 5 do do VBP 40288 1443 6 not not RB 40288 1443 7 agree agree VB 40288 1443 8 entirely entirely RB 40288 1443 9 with with IN 40288 1443 10 the the DT 40288 1443 11 species specie NNS 40288 1443 12 of of IN 40288 1443 13 the the DT 40288 1443 14 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1443 15 as as IN 40288 1443 16 given give VBN 40288 1443 17 by by IN 40288 1443 18 the the DT 40288 1443 19 pseudo pseudo NN 40288 1443 20 - - NNP 40288 1443 21 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 1443 22 leads lead VBZ 40288 1443 23 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1443 24 to to TO 40288 1443 25 think think VB 40288 1443 26 that that IN 40288 1443 27 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1443 28 may may MD 40288 1443 29 be be VB 40288 1443 30 influenced influence VBN 40288 1443 31 by by IN 40288 1443 32 scales scale NNS 40288 1443 33 used use VBN 40288 1443 34 in in IN 40288 1443 35 actual actual JJ 40288 1443 36 music music NN 40288 1443 37 . . . 40288 1444 1 This this DT 40288 1444 2 applies apply VBZ 40288 1444 3 especially especially RB 40288 1444 4 to to IN 40288 1444 5 the the DT 40288 1444 6 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1444 7 , , , 40288 1444 8 which which WDT 40288 1444 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1444 10 as as IN 40288 1444 11 has have VBZ 40288 1444 12 been be VBN 40288 1444 13 shown show VBN 40288 1444 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1444 15 is be VBZ 40288 1444 16 really really RB 40288 1444 17 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1444 18 . . . 40288 1445 1 The the DT 40288 1445 2 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 1445 3 , , , 40288 1445 4 again again RB 40288 1445 5 , , , 40288 1445 6 is be VBZ 40288 1445 7 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 1445 8 merely merely RB 40288 1445 9 an an DT 40288 1445 10 imperfect imperfect JJ 40288 1445 11 form form NN 40288 1445 12 of of IN 40288 1445 13 the the DT 40288 1445 14 same same JJ 40288 1445 15 scale scale NN 40288 1445 16 , , , 40288 1445 17 viz viz NN 40288 1445 18 . . . 40288 1446 1 the the DT 40288 1446 2 octave octave NN 40288 1446 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1446 4 d d NNP 40288 1446 5 - - HYPH 40288 1446 6 d d NNP 40288 1446 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1446 8 with with IN 40288 1446 9 lower low JJR 40288 1446 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1446 11 d d NNP 40288 1446 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1446 13 omitted omit VBD 40288 1446 14 . . . 40288 1447 1 And and CC 40288 1447 2 the the DT 40288 1447 3 Syntono Syntono NNP 40288 1447 4 - - HYPH 40288 1447 5 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1447 6 may may MD 40288 1447 7 be be VB 40288 1447 8 the the DT 40288 1447 9 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1447 10 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1447 11 octave octave NN 40288 1447 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1447 13 c c NNP 40288 1447 14 - - HYPH 40288 1447 15 c c NNP 40288 1447 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1447 17 with with IN 40288 1447 18 a a DT 40288 1447 19 similar similar JJ 40288 1447 20 omission omission NN 40288 1447 21 of of IN 40288 1447 22 the the DT 40288 1447 23 lower low JJR 40288 1447 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1447 25 c c NNP 40288 1447 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1447 27 . . . 40288 1448 1 § § ADD 40288 1448 2 35 35 CD 40288 1448 3 . . . 40288 1449 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1449 2 Evidence evidence NN 40288 1449 3 for for IN 40288 1449 4 Scales scale NNS 40288 1449 5 of of IN 40288 1449 6 different different JJ 40288 1449 7 species specie NNS 40288 1449 8 . . . 40288 1449 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1449 10 The the DT 40288 1449 11 object object NN 40288 1449 12 of of IN 40288 1449 13 the the DT 40288 1449 14 foregoing foregoing JJ 40288 1449 15 discussion discussion NN 40288 1449 16 has have VBZ 40288 1449 17 been be VBN 40288 1449 18 to to TO 40288 1449 19 show show VB 40288 1449 20 , , , 40288 1449 21 in in IN 40288 1449 22 the the DT 40288 1449 23 first first JJ 40288 1449 24 place place NN 40288 1449 25 , , , 40288 1449 26 that that IN 40288 1449 27 there there EX 40288 1449 28 was be VBD 40288 1449 29 no no DT 40288 1449 30 such such JJ 40288 1449 31 distinction distinction NN 40288 1449 32 in in IN 40288 1449 33 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1449 34 Greek greek JJ 40288 1449 35 music music NN 40288 1449 36 as as IN 40288 1449 37 that that DT 40288 1449 38 which which WDT 40288 1449 39 scholars scholar NNS 40288 1449 40 have have VBP 40288 1449 41 drawn draw VBN 40288 1449 42 between between IN 40288 1449 43 Modes Modes NNP 40288 1449 44 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1449 45 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1449 46 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1449 47 : : : 40288 1449 48 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1449 49 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1449 50 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1449 51 and and CC 40288 1449 52 Keys key NNS 40288 1449 53 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1449 54 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1449 55 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1449 56 : : : 40288 1449 57 tonoi tonoi NNS 40288 1449 58 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1449 59 or or CC 40288 1449 60 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1449 61 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1449 62 : : : 40288 1449 63 tropoi tropoi NNP 40288 1449 64 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1449 65 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1449 66 : : : 40288 1449 67 and and CC 40288 1449 68 , , , 40288 1449 69 in in IN 40288 1449 70 the the DT 40288 1449 71 second second JJ 40288 1449 72 place place NN 40288 1449 73 , , , 40288 1449 74 that that IN 40288 1449 75 the the DT 40288 1449 76 musical musical JJ 40288 1449 77 scales scale NNS 40288 1449 78 denoted denote VBN 40288 1449 79 by by IN 40288 1449 80 these these DT 40288 1449 81 terms term NNS 40288 1449 82 were be VBD 40288 1449 83 primarily primarily RB 40288 1449 84 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 1449 85 by by IN 40288 1449 86 difference difference NN 40288 1449 87 of of IN 40288 1449 88 _ _ NNP 40288 1449 89 pitch_,--that pitch_,--that NNP 40288 1449 90 in in IN 40288 1449 91 fact fact NN 40288 1449 92 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1449 93 were be VBD 40288 1449 94 so so RB 40288 1449 95 many many JJ 40288 1449 96 keys key NNS 40288 1449 97 of of IN 40288 1449 98 the the DT 40288 1449 99 standard standard JJ 40288 1449 100 scale scale NN 40288 1449 101 known know VBN 40288 1449 102 in in IN 40288 1449 103 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1449 104 final final JJ 40288 1449 105 form form NN 40288 1449 106 as as IN 40288 1449 107 the the DT 40288 1449 108 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1449 109 System System NNP 40288 1449 110 . . . 40288 1450 1 The the DT 40288 1450 2 evidence evidence NN 40288 1450 3 now now RB 40288 1450 4 brought bring VBD 40288 1450 5 forward forward RB 40288 1450 6 in in IN 40288 1450 7 support support NN 40288 1450 8 of of IN 40288 1450 9 these these DT 40288 1450 10 two two CD 40288 1450 11 propositions proposition NNS 40288 1450 12 is be VBZ 40288 1450 13 surely surely RB 40288 1450 14 as as RB 40288 1450 15 complete complete JJ 40288 1450 16 as as IN 40288 1450 17 that that DT 40288 1450 18 which which WDT 40288 1450 19 has have VBZ 40288 1450 20 been be VBN 40288 1450 21 allowed allow VBN 40288 1450 22 to to TO 40288 1450 23 determine determine VB 40288 1450 24 any any DT 40288 1450 25 question question NN 40288 1450 26 of of IN 40288 1450 27 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1450 28 learning learning NN 40288 1450 29 . . . 40288 1451 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1451 2 does do VBZ 40288 1451 3 not not RB 40288 1451 4 , , , 40288 1451 5 however however RB 40288 1451 6 , , , 40288 1451 7 follow follow VBP 40288 1451 8 that that IN 40288 1451 9 the the DT 40288 1451 10 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 1451 11 knew know VBD 40288 1451 12 of of IN 40288 1451 13 no no DT 40288 1451 14 musical musical JJ 40288 1451 15 forms form NNS 40288 1451 16 analogous analogous JJ 40288 1451 17 to to IN 40288 1451 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1451 19 Major Major NNP 40288 1451 20 and and CC 40288 1451 21 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1451 22 modes mode NNS 40288 1451 23 , , , 40288 1451 24 or or CC 40288 1451 25 to to IN 40288 1451 26 the the DT 40288 1451 27 mediaeval mediaeval JJ 40288 1451 28 Tones Tones NNPS 40288 1451 29 . . . 40288 1452 1 On on IN 40288 1452 2 the the DT 40288 1452 3 contrary contrary NN 40288 1452 4 , , , 40288 1452 5 the the DT 40288 1452 6 course course NN 40288 1452 7 of of IN 40288 1452 8 the the DT 40288 1452 9 discussion discussion NN 40288 1452 10 has have VBZ 40288 1452 11 led lead VBN 40288 1452 12 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1452 13 to to TO 40288 1452 14 recognise recognise VB 40288 1452 15 distinctions distinction NNS 40288 1452 16 of of IN 40288 1452 17 this this DT 40288 1452 18 kind kind NN 40288 1452 19 in in RB 40288 1452 20 more more JJR 40288 1452 21 than than IN 40288 1452 22 one one CD 40288 1452 23 instance instance NN 40288 1452 24 . . . 40288 1453 1 The the DT 40288 1453 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40288 1453 3 against against IN 40288 1453 4 which which WDT 40288 1453 5 the the DT 40288 1453 6 argument argument NN 40288 1453 7 has have VBZ 40288 1453 8 been be VBN 40288 1453 9 mainly mainly RB 40288 1453 10 directed direct VBN 40288 1453 11 is be VBZ 40288 1453 12 not not RB 40288 1453 13 that that RB 40288 1453 14 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1453 15 scales scale NNS 40288 1453 16 were be VBD 40288 1453 17 of of IN 40288 1453 18 more more JJR 40288 1453 19 than than IN 40288 1453 20 one one CD 40288 1453 21 species specie NNS 40288 1453 22 or or CC 40288 1453 23 ' ' `` 40288 1453 24 mode mode NN 40288 1453 25 ' ' '' 40288 1453 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1453 27 as as IN 40288 1453 28 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1453 29 is be VBZ 40288 1453 30 now now RB 40288 1453 31 called call VBN 40288 1453 32 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1453 33 , , , 40288 1453 34 but but CC 40288 1453 35 that that DT 40288 1453 36 difference difference NN 40288 1453 37 of of IN 40288 1453 38 species specie NNS 40288 1453 39 was be VBD 40288 1453 40 the the DT 40288 1453 41 basis basis NN 40288 1453 42 of of IN 40288 1453 43 the the DT 40288 1453 44 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1453 45 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1453 46 Modes Modes NNP 40288 1453 47 . . . 40288 1454 1 This this DT 40288 1454 2 will will MD 40288 1454 3 become become VB 40288 1454 4 clear clear JJ 40288 1454 5 if if IN 40288 1454 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1454 7 bring bring VBP 40288 1454 8 together together RB 40288 1454 9 all all PDT 40288 1454 10 the the DT 40288 1454 11 indications indication NNS 40288 1454 12 which which WDT 40288 1454 13 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1454 14 have have VBP 40288 1454 15 observed observe VBN 40288 1454 16 of of IN 40288 1454 17 scales scale NNS 40288 1454 18 differing differ VBG 40288 1454 19 from from IN 40288 1454 20 each each DT 40288 1454 21 other other JJ 40288 1454 22 in in IN 40288 1454 23 species specie NNS 40288 1454 24 , , , 40288 1454 25 that that RB 40288 1454 26 is is RB 40288 1454 27 , , , 40288 1454 28 in in IN 40288 1454 29 the the DT 40288 1454 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1454 31 order order NN 40288 1454 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1454 33 of of IN 40288 1454 34 the the DT 40288 1454 35 intervals interval NNS 40288 1454 36 in in IN 40288 1454 37 the the DT 40288 1454 38 octave octave NN 40288 1454 39 . . . 40288 1455 1 In in IN 40288 1455 2 doing do VBG 40288 1455 3 so so RB 40288 1455 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1455 5 will will MD 40288 1455 6 be be VB 40288 1455 7 especially especially RB 40288 1455 8 important important JJ 40288 1455 9 to to TO 40288 1455 10 be be VB 40288 1455 11 guided guide VBN 40288 1455 12 by by IN 40288 1455 13 the the DT 40288 1455 14 principle principle NN 40288 1455 15 which which WDT 40288 1455 16 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1455 17 laid lay VBD 40288 1455 18 down down RP 40288 1455 19 at at IN 40288 1455 20 the the DT 40288 1455 21 outset outset NN 40288 1455 22 , , , 40288 1455 23 of of IN 40288 1455 24 arranging arrange VBG 40288 1455 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1455 26 materials material NNS 40288 1455 27 according accord VBG 40288 1455 28 to to IN 40288 1455 29 chronology chronology NN 40288 1455 30 , , , 40288 1455 31 and and CC 40288 1455 32 judging judging NN 40288 1455 33 of of IN 40288 1455 34 each each DT 40288 1455 35 piece piece NN 40288 1455 36 of of IN 40288 1455 37 evidence evidence NN 40288 1455 38 strictly strictly RB 40288 1455 39 with with IN 40288 1455 40 reference reference NN 40288 1455 41 to to IN 40288 1455 42 the the DT 40288 1455 43 period period NN 40288 1455 44 to to TO 40288 1455 45 which which WDT 40288 1455 46 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1455 47 belongs belong VBZ 40288 1455 48 . . . 40288 1456 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1456 2 is be VBZ 40288 1456 3 only only RB 40288 1456 4 thus thus RB 40288 1456 5 that that IN 40288 1456 6 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1456 7 can can MD 40288 1456 8 hope hope VB 40288 1456 9 to to TO 40288 1456 10 gain gain VB 40288 1456 11 a a DT 40288 1456 12 conception conception NN 40288 1456 13 of of IN 40288 1456 14 Greek greek JJ 40288 1456 15 music music NN 40288 1456 16 as as IN 40288 1456 17 the the DT 40288 1456 18 living live VBG 40288 1456 19 and and CC 40288 1456 20 changing change VBG 40288 1456 21 thing thing NN 40288 1456 22 that that WDT 40288 1456 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1456 24 know know VBP 40288 1456 25 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1456 26 must must MD 40288 1456 27 have have VB 40288 1456 28 been be VBN 40288 1456 29 . . . 40288 1457 1 1 1 LS 40288 1457 2 . . . 40288 1458 1 The the DT 40288 1458 2 principal principal JJ 40288 1458 3 scale scale NN 40288 1458 4 of of IN 40288 1458 5 Greek greek JJ 40288 1458 6 music music NN 40288 1458 7 is be VBZ 40288 1458 8 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40288 1458 9 of of IN 40288 1458 10 the the DT 40288 1458 11 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1458 12 - - HYPH 40288 1458 13 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1458 14 or or CC 40288 1458 15 common common JJ 40288 1458 16 species specie NNS 40288 1458 17 . . . 40288 1459 1 This this DT 40288 1459 2 is be VBZ 40288 1459 3 sufficiently sufficiently RB 40288 1459 4 proved prove VBN 40288 1459 5 by by IN 40288 1459 6 the the DT 40288 1459 7 facts fact NNS 40288 1459 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1459 9 1 1 LS 40288 1459 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1459 11 that that IN 40288 1459 12 two two CD 40288 1459 13 octaves octave NNS 40288 1459 14 of of IN 40288 1459 15 this this DT 40288 1459 16 species specie NNS 40288 1459 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1459 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1459 19 a a DT 40288 1459 20 - - : 40288 1459 21 a a DT 40288 1459 22 _ _ NN 40288 1459 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1459 24 constitute constitute VB 40288 1459 25 the the DT 40288 1459 26 scale scale NN 40288 1459 27 known know VBN 40288 1459 28 as as IN 40288 1459 29 the the DT 40288 1459 30 Greater Greater NNP 40288 1459 31 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1459 32 System System NNP 40288 1459 33 , , , 40288 1459 34 and and CC 40288 1459 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1459 36 2 2 LS 40288 1459 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1459 38 that that IN 40288 1459 39 the the DT 40288 1459 40 central central JJ 40288 1459 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1459 42 a a DT 40288 1459 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1459 44 of of IN 40288 1459 45 this this DT 40288 1459 46 system system NN 40288 1459 47 , , , 40288 1459 48 called call VBN 40288 1459 49 the the DT 40288 1459 50 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1459 51 , , , 40288 1459 52 is be VBZ 40288 1459 53 said say VBN 40288 1459 54 to to TO 40288 1459 55 have have VB 40288 1459 56 been be VBN 40288 1459 57 the the DT 40288 1459 58 key key NN 40288 1459 59 - - HYPH 40288 1459 60 note note NN 40288 1459 61 , , , 40288 1459 62 or or CC 40288 1459 63 at at IN 40288 1459 64 least least JJS 40288 1459 65 to to TO 40288 1459 66 have have VB 40288 1459 67 had have VBN 40288 1459 68 the the DT 40288 1459 69 kind kind NN 40288 1459 70 of of IN 40288 1459 71 importance importance NN 40288 1459 72 in in IN 40288 1459 73 the the DT 40288 1459 74 scale scale NN 40288 1459 75 which which WDT 40288 1459 76 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1459 77 connect connect VBP 40288 1459 78 with with IN 40288 1459 79 the the DT 40288 1459 80 key key JJ 40288 1459 81 - - HYPH 40288 1459 82 note note NN 40288 1459 83 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1459 84 Arist Arist NNP 40288 1459 85 . . . 40288 1460 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1460 2 Probl Probl NNP 40288 1460 3 . . . 40288 1460 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1460 5 xix xix NNP 40288 1460 6 . . . 40288 1461 1 20 20 CD 40288 1461 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1461 3 . . . 40288 1462 1 This this DT 40288 1462 2 mode mode NN 40288 1462 3 , , , 40288 1462 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1462 5 is be VBZ 40288 1462 6 obvious obvious JJ 40288 1462 7 , , , 40288 1462 8 is be VBZ 40288 1462 9 based base VBN 40288 1462 10 on on IN 40288 1462 11 the the DT 40288 1462 12 scale scale NN 40288 1462 13 which which WDT 40288 1462 14 is be VBZ 40288 1462 15 the the DT 40288 1462 16 descending descend VBG 40288 1462 17 scale scale NN 40288 1462 18 of of IN 40288 1462 19 the the DT 40288 1462 20 modern modern JJ 40288 1462 21 Minor minor JJ 40288 1462 22 mode mode NN 40288 1462 23 . . . 40288 1463 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1463 2 may may MD 40288 1463 3 therefore therefore RB 40288 1463 4 be be VB 40288 1463 5 identified identify VBN 40288 1463 6 with with IN 40288 1463 7 the the DT 40288 1463 8 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1463 9 , , , 40288 1463 10 except except IN 40288 1463 11 that that IN 40288 1463 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1463 13 does do VBZ 40288 1463 14 not not RB 40288 1463 15 admit admit VB 40288 1463 16 the the DT 40288 1463 17 leading leading JJ 40288 1463 18 note note NN 40288 1463 19 . . . 40288 1464 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1464 2 should should MD 40288 1464 3 be be VB 40288 1464 4 observed observe VBN 40288 1464 5 that that IN 40288 1464 6 this this DT 40288 1464 7 mode mode NN 40288 1464 8 is be VBZ 40288 1464 9 to to TO 40288 1464 10 be be VB 40288 1464 11 recognised recognise VBN 40288 1464 12 not not RB 40288 1464 13 merely merely RB 40288 1464 14 in in IN 40288 1464 15 the the DT 40288 1464 16 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1464 17 System System NNP 40288 1464 18 but but CC 40288 1464 19 equally equally RB 40288 1464 20 in in IN 40288 1464 21 the the DT 40288 1464 22 primitive primitive JJ 40288 1464 23 octave octave NN 40288 1464 24 , , , 40288 1464 25 of of IN 40288 1464 26 the the DT 40288 1464 27 form form NN 40288 1464 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1464 29 e e NNP 40288 1464 30 - - HYPH 40288 1464 31 e e NNP 40288 1464 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1464 33 , , , 40288 1464 34 out out IN 40288 1464 35 of of IN 40288 1464 36 which which WDT 40288 1464 37 the the DT 40288 1464 38 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1464 39 System System NNP 40288 1464 40 grew grow VBD 40288 1464 41 . . . 40288 1465 1 The the DT 40288 1465 2 important important JJ 40288 1465 3 point point NN 40288 1465 4 is be VBZ 40288 1465 5 the the DT 40288 1465 6 tonic tonic NN 40288 1465 7 character character NN 40288 1465 8 of of IN 40288 1465 9 the the DT 40288 1465 10 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1465 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1465 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1465 13 a a DT 40288 1465 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1465 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1465 16 , , , 40288 1465 17 and and CC 40288 1465 18 this this DT 40288 1465 19 , , , 40288 1465 20 as as IN 40288 1465 21 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1465 22 happens happen VBZ 40288 1465 23 , , , 40288 1465 24 rests rest NNS 40288 1465 25 upon upon IN 40288 1465 26 the the DT 40288 1465 27 testimony testimony NN 40288 1465 28 of of IN 40288 1465 29 an an DT 40288 1465 30 author author NN 40288 1465 31 who who WP 40288 1465 32 knows know VBZ 40288 1465 33 the the DT 40288 1465 34 primitive primitive JJ 40288 1465 35 octave octave NN 40288 1465 36 only only RB 40288 1465 37 . . . 40288 1466 1 The the DT 40288 1466 2 fact fact NN 40288 1466 3 that that IN 40288 1466 4 that that DT 40288 1466 5 octave octave NN 40288 1466 6 is be VBZ 40288 1466 7 of of IN 40288 1466 8 the the DT 40288 1466 9 so so RB 40288 1466 10 - - HYPH 40288 1466 11 called call VBN 40288 1466 12 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1466 13 species specie NNS 40288 1466 14 does do VBZ 40288 1466 15 not not RB 40288 1466 16 alter alter VB 40288 1466 17 the the DT 40288 1466 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1466 19 mode mode NN 40288 1466 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1466 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1466 22 as as IN 40288 1466 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1466 24 are be VBP 40288 1466 25 now now RB 40288 1466 26 using use VBG 40288 1466 27 that that DT 40288 1466 28 term term NN 40288 1466 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1466 30 , , , 40288 1466 31 but but CC 40288 1466 32 only only RB 40288 1466 33 the the DT 40288 1466 34 compass compass NN 40288 1466 35 of of IN 40288 1466 36 the the DT 40288 1466 37 notes note NNS 40288 1466 38 employed employ VBN 40288 1466 39 . . . 40288 1467 1 The the DT 40288 1467 2 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1467 3 - - HYPH 40288 1467 4 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1467 5 octave octave NN 40288 1467 6 is be VBZ 40288 1467 7 seen see VBN 40288 1467 8 in in IN 40288 1467 9 two two CD 40288 1467 10 of of IN 40288 1467 11 the the DT 40288 1467 12 scales scale NNS 40288 1467 13 of of IN 40288 1467 14 the the DT 40288 1467 15 cithara cithara NN 40288 1467 16 given give VBN 40288 1467 17 by by IN 40288 1467 18 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1467 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1467 20 p. p. NN 40288 1467 21 85 85 CD 40288 1467 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1467 23 , , , 40288 1467 24 viz viz NN 40288 1467 25 . . . 40288 1468 1 those those DT 40288 1468 2 called call VBN 40288 1468 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1468 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1468 5 : : : 40288 1468 6 tritai tritai NNP 40288 1468 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1468 8 and and CC 40288 1468 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1468 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1468 11 : : : 40288 1468 12 tropoi tropoi NNP 40288 1468 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1468 14 , , , 40288 1468 15 and and CC 40288 1468 16 the the DT 40288 1468 17 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1468 18 octave octave NN 40288 1468 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1468 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1468 21 e e NNP 40288 1468 22 - - HYPH 40288 1468 23 e e NNP 40288 1468 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1468 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1468 26 in in IN 40288 1468 27 two two CD 40288 1468 28 scales scale NNS 40288 1468 29 , , , 40288 1468 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1468 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1468 32 : : : 40288 1468 33 parupatai parupatai NN 40288 1468 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1468 35 and and CC 40288 1468 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1468 37 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1468 38 : : : 40288 1468 39 ludia ludia NN 40288 1468 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1468 41 . . . 40288 1469 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1469 2 is be VBZ 40288 1469 3 very very RB 40288 1469 4 possible possible JJ 40288 1469 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1469 6 as as IN 40288 1469 7 was be VBD 40288 1469 8 observed observe VBN 40288 1469 9 in in IN 40288 1469 10 commenting comment VBG 40288 1469 11 on on IN 40288 1469 12 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1469 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1469 14 that that IN 40288 1469 15 the the DT 40288 1469 16 two two CD 40288 1469 17 latter latter JJ 40288 1469 18 scales scale NNS 40288 1469 19 were be VBD 40288 1469 20 in in IN 40288 1469 21 the the DT 40288 1469 22 key key NN 40288 1469 23 of of IN 40288 1469 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1469 25 a a DT 40288 1469 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1469 27 , , , 40288 1469 28 and and CC 40288 1469 29 therefore therefore RB 40288 1469 30 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1469 31 - - HYPH 40288 1469 32 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1469 33 in in IN 40288 1469 34 respect respect NN 40288 1469 35 of of IN 40288 1469 36 mode mode NN 40288 1469 37 . . . 40288 1470 1 The the DT 40288 1470 2 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1470 3 - - HYPH 40288 1470 4 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1470 5 mode mode NN 40288 1470 6 is be VBZ 40288 1470 7 also also RB 40288 1470 8 exemplified exemplify VBN 40288 1470 9 by by IN 40288 1470 10 three three CD 40288 1470 11 at at IN 40288 1470 12 least least JJS 40288 1470 13 of of IN 40288 1470 14 the the DT 40288 1470 15 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1470 16 passages passage NNS 40288 1470 17 given give VBN 40288 1470 18 by by IN 40288 1470 19 the the DT 40288 1470 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1470 21 Anonymus Anonymus NNP 40288 1470 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1470 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1470 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1470 25 supra supra NNP 40288 1470 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1470 27 , , , 40288 1470 28 p. p. NN 40288 1470 29 89 89 CD 40288 1470 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1470 31 . . . 40288 1471 1 2 2 LS 40288 1471 2 . . . 40288 1472 1 The the DT 40288 1472 2 earliest early JJS 40288 1472 3 trace trace NN 40288 1472 4 of of IN 40288 1472 5 a a DT 40288 1472 6 difference difference NN 40288 1472 7 of of IN 40288 1472 8 species specie NNS 40288 1472 9 appears appear VBZ 40288 1472 10 to to TO 40288 1472 11 be be VB 40288 1472 12 found find VBN 40288 1472 13 in in IN 40288 1472 14 the the DT 40288 1472 15 passage passage NN 40288 1472 16 on on IN 40288 1472 17 the the DT 40288 1472 18 subject subject NN 40288 1472 19 of of IN 40288 1472 20 the the DT 40288 1472 21 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1472 22 - - HYPH 40288 1472 23 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1472 24 mode mode NN 40288 1472 25 quoted quote VBN 40288 1472 26 above above RB 40288 1472 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1472 28 p. p. NN 40288 1472 29 24 24 CD 40288 1472 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1472 31 from from IN 40288 1472 32 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 1472 33 's 's POS 40288 1472 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1472 35 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40288 1472 36 on on IN 40288 1472 37 Music Music NNP 40288 1472 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1472 39 . . . 40288 1473 1 In in IN 40288 1473 2 that that DT 40288 1473 3 mode mode NN 40288 1473 4 , , , 40288 1473 5 according accord VBG 40288 1473 6 to to IN 40288 1473 7 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 1473 8 , , , 40288 1473 9 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1473 10 was be VBD 40288 1473 11 discovered discover VBN 40288 1473 12 by by IN 40288 1473 13 a a DT 40288 1473 14 certain certain JJ 40288 1473 15 Lamprocles Lamprocles NNPS 40288 1473 16 of of IN 40288 1473 17 Athens Athens NNP 40288 1473 18 that that IN 40288 1473 19 the the DT 40288 1473 20 Disjunctive Disjunctive NNP 40288 1473 21 Tone Tone NNP 40288 1473 22 was be VBD 40288 1473 23 the the DT 40288 1473 24 highest high JJS 40288 1473 25 interval interval NN 40288 1473 26 , , , 40288 1473 27 that that DT 40288 1473 28 is be VBZ 40288 1473 29 to to TO 40288 1473 30 say say VB 40288 1473 31 , , , 40288 1473 32 that that IN 40288 1473 33 the the DT 40288 1473 34 octave octave NN 40288 1473 35 in in IN 40288 1473 36 reality reality NN 40288 1473 37 consisted consist VBN 40288 1473 38 of of IN 40288 1473 39 two two CD 40288 1473 40 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 1473 41 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1473 42 and and CC 40288 1473 43 a a DT 40288 1473 44 tone tone NN 40288 1473 45 : : : 40288 1473 46 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1473 47 Music music NN 40288 1473 48 : : : 40288 1473 49 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1473 50 Disj Disj NNP 40288 1473 51 . . . 40288 1474 1 Tone tone NN 40288 1474 2 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1474 3 As as IN 40288 1474 4 the the DT 40288 1474 5 note note NN 40288 1474 6 which which WDT 40288 1474 7 is be VBZ 40288 1474 8 the the DT 40288 1474 9 meeting meeting NN 40288 1474 10 - - HYPH 40288 1474 11 point point NN 40288 1474 12 of of IN 40288 1474 13 the the DT 40288 1474 14 two two CD 40288 1474 15 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1474 16 is be VBZ 40288 1474 17 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 1474 18 the the DT 40288 1474 19 key key NN 40288 1474 20 - - HYPH 40288 1474 21 note note NN 40288 1474 22 , , , 40288 1474 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1474 24 shall shall MD 40288 1474 25 not not RB 40288 1474 26 be be VB 40288 1474 27 wrong wrong JJ 40288 1474 28 in in IN 40288 1474 29 making make VBG 40288 1474 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1474 31 the the DT 40288 1474 32 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1474 33 , , , 40288 1474 34 and and CC 40288 1474 35 thus thus RB 40288 1474 36 finding find VBG 40288 1474 37 the the DT 40288 1474 38 octave octave NN 40288 1474 39 in in IN 40288 1474 40 question question NN 40288 1474 41 in in IN 40288 1474 42 the the DT 40288 1474 43 Perfect Perfect NNP 40288 1474 44 System System NNP 40288 1474 45 and and CC 40288 1474 46 in in IN 40288 1474 47 the the DT 40288 1474 48 oldest old JJS 40288 1474 49 part part NN 40288 1474 50 of of IN 40288 1474 51 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1474 52 , , , 40288 1474 53 viz viz NN 40288 1474 54 . . . 40288 1475 1 the the DT 40288 1475 2 tetrachords tetrachords NNPS 40288 1475 3 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1475 4 and and CC 40288 1475 5 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 1475 6 , , , 40288 1475 7 with with IN 40288 1475 8 the the DT 40288 1475 9 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1475 10 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1475 11 . . . 40288 1476 1 How how WRB 40288 1476 2 then then RB 40288 1476 3 did do VBD 40288 1476 4 this this DT 40288 1476 5 octave octave NN 40288 1476 6 come come VB 40288 1476 7 to to TO 40288 1476 8 be be VB 40288 1476 9 recognised recognise VBN 40288 1476 10 by by IN 40288 1476 11 Lamprocles lamprocle NNS 40288 1476 12 as as RB 40288 1476 13 distinctively distinctively RB 40288 1476 14 Mixo mixo NN 40288 1476 15 - - HYPH 40288 1476 16 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1476 17 ? ? . 40288 1477 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1477 2 can can MD 40288 1477 3 not not RB 40288 1477 4 tell tell VB 40288 1477 5 with with IN 40288 1477 6 certainty certainty NN 40288 1477 7 , , , 40288 1477 8 because because IN 40288 1477 9 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1477 10 do do VBP 40288 1477 11 not not RB 40288 1477 12 know know VB 40288 1477 13 what what WP 40288 1477 14 the the DT 40288 1477 15 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1477 16 - - HYPH 40288 1477 17 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1477 18 scale scale NN 40288 1477 19 was be VBD 40288 1477 20 before before IN 40288 1477 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1477 22 treatment treatment NN 40288 1477 23 of of IN 40288 1477 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1477 25 . . . 40288 1478 1 Probably probably RB 40288 1478 2 , , , 40288 1478 3 however however RB 40288 1478 4 , , , 40288 1478 5 the the DT 40288 1478 6 answer answer NN 40288 1478 7 is be VBZ 40288 1478 8 to to TO 40288 1478 9 be be VB 40288 1478 10 sought seek VBN 40288 1478 11 in in IN 40288 1478 12 the the DT 40288 1478 13 relation relation NN 40288 1478 14 in in IN 40288 1478 15 respect respect NN 40288 1478 16 of of IN 40288 1478 17 pitch pitch NN 40288 1478 18 between between IN 40288 1478 19 the the DT 40288 1478 20 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1478 21 and and CC 40288 1478 22 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1478 23 - - HYPH 40288 1478 24 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1478 25 keys key NNS 40288 1478 26 . . . 40288 1479 1 These these DT 40288 1479 2 , , , 40288 1479 3 as as IN 40288 1479 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1479 5 have have VBP 40288 1479 6 seen see VBN 40288 1479 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1479 8 p. p. NN 40288 1479 9 23 23 CD 40288 1479 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1479 11 , , , 40288 1479 12 were be VBD 40288 1479 13 the the DT 40288 1479 14 keys key NNS 40288 1479 15 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 1479 16 employed employ VBN 40288 1479 17 in in IN 40288 1479 18 tragedy tragedy NN 40288 1479 19 , , , 40288 1479 20 and and CC 40288 1479 21 the the DT 40288 1479 22 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1479 23 - - HYPH 40288 1479 24 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1479 25 was be VBD 40288 1479 26 a a DT 40288 1479 27 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1479 28 higher high JJR 40288 1479 29 than than IN 40288 1479 30 the the DT 40288 1479 31 other other JJ 40288 1479 32 . . . 40288 1480 1 Now now RB 40288 1480 2 when when WRB 40288 1480 3 a a DT 40288 1480 4 scale scale NN 40288 1480 5 consisting consist VBG 40288 1480 6 of of IN 40288 1480 7 white white JJ 40288 1480 8 notes note NNS 40288 1480 9 is be VBZ 40288 1480 10 transposed transpose VBN 40288 1480 11 to to IN 40288 1480 12 a a DT 40288 1480 13 key key NN 40288 1480 14 a a DT 40288 1480 15 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1480 16 higher high JJR 40288 1480 17 , , , 40288 1480 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1480 19 becomes become VBZ 40288 1480 20 a a DT 40288 1480 21 scale scale NN 40288 1480 22 with with IN 40288 1480 23 one one CD 40288 1480 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1480 25 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1480 26 : : : 40288 1480 27 Flat flat JJ 40288 1480 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1480 29 . . . 40288 1481 1 In in IN 40288 1481 2 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1481 3 language language NN 40288 1481 4 , , , 40288 1481 5 the the DT 40288 1481 6 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1481 7 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 1481 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1481 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1481 10 a a DT 40288 1481 11 - - HYPH 40288 1481 12 b[Symbol b[symbol NN 40288 1481 13 : : : 40288 1481 14 Flat]-c Flat]-c NNP 40288 1481 15 - - HYPH 40288 1481 16 d d NNP 40288 1481 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1481 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1481 19 takes take VBZ 40288 1481 20 the the DT 40288 1481 21 place place NN 40288 1481 22 of of IN 40288 1481 23 the the DT 40288 1481 24 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1481 25 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1481 26 . . . 40288 1482 1 In in IN 40288 1482 2 some some DT 40288 1482 3 such such JJ 40288 1482 4 way way NN 40288 1482 5 as as IN 40288 1482 6 this this DT 40288 1482 7 the the DT 40288 1482 8 octave octave NN 40288 1482 9 of of IN 40288 1482 10 this this DT 40288 1482 11 form form NN 40288 1482 12 may may MD 40288 1482 13 have have VB 40288 1482 14 come come VBN 40288 1482 15 to to TO 40288 1482 16 be be VB 40288 1482 17 associated associate VBN 40288 1482 18 in in IN 40288 1482 19 a a DT 40288 1482 20 special special JJ 40288 1482 21 way way NN 40288 1482 22 with with IN 40288 1482 23 the the DT 40288 1482 24 use use NN 40288 1482 25 of of IN 40288 1482 26 the the DT 40288 1482 27 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1482 28 - - HYPH 40288 1482 29 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1482 30 key key NN 40288 1482 31 . . . 40288 1483 1 However however RB 40288 1483 2 this this DT 40288 1483 3 may may MD 40288 1483 4 be be VB 40288 1483 5 , , , 40288 1483 6 the the DT 40288 1483 7 change change NN 40288 1483 8 from from IN 40288 1483 9 the the DT 40288 1483 10 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1483 11 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1483 12 to to IN 40288 1483 13 the the DT 40288 1483 14 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1483 15 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 1483 16 , , , 40288 1483 17 or or CC 40288 1483 18 the the DT 40288 1483 19 reverse reverse NN 40288 1483 20 , , , 40288 1483 21 is be VBZ 40288 1483 22 a a DT 40288 1483 23 change change NN 40288 1483 24 of of IN 40288 1483 25 mode mode NN 40288 1483 26 in in IN 40288 1483 27 the the DT 40288 1483 28 modern modern JJ 40288 1483 29 sense sense NN 40288 1483 30 , , , 40288 1483 31 for for IN 40288 1483 32 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1483 33 is be VBZ 40288 1483 34 what what WP 40288 1483 35 the the DT 40288 1483 36 ancients ancient NNS 40288 1483 37 classified classify VBD 40288 1483 38 as as IN 40288 1483 39 a a DT 40288 1483 40 change change NN 40288 1483 41 of of IN 40288 1483 42 System system NN 40288 1483 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1483 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1483 45 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1483 46 : : : 40288 1483 47 metabolê metabolê NN 40288 1483 48 kata kata NNP 40288 1483 49 systêma])[1 systêma])[1 XX 40288 1483 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1483 51 . . . 40288 1484 1 Nor nor CC 40288 1484 2 is be VBZ 40288 1484 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1484 4 hard hard JJ 40288 1484 5 to to TO 40288 1484 6 determine determine VB 40288 1484 7 the the DT 40288 1484 8 two two CD 40288 1484 9 ' ' `` 40288 1484 10 modes mode NNS 40288 1484 11 ' ' POS 40288 1484 12 concerned concern VBN 40288 1484 13 , , , 40288 1484 14 if if IN 40288 1484 15 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1484 16 may may MD 40288 1484 17 trust trust VB 40288 1484 18 to to IN 40288 1484 19 the the DT 40288 1484 20 authority authority NN 40288 1484 21 of of IN 40288 1484 22 the the DT 40288 1484 23 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 1484 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1484 25 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1484 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1484 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1484 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1484 29 l l NNP 40288 1484 30 . . . 40288 1485 1 c. c. NNP 40288 1485 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1485 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1485 4 and and CC 40288 1485 5 regard regard VB 40288 1485 6 the the DT 40288 1485 7 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1485 8 as as IN 40288 1485 9 always always RB 40288 1485 10 the the DT 40288 1485 11 key key JJ 40288 1485 12 - - HYPH 40288 1485 13 note note NN 40288 1485 14 . . . 40288 1486 1 For for IN 40288 1486 2 if if IN 40288 1486 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1486 4 a a DT 40288 1486 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1486 6 is be VBZ 40288 1486 7 kept keep VBN 40288 1486 8 as as IN 40288 1486 9 the the DT 40288 1486 10 key key NN 40288 1486 11 - - HYPH 40288 1486 12 note note NN 40288 1486 13 , , , 40288 1486 14 the the DT 40288 1486 15 octave octave NN 40288 1486 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1486 17 a a DT 40288 1486 18 - - : 40288 1486 19 a a FW 40288 1486 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1486 21 with with IN 40288 1486 22 one one CD 40288 1486 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1486 24 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1486 25 : : : 40288 1486 26 b b LS 40288 1486 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1486 28 is be VBZ 40288 1486 29 the the DT 40288 1486 30 so so RB 40288 1486 31 - - HYPH 40288 1486 32 called call VBN 40288 1486 33 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1486 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1486 35 _ _ NNP 40288 1486 36 e e NNP 40288 1486 37 - - HYPH 40288 1486 38 e e NNP 40288 1486 39 _ _ NNP 40288 1486 40 on on IN 40288 1486 41 the the DT 40288 1486 42 white white JJ 40288 1486 43 notes note NNS 40288 1486 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1486 45 . . . 40288 1487 1 In in IN 40288 1487 2 this this DT 40288 1487 3 way way NN 40288 1487 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1487 5 arrive arrive VBP 40288 1487 6 at at IN 40288 1487 7 the the DT 40288 1487 8 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 1487 9 confusing confusing JJ 40288 1487 10 result result NN 40288 1487 11 that that IN 40288 1487 12 the the DT 40288 1487 13 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1487 14 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1487 15 species specie NNS 40288 1487 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1487 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1487 18 e e NNP 40288 1487 19 - - HYPH 40288 1487 20 e e NNP 40288 1487 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1487 22 but but CC 40288 1487 23 with with IN 40288 1487 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1487 25 a a DT 40288 1487 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1487 27 as as IN 40288 1487 28 key key JJ 40288 1487 29 - - HYPH 40288 1487 30 note note NN 40288 1487 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1487 32 yields yield VBZ 40288 1487 33 the the DT 40288 1487 34 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1487 35 - - HYPH 40288 1487 36 dorian dorian JJ 40288 1487 37 or or CC 40288 1487 38 modern modern JJ 40288 1487 39 Minor minor JJ 40288 1487 40 mode mode NN 40288 1487 41 : : : 40288 1487 42 while while IN 40288 1487 43 the the DT 40288 1487 44 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1487 45 mode mode NN 40288 1487 46 of of IN 40288 1487 47 modern modern JJ 40288 1487 48 scientific scientific JJ 40288 1487 49 theory[2 theory[2 FW 40288 1487 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1487 51 has have VBZ 40288 1487 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1487 53 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1487 54 prototype prototype NN 40288 1487 55 in in IN 40288 1487 56 the the DT 40288 1487 57 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1487 58 - - HYPH 40288 1487 59 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1487 60 species specie NNS 40288 1487 61 , , , 40288 1487 62 viz viz NN 40288 1487 63 . . . 40288 1488 1 the the DT 40288 1488 2 octave octave NN 40288 1488 3 first first RB 40288 1488 4 brought bring VBN 40288 1488 5 to to IN 40288 1488 6 light light NN 40288 1488 7 by by IN 40288 1488 8 Lamprocles lamprocle NNS 40288 1488 9 . . . 40288 1489 1 The the DT 40288 1489 2 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 1489 3 of of IN 40288 1489 4 course course NN 40288 1489 5 arises arise VBZ 40288 1489 6 from from IN 40288 1489 7 the the DT 40288 1489 8 species specie NNS 40288 1489 9 of of IN 40288 1489 10 the the DT 40288 1489 11 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1489 12 being be VBG 40288 1489 13 classified classify VBN 40288 1489 14 according accord VBG 40288 1489 15 to to IN 40288 1489 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1489 17 compass compass NN 40288 1489 18 , , , 40288 1489 19 without without IN 40288 1489 20 reference reference NN 40288 1489 21 to to IN 40288 1489 22 the the DT 40288 1489 23 tonic tonic NN 40288 1489 24 character character NN 40288 1489 25 of of IN 40288 1489 26 the the DT 40288 1489 27 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1489 28 . . . 40288 1490 1 The the DT 40288 1490 2 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1490 3 mode mode NN 40288 1490 4 is be VBZ 40288 1490 5 amply amply RB 40288 1490 6 represented represent VBN 40288 1490 7 in in IN 40288 1490 8 the the DT 40288 1490 9 extant extant JJ 40288 1490 10 remains remain NNS 40288 1490 11 of of IN 40288 1490 12 Greek greek JJ 40288 1490 13 music music NN 40288 1490 14 . . . 40288 1491 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1491 2 is be VBZ 40288 1491 3 the the DT 40288 1491 4 mode mode NN 40288 1491 5 of of IN 40288 1491 6 the the DT 40288 1491 7 two two CD 40288 1491 8 compositions composition NNS 40288 1491 9 of of IN 40288 1491 10 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1491 11 , , , 40288 1491 12 the the DT 40288 1491 13 Hymn Hymn NNP 40288 1491 14 to to IN 40288 1491 15 Calliope Calliope NNP 40288 1491 16 and and CC 40288 1491 17 the the DT 40288 1491 18 Hymn Hymn NNP 40288 1491 19 to to IN 40288 1491 20 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 1491 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1491 22 p. p. NN 40288 1491 23 88 88 CD 40288 1491 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1491 25 , , , 40288 1491 26 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 1491 27 also also RB 40288 1491 28 of of IN 40288 1491 29 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1491 30 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1491 31 's 's POS 40288 1491 32 musical musical JJ 40288 1491 33 inscription inscription NN 40288 1491 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1491 35 p. p. NN 40288 1491 36 90 90 CD 40288 1491 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1491 38 . . . 40288 1492 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1492 2 would would MD 40288 1492 3 have have VB 40288 1492 4 been be VBN 40288 1492 5 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40288 1492 6 if if IN 40288 1492 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1492 8 could could MD 40288 1492 9 have have VB 40288 1492 10 found find VBN 40288 1492 11 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1492 12 in in IN 40288 1492 13 the the DT 40288 1492 14 much much RB 40288 1492 15 more more RBR 40288 1492 16 important important JJ 40288 1492 17 fragment fragment NN 40288 1492 18 of of IN 40288 1492 19 the the DT 40288 1492 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1492 21 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1492 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1492 23 . . . 40288 1493 1 Such such JJ 40288 1493 2 indications indication NNS 40288 1493 3 as as IN 40288 1493 4 that that DT 40288 1493 5 fragment fragment NN 40288 1493 6 presents present NNS 40288 1493 7 seem seem VBP 40288 1493 8 to to IN 40288 1493 9 me -PRON- PRP 40288 1493 10 to to TO 40288 1493 11 point point VB 40288 1493 12 to to IN 40288 1493 13 the the DT 40288 1493 14 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1493 15 mode mode NN 40288 1493 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1493 17 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1493 18 - - HYPH 40288 1493 19 lydian lydian NN 40288 1493 20 of of IN 40288 1493 21 Lamprocles Lamprocles NNPS 40288 1493 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1493 23 . . . 40288 1494 1 3 3 LS 40288 1494 2 . . . 40288 1495 1 The the DT 40288 1495 2 scales scale NNS 40288 1495 3 of of IN 40288 1495 4 the the DT 40288 1495 5 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1495 6 furnish furnish NNP 40288 1495 7 one one CD 40288 1495 8 example example NN 40288 1495 9 of of IN 40288 1495 10 the the DT 40288 1495 11 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1495 12 species specie NNS 40288 1495 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1495 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1495 15 d d NNP 40288 1495 16 - - HYPH 40288 1495 17 d d NNP 40288 1495 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1495 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1495 20 , , , 40288 1495 21 and and CC 40288 1495 22 one one CD 40288 1495 23 of of IN 40288 1495 24 the the DT 40288 1495 25 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1495 26 - - HYPH 40288 1495 27 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1495 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1495 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1495 30 g g NNP 40288 1495 31 - - HYPH 40288 1495 32 g g NNP 40288 1495 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1495 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1495 35 : : : 40288 1495 36 but but CC 40288 1495 37 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1495 38 have have VBP 40288 1495 39 no no DT 40288 1495 40 means means NN 40288 1495 41 of of IN 40288 1495 42 determining determining NN 40288 1495 43 which which WDT 40288 1495 44 note note NN 40288 1495 45 of of IN 40288 1495 46 the the DT 40288 1495 47 scale scale NN 40288 1495 48 is be VBZ 40288 1495 49 to to TO 40288 1495 50 be be VB 40288 1495 51 treated treat VBN 40288 1495 52 as as IN 40288 1495 53 the the DT 40288 1495 54 key key NN 40288 1495 55 - - HYPH 40288 1495 56 note note NN 40288 1495 57 . . . 40288 1496 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1496 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1496 3 1 1 CD 40288 1496 4 : : : 40288 1496 5 Ps ps UH 40288 1496 6 . . . 40288 1497 1 Eucl eucl VB 40288 1497 2 . . . 40288 1498 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1498 2 Introd Introd NNP 40288 1498 3 . . . 40288 1498 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1498 5 p. p. NN 40288 1498 6 20 20 CD 40288 1498 7 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1498 8 . . . 40288 1499 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1499 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1499 3 : : : 40288 1499 4 kata kata NNP 40288 1499 5 systêma systêma NNP 40288 1499 6 de de NNP 40288 1499 7 hotan hotan NNP 40288 1499 8 ek ek NNP 40288 1499 9 synaphês synaphês NNP 40288 1499 10 eis eis NNP 40288 1499 11 diazeuxin diazeuxin NNP 40288 1499 12 ê ê NNP 40288 1499 13 anapalin anapalin NNP 40288 1499 14 metabolê metabolê NNP 40288 1499 15 ginêtai ginêtai NNP 40288 1499 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1499 17 . . . 40288 1500 1 Anonym anonym NN 40288 1500 2 . . . 40288 1501 1 § § ADD 40288 1501 2 65 65 CD 40288 1501 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1501 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1501 5 : : : 40288 1501 6 systêmatikai systêmatikai NNP 40288 1501 7 de de FW 40288 1501 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1501 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1501 10 sc sc IN 40288 1501 11 . . . 40288 1502 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1502 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1502 3 : : : 40288 1502 4 metabolai metabolai NNP 40288 1502 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1502 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1502 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1502 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1502 9 : : : 40288 1502 10 hopotan hopotan NNP 40288 1502 11 ek ek NNP 40288 1502 12 diazeuxeôs diazeuxeôs NNP 40288 1502 13 eis eis NNP 40288 1502 14 synaphên synaphên NNP 40288 1502 15 ê ê NNP 40288 1502 16 empalin empalin NNP 40288 1502 17 metelthê metelthê NNP 40288 1502 18 to to IN 40288 1502 19 melos melos NNP 40288 1502 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1502 21 . . . 40288 1502 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1503 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1503 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1503 3 2 2 CD 40288 1503 4 : : : 40288 1503 5 As as IN 40288 1503 6 represented represent VBN 40288 1503 7 primarily primarily RB 40288 1503 8 by by IN 40288 1503 9 the the DT 40288 1503 10 analysis analysis NN 40288 1503 11 of of IN 40288 1503 12 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1503 13 , , , 40288 1503 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1503 15 Die Die NNP 40288 1503 16 Tonempfindungen Tonempfindungen NNP 40288 1503 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1503 18 , , , 40288 1503 19 p. p. NN 40288 1503 20 467 467 CD 40288 1503 21 , , , 40288 1503 22 ed ed NNP 40288 1503 23 . . . 40288 1504 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 1504 2 . . . 40288 1504 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1505 1 In in IN 40288 1505 2 the the DT 40288 1505 3 Hymn Hymn NNP 40288 1505 4 to to IN 40288 1505 5 Nemesis Nemesis NNP 40288 1505 6 , , , 40288 1505 7 however however RB 40288 1505 8 , , , 40288 1505 9 in in IN 40288 1505 10 spite spite NN 40288 1505 11 of of IN 40288 1505 12 the the DT 40288 1505 13 incomplete incomplete JJ 40288 1505 14 form form NN 40288 1505 15 in in IN 40288 1505 16 which which WDT 40288 1505 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1505 18 has have VBZ 40288 1505 19 reached reach VBN 40288 1505 20 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1505 21 , , , 40288 1505 22 there there EX 40288 1505 23 is be VBZ 40288 1505 24 a a DT 40288 1505 25 sufficiently sufficiently RB 40288 1505 26 clear clear JJ 40288 1505 27 example example NN 40288 1505 28 of of IN 40288 1505 29 the the DT 40288 1505 30 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1505 31 - - HYPH 40288 1505 32 phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1505 33 mode mode NN 40288 1505 34 . . . 40288 1506 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1506 2 has have VBZ 40288 1506 3 been be VBN 40288 1506 4 suggested suggest VBN 40288 1506 5 as as IN 40288 1506 6 possible possible JJ 40288 1506 7 that that IN 40288 1506 8 the the DT 40288 1506 9 melody melody NN 40288 1506 10 of of IN 40288 1506 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1506 12 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1506 13 's 's POS 40288 1506 14 inscription inscription NN 40288 1506 15 is be VBZ 40288 1506 16 also also RB 40288 1506 17 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1506 18 - - HYPH 40288 1506 19 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1506 20 , , , 40288 1506 21 and and CC 40288 1506 22 if if IN 40288 1506 23 so so RB 40288 1506 24 the the DT 40288 1506 25 evidence evidence NN 40288 1506 26 for for IN 40288 1506 27 the the DT 40288 1506 28 mode mode NN 40288 1506 29 would would MD 40288 1506 30 be be VB 40288 1506 31 carried carry VBN 40288 1506 32 back back RB 40288 1506 33 to to IN 40288 1506 34 the the DT 40288 1506 35 first first JJ 40288 1506 36 century century NN 40288 1506 37 . . . 40288 1507 1 The the DT 40288 1507 2 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1507 3 - - HYPH 40288 1507 4 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1507 5 is be VBZ 40288 1507 6 the the DT 40288 1507 7 nearest near JJS 40288 1507 8 approach approach NN 40288 1507 9 made make VBN 40288 1507 10 by by IN 40288 1507 11 any any DT 40288 1507 12 specimen speciman NNS 40288 1507 13 of of IN 40288 1507 14 Greek greek JJ 40288 1507 15 music music NN 40288 1507 16 to to IN 40288 1507 17 the the DT 40288 1507 18 modern modern JJ 40288 1507 19 Major Major NNP 40288 1507 20 mode,--the mode,--the DT 40288 1507 21 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1507 22 or or CC 40288 1507 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1507 24 c_-species c_-species NNP 40288 1507 25 not not RB 40288 1507 26 being be VBG 40288 1507 27 found find VBN 40288 1507 28 even even RB 40288 1507 29 among among IN 40288 1507 30 the the DT 40288 1507 31 scales scale NNS 40288 1507 32 of of IN 40288 1507 33 the the DT 40288 1507 34 cithara cithara NN 40288 1507 35 as as IN 40288 1507 36 given give VBN 40288 1507 37 by by IN 40288 1507 38 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1507 39 . . . 40288 1508 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1508 2 is be VBZ 40288 1508 3 therefore therefore RB 40288 1508 4 of of IN 40288 1508 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 1508 6 interest interest NN 40288 1508 7 for for IN 40288 1508 8 musical musical JJ 40288 1508 9 history history NN 40288 1508 10 , , , 40288 1508 11 and and CC 40288 1508 12 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1508 13 look look VBP 40288 1508 14 with with IN 40288 1508 15 eagerness eagerness NN 40288 1508 16 for for IN 40288 1508 17 any any DT 40288 1508 18 indication indication NN 40288 1508 19 which which WDT 40288 1508 20 would would MD 40288 1508 21 allow allow VB 40288 1508 22 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1508 23 to to TO 40288 1508 24 connect connect VB 40288 1508 25 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1508 26 with with IN 40288 1508 27 the the DT 40288 1508 28 classical classical JJ 40288 1508 29 period period NN 40288 1508 30 of of IN 40288 1508 31 Greek greek JJ 40288 1508 32 art art NN 40288 1508 33 . . . 40288 1509 1 One one CD 40288 1509 2 or or CC 40288 1509 3 two two CD 40288 1509 4 sayings saying NNS 40288 1509 5 of of IN 40288 1509 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1509 7 have have VBP 40288 1509 8 been be VBN 40288 1509 9 thought think VBN 40288 1509 10 to to TO 40288 1509 11 bear bear VB 40288 1509 12 upon upon IN 40288 1509 13 this this DT 40288 1509 14 issue issue NN 40288 1509 15 . . . 40288 1510 1 The the DT 40288 1510 2 most most RBS 40288 1510 3 interesting interesting JJ 40288 1510 4 is be VBZ 40288 1510 5 a a DT 40288 1510 6 passage passage NN 40288 1510 7 in in IN 40288 1510 8 the the DT 40288 1510 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1510 10 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 1510 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1510 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1510 13 iv iv UH 40288 1510 14 . . . 40288 1511 1 3 3 CD 40288 1511 2 , , , 40288 1511 3 cp cp NNP 40288 1511 4 . . . 40288 1512 1 p. p. NN 40288 1512 2 13 13 CD 40288 1512 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1512 4 , , , 40288 1512 5 where where WRB 40288 1512 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1512 7 is be VBZ 40288 1512 8 speaking speak VBG 40288 1512 9 of of IN 40288 1512 10 the the DT 40288 1512 11 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40288 1512 12 of of IN 40288 1512 13 forms form NNS 40288 1512 14 of of IN 40288 1512 15 government government NN 40288 1512 16 , , , 40288 1512 17 and and CC 40288 1512 18 showing show VBG 40288 1512 19 how how WRB 40288 1512 20 a a DT 40288 1512 21 great great JJ 40288 1512 22 number number NN 40288 1512 23 of of IN 40288 1512 24 varieties variety NNS 40288 1512 25 may may MD 40288 1512 26 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40288 1512 27 be be VB 40288 1512 28 brought bring VBN 40288 1512 29 under under IN 40288 1512 30 a a DT 40288 1512 31 few few JJ 40288 1512 32 classes class NNS 40288 1512 33 or or CC 40288 1512 34 types type NNS 40288 1512 35 . . . 