id sid tid token lemma pos 19768 1 1 file file NN 19768 1 2 was be VBD 19768 1 3 produced produce VBN 19768 1 4 from from IN 19768 1 5 images image NNS 19768 1 6 generously generously RB 19768 1 7 made make VBN 19768 1 8 available available JJ 19768 1 9 by by IN 19768 1 10 Case Case NNP 19768 1 11 Western Western NNP 19768 1 12 Reserve Reserve NNP 19768 1 13 University University NNP 19768 1 14 Preservation Preservation NNP 19768 1 15 Department Department NNP 19768 1 16 Digital Digital NNP 19768 1 17 Library Library NNP 19768 1 18 . . . 19768 1 19 ) ) -RRB- 19768 2 1 PROFESSOR PROFESSOR NNP 19768 2 2 ROYCE ROYCE NNP 19768 2 3 'S 's POS 19768 2 4 LIBEL LIBEL NNP 19768 2 5 . . . 19768 3 1 * * NFP 19768 3 2 * * NFP 19768 3 3 * * NFP 19768 3 4 * * NFP 19768 3 5 * * NFP 19768 3 6 A a DT 19768 3 7 PUBLIC public NN 19768 3 8 APPEAL APPEAL VBZ 19768 3 9 FOR for IN 19768 3 10 REDRESS REDRESS NNP 19768 3 11 TO to IN 19768 3 12 THE the DT 19768 3 13 CORPORATION CORPORATION NNP 19768 3 14 AND and CC 19768 3 15 OVERSEERS OVERSEERS NNPS 19768 3 16 OF of IN 19768 3 17 HARVARD HARVARD NNP 19768 3 18 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 19768 3 19 . . . 19768 4 1 BY by IN 19768 4 2 FRANCIS FRANCIS NNP 19768 4 3 ELLINGWOOD ELLINGWOOD NNP 19768 4 4 ABBOT ABBOT NNP 19768 4 5 , , , 19768 4 6 PH.D. PH.D. NNP 19768 4 7 CAMBRIDGE CAMBRIDGE NNP 19768 4 8 , , , 19768 4 9 MASS MASS NNP 19768 4 10 . . . 19768 5 1 * * NFP 19768 5 2 * * NFP 19768 5 3 * * NFP 19768 5 4 * * NFP 19768 5 5 * * NFP 19768 5 6 BOSTON BOSTON NNP 19768 5 7 , , , 19768 5 8 MASS MASS NNP 19768 5 9 . . . 19768 6 1 GEO GEO NNP 19768 6 2 . . . 19768 7 1 H. H. NNP 19768 7 2 ELLIS ELLIS NNP 19768 7 3 , , , 19768 7 4 141 141 CD 19768 7 5 FRANKLIN FRANKLIN NNP 19768 7 6 STREET STREET NNP 19768 7 7 , , , 19768 7 8 1891 1891 CD 19768 7 9 . . . 19768 8 1 PUBLIC PUBLIC NNP 19768 8 2 APPEAL APPEAL NNP 19768 8 3 . . . 19768 9 1 TO to IN 19768 9 2 THE the DT 19768 9 3 PRESIDENT PRESIDENT NNP 19768 9 4 AND and CC 19768 9 5 FELLOWS FELLOWS NNP 19768 9 6 AND and CC 19768 9 7 BOARD BOARD NNP 19768 9 8 OF of IN 19768 9 9 OVERSEERS OVERSEERS NNP 19768 9 10 OF of IN 19768 9 11 HARVARD HARVARD NNP 19768 9 12 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 19768 9 13 : : : 19768 9 14 _ _ NNP 19768 9 15 Gentlemen_,--Believing Gentlemen_,--Believing NNP 19768 9 16 it -PRON- PRP 19768 9 17 to to TO 19768 9 18 be be VB 19768 9 19 a a DT 19768 9 20 necessary necessary JJ 19768 9 21 part part NN 19768 9 22 of of IN 19768 9 23 good good JJ 19768 9 24 citizenship citizenship NN 19768 9 25 to to TO 19768 9 26 defend defend VB 19768 9 27 one one NN 19768 9 28 's 's POS 19768 9 29 reputation reputation NN 19768 9 30 against against IN 19768 9 31 unjustifiable unjustifiable JJ 19768 9 32 attacks attack NNS 19768 9 33 , , , 19768 9 34 and and CC 19768 9 35 believing believe VBG 19768 9 36 you -PRON- PRP 19768 9 37 to to TO 19768 9 38 have have VB 19768 9 39 been be VBN 19768 9 40 unwarrantably unwarrantably RB 19768 9 41 , , , 19768 9 42 but but CC 19768 9 43 not not RB 19768 9 44 remotely remotely RB 19768 9 45 , , , 19768 9 46 implicated implicate VBN 19768 9 47 in in IN 19768 9 48 an an DT 19768 9 49 unjustifiable unjustifiable JJ 19768 9 50 attack attack NN 19768 9 51 upon upon IN 19768 9 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 9 53 own own JJ 19768 9 54 reputation reputation NN 19768 9 55 by by IN 19768 9 56 Assistant Assistant NNP 19768 9 57 Professor Professor NNP 19768 9 58 Josiah Josiah NNP 19768 9 59 Royce Royce NNP 19768 9 60 , , , 19768 9 61 since since IN 19768 9 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 9 63 attack attack NN 19768 9 64 is be VBZ 19768 9 65 made make VBN 19768 9 66 publicly publicly RB 19768 9 67 , , , 19768 9 68 explicitly explicitly RB 19768 9 69 , , , 19768 9 70 and and CC 19768 9 71 emphatically emphatically RB 19768 9 72 on on IN 19768 9 73 the the DT 19768 9 74 authority authority NN 19768 9 75 of of IN 19768 9 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 9 77 " " `` 19768 9 78 professional professional JJ 19768 9 79 " " '' 19768 9 80 position position NN 19768 9 81 as as IN 19768 9 82 one one CD 19768 9 83 of of IN 19768 9 84 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 9 85 agents agent NNS 19768 9 86 and and CC 19768 9 87 appointees appointee NNS 19768 9 88 , , , 19768 9 89 I -PRON- PRP 19768 9 90 respectfully respectfully RB 19768 9 91 apply apply VBP 19768 9 92 to to IN 19768 9 93 you -PRON- PRP 19768 9 94 for for IN 19768 9 95 redress redress NN 19768 9 96 of of IN 19768 9 97 the the DT 19768 9 98 wrong wrong NN 19768 9 99 , , , 19768 9 100 leaving leave VBG 19768 9 101 it -PRON- PRP 19768 9 102 wholly wholly RB 19768 9 103 to to IN 19768 9 104 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 9 105 own own JJ 19768 9 106 wisdom wisdom NN 19768 9 107 and and CC 19768 9 108 sense sense NN 19768 9 109 of of IN 19768 9 110 justice justice NN 19768 9 111 to to TO 19768 9 112 decide decide VB 19768 9 113 what what WDT 19768 9 114 form form NN 19768 9 115 such such JJ 19768 9 116 redress redress NN 19768 9 117 should should MD 19768 9 118 take take VB 19768 9 119 . . . 19768 10 1 If if IN 19768 10 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 10 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 10 4 had have VBD 19768 10 5 not not RB 19768 10 6 , , , 19768 10 7 by by IN 19768 10 8 clear clear JJ 19768 10 9 and and CC 19768 10 10 undeniable undeniable JJ 19768 10 11 implication implication NN 19768 10 12 , , , 19768 10 13 appealed appeal VBD 19768 10 14 to to IN 19768 10 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 10 16 high high JJ 19768 10 17 sanction sanction NN 19768 10 18 to to TO 19768 10 19 sustain sustain VB 19768 10 20 him -PRON- PRP 19768 10 21 in in IN 19768 10 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 10 23 attack,--if attack,--if NN 19768 10 24 he -PRON- PRP 19768 10 25 had have VBD 19768 10 26 not not RB 19768 10 27 undeniably undeniably RB 19768 10 28 sought seek VBN 19768 10 29 to to TO 19768 10 30 create create VB 19768 10 31 a a DT 19768 10 32 widespread widespread JJ 19768 10 33 but but CC 19768 10 34 false false JJ 19768 10 35 public public JJ 19768 10 36 impression impression NN 19768 10 37 that that IN 19768 10 38 , , , 19768 10 39 in in IN 19768 10 40 making make VBG 19768 10 41 this this DT 19768 10 42 attack attack NN 19768 10 43 , , , 19768 10 44 he -PRON- PRP 19768 10 45 spoke speak VBD 19768 10 46 , , , 19768 10 47 and and CC 19768 10 48 had have VBD 19768 10 49 a a DT 19768 10 50 right right NN 19768 10 51 to to TO 19768 10 52 speak speak VB 19768 10 53 , , , 19768 10 54 with with IN 19768 10 55 all all PDT 19768 10 56 the the DT 19768 10 57 prestige prestige NN 19768 10 58 and and CC 19768 10 59 authority authority NN 19768 10 60 of of IN 19768 10 61 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 10 62 University University NNP 19768 10 63 itself,--I itself,--I NNS 19768 10 64 should should MD 19768 10 65 not not RB 19768 10 66 have have VB 19768 10 67 deemed deem VBN 19768 10 68 it -PRON- PRP 19768 10 69 either either CC 19768 10 70 necessary necessary JJ 19768 10 71 or or CC 19768 10 72 becoming become VBG 19768 10 73 to to TO 19768 10 74 appeal appeal VB 19768 10 75 to to IN 19768 10 76 you -PRON- PRP 19768 10 77 in in IN 19768 10 78 self self NN 19768 10 79 - - HYPH 19768 10 80 defence defence NN 19768 10 81 , , , 19768 10 82 or or CC 19768 10 83 , , , 19768 10 84 indeed indeed RB 19768 10 85 , , , 19768 10 86 to to TO 19768 10 87 take take VB 19768 10 88 any any DT 19768 10 89 public public JJ 19768 10 90 notice notice NN 19768 10 91 whatever whatever WDT 19768 10 92 of of IN 19768 10 93 an an DT 19768 10 94 attack attack NN 19768 10 95 otherwise otherwise RB 19768 10 96 unworthy unworthy JJ 19768 10 97 of of IN 19768 10 98 it -PRON- PRP 19768 10 99 . . . 19768 11 1 But but CC 19768 11 2 under under IN 19768 11 3 the the DT 19768 11 4 circumstances circumstance NNS 19768 11 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 11 6 am be VBP 19768 11 7 confident confident JJ 19768 11 8 that that IN 19768 11 9 you -PRON- PRP 19768 11 10 will will MD 19768 11 11 at at IN 19768 11 12 once once RB 19768 11 13 recognize recognize VB 19768 11 14 the the DT 19768 11 15 inevitableness inevitableness NN 19768 11 16 and and CC 19768 11 17 unquestionable unquestionable JJ 19768 11 18 propriety propriety NN 19768 11 19 of of IN 19768 11 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 11 21 appeal appeal NN 19768 11 22 from from IN 19768 11 23 the the DT 19768 11 24 employee employee NN 19768 11 25 to to IN 19768 11 26 the the DT 19768 11 27 employer employer NN 19768 11 28 , , , 19768 11 29 from from IN 19768 11 30 the the DT 19768 11 31 agent agent NN 19768 11 32 to to IN 19768 11 33 the the DT 19768 11 34 principal principal NN 19768 11 35 ; ; : 19768 11 36 and and CC 19768 11 37 it -PRON- PRP 19768 11 38 would would MD 19768 11 39 be be VB 19768 11 40 disrespectful disrespectful JJ 19768 11 41 to to IN 19768 11 42 you -PRON- PRP 19768 11 43 to to TO 19768 11 44 doubt doubt VB 19768 11 45 for for IN 19768 11 46 a a DT 19768 11 47 moment moment NN 19768 11 48 that that WDT 19768 11 49 , , , 19768 11 50 disapproving disapprove VBG 19768 11 51 of of IN 19768 11 52 an an DT 19768 11 53 attack attack NN 19768 11 54 made make VBN 19768 11 55 impliedly impliedly RB 19768 11 56 and and CC 19768 11 57 yet yet RB 19768 11 58 unwarrantably unwarrantably RB 19768 11 59 in in IN 19768 11 60 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 11 61 name name NN 19768 11 62 , , , 19768 11 63 you -PRON- PRP 19768 11 64 will will MD 19768 11 65 express express VB 19768 11 66 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 11 67 disapprobation disapprobation NN 19768 11 68 in in IN 19768 11 69 some some DT 19768 11 70 just just JJ 19768 11 71 and and CC 19768 11 72 appropriate appropriate JJ 19768 11 73 manner manner NN 19768 11 74 . . . 19768 12 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 19768 12 2 action action NN 19768 12 3 in in IN 19768 12 4 thus thus RB 19768 12 5 laying lay VBG 19768 12 6 the the DT 19768 12 7 matter matter NN 19768 12 8 publicly publicly RB 19768 12 9 before before IN 19768 12 10 you -PRON- PRP 19768 12 11 can can MD 19768 12 12 inflict inflict VB 19768 12 13 no no DT 19768 12 14 possible possible JJ 19768 12 15 injury injury NN 19768 12 16 upon upon IN 19768 12 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 12 18 honored honor VBN 19768 12 19 and and CC 19768 12 20 revered revere VBN 19768 12 21 Alma Alma NNP 19768 12 22 Mater Mater NNP 19768 12 23 : : : 19768 12 24 injury injury NN 19768 12 25 to to IN 19768 12 26 her -PRON- PRP 19768 12 27 is be VBZ 19768 12 28 not not RB 19768 12 29 even even RB 19768 12 30 conceivable conceivable JJ 19768 12 31 , , , 19768 12 32 except except IN 19768 12 33 on on IN 19768 12 34 the the DT 19768 12 35 wildly wildly RB 19768 12 36 improbable improbable JJ 19768 12 37 supposition supposition NN 19768 12 38 of of IN 19768 12 39 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 12 40 being be VBG 19768 12 41 indifferent indifferent JJ 19768 12 42 to to IN 19768 12 43 a a DT 19768 12 44 scandalous scandalous JJ 19768 12 45 abuse abuse NN 19768 12 46 of of IN 19768 12 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 12 48 position position NN 19768 12 49 by by IN 19768 12 50 one one CD 19768 12 51 of of IN 19768 12 52 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 12 53 assistant assistant JJ 19768 12 54 professors professor NNS 19768 12 55 , , , 19768 12 56 who who WP 19768 12 57 , , , 19768 12 58 with with IN 19768 12 59 no no DT 19768 12 60 imaginable imaginable JJ 19768 12 61 motive motive NN 19768 12 62 other other JJ 19768 12 63 than than IN 19768 12 64 mere mere JJ 19768 12 65 professional professional JJ 19768 12 66 jealousy jealousy NN 19768 12 67 or or CC 19768 12 68 rivalry rivalry NN 19768 12 69 of of IN 19768 12 70 authorship authorship NN 19768 12 71 , , , 19768 12 72 has have VBZ 19768 12 73 gone go VBN 19768 12 74 to to IN 19768 12 75 the the DT 19768 12 76 unheard unheard JJ 19768 12 77 - - HYPH 19768 12 78 of of IN 19768 12 79 length length NN 19768 12 80 of of IN 19768 12 81 " " `` 19768 12 82 professionally professionally RB 19768 12 83 warning warn VBG 19768 12 84 the the DT 19768 12 85 public public NN 19768 12 86 " " '' 19768 12 87 against against IN 19768 12 88 a a DT 19768 12 89 peaceable peaceable JJ 19768 12 90 and and CC 19768 12 91 inoffensive inoffensive JJ 19768 12 92 private private JJ 19768 12 93 scholar scholar NN 19768 12 94 , , , 19768 12 95 whose whose WP$ 19768 12 96 published publish VBN 19768 12 97 arguments argument NNS 19768 12 98 he -PRON- PRP 19768 12 99 has have VBZ 19768 12 100 twice twice RB 19768 12 101 tried try VBN 19768 12 102 , , , 19768 12 103 but but CC 19768 12 104 twice twice PDT 19768 12 105 signally signally RB 19768 12 106 failed fail VBD 19768 12 107 , , , 19768 12 108 to to TO 19768 12 109 meet meet VB 19768 12 110 in in IN 19768 12 111 an an DT 19768 12 112 intellectual intellectual JJ 19768 12 113 way way NN 19768 12 114 . . . 19768 13 1 If if IN 19768 13 2 the the DT 19768 13 3 public public NN 19768 13 4 at at IN 19768 13 5 large large JJ 19768 13 6 should should MD 19768 13 7 have have VB 19768 13 8 reason reason NN 19768 13 9 to to TO 19768 13 10 believe believe VB 19768 13 11 that that DT 19768 13 12 conduct conduct NN 19768 13 13 so so RB 19768 13 14 scandalous scandalous JJ 19768 13 15 as as IN 19768 13 16 this this DT 19768 13 17 in in IN 19768 13 18 a a DT 19768 13 19 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 13 20 professor professor NN 19768 13 21 will will MD 19768 13 22 not not RB 19768 13 23 be be VB 19768 13 24 condemned condemn VBN 19768 13 25 by by IN 19768 13 26 you -PRON- PRP 19768 13 27 , , , 19768 13 28 as as IN 19768 13 29 incompatible incompatible JJ 19768 13 30 with with IN 19768 13 31 the the DT 19768 13 32 dignity dignity NN 19768 13 33 and and CC 19768 13 34 the the DT 19768 13 35 decencies decency NNS 19768 13 36 of of IN 19768 13 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 13 38 office office NN 19768 13 39 and and CC 19768 13 40 with with IN 19768 13 41 the the DT 19768 13 42 rights right NNS 19768 13 43 of of IN 19768 13 44 private private JJ 19768 13 45 citizens citizen NNS 19768 13 46 in in IN 19768 13 47 general general JJ 19768 13 48 , , , 19768 13 49 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 13 50 University University NNP 19768 13 51 would would MD 19768 13 52 indeed indeed RB 19768 13 53 suffer suffer VB 19768 13 54 , , , 19768 13 55 and and CC 19768 13 56 ought ought MD 19768 13 57 to to TO 19768 13 58 suffer suffer VB 19768 13 59 ; ; : 19768 13 60 but but CC 19768 13 61 it -PRON- PRP 19768 13 62 is be VBZ 19768 13 63 wholly wholly RB 19768 13 64 within within IN 19768 13 65 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 13 66 power power NN 19768 13 67 to to TO 19768 13 68 prevent prevent VB 19768 13 69 the the DT 19768 13 70 growth growth NN 19768 13 71 of of IN 19768 13 72 so so RB 19768 13 73 injurious injurious JJ 19768 13 74 a a DT 19768 13 75 belief belief NN 19768 13 76 . . . 19768 14 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 14 2 beg beg VBP 19768 14 3 leave leave VBP 19768 14 4 , , , 19768 14 5 therefore therefore RB 19768 14 6 , , , 19768 14 7 to to TO 19768 14 8 submit submit VB 19768 14 9 to to IN 19768 14 10 you -PRON- PRP 19768 14 11 the the DT 19768 14 12 following follow VBG 19768 14 13 statement statement NN 19768 14 14 , , , 19768 14 15 and and CC 19768 14 16 to to TO 19768 14 17 solicit solicit VB 19768 14 18 for for IN 19768 14 19 it -PRON- PRP 19768 14 20 the the DT 19768 14 21 patient patient JJ 19768 14 22 and and CC 19768 14 23 impartial impartial JJ 19768 14 24 consideration consideration NN 19768 14 25 which which WDT 19768 14 26 the the DT 19768 14 27 gravity gravity NN 19768 14 28 of of IN 19768 14 29 the the DT 19768 14 30 case case NN 19768 14 31 requires require VBZ 19768 14 32 . . . 19768 15 1 I. I. NNP 19768 16 1 The the DT 19768 16 2 first first JJ 19768 16 3 number number NN 19768 16 4 of of IN 19768 16 5 a a DT 19768 16 6 new new JJ 19768 16 7 quarterly quarterly JJ 19768 16 8 periodical periodical NN 19768 16 9 , , , 19768 16 10 the the DT 19768 16 11 " " `` 19768 16 12 International International NNP 19768 16 13 Journal Journal NNP 19768 16 14 of of IN 19768 16 15 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 16 16 , , , 19768 16 17 " " '' 19768 16 18 published publish VBN 19768 16 19 at at IN 19768 16 20 Philadelphia Philadelphia NNP 19768 16 21 in in IN 19768 16 22 October October NNP 19768 16 23 , , , 19768 16 24 1890 1890 CD 19768 16 25 , , , 19768 16 26 contained contain VBD 19768 16 27 an an DT 19768 16 28 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 16 29 review review NN 19768 16 30 by by IN 19768 16 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 16 32 Royce Royce NNP 19768 16 33 of of IN 19768 16 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 16 35 last last JJ 19768 16 36 book book NN 19768 16 37 , , , 19768 16 38 " " `` 19768 16 39 The the DT 19768 16 40 Way way NN 19768 16 41 out out IN 19768 16 42 of of IN 19768 16 43 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 19768 16 44 . . . 19768 16 45 " " '' 19768 17 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 17 2 advisedly advisedly RB 19768 17 3 use use VBP 19768 17 4 the the DT 19768 17 5 word word NN 19768 17 6 " " `` 19768 17 7 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 17 8 , , , 19768 17 9 " " '' 19768 17 10 because because IN 19768 17 11 the the DT 19768 17 12 main main JJ 19768 17 13 purport purport NN 19768 17 14 and and CC 19768 17 15 intention intention NN 19768 17 16 of of IN 19768 17 17 the the DT 19768 17 18 article article NN 19768 17 19 were be VBD 19768 17 20 not not RB 19768 17 21 at at RB 19768 17 22 all all RB 19768 17 23 to to TO 19768 17 24 criticise criticise VB 19768 17 25 a a DT 19768 17 26 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 17 27 , , , 19768 17 28 but but CC 19768 17 29 to to TO 19768 17 30 sully sully RB 19768 17 31 the the DT 19768 17 32 reputation reputation NN 19768 17 33 of of IN 19768 17 34 the the DT 19768 17 35 philosopher philosopher NN 19768 17 36 , , , 19768 17 37 deprive deprive VB 19768 17 38 him -PRON- PRP 19768 17 39 of of IN 19768 17 40 public public JJ 19768 17 41 confidence confidence NN 19768 17 42 , , , 19768 17 43 ridicule ridicule NN 19768 17 44 and and CC 19768 17 45 misrepresent misrepresent VB 19768 17 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 17 47 labors labor NNS 19768 17 48 , , , 19768 17 49 hold hold VB 19768 17 50 him -PRON- PRP 19768 17 51 up up RP 19768 17 52 by by IN 19768 17 53 name name NN 19768 17 54 to to IN 19768 17 55 public public JJ 19768 17 56 obloquy obloquy NN 19768 17 57 and and CC 19768 17 58 contempt contempt NN 19768 17 59 , , , 19768 17 60 destroy destroy VB 19768 17 61 or or CC 19768 17 62 lessen lessen VB 19768 17 63 the the DT 19768 17 64 circulation circulation NN 19768 17 65 of of IN 19768 17 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 17 67 books book NNS 19768 17 68 , , , 19768 17 69 and and CC 19768 17 70 , , , 19768 17 71 in in IN 19768 17 72 general general JJ 19768 17 73 , , , 19768 17 74 to to TO 19768 17 75 blacken blacken VB 19768 17 76 and and CC 19768 17 77 break break VB 19768 17 78 down down RP 19768 17 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 17 80 literary literary JJ 19768 17 81 reputation reputation NN 19768 17 82 by by IN 19768 17 83 any any DT 19768 17 84 and and CC 19768 17 85 every every DT 19768 17 86 means mean NNS 19768 17 87 , , , 19768 17 88 even even RB 19768 17 89 to to IN 19768 17 90 the the DT 19768 17 91 extent extent NN 19768 17 92 of of IN 19768 17 93 aspersing asperse VBG 19768 17 94 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 17 95 personal personal JJ 19768 17 96 reputation reputation NN 19768 17 97 , , , 19768 17 98 although although IN 19768 17 99 there there EX 19768 17 100 had have VBD 19768 17 101 never never RB 19768 17 102 been be VBN 19768 17 103 the the DT 19768 17 104 slightest slight JJS 19768 17 105 personal personal JJ 19768 17 106 collision collision NN 19768 17 107 . . . 19768 18 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 18 2 bitter bitter JJ 19768 18 3 and and CC 19768 18 4 invidious invidious JJ 19768 18 5 spirit spirit NN 19768 18 6 was be VBD 19768 18 7 not not RB 19768 18 8 in in IN 19768 18 9 the the DT 19768 18 10 least least JJS 19768 18 11 disguised disguise VBN 19768 18 12 by by IN 19768 18 13 a a DT 19768 18 14 few few JJ 19768 18 15 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 19768 18 16 compliments compliment NNS 19768 18 17 adroitly adroitly RB 19768 18 18 inserted insert VBN 19768 18 19 here here RB 19768 18 20 and and CC 19768 18 21 there there RB 19768 18 22 : : : 19768 18 23 these these DT 19768 18 24 merely merely RB 19768 18 25 furnish furnish VBP 19768 18 26 the the DT 19768 18 27 foil foil NN 19768 18 28 needed need VBN 19768 18 29 to to TO 19768 18 30 give give VB 19768 18 31 greater great JJR 19768 18 32 potency potency NN 19768 18 33 and and CC 19768 18 34 efficiency efficiency NN 19768 18 35 to to IN 19768 18 36 the the DT 19768 18 37 personal personal JJ 19768 18 38 insinuations insinuation NNS 19768 18 39 , , , 19768 18 40 and and CC 19768 18 41 , , , 19768 18 42 like like IN 19768 18 43 Mark Mark NNP 19768 18 44 Antony Antony NNP 19768 18 45 's 's POS 19768 18 46 compliments compliment NNS 19768 18 47 to to IN 19768 18 48 Cæsar Cæsar NNP 19768 18 49 's 's POS 19768 18 50 assassins assassin NNS 19768 18 51 , , , 19768 18 52 subserved subserve VBD 19768 18 53 quite quite RB 19768 18 54 too too RB 19768 18 55 many many JJ 19768 18 56 politic politic JJ 19768 18 57 purposes purpose NNS 19768 18 58 to to TO 19768 18 59 be be VB 19768 18 60 accepted accept VBN 19768 18 61 as as IN 19768 18 62 sincere sincere JJ 19768 18 63 . . . 19768 19 1 Only only RB 19768 19 2 a a DT 19768 19 3 native native NN 19768 19 4 of of IN 19768 19 5 Boeotia Boeotia NNP 19768 19 6 could could MD 19768 19 7 be be VB 19768 19 8 imposed impose VBN 19768 19 9 upon upon IN 19768 19 10 by by IN 19768 19 11 them -PRON- PRP 19768 19 12 , , , 19768 19 13 when when WRB 19768 19 14 the the DT 19768 19 15 actual actual JJ 19768 19 16 character character NN 19768 19 17 of of IN 19768 19 18 the the DT 19768 19 19 book book NN 19768 19 20 in in IN 19768 19 21 question question NN 19768 19 22 was be VBD 19768 19 23 carefully carefully RB 19768 19 24 misrepresented misrepresent VBN 19768 19 25 , , , 19768 19 26 and and CC 19768 19 27 when when WRB 19768 19 28 the the DT 19768 19 29 self self NN 19768 19 30 - - HYPH 19768 19 31 evident evident JJ 19768 19 32 trend trend NN 19768 19 33 , , , 19768 19 34 tenor tenor NN 19768 19 35 , , , 19768 19 36 and and CC 19768 19 37 aim aim VB 19768 19 38 of of IN 19768 19 39 the the DT 19768 19 40 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 19 41 review review NN 19768 19 42 were be VBD 19768 19 43 to to TO 19768 19 44 excite excite VB 19768 19 45 public public JJ 19768 19 46 prejudice prejudice NN 19768 19 47 against against IN 19768 19 48 the the DT 19768 19 49 author author NN 19768 19 50 on on IN 19768 19 51 grounds ground NNS 19768 19 52 wholly wholly RB 19768 19 53 irrespective irrespective RB 19768 19 54 of of IN 19768 19 55 the the DT 19768 19 56 truth truth NN 19768 19 57 or or CC 19768 19 58 untruth untruth NN 19768 19 59 of of IN 19768 19 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 19 61 expressed express VBN 19768 19 62 opinions opinion NNS 19768 19 63 . . . 19768 20 1 Of of RB 19768 20 2 course course RB 19768 20 3 , , , 19768 20 4 the the DT 19768 20 5 very very RB 19768 20 6 largest large JJS 19768 20 7 liberty liberty NN 19768 20 8 must must MD 19768 20 9 be be VB 19768 20 10 and and CC 19768 20 11 should should MD 19768 20 12 be be VB 19768 20 13 conceded concede VBN 19768 20 14 to to TO 19768 20 15 legitimate legitimate VB 19768 20 16 criticism criticism NN 19768 20 17 . . . 19768 21 1 From from IN 19768 21 2 this this DT 19768 21 3 , , , 19768 21 4 as as IN 19768 21 5 is be VBZ 19768 21 6 well well RB 19768 21 7 known known JJ 19768 21 8 , , , 19768 21 9 I -PRON- PRP 19768 21 10 never never RB 19768 21 11 shrank shrink VBD 19768 21 12 in in IN 19768 21 13 the the DT 19768 21 14 least least JJS 19768 21 15 ; ; , 19768 21 16 on on IN 19768 21 17 the the DT 19768 21 18 contrary contrary NN 19768 21 19 , , , 19768 21 20 I -PRON- PRP 19768 21 21 court court VBP 19768 21 22 it -PRON- PRP 19768 21 23 , , , 19768 21 24 and and CC 19768 21 25 desire desire VB 19768 21 26 nothing nothing NN 19768 21 27 better well JJR 19768 21 28 for for IN 19768 21 29 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 21 30 books book NNS 19768 21 31 , , , 19768 21 32 provided provide VBN 19768 21 33 only only RB 19768 21 34 that that IN 19768 21 35 the the DT 19768 21 36 criticism criticism NN 19768 21 37 be be VB 19768 21 38 pertinent pertinent JJ 19768 21 39 , , , 19768 21 40 intelligent intelligent JJ 19768 21 41 , , , 19768 21 42 and and CC 19768 21 43 fair fair JJ 19768 21 44 . . . 19768 22 1 But but CC 19768 22 2 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 22 3 for for IN 19768 22 4 the the DT 19768 22 5 purpose purpose NN 19768 22 6 of of IN 19768 22 7 detraction detraction NN 19768 22 8 is be VBZ 19768 22 9 not not RB 19768 22 10 criticism criticism NN 19768 22 11 at at RB 19768 22 12 all all RB 19768 22 13 ; ; : 19768 22 14 and and CC 19768 22 15 ( ( -LRB- 19768 22 16 notwithstanding notwithstanding RB 19768 22 17 numerous numerous JJ 19768 22 18 quotations quotation NNS 19768 22 19 perverted pervert VBN 19768 22 20 by by IN 19768 22 21 unfair unfair JJ 19768 22 22 and and CC 19768 22 23 misleading misleading JJ 19768 22 24 glosses gloss NNS 19768 22 25 , , , 19768 22 26 including include VBG 19768 22 27 two two CD 19768 22 28 misquotations misquotation NNS 19768 22 29 quite quite RB 19768 22 30 too too RB 19768 22 31 useful useful JJ 19768 22 32 to to TO 19768 22 33 be be VB 19768 22 34 accidental accidental JJ 19768 22 35 ) ) -RRB- 19768 22 36 this this DT 19768 22 37 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 22 38 review review NN 19768 22 39 is be VBZ 19768 22 40 , , , 19768 22 41 from from IN 19768 22 42 beginning begin VBG 19768 22 43 to to IN 19768 22 44 end end NN 19768 22 45 , , , 19768 22 46 nothing nothing NN 19768 22 47 but but IN 19768 22 48 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 22 49 for for IN 19768 22 50 the the DT 19768 22 51 purpose purpose NN 19768 22 52 of of IN 19768 22 53 detraction detraction NN 19768 22 54 . . . 19768 23 1 Passing pass VBG 19768 23 2 over over RP 19768 23 3 numerous numerous JJ 19768 23 4 minor minor JJ 19768 23 5 instances instance NNS 19768 23 6 , , , 19768 23 7 permit permit VB 19768 23 8 me -PRON- PRP 19768 23 9 to to TO 19768 23 10 invite invite VB 19768 23 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 23 12 attention attention NN 19768 23 13 to to IN 19768 23 14 three three CD 19768 23 15 gross gross JJ 19768 23 16 instances instance NNS 19768 23 17 of of IN 19768 23 18 such such JJ 19768 23 19 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 23 20 . . . 19768 24 1 II ii CD 19768 24 2 . . . 19768 25 1 The the DT 19768 25 2 book book NN 19768 25 3 under under IN 19768 25 4 review review NN 19768 25 5 had have VBD 19768 25 6 taken take VBN 19768 25 7 the the DT 19768 25 8 utmost utmost JJ 19768 25 9 pains pain NNS 19768 25 10 ( ( -LRB- 19768 25 11 pages page NNS 19768 25 12 16 16 CD 19768 25 13 - - SYM 19768 25 14 39 39 CD 19768 25 15 , , , 19768 25 16 especially especially RB 19768 25 17 page page NN 19768 25 18 39 39 CD 19768 25 19 ) ) -RRB- 19768 25 20 to to TO 19768 25 21 distinguish distinguish VB 19768 25 22 " " `` 19768 25 23 realism realism NN 19768 25 24 " " '' 19768 25 25 from from IN 19768 25 26 " " `` 19768 25 27 idealism idealism NN 19768 25 28 , , , 19768 25 29 " " '' 19768 25 30 and and CC 19768 25 31 to to TO 19768 25 32 argue argue VB 19768 25 33 for for IN 19768 25 34 the the DT 19768 25 35 former former JJ 19768 25 36 in in IN 19768 25 37 opposition opposition NN 19768 25 38 to to IN 19768 25 39 the the DT 19768 25 40 latter latter JJ 19768 25 41 , , , 19768 25 42 on on IN 19768 25 43 the the DT 19768 25 44 ground ground NN 19768 25 45 of of IN 19768 25 46 the the DT 19768 25 47 absolute absolute JJ 19768 25 48 incompatibility incompatibility NN 19768 25 49 of of IN 19768 25 50 the the DT 19768 25 51 latter latter JJ 19768 25 52 with with IN 19768 25 53 the the DT 19768 25 54 scientific scientific JJ 19768 25 55 method method NN 19768 25 56 of of IN 19768 25 57 investigation investigation NN 19768 25 58 . . . 19768 26 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 26 2 had have VBD 19768 26 3 taken take VBN 19768 26 4 the the DT 19768 26 5 utmost utmost JJ 19768 26 6 pains pain NNS 19768 26 7 to to TO 19768 26 8 make make VB 19768 26 9 the the DT 19768 26 10 contrast contrast NN 19768 26 11 broad broad JJ 19768 26 12 and and CC 19768 26 13 deep deep JJ 19768 26 14 , , , 19768 26 15 and and CC 19768 26 16 to to TO 19768 26 17 point point VB 19768 26 18 out out RP 19768 26 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 26 20 far far RB 19768 26 21 - - HYPH 19768 26 22 reaching reach VBG 19768 26 23 consequences consequence NNS 19768 26 24 by by IN 19768 26 25 explicitly explicitly RB 19768 26 26 opposing oppose VBG 19768 26 27 ( ( -LRB- 19768 26 28 1 1 LS 19768 26 29 ) ) -RRB- 19768 26 30 scientific scientific JJ 19768 26 31 realism realism NN 19768 26 32 to to IN 19768 26 33 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 26 34 idealism idealism NN 19768 26 35 in in IN 19768 26 36 general general JJ 19768 26 37 , , , 19768 26 38 and and CC 19768 26 39 in in IN 19768 26 40 particular particular JJ 19768 26 41 ( ( -LRB- 19768 26 42 2 2 LS 19768 26 43 ) ) -RRB- 19768 26 44 constructive constructive JJ 19768 26 45 realism realism NN 19768 26 46 to to IN 19768 26 47 constructive constructive JJ 19768 26 48 idealism idealism NN 19768 26 49 , , , 19768 26 50 ( ( -LRB- 19768 26 51 3 3 LS 19768 26 52 ) ) -RRB- 19768 26 53 critical critical JJ 19768 26 54 realism realism NN 19768 26 55 to to IN 19768 26 56 critical critical JJ 19768 26 57 idealism idealism NN 19768 26 58 , , , 19768 26 59 ( ( -LRB- 19768 26 60 4 4 LS 19768 26 61 ) ) -RRB- 19768 26 62 ethical ethical JJ 19768 26 63 realism realism NN 19768 26 64 to to IN 19768 26 65 ethical ethical JJ 19768 26 66 idealism idealism NN 19768 26 67 , , , 19768 26 68 and and CC 19768 26 69 ( ( -LRB- 19768 26 70 5 5 LS 19768 26 71 ) ) -RRB- 19768 26 72 religious religious JJ 19768 26 73 realism realism NN 19768 26 74 to to IN 19768 26 75 religious religious JJ 19768 26 76 idealism idealism NN 19768 26 77 . . . 19768 27 1 Any any DT 19768 27 2 fair fair JJ 19768 27 3 or or CC 19768 27 4 honorable honorable JJ 19768 27 5 critic critic NN 19768 27 6 would would MD 19768 27 7 recognize recognize VB 19768 27 8 this this DT 19768 27 9 contrast contrast NN 19768 27 10 and and CC 19768 27 11 opposition opposition NN 19768 27 12 between between IN 19768 27 13 realism realism NN 19768 27 14 and and CC 19768 27 15 idealism idealism NN 19768 27 16 as as IN 19768 27 17 the the DT 19768 27 18 very very JJ 19768 27 19 foundation foundation NN 19768 27 20 of of IN 19768 27 21 the the DT 19768 27 22 work work NN 19768 27 23 he -PRON- PRP 19768 27 24 was be VBD 19768 27 25 criticising criticise VBG 19768 27 26 , , , 19768 27 27 and and CC 19768 27 28 would would MD 19768 27 29 at at IN 19768 27 30 least least JJS 19768 27 31 state state NN 19768 27 32 it -PRON- PRP 19768 27 33 candidly candidly RB 19768 27 34 , , , 19768 27 35 as as IN 19768 27 36 the the DT 19768 27 37 foundation foundation NN 19768 27 38 of of IN 19768 27 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 27 40 own own JJ 19768 27 41 favorable favorable JJ 19768 27 42 or or CC 19768 27 43 unfavorable unfavorable JJ 19768 27 44 comments comment NNS 19768 27 45 . . . 19768 28 1 How how WRB 19768 28 2 did do VBD 19768 28 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 28 4 Royce Royce NNP 19768 28 5 treat treat VB 19768 28 6 it -PRON- PRP 19768 28 7 ? ? . 19768 29 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 29 2 not not RB 19768 29 3 only only RB 19768 29 4 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 29 5 ignored ignore VBD 19768 29 6 it -PRON- PRP 19768 29 7 , , , 19768 29 8 not not RB 19768 29 9 only only RB 19768 29 10 said say VBD 19768 29 11 nothing nothing NN 19768 29 12 whatever whatever WDT 19768 29 13 about about IN 19768 29 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 29 15 , , , 19768 29 16 but but CC 19768 29 17 actually actually RB 19768 29 18 took take VBD 19768 29 19 pains pain NNS 19768 29 20 to to TO 19768 29 21 put put VB 19768 29 22 the the DT 19768 29 23 reader reader NN 19768 29 24 on on IN 19768 29 25 a a DT 19768 29 26 false false JJ 19768 29 27 scent scent NN 19768 29 28 at at IN 19768 29 29 the the DT 19768 29 30 start start NN 19768 29 31 , , , 19768 29 32 by by IN 19768 29 33 assuring assure VBG 19768 29 34 him -PRON- PRP 19768 29 35 ( ( -LRB- 19768 29 36 without without IN 19768 29 37 the the DT 19768 29 38 least least JJS 19768 29 39 discussion discussion NN 19768 29 40 of of IN 19768 29 41 this this DT 19768 29 42 all all RB 19768 29 43 - - HYPH 19768 29 44 important important JJ 19768 29 45 point point NN 19768 29 46 ) ) -RRB- 19768 29 47 that that IN 19768 29 48 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 29 49 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 29 50 conclusions conclusion NNS 19768 29 51 are be VBP 19768 29 52 " " `` 19768 29 53 essentially essentially RB 19768 29 54 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 29 55 " " '' 19768 29 56 ! ! . 19768 30 1 So so CC 19768 30 2 gross gross JJ 19768 30 3 a a DT 19768 30 4 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 30 5 as as IN 19768 30 6 this this DT 19768 30 7 might may MD 19768 30 8 be be VB 19768 30 9 charitably charitably RB 19768 30 10 attributed attribute VBN 19768 30 11 to to IN 19768 30 12 critical critical JJ 19768 30 13 incapacity incapacity NN 19768 30 14 of of IN 19768 30 15 some some DT 19768 30 16 sort sort NN 19768 30 17 , , , 19768 30 18 if if IN 19768 30 19 it -PRON- PRP 19768 30 20 did do VBD 19768 30 21 not not RB 19768 30 22 so so RB 19768 30 23 very very RB 19768 30 24 conveniently conveniently RB 19768 30 25 pave pave VBP 19768 30 26 the the DT 19768 30 27 way way NN 19768 30 28 for for IN 19768 30 29 the the DT 19768 30 30 second second JJ 19768 30 31 gross gross JJ 19768 30 32 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 30 33 which which WDT 19768 30 34 was be VBD 19768 30 35 to to TO 19768 30 36 follow follow VB 19768 30 37 : : : 19768 30 38 namely namely RB 19768 30 39 , , , 19768 30 40 that that IN 19768 30 41 the the DT 19768 30 42 theory theory NN 19768 30 43 actually actually RB 19768 30 44 propounded propound VBD 19768 30 45 in in IN 19768 30 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 30 47 book book NN 19768 30 48 had have VBD 19768 30 49 been be VBN 19768 30 50 , , , 19768 30 51 in in IN 19768 30 52 fact fact NN 19768 30 53 , , , 19768 30 54 " " '' 19768 30 55 _ _ NNP 19768 30 56 appropriated appropriate VBD 19768 30 57 " " '' 19768 30 58 and and CC 19768 30 59 " " `` 19768 30 60 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 30 61 " " '' 19768 30 62 from from IN 19768 30 63 an an DT 19768 30 64 idealist idealist NN 19768 30 65 _ _ NNP 19768 30 66 ! ! . 19768 31 1 The the DT 19768 31 2 immense immense JJ 19768 31 3 utility utility NN 19768 31 4 of of IN 19768 31 5 misrepresenting misrepresent VBG 19768 31 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 31 7 system system NN 19768 31 8 at at IN 19768 31 9 the the DT 19768 31 10 start start NN 19768 31 11 as as IN 19768 31 12 " " `` 19768 31 13 essentially essentially RB 19768 31 14 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 31 15 " " '' 19768 31 16 lay lie VBD 19768 31 17 in in IN 19768 31 18 the the DT 19768 31 19 fact fact NN 19768 31 20 that that IN 19768 31 21 , , , 19768 31 22 by by IN 19768 31 23 adopting adopt VBG 19768 31 24 this this DT 19768 31 25 stratagem stratagem NN 19768 31 26 , , , 19768 31 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 31 28 Royce Royce NNP 19768 31 29 could could MD 19768 31 30 escape escape VB 19768 31 31 altogether altogether RB 19768 31 32 the the DT 19768 31 33 formidable formidable JJ 19768 31 34 necessity necessity NN 19768 31 35 of of IN 19768 31 36 _ _ NNP 19768 31 37 first first RB 19768 31 38 arguing argue VBG 19768 31 39 the the DT 19768 31 40 main main JJ 19768 31 41 question question NN 19768 31 42 of of IN 19768 31 43 idealism idealism NN 19768 31 44 versus versus IN 19768 31 45 realism realism NN 19768 31 46 _ _ NNP 19768 31 47 . . . 19768 32 1 Secretly secretly RB 19768 32 2 conscious conscious JJ 19768 32 3 of of IN 19768 32 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 32 5 own own JJ 19768 32 6 inability inability NN 19768 32 7 to to TO 19768 32 8 handle handle VB 19768 32 9 that that DT 19768 32 10 question question NN 19768 32 11 , , , 19768 32 12 to to TO 19768 32 13 refute refute VB 19768 32 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 32 15 " " `` 19768 32 16 Soliloquy Soliloquy NNP 19768 32 17 of of IN 19768 32 18 the the DT 19768 32 19 Self Self NNP 19768 32 20 - - HYPH 19768 32 21 Consistent consistent JJ 19768 32 22 Idealist Idealist NNP 19768 32 23 , , , 19768 32 24 " " '' 19768 32 25 or or CC 19768 32 26 to to TO 19768 32 27 overthrow overthrow VB 19768 32 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 32 29 demonstration demonstration NN 19768 32 30 that that IN 19768 32 31 consistent consistent JJ 19768 32 32 idealism idealism NN 19768 32 33 leads lead VBZ 19768 32 34 logically logically RB 19768 32 35 to to IN 19768 32 36 hopeless hopeless JJ 19768 32 37 absurdity absurdity NN 19768 32 38 at at IN 19768 32 39 last last JJ 19768 32 40 , , , 19768 32 41 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 32 42 Royce Royce NNP 19768 32 43 found find VBD 19768 32 44 it -PRON- PRP 19768 32 45 infinitely infinitely RB 19768 32 46 easier easy JJR 19768 32 47 to to TO 19768 32 48 deceive deceive VB 19768 32 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 32 50 uninformed uninformed JJ 19768 32 51 readers reader NNS 19768 32 52 by by IN 19768 32 53 a a DT 19768 32 54 bold bold JJ 19768 32 55 assertion assertion NN 19768 32 56 that that IN 19768 32 57 I -PRON- PRP 19768 32 58 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 32 59 am be VBP 19768 32 60 an an DT 19768 32 61 idealist idealist NN 19768 32 62 at at IN 19768 32 63 bottom bottom NN 19768 32 64 . . . 19768 33 1 This this DT 19768 33 2 assertion assertion NN 19768 33 3 , , , 19768 33 4 swallowed swallow VBD 19768 33 5 without without IN 19768 33 6 suspicion suspicion NN 19768 33 7 of of IN 19768 33 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 33 9 absolute absolute JJ 19768 33 10 untruth untruth NN 19768 33 11 , , , 19768 33 12 would would MD 19768 33 13 render render VB 19768 33 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 33 15 plausible plausible JJ 19768 33 16 and and CC 19768 33 17 quite quite RB 19768 33 18 credible credible JJ 19768 33 19 to to TO 19768 33 20 assert assert VB 19768 33 21 , , , 19768 33 22 next next RB 19768 33 23 , , , 19768 33 24 that that IN 19768 33 25 I -PRON- PRP 19768 33 26 had have VBD 19768 33 27 actually actually RB 19768 33 28 " " `` 19768 33 29 appropriated appropriate VBN 19768 33 30 " " '' 19768 33 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 33 32 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 33 33 from from IN 19768 33 34 a a DT 19768 33 35 greater great JJR 19768 33 36 idealist idealist NN 19768 33 37 than than IN 19768 33 38 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 33 39 . . . 19768 34 1 For for IN 19768 34 2 the the DT 19768 34 3 only only JJ 19768 34 4 substantial substantial JJ 19768 34 5 criticism criticism NN 19768 34 6 of of IN 19768 34 7 the the DT 19768 34 8 book book NN 19768 34 9 made make VBN 19768 34 10 by by IN 19768 34 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 34 12 Royce Royce NNP 19768 34 13 is be VBZ 19768 34 14 that that IN 19768 34 15 I -PRON- PRP 19768 34 16 " " `` 19768 34 17 borrowed borrow VBD 19768 34 18 " " `` 19768 34 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 34 20 whole whole JJ 19768 34 21 theory theory NN 19768 34 22 of of IN 19768 34 23 universals universal NNS 19768 34 24 from from IN 19768 34 25 Hegel--"unconsciously Hegel--"unconsciously NNP 19768 34 26 , , , 19768 34 27 " " '' 19768 34 28 he -PRON- PRP 19768 34 29 has have VBZ 19768 34 30 the the DT 19768 34 31 caution caution NN 19768 34 32 to to TO 19768 34 33 say say VB 19768 34 34 ; ; : 19768 34 35 but but CC 19768 34 36 that that IN 19768 34 37 qualification qualification NN 19768 34 38 does do VBZ 19768 34 39 not not RB 19768 34 40 in in IN 19768 34 41 the the DT 19768 34 42 least least JJS 19768 34 43 mitigate mitigate VB 19768 34 44 the the DT 19768 34 45 mischievous mischievous JJ 19768 34 46 intention intention NN 19768 34 47 and and CC 19768 34 48 effect effect NN 19768 34 49 of of IN 19768 34 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 34 51 accusation accusation NN 19768 34 52 as as IN 19768 34 53 a a DT 19768 34 54 glaring glaring JJ 19768 34 55 falsification falsification NN 19768 34 56 of of IN 19768 34 57 fact fact NN 19768 34 58 and and CC 19768 34 59 artful artful JJ 19768 34 60 misdescription misdescription NN 19768 34 61 of of IN 19768 34 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 34 63 work work NN 19768 34 64 . . . 19768 35 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 35 2 would would MD 19768 35 3 be be VB 19768 35 4 inopportune inopportune JJ 19768 35 5 and and CC 19768 35 6 discourteous discourteous JJ 19768 35 7 to to IN 19768 35 8 weary weary NNP 19768 35 9 you -PRON- PRP 19768 35 10 with with IN 19768 35 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 35 12 discussions discussion NNS 19768 35 13 . . . 19768 36 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 36 2 exposed expose VBD 19768 36 3 the the DT 19768 36 4 amazing amazing JJ 19768 36 5 absurdity absurdity NN 19768 36 6 of of IN 19768 36 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 36 8 Royce Royce NNP 19768 36 9 's 's POS 19768 36 10 accusation accusation NN 19768 36 11 of of IN 19768 36 12 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 36 13 in in IN 19768 36 14 the the DT 19768 36 15 reply reply NN 19768 36 16 to to IN 19768 36 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 36 18 article article NN 19768 36 19 which which WDT 19768 36 20 , , , 19768 36 21 as as IN 19768 36 22 appears appear VBZ 19768 36 23 below below RB 19768 36 24 , , , 19768 36 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 36 26 Royce Royce NNP 19768 36 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 36 28 anxiously anxiously RB 19768 36 29 suppressed suppress VBN 19768 36 30 , , , 19768 36 31 and and CC 19768 36 32 which which WDT 19768 36 33 I -PRON- PRP 19768 36 34 should should MD 19768 36 35 now now RB 19768 36 36 submit submit VB 19768 36 37 to to IN 19768 36 38 you -PRON- PRP 19768 36 39 , , , 19768 36 40 if if IN 19768 36 41 he -PRON- PRP 19768 36 42 had have VBD 19768 36 43 not not RB 19768 36 44 at at IN 19768 36 45 last last JJ 19768 36 46 taken take VBN 19768 36 47 fright fright NN 19768 36 48 and and CC 19768 36 49 served serve VBD 19768 36 50 upon upon IN 19768 36 51 me -PRON- PRP 19768 36 52 a a DT 19768 36 53 legal legal JJ 19768 36 54 protest protest NN 19768 36 55 against against IN 19768 36 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 36 57 circulation circulation NN 19768 36 58 . . . 19768 37 1 But but CC 19768 37 2 , , , 19768 37 3 to to IN 19768 37 4 any any DT 19768 37 5 well well RB 19768 37 6 - - HYPH 19768 37 7 educated educate VBN 19768 37 8 man man NN 19768 37 9 , , , 19768 37 10 such such PDT 19768 37 11 an an DT 19768 37 12 accusation accusation NN 19768 37 13 as as IN 19768 37 14 this this DT 19768 37 15 refutes refute VBZ 19768 37 16 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 37 17 . . . 19768 38 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 38 2 would would MD 19768 38 3 be be VB 19768 38 4 just just RB 19768 38 5 as as RB 19768 38 6 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 38 7 , , , 19768 38 8 just just RB 19768 38 9 as as RB 19768 38 10 plausible plausible JJ 19768 38 11 , , , 19768 38 12 to to TO 19768 38 13 accuse accuse VB 19768 38 14 Darwin Darwin NNP 19768 38 15 of of IN 19768 38 16 having have VBG 19768 38 17 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 38 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 38 19 theory theory NN 19768 38 20 of of IN 19768 38 21 natural natural JJ 19768 38 22 selection selection NN 19768 38 23 from from IN 19768 38 24 Agassiz Agassiz NNP 19768 38 25 , , , 19768 38 26 or or CC 19768 38 27 Daniel Daniel NNP 19768 38 28 Webster Webster NNP 19768 38 29 of of IN 19768 38 30 having have VBG 19768 38 31 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 38 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 38 33 theory theory NN 19768 38 34 of of IN 19768 38 35 the the DT 19768 38 36 inseparable inseparable JJ 19768 38 37 Union Union NNP 19768 38 38 from from IN 19768 38 39 John John NNP 19768 38 40 C. C. NNP 19768 38 41 Calhoun Calhoun NNP 19768 38 42 , , , 19768 38 43 or or CC 19768 38 44 ex ex JJ 19768 38 45 - - JJ 19768 38 46 President President NNP 19768 38 47 Cleveland Cleveland NNP 19768 38 48 of of IN 19768 38 49 having have VBG 19768 38 50 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 38 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 38 52 message message NN 19768 38 53 on on IN 19768 38 54 tariff tariff NN 19768 38 55 reform reform NN 19768 38 56 from from IN 19768 38 57 the the DT 19768 38 58 Home Home NNP 19768 38 59 Market Market NNP 19768 38 60 Club Club NNP 19768 38 61 , , , 19768 38 62 as as IN 19768 38 63 to to TO 19768 38 64 accuse accuse VB 19768 38 65 me -PRON- PRP 19768 38 66 of of IN 19768 38 67 having have VBG 19768 38 68 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 38 69 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 38 70 theory theory NN 19768 38 71 of of IN 19768 38 72 universals universal NNS 19768 38 73 from from IN 19768 38 74 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 38 75 . . . 19768 39 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 39 2 's 's POS 19768 39 3 theory theory NN 19768 39 4 of of IN 19768 39 5 universals universal NNS 19768 39 6 is be VBZ 19768 39 7 divided divide VBN 19768 39 8 from from IN 19768 39 9 mine -PRON- PRP 19768 39 10 by by IN 19768 39 11 the the DT 19768 39 12 whole whole JJ 19768 39 13 vast vast JJ 19768 39 14 chasm chasm NN 19768 39 15 between between IN 19768 39 16 realism realism NN 19768 39 17 and and CC 19768 39 18 idealism idealism NN 19768 39 19 . . . 19768 40 1 The the DT 19768 40 2 two two CD 19768 40 3 theories theory NNS 19768 40 4 contradict contradict VBP 19768 40 5 each each DT 19768 40 6 other other JJ 19768 40 7 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 40 8 , , , 19768 40 9 uncompromisingly uncompromisingly RB 19768 40 10 , , , 19768 40 11 irreconcilably irreconcilably RB 19768 40 12 : : : 19768 40 13 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 40 14 's 's POS 19768 40 15 is be VBZ 19768 40 16 a a DT 19768 40 17 theory theory NN 19768 40 18 of of IN 19768 40 19 " " `` 19768 40 20 absolute absolute JJ 19768 40 21 idealism idealism NN 19768 40 22 " " '' 19768 40 23 or or CC 19768 40 24 " " `` 19768 40 25 pure pure JJ 19768 40 26 thought thought NN 19768 40 27 " " '' 19768 40 28 ( ( -LRB- 19768 40 29 _ _ NNP 19768 40 30 reines reine NNS 19768 40 31 Denken Denken NNP 19768 40 32 _ _ NNP 19768 40 33 ) ) -RRB- 19768 40 34 , , , 19768 40 35 that that RB 19768 40 36 is is RB 19768 40 37 , , , 19768 40 38 of of IN 19768 40 39 _ _ NNP 19768 40 40 thought think VBD 19768 40 41 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 40 42 independent independent JJ 19768 40 43 of of IN 19768 40 44 experience experience NN 19768 40 45 _ _ NNP 19768 40 46 , , , 19768 40 47 while while IN 19768 40 48 mine mine NN 19768 40 49 is be VBZ 19768 40 50 a a DT 19768 40 51 theory theory NN 19768 40 52 of of IN 19768 40 53 " " `` 19768 40 54 scientific scientific JJ 19768 40 55 realism realism NN 19768 40 56 , , , 19768 40 57 " " '' 19768 40 58 that that RB 19768 40 59 is is RB 19768 40 60 , , , 19768 40 61 of of IN 19768 40 62 _ _ NNP 19768 40 63 thought think VBD 19768 40 64 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 40 65 dependent dependent JJ 19768 40 66 upon upon IN 19768 40 67 experience experience NN 19768 40 68 . . . 19768 40 69 _ _ NNP 19768 40 70 It -PRON- PRP 19768 40 71 is be VBZ 19768 40 72 quite quite RB 19768 40 73 immaterial immaterial JJ 19768 40 74 here here RB 19768 40 75 which which WDT 19768 40 76 theory theory NN 19768 40 77 is be VBZ 19768 40 78 the the DT 19768 40 79 true true JJ 19768 40 80 one one NN 19768 40 81 ; ; : 19768 40 82 the the DT 19768 40 83 only only JJ 19768 40 84 point point NN 19768 40 85 involved involve VBN 19768 40 86 at at IN 19768 40 87 present present JJ 19768 40 88 is be VBZ 19768 40 89 that that IN 19768 40 90 the the DT 19768 40 91 two two CD 19768 40 92 theories theory NNS 19768 40 93 flatly flatly RB 19768 40 94 contradict contradict VBP 19768 40 95 each each DT 19768 40 96 other other JJ 19768 40 97 , , , 19768 40 98 and and CC 19768 40 99 that that IN 19768 40 100 it -PRON- PRP 19768 40 101 is be VBZ 19768 40 102 self self NN 19768 40 103 - - HYPH 19768 40 104 evidently evidently RB 19768 40 105 impossible impossible JJ 19768 40 106 that that IN 19768 40 107 either either DT 19768 40 108 _ _ NNP 19768 40 109 could could MD 19768 40 110 _ _ NNP 19768 40 111 be be VB 19768 40 112 " " `` 19768 40 113 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 40 114 , , , 19768 40 115 " " '' 19768 40 116 consciously consciously RB 19768 40 117 or or CC 19768 40 118 unconsciously unconsciously RB 19768 40 119 , , , 19768 40 120 from from IN 19768 40 121 the the DT 19768 40 122 other other JJ 19768 40 123 . . . 19768 41 1 If if IN 19768 41 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 41 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 41 4 had have VBD 19768 41 5 ever ever RB 19768 41 6 done do VBN 19768 41 7 any any DT 19768 41 8 hard hard JJ 19768 41 9 thinking thinking NN 19768 41 10 on on IN 19768 41 11 the the DT 19768 41 12 theory theory NN 19768 41 13 of of IN 19768 41 14 universals universal NNS 19768 41 15 , , , 19768 41 16 or or CC 19768 41 17 if if IN 19768 41 18 he -PRON- PRP 19768 41 19 had have VBD 19768 41 20 the the DT 19768 41 21 slightest slight JJS 19768 41 22 comprehension comprehension NN 19768 41 23 of of IN 19768 41 24 the the DT 19768 41 25 problems problem NNS 19768 41 26 it -PRON- PRP 19768 41 27 involves involve VBZ 19768 41 28 , , , 19768 41 29 he -PRON- PRP 19768 41 30 would would MD 19768 41 31 never never RB 19768 41 32 have have VB 19768 41 33 been be VBN 19768 41 34 so so RB 19768 41 35 rash rash JJ 19768 41 36 as as IN 19768 41 37 to to TO 19768 41 38 charge charge VB 19768 41 39 me -PRON- PRP 19768 41 40 with with IN 19768 41 41 " " `` 19768 41 42 borrowing borrow VBG 19768 41 43 " " '' 19768 41 44 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 41 45 theory theory NN 19768 41 46 from from IN 19768 41 47 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 41 48 , , , 19768 41 49 and and CC 19768 41 50 thus thus RB 19768 41 51 to to TO 19768 41 52 commit commit VB 19768 41 53 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 41 54 irrevocably irrevocably RB 19768 41 55 to to IN 19768 41 56 a a DT 19768 41 57 defence defence NN 19768 41 58 of of IN 19768 41 59 the the DT 19768 41 60 absurd absurd JJ 19768 41 61 ; ; : 19768 41 62 but but CC 19768 41 63 eagerness eagerness NN 19768 41 64 to to TO 19768 41 65 accuse accuse VB 19768 41 66 another another DT 19768 41 67 has have VBZ 19768 41 68 betrayed betray VBN 19768 41 69 him -PRON- PRP 19768 41 70 into into IN 19768 41 71 a a DT 19768 41 72 position position NN 19768 41 73 whence whence NN 19768 41 74 it -PRON- PRP 19768 41 75 is be VBZ 19768 41 76 impossible impossible JJ 19768 41 77 for for IN 19768 41 78 him -PRON- PRP 19768 41 79 to to TO 19768 41 80 escape escape VB 19768 41 81 with with IN 19768 41 82 honor honor NN 19768 41 83 . . . 19768 42 1 Solely solely RB 19768 42 2 by by IN 19768 42 3 misdescribing misdescribe VBG 19768 42 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 42 5 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 42 6 as as IN 19768 42 7 " " `` 19768 42 8 essentially essentially RB 19768 42 9 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 42 10 " " '' 19768 42 11 when when WRB 19768 42 12 it -PRON- PRP 19768 42 13 openly openly RB 19768 42 14 and and CC 19768 42 15 constantly constantly RB 19768 42 16 and and CC 19768 42 17 emphatically emphatically RB 19768 42 18 avows avow VBZ 19768 42 19 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 42 20 to to TO 19768 42 21 be be VB 19768 42 22 essentially essentially RB 19768 42 23 realistic realistic JJ 19768 42 24 , , , 19768 42 25 could could MD 19768 42 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 42 27 Royce Royce NNP 19768 42 28 give give VB 19768 42 29 the the DT 19768 42 30 faintest faint JJS 19768 42 31 color color NN 19768 42 32 of of IN 19768 42 33 plausibility plausibility NN 19768 42 34 to to IN 19768 42 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 42 36 monstrous monstrous JJ 19768 42 37 and and CC 19768 42 38 supremely supremely RB 19768 42 39 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 19768 42 40 accusation accusation NN 19768 42 41 of of IN 19768 42 42 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 42 43 ; ; : 19768 42 44 solely solely RB 19768 42 45 by by IN 19768 42 46 presuming presume VBG 19768 42 47 upon upon IN 19768 42 48 the the DT 19768 42 49 public public JJ 19768 42 50 ignorance ignorance NN 19768 42 51 both both DT 19768 42 52 of of IN 19768 42 53 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 42 54 and and CC 19768 42 55 of of IN 19768 42 56 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 42 57 own own JJ 19768 42 58 work work NN 19768 42 59 could could MD 19768 42 60 he -PRON- PRP 19768 42 61 dare dare VB 19768 42 62 to to TO 19768 42 63 publish publish VB 19768 42 64 such such PDT 19768 42 65 an an DT 19768 42 66 accusation accusation NN 19768 42 67 to to IN 19768 42 68 the the DT 19768 42 69 world world NN 19768 42 70 . . . 19768 43 1 These these DT 19768 43 2 gross gross JJ 19768 43 3 misrepresentations misrepresentation NNS 19768 43 4 , , , 19768 43 5 however however RB 19768 43 6 , , , 19768 43 7 he -PRON- PRP 19768 43 8 did do VBD 19768 43 9 not not RB 19768 43 10 hesitate hesitate VB 19768 43 11 to to TO 19768 43 12 make make VB 19768 43 13 , , , 19768 43 14 since since IN 19768 43 15 they -PRON- PRP 19768 43 16 were be VBD 19768 43 17 necessary necessary JJ 19768 43 18 in in IN 19768 43 19 order order NN 19768 43 20 to to TO 19768 43 21 pave pave VB 19768 43 22 the the DT 19768 43 23 way way NN 19768 43 24 to to IN 19768 43 25 a a DT 19768 43 26 third third JJ 19768 43 27 and and CC 19768 43 28 still still RB 19768 43 29 grosser gross JJR 19768 43 30 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 43 31 on on IN 19768 43 32 which which WDT 19768 43 33 he -PRON- PRP 19768 43 34 apparently apparently RB 19768 43 35 had have VBD 19768 43 36 set set VBN 19768 43 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 43 38 heart heart NN 19768 43 39 : : : 19768 43 40 namely namely RB 19768 43 41 , , , 19768 43 42 that that IN 19768 43 43 , , , 19768 43 44 after after IN 19768 43 45 borrowing borrow VBG 19768 43 46 the the DT 19768 43 47 whole whole JJ 19768 43 48 substance substance NN 19768 43 49 of of IN 19768 43 50 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 43 51 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 43 52 from from IN 19768 43 53 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 43 54 , , , 19768 43 55 I -PRON- PRP 19768 43 56 have have VBP 19768 43 57 been be VBN 19768 43 58 guilty guilty JJ 19768 43 59 of of IN 19768 43 60 making make VBG 19768 43 61 " " `` 19768 43 62 vast vast JJ 19768 43 63 and and CC 19768 43 64 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 43 65 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 43 66 " " '' 19768 43 67 as as IN 19768 43 68 to to IN 19768 43 69 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 43 70 own own JJ 19768 43 71 " " `` 19768 43 72 novelty novelty NN 19768 43 73 , , , 19768 43 74 " " '' 19768 43 75 " " `` 19768 43 76 originality originality NN 19768 43 77 , , , 19768 43 78 " " '' 19768 43 79 and and CC 19768 43 80 " " `` 19768 43 81 profundity profundity NN 19768 43 82 , , , 19768 43 83 " " '' 19768 43 84 not not RB 19768 43 85 only only RB 19768 43 86 with with IN 19768 43 87 regard regard NN 19768 43 88 to to IN 19768 43 89 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 43 90 published publish VBN 19768 43 91 books book NNS 19768 43 92 , , , 19768 43 93 but but CC 19768 43 94 also also RB 19768 43 95 with with IN 19768 43 96 regard regard NN 19768 43 97 to to IN 19768 43 98 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 43 99 " " `` 19768 43 100 still still RB 19768 43 101 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 43 102 system system NN 19768 43 103 of of IN 19768 43 104 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 43 105 . . . 19768 43 106 " " '' 19768 44 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19768 44 2 words word NNS 19768 44 3 are be VBP 19768 44 4 these:-- these:-- PRP 19768 44 5 " " `` 19768 44 6 Of of IN 19768 44 7 novelty novelty JJ 19768 44 8 , , , 19768 44 9 good good JJ 19768 44 10 or or CC 19768 44 11 bad bad JJ 19768 44 12 , , , 19768 44 13 the the DT 19768 44 14 book book NN 19768 44 15 contains contain VBZ 19768 44 16 , , , 19768 44 17 indeed indeed RB 19768 44 18 , , , 19768 44 19 despite despite IN 19768 44 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 44 21 vast vast JJ 19768 44 22 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 44 23 , , , 19768 44 24 hardly hardly RB 19768 44 25 a a DT 19768 44 26 sign sign NN 19768 44 27 . . . 19768 44 28 " " '' 19768 45 1 " " `` 19768 45 2 It -PRON- PRP 19768 45 3 is be VBZ 19768 45 4 due due JJ 19768 45 5 also also RB 19768 45 6 to to IN 19768 45 7 the the DT 19768 45 8 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 45 9 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 45 10 which which WDT 19768 45 11 he -PRON- PRP 19768 45 12 frequently frequently RB 19768 45 13 makes make VBZ 19768 45 14 of of RB 19768 45 15 late late RB 19768 45 16 as as IN 19768 45 17 to to IN 19768 45 18 the the DT 19768 45 19 originality originality NN 19768 45 20 and and CC 19768 45 21 profundity profundity NN 19768 45 22 of of IN 19768 45 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 45 24 still still RB 19768 45 25 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 45 26 system system NN 19768 45 27 of of IN 19768 45 28 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 45 29 , , , 19768 45 30 to to TO 19768 45 31 give give VB 19768 45 32 the the DT 19768 45 33 reader reader NN 19768 45 34 some some DT 19768 45 35 hint hint NN 19768 45 36 of of IN 19768 45 37 what what WP 19768 45 38 so so RB 19768 45 39 far far RB 19768 45 40 appears appear VBZ 19768 45 41 to to TO 19768 45 42 be be VB 19768 45 43 the the DT 19768 45 44 nature nature NN 19768 45 45 of of IN 19768 45 46 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 45 47 author author NN 19768 45 48 's 's POS 19768 45 49 contributions contribution NNS 19768 45 50 to to IN 19768 45 51 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 45 52 reflection reflection NN 19768 45 53 . . . 19768 45 54 " " '' 19768 46 1 Precisely precisely RB 19768 46 2 what what WP 19768 46 3 have have VBP 19768 46 4 been be VBN 19768 46 5 these these DT 19768 46 6 alleged allege VBN 19768 46 7 " " `` 19768 46 8 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 46 9 " " '' 19768 46 10 ? ? . 19768 47 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 47 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 47 3 cites cite VBZ 19768 47 4 only only RB 19768 47 5 three three CD 19768 47 6 instances instance NNS 19768 47 7 . . . 19768 48 1 I. I. NNP 19768 49 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 49 2 first first RB 19768 49 3 garbles garble VBZ 19768 49 4 a a DT 19768 49 5 sentence sentence NN 19768 49 6 in in IN 19768 49 7 the the DT 19768 49 8 prefatory prefatory NN 19768 49 9 Note note NN 19768 49 10 to to IN 19768 49 11 " " `` 19768 49 12 The the DT 19768 49 13 Way way NN 19768 49 14 out out IN 19768 49 15 of of IN 19768 49 16 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 19768 49 17 , , , 19768 49 18 " " '' 19768 49 19 by by IN 19768 49 20 quoting quote VBG 19768 49 21 only only RB 19768 49 22 one one CD 19768 49 23 phrase phrase NN 19768 49 24 from from IN 19768 49 25 it -PRON- PRP 19768 49 26 . . . 19768 50 1 The the DT 19768 50 2 sentence sentence NN 19768 50 3 in in IN 19768 50 4 full full JJ 19768 50 5 is be VBZ 19768 50 6 this this DT 19768 50 7 : : : 19768 50 8 " " `` 19768 50 9 By by IN 19768 50 10 a a DT 19768 50 11 wholly wholly RB 19768 50 12 new new JJ 19768 50 13 line line NN 19768 50 14 of of IN 19768 50 15 reasoning reasoning NN 19768 50 16 , , , 19768 50 17 drawn draw VBN 19768 50 18 exclusively exclusively RB 19768 50 19 from from IN 19768 50 20 those those DT 19768 50 21 sources source NNS 19768 50 22 [ [ -LRB- 19768 50 23 science science NN 19768 50 24 and and CC 19768 50 25 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 50 26 ] ] -RRB- 19768 50 27 , , , 19768 50 28 this this DT 19768 50 29 book book NN 19768 50 30 aims aim VBZ 19768 50 31 to to TO 19768 50 32 show show VB 19768 50 33 that that IN 19768 50 34 , , , 19768 50 35 in in IN 19768 50 36 order order NN 19768 50 37 to to TO 19768 50 38 refute refute VB 19768 50 39 agnosticism agnosticism NN 19768 50 40 and and CC 19768 50 41 establish establish VB 19768 50 42 enlightened enlighten VBN 19768 50 43 theism theism NN 19768 50 44 , , , 19768 50 45 nothing nothing NN 19768 50 46 is be VBZ 19768 50 47 now now RB 19768 50 48 necessary necessary JJ 19768 50 49 but but CC 19768 50 50 to to TO 19768 50 51 philosophize philosophize VB 19768 50 52 that that IN 19768 50 53 very very RB 19768 50 54 scientific scientific JJ 19768 50 55 method method NN 19768 50 56 which which WDT 19768 50 57 agnosticism agnosticism NN 19768 50 58 barbarously barbarously RB 19768 50 59 misunderstands misunderstand VBZ 19768 50 60 and and CC 19768 50 61 misuses misuse NNS 19768 50 62 . . . 19768 50 63 " " '' 19768 51 1 There there EX 19768 51 2 is be VBZ 19768 51 3 no no DT 19768 51 4 " " `` 19768 51 5 pretension pretension NN 19768 51 6 " " '' 19768 51 7 whatever whatever WDT 19768 51 8 in in IN 19768 51 9 these these DT 19768 51 10 words word NNS 19768 51 11 , , , 19768 51 12 except except IN 19768 51 13 that that IN 19768 51 14 the the DT 19768 51 15 general general JJ 19768 51 16 " " `` 19768 51 17 line line NN 19768 51 18 of of IN 19768 51 19 reasoning reason VBG 19768 51 20 " " `` 19768 51 21 set set VBN 19768 51 22 forth forth RP 19768 51 23 in in IN 19768 51 24 the the DT 19768 51 25 book book NN 19768 51 26 is be VBZ 19768 51 27 , , , 19768 51 28 _ _ NNP 19768 51 29 as as IN 19768 51 30 a a DT 19768 51 31 whole whole JJ 19768 51 32 _ _ NNP 19768 51 33 , , , 19768 51 34 different different JJ 19768 51 35 from from IN 19768 51 36 that that DT 19768 51 37 of of IN 19768 51 38 other other JJ 19768 51 39 books book NNS 19768 51 40 . . . 19768 52 1 If if IN 19768 52 2 not not RB 19768 52 3 , , , 19768 52 4 why why WRB 19768 52 5 publish publish VB 19768 52 6 it -PRON- PRP 19768 52 7 ? ? . 19768 53 1 Or or CC 19768 53 2 , , , 19768 53 3 without without IN 19768 53 4 the the DT 19768 53 5 same same JJ 19768 53 6 cause cause NN 19768 53 7 , , , 19768 53 8 why why WRB 19768 53 9 publish publish VB 19768 53 10 any any DT 19768 53 11 book book NN 19768 53 12 ? ? . 19768 54 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 54 2 see see VBP 19768 54 3 no no DT 19768 54 4 reason reason NN 19768 54 5 to to TO 19768 54 6 recall recall VB 19768 54 7 or or CC 19768 54 8 to to TO 19768 54 9 modify modify VB 19768 54 10 this this DT 19768 54 11 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 54 12 true true JJ 19768 54 13 statement statement NN 19768 54 14 ; ; : 19768 54 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 54 16 Royce Royce NNP 19768 54 17 , , , 19768 54 18 at at IN 19768 54 19 least least JJS 19768 54 20 , , , 19768 54 21 has have VBZ 19768 54 22 shown show VBN 19768 54 23 none none NN 19768 54 24 . . . 19768 55 1 The the DT 19768 55 2 " " `` 19768 55 3 novelty novelty NN 19768 55 4 " " '' 19768 55 5 of of IN 19768 55 6 the the DT 19768 55 7 book book NN 19768 55 8 lies lie VBZ 19768 55 9 in in IN 19768 55 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 55 11 very very JJ 19768 55 12 attempt attempt NN 19768 55 13 to to TO 19768 55 14 evolve evolve VB 19768 55 15 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 55 16 as as IN 19768 55 17 a a DT 19768 55 18 whole whole NN 19768 55 19 out out IN 19768 55 20 of of IN 19768 55 21 the the DT 19768 55 22 scientific scientific JJ 19768 55 23 method method NN 19768 55 24 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 55 25 , , , 19768 55 26 as as IN 19768 55 27 " " `` 19768 55 28 observation observation NN 19768 55 29 , , , 19768 55 30 hypothesis hypothesis NN 19768 55 31 , , , 19768 55 32 and and CC 19768 55 33 experimental experimental JJ 19768 55 34 verification verification NN 19768 55 35 , , , 19768 55 36 " " '' 19768 55 37 by by IN 19768 55 38 developing develop VBG 19768 55 39 the the DT 19768 55 40 theory theory NN 19768 55 41 of of IN 19768 55 42 universals universal NNS 19768 55 43 which which WDT 19768 55 44 is be VBZ 19768 55 45 implicit implicit JJ 19768 55 46 in in IN 19768 55 47 that that DT 19768 55 48 purely purely RB 19768 55 49 experiential experiential JJ 19768 55 50 method method NN 19768 55 51 ; ; : 19768 55 52 and and CC 19768 55 53 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 55 54 Royce Royce NNP 19768 55 55 does do VBZ 19768 55 56 not not RB 19768 55 57 even even RB 19768 55 58 try try VB 19768 55 59 to to TO 19768 55 60 prove prove VB 19768 55 61 that that IN 19768 55 62 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 55 63 , , , 19768 55 64 or or CC 19768 55 65 anybody anybody NN 19768 55 66 else else RB 19768 55 67 , , , 19768 55 68 has have VBZ 19768 55 69 ever ever RB 19768 55 70 made make VBN 19768 55 71 just just RB 19768 55 72 such such PDT 19768 55 73 an an DT 19768 55 74 attempt attempt NN 19768 55 75 as as IN 19768 55 76 that that DT 19768 55 77 . . . 19768 56 1 Unless unless IN 19768 56 2 there there EX 19768 56 3 can can MD 19768 56 4 be be VB 19768 56 5 shown show VBN 19768 56 6 somewhere somewhere RB 19768 56 7 a a DT 19768 56 8 _ _ NNP 19768 56 9 parallel parallel NN 19768 56 10 attempt attempt NN 19768 56 11 _ _ NNP 19768 56 12 , , , 19768 56 13 the the DT 19768 56 14 statement statement NN 19768 56 15 is be VBZ 19768 56 16 as as RB 19768 56 17 undeniably undeniably RB 19768 56 18 true true JJ 19768 56 19 as as IN 19768 56 20 it -PRON- PRP 19768 56 21 is be VBZ 19768 56 22 certainly certainly RB 19768 56 23 unpretentious unpretentious JJ 19768 56 24 . . . 19768 57 1 II ii CD 19768 57 2 . . . 