id sid tid token lemma pos 37158 1 1 generously generously RB 37158 1 2 made make VBN 37158 1 3 available available JJ 37158 1 4 by by IN 37158 1 5 The the DT 37158 1 6 Internet Internet NNP 37158 1 7 Archive Archive NNP 37158 1 8 / / SYM 37158 1 9 American American NNP 37158 1 10 Libraries Libraries NNPS 37158 1 11 . . . 37158 1 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 2 1 THE the DT 37158 2 2 PROS PROS NNP 37158 2 3 AND and CC 37158 2 4 CONS con NNS 37158 2 5 OF of IN 37158 2 6 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 2 7 _ _ XX 37158 2 8 All all DT 37158 2 9 rights right NNS 37158 2 10 reserved reserve VBN 37158 2 11 _ _ NNP 37158 2 12 [ [ -LRB- 37158 2 13 Illustration illustration NN 37158 2 14 : : : 37158 2 15 " " `` 37158 2 16 LA LA NNP 37158 2 17 MORT MORT NNP 37158 2 18 . . . 37158 2 19 " " '' 37158 3 1 _ _ NNP 37158 3 2 By by IN 37158 3 3 Bartholomé Bartholomé NNP 37158 3 4 in in IN 37158 3 5 Père Père NNP 37158 3 6 Lachaise Lachaise NNP 37158 3 7 , , , 37158 3 8 Paris Paris NNP 37158 3 9 . . . 37158 3 10 _ _ NNP 37158 3 11 _ _ NNP 37158 3 12 Frontispiece Frontispiece NNP 37158 3 13 . . . 37158 3 14 _ _ NNP 37158 3 15 ] ] -RRB- 37158 3 16 THE the DT 37158 3 17 PROS PROS NNP 37158 3 18 AND and CC 37158 3 19 CONS con NNS 37158 3 20 OF of IN 37158 3 21 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 3 22 BY by IN 37158 3 23 DR DR NNP 37158 3 24 CHARLES CHARLES NNP 37158 3 25 RICHET RICHET NNP 37158 3 26 PROFESSOR PROFESSOR NNS 37158 3 27 OF of IN 37158 3 28 PHYSIOLOGY PHYSIOLOGY NNP 37158 3 29 IN in IN 37158 3 30 THE the DT 37158 3 31 FACULTY faculty NN 37158 3 32 OF of IN 37158 3 33 MEDICINE medicine NN 37158 3 34 PARIS pari NNS 37158 3 35 WITH with IN 37158 3 36 A a DT 37158 3 37 PREFACE preface NN 37158 3 38 BY by IN 37158 3 39 W. W. NNP 37158 3 40 D. D. NNP 37158 3 41 HALLIBURTON HALLIBURTON NNP 37158 3 42 , , , 37158 3 43 M.D. M.D. NNP 37158 3 44 , , , 37158 3 45 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 3 46 , , , 37158 3 47 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 4 1 PROFESSOR PROFESSOR NNP 37158 4 2 OF of IN 37158 4 3 PHYSIOLOGY PHYSIOLOGY NNP 37158 4 4 , , , 37158 4 5 KING KING NNP 37158 4 6 'S 's POS 37158 4 7 COLLEGE COLLEGE NNP 37158 4 8 , , , 37158 4 9 LONDON LONDON NNP 37158 4 10 LONDON LONDON NNP 37158 4 11 DUCKWORTH DUCKWORTH NNP 37158 4 12 & & CC 37158 4 13 CO CO NNP 37158 4 14 . . NNP 37158 4 15 3 3 CD 37158 4 16 HENRIETTA HENRIETTA NNP 37158 4 17 STREET STREET NNP 37158 4 18 , , , 37158 4 19 COVENT COVENT NNP 37158 4 20 GARDEN GARDEN NNP 37158 4 21 1908 1908 CD 37158 4 22 PREFACE preface NN 37158 4 23 To to IN 37158 4 24 scientific scientific JJ 37158 4 25 readers reader NNS 37158 4 26 , , , 37158 4 27 Professor Professor NNP 37158 4 28 Charles Charles NNP 37158 4 29 Richet Richet NNP 37158 4 30 needs need VBZ 37158 4 31 no no DT 37158 4 32 introduction introduction NN 37158 4 33 , , , 37158 4 34 but but CC 37158 4 35 to to IN 37158 4 36 the the DT 37158 4 37 public public NN 37158 4 38 at at IN 37158 4 39 large large JJ 37158 4 40 it -PRON- PRP 37158 4 41 may may MD 37158 4 42 be be VB 37158 4 43 necessary necessary JJ 37158 4 44 to to TO 37158 4 45 mention mention VB 37158 4 46 that that IN 37158 4 47 he -PRON- PRP 37158 4 48 is be VBZ 37158 4 49 one one CD 37158 4 50 of of IN 37158 4 51 the the DT 37158 4 52 best well RBS 37158 4 53 known know VBN 37158 4 54 of of IN 37158 4 55 French french JJ 37158 4 56 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 4 57 . . . 37158 5 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 5 2 has have VBZ 37158 5 3 occupied occupy VBN 37158 5 4 for for IN 37158 5 5 a a DT 37158 5 6 good good JJ 37158 5 7 many many JJ 37158 5 8 years year NNS 37158 5 9 the the DT 37158 5 10 Chair Chair NNP 37158 5 11 of of IN 37158 5 12 Physiology Physiology NNP 37158 5 13 in in IN 37158 5 14 the the DT 37158 5 15 Faculty Faculty NNP 37158 5 16 of of IN 37158 5 17 Medicine Medicine NNP 37158 5 18 in in IN 37158 5 19 Paris Paris NNP 37158 5 20 , , , 37158 5 21 and and CC 37158 5 22 he -PRON- PRP 37158 5 23 has have VBZ 37158 5 24 contributed contribute VBN 37158 5 25 greatly greatly RB 37158 5 26 to to IN 37158 5 27 the the DT 37158 5 28 progress progress NN 37158 5 29 of of IN 37158 5 30 the the DT 37158 5 31 science science NN 37158 5 32 to to TO 37158 5 33 which which WDT 37158 5 34 he -PRON- PRP 37158 5 35 has have VBZ 37158 5 36 devoted devote VBN 37158 5 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 5 38 life life NN 37158 5 39 ; ; : 37158 5 40 some some DT 37158 5 41 of of IN 37158 5 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 5 43 discoveries discovery NNS 37158 5 44 are be VBP 37158 5 45 alluded allude VBN 37158 5 46 to to IN 37158 5 47 with with IN 37158 5 48 all all DT 37158 5 49 modesty modesty NN 37158 5 50 in in IN 37158 5 51 the the DT 37158 5 52 pages page NNS 37158 5 53 which which WDT 37158 5 54 follow follow VBP 37158 5 55 . . . 37158 6 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 6 2 is be VBZ 37158 6 3 , , , 37158 6 4 moreover moreover RB 37158 6 5 , , , 37158 6 6 a a DT 37158 6 7 man man NN 37158 6 8 of of IN 37158 6 9 great great JJ 37158 6 10 erudition erudition NN 37158 6 11 , , , 37158 6 12 and and CC 37158 6 13 has have VBZ 37158 6 14 been be VBN 37158 6 15 wisely wisely RB 37158 6 16 selected select VBN 37158 6 17 to to TO 37158 6 18 be be VB 37158 6 19 the the DT 37158 6 20 editor editor NN 37158 6 21 of of IN 37158 6 22 a a DT 37158 6 23 monumental monumental JJ 37158 6 24 work work NN 37158 6 25 , , , 37158 6 26 _ _ NNP 37158 6 27 Le Le NNP 37158 6 28 dictionnaire dictionnaire NN 37158 6 29 de de FW 37158 6 30 physiologie physiologie NNP 37158 6 31 _ _ NNP 37158 6 32 , , , 37158 6 33 which which WDT 37158 6 34 is be VBZ 37158 6 35 issuing issue VBG 37158 6 36 from from IN 37158 6 37 the the DT 37158 6 38 press press NN 37158 6 39 to to NN 37158 6 40 - - HYPH 37158 6 41 day day NN 37158 6 42 . . . 37158 7 1 Professor Professor NNP 37158 7 2 Richet Richet NNP 37158 7 3 has have VBZ 37158 7 4 given give VBN 37158 7 5 particular particular JJ 37158 7 6 attention attention NN 37158 7 7 to to IN 37158 7 8 the the DT 37158 7 9 study study NN 37158 7 10 of of IN 37158 7 11 the the DT 37158 7 12 psychological psychological JJ 37158 7 13 side side NN 37158 7 14 of of IN 37158 7 15 physiology physiology NN 37158 7 16 , , , 37158 7 17 and and CC 37158 7 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 7 19 views view NNS 37158 7 20 on on IN 37158 7 21 pain pain NN 37158 7 22 will will MD 37158 7 23 be be VB 37158 7 24 read read VBN 37158 7 25 as as IN 37158 7 26 coming come VBG 37158 7 27 from from IN 37158 7 28 one one CD 37158 7 29 who who WP 37158 7 30 is be VBZ 37158 7 31 specially specially RB 37158 7 32 fitted fit VBN 37158 7 33 to to TO 37158 7 34 deal deal VB 37158 7 35 with with IN 37158 7 36 this this DT 37158 7 37 and and CC 37158 7 38 other other JJ 37158 7 39 mental mental JJ 37158 7 40 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37158 7 41 . . . 37158 8 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 8 2 therefore therefore RB 37158 8 3 consider consider VBP 37158 8 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 8 5 a a DT 37158 8 6 great great JJ 37158 8 7 honour honour NN 37158 8 8 that that IN 37158 8 9 Professor Professor NNP 37158 8 10 Richet Richet NNP 37158 8 11 should should MD 37158 8 12 have have VB 37158 8 13 asked ask VBN 37158 8 14 me -PRON- PRP 37158 8 15 to to TO 37158 8 16 write write VB 37158 8 17 a a DT 37158 8 18 preface preface NN 37158 8 19 to to IN 37158 8 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 8 21 most most RBS 37158 8 22 interesting interesting JJ 37158 8 23 and and CC 37158 8 24 convincing convincing JJ 37158 8 25 book book NN 37158 8 26 on on IN 37158 8 27 the the DT 37158 8 28 Pros Pros NNPS 37158 8 29 and and CC 37158 8 30 Cons Cons NNPS 37158 8 31 of of IN 37158 8 32 Vivisection vivisection NN 37158 8 33 , , , 37158 8 34 and and CC 37158 8 35 it -PRON- PRP 37158 8 36 is be VBZ 37158 8 37 a a DT 37158 8 38 great great JJ 37158 8 39 pleasure pleasure NN 37158 8 40 to to IN 37158 8 41 me -PRON- PRP 37158 8 42 to to TO 37158 8 43 commend commend VB 37158 8 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 8 45 thoughtful thoughtful JJ 37158 8 46 perusal perusal NN 37158 8 47 to to IN 37158 8 48 all all DT 37158 8 49 who who WP 37158 8 50 are be VBP 37158 8 51 interested interested JJ 37158 8 52 in in IN 37158 8 53 the the DT 37158 8 54 subject subject NN 37158 8 55 . . . 37158 9 1 Professor Professor NNP 37158 9 2 Richet Richet NNP 37158 9 3 is be VBZ 37158 9 4 not not RB 37158 9 5 only only RB 37158 9 6 one one CD 37158 9 7 who who WP 37158 9 8 speaks speak VBZ 37158 9 9 with with IN 37158 9 10 authority authority NN 37158 9 11 , , , 37158 9 12 but but CC 37158 9 13 he -PRON- PRP 37158 9 14 is be VBZ 37158 9 15 one one CD 37158 9 16 of of IN 37158 9 17 the the DT 37158 9 18 gentlest gentle JJS 37158 9 19 and and CC 37158 9 20 kindliest kindliest NN 37158 9 21 of of IN 37158 9 22 men man NNS 37158 9 23 . . . 37158 10 1 The the DT 37158 10 2 science science NN 37158 10 3 which which WDT 37158 10 4 he -PRON- PRP 37158 10 5 teaches teach VBZ 37158 10 6 is be VBZ 37158 10 7 the the DT 37158 10 8 science science NN 37158 10 9 of of IN 37158 10 10 life life NN 37158 10 11 . . . 37158 11 1 To to TO 37158 11 2 understand understand VB 37158 11 3 the the DT 37158 11 4 meaning meaning NN 37158 11 5 of of IN 37158 11 6 vital vital JJ 37158 11 7 processes process NNS 37158 11 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 11 9 is be VBZ 37158 11 10 necessary necessary JJ 37158 11 11 to to TO 37158 11 12 study study VB 37158 11 13 the the DT 37158 11 14 living live VBG 37158 11 15 organism organism NN 37158 11 16 , , , 37158 11 17 and and CC 37158 11 18 to to TO 37158 11 19 obtain obtain VB 37158 11 20 this this DT 37158 11 21 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 11 22 it -PRON- PRP 37158 11 23 is be VBZ 37158 11 24 sometimes sometimes RB 37158 11 25 necessary necessary JJ 37158 11 26 to to TO 37158 11 27 perform perform VB 37158 11 28 experiments experiment NNS 37158 11 29 on on IN 37158 11 30 living live VBG 37158 11 31 animals animal NNS 37158 11 32 . . . 37158 12 1 When when WRB 37158 12 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 12 3 defends defend VBZ 37158 12 4 a a DT 37158 12 5 practice practice NN 37158 12 6 which which WDT 37158 12 7 many many JJ 37158 12 8 regard regard NN 37158 12 9 as as IN 37158 12 10 cruel cruel JJ 37158 12 11 , , , 37158 12 12 detestable detestable JJ 37158 12 13 , , , 37158 12 14 and and CC 37158 12 15 immoral immoral JJ 37158 12 16 , , , 37158 12 17 mainly mainly RB 37158 12 18 because because IN 37158 12 19 of of IN 37158 12 20 the the DT 37158 12 21 unscrupulous unscrupulous JJ 37158 12 22 misrepresentations misrepresentation NNS 37158 12 23 put put VBN 37158 12 24 forward forward RP 37158 12 25 by by IN 37158 12 26 the the DT 37158 12 27 professional professional JJ 37158 12 28 Anti Anti NNP 37158 12 29 - - NNP 37158 12 30 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 12 31 , , , 37158 12 32 he -PRON- PRP 37158 12 33 does do VBZ 37158 12 34 so so RB 37158 12 35 because because IN 37158 12 36 he -PRON- PRP 37158 12 37 is be VBZ 37158 12 38 convinced convince VBN 37158 12 39 that that IN 37158 12 40 none none NN 37158 12 41 of of IN 37158 12 42 the the DT 37158 12 43 epithets epithet NNS 37158 12 44 just just RB 37158 12 45 mentioned mention VBN 37158 12 46 correctly correctly RB 37158 12 47 describe describe VBP 37158 12 48 the the DT 37158 12 49 experiments experiment NNS 37158 12 50 which which WDT 37158 12 51 are be VBP 37158 12 52 carried carry VBN 37158 12 53 out out RP 37158 12 54 in in IN 37158 12 55 physiological physiological JJ 37158 12 56 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 12 57 at at IN 37158 12 58 the the DT 37158 12 59 present present JJ 37158 12 60 time time NN 37158 12 61 . . . 37158 13 1 These these DT 37158 13 2 experiments experiment NNS 37158 13 3 are be VBP 37158 13 4 undertaken undertake VBN 37158 13 5 only only RB 37158 13 6 by by IN 37158 13 7 properly properly RB 37158 13 8 qualified qualified JJ 37158 13 9 persons person NNS 37158 13 10 having have VBG 37158 13 11 a a DT 37158 13 12 due due JJ 37158 13 13 sense sense NN 37158 13 14 of of IN 37158 13 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 13 16 responsibilities responsibility NNS 37158 13 17 . . . 37158 14 1 Every every DT 37158 14 2 regard regard NN 37158 14 3 is be VBZ 37158 14 4 paid pay VBN 37158 14 5 to to IN 37158 14 6 the the DT 37158 14 7 comfort comfort NN 37158 14 8 of of IN 37158 14 9 the the DT 37158 14 10 animals animal NNS 37158 14 11 employed employ VBN 37158 14 12 ; ; : 37158 14 13 and and CC 37158 14 14 the the DT 37158 14 15 ultimate ultimate JJ 37158 14 16 aim aim NN 37158 14 17 of of IN 37158 14 18 this this DT 37158 14 19 work work NN 37158 14 20 is be VBZ 37158 14 21 the the DT 37158 14 22 progress progress NN 37158 14 23 of of IN 37158 14 24 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 14 25 , , , 37158 14 26 and and CC 37158 14 27 the the DT 37158 14 28 consequent consequent JJ 37158 14 29 relief relief NN 37158 14 30 to to IN 37158 14 31 suffering suffering NN 37158 14 32 which which WDT 37158 14 33 is be VBZ 37158 14 34 so so RB 37158 14 35 often often RB 37158 14 36 only only RB 37158 14 37 the the DT 37158 14 38 result result NN 37158 14 39 of of IN 37158 14 40 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 14 41 . . . 37158 15 1 The the DT 37158 15 2 benefits benefit NNS 37158 15 3 which which WDT 37158 15 4 accrue accrue NN 37158 15 5 are be VBP 37158 15 6 felt feel VBN 37158 15 7 not not RB 37158 15 8 only only RB 37158 15 9 by by IN 37158 15 10 human human JJ 37158 15 11 beings being NNS 37158 15 12 , , , 37158 15 13 but but CC 37158 15 14 also also RB 37158 15 15 ( ( -LRB- 37158 15 16 as as IN 37158 15 17 in in IN 37158 15 18 veterinary veterinary JJ 37158 15 19 practice practice NN 37158 15 20 ) ) -RRB- 37158 15 21 by by IN 37158 15 22 the the DT 37158 15 23 animals animal NNS 37158 15 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 15 25 . . . 37158 16 1 No no DT 37158 16 2 attempt attempt NN 37158 16 3 is be VBZ 37158 16 4 made make VBN 37158 16 5 here here RB 37158 16 6 to to TO 37158 16 7 defend defend VB 37158 16 8 experiments experiment NNS 37158 16 9 which which WDT 37158 16 10 have have VBP 37158 16 11 not not RB 37158 16 12 these these DT 37158 16 13 objects object NNS 37158 16 14 in in IN 37158 16 15 view view NN 37158 16 16 , , , 37158 16 17 or or CC 37158 16 18 which which WDT 37158 16 19 ( ( -LRB- 37158 16 20 as as IN 37158 16 21 has have VBZ 37158 16 22 happened happen VBN 37158 16 23 in in IN 37158 16 24 the the DT 37158 16 25 past past NN 37158 16 26 ) ) -RRB- 37158 16 27 pay pay VB 37158 16 28 no no DT 37158 16 29 consideration consideration NN 37158 16 30 to to IN 37158 16 31 the the DT 37158 16 32 pain pain NN 37158 16 33 an an DT 37158 16 34 animal animal NN 37158 16 35 experiences experience NNS 37158 16 36 . . . 37158 17 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 17 2 feel feel VBP 37158 17 3 quite quite RB 37158 17 4 sure sure JJ 37158 17 5 that that IN 37158 17 6 if if IN 37158 17 7 the the DT 37158 17 8 British british JJ 37158 17 9 public public NN 37158 17 10 were be VBD 37158 17 11 convinced convince VBN 37158 17 12 that that IN 37158 17 13 the the DT 37158 17 14 experiments experiment NNS 37158 17 15 in in IN 37158 17 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 17 17 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 17 18 were be VBD 37158 17 19 all all DT 37158 17 20 conducted conduct VBN 37158 17 21 in in IN 37158 17 22 accordance accordance NN 37158 17 23 with with IN 37158 17 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 17 25 present present JJ 37158 17 26 law law NN 37158 17 27 , , , 37158 17 28 the the DT 37158 17 29 Anti anti JJ 37158 17 30 - - JJ 37158 17 31 vivisection vivisection JJ 37158 17 32 crusade crusade NN 37158 17 33 would would MD 37158 17 34 flicker flicker VB 37158 17 35 out out RP 37158 17 36 . . . 37158 18 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 18 2 is be VBZ 37158 18 3 the the DT 37158 18 4 object object NN 37158 18 5 of of IN 37158 18 6 those those DT 37158 18 7 who who WP 37158 18 8 are be VBP 37158 18 9 active active JJ 37158 18 10 propagandists propagandist NNS 37158 18 11 on on IN 37158 18 12 the the DT 37158 18 13 other other JJ 37158 18 14 side side NN 37158 18 15 to to TO 37158 18 16 keep keep VB 37158 18 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 18 18 agitation agitation NN 37158 18 19 going go VBG 37158 18 20 , , , 37158 18 21 by by IN 37158 18 22 omitting omit VBG 37158 18 23 to to TO 37158 18 24 mention mention VB 37158 18 25 the the DT 37158 18 26 painlessness painlessness NN 37158 18 27 of of IN 37158 18 28 the the DT 37158 18 29 operations operation NNS 37158 18 30 performed perform VBN 37158 18 31 , , , 37158 18 32 or or CC 37158 18 33 by by IN 37158 18 34 suggesting suggest VBG 37158 18 35 ( ( -LRB- 37158 18 36 either either CC 37158 18 37 directly directly RB 37158 18 38 or or CC 37158 18 39 by by IN 37158 18 40 innuendo innuendo NN 37158 18 41 ) ) -RRB- 37158 18 42 that that IN 37158 18 43 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 18 44 is be VBZ 37158 18 45 a a DT 37158 18 46 sham sham NN 37158 18 47 . . . 