40288 1513 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1513 2 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40288 1513 3 the the DT 40288 1513 4 point point NN 40288 1513 5 from from IN 40288 1513 6 the the DT 40288 1513 7 musical musical JJ 40288 1513 8 Modes mode NNS 40288 1513 9 , , , 40288 1513 10 observing observe VBG 40288 1513 11 that that IN 40288 1513 12 all all DT 40288 1513 13 constitutions constitution NNS 40288 1513 14 may may MD 40288 1513 15 be be VB 40288 1513 16 regarded regard VBN 40288 1513 17 as as IN 40288 1513 18 either either DT 40288 1513 19 oligarchical oligarchical JJ 40288 1513 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1513 21 government government NN 40288 1513 22 by by IN 40288 1513 23 a a DT 40288 1513 24 minority minority NN 40288 1513 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1513 26 or or CC 40288 1513 27 democratical democratical JJ 40288 1513 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1513 29 government government NN 40288 1513 30 by by IN 40288 1513 31 the the DT 40288 1513 32 majority majority NN 40288 1513 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1513 34 , , , 40288 1513 35 just just RB 40288 1513 36 as as IN 40288 1513 37 in in IN 40288 1513 38 the the DT 40288 1513 39 opinion opinion NN 40288 1513 40 of of IN 40288 1513 41 some some DT 40288 1513 42 musicians musician NNS 40288 1513 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1513 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1513 45 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1513 46 : : : 40288 1513 47 hôs hôs VB 40288 1513 48 phasi phasi NN 40288 1513 49 tines tine NNS 40288 1513 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1513 51 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1513 52 all all DT 40288 1513 53 modes mode NNS 40288 1513 54 are be VBP 40288 1513 55 essentially essentially RB 40288 1513 56 either either CC 40288 1513 57 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1513 58 or or CC 40288 1513 59 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1513 60 . . . 40288 1514 1 What what WP 40288 1514 2 , , , 40288 1514 3 then then RB 40288 1514 4 , , , 40288 1514 5 is be VBZ 40288 1514 6 the the DT 40288 1514 7 basis basis NN 40288 1514 8 of of IN 40288 1514 9 this this DT 40288 1514 10 grouping grouping NN 40288 1514 11 of of IN 40288 1514 12 certain certain JJ 40288 1514 13 modes mode NNS 40288 1514 14 together together RB 40288 1514 15 as as IN 40288 1514 16 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1514 17 , , , 40288 1514 18 while while IN 40288 1514 19 the the DT 40288 1514 20 rest rest NN 40288 1514 21 are be VBP 40288 1514 22 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1514 23 in in IN 40288 1514 24 character character NN 40288 1514 25 ? ? . 40288 1515 1 According accord VBG 40288 1515 2 to to IN 40288 1515 3 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1515 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1515 5 is be VBZ 40288 1515 6 a a DT 40288 1515 7 form form NN 40288 1515 8 of of IN 40288 1515 9 the the DT 40288 1515 10 opposition opposition NN 40288 1515 11 between between IN 40288 1515 12 the the DT 40288 1515 13 true true JJ 40288 1515 14 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 40288 1515 15 music music NN 40288 1515 16 , , , 40288 1515 17 represented represent VBN 40288 1515 18 by by IN 40288 1515 19 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1515 20 , , , 40288 1515 21 and and CC 40288 1515 22 the the DT 40288 1515 23 foreign foreign JJ 40288 1515 24 music music NN 40288 1515 25 , , , 40288 1515 26 the the DT 40288 1515 27 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1515 28 and and CC 40288 1515 29 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1515 30 , , , 40288 1515 31 with with IN 40288 1515 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1515 33 varieties variety NNS 40288 1515 34 . . . 40288 1516 1 Moreover moreover RB 40288 1516 2 , , , 40288 1516 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1516 4 is be VBZ 40288 1516 5 in in IN 40288 1516 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1516 7 view view NN 40288 1516 8 virtually virtually RB 40288 1516 9 the the DT 40288 1516 10 same same JJ 40288 1516 11 distinction distinction NN 40288 1516 12 as as IN 40288 1516 13 that that DT 40288 1516 14 which which WDT 40288 1516 15 obtains obtain VBZ 40288 1516 16 in in IN 40288 1516 17 modern modern JJ 40288 1516 18 music music NN 40288 1516 19 between between IN 40288 1516 20 the the DT 40288 1516 21 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1516 22 and and CC 40288 1516 23 the the DT 40288 1516 24 Major Major NNP 40288 1516 25 scales[1 scales[1 NNP 40288 1516 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1516 27 . . . 40288 1517 1 This this DT 40288 1517 2 account account NN 40288 1517 3 of of IN 40288 1517 4 the the DT 40288 1517 5 matter matter NN 40288 1517 6 , , , 40288 1517 7 however however RB 40288 1517 8 , , , 40288 1517 9 is be VBZ 40288 1517 10 not not RB 40288 1517 11 supported support VBN 40288 1517 12 by by IN 40288 1517 13 the the DT 40288 1517 14 context context NN 40288 1517 15 of of IN 40288 1517 16 the the DT 40288 1517 17 passage passage NN 40288 1517 18 . . . 40288 1518 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1518 2 draws draw VBZ 40288 1518 3 out out RP 40288 1518 4 the the DT 40288 1518 5 comparison comparison NN 40288 1518 6 between between IN 40288 1518 7 forms form NNS 40288 1518 8 of of IN 40288 1518 9 government government NN 40288 1518 10 and and CC 40288 1518 11 musical musical JJ 40288 1518 12 modes mode NNS 40288 1518 13 in in IN 40288 1518 14 such such PDT 40288 1518 15 a a DT 40288 1518 16 way way NN 40288 1518 17 as as IN 40288 1518 18 to to TO 40288 1518 19 make make VB 40288 1518 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1518 21 plain plain JJ 40288 1518 22 that that IN 40288 1518 23 in in IN 40288 1518 24 the the DT 40288 1518 25 case case NN 40288 1518 26 of of IN 40288 1518 27 the the DT 40288 1518 28 modes mode NNS 40288 1518 29 the the DT 40288 1518 30 distinction distinction NN 40288 1518 31 was be VBD 40288 1518 32 one one CD 40288 1518 33 of of IN 40288 1518 34 pitch pitch NN 40288 1518 35 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1518 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1518 37 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1518 38 : : : 40288 1518 39 tas tas NNP 40288 1518 40 suntonôteras suntonôtera VBZ 40288 1518 41 ... ... : 40288 1518 42 tas tas NNP 40288 1518 43 d d NNP 40288 1518 44 ' ' POS 40288 1518 45 aneimenas aneimenas NNP 40288 1518 46 kai kai NNP 40288 1518 47 malakas malakas NNP 40288 1518 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1518 49 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1518 50 . . . 40288 1519 1 The the DT 40288 1519 2 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1519 3 was be VBD 40288 1519 4 the the DT 40288 1519 5 best good JJS 40288 1519 6 , , , 40288 1519 7 because because IN 40288 1519 8 the the DT 40288 1519 9 highest high JJS 40288 1519 10 , , , 40288 1519 11 of of IN 40288 1519 12 the the DT 40288 1519 13 lower low JJR 40288 1519 14 keys,--the keys,--the NNP 40288 1519 15 others other NNS 40288 1519 16 being be VBG 40288 1519 17 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1519 18 - - HYPH 40288 1519 19 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1519 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1519 21 in in IN 40288 1519 22 the the DT 40288 1519 23 earlier early JJR 40288 1519 24 sense sense NN 40288 1519 25 , , , 40288 1519 26 immediately immediately RB 40288 1519 27 below below IN 40288 1519 28 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1519 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1519 30 , , , 40288 1519 31 and and CC 40288 1519 32 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1519 33 - - HYPH 40288 1519 34 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1519 35 -- -- : 40288 1519 36 while while IN 40288 1519 37 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1519 38 was be VBD 40288 1519 39 the the DT 40288 1519 40 first first JJ 40288 1519 41 of of IN 40288 1519 42 the the DT 40288 1519 43 higher high JJR 40288 1519 44 series series NN 40288 1519 45 which which WDT 40288 1519 46 took take VBD 40288 1519 47 in in RP 40288 1519 48 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1519 49 and and CC 40288 1519 50 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1519 51 - - HYPH 40288 1519 52 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1519 53 . . . 40288 1520 1 The the DT 40288 1520 2 division division NN 40288 1520 3 would would MD 40288 1520 4 be be VB 40288 1520 5 aided aid VBN 40288 1520 6 , , , 40288 1520 7 or or CC 40288 1520 8 may may MD 40288 1520 9 even even RB 40288 1520 10 have have VB 40288 1520 11 been be VBN 40288 1520 12 suggested suggest VBN 40288 1520 13 , , , 40288 1520 14 by by IN 40288 1520 15 the the DT 40288 1520 16 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 1520 17 that that WDT 40288 1520 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1520 19 nearly nearly RB 40288 1520 20 coincided coincide VBD 40288 1520 21 with with IN 40288 1520 22 the the DT 40288 1520 23 favourite favourite JJ 40288 1520 24 contrast contrast NN 40288 1520 25 of of IN 40288 1520 26 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 40288 1520 27 and and CC 40288 1520 28 ' ' `` 40288 1520 29 barbarous barbarous JJ 40288 1520 30 ' ' '' 40288 1520 31 modes[2 modes[2 NNP 40288 1520 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1520 33 . . . 40288 1521 1 There there EX 40288 1521 2 is be VBZ 40288 1521 3 another another DT 40288 1521 4 passage passage NN 40288 1521 5 , , , 40288 1521 6 however however RB 40288 1521 7 , , , 40288 1521 8 which which WDT 40288 1521 9 can can MD 40288 1521 10 hardly hardly RB 40288 1521 11 be be VB 40288 1521 12 reconciled reconcile VBN 40288 1521 13 with with IN 40288 1521 14 a a DT 40288 1521 15 classification classification NN 40288 1521 16 according accord VBG 40288 1521 17 to to IN 40288 1521 18 pitch pitch NN 40288 1521 19 alone alone RB 40288 1521 20 . . . 40288 1522 1 In in IN 40288 1522 2 the the DT 40288 1522 3 chapters chapter NNS 40288 1522 4 dealing deal VBG 40288 1522 5 with with IN 40288 1522 6 the the DT 40288 1522 7 ethical ethical JJ 40288 1522 8 character character NN 40288 1522 9 of of IN 40288 1522 10 music music NN 40288 1522 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1522 12 dwells dwell NNS 40288 1522 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1522 14 as as IN 40288 1522 15 will will MD 40288 1522 16 be be VB 40288 1522 17 remembered remember VBN 40288 1522 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1522 19 upon upon IN 40288 1522 20 the the DT 40288 1522 21 exciting exciting JJ 40288 1522 22 and and CC 40288 1522 23 orgiastic orgiastic JJ 40288 1522 24 character character NN 40288 1522 25 of of IN 40288 1522 26 the the DT 40288 1522 27 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1522 28 mode mode NN 40288 1522 29 , , , 40288 1522 30 and and CC 40288 1522 31 notices notice VBZ 40288 1522 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1522 33 especial especial JJ 40288 1522 34 fitness fitness NN 40288 1522 35 for for IN 40288 1522 36 the the DT 40288 1522 37 dithyramb dithyramb NNP 40288 1522 38 . . . 40288 1523 1 This this DT 40288 1523 2 fitness fitness NN 40288 1523 3 or or CC 40288 1523 4 affinity affinity NN 40288 1523 5 , , , 40288 1523 6 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1523 7 says say VBZ 40288 1523 8 , , , 40288 1523 9 was be VBD 40288 1523 10 so so RB 40288 1523 11 marked mark VBN 40288 1523 12 that that IN 40288 1523 13 a a DT 40288 1523 14 poet poet NN 40288 1523 15 who who WP 40288 1523 16 tried try VBD 40288 1523 17 to to TO 40288 1523 18 compose compose VB 40288 1523 19 a a DT 40288 1523 20 dithyramb dithyramb NN 40288 1523 21 in in IN 40288 1523 22 another another DT 40288 1523 23 mode mode NN 40288 1523 24 found find VBD 40288 1523 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 1523 26 passing pass VBG 40288 1523 27 unawares unaware NNS 40288 1523 28 into into IN 40288 1523 29 the the DT 40288 1523 30 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1523 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1523 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1523 33 Pol Pol NNP 40288 1523 34 . . . 40288 1523 35 _ _ NNP 40288 1523 36 viii viii NN 40288 1523 37 . . . 40288 1524 1 7 7 LS 40288 1524 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1524 3 . . . 40288 1525 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1525 2 is be VBZ 40288 1525 3 natural natural JJ 40288 1525 4 to to TO 40288 1525 5 understand understand VB 40288 1525 6 this this DT 40288 1525 7 of of IN 40288 1525 8 the the DT 40288 1525 9 use use NN 40288 1525 10 of of IN 40288 1525 11 certain certain JJ 40288 1525 12 sequences sequence NNS 40288 1525 13 of of IN 40288 1525 14 intervals interval NNS 40288 1525 15 , , , 40288 1525 16 or or CC 40288 1525 17 of of IN 40288 1525 18 cadences cadence NNS 40288 1525 19 , , , 40288 1525 20 such such JJ 40288 1525 21 as as IN 40288 1525 22 are be VBP 40288 1525 23 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 1525 24 of of IN 40288 1525 25 a a DT 40288 1525 26 ' ' `` 40288 1525 27 mode mode NN 40288 1525 28 ' ' '' 40288 1525 29 in in IN 40288 1525 30 the the DT 40288 1525 31 modern modern JJ 40288 1525 32 sense sense NN 40288 1525 33 of of IN 40288 1525 34 the the DT 40288 1525 35 word word NN 40288 1525 36 , , , 40288 1525 37 rather rather RB 40288 1525 38 than than IN 40288 1525 39 of of IN 40288 1525 40 a a DT 40288 1525 41 change change NN 40288 1525 42 of of IN 40288 1525 43 key key NN 40288 1525 44 . . . 40288 1526 1 If if IN 40288 1526 2 this this DT 40288 1526 3 is be VBZ 40288 1526 4 so so RB 40288 1526 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1526 6 may may MD 40288 1526 7 venture venture VB 40288 1526 8 the the DT 40288 1526 9 further further JJ 40288 1526 10 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40288 1526 11 that that IN 40288 1526 12 the the DT 40288 1526 13 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1526 14 music music NN 40288 1526 15 , , , 40288 1526 16 in in IN 40288 1526 17 some some DT 40288 1526 18 at at IN 40288 1526 19 least least JJS 40288 1526 20 of of IN 40288 1526 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1526 22 forms form NNS 40288 1526 23 , , , 40288 1526 24 was be VBD 40288 1526 25 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 1526 26 not not RB 40288 1526 27 only only RB 40288 1526 28 by by IN 40288 1526 29 pitch pitch NN 40288 1526 30 , , , 40288 1526 31 but but CC 40288 1526 32 also also RB 40288 1526 33 by by IN 40288 1526 34 the the DT 40288 1526 35 more more RBR 40288 1526 36 or or CC 40288 1526 37 less less RBR 40288 1526 38 conscious conscious JJ 40288 1526 39 use use NN 40288 1526 40 of of IN 40288 1526 41 scales scale NNS 40288 1526 42 which which WDT 40288 1526 43 differed differ VBD 40288 1526 44 in in IN 40288 1526 45 type type NN 40288 1526 46 from from IN 40288 1526 47 the the DT 40288 1526 48 scale scale NN 40288 1526 49 of of IN 40288 1526 50 the the DT 40288 1526 51 Greek greek JJ 40288 1526 52 standard standard JJ 40288 1526 53 system system NN 40288 1526 54 . . . 40288 1527 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1527 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1527 3 1 1 CD 40288 1527 4 : : : 40288 1527 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1527 6 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 1527 7 und und NN 40288 1527 8 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 1527 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1527 10 , , , 40288 1527 11 p. p. NN 40288 1527 12 356 356 CD 40288 1527 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1527 14 ed ed NN 40288 1527 15 . . . 40288 1528 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 1528 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1528 3 : : : 40288 1528 4 ' ' `` 40288 1528 5 Die die JJ 40288 1528 6 älteste älteste NN 40288 1528 7 griechische griechische NN 40288 1528 8 Tonart tonart NN 40288 1528 9 ist ist NN 40288 1528 10 demnach demnach NN 40288 1528 11 eine eine NN 40288 1528 12 Molltonart Molltonart NNP 40288 1528 13 .... .... . 40288 1528 14 Aus Aus NNP 40288 1528 15 Kleinasien Kleinasien NNP 40288 1528 16 wurden wurden NNP 40288 1528 17 zunächst zunächst NNP 40288 1528 18 zwei zwei NNP 40288 1528 19 Durtonarten Durtonarten NNP 40288 1528 20 nach nach RB 40288 1528 21 Griechenland Griechenland NNP 40288 1528 22 eingeführt eingeführt NN 40288 1528 23 , , , 40288 1528 24 die die VBP 40288 1528 25 lydische lydische NNP 40288 1528 26 und und JJ 40288 1528 27 phrygische phrygische NN 40288 1528 28 . . . 40288 1528 29 ' ' '' 40288 1529 1 In in IN 40288 1529 2 the the DT 40288 1529 3 1886 1886 CD 40288 1529 4 edition edition NN 40288 1529 5 of of IN 40288 1529 6 the the DT 40288 1529 7 same same JJ 40288 1529 8 book book NN 40288 1529 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1529 10 p. p. NN 40288 1529 11 189 189 CD 40288 1529 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1529 13 Westphal westphal JJ 40288 1529 14 discovers discover VBZ 40288 1529 15 a a DT 40288 1529 16 similar similar JJ 40288 1529 17 classification classification NN 40288 1529 18 of of IN 40288 1529 19 modes mode NNS 40288 1529 20 implied imply VBN 40288 1529 21 in in IN 40288 1529 22 the the DT 40288 1529 23 words word NNS 40288 1529 24 of of IN 40288 1529 25 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1529 26 , , , 40288 1529 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1529 28 Rep. Rep. NNP 40288 1529 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1529 30 p. p. NN 40288 1529 31 400 400 CD 40288 1529 32 a a DT 40288 1529 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1529 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1529 35 : : : 40288 1529 36 tri tri NNP 40288 1529 37 ' ' POS 40288 1529 38 atta atta NNP 40288 1529 39 estin estin NNP 40288 1529 40 eidê eidê NNP 40288 1529 41 ex ex NNP 40288 1529 42 hôn hôn NNP 40288 1529 43 hai hai NNP 40288 1529 44 baseis baseis NNP 40288 1529 45 plekontai plekontai NNP 40288 1529 46 , , , 40288 1529 47 hôsper hôsper NNP 40288 1529 48 en en FW 40288 1529 49 tois tois NNP 40288 1529 50 phthongois phthongois NNP 40288 1529 51 tettara tettara NNP 40288 1529 52 hothen hothen NNP 40288 1529 53 hai hai NNP 40288 1529 54 pasai pasai NNP 40288 1529 55 harmoniai harmoniai NNP 40288 1529 56 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1529 57 . . . 40288 1530 1 But but CC 40288 1530 2 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1530 3 is be VBZ 40288 1530 4 evidently evidently RB 40288 1530 5 referring refer VBG 40288 1530 6 to to IN 40288 1530 7 some some DT 40288 1530 8 matter matter NN 40288 1530 9 of of IN 40288 1530 10 common common JJ 40288 1530 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40288 1530 12 . . . 40288 1531 1 The the DT 40288 1531 2 three three CD 40288 1531 3 forms form NNS 40288 1531 4 or or CC 40288 1531 5 elements element NNS 40288 1531 6 of of IN 40288 1531 7 which which WDT 40288 1531 8 all all DT 40288 1531 9 rhythms rhythm NNS 40288 1531 10 are be VBP 40288 1531 11 made make VBN 40288 1531 12 up up RP 40288 1531 13 are be VBP 40288 1531 14 of of IN 40288 1531 15 course course NN 40288 1531 16 the the DT 40288 1531 17 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1531 18 1 1 CD 40288 1531 19 : : SYM 40288 1531 20 1 1 CD 40288 1531 21 , , , 40288 1531 22 2 2 CD 40288 1531 23 : : SYM 40288 1531 24 1 1 CD 40288 1531 25 and and CC 40288 1531 26 3 3 CD 40288 1531 27 : : SYM 40288 1531 28 2 2 CD 40288 1531 29 , , , 40288 1531 30 which which WDT 40288 1531 31 yield yield VBP 40288 1531 32 the the DT 40288 1531 33 three three CD 40288 1531 34 kinds kind NNS 40288 1531 35 of of IN 40288 1531 36 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1531 37 , , , 40288 1531 38 dactylic dactylic NNP 40288 1531 39 , , , 40288 1531 40 iambic iambic JJ 40288 1531 41 and and CC 40288 1531 42 cretic cretic JJ 40288 1531 43 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1531 44 answering answer VBG 40288 1531 45 to to IN 40288 1531 46 common common JJ 40288 1531 47 , , , 40288 1531 48 triple triple JJ 40288 1531 49 , , , 40288 1531 50 and and CC 40288 1531 51 quintuple quintuple NN 40288 1531 52 time time NN 40288 1531 53 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1531 54 . . . 40288 1532 1 Surely surely RB 40288 1532 2 the the DT 40288 1532 3 four four CD 40288 1532 4 elements element NNS 40288 1532 5 of of IN 40288 1532 6 all all DT 40288 1532 7 musical musical JJ 40288 1532 8 scales scale NNS 40288 1532 9 of of IN 40288 1532 10 which which WDT 40288 1532 11 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1532 12 speaks speak VBZ 40288 1532 13 are be VBP 40288 1532 14 not not RB 40288 1532 15 four four CD 40288 1532 16 kinds kind NNS 40288 1532 17 of of IN 40288 1532 18 scale scale NN 40288 1532 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1532 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1532 21 Harmonien Harmonien NNP 40288 1532 22 - - HYPH 40288 1532 23 Klassen Klassen NNP 40288 1532 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1532 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1532 26 , , , 40288 1532 27 but but CC 40288 1532 28 the the DT 40288 1532 29 four four CD 40288 1532 30 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1532 31 which which WDT 40288 1532 32 give give VBP 40288 1532 33 the the DT 40288 1532 34 primary primary JJ 40288 1532 35 musical musical JJ 40288 1532 36 intervals interval NNS 40288 1532 37 -- -- : 40288 1532 38 viz viz NN 40288 1532 39 . . . 40288 1533 1 the the DT 40288 1533 2 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1533 3 2 2 CD 40288 1533 4 : : SYM 40288 1533 5 1 1 CD 40288 1533 6 , , , 40288 1533 7 3 3 CD 40288 1533 8 : : SYM 40288 1533 9 2 2 CD 40288 1533 10 , , , 40288 1533 11 4 4 CD 40288 1533 12 : : SYM 40288 1533 13 3 3 CD 40288 1533 14 and and CC 40288 1533 15 9 9 CD 40288 1533 16 : : SYM 40288 1533 17 8 8 CD 40288 1533 18 , , , 40288 1533 19 which which WDT 40288 1533 20 give give VBP 40288 1533 21 the the DT 40288 1533 22 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1533 23 , , , 40288 1533 24 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 1533 25 , , , 40288 1533 26 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1533 27 and and CC 40288 1533 28 Tone Tone NNP 40288 1533 29 . . . 40288 1533 30 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1534 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1534 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1534 3 2 2 CD 40288 1534 4 : : : 40288 1534 5 If if IN 40288 1534 6 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1534 7 - - HYPH 40288 1534 8 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1534 9 is be VBZ 40288 1534 10 the the DT 40288 1534 11 same same JJ 40288 1534 12 as as IN 40288 1534 13 the the DT 40288 1534 14 older old JJR 40288 1534 15 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1534 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1534 17 p. p. NN 40288 1534 18 11 11 CD 40288 1534 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1534 20 , , , 40288 1534 21 the the DT 40288 1534 22 coincidence coincidence NN 40288 1534 23 is be VBZ 40288 1534 24 complete complete JJ 40288 1534 25 for for IN 40288 1534 26 the the DT 40288 1534 27 time time NN 40288 1534 28 of of IN 40288 1534 29 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40288 1534 30 . . . 40288 1535 1 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1535 2 treats treat VBZ 40288 1535 3 the the DT 40288 1535 4 claim claim NN 40288 1535 5 of of IN 40288 1535 6 Ionian Ionian NNP 40288 1535 7 to to TO 40288 1535 8 rank rank VB 40288 1535 9 among among IN 40288 1535 10 the the DT 40288 1535 11 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 40288 1535 12 modes mode NNS 40288 1535 13 as as RB 40288 1535 14 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 1535 15 doubtful doubtful JJ 40288 1535 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1535 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1535 18 Laches Laches NNP 40288 1535 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1535 20 , , , 40288 1535 21 p. p. NN 40288 1536 1 188 188 CD 40288 1536 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1536 3 . . . 40288 1536 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1537 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1537 2 may may MD 40288 1537 3 be be VB 40288 1537 4 urged urge VBN 40288 1537 5 that that IN 40288 1537 6 this this DT 40288 1537 7 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40288 1537 8 is be VBZ 40288 1537 9 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40288 1537 10 with with IN 40288 1537 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1537 12 interpretation interpretation NN 40288 1537 13 of of IN 40288 1537 14 the the DT 40288 1537 15 passage passage NN 40288 1537 16 of of IN 40288 1537 17 the the DT 40288 1537 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1537 19 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1537 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1537 21 about about IN 40288 1537 22 the the DT 40288 1537 23 tonic tonic NN 40288 1537 24 character character NN 40288 1537 25 of of IN 40288 1537 26 the the DT 40288 1537 27 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1537 28 . . . 40288 1538 1 If if IN 40288 1538 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1538 3 a a DT 40288 1538 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1538 5 is be VBZ 40288 1538 6 key key NN 40288 1538 7 - - HYPH 40288 1538 8 note note NN 40288 1538 9 , , , 40288 1538 10 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1538 11 was be VBD 40288 1538 12 argued argue VBN 40288 1538 13 , , , 40288 1538 14 the the DT 40288 1538 15 mode mode NN 40288 1538 16 is be VBZ 40288 1538 17 that that DT 40288 1538 18 of of IN 40288 1538 19 the the DT 40288 1538 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1538 21 a_-species a_-species NNP 40288 1538 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1538 23 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1538 24 - - HYPH 40288 1538 25 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1538 26 , , , 40288 1538 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1538 28 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1538 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1538 30 , , , 40288 1538 31 or or CC 40288 1538 32 at at IN 40288 1538 33 most most JJS 40288 1538 34 -- -- : 40288 1538 35 by by IN 40288 1538 36 admitting admit VBG 40288 1538 37 the the DT 40288 1538 38 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1538 39 Synêmmenôn Synêmmenôn NNP 40288 1538 40 -- -- : 40288 1538 41 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1538 42 includes include VBZ 40288 1538 43 the the DT 40288 1538 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1538 45 e_-species e_-species NNP 40288 1538 46 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1538 47 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1538 48 of of IN 40288 1538 49 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1538 50 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1538 51 . . . 40288 1539 1 The the DT 40288 1539 2 answer answer NN 40288 1539 3 may may MD 40288 1539 4 be be VB 40288 1539 5 that that IN 40288 1539 6 the the DT 40288 1539 7 statement statement NN 40288 1539 8 of of IN 40288 1539 9 the the DT 40288 1539 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1539 11 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1539 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1539 13 is be VBZ 40288 1539 14 not not RB 40288 1539 15 of of IN 40288 1539 16 this this DT 40288 1539 17 absolute absolute JJ 40288 1539 18 kind kind NN 40288 1539 19 . . . 40288 1540 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1540 2 is be VBZ 40288 1540 3 not not RB 40288 1540 4 the the DT 40288 1540 5 statement statement NN 40288 1540 6 of of IN 40288 1540 7 a a DT 40288 1540 8 technical technical JJ 40288 1540 9 writer writer NN 40288 1540 10 , , , 40288 1540 11 laying lay VBG 40288 1540 12 down down RP 40288 1540 13 definite definite JJ 40288 1540 14 rules rule NNS 40288 1540 15 , , , 40288 1540 16 but but CC 40288 1540 17 is be VBZ 40288 1540 18 a a DT 40288 1540 19 general general JJ 40288 1540 20 observation observation NN 40288 1540 21 , , , 40288 1540 22 or or CC 40288 1540 23 at at IN 40288 1540 24 best good JJS 40288 1540 25 a a DT 40288 1540 26 canon canon NN 40288 1540 27 of of IN 40288 1540 28 taste taste NN 40288 1540 29 . . . 40288 1541 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1541 2 are be VBP 40288 1541 3 not not RB 40288 1541 4 told tell VBN 40288 1541 5 how how WRB 40288 1541 6 the the DT 40288 1541 7 predominance predominance NN 40288 1541 8 of of IN 40288 1541 9 the the DT 40288 1541 10 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1541 11 is be VBZ 40288 1541 12 shown show VBN 40288 1541 13 in in IN 40288 1541 14 the the DT 40288 1541 15 form form NN 40288 1541 16 of of IN 40288 1541 17 the the DT 40288 1541 18 melody melody NN 40288 1541 19 . . . 40288 1542 1 Moreover moreover RB 40288 1542 2 this this DT 40288 1542 3 predominance predominance NN 40288 1542 4 is be VBZ 40288 1542 5 not not RB 40288 1542 6 said say VBN 40288 1542 7 to to TO 40288 1542 8 be be VB 40288 1542 9 exercised exercise VBN 40288 1542 10 in in IN 40288 1542 11 music music NN 40288 1542 12 generally generally RB 40288 1542 13 , , , 40288 1542 14 but but CC 40288 1542 15 in in IN 40288 1542 16 all all DT 40288 1542 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1542 18 good good JJ 40288 1542 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1542 20 music music NN 40288 1542 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1542 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1542 23 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1542 24 : : : 40288 1542 25 panta panta NNP 40288 1542 26 gar gar NNP 40288 1542 27 ta ta NNP 40288 1542 28 chrêsta chrêsta NNP 40288 1542 29 melê melê NNP 40288 1542 30 pollakis pollakis NNP 40288 1542 31 tê tê DT 40288 1542 32 mesê mesê NNP 40288 1542 33 chrêtai chrêtai NNP 40288 1542 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1542 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1542 36 . . . 40288 1543 1 This this DT 40288 1543 2 may may MD 40288 1543 3 mean mean VB 40288 1543 4 either either CC 40288 1543 5 that that IN 40288 1543 6 tonality tonality NN 40288 1543 7 in in IN 40288 1543 8 Greek greek JJ 40288 1543 9 music music NN 40288 1543 10 was be VBD 40288 1543 11 of of IN 40288 1543 12 an an DT 40288 1543 13 imperfect imperfect JJ 40288 1543 14 kind kind NN 40288 1543 15 , , , 40288 1543 16 a a DT 40288 1543 17 question question NN 40288 1543 18 of of IN 40288 1543 19 style style NN 40288 1543 20 and and CC 40288 1543 21 taste taste NN 40288 1543 22 rather rather RB 40288 1543 23 than than IN 40288 1543 24 of of IN 40288 1543 25 fixed fix VBN 40288 1543 26 rule rule NN 40288 1543 27 , , , 40288 1543 28 or or CC 40288 1543 29 that that IN 40288 1543 30 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1543 31 occasionally occasionally RB 40288 1543 32 employed employ VBD 40288 1543 33 modes mode NNS 40288 1543 34 of of IN 40288 1543 35 a a DT 40288 1543 36 less less RBR 40288 1543 37 approved approved JJ 40288 1543 38 stamp stamp NN 40288 1543 39 , , , 40288 1543 40 unrecognised unrecognise VBN 40288 1543 41 in in IN 40288 1543 42 the the DT 40288 1543 43 earlier early JJR 40288 1543 44 musical musical JJ 40288 1543 45 theory theory NN 40288 1543 46 . . . 40288 1544 1 § § ADD 40288 1544 2 36 36 CD 40288 1544 3 . . . 40288 1545 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1545 2 Conclusion Conclusion NNP 40288 1545 3 . . . 40288 1545 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1545 5 The the DT 40288 1545 6 considerations consideration NNS 40288 1545 7 set set VBN 40288 1545 8 forth forth RP 40288 1545 9 in in IN 40288 1545 10 the the DT 40288 1545 11 last last JJ 40288 1545 12 chapter chapter NN 40288 1545 13 seem seem VBP 40288 1545 14 to to TO 40288 1545 15 show show VB 40288 1545 16 that that IN 40288 1545 17 if if IN 40288 1545 18 difference difference NN 40288 1545 19 of of IN 40288 1545 20 mode mode NN 40288 1545 21 or or CC 40288 1545 22 species specie NNS 40288 1545 23 can can MD 40288 1545 24 not not RB 40288 1545 25 be be VB 40288 1545 26 entirely entirely RB 40288 1545 27 denied deny VBN 40288 1545 28 of of IN 40288 1545 29 the the DT 40288 1545 30 classical classical JJ 40288 1545 31 period period NN 40288 1545 32 of of IN 40288 1545 33 Greek greek JJ 40288 1545 34 music music NN 40288 1545 35 , , , 40288 1545 36 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1545 37 occupied occupy VBD 40288 1545 38 a a DT 40288 1545 39 subordinate subordinate JJ 40288 1545 40 and and CC 40288 1545 41 almost almost RB 40288 1545 42 unrecognised unrecognised JJ 40288 1545 43 place place NN 40288 1545 44 . . . 40288 1546 1 The the DT 40288 1546 2 main main JJ 40288 1546 3 elements element NNS 40288 1546 4 of of IN 40288 1546 5 the the DT 40288 1546 6 art art NN 40288 1546 7 were be VBD 40288 1546 8 , , , 40288 1546 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1546 10 1 1 LS 40288 1546 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1546 12 difference difference NN 40288 1546 13 of of IN 40288 1546 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1546 15 genus_,--the genus_,--the VBG 40288 1546 16 sub sub NN 40288 1546 17 - - NNS 40288 1546 18 divisions division NNS 40288 1546 19 of of IN 40288 1546 20 the the DT 40288 1546 21 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1546 22 which which WDT 40288 1546 23 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1546 24 and and CC 40288 1546 25 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1546 26 alike alike RB 40288 1546 27 recognise recognise NN 40288 1546 28 , , , 40288 1546 29 though though IN 40288 1546 30 with with IN 40288 1546 31 important important JJ 40288 1546 32 discrepancies discrepancy NNS 40288 1546 33 in in IN 40288 1546 34 detail detail NN 40288 1546 35 ; ; : 40288 1546 36 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1546 37 2 2 LS 40288 1546 38 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1546 39 difference difference NN 40288 1546 40 of of IN 40288 1546 41 pitch pitch NN 40288 1546 42 or or CC 40288 1546 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1546 44 key key NN 40288 1546 45 _ _ NNP 40288 1546 46 ; ; : 40288 1546 47 and and CC 40288 1546 48 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1546 49 3 3 LS 40288 1546 50 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1546 51 _ _ NNP 40288 1546 52 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1546 53 _ _ NNP 40288 1546 54 . . . 40288 1547 1 Passing pass VBG 40288 1547 2 over over RP 40288 1547 3 the the DT 40288 1547 4 last last JJ 40288 1547 5 , , , 40288 1547 6 as as IN 40288 1547 7 not not RB 40288 1547 8 belonging belong VBG 40288 1547 9 to to IN 40288 1547 10 the the DT 40288 1547 11 subject subject NN 40288 1547 12 of of IN 40288 1547 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1547 14 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 1547 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1547 16 , , , 40288 1547 17 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1547 18 may may MD 40288 1547 19 now now RB 40288 1547 20 say say VB 40288 1547 21 that that IN 40288 1547 22 genus genus JJ 40288 1547 23 and and CC 40288 1547 24 key key NN 40288 1547 25 are be VBP 40288 1547 26 the the DT 40288 1547 27 only only JJ 40288 1547 28 grounds ground NNS 40288 1547 29 of of IN 40288 1547 30 distinction distinction NN 40288 1547 31 which which WDT 40288 1547 32 are be VBP 40288 1547 33 evidently evidently RB 40288 1547 34 of of IN 40288 1547 35 practical practical JJ 40288 1547 36 importance importance NN 40288 1547 37 . . . 40288 1548 1 No no DT 40288 1548 2 others other NNS 40288 1548 3 were be VBD 40288 1548 4 associated associate VBN 40288 1548 5 with with IN 40288 1548 6 the the DT 40288 1548 7 early early JJ 40288 1548 8 history history NN 40288 1548 9 of of IN 40288 1548 10 the the DT 40288 1548 11 art art NN 40288 1548 12 , , , 40288 1548 13 with with IN 40288 1548 14 particular particular JJ 40288 1548 15 composers composer NNS 40288 1548 16 or or CC 40288 1548 17 periods period NNS 40288 1548 18 , , , 40288 1548 19 with with IN 40288 1548 20 particular particular JJ 40288 1548 21 instruments instrument NNS 40288 1548 22 , , , 40288 1548 23 or or CC 40288 1548 24 with with IN 40288 1548 25 the the DT 40288 1548 26 ethos ethos NN 40288 1548 27 of of IN 40288 1548 28 music music NN 40288 1548 29 . . . 40288 1549 1 This this DT 40288 1549 2 , , , 40288 1549 3 however however RB 40288 1549 4 , , , 40288 1549 5 is be VBZ 40288 1549 6 only only RB 40288 1549 7 true true JJ 40288 1549 8 in in IN 40288 1549 9 the the DT 40288 1549 10 fullest full JJS 40288 1549 11 sense sense NN 40288 1549 12 of of IN 40288 1549 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 1549 14 music music NN 40288 1549 15 before before IN 40288 1549 16 the the DT 40288 1549 17 time time NN 40288 1549 18 of of IN 40288 1549 19 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1549 20 . . . 40288 1550 1 The the DT 40288 1550 2 main main JJ 40288 1550 3 object object NN 40288 1550 4 of of IN 40288 1550 5 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1550 6 's 's POS 40288 1550 7 reform reform NN 40288 1550 8 of of IN 40288 1550 9 the the DT 40288 1550 10 keys key NNS 40288 1550 11 was be VBD 40288 1550 12 to to TO 40288 1550 13 provide provide VB 40288 1550 14 a a DT 40288 1550 15 new new JJ 40288 1550 16 set set NN 40288 1550 17 of of IN 40288 1550 18 scales scale NNS 40288 1550 19 , , , 40288 1550 20 each each DT 40288 1550 21 characterised characterise VBN 40288 1550 22 by by IN 40288 1550 23 a a DT 40288 1550 24 particular particular JJ 40288 1550 25 succession succession NN 40288 1550 26 of of IN 40288 1550 27 intervals interval NNS 40288 1550 28 , , , 40288 1550 29 while while IN 40288 1550 30 the the DT 40288 1550 31 pitch pitch NN 40288 1550 32 was be VBD 40288 1550 33 left leave VBN 40288 1550 34 to to TO 40288 1550 35 take take VB 40288 1550 36 care care NN 40288 1550 37 of of IN 40288 1550 38 itself -PRON- PRP 40288 1550 39 . . . 40288 1551 1 And and CC 40288 1551 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1551 3 is be VBZ 40288 1551 4 clear clear JJ 40288 1551 5 , , , 40288 1551 6 especially especially RB 40288 1551 7 from from IN 40288 1551 8 the the DT 40288 1551 9 specimens specimen NNS 40288 1551 10 which which WDT 40288 1551 11 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1551 12 gives give VBZ 40288 1551 13 of of IN 40288 1551 14 the the DT 40288 1551 15 scales scale NNS 40288 1551 16 in in IN 40288 1551 17 use use NN 40288 1551 18 in in IN 40288 1551 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1551 20 time time NN 40288 1551 21 , , , 40288 1551 22 that that IN 40288 1551 23 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1551 24 was be VBD 40288 1551 25 only only RB 40288 1551 26 endeavouring endeavour VBG 40288 1551 27 to to TO 40288 1551 28 systematise systematise VB 40288 1551 29 what what WP 40288 1551 30 already already RB 40288 1551 31 existed exist VBD 40288 1551 32 , , , 40288 1551 33 and and CC 40288 1551 34 bring bring VB 40288 1551 35 theory theory NN 40288 1551 36 into into IN 40288 1551 37 harmony harmony NN 40288 1551 38 with with IN 40288 1551 39 the the DT 40288 1551 40 developments development NNS 40288 1551 41 of of IN 40288 1551 42 practice practice NN 40288 1551 43 . . . 40288 1552 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1552 2 must must MD 40288 1552 3 suppose suppose VB 40288 1552 4 , , , 40288 1552 5 therefore therefore RB 40288 1552 6 , , , 40288 1552 7 that that IN 40288 1552 8 the the DT 40288 1552 9 musical musical JJ 40288 1552 10 feeling feeling NN 40288 1552 11 which which WDT 40288 1552 12 sought seek VBD 40288 1552 13 variety variety NN 40288 1552 14 in in IN 40288 1552 15 differences difference NNS 40288 1552 16 of of IN 40288 1552 17 key key NN 40288 1552 18 came come VBD 40288 1552 19 to to TO 40288 1552 20 have have VB 40288 1552 21 less less JJR 40288 1552 22 influence influence NN 40288 1552 23 on on IN 40288 1552 24 the the DT 40288 1552 25 practical practical JJ 40288 1552 26 art art NN 40288 1552 27 , , , 40288 1552 28 and and CC 40288 1552 29 that that IN 40288 1552 30 musicians musician NNS 40288 1552 31 began begin VBD 40288 1552 32 to to TO 40288 1552 33 discover discover VB 40288 1552 34 , , , 40288 1552 35 or or CC 40288 1552 36 to to TO 40288 1552 37 appreciate appreciate VB 40288 1552 38 more more JJR 40288 1552 39 than than IN 40288 1552 40 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1552 41 had have VBD 40288 1552 42 done do VBN 40288 1552 43 , , , 40288 1552 44 the the DT 40288 1552 45 use use NN 40288 1552 46 of of IN 40288 1552 47 different different JJ 40288 1552 48 ' ' '' 40288 1552 49 modes mode NNS 40288 1552 50 ' ' '' 40288 1552 51 or or CC 40288 1552 52 forms form NNS 40288 1552 53 of of IN 40288 1552 54 the the DT 40288 1552 55 octave octave NN 40288 1552 56 scale scale NN 40288 1552 57 . . . 40288 1553 1 Along along IN 40288 1553 2 with with IN 40288 1553 3 this this DT 40288 1553 4 change change NN 40288 1553 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1553 6 have have VBP 40288 1553 7 to to TO 40288 1553 8 note note VB 40288 1553 9 the the DT 40288 1553 10 comparative comparative JJ 40288 1553 11 disuse disuse NN 40288 1553 12 of of IN 40288 1553 13 the the DT 40288 1553 14 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1553 15 and and CC 40288 1553 16 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1553 17 divisions division NNS 40288 1553 18 of of IN 40288 1553 19 the the DT 40288 1553 20 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1553 21 . . . 40288 1554 1 The the DT 40288 1554 2 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1554 3 , , , 40288 1554 4 according accord VBG 40288 1554 5 to to IN 40288 1554 6 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1554 7 , , , 40288 1554 8 had have VBD 40288 1554 9 ceased cease VBN 40288 1554 10 to to TO 40288 1554 11 be be VB 40288 1554 12 employed employ VBN 40288 1554 13 . . . 40288 1555 1 Of of IN 40288 1555 2 the the DT 40288 1555 3 three three CD 40288 1555 4 varieties variety NNS 40288 1555 5 of of IN 40288 1555 6 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1555 7 given give VBN 40288 1555 8 by by IN 40288 1555 9 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1555 10 only only RB 40288 1555 11 one one CD 40288 1555 12 remains remain VBZ 40288 1555 13 on on IN 40288 1555 14 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1555 15 's 's POS 40288 1555 16 list list NN 40288 1555 17 , , , 40288 1555 18 and and CC 40288 1555 19 that that IN 40288 1555 20 the the DT 40288 1555 21 one one NN 40288 1555 22 which which WDT 40288 1555 23 in in IN 40288 1555 24 the the DT 40288 1555 25 scheme scheme NN 40288 1555 26 of of IN 40288 1555 27 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1555 28 involved involve VBD 40288 1555 29 no no DT 40288 1555 30 interval interval NN 40288 1555 31 less less JJR 40288 1555 32 than than IN 40288 1555 33 a a DT 40288 1555 34 semitone semitone NN 40288 1555 35 . . . 40288 1556 1 And and CC 40288 1556 2 although although IN 40288 1556 3 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1556 4 distinguished distinguish VBD 40288 1556 5 at at RB 40288 1556 6 least least RBS 40288 1556 7 three three CD 40288 1556 8 varieties variety NNS 40288 1556 9 of of IN 40288 1556 10 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1556 11 , , , 40288 1556 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1556 13 is be VBZ 40288 1556 14 worth worth JJ 40288 1556 15 notice notice NN 40288 1556 16 that that IN 40288 1556 17 only only RB 40288 1556 18 one one CD 40288 1556 19 of of IN 40288 1556 20 these these DT 40288 1556 21 was be VBD 40288 1556 22 admitted admit VBN 40288 1556 23 in in IN 40288 1556 24 the the DT 40288 1556 25 tuning tuning NN 40288 1556 26 of of IN 40288 1556 27 the the DT 40288 1556 28 lyre,--the lyre,--the NNP 40288 1556 29 others other NNS 40288 1556 30 being be VBG 40288 1556 31 confined confine VBN 40288 1556 32 to to IN 40288 1556 33 the the DT 40288 1556 34 more more RBR 40288 1556 35 elaborate elaborate JJ 40288 1556 36 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1556 37 . . . 40288 1557 1 In in IN 40288 1557 2 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1557 3 's 's POS 40288 1557 4 time time NN 40288 1557 5 , , , 40288 1557 6 therefore therefore RB 40288 1557 7 , , , 40288 1557 8 music music NN 40288 1557 9 was be VBD 40288 1557 10 rapidly rapidly RB 40288 1557 11 approaching approach VBG 40288 1557 12 the the DT 40288 1557 13 stage stage NN 40288 1557 14 in in IN 40288 1557 15 which which WDT 40288 1557 16 all all DT 40288 1557 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1557 18 forms form NNS 40288 1557 19 are be VBP 40288 1557 20 based base VBN 40288 1557 21 upon upon IN 40288 1557 22 a a DT 40288 1557 23 single single JJ 40288 1557 24 scale scale NN 40288 1557 25 -- -- : 40288 1557 26 the the DT 40288 1557 27 natural natural JJ 40288 1557 28 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1557 29 scale scale NN 40288 1557 30 of of IN 40288 1557 31 modern modern JJ 40288 1557 32 Europe Europe NNP 40288 1557 33 . . . 40288 1558 1 In in IN 40288 1558 2 the the DT 40288 1558 3 light light NN 40288 1558 4 of of IN 40288 1558 5 these these DT 40288 1558 6 facts fact NNS 40288 1558 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1558 8 must must MD 40288 1558 9 occur occur VB 40288 1558 10 to to IN 40288 1558 11 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1558 12 that that IN 40288 1558 13 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1558 14 's 's POS 40288 1558 15 theory theory NN 40288 1558 16 of of IN 40288 1558 17 seven seven CD 40288 1558 18 modes mode NNS 40288 1558 19 or or CC 40288 1558 20 species specie NNS 40288 1558 21 of of IN 40288 1558 22 the the DT 40288 1558 23 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1558 24 is be VBZ 40288 1558 25 really really RB 40288 1558 26 open open JJ 40288 1558 27 to to IN 40288 1558 28 an an DT 40288 1558 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1558 30 a a DT 40288 1558 31 priori priori FW 40288 1558 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1558 33 objection objection NN 40288 1558 34 as as IN 40288 1558 35 decisive decisive JJ 40288 1558 36 in in IN 40288 1558 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1558 38 nature nature NN 40288 1558 39 as as IN 40288 1558 40 any any DT 40288 1558 41 of of IN 40288 1558 42 the the DT 40288 1558 43 testimony testimony NN 40288 1558 44 which which WDT 40288 1558 45 has have VBZ 40288 1558 46 been be VBN 40288 1558 47 brought bring VBN 40288 1558 48 against against IN 40288 1558 49 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1558 50 . . . 40288 1559 1 Is be VBZ 40288 1559 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1559 3 possible possible JJ 40288 1559 4 , , , 40288 1559 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1559 6 may may MD 40288 1559 7 ask ask VB 40288 1559 8 , , , 40288 1559 9 that that IN 40288 1559 10 a a DT 40288 1559 11 system system NN 40288 1559 12 of of IN 40288 1559 13 modes mode NNS 40288 1559 14 analogous analogous JJ 40288 1559 15 to to IN 40288 1559 16 the the DT 40288 1559 17 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 40288 1559 18 Tones Tones NNPS 40288 1559 19 can can MD 40288 1559 20 have have VB 40288 1559 21 subsisted subsist VBN 40288 1559 22 along along IN 40288 1559 23 with with IN 40288 1559 24 a a DT 40288 1559 25 system system NN 40288 1559 26 of of IN 40288 1559 27 scales scale NNS 40288 1559 28 such such JJ 40288 1559 29 as as IN 40288 1559 30 the the DT 40288 1559 31 genera genera NN 40288 1559 32 and and CC 40288 1559 33 ' ' `` 40288 1559 34 colours colour NNS 40288 1559 35 ' ' '' 40288 1559 36 of of IN 40288 1559 37 early early JJ 40288 1559 38 Greek greek JJ 40288 1559 39 music music NN 40288 1559 40 ? ? . 40288 1560 1 The the DT 40288 1560 2 reply reply NN 40288 1560 3 may may MD 40288 1560 4 be be VB 40288 1560 5 that that IN 40288 1560 6 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1560 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40288 1560 8 combines combine VBZ 40288 1560 9 the the DT 40288 1560 10 two two CD 40288 1560 11 systems system NNS 40288 1560 12 . . . 40288 1561 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1561 2 supposes suppose VBZ 40288 1561 3 five five CD 40288 1561 4 divisions division NNS 40288 1561 5 of of IN 40288 1561 6 the the DT 40288 1561 7 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1561 8 , , , 40288 1561 9 and and CC 40288 1561 10 seven seven CD 40288 1561 11 modes mode NNS 40288 1561 12 based base VBN 40288 1561 13 upon upon IN 40288 1561 14 so so RB 40288 1561 15 many many JJ 40288 1561 16 species specie NNS 40288 1561 17 of of IN 40288 1561 18 the the DT 40288 1561 19 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1561 20 -- -- : 40288 1561 21 in in IN 40288 1561 22 all all DT 40288 1561 23 thirty thirty CD 40288 1561 24 - - HYPH 40288 1561 25 five five CD 40288 1561 26 different different JJ 40288 1561 27 scales scale NNS 40288 1561 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1561 29 or or CC 40288 1561 30 seventy seventy CD 40288 1561 31 , , , 40288 1561 32 if if IN 40288 1561 33 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1561 34 bring bring VBP 40288 1561 35 in in RP 40288 1561 36 the the DT 40288 1561 37 distinction distinction NN 40288 1561 38 of of IN 40288 1561 39 octaves octave NNS 40288 1561 40 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1561 41 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1561 42 : : : 40288 1561 43 apo apo NNP 40288 1561 44 nêtês nêtês NN 40288 1561 45 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1561 46 and and CC 40288 1561 47 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1561 48 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1561 49 : : : 40288 1561 50 apo apo NNP 40288 1561 51 mesês mesês NN 40288 1561 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1561 53 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1561 54 . . . 40288 1562 1 But but CC 40288 1562 2 when when WRB 40288 1562 3 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1562 4 come come VBP 40288 1562 5 to to IN 40288 1562 6 the the DT 40288 1562 7 scales scale NNS 40288 1562 8 actually actually RB 40288 1562 9 used use VBN 40288 1562 10 on on IN 40288 1562 11 the the DT 40288 1562 12 chief chief JJ 40288 1562 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 1562 14 instrument instrument NN 40288 1562 15 , , , 40288 1562 16 the the DT 40288 1562 17 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1562 18 , , , 40288 1562 19 the the DT 40288 1562 20 number number NN 40288 1562 21 falls fall VBZ 40288 1562 22 at at IN 40288 1562 23 once once RB 40288 1562 24 to to IN 40288 1562 25 six six CD 40288 1562 26 . . . 40288 1563 1 Evidently evidently RB 40288 1563 2 the the DT 40288 1563 3 others other NNS 40288 1563 4 , , , 40288 1563 5 or or CC 40288 1563 6 most most JJS 40288 1563 7 of of IN 40288 1563 8 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1563 9 , , , 40288 1563 10 only only RB 40288 1563 11 existed exist VBD 40288 1563 12 on on IN 40288 1563 13 paper paper NN 40288 1563 14 , , , 40288 1563 15 as as IN 40288 1563 16 the the DT 40288 1563 17 mathematical mathematical JJ 40288 1563 18 results result NNS 40288 1563 19 of of IN 40288 1563 20 certain certain JJ 40288 1563 21 assumptions assumption NNS 40288 1563 22 which which WDT 40288 1563 23 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1563 24 had have VBD 40288 1563 25 made make VBN 40288 1563 26 . . . 40288 1564 1 And and CC 40288 1564 2 if if IN 40288 1564 3 this this DT 40288 1564 4 can can MD 40288 1564 5 be be VB 40288 1564 6 said say VBN 40288 1564 7 of of IN 40288 1564 8 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1564 9 's 's POS 40288 1564 10 theory theory NN 40288 1564 11 , , , 40288 1564 12 what what WP 40288 1564 13 would would MD 40288 1564 14 be be VB 40288 1564 15 the the DT 40288 1564 16 value value NN 40288 1564 17 of of IN 40288 1564 18 a a DT 40288 1564 19 similar similar JJ 40288 1564 20 scheme scheme NN 40288 1564 21 combining combine VBG 40288 1564 22 the the DT 40288 1564 23 modes mode NNS 40288 1564 24 with with IN 40288 1564 25 the the DT 40288 1564 26 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1564 27 and and CC 40288 1564 28 the the DT 40288 1564 29 different different JJ 40288 1564 30 varieties variety NNS 40288 1564 31 of of IN 40288 1564 32 the the DT 40288 1564 33 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1564 34 genus genus NN 40288 1564 35 ? ? . 40288 1565 1 The the DT 40288 1565 2 truth truth NN 40288 1565 3 is be VBZ 40288 1565 4 , , , 40288 1565 5 surely surely RB 40288 1565 6 , , , 40288 1565 7 that that IN 40288 1565 8 such such PDT 40288 1565 9 a a DT 40288 1565 10 scheme scheme NN 40288 1565 11 tries try VBZ 40288 1565 12 to to TO 40288 1565 13 unite unite VB 40288 1565 14 elements element NNS 40288 1565 15 which which WDT 40288 1565 16 belong belong VBP 40288 1565 17 to to IN 40288 1565 18 different different JJ 40288 1565 19 times time NNS 40288 1565 20 , , , 40288 1565 21 which which WDT 40288 1565 22 in in IN 40288 1565 23 fact fact NN 40288 1565 24 are be VBP 40288 1565 25 the the DT 40288 1565 26 fundamental fundamental JJ 40288 1565 27 ideas idea NNS 40288 1565 28 of of IN 40288 1565 29 different different JJ 40288 1565 30 stages stage NNS 40288 1565 31 of of IN 40288 1565 32 art art NN 40288 1565 33 . . . 40288 1566 1 The the DT 40288 1566 2 most most RBS 40288 1566 3 striking striking JJ 40288 1566 4 characteristic characteristic NN 40288 1566 5 of of IN 40288 1566 6 Greek greek JJ 40288 1566 7 music music NN 40288 1566 8 , , , 40288 1566 9 especially especially RB 40288 1566 10 in in IN 40288 1566 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1566 12 earlier early JJR 40288 1566 13 periods period NNS 40288 1566 14 , , , 40288 1566 15 is be VBZ 40288 1566 16 the the DT 40288 1566 17 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40288 1566 18 and and CC 40288 1566 19 delicacy delicacy NN 40288 1566 20 of of IN 40288 1566 21 the the DT 40288 1566 22 intervals interval NNS 40288 1566 23 into into IN 40288 1566 24 which which WDT 40288 1566 25 the the DT 40288 1566 26 scale scale NN 40288 1566 27 was be VBD 40288 1566 28 divided divide VBN 40288 1566 29 . . . 40288 1567 1 A a DT 40288 1567 2 sort sort NN 40288 1567 3 of of IN 40288 1567 4 frame frame NN 40288 1567 5 - - HYPH 40288 1567 6 work work NN 40288 1567 7 was be VBD 40288 1567 8 formed form VBN 40288 1567 9 by by IN 40288 1567 10 the the DT 40288 1567 11 division division NN 40288 1567 12 of of IN 40288 1567 13 the the DT 40288 1567 14 octave octave NN 40288 1567 15 into into IN 40288 1567 16 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1567 17 , , , 40288 1567 18 completed complete VBN 40288 1567 19 by by IN 40288 1567 20 the the DT 40288 1567 21 so so RB 40288 1567 22 - - HYPH 40288 1567 23 called call VBN 40288 1567 24 disjunctive disjunctive JJ 40288 1567 25 tone tone NN 40288 1567 26 ; ; : 40288 1567 27 and and CC 40288 1567 28 so so RB 40288 1567 29 far far RB 40288 1567 30 all all DT 40288 1567 31 Greek greek JJ 40288 1567 32 music music NN 40288 1567 33 was be VBD 40288 1567 34 alike alike RB 40288 1567 35 . . . 40288 1568 1 But but CC 40288 1568 2 within within IN 40288 1568 3 the the DT 40288 1568 4 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1568 5 the the DT 40288 1568 6 reign reign NN 40288 1568 7 of of IN 40288 1568 8 diversity diversity NN 40288 1568 9 was be VBD 40288 1568 10 unchecked unchecked JJ 40288 1568 11 . . . 40288 1569 1 Not not RB 40288 1569 2 only only RB 40288 1569 3 were be VBD 40288 1569 4 there there RB 40288 1569 5 recognised recognise VBN 40288 1569 6 divisions division NNS 40288 1569 7 containing contain VBG 40288 1569 8 intervals interval NNS 40288 1569 9 of of IN 40288 1569 10 a a DT 40288 1569 11 fourth fourth JJ 40288 1569 12 , , , 40288 1569 13 a a DT 40288 1569 14 third third JJ 40288 1569 15 , , , 40288 1569 16 and and CC 40288 1569 17 even even RB 40288 1569 18 three three CD 40288 1569 19 - - HYPH 40288 1569 20 eighths eighth NNS 40288 1569 21 of of IN 40288 1569 22 a a DT 40288 1569 23 tone tone NN 40288 1569 24 , , , 40288 1569 25 but but CC 40288 1569 26 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1569 27 gather gather VBP 40288 1569 28 from from IN 40288 1569 29 several several JJ 40288 1569 30 things thing NNS 40288 1569 31 said say VBN 40288 1569 32 by by IN 40288 1569 33 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1569 34 that that IN 40288 1569 35 the the DT 40288 1569 36 number number NN 40288 1569 37 of of IN 40288 1569 38 possible possible JJ 40288 1569 39 divisions division NNS 40288 1569 40 was be VBD 40288 1569 41 regarded regard VBN 40288 1569 42 as as IN 40288 1569 43 theoretically theoretically RB 40288 1569 44 unlimited unlimited JJ 40288 1569 45 . . . 40288 1570 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1570 2 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1570 3 tells tell VBZ 40288 1570 4 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1570 5 that that IN 40288 1570 6 there there EX 40288 1570 7 was be VBD 40288 1570 8 a a DT 40288 1570 9 constant constant JJ 40288 1570 10 tendency tendency NN 40288 1570 11 to to TO 40288 1570 12 flatten flatten VB 40288 1570 13 the the DT 40288 1570 14 ' ' `` 40288 1570 15 moveable moveable JJ 40288 1570 16 ' ' '' 40288 1570 17 notes note NNS 40288 1570 18 of of IN 40288 1570 19 the the DT 40288 1570 20 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1570 21 genus genus NN 40288 1570 22 , , , 40288 1570 23 and and CC 40288 1570 24 thus thus RB 40288 1570 25 diminish diminish VB 40288 1570 26 the the DT 40288 1570 27 small small JJ 40288 1570 28 intervals interval NNS 40288 1570 29 , , , 40288 1570 30 for for IN 40288 1570 31 the the DT 40288 1570 32 sake sake NN 40288 1570 33 of of IN 40288 1570 34 ' ' `` 40288 1570 35 sweetness sweetness NN 40288 1570 36 ' ' '' 40288 1570 37 or or CC 40288 1570 38 in in IN 40288 1570 39 order order NN 40288 1570 40 to to TO 40288 1570 41 obtain obtain VB 40288 1570 42 a a DT 40288 1570 43 plaintive plaintive NN 40288 1570 44 tone[1];--that tone[1];--that IN 40288 1570 45 the the DT 40288 1570 46 Lichanos Lichanos NNPS 40288 1570 47 of of IN 40288 1570 48 a a DT 40288 1570 49 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1570 50 may may MD 40288 1570 51 in in IN 40288 1570 52 theory theory NN 40288 1570 53 be be VB 40288 1570 54 any any DT 40288 1570 55 note note NN 40288 1570 56 between between IN 40288 1570 57 the the DT 40288 1570 58 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1570 59 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1570 60 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1570 61 _ _ NNP 40288 1570 62 f f NNP 40288 1570 63 _ _ NNP 40288 1570 64 in in IN 40288 1570 65 the the DT 40288 1570 66 scale scale NN 40288 1570 67 _ _ NNP 40288 1570 68 e e NNP 40288 1570 69 - - HYPH 40288 1570 70 e*-f e*-f VB 40288 1570 71 - - HYPH 40288 1570 72 a a DT 40288 1570 73 _ _ NN 40288 1570 74 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1570 75 and and CC 40288 1570 76 the the DT 40288 1570 77 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1570 78 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1570 79 _ _ NNP 40288 1570 80 g g NNP 40288 1570 81 _ _ NNP 40288 1570 82 in in IN 40288 1570 83 the the DT 40288 1570 84 scale scale NN 40288 1570 85 _ _ NNP 40288 1570 86 e e NNP 40288 1570 87 - - HYPH 40288 1570 88 f f NNP 40288 1570 89 - - HYPH 40288 1570 90 g g NNP 40288 1570 91 - - HYPH 40288 1570 92 a_)[2];--and a_)[2];--and NNP 40288 1570 93 that that IN 40288 1570 94 the the DT 40288 1570 95 magnitude magnitude NN 40288 1570 96 of of IN 40288 1570 97 the the DT 40288 1570 98 smaller small JJR 40288 1570 99 intervals interval NNS 40288 1570 100 and and CC 40288 1570 101 division division NN 40288 1570 102 of of IN 40288 1570 103 the the DT 40288 1570 104 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1570 105 generally generally RB 40288 1570 106 belongs belong VBZ 40288 1570 107 to to IN 40288 1570 108 the the DT 40288 1570 109 indefinite indefinite JJ 40288 1570 110 or or CC 40288 1570 111 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 40288 1570 112 element element NN 40288 1570 113 in in IN 40288 1570 114 music[3 music[3 NNP 40288 1570 115 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1570 116 . . . 