19768 58 1 Next next RB 19768 58 2 , , , 19768 58 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 58 4 Royce Royce NNP 19768 58 5 extracts extract VBZ 19768 58 6 these these DT 19768 58 7 sentences sentence NNS 19768 58 8 from from IN 19768 58 9 the the DT 19768 58 10 body body NN 19768 58 11 of of IN 19768 58 12 the the DT 19768 58 13 book book NN 19768 58 14 ( ( -LRB- 19768 58 15 I -PRON- PRP 19768 58 16 supply supply VBP 19768 58 17 in in IN 19768 58 18 brackets bracket NNS 19768 58 19 words word NNS 19768 58 20 which which WDT 19768 58 21 he -PRON- PRP 19768 58 22 omitted omit VBD 19768 58 23 ) ) -RRB- 19768 58 24 : : : 19768 58 25 " " `` 19768 58 26 The the DT 19768 58 27 first first JJ 19768 58 28 great great JJ 19768 58 29 task task NN 19768 58 30 of of IN 19768 58 31 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 58 32 is be VBZ 19768 58 33 to to TO 19768 58 34 lay lay VB 19768 58 35 deep deep JJ 19768 58 36 and and CC 19768 58 37 solid solid JJ 19768 58 38 foundations foundation NNS 19768 58 39 for for IN 19768 58 40 the the DT 19768 58 41 expansion expansion NN 19768 58 42 [ [ -LRB- 19768 58 43 and and CC 19768 58 44 ideal ideal JJ 19768 58 45 perfection perfection NN 19768 58 46 ] ] -RRB- 19768 58 47 of of IN 19768 58 48 human human JJ 19768 58 49 knowledge knowledge NN 19768 58 50 in in IN 19768 58 51 a a DT 19768 58 52 bold bold JJ 19768 58 53 , , , 19768 58 54 new new JJ 19768 58 55 , , , 19768 58 56 and and CC 19768 58 57 true true JJ 19768 58 58 theory theory NN 19768 58 59 of of IN 19768 58 60 universals universal NNS 19768 58 61 . . . 19768 59 1 For for IN 19768 59 2 so so RB 19768 59 3 - - HYPH 19768 59 4 called call VBN 19768 59 5 modern modern JJ 19768 59 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 59 7 rests rest VBZ 19768 59 8 complacently complacently RB 19768 59 9 in in IN 19768 59 10 a a DT 19768 59 11 theory theory NN 19768 59 12 of of IN 19768 59 13 universals universal NNS 19768 59 14 which which WDT 19768 59 15 is be VBZ 19768 59 16 thoroughly thoroughly RB 19768 59 17 mediæval mediæval NN 19768 59 18 or or CC 19768 59 19 antiquated antiquated JJ 19768 59 20 . . . 19768 59 21 " " '' 19768 60 1 What what WDT 19768 60 2 personal personal JJ 19768 60 3 pretension pretension NN 19768 60 4 , , , 19768 60 5 even even RB 19768 60 6 of of IN 19768 60 7 the the DT 19768 60 8 mildest mild JJS 19768 60 9 sort sort NN 19768 60 10 , , , 19768 60 11 can can MD 19768 60 12 be be VB 19768 60 13 conceived conceive VBN 19768 60 14 to to IN 19768 60 15 lurk lurk VB 19768 60 16 in in IN 19768 60 17 these these DT 19768 60 18 innocent innocent JJ 19768 60 19 words word NNS 19768 60 20 ? ? . 19768 61 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 61 2 did do VBD 19768 61 3 not not RB 19768 61 4 say say VB 19768 61 5 that that IN 19768 61 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 61 7 have have VBP 19768 61 8 succeeded succeed VBN 19768 61 9 in in IN 19768 61 10 performing perform VBG 19768 61 11 that that IN 19768 61 12 " " `` 19768 61 13 task task NN 19768 61 14 " " '' 19768 61 15 ; ; : 19768 61 16 I -PRON- PRP 19768 61 17 repeat repeat VBP 19768 61 18 now now RB 19768 61 19 what what WP 19768 61 20 I -PRON- PRP 19768 61 21 have have VBP 19768 61 22 often often RB 19768 61 23 said say VBN 19768 61 24 and and CC 19768 61 25 what what WP 19768 61 26 I -PRON- PRP 19768 61 27 meant mean VBD 19768 61 28 then then RB 19768 61 29 ; ; : 19768 61 30 namely namely RB 19768 61 31 , , , 19768 61 32 that that IN 19768 61 33 modern modern JJ 19768 61 34 science science NN 19768 61 35 has have VBZ 19768 61 36 unawares unawares RB 19768 61 37 performed perform VBN 19768 61 38 it -PRON- PRP 19768 61 39 already already RB 19768 61 40 , , , 19768 61 41 that that IN 19768 61 42 I -PRON- PRP 19768 61 43 have have VBP 19768 61 44 faithfully faithfully RB 19768 61 45 tried try VBN 19768 61 46 to to TO 19768 61 47 formulate formulate VB 19768 61 48 and and CC 19768 61 49 further further RB 19768 61 50 apply apply VB 19768 61 51 what what WP 19768 61 52 science science NN 19768 61 53 has have VBZ 19768 61 54 done do VBN 19768 61 55 , , , 19768 61 56 and and CC 19768 61 57 that that IN 19768 61 58 I -PRON- PRP 19768 61 59 respectfully respectfully RB 19768 61 60 submit submit VBP 19768 61 61 the the DT 19768 61 62 result result NN 19768 61 63 ( ( -LRB- 19768 61 64 so so RB 19768 61 65 far far RB 19768 61 66 as as IN 19768 61 67 already already RB 19768 61 68 published publish VBN 19768 61 69 ) ) -RRB- 19768 61 70 , , , 19768 61 71 not not RB 19768 61 72 to to IN 19768 61 73 such such JJ 19768 61 74 critics critic NNS 19768 61 75 as as IN 19768 61 76 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 61 77 Royce Royce NNP 19768 61 78 , , , 19768 61 79 but but CC 19768 61 80 to to IN 19768 61 81 able able JJ 19768 61 82 , , , 19768 61 83 learned learn VBN 19768 61 84 , , , 19768 61 85 and and CC 19768 61 86 magnanimous magnanimous JJ 19768 61 87 students student NNS 19768 61 88 of of IN 19768 61 89 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 61 90 everywhere everywhere RB 19768 61 91 . . . 19768 62 1 III iii CD 19768 62 2 . . . 19768 63 1 Lastly lastly RB 19768 63 2 , , , 19768 63 3 though though IN 19768 63 4 employing employ VBG 19768 63 5 quotation quotation NN 19768 63 6 marks mark NNS 19768 63 7 so so IN 19768 63 8 as as IN 19768 63 9 to to TO 19768 63 10 evade evade VB 19768 63 11 a a DT 19768 63 12 charge charge NN 19768 63 13 of of IN 19768 63 14 formal formal JJ 19768 63 15 misquotation misquotation NN 19768 63 16 , , , 19768 63 17 he -PRON- PRP 19768 63 18 perverts pervert VBZ 19768 63 19 and and CC 19768 63 20 effectually effectually RB 19768 63 21 misquotes misquote VBZ 19768 63 22 a a DT 19768 63 23 sentence sentence NN 19768 63 24 of of IN 19768 63 25 the the DT 19768 63 26 book book NN 19768 63 27 in in IN 19768 63 28 a a DT 19768 63 29 way way NN 19768 63 30 which which WDT 19768 63 31 makes make VBZ 19768 63 32 it -PRON- PRP 19768 63 33 appear appear VB 19768 63 34 exactly exactly RB 19768 63 35 what what WP 19768 63 36 it -PRON- PRP 19768 63 37 is be VBZ 19768 63 38 not,--"pretentious not,--"pretentious JJ 19768 63 39 . . . 19768 63 40 " " '' 19768 64 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 64 2 had have VBD 19768 64 3 said say VBN 19768 64 4 at at IN 19768 64 5 the the DT 19768 64 6 end end NN 19768 64 7 of of IN 19768 64 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 64 9 own own JJ 19768 64 10 book book NN 19768 64 11 ( ( -LRB- 19768 64 12 page page NN 19768 64 13 75 75 CD 19768 64 14 ) ) -RRB- 19768 64 15 : : : 19768 64 16 " " `` 19768 64 17 _ _ NNP 19768 64 18 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 64 19 aim aim NN 19768 64 20 has have VBZ 19768 64 21 been be VBN 19768 64 22 to to TO 19768 64 23 show show VB 19768 64 24 _ _ NNP 19768 64 25 the the DT 19768 64 26 way way NN 19768 64 27 out out IN 19768 64 28 of of IN 19768 64 29 agnosticism agnosticism NN 19768 64 30 into into IN 19768 64 31 the the DT 19768 64 32 sunlight sunlight NN 19768 64 33 of of IN 19768 64 34 the the DT 19768 64 35 predestined predestined JJ 19768 64 36 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 64 37 of of IN 19768 64 38 science science NN 19768 64 39 . . . 19768 64 40 " " '' 19768 65 1 This this DT 19768 65 2 expression expression NN 19768 65 3 is be VBZ 19768 65 4 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 65 5 in in IN 19768 65 6 harmony harmony NN 19768 65 7 with with IN 19768 65 8 the the DT 19768 65 9 prefatory prefatory NN 19768 65 10 Note note NN 19768 65 11 , , , 19768 65 12 which which WDT 19768 65 13 says say VBZ 19768 65 14 that that IN 19768 65 15 " " `` 19768 65 16 _ _ NNP 19768 65 17 this this DT 19768 65 18 book book NN 19768 65 19 aims aim VBZ 19768 65 20 to to TO 19768 65 21 show show VB 19768 65 22 _ _ NNP 19768 65 23 that that DT 19768 65 24 , , , 19768 65 25 in in IN 19768 65 26 order order NN 19768 65 27 to to TO 19768 65 28 refute refute VB 19768 65 29 agnosticism agnosticism NN 19768 65 30 and and CC 19768 65 31 establish establish VB 19768 65 32 enlightened enlighten VBN 19768 65 33 theism theism NN 19768 65 34 , , , 19768 65 35 nothing nothing NN 19768 65 36 is be VBZ 19768 65 37 now now RB 19768 65 38 necessary necessary JJ 19768 65 39 but but CC 19768 65 40 to to TO 19768 65 41 philosophize philosophize VB 19768 65 42 that that IN 19768 65 43 very very RB 19768 65 44 scientific scientific JJ 19768 65 45 method method NN 19768 65 46 which which WDT 19768 65 47 agnosticism agnosticism NN 19768 65 48 barbarously barbarously RB 19768 65 49 misunderstands misunderstand VBZ 19768 65 50 and and CC 19768 65 51 misuses misuse NNS 19768 65 52 , , , 19768 65 53 " " '' 19768 65 54 and and CC 19768 65 55 which which WDT 19768 65 56 immediately immediately RB 19768 65 57 adds add VBZ 19768 65 58 : : : 19768 65 59 " " `` 19768 65 60 _ _ NNP 19768 65 61 Of of IN 19768 65 62 the the DT 19768 65 63 success success NN 19768 65 64 of of IN 19768 65 65 the the DT 19768 65 66 perhaps perhaps RB 19768 65 67 unwise unwise JJ 19768 65 68 attempt attempt NN 19768 65 69 to to TO 19768 65 70 show show VB 19768 65 71 this this DT 19768 65 72 in in IN 19768 65 73 so so RB 19768 65 74 small small JJ 19768 65 75 a a DT 19768 65 76 compass compass NN 19768 65 77 , , , 19768 65 78 the the DT 19768 65 79 educated educate VBN 19768 65 80 public public NN 19768 65 81 must must MD 19768 65 82 be be VB 19768 65 83 the the DT 19768 65 84 judge judge NN 19768 65 85 . . . 19768 65 86 _ _ NNP 19768 65 87 " " `` 19768 65 88 Most most RBS 19768 65 89 certainly certainly RB 19768 65 90 , , , 19768 65 91 there there EX 19768 65 92 is be VBZ 19768 65 93 no no DT 19768 65 94 " " `` 19768 65 95 pretension pretension NN 19768 65 96 " " '' 19768 65 97 in in IN 19768 65 98 this this DT 19768 65 99 modest modest JJ 19768 65 100 and and CC 19768 65 101 carefully carefully RB 19768 65 102 guarded guard VBN 19768 65 103 avowal avowal NN 19768 65 104 of of IN 19768 65 105 the the DT 19768 65 106 simple simple JJ 19768 65 107 aim aim NN 19768 65 108 of of IN 19768 65 109 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 65 110 book book NN 19768 65 111 . . . 19768 66 1 But but CC 19768 66 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 66 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 66 4 twists twist VBZ 19768 66 5 this this DT 19768 66 6 modest modest JJ 19768 66 7 avowal avowal NN 19768 66 8 into into IN 19768 66 9 a a DT 19768 66 10 barefaced bareface VBN 19768 66 11 boast boast NN 19768 66 12 , , , 19768 66 13 and and CC 19768 66 14 injuriously injuriously RB 19768 66 15 misquotes misquote VBZ 19768 66 16 me -PRON- PRP 19768 66 17 to to IN 19768 66 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 66 19 own own JJ 19768 66 20 readers reader NNS 19768 66 21 thus thus RB 19768 66 22 : : : 19768 66 23 " " `` 19768 66 24 At at IN 19768 66 25 the the DT 19768 66 26 conclusion conclusion NN 19768 66 27 of of IN 19768 66 28 the the DT 19768 66 29 book book NN 19768 66 30 , , , 19768 66 31 we -PRON- PRP 19768 66 32 learn learn VBP 19768 66 33 that that IN 19768 66 34 _ _ NNP 19768 66 35 we -PRON- PRP 19768 66 36 have have VBP 19768 66 37 been be VBN 19768 66 38 shown show VBN 19768 66 39 _ _ IN 19768 66 40 ' ' '' 19768 66 41 the the DT 19768 66 42 way way NN 19768 66 43 out out IN 19768 66 44 of of IN 19768 66 45 agnosticism agnosticism NN 19768 66 46 into into IN 19768 66 47 the the DT 19768 66 48 sunlight sunlight NN 19768 66 49 of of IN 19768 66 50 the the DT 19768 66 51 predestined predestined JJ 19768 66 52 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 66 53 of of IN 19768 66 54 science science NN 19768 66 55 . . . 19768 66 56 ' ' '' 19768 66 57 " " '' 19768 67 1 Gentlemen Gentlemen NNP 19768 67 2 , , , 19768 67 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 67 4 request request VBP 19768 67 5 you -PRON- PRP 19768 67 6 to to TO 19768 67 7 compare compare VB 19768 67 8 thoughtfully thoughtfully RB 19768 67 9 the the DT 19768 67 10 expressions expression NNS 19768 67 11 which which WDT 19768 67 12 I -PRON- PRP 19768 67 13 have have VBP 19768 67 14 here here RB 19768 67 15 italicized italicize VBN 19768 67 16 , , , 19768 67 17 and and CC 19768 67 18 then then RB 19768 67 19 decide decide VB 19768 67 20 for for IN 19768 67 21 yourselves yourself NNS 19768 67 22 whether whether IN 19768 67 23 this this DT 19768 67 24 injurious injurious JJ 19768 67 25 misquotation misquotation NN 19768 67 26 is be VBZ 19768 67 27 purely purely RB 19768 67 28 accidental accidental JJ 19768 67 29 , , , 19768 67 30 or or CC 19768 67 31 , , , 19768 67 32 in in IN 19768 67 33 view view NN 19768 67 34 of of IN 19768 67 35 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 67 36 Royce Royce NNP 19768 67 37 's 's POS 19768 67 38 purpose purpose NN 19768 67 39 of of IN 19768 67 40 proving prove VBG 19768 67 41 me -PRON- PRP 19768 67 42 guilty guilty JJ 19768 67 43 of of IN 19768 67 44 " " `` 19768 67 45 vast vast JJ 19768 67 46 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 67 47 , , , 19768 67 48 " " '' 19768 67 49 quite quite RB 19768 67 50 too too RB 19768 67 51 useful useful JJ 19768 67 52 to to TO 19768 67 53 be be VB 19768 67 54 purely purely RB 19768 67 55 accidental accidental JJ 19768 67 56 . . . 19768 68 1 IV IV NNP 19768 68 2 . . . 19768 69 1 But but CC 19768 69 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 69 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 69 4 does do VBZ 19768 69 5 not not RB 19768 69 6 content content VB 19768 69 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 69 8 with with IN 19768 69 9 quoting quoting NN 19768 69 10 or or CC 19768 69 11 misquoting misquote VBG 19768 69 12 what what WP 19768 69 13 I -PRON- PRP 19768 69 14 have have VBP 19768 69 15 published publish VBN 19768 69 16 , , , 19768 69 17 for for IN 19768 69 18 the the DT 19768 69 19 self self NN 19768 69 20 - - HYPH 19768 69 21 evident evident JJ 19768 69 22 reason reason NN 19768 69 23 that that IN 19768 69 24 what what WP 19768 69 25 I -PRON- PRP 19768 69 26 have have VBP 19768 69 27 published publish VBN 19768 69 28 is be VBZ 19768 69 29 not not RB 19768 69 30 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19768 69 31 " " `` 19768 69 32 pretentious pretentious JJ 19768 69 33 " " '' 19768 69 34 for for IN 19768 69 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 69 36 purpose purpose NN 19768 69 37 . . . 19768 70 1 Disinterested disintereste VBN 19768 70 2 anxiety anxiety NN 19768 70 3 for for IN 19768 70 4 the the DT 19768 70 5 public public JJ 19768 70 6 welfare welfare NN 19768 70 7 , , , 19768 70 8 and and CC 19768 70 9 tender tender NN 19768 70 10 sorrow sorrow NN 19768 70 11 over over IN 19768 70 12 the the DT 19768 70 13 " " `` 19768 70 14 harm harm NN 19768 70 15 to to IN 19768 70 16 careful careful JJ 19768 70 17 inquiry inquiry NN 19768 70 18 " " '' 19768 70 19 which which WDT 19768 70 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 70 21 book book NN 19768 70 22 is be VBZ 19768 70 23 doing do VBG 19768 70 24 by by IN 19768 70 25 " " `` 19768 70 26 getting get VBG 19768 70 27 influence influence NN 19768 70 28 over over IN 19768 70 29 immature immature JJ 19768 70 30 or or CC 19768 70 31 imperfectly imperfectly RB 19768 70 32 trained train VBN 19768 70 33 minds mind NNS 19768 70 34 , , , 19768 70 35 " " '' 19768 70 36 constrain constrain VB 19768 70 37 him -PRON- PRP 19768 70 38 to to TO 19768 70 39 accuse accuse VB 19768 70 40 me -PRON- PRP 19768 70 41 of of IN 19768 70 42 " " `` 19768 70 43 frequently frequently RB 19768 70 44 making make VBG 19768 70 45 of of IN 19768 70 46 late late JJ 19768 70 47 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 70 48 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 70 49 as as IN 19768 70 50 to to IN 19768 70 51 the the DT 19768 70 52 originality originality NN 19768 70 53 and and CC 19768 70 54 profundity profundity NN 19768 70 55 " " '' 19768 70 56 of of IN 19768 70 57 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 70 58 " " '' 19768 70 59 still still RB 19768 70 60 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 70 61 system system NN 19768 70 62 of of IN 19768 70 63 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 70 64 . . . 19768 70 65 " " '' 19768 71 1 Precisely precisely RB 19768 71 2 what what WP 19768 71 3 have have VBP 19768 71 4 been be VBN 19768 71 5 these these DT 19768 71 6 " " `` 19768 71 7 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 71 8 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 71 9 " " '' 19768 71 10 ? ? . 19768 72 1 Simply simply RB 19768 72 2 these:-- these:-- ADD 19768 72 3 In in IN 19768 72 4 the the DT 19768 72 5 preface preface NN 19768 72 6 to to IN 19768 72 7 " " `` 19768 72 8 Scientific scientific JJ 19768 72 9 Theism theism NN 19768 72 10 , , , 19768 72 11 " " '' 19768 72 12 I -PRON- PRP 19768 72 13 said say VBD 19768 72 14 of of IN 19768 72 15 that that DT 19768 72 16 book book NN 19768 72 17 : : : 19768 72 18 " " `` 19768 72 19 It -PRON- PRP 19768 72 20 is be VBZ 19768 72 21 a a DT 19768 72 22 mere mere JJ 19768 72 23 _ _ NNP 19768 72 24 résumé résumé NN 19768 72 25 _ _ NNP 19768 72 26 of of IN 19768 72 27 a a DT 19768 72 28 small small JJ 19768 72 29 portion portion NN 19768 72 30 of of IN 19768 72 31 a a DT 19768 72 32 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19768 72 33 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 72 34 system system NN 19768 72 35 , , , 19768 72 36 so so RB 19768 72 37 far far RB 19768 72 38 as as IN 19768 72 39 I -PRON- PRP 19768 72 40 have have VBP 19768 72 41 been be VBN 19768 72 42 able able JJ 19768 72 43 to to TO 19768 72 44 work work VB 19768 72 45 it -PRON- PRP 19768 72 46 out out RP 19768 72 47 under under IN 19768 72 48 most most JJS 19768 72 49 distracting distracting JJ 19768 72 50 , , , 19768 72 51 discouraging discouraging NN 19768 72 52 , , , 19768 72 53 and and CC 19768 72 54 unpropitious unpropitious JJ 19768 72 55 circumstances circumstance NNS 19768 72 56 of of IN 19768 72 57 many many JJ 19768 72 58 years year NNS 19768 72 59 ; ; : 19768 72 60 and and CC 19768 72 61 for for IN 19768 72 62 this this DT 19768 72 63 reason reason NN 19768 72 64 I -PRON- PRP 19768 72 65 must must MD 19768 72 66 beg beg VB 19768 72 67 some some DT 19768 72 68 indulgence indulgence NN 19768 72 69 for for IN 19768 72 70 the the DT 19768 72 71 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19768 72 72 incompleteness incompleteness NN 19768 72 73 of of IN 19768 72 74 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 72 75 work work NN 19768 72 76 . . . 19768 72 77 " " '' 19768 73 1 Enumerating enumerate VBG 19768 73 2 some some DT 19768 73 3 reasons reason NNS 19768 73 4 why why WRB 19768 73 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 73 6 hesitated hesitate VBD 19768 73 7 to to TO 19768 73 8 begin begin VB 19768 73 9 the the DT 19768 73 10 series series NN 19768 73 11 of of IN 19768 73 12 papers paper NNS 19768 73 13 afterwards afterwards RB 19768 73 14 published publish VBN 19768 73 15 as as IN 19768 73 16 " " `` 19768 73 17 The the DT 19768 73 18 Way way NN 19768 73 19 out out IN 19768 73 20 of of IN 19768 73 21 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 19768 73 22 , , , 19768 73 23 " " '' 19768 73 24 I -PRON- PRP 19768 73 25 said say VBD 19768 73 26 , , , 19768 73 27 in in IN 19768 73 28 the the DT 19768 73 29 first first JJ 19768 73 30 of of IN 19768 73 31 these these DT 19768 73 32 papers paper NNS 19768 73 33 : : : 19768 73 34 " " `` 19768 73 35 First first RB 19768 73 36 and and CC 19768 73 37 foremost foremost RB 19768 73 38 , , , 19768 73 39 perhaps perhaps RB 19768 73 40 , , , 19768 73 41 is be VBZ 19768 73 42 the the DT 19768 73 43 fact fact NN 19768 73 44 that that IN 19768 73 45 , , , 19768 73 46 although although IN 19768 73 47 the the DT 19768 73 48 ground ground NN 19768 73 49 - - HYPH 19768 73 50 plan plan NN 19768 73 51 of of IN 19768 73 52 this this DT 19768 73 53 theory theory NN 19768 73 54 is be VBZ 19768 73 55 already already RB 19768 73 56 thoroughly thoroughly RB 19768 73 57 matured mature VBN 19768 73 58 , , , 19768 73 59 the the DT 19768 73 60 literary literary JJ 19768 73 61 execution execution NN 19768 73 62 of of IN 19768 73 63 it -PRON- PRP 19768 73 64 is be VBZ 19768 73 65 as as RB 19768 73 66 yet yet RB 19768 73 67 scarcely scarcely RB 19768 73 68 even even RB 19768 73 69 begun begin VBN 19768 73 70 , , , 19768 73 71 and and CC 19768 73 72 from from IN 19768 73 73 want want NN 19768 73 74 of of IN 19768 73 75 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 73 76 may may MD 19768 73 77 never never RB 19768 73 78 be be VB 19768 73 79 completed complete VBN 19768 73 80 ; ; : 19768 73 81 and and CC 19768 73 82 it -PRON- PRP 19768 73 83 seems seem VBZ 19768 73 84 almost almost RB 19768 73 85 absurd absurd JJ 19768 73 86 to to TO 19768 73 87 present present VB 19768 73 88 the the DT 19768 73 89 abridgment abridgment NN 19768 73 90 of of IN 19768 73 91 a a DT 19768 73 92 work work NN 19768 73 93 which which WDT 19768 73 94 does do VBZ 19768 73 95 not not RB 19768 73 96 yet yet RB 19768 73 97 exist exist VB 19768 73 98 to to TO 19768 73 99 be be VB 19768 73 100 abridged abridge VBN 19768 73 101 . . . 19768 73 102 " " '' 19768 74 1 Finally finally RB 19768 74 2 , , , 19768 74 3 in in IN 19768 74 4 an an DT 19768 74 5 address address NN 19768 74 6 printed print VBN 19768 74 7 in in IN 19768 74 8 the the DT 19768 74 9 " " `` 19768 74 10 Unitarian Unitarian NNP 19768 74 11 Review Review NNP 19768 74 12 " " '' 19768 74 13 for for IN 19768 74 14 December December NNP 19768 74 15 , , , 19768 74 16 1889 1889 CD 19768 74 17 , , , 19768 74 18 I -PRON- PRP 19768 74 19 said say VBD 19768 74 20 : : : 19768 74 21 " " `` 19768 74 22 Without without IN 19768 74 23 advancing advance VBG 19768 74 24 any any DT 19768 74 25 personal personal JJ 19768 74 26 claim claim NN 19768 74 27 whatever whatever WDT 19768 74 28 , , , 19768 74 29 permit permit VB 19768 74 30 me -PRON- PRP 19768 74 31 to to TO 19768 74 32 take take VB 19768 74 33 advantage advantage NN 19768 74 34 of of IN 19768 74 35 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 74 36 indulgent indulgent JJ 19768 74 37 kindness kindness NN 19768 74 38 , , , 19768 74 39 and and CC 19768 74 40 to to TO 19768 74 41 make make VB 19768 74 42 here here RB 19768 74 43 the the DT 19768 74 44 first first JJ 19768 74 45 public public JJ 19768 74 46 confession confession NN 19768 74 47 of of IN 19768 74 48 certain certain JJ 19768 74 49 painfully painfully RB 19768 74 50 matured mature VBN 19768 74 51 results result NNS 19768 74 52 of of IN 19768 74 53 thirty thirty CD 19768 74 54 years year NNS 19768 74 55 ' ' POS 19768 74 56 thinking thinking NN 19768 74 57 , , , 19768 74 58 which which WDT 19768 74 59 , , , 19768 74 60 in in IN 19768 74 61 the the DT 19768 74 62 momentous momentous JJ 19768 74 63 and and CC 19768 74 64 arduous arduous JJ 19768 74 65 enterprise enterprise NN 19768 74 66 of of IN 19768 74 67 developing develop VBG 19768 74 68 a a DT 19768 74 69 scientific scientific JJ 19768 74 70 theology theology NN 19768 74 71 out out IN 19768 74 72 of of IN 19768 74 73 the the DT 19768 74 74 scientific scientific JJ 19768 74 75 method method NN 19768 74 76 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 74 77 , , , 19768 74 78 appear appear VB 19768 74 79 to to TO 19768 74 80 be be VB 19768 74 81 principles principle NNS 19768 74 82 of of IN 19768 74 83 cosmical cosmical JJ 19768 74 84 import import NN 19768 74 85 .... .... . 19768 74 86 Perhaps perhaps RB 19768 74 87 I -PRON- PRP 19768 74 88 can can MD 19768 74 89 make make VB 19768 74 90 them -PRON- PRP 19768 74 91 intelligible intelligible JJ 19768 74 92 , , , 19768 74 93 as as IN 19768 74 94 a a DT 19768 74 95 contribution contribution NN 19768 74 96 to to IN 19768 74 97 that that DT 19768 74 98 ' ' `` 19768 74 99 Unitary Unitary NNP 19768 74 100 Science Science NNP 19768 74 101 ' ' '' 19768 74 102 which which WDT 19768 74 103 the the DT 19768 74 104 great great JJ 19768 74 105 Agassiz Agassiz NNP 19768 74 106 foresaw foresaw NN 19768 74 107 and and CC 19768 74 108 foretold foretold NN 19768 74 109 . . . 19768 74 110 " " '' 19768 75 1 In in IN 19768 75 2 a a DT 19768 75 3 postscript postscript NN 19768 75 4 to to IN 19768 75 5 this this DT 19768 75 6 address address NN 19768 75 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 75 8 added add VBD 19768 75 9 : : : 19768 75 10 " " `` 19768 75 11 For for IN 19768 75 12 fuller full JJR 19768 75 13 support support NN 19768 75 14 of of IN 19768 75 15 the the DT 19768 75 16 position position NN 19768 75 17 taken take VBN 19768 75 18 above above RB 19768 75 19 , , , 19768 75 20 I -PRON- PRP 19768 75 21 am be VBP 19768 75 22 constrained constrain VBN 19768 75 23 to to TO 19768 75 24 refer refer VB 19768 75 25 ... ... NFP 19768 75 26 to to IN 19768 75 27 a a DT 19768 75 28 large large JJ 19768 75 29 treatise treatise NN 19768 75 30 , , , 19768 75 31 now now RB 19768 75 32 in in IN 19768 75 33 process process NN 19768 75 34 of of IN 19768 75 35 preparation preparation NN 19768 75 36 , , , 19768 75 37 which which WDT 19768 75 38 aims aim VBZ 19768 75 39 to to TO 19768 75 40 rethink rethink VB 19768 75 41 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 75 42 as as IN 19768 75 43 a a DT 19768 75 44 whole whole NN 19768 75 45 in in IN 19768 75 46 the the DT 19768 75 47 light light NN 19768 75 48 of of IN 19768 75 49 modern modern JJ 19768 75 50 science science NN 19768 75 51 and and CC 19768 75 52 under under IN 19768 75 53 the the DT 19768 75 54 form form NN 19768 75 55 of of IN 19768 75 56 a a DT 19768 75 57 natural natural JJ 19768 75 58 development development NN 19768 75 59 of of IN 19768 75 60 the the DT 19768 75 61 scientific scientific JJ 19768 75 62 method method NN 19768 75 63 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 75 64 . . . 19768 75 65 " " '' 19768 76 1 What what WP 19768 76 2 remotest remotest VBD 19768 76 3 allusion allusion NN 19768 76 4 to to IN 19768 76 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 76 6 own own JJ 19768 76 7 " " `` 19768 76 8 originality originality NN 19768 76 9 " " '' 19768 76 10 is be VBZ 19768 76 11 contained contain VBN 19768 76 12 in in IN 19768 76 13 these these DT 19768 76 14 passages passage NNS 19768 76 15 , , , 19768 76 16 or or CC 19768 76 17 what what WP 19768 76 18 remotest remotest VBD 19768 76 19 allusion allusion NN 19768 76 20 to to IN 19768 76 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 76 22 own own JJ 19768 76 23 " " `` 19768 76 24 profundity profundity NN 19768 76 25 " " '' 19768 76 26 ? ? . 19768 77 1 What what WP 19768 77 2 " " `` 19768 77 3 pretension pretension NN 19768 77 4 " " '' 19768 77 5 of of IN 19768 77 6 any any DT 19768 77 7 sort sort NN 19768 77 8 is be VBZ 19768 77 9 here here RB 19768 77 10 made make VBN 19768 77 11 , , , 19768 77 12 whether whether IN 19768 77 13 " " `` 19768 77 14 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 77 15 " " '' 19768 77 16 or or CC 19768 77 17 moderate moderate JJ 19768 77 18 ? ? . 19768 78 1 Yet yet CC 19768 78 2 this this DT 19768 78 3 is be VBZ 19768 78 4 the the DT 19768 78 5 only only JJ 19768 78 6 actual actual JJ 19768 78 7 evidence evidence NN 19768 78 8 , , , 19768 78 9 _ _ NNP 19768 78 10 and and CC 19768 78 11 the the DT 19768 78 12 whole whole NN 19768 78 13 of of IN 19768 78 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 78 15 _ _ NNP 19768 78 16 , , , 19768 78 17 on on IN 19768 78 18 which which WDT 19768 78 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 78 20 Royce Royce NNP 19768 78 21 dares dare VBZ 19768 78 22 to to TO 19768 78 23 accuse accuse VB 19768 78 24 me -PRON- PRP 19768 78 25 of of IN 19768 78 26 " " `` 19768 78 27 frequently frequently RB 19768 78 28 making make VBG 19768 78 29 of of IN 19768 78 30 late late JJ 19768 78 31 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 78 32 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 78 33 as as IN 19768 78 34 to to IN 19768 78 35 the the DT 19768 78 36 originality originality NN 19768 78 37 and and CC 19768 78 38 profundity profundity NN 19768 78 39 of of IN 19768 78 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 78 41 still still RB 19768 78 42 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 78 43 system system NN 19768 78 44 of of IN 19768 78 45 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 78 46 " " '' 19768 78 47 ! ! . 19768 79 1 The the DT 19768 79 2 pure pure JJ 19768 79 3 absurdity absurdity NN 19768 79 4 of of IN 19768 79 5 such such PDT 19768 79 6 an an DT 19768 79 7 accusation accusation NN 19768 79 8 reveals reveal VBZ 19768 79 9 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 79 10 in in IN 19768 79 11 the the DT 19768 79 12 very very JJ 19768 79 13 statement statement NN 19768 79 14 of of IN 19768 79 15 it -PRON- PRP 19768 79 16 . . . 19768 80 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 80 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 80 3 is be VBZ 19768 80 4 referring refer VBG 19768 80 5 here here RB 19768 80 6 , , , 19768 80 7 be be VB 19768 80 8 it -PRON- PRP 19768 80 9 understood understand VBN 19768 80 10 , , , 19768 80 11 not not RB 19768 80 12 to to IN 19768 80 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 80 14 published publish VBN 19768 80 15 books book NNS 19768 80 16 , , , 19768 80 17 but but CC 19768 80 18 to to IN 19768 80 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 80 20 " " `` 19768 80 21 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 80 22 system system NN 19768 80 23 of of IN 19768 80 24 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 80 25 . . . 19768 80 26 " " '' 19768 81 1 _ _ NNP 19768 81 2 How how WRB 19768 81 3 does do VBZ 19768 81 4 he -PRON- PRP 19768 81 5 know know VB 19768 81 6 anything anything NN 19768 81 7 about about IN 19768 81 8 it -PRON- PRP 19768 81 9 ? ? . 19768 81 10 _ _ NNP 19768 81 11 I -PRON- PRP 19768 81 12 certainly certainly RB 19768 81 13 have have VBP 19768 81 14 never never RB 19768 81 15 shown show VBN 19768 81 16 him -PRON- PRP 19768 81 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 81 18 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 81 19 manuscript manuscript NN 19768 81 20 , , , 19768 81 21 and and CC 19768 81 22 beyond beyond IN 19768 81 23 those those DT 19768 81 24 published publish VBN 19768 81 25 allusions allusion NNS 19768 81 26 to to IN 19768 81 27 it -PRON- PRP 19768 81 28 he -PRON- PRP 19768 81 29 possesses possess VBZ 19768 81 30 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 81 31 no no DT 19768 81 32 means means NN 19768 81 33 whatever whatever WDT 19768 81 34 of of IN 19768 81 35 knowing know VBG 19768 81 36 anything anything NN 19768 81 37 about about IN 19768 81 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 81 39 contents content NNS 19768 81 40 . . . 19768 82 1 Nothing nothing NN 19768 82 2 , , , 19768 82 3 surely surely RB 19768 82 4 , , , 19768 82 5 except except IN 19768 82 6 full full JJ 19768 82 7 and and CC 19768 82 8 exact exact JJ 19768 82 9 knowledge knowledge NN 19768 82 10 , , , 19768 82 11 derived derive VBN 19768 82 12 from from IN 19768 82 13 careful careful JJ 19768 82 14 and and CC 19768 82 15 patient patient JJ 19768 82 16 personal personal JJ 19768 82 17 examination examination NN 19768 82 18 of of IN 19768 82 19 that that DT 19768 82 20 manuscript manuscript NN 19768 82 21 , , , 19768 82 22 could could MD 19768 82 23 possibly possibly RB 19768 82 24 be be VB 19768 82 25 a a DT 19768 82 26 ground ground NN 19768 82 27 of of IN 19768 82 28 just just JJ 19768 82 29 judgment judgment NN 19768 82 30 of of IN 19768 82 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 82 32 character character NN 19768 82 33 . . . 19768 83 1 How how WRB 19768 83 2 , , , 19768 83 3 then then RB 19768 83 4 , , , 19768 83 5 in in IN 19768 83 6 absolute absolute JJ 19768 83 7 ignorance ignorance NN 19768 83 8 of of IN 19768 83 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 83 10 character character NN 19768 83 11 and and CC 19768 83 12 contents content NNS 19768 83 13 , , , 19768 83 14 could could MD 19768 83 15 any any DT 19768 83 16 fair fair JJ 19768 83 17 man man NN 19768 83 18 hazard hazard NN 19768 83 19 any any DT 19768 83 20 public public JJ 19768 83 21 verdict verdict NN 19768 83 22 upon upon IN 19768 83 23 it -PRON- PRP 19768 83 24 ? ? . 19768 84 1 Yet yet CC 19768 84 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 84 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 84 4 not not RB 19768 84 5 only only RB 19768 84 6 accuses accuse VBZ 19768 84 7 me -PRON- PRP 19768 84 8 of of IN 19768 84 9 making make VBG 19768 84 10 " " `` 19768 84 11 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 84 12 " " '' 19768 84 13 about about IN 19768 84 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 84 15 which which WDT 19768 84 16 I -PRON- PRP 19768 84 17 never never RB 19768 84 18 made make VBD 19768 84 19 , , , 19768 84 20 but but CC 19768 84 21 dares dare VBZ 19768 84 22 to to TO 19768 84 23 characterize characterize VB 19768 84 24 them -PRON- PRP 19768 84 25 as as IN 19768 84 26 " " `` 19768 84 27 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 84 28 , , , 19768 84 29 " " '' 19768 84 30 when when WRB 19768 84 31 , , , 19768 84 32 _ _ NNP 19768 84 33 for for IN 19768 84 34 all all DT 19768 84 35 he -PRON- PRP 19768 84 36 knows know VBZ 19768 84 37 _ _ NNP 19768 84 38 , , , 19768 84 39 they -PRON- PRP 19768 84 40 might may MD 19768 84 41 ( ( -LRB- 19768 84 42 if if IN 19768 84 43 made make VBN 19768 84 44 ) ) -RRB- 19768 84 45 fall fall VB 19768 84 46 far far RB 19768 84 47 short short RB 19768 84 48 of of IN 19768 84 49 the the DT 19768 84 50 truth truth NN 19768 84 51 . . . 19768 85 1 Whether whether IN 19768 85 2 in in IN 19768 85 3 this this DT 19768 85 4 case case NN 19768 85 5 the the DT 19768 85 6 evidence evidence NN 19768 85 7 supports support VBZ 19768 85 8 the the DT 19768 85 9 accusation accusation NN 19768 85 10 , , , 19768 85 11 and and CC 19768 85 12 whether whether IN 19768 85 13 the the DT 19768 85 14 conscience conscience NN 19768 85 15 which which WDT 19768 85 16 permits permit VBZ 19768 85 17 the the DT 19768 85 18 making making NN 19768 85 19 of of IN 19768 85 20 such such PDT 19768 85 21 an an DT 19768 85 22 accusation accusation NN 19768 85 23 on on IN 19768 85 24 such such JJ 19768 85 25 evidence evidence NN 19768 85 26 is be VBZ 19768 85 27 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 85 28 such such PDT 19768 85 29 a a DT 19768 85 30 conscience conscience NN 19768 85 31 as as IN 19768 85 32 you -PRON- PRP 19768 85 33 expect expect VBP 19768 85 34 to to TO 19768 85 35 find find VB 19768 85 36 in in IN 19768 85 37 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 85 38 appointees,--these appointees,--these NNP 19768 85 39 , , , 19768 85 40 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 85 41 , , , 19768 85 42 are be VBP 19768 85 43 questions question NNS 19768 85 44 for for IN 19768 85 45 you -PRON- PRP 19768 85 46 yourselves yourself NNS 19768 85 47 to to TO 19768 85 48 decide decide VB 19768 85 49 . . . 19768 86 1 III iii CD 19768 86 2 . . . 19768 87 1 These these DT 19768 87 2 three three CD 19768 87 3 connected connected JJ 19768 87 4 and and CC 19768 87 5 logically logically RB 19768 87 6 affiliated affiliate VBN 19768 87 7 _ _ NNP 19768 87 8 misstatements misstatement NNS 19768 87 9 of of IN 19768 87 10 fact_--namely fact_--namely RB 19768 87 11 , , , 19768 87 12 ( ( -LRB- 19768 87 13 1 1 LS 19768 87 14 ) ) -RRB- 19768 87 15 that that IN 19768 87 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 87 17 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 87 18 is be VBZ 19768 87 19 " " `` 19768 87 20 essentially essentially RB 19768 87 21 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 87 22 , , , 19768 87 23 " " '' 19768 87 24 ( ( -LRB- 19768 87 25 2 2 LS 19768 87 26 ) ) -RRB- 19768 87 27 that that IN 19768 87 28 it -PRON- PRP 19768 87 29 has have VBZ 19768 87 30 been be VBN 19768 87 31 " " `` 19768 87 32 appropriated appropriate VBN 19768 87 33 " " '' 19768 87 34 and and CC 19768 87 35 " " `` 19768 87 36 unconsciously unconsciously RB 19768 87 37 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 87 38 " " '' 19768 87 39 from from IN 19768 87 40 the the DT 19768 87 41 idealist idealist JJ 19768 87 42 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 87 43 , , , 19768 87 44 and and CC 19768 87 45 ( ( -LRB- 19768 87 46 3 3 LS 19768 87 47 ) ) -RRB- 19768 87 48 that that WDT 19768 87 49 I -PRON- PRP 19768 87 50 have have VBP 19768 87 51 frequently frequently RB 19768 87 52 made make VBN 19768 87 53 " " `` 19768 87 54 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 87 55 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 87 56 as as IN 19768 87 57 to to IN 19768 87 58 the the DT 19768 87 59 originality originality NN 19768 87 60 and and CC 19768 87 61 profundity profundity NN 19768 87 62 " " '' 19768 87 63 of of IN 19768 87 64 this this DT 19768 87 65 merely merely RB 19768 87 66 " " `` 19768 87 67 borrowed borrow VBD 19768 87 68 " " '' 19768 87 69 and and CC 19768 87 70 " " `` 19768 87 71 appropriated appropriated JJ 19768 87 72 " " '' 19768 87 73 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 87 74 -- -- : 19768 87 75 constitute constitute VB 19768 87 76 in in IN 19768 87 77 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 87 78 totality totality NN 19768 87 79 a a DT 19768 87 80 regular regular JJ 19768 87 81 system system NN 19768 87 82 of of IN 19768 87 83 gross gross JJ 19768 87 84 and and CC 19768 87 85 studied studied JJ 19768 87 86 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 87 87 , , , 19768 87 88 as as IN 19768 87 89 methodical methodical JJ 19768 87 90 and and CC 19768 87 91 coherent coherent JJ 19768 87 92 as as IN 19768 87 93 it -PRON- PRP 19768 87 94 is be VBZ 19768 87 95 unscrupulous unscrupulous JJ 19768 87 96 . . . 19768 88 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 88 2 is be VBZ 19768 88 3 not not RB 19768 88 4 " " `` 19768 88 5 fair fair JJ 19768 88 6 criticism criticism NN 19768 88 7 " " '' 19768 88 8 ; ; : 19768 88 9 it -PRON- PRP 19768 88 10 is be VBZ 19768 88 11 not not RB 19768 88 12 " " `` 19768 88 13 criticism criticism NN 19768 88 14 " " '' 19768 88 15 at at RB 19768 88 16 all all RB 19768 88 17 ; ; : 19768 88 18 and and CC 19768 88 19 I -PRON- PRP 19768 88 20 do do VBP 19768 88 21 not not RB 19768 88 22 hesitate hesitate VB 19768 88 23 to to TO 19768 88 24 characterize characterize VB 19768 88 25 it -PRON- PRP 19768 88 26 deliberately deliberately RB 19768 88 27 as as IN 19768 88 28 a a DT 19768 88 29 disgrace disgrace NN 19768 88 30 both both CC 19768 88 31 to to IN 19768 88 32 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 88 33 University University NNP 19768 88 34 and and CC 19768 88 35 to to IN 19768 88 36 American american JJ 19768 88 37 scholarship scholarship NN 19768 88 38 . . . 19768 89 1 Yet yet RB 19768 89 2 , , , 19768 89 3 gross gross JJ 19768 89 4 and and CC 19768 89 5 studied studied JJ 19768 89 6 and and CC 19768 89 7 systematic systematic JJ 19768 89 8 as as IN 19768 89 9 this this DT 19768 89 10 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 89 11 is be VBZ 19768 89 12 , , , 19768 89 13 I -PRON- PRP 19768 89 14 should should MD 19768 89 15 have have VB 19768 89 16 passed pass VBN 19768 89 17 it -PRON- PRP 19768 89 18 over over RP 19768 89 19 in in IN 19768 89 20 silence silence NN 19768 89 21 , , , 19768 89 22 precisely precisely RB 19768 89 23 as as IN 19768 89 24 I -PRON- PRP 19768 89 25 did do VBD 19768 89 26 pass pass VB 19768 89 27 over over RP 19768 89 28 a a DT 19768 89 29 similar similar JJ 19768 89 30 attack attack NN 19768 89 31 by by IN 19768 89 32 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 89 33 Royce Royce NNP 19768 89 34 on on IN 19768 89 35 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 89 36 earlier early JJR 19768 89 37 book book NN 19768 89 38 in in IN 19768 89 39 " " `` 19768 89 40 Science Science NNP 19768 89 41 " " '' 19768 89 42 for for IN 19768 89 43 April April NNP 19768 89 44 9 9 CD 19768 89 45 , , , 19768 89 46 1886 1886 CD 19768 89 47 , , , 19768 89 48 were be VBD 19768 89 49 it -PRON- PRP 19768 89 50 not not RB 19768 89 51 that that IN 19768 89 52 , , , 19768 89 53 perhaps perhaps RB 19768 89 54 emboldened embolden VBN 19768 89 55 by by IN 19768 89 56 former former JJ 19768 89 57 impunity impunity NN 19768 89 58 , , , 19768 89 59 he -PRON- PRP 19768 89 60 now now RB 19768 89 61 makes make VBZ 19768 89 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 89 63 misrepresentations misrepresentation NNS 19768 89 64 culminate culminate VB 19768 89 65 in in IN 19768 89 66 the the DT 19768 89 67 perpetration perpetration NN 19768 89 68 of of IN 19768 89 69 a a DT 19768 89 70 literary literary JJ 19768 89 71 outrage outrage NN 19768 89 72 , , , 19768 89 73 to to IN 19768 89 74 which which WDT 19768 89 75 , , , 19768 89 76 I -PRON- PRP 19768 89 77 am be VBP 19768 89 78 persuaded persuade VBN 19768 89 79 , , , 19768 89 80 no no DT 19768 89 81 parallel parallel NN 19768 89 82 can can MD 19768 89 83 be be VB 19768 89 84 found find VBN 19768 89 85 in in IN 19768 89 86 the the DT 19768 89 87 history history NN 19768 89 88 of of IN 19768 89 89 polite polite JJ 19768 89 90 literature literature NN 19768 89 91 . . . 19768 90 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 90 2 is be VBZ 19768 90 3 clear clear JJ 19768 90 4 that that IN 19768 90 5 forbearance forbearance NN 19768 90 6 must must MD 19768 90 7 have have VB 19768 90 8 somewhere somewhere RB 19768 90 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 90 10 limit limit NN 19768 90 11 . . . 19768 91 1 The the DT 19768 91 2 commands command NNS 19768 91 3 of of IN 19768 91 4 self self NN 19768 91 5 - - HYPH 19768 91 6 respect respect NN 19768 91 7 and and CC 19768 91 8 of of IN 19768 91 9 civic civic JJ 19768 91 10 conscience conscience NN 19768 91 11 , , , 19768 91 12 the the DT 19768 91 13 duty duty NN 19768 91 14 which which WDT 19768 91 15 every every DT 19768 91 16 citizen citizen NN 19768 91 17 owes owe VBZ 19768 91 18 to to IN 19768 91 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 91 20 fellow fellow JJ 19768 91 21 - - HYPH 19768 91 22 citizens citizen NNS 19768 91 23 not not RB 19768 91 24 to to TO 19768 91 25 permit permit VB 19768 91 26 the the DT 19768 91 27 fundamental fundamental JJ 19768 91 28 rights right NNS 19768 91 29 of of IN 19768 91 30 all all DT 19768 91 31 to to TO 19768 91 32 be be VB 19768 91 33 unlimitedly unlimitedly RB 19768 91 34 violated violate VBN 19768 91 35 in in IN 19768 91 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 91 37 own own JJ 19768 91 38 person person NN 19768 91 39 , , , 19768 91 40 must must MD 19768 91 41 at at IN 19768 91 42 last last RB 19768 91 43 set set VB 19768 91 44 a a DT 19768 91 45 bound bound NN 19768 91 46 to to TO 19768 91 47 forbearance forbearance VB 19768 91 48 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 91 49 , , , 19768 91 50 and and CC 19768 91 51 compel compel VB 19768 91 52 to to IN 19768 91 53 self self NN 19768 91 54 - - HYPH 19768 91 55 defence defence NN 19768 91 56 . . . 19768 92 1 These these DT 19768 92 2 are be VBP 19768 92 3 the the DT 19768 92 4 reasons reason NNS 19768 92 5 which which WDT 19768 92 6 , , , 19768 92 7 after after IN 19768 92 8 patient patient JJ 19768 92 9 exhaustion exhaustion NN 19768 92 10 of of IN 19768 92 11 every every DT 19768 92 12 milder milder NN 19768 92 13 means mean NNS 19768 92 14 of of IN 19768 92 15 redress redress NN 19768 92 16 , , , 19768 92 17 have have VBP 19768 92 18 moved move VBN 19768 92 19 me -PRON- PRP 19768 92 20 to to IN 19768 92 21 this this DT 19768 92 22 public public JJ 19768 92 23 appeal appeal NN 19768 92 24 . . . 19768 93 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 93 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 93 3 's 's POS 19768 93 4 misstatements misstatement NNS 19768 93 5 of of IN 19768 93 6 fact fact NN 19768 93 7 , , , 19768 93 8 so so RB 19768 93 9 elaborately elaborately RB 19768 93 10 fashioned fashioned JJ 19768 93 11 and and CC 19768 93 12 so so RB 19768 93 13 ingeniously ingeniously RB 19768 93 14 mortised mortise VBN 19768 93 15 together together RB 19768 93 16 , , , 19768 93 17 were be VBD 19768 93 18 merely merely RB 19768 93 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 93 20 foundation foundation NN 19768 93 21 for for IN 19768 93 22 a a DT 19768 93 23 deliberate deliberate JJ 19768 93 24 and and CC 19768 93 25 formal formal JJ 19768 93 26 " " '' 19768 93 27 professional professional JJ 19768 93 28 warning warning NN 19768 93 29 to to IN 19768 93 30 the the DT 19768 93 31 liberal liberal JJ 19768 93 32 - - HYPH 19768 93 33 minded minded JJ 19768 93 34 public public NN 19768 93 35 " " '' 19768 93 36 against against IN 19768 93 37 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 93 38 alleged alleged JJ 19768 93 39 " " `` 19768 93 40 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 93 41 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 93 42 . . . 19768 93 43 " " '' 19768 94 1 The the DT 19768 94 2 device device NN 19768 94 3 of of IN 19768 94 4 attributing attribute VBG 19768 94 5 to to IN 19768 94 6 me -PRON- PRP 19768 94 7 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 94 8 but but CC 19768 94 9 groundless groundless JJ 19768 94 10 " " '' 19768 94 11 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 94 12 " " '' 19768 94 13 to to IN 19768 94 14 " " `` 19768 94 15 originality originality NN 19768 94 16 " " '' 19768 94 17 and and CC 19768 94 18 " " `` 19768 94 19 profundity"--since profundity"--since NN 19768 94 20 he -PRON- PRP 19768 94 21 is be VBZ 19768 94 22 unable unable JJ 19768 94 23 to to TO 19768 94 24 cite cite VB 19768 94 25 a a DT 19768 94 26 single single JJ 19768 94 27 passage passage NN 19768 94 28 in in IN 19768 94 29 which which WDT 19768 94 30 I -PRON- PRP 19768 94 31 ever ever RB 19768 94 32 used use VBD 19768 94 33 such such JJ 19768 94 34 expressions expression NNS 19768 94 35 of of IN 19768 94 36 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 94 37 -- -- : 19768 94 38 was be VBD 19768 94 39 probably probably RB 19768 94 40 suggested suggest VBN 19768 94 41 to to IN 19768 94 42 him -PRON- PRP 19768 94 43 by by IN 19768 94 44 the the DT 19768 94 45 " " `` 19768 94 46 Press Press NNP 19768 94 47 Notices Notices NNPS 19768 94 48 of of IN 19768 94 49 ' ' `` 19768 94 50 Scientific Scientific NNP 19768 94 51 Theism theism NN 19768 94 52 , , , 19768 94 53 ' ' '' 19768 94 54 " " '' 19768 94 55 printed print VBN 19768 94 56 as as IN 19768 94 57 a a DT 19768 94 58 publishers publisher NNS 19768 94 59 ' ' POS 19768 94 60 advertisement advertisement NN 19768 94 61 of of IN 19768 94 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 94 63 former former JJ 19768 94 64 book book NN 19768 94 65 at at IN 19768 94 66 the the DT 19768 94 67 end end NN 19768 94 68 of of IN 19768 94 69 the the DT 19768 94 70 book book NN 19768 94 71 which which WDT 19768 94 72 lay lie VBD 19768 94 73 before before IN 19768 94 74 him -PRON- PRP 19768 94 75 . . . 19768 95 1 These these DT 19768 95 2 " " `` 19768 95 3 Press Press NNP 19768 95 4 Notices Notices NNP 19768 95 5 , , , 19768 95 6 " " '' 19768 95 7 as as IN 19768 95 8 usual usual JJ 19768 95 9 , , , 19768 95 10 contain contain VBP 19768 95 11 numerous numerous JJ 19768 95 12 extracts extract NNS 19768 95 13 from from IN 19768 95 14 eulogistic eulogistic JJ 19768 95 15 reviews review NNS 19768 95 16 , , , 19768 95 17 in in IN 19768 95 18 which which WDT 19768 95 19 , , , 19768 95 20 curiously curiously RB 19768 95 21 enough enough RB 19768 95 22 , , , 19768 95 23 these these DT 19768 95 24 very very JJ 19768 95 25 words word NNS 19768 95 26 , , , 19768 95 27 " " `` 19768 95 28 original original JJ 19768 95 29 " " '' 19768 95 30 and and CC 19768 95 31 " " `` 19768 95 32 profound profound JJ 19768 95 33 , , , 19768 95 34 " " '' 19768 95 35 or or CC 19768 95 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 95 37 equivalents equivalent NNS 19768 95 38 , , , 19768 95 39 occur occur VB 19768 95 40 with with IN 19768 95 41 sufficient sufficient JJ 19768 95 42 frequency frequency NN 19768 95 43 to to TO 19768 95 44 explain explain VB 19768 95 45 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 95 46 Royce Royce NNP 19768 95 47 's 's POS 19768 95 48 choleric choleric JJ 19768 95 49 unhappiness unhappiness NN 19768 95 50 . . . 19768 96 1 For for IN 19768 96 2 instance instance NN 19768 96 3 , , , 19768 96 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 96 5 James James NNP 19768 96 6 Freeman Freeman NNP 19768 96 7 Clarke Clarke NNP 19768 96 8 wrote write VBD 19768 96 9 in in IN 19768 96 10 the the DT 19768 96 11 " " `` 19768 96 12 Unitarian Unitarian NNP 19768 96 13 Review Review NNP 19768 96 14 " " '' 19768 96 15 : : : 19768 96 16 " " `` 19768 96 17 If if IN 19768 96 18 every every DT 19768 96 19 position position NN 19768 96 20 taken take VBN 19768 96 21 by by IN 19768 96 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 96 23 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 96 24 can can MD 19768 96 25 not not RB 19768 96 26 be be VB 19768 96 27 maintained maintain VBN 19768 96 28 , , , 19768 96 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 96 30 book book NN 19768 96 31 remains remain VBZ 19768 96 32 an an DT 19768 96 33 original original JJ 19768 96 34 contribution contribution NN 19768 96 35 to to IN 19768 96 36 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 96 37 of of IN 19768 96 38 a a DT 19768 96 39 high high JJ 19768 96 40 order order NN 19768 96 41 and and CC 19768 96 42 of of IN 19768 96 43 great great JJ 19768 96 44 value value NN 19768 96 45 " " '' 19768 96 46 ; ; : 19768 96 47 M. M. NNP 19768 96 48 Renouvier Renouvier NNP 19768 96 49 , , , 19768 96 50 in in IN 19768 96 51 " " `` 19768 96 52 La La NNP 19768 96 53 Critique Critique NNP 19768 96 54 Philosophique Philosophique NNP 19768 96 55 , , , 19768 96 56 " " '' 19768 96 57 classed class VBD 19768 96 58 the the DT 19768 96 59 book book NN 19768 96 60 among among IN 19768 96 61 " " `` 19768 96 62 de de FW 19768 96 63 remarquables remarquable VBZ 19768 96 64 efforts effort NNS 19768 96 65 de de IN 19768 96 66 construction construction NN 19768 96 67 métaphysique métaphysique NNP 19768 96 68 et et NNP 19768 96 69 morale morale NN 19768 96 70 dus dus NNP 19768 96 71 à à NNP 19768 96 72 des des NNP 19768 96 73 penseurs penseurs NNP 19768 96 74 indépendants indépendant NNS 19768 96 75 et et NN 19768 96 76 profonds profond NNS 19768 96 77 " " '' 19768 96 78 ; ; : 19768 96 79 and and CC 19768 96 80 M. M. NNP 19768 96 81 Carrau Carrau NNP 19768 96 82 , , , 19768 96 83 in in IN 19768 96 84 explaining explain VBG 19768 96 85 why why WRB 19768 96 86 he -PRON- PRP 19768 96 87 added add VBD 19768 96 88 to to IN 19768 96 89 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 96 90 critical critical JJ 19768 96 91 history history NN 19768 96 92 of of IN 19768 96 93 " " `` 19768 96 94 Religious religious JJ 19768 96 95 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19768 96 96 in in IN 19768 96 97 England England NNP 19768 96 98 " " '' 19768 96 99 a a DT 19768 96 100 chapter chapter NN 19768 96 101 of of IN 19768 96 102 twenty twenty CD 19768 96 103 pages page NNS 19768 96 104 on on IN 19768 96 105 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 96 106 own own JJ 19768 96 107 system system NN 19768 96 108 , , , 19768 96 109 actually actually RB 19768 96 110 introduced introduce VBD 19768 96 111 both both DT 19768 96 112 of of IN 19768 96 113 the the DT 19768 96 114 words word NNS 19768 96 115 which which WDT 19768 96 116 , , , 19768 96 117 when when WRB 19768 96 118 thus thus RB 19768 96 119 applied apply VBD 19768 96 120 , , , 19768 96 121 jar jar NN 19768 96 122 so so RB 19768 96 123 painfully painfully RB 19768 96 124 on on IN 19768 96 125 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 96 126 Royce Royce NNP 19768 96 127 's 's POS 19768 96 128 nerves nerve NNS 19768 96 129 : : : 19768 96 130 " " `` 19768 96 131 La La NNP 19768 96 132 pensée pensée NNP 19768 96 133 de de NNP 19768 96 134 M. M. NNP 19768 96 135 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 96 136 m'a m'a VBZ 19768 96 137 paru paru NN 19768 96 138 assez assez NNP 19768 96 139 profonde profonde NNP 19768 96 140 et et NNP 19768 96 141 assez assez NNP 19768 96 142 originale originale NNP 19768 96 143 pour pour NNP 19768 96 144 mériter mériter NNP 19768 96 145 d'être d'être NNP 19768 96 146 reproduite reproduite NNP 19768 96 147 littéralement littéralement NN 19768 96 148 . . . 19768 96 149 " " '' 19768 97 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 97 2 La La NNP 19768 97 3 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 19768 97 4 Religieuse Religieuse NNP 19768 97 5 en en NNP 19768 97 6 Angleterre Angleterre NNP 19768 97 7 . . . 19768 98 1 Par Par NNP 19768 98 2 Ludovic Ludovic NNP 19768 98 3 Carrau Carrau NNP 19768 98 4 , , , 19768 98 5 Directeur Directeur NNP 19768 98 6 des des FW 19768 98 7 Conférences Conférences NNP 19768 98 8 de de NNP 19768 98 9 philosophie philosophie NNP 19768 98 10 à à NNP 19768 98 11 la la NNP 19768 98 12 Faculté Faculté NNP 19768 98 13 des des FW 19768 98 14 lettres lettre NNS 19768 98 15 de de IN 19768 98 16 Paris Paris NNP 19768 98 17 . . . 19768 99 1 Paris Paris NNP 19768 99 2 , , , 19768 99 3 1888 1888 CD 19768 99 4 . . . 19768 99 5 ) ) -RRB- 19768 100 1 These these DT 19768 100 2 extracts extract NNS 19768 100 3 , , , 19768 100 4 be be VB 19768 100 5 it -PRON- PRP 19768 100 6 remembered remember VBN 19768 100 7 , , , 19768 100 8 were be VBD 19768 100 9 all all DT 19768 100 10 printed print VBN 19768 100 11 at at IN 19768 100 12 the the DT 19768 100 13 end end NN 19768 100 14 of of IN 19768 100 15 the the DT 19768 100 16 book book NN 19768 100 17 which which WDT 19768 100 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 100 19 Royce Royce NNP 19768 100 20 was be VBD 19768 100 21 reviewing review VBG 19768 100 22 . . . 19768 101 1 Now now RB 19768 101 2 he -PRON- PRP 19768 101 3 had have VBD 19768 101 4 an an DT 19768 101 5 undoubted undoubted JJ 19768 101 6 right right NN 19768 101 7 to to TO 19768 101 8 think think VB 19768 101 9 and and CC 19768 101 10 to to TO 19768 101 11 say say VB 19768 101 12 that that IN 19768 101 13 such such JJ 19768 101 14 encomiums encomium NNS 19768 101 15 as as IN 19768 101 16 these these DT 19768 101 17 on on IN 19768 101 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 101 19 work work NN 19768 101 20 were be VBD 19768 101 21 silly silly JJ 19768 101 22 , , , 19768 101 23 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 101 24 , , , 19768 101 25 preposterous preposterous JJ 19768 101 26 , , , 19768 101 27 and and CC 19768 101 28 totally totally RB 19768 101 29 undeserved undeserved JJ 19768 101 30 ; ; : 19768 101 31 but but CC 19768 101 32 _ _ NNP 19768 101 33 to to TO 19768 101 34 take take VB 19768 101 35 them -PRON- PRP 19768 101 36 out out IN 19768 101 37 of of IN 19768 101 38 the the DT 19768 101 39 mouth mouth NN 19768 101 40 of of IN 19768 101 41 others other NNS 19768 101 42 and and CC 19768 101 43 put put VB 19768 101 44 them -PRON- PRP 19768 101 45 into into IN 19768 101 46 mine mine NN 19768 101 47 was be VBD 19768 101 48 wilful wilful JJ 19768 101 49 and and CC 19768 101 50 deliberate deliberate JJ 19768 101 51 calumny calumny NN 19768 101 52 _ _ NNP 19768 101 53 . . . 19768 102 1 Systematic systematic JJ 19768 102 2 and and CC 19768 102 3 calumnious calumnious JJ 19768 102 4 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 102 5 is be VBZ 19768 102 6 the the DT 19768 102 7 sole sole JJ 19768 102 8 foundation foundation NN 19768 102 9 of of IN 19768 102 10 the the DT 19768 102 11 " " `` 19768 102 12 professional professional JJ 19768 102 13 warning warning NN 19768 102 14 " " '' 19768 102 15 in in IN 19768 102 16 which which WDT 19768 102 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 102 18 Royce Royce NNP 19768 102 19 's 's POS 19768 102 20 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 102 21 review review NN 19768 102 22 culminates culminate NNS 19768 102 23 , , , 19768 102 24 and and CC 19768 102 25 which which WDT 19768 102 26 is be VBZ 19768 102 27 too too RB 19768 102 28 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19768 102 29 not not RB 19768 102 30 to to TO 19768 102 31 be be VB 19768 102 32 quoted quote VBN 19768 102 33 here here RB 19768 102 34 in in IN 19768 102 35 full:-- full:-- NNP 19768 102 36 " " '' 19768 102 37 And and CC 19768 102 38 so so RB 19768 102 39 , , , 19768 102 40 finally finally RB 19768 102 41 , , , 19768 102 42 after after IN 19768 102 43 this this DT 19768 102 44 somewhat somewhat RB 19768 102 45 detailed detailed JJ 19768 102 46 study study NN 19768 102 47 of of IN 19768 102 48 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 102 49 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 102 50 's 's POS 19768 102 51 little little JJ 19768 102 52 book book NN 19768 102 53 , , , 19768 102 54 I -PRON- PRP 19768 102 55 feel feel VBP 19768 102 56 constrained constrain VBN 19768 102 57 to to TO 19768 102 58 repeat repeat VB 19768 102 59 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 102 60 judgment judgment NN 19768 102 61 as as IN 19768 102 62 above above RB 19768 102 63 . . . 19768 103 1 Results result NNS 19768 103 2 in in IN 19768 103 3 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 103 4 are be VBP 19768 103 5 one one CD 19768 103 6 thing thing NN 19768 103 7 ; ; : 19768 103 8 a a DT 19768 103 9 careful careful JJ 19768 103 10 way way NN 19768 103 11 of of IN 19768 103 12 thinking thinking NN 19768 103 13 is be VBZ 19768 103 14 another another DT 19768 103 15 . . . 19768 104 1 Babes babe NNS 19768 104 2 and and CC 19768 104 3 sucklings suckling NNS 19768 104 4 often often RB 19768 104 5 get get VBP 19768 104 6 very very RB 19768 104 7 magnificent magnificent JJ 19768 104 8 results result NNS 19768 104 9 . . . 19768 105 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 105 2 is be VBZ 19768 105 3 not not RB 19768 105 4 the the DT 19768 105 5 office office NN 19768 105 6 of of IN 19768 105 7 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 105 8 to to TO 19768 105 9 outdo outdo VB 19768 105 10 the the DT 19768 105 11 babes babe NNS 19768 105 12 and and CC 19768 105 13 sucklings suckling NNS 19768 105 14 at at IN 19768 105 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 105 16 own own JJ 19768 105 17 business business NN 19768 105 18 of of IN 19768 105 19 receiving receive VBG 19768 105 20 revelations revelation NNS 19768 105 21 . . . 19768 106 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 106 2 is be VBZ 19768 106 3 the the DT 19768 106 4 office office NN 19768 106 5 of of IN 19768 106 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 106 7 to to TO 19768 106 8 undertake undertake VB 19768 106 9 a a DT 19768 106 10 serious serious JJ 19768 106 11 scrutiny scrutiny NN 19768 106 12 of of IN 19768 106 13 the the DT 19768 106 14 presuppositions presupposition NNS 19768 106 15 of of IN 19768 106 16 human human JJ 19768 106 17 belief belief NN 19768 106 18 . . . 19768 107 1 Hence hence RB 19768 107 2 the the DT 19768 107 3 importance importance NN 19768 107 4 of of IN 19768 107 5 the the DT 19768 107 6 careful careful JJ 19768 107 7 way way NN 19768 107 8 of of IN 19768 107 9 thinking thinking NN 19768 107 10 in in IN 19768 107 11 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 107 12 . . . 19768 108 1 But but CC 19768 108 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 108 3 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 108 4 's 's POS 19768 108 5 way way NN 19768 108 6 is be VBZ 19768 108 7 not not RB 19768 108 8 careful careful JJ 19768 108 9 , , , 19768 108 10 is be VBZ 19768 108 11 not not RB 19768 108 12 novel novel JJ 19768 108 13 , , , 19768 108 14 and and CC 19768 108 15 , , , 19768 108 16 when when WRB 19768 108 17 thus thus RB 19768 108 18 set set VBN 19768 108 19 forth forth RB 19768 108 20 to to IN 19768 108 21 the the DT 19768 108 22 people people NNS 19768 108 23 as as IN 19768 108 24 new new JJ 19768 108 25 and and CC 19768 108 26 bold bold JJ 19768 108 27 and and CC 19768 108 28 American american JJ 19768 108 29 , , , 19768 108 30 it -PRON- PRP 19768 108 31 is be VBZ 19768 108 32 likely likely JJ 19768 108 33 to to TO 19768 108 34 do do VB 19768 108 35 precisely precisely RB 19768 108 36 as as IN 19768 108 37 much much JJ 19768 108 38 harm harm NN 19768 108 39 to to IN 19768 108 40 careful careful JJ 19768 108 41 inquiry inquiry NN 19768 108 42 as as IN 19768 108 43 it -PRON- PRP 19768 108 44 gets get VBZ 19768 108 45 influence influence NN 19768 108 46 over over IN 19768 108 47 immature immature JJ 19768 108 48 or or CC 19768 108 49 imperfectly imperfectly RB 19768 108 50 trained train VBN 19768 108 51 minds mind NNS 19768 108 52 . . . 19768 109 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 109 2 venture venture VBP 19768 109 3 , , , 19768 109 4 therefore therefore RB 19768 109 5 , , , 19768 109 6 to to TO 19768 109 7 speak speak VB 19768 109 8 plainly plainly RB 19768 109 9 , , , 19768 109 10 by by IN 19768 109 11 way way NN 19768 109 12 of of IN 19768 109 13 a a DT 19768 109 14 professional professional JJ 19768 109 15 warning warning NN 19768 109 16 to to IN 19768 109 17 the the DT 19768 109 18 liberal liberal JJ 19768 109 19 - - HYPH 19768 109 20 minded minded JJ 19768 109 21 public public NN 19768 109 22 concerning concern VBG 19768 109 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 109 24 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 109 25 's 's POS 19768 109 26 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 109 27 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 109 28 . . . 19768 110 1 And and CC 19768 110 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 110 3 warning warning NN 19768 110 4 takes take VBZ 19768 110 5 the the DT 19768 110 6 form form NN 19768 110 7 of of IN 19768 110 8 saying say VBG 19768 110 9 that that IN 19768 110 10 , , , 19768 110 11 if if IN 19768 110 12 people people NNS 19768 110 13 are be VBP 19768 110 14 to to TO 19768 110 15 think think VB 19768 110 16 in in IN 19768 110 17 this this DT 19768 110 18 confused confused JJ 19768 110 19 way way NN 19768 110 20 , , , 19768 110 21 unconsciously unconsciously RB 19768 110 22 borrowing borrow VBG 19768 110 23 from from IN 19768 110 24 a a DT 19768 110 25 great great JJ 19768 110 26 speculator speculator NN 19768 110 27 like like IN 19768 110 28 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 110 29 , , , 19768 110 30 and and CC 19768 110 31 then then RB 19768 110 32 depriving deprive VBG 19768 110 33 the the DT 19768 110 34 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 110 35 conception conception NN 19768 110 36 of of IN 19768 110 37 the the DT 19768 110 38 peculiar peculiar JJ 19768 110 39 subtlety subtlety NN 19768 110 40 of of IN 19768 110 41 statement statement NN 19768 110 42 that that WDT 19768 110 43 made make VBD 19768 110 44 it -PRON- PRP 19768 110 45 useful useful JJ 19768 110 46 in in IN 19768 110 47 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 110 48 place,--and place,--and NN 19768 110 49 if if IN 19768 110 50 we -PRON- PRP 19768 110 51 readers reader NNS 19768 110 52 are be VBP 19768 110 53 for for IN 19768 110 54 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 110 55 part part NN 19768 110 56 to to TO 19768 110 57 accept accept VB 19768 110 58 such such JJ 19768 110 59 scholasticism scholasticism NN 19768 110 60 as as IN 19768 110 61 is be VBZ 19768 110 62 found find VBN 19768 110 63 in in IN 19768 110 64 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 110 65 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 110 66 's 's POS 19768 110 67 concluding concluding NN 19768 110 68 sections section NNS 19768 110 69 as as IN 19768 110 70 at at IN 19768 110 71 all all DT 19768 110 72 resembling resemble VBG 19768 110 73 philosophy,--then philosophy,--then NNP 19768 110 74 it -PRON- PRP 19768 110 75 were be VBD 19768 110 76 far far RB 19768 110 77 better well JJR 19768 110 78 for for IN 19768 110 79 the the DT 19768 110 80 world world NN 19768 110 81 that that WDT 19768 110 82 no no DT 19768 110 83 reflective reflective JJ 19768 110 84 thinking thinking NN 19768 110 85 whatever whatever WDT 19768 110 86 should should MD 19768 110 87 be be VB 19768 110 88 done do VBN 19768 110 89 . . . 19768 111 1 If if IN 19768 111 2 we -PRON- PRP 19768 111 3 ca can MD 19768 111 4 n't not RB 19768 111 5 improve improve VB 19768 111 6 on on IN 19768 111 7 what what WP 19768 111 8 God God NNP 19768 111 9 has have VBZ 19768 111 10 already already RB 19768 111 11 put put VBN 19768 111 12 into into IN 19768 111 13 the the DT 19768 111 14 mouth mouth NN 19768 111 15 of of IN 19768 111 16 the the DT 19768 111 17 babes babe NNS 19768 111 18 and and CC 19768 111 19 sucklings suckling NNS 19768 111 20 , , , 19768 111 21 let let VB 19768 111 22 us -PRON- PRP 19768 111 23 at at IN 19768 111 24 all all DT 19768 111 25 events event NNS 19768 111 26 make make VBP 19768 111 27 some some DT 19768 111 28 other other JJ 19768 111 29 use use NN 19768 111 30 of of IN 19768 111 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 111 32 wisdom wisdom NN 19768 111 33 and and CC 19768 111 34 prudence prudence NN 19768 111 35 than than IN 19768 111 36 in in IN 19768 111 37 setting set VBG 19768 111 38 forth forth RP 19768 111 39 the the DT 19768 111 40 American american JJ 19768 111 41 theory theory NN 19768 111 42 of of IN 19768 111 43 what what WP 19768 111 44 has have VBZ 19768 111 45 been be VBN 19768 111 46 in in IN 19768 111 47 large large JJ 19768 111 48 part part NN 19768 111 49 hidden hide VBN 19768 111 50 from from IN 19768 111 51 us -PRON- PRP 19768 111 52 . . . 19768 111 53 " " '' 19768 112 1 Gentlemen Gentlemen NNP 19768 112 2 , , , 19768 112 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 112 4 deny deny VBP 19768 112 5 sweepingly sweepingly RB 19768 112 6 the the DT 19768 112 7 whole whole JJ 19768 112 8 groundwork groundwork NN 19768 112 9 of of IN 19768 112 10 cunning cunning JJ 19768 112 11 and and CC 19768 112 12 amazing amazing JJ 19768 112 13 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 112 14 on on IN 19768 112 15 which which WDT 19768 112 16 this this DT 19768 112 17 unparalleled unparalleled JJ 19768 112 18 tirade tirade NN 19768 112 19 is be VBZ 19768 112 20 founded found VBN 19768 112 21 . . . 19768 113 1 I. I. NNP 19768 113 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 113 3 deny deny VBP 19768 113 4 that that IN 19768 113 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 113 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 113 7 is be VBZ 19768 113 8 " " `` 19768 113 9 essentially essentially RB 19768 113 10 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 113 11 , , , 19768 113 12 " " '' 19768 113 13 or or CC 19768 113 14 that that IN 19768 113 15 any any DT 19768 113 16 " " `` 19768 113 17 careful careful JJ 19768 113 18 " " '' 19768 113 19 or or CC 19768 113 20 conscientious conscientious JJ 19768 113 21 scholar scholar NN 19768 113 22 could could MD 19768 113 23 possibly possibly RB 19768 113 24 affirm affirm VB 19768 113 25 it -PRON- PRP 19768 113 26 to to TO 19768 113 27 be be VB 19768 113 28 such such JJ 19768 113 29 . . . 19768 114 1 II ii CD 19768 114 2 . . . 19768 115 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 115 2 deny deny VBP 19768 115 3 that that IN 19768 115 4 I -PRON- PRP 19768 115 5 " " `` 19768 115 6 borrowed borrow VBD 19768 115 7 " " `` 19768 115 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 115 9 realistic realistic JJ 19768 115 10 theory theory NN 19768 115 11 of of IN 19768 115 12 universals universal NNS 19768 115 13 from from IN 19768 115 14 the the DT 19768 115 15 idealist idealist NN 19768 115 16 , , , 19768 115 17 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 115 18 , , , 19768 115 19 whether whether IN 19768 115 20 consciously consciously RB 19768 115 21 or or CC 19768 115 22 unconsciously unconsciously RB 19768 115 23 . . . 19768 116 1 The the DT 19768 116 2 charge charge NN 19768 116 3 is be VBZ 19768 116 4 unspeakably unspeakably RB 19768 116 5 silly silly JJ 19768 116 6 . . . 