37158 19 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37158 19 2 own own JJ 37158 19 3 experience experience NN 37158 19 4 , , , 37158 19 5 which which WDT 37158 19 6 is be VBZ 37158 19 7 a a DT 37158 19 8 wide wide JJ 37158 19 9 one one NN 37158 19 10 , , , 37158 19 11 has have VBZ 37158 19 12 been be VBN 37158 19 13 that that IN 37158 19 14 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 19 15 not not RB 37158 19 16 only only RB 37158 19 17 obey obey VBP 37158 19 18 the the DT 37158 19 19 law law NN 37158 19 20 literally literally RB 37158 19 21 , , , 37158 19 22 but but CC 37158 19 23 are be VBP 37158 19 24 most most RBS 37158 19 25 punctilious punctilious JJ 37158 19 26 in in IN 37158 19 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 19 28 due due JJ 37158 19 29 observance observance NN 37158 19 30 . . . 37158 20 1 A a DT 37158 20 2 certain certain JJ 37158 20 3 number number NN 37158 20 4 of of IN 37158 20 5 trivial trivial JJ 37158 20 6 irregularities irregularity NNS 37158 20 7 have have VBP 37158 20 8 been be VBN 37158 20 9 reported report VBN 37158 20 10 to to IN 37158 20 11 the the DT 37158 20 12 Home Home NNP 37158 20 13 Office Office NNP 37158 20 14 by by IN 37158 20 15 the the DT 37158 20 16 inspectors inspector NNS 37158 20 17 appointed appoint VBN 37158 20 18 under under IN 37158 20 19 the the DT 37158 20 20 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 20 21 Act Act NNP 37158 20 22 , , , 37158 20 23 but but CC 37158 20 24 there there EX 37158 20 25 has have VBZ 37158 20 26 been be VBN 37158 20 27 no no DT 37158 20 28 case case NN 37158 20 29 of of IN 37158 20 30 omitting omit VBG 37158 20 31 the the DT 37158 20 32 use use NN 37158 20 33 of of IN 37158 20 34 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 20 35 . . . 37158 21 1 The the DT 37158 21 2 majority majority NN 37158 21 3 of of IN 37158 21 4 these these DT 37158 21 5 offences offence NNS 37158 21 6 have have VBP 37158 21 7 been be VBN 37158 21 8 for for IN 37158 21 9 using use VBG 37158 21 10 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 21 11 unnecessarily unnecessarily RB 37158 21 12 . . . 37158 22 1 A a DT 37158 22 2 certificate certificate NN 37158 22 3 in in IN 37158 22 4 certain certain JJ 37158 22 5 cases case NNS 37158 22 6 is be VBZ 37158 22 7 granted grant VBN 37158 22 8 for for IN 37158 22 9 the the DT 37158 22 10 omission omission NN 37158 22 11 of of IN 37158 22 12 an an DT 37158 22 13 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 22 14 : : : 37158 22 15 this this DT 37158 22 16 is be VBZ 37158 22 17 given give VBN 37158 22 18 when when WRB 37158 22 19 the the DT 37158 22 20 operation operation NN 37158 22 21 is be VBZ 37158 22 22 a a DT 37158 22 23 trifling trifling NN 37158 22 24 one one NN 37158 22 25 , , , 37158 22 26 and and CC 37158 22 27 has have VBZ 37158 22 28 never never RB 37158 22 29 been be VBN 37158 22 30 granted grant VBN 37158 22 31 for for IN 37158 22 32 any any DT 37158 22 33 operation operation NN 37158 22 34 more more RBR 37158 22 35 serious serious JJ 37158 22 36 than than IN 37158 22 37 the the DT 37158 22 38 prick prick NN 37158 22 39 of of IN 37158 22 40 a a DT 37158 22 41 hypodermic hypodermic JJ 37158 22 42 needle needle NN 37158 22 43 . . . 37158 23 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 23 2 , , , 37158 23 3 the the DT 37158 23 4 operator operator NN 37158 23 5 has have VBZ 37158 23 6 sometimes sometimes RB 37158 23 7 employed employ VBN 37158 23 8 an an DT 37158 23 9 anæsthetic anæsthetic JJ 37158 23 10 even even RB 37158 23 11 for for IN 37158 23 12 this this DT 37158 23 13 , , , 37158 23 14 and and CC 37158 23 15 has have VBZ 37158 23 16 in in IN 37158 23 17 consequence consequence NN 37158 23 18 been be VBN 37158 23 19 reported report VBN 37158 23 20 to to IN 37158 23 21 the the DT 37158 23 22 Home Home NNP 37158 23 23 Office Office NNP 37158 23 24 for for IN 37158 23 25 infringing infringe VBG 37158 23 26 the the DT 37158 23 27 terms term NNS 37158 23 28 of of IN 37158 23 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 23 30 certificate certificate NN 37158 23 31 . . . 37158 24 1 Pawloff Pawloff NNP 37158 24 2 has have VBZ 37158 24 3 truly truly RB 37158 24 4 said say VBN 37158 24 5 that that IN 37158 24 6 the the DT 37158 24 7 ideal ideal JJ 37158 24 8 experiment experiment NN 37158 24 9 is be VBZ 37158 24 10 one one CD 37158 24 11 performed perform VBN 37158 24 12 without without IN 37158 24 13 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 24 14 and and CC 37158 24 15 without without IN 37158 24 16 pain pain NN 37158 24 17 . . . 37158 25 1 In in IN 37158 25 2 many many JJ 37158 25 3 cases case NNS 37158 25 4 this this DT 37158 25 5 ideal ideal NN 37158 25 6 can can MD 37158 25 7 be be VB 37158 25 8 realised realise VBN 37158 25 9 , , , 37158 25 10 but but CC 37158 25 11 in in IN 37158 25 12 other other JJ 37158 25 13 cases case NNS 37158 25 14 it -PRON- PRP 37158 25 15 is be VBZ 37158 25 16 unattainable unattainable JJ 37158 25 17 . . . 37158 26 1 Physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 26 2 have have VBP 37158 26 3 , , , 37158 26 4 therefore therefore RB 37158 26 5 , , , 37158 26 6 had have VBD 37158 26 7 to to TO 37158 26 8 select select VB 37158 26 9 which which WDT 37158 26 10 of of IN 37158 26 11 the the DT 37158 26 12 two two CD 37158 26 13 disturbing disturbing JJ 37158 26 14 factors factor NNS 37158 26 15 shall shall MD 37158 26 16 be be VB 37158 26 17 absent absent JJ 37158 26 18 , , , 37158 26 19 and and CC 37158 26 20 they -PRON- PRP 37158 26 21 have have VBP 37158 26 22 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 37158 26 23 chosen choose VBN 37158 26 24 the the DT 37158 26 25 latter latter JJ 37158 26 26 . . . 37158 27 1 Pain pain NN 37158 27 2 must must MD 37158 27 3 be be VB 37158 27 4 absent absent JJ 37158 27 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 27 6 1 1 CD 37158 27 7 ) ) -RRB- 37158 27 8 on on IN 37158 27 9 grounds ground NNS 37158 27 10 of of IN 37158 27 11 humanity humanity NN 37158 27 12 , , , 37158 27 13 ( ( -LRB- 37158 27 14 2 2 LS 37158 27 15 ) ) -RRB- 37158 27 16 because because IN 37158 27 17 it -PRON- PRP 37158 27 18 is be VBZ 37158 27 19 a a DT 37158 27 20 far far RB 37158 27 21 greater great JJR 37158 27 22 disturber disturber NN 37158 27 23 of of IN 37158 27 24 the the DT 37158 27 25 normal normal JJ 37158 27 26 functions function NNS 37158 27 27 than than IN 37158 27 28 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 27 29 is be VBZ 37158 27 30 , , , 37158 27 31 and and CC 37158 27 32 ( ( -LRB- 37158 27 33 3 3 LS 37158 27 34 ) ) -RRB- 37158 27 35 because because IN 37158 27 36 the the DT 37158 27 37 struggles struggle NNS 37158 27 38 of of IN 37158 27 39 an an DT 37158 27 40 animal animal NN 37158 27 41 in in IN 37158 27 42 pain pain NN 37158 27 43 will will MD 37158 27 44 nullify nullify VB 37158 27 45 the the DT 37158 27 46 accuracy accuracy NN 37158 27 47 of of IN 37158 27 48 the the DT 37158 27 49 experiment experiment NN 37158 27 50 , , , 37158 27 51 and and CC 37158 27 52 endanger endanger VB 37158 27 53 the the DT 37158 27 54 safety safety NN 37158 27 55 of of IN 37158 27 56 the the DT 37158 27 57 delicate delicate JJ 37158 27 58 apparatus apparatus NN 37158 27 59 which which WDT 37158 27 60 it -PRON- PRP 37158 27 61 may may MD 37158 27 62 be be VB 37158 27 63 necessary necessary JJ 37158 27 64 to to TO 37158 27 65 employ employ VB 37158 27 66 . . . 37158 28 1 Exactly exactly RB 37158 28 2 the the DT 37158 28 3 same same JJ 37158 28 4 arguments argument NNS 37158 28 5 apply apply VBP 37158 28 6 to to IN 37158 28 7 the the DT 37158 28 8 employment employment NN 37158 28 9 of of IN 37158 28 10 the the DT 37158 28 11 antiseptic antiseptic JJ 37158 28 12 or or CC 37158 28 13 aseptic aseptic JJ 37158 28 14 methods method NNS 37158 28 15 of of IN 37158 28 16 surgery surgery NN 37158 28 17 , , , 37158 28 18 in in IN 37158 28 19 experiments experiment NNS 37158 28 20 in in IN 37158 28 21 which which WDT 37158 28 22 the the DT 37158 28 23 animal animal NN 37158 28 24 is be VBZ 37158 28 25 kept keep VBN 37158 28 26 alive alive JJ 37158 28 27 after after IN 37158 28 28 an an DT 37158 28 29 operation operation NN 37158 28 30 to to TO 37158 28 31 study study VB 37158 28 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 28 33 effects effect NNS 37158 28 34 . . . 37158 29 1 The the DT 37158 29 2 healing healing NN 37158 29 3 process process NN 37158 29 4 is be VBZ 37158 29 5 then then RB 37158 29 6 painless painless JJ 37158 29 7 , , , 37158 29 8 and and CC 37158 29 9 there there EX 37158 29 10 is be VBZ 37158 29 11 absence absence NN 37158 29 12 of of IN 37158 29 13 those those DT 37158 29 14 febrile febrile NN 37158 29 15 and and CC 37158 29 16 inflammatory inflammatory JJ 37158 29 17 conditions condition NNS 37158 29 18 which which WDT 37158 29 19 would would MD 37158 29 20 otherwise otherwise RB 37158 29 21 complicate complicate VB 37158 29 22 the the DT 37158 29 23 issue issue NN 37158 29 24 . . . 37158 30 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 30 2 is be VBZ 37158 30 3 therefore therefore RB 37158 30 4 for for IN 37158 30 5 two two CD 37158 30 6 reasons reason NNS 37158 30 7 that that WDT 37158 30 8 an an DT 37158 30 9 experimenter experimenter NN 37158 30 10 uses use VBZ 37158 30 11 both both CC 37158 30 12 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 30 13 and and CC 37158 30 14 antiseptics antiseptic NNS 37158 30 15 , , , 37158 30 16 ( ( -LRB- 37158 30 17 1 1 LS 37158 30 18 ) ) -RRB- 37158 30 19 to to TO 37158 30 20 save save VB 37158 30 21 the the DT 37158 30 22 animal animal NN 37158 30 23 suffering suffering NN 37158 30 24 , , , 37158 30 25 and and CC 37158 30 26 ( ( -LRB- 37158 30 27 2 2 LS 37158 30 28 ) ) -RRB- 37158 30 29 to to TO 37158 30 30 ensure ensure VB 37158 30 31 the the DT 37158 30 32 success success NN 37158 30 33 of of IN 37158 30 34 the the DT 37158 30 35 experiment experiment NN 37158 30 36 . . . 37158 31 1 The the DT 37158 31 2 barbarities barbarity NNS 37158 31 3 which which WDT 37158 31 4 are be VBP 37158 31 5 recorded record VBN 37158 31 6 by by IN 37158 31 7 Anti anti JJ 37158 31 8 - - JJ 37158 31 9 vivisectionist vivisectionist JJ 37158 31 10 agitators agitator NNS 37158 31 11 do do VBP 37158 31 12 not not RB 37158 31 13 exist exist VB 37158 31 14 ; ; : 37158 31 15 the the DT 37158 31 16 repetition repetition NN 37158 31 17 of of IN 37158 31 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 31 19 stories story NNS 37158 31 20 in in IN 37158 31 21 spite spite NN 37158 31 22 of of IN 37158 31 23 repeated repeat VBN 37158 31 24 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 31 25 is be VBZ 37158 31 26 partly partly RB 37158 31 27 due due JJ 37158 31 28 to to IN 37158 31 29 wilful wilful JJ 37158 31 30 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 37158 31 31 and and CC 37158 31 32 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37158 31 33 , , , 37158 31 34 and and CC 37158 31 35 partly partly RB 37158 31 36 the the DT 37158 31 37 result result NN 37158 31 38 of of IN 37158 31 39 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 31 40 of of IN 37158 31 41 the the DT 37158 31 42 meaning meaning NN 37158 31 43 of of IN 37158 31 44 the the DT 37158 31 45 technical technical JJ 37158 31 46 terms term NNS 37158 31 47 employed employ VBN 37158 31 48 by by IN 37158 31 49 physiological physiological JJ 37158 31 50 writers writer NNS 37158 31 51 . . . 37158 32 1 At at IN 37158 32 2 the the DT 37158 32 3 Royal Royal NNP 37158 32 4 Commission Commission NNP 37158 32 5 which which WDT 37158 32 6 is be VBZ 37158 32 7 now now RB 37158 32 8 considering consider VBG 37158 32 9 the the DT 37158 32 10 question question NN 37158 32 11 of of IN 37158 32 12 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 32 13 , , , 37158 32 14 the the DT 37158 32 15 cases case NNS 37158 32 16 of of IN 37158 32 17 alleged alleged JJ 37158 32 18 cruelty cruelty NN 37158 32 19 have have VBP 37158 32 20 been be VBN 37158 32 21 one one CD 37158 32 22 by by IN 37158 32 23 one one CD 37158 32 24 sifted sift VBN 37158 32 25 to to IN 37158 32 26 the the DT 37158 32 27 bottom bottom NN 37158 32 28 , , , 37158 32 29 and and CC 37158 32 30 in in IN 37158 32 31 no no DT 37158 32 32 single single JJ 37158 32 33 case case NN 37158 32 34 has have VBZ 37158 32 35 a a DT 37158 32 36 charge charge NN 37158 32 37 of of IN 37158 32 38 cruelty cruelty NN 37158 32 39 been be VBN 37158 32 40 sustained sustain VBN 37158 32 41 . . . 37158 33 1 Any any DT 37158 33 2 one one NN 37158 33 3 who who WP 37158 33 4 cares care VBZ 37158 33 5 to to TO 37158 33 6 wade wade VB 37158 33 7 through through IN 37158 33 8 the the DT 37158 33 9 four four CD 37158 33 10 bluebooks bluebook NNS 37158 33 11 of of IN 37158 33 12 evidence evidence NN 37158 33 13 which which WDT 37158 33 14 have have VBP 37158 33 15 been be VBN 37158 33 16 printed print VBN 37158 33 17 will will MD 37158 33 18 discover discover VB 37158 33 19 for for IN 37158 33 20 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 33 21 that that IN 37158 33 22 this this DT 37158 33 23 is be VBZ 37158 33 24 so so RB 37158 33 25 . . . 37158 34 1 In in IN 37158 34 2 fact fact NN 37158 34 3 , , , 37158 34 4 one one CD 37158 34 5 prominent prominent JJ 37158 34 6 Anti Anti NNP 37158 34 7 - - JJ 37158 34 8 vivisection vivisection JJ 37158 34 9 journal journal NN 37158 34 10 ( ( -LRB- 37158 34 11 the the DT 37158 34 12 _ _ NNP 37158 34 13 Verulam Verulam NNP 37158 34 14 Review Review NNP 37158 34 15 _ _ NNP 37158 34 16 , , , 37158 34 17 April April NNP 37158 34 18 - - HYPH 37158 34 19 June June NNP 37158 34 20 1907 1907 CD 37158 34 21 , , , 37158 34 22 p. p. NN 37158 34 23 186 186 CD 37158 34 24 ) ) -RRB- 37158 34 25 , , , 37158 34 26 in in IN 37158 34 27 reference reference NN 37158 34 28 to to IN 37158 34 29 the the DT 37158 34 30 evidence evidence NN 37158 34 31 given give VBN 37158 34 32 by by IN 37158 34 33 one one CD 37158 34 34 of of IN 37158 34 35 the the DT 37158 34 36 witnesses witness NNS 37158 34 37 before before IN 37158 34 38 the the DT 37158 34 39 Commission Commission NNP 37158 34 40 , , , 37158 34 41 had have VBD 37158 34 42 to to TO 37158 34 43 confess confess VB 37158 34 44 , , , 37158 34 45 " " `` 37158 34 46 Almost almost RB 37158 34 47 every every DT 37158 34 48 one one CD 37158 34 49 of of IN 37158 34 50 Mrs Mrs NNP 37158 34 51 Cook Cook NNP 37158 34 52 's 's POS 37158 34 53 horrifying horrifying JJ 37158 34 54 cases case NNS 37158 34 55 seems seem VBZ 37158 34 56 , , , 37158 34 57 when when WRB 37158 34 58 examined examine VBN 37158 34 59 , , , 37158 34 60 to to TO 37158 34 61 melt melt VB 37158 34 62 away away RP 37158 34 63 . . . 37158 34 64 " " '' 37158 35 1 An an DT 37158 35 2 Anti anti JJ 37158 35 3 - - JJ 37158 35 4 vivisectionist vivisectionist JJ 37158 35 5 publication publication NN 37158 35 6 which which WDT 37158 35 7 has have VBZ 37158 35 8 obtained obtain VBN 37158 35 9 some some DT 37158 35 10 notoriety notoriety NN 37158 35 11 ( ( -LRB- 37158 35 12 " " `` 37158 35 13 The the DT 37158 35 14 Shambles Shambles NNPS 37158 35 15 of of IN 37158 35 16 Science Science NNP 37158 35 17 " " '' 37158 35 18 ) ) -RRB- 37158 35 19 figured figure VBD 37158 35 20 in in IN 37158 35 21 a a DT 37158 35 22 recent recent JJ 37158 35 23 lawsuit lawsuit NN 37158 35 24 . . . 37158 36 1 When when WRB 37158 36 2 the the DT 37158 36 3 particular particular JJ 37158 36 4 charge charge NN 37158 36 5 which which WDT 37158 36 6 was be VBD 37158 36 7 the the DT 37158 36 8 subject subject NN 37158 36 9 of of IN 37158 36 10 the the DT 37158 36 11 action action NN 37158 36 12 was be VBD 37158 36 13 investigated investigate VBN 37158 36 14 by by IN 37158 36 15 a a DT 37158 36 16 prolonged prolonged JJ 37158 36 17 inquiry inquiry NN 37158 36 18 before before IN 37158 36 19 the the DT 37158 36 20 Lord Lord NNP 37158 36 21 Chief Chief NNP 37158 36 22 - - HYPH 37158 36 23 Justice Justice NNP 37158 36 24 , , , 37158 36 25 a a DT 37158 36 26 British british JJ 37158 36 27 jury jury NN 37158 36 28 showed show VBD 37158 36 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 36 30 sense sense NN 37158 36 31 of of IN 37158 36 32 the the DT 37158 36 33 enormity enormity NN 37158 36 34 of of IN 37158 36 35 the the DT 37158 36 36 slander slander NN 37158 36 37 by by IN 37158 36 38 awarding award VBG 37158 36 39 the the DT 37158 36 40 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 36 41 impugned impugn VBD 37158 36 42 the the DT 37158 36 43 very very RB 37158 36 44 substantial substantial JJ 37158 36 45 damages damage NNS 37158 36 46 of of IN 37158 36 47 £ £ $ 37158 36 48 2000 2000 CD 37158 36 49 . . . 