40288 1571 1 Moreover moreover RB 40288 1571 2 , , , 40288 1571 3 in in IN 40288 1571 4 spite spite NN 40288 1571 5 of of IN 40288 1571 6 the the DT 40288 1571 7 disuse disuse NN 40288 1571 8 of of IN 40288 1571 9 several several JJ 40288 1571 10 of of IN 40288 1571 11 the the DT 40288 1571 12 older old JJR 40288 1571 13 scales scale NNS 40288 1571 14 , , , 40288 1571 15 much much JJ 40288 1571 16 of of IN 40288 1571 17 this this DT 40288 1571 18 holds hold VBZ 40288 1571 19 good good JJ 40288 1571 20 for for IN 40288 1571 21 the the DT 40288 1571 22 time time NN 40288 1571 23 of of IN 40288 1571 24 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1571 25 . . . 40288 1572 1 The the DT 40288 1572 2 modern modern JJ 40288 1572 3 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1572 4 scale scale NN 40288 1572 5 is be VBZ 40288 1572 6 fully fully RB 40288 1572 7 recognised recognise VBN 40288 1572 8 by by IN 40288 1572 9 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1572 10 , , , 40288 1572 11 but but CC 40288 1572 12 only only RB 40288 1572 13 as as IN 40288 1572 14 one one CD 40288 1572 15 of of IN 40288 1572 16 several several JJ 40288 1572 17 different different JJ 40288 1572 18 divisions division NNS 40288 1572 19 . . . 40288 1573 1 And and CC 40288 1573 2 the the DT 40288 1573 3 division division NN 40288 1573 4 which which WDT 40288 1573 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1573 6 treats treat VBZ 40288 1573 7 as as IN 40288 1573 8 the the DT 40288 1573 9 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1573 10 or or CC 40288 1573 11 standard standard JJ 40288 1573 12 form form NN 40288 1573 13 of of IN 40288 1573 14 the the DT 40288 1573 15 octave octave NN 40288 1573 16 is be VBZ 40288 1573 17 not not RB 40288 1573 18 the the DT 40288 1573 19 modern modern JJ 40288 1573 20 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1573 21 scale scale NN 40288 1573 22 , , , 40288 1573 23 but but CC 40288 1573 24 one one CD 40288 1573 25 of of IN 40288 1573 26 the the DT 40288 1573 27 so so RB 40288 1573 28 - - HYPH 40288 1573 29 called call VBN 40288 1573 30 ' ' `` 40288 1573 31 soft soft JJ 40288 1573 32 ' ' '' 40288 1573 33 or or CC 40288 1573 34 flattened flatten VBD 40288 1573 35 varieties variety NNS 40288 1573 36 . . . 40288 1574 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1574 2 is be VBZ 40288 1574 3 clear clear JJ 40288 1574 4 that that IN 40288 1574 5 in in IN 40288 1574 6 the the DT 40288 1574 7 best good JJS 40288 1574 8 periods period NNS 40288 1574 9 of of IN 40288 1574 10 Greek greek JJ 40288 1574 11 music music NN 40288 1574 12 these these DT 40288 1574 13 refinements refinement NNS 40288 1574 14 of of IN 40288 1574 15 melody melody NN 40288 1574 16 , , , 40288 1574 17 which which WDT 40288 1574 18 modern modern JJ 40288 1574 19 musicians musician NNS 40288 1574 20 find find VBP 40288 1574 21 scarcely scarcely RB 40288 1574 22 conceivable conceivable JJ 40288 1574 23 , , , 40288 1574 24 were be VBD 40288 1574 25 far far RB 40288 1574 26 from from IN 40288 1574 27 being be VBG 40288 1574 28 accidental accidental JJ 40288 1574 29 or or CC 40288 1574 30 subordinate subordinate JJ 40288 1574 31 features feature NNS 40288 1574 32 . . . 40288 1575 1 Rather rather RB 40288 1575 2 , , , 40288 1575 3 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1575 4 were be VBD 40288 1575 5 as as RB 40288 1575 6 much much JJ 40288 1575 7 bound bind VBN 40288 1575 8 up up RP 40288 1575 9 with with IN 40288 1575 10 the the DT 40288 1575 11 fundamental fundamental JJ 40288 1575 12 nature nature NN 40288 1575 13 of of IN 40288 1575 14 that that DT 40288 1575 15 music music NN 40288 1575 16 as as IN 40288 1575 17 complex complex JJ 40288 1575 18 harmony harmony NN 40288 1575 19 is be VBZ 40288 1575 20 with with IN 40288 1575 21 the the DT 40288 1575 22 music music NN 40288 1575 23 of of IN 40288 1575 24 modern modern JJ 40288 1575 25 Europe Europe NNP 40288 1575 26 . . . 40288 1576 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1576 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1576 3 1 1 CD 40288 1576 4 : : : 40288 1576 5 Aristox Aristox NNS 40288 1576 6 . . . 40288 1577 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1577 2 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1577 3 . . . 40288 1577 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1577 5 p. p. NN 40288 1577 6 23 23 CD 40288 1577 7 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1577 8 . . . 40288 1578 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1578 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1578 3 : : : 40288 1578 4 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1578 5 men man NNS 40288 1578 6 gar gar VBP 40288 1578 7 tê tê PRP 40288 1578 8 nun nun VB 40288 1578 9 katechousê katechousê NNP 40288 1578 10 melopoiia melopoiia NNP 40288 1578 11 ounêtheis ounêtheis NNP 40288 1578 12 monon monon NNP 40288 1578 13 ontes onte NNS 40288 1578 14 eiktôs eiktôs NNP 40288 1578 15 tên tên NNP 40288 1578 16 ditonon ditonon NNP 40288 1578 17 lichanon lichanon NNP 40288 1578 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1578 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1578 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1578 21 f f NNP 40288 1578 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1578 23 in in IN 40288 1578 24 the the DT 40288 1578 25 scale scale NN 40288 1578 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1578 27 e e NNP 40288 1578 28 - - : 40288 1578 29 a a DT 40288 1578 30 _ _ NN 40288 1578 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1578 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1578 33 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1578 34 : : : 40288 1578 35 exorizousi exorizousi NN 40288 1578 36 ; ; : 40288 1578 37 suntonôterais suntonôterais NNP 40288 1578 38 gar gar NNP 40288 1578 39 chrôntai chrôntai NNP 40288 1578 40 schedon schedon NNP 40288 1578 41 hoi hoi NNP 40288 1578 42 pleistoi pleistoi NNP 40288 1578 43 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1578 44 nun nun NN 40288 1578 45 . . . 40288 1579 1 toutou toutou NNP 40288 1579 2 d d NNP 40288 1579 3 ' ' POS 40288 1579 4 aition aition NN 40288 1579 5 to to IN 40288 1579 6 boulesthai boulesthai NNP 40288 1579 7 glukainein glukainein NNP 40288 1579 8 aei aei NNP 40288 1579 9 . . . 40288 1580 1 sêmeion sêmeion NNP 40288 1580 2 de de NNP 40288 1580 3 hoti hoti NNP 40288 1580 4 toutou toutou NNP 40288 1580 5 stochazontai stochazontai NNP 40288 1580 6 , , , 40288 1580 7 malista malista NNP 40288 1580 8 men man NNS 40288 1580 9 gar gar NNP 40288 1580 10 kai kai NNP 40288 1580 11 pleiston pleiston NNP 40288 1580 12 chronon chronon NNP 40288 1580 13 en en NNP 40288 1580 14 tô tô NNP 40288 1580 15 chrômati chrômati NNP 40288 1580 16 diatribousin diatribousin NNP 40288 1580 17 . . . 40288 1581 1 hotan hotan NNP 40288 1581 2 d d NNP 40288 1581 3 ' ' `` 40288 1581 4 aphikôntai aphikôntai NNP 40288 1581 5 pote pote NNP 40288 1581 6 eis eis NNP 40288 1581 7 tên tên NNP 40288 1581 8 harmonian harmonian NNP 40288 1581 9 engus engus NNP 40288 1581 10 tou tou NNP 40288 1581 11 chromatos chromatos NNP 40288 1581 12 prosagousi prosagousi NNP 40288 1581 13 , , , 40288 1581 14 sunepismômenou sunepismômenou NNP 40288 1581 15 tou tou NNP 40288 1581 16 êthous êthous NNP 40288 1581 17 . . . 40288 1581 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1581 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1582 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1582 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1582 3 2 2 CD 40288 1582 4 : : : 40288 1582 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 40288 1582 6 . . . 40288 1583 1 p. p. NN 40288 1583 2 26 26 CD 40288 1583 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1583 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1583 5 : : : 40288 1583 6 noêteon noêteon NNP 40288 1583 7 gar gar NNP 40288 1583 8 apeirous apeirous NNP 40288 1583 9 ton ton NNP 40288 1583 10 arithmon arithmon NNP 40288 1583 11 tas tas NNP 40288 1583 12 lichanous lichanous JJ 40288 1583 13 . . . 40288 1584 1 hou hou NNP 40288 1584 2 gar gar NNP 40288 1584 3 an an DT 40288 1584 4 stêsês stêsês NN 40288 1584 5 tên tên NN 40288 1584 6 phônên phônên NNP 40288 1584 7 apodedeigmenon apodedeigmenon NNP 40288 1584 8 lichanô lichanô NN 40288 1584 9 topou topou NNP 40288 1584 10 lichanos lichanos NNP 40288 1584 11 estai estai NNP 40288 1584 12 ; ; : 40288 1584 13 diakenon diakenon NNP 40288 1584 14 de de NNP 40288 1584 15 ouden ouden NNP 40288 1584 16 esti esti NNP 40288 1584 17 tou tou NNP 40288 1584 18 lichanoeidous lichanoeidous JJ 40288 1584 19 topou topou NNP 40288 1584 20 , , , 40288 1584 21 oude oude NNP 40288 1584 22 toiouton toiouton NNP 40288 1584 23 hôste hôste NN 40288 1584 24 mê mê NNP 40288 1584 25 dechisthai dechisthai NNP 40288 1584 26 lichanon lichanon NNP 40288 1584 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1584 28 . . . 40288 1585 1 And and CC 40288 1585 2 p. p. NN 40288 1585 3 48 48 CD 40288 1585 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1585 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1585 6 : : : 40288 1585 7 epeidê epeidê VB 40288 1585 8 per per IN 40288 1585 9 ho ho NNP 40288 1585 10 tês tês NNP 40288 1585 11 lichanou lichanou NNP 40288 1585 12 topos topos NNP 40288 1585 13 eis eis NNP 40288 1585 14 apeirous apeirous NNP 40288 1585 15 temnetai temnetai NNP 40288 1585 16 tomas tomas NNP 40288 1585 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1585 18 . . . 40288 1585 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1586 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1586 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1586 3 3 3 CD 40288 1586 4 : : : 40288 1586 5 Aristox Aristox NNS 40288 1586 6 . . . 40288 1587 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1587 2 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1587 3 . . . 40288 1587 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1587 5 p. p. NN 40288 1587 6 69 69 CD 40288 1587 7 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1587 8 . . . 40288 1588 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1588 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1588 3 : : : 40288 1588 4 kata kata NNP 40288 1588 5 men man NNS 40288 1588 6 oun oun NNP 40288 1588 7 ta ta NNP 40288 1588 8 megethê megethê NNP 40288 1588 9 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1588 10 diastêmatôn diastêmatôn NNP 40288 1588 11 kai kai NNP 40288 1588 12 tas tas NNP 40288 1588 13 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1588 14 phthongôn phthongôn NNP 40288 1588 15 taseis taseis NNP 40288 1588 16 apeira apeira NNP 40288 1588 17 pôs pôs NNP 40288 1588 18 phainetai phainetai NNP 40288 1588 19 einai einai NNP 40288 1588 20 ta ta NNP 40288 1588 21 peri peri NNP 40288 1588 22 to to IN 40288 1588 23 melos melos NNP 40288 1588 24 , , , 40288 1588 25 kata kata NNP 40288 1588 26 de de NNP 40288 1588 27 tas tas NNP 40288 1588 28 dynameis dynameis NNP 40288 1588 29 kai kai NNP 40288 1588 30 kata kata NNP 40288 1588 31 ta ta NNP 40288 1588 32 eidê eidê NNP 40288 1588 33 kai kai NNP 40288 1588 34 kata kata NNP 40288 1588 35 tas tas NNP 40288 1588 36 theseis theseis NNP 40288 1588 37 peperasmena peperasmena NNP 40288 1588 38 te te NNP 40288 1588 39 kai kai NNP 40288 1588 40 tetagmena tetagmena NNP 40288 1588 41 . . . 40288 1588 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1588 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1589 1 The the DT 40288 1589 2 mediaeval mediaeval JJ 40288 1589 3 modes mode NNS 40288 1589 4 or or CC 40288 1589 5 Tones Tones NNP 40288 1589 6 , , , 40288 1589 7 on on IN 40288 1589 8 the the DT 40288 1589 9 other other JJ 40288 1589 10 hand hand NN 40288 1589 11 , , , 40288 1589 12 are be VBP 40288 1589 13 essentially essentially RB 40288 1589 14 based base VBN 40288 1589 15 on on IN 40288 1589 16 the the DT 40288 1589 17 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1589 18 scale,--the scale,--the DT 40288 1589 19 scale scale NN 40288 1589 20 that that WDT 40288 1589 21 knows know VBZ 40288 1589 22 only only RB 40288 1589 23 of of IN 40288 1589 24 tones tone NNS 40288 1589 25 and and CC 40288 1589 26 semitones semitone NNS 40288 1589 27 . . . 40288 1590 1 To to TO 40288 1590 2 suppose suppose VB 40288 1590 3 that that IN 40288 1590 4 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1590 5 held hold VBD 40288 1590 6 in in IN 40288 1590 7 the the DT 40288 1590 8 earliest early JJS 40288 1590 9 Greek greek JJ 40288 1590 10 music music NN 40288 1590 11 the the DT 40288 1590 12 prominent prominent JJ 40288 1590 13 place place NN 40288 1590 14 which which WDT 40288 1590 15 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1590 16 find find VBP 40288 1590 17 assigned assign VBN 40288 1590 18 to to IN 40288 1590 19 the the DT 40288 1590 20 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1590 21 Modes mode NNS 40288 1590 22 or or CC 40288 1590 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1590 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1590 25 : : : 40288 1590 26 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1590 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1590 28 is be VBZ 40288 1590 29 to to TO 40288 1590 30 suppose suppose VB 40288 1590 31 that that IN 40288 1590 32 the the DT 40288 1590 33 art art NN 40288 1590 34 of of IN 40288 1590 35 music music NN 40288 1590 36 was be VBD 40288 1590 37 developed develop VBN 40288 1590 38 in in IN 40288 1590 39 Greece Greece NNP 40288 1590 40 in in IN 40288 1590 41 two two CD 40288 1590 42 different different JJ 40288 1590 43 directions direction NNS 40288 1590 44 , , , 40288 1590 45 under under IN 40288 1590 46 the the DT 40288 1590 47 influence influence NN 40288 1590 48 of of IN 40288 1590 49 different different JJ 40288 1590 50 and and CC 40288 1590 51 almost almost RB 40288 1590 52 opposite opposite JJ 40288 1590 53 ideas idea NNS 40288 1590 54 . . . 40288 1591 1 Yet yet RB 40288 1591 2 nothing nothing NN 40288 1591 3 is be VBZ 40288 1591 4 more more RBR 40288 1591 5 remarkable remarkable JJ 40288 1591 6 in in IN 40288 1591 7 all all DT 40288 1591 8 departments department NNS 40288 1591 9 of of IN 40288 1591 10 Greek greek JJ 40288 1591 11 art art NN 40288 1591 12 than than IN 40288 1591 13 the the DT 40288 1591 14 strictness strictness NN 40288 1591 15 with with IN 40288 1591 16 which which WDT 40288 1591 17 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1591 18 confines confine VBZ 40288 1591 19 itself -PRON- PRP 40288 1591 20 within within IN 40288 1591 21 the the DT 40288 1591 22 limits limit NNS 40288 1591 23 given give VBN 40288 1591 24 once once RB 40288 1591 25 for for IN 40288 1591 26 all all DT 40288 1591 27 in in IN 40288 1591 28 the the DT 40288 1591 29 leading lead VBG 40288 1591 30 types type NNS 40288 1591 31 , , , 40288 1591 32 and and CC 40288 1591 33 the the DT 40288 1591 34 consequent consequent JJ 40288 1591 35 harmony harmony NN 40288 1591 36 and and CC 40288 1591 37 consistency consistency NN 40288 1591 38 of of IN 40288 1591 39 all all PDT 40288 1591 40 the the DT 40288 1591 41 forms form NNS 40288 1591 42 which which WDT 40288 1591 43 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1591 44 takes take VBZ 40288 1591 45 in in RP 40288 1591 46 the the DT 40288 1591 47 course course NN 40288 1591 48 of of IN 40288 1591 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1591 50 growth growth NN 40288 1591 51 . . . 40288 1592 1 The the DT 40288 1592 2 dependence dependence NN 40288 1592 3 of of IN 40288 1592 4 artistic artistic JJ 40288 1592 5 forms form NNS 40288 1592 6 in in IN 40288 1592 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1592 8 manifold manifold JJ 40288 1592 9 developments development NNS 40288 1592 10 upon upon IN 40288 1592 11 a a DT 40288 1592 12 central central JJ 40288 1592 13 governing govern VBG 40288 1592 14 idea idea NN 40288 1592 15 or or CC 40288 1592 16 principle principle NN 40288 1592 17 has have VBZ 40288 1592 18 never never RB 40288 1592 19 been be VBN 40288 1592 20 more more RBR 40288 1592 21 luminously luminously RB 40288 1592 22 stated state VBN 40288 1592 23 than than IN 40288 1592 24 by by IN 40288 1592 25 the the DT 40288 1592 26 illustrious illustrious JJ 40288 1592 27 physicist physicist JJ 40288 1592 28 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1592 29 , , , 40288 1592 30 in in IN 40288 1592 31 the the DT 40288 1592 32 thirteenth thirteenth JJ 40288 1592 33 chapter chapter NN 40288 1592 34 of of IN 40288 1592 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1592 36 _ _ NNP 40288 1592 37 Tonempfindungen Tonempfindungen NNP 40288 1592 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1592 39 . . . 40288 1593 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1593 2 venture venture VBP 40288 1593 3 to to TO 40288 1593 4 think think VB 40288 1593 5 that that IN 40288 1593 6 in in IN 40288 1593 7 applying apply VBG 40288 1593 8 that that DT 40288 1593 9 truth truth NN 40288 1593 10 to to IN 40288 1593 11 the the DT 40288 1593 12 facts fact NNS 40288 1593 13 of of IN 40288 1593 14 Greek greek JJ 40288 1593 15 music music NN 40288 1593 16 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1593 17 was be VBD 40288 1593 18 materially materially RB 40288 1593 19 hindered hinder VBN 40288 1593 20 by by IN 40288 1593 21 the the DT 40288 1593 22 accepted accepted JJ 40288 1593 23 theory theory NN 40288 1593 24 of of IN 40288 1593 25 the the DT 40288 1593 26 Greek greek JJ 40288 1593 27 modes mode NNS 40288 1593 28 . . . 40288 1594 1 The the DT 40288 1594 2 scales scale NNS 40288 1594 3 which which WDT 40288 1594 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1594 5 analyses analyse VBZ 40288 1594 6 under under IN 40288 1594 7 that that DT 40288 1594 8 name name NN 40288 1594 9 were be VBD 40288 1594 10 certainly certainly RB 40288 1594 11 the the DT 40288 1594 12 basis basis NN 40288 1594 13 of of IN 40288 1594 14 all all DT 40288 1594 15 music music NN 40288 1594 16 in in IN 40288 1594 17 the the DT 40288 1594 18 Middle Middle NNP 40288 1594 19 Ages Ages NNPS 40288 1594 20 , , , 40288 1594 21 and and CC 40288 1594 22 are be VBP 40288 1594 23 much much RB 40288 1594 24 more more RBR 40288 1594 25 intelligible intelligible JJ 40288 1594 26 as as IN 40288 1594 27 such such JJ 40288 1594 28 than than IN 40288 1594 29 in in IN 40288 1594 30 relation relation NN 40288 1594 31 to to IN 40288 1594 32 the the DT 40288 1594 33 primitive primitive JJ 40288 1594 34 Greek greek JJ 40288 1594 35 forms form NNS 40288 1594 36 of of IN 40288 1594 37 the the DT 40288 1594 38 art[1 art[1 NN 40288 1594 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1594 40 . . . 40288 1595 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1595 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1595 3 1 1 CD 40288 1595 4 : : : 40288 1595 5 The the DT 40288 1595 6 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 40288 1595 7 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1595 8 received receive VBD 40288 1595 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1595 10 final final JJ 40288 1595 11 shape shape NN 40288 1595 12 in in IN 40288 1595 13 the the DT 40288 1595 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1595 15 Dodecachordon Dodecachordon NNP 40288 1595 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1595 17 of of IN 40288 1595 18 Glareanus Glareanus NNP 40288 1595 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1595 20 Bâle Bâle NNP 40288 1595 21 , , , 40288 1595 22 1547 1547 CD 40288 1595 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1595 24 . . . 40288 1596 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1596 2 are be VBP 40288 1596 3 substantially substantially RB 40288 1596 4 the the DT 40288 1596 5 Greek greek JJ 40288 1596 6 modes mode NNS 40288 1596 7 of of IN 40288 1596 8 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1596 9 's 's POS 40288 1596 10 theory theory NN 40288 1596 11 , , , 40288 1596 12 although although IN 40288 1596 13 the the DT 40288 1596 14 Greek greek JJ 40288 1596 15 names name NNS 40288 1596 16 which which WDT 40288 1596 17 Glareanus Glareanus NNP 40288 1596 18 adopted adopt VBD 40288 1596 19 seem seem VBP 40288 1596 20 to to TO 40288 1596 21 have have VB 40288 1596 22 been be VBN 40288 1596 23 chosen choose VBN 40288 1596 24 at at IN 40288 1596 25 haphazard haphazard NN 40288 1596 26 . . . 40288 1597 1 But but CC 40288 1597 2 the the DT 40288 1597 3 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 40288 1597 4 Modes mode NNS 40288 1597 5 , , , 40288 1597 6 as as IN 40288 1597 7 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1597 8 points point VBZ 40288 1597 9 out out RP 40288 1597 10 , , , 40288 1597 11 were be VBD 40288 1597 12 developed develop VBN 40288 1597 13 under under IN 40288 1597 14 the the DT 40288 1597 15 influence influence NN 40288 1597 16 of of IN 40288 1597 17 polyphonic polyphonic NN 40288 1597 18 music music NN 40288 1597 19 from from IN 40288 1597 20 the the DT 40288 1597 21 earlier early JJR 40288 1597 22 stages stage NNS 40288 1597 23 represented represent VBN 40288 1597 24 by by IN 40288 1597 25 the the DT 40288 1597 26 Ambrosian ambrosian JJ 40288 1597 27 and and CC 40288 1597 28 Gregorian gregorian JJ 40288 1597 29 scales scale NNS 40288 1597 30 . . . 40288 1598 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1598 2 would would MD 40288 1598 3 be be VB 40288 1598 4 a a DT 40288 1598 5 singular singular JJ 40288 1598 6 chance chance NN 40288 1598 7 if if IN 40288 1598 8 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1598 9 were be VBD 40288 1598 10 also also RB 40288 1598 11 , , , 40288 1598 12 as as IN 40288 1598 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1598 14 modes mode NNS 40288 1598 15 , , , 40288 1598 16 the the DT 40288 1598 17 source source NN 40288 1598 18 from from IN 40288 1598 19 which which WDT 40288 1598 20 the the DT 40288 1598 21 Ambrosian ambrosian JJ 40288 1598 22 and and CC 40288 1598 23 Gregorian gregorian JJ 40288 1598 24 scales scale NNS 40288 1598 25 were be VBD 40288 1598 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 40288 1598 27 derived derive VBN 40288 1598 28 . . . 40288 1599 1 Some some DT 40288 1599 2 further further JJ 40288 1599 3 hints hint NNS 40288 1599 4 on on IN 40288 1599 5 this this DT 40288 1599 6 part part NN 40288 1599 7 of of IN 40288 1599 8 the the DT 40288 1599 9 subject subject NN 40288 1599 10 may may MD 40288 1599 11 possibly possibly RB 40288 1599 12 be be VB 40288 1599 13 derived derive VBN 40288 1599 14 from from IN 40288 1599 15 the the DT 40288 1599 16 musical musical JJ 40288 1599 17 scales scale NNS 40288 1599 18 in in IN 40288 1599 19 use use NN 40288 1599 20 among among IN 40288 1599 21 nations nation NNS 40288 1599 22 that that WDT 40288 1599 23 have have VBP 40288 1599 24 not not RB 40288 1599 25 attained attain VBN 40288 1599 26 to to IN 40288 1599 27 any any DT 40288 1599 28 form form NN 40288 1599 29 of of IN 40288 1599 30 harmony harmony NN 40288 1599 31 , , , 40288 1599 32 such such JJ 40288 1599 33 as as IN 40288 1599 34 the the DT 40288 1599 35 Arabians Arabians NNPS 40288 1599 36 , , , 40288 1599 37 the the DT 40288 1599 38 Indians Indians NNPS 40288 1599 39 , , , 40288 1599 40 or or CC 40288 1599 41 the the DT 40288 1599 42 Chinese Chinese NNPS 40288 1599 43 . . . 40288 1600 1 A a DT 40288 1600 2 valuable valuable JJ 40288 1600 3 collection collection NN 40288 1600 4 of of IN 40288 1600 5 these these DT 40288 1600 6 scales scale NNS 40288 1600 7 is be VBZ 40288 1600 8 given give VBN 40288 1600 9 by by IN 40288 1600 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1600 11 A. A. NNP 40288 1600 12 J. J. NNP 40288 1600 13 Ellis Ellis NNP 40288 1600 14 at at IN 40288 1600 15 the the DT 40288 1600 16 end end NN 40288 1600 17 of of IN 40288 1600 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1600 19 translation translation NN 40288 1600 20 of of IN 40288 1600 21 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1600 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1600 23 Appendix Appendix NNP 40288 1600 24 XX XX NNP 40288 1600 25 . . . 40288 1601 1 Sect Sect NNP 40288 1601 2 . . . 40288 1602 1 K K NNP 40288 1602 2 , , , 40288 1602 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1602 4 Non Non NNP 40288 1602 5 - - JJ 40288 1602 6 harmonic harmonic JJ 40288 1602 7 Scales Scales NNPS 40288 1602 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1602 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1602 10 . . . 40288 1603 1 Among among IN 40288 1603 2 the the DT 40288 1603 3 most most RBS 40288 1603 4 interesting interesting JJ 40288 1603 5 for for IN 40288 1603 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1603 7 purpose purpose NN 40288 1603 8 are be VBP 40288 1603 9 the the DT 40288 1603 10 eight eight CD 40288 1603 11 mediaeval mediaeval JJ 40288 1603 12 Arabian arabian JJ 40288 1603 13 scales scale NNS 40288 1603 14 given give VBN 40288 1603 15 on on IN 40288 1603 16 the the DT 40288 1603 17 authority authority NN 40288 1603 18 of of IN 40288 1603 19 Professor Professor NNP 40288 1603 20 Land Land NNP 40288 1603 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1603 22 nos nos NNP 40288 1603 23 . . . 40288 1604 1 54 54 CD 40288 1604 2 - - SYM 40288 1604 3 61 61 CD 40288 1604 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1604 5 . . . 40288 1605 1 The the DT 40288 1605 2 first first JJ 40288 1605 3 three three CD 40288 1605 4 of of IN 40288 1605 5 these these DT 40288 1605 6 -- -- : 40288 1605 7 called call VBN 40288 1605 8 ' ' `` 40288 1605 9 Ochaq ochaq NN 40288 1605 10 , , , 40288 1605 11 Nawa Nawa NNP 40288 1605 12 and and CC 40288 1605 13 Boas[=i]li Boas[=i]li NNP 40288 1605 14 -- -- : 40288 1605 15 follow follow VB 40288 1605 16 the the DT 40288 1605 17 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1605 18 intonation intonation NN 40288 1605 19 , , , 40288 1605 20 and and CC 40288 1605 21 answer answer VB 40288 1605 22 respectively respectively RB 40288 1605 23 to to IN 40288 1605 24 the the DT 40288 1605 25 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1605 26 - - HYPH 40288 1605 27 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1605 28 , , , 40288 1605 29 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1605 30 , , , 40288 1605 31 and and CC 40288 1605 32 Mixo mixo JJ 40288 1605 33 - - HYPH 40288 1605 34 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1605 35 species specie NNS 40288 1605 36 of of IN 40288 1605 37 the the DT 40288 1605 38 octave octave NN 40288 1605 39 . . . 40288 1606 1 The the DT 40288 1606 2 next next JJ 40288 1606 3 two two CD 40288 1606 4 -- -- : 40288 1606 5 Rast Rast NNP 40288 1606 6 and and CC 40288 1606 7 Zenkouleh Zenkouleh NNP 40288 1606 8 -- -- : 40288 1606 9 are be VBP 40288 1606 10 also also RB 40288 1606 11 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1606 12 - - HYPH 40288 1606 13 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1606 14 in in IN 40288 1606 15 species specie NNS 40288 1606 16 , , , 40288 1606 17 but but CC 40288 1606 18 the the DT 40288 1606 19 Third Third NNP 40288 1606 20 and and CC 40288 1606 21 Sixth Sixth NNP 40288 1606 22 are be VBP 40288 1606 23 flatter flat JJR 40288 1606 24 by by IN 40288 1606 25 about about RB 40288 1606 26 an an DT 40288 1606 27 eighth eighth NN 40288 1606 28 of of IN 40288 1606 29 a a DT 40288 1606 30 tone tone NN 40288 1606 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1606 32 the the DT 40288 1606 33 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1606 34 comma comma NN 40288 1606 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1606 36 . . . 40288 1607 1 In in IN 40288 1607 2 Zenkouleh Zenkouleh NNP 40288 1607 3 the the DT 40288 1607 4 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 1607 5 also also RB 40288 1607 6 is be VBZ 40288 1607 7 similarly similarly RB 40288 1607 8 flattened flatten VBN 40288 1607 9 . . . 40288 1608 1 The the DT 40288 1608 2 last last JJ 40288 1608 3 two two CD 40288 1608 4 scales scale NNS 40288 1608 5 -- -- : 40288 1608 6 Hhosa[=i]ni Hhosa[=i]ni NNP 40288 1608 7 and and CC 40288 1608 8 Hhidjazi Hhidjazi NNP 40288 1608 9 -- -- : 40288 1608 10 are be VBP 40288 1608 11 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1608 12 : : : 40288 1608 13 but but CC 40288 1608 14 the the DT 40288 1608 15 Second Second NNP 40288 1608 16 and and CC 40288 1608 17 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 1608 18 , , , 40288 1608 19 and and CC 40288 1608 20 in in IN 40288 1608 21 the the DT 40288 1608 22 case case NN 40288 1608 23 of of IN 40288 1608 24 Hhidjazi Hhidjazi NNP 40288 1608 25 also also RB 40288 1608 26 the the DT 40288 1608 27 Sixth Sixth NNP 40288 1608 28 , , , 40288 1608 29 are be VBP 40288 1608 30 flatter flat JJR 40288 1608 31 by by IN 40288 1608 32 the the DT 40288 1608 33 interval interval NN 40288 1608 34 of of IN 40288 1608 35 a a DT 40288 1608 36 comma comma NN 40288 1608 37 . . . 40288 1609 1 The the DT 40288 1609 2 remaining remain VBG 40288 1609 3 scale scale NN 40288 1609 4 , , , 40288 1609 5 called call VBD 40288 1609 6 Rahawi Rahawi NNP 40288 1609 7 , , , 40288 1609 8 does do VBZ 40288 1609 9 not not RB 40288 1609 10 fall fall VB 40288 1609 11 under under IN 40288 1609 12 any any DT 40288 1609 13 species specie NNS 40288 1609 14 , , , 40288 1609 15 since since IN 40288 1609 16 the the DT 40288 1609 17 semitones semitone NNS 40288 1609 18 are be VBP 40288 1609 19 between between IN 40288 1609 20 the the DT 40288 1609 21 Third Third NNP 40288 1609 22 and and CC 40288 1609 23 Fourth fourth JJ 40288 1609 24 , , , 40288 1609 25 and and CC 40288 1609 26 again again RB 40288 1609 27 between between IN 40288 1609 28 the the DT 40288 1609 29 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 1609 30 and and CC 40288 1609 31 Sixth Sixth NNP 40288 1609 32 . . . 40288 1610 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1610 2 will will MD 40288 1610 3 be be VB 40288 1610 4 seen see VBN 40288 1610 5 that that IN 40288 1610 6 in in IN 40288 1610 7 general general JJ 40288 1610 8 character character NN 40288 1610 9 -- -- : 40288 1610 10 though though RB 40288 1610 11 by by IN 40288 1610 12 no no DT 40288 1610 13 means means NN 40288 1610 14 in in IN 40288 1610 15 details detail NNS 40288 1610 16 -- -- : 40288 1610 17 this this DT 40288 1610 18 series series NN 40288 1610 19 of of IN 40288 1610 20 scales scale NNS 40288 1610 21 bears bear VBZ 40288 1610 22 a a DT 40288 1610 23 considerable considerable JJ 40288 1610 24 resemblance resemblance NN 40288 1610 25 to to IN 40288 1610 26 the the DT 40288 1610 27 ' ' `` 40288 1610 28 scales scale NNS 40288 1610 29 of of IN 40288 1610 30 the the DT 40288 1610 31 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1610 32 ' ' '' 40288 1610 33 as as IN 40288 1610 34 given give VBN 40288 1610 35 by by IN 40288 1610 36 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1610 37 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1610 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1610 39 supra supra NNP 40288 1610 40 _ _ NNP 40288 1610 41 , , , 40288 1610 42 p. p. NN 40288 1610 43 85 85 CD 40288 1610 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1610 45 . . . 40288 1611 1 In in IN 40288 1611 2 both both DT 40288 1611 3 cases case NNS 40288 1611 4 the the DT 40288 1611 5 several several JJ 40288 1611 6 scales scale NNS 40288 1611 7 are be VBP 40288 1611 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 1611 9 from from IN 40288 1611 10 each each DT 40288 1611 11 other other JJ 40288 1611 12 partly partly RB 40288 1611 13 by by IN 40288 1611 14 the the DT 40288 1611 15 order order NN 40288 1611 16 of of IN 40288 1611 17 the the DT 40288 1611 18 intervals interval NNS 40288 1611 19 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1611 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1611 21 species specie NNS 40288 1611 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1611 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1611 24 , , , 40288 1611 25 partly partly RB 40288 1611 26 by by IN 40288 1611 27 the the DT 40288 1611 28 intonation intonation NN 40288 1611 29 , , , 40288 1611 30 or or CC 40288 1611 31 magnitude magnitude NN 40288 1611 32 of of IN 40288 1611 33 the the DT 40288 1611 34 intervals interval NNS 40288 1611 35 employed employ VBN 40288 1611 36 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1611 37 _ _ NNP 40288 1611 38 genus genus NNP 40288 1611 39 _ _ NNP 40288 1611 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1611 41 . . . 40288 1612 1 This this DT 40288 1612 2 latter latter JJ 40288 1612 3 element element NN 40288 1612 4 is be VBZ 40288 1612 5 conspicuously conspicuously RB 40288 1612 6 absent absent JJ 40288 1612 7 from from IN 40288 1612 8 the the DT 40288 1612 9 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 40288 1612 10 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1612 11 . . . 40288 1612 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1613 1 § § ADD 40288 1613 2 37 37 CD 40288 1613 3 . . . 40288 1614 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1614 2 Epilogue Epilogue NNP 40288 1614 3 -- -- : 40288 1614 4 Speech Speech NNP 40288 1614 5 and and CC 40288 1614 6 Song Song NNP 40288 1614 7 . . . 40288 1614 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1614 9 Several several JJ 40288 1614 10 indications indication NNS 40288 1614 11 combine combine VBP 40288 1614 12 to to TO 40288 1614 13 make make VB 40288 1614 14 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1614 15 probable probable JJ 40288 1614 16 that that IN 40288 1614 17 singing singe VBG 40288 1614 18 and and CC 40288 1614 19 speaking speaking NN 40288 1614 20 were be VBD 40288 1614 21 not not RB 40288 1614 22 so so RB 40288 1614 23 widely widely RB 40288 1614 24 separated separate VBN 40288 1614 25 from from IN 40288 1614 26 each each DT 40288 1614 27 other other JJ 40288 1614 28 in in IN 40288 1614 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1614 30 as as IN 40288 1614 31 in in IN 40288 1614 32 the the DT 40288 1614 33 modern modern JJ 40288 1614 34 languages language NNS 40288 1614 35 with with IN 40288 1614 36 which which WDT 40288 1614 37 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1614 38 are be VBP 40288 1614 39 most most RBS 40288 1614 40 familiar familiar JJ 40288 1614 41 . . . 40288 1615 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1615 2 1 1 LS 40288 1615 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1615 4 The the DT 40288 1615 5 teaching teaching NN 40288 1615 6 of of IN 40288 1615 7 the the DT 40288 1615 8 grammarians grammarian NNS 40288 1615 9 on on IN 40288 1615 10 the the DT 40288 1615 11 subject subject NN 40288 1615 12 of of IN 40288 1615 13 accent accent JJ 40288 1615 14 points point NNS 40288 1615 15 to to IN 40288 1615 16 this this DT 40288 1615 17 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 1615 18 . . . 40288 1616 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1616 2 habit habit NN 40288 1616 3 of of IN 40288 1616 4 using use VBG 40288 1616 5 Latin latin JJ 40288 1616 6 translations translation NNS 40288 1616 7 of of IN 40288 1616 8 the the DT 40288 1616 9 terms term NNS 40288 1616 10 of of IN 40288 1616 11 Greek greek JJ 40288 1616 12 grammar grammar NN 40288 1616 13 has have VBZ 40288 1616 14 tended tend VBN 40288 1616 15 to to TO 40288 1616 16 obscure obscure VB 40288 1616 17 the the DT 40288 1616 18 fact fact NN 40288 1616 19 that that IN 40288 1616 20 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1616 21 belong belong VBP 40288 1616 22 in in IN 40288 1616 23 almost almost RB 40288 1616 24 every every DT 40288 1616 25 case case NN 40288 1616 26 to to IN 40288 1616 27 the the DT 40288 1616 28 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1616 29 vocabulary vocabulary NN 40288 1616 30 of of IN 40288 1616 31 music music NN 40288 1616 32 . . . 40288 1617 1 The the DT 40288 1617 2 word word NN 40288 1617 3 for for IN 40288 1617 4 ' ' `` 40288 1617 5 accent accent NN 40288 1617 6 ' ' '' 40288 1617 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1617 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1617 9 Greek greek NN 40288 1617 10 : : : 40288 1617 11 tonos tonos NN 40288 1617 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1617 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1617 14 is be VBZ 40288 1617 15 simply simply RB 40288 1617 16 the the DT 40288 1617 17 musical musical JJ 40288 1617 18 term term NN 40288 1617 19 for for IN 40288 1617 20 ' ' `` 40288 1617 21 pitch pitch NN 40288 1617 22 ' ' '' 40288 1617 23 or or CC 40288 1617 24 ' ' `` 40288 1617 25 key key NN 40288 1617 26 . . . 40288 1617 27 ' ' '' 40288 1618 1 The the DT 40288 1618 2 words word NNS 40288 1618 3 ' ' `` 40288 1618 4 acute acute NN 40288 1618 5 ' ' '' 40288 1618 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1618 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1618 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1618 9 : : : 40288 1618 10 oxys oxys NN 40288 1618 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1618 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1618 13 and and CC 40288 1618 14 ' ' `` 40288 1618 15 grave grave NN 40288 1618 16 ' ' '' 40288 1618 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1618 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1618 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1618 20 : : : 40288 1618 21 barys barys NN 40288 1618 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1618 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1618 24 mean mean VB 40288 1618 25 nothing nothing NN 40288 1618 26 more more JJR 40288 1618 27 than than IN 40288 1618 28 ' ' `` 40288 1618 29 high high JJ 40288 1618 30 ' ' '' 40288 1618 31 and and CC 40288 1618 32 ' ' `` 40288 1618 33 low low JJ 40288 1618 34 ' ' '' 40288 1618 35 in in IN 40288 1618 36 pitch pitch NN 40288 1618 37 . . . 40288 1619 1 A a DT 40288 1619 2 syllable syllable NN 40288 1619 3 may may MD 40288 1619 4 have have VB 40288 1619 5 two two CD 40288 1619 6 accents accent NNS 40288 1619 7 , , , 40288 1619 8 just just RB 40288 1619 9 as as IN 40288 1619 10 in in IN 40288 1619 11 music music NN 40288 1619 12 a a DT 40288 1619 13 syllable syllable NN 40288 1619 14 may may MD 40288 1619 15 be be VB 40288 1619 16 sung sing VBN 40288 1619 17 with with IN 40288 1619 18 more more JJR 40288 1619 19 than than IN 40288 1619 20 one one CD 40288 1619 21 note note NN 40288 1619 22 . . . 40288 1620 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 1620 2 the the DT 40288 1620 3 ' ' `` 40288 1620 4 quantity quantity NN 40288 1620 5 ' ' '' 40288 1620 6 of of IN 40288 1620 7 each each DT 40288 1620 8 syllable syllable JJ 40288 1620 9 answers answer NNS 40288 1620 10 to to IN 40288 1620 11 the the DT 40288 1620 12 time time NN 40288 1620 13 of of IN 40288 1620 14 a a DT 40288 1620 15 musical musical JJ 40288 1620 16 note note NN 40288 1620 17 , , , 40288 1620 18 and and CC 40288 1620 19 the the DT 40288 1620 20 rule rule NN 40288 1620 21 that that IN 40288 1620 22 a a DT 40288 1620 23 long long JJ 40288 1620 24 syllable syllable NN 40288 1620 25 is be VBZ 40288 1620 26 equal equal JJ 40288 1620 27 to to IN 40288 1620 28 two two CD 40288 1620 29 short short JJ 40288 1620 30 ones one NNS 40288 1620 31 is be VBZ 40288 1620 32 no no RB 40288 1620 33 doubt doubt RB 40288 1620 34 approximately approximately RB 40288 1620 35 correct correct JJ 40288 1620 36 . . . 40288 1621 1 Consequently consequently RB 40288 1621 2 every every DT 40288 1621 3 Greek greek JJ 40288 1621 4 word word NN 40288 1621 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1621 6 enclitics enclitic NNS 40288 1621 7 being be VBG 40288 1621 8 reckoned reckon VBN 40288 1621 9 as as IN 40288 1621 10 parts part NNS 40288 1621 11 of of IN 40288 1621 12 a a DT 40288 1621 13 word word NN 40288 1621 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1621 15 is be VBZ 40288 1621 16 a a DT 40288 1621 17 sort sort NN 40288 1621 18 of of IN 40288 1621 19 musical musical JJ 40288 1621 20 phrase phrase NN 40288 1621 21 , , , 40288 1621 22 and and CC 40288 1621 23 every every DT 40288 1621 24 sentence sentence NN 40288 1621 25 is be VBZ 40288 1621 26 a a DT 40288 1621 27 more more RBR 40288 1621 28 or or CC 40288 1621 29 less less RBR 40288 1621 30 definite definite JJ 40288 1621 31 melody--[Greek melody--[greek CD 40288 1621 32 : : : 40288 1621 33 logôdes logôde NNS 40288 1621 34 ti ti NNP 40288 1621 35 melos melos NNP 40288 1621 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1621 37 , , , 40288 1621 38 as as IN 40288 1621 39 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1621 40 is be VBZ 40288 1621 41 called call VBN 40288 1621 42 by by IN 40288 1621 43 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1621 44 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1621 45 p. p. NN 40288 1621 46 18 18 CD 40288 1621 47 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1621 48 . . . 40288 1621 49 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1621 50 . . . 40288 1622 1 Moreover moreover RB 40288 1622 2 the the DT 40288 1622 3 accent accent NN 40288 1622 4 in in IN 40288 1622 5 the the DT 40288 1622 6 modern modern JJ 40288 1622 7 sense sense NN 40288 1622 8 , , , 40288 1622 9 the the DT 40288 1622 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1622 11 ictus ictus NN 40288 1622 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1622 13 or or CC 40288 1622 14 stress stress NN 40288 1622 15 of of IN 40288 1622 16 the the DT 40288 1622 17 voice voice NN 40288 1622 18 , , , 40288 1622 19 appears appear VBZ 40288 1622 20 to to TO 40288 1622 21 be be VB 40288 1622 22 quite quite RB 40288 1622 23 independent independent JJ 40288 1622 24 of of IN 40288 1622 25 the the DT 40288 1622 26 pitch pitch NN 40288 1622 27 or or CC 40288 1622 28 ' ' `` 40288 1622 29 tonic tonic NN 40288 1622 30 ' ' '' 40288 1622 31 accent accent NN 40288 1622 32 : : : 40288 1622 33 for for IN 40288 1622 34 in in IN 40288 1622 35 Greek greek JJ 40288 1622 36 poetry poetry NN 40288 1622 37 the the DT 40288 1622 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1622 39 ictus ictus NN 40288 1622 40 _ _ NNP 40288 1622 41 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1622 42 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1622 43 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1622 44 : : : 40288 1622 45 arsis arsis NN 40288 1622 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1622 47 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1622 48 is be VBZ 40288 1622 49 determined determine VBN 40288 1622 50 by by IN 40288 1622 51 the the DT 40288 1622 52 metre metre NNP 40288 1622 53 , , , 40288 1622 54 with with IN 40288 1622 55 which which WDT 40288 1622 56 the the DT 40288 1622 57 tonic tonic NN 40288 1622 58 accent accent NN 40288 1622 59 evidently evidently RB 40288 1622 60 has have VBZ 40288 1622 61 nothing nothing NN 40288 1622 62 to to TO 40288 1622 63 do do VB 40288 1622 64 . . . 40288 1623 1 In in IN 40288 1623 2 singing singing NN 40288 1623 3 , , , 40288 1623 4 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 1623 5 , , , 40288 1623 6 the the DT 40288 1623 7 tonic tonic NN 40288 1623 8 accents accent NNS 40288 1623 9 disappear disappear VBP 40288 1623 10 ; ; : 40288 1623 11 for for IN 40288 1623 12 the the DT 40288 1623 13 melody melody NN 40288 1623 14 takes take VBZ 40288 1623 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1623 16 place place NN 40288 1623 17 , , , 40288 1623 18 and and CC 40288 1623 19 gives give VBZ 40288 1623 20 each each DT 40288 1623 21 syllable syllable NN 40288 1623 22 a a DT 40288 1623 23 new new JJ 40288 1623 24 pitch pitch NN 40288 1623 25 , , , 40288 1623 26 on on IN 40288 1623 27 which which WDT 40288 1623 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1623 29 as as IN 40288 1623 30 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1623 31 shall shall MD 40288 1623 32 presently presently RB 40288 1623 33 see see VB 40288 1623 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1623 35 the the DT 40288 1623 36 spoken spoken JJ 40288 1623 37 pitch pitch NN 40288 1623 38 has have VBZ 40288 1623 39 no no DT 40288 1623 40 influence influence NN 40288 1623 41 . . . 40288 1624 1 The the DT 40288 1624 2 rise rise NN 40288 1624 3 and and CC 40288 1624 4 fall fall NN 40288 1624 5 of of IN 40288 1624 6 the the DT 40288 1624 7 voice voice NN 40288 1624 8 in in IN 40288 1624 9 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1624 10 speaking speaking NN 40288 1624 11 is be VBZ 40288 1624 12 perceptible perceptible JJ 40288 1624 13 enough enough RB 40288 1624 14 in in IN 40288 1624 15 English English NNP 40288 1624 16 , , , 40288 1624 17 though though IN 40288 1624 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1624 19 is be VBZ 40288 1624 20 more more RBR 40288 1624 21 marked marked JJ 40288 1624 22 in in IN 40288 1624 23 other other JJ 40288 1624 24 European european JJ 40288 1624 25 languages language NNS 40288 1624 26 . . . 40288 1625 1 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1625 2 tells tell VBZ 40288 1625 3 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1625 4 -- -- : 40288 1625 5 with with IN 40288 1625 6 tacit tacit JJ 40288 1625 7 reference reference NN 40288 1625 8 to to IN 40288 1625 9 the the DT 40288 1625 10 speech speech NN 40288 1625 11 of of IN 40288 1625 12 North North NNP 40288 1625 13 Germany Germany NNP 40288 1625 14 -- -- : 40288 1625 15 that that IN 40288 1625 16 an an DT 40288 1625 17 affirmative affirmative JJ 40288 1625 18 sentence sentence NN 40288 1625 19 generally generally RB 40288 1625 20 ends end VBZ 40288 1625 21 with with IN 40288 1625 22 a a DT 40288 1625 23 drop drop NN 40288 1625 24 in in IN 40288 1625 25 the the DT 40288 1625 26 tone tone NN 40288 1625 27 of of IN 40288 1625 28 about about RB 40288 1625 29 a a DT 40288 1625 30 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1625 31 , , , 40288 1625 32 while while IN 40288 1625 33 an an DT 40288 1625 34 interrogative interrogative NN 40288 1625 35 is be VBZ 40288 1625 36 marked mark VBN 40288 1625 37 by by IN 40288 1625 38 a a DT 40288 1625 39 rise rise NN 40288 1625 40 which which WDT 40288 1625 41 is be VBZ 40288 1625 42 often often RB 40288 1625 43 as as RB 40288 1625 44 much much JJ 40288 1625 45 as as IN 40288 1625 46 a a DT 40288 1625 47 Fifth[1 fifth[1 NN 40288 1625 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1625 49 . . . 40288 1626 1 In in IN 40288 1626 2 Italian italian JJ 40288 1626 3 the the DT 40288 1626 4 interrogative interrogative JJ 40288 1626 5 form form NN 40288 1626 6 is be VBZ 40288 1626 7 regularly regularly RB 40288 1626 8 given give VBN 40288 1626 9 , , , 40288 1626 10 not not RB 40288 1626 11 by by IN 40288 1626 12 a a DT 40288 1626 13 particle particle NN 40288 1626 14 or or CC 40288 1626 15 a a DT 40288 1626 16 change change NN 40288 1626 17 in in IN 40288 1626 18 the the DT 40288 1626 19 order order NN 40288 1626 20 of of IN 40288 1626 21 the the DT 40288 1626 22 words word NNS 40288 1626 23 , , , 40288 1626 24 but but CC 40288 1626 25 by by IN 40288 1626 26 a a DT 40288 1626 27 rise rise NN 40288 1626 28 of of IN 40288 1626 29 pitch pitch NN 40288 1626 30 . . . 40288 1627 1 The the DT 40288 1627 2 Gregorian gregorian JJ 40288 1627 3 church church NN 40288 1627 4 music music NN 40288 1627 5 , , , 40288 1627 6 according accord VBG 40288 1627 7 to to IN 40288 1627 8 a a DT 40288 1627 9 series series NN 40288 1627 10 of of IN 40288 1627 11 rules rule NNS 40288 1627 12 quoted quote VBN 40288 1627 13 by by IN 40288 1627 14 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 40288 1627 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1627 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1627 17 l l NNP 40288 1627 18 . . . 40288 1628 1 c. c. NNP 40288 1628 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1628 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1628 4 , , , 40288 1628 5 marked mark VBD 40288 1628 6 a a DT 40288 1628 7 comma comma NN 40288 1628 8 by by IN 40288 1628 9 a a DT 40288 1628 10 rise rise NN 40288 1628 11 of of IN 40288 1628 12 a a DT 40288 1628 13 Tone tone NN 40288 1628 14 , , , 40288 1628 15 a a DT 40288 1628 16 colon colon NN 40288 1628 17 by by IN 40288 1628 18 a a DT 40288 1628 19 fall fall NN 40288 1628 20 of of IN 40288 1628 21 a a DT 40288 1628 22 Semitone Semitone NNP 40288 1628 23 ; ; : 40288 1628 24 a a DT 40288 1628 25 full full JJ 40288 1628 26 stop stop NN 40288 1628 27 by by IN 40288 1628 28 a a DT 40288 1628 29 Tone tone NN 40288 1628 30 above above RB 40288 1628 31 , , , 40288 1628 32 followed follow VBN 40288 1628 33 by by IN 40288 1628 34 a a DT 40288 1628 35 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1628 36 below below RB 40288 1628 37 , , , 40288 1628 38 the the DT 40288 1628 39 ' ' `` 40288 1628 40 reciting recite VBG 40288 1628 41 note note NN 40288 1628 42 ' ' '' 40288 1628 43 ; ; : 40288 1628 44 and and CC 40288 1628 45 an an DT 40288 1628 46 interrogation interrogation NN 40288 1628 47 by by IN 40288 1628 48 a a DT 40288 1628 49 phrase phrase NN 40288 1628 50 of of IN 40288 1628 51 the the DT 40288 1628 52 form form NN 40288 1628 53 _ _ NNP 40288 1628 54 d d NNP 40288 1628 55 b b NNP 40288 1628 56 c c NNP 40288 1628 57 d d NNP 40288 1628 58 _ _ NNP 40288 1628 59 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1628 60 _ _ NNP 40288 1628 61 c c NNP 40288 1628 62 _ _ NNP 40288 1628 63 being be VBG 40288 1628 64 the the DT 40288 1628 65 reciting recite VBG 40288 1628 66 note note NN 40288 1628 67 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1628 68 . . . 40288 1629 1 These these DT 40288 1629 2 examples example NNS 40288 1629 3 , , , 40288 1629 4 however however RB 40288 1629 5 , , , 40288 1629 6 do do VBP 40288 1629 7 little little JJ 40288 1629 8 towards towards IN 40288 1629 9 enabling enable VBG 40288 1629 10 modern modern JJ 40288 1629 11 scholars scholar NNS 40288 1629 12 to to TO 40288 1629 13 form form VB 40288 1629 14 a a DT 40288 1629 15 notion notion NN 40288 1629 16 of of IN 40288 1629 17 the the DT 40288 1629 18 Greek greek JJ 40288 1629 19 system system NN 40288 1629 20 of of IN 40288 1629 21 accentuation accentuation NN 40288 1629 22 . . . 40288 1630 1 In in IN 40288 1630 2 these these DT 40288 1630 3 and and CC 40288 1630 4 similar similar JJ 40288 1630 5 cases case NNS 40288 1630 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1630 7 is be VBZ 40288 1630 8 the the DT 40288 1630 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1630 10 sentence sentence NN 40288 1630 11 as as IN 40288 1630 12 a a DT 40288 1630 13 whole whole JJ 40288 1630 14 _ _ NN 40288 1630 15 which which WDT 40288 1630 16 is be VBZ 40288 1630 17 modified modify VBN 40288 1630 18 by by IN 40288 1630 19 the the DT 40288 1630 20 tonic tonic NN 40288 1630 21 accent accent NN 40288 1630 22 , , , 40288 1630 23 whereas whereas IN 40288 1630 24 in in IN 40288 1630 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1630 26 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1630 27 is be VBZ 40288 1630 28 the the DT 40288 1630 29 individual individual JJ 40288 1630 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1630 31 word word NN 40288 1630 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1630 33 . . . 40288 1631 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1631 2 is be VBZ 40288 1631 3 true true JJ 40288 1631 4 that that IN 40288 1631 5 the the DT 40288 1631 6 accent accent NN 40288 1631 7 of of IN 40288 1631 8 a a DT 40288 1631 9 word word NN 40288 1631 10 may may MD 40288 1631 11 be be VB 40288 1631 12 affected affect VBN 40288 1631 13 by by IN 40288 1631 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1631 15 place place NN 40288 1631 16 in in IN 40288 1631 17 the the DT 40288 1631 18 sentence sentence NN 40288 1631 19 : : : 40288 1631 20 as as IN 40288 1631 21 is be VBZ 40288 1631 22 seen see VBN 40288 1631 23 in in IN 40288 1631 24 the the DT 40288 1631 25 loss loss NN 40288 1631 26 of of IN 40288 1631 27 the the DT 40288 1631 28 accent accent NN 40288 1631 29 of of IN 40288 1631 30 oxytone oxytone JJ 40288 1631 31 words word NNS 40288 1631 32 when when WRB 40288 1631 33 not not RB 40288 1631 34 followed follow VBN 40288 1631 35 by by IN 40288 1631 36 a a DT 40288 1631 37 pause pause NN 40288 1631 38 , , , 40288 1631 39 in in IN 40288 1631 40 the the DT 40288 1631 41 anastrophe anastrophe NN 40288 1631 42 of of IN 40288 1631 43 prepositions preposition NNS 40288 1631 44 , , , 40288 1631 45 and and CC 40288 1631 46 in in IN 40288 1631 47 the the DT 40288 1631 48 treatment treatment NN 40288 1631 49 of of IN 40288 1631 50 the the DT 40288 1631 51 different different JJ 40288 1631 52 classes class NNS 40288 1631 53 of of IN 40288 1631 54 enclitics enclitic NNS 40288 1631 55 . . . 40288 1632 1 But but CC 40288 1632 2 in in IN 40288 1632 3 all all PDT 40288 1632 4 these these DT 40288 1632 5 instances instance NNS 40288 1632 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1632 7 is be VBZ 40288 1632 8 the the DT 40288 1632 9 intonation intonation NN 40288 1632 10 of of IN 40288 1632 11 the the DT 40288 1632 12 word word NN 40288 1632 13 as as IN 40288 1632 14 such such JJ 40288 1632 15 , , , 40288 1632 16 not not RB 40288 1632 17 of of IN 40288 1632 18 the the DT 40288 1632 19 sentence sentence NN 40288 1632 20 , , , 40288 1632 21 which which WDT 40288 1632 22 is be VBZ 40288 1632 23 primarily primarily RB 40288 1632 24 concerned concern VBN 40288 1632 25 . . . 40288 1633 1 What what WP 40288 1633 2 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1633 3 really really RB 40288 1633 4 prove prove VBP 40288 1633 5 is be VBZ 40288 1633 6 that that IN 40288 1633 7 the the DT 40288 1633 8 musical musical JJ 40288 1633 9 accent accent NN 40288 1633 10 is be VBZ 40288 1633 11 not not RB 40288 1633 12 so so RB 40288 1633 13 invariable invariable JJ 40288 1633 14 as as IN 40288 1633 15 the the DT 40288 1633 16 stress stress NN 40288 1633 17 accent accent NN 40288 1633 18 in in IN 40288 1633 19 English English NNP 40288 1633 20 or or CC 40288 1633 21 German German NNP 40288 1633 22 , , , 40288 1633 23 but but CC 40288 1633 24 may may MD 40288 1633 25 depend depend VB 40288 1633 26 upon upon IN 40288 1633 27 the the DT 40288 1633 28 collocation collocation NN 40288 1633 29 of of IN 40288 1633 30 the the DT 40288 1633 31 word word NN 40288 1633 32 , , , 40288 1633 33 or or CC 40288 1633 34 upon upon IN 40288 1633 35 the the DT 40288 1633 36 degree degree NN 40288 1633 37 of of IN 40288 1633 38 emphasis emphasis NN 40288 1633 39 which which WDT 40288 1633 40 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1633 41 has have VBZ 40288 1633 42 in in IN 40288 1633 43 a a DT 40288 1633 44 particular particular JJ 40288 1633 45 use use NN 40288 1633 46 . . . 40288 1634 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1634 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1634 3 1 1 CD 40288 1634 4 : : : 40288 1634 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1634 6 Tonempfindungen Tonempfindungen NNP 40288 1634 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1634 8 , , , 40288 1634 9 p. p. NN 40288 1634 10 364 364 CD 40288 1634 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1634 12 ed ed NN 40288 1634 13 . . . 40288 1635 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 1635 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1635 3 . . . 40288 1635 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1636 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1636 2 2 2 LS 40288 1636 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1636 4 The the DT 40288 1636 5 same same JJ 40288 1636 6 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 1636 7 may may MD 40288 1636 8 be be VB 40288 1636 9 drawn draw VBN 40288 1636 10 from from IN 40288 1636 11 the the DT 40288 1636 12 terms term NNS 40288 1636 13 in in IN 40288 1636 14 which which WDT 40288 1636 15 the the DT 40288 1636 16 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1636 17 writers writer NNS 40288 1636 18 on on IN 40288 1636 19 music music NN 40288 1636 20 endeavour endeavour NN 40288 1636 21 to to TO 40288 1636 22 distinguish distinguish VB 40288 1636 23 musical musical JJ 40288 1636 24 and and CC 40288 1636 25 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1636 26 utterance utterance NN 40288 1636 27 . . . 40288 1637 1 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1637 2 begins begin VBZ 40288 1637 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1637 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 5 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 1637 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 7 by by IN 40288 1637 8 observing observe VBG 40288 1637 9 that that IN 40288 1637 10 there there EX 40288 1637 11 are be VBP 40288 1637 12 two two CD 40288 1637 13 movements movement NNS 40288 1637 14 of of IN 40288 1637 15 the the DT 40288 1637 16 voice voice NN 40288 1637 17 , , , 40288 1637 18 not not RB 40288 1637 19 properly properly RB 40288 1637 20 discriminated discriminate VBN 40288 1637 21 by by IN 40288 1637 22 any any DT 40288 1637 23 previous previous JJ 40288 1637 24 writer writer NN 40288 1637 25 ; ; : 40288 1637 26 namely namely RB 40288 1637 27 , , , 40288 1637 28 the the DT 40288 1637 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 30 continuous continuous JJ 40288 1637 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 32 , , , 40288 1637 33 which which WDT 40288 1637 34 is be VBZ 40288 1637 35 the the DT 40288 1637 36 movement movement NN 40288 1637 37 characteristic characteristic NN 40288 1637 38 of of IN 40288 1637 39 speaking speak VBG 40288 1637 40 , , , 40288 1637 41 and and CC 40288 1637 42 the the DT 40288 1637 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 44 discrete discrete JJ 40288 1637 45 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 46 or or CC 40288 1637 47 that that IN 40288 1637 48 which which WDT 40288 1637 49 proceeds proceed VBZ 40288 1637 50 by by IN 40288 1637 51 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 52 intervals interval NNS 40288 1637 53 _ _ NNP 40288 1637 54 , , , 40288 1637 55 the the DT 40288 1637 56 movement movement NN 40288 1637 57 of of IN 40288 1637 58 singing singing NN 40288 1637 59 . . . 40288 1638 1 In in IN 40288 1638 2 the the DT 40288 1638 3 latter latter JJ 40288 1638 4 the the DT 40288 1638 5 voice voice NN 40288 1638 6 remains remain VBZ 40288 1638 7 for for IN 40288 1638 8 a a DT 40288 1638 9 certain certain JJ 40288 1638 10 time time NN 40288 1638 11 on on IN 40288 1638 12 one one CD 40288 1638 13 note note NN 40288 1638 14 , , , 40288 1638 15 and and CC 40288 1638 16 then then RB 40288 1638 17 passes pass VBZ 40288 1638 18 by by IN 40288 1638 19 a a DT 40288 1638 20 definite definite JJ 40288 1638 21 interval interval NN 40288 1638 22 to to IN 40288 1638 23 another another DT 40288 1638 24 . . . 40288 1639 1 In in IN 40288 1639 2 the the DT 40288 1639 3 former former JJ 40288 1639 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1639 5 is be VBZ 40288 1639 6 continually continually RB 40288 1639 7 gliding glide VBG 40288 1639 8 by by IN 40288 1639 9 imperceptible imperceptible JJ 40288 1639 10 degrees degree NNS 40288 1639 11 from from IN 40288 1639 12 higher high JJR 40288 1639 13 to to IN 40288 1639 14 lower low JJR 40288 1639 15 or or CC 40288 1639 16 the the DT 40288 1639 17 reverse[1 reverse[1 NNP 40288 1639 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1639 19 . . . 40288 1640 1 In in IN 40288 1640 2 this this DT 40288 1640 3 kind kind NN 40288 1640 4 of of IN 40288 1640 5 movement movement NN 40288 1640 6 the the DT 40288 1640 7 rise rise NN 40288 1640 8 and and CC 40288 1640 9 fall fall NN 40288 1640 10 of of IN 40288 1640 11 the the DT 40288 1640 12 voice voice NN 40288 1640 13 is be VBZ 40288 1640 14 marked mark VBN 40288 1640 15 by by IN 40288 1640 16 the the DT 40288 1640 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1640 18 accents accent NNS 40288 1640 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1640 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1640 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1640 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1640 23 : : : 40288 1640 24 prosôdiai prosôdiai NN 40288 1640 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1640 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1640 27 , , , 40288 1640 28 which which WDT 40288 1640 29 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 1640 30 form form VBP 40288 1640 31 the the DT 40288 1640 32 melody melody NN 40288 1640 33 , , , 40288 1640 34 as as IN 40288 1640 35 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1640 36 may may MD 40288 1640 37 be be VB 40288 1640 38 called call VBN 40288 1640 39 , , , 40288 1640 40 of of IN 40288 1640 41 spoken speak VBN 40288 1640 42 utterance[2 utterance[2 NNP 40288 1640 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1640 44 . . . 