19768 117 1 Realism realism NN 19768 117 2 and and CC 19768 117 3 idealism idealism NN 19768 117 4 contradict contradict NN 19768 117 5 each each DT 19768 117 6 other other JJ 19768 117 7 more more RBR 19768 117 8 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 117 9 than than IN 19768 117 10 protectionism protectionism NN 19768 117 11 and and CC 19768 117 12 free free JJ 19768 117 13 - - HYPH 19768 117 14 trade trade NN 19768 117 15 . . . 19768 118 1 III iii CD 19768 118 2 . . . 19768 119 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 119 2 deny deny VBP 19768 119 3 that that IN 19768 119 4 I -PRON- PRP 19768 119 5 ever ever RB 19768 119 6 made make VBD 19768 119 7 the the DT 19768 119 8 " " `` 19768 119 9 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 119 10 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 119 11 " " '' 19768 119 12 which which WDT 19768 119 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 119 14 Royce Royce NNP 19768 119 15 calumniously calumniously RB 19768 119 16 imputes impute VBZ 19768 119 17 to to IN 19768 119 18 me -PRON- PRP 19768 119 19 . . . 19768 120 1 But but CC 19768 120 2 , , , 19768 120 3 if if IN 19768 120 4 I -PRON- PRP 19768 120 5 had have VBD 19768 120 6 made make VBN 19768 120 7 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 120 8 as as RB 19768 120 9 high high RB 19768 120 10 as as IN 19768 120 11 the the DT 19768 120 12 Himalayas Himalayas NNP 19768 120 13 , , , 19768 120 14 I -PRON- PRP 19768 120 15 deny deny VBP 19768 120 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 120 17 authority authority NN 19768 120 18 to to TO 19768 120 19 post post VB 19768 120 20 me -PRON- PRP 19768 120 21 publicly publicly RB 19768 120 22 -- -- : 19768 120 23 to to TO 19768 120 24 act act VB 19768 120 25 as as IN 19768 120 26 policeman policeman NN 19768 120 27 in in IN 19768 120 28 the the DT 19768 120 29 republic republic NN 19768 120 30 of of IN 19768 120 31 letters letter NNS 19768 120 32 and and CC 19768 120 33 to to TO 19768 120 34 collar collar VB 19768 120 35 me -PRON- PRP 19768 120 36 on on IN 19768 120 37 that that DT 19768 120 38 account account NN 19768 120 39 . . . 19768 121 1 A a DT 19768 121 2 college college NN 19768 121 3 professor professor NN 19768 121 4 who who WP 19768 121 5 thus thus RB 19768 121 6 mistakes mistake VBZ 19768 121 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 121 8 academic academic JJ 19768 121 9 gown gown NN 19768 121 10 for for IN 19768 121 11 the the DT 19768 121 12 policeman policeman NN 19768 121 13 's 's POS 19768 121 14 uniform uniform NN 19768 121 15 , , , 19768 121 16 and and CC 19768 121 17 dares dare VBZ 19768 121 18 to to TO 19768 121 19 use use VB 19768 121 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 121 21 private private JJ 19768 121 22 walking walking NN 19768 121 23 - - HYPH 19768 121 24 stick stick NN 19768 121 25 for for IN 19768 121 26 the the DT 19768 121 27 policeman policeman NN 19768 121 28 's 's POS 19768 121 29 bludgeon bludgeon NN 19768 121 30 , , , 19768 121 31 is be VBZ 19768 121 32 likely likely JJ 19768 121 33 to to TO 19768 121 34 find find VB 19768 121 35 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 121 36 suddenly suddenly RB 19768 121 37 prostrated prostrate VBN 19768 121 38 by by IN 19768 121 39 a a DT 19768 121 40 return return NN 19768 121 41 blow blow NN 19768 121 42 , , , 19768 121 43 arrested arrest VBN 19768 121 44 for for IN 19768 121 45 assault assault NN 19768 121 46 and and CC 19768 121 47 battery battery NN 19768 121 48 , , , 19768 121 49 and and CC 19768 121 50 unceremoniously unceremoniously RB 19768 121 51 hustled hustle VBD 19768 121 52 off off RP 19768 121 53 into into IN 19768 121 54 a a DT 19768 121 55 cell cell NN 19768 121 56 , , , 19768 121 57 by by IN 19768 121 58 the the DT 19768 121 59 officer officer NN 19768 121 60 whose whose WP$ 19768 121 61 function function NN 19768 121 62 he -PRON- PRP 19768 121 63 has have VBZ 19768 121 64 injudiciously injudiciously RB 19768 121 65 aped ape VBN 19768 121 66 without without IN 19768 121 67 waiting wait VBG 19768 121 68 for for IN 19768 121 69 the the DT 19768 121 70 tiresome tiresome JJ 19768 121 71 but but CC 19768 121 72 quite quite RB 19768 121 73 indispensable indispensable JJ 19768 121 74 little little JJ 19768 121 75 preliminary preliminary JJ 19768 121 76 of of IN 19768 121 77 first first JJ 19768 121 78 securing secure VBG 19768 121 79 a a DT 19768 121 80 regular regular JJ 19768 121 81 commission commission NN 19768 121 82 . . . 19768 122 1 IV IV NNP 19768 122 2 . . . 19768 123 1 Most Most JJS 19768 123 2 of of IN 19768 123 3 all all DT 19768 123 4 , , , 19768 123 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 123 6 deny deny VBP 19768 123 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 123 8 Royce Royce NNP 19768 123 9 's 's POS 19768 123 10 self self NN 19768 123 11 - - HYPH 19768 123 12 assumed assume VBN 19768 123 13 right right NN 19768 123 14 to to IN 19768 123 15 club club VB 19768 123 16 every every DT 19768 123 17 philosopher philosopher NN 19768 123 18 whose whose WP$ 19768 123 19 reasoning reasoning NN 19768 123 20 he -PRON- PRP 19768 123 21 can can MD 19768 123 22 neither neither CC 19768 123 23 refute refute VB 19768 123 24 nor nor CC 19768 123 25 understand understand VB 19768 123 26 . . . 19768 124 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 124 2 deny deny VBP 19768 124 3 , , , 19768 124 4 in in IN 19768 124 5 general general JJ 19768 124 6 , , , 19768 124 7 that that IN 19768 124 8 any any DT 19768 124 9 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 124 10 professor professor NN 19768 124 11 has have VBZ 19768 124 12 the the DT 19768 124 13 right right NN 19768 124 14 to to TO 19768 124 15 fulminate fulminate VB 19768 124 16 a a DT 19768 124 17 " " `` 19768 124 18 professional professional JJ 19768 124 19 warning warning NN 19768 124 20 " " '' 19768 124 21 _ _ NNP 19768 124 22 against against IN 19768 124 23 anybody anybody NN 19768 124 24 _ _ NNP 19768 124 25 ; ; : 19768 124 26 and and CC 19768 124 27 , , , 19768 124 28 in in IN 19768 124 29 particular particular JJ 19768 124 30 , , , 19768 124 31 that that IN 19768 124 32 you -PRON- PRP 19768 124 33 , , , 19768 124 34 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 124 35 , , , 19768 124 36 ever ever RB 19768 124 37 voted vote VBD 19768 124 38 or or CC 19768 124 39 intended intend VBN 19768 124 40 to to TO 19768 124 41 invest invest VB 19768 124 42 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 124 43 Royce Royce NNP 19768 124 44 with with IN 19768 124 45 that that DT 19768 124 46 right right NN 19768 124 47 . . . 19768 125 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 125 2 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 125 3 now now RB 19768 125 4 publicly publicly RB 19768 125 5 puts put VBZ 19768 125 6 forth forth RP 19768 125 7 a a DT 19768 125 8 worse bad JJR 19768 125 9 than than IN 19768 125 10 " " `` 19768 125 11 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 125 12 pretension pretension NN 19768 125 13 " " '' 19768 125 14 when when WRB 19768 125 15 he -PRON- PRP 19768 125 16 arrogates arrogate VBZ 19768 125 17 to to IN 19768 125 18 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 125 19 this this DT 19768 125 20 right right NN 19768 125 21 of of IN 19768 125 22 literary literary JJ 19768 125 23 outrage outrage NN 19768 125 24 . . . 19768 126 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 126 2 was be VBD 19768 126 3 not not RB 19768 126 4 appointed appoint VBN 19768 126 5 professor professor NN 19768 126 6 by by IN 19768 126 7 you -PRON- PRP 19768 126 8 for for IN 19768 126 9 any any DT 19768 126 10 such such JJ 19768 126 11 unseemly unseemly JJ 19768 126 12 purpose purpose NN 19768 126 13 . . . 19768 127 1 To to TO 19768 127 2 arrogate arrogate VB 19768 127 3 to to IN 19768 127 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 127 5 a a DT 19768 127 6 senseless senseless JJ 19768 127 7 " " `` 19768 127 8 professional professional JJ 19768 127 9 " " '' 19768 127 10 superiority superiority NN 19768 127 11 over over IN 19768 127 12 all all DT 19768 127 13 non-"professional non-"professional JJ 19768 127 14 " " `` 19768 127 15 authors author NNS 19768 127 16 , , , 19768 127 17 to to IN 19768 127 18 the the DT 19768 127 19 insufferable insufferable JJ 19768 127 20 extent extent NN 19768 127 21 of of IN 19768 127 22 publicly publicly RB 19768 127 23 posting post VBG 19768 127 24 and and CC 19768 127 25 placarding placard VBG 19768 127 26 them -PRON- PRP 19768 127 27 for for IN 19768 127 28 a a DT 19768 127 29 mere mere JJ 19768 127 30 difference difference NN 19768 127 31 of of IN 19768 127 32 opinion opinion NN 19768 127 33 , , , 19768 127 34 is be VBZ 19768 127 35 , , , 19768 127 36 from from IN 19768 127 37 a a DT 19768 127 38 moral moral JJ 19768 127 39 point point NN 19768 127 40 of of IN 19768 127 41 view view NN 19768 127 42 , , , 19768 127 43 scandalously scandalously RB 19768 127 44 to to TO 19768 127 45 abuse abuse VB 19768 127 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 127 47 academical academical JJ 19768 127 48 position position NN 19768 127 49 , , , 19768 127 50 to to TO 19768 127 51 compromise compromise VB 19768 127 52 the the DT 19768 127 53 dignity dignity NN 19768 127 54 of of IN 19768 127 55 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 127 56 University University NNP 19768 127 57 , , , 19768 127 58 to to TO 19768 127 59 draw draw VB 19768 127 60 down down RP 19768 127 61 universal universal JJ 19768 127 62 contempt contempt NN 19768 127 63 upon upon IN 19768 127 64 the the DT 19768 127 65 " " `` 19768 127 66 profession profession NN 19768 127 67 " " '' 19768 127 68 which which WDT 19768 127 69 he -PRON- PRP 19768 127 70 prostitutes prostitute VBZ 19768 127 71 to to IN 19768 127 72 the the DT 19768 127 73 uses use NNS 19768 127 74 of of IN 19768 127 75 mere mere JJ 19768 127 76 professional professional JJ 19768 127 77 jealousy jealousy NN 19768 127 78 or or CC 19768 127 79 literary literary JJ 19768 127 80 rivalry rivalry NN 19768 127 81 , , , 19768 127 82 and and CC 19768 127 83 to to TO 19768 127 84 degrade degrade VB 19768 127 85 the the DT 19768 127 86 honorable honorable JJ 19768 127 87 office office NN 19768 127 88 of of IN 19768 127 89 professor professor NNP 19768 127 90 in in IN 19768 127 91 the the DT 19768 127 92 eyes eye NNS 19768 127 93 of of IN 19768 127 94 all all DT 19768 127 95 who who WP 19768 127 96 understand understand VBP 19768 127 97 that that IN 19768 127 98 a a DT 19768 127 99 weak weak JJ 19768 127 100 argument argument NN 19768 127 101 is be VBZ 19768 127 102 not not RB 19768 127 103 strengthened strengthen VBN 19768 127 104 , , , 19768 127 105 and and CC 19768 127 106 a a DT 19768 127 107 false false JJ 19768 127 108 accusation accusation NN 19768 127 109 is be VBZ 19768 127 110 not not RB 19768 127 111 justified justify VBN 19768 127 112 , , , 19768 127 113 by by IN 19768 127 114 throwing throw VBG 19768 127 115 " " `` 19768 127 116 professional professional JJ 19768 127 117 warnings warning NNS 19768 127 118 " " '' 19768 127 119 as as IN 19768 127 120 a a DT 19768 127 121 make make NN 19768 127 122 - - HYPH 19768 127 123 weight weight NN 19768 127 124 into into IN 19768 127 125 the the DT 19768 127 126 scales scale NNS 19768 127 127 of of IN 19768 127 128 reason reason NN 19768 127 129 . . . 19768 128 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 128 2 affirm affirm VBP 19768 128 3 emphatically emphatically RB 19768 128 4 that that IN 19768 128 5 no no DT 19768 128 6 professor professor NN 19768 128 7 has have VBZ 19768 128 8 a a DT 19768 128 9 moral moral JJ 19768 128 10 right right NN 19768 128 11 to to TO 19768 128 12 treat treat VB 19768 128 13 anybody anybody NN 19768 128 14 with with IN 19768 128 15 this this DT 19768 128 16 undisguised undisguised JJ 19768 128 17 " " '' 19768 128 18 insolence insolence NN 19768 128 19 of of IN 19768 128 20 office office NN 19768 128 21 , , , 19768 128 22 " " '' 19768 128 23 or or CC 19768 128 24 to to TO 19768 128 25 use use VB 19768 128 26 any any DT 19768 128 27 weapon weapon NN 19768 128 28 but but CC 19768 128 29 reason reason NN 19768 128 30 in in IN 19768 128 31 order order NN 19768 128 32 to to TO 19768 128 33 put put VB 19768 128 34 down down RP 19768 128 35 what what WP 19768 128 36 he -PRON- PRP 19768 128 37 conceives conceive VBZ 19768 128 38 to to TO 19768 128 39 be be VB 19768 128 40 errors error NNS 19768 128 41 in in IN 19768 128 42 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 128 43 . . . 19768 129 1 In in IN 19768 129 2 the the DT 19768 129 3 present present JJ 19768 129 4 case case NN 19768 129 5 , , , 19768 129 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 129 7 deny deny VBP 19768 129 8 that that IN 19768 129 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 129 10 Royce Royce NNP 19768 129 11 has have VBZ 19768 129 12 any any DT 19768 129 13 better well JJR 19768 129 14 or or CC 19768 129 15 stronger strong JJR 19768 129 16 claim claim NN 19768 129 17 than than IN 19768 129 18 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 129 19 to to TO 19768 129 20 speak speak VB 19768 129 21 " " `` 19768 129 22 professionally professionally RB 19768 129 23 " " '' 19768 129 24 on on IN 19768 129 25 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 129 26 questions question NNS 19768 129 27 . . . 19768 130 1 The the DT 19768 130 2 very very JJ 19768 130 3 book book NN 19768 130 4 against against IN 19768 130 5 which which WDT 19768 130 6 he -PRON- PRP 19768 130 7 presumes presume VBZ 19768 130 8 to to TO 19768 130 9 warn warn VB 19768 130 10 the the DT 19768 130 11 public public NN 19768 130 12 " " `` 19768 130 13 professionally professionally RB 19768 130 14 " " '' 19768 130 15 is be VBZ 19768 130 16 founded found VBN 19768 130 17 upon upon IN 19768 130 18 lectures lecture NNS 19768 130 19 which which WDT 19768 130 20 I -PRON- PRP 19768 130 21 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 130 22 " " `` 19768 130 23 professionally professionally RB 19768 130 24 " " '' 19768 130 25 delivered deliver VBN 19768 130 26 , , , 19768 130 27 not not RB 19768 130 28 only only RB 19768 130 29 from from IN 19768 130 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 130 31 Royce Royce NNP 19768 130 32 's 's POS 19768 130 33 own own JJ 19768 130 34 desk desk NN 19768 130 35 and and CC 19768 130 36 to to IN 19768 130 37 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 130 38 Royce Royce NNP 19768 130 39 's 's POS 19768 130 40 own own JJ 19768 130 41 college college NN 19768 130 42 class class NN 19768 130 43 , , , 19768 130 44 but but CC 19768 130 45 as as IN 19768 130 46 a a DT 19768 130 47 substitute substitute NN 19768 130 48 for for IN 19768 130 49 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 130 50 Royce Royce NNP 19768 130 51 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 130 52 , , , 19768 130 53 at at IN 19768 130 54 the the DT 19768 130 55 request request NN 19768 130 56 and and CC 19768 130 57 by by IN 19768 130 58 the the DT 19768 130 59 appointment appointment NN 19768 130 60 of of IN 19768 130 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 130 62 own own JJ 19768 130 63 superiors superior NNS 19768 130 64 , , , 19768 130 65 the the DT 19768 130 66 Corporation Corporation NNP 19768 130 67 and and CC 19768 130 68 Overseers Overseers NNPS 19768 130 69 of of IN 19768 130 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 130 71 own own JJ 19768 130 72 University University NNP 19768 130 73 ; ; : 19768 130 74 and and CC 19768 130 75 the the DT 19768 130 76 singular singular JJ 19768 130 77 impropriety impropriety NN 19768 130 78 ( ( -LRB- 19768 130 79 to to TO 19768 130 80 use use VB 19768 130 81 no no DT 19768 130 82 stronger strong JJR 19768 130 83 word word NN 19768 130 84 ) ) -RRB- 19768 130 85 of of IN 19768 130 86 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 130 87 " " `` 19768 130 88 professional professional JJ 19768 130 89 warning warning NN 19768 130 90 " " '' 19768 130 91 will will MD 19768 130 92 be be VB 19768 130 93 apparent apparent JJ 19768 130 94 to to IN 19768 130 95 every every DT 19768 130 96 one one CD 19768 130 97 in in IN 19768 130 98 the the DT 19768 130 99 light light NN 19768 130 100 of of IN 19768 130 101 that that DT 19768 130 102 fact fact NN 19768 130 103 . . . 19768 131 1 IV IV NNP 19768 131 2 . . . 19768 132 1 So so RB 19768 132 2 far far RB 19768 132 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 132 4 have have VBP 19768 132 5 treated treat VBN 19768 132 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 132 7 Royce Royce NNP 19768 132 8 's 's POS 19768 132 9 attack attack NN 19768 132 10 solely solely RB 19768 132 11 from from IN 19768 132 12 the the DT 19768 132 13 literary literary JJ 19768 132 14 and and CC 19768 132 15 ethical ethical JJ 19768 132 16 points point NNS 19768 132 17 of of IN 19768 132 18 view view NN 19768 132 19 . . . 19768 133 1 The the DT 19768 133 2 legal legal JJ 19768 133 3 point point NN 19768 133 4 of of IN 19768 133 5 view view NN 19768 133 6 must must MD 19768 133 7 now now RB 19768 133 8 be be VB 19768 133 9 considered consider VBN 19768 133 10 . . . 19768 134 1 Plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 134 2 , , , 19768 134 3 conscious conscious JJ 19768 134 4 or or CC 19768 134 5 unconscious unconscious JJ 19768 134 6 , , , 19768 134 7 is be VBZ 19768 134 8 a a DT 19768 134 9 very very RB 19768 134 10 grave grave JJ 19768 134 11 and and CC 19768 134 12 serious serious JJ 19768 134 13 charge charge NN 19768 134 14 to to TO 19768 134 15 bring bring VB 19768 134 16 against against IN 19768 134 17 an an DT 19768 134 18 author author NN 19768 134 19 , , , 19768 134 20 and and CC 19768 134 21 one one CD 19768 134 22 which which WDT 19768 134 23 may may MD 19768 134 24 entail entail VB 19768 134 25 upon upon IN 19768 134 26 him -PRON- PRP 19768 134 27 , , , 19768 134 28 not not RB 19768 134 29 only only RB 19768 134 30 great great JJ 19768 134 31 damage damage NN 19768 134 32 to to IN 19768 134 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 134 34 literary literary JJ 19768 134 35 reputation reputation NN 19768 134 36 , , , 19768 134 37 but but CC 19768 134 38 also also RB 19768 134 39 social social JJ 19768 134 40 disgrace disgrace NN 19768 134 41 and and CC 19768 134 42 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 19768 134 43 loss loss NN 19768 134 44 . . . 19768 135 1 If if IN 19768 135 2 proved prove VBN 19768 135 3 , , , 19768 135 4 or or CC 19768 135 5 even even RB 19768 135 6 if if IN 19768 135 7 widely widely RB 19768 135 8 believed believe VBD 19768 135 9 without without IN 19768 135 10 proof proof NN 19768 135 11 , , , 19768 135 12 it -PRON- PRP 19768 135 13 can can MD 19768 135 14 not not RB 19768 135 15 but but RB 19768 135 16 ruin ruin VB 19768 135 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 135 18 literary literary JJ 19768 135 19 career career NN 19768 135 20 and and CC 19768 135 21 destroy destroy VB 19768 135 22 the the DT 19768 135 23 marketable marketable JJ 19768 135 24 value value NN 19768 135 25 of of IN 19768 135 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 135 27 books book NNS 19768 135 28 ; ; : 19768 135 29 and and CC 19768 135 30 it -PRON- PRP 19768 135 31 matters matter VBZ 19768 135 32 little little JJ 19768 135 33 , , , 19768 135 34 so so RB 19768 135 35 far far RB 19768 135 36 as as IN 19768 135 37 these these DT 19768 135 38 practical practical JJ 19768 135 39 results result NNS 19768 135 40 are be VBP 19768 135 41 concerned concern VBN 19768 135 42 , , , 19768 135 43 whether whether IN 19768 135 44 the the DT 19768 135 45 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 135 46 attributed attribute VBD 19768 135 47 to to IN 19768 135 48 him -PRON- PRP 19768 135 49 is be VBZ 19768 135 50 conscious conscious JJ 19768 135 51 or or CC 19768 135 52 unconscious unconscious JJ 19768 135 53 . . . 19768 136 1 In in IN 19768 136 2 an an DT 19768 136 3 able able JJ 19768 136 4 editorial editorial JJ 19768 136 5 article article NN 19768 136 6 on on IN 19768 136 7 " " `` 19768 136 8 Law Law NNP 19768 136 9 and and CC 19768 136 10 Theft Theft NNP 19768 136 11 , , , 19768 136 12 " " '' 19768 136 13 published publish VBN 19768 136 14 in in IN 19768 136 15 the the DT 19768 136 16 New New NNP 19768 136 17 York York NNP 19768 136 18 " " `` 19768 136 19 Nation Nation NNP 19768 136 20 " " '' 19768 136 21 of of IN 19768 136 22 Feb. February NNP 19768 136 23 12 12 CD 19768 136 24 , , , 19768 136 25 1891 1891 CD 19768 136 26 , , , 19768 136 27 it -PRON- PRP 19768 136 28 is be VBZ 19768 136 29 forcibly forcibly RB 19768 136 30 said say VBN 19768 136 31 : : : 19768 136 32 " " `` 19768 136 33 Authors author NNS 19768 136 34 or or CC 19768 136 35 writers writer NNS 19768 136 36 who who WP 19768 136 37 do do VBP 19768 136 38 this this DT 19768 136 39 [ [ -LRB- 19768 136 40 borrowing borrow VBG 19768 136 41 other other JJ 19768 136 42 men man NNS 19768 136 43 's 's POS 19768 136 44 ideas idea NNS 19768 136 45 ] ] -RRB- 19768 136 46 a a DT 19768 136 47 good good JJ 19768 136 48 deal deal NN 19768 136 49 , , , 19768 136 50 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19768 136 51 incur incur VBP 19768 136 52 discredit discredit JJ 19768 136 53 by by IN 19768 136 54 it -PRON- PRP 19768 136 55 with with IN 19768 136 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 136 57 fellows fellow NNS 19768 136 58 and and CC 19768 136 59 the the DT 19768 136 60 general general JJ 19768 136 61 public public NN 19768 136 62 . . . 19768 137 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 137 2 greatly greatly RB 19768 137 3 damages damage VBZ 19768 137 4 a a DT 19768 137 5 writer writer NN 19768 137 6 's 's POS 19768 137 7 fame fame NN 19768 137 8 to to TO 19768 137 9 be be VB 19768 137 10 rightfully rightfully RB 19768 137 11 accused accuse VBN 19768 137 12 of of IN 19768 137 13 want want NN 19768 137 14 of of IN 19768 137 15 originality originality NN 19768 137 16 , , , 19768 137 17 or or CC 19768 137 18 of of IN 19768 137 19 imitation imitation NN 19768 137 20 , , , 19768 137 21 or or CC 19768 137 22 of of IN 19768 137 23 getting get VBG 19768 137 24 materials material NNS 19768 137 25 at at IN 19768 137 26 second second JJ 19768 137 27 hand hand NN 19768 137 28 . . . 19768 138 1 But but CC 19768 138 2 no no DT 19768 138 3 one one NN 19768 138 4 has have VBZ 19768 138 5 ever ever RB 19768 138 6 proposed propose VBN 19768 138 7 to to TO 19768 138 8 punish punish VB 19768 138 9 or or CC 19768 138 10 restrain restrain VB 19768 138 11 this this DT 19768 138 12 sort sort NN 19768 138 13 of of IN 19768 138 14 misappropriation misappropriation NN 19768 138 15 by by IN 19768 138 16 law law NN 19768 138 17 . . . 19768 139 1 No no DT 19768 139 2 one one NN 19768 139 3 has have VBZ 19768 139 4 ever ever RB 19768 139 5 contended contend VBN 19768 139 6 for for IN 19768 139 7 the the DT 19768 139 8 infliction infliction NN 19768 139 9 on on IN 19768 139 10 the the DT 19768 139 11 purloiners purloiner NNS 19768 139 12 of of IN 19768 139 13 other other JJ 19768 139 14 men man NNS 19768 139 15 's 's POS 19768 139 16 ideas idea NNS 19768 139 17 of of IN 19768 139 18 any any DT 19768 139 19 penalty penalty NN 19768 139 20 but but CC 19768 139 21 ridicule ridicule NN 19768 139 22 or or CC 19768 139 23 disgrace disgrace NN 19768 139 24 . . . 19768 139 25 " " '' 19768 140 1 Whoever whoever WP 19768 140 2 _ _ NNP 19768 140 3 wrongfully wrongfully RB 19768 140 4 _ _ NNP 19768 140 5 accuses accuse VBZ 19768 140 6 an an DT 19768 140 7 author author NN 19768 140 8 of of IN 19768 140 9 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 140 10 , , , 19768 140 11 then then RB 19768 140 12 , , , 19768 140 13 holds hold VBZ 19768 140 14 him -PRON- PRP 19768 140 15 up up RP 19768 140 16 _ _ NNP 19768 140 17 undeservedly undeservedly RB 19768 140 18 _ _ NNP 19768 140 19 to to TO 19768 140 20 " " `` 19768 140 21 discredit discredit NNP 19768 140 22 , , , 19768 140 23 ridicule ridicule NN 19768 140 24 , , , 19768 140 25 or or CC 19768 140 26 disgrace disgrace NN 19768 140 27 , , , 19768 140 28 " " '' 19768 140 29 and and CC 19768 140 30 " " `` 19768 140 31 slanders slander VBZ 19768 140 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 140 33 title title NN 19768 140 34 " " '' 19768 140 35 to to IN 19768 140 36 the the DT 19768 140 37 product product NN 19768 140 38 of of IN 19768 140 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 140 40 own own JJ 19768 140 41 brain brain NN 19768 140 42 . . . 19768 141 1 This this DT 19768 141 2 is be VBZ 19768 141 3 contrary contrary JJ 19768 141 4 to to IN 19768 141 5 the the DT 19768 141 6 law law NN 19768 141 7 . . . 19768 142 1 Yet yet CC 19768 142 2 this this DT 19768 142 3 is be VBZ 19768 142 4 precisely precisely RB 19768 142 5 what what WP 19768 142 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 142 7 Royce Royce NNP 19768 142 8 has have VBZ 19768 142 9 done do VBN 19768 142 10 in in IN 19768 142 11 accusing accuse VBG 19768 142 12 me -PRON- PRP 19768 142 13 _ _ NNP 19768 142 14 falsely falsely RB 19768 142 15 _ _ NNP 19768 142 16 , , , 19768 142 17 and and CC 19768 142 18 as as IN 19768 142 19 a a DT 19768 142 20 _ _ NNP 19768 142 21 " " `` 19768 142 22 certain certain JJ 19768 142 23 " " '' 19768 142 24 matter matter NN 19768 142 25 of of IN 19768 142 26 fact fact NN 19768 142 27 _ _ NNP 19768 142 28 , , , 19768 142 29 of of IN 19768 142 30 borrowing borrow VBG 19768 142 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 142 32 theory theory NN 19768 142 33 of of IN 19768 142 34 universals universal NNS 19768 142 35 from from IN 19768 142 36 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 142 37 . . . 19768 143 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19768 143 2 accusation accusation NN 19768 143 3 is be VBZ 19768 143 4 made make VBN 19768 143 5 with with IN 19768 143 6 as as RB 19768 143 7 many many JJ 19768 143 8 sneers sneer NNS 19768 143 9 and and CC 19768 143 10 as as IN 19768 143 11 much much JJ 19768 143 12 insult insult NN 19768 143 13 as as IN 19768 143 14 could could MD 19768 143 15 well well RB 19768 143 16 be be VB 19768 143 17 compressed compress VBN 19768 143 18 into into IN 19768 143 19 the the DT 19768 143 20 space:-- space:-- NN 19768 143 21 " " `` 19768 143 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 143 23 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 143 24 is be VBZ 19768 143 25 hopelessly hopelessly RB 19768 143 26 unhistorical unhistorical JJ 19768 143 27 in in IN 19768 143 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 143 29 consciousness consciousness NN 19768 143 30 . . . 19768 144 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19768 144 2 ' ' `` 19768 144 3 American american JJ 19768 144 4 theory theory NN 19768 144 5 of of IN 19768 144 6 universals universal NNS 19768 144 7 ' ' '' 19768 144 8 is be VBZ 19768 144 9 so so RB 19768 144 10 far far RB 19768 144 11 from from IN 19768 144 12 being be VBG 19768 144 13 either either CC 19768 144 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 144 15 own own JJ 19768 144 16 or or CC 19768 144 17 a a DT 19768 144 18 product product NN 19768 144 19 of of IN 19768 144 20 America America NNP 19768 144 21 that that IN 19768 144 22 in in IN 19768 144 23 this this DT 19768 144 24 book book NN 19768 144 25 he -PRON- PRP 19768 144 26 continually continually RB 19768 144 27 has have VBZ 19768 144 28 to to TO 19768 144 29 use use VB 19768 144 30 , , , 19768 144 31 in in IN 19768 144 32 expounding expound VBG 19768 144 33 it -PRON- PRP 19768 144 34 , , , 19768 144 35 one one CD 19768 144 36 of of IN 19768 144 37 the the DT 19768 144 38 most most RBS 19768 144 39 characteristic characteristic JJ 19768 144 40 and and CC 19768 144 41 familiar familiar JJ 19768 144 42 of of IN 19768 144 43 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 144 44 's 's POS 19768 144 45 technical technical JJ 19768 144 46 terms term NNS 19768 144 47 , , , 19768 144 48 namely namely RB 19768 144 49 , , , 19768 144 50 ' ' `` 19768 144 51 concrete concrete NN 19768 144 52 , , , 19768 144 53 ' ' '' 19768 144 54 in in IN 19768 144 55 that that DT 19768 144 56 sense sense NN 19768 144 57 in in IN 19768 144 58 which which WDT 19768 144 59 it -PRON- PRP 19768 144 60 is be VBZ 19768 144 61 applied apply VBN 19768 144 62 to to IN 19768 144 63 the the DT 19768 144 64 objective objective JJ 19768 144 65 and and CC 19768 144 66 universal universal JJ 19768 144 67 ' ' '' 19768 144 68 genus genus NN 19768 144 69 . . . 19768 144 70 ' ' '' 19768 145 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 145 2 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 145 3 's 's POS 19768 145 4 appropriation appropriation NN 19768 145 5 of of IN 19768 145 6 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 145 7 's 's POS 19768 145 8 peculiar peculiar JJ 19768 145 9 terminology terminology NN 19768 145 10 comes come VBZ 19768 145 11 ill ill RB 19768 145 12 indeed indeed RB 19768 145 13 from from IN 19768 145 14 one one CD 19768 145 15 who who WP 19768 145 16 talks talk VBZ 19768 145 17 , , , 19768 145 18 " " `` 19768 145 19 _ _ NNP 19768 145 20 etc etc FW 19768 145 21 . . . 19768 145 22 _ _ NNP 19768 145 23 " " `` 19768 145 24 This this DT 19768 145 25 I -PRON- PRP 19768 145 26 say say VBP 19768 145 27 not not RB 19768 145 28 to to TO 19768 145 29 defend defend VB 19768 145 30 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 145 31 , , , 19768 145 32 for for IN 19768 145 33 whose whose WP$ 19768 145 34 elaborate elaborate JJ 19768 145 35 theory theory NN 19768 145 36 of of IN 19768 145 37 universals universal NNS 19768 145 38 I -PRON- PRP 19768 145 39 hold hold VBP 19768 145 40 in in RP 19768 145 41 no no UH 19768 145 42 wise wise JJ 19768 145 43 a a DT 19768 145 44 brief brief NN 19768 145 45 , , , 19768 145 46 but but CC 19768 145 47 simply simply RB 19768 145 48 in in IN 19768 145 49 the the DT 19768 145 50 cause cause NN 19768 145 51 of of IN 19768 145 52 literary literary JJ 19768 145 53 property property NN 19768 145 54 - - HYPH 19768 145 55 rights right NNS 19768 145 56 . . . 19768 146 1 When when WRB 19768 146 2 we -PRON- PRP 19768 146 3 plough plough VBP 19768 146 4 with with IN 19768 146 5 another another DT 19768 146 6 man man NN 19768 146 7 's 's POS 19768 146 8 heifer heifer NN 19768 146 9 , , , 19768 146 10 however however WRB 19768 146 11 unconscious unconscious JJ 19768 146 12 we -PRON- PRP 19768 146 13 are be VBP 19768 146 14 of of IN 19768 146 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 146 16 appropriation appropriation NN 19768 146 17 , , , 19768 146 18 however however RB 19768 146 19 sincerely sincerely RB 19768 146 20 we -PRON- PRP 19768 146 21 seem seem VBP 19768 146 22 to to TO 19768 146 23 remember remember VB 19768 146 24 that that IN 19768 146 25 we -PRON- PRP 19768 146 26 alone alone RB 19768 146 27 raised raise VBD 19768 146 28 her -PRON- PRP 19768 146 29 from from IN 19768 146 30 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 146 31 earliest early JJS 19768 146 32 calfhood calfhood NN 19768 146 33 , , , 19768 146 34 it -PRON- PRP 19768 146 35 is be VBZ 19768 146 36 yet yet RB 19768 146 37 in in IN 19768 146 38 vain vain JJ 19768 146 39 , , , 19768 146 40 after after RB 19768 146 41 all all RB 19768 146 42 , , , 19768 146 43 that that IN 19768 146 44 we -PRON- PRP 19768 146 45 put put VBP 19768 146 46 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 146 47 brand brand NN 19768 146 48 on on IN 19768 146 49 her -PRON- PRP 19768 146 50 , , , 19768 146 51 or or CC 19768 146 52 call call VB 19768 146 53 her -PRON- PRP 19768 146 54 ' ' `` 19768 146 55 American american JJ 19768 146 56 . . . 19768 146 57 ' ' '' 19768 146 58 ... ... : 19768 147 1 Now now RB 19768 147 2 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 147 3 's 's POS 19768 147 4 whole whole JJ 19768 147 5 theory theory NN 19768 147 6 may may MD 19768 147 7 be be VB 19768 147 8 false false JJ 19768 147 9 ; ; : 19768 147 10 but but CC 19768 147 11 what what WP 19768 147 12 is be VBZ 19768 147 13 certain certain JJ 19768 147 14 is be VBZ 19768 147 15 that that IN 19768 147 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 147 17 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 147 18 , , , 19768 147 19 who who WP 19768 147 20 has have VBZ 19768 147 21 all all PDT 19768 147 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 147 23 life life NN 19768 147 24 been be VBN 19768 147 25 working work VBG 19768 147 26 in in IN 19768 147 27 an an DT 19768 147 28 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19768 147 29 where where WRB 19768 147 30 Hegelian hegelian JJ 19768 147 31 ideas idea NNS 19768 147 32 were be VBD 19768 147 33 more more RBR 19768 147 34 or or CC 19768 147 35 less less RBR 19768 147 36 infectious infectious JJ 19768 147 37 , , , 19768 147 38 has have VBZ 19768 147 39 derived derive VBN 19768 147 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 147 41 whole whole JJ 19768 147 42 theory theory NN 19768 147 43 of of IN 19768 147 44 universals universal NNS 19768 147 45 , , , 19768 147 46 so so RB 19768 147 47 far far RB 19768 147 48 as as IN 19768 147 49 he -PRON- PRP 19768 147 50 has have VBZ 19768 147 51 yet yet RB 19768 147 52 revealed reveal VBN 19768 147 53 it -PRON- PRP 19768 147 54 with with IN 19768 147 55 any any DT 19768 147 56 coherency coherency NN 19768 147 57 , , , 19768 147 58 from from IN 19768 147 59 Hegelian hegelian JJ 19768 147 60 sources source NNS 19768 147 61 , , , 19768 147 62 and and CC 19768 147 63 even even RB 19768 147 64 now now RB 19768 147 65 can can MD 19768 147 66 not not RB 19768 147 67 suggest suggest VB 19768 147 68 any any DT 19768 147 69 better well JJR 19768 147 70 terminology terminology NN 19768 147 71 than than IN 19768 147 72 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 147 73 's 's POS 19768 147 74 for for IN 19768 147 75 an an DT 19768 147 76 important important JJ 19768 147 77 portion portion NN 19768 147 78 of of IN 19768 147 79 the the DT 19768 147 80 doctrine doctrine NN 19768 147 81 . . . 19768 148 1 Yet yet CC 19768 148 2 in in IN 19768 148 3 the the DT 19768 148 4 volume volume NN 19768 148 5 before before IN 19768 148 6 us -PRON- PRP 19768 148 7 we -PRON- PRP 19768 148 8 find find VBP 19768 148 9 all all PDT 19768 148 10 this this DT 19768 148 11 pretentious pretentious JJ 19768 148 12 speech speech NN 19768 148 13 of of IN 19768 148 14 an an DT 19768 148 15 ' ' `` 19768 148 16 American American NNP 19768 148 17 ' ' '' 19768 148 18 theory theory NN 19768 148 19 , , , 19768 148 20 and and CC 19768 148 21 discover discover VBP 19768 148 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 148 23 author author NN 19768 148 24 wholly wholly RB 19768 148 25 unaware unaware JJ 19768 148 26 that that IN 19768 148 27 he -PRON- PRP 19768 148 28 is be VBZ 19768 148 29 sinning sin VBG 19768 148 30 against against IN 19768 148 31 the the DT 19768 148 32 most most RBS 19768 148 33 obvious obvious JJ 19768 148 34 demands demand NNS 19768 148 35 of of IN 19768 148 36 literary literary JJ 19768 148 37 property property NN 19768 148 38 - - HYPH 19768 148 39 rights right NNS 19768 148 40 . . . 19768 148 41 " " '' 19768 149 1 Passing pass VBG 19768 149 2 over over RP 19768 149 3 the the DT 19768 149 4 self self NN 19768 149 5 - - HYPH 19768 149 6 evident evident JJ 19768 149 7 point point NN 19768 149 8 that that IN 19768 149 9 whoever whoever WP 19768 149 10 is be VBZ 19768 149 11 " " `` 19768 149 12 _ _ NNP 19768 149 13 unaware unaware JJ 19768 149 14 _ _ NNP 19768 149 15 that that IN 19768 149 16 he -PRON- PRP 19768 149 17 is be VBZ 19768 149 18 sinning sin VBG 19768 149 19 " " `` 19768 149 20 can can MD 19768 149 21 not not RB 19768 149 22 be be VB 19768 149 23 " " `` 19768 149 24 sinning sin VBG 19768 149 25 " " '' 19768 149 26 at at RB 19768 149 27 all all RB 19768 149 28 , , , 19768 149 29 since since IN 19768 149 30 " " `` 19768 149 31 sinning sin VBG 19768 149 32 " " '' 19768 149 33 consists consist VBZ 19768 149 34 in in IN 19768 149 35 _ _ NNP 19768 149 36 being be VBG 19768 149 37 aware aware JJ 19768 149 38 _ _ NNP 19768 149 39 of of IN 19768 149 40 the the DT 19768 149 41 wrong wrong NN 19768 149 42 we -PRON- PRP 19768 149 43 do,--and do,--and NNP 19768 149 44 , , , 19768 149 45 consequently consequently RB 19768 149 46 , , , 19768 149 47 that that IN 19768 149 48 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 149 49 Royce Royce NNP 19768 149 50 comes come VBZ 19768 149 51 here here RB 19768 149 52 as as RB 19768 149 53 near near RB 19768 149 54 as as IN 19768 149 55 he -PRON- PRP 19768 149 56 dares dare VBZ 19768 149 57 to to IN 19768 149 58 a a DT 19768 149 59 direct direct JJ 19768 149 60 insinuation insinuation NN 19768 149 61 that that IN 19768 149 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 149 63 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 149 64 is be VBZ 19768 149 65 conscious conscious JJ 19768 149 66 , , , 19768 149 67 and and CC 19768 149 68 not not RB 19768 149 69 " " `` 19768 149 70 unconscious,"--let unconscious,"--let VB 19768 149 71 me -PRON- PRP 19768 149 72 call call VBP 19768 149 73 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 149 74 attention attention NN 19768 149 75 to to IN 19768 149 76 the the DT 19768 149 77 more more RBR 19768 149 78 important important JJ 19768 149 79 point point NN 19768 149 80 , , , 19768 149 81 that that IN 19768 149 82 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 149 83 Royce Royce NNP 19768 149 84 affirms affirm VBZ 19768 149 85 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 149 86 conscious conscious JJ 19768 149 87 or or CC 19768 149 88 unconscious unconscious JJ 19768 149 89 theft theft NN 19768 149 90 from from IN 19768 149 91 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 149 92 as as IN 19768 149 93 a a DT 19768 149 94 matter matter NN 19768 149 95 of of IN 19768 149 96 _ _ NNP 19768 149 97 " " `` 19768 149 98 certain certain JJ 19768 149 99 " " '' 19768 149 100 fact fact NN 19768 149 101 _ _ NNP 19768 149 102 , , , 19768 149 103 not not RB 19768 149 104 merely merely RB 19768 149 105 as as IN 19768 149 106 a a DT 19768 149 107 matter matter NN 19768 149 108 of of IN 19768 149 109 _ _ NNP 19768 149 110 probable probable JJ 19768 149 111 inference inference NN 19768 149 112 _ _ NNP 19768 149 113 . . . 19768 150 1 Yet yet CC 19768 150 2 the the DT 19768 150 3 only only JJ 19768 150 4 evidence evidence NN 19768 150 5 he -PRON- PRP 19768 150 6 has have VBZ 19768 150 7 to to TO 19768 150 8 offer offer VB 19768 150 9 in in IN 19768 150 10 support support NN 19768 150 11 of of IN 19768 150 12 this this DT 19768 150 13 " " `` 19768 150 14 certainty certainty NN 19768 150 15 " " '' 19768 150 16 is be VBZ 19768 150 17 ( ( -LRB- 19768 150 18 1 1 LS 19768 150 19 ) ) -RRB- 19768 150 20 that that WDT 19768 150 21 I -PRON- PRP 19768 150 22 use use VBP 19768 150 23 the the DT 19768 150 24 word word NN 19768 150 25 " " `` 19768 150 26 concrete concrete NN 19768 150 27 " " '' 19768 150 28 in in IN 19768 150 29 the the DT 19768 150 30 same same JJ 19768 150 31 sense sense NN 19768 150 32 as as IN 19768 150 33 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 150 34 , , , 19768 150 35 and and CC 19768 150 36 ( ( -LRB- 19768 150 37 2 2 LS 19768 150 38 ) ) -RRB- 19768 150 39 that that WDT 19768 150 40 I -PRON- PRP 19768 150 41 have have VBP 19768 150 42 worked work VBN 19768 150 43 all all PDT 19768 150 44 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 150 45 life life NN 19768 150 46 in in IN 19768 150 47 a a DT 19768 150 48 Hegelian hegelian JJ 19768 150 49 " " '' 19768 150 50 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19768 150 51 . . . 19768 150 52 " " '' 19768 151 1 These these DT 19768 151 2 two two CD 19768 151 3 points point NNS 19768 151 4 cover cover VBP 19768 151 5 all all PDT 19768 151 6 the the DT 19768 151 7 grounds ground NNS 19768 151 8 of of IN 19768 151 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 151 10 accusation accusation NN 19768 151 11 . . . 19768 152 1 Permit permit VB 19768 152 2 me -PRON- PRP 19768 152 3 very very RB 19768 152 4 briefly briefly NN 19768 152 5 to to TO 19768 152 6 examine examine VB 19768 152 7 them -PRON- PRP 19768 152 8 . . . 19768 153 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 153 2 1 1 LS 19768 153 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 153 4 The the DT 19768 153 5 word word NN 19768 153 6 " " `` 19768 153 7 concrete concrete NN 19768 153 8 " " '' 19768 153 9 is be VBZ 19768 153 10 not not RB 19768 153 11 in in IN 19768 153 12 the the DT 19768 153 13 least least JJS 19768 153 14 a a DT 19768 153 15 technical technical JJ 19768 153 16 term term NN 19768 153 17 copyrighted copyright VBN 19768 153 18 by by IN 19768 153 19 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 153 20 , , , 19768 153 21 nor nor CC 19768 153 22 is be VBZ 19768 153 23 it -PRON- PRP 19768 153 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 153 25 trademark trademark NN 19768 153 26 . . . 19768 154 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 154 2 is be VBZ 19768 154 3 one one CD 19768 154 4 of of IN 19768 154 5 the the DT 19768 154 6 commonest common JJS 19768 154 7 of of IN 19768 154 8 words word NNS 19768 154 9 , , , 19768 154 10 and and CC 19768 154 11 free free JJ 19768 154 12 to to IN 19768 154 13 all all DT 19768 154 14 . . . 19768 155 1 But but CC 19768 155 2 what what WP 19768 155 3 sort sort NN 19768 155 4 of of IN 19768 155 5 a a DT 19768 155 6 reasoner reasoner NN 19768 155 7 is be VBZ 19768 155 8 he -PRON- PRP 19768 155 9 who who WP 19768 155 10 infers infer VBZ 19768 155 11 the the DT 19768 155 12 identity identity NN 19768 155 13 of of IN 19768 155 14 two two CD 19768 155 15 whole whole JJ 19768 155 16 complex complex JJ 19768 155 17 theories theory NNS 19768 155 18 from from IN 19768 155 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 155 20 coincidence coincidence NN 19768 155 21 in in IN 19768 155 22 the the DT 19768 155 23 use use NN 19768 155 24 of of IN 19768 155 25 only only RB 19768 155 26 a a DT 19768 155 27 single single JJ 19768 155 28 word word NN 19768 155 29 ? ? . 19768 156 1 Even even RB 19768 156 2 this this DT 19768 156 3 poor poor JJ 19768 156 4 and and CC 19768 156 5 solitary solitary JJ 19768 156 6 little little JJ 19768 156 7 premise premise NN 19768 156 8 slips slip VBZ 19768 156 9 out out IN 19768 156 10 of of IN 19768 156 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 156 12 Royce Royce NNP 19768 156 13 's 's POS 19768 156 14 clutch clutch NN 19768 156 15 , , , 19768 156 16 for for IN 19768 156 17 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 156 18 's 's POS 19768 156 19 use use NN 19768 156 20 of of IN 19768 156 21 the the DT 19768 156 22 word word NN 19768 156 23 is be VBZ 19768 156 24 _ _ NNP 19768 156 25 contradictory contradictory JJ 19768 156 26 to to IN 19768 156 27 mine -PRON- PRP 19768 156 28 _ _ NNP 19768 156 29 ! ! . 19768 157 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 157 2 has have VBZ 19768 157 3 to to TO 19768 157 4 put put VB 19768 157 5 upon upon IN 19768 157 6 the the DT 19768 157 7 word word NN 19768 157 8 " " `` 19768 157 9 concrete concrete NN 19768 157 10 " " '' 19768 157 11 a a DT 19768 157 12 very very RB 19768 157 13 unusual unusual JJ 19768 157 14 , , , 19768 157 15 strained strained JJ 19768 157 16 , , , 19768 157 17 and and CC 19768 157 18 artificial artificial JJ 19768 157 19 sense sense NN 19768 157 20 , , , 19768 157 21 in in IN 19768 157 22 order order NN 19768 157 23 to to TO 19768 157 24 cover cover VB 19768 157 25 up up RP 19768 157 26 the the DT 19768 157 27 weakest weak JJS 19768 157 28 point point NN 19768 157 29 of of IN 19768 157 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 157 31 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 157 32 system system NN 19768 157 33 . . . 19768 158 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 158 2 explains explain VBZ 19768 158 3 it -PRON- PRP 19768 158 4 , , , 19768 158 5 however however RB 19768 158 6 , , , 19768 158 7 frankly frankly RB 19768 158 8 , , , 19768 158 9 clearly clearly RB 19768 158 10 , , , 19768 158 11 and and CC 19768 158 12 unambiguously unambiguously RB 19768 158 13 : : : 19768 158 14 " " `` 19768 158 15 The the DT 19768 158 16 Concept Concept NNP 19768 158 17 or or CC 19768 158 18 Notion Notion NNP 19768 158 19 ( ( -LRB- 19768 158 20 _ _ NNP 19768 158 21 Begriff Begriff NNP 19768 158 22 _ _ NNP 19768 158 23 ) ) -RRB- 19768 158 24 may may MD 19768 158 25 be be VB 19768 158 26 always always RB 19768 158 27 called call VBN 19768 158 28 ' ' '' 19768 158 29 abstract abstract JJ 19768 158 30 , , , 19768 158 31 ' ' '' 19768 158 32 if if IN 19768 158 33 the the DT 19768 158 34 term term NN 19768 158 35 ' ' `` 19768 158 36 concrete concrete NN 19768 158 37 ' ' '' 19768 158 38 must must MD 19768 158 39 be be VB 19768 158 40 limited limit VBN 19768 158 41 to to IN 19768 158 42 the the DT 19768 158 43 mere mere JJ 19768 158 44 concrete concrete NN 19768 158 45 of of IN 19768 158 46 sensation sensation NN 19768 158 47 and and CC 19768 158 48 immediate immediate JJ 19768 158 49 perception perception NN 19768 158 50 ; ; : 19768 158 51 the the DT 19768 158 52 Notion Notion NNP 19768 158 53 as as IN 19768 158 54 such such JJ 19768 158 55 can can MD 19768 158 56 not not RB 19768 158 57 be be VB 19768 158 58 grasped grasp VBN 19768 158 59 by by IN 19768 158 60 the the DT 19768 158 61 hands hand NNS 19768 158 62 , , , 19768 158 63 and and CC 19768 158 64 , , , 19768 158 65 when when WRB 19768 158 66 we -PRON- PRP 19768 158 67 deal deal VBP 19768 158 68 with with IN 19768 158 69 it -PRON- PRP 19768 158 70 , , , 19768 158 71 eyes eye NNS 19768 158 72 and and CC 19768 158 73 ears ear NNS 19768 158 74 are be VBP 19768 158 75 out out IN 19768 158 76 of of IN 19768 158 77 the the DT 19768 158 78 question question NN 19768 158 79 . . . 19768 159 1 Yet yet RB 19768 159 2 , , , 19768 159 3 as as IN 19768 159 4 was be VBD 19768 159 5 said say VBN 19768 159 6 before before RB 19768 159 7 , , , 19768 159 8 the the DT 19768 159 9 Notion Notion NNP 19768 159 10 is be VBZ 19768 159 11 the the DT 19768 159 12 only only JJ 19768 159 13 true true JJ 19768 159 14 concrete concrete NN 19768 159 15 . . . 19768 159 16 " " '' 19768 160 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 160 2 _ _ NNP 19768 160 3 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19768 160 4 , , , 19768 160 5 Werke Werke NNP 19768 160 6 _ _ NNP 19768 160 7 , , , 19768 160 8 VI VI NNP 19768 160 9 . . . 19768 161 1 316 316 CD 19768 161 2 . . . 19768 161 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 162 1 Again again RB 19768 162 2 : : : 19768 162 3 " " `` 19768 162 4 Just just RB 19768 162 5 as as RB 19768 162 6 little little JJ 19768 162 7 is be VBZ 19768 162 8 the the DT 19768 162 9 sensuous sensuous JJ 19768 162 10 - - HYPH 19768 162 11 concrete concrete NN 19768 162 12 of of IN 19768 162 13 Intuition Intuition NNP 19768 162 14 a a DT 19768 162 15 rational rational JJ 19768 162 16 - - HYPH 19768 162 17 concrete concrete NN 19768 162 18 of of IN 19768 162 19 the the DT 19768 162 20 Idea Idea NNP 19768 162 21 . . . 19768 162 22 " " '' 19768 163 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 163 2 _ _ NNP 19768 163 3 Ibid Ibid NNP 19768 163 4 . . . 19768 163 5 , , , 19768 163 6 Werke Werke NNP 19768 163 7 _ _ NNP 19768 163 8 , , , 19768 163 9 VI VI NNP 19768 163 10 . . . 19768 164 1 404 404 CD 19768 164 2 . . . 19768 164 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 165 1 A a DT 19768 165 2 score score NN 19768 165 3 of of IN 19768 165 4 similar similar JJ 19768 165 5 passages passage NNS 19768 165 6 can can MD 19768 165 7 easily easily RB 19768 165 8 be be VB 19768 165 9 cited cite VBN 19768 165 10 . . . 19768 166 1 That that DT 19768 166 2 is be VBZ 19768 166 3 to to TO 19768 166 4 say say VB 19768 166 5 , , , 19768 166 6 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 166 7 avowedly avowedly RB 19768 166 8 excludes exclude VBZ 19768 166 9 from from IN 19768 166 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 166 11 _ _ NNP 19768 166 12 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 166 13 _ _ NNP 19768 166 14 theory theory NN 19768 166 15 of of IN 19768 166 16 universals universal NNS 19768 166 17 the the DT 19768 166 18 " " `` 19768 166 19 concrete concrete JJ 19768 166 20 " " '' 19768 166 21 of of IN 19768 166 22 sensation sensation NN 19768 166 23 , , , 19768 166 24 perception perception NN 19768 166 25 , , , 19768 166 26 intuition intuition NN 19768 166 27 , , , 19768 166 28 or or CC 19768 166 29 _ _ NNP 19768 166 30 real real JJ 19768 166 31 experience experience NN 19768 166 32 _ _ NNP 19768 166 33 , , , 19768 166 34 and and CC 19768 166 35 admits admit VBZ 19768 166 36 into into IN 19768 166 37 it -PRON- PRP 19768 166 38 only only RB 19768 166 39 the the DT 19768 166 40 " " `` 19768 166 41 concrete concrete NN 19768 166 42 " " '' 19768 166 43 of of IN 19768 166 44 _ _ NNP 19768 166 45 pure pure JJ 19768 166 46 or or CC 19768 166 47 non non JJ 19768 166 48 - - JJ 19768 166 49 empirical empirical JJ 19768 166 50 thought thought NN 19768 166 51 _ _ NNP 19768 166 52 ; ; : 19768 166 53 while while IN 19768 166 54 I -PRON- PRP 19768 166 55 avowedly avowedly RB 19768 166 56 exclude exclude VBP 19768 166 57 from from IN 19768 166 58 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 166 59 _ _ NNP 19768 166 60 realistic realistic JJ 19768 166 61 _ _ NNP 19768 166 62 theory theory NN 19768 166 63 of of IN 19768 166 64 universals universal NNS 19768 166 65 the the DT 19768 166 66 " " `` 19768 166 67 concrete concrete NN 19768 166 68 " " '' 19768 166 69 of of IN 19768 166 70 _ _ NNP 19768 166 71 pure pure JJ 19768 166 72 thought thought NN 19768 166 73 _ _ NNP 19768 166 74 , , , 19768 166 75 and and CC 19768 166 76 admit admit VB 19768 166 77 into into IN 19768 166 78 it -PRON- PRP 19768 166 79 only only RB 19768 166 80 the the DT 19768 166 81 " " `` 19768 166 82 concrete concrete NN 19768 166 83 " " '' 19768 166 84 of of IN 19768 166 85 _ _ NNP 19768 166 86 real real JJ 19768 166 87 experience experience NN 19768 166 88 _ _ NNP 19768 166 89 . . . 19768 167 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 167 2 's 's POS 19768 167 3 " " `` 19768 167 4 concrete concrete NN 19768 167 5 " " '' 19768 167 6 can can MD 19768 167 7 not not RB 19768 167 8 be be VB 19768 167 9 seen see VBN 19768 167 10 , , , 19768 167 11 heard hear VBN 19768 167 12 , , , 19768 167 13 or or CC 19768 167 14 touched touch VBD 19768 167 15 ; ; : 19768 167 16 while while IN 19768 167 17 to to IN 19768 167 18 me -PRON- PRP 19768 167 19 nothing nothing NN 19768 167 20 which which WDT 19768 167 21 can can MD 19768 167 22 not not RB 19768 167 23 be be VB 19768 167 24 seen see VBN 19768 167 25 , , , 19768 167 26 heard hear VBN 19768 167 27 , , , 19768 167 28 or or CC 19768 167 29 touched touch VBN 19768 167 30 is be VBZ 19768 167 31 " " `` 19768 167 32 concrete concrete JJ 19768 167 33 " " '' 19768 167 34 at at RB 19768 167 35 all all RB 19768 167 36 . . . 19768 168 1 A a DT 19768 168 2 mere mere JJ 19768 168 3 common common JJ 19768 168 4 school school NN 19768 168 5 education education NN 19768 168 6 is be VBZ 19768 168 7 quite quite RB 19768 168 8 sufficient sufficient JJ 19768 168 9 for for IN 19768 168 10 comprehension comprehension NN 19768 168 11 of of IN 19768 168 12 the the DT 19768 168 13 contradictoriness contradictoriness NN 19768 168 14 of of IN 19768 168 15 these these DT 19768 168 16 two two CD 19768 168 17 uses use NNS 19768 168 18 of of IN 19768 168 19 the the DT 19768 168 20 word word NN 19768 168 21 . . . 19768 169 1 Yet yet CC 19768 169 2 , , , 19768 169 3 in in IN 19768 169 4 order order NN 19768 169 5 to to TO 19768 169 6 found find VBN 19768 169 7 a a DT 19768 169 8 malicious malicious JJ 19768 169 9 charge charge NN 19768 169 10 of of IN 19768 169 11 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 169 12 , , , 19768 169 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 169 14 Royce Royce NNP 19768 169 15 has have VBZ 19768 169 16 the the DT 19768 169 17 hardihood hardihood NNP 19768 169 18 to to TO 19768 169 19 assure assure VB 19768 169 20 the the DT 19768 169 21 uninformed uninformed JJ 19768 169 22 general general JJ 19768 169 23 public public NN 19768 169 24 that that IN 19768 169 25 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 169 26 and and CC 19768 169 27 I -PRON- PRP 19768 169 28 use use VBP 19768 169 29 the the DT 19768 169 30 word word NN 19768 169 31 " " `` 19768 169 32 concrete concrete NN 19768 169 33 " " '' 19768 169 34 in in IN 19768 169 35 one one CD 19768 169 36 and and CC 19768 169 37 the the DT 19768 169 38 same same JJ 19768 169 39 sense sense NN 19768 169 40 ! ! . 19768 170 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 170 2 2 2 LS 19768 170 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 170 4 The the DT 19768 170 5 assertion assertion NN 19768 170 6 that that WDT 19768 170 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 170 8 have have VBP 19768 170 9 lived live VBN 19768 170 10 all all PDT 19768 170 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 170 12 life life NN 19768 170 13 in in IN 19768 170 14 a a DT 19768 170 15 Hegelian hegelian JJ 19768 170 16 " " `` 19768 170 17 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19768 170 18 " " '' 19768 170 19 I -PRON- PRP 19768 170 20 can can MD 19768 170 21 only only RB 19768 170 22 meet meet VB 19768 170 23 with with IN 19768 170 24 a a DT 19768 170 25 short short JJ 19768 170 26 , , , 19768 170 27 sharp sharp JJ 19768 170 28 , , , 19768 170 29 and and CC 19768 170 30 indignant indignant JJ 19768 170 31 denial denial NN 19768 170 32 . . . 19768 171 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 171 2 know know VBP 19768 171 3 of of IN 19768 171 4 no no DT 19768 171 5 such such JJ 19768 171 6 " " `` 19768 171 7 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19768 171 8 " " '' 19768 171 9 in in IN 19768 171 10 all all DT 19768 171 11 America America NNP 19768 171 12 ; ; : 19768 171 13 if if IN 19768 171 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 171 15 anywhere anywhere RB 19768 171 16 exists exist VBZ 19768 171 17 , , , 19768 171 18 I -PRON- PRP 19768 171 19 certainly certainly RB 19768 171 20 never never RB 19768 171 21 lived live VBD 19768 171 22 , , , 19768 171 23 moved move VBD 19768 171 24 , , , 19768 171 25 or or CC 19768 171 26 worked work VBD 19768 171 27 in in IN 19768 171 28 it -PRON- PRP 19768 171 29 . . . 19768 172 1 The the DT 19768 172 2 statement statement NN 19768 172 3 is be VBZ 19768 172 4 a a DT 19768 172 5 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 19768 172 6 , , , 19768 172 7 impertinent impertinent JJ 19768 172 8 , , , 19768 172 9 and and CC 19768 172 10 _ _ NNP 19768 172 11 totally totally RB 19768 172 12 false false JJ 19768 172 13 allegation allegation NN 19768 172 14 of of IN 19768 172 15 fact fact NN 19768 172 16 _ _ NNP 19768 172 17 , , , 19768 172 18 wholly wholly RB 19768 172 19 outside outside IN 19768 172 20 of of IN 19768 172 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 172 22 book book NN 19768 172 23 and and CC 19768 172 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 172 25 contents content NNS 19768 172 26 , , , 19768 172 27 and and CC 19768 172 28 is be VBZ 19768 172 29 used use VBN 19768 172 30 in in IN 19768 172 31 this this DT 19768 172 32 connection connection NN 19768 172 33 solely solely RB 19768 172 34 to to TO 19768 172 35 feather feather VB 19768 172 36 an an DT 19768 172 37 arrow arrow NN 19768 172 38 shot shoot VBD 19768 172 39 at at IN 19768 172 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 172 41 reputation reputation NN 19768 172 42 ; ; : 19768 172 43 it -PRON- PRP 19768 172 44 is be VBZ 19768 172 45 a a DT 19768 172 46 pure pure JJ 19768 172 47 invention invention NN 19768 172 48 , , , 19768 172 49 a a DT 19768 172 50 manufactured manufacture VBN 19768 172 51 assertion assertion NN 19768 172 52 which which WDT 19768 172 53 is be VBZ 19768 172 54 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 172 55 without without IN 19768 172 56 foundation foundation NN 19768 172 57 , , , 19768 172 58 and and CC 19768 172 59 , , , 19768 172 60 when when WRB 19768 172 61 thus thus RB 19768 172 62 artfully artfully RB 19768 172 63 thrown throw VBN 19768 172 64 out out RP 19768 172 65 with with IN 19768 172 66 apparent apparent JJ 19768 172 67 artlessness artlessness NN 19768 172 68 ( ( -LRB- 19768 172 69 _ _ NNP 19768 172 70 ars ars DT 19768 172 71 celare celare NN 19768 172 72 artem artem NNP 19768 172 73 _ _ NNP 19768 172 74 ) ) -RRB- 19768 172 75 as as IN 19768 172 76 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 172 77 foundation foundation NN 19768 172 78 for for IN 19768 172 79 a a DT 19768 172 80 false false JJ 19768 172 81 and and CC 19768 172 82 malicious malicious JJ 19768 172 83 charge charge NN 19768 172 84 of of IN 19768 172 85 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 172 86 , , , 19768 172 87 it -PRON- PRP 19768 172 88 becomes become VBZ 19768 172 89 fabrication fabrication NN 19768 172 90 of of IN 19768 172 91 evidence evidence NN 19768 172 92 for for IN 19768 172 93 the the DT 19768 172 94 purpose purpose NN 19768 172 95 of of IN 19768 172 96 defamation defamation NN 19768 172 97 . . . 19768 173 1 The the DT 19768 173 2 less less RBR 19768 173 3 said say VBD 19768 173 4 about about IN 19768 173 5 such such PDT 19768 173 6 an an DT 19768 173 7 offence offence NN 19768 173 8 as as IN 19768 173 9 that that DT 19768 173 10 , , , 19768 173 11 the the DT 19768 173 12 better well JJR 19768 173 13 for for IN 19768 173 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 173 15 Royce Royce NNP 19768 173 16 , , , 19768 173 17 and and CC 19768 173 18 I -PRON- PRP 19768 173 19 spare spare VBP 19768 173 20 him -PRON- PRP 19768 173 21 the the DT 19768 173 22 comment comment NN 19768 173 23 it -PRON- PRP 19768 173 24 deserves deserve VBZ 19768 173 25 . . . 19768 174 1 Now now RB 19768 174 2 , , , 19768 174 3 while while IN 19768 174 4 it -PRON- PRP 19768 174 5 might may MD 19768 174 6 be be VB 19768 174 7 " " `` 19768 174 8 fair fair JJ 19768 174 9 criticism criticism NN 19768 174 10 " " '' 19768 174 11 _ _ NNP 19768 174 12 to to TO 19768 174 13 infer infer VB 19768 174 14 _ _ NNP 19768 174 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 174 16 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 174 17 from from IN 19768 174 18 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 174 19 , , , 19768 174 20 if if IN 19768 174 21 there there EX 19768 174 22 were be VBD 19768 174 23 only only RB 19768 174 24 some some DT 19768 174 25 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 174 26 or or CC 19768 174 27 even even RB 19768 174 28 merely merely RB 19768 174 29 plausible plausible JJ 19768 174 30 evidence evidence NN 19768 174 31 to to TO 19768 174 32 support support VB 19768 174 33 the the DT 19768 174 34 inference inference NN 19768 174 35 ( ( -LRB- 19768 174 36 which which WDT 19768 174 37 I -PRON- PRP 19768 174 38 have have VBP 19768 174 39 just just RB 19768 174 40 proved prove VBN 19768 174 41 not not RB 19768 174 42 to to TO 19768 174 43 be be VB 19768 174 44 the the DT 19768 174 45 case case NN 19768 174 46 ) ) -RRB- 19768 174 47 , , , 19768 174 48 it -PRON- PRP 19768 174 49 is be VBZ 19768 174 50 incontestable incontestable JJ 19768 174 51 that that IN 19768 174 52 _ _ NNP 19768 174 53 to to TO 19768 174 54 affirm affirm VB 19768 174 55 _ _ NNP 19768 174 56 this this DT 19768 174 57 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 174 58 , , , 19768 174 59 as as IN 19768 174 60 a a DT 19768 174 61 " " `` 19768 174 62 certain certain JJ 19768 174 63 " " '' 19768 174 64 matter matter NN 19768 174 65 of of IN 19768 174 66 fact fact NN 19768 174 67 , , , 19768 174 68 without without IN 19768 174 69 any any DT 19768 174 70 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 174 71 evidence evidence NN 19768 174 72 at at RB 19768 174 73 all all RB 19768 174 74 , , , 19768 174 75 is be VBZ 19768 174 76 not not RB 19768 174 77 that that IN 19768 174 78 " " `` 19768 174 79 fair fair JJ 19768 174 80 criticism criticism NN 19768 174 81 " " '' 19768 174 82 which which WDT 19768 174 83 the the DT 19768 174 84 law law NN 19768 174 85 justly justly RB 19768 174 86 allows allow VBZ 19768 174 87 , , , 19768 174 88 but but CC 19768 174 89 , , , 19768 174 90 on on IN 19768 174 91 the the DT 19768 174 92 contrary contrary NN 19768 174 93 , , , 19768 174 94 a a DT 19768 174 95 totally totally RB 19768 174 96 unjustifiable unjustifiable JJ 19768 174 97 libel libel NN 19768 174 98 . . . 19768 175 1 In in IN 19768 175 2 accusing accuse VBG 19768 175 3 me -PRON- PRP 19768 175 4 personally personally RB 19768 175 5 of of IN 19768 175 6 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 175 7 on on IN 19768 175 8 no no DT 19768 175 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 175 10 grounds ground NNS 19768 175 11 whatever whatever WDT 19768 175 12 , , , 19768 175 13 as as IN 19768 175 14 I -PRON- PRP 19768 175 15 have have VBP 19768 175 16 just just RB 19768 175 17 unanswerably unanswerably RB 19768 175 18 proved prove VBN 19768 175 19 him -PRON- PRP 19768 175 20 to to TO 19768 175 21 have have VB 19768 175 22 done do VBN 19768 175 23 , , , 19768 175 24 and and CC 19768 175 25 in in IN 19768 175 26 making make VBG 19768 175 27 the the DT 19768 175 28 " " `` 19768 175 29 certainty certainty NN 19768 175 30 " " '' 19768 175 31 of of IN 19768 175 32 the the DT 19768 175 33 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 175 34 depend depend VBP 19768 175 35 upon upon IN 19768 175 36 an an DT 19768 175 37 allegation allegation NN 19768 175 38 of of IN 19768 175 39 fact fact NN 19768 175 40 wholly wholly RB 19768 175 41 independent independent JJ 19768 175 42 of of IN 19768 175 43 the the DT 19768 175 44 book book NN 19768 175 45 which which WDT 19768 175 46 he -PRON- PRP 19768 175 47 professed profess VBD 19768 175 48 to to TO 19768 175 49 be be VB 19768 175 50 criticising criticise VBG 19768 175 51 ( ( -LRB- 19768 175 52 namely namely RB 19768 175 53 , , , 19768 175 54 the the DT 19768 175 55 false false JJ 19768 175 56 allegation allegation NN 19768 175 57 that that WDT 19768 175 58 I -PRON- PRP 19768 175 59 have have VBP 19768 175 60 worked work VBN 19768 175 61 all all PDT 19768 175 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 175 63 life life NN 19768 175 64 in in IN 19768 175 65 a a DT 19768 175 66 Hegelian hegelian JJ 19768 175 67 " " `` 19768 175 68 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19768 175 69 " " '' 19768 175 70 ) ) -RRB- 19768 175 71 , , , 19768 175 72 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 175 73 Royce Royce NNP 19768 175 74 has have VBZ 19768 175 75 beyond beyond IN 19768 175 76 all all DT 19768 175 77 controversy controversy NN 19768 175 78 transgressed transgress VBD 19768 175 79 the the DT 19768 175 80 legally legally RB 19768 175 81 defined define VBN 19768 175 82 limits limit NNS 19768 175 83 of of IN 19768 175 84 " " `` 19768 175 85 fair fair JJ 19768 175 86 criticism criticism NN 19768 175 87 , , , 19768 175 88 " " '' 19768 175 89 and and CC 19768 175 90 become become VB 19768 175 91 a a DT 19768 175 92 libeller libeller NN 19768 175 93 . . . 19768 176 1 But but CC 19768 176 2 this this DT 19768 176 3 is be VBZ 19768 176 4 by by IN 19768 176 5 no no DT 19768 176 6 means means NN 19768 176 7 all all DT 19768 176 8 . . . 19768 177 1 If if IN 19768 177 2 the the DT 19768 177 3 bat bat NN 19768 177 4 - - HYPH 19768 177 5 like like JJ 19768 177 6 accusation accusation NN 19768 177 7 of of IN 19768 177 8 an an DT 19768 177 9 " " `` 19768 177 10 unconscious unconscious JJ 19768 177 11 " " '' 19768 177 12 , , , 19768 177 13 yet yet CC 19768 177 14 " " `` 19768 177 15 sinning sin VBG 19768 177 16 " " '' 19768 177 17 ( ( -LRB- 19768 177 18 or or CC 19768 177 19 sinful sinful JJ 19768 177 20 ) ) -RRB- 19768 177 21 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 177 22 hovers hover NNS 19768 177 23 ambiguously ambiguously RB 19768 177 24 between between IN 19768 177 25 attacking attack VBG 19768 177 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 177 27 literary literary JJ 19768 177 28 reputation reputation NN 19768 177 29 and and CC 19768 177 30 attacking attack VBG 19768 177 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 177 32 moral moral JJ 19768 177 33 character character NN 19768 177 34 , , , 19768 177 35 there there EX 19768 177 36 is be VBZ 19768 177 37 no no DT 19768 177 38 such such JJ 19768 177 39 ambiguity ambiguity NN 19768 177 40 hanging hang VBG 19768 177 41 about about IN 19768 177 42 the the DT 19768 177 43 accusation accusation NN 19768 177 44 of of IN 19768 177 45 " " `` 19768 177 46 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 177 47 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 177 48 as as IN 19768 177 49 to to IN 19768 177 50 the the DT 19768 177 51 originality originality NN 19768 177 52 and and CC 19768 177 53 profundity profundity NN 19768 177 54 of of IN 19768 177 55 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 177 56 still still RB 19768 177 57 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 177 58 system system NN 19768 177 59 of of IN 19768 177 60 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 177 61 . . . 19768 177 62 " " '' 19768 178 1 A a DT 19768 178 2 decent decent JJ 19768 178 3 modesty modesty NN 19768 178 4 , , , 19768 178 5 a a DT 19768 178 6 self self NN 19768 178 7 - - HYPH 19768 178 8 respectful respectful JJ 19768 178 9 reserve reserve NN 19768 178 10 , , , 19768 178 11 a a DT 19768 178 12 manly manly JJ 19768 178 13 humility humility NN 19768 178 14 in in IN 19768 178 15 presence presence NN 19768 178 16 of of IN 19768 178 17 the the DT 19768 178 18 unattainable unattainable JJ 19768 178 19 ideal ideal NN 19768 178 20 of of IN 19768 178 21 either either CC 19768 178 22 moral moral JJ 19768 178 23 or or CC 19768 178 24 intellectual intellectual JJ 19768 178 25 perfection perfection NN 19768 178 26 , , , 19768 178 27 a a DT 19768 178 28 speechless speechless JJ 19768 178 29 reverence reverence NN 19768 178 30 in in IN 19768 178 31 the the DT 19768 178 32 presence presence NN 19768 178 33 of of IN 19768 178 34 either either DT 19768 178 35 infinite infinite JJ 19768 178 36 goodness goodness NN 19768 178 37 or or CC 19768 178 38 infinite infinite VB 19768 178 39 truth,--these truth,--these NNP 19768 178 40 are be VBP 19768 178 41 virtues virtue NNS 19768 178 42 which which WDT 19768 178 43 belong belong VBP 19768 178 44 to to IN 19768 178 45 the the DT 19768 178 46 very very RB 19768 178 47 warp warp JJ 19768 178 48 and and CC 19768 178 49 woof woof NN 19768 178 50 of of IN 19768 178 51 all all DT 19768 178 52 noble noble JJ 19768 178 53 , , , 19768 178 54 elevated elevated JJ 19768 178 55 , , , 19768 178 56 and and CC 19768 178 57 justly justly RB 19768 178 58 estimable estimable JJ 19768 178 59 character character NN 19768 178 60 ; ; , 19768 178 61 and and CC 19768 178 62 wherever wherever WRB 19768 178 63 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 178 64 absence absence NN 19768 178 65 is be VBZ 19768 178 66 conspicuously conspicuously RB 19768 178 67 shown show VBN 19768 178 68 , , , 19768 178 69 there there EX 19768 178 70 is be VBZ 19768 178 71 just just RB 19768 178 72 ground ground NN 19768 178 73 for for IN 19768 178 74 moral moral JJ 19768 178 75 condemnation condemnation NN 19768 178 76 and and CC 19768 178 77 the the DT 19768 178 78 contempt contempt NN 19768 178 79 of of IN 19768 178 80 mankind mankind NN 19768 178 81 . . . 