37158 37 1 An an DT 37158 37 2 undertaking undertaking NN 37158 37 3 was be VBD 37158 37 4 subsequently subsequently RB 37158 37 5 given give VBN 37158 37 6 by by IN 37158 37 7 the the DT 37158 37 8 publisher publisher NN 37158 37 9 of of IN 37158 37 10 this this DT 37158 37 11 " " `` 37158 37 12 hysterical hysterical JJ 37158 37 13 work work NN 37158 37 14 " " '' 37158 37 15 ( ( -LRB- 37158 37 16 to to TO 37158 37 17 quote quote VB 37158 37 18 the the DT 37158 37 19 words word NNS 37158 37 20 of of IN 37158 37 21 the the DT 37158 37 22 Lord Lord NNP 37158 37 23 Chief Chief NNP 37158 37 24 - - HYPH 37158 37 25 Justice Justice NNP 37158 37 26 ) ) -RRB- 37158 37 27 that that IN 37158 37 28 it -PRON- PRP 37158 37 29 should should MD 37158 37 30 be be VB 37158 37 31 withdrawn withdraw VBN 37158 37 32 from from IN 37158 37 33 publication publication NN 37158 37 34 . . . 37158 38 1 Yet yet RB 37158 38 2 the the DT 37158 38 3 book book NN 37158 38 4 has have VBZ 37158 38 5 been be VBN 37158 38 6 since since IN 37158 38 7 re re VBN 37158 38 8 - - VBN 37158 38 9 issued issue VBN 37158 38 10 by by IN 37158 38 11 the the DT 37158 38 12 authors author NNS 37158 38 13 , , , 37158 38 14 with with IN 37158 38 15 the the DT 37158 38 16 chapter chapter NN 37158 38 17 that that WDT 37158 38 18 formed form VBD 37158 38 19 the the DT 37158 38 20 subject subject NN 37158 38 21 of of IN 37158 38 22 the the DT 37158 38 23 trial trial NN 37158 38 24 omitted omit VBD 37158 38 25 , , , 37158 38 26 but but CC 37158 38 27 otherwise otherwise RB 37158 38 28 with with IN 37158 38 29 very very RB 37158 38 30 little little JJ 37158 38 31 alteration alteration NN 37158 38 32 . . . 37158 39 1 The the DT 37158 39 2 libellous libellous JJ 37158 39 3 statements statement NNS 37158 39 4 scattered scatter VBN 37158 39 5 through through IN 37158 39 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 39 7 other other JJ 37158 39 8 chapters chapter NNS 37158 39 9 can can MD 37158 39 10 still still RB 37158 39 11 be be VB 37158 39 12 read read VBN 37158 39 13 by by IN 37158 39 14 the the DT 37158 39 15 lovers lover NNS 37158 39 16 of of IN 37158 39 17 sensation sensation NN 37158 39 18 , , , 37158 39 19 and and CC 37158 39 20 the the DT 37158 39 21 authors author NNS 37158 39 22 doubtless doubtless RB 37158 39 23 hope hope VBP 37158 39 24 that that IN 37158 39 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 39 26 readers reader NNS 37158 39 27 will will MD 37158 39 28 never never RB 37158 39 29 take take VB 37158 39 30 the the DT 37158 39 31 trouble trouble NN 37158 39 32 to to TO 37158 39 33 read read VB 37158 39 34 also also RB 37158 39 35 the the DT 37158 39 36 evidence evidence NN 37158 39 37 before before IN 37158 39 38 the the DT 37158 39 39 Royal Royal NNP 37158 39 40 Commission Commission NNP 37158 39 41 in in IN 37158 39 42 which which WDT 37158 39 43 all all PDT 37158 39 44 the the DT 37158 39 45 allegations allegation NNS 37158 39 46 of of IN 37158 39 47 cruelty cruelty NN 37158 39 48 have have VBP 37158 39 49 been be VBN 37158 39 50 shown show VBN 37158 39 51 to to TO 37158 39 52 be be VB 37158 39 53 groundless groundless JJ 37158 39 54 . . . 37158 40 1 The the DT 37158 40 2 subject subject NN 37158 40 3 of of IN 37158 40 4 curare curare NN 37158 40 5 , , , 37158 40 6 another another DT 37158 40 7 bugbear bugbear NN 37158 40 8 of of IN 37158 40 9 the the DT 37158 40 10 Anti anti JJ 37158 40 11 - - JJ 37158 40 12 vivisection vivisection JJ 37158 40 13 lecturer lecturer NN 37158 40 14 , , , 37158 40 15 is be VBZ 37158 40 16 so so RB 37158 40 17 adequately adequately RB 37158 40 18 dealt deal VBN 37158 40 19 with with IN 37158 40 20 by by IN 37158 40 21 Professor Professor NNP 37158 40 22 Richet Richet NNP 37158 40 23 that that IN 37158 40 24 I -PRON- PRP 37158 40 25 will will MD 37158 40 26 spare spare VB 37158 40 27 the the DT 37158 40 28 reader reader NN 37158 40 29 any any DT 37158 40 30 further further JJ 37158 40 31 discussion discussion NN 37158 40 32 on on IN 37158 40 33 that that DT 37158 40 34 question question NN 37158 40 35 here here RB 37158 40 36 . . . 37158 41 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 41 2 have have VBP 37158 41 3 taken take VBN 37158 41 4 the the DT 37158 41 5 liberty liberty NN 37158 41 6 of of IN 37158 41 7 adding add VBG 37158 41 8 , , , 37158 41 9 in in IN 37158 41 10 a a DT 37158 41 11 footnote footnote NN 37158 41 12 on on IN 37158 41 13 p. p. NN 37158 41 14 36 36 CD 37158 41 15 , , , 37158 41 16 a a DT 37158 41 17 statement statement NN 37158 41 18 in in IN 37158 41 19 respect respect NN 37158 41 20 to to IN 37158 41 21 the the DT 37158 41 22 usages usage NNS 37158 41 23 of of IN 37158 41 24 English english JJ 37158 41 25 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 41 26 in in IN 37158 41 27 relation relation NN 37158 41 28 to to IN 37158 41 29 that that DT 37158 41 30 drug drug NN 37158 41 31 . . . 37158 42 1 The the DT 37158 42 2 experiments experiment NNS 37158 42 3 of of IN 37158 42 4 the the DT 37158 42 5 pharmacologist pharmacologist NN 37158 42 6 in in IN 37158 42 7 the the DT 37158 42 8 investigation investigation NN 37158 42 9 of of IN 37158 42 10 the the DT 37158 42 11 action action NN 37158 42 12 of of IN 37158 42 13 drugs drug NNS 37158 42 14 can can MD 37158 42 15 be be VB 37158 42 16 and and CC 37158 42 17 are be VBP 37158 42 18 carried carry VBN 37158 42 19 out out RP 37158 42 20 under under IN 37158 42 21 anæsthesia anæsthesia NN 37158 42 22 in in IN 37158 42 23 the the DT 37158 42 24 same same JJ 37158 42 25 way way NN 37158 42 26 as as IN 37158 42 27 those those DT 37158 42 28 of of IN 37158 42 29 the the DT 37158 42 30 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 42 31 . . . 37158 43 1 But but CC 37158 43 2 the the DT 37158 43 3 experiments experiment NNS 37158 43 4 of of IN 37158 43 5 the the DT 37158 43 6 pathologist pathologist NN 37158 43 7 , , , 37158 43 8 which which WDT 37158 43 9 consist consist VBP 37158 43 10 in in IN 37158 43 11 conveying convey VBG 37158 43 12 germs germ NNS 37158 43 13 and and CC 37158 43 14 other other JJ 37158 43 15 disease disease NN 37158 43 16 products product NNS 37158 43 17 to to IN 37158 43 18 animals animal NNS 37158 43 19 , , , 37158 43 20 come come VB 37158 43 21 under under IN 37158 43 22 a a DT 37158 43 23 different different JJ 37158 43 24 heading heading NN 37158 43 25 . . . 37158 44 1 One one NN 37158 44 2 does do VBZ 37158 44 3 not not RB 37158 44 4 deny deny VB 37158 44 5 that that IN 37158 44 6 if if IN 37158 44 7 the the DT 37158 44 8 animal animal NN 37158 44 9 takes take VBZ 37158 44 10 the the DT 37158 44 11 disease disease NN 37158 44 12 , , , 37158 44 13 suffering suffering NN 37158 44 14 is be VBZ 37158 44 15 produced produce VBN 37158 44 16 . . . 37158 45 1 This this DT 37158 45 2 is be VBZ 37158 45 3 fully fully RB 37158 45 4 admitted admit VBN 37158 45 5 by by IN 37158 45 6 Professor Professor NNP 37158 45 7 Richet Richet NNP 37158 45 8 , , , 37158 45 9 and and CC 37158 45 10 I -PRON- PRP 37158 45 11 think think VBP 37158 45 12 that that IN 37158 45 13 any any DT 37158 45 14 common common JJ 37158 45 15 - - HYPH 37158 45 16 sense sense NN 37158 45 17 reader reader NN 37158 45 18 will will MD 37158 45 19 be be VB 37158 45 20 convinced convince VBN 37158 45 21 by by IN 37158 45 22 the the DT 37158 45 23 arguments argument NNS 37158 45 24 put put VBN 37158 45 25 forward forward RB 37158 45 26 that that IN 37158 45 27 the the DT 37158 45 28 practice practice NN 37158 45 29 is be VBZ 37158 45 30 fully fully RB 37158 45 31 justifiable justifiable JJ 37158 45 32 . . . 37158 46 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 46 2 is be VBZ 37158 46 3 difficult difficult JJ 37158 46 4 , , , 37158 46 5 as as IN 37158 46 6 Professor Professor NNP 37158 46 7 Richet Richet NNP 37158 46 8 points point VBZ 37158 46 9 out out RP 37158 46 10 , , , 37158 46 11 to to TO 37158 46 12 gauge gauge VB 37158 46 13 the the DT 37158 46 14 amount amount NN 37158 46 15 of of IN 37158 46 16 pain pain NN 37158 46 17 an an DT 37158 46 18 animal animal NN 37158 46 19 such such JJ 37158 46 20 as as IN 37158 46 21 a a DT 37158 46 22 rat rat NN 37158 46 23 , , , 37158 46 24 guinea guinea NN 37158 46 25 - - HYPH 37158 46 26 pig pig NN 37158 46 27 , , , 37158 46 28 or or CC 37158 46 29 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 46 30 ( ( -LRB- 37158 46 31 the the DT 37158 46 32 animals animal NNS 37158 46 33 usually usually RB 37158 46 34 employed employ VBN 37158 46 35 for for IN 37158 46 36 the the DT 37158 46 37 purpose purpose NN 37158 46 38 ) ) -RRB- 37158 46 39 really really RB 37158 46 40 feels feel VBZ 37158 46 41 when when WRB 37158 46 42 given give VBN 37158 46 43 a a DT 37158 46 44 disease disease NN 37158 46 45 experimentally experimentally RB 37158 46 46 , , , 37158 46 47 and and CC 37158 46 48 whether whether IN 37158 46 49 this this DT 37158 46 50 is be VBZ 37158 46 51 greater great JJR 37158 46 52 or or CC 37158 46 53 less less JJR 37158 46 54 than than IN 37158 46 55 the the DT 37158 46 56 suffering suffering NN 37158 46 57 it -PRON- PRP 37158 46 58 will will MD 37158 46 59 endure endure VB 37158 46 60 when when WRB 37158 46 61 another another DT 37158 46 62 disease disease NN 37158 46 63 or or CC 37158 46 64 a a DT 37158 46 65 violent violent JJ 37158 46 66 death death NN 37158 46 67 carries carry VBZ 37158 46 68 it -PRON- PRP 37158 46 69 off off RP 37158 46 70 in in IN 37158 46 71 the the DT 37158 46 72 usual usual JJ 37158 46 73 course course NN 37158 46 74 of of IN 37158 46 75 nature nature NN 37158 46 76 . . . 37158 47 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 47 2 is be VBZ 37158 47 3 , , , 37158 47 4 however however RB 37158 47 5 , , , 37158 47 6 undeniable undeniable JJ 37158 47 7 that that IN 37158 47 8 the the DT 37158 47 9 suffering suffering NN 37158 47 10 of of IN 37158 47 11 these these DT 37158 47 12 animals animal NNS 37158 47 13 is be VBZ 37158 47 14 much much RB 37158 47 15 less less JJR 37158 47 16 than than IN 37158 47 17 those those DT 37158 47 18 of of IN 37158 47 19 human human JJ 37158 47 20 beings being NNS 37158 47 21 . . . 37158 48 1 A a DT 37158 48 2 man man NN 37158 48 3 , , , 37158 48 4 when when WRB 37158 48 5 he -PRON- PRP 37158 48 6 is be VBZ 37158 48 7 ill ill JJ 37158 48 8 , , , 37158 48 9 suffers suffer VBZ 37158 48 10 a a DT 37158 48 11 certain certain JJ 37158 48 12 amount amount NN 37158 48 13 of of IN 37158 48 14 discomfort discomfort NN 37158 48 15 and and CC 37158 48 16 physical physical JJ 37158 48 17 bodily bodily JJ 37158 48 18 pain pain NN 37158 48 19 ; ; : 37158 48 20 but but CC 37158 48 21 this this DT 37158 48 22 is be VBZ 37158 48 23 a a DT 37158 48 24 drop drop NN 37158 48 25 in in IN 37158 48 26 the the DT 37158 48 27 ocean ocean NN 37158 48 28 compared compare VBN 37158 48 29 to to IN 37158 48 30 the the DT 37158 48 31 mental mental JJ 37158 48 32 worry worry NN 37158 48 33 and and CC 37158 48 34 anxiety anxiety NN 37158 48 35 he -PRON- PRP 37158 48 36 endures endure VBZ 37158 48 37 -- -- : 37158 48 38 all all PDT 37158 48 39 that that DT 37158 48 40 , , , 37158 48 41 at at IN 37158 48 42 any any DT 37158 48 43 rate rate NN 37158 48 44 , , , 37158 48 45 is be VBZ 37158 48 46 absent absent JJ 37158 48 47 from from IN 37158 48 48 the the DT 37158 48 49 suffering suffering NN 37158 48 50 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 48 51 . . . 37158 49 1 The the DT 37158 49 2 pathologist pathologist NN 37158 49 3 sees see VBZ 37158 49 4 beyond beyond IN 37158 49 5 the the DT 37158 49 6 pain pain NN 37158 49 7 which which WDT 37158 49 8 he -PRON- PRP 37158 49 9 inflicts inflict VBZ 37158 49 10 to to IN 37158 49 11 the the DT 37158 49 12 pain pain NN 37158 49 13 which which WDT 37158 49 14 he -PRON- PRP 37158 49 15 prevents prevent VBZ 37158 49 16 . . . 37158 50 1 The the DT 37158 50 2 death death NN 37158 50 3 of of IN 37158 50 4 a a DT 37158 50 5 few few JJ 37158 50 6 lower low JJR 37158 50 7 animals animal NNS 37158 50 8 may may MD 37158 50 9 be be VB 37158 50 10 , , , 37158 50 11 and and CC 37158 50 12 has have VBZ 37158 50 13 in in IN 37158 50 14 the the DT 37158 50 15 past past NN 37158 50 16 been be VBN 37158 50 17 the the DT 37158 50 18 means mean NNS 37158 50 19 of of IN 37158 50 20 preventing prevent VBG 37158 50 21 pain pain NN 37158 50 22 and and CC 37158 50 23 disease disease NN 37158 50 24 both both DT 37158 50 25 to to IN 37158 50 26 the the DT 37158 50 27 animals animal NNS 37158 50 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 50 29 and and CC 37158 50 30 to to IN 37158 50 31 human human JJ 37158 50 32 beings being NNS 37158 50 33 also also RB 37158 50 34 , , , 37158 50 35 who who WP 37158 50 36 may may MD 37158 50 37 be be VB 37158 50 38 counted count VBN 37158 50 39 by by IN 37158 50 40 thousands thousand NNS 37158 50 41 or or CC 37158 50 42 even even RB 37158 50 43 millions million NNS 37158 50 44 . . . 37158 51 1 If if IN 37158 51 2 there there EX 37158 51 3 is be VBZ 37158 51 4 one one CD 37158 51 5 piece piece NN 37158 51 6 of of IN 37158 51 7 evidence evidence NN 37158 51 8 more more JJR 37158 51 9 than than IN 37158 51 10 another another DT 37158 51 11 which which WDT 37158 51 12 was be VBD 37158 51 13 given give VBN 37158 51 14 before before IN 37158 51 15 the the DT 37158 51 16 Royal Royal NNP 37158 51 17 Commission Commission NNP 37158 51 18 that that WDT 37158 51 19 deserves deserve VBZ 37158 51 20 rescue rescue NN 37158 51 21 from from IN 37158 51 22 the the DT 37158 51 23 oblivion oblivion NN 37158 51 24 of of IN 37158 51 25 a a DT 37158 51 26 bluebook bluebook NN 37158 51 27 , , , 37158 51 28 it -PRON- PRP 37158 51 29 is be VBZ 37158 51 30 that that DT 37158 51 31 given give VBN 37158 51 32 by by IN 37158 51 33 Lord Lord NNP 37158 51 34 Justice Justice NNP 37158 51 35 Fletcher Fletcher NNP 37158 51 36 Moulton Moulton NNP 37158 51 37 . . . 37158 52 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37158 52 2 is be VBZ 37158 52 3 one one CD 37158 52 4 of of IN 37158 52 5 the the DT 37158 52 6 keenest keen JJS 37158 52 7 legal legal JJ 37158 52 8 intellects intellect NNS 37158 52 9 of of IN 37158 52 10 modern modern JJ 37158 52 11 times time NNS 37158 52 12 , , , 37158 52 13 and and CC 37158 52 14 he -PRON- PRP 37158 52 15 at at IN 37158 52 16 any any DT 37158 52 17 rate rate NN 37158 52 18 can can MD 37158 52 19 not not RB 37158 52 20 be be VB 37158 52 21 accused accuse VBN 37158 52 22 of of IN 37158 52 23 having have VBG 37158 52 24 any any DT 37158 52 25 axe axe NN 37158 52 26 of of IN 37158 52 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 52 28 own own JJ 37158 52 29 to to TO 37158 52 30 grind grind VB 37158 52 31 . . . 37158 53 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 53 2 regret regret VBP 37158 53 3 that that IN 37158 53 4 exigencies exigency NNS 37158 53 5 of of IN 37158 53 6 space space NN 37158 53 7 prevent prevent VB 37158 53 8 me -PRON- PRP 37158 53 9 from from IN 37158 53 10 making make VBG 37158 53 11 more more JJR 37158 53 12 than than IN 37158 53 13 one one CD 37158 53 14 or or CC 37158 53 15 two two CD 37158 53 16 references reference NNS 37158 53 17 to to IN 37158 53 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 53 19 . . . 37158 54 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 54 2 begins begin VBZ 37158 54 3 by by IN 37158 54 4 taking take VBG 37158 54 5 the the DT 37158 54 6 case case NN 37158 54 7 of of IN 37158 54 8 a a DT 37158 54 9 ship ship NN 37158 54 10 infected infect VBN 37158 54 11 with with IN 37158 54 12 plague plague NN 37158 54 13 , , , 37158 54 14 and and CC 37158 54 15 infested infest VBN 37158 54 16 also also RB 37158 54 17 with with IN 37158 54 18 rats rat NNS 37158 54 19 , , , 37158 54 20 the the DT 37158 54 21 carriers carrier NNS 37158 54 22 of of IN 37158 54 23 plague plague NN 37158 54 24 . . . 37158 55 1 The the DT 37158 55 2 ship ship NN 37158 55 3 enters enter VBZ 37158 55 4 port port NN 37158 55 5 . . . 37158 56 1 Would Would MD 37158 56 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 56 3 be be VB 37158 56 4 preferable preferable JJ 37158 56 5 to to TO 37158 56 6 kill kill VB 37158 56 7 the the DT 37158 56 8 rats rat NNS 37158 56 9 , , , 37158 56 10 and and CC 37158 56 11 so so RB 37158 56 12 prevent prevent VB 37158 56 13 them -PRON- PRP 37158 56 14 and and CC 37158 56 15 the the DT 37158 56 16 disease disease NN 37158 56 17 from from IN 37158 56 18 entering enter VBG 37158 56 19 the the DT 37158 56 20 port port NN 37158 56 21 and and CC 37158 56 22 causing cause VBG 37158 56 23 untold untold JJ 37158 56 24 disaster disaster NN 37158 56 25 there there RB 37158 56 26 , , , 37158 56 27 or or CC 37158 56 28 staying stay VBG 37158 56 29 one one PRP 37158 56 30 's 's POS 37158 56 31 hand hand NN 37158 56 32 because because IN 37158 56 33 the the DT 37158 56 34 slaughter slaughter NN 37158 56 35 of of IN 37158 56 36 the the DT 37158 56 37 rats rat NNS 37158 56 38 would would MD 37158 56 39 be be VB 37158 56 40 a a DT 37158 56 41 painful painful JJ 37158 56 42 proceeding proceeding NN 37158 56 43 ? ? . 