40288 1641 1 Later later JJ 40288 1641 2 writers writer NNS 40288 1641 3 state state VBP 40288 1641 4 the the DT 40288 1641 5 distinction distinction NN 40288 1641 6 in in IN 40288 1641 7 much much RB 40288 1641 8 the the DT 40288 1641 9 same same JJ 40288 1641 10 language language NN 40288 1641 11 . . . 40288 1642 1 Nicomachus Nicomachus NNP 40288 1642 2 tells tell VBZ 40288 1642 3 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1642 4 that that IN 40288 1642 5 the the DT 40288 1642 6 two two CD 40288 1642 7 movements movement NNS 40288 1642 8 were be VBD 40288 1642 9 first first RB 40288 1642 10 discriminated discriminate VBN 40288 1642 11 by by IN 40288 1642 12 the the DT 40288 1642 13 Pythagoreans Pythagoreans NNPS 40288 1642 14 . . . 40288 1643 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1643 2 dwells dwell VBZ 40288 1643 3 especially especially RB 40288 1643 4 on on IN 40288 1643 5 the the DT 40288 1643 6 ease ease NN 40288 1643 7 with with IN 40288 1643 8 which which WDT 40288 1643 9 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1643 10 pass pass VBP 40288 1643 11 from from IN 40288 1643 12 one one CD 40288 1643 13 to to IN 40288 1643 14 the the DT 40288 1643 15 other other JJ 40288 1643 16 . . . 40288 1644 1 If if IN 40288 1644 2 the the DT 40288 1644 3 notes note NNS 40288 1644 4 and and CC 40288 1644 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 1644 6 of of IN 40288 1644 7 the the DT 40288 1644 8 speaking speak VBG 40288 1644 9 voice voice NN 40288 1644 10 are be VBP 40288 1644 11 allowed allow VBN 40288 1644 12 to to TO 40288 1644 13 be be VB 40288 1644 14 separate separate JJ 40288 1644 15 and and CC 40288 1644 16 distinct distinct JJ 40288 1644 17 , , , 40288 1644 18 the the DT 40288 1644 19 form form NN 40288 1644 20 of of IN 40288 1644 21 utterance utterance NN 40288 1644 22 becomes become VBZ 40288 1644 23 singing[3 singing[3 NNP 40288 1644 24 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1644 25 . . . 40288 1645 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 1645 2 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1645 3 says say VBZ 40288 1645 4 that that IN 40288 1645 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1645 6 do do VBP 40288 1645 7 not not RB 40288 1645 8 rest rest VB 40288 1645 9 upon upon IN 40288 1645 10 a a DT 40288 1645 11 note note NN 40288 1645 12 , , , 40288 1645 13 unless unless IN 40288 1645 14 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1645 15 are be VBP 40288 1645 16 led lead VBN 40288 1645 17 to to TO 40288 1645 18 do do VB 40288 1645 19 so so RB 40288 1645 20 by by IN 40288 1645 21 the the DT 40288 1645 22 influence influence NN 40288 1645 23 of of IN 40288 1645 24 feeling feeling NN 40288 1645 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1645 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1645 27 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1645 28 : : : 40288 1645 29 an an DT 40288 1645 30 mê mê NNP 40288 1645 31 dia dia NNP 40288 1645 32 pathos pathos NNP 40288 1645 33 pote pote NNP 40288 1645 34 eis eis NNP 40288 1645 35 toiautên toiautên NNP 40288 1645 36 kinêsin kinêsin NNP 40288 1645 37 anankasthômen anankasthômen NNP 40288 1645 38 elthein elthein NNP 40288 1645 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1645 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1645 41 . . . 40288 1646 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1646 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1646 3 1 1 CD 40288 1646 4 : : : 40288 1646 5 Aristox Aristox NNP 40288 1646 6 . . . 40288 1646 7 , , , 40288 1646 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1646 9 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1646 10 . . . 40288 1646 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1646 12 p. p. NN 40288 1646 13 3 3 CD 40288 1646 14 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1646 15 . . . 40288 1647 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1647 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1647 3 : : : 40288 1647 4 kineitai kineitai NNP 40288 1647 5 men man NNS 40288 1647 6 gar gar NNP 40288 1647 7 kai kai NNP 40288 1647 8 dialegomenôn dialegomenôn NNP 40288 1647 9 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 40288 1647 10 kai kai NNP 40288 1647 11 melôdountôn melôdountôn NNP 40288 1647 12 tên tên NNP 40288 1647 13 eirêmenên eirêmenên NNP 40288 1647 14 kinêsin kinêsin NNP 40288 1647 15 ; ; : 40288 1647 16 oxy oxy NNP 40288 1647 17 gar gar NNP 40288 1647 18 kai kai NNP 40288 1647 19 bary bary NNP 40288 1647 20 dêlon dêlon NNP 40288 1647 21 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1647 22 en en IN 40288 1647 23 amphoterois amphoterois NNP 40288 1647 24 toutois toutois NNP 40288 1647 25 enestin enestin NNP 40288 1647 26 . . . 40288 1647 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1648 1 Also also RB 40288 1648 2 p. p. NN 40288 1648 3 8 8 CD 40288 1648 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1648 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1648 6 : : : 40288 1648 7 dyo dyo NN 40288 1648 8 tines tines NNPS 40288 1648 9 eisin eisin NNP 40288 1648 10 ideai ideai NNP 40288 1648 11 kinêseôs kinêseôs NNP 40288 1648 12 , , , 40288 1648 13 hê hê NNP 40288 1648 14 te te NNP 40288 1648 15 synechês synechês NNP 40288 1648 16 kai kai NNP 40288 1648 17 hê hê NNP 40288 1648 18 diastêmatikê diastêmatikê NNP 40288 1648 19 ; ; : 40288 1648 20 kata kata NNP 40288 1648 21 men man NNS 40288 1648 22 oun oun NNP 40288 1648 23 tên tên NNP 40288 1648 24 synechê synechê NNP 40288 1648 25 topon topon NNP 40288 1648 26 tina tina NNP 40288 1648 27 diexienai diexienai NNP 40288 1648 28 phainetai phainetai NNP 40288 1648 29 hê hê NNP 40288 1648 30 phônê phônê NNP 40288 1648 31 tê tê NNP 40288 1648 32 aisthêsei aisthêsei NNP 40288 1648 33 houtôs houtôs NNP 40288 1648 34 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1648 35 an an DT 40288 1648 36 mêdamou mêdamou NN 40288 1648 37 histamenê histamenê NN 40288 1648 38 , , , 40288 1648 39 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1648 40 . . . 40288 1648 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1649 1 And and CC 40288 1649 2 p. p. NN 40288 1649 3 9 9 CD 40288 1649 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1649 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1649 6 : : : 40288 1649 7 tên tên NNP 40288 1649 8 oun oun NNP 40288 1649 9 synechê synechê NNP 40288 1649 10 logikên logikên NNP 40288 1649 11 einai einai NNP 40288 1649 12 phanen phanen NNP 40288 1649 13 , , , 40288 1649 14 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1649 15 . . . 40288 1649 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1649 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1650 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1650 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1650 3 2 2 CD 40288 1650 4 : : : 40288 1650 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 40288 1650 6 . . . 40288 1651 1 p. p. NN 40288 1651 2 18 18 CD 40288 1651 3 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1651 4 . . . 40288 1652 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1652 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1652 3 : : : 40288 1652 4 tou tou NNP 40288 1652 5 ge ge NNP 40288 1652 6 logôdous logôdous JJ 40288 1652 7 kechôristai kechôristai NNP 40288 1652 8 tautê tautê NNP 40288 1652 9 to to IN 40288 1652 10 mousikon mousikon NNP 40288 1652 11 melos melos NNP 40288 1652 12 ; ; : 40288 1652 13 legetai legetai NNP 40288 1652 14 gar gar NNP 40288 1652 15 dê dê NNP 40288 1652 16 kai kai NNP 40288 1652 17 logôdes logôde NNS 40288 1652 18 ti ti NNP 40288 1652 19 melos melos NNP 40288 1652 20 , , , 40288 1652 21 to to TO 40288 1652 22 synkeimenon synkeimenon VB 40288 1652 23 ek ek NNP 40288 1652 24 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1652 25 prosôdiôn prosôdiôn NNP 40288 1652 26 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1652 27 en en NNP 40288 1652 28 tois tois NNP 40288 1652 29 onomasin onomasin NNP 40288 1652 30 ; ; : 40288 1652 31 physikon physikon NNP 40288 1652 32 gar gar NNP 40288 1652 33 to to IN 40288 1652 34 epiteinein epiteinein NNP 40288 1652 35 kai kai NNP 40288 1652 36 anienai anienai NNP 40288 1652 37 en en NNP 40288 1652 38 tô tô NNP 40288 1652 39 dialegesthai dialegesthai NNP 40288 1652 40 . . . 40288 1652 41 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1652 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1653 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1653 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1653 3 3 3 CD 40288 1653 4 : : : 40288 1653 5 Nicomachus Nicomachus NNP 40288 1653 6 , , , 40288 1653 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1653 8 Enchiridion Enchiridion NNP 40288 1653 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1653 10 , , , 40288 1653 11 p. p. NN 40288 1653 12 4 4 CD 40288 1653 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1653 14 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1653 15 : : : 40288 1653 16 ei ei NNP 40288 1653 17 gar gar NNP 40288 1653 18 tis tis NNP 40288 1653 19 ê ê NNP 40288 1653 20 dialegomenos dialegomeno VBD 40288 1653 21 ê ê NNP 40288 1653 22 apologoumenos apologoumenos NNP 40288 1653 23 tini tini NNP 40288 1653 24 ê ê NNP 40288 1653 25 anaginôskôn anaginôskôn NNP 40288 1653 26 ge ge NNP 40288 1653 27 ekdêla ekdêla NNP 40288 1653 28 metaxy metaxy NNP 40288 1653 29 kath kath NNP 40288 1653 30 ' ' POS 40288 1653 31 hekaston hekaston NNP 40288 1653 32 phthongon phthongon NNP 40288 1653 33 poiei poiei NNP 40288 1653 34 ta ta NNP 40288 1653 35 megethê megethê NNP 40288 1653 36 , , , 40288 1653 37 diistanôn diistanôn NNP 40288 1653 38 kai kai NNP 40288 1653 39 metaballôn metaballôn NNP 40288 1653 40 tên tên NNP 40288 1653 41 phônên phônên NN 40288 1653 42 ap ap NNP 40288 1653 43 ' ' '' 40288 1653 44 allou allou NNP 40288 1653 45 eis eis NNP 40288 1653 46 allon allon NNP 40288 1653 47 , , , 40288 1653 48 ouketi ouketi NNP 40288 1653 49 legein legein NNP 40288 1653 50 ho ho NNP 40288 1653 51 toioutos toioutos NNP 40288 1653 52 oude oude NNP 40288 1653 53 anaginôskein anaginôskein NNP 40288 1653 54 alla alla NNP 40288 1653 55 meleazein meleazein NNP 40288 1653 56 legetai legetai NNP 40288 1653 57 . . . 40288 1653 58 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1653 59 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1654 1 According accord VBG 40288 1654 2 to to IN 40288 1654 3 the the DT 40288 1654 4 rhetorician rhetorician JJ 40288 1654 5 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1654 6 of of IN 40288 1654 7 Halicarnassus Halicarnassus NNP 40288 1654 8 the the DT 40288 1654 9 interval interval NN 40288 1654 10 used use VBN 40288 1654 11 in in IN 40288 1654 12 the the DT 40288 1654 13 melody melody NN 40288 1654 14 of of IN 40288 1654 15 spoken spoken JJ 40288 1654 16 utterance utterance NN 40288 1654 17 is be VBZ 40288 1654 18 approximately approximately RB 40288 1654 19 a a DT 40288 1654 20 Fifth fifth JJ 40288 1654 21 , , , 40288 1654 22 or or CC 40288 1654 23 three three CD 40288 1654 24 tones tone NNS 40288 1654 25 and and CC 40288 1654 26 a a DT 40288 1654 27 half half NN 40288 1654 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1654 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1654 30 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1654 31 : : : 40288 1654 32 dialektou dialektou NNP 40288 1654 33 men man NNS 40288 1654 34 oun oun NNP 40288 1654 35 melos melos NNP 40288 1654 36 heni heni NNP 40288 1654 37 metreitai metreitai NNP 40288 1654 38 diastêmati diastêmati NNP 40288 1654 39 tô tô NNP 40288 1654 40 legomenô legomenô NNP 40288 1654 41 dia dia NNP 40288 1654 42 pente pente NNP 40288 1654 43 , , , 40288 1654 44 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1654 45 engista engista NNP 40288 1654 46 ; ; : 40288 1654 47 kai kai NNP 40288 1654 48 oute oute NNP 40288 1654 49 epiteinetai epiteinetai NNP 40288 1654 50 pera pera NNP 40288 1654 51 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1654 52 triôn triôn NNP 40288 1654 53 tonôn tonôn NNP 40288 1654 54 kai kai NNP 40288 1654 55 hêmitoniou hêmitoniou NNP 40288 1654 56 epi epi NNP 40288 1654 57 to to IN 40288 1654 58 oxy oxy NNP 40288 1654 59 oute oute NNP 40288 1654 60 anietai anietai NNP 40288 1654 61 tou tou NNP 40288 1654 62 chôriou chôriou NNP 40288 1654 63 toutou toutou NNP 40288 1654 64 pleion pleion NN 40288 1654 65 epi epi NNP 40288 1654 66 to to IN 40288 1654 67 bary][1 bary][1 NNP 40288 1654 68 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1654 69 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1654 70 . . . 40288 1655 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1655 2 gives give VBZ 40288 1655 3 an an DT 40288 1655 4 interesting interesting JJ 40288 1655 5 example example NN 40288 1655 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1655 7 quoted quote VBN 40288 1655 8 above above RB 40288 1655 9 on on IN 40288 1655 10 p. p. NN 40288 1655 11 91 91 CD 40288 1655 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1655 13 from from IN 40288 1655 14 the the DT 40288 1655 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1655 16 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1655 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1655 18 of of IN 40288 1655 19 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1655 20 , , , 40288 1655 21 to to TO 40288 1655 22 show show VB 40288 1655 23 that that IN 40288 1655 24 when when WRB 40288 1655 25 words word NNS 40288 1655 26 are be VBP 40288 1655 27 set set VBN 40288 1655 28 to to IN 40288 1655 29 music music NN 40288 1655 30 no no DT 40288 1655 31 account account NN 40288 1655 32 is be VBZ 40288 1655 33 taken take VBN 40288 1655 34 of of IN 40288 1655 35 the the DT 40288 1655 36 accents accent NNS 40288 1655 37 , , , 40288 1655 38 or or CC 40288 1655 39 spoken speak VBN 40288 1655 40 melody melody NN 40288 1655 41 . . . 40288 1656 1 Not not RB 40288 1656 2 merely merely RB 40288 1656 3 are be VBP 40288 1656 4 the the DT 40288 1656 5 intervals interval NNS 40288 1656 6 varied vary VBN 40288 1656 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1656 8 instead instead RB 40288 1656 9 of of IN 40288 1656 10 being be VBG 40288 1656 11 nearly nearly RB 40288 1656 12 uniform uniform JJ 40288 1656 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1656 14 , , , 40288 1656 15 but but CC 40288 1656 16 the the DT 40288 1656 17 rise rise NN 40288 1656 18 and and CC 40288 1656 19 fall fall NN 40288 1656 20 of of IN 40288 1656 21 the the DT 40288 1656 22 notes note NNS 40288 1656 23 does do VBZ 40288 1656 24 not not RB 40288 1656 25 answer answer VB 40288 1656 26 to to IN 40288 1656 27 the the DT 40288 1656 28 rise rise NN 40288 1656 29 and and CC 40288 1656 30 fall fall NN 40288 1656 31 of of IN 40288 1656 32 the the DT 40288 1656 33 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1656 34 in in IN 40288 1656 35 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1656 36 speech speech NN 40288 1656 37 . . . 40288 1657 1 This this DT 40288 1657 2 statement statement NN 40288 1657 3 is be VBZ 40288 1657 4 rendered render VBN 40288 1657 5 the the DT 40288 1657 6 more more RBR 40288 1657 7 interesting interesting JJ 40288 1657 8 from from IN 40288 1657 9 the the DT 40288 1657 10 circumstance circumstance NN 40288 1657 11 that that WDT 40288 1657 12 the the DT 40288 1657 13 inscription inscription NN 40288 1657 14 discovered discover VBN 40288 1657 15 by by IN 40288 1657 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1657 17 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1657 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1657 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1657 20 supra supra NNP 40288 1657 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1657 22 , , , 40288 1657 23 p. p. NN 40288 1657 24 89 89 CD 40288 1657 25 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1657 26 , , , 40288 1657 27 which which WDT 40288 1657 28 is be VBZ 40288 1657 29 about about RB 40288 1657 30 a a DT 40288 1657 31 century century NN 40288 1657 32 later later RB 40288 1657 33 , , , 40288 1657 34 does do VBZ 40288 1657 35 exhibit exhibit VB 40288 1657 36 precisely precisely RB 40288 1657 37 this this DT 40288 1657 38 correspondence correspondence NN 40288 1657 39 . . . 40288 1658 1 Apparently apparently RB 40288 1658 2 , , , 40288 1658 3 then then RB 40288 1658 4 , , , 40288 1658 5 the the DT 40288 1658 6 melody melody NN 40288 1658 7 of of IN 40288 1658 8 the the DT 40288 1658 9 inscription inscription NN 40288 1658 10 represents represent VBZ 40288 1658 11 a a DT 40288 1658 12 new new JJ 40288 1658 13 idea idea NN 40288 1658 14 in in IN 40288 1658 15 music,--an music,--an NNP 40288 1658 16 attempt attempt VB 40288 1658 17 to to TO 40288 1658 18 bring bring VB 40288 1658 19 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1658 20 into into IN 40288 1658 21 a a DT 40288 1658 22 more more RBR 40288 1658 23 direct direct JJ 40288 1658 24 connexion connexion NN 40288 1658 25 with with IN 40288 1658 26 the the DT 40288 1658 27 tones tone NNS 40288 1658 28 of of IN 40288 1658 29 the the DT 40288 1658 30 speaking speak VBG 40288 1658 31 voice voice NN 40288 1658 32 . . . 40288 1659 1 The the DT 40288 1659 2 fact fact NN 40288 1659 3 of of IN 40288 1659 4 such such PDT 40288 1659 5 an an DT 40288 1659 6 attempt attempt NN 40288 1659 7 being be VBG 40288 1659 8 made make VBN 40288 1659 9 seems seem VBZ 40288 1659 10 to to TO 40288 1659 11 indicate indicate VB 40288 1659 12 that that IN 40288 1659 13 the the DT 40288 1659 14 divergence divergence NN 40288 1659 15 between between IN 40288 1659 16 the the DT 40288 1659 17 two two CD 40288 1659 18 kinds kind NNS 40288 1659 19 of of IN 40288 1659 20 utterance utterance NN 40288 1659 21 was be VBD 40288 1659 22 becoming become VBG 40288 1659 23 more more RBR 40288 1659 24 marked marked JJ 40288 1659 25 than than IN 40288 1659 26 had have VBD 40288 1659 27 formerly formerly RB 40288 1659 28 been be VBN 40288 1659 29 the the DT 40288 1659 30 case case NN 40288 1659 31 . . . 40288 1660 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1660 2 may may MD 40288 1660 3 be be VB 40288 1660 4 compared compare VBN 40288 1660 5 with with IN 40288 1660 6 the the DT 40288 1660 7 invention invention NN 40288 1660 8 of of IN 40288 1660 9 recitative recitative NN 40288 1660 10 in in IN 40288 1660 11 the the DT 40288 1660 12 beginning beginning NN 40288 1660 13 of of IN 40288 1660 14 the the DT 40288 1660 15 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 40288 1660 16 century century NN 40288 1660 17 . . . 40288 1661 1 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1661 2 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 1661 3 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1661 4 p. p. NN 40288 1661 5 7 7 CD 40288 1661 6 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1661 7 . . . 40288 1661 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1662 1 recognises recognise VBZ 40288 1662 2 a a DT 40288 1662 3 third third JJ 40288 1662 4 or or CC 40288 1662 5 intermediate intermediate JJ 40288 1662 6 movement movement NN 40288 1662 7 of of IN 40288 1662 8 the the DT 40288 1662 9 voice voice NN 40288 1662 10 , , , 40288 1662 11 viz viz NN 40288 1662 12 . . . 40288 1663 1 that that DT 40288 1663 2 which which WDT 40288 1663 3 is be VBZ 40288 1663 4 employed employ VBN 40288 1663 5 in in IN 40288 1663 6 the the DT 40288 1663 7 recitation recitation NN 40288 1663 8 of of IN 40288 1663 9 poetry poetry NN 40288 1663 10 . . . 40288 1664 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1664 2 is be VBZ 40288 1664 3 probable probable JJ 40288 1664 4 that that IN 40288 1664 5 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1664 6 is be VBZ 40288 1664 7 one one CD 40288 1664 8 of of IN 40288 1664 9 the the DT 40288 1664 10 latest late JJS 40288 1664 11 writers writer NNS 40288 1664 12 on on IN 40288 1664 13 the the DT 40288 1664 14 subject subject NN 40288 1664 15 , , , 40288 1664 16 and and CC 40288 1664 17 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1664 18 may may MD 40288 1664 19 conjecture conjecture VB 40288 1664 20 that that DT 40288 1664 21 in in IN 40288 1664 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1664 23 time time NN 40288 1664 24 the the DT 40288 1664 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1664 26 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1664 27 Footnote Footnote NNP 40288 1664 28 1 1 CD 40288 1664 29 : : : 40288 1664 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1664 31 De De NNP 40288 1664 32 Compositione Compositione NNP 40288 1664 33 Verborum Verborum NNP 40288 1664 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1664 35 , , , 40288 1664 36 c. c. NNP 40288 1664 37 11 11 CD 40288 1664 38 , , , 40288 1664 39 p. p. NN 40288 1664 40 58 58 CD 40288 1664 41 Reisk Reisk NNP 40288 1664 42 . . . 40288 1664 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1665 1 language language NN 40288 1665 2 had have VBD 40288 1665 3 in in IN 40288 1665 4 great great JJ 40288 1665 5 measure measure NN 40288 1665 6 lost lose VBD 40288 1665 7 the the DT 40288 1665 8 original original JJ 40288 1665 9 tonic tonic NN 40288 1665 10 accents accent NNS 40288 1665 11 , , , 40288 1665 12 and and CC 40288 1665 13 with with IN 40288 1665 14 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1665 15 the the DT 40288 1665 16 quasi quasi JJ 40288 1665 17 - - JJ 40288 1665 18 melodious melodious JJ 40288 1665 19 character character NN 40288 1665 20 which which WDT 40288 1665 21 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1665 22 gave give VBD 40288 1665 23 to to TO 40288 1665 24 prose prose VB 40288 1665 25 utterance utterance NN 40288 1665 26 . . . 40288 1666 1 In in IN 40288 1666 2 the the DT 40288 1666 3 view view NN 40288 1666 4 which which WDT 40288 1666 5 these these DT 40288 1666 6 notices notice NNS 40288 1666 7 suggest suggest VBP 40288 1666 8 the the DT 40288 1666 9 difference difference NN 40288 1666 10 between between IN 40288 1666 11 speaking speak VBG 40288 1666 12 and and CC 40288 1666 13 singing singing NN 40288 1666 14 is be VBZ 40288 1666 15 reduced reduce VBN 40288 1666 16 to to IN 40288 1666 17 one one CD 40288 1666 18 of of IN 40288 1666 19 degree degree NN 40288 1666 20 . . . 40288 1667 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1667 2 is be VBZ 40288 1667 3 analysed analyse VBN 40288 1667 4 in in IN 40288 1667 5 language language NN 40288 1667 6 such such JJ 40288 1667 7 as as IN 40288 1667 8 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1667 9 might may MD 40288 1667 10 use use VB 40288 1667 11 to to TO 40288 1667 12 express express VB 40288 1667 13 the the DT 40288 1667 14 difference difference NN 40288 1667 15 between between IN 40288 1667 16 a a DT 40288 1667 17 monotonous monotonous JJ 40288 1667 18 and and CC 40288 1667 19 a a DT 40288 1667 20 varied varied JJ 40288 1667 21 manner manner NN 40288 1667 22 of of IN 40288 1667 23 speaking speaking NN 40288 1667 24 , , , 40288 1667 25 or or CC 40288 1667 26 between between IN 40288 1667 27 the the DT 40288 1667 28 sounds sound NNS 40288 1667 29 of of IN 40288 1667 30 an an DT 40288 1667 31 Aeolian aeolian JJ 40288 1667 32 harp harp NN 40288 1667 33 and and CC 40288 1667 34 those those DT 40288 1667 35 of of IN 40288 1667 36 a a DT 40288 1667 37 musical musical JJ 40288 1667 38 instrument instrument NN 40288 1667 39 . . . 40288 1668 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1668 2 3 3 LS 40288 1668 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1668 4 What what WP 40288 1668 5 has have VBZ 40288 1668 6 been be VBN 40288 1668 7 said say VBN 40288 1668 8 of of IN 40288 1668 9 melody melody NN 40288 1668 10 in in IN 40288 1668 11 the the DT 40288 1668 12 two two CD 40288 1668 13 spheres sphere NNS 40288 1668 14 of of IN 40288 1668 15 speech speech NN 40288 1668 16 and and CC 40288 1668 17 song song NN 40288 1668 18 applies apply VBZ 40288 1668 19 also also RB 40288 1668 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1668 21 mutatis mutatis NN 40288 1668 22 mutandis mutandis NN 40288 1668 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1668 24 to to TO 40288 1668 25 rhythm rhythm VB 40288 1668 26 . . . 40288 1669 1 In in IN 40288 1669 2 English English NNP 40288 1669 3 the the DT 40288 1669 4 time time NN 40288 1669 5 or or CC 40288 1669 6 quantity quantity NN 40288 1669 7 of of IN 40288 1669 8 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1669 9 is be VBZ 40288 1669 10 as as RB 40288 1669 11 little little JJ 40288 1669 12 attended attended JJ 40288 1669 13 to to IN 40288 1669 14 as as IN 40288 1669 15 the the DT 40288 1669 16 pitch pitch NN 40288 1669 17 . . . 40288 1670 1 But but CC 40288 1670 2 in in IN 40288 1670 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1670 4 the the DT 40288 1670 5 distinction distinction NN 40288 1670 6 of of IN 40288 1670 7 long long JJ 40288 1670 8 and and CC 40288 1670 9 short short JJ 40288 1670 10 furnished furnish VBD 40288 1670 11 a a DT 40288 1670 12 prose prose JJ 40288 1670 13 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1670 14 which which WDT 40288 1670 15 was be VBD 40288 1670 16 a a DT 40288 1670 17 serious serious JJ 40288 1670 18 element element NN 40288 1670 19 in in IN 40288 1670 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1670 21 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40288 1670 22 . . . 40288 1671 1 In in IN 40288 1671 2 the the DT 40288 1671 3 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1671 4 of of IN 40288 1671 5 music music NN 40288 1671 6 , , , 40288 1671 7 according accord VBG 40288 1671 8 to to IN 40288 1671 9 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1671 10 , , , 40288 1671 11 the the DT 40288 1671 12 quantity quantity NN 40288 1671 13 of of IN 40288 1671 14 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1671 15 could could MD 40288 1671 16 be be VB 40288 1671 17 neglected neglect VBN 40288 1671 18 , , , 40288 1671 19 just just RB 40288 1671 20 as as IN 40288 1671 21 the the DT 40288 1671 22 accent accent NN 40288 1671 23 was be VBD 40288 1671 24 neglected neglect VBN 40288 1671 25 in in IN 40288 1671 26 the the DT 40288 1671 27 melody[1 melody[1 NNP 40288 1671 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1671 29 . . . 40288 1672 1 This this DT 40288 1672 2 , , , 40288 1672 3 however however RB 40288 1672 4 , , , 40288 1672 5 does do VBZ 40288 1672 6 not not RB 40288 1672 7 mean mean VB 40288 1672 8 that that IN 40288 1672 9 the the DT 40288 1672 10 natural natural JJ 40288 1672 11 time time NN 40288 1672 12 of of IN 40288 1672 13 the the DT 40288 1672 14 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1672 15 could could MD 40288 1672 16 be be VB 40288 1672 17 treated treat VBN 40288 1672 18 with with IN 40288 1672 19 the the DT 40288 1672 20 freedom freedom NN 40288 1672 21 which which WDT 40288 1672 22 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1672 23 see see VBP 40288 1672 24 in in IN 40288 1672 25 a a DT 40288 1672 26 modern modern JJ 40288 1672 27 composition composition NN 40288 1672 28 . . . 40288 1673 1 The the DT 40288 1673 2 regularity regularity NN 40288 1673 3 of of IN 40288 1673 4 lyric lyric NN 40288 1673 5 metres metre NNS 40288 1673 6 is be VBZ 40288 1673 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 40288 1673 8 to to TO 40288 1673 9 prove prove VB 40288 1673 10 that that IN 40288 1673 11 the the DT 40288 1673 12 increase increase NN 40288 1673 13 or or CC 40288 1673 14 diminution diminution NN 40288 1673 15 of of IN 40288 1673 16 natural natural JJ 40288 1673 17 quantity quantity NN 40288 1673 18 referred refer VBN 40288 1673 19 to to IN 40288 1673 20 by by IN 40288 1673 21 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1673 22 was be VBD 40288 1673 23 kept keep VBN 40288 1673 24 within within IN 40288 1673 25 narrow narrow JJ 40288 1673 26 limits limit NNS 40288 1673 27 , , , 40288 1673 28 the the DT 40288 1673 29 nature nature NN 40288 1673 30 of of IN 40288 1673 31 which which WDT 40288 1673 32 is be VBZ 40288 1673 33 to to TO 40288 1673 34 be be VB 40288 1673 35 gathered gather VBN 40288 1673 36 from from IN 40288 1673 37 the the DT 40288 1673 38 remains remain NNS 40288 1673 39 of of IN 40288 1673 40 the the DT 40288 1673 41 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1673 42 system system NN 40288 1673 43 of of IN 40288 1673 44 Rhythmic Rhythmic NNP 40288 1673 45 . . . 40288 1674 1 From from IN 40288 1674 2 these these DT 40288 1674 3 sources source NNS 40288 1674 4 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1674 5 learn learn VBP 40288 1674 6 with with IN 40288 1674 7 something something NN 40288 1674 8 like like IN 40288 1674 9 certainty certainty NN 40288 1674 10 that that IN 40288 1674 11 the the DT 40288 1674 12 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1674 13 of of IN 40288 1674 14 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1674 15 speech speech NN 40288 1674 16 , , , 40288 1674 17 as as IN 40288 1674 18 determined determine VBN 40288 1674 19 by by IN 40288 1674 20 the the DT 40288 1674 21 succession succession NN 40288 1674 22 of of IN 40288 1674 23 long long JJ 40288 1674 24 or or CC 40288 1674 25 short short JJ 40288 1674 26 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1674 27 , , , 40288 1674 28 was be VBD 40288 1674 29 the the DT 40288 1674 30 basis basis NN 40288 1674 31 not not RB 40288 1674 32 only only RB 40288 1674 33 of of IN 40288 1674 34 metres metre NNS 40288 1674 35 intended intend VBN 40288 1674 36 for for IN 40288 1674 37 recitation recitation NN 40288 1674 38 , , , 40288 1674 39 such such JJ 40288 1674 40 as as IN 40288 1674 41 the the DT 40288 1674 42 hexameter hexameter NN 40288 1674 43 and and CC 40288 1674 44 the the DT 40288 1674 45 iambic iambic JJ 40288 1674 46 trimeter trimeter NN 40288 1674 47 , , , 40288 1674 48 but but CC 40288 1674 49 also also RB 40288 1674 50 of of IN 40288 1674 51 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 1674 52 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1674 53 of of IN 40288 1674 54 every every DT 40288 1674 55 kind kind NN 40288 1674 56 . . . 40288 1675 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1675 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1675 3 1 1 CD 40288 1675 4 : : : 40288 1675 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1675 6 De De NNP 40288 1675 7 Comp Comp NNP 40288 1675 8 . . . 40288 1675 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1675 10 c. c. NNP 40288 1675 11 11 11 CD 40288 1675 12 , , , 40288 1675 13 p. p. NN 40288 1675 14 64 64 CD 40288 1675 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1675 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1675 17 : : : 40288 1675 18 to to TO 40288 1675 19 de de NNP 40288 1675 20 auto auto NNP 40288 1675 21 ginetai ginetai NNP 40288 1675 22 kai kai NNP 40288 1675 23 peri peri NNP 40288 1675 24 tous tous NNP 40288 1675 25 rhythmous rhythmous NNP 40288 1675 26 ; ; : 40288 1675 27 hê hê NN 40288 1675 28 men man NNS 40288 1675 29 gar gar NNP 40288 1675 30 pezê pezê NNP 40288 1675 31 lexis lexis NNP 40288 1675 32 oudenos oudenos NNP 40288 1675 33 oute oute NNP 40288 1675 34 onomatos onomatos NNP 40288 1675 35 oute oute NNP 40288 1675 36 rhêmatos rhêmatos NNP 40288 1675 37 biazetai biazetai NNP 40288 1675 38 tous tous JJ 40288 1675 39 chronous chronous JJ 40288 1675 40 oude oude NN 40288 1675 41 metatithêsin metatithêsin NN 40288 1675 42 , , , 40288 1675 43 all all DT 40288 1675 44 ' ' `` 40288 1675 45 oias oias NNP 40288 1675 46 pareilêphe pareilêphe NNP 40288 1675 47 tê tê DT 40288 1675 48 physei physei NNP 40288 1675 49 tas tas NNP 40288 1675 50 syllabas syllabas NNP 40288 1675 51 , , , 40288 1675 52 tas tas NNP 40288 1675 53 te te NNP 40288 1675 54 makras makras NNP 40288 1675 55 kai kai NNP 40288 1675 56 tas tas NNP 40288 1675 57 bracheias bracheias NNP 40288 1675 58 , , , 40288 1675 59 toiautas toiautas NNP 40288 1675 60 phylattei phylattei NNP 40288 1675 61 ; ; : 40288 1675 62 hê hê NNP 40288 1675 63 de de NNP 40288 1675 64 mousikê mousikê NNP 40288 1675 65 te te NNP 40288 1675 66 kai kai NNP 40288 1675 67 rhythmikê rhythmikê NNP 40288 1675 68 metaballousin metaballousin NNP 40288 1675 69 autas autas NNP 40288 1675 70 meiousai meiousai NNP 40288 1675 71 kai kai NNP 40288 1675 72 parauxousai parauxousai NNP 40288 1675 73 , , , 40288 1675 74 ôite ôite NNP 40288 1675 75 pollakis pollakis NNP 40288 1675 76 eis eis NNP 40288 1675 77 tanantia tanantia NNP 40288 1675 78 metachôrein metachôrein NNP 40288 1675 79 ; ; : 40288 1675 80 ou ou NNP 40288 1675 81 gar gar NNP 40288 1675 82 tais tais NNP 40288 1675 83 syllabais syllabais NNP 40288 1675 84 apeuthynousi apeuthynousi NNP 40288 1675 85 tous tous JJ 40288 1675 86 chronous chronous JJ 40288 1675 87 , , , 40288 1675 88 alla alla NNP 40288 1675 89 tois tois NNP 40288 1675 90 chronois chronois NNP 40288 1675 91 tas tas NNP 40288 1675 92 syllabas syllabas NNP 40288 1675 93 . . . 40288 1675 94 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1675 95 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1676 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1676 2 4 4 LS 40288 1676 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1676 4 As as IN 40288 1676 5 to to IN 40288 1676 6 the the DT 40288 1676 7 use use NN 40288 1676 8 of of IN 40288 1676 9 the the DT 40288 1676 10 stress stress NN 40288 1676 11 accent accent NN 40288 1676 12 in in IN 40288 1676 13 Greek greek JJ 40288 1676 14 prose prose NN 40288 1676 15 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1676 16 are be VBP 40288 1676 17 without without IN 40288 1676 18 direct direct JJ 40288 1676 19 information information NN 40288 1676 20 . . . 40288 1677 1 In in IN 40288 1677 2 verse verse NN 40288 1677 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1677 4 appears appear VBZ 40288 1677 5 as as IN 40288 1677 6 the the DT 40288 1677 7 metrical metrical JJ 40288 1677 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1677 9 ictus ictus NN 40288 1677 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1677 11 or or CC 40288 1677 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1677 13 arsis arsis NN 40288 1677 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1677 15 of of IN 40288 1677 16 each each DT 40288 1677 17 foot foot NN 40288 1677 18 , , , 40288 1677 19 which which WDT 40288 1677 20 answers answer VBZ 40288 1677 21 to to IN 40288 1677 22 what what WP 40288 1677 23 English english JJ 40288 1677 24 musicians musician NNS 40288 1677 25 call call VBP 40288 1677 26 the the DT 40288 1677 27 ' ' `` 40288 1677 28 strong strong JJ 40288 1677 29 beat beat NN 40288 1677 30 ' ' '' 40288 1677 31 or or CC 40288 1677 32 accented accented JJ 40288 1677 33 part part NN 40288 1677 34 of of IN 40288 1677 35 the the DT 40288 1677 36 bar[1 bar[1 NN 40288 1677 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1677 38 . . . 40288 1678 1 In in IN 40288 1678 2 the the DT 40288 1678 3 Homeric Homeric NNP 40288 1678 4 hexameter hexameter NN 40288 1678 5 the the DT 40288 1678 6 ictus ictus NN 40288 1678 7 is be VBZ 40288 1678 8 confined confine VBN 40288 1678 9 to to IN 40288 1678 10 long long JJ 40288 1678 11 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1678 12 , , , 40288 1678 13 and and CC 40288 1678 14 appears appear VBZ 40288 1678 15 to to TO 40288 1678 16 have have VB 40288 1678 17 some some DT 40288 1678 18 power power NN 40288 1678 19 of of IN 40288 1678 20 lengthening lengthen VBG 40288 1678 21 a a DT 40288 1678 22 short short JJ 40288 1678 23 or or CC 40288 1678 24 doubtful doubtful JJ 40288 1678 25 syllable syllable NN 40288 1678 26 . . . 40288 1679 1 In in IN 40288 1679 2 the the DT 40288 1679 3 Attic attic JJ 40288 1679 4 poetry poetry NN 40288 1679 5 which which WDT 40288 1679 6 was be VBD 40288 1679 7 written write VBN 40288 1679 8 in in IN 40288 1679 9 direct direct JJ 40288 1679 10 imitation imitation NN 40288 1679 11 of of IN 40288 1679 12 colloquial colloquial JJ 40288 1679 13 speech speech NN 40288 1679 14 , , , 40288 1679 15 viz viz NN 40288 1679 16 . . . 40288 1680 1 the the DT 40288 1680 2 tragic tragic JJ 40288 1680 3 and and CC 40288 1680 4 comic comic JJ 40288 1680 5 trimeter trimeter NN 40288 1680 6 , , , 40288 1680 7 there there EX 40288 1680 8 is be VBZ 40288 1680 9 no no DT 40288 1680 10 necessary necessary JJ 40288 1680 11 connexion connexion NN 40288 1680 12 between between IN 40288 1680 13 the the DT 40288 1680 14 ictus ictus NN 40288 1680 15 and and CC 40288 1680 16 syllabic syllabic JJ 40288 1680 17 length length NN 40288 1680 18 : : : 40288 1680 19 but but CC 40288 1680 20 on on IN 40288 1680 21 the the DT 40288 1680 22 other other JJ 40288 1680 23 hand hand NN 40288 1680 24 a a DT 40288 1680 25 naturally naturally RB 40288 1680 26 long long JJ 40288 1680 27 syllable syllable NN 40288 1680 28 which which WDT 40288 1680 29 is be VBZ 40288 1680 30 without without IN 40288 1680 31 the the DT 40288 1680 32 ictus ictus NN 40288 1680 33 may may MD 40288 1680 34 be be VB 40288 1680 35 rhythmically rhythmically RB 40288 1680 36 short short JJ 40288 1680 37 . . . 40288 1681 1 In in IN 40288 1681 2 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 1681 3 versification versification NN 40288 1681 4 the the DT 40288 1681 5 ictus ictus NN 40288 1681 6 does do VBZ 40288 1681 7 not not RB 40288 1681 8 seem seem VB 40288 1681 9 to to TO 40288 1681 10 have have VB 40288 1681 11 any any DT 40288 1681 12 connexion connexion NN 40288 1681 13 with with IN 40288 1681 14 quantity quantity NN 40288 1681 15 : : : 40288 1681 16 and and CC 40288 1681 17 on on IN 40288 1681 18 the the DT 40288 1681 19 whole whole NN 40288 1681 20 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1681 21 may may MD 40288 1681 22 gather gather VB 40288 1681 23 that that IN 40288 1681 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1681 25 was be VBD 40288 1681 26 not not RB 40288 1681 27 until until IN 40288 1681 28 the the DT 40288 1681 29 Byzantine byzantine JJ 40288 1681 30 period period NN 40288 1681 31 of of IN 40288 1681 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1681 33 that that IN 40288 1681 34 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1681 35 came come VBD 40288 1681 36 to to TO 40288 1681 37 be be VB 40288 1681 38 recognised recognise VBN 40288 1681 39 as as IN 40288 1681 40 a a DT 40288 1681 41 distinct distinct JJ 40288 1681 42 factor factor NN 40288 1681 43 in in IN 40288 1681 44 pronunciation pronunciation NN 40288 1681 45 . . . 40288 1682 1 The the DT 40288 1682 2 chief chief JJ 40288 1682 3 elements element NNS 40288 1682 4 of of IN 40288 1682 5 utterance utterance NN 40288 1682 6 -- -- : 40288 1682 7 pitch pitch NN 40288 1682 8 , , , 40288 1682 9 time time NN 40288 1682 10 and and CC 40288 1682 11 stress stress NN 40288 1682 12 -- -- : 40288 1682 13 were be VBD 40288 1682 14 independent independent JJ 40288 1682 15 in in IN 40288 1682 16 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1682 17 Greek greek JJ 40288 1682 18 speech speech NN 40288 1682 19 , , , 40288 1682 20 just just RB 40288 1682 21 as as IN 40288 1682 22 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1682 23 are be VBP 40288 1682 24 in in IN 40288 1682 25 music music NN 40288 1682 26 . . . 40288 1683 1 And and CC 40288 1683 2 the the DT 40288 1683 3 fact fact NN 40288 1683 4 that that IN 40288 1683 5 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1683 6 were be VBD 40288 1683 7 independent independent JJ 40288 1683 8 goes go VBZ 40288 1683 9 a a DT 40288 1683 10 long long JJ 40288 1683 11 way way NN 40288 1683 12 to to TO 40288 1683 13 prove prove VB 40288 1683 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1683 15 main main JJ 40288 1683 16 contention contention NN 40288 1683 17 , , , 40288 1683 18 viz viz NN 40288 1683 19 . . . 40288 1684 1 that that DT 40288 1684 2 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1684 3 Greek greek JJ 40288 1684 4 speech speech NN 40288 1684 5 had have VBD 40288 1684 6 a a DT 40288 1684 7 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 1684 8 quasi quasi JJ 40288 1684 9 - - JJ 40288 1684 10 musical musical JJ 40288 1684 11 character character NN 40288 1684 12 , , , 40288 1684 13 consequently consequently RB 40288 1684 14 that that IN 40288 1684 15 the the DT 40288 1684 16 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 1684 17 which which WDT 40288 1684 18 modern modern JJ 40288 1684 19 scholars scholar NNS 40288 1684 20 feel feel VBP 40288 1684 21 in in IN 40288 1684 22 understanding understand VBG 40288 1684 23 the the DT 40288 1684 24 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1684 25 statements statement NNS 40288 1684 26 on on IN 40288 1684 27 such such JJ 40288 1684 28 matters matter NNS 40288 1684 29 as as IN 40288 1684 30 accent accent NN 40288 1684 31 and and CC 40288 1684 32 quantity quantity NN 40288 1684 33 is be VBZ 40288 1684 34 simply simply RB 40288 1684 35 the the DT 40288 1684 36 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 1684 37 of of IN 40288 1684 38 conceiving conceive VBG 40288 1684 39 a a DT 40288 1684 40 form form NN 40288 1684 41 of of IN 40288 1684 42 utterance utterance NN 40288 1684 43 of of IN 40288 1684 44 which which WDT 40288 1684 45 no no DT 40288 1684 46 examples example NNS 40288 1684 47 can can MD 40288 1684 48 now now RB 40288 1684 49 be be VB 40288 1684 50 observed observe VBN 40288 1684 51 . . . 40288 1685 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1685 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1685 3 1 1 CD 40288 1685 4 : : : 40288 1685 5 The the DT 40288 1685 6 metrical metrical JJ 40288 1685 7 accent accent NN 40288 1685 8 or or CC 40288 1685 9 ictus ictus NN 40288 1685 10 was be VBD 40288 1685 11 marked mark VBN 40288 1685 12 in in IN 40288 1685 13 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1685 14 notation notation NN 40288 1685 15 by by IN 40288 1685 16 points point NNS 40288 1685 17 placed place VBN 40288 1685 18 over over IN 40288 1685 19 the the DT 40288 1685 20 accented accented JJ 40288 1685 21 syllable syllable NN 40288 1685 22 . . . 40288 1686 1 These these DT 40288 1686 2 points point NNS 40288 1686 3 have have VBP 40288 1686 4 been be VBN 40288 1686 5 preserved preserve VBN 40288 1686 6 in in IN 40288 1686 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1686 8 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1686 9 's 's POS 40288 1686 10 musical musical JJ 40288 1686 11 inscription inscription NN 40288 1686 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1686 13 see see VB 40288 1686 14 the the DT 40288 1686 15 Appendix Appendix NNP 40288 1686 16 , , , 40288 1686 17 p. p. NN 40288 1686 18 133 133 CD 40288 1686 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1686 20 and and CC 40288 1686 21 in in IN 40288 1686 22 one one CD 40288 1686 23 or or CC 40288 1686 24 two two CD 40288 1686 25 places place NNS 40288 1686 26 of of IN 40288 1686 27 the the DT 40288 1686 28 fragment fragment NN 40288 1686 29 of of IN 40288 1686 30 the the DT 40288 1686 31 _ _ NNP 40288 1686 32 Orestes Orestes NNP 40288 1686 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1686 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1686 35 p. p. NN 40288 1686 36 130 130 CD 40288 1686 37 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1686 38 . . . 40288 1687 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1687 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1687 3 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1687 4 has have VBZ 40288 1687 5 been be VBN 40288 1687 6 able able JJ 40288 1687 7 to to TO 40288 1687 8 restore restore VB 40288 1687 9 the the DT 40288 1687 10 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1687 11 with with IN 40288 1687 12 tolerable tolerable JJ 40288 1687 13 certainty certainty NN 40288 1687 14 , , , 40288 1687 15 and and CC 40288 1687 16 has have VBZ 40288 1687 17 made make VBN 40288 1687 18 the the DT 40288 1687 19 interesting interesting JJ 40288 1687 20 discovery discovery NN 40288 1687 21 that that IN 40288 1687 22 in in IN 40288 1687 23 both both DT 40288 1687 24 pieces piece NNS 40288 1687 25 the the DT 40288 1687 26 ictus ictus NN 40288 1687 27 falls fall VBZ 40288 1687 28 as as IN 40288 1687 29 a a DT 40288 1687 30 rule rule NN 40288 1687 31 on on IN 40288 1687 32 a a DT 40288 1687 33 short short JJ 40288 1687 34 syllable syllable NN 40288 1687 35 . . . 40288 1688 1 The the DT 40288 1688 2 only only JJ 40288 1688 3 exceptions exception NNS 40288 1688 4 in in IN 40288 1688 5 the the DT 40288 1688 6 inscription inscription NN 40288 1688 7 are be VBP 40288 1688 8 circumflexed circumflexe VBN 40288 1688 9 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1688 10 , , , 40288 1688 11 where where WRB 40288 1688 12 the the DT 40288 1688 13 long long JJ 40288 1688 14 vowel vowel NNP 40288 1688 15 or or CC 40288 1688 16 diphthong diphthong NNP 40288 1688 17 is be VBZ 40288 1688 18 set set VBN 40288 1688 19 to to IN 40288 1688 20 two two CD 40288 1688 21 notes note NNS 40288 1688 22 , , , 40288 1688 23 the the DT 40288 1688 24 first first JJ 40288 1688 25 of of IN 40288 1688 26 which which WDT 40288 1688 27 is be VBZ 40288 1688 28 short short JJ 40288 1688 29 and and CC 40288 1688 30 accented accented JJ 40288 1688 31 . . . 40288 1689 1 The the DT 40288 1689 2 accents accent NNS 40288 1689 3 on on IN 40288 1689 4 the the DT 40288 1689 5 short short JJ 40288 1689 6 first first JJ 40288 1689 7 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1689 8 of of IN 40288 1689 9 the the DT 40288 1689 10 dochmiacs dochmiacs NN 40288 1689 11 of of IN 40288 1689 12 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1689 13 are be VBP 40288 1689 14 a a DT 40288 1689 15 still still RB 40288 1689 16 more more RBR 40288 1689 17 unexpected unexpected JJ 40288 1689 18 evidence evidence NN 40288 1689 19 of of IN 40288 1689 20 the the DT 40288 1689 21 same same JJ 40288 1689 22 rhythmical rhythmical JJ 40288 1689 23 tendency tendency NN 40288 1689 24 . . . 40288 1689 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1690 1 * * NFP 40288 1690 2 * * NFP 40288 1690 3 * * NFP 40288 1690 4 * * NFP 40288 1690 5 * * NFP 40288 1690 6 The the DT 40288 1690 7 conception conception NN 40288 1690 8 which which WDT 40288 1690 9 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1690 10 have have VBP 40288 1690 11 thus thus RB 40288 1690 12 been be VBN 40288 1690 13 led lead VBN 40288 1690 14 to to IN 40288 1690 15 form form NN 40288 1690 16 of of IN 40288 1690 17 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1690 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1690 19 as as IN 40288 1690 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1690 21 was be VBD 40288 1690 22 spoken speak VBN 40288 1690 23 is be VBZ 40288 1690 24 not not RB 40288 1690 25 without without IN 40288 1690 26 bearing bear VBG 40288 1690 27 on on IN 40288 1690 28 the the DT 40288 1690 29 main main JJ 40288 1690 30 subject subject NN 40288 1690 31 of of IN 40288 1690 32 these these DT 40288 1690 33 pages page NNS 40288 1690 34 . . . 40288 1691 1 For for IN 40288 1691 2 if if IN 40288 1691 3 the the DT 40288 1691 4 language language NN 40288 1691 5 even even RB 40288 1691 6 in in IN 40288 1691 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1691 8 colloquial colloquial JJ 40288 1691 9 form form NN 40288 1691 10 had have VBD 40288 1691 11 qualities quality NNS 40288 1691 12 of of IN 40288 1691 13 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1691 14 and and CC 40288 1691 15 intonation intonation NN 40288 1691 16 which which WDT 40288 1691 17 gave give VBD 40288 1691 18 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1691 19 this this DT 40288 1691 20 peculiar peculiar JJ 40288 1691 21 half half JJ 40288 1691 22 musical musical JJ 40288 1691 23 character character NN 40288 1691 24 , , , 40288 1691 25 so so IN 40288 1691 26 that that IN 40288 1691 27 singing singe VBG 40288 1691 28 and and CC 40288 1691 29 speaking speaking NN 40288 1691 30 were be VBD 40288 1691 31 more more RBR 40288 1691 32 closely closely RB 40288 1691 33 akin akin JJ 40288 1691 34 than than IN 40288 1691 35 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1691 36 ever ever RB 40288 1691 37 are be VBP 40288 1691 38 in in IN 40288 1691 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1691 40 experience experience NN 40288 1691 41 , , , 40288 1691 42 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1691 43 may may MD 40288 1691 44 expect expect VB 40288 1691 45 to to TO 40288 1691 46 find find VB 40288 1691 47 that that IN 40288 1691 48 music music NN 40288 1691 49 was be VBD 40288 1691 50 influenced influence VBN 40288 1691 51 in in IN 40288 1691 52 some some DT 40288 1691 53 measure measure NN 40288 1691 54 by by IN 40288 1691 55 this this DT 40288 1691 56 state state NN 40288 1691 57 of of IN 40288 1691 58 things thing NNS 40288 1691 59 . . . 40288 1692 1 What what WP 40288 1692 2 is be VBZ 40288 1692 3 there there RB 40288 1692 4 , , , 40288 1692 5 then then RB 40288 1692 6 , , , 40288 1692 7 in in IN 40288 1692 8 the the DT 40288 1692 9 special special JJ 40288 1692 10 characteristics characteristic NNS 40288 1692 11 of of IN 40288 1692 12 Greek greek JJ 40288 1692 13 music music NN 40288 1692 14 which which WDT 40288 1692 15 can can MD 40288 1692 16 be be VB 40288 1692 17 connected connect VBN 40288 1692 18 with with IN 40288 1692 19 the the DT 40288 1692 20 exceptional exceptional JJ 40288 1692 21 relation relation NN 40288 1692 22 in in IN 40288 1692 23 which which WDT 40288 1692 24 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1692 25 stood stand VBD 40288 1692 26 to to TO 40288 1692 27 language language VB 40288 1692 28 ? ? . 40288 1693 1 Greek greek JJ 40288 1693 2 music music NN 40288 1693 3 was be VBD 40288 1693 4 primarily primarily RB 40288 1693 5 and and CC 40288 1693 6 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 1693 7 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1693 8 . . . 40288 1694 1 Instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1694 2 music music NN 40288 1694 3 was be VBD 40288 1694 4 looked look VBN 40288 1694 5 upon upon IN 40288 1694 6 as as IN 40288 1694 7 essentially essentially RB 40288 1694 8 subordinate,--an subordinate,--an VBZ 40288 1694 9 accompaniment accompaniment NN 40288 1694 10 or or CC 40288 1694 11 at at IN 40288 1694 12 best good JJS 40288 1694 13 an an DT 40288 1694 14 imitation imitation NN 40288 1694 15 of of IN 40288 1694 16 singing singing NN 40288 1694 17 . . . 40288 1695 1 For for IN 40288 1695 2 in in IN 40288 1695 3 the the DT 40288 1695 4 view view NN 40288 1695 5 of of IN 40288 1695 6 the the DT 40288 1695 7 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 1695 8 the the DT 40288 1695 9 words word NNS 40288 1695 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1695 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1695 12 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1695 13 : : : 40288 1695 14 lexis lexis NN 40288 1695 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1695 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1695 17 were be VBD 40288 1695 18 an an DT 40288 1695 19 integral integral JJ 40288 1695 20 part part NN 40288 1695 21 of of IN 40288 1695 22 the the DT 40288 1695 23 whole whole JJ 40288 1695 24 composition composition NN 40288 1695 25 . . . 40288 1696 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1696 2 contained contain VBD 40288 1696 3 the the DT 40288 1696 4 ideas idea NNS 40288 1696 5 , , , 40288 1696 6 while while IN 40288 1696 7 the the DT 40288 1696 8 music music NN 40288 1696 9 with with IN 40288 1696 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1696 11 variations variation NNS 40288 1696 12 of of IN 40288 1696 13 time time NN 40288 1696 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1696 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1696 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1696 17 : : : 40288 1696 18 rhythmos rhythmo NNS 40288 1696 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1696 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1696 21 and and CC 40288 1696 22 pitch pitch NN 40288 1696 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1696 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1696 25 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1696 26 : : : 40288 1696 27 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 1696 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1696 29 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1696 30 furnished furnish VBD 40288 1696 31 a a DT 40288 1696 32 natural natural JJ 40288 1696 33 vehicle vehicle NN 40288 1696 34 for for IN 40288 1696 35 the the DT 40288 1696 36 appropriate appropriate JJ 40288 1696 37 feelings feeling NNS 40288 1696 38 . . . 40288 1697 1 Purely purely RB 40288 1697 2 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1697 3 music music NN 40288 1697 4 could could MD 40288 1697 5 not not RB 40288 1697 6 do do VB 40288 1697 7 this this DT 40288 1697 8 , , , 40288 1697 9 because because IN 40288 1697 10 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1697 11 could could MD 40288 1697 12 not not RB 40288 1697 13 convey convey VB 40288 1697 14 the the DT 40288 1697 15 ideas idea NNS 40288 1697 16 or or CC 40288 1697 17 impressions impression NNS 40288 1697 18 fitted fit VBD 40288 1697 19 to to TO 40288 1697 20 be be VB 40288 1697 21 the the DT 40288 1697 22 object object NN 40288 1697 23 of of IN 40288 1697 24 feeling feeling NN 40288 1697 25 . . . 40288 1698 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1698 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1698 3 find find VBP 40288 1698 4 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1698 5 complaining complain VBG 40288 1698 6 on on IN 40288 1698 7 this this DT 40288 1698 8 ground ground NN 40288 1698 9 of of IN 40288 1698 10 the the DT 40288 1698 11 separation separation NN 40288 1698 12 of of IN 40288 1698 13 poetry poetry NN 40288 1698 14 and and CC 40288 1698 15 music music NN 40288 1698 16 which which WDT 40288 1698 17 was be VBD 40288 1698 18 beginning begin VBG 40288 1698 19 to to TO 40288 1698 20 be be VB 40288 1698 21 allowed allow VBN 40288 1698 22 in in IN 40288 1698 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1698 24 time time NN 40288 1698 25 . . . 40288 1699 1 The the DT 40288 1699 2 poets poet NNS 40288 1699 3 , , , 40288 1699 4 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1699 5 says say VBZ 40288 1699 6 , , , 40288 1699 7 rend rend VB 40288 1699 8 asunder asunder IN 40288 1699 9 the the DT 40288 1699 10 elements element NNS 40288 1699 11 of of IN 40288 1699 12 music music NN 40288 1699 13 ; ; : 40288 1699 14 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1699 15 separate separate VBP 40288 1699 16 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1699 17 and and CC 40288 1699 18 dance dance NN 40288 1699 19 movements movement NNS 40288 1699 20 from from IN 40288 1699 21 melody melody NN 40288 1699 22 , , , 40288 1699 23 putting put VBG 40288 1699 24 unmusical unmusical JJ 40288 1699 25 language language NN 40288 1699 26 into into IN 40288 1699 27 metre metre NNP 40288 1699 28 , , , 40288 1699 29 and and CC 40288 1699 30 again again RB 40288 1699 31 make make VB 40288 1699 32 melody melody NN 40288 1699 33 and and CC 40288 1699 34 rhythm rhythm VB 40288 1699 35 without without IN 40288 1699 36 words word NNS 40288 1699 37 , , , 40288 1699 38 employing employ VBG 40288 1699 39 the the DT 40288 1699 40 lyre lyre NN 40288 1699 41 and and CC 40288 1699 42 the the DT 40288 1699 43 flute flute NN 40288 1699 44 without without IN 40288 1699 45 the the DT 40288 1699 46 voice voice NN 40288 1699 47 : : : 40288 1699 48 so so IN 40288 1699 49 that that IN 40288 1699 50 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1699 51 is be VBZ 40288 1699 52 most most RBS 40288 1699 53 difficult difficult JJ 40288 1699 54 , , , 40288 1699 55 when when WRB 40288 1699 56 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1699 57 and and CC 40288 1699 58 melody melody NN 40288 1699 59 is be VBZ 40288 1699 60 produced produce VBN 40288 1699 61 without without IN 40288 1699 62 language language NN 40288 1699 63 , , , 40288 1699 64 to to TO 40288 1699 65 know know VB 40288 1699 66 what what WP 40288 1699 67 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1699 68 means mean VBZ 40288 1699 69 , , , 40288 1699 70 or or CC 40288 1699 71 what what WDT 40288 1699 72 subject subject NN 40288 1699 73 worthy worthy JJ 40288 1699 74 of of IN 40288 1699 75 the the DT 40288 1699 76 name name NN 40288 1699 77 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1699 78 represents represent VBZ 40288 1699 79 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1699 80 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1699 81 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1699 82 : : : 40288 1699 83 kai kai NNP 40288 1699 84 hotô hotô NNP 40288 1699 85 eoike eoike NNP 40288 1699 86 tôn tôn NNP 40288 1699 87 axiologôn axiologôn NNP 40288 1699 88 mimêmatôn mimêmatôn NNP 40288 1699 89 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1699 90 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1699 91 . . . 40288 1700 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1700 2 is be VBZ 40288 1700 3 utterly utterly RB 40288 1700 4 false false JJ 40288 1700 5 taste taste NN 40288 1700 6 , , , 40288 1700 7 in in IN 40288 1700 8 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1700 9 's 's POS 40288 1700 10 opinion opinion NN 40288 1700 11 , , , 40288 1700 12 to to TO 40288 1700 13 use use VB 40288 1700 14 the the DT 40288 1700 15 flute flute NN 40288 1700 16 or or CC 40288 1700 17 the the DT 40288 1700 18 lyre lyre NN 40288 1700 19 otherwise otherwise RB 40288 1700 20 than than IN 40288 1700 21 as as IN 40288 1700 22 an an DT 40288 1700 23 accompaniment accompaniment NN 40288 1700 24 to to TO 40288 1700 25 dance dance VB 40288 1700 26 and and CC 40288 1700 27 song[1 song[1 NNPS 40288 1700 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1700 29 . . . 40288 1701 1 Similarly similarly RB 40288 1701 2 in in IN 40288 1701 3 the the DT 40288 1701 4 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 1701 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1701 6 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1701 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1701 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1701 9 xix xix NNP 40288 1701 10 . . . 40288 1702 1 10 10 LS 40288 1702 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1702 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1702 4 is be VBZ 40288 1702 5 asked ask VBN 40288 1702 6 why why WRB 40288 1702 7 , , , 40288 1702 8 although although IN 40288 1702 9 the the DT 40288 1702 10 human human JJ 40288 1702 11 voice voice NN 40288 1702 12 is be VBZ 40288 1702 13 the the DT 40288 1702 14 most most RBS 40288 1702 15 pleasing pleasing JJ 40288 1702 16 , , , 40288 1702 17 singing singe VBG 40288 1702 18 without without IN 40288 1702 19 words word NNS 40288 1702 20 , , , 40288 1702 21 as as IN 40288 1702 22 in in IN 40288 1702 23 humming humming NN 40288 1702 24 or or CC 40288 1702 25 whistling whistling NN 40288 1702 26 , , , 40288 1702 27 is be VBZ 40288 1702 28 not not RB 40288 1702 29 more more RBR 40288 1702 30 agreeable agreeable JJ 40288 1702 31 than than IN 40288 1702 32 the the DT 40288 1702 33 flute flute NN 40288 1702 34 or or CC 40288 1702 35 the the DT 40288 1702 36 lyre lyre NN 40288 1702 37 . . . 40288 1703 1 Shall Shall MD 40288 1703 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1703 3 say say VB 40288 1703 4 , , , 40288 1703 5 the the DT 40288 1703 6 writer writer NN 40288 1703 7 answers answer VBZ 40288 1703 8 , , , 40288 1703 9 ' ' '' 40288 1703 10 that that IN 40288 1703 11 the the DT 40288 1703 12 human human JJ 40288 1703 13 voice voice NN 40288 1703 14 too too RB 40288 1703 15 is be VBZ 40288 1703 16 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 1703 17 without without IN 40288 1703 18 charm charm NN 40288 1703 19 if if IN 40288 1703 20 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1703 21 does do VBZ 40288 1703 22 not not RB 40288 1703 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1703 24 represent represent VB 40288 1703 25 _ _ NNP 40288 1703 26 something something NN 40288 1703 27 ? ? . 40288 1704 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1704 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1704 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1704 4 : : : 40288 1704 5 ê ê NNP 40288 1704 6 oud oud NNP 40288 1704 7 ' ' '' 40288 1704 8 ekei ekei NNP 40288 1704 9 , , , 40288 1704 10 ean ean NNP 40288 1704 11 mê mê NNP 40288 1704 12 mimêtai mimêtai NNP 40288 1704 13 , , , 40288 1704 14 homoiôs homoiôs NNP 40288 1704 15 hêdy hêdy NNP 40288 1704 16 ? ? . 