19768 179 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 179 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 179 3 has have VBZ 19768 179 4 not not RB 19768 179 5 scrupled scruple VBN 19768 179 6 to to TO 19768 179 7 accuse accuse VB 19768 179 8 me -PRON- PRP 19768 179 9 of of IN 19768 179 10 making make VBG 19768 179 11 , , , 19768 179 12 not not RB 19768 179 13 only only RB 19768 179 14 " " `` 19768 179 15 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 179 16 , , , 19768 179 17 " " '' 19768 179 18 but but CC 19768 179 19 even even RB 19768 179 20 " " `` 19768 179 21 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 179 22 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 179 23 , , , 19768 179 24 " " '' 19768 179 25 which which WDT 19768 179 26 are be VBP 19768 179 27 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 179 28 incompatible incompatible JJ 19768 179 29 with with IN 19768 179 30 the the DT 19768 179 31 possession possession NN 19768 179 32 of of IN 19768 179 33 these these DT 19768 179 34 beautiful beautiful JJ 19768 179 35 and and CC 19768 179 36 essential essential JJ 19768 179 37 virtues virtue NNS 19768 179 38 , , , 19768 179 39 and and CC 19768 179 40 thereby thereby RB 19768 179 41 to to TO 19768 179 42 hold hold VB 19768 179 43 me -PRON- PRP 19768 179 44 up up RP 19768 179 45 to to IN 19768 179 46 universal universal JJ 19768 179 47 contempt contempt NN 19768 179 48 and and CC 19768 179 49 derision derision NN 19768 179 50 . . . 19768 180 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 180 2 has have VBZ 19768 180 3 done do VBN 19768 180 4 this this DT 19768 180 5 , , , 19768 180 6 by by IN 19768 180 7 the the DT 19768 180 8 very very JJ 19768 180 9 terms term NNS 19768 180 10 of of IN 19768 180 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 180 12 accusation accusation NN 19768 180 13 , , , 19768 180 14 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 180 15 and and CC 19768 180 16 confessedly confessedly RB 19768 180 17 _ _ NNP 19768 180 18 without without IN 19768 180 19 cause cause NNP 19768 180 20 _ _ NNP 19768 180 21 ; ; : 19768 180 22 for for IN 19768 180 23 the the DT 19768 180 24 system system NN 19768 180 25 of of IN 19768 180 26 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 180 27 which which WDT 19768 180 28 is be VBZ 19768 180 29 " " `` 19768 180 30 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 180 31 " " '' 19768 180 32 to to IN 19768 180 33 others other NNS 19768 180 34 is be VBZ 19768 180 35 no no DT 19768 180 36 less less JJR 19768 180 37 " " `` 19768 180 38 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 180 39 " " '' 19768 180 40 to to IN 19768 180 41 him -PRON- PRP 19768 180 42 , , , 19768 180 43 and and CC 19768 180 44 an an DT 19768 180 45 accusation accusation NN 19768 180 46 thus thus RB 19768 180 47 made make VBN 19768 180 48 confessedly confessedly RB 19768 180 49 without without IN 19768 180 50 any any DT 19768 180 51 knowledge knowledge NN 19768 180 52 of of IN 19768 180 53 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 180 54 truth truth NN 19768 180 55 is be VBZ 19768 180 56 , , , 19768 180 57 on on IN 19768 180 58 the the DT 19768 180 59 very very JJ 19768 180 60 face face NN 19768 180 61 of of IN 19768 180 62 it -PRON- PRP 19768 180 63 , , , 19768 180 64 an an DT 19768 180 65 accusation accusation NN 19768 180 66 which which WDT 19768 180 67 is be VBZ 19768 180 68 as as RB 19768 180 69 malicious malicious JJ 19768 180 70 as as IN 19768 180 71 it -PRON- PRP 19768 180 72 is be VBZ 19768 180 73 groundless groundless JJ 19768 180 74 . . . 19768 181 1 To to TO 19768 181 2 make make VB 19768 181 3 such such PDT 19768 181 4 a a DT 19768 181 5 self self NN 19768 181 6 - - HYPH 19768 181 7 proved prove VBN 19768 181 8 and and CC 19768 181 9 self self NN 19768 181 10 - - HYPH 19768 181 11 condemned condemn VBN 19768 181 12 accusation accusation NN 19768 181 13 as as IN 19768 181 14 this this DT 19768 181 15 is be VBZ 19768 181 16 , , , 19768 181 17 I -PRON- PRP 19768 181 18 submit submit VBP 19768 181 19 , , , 19768 181 20 to to TO 19768 181 21 be be VB 19768 181 22 guilty guilty JJ 19768 181 23 of of IN 19768 181 24 libel libel NN 19768 181 25 with with IN 19768 181 26 no no DT 19768 181 27 ordinary ordinary JJ 19768 181 28 degree degree NN 19768 181 29 of of IN 19768 181 30 culpability culpability NN 19768 181 31 . . . 19768 182 1 But but CC 19768 182 2 the the DT 19768 182 3 libel libel NN 19768 182 4 of of IN 19768 182 5 which which WDT 19768 182 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 182 7 have have VBP 19768 182 8 greatest great JJS 19768 182 9 cause cause NN 19768 182 10 to to TO 19768 182 11 complain complain VB 19768 182 12 is be VBZ 19768 182 13 not not RB 19768 182 14 confined confine VBN 19768 182 15 to to IN 19768 182 16 exceptional exceptional JJ 19768 182 17 or or CC 19768 182 18 isolated isolated JJ 19768 182 19 expressions expression NNS 19768 182 20 . . . 19768 183 1 These these DT 19768 183 2 might may MD 19768 183 3 charitably charitably RB 19768 183 4 be be VB 19768 183 5 explained explain VBN 19768 183 6 as as IN 19768 183 7 mere mere JJ 19768 183 8 momentary momentary JJ 19768 183 9 ebullitions ebullition NNS 19768 183 10 of of IN 19768 183 11 pettishness pettishness NN 19768 183 12 or or CC 19768 183 13 spleen spleen NN 19768 183 14 , , , 19768 183 15 and and CC 19768 183 16 pardonable pardonable JJ 19768 183 17 as as IN 19768 183 18 merely merely RB 19768 183 19 faults fault NNS 19768 183 20 of of IN 19768 183 21 temper temper NN 19768 183 22 in in IN 19768 183 23 a a DT 19768 183 24 criticism criticism NN 19768 183 25 which which WDT 19768 183 26 was be VBD 19768 183 27 in in IN 19768 183 28 the the DT 19768 183 29 main main JJ 19768 183 30 conscientious conscientious JJ 19768 183 31 and and CC 19768 183 32 fair fair JJ 19768 183 33 . . . 19768 184 1 But but CC 19768 184 2 the the DT 19768 184 3 libel libel NN 19768 184 4 of of IN 19768 184 5 which which WDT 19768 184 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 184 7 complain complain VBP 19768 184 8 most most JJS 19768 184 9 of of IN 19768 184 10 all all DT 19768 184 11 is be VBZ 19768 184 12 one one CD 19768 184 13 that that WDT 19768 184 14 constitutes constitute VBZ 19768 184 15 the the DT 19768 184 16 entire entire JJ 19768 184 17 ground ground NN 19768 184 18 and and CC 19768 184 19 framework framework NN 19768 184 20 of of IN 19768 184 21 the the DT 19768 184 22 article article NN 19768 184 23 _ _ NNP 19768 184 24 as as IN 19768 184 25 a a DT 19768 184 26 whole whole JJ 19768 184 27 _ _ NN 19768 184 28 . . . 19768 185 1 Every every DT 19768 185 2 part part NN 19768 185 3 of of IN 19768 185 4 it -PRON- PRP 19768 185 5 is be VBZ 19768 185 6 methodically methodically RB 19768 185 7 spun spin VBN 19768 185 8 and and CC 19768 185 9 interwoven interwoven JJ 19768 185 10 with with IN 19768 185 11 every every DT 19768 185 12 other other JJ 19768 185 13 part part NN 19768 185 14 , , , 19768 185 15 in in IN 19768 185 16 such such PDT 19768 185 17 a a DT 19768 185 18 way way NN 19768 185 19 as as IN 19768 185 20 to to TO 19768 185 21 make make VB 19768 185 22 it -PRON- PRP 19768 185 23 one one CD 19768 185 24 seamless seamless JJ 19768 185 25 tissue tissue NN 19768 185 26 of of IN 19768 185 27 libel libel NN 19768 185 28 from from IN 19768 185 29 beginning begin VBG 19768 185 30 to to IN 19768 185 31 end end NN 19768 185 32 . . . 19768 186 1 This this DT 19768 186 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 186 3 say say VBP 19768 186 4 in in IN 19768 186 5 full full JJ 19768 186 6 consciousness consciousness NN 19768 186 7 of of IN 19768 186 8 the the DT 19768 186 9 interspersed interspersed JJ 19768 186 10 occasional occasional JJ 19768 186 11 compliments compliment NNS 19768 186 12 , , , 19768 186 13 since since IN 19768 186 14 these these DT 19768 186 15 have have VBP 19768 186 16 only only RB 19768 186 17 the the DT 19768 186 18 effect effect NN 19768 186 19 of of IN 19768 186 20 disguising disguise VBG 19768 186 21 the the DT 19768 186 22 libellous libellous JJ 19768 186 23 intent intent NN 19768 186 24 of of IN 19768 186 25 the the DT 19768 186 26 whole whole NN 19768 186 27 from from IN 19768 186 28 a a DT 19768 186 29 simple simple JJ 19768 186 30 - - HYPH 19768 186 31 minded minded JJ 19768 186 32 or or CC 19768 186 33 careless careless JJ 19768 186 34 reader reader NN 19768 186 35 , , , 19768 186 36 and and CC 19768 186 37 since since IN 19768 186 38 they -PRON- PRP 19768 186 39 subserve subserve VBP 19768 186 40 the the DT 19768 186 41 purpose purpose NN 19768 186 42 of of IN 19768 186 43 furnishing furnish VBG 19768 186 44 to to IN 19768 186 45 the the DT 19768 186 46 writer writer NN 19768 186 47 a a DT 19768 186 48 plausible plausible JJ 19768 186 49 and and CC 19768 186 50 ready ready JJ 19768 186 51 - - HYPH 19768 186 52 made make VBN 19768 186 53 defence defence NN 19768 186 54 of of IN 19768 186 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 186 56 libel libel NN 19768 186 57 against against IN 19768 186 58 a a DT 19768 186 59 foreseen foreseen JJ 19768 186 60 protest protest NN 19768 186 61 . . . 19768 187 1 Compliments compliment NNS 19768 187 2 to to TO 19768 187 3 eke eke VB 19768 187 4 out out RP 19768 187 5 a a DT 19768 187 6 libel libel NN 19768 187 7 are be VBP 19768 187 8 merely merely RB 19768 187 9 insults insult NNS 19768 187 10 in in IN 19768 187 11 masquerade masquerade NN 19768 187 12 . . . 19768 188 1 The the DT 19768 188 2 libellous libellous JJ 19768 188 3 plan plan NN 19768 188 4 of of IN 19768 188 5 the the DT 19768 188 6 article article NN 19768 188 7 as as IN 19768 188 8 a a DT 19768 188 9 whole whole NN 19768 188 10 is be VBZ 19768 188 11 shown show VBN 19768 188 12 in in IN 19768 188 13 the the DT 19768 188 14 _ _ NNP 19768 188 15 regular regular JJ 19768 188 16 system system NN 19768 188 17 _ _ NNP 19768 188 18 of of IN 19768 188 19 gross gross JJ 19768 188 20 and and CC 19768 188 21 studied studied JJ 19768 188 22 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 188 23 , , , 19768 188 24 of of IN 19768 188 25 logically logically RB 19768 188 26 connected connected JJ 19768 188 27 and and CC 19768 188 28 nicely nicely RB 19768 188 29 dovetailed dovetail VBN 19768 188 30 misstatements misstatement NNS 19768 188 31 of of IN 19768 188 32 facts fact NNS 19768 188 33 , , , 19768 188 34 which which WDT 19768 188 35 I -PRON- PRP 19768 188 36 exposed expose VBD 19768 188 37 at at IN 19768 188 38 the the DT 19768 188 39 outset outset NN 19768 188 40 . . . 19768 189 1 Every every DT 19768 189 2 intelligent intelligent JJ 19768 189 3 reader reader NN 19768 189 4 of of IN 19768 189 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 189 6 two two CD 19768 189 7 books book NNS 19768 189 8 is be VBZ 19768 189 9 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 189 10 aware aware JJ 19768 189 11 that that IN 19768 189 12 they -PRON- PRP 19768 189 13 are be VBP 19768 189 14 both both DT 19768 189 15 devoted devoted JJ 19768 189 16 to to IN 19768 189 17 an an DT 19768 189 18 exposition exposition NN 19768 189 19 of of IN 19768 189 20 the the DT 19768 189 21 fundamental fundamental JJ 19768 189 22 and and CC 19768 189 23 irreconcilable irreconcilable JJ 19768 189 24 conflict conflict NN 19768 189 25 between between IN 19768 189 26 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 189 27 idealism idealism NN 19768 189 28 and and CC 19768 189 29 scientific scientific JJ 19768 189 30 realism realism NN 19768 189 31 , , , 19768 189 32 and and CC 19768 189 33 to to IN 19768 189 34 a a DT 19768 189 35 defence defence NN 19768 189 36 of of IN 19768 189 37 the the DT 19768 189 38 latter latter JJ 19768 189 39 against against IN 19768 189 40 the the DT 19768 189 41 former former JJ 19768 189 42 , , , 19768 189 43 as as IN 19768 189 44 the the DT 19768 189 45 only only JJ 19768 189 46 possible possible JJ 19768 189 47 method method NN 19768 189 48 by by IN 19768 189 49 which which WDT 19768 189 50 a a DT 19768 189 51 spiritual spiritual JJ 19768 189 52 theism theism NN 19768 189 53 can can MD 19768 189 54 be be VB 19768 189 55 intellectually intellectually RB 19768 189 56 , , , 19768 189 57 and and CC 19768 189 58 therefore therefore RB 19768 189 59 successfully successfully RB 19768 189 60 , , , 19768 189 61 defended defend VBN 19768 189 62 in in IN 19768 189 63 this this DT 19768 189 64 age age NN 19768 189 65 of of IN 19768 189 66 science science NN 19768 189 67 . . . 19768 190 1 Only only RB 19768 190 2 one one CD 19768 190 3 who who WP 19768 190 4 has have VBZ 19768 190 5 read read VBN 19768 190 6 and and CC 19768 190 7 digested digest VBD 19768 190 8 the the DT 19768 190 9 two two CD 19768 190 10 books book NNS 19768 190 11 can can MD 19768 190 12 fully fully RB 19768 190 13 appreciate appreciate VB 19768 190 14 the the DT 19768 190 15 enormity enormity NN 19768 190 16 and and CC 19768 190 17 the the DT 19768 190 18 unscrupulousness unscrupulousness NN 19768 190 19 of of IN 19768 190 20 the the DT 19768 190 21 initial initial JJ 19768 190 22 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 190 23 , , , 19768 190 24 slipped slip VBD 19768 190 25 in in RP 19768 190 26 , , , 19768 190 27 as as IN 19768 190 28 it -PRON- PRP 19768 190 29 were be VBD 19768 190 30 , , , 19768 190 31 quite quite RB 19768 190 32 casually casually RB 19768 190 33 , , , 19768 190 34 and and CC 19768 190 35 without without IN 19768 190 36 any any DT 19768 190 37 argument argument NN 19768 190 38 , , , 19768 190 39 in in IN 19768 190 40 the the DT 19768 190 41 apparently apparently RB 19768 190 42 incidental incidental JJ 19768 190 43 and and CC 19768 190 44 matter matter JJ 19768 190 45 - - HYPH 19768 190 46 of of IN 19768 190 47 - - HYPH 19768 190 48 course course NN 19768 190 49 statement statement NN 19768 190 50 that that IN 19768 190 51 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 190 52 " " `` 19768 190 53 conclusion conclusion NN 19768 190 54 " " '' 19768 190 55 is be VBZ 19768 190 56 " " `` 19768 190 57 essentially essentially RB 19768 190 58 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 190 59 . . . 19768 190 60 " " '' 19768 191 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 191 2 is be VBZ 19768 191 3 _ _ NNP 19768 191 4 not not RB 19768 191 5 _ _ IN 19768 191 6 " " `` 19768 191 7 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 191 8 " " '' 19768 191 9 at at RB 19768 191 10 all all RB 19768 191 11 , , , 19768 191 12 but but CC 19768 191 13 as as IN 19768 191 14 radically radically RB 19768 191 15 realistic realistic JJ 19768 191 16 as as IN 19768 191 17 the the DT 19768 191 18 premises premise NNS 19768 191 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 19768 191 20 ; ; : 19768 191 21 and and CC 19768 191 22 no no DT 19768 191 23 professor professor NN 19768 191 24 of of IN 19768 191 25 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 191 26 could could MD 19768 191 27 ever ever RB 19768 191 28 have have VB 19768 191 29 called call VBN 19768 191 30 it -PRON- PRP 19768 191 31 " " `` 19768 191 32 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 191 33 " " '' 19768 191 34 by by IN 19768 191 35 a a DT 19768 191 36 mere mere JJ 19768 191 37 slip slip NN 19768 191 38 of of IN 19768 191 39 the the DT 19768 191 40 tongue tongue NN 19768 191 41 or or CC 19768 191 42 pen pen NN 19768 191 43 . . . 19768 192 1 The the DT 19768 192 2 intelligent intelligent JJ 19768 192 3 origin origin NN 19768 192 4 of of IN 19768 192 5 this this DT 19768 192 6 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 192 7 is be VBZ 19768 192 8 clearly clearly RB 19768 192 9 enough enough RB 19768 192 10 suggested suggest VBN 19768 192 11 in in IN 19768 192 12 the the DT 19768 192 13 use use NN 19768 192 14 to to TO 19768 192 15 which which WDT 19768 192 16 it -PRON- PRP 19768 192 17 is be VBZ 19768 192 18 at at IN 19768 192 19 once once RB 19768 192 20 put put VBN 19768 192 21 : : : 19768 192 22 namely namely RB 19768 192 23 , , , 19768 192 24 to to TO 19768 192 25 render render VB 19768 192 26 plausible plausible JJ 19768 192 27 the the DT 19768 192 28 otherwise otherwise RB 19768 192 29 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 19768 192 30 charge charge NN 19768 192 31 that that IN 19768 192 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 192 33 theory theory NN 19768 192 34 of of IN 19768 192 35 universals universal NNS 19768 192 36 was be VBD 19768 192 37 " " `` 19768 192 38 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 192 39 " " '' 19768 192 40 from from IN 19768 192 41 an an DT 19768 192 42 idealist idealist NN 19768 192 43 . . . 19768 193 1 Next next RB 19768 193 2 , , , 19768 193 3 the the DT 19768 193 4 same same JJ 19768 193 5 origin origin NN 19768 193 6 is be VBZ 19768 193 7 more more RBR 19768 193 8 than than IN 19768 193 9 suggested suggest VBN 19768 193 10 by by IN 19768 193 11 the the DT 19768 193 12 use use NN 19768 193 13 to to TO 19768 193 14 which which WDT 19768 193 15 these these DT 19768 193 16 two two CD 19768 193 17 misrepresentations misrepresentation NNS 19768 193 18 together together RB 19768 193 19 are be VBP 19768 193 20 put put VBN 19768 193 21 : : : 19768 193 22 namely namely RB 19768 193 23 , , , 19768 193 24 to to TO 19768 193 25 show show VB 19768 193 26 that that IN 19768 193 27 any any DT 19768 193 28 claim claim NN 19768 193 29 of of IN 19768 193 30 " " `` 19768 193 31 novelty novelty NN 19768 193 32 " " '' 19768 193 33 for for IN 19768 193 34 a a DT 19768 193 35 merely merely RB 19768 193 36 " " `` 19768 193 37 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 193 38 " " '' 19768 193 39 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 193 40 is be VBZ 19768 193 41 a a DT 19768 193 42 " " `` 19768 193 43 vast vast JJ 19768 193 44 " " '' 19768 193 45 and and CC 19768 193 46 " " `` 19768 193 47 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 193 48 pretension pretension NN 19768 193 49 . . . 19768 193 50 " " '' 19768 194 1 Lastly lastly RB 19768 194 2 , , , 19768 194 3 the the DT 19768 194 4 same same JJ 19768 194 5 origin origin NN 19768 194 6 is be VBZ 19768 194 7 inductively inductively RB 19768 194 8 and and CC 19768 194 9 conclusively conclusively RB 19768 194 10 proved prove VBN 19768 194 11 , , , 19768 194 12 when when WRB 19768 194 13 these these DT 19768 194 14 three three CD 19768 194 15 inter inter RB 19768 194 16 - - JJ 19768 194 17 linked link VBN 19768 194 18 misrepresentations misrepresentation NNS 19768 194 19 , , , 19768 194 20 as as IN 19768 194 21 a a DT 19768 194 22 whole whole NN 19768 194 23 , , , 19768 194 24 are be VBP 19768 194 25 made make VBN 19768 194 26 the the DT 19768 194 27 general general JJ 19768 194 28 foundation foundation NN 19768 194 29 for for IN 19768 194 30 a a DT 19768 194 31 brutal brutal JJ 19768 194 32 " " `` 19768 194 33 professional professional JJ 19768 194 34 warning warning NN 19768 194 35 " " '' 19768 194 36 to to IN 19768 194 37 the the DT 19768 194 38 public public NN 19768 194 39 at at IN 19768 194 40 large large JJ 19768 194 41 against against IN 19768 194 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 194 43 " " `` 19768 194 44 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 194 45 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 194 46 " " '' 19768 194 47 in in IN 19768 194 48 general general JJ 19768 194 49 . . . 19768 195 1 Not not RB 19768 195 2 one one CD 19768 195 3 of of IN 19768 195 4 these these DT 19768 195 5 fundamental fundamental JJ 19768 195 6 positions position NNS 19768 195 7 of of IN 19768 195 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 195 9 Royce Royce NNP 19768 195 10 's 's POS 19768 195 11 article article NN 19768 195 12 is be VBZ 19768 195 13 a a DT 19768 195 14 fact,--least fact,--least NNP 19768 195 15 of of IN 19768 195 16 all all DT 19768 195 17 , , , 19768 195 18 an an DT 19768 195 19 " " `` 19768 195 20 admitted admit VBN 19768 195 21 fact fact NN 19768 195 22 " " '' 19768 195 23 ; ; , 19768 195 24 on on IN 19768 195 25 the the DT 19768 195 26 contrary contrary NN 19768 195 27 , , , 19768 195 28 each each DT 19768 195 29 of of IN 19768 195 30 them -PRON- PRP 19768 195 31 is be VBZ 19768 195 32 energetically energetically RB 19768 195 33 and and CC 19768 195 34 indignantly indignantly RB 19768 195 35 denied deny VBN 19768 195 36 . . . 19768 196 1 But but CC 19768 196 2 the the DT 19768 196 3 libel libel NN 19768 196 4 of of IN 19768 196 5 which which WDT 19768 196 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 196 7 complain complain VBP 19768 196 8 above above IN 19768 196 9 all all DT 19768 196 10 is be VBZ 19768 196 11 the the DT 19768 196 12 _ _ NNP 19768 196 13 regular regular JJ 19768 196 14 system system NN 19768 196 15 _ _ NNP 19768 196 16 of of IN 19768 196 17 gross gross JJ 19768 196 18 and and CC 19768 196 19 studied studied JJ 19768 196 20 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 196 21 by by IN 19768 196 22 which which WDT 19768 196 23 the the DT 19768 196 24 most most RBS 19768 196 25 essential essential JJ 19768 196 26 facts fact NNS 19768 196 27 are be VBP 19768 196 28 first first RB 19768 196 29 misstated misstate VBN 19768 196 30 and and CC 19768 196 31 falsified falsify VBN 19768 196 32 , , , 19768 196 33 and and CC 19768 196 34 then then RB 19768 196 35 used use VBD 19768 196 36 to to IN 19768 196 37 the the DT 19768 196 38 injury injury NN 19768 196 39 of of IN 19768 196 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 196 41 literary literary JJ 19768 196 42 and and CC 19768 196 43 personal personal JJ 19768 196 44 reputation reputation NN 19768 196 45 . . . 19768 197 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 197 2 may may MD 19768 197 3 , , , 19768 197 4 I -PRON- PRP 19768 197 5 trust trust VBP 19768 197 6 , , , 19768 197 7 be be VB 19768 197 8 permitted permit VBN 19768 197 9 to to IN 19768 197 10 me -PRON- PRP 19768 197 11 here here RB 19768 197 12 to to TO 19768 197 13 show show VB 19768 197 14 clearly clearly RB 19768 197 15 what what WP 19768 197 16 the the DT 19768 197 17 law law NN 19768 197 18 is be VBZ 19768 197 19 , , , 19768 197 20 as as IN 19768 197 21 applicable applicable JJ 19768 197 22 to to IN 19768 197 23 the the DT 19768 197 24 case case NN 19768 197 25 in in IN 19768 197 26 hand hand NN 19768 197 27 , , , 19768 197 28 by by IN 19768 197 29 a a DT 19768 197 30 few few JJ 19768 197 31 pertinent pertinent JJ 19768 197 32 citations citation NNS 19768 197 33 . . . 19768 198 1 " " `` 19768 198 2 The the DT 19768 198 3 critic critic NN 19768 198 4 must must MD 19768 198 5 confine confine VB 19768 198 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 198 7 to to IN 19768 198 8 criticism criticism NN 19768 198 9 , , , 19768 198 10 and and CC 19768 198 11 not not RB 19768 198 12 make make VB 19768 198 13 it -PRON- PRP 19768 198 14 the the DT 19768 198 15 veil veil NN 19768 198 16 for for IN 19768 198 17 personal personal JJ 19768 198 18 censure censure NN 19768 198 19 , , , 19768 198 20 nor nor CC 19768 198 21 allow allow VB 19768 198 22 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 198 23 to to TO 19768 198 24 run run VB 19768 198 25 into into IN 19768 198 26 reckless reckless JJ 19768 198 27 and and CC 19768 198 28 unfair unfair JJ 19768 198 29 attacks attack NNS 19768 198 30 , , , 19768 198 31 merely merely RB 19768 198 32 from from IN 19768 198 33 the the DT 19768 198 34 love love NN 19768 198 35 of of IN 19768 198 36 exercising exercise VBG 19768 198 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 198 38 power power NN 19768 198 39 of of IN 19768 198 40 denunciation denunciation NN 19768 198 41 . . . 19768 199 1 Criticism criticism NN 19768 199 2 and and CC 19768 199 3 comment comment NN 19768 199 4 on on IN 19768 199 5 well well RB 19768 199 6 - - HYPH 19768 199 7 known know VBN 19768 199 8 and and CC 19768 199 9 admitted admit VBN 19768 199 10 facts fact NNS 19768 199 11 are be VBP 19768 199 12 very very RB 19768 199 13 different different JJ 19768 199 14 things thing NNS 19768 199 15 from from IN 19768 199 16 the the DT 19768 199 17 assertion assertion NN 19768 199 18 of of IN 19768 199 19 unsubstantiated unsubstantiated JJ 19768 199 20 facts fact NNS 19768 199 21 . . . 19768 200 1 A a DT 19768 200 2 fair fair JJ 19768 200 3 and and CC 19768 200 4 _ _ NNP 19768 200 5 bona bona NN 19768 200 6 fide fide FW 19768 200 7 _ _ NNP 19768 200 8 comment comment NN 19768 200 9 on on IN 19768 200 10 a a DT 19768 200 11 matter matter NN 19768 200 12 of of IN 19768 200 13 public public JJ 19768 200 14 interest interest NN 19768 200 15 is be VBZ 19768 200 16 an an DT 19768 200 17 excuse excuse NN 19768 200 18 of of IN 19768 200 19 what what WP 19768 200 20 would would MD 19768 200 21 otherwise otherwise RB 19768 200 22 be be VB 19768 200 23 a a DT 19768 200 24 defamatory defamatory JJ 19768 200 25 publication publication NN 19768 200 26 . . . 19768 201 1 The the DT 19768 201 2 statement statement NN 19768 201 3 of of IN 19768 201 4 this this DT 19768 201 5 rule rule NN 19768 201 6 assumes assume VBZ 19768 201 7 the the DT 19768 201 8 matters matter NNS 19768 201 9 of of IN 19768 201 10 fact fact NN 19768 201 11 commented comment VBN 19768 201 12 on on IN 19768 201 13 to to TO 19768 201 14 be be VB 19768 201 15 somehow somehow RB 19768 201 16 ascertained ascertain VBN 19768 201 17 . . . 19768 202 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 202 2 does do VBZ 19768 202 3 not not RB 19768 202 4 mean mean VB 19768 202 5 that that IN 19768 202 6 a a DT 19768 202 7 man man NN 19768 202 8 may may MD 19768 202 9 invent invent VB 19768 202 10 facts fact NNS 19768 202 11 , , , 19768 202 12 and and CC 19768 202 13 comment comment VB 19768 202 14 on on IN 19768 202 15 the the DT 19768 202 16 facts fact NNS 19768 202 17 so so RB 19768 202 18 invented invent VBN 19768 202 19 in in IN 19768 202 20 what what WP 19768 202 21 would would MD 19768 202 22 be be VB 19768 202 23 a a DT 19768 202 24 fair fair JJ 19768 202 25 and and CC 19768 202 26 _ _ NNP 19768 202 27 bona bona NN 19768 202 28 fide fide FW 19768 202 29 _ _ NNP 19768 202 30 manner manner NN 19768 202 31 , , , 19768 202 32 on on IN 19768 202 33 the the DT 19768 202 34 supposition supposition NN 19768 202 35 that that IN 19768 202 36 the the DT 19768 202 37 facts fact NNS 19768 202 38 were be VBD 19768 202 39 true true JJ 19768 202 40 . . . 19768 203 1 If if IN 19768 203 2 the the DT 19768 203 3 facts fact NNS 19768 203 4 as as IN 19768 203 5 a a DT 19768 203 6 comment comment NN 19768 203 7 upon upon IN 19768 203 8 which which WDT 19768 203 9 the the DT 19768 203 10 publication publication NN 19768 203 11 is be VBZ 19768 203 12 sought seek VBN 19768 203 13 to to TO 19768 203 14 be be VB 19768 203 15 excused excuse VBN 19768 203 16 do do VBP 19768 203 17 not not RB 19768 203 18 exist exist VB 19768 203 19 , , , 19768 203 20 the the DT 19768 203 21 foundation foundation NN 19768 203 22 fails fail VBZ 19768 203 23 .... .... . 19768 204 1 The the DT 19768 204 2 distinction distinction NN 19768 204 3 can can MD 19768 204 4 not not RB 19768 204 5 be be VB 19768 204 6 too too RB 19768 204 7 clearly clearly RB 19768 204 8 borne bear VBN 19768 204 9 in in IN 19768 204 10 mind mind NN 19768 204 11 between between IN 19768 204 12 comment comment NN 19768 204 13 or or CC 19768 204 14 criticism criticism NN 19768 204 15 and and CC 19768 204 16 allegations allegation NNS 19768 204 17 of of IN 19768 204 18 fact fact NN 19768 204 19 .... .... . 19768 204 20 To to IN 19768 204 21 state state NN 19768 204 22 matters matter NNS 19768 204 23 which which WDT 19768 204 24 are be VBP 19768 204 25 libellous libellous JJ 19768 204 26 is be VBZ 19768 204 27 not not RB 19768 204 28 comment comment NN 19768 204 29 or or CC 19768 204 30 criticism criticism NN 19768 204 31 . . . 19768 204 32 " " '' 19768 205 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 205 2 _ _ NNP 19768 205 3 Newell Newell NNP 19768 205 4 on on IN 19768 205 5 Defamation Defamation NNP 19768 205 6 , , , 19768 205 7 Slander Slander NNP 19768 205 8 , , , 19768 205 9 and and CC 19768 205 10 Libel Libel NNP 19768 205 11 _ _ NNP 19768 205 12 , , , 19768 205 13 p. p. NN 19768 206 1 568 568 CD 19768 206 2 . . . 19768 206 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 207 1 Applying apply VBG 19768 207 2 this this DT 19768 207 3 to to IN 19768 207 4 the the DT 19768 207 5 case case NN 19768 207 6 in in IN 19768 207 7 hand hand NN 19768 207 8 : : : 19768 207 9 the the DT 19768 207 10 " " `` 19768 207 11 admitted admit VBN 19768 207 12 facts fact NNS 19768 207 13 " " `` 19768 207 14 are be VBP 19768 207 15 these these DT 19768 207 16 : : : 19768 207 17 ( ( -LRB- 19768 207 18 1 1 LS 19768 207 19 ) ) -RRB- 19768 207 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 207 21 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 207 22 is be VBZ 19768 207 23 realistic realistic JJ 19768 207 24 from from IN 19768 207 25 beginning begin VBG 19768 207 26 to to IN 19768 207 27 end end NN 19768 207 28 ; ; : 19768 207 29 ( ( -LRB- 19768 207 30 2 2 LS 19768 207 31 ) ) -RRB- 19768 207 32 I -PRON- PRP 19768 207 33 have have VBP 19768 207 34 not not RB 19768 207 35 worked work VBN 19768 207 36 all all PDT 19768 207 37 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 207 38 life life NN 19768 207 39 , , , 19768 207 40 nor nor CC 19768 207 41 any any DT 19768 207 42 part part NN 19768 207 43 of of IN 19768 207 44 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 207 45 life life NN 19768 207 46 , , , 19768 207 47 in in IN 19768 207 48 a a DT 19768 207 49 Hegelian hegelian JJ 19768 207 50 " " `` 19768 207 51 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19768 207 52 " " '' 19768 207 53 ; ; , 19768 207 54 ( ( -LRB- 19768 207 55 3 3 LS 19768 207 56 ) ) -RRB- 19768 207 57 I -PRON- PRP 19768 207 58 did do VBD 19768 207 59 not not RB 19768 207 60 borrow borrow VB 19768 207 61 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 207 62 theory theory NN 19768 207 63 of of IN 19768 207 64 universals universal NNS 19768 207 65 from from IN 19768 207 66 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 207 67 ; ; : 19768 207 68 ( ( -LRB- 19768 207 69 4 4 LS 19768 207 70 ) ) -RRB- 19768 207 71 I -PRON- PRP 19768 207 72 have have VBP 19768 207 73 made make VBN 19768 207 74 no no DT 19768 207 75 vast vast JJ 19768 207 76 or or CC 19768 207 77 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 207 78 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 207 79 whatever whatever WDT 19768 207 80 as as IN 19768 207 81 to to IN 19768 207 82 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 207 83 own own JJ 19768 207 84 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 207 85 . . . 19768 208 1 But but CC 19768 208 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 208 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 208 4 invents invent NNS 19768 208 5 and and CC 19768 208 6 states state VBZ 19768 208 7 the the DT 19768 208 8 exact exact JJ 19768 208 9 opposite opposite NN 19768 208 10 of of IN 19768 208 11 all all PDT 19768 208 12 these these DT 19768 208 13 facts fact NNS 19768 208 14 , , , 19768 208 15 and and CC 19768 208 16 then then RB 19768 208 17 bases base VBZ 19768 208 18 on on IN 19768 208 19 these these DT 19768 208 20 purely purely RB 19768 208 21 invented invent VBN 19768 208 22 facts fact NNS 19768 208 23 most most RBS 19768 208 24 undeserved undeserved JJ 19768 208 25 " " `` 19768 208 26 personal personal JJ 19768 208 27 censure censure NN 19768 208 28 " " '' 19768 208 29 and and CC 19768 208 30 most most JJS 19768 208 31 " " `` 19768 208 32 reckless reckless JJ 19768 208 33 and and CC 19768 208 34 unfair unfair JJ 19768 208 35 attacks attack NNS 19768 208 36 . . . 19768 208 37 " " '' 19768 209 1 Therefore therefore RB 19768 209 2 , , , 19768 209 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 209 4 article article NN 19768 209 5 is be VBZ 19768 209 6 a a DT 19768 209 7 libel libel NN 19768 209 8 in in IN 19768 209 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 209 10 whole whole JJ 19768 209 11 groundwork groundwork NN 19768 209 12 and and CC 19768 209 13 essential essential JJ 19768 209 14 spirit spirit NN 19768 209 15 . . . 19768 210 1 " " `` 19768 210 2 If if IN 19768 210 3 a a DT 19768 210 4 person person NN 19768 210 5 , , , 19768 210 6 under under IN 19768 210 7 pretence pretence NN 19768 210 8 of of IN 19768 210 9 criticising criticise VBG 19768 210 10 a a DT 19768 210 11 literary literary JJ 19768 210 12 work work NN 19768 210 13 , , , 19768 210 14 defames defame VBZ 19768 210 15 the the DT 19768 210 16 private private JJ 19768 210 17 character character NN 19768 210 18 of of IN 19768 210 19 the the DT 19768 210 20 author author NN 19768 210 21 , , , 19768 210 22 and and CC 19768 210 23 , , , 19768 210 24 instead instead RB 19768 210 25 of of IN 19768 210 26 writing write VBG 19768 210 27 in in IN 19768 210 28 the the DT 19768 210 29 spirit spirit NN 19768 210 30 and and CC 19768 210 31 for for IN 19768 210 32 the the DT 19768 210 33 purpose purpose NN 19768 210 34 of of IN 19768 210 35 fair fair JJ 19768 210 36 and and CC 19768 210 37 candid candid JJ 19768 210 38 discussion discussion NN 19768 210 39 , , , 19768 210 40 travels travel VBZ 19768 210 41 into into IN 19768 210 42 collateral collateral JJ 19768 210 43 matter matter NN 19768 210 44 , , , 19768 210 45 and and CC 19768 210 46 introduces introduce VBZ 19768 210 47 facts fact NNS 19768 210 48 not not RB 19768 210 49 stated state VBN 19768 210 50 in in IN 19768 210 51 the the DT 19768 210 52 work work NN 19768 210 53 , , , 19768 210 54 accompanied accompany VBN 19768 210 55 with with IN 19768 210 56 injurious injurious JJ 19768 210 57 comment comment NN 19768 210 58 upon upon IN 19768 210 59 them -PRON- PRP 19768 210 60 , , , 19768 210 61 such such JJ 19768 210 62 person person NN 19768 210 63 is be VBZ 19768 210 64 a a DT 19768 210 65 libeller libeller NN 19768 210 66 , , , 19768 210 67 and and CC 19768 210 68 liable liable JJ 19768 210 69 to to IN 19768 210 70 an an DT 19768 210 71 action action NN 19768 210 72 . . . 19768 210 73 " " '' 19768 211 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 211 2 _ _ NNP 19768 211 3 Broom Broom NNP 19768 211 4 's 's POS 19768 211 5 Legal Legal NNP 19768 211 6 Maxims Maxims NNPS 19768 211 7 _ _ NNP 19768 211 8 , , , 19768 211 9 p. p. NN 19768 212 1 320 320 CD 19768 212 2 . . . 19768 212 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 213 1 Applying apply VBG 19768 213 2 this this DT 19768 213 3 to to IN 19768 213 4 the the DT 19768 213 5 case case NN 19768 213 6 in in IN 19768 213 7 hand hand NN 19768 213 8 : : : 19768 213 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 213 10 Royce Royce NNP 19768 213 11 " " `` 19768 213 12 defames defame VBZ 19768 213 13 " " `` 19768 213 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 213 15 " " '' 19768 213 16 private private JJ 19768 213 17 character character NN 19768 213 18 , , , 19768 213 19 " " '' 19768 213 20 when when WRB 19768 213 21 he -PRON- PRP 19768 213 22 accuses accuse VBZ 19768 213 23 me -PRON- PRP 19768 213 24 of of IN 19768 213 25 " " `` 19768 213 26 frequently frequently RB 19768 213 27 " " `` 19768 213 28 indulging indulge VBG 19768 213 29 in in IN 19768 213 30 " " `` 19768 213 31 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 213 32 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 213 33 " " '' 19768 213 34 ; ; : 19768 213 35 he -PRON- PRP 19768 213 36 " " `` 19768 213 37 travels travel VBZ 19768 213 38 into into IN 19768 213 39 collateral collateral JJ 19768 213 40 matter matter NN 19768 213 41 , , , 19768 213 42 " " '' 19768 213 43 when when WRB 19768 213 44 he -PRON- PRP 19768 213 45 alludes allude VBZ 19768 213 46 at at RB 19768 213 47 all all RB 19768 213 48 to to IN 19768 213 49 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 213 50 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 213 51 manuscript manuscript NN 19768 213 52 ; ; : 19768 213 53 he -PRON- PRP 19768 213 54 " " `` 19768 213 55 introduces introduce VBZ 19768 213 56 facts fact NNS 19768 213 57 not not RB 19768 213 58 stated state VBN 19768 213 59 in in IN 19768 213 60 the the DT 19768 213 61 work work NN 19768 213 62 , , , 19768 213 63 accompanied accompany VBN 19768 213 64 with with IN 19768 213 65 injurious injurious JJ 19768 213 66 comment comment NN 19768 213 67 upon upon IN 19768 213 68 them -PRON- PRP 19768 213 69 , , , 19768 213 70 " " '' 19768 213 71 when when WRB 19768 213 72 he -PRON- PRP 19768 213 73 alludes allude VBZ 19768 213 74 to to IN 19768 213 75 this this DT 19768 213 76 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 213 77 manuscript manuscript NN 19768 213 78 for for IN 19768 213 79 the the DT 19768 213 80 sole sole JJ 19768 213 81 purpose purpose NN 19768 213 82 of of IN 19768 213 83 saying say VBG 19768 213 84 ( ( -LRB- 19768 213 85 untruthfully untruthfully RB 19768 213 86 ) ) -RRB- 19768 213 87 that that IN 19768 213 88 I -PRON- PRP 19768 213 89 " " `` 19768 213 90 frequently frequently RB 19768 213 91 make make VBP 19768 213 92 , , , 19768 213 93 of of IN 19768 213 94 late late JJ 19768 213 95 , , , 19768 213 96 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 213 97 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 213 98 as as IN 19768 213 99 to to IN 19768 213 100 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 213 101 originality originality NN 19768 213 102 and and CC 19768 213 103 profundity profundity NN 19768 213 104 , , , 19768 213 105 " " '' 19768 213 106 and and CC 19768 213 107 again again RB 19768 213 108 when when WRB 19768 213 109 he -PRON- PRP 19768 213 110 says say VBZ 19768 213 111 that that IN 19768 213 112 I -PRON- PRP 19768 213 113 have have VBP 19768 213 114 worked work VBN 19768 213 115 all all PDT 19768 213 116 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 213 117 life life NN 19768 213 118 in in IN 19768 213 119 a a DT 19768 213 120 Hegelian hegelian JJ 19768 213 121 " " '' 19768 213 122 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19768 213 123 , , , 19768 213 124 " " '' 19768 213 125 for for IN 19768 213 126 the the DT 19768 213 127 sole sole JJ 19768 213 128 purpose purpose NN 19768 213 129 of of IN 19768 213 130 founding found VBG 19768 213 131 upon upon IN 19768 213 132 this this DT 19768 213 133 false false JJ 19768 213 134 statement statement NN 19768 213 135 a a DT 19768 213 136 false false JJ 19768 213 137 charge charge NN 19768 213 138 of of IN 19768 213 139 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 213 140 . . . 19768 214 1 In in IN 19768 214 2 the the DT 19768 214 3 " " `` 19768 214 4 Griffith Griffith NNP 19768 214 5 Gaunt Gaunt NNP 19768 214 6 " " '' 19768 214 7 case case NN 19768 214 8 , , , 19768 214 9 Judge Judge NNP 19768 214 10 Clerke Clerke NNP 19768 214 11 said say VBD 19768 214 12 in in IN 19768 214 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 214 14 charge charge NN 19768 214 15 to to IN 19768 214 16 the the DT 19768 214 17 jury jury NN 19768 214 18 : : : 19768 214 19 " " `` 19768 214 20 The the DT 19768 214 21 interests interest NNS 19768 214 22 of of IN 19768 214 23 literature literature NN 19768 214 24 and and CC 19768 214 25 science science NN 19768 214 26 require require VBP 19768 214 27 that that IN 19768 214 28 the the DT 19768 214 29 productions production NNS 19768 214 30 of of IN 19768 214 31 authors author NNS 19768 214 32 shall shall MD 19768 214 33 be be VB 19768 214 34 subject subject JJ 19768 214 35 to to IN 19768 214 36 fair fair JJ 19768 214 37 criticism,--that criticism,--that NNP 19768 214 38 even even RB 19768 214 39 some some DT 19768 214 40 animadversion animadversion NN 19768 214 41 may may MD 19768 214 42 be be VB 19768 214 43 permitted permit VBN 19768 214 44 , , , 19768 214 45 unless unless IN 19768 214 46 it -PRON- PRP 19768 214 47 appears appear VBZ 19768 214 48 that that IN 19768 214 49 the the DT 19768 214 50 critic critic NN 19768 214 51 , , , 19768 214 52 under under IN 19768 214 53 the the DT 19768 214 54 pretext pretext NN 19768 214 55 of of IN 19768 214 56 reviewing review VBG 19768 214 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 214 58 book book NN 19768 214 59 , , , 19768 214 60 takes take VBZ 19768 214 61 an an DT 19768 214 62 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 214 63 of of IN 19768 214 64 attacking attack VBG 19768 214 65 the the DT 19768 214 66 character character NN 19768 214 67 of of IN 19768 214 68 the the DT 19768 214 69 author author NN 19768 214 70 , , , 19768 214 71 and and CC 19768 214 72 of of IN 19768 214 73 holding hold VBG 19768 214 74 him -PRON- PRP 19768 214 75 up up RP 19768 214 76 as as IN 19768 214 77 an an DT 19768 214 78 object object NN 19768 214 79 of of IN 19768 214 80 ridicule ridicule NN 19768 214 81 , , , 19768 214 82 hatred hatred NN 19768 214 83 , , , 19768 214 84 or or CC 19768 214 85 contempt contempt NN 19768 214 86 . . . 19768 215 1 In in IN 19768 215 2 other other JJ 19768 215 3 words word NNS 19768 215 4 , , , 19768 215 5 the the DT 19768 215 6 critic critic NN 19768 215 7 may may MD 19768 215 8 say say VB 19768 215 9 what what WP 19768 215 10 he -PRON- PRP 19768 215 11 pleases please VBZ 19768 215 12 of of IN 19768 215 13 the the DT 19768 215 14 literary literary JJ 19768 215 15 merits merit NNS 19768 215 16 or or CC 19768 215 17 demerits demerit NNS 19768 215 18 of of IN 19768 215 19 the the DT 19768 215 20 published publish VBN 19768 215 21 production production NN 19768 215 22 of of IN 19768 215 23 an an DT 19768 215 24 author author NN 19768 215 25 ; ; : 19768 215 26 but but CC 19768 215 27 , , , 19768 215 28 with with IN 19768 215 29 respect respect NN 19768 215 30 to to IN 19768 215 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 215 32 personal personal JJ 19768 215 33 rights right NNS 19768 215 34 relating relate VBG 19768 215 35 to to IN 19768 215 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 215 37 reputation reputation NN 19768 215 38 , , , 19768 215 39 the the DT 19768 215 40 critic critic NN 19768 215 41 has have VBZ 19768 215 42 no no DT 19768 215 43 more more JJR 19768 215 44 privilege privilege NN 19768 215 45 than than IN 19768 215 46 any any DT 19768 215 47 other other JJ 19768 215 48 person person NN 19768 215 49 not not RB 19768 215 50 assuming assume VBG 19768 215 51 the the DT 19768 215 52 business business NN 19768 215 53 of of IN 19768 215 54 criticism criticism NN 19768 215 55 . . . 19768 215 56 " " '' 19768 216 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 216 2 _ _ NNP 19768 216 3 Abbott Abbott NNP 19768 216 4 's 's POS 19768 216 5 Practice Practice NNP 19768 216 6 Reports Reports NNPS 19768 216 7 _ _ NNP 19768 216 8 , , , 19768 216 9 New New NNP 19768 216 10 Series Series NNP 19768 216 11 , , , 19768 216 12 VI VI NNP 19768 216 13 . . . 19768 217 1 18 18 CD 19768 217 2 . . . 19768 217 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 218 1 Applying apply VBG 19768 218 2 this this DT 19768 218 3 to to IN 19768 218 4 the the DT 19768 218 5 case case NN 19768 218 6 in in IN 19768 218 7 hand hand NN 19768 218 8 : : : 19768 218 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 218 10 Royce Royce NNP 19768 218 11 , , , 19768 218 12 " " `` 19768 218 13 under under IN 19768 218 14 the the DT 19768 218 15 pretext pretext NN 19768 218 16 of of IN 19768 218 17 reviewing review VBG 19768 218 18 " " `` 19768 218 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 218 20 " " '' 19768 218 21 book book NN 19768 218 22 , , , 19768 218 23 takes take VBZ 19768 218 24 an an DT 19768 218 25 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 218 26 of of IN 19768 218 27 attacking attack VBG 19768 218 28 the the DT 19768 218 29 author author NN 19768 218 30 , , , 19768 218 31 and and CC 19768 218 32 of of IN 19768 218 33 holding hold VBG 19768 218 34 him -PRON- PRP 19768 218 35 up up RP 19768 218 36 as as IN 19768 218 37 an an DT 19768 218 38 object object NN 19768 218 39 of of IN 19768 218 40 ridicule ridicule NN 19768 218 41 and and CC 19768 218 42 contempt contempt NN 19768 218 43 , , , 19768 218 44 " " '' 19768 218 45 if if IN 19768 218 46 ridicule ridicule NN 19768 218 47 and and CC 19768 218 48 contempt contempt NN 19768 218 49 are be VBP 19768 218 50 the the DT 19768 218 51 deservedly deservedly RB 19768 218 52 universal universal JJ 19768 218 53 punishment punishment NN 19768 218 54 of of IN 19768 218 55 the the DT 19768 218 56 plagiarist plagiarist NN 19768 218 57 and and CC 19768 218 58 the the DT 19768 218 59 braggart braggart NN 19768 218 60 . . . 19768 219 1 To to TO 19768 219 2 so so RB 19768 219 3 unprecedented unprecedented JJ 19768 219 4 a a DT 19768 219 5 length length NN 19768 219 6 has have VBZ 19768 219 7 he -PRON- PRP 19768 219 8 carried carry VBN 19768 219 9 this this DT 19768 219 10 attack attack NN 19768 219 11 , , , 19768 219 12 as as RB 19768 219 13 deliberately deliberately RB 19768 219 14 and and CC 19768 219 15 formally formally RB 19768 219 16 , , , 19768 219 17 in in IN 19768 219 18 the the DT 19768 219 19 name name NN 19768 219 20 of of IN 19768 219 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 219 22 " " `` 19768 219 23 profession profession NN 19768 219 24 , , , 19768 219 25 " " '' 19768 219 26 and and CC 19768 219 27 therefore therefore RB 19768 219 28 , , , 19768 219 29 by by IN 19768 219 30 necessary necessary JJ 19768 219 31 implication implication NN 19768 219 32 , , , 19768 219 33 in in IN 19768 219 34 the the DT 19768 219 35 name name NN 19768 219 36 of of IN 19768 219 37 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 219 38 University University NNP 19768 219 39 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 219 40 , , , 19768 219 41 to to TO 19768 219 42 " " `` 19768 219 43 warn warn VB 19768 219 44 the the DT 19768 219 45 liberal liberal JJ 19768 219 46 - - HYPH 19768 219 47 minded minded JJ 19768 219 48 public public NN 19768 219 49 " " '' 19768 219 50 against against IN 19768 219 51 me -PRON- PRP 19768 219 52 , , , 19768 219 53 _ _ NNP 19768 219 54 precisely precisely RB 19768 219 55 as as IN 19768 219 56 one one PRP 19768 219 57 warns warn VBZ 19768 219 58 the the DT 19768 219 59 general general JJ 19768 219 60 public public NN 19768 219 61 against against IN 19768 219 62 an an DT 19768 219 63 impostor impostor NN 19768 219 64 soliciting solicit VBG 19768 219 65 alms alm NNS 19768 219 66 under under IN 19768 219 67 false false JJ 19768 219 68 pretences pretence NNS 19768 219 69 _ _ XX 19768 219 70 ! ! . 19768 220 1 This this DT 19768 220 2 is be VBZ 19768 220 3 a a DT 19768 220 4 flagrant flagrant JJ 19768 220 5 violation violation NN 19768 220 6 of of IN 19768 220 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 220 8 " " `` 19768 220 9 personal personal JJ 19768 220 10 rights right NNS 19768 220 11 relating relate VBG 19768 220 12 to to IN 19768 220 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 220 14 reputation reputation NN 19768 220 15 " " '' 19768 220 16 ; ; : 19768 220 17 and and CC 19768 220 18 , , , 19768 220 19 therefore therefore RB 19768 220 20 , , , 19768 220 21 according accord VBG 19768 220 22 to to IN 19768 220 23 the the DT 19768 220 24 above above IN 19768 220 25 judicial judicial JJ 19768 220 26 ruling ruling NN 19768 220 27 of of IN 19768 220 28 an an DT 19768 220 29 American american JJ 19768 220 30 court court NN 19768 220 31 , , , 19768 220 32 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 220 33 Royce Royce NNP 19768 220 34 is be VBZ 19768 220 35 guilty guilty JJ 19768 220 36 of of IN 19768 220 37 wanton wanton NN 19768 220 38 and and CC 19768 220 39 unprovoked unprovoked JJ 19768 220 40 libel libel NN 19768 220 41 against against IN 19768 220 42 one one CD 19768 220 43 who who WP 19768 220 44 never never RB 19768 220 45 injured injure VBD 19768 220 46 him -PRON- PRP 19768 220 47 in in IN 19768 220 48 the the DT 19768 220 49 slightest slight JJS 19768 220 50 degree degree NN 19768 220 51 . . . 19768 221 1 In in IN 19768 221 2 the the DT 19768 221 3 case case NN 19768 221 4 of of IN 19768 221 5 Strauss Strauss NNP 19768 221 6 _ _ NNP 19768 221 7 versus versus IN 19768 221 8 _ _ NNP 19768 221 9 Francis Francis NNP 19768 221 10 , , , 19768 221 11 Chief Chief NNP 19768 221 12 Justice Justice NNP 19768 221 13 Cockburn Cockburn NNP 19768 221 14 said say VBD 19768 221 15 : : : 19768 221 16 " " `` 19768 221 17 The the DT 19768 221 18 question question NN 19768 221 19 is be VBZ 19768 221 20 as as IN 19768 221 21 to to IN 19768 221 22 the the DT 19768 221 23 article article NN 19768 221 24 as as IN 19768 221 25 a a DT 19768 221 26 whole whole NN 19768 221 27 .... .... . 19768 222 1 The the DT 19768 222 2 verdict verdict NN 19768 222 3 must must MD 19768 222 4 be be VB 19768 222 5 upon upon IN 19768 222 6 the the DT 19768 222 7 article article NN 19768 222 8 as as IN 19768 222 9 a a DT 19768 222 10 whole whole NN 19768 222 11 , , , 19768 222 12 and and CC 19768 222 13 whether whether IN 19768 222 14 , , , 19768 222 15 as as IN 19768 222 16 a a DT 19768 222 17 whole whole NN 19768 222 18 , , , 19768 222 19 it -PRON- PRP 19768 222 20 is be VBZ 19768 222 21 to to TO 19768 222 22 be be VB 19768 222 23 deemed deem VBN 19768 222 24 malicious malicious JJ 19768 222 25 and and CC 19768 222 26 libellous libellous JJ 19768 222 27 . . . 19768 222 28 " " '' 19768 223 1 ( ( -LRB- 19768 223 2 _ _ NNP 19768 223 3 Foster Foster NNP 19768 223 4 and and CC 19768 223 5 Finlason Finlason NNP 19768 223 6 's 's POS 19768 223 7 Reports Reports NNPS 19768 223 8 _ _ NNP 19768 223 9 , , , 19768 223 10 IV IV NNP 19768 223 11 . . . 19768 224 1 1107 1107 CD 19768 224 2 . . . 19768 224 3 ) ) -RRB- 19768 225 1 Applying apply VBG 19768 225 2 this this DT 19768 225 3 to to IN 19768 225 4 the the DT 19768 225 5 case case NN 19768 225 6 in in IN 19768 225 7 hand hand NN 19768 225 8 : : : 19768 225 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 225 10 Royce Royce NNP 19768 225 11 's 's POS 19768 225 12 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 225 13 review review NN 19768 225 14 presents present VBZ 19768 225 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 225 16 darkest dark JJS 19768 225 17 , , , 19768 225 18 most most RBS 19768 225 19 odious odious JJ 19768 225 20 , , , 19768 225 21 and and CC 19768 225 22 most most RBS 19768 225 23 libellous libellous JJ 19768 225 24 aspect aspect NN 19768 225 25 to to IN 19768 225 26 him -PRON- PRP 19768 225 27 who who WP 19768 225 28 most most RBS 19768 225 29 thoroughly thoroughly RB 19768 225 30 , , , 19768 225 31 penetratingly penetratingly RB 19768 225 32 , , , 19768 225 33 and and CC 19768 225 34 comprehensively comprehensively RB 19768 225 35 studies study NNS 19768 225 36 out out RP 19768 225 37 the the DT 19768 225 38 inner inner JJ 19768 225 39 structure structure NN 19768 225 40 of of IN 19768 225 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 225 42 argument argument NN 19768 225 43 _ _ NNP 19768 225 44 as as IN 19768 225 45 a a DT 19768 225 46 whole whole JJ 19768 225 47 _ _ NNP 19768 225 48 , , , 19768 225 49 and and CC 19768 225 50 who who WP 19768 225 51 most most RBS 19768 225 52 intelligently intelligently RB 19768 225 53 compares compare VBZ 19768 225 54 it -PRON- PRP 19768 225 55 with with IN 19768 225 56 the the DT 19768 225 57 book book NN 19768 225 58 which which WDT 19768 225 59 it -PRON- PRP 19768 225 60 falsely falsely RB 19768 225 61 professes profess VBZ 19768 225 62 to to TO 19768 225 63 criticise criticise VB 19768 225 64 fairly fairly RB 19768 225 65 . . . 19768 226 1 Allow allow VB 19768 226 2 me -PRON- PRP 19768 226 3 to to TO 19768 226 4 quote quote VB 19768 226 5 here here RB 19768 226 6 a a DT 19768 226 7 passage passage NN 19768 226 8 from from IN 19768 226 9 page page NN 19768 226 10 39 39 CD 19768 226 11 of of IN 19768 226 12 " " `` 19768 226 13 the the DT 19768 226 14 Way way NN 19768 226 15 out out IN 19768 226 16 of of IN 19768 226 17 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 19768 226 18 " " '' 19768 226 19 in in IN 19768 226 20 order order NN 19768 226 21 simply simply RB 19768 226 22 to to TO 19768 226 23 show show VB 19768 226 24 you -PRON- PRP 19768 226 25 how how WRB 19768 226 26 uncompromisingly uncompromisingly RB 19768 226 27 this this DT 19768 226 28 passage passage NN 19768 226 29 , , , 19768 226 30 which which WDT 19768 226 31 sums sum VBZ 19768 226 32 up up RP 19768 226 33 the the DT 19768 226 34 entire entire JJ 19768 226 35 results result NNS 19768 226 36 of of IN 19768 226 37 the the DT 19768 226 38 first first JJ 19768 226 39 half half NN 19768 226 40 of of IN 19768 226 41 the the DT 19768 226 42 book book NN 19768 226 43 and and CC 19768 226 44 luminously luminously RB 19768 226 45 forecasts forecast VBZ 19768 226 46 the the DT 19768 226 47 entire entire JJ 19768 226 48 conclusion conclusion NN 19768 226 49 of of IN 19768 226 50 the the DT 19768 226 51 whole whole NN 19768 226 52 , , , 19768 226 53 plants plant VBZ 19768 226 54 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 226 55 system system NN 19768 226 56 on on IN 19768 226 57 the the DT 19768 226 58 side side NN 19768 226 59 of of IN 19768 226 60 Realism:-- realism:-- NN 19768 226 61 " " `` 19768 226 62 The the DT 19768 226 63 scientific scientific JJ 19768 226 64 , , , 19768 226 65 modern modern JJ 19768 226 66 , , , 19768 226 67 or or CC 19768 226 68 American american JJ 19768 226 69 theory theory NN 19768 226 70 of of IN 19768 226 71 universals universal NNS 19768 226 72 , , , 19768 226 73 which which WDT 19768 226 74 results result VBZ 19768 226 75 necessarily necessarily RB 19768 226 76 from from IN 19768 226 77 analysis analysis NN 19768 226 78 of of IN 19768 226 79 the the DT 19768 226 80 scientific scientific JJ 19768 226 81 method method NN 19768 226 82 , , , 19768 226 83 is be VBZ 19768 226 84 Scientific scientific JJ 19768 226 85 Realism realism NN 19768 226 86 , , , 19768 226 87 as as IN 19768 226 88 opposed oppose VBN 19768 226 89 to to IN 19768 226 90 Philosophical Philosophical NNP 19768 226 91 Idealism Idealism NNP 19768 226 92 ; ; : 19768 226 93 and and CC 19768 226 94 it -PRON- PRP 19768 226 95 determines determine VBZ 19768 226 96 the the DT 19768 226 97 subdivision subdivision NN 19768 226 98 of of IN 19768 226 99 scientific scientific JJ 19768 226 100 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 226 101 into into IN 19768 226 102 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 226 103 three three CD 19768 226 104 great great JJ 19768 226 105 departments department NNS 19768 226 106 , , , 19768 226 107 the the DT 19768 226 108 theories theory NNS 19768 226 109 of of IN 19768 226 110 Being Being NNP 19768 226 111 , , , 19768 226 112 of of IN 19768 226 113 Knowing Knowing NNP 19768 226 114 , , , 19768 226 115 and and CC 19768 226 116 of of IN 19768 226 117 Doing do VBG 19768 226 118 . . . 19768 227 1 The the DT 19768 227 2 scientific scientific JJ 19768 227 3 theory theory NN 19768 227 4 of of IN 19768 227 5 Being be VBG 19768 227 6 results result NNS 19768 227 7 from from IN 19768 227 8 analysis analysis NN 19768 227 9 of of IN 19768 227 10 the the DT 19768 227 11 Genus Genus NNP 19768 227 12 - - HYPH 19768 227 13 in in IN 19768 227 14 - - HYPH 19768 227 15 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 227 16 , , , 19768 227 17 and and CC 19768 227 18 constitutes constitute VBZ 19768 227 19 ontology ontology NN 19768 227 20 or or CC 19768 227 21 Constructive constructive JJ 19768 227 22 Realism Realism NNP 19768 227 23 , , , 19768 227 24 as as IN 19768 227 25 opposed oppose VBN 19768 227 26 to to IN 19768 227 27 all all DT 19768 227 28 forms form NNS 19768 227 29 of of IN 19768 227 30 Constructive Constructive NNP 19768 227 31 Idealism Idealism NNP 19768 227 32 . . . 19768 228 1 The the DT 19768 228 2 scientific scientific JJ 19768 228 3 theory theory NN 19768 228 4 of of IN 19768 228 5 Knowledge knowledge NN 19768 228 6 results result NNS 19768 228 7 from from IN 19768 228 8 analysis analysis NN 19768 228 9 of of IN 19768 228 10 the the DT 19768 228 11 Concept Concept NNP 19768 228 12 , , , 19768 228 13 and and CC 19768 228 14 constitutes constitute VBZ 19768 228 15 psychology psychology NN 19768 228 16 or or CC 19768 228 17 Critical Critical NNP 19768 228 18 Realism Realism NNP 19768 228 19 , , , 19768 228 20 as as IN 19768 228 21 opposed oppose VBN 19768 228 22 to to IN 19768 228 23 all all DT 19768 228 24 forms form NNS 19768 228 25 of of IN 19768 228 26 transcendental transcendental JJ 19768 228 27 or or CC 19768 228 28 Critical Critical NNP 19768 228 29 Idealism Idealism NNP 19768 228 30 . . . 19768 229 1 The the DT 19768 229 2 scientific scientific JJ 19768 229 3 theory theory NN 19768 229 4 of of IN 19768 229 5 Conduct conduct NN 19768 229 6 results result NNS 19768 229 7 from from IN 19768 229 8 analysis analysis NN 19768 229 9 of of IN 19768 229 10 the the DT 19768 229 11 Word Word NNP 19768 229 12 , , , 19768 229 13 and and CC 19768 229 14 constitutes constitute VBZ 19768 229 15 anthroponomy anthroponomy NN 19768 229 16 ( ( -LRB- 19768 229 17 including include VBG 19768 229 18 ethics ethic NNS 19768 229 19 , , , 19768 229 20 politics politic NNS 19768 229 21 , , , 19768 229 22 and and CC 19768 229 23 art art NN 19768 229 24 in in IN 19768 229 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 229 26 widest wide JJS 19768 229 27 sense sense NN 19768 229 28 ) ) -RRB- 19768 229 29 , , , 19768 229 30 sociology sociology NN 19768 229 31 , , , 19768 229 32 or or CC 19768 229 33 Ethical Ethical NNP 19768 229 34 Realism Realism NNP 19768 229 35 , , , 19768 229 36 as as IN 19768 229 37 opposed oppose VBN 19768 229 38 to to IN 19768 229 39 all all DT 19768 229 40 forms form NNS 19768 229 41 of of IN 19768 229 42 Ethical Ethical NNP 19768 229 43 Idealism Idealism NNP 19768 229 44 . . . 19768 230 1 The the DT 19768 230 2 scientific scientific JJ 19768 230 3 theory theory NN 19768 230 4 of of IN 19768 230 5 the the DT 19768 230 6 universe universe NN 19768 230 7 , , , 19768 230 8 as as IN 19768 230 9 the the DT 19768 230 10 absolute absolute JJ 19768 230 11 union union NN 19768 230 12 of of IN 19768 230 13 Being Being NNP 19768 230 14 , , , 19768 230 15 Knowing Knowing NNP 19768 230 16 , , , 19768 230 17 and and CC 19768 230 18 Doing do VBG 19768 230 19 in in IN 19768 230 20 the the DT 19768 230 21 One one NN 19768 230 22 and and CC 19768 230 23 All all DT 19768 230 24 , , , 19768 230 25 results result NNS 19768 230 26 from from IN 19768 230 27 comprehension comprehension NN 19768 230 28 of of IN 19768 230 29 these these DT 19768 230 30 three three CD 19768 230 31 theories theory NNS 19768 230 32 in in IN 19768 230 33 complete complete JJ 19768 230 34 organic organic JJ 19768 230 35 unity unity NN 19768 230 36 , , , 19768 230 37 and and CC 19768 230 38 constitutes constitute VBZ 19768 230 39 organic organic JJ 19768 230 40 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 230 41 , , , 19768 230 42 scientific scientific JJ 19768 230 43 theology theology NN 19768 230 44 , , , 19768 230 45 or or CC 19768 230 46 Religious religious JJ 19768 230 47 Realism realism NN 19768 230 48 , , , 19768 230 49 as as IN 19768 230 50 opposed oppose VBN 19768 230 51 to to IN 19768 230 52 all all DT 19768 230 53 forms form NNS 19768 230 54 of of IN 19768 230 55 Religious Religious NNP 19768 230 56 Idealism Idealism NNP 19768 230 57 . . . 19768 230 58 " " '' 19768 231 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 231 2 submit submit VBP 19768 231 3 this this DT 19768 231 4 long long JJ 19768 231 5 extract extract NN 19768 231 6 to to IN 19768 231 7 you -PRON- PRP 19768 231 8 , , , 19768 231 9 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 231 10 , , , 19768 231 11 not not RB 19768 231 12 to to TO 19768 231 13 bore bore VB 19768 231 14 you -PRON- PRP 19768 231 15 with with IN 19768 231 16 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 19768 231 17 speculations speculation NNS 19768 231 18 , , , 19768 231 19 but but CC 19768 231 20 simply simply RB 19768 231 21 to to TO 19768 231 22 enable enable VB 19768 231 23 you -PRON- PRP 19768 231 24 , , , 19768 231 25 as as IN 19768 231 26 educated educate VBN 19768 231 27 men man NNS 19768 231 28 who who WP 19768 231 29 understand understand VBP 19768 231 30 the the DT 19768 231 31 meaning meaning NN 19768 231 32 of of IN 19768 231 33 plain plain JJ 19768 231 34 and and CC 19768 231 35 straightforward straightforward JJ 19768 231 36 English English NNP 19768 231 37 on on IN 19768 231 38 any any DT 19768 231 39 subject subject NN 19768 231 40 , , , 19768 231 41 to to TO 19768 231 42 follow follow VB 19768 231 43 the the DT 19768 231 44 twistings twisting NNS 19768 231 45 and and CC 19768 231 46 turnings turning NNS 19768 231 47 of of IN 19768 231 48 an an DT 19768 231 49 extraordinarily extraordinarily RB 19768 231 50 sinuous sinuous JJ 19768 231 51 and and CC 19768 231 52 disingenuous disingenuous JJ 19768 231 53 intellect intellect NN 19768 231 54 , , , 19768 231 55 and and CC 19768 231 56 intelligently intelligently RB 19768 231 57 to to TO 19768 231 58 decide decide VB 19768 231 59 a a DT 19768 231 60 question question NN 19768 231 61 which which WDT 19768 231 62 needs need VBZ 19768 231 63 here here RB 19768 231 64 to to TO 19768 231 65 be be VB 19768 231 66 settled settle VBN 19768 231 67 clearly clearly RB 19768 231 68 in in IN 19768 231 69 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 231 70 own own JJ 19768 231 71 minds mind NNS 19768 231 72 : : : 19768 231 73 could could MD 19768 231 74 any any DT 19768 231 75 competent competent JJ 19768 231 76 professor professor NN 19768 231 77 of of IN 19768 231 78 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 231 79 , , , 19768 231 80 undertaking undertake VBG 19768 231 81 to to TO 19768 231 82 give give VB 19768 231 83 , , , 19768 231 84 as as IN 19768 231 85 a a DT 19768 231 86 fair fair JJ 19768 231 87 critic critic NN 19768 231 88 , , , 19768 231 89 a a DT 19768 231 90 truthful truthful JJ 19768 231 91 account account NN 19768 231 92 to to IN 19768 231 93 the the DT 19768 231 94 public public NN 19768 231 95 of of IN 19768 231 96 the the DT 19768 231 97 contents content NNS 19768 231 98 of of IN 19768 231 99 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 231 100 book book NN 19768 231 101 , , , 19768 231 102 read read VBD 19768 231 103 that that DT 19768 231 104 passage passage NN 19768 231 105 , , , 19768 231 106 and and CC 19768 231 107 then then RB 19768 231 108 , , , 19768 231 109 omitting omit VBG 19768 231 110 all all DT 19768 231 111 reference reference NN 19768 231 112 to to IN 19768 231 113 the the DT 19768 231 114 contrast contrast NN 19768 231 115 there there RB 19768 231 116 and and CC 19768 231 117 everywhere everywhere RB 19768 231 118 made make VBN 19768 231 119 between between IN 19768 231 120 realism realism NN 19768 231 121 and and CC 19768 231 122 idealism idealism NN 19768 231 123 , , , 19768 231 124 honestly honestly RB 19768 231 125 tell tell VB 19768 231 126 that that DT 19768 231 127 public public NN 19768 231 128 , , , 19768 231 129 without without IN 19768 231 130 any any DT 19768 231 131 further further JJ 19768 231 132 information information NN 19768 231 133 at at RB 19768 231 134 all all RB 19768 231 135 on on IN 19768 231 136 the the DT 19768 231 137 subject subject NN 19768 231 138 , , , 19768 231 139 that that IN 19768 231 140 the the DT 19768 231 141 " " `` 19768 231 142 conclusion conclusion NN 19768 231 143 " " '' 19768 231 144 of of IN 19768 231 145 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 231 146 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 231 147 is be VBZ 19768 231 148 " " `` 19768 231 149 essentially essentially RB 19768 231 150 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 231 151 " " '' 19768 231 152 ? ? . 19768 232 1 Yet yet CC 19768 232 2 that that DT 19768 232 3 is be VBZ 19768 232 4 the the DT 19768 232 5 conscienceless conscienceless NN 19768 232 6 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 232 7 with with IN 19768 232 8 which which WDT 19768 232 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 232 10 Royce Royce NNP 19768 232 11 prepares prepare VBZ 19768 232 12 the the DT 19768 232 13 way way NN 19768 232 14 for for IN 19768 232 15 all all DT 19768 232 16 that that WDT 19768 232 17 is be VBZ 19768 232 18 to to TO 19768 232 19 follow follow VB 19768 232 20 , , , 19768 232 21 deceives deceive VBZ 19768 232 22 the the DT 19768 232 23 reader reader NN 19768 232 24 at at IN 19768 232 25 the the DT 19768 232 26 very very JJ 19768 232 27 outset outset NN 19768 232 28 , , , 19768 232 29 predisposes predispose VBZ 19768 232 30 him -PRON- PRP 19768 232 31 to to TO 19768 232 32 believe believe VB 19768 232 33 the the DT 19768 232 34 preposterous preposterous JJ 19768 232 35 charge charge NN 19768 232 36 that that IN 19768 232 37 I -PRON- PRP 19768 232 38 " " `` 19768 232 39 appropriated appropriate VBD 19768 232 40 " " '' 19768 232 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 232 42 main main JJ 19768 232 43 theory theory NN 19768 232 44 from from IN 19768 232 45 the the DT 19768 232 46 great great JJ 19768 232 47 idealist idealist NN 19768 232 48 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 232 49 , , , 19768 232 50 arouses arouse VBZ 19768 232 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 232 52 indignation indignation NN 19768 232 53 or or CC 19768 232 54 mirth mirth NN 19768 232 55 , , , 19768 232 56 as as IN 19768 232 57 the the DT 19768 232 58 case case NN 19768 232 59 may may MD 19768 232 60 be be VB 19768 232 61 , , , 19768 232 62 at at IN 19768 232 63 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 232 64 alleged allege VBN 19768 232 65 strutting strut VBG 19768 232 66 about about IN 19768 232 67 in in IN 19768 232 68 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 232 69 plumes plume NNS 19768 232 70 , , , 19768 232 71 and and CC 19768 232 72 so so RB 19768 232 73 leads lead VBZ 19768 232 74 him -PRON- PRP 19768 232 75 at at IN 19768 232 76 last last RB 19768 232 77 to to TO 19768 232 78 applaud applaud VB 19768 232 79 the the DT 19768 232 80 righteous righteous JJ 19768 232 81 castigation castigation NN 19768 232 82 of of IN 19768 232 83 the the DT 19768 232 84 " " `` 19768 232 85 professional professional JJ 19768 232 86 warning warning NN 19768 232 87 , , , 19768 232 88 " " '' 19768 232 89 by by IN 19768 232 90 which which WDT 19768 232 91 the the DT 19768 232 92 peacock peacock NN 19768 232 93 - - HYPH 19768 232 94 feathers feather NNS 19768 232 95 are be VBP 19768 232 96 made make VBN 19768 232 97 to to TO 19768 232 98 fly fly VB 19768 232 99 in in IN 19768 232 100 all all DT 19768 232 101 directions direction NNS 19768 232 102 and and CC 19768 232 103 I -PRON- PRP 19768 232 104 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 232 105 am be VBP 19768 232 106 scourged scourge VBN 19768 232 107 back back RB 19768 232 108 among among IN 19768 232 109 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 232 110 brother brother NN 19768 232 111 - - HYPH 19768 232 112 jackdaws jackdaws NNP 19768 232 113 , , , 19768 232 114 the the DT 19768 232 115 impostors impostor NNS 19768 232 116 , , , 19768 232 117 charlatans charlatans NNPS 19768 232 118 , , , 19768 232 119 and and CC 19768 232 120 quacks quack NNS 19768 232 121 of of IN 19768 232 122 myriad myriad JJ 19768 232 123 kinds kind NNS 19768 232 124 . . . 19768 233 1 This this DT 19768 233 2 is be VBZ 19768 233 3 the the DT 19768 233 4 purport purport NN 19768 233 5 and and CC 19768 233 6 the the DT 19768 233 7 spirit spirit NN 19768 233 8 of of IN 19768 233 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 233 10 Royce Royce NNP 19768 233 11 's 's POS 19768 233 12 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 233 13 review review NN 19768 233 14 , , , 19768 233 15 " " '' 19768 233 16 _ _ NNP 19768 233 17 as as IN 19768 233 18 a a DT 19768 233 19 whole whole JJ 19768 233 20 _ _ NN 19768 233 21 . . . 19768 233 22 " " '' 19768 234 1 Is be VBZ 19768 234 2 it -PRON- PRP 19768 234 3 the the DT 19768 234 4 " " `` 19768 234 5 fair fair JJ 19768 234 6 criticism criticism NN 19768 234 7 " " '' 19768 234 8 which which WDT 19768 234 9 the the DT 19768 234 10 law law NN 19768 234 11 allows allow VBZ 19768 234 12 ? ? . 19768 235 1 Or or CC 19768 235 2 is be VBZ 19768 235 3 it -PRON- PRP 19768 235 4 the the DT 19768 235 5 " " `` 19768 235 6 libel libel NN 19768 235 7 " " '' 19768 235 8 which which WDT 19768 235 9 the the DT 19768 235 10 law law NN 19768 235 11 condemns condemn VBZ 19768 235 12 ? ? . 19768 236 1 Is be VBZ 19768 236 2 it -PRON- PRP 19768 236 3 the the DT 19768 236 4 fair fair JJ 19768 236 5 and and CC 19768 236 6 critical critical JJ 19768 236 7 judgment judgment NN 19768 236 8 which which WDT 19768 236 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 236 10 silence silence NN 19768 236 11 shall shall MD 19768 236 12 sanction sanction NN 19768 236 13 , , , 19768 236 14 as as IN 19768 236 15 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 236 16 's 's POS 19768 236 17 official official JJ 19768 236 18 verdict verdict NN 19768 236 19 on on IN 19768 236 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 236 21 work work NN 19768 236 22 ? ? . 