37158 57 1 The the DT 37158 57 2 captain captain NN 37158 57 3 who who WP 37158 57 4 gives give VBZ 37158 57 5 orders order NNS 37158 57 6 for for IN 37158 57 7 the the DT 37158 57 8 destruction destruction NN 37158 57 9 of of IN 37158 57 10 the the DT 37158 57 11 rats rat NNS 37158 57 12 inflicts inflict VBZ 37158 57 13 pain pain NN 37158 57 14 and and CC 37158 57 15 death death NN 37158 57 16 on on IN 37158 57 17 them -PRON- PRP 37158 57 18 in in IN 37158 57 19 order order NN 37158 57 20 to to TO 37158 57 21 prevent prevent VB 37158 57 22 greater great JJR 37158 57 23 pain pain NN 37158 57 24 and and CC 37158 57 25 more more RBR 37158 57 26 widespread widespread JJ 37158 57 27 death death NN 37158 57 28 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37158 57 29 . . . 37158 58 1 The the DT 37158 58 2 captain captain NN 37158 58 3 who who WP 37158 58 4 says say VBZ 37158 58 5 , , , 37158 58 6 " " `` 37158 58 7 Spare spare VB 37158 58 8 the the DT 37158 58 9 rats rat NNS 37158 58 10 , , , 37158 58 11 " " '' 37158 58 12 is be VBZ 37158 58 13 guilty guilty JJ 37158 58 14 of of IN 37158 58 15 the the DT 37158 58 16 criminal criminal JJ 37158 58 17 act act NN 37158 58 18 of of IN 37158 58 19 causing cause VBG 37158 58 20 the the DT 37158 58 21 death death NN 37158 58 22 of of IN 37158 58 23 many many JJ 37158 58 24 innocent innocent JJ 37158 58 25 human human JJ 37158 58 26 beings being NNS 37158 58 27 . . . 37158 59 1 So so CC 37158 59 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 59 3 is be VBZ 37158 59 4 with with IN 37158 59 5 the the DT 37158 59 6 Anti Anti NNP 37158 59 7 - - NN 37158 59 8 vivisectionists vivisectionist VBZ 37158 59 9 : : : 37158 59 10 they -PRON- PRP 37158 59 11 see see VBP 37158 59 12 only only RB 37158 59 13 the the DT 37158 59 14 pain pain NN 37158 59 15 inflicted inflict VBD 37158 59 16 , , , 37158 59 17 and and CC 37158 59 18 do do VBP 37158 59 19 not not RB 37158 59 20 heed heed VB 37158 59 21 the the DT 37158 59 22 pain pain NN 37158 59 23 prevented prevent VBN 37158 59 24 . . . 37158 60 1 On on IN 37158 60 2 this this DT 37158 60 3 score score NN 37158 60 4 they -PRON- PRP 37158 60 5 are be VBP 37158 60 6 in in IN 37158 60 7 a a DT 37158 60 8 sense sense NN 37158 60 9 logical logical JJ 37158 60 10 when when WRB 37158 60 11 they -PRON- PRP 37158 60 12 call call VBP 37158 60 13 Lord Lord NNP 37158 60 14 Lister Lister NNP 37158 60 15 a a DT 37158 60 16 brute brute NN 37158 60 17 , , , 37158 60 18 although although IN 37158 60 19 he -PRON- PRP 37158 60 20 of of IN 37158 60 21 all all DT 37158 60 22 men man NNS 37158 60 23 living live VBG 37158 60 24 at at IN 37158 60 25 the the DT 37158 60 26 present present JJ 37158 60 27 time time NN 37158 60 28 has have VBZ 37158 60 29 been be VBN 37158 60 30 the the DT 37158 60 31 means mean NNS 37158 60 32 of of IN 37158 60 33 preventing prevent VBG 37158 60 34 the the DT 37158 60 35 greatest great JJS 37158 60 36 amount amount NN 37158 60 37 of of IN 37158 60 38 suffering suffering NN 37158 60 39 . . . 37158 61 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 61 2 see see VBP 37158 61 3 only only RB 37158 61 4 the the DT 37158 61 5 pain pain NN 37158 61 6 which which WDT 37158 61 7 he -PRON- PRP 37158 61 8 deliberately deliberately RB 37158 61 9 inflicted inflict VBD 37158 61 10 on on IN 37158 61 11 a a DT 37158 61 12 few few JJ 37158 61 13 rats rat NNS 37158 61 14 and and CC 37158 61 15 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 61 16 ; ; : 37158 61 17 they -PRON- PRP 37158 61 18 can can MD 37158 61 19 not not RB 37158 61 20 see see VB 37158 61 21 , , , 37158 61 22 or or CC 37158 61 23 refuse refuse VBP 37158 61 24 to to TO 37158 61 25 see see VB 37158 61 26 the the DT 37158 61 27 measureless measureless JJ 37158 61 28 amount amount NN 37158 61 29 of of IN 37158 61 30 misery misery NN 37158 61 31 he -PRON- PRP 37158 61 32 has have VBZ 37158 61 33 prevented prevent VBN 37158 61 34 . . . 37158 62 1 In in IN 37158 62 2 another another DT 37158 62 3 place place NN 37158 62 4 the the DT 37158 62 5 Lord Lord NNP 37158 62 6 Justice Justice NNP 37158 62 7 points point VBZ 37158 62 8 out out RP 37158 62 9 that that IN 37158 62 10 the the DT 37158 62 11 pain pain NN 37158 62 12 inflicted inflict VBN 37158 62 13 in in IN 37158 62 14 all all PDT 37158 62 15 the the DT 37158 62 16 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 62 17 of of IN 37158 62 18 the the DT 37158 62 19 country country NN 37158 62 20 put put VBN 37158 62 21 together together RB 37158 62 22 during during IN 37158 62 23 a a DT 37158 62 24 year year NN 37158 62 25 is be VBZ 37158 62 26 infinitesimal infinitesimal JJ 37158 62 27 compared compare VBN 37158 62 28 to to IN 37158 62 29 that that DT 37158 62 30 which which WDT 37158 62 31 is be VBZ 37158 62 32 inflicted inflict VBN 37158 62 33 every every DT 37158 62 34 day day NN 37158 62 35 in in IN 37158 62 36 the the DT 37158 62 37 slaughter slaughter NN 37158 62 38 of of IN 37158 62 39 animals animal NNS 37158 62 40 for for IN 37158 62 41 food food NN 37158 62 42 ; ; : 37158 62 43 to to IN 37158 62 44 that that DT 37158 62 45 which which WDT 37158 62 46 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 62 47 farm farm NN 37158 62 48 labourers labourer NNS 37158 62 49 inflict inflict VBP 37158 62 50 without without IN 37158 62 51 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 62 52 , , , 37158 62 53 in in IN 37158 62 54 spaying spay VBG 37158 62 55 animals animal NNS 37158 62 56 by by IN 37158 62 57 thousands thousand NNS 37158 62 58 in in IN 37158 62 59 order order NN 37158 62 60 that that IN 37158 62 61 beef beef NN 37158 62 62 and and CC 37158 62 63 mutton mutton NN 37158 62 64 may may MD 37158 62 65 be be VB 37158 62 66 tenderer tenderer NN 37158 62 67 or or CC 37158 62 68 have have VB 37158 62 69 a a DT 37158 62 70 more more RBR 37158 62 71 pleasant pleasant JJ 37158 62 72 flavour flavour NN 37158 62 73 to to IN 37158 62 74 the the DT 37158 62 75 consumer consumer NN 37158 62 76 ; ; : 37158 62 77 to to IN 37158 62 78 that that DT 37158 62 79 inflicted inflict VBN 37158 62 80 by by IN 37158 62 81 sportsmen sportsman NNS 37158 62 82 when when WRB 37158 62 83 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 62 84 victims victim NNS 37158 62 85 , , , 37158 62 86 imperfectly imperfectly RB 37158 62 87 shot shoot VBN 37158 62 88 , , , 37158 62 89 die die VB 37158 62 90 a a DT 37158 62 91 lingering linger VBG 37158 62 92 death death NN 37158 62 93 ; ; : 37158 62 94 to to IN 37158 62 95 that that DT 37158 62 96 which which WDT 37158 62 97 women woman NNS 37158 62 98 thoughtlessly thoughtlessly RB 37158 62 99 allow allow VBP 37158 62 100 in in IN 37158 62 101 order order NN 37158 62 102 that that IN 37158 62 103 they -PRON- PRP 37158 62 104 may may MD 37158 62 105 have have VB 37158 62 106 ospreys osprey NNS 37158 62 107 in in IN 37158 62 108 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 62 109 hats hat NNS 37158 62 110 and and CC 37158 62 111 furs fur NNS 37158 62 112 upon upon IN 37158 62 113 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 62 114 backs back NNS 37158 62 115 . . . 37158 63 1 So so RB 37158 63 2 far far RB 37158 63 3 as as IN 37158 63 4 the the DT 37158 63 5 satisfaction satisfaction NN 37158 63 6 of of IN 37158 63 7 appetite appetite NN 37158 63 8 , , , 37158 63 9 the the DT 37158 63 10 pandering pandering NN 37158 63 11 to to IN 37158 63 12 the the DT 37158 63 13 so so RB 37158 63 14 - - HYPH 37158 63 15 called call VBN 37158 63 16 sportsman sportsman NNP 37158 63 17 's 's POS 37158 63 18 instincts instinct NNS 37158 63 19 , , , 37158 63 20 or or CC 37158 63 21 the the DT 37158 63 22 gratification gratification NN 37158 63 23 of of IN 37158 63 24 vanity vanity NN 37158 63 25 are be VBP 37158 63 26 concerned concern VBN 37158 63 27 , , , 37158 63 28 these these DT 37158 63 29 things thing NNS 37158 63 30 may may MD 37158 63 31 go go VB 37158 63 32 on on RP 37158 63 33 . . . 37158 64 1 The the DT 37158 64 2 average average JJ 37158 64 3 Anti anti JJ 37158 64 4 - - JJ 37158 64 5 vivisectionist vivisectionist JJ 37158 64 6 disregards disregard VBZ 37158 64 7 them -PRON- PRP 37158 64 8 , , , 37158 64 9 or or CC 37158 64 10 at at IN 37158 64 11 least least JJS 37158 64 12 makes make VBZ 37158 64 13 no no DT 37158 64 14 effort effort NN 37158 64 15 to to TO 37158 64 16 prevent prevent VB 37158 64 17 them -PRON- PRP 37158 64 18 . . . 37158 65 1 The the DT 37158 65 2 only only JJ 37158 65 3 kind kind NN 37158 65 4 of of IN 37158 65 5 pain pain NN 37158 65 6 which which WDT 37158 65 7 stirs stir VBZ 37158 65 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 65 9 feelings feeling NNS 37158 65 10 , , , 37158 65 11 and and CC 37158 65 12 meets meet VBZ 37158 65 13 with with IN 37158 65 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 65 15 opprobrium opprobrium NN 37158 65 16 , , , 37158 65 17 and and CC 37158 65 18 enables enable VBZ 37158 65 19 him -PRON- PRP 37158 65 20 to to TO 37158 65 21 indulge indulge VB 37158 65 22 in in IN 37158 65 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 65 24 favourite favourite JJ 37158 65 25 epithets epithet NNS 37158 65 26 , , , 37158 65 27 is be VBZ 37158 65 28 _ _ NNP 37158 65 29 the the DT 37158 65 30 one one CD 37158 65 31 justifiable justifiable JJ 37158 65 32 bit bit NN 37158 65 33 of of IN 37158 65 34 pain pain NN 37158 65 35 in in IN 37158 65 36 the the DT 37158 65 37 whole whole JJ 37158 65 38 world_--a world_--a NNP 37158 65 39 pain pain NN 37158 65 40 inflicted inflict VBN 37158 65 41 with with IN 37158 65 42 the the DT 37158 65 43 noblest noble JJS 37158 65 44 of of IN 37158 65 45 all all DT 37158 65 46 objects object NNS 37158 65 47 , , , 37158 65 48 and and CC 37158 65 49 by by IN 37158 65 50 the the DT 37158 65 51 most most RBS 37158 65 52 humane humane JJ 37158 65 53 of of IN 37158 65 54 all all DT 37158 65 55 men man NNS 37158 65 56 ( ( -LRB- 37158 65 57 for for IN 37158 65 58 so so RB 37158 65 59 the the DT 37158 65 60 medical medical JJ 37158 65 61 profession profession NN 37158 65 62 admittedly admittedly RB 37158 65 63 is be VBZ 37158 65 64 ) ) -RRB- 37158 65 65 , , , 37158 65 66 the the DT 37158 65 67 object object NN 37158 65 68 , , , 37158 65 69 namely namely RB 37158 65 70 , , , 37158 65 71 of of IN 37158 65 72 preventing prevent VBG 37158 65 73 future future JJ 37158 65 74 pain pain NN 37158 65 75 , , , 37158 65 76 which which WDT 37158 65 77 otherwise otherwise RB 37158 65 78 would would MD 37158 65 79 encompass encompass VB 37158 65 80 the the DT 37158 65 81 world world NN 37158 65 82 of of IN 37158 65 83 life life NN 37158 65 84 . . . 37158 66 1 Professor Professor NNP 37158 66 2 Richet Richet NNP 37158 66 3 has have VBZ 37158 66 4 wisely wisely RB 37158 66 5 not not RB 37158 66 6 made make VBN 37158 66 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 66 8 book book NN 37158 66 9 too too RB 37158 66 10 long long RB 37158 66 11 . . . 37158 67 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 67 2 has have VBZ 37158 67 3 been be VBN 37158 67 4 content content JJ 37158 67 5 to to TO 37158 67 6 select select VB 37158 67 7 a a DT 37158 67 8 few few JJ 37158 67 9 typical typical JJ 37158 67 10 and and CC 37158 67 11 striking striking JJ 37158 67 12 examples example NNS 37158 67 13 of of IN 37158 67 14 the the DT 37158 67 15 benefits benefit NNS 37158 67 16 which which WDT 37158 67 17 experimentation experimentation VBP 37158 67 18 on on IN 37158 67 19 animals animal NNS 37158 67 20 has have VBZ 37158 67 21 conferred confer VBN 37158 67 22 upon upon IN 37158 67 23 humanity humanity NN 37158 67 24 , , , 37158 67 25 instead instead RB 37158 67 26 of of IN 37158 67 27 attempting attempt VBG 37158 67 28 even even RB 37158 67 29 to to TO 37158 67 30 enumerate enumerate VB 37158 67 31 them -PRON- PRP 37158 67 32 all all DT 37158 67 33 . . . 37158 68 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 68 2 might may MD 37158 68 3 for for IN 37158 68 4 instance instance NN 37158 68 5 have have VBP 37158 68 6 dwelt dwell VBN 37158 68 7 upon upon IN 37158 68 8 the the DT 37158 68 9 extinction extinction NN 37158 68 10 of of IN 37158 68 11 rinderpest rinderp JJS 37158 68 12 in in IN 37158 68 13 South South NNP 37158 68 14 Africa Africa NNP 37158 68 15 : : : 37158 68 16 here here RB 37158 68 17 , , , 37158 68 18 at at IN 37158 68 19 the the DT 37158 68 20 expense expense NN 37158 68 21 of of IN 37158 68 22 a a DT 37158 68 23 few few JJ 37158 68 24 experimental experimental JJ 37158 68 25 animals animal NNS 37158 68 26 , , , 37158 68 27 Koch Koch NNP 37158 68 28 has have VBZ 37158 68 29 prevented prevent VBN 37158 68 30 a a DT 37158 68 31 scourge scourge NN 37158 68 32 which which WDT 37158 68 33 formerly formerly RB 37158 68 34 exterminated exterminate VBD 37158 68 35 hundreds hundred NNS 37158 68 36 of of IN 37158 68 37 thousands thousand NNS 37158 68 38 of of IN 37158 68 39 cattle cattle NNS 37158 68 40 annually annually RB 37158 68 41 , , , 37158 68 42 and and CC 37158 68 43 might may MD 37158 68 44 still still RB 37158 68 45 be be VB 37158 68 46 exercising exercise VBG 37158 68 47 this this DT 37158 68 48 fell fall VBN 37158 68 49 influence influence NN 37158 68 50 on on IN 37158 68 51 to to IN 37158 68 52 all all DT 37158 68 53 eternity eternity NN 37158 68 54 if if IN 37158 68 55 the the DT 37158 68 56 opponents opponent NNS 37158 68 57 of of IN 37158 68 58 scientific scientific JJ 37158 68 59 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 68 60 had have VBD 37158 68 61 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 68 62 way way NN 37158 68 63 . . . 37158 69 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 69 2 might may MD 37158 69 3 have have VB 37158 69 4 taken take VBN 37158 69 5 the the DT 37158 69 6 case case NN 37158 69 7 of of IN 37158 69 8 snake snake NN 37158 69 9 bite bite NNP 37158 69 10 , , , 37158 69 11 and and CC 37158 69 12 the the DT 37158 69 13 discovery discovery NN 37158 69 14 made make VBN 37158 69 15 by by IN 37158 69 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 69 17 great great JJ 37158 69 18 fellow fellow NN 37158 69 19 - - HYPH 37158 69 20 countryman countryman NN 37158 69 21 Calmette Calmette NNP 37158 69 22 of of IN 37158 69 23 the the DT 37158 69 24 means mean NNS 37158 69 25 of of IN 37158 69 26 combating combat VBG 37158 69 27 this this DT 37158 69 28 deadly deadly JJ 37158 69 29 poison poison NN 37158 69 30 , , , 37158 69 31 which which WDT 37158 69 32 has have VBZ 37158 69 33 hitherto hitherto VBN 37158 69 34 killed kill VBN 37158 69 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 69 36 Indian indian JJ 37158 69 37 fellow fellow NN 37158 69 38 - - HYPH 37158 69 39 subjects subject NNS 37158 69 40 by by IN 37158 69 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 69 42 tens ten NNS 37158 69 43 of of IN 37158 69 44 thousands thousand NNS 37158 69 45 a a DT 37158 69 46 year year NN 37158 69 47 . . . 37158 70 1 On on IN 37158 70 2 coming come VBG 37158 70 3 to to IN 37158 70 4 one one CD 37158 70 5 of of IN 37158 70 6 the the DT 37158 70 7 most most RBS 37158 70 8 recent recent JJ 37158 70 9 of of IN 37158 70 10 beneficent beneficent JJ 37158 70 11 discoveries discovery NNS 37158 70 12 , , , 37158 70 13 he -PRON- PRP 37158 70 14 might may MD 37158 70 15 have have VB 37158 70 16 dwelt dwell VBN 37158 70 17 upon upon IN 37158 70 18 the the DT 37158 70 19 case case NN 37158 70 20 of of IN 37158 70 21 Mediterranean Mediterranean NNP 37158 70 22 fever fever NN 37158 70 23 , , , 37158 70 24 and and CC 37158 70 25 the the DT 37158 70 26 way way NN 37158 70 27 which which WDT 37158 70 28 it -PRON- PRP 37158 70 29 has have VBZ 37158 70 30 been be VBN 37158 70 31 practically practically RB 37158 70 32 stamped stamp VBN 37158 70 33 out out RP 37158 70 34 at at IN 37158 70 35 Malta Malta NNP 37158 70 36 and and CC 37158 70 37 Gibraltar Gibraltar NNP 37158 70 38 , , , 37158 70 39 because because IN 37158 70 40 the the DT 37158 70 41 method method NN 37158 70 42 of of IN 37158 70 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 70 44 spread spread NN 37158 70 45 has have VBZ 37158 70 46 been be VBN 37158 70 47 discovered discover VBN 37158 70 48 and and CC 37158 70 49 the the DT 37158 70 50 disease disease NN 37158 70 51 prevented prevent VBN 37158 70 52 at at IN 37158 70 53 the the DT 37158 70 54 expense expense NN 37158 70 55 of of IN 37158 70 56 a a DT 37158 70 57 few few JJ 37158 70 58 goats goat NNS 37158 70 59 and and CC 37158 70 60 other other JJ 37158 70 61 animals animal NNS 37158 70 62 . . . 37158 71 1 But but CC 37158 71 2 those those DT 37158 71 3 who who WP 37158 71 4 are be VBP 37158 71 5 wilfully wilfully RB 37158 71 6 deaf deaf JJ 37158 71 7 to to IN 37158 71 8 such such JJ 37158 71 9 arguments argument NNS 37158 71 10 will will MD 37158 71 11 not not RB 37158 71 12 , , , 37158 71 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 71 14 fear fear VBP 37158 71 15 , , , 37158 71 16 be be VB 37158 71 17 convinced convince VBN 37158 71 18 , , , 37158 71 19 even even RB 37158 71 20 if if IN 37158 71 21 examples example NNS 37158 71 22 are be VBP 37158 71 23 multiplied multiply VBN 37158 71 24 indefinitely indefinitely RB 37158 71 25 . . . 