40288 1704 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1704 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1705 1 That that DT 40288 1705 2 is be VBZ 40288 1705 3 to to TO 40288 1705 4 say say VB 40288 1705 5 , , , 40288 1705 6 music music NN 40288 1705 7 is be VBZ 40288 1705 8 expressive expressive JJ 40288 1705 9 of of IN 40288 1705 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1705 11 feeling feel VBG 40288 1705 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1705 13 , , , 40288 1705 14 which which WDT 40288 1705 15 may may MD 40288 1705 16 range range VB 40288 1705 17 from from IN 40288 1705 18 acute acute JJ 40288 1705 19 passion passion NN 40288 1705 20 to to TO 40288 1705 21 calm calm JJ 40288 1705 22 and and CC 40288 1705 23 lofty lofty JJ 40288 1705 24 sentiment sentiment NN 40288 1705 25 , , , 40288 1705 26 but but CC 40288 1705 27 feeling feeling NN 40288 1705 28 must must MD 40288 1705 29 have have VB 40288 1705 30 an an DT 40288 1705 31 object object NN 40288 1705 32 , , , 40288 1705 33 and and CC 40288 1705 34 this this DT 40288 1705 35 can can MD 40288 1705 36 only only RB 40288 1705 37 be be VB 40288 1705 38 adequately adequately RB 40288 1705 39 given give VBN 40288 1705 40 by by IN 40288 1705 41 language language NN 40288 1705 42 . . . 40288 1706 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1706 2 language language NN 40288 1706 3 is be VBZ 40288 1706 4 , , , 40288 1706 5 in in IN 40288 1706 6 the the DT 40288 1706 7 first first JJ 40288 1706 8 instance instance NN 40288 1706 9 at at IN 40288 1706 10 least least JJS 40288 1706 11 , , , 40288 1706 12 the the DT 40288 1706 13 matter matter NN 40288 1706 14 to to TO 40288 1706 15 which which WDT 40288 1706 16 musical musical JJ 40288 1706 17 treatment treatment NN 40288 1706 18 gives give VBZ 40288 1706 19 artistic artistic JJ 40288 1706 20 form form NN 40288 1706 21 . . . 40288 1707 1 In in IN 40288 1707 2 modern modern JJ 40288 1707 3 times time NNS 40288 1707 4 the the DT 40288 1707 5 tendency tendency NN 40288 1707 6 is be VBZ 40288 1707 7 to to TO 40288 1707 8 regard regard VB 40288 1707 9 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1707 10 music music NN 40288 1707 11 as as IN 40288 1707 12 the the DT 40288 1707 13 highest high JJS 40288 1707 14 form form NN 40288 1707 15 of of IN 40288 1707 16 the the DT 40288 1707 17 art art NN 40288 1707 18 , , , 40288 1707 19 because because IN 40288 1707 20 in in IN 40288 1707 21 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1707 22 music music NN 40288 1707 23 the the DT 40288 1707 24 artist artist NN 40288 1707 25 creates create VBZ 40288 1707 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1707 27 work work NN 40288 1707 28 , , , 40288 1707 29 not not RB 40288 1707 30 by by IN 40288 1707 31 taking take VBG 40288 1707 32 ideas idea NNS 40288 1707 33 and and CC 40288 1707 34 feelings feeling NNS 40288 1707 35 as as IN 40288 1707 36 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1707 37 finds find VBZ 40288 1707 38 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1707 39 already already RB 40288 1707 40 expressed express VBN 40288 1707 41 in in IN 40288 1707 42 language language NN 40288 1707 43 , , , 40288 1707 44 but but CC 40288 1707 45 directly directly RB 40288 1707 46 , , , 40288 1707 47 by by IN 40288 1707 48 forming form VBG 40288 1707 49 an an DT 40288 1707 50 independent independent JJ 40288 1707 51 vehicle vehicle NN 40288 1707 52 of of IN 40288 1707 53 feeling,--a feeling,--a NNP 40288 1707 54 new new JJ 40288 1707 55 language language NN 40288 1707 56 , , , 40288 1707 57 as as IN 40288 1707 58 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1707 59 were be VBD 40288 1707 60 , , , 40288 1707 61 of of IN 40288 1707 62 passion passion NN 40288 1707 63 and and CC 40288 1707 64 sentiment,--out sentiment,--out NNP 40288 1707 65 of of IN 40288 1707 66 the the DT 40288 1707 67 absolute absolute JJ 40288 1707 68 relations relation NNS 40288 1707 69 of of IN 40288 1707 70 movement movement NN 40288 1707 71 and and CC 40288 1707 72 sound sound NN 40288 1707 73 . . . 40288 1708 1 The the DT 40288 1708 2 intimate intimate JJ 40288 1708 3 connexion connexion NN 40288 1708 4 in in IN 40288 1708 5 Greek greek JJ 40288 1708 6 music music NN 40288 1708 7 between between IN 40288 1708 8 words word NNS 40288 1708 9 and and CC 40288 1708 10 melody melody NN 40288 1708 11 may may MD 40288 1708 12 be be VB 40288 1708 13 shown show VBN 40288 1708 14 in in IN 40288 1708 15 various various JJ 40288 1708 16 particulars particular NNS 40288 1708 17 . . . 40288 1709 1 The the DT 40288 1709 2 modern modern JJ 40288 1709 3 practice practice NN 40288 1709 4 of of IN 40288 1709 5 basing base VBG 40288 1709 6 a a DT 40288 1709 7 musical musical JJ 40288 1709 8 composition composition NN 40288 1709 9 -- -- : 40288 1709 10 a a DT 40288 1709 11 long long JJ 40288 1709 12 and and CC 40288 1709 13 elaborate elaborate JJ 40288 1709 14 chorus chorus NN 40288 1709 15 , , , 40288 1709 16 for for IN 40288 1709 17 example example NN 40288 1709 18 -- -- : 40288 1709 19 upon upon IN 40288 1709 20 a a DT 40288 1709 21 few few JJ 40288 1709 22 words word NNS 40288 1709 23 , , , 40288 1709 24 which which WDT 40288 1709 25 are be VBP 40288 1709 26 repeated repeat VBN 40288 1709 27 again again RB 40288 1709 28 and and CC 40288 1709 29 again again RB 40288 1709 30 as as IN 40288 1709 31 the the DT 40288 1709 32 music music NN 40288 1709 33 is be VBZ 40288 1709 34 developed develop VBN 40288 1709 35 , , , 40288 1709 36 would would MD 40288 1709 37 have have VB 40288 1709 38 been be VBN 40288 1709 39 impossible impossible JJ 40288 1709 40 in in IN 40288 1709 41 Greece Greece NNP 40288 1709 42 . . . 40288 1710 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1710 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1710 3 1 1 CD 40288 1710 4 : : : 40288 1710 5 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1710 6 , , , 40288 1710 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1710 8 Legg Legg NNP 40288 1710 9 . . . 40288 1710 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1710 11 p. p. NN 40288 1711 1 669 669 CD 40288 1711 2 . . . 40288 1711 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1712 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1712 2 becomes become VBZ 40288 1712 3 natural natural JJ 40288 1712 4 when when WRB 40288 1712 5 the the DT 40288 1712 6 words word NNS 40288 1712 7 are be VBP 40288 1712 8 not not RB 40288 1712 9 an an DT 40288 1712 10 integral integral JJ 40288 1712 11 part part NN 40288 1712 12 of of IN 40288 1712 13 the the DT 40288 1712 14 work work NN 40288 1712 15 , , , 40288 1712 16 but but CC 40288 1712 17 only only RB 40288 1712 18 serve serve VB 40288 1712 19 to to TO 40288 1712 20 announce announce VB 40288 1712 21 the the DT 40288 1712 22 idea idea NN 40288 1712 23 on on IN 40288 1712 24 which which WDT 40288 1712 25 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1712 26 is be VBZ 40288 1712 27 based base VBN 40288 1712 28 , , , 40288 1712 29 and and CC 40288 1712 30 which which WDT 40288 1712 31 the the DT 40288 1712 32 music music NN 40288 1712 33 brings bring VBZ 40288 1712 34 out out RP 40288 1712 35 under under IN 40288 1712 36 successive successive JJ 40288 1712 37 aspects aspect NNS 40288 1712 38 . . . 40288 1713 1 The the DT 40288 1713 2 same same JJ 40288 1713 3 may may MD 40288 1713 4 be be VB 40288 1713 5 said say VBN 40288 1713 6 of of IN 40288 1713 7 the the DT 40288 1713 8 use use NN 40288 1713 9 of of IN 40288 1713 10 a a DT 40288 1713 11 melody melody NN 40288 1713 12 with with IN 40288 1713 13 many many JJ 40288 1713 14 different different JJ 40288 1713 15 sets set NNS 40288 1713 16 of of IN 40288 1713 17 words word NNS 40288 1713 18 . . . 40288 1714 1 Greek greek JJ 40288 1714 2 writers writer NNS 40288 1714 3 regard regard VBP 40288 1714 4 even even RB 40288 1714 5 the the DT 40288 1714 6 repetition repetition NN 40288 1714 7 of of IN 40288 1714 8 the the DT 40288 1714 9 melody melody NN 40288 1714 10 in in IN 40288 1714 11 a a DT 40288 1714 12 strophe strophe NN 40288 1714 13 and and CC 40288 1714 14 antistrophe antistrophe VB 40288 1714 15 as as IN 40288 1714 16 a a DT 40288 1714 17 concession concession NN 40288 1714 18 to to IN 40288 1714 19 the the DT 40288 1714 20 comparative comparative JJ 40288 1714 21 weakness weakness NN 40288 1714 22 of of IN 40288 1714 23 a a DT 40288 1714 24 chorus chorus NN 40288 1714 25 . . . 40288 1715 1 With with IN 40288 1715 2 the the DT 40288 1715 3 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 1715 4 , , , 40288 1715 5 moreover moreover RB 40288 1715 6 , , , 40288 1715 7 the the DT 40288 1715 8 union union NN 40288 1715 9 in in IN 40288 1715 10 one one CD 40288 1715 11 artist artist NN 40288 1715 12 of of IN 40288 1715 13 the the DT 40288 1715 14 functions function NNS 40288 1715 15 of of IN 40288 1715 16 poet poet NN 40288 1715 17 and and CC 40288 1715 18 musician musician NN 40288 1715 19 must must MD 40288 1715 20 have have VB 40288 1715 21 tended tend VBN 40288 1715 22 to to IN 40288 1715 23 a a DT 40288 1715 24 more more RBR 40288 1715 25 exquisite exquisite JJ 40288 1715 26 adaptation adaptation NN 40288 1715 27 of of IN 40288 1715 28 language language NN 40288 1715 29 and and CC 40288 1715 30 music music NN 40288 1715 31 than than IN 40288 1715 32 can can MD 40288 1715 33 be be VB 40288 1715 34 expected expect VBN 40288 1715 35 when when WRB 40288 1715 36 the the DT 40288 1715 37 work work NN 40288 1715 38 of of IN 40288 1715 39 art art NN 40288 1715 40 is be VBZ 40288 1715 41 the the DT 40288 1715 42 product product NN 40288 1715 43 of of IN 40288 1715 44 divided divided JJ 40288 1715 45 labour labour NN 40288 1715 46 . . . 40288 1716 1 In in IN 40288 1716 2 Greece Greece NNP 40288 1716 3 the the DT 40288 1716 4 principle principle NN 40288 1716 5 of of IN 40288 1716 6 the the DT 40288 1716 7 interdependence interdependence NN 40288 1716 8 of of IN 40288 1716 9 language language NN 40288 1716 10 , , , 40288 1716 11 metre metre NNP 40288 1716 12 , , , 40288 1716 13 and and CC 40288 1716 14 musical musical JJ 40288 1716 15 sound sound NN 40288 1716 16 was be VBD 40288 1716 17 carried carry VBN 40288 1716 18 very very RB 40288 1716 19 far far RB 40288 1716 20 . . . 40288 1717 1 The the DT 40288 1717 2 different different JJ 40288 1717 3 recognised recognise VBN 40288 1717 4 styles style NNS 40288 1717 5 had have VBD 40288 1717 6 each each DT 40288 1717 7 certain certain JJ 40288 1717 8 metrical metrical JJ 40288 1717 9 forms form NNS 40288 1717 10 and and CC 40288 1717 11 certain certain JJ 40288 1717 12 musical musical JJ 40288 1717 13 scales scale NNS 40288 1717 14 or or CC 40288 1717 15 keys key NNS 40288 1717 16 appropriated appropriate VBN 40288 1717 17 to to IN 40288 1717 18 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1717 19 , , , 40288 1717 20 in in IN 40288 1717 21 some some DT 40288 1717 22 cases case NNS 40288 1717 23 also also RB 40288 1717 24 a a DT 40288 1717 25 certain certain JJ 40288 1717 26 dialect dialect NN 40288 1717 27 and and CC 40288 1717 28 vocabulary vocabulary NN 40288 1717 29 . . . 40288 1718 1 These these DT 40288 1718 2 various various JJ 40288 1718 3 elements element NNS 40288 1718 4 were be VBD 40288 1718 5 usually usually RB 40288 1718 6 summed sum VBN 40288 1718 7 up up RP 40288 1718 8 in in IN 40288 1718 9 an an DT 40288 1718 10 ethnical ethnical JJ 40288 1718 11 type type NN 40288 1718 12 , , , 40288 1718 13 one one CD 40288 1718 14 of of IN 40288 1718 15 those those DT 40288 1718 16 which which WDT 40288 1718 17 played play VBD 40288 1718 18 so so RB 40288 1718 19 large large JJ 40288 1718 20 a a DT 40288 1718 21 part part NN 40288 1718 22 in in IN 40288 1718 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1718 24 political political JJ 40288 1718 25 history history NN 40288 1718 26 . . . 40288 1719 1 Such such PDT 40288 1719 2 a a DT 40288 1719 3 term term NN 40288 1719 4 as as IN 40288 1719 5 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1719 6 was be VBD 40288 1719 7 not not RB 40288 1719 8 applied apply VBN 40288 1719 9 to to IN 40288 1719 10 a a DT 40288 1719 11 particular particular JJ 40288 1719 12 scale scale NN 40288 1719 13 at at IN 40288 1719 14 random random JJ 40288 1719 15 , , , 40288 1719 16 but but CC 40288 1719 17 because because IN 40288 1719 18 that that DT 40288 1719 19 scale scale NN 40288 1719 20 was be VBD 40288 1719 21 distinctive distinctive JJ 40288 1719 22 of of IN 40288 1719 23 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1719 24 music music NN 40288 1719 25 : : : 40288 1719 26 and and CC 40288 1719 27 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1719 28 music music NN 40288 1719 29 , , , 40288 1719 30 again again RB 40288 1719 31 , , , 40288 1719 32 was be VBD 40288 1719 33 one one CD 40288 1719 34 aspect aspect NN 40288 1719 35 of of IN 40288 1719 36 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1719 37 temper temper NN 40288 1719 38 and and CC 40288 1719 39 institutions institution NNS 40288 1719 40 , , , 40288 1719 41 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1719 42 literature literature NN 40288 1719 43 and and CC 40288 1719 44 thought think VBD 40288 1719 45 . . . 40288 1720 1 Whether whether IN 40288 1720 2 the the DT 40288 1720 3 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 1720 4 were be VBD 40288 1720 5 acquainted acquaint VBN 40288 1720 6 with with IN 40288 1720 7 harmony harmony NN 40288 1720 8 -- -- : 40288 1720 9 in in IN 40288 1720 10 the the DT 40288 1720 11 modern modern JJ 40288 1720 12 sense sense NN 40288 1720 13 of of IN 40288 1720 14 the the DT 40288 1720 15 word word NN 40288 1720 16 -- -- : 40288 1720 17 is be VBZ 40288 1720 18 a a DT 40288 1720 19 question question NN 40288 1720 20 that that WDT 40288 1720 21 has have VBZ 40288 1720 22 been be VBN 40288 1720 23 much much RB 40288 1720 24 discussed discuss VBN 40288 1720 25 , , , 40288 1720 26 and and CC 40288 1720 27 may may MD 40288 1720 28 now now RB 40288 1720 29 be be VB 40288 1720 30 regarded regard VBN 40288 1720 31 as as IN 40288 1720 32 settled[1 settled[1 NNP 40288 1720 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1720 34 . . . 40288 1721 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1721 2 is be VBZ 40288 1721 3 clear clear JJ 40288 1721 4 that that IN 40288 1721 5 the the DT 40288 1721 6 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 1721 7 were be VBD 40288 1721 8 acquainted acquaint VBN 40288 1721 9 with with IN 40288 1721 10 the the DT 40288 1721 11 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40288 1721 12 on on IN 40288 1721 13 which which WDT 40288 1721 14 harmony harmony NN 40288 1721 15 depends depend VBZ 40288 1721 16 , , , 40288 1721 17 viz viz NN 40288 1721 18 . . . 40288 1722 1 the the DT 40288 1722 2 effect effect NN 40288 1722 3 produced produce VBN 40288 1722 4 by by IN 40288 1722 5 sounding sound VBG 40288 1722 6 certain certain JJ 40288 1722 7 notes note NNS 40288 1722 8 together together RB 40288 1722 9 . . . 40288 1723 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1723 2 appears appear VBZ 40288 1723 3 also also RB 40288 1723 4 that that IN 40288 1723 5 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1723 6 made make VBD 40288 1723 7 some some DT 40288 1723 8 use use NN 40288 1723 9 of of IN 40288 1723 10 harmony,--and harmony,--and NN 40288 1723 11 of of IN 40288 1723 12 dissonant dissonant NN 40288 1723 13 as as RB 40288 1723 14 well well RB 40288 1723 15 as as IN 40288 1723 16 consonant consonant NN 40288 1723 17 intervals,--in intervals,--in NNP 40288 1723 18 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1723 19 accompaniment accompaniment NN 40288 1723 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1723 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1723 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1723 23 : : : 40288 1723 24 krousis krousis NN 40288 1723 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1723 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1723 27 . . . 40288 1724 1 On on IN 40288 1724 2 the the DT 40288 1724 3 other other JJ 40288 1724 4 hand hand NN 40288 1724 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1724 6 was be VBD 40288 1724 7 unknown unknown JJ 40288 1724 8 in in IN 40288 1724 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1724 10 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1724 11 music music NN 40288 1724 12 , , , 40288 1724 13 except except IN 40288 1724 14 in in IN 40288 1724 15 the the DT 40288 1724 16 form form NN 40288 1724 17 of of IN 40288 1724 18 bass bass NN 40288 1724 19 and and CC 40288 1724 20 treble treble JJ 40288 1724 21 voices voice NNS 40288 1724 22 singing singe VBG 40288 1724 23 the the DT 40288 1724 24 same same JJ 40288 1724 25 melody melody NN 40288 1724 26 . . . 40288 1725 1 In in IN 40288 1725 2 the the DT 40288 1725 3 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1725 4 accompaniment accompaniment NN 40288 1725 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1725 6 was be VBD 40288 1725 7 only only RB 40288 1725 8 an an DT 40288 1725 9 occasional occasional JJ 40288 1725 10 ornament ornament NN 40288 1725 11 , , , 40288 1725 12 not not RB 40288 1725 13 a a DT 40288 1725 14 necessary necessary JJ 40288 1725 15 or or CC 40288 1725 16 regular regular JJ 40288 1725 17 part part NN 40288 1725 18 of of IN 40288 1725 19 the the DT 40288 1725 20 music music NN 40288 1725 21 . . . 40288 1726 1 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1726 2 speaks speak VBZ 40288 1726 3 of of IN 40288 1726 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1726 5 in in IN 40288 1726 6 the the DT 40288 1726 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1726 8 Laws Laws NNPS 40288 1726 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1726 10 as as IN 40288 1726 11 something something NN 40288 1726 12 which which WDT 40288 1726 13 those those DT 40288 1726 14 who who WP 40288 1726 15 learn learn VBP 40288 1726 16 music music NN 40288 1726 17 as as IN 40288 1726 18 a a DT 40288 1726 19 branch branch NN 40288 1726 20 of of IN 40288 1726 21 liberal liberal JJ 40288 1726 22 education education NN 40288 1726 23 should should MD 40288 1726 24 not not RB 40288 1726 25 attempt[1 attempt[1 '' 40288 1726 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1726 27 . . . 40288 1727 1 The the DT 40288 1727 2 silence silence NN 40288 1727 3 of of IN 40288 1727 4 the the DT 40288 1727 5 technical technical JJ 40288 1727 6 writers writer NNS 40288 1727 7 , , , 40288 1727 8 both both CC 40288 1727 9 as as IN 40288 1727 10 to to IN 40288 1727 11 the the DT 40288 1727 12 use use NN 40288 1727 13 of of IN 40288 1727 14 harmony harmony NN 40288 1727 15 and and CC 40288 1727 16 as as IN 40288 1727 17 to to IN 40288 1727 18 the the DT 40288 1727 19 tonality tonality NN 40288 1727 20 of of IN 40288 1727 21 the the DT 40288 1727 22 Greek greek JJ 40288 1727 23 scale scale NN 40288 1727 24 , , , 40288 1727 25 points point NNS 40288 1727 26 in in IN 40288 1727 27 the the DT 40288 1727 28 same same JJ 40288 1727 29 direction direction NN 40288 1727 30 . . . 40288 1728 1 Evidently evidently RB 40288 1728 2 there there EX 40288 1728 3 was be VBD 40288 1728 4 no no DT 40288 1728 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1728 6 system system NN 40288 1728 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1728 8 of of IN 40288 1728 9 harmony,--no harmony,--no NNP 40288 1728 10 notion notion NN 40288 1728 11 of of IN 40288 1728 12 the the DT 40288 1728 13 effect effect NN 40288 1728 14 of of IN 40288 1728 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1728 16 successive successive JJ 40288 1728 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1728 18 harmonies harmony NNS 40288 1728 19 , , , 40288 1728 20 or or CC 40288 1728 21 of of IN 40288 1728 22 two two CD 40288 1728 23 distinct distinct JJ 40288 1728 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1728 25 parts part NNS 40288 1728 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1728 27 or or CC 40288 1728 28 progressions progression NNS 40288 1728 29 of of IN 40288 1728 30 notes note NNS 40288 1728 31 harmonising harmonise VBG 40288 1728 32 with with IN 40288 1728 33 each each DT 40288 1728 34 other other JJ 40288 1728 35 . . . 40288 1729 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1729 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1729 3 1 1 CD 40288 1729 4 : : : 40288 1729 5 On on IN 40288 1729 6 this this DT 40288 1729 7 point point NN 40288 1729 8 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1729 9 may may MD 40288 1729 10 refer refer VB 40288 1729 11 to to IN 40288 1729 12 the the DT 40288 1729 13 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 1729 14 fuller full JJR 40288 1729 15 treatment treatment NN 40288 1729 16 in in IN 40288 1729 17 Smith Smith NNP 40288 1729 18 's 's POS 40288 1729 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1729 20 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 40288 1729 21 of of IN 40288 1729 22 Antiquities Antiquities NNPS 40288 1729 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1729 24 , , , 40288 1729 25 art art NN 40288 1729 26 . . . 40288 1730 1 MUSICA MUSICA NNP 40288 1730 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1730 3 Vol Vol NNP 40288 1730 4 . . . 40288 1731 1 II II NNP 40288 1731 2 , , , 40288 1731 3 p. p. NN 40288 1731 4 199 199 CD 40288 1731 5 , , , 40288 1731 6 ed ed NN 40288 1731 7 . . . 40288 1732 1 1890 1890 CD 40288 1732 2 - - SYM 40288 1732 3 91 91 CD 40288 1732 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1732 5 . . . 40288 1732 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1733 1 The the DT 40288 1733 2 want want NN 40288 1733 3 of of IN 40288 1733 4 harmony harmony NN 40288 1733 5 is be VBZ 40288 1733 6 to to TO 40288 1733 7 be be VB 40288 1733 8 connected connect VBN 40288 1733 9 not not RB 40288 1733 10 only only RB 40288 1733 11 with with IN 40288 1733 12 the the DT 40288 1733 13 defective defective JJ 40288 1733 14 tonality tonality NN 40288 1733 15 which which WDT 40288 1733 16 was be VBD 40288 1733 17 probably probably RB 40288 1733 18 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 1733 19 of of IN 40288 1733 20 Greek greek JJ 40288 1733 21 music,--we music,--we NN 40288 1733 22 have have VBP 40288 1733 23 seen see VBN 40288 1733 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1733 25 p. p. NN 40288 1733 26 42 42 CD 40288 1733 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1733 28 that that IN 40288 1733 29 there there EX 40288 1733 30 is be VBZ 40288 1733 31 some some DT 40288 1733 32 evidence evidence NN 40288 1733 33 of of IN 40288 1733 34 tonality,--but tonality,--but CC 40288 1733 35 still still RB 40288 1733 36 more more JJR 40288 1733 37 with with IN 40288 1733 38 the the DT 40288 1733 39 non non JJ 40288 1733 40 - - JJ 40288 1733 41 harmonic harmonic JJ 40288 1733 42 quality quality NN 40288 1733 43 of of IN 40288 1733 44 many many JJ 40288 1733 45 of of IN 40288 1733 46 the the DT 40288 1733 47 intervals interval NNS 40288 1733 48 of of IN 40288 1733 49 which which WDT 40288 1733 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1733 51 scales scale NNS 40288 1733 52 were be VBD 40288 1733 53 composed compose VBN 40288 1733 54 . . . 40288 1734 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1734 2 have have VBP 40288 1734 3 repeatedly repeatedly RB 40288 1734 4 dwelt dwell VBN 40288 1734 5 upon upon IN 40288 1734 6 the the DT 40288 1734 7 variety variety NN 40288 1734 8 and and CC 40288 1734 9 strangeness strangeness NN 40288 1734 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1734 11 to to IN 40288 1734 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1734 13 apprehension apprehension NN 40288 1734 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1734 15 of of IN 40288 1734 16 these these DT 40288 1734 17 intervals interval NNS 40288 1734 18 . . . 40288 1735 1 Modern modern JJ 40288 1735 2 writers writer NNS 40288 1735 3 are be VBP 40288 1735 4 usually usually RB 40288 1735 5 disposed disposed JJ 40288 1735 6 to to TO 40288 1735 7 underrate underrate VB 40288 1735 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1735 9 importance importance NN 40288 1735 10 , , , 40288 1735 11 or or CC 40288 1735 12 even even RB 40288 1735 13 to to TO 40288 1735 14 explain explain VB 40288 1735 15 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1735 16 away away RB 40288 1735 17 . . . 40288 1736 1 The the DT 40288 1736 2 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1736 3 , , , 40288 1736 4 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1736 5 point point VBP 40288 1736 6 out out RP 40288 1736 7 , , , 40288 1736 8 was be VBD 40288 1736 9 produced produce VBN 40288 1736 10 by by IN 40288 1736 11 the the DT 40288 1736 12 interpolation interpolation NN 40288 1736 13 of of IN 40288 1736 14 a a DT 40288 1736 15 note note NN 40288 1736 16 which which WDT 40288 1736 17 may may MD 40288 1736 18 have have VB 40288 1736 19 been be VBN 40288 1736 20 only only RB 40288 1736 21 a a DT 40288 1736 22 passing passing JJ 40288 1736 23 note note NN 40288 1736 24 or or CC 40288 1736 25 _ _ NNP 40288 1736 26 appoggiatura appoggiatura NNP 40288 1736 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1736 28 . . . 40288 1737 1 The the DT 40288 1737 2 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1737 3 also also RB 40288 1737 4 , , , 40288 1737 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1737 6 is be VBZ 40288 1737 7 said say VBN 40288 1737 8 , , , 40288 1737 9 was be VBD 40288 1737 10 regarded regard VBN 40288 1737 11 as as RB 40288 1737 12 too too RB 40288 1737 13 difficult difficult JJ 40288 1737 14 for for IN 40288 1737 15 ordinary ordinary JJ 40288 1737 16 performers performer NNS 40288 1737 17 , , , 40288 1737 18 and and CC 40288 1737 19 most most JJS 40288 1737 20 of of IN 40288 1737 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1737 22 varieties variety NNS 40288 1737 23 went go VBD 40288 1737 24 out out IN 40288 1737 25 of of IN 40288 1737 26 use use NN 40288 1737 27 at at IN 40288 1737 28 a a DT 40288 1737 29 comparatively comparatively RB 40288 1737 30 early early JJ 40288 1737 31 period period NN 40288 1737 32 . . . 40288 1738 1 Yet yet RB 40288 1738 2 the the DT 40288 1738 3 accounts account NNS 40288 1738 4 which which WDT 40288 1738 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1738 6 find find VBP 40288 1738 7 in in IN 40288 1738 8 writers writer NNS 40288 1738 9 so so RB 40288 1738 10 remote remote JJ 40288 1738 11 in in IN 40288 1738 12 time time NN 40288 1738 13 and and CC 40288 1738 14 so so RB 40288 1738 15 opposed opposed JJ 40288 1738 16 in in IN 40288 1738 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1738 18 theoretical theoretical JJ 40288 1738 19 views view NNS 40288 1738 20 as as IN 40288 1738 21 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1738 22 and and CC 40288 1738 23 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1738 24 , , , 40288 1738 25 bear bear VBP 40288 1738 26 the the DT 40288 1738 27 strongest strong JJS 40288 1738 28 testimony testimony NN 40288 1738 29 to to IN 40288 1738 30 the the DT 40288 1738 31 reality reality NN 40288 1738 32 and and CC 40288 1738 33 persistence persistence NN 40288 1738 34 of of IN 40288 1738 35 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1738 36 Footnote Footnote NNP 40288 1738 37 1 1 CD 40288 1738 38 : : : 40288 1738 39 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1738 40 , , , 40288 1738 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1738 42 Legg Legg NNP 40288 1738 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1738 44 . . . 40288 1739 1 p. p. NN 40288 1739 2 812 812 CD 40288 1739 3 d d NNS 40288 1739 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1739 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1739 6 : : : 40288 1739 7 panta panta NNP 40288 1739 8 oun oun NNP 40288 1739 9 ta ta NNP 40288 1739 10 toiauta toiauta NNP 40288 1739 11 mê mê NNP 40288 1739 12 prospherein prospherein NNP 40288 1739 13 tois tois NNP 40288 1739 14 mellousin mellousin NNP 40288 1739 15 en en IN 40288 1739 16 trisin trisin NNP 40288 1739 17 etesi etesi NNP 40288 1739 18 to to IN 40288 1739 19 tês tês NNP 40288 1739 20 mousikês mousikês NNP 40288 1739 21 chrêsimon chrêsimon NNP 40288 1739 22 eklêpsesthai eklêpsesthai NNP 40288 1739 23 dia dia NNP 40288 1739 24 tachous tachous NNP 40288 1739 25 . . . 40288 1739 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1739 27 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1740 1 these these DT 40288 1740 2 non non JJ 40288 1740 3 - - JJ 40288 1740 4 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1740 5 scales scale NNS 40288 1740 6 . . . 40288 1741 1 And and CC 40288 1741 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1741 3 have have VBP 40288 1741 4 the the DT 40288 1741 5 decisive decisive JJ 40288 1741 6 fact fact NN 40288 1741 7 that that IN 40288 1741 8 of of IN 40288 1741 9 the the DT 40288 1741 10 six six CD 40288 1741 11 scales scale NNS 40288 1741 12 of of IN 40288 1741 13 the the DT 40288 1741 14 cithara cithara NN 40288 1741 15 given give VBN 40288 1741 16 by by IN 40288 1741 17 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1741 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1741 19 see see VB 40288 1741 20 p. p. NN 40288 1741 21 85 85 CD 40288 1741 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1741 23 not not RB 40288 1741 24 one one CD 40288 1741 25 is be VBZ 40288 1741 26 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1741 27 in in IN 40288 1741 28 the the DT 40288 1741 29 modern modern JJ 40288 1741 30 sense sense NN 40288 1741 31 of of IN 40288 1741 32 the the DT 40288 1741 33 word word NN 40288 1741 34 . . . 40288 1742 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1742 2 may may MD 40288 1742 3 be be VB 40288 1742 4 alleged allege VBN 40288 1742 5 on on IN 40288 1742 6 the the DT 40288 1742 7 other other JJ 40288 1742 8 side side NN 40288 1742 9 that that IN 40288 1742 10 the the DT 40288 1742 11 ideal ideal JJ 40288 1742 12 scale scale NN 40288 1742 13 in in IN 40288 1742 14 the the DT 40288 1742 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1742 16 Timaeus Timaeus NNP 40288 1742 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1742 18 of of IN 40288 1742 19 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1742 20 is be VBZ 40288 1742 21 purely purely RB 40288 1742 22 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1742 23 , , , 40288 1742 24 and and CC 40288 1742 25 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40288 1742 26 the the DT 40288 1742 27 strictest strict JJS 40288 1742 28 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1742 29 division division NN 40288 1742 30 . . . 40288 1743 1 But but CC 40288 1743 2 that that DT 40288 1743 3 scale scale NN 40288 1743 4 is be VBZ 40288 1743 5 primarily primarily RB 40288 1743 6 a a DT 40288 1743 7 framework framework NN 40288 1743 8 of of IN 40288 1743 9 mathematical mathematical JJ 40288 1743 10 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1743 11 , , , 40288 1743 12 and and CC 40288 1743 13 could could MD 40288 1743 14 not not RB 40288 1743 15 take take VB 40288 1743 16 notice notice NN 40288 1743 17 of of IN 40288 1743 18 intervals interval NNS 40288 1743 19 which which WDT 40288 1743 20 had have VBD 40288 1743 21 not not RB 40288 1743 22 yet yet RB 40288 1743 23 been be VBN 40288 1743 24 identified identify VBN 40288 1743 25 with with IN 40288 1743 26 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1743 27 . . . 40288 1744 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1744 2 is be VBZ 40288 1744 3 not not RB 40288 1744 4 certain certain JJ 40288 1744 5 when when WRB 40288 1744 6 the the DT 40288 1744 7 discovery discovery NN 40288 1744 8 of of IN 40288 1744 9 Pythagoras Pythagoras NNP 40288 1744 10 was be VBD 40288 1744 11 extended extend VBN 40288 1744 12 to to IN 40288 1744 13 the the DT 40288 1744 14 non non JJ 40288 1744 15 - - JJ 40288 1744 16 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1744 17 scales scale NNS 40288 1744 18 . . . 40288 1745 1 Even even RB 40288 1745 2 in in IN 40288 1745 3 the the DT 40288 1745 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1745 5 Sectio Sectio NNP 40288 1745 6 Canonis Canonis NNP 40288 1745 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1745 8 of of IN 40288 1745 9 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 1745 10 there there EX 40288 1745 11 is be VBZ 40288 1745 12 no no DT 40288 1745 13 trace trace NN 40288 1745 14 of of IN 40288 1745 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40288 1745 16 that that WDT 40288 1745 17 any any DT 40288 1745 18 intervals interval NNS 40288 1745 19 except except IN 40288 1745 20 those those DT 40288 1745 21 of of IN 40288 1745 22 the the DT 40288 1745 23 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1745 24 diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1745 25 scale scale NN 40288 1745 26 had have VBD 40288 1745 27 a a DT 40288 1745 28 numerical numerical JJ 40288 1745 29 or or CC 40288 1745 30 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1745 31 as as IN 40288 1745 32 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1745 33 should should MD 40288 1745 34 say say VB 40288 1745 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1745 36 physical physical NNP 40288 1745 37 basis[1 basis[1 NNP 40288 1745 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1745 39 . . . 40288 1746 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1746 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1746 3 1 1 CD 40288 1746 4 : : : 40288 1746 5 In in IN 40288 1746 6 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 1746 7 's 's POS 40288 1746 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1746 9 Sectio Sectio NNP 40288 1746 10 Canonis Canonis NNP 40288 1746 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1746 12 the the DT 40288 1746 13 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1746 14 division division NN 40288 1746 15 is be VBZ 40288 1746 16 assumed assume VBN 40288 1746 17 , , , 40288 1746 18 and and CC 40288 1746 19 there there EX 40288 1746 20 is be VBZ 40288 1746 21 no no DT 40288 1746 22 hint hint NN 40288 1746 23 of of IN 40288 1746 24 any any DT 40288 1746 25 other other JJ 40288 1746 26 ratio ratio NN 40288 1746 27 than than IN 40288 1746 28 those those DT 40288 1746 29 which which WDT 40288 1746 30 Pythagoras Pythagoras NNP 40288 1746 31 discovered discover VBD 40288 1746 32 . . . 40288 1747 1 Prop Prop NNP 40288 1747 2 . . . 40288 1748 1 xvii xvii NN 40288 1748 2 shows show VBZ 40288 1748 3 how how WRB 40288 1748 4 to to TO 40288 1748 5 find find VB 40288 1748 6 the the DT 40288 1748 7 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1748 8 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1748 9 and and CC 40288 1748 10 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 1748 11 by by IN 40288 1748 12 means mean NNS 40288 1748 13 of of IN 40288 1748 14 the the DT 40288 1748 15 Fourth Fourth NNP 40288 1748 16 and and CC 40288 1748 17 Fifth Fifth NNP 40288 1748 18 . . . 40288 1749 1 Prop Prop NNP 40288 1749 2 . . . 40288 1750 1 xviii xviii NNP 40288 1750 2 proves prove VBZ 40288 1750 3 against against IN 40288 1750 4 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1750 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1750 6 of of RB 40288 1750 7 course course NN 40288 1750 8 without without IN 40288 1750 9 naming name VBG 40288 1750 10 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1750 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1750 12 , , , 40288 1750 13 that that IN 40288 1750 14 a a DT 40288 1750 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1750 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1750 17 : : : 40288 1750 18 pyknon pyknon NN 40288 1750 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1750 20 can can MD 40288 1750 21 not not RB 40288 1750 22 be be VB 40288 1750 23 divided divide VBN 40288 1750 24 into into IN 40288 1750 25 two two CD 40288 1750 26 equal equal JJ 40288 1750 27 intervals interval NNS 40288 1750 28 ; ; : 40288 1750 29 but but CC 40288 1750 30 there there EX 40288 1750 31 is be VBZ 40288 1750 32 no no DT 40288 1750 33 attempt attempt NN 40288 1750 34 to to TO 40288 1750 35 explain explain VB 40288 1750 36 the the DT 40288 1750 37 nature nature NN 40288 1750 38 of of IN 40288 1750 39 the the DT 40288 1750 40 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1750 41 diesis diesis NN 40288 1750 42 . . . 40288 1751 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1751 2 is be VBZ 40288 1751 3 worth worth JJ 40288 1751 4 notice notice NN 40288 1751 5 that that IN 40288 1751 6 in in IN 40288 1751 7 these these DT 40288 1751 8 propositions proposition NNS 40288 1751 9 the the DT 40288 1751 10 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1751 11 and and CC 40288 1751 12 Paranêtê Paranêtê NNP 40288 1751 13 of of IN 40288 1751 14 the the DT 40288 1751 15 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1751 16 scale scale NN 40288 1751 17 are be VBP 40288 1751 18 called call VBN 40288 1751 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1751 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1751 21 : : : 40288 1751 22 lichanos lichanos LS 40288 1751 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1751 24 and and CC 40288 1751 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1751 26 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1751 27 : : : 40288 1751 28 paranêtê paranêtê NNS 40288 1751 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1751 30 simply simply RB 40288 1751 31 , , , 40288 1751 32 as as IN 40288 1751 33 though though IN 40288 1751 34 the the DT 40288 1751 35 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1751 36 were be VBD 40288 1751 37 the the DT 40288 1751 38 only only JJ 40288 1751 39 genus genus NN 40288 1751 40 -- -- : 40288 1751 41 a a DT 40288 1751 42 usage usage NN 40288 1751 43 which which WDT 40288 1751 44 agrees agree VBZ 40288 1751 45 with with IN 40288 1751 46 that that DT 40288 1751 47 of of IN 40288 1751 48 the the DT 40288 1751 49 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40288 1751 50 _ _ NNP 40288 1751 51 Problems Problems NNPS 40288 1751 52 _ _ NNP 40288 1751 53 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1751 54 supra supra NNP 40288 1751 55 , , , 40288 1751 56 p. p. NN 40288 1751 57 33 33 CD 40288 1751 58 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1751 59 . . . 40288 1752 1 According accord VBG 40288 1752 2 to to IN 40288 1752 3 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1752 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1752 5 i. i. NNP 40288 1753 1 13 13 LS 40288 1753 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1753 3 the the DT 40288 1753 4 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1753 5 philosopher philosopher NN 40288 1753 6 Archytas Archytas NNP 40288 1753 7 was be VBD 40288 1753 8 the the DT 40288 1753 9 author author NN 40288 1753 10 of of IN 40288 1753 11 a a DT 40288 1753 12 new new JJ 40288 1753 13 division division NN 40288 1753 14 of of IN 40288 1753 15 the the DT 40288 1753 16 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1753 17 for for IN 40288 1753 18 each each DT 40288 1753 19 of of IN 40288 1753 20 the the DT 40288 1753 21 three three CD 40288 1753 22 genera genera NN 40288 1753 23 . . . 40288 1754 1 In in IN 40288 1754 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1754 3 the the DT 40288 1754 4 natural natural JJ 40288 1754 5 Major Major NNP 40288 1754 6 Third Third NNP 40288 1754 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1754 8 5 5 CD 40288 1754 9 : : SYM 40288 1754 10 4 4 CD 40288 1754 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1754 12 was be VBD 40288 1754 13 given give VBN 40288 1754 14 for for IN 40288 1754 15 the the DT 40288 1754 16 large large JJ 40288 1754 17 interval interval NN 40288 1754 18 of of IN 40288 1754 19 the the DT 40288 1754 20 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1754 21 , , , 40288 1754 22 in in IN 40288 1754 23 place place NN 40288 1754 24 of of IN 40288 1754 25 the the DT 40288 1754 26 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1754 27 ditone ditone NN 40288 1754 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1754 29 81 81 CD 40288 1754 30 : : SYM 40288 1754 31 64 64 CD 40288 1754 32 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1754 33 ; ; : 40288 1754 34 and and CC 40288 1754 35 the the DT 40288 1754 36 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1754 37 was be VBD 40288 1754 38 the the DT 40288 1754 39 same same JJ 40288 1754 40 as as IN 40288 1754 41 the the DT 40288 1754 42 Middle Middle NNP 40288 1754 43 Soft Soft NNP 40288 1754 44 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1754 45 of of IN 40288 1754 46 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1754 47 . . . 40288 1755 1 But but CC 40288 1755 2 , , , 40288 1755 3 as as IN 40288 1755 4 Westphal Westphal NNP 40288 1755 5 long long RB 40288 1755 6 ago ago RB 40288 1755 7 pointed point VBD 40288 1755 8 out out RP 40288 1755 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1755 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1755 11 Harmonik Harmonik NNP 40288 1755 12 und und NN 40288 1755 13 Melopöie Melopöie NNP 40288 1755 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1755 15 , , , 40288 1755 16 p. p. NN 40288 1755 17 230 230 CD 40288 1755 18 , , , 40288 1755 19 ed ed NN 40288 1755 20 . . . 40288 1756 1 1863 1863 CD 40288 1756 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1756 3 , , , 40288 1756 4 this this DT 40288 1756 5 scheme scheme NN 40288 1756 6 is be VBZ 40288 1756 7 probably probably RB 40288 1756 8 the the DT 40288 1756 9 work work NN 40288 1756 10 of of IN 40288 1756 11 the the DT 40288 1756 12 later later JJ 40288 1756 13 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40288 1756 14 school school NN 40288 1756 15 . . . 40288 1757 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1757 2 seems seem VBZ 40288 1757 3 to to TO 40288 1757 4 be be VB 40288 1757 5 unknown unknown JJ 40288 1757 6 to to IN 40288 1757 7 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1757 8 and and CC 40288 1757 9 Aristoxenus,--the aristoxenus,--the DT 40288 1757 10 latter latter JJ 40288 1757 11 wrote write VBD 40288 1757 12 a a DT 40288 1757 13 life life NN 40288 1757 14 of of IN 40288 1757 15 Archytas Archytas NNP 40288 1757 16 -- -- : 40288 1757 17 and and CC 40288 1757 18 also also RB 40288 1757 19 to to IN 40288 1757 20 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 1757 21 , , , 40288 1757 22 as as IN 40288 1757 23 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1757 24 have have VBP 40288 1757 25 seen see VBN 40288 1757 26 . . . 40288 1758 1 The the DT 40288 1758 2 next next JJ 40288 1758 3 scheme scheme NN 40288 1758 4 of of IN 40288 1758 5 musical musical JJ 40288 1758 6 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1758 7 is be VBZ 40288 1758 8 that that DT 40288 1758 9 of of IN 40288 1758 10 Eratosthenes Eratosthenes NNPS 40288 1758 11 , , , 40288 1758 12 who who WP 40288 1758 13 makes make VBZ 40288 1758 14 no no DT 40288 1758 15 use use NN 40288 1758 16 of of IN 40288 1758 17 the the DT 40288 1758 18 natural natural JJ 40288 1758 19 Major Major NNP 40288 1758 20 Third Third NNP 40288 1758 21 . . . 40288 1758 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1759 1 In in IN 40288 1759 2 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1759 3 's 's POS 40288 1759 4 time time NN 40288 1759 5 , , , 40288 1759 6 as as IN 40288 1759 7 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1759 8 can can MD 40288 1759 9 see see VB 40288 1759 10 from from IN 40288 1759 11 a a DT 40288 1759 12 well well RB 40288 1759 13 - - HYPH 40288 1759 14 known know VBN 40288 1759 15 passage passage NN 40288 1759 16 of of IN 40288 1759 17 the the DT 40288 1759 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1759 19 Republic Republic NNP 40288 1759 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1759 21 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1759 22 quoted quote VBN 40288 1759 23 on on IN 40288 1759 24 p. p. NN 40288 1759 25 53 53 CD 40288 1759 26 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1759 27 , , , 40288 1759 28 the the DT 40288 1759 29 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1759 30 and and CC 40288 1759 31 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1759 32 scales scale NNS 40288 1759 33 were be VBD 40288 1759 34 the the DT 40288 1759 35 object object NN 40288 1759 36 of of IN 40288 1759 37 much much JJ 40288 1759 38 zealous zealous JJ 40288 1759 39 study study NN 40288 1759 40 and and CC 40288 1759 41 experiment experiment NN 40288 1759 42 on on IN 40288 1759 43 the the DT 40288 1759 44 part part NN 40288 1759 45 of of IN 40288 1759 46 musicians musician NNS 40288 1759 47 of of IN 40288 1759 48 different different JJ 40288 1759 49 schools,--some schools,--some NNP 40288 1759 50 seeking seek VBG 40288 1759 51 to to TO 40288 1759 52 measure measure VB 40288 1759 53 and and CC 40288 1759 54 compare compare VB 40288 1759 55 the the DT 40288 1759 56 intervals interval NNS 40288 1759 57 directly directly RB 40288 1759 58 by by IN 40288 1759 59 the the DT 40288 1759 60 ear ear NN 40288 1759 61 , , , 40288 1759 62 others other NNS 40288 1759 63 to to TO 40288 1759 64 find find VB 40288 1759 65 numbers number NNS 40288 1759 66 in in IN 40288 1759 67 the the DT 40288 1759 68 consonances consonance NNS 40288 1759 69 which which WDT 40288 1759 70 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1759 71 heard hear VBD 40288 1759 72 , , , 40288 1759 73 and and CC 40288 1759 74 both both DT 40288 1759 75 , , , 40288 1759 76 from from IN 40288 1759 77 the the DT 40288 1759 78 Platonic platonic JJ 40288 1759 79 point point NN 40288 1759 80 of of IN 40288 1759 81 view view NN 40288 1759 82 , , , 40288 1759 83 ' ' '' 40288 1759 84 setting set VBG 40288 1759 85 ears ear NNS 40288 1759 86 above above IN 40288 1759 87 intelligence intelligence NN 40288 1759 88 , , , 40288 1759 89 ' ' '' 40288 1759 90 and and CC 40288 1759 91 therefore therefore RB 40288 1759 92 labouring labour VBG 40288 1759 93 in in IN 40288 1759 94 vain[1 vain[1 NNP 40288 1759 95 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1759 96 . . . 40288 1760 1 The the DT 40288 1760 2 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40288 1760 3 of of IN 40288 1760 4 intervals interval NNS 40288 1760 5 , , , 40288 1760 6 then then RB 40288 1760 7 , , , 40288 1760 8 which which WDT 40288 1760 9 surprises surprise VBZ 40288 1760 10 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1760 11 in in IN 40288 1760 12 the the DT 40288 1760 13 doctrine doctrine NN 40288 1760 14 of of IN 40288 1760 15 the the DT 40288 1760 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1760 17 genera genera NN 40288 1760 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1760 19 and and CC 40288 1760 20 ' ' `` 40288 1760 21 colours colour NNS 40288 1760 22 ' ' '' 40288 1760 23 was be VBD 40288 1760 24 not not RB 40288 1760 25 an an DT 40288 1760 26 accident accident NN 40288 1760 27 or or CC 40288 1760 28 excrescence excrescence NN 40288 1760 29 . . . 40288 1761 1 And and CC 40288 1761 2 although although IN 40288 1761 3 some some DT 40288 1761 4 of of IN 40288 1761 5 the the DT 40288 1761 6 finer fine JJR 40288 1761 7 varieties variety NNS 40288 1761 8 , , , 40288 1761 9 such such JJ 40288 1761 10 as as IN 40288 1761 11 the the DT 40288 1761 12 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1761 13 , , , 40288 1761 14 belong belong VBP 40288 1761 15 only only RB 40288 1761 16 to to IN 40288 1761 17 the the DT 40288 1761 18 early early JJ 40288 1761 19 or or CC 40288 1761 20 classical classical JJ 40288 1761 21 period period NN 40288 1761 22 , , , 40288 1761 23 there there EX 40288 1761 24 is be VBZ 40288 1761 25 enough enough JJ 40288 1761 26 to to TO 40288 1761 27 show show VB 40288 1761 28 that that IN 40288 1761 29 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1761 30 continued continue VBD 40288 1761 31 to to TO 40288 1761 32 be be VB 40288 1761 33 characteristic characteristic JJ 40288 1761 34 of of IN 40288 1761 35 the the DT 40288 1761 36 Greek greek JJ 40288 1761 37 musical musical JJ 40288 1761 38 system system NN 40288 1761 39 , , , 40288 1761 40 at at IN 40288 1761 41 least least JJS 40288 1761 42 until until IN 40288 1761 43 the the DT 40288 1761 44 revival revival NN 40288 1761 45 of of IN 40288 1761 46 Hellenism Hellenism NNP 40288 1761 47 in in IN 40288 1761 48 the the DT 40288 1761 49 age age NN 40288 1761 50 of of IN 40288 1761 51 the the DT 40288 1761 52 Antonines Antonines NNPS 40288 1761 53 . . . 40288 1762 1 The the DT 40288 1762 2 grounds ground NNS 40288 1762 3 of of IN 40288 1762 4 this this DT 40288 1762 5 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40288 1762 6 may may MD 40288 1762 7 be be VB 40288 1762 8 sought seek VBN 40288 1762 9 partly partly RB 40288 1762 10 in in IN 40288 1762 11 the the DT 40288 1762 12 Greek greek JJ 40288 1762 13 temperament temperament NN 40288 1762 14 . . . 40288 1763 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1763 2 can can MD 40288 1763 3 hardly hardly RB 40288 1763 4 deny deny VB 40288 1763 5 the the DT 40288 1763 6 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40288 1763 7 the the DT 40288 1763 8 credit credit NN 40288 1763 9 of of IN 40288 1763 10 a a DT 40288 1763 11 fineness fineness NN 40288 1763 12 of of IN 40288 1763 13 sensibility sensibility NN 40288 1763 14 upon upon IN 40288 1763 15 which which WDT 40288 1763 16 civilisation civilisation NN 40288 1763 17 , , , 40288 1763 18 to to TO 40288 1763 19 say say VB 40288 1763 20 the the DT 40288 1763 21 least least JJS 40288 1763 22 , , , 40288 1763 23 has have VBZ 40288 1763 24 made make VBN 40288 1763 25 no no DT 40288 1763 26 advance advance NN 40288 1763 27 . . . 40288 1764 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1764 2 may may MD 40288 1764 3 note note VB 40288 1764 4 further further RB 40288 1764 5 how how WRB 40288 1764 6 entirely entirely RB 40288 1764 7 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1764 8 is be VBZ 40288 1764 9 in in IN 40288 1764 10 accordance accordance NN 40288 1764 11 with with IN 40288 1764 12 the the DT 40288 1764 13 analogies analogy NNS 40288 1764 14 of of IN 40288 1764 15 Greek greek JJ 40288 1764 16 art art NN 40288 1764 17 to to TO 40288 1764 18 find find VB 40288 1764 19 a a DT 40288 1764 20 series series NN 40288 1764 21 of of IN 40288 1764 22 artistic artistic JJ 40288 1764 23 types type NNS 40288 1764 24 created create VBN 40288 1764 25 by by IN 40288 1764 26 subtle subtle JJ 40288 1764 27 variations variation NNS 40288 1764 28 within within IN 40288 1764 29 certain certain JJ 40288 1764 30 well well RB 40288 1764 31 - - HYPH 40288 1764 32 defined define VBN 40288 1764 33 limits limit NNS 40288 1764 34 . . . 40288 1765 1 For for IN 40288 1765 2 the the DT 40288 1765 3 present present JJ 40288 1765 4 purpose purpose NN 40288 1765 5 , , , 40288 1765 6 however however RB 40288 1765 7 , , , 40288 1765 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1765 9 will will MD 40288 1765 10 be be VB 40288 1765 11 enough enough JJ 40288 1765 12 to to TO 40288 1765 13 consider consider VB 40288 1765 14 how how WRB 40288 1765 15 the the DT 40288 1765 16 phenomenon phenomenon NN 40288 1765 17 is be VBZ 40288 1765 18 connected connect VBN 40288 1765 19 with with IN 40288 1765 20 other other JJ 40288 1765 21 known know VBN 40288 1765 22 characteristics characteristic NNS 40288 1765 23 of of IN 40288 1765 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1765 25 music,--its music,--its NNP 40288 1765 26 limited limited JJ 40288 1765 27 compass compass NN 40288 1765 28 and and CC 40288 1765 29 probably probably RB 40288 1765 30 imperfect imperfect VB 40288 1765 31 tonality tonality NN 40288 1765 32 , , , 40288 1765 33 the the DT 40288 1765 34 thin thin JJ 40288 1765 35 and and CC 40288 1765 36 passionless passionless JJ 40288 1765 37 quality quality NN 40288 1765 38 of of IN 40288 1765 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1765 40 chief chief JJ 40288 1765 41 instrument instrument NN 40288 1765 42 , , , 40288 1765 43 on on IN 40288 1765 44 the the DT 40288 1765 45 other other JJ 40288 1765 46 hand hand NN 40288 1765 47 the the DT 40288 1765 48 keen keen JJ 40288 1765 49 sense sense NN 40288 1765 50 of of IN 40288 1765 51 differences difference NNS 40288 1765 52 of of IN 40288 1765 53 pitch pitch NN 40288 1765 54 , , , 40288 1765 55 the the DT 40288 1765 56 finely finely RB 40288 1765 57 constructed construct VBN 40288 1765 58 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1765 59 , , , 40288 1765 60 and and CC 40288 1765 61 finally finally RB 40288 1765 62 the the DT 40288 1765 63 natural natural JJ 40288 1765 64 adaptation adaptation NN 40288 1765 65 , , , 40288 1765 66 on on IN 40288 1765 67 which which WDT 40288 1765 68 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1765 69 have have VBP 40288 1765 70 already already RB 40288 1765 71 dwelt dwell VBN 40288 1765 72 , , , 40288 1765 73 between between IN 40288 1765 74 the the DT 40288 1765 75 musical musical JJ 40288 1765 76 form form NN 40288 1765 77 and and CC 40288 1765 78 the the DT 40288 1765 79 language language NN 40288 1765 80 . . . 40288 1766 1 The the DT 40288 1766 2 last last JJ 40288 1766 3 is be VBZ 40288 1766 4 perhaps perhaps RB 40288 1766 5 the the DT 40288 1766 6 feature feature NN 40288 1766 7 of of IN 40288 1766 8 greatest great JJS 40288 1766 9 significance significance NN 40288 1766 10 , , , 40288 1766 11 especially especially RB 40288 1766 12 in in IN 40288 1766 13 a a DT 40288 1766 14 comparison comparison NN 40288 1766 15 of of IN 40288 1766 16 the the DT 40288 1766 17 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1766 18 and and CC 40288 1766 19 modern modern JJ 40288 1766 20 types type NNS 40288 1766 21 of of IN 40288 1766 22 the the DT 40288 1766 23 art art NN 40288 1766 24 . . . 40288 1767 1 The the DT 40288 1767 2 beauty beauty NN 40288 1767 3 and and CC 40288 1767 4 even even RB 40288 1767 5 the the DT 40288 1767 6 persuasive persuasive JJ 40288 1767 7 effect effect NN 40288 1767 8 of of IN 40288 1767 9 a a DT 40288 1767 10 voice voice NN 40288 1767 11 depend depend NN 40288 1767 12 , , , 40288 1767 13 as as IN 40288 1767 14 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1767 15 are be VBP 40288 1767 16 more more RBR 40288 1767 17 or or CC 40288 1767 18 less less RBR 40288 1767 19 aware aware JJ 40288 1767 20 , , , 40288 1767 21 in in IN 40288 1767 22 the the DT 40288 1767 23 first first JJ 40288 1767 24 place place NN 40288 1767 25 upon upon IN 40288 1767 26 the the DT 40288 1767 27 pitch pitch NN 40288 1767 28 or or CC 40288 1767 29 key key NN 40288 1767 30 in in IN 40288 1767 31 which which WDT 40288 1767 32 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1767 33 is be VBZ 40288 1767 34 set set VBN 40288 1767 35 , , , 40288 1767 36 and and CC 40288 1767 37 in in IN 40288 1767 38 the the DT 40288 1767 39 second second JJ 40288 1767 40 place place NN 40288 1767 41 upon upon IN 40288 1767 42 subtle subtle JJ 40288 1767 43 variations variation NNS 40288 1767 44 of of IN 40288 1767 45 pitch pitch NN 40288 1767 46 , , , 40288 1767 47 which which WDT 40288 1767 48 give give VBP 40288 1767 49 emphasis emphasis NN 40288 1767 50 , , , 40288 1767 51 or or CC 40288 1767 52 light light NN 40288 1767 53 and and CC 40288 1767 54 shade shade NN 40288 1767 55 . . . 40288 1768 1 Answering answer VBG 40288 1768 2 to to IN 40288 1768 3 the the DT 40288 1768 4 first first JJ 40288 1768 5 of of IN 40288 1768 6 these these DT 40288 1768 7 elements element NNS 40288 1768 8 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1768 9 music music NN 40288 1768 10 , , , 40288 1768 11 if if IN 40288 1768 12 the the DT 40288 1768 13 main main JJ 40288 1768 14 contention contention NN 40288 1768 15 of of IN 40288 1768 16 this this DT 40288 1768 17 essay essay NN 40288 1768 18 is be VBZ 40288 1768 19 right right JJ 40288 1768 20 , , , 40288 1768 21 has have VBZ 40288 1768 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1768 23 system system NN 40288 1768 24 of of IN 40288 1768 25 Modes Modes NNPS 40288 1768 26 or or CC 40288 1768 27 keys key NNS 40288 1768 28 . . . 40288 1769 1 Answering answer VBG 40288 1769 2 to to IN 40288 1769 3 the the DT 40288 1769 4 second second JJ 40288 1769 5 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1769 6 has have VBZ 40288 1769 7 a a DT 40288 1769 8 series series NN 40288 1769 9 of of IN 40288 1769 10 scales scale NNS 40288 1769 11 in in IN 40288 1769 12 which which WDT 40288 1769 13 the the DT 40288 1769 14 delicacy delicacy NN 40288 1769 15 and and CC 40288 1769 16 variety variety NN 40288 1769 17 of of IN 40288 1769 18 the the DT 40288 1769 19 intervals interval NNS 40288 1769 20 still still RB 40288 1769 21 fill fill VBP 40288 1769 22 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1769 23 with with IN 40288 1769 24 wonder wonder NN 40288 1769 25 . . . 40288 1770 1 In in IN 40288 1770 2 both both PDT 40288 1770 3 these these DT 40288 1770 4 points point NNS 40288 1770 5 modern modern JJ 40288 1770 6 music music NN 40288 1770 7 shows show NNS 40288 1770 8 diminished diminished JJ 40288 1770 9 resources resource NNS 40288 1770 10 . . . 40288 1771 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1771 2 have have VBP 40288 1771 3 in in IN 40288 1771 4 the the DT 40288 1771 5 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 1771 6 the the DT 40288 1771 7 same same JJ 40288 1771 8 or or CC 40288 1771 9 even even RB 40288 1771 10 a a DT 40288 1771 11 greater great JJR 40288 1771 12 command command NN 40288 1771 13 of of IN 40288 1771 14 degrees degree NNS 40288 1771 15 of of IN 40288 1771 16 pitch pitch NN 40288 1771 17 : : : 40288 1771 18 but but CC 40288 1771 19 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1771 20 seem seem VBP 40288 1771 21 to to TO 40288 1771 22 have have VB 40288 1771 23 lost lose VBN 40288 1771 24 the the DT 40288 1771 25 close close JJ 40288 1771 26 relation relation NN 40288 1771 27 which which WDT 40288 1771 28 once once RB 40288 1771 29 obtained obtain VBD 40288 1771 30 between between IN 40288 1771 31 a a DT 40288 1771 32 note note NN 40288 1771 33 as as IN 40288 1771 34 the the DT 40288 1771 35 result result NN 40288 1771 36 of of IN 40288 1771 37 physical physical JJ 40288 1771 38 facts fact NNS 40288 1771 39 and and CC 40288 1771 40 the the DT 40288 1771 41 same same JJ 40288 1771 42 note note NN 40288 1771 43 as as IN 40288 1771 44 an an DT 40288 1771 45 index index NN 40288 1771 46 of of IN 40288 1771 47 temper temper NN 40288 1771 48 or or CC 40288 1771 49 emotion emotion NN 40288 1771 50 . . . 40288 1772 1 A a DT 40288 1772 2 change change NN 40288 1772 3 of of IN 40288 1772 4 key key NN 40288 1772 5 affects affect VBZ 40288 1772 6 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1772 7 , , , 40288 1772 8 generally generally RB 40288 1772 9 speaking speak VBG 40288 1772 10 , , , 40288 1772 11 like like IN 40288 1772 12 a a DT 40288 1772 13 change change NN 40288 1772 14 of of IN 40288 1772 15 colour colour NN 40288 1772 16 or or CC 40288 1772 17 of of IN 40288 1772 18 movement movement NN 40288 1772 19 -- -- : 40288 1772 20 not not RB 40288 1772 21 as as IN 40288 1772 22 the the DT 40288 1772 23 heightening heighten VBG 40288 1772 24 or or CC 40288 1772 25 soothing soothing JJ 40288 1772 26 of of IN 40288 1772 27 a a DT 40288 1772 28 state state NN 40288 1772 29 of of IN 40288 1772 30 feeling feeling NN 40288 1772 31 . . . 40288 1773 1 In in IN 40288 1773 2 respect respect NN 40288 1773 3 of of IN 40288 1773 4 the the DT 40288 1773 5 second second JJ 40288 1773 6 element element NN 40288 1773 7 of of IN 40288 1773 8 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1773 9 expression expression NN 40288 1773 10 , , , 40288 1773 11 the the DT 40288 1773 12 rise rise NN 40288 1773 13 and and CC 40288 1773 14 fall fall NN 40288 1773 15 of of IN 40288 1773 16 the the DT 40288 1773 17 pitch pitch NN 40288 1773 18 , , , 40288 1773 19 Greek greek JJ 40288 1773 20 music music NN 40288 1773 21 possessed possess VBN 40288 1773 22 in in IN 40288 1773 23 the the DT 40288 1773 24 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40288 1773 25 of of IN 40288 1773 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1773 27 scales scale NNS 40288 1773 28 a a DT 40288 1773 29 range range NN 40288 1773 30 of of IN 40288 1773 31 expression expression NN 40288 1773 32 to to TO 40288 1773 33 which which WDT 40288 1773 34 there there EX 40288 1773 35 is be VBZ 40288 1773 36 no no DT 40288 1773 37 modern modern JJ 40288 1773 38 parallel parallel NN 40288 1773 39 . . . 40288 1774 1 The the DT 40288 1774 2 nearest near JJS 40288 1774 3 analogue analogue NN 40288 1774 4 may may MD 40288 1774 5 be be VB 40288 1774 6 found find VBN 40288 1774 7 in in IN 40288 1774 8 the the DT 40288 1774 9 use use NN 40288 1774 10 of of IN 40288 1774 11 modulation modulation NN 40288 1774 12 from from IN 40288 1774 13 a a DT 40288 1774 14 Major Major NNP 40288 1774 15 to to IN 40288 1774 16 a a DT 40288 1774 17 Minor minor JJ 40288 1774 18 key key NN 40288 1774 19 , , , 40288 1774 20 or or CC 40288 1774 21 the the DT 40288 1774 22 reverse reverse NN 40288 1774 23 . . . 