19768 237 1 Or or CC 19768 237 2 is be VBZ 19768 237 3 it -PRON- PRP 19768 237 4 the the DT 19768 237 5 libellous libellous JJ 19768 237 6 and and CC 19768 237 7 vulgar vulgar JJ 19768 237 8 abuse abuse NN 19768 237 9 which which WDT 19768 237 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 237 11 speech speech NN 19768 237 12 shall shall MD 19768 237 13 rebuke rebuke VB 19768 237 14 , , , 19768 237 15 as as IN 19768 237 16 shaming shame VBG 19768 237 17 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 237 18 more more RBR 19768 237 19 than than IN 19768 237 20 me -PRON- PRP 19768 237 21 by by IN 19768 237 22 bringing bring VBG 19768 237 23 the the DT 19768 237 24 ethics ethic NNS 19768 237 25 and and CC 19768 237 26 manners manner NNS 19768 237 27 of of IN 19768 237 28 the the DT 19768 237 29 literary literary JJ 19768 237 30 Bedouin Bedouin NNP 19768 237 31 into into IN 19768 237 32 the the DT 19768 237 33 professor professor NN 19768 237 34 's 's POS 19768 237 35 chair chair NN 19768 237 36 ? ? . 19768 238 1 V. V. NNP 19768 238 2 But But NNP 19768 238 3 , , , 19768 238 4 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 238 5 , , , 19768 238 6 the the DT 19768 238 7 gravest grave JJS 19768 238 8 aspect aspect NN 19768 238 9 of of IN 19768 238 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 238 11 Royce Royce NNP 19768 238 12 's 's POS 19768 238 13 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 238 14 review review NN 19768 238 15 remains remain VBZ 19768 238 16 still still RB 19768 238 17 to to TO 19768 238 18 be be VB 19768 238 19 considered consider VBN 19768 238 20 . . . 19768 239 1 Is be VBZ 19768 239 2 libel libel NN 19768 239 3 -- -- : 19768 239 4 vulgar vulgar JJ 19768 239 5 , , , 19768 239 6 violent violent JJ 19768 239 7 , , , 19768 239 8 and and CC 19768 239 9 brutal brutal JJ 19768 239 10 libel libel NN 19768 239 11 -- -- : 19768 239 12 the the DT 19768 239 13 means mean NNS 19768 239 14 by by IN 19768 239 15 which which WDT 19768 239 16 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 239 17 University University NNP 19768 239 18 , , , 19768 239 19 represented represent VBN 19768 239 20 by by IN 19768 239 21 one one CD 19768 239 22 of of IN 19768 239 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 239 24 professors professor NNS 19768 239 25 of of IN 19768 239 26 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 239 27 who who WP 19768 239 28 openly openly RB 19768 239 29 claims claim VBZ 19768 239 30 to to TO 19768 239 31 address address VB 19768 239 32 the the DT 19768 239 33 general general JJ 19768 239 34 public public NN 19768 239 35 in in IN 19768 239 36 the the DT 19768 239 37 name name NN 19768 239 38 of of IN 19768 239 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 239 40 office office NN 19768 239 41 and and CC 19768 239 42 of of IN 19768 239 43 her -PRON- PRP 19768 239 44 , , , 19768 239 45 proposes propose VBZ 19768 239 46 to to TO 19768 239 47 realize realize VB 19768 239 48 the the DT 19768 239 49 lofty lofty JJ 19768 239 50 ideal ideal NN 19768 239 51 of of IN 19768 239 52 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 239 53 President President NNP 19768 239 54 , , , 19768 239 55 and and CC 19768 239 56 make make VB 19768 239 57 herself -PRON- PRP 19768 239 58 the the DT 19768 239 59 " " `` 19768 239 60 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 239 61 pioneer pioneer NN 19768 239 62 " " '' 19768 239 63 for for IN 19768 239 64 each each DT 19768 239 65 new new JJ 19768 239 66 generation generation NN 19768 239 67 in in IN 19768 239 68 the the DT 19768 239 69 pursuit pursuit NN 19768 239 70 of of IN 19768 239 71 truth truth NN 19768 239 72 ? ? . 19768 240 1 Is be VBZ 19768 240 2 this this DT 19768 240 3 the the DT 19768 240 4 welcome welcome NN 19768 240 5 which which WDT 19768 240 6 she -PRON- PRP 19768 240 7 accords accord VBZ 19768 240 8 to to IN 19768 240 9 serious serious JJ 19768 240 10 , , , 19768 240 11 dignified dignified JJ 19768 240 12 , , , 19768 240 13 and and CC 19768 240 14 not not RB 19768 240 15 unscholarly unscholarly JJ 19768 240 16 works work NNS 19768 240 17 , , , 19768 240 18 giving give VBG 19768 240 19 the the DT 19768 240 20 results result NNS 19768 240 21 , , , 19768 240 22 however however RB 19768 240 23 partially partially RB 19768 240 24 and and CC 19768 240 25 imperfectly imperfectly RB 19768 240 26 wrought work VBD 19768 240 27 out out RP 19768 240 28 , , , 19768 240 29 of of IN 19768 240 30 patient patient JJ 19768 240 31 and and CC 19768 240 32 independent independent JJ 19768 240 33 reflection reflection NN 19768 240 34 for for IN 19768 240 35 more more JJR 19768 240 36 than than IN 19768 240 37 thirty thirty CD 19768 240 38 years year NNS 19768 240 39 on on IN 19768 240 40 the the DT 19768 240 41 highest high JJS 19768 240 42 problems problem NNS 19768 240 43 of of IN 19768 240 44 human human JJ 19768 240 45 life life NN 19768 240 46 and and CC 19768 240 47 thought thought NN 19768 240 48 ? ? . 19768 241 1 Is be VBZ 19768 241 2 this this DT 19768 241 3 the the DT 19768 241 4 best good JJS 19768 241 5 sympathy sympathy NN 19768 241 6 and and CC 19768 241 7 encouragement encouragement NN 19768 241 8 she -PRON- PRP 19768 241 9 has have VBZ 19768 241 10 to to TO 19768 241 11 offer offer VB 19768 241 12 to to IN 19768 241 13 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 241 14 own own JJ 19768 241 15 sons son NNS 19768 241 16 when when WRB 19768 241 17 they -PRON- PRP 19768 241 18 take take VBP 19768 241 19 up up RP 19768 241 20 in in IN 19768 241 21 earnest earnest JJ 19768 241 22 the the DT 19768 241 23 task task NN 19768 241 24 of of IN 19768 241 25 helping help VBG 19768 241 26 her -PRON- PRP 19768 241 27 to to TO 19768 241 28 realize realize VB 19768 241 29 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 241 30 own own JJ 19768 241 31 ideal ideal NN 19768 241 32 ? ? . 19768 242 1 Is be VBZ 19768 242 2 this this DT 19768 242 3 the the DT 19768 242 4 attitude attitude NN 19768 242 5 in in IN 19768 242 6 which which WDT 19768 242 7 she -PRON- PRP 19768 242 8 confronts confront VBZ 19768 242 9 the the DT 19768 242 10 great great JJ 19768 242 11 questions question NNS 19768 242 12 of of IN 19768 242 13 the the DT 19768 242 14 age age NN 19768 242 15 , , , 19768 242 16 and and CC 19768 242 17 the the DT 19768 242 18 spirit spirit NN 19768 242 19 which which WDT 19768 242 20 she -PRON- PRP 19768 242 21 aims aim VBZ 19768 242 22 to to TO 19768 242 23 foster foster VB 19768 242 24 in in IN 19768 242 25 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 242 26 young young JJ 19768 242 27 men man NNS 19768 242 28 ? ? . 19768 243 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 243 2 do do VBP 19768 243 3 not not RB 19768 243 4 believe believe VB 19768 243 5 it -PRON- PRP 19768 243 6 ; ; : 19768 243 7 but but CC 19768 243 8 you -PRON- PRP 19768 243 9 alone alone RB 19768 243 10 , , , 19768 243 11 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 243 12 , , , 19768 243 13 can can MD 19768 243 14 give give VB 19768 243 15 the the DT 19768 243 16 authoritative authoritative JJ 19768 243 17 answer answer NN 19768 243 18 to to IN 19768 243 19 such such JJ 19768 243 20 queries query NNS 19768 243 21 . . . 19768 244 1 When when WRB 19768 244 2 civil civil JJ 19768 244 3 service service NN 19768 244 4 reformers reformer NNS 19768 244 5 plead plead VBP 19768 244 6 the the DT 19768 244 7 urgent urgent JJ 19768 244 8 necessity necessity NN 19768 244 9 of of IN 19768 244 10 political political JJ 19768 244 11 reform reform NN 19768 244 12 , , , 19768 244 13 they -PRON- PRP 19768 244 14 are be VBP 19768 244 15 irrelevantly irrelevantly RB 19768 244 16 charged charge VBN 19768 244 17 by by IN 19768 244 18 the the DT 19768 244 19 adherents adherent NNS 19768 244 20 of of IN 19768 244 21 the the DT 19768 244 22 spoils spoil NNS 19768 244 23 system system NN 19768 244 24 with with IN 19768 244 25 being be VBG 19768 244 26 " " `` 19768 244 27 hypocrites hypocrite NNS 19768 244 28 and and CC 19768 244 29 pharisees pharisee NNS 19768 244 30 . . . 19768 244 31 " " '' 19768 245 1 Precisely precisely RB 19768 245 2 so so RB 19768 245 3 , , , 19768 245 4 when when WRB 19768 245 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 245 6 plead plead VBP 19768 245 7 the the DT 19768 245 8 urgent urgent JJ 19768 245 9 necessity necessity NN 19768 245 10 of of IN 19768 245 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 245 12 reform reform NN 19768 245 13 , , , 19768 245 14 I -PRON- PRP 19768 245 15 am be VBP 19768 245 16 irrelevantly irrelevantly RB 19768 245 17 charged charge VBN 19768 245 18 by by IN 19768 245 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 245 20 Royce Royce NNP 19768 245 21 , , , 19768 245 22 in in IN 19768 245 23 effect effect NN 19768 245 24 , , , 19768 245 25 with with IN 19768 245 26 being be VBG 19768 245 27 a a DT 19768 245 28 false false JJ 19768 245 29 pretender pretender NN 19768 245 30 , , , 19768 245 31 a a DT 19768 245 32 plagiarist plagiarist NN 19768 245 33 , , , 19768 245 34 and and CC 19768 245 35 an an DT 19768 245 36 impostor impostor NN 19768 245 37 . . . 19768 246 1 The the DT 19768 246 2 charge charge NN 19768 246 3 is be VBZ 19768 246 4 just just RB 19768 246 5 as as RB 19768 246 6 true true JJ 19768 246 7 in in IN 19768 246 8 one one CD 19768 246 9 case case NN 19768 246 10 as as IN 19768 246 11 in in IN 19768 246 12 the the DT 19768 246 13 other other JJ 19768 246 14 . . . 19768 247 1 But but CC 19768 247 2 , , , 19768 247 3 be be VB 19768 247 4 the the DT 19768 247 5 charge charge NN 19768 247 6 true true JJ 19768 247 7 or or CC 19768 247 8 untrue untrue JJ 19768 247 9 , , , 19768 247 10 the the DT 19768 247 11 attention attention NN 19768 247 12 of of IN 19768 247 13 keen keen JJ 19768 247 14 and and CC 19768 247 15 candid candid JJ 19768 247 16 minds mind NNS 19768 247 17 is be VBZ 19768 247 18 not not RB 19768 247 19 to to TO 19768 247 20 be be VB 19768 247 21 diverted divert VBN 19768 247 22 by by IN 19768 247 23 this this DT 19768 247 24 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 247 25 transparent transparent JJ 19768 247 26 device device NN 19768 247 27 from from IN 19768 247 28 the the DT 19768 247 29 main main JJ 19768 247 30 point point NN 19768 247 31 of of IN 19768 247 32 reform reform NN 19768 247 33 . . . 19768 248 1 What what WP 19768 248 2 is be VBZ 19768 248 3 this this DT 19768 248 4 needed need VBN 19768 248 5 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 248 6 reform reform NN 19768 248 7 ? ? . 19768 249 1 Briefly briefly RB 19768 249 2 , , , 19768 249 3 _ _ NNP 19768 249 4 to to TO 19768 249 5 substitute substitute VB 19768 249 6 the the DT 19768 249 7 scientific scientific JJ 19768 249 8 method method NN 19768 249 9 for for IN 19768 249 10 the the DT 19768 249 11 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 249 12 method method NN 19768 249 13 in in IN 19768 249 14 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 249 15 _ _ NNP 19768 249 16 , , , 19768 249 17 as as IN 19768 249 18 the the DT 19768 249 19 only only JJ 19768 249 20 possible possible JJ 19768 249 21 means mean NNS 19768 249 22 , , , 19768 249 23 in in IN 19768 249 24 this this DT 19768 249 25 critical critical JJ 19768 249 26 and and CC 19768 249 27 sceptical sceptical JJ 19768 249 28 age age NN 19768 249 29 , , , 19768 249 30 of of IN 19768 249 31 making make VBG 19768 249 32 ethics ethic NNS 19768 249 33 and and CC 19768 249 34 religion religion NN 19768 249 35 so so RB 19768 249 36 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 249 37 as as IN 19768 249 38 to to TO 19768 249 39 command command VB 19768 249 40 the the DT 19768 249 41 continued continue VBN 19768 249 42 allegiance allegiance NN 19768 249 43 of of IN 19768 249 44 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 249 45 minds mind NNS 19768 249 46 . . . 19768 250 1 Unphilosophized unphilosophized JJ 19768 250 2 science science NN 19768 250 3 conceives conceive VBZ 19768 250 4 the the DT 19768 250 5 universe universe NN 19768 250 6 as as IN 19768 250 7 nothing nothing NN 19768 250 8 but but CC 19768 250 9 a a DT 19768 250 10 Machine Machine NNP 19768 250 11 - - HYPH 19768 250 12 World world NN 19768 250 13 ; ; : 19768 250 14 and and CC 19768 250 15 in in IN 19768 250 16 this this DT 19768 250 17 conception conception NN 19768 250 18 there there EX 19768 250 19 is be VBZ 19768 250 20 no no DT 19768 250 21 room room NN 19768 250 22 for for IN 19768 250 23 any any DT 19768 250 24 Ethical Ethical NNP 19768 250 25 Ideal Ideal NNP 19768 250 26 . . . 19768 251 1 Unscientific unscientific JJ 19768 251 2 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 251 3 conceives conceive VBZ 19768 251 4 the the DT 19768 251 5 universe universe NN 19768 251 6 as as IN 19768 251 7 nothing nothing NN 19768 251 8 but but IN 19768 251 9 a a DT 19768 251 10 Thought Thought NNP 19768 251 11 - - HYPH 19768 251 12 World world NN 19768 251 13 ; ; : 19768 251 14 and and CC 19768 251 15 in in IN 19768 251 16 this this DT 19768 251 17 conception conception NN 19768 251 18 there there EX 19768 251 19 is be VBZ 19768 251 20 no no DT 19768 251 21 room room NN 19768 251 22 for for IN 19768 251 23 any any DT 19768 251 24 Mechanical Mechanical NNP 19768 251 25 Real Real NNP 19768 251 26 . . . 19768 252 1 On on IN 19768 252 2 the the DT 19768 252 3 possibility possibility NN 19768 252 4 of of IN 19768 252 5 developing develop VBG 19768 252 6 a a DT 19768 252 7 scientific scientific JJ 19768 252 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 252 9 out out IN 19768 252 10 of of IN 19768 252 11 the the DT 19768 252 12 scientific scientific JJ 19768 252 13 method method NN 19768 252 14 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 252 15 must must MD 19768 252 16 depend depend VB 19768 252 17 at at IN 19768 252 18 last last JJ 19768 252 19 the the DT 19768 252 20 only only JJ 19768 252 21 possibility possibility NN 19768 252 22 , , , 19768 252 23 for for IN 19768 252 24 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 252 25 men man NNS 19768 252 26 , , , 19768 252 27 of of IN 19768 252 28 believing believe VBG 19768 252 29 equally equally RB 19768 252 30 in in IN 19768 252 31 the the DT 19768 252 32 real real JJ 19768 252 33 principles principle NNS 19768 252 34 of of IN 19768 252 35 mechanical mechanical JJ 19768 252 36 science science NN 19768 252 37 and and CC 19768 252 38 in in IN 19768 252 39 the the DT 19768 252 40 ideal ideal JJ 19768 252 41 principles principle NNS 19768 252 42 of of IN 19768 252 43 ethical ethical JJ 19768 252 44 science science NN 19768 252 45 . . . 19768 253 1 To to NN 19768 253 2 - - HYPH 19768 253 3 day day NN 19768 253 4 the the DT 19768 253 5 greatest great JJS 19768 253 6 obstacle obstacle NN 19768 253 7 to to IN 19768 253 8 such such PDT 19768 253 9 a a DT 19768 253 10 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 253 11 belief belief NN 19768 253 12 is be VBZ 19768 253 13 the the DT 19768 253 14 " " `` 19768 253 15 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 253 16 idealism idealism NN 19768 253 17 " " '' 19768 253 18 which which WDT 19768 253 19 directly directly RB 19768 253 20 contradicts contradict VBZ 19768 253 21 it -PRON- PRP 19768 253 22 ; ; : 19768 253 23 and and CC 19768 253 24 the the DT 19768 253 25 greatest great JJS 19768 253 26 reform reform NN 19768 253 27 needed need VBN 19768 253 28 in in IN 19768 253 29 modern modern JJ 19768 253 30 thought thought NN 19768 253 31 , , , 19768 253 32 above above IN 19768 253 33 all all DT 19768 253 34 in in IN 19768 253 35 the the DT 19768 253 36 theory theory NN 19768 253 37 of of IN 19768 253 38 ethics ethic NNS 19768 253 39 , , , 19768 253 40 is be VBZ 19768 253 41 the the DT 19768 253 42 substitution substitution NN 19768 253 43 of of IN 19768 253 44 the the DT 19768 253 45 scientific scientific JJ 19768 253 46 method method NN 19768 253 47 for for IN 19768 253 48 the the DT 19768 253 49 idealistic idealistic JJ 19768 253 50 method method NN 19768 253 51 in in IN 19768 253 52 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 253 53 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 253 54 . . . 19768 254 1 The the DT 19768 254 2 cause cause NN 19768 254 3 of of IN 19768 254 4 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 254 5 reform reform NN 19768 254 6 , , , 19768 254 7 indeed indeed RB 19768 254 8 , , , 19768 254 9 can can MD 19768 254 10 not not RB 19768 254 11 be be VB 19768 254 12 long long RB 19768 254 13 delayed delay VBN 19768 254 14 by by IN 19768 254 15 any any DT 19768 254 16 Philistinism Philistinism NNP 19768 254 17 in in IN 19768 254 18 those those DT 19768 254 19 who who WP 19768 254 20 , , , 19768 254 21 by by IN 19768 254 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 254 23 professional professional JJ 19768 254 24 position position NN 19768 254 25 , , , 19768 254 26 ought ought MD 19768 254 27 to to TO 19768 254 28 be be VB 19768 254 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 254 30 most most RBS 19768 254 31 ardent ardent JJ 19768 254 32 friends friend NNS 19768 254 33 . . . 19768 255 1 The the DT 19768 255 2 method method NN 19768 255 3 of of IN 19768 255 4 science science NN 19768 255 5 is be VBZ 19768 255 6 destined destine VBN 19768 255 7 to to TO 19768 255 8 revolutionize revolutionize VB 19768 255 9 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 255 10 -- -- : 19768 255 11 to to TO 19768 255 12 modernize modernize VB 19768 255 13 it -PRON- PRP 19768 255 14 by by IN 19768 255 15 founding found VBG 19768 255 16 it -PRON- PRP 19768 255 17 anew anew RB 19768 255 18 upon upon IN 19768 255 19 a a DT 19768 255 20 thoroughly thoroughly RB 19768 255 21 realistic realistic JJ 19768 255 22 and and CC 19768 255 23 scientific scientific JJ 19768 255 24 theory theory NN 19768 255 25 of of IN 19768 255 26 universals universal NNS 19768 255 27 . . . 19768 256 1 The the DT 19768 256 2 net net JJ 19768 256 3 result result NN 19768 256 4 of of IN 19768 256 5 all all PDT 19768 256 6 the the DT 19768 256 7 physical physical JJ 19768 256 8 sciences science NNS 19768 256 9 thus thus RB 19768 256 10 far far RB 19768 256 11 , , , 19768 256 12 the the DT 19768 256 13 one one CD 19768 256 14 fixed fix VBN 19768 256 15 result result NN 19768 256 16 to to IN 19768 256 17 which which WDT 19768 256 18 all all DT 19768 256 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 256 20 other other JJ 19768 256 21 results result NNS 19768 256 22 steadily steadily RB 19768 256 23 point point VBP 19768 256 24 with with IN 19768 256 25 increasingly increasingly RB 19768 256 26 evident evident JJ 19768 256 27 convergence convergence NN 19768 256 28 , , , 19768 256 29 is be VBZ 19768 256 30 that that IN 19768 256 31 _ _ NNP 19768 256 32 the the DT 19768 256 33 already already RB 19768 256 34 known know VBN 19768 256 35 constitution constitution NN 19768 256 36 of of IN 19768 256 37 the the DT 19768 256 38 real real JJ 19768 256 39 universe universe NN 19768 256 40 is be VBZ 19768 256 41 that that DT 19768 256 42 of of IN 19768 256 43 the the DT 19768 256 44 Machine Machine NNP 19768 256 45 _ _ NNP 19768 256 46 . . . 19768 257 1 This this DT 19768 257 2 universal universal JJ 19768 257 3 fixed fix VBN 19768 257 4 result result NN 19768 257 5 , , , 19768 257 6 and and CC 19768 257 7 not not RB 19768 257 8 mere mere JJ 19768 257 9 individual individual JJ 19768 257 10 self self NN 19768 257 11 - - HYPH 19768 257 12 consciousness consciousness NN 19768 257 13 , , , 19768 257 14 is be VBZ 19768 257 15 the the DT 19768 257 16 necessary necessary JJ 19768 257 17 and and CC 19768 257 18 only only RB 19768 257 19 beginning beginning NN 19768 257 20 - - HYPH 19768 257 21 point point NN 19768 257 22 of of IN 19768 257 23 a a DT 19768 257 24 constructive constructive JJ 19768 257 25 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 257 26 of of IN 19768 257 27 Nature nature NN 19768 257 28 ; ; : 19768 257 29 for for IN 19768 257 30 , , , 19768 257 31 where where WRB 19768 257 32 the the DT 19768 257 33 special special JJ 19768 257 34 sciences science NNS 19768 257 35 end end VBP 19768 257 36 , , , 19768 257 37 there there RB 19768 257 38 universal universal JJ 19768 257 39 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 257 40 must must MD 19768 257 41 begin begin VB 19768 257 42 . . . 19768 258 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 258 2 is be VBZ 19768 258 3 the the DT 19768 258 4 task task NN 19768 258 5 of of IN 19768 258 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 258 7 to to NN 19768 258 8 - - HYPH 19768 258 9 day day NN 19768 258 10 to to TO 19768 258 11 show show VB 19768 258 12 that that IN 19768 258 13 the the DT 19768 258 14 unquestionably unquestionably JJ 19768 258 15 mechanical mechanical JJ 19768 258 16 constitution constitution NN 19768 258 17 of of IN 19768 258 18 the the DT 19768 258 19 universe universe NN 19768 258 20 , , , 19768 258 21 instead instead RB 19768 258 22 of of IN 19768 258 23 being be VBG 19768 258 24 the the DT 19768 258 25 ultimate ultimate JJ 19768 258 26 boundary boundary NN 19768 258 27 of of IN 19768 258 28 scientific scientific JJ 19768 258 29 investigation investigation NN 19768 258 30 , , , 19768 258 31 is be VBZ 19768 258 32 merely merely RB 19768 258 33 the the DT 19768 258 34 starting starting NN 19768 258 35 - - HYPH 19768 258 36 point point NN 19768 258 37 in in IN 19768 258 38 a a DT 19768 258 39 new new JJ 19768 258 40 series series NN 19768 258 41 of of IN 19768 258 42 investigations investigation NNS 19768 258 43 , , , 19768 258 44 no no RB 19768 258 45 less less RBR 19768 258 46 scientific scientific JJ 19768 258 47 than than IN 19768 258 48 those those DT 19768 258 49 of of IN 19768 258 50 physical physical JJ 19768 258 51 science science NN 19768 258 52 , , , 19768 258 53 but but CC 19768 258 54 far far RB 19768 258 55 more more RBR 19768 258 56 profound profound JJ 19768 258 57 ; ; : 19768 258 58 and and CC 19768 258 59 to to TO 19768 258 60 show show VB 19768 258 61 that that IN 19768 258 62 the the DT 19768 258 63 mechanical mechanical JJ 19768 258 64 constitution constitution NN 19768 258 65 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 258 66 , , , 19768 258 67 when when WRB 19768 258 68 deeply deeply RB 19768 258 69 studied study VBN 19768 258 70 and and CC 19768 258 71 comprehended comprehend VBD 19768 258 72 , , , 19768 258 73 necessarily necessarily RB 19768 258 74 involves involve VBZ 19768 258 75 the the DT 19768 258 76 organic organic JJ 19768 258 77 and and CC 19768 258 78 the the DT 19768 258 79 personal personal JJ 19768 258 80 constitutions constitution NNS 19768 258 81 . . . 19768 259 1 In in IN 19768 259 2 this this DT 19768 259 3 way way NN 19768 259 4 , , , 19768 259 5 and and CC 19768 259 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 259 7 believe believe VBP 19768 259 8 in in IN 19768 259 9 no no DT 19768 259 10 other other JJ 19768 259 11 way way NN 19768 259 12 , , , 19768 259 13 can can MD 19768 259 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 259 15 be be VB 19768 259 16 proved prove VBN 19768 259 17 to to IN 19768 259 18 the the DT 19768 259 19 satisfaction satisfaction NN 19768 259 20 of of IN 19768 259 21 the the DT 19768 259 22 modern modern JJ 19768 259 23 intelligence intelligence NN 19768 259 24 that that WDT 19768 259 25 the the DT 19768 259 26 Mechanical Mechanical NNP 19768 259 27 Real Real NNP 19768 259 28 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 259 29 , , , 19768 259 30 at at IN 19768 259 31 bottom bottom NN 19768 259 32 , , , 19768 259 33 includes include VBZ 19768 259 34 the the DT 19768 259 35 Ethical Ethical NNP 19768 259 36 Ideal Ideal NNP 19768 259 37 -- -- : 19768 259 38 that that IN 19768 259 39 the the DT 19768 259 40 Moral Moral NNP 19768 259 41 Law Law NNP 19768 259 42 , , , 19768 259 43 the the DT 19768 259 44 Divine Divine NNP 19768 259 45 Ideal Ideal NNP 19768 259 46 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 259 47 , , , 19768 259 48 is be VBZ 19768 259 49 the the DT 19768 259 50 innermost innermost NNP 19768 259 51 Fact Fact NNP 19768 259 52 of of IN 19768 259 53 Nature nature NN 19768 259 54 . . . 19768 260 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 260 2 have have VBP 19768 260 3 made make VBN 19768 260 4 , , , 19768 260 5 and and CC 19768 260 6 make make VB 19768 260 7 now now RB 19768 260 8 , , , 19768 260 9 not not RB 19768 260 10 the the DT 19768 260 11 slightest slight JJS 19768 260 12 personal personal JJ 19768 260 13 " " `` 19768 260 14 pretension pretension NN 19768 260 15 " " '' 19768 260 16 ; ; : 19768 260 17 but but CC 19768 260 18 , , , 19768 260 19 finding find VBG 19768 260 20 in in RP 19768 260 21 all all DT 19768 260 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 260 23 reading reading NN 19768 260 24 no no DT 19768 260 25 outline outline NN 19768 260 26 of of IN 19768 260 27 any any DT 19768 260 28 such such JJ 19768 260 29 argument argument NN 19768 260 30 as as IN 19768 260 31 this this DT 19768 260 32 , , , 19768 260 33 and and CC 19768 260 34 believing believe VBG 19768 260 35 it -PRON- PRP 19768 260 36 to to TO 19768 260 37 be be VB 19768 260 38 fruitful fruitful JJ 19768 260 39 of of IN 19768 260 40 the the DT 19768 260 41 very very RB 19768 260 42 noblest noble JJS 19768 260 43 results result NNS 19768 260 44 , , , 19768 260 45 I -PRON- PRP 19768 260 46 have have VBP 19768 260 47 done do VBN 19768 260 48 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 260 49 best good JJS 19768 260 50 to to TO 19768 260 51 point point VB 19768 260 52 out out RP 19768 260 53 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 260 54 possibilities possibility NNS 19768 260 55 to to IN 19768 260 56 other other JJ 19768 260 57 earnest earnest JJ 19768 260 58 searchers searcher NNS 19768 260 59 after after IN 19768 260 60 truth truth NN 19768 260 61 . . . 19768 261 1 Not not RB 19768 261 2 until until IN 19768 261 3 this this DT 19768 261 4 new new JJ 19768 261 5 field field NN 19768 261 6 has have VBZ 19768 261 7 been be VBN 19768 261 8 faithfully faithfully RB 19768 261 9 examined examine VBN 19768 261 10 and and CC 19768 261 11 explored explore VBN 19768 261 12 and and CC 19768 261 13 proved prove VBD 19768 261 14 to to TO 19768 261 15 be be VB 19768 261 16 sterile sterile JJ 19768 261 17 , , , 19768 261 18 shall shall MD 19768 261 19 I -PRON- PRP 19768 261 20 cease cease VB 19768 261 21 to to TO 19768 261 22 recommend recommend VB 19768 261 23 it -PRON- PRP 19768 261 24 to to IN 19768 261 25 the the DT 19768 261 26 attention attention NN 19768 261 27 of of IN 19768 261 28 all all DT 19768 261 29 who who WP 19768 261 30 would would MD 19768 261 31 fain fain VB 19768 261 32 _ _ NNP 19768 261 33 see see VB 19768 261 34 reason reason NN 19768 261 35 _ _ NNP 19768 261 36 to to TO 19768 261 37 believe believe VB 19768 261 38 that that IN 19768 261 39 the the DT 19768 261 40 Ethical Ethical NNP 19768 261 41 Ideal Ideal NNP 19768 261 42 is be VBZ 19768 261 43 no no DT 19768 261 44 Unreality Unreality NNP 19768 261 45 , , , 19768 261 46 but but CC 19768 261 47 rather rather RB 19768 261 48 the the DT 19768 261 49 innermost innermost JJS 19768 261 50 Reality reality NN 19768 261 51 of of IN 19768 261 52 the the DT 19768 261 53 real real JJ 19768 261 54 universe universe NN 19768 261 55 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 261 56 . . . 19768 262 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 262 2 speak speak VBP 19768 262 3 only only RB 19768 262 4 to to IN 19768 262 5 those those DT 19768 262 6 who who WP 19768 262 7 have have VBP 19768 262 8 souls soul NNS 19768 262 9 to to TO 19768 262 10 hear hear VB 19768 262 11 and and CC 19768 262 12 to to TO 19768 262 13 respond respond VB 19768 262 14 ; ; : 19768 262 15 let let VB 19768 262 16 the the DT 19768 262 17 rest rest NN 19768 262 18 listen listen VB 19768 262 19 to to IN 19768 262 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 262 21 Royce Royce NNP 19768 262 22 , , , 19768 262 23 and and CC 19768 262 24 be be VB 19768 262 25 dupes dupe NNS 19768 262 26 of of IN 19768 262 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 262 28 " " `` 19768 262 29 professional professional JJ 19768 262 30 warning warning NN 19768 262 31 . . . 19768 262 32 " " '' 19768 263 1 But but CC 19768 263 2 the the DT 19768 263 3 cause cause NN 19768 263 4 of of IN 19768 263 5 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 263 6 reform reform NN 19768 263 7 will will MD 19768 263 8 not not RB 19768 263 9 be be VB 19768 263 10 stayed stay VBN 19768 263 11 by by IN 19768 263 12 him -PRON- PRP 19768 263 13 or or CC 19768 263 14 by by IN 19768 263 15 them -PRON- PRP 19768 263 16 : : : 19768 263 17 the the DT 19768 263 18 world world NN 19768 263 19 's 's POS 19768 263 20 heart heart NN 19768 263 21 is be VBZ 19768 263 22 hungry hungry JJ 19768 263 23 for for IN 19768 263 24 higher high JJR 19768 263 25 truth truth NN 19768 263 26 than than IN 19768 263 27 idealism idealism NN 19768 263 28 can can MD 19768 263 29 discover discover VB 19768 263 30 , , , 19768 263 31 and and CC 19768 263 32 will will MD 19768 263 33 be be VB 19768 263 34 grateful grateful JJ 19768 263 35 in in IN 19768 263 36 the the DT 19768 263 37 end end NN 19768 263 38 to to IN 19768 263 39 any any DT 19768 263 40 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 263 41 which which WDT 19768 263 42 shall shall MD 19768 263 43 show show VB 19768 263 44 what what WP 19768 263 45 mighty mighty JJ 19768 263 46 moral moral JJ 19768 263 47 conviction conviction NN 19768 263 48 , , , 19768 263 49 what what WDT 19768 263 50 unspeakable unspeakable JJ 19768 263 51 spiritual spiritual JJ 19768 263 52 invigoration invigoration NN 19768 263 53 , , , 19768 263 54 must must MD 19768 263 55 needs need NNS 19768 263 56 grow grow VB 19768 263 57 out out IN 19768 263 58 of of IN 19768 263 59 comprehension comprehension NN 19768 263 60 of of IN 19768 263 61 the the DT 19768 263 62 despised despised JJ 19768 263 63 Real Real NNP 19768 263 64 . . . 19768 264 1 These these DT 19768 264 2 thoughts thought NNS 19768 264 3 are be VBP 19768 264 4 not not RB 19768 264 5 remote remote JJ 19768 264 6 abstractions abstraction NNS 19768 264 7 , , , 19768 264 8 up up RB 19768 264 9 in in IN 19768 264 10 the the DT 19768 264 11 air air NN 19768 264 12 , , , 19768 264 13 out out IN 19768 264 14 of of IN 19768 264 15 reach reach NN 19768 264 16 , , , 19768 264 17 of of IN 19768 264 18 no no DT 19768 264 19 practical practical JJ 19768 264 20 value value NN 19768 264 21 or or CC 19768 264 22 application application NN 19768 264 23 ; ; : 19768 264 24 they -PRON- PRP 19768 264 25 touch touch VBP 19768 264 26 the the DT 19768 264 27 very very JJ 19768 264 28 life life NN 19768 264 29 and and CC 19768 264 30 soul soul NN 19768 264 31 of of IN 19768 264 32 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 264 33 University University NNP 19768 264 34 . . . 19768 265 1 For for IN 19768 265 2 want want NN 19768 265 3 of of IN 19768 265 4 such such JJ 19768 265 5 thoughts thought NNS 19768 265 6 , , , 19768 265 7 many many JJ 19768 265 8 of of IN 19768 265 9 the the DT 19768 265 10 brightest bright JJS 19768 265 11 and and CC 19768 265 12 most most RBS 19768 265 13 intellectual intellectual JJ 19768 265 14 of of IN 19768 265 15 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 265 16 students student NNS 19768 265 17 , , , 19768 265 18 graduates graduate VBZ 19768 265 19 from from IN 19768 265 20 the the DT 19768 265 21 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 265 22 courses course NNS 19768 265 23 , , , 19768 265 24 go go VB 19768 265 25 out out RP 19768 265 26 year year NN 19768 265 27 after after IN 19768 265 28 year year NN 19768 265 29 disbelieving disbelieve VBG 19768 265 30 totally totally RB 19768 265 31 in in IN 19768 265 32 the the DT 19768 265 33 possibility possibility NN 19768 265 34 of of IN 19768 265 35 arriving arrive VBG 19768 265 36 at at IN 19768 265 37 any any DT 19768 265 38 fundamental fundamental JJ 19768 265 39 " " `` 19768 265 40 truth truth NN 19768 265 41 " " '' 19768 265 42 whatever whatever WDT 19768 265 43 , , , 19768 265 44 even even RB 19768 265 45 in in IN 19768 265 46 ethics ethic NNS 19768 265 47 . . . 19768 266 1 Several several JJ 19768 266 2 years year NNS 19768 266 3 ago ago RB 19768 266 4 , , , 19768 266 5 the the DT 19768 266 6 then then RB 19768 266 7 President President NNP 19768 266 8 of of IN 19768 266 9 the the DT 19768 266 10 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 266 11 " " `` 19768 266 12 Philosophical Philosophical NNP 19768 266 13 Club Club NNP 19768 266 14 " " '' 19768 266 15 said say VBD 19768 266 16 in in IN 19768 266 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 266 18 hearing hearing NN 19768 266 19 that that IN 19768 266 20 he -PRON- PRP 19768 266 21 " " `` 19768 266 22 saw see VBD 19768 266 23 no no DT 19768 266 24 ground ground NN 19768 266 25 of of IN 19768 266 26 moral moral JJ 19768 266 27 obligation obligation NN 19768 266 28 anywhere anywhere RB 19768 266 29 in in IN 19768 266 30 the the DT 19768 266 31 universe universe NN 19768 266 32 " " '' 19768 266 33 ; ; , 19768 266 34 and and CC 19768 266 35 this this DT 19768 266 36 declaration declaration NN 19768 266 37 was be VBD 19768 266 38 apparently apparently RB 19768 266 39 assented assent VBN 19768 266 40 to to IN 19768 266 41 by by IN 19768 266 42 every every DT 19768 266 43 one one CD 19768 266 44 of of IN 19768 266 45 the the DT 19768 266 46 fifteen fifteen CD 19768 266 47 or or CC 19768 266 48 twenty twenty CD 19768 266 49 members member NNS 19768 266 50 present present JJ 19768 266 51 . . . 19768 267 1 This this DT 19768 267 2 very very RB 19768 267 3 last last JJ 19768 267 4 summer summer NN 19768 267 5 , , , 19768 267 6 a a DT 19768 267 7 recent recent JJ 19768 267 8 graduate graduate NN 19768 267 9 told tell VBD 19768 267 10 me -PRON- PRP 19768 267 11 that that IN 19768 267 12 he -PRON- PRP 19768 267 13 left leave VBD 19768 267 14 college college NN 19768 267 15 bewildered bewildered NNP 19768 267 16 , , , 19768 267 17 depressed depressed JJ 19768 267 18 , , , 19768 267 19 and and CC 19768 267 20 " " `` 19768 267 21 disheartened dishearten VBN 19768 267 22 , , , 19768 267 23 " " '' 19768 267 24 because because IN 19768 267 25 he -PRON- PRP 19768 267 26 saw see VBD 19768 267 27 nowhere nowhere RB 19768 267 28 any any DT 19768 267 29 ground ground NN 19768 267 30 of of IN 19768 267 31 rational rational JJ 19768 267 32 " " `` 19768 267 33 conviction conviction NN 19768 267 34 " " '' 19768 267 35 about about IN 19768 267 36 anything anything NN 19768 267 37 ; ; : 19768 267 38 and and CC 19768 267 39 that that IN 19768 267 40 it -PRON- PRP 19768 267 41 was be VBD 19768 267 42 " " `` 19768 267 43 just just RB 19768 267 44 the the DT 19768 267 45 same same JJ 19768 267 46 with with IN 19768 267 47 all all PDT 19768 267 48 the the DT 19768 267 49 other other JJ 19768 267 50 fellows"--that fellows"--that NNP 19768 267 51 is be VBZ 19768 267 52 , , , 19768 267 53 all all PDT 19768 267 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 267 55 companions companion NNS 19768 267 56 in in IN 19768 267 57 the the DT 19768 267 58 study study NN 19768 267 59 of of IN 19768 267 60 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 267 61 . . . 19768 268 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 268 2 is be VBZ 19768 268 3 time time NN 19768 268 4 , , , 19768 268 5 high high JJ 19768 268 6 time time NN 19768 268 7 , , , 19768 268 8 that that IN 19768 268 9 this this DT 19768 268 10 state state NN 19768 268 11 of of IN 19768 268 12 things thing NNS 19768 268 13 should should MD 19768 268 14 be be VB 19768 268 15 searchingly searchingly RB 19768 268 16 investigated investigate VBN 19768 268 17 in in IN 19768 268 18 the the DT 19768 268 19 interest interest NN 19768 268 20 of of IN 19768 268 21 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 268 22 University University NNP 19768 268 23 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 268 24 , , , 19768 268 25 the the DT 19768 268 26 facts fact NNS 19768 268 27 determined determine VBD 19768 268 28 , , , 19768 268 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 268 30 causes cause NNS 19768 268 31 ascertained ascertain VBD 19768 268 32 . . . 19768 269 1 While while IN 19768 269 2 such such JJ 19768 269 3 a a DT 19768 269 4 state state NN 19768 269 5 of of IN 19768 269 6 things thing NNS 19768 269 7 prevails prevail NNS 19768 269 8 , , , 19768 269 9 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 269 10 conspicuously conspicuously RB 19768 269 11 fails fail VBZ 19768 269 12 to to TO 19768 269 13 be be VB 19768 269 14 a a DT 19768 269 15 " " `` 19768 269 16 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 269 17 pioneer pioneer NN 19768 269 18 " " '' 19768 269 19 except except IN 19768 269 20 in in IN 19768 269 21 a a DT 19768 269 22 distinctly distinctly RB 19768 269 23 retrograde retrograde NN 19768 269 24 direction direction NN 19768 269 25 -- -- : 19768 269 26 conspicuously conspicuously RB 19768 269 27 fails fail VBZ 19768 269 28 to to TO 19768 269 29 discharge discharge VB 19768 269 30 the the DT 19768 269 31 highest high JJS 19768 269 32 service service NN 19768 269 33 which which WDT 19768 269 34 she -PRON- PRP 19768 269 35 owes owe VBZ 19768 269 36 to to IN 19768 269 37 the the DT 19768 269 38 world world NN 19768 269 39 : : : 19768 269 40 namely namely RB 19768 269 41 , , , 19768 269 42 to to TO 19768 269 43 send send VB 19768 269 44 out out RP 19768 269 45 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 269 46 young young JJ 19768 269 47 graduates graduate NNS 19768 269 48 well well RB 19768 269 49 armed armed JJ 19768 269 50 beforehand beforehand RB 19768 269 51 for for IN 19768 269 52 the the DT 19768 269 53 battle battle NN 19768 269 54 of of IN 19768 269 55 life life NN 19768 269 56 with with IN 19768 269 57 clear clear JJ 19768 269 58 , , , 19768 269 59 strong strong JJ 19768 269 60 , , , 19768 269 61 and and CC 19768 269 62 lofty lofty JJ 19768 269 63 _ _ NNP 19768 269 64 moral moral JJ 19768 269 65 convictions conviction NNS 19768 269 66 _ _ NNP 19768 269 67 . . . 19768 270 1 Whatever whatever WDT 19768 270 2 other other JJ 19768 270 3 causes cause NNS 19768 270 4 may may MD 19768 270 5 exist exist VB 19768 270 6 for for IN 19768 270 7 the the DT 19768 270 8 failure failure NN 19768 270 9 , , , 19768 270 10 one one CD 19768 270 11 cause cause NN 19768 270 12 at at IN 19768 270 13 least least JJS 19768 270 14 is be VBZ 19768 270 15 certain certain JJ 19768 270 16 -- -- : 19768 270 17 the the DT 19768 270 18 self self NN 19768 270 19 - - HYPH 19768 270 20 proved proved JJ 19768 270 21 and and CC 19768 270 22 amazing amazing JJ 19768 270 23 inability inability NN 19768 270 24 of of IN 19768 270 25 one one CD 19768 270 26 of of IN 19768 270 27 her -PRON- PRP$ 19768 270 28 professors professor NNS 19768 270 29 of of IN 19768 270 30 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 270 31 to to TO 19768 270 32 give give VB 19768 270 33 an an DT 19768 270 34 honest honest JJ 19768 270 35 or or CC 19768 270 36 intelligent intelligent JJ 19768 270 37 reception reception NN 19768 270 38 to to IN 19768 270 39 a a DT 19768 270 40 thoughtful thoughtful JJ 19768 270 41 , , , 19768 270 42 closely closely RB 19768 270 43 reasoned reason VBN 19768 270 44 , , , 19768 270 45 and and CC 19768 270 46 earnest earnest JJ 19768 270 47 plea plea NN 19768 270 48 for for IN 19768 270 49 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 270 50 reform reform NN 19768 270 51 in in IN 19768 270 52 this this DT 19768 270 53 very very JJ 19768 270 54 direction direction NN 19768 270 55 , , , 19768 270 56 or or CC 19768 270 57 to to TO 19768 270 58 criticise criticise VB 19768 270 59 it -PRON- PRP 19768 270 60 with with IN 19768 270 61 anything anything NN 19768 270 62 better well JJR 19768 270 63 than than IN 19768 270 64 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 19768 270 65 and and CC 19768 270 66 unparliamentary unparliamentary JJ 19768 270 67 personalities personality NNS 19768 270 68 , , , 19768 270 69 studied studied JJ 19768 270 70 and and CC 19768 270 71 systematic systematic JJ 19768 270 72 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 270 73 both both DT 19768 270 74 of of IN 19768 270 75 the the DT 19768 270 76 plea plea NN 19768 270 77 and and CC 19768 270 78 of of IN 19768 270 79 the the DT 19768 270 80 pleader pleader NN 19768 270 81 , , , 19768 270 82 and and CC 19768 270 83 a a DT 19768 270 84 demoralizing demoralize VBG 19768 270 85 example example NN 19768 270 86 of of IN 19768 270 87 libel libel NN 19768 270 88 , , , 19768 270 89 so so RB 19768 270 90 bitter bitter JJ 19768 270 91 and and CC 19768 270 92 so so RB 19768 270 93 extreme extreme JJ 19768 270 94 as as IN 19768 270 95 to to TO 19768 270 96 furnish furnish VB 19768 270 97 abundant abundant JJ 19768 270 98 ground ground NN 19768 270 99 for for IN 19768 270 100 prosecution prosecution NN 19768 270 101 . . . 19768 271 1 VI VI NNP 19768 271 2 . . . 19768 272 1 Here here RB 19768 272 2 , , , 19768 272 3 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 272 4 , , , 19768 272 5 you -PRON- PRP 19768 272 6 may may MD 19768 272 7 very very RB 19768 272 8 properly properly RB 19768 272 9 inquire inquire VB 19768 272 10 : : : 19768 272 11 " " `` 19768 272 12 Why why WRB 19768 272 13 do do VBP 19768 272 14 you -PRON- PRP 19768 272 15 not not RB 19768 272 16 , , , 19768 272 17 then then RB 19768 272 18 , , , 19768 272 19 prosecute prosecute NN 19768 272 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 272 21 Royce Royce NNP 19768 272 22 in in IN 19768 272 23 the the DT 19768 272 24 courts court NNS 19768 272 25 , , , 19768 272 26 instead instead RB 19768 272 27 of of IN 19768 272 28 bringing bring VBG 19768 272 29 the the DT 19768 272 30 case case NN 19768 272 31 before before IN 19768 272 32 us -PRON- PRP 19768 272 33 ? ? . 19768 272 34 " " '' 19768 273 1 Briefly briefly RB 19768 273 2 , , , 19768 273 3 because because IN 19768 273 4 I -PRON- PRP 19768 273 5 have have VBP 19768 273 6 not not RB 19768 273 7 yet yet RB 19768 273 8 exhausted exhaust VBN 19768 273 9 those those DT 19768 273 10 milder milder NN 19768 273 11 means mean NNS 19768 273 12 of of IN 19768 273 13 obtaining obtain VBG 19768 273 14 redress redress NN 19768 273 15 which which WDT 19768 273 16 it -PRON- PRP 19768 273 17 befits befit VBZ 19768 273 18 a a DT 19768 273 19 peaceable peaceable JJ 19768 273 20 and and CC 19768 273 21 non non JJ 19768 273 22 - - JJ 19768 273 23 litigious litigious JJ 19768 273 24 citizen citizen NN 19768 273 25 to to TO 19768 273 26 employ employ VB 19768 273 27 before before IN 19768 273 28 resorting resort VBG 19768 273 29 to to IN 19768 273 30 legal legal JJ 19768 273 31 measures measure NNS 19768 273 32 . . . 19768 274 1 You -PRON- PRP 19768 274 2 would would MD 19768 274 3 have have VB 19768 274 4 had have VBD 19768 274 5 just just RB 19768 274 6 cause cause VB 19768 274 7 to to TO 19768 274 8 complain complain VB 19768 274 9 of of IN 19768 274 10 me -PRON- PRP 19768 274 11 , , , 19768 274 12 if if IN 19768 274 13 I -PRON- PRP 19768 274 14 had have VBD 19768 274 15 precipitately precipitately RB 19768 274 16 prosecuted prosecute VBN 19768 274 17 one one CD 19768 274 18 of of IN 19768 274 19 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 274 20 professors professor NNS 19768 274 21 for for IN 19768 274 22 a a DT 19768 274 23 " " `` 19768 274 24 professional professional JJ 19768 274 25 " " '' 19768 274 26 attack attack NN 19768 274 27 without without IN 19768 274 28 giving give VBG 19768 274 29 you -PRON- PRP 19768 274 30 previously previously RB 19768 274 31 an an DT 19768 274 32 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 274 33 to to TO 19768 274 34 discipline discipline VB 19768 274 35 him -PRON- PRP 19768 274 36 in in IN 19768 274 37 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 274 38 own own JJ 19768 274 39 way way NN 19768 274 40 , , , 19768 274 41 and and CC 19768 274 42 in in IN 19768 274 43 dignified dignified JJ 19768 274 44 recognition recognition NN 19768 274 45 of of IN 19768 274 46 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 274 47 own own JJ 19768 274 48 ultimate ultimate JJ 19768 274 49 responsibility responsibility NN 19768 274 50 . . . 19768 275 1 A a DT 19768 275 2 prosecution prosecution NN 19768 275 3 may may MD 19768 275 4 not not RB 19768 275 5 , , , 19768 275 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 275 7 trust trust VBP 19768 275 8 will will MD 19768 275 9 not not RB 19768 275 10 , , , 19768 275 11 prove prove VB 19768 275 12 necessary necessary JJ 19768 275 13 ; ; : 19768 275 14 for for IN 19768 275 15 I -PRON- PRP 19768 275 16 have have VBP 19768 275 17 neither neither CC 19768 275 18 malice malice NN 19768 275 19 nor nor CC 19768 275 20 vindictiveness vindictiveness NN 19768 275 21 to to TO 19768 275 22 gratify gratify VB 19768 275 23 , , , 19768 275 24 but but CC 19768 275 25 only only RB 19768 275 26 a a DT 19768 275 27 resolute resolute JJ 19768 275 28 purpose purpose NN 19768 275 29 to to TO 19768 275 30 defend defend VB 19768 275 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 275 32 reputation reputation NN 19768 275 33 effectually effectually RB 19768 275 34 against against IN 19768 275 35 a a DT 19768 275 36 malicious malicious JJ 19768 275 37 libel libel NN 19768 275 38 , , , 19768 275 39 and and CC 19768 275 40 not not RB 19768 275 41 to to TO 19768 275 42 permit permit VB 19768 275 43 the the DT 19768 275 44 libeller libeller NN 19768 275 45 to to TO 19768 275 46 set set VB 19768 275 47 up up RP 19768 275 48 a a DT 19768 275 49 plausible plausible JJ 19768 275 50 claim claim NN 19768 275 51 that that IN 19768 275 52 , , , 19768 275 53 by by IN 19768 275 54 silence silence NN 19768 275 55 and and CC 19768 275 56 passive passive JJ 19768 275 57 submission submission NN 19768 275 58 , , , 19768 275 59 I -PRON- PRP 19768 275 60 " " `` 19768 275 61 tacitly tacitly RB 19768 275 62 confess confess JJ 19768 275 63 the the DT 19768 275 64 justice justice NN 19768 275 65 of of IN 19768 275 66 an an DT 19768 275 67 official official JJ 19768 275 68 condemnation condemnation NN 19768 275 69 by by IN 19768 275 70 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 275 71 University University NNP 19768 275 72 of of IN 19768 275 73 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 275 74 ' ' `` 19768 275 75 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 275 76 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 275 77 . . . 19768 275 78 ' ' '' 19768 275 79 " " '' 19768 276 1 Except except IN 19768 276 2 for for IN 19768 276 3 that that DT 19768 276 4 one one CD 19768 276 5 phrase phrase NN 19768 276 6 , , , 19768 276 7 " " `` 19768 276 8 professional professional JJ 19768 276 9 warning warning NN 19768 276 10 , , , 19768 276 11 " " '' 19768 276 12 in in IN 19768 276 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 276 14 Royce Royce NNP 19768 276 15 's 's POS 19768 276 16 attack attack NN 19768 276 17 , , , 19768 276 18 this this DT 19768 276 19 appeal appeal NN 19768 276 20 would would MD 19768 276 21 never never RB 19768 276 22 have have VB 19768 276 23 been be VBN 19768 276 24 written write VBN 19768 276 25 , , , 19768 276 26 or or CC 19768 276 27 the the DT 19768 276 28 least least JJS 19768 276 29 notice notice NN 19768 276 30 taken take VBN 19768 276 31 of of IN 19768 276 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 276 33 intrinsically intrinsically RB 19768 276 34 puerile puerile JJ 19768 276 35 " " '' 19768 276 36 criticisms criticism NNS 19768 276 37 . . . 19768 276 38 " " '' 19768 277 1 When when WRB 19768 277 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 277 3 Herbert Herbert NNP 19768 277 4 Spencer Spencer NNP 19768 277 5 , , , 19768 277 6 whom whom WP 19768 277 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 277 8 have have VBP 19768 277 9 more more JJR 19768 277 10 than than IN 19768 277 11 once once RB 19768 277 12 publicly publicly RB 19768 277 13 criticised criticise VBN 19768 277 14 , , , 19768 277 15 can can MD 19768 277 16 yet yet RB 19768 277 17 magnanimously magnanimously RB 19768 277 18 write write VB 19768 277 19 to to IN 19768 277 20 me -PRON- PRP 19768 277 21 of of IN 19768 277 22 this this DT 19768 277 23 very very JJ 19768 277 24 book book NN 19768 277 25 , , , 19768 277 26 " " `` 19768 277 27 I -PRON- PRP 19768 277 28 do do VBP 19768 277 29 not not RB 19768 277 30 see see VB 19768 277 31 any any DT 19768 277 32 probability probability NN 19768 277 33 that that IN 19768 277 34 it -PRON- PRP 19768 277 35 will will MD 19768 277 36 change change VB 19768 277 37 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 277 38 beliefs belief NNS 19768 277 39 , , , 19768 277 40 yet yet CC 19768 277 41 I -PRON- PRP 19768 277 42 rejoice rejoice VBP 19768 277 43 that that IN 19768 277 44 the the DT 19768 277 45 subject subject NN 19768 277 46 should should MD 19768 277 47 be be VB 19768 277 48 so so RB 19768 277 49 well well RB 19768 277 50 discussed,"--and discussed,"--and JJ 19768 277 51 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 277 52 William William NNP 19768 277 53 Ewart Ewart NNP 19768 277 54 Gladstone Gladstone NNP 19768 277 55 , , , 19768 277 56 " " `` 19768 277 57 I -PRON- PRP 19768 277 58 am be VBP 19768 277 59 very very RB 19768 277 60 conscious conscious JJ 19768 277 61 of of IN 19768 277 62 the the DT 19768 277 63 force force NN 19768 277 64 with with IN 19768 277 65 which which WDT 19768 277 66 you -PRON- PRP 19768 277 67 handle handle VBP 19768 277 68 the the DT 19768 277 69 subject,"--and subject,"--and JJ 19768 277 70 ex ex NNP 19768 277 71 - - JJ 19768 277 72 President President NNP 19768 277 73 Noah Noah NNP 19768 277 74 Porter Porter NNP 19768 277 75 , , , 19768 277 76 " " `` 19768 277 77 I -PRON- PRP 19768 277 78 thank thank VBP 19768 277 79 you -PRON- PRP 19768 277 80 very very RB 19768 277 81 sincerely sincerely RB 19768 277 82 for for IN 19768 277 83 sending send VBG 19768 277 84 me -PRON- PRP 19768 277 85 a a DT 19768 277 86 copy copy NN 19768 277 87 of of IN 19768 277 88 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 277 89 last last JJ 19768 277 90 book book NN 19768 277 91 ; ; : 19768 277 92 I -PRON- PRP 19768 277 93 had have VBD 19768 277 94 already already RB 19768 277 95 read read VBN 19768 277 96 it -PRON- PRP 19768 277 97 nearly nearly RB 19768 277 98 twice twice RB 19768 277 99 , , , 19768 277 100 and and CC 19768 277 101 found find VBD 19768 277 102 much much JJ 19768 277 103 in in IN 19768 277 104 it -PRON- PRP 19768 277 105 very very RB 19768 277 106 admirable admirable JJ 19768 277 107 and and CC 19768 277 108 timely,"--I timely,"--i NN 19768 277 109 could could MD 19768 277 110 very very RB 19768 277 111 well well RB 19768 277 112 afford afford VB 19768 277 113 to to TO 19768 277 114 pass pass VB 19768 277 115 over over RP 19768 277 116 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 277 117 Royce Royce NNP 19768 277 118 's 's POS 19768 277 119 ineffectual ineffectual JJ 19768 277 120 " " `` 19768 277 121 criticisms criticism NNS 19768 277 122 " " '' 19768 277 123 with with IN 19768 277 124 indifference indifference NN 19768 277 125 . . . 19768 278 1 But but CC 19768 278 2 when when WRB 19768 278 3 he -PRON- PRP 19768 278 4 insinuates insinuate VBZ 19768 278 5 to to IN 19768 278 6 the the DT 19768 278 7 uninformed uninformed JJ 19768 278 8 public public NN 19768 278 9 that that IN 19768 278 10 these these DT 19768 278 11 same same JJ 19768 278 12 " " `` 19768 278 13 criticisms criticism NNS 19768 278 14 " " '' 19768 278 15 have have VBP 19768 278 16 the the DT 19768 278 17 weighty weighty JJ 19768 278 18 sanction sanction NN 19768 278 19 of of IN 19768 278 20 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 278 21 University University NNP 19768 278 22 , , , 19768 278 23 it -PRON- PRP 19768 278 24 is be VBZ 19768 278 25 quite quite PDT 19768 278 26 another another DT 19768 278 27 matter matter NN 19768 278 28 . . . 19768 279 1 That that DT 19768 279 2 calls call VBZ 19768 279 3 upon upon IN 19768 279 4 me -PRON- PRP 19768 279 5 to to TO 19768 279 6 defend defend VB 19768 279 7 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 279 8 against against IN 19768 279 9 so so RB 19768 279 10 atrocious atrocious JJ 19768 279 11 a a DT 19768 279 12 calumny calumny NN 19768 279 13 . . . 19768 280 1 But but CC 19768 280 2 even even RB 19768 280 3 self self NN 19768 280 4 - - HYPH 19768 280 5 defence defence NN 19768 280 6 has have VBZ 19768 280 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 280 8 proprieties propriety NNS 19768 280 9 , , , 19768 280 10 and and CC 19768 280 11 to to IN 19768 280 12 these these DT 19768 280 13 I -PRON- PRP 19768 280 14 scrupulously scrupulously RB 19768 280 15 submit submit VBP 19768 280 16 . . . 19768 281 1 The the DT 19768 281 2 first first JJ 19768 281 3 step step NN 19768 281 4 was be VBD 19768 281 5 to to TO 19768 281 6 send send VB 19768 281 7 a a DT 19768 281 8 reply reply NN 19768 281 9 to to IN 19768 281 10 the the DT 19768 281 11 periodical periodical NN 19768 281 12 which which WDT 19768 281 13 published publish VBD 19768 281 14 the the DT 19768 281 15 attack attack NN 19768 281 16 . . . 19768 282 1 This this DT 19768 282 2 was be VBD 19768 282 3 sent send VBN 19768 282 4 . . . 19768 283 1 At at IN 19768 283 2 first first RB 19768 283 3 , , , 19768 283 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 283 5 Royce Royce NNP 19768 283 6 effusively effusively RB 19768 283 7 agreed agree VBD 19768 283 8 to to IN 19768 283 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 283 10 publication publication NN 19768 283 11 , , , 19768 283 12 and and CC 19768 283 13 wrote write VBD 19768 283 14 a a DT 19768 283 15 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 283 16 to to TO 19768 283 17 be be VB 19768 283 18 published publish VBN 19768 283 19 simultaneously simultaneously RB 19768 283 20 with with IN 19768 283 21 it -PRON- PRP 19768 283 22 . . . 19768 284 1 Later later RB 19768 284 2 , , , 19768 284 3 in in IN 19768 284 4 alarm alarm NN 19768 284 5 , , , 19768 284 6 he -PRON- PRP 19768 284 7 procured procure VBD 19768 284 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 284 9 rejection rejection NN 19768 284 10 , , , 19768 284 11 and and CC 19768 284 12 , , , 19768 284 13 through through IN 19768 284 14 legal legal JJ 19768 284 15 counsel counsel NN 19768 284 16 , , , 19768 284 17 served serve VBD 19768 284 18 a a DT 19768 284 19 formal formal JJ 19768 284 20 notice notice NN 19768 284 21 upon upon IN 19768 284 22 me -PRON- PRP 19768 284 23 not not RB 19768 284 24 to to TO 19768 284 25 publish publish VB 19768 284 26 or or CC 19768 284 27 to to TO 19768 284 28 circulate circulate VB 19768 284 29 it -PRON- PRP 19768 284 30 at at RB 19768 284 31 all all RB 19768 284 32 . . . 19768 285 1 The the DT 19768 285 2 second second JJ 19768 285 3 step step NN 19768 285 4 was be VBD 19768 285 5 to to TO 19768 285 6 demand demand VB 19768 285 7 from from IN 19768 285 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 285 9 Royce Royce NNP 19768 285 10 a a DT 19768 285 11 specific specific JJ 19768 285 12 retraction retraction NN 19768 285 13 and and CC 19768 285 14 apology apology NN 19768 285 15 ; ; : 19768 285 16 this this DT 19768 285 17 he -PRON- PRP 19768 285 18 contemptuously contemptuously RB 19768 285 19 refused refuse VBD 19768 285 20 . . . 19768 286 1 The the DT 19768 286 2 third third JJ 19768 286 3 step step NN 19768 286 4 was be VBD 19768 286 5 to to TO 19768 286 6 appeal appeal VB 19768 286 7 from from IN 19768 286 8 the the DT 19768 286 9 recalcitrant recalcitrant JJ 19768 286 10 employee employee NN 19768 286 11 to to IN 19768 286 12 the the DT 19768 286 13 responsible responsible JJ 19768 286 14 employer employer NN 19768 286 15 , , , 19768 286 16 and and CC 19768 286 17 to to TO 19768 286 18 lay lay VB 19768 286 19 the the DT 19768 286 20 case case NN 19768 286 21 respectfully respectfully RB 19768 286 22 before before IN 19768 286 23 the the DT 19768 286 24 supreme supreme NNP 19768 286 25 representatives representatives NNPS 19768 286 26 of of IN 19768 286 27 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 286 28 University University NNP 19768 286 29 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 286 30 . . . 19768 287 1 This this DT 19768 287 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 287 3 now now RB 19768 287 4 do do VBP 19768 287 5 , , , 19768 287 6 and and CC 19768 287 7 it -PRON- PRP 19768 287 8 is be VBZ 19768 287 9 entirely entirely RB 19768 287 10 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19768 287 11 to to TO 19768 287 12 look look VB 19768 287 13 any any DT 19768 287 14 farther farther RB 19768 287 15 . . . 19768 288 1 But but CC 19768 288 2 , , , 19768 288 3 in in IN 19768 288 4 order order NN 19768 288 5 to to TO 19768 288 6 lay lay VB 19768 288 7 the the DT 19768 288 8 case case NN 19768 288 9 before before IN 19768 288 10 you -PRON- PRP 19768 288 11 fully fully RB 19768 288 12 , , , 19768 288 13 it -PRON- PRP 19768 288 14 is be VBZ 19768 288 15 incumbent incumbent JJ 19768 288 16 upon upon IN 19768 288 17 me -PRON- PRP 19768 288 18 to to TO 19768 288 19 state state VB 19768 288 20 the the DT 19768 288 21 details detail NNS 19768 288 22 of of IN 19768 288 23 these these DT 19768 288 24 proceedings proceeding NNS 19768 288 25 with with IN 19768 288 26 some some DT 19768 288 27 minuteness minuteness NN 19768 288 28 , , , 19768 288 29 and and CC 19768 288 30 I -PRON- PRP 19768 288 31 now now RB 19768 288 32 proceed proceed VBP 19768 288 33 to to TO 19768 288 34 unfold unfold VB 19768 288 35 the the DT 19768 288 36 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19768 288 37 tale tale NN 19768 288 38 . . . 19768 289 1 VII VII NNP 19768 289 2 . . . 19768 290 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 290 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 290 3 wound wind VBD 19768 290 4 up up RP 19768 290 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 290 6 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 290 7 review review NN 19768 290 8 with with IN 19768 290 9 these these DT 19768 290 10 words word NNS 19768 290 11 of of IN 19768 290 12 bravado bravado NNP 19768 290 13 and and CC 19768 290 14 of of IN 19768 290 15 challenge challenge NN 19768 290 16 : : : 19768 290 17 " " `` 19768 290 18 _ _ NNP 19768 290 19 We -PRON- PRP 19768 290 20 must must MD 19768 290 21 show show VB 19768 290 22 no no DT 19768 290 23 mercy,--as mercy,--as NN 19768 290 24 we -PRON- PRP 19768 290 25 ask ask VBP 19768 290 26 none none NN 19768 290 27 . . . 19768 290 28 _ _ NNP 19768 290 29 " " `` 19768 290 30 This this DT 19768 290 31 fierce fierce JJ 19768 290 32 flourish flourish NN 19768 290 33 of of IN 19768 290 34 trumpets trumpet NNS 19768 290 35 I -PRON- PRP 19768 290 36 understood understand VBD 19768 290 37 to to TO 19768 290 38 be be VB 19768 290 39 , , , 19768 290 40 at at IN 19768 290 41 least least JJS 19768 290 42 , , , 19768 290 43 a a DT 19768 290 44 fearless fearless JJ 19768 290 45 public public JJ 19768 290 46 pledge pledge NN 19768 290 47 of of IN 19768 290 48 a a DT 19768 290 49 fair fair JJ 19768 290 50 hearing hearing NN 19768 290 51 in in IN 19768 290 52 the the DT 19768 290 53 " " `` 19768 290 54 Journal Journal NNP 19768 290 55 of of IN 19768 290 56 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 290 57 " " '' 19768 290 58 of of IN 19768 290 59 which which WDT 19768 290 60 he -PRON- PRP 19768 290 61 was be VBD 19768 290 62 one one CD 19768 290 63 of of IN 19768 290 64 the the DT 19768 290 65 editors editor NNS 19768 290 66 . . . 19768 291 1 Moreover moreover RB 19768 291 2 , , , 19768 291 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 291 4 conceived conceive VBD 19768 291 5 that that IN 19768 291 6 a a DT 19768 291 7 magazine magazine NN 19768 291 8 expressly expressly RB 19768 291 9 devoted devote VBN 19768 291 10 to to IN 19768 291 11 ethics ethic NNS 19768 291 12 would would MD 19768 291 13 be be VB 19768 291 14 ashamed ashamed JJ 19768 291 15 not not RB 19768 291 16 to to TO 19768 291 17 practise practise VB 19768 291 18 the the DT 19768 291 19 ethics ethic NNS 19768 291 20 which which WDT 19768 291 21 it -PRON- PRP 19768 291 22 preached preach VBD 19768 291 23 -- -- : 19768 291 24 ashamed ashamed JJ 19768 291 25 not not RB 19768 291 26 to to TO 19768 291 27 grant grant VB 19768 291 28 to to IN 19768 291 29 the the DT 19768 291 30 accused accuse VBN 19768 291 31 a a DT 19768 291 32 freedom freedom NN 19768 291 33 scrupulously scrupulously RB 19768 291 34 made make VBN 19768 291 35 equal equal JJ 19768 291 36 to to IN 19768 291 37 that that DT 19768 291 38 which which WDT 19768 291 39 it -PRON- PRP 19768 291 40 had have VBD 19768 291 41 already already RB 19768 291 42 granted grant VBN 19768 291 43 to to IN 19768 291 44 the the DT 19768 291 45 accuser accuser NN 19768 291 46 . . . 19768 292 1 Lastly lastly RB 19768 292 2 , , , 19768 292 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 292 4 was be VBD 19768 292 5 averse averse JJ 19768 292 6 to to IN 19768 292 7 litigation litigation NN 19768 292 8 , , , 19768 292 9 and and CC 19768 292 10 desired desire VBN 19768 292 11 to to TO 19768 292 12 use use VB 19768 292 13 no no DT 19768 292 14 coarser coarser NN 19768 292 15 weapon weapon NN 19768 292 16 , , , 19768 292 17 even even RB 19768 292 18 against against IN 19768 292 19 a a DT 19768 292 20 calumniator calumniator NN 19768 292 21 and and CC 19768 292 22 libeller libeller NNP 19768 292 23 , , , 19768 292 24 than than IN 19768 292 25 the the DT 19768 292 26 sharp sharp JJ 19768 292 27 edge edge NN 19768 292 28 of of IN 19768 292 29 reason reason NN 19768 292 30 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 292 31 . . . 19768 293 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19768 293 2 , , , 19768 293 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 293 4 sought seek VBD 19768 293 5 redress redress NN 19768 293 6 in in IN 19768 293 7 the the DT 19768 293 8 first first JJ 19768 293 9 instance instance NN 19768 293 10 from from IN 19768 293 11 the the DT 19768 293 12 " " `` 19768 293 13 International International NNP 19768 293 14 Journal Journal NNP 19768 293 15 of of IN 19768 293 16 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 293 17 . . . 19768 293 18 " " '' 19768 294 1 On on IN 19768 294 2 January January NNP 19768 294 3 21 21 CD 19768 294 4 , , , 19768 294 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 294 6 mailed mail VBD 19768 294 7 to to IN 19768 294 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 294 9 S. S. NNP 19768 294 10 Burns Burns NNP 19768 294 11 Weston Weston NNP 19768 294 12 , , , 19768 294 13 the the DT 19768 294 14 office office NN 19768 294 15 editor editor NN 19768 294 16 , , , 19768 294 17 an an DT 19768 294 18 article article NN 19768 294 19 in in IN 19768 294 20 reply reply NN 19768 294 21 to to IN 19768 294 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 294 23 Royce Royce NNP 19768 294 24 's 's POS 19768 294 25 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 294 26 review review NN 19768 294 27 , , , 19768 294 28 together together RB 19768 294 29 with with IN 19768 294 30 a a DT 19768 294 31 letter letter NN 19768 294 32 in in IN 19768 294 33 which which WDT 19768 294 34 I -PRON- PRP 19768 294 35 wrote write VBD 19768 294 36 : : : 19768 294 37 " " `` 19768 294 38 I -PRON- PRP 19768 294 39 do do VBP 19768 294 40 not not RB 19768 294 41 at at RB 19768 294 42 all all RB 19768 294 43 complain complain VB 19768 294 44 of of IN 19768 294 45 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 294 46 publishing publishing NN 19768 294 47 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 294 48 Royce Royce NNP 19768 294 49 's 's POS 19768 294 50 original original JJ 19768 294 51 article article NN 19768 294 52 , , , 19768 294 53 although although IN 19768 294 54 it -PRON- PRP 19768 294 55 was be VBD 19768 294 56 a a DT 19768 294 57 most most RBS 19768 294 58 malicious malicious JJ 19768 294 59 and and CC 19768 294 60 slanderous slanderous JJ 19768 294 61 one one CD 19768 294 62 , , , 19768 294 63 and and CC 19768 294 64 undertook undertake VBD 19768 294 65 ( ( -LRB- 19768 294 66 not not RB 19768 294 67 to to TO 19768 294 68 put put VB 19768 294 69 too too RB 19768 294 70 fine fine JJ 19768 294 71 a a DT 19768 294 72 point point NN 19768 294 73 upon upon IN 19768 294 74 it -PRON- PRP 19768 294 75 ) ) -RRB- 19768 294 76 to to TO 19768 294 77 post post VB 19768 294 78 me -PRON- PRP 19768 294 79 publicly publicly RB 19768 294 80 as as IN 19768 294 81 a a DT 19768 294 82 quack quack NN 19768 294 83 . . . 19768 295 1 If if IN 19768 295 2 you -PRON- PRP 19768 295 3 do do VBP 19768 295 4 not not RB 19768 295 5 deny deny VB 19768 295 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 295 7 indefeasible indefeasible JJ 19768 295 8 right right NN 19768 295 9 to to TO 19768 295 10 be be VB 19768 295 11 heard hear VBN 19768 295 12 in in IN 19768 295 13 self self NN 19768 295 14 - - HYPH 19768 295 15 defence defence NN 19768 295 16 in in IN 19768 295 17 the the DT 19768 295 18 same same JJ 19768 295 19 columns column NNS 19768 295 20 , , , 19768 295 21 I -PRON- PRP 19768 295 22 shall shall MD 19768 295 23 feel feel VB 19768 295 24 that that IN 19768 295 25 I -PRON- PRP 19768 295 26 have have VBP 19768 295 27 no no DT 19768 295 28 cause cause NN 19768 295 29 whatever whatever WDT 19768 295 30 to to TO 19768 295 31 regard regard VB 19768 295 32 you -PRON- PRP 19768 295 33 or or CC 19768 295 34 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 295 35 committee committee NN 19768 295 36 as as IN 19768 295 37 a a DT 19768 295 38 party party NN 19768 295 39 to to IN 19768 295 40 the the DT 19768 295 41 outrage outrage NN 19768 295 42 , , , 19768 295 43 and and CC 19768 295 44 shall shall MD 19768 295 45 entertain entertain VB 19768 295 46 no no DT 19768 295 47 feelings feeling NNS 19768 295 48 towards towards IN 19768 295 49 you -PRON- PRP 19768 295 50 or or CC 19768 295 51 towards towards IN 19768 295 52 them -PRON- PRP 19768 295 53 other other JJ 19768 295 54 than than IN 19768 295 55 such such JJ 19768 295 56 as as IN 19768 295 57 are be VBP 19768 295 58 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 295 59 friendly friendly JJ 19768 295 60 . . . 19768 296 1 Let let VB 19768 296 2 even even RB 19768 296 3 slander slander VB 19768 296 4 and and CC 19768 296 5 malice malice NN 19768 296 6 be be VB 19768 296 7 heard hear VBN 19768 296 8 , , , 19768 296 9 if if IN 19768 296 10 truth truth NN 19768 296 11 shall shall MD 19768 296 12 be be VB 19768 296 13 as as RB 19768 296 14 free free JJ 19768 296 15 to to TO 19768 296 16 reply reply VB 19768 296 17 . . . 19768 296 18 " " '' 19768 297 1 Pressing pressing NN 19768 297 2 engagements engagement NNS 19768 297 3 had have VBD 19768 297 4 prevented prevent VBN 19768 297 5 me -PRON- PRP 19768 297 6 from from IN 19768 297 7 writing write VBG 19768 297 8 the the DT 19768 297 9 article article NN 19768 297 10 in in IN 19768 297 11 season season NN 19768 297 12 for for IN 19768 297 13 the the DT 19768 297 14 January January NNP 19768 297 15 number number NN 19768 297 16 of of IN 19768 297 17 the the DT 19768 297 18 " " `` 19768 297 19 Journal Journal NNP 19768 297 20 of of IN 19768 297 21 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 297 22 , , , 19768 297 23 " " '' 19768 297 24 but but CC 19768 297 25 it -PRON- PRP 19768 297 26 was be VBD 19768 297 27 in in IN 19768 297 28 ample ample JJ 19768 297 29 season season NN 19768 297 30 for for IN 19768 297 31 the the DT 19768 297 32 April April NNP 19768 297 33 number number NN 19768 297 34 . . . 