37158 72 1 In in IN 37158 72 2 spite spite NN 37158 72 3 of of IN 37158 72 4 the the DT 37158 72 5 love love NN 37158 72 6 for for IN 37158 72 7 animals animal NNS 37158 72 8 which which WDT 37158 72 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 72 10 opponents opponent NNS 37158 72 11 profess profess VBP 37158 72 12 , , , 37158 72 13 the the DT 37158 72 14 life life NN 37158 72 15 of of IN 37158 72 16 cattle cattle NNS 37158 72 17 , , , 37158 72 18 particularly particularly RB 37158 72 19 if if IN 37158 72 20 they -PRON- PRP 37158 72 21 are be VBP 37158 72 22 so so RB 37158 72 23 far far RB 37158 72 24 away away RB 37158 72 25 as as IN 37158 72 26 South South NNP 37158 72 27 Africa Africa NNP 37158 72 28 , , , 37158 72 29 does do VBZ 37158 72 30 not not RB 37158 72 31 appeal appeal VB 37158 72 32 to to IN 37158 72 33 them -PRON- PRP 37158 72 34 . . . 37158 73 1 The the DT 37158 73 2 happiness happiness NN 37158 73 3 of of IN 37158 73 4 the the DT 37158 73 5 teeming teem VBG 37158 73 6 millions million NNS 37158 73 7 of of IN 37158 73 8 India India NNP 37158 73 9 does do VBZ 37158 73 10 not not RB 37158 73 11 come come VB 37158 73 12 home home RB 37158 73 13 to to IN 37158 73 14 them -PRON- PRP 37158 73 15 . . . 37158 74 1 Even even RB 37158 74 2 the the DT 37158 74 3 comfort comfort NN 37158 74 4 of of IN 37158 74 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 74 6 brave brave JJ 37158 74 7 soldiers soldier NNS 37158 74 8 and and CC 37158 74 9 sailors sailor NNS 37158 74 10 in in IN 37158 74 11 the the DT 37158 74 12 Mediterranean Mediterranean NNP 37158 74 13 stations station NNS 37158 74 14 is be VBZ 37158 74 15 of of IN 37158 74 16 little little JJ 37158 74 17 account account NN 37158 74 18 : : : 37158 74 19 they -PRON- PRP 37158 74 20 have have VBP 37158 74 21 never never RB 37158 74 22 visited visit VBN 37158 74 23 the the DT 37158 74 24 hospitals hospital NNS 37158 74 25 at at IN 37158 74 26 Malta Malta NNP 37158 74 27 or or CC 37158 74 28 Gibraltar Gibraltar NNP 37158 74 29 , , , 37158 74 30 and and CC 37158 74 31 seen see VBN 37158 74 32 , , , 37158 74 33 as as IN 37158 74 34 they -PRON- PRP 37158 74 35 could could MD 37158 74 36 have have VB 37158 74 37 seen see VBN 37158 74 38 a a DT 37158 74 39 year year NN 37158 74 40 or or CC 37158 74 41 two two CD 37158 74 42 ago ago RB 37158 74 43 , , , 37158 74 44 the the DT 37158 74 45 poor poor JJ 37158 74 46 fellows fellow NNS 37158 74 47 dying die VBG 37158 74 48 off off RP 37158 74 49 like like IN 37158 74 50 flies fly NNS 37158 74 51 from from IN 37158 74 52 a a DT 37158 74 53 mysterious mysterious JJ 37158 74 54 disease disease NN 37158 74 55 that that WDT 37158 74 56 nothing nothing NN 37158 74 57 could could MD 37158 74 58 be be VB 37158 74 59 done do VBN 37158 74 60 for for IN 37158 74 61 , , , 37158 74 62 because because IN 37158 74 63 the the DT 37158 74 64 manner manner NN 37158 74 65 in in IN 37158 74 66 which which WDT 37158 74 67 the the DT 37158 74 68 fatal fatal JJ 37158 74 69 germ germ NN 37158 74 70 entered enter VBD 37158 74 71 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 74 72 bodies body NNS 37158 74 73 was be VBD 37158 74 74 unknown unknown JJ 37158 74 75 . . . 37158 75 1 Now now RB 37158 75 2 , , , 37158 75 3 by by IN 37158 75 4 the the DT 37158 75 5 simple simple JJ 37158 75 6 prohibition prohibition NN 37158 75 7 of of IN 37158 75 8 the the DT 37158 75 9 use use NN 37158 75 10 of of IN 37158 75 11 goat goat NNP 37158 75 12 's 's POS 37158 75 13 milk milk NN 37158 75 14 , , , 37158 75 15 a a DT 37158 75 16 prohibition prohibition NN 37158 75 17 due due IN 37158 75 18 to to IN 37158 75 19 animal animal NN 37158 75 20 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 75 21 and and CC 37158 75 22 to to IN 37158 75 23 that that DT 37158 75 24 alone alone RB 37158 75 25 , , , 37158 75 26 the the DT 37158 75 27 disease disease NN 37158 75 28 has have VBZ 37158 75 29 been be VBN 37158 75 30 exterminated exterminate VBN 37158 75 31 . . . 37158 76 1 Anti Anti NNS 37158 76 2 - - NNS 37158 76 3 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 76 4 do do VBP 37158 76 5 not not RB 37158 76 6 come come VB 37158 76 7 in in IN 37158 76 8 contact contact NN 37158 76 9 with with IN 37158 76 10 disease disease NN 37158 76 11 all all DT 37158 76 12 day day NN 37158 76 13 and and CC 37158 76 14 every every DT 37158 76 15 day day NN 37158 76 16 as as IN 37158 76 17 medical medical JJ 37158 76 18 men man NNS 37158 76 19 do do VBP 37158 76 20 ; ; : 37158 76 21 they -PRON- PRP 37158 76 22 therefore therefore RB 37158 76 23 do do VBP 37158 76 24 not not RB 37158 76 25 realise realise VB 37158 76 26 how how WRB 37158 76 27 widespread widespread JJ 37158 76 28 it -PRON- PRP 37158 76 29 is be VBZ 37158 76 30 , , , 37158 76 31 and and CC 37158 76 32 what what WDT 37158 76 33 terrible terrible JJ 37158 76 34 forms form NNS 37158 76 35 it -PRON- PRP 37158 76 36 may may MD 37158 76 37 take take VB 37158 76 38 . . . 37158 77 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 77 2 notions notion NNS 37158 77 3 are be VBP 37158 77 4 vague vague JJ 37158 77 5 ; ; : 37158 77 6 they -PRON- PRP 37158 77 7 talk talk VBP 37158 77 8 about about IN 37158 77 9 suffering suffer VBG 37158 77 10 without without IN 37158 77 11 any any DT 37158 77 12 intimate intimate JJ 37158 77 13 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 77 14 of of IN 37158 77 15 the the DT 37158 77 16 question question NN 37158 77 17 . . . 37158 78 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 78 2 bestow bestow VBP 37158 78 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 78 4 sympathies sympathy NNS 37158 78 5 upon upon IN 37158 78 6 the the DT 37158 78 7 few few JJ 37158 78 8 victims victim NNS 37158 78 9 of of IN 37158 78 10 the the DT 37158 78 11 vivisector vivisector NN 37158 78 12 's 's POS 37158 78 13 knife knife NN 37158 78 14 or or CC 37158 78 15 syringe syringe NN 37158 78 16 ; ; : 37158 78 17 they -PRON- PRP 37158 78 18 have have VBP 37158 78 19 none none NN 37158 78 20 left leave VBN 37158 78 21 for for IN 37158 78 22 the the DT 37158 78 23 larger large JJR 37158 78 24 number number NN 37158 78 25 of of IN 37158 78 26 victims victim NNS 37158 78 27 which which WDT 37158 78 28 would would MD 37158 78 29 have have VB 37158 78 30 suffered suffer VBN 37158 78 31 if if IN 37158 78 32 the the DT 37158 78 33 few few JJ 37158 78 34 had have VBD 37158 78 35 not not RB 37158 78 36 been be VBN 37158 78 37 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 37158 78 38 . . . 37158 79 1 Can Can MD 37158 79 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 79 3 be be VB 37158 79 4 wondered wonder VBN 37158 79 5 at at IN 37158 79 6 that that DT 37158 79 7 medical medical JJ 37158 79 8 men man NNS 37158 79 9 , , , 37158 79 10 whose whose WP$ 37158 79 11 experience experience NN 37158 79 12 is be VBZ 37158 79 13 so so RB 37158 79 14 different different JJ 37158 79 15 to to IN 37158 79 16 theirs -PRON- PRP 37158 79 17 , , , 37158 79 18 feel feel VB 37158 79 19 otherwise otherwise RB 37158 79 20 ? ? . 37158 80 1 The the DT 37158 80 2 doctor doctor NN 37158 80 3 's 's POS 37158 80 4 life life NN 37158 80 5 is be VBZ 37158 80 6 not not RB 37158 80 7 one one CD 37158 80 8 in in IN 37158 80 9 which which WDT 37158 80 10 these these DT 37158 80 11 are be VBP 37158 80 12 just just RB 37158 80 13 a a DT 37158 80 14 few few JJ 37158 80 15 painful painful JJ 37158 80 16 partings parting NNS 37158 80 17 with with IN 37158 80 18 dear dear JJ 37158 80 19 ones one NNS 37158 80 20 , , , 37158 80 21 but but CC 37158 80 22 he -PRON- PRP 37158 80 23 is be VBZ 37158 80 24 steeped steep VBN 37158 80 25 in in IN 37158 80 26 such such JJ 37158 80 27 experiences experience NNS 37158 80 28 from from IN 37158 80 29 morning morning NN 37158 80 30 till till IN 37158 80 31 night night NN 37158 80 32 . . . 37158 81 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37158 81 2 sympathies sympathy NNS 37158 81 3 aim aim VBP 37158 81 4 at at IN 37158 81 5 the the DT 37158 81 6 relief relief NN 37158 81 7 and and CC 37158 81 8 cure cure NN 37158 81 9 of of IN 37158 81 10 all all PDT 37158 81 11 this this DT 37158 81 12 evil evil NN 37158 81 13 ; ; : 37158 81 14 and and CC 37158 81 15 the the DT 37158 81 16 death death NN 37158 81 17 of of IN 37158 81 18 a a DT 37158 81 19 few few JJ 37158 81 20 guinea guinea NN 37158 81 21 - - HYPH 37158 81 22 pigs pig NNS 37158 81 23 or or CC 37158 81 24 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 81 25 is be VBZ 37158 81 26 a a DT 37158 81 27 necessary necessary JJ 37158 81 28 incident incident NN 37158 81 29 which which WDT 37158 81 30 he -PRON- PRP 37158 81 31 has have VBZ 37158 81 32 the the DT 37158 81 33 courage courage NN 37158 81 34 to to TO 37158 81 35 permit permit VB 37158 81 36 because because IN 37158 81 37 of of IN 37158 81 38 the the DT 37158 81 39 greater great JJR 37158 81 40 good good NN 37158 81 41 that that WDT 37158 81 42 is be VBZ 37158 81 43 the the DT 37158 81 44 ultimate ultimate JJ 37158 81 45 result result NN 37158 81 46 . . . 37158 82 1 There there EX 37158 82 2 are be VBP 37158 82 3 , , , 37158 82 4 however however RB 37158 82 5 , , , 37158 82 6 some some DT 37158 82 7 of of IN 37158 82 8 the the DT 37158 82 9 examples example NNS 37158 82 10 which which WDT 37158 82 11 ought ought MD 37158 82 12 to to TO 37158 82 13 stir stir VB 37158 82 14 better well JJR 37158 82 15 feelings feeling NNS 37158 82 16 even even RB 37158 82 17 in in IN 37158 82 18 the the DT 37158 82 19 Anti anti JJ 37158 82 20 - - JJ 37158 82 21 vivisectionist vivisectionist JJ 37158 82 22 camp camp NN 37158 82 23 , , , 37158 82 24 namely namely RB 37158 82 25 , , , 37158 82 26 cases case NNS 37158 82 27 of of IN 37158 82 28 diseases disease NNS 37158 82 29 which which WDT 37158 82 30 are be VBP 37158 82 31 common common JJ 37158 82 32 or or CC 37158 82 33 used use VBN 37158 82 34 to to TO 37158 82 35 be be VB 37158 82 36 common common JJ 37158 82 37 in in IN 37158 82 38 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 82 39 very very JJ 37158 82 40 midst midst NN 37158 82 41 , , , 37158 82 42 and and CC 37158 82 43 which which WDT 37158 82 44 we -PRON- PRP 37158 82 45 need need VBP 37158 82 46 not not RB 37158 82 47 go go VB 37158 82 48 to to IN 37158 82 49 India India NNP 37158 82 50 or or CC 37158 82 51 Malta Malta NNP 37158 82 52 to to TO 37158 82 53 look look VB 37158 82 54 for for IN 37158 82 55 . . . 37158 83 1 One one CD 37158 83 2 of of IN 37158 83 3 these these DT 37158 83 4 is be VBZ 37158 83 5 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 83 6 , , , 37158 83 7 and and CC 37158 83 8 the the DT 37158 83 9 statements statement NNS 37158 83 10 and and CC 37158 83 11 statistics statistic NNS 37158 83 12 in in IN 37158 83 13 relation relation NN 37158 83 14 to to IN 37158 83 15 the the DT 37158 83 16 almost almost RB 37158 83 17 miraculous miraculous JJ 37158 83 18 change change NN 37158 83 19 which which WDT 37158 83 20 has have VBZ 37158 83 21 come come VBN 37158 83 22 over over IN 37158 83 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 83 24 ideas idea NNS 37158 83 25 on on IN 37158 83 26 this this DT 37158 83 27 affection affection NN 37158 83 28 are be VBP 37158 83 29 incontrovertible incontrovertible JJ 37158 83 30 , , , 37158 83 31 and and CC 37158 83 32 are be VBP 37158 83 33 fully fully RB 37158 83 34 set set VBN 37158 83 35 forth forth RP 37158 83 36 in in IN 37158 83 37 the the DT 37158 83 38 following follow VBG 37158 83 39 pages page NNS 37158 83 40 . . . 37158 84 1 The the DT 37158 84 2 disease disease NN 37158 84 3 no no RB 37158 84 4 longer long RBR 37158 84 5 inspires inspire VBZ 37158 84 6 the the DT 37158 84 7 terror terror NN 37158 84 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 84 9 used use VBD 37158 84 10 to to TO 37158 84 11 do do VB 37158 84 12 , , , 37158 84 13 for for IN 37158 84 14 it -PRON- PRP 37158 84 15 is be VBZ 37158 84 16 one one CD 37158 84 17 which which WDT 37158 84 18 can can MD 37158 84 19 be be VB 37158 84 20 cured cure VBN 37158 84 21 , , , 37158 84 22 and and CC 37158 84 23 easily easily RB 37158 84 24 cured cure VBN 37158 84 25 , , , 37158 84 26 by by IN 37158 84 27 the the DT 37158 84 28 method method NN 37158 84 29 of of IN 37158 84 30 serum serum NN 37158 84 31 therapy therapy NN 37158 84 32 . . . 37158 85 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 85 2 has have VBZ 37158 85 3 not not RB 37158 85 4 , , , 37158 85 5 it -PRON- PRP 37158 85 6 is be VBZ 37158 85 7 true true JJ 37158 85 8 , , , 37158 85 9 been be VBN 37158 85 10 stamped stamp VBN 37158 85 11 out out RP 37158 85 12 , , , 37158 85 13 for for IN 37158 85 14 up up IN 37158 85 15 till till IN 37158 85 16 the the DT 37158 85 17 present present JJ 37158 85 18 success success NN 37158 85 19 has have VBZ 37158 85 20 not not RB 37158 85 21 attended attend VBN 37158 85 22 efforts effort NNS 37158 85 23 of of IN 37158 85 24 prevention prevention NN 37158 85 25 . . . 37158 86 1 Prevention prevention NN 37158 86 2 is be VBZ 37158 86 3 better well JJR 37158 86 4 than than IN 37158 86 5 cure cure VB 37158 86 6 , , , 37158 86 7 but but CC 37158 86 8 cure cure NN 37158 86 9 is be VBZ 37158 86 10 better well JJR 37158 86 11 than than IN 37158 86 12 suffering suffering NN 37158 86 13 and and CC 37158 86 14 death death NN 37158 86 15 . . . 37158 87 1 Just just RB 37158 87 2 now now RB 37158 87 3 , , , 37158 87 4 medical medical JJ 37158 87 5 science science NN 37158 87 6 can can MD 37158 87 7 cure cure VB 37158 87 8 the the DT 37158 87 9 disease disease NN 37158 87 10 , , , 37158 87 11 and and CC 37158 87 12 if if IN 37158 87 13 medical medical JJ 37158 87 14 progress progress NN 37158 87 15 continues continue VBZ 37158 87 16 at at IN 37158 87 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 87 18 present present JJ 37158 87 19 rapid rapid JJ 37158 87 20 rate rate NN 37158 87 21 of of IN 37158 87 22 growth growth NN 37158 87 23 , , , 37158 87 24 who who WP 37158 87 25 can can MD 37158 87 26 doubt doubt VB 37158 87 27 that that IN 37158 87 28 in in IN 37158 87 29 the the DT 37158 87 30 near near JJ 37158 87 31 future future NN 37158 87 32 this this DT 37158 87 33 disease disease NN 37158 87 34 , , , 37158 87 35 like like IN 37158 87 36 typhus typhus NN 37158 87 37 and and CC 37158 87 38 typhoid typhoid NN 37158 87 39 , , , 37158 87 40 will will MD 37158 87 41 be be VB 37158 87 42 stamped stamp VBN 37158 87 43 out out RP 37158 87 44 ? ? . 37158 88 1 Typhoid typhoid JJ 37158 88 2 fever fever NN 37158 88 3 is be VBZ 37158 88 4 an an DT 37158 88 5 example example NN 37158 88 6 of of IN 37158 88 7 a a DT 37158 88 8 disease disease NN 37158 88 9 which which WDT 37158 88 10 has have VBZ 37158 88 11 only only RB 37158 88 12 died die VBN 37158 88 13 out out RP 37158 88 14 in in IN 37158 88 15 this this DT 37158 88 16 country country NN 37158 88 17 quite quite RB 37158 88 18 recently recently RB 37158 88 19 . . . 37158 89 1 When when WRB 37158 89 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 89 3 was be VBD 37158 89 4 a a DT 37158 89 5 student student NN 37158 89 6 the the DT 37158 89 7 hospital hospital NN 37158 89 8 wards ward NNS 37158 89 9 were be VBD 37158 89 10 full full JJ 37158 89 11 of of IN 37158 89 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 89 13 ; ; : 37158 89 14 but but CC 37158 89 15 to to IN 37158 89 16 - - HYPH 37158 89 17 day day NN 37158 89 18 most most RBS 37158 89 19 medical medical JJ 37158 89 20 students student NNS 37158 89 21 in in IN 37158 89 22 London London NNP 37158 89 23 pass pass VBP 37158 89 24 through through IN 37158 89 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 89 26 entire entire JJ 37158 89 27 curriculum curriculum NN 37158 89 28 of of IN 37158 89 29 five five CD 37158 89 30 years year NNS 37158 89 31 or or CC 37158 89 32 more more JJR 37158 89 33 without without IN 37158 89 34 ever ever RB 37158 89 35 seeing see VBG 37158 89 36 a a DT 37158 89 37 case case NN 37158 89 38 . . . 37158 90 1 What what WP 37158 90 2 has have VBZ 37158 90 3 been be VBN 37158 90 4 accomplished accomplish VBN 37158 90 5 for for IN 37158 90 6 London London NNP 37158 90 7 can can MD 37158 90 8 also also RB 37158 90 9 be be VB 37158 90 10 carried carry VBN 37158 90 11 out out RP 37158 90 12 in in IN 37158 90 13 other other JJ 37158 90 14 large large JJ 37158 90 15 cities city NNS 37158 90 16 , , , 37158 90 17 and and CC 37158 90 18 the the DT 37158 90 19 extinction extinction NN 37158 90 20 of of IN 37158 90 21 the the DT 37158 90 22 disease disease NN 37158 90 23 is be VBZ 37158 90 24 entirely entirely RB 37158 90 25 due due JJ 37158 90 26 to to IN 37158 90 27 improved improve VBN 37158 90 28 sanitary sanitary JJ 37158 90 29 measures measure NNS 37158 90 30 , , , 37158 90 31 and and CC 37158 90 32 the the DT 37158 90 33 destruction destruction NN 37158 90 34 of of IN 37158 90 35 the the DT 37158 90 36 bacillus bacillus NN 37158 90 37 which which WDT 37158 90 38 causes cause VBZ 37158 90 39 the the DT 37158 90 40 malady malady JJ 37158 90 41 . . . 