40288 1775 1 But but CC 40288 1775 2 the the DT 40288 1775 3 changes change NNS 40288 1775 4 of of IN 40288 1775 5 genus genus JJ 40288 1775 6 and and CC 40288 1775 7 ' ' `` 40288 1775 8 colour colour NN 40288 1775 9 ' ' '' 40288 1775 10 at at IN 40288 1775 11 the the DT 40288 1775 12 disposal disposal NN 40288 1775 13 of of IN 40288 1775 14 an an DT 40288 1775 15 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1775 16 musician musician NN 40288 1775 17 must must MD 40288 1775 18 have have VB 40288 1775 19 been be VBN 40288 1775 20 acoustically acoustically RB 40288 1775 21 more more RBR 40288 1775 22 striking striking JJ 40288 1775 23 , , , 40288 1775 24 and and CC 40288 1775 25 must must MD 40288 1775 26 have have VB 40288 1775 27 come come VBN 40288 1775 28 nearer nearer RB 40288 1775 29 to to IN 40288 1775 30 reproducing reproducing NN 40288 1775 31 , , , 40288 1775 32 in in IN 40288 1775 33 an an DT 40288 1775 34 idealised idealised JJ 40288 1775 35 form form NN 40288 1775 36 , , , 40288 1775 37 the the DT 40288 1775 38 tones tone NNS 40288 1775 39 and and CC 40288 1775 40 inflexions inflexion NNS 40288 1775 41 of of IN 40288 1775 42 the the DT 40288 1775 43 speaking speak VBG 40288 1775 44 voice voice NN 40288 1775 45 . . . 40288 1776 1 The the DT 40288 1776 2 tendency tendency NN 40288 1776 3 of of IN 40288 1776 4 music music NN 40288 1776 5 that that WDT 40288 1776 6 is be VBZ 40288 1776 7 based base VBN 40288 1776 8 upon upon IN 40288 1776 9 harmony harmony NN 40288 1776 10 is be VBZ 40288 1776 11 to to TO 40288 1776 12 treat treat VB 40288 1776 13 the the DT 40288 1776 14 voice voice NN 40288 1776 15 as as IN 40288 1776 16 one one CD 40288 1776 17 of of IN 40288 1776 18 a a DT 40288 1776 19 number number NN 40288 1776 20 of of IN 40288 1776 21 instruments instrument NNS 40288 1776 22 , , , 40288 1776 23 and and CC 40288 1776 24 accordingly accordingly RB 40288 1776 25 to to TO 40288 1776 26 curtail curtail VB 40288 1776 27 the the DT 40288 1776 28 use use NN 40288 1776 29 of of IN 40288 1776 30 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1776 31 as as IN 40288 1776 32 the the DT 40288 1776 33 great great JJ 40288 1776 34 source source NN 40288 1776 35 of of IN 40288 1776 36 dramatic dramatic JJ 40288 1776 37 and and CC 40288 1776 38 emotional emotional JJ 40288 1776 39 effect effect NN 40288 1776 40 . . . 40288 1777 1 The the DT 40288 1777 2 consequence consequence NN 40288 1777 3 is be VBZ 40288 1777 4 twofold twofold JJ 40288 1777 5 . . . 40288 1778 1 On on IN 40288 1778 2 the the DT 40288 1778 3 one one CD 40288 1778 4 hand hand NN 40288 1778 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1778 6 lose lose VBP 40288 1778 7 sight sight NN 40288 1778 8 of of IN 40288 1778 9 the the DT 40288 1778 10 direct direct JJ 40288 1778 11 influence influence NN 40288 1778 12 exerted exert VBN 40288 1778 13 by by IN 40288 1778 14 sound sound NN 40288 1778 15 of of IN 40288 1778 16 certain certain JJ 40288 1778 17 degrees degree NNS 40288 1778 18 of of IN 40288 1778 19 pitch pitch NN 40288 1778 20 on on IN 40288 1778 21 the the DT 40288 1778 22 human human JJ 40288 1778 23 sensibility sensibility NN 40288 1778 24 , , , 40288 1778 25 and and CC 40288 1778 26 thus thus RB 40288 1778 27 ultimately ultimately RB 40288 1778 28 on on IN 40288 1778 29 character character NN 40288 1778 30 . . . 40288 1779 1 On on IN 40288 1779 2 the the DT 40288 1779 3 other other JJ 40288 1779 4 hand hand NN 40288 1779 5 the the DT 40288 1779 6 music music NN 40288 1779 7 becomes become VBZ 40288 1779 8 an an DT 40288 1779 9 independent independent JJ 40288 1779 10 creation creation NN 40288 1779 11 . . . 40288 1780 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1780 2 may may MD 40288 1780 3 still still RB 40288 1780 4 be be VB 40288 1780 5 a a DT 40288 1780 6 vehicle vehicle NN 40288 1780 7 of of IN 40288 1780 8 the the DT 40288 1780 9 deepest deep JJS 40288 1780 10 feeling feeling NN 40288 1780 11 : : : 40288 1780 12 but but CC 40288 1780 13 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1780 14 no no RB 40288 1780 15 longer longer RB 40288 1780 16 seeks seek VBZ 40288 1780 17 the the DT 40288 1780 18 aid aid NN 40288 1780 19 of of IN 40288 1780 20 language language NN 40288 1780 21 , , , 40288 1780 22 or or CC 40288 1780 23 reaches reach VBZ 40288 1780 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1780 25 aim aim NN 40288 1780 26 through through IN 40288 1780 27 the the DT 40288 1780 28 channels channel NNS 40288 1780 29 by by IN 40288 1780 30 which which WDT 40288 1780 31 language language NN 40288 1780 32 influences influence VBZ 40288 1780 33 the the DT 40288 1780 34 mind mind NN 40288 1780 35 of of IN 40288 1780 36 man man NN 40288 1780 37 . . . 40288 1781 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1781 2 Footnote footnote NN 40288 1781 3 1 1 CD 40288 1781 4 : : : 40288 1781 5 The the DT 40288 1781 6 two two CD 40288 1781 7 schools school NNS 40288 1781 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 1781 9 by by IN 40288 1781 10 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1781 11 seem seem VBP 40288 1781 12 to to TO 40288 1781 13 be be VB 40288 1781 14 those those DT 40288 1781 15 which which WDT 40288 1781 16 were be VBD 40288 1781 17 afterwards afterwards RB 40288 1781 18 known know VBN 40288 1781 19 as as IN 40288 1781 20 the the DT 40288 1781 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1781 22 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1781 23 : : : 40288 1781 24 harmonikoi harmonikoi NN 40288 1781 25 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1781 26 or or CC 40288 1781 27 Aristoxeneans Aristoxeneans NNPS 40288 1781 28 , , , 40288 1781 29 and and CC 40288 1781 30 the the DT 40288 1781 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1781 32 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1781 33 : : : 40288 1781 34 mathêmatikoi mathêmatikoi NNP 40288 1781 35 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1781 36 , , , 40288 1781 37 who who WP 40288 1781 38 carried carry VBD 40288 1781 39 on on IN 40288 1781 40 the the DT 40288 1781 41 tradition tradition NN 40288 1781 42 of of IN 40288 1781 43 Pythagoras Pythagoras NNP 40288 1781 44 . . . 40288 1782 1 The the DT 40288 1782 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1782 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1782 4 : : : 40288 1782 5 harmonikoi harmonikoi NNP 40288 1782 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1782 7 regarded regard VBD 40288 1782 8 a a DT 40288 1782 9 musical musical JJ 40288 1782 10 interval interval NN 40288 1782 11 as as IN 40288 1782 12 a a DT 40288 1782 13 quantity quantity NN 40288 1782 14 which which WDT 40288 1782 15 could could MD 40288 1782 16 be be VB 40288 1782 17 measured measure VBN 40288 1782 18 directly directly RB 40288 1782 19 by by IN 40288 1782 20 the the DT 40288 1782 21 ear ear NN 40288 1782 22 , , , 40288 1782 23 without without IN 40288 1782 24 reference reference NN 40288 1782 25 to to IN 40288 1782 26 the the DT 40288 1782 27 numerical numerical JJ 40288 1782 28 ratio ratio NN 40288 1782 29 upon upon IN 40288 1782 30 which which WDT 40288 1782 31 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1782 32 might may MD 40288 1782 33 be be VB 40288 1782 34 based base VBN 40288 1782 35 . . . 40288 1783 1 They -PRON- PRP 40288 1783 2 practically practically RB 40288 1783 3 adopted adopt VBD 40288 1783 4 the the DT 40288 1783 5 system system NN 40288 1783 6 of of IN 40288 1783 7 equal equal JJ 40288 1783 8 temperament temperament NN 40288 1783 9 . . . 40288 1784 1 The the DT 40288 1784 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1784 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1784 4 : : : 40288 1784 5 mathêmatikoi mathêmatikoi NNP 40288 1784 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1784 7 sought seek VBN 40288 1784 8 for for IN 40288 1784 9 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1784 10 , , , 40288 1784 11 but but CC 40288 1784 12 by by IN 40288 1784 13 experiment experiment NN 40288 1784 14 ' ' '' 40288 1784 15 among among IN 40288 1784 16 the the DT 40288 1784 17 consonances consonance NNS 40288 1784 18 which which WDT 40288 1784 19 are be VBP 40288 1784 20 heard hear VBN 40288 1784 21 , , , 40288 1784 22 ' ' '' 40288 1784 23 as as IN 40288 1784 24 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1784 25 says say VBZ 40288 1784 26 . . . 40288 1785 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1785 2 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1785 3 failed fail VBD 40288 1785 4 equally equally RB 40288 1785 5 with with IN 40288 1785 6 those those DT 40288 1785 7 whose whose WP$ 40288 1785 8 method method NN 40288 1785 9 never never RB 40288 1785 10 rose rise VBD 40288 1785 11 above above IN 40288 1785 12 the the DT 40288 1785 13 facts fact NNS 40288 1785 14 of of IN 40288 1785 15 sense sense NN 40288 1785 16 . . . 40288 1785 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1786 1 * * NFP 40288 1786 2 * * NFP 40288 1786 3 * * NFP 40288 1786 4 * * NFP 40288 1786 5 * * NFP 40288 1786 6 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 40288 1786 7 TABLE TABLE NNP 40288 1786 8 I. i. NN 40288 1787 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1787 2 Scales Scales NNP 40288 1787 3 of of IN 40288 1787 4 the the DT 40288 1787 5 seven seven CD 40288 1787 6 oldest old JJS 40288 1787 7 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 1787 8 , , , 40288 1787 9 with with IN 40288 1787 10 the the DT 40288 1787 11 species specie NNS 40288 1787 12 of of IN 40288 1787 13 the the DT 40288 1787 14 same same JJ 40288 1787 15 name name NN 40288 1787 16 . . . 40288 1787 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1787 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1787 19 Music music NN 40288 1787 20 : : : 40288 1787 21 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1787 22 - - HYPH 40288 1787 23 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1787 24 . . . 40288 1788 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1788 2 b_-species b_-species NNP 40288 1788 3 . . . 40288 1788 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1789 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1789 2 Music music NN 40288 1789 3 : : : 40288 1789 4 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1789 5 . . . 40288 1790 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1790 2 c_-species c_-species NNP 40288 1790 3 . . . 40288 1790 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1791 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1791 2 Music music NN 40288 1791 3 : : : 40288 1791 4 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1791 5 . . . 40288 1792 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1792 2 d_-species d_-species NNP 40288 1792 3 . . . 40288 1792 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1793 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1793 2 Music music NN 40288 1793 3 : : : 40288 1793 4 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1793 5 . . . 40288 1794 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1794 2 e_-species e_-species NNP 40288 1794 3 . . . 40288 1794 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1795 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1795 2 Music music NN 40288 1795 3 : : : 40288 1795 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1795 5 - - HYPH 40288 1795 6 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1795 7 . . . 40288 1796 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1796 2 f_-species f_-species NNP 40288 1796 3 . . . 40288 1796 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1797 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1797 2 Music music NN 40288 1797 3 : : : 40288 1797 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1797 5 - - HYPH 40288 1797 6 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1797 7 . . . 40288 1798 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1798 2 g_-species g_-species NNP 40288 1798 3 . . . 40288 1798 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1799 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1799 2 Music music NN 40288 1799 3 : : : 40288 1799 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1799 5 - - HYPH 40288 1799 6 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1799 7 . . . 40288 1800 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1800 2 a_-species a_-species NNP 40288 1800 3 . . . 40288 1800 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1801 1 TABLE TABLE NNP 40288 1801 2 II ii CD 40288 1801 3 . . . 40288 1802 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1802 2 The the DT 40288 1802 3 fifteen fifteen CD 40288 1802 4 Keys Keys NNPS 40288 1802 5 . . . 40288 1802 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1802 7 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1802 8 . . . 40288 1803 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1803 2 Music music NN 40288 1803 3 : : : 40288 1803 4 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 1803 5 - - HYPH 40288 1803 6 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1803 7 . . . 40288 1803 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1804 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1804 2 Music music NN 40288 1804 3 : : : 40288 1804 4 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 1804 5 - - HYPH 40288 1804 6 aeolian aeolian NNP 40288 1804 7 . . . 40288 1804 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1805 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1805 2 Music music NN 40288 1805 3 : : : 40288 1805 4 Hyper hyper NN 40288 1805 5 - - NN 40288 1805 6 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1805 7 . . . 40288 1805 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1806 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1806 2 Music music NN 40288 1806 3 : : : 40288 1806 4 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 1806 5 - - HYPH 40288 1806 6 ionian ionian NNP 40288 1806 7 . . . 40288 1806 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1807 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1807 2 Music music NN 40288 1807 3 : : : 40288 1807 4 Mixo Mixo NNP 40288 1807 5 - - HYPH 40288 1807 6 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1807 7 . . . 40288 1807 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1808 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1808 2 Music music NN 40288 1808 3 : : : 40288 1808 4 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1808 5 . . . 40288 1808 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1809 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1809 2 Music music NN 40288 1809 3 : : : 40288 1809 4 Aeolian Aeolian NNP 40288 1809 5 . . . 40288 1809 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1810 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1810 2 Music music NN 40288 1810 3 : : : 40288 1810 4 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1810 5 . . . 40288 1810 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1811 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1811 2 Music music NN 40288 1811 3 : : : 40288 1811 4 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1811 5 . . . 40288 1811 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1812 1 Mesê Mesê NNS 40288 1812 2 . . . 40288 1813 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1813 2 Music music NN 40288 1813 3 : : : 40288 1813 4 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1813 5 . . . 40288 1813 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1814 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1814 2 Music music NN 40288 1814 3 : : : 40288 1814 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1814 5 - - HYPH 40288 1814 6 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1814 7 . . . 40288 1814 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1815 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1815 2 Music music NN 40288 1815 3 : : : 40288 1815 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1815 5 - - HYPH 40288 1815 6 aeolian aeolian NNP 40288 1815 7 . . . 40288 1815 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1816 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1816 2 Music music NN 40288 1816 3 : : : 40288 1816 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1816 5 - - HYPH 40288 1816 6 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1816 7 . . . 40288 1816 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1817 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1817 2 Music music NN 40288 1817 3 : : : 40288 1817 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1817 5 - - HYPH 40288 1817 6 ionian ionian NNP 40288 1817 7 . . . 40288 1817 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1818 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1818 2 Music music NN 40288 1818 3 : : : 40288 1818 4 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1818 5 - - HYPH 40288 1818 6 dorian dorian NNP 40288 1818 7 . . . 40288 1818 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1819 1 The the DT 40288 1819 2 moveable moveable JJ 40288 1819 3 notes note NNS 40288 1819 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1819 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1819 6 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1819 7 : : : 40288 1819 8 phthongoi phthongoi NNP 40288 1819 9 kinoumenoi kinoumenoi NNP 40288 1819 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1819 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1819 12 are be VBP 40288 1819 13 distinguished distinguish VBN 40288 1819 14 by by IN 40288 1819 15 being be VBG 40288 1819 16 printed print VBN 40288 1819 17 as as IN 40288 1819 18 crotchets crotchet NNS 40288 1819 19 . . . 40288 1820 1 The the DT 40288 1820 2 two two CD 40288 1820 3 highest high JJS 40288 1820 4 of of IN 40288 1820 5 these these DT 40288 1820 6 keys key NNS 40288 1820 7 -- -- : 40288 1820 8 the the DT 40288 1820 9 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 1820 10 - - HYPH 40288 1820 11 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1820 12 and and CC 40288 1820 13 the the DT 40288 1820 14 Hyper Hyper NNP 40288 1820 15 - - HYPH 40288 1820 16 aeolian aeolian NNP 40288 1820 17 -- -- : 40288 1820 18 appear appear VBP 40288 1820 19 to to TO 40288 1820 20 have have VB 40288 1820 21 been be VBN 40288 1820 22 added add VBN 40288 1820 23 in in IN 40288 1820 24 the the DT 40288 1820 25 time time NN 40288 1820 26 of of IN 40288 1820 27 the the DT 40288 1820 28 Empire Empire NNP 40288 1820 29 . . . 40288 1821 1 The the DT 40288 1821 2 remaining remain VBG 40288 1821 3 thirteen thirteen CD 40288 1821 4 are be VBP 40288 1821 5 attributed attribute VBN 40288 1821 6 to to IN 40288 1821 7 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1821 8 in in IN 40288 1821 9 the the DT 40288 1821 10 pseudo pseudo NN 40288 1821 11 - - JJ 40288 1821 12 Euclidean euclidean JJ 40288 1821 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1821 14 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 1821 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1821 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1821 17 p. p. NN 40288 1821 18 19 19 CD 40288 1821 19 , , , 40288 1821 20 l. l. NNP 40288 1821 21 30 30 CD 40288 1821 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1821 23 , , , 40288 1821 24 and and CC 40288 1821 25 by by IN 40288 1821 26 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1821 27 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 1821 28 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1821 29 p. p. NN 40288 1821 30 22 22 CD 40288 1821 31 , , , 40288 1821 32 l. l. NNP 40288 1821 33 30 30 CD 40288 1821 34 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1821 35 : : : 40288 1821 36 but but CC 40288 1821 37 there there EX 40288 1821 38 is be VBZ 40288 1821 39 no no DT 40288 1821 40 mention mention NN 40288 1821 41 of of IN 40288 1821 42 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1821 43 in in IN 40288 1821 44 the the DT 40288 1821 45 extant extant JJ 40288 1821 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1821 47 Harmonics Harmonics NNP 40288 1821 48 _ _ NNP 40288 1821 49 . . . 40288 1822 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1822 2 may may MD 40288 1822 3 be be VB 40288 1822 4 gathered gather VBN 40288 1822 5 , , , 40288 1822 6 however however RB 40288 1822 7 , , , 40288 1822 8 from from IN 40288 1822 9 the the DT 40288 1822 10 criticism criticism NN 40288 1822 11 of of IN 40288 1822 12 Heraclides Heraclides NNP 40288 1822 13 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 1822 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1822 15 see see VB 40288 1822 16 the the DT 40288 1822 17 passage passage NN 40288 1822 18 discussed discuss VBN 40288 1822 19 on on IN 40288 1822 20 pp pp NNP 40288 1822 21 . . . 40288 1823 1 9 9 CD 40288 1823 2 - - SYM 40288 1823 3 12 12 CD 40288 1823 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1823 5 that that IN 40288 1823 6 the the DT 40288 1823 7 list list NN 40288 1823 8 of of IN 40288 1823 9 keys key NNS 40288 1823 10 was be VBD 40288 1823 11 being be VBG 40288 1823 12 considerably considerably RB 40288 1823 13 enlarged enlarge VBN 40288 1823 14 in in IN 40288 1823 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1823 16 time time NN 40288 1823 17 , , , 40288 1823 18 and and CC 40288 1823 19 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1823 20 , , , 40288 1823 21 though though IN 40288 1823 22 not not RB 40288 1823 23 named name VBN 40288 1823 24 , , , 40288 1823 25 is be VBZ 40288 1823 26 doubtless doubtless RB 40288 1823 27 aimed aim VBN 40288 1823 28 at at IN 40288 1823 29 there there RB 40288 1823 30 . . . 40288 1824 1 Music music NN 40288 1824 2 of of IN 40288 1824 3 the the DT 40288 1824 4 ' ' `` 40288 1824 5 Orestes oreste NNS 40288 1824 6 ' ' '' 40288 1824 7 of of IN 40288 1824 8 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1824 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1824 10 ll will NN 40288 1824 11 . . . 40288 1825 1 338 338 CD 40288 1825 2 - - SYM 40288 1825 3 344 344 CD 40288 1825 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1825 5 . . . 40288 1826 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1826 2 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1826 3 : : : 40288 1826 4 II II NNP 40288 1826 5 P p NN 40288 1826 6 C. c. NN 40288 1826 7 P p NN 40288 1826 8 ? ? . 40288 1827 1 40 40 CD 40288 1827 2 n n NN 40288 1827 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1827 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1827 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1827 6 : : : 40288 1827 7 katoloPHYROMAIZMATEROS katoloPHYROMAIZMATEROS NNP 40288 1827 8 haima haima NNP 40288 1827 9 sas sas NNP 40288 1827 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1827 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1827 12 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1827 13 : : : 40288 1827 14 Z Z NNP 40288 1827 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1827 16 ? ? . 40288 1828 1 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1828 2 .. .. NFP 40288 1828 3 1 1 CD 40288 1828 4 ' ' POS 40288 1828 5 " " `` 40288 1828 6 Z z NN 40288 1828 7 E e NN 40288 1828 8 E e NN 40288 1828 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1828 10 ? ? . 40288 1828 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1828 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1829 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1829 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1829 3 : : : 40288 1829 4 ho ho NNP 40288 1829 5 s s NNP 40288 1829 6 ' ' '' 40288 1829 7 anab anab NN 40288 1829 8 AKCHEUEIZOMEGAS AKCHEUEIZOMEGAS NNP 40288 1829 9 olbos olbos RB 40288 1829 10 ou ou NNP 40288 1829 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1829 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1829 13 Symbols:-ii Symbols:-ii NNP 40288 1829 14 P p NN 40288 1829 15 C. c. NN 40288 1829 16 I i NN 40288 1829 17 ' ' `` 40288 1829 18 Z z NN 40288 1829 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1829 20 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1829 21 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1829 22 : : : 40288 1829 23 monimoSEMBROTOISZANA monimosembrotoiszana FW 40288 1829 24 de de FW 40288 1829 25 laiphos laiphos NNP 40288 1829 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1829 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1829 28 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1829 29 : : : 40288 1829 30 C C NNP 40288 1829 31 P P NNP 40288 1829 32 - - HYPH 40288 1829 33 A a NN 40288 1829 34 C C NNP 40288 1829 35 p p NN 40288 1829 36 - - : 40288 1829 37 i i PRP 40288 1829 38 ? ? . 40288 1829 39 . . . 40288 1830 1 c c LS 40288 1830 2 , , , 40288 1830 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1830 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1830 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1830 6 : : : 40288 1830 7 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1830 8 tiSAKATOUTHOASTINAxas tiSAKATOUTHOASTINAxas NNP 40288 1830 9 dai- dai- NN 40288 1830 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1830 11 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1830 12 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1830 13 : : : 40288 1830 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1830 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1830 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1830 17 : : : 40288 1830 18 môn môn NNP 40288 1830 19 KATEKLYSEN KATEKLYSEN NNP 40288 1830 20 deinôn deinôn NNP 40288 1830 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1830 22 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1830 23 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1830 24 : : : 40288 1830 25 Z z XX 40288 1830 26 re re NN 40288 1830 27 . . . 40288 1831 1 z z LS 40288 1831 2 ? ? . 40288 1831 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1832 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1832 2 Greek greek JJ 40288 1832 3 : : : 40288 1832 4 ponôN[Symbols ponôn[symbol NNS 40288 1832 5 : : : 40288 1832 6 ? ? . 40288 1832 7 ? ? . 40288 1832 8 ? ? . 40288 1833 1 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1833 2 ÔÔSPONT ÔÔSPONT NNP 40288 1833 3 ou ou NNP 40288 1833 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1833 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1833 6 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1833 7 : : : 40288 1833 8 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1833 9 C c NN 40288 1833 10 : : : 40288 1833 11 C c NN 40288 1833 12 : : : 40288 1833 13 Pvl Pvl NNP 40288 1833 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1833 15 ? ? . 40288 1833 16 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1834 1 40 40 CD 40288 1834 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1834 3 ? ? . 40288 1834 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1834 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1835 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1835 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1835 3 : : : 40288 1835 4 olethrIoiSIN olethrioisin UH 40288 1835 5 en en FW 40288 1835 6 kymasin kymasin NNP 40288 1835 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1835 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1835 9 Music music NN 40288 1835 10 : : : 40288 1835 11 Restoration Restoration NNP 40288 1835 12 proposed propose VBN 40288 1835 13 by by IN 40288 1835 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1835 15 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1835 16 . . . 40288 1836 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1836 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1836 3 : : : 40288 1836 4 kat kat NNP 40288 1836 5 - - HYPH 40288 1836 6 o o NNP 40288 1836 7 - - HYPH 40288 1836 8 lo lo NNP 40288 1836 9 - - HYPH 40288 1836 10 phu phu NNP 40288 1836 11 - - HYPH 40288 1836 12 ro ro NNP 40288 1836 13 - - HYPH 40288 1836 14 mai mai NNP 40288 1836 15 ma ma NNP 40288 1836 16 - - HYPH 40288 1836 17 te te NNP 40288 1836 18 - - HYPH 40288 1836 19 ros ros NNP 40288 1836 20 ai ai NNP 40288 1836 21 - - HYPH 40288 1836 22 ma ma NNP 40288 1836 23 sas sas NNP 40288 1836 24 o o NNP 40288 1836 25 s s NNP 40288 1836 26 ana ana NNP 40288 1836 27 - - HYPH 40288 1836 28 bak bak NNP 40288 1836 29 - - HYPH 40288 1836 30 cheu cheu NNP 40288 1836 31 - - HYPH 40288 1836 32 ei ei NNP 40288 1836 33 . . . 40288 1837 1 o o UH 40288 1837 2 me me NN 40288 1837 3 - - HYPH 40288 1837 4 gas gas NN 40288 1837 5 ol ol NNP 40288 1837 6 - - HYPH 40288 1837 7 bos bos NNP 40288 1837 8 ou ou NNP 40288 1837 9 mon mon NNP 40288 1837 10 - - HYPH 40288 1837 11 i i NNP 40288 1837 12 - - HYPH 40288 1837 13 mos mos NN 40288 1837 14 en en NNP 40288 1837 15 Bro Bro NNP 40288 1837 16 - - HYPH 40288 1837 17 tois tois NNP 40288 1837 18 a a DT 40288 1837 19 - - : 40288 1837 20 na na FW 40288 1837 21 de de NNP 40288 1837 22 lai lai NNP 40288 1837 23 - - HYPH 40288 1837 24 phos phos NNP 40288 1837 25 hôs hôs NN 40288 1837 26 tis tis CC 40288 1837 27 a a DT 40288 1837 28 - - HYPH 40288 1837 29 ka ka NNP 40288 1837 30 - - HYPH 40288 1837 31 tou tou NNP 40288 1837 32 tho tho NN 40288 1837 33 - - : 40288 1837 34 as as IN 40288 1837 35 ti ti JJ 40288 1837 36 - - HYPH 40288 1837 37 na na IN 40288 1837 38 - - HYPH 40288 1837 39 xas xas NNP 40288 1837 40 dai dai NNP 40288 1837 41 - - HYPH 40288 1837 42 môn môn NNP 40288 1837 43 kat kat NNP 40288 1837 44 - - HYPH 40288 1837 45 ek ek NNP 40288 1837 46 - - HYPH 40288 1837 47 ly ly NNP 40288 1837 48 - - HYPH 40288 1837 49 sen sen NNP 40288 1837 50 dei dei NNP 40288 1837 51 - - HYPH 40288 1837 52 nôn nôn NNP 40288 1837 53 po po NNP 40288 1837 54 - - HYPH 40288 1837 55 nôn nôn NNP 40288 1837 56 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1837 57 pon pon NNP 40288 1837 58 - - HYPH 40288 1837 59 tou tou NNP 40288 1837 60 lab lab NNP 40288 1837 61 - - HYPH 40288 1837 62 rois rois NNP 40288 1837 63 o o NN 40288 1837 64 - - HYPH 40288 1837 65 leth leth NN 40288 1837 66 - - HYPH 40288 1837 67 ri ri IN 40288 1837 68 - - HYPH 40288 1837 69 oi oi NN 40288 1837 70 - - HYPH 40288 1837 71 sin sin NN 40288 1837 72 en en FW 40288 1837 73 ky ky NNP 40288 1837 74 - - HYPH 40288 1837 75 ma ma NNP 40288 1837 76 - - HYPH 40288 1837 77 sin sin NNP 40288 1837 78 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1837 79 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1837 80 The the DT 40288 1837 81 metre metre NN 40288 1837 82 is be VBZ 40288 1837 83 dochmiac dochmiac NN 40288 1837 84 , , , 40288 1837 85 each each DT 40288 1837 86 dochmius dochmius NN 40288 1837 87 consisting consist VBG 40288 1837 88 of of IN 40288 1837 89 an an DT 40288 1837 90 iambus iambus NN 40288 1837 91 followed follow VBN 40288 1837 92 by by IN 40288 1837 93 a a DT 40288 1837 94 cretic cretic JJ 40288 1837 95 , , , 40288 1837 96 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1837 97 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1837 98 : : : 40288 1837 99 u u LS 40288 1837 100 -- -- : 40288 1837 101 u- u- XX 40288 1837 102 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1837 103 . . . 40288 1838 1 The the DT 40288 1838 2 points point NNS 40288 1838 3 which which WDT 40288 1838 4 seem seem VBP 40288 1838 5 to to TO 40288 1838 6 mark mark VB 40288 1838 7 the the DT 40288 1838 8 ictus ictus NN 40288 1838 9 , , , 40288 1838 10 or or CC 40288 1838 11 rhythmical rhythmical JJ 40288 1838 12 accent accent NN 40288 1838 13 , , , 40288 1838 14 are be VBP 40288 1838 15 found find VBN 40288 1838 16 on on IN 40288 1838 17 the the DT 40288 1838 18 first first JJ 40288 1838 19 syllable syllable NN 40288 1838 20 of of IN 40288 1838 21 each each DT 40288 1838 22 of of IN 40288 1838 23 these these DT 40288 1838 24 two two CD 40288 1838 25 feet foot NNS 40288 1838 26 . . . 40288 1839 1 If if IN 40288 1839 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1839 3 assume assume VBP 40288 1839 4 that that IN 40288 1839 5 the the DT 40288 1839 6 first first JJ 40288 1839 7 syllable syllable NN 40288 1839 8 of of IN 40288 1839 9 the the DT 40288 1839 10 iambus iambus NNP 40288 1839 11 has have VBZ 40288 1839 12 the the DT 40288 1839 13 chief chief JJ 40288 1839 14 accent accent NN 40288 1839 15 , , , 40288 1839 16 the the DT 40288 1839 17 dochmius dochmius NN 40288 1839 18 will will MD 40288 1839 19 be be VB 40288 1839 20 correctly correctly RB 40288 1839 21 expressed express VBN 40288 1839 22 as as IN 40288 1839 23 a a DT 40288 1839 24 musical musical JJ 40288 1839 25 bar bar NN 40288 1839 26 of of IN 40288 1839 27 the the DT 40288 1839 28 form-- form-- JJ 40288 1839 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1839 30 Music Music NNP 40288 1839 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1839 32 If if IN 40288 1839 33 the the DT 40288 1839 34 first first JJ 40288 1839 35 syllable syllable NN 40288 1839 36 of of IN 40288 1839 37 the the DT 40288 1839 38 cretic cretic NN 40288 1839 39 is be VBZ 40288 1839 40 accented accent VBN 40288 1839 41 , , , 40288 1839 42 the the DT 40288 1839 43 dochmius dochmius NN 40288 1839 44 is be VBZ 40288 1839 45 divided divide VBN 40288 1839 46 between between IN 40288 1839 47 two two CD 40288 1839 48 bars bar NNS 40288 1839 49 , , , 40288 1839 50 and and CC 40288 1839 51 becomes-- becomes-- JJ 40288 1839 52 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1839 53 Music Music NNP 40288 1839 54 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1839 55 The the DT 40288 1839 56 accompaniment accompaniment NN 40288 1839 57 or or CC 40288 1839 58 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1839 59 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1839 60 : : : 40288 1839 61 krousis krousis NN 40288 1839 62 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1839 63 , , , 40288 1839 64 consisting consist VBG 40288 1839 65 of of IN 40288 1839 66 notes note NNS 40288 1839 67 interposed interpose VBN 40288 1839 68 between between IN 40288 1839 69 the the DT 40288 1839 70 phrases phrase NNS 40288 1839 71 of of IN 40288 1839 72 the the DT 40288 1839 73 melody melody NN 40288 1839 74 , , , 40288 1839 75 is be VBZ 40288 1839 76 found find VBN 40288 1839 77 by by IN 40288 1839 78 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1839 79 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1839 80 and and CC 40288 1839 81 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1839 82 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1839 83 in in IN 40288 1839 84 the the DT 40288 1839 85 following follow VBG 40288 1839 86 characters character NNS 40288 1839 87 : : : 40288 1839 88 1 1 CD 40288 1839 89 . . . 40288 1840 1 The the DT 40288 1840 2 character character NN 40288 1840 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1840 4 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1840 5 : : : 40288 1840 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1840 7 appears appear VBZ 40288 1840 8 at at IN 40288 1840 9 the the DT 40288 1840 10 end end NN 40288 1840 11 of of IN 40288 1840 12 every every DT 40288 1840 13 dochmius dochmius NN 40288 1840 14 shown show VBN 40288 1840 15 by by IN 40288 1840 16 the the DT 40288 1840 17 papyrus papyru NNS 40288 1840 18 . . . 40288 1841 1 After after IN 40288 1841 2 the the DT 40288 1841 3 first first JJ 40288 1841 4 , , , 40288 1841 5 third third JJ 40288 1841 6 and and CC 40288 1841 7 fifth fifth JJ 40288 1841 8 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1841 9 is be VBZ 40288 1841 10 written write VBN 40288 1841 11 in in IN 40288 1841 12 the the DT 40288 1841 13 same same JJ 40288 1841 14 line line NN 40288 1841 15 with with IN 40288 1841 16 the the DT 40288 1841 17 text text NN 40288 1841 18 . . . 40288 1842 1 After after IN 40288 1842 2 the the DT 40288 1842 3 seventh seventh JJ 40288 1842 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1842 5 is be VBZ 40288 1842 6 written write VBN 40288 1842 7 above above IN 40288 1842 8 that that DT 40288 1842 9 line line NN 40288 1842 10 , , , 40288 1842 11 between between IN 40288 1842 12 two two CD 40288 1842 13 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1842 14 notes note NNS 40288 1842 15 . . . 40288 1843 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1843 2 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1843 3 takes take VBZ 40288 1843 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1843 5 to to TO 40288 1843 6 be be VB 40288 1843 7 the the DT 40288 1843 8 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1843 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1843 10 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1843 11 : : : 40288 1843 12 Z Z NNP 40288 1843 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1843 14 , , , 40288 1843 15 explaining explain VBG 40288 1843 16 the the DT 40288 1843 17 difference difference NN 40288 1843 18 of of IN 40288 1843 19 shape shape NN 40288 1843 20 as as IN 40288 1843 21 due due IN 40288 1843 22 to to IN 40288 1843 23 the the DT 40288 1843 24 necessity necessity NN 40288 1843 25 or or CC 40288 1843 26 convenience convenience NN 40288 1843 27 of of IN 40288 1843 28 distinguishing distinguish VBG 40288 1843 29 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1843 30 from from IN 40288 1843 31 the the DT 40288 1843 32 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1843 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1843 34 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1843 35 : : : 40288 1843 36 Z Z NNP 40288 1843 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1843 38 . . . 40288 1844 1 If if IN 40288 1844 2 that that DT 40288 1844 3 were be VBD 40288 1844 4 so so RB 40288 1844 5 the the DT 40288 1844 6 form form NN 40288 1844 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1844 8 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1844 9 : : : 40288 1844 10 1 1 LS 40288 1844 11 . . . 40288 1844 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1845 1 would would MD 40288 1845 2 surely surely RB 40288 1845 3 have have VB 40288 1845 4 been be VBN 40288 1845 5 permanent permanent JJ 40288 1845 6 , , , 40288 1845 7 and and CC 40288 1845 8 would would MD 40288 1845 9 have have VB 40288 1845 10 been be VBN 40288 1845 11 given give VBN 40288 1845 12 in in IN 40288 1845 13 the the DT 40288 1845 14 schemes scheme NNS 40288 1845 15 of of IN 40288 1845 16 Alypius Alypius NNP 40288 1845 17 and and CC 40288 1845 18 Aristides Aristides NNP 40288 1845 19 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 1845 20 . . . 40288 1846 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1846 2 venture venture VBP 40288 1846 3 to to TO 40288 1846 4 suggest suggest VB 40288 1846 5 that that IN 40288 1846 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1846 7 is be VBZ 40288 1846 8 a a DT 40288 1846 9 mark mark NN 40288 1846 10 intended intend VBN 40288 1846 11 to to TO 40288 1846 12 show show VB 40288 1846 13 the the DT 40288 1846 14 end end NN 40288 1846 15 of of IN 40288 1846 16 the the DT 40288 1846 17 dochmius dochmius NN 40288 1846 18 or or CC 40288 1846 19 bar bar NN 40288 1846 20 . . . 40288 1847 1 2 2 LS 40288 1847 2 . . . 40288 1848 1 The the DT 40288 1848 2 group group NN 40288 1848 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1848 4 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1848 5 : : : 40288 1848 6 21 21 CD 40288 1848 7 D d NN 40288 1848 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1848 9 occurs occur VBZ 40288 1848 10 twice twice RB 40288 1848 11 , , , 40288 1848 12 before before RB 40288 1848 13 and and CC 40288 1848 14 after after IN 40288 1848 15 the the DT 40288 1848 16 words word NNS 40288 1848 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1848 18 Greek greek JJ 40288 1848 19 : : : 40288 1848 20 deinôn deinôn NNP 40288 1848 21 ponôn ponôn NN 40288 1848 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1848 23 . . . 40288 1849 1 There there EX 40288 1849 2 is be VBZ 40288 1849 3 a a DT 40288 1849 4 difficulty difficulty NN 40288 1849 5 about about IN 40288 1849 6 the the DT 40288 1849 7 sign sign NN 40288 1849 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1849 9 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1849 10 : : : 40288 1849 11 2 2 LS 40288 1849 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1849 13 , , , 40288 1849 14 which which WDT 40288 1849 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1849 16 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1849 17 takes take VBZ 40288 1849 18 to to TO 40288 1849 19 be be VB 40288 1849 20 a a DT 40288 1849 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1849 22 Vortragszeichen Vortragszeichen NNP 40288 1849 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1849 24 . . . 40288 1850 1 The the DT 40288 1850 2 other other JJ 40288 1850 3 two two CD 40288 1850 4 characters character NNS 40288 1850 5 may may MD 40288 1850 6 be be VB 40288 1850 7 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1850 8 notes note NNS 40288 1850 9 . . . 40288 1851 1 The the DT 40288 1851 2 double double JJ 40288 1851 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1851 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1851 5 : : : 40288 1851 6 ô ô LS 40288 1851 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1851 8 of of IN 40288 1851 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1851 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1851 11 : : : 40288 1851 12 hôs hôs NN 40288 1851 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1851 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1851 15 written write VBN 40288 1851 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1851 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1851 18 : : : 40288 1851 19 ÔÔS ÔÔS NNP 40288 1851 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1851 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1851 22 is be VBZ 40288 1851 23 interesting interesting JJ 40288 1851 24 because because IN 40288 1851 25 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1851 26 shows show VBZ 40288 1851 27 that that IN 40288 1851 28 when when WRB 40288 1851 29 more more JJR 40288 1851 30 than than IN 40288 1851 31 one one CD 40288 1851 32 note note NN 40288 1851 33 went go VBD 40288 1851 34 with with IN 40288 1851 35 a a DT 40288 1851 36 syllable syllable NN 40288 1851 37 , , , 40288 1851 38 the the DT 40288 1851 39 vowel vowel NN 40288 1851 40 or or CC 40288 1851 41 diphthong diphthong NNP 40288 1851 42 was be VBD 40288 1851 43 repeated repeat VBN 40288 1851 44 . . . 40288 1852 1 This this DT 40288 1852 2 agrees agree VBZ 40288 1852 3 with with IN 40288 1852 4 the the DT 40288 1852 5 well well RB 40288 1852 6 - - HYPH 40288 1852 7 known know VBN 40288 1852 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1852 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1852 10 : : : 40288 1852 11 hei hei JJ 40288 1852 12 - - HYPH 40288 1852 13 ei ei JJ 40288 1852 14 - - HYPH 40288 1852 15 ei ei NNP 40288 1852 16 - - HYPH 40288 1852 17 ei ei NNP 40288 1852 18 - - HYPH 40288 1852 19 ei ei NN 40288 1852 20 - - HYPH 40288 1852 21 eilissete eilissete NN 40288 1852 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1852 23 of of IN 40288 1852 24 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40288 1852 25 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1852 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1852 27 Ran Ran NNP 40288 1852 28 . . . 40288 1852 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1852 30 1314 1314 CD 40288 1852 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1852 32 , , , 40288 1852 33 and and CC 40288 1852 34 is be VBZ 40288 1852 35 amply amply RB 40288 1852 36 confirmed confirm VBN 40288 1852 37 by by IN 40288 1852 38 the the DT 40288 1852 39 newly newly RB 40288 1852 40 discovered discover VBN 40288 1852 41 hymn hymn NN 40288 1852 42 to to IN 40288 1852 43 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 1852 44 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1852 45 p. p. NN 40288 1852 46 134 134 CD 40288 1852 47 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1852 48 . . . 40288 1853 1 _ _ IN 40288 1853 2 Musical musical JJ 40288 1853 3 part part NN 40288 1853 4 of of IN 40288 1853 5 the the DT 40288 1853 6 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 1853 7 inscription inscription NN 40288 1853 8 . . . 40288 1853 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1853 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 11 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1853 12 : : : 40288 1853 13 C C NNP 40288 1853 14 Z Z NNP 40288 1853 15 Z Z NNP 40288 1853 16 KIZ KIZ NNP 40288 1853 17 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1853 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 19 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 20 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1853 21 : : : 40288 1853 22 OSONZÊSPHAINOU OSONZÊSPHAINOU NNP 40288 1853 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 25 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1853 26 : : : 40288 1853 27 K K NNP 40288 1853 28 I i NN 40288 1853 29 Z z NN 40288 1853 30 IK ik NN 40288 1853 31 O o NN 40288 1853 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 34 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1853 35 : : : 40288 1853 36 MÊDENOLÔSSY MÊDENOLÔSSY NNP 40288 1853 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 39 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1853 40 : : : 40288 1853 41 E. E. NNP 40288 1853 42 , , , 40288 1853 43 C C NNP 40288 1853 44 O o UH 40288 1853 45 i i NN 40288 1853 46 ; ; : 40288 1853 47 C C NNP 40288 1853 48 K K NNP 40288 1853 49 Z Z NNP 40288 1853 50 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 51 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 52 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1853 53 : : : 40288 1853 54 LYPOUPOSOLI lypouposoli NN 40288 1853 55 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 56 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 57 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1853 58 : : : 40288 1853 59 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1853 60 IC IC NNP 40288 1853 61 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1853 62 K k VBP 40288 1853 63 C C NNP 40288 1853 64 OZ OZ NNP 40288 1853 65 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 66 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 67 Greek greek JJ 40288 1853 68 : : : 40288 1853 69 GONESTITOZÊN gonestitozên NN 40288 1853 70 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 71 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 72 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1853 73 : : : 40288 1853 74 C C NNP 40288 1853 75 K k NN 40288 1853 76 O o UH 40288 1853 77 i i NN 40288 1853 78 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 79 .Z .Z . 40288 1853 80 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 81 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 82 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 83 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1853 84 : : : 40288 1853 85 TOTELOSOCHRO TOTELOSOCHRO NNP 40288 1853 86 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 87 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 88 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1853 89 : : : 40288 1853 90 K K NNP 40288 1853 91 C C NNP 40288 1853 92 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 93 = = SYM 40288 1853 94 C C NNP 40288 1853 95 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 96 C C NNP 40288 1853 97 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 98 .=X .=X . 40288 1853 99 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 100 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 101 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1853 102 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1853 103 : : : 40288 1853 104 NOSAPAITEI NOSAPAITEI NNP 40288 1853 105 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1853 106 The the DT 40288 1853 107 inscription inscription NN 40288 1853 108 of of IN 40288 1853 109 which which WDT 40288 1853 110 these these DT 40288 1853 111 lines line NNS 40288 1853 112 form form VBP 40288 1853 113 part part NN 40288 1853 114 was be VBD 40288 1853 115 discovered discover VBN 40288 1853 116 by by IN 40288 1853 117 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1853 118 W. W. NNP 40288 1853 119 M. M. NNP 40288 1853 120 Ramsay Ramsay NNP 40288 1853 121 , , , 40288 1853 122 and and CC 40288 1853 123 was be VBD 40288 1853 124 first first RB 40288 1853 125 published publish VBN 40288 1853 126 by by IN 40288 1853 127 him -PRON- PRP 40288 1853 128 in in IN 40288 1853 129 the the DT 40288 1853 130 _ _ NNP 40288 1853 131 Bulletin Bulletin NNP 40288 1853 132 de de IN 40288 1853 133 correspondance correspondance NN 40288 1853 134 hellénique hellénique NNP 40288 1853 135 _ _ NNP 40288 1853 136 for for IN 40288 1853 137 1883 1883 CD 40288 1853 138 , , , 40288 1853 139 p. p. NN 40288 1853 140 277 277 CD 40288 1853 141 . . . 40288 1854 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1854 2 professes profess VBZ 40288 1854 3 to to TO 40288 1854 4 be be VB 40288 1854 5 the the DT 40288 1854 6 work work NN 40288 1854 7 of of IN 40288 1854 8 a a DT 40288 1854 9 certain certain JJ 40288 1854 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1854 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1854 12 : : : 40288 1854 13 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 1854 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1854 15 . . . 40288 1855 1 The the DT 40288 1855 2 discovery discovery NN 40288 1855 3 that that IN 40288 1855 4 the the DT 40288 1855 5 smaller small JJR 40288 1855 6 letters letter NNS 40288 1855 7 between between IN 40288 1855 8 the the DT 40288 1855 9 lines line NNS 40288 1855 10 are be VBP 40288 1855 11 musical musical JJ 40288 1855 12 notes note NNS 40288 1855 13 was be VBD 40288 1855 14 made make VBN 40288 1855 15 by by IN 40288 1855 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1855 17 Wessely Wessely NNP 40288 1855 18 . . . 40288 1856 1 The the DT 40288 1856 2 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 1856 3 inscription inscription NN 40288 1856 4 , , , 40288 1856 5 as as IN 40288 1856 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 40288 1856 7 O. O. NNP 40288 1856 8 Crusius Crusius NNP 40288 1856 9 has have VBZ 40288 1856 10 shown show VBN 40288 1856 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1856 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1856 13 Philologus Philologus NNP 40288 1856 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1856 15 for for IN 40288 1856 16 1893 1893 CD 40288 1856 17 , , , 40288 1856 18 LII LII NNP 40288 1856 19 . . . 40288 1857 1 p. p. NN 40288 1857 2 161 161 CD 40288 1857 3 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1857 4 , , , 40288 1857 5 is be VBZ 40288 1857 6 especially especially RB 40288 1857 7 valuable valuable JJ 40288 1857 8 for for IN 40288 1857 9 the the DT 40288 1857 10 light light NN 40288 1857 11 which which WDT 40288 1857 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1857 13 throws throw VBZ 40288 1857 14 upon upon IN 40288 1857 15 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1857 16 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1857 17 . . . 40288 1858 1 The the DT 40288 1858 2 quantity quantity NN 40288 1858 3 of of IN 40288 1858 4 the the DT 40288 1858 5 syllables syllable NNS 40288 1858 6 and and CC 40288 1858 7 the the DT 40288 1858 8 place place NN 40288 1858 9 of of IN 40288 1858 10 the the DT 40288 1858 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1858 12 ictus ictus NN 40288 1858 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1858 14 is be VBZ 40288 1858 15 marked mark VBN 40288 1858 16 in in IN 40288 1858 17 every every DT 40288 1858 18 case case NN 40288 1858 19 , , , 40288 1858 20 and and CC 40288 1858 21 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1858 22 are be VBP 40288 1858 23 able able JJ 40288 1858 24 therefore therefore RB 40288 1858 25 to to TO 40288 1858 26 divide divide VB 40288 1858 27 the the DT 40288 1858 28 melody melody NN 40288 1858 29 into into IN 40288 1858 30 bars bar NNS 40288 1858 31 , , , 40288 1858 32 which which WDT 40288 1858 33 may may MD 40288 1858 34 be be VB 40288 1858 35 represented represent VBN 40288 1858 36 as as IN 40288 1858 37 follows follow VBZ 40288 1858 38 : : : 40288 1858 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1858 40 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1858 41 : : : 40288 1858 42 V?--I V?--I NNP 40288 1858 43 v v IN 40288 1858 44 % % NN 40288 1858 45 . . . 40288 1859 1 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1859 2 .. .. NFP 40288 1859 3 s s LS 40288 1859 4 10-I 10-i JJ 40288 1859 5 ? ? . 40288 1860 1 L L NNP 40288 1860 2 , , , 40288 1860 3 I/4 i/4 UH 40288 1860 4 i i PRP 40288 1860 5 v^% v^% VBP 40288 1860 6 . . NNP 40288 1860 7 , , , 40288 1860 8 L L NNP 40288 1860 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1860 10 ? ? . 40288 1861 1 % % NN 40288 1861 2 i:\--% i:\--% NNP 40288 1861 3 . . . 40288 1862 1 i i PRP 40288 1862 2 v1/4d v1/4d : 40288 1862 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1862 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1862 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1862 6 : : : 40288 1862 7 hoson hoson NNP 40288 1862 8 | | NNP 40288 1862 9 zês zês NNP 40288 1862 10 phai-| phai-| NNP 40288 1862 11 nou nou NNP 40288 1862 12 ; ; : 40288 1862 13 mêden mêden NNP 40288 1862 14 | | NNP 40288 1862 15 holôs holôs NNP 40288 1862 16 sy sy NNP 40288 1862 17 ly-| ly-| NNP 40288 1862 18 pou pou NNP 40288 1862 19 ; ; : 40288 1862 20 pros pro NNS 40288 1862 21 oli-| oli-| NN 40288 1862 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1862 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1862 24 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1862 25 : : : 40288 1862 26 " " `` 40288 1862 27 \s \s CD 40288 1862 28 10 10 CD 40288 1862 29 V1/4.0 V1/4.0 NNS 40288 1862 30 , , , 40288 1862 31 ? ? . 40288 1863 1 V v NN 40288 1863 2 ? ? . 40288 1864 1 V v NN 40288 1864 2 V v NN 40288 1864 3 Lo lo NN 40288 1864 4 V v NN 40288 1864 5 V v NN 40288 1864 6 V v NN 40288 1864 7 L. l. NN 40288 1864 8 ? ? . 40288 1865 1 I/4 i/4 UH 40288 1865 2 . . . 40288 1865 3 ? ? . 40288 1865 4 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1866 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1866 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1866 3 : : : 40288 1866 4 gon gon NNP 40288 1866 5 esti esti NN 40288 1866 6 to to IN 40288 1866 7 | | JJ 40288 1866 8 zên zên NN 40288 1866 9 ; ; : 40288 1866 10 to to IN 40288 1866 11 telos telos NNP 40288 1866 12 | | NNP 40288 1866 13 ho ho RP 40288 1866 14 chronos chronos NNP 40288 1866 15 apai-| apai-| NNP 40288 1866 16 tei tei NN 40288 1866 17 . . . 40288 1866 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1867 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1867 2 The the DT 40288 1867 3 hymns hymn NNS 40288 1867 4 recently recently RB 40288 1867 5 discovered discover VBD 40288 1867 6 at at IN 40288 1867 7 Delphi Delphi NNP 40288 1867 8 . . . 40288 1867 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1867 10 Since since IN 40288 1867 11 these these DT 40288 1867 12 sheets sheet NNS 40288 1867 13 were be VBD 40288 1867 14 in in IN 40288 1867 15 type type NN 40288 1867 16 the the DT 40288 1867 17 materials material NNS 40288 1867 18 for for IN 40288 1867 19 the the DT 40288 1867 20 study study NN 40288 1867 21 of of IN 40288 1867 22 ancient ancient JJ 40288 1867 23 Greek greek JJ 40288 1867 24 music music NN 40288 1867 25 have have VBP 40288 1867 26 received receive VBN 40288 1867 27 a a DT 40288 1867 28 notable notable JJ 40288 1867 29 accession accession NN 40288 1867 30 . . . 40288 1868 1 The the DT 40288 1868 2 French french JJ 40288 1868 3 archaeologists archaeologist NNS 40288 1868 4 who who WP 40288 1868 5 are be VBP 40288 1868 6 now now RB 40288 1868 7 excavating excavate VBG 40288 1868 8 on on IN 40288 1868 9 the the DT 40288 1868 10 site site NN 40288 1868 11 of of IN 40288 1868 12 Delphi Delphi NNP 40288 1868 13 have have VBP 40288 1868 14 found find VBN 40288 1868 15 several several JJ 40288 1868 16 important important JJ 40288 1868 17 fragments fragment NNS 40288 1868 18 of of IN 40288 1868 19 lyrical lyrical JJ 40288 1868 20 poetry poetry NN 40288 1868 21 , , , 40288 1868 22 some some DT 40288 1868 23 of of IN 40288 1868 24 them -PRON- PRP 40288 1868 25 with with IN 40288 1868 26 the the DT 40288 1868 27 music music NN 40288 1868 28 noted note VBN 40288 1868 29 over over IN 40288 1868 30 the the DT 40288 1868 31 words word NNS 40288 1868 32 , , , 40288 1868 33 as as IN 40288 1868 34 in in IN 40288 1868 35 the the DT 40288 1868 36 examples example NNS 40288 1868 37 already already RB 40288 1868 38 known know VBN 40288 1868 39 . . . 40288 1869 1 The the DT 40288 1869 2 two two CD 40288 1869 3 largest large JJS 40288 1869 4 of of IN 40288 1869 5 these these DT 40288 1869 6 fragments fragment NNS 40288 1869 7 have have VBP 40288 1869 8 been be VBN 40288 1869 9 shown show VBN 40288 1869 10 to to TO 40288 1869 11 belong belong VB 40288 1869 12 to to IN 40288 1869 13 a a DT 40288 1869 14 single single JJ 40288 1869 15 inscription inscription NN 40288 1869 16 , , , 40288 1869 17 containing contain VBG 40288 1869 18 a a DT 40288 1869 19 hymn hymn NN 40288 1869 20 to to IN 40288 1869 21 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 1869 22 , , , 40288 1869 23 which which WDT 40288 1869 24 dates date VBZ 40288 1869 25 in in IN 40288 1869 26 all all DT 40288 1869 27 probability probability NN 40288 1869 28 from from IN 40288 1869 29 the the DT 40288 1869 30 early early JJ 40288 1869 31 part part NN 40288 1869 32 of of IN 40288 1869 33 the the DT 40288 1869 34 third third JJ 40288 1869 35 century century NN 40288 1869 36 B.C. B.C. NNP 40288 1870 1 Of of IN 40288 1870 2 the the DT 40288 1870 3 other other JJ 40288 1870 4 fragments fragment VBZ 40288 1870 5 the the DT 40288 1870 6 most most RBS 40288 1870 7 considerable considerable JJ 40288 1870 8 is be VBZ 40288 1870 9 plausibly plausibly RB 40288 1870 10 referred refer VBN 40288 1870 11 to to IN 40288 1870 12 the the DT 40288 1870 13 first first JJ 40288 1870 14 century century NN 40288 1870 15 B.C. B.C. NNP 40288 1871 1 These these DT 40288 1871 2 inscriptions inscription NNS 40288 1871 3 have have VBP 40288 1871 4 been be VBN 40288 1871 5 published publish VBN 40288 1871 6 in in IN 40288 1871 7 the the DT 40288 1871 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1871 9 Bulletin Bulletin NNP 40288 1871 10 de de IN 40288 1871 11 correspondance correspondance NN 40288 1871 12 hellénique hellénique NNP 40288 1871 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1871 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1871 15 viii viii NNP 40288 1871 16 - - HYPH 40288 1871 17 xii xii NNP 40288 1871 18 . . . 40288 1872 1 pp pp NNP 40288 1872 2 . . . 40288 1873 1 569 569 CD 40288 1873 2 - - SYM 40288 1873 3 610 610 CD 40288 1873 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1873 5 , , , 40288 1873 6 with with IN 40288 1873 7 two two CD 40288 1873 8 valuable valuable JJ 40288 1873 9 commentaries commentary NNS 40288 1873 10 by by IN 40288 1873 11 M. M. NNP 40288 1873 12 Henri Henri NNP 40288 1873 13 Weil Weil NNP 40288 1873 14 and and CC 40288 1873 15 M. M. NNP 40288 1873 16 Théodore Théodore NNP 40288 1873 17 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1873 18 . . . 40288 1874 1 The the DT 40288 1874 2 former former JJ 40288 1874 3 scholar scholar NN 40288 1874 4 deals deal VBZ 40288 1874 5 with with IN 40288 1874 6 the the DT 40288 1874 7 text text NN 40288 1874 8 , , , 40288 1874 9 the the DT 40288 1874 10 latter latter JJ 40288 1874 11 chiefly chiefly NN 40288 1874 12 with with IN 40288 1874 13 the the DT 40288 1874 14 music music NN 40288 1874 15 . . . 40288 1875 1 The the DT 40288 1875 2 music music NN 40288 1875 3 of of IN 40288 1875 4 the the DT 40288 1875 5 hymn hymn NN 40288 1875 6 to to IN 40288 1875 7 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 1875 8 is be VBZ 40288 1875 9 written write VBN 40288 1875 10 in in IN 40288 1875 11 the the DT 40288 1875 12 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1875 13 notation notation NN 40288 1875 14 . . . 