19768 298 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 298 2 sent send VBD 19768 298 3 it -PRON- PRP 19768 298 4 at at IN 19768 298 5 last last RB 19768 298 6 because because IN 19768 298 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 298 8 had have VBD 19768 298 9 full full JJ 19768 298 10 confidence confidence NN 19768 298 11 in in IN 19768 298 12 the the DT 19768 298 13 soundness soundness NN 19768 298 14 of of IN 19768 298 15 what what WP 19768 298 16 Thomas Thomas NNP 19768 298 17 Jefferson Jefferson NNP 19768 298 18 said say VBD 19768 298 19 so so RB 19768 298 20 well well RB 19768 298 21 : : : 19768 298 22 " " `` 19768 298 23 Truth truth NN 19768 298 24 and and CC 19768 298 25 reason reason NN 19768 298 26 can can MD 19768 298 27 maintain maintain VB 19768 298 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 19768 298 29 without without IN 19768 298 30 the the DT 19768 298 31 aid aid NN 19768 298 32 of of IN 19768 298 33 coercion coercion NN 19768 298 34 , , , 19768 298 35 if if IN 19768 298 36 left leave VBD 19768 298 37 free free JJ 19768 298 38 to to TO 19768 298 39 defend defend VB 19768 298 40 themselves -PRON- PRP 19768 298 41 . . . 19768 299 1 But but CC 19768 299 2 then then RB 19768 299 3 they -PRON- PRP 19768 299 4 must must MD 19768 299 5 defend defend VB 19768 299 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19768 299 7 . . . 19768 300 1 Eternal eternal JJ 19768 300 2 lies lie NNS 19768 300 3 and and CC 19768 300 4 sophisms sophism NNS 19768 300 5 on on IN 19768 300 6 one one CD 19768 300 7 side side NN 19768 300 8 , , , 19768 300 9 and and CC 19768 300 10 silence silence NN 19768 300 11 on on IN 19768 300 12 the the DT 19768 300 13 other other JJ 19768 300 14 , , , 19768 300 15 are be VBP 19768 300 16 too too RB 19768 300 17 unequal unequal JJ 19768 300 18 . . . 19768 300 19 " " '' 19768 301 1 The the DT 19768 301 2 " " `` 19768 301 3 International International NNP 19768 301 4 Journal Journal NNP 19768 301 5 of of IN 19768 301 6 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 301 7 " " '' 19768 301 8 is be VBZ 19768 301 9 under under IN 19768 301 10 the the DT 19768 301 11 control control NN 19768 301 12 of of IN 19768 301 13 an an DT 19768 301 14 " " `` 19768 301 15 editorial editorial JJ 19768 301 16 committee committee NN 19768 301 17 " " '' 19768 301 18 of of IN 19768 301 19 eight eight CD 19768 301 20 , , , 19768 301 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 301 22 Felix Felix NNP 19768 301 23 Adler Adler NNP 19768 301 24 at at IN 19768 301 25 the the DT 19768 301 26 head head NN 19768 301 27 and and CC 19768 301 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 301 29 Royce Royce NNP 19768 301 30 at at IN 19768 301 31 the the DT 19768 301 32 end end NN 19768 301 33 ; ; : 19768 301 34 the the DT 19768 301 35 other other JJ 19768 301 36 six six CD 19768 301 37 members member NNS 19768 301 38 live live VBP 19768 301 39 in in IN 19768 301 40 Europe Europe NNP 19768 301 41 and and CC 19768 301 42 have have VB 19768 301 43 no no DT 19768 301 44 share share NN 19768 301 45 in in IN 19768 301 46 the the DT 19768 301 47 home home NN 19768 301 48 management management NN 19768 301 49 . . . 19768 302 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 302 2 Weston Weston NNP 19768 302 3 is be VBZ 19768 302 4 not not RB 19768 302 5 a a DT 19768 302 6 member member NN 19768 302 7 of of IN 19768 302 8 the the DT 19768 302 9 committee committee NN 19768 302 10 , , , 19768 302 11 has have VBZ 19768 302 12 little little JJ 19768 302 13 editorial editorial JJ 19768 302 14 authority authority NN 19768 302 15 , , , 19768 302 16 and and CC 19768 302 17 , , , 19768 302 18 in in IN 19768 302 19 case case NN 19768 302 20 of of IN 19768 302 21 disagreement disagreement NN 19768 302 22 between between IN 19768 302 23 the the DT 19768 302 24 two two CD 19768 302 25 American american JJ 19768 302 26 members member NNS 19768 302 27 , , , 19768 302 28 would would MD 19768 302 29 , , , 19768 302 30 as as IN 19768 302 31 he -PRON- PRP 19768 302 32 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 302 33 expressly expressly RB 19768 302 34 and and CC 19768 302 35 frankly frankly RB 19768 302 36 informed inform VBD 19768 302 37 me -PRON- PRP 19768 302 38 in in IN 19768 302 39 answer answer NN 19768 302 40 to to IN 19768 302 41 a a DT 19768 302 42 direct direct JJ 19768 302 43 question question NN 19768 302 44 , , , 19768 302 45 obey obey VBP 19768 302 46 implicitly implicitly RB 19768 302 47 the the DT 19768 302 48 directions direction NNS 19768 302 49 of of IN 19768 302 50 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 302 51 Adler Adler NNP 19768 302 52 . . . 19768 303 1 To to IN 19768 303 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 303 3 Adler Adler NNP 19768 303 4 , , , 19768 303 5 therefore therefore RB 19768 303 6 , , , 19768 303 7 belongs belong VBZ 19768 303 8 the the DT 19768 303 9 general general JJ 19768 303 10 and and CC 19768 303 11 ultimate ultimate JJ 19768 303 12 editorial editorial JJ 19768 303 13 responsibility responsibility NN 19768 303 14 , , , 19768 303 15 whether whether IN 19768 303 16 legal legal JJ 19768 303 17 or or CC 19768 303 18 moral moral JJ 19768 303 19 , , , 19768 303 20 since since IN 19768 303 21 , , , 19768 303 22 according accord VBG 19768 303 23 to to IN 19768 303 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 303 25 Western Western NNP 19768 303 26 's 's POS 19768 303 27 just just RB 19768 303 28 quoted quote VBN 19768 303 29 declaration declaration NN 19768 303 30 , , , 19768 303 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 303 32 Adler Adler NNP 19768 303 33 alone alone RB 19768 303 34 has have VBZ 19768 303 35 actual actual JJ 19768 303 36 power power NN 19768 303 37 either either CC 19768 303 38 to to TO 19768 303 39 procure procure VB 19768 303 40 or or CC 19768 303 41 to to TO 19768 303 42 prevent prevent VB 19768 303 43 publication publication NN 19768 303 44 ; ; : 19768 303 45 while while IN 19768 303 46 to to IN 19768 303 47 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 303 48 Royce Royce NNP 19768 303 49 is be VBZ 19768 303 50 assigned assign VBN 19768 303 51 merely merely RB 19768 303 52 the the DT 19768 303 53 special special JJ 19768 303 54 department department NN 19768 303 55 of of IN 19768 303 56 " " `` 19768 303 57 theoretical theoretical JJ 19768 303 58 ethics ethic NNS 19768 303 59 . . . 19768 303 60 " " '' 19768 304 1 Hence hence RB 19768 304 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 304 3 Adler Adler NNP 19768 304 4 and and CC 19768 304 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 304 6 Royce Royce NNP 19768 304 7 were be VBD 19768 304 8 jointly jointly RB 19768 304 9 responsible responsible JJ 19768 304 10 for for IN 19768 304 11 the the DT 19768 304 12 original original JJ 19768 304 13 libel libel NN 19768 304 14 , , , 19768 304 15 the the DT 19768 304 16 latter latter JJ 19768 304 17 for for IN 19768 304 18 writing write VBG 19768 304 19 it -PRON- PRP 19768 304 20 , , , 19768 304 21 the the DT 19768 304 22 former former JJ 19768 304 23 for for IN 19768 304 24 publishing publish VBG 19768 304 25 it -PRON- PRP 19768 304 26 ; ; : 19768 304 27 but but CC 19768 304 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 304 29 Adler Adler NNP 19768 304 30 alone alone RB 19768 304 31 was be VBD 19768 304 32 editorially editorially RB 19768 304 33 responsible responsible JJ 19768 304 34 for for IN 19768 304 35 publishing publish VBG 19768 304 36 or or CC 19768 304 37 refusing refuse VBG 19768 304 38 to to TO 19768 304 39 publish publish VB 19768 304 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 304 41 reply reply NN 19768 304 42 to to IN 19768 304 43 it -PRON- PRP 19768 304 44 . . . 19768 305 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 305 2 was be VBD 19768 305 3 to to IN 19768 305 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 305 5 Adler Adler NNP 19768 305 6 alone alone RB 19768 305 7 , , , 19768 305 8 as as IN 19768 305 9 responsible responsible JJ 19768 305 10 editor editor NN 19768 305 11 - - HYPH 19768 305 12 in in IN 19768 305 13 - - HYPH 19768 305 14 chief chief NN 19768 305 15 of of IN 19768 305 16 the the DT 19768 305 17 " " `` 19768 305 18 Journal Journal NNP 19768 305 19 of of IN 19768 305 20 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 305 21 , , , 19768 305 22 " " '' 19768 305 23 that that IN 19768 305 24 I -PRON- PRP 19768 305 25 looked look VBD 19768 305 26 for for IN 19768 305 27 publication publication NN 19768 305 28 of of IN 19768 305 29 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 305 30 defence defence NN 19768 305 31 , , , 19768 305 32 as as IN 19768 305 33 the the DT 19768 305 34 best good JJS 19768 305 35 possible possible JJ 19768 305 36 reparation reparation NN 19768 305 37 for for IN 19768 305 38 the the DT 19768 305 39 wrong wrong JJ 19768 305 40 done do VBN 19768 305 41 in in IN 19768 305 42 publishing publish VBG 19768 305 43 the the DT 19768 305 44 libellous libellous JJ 19768 305 45 attack attack NN 19768 305 46 ; ; : 19768 305 47 and and CC 19768 305 48 I -PRON- PRP 19768 305 49 looked look VBD 19768 305 50 to to IN 19768 305 51 him -PRON- PRP 19768 305 52 with with IN 19768 305 53 confidence confidence NN 19768 305 54 for for IN 19768 305 55 this this DT 19768 305 56 partial partial JJ 19768 305 57 and and CC 19768 305 58 inadequate inadequate JJ 19768 305 59 reparation reparation NN 19768 305 60 , , , 19768 305 61 believing believe VBG 19768 305 62 that that IN 19768 305 63 , , , 19768 305 64 as as IN 19768 305 65 head head NN 19768 305 66 of of IN 19768 305 67 the the DT 19768 305 68 " " `` 19768 305 69 ethical ethical JJ 19768 305 70 culture culture NN 19768 305 71 movement movement NN 19768 305 72 , , , 19768 305 73 " " '' 19768 305 74 he -PRON- PRP 19768 305 75 would would MD 19768 305 76 be be VB 19768 305 77 anxious anxious JJ 19768 305 78 to to TO 19768 305 79 conduct conduct VB 19768 305 80 the the DT 19768 305 81 " " `` 19768 305 82 Journal Journal NNP 19768 305 83 of of IN 19768 305 84 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 305 85 " " '' 19768 305 86 in in IN 19768 305 87 accordance accordance NN 19768 305 88 with with IN 19768 305 89 the the DT 19768 305 90 highest high JJS 19768 305 91 principles principle NNS 19768 305 92 of of IN 19768 305 93 justice justice NN 19768 305 94 , , , 19768 305 95 honor honor NN 19768 305 96 , , , 19768 305 97 and and CC 19768 305 98 fair fair JJ 19768 305 99 play play NN 19768 305 100 . . . 19768 306 1 To to IN 19768 306 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 306 3 astonishment astonishment NN 19768 306 4 and and CC 19768 306 5 indignation indignation NN 19768 306 6 , , , 19768 306 7 however however RB 19768 306 8 , , , 19768 306 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 306 10 manuscript manuscript NN 19768 306 11 , , , 19768 306 12 instead instead RB 19768 306 13 of of IN 19768 306 14 being be VBG 19768 306 15 considered consider VBN 19768 306 16 and and CC 19768 306 17 finally finally RB 19768 306 18 passed pass VBN 19768 306 19 upon upon IN 19768 306 20 by by IN 19768 306 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 306 22 Adler Adler NNP 19768 306 23 , , , 19768 306 24 was be VBD 19768 306 25 forwarded forward VBN 19768 306 26 by by IN 19768 306 27 him -PRON- PRP 19768 306 28 or or CC 19768 306 29 by by IN 19768 306 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 306 31 direction direction NN 19768 306 32 to to IN 19768 306 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 306 34 Royce Royce NNP 19768 306 35 ! ! . 19768 307 1 The the DT 19768 307 2 latter latter JJ 19768 307 3 , , , 19768 307 4 getting get VBG 19768 307 5 wind wind NN 19768 307 6 of of IN 19768 307 7 it -PRON- PRP 19768 307 8 , , , 19768 307 9 had have VBD 19768 307 10 " " `` 19768 307 11 insisted insist VBN 19768 307 12 " " '' 19768 307 13 that that IN 19768 307 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 307 15 belonged belong VBD 19768 307 16 to to IN 19768 307 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 307 18 department department NN 19768 307 19 of of IN 19768 307 20 " " `` 19768 307 21 theoretical theoretical JJ 19768 307 22 ethics ethic NNS 19768 307 23 , , , 19768 307 24 " " '' 19768 307 25 and and CC 19768 307 26 " " `` 19768 307 27 claimed claim VBD 19768 307 28 the the DT 19768 307 29 right right NN 19768 307 30 " " '' 19768 307 31 to to TO 19768 307 32 _ _ NNP 19768 307 33 edit edit VB 19768 307 34 it -PRON- PRP 19768 307 35 with with IN 19768 307 36 a a DT 19768 307 37 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 307 38 in in IN 19768 307 39 the the DT 19768 307 40 same same JJ 19768 307 41 issue issue NN 19768 307 42 _ _ NNP 19768 307 43 . . . 19768 308 1 Nothing nothing NN 19768 308 2 could could MD 19768 308 3 be be VB 19768 308 4 conceived conceive VBN 19768 308 5 more more RBR 19768 308 6 unfair unfair JJ 19768 308 7 or or CC 19768 308 8 more more RBR 19768 308 9 absurd absurd JJ 19768 308 10 . . . 19768 309 1 A a DT 19768 309 2 libel libel NN 19768 309 3 had have VBD 19768 309 4 been be VBN 19768 309 5 published publish VBN 19768 309 6 by by IN 19768 309 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 309 8 Adler Adler NNP 19768 309 9 , , , 19768 309 10 and and CC 19768 309 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 309 12 Adler Adler NNP 19768 309 13 sent send VBD 19768 309 14 the the DT 19768 309 15 defence defence NN 19768 309 16 against against IN 19768 309 17 this this DT 19768 309 18 libel libel NN 19768 309 19 to to TO 19768 309 20 be be VB 19768 309 21 edited edit VBN 19768 309 22 by by IN 19768 309 23 the the DT 19768 309 24 libeller libeller NN 19768 309 25 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 309 26 ! ! . 19768 310 1 Protest protest NN 19768 310 2 was be VBD 19768 310 3 in in IN 19768 310 4 vain vain JJ 19768 310 5 . . . 19768 311 1 Dr Dr NNP 19768 311 2 Adler Adler NNP 19768 311 3 denied deny VBD 19768 311 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 311 5 own own JJ 19768 311 6 moral moral JJ 19768 311 7 responsibility responsibility NN 19768 311 8 , , , 19768 311 9 washed wash VBD 19768 311 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 311 11 hands hand NNS 19768 311 12 of of IN 19768 311 13 the the DT 19768 311 14 whole whole JJ 19768 311 15 affair affair NN 19768 311 16 , , , 19768 311 17 and and CC 19768 311 18 even even RB 19768 311 19 refused refuse VBD 19768 311 20 to to TO 19768 311 21 enlighten enlighten VB 19768 311 22 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 311 23 as as IN 19768 311 24 to to IN 19768 311 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 311 26 own own JJ 19768 311 27 duty duty NN 19768 311 28 ( ( -LRB- 19768 311 29 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 19768 311 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 311 31 urgent urgent JJ 19768 311 32 request request NN 19768 311 33 that that IN 19768 311 34 he -PRON- PRP 19768 311 35 should should MD 19768 311 36 do do VB 19768 311 37 so so RB 19768 311 38 ) ) -RRB- 19768 311 39 by by IN 19768 311 40 taking take VBG 19768 311 41 counsel counsel NN 19768 311 42 of of IN 19768 311 43 some some DT 19768 311 44 wise wise JJ 19768 311 45 and and CC 19768 311 46 able able JJ 19768 311 47 lawyer lawyer NN 19768 311 48 of of IN 19768 311 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 311 50 own own JJ 19768 311 51 acquaintance acquaintance NN 19768 311 52 . . . 19768 312 1 Instead instead RB 19768 312 2 of of IN 19768 312 3 doing do VBG 19768 312 4 this this DT 19768 312 5 , , , 19768 312 6 he -PRON- PRP 19768 312 7 affected affect VBD 19768 312 8 to to TO 19768 312 9 consider consider VB 19768 312 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 312 11 self self NN 19768 312 12 - - HYPH 19768 312 13 defence defence NN 19768 312 14 against against IN 19768 312 15 a a DT 19768 312 16 libel libel NN 19768 312 17 as as RB 19768 312 18 merely merely RB 19768 312 19 a a DT 19768 312 20 reply reply NN 19768 312 21 to to IN 19768 312 22 an an DT 19768 312 23 ordinary ordinary JJ 19768 312 24 " " `` 19768 312 25 book book NN 19768 312 26 - - HYPH 19768 312 27 criticism criticism NN 19768 312 28 , , , 19768 312 29 " " '' 19768 312 30 made make VBD 19768 312 31 a a DT 19768 312 32 few few JJ 19768 312 33 inquiries inquiry NNS 19768 312 34 as as IN 19768 312 35 to to IN 19768 312 36 the the DT 19768 312 37 " " `` 19768 312 38 usual usual JJ 19768 312 39 practice practice NN 19768 312 40 of of IN 19768 312 41 journals journal NNS 19768 312 42 " " '' 19768 312 43 with with IN 19768 312 44 reference reference NN 19768 312 45 to to IN 19768 312 46 book book NN 19768 312 47 - - HYPH 19768 312 48 criticisms criticism NNS 19768 312 49 alone alone RB 19768 312 50 , , , 19768 312 51 turned turn VBD 19768 312 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 312 53 article article NN 19768 312 54 over over IN 19768 312 55 to to IN 19768 312 56 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 312 57 Royce Royce NNP 19768 312 58 as as IN 19768 312 59 one one CD 19768 312 60 on on IN 19768 312 61 " " `` 19768 312 62 theoretical theoretical JJ 19768 312 63 ethics ethic NNS 19768 312 64 , , , 19768 312 65 " " '' 19768 312 66 and and CC 19768 312 67 permitted permit VBD 19768 312 68 him -PRON- PRP 19768 312 69 to to TO 19768 312 70 attach attach VB 19768 312 71 to to IN 19768 312 72 it -PRON- PRP 19768 312 73 a a DT 19768 312 74 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 312 75 which which WDT 19768 312 76 reiterated reiterate VBD 19768 312 77 the the DT 19768 312 78 original original JJ 19768 312 79 libel libel NN 19768 312 80 with with IN 19768 312 81 additions addition NNS 19768 312 82 and and CC 19768 312 83 improvements improvement NNS 19768 312 84 , , , 19768 312 85 but but CC 19768 312 86 in in IN 19768 312 87 which which WDT 19768 312 88 he -PRON- PRP 19768 312 89 took take VBD 19768 312 90 pains pain NNS 19768 312 91 to to TO 19768 312 92 say say VB 19768 312 93 of of IN 19768 312 94 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 312 95 reply reply NN 19768 312 96 : : : 19768 312 97 " " `` 19768 312 98 I -PRON- PRP 19768 312 99 may may MD 19768 312 100 add add VB 19768 312 101 that that IN 19768 312 102 even even RB 19768 312 103 now now RB 19768 312 104 it -PRON- PRP 19768 312 105 does do VBZ 19768 312 106 not not RB 19768 312 107 occur occur VB 19768 312 108 to to IN 19768 312 109 me -PRON- PRP 19768 312 110 to to TO 19768 312 111 feel feel VB 19768 312 112 personally personally RB 19768 312 113 wounded wound VBN 19768 312 114 , , , 19768 312 115 nor nor CC 19768 312 116 yet yet RB 19768 312 117 uneasy uneasy JJ 19768 312 118 at at IN 19768 312 119 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 312 120 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 312 121 's 's POS 19768 312 122 present present JJ 19768 312 123 warmth warmth NN 19768 312 124 . . . 19768 312 125 " " '' 19768 313 1 These these DT 19768 313 2 words word NNS 19768 313 3 have have VBP 19768 313 4 a a DT 19768 313 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 19768 313 6 interest interest NN 19768 313 7 with with IN 19768 313 8 reference reference NN 19768 313 9 to to IN 19768 313 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 313 11 later later JJ 19768 313 12 legal legal JJ 19768 313 13 notice notice NN 19768 313 14 against against IN 19768 313 15 all all DT 19768 313 16 publication publication NN 19768 313 17 or or CC 19768 313 18 circulation circulation NN 19768 313 19 of of IN 19768 313 20 this this DT 19768 313 21 very very JJ 19768 313 22 reply reply NN 19768 313 23 : : : 19768 313 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 313 25 assumed assumed JJ 19768 313 26 or or CC 19768 313 27 genuine genuine JJ 19768 313 28 pachydermatousness pachydermatousness NN 19768 313 29 soon soon RB 19768 313 30 gave give VBD 19768 313 31 way way NN 19768 313 32 to to IN 19768 313 33 fearful fearful JJ 19768 313 34 apprehension apprehension NN 19768 313 35 of of IN 19768 313 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 313 37 effect effect NN 19768 313 38 upon upon IN 19768 313 39 the the DT 19768 313 40 public public JJ 19768 313 41 mind mind NN 19768 313 42 . . . 19768 314 1 In in IN 19768 314 2 no no DT 19768 314 3 sense sense NN 19768 314 4 whatever whatever WDT 19768 314 5 was be VBD 19768 314 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 314 7 reply reply NN 19768 314 8 an an DT 19768 314 9 article article NN 19768 314 10 on on IN 19768 314 11 " " `` 19768 314 12 theoretical theoretical JJ 19768 314 13 ethics ethic NNS 19768 314 14 . . . 19768 314 15 " " '' 19768 315 1 To to IN 19768 315 2 what what WDT 19768 315 3 part part NN 19768 315 4 of of IN 19768 315 5 the the DT 19768 315 6 " " `` 19768 315 7 theory theory NN 19768 315 8 of of IN 19768 315 9 ethics ethic NNS 19768 315 10 " " '' 19768 315 11 belongs belong VBZ 19768 315 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 315 13 Royce Royce NNP 19768 315 14 's 's POS 19768 315 15 false false JJ 19768 315 16 personal personal JJ 19768 315 17 accusation accusation NN 19768 315 18 of of IN 19768 315 19 " " `` 19768 315 20 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 315 21 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 315 22 " " '' 19768 315 23 ? ? . 19768 316 1 To to IN 19768 316 2 what what WDT 19768 316 3 part part NN 19768 316 4 of of IN 19768 316 5 the the DT 19768 316 6 " " `` 19768 316 7 theory theory NN 19768 316 8 of of IN 19768 316 9 ethics ethic NNS 19768 316 10 " " '' 19768 316 11 belongs belong VBZ 19768 316 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 316 13 Royce Royce NNP 19768 316 14 's 's POS 19768 316 15 false false JJ 19768 316 16 personal personal JJ 19768 316 17 accusation accusation NN 19768 316 18 of of IN 19768 316 19 " " `` 19768 316 20 sinning sin VBG 19768 316 21 against against IN 19768 316 22 the the DT 19768 316 23 most most RBS 19768 316 24 obvious obvious JJ 19768 316 25 demands demand NNS 19768 316 26 of of IN 19768 316 27 literary literary JJ 19768 316 28 property property NN 19768 316 29 - - HYPH 19768 316 30 rights right NNS 19768 316 31 " " '' 19768 316 32 ? ? . 19768 317 1 To to IN 19768 317 2 what what WDT 19768 317 3 part part NN 19768 317 4 of of IN 19768 317 5 the the DT 19768 317 6 " " `` 19768 317 7 theory theory NN 19768 317 8 of of IN 19768 317 9 ethics ethic NNS 19768 317 10 " " '' 19768 317 11 belongs belong VBZ 19768 317 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 317 13 Royce Royce NNP 19768 317 14 's 's POS 19768 317 15 " " `` 19768 317 16 professional professional JJ 19768 317 17 warning warning NN 19768 317 18 " " '' 19768 317 19 against against IN 19768 317 20 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 317 21 which which WDT 19768 317 22 were be VBD 19768 317 23 never never RB 19768 317 24 made make VBN 19768 317 25 ? ? . 19768 318 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19768 318 2 false false JJ 19768 318 3 accusations accusation NNS 19768 318 4 and and CC 19768 318 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 318 6 false false JJ 19768 318 7 grounds ground NNS 19768 318 8 were be VBD 19768 318 9 the the DT 19768 318 10 main main JJ 19768 318 11 theme theme NN 19768 318 12 of of IN 19768 318 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 318 14 article article NN 19768 318 15 , , , 19768 318 16 and and CC 19768 318 17 they -PRON- PRP 19768 318 18 had have VBD 19768 318 19 nothing nothing NN 19768 318 20 to to TO 19768 318 21 do do VB 19768 318 22 with with IN 19768 318 23 " " `` 19768 318 24 theoretical theoretical JJ 19768 318 25 ethics ethic NNS 19768 318 26 , , , 19768 318 27 " " '' 19768 318 28 Dr Dr NNP 19768 318 29 Adler Adler NNP 19768 318 30 and and CC 19768 318 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 318 32 Royce Royce NNP 19768 318 33 to to IN 19768 318 34 the the DT 19768 318 35 contrary contrary NN 19768 318 36 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 19768 318 37 . . . 19768 319 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 319 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 319 3 had have VBD 19768 319 4 no no DT 19768 319 5 shadow shadow NN 19768 319 6 of of IN 19768 319 7 right right NN 19768 319 8 to to TO 19768 319 9 set set VB 19768 319 10 up up RP 19768 319 11 so so RB 19768 319 12 preposterous preposterous JJ 19768 319 13 a a DT 19768 319 14 claim claim NN 19768 319 15 , , , 19768 319 16 and and CC 19768 319 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 319 18 Adler Adler NNP 19768 319 19 had have VBD 19768 319 20 no no DT 19768 319 21 shadow shadow NN 19768 319 22 of of IN 19768 319 23 right right NN 19768 319 24 to to TO 19768 319 25 yield yield VB 19768 319 26 to to IN 19768 319 27 it -PRON- PRP 19768 319 28 , , , 19768 319 29 as as IN 19768 319 30 he -PRON- PRP 19768 319 31 weakly weakly RB 19768 319 32 did do VBD 19768 319 33 , , , 19768 319 34 thereby thereby RB 19768 319 35 violating violate VBG 19768 319 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 319 37 own own JJ 19768 319 38 undeniable undeniable JJ 19768 319 39 obligation obligation NN 19768 319 40 , , , 19768 319 41 as as IN 19768 319 42 editor editor NN 19768 319 43 - - HYPH 19768 319 44 in in IN 19768 319 45 - - HYPH 19768 319 46 chief chief NN 19768 319 47 , , , 19768 319 48 to to TO 19768 319 49 do do VB 19768 319 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 319 51 utmost utmost NN 19768 319 52 to to TO 19768 319 53 repair repair VB 19768 319 54 the the DT 19768 319 55 wrong wrong NN 19768 319 56 which which WDT 19768 319 57 he -PRON- PRP 19768 319 58 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 319 59 had have VBD 19768 319 60 done do VBN 19768 319 61 in in IN 19768 319 62 publishing publish VBG 19768 319 63 a a DT 19768 319 64 libel libel NN 19768 319 65 . . . 19768 320 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 19768 320 2 article article NN 19768 320 3 was be VBD 19768 320 4 avowedly avowedly RB 19768 320 5 nothing nothing NN 19768 320 6 but but IN 19768 320 7 a a DT 19768 320 8 defence defence NN 19768 320 9 against against IN 19768 320 10 this this DT 19768 320 11 libel libel NN 19768 320 12 , , , 19768 320 13 and and CC 19768 320 14 , , , 19768 320 15 as as IN 19768 320 16 such such JJ 19768 320 17 , , , 19768 320 18 was be VBD 19768 320 19 necessarily necessarily RB 19768 320 20 addressed address VBN 19768 320 21 to to IN 19768 320 22 the the DT 19768 320 23 responsible responsible JJ 19768 320 24 editor editor NN 19768 320 25 of of IN 19768 320 26 the the DT 19768 320 27 " " `` 19768 320 28 Journal Journal NNP 19768 320 29 of of IN 19768 320 30 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 320 31 , , , 19768 320 32 " " '' 19768 320 33 not not RB 19768 320 34 to to IN 19768 320 35 the the DT 19768 320 36 sub sub NN 19768 320 37 - - NN 19768 320 38 editor editor NN 19768 320 39 of of IN 19768 320 40 one one CD 19768 320 41 of of IN 19768 320 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 320 43 special special JJ 19768 320 44 departments department NNS 19768 320 45 -- -- : 19768 320 46 most most RBS 19768 320 47 assuredly assuredly RB 19768 320 48 not not RB 19768 320 49 to to IN 19768 320 50 the the DT 19768 320 51 libeller libeller NN 19768 320 52 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 320 53 . . . 19768 321 1 The the DT 19768 321 2 only only JJ 19768 321 3 fair fair JJ 19768 321 4 and and CC 19768 321 5 just just RB 19768 321 6 course course NN 19768 321 7 was be VBD 19768 321 8 to to TO 19768 321 9 publish publish VB 19768 321 10 this this DT 19768 321 11 defence defence NN 19768 321 12 alone alone RB 19768 321 13 by by IN 19768 321 14 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 321 15 , , , 19768 321 16 precisely precisely RB 19768 321 17 as as IN 19768 321 18 the the DT 19768 321 19 libel libel NN 19768 321 20 had have VBD 19768 321 21 been be VBN 19768 321 22 published publish VBN 19768 321 23 alone alone RB 19768 321 24 by by IN 19768 321 25 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 321 26 , , , 19768 321 27 and and CC 19768 321 28 afterwards afterwards RB 19768 321 29 to to TO 19768 321 30 allow allow VB 19768 321 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 321 32 Royce Royce NNP 19768 321 33 to to TO 19768 321 34 follow follow VB 19768 321 35 it -PRON- PRP 19768 321 36 , , , 19768 321 37 if if IN 19768 321 38 he -PRON- PRP 19768 321 39 pleased please VBD 19768 321 40 , , , 19768 321 41 with with IN 19768 321 42 a a DT 19768 321 43 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 321 44 in in IN 19768 321 45 the the DT 19768 321 46 succeeding succeed VBG 19768 321 47 number number NN 19768 321 48 . . . 19768 322 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 322 2 made make VBD 19768 322 3 not not RB 19768 322 4 the the DT 19768 322 5 slightest slight JJS 19768 322 6 objection objection NN 19768 322 7 to to IN 19768 322 8 one one CD 19768 322 9 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 322 10 or or CC 19768 322 11 a a DT 19768 322 12 dozen dozen NN 19768 322 13 rejoinders rejoinder NNS 19768 322 14 from from IN 19768 322 15 him -PRON- PRP 19768 322 16 , , , 19768 322 17 provided provide VBD 19768 322 18 the the DT 19768 322 19 responsible responsible JJ 19768 322 20 editor editor NN 19768 322 21 held hold VBD 19768 322 22 the the DT 19768 322 23 balance balance NN 19768 322 24 true true JJ 19768 322 25 , , , 19768 322 26 accorded accord VBN 19768 322 27 as as IN 19768 322 28 fair fair JJ 19768 322 29 a a DT 19768 322 30 hearing hearing NN 19768 322 31 to to IN 19768 322 32 the the DT 19768 322 33 accused accuse VBN 19768 322 34 as as IN 19768 322 35 he -PRON- PRP 19768 322 36 had have VBD 19768 322 37 accorded accord VBN 19768 322 38 to to IN 19768 322 39 the the DT 19768 322 40 accuser accuser NN 19768 322 41 , , , 19768 322 42 and and CC 19768 322 43 granted grant VBN 19768 322 44 to to IN 19768 322 45 each each DT 19768 322 46 in in IN 19768 322 47 turn turn NN 19768 322 48 an an DT 19768 322 49 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 322 50 to to TO 19768 322 51 plead plead VB 19768 322 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 322 53 cause cause NN 19768 322 54 without without IN 19768 322 55 interruption interruption NN 19768 322 56 by by IN 19768 322 57 the the DT 19768 322 58 other other JJ 19768 322 59 . . . 19768 323 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 323 2 asked ask VBD 19768 323 3 no no RB 19768 323 4 more more JJR 19768 323 5 than than IN 19768 323 6 what what WP 19768 323 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 323 8 Royce Royce NNP 19768 323 9 had have VBD 19768 323 10 already already RB 19768 323 11 received receive VBN 19768 323 12 -- -- : 19768 323 13 an an DT 19768 323 14 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 323 15 to to TO 19768 323 16 enjoy enjoy VB 19768 323 17 the the DT 19768 323 18 undivided undivided JJ 19768 323 19 and and CC 19768 323 20 undistracted undistracted JJ 19768 323 21 attention attention NN 19768 323 22 of of IN 19768 323 23 the the DT 19768 323 24 audience audience NN 19768 323 25 for for IN 19768 323 26 a a DT 19768 323 27 limited limited JJ 19768 323 28 time time NN 19768 323 29 . . . 19768 324 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 324 2 had have VBD 19768 324 3 had have VBN 19768 324 4 the the DT 19768 324 5 ear ear NN 19768 324 6 of of IN 19768 324 7 the the DT 19768 324 8 public public NN 19768 324 9 for for IN 19768 324 10 six six CD 19768 324 11 months month NNS 19768 324 12 . . . 19768 325 1 Could Could MD 19768 325 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 325 3 not not RB 19768 325 4 have have VB 19768 325 5 it -PRON- PRP 19768 325 6 for for IN 19768 325 7 three three CD 19768 325 8 ? ? . 19768 326 1 But but CC 19768 326 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 326 3 regret regret VBP 19768 326 4 to to TO 19768 326 5 say say VB 19768 326 6 that that IN 19768 326 7 considerations consideration NNS 19768 326 8 of of IN 19768 326 9 equal equal JJ 19768 326 10 justice justice NN 19768 326 11 seemed seem VBD 19768 326 12 to to TO 19768 326 13 have have VB 19768 326 14 no no DT 19768 326 15 weight weight NN 19768 326 16 whatever whatever WDT 19768 326 17 with with IN 19768 326 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 326 19 Adler Adler NNP 19768 326 20 . . . 19768 327 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 327 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 327 3 , , , 19768 327 4 despite despite IN 19768 327 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 327 6 public public JJ 19768 327 7 pledge pledge NN 19768 327 8 , , , 19768 327 9 was be VBD 19768 327 10 " " `` 19768 327 11 asking ask VBG 19768 327 12 for for IN 19768 327 13 mercy mercy NN 19768 327 14 , , , 19768 327 15 " " '' 19768 327 16 after after RB 19768 327 17 all all RB 19768 327 18 , , , 19768 327 19 and and CC 19768 327 20 got get VBD 19768 327 21 from from IN 19768 327 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 327 23 Adler Adler NNP 19768 327 24 all all DT 19768 327 25 he -PRON- PRP 19768 327 26 asked ask VBD 19768 327 27 for for IN 19768 327 28 ; ; : 19768 327 29 I -PRON- PRP 19768 327 30 asked ask VBD 19768 327 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 327 32 Adler Adler NNP 19768 327 33 for for IN 19768 327 34 equity equity NN 19768 327 35 alone alone RB 19768 327 36 , , , 19768 327 37 and and CC 19768 327 38 could could MD 19768 327 39 not not RB 19768 327 40 get get VB 19768 327 41 even even RB 19768 327 42 that that DT 19768 327 43 . . . 19768 328 1 The the DT 19768 328 2 sole sole JJ 19768 328 3 concession concession NN 19768 328 4 made make VBN 19768 328 5 was be VBD 19768 328 6 that that IN 19768 328 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 328 8 might may MD 19768 328 9 follow follow VB 19768 328 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 328 11 Royce Royce NNP 19768 328 12 's 's POS 19768 328 13 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 328 14 with with IN 19768 328 15 a a DT 19768 328 16 second second JJ 19768 328 17 reply reply NN 19768 328 18 in in IN 19768 328 19 the the DT 19768 328 20 same same JJ 19768 328 21 number number NN 19768 328 22 , , , 19768 328 23 thus thus RB 19768 328 24 closing close VBG 19768 328 25 the the DT 19768 328 26 case case NN 19768 328 27 with with IN 19768 328 28 a a DT 19768 328 29 last last JJ 19768 328 30 word word NN 19768 328 31 for for IN 19768 328 32 the the DT 19768 328 33 defence defence NN 19768 328 34 . . . 19768 329 1 To to IN 19768 329 2 this this DT 19768 329 3 last last JJ 19768 329 4 proposal proposal NN 19768 329 5 , , , 19768 329 6 in in IN 19768 329 7 order order NN 19768 329 8 not not RB 19768 329 9 to to TO 19768 329 10 refuse refuse VB 19768 329 11 a a DT 19768 329 12 meagre meagre JJ 19768 329 13 measure measure NN 19768 329 14 of of IN 19768 329 15 justice justice NN 19768 329 16 , , , 19768 329 17 I -PRON- PRP 19768 329 18 consented consent VBD 19768 329 19 under under IN 19768 329 20 protest protest NN 19768 329 21 . . . 19768 330 1 But but CC 19768 330 2 the the DT 19768 330 3 proof proof NN 19768 330 4 - - HYPH 19768 330 5 sheets sheet NNS 19768 330 6 of of IN 19768 330 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 330 8 Royce Royce NNP 19768 330 9 's 's POS 19768 330 10 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 330 11 , , , 19768 330 12 to to TO 19768 330 13 which which WDT 19768 330 14 I -PRON- PRP 19768 330 15 was be VBD 19768 330 16 to to TO 19768 330 17 reply reply VB 19768 330 18 , , , 19768 330 19 did do VBD 19768 330 20 not not RB 19768 330 21 reach reach VB 19768 330 22 me -PRON- PRP 19768 330 23 till till IN 19768 330 24 March March NNP 19768 330 25 18 18 CD 19768 330 26 , , , 19768 330 27 and and CC 19768 330 28 were be VBD 19768 330 29 accompanied accompany VBN 19768 330 30 with with IN 19768 330 31 a a DT 19768 330 32 notice notice NN 19768 330 33 from from IN 19768 330 34 the the DT 19768 330 35 " " `` 19768 330 36 Journal Journal NNP 19768 330 37 of of IN 19768 330 38 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 330 39 " " '' 19768 330 40 that that IN 19768 330 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 330 42 reply reply NN 19768 330 43 must must MD 19768 330 44 be be VB 19768 330 45 mailed mail VBN 19768 330 46 " " `` 19768 330 47 within within IN 19768 330 48 ten ten CD 19768 330 49 hours hour NNS 19768 330 50 after after IN 19768 330 51 receiving receive VBG 19768 330 52 Royce Royce NNP 19768 330 53 's 's POS 19768 330 54 proof proof NN 19768 330 55 . . . 19768 330 56 " " '' 19768 331 1 This this DT 19768 331 2 notice notice NN 19768 331 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 331 4 answered answer VBD 19768 331 5 as as IN 19768 331 6 follows:-- follows:-- `` 19768 331 7 " " `` 19768 331 8 The the DT 19768 331 9 proof proof NN 19768 331 10 of of IN 19768 331 11 Royce Royce NNP 19768 331 12 's 's POS 19768 331 13 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 331 14 , , , 19768 331 15 with with IN 19768 331 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 331 17 notes note NNS 19768 331 18 of of IN 19768 331 19 the the DT 19768 331 20 16th 16th JJ 19768 331 21 and and CC 19768 331 22 17th 17th JJ 19768 331 23 , , , 19768 331 24 arrived arrive VBD 19768 331 25 this this DT 19768 331 26 morning morning NN 19768 331 27 at at IN 19768 331 28 9 9 CD 19768 331 29 A.M. A.M. NNP 19768 331 30 As as IN 19768 331 31 I -PRON- PRP 19768 331 32 have have VBP 19768 331 33 had have VBN 19768 331 34 to to TO 19768 331 35 be be VB 19768 331 36 at at IN 19768 331 37 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 331 38 teaching teaching NN 19768 331 39 till till IN 19768 331 40 3 3 CD 19768 331 41 P.M. P.M. NNP 19768 331 42 , , , 19768 331 43 it -PRON- PRP 19768 331 44 was be VBD 19768 331 45 obviously obviously RB 19768 331 46 impossible impossible JJ 19768 331 47 to to TO 19768 331 48 mail mail VB 19768 331 49 a a DT 19768 331 50 reply reply NN 19768 331 51 by by IN 19768 331 52 7 7 CD 19768 331 53 P.M. P.M. NNP 19768 332 1 Hence hence RB 19768 332 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 332 3 telegraphed telegraph VBD 19768 332 4 to to IN 19768 332 5 you -PRON- PRP 19768 332 6 at at IN 19768 332 7 once once RB 19768 332 8 : : : 19768 332 9 ' ' `` 19768 332 10 _ _ NNP 19768 332 11 I -PRON- PRP 19768 332 12 protest protest VBP 19768 332 13 against against IN 19768 332 14 the the DT 19768 332 15 gross gross JJ 19768 332 16 injustice injustice NN 19768 332 17 of of IN 19768 332 18 postponing postpone VBG 19768 332 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 332 20 article article NN 19768 332 21 , , , 19768 332 22 or or CC 19768 332 23 of of IN 19768 332 24 publishing publish VBG 19768 332 25 this this DT 19768 332 26 new new JJ 19768 332 27 attack attack NN 19768 332 28 without without IN 19768 332 29 the the DT 19768 332 30 last last JJ 19768 332 31 word word NN 19768 332 32 you -PRON- PRP 19768 332 33 promised promise VBD 19768 332 34 me -PRON- PRP 19768 332 35 . . . 19768 333 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 333 2 is be VBZ 19768 333 3 impossible impossible JJ 19768 333 4 to to TO 19768 333 5 write write VB 19768 333 6 this this DT 19768 333 7 now now RB 19768 333 8 _ _ NNP 19768 333 9 [ [ -LRB- 19768 333 10 _ _ NNP 19768 333 11 i i PRP 19768 333 12 . . . 19768 334 1 e. e. NNP 19768 334 2 _ _ NNP 19768 334 3 , , , 19768 334 4 within within IN 19768 334 5 the the DT 19768 334 6 ten ten CD 19768 334 7 hours hour NNS 19768 334 8 stipulated stipulate VBN 19768 334 9 ] ] -RRB- 19768 334 10 . . . 19768 335 1 _ _ XX 19768 335 2 If if IN 19768 335 3 you -PRON- PRP 19768 335 4 have have VBP 19768 335 5 any any DT 19768 335 6 love love NN 19768 335 7 of of IN 19768 335 8 justice justice NN 19768 335 9 , , , 19768 335 10 publish publish VB 19768 335 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 335 12 article article NN 19768 335 13 now now RB 19768 335 14 , , , 19768 335 15 and and CC 19768 335 16 postpone postpone VB 19768 335 17 the the DT 19768 335 18 rejoinders rejoinder NNS 19768 335 19 to to IN 19768 335 20 next next JJ 19768 335 21 issue issue NN 19768 335 22 . . . 19768 335 23 _ _ NNP 19768 335 24 ' ' `` 19768 335 25 Nothing Nothing NNP 19768 335 26 stands stand VBZ 19768 335 27 in in IN 19768 335 28 the the DT 19768 335 29 way way NN 19768 335 30 of of IN 19768 335 31 this this DT 19768 335 32 , , , 19768 335 33 the the DT 19768 335 34 only only JJ 19768 335 35 fair fair JJ 19768 335 36 course course NN 19768 335 37 , , , 19768 335 38 except except IN 19768 335 39 Royce Royce NNP 19768 335 40 's 's POS 19768 335 41 insistence insistence NN 19768 335 42 on on IN 19768 335 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 335 44 right right NN 19768 335 45 to to TO 19768 335 46 deprive deprive VB 19768 335 47 me -PRON- PRP 19768 335 48 of of IN 19768 335 49 the the DT 19768 335 50 equality equality NN 19768 335 51 of of IN 19768 335 52 treatment treatment NN 19768 335 53 which which WDT 19768 335 54 I -PRON- PRP 19768 335 55 supposed suppose VBD 19768 335 56 he -PRON- PRP 19768 335 57 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 335 58 guaranteed guarantee VBD 19768 335 59 in in IN 19768 335 60 his--'as his--'as NNP 19768 335 61 we -PRON- PRP 19768 335 62 ask ask VBP 19768 335 63 none none NN 19768 335 64 . . . 19768 335 65 ' ' '' 19768 336 1 To to TO 19768 336 2 hold hold VB 19768 336 3 back back RP 19768 336 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 336 5 reply reply NN 19768 336 6 to to IN 19768 336 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 336 8 libel libel NN 19768 336 9 for for IN 19768 336 10 three three CD 19768 336 11 months month NNS 19768 336 12 longer long RBR 19768 336 13 , , , 19768 336 14 merely merely RB 19768 336 15 because because IN 19768 336 16 he -PRON- PRP 19768 336 17 is be VBZ 19768 336 18 afraid afraid JJ 19768 336 19 to to TO 19768 336 20 let let VB 19768 336 21 it -PRON- PRP 19768 336 22 go go VB 19768 336 23 forth forth RB 19768 336 24 without without IN 19768 336 25 an an DT 19768 336 26 attempt attempt NN 19768 336 27 to to TO 19768 336 28 break break VB 19768 336 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 336 30 force force NN 19768 336 31 in in IN 19768 336 32 the the DT 19768 336 33 same same JJ 19768 336 34 number number NN 19768 336 35 , , , 19768 336 36 would would MD 19768 336 37 be be VB 19768 336 38 disgracefully disgracefully RB 19768 336 39 unjust unjust JJ 19768 336 40 in in IN 19768 336 41 him -PRON- PRP 19768 336 42 and and CC 19768 336 43 in in IN 19768 336 44 the the DT 19768 336 45 ' ' `` 19768 336 46 Journal Journal NNP 19768 336 47 . . . 19768 336 48 ' ' '' 19768 337 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19768 337 2 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 337 3 is be VBZ 19768 337 4 simply simply RB 19768 337 5 a a DT 19768 337 6 fresh fresh JJ 19768 337 7 libel libel NN 19768 337 8 ; ; : 19768 337 9 there there EX 19768 337 10 is be VBZ 19768 337 11 nothing nothing NN 19768 337 12 in in IN 19768 337 13 it -PRON- PRP 19768 337 14 to to TO 19768 337 15 which which WDT 19768 337 16 I -PRON- PRP 19768 337 17 can can MD 19768 337 18 not not RB 19768 337 19 easily easily RB 19768 337 20 and and CC 19768 337 21 effectually effectually RB 19768 337 22 reply reply VB 19768 337 23 . . . 19768 338 1 But but CC 19768 338 2 what what WP 19768 338 3 _ _ NNP 19768 338 4 right right UH 19768 338 5 _ _ NNP 19768 338 6 is be VBZ 19768 338 7 there there RB 19768 338 8 in in IN 19768 338 9 refusing refuse VBG 19768 338 10 to to IN 19768 338 11 me -PRON- PRP 19768 338 12 the the DT 19768 338 13 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 338 14 of of IN 19768 338 15 answering answer VBG 19768 338 16 one one CD 19768 338 17 libel libel NN 19768 338 18 at at IN 19768 338 19 a a DT 19768 338 20 time time NN 19768 338 21 ? ? . 19768 339 1 Or or CC 19768 339 2 in in IN 19768 339 3 compelling compel VBG 19768 339 4 me -PRON- PRP 19768 339 5 to to TO 19768 339 6 be be VB 19768 339 7 silent silent JJ 19768 339 8 nine nine CD 19768 339 9 months month NNS 19768 339 10 [ [ -LRB- 19768 339 11 from from IN 19768 339 12 October October NNP 19768 339 13 to to IN 19768 339 14 July July NNP 19768 339 15 ] ] -RRB- 19768 339 16 , , , 19768 339 17 in in IN 19768 339 18 order order NN 19768 339 19 to to TO 19768 339 20 save save VB 19768 339 21 him -PRON- PRP 19768 339 22 from from IN 19768 339 23 being be VBG 19768 339 24 silent silent JJ 19768 339 25 three three CD 19768 339 26 months month NNS 19768 339 27 [ [ -LRB- 19768 339 28 from from IN 19768 339 29 April April NNP 19768 339 30 to to IN 19768 339 31 July July NNP 19768 339 32 ] ] -RRB- 19768 339 33 ? ? . 19768 340 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 340 2 will will MD 19768 340 3 be be VB 19768 340 4 a a DT 19768 340 5 bitter bitter JJ 19768 340 6 comment comment NN 19768 340 7 on on IN 19768 340 8 the the DT 19768 340 9 sincerity sincerity NN 19768 340 10 of of IN 19768 340 11 the the DT 19768 340 12 ' ' `` 19768 340 13 ethical ethical JJ 19768 340 14 culture culture NN 19768 340 15 movement movement NN 19768 340 16 ' ' '' 19768 340 17 to to TO 19768 340 18 make make VB 19768 340 19 so so RB 19768 340 20 unethical unethical JJ 19768 340 21 a a DT 19768 340 22 judgment judgment NN 19768 340 23 in in IN 19768 340 24 so so RB 19768 340 25 grave grave VB 19768 340 26 a a DT 19768 340 27 case case NN 19768 340 28 as as IN 19768 340 29 this this DT 19768 340 30 . . . 19768 340 31 " " '' 19768 341 1 But but CC 19768 341 2 the the DT 19768 341 3 April April NNP 19768 341 4 number number NN 19768 341 5 of of IN 19768 341 6 the the DT 19768 341 7 " " `` 19768 341 8 Journal Journal NNP 19768 341 9 of of IN 19768 341 10 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 341 11 , , , 19768 341 12 " " '' 19768 341 13 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19768 341 14 , , , 19768 341 15 was be VBD 19768 341 16 published publish VBN 19768 341 17 without without IN 19768 341 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 341 19 article article NN 19768 341 20 . . . 19768 342 1 The the DT 19768 342 2 latter latter JJ 19768 342 3 was be VBD 19768 342 4 all all DT 19768 342 5 in in IN 19768 342 6 type type NN 19768 342 7 , , , 19768 342 8 and and CC 19768 342 9 the the DT 19768 342 10 proof proof NN 19768 342 11 - - HYPH 19768 342 12 sheets sheet NNS 19768 342 13 had have VBD 19768 342 14 been be VBN 19768 342 15 corrected correct VBN 19768 342 16 ; ; : 19768 342 17 nothing nothing NN 19768 342 18 prevented prevent VBD 19768 342 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 342 20 publication publication NN 19768 342 21 in in IN 19768 342 22 April April NNP 19768 342 23 except except IN 19768 342 24 ( ( -LRB- 19768 342 25 1 1 CD 19768 342 26 ) ) -RRB- 19768 342 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 342 28 Royce Royce NNP 19768 342 29 's 's POS 19768 342 30 insistence insistence NN 19768 342 31 that that IN 19768 342 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 342 33 reply reply NN 19768 342 34 to to IN 19768 342 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 342 36 first first JJ 19768 342 37 libel libel NN 19768 342 38 should should MD 19768 342 39 _ _ NNP 19768 342 40 not not RB 19768 342 41 be be VB 19768 342 42 published publish VBN 19768 342 43 at at RB 19768 342 44 all all RB 19768 342 45 without without IN 19768 342 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 342 47 second second JJ 19768 342 48 libel libel NN 19768 342 49 _ _ NNP 19768 342 50 , , , 19768 342 51 and and CC 19768 342 52 ( ( -LRB- 19768 342 53 2 2 LS 19768 342 54 ) ) -RRB- 19768 342 55 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 342 56 Adler Adler NNP 19768 342 57 's 's POS 19768 342 58 weak weak JJ 19768 342 59 submission submission NN 19768 342 60 to to IN 19768 342 61 this this DT 19768 342 62 unjust unjust JJ 19768 342 63 and and CC 19768 342 64 pusillanimous pusillanimous JJ 19768 342 65 demand demand NN 19768 342 66 of of IN 19768 342 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 342 68 associate associate NN 19768 342 69 . . . 19768 343 1 The the DT 19768 343 2 whole whole JJ 19768 343 3 matter matter NN 19768 343 4 was be VBD 19768 343 5 thus thus RB 19768 343 6 most most RBS 19768 343 7 inequitably inequitably RB 19768 343 8 postponed postpone VBN 19768 343 9 to to IN 19768 343 10 the the DT 19768 343 11 July July NNP 19768 343 12 number number NN 19768 343 13 , , , 19768 343 14 primarily primarily RB 19768 343 15 at at IN 19768 343 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 343 17 Royce Royce NNP 19768 343 18 's 's POS 19768 343 19 instigation instigation NN 19768 343 20 . . . 19768 344 1 But but CC 19768 344 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 344 3 now now RB 19768 344 4 found find VBD 19768 344 5 that that IN 19768 344 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 344 7 was be VBD 19768 344 8 to to TO 19768 344 9 be be VB 19768 344 10 refused refuse VBN 19768 344 11 the the DT 19768 344 12 freedom freedom NN 19768 344 13 necessary necessary JJ 19768 344 14 to to IN 19768 344 15 self self NN 19768 344 16 - - HYPH 19768 344 17 defence defence NN 19768 344 18 against against IN 19768 344 19 the the DT 19768 344 20 second second JJ 19768 344 21 libel libel NN 19768 344 22 -- -- : 19768 344 23 the the DT 19768 344 24 same same JJ 19768 344 25 freedom freedom NN 19768 344 26 already already RB 19768 344 27 yielded yield VBN 19768 344 28 in in IN 19768 344 29 replying reply VBG 19768 344 30 to to IN 19768 344 31 the the DT 19768 344 32 first first JJ 19768 344 33 . . . 19768 345 1 Now now RB 19768 345 2 to to TO 19768 345 3 answer answer VB 19768 345 4 a a DT 19768 345 5 libel libel NN 19768 345 6 effectively effectively RB 19768 345 7 requires require VBZ 19768 345 8 the the DT 19768 345 9 freedom freedom NN 19768 345 10 , , , 19768 345 11 not not RB 19768 345 12 of of IN 19768 345 13 the the DT 19768 345 14 parliament parliament NN 19768 345 15 , , , 19768 345 16 but but CC 19768 345 17 of of IN 19768 345 18 the the DT 19768 345 19 courts court NNS 19768 345 20 . . . 19768 346 1 A a DT 19768 346 2 mere mere JJ 19768 346 3 literary literary JJ 19768 346 4 discussion discussion NN 19768 346 5 admits admit NNS 19768 346 6 of of IN 19768 346 7 parliamentary parliamentary JJ 19768 346 8 freedom freedom NN 19768 346 9 alone alone RB 19768 346 10 , , , 19768 346 11 and and CC 19768 346 12 properly properly RB 19768 346 13 excludes exclude VBZ 19768 346 14 all all DT 19768 346 15 reflections reflection NNS 19768 346 16 upon upon IN 19768 346 17 personal personal JJ 19768 346 18 character character NN 19768 346 19 . . . 19768 347 1 But but CC 19768 347 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 347 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 347 4 had have VBD 19768 347 5 most most RBS 19768 347 6 unparliamentarily unparliamentarily RB 19768 347 7 turned turn VBN 19768 347 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 347 9 ostensible ostensible JJ 19768 347 10 review review NN 19768 347 11 into into IN 19768 347 12 a a DT 19768 347 13 libel libel NN 19768 347 14 , , , 19768 347 15 and and CC 19768 347 16 , , , 19768 347 17 contrary contrary JJ 19768 347 18 to to IN 19768 347 19 all all DT 19768 347 20 canons canon NNS 19768 347 21 of of IN 19768 347 22 literary literary JJ 19768 347 23 discussion discussion NN 19768 347 24 , , , 19768 347 25 had have VBD 19768 347 26 indulged indulge VBN 19768 347 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 347 28 in in IN 19768 347 29 reflections reflection NNS 19768 347 30 upon upon IN 19768 347 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 347 32 personal personal JJ 19768 347 33 character character NN 19768 347 34 as as RB 19768 347 35 malicious malicious JJ 19768 347 36 as as IN 19768 347 37 they -PRON- PRP 19768 347 38 were be VBD 19768 347 39 false false JJ 19768 347 40 . . . 19768 348 1 Now now RB 19768 348 2 the the DT 19768 348 3 only only JJ 19768 348 4 possible possible JJ 19768 348 5 disproof disproof NN 19768 348 6 of of IN 19768 348 7 a a DT 19768 348 8 libel libel NN 19768 348 9 is be VBZ 19768 348 10 the the DT 19768 348 11 proof proof NN 19768 348 12 that that IN 19768 348 13 it -PRON- PRP 19768 348 14 _ _ NNP 19768 348 15 is be VBZ 19768 348 16 _ _ NNP 19768 348 17 a a DT 19768 348 18 libel,--that libel,--that . 19768 348 19 it -PRON- PRP 19768 348 20 is be VBZ 19768 348 21 either either CC 19768 348 22 untruthful untruthful JJ 19768 348 23 , , , 19768 348 24 or or CC 19768 348 25 malicious malicious JJ 19768 348 26 , , , 19768 348 27 or or CC 19768 348 28 both both DT 19768 348 29 ; ; : 19768 348 30 and and CC 19768 348 31 , , , 19768 348 32 since since IN 19768 348 33 a a DT 19768 348 34 libel libel NN 19768 348 35 is be VBZ 19768 348 36 both both CC 19768 348 37 a a DT 19768 348 38 civil civil JJ 19768 348 39 injury injury NN 19768 348 40 and and CC 19768 348 41 a a DT 19768 348 42 criminal criminal JJ 19768 348 43 offence offence NN 19768 348 44 , , , 19768 348 45 the the DT 19768 348 46 proof proof NN 19768 348 47 of of IN 19768 348 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 348 49 libellous libellous JJ 19768 348 50 character character NN 19768 348 51 can can MD 19768 348 52 not not RB 19768 348 53 be be VB 19768 348 54 established establish VBN 19768 348 55 without without IN 19768 348 56 reflecting reflect VBG 19768 348 57 upon upon IN 19768 348 58 the the DT 19768 348 59 personal personal JJ 19768 348 60 character character NN 19768 348 61 of of IN 19768 348 62 the the DT 19768 348 63 libeller libeller NN 19768 348 64 . . . 19768 349 1 Hence hence RB 19768 349 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 349 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 349 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 349 5 , , , 19768 349 6 by by IN 19768 349 7 writing write VBG 19768 349 8 a a DT 19768 349 9 libel libel NN 19768 349 10 , , , 19768 349 11 had have VBD 19768 349 12 self self NN 19768 349 13 - - HYPH 19768 349 14 evidently evidently RB 19768 349 15 raised raise VBD 19768 349 16 the the DT 19768 349 17 question question NN 19768 349 18 of of IN 19768 349 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 349 20 own own JJ 19768 349 21 personal personal JJ 19768 349 22 character character NN 19768 349 23 , , , 19768 349 24 and and CC 19768 349 25 bound bind VBD 19768 349 26 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 349 27 beforehand beforehand RB 19768 349 28 , , , 19768 349 29 by by IN 19768 349 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 349 31 own own JJ 19768 349 32 act act NN 19768 349 33 , , , 19768 349 34 to to TO 19768 349 35 submit submit VB 19768 349 36 with with IN 19768 349 37 what what WDT 19768 349 38 grace grace NN 19768 349 39 he -PRON- PRP 19768 349 40 could could MD 19768 349 41 to to IN 19768 349 42 the the DT 19768 349 43 necessary necessary JJ 19768 349 44 consequences consequence NNS 19768 349 45 of of IN 19768 349 46 that that DT 19768 349 47 act act NN 19768 349 48 ; ; : 19768 349 49 and and CC 19768 349 50 to to TO 19768 349 51 seek seek VB 19768 349 52 to to TO 19768 349 53 shield shield VB 19768 349 54 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 349 55 from from IN 19768 349 56 these these DT 19768 349 57 consequences consequence NNS 19768 349 58 , , , 19768 349 59 which which WDT 19768 349 60 he -PRON- PRP 19768 349 61 should should MD 19768 349 62 have have VB 19768 349 63 foreseen foresee VBN 19768 349 64 clearly clearly RB 19768 349 65 and and CC 19768 349 66 nerved nerve VBD 19768 349 67 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 349 68 to to TO 19768 349 69 bear bear VB 19768 349 70 bravely bravely RB 19768 349 71 , , , 19768 349 72 was be VBD 19768 349 73 only only RB 19768 349 74 to to TO 19768 349 75 incur incur VB 19768 349 76 the the DT 19768 349 77 ridicule ridicule NN 19768 349 78 invited invite VBN 19768 349 79 by by IN 19768 349 80 a a DT 19768 349 81 timorous timorous JJ 19768 349 82 man man NN 19768 349 83 who who WP 19768 349 84 first first RB 19768 349 85 strikes strike VBZ 19768 349 86 another another DT 19768 349 87 and and CC 19768 349 88 then then RB 19768 349 89 runs run VBZ 19768 349 90 away away RB 19768 349 91 . . . 19768 350 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 350 2 Adler Adler NNP 19768 350 3 , , , 19768 350 4 moreover moreover RB 19768 350 5 , , , 19768 350 6 as as IN 19768 350 7 the the DT 19768 350 8 responsible responsible JJ 19768 350 9 editor editor NN 19768 350 10 of of IN 19768 350 11 the the DT 19768 350 12 " " `` 19768 350 13 Journal Journal NNP 19768 350 14 of of IN 19768 350 15 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 350 16 , , , 19768 350 17 " " '' 19768 350 18 had have VBD 19768 350 19 laid lay VBN 19768 350 20 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 350 21 , , , 19768 350 22 by by IN 19768 350 23 publishing publish VBG 19768 350 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 350 25 Royce Royce NNP 19768 350 26 's 's POS 19768 350 27 libel libel NN 19768 350 28 , , , 19768 350 29 under under IN 19768 350 30 the the DT 19768 350 31 clear clear JJ 19768 350 32 moral moral JJ 19768 350 33 obligation obligation NN 19768 350 34 of of IN 19768 350 35 according accord VBG 19768 350 36 to to IN 19768 350 37 the the DT 19768 350 38 accused accuse VBN 19768 350 39 the the DT 19768 350 40 same same JJ 19768 350 41 freedom freedom NN 19768 350 42 of of IN 19768 350 43 the the DT 19768 350 44 courts court NNS 19768 350 45 which which WDT 19768 350 46 he -PRON- PRP 19768 350 47 had have VBD 19768 350 48 already already RB 19768 350 49 accorded accord VBN 19768 350 50 to to IN 19768 350 51 the the DT 19768 350 52 accuser accuser NN 19768 350 53 ; ; : 19768 350 54 and and CC 19768 350 55 to to TO 19768 350 56 seek seek VB 19768 350 57 to to TO 19768 350 58 escape escape VB 19768 350 59 this this DT 19768 350 60 moral moral JJ 19768 350 61 obligation obligation NN 19768 350 62 was be VBD 19768 350 63 to to TO 19768 350 64 incur incur VB 19768 350 65 the the DT 19768 350 66 censure censure NN 19768 350 67 invited invite VBN 19768 350 68 by by IN 19768 350 69 any any DT 19768 350 70 one one NN 19768 350 71 who who WP 19768 350 72 assumes assume VBZ 19768 350 73 the the DT 19768 350 74 editorial editorial JJ 19768 350 75 function function NN 19768 350 76 without without IN 19768 350 77 properly properly RB 19768 350 78 informing inform VBG 19768 350 79 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 350 80 of of IN 19768 350 81 the the DT 19768 350 82 duties duty NNS 19768 350 83 which which WDT 19768 350 84 it -PRON- PRP 19768 350 85 imposes impose VBZ 19768 350 86 with with IN 19768 350 87 reference reference NN 19768 350 88 to to IN 19768 350 89 third third JJ 19768 350 90 parties party NNS 19768 350 91 . . . 19768 351 1 Both both DT 19768 351 2 the the DT 19768 351 3 one one NN 19768 351 4 and and CC 19768 351 5 the the DT 19768 351 6 other other JJ 19768 351 7 had have VBD 19768 351 8 estopped estop VBN 19768 351 9 themselves -PRON- PRP 19768 351 10 from from IN 19768 351 11 denying deny VBG 19768 351 12 to to IN 19768 351 13 the the DT 19768 351 14 accused accuse VBN 19768 351 15 in in IN 19768 351 16 self self NN 19768 351 17 - - HYPH 19768 351 18 defence defence NN 19768 351 19 the the DT 19768 351 20 same same JJ 19768 351 21 freedom freedom NN 19768 351 22 of of IN 19768 351 23 the the DT 19768 351 24 courts court NNS 19768 351 25 which which WDT 19768 351 26 they -PRON- PRP 19768 351 27 had have VBD 19768 351 28 granted grant VBN 19768 351 29 to to IN 19768 351 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 19768 351 31 as as IN 19768 351 32 accusers accuser NNS 19768 351 33 in in IN 19768 351 34 attack attack NN 19768 351 35 . . . 19768 352 1 Notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 19768 352 2 these these DT 19768 352 3 plain plain JJ 19768 352 4 facts fact NNS 19768 352 5 , , , 19768 352 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 352 7 Royce Royce NNP 19768 352 8 and and CC 19768 352 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 352 10 Adler Adler NNP 19768 352 11 united united JJ 19768 352 12 in in IN 19768 352 13 denying deny VBG 19768 352 14 to to IN 19768 352 15 me -PRON- PRP 19768 352 16 the the DT 19768 352 17 necessary necessary JJ 19768 352 18 freedom freedom NN 19768 352 19 of of IN 19768 352 20 self self NN 19768 352 21 - - HYPH 19768 352 22 defence defence NN 19768 352 23 against against IN 19768 352 24 the the DT 19768 352 25 attack attack NN 19768 352 26 which which WDT 19768 352 27 they -PRON- PRP 19768 352 28 had have VBD 19768 352 29 united unite VBN 19768 352 30 in in IN 19768 352 31 making make VBG 19768 352 32 . . . 19768 353 1 At at IN 19768 353 2 first first RB 19768 353 3 , , , 19768 353 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 353 5 Royce Royce NNP 19768 353 6 undertook undertake VBD 19768 353 7 to to TO 19768 353 8 dictate dictate VB 19768 353 9 to to IN 19768 353 10 me -PRON- PRP 19768 353 11 beforehand beforehand IN 19768 353 12 the the DT 19768 353 13 nature nature NN 19768 353 14 of of IN 19768 353 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 353 16 reply reply NN 19768 353 17 to to IN 19768 353 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 353 19 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 353 20 , , , 19768 353 21 and and CC 19768 353 22 sought seek VBD 19768 353 23 to to TO 19768 353 24 restrict restrict VB 19768 353 25 it -PRON- PRP 19768 353 26 to to IN 19768 353 27 the the DT 19768 353 28 parliamentary parliamentary JJ 19768 353 29 freedom freedom NN 19768 353 30 of of IN 19768 353 31 a a DT 19768 353 32 purely purely RB 19768 353 33 literary literary JJ 19768 353 34 discussion discussion NN 19768 353 35 . . . 19768 354 1 Ignoring ignore VBG 19768 354 2 the the DT 19768 354 3 fact fact NN 19768 354 4 that that IN 19768 354 5 he -PRON- PRP 19768 354 6 had have VBD 19768 354 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 354 8 rendered render VBN 19768 354 9 a a DT 19768 354 10 purely purely RB 19768 354 11 literary literary JJ 19768 354 12 discussion discussion NN 19768 354 13 impossible impossible JJ 19768 354 14 by by IN 19768 354 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 354 16 own own JJ 19768 354 17 reflections reflection NNS 19768 354 18 upon upon IN 19768 354 19 personal personal JJ 19768 354 20 character character NN 19768 354 21 , , , 19768 354 22 he -PRON- PRP 19768 354 23 endeavored endeavor VBD 19768 354 24 now now RB 19768 354 25 to to TO 19768 354 26 restrict restrict VB 19768 354 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 354 28 defence defence NN 19768 354 29 to to IN 19768 354 30 a a DT 19768 354 31 purely purely RB 19768 354 32 literary literary JJ 19768 354 33 discussion discussion NN 19768 354 34 of of IN 19768 354 35 what what WP 19768 354 36 , , , 19768 354 37 with with IN 19768 354 38 amusing amusing JJ 19768 354 39 deficiency deficiency NN 19768 354 40 in in IN 19768 354 41 the the DT 19768 354 42 sense sense NN 19768 354 43 of of IN 19768 354 44 humor humor NN 19768 354 45 , , , 19768 354 46 he -PRON- PRP 19768 354 47 considered consider VBD 19768 354 48 to to TO 19768 354 49 be be VB 19768 354 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 354 51 " " `` 19768 354 52 criticisms criticism NNS 19768 354 53 " " '' 19768 354 54 ; ; : 19768 354 55 whereas whereas IN 19768 354 56 these these DT 19768 354 57 pointless pointless JJ 19768 354 58 and and CC 19768 354 59 ignorant ignorant JJ 19768 354 60 criticisms criticism NNS 19768 354 61 had have VBD 19768 354 62 no no DT 19768 354 63 importance importance NN 19768 354 64 whatever whatever WDT 19768 354 65 except except IN 19768 354 66 as as IN 19768 354 67 leading lead VBG 19768 354 68 up up RP 19768 354 69 to to IN 19768 354 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 354 71 " " `` 19768 354 72 professional professional JJ 19768 354 73 warning warning NN 19768 354 74 . . . 19768 354 75 " " '' 19768 355 1 The the DT 19768 355 2 only only JJ 19768 355 3 object object NN 19768 355 4 of of IN 19768 355 5 a a DT 19768 355 6 reply reply NN 19768 355 7 to to IN 19768 355 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 355 9 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 355 10 was be VBD 19768 355 11 to to TO 19768 355 12 expose expose VB 19768 355 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 355 14 true true JJ 19768 355 15 character character NN 19768 355 16 as as IN 19768 355 17 a a DT 19768 355 18 second second JJ 19768 355 19 libel libel NN 19768 355 20 , , , 19768 355 21 and and CC 19768 355 22 thereby thereby RB 19768 355 23 make make VB 19768 355 24 plain plain JJ 19768 355 25 to to IN 19768 355 26 the the DT 19768 355 27 dullest dull JJS 19768 355 28 mind mind NN 19768 355 29 the the DT 19768 355 30 outrage outrage NN 19768 355 31 of of IN 19768 355 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 355 33 " " `` 19768 355 34 professional professional JJ 19768 355 35 warning warning NN 19768 355 36 . . . 19768 355 37 " " '' 19768 356 1 Evidently evidently RB 19768 356 2 fearing fear VBG 19768 356 3 this this DT 19768 356 4 , , , 19768 356 5 and and CC 19768 356 6 being be VBG 19768 356 7 anxious anxious JJ 19768 356 8 to to TO 19768 356 9 prevent prevent VB 19768 356 10 the the DT 19768 356 11 exposure exposure NN 19768 356 12 , , , 19768 356 13 he -PRON- PRP 19768 356 14 sent send VBD 19768 356 15 to to IN 19768 356 16 me -PRON- PRP 19768 356 17 through through IN 19768 356 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 356 19 Weston Weston NNP 19768 356 20 , , , 19768 356 21 who who WP 19768 356 22 called call VBD 19768 356 23 upon upon IN 19768 356 24 me -PRON- PRP 19768 356 25 for for IN 19768 356 26 the the DT 19768 356 27 purpose purpose NN 19768 356 28 on on IN 19768 356 29 April April NNP 19768 356 30 15 15 CD 19768 356 31 , , , 19768 356 32 the the DT 19768 356 33 following follow VBG 19768 356 34 unspeakable unspeakable JJ 19768 356 35 document document NN 19768 356 36 , , , 19768 356 37 apparently apparently RB 19768 356 38 without without IN 19768 356 39 a a DT 19768 356 40 suspicion suspicion NN 19768 356 41 that that WDT 19768 356 42 it -PRON- PRP 19768 356 43 pricked prick VBD 19768 356 44 the the DT 19768 356 45 bubble bubble NN 19768 356 46 of of IN 19768 356 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 356 48 previous previous JJ 19768 356 49 iridescent iridescent JJ 19768 356 50 pledge pledge NN 19768 356 51 to to TO 19768 356 52 " " `` 19768 356 53 ask ask VB 19768 356 54 no no DT 19768 356 55 mercy":-- mercy":-- NNP 19768 356 56 MEMORANDUM MEMORANDUM NNP 19768 356 57 OF of IN 19768 356 58 APR APR NNP 19768 356 59 . . . 19768 357 1 13 13 CD 19768 357 2 , , , 19768 357 3 1891 1891 CD 19768 357 4 . . . 19768 358 1 1 1 LS 19768 358 2 . . . 19768 359 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 359 2 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 359 3 's 's POS 19768 359 4 article article NN 19768 359 5 must must MD 19768 359 6 be be VB 19768 359 7 in in IN 19768 359 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 359 9 Weston Weston NNP 19768 359 10 's 's POS 19768 359 11 hands hand NNS 19768 359 12 in in IN 19768 359 13 MS MS NNP 19768 359 14 . . . 19768 359 15 by by IN 19768 359 16 June June NNP 19768 359 17 1 1 CD 19768 359 18 , , , 19768 359 19 for for IN 19768 359 20 issue issue NN 19768 359 21 in in IN 19768 359 22 the the DT 19768 359 23 July July NNP 19768 359 24 No No NNP 19768 359 25 . . . 19768 359 26 , , , 19768 359 27 if if IN 19768 359 28 possible possible JJ 19768 359 29 . . . 19768 360 1 2 2 LS 19768 360 2 . . . 19768 361 1 This this DT 19768 361 2 article article NN 19768 361 3 must must MD 19768 361 4 not not RB 19768 361 5 exceed exceed VB 19768 361 6 , , , 19768 361 7 in in IN 19768 361 8 actual actual JJ 19768 361 9 number number NN 19768 361 10 of of IN 19768 361 11 words word NNS 19768 361 12 , , , 19768 361 13 Prof. Prof. NNP 19768 361 14 Royce Royce NNP 19768 361 15 's 's POS 19768 361 16 last last JJ 19768 361 17 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 361 18 . . . 