37158 91 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 91 2 often often RB 37158 91 3 quite quite RB 37158 91 4 legitimately legitimately RB 37158 91 5 complain complain VBP 37158 91 6 of of IN 37158 91 7 the the DT 37158 91 8 extravagances extravagance NNS 37158 91 9 of of IN 37158 91 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 91 11 Government Government NNP 37158 91 12 departments department NNS 37158 91 13 and and CC 37158 91 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 91 15 County County NNP 37158 91 16 Councils Councils NNP 37158 91 17 , , , 37158 91 18 and and CC 37158 91 19 of of IN 37158 91 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 91 21 apathy apathy NN 37158 91 22 in in IN 37158 91 23 questions question NNS 37158 91 24 affecting affect VBG 37158 91 25 the the DT 37158 91 26 health health NN 37158 91 27 of of IN 37158 91 28 the the DT 37158 91 29 country country NN 37158 91 30 . . . 37158 92 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 92 2 are be VBP 37158 92 3 still still RB 37158 92 4 awaiting await VBG 37158 92 5 , , , 37158 92 6 for for IN 37158 92 7 instance instance NN 37158 92 8 , , , 37158 92 9 proper proper JJ 37158 92 10 legislative legislative JJ 37158 92 11 measures measure NNS 37158 92 12 to to TO 37158 92 13 ensure ensure VB 37158 92 14 the the DT 37158 92 15 purity purity NN 37158 92 16 of of IN 37158 92 17 milk milk NN 37158 92 18 . . . 37158 93 1 But but CC 37158 93 2 this this DT 37158 93 3 at at IN 37158 93 4 least least JJS 37158 93 5 we -PRON- PRP 37158 93 6 can can MD 37158 93 7 thank thank VB 37158 93 8 them -PRON- PRP 37158 93 9 for for IN 37158 93 10 -- -- : 37158 93 11 proper proper JJ 37158 93 12 methods method NNS 37158 93 13 of of IN 37158 93 14 disinfection disinfection NN 37158 93 15 and and CC 37158 93 16 a a DT 37158 93 17 purer purer NN 37158 93 18 water water NN 37158 93 19 - - HYPH 37158 93 20 supply supply NN 37158 93 21 have have VBP 37158 93 22 led lead VBN 37158 93 23 to to IN 37158 93 24 the the DT 37158 93 25 almost almost RB 37158 93 26 complete complete JJ 37158 93 27 extinction extinction NN 37158 93 28 of of IN 37158 93 29 what what WP 37158 93 30 was be VBD 37158 93 31 a a DT 37158 93 32 common common JJ 37158 93 33 and and CC 37158 93 34 painful painful JJ 37158 93 35 and and CC 37158 93 36 fatal fatal JJ 37158 93 37 disease disease NN 37158 93 38 . . . 37158 94 1 But but CC 37158 94 2 how how WRB 37158 94 3 does do VBZ 37158 94 4 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 94 5 come come VB 37158 94 6 in in RP 37158 94 7 here here RB 37158 94 8 ? ? . 37158 95 1 County county NN 37158 95 2 councillors councillor NNS 37158 95 3 are be VBP 37158 95 4 not not RB 37158 95 5 Vivisectors Vivisectors NNPS 37158 95 6 . . . 37158 96 1 No no UH 37158 96 2 , , , 37158 96 3 they -PRON- PRP 37158 96 4 are be VBP 37158 96 5 not not RB 37158 96 6 , , , 37158 96 7 but but CC 37158 96 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 96 9 action action NN 37158 96 10 is be VBZ 37158 96 11 the the DT 37158 96 12 undoubted undoubted JJ 37158 96 13 result result NN 37158 96 14 of of IN 37158 96 15 public public JJ 37158 96 16 opinion opinion NN 37158 96 17 ; ; : 37158 96 18 and and CC 37158 96 19 that that DT 37158 96 20 healthy healthy JJ 37158 96 21 public public JJ 37158 96 22 opinion opinion NN 37158 96 23 is be VBZ 37158 96 24 the the DT 37158 96 25 outcome outcome NN 37158 96 26 of of IN 37158 96 27 medical medical JJ 37158 96 28 opinion opinion NN 37158 96 29 , , , 37158 96 30 which which WDT 37158 96 31 was be VBD 37158 96 32 preached preach VBN 37158 96 33 to to TO 37158 96 34 deaf deaf VB 37158 96 35 ears ear NNS 37158 96 36 for for IN 37158 96 37 many many JJ 37158 96 38 years year NNS 37158 96 39 , , , 37158 96 40 and and CC 37158 96 41 at at IN 37158 96 42 last last JJ 37158 96 43 succeeded succeed VBN 37158 96 44 in in IN 37158 96 45 impressing impress VBG 37158 96 46 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 96 47 upon upon IN 37158 96 48 the the DT 37158 96 49 public public NN 37158 96 50 at at IN 37158 96 51 large large JJ 37158 96 52 ; ; : 37158 96 53 and and CC 37158 96 54 this this DT 37158 96 55 medical medical JJ 37158 96 56 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 96 57 was be VBD 37158 96 58 the the DT 37158 96 59 offspring offspring NN 37158 96 60 of of IN 37158 96 61 the the DT 37158 96 62 only only JJ 37158 96 63 certain certain JJ 37158 96 64 guide guide NN 37158 96 65 in in IN 37158 96 66 such such JJ 37158 96 67 matters matter NNS 37158 96 68 , , , 37158 96 69 pathological pathological JJ 37158 96 70 experiment experiment NN 37158 96 71 . . . 37158 97 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 97 2 was be VBD 37158 97 3 not not RB 37158 97 4 until until IN 37158 97 5 the the DT 37158 97 6 germ germ NN 37158 97 7 of of IN 37158 97 8 typhoid typhoid NN 37158 97 9 fever fever NN 37158 97 10 was be VBD 37158 97 11 recognised recognise VBN 37158 97 12 and and CC 37158 97 13 isolated isolate VBN 37158 97 14 , , , 37158 97 15 not not RB 37158 97 16 until until IN 37158 97 17 the the DT 37158 97 18 conditions condition NNS 37158 97 19 of of IN 37158 97 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 97 21 growth growth NN 37158 97 22 and and CC 37158 97 23 the the DT 37158 97 24 means mean NNS 37158 97 25 of of IN 37158 97 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 97 27 destruction destruction NN 37158 97 28 were be VBD 37158 97 29 experimentally experimentally RB 37158 97 30 verified verify VBN 37158 97 31 upon upon IN 37158 97 32 the the DT 37158 97 33 lower low JJR 37158 97 34 animals animal NNS 37158 97 35 , , , 37158 97 36 that that IN 37158 97 37 any any DT 37158 97 38 sound sound JJ 37158 97 39 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 97 40 was be VBD 37158 97 41 obtained obtain VBN 37158 97 42 . . . 37158 98 1 Bacteriology bacteriology NN 37158 98 2 is be VBZ 37158 98 3 at at IN 37158 98 4 the the DT 37158 98 5 bottom bottom NN 37158 98 6 of of IN 37158 98 7 hygiene hygiene NN 37158 98 8 ; ; : 37158 98 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 98 10 is be VBZ 37158 98 11 by by IN 37158 98 12 hygienic hygienic JJ 37158 98 13 precautions precaution NNS 37158 98 14 that that WDT 37158 98 15 certain certain JJ 37158 98 16 diseases disease NNS 37158 98 17 are be VBP 37158 98 18 prevented prevent VBN 37158 98 19 ; ; : 37158 98 20 and and CC 37158 98 21 the the DT 37158 98 22 basis basis NN 37158 98 23 of of IN 37158 98 24 bacteriology bacteriology NN 37158 98 25 is be VBZ 37158 98 26 experiment experiment NN 37158 98 27 on on IN 37158 98 28 animals animal NNS 37158 98 29 . . . 37158 99 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 99 2 will will MD 37158 99 3 allow allow VB 37158 99 4 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 99 5 only only RB 37158 99 6 one one CD 37158 99 7 more more JJR 37158 99 8 point point NN 37158 99 9 , , , 37158 99 10 and and CC 37158 99 11 that that DT 37158 99 12 relates relate VBZ 37158 99 13 to to IN 37158 99 14 the the DT 37158 99 15 general general JJ 37158 99 16 question question NN 37158 99 17 of of IN 37158 99 18 serum serum NN 37158 99 19 therapy therapy NN 37158 99 20 . . . 37158 100 1 Some some DT 37158 100 2 people people NNS 37158 100 3 object object VBP 37158 100 4 to to IN 37158 100 5 the the DT 37158 100 6 whole whole JJ 37158 100 7 conception conception NN 37158 100 8 of of IN 37158 100 9 serum serum NN 37158 100 10 treatment treatment NN 37158 100 11 , , , 37158 100 12 on on IN 37158 100 13 the the DT 37158 100 14 ground ground NN 37158 100 15 that that WDT 37158 100 16 serum serum NNP 37158 100 17 and and CC 37158 100 18 allied allied JJ 37158 100 19 substances substance NNS 37158 100 20 are be VBP 37158 100 21 ' ' `` 37158 100 22 messy messy JJ 37158 100 23 ' ' '' 37158 100 24 things thing NNS 37158 100 25 . . . 37158 101 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 101 2 was be VBD 37158 101 3 by by IN 37158 101 4 this this DT 37158 101 5 very very RB 37158 101 6 expressive expressive JJ 37158 101 7 phrase phrase NN 37158 101 8 that that IN 37158 101 9 Lord Lord NNP 37158 101 10 Justice Justice NNP 37158 101 11 Fletcher Fletcher NNP 37158 101 12 Moulton Moulton NNP 37158 101 13 summarised summarise VBD 37158 101 14 and and CC 37158 101 15 paraphrased paraphrase VBD 37158 101 16 the the DT 37158 101 17 Anti anti JJ 37158 101 18 - - JJ 37158 101 19 vivisectionist vivisectionist JJ 37158 101 20 attitude attitude NN 37158 101 21 on on IN 37158 101 22 the the DT 37158 101 23 serum serum NN 37158 101 24 method method NN 37158 101 25 of of IN 37158 101 26 treatment treatment NN 37158 101 27 . . . 37158 102 1 Miss Miss NNP 37158 102 2 Lind Lind NNP 37158 102 3 af af IN 37158 102 4 Hageby Hageby NNP 37158 102 5 on on IN 37158 102 6 one one CD 37158 102 7 occasion occasion NN 37158 102 8 characterised characterise VBD 37158 102 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 102 10 as as IN 37158 102 11 ' ' `` 37158 102 12 medieval medieval JJ 37158 102 13 , , , 37158 102 14 ' ' '' 37158 102 15 a a DT 37158 102 16 word word NN 37158 102 17 which which WDT 37158 102 18 is be VBZ 37158 102 19 quite quite RB 37158 102 20 meaningless meaningless JJ 37158 102 21 in in IN 37158 102 22 this this DT 37158 102 23 connection connection NN 37158 102 24 , , , 37158 102 25 but but CC 37158 102 26 prettier pretty JJR 37158 102 27 , , , 37158 102 28 I -PRON- PRP 37158 102 29 admit admit VBP 37158 102 30 , , , 37158 102 31 than than IN 37158 102 32 " " `` 37158 102 33 Behring behre VBG 37158 102 34 's 's POS 37158 102 35 filth filth NN 37158 102 36 product product NN 37158 102 37 , , , 37158 102 38 " " '' 37158 102 39 which which WDT 37158 102 40 is be VBZ 37158 102 41 the the DT 37158 102 42 elegant elegant JJ 37158 102 43 name name NN 37158 102 44 coined coin VBD 37158 102 45 for for IN 37158 102 46 antidiphtheritic antidiphtheritic JJ 37158 102 47 serum serum NN 37158 102 48 by by IN 37158 102 49 one one CD 37158 102 50 of of IN 37158 102 51 her -PRON- PRP$ 37158 102 52 friends friend NNS 37158 102 53 . . . 37158 103 1 Filth filth NN 37158 103 2 or or CC 37158 103 3 dirt dirt NN 37158 103 4 has have VBZ 37158 103 5 been be VBN 37158 103 6 well well RB 37158 103 7 defined define VBN 37158 103 8 as as IN 37158 103 9 matter matter NN 37158 103 10 in in IN 37158 103 11 the the DT 37158 103 12 wrong wrong JJ 37158 103 13 place place NN 37158 103 14 . . . 37158 104 1 Blood blood NN 37158 104 2 on on IN 37158 104 3 a a DT 37158 104 4 carpet carpet NN 37158 104 5 , , , 37158 104 6 for for IN 37158 104 7 example example NN 37158 104 8 , , , 37158 104 9 is be VBZ 37158 104 10 certainly certainly RB 37158 104 11 messy messy JJ 37158 104 12 and and CC 37158 104 13 dirty dirty JJ 37158 104 14 ; ; : 37158 104 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 104 16 ought ought MD 37158 104 17 not not RB 37158 104 18 to to TO 37158 104 19 be be VB 37158 104 20 there there RB 37158 104 21 . . . 37158 105 1 But but CC 37158 105 2 blood blood NN 37158 105 3 or or CC 37158 105 4 serum serum NN 37158 105 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 105 6 the the DT 37158 105 7 fluid fluid JJ 37158 105 8 part part NN 37158 105 9 of of IN 37158 105 10 the the DT 37158 105 11 blood blood NN 37158 105 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 105 13 in in IN 37158 105 14 the the DT 37158 105 15 heart heart NN 37158 105 16 , , , 37158 105 17 or or CC 37158 105 18 in in IN 37158 105 19 the the DT 37158 105 20 arteries artery NNS 37158 105 21 and and CC 37158 105 22 veins vein NNS 37158 105 23 , , , 37158 105 24 is be VBZ 37158 105 25 in in IN 37158 105 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 105 27 rightful rightful JJ 37158 105 28 place place NN 37158 105 29 , , , 37158 105 30 and and CC 37158 105 31 it -PRON- PRP 37158 105 32 does do VBZ 37158 105 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 105 34 duty duty NN 37158 105 35 of of IN 37158 105 36 nutrition nutrition NN 37158 105 37 and and CC 37158 105 38 so so RB 37158 105 39 forth forth RB 37158 105 40 when when WRB 37158 105 41 it -PRON- PRP 37158 105 42 comes come VBZ 37158 105 43 into into IN 37158 105 44 more more JJR 37158 105 45 immediate immediate JJ 37158 105 46 contact contact NN 37158 105 47 with with IN 37158 105 48 the the DT 37158 105 49 tissues tissue NNS 37158 105 50 in in IN 37158 105 51 the the DT 37158 105 52 small small JJ 37158 105 53 tubes tube NNS 37158 105 54 we -PRON- PRP 37158 105 55 call call VBP 37158 105 56 the the DT 37158 105 57 capillaries capillary NNS 37158 105 58 . . . 37158 106 1 One one CD 37158 106 2 of of IN 37158 106 3 these these DT 37158 106 4 duties duty NNS 37158 106 5 is be VBZ 37158 106 6 to to TO 37158 106 7 exert exert VB 37158 106 8 a a DT 37158 106 9 protective protective JJ 37158 106 10 influence influence NN 37158 106 11 upon upon IN 37158 106 12 the the DT 37158 106 13 whole whole JJ 37158 106 14 body body NN 37158 106 15 , , , 37158 106 16 by by IN 37158 106 17 destroying destroy VBG 37158 106 18 the the DT 37158 106 19 germs germ NNS 37158 106 20 of of IN 37158 106 21 disease disease NN 37158 106 22 which which WDT 37158 106 23 get get VBP 37158 106 24 in in RP 37158 106 25 , , , 37158 106 26 despite despite IN 37158 106 27 all all DT 37158 106 28 precautions precaution NNS 37158 106 29 . . . 37158 107 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 107 2 are be VBP 37158 107 3 all all DT 37158 107 4 of of IN 37158 107 5 us -PRON- PRP 37158 107 6 exposed expose VBN 37158 107 7 , , , 37158 107 8 so so RB 37158 107 9 long long RB 37158 107 10 as as IN 37158 107 11 spitting spit VBG 37158 107 12 in in IN 37158 107 13 public public JJ 37158 107 14 places place NNS 37158 107 15 is be VBZ 37158 107 16 not not RB 37158 107 17 prohibited prohibit VBN 37158 107 18 , , , 37158 107 19 to to IN 37158 107 20 the the DT 37158 107 21 germs germ NNS 37158 107 22 of of IN 37158 107 23 consumption consumption NN 37158 107 24 , , , 37158 107 25 but but CC 37158 107 26 we -PRON- PRP 37158 107 27 do do VBP 37158 107 28 not not RB 37158 107 29 all all RB 37158 107 30 die die VB 37158 107 31 of of IN 37158 107 32 that that DT 37158 107 33 disease disease NN 37158 107 34 . . . 37158 108 1 This this DT 37158 108 2 is be VBZ 37158 108 3 because because IN 37158 108 4 the the DT 37158 108 5 white white JJ 37158 108 6 corpuscles corpuscle NNS 37158 108 7 of of IN 37158 108 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 108 9 blood blood NN 37158 108 10 are be VBP 37158 108 11 in in IN 37158 108 12 good good JJ 37158 108 13 trim trim NN 37158 108 14 , , , 37158 108 15 and and CC 37158 108 16 able able JJ 37158 108 17 successfully successfully RB 37158 108 18 to to TO 37158 108 19 devour devour VB 37158 108 20 the the DT 37158 108 21 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 108 22 that that WDT 37158 108 23 enter enter VBP 37158 108 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 108 25 interior interior NN 37158 108 26 . . . 37158 109 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 109 2 is be VBZ 37158 109 3 those those DT 37158 109 4 people people NNS 37158 109 5 who who WP 37158 109 6 are be VBP 37158 109 7 run run VBN 37158 109 8 down down RB 37158 109 9 , , , 37158 109 10 and and CC 37158 109 11 in in IN 37158 109 12 whom whom WP 37158 109 13 the the DT 37158 109 14 white white JJ 37158 109 15 corpuscles corpuscle NNS 37158 109 16 are be VBP 37158 109 17 ' ' '' 37158 109 18 below below IN 37158 109 19 par par NN 37158 109 20 , , , 37158 109 21 ' ' '' 37158 109 22 that that WDT 37158 109 23 catch catch VBP 37158 109 24 the the DT 37158 109 25 disease disease NN 37158 109 26 . . . 37158 110 1 In in IN 37158 110 2 assisting assist VBG 37158 110 3 the the DT 37158 110 4 white white JJ 37158 110 5 corpuscles corpuscle NNS 37158 110 6 to to TO 37158 110 7 perform perform VB 37158 110 8 this this DT 37158 110 9 important important JJ 37158 110 10 function function NN 37158 110 11 , , , 37158 110 12 the the DT 37158 110 13 co co NN 37158 110 14 - - NN 37158 110 15 operation operation NN 37158 110 16 of of IN 37158 110 17 certain certain JJ 37158 110 18 substances substance NNS 37158 110 19 dissolved dissolve VBN 37158 110 20 in in IN 37158 110 21 the the DT 37158 110 22 fluid fluid JJ 37158 110 23 portion portion NN 37158 110 24 of of IN 37158 110 25 the the DT 37158 110 26 blood blood NN 37158 110 27 is be VBZ 37158 110 28 also also RB 37158 110 29 necessary necessary JJ 37158 110 30 . . . 37158 111 1 The the DT 37158 111 2 most most RBS 37158 111 3 recently recently RB 37158 111 4 discovered discover VBN 37158 111 5 of of IN 37158 111 6 these these DT 37158 111 7 auxiliary auxiliary JJ 37158 111 8 substances substance NNS 37158 111 9 are be VBP 37158 111 10 called call VBN 37158 111 11 _ _ NNP 37158 111 12 opsonins opsonin NNS 37158 111 13 _ _ NNP 37158 111 14 . . . 