40288 1876 1 The the DT 40288 1876 2 metre metre NN 40288 1876 3 is be VBZ 40288 1876 4 the the DT 40288 1876 5 cretic cretic JJ 40288 1876 6 or or CC 40288 1876 7 paeonic paeonic NN 40288 1876 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1876 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1876 10 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1876 11 : : : 40288 1876 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1876 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1876 14 , , , 40288 1876 15 and and CC 40288 1876 16 the the DT 40288 1876 17 key key NN 40288 1876 18 , , , 40288 1876 19 as as IN 40288 1876 20 M. M. NNP 40288 1876 21 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1876 22 has have VBZ 40288 1876 23 shown show VBN 40288 1876 24 , , , 40288 1876 25 is be VBZ 40288 1876 26 the the DT 40288 1876 27 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1876 28 -- -- : 40288 1876 29 the the DT 40288 1876 30 scale scale NN 40288 1876 31 of of IN 40288 1876 32 C C NNP 40288 1876 33 minor minor JJ 40288 1876 34 , , , 40288 1876 35 with with IN 40288 1876 36 the the DT 40288 1876 37 conjunct conjunct NN 40288 1876 38 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1876 39 _ _ NNP 40288 1876 40 c c NNP 40288 1876 41 -- -- : 40288 1876 42 d[Symbol d[symbol XX 40288 1876 43 : : : 40288 1876 44 flat]--d flat]--d NNP 40288 1876 45 -- -- : 40288 1876 46 f f NNP 40288 1876 47 _ _ NNP 40288 1876 48 . . . 40288 1877 1 In in IN 40288 1877 2 the the DT 40288 1877 3 following following JJ 40288 1877 4 transcription transcription NN 40288 1877 5 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1877 6 have have VBP 40288 1877 7 followed follow VBN 40288 1877 8 M. M. NNP 40288 1877 9 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1877 10 except except IN 40288 1877 11 in in IN 40288 1877 12 a a DT 40288 1877 13 few few JJ 40288 1877 14 minor minor JJ 40288 1877 15 points point NNS 40288 1877 16 . . . 40288 1878 1 When when WRB 40288 1878 2 two two CD 40288 1878 3 notes note NNS 40288 1878 4 are be VBP 40288 1878 5 sung sing VBN 40288 1878 6 to to IN 40288 1878 7 the the DT 40288 1878 8 same same JJ 40288 1878 9 syllable syllable NN 40288 1878 10 the the DT 40288 1878 11 vowel vowel NN 40288 1878 12 or or CC 40288 1878 13 diphthong diphthong NNP 40288 1878 14 is be VBZ 40288 1878 15 repeated repeat VBN 40288 1878 16 , , , 40288 1878 17 as as IN 40288 1878 18 in in IN 40288 1878 19 the the DT 40288 1878 20 fragment fragment NN 40288 1878 21 of of IN 40288 1878 22 the the DT 40288 1878 23 Orestes Orestes NNPS 40288 1878 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1878 25 p. p. NN 40288 1878 26 132 132 CD 40288 1878 27 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1878 28 : : : 40288 1878 29 but but CC 40288 1878 30 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1878 31 have have VBP 40288 1878 32 thought think VBN 40288 1878 33 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1878 34 best well RBS 40288 1878 35 to to TO 40288 1878 36 adhere adhere VB 40288 1878 37 to to IN 40288 1878 38 the the DT 40288 1878 39 modern modern JJ 40288 1878 40 method method NN 40288 1878 41 . . . 40288 1879 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 2 Music music NN 40288 1879 3 : : : 40288 1879 4 A a DT 40288 1879 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 6 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1879 7 : : : 40288 1879 8 o o XX 40288 1879 9 r r NN 40288 1879 10 4 4 CD 40288 1879 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1879 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1879 14 : : : 40288 1879 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 16 Ton Ton NNP 40288 1879 17 kithari]sei kithari]sei NNP 40288 1879 18 kly kly NN 40288 1879 19 - - HYPH 40288 1879 20 ton ton NN 40288 1879 21 pai pai NNP 40288 1879 22 - - HYPH 40288 1879 23 da da NNP 40288 1879 24 me -PRON- PRP 40288 1879 25 - - HYPH 40288 1879 26 ga ga JJ 40288 1879 27 - - HYPH 40288 1879 28 lou lou NNP 40288 1879 29 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 30 Dios Dios NNP 40288 1879 31 a- a- XX 40288 1879 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1879 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1879 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 35 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1879 36 : : : 40288 1879 37 oruh.u4r oruh.u4r LS 40288 1879 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1879 39 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 40 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1879 41 : : : 40288 1879 42 eidete eidete NN 40288 1879 43 pa]r pa]r NNP 40288 1879 44 ' ' POS 40288 1879 45 a a DT 40288 1879 46 - - HYPH 40288 1879 47 kro kro NNP 40288 1879 48 - - HYPH 40288 1879 49 ni ni NN 40288 1879 50 - - HYPH 40288 1879 51 phê phê NN 40288 1879 52 ton ton NN 40288 1879 53 - - HYPH 40288 1879 54 de de NNP 40288 1879 55 pa pa NNP 40288 1879 56 - - HYPH 40288 1879 57 gon gon NNP 40288 1879 58 , , , 40288 1879 59 am[broth am[broth NNP 40288 1879 60 ' ' '' 40288 1879 61 hos hos NN 40288 1879 62 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1879 63 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1879 64 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1879 65 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 66 Music music NN 40288 1879 67 : : : 40288 1879 68 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1879 69 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1879 70 : : : 40288 1879 71 # # $ 40288 1879 72 1 1 CD 40288 1879 73 ? ? . 40288 1880 1 ZS ZS NNP 40288 1880 2 A A NNP 40288 1880 3 rty rty NN 40288 1880 4 r r NN 40288 1880 5 M m NN 40288 1880 6 Y Y NNP 40288 1880 7 M m NN 40288 1880 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1880 11 : : : 40288 1880 12 pa pa NNP 40288 1880 13 - - HYPH 40288 1880 14 si si NNP 40288 1880 15 thna thna NNS 40288 1880 16 - - HYPH 40288 1880 17 tois tois NN 40288 1880 18 pro pro JJ 40288 1880 19 - - JJ 40288 1880 20 phai phai JJ 40288 1880 21 - - HYPH 40288 1880 22 neis neis NNP 40288 1880 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 24 logia logia NN 40288 1880 25 , , , 40288 1880 26 tr]i tr]i NNP 40288 1880 27 - - HYPH 40288 1880 28 po po NNP 40288 1880 29 - - HYPH 40288 1880 30 da da NNP 40288 1880 31 man- man- NN 40288 1880 32 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 33 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 34 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1880 35 : : : 40288 1880 36 1 1 LS 40288 1880 37 M m NN 40288 1880 38 I i NN 40288 1880 39 O o NN 40288 1880 40 r r NN 40288 1880 41 O o NN 40288 1880 42 4ruh.0 4ruh.0 NN 40288 1880 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 45 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1880 46 : : : 40288 1880 47 tei tei NN 40288 1880 48 - - HYPH 40288 1880 49 on on RP 40288 1880 50 hôs hôs NNP 40288 1880 51 hei[les hei[le NNS 40288 1880 52 , , , 40288 1880 53 echthros echthros NNP 40288 1880 54 hon hon NNP 40288 1880 55 e e NNP 40288 1880 56 - - HYPH 40288 1880 57 phr]ou phr]ou NNP 40288 1880 58 - - HYPH 40288 1880 59 rei rei NN 40288 1880 60 dra dra NNP 40288 1880 61 - - HYPH 40288 1880 62 kôn kôn NNP 40288 1880 63 ; ; , 40288 1880 64 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 65 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 66 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1880 67 : : : 40288 1880 68 4 4 LS 40288 1880 69 : : : 40288 1880 70 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1880 71 U!or U!or NNP 40288 1880 72 4 4 CD 40288 1880 73 u u NN 40288 1880 74 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 75 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 76 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1880 77 : : : 40288 1880 78 ho ho NNP 40288 1880 79 - - HYPH 40288 1880 80 te te NNP 40288 1880 81 te[oisi te[oisi NNP 40288 1880 82 belesin belesin NN 40288 1880 83 e e LS 40288 1880 84 - - : 40288 1880 85 tr]ê tr]ê NNP 40288 1880 86 - - HYPH 40288 1880 87 sas sas NNP 40288 1880 88 ai ai NNP 40288 1880 89 - - HYPH 40288 1880 90 o o NNP 40288 1880 91 - - HYPH 40288 1880 92 lon lon NN 40288 1880 93 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1880 94 - - HYPH 40288 1880 95 lik lik JJ 40288 1880 96 - - HYPH 40288 1880 97 tan tan NNP 40288 1880 98 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 99 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 100 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 101 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1880 102 : : : 40288 1880 103 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1880 104 omio omio VBP 40288 1880 105 r r NN 40288 1880 106 4 4 CD 40288 1880 107 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 108 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 109 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1880 110 : : : 40288 1880 111 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 112 sy sy JJ 40288 1880 113 - - HYPH 40288 1880 114 rig rig NN 40288 1880 115 - - HYPH 40288 1880 116 math math NN 40288 1880 117 ' ' '' 40288 1880 118 hi hi NNP 40288 1880 119 - - HYPH 40288 1880 120 eis eis NNP 40288 1880 121 a a DT 40288 1880 122 - - HYPH 40288 1880 123 thô thô NN 40288 1880 124 - - HYPH 40288 1880 125 pe[ut pe[ut NN 40288 1880 126 ' ' '' 40288 1880 127 eba eba NN 40288 1880 128 ; ; , 40288 1880 129 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1880 130 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1880 131 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1880 132 : : : 40288 1880 133 U U NNP 40288 1880 134 ior.t ior.t NNS 40288 1880 135 . . . 40288 1881 1 U u NN 40288 1881 2 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1881 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1881 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1881 5 : : : 40288 1881 6 nyn nyn NNP 40288 1881 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1881 8 de de NNP 40288 1881 9 Ga Ga NNP 40288 1881 10 - - HYPH 40288 1881 11 la la NNP 40288 1881 12 - - HYPH 40288 1881 13 tan tan NNP 40288 1881 14 a a DT 40288 1881 15 - - HYPH 40288 1881 16 rês rês NN 40288 1881 17 .. .. NFP 40288 1881 18 n n CC 40288 1881 19 epe epe NNP 40288 1881 20 - - HYPH 40288 1881 21 ras ras NNP 40288 1881 22 ' ' '' 40288 1881 23 a a DT 40288 1881 24 - - HYPH 40288 1881 25 sep sep NN 40288 1881 26 - - HYPH 40288 1881 27 t[os t[os NN 40288 1881 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1881 29 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1881 30 : : : 40288 1881 31 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1881 32 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1881 33 Greek greek JJ 40288 1881 34 : : : 40288 1881 35 sal sal JJ 40288 1881 36 - - HYPH 40288 1881 37 li li NNP 40288 1881 38 - - HYPH 40288 1881 39 ô ô NNP 40288 1881 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1881 41 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1881 42 ? ? . 40288 1881 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1882 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1882 2 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1882 3 : : : 40288 1882 4 gen gen NNP 40288 1882 5 - - HYPH 40288 1882 6 nan nan NNP 40288 1882 7 .. .. NFP 40288 1882 8 n n NNP 40288 1882 9 thalos thalos NNP 40288 1882 10 phi phi NNP 40288 1882 11 - - HYPH 40288 1882 12 lon lon NNP 40288 1882 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1882 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1882 15 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1882 16 : : : 40288 1882 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1882 18 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1882 19 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1882 20 : : : 40288 1882 21 da da NNP 40288 1882 22 - - HYPH 40288 1882 23 moi moi NNP 40288 1882 24 - - HYPH 40288 1882 25 o o XX 40288 1882 26 lo lo NNP 40288 1882 27 .... .... NFP 40288 1882 28 rôn rôn NNP 40288 1882 29 e e NNP 40288 1882 30 - - NNP 40288 1882 31 phor phor NNP 40288 1882 32 .. .. NFP 40288 1882 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1882 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1882 35 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1882 36 : : : 40288 1882 37 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1882 38 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1882 39 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1882 40 : : : 40288 1882 41 te te NNP 40288 1882 42 - - HYPH 40288 1882 43 on on RP 40288 1882 44 k k NNP 40288 1882 45 .. .. NFP 40288 1882 46 e e NNP 40288 1882 47 - - HYPH 40288 1882 48 nai nai NNP 40288 1882 49 k k NNP 40288 1882 50 .. .. NFP 40288 1882 51 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1882 52 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1882 53 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1882 54 about about RB 40288 1882 55 12 12 CD 40288 1882 56 bars bar NNS 40288 1882 57 wanting want VBG 40288 1882 58 . . . 40288 1882 59 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1882 60 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 2 Music music NN 40288 1883 3 : : : 40288 1883 4 B b NN 40288 1883 5 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 6 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1883 7 : : : 40288 1883 8 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1883 9 M m NN 40288 1883 10 G g NN 40288 1883 11 M M NNP 40288 1883 12 Th Th NNP 40288 1883 13 I i NN 40288 1883 14 M m NN 40288 1883 15 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1883 18 : : : 40288 1883 19 Helik]ôna Helik]ôna NNP 40288 1883 20 ba ba NN 40288 1883 21 - - HYPH 40288 1883 22 thy thy JJ 40288 1883 23 - - HYPH 40288 1883 24 den den NN 40288 1883 25 - - HYPH 40288 1883 26 dron dron NNP 40288 1883 27 hai hai NNP 40288 1883 28 la[chete la[chete NNP 40288 1883 29 Dios Dios NNP 40288 1883 30 eri]bro eri]bro NNP 40288 1883 31 - - HYPH 40288 1883 32 mou mou NN 40288 1883 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 34 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 35 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1883 36 : : : 40288 1883 37 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1883 38 M m NN 40288 1883 39 U u NN 40288 1883 40 M m NN 40288 1883 41 Th Th NNP 40288 1883 42 Th Th NNP 40288 1883 43 I i NN 40288 1883 44 M m NN 40288 1883 45 I i NN 40288 1883 46 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 47 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 48 Greek greek JJ 40288 1883 49 : : : 40288 1883 50 thy thy NN 40288 1883 51 - - HYPH 40288 1883 52 ga ga NN 40288 1883 53 - - HYPH 40288 1883 54 tres tre NNS 40288 1883 55 eu eu NNP 40288 1883 56 - - HYPH 40288 1883 57 ô ô NNP 40288 1883 58 - - HYPH 40288 1883 59 le[noi le[noi NNP 40288 1883 60 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 61 mo mo NN 40288 1883 62 - - HYPH 40288 1883 63 le[te le[te NN 40288 1883 64 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 65 syn syn JJ 40288 1883 66 - - HYPH 40288 1883 67 o o JJ 40288 1883 68 - - HYPH 40288 1883 69 mai mai NNP 40288 1883 70 - - HYPH 40288 1883 71 mon mon NN 40288 1883 72 hi hi JJ 40288 1883 73 - - HYPH 40288 1883 74 na na NN 40288 1883 75 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 76 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 77 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1883 78 : : : 40288 1883 79 M M NNP 40288 1883 80 U u NN 40288 1883 81 M m NN 40288 1883 82 U u NN 40288 1883 83 M M NNP 40288 1883 84 W w NN 40288 1883 85 Th Th NNP 40288 1883 86 G g NN 40288 1883 87 W w NN 40288 1883 88 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 89 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 90 Greek greek JJ 40288 1883 91 : : : 40288 1883 92 Phoi Phoi NNP 40288 1883 93 - - HYPH 40288 1883 94 bon bon NNP 40288 1883 95 ô ô NNP 40288 1883 96 - - HYPH 40288 1883 97 dai dai NNP 40288 1883 98 - - HYPH 40288 1883 99 si si NN 40288 1883 100 mel mel NNP 40288 1883 101 - - HYPH 40288 1883 102 psê psê NNP 40288 1883 103 - - HYPH 40288 1883 104 te te NNP 40288 1883 105 chry chry NNP 40288 1883 106 - - HYPH 40288 1883 107 se se NNP 40288 1883 108 - - HYPH 40288 1883 109 o o NNP 40288 1883 110 - - HYPH 40288 1883 111 ko ko NNP 40288 1883 112 - - HYPH 40288 1883 113 man man NNP 40288 1883 114 ; ; , 40288 1883 115 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 116 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 117 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1883 118 : : : 40288 1883 119 Th Th NNP 40288 1883 120 Ô Ô NNP 40288 1883 121 Ps Ps NNP 40288 1883 122 Ô Ô NNP 40288 1883 123 Th Th NNP 40288 1883 124 Ô ô NN 40288 1883 125 Th th UH 40288 1883 126 I i NN 40288 1883 127 M m NN 40288 1883 128 Th th NN 40288 1883 129 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 130 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 131 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1883 132 : : : 40288 1883 133 hos hos PRP 40288 1883 134 a a DT 40288 1883 135 - - HYPH 40288 1883 136 na na FW 40288 1883 137 di di FW 40288 1883 138 - - HYPH 40288 1883 139 ko ko NNP 40288 1883 140 - - HYPH 40288 1883 141 ry ry NNP 40288 1883 142 - - HYPH 40288 1883 143 ni ni NNP 40288 1883 144 - - HYPH 40288 1883 145 a a DT 40288 1883 146 Par Par NNP 40288 1883 147 - - HYPH 40288 1883 148 nas nas NNP 40288 1883 149 - - HYPH 40288 1883 150 si si NNP 40288 1883 151 - - HYPH 40288 1883 152 dos dos NNP 40288 1883 153 tas tas NNP 40288 1883 154 - - HYPH 40288 1883 155 de de NNP 40288 1883 156 pet- pet- NN 40288 1883 157 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 158 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 159 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1883 160 : : : 40288 1883 161 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1883 162 M m NN 40288 1883 163 U u NN 40288 1883 164 M m NN 40288 1883 165 U u NN 40288 1883 166 M m NN 40288 1883 167 I i NN 40288 1883 168 Th th UH 40288 1883 169 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1883 170 Th th VBP 40288 1883 171 G g NN 40288 1883 172 Ô ô NN 40288 1883 173 Ps Ps NNP 40288 1883 174 G g NN 40288 1883 175 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 176 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 177 Greek:-ras Greek:-ras NNP 40288 1883 178 he he NNP 40288 1883 179 - - HYPH 40288 1883 180 dra dra NNP 40288 1883 181 - - HYPH 40288 1883 182 na na IN 40288 1883 183 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 184 me]ta me]ta JJ 40288 1883 185 kly kly NNP 40288 1883 186 - - HYPH 40288 1883 187 tais tais NNP 40288 1883 188 Del Del NNP 40288 1883 189 - - HYPH 40288 1883 190 phi phi NNP 40288 1883 191 - - HYPH 40288 1883 192 sin sin NNP 40288 1883 193 Kas Kas NNP 40288 1883 194 - - HYPH 40288 1883 195 ta ta NNP 40288 1883 196 - - HYPH 40288 1883 197 li li NNP 40288 1883 198 - - HYPH 40288 1883 199 dos dos NNP 40288 1883 200 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 201 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 202 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1883 203 : : : 40288 1883 204 Ô Ô NNP 40288 1883 205 Ps Ps NNP 40288 1883 206 Ô Ô NNP 40288 1883 207 Th Th NNP 40288 1883 208 G g NN 40288 1883 209 L L NNP 40288 1883 210 M m NN 40288 1883 211 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 212 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 213 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1883 214 : : : 40288 1883 215 eu eu NNP 40288 1883 216 - - HYPH 40288 1883 217 u u NNP 40288 1883 218 - - HYPH 40288 1883 219 drou drou NN 40288 1883 220 na na NNP 40288 1883 221 - - HYPH 40288 1883 222 mat mat NN 40288 1883 223 ' ' `` 40288 1883 224 e e NNP 40288 1883 225 - - HYPH 40288 1883 226 pi pi NNP 40288 1883 227 - - HYPH 40288 1883 228 ni ni NNP 40288 1883 229 - - HYPH 40288 1883 230 se se NNP 40288 1883 231 - - HYPH 40288 1883 232 tai tai NNP 40288 1883 233 , , , 40288 1883 234 Del Del NNP 40288 1883 235 - - HYPH 40288 1883 236 phon phon NNP 40288 1883 237 a a DT 40288 1883 238 - - HYPH 40288 1883 239 na na NN 40288 1883 240 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 241 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 242 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1883 243 : : : 40288 1883 244 G g NN 40288 1883 245 M m NN 40288 1883 246 I i NN 40288 1883 247 Th th VBP 40288 1883 248 I i NN 40288 1883 249 M m NN 40288 1883 250 Ph Ph NNP 40288 1883 251 G g NN 40288 1883 252 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1883 253 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 254 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1883 255 : : : 40288 1883 256 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1883 257 pr]ô pr]ô FW 40288 1883 258 - - HYPH 40288 1883 259 na na CD 40288 1883 260 man man NN 40288 1883 261 - - HYPH 40288 1883 262 tei tei NN 40288 1883 263 - - HYPH 40288 1883 264 on on RP 40288 1883 265 e e NNP 40288 1883 266 - - HYPH 40288 1883 267 phe phe NNP 40288 1883 268 - - HYPH 40288 1883 269 pôn pôn NNP 40288 1883 270 pa pa NNP 40288 1883 271 - - HYPH 40288 1883 272 gon gon NNP 40288 1883 273 . . . 40288 1884 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 2 ithi ithi NN 40288 1884 3 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 4 klyta klyta NNP 40288 1884 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 6 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 8 Music music NN 40288 1884 9 : : : 40288 1884 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 11 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1884 12 : : : 40288 1884 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1884 16 : : : 40288 1884 17 me -PRON- PRP 40288 1884 18 - - HYPH 40288 1884 19 ga ga NNP 40288 1884 20 - - HYPH 40288 1884 21 lo lo NNP 40288 1884 22 - - HYPH 40288 1884 23 po po NNP 40288 1884 24 - - HYPH 40288 1884 25 lis lis NNP 40288 1884 26 Ath Ath NNP 40288 1884 27 - - : 40288 1884 28 this this DT 40288 1884 29 , , , 40288 1884 30 eu eu NNP 40288 1884 31 - - HYPH 40288 1884 32 chai chai NNP 40288 1884 33 - - HYPH 40288 1884 34 si si NN 40288 1884 35 phe phe NNP 40288 1884 36 - - HYPH 40288 1884 37 ro ro JJ 40288 1884 38 - - HYPH 40288 1884 39 ploi ploi FW 40288 1884 40 - - HYPH 40288 1884 41 o o NN 40288 1884 42 nai- nai- NN 40288 1884 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 45 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1884 46 : : : 40288 1884 47 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 48 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 49 Greek:-ou greek:-ou FW 40288 1884 50 - - HYPH 40288 1884 51 sa sa NNP 40288 1884 52 Tri Tri NNP 40288 1884 53 - - HYPH 40288 1884 54 tô tô NNP 40288 1884 55 - - HYPH 40288 1884 56 ni ni NNP 40288 1884 57 - - HYPH 40288 1884 58 dos dos NNP 40288 1884 59 da[ped]on da[ped]on NNP 40288 1884 60 a a DT 40288 1884 61 - - HYPH 40288 1884 62 thrauston thrauston NNP 40288 1884 63 , , , 40288 1884 64 ha ha NNP 40288 1884 65 - - HYPH 40288 1884 66 gi- gi- NNP 40288 1884 67 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 68 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 69 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1884 70 : : : 40288 1884 71 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 72 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 73 Greek:-ois Greek:-ois NNP 40288 1884 74 de de NNP 40288 1884 75 bô bô NNP 40288 1884 76 - - HYPH 40288 1884 77 moi moi NNP 40288 1884 78 - - HYPH 40288 1884 79 sin sin NN 40288 1884 80 Ha Ha NNP 40288 1884 81 - - HYPH 40288 1884 82 phais phais NNP 40288 1884 83 - - HYPH 40288 1884 84 tos tos NNP 40288 1884 85 ai ai NNP 40288 1884 86 - - HYPH 40288 1884 87 thei thei NNP 40288 1884 88 ne ne NNP 40288 1884 89 - - HYPH 40288 1884 90 ôn ôn NNP 40288 1884 91 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 92 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 93 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1884 94 : : : 40288 1884 95 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 96 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 97 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1884 98 : : : 40288 1884 99 mê mê NNP 40288 1884 100 - - HYPH 40288 1884 101 ra ra NNP 40288 1884 102 tau tau NNP 40288 1884 103 - - HYPH 40288 1884 104 rôn rôn NNP 40288 1884 105 ; ; : 40288 1884 106 ho ho NNP 40288 1884 107 - - HYPH 40288 1884 108 mou mou FW 40288 1884 109 de de FW 40288 1884 110 nin nin NNP 40288 1884 111 A a NN 40288 1884 112 - - HYPH 40288 1884 113 raps rap NNS 40288 1884 114 at at IN 40288 1884 115 - - HYPH 40288 1884 116 mos mos NNP 40288 1884 117 es es NNP 40288 1884 118 Y- Y- NNP 40288 1884 119 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 120 Symbols Symbols NNPS 40288 1884 121 : : : 40288 1884 122 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 123 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 124 Greek:-lym greek:-lym NN 40288 1884 125 - - RB 40288 1884 126 pon pon VB 40288 1884 127 a a DT 40288 1884 128 - - HYPH 40288 1884 129 na na IN 40288 1884 130 - - HYPH 40288 1884 131 kid kid NN 40288 1884 132 - - HYPH 40288 1884 133 na na IN 40288 1884 134 - - HYPH 40288 1884 135 tai tai NNP 40288 1884 136 ; ; : 40288 1884 137 li li NNP 40288 1884 138 - - HYPH 40288 1884 139 gy gy NNP 40288 1884 140 de de NNP 40288 1884 141 lô lô NNP 40288 1884 142 - - HYPH 40288 1884 143 tos tos NNP 40288 1884 144 bre bre NNP 40288 1884 145 - - HYPH 40288 1884 146 môn môn NNP 40288 1884 147 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 148 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 149 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1884 150 : : : 40288 1884 151 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 152 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 153 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1884 154 : : : 40288 1884 155 ai ai VB 40288 1884 156 - - HYPH 40288 1884 157 o o NN 40288 1884 158 - - HYPH 40288 1884 159 lois lois JJ 40288 1884 160 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 161 me]le me]le NN 40288 1884 162 - - HYPH 40288 1884 163 sin sin NN 40288 1884 164 ô ô NNP 40288 1884 165 - - HYPH 40288 1884 166 dan dan NNP 40288 1884 167 kre kre NNP 40288 1884 168 - - HYPH 40288 1884 169 kei kei NNP 40288 1884 170 ; ; : 40288 1884 171 chry chry NNP 40288 1884 172 - - HYPH 40288 1884 173 sea sea NNP 40288 1884 174 d d NNP 40288 1884 175 ' ' '' 40288 1884 176 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 177 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 178 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1884 179 : : : 40288 1884 180 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 181 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 182 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1884 183 : : : 40288 1884 184 ha ha LS 40288 1884 185 - - HYPH 40288 1884 186 dy dy NNP 40288 1884 187 - - HYPH 40288 1884 188 throu[s throu[s NNP 40288 1884 189 ki]-tha ki]-tha NNP 40288 1884 190 - - HYPH 40288 1884 191 ris ris NNP 40288 1884 192 hym hym NNP 40288 1884 193 - - HYPH 40288 1884 194 noi noi NNP 40288 1884 195 - - HYPH 40288 1884 196 sin sin VB 40288 1884 197 a a DT 40288 1884 198 - - HYPH 40288 1884 199 na na IN 40288 1884 200 - - HYPH 40288 1884 201 mel mel JJ 40288 1884 202 - - HYPH 40288 1884 203 pe pe NN 40288 1884 204 - - HYPH 40288 1884 205 tai tai NNP 40288 1884 206 ; ; : 40288 1884 207 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 208 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 209 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1884 210 : : : 40288 1884 211 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 212 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 213 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1884 214 : : : 40288 1884 215 ho ho NNP 40288 1884 216 de de NNP 40288 1884 217 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1884 218 the]-ô the]-ô NNP 40288 1884 219 - - HYPH 40288 1884 220 rôn rôn NNP 40288 1884 221 pro pro JJ 40288 1884 222 - - JJ 40288 1884 223 pas pas JJ 40288 1884 224 es es NNP 40288 1884 225 - - HYPH 40288 1884 226 mos mos NNP 40288 1884 227 Ath Ath NNP 40288 1884 228 - - HYPH 40288 1884 229 thi thi NNP 40288 1884 230 - - HYPH 40288 1884 231 da da NNP 40288 1884 232 lach[ôn lach[ôn NNP 40288 1884 233 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 234 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 235 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1884 236 The the DT 40288 1884 237 notes note NNS 40288 1884 238 employed employ VBN 40288 1884 239 in in IN 40288 1884 240 this this DT 40288 1884 241 piece piece NN 40288 1884 242 of of IN 40288 1884 243 music music NN 40288 1884 244 cover cover NN 40288 1884 245 about about IN 40288 1884 246 an an DT 40288 1884 247 octave octave NN 40288 1884 248 and and CC 40288 1884 249 a a DT 40288 1884 250 half half NN 40288 1884 251 , , , 40288 1884 252 viz viz NN 40288 1884 253 . . . 40288 1885 1 from from IN 40288 1885 2 Parypatê Parypatê NNP 40288 1885 3 Hypatôn Hypatôn NNP 40288 1885 4 to to IN 40288 1885 5 the the DT 40288 1885 6 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1885 7 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1885 8 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 1885 9 . . . 40288 1886 1 In in IN 40288 1886 2 two two CD 40288 1886 3 of of IN 40288 1886 4 the the DT 40288 1886 5 tetrachords tetrachord NNS 40288 1886 6 , , , 40288 1886 7 viz viz NN 40288 1886 8 . . . 40288 1887 1 Synemmenôn Synemmenôn NNP 40288 1887 2 and and CC 40288 1887 3 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 1887 4 , , , 40288 1887 5 the the DT 40288 1887 6 intervals interval NNS 40288 1887 7 employed employ VBN 40288 1887 8 are be VBP 40288 1887 9 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1887 10 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1887 11 or or CC 40288 1887 12 possibly possibly RB 40288 1887 13 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1887 14 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1887 15 : : : 40288 1887 16 in in IN 40288 1887 17 the the DT 40288 1887 18 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1887 19 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1887 20 they -PRON- PRP 40288 1887 21 are be VBP 40288 1887 22 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1887 23 , , , 40288 1887 24 while while IN 40288 1887 25 in in IN 40288 1887 26 the the DT 40288 1887 27 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1887 28 Mesôn Mesôn NNP 40288 1887 29 the the DT 40288 1887 30 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1887 31 , , , 40288 1887 32 which which WDT 40288 1887 33 would would MD 40288 1887 34 distinguish distinguish VB 40288 1887 35 the the DT 40288 1887 36 genus genus NN 40288 1887 37 , , , 40288 1887 38 is be VBZ 40288 1887 39 wanting want VBG 40288 1887 40 . . . 40288 1888 1 On on IN 40288 1888 2 the the DT 40288 1888 3 other other JJ 40288 1888 4 hand hand NN 40288 1888 5 there there EX 40288 1888 6 are be VBP 40288 1888 7 two two CD 40288 1888 8 notes note NNS 40288 1888 9 which which WDT 40288 1888 10 do do VBP 40288 1888 11 not not RB 40288 1888 12 belong belong VB 40288 1888 13 to to IN 40288 1888 14 the the DT 40288 1888 15 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1888 16 key key NN 40288 1888 17 as as IN 40288 1888 18 hitherto hitherto NNP 40288 1888 19 known known JJ 40288 1888 20 , , , 40288 1888 21 viz viz NN 40288 1888 22 . . . 40288 1889 1 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1889 2 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1889 3 : : : 40288 1889 4 O o NN 40288 1889 5 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1889 6 , , , 40288 1889 7 a a DT 40288 1889 8 semitone semitone NN 40288 1889 9 below below IN 40288 1889 10 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1889 11 , , , 40288 1889 12 and and CC 40288 1889 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1889 14 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1889 15 : : : 40288 1889 16 B b NN 40288 1889 17 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1889 18 , , , 40288 1889 19 a a DT 40288 1889 20 semitone semitone NN 40288 1889 21 below below IN 40288 1889 22 Nêtê Nêtê NNP 40288 1889 23 Diezeugmenôn Diezeugmenôn NNP 40288 1889 24 . . . 40288 1890 1 If if IN 40288 1890 2 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1890 3 assume assume VBP 40288 1890 4 that that IN 40288 1890 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1890 6 have have VBP 40288 1890 7 before before IN 40288 1890 8 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1890 9 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1890 10 of of IN 40288 1890 11 the the DT 40288 1890 12 standard standard JJ 40288 1890 13 kind kind NN 40288 1890 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1890 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1890 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1890 17 : : : 40288 1890 18 chrôma chrôma NNP 40288 1890 19 toniaion toniaion NN 40288 1890 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1890 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1890 22 , , , 40288 1890 23 the the DT 40288 1890 24 complete complete JJ 40288 1890 25 scale scale NN 40288 1890 26 is-- is-- NNP 40288 1890 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1890 28 Music music NN 40288 1890 29 : : : 40288 1890 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1890 31 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1890 32 : : : 40288 1890 33 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1890 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1890 35 If if IN 40288 1890 36 the the DT 40288 1890 37 intervals interval NNS 40288 1890 38 are be VBP 40288 1890 39 Enharmonic enharmonic JJ 40288 1890 40 , , , 40288 1890 41 or or CC 40288 1890 42 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1890 43 of of IN 40288 1890 44 a a DT 40288 1890 45 different different JJ 40288 1890 46 variety variety NN 40288 1890 47 , , , 40288 1890 48 the the DT 40288 1890 49 moveable moveable JJ 40288 1890 50 notes note NNS 40288 1890 51 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1890 52 in in IN 40288 1890 53 this this DT 40288 1890 54 case case NN 40288 1890 55 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1890 56 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1890 57 : : : 40288 1890 58 A a DT 40288 1890 59 K k NN 40288 1890 60 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1890 61 and and CC 40288 1890 62 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1890 63 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1890 64 : : : 40288 1890 65 4 4 CD 40288 1890 66 3E 3e NN 40288 1890 67 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1890 68 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1890 69 will will MD 40288 1890 70 be be VB 40288 1890 71 somewhat somewhat RB 40288 1890 72 flatter flat JJR 40288 1890 73 . . . 40288 1891 1 M. M. NNP 40288 1891 2 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1891 3 is be VBZ 40288 1891 4 particularly particularly RB 40288 1891 5 happy happy JJ 40288 1891 6 in in IN 40288 1891 7 tracing trace VBG 40288 1891 8 the the DT 40288 1891 9 successive successive JJ 40288 1891 10 changes change NNS 40288 1891 11 of of IN 40288 1891 12 genus genus NN 40288 1891 13 and and CC 40288 1891 14 key key NN 40288 1891 15 in in IN 40288 1891 16 the the DT 40288 1891 17 course course NN 40288 1891 18 of of IN 40288 1891 19 the the DT 40288 1891 20 poem poem NN 40288 1891 21 . . . 40288 1892 1 The the DT 40288 1892 2 opening opening NN 40288 1892 3 passage passage NN 40288 1892 4 , , , 40288 1892 5 as as IN 40288 1892 6 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1892 7 shows show VBZ 40288 1892 8 , , , 40288 1892 9 is be VBZ 40288 1892 10 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1892 11 . . . 40288 1893 1 With with IN 40288 1893 2 the the DT 40288 1893 3 mention mention NN 40288 1893 4 of of IN 40288 1893 5 the the DT 40288 1893 6 Gaulish gaulish JJ 40288 1893 7 invasion invasion NN 40288 1893 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1893 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1893 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1893 11 : : : 40288 1893 12 Galatan Galatan NNP 40288 1893 13 arês arês NN 40288 1893 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1893 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1893 16 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1893 17 come come VBP 40288 1893 18 upon upon IN 40288 1893 19 the the DT 40288 1893 20 group group NN 40288 1893 21 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1893 22 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1893 23 : : : 40288 1893 24 U u NN 40288 1893 25 4 4 CD 40288 1893 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1893 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1893 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1893 29 g g NNP 40288 1893 30 -- -- : 40288 1893 31 a[Symbol a[symbol ADD 40288 1893 32 : : : 40288 1893 33 b]--a b]--a NNP 40288 1893 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1893 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1893 36 of of IN 40288 1893 37 the the DT 40288 1893 38 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1893 39 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1893 40 Hyperbolaiôn Hyperbolaiôn NNP 40288 1893 41 . . . 40288 1894 1 At at IN 40288 1894 2 the the DT 40288 1894 3 beginning beginning NN 40288 1894 4 of of IN 40288 1894 5 the the DT 40288 1894 6 second second JJ 40288 1894 7 fragment fragment NN 40288 1894 8 the the DT 40288 1894 9 intervals interval NNS 40288 1894 10 are be VBP 40288 1894 11 again again RB 40288 1894 12 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1894 13 , , , 40288 1894 14 up up IN 40288 1894 15 to to IN 40288 1894 16 the the DT 40288 1894 17 point point NN 40288 1894 18 where where WRB 40288 1894 19 the the DT 40288 1894 20 poet poet NN 40288 1894 21 turns turn VBZ 40288 1894 22 to to TO 40288 1894 23 address address VB 40288 1894 24 the the DT 40288 1894 25 Attic attic JJ 40288 1894 26 procession procession NN 40288 1894 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1894 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1894 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1894 30 : : : 40288 1894 31 ithi ithi NN 40288 1894 32 , , , 40288 1894 33 klyta klyta NNP 40288 1894 34 megalopolis megalopolis NNP 40288 1894 35 Aththis Aththis NNP 40288 1894 36 , , , 40288 1894 37 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1894 38 . . . 40288 1894 39 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1894 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1894 41 . . . 40288 1895 1 From from IN 40288 1895 2 this this DT 40288 1895 3 point point NN 40288 1895 4 the the DT 40288 1895 5 melody melody NN 40288 1895 6 lies lie VBZ 40288 1895 7 chiefly chiefly RB 40288 1895 8 in in IN 40288 1895 9 the the DT 40288 1895 10 Chromatic chromatic JJ 40288 1895 11 tetrachord tetrachord NN 40288 1895 12 Synemmenôn Synemmenôn NNP 40288 1895 13 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1895 14 Symbols Symbols NNP 40288 1895 15 : : : 40288 1895 16 M M NNP 40288 1895 17 AK AK NNP 40288 1895 18 r r NN 40288 1895 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1895 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1895 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1895 22 c c NNP 40288 1895 23 -- -- : 40288 1895 24 d[Symbol d[symbol XX 40288 1895 25 : : : 40288 1895 26 o]--d o]--d XX 40288 1895 27 -- -- : 40288 1895 28 f_)--a f_)--a NNP 40288 1895 29 modulation modulation NN 40288 1895 30 into into IN 40288 1895 31 the the DT 40288 1895 32 key key NN 40288 1895 33 of of IN 40288 1895 34 the the DT 40288 1895 35 sub sub JJ 40288 1895 36 - - JJ 40288 1895 37 dominant dominant JJ 40288 1895 38 as as RB 40288 1895 39 well well RB 40288 1895 40 as as IN 40288 1895 41 a a DT 40288 1895 42 change change NN 40288 1895 43 of of IN 40288 1895 44 genus genus NNP 40288 1895 45 . . . 40288 1896 1 At at IN 40288 1896 2 the the DT 40288 1896 3 end end NN 40288 1896 4 of of IN 40288 1896 5 the the DT 40288 1896 6 fragment fragment NN 40288 1896 7 the the DT 40288 1896 8 poet poet NN 40288 1896 9 returns return VBZ 40288 1896 10 to to IN 40288 1896 11 the the DT 40288 1896 12 Diatonic Diatonic NNP 40288 1896 13 and and CC 40288 1896 14 the the DT 40288 1896 15 original original JJ 40288 1896 16 key key NN 40288 1896 17 . . . 40288 1897 1 With with IN 40288 1897 2 regard regard NN 40288 1897 3 to to IN 40288 1897 4 the the DT 40288 1897 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1897 6 mode_--the mode_--the NNP 40288 1897 7 question question NN 40288 1897 8 which which WDT 40288 1897 9 mainly mainly RB 40288 1897 10 concerns concern VBZ 40288 1897 11 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1897 12 at at IN 40288 1897 13 present present JJ 40288 1897 14 -- -- : 40288 1897 15 M. M. NNP 40288 1897 16 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1897 17 's 's POS 40288 1897 18 exposition exposition NN 40288 1897 19 is be VBZ 40288 1897 20 clear clear JJ 40288 1897 21 and and CC 40288 1897 22 convincing convincing JJ 40288 1897 23 . . . 40288 1898 1 He -PRON- PRP 40288 1898 2 appeals appeal VBZ 40288 1898 3 to to IN 40288 1898 4 three three CD 40288 1898 5 criteria,--(1 criteria,--(1 NNPS 40288 1898 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1898 7 the the DT 40288 1898 8 impression impression NN 40288 1898 9 which which WDT 40288 1898 10 the the DT 40288 1898 11 music music NN 40288 1898 12 makes make VBZ 40288 1898 13 on on IN 40288 1898 14 a a DT 40288 1898 15 modern modern JJ 40288 1898 16 ear ear NN 40288 1898 17 ; ; : 40288 1898 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1898 19 2 2 LS 40288 1898 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1898 21 the the DT 40288 1898 22 endings ending NNS 40288 1898 23 of of IN 40288 1898 24 the the DT 40288 1898 25 several several JJ 40288 1898 26 phrases phrase NNS 40288 1898 27 and and CC 40288 1898 28 divisions division NNS 40288 1898 29 ; ; : 40288 1898 30 and and CC 40288 1898 31 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1898 32 3 3 LS 40288 1898 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1898 34 the the DT 40288 1898 35 note note NN 40288 1898 36 which which WDT 40288 1898 37 recurs recur VBZ 40288 1898 38 most most RBS 40288 1898 39 frequently frequently RB 40288 1898 40 . . . 40288 1899 1 All all PDT 40288 1899 2 these these DT 40288 1899 3 criteria criterion NNS 40288 1899 4 point point VBP 40288 1899 5 to to IN 40288 1899 6 a a DT 40288 1899 7 Minor minor JJ 40288 1899 8 mode mode NN 40288 1899 9 . . . 40288 1900 1 The the DT 40288 1900 2 general general JJ 40288 1900 3 impression impression NN 40288 1900 4 made make VBN 40288 1900 5 by by IN 40288 1900 6 the the DT 40288 1900 7 Diatonic diatonic JJ 40288 1900 8 parts part NNS 40288 1900 9 of of IN 40288 1900 10 the the DT 40288 1900 11 melody melody NN 40288 1900 12 is be VBZ 40288 1900 13 that that DT 40288 1900 14 of of IN 40288 1900 15 the the DT 40288 1900 16 key key NN 40288 1900 17 of of IN 40288 1900 18 _ _ NNP 40288 1900 19 C C NNP 40288 1900 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1900 21 minor minor NN 40288 1900 22 : : : 40288 1900 23 the the DT 40288 1900 24 rhythmical rhythmical JJ 40288 1900 25 periods period NNS 40288 1900 26 end end VBP 40288 1900 27 on on IN 40288 1900 28 one one CD 40288 1900 29 or or CC 40288 1900 30 other other JJ 40288 1900 31 of of IN 40288 1900 32 the the DT 40288 1900 33 notes note NNS 40288 1900 34 _ _ NNP 40288 1900 35 c c NNP 40288 1900 36 - - HYPH 40288 1900 37 e[Symbol e[Symbol NNP 40288 1900 38 : : : 40288 1900 39 flat]-g flat]-g NNP 40288 1900 40 _ _ NNP 40288 1900 41 , , , 40288 1900 42 which which WDT 40288 1900 43 form form VBP 40288 1900 44 the the DT 40288 1900 45 chord chord NN 40288 1900 46 of of IN 40288 1900 47 that that DT 40288 1900 48 key key NN 40288 1900 49 : : : 40288 1900 50 and and CC 40288 1900 51 the the DT 40288 1900 52 note note NN 40288 1900 53 _ _ NNP 40288 1900 54 c c NNP 40288 1900 55 _ _ NNP 40288 1900 56 distinctly distinctly RB 40288 1900 57 predominates predominate VBZ 40288 1900 58 . . . 40288 1901 1 This this DT 40288 1901 2 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 1901 3 , , , 40288 1901 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1901 5 need nee MD 40288 1901 6 hardly hardly RB 40288 1901 7 be be VB 40288 1901 8 said say VBN 40288 1901 9 , , , 40288 1901 10 is be VBZ 40288 1901 11 in in IN 40288 1901 12 entire entire JJ 40288 1901 13 agreement agreement NN 40288 1901 14 with with IN 40288 1901 15 the the DT 40288 1901 16 main main JJ 40288 1901 17 thesis thesis NN 40288 1901 18 of of IN 40288 1901 19 the the DT 40288 1901 20 preceding precede VBG 40288 1901 21 pages page NNS 40288 1901 22 . . . 40288 1902 1 The the DT 40288 1902 2 symbols symbol NNS 40288 1902 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1902 4 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1902 5 : : : 40288 1902 6 O o NN 40288 1902 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1902 8 and and CC 40288 1902 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1902 10 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1902 11 : : : 40288 1902 12 B b NN 40288 1902 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1902 14 , , , 40288 1902 15 which which WDT 40288 1902 16 do do VBP 40288 1902 17 not not RB 40288 1902 18 belong belong VB 40288 1902 19 to to IN 40288 1902 20 the the DT 40288 1902 21 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1902 22 scale scale NN 40288 1902 23 , , , 40288 1902 24 are be VBP 40288 1902 25 explained explain VBN 40288 1902 26 by by IN 40288 1902 27 M. M. NNP 40288 1902 28 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1902 29 in in IN 40288 1902 30 a a DT 40288 1902 31 way way NN 40288 1902 32 that that WDT 40288 1902 33 is be VBZ 40288 1902 34 in in IN 40288 1902 35 a a DT 40288 1902 36 high high JJ 40288 1902 37 degree degree NN 40288 1902 38 plausible plausible JJ 40288 1902 39 and and CC 40288 1902 40 suggestive suggestive JJ 40288 1902 41 . . . 40288 1903 1 In in IN 40288 1903 2 other other JJ 40288 1903 3 keys key NNS 40288 1903 4 , , , 40288 1903 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1903 6 observes observe VBZ 40288 1903 7 , , , 40288 1903 8 the the DT 40288 1903 9 symbol symbol NN 40288 1903 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1903 11 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1903 12 : : : 40288 1903 13 O o NN 40288 1903 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1903 15 stands stand VBZ 40288 1903 16 for for IN 40288 1903 17 the the DT 40288 1903 18 note note NN 40288 1903 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1903 20 b b NNP 40288 1903 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1903 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1903 23 natural natural JJ 40288 1903 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1903 25 . . . 40288 1904 1 Thus thus RB 40288 1904 2 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1904 3 holds hold VBZ 40288 1904 4 the the DT 40288 1904 5 place place NN 40288 1904 6 of of IN 40288 1904 7 ' ' `` 40288 1904 8 leading leading NN 40288 1904 9 - - HYPH 40288 1904 10 note note NN 40288 1904 11 ' ' '' 40288 1904 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1904 13 _ _ NNP 40288 1904 14 note note NN 40288 1904 15 sensible sensible JJ 40288 1904 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1904 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1904 18 to to IN 40288 1904 19 the the DT 40288 1904 20 keynote keynote NN 40288 1904 21 , , , 40288 1904 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1904 23 c c NNP 40288 1904 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1904 25 . . . 40288 1905 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1905 2 has have VBZ 40288 1905 3 hitherto hitherto VBN 40288 1905 4 been be VBN 40288 1905 5 supposed suppose VBN 40288 1905 6 that that IN 40288 1905 7 the the DT 40288 1905 8 standard standard JJ 40288 1905 9 scale scale NN 40288 1905 10 of of IN 40288 1905 11 Greek greek JJ 40288 1905 12 music music NN 40288 1905 13 , , , 40288 1905 14 the the DT 40288 1905 15 octave octave NN 40288 1905 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1905 17 a a DT 40288 1905 18 - - : 40288 1905 19 a a DT 40288 1905 20 _ _ NNP 40288 1905 21 , , , 40288 1905 22 differed differ VBN 40288 1905 23 from from IN 40288 1905 24 the the DT 40288 1905 25 modern modern JJ 40288 1905 26 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1905 27 in in IN 40288 1905 28 the the DT 40288 1905 29 want want NN 40288 1905 30 of of IN 40288 1905 31 a a DT 40288 1905 32 leading leading JJ 40288 1905 33 note note NN 40288 1905 34 . . . 40288 1906 1 Here here RB 40288 1906 2 , , , 40288 1906 3 however however RB 40288 1906 4 , , , 40288 1906 5 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1906 6 find find VBP 40288 1906 7 evidence evidence NN 40288 1906 8 that that IN 40288 1906 9 such such PDT 40288 1906 10 a a DT 40288 1906 11 note note NN 40288 1906 12 was be VBD 40288 1906 13 known know VBN 40288 1906 14 in in IN 40288 1906 15 practice practice NN 40288 1906 16 , , , 40288 1906 17 if if IN 40288 1906 18 not not RB 40288 1906 19 as as IN 40288 1906 20 a a DT 40288 1906 21 matter matter NN 40288 1906 22 of of IN 40288 1906 23 theory theory NN 40288 1906 24 , , , 40288 1906 25 to to IN 40288 1906 26 Greek greek JJ 40288 1906 27 musicians musician NNS 40288 1906 28 . . . 40288 1907 1 If if IN 40288 1907 2 this this DT 40288 1907 3 is be VBZ 40288 1907 4 so so RB 40288 1907 5 , , , 40288 1907 6 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1907 7 strongly strongly RB 40288 1907 8 confirms confirm VBZ 40288 1907 9 the the DT 40288 1907 10 view view NN 40288 1907 11 that that IN 40288 1907 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1907 13 c c NNP 40288 1907 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1907 15 was be VBD 40288 1907 16 in in IN 40288 1907 17 fact fact NN 40288 1907 18 the the DT 40288 1907 19 key key NN 40288 1907 20 - - HYPH 40288 1907 21 note note NN 40288 1907 22 of of IN 40288 1907 23 the the DT 40288 1907 24 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1907 25 scale scale NN 40288 1907 26 . . . 40288 1908 1 The the DT 40288 1908 2 symbol symbol NN 40288 1908 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1908 4 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1908 5 : : : 40288 1908 6 B b NN 40288 1908 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1908 8 , , , 40288 1908 9 which which WDT 40288 1908 10 occurs occur VBZ 40288 1908 11 only only RB 40288 1908 12 once once RB 40288 1908 13 , , , 40288 1908 14 answers answer NNS 40288 1908 15 to to IN 40288 1908 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1908 17 _ _ NNP 40288 1908 18 g_[Symbol g_[Symbol NNP 40288 1908 19 : : : 40288 1908 20 flat flat NN 40288 1908 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1908 22 , , , 40288 1908 23 and and CC 40288 1908 24 may may MD 40288 1908 25 be be VB 40288 1908 26 similarly similarly RB 40288 1908 27 explained explain VBN 40288 1908 28 as as IN 40288 1908 29 a a DT 40288 1908 30 leading leading JJ 40288 1908 31 note note NN 40288 1908 32 to to IN 40288 1908 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1908 34 g g NNP 40288 1908 35 _ _ NNP 40288 1908 36 , , , 40288 1908 37 the the DT 40288 1908 38 dominant dominant NN 40288 1908 39 of of IN 40288 1908 40 the the DT 40288 1908 41 key key NN 40288 1908 42 . . . 40288 1909 1 We -PRON- PRP 40288 1909 2 infer infer VBP 40288 1909 3 , , , 40288 1909 4 with with IN 40288 1909 5 M. M. NNP 40288 1909 6 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1909 7 , , , 40288 1909 8 that that IN 40288 1909 9 the the DT 40288 1909 10 scale scale NN 40288 1909 11 employed employ VBN 40288 1909 12 in in IN 40288 1909 13 the the DT 40288 1909 14 hymn hymn NN 40288 1909 15 is be VBZ 40288 1909 16 not not RB 40288 1909 17 only only RB 40288 1909 18 like like UH 40288 1909 19 , , , 40288 1909 20 but but CC 40288 1909 21 identical identical JJ 40288 1909 22 with with IN 40288 1909 23 , , , 40288 1909 24 the the DT 40288 1909 25 scale scale NN 40288 1909 26 of of IN 40288 1909 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1909 28 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1909 29 . . . 40288 1910 1 The the DT 40288 1910 2 fragment fragment NN 40288 1910 3 marked mark VBD 40288 1910 4 C C NNP 40288 1910 5 by by IN 40288 1910 6 M. M. NNP 40288 1910 7 Weil Weil NNP 40288 1910 8 resembles resemble VBZ 40288 1910 9 the the DT 40288 1910 10 hymn hymn NN 40288 1910 11 to to IN 40288 1910 12 Apollo Apollo NNP 40288 1910 13 in in IN 40288 1910 14 subject subject NN 40288 1910 15 , , , 40288 1910 16 and and CC 40288 1910 17 also also RB 40288 1910 18 in in IN 40288 1910 19 metre metre NNP 40288 1910 20 , , , 40288 1910 21 but but CC 40288 1910 22 can can MD 40288 1910 23 not not RB 40288 1910 24 belong belong VB 40288 1910 25 to to IN 40288 1910 26 the the DT 40288 1910 27 same same JJ 40288 1910 28 work work NN 40288 1910 29 . . . 40288 1911 1 The the DT 40288 1911 2 melody melody NN 40288 1911 3 is be VBZ 40288 1911 4 written write VBN 40288 1911 5 in in IN 40288 1911 6 the the DT 40288 1911 7 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1911 8 key key NN 40288 1911 9 , , , 40288 1911 10 with with IN 40288 1911 11 the the DT 40288 1911 12 notation notation NN 40288 1911 13 which which WDT 40288 1911 14 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1911 15 have have VBP 40288 1911 16 hitherto hitherto VBN 40288 1911 17 known know VBN 40288 1911 18 as as IN 40288 1911 19 the the DT 40288 1911 20 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1911 21 , , , 40288 1911 22 but but CC 40288 1911 23 which which WDT 40288 1911 24 is be VBZ 40288 1911 25 now now RB 40288 1911 26 shown show VBN 40288 1911 27 to to TO 40288 1911 28 have have VB 40288 1911 29 been be VBN 40288 1911 30 used use VBN 40288 1911 31 , , , 40288 1911 32 occasionally occasionally RB 40288 1911 33 at at IN 40288 1911 34 least least JJS 40288 1911 35 , , , 40288 1911 36 for for IN 40288 1911 37 vocal vocal JJ 40288 1911 38 music music NN 40288 1911 39 . . . 40288 1912 1 The the DT 40288 1912 2 fragment fragment NN 40288 1912 3 is be VBZ 40288 1912 4 as as RB 40288 1912 5 follows:[Music follows:[music NN 40288 1912 6 : : : 40288 1912 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1912 8 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1912 9 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1912 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1912 12 : : : 40288 1912 13 t t NN 40288 1912 14 ' ' POS 40288 1912 15 e e NNP 40288 1912 16 - - HYPH 40288 1912 17 pi pi NNP 40288 1912 18 tê tê NN 40288 1912 19 - - HYPH 40288 1912 20 les les FW 40288 1912 21 - - HYPH 40288 1912 22 ko ko NN 40288 1912 23 - - HYPH 40288 1912 24 pon pon NNP 40288 1912 25 tan[de tan[de NNP 40288 1912 26 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 27 di di NNP 40288 1912 28 - - HYPH 40288 1912 29 ko ko NNP 40288 1912 30 - - HYPH 40288 1912 31 ry ry NNP 40288 1912 32 - - HYPH 40288 1912 33 phon phon NNP 40288 1912 34 klei klei NN 40288 1912 35 - - HYPH 40288 1912 36 tyn tyn NNP 40288 1912 37 hym[in hym[in NNP 40288 1912 38 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 39 Pi Pi NNP 40288 1912 40 - - HYPH 40288 1912 41 erides erides NNP 40288 1912 42 ai ai VBP 40288 1912 43 ni ni NNP 40288 1912 44 - - HYPH 40288 1912 45 pho pho NNP 40288 1912 46 - - HYPH 40288 1912 47 bo bo NNP 40288 1912 48 - - HYPH 40288 1912 49 lous lous JJ 40288 1912 50 mel mel JJ 40288 1912 51 - - JJ 40288 1912 52 pe pe JJ 40288 1912 53 - - HYPH 40288 1912 54 te te NNP 40288 1912 55 de de NNP 40288 1912 56 Py Py NNP 40288 1912 57 - - HYPH 40288 1912 58 thi thi NNP 40288 1912 59 - - HYPH 40288 1912 60 on on IN 40288 1912 61 Phoi Phoi NNP 40288 1912 62 - - HYPH 40288 1912 63 bon bon FW 40288 1912 64 on on IN 40288 1912 65 e e NNP 40288 1912 66 - - HYPH 40288 1912 67 tik tik NNP 40288 1912 68 - - HYPH 40288 1912 69 te te NNP 40288 1912 70 L[a L[a NNP 40288 1912 71 - - HYPH 40288 1912 72 tô tô NNP 40288 1912 73 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 74 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 75 M. M. NNP 40288 1912 76 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1912 77 connects connect VBZ 40288 1912 78 this this DT 40288 1912 79 fragment fragment NN 40288 1912 80 with with IN 40288 1912 81 a a DT 40288 1912 82 shorter short JJR 40288 1912 83 one one NN 40288 1912 84 , , , 40288 1912 85 also also RB 40288 1912 86 in in IN 40288 1912 87 the the DT 40288 1912 88 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1912 89 key key NN 40288 1912 90 , , , 40288 1912 91 but but CC 40288 1912 92 not not RB 40288 1912 93 in in IN 40288 1912 94 paeonic paeonic NNP 40288 1912 95 metre metre NNP 40288 1912 96 , , , 40288 1912 97 viz.-- viz.-- : 40288 1912 98 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1912 99 Music music NN 40288 1912 100 : : : 40288 1912 101 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1912 102 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1912 103 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 104 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1912 105 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1912 106 : : : 40288 1912 107 .. .. NFP 40288 1912 108 thon thon NNP 40288 1912 109 es es NNP 40288 1912 110 - - HYPH 40288 1912 111 che che NNP 40288 1912 112 ma ma NNP 40288 1912 113 ... ... NNP 40288 1912 114 thê thê NNP 40288 1912 115 - - HYPH 40288 1912 116 ra ra NNP 40288 1912 117 kat kat NNP 40288 1912 118 - - HYPH 40288 1912 119 ek ek NNP 40288 1912 120 - - HYPH 40288 1912 121 ta ta NNP 40288 1912 122 .... .... NFP 40288 1912 123 syrigm syrigm VB 40288 1912 124 ' ' `` 40288 1912 125 a a DT 40288 1912 126 - - HYPH 40288 1912 127 per per NN 40288 1912 128 .. .. NFP 40288 1912 129 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 130 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1912 131 M. M. NNP 40288 1912 132 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1912 133 thinks think VBZ 40288 1912 134 that that IN 40288 1912 135 the the DT 40288 1912 136 mode mode NN 40288 1912 137 may may MD 40288 1912 138 be be VB 40288 1912 139 the the DT 40288 1912 140 so so RB 40288 1912 141 - - HYPH 40288 1912 142 called call VBN 40288 1912 143 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1912 144 - - HYPH 40288 1912 145 lydian lydian NNP 40288 1912 146 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1912 147 the the DT 40288 1912 148 octave octave NN 40288 1912 149 _ _ NNP 40288 1912 150 f f NNP 40288 1912 151 - - HYPH 40288 1912 152 f f NNP 40288 1912 153 _ _ NNP 40288 1912 154 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1912 155 . . . 40288 1913 1 The the DT 40288 1913 2 materials material NNS 40288 1913 3 are be VBP 40288 1913 4 surely surely RB 40288 1913 5 too too RB 40288 1913 6 scanty scanty NN 40288 1913 7 for for IN 40288 1913 8 any any DT 40288 1913 9 conclusion conclusion NN 40288 1913 10 as as IN 40288 1913 11 to to IN 40288 1913 12 this this DT 40288 1913 13 . . . 40288 1914 1 The the DT 40288 1914 2 fragment fragment NN 40288 1914 3 D d NN 40288 1914 4 , , , 40288 1914 5 the the DT 40288 1914 6 only only RB 40288 1914 7 remaining remain VBG 40288 1914 8 piece piece NN 40288 1914 9 which which WDT 40288 1914 10 M. M. NNP 40288 1914 11 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1914 12 has have VBZ 40288 1914 13 found find VBN 40288 1914 14 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1914 15 worth worth JJ 40288 1914 16 while while IN 40288 1914 17 to to IN 40288 1914 18 transcribe transcribe NN 40288 1914 19 , , , 40288 1914 20 is be VBZ 40288 1914 21 also also RB 40288 1914 22 written write VBN 40288 1914 23 in in IN 40288 1914 24 the the DT 40288 1914 25 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1914 26 notation notation NN 40288 1914 27 of of IN 40288 1914 28 the the DT 40288 1914 29 Lydian lydian JJ 40288 1914 30 key key NN 40288 1914 31 . . . 40288 1915 1 The the DT 40288 1915 2 metre metre NN 40288 1915 3 is be VBZ 40288 1915 4 the the DT 40288 1915 5 glyconic glyconic NNP 40288 1915 6 . . . 