19768 362 1 3 3 LS 19768 362 2 . . . 19768 363 1 Prof. Prof. NNP 19768 363 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 363 3 is be VBZ 19768 363 4 not not RB 19768 363 5 to to TO 19768 363 6 reply reply VB 19768 363 7 to to IN 19768 363 8 the the DT 19768 363 9 above above JJ 19768 363 10 article article NN 19768 363 11 of of IN 19768 363 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 363 13 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 363 14 before before IN 19768 363 15 or or CC 19768 363 16 simultaneously simultaneously RB 19768 363 17 with with IN 19768 363 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 363 19 publication publication NN 19768 363 20 in in IN 19768 363 21 the the DT 19768 363 22 " " `` 19768 363 23 Journal Journal NNP 19768 363 24 of of IN 19768 363 25 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 363 26 " " '' 19768 363 27 ; ; : 19768 363 28 and and CC 19768 363 29 the the DT 19768 363 30 controversy controversy NN 19768 363 31 is be VBZ 19768 363 32 thus thus RB 19768 363 33 to to TO 19768 363 34 be be VB 19768 363 35 closed close VBN 19768 363 36 in in IN 19768 363 37 the the DT 19768 363 38 " " `` 19768 363 39 Journal Journal NNP 19768 363 40 " " '' 19768 363 41 by by IN 19768 363 42 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 363 43 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 363 44 . . . 19768 364 1 4 4 LS 19768 364 2 . . . 19768 365 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 365 2 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 365 3 's 's POS 19768 365 4 article article NN 19768 365 5 is be VBZ 19768 365 6 to to TO 19768 365 7 be be VB 19768 365 8 strictly strictly RB 19768 365 9 a a DT 19768 365 10 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 365 11 , , , 19768 365 12 is be VBZ 19768 365 13 not not RB 19768 365 14 to to TO 19768 365 15 raise raise VB 19768 365 16 essentially essentially RB 19768 365 17 new new JJ 19768 365 18 issues issue NNS 19768 365 19 , , , 19768 365 20 is be VBZ 19768 365 21 not not RB 19768 365 22 to to TO 19768 365 23 assault assault VB 19768 365 24 any any DT 19768 365 25 further further RB 19768 365 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 365 27 opponent opponent NN 19768 365 28 's 's POS 19768 365 29 personal personal JJ 19768 365 30 character character NN 19768 365 31 , , , 19768 365 32 is be VBZ 19768 365 33 to to TO 19768 365 34 be be VB 19768 365 35 parliamentary parliamentary JJ 19768 365 36 in in IN 19768 365 37 form form NN 19768 365 38 , , , 19768 365 39 and and CC 19768 365 40 free free JJ 19768 365 41 from from IN 19768 365 42 personally personally RB 19768 365 43 abusive abusive JJ 19768 365 44 language language NN 19768 365 45 . . . 19768 366 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 19768 366 2 it -PRON- PRP 19768 366 3 is be VBZ 19768 366 4 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 366 5 free free JJ 19768 366 6 as as IN 19768 366 7 to to IN 19768 366 8 plainness plainness NN 19768 366 9 of of IN 19768 366 10 speech speech NN 19768 366 11 . . . 19768 367 1 5 5 CD 19768 367 2 . . . 19768 368 1 Prof. Prof. NNP 19768 368 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 368 3 is be VBZ 19768 368 4 to to TO 19768 368 5 see see VB 19768 368 6 this this DT 19768 368 7 article article NN 19768 368 8 at at IN 19768 368 9 once once RB 19768 368 10 , , , 19768 368 11 and and CC 19768 368 12 before before IN 19768 368 13 it -PRON- PRP 19768 368 14 goes go VBZ 19768 368 15 to to IN 19768 368 16 the the DT 19768 368 17 printer printer NN 19768 368 18 . . . 19768 369 1 6 6 CD 19768 369 2 . . . 19768 370 1 Should Should NNP 19768 370 2 Prof. Prof. NNP 19768 370 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 370 4 , , , 19768 370 5 after after IN 19768 370 6 seeing see VBG 19768 370 7 the the DT 19768 370 8 paper paper NN 19768 370 9 , , , 19768 370 10 object object NN 19768 370 11 to to IN 19768 370 12 the the DT 19768 370 13 article article NN 19768 370 14 as as IN 19768 370 15 " " `` 19768 370 16 _ _ NNP 19768 370 17 not not RB 19768 370 18 in in IN 19768 370 19 conformity conformity NN 19768 370 20 with with IN 19768 370 21 the the DT 19768 370 22 conditions condition NNS 19768 370 23 of of IN 19768 370 24 No no UH 19768 370 25 . . . 19768 371 1 4 4 CD 19768 371 2 _ _ NNP 19768 371 3 ( ( -LRB- 19768 371 4 _ _ NNP 19768 371 5 above above IN 19768 371 6 _ _ NNP 19768 371 7 ) ) -RRB- 19768 371 8 , , , 19768 371 9 " " '' 19768 371 10 then then RB 19768 371 11 , , , 19768 371 12 but but CC 19768 371 13 only only RB 19768 371 14 then then RB 19768 371 15 , , , 19768 371 16 the the DT 19768 371 17 article article NN 19768 371 18 is be VBZ 19768 371 19 to to TO 19768 371 20 be be VB 19768 371 21 submitted submit VBN 19768 371 22 , , , 19768 371 23 before before IN 19768 371 24 publication publication NN 19768 371 25 , , , 19768 371 26 to to IN 19768 371 27 the the DT 19768 371 28 judgment judgment NN 19768 371 29 of of IN 19768 371 30 some some DT 19768 371 31 impartial impartial JJ 19768 371 32 friend friend NN 19768 371 33 or or CC 19768 371 34 friends friend NNS 19768 371 35 of of IN 19768 371 36 both both CC 19768 371 37 the the DT 19768 371 38 disputants disputant NNS 19768 371 39 , , , 19768 371 40 such such JJ 19768 371 41 friend friend NN 19768 371 42 or or CC 19768 371 43 friends friend NNS 19768 371 44 to to TO 19768 371 45 be be VB 19768 371 46 chosen choose VBN 19768 371 47 as as RB 19768 371 48 promptly promptly RB 19768 371 49 as as IN 19768 371 50 possible possible JJ 19768 371 51 , , , 19768 371 52 and and CC 19768 371 53 by by IN 19768 371 54 agreement agreement NN 19768 371 55 , , , 19768 371 56 and and CC 19768 371 57 to to TO 19768 371 58 arbitrate arbitrate VB 19768 371 59 the the DT 19768 371 60 question question NN 19768 371 61 , , , 19768 371 62 " " `` 19768 371 63 _ _ NNP 19768 371 64 Whether Whether NNP 19768 371 65 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 371 66 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 371 67 's 's POS 19768 371 68 final final JJ 19768 371 69 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 371 70 is be VBZ 19768 371 71 in in IN 19768 371 72 conformity conformity NN 19768 371 73 with with IN 19768 371 74 the the DT 19768 371 75 conditions condition NNS 19768 371 76 of of IN 19768 371 77 this this DT 19768 371 78 present present JJ 19768 371 79 memorandum memorandum NN 19768 371 80 ? ? . 19768 371 81 _ _ NNP 19768 371 82 " " `` 19768 371 83 The the DT 19768 371 84 arbitrator arbitrator NN 19768 371 85 or or CC 19768 371 86 arbitrators arbitrator NNS 19768 371 87 may may MD 19768 371 88 be be VB 19768 371 89 any any DT 19768 371 90 person person NN 19768 371 91 or or CC 19768 371 92 persons person NNS 19768 371 93 agreable agreable JJ 19768 371 94 [ [ -LRB- 19768 371 95 _ _ NNP 19768 371 96 sic sic NN 19768 371 97 _ _ NNP 19768 371 98 ] ] -RRB- 19768 371 99 to to IN 19768 371 100 the the DT 19768 371 101 wishes wish NNS 19768 371 102 of of IN 19768 371 103 both both CC 19768 371 104 the the DT 19768 371 105 disputants disputant NNS 19768 371 106 , , , 19768 371 107 as as IN 19768 371 108 determined determine VBN 19768 371 109 in in IN 19768 371 110 case case NN 19768 371 111 the the DT 19768 371 112 mentioned mention VBN 19768 371 113 objection objection NN 19768 371 114 of of IN 19768 371 115 Prof. Prof. NNP 19768 371 116 Royce Royce NNP 19768 371 117 should should MD 19768 371 118 be be VB 19768 371 119 made make VBN 19768 371 120 , , , 19768 371 121 but but CC 19768 371 122 not not RB 19768 371 123 otherwise otherwise RB 19768 371 124 . . . 19768 372 1 7 7 LS 19768 372 2 . . . 19768 373 1 Should Should NNP 19768 373 2 Prof. Prof. NNP 19768 373 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 373 4 _ _ NNP 19768 373 5 not not RB 19768 373 6 _ _ NNP 19768 373 7 object object NN 19768 373 8 to to IN 19768 373 9 the the DT 19768 373 10 article article NN 19768 373 11 , , , 19768 373 12 or or CC 19768 373 13 should should MD 19768 373 14 he -PRON- PRP 19768 373 15 not not RB 19768 373 16 formally formally RB 19768 373 17 object object VB 19768 373 18 _ _ NNP 19768 373 19 on on IN 19768 373 20 the the DT 19768 373 21 grounds ground NNS 19768 373 22 mentioned mention VBD 19768 373 23 _ _ NNP 19768 373 24 , , , 19768 373 25 then then RB 19768 373 26 the the DT 19768 373 27 article article NN 19768 373 28 of of IN 19768 373 29 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 373 30 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 373 31 is be VBZ 19768 373 32 to to TO 19768 373 33 close close VB 19768 373 34 the the DT 19768 373 35 controversy controversy NN 19768 373 36 in in IN 19768 373 37 the the DT 19768 373 38 " " `` 19768 373 39 Journal Journal NNP 19768 373 40 of of IN 19768 373 41 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 373 42 . . . 19768 373 43 " " '' 19768 374 1 8 8 LS 19768 374 2 . . . 19768 375 1 Should Should NNP 19768 375 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 375 3 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 375 4 _ _ NNP 19768 375 5 not not RB 19768 375 6 _ _ NNP 19768 375 7 accept accept VBP 19768 375 8 the the DT 19768 375 9 conditions condition NNS 19768 375 10 of of IN 19768 375 11 the the DT 19768 375 12 present present JJ 19768 375 13 memorandum memorandum NN 19768 375 14 , , , 19768 375 15 he -PRON- PRP 19768 375 16 is be VBZ 19768 375 17 at at IN 19768 375 18 liberty liberty NN 19768 375 19 to to TO 19768 375 20 withdraw withdraw VB 19768 375 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 375 22 paper paper NN 19768 375 23 , , , 19768 375 24 or or CC 19768 375 25 else else RB 19768 375 26 to to TO 19768 375 27 let let VB 19768 375 28 both both DT 19768 375 29 the the DT 19768 375 30 papers paper NNS 19768 375 31 now now RB 19768 375 32 in in IN 19768 375 33 type type NN 19768 375 34 appear appear VBP 19768 375 35 as as IN 19768 375 36 they -PRON- PRP 19768 375 37 are be VBP 19768 375 38 , , , 19768 375 39 at at IN 19768 375 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 375 41 pleasure pleasure NN 19768 375 42 . . . 19768 376 1 [ [ -LRB- 19768 376 2 Signed sign VBN 19768 376 3 ] ] -RRB- 19768 376 4 J. J. NNP 19768 376 5 R. R. NNP 19768 376 6 It -PRON- PRP 19768 376 7 is be VBZ 19768 376 8 difficult difficult JJ 19768 376 9 to to TO 19768 376 10 conceive conceive VB 19768 376 11 the the DT 19768 376 12 state state NN 19768 376 13 of of IN 19768 376 14 mind mind NN 19768 376 15 in in IN 19768 376 16 which which WDT 19768 376 17 so so RB 19768 376 18 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19768 376 19 a a DT 19768 376 20 document document NN 19768 376 21 as as IN 19768 376 22 this this DT 19768 376 23 could could MD 19768 376 24 have have VB 19768 376 25 originated originate VBN 19768 376 26 . . . 19768 377 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 19768 377 2 answer answer NN 19768 377 3 to to IN 19768 377 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 377 5 Royce Royce NNP 19768 377 6 's 's POS 19768 377 7 officious officious JJ 19768 377 8 interference interference NN 19768 377 9 was be VBD 19768 377 10 a a DT 19768 377 11 short short JJ 19768 377 12 and and CC 19768 377 13 dry dry JJ 19768 377 14 rejection rejection NN 19768 377 15 _ _ NNP 19768 377 16 in in IN 19768 377 17 toto toto NN 19768 377 18 _ _ NNP 19768 377 19 . . . 19768 378 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 378 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 378 3 was be VBD 19768 378 4 not not RB 19768 378 5 the the DT 19768 378 6 responsible responsible JJ 19768 378 7 editor editor NN 19768 378 8 of of IN 19768 378 9 the the DT 19768 378 10 " " `` 19768 378 11 Journal Journal NNP 19768 378 12 of of IN 19768 378 13 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 378 14 , , , 19768 378 15 " " '' 19768 378 16 and and CC 19768 378 17 had have VBD 19768 378 18 no no DT 19768 378 19 power power NN 19768 378 20 to to TO 19768 378 21 dictate dictate VB 19768 378 22 any any DT 19768 378 23 conditions condition NNS 19768 378 24 of of IN 19768 378 25 publication publication NN 19768 378 26 whatever whatever WDT 19768 378 27 . . . 19768 379 1 That that IN 19768 379 2 a a DT 19768 379 3 libeller libeller NN 19768 379 4 should should MD 19768 379 5 actually actually RB 19768 379 6 presume presume VB 19768 379 7 to to TO 19768 379 8 dictate dictate VB 19768 379 9 to to IN 19768 379 10 the the DT 19768 379 11 libelled libel VBN 19768 379 12 the the DT 19768 379 13 terms term NNS 19768 379 14 of of IN 19768 379 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 379 16 defence defence NN 19768 379 17 , , , 19768 379 18 to to TO 19768 379 19 demand demand VB 19768 379 20 that that IN 19768 379 21 this this DT 19768 379 22 defence defence NN 19768 379 23 should should MD 19768 379 24 be be VB 19768 379 25 submitted submit VBN 19768 379 26 to to IN 19768 379 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 379 28 in in IN 19768 379 29 advance advance NN 19768 379 30 of of IN 19768 379 31 publication publication NN 19768 379 32 for for IN 19768 379 33 approval approval NN 19768 379 34 or or CC 19768 379 35 disapproval disapproval NN 19768 379 36 , , , 19768 379 37 and and CC 19768 379 38 , , , 19768 379 39 in in IN 19768 379 40 case case NN 19768 379 41 of of IN 19768 379 42 disapproval disapproval NN 19768 379 43 , , , 19768 379 44 to to TO 19768 379 45 invoke invoke VB 19768 379 46 a a DT 19768 379 47 board board NN 19768 379 48 of of IN 19768 379 49 referees referee NNS 19768 379 50 for for IN 19768 379 51 the the DT 19768 379 52 sole sole JJ 19768 379 53 purpose purpose NN 19768 379 54 of of IN 19768 379 55 enforcing enforce VBG 19768 379 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 379 57 own own JJ 19768 379 58 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 19768 379 59 and and CC 19768 379 60 preposterous preposterous JJ 19768 379 61 " " '' 19768 379 62 conditions,"--this conditions,"--this PRP 19768 379 63 was be VBD 19768 379 64 too too RB 19768 379 65 exquisitely exquisitely RB 19768 379 66 absurd absurd JJ 19768 379 67 . . . 19768 380 1 But but CC 19768 380 2 there there EX 19768 380 3 was be VBD 19768 380 4 method method NN 19768 380 5 in in IN 19768 380 6 the the DT 19768 380 7 madness madness NN 19768 380 8 . . . 19768 381 1 The the DT 19768 381 2 central central JJ 19768 381 3 aim aim NN 19768 381 4 of of IN 19768 381 5 the the DT 19768 381 6 " " `` 19768 381 7 Memorandum Memorandum NNP 19768 381 8 " " '' 19768 381 9 is be VBZ 19768 381 10 clear clear JJ 19768 381 11 on on IN 19768 381 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 381 13 face face NN 19768 381 14 : : : 19768 381 15 namely namely RB 19768 381 16 , , , 19768 381 17 _ _ NNP 19768 381 18 to to TO 19768 381 19 refuse refuse VB 19768 381 20 the the DT 19768 381 21 forensic forensic JJ 19768 381 22 freedom freedom NN 19768 381 23 necessary necessary JJ 19768 381 24 to to IN 19768 381 25 self self NN 19768 381 26 - - HYPH 19768 381 27 defence defence NN 19768 381 28 against against IN 19768 381 29 a a DT 19768 381 30 libel libel NN 19768 381 31 , , , 19768 381 32 and and CC 19768 381 33 to to TO 19768 381 34 concede concede VB 19768 381 35 only only RB 19768 381 36 the the DT 19768 381 37 parliamentary parliamentary JJ 19768 381 38 freedom freedom NN 19768 381 39 proper proper JJ 19768 381 40 to to IN 19768 381 41 a a DT 19768 381 42 purely purely RB 19768 381 43 literary literary JJ 19768 381 44 discussion discussion NN 19768 381 45 _ _ NNP 19768 381 46 . . . 19768 382 1 Since since IN 19768 382 2 , , , 19768 382 3 however however RB 19768 382 4 , , , 19768 382 5 the the DT 19768 382 6 only only JJ 19768 382 7 object object NN 19768 382 8 of of IN 19768 382 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 382 10 writing writing NN 19768 382 11 at at RB 19768 382 12 all all DT 19768 382 13 was be VBD 19768 382 14 to to TO 19768 382 15 expose expose VB 19768 382 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 382 17 rejoinder rejoinder NN 19768 382 18 as as IN 19768 382 19 a a DT 19768 382 20 second second JJ 19768 382 21 libel libel NN 19768 382 22 , , , 19768 382 23 and and CC 19768 382 24 since since IN 19768 382 25 the the DT 19768 382 26 central central JJ 19768 382 27 aim aim NN 19768 382 28 of of IN 19768 382 29 the the DT 19768 382 30 " " `` 19768 382 31 Memorandum Memorandum NNP 19768 382 32 " " '' 19768 382 33 was be VBD 19768 382 34 to to TO 19768 382 35 defeat defeat VB 19768 382 36 this this DT 19768 382 37 very very JJ 19768 382 38 object object NN 19768 382 39 , , , 19768 382 40 nothing nothing NN 19768 382 41 could could MD 19768 382 42 be be VB 19768 382 43 plainer plainer NN 19768 382 44 than than IN 19768 382 45 this this DT 19768 382 46 : : : 19768 382 47 that that IN 19768 382 48 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 382 49 Royce Royce NNP 19768 382 50 , , , 19768 382 51 having have VBG 19768 382 52 been be VBN 19768 382 53 guilty guilty JJ 19768 382 54 of of IN 19768 382 55 two two CD 19768 382 56 unprovoked unprovoked JJ 19768 382 57 and and CC 19768 382 58 malicious malicious JJ 19768 382 59 libels libel NNS 19768 382 60 , , , 19768 382 61 now now RB 19768 382 62 sought seek VBD 19768 382 63 to to TO 19768 382 64 prevent prevent VB 19768 382 65 the the DT 19768 382 66 exposure exposure NN 19768 382 67 of of IN 19768 382 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 382 69 guilt guilt NN 19768 382 70 by by IN 19768 382 71 suppressing suppress VBG 19768 382 72 the the DT 19768 382 73 necessary necessary JJ 19768 382 74 freedom freedom NN 19768 382 75 of of IN 19768 382 76 self self NN 19768 382 77 - - HYPH 19768 382 78 defence defence NN 19768 382 79 . . . 19768 383 1 For for IN 19768 383 2 , , , 19768 383 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 383 4 repeat repeat VBP 19768 383 5 , , , 19768 383 6 the the DT 19768 383 7 only only JJ 19768 383 8 possible possible JJ 19768 383 9 defence defence NN 19768 383 10 against against IN 19768 383 11 a a DT 19768 383 12 libel libel NN 19768 383 13 is be VBZ 19768 383 14 to to TO 19768 383 15 prove prove VB 19768 383 16 that that IN 19768 383 17 it -PRON- PRP 19768 383 18 _ _ NNP 19768 383 19 is be VBZ 19768 383 20 _ _ NNP 19768 383 21 a a DT 19768 383 22 libel libel NN 19768 383 23 , , , 19768 383 24 and and CC 19768 383 25 this this DT 19768 383 26 can can MD 19768 383 27 not not RB 19768 383 28 be be VB 19768 383 29 done do VBN 19768 383 30 without without IN 19768 383 31 reflecting reflect VBG 19768 383 32 upon upon IN 19768 383 33 the the DT 19768 383 34 " " `` 19768 383 35 personal personal JJ 19768 383 36 character character NN 19768 383 37 " " '' 19768 383 38 of of IN 19768 383 39 the the DT 19768 383 40 libeller libeller NN 19768 383 41 . . . 19768 384 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 384 2 was be VBD 19768 384 3 no no DT 19768 384 4 fault fault NN 19768 384 5 of of IN 19768 384 6 mine mine NN 19768 384 7 that that IN 19768 384 8 he -PRON- PRP 19768 384 9 had have VBD 19768 384 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 384 11 rendered render VBN 19768 384 12 a a DT 19768 384 13 " " `` 19768 384 14 parliamentary parliamentary JJ 19768 384 15 " " '' 19768 384 16 discussion discussion NN 19768 384 17 impossible impossible JJ 19768 384 18 ; ; : 19768 384 19 it -PRON- PRP 19768 384 20 was be VBD 19768 384 21 no no DT 19768 384 22 fault fault NN 19768 384 23 of of IN 19768 384 24 mine mine NN 19768 384 25 that that IN 19768 384 26 he -PRON- PRP 19768 384 27 had have VBD 19768 384 28 made make VBN 19768 384 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 384 30 own own JJ 19768 384 31 " " `` 19768 384 32 personal personal JJ 19768 384 33 character character NN 19768 384 34 " " '' 19768 384 35 the the DT 19768 384 36 real real JJ 19768 384 37 point point NN 19768 384 38 at at IN 19768 384 39 issue issue NN 19768 384 40 ; ; : 19768 384 41 it -PRON- PRP 19768 384 42 was be VBD 19768 384 43 no no DT 19768 384 44 fault fault NN 19768 384 45 of of IN 19768 384 46 mine mine NN 19768 384 47 that that IN 19768 384 48 he -PRON- PRP 19768 384 49 now now RB 19768 384 50 betrayed betray VBD 19768 384 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 384 52 secret secret JJ 19768 384 53 alarm alarm NN 19768 384 54 , , , 19768 384 55 uttered utter VBD 19768 384 56 a a DT 19768 384 57 cry cry NN 19768 384 58 for for IN 19768 384 59 " " `` 19768 384 60 mercy mercy NN 19768 384 61 , , , 19768 384 62 " " '' 19768 384 63 and and CC 19768 384 64 convicted convict VBD 19768 384 65 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 384 66 out out IN 19768 384 67 of of IN 19768 384 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 384 69 own own JJ 19768 384 70 mouth mouth NN 19768 384 71 , , , 19768 384 72 in in IN 19768 384 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 384 74 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19768 384 75 and and CC 19768 384 76 indescribable indescribable JJ 19768 384 77 " " `` 19768 384 78 Memorandum Memorandum NNP 19768 384 79 . . . 19768 384 80 " " '' 19768 385 1 That that IN 19768 385 2 " " `` 19768 385 3 Memorandum Memorandum NNP 19768 385 4 " " '' 19768 385 5 tells tell VBZ 19768 385 6 the the DT 19768 385 7 whole whole JJ 19768 385 8 story story NN 19768 385 9 . . . 19768 386 1 On on IN 19768 386 2 the the DT 19768 386 3 failure failure NN 19768 386 4 of of IN 19768 386 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 386 6 Royce Royce NNP 19768 386 7 's 's POS 19768 386 8 very very RB 19768 386 9 injudicious injudicious JJ 19768 386 10 attempt attempt NN 19768 386 11 at at IN 19768 386 12 dictation dictation NN 19768 386 13 , , , 19768 386 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 386 15 Adler Adler NNP 19768 386 16 found find VBD 19768 386 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 386 18 compelled compel VBN 19768 386 19 to to TO 19768 386 20 assume assume VB 19768 386 21 the the DT 19768 386 22 editorial editorial JJ 19768 386 23 power power NN 19768 386 24 and and CC 19768 386 25 responsibility responsibility NN 19768 386 26 , , , 19768 386 27 which which WDT 19768 386 28 he -PRON- PRP 19768 386 29 ought ought MD 19768 386 30 to to TO 19768 386 31 have have VB 19768 386 32 assumed assume VBN 19768 386 33 and and CC 19768 386 34 exercised exercise VBN 19768 386 35 in in IN 19768 386 36 the the DT 19768 386 37 first first JJ 19768 386 38 instance instance NN 19768 386 39 by by IN 19768 386 40 refusing refuse VBG 19768 386 41 publication publication NN 19768 386 42 to to IN 19768 386 43 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 386 44 Royce Royce NNP 19768 386 45 's 's POS 19768 386 46 original original JJ 19768 386 47 libel libel NN 19768 386 48 . . . 19768 387 1 But but CC 19768 387 2 , , , 19768 387 3 yielding yield VBG 19768 387 4 to to IN 19768 387 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 387 6 Royce Royce NNP 19768 387 7 's 's POS 19768 387 8 influence influence NN 19768 387 9 , , , 19768 387 10 he -PRON- PRP 19768 387 11 took take VBD 19768 387 12 the the DT 19768 387 13 same same JJ 19768 387 14 position position NN 19768 387 15 , , , 19768 387 16 and and CC 19768 387 17 still still RB 19768 387 18 tried try VBD 19768 387 19 to to TO 19768 387 20 shield shield VB 19768 387 21 the the DT 19768 387 22 libeller libeller NN 19768 387 23 from from IN 19768 387 24 the the DT 19768 387 25 just just JJ 19768 387 26 and and CC 19768 387 27 lawful lawful JJ 19768 387 28 consequences consequence NNS 19768 387 29 of of IN 19768 387 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 387 31 libel libel NN 19768 387 32 . . . 19768 388 1 No no DT 19768 388 2 principle principle NN 19768 388 3 is be VBZ 19768 388 4 more more RBR 19768 388 5 firmly firmly RB 19768 388 6 established establish VBN 19768 388 7 in in IN 19768 388 8 the the DT 19768 388 9 public public JJ 19768 388 10 conscience conscience NN 19768 388 11 , , , 19768 388 12 as as IN 19768 388 13 interpreted interpret VBN 19768 388 14 by by IN 19768 388 15 the the DT 19768 388 16 common common JJ 19768 388 17 law law NN 19768 388 18 , , , 19768 388 19 than than IN 19768 388 20 that that IN 19768 388 21 the the DT 19768 388 22 fact fact NN 19768 388 23 of of IN 19768 388 24 an an DT 19768 388 25 attack attack NN 19768 388 26 by by IN 19768 388 27 A a DT 19768 388 28 involves involve VBZ 19768 388 29 the the DT 19768 388 30 right right NN 19768 388 31 of of IN 19768 388 32 self self NN 19768 388 33 - - HYPH 19768 388 34 defence defence NN 19768 388 35 by by IN 19768 388 36 B. B. NNP 19768 388 37 Whoever Whoever NNP 19768 388 38 , , , 19768 388 39 therefore therefore RB 19768 388 40 , , , 19768 388 41 has have VBZ 19768 388 42 permitted permit VBN 19768 388 43 an an DT 19768 388 44 attack attack NN 19768 388 45 which which WDT 19768 388 46 he -PRON- PRP 19768 388 47 might may MD 19768 388 48 have have VB 19768 388 49 prevented prevent VBN 19768 388 50 is be VBZ 19768 388 51 bound bind VBN 19768 388 52 to to TO 19768 388 53 permit permit VB 19768 388 54 the the DT 19768 388 55 self self NN 19768 388 56 - - HYPH 19768 388 57 defence defence NN 19768 388 58 , , , 19768 388 59 also also RB 19768 388 60 ; ; : 19768 388 61 and and CC 19768 388 62 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 388 63 Adler Adler NNP 19768 388 64 , , , 19768 388 65 having have VBG 19768 388 66 granted grant VBN 19768 388 67 to to IN 19768 388 68 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 388 69 Royce Royce NNP 19768 388 70 the the DT 19768 388 71 freedom freedom NN 19768 388 72 of of IN 19768 388 73 libelling libel VBG 19768 388 74 me -PRON- PRP 19768 388 75 , , , 19768 388 76 was be VBD 19768 388 77 bound bind VBN 19768 388 78 to to TO 19768 388 79 grant grant VB 19768 388 80 to to IN 19768 388 81 me -PRON- PRP 19768 388 82 the the DT 19768 388 83 equal equal JJ 19768 388 84 freedom freedom NN 19768 388 85 of of IN 19768 388 86 defending defend VBG 19768 388 87 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 388 88 against against IN 19768 388 89 the the DT 19768 388 90 libel libel NN 19768 388 91 . . . 19768 389 1 But but CC 19768 389 2 this this DT 19768 389 3 equal equal JJ 19768 389 4 freedom freedom NN 19768 389 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 389 6 Adler Adler NNP 19768 389 7 denied deny VBD 19768 389 8 . . . 19768 390 1 After after IN 19768 390 2 some some DT 19768 390 3 fruitless fruitless JJ 19768 390 4 correspondence correspondence NN 19768 390 5 , , , 19768 390 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 390 7 wrote write VBD 19768 390 8 to to IN 19768 390 9 him -PRON- PRP 19768 390 10 on on IN 19768 390 11 May May NNP 19768 390 12 4 4 CD 19768 390 13 as as IN 19768 390 14 follows follow VBZ 19768 390 15 : : : 19768 390 16 " " `` 19768 390 17 I -PRON- PRP 19768 390 18 require require VBP 19768 390 19 the the DT 19768 390 20 freedom freedom NN 19768 390 21 , , , 19768 390 22 not not RB 19768 390 23 of of IN 19768 390 24 ' ' `` 19768 390 25 parliament parliament NN 19768 390 26 , , , 19768 390 27 ' ' '' 19768 390 28 but but CC 19768 390 29 of of IN 19768 390 30 the the DT 19768 390 31 courts court NNS 19768 390 32 -- -- : 19768 390 33 freedom freedom NN 19768 390 34 to to TO 19768 390 35 present present VB 19768 390 36 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 390 37 ' ' '' 19768 390 38 facts fact NNS 19768 390 39 , , , 19768 390 40 ' ' '' 19768 390 41 and and CC 19768 390 42 no no DT 19768 390 43 less less JJR 19768 390 44 to to TO 19768 390 45 draw draw VB 19768 390 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 390 47 ' ' '' 19768 390 48 inferences'--freedom inferences'--freedom NN 19768 390 49 to to TO 19768 390 50 array array VB 19768 390 51 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 390 52 evidence evidence NN 19768 390 53 , , , 19768 390 54 and and CC 19768 390 55 no no DT 19768 390 56 less less JJR 19768 390 57 to to TO 19768 390 58 make make VB 19768 390 59 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 390 60 pleading pleading NN 19768 390 61 . . . 19768 391 1 By by IN 19768 391 2 publishing publish VBG 19768 391 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 391 4 new new JJ 19768 391 5 libel libel NN 19768 391 6 , , , 19768 391 7 you -PRON- PRP 19768 391 8 estop estop VBP 19768 391 9 yourself -PRON- PRP 19768 391 10 from from IN 19768 391 11 denying deny VBG 19768 391 12 me -PRON- PRP 19768 391 13 this this DT 19768 391 14 freedom freedom NN 19768 391 15 . . . 19768 392 1 If if IN 19768 392 2 you -PRON- PRP 19768 392 3 do do VBP 19768 392 4 deny deny VB 19768 392 5 it -PRON- PRP 19768 392 6 , , , 19768 392 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 392 8 withdraw withdraw VBP 19768 392 9 altogether altogether RB 19768 392 10 and and CC 19768 392 11 seek seek VB 19768 392 12 justice justice NN 19768 392 13 and and CC 19768 392 14 redress redress VB 19768 392 15 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19768 392 16 . . . 19768 393 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 393 2 ask ask VBP 19768 393 3 only only RB 19768 393 4 what what WP 19768 393 5 is be VBZ 19768 393 6 self self NN 19768 393 7 - - HYPH 19768 393 8 evidently evidently RB 19768 393 9 fair fair JJ 19768 393 10 : : : 19768 393 11 ( ( -LRB- 19768 393 12 1 1 LS 19768 393 13 ) ) -RRB- 19768 393 14 equal equal JJ 19768 393 15 space space NN 19768 393 16 with with IN 19768 393 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 393 18 Royce Royce NNP 19768 393 19 , , , 19768 393 20 ( ( -LRB- 19768 393 21 2 2 LS 19768 393 22 ) ) -RRB- 19768 393 23 equal equal JJ 19768 393 24 freedom freedom NN 19768 393 25 with with IN 19768 393 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 393 27 Royce Royce NNP 19768 393 28 , , , 19768 393 29 ( ( -LRB- 19768 393 30 3 3 LS 19768 393 31 ) ) -RRB- 19768 393 32 no no DT 19768 393 33 further further JJ 19768 393 34 rejoinders rejoinder NNS 19768 393 35 by by IN 19768 393 36 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 393 37 Royce Royce NNP 19768 393 38 , , , 19768 393 39 and and CC 19768 393 40 ( ( -LRB- 19768 393 41 4 4 LS 19768 393 42 ) ) -RRB- 19768 393 43 no no DT 19768 393 44 editorial editorial JJ 19768 393 45 mention mention NN 19768 393 46 of of IN 19768 393 47 the the DT 19768 393 48 matter matter NN 19768 393 49 at at RB 19768 393 50 all all RB 19768 393 51 from from IN 19768 393 52 the the DT 19768 393 53 ' ' `` 19768 393 54 Journal Journal NNP 19768 393 55 ' ' '' 19768 393 56 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 393 57 . . . 19768 393 58 " " '' 19768 394 1 To to IN 19768 394 2 this this DT 19768 394 3 letter letter NN 19768 394 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 394 5 Adler Adler NNP 19768 394 6 merely merely RB 19768 394 7 telegraphed telegraph VBD 19768 394 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 394 9 final final JJ 19768 394 10 reply reply NN 19768 394 11 on on IN 19768 394 12 May May NNP 19768 394 13 6 6 CD 19768 394 14 in in IN 19768 394 15 these these DT 19768 394 16 brief brief JJ 19768 394 17 terms term NNS 19768 394 18 : : : 19768 394 19 " " `` 19768 394 20 Regret regret VB 19768 394 21 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 394 22 insistence insistence NN 19768 394 23 on on IN 19768 394 24 freedom freedom NN 19768 394 25 of of IN 19768 394 26 courts court NNS 19768 394 27 -- -- : 19768 394 28 parliamentary parliamentary JJ 19768 394 29 freedom freedom NN 19768 394 30 open open JJ 19768 394 31 to to IN 19768 394 32 you -PRON- PRP 19768 394 33 . . . 19768 394 34 " " '' 19768 395 1 This this DT 19768 395 2 ended end VBD 19768 395 3 the the DT 19768 395 4 matter matter NN 19768 395 5 , , , 19768 395 6 so so RB 19768 395 7 far far RB 19768 395 8 as as IN 19768 395 9 the the DT 19768 395 10 " " `` 19768 395 11 Journal Journal NNP 19768 395 12 of of IN 19768 395 13 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 395 14 " " '' 19768 395 15 was be VBD 19768 395 16 concerned concern VBN 19768 395 17 , , , 19768 395 18 in in IN 19768 395 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 395 20 Adler Adler NNP 19768 395 21 's 's POS 19768 395 22 explicit explicit JJ 19768 395 23 denial denial NN 19768 395 24 of of IN 19768 395 25 a a DT 19768 395 26 full full JJ 19768 395 27 and and CC 19768 395 28 fair fair JJ 19768 395 29 hearing hearing NN 19768 395 30 in in IN 19768 395 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 395 32 columns column NNS 19768 395 33 to to IN 19768 395 34 a a DT 19768 395 35 party party NN 19768 395 36 calumniated calumniate VBN 19768 395 37 and and CC 19768 395 38 libelled libel VBN 19768 395 39 by by IN 19768 395 40 one one CD 19768 395 41 of of IN 19768 395 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 395 43 own own JJ 19768 395 44 contributors contributor NNS 19768 395 45 and and CC 19768 395 46 a a DT 19768 395 47 member member NN 19768 395 48 of of IN 19768 395 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 395 50 own own JJ 19768 395 51 " " '' 19768 395 52 editorial editorial JJ 19768 395 53 committee committee NN 19768 395 54 . . . 19768 395 55 " " '' 19768 396 1 Negotiations negotiation NNS 19768 396 2 , , , 19768 396 3 it -PRON- PRP 19768 396 4 is be VBZ 19768 396 5 true true JJ 19768 396 6 , , , 19768 396 7 for for IN 19768 396 8 the the DT 19768 396 9 publication publication NN 19768 396 10 of of IN 19768 396 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 396 12 reply reply NN 19768 396 13 in in IN 19768 396 14 the the DT 19768 396 15 July July NNP 19768 396 16 number number NN 19768 396 17 were be VBD 19768 396 18 a a DT 19768 396 19 little little JJ 19768 396 20 later later RBR 19768 396 21 re re NN 19768 396 22 - - VBN 19768 396 23 opened open VBN 19768 396 24 by by IN 19768 396 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 396 26 Adler Adler NNP 19768 396 27 , , , 19768 396 28 on on IN 19768 396 29 receiving receive VBG 19768 396 30 advice advice NN 19768 396 31 from from IN 19768 396 32 a a DT 19768 396 33 legal legal JJ 19768 396 34 friend friend NN 19768 396 35 of of IN 19768 396 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 396 37 own own JJ 19768 396 38 that that DT 19768 396 39 to to TO 19768 396 40 publish publish VB 19768 396 41 it -PRON- PRP 19768 396 42 would would MD 19768 396 43 be be VB 19768 396 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 396 45 wisest wise JJS 19768 396 46 course course NN 19768 396 47 ; ; : 19768 396 48 but but CC 19768 396 49 he -PRON- PRP 19768 396 50 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 396 51 broke break VBD 19768 396 52 them -PRON- PRP 19768 396 53 off off RP 19768 396 54 on on IN 19768 396 55 a a DT 19768 396 56 trivial trivial JJ 19768 396 57 pretext pretext NN 19768 396 58 , , , 19768 396 59 after after IN 19768 396 60 receiving receive VBG 19768 396 61 contrary contrary JJ 19768 396 62 advice advice NN 19768 396 63 from from IN 19768 396 64 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 396 65 Royce Royce NNP 19768 396 66 's 's POS 19768 396 67 counsel counsel NN 19768 396 68 , , , 19768 396 69 together together RB 19768 396 70 with with IN 19768 396 71 a a DT 19768 396 72 copy copy NN 19768 396 73 of of IN 19768 396 74 the the DT 19768 396 75 legal legal JJ 19768 396 76 protest protest NN 19768 396 77 sent send VBN 19768 396 78 to to IN 19768 396 79 me -PRON- PRP 19768 396 80 personally personally RB 19768 396 81 . . . 19768 397 1 Thus thus RB 19768 397 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 397 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 397 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 397 5 , , , 19768 397 6 recalling recall VBG 19768 397 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 397 8 original original JJ 19768 397 9 consent consent NN 19768 397 10 , , , 19768 397 11 procured procure VBD 19768 397 12 the the DT 19768 397 13 final final JJ 19768 397 14 rejection rejection NN 19768 397 15 by by IN 19768 397 16 the the DT 19768 397 17 " " `` 19768 397 18 Journal Journal NNP 19768 397 19 of of IN 19768 397 20 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 397 21 " " '' 19768 397 22 of of IN 19768 397 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 397 24 reply reply NN 19768 397 25 to to IN 19768 397 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 397 27 own own JJ 19768 397 28 attack attack NN 19768 397 29 . . . 19768 398 1 On on IN 19768 398 2 June June NNP 19768 398 3 19 19 CD 19768 398 4 , , , 19768 398 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 398 6 was be VBD 19768 398 7 notified notify VBN 19768 398 8 that that IN 19768 398 9 the the DT 19768 398 10 July July NNP 19768 398 11 number number NN 19768 398 12 had have VBD 19768 398 13 been be VBN 19768 398 14 made make VBN 19768 398 15 up up RP 19768 398 16 without without IN 19768 398 17 it -PRON- PRP 19768 398 18 . . . 19768 399 1 But but CC 19768 399 2 already already RB 19768 399 3 , , , 19768 399 4 on on IN 19768 399 5 June June NNP 19768 399 6 9 9 CD 19768 399 7 , , , 19768 399 8 I -PRON- PRP 19768 399 9 had have VBD 19768 399 10 received receive VBN 19768 399 11 from from IN 19768 399 12 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 399 13 J. J. NNP 19768 400 1 B. B. NNP 19768 400 2 Warner Warner NNP 19768 400 3 , , , 19768 400 4 acting act VBG 19768 400 5 as as IN 19768 400 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 400 7 Royce Royce NNP 19768 400 8 's 's POS 19768 400 9 counsel counsel NN 19768 400 10 , , , 19768 400 11 this this DT 19768 400 12 formal formal JJ 19768 400 13 protest protest NN 19768 400 14 against against IN 19768 400 15 any any DT 19768 400 16 other other JJ 19768 400 17 use use NN 19768 400 18 whatever whatever WDT 19768 400 19 of of IN 19768 400 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 400 21 reply reply NN 19768 400 22 : : : 19768 400 23 " " `` 19768 400 24 On on IN 19768 400 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 400 26 Royce Royce NNP 19768 400 27 's 's POS 19768 400 28 behalf behalf NN 19768 400 29 , , , 19768 400 30 I -PRON- PRP 19768 400 31 must must MD 19768 400 32 warn warn VB 19768 400 33 you -PRON- PRP 19768 400 34 that that IN 19768 400 35 he -PRON- PRP 19768 400 36 protests protest VBZ 19768 400 37 against against IN 19768 400 38 the the DT 19768 400 39 publication publication NN 19768 400 40 or or CC 19768 400 41 any any DT 19768 400 42 circulation circulation NN 19768 400 43 of of IN 19768 400 44 it -PRON- PRP 19768 400 45 , , , 19768 400 46 in in IN 19768 400 47 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 400 48 present present JJ 19768 400 49 shape shape NN 19768 400 50 , , , 19768 400 51 and and CC 19768 400 52 must must MD 19768 400 53 point point VB 19768 400 54 out out RP 19768 400 55 to to IN 19768 400 56 you -PRON- PRP 19768 400 57 that that IN 19768 400 58 it -PRON- PRP 19768 400 59 may may MD 19768 400 60 , , , 19768 400 61 if if IN 19768 400 62 circulated circulate VBN 19768 400 63 , , , 19768 400 64 entail entail VBP 19768 400 65 a a DT 19768 400 66 serious serious JJ 19768 400 67 legal legal JJ 19768 400 68 responsibility responsibility NN 19768 400 69 . . . 19768 400 70 " " '' 19768 401 1 To to IN 19768 401 2 this this DT 19768 401 3 strangely strangely RB 19768 401 4 impolitic impolitic JJ 19768 401 5 and and CC 19768 401 6 utterly utterly RB 19768 401 7 futile futile JJ 19768 401 8 attempt attempt NN 19768 401 9 to to TO 19768 401 10 intimidate intimidate VB 19768 401 11 me -PRON- PRP 19768 401 12 in in IN 19768 401 13 the the DT 19768 401 14 defence defence NN 19768 401 15 of of IN 19768 401 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 401 17 own own JJ 19768 401 18 reputation reputation NN 19768 401 19 , , , 19768 401 20 I -PRON- PRP 19768 401 21 chose choose VBD 19768 401 22 to to TO 19768 401 23 offer offer VB 19768 401 24 not not RB 19768 401 25 the the DT 19768 401 26 slightest slight JJS 19768 401 27 resistance resistance NN 19768 401 28 . . . 19768 402 1 The the DT 19768 402 2 protest protest NN 19768 402 3 only only RB 19768 402 4 facilitated facilitate VBD 19768 402 5 that that IN 19768 402 6 defence defence NN 19768 402 7 . . . 19768 403 1 How how WRB 19768 403 2 could could MD 19768 403 3 a a DT 19768 403 4 libeller libeller NN 19768 403 5 more more RBR 19768 403 6 conspicuously conspicuously RB 19768 403 7 put put VB 19768 403 8 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 403 9 in in IN 19768 403 10 the the DT 19768 403 11 wrong wrong NN 19768 403 12 , , , 19768 403 13 or or CC 19768 403 14 more more RBR 19768 403 15 effectually effectually RB 19768 403 16 ruin ruin VB 19768 403 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 403 18 own own JJ 19768 403 19 evil evil NN 19768 403 20 cause cause NN 19768 403 21 in in IN 19768 403 22 all all DT 19768 403 23 eyes eye NNS 19768 403 24 , , , 19768 403 25 than than IN 19768 403 26 by by IN 19768 403 27 _ _ NNP 19768 403 28 trying try VBG 19768 403 29 to to TO 19768 403 30 gag gag VB 19768 403 31 the the DT 19768 403 32 man man NN 19768 403 33 he -PRON- PRP 19768 403 34 had have VBD 19768 403 35 injured injure VBN 19768 403 36 _ _ NNP 19768 403 37 ? ? . 19768 404 1 First first RB 19768 404 2 , , , 19768 404 3 to to TO 19768 404 4 prevent prevent VB 19768 404 5 publication publication NN 19768 404 6 in in IN 19768 404 7 the the DT 19768 404 8 " " `` 19768 404 9 Journal Journal NNP 19768 404 10 of of IN 19768 404 11 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 404 12 " " '' 19768 404 13 of of IN 19768 404 14 the the DT 19768 404 15 very very JJ 19768 404 16 reply reply NN 19768 404 17 he -PRON- PRP 19768 404 18 had have VBD 19768 404 19 publicly publicly RB 19768 404 20 and and CC 19768 404 21 defiantly defiantly RB 19768 404 22 challenged challenge VBN 19768 404 23 , , , 19768 404 24 and and CC 19768 404 25 then then RB 19768 404 26 to to TO 19768 404 27 suppress suppress VB 19768 404 28 all all DT 19768 404 29 circulation circulation NN 19768 404 30 of of IN 19768 404 31 a a DT 19768 404 32 few few JJ 19768 404 33 privately privately RB 19768 404 34 printed print VBN 19768 404 35 copies copy NNS 19768 404 36 of of IN 19768 404 37 it -PRON- PRP 19768 404 38 by by IN 19768 404 39 means mean NNS 19768 404 40 of of IN 19768 404 41 legal legal JJ 19768 404 42 threats threat NNS 19768 404 43 : : : 19768 404 44 if if IN 19768 404 45 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 404 46 Royce Royce NNP 19768 404 47 could could MD 19768 404 48 afford afford VB 19768 404 49 to to TO 19768 404 50 commit commit VB 19768 404 51 such such JJ 19768 404 52 blunders blunder NNS 19768 404 53 , , , 19768 404 54 why why WRB 19768 404 55 should should MD 19768 404 56 I -PRON- PRP 19768 404 57 shield shield VB 19768 404 58 him -PRON- PRP 19768 404 59 from from IN 19768 404 60 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 404 61 ? ? . 19768 405 1 " " `` 19768 405 2 Whom whom WP 19768 405 3 the the DT 19768 405 4 gods god NNS 19768 405 5 destroy destroy VBP 19768 405 6 , , , 19768 405 7 they -PRON- PRP 19768 405 8 first first RB 19768 405 9 make make VBP 19768 405 10 mad mad JJ 19768 405 11 . . . 19768 405 12 " " '' 19768 406 1 Before before IN 19768 406 2 proceeding proceed VBG 19768 406 3 to to IN 19768 406 4 any any DT 19768 406 5 more more RBR 19768 406 6 energetic energetic JJ 19768 406 7 measures measure NNS 19768 406 8 , , , 19768 406 9 however however RB 19768 406 10 , , , 19768 406 11 in in IN 19768 406 12 order order NN 19768 406 13 to to TO 19768 406 14 vindicate vindicate VB 19768 406 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 406 16 reputation reputation NN 19768 406 17 , , , 19768 406 18 I -PRON- PRP 19768 406 19 was be VBD 19768 406 20 anxious anxious JJ 19768 406 21 to to TO 19768 406 22 offer offer VB 19768 406 23 to to IN 19768 406 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 406 25 Royce Royce NNP 19768 406 26 an an DT 19768 406 27 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 406 28 of of IN 19768 406 29 doing do VBG 19768 406 30 me -PRON- PRP 19768 406 31 justice justice NN 19768 406 32 in in IN 19768 406 33 a a DT 19768 406 34 manner manner NN 19768 406 35 which which WDT 19768 406 36 should should MD 19768 406 37 be be VB 19768 406 38 consistent consistent JJ 19768 406 39 with with IN 19768 406 40 full full JJ 19768 406 41 vindication vindication NN 19768 406 42 , , , 19768 406 43 yet yet RB 19768 406 44 should should MD 19768 406 45 involve involve VB 19768 406 46 the the DT 19768 406 47 least least JJS 19768 406 48 possible possible JJ 19768 406 49 publicity publicity NN 19768 406 50 and and CC 19768 406 51 the the DT 19768 406 52 least least JJS 19768 406 53 possible possible JJ 19768 406 54 mortification mortification NN 19768 406 55 to to IN 19768 406 56 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 406 57 . . . 19768 407 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19768 407 2 , , , 19768 407 3 on on IN 19768 407 4 June June NNP 19768 407 5 20 20 CD 19768 407 6 , , , 19768 407 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 407 8 wrote write VBD 19768 407 9 to to IN 19768 407 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 407 11 Warner Warner NNP 19768 407 12 thus thus RB 19768 407 13 : : : 19768 407 14 " " `` 19768 407 15 I -PRON- PRP 19768 407 16 beg beg VBP 19768 407 17 leave leave VBP 19768 407 18 to to TO 19768 407 19 enclose enclose VB 19768 407 20 a a DT 19768 407 21 Card card NN 19768 407 22 , , , 19768 407 23 which which WDT 19768 407 24 , , , 19768 407 25 if if IN 19768 407 26 returned return VBD 19768 407 27 to to IN 19768 407 28 me -PRON- PRP 19768 407 29 within within IN 19768 407 30 a a DT 19768 407 31 week week NN 19768 407 32 from from IN 19768 407 33 to to IN 19768 407 34 - - HYPH 19768 407 35 day day NN 19768 407 36 , , , 19768 407 37 unchanged unchanged JJ 19768 407 38 , , , 19768 407 39 dated date VBN 19768 407 40 , , , 19768 407 41 and and CC 19768 407 42 signed sign VBN 19768 407 43 by by IN 19768 407 44 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 407 45 Royce Royce NNP 19768 407 46 , , , 19768 407 47 and and CC 19768 407 48 if if IN 19768 407 49 actually actually RB 19768 407 50 published publish VBN 19768 407 51 in in IN 19768 407 52 the the DT 19768 407 53 October October NNP 19768 407 54 number number NN 19768 407 55 of of IN 19768 407 56 the the DT 19768 407 57 ' ' `` 19768 407 58 Journal Journal NNP 19768 407 59 , , , 19768 407 60 ' ' '' 19768 407 61 will will MD 19768 407 62 render render VB 19768 407 63 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19768 407 64 further further JJ 19768 407 65 measures measure NNS 19768 407 66 of of IN 19768 407 67 self self NN 19768 407 68 - - HYPH 19768 407 69 vindication vindication NN 19768 407 70 as as RB 19768 407 71 now now RB 19768 407 72 contemplated contemplate VBN 19768 407 73 . . . 19768 408 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 408 2 send send VBP 19768 408 3 this this DT 19768 408 4 because because IN 19768 408 5 you -PRON- PRP 19768 408 6 assured assure VBD 19768 408 7 me -PRON- PRP 19768 408 8 that that IN 19768 408 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 408 10 Royce Royce NNP 19768 408 11 disclaims disclaim VBZ 19768 408 12 all all DT 19768 408 13 malice malice NN 19768 408 14 in in IN 19768 408 15 the the DT 19768 408 16 publication publication NN 19768 408 17 of of IN 19768 408 18 the the DT 19768 408 19 original original JJ 19768 408 20 article article NN 19768 408 21 I -PRON- PRP 19768 408 22 complain complain VBP 19768 408 23 of of IN 19768 408 24 , , , 19768 408 25 and and CC 19768 408 26 because because IN 19768 408 27 I -PRON- PRP 19768 408 28 am be VBP 19768 408 29 willing willing JJ 19768 408 30 to to TO 19768 408 31 test test VB 19768 408 32 the the DT 19768 408 33 sincerity sincerity NN 19768 408 34 of of IN 19768 408 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 408 36 disclaimer disclaimer NN 19768 408 37 before before IN 19768 408 38 resorting resort VBG 19768 408 39 to to IN 19768 408 40 other other JJ 19768 408 41 measures measure NNS 19768 408 42 for for IN 19768 408 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 408 44 self self NN 19768 408 45 - - HYPH 19768 408 46 protection protection NN 19768 408 47 . . . 19768 409 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 409 2 expect expect VBP 19768 409 3 you -PRON- PRP 19768 409 4 , , , 19768 409 5 who who WP 19768 409 6 came come VBD 19768 409 7 to to IN 19768 409 8 me -PRON- PRP 19768 409 9 in in IN 19768 409 10 the the DT 19768 409 11 character character NN 19768 409 12 of of IN 19768 409 13 a a DT 19768 409 14 pacificator pacificator NN 19768 409 15 , , , 19768 409 16 and and CC 19768 409 17 who who WP 19768 409 18 expressed express VBD 19768 409 19 a a DT 19768 409 20 creditable creditable JJ 19768 409 21 desire desire NN 19768 409 22 , , , 19768 409 23 in in IN 19768 409 24 which which WDT 19768 409 25 I -PRON- PRP 19768 409 26 fully fully RB 19768 409 27 join join VBP 19768 409 28 , , , 19768 409 29 for for IN 19768 409 30 the the DT 19768 409 31 settlement settlement NN 19768 409 32 of of IN 19768 409 33 this this DT 19768 409 34 trouble trouble NN 19768 409 35 in in IN 19768 409 36 some some DT 19768 409 37 way way NN 19768 409 38 which which WDT 19768 409 39 shall shall MD 19768 409 40 occasion occasion VB 19768 409 41 no no DT 19768 409 42 scandal scandal NN 19768 409 43 to to IN 19768 409 44 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 409 45 College College NNP 19768 409 46 , , , 19768 409 47 to to TO 19768 409 48 exert exert VB 19768 409 49 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 409 50 utmost utmost JJ 19768 409 51 influence influence NN 19768 409 52 with with IN 19768 409 53 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 409 54 Royce Royce NNP 19768 409 55 to to TO 19768 409 56 persuade persuade VB 19768 409 57 him -PRON- PRP 19768 409 58 to to TO 19768 409 59 perform perform VB 19768 409 60 this this DT 19768 409 61 act act NN 19768 409 62 of of IN 19768 409 63 manifest manifest NN 19768 409 64 justice justice NN 19768 409 65 to to IN 19768 409 66 me -PRON- PRP 19768 409 67 . . . 19768 410 1 A a DT 19768 410 2 frank frank JJ 19768 410 3 retraction retraction NN 19768 410 4 and and CC 19768 410 5 apology apology NN 19768 410 6 , , , 19768 410 7 when when WRB 19768 410 8 unjust unjust JJ 19768 410 9 charges charge NNS 19768 410 10 have have VBP 19768 410 11 been be VBN 19768 410 12 made make VBN 19768 410 13 as as IN 19768 410 14 now now RB 19768 410 15 , , , 19768 410 16 is be VBZ 19768 410 17 not not RB 19768 410 18 dishonorable dishonorable JJ 19768 410 19 and and CC 19768 410 20 ought ought MD 19768 410 21 not not RB 19768 410 22 to to TO 19768 410 23 be be VB 19768 410 24 humiliating humiliating JJ 19768 410 25 ; ; : 19768 410 26 and and CC 19768 410 27 I -PRON- PRP 19768 410 28 shall shall MD 19768 410 29 consider consider VB 19768 410 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 410 31 Royce Royce NNP 19768 410 32 's 's POS 19768 410 33 action action NN 19768 410 34 in in IN 19768 410 35 this this DT 19768 410 36 matter matter NN 19768 410 37 as as IN 19768 410 38 showing show VBG 19768 410 39 the the DT 19768 410 40 sincerity sincerity NN 19768 410 41 or or CC 19768 410 42 insincerity insincerity NN 19768 410 43 of of IN 19768 410 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 410 45 disclaimer disclaimer NN 19768 410 46 of of IN 19768 410 47 all all DT 19768 410 48 malice malice NN 19768 410 49 in in IN 19768 410 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 410 51 original original JJ 19768 410 52 article article NN 19768 410 53 . . . 19768 410 54 " " '' 19768 411 1 The the DT 19768 411 2 enclosed enclose VBN 19768 411 3 paper paper NN 19768 411 4 above above IN 19768 411 5 mentioned mention VBN 19768 411 6 was be VBD 19768 411 7 this:-- this:-- NNP 19768 411 8 A a DT 19768 411 9 CARD card NN 19768 411 10 . . . 19768 412 1 CAMBRIDGE CAMBRIDGE NNP 19768 412 2 , , , 19768 412 3 June June NNP 19768 412 4 -- -- : 19768 412 5 , , , 19768 412 6 1891 1891 CD 19768 412 7 . . . 19768 413 1 I. I. NNP 19768 413 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 413 3 admit admit VBP 19768 413 4 that that IN 19768 413 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 413 6 have have VBP 19768 413 7 no no DT 19768 413 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19768 413 9 whatever whatever WDT 19768 413 10 of of IN 19768 413 11 any any DT 19768 413 12 " " `` 19768 413 13 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 413 14 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 413 15 " " '' 19768 413 16 made make VBN 19768 413 17 by by IN 19768 413 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 413 19 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 413 20 " " '' 19768 413 21 as as IN 19768 413 22 to to IN 19768 413 23 the the DT 19768 413 24 originality originality NN 19768 413 25 and and CC 19768 413 26 profundity profundity NN 19768 413 27 of of IN 19768 413 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 413 29 still still RB 19768 413 30 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 413 31 system system NN 19768 413 32 of of IN 19768 413 33 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 413 34 . . . 19768 413 35 " " '' 19768 414 1 II ii CD 19768 414 2 . . . 19768 415 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 415 2 admit admit VBP 19768 415 3 that that IN 19768 415 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 415 5 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 415 6 did do VBD 19768 415 7 not not RB 19768 415 8 , , , 19768 415 9 consciously consciously RB 19768 415 10 or or CC 19768 415 11 unconsciously unconsciously RB 19768 415 12 , , , 19768 415 13 " " `` 19768 415 14 borrow borrow VB 19768 415 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 415 16 theory theory NN 19768 415 17 of of IN 19768 415 18 universals universal NNS 19768 415 19 from from IN 19768 415 20 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 415 21 , , , 19768 415 22 " " '' 19768 415 23 or or CC 19768 415 24 " " `` 19768 415 25 sin sin NN 19768 415 26 against against IN 19768 415 27 the the DT 19768 415 28 most most RBS 19768 415 29 obvious obvious JJ 19768 415 30 demands demand NNS 19768 415 31 of of IN 19768 415 32 literary literary JJ 19768 415 33 property property NN 19768 415 34 - - HYPH 19768 415 35 rights right NNS 19768 415 36 . . . 19768 415 37 " " '' 19768 416 1 III iii CD 19768 416 2 . . . 19768 417 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 417 2 unconditionally unconditionally RB 19768 417 3 retract retract VBP 19768 417 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 417 5 " " `` 19768 417 6 professional professional JJ 19768 417 7 warning warning NN 19768 417 8 to to IN 19768 417 9 the the DT 19768 417 10 liberal liberal JJ 19768 417 11 - - HYPH 19768 417 12 minded minded JJ 19768 417 13 public public NN 19768 417 14 against against IN 19768 417 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 417 16 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 417 17 's 's POS 19768 417 18 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 417 19 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 417 20 , , , 19768 417 21 " " '' 19768 417 22 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 19768 417 23 that that IN 19768 417 24 it -PRON- PRP 19768 417 25 was be VBD 19768 417 26 groundless groundless JJ 19768 417 27 and and CC 19768 417 28 unjustifiable unjustifiable JJ 19768 417 29 , , , 19768 417 30 and and CC 19768 417 31 apologize apologize VB 19768 417 32 to to IN 19768 417 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 417 34 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 417 35 for for IN 19768 417 36 having have VBG 19768 417 37 published publish VBN 19768 417 38 it -PRON- PRP 19768 417 39 in in IN 19768 417 40 the the DT 19768 417 41 " " `` 19768 417 42 International International NNP 19768 417 43 Journal Journal NNP 19768 417 44 of of IN 19768 417 45 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 417 46 . . . 19768 417 47 " " '' 19768 418 1 IV IV NNP 19768 418 2 . . . 19768 419 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 419 2 authorize authorize VBP 19768 419 3 the the DT 19768 419 4 publication publication NN 19768 419 5 of of IN 19768 419 6 this this DT 19768 419 7 retraction retraction NN 19768 419 8 and and CC 19768 419 9 apology apology NN 19768 419 10 in in IN 19768 419 11 the the DT 19768 419 12 next next JJ 19768 419 13 number number NN 19768 419 14 of of IN 19768 419 15 the the DT 19768 419 16 " " `` 19768 419 17 International International NNP 19768 419 18 Journal Journal NNP 19768 419 19 of of IN 19768 419 20 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 419 21 " " '' 19768 419 22 without without IN 19768 419 23 note note NN 19768 419 24 or or CC 19768 419 25 comment comment NN 19768 419 26 . . . 19768 420 1 In in IN 19768 420 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 420 3 answer answer NN 19768 420 4 of of IN 19768 420 5 June June NNP 19768 420 6 24 24 CD 19768 420 7 , , , 19768 420 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 420 9 Warner Warner NNP 19768 420 10 informed inform VBD 19768 420 11 me -PRON- PRP 19768 420 12 that that IN 19768 420 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 420 14 Royce Royce NNP 19768 420 15 had have VBD 19768 420 16 gone go VBN 19768 420 17 to to IN 19768 420 18 Denver Denver NNP 19768 420 19 , , , 19768 420 20 and and CC 19768 420 21 wrote write VBD 19768 420 22 : : : 19768 420 23 " " `` 19768 420 24 As as IN 19768 420 25 for for IN 19768 420 26 the the DT 19768 420 27 Card card NN 19768 420 28 which which WDT 19768 420 29 you -PRON- PRP 19768 420 30 propose propose VBP 19768 420 31 , , , 19768 420 32 I -PRON- PRP 19768 420 33 will will MD 19768 420 34 leave leave VB 19768 420 35 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 420 36 Royce Royce NNP 19768 420 37 to to TO 19768 420 38 make make VB 19768 420 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 420 40 own own JJ 19768 420 41 answer answer NN 19768 420 42 after after IN 19768 420 43 he -PRON- PRP 19768 420 44 has have VBZ 19768 420 45 seen see VBN 19768 420 46 it -PRON- PRP 19768 420 47 . . . 19768 421 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 421 2 will will MD 19768 421 3 say say VB 19768 421 4 , , , 19768 421 5 however however RB 19768 421 6 , , , 19768 421 7 for for IN 19768 421 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 421 9 own own JJ 19768 421 10 part part NN 19768 421 11 , , , 19768 421 12 that that IN 19768 421 13 , , , 19768 421 14 while while IN 19768 421 15 he -PRON- PRP 19768 421 16 has have VBZ 19768 421 17 always always RB 19768 421 18 been be VBN 19768 421 19 ready ready JJ 19768 421 20 to to TO 19768 421 21 disclaim disclaim VB 19768 421 22 any any DT 19768 421 23 desire desire NN 19768 421 24 to to TO 19768 421 25 injure injure VB 19768 421 26 you -PRON- PRP 19768 421 27 personally personally RB 19768 421 28 , , , 19768 421 29 I -PRON- PRP 19768 421 30 think think VBP 19768 421 31 that that IN 19768 421 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 421 33 opinions opinion NNS 19768 421 34 concerning concern VBG 19768 421 35 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 421 36 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 421 37 system system NN 19768 421 38 and and CC 19768 421 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 421 40 origin origin NN 19768 421 41 are be VBP 19768 421 42 unchanged unchanged JJ 19768 421 43 , , , 19768 421 44 and and CC 19768 421 45 he -PRON- PRP 19768 421 46 is be VBZ 19768 421 47 not not RB 19768 421 48 likely likely JJ 19768 421 49 to to TO 19768 421 50 retract retract VB 19768 421 51 them -PRON- PRP 19768 421 52 . . . 19768 422 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 422 2 must must MD 19768 422 3 say say VB 19768 422 4 , , , 19768 422 5 too too RB 19768 422 6 , , , 19768 422 7 that that IN 19768 422 8 you -PRON- PRP 19768 422 9 have have VBP 19768 422 10 put put VBN 19768 422 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 422 12 Card card NN 19768 422 13 in in IN 19768 422 14 a a DT 19768 422 15 form form NN 19768 422 16 in in IN 19768 422 17 which which WDT 19768 422 18 you -PRON- PRP 19768 422 19 could could MD 19768 422 20 not not RB 19768 422 21 have have VB 19768 422 22 expected expect VBN 19768 422 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 422 24 Royce Royce NNP 19768 422 25 to to TO 19768 422 26 sign sign VB 19768 422 27 it -PRON- PRP 19768 422 28 , , , 19768 422 29 and and CC 19768 422 30 I -PRON- PRP 19768 422 31 do do VBP 19768 422 32 not not RB 19768 422 33 regard regard VB 19768 422 34 it -PRON- PRP 19768 422 35 as as IN 19768 422 36 any any DT 19768 422 37 step step NN 19768 422 38 , , , 19768 422 39 on on IN 19768 422 40 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 422 41 part part NN 19768 422 42 , , , 19768 422 43 toward toward IN 19768 422 44 a a DT 19768 422 45 pacific pacific JJ 19768 422 46 settlement settlement NN 19768 422 47 , , , 19768 422 48 nor nor CC 19768 422 49 think think VB 19768 422 50 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 422 51 demand demand NN 19768 422 52 a a DT 19768 422 53 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 422 54 one one NN 19768 422 55 to to TO 19768 422 56 make make VB 19768 422 57 of of IN 19768 422 58 a a DT 19768 422 59 self self NN 19768 422 60 - - HYPH 19768 422 61 respecting respect VBG 19768 422 62 man man NN 19768 422 63 . . . 19768 422 64 " " '' 19768 423 1 The the DT 19768 423 2 next next JJ 19768 423 3 day day NN 19768 423 4 , , , 19768 423 5 June June NNP 19768 423 6 25 25 CD 19768 423 7 , , , 19768 423 8 I -PRON- PRP 19768 423 9 wrote write VBD 19768 423 10 to to IN 19768 423 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 423 12 Warner Warner NNP 19768 423 13 : : : 19768 423 14 " " `` 19768 423 15 I -PRON- PRP 19768 423 16 ought ought MD 19768 423 17 distinctly distinctly RB 19768 423 18 to to TO 19768 423 19 deny deny VB 19768 423 20 that that IN 19768 423 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 423 22 rejected reject VBN 19768 423 23 article article NN 19768 423 24 is be VBZ 19768 423 25 ' ' `` 19768 423 26 a a DT 19768 423 27 libellous libellous JJ 19768 423 28 paper paper NN 19768 423 29 . . . 19768 423 30 ' ' '' 19768 424 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 424 2 statements statement NNS 19768 424 3 are be VBP 19768 424 4 true true JJ 19768 424 5 ; ; : 19768 424 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 424 7 motive motive NN 19768 424 8 is be VBZ 19768 424 9 not not RB 19768 424 10 malice malice NN 19768 424 11 , , , 19768 424 12 but but CC 19768 424 13 a a DT 19768 424 14 self self NN 19768 424 15 - - HYPH 19768 424 16 evident evident JJ 19768 424 17 purpose purpose NN 19768 424 18 to to TO 19768 424 19 defend defend VB 19768 424 20 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 424 21 against against IN 19768 424 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 424 23 Royce Royce NNP 19768 424 24 's 's POS 19768 424 25 libel libel NN 19768 424 26 ; ; : 19768 424 27 and and CC 19768 424 28 , , , 19768 424 29 even even RB 19768 424 30 if if IN 19768 424 31 it -PRON- PRP 19768 424 32 should should MD 19768 424 33 be be VB 19768 424 34 concluded conclude VBN 19768 424 35 to to TO 19768 424 36 come come VB 19768 424 37 under under IN 19768 424 38 any any DT 19768 424 39 legal legal JJ 19768 424 40 definition definition NN 19768 424 41 of of IN 19768 424 42 ' ' `` 19768 424 43 libel libel NN 19768 424 44 , , , 19768 424 45 ' ' '' 19768 424 46 I -PRON- PRP 19768 424 47 maintain maintain VBP 19768 424 48 that that IN 19768 424 49 it -PRON- PRP 19768 424 50 is be VBZ 19768 424 51 self self NN 19768 424 52 - - HYPH 19768 424 53 evidently evidently RB 19768 424 54 a a DT 19768 424 55 ' ' `` 19768 424 56 justifiable justifiable JJ 19768 424 57 libel libel NN 19768 424 58 . . . 19768 424 59 ' ' '' 19768 425 1 If if IN 19768 425 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 425 3 pay pay VBP 19768 425 4 any any DT 19768 425 5 heed heed NN 19768 425 6 to to IN 19768 425 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 425 8 notice notice NN 19768 425 9 , , , 19768 425 10 it -PRON- PRP 19768 425 11 is be VBZ 19768 425 12 merely merely RB 19768 425 13 because because IN 19768 425 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 425 15 notice notice NN 19768 425 16 strengthens strengthen VBZ 19768 425 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 425 18 case.--You case.--You JJR 19768 425 19 do do VBP 19768 425 20 not not RB 19768 425 21 mention mention VB 19768 425 22 when when WRB 19768 425 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 425 24 Royce Royce NNP 19768 425 25 will will MD 19768 425 26 return return VB 19768 425 27 from from IN 19768 425 28 Denver Denver NNP 19768 425 29 ; ; : 19768 425 30 but but CC 19768 425 31 , , , 19768 425 32 because because IN 19768 425 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 425 34 purpose purpose NN 19768 425 35 in in IN 19768 425 36 enclosing enclose VBG 19768 425 37 to to IN 19768 425 38 you -PRON- PRP 19768 425 39 that that IN 19768 425 40 Card Card NNP 19768 425 41 is be VBZ 19768 425 42 in in IN 19768 425 43 good good JJ 19768 425 44 faith faith NN 19768 425 45 a a DT 19768 425 46 pacific pacific NNP 19768 425 47 one one NN 19768 425 48 , , , 19768 425 49 I -PRON- PRP 19768 425 50 will will MD 19768 425 51 wait wait VB 19768 425 52 a a DT 19768 425 53 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 425 54 time time NN 19768 425 55 for for IN 19768 425 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 425 57 return return NN 19768 425 58 beyond beyond IN 19768 425 59 the the DT 19768 425 60 date date NN 19768 425 61 I -PRON- PRP 19768 425 62 mentioned mention VBD 19768 425 63 . . . 19768 426 1 You -PRON- PRP 19768 426 2 will will MD 19768 426 3 not not RB 19768 426 4 judge judge VB 19768 426 5 the the DT 19768 426 6 character character NN 19768 426 7 of of IN 19768 426 8 that that DT 19768 426 9 Card Card NNP 19768 426 10 accurately accurately RB 19768 426 11 , , , 19768 426 12 and and CC 19768 426 13 you -PRON- PRP 19768 426 14 can can MD 19768 426 15 not not RB 19768 426 16 give give VB 19768 426 17 sound sound JJ 19768 426 18 or or CC 19768 426 19 salutary salutary JJ 19768 426 20 advice advice NN 19768 426 21 to to IN 19768 426 22 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 426 23 client client NN 19768 426 24 , , , 19768 426 25 if if IN 19768 426 26 you -PRON- PRP 19768 426 27 ignore ignore VBP 19768 426 28 the the DT 19768 426 29 libellous libellous JJ 19768 426 30 character character NN 19768 426 31 of of IN 19768 426 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 426 33 original original JJ 19768 426 34 article article NN 19768 426 35 . . . 19768 427 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 427 2 do do VBP 19768 427 3 not not RB 19768 427 4 see see VB 19768 427 5 how how WRB 19768 427 6 ' ' '' 19768 427 7 a a DT 19768 427 8 self self NN 19768 427 9 - - HYPH 19768 427 10 respecting respect VBG 19768 427 11 man man NN 19768 427 12 ' ' '' 19768 427 13 could could MD 19768 427 14 ever ever RB 19768 427 15 have have VB 19768 427 16 written write VBN 19768 427 17 such such PDT 19768 427 18 a a DT 19768 427 19 paper paper NN 19768 427 20 ; ; : 19768 427 21 but but CC 19768 427 22 , , , 19768 427 23 if if IN 19768 427 24 he -PRON- PRP 19768 427 25 did do VBD 19768 427 26 it -PRON- PRP 19768 427 27 inadvertently inadvertently RB 19768 427 28 and and CC 19768 427 29 not not RB 19768 427 30 maliciously maliciously RB 19768 427 31 , , , 19768 427 32 he -PRON- PRP 19768 427 33 would would MD 19768 427 34 certainly certainly RB 19768 427 35 do do VB 19768 427 36 one one CD 19768 427 37 of of IN 19768 427 38 two two CD 19768 427 39 things thing NNS 19768 427 40 : : : 19768 427 41 ( ( -LRB- 19768 427 42 1 1 LS 19768 427 43 ) ) -RRB- 19768 427 44 either either CC 19768 427 45 submit submit VB 19768 427 46 courageously courageously RB 19768 427 47 , , , 19768 427 48 unflinchingly unflinchingly RB 19768 427 49 , , , 19768 427 50 and and CC 19768 427 51 without without IN 19768 427 52 legal legal JJ 19768 427 53 protest protest NN 19768 427 54 , , , 19768 427 55 to to IN 19768 427 56 the the DT 19768 427 57 reply reply NN 19768 427 58 it -PRON- PRP 19768 427 59 challenged challenge VBD 19768 427 60 and and CC 19768 427 61 evoked evoke VBD 19768 427 62 , , , 19768 427 63 or or CC 19768 427 64 ( ( -LRB- 19768 427 65 2 2 LS 19768 427 66 ) ) -RRB- 19768 427 67 manfully manfully RB 19768 427 68 retract retract NN 19768 427 69 charges charge NNS 19768 427 70 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 19768 427 71 , , , 19768 427 72 as as IN 19768 427 73 these these DT 19768 427 74 have have VBP 19768 427 75 been be VBN 19768 427 76 , , , 19768 427 77 to to TO 19768 427 78 be be VB 19768 427 79 false false JJ 19768 427 80 . . . 