37158 112 1 The the DT 37158 112 2 word word NN 37158 112 3 opsonin opsonin FW 37158 112 4 is be VBZ 37158 112 5 derived derive VBN 37158 112 6 from from IN 37158 112 7 a a DT 37158 112 8 Greek greek JJ 37158 112 9 root root NN 37158 112 10 which which WDT 37158 112 11 means mean VBZ 37158 112 12 " " `` 37158 112 13 to to TO 37158 112 14 prepare prepare VB 37158 112 15 the the DT 37158 112 16 feast feast NN 37158 112 17 . . . 37158 112 18 " " '' 37158 113 1 The the DT 37158 113 2 opsonin opsonin NNS 37158 113 3 either either CC 37158 113 4 adds add VBZ 37158 113 5 something something NN 37158 113 6 to to IN 37158 113 7 the the DT 37158 113 8 bacterium bacterium NN 37158 113 9 which which WDT 37158 113 10 makes make VBZ 37158 113 11 it -PRON- PRP 37158 113 12 tasty tasty JJ 37158 113 13 to to IN 37158 113 14 the the DT 37158 113 15 white white JJ 37158 113 16 corpuscle corpuscle NN 37158 113 17 , , , 37158 113 18 or or CC 37158 113 19 removes remove VBZ 37158 113 20 ( ( -LRB- 37158 113 21 or or CC 37158 113 22 neutralises neutralise NNS 37158 113 23 ) ) -RRB- 37158 113 24 something something NN 37158 113 25 which which WDT 37158 113 26 previously previously RB 37158 113 27 made make VBD 37158 113 28 it -PRON- PRP 37158 113 29 distasteful distasteful JJ 37158 113 30 . . . 37158 114 1 White white JJ 37158 114 2 corpuscles corpuscle NNS 37158 114 3 will will MD 37158 114 4 not not RB 37158 114 5 as as IN 37158 114 6 a a DT 37158 114 7 rule rule NN 37158 114 8 ingest ingest NN 37158 114 9 and and CC 37158 114 10 devour devour JJ 37158 114 11 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 114 12 from from IN 37158 114 13 a a DT 37158 114 14 pure pure JJ 37158 114 15 culture culture NN 37158 114 16 , , , 37158 114 17 but but CC 37158 114 18 they -PRON- PRP 37158 114 19 do do VBP 37158 114 20 so so RB 37158 114 21 eagerly eagerly RB 37158 114 22 immediately immediately RB 37158 114 23 the the DT 37158 114 24 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 114 25 are be VBP 37158 114 26 bathed bathe VBN 37158 114 27 in in IN 37158 114 28 serum serum NN 37158 114 29 ; ; : 37158 114 30 and and CC 37158 114 31 the the DT 37158 114 32 serum serum NN 37158 114 33 which which WDT 37158 114 34 is be VBZ 37158 114 35 most most RBS 37158 114 36 efficacious efficacious JJ 37158 114 37 in in IN 37158 114 38 acting act VBG 37158 114 39 as as IN 37158 114 40 a a DT 37158 114 41 sort sort NN 37158 114 42 of of IN 37158 114 43 sauce sauce NN 37158 114 44 is be VBZ 37158 114 45 that that DT 37158 114 46 which which WDT 37158 114 47 has have VBZ 37158 114 48 been be VBN 37158 114 49 obtained obtain VBN 37158 114 50 from from IN 37158 114 51 an an DT 37158 114 52 animal animal NN 37158 114 53 which which WDT 37158 114 54 has have VBZ 37158 114 55 been be VBN 37158 114 56 previously previously RB 37158 114 57 infected infect VBN 37158 114 58 with with IN 37158 114 59 the the DT 37158 114 60 same same JJ 37158 114 61 kind kind NN 37158 114 62 of of IN 37158 114 63 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 114 64 , , , 37158 114 65 and and CC 37158 114 66 which which WDT 37158 114 67 has have VBZ 37158 114 68 recovered recover VBN 37158 114 69 from from IN 37158 114 70 the the DT 37158 114 71 ailment ailment JJ 37158 114 72 such such JJ 37158 114 73 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 114 74 have have VBP 37158 114 75 set set VBN 37158 114 76 up up RP 37158 114 77 . . . 37158 115 1 This this DT 37158 115 2 is be VBZ 37158 115 3 not not RB 37158 115 4 mere mere JJ 37158 115 5 fancy fancy JJ 37158 115 6 : : : 37158 115 7 the the DT 37158 115 8 whole whole JJ 37158 115 9 sequence sequence NN 37158 115 10 of of IN 37158 115 11 events event NNS 37158 115 12 can can MD 37158 115 13 be be VB 37158 115 14 easily easily RB 37158 115 15 followed follow VBN 37158 115 16 on on IN 37158 115 17 a a DT 37158 115 18 glass glass NN 37158 115 19 slide slide NN 37158 115 20 kept keep VBD 37158 115 21 at at IN 37158 115 22 body body NN 37158 115 23 temperature temperature NN 37158 115 24 and and CC 37158 115 25 examined examine VBD 37158 115 26 with with IN 37158 115 27 a a DT 37158 115 28 microscope microscope NN 37158 115 29 . . . 37158 116 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 116 2 is be VBZ 37158 116 3 well well RB 37158 116 4 known know VBN 37158 116 5 that that IN 37158 116 6 if if IN 37158 116 7 the the DT 37158 116 8 yeast yeast NN 37158 116 9 plant plant NN 37158 116 10 ( ( -LRB- 37158 116 11 which which WDT 37158 116 12 is be VBZ 37158 116 13 very very RB 37158 116 14 similar similar JJ 37158 116 15 in in IN 37158 116 16 many many JJ 37158 116 17 details detail NNS 37158 116 18 to to IN 37158 116 19 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 116 20 ) ) -RRB- 37158 116 21 is be VBZ 37158 116 22 grown grow VBN 37158 116 23 in in IN 37158 116 24 a a DT 37158 116 25 solution solution NN 37158 116 26 of of IN 37158 116 27 sugar sugar NN 37158 116 28 , , , 37158 116 29 the the DT 37158 116 30 sugar sugar NN 37158 116 31 is be VBZ 37158 116 32 broken break VBN 37158 116 33 up up RP 37158 116 34 and and CC 37158 116 35 disappears disappear VBZ 37158 116 36 , , , 37158 116 37 and and CC 37158 116 38 two two CD 37158 116 39 new new JJ 37158 116 40 substances substance NNS 37158 116 41 formed form VBN 37158 116 42 from from IN 37158 116 43 the the DT 37158 116 44 sugar sugar NN 37158 116 45 take take VB 37158 116 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 116 47 place place NN 37158 116 48 . . . 37158 117 1 These these DT 37158 117 2 are be VBP 37158 117 3 alcohol alcohol NN 37158 117 4 and and CC 37158 117 5 carbonic carbonic JJ 37158 117 6 acid acid NN 37158 117 7 gas gas NN 37158 117 8 . . . 37158 118 1 If if IN 37158 118 2 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 118 3 grow grow VBP 37158 118 4 in in IN 37158 118 5 the the DT 37158 118 6 blood blood NN 37158 118 7 , , , 37158 118 8 they -PRON- PRP 37158 118 9 do do VBP 37158 118 10 not not RB 37158 118 11 produce produce VB 37158 118 12 alcohol alcohol NN 37158 118 13 , , , 37158 118 14 but but CC 37158 118 15 they -PRON- PRP 37158 118 16 do do VBP 37158 118 17 produce produce VB 37158 118 18 other other JJ 37158 118 19 poisons poison NNS 37158 118 20 in in IN 37158 118 21 a a DT 37158 118 22 way way NN 37158 118 23 analogous analogous JJ 37158 118 24 to to IN 37158 118 25 that that DT 37158 118 26 by by IN 37158 118 27 which which WDT 37158 118 28 yeast yeast NN 37158 118 29 produces produce VBZ 37158 118 30 alcohol alcohol NN 37158 118 31 . . . 37158 119 1 These these DT 37158 119 2 poisons poison NNS 37158 119 3 are be VBP 37158 119 4 called call VBN 37158 119 5 _ _ NNP 37158 119 6 toxins toxin NNS 37158 119 7 _ _ NNP 37158 119 8 . . . 37158 120 1 There there EX 37158 120 2 are be VBP 37158 120 3 substances substance NNS 37158 120 4 in in IN 37158 120 5 the the DT 37158 120 6 fluid fluid JJ 37158 120 7 part part NN 37158 120 8 of of IN 37158 120 9 the the DT 37158 120 10 blood blood NN 37158 120 11 which which WDT 37158 120 12 are be VBP 37158 120 13 called call VBN 37158 120 14 antitoxins antitoxin NNS 37158 120 15 , , , 37158 120 16 because because IN 37158 120 17 they -PRON- PRP 37158 120 18 neutralise neutralise VBP 37158 120 19 the the DT 37158 120 20 toxins toxin NNS 37158 120 21 produced produce VBN 37158 120 22 by by IN 37158 120 23 the the DT 37158 120 24 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 120 25 . . . 37158 121 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 121 2 presence presence NN 37158 121 3 constitutes constitute VBZ 37158 121 4 a a DT 37158 121 5 means means NN 37158 121 6 of of IN 37158 121 7 defence defence NN 37158 121 8 against against IN 37158 121 9 the the DT 37158 121 10 harmful harmful JJ 37158 121 11 effects effect NNS 37158 121 12 the the DT 37158 121 13 toxins toxin NNS 37158 121 14 would would MD 37158 121 15 otherwise otherwise RB 37158 121 16 produce produce VB 37158 121 17 . . . 37158 122 1 The the DT 37158 122 2 marvellous marvellous JJ 37158 122 3 part part NN 37158 122 4 of of IN 37158 122 5 the the DT 37158 122 6 defence defence NN 37158 122 7 is be VBZ 37158 122 8 that that IN 37158 122 9 , , , 37158 122 10 although although IN 37158 122 11 we -PRON- PRP 37158 122 12 all all DT 37158 122 13 have have VBP 37158 122 14 a a DT 37158 122 15 certain certain JJ 37158 122 16 amount amount NN 37158 122 17 of of IN 37158 122 18 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 122 19 in in IN 37158 122 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 122 21 blood blood NN 37158 122 22 , , , 37158 122 23 the the DT 37158 122 24 amount amount NN 37158 122 25 increases increase VBZ 37158 122 26 in in IN 37158 122 27 proportion proportion NN 37158 122 28 to to IN 37158 122 29 the the DT 37158 122 30 amount amount NN 37158 122 31 of of IN 37158 122 32 toxin toxin NN 37158 122 33 . . . 37158 123 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 123 2 is be VBZ 37158 123 3 a a DT 37158 123 4 familiar familiar JJ 37158 123 5 fact fact NN 37158 123 6 that that IN 37158 123 7 rough rough JJ 37158 123 8 manual manual JJ 37158 123 9 labour labour NN 37158 123 10 increases increase VBZ 37158 123 11 the the DT 37158 123 12 hardness hardness NN 37158 123 13 of of IN 37158 123 14 the the DT 37158 123 15 hands hand NNS 37158 123 16 ; ; : 37158 123 17 friction friction NN 37158 123 18 stimulates stimulate VBZ 37158 123 19 the the DT 37158 123 20 epidermis epidermis NN 37158 123 21 or or CC 37158 123 22 outer outer JJ 37158 123 23 skin skin NN 37158 123 24 , , , 37158 123 25 so so IN 37158 123 26 that that IN 37158 123 27 it -PRON- PRP 37158 123 28 grows grow VBZ 37158 123 29 in in IN 37158 123 30 thickness thickness NN 37158 123 31 . . . 37158 124 1 The the DT 37158 124 2 body body NN 37158 124 3 affords afford VBZ 37158 124 4 numerous numerous JJ 37158 124 5 similar similar JJ 37158 124 6 instances instance NNS 37158 124 7 of of IN 37158 124 8 how how WRB 37158 124 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 124 10 is be VBZ 37158 124 11 capable capable JJ 37158 124 12 of of IN 37158 124 13 rising rise VBG 37158 124 14 to to IN 37158 124 15 the the DT 37158 124 16 occasion occasion NN 37158 124 17 and and CC 37158 124 18 increasing increase VBG 37158 124 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 124 20 defences defence NNS 37158 124 21 . . . 37158 125 1 Just just RB 37158 125 2 in in IN 37158 125 3 the the DT 37158 125 4 same same JJ 37158 125 5 way way NN 37158 125 6 , , , 37158 125 7 the the DT 37158 125 8 presence presence NN 37158 125 9 of of IN 37158 125 10 a a DT 37158 125 11 toxin toxin NN 37158 125 12 stimulates stimulate VBZ 37158 125 13 the the DT 37158 125 14 living live VBG 37158 125 15 cells cell NNS 37158 125 16 to to TO 37158 125 17 produce produce VB 37158 125 18 more more JJR 37158 125 19 and and CC 37158 125 20 more more JJR 37158 125 21 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 125 22 , , , 37158 125 23 and and CC 37158 125 24 the the DT 37158 125 25 blood blood NN 37158 125 26 remains remain VBZ 37158 125 27 rich rich JJ 37158 125 28 in in IN 37158 125 29 the the DT 37158 125 30 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 125 31 for for IN 37158 125 32 a a DT 37158 125 33 considerable considerable JJ 37158 125 34 time time NN 37158 125 35 afterwards afterwards RB 37158 125 36 . . . 37158 126 1 This this DT 37158 126 2 explains explain VBZ 37158 126 3 why why WRB 37158 126 4 a a DT 37158 126 5 person person NN 37158 126 6 who who WP 37158 126 7 has have VBZ 37158 126 8 had have VBN 37158 126 9 an an DT 37158 126 10 infectious infectious JJ 37158 126 11 disease disease NN 37158 126 12 does do VBZ 37158 126 13 not not RB 37158 126 14 take take VB 37158 126 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 126 16 readily readily RB 37158 126 17 a a DT 37158 126 18 second second JJ 37158 126 19 time time NN 37158 126 20 ; ; : 37158 126 21 he -PRON- PRP 37158 126 22 is be VBZ 37158 126 23 immune immune JJ 37158 126 24 for for IN 37158 126 25 a a DT 37158 126 26 certain certain JJ 37158 126 27 number number NN 37158 126 28 of of IN 37158 126 29 years year NNS 37158 126 30 , , , 37158 126 31 because because IN 37158 126 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 126 33 blood blood NN 37158 126 34 is be VBZ 37158 126 35 so so RB 37158 126 36 rich rich JJ 37158 126 37 in in IN 37158 126 38 the the DT 37158 126 39 antidote antidote NN 37158 126 40 . . . 37158 127 1 Now now RB 37158 127 2 , , , 37158 127 3 the the DT 37158 127 4 principle principle NN 37158 127 5 of of IN 37158 127 6 serum serum NN 37158 127 7 treatment treatment NN 37158 127 8 depends depend VBZ 37158 127 9 on on IN 37158 127 10 those those DT 37158 127 11 ascertained ascertain VBN 37158 127 12 and and CC 37158 127 13 definitely definitely RB 37158 127 14 proved prove VBD 37158 127 15 facts fact NNS 37158 127 16 . . . 37158 128 1 In in IN 37158 128 2 the the DT 37158 128 3 modern modern JJ 37158 128 4 treatment treatment NN 37158 128 5 of of IN 37158 128 6 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 128 7 , , , 37158 128 8 for for IN 37158 128 9 example example NN 37158 128 10 , , , 37158 128 11 the the DT 37158 128 12 aim aim NN 37158 128 13 of of IN 37158 128 14 the the DT 37158 128 15 physician physician NN 37158 128 16 is be VBZ 37158 128 17 to to TO 37158 128 18 increase increase VB 37158 128 19 nature nature NN 37158 128 20 's 's POS 37158 128 21 method method NN 37158 128 22 of of IN 37158 128 23 cure cure NN 37158 128 24 : : : 37158 128 25 good good JJ 37158 128 26 food food NN 37158 128 27 and and CC 37158 128 28 pure pure JJ 37158 128 29 air air NN 37158 128 30 do do VBP 37158 128 31 much much RB 37158 128 32 to to TO 37158 128 33 increase increase VB 37158 128 34 the the DT 37158 128 35 healthiness healthiness NN 37158 128 36 of of IN 37158 128 37 the the DT 37158 128 38 blood blood NN 37158 128 39 and and CC 37158 128 40 fortify fortify VB 37158 128 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 128 42 natural natural JJ 37158 128 43 power power NN 37158 128 44 , , , 37158 128 45 of of IN 37158 128 46 destroying destroy VBG 37158 128 47 the the DT 37158 128 48 germs germ NNS 37158 128 49 ; ; : 37158 128 50 sometimes sometimes RB 37158 128 51 this this DT 37158 128 52 alone alone RB 37158 128 53 suffices suffice VBZ 37158 128 54 . . . 37158 129 1 At at IN 37158 129 2 other other JJ 37158 129 3 times time NNS 37158 129 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 129 5 is be VBZ 37158 129 6 not not RB 37158 129 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 129 8 , , , 37158 129 9 particularly particularly RB 37158 129 10 if if IN 37158 129 11 the the DT 37158 129 12 disease disease NN 37158 129 13 has have VBZ 37158 129 14 advanced advance VBN 37158 129 15 and and CC 37158 129 16 the the DT 37158 129 17 number number NN 37158 129 18 of of IN 37158 129 19 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 129 20 is be VBZ 37158 129 21 too too RB 37158 129 22 great great JJ 37158 129 23 for for IN 37158 129 24 the the DT 37158 129 25 enfeebled enfeebled JJ 37158 129 26 white white JJ 37158 129 27 corpuscles corpuscle NNS 37158 129 28 to to TO 37158 129 29 deal deal VB 37158 129 30 with with IN 37158 129 31 . . . 37158 130 1 Then then RB 37158 130 2 the the DT 37158 130 3 physician physician NN 37158 130 4 goes go VBZ 37158 130 5 a a DT 37158 130 6 step step NN 37158 130 7 farther far RBR 37158 130 8 , , , 37158 130 9 and and CC 37158 130 10 administers administer VBZ 37158 130 11 the the DT 37158 130 12 appropriate appropriate JJ 37158 130 13 opsonin opsonin VBN 37158 130 14 by by IN 37158 130 15 injecting inject VBG 37158 130 16 it -PRON- PRP 37158 130 17 under under IN 37158 130 18 the the DT 37158 130 19 skin skin NN 37158 130 20 , , , 37158 130 21 again again RB 37158 130 22 simply simply RB 37158 130 23 increasing increase VBG 37158 130 24 the the DT 37158 130 25 resistance resistance NN 37158 130 26 of of IN 37158 130 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 130 28 patient patient NN 37158 130 29 by by IN 37158 130 30 a a DT 37158 130 31 perfectly perfectly RB 37158 130 32 natural natural JJ 37158 130 33 method method NN 37158 130 34 . . . 37158 131 1 In in IN 37158 131 2 the the DT 37158 131 3 case case NN 37158 131 4 of of IN 37158 131 5 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 131 6 , , , 37158 131 7 the the DT 37158 131 8 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 131 9 appears appear VBZ 37158 131 10 to to TO 37158 131 11 be be VB 37158 131 12 more more RBR 37158 131 13 efficacious efficacious JJ 37158 131 14 than than IN 37158 131 15 an an DT 37158 131 16 opsonin opsonin NN 37158 131 17 . . . 37158 132 1 A a DT 37158 132 2 horse horse NN 37158 132 3 is be VBZ 37158 132 4 inoculated inoculate VBN 37158 132 5 with with IN 37158 132 6 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 132 7 , , , 37158 132 8 and and CC 37158 132 9 when when WRB 37158 132 10 he -PRON- PRP 37158 132 11 has have VBZ 37158 132 12 recovered recover VBN 37158 132 13 , , , 37158 132 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 132 15 blood blood NN 37158 132 16 is be VBZ 37158 132 17 collected collect VBN 37158 132 18 . . . 