40288 1916 1 The the DT 40288 1916 2 fragment fragment NN 40288 1916 3 is be VBZ 40288 1916 4 as as IN 40288 1916 5 follows:-- follows:-- ADD 40288 1916 6 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 7 Music music NN 40288 1916 8 : : : 40288 1916 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 10 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1916 11 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1916 14 : : : 40288 1916 15 ton ton NN 40288 1916 16 man man NN 40288 1916 17 - - HYPH 40288 1916 18 to to IN 40288 1916 19 - - HYPH 40288 1916 20 sy[na sy[na NNP 40288 1916 21 klyton klyton NN 40288 1916 22 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 23 ô ô NN 40288 1916 24 - - HYPH 40288 1916 25 leth leth NN 40288 1916 26 ' ' '' 40288 1916 27 hy hy NNP 40288 1916 28 - - HYPH 40288 1916 29 gra gra NNP 40288 1916 30 ch ch NNP 40288 1916 31 ... ... NFP 40288 1916 32 despoti despoti NNP 40288 1916 33 Krê Krê NNP 40288 1916 34 - - HYPH 40288 1916 35 siôn siôn NNP 40288 1916 36 .. .. NFP 40288 1916 37 ai ai VBP 40288 1916 38 nae nae NN 40288 1916 39 - - HYPH 40288 1916 40 tas tas NNP 40288 1916 41 Delphôn Delphôn NNP 40288 1916 42 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 43 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 45 Music music NN 40288 1916 46 : : : 40288 1916 47 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 48 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1916 49 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 50 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 51 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1916 52 : : : 40288 1916 53 ... ... NFP 40288 1916 54 in in IN 40288 1916 55 ap ap NNP 40288 1916 56 - - HYPH 40288 1916 57 tais tais RB 40288 1916 58 - - HYPH 40288 1916 59 tous tous JJ 40288 1916 60 Bak Bak NNP 40288 1916 61 - - HYPH 40288 1916 62 chou chou NNP 40288 1916 63 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 64 thiasous thiasous JJ 40288 1916 65 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 66 ... ... NFP 40288 1916 67 te te NNP 40288 1916 68 prospolois prospolois NNP 40288 1916 69 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 70 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 71 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 72 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1916 73 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 74 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1916 75 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1916 76 : : : 40288 1916 77 tan tan NNP 40288 1916 78 te te NNP 40288 1916 79 do[u]ri[klytôn do[u]ri[klytôn NNP 40288 1916 80 ar ar NNP 40288 1916 81 - - HYPH 40288 1916 82 chan chan NNP 40288 1916 83 au au NNP 40288 1916 84 - - HYPH 40288 1916 85 xet xet NNP 40288 1916 86 ' ' '' 40288 1916 87 a a DT 40288 1916 88 - - HYPH 40288 1916 89 gê gê NNP 40288 1916 90 - - HYPH 40288 1916 91 ra ra NNP 40288 1916 92 - - HYPH 40288 1916 93 tô tô NNP 40288 1916 94 thal thal NNS 40288 1916 95 ... ... NFP 40288 1916 96 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 97 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1916 98 This this DT 40288 1916 99 piece piece NN 40288 1916 100 also also RB 40288 1916 101 is be VBZ 40288 1916 102 referred refer VBN 40288 1916 103 by by IN 40288 1916 104 M. M. NNP 40288 1916 105 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1916 106 to to IN 40288 1916 107 the the DT 40288 1916 108 Hypo hypo JJ 40288 1916 109 - - HYPH 40288 1916 110 lydian lydian JJ 40288 1916 111 mode mode NN 40288 1916 112 . . . 40288 1917 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1917 2 may may MD 40288 1917 3 surely surely RB 40288 1917 4 be be VB 40288 1917 5 objected object VBN 40288 1917 6 that that IN 40288 1917 7 of of IN 40288 1917 8 three three CD 40288 1917 9 places place NNS 40288 1917 10 in in IN 40288 1917 11 which which WDT 40288 1917 12 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1917 13 may may MD 40288 1917 14 fairly fairly RB 40288 1917 15 suppose suppose VB 40288 1917 16 that that IN 40288 1917 17 we -PRON- PRP 40288 1917 18 have have VBP 40288 1917 19 the the DT 40288 1917 20 end end NN 40288 1917 21 of of IN 40288 1917 22 a a DT 40288 1917 23 metrical metrical JJ 40288 1917 24 division division NN 40288 1917 25 , , , 40288 1917 26 viz viz NN 40288 1917 27 . . . 40288 1918 1 those those DT 40288 1918 2 which which WDT 40288 1918 3 end end VBP 40288 1918 4 with with IN 40288 1918 5 the the DT 40288 1918 6 words word NNS 40288 1918 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1918 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1918 9 : : : 40288 1918 10 Delphôn delphôn NN 40288 1918 11 , , , 40288 1918 12 prospolois prospolois NN 40288 1918 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1918 14 and and CC 40288 1918 15 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1918 16 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1918 17 : : : 40288 1918 18 agêratô agêratô NN 40288 1918 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1918 20 , , , 40288 1918 21 two two CD 40288 1918 22 present present VB 40288 1918 23 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1918 24 with with IN 40288 1918 25 cadences cadence NNS 40288 1918 26 on on IN 40288 1918 27 the the DT 40288 1918 28 Mesê Mesê NNPS 40288 1918 29 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1918 30 _ _ NNP 40288 1918 31 d d NNP 40288 1918 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1918 33 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1918 34 , , , 40288 1918 35 and and CC 40288 1918 36 one one CD 40288 1918 37 on on IN 40288 1918 38 the the DT 40288 1918 39 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1918 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1918 41 _ _ NNP 40288 1918 42 a a DT 40288 1918 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1918 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1918 45 . . . 40288 1919 1 This this DT 40288 1919 2 seems seem VBZ 40288 1919 3 to to TO 40288 1919 4 point point VB 40288 1919 5 strongly strongly RB 40288 1919 6 to to IN 40288 1919 7 the the DT 40288 1919 8 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1919 9 Mode Mode NNP 40288 1919 10 . . . 40288 1920 1 On on IN 40288 1920 2 the the DT 40288 1920 3 whole whole NN 40288 1920 4 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1920 5 would would MD 40288 1920 6 seem seem VB 40288 1920 7 that that IN 40288 1920 8 the the DT 40288 1920 9 only only JJ 40288 1920 10 _ _ NNP 40288 1920 11 mode mode NN 40288 1920 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1920 13 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1920 14 in in IN 40288 1920 15 the the DT 40288 1920 16 modern modern JJ 40288 1920 17 sense sense NN 40288 1920 18 of of IN 40288 1920 19 the the DT 40288 1920 20 word word NN 40288 1920 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1920 22 of of IN 40288 1920 23 which which WDT 40288 1920 24 the the DT 40288 1920 25 new new JJ 40288 1920 26 discoveries discovery NNS 40288 1920 27 tell tell VBP 40288 1920 28 us -PRON- PRP 40288 1920 29 anything anything NN 40288 1920 30 is be VBZ 40288 1920 31 a a DT 40288 1920 32 mode mode NN 40288 1920 33 practically practically RB 40288 1920 34 identical identical JJ 40288 1920 35 with with IN 40288 1920 36 the the DT 40288 1920 37 modern modern JJ 40288 1920 38 Minor Minor NNP 40288 1920 39 . . . 40288 1921 1 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1921 2 venture venture VBP 40288 1921 3 to to TO 40288 1921 4 think think VB 40288 1921 5 this this DT 40288 1921 6 a a DT 40288 1921 7 confirmation confirmation NN 40288 1921 8 , , , 40288 1921 9 as as IN 40288 1921 10 signal signal NN 40288 1921 11 as as IN 40288 1921 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1921 13 was be VBD 40288 1921 14 unexpected unexpected JJ 40288 1921 15 , , , 40288 1921 16 of of IN 40288 1921 17 the the DT 40288 1921 18 main main JJ 40288 1921 19 contention contention NN 40288 1921 20 of of IN 40288 1921 21 this this DT 40288 1921 22 treatise treatise NN 40288 1921 23 . . . 40288 1922 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1922 2 does do VBZ 40288 1922 3 not not RB 40288 1922 4 seem seem VB 40288 1922 5 to to TO 40288 1922 6 have have VB 40288 1922 7 been be VBN 40288 1922 8 observed observe VBN 40288 1922 9 by by IN 40288 1922 10 M. M. NNP 40288 1922 11 Weil Weil NNP 40288 1922 12 or or CC 40288 1922 13 M. M. NNP 40288 1922 14 Reinach Reinach NNP 40288 1922 15 that that IN 40288 1922 16 in in IN 40288 1922 17 all all PDT 40288 1922 18 these these DT 40288 1922 19 pieces piece NNS 40288 1922 20 of of IN 40288 1922 21 music music NN 40288 1922 22 there there EX 40288 1922 23 is be VBZ 40288 1922 24 the the DT 40288 1922 25 same same JJ 40288 1922 26 remarkable remarkable JJ 40288 1922 27 correspondence correspondence NN 40288 1922 28 between between IN 40288 1922 29 the the DT 40288 1922 30 melody melody NN 40288 1922 31 and and CC 40288 1922 32 the the DT 40288 1922 33 accentuation accentuation NN 40288 1922 34 that that WDT 40288 1922 35 has have VBZ 40288 1922 36 been be VBN 40288 1922 37 pointed point VBN 40288 1922 38 out out RP 40288 1922 39 in in IN 40288 1922 40 the the DT 40288 1922 41 case case NN 40288 1922 42 of of IN 40288 1922 43 the the DT 40288 1922 44 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 1922 45 inscription inscription NN 40288 1922 46 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1922 47 pp pp NNP 40288 1922 48 . . . 40288 1923 1 90 90 CD 40288 1923 2 , , , 40288 1923 3 91 91 CD 40288 1923 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1923 5 . . . 40288 1924 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1924 2 can can MD 40288 1924 3 not not RB 40288 1924 4 indeed indeed RB 40288 1924 5 be be VB 40288 1924 6 said say VBN 40288 1924 7 that that IN 40288 1924 8 every every DT 40288 1924 9 acute acute JJ 40288 1924 10 accent accent NN 40288 1924 11 coincides coincide VBZ 40288 1924 12 with with IN 40288 1924 13 a a DT 40288 1924 14 rise rise NN 40288 1924 15 of of IN 40288 1924 16 pitch pitch NN 40288 1924 17 : : : 40288 1924 18 but but CC 40288 1924 19 the the DT 40288 1924 20 note note NN 40288 1924 21 of of IN 40288 1924 22 an an DT 40288 1924 23 accented accented JJ 40288 1924 24 syllable syllable NN 40288 1924 25 is be VBZ 40288 1924 26 almost almost RB 40288 1924 27 always always RB 40288 1924 28 followed follow VBN 40288 1924 29 by by IN 40288 1924 30 a a DT 40288 1924 31 note note NN 40288 1924 32 of of IN 40288 1924 33 lower low JJR 40288 1924 34 pitch pitch NN 40288 1924 35 . . . 40288 1925 1 Exceptions exception NNS 40288 1925 2 are be VBP 40288 1925 3 , , , 40288 1925 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1925 5 Greek greek JJ 40288 1925 6 : : : 40288 1925 7 aiolon aiolon NNP 40288 1925 8 , , , 40288 1925 9 hina hina NNP 40288 1925 10 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1925 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1925 12 which which WDT 40288 1925 13 may may MD 40288 1925 14 have have VB 40288 1925 15 practically practically RB 40288 1925 16 lost lose VBN 40288 1925 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1925 18 accent accent NN 40288 1925 19 , , , 40288 1925 20 cp cp NNP 40288 1925 21 . . . 40288 1926 1 the the DT 40288 1926 2 Modern Modern NNP 40288 1926 3 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1926 4 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1926 5 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1926 6 : : : 40288 1926 7 na na XX 40288 1926 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1926 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1926 10 , , , 40288 1926 11 and and CC 40288 1926 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1926 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1926 14 : : : 40288 1926 15 molete molete NN 40288 1926 16 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1926 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1926 18 if if IN 40288 1926 19 rightly rightly RB 40288 1926 20 restored restore VBN 40288 1926 21 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1926 22 . . . 40288 1927 1 The the DT 40288 1927 2 fall fall NN 40288 1927 3 of of IN 40288 1927 4 pitch pitch NN 40288 1927 5 in in IN 40288 1927 6 the the DT 40288 1927 7 two two CD 40288 1927 8 notes note NNS 40288 1927 9 of of IN 40288 1927 10 a a DT 40288 1927 11 circumflexed circumflexed JJ 40288 1927 12 syllable syllable NN 40288 1927 13 is be VBZ 40288 1927 14 exemplified exemplify VBN 40288 1927 15 in in IN 40288 1927 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1927 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1927 18 : : : 40288 1927 19 manteion manteion NN 40288 1927 20 , , , 40288 1927 21 heilen heilen NN 40288 1927 22 , , , 40288 1927 23 Galatan Galatan NNP 40288 1927 24 , , , 40288 1927 25 Phoibon Phoibon NNP 40288 1927 26 , , , 40288 1927 27 ôdaisi ôdaisi RB 40288 1927 28 , , , 40288 1927 29 klytais klytais NNP 40288 1927 30 , , , 40288 1927 31 bômoisin bômoisin NNP 40288 1927 32 , , , 40288 1927 33 homou homou NNP 40288 1927 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1927 35 : : : 40288 1927 36 the the DT 40288 1927 37 opposite opposite JJ 40288 1927 38 case case NN 40288 1927 39 occurs occur VBZ 40288 1927 40 only only RB 40288 1927 41 once once RB 40288 1927 42 , , , 40288 1927 43 in in IN 40288 1927 44 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1927 45 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1927 46 : : : 40288 1927 47 thnatois thnatois NNP 40288 1927 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1927 49 . . . 40288 1928 1 The the DT 40288 1928 2 observation observation NN 40288 1928 3 holds hold VBZ 40288 1928 4 not not RB 40288 1928 5 only only RB 40288 1928 6 of of IN 40288 1928 7 the the DT 40288 1928 8 chief chief JJ 40288 1928 9 hymn hymn NN 40288 1928 10 , , , 40288 1928 11 but but CC 40288 1928 12 of of IN 40288 1928 13 all all PDT 40288 1928 14 the the DT 40288 1928 15 fragments fragment NNS 40288 1928 16 . . . 40288 1929 1 INDEX index NN 40288 1929 2 OF of IN 40288 1929 3 PASSAGES passages NN 40288 1929 4 DISCUSSED DISCUSSED NNS 40288 1929 5 OR or CC 40288 1929 6 REFERRED refer VBD 40288 1929 7 TO to IN 40288 1929 8 . . . 40288 1930 1 AUTHOR AUTHOR NNP 40288 1930 2 PAGE PAGE NNP 40288 1930 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1930 4 Anonymi Anonymi NNP 40288 1930 5 Scriptio Scriptio NNP 40288 1930 6 de de NNP 40288 1930 7 Musica Musica NNP 40288 1930 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1930 9 , , , 40288 1930 10 § § ADD 40288 1930 11 28 28 CD 40288 1930 12 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1930 13 the the DT 40288 1930 14 modes mode NNS 40288 1930 15 employed employ VBN 40288 1930 16 on on IN 40288 1930 17 different different JJ 40288 1930 18 instruments instrument NNS 40288 1930 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1930 20 , , , 40288 1930 21 27 27 CD 40288 1930 22 § § CD 40288 1930 23 § § CD 40288 1930 24 63 63 CD 40288 1930 25 - - SYM 40288 1930 26 64 64 CD 40288 1930 27 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1930 28 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1930 29 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1930 30 : : : 40288 1930 31 topoi topoi NNP 40288 1930 32 tês tês NNP 40288 1930 33 phônês phônês NNP 40288 1930 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1930 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1930 36 , , , 40288 1930 37 64 64 CD 40288 1930 38 Aristides aristide NNS 40288 1930 39 Quintilianus Quintilianus NNP 40288 1930 40 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1930 41 ed ed NN 40288 1930 42 . . . 40288 1931 1 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1931 2 . . . 40288 1932 1 ): ): NNP 40288 1932 2 p. p. NN 40288 1932 3 10 10 CD 40288 1932 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1932 5 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1932 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1932 7 , , , 40288 1932 8 31 31 CD 40288 1932 9 p. p. NN 40288 1932 10 13 13 CD 40288 1932 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1932 12 ethos ethos NN 40288 1932 13 of of IN 40288 1932 14 music music NN 40288 1932 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1932 16 , , , 40288 1932 17 63 63 CD 40288 1932 18 , , , 40288 1932 19 66 66 CD 40288 1932 20 p. p. NN 40288 1932 21 15 15 CD 40288 1932 22 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1932 23 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1932 24 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1932 25 : : : 40288 1932 26 kata kata NNP 40288 1932 27 dieseis dieseis NNP 40288 1932 28 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 1932 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1932 30 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1932 31 , , , 40288 1932 32 53 53 CD 40288 1932 33 , , , 40288 1932 34 98 98 CD 40288 1932 35 p. p. NN 40288 1932 36 21 21 CD 40288 1932 37 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1932 38 Modes Modes NNP 40288 1932 39 in in IN 40288 1932 40 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1932 41 's 's POS 40288 1932 42 _ _ NNP 40288 1932 43 Republic Republic NNP 40288 1932 44 _ _ NNP 40288 1932 45 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1932 46 , , , 40288 1932 47 94 94 CD 40288 1932 48 - - SYM 40288 1932 49 100 100 CD 40288 1932 50 p. p. NN 40288 1932 51 28 28 CD 40288 1932 52 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1932 53 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1932 54 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1932 55 : : : 40288 1932 56 topoi topoi NNP 40288 1932 57 tês tês NNP 40288 1932 58 phônês phônês NNP 40288 1932 59 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1932 60 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1932 61 , , , 40288 1932 62 63 63 CD 40288 1932 63 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40288 1932 64 , , , 40288 1932 65 _ _ NNP 40288 1932 66 Eq Eq NNP 40288 1932 67 . . . 40288 1932 68 _ _ NNP 40288 1932 69 985 985 CD 40288 1932 70 - - HYPH 40288 1932 71 996 996 CD 40288 1932 72 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1932 73 Dorian Dorian NNP 40288 1932 74 Mode Mode NNP 40288 1932 75 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1932 76 , , , 40288 1932 77 7 7 CD 40288 1932 78 , , , 40288 1932 79 42 42 CD 40288 1932 80 Aristotle aristotle NN 40288 1932 81 : : : 40288 1932 82 _ _ NNP 40288 1932 83 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 40288 1932 84 _ _ NNP 40288 1932 85 , , , 40288 1932 86 iv iv NNP 40288 1932 87 . . . 40288 1933 1 11 11 CD 40288 1933 2 , , , 40288 1933 3 p. p. NN 40288 1933 4 1018 1018 CD 40288 1933 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1933 6 b b NNP 40288 1933 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1933 8 26 26 CD 40288 1933 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1933 10 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1933 11 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1933 12 : : : 40288 1933 13 archê archê NNP 40288 1933 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1933 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1933 16 , , , 40288 1933 17 46 46 CD 40288 1933 18 Politics Politics NNPS 40288 1933 19 , , , 40288 1933 20 iv iv NNP 40288 1933 21 . . . 40288 1934 1 3 3 CD 40288 1934 2 , , , 40288 1934 3 p. p. NN 40288 1934 4 1290 1290 CD 40288 1934 5 a a DT 40288 1934 6 20 20 CD 40288 1934 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1934 8 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1934 9 and and CC 40288 1934 10 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1934 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1934 12 , , , 40288 1934 13 105 105 CD 40288 1934 14 viii viii NN 40288 1934 15 . . . 40288 1935 1 5 5 CD 40288 1935 2 - - SYM 40288 1935 3 7 7 CD 40288 1935 4 , , , 40288 1935 5 pp pp NNP 40288 1935 6 . . . 40288 1936 1 1340 1340 CD 40288 1936 2 - - SYM 40288 1936 3 1342 1342 CD 40288 1936 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1936 5 ethos ethos NN 40288 1936 6 of of IN 40288 1936 7 music music NN 40288 1936 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1936 9 , , , 40288 1936 10 9 9 CD 40288 1936 11 , , , 40288 1936 12 12 12 CD 40288 1936 13 , , , 40288 1936 14 13 13 CD 40288 1936 15 , , , 40288 1936 16 107 107 CD 40288 1936 17 viii viii NN 40288 1936 18 . . . 40288 1937 1 7 7 CD 40288 1937 2 , , , 40288 1937 3 p. p. NN 40288 1937 4 1342 1342 CD 40288 1937 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1937 6 a a DT 40288 1937 7 _ _ NNP 40288 1937 8 32 32 CD 40288 1937 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1937 10 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1937 11 Mode Mode NNP 40288 1937 12 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1937 13 , , , 40288 1937 14 12 12 CD 40288 1937 15 , , , 40288 1937 16 13 13 CD 40288 1937 17 , , , 40288 1937 18 107 107 CD 40288 1937 19 Problems problem NNS 40288 1937 20 , , , 40288 1937 21 xix xix NN 40288 1937 22 . . . 40288 1938 1 20 20 CD 40288 1938 2 , , , 40288 1938 3 p. p. NN 40288 1938 4 919 919 CD 40288 1938 5 a a DT 40288 1938 6 13 13 CD 40288 1938 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1938 8 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1938 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1938 10 , , , 40288 1938 11 43 43 CD 40288 1938 12 , , , 40288 1938 13 82 82 CD 40288 1938 14 , , , 40288 1938 15 102 102 CD 40288 1938 16 , , , 40288 1938 17 107 107 CD 40288 1938 18 26 26 CD 40288 1938 19 , , , 40288 1938 20 p. p. NN 40288 1938 21 919 919 CD 40288 1938 22 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 23 b b NNP 40288 1938 24 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 25 21 21 CD 40288 1938 26 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1938 27 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1938 28 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1938 29 : : : 40288 1938 30 harmonia]=System harmonia]=System NNP 40288 1938 31 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1938 32 , , , 40288 1938 33 55 55 CD 40288 1938 34 33 33 CD 40288 1938 35 , , , 40288 1938 36 p. p. NN 40288 1938 37 920 920 CD 40288 1938 38 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 39 a a DT 40288 1938 40 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 41 19 19 CD 40288 1938 42 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1938 43 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1938 44 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1938 45 , , , 40288 1938 46 44 44 CD 40288 1938 47 36 36 CD 40288 1938 48 , , , 40288 1938 49 p. p. NN 40288 1938 50 920 920 CD 40288 1938 51 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 52 b b NNP 40288 1938 53 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 54 7 7 CD 40288 1938 55 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1938 56 Mesê Mesê NNP 40288 1938 57 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1938 58 , , , 40288 1938 59 44 44 CD 40288 1938 60 47 47 CD 40288 1938 61 , , , 40288 1938 62 p. p. NN 40288 1938 63 922 922 CD 40288 1938 64 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 65 b b NNP 40288 1938 66 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 67 3 3 CD 40288 1938 68 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1938 69 heptachord heptachord NNP 40288 1938 70 scales scales NNP 40288 1938 71 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1938 72 , , , 40288 1938 73 33 33 CD 40288 1938 74 48 48 CD 40288 1938 75 , , , 40288 1938 76 p. p. NN 40288 1938 77 922 922 CD 40288 1938 78 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 79 b b NNP 40288 1938 80 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 81 10 10 CD 40288 1938 82 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1938 83 modes mode NNS 40288 1938 84 used use VBN 40288 1938 85 by by IN 40288 1938 86 chorus chorus NNP 40288 1938 87 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1938 88 , , , 40288 1938 89 14 14 CD 40288 1938 90 49 49 CD 40288 1938 91 , , , 40288 1938 92 p. p. NN 40288 1938 93 922 922 CD 40288 1938 94 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 95 b b NNP 40288 1938 96 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 97 31 31 CD 40288 1938 98 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1938 99 high high JJ 40288 1938 100 and and CC 40288 1938 101 low low JJ 40288 1938 102 pitch pitch NN 40288 1938 103 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1938 104 , , , 40288 1938 105 15 15 CD 40288 1938 106 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 107 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40288 1938 108 _ _ NNP 40288 1938 109 , , , 40288 1938 110 iii iii NNP 40288 1938 111 . . . 40288 1939 1 1 1 CD 40288 1939 2 , , , 40288 1939 3 p. p. NN 40288 1939 4 1403 1403 CD 40288 1939 5 b b CD 40288 1939 6 27 27 CD 40288 1939 7 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1939 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1939 9 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1939 10 : : : 40288 1939 11 tonos tonos NN 40288 1939 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1939 13 and and CC 40288 1939 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1939 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1939 16 : : : 40288 1939 17 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 1939 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1939 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1939 20 , , , 40288 1939 21 15 15 CD 40288 1939 22 Aristoxenus Aristoxenus NNP 40288 1939 23 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1939 24 ed ed NN 40288 1939 25 . . . 40288 1940 1 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1940 2 . . . 40288 1941 1 ): ): LS 40288 1941 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1941 3 Harm Harm NNP 40288 1941 4 . . . 40288 1941 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1941 6 p. p. NN 40288 1941 7 2 2 CD 40288 1941 8 , , , 40288 1941 9 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 10 15 15 CD 40288 1941 11 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 12 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 1941 13 of of IN 40288 1941 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1941 15 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1941 16 : : : 40288 1941 17 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1941 18 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1941 19 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 20 , , , 40288 1941 21 49 49 CD 40288 1941 22 p. p. NN 40288 1941 23 3 3 CD 40288 1941 24 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 25 melody melody NN 40288 1941 26 of of IN 40288 1941 27 speech speech NN 40288 1941 28 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 29 , , , 40288 1941 30 115 115 CD 40288 1941 31 p. p. NN 40288 1941 32 6 6 CD 40288 1941 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 34 nomenclature nomenclature JJ 40288 1941 35 by by IN 40288 1941 36 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1941 37 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1941 38 : : : 40288 1941 39 thesis thesis NN 40288 1941 40 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1941 41 or or CC 40288 1941 42 position position NN 40288 1941 43 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 44 , , , 40288 1941 45 81 81 CD 40288 1941 46 p. p. NN 40288 1941 47 6 6 CD 40288 1941 48 , , , 40288 1941 49 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 50 20 20 CD 40288 1941 51 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 52 species specie NNS 40288 1941 53 of of IN 40288 1941 54 the the DT 40288 1941 55 Octave Octave NNP 40288 1941 56 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 57 , , , 40288 1941 58 50 50 CD 40288 1941 59 p. p. NN 40288 1941 60 8 8 CD 40288 1941 61 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 62 speaking speak VBG 40288 1941 63 and and CC 40288 1941 64 singing singing NN 40288 1941 65 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 66 , , , 40288 1941 67 115 115 CD 40288 1941 68 p. p. NN 40288 1941 69 8 8 CD 40288 1941 70 , , , 40288 1941 71 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 72 12 12 CD 40288 1941 73 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 74 perfect perfect JJ 40288 1941 75 System system NN 40288 1941 76 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 77 , , , 40288 1941 78 36 36 CD 40288 1941 79 p. p. NN 40288 1941 80 18 18 CD 40288 1941 81 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 82 melody melody NN 40288 1941 83 of of IN 40288 1941 84 speech speech NN 40288 1941 85 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 86 , , , 40288 1941 87 90 90 CD 40288 1941 88 , , , 40288 1941 89 115 115 CD 40288 1941 90 p. p. NN 40288 1941 91 23 23 CD 40288 1941 92 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 93 Chromatic Chromatic NNP 40288 1941 94 and and CC 40288 1941 95 Enharmonic Enharmonic NNP 40288 1941 96 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 97 , , , 40288 1941 98 110 110 CD 40288 1941 99 p. p. NN 40288 1941 100 26 26 CD 40288 1941 101 , , , 40288 1941 102 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 103 14 14 CD 40288 1941 104 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 105 Lichanos lichanos JJ 40288 1941 106 indefinite indefinite JJ 40288 1941 107 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 108 , , , 40288 1941 109 110 110 CD 40288 1941 110 p. p. NN 40288 1941 111 27 27 CD 40288 1941 112 , , , 40288 1941 113 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 114 34 34 CD 40288 1941 115 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 116 diagrams diagram NNS 40288 1941 117 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 118 , , , 40288 1941 119 52 52 CD 40288 1941 120 p. p. NN 40288 1941 121 36 36 CD 40288 1941 122 , , , 40288 1941 123 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 124 29 29 CD 40288 1941 125 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 126 seven seven CD 40288 1941 127 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1941 128 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1941 129 : : : 40288 1941 130 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1941 131 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1941 132 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 133 , , , 40288 1941 134 51 51 CD 40288 1941 135 , , , 40288 1941 136 54 54 CD 40288 1941 137 p. p. NN 40288 1941 138 37 37 CD 40288 1941 139 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 140 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1941 141 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1941 142 : : : 40288 1941 143 tonoi tonoi NNS 40288 1941 144 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1941 145 or or CC 40288 1941 146 keys key NNS 40288 1941 147 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 148 , , , 40288 1941 149 17 17 CD 40288 1941 150 - - SYM 40288 1941 151 19 19 CD 40288 1941 152 p. p. NN 40288 1941 153 48 48 CD 40288 1941 154 , , , 40288 1941 155 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 156 13 13 CD 40288 1941 157 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 158 Lichanos Lichanos NNP 40288 1941 159 indefinite indefinite JJ 40288 1941 160 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 161 , , , 40288 1941 162 110 110 CD 40288 1941 163 p. p. NN 40288 1941 164 69 69 CD 40288 1941 165 , , , 40288 1941 166 l. l. NNP 40288 1941 167 6 6 CD 40288 1941 168 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 169 nomenclature nomenclature JJ 40288 1941 170 by by IN 40288 1941 171 position position NN 40288 1941 172 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 173 , , , 40288 1941 174 81 81 CD 40288 1941 175 _ _ NNP 40288 1941 176 ibid ibid NN 40288 1941 177 . . . 40288 1941 178 _ _ NNP 40288 1941 179 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 180 indefinite indefinite NNP 40288 1941 181 element element NN 40288 1941 182 in in IN 40288 1941 183 music music NN 40288 1941 184 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1941 185 , , , 40288 1941 186 111 111 CD 40288 1941 187 Bacchius Bacchius NNP 40288 1941 188 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1941 189 ed ed NNP 40288 1941 190 . . . 40288 1942 1 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1942 2 . . . 40288 1943 1 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1943 2 , , , 40288 1943 3 p. p. NN 40288 1943 4 11 11 CD 40288 1943 5 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1943 6 topoi topoi NNP 40288 1943 7 tês tês NNP 40288 1943 8 phônês phônês NNP 40288 1943 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1943 10 , , , 40288 1943 11 65 65 CD 40288 1943 12 p. p. NN 40288 1943 13 19 19 CD 40288 1943 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1943 15 theseis theseis JJ 40288 1943 16 tetrachordôn tetrachordôn NN 40288 1943 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1943 18 , , , 40288 1943 19 82 82 CD 40288 1943 20 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40288 1943 21 Hal Hal NNP 40288 1943 22 . . . 40288 1944 1 : : : 40288 1944 2 c. c. NNP 40288 1944 3 11 11 CD 40288 1944 4 , , , 40288 1944 5 p. p. NN 40288 1944 6 58 58 CD 40288 1944 7 Reisk Reisk NNP 40288 1944 8 . . . 40288 1945 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1945 2 accent accent NN 40288 1945 3 and and CC 40288 1945 4 melody melody NN 40288 1945 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1945 6 , , , 40288 1945 7 90 90 CD 40288 1945 8 , , , 40288 1945 9 115 115 CD 40288 1945 10 c. c. NN 40288 1945 11 11 11 CD 40288 1945 12 , , , 40288 1945 13 p. p. NN 40288 1945 14 64 64 CD 40288 1945 15 Reisk Reisk NNP 40288 1945 16 . . . 40288 1946 1 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1946 2 rhythm rhythm NN 40288 1946 3 and and CC 40288 1946 4 quantity quantity NN 40288 1946 5 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1946 6 , , , 40288 1946 7 115 115 CD 40288 1946 8 Euclid Euclid NNP 40288 1946 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1946 10 ed ed NN 40288 1946 11 . . . 40288 1947 1 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1947 2 . . . 40288 1948 1 ): ): NNP 40288 1948 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1948 3 Introductio Introductio NNP 40288 1948 4 _ _ NNP 40288 1948 5 , , , 40288 1948 6 p. p. NN 40288 1948 7 19 19 CD 40288 1948 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1948 9 ten ten CD 40288 1948 10 - - HYPH 40288 1948 11 stringed stringed JJ 40288 1948 12 lyre lyre NN 40288 1948 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1948 14 , , , 40288 1948 15 38 38 CD 40288 1948 16 p. p. NN 40288 1948 17 20 20 CD 40288 1948 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1948 19 modulation modulation NN 40288 1948 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1948 21 , , , 40288 1948 22 104 104 CD 40288 1948 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1948 24 Sectio Sectio NNP 40288 1948 25 Canonis Canonis NNP 40288 1948 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1948 27 , , , 40288 1948 28 Prop Prop NNP 40288 1948 29 . . . 40288 1949 1 xvii xvii NNP 40288 1949 2 , , , 40288 1949 3 xviii xviii NNP 40288 1949 4 , , , 40288 1949 5 123 123 CD 40288 1949 6 Euripides Euripides NNP 40288 1949 7 , , , 40288 1949 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1949 9 Orest Orest NNP 40288 1949 10 . . . 40288 1949 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1949 12 338 338 CD 40288 1949 13 - - SYM 40288 1949 14 343 343 CD 40288 1949 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1949 16 musical musical JJ 40288 1949 17 setting setting NN 40288 1949 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1949 19 , , , 40288 1949 20 92 92 CD 40288 1949 21 , , , 40288 1949 22 130 130 CD 40288 1949 23 Heraclides Heraclides NNPS 40288 1949 24 Ponticus Ponticus NNP 40288 1949 25 ap ap NNP 40288 1949 26 . . . 40288 1950 1 Athen Athen NNP 40288 1950 2 . . . 40288 1951 1 xiv xiv NNP 40288 1951 2 . . . 40288 1952 1 pp pp NNP 40288 1952 2 . . . 40288 1953 1 624 624 CD 40288 1953 2 - - SYM 40288 1953 3 626 626 CD 40288 1953 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1953 5 modes mode NNS 40288 1953 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1953 7 , , , 40288 1953 8 9 9 CD 40288 1953 9 - - SYM 40288 1953 10 11 11 CD 40288 1953 11 , , , 40288 1953 12 76 76 CD 40288 1953 13 Lasus Lasus NNP 40288 1953 14 ap ap NNP 40288 1953 15 . . . 40288 1954 1 Athen Athen NNP 40288 1954 2 . . . 40288 1955 1 xiv xiv NNP 40288 1955 2 . . . 40288 1956 1 p. p. NN 40288 1956 2 624 624 CD 40288 1956 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1956 4 e e NNP 40288 1956 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1956 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1956 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1956 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1956 9 : : : 40288 1956 10 Aiolis Aiolis NNP 40288 1956 11 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 1956 12 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1956 13 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1956 14 , , , 40288 1956 15 6 6 CD 40288 1956 16 Nicomachus Nicomachus NNP 40288 1956 17 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1956 18 ed ed NN 40288 1956 19 . . . 40288 1957 1 Meib Meib NNP 40288 1957 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1957 3 , , , 40288 1957 4 p. p. NN 40288 1957 5 4 4 CD 40288 1957 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1957 7 speaking speaking NN 40288 1957 8 and and CC 40288 1957 9 singing singing NN 40288 1957 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1957 11 , , , 40288 1957 12 115 115 CD 40288 1957 13 p. p. NN 40288 1957 14 7 7 CD 40288 1957 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1957 16 heptachord heptachord NNP 40288 1957 17 scales scales NNP 40288 1957 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1957 19 , , , 40288 1957 20 34 34 CD 40288 1957 21 Pausanias Pausanias NNPS 40288 1957 22 , , , 40288 1957 23 iv iv NNP 40288 1957 24 . . . 40288 1958 1 27 27 CD 40288 1958 2 , , , 40288 1958 3 4 4 CD 40288 1958 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1958 5 Sacadas Sacadas NNP 40288 1958 6 and and CC 40288 1958 7 Pronomus Pronomus NNP 40288 1958 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1958 9 , , , 40288 1958 10 75 75 CD 40288 1958 11 Pherecrates Pherecrates NNPS 40288 1958 12 ap ap VBP 40288 1958 13 . . . 40288 1959 1 Plut Plut NNP 40288 1959 2 . . . 40288 1960 1 _ _ NNP 40288 1960 2 de de NNP 40288 1960 3 Mus Mus NNP 40288 1960 4 . . . 40288 1960 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1960 6 c. c. NNP 40288 1960 7 30 30 CD 40288 1960 8 , , , 40288 1960 9 38 38 CD 40288 1960 10 Pindar Pindar NNP 40288 1960 11 , , , 40288 1960 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1960 13 Nem Nem NNP 40288 1960 14 . . NNP 40288 1960 15 _ _ NNP 40288 1960 16 iv iv NNP 40288 1960 17 . . . 40288 1961 1 45 45 CD 40288 1961 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 3 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1961 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 5 , , , 40288 1961 6 7 7 CD 40288 1961 7 Plato Plato NNP 40288 1961 8 : : : 40288 1961 9 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 10 Phileb Phileb NNP 40288 1961 11 . . . 40288 1961 12 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 13 p. p. NN 40288 1961 14 17 17 CD 40288 1961 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 16 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1961 17 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1961 18 : : : 40288 1961 19 harmonia harmonia NN 40288 1961 20 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1961 21 = = NFP 40288 1961 22 System system NN 40288 1961 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 24 , , , 40288 1961 25 55 55 CD 40288 1961 26 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 27 Laches Laches NNP 40288 1961 28 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 29 , , , 40288 1961 30 p. p. NN 40288 1961 31 188 188 CD 40288 1961 32 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 33 Dorian dorian JJ 40288 1961 34 , , , 40288 1961 35 Ionian ionian JJ 40288 1961 36 , , , 40288 1961 37 Phrygian phrygian JJ 40288 1961 38 , , , 40288 1961 39 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1961 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 41 , , , 40288 1961 42 8 8 CD 40288 1961 43 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 44 Repub Repub NNP 40288 1961 45 . . . 40288 1961 46 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 47 p. p. NN 40288 1961 48 398 398 CD 40288 1961 49 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 50 use use NN 40288 1961 51 of of IN 40288 1961 52 modes mode NNS 40288 1961 53 in in IN 40288 1961 54 education education NN 40288 1961 55 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 56 , , , 40288 1961 57 7 7 CD 40288 1961 58 , , , 40288 1961 59 8 8 CD 40288 1961 60 p. p. NN 40288 1961 61 399 399 CD 40288 1961 62 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 63 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1961 64 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1961 65 : : : 40288 1961 66 aulos aulos NNP 40288 1961 67 -- -- : 40288 1961 68 poluchordia poluchordia NNP 40288 1961 69 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1961 70 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 71 . . . 40288 1961 72 , , , 40288 1961 73 39 39 CD 40288 1961 74 , , , 40288 1961 75 41 41 CD 40288 1961 76 p. p. NN 40288 1961 77 531 531 CD 40288 1961 78 A a DT 40288 1961 79 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 80 study study NN 40288 1961 81 of of IN 40288 1961 82 music music NN 40288 1961 83 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 84 , , , 40288 1961 85 53 53 CD 40288 1961 86 , , , 40288 1961 87 123 123 CD 40288 1961 88 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 89 Laws Laws NNPS 40288 1961 90 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 91 , , , 40288 1961 92 p. p. NN 40288 1961 93 669 669 CD 40288 1961 94 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 95 instrumental instrumental JJ 40288 1961 96 music music NN 40288 1961 97 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 98 , , , 40288 1961 99 120 120 CD 40288 1961 100 p. p. NN 40288 1961 101 812 812 CD 40288 1961 102 D d NN 40288 1961 103 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 104 harmony harmony NN 40288 1961 105 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 106 , , , 40288 1961 107 122 122 CD 40288 1961 108 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40288 1961 109 : : : 40288 1961 110 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 111 De De NNP 40288 1961 112 Musica Musica NNP 40288 1961 113 _ _ NNP 40288 1961 114 , , , 40288 1961 115 c. c. NNP 40288 1961 116 6 6 CD 40288 1961 117 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1961 118 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1961 119 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1961 120 : : : 40288 1961 121 harmoniai harmoniai NN 40288 1961 122 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1961 123 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1961 124 , , , 40288 1961 125 25 25 CD 40288 1961 126 cc cc NN 40288 1961 127 . . . 40288 1962 1 15 15 CD 40288 1962 2 - - SYM 40288 1962 3 17 17 CD 40288 1962 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1962 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40288 1962 6 modes mode NNS 40288 1962 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1962 8 , , , 40288 1962 9 21 21 CD 40288 1962 10 - - SYM 40288 1962 11 25 25 CD 40288 1962 12 , , , 40288 1962 13 103 103 CD 40288 1962 14 c. c. NN 40288 1962 15 19 19 CD 40288 1962 16 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1962 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1962 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1962 19 : : : 40288 1962 20 tonos tonos NN 40288 1962 21 , , , 40288 1962 22 harmonia harmonia NNP 40288 1962 23 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1962 24 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1962 25 , , , 40288 1962 26 26 26 CD 40288 1962 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1962 28 De De NNP 40288 1962 29 gener gener NNP 40288 1962 30 . . . 40288 1963 1 Mundi Mundi NNP 40288 1963 2 _ _ NNP 40288 1963 3 , , , 40288 1963 4 p. p. NN 40288 1963 5 1029 1029 CD 40288 1963 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1963 7 c c NNP 40288 1963 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1963 9 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1963 10 Proslambanomenos Proslambanomenos NNP 40288 1963 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1963 12 , , , 40288 1963 13 39 39 CD 40288 1963 14 Pollux Pollux NNP 40288 1963 15 , , , 40288 1963 16 _ _ NNP 40288 1963 17 Onom Onom NNP 40288 1963 18 . . . 40288 1963 19 _ _ NNP 40288 1963 20 iv iv NNP 40288 1963 21 . . . 40288 1964 1 78 78 CD 40288 1964 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1964 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1964 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1964 5 : : : 40288 1964 6 harmoniai harmoniai NNP 40288 1964 7 aulêtikai aulêtikai NNP 40288 1964 8 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1964 9 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1964 10 , , , 40288 1964 11 22 22 CD 40288 1964 12 , , , 40288 1964 13 28 28 CD 40288 1964 14 Pratinas Pratinas NNP 40288 1964 15 ap ap VBD 40288 1964 16 . . . 40288 1965 1 Athen Athen NNP 40288 1965 2 . . . 40288 1966 1 xiv xiv NNP 40288 1966 2 . . . 40288 1967 1 p. p. NN 40288 1967 2 624 624 CD 40288 1967 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1967 4 f f NNP 40288 1967 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1967 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1967 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1967 8 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1967 9 : : : 40288 1967 10 mête mête NNP 40288 1967 11 syntonon syntonon NNP 40288 1967 12 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 40288 1967 13 . . . 40288 1968 1 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1968 2 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1968 3 , , , 40288 1968 4 5 5 CD 40288 1968 5 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 40288 1968 6 : : : 40288 1968 7 Harm harm NN 40288 1968 8 . . . 40288 1969 1 i. i. NNP 40288 1970 1 13 13 CD 40288 1970 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1970 3 musical musical JJ 40288 1970 4 ratios ratio NNS 40288 1970 5 of of IN 40288 1970 6 Archytas Archytas NNP 40288 1970 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1970 8 , , , 40288 1970 9 123 123 CD 40288 1970 10 i. i. NN 40288 1971 1 16 16 CD 40288 1971 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1971 3 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1971 4 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1971 5 : : : 40288 1971 6 hêgemôn]=highest hêgemôn]=highest JJ 40288 1971 7 note note NN 40288 1971 8 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1971 9 , , , 40288 1971 10 45 45 CD 40288 1971 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1971 12 ibid ibid NN 40288 1971 13 . . . 40288 1971 14 _ _ NNP 40288 1971 15 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1971 16 scales scale NNS 40288 1971 17 of of IN 40288 1971 18 the the DT 40288 1971 19 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1971 20 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1971 21 , , , 40288 1971 22 84 84 CD 40288 1971 23 - - SYM 40288 1971 24 86 86 CD 40288 1971 25 , , , 40288 1971 26 102 102 CD 40288 1971 27 , , , 40288 1971 28 123 123 CD 40288 1971 29 _ _ NNP 40288 1971 30 ibid ibid NN 40288 1971 31 . . . 40288 1971 32 _ _ NNP 40288 1971 33 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1971 34 Pythagorean Pythagorean NNP 40288 1971 35 division division NN 40288 1971 36 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1971 37 , , , 40288 1971 38 87 87 CD 40288 1971 39 ii ii NN 40288 1971 40 . . . 40288 1972 1 6 6 CD 40288 1972 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1972 3 modulation modulation NN 40288 1972 4 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1972 5 , , , 40288 1972 6 67 67 CD 40288 1972 7 ii ii NN 40288 1972 8 . . . 40288 1973 1 7 7 LS 40288 1973 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1973 3 pitch pitch NN 40288 1973 4 of of IN 40288 1973 5 scales scales NNP 40288 1973 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1973 7 , , , 40288 1973 8 80 80 CD 40288 1973 9 ii ii NN 40288 1973 10 . . . 40288 1974 1 16 16 CD 40288 1974 2 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1974 3 scales scale NNS 40288 1974 4 of of IN 40288 1974 5 the the DT 40288 1974 6 cithara cithara NNP 40288 1974 7 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1974 8 , , , 40288 1974 9 84 84 CD 40288 1974 10 - - SYM 40288 1974 11 86 86 CD 40288 1974 12 , , , 40288 1974 13 102 102 CD 40288 1974 14 Seikelos Seikelos NNP 40288 1974 15 inscription inscription NN 40288 1974 16 , , , 40288 1974 17 89 89 CD 40288 1974 18 , , , 40288 1974 19 132 132 CD 40288 1974 20 Telestes teleste NNS 40288 1974 21 ap ap NNP 40288 1974 22 . . . 40288 1975 1 Athen Athen NNP 40288 1975 2 . . . 40288 1976 1 xiv xiv NNP 40288 1976 2 . . . 40288 1977 1 p. p. NN 40288 1977 2 625 625 CD 40288 1977 3 _ _ NNP 40288 1977 4 f f NNP 40288 1977 5 _ _ NNP 40288 1977 6 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1977 7 Phrygian Phrygian NNP 40288 1977 8 and and CC 40288 1977 9 Lydian Lydian NNP 40288 1977 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1977 11 , , , 40288 1977 12 6 6 CD 40288 1977 13 Theon Theon NNP 40288 1977 14 Smyrnaeus Smyrnaeus NNP 40288 1977 15 , , , 40288 1977 16 c. c. NNP 40288 1977 17 8 8 CD 40288 1977 18 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1977 19 enlargement enlargement NN 40288 1977 20 of of IN 40288 1977 21 scale scale NN 40288 1977 22 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1977 23 , , , 40288 1977 24 37 37 CD 40288 1977 25 THE the DT 40288 1977 26 END END NNP 40288 1977 27 _ _ NNP 40288 1977 28 Note Note NNP 40288 1977 29 on on IN 40288 1977 30 the the DT 40288 1977 31 Seikilos Seikilos NNP 40288 1977 32 Inscription Inscription NNP 40288 1977 33 _ _ NNP 40288 1977 34 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1977 35 pp pp NNP 40288 1977 36 . . . 40288 1978 1 89 89 CD 40288 1978 2 - - SYM 40288 1978 3 91 91 CD 40288 1978 4 , , , 40288 1978 5 133 133 CD 40288 1978 6 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1978 7 . . . 40288 1979 1 Since since IN 40288 1979 2 the the DT 40288 1979 3 publication publication NN 40288 1979 4 of of IN 40288 1979 5 this this DT 40288 1979 6 work work NN 40288 1979 7 , , , 40288 1979 8 the the DT 40288 1979 9 Seikilos Seikilos NNP 40288 1979 10 inscription inscription NN 40288 1979 11 has have VBZ 40288 1979 12 been be VBN 40288 1979 13 examined examine VBN 40288 1979 14 afresh afresh RB 40288 1979 15 by by IN 40288 1979 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 40288 1979 17 J. J. NNP 40288 1980 1 A. A. NNP 40288 1980 2 R. R. NNP 40288 1980 3 Munro Munro NNP 40288 1980 4 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1980 5 of of IN 40288 1980 6 Lincoln Lincoln NNP 40288 1980 7 College College NNP 40288 1980 8 , , , 40288 1980 9 Oxford Oxford NNP 40288 1980 10 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1980 11 . . . 40288 1981 1 The the DT 40288 1981 2 result result NN 40288 1981 3 of of IN 40288 1981 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1981 5 examination examination NN 40288 1981 6 is be VBZ 40288 1981 7 to to TO 40288 1981 8 show show VB 40288 1981 9 that that IN 40288 1981 10 the the DT 40288 1981 11 last last JJ 40288 1981 12 note note NN 40288 1981 13 of of IN 40288 1981 14 the the DT 40288 1981 15 melody melody NN 40288 1981 16 has have VBZ 40288 1981 17 been be VBN 40288 1981 18 misread misread JJ 40288 1981 19 . . . 40288 1982 1 From from IN 40288 1982 2 a a DT 40288 1982 3 squeeze squeeze NN 40288 1982 4 which which WDT 40288 1982 5 he -PRON- PRP 40288 1982 6 has have VBZ 40288 1982 7 kindly kindly RB 40288 1982 8 placed place VBN 40288 1982 9 at at IN 40288 1982 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1982 11 disposal disposal NN 40288 1982 12 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1982 13 appears appear VBZ 40288 1982 14 that that IN 40288 1982 15 the the DT 40288 1982 16 word word NN 40288 1982 17 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1982 18 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1982 19 : : : 40288 1982 20 apaitei apaitei NN 40288 1982 21 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1982 22 is be VBZ 40288 1982 23 written-- written-- NNP 40288 1982 24 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1982 25 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1982 26 : : : 40288 1982 27 c c LS 40288 1982 28 x x NN 40288 1982 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1982 30 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1982 31 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1982 32 : : : 40288 1982 33 APAITEI apaitei LS 40288 1982 34 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1982 35 The the DT 40288 1982 36 line line NN 40288 1982 37 drawn draw VBN 40288 1982 38 under under IN 40288 1982 39 the the DT 40288 1982 40 three three CD 40288 1982 41 notes note NNS 40288 1982 42 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1982 43 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1982 44 : : : 40288 1982 45 C C NNP 40288 1982 46 X x NN 40288 1982 47 I i NN 40288 1982 48 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1982 49 has have VBZ 40288 1982 50 caused cause VBN 40288 1982 51 the the DT 40288 1982 52 last last JJ 40288 1982 53 to to TO 40288 1982 54 be be VB 40288 1982 55 read read VBN 40288 1982 56 as as IN 40288 1982 57 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1982 58 Symbol symbol NN 40288 1982 59 : : : 40288 1982 60 3 3 LS 40288 1982 61 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1982 62 , , , 40288 1982 63 which which WDT 40288 1982 64 has have VBZ 40288 1982 65 no no DT 40288 1982 66 meaning meaning NN 40288 1982 67 here here RB 40288 1982 68 . . . 40288 1983 1 In in IN 40288 1983 2 fact fact NN 40288 1983 3 it -PRON- PRP 40288 1983 4 is be VBZ 40288 1983 5 a a DT 40288 1983 6 reversed reversed JJ 40288 1983 7 Gamma gamma NN 40288 1983 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1983 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1983 10 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1983 11 : : : 40288 1983 12 g g NNP 40288 1983 13 apestrammenon apestrammenon NNP 40288 1983 14 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1983 15 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1983 16 , , , 40288 1983 17 and and CC 40288 1983 18 answers answer NNS 40288 1983 19 to to IN 40288 1983 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1983 21 _ _ NNP 40288 1983 22 e e NNP 40288 1983 23 _ _ NNP 40288 1983 24 natural natural NN 40288 1983 25 . . . 40288 1984 1 Hence hence RB 40288 1984 2 the the DT 40288 1984 3 last last JJ 40288 1984 4 line line NN 40288 1984 5 of of IN 40288 1984 6 the the DT 40288 1984 7 transcription transcription NN 40288 1984 8 on on IN 40288 1984 9 pp pp NNP 40288 1984 10 . . . 40288 1985 1 89 89 CD 40288 1985 2 - - SYM 40288 1985 3 90 90 CD 40288 1985 4 should should MD 40288 1985 5 be be VB 40288 1985 6 as as IN 40288 1985 7 follows follow VBZ 40288 1985 8 : : : 40288 1985 9 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1985 10 Music music NN 40288 1985 11 : : : 40288 1985 12 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1985 13 Greek Greek NNP 40288 1985 14 : : : 40288 1985 15 to to IN 40288 1985 16 te te NNP 40288 1985 17 - - HYPH 40288 1985 18 los los NNP 40288 1985 19 ho ho NNP 40288 1985 20 chro chro NNP 40288 1985 21 - - HYPH 40288 1985 22 nos nos NNP 40288 1985 23 a a DT 40288 1985 24 - - HYPH 40288 1985 25 pai pai NNP 40288 1985 26 -- -- : 40288 1985 27 tei tei NN 40288 1985 28 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1985 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1985 30 The the DT 40288 1985 31 importance importance NN 40288 1985 32 of of IN 40288 1985 33 this this DT 40288 1985 34 correction correction NN 40288 1985 35 is be VBZ 40288 1985 36 obvious obvious JJ 40288 1985 37 . . . 40288 1986 1 The the DT 40288 1986 2 scale scale NN 40288 1986 3 employed employ VBN 40288 1986 4 is be VBZ 40288 1986 5 now now RB 40288 1986 6 seen see VBN 40288 1986 7 to to TO 40288 1986 8 be be VB 40288 1986 9 the the DT 40288 1986 10 octave-- octave-- NNP 40288 1986 11 _ _ NNP 40288 1986 12 e e NNP 40288 1986 13 f f NNP 40288 1986 14 # # NNP 40288 1986 15 g g NNP 40288 1986 16 a a DT 40288 1986 17 b b NN 40288 1986 18 c c NN 40288 1986 19 # # NN 40288 1986 20 d d NN 40288 1986 21 e e NN 40288 1986 22 _ _ XX 40288 1986 23 If if IN 40288 1986 24 , , , 40288 1986 25 as as IN 40288 1986 26 I -PRON- PRP 40288 1986 27 ventured venture VBD 40288 1986 28 to to TO 40288 1986 29 suggest suggest VB 40288 1986 30 on on IN 40288 1986 31 p. p. NN 40288 1986 32 90 90 CD 40288 1986 33 , , , 40288 1986 34 the the DT 40288 1986 35 mode mode NN 40288 1986 36 is be VBZ 40288 1986 37 the the DT 40288 1986 38 Hypo Hypo NNP 40288 1986 39 - - HYPH 40288 1986 40 phrygian phrygian NNP 40288 1986 41 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1986 42 the the DT 40288 1986 43 scale scale NN 40288 1986 44 of of IN 40288 1986 45 our -PRON- PRP$ 40288 1986 46 Major major JJ 40288 1986 47 mode mode NN 40288 1986 48 , , , 40288 1986 49 but but CC 40288 1986 50 with with IN 40288 1986 51 a a DT 40288 1986 52 flat flat JJ 40288 1986 53 Seventh Seventh NNP 40288 1986 54 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1986 55 , , , 40288 1986 56 the the DT 40288 1986 57 key key NN 40288 1986 58 - - HYPH 40288 1986 59 note note NN 40288 1986 60 will will MD 40288 1986 61 be be VB 40288 1986 62 _ _ NNP 40288 1986 63 a a DT 40288 1986 64 _ _ NNP 40288 1986 65 . . . 40288 1987 1 The the DT 40288 1987 2 close close NN 40288 1987 3 on on IN 40288 1987 4 the the DT 40288 1987 5 Dominant Dominant NNP 40288 1987 6 _ _ NNP 40288 1987 7 e e NNP 40288 1987 8 _ _ NNP 40288 1987 9 will will MD 40288 1987 10 then then RB 40288 1987 11 have have VB 40288 1987 12 to to TO 40288 1987 13 be be VB 40288 1987 14 noted note VBN 40288 1987 15 as as IN 40288 1987 16 a a DT 40288 1987 17 fact fact NN 40288 1987 18 supporting support VBG 40288 1987 19 the the DT 40288 1987 20 belief belief NN 40288 1987 21 that that IN 40288 1987 22 in in IN 40288 1987 23 Greek greek JJ 40288 1987 24 music music NN 40288 1987 25 the the DT 40288 1987 26 close close NN 40288 1987 27 on on IN 40288 1987 28 the the DT 40288 1987 29 Dominant Dominant NNP 40288 1987 30 or or CC 40288 1987 31 Hypatê Hypatê NNP 40288 1987 32 was be VBD 40288 1987 33 the the DT 40288 1987 34 usual usual JJ 40288 1987 35 one one NN 40288 1987 36 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1987 37 see see VB 40288 1987 38 p. p. NN 40288 1987 39 45 45 CD 40288 1987 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1987 41 . . . 40288 1988 1 The the DT 40288 1988 2 line line NN 40288 1988 3 drawn draw VBN 40288 1988 4 under under IN 40288 1988 5 the the DT 40288 1988 6 three three CD 40288 1988 7 symbols symbol NNS 40288 1988 8 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1988 9 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1988 10 : : : 40288 1988 11 C C NNP 40288 1988 12 N1 N1 NNP 40288 1988 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1988 14 is be VBZ 40288 1988 15 found find VBN 40288 1988 16 in in IN 40288 1988 17 several several JJ 40288 1988 18 other other JJ 40288 1988 19 cases case NNS 40288 1988 20 where where WRB 40288 1988 21 the the DT 40288 1988 22 melody melody NN 40288 1988 23 gives give VBZ 40288 1988 24 more more JJR 40288 1988 25 than than IN 40288 1988 26 one one CD 40288 1988 27 note note NN 40288 1988 28 for for IN 40288 1988 29 a a DT 40288 1988 30 syllable syllable NN 40288 1988 31 . . . 40288 1989 1 So so RB 40288 1989 2 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1989 3 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1989 4 : : : 40288 1989 5 1 1 CD 40288 1989 6 K k NN 40288 1989 7 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1989 8 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1989 9 l. l. NNP 40288 1989 10 2 2 CD 40288 1989 11 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1989 12 , , , 40288 1989 13 and and CC 40288 1989 14 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1989 15 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1989 16 : : : 40288 1989 17 04 04 CD 40288 1989 18 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1989 19 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1989 20 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1989 21 l. l. NNP 40288 1989 22 3 3 CD 40288 1989 23 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1989 24 , , , 40288 1989 25 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1989 26 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1989 27 : : : 40288 1989 28 K1 k1 NN 40288 1989 29 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1989 30 and and CC 40288 1989 31 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1989 32 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1989 33 : : : 40288 1989 34 04 04 CD 40288 1989 35 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1989 36 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1989 37 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1989 38 l. l. NNP 40288 1989 39 4 4 CD 40288 1989 40 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1989 41 . . . 40288 1990 1 It -PRON- PRP 40288 1990 2 does do VBZ 40288 1990 3 not not RB 40288 1990 4 appear appear VB 40288 1990 5 however however RB 40288 1990 6 under under IN 40288 1990 7 [ [ -LRB- 40288 1990 8 Symbols symbol NNS 40288 1990 9 : : : 40288 1990 10 K K NNP 40288 1990 11 I I NNP 40288 1990 12 Z Z NNP 40288 1990 13 ] ] -RRB- 40288 1990 14 ( ( -LRB- 40288 1990 15 l. l. NNP 40288 1990 16 1 1 CD 40288 1990 17 ) ) -RRB- 40288 1990 18 . . . 40288 1991 1 D. D. NNP 40288 1991 2 B. B. NNP 40288 1991 3 M. M. NNP