19768 428 1 Have have VBP 19768 428 2 you -PRON- PRP 19768 428 3 really really RB 19768 428 4 a a DT 19768 428 5 different different JJ 19768 428 6 idea idea NN 19768 428 7 of of IN 19768 428 8 ' ' `` 19768 428 9 self self NN 19768 428 10 - - HYPH 19768 428 11 respect respect NN 19768 428 12 ' ' '' 19768 428 13 ? ? . 19768 429 1 Certainly certainly RB 19768 429 2 not not RB 19768 429 3 , , , 19768 429 4 for for IN 19768 429 5 you -PRON- PRP 19768 429 6 are be VBP 19768 429 7 an an DT 19768 429 8 honorable honorable JJ 19768 429 9 gentleman gentleman NN 19768 429 10 . . . 19768 430 1 Be be VB 19768 430 2 this this DT 19768 430 3 as as IN 19768 430 4 it -PRON- PRP 19768 430 5 may may MD 19768 430 6 , , , 19768 430 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 430 8 warn warn VBP 19768 430 9 you -PRON- PRP 19768 430 10 not not RB 19768 430 11 to to TO 19768 430 12 persist persist VB 19768 430 13 in in IN 19768 430 14 considering consider VBG 19768 430 15 that that IN 19768 430 16 Card Card NNP 19768 430 17 as as IN 19768 430 18 other other JJ 19768 430 19 than than IN 19768 430 20 a a DT 19768 430 21 pacific pacific JJ 19768 430 22 step step NN 19768 430 23 on on IN 19768 430 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 430 25 part part NN 19768 430 26 , , , 19768 430 27 if if IN 19768 430 28 you -PRON- PRP 19768 430 29 desire desire VBP 19768 430 30 to to TO 19768 430 31 counsel counsel VB 19768 430 32 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 430 33 client client NN 19768 430 34 to to IN 19768 430 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 430 36 own own JJ 19768 430 37 good good NN 19768 430 38 , , , 19768 430 39 or or CC 19768 430 40 to to TO 19768 430 41 prove prove VB 19768 430 42 yourself -PRON- PRP 19768 430 43 a a DT 19768 430 44 real real JJ 19768 430 45 friend friend NN 19768 430 46 to to IN 19768 430 47 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 430 48 College College NNP 19768 430 49 . . . 19768 431 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 431 2 say say VBP 19768 431 3 this this DT 19768 431 4 in in IN 19768 431 5 good good JJ 19768 431 6 faith faith NN 19768 431 7 . . . 19768 431 8 " " '' 19768 432 1 To to IN 19768 432 2 this this DT 19768 432 3 , , , 19768 432 4 on on IN 19768 432 5 July July NNP 19768 432 6 2 2 CD 19768 432 7 , , , 19768 432 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 432 9 Warner Warner NNP 19768 432 10 replied reply VBD 19768 432 11 : : : 19768 432 12 " " `` 19768 432 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 432 14 Royce Royce NNP 19768 432 15 has have VBZ 19768 432 16 returned return VBN 19768 432 17 , , , 19768 432 18 and and CC 19768 432 19 I -PRON- PRP 19768 432 20 have have VBP 19768 432 21 submitted submit VBN 19768 432 22 to to IN 19768 432 23 him -PRON- PRP 19768 432 24 the the DT 19768 432 25 Card card NN 19768 432 26 which which WDT 19768 432 27 you -PRON- PRP 19768 432 28 have have VBP 19768 432 29 prepared prepare VBN 19768 432 30 . . . 19768 433 1 As as IN 19768 433 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 433 3 anticipated anticipate VBD 19768 433 4 , , , 19768 433 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 433 6 Royce Royce NNP 19768 433 7 says say VBZ 19768 433 8 that that IN 19768 433 9 he -PRON- PRP 19768 433 10 can can MD 19768 433 11 not not RB 19768 433 12 sign sign VB 19768 433 13 it -PRON- PRP 19768 433 14 , , , 19768 433 15 nor nor CC 19768 433 16 can can MD 19768 433 17 I -PRON- PRP 19768 433 18 advise advise VB 19768 433 19 him -PRON- PRP 19768 433 20 to to TO 19768 433 21 do do VB 19768 433 22 so so RB 19768 433 23 . . . 19768 434 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 434 2 goes go VBZ 19768 434 3 far far RB 19768 434 4 beyond beyond IN 19768 434 5 any any DT 19768 434 6 disavowal disavowal NN 19768 434 7 of of IN 19768 434 8 malice malice NN 19768 434 9 or or CC 19768 434 10 personal personal JJ 19768 434 11 hostility hostility NN 19768 434 12 , , , 19768 434 13 and and CC 19768 434 14 it -PRON- PRP 19768 434 15 amounts amount VBZ 19768 434 16 to to IN 19768 434 17 a a DT 19768 434 18 retraction retraction NN 19768 434 19 of of IN 19768 434 20 the the DT 19768 434 21 opinions opinion NNS 19768 434 22 which which WDT 19768 434 23 he -PRON- PRP 19768 434 24 actually actually RB 19768 434 25 holds hold VBZ 19768 434 26 about about IN 19768 434 27 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 434 28 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 434 29 system system NN 19768 434 30 , , , 19768 434 31 and and CC 19768 434 32 that that IN 19768 434 33 retraction retraction NN 19768 434 34 you -PRON- PRP 19768 434 35 surely surely RB 19768 434 36 can can MD 19768 434 37 not not RB 19768 434 38 expect expect VB 19768 434 39 him -PRON- PRP 19768 434 40 to to TO 19768 434 41 make make VB 19768 434 42 . . . 19768 435 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 435 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 435 3 has have VBZ 19768 435 4 again again RB 19768 435 5 expressed express VBN 19768 435 6 to to IN 19768 435 7 me -PRON- PRP 19768 435 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 435 9 regret regret NN 19768 435 10 that that IN 19768 435 11 the the DT 19768 435 12 form form NN 19768 435 13 of of IN 19768 435 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 435 15 article article NN 19768 435 16 should should MD 19768 435 17 have have VB 19768 435 18 wounded wound VBN 19768 435 19 you -PRON- PRP 19768 435 20 , , , 19768 435 21 and and CC 19768 435 22 he -PRON- PRP 19768 435 23 is be VBZ 19768 435 24 entirely entirely RB 19768 435 25 ready ready JJ 19768 435 26 to to TO 19768 435 27 disavow disavow VB 19768 435 28 any any DT 19768 435 29 intention intention NN 19768 435 30 of of IN 19768 435 31 wounding wound VBG 19768 435 32 you -PRON- PRP 19768 435 33 . . . 19768 435 34 " " '' 19768 436 1 On on IN 19768 436 2 July July NNP 19768 436 3 11 11 CD 19768 436 4 , , , 19768 436 5 I -PRON- PRP 19768 436 6 wrote write VBD 19768 436 7 in in IN 19768 436 8 answer answer NN 19768 436 9 : : : 19768 436 10 " " `` 19768 436 11 Most most RBS 19768 436 12 certainly certainly RB 19768 436 13 I -PRON- PRP 19768 436 14 do do VBP 19768 436 15 not not RB 19768 436 16 expect expect VB 19768 436 17 , , , 19768 436 18 or or CC 19768 436 19 wish wish VB 19768 436 20 , , , 19768 436 21 that that IN 19768 436 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 436 23 Royce Royce NNP 19768 436 24 should should MD 19768 436 25 disavow disavow VB 19768 436 26 any any DT 19768 436 27 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 436 28 ' ' `` 19768 436 29 opinions opinion NNS 19768 436 30 ' ' '' 19768 436 31 he -PRON- PRP 19768 436 32 may may MD 19768 436 33 hold hold VB 19768 436 34 . . . 19768 437 1 What what WP 19768 437 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 437 3 complain complain VBP 19768 437 4 of of IN 19768 437 5 is be VBZ 19768 437 6 a a DT 19768 437 7 _ _ NNP 19768 437 8 misstatement misstatement NN 19768 437 9 of of IN 19768 437 10 fact fact NN 19768 437 11 _ _ NNP 19768 437 12 , , , 19768 437 13 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 19768 437 14 to to TO 19768 437 15 be be VB 19768 437 16 such such JJ 19768 437 17 , , , 19768 437 18 which which WDT 19768 437 19 I -PRON- PRP 19768 437 20 believe believe VBP 19768 437 21 to to TO 19768 437 22 have have VB 19768 437 23 had have VBN 19768 437 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 437 25 origin origin NN 19768 437 26 in in IN 19768 437 27 a a DT 19768 437 28 spirit spirit NN 19768 437 29 of of IN 19768 437 30 malicious malicious JJ 19768 437 31 detraction detraction NN 19768 437 32 , , , 19768 437 33 and and CC 19768 437 34 to to TO 19768 437 35 be be VB 19768 437 36 now now RB 19768 437 37 persevered persevere VBN 19768 437 38 in in IN 19768 437 39 from from IN 19768 437 40 no no DT 19768 437 41 other other JJ 19768 437 42 cause cause NN 19768 437 43 . . . 19768 438 1 In in IN 19768 438 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 438 3 reply reply NN 19768 438 4 to to IN 19768 438 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 438 6 article article NN 19768 438 7 , , , 19768 438 8 which which WDT 19768 438 9 he -PRON- PRP 19768 438 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 438 11 challenged challenge VBD 19768 438 12 and and CC 19768 438 13 then then RB 19768 438 14 pusillanimously pusillanimously RB 19768 438 15 suppressed suppress VBN 19768 438 16 , , , 19768 438 17 he -PRON- PRP 19768 438 18 has have VBZ 19768 438 19 had have VBN 19768 438 20 abundant abundant JJ 19768 438 21 means mean NNS 19768 438 22 of of IN 19768 438 23 information information NN 19768 438 24 . . . 19768 439 1 If if IN 19768 439 2 he -PRON- PRP 19768 439 3 now now RB 19768 439 4 refuses refuse VBZ 19768 439 5 to to TO 19768 439 6 correct correct VB 19768 439 7 a a DT 19768 439 8 misstatement misstatement NN 19768 439 9 which which WDT 19768 439 10 grossly grossly RB 19768 439 11 injures injure VBZ 19768 439 12 me -PRON- PRP 19768 439 13 , , , 19768 439 14 after after IN 19768 439 15 he -PRON- PRP 19768 439 16 has have VBZ 19768 439 17 been be VBN 19768 439 18 informed inform VBN 19768 439 19 of of IN 19768 439 20 the the DT 19768 439 21 truth truth NN 19768 439 22 , , , 19768 439 23 the the DT 19768 439 24 refusal refusal NN 19768 439 25 admits admit VBZ 19768 439 26 of of IN 19768 439 27 but but CC 19768 439 28 one one CD 19768 439 29 interpretation interpretation NN 19768 439 30 , , , 19768 439 31 and and CC 19768 439 32 throws throw VBZ 19768 439 33 a a DT 19768 439 34 satirical satirical JJ 19768 439 35 light light NN 19768 439 36 on on IN 19768 439 37 the the DT 19768 439 38 merely merely RB 19768 439 39 private private JJ 19768 439 40 ' ' `` 19768 439 41 regret regret NN 19768 439 42 ' ' '' 19768 439 43 he -PRON- PRP 19768 439 44 professes profess VBZ 19768 439 45 . . . 19768 440 1 Inasmuch inasmuch RB 19768 440 2 , , , 19768 440 3 however however RB 19768 440 4 , , , 19768 440 5 as as IN 19768 440 6 you -PRON- PRP 19768 440 7 have have VBP 19768 440 8 objected object VBN 19768 440 9 ( ( -LRB- 19768 440 10 quite quite RB 19768 440 11 unnecessarily unnecessarily RB 19768 440 12 , , , 19768 440 13 as as IN 19768 440 14 I -PRON- PRP 19768 440 15 think think VBP 19768 440 16 ) ) -RRB- 19768 440 17 to to IN 19768 440 18 the the DT 19768 440 19 ' ' `` 19768 440 20 form form NN 19768 440 21 ' ' '' 19768 440 22 of of IN 19768 440 23 the the DT 19768 440 24 Card Card NNP 19768 440 25 I -PRON- PRP 19768 440 26 sent send VBD 19768 440 27 you -PRON- PRP 19768 440 28 , , , 19768 440 29 and and CC 19768 440 30 inasmuch inasmuch VB 19768 440 31 as as IN 19768 440 32 I -PRON- PRP 19768 440 33 intend intend VBP 19768 440 34 to to TO 19768 440 35 leave leave VB 19768 440 36 no no DT 19768 440 37 room room NN 19768 440 38 for for IN 19768 440 39 doubt doubt NN 19768 440 40 as as IN 19768 440 41 to to IN 19768 440 42 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 440 43 Royce Royce NNP 19768 440 44 's 's POS 19768 440 45 real real JJ 19768 440 46 animus animus NN 19768 440 47 in in IN 19768 440 48 this this DT 19768 440 49 affair affair NN 19768 440 50 , , , 19768 440 51 I -PRON- PRP 19768 440 52 propose propose VBP 19768 440 53 now now RB 19768 440 54 that that IN 19768 440 55 he -PRON- PRP 19768 440 56 send send VB 19768 440 57 me -PRON- PRP 19768 440 58 such such JJ 19768 440 59 a a DT 19768 440 60 retraction retraction NN 19768 440 61 and and CC 19768 440 62 apology apology NN 19768 440 63 as as IN 19768 440 64 you -PRON- PRP 19768 440 65 yourself -PRON- PRP 19768 440 66 shall shall MD 19768 440 67 deem deem VB 19768 440 68 adequate adequate JJ 19768 440 69 , , , 19768 440 70 fitting fitting JJ 19768 440 71 , , , 19768 440 72 and and CC 19768 440 73 due due JJ 19768 440 74 . . . 19768 441 1 In in IN 19768 441 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 441 3 letter letter NN 19768 441 4 of of IN 19768 441 5 June June NNP 19768 441 6 9 9 CD 19768 441 7 , , , 19768 441 8 you -PRON- PRP 19768 441 9 admitted admit VBD 19768 441 10 that that IN 19768 441 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 441 12 Royce Royce NNP 19768 441 13 had have VBD 19768 441 14 ' ' `` 19768 441 15 transgressed transgress VBN 19768 441 16 the the DT 19768 441 17 limits limit NNS 19768 441 18 of of IN 19768 441 19 courteous courteous JJ 19768 441 20 discussion discussion NN 19768 441 21 ' ' '' 19768 441 22 and and CC 19768 441 23 that that IN 19768 441 24 you -PRON- PRP 19768 441 25 ' ' `` 19768 441 26 do do VBP 19768 441 27 not not RB 19768 441 28 defend defend VB 19768 441 29 in in IN 19768 441 30 all all DT 19768 441 31 respects respect NNS 19768 441 32 the the DT 19768 441 33 tone tone NN 19768 441 34 of of IN 19768 441 35 the the DT 19768 441 36 review review NN 19768 441 37 . . . 19768 441 38 ' ' '' 19768 442 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 442 2 is be VBZ 19768 442 3 plain plain JJ 19768 442 4 enough enough RB 19768 442 5 that that IN 19768 442 6 you -PRON- PRP 19768 442 7 , , , 19768 442 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 442 9 Royce Royce NNP 19768 442 10 's 's POS 19768 442 11 own own JJ 19768 442 12 counsel counsel NN 19768 442 13 , , , 19768 442 14 perceive perceive NN 19768 442 15 at at IN 19768 442 16 least least JJS 19768 442 17 something something NN 19768 442 18 improper improper JJ 19768 442 19 , , , 19768 442 20 something something NN 19768 442 21 that that WDT 19768 442 22 ought ought MD 19768 442 23 to to TO 19768 442 24 be be VB 19768 442 25 retracted retract VBN 19768 442 26 and and CC 19768 442 27 apologized apologize VBN 19768 442 28 for for IN 19768 442 29 . . . 19768 443 1 You -PRON- PRP 19768 443 2 are be VBP 19768 443 3 , , , 19768 443 4 then then RB 19768 443 5 , , , 19768 443 6 I -PRON- PRP 19768 443 7 submit submit VBP 19768 443 8 , , , 19768 443 9 bound bind VBN 19768 443 10 to to TO 19768 443 11 do do VB 19768 443 12 what what WP 19768 443 13 you -PRON- PRP 19768 443 14 can can MD 19768 443 15 to to TO 19768 443 16 right right VB 19768 443 17 the the DT 19768 443 18 wrong wrong NN 19768 443 19 , , , 19768 443 20 which which WDT 19768 443 21 is be VBZ 19768 443 22 not not RB 19768 443 23 at at RB 19768 443 24 all all RB 19768 443 25 done do VBN 19768 443 26 by by IN 19768 443 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 443 28 Royce Royce NNP 19768 443 29 's 's POS 19768 443 30 profuse profuse NN 19768 443 31 , , , 19768 443 32 _ _ NNP 19768 443 33 but but CC 19768 443 34 private private JJ 19768 443 35 _ _ NNP 19768 443 36 , , , 19768 443 37 disclaimers disclaimer NNS 19768 443 38 . . . 19768 444 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 444 2 professes profess VBZ 19768 444 3 to to TO 19768 444 4 bear bear VB 19768 444 5 no no DT 19768 444 6 malice malice NN 19768 444 7 . . . 19768 445 1 Very very RB 19768 445 2 well well RB 19768 445 3 , , , 19768 445 4 then then RB 19768 445 5 : : : 19768 445 6 let let VB 19768 445 7 him -PRON- PRP 19768 445 8 make make VB 19768 445 9 reparation reparation NN 19768 445 10 for for IN 19768 445 11 the the DT 19768 445 12 wrong wrong NN 19768 445 13 he -PRON- PRP 19768 445 14 has have VBZ 19768 445 15 committed commit VBN 19768 445 16 . . . 19768 446 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 446 2 owes owe VBZ 19768 446 3 it -PRON- PRP 19768 446 4 to to IN 19768 446 5 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 446 6 , , , 19768 446 7 if if IN 19768 446 8 he -PRON- PRP 19768 446 9 considers consider VBZ 19768 446 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 446 11 a a DT 19768 446 12 gentleman gentleman NN 19768 446 13 , , , 19768 446 14 certainly certainly RB 19768 446 15 to to IN 19768 446 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 446 17 position position NN 19768 446 18 in in IN 19768 446 19 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 446 20 College College NNP 19768 446 21 , , , 19768 446 22 to to TO 19768 446 23 send send VB 19768 446 24 me -PRON- PRP 19768 446 25 some some DT 19768 446 26 paper paper NN 19768 446 27 , , , 19768 446 28 specifying specify VBG 19768 446 29 what what WP 19768 446 30 he -PRON- PRP 19768 446 31 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 446 32 regrets regret VBZ 19768 446 33 in in IN 19768 446 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 446 35 own own JJ 19768 446 36 article article NN 19768 446 37 , , , 19768 446 38 with with IN 19768 446 39 authority authority NN 19768 446 40 to to TO 19768 446 41 publish publish VB 19768 446 42 this this DT 19768 446 43 paper paper NN 19768 446 44 in in IN 19768 446 45 the the DT 19768 446 46 ' ' `` 19768 446 47 Journal Journal NNP 19768 446 48 of of IN 19768 446 49 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 446 50 . . . 19768 446 51 ' ' '' 19768 447 1 The the DT 19768 447 2 Card Card NNP 19768 447 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 447 4 sent send VBD 19768 447 5 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19768 447 6 indicates indicate VBZ 19768 447 7 what what WP 19768 447 8 I -PRON- PRP 19768 447 9 think think VBP 19768 447 10 is be VBZ 19768 447 11 due due JJ 19768 447 12 to to IN 19768 447 13 me -PRON- PRP 19768 447 14 ; ; : 19768 447 15 if if IN 19768 447 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 447 17 Royce Royce NNP 19768 447 18 , , , 19768 447 19 in in IN 19768 447 20 other other JJ 19768 447 21 language language NN 19768 447 22 , , , 19768 447 23 covers cover VBZ 19768 447 24 the the DT 19768 447 25 same same JJ 19768 447 26 ground ground NN 19768 447 27 , , , 19768 447 28 it -PRON- PRP 19768 447 29 will will MD 19768 447 30 be be VB 19768 447 31 accepted accept VBN 19768 447 32 as as IN 19768 447 33 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 19768 447 34 . . . 19768 448 1 That that DT 19768 448 2 is be VBZ 19768 448 3 the the DT 19768 448 4 very very RB 19768 448 5 least least JJS 19768 448 6 that that IN 19768 448 7 a a DT 19768 448 8 gentleman gentleman NN 19768 448 9 would would MD 19768 448 10 do do VB 19768 448 11 under under IN 19768 448 12 the the DT 19768 448 13 circumstances circumstance NNS 19768 448 14 . . . 19768 449 1 You -PRON- PRP 19768 449 2 can can MD 19768 449 3 not not RB 19768 449 4 object object VB 19768 449 5 to to IN 19768 449 6 this this DT 19768 449 7 proposal proposal NN 19768 449 8 on on IN 19768 449 9 account account NN 19768 449 10 of of IN 19768 449 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 449 12 ' ' `` 19768 449 13 form form NN 19768 449 14 ' ' '' 19768 449 15 ; ; : 19768 449 16 if if IN 19768 449 17 either either CC 19768 449 18 you -PRON- PRP 19768 449 19 or or CC 19768 449 20 he -PRON- PRP 19768 449 21 objects object VBZ 19768 449 22 to to IN 19768 449 23 it -PRON- PRP 19768 449 24 at at RB 19768 449 25 all all RB 19768 449 26 , , , 19768 449 27 it -PRON- PRP 19768 449 28 must must MD 19768 449 29 be be VB 19768 449 30 on on IN 19768 449 31 account account NN 19768 449 32 of of IN 19768 449 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 449 34 substance substance NN 19768 449 35 . . . 19768 450 1 Certainly certainly RB 19768 450 2 you -PRON- PRP 19768 450 3 can can MD 19768 450 4 not not RB 19768 450 5 affect affect VB 19768 450 6 to to TO 19768 450 7 consider consider VB 19768 450 8 it -PRON- PRP 19768 450 9 as as IN 19768 450 10 other other JJ 19768 450 11 than than IN 19768 450 12 ' ' `` 19768 450 13 pacific pacific NNP 19768 450 14 . . . 19768 450 15 ' ' '' 19768 451 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 451 2 shall shall MD 19768 451 3 await await VB 19768 451 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 451 5 answer answer NN 19768 451 6 to to IN 19768 451 7 it -PRON- PRP 19768 451 8 as as IN 19768 451 9 to to IN 19768 451 10 the the DT 19768 451 11 only only JJ 19768 451 12 ' ' `` 19768 451 13 pacific pacific JJ 19768 451 14 step step NN 19768 451 15 on on IN 19768 451 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 451 17 part part NN 19768 451 18 ' ' '' 19768 451 19 which which WDT 19768 451 20 remains remain VBZ 19768 451 21 possible possible JJ 19768 451 22 to to IN 19768 451 23 me -PRON- PRP 19768 451 24 . . . 19768 451 25 " " '' 19768 452 1 In in IN 19768 452 2 reply reply NN 19768 452 3 to to IN 19768 452 4 this this DT 19768 452 5 letter letter NN 19768 452 6 , , , 19768 452 7 on on IN 19768 452 8 July July NNP 19768 452 9 24 24 CD 19768 452 10 , , , 19768 452 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 452 12 Warner Warner NNP 19768 452 13 wrote write VBD 19768 452 14 : : : 19768 452 15 " " `` 19768 452 16 I -PRON- PRP 19768 452 17 forwarded forward VBD 19768 452 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 452 19 letter letter NN 19768 452 20 of of IN 19768 452 21 July July NNP 19768 452 22 11 11 CD 19768 452 23 to to IN 19768 452 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 452 25 Royce Royce NNP 19768 452 26 , , , 19768 452 27 and and CC 19768 452 28 he -PRON- PRP 19768 452 29 has have VBZ 19768 452 30 written write VBN 19768 452 31 a a DT 19768 452 32 reply reply NN 19768 452 33 to to IN 19768 452 34 me -PRON- PRP 19768 452 35 which which WDT 19768 452 36 I -PRON- PRP 19768 452 37 think think VBP 19768 452 38 it -PRON- PRP 19768 452 39 best good JJS 19768 452 40 to to TO 19768 452 41 enclose enclose VB 19768 452 42 as as IN 19768 452 43 he -PRON- PRP 19768 452 44 wrote write VBD 19768 452 45 it -PRON- PRP 19768 452 46 . . . 19768 452 47 " " '' 19768 453 1 In in IN 19768 453 2 this this DT 19768 453 3 enclosed enclose VBN 19768 453 4 letter letter NN 19768 453 5 , , , 19768 453 6 dated date VBN 19768 453 7 July July NNP 19768 453 8 14 14 CD 19768 453 9 , , , 19768 453 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 453 11 Royce Royce NNP 19768 453 12 first first RB 19768 453 13 re re NN 19768 453 14 - - VBN 19768 453 15 affirmed affirm VBN 19768 453 16 , , , 19768 453 17 in in IN 19768 453 18 substance substance NN 19768 453 19 , , , 19768 453 20 the the DT 19768 453 21 truth truth NN 19768 453 22 of of IN 19768 453 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 453 24 false false JJ 19768 453 25 and and CC 19768 453 26 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 19768 453 27 accusation accusation NN 19768 453 28 of of IN 19768 453 29 plagiarism plagiarism NN 19768 453 30 from from IN 19768 453 31 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 453 32 , , , 19768 453 33 and and CC 19768 453 34 then then RB 19768 453 35 wrote write VBD 19768 453 36 as as IN 19768 453 37 follows follow VBZ 19768 453 38 : : : 19768 453 39 " " `` 19768 453 40 Now now RB 19768 453 41 as as IN 19768 453 42 to to IN 19768 453 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 453 44 feeling feeling NN 19768 453 45 concerning concern VBG 19768 453 46 what what WP 19768 453 47 was be VBD 19768 453 48 regrettable regrettable JJ 19768 453 49 in in IN 19768 453 50 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 453 51 article article NN 19768 453 52 . . . 19768 454 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 454 2 repeat repeat VBP 19768 454 3 once once RB 19768 454 4 more more RBR 19768 454 5 -- -- : 19768 454 6 regrettable regrettable JJ 19768 454 7 , , , 19768 454 8 in in IN 19768 454 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 454 10 eyes eye NNS 19768 454 11 , , , 19768 454 12 was be VBD 19768 454 13 the the DT 19768 454 14 manner manner NN 19768 454 15 of of IN 19768 454 16 the the DT 19768 454 17 article article NN 19768 454 18 in in IN 19768 454 19 so so RB 19768 454 20 far far RB 19768 454 21 as as IN 19768 454 22 it -PRON- PRP 19768 454 23 actually actually RB 19768 454 24 gave give VBD 19768 454 25 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19768 454 26 pain pain NN 19768 454 27 to to IN 19768 454 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 454 29 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 454 30 . . . 19768 455 1 And and CC 19768 455 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 455 3 regard regard VBP 19768 455 4 any any DT 19768 455 5 pain pain NN 19768 455 6 as as RB 19768 455 7 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19768 455 8 that that WDT 19768 455 9 may may MD 19768 455 10 have have VB 19768 455 11 been be VBN 19768 455 12 due due JJ 19768 455 13 , , , 19768 455 14 _ _ NNP 19768 455 15 not not RB 19768 455 16 _ _ NNP 19768 455 17 to to IN 19768 455 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 455 19 objectively objectively RB 19768 455 20 justified justified JJ 19768 455 21 opinion opinion NN 19768 455 22 of of IN 19768 455 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 455 24 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 455 25 's 's POS 19768 455 26 work work NN 19768 455 27 ( ( -LRB- 19768 455 28 an an DT 19768 455 29 opinion opinion NN 19768 455 30 which which WDT 19768 455 31 I -PRON- PRP 19768 455 32 can can MD 19768 455 33 not not RB 19768 455 34 alter alter VB 19768 455 35 in in IN 19768 455 36 the the DT 19768 455 37 least least JJS 19768 455 38 ) ) -RRB- 19768 455 39 , , , 19768 455 40 but but CC 19768 455 41 to to IN 19768 455 42 any any DT 19768 455 43 severity severity NN 19768 455 44 of of IN 19768 455 45 expression expression NN 19768 455 46 that that WDT 19768 455 47 may may MD 19768 455 48 not not RB 19768 455 49 have have VB 19768 455 50 been be VBN 19768 455 51 absolutely absolutely RB 19768 455 52 needful needful JJ 19768 455 53 to to TO 19768 455 54 give give VB 19768 455 55 form form NN 19768 455 56 to to IN 19768 455 57 this this DT 19768 455 58 opinion opinion NN 19768 455 59 itself -PRON- PRP 19768 455 60 . . . 19768 456 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 456 2 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 456 3 's 's POS 19768 456 4 reply reply NN 19768 456 5 has have VBZ 19768 456 6 shown show VBN 19768 456 7 him -PRON- PRP 19768 456 8 to to TO 19768 456 9 be be VB 19768 456 10 not not RB 19768 456 11 merely merely RB 19768 456 12 alive alive JJ 19768 456 13 to to IN 19768 456 14 the the DT 19768 456 15 strong strong JJ 19768 456 16 difference difference NN 19768 456 17 of of IN 19768 456 18 opinion opinion NN 19768 456 19 that that WDT 19768 456 20 separates separate VBZ 19768 456 21 us -PRON- PRP 19768 456 22 , , , 19768 456 23 but but CC 19768 456 24 personally personally RB 19768 456 25 offended offend VBN 19768 456 26 by by IN 19768 456 27 an an DT 19768 456 28 attack attack NN 19768 456 29 that that WDT 19768 456 30 was be VBD 19768 456 31 intended intend VBN 19768 456 32 to to TO 19768 456 33 be be VB 19768 456 34 indeed indeed RB 19768 456 35 severe severe JJ 19768 456 36 , , , 19768 456 37 but but CC 19768 456 38 directed direct VBD 19768 456 39 wholly wholly RB 19768 456 40 to to IN 19768 456 41 matters matter NNS 19768 456 42 of of IN 19768 456 43 professional professional JJ 19768 456 44 , , , 19768 456 45 but but CC 19768 456 46 not not RB 19768 456 47 of of IN 19768 456 48 personal personal JJ 19768 456 49 concern concern NN 19768 456 50 . . . 19768 457 1 This this DT 19768 457 2 attitude attitude NN 19768 457 3 of of IN 19768 457 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 457 5 Abbot Abbot NNP 19768 457 6 's 's POS 19768 457 7 I -PRON- PRP 19768 457 8 regret regret VBP 19768 457 9 , , , 19768 457 10 and and CC 19768 457 11 , , , 19768 457 12 in in IN 19768 457 13 so so RB 19768 457 14 far far RB 19768 457 15 as as IN 19768 457 16 I -PRON- PRP 19768 457 17 am be VBP 19768 457 18 to to TO 19768 457 19 blame blame VB 19768 457 20 for for IN 19768 457 21 it -PRON- PRP 19768 457 22 , , , 19768 457 23 I -PRON- PRP 19768 457 24 am be VBP 19768 457 25 willing willing JJ 19768 457 26 to to TO 19768 457 27 express express VB 19768 457 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 457 29 regret regret NN 19768 457 30 publicly publicly RB 19768 457 31 . . . 19768 457 32 " " '' 19768 458 1 This this DT 19768 458 2 letter letter NN 19768 458 3 of of IN 19768 458 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 458 5 Royce Royce NNP 19768 458 6 is be VBZ 19768 458 7 , , , 19768 458 8 in in IN 19768 458 9 effect effect NN 19768 458 10 , , , 19768 458 11 a a DT 19768 458 12 deliberate deliberate JJ 19768 458 13 and and CC 19768 458 14 unqualified unqualified JJ 19768 458 15 re re NN 19768 458 16 - - NN 19768 458 17 affirmation affirmation NN 19768 458 18 of of IN 19768 458 19 every every DT 19768 458 20 fact fact NN 19768 458 21 as as IN 19768 458 22 alleged allege VBN 19768 458 23 , , , 19768 458 24 and and CC 19768 458 25 every every DT 19768 458 26 inference inference NN 19768 458 27 as as IN 19768 458 28 drawn draw VBN 19768 458 29 , , , 19768 458 30 in in IN 19768 458 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 458 32 original original JJ 19768 458 33 libel libel NN 19768 458 34 -- -- : 19768 458 35 a a DT 19768 458 36 deliberate deliberate JJ 19768 458 37 and and CC 19768 458 38 contemptuous contemptuous JJ 19768 458 39 re re NN 19768 458 40 - - NN 19768 458 41 affirmation affirmation NN 19768 458 42 of of IN 19768 458 43 the the DT 19768 458 44 whole whole JJ 19768 458 45 system system NN 19768 458 46 of of IN 19768 458 47 elaborate elaborate JJ 19768 458 48 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19768 458 49 which which WDT 19768 458 50 constitutes constitute VBZ 19768 458 51 it -PRON- PRP 19768 458 52 one one CD 19768 458 53 tissue tissue NN 19768 458 54 of of IN 19768 458 55 libel libel NN 19768 458 56 from from IN 19768 458 57 beginning begin VBG 19768 458 58 to to IN 19768 458 59 end end NN 19768 458 60 . . . 19768 459 1 Nothing nothing NN 19768 459 2 whatever whatever WDT 19768 459 3 in in IN 19768 459 4 the the DT 19768 459 5 substance substance NN 19768 459 6 of of IN 19768 459 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 459 8 article article NN 19768 459 9 is be VBZ 19768 459 10 retracted retract VBN 19768 459 11 or or CC 19768 459 12 regretted regret VBN 19768 459 13 ; ; : 19768 459 14 nothing nothing NN 19768 459 15 is be VBZ 19768 459 16 " " `` 19768 459 17 regrettable regrettable JJ 19768 459 18 " " '' 19768 459 19 even even RB 19768 459 20 in in IN 19768 459 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 459 22 form form NN 19768 459 23 , , , 19768 459 24 except except IN 19768 459 25 vaguely vaguely RB 19768 459 26 , , , 19768 459 27 hypothetically hypothetically RB 19768 459 28 , , , 19768 459 29 and and CC 19768 459 30 conditionally conditionally RB 19768 459 31 ; ; : 19768 459 32 the the DT 19768 459 33 only only JJ 19768 459 34 thing thing NN 19768 459 35 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 459 36 Royce Royce NNP 19768 459 37 " " `` 19768 459 38 regrets regret VBZ 19768 459 39 , , , 19768 459 40 " " '' 19768 459 41 as as IN 19768 459 42 a a DT 19768 459 43 fact fact NN 19768 459 44 , , , 19768 459 45 is be VBZ 19768 459 46 that that IN 19768 459 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 459 48 " " `` 19768 459 49 objectively objectively RB 19768 459 50 justified justify VBD 19768 459 51 " " '' 19768 459 52 and and CC 19768 459 53 " " `` 19768 459 54 intentionally intentionally RB 19768 459 55 severe severe JJ 19768 459 56 attack attack NN 19768 459 57 " " '' 19768 459 58 should should MD 19768 459 59 have have VB 19768 459 60 given give VBN 19768 459 61 needless needless JJ 19768 459 62 " " `` 19768 459 63 personal personal JJ 19768 459 64 offence offence NN 19768 459 65 " " '' 19768 459 66 and and CC 19768 459 67 " " `` 19768 459 68 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19768 459 69 pain pain NN 19768 459 70 " " '' 19768 459 71 to to IN 19768 459 72 its -PRON- PRP$ 19768 459 73 object object NN 19768 459 74 ! ! . 19768 460 1 This this DT 19768 460 2 deliberate deliberate JJ 19768 460 3 and and CC 19768 460 4 contemptuous contemptuous JJ 19768 460 5 refusal refusal NN 19768 460 6 to to TO 19768 460 7 recall recall VB 19768 460 8 , , , 19768 460 9 to to TO 19768 460 10 modify modify VB 19768 460 11 , , , 19768 460 12 or or CC 19768 460 13 to to TO 19768 460 14 apologize apologize VB 19768 460 15 for for IN 19768 460 16 any any DT 19768 460 17 of of IN 19768 460 18 the the DT 19768 460 19 false false JJ 19768 460 20 accusations accusation NNS 19768 460 21 he -PRON- PRP 19768 460 22 has have VBZ 19768 460 23 made make VBN 19768 460 24 against against IN 19768 460 25 me -PRON- PRP 19768 460 26 is be VBZ 19768 460 27 , , , 19768 460 28 I -PRON- PRP 19768 460 29 submit submit VBP 19768 460 30 , , , 19768 460 31 demonstration demonstration NN 19768 460 32 of of IN 19768 460 33 the the DT 19768 460 34 malice malice NN 19768 460 35 which which WDT 19768 460 36 originally originally RB 19768 460 37 prompted prompt VBD 19768 460 38 them -PRON- PRP 19768 460 39 , , , 19768 460 40 and and CC 19768 460 41 now now RB 19768 460 42 moves move VBZ 19768 460 43 him -PRON- PRP 19768 460 44 to to TO 19768 460 45 maintain maintain VB 19768 460 46 them -PRON- PRP 19768 460 47 ; ; : 19768 460 48 nothing nothing NN 19768 460 49 further further RB 19768 460 50 is be VBZ 19768 460 51 needed need VBN 19768 460 52 to to TO 19768 460 53 make make VB 19768 460 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 19768 460 55 malicious malicious JJ 19768 460 56 character character NN 19768 460 57 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 460 58 plain plain JJ 19768 460 59 , , , 19768 460 60 and and CC 19768 460 61 to to TO 19768 460 62 prove prove VB 19768 460 63 the the DT 19768 460 64 insincerity insincerity NN 19768 460 65 of of IN 19768 460 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 460 67 disclaimers disclaimer NNS 19768 460 68 of of IN 19768 460 69 malice malice NN 19768 460 70 . . . 19768 461 1 But but CC 19768 461 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 461 3 Royce Royce NNP 19768 461 4 seriously seriously RB 19768 461 5 mistakes mistake VBZ 19768 461 6 the the DT 19768 461 7 nature nature NN 19768 461 8 of of IN 19768 461 9 the the DT 19768 461 10 effect effect NN 19768 461 11 produced produce VBN 19768 461 12 by by IN 19768 461 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 461 14 " " `` 19768 461 15 attack attack NN 19768 461 16 , , , 19768 461 17 " " '' 19768 461 18 when when WRB 19768 461 19 he -PRON- PRP 19768 461 20 affects affect VBZ 19768 461 21 to to TO 19768 461 22 consider consider VB 19768 461 23 it -PRON- PRP 19768 461 24 as as IN 19768 461 25 the the DT 19768 461 26 quite quite RB 19768 461 27 needless needless JJ 19768 461 28 excitation excitation NN 19768 461 29 of of IN 19768 461 30 excessive excessive JJ 19768 461 31 sensitiveness sensitiveness NN 19768 461 32 . . . 19768 462 1 If if IN 19768 462 2 a a DT 19768 462 3 gentleman gentleman NN 19768 462 4 in in IN 19768 462 5 a a DT 19768 462 6 crowd crowd NN 19768 462 7 discovers discover VBZ 19768 462 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 462 9 nearest near JJS 19768 462 10 neighbor neighbor NN 19768 462 11 engaged engage VBN 19768 462 12 in in IN 19768 462 13 filching filch VBG 19768 462 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 462 15 pocket pocket NN 19768 462 16 - - HYPH 19768 462 17 book book NN 19768 462 18 , , , 19768 462 19 and and CC 19768 462 20 at at IN 19768 462 21 once once RB 19768 462 22 hands hand NNS 19768 462 23 the the DT 19768 462 24 culprit culprit NN 19768 462 25 over over RP 19768 462 26 to to IN 19768 462 27 the the DT 19768 462 28 police police NN 19768 462 29 , , , 19768 462 30 it -PRON- PRP 19768 462 31 would would MD 19768 462 32 hardly hardly RB 19768 462 33 be be VB 19768 462 34 graphic graphic JJ 19768 462 35 to to TO 19768 462 36 describe describe VB 19768 462 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 462 38 frame frame NN 19768 462 39 of of IN 19768 462 40 mind mind NN 19768 462 41 as as IN 19768 462 42 needless needless JJ 19768 462 43 " " `` 19768 462 44 personal personal JJ 19768 462 45 offence offence NN 19768 462 46 " " '' 19768 462 47 or or CC 19768 462 48 " " `` 19768 462 49 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19768 462 50 pain pain NN 19768 462 51 " " '' 19768 462 52 ; ; , 19768 462 53 and and CC 19768 462 54 the the DT 19768 462 55 expressions expression NNS 19768 462 56 are be VBP 19768 462 57 no no RB 19768 462 58 more more RBR 19768 462 59 graphic graphic JJ 19768 462 60 as as IN 19768 462 61 to to IN 19768 462 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 462 63 own own JJ 19768 462 64 frame frame NN 19768 462 65 of of IN 19768 462 66 mind mind NN 19768 462 67 , , , 19768 462 68 when when WRB 19768 462 69 I -PRON- PRP 19768 462 70 discover discover VBP 19768 462 71 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 462 72 Royce Royce NNP 19768 462 73 endeavoring endeavor VBG 19768 462 74 to to TO 19768 462 75 filch filch VB 19768 462 76 from from IN 19768 462 77 me -PRON- PRP 19768 462 78 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 462 79 reputation reputation NN 19768 462 80 in in IN 19768 462 81 the the DT 19768 462 82 name name NN 19768 462 83 of of IN 19768 462 84 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 462 85 University University NNP 19768 462 86 . . . 19768 463 1 It -PRON- PRP 19768 463 2 is be VBZ 19768 463 3 not not RB 19768 463 4 always always RB 19768 463 5 safe safe JJ 19768 463 6 to to TO 19768 463 7 reckon reckon VB 19768 463 8 on on IN 19768 463 9 the the DT 19768 463 10 absence absence NN 19768 463 11 , , , 19768 463 12 in in IN 19768 463 13 parties party NNS 19768 463 14 confessedly confessedly RB 19768 463 15 " " '' 19768 463 16 attacked attack VBN 19768 463 17 , , , 19768 463 18 " " '' 19768 463 19 of of IN 19768 463 20 all all DT 19768 463 21 capacity capacity NN 19768 463 22 for for IN 19768 463 23 _ _ NNP 19768 463 24 moral moral JJ 19768 463 25 indignation indignation NN 19768 463 26 _ _ NNP 19768 463 27 , , , 19768 463 28 or or CC 19768 463 29 all all DT 19768 463 30 capacity capacity NN 19768 463 31 for for IN 19768 463 32 moral moral JJ 19768 463 33 self self NN 19768 463 34 - - HYPH 19768 463 35 defence defence NN 19768 463 36 . . . 19768 464 1 In in IN 19768 464 2 reply reply NN 19768 464 3 to to IN 19768 464 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 19768 464 5 Warner Warner NNP 19768 464 6 , , , 19768 464 7 August August NNP 19768 464 8 4 4 CD 19768 464 9 , , , 19768 464 10 I -PRON- PRP 19768 464 11 wrote write VBD 19768 464 12 as as IN 19768 464 13 follows follow VBZ 19768 464 14 : : : 19768 464 15 " " `` 19768 464 16 Permit permit VB 19768 464 17 me -PRON- PRP 19768 464 18 further further RB 19768 464 19 to to TO 19768 464 20 say say VB 19768 464 21 , , , 19768 464 22 with with IN 19768 464 23 regard regard NN 19768 464 24 to to IN 19768 464 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 464 26 Royce Royce NNP 19768 464 27 's 's POS 19768 464 28 letter letter NN 19768 464 29 , , , 19768 464 30 that that IN 19768 464 31 I -PRON- PRP 19768 464 32 can can MD 19768 464 33 only only RB 19768 464 34 interpret interpret VB 19768 464 35 it -PRON- PRP 19768 464 36 as as IN 19768 464 37 a a DT 19768 464 38 distinct distinct JJ 19768 464 39 refusal refusal NN 19768 464 40 to to TO 19768 464 41 retract retract VB 19768 464 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 464 43 accusation accusation NN 19768 464 44 that that IN 19768 464 45 I -PRON- PRP 19768 464 46 have have VBP 19768 464 47 made make VBN 19768 464 48 ' ' `` 19768 464 49 extravagant extravagant JJ 19768 464 50 pretensions pretension NNS 19768 464 51 as as IN 19768 464 52 to to IN 19768 464 53 the the DT 19768 464 54 originality originality NN 19768 464 55 and and CC 19768 464 56 profundity profundity NN 19768 464 57 of of IN 19768 464 58 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 464 59 still still RB 19768 464 60 unpublished unpublished JJ 19768 464 61 system system NN 19768 464 62 of of IN 19768 464 63 philosophy'--a philosophy'--a NN 19768 464 64 distinct distinct JJ 19768 464 65 refusal refusal NN 19768 464 66 to to TO 19768 464 67 retract retract VB 19768 464 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 464 69 accusation accusation NN 19768 464 70 that that IN 19768 464 71 I -PRON- PRP 19768 464 72 have have VBP 19768 464 73 ' ' `` 19768 464 74 borrowed borrow VBN 19768 464 75 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 464 76 theory theory NN 19768 464 77 of of IN 19768 464 78 universals universal NNS 19768 464 79 from from IN 19768 464 80 Hegel'--a Hegel'--a NNP 19768 464 81 distinct distinct JJ 19768 464 82 refusal refusal NN 19768 464 83 to to TO 19768 464 84 retract retract VB 19768 464 85 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 464 86 ' ' `` 19768 464 87 professional professional JJ 19768 464 88 warning warning NN 19768 464 89 ' ' '' 19768 464 90 based base VBN 19768 464 91 upon upon IN 19768 464 92 these these DT 19768 464 93 accusations accusation NNS 19768 464 94 . . . 19768 465 1 These these DT 19768 465 2 were be VBD 19768 465 3 the the DT 19768 465 4 chief chief JJ 19768 465 5 points point NNS 19768 465 6 of of IN 19768 465 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 465 8 Card Card NNP 19768 465 9 , , , 19768 465 10 and and CC 19768 465 11 I -PRON- PRP 19768 465 12 note note VBP 19768 465 13 the the DT 19768 465 14 refusal refusal NN 19768 465 15 implied imply VBN 19768 465 16 by by IN 19768 465 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 465 18 Royce Royce NNP 19768 465 19 's 's POS 19768 465 20 evasive evasive JJ 19768 465 21 letter letter NN 19768 465 22 . . . 19768 466 1 But but CC 19768 466 2 I -PRON- PRP 19768 466 3 decline decline VBP 19768 466 4 to to TO 19768 466 5 accept accept VB 19768 466 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 466 7 plea plea NN 19768 466 8 of of IN 19768 466 9 ' ' `` 19768 466 10 conscientiousness conscientiousness NN 19768 466 11 ' ' '' 19768 466 12 in in IN 19768 466 13 maintaining maintain VBG 19768 466 14 the the DT 19768 466 15 accusation accusation NN 19768 466 16 as as IN 19768 466 17 to to IN 19768 466 18 Hegel Hegel NNP 19768 466 19 . . . 19768 467 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 467 2 might may MD 19768 467 3 as as RB 19768 467 4 well well RB 19768 467 5 plead plead VB 19768 467 6 ' ' `` 19768 467 7 conscientiousness conscientiousness NN 19768 467 8 ' ' '' 19768 467 9 in in IN 19768 467 10 maintaining maintain VBG 19768 467 11 an an DT 19768 467 12 accusation accusation NN 19768 467 13 that that IN 19768 467 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 467 15 Royce Royce NNP 19768 467 16 assassinated assassinate VBD 19768 467 17 Abraham Abraham NNP 19768 467 18 Lincoln Lincoln NNP 19768 467 19 , , , 19768 467 20 in in IN 19768 467 21 face face NN 19768 467 22 of of IN 19768 467 23 the the DT 19768 467 24 evidence evidence NN 19768 467 25 that that IN 19768 467 26 John John NNP 19768 467 27 Wilkes Wilkes NNP 19768 467 28 Booth Booth NNP 19768 467 29 was be VBD 19768 467 30 the the DT 19768 467 31 assassin assassin NN 19768 467 32 . . . 19768 467 33 " " '' 19768 468 1 Here here RB 19768 468 2 the the DT 19768 468 3 correspondence correspondence NN 19768 468 4 closed close VBD 19768 468 5 . . . 19768 469 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 19768 469 2 apology apology NN 19768 469 3 for for IN 19768 469 4 inflicting inflict VBG 19768 469 5 it -PRON- PRP 19768 469 6 upon upon IN 19768 469 7 you -PRON- PRP 19768 469 8 , , , 19768 469 9 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 469 10 , , , 19768 469 11 must must MD 19768 469 12 be be VB 19768 469 13 the the DT 19768 469 14 necessity necessity NN 19768 469 15 of of IN 19768 469 16 showing show VBG 19768 469 17 to to IN 19768 469 18 you -PRON- PRP 19768 469 19 that that IN 19768 469 20 , , , 19768 469 21 as as IN 19768 469 22 I -PRON- PRP 19768 469 23 was be VBD 19768 469 24 plainly plainly RB 19768 469 25 bound bind VBN 19768 469 26 to to TO 19768 469 27 do do VB 19768 469 28 , , , 19768 469 29 I -PRON- PRP 19768 469 30 first first RB 19768 469 31 exhausted exhaust VBD 19768 469 32 every every DT 19768 469 33 means means NN 19768 469 34 of of IN 19768 469 35 private private JJ 19768 469 36 redress redress NN 19768 469 37 before before IN 19768 469 38 laying lay VBG 19768 469 39 the the DT 19768 469 40 matter matter NN 19768 469 41 before before IN 19768 469 42 you -PRON- PRP 19768 469 43 publicly publicly RB 19768 469 44 . . . 19768 470 1 Not not RB 19768 470 2 till till IN 19768 470 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 470 4 had have VBD 19768 470 5 failed fail VBN 19768 470 6 to to TO 19768 470 7 obtain obtain VB 19768 470 8 a a DT 19768 470 9 fair fair JJ 19768 470 10 hearing hearing NN 19768 470 11 in in IN 19768 470 12 the the DT 19768 470 13 same same JJ 19768 470 14 periodical periodical NN 19768 470 15 which which WDT 19768 470 16 published publish VBD 19768 470 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 470 18 Royce Royce NNP 19768 470 19 's 's POS 19768 470 20 libel libel NN 19768 470 21 , , , 19768 470 22 and and CC 19768 470 23 not not RB 19768 470 24 till till IN 19768 470 25 I -PRON- PRP 19768 470 26 had have VBD 19768 470 27 failed fail VBN 19768 470 28 to to TO 19768 470 29 obtain obtain VB 19768 470 30 from from IN 19768 470 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 470 32 Royce Royce NNP 19768 470 33 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 470 34 a a DT 19768 470 35 retraction retraction NN 19768 470 36 of of IN 19768 470 37 this this DT 19768 470 38 libel libel NN 19768 470 39 , , , 19768 470 40 did do VBD 19768 470 41 I -PRON- PRP 19768 470 42 find find VB 19768 470 43 myself -PRON- PRP 19768 470 44 reduced reduce VBN 19768 470 45 to to IN 19768 470 46 the the DT 19768 470 47 alternatives alternative NNS 19768 470 48 of of IN 19768 470 49 either either DT 19768 470 50 acquiescing acquiescing NN 19768 470 51 in in IN 19768 470 52 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 470 53 own own JJ 19768 470 54 unwarrantably unwarrantably RB 19768 470 55 insinuated insinuate VBN 19768 470 56 condemnation condemnation NN 19768 470 57 , , , 19768 470 58 or or CC 19768 470 59 else else RB 19768 470 60 of of IN 19768 470 61 clearing clear VBG 19768 470 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 470 63 assailed assailed JJ 19768 470 64 reputation reputation NN 19768 470 65 through through IN 19768 470 66 direct direct JJ 19768 470 67 and and CC 19768 470 68 open open JJ 19768 470 69 appeal appeal NN 19768 470 70 to to IN 19768 470 71 you -PRON- PRP 19768 470 72 . . . 19768 471 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 471 2 am be VBP 19768 471 3 no no DT 19768 471 4 lover lover NN 19768 471 5 of of IN 19768 471 6 strife strife NN 19768 471 7 , , , 19768 471 8 and and CC 19768 471 9 least least JJS 19768 471 10 of of IN 19768 471 11 all all DT 19768 471 12 do do VBP 19768 471 13 I -PRON- PRP 19768 471 14 now now RB 19768 471 15 seek seek VB 19768 471 16 revenge revenge NN 19768 471 17 . . . 19768 472 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 472 2 seek seek VBP 19768 472 3 only only RB 19768 472 4 such such PDT 19768 472 5 a a DT 19768 472 6 vindication vindication NN 19768 472 7 of of IN 19768 472 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 472 9 good good JJ 19768 472 10 name name NN 19768 472 11 from from IN 19768 472 12 unmerited unmerited JJ 19768 472 13 calumny calumny NNP 19768 472 14 as as IN 19768 472 15 you -PRON- PRP 19768 472 16 , , , 19768 472 17 in in IN 19768 472 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 472 19 own own JJ 19768 472 20 good good JJ 19768 472 21 judgment judgment NN 19768 472 22 and and CC 19768 472 23 in in IN 19768 472 24 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 472 25 own own JJ 19768 472 26 chosen choose VBN 19768 472 27 way way NN 19768 472 28 , , , 19768 472 29 are be VBP 19768 472 30 now now RB 19768 472 31 , , , 19768 472 32 I -PRON- PRP 19768 472 33 most most RBS 19768 472 34 respectfully respectfully RB 19768 472 35 submit submit VBP 19768 472 36 , , , 19768 472 37 bound bind VBN 19768 472 38 in in IN 19768 472 39 justice justice NN 19768 472 40 to to TO 19768 472 41 give give VB 19768 472 42 . . . 19768 473 1 VIII VIII NNP 19768 473 2 . . . 19768 474 1 To to IN 19768 474 2 you -PRON- PRP 19768 474 3 , , , 19768 474 4 therefore therefore RB 19768 474 5 , , , 19768 474 6 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 474 7 of of IN 19768 474 8 the the DT 19768 474 9 Corporation Corporation NNP 19768 474 10 and and CC 19768 474 11 Board Board NNP 19768 474 12 of of IN 19768 474 13 Overseers Overseers NNP 19768 474 14 of of IN 19768 474 15 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 474 16 University University NNP 19768 474 17 , , , 19768 474 18 I -PRON- PRP 19768 474 19 make make VBP 19768 474 20 with with IN 19768 474 21 all all DT 19768 474 22 due due JJ 19768 474 23 deference deference NN 19768 474 24 this this DT 19768 474 25 public public JJ 19768 474 26 appeal appeal NN 19768 474 27 for for IN 19768 474 28 redress redress NN 19768 474 29 of of IN 19768 474 30 a a DT 19768 474 31 wrong wrong JJ 19768 474 32 done do VBN 19768 474 33 to to IN 19768 474 34 me -PRON- PRP 19768 474 35 by by IN 19768 474 36 one one CD 19768 474 37 of of IN 19768 474 38 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 474 39 appointees appointee NNS 19768 474 40 -- -- : 19768 474 41 a a DT 19768 474 42 wrong wrong JJ 19768 474 43 done do VBN 19768 474 44 , , , 19768 474 45 not not RB 19768 474 46 in in IN 19768 474 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 474 48 private private JJ 19768 474 49 capacity capacity NN 19768 474 50 as as IN 19768 474 51 an an DT 19768 474 52 individual individual NN 19768 474 53 ( ( -LRB- 19768 474 54 for for IN 19768 474 55 which which WDT 19768 474 56 , , , 19768 474 57 of of IN 19768 474 58 course course NN 19768 474 59 , , , 19768 474 60 you -PRON- PRP 19768 474 61 would would MD 19768 474 62 not not RB 19768 474 63 be be VB 19768 474 64 justly justly RB 19768 474 65 held hold VBN 19768 474 66 responsible responsible JJ 19768 474 67 ) ) -RRB- 19768 474 68 , , , 19768 474 69 but but CC 19768 474 70 publicly publicly RB 19768 474 71 and and CC 19768 474 72 explicitly explicitly RB 19768 474 73 and and CC 19768 474 74 emphatically emphatically RB 19768 474 75 in in IN 19768 474 76 the the DT 19768 474 77 name name NN 19768 474 78 of of IN 19768 474 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 474 80 " " `` 19768 474 81 profession profession NN 19768 474 82 , , , 19768 474 83 " " '' 19768 474 84 that that RB 19768 474 85 is is RB 19768 474 86 , , , 19768 474 87 of of IN 19768 474 88 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 474 89 position position NN 19768 474 90 as as IN 19768 474 91 a a DT 19768 474 92 professor professor NN 19768 474 93 in in IN 19768 474 94 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 474 95 College College NNP 19768 474 96 . . . 19768 475 1 This this DT 19768 475 2 position position NN 19768 475 3 is be VBZ 19768 475 4 an an DT 19768 475 5 official official JJ 19768 475 6 one one NN 19768 475 7 , , , 19768 475 8 due due IN 19768 475 9 to to IN 19768 475 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 475 11 appointment appointment NN 19768 475 12 ; ; : 19768 475 13 and and CC 19768 475 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 475 15 scandalous scandalous JJ 19768 475 16 abuse abuse NN 19768 475 17 of of IN 19768 475 18 it -PRON- PRP 19768 475 19 renders render VBZ 19768 475 20 him -PRON- PRP 19768 475 21 amenable amenable JJ 19768 475 22 to to TO 19768 475 23 discipline discipline VB 19768 475 24 by by IN 19768 475 25 you -PRON- PRP 19768 475 26 to to IN 19768 475 27 whom whom WP 19768 475 28 he -PRON- PRP 19768 475 29 owes owe VBZ 19768 475 30 it -PRON- PRP 19768 475 31 . . . 19768 476 1 Therefore therefore RB 19768 476 2 , , , 19768 476 3 I -PRON- PRP 19768 476 4 now now RB 19768 476 5 formally formally RB 19768 476 6 appeal appeal VBP 19768 476 7 to to IN 19768 476 8 you -PRON- PRP 19768 476 9 for for IN 19768 476 10 redress redress NN 19768 476 11 of of IN 19768 476 12 these these DT 19768 476 13 specific specific JJ 19768 476 14 wrongs wrong NNS 19768 476 15 , , , 19768 476 16 committed commit VBN 19768 476 17 by by IN 19768 476 18 Assistant Assistant NNP 19768 476 19 Professor Professor NNP 19768 476 20 Josiah Josiah NNP 19768 476 21 Royce Royce NNP 19768 476 22 in in IN 19768 476 23 flagrant flagrant JJ 19768 476 24 violation violation NN 19768 476 25 of of IN 19768 476 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 476 27 rights right NNS 19768 476 28 as as IN 19768 476 29 a a DT 19768 476 30 citizen citizen NN 19768 476 31 and and CC 19768 476 32 as as IN 19768 476 33 a a DT 19768 476 34 man:-- man:-- NN 19768 476 35 I. i. NN 19768 477 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 477 2 has have VBZ 19768 477 3 published publish VBN 19768 477 4 against against IN 19768 477 5 me -PRON- PRP 19768 477 6 , , , 19768 477 7 in in IN 19768 477 8 the the DT 19768 477 9 " " `` 19768 477 10 International International NNP 19768 477 11 Journal Journal NNP 19768 477 12 of of IN 19768 477 13 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 477 14 , , , 19768 477 15 " " '' 19768 477 16 a a DT 19768 477 17 libel libel NN 19768 477 18 which which WDT 19768 477 19 is be VBZ 19768 477 20 as as IN 19768 477 21 wanton wanton NN 19768 477 22 and and CC 19768 477 23 unprovoked unprovoke VBD 19768 477 24 as as IN 19768 477 25 it -PRON- PRP 19768 477 26 is be VBZ 19768 477 27 malicious malicious JJ 19768 477 28 and and CC 19768 477 29 false false JJ 19768 477 30 , , , 19768 477 31 and and CC 19768 477 32 for for IN 19768 477 33 which which WDT 19768 477 34 no no DT 19768 477 35 motive motive NN 19768 477 36 is be VBZ 19768 477 37 even even RB 19768 477 38 conceivable conceivable JJ 19768 477 39 except except IN 19768 477 40 mere mere JJ 19768 477 41 professional professional JJ 19768 477 42 jealousy jealousy NN 19768 477 43 or or CC 19768 477 44 rivalry rivalry NN 19768 477 45 in in IN 19768 477 46 authorship authorship NN 19768 477 47 . . . 19768 478 1 II ii CD 19768 478 2 . . . 19768 479 1 He -PRON- PRP 19768 479 2 has have VBZ 19768 479 3 sought seek VBN 19768 479 4 to to TO 19768 479 5 give give VB 19768 479 6 credibility credibility NN 19768 479 7 and and CC 19768 479 8 respectability respectability NN 19768 479 9 to to IN 19768 479 10 this this DT 19768 479 11 false false JJ 19768 479 12 and and CC 19768 479 13 libellous libellous JJ 19768 479 14 publication publication NN 19768 479 15 by by IN 19768 479 16 invoking invoke VBG 19768 479 17 the the DT 19768 479 18 authority authority NN 19768 479 19 , , , 19768 479 20 not not RB 19768 479 21 of of IN 19768 479 22 reason reason NN 19768 479 23 or or CC 19768 479 24 truth truth NN 19768 479 25 , , , 19768 479 26 but but CC 19768 479 27 of of IN 19768 479 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 479 29 mere mere JJ 19768 479 30 " " `` 19768 479 31 professional professional JJ 19768 479 32 " " '' 19768 479 33 position position NN 19768 479 34 as as IN 19768 479 35 professor professor NN 19768 479 36 in in IN 19768 479 37 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 479 38 University University NNP 19768 479 39 , , , 19768 479 40 thereby thereby RB 19768 479 41 artfully artfully RB 19768 479 42 suggesting suggest VBG 19768 479 43 and and CC 19768 479 44 insinuating insinuate VBG 19768 479 45 to to IN 19768 479 46 the the DT 19768 479 47 uninformed uninformed JJ 19768 479 48 public public NN 19768 479 49 that that IN 19768 479 50 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 479 51 University University NNP 19768 479 52 sustains sustain VBZ 19768 479 53 him -PRON- PRP 19768 479 54 in in IN 19768 479 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 479 56 attack attack NN 19768 479 57 ; ; : 19768 479 58 whereas whereas IN 19768 479 59 , , , 19768 479 60 in in IN 19768 479 61 conferring confer VBG 19768 479 62 upon upon IN 19768 479 63 me -PRON- PRP 19768 479 64 the the DT 19768 479 65 degree degree NN 19768 479 66 of of IN 19768 479 67 doctor doctor NN 19768 479 68 of of IN 19768 479 69 philosophy philosophy NN 19768 479 70 and and CC 19768 479 71 in in IN 19768 479 72 committing commit VBG 19768 479 73 to to IN 19768 479 74 me -PRON- PRP 19768 479 75 formerly formerly RB 19768 479 76 the the DT 19768 479 77 conduct conduct NN 19768 479 78 of of IN 19768 479 79 an an DT 19768 479 80 advanced advanced JJ 19768 479 81 course course NN 19768 479 82 of of IN 19768 479 83 philosophical philosophical JJ 19768 479 84 instruction instruction NN 19768 479 85 , , , 19768 479 86 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 479 87 University University NNP 19768 479 88 has have VBZ 19768 479 89 given give VBN 19768 479 90 emphatic emphatic JJ 19768 479 91 testimony testimony NN 19768 479 92 to to IN 19768 479 93 the the DT 19768 479 94 contrary contrary NN 19768 479 95 . . . 19768 480 1 III iii CD 19768 480 2 . . . 19768 481 1 Repudiating repudiate VBG 19768 481 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 481 3 bold bold JJ 19768 481 4 promise promise NN 19768 481 5 to to TO 19768 481 6 " " `` 19768 481 7 ask ask VB 19768 481 8 no no DT 19768 481 9 mercy mercy NN 19768 481 10 , , , 19768 481 11 " " '' 19768 481 12 he -PRON- PRP 19768 481 13 has have VBZ 19768 481 14 sought seek VBN 19768 481 15 , , , 19768 481 16 with with IN 19768 481 17 incredible incredible JJ 19768 481 18 cowardice cowardice NN 19768 481 19 and and CC 19768 481 20 meanness meanness JJ 19768 481 21 , , , 19768 481 22 to to TO 19768 481 23 deprive deprive VB 19768 481 24 me -PRON- PRP 19768 481 25 of of IN 19768 481 26 all all DT 19768 481 27 opportunity opportunity NN 19768 481 28 of of IN 19768 481 29 being be VBG 19768 481 30 heard hear VBN 19768 481 31 in in IN 19768 481 32 self self NN 19768 481 33 - - HYPH 19768 481 34 defence defence NN 19768 481 35 , , , 19768 481 36 _ _ NNP 19768 481 37 first first JJ 19768 481 38 _ _ NNP 19768 481 39 , , , 19768 481 40 by by IN 19768 481 41 excluding exclude VBG 19768 481 42 from from IN 19768 481 43 the the DT 19768 481 44 " " `` 19768 481 45 International International NNP 19768 481 46 Journal Journal NNP 19768 481 47 of of IN 19768 481 48 Ethics Ethics NNP 19768 481 49 " " `` 19768 481 50 my -PRON- PRP$ 19768 481 51 perfectly perfectly RB 19768 481 52 reasonable reasonable JJ 19768 481 53 reply reply NN 19768 481 54 to to IN 19768 481 55 what what WP 19768 481 56 he -PRON- PRP 19768 481 57 himself -PRON- PRP 19768 481 58 confesses confess VBZ 19768 481 59 to to TO 19768 481 60 have have VB 19768 481 61 been be VBN 19768 481 62 an an DT 19768 481 63 " " `` 19768 481 64 intentionally intentionally RB 19768 481 65 severe severe JJ 19768 481 66 attack attack NN 19768 481 67 , , , 19768 481 68 " " '' 19768 481 69 and and CC 19768 481 70 , , , 19768 481 71 _ _ NNP 19768 481 72 secondly secondly RB 19768 481 73 _ _ NNP 19768 481 74 , , , 19768 481 75 by by IN 19768 481 76 threatening threaten VBG 19768 481 77 me -PRON- PRP 19768 481 78 through through IN 19768 481 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 481 80 counsel counsel NN 19768 481 81 with with IN 19768 481 82 legal legal JJ 19768 481 83 prosecution prosecution NN 19768 481 84 , , , 19768 481 85 if if IN 19768 481 86 I -PRON- PRP 19768 481 87 publish publish VBP 19768 481 88 it -PRON- PRP 19768 481 89 anywhere anywhere RB 19768 481 90 else else RB 19768 481 91 or or CC 19768 481 92 circulate circulate VB 19768 481 93 it -PRON- PRP 19768 481 94 at at RB 19768 481 95 all all RB 19768 481 96 . . . 19768 482 1 IV IV NNP 19768 482 2 . . . 19768 483 1 Lastly lastly RB 19768 483 2 , , , 19768 483 3 when when WRB 19768 483 4 , , , 19768 483 5 after after IN 19768 483 6 all all PDT 19768 483 7 this this DT 19768 483 8 , , , 19768 483 9 in in IN 19768 483 10 order order NN 19768 483 11 to to TO 19768 483 12 spare spare VB 19768 483 13 him -PRON- PRP 19768 483 14 the the DT 19768 483 15 mortification mortification NN 19768 483 16 and and CC 19768 483 17 disgrace disgrace NN 19768 483 18 of of IN 19768 483 19 a a DT 19768 483 20 public public JJ 19768 483 21 exposure exposure NN 19768 483 22 , , , 19768 483 23 and and CC 19768 483 24 in in IN 19768 483 25 order order NN 19768 483 26 to to TO 19768 483 27 prevent prevent VB 19768 483 28 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 483 29 University University NNP 19768 483 30 from from IN 19768 483 31 incurring incur VBG 19768 483 32 any any DT 19768 483 33 possible possible JJ 19768 483 34 discredit discredit NN 19768 483 35 on on IN 19768 483 36 account account NN 19768 483 37 of of IN 19768 483 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 483 39 personal personal JJ 19768 483 40 misconduct misconduct NN 19768 483 41 , , , 19768 483 42 I -PRON- PRP 19768 483 43 proposed propose VBD 19768 483 44 to to IN 19768 483 45 him -PRON- PRP 19768 483 46 a a DT 19768 483 47 pacific pacific JJ 19768 483 48 settlement settlement NN 19768 483 49 of of IN 19768 483 50 the the DT 19768 483 51 whole whole JJ 19768 483 52 affair affair NN 19768 483 53 through through IN 19768 483 54 a a DT 19768 483 55 simple simple JJ 19768 483 56 retraction retraction NN 19768 483 57 of of IN 19768 483 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 483 59 calumnious calumnious JJ 19768 483 60 accusations accusation NNS 19768 483 61 , , , 19768 483 62 and and CC 19768 483 63 that that DT 19768 483 64 , , , 19768 483 65 too too RB 19768 483 66 , , , 19768 483 67 in in IN 19768 483 68 words word NNS 19768 483 69 of of IN 19768 483 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 19768 483 71 own own JJ 19768 483 72 choosing choosing NN 19768 483 73 , , , 19768 483 74 he -PRON- PRP 19768 483 75 made make VBD 19768 483 76 no no DT 19768 483 77 answer answer NN 19768 483 78 but but CC 19768 483 79 a a DT 19768 483 80 stubborn stubborn JJ 19768 483 81 and and CC 19768 483 82 contumelious contumelious JJ 19768 483 83 re re NN 19768 483 84 - - NN 19768 483 85 affirmation affirmation NN 19768 483 86 of of IN 19768 483 87 the the DT 19768 483 88 original original JJ 19768 483 89 libel libel NN 19768 483 90 . . . 19768 484 1 I -PRON- PRP 19768 484 2 submit submit VBP 19768 484 3 that that IN 19768 484 4 these these DT 19768 484 5 acts act NNS 19768 484 6 of of IN 19768 484 7 wrong wrong JJ 19768 484 8 constitute constitute NN 19768 484 9 conduct conduct NN 19768 484 10 unbecoming unbecome VBG 19768 484 11 a a DT 19768 484 12 gentleman gentleman NN 19768 484 13 , , , 19768 484 14 a a DT 19768 484 15 man man NN 19768 484 16 of of IN 19768 484 17 honor honor NN 19768 484 18 , , , 19768 484 19 or or CC 19768 484 20 a a DT 19768 484 21 professor professor NN 19768 484 22 in in IN 19768 484 23 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 484 24 University University NNP 19768 484 25 , , , 19768 484 26 and and CC 19768 484 27 justly justly RB 19768 484 28 entitle entitle VB 19768 484 29 me -PRON- PRP 19768 484 30 to to TO 19768 484 31 redress redress VB 19768 484 32 at at IN 19768 484 33 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 484 34 hands hand NNS 19768 484 35 . . . 19768 485 1 This this DT 19768 485 2 appeal appeal NN 19768 485 3 has have VBZ 19768 485 4 not not RB 19768 485 5 been be VBN 19768 485 6 made make VBN 19768 485 7 hastily hastily RB 19768 485 8 or or CC 19768 485 9 without without IN 19768 485 10 a a DT 19768 485 11 patient patient JJ 19768 485 12 and and CC 19768 485 13 long long RB 19768 485 14 - - HYPH 19768 485 15 protracted protract VBN 19768 485 16 effort effort NN 19768 485 17 to to TO 19768 485 18 secure secure VB 19768 485 19 justice justice NN 19768 485 20 in in IN 19768 485 21 other other JJ 19768 485 22 ways way NNS 19768 485 23 . . . 19768 486 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 19768 486 2 Royce Royce NNP 19768 486 3 has have VBZ 19768 486 4 succeeded succeed VBN 19768 486 5 hitherto hitherto NNP 19768 486 6 , , , 19768 486 7 during during IN 19768 486 8 many many JJ 19768 486 9 months month NNS 19768 486 10 , , , 19768 486 11 in in IN 19768 486 12 defeating defeat VBG 19768 486 13 that that DT 19768 486 14 effort effort NN 19768 486 15 ; ; : 19768 486 16 but but CC 19768 486 17 now now RB 19768 486 18 the the DT 19768 486 19 appeal appeal NN 19768 486 20 lies lie VBZ 19768 486 21 to to IN 19768 486 22 those those DT 19768 486 23 whom whom WP 19768 486 24 he -PRON- PRP 19768 486 25 can can MD 19768 486 26 not not RB 19768 486 27 control control VB 19768 486 28 , , , 19768 486 29 and and CC 19768 486 30 now now RB 19768 486 31 he -PRON- PRP 19768 486 32 must must MD 19768 486 33 abide abide VB 19768 486 34 your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 486 35 judgment judgment NN 19768 486 36 . . . 19768 487 1 Asking ask VBG 19768 487 2 neither neither CC 19768 487 3 less less JJR 19768 487 4 nor nor CC 19768 487 5 more more JJR 19768 487 6 than than IN 19768 487 7 justice justice NN 19768 487 8 , , , 19768 487 9 and and CC 19768 487 10 believing believe VBG 19768 487 11 that that IN 19768 487 12 you -PRON- PRP 19768 487 13 will will MD 19768 487 14 recognize recognize VB 19768 487 15 justice justice NN 19768 487 16 as as IN 19768 487 17 Harvard Harvard NNP 19768 487 18 's 's POS 19768 487 19 highest high JJS 19768 487 20 law law NN 19768 487 21 , , , 19768 487 22 I -PRON- PRP 19768 487 23 have have VBP 19768 487 24 the the DT 19768 487 25 honor honor NN 19768 487 26 to to TO 19768 487 27 remain remain VB 19768 487 28 , , , 19768 487 29 gentlemen gentleman NNS 19768 487 30 , , , 19768 487 31 in in IN 19768 487 32 devoted devote VBN 19768 487 33 loyalty loyalty NN 19768 487 34 to to IN 19768 487 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 19768 487 36 Alma Alma NNP 19768 487 37 Mater Mater NNP 19768 487 38 , , , 19768 487 39 Your -PRON- PRP$ 19768 487 40 obedient obedient JJ 19768 487 41 servant servant NN 19768 487 42 , , , 19768 487 43 FRANCIS FRANCIS NNP 19768 487 44 E. E. NNP 19768 487 45 ABBOT ABBOT NNP 19768 487 46 . . . 19768 488 1 CAMBRIDGE CAMBRIDGE NNP 19768 488 2 , , , 19768 488 3 Oct. October NNP 19768 488 4 1 1 CD 19768 488 5 , , , 19768 488 6 1891 1891 CD 19768 488 7 . . . 19768 489 1 * * NFP 19768 489 2 * * NFP 19768 489 3 * * NFP 19768 489 4 * * NFP 19768 489 5 * * NFP 19768 489 6 TRANSCRIBER TRANSCRIBER NNP 19768 489 7 'S be VBZ 19768 489 8 NOTE note NN 19768 489 9 : : : 19768 489 10 On on IN 19768 489 11 page page NN 19768 489 12 5 5 CD 19768 489 13 , , , 19768 489 14 in in IN 19768 489 15 the the DT 19768 489 16 word word NN 19768 489 17 Boeotia Boeotia NNP 19768 489 18 , , , 19768 489 19 the the DT 19768 489 20 oe oe NN 19768 489 21 ligature ligature NN 19768 489 22 has have VBZ 19768 489 23 been be VBN 19768 489 24 expanded expand VBN 19768 489 25 to to IN 19768 489 26 the the DT 19768 489 27 two two CD 19768 489 28 characters character NNS 19768 489 29 , , , 19768 489 30 oe oe RB 19768 489 31 . . . 19768 490 1 The the DT 19768 490 2 sentence sentence NN 19768 490 3 begins begin VBZ 19768 490 4 : : : 19768 490 5 Only only RB 19768 490 6 a a DT 19768 490 7 native native NN 19768 490 8 of of IN 19768 490 9 Boeotia Boeotia NNP 19768 490 10 could could MD 19768 490 11 be be VB 19768 490 12 imposed impose VBN 19768 490 13 upon upon IN 19768 490 14 by by IN 19768 490 15 them -PRON- PRP 19768 490 16 , , , 19768 490 17 when when WRB 19768 490 18 the the DT 19768 490 19 actual actual JJ 19768 490 20 character character NN 19768 490 21 .... .... .