37158 133 1 This this DT 37158 133 2 blood blood NN 37158 133 3 is be VBZ 37158 133 4 then then RB 37158 133 5 rich rich JJ 37158 133 6 in in IN 37158 133 7 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 133 8 , , , 37158 133 9 the the DT 37158 133 10 natural natural JJ 37158 133 11 antidote antidote NN 37158 133 12 that that WDT 37158 133 13 has have VBZ 37158 133 14 enabled enable VBN 37158 133 15 the the DT 37158 133 16 horse horse NN 37158 133 17 to to TO 37158 133 18 get get VB 37158 133 19 well well JJ 37158 133 20 again again RB 37158 133 21 . . . 37158 134 1 The the DT 37158 134 2 blood blood NN 37158 134 3 is be VBZ 37158 134 4 allowed allow VBN 37158 134 5 to to TO 37158 134 6 clot clot VB 37158 134 7 , , , 37158 134 8 and and CC 37158 134 9 the the DT 37158 134 10 clot clot NN 37158 134 11 is be VBZ 37158 134 12 removed remove VBN 37158 134 13 ; ; : 37158 134 14 the the DT 37158 134 15 fluid fluid JJ 37158 134 16 residue residue NN 37158 134 17 is be VBZ 37158 134 18 called call VBN 37158 134 19 serum serum NN 37158 134 20 , , , 37158 134 21 and and CC 37158 134 22 the the DT 37158 134 23 serum serum NN 37158 134 24 contains contain VBZ 37158 134 25 the the DT 37158 134 26 antidote antidote NN 37158 134 27 . . . 37158 135 1 If if IN 37158 135 2 now now RB 37158 135 3 another another DT 37158 135 4 horse horse NN 37158 135 5 has have VBZ 37158 135 6 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 135 7 , , , 37158 135 8 and and CC 37158 135 9 you -PRON- PRP 37158 135 10 want want VBP 37158 135 11 to to TO 37158 135 12 cure cure VB 37158 135 13 him -PRON- PRP 37158 135 14 quickly quickly RB 37158 135 15 , , , 37158 135 16 what what WDT 37158 135 17 more more RBR 37158 135 18 natural natural JJ 37158 135 19 than than IN 37158 135 20 inject inject VB 37158 135 21 the the DT 37158 135 22 serum serum NN 37158 135 23 of of IN 37158 135 24 the the DT 37158 135 25 horse horse NN 37158 135 26 who who WP 37158 135 27 has have VBZ 37158 135 28 just just RB 37158 135 29 recovered recover VBN 37158 135 30 ? ? . 37158 136 1 it -PRON- PRP 37158 136 2 will will MD 37158 136 3 save save VB 37158 136 4 the the DT 37158 136 5 second second JJ 37158 136 6 horse horse NN 37158 136 7 the the DT 37158 136 8 trouble trouble NN 37158 136 9 and and CC 37158 136 10 the the DT 37158 136 11 time time NN 37158 136 12 of of IN 37158 136 13 making make VBG 37158 136 14 the the DT 37158 136 15 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 136 16 for for IN 37158 136 17 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 136 18 , , , 37158 136 19 and and CC 37158 136 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 136 21 has have VBZ 37158 136 22 been be VBN 37158 136 23 proved prove VBN 37158 136 24 over over RB 37158 136 25 and and CC 37158 136 26 over over RB 37158 136 27 again again RB 37158 136 28 that that IN 37158 136 29 the the DT 37158 136 30 second second JJ 37158 136 31 horse horse NN 37158 136 32 does do VBZ 37158 136 33 recover recover VB 37158 136 34 with with IN 37158 136 35 amazing amazing JJ 37158 136 36 celerity celerity NN 37158 136 37 . . . 37158 137 1 The the DT 37158 137 2 pathologists pathologist NNS 37158 137 3 then then RB 37158 137 4 advanced advance VBD 37158 137 5 a a DT 37158 137 6 step step NN 37158 137 7 , , , 37158 137 8 and and CC 37158 137 9 asked ask VBD 37158 137 10 , , , 37158 137 11 Why why WRB 37158 137 12 should should MD 37158 137 13 this this DT 37158 137 14 antidote antidote NN 37158 137 15 be be VB 37158 137 16 used use VBN 37158 137 17 solely solely RB 37158 137 18 for for IN 37158 137 19 animals animal NNS 37158 137 20 when when WRB 37158 137 21 they -PRON- PRP 37158 137 22 have have VBP 37158 137 23 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 137 24 ? ? . 37158 138 1 Why why WRB 37158 138 2 should should MD 37158 138 3 not not RB 37158 138 4 the the DT 37158 138 5 horse horse NN 37158 138 6 's 's POS 37158 138 7 serum serum NN 37158 138 8 be be VB 37158 138 9 beneficial beneficial JJ 37158 138 10 to to IN 37158 138 11 human human JJ 37158 138 12 beings being NNS 37158 138 13 when when WRB 37158 138 14 they -PRON- PRP 37158 138 15 are be VBP 37158 138 16 attacked attack VBN 37158 138 17 with with IN 37158 138 18 the the DT 37158 138 19 same same JJ 37158 138 20 disease disease NN 37158 138 21 ? ? . 37158 139 1 The the DT 37158 139 2 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 139 3 poison poison NN 37158 139 4 is be VBZ 37158 139 5 much much RB 37158 139 6 more more RBR 37158 139 7 harmful harmful JJ 37158 139 8 to to IN 37158 139 9 a a DT 37158 139 10 man man NN 37158 139 11 , , , 37158 139 12 and and CC 37158 139 13 kills kill VBZ 37158 139 14 him -PRON- PRP 37158 139 15 more more RBR 37158 139 16 quickly quickly RB 37158 139 17 than than IN 37158 139 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 139 19 does do VBZ 37158 139 20 a a DT 37158 139 21 horse horse NN 37158 139 22 ; ; : 37158 139 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 139 24 is be VBZ 37158 139 25 therefore therefore RB 37158 139 26 imperative imperative JJ 37158 139 27 to to TO 37158 139 28 use use VB 37158 139 29 the the DT 37158 139 30 antidote antidote NN 37158 139 31 early early RB 37158 139 32 . . . 37158 140 1 The the DT 37158 140 2 crucial crucial JJ 37158 140 3 experiment experiment NN 37158 140 4 was be VBD 37158 140 5 made make VBN 37158 140 6 ; ; , 37158 140 7 entire entire JJ 37158 140 8 success success NN 37158 140 9 followed follow VBD 37158 140 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 140 11 , , , 37158 140 12 and and CC 37158 140 13 now now RB 37158 140 14 , , , 37158 140 15 as as IN 37158 140 16 Professor Professor NNP 37158 140 17 Richet Richet NNP 37158 140 18 says say VBZ 37158 140 19 , , , 37158 140 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 140 21 is be VBZ 37158 140 22 the the DT 37158 140 23 only only JJ 37158 140 24 treatment treatment NN 37158 140 25 employed employ VBN 37158 140 26 , , , 37158 140 27 and and CC 37158 140 28 any any DT 37158 140 29 medical medical JJ 37158 140 30 man man NN 37158 140 31 who who WP 37158 140 32 refuses refuse VBZ 37158 140 33 to to TO 37158 140 34 use use VB 37158 140 35 it -PRON- PRP 37158 140 36 is be VBZ 37158 140 37 little little RB 37158 140 38 short short JJ 37158 140 39 of of IN 37158 140 40 a a DT 37158 140 41 criminal criminal NN 37158 140 42 . . . 37158 141 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 141 2 have have VBP 37158 141 3 entered enter VBN 37158 141 4 into into IN 37158 141 5 this this DT 37158 141 6 brief brief NN 37158 141 7 and and CC 37158 141 8 , , , 37158 141 9 I -PRON- PRP 37158 141 10 trust trust VBP 37158 141 11 , , , 37158 141 12 simple simple JJ 37158 141 13 explanation explanation NN 37158 141 14 of of IN 37158 141 15 serum serum NN 37158 141 16 treatment treatment NN 37158 141 17 , , , 37158 141 18 because because IN 37158 141 19 so so RB 37158 141 20 many many JJ 37158 141 21 people people NNS 37158 141 22 want want VBP 37158 141 23 to to TO 37158 141 24 understand understand VB 37158 141 25 it -PRON- PRP 37158 141 26 and and CC 37158 141 27 are be VBP 37158 141 28 unable unable JJ 37158 141 29 to to TO 37158 141 30 comprehend comprehend VB 37158 141 31 the the DT 37158 141 32 technical technical JJ 37158 141 33 terms term NNS 37158 141 34 which which WDT 37158 141 35 scientific scientific JJ 37158 141 36 men man NNS 37158 141 37 , , , 37158 141 38 writing write VBG 37158 141 39 for for IN 37158 141 40 scientific scientific JJ 37158 141 41 readers reader NNS 37158 141 42 , , , 37158 141 43 almost almost RB 37158 141 44 exclusively exclusively RB 37158 141 45 employ employ VBP 37158 141 46 . . . 37158 142 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 142 2 am be VBP 37158 142 3 even even RB 37158 142 4 hopeful hopeful JJ 37158 142 5 that that IN 37158 142 6 some some DT 37158 142 7 of of IN 37158 142 8 the the DT 37158 142 9 more more RBR 37158 142 10 reasonable reasonable JJ 37158 142 11 opponents opponent NNS 37158 142 12 of of IN 37158 142 13 animal animal NN 37158 142 14 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 142 15 may may MD 37158 142 16 be be VB 37158 142 17 convinced convince VBN 37158 142 18 that that IN 37158 142 19 by by IN 37158 142 20 carrying carry VBG 37158 142 21 out out RP 37158 142 22 the the DT 37158 142 23 new new JJ 37158 142 24 methods method NNS 37158 142 25 of of IN 37158 142 26 serum serum NN 37158 142 27 therapy therapy NN 37158 142 28 , , , 37158 142 29 we -PRON- PRP 37158 142 30 are be VBP 37158 142 31 not not RB 37158 142 32 going go VBG 37158 142 33 against against IN 37158 142 34 nature nature NN 37158 142 35 but but CC 37158 142 36 helping help VBG 37158 142 37 her -PRON- PRP 37158 142 38 . . . 37158 143 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 143 2 is be VBZ 37158 143 3 just just RB 37158 143 4 these these DT 37158 143 5 ' ' `` 37158 143 6 messy messy JJ 37158 143 7 things thing NNS 37158 143 8 ' ' '' 37158 143 9 that that IN 37158 143 10 nature nature NN 37158 143 11 uses use VBZ 37158 143 12 for for IN 37158 143 13 curing cure VBG 37158 143 14 infectious infectious JJ 37158 143 15 diseases disease NNS 37158 143 16 , , , 37158 143 17 and and CC 37158 143 18 the the DT 37158 143 19 introduction introduction NN 37158 143 20 of of IN 37158 143 21 an an DT 37158 143 22 opsonin opsonin NNS 37158 143 23 or or CC 37158 143 24 an an DT 37158 143 25 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 143 26 is be VBZ 37158 143 27 not not RB 37158 143 28 putting put VBG 37158 143 29 matter matter NN 37158 143 30 in in IN 37158 143 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 143 32 wrong wrong JJ 37158 143 33 place place NN 37158 143 34 , , , 37158 143 35 but but CC 37158 143 36 in in IN 37158 143 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 143 38 right right JJ 37158 143 39 place place NN 37158 143 40 ; ; : 37158 143 41 and and CC 37158 143 42 therefore therefore RB 37158 143 43 the the DT 37158 143 44 use use NN 37158 143 45 of of IN 37158 143 46 the the DT 37158 143 47 terms term NNS 37158 143 48 filth filth NN 37158 143 49 and and CC 37158 143 50 dirt dirt NN 37158 143 51 in in IN 37158 143 52 this this DT 37158 143 53 relationship relationship NN 37158 143 54 should should MD 37158 143 55 be be VB 37158 143 56 confined confine VBN 37158 143 57 either either CC 37158 143 58 to to IN 37158 143 59 the the DT 37158 143 60 foul foul JJ 37158 143 61 - - HYPH 37158 143 62 mouthed mouthed JJ 37158 143 63 or or CC 37158 143 64 to to IN 37158 143 65 the the DT 37158 143 66 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 143 67 . . . 37158 144 1 W. W. NNP 37158 144 2 D. D. NNP 37158 144 3 HALLIBURTON HALLIBURTON NNP 37158 144 4 . . . 37158 145 1 _ _ NNP 37158 145 2 July July NNP 37158 145 3 1908 1908 CD 37158 145 4 . . . 37158 145 5 _ _ NNP 37158 145 6 P.S.--The P.S.--The NNP 37158 145 7 proof proof JJ 37158 145 8 sheets sheet NNS 37158 145 9 of of IN 37158 145 10 Professor Professor NNP 37158 145 11 Richet Richet NNP 37158 145 12 's 's POS 37158 145 13 book book NN 37158 145 14 have have VBP 37158 145 15 passed pass VBN 37158 145 16 through through IN 37158 145 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 145 18 hands hand NNS 37158 145 19 during during IN 37158 145 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 145 21 issue issue NN 37158 145 22 from from IN 37158 145 23 the the DT 37158 145 24 press press NN 37158 145 25 . . . 37158 146 1 Beyond beyond IN 37158 146 2 a a DT 37158 146 3 few few JJ 37158 146 4 verbal verbal JJ 37158 146 5 amendments amendment NNS 37158 146 6 , , , 37158 146 7 and and CC 37158 146 8 a a DT 37158 146 9 footnote footnote NN 37158 146 10 here here RB 37158 146 11 and and CC 37158 146 12 there there EX 37158 146 13 which which WDT 37158 146 14 I -PRON- PRP 37158 146 15 have have VBP 37158 146 16 added add VBN 37158 146 17 and and CC 37158 146 18 initialled initial VBN 37158 146 19 , , , 37158 146 20 no no DT 37158 146 21 alterations alteration NNS 37158 146 22 have have VBP 37158 146 23 been be VBN 37158 146 24 made make VBN 37158 146 25 in in IN 37158 146 26 the the DT 37158 146 27 original original NN 37158 146 28 . . . 37158 147 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 147 2 am be VBP 37158 147 3 also also RB 37158 147 4 responsible responsible JJ 37158 147 5 for for IN 37158 147 6 the the DT 37158 147 7 insertion insertion NN 37158 147 8 of of IN 37158 147 9 Appendix Appendix NNP 37158 147 10 C C NNP 37158 147 11 , , , 37158 147 12 regarding regard VBG 37158 147 13 the the DT 37158 147 14 aims aim NNS 37158 147 15 and and CC 37158 147 16 objects object NNS 37158 147 17 of of IN 37158 147 18 the the DT 37158 147 19 Research Research NNP 37158 147 20 Defence Defence NNP 37158 147 21 Society Society NNP 37158 147 22 . . . 37158 148 1 These these DT 37158 148 2 additions addition NNS 37158 148 3 and and CC 37158 148 4 minor minor JJ 37158 148 5 alterations alteration NNS 37158 148 6 have have VBP 37158 148 7 all all DT 37158 148 8 met meet VBN 37158 148 9 with with IN 37158 148 10 Professor Professor NNP 37158 148 11 Richet Richet NNP 37158 148 12 's 's POS 37158 148 13 approval approval NN 37158 148 14 . . . 37158 149 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 149 2 may may MD 37158 149 3 mention mention VB 37158 149 4 that that IN 37158 149 5 the the DT 37158 149 6 book book NN 37158 149 7 has have VBZ 37158 149 8 not not RB 37158 149 9 yet yet RB 37158 149 10 been be VBN 37158 149 11 published publish VBN 37158 149 12 in in IN 37158 149 13 French French NNP 37158 149 14 , , , 37158 149 15 and and CC 37158 149 16 is be VBZ 37158 149 17 presented present VBN 37158 149 18 to to IN 37158 149 19 the the DT 37158 149 20 public public NN 37158 149 21 for for IN 37158 149 22 the the DT 37158 149 23 first first JJ 37158 149 24 time time NN 37158 149 25 in in IN 37158 149 26 English English NNP 37158 149 27 dress dress NN 37158 149 28 . . . 37158 150 1 The the DT 37158 150 2 English English NNP 37158 150 3 lady lady NN 37158 150 4 who who WP 37158 150 5 collaborated collaborate VBD 37158 150 6 with with IN 37158 150 7 Professor Professor NNP 37158 150 8 Richet Richet NNP 37158 150 9 in in IN 37158 150 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 150 11 production production NN 37158 150 12 has have VBZ 37158 150 13 worked work VBN 37158 150 14 with with IN 37158 150 15 and and CC 37158 150 16 studied study VBD 37158 150 17 under under IN 37158 150 18 him -PRON- PRP 37158 150 19 for for IN 37158 150 20 some some DT 37158 150 21 years year NNS 37158 150 22 , , , 37158 150 23 and and CC 37158 150 24 it -PRON- PRP 37158 150 25 was be VBD 37158 150 26 largely largely RB 37158 150 27 owing owing JJ 37158 150 28 to to IN 37158 150 29 her -PRON- PRP$ 37158 150 30 persuasion persuasion NN 37158 150 31 that that IN 37158 150 32 he -PRON- PRP 37158 150 33 consented consent VBD 37158 150 34 to to TO 37158 150 35 express express VB 37158 150 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 150 37 views view NNS 37158 150 38 publicly publicly RB 37158 150 39 . . . 37158 151 1 She -PRON- PRP 37158 151 2 desires desire VBZ 37158 151 3 for for IN 37158 151 4 the the DT 37158 151 5 present present NN 37158 151 6 to to TO 37158 151 7 remain remain VB 37158 151 8 anonymous anonymous JJ 37158 151 9 . . . 37158 152 1 W. W. NNP 37158 152 2 D. D. NNP 37158 152 3 H. H. NNP 37158 152 4 _ _ NNP 37158 152 5 October October NNP 37158 152 6 1908 1908 CD 37158 152 7 . . . 37158 152 8 _ _ NNP 37158 152 9 CONTENTS CONTENTS NNP 37158 152 10 PAGE PAGE NNP 37158 152 11 PREFACE preface NN 37158 152 12 BY by IN 37158 152 13 PROFESSOR PROFESSOR NNS 37158 152 14 HALLIBURTON HALLIBURTON NNP 37158 152 15 v v IN 37158 152 16 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 37158 152 17 1 1 CD 37158 152 18 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 152 19 I -PRON- PRP 37158 152 20 THE the DT 37158 152 21 NECESSARY necessary NN 37158 152 22 LIMITS limit NNS 37158 152 23 OF of IN 37158 152 24 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 152 25 7 7 CD 37158 152 26 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37158 152 27 II II NNP 37158 152 28 PAIN PAIN NNP 37158 152 29 AND and CC 37158 152 30 DEATH death NN 37158 152 31 18 18 CD 37158 152 32 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 152 33 III iii CD 37158 152 34 CONCERNING concerning NN 37158 152 35 ANÆSTHESIA ANÆSTHESIA NNP 37158 152 36 IN in IN 37158 152 37 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 152 38 31 31 CD 37158 152 39 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37158 152 40 IV IV NNP 37158 152 41 CONCERNING concern VBG 37158 152 42 EXPERIMENTATION experimentation NN 37158 152 43 OTHER other JJ 37158 152 44 THAN than IN 37158 152 45 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 152 46 40 40 CD 37158 152 47 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 152 48 V V NNP 37158 152 49 SERVICES services NN 37158 152 50 RENDERED rendered NN 37158 152 51 TO to IN 37158 152 52 SCIENCE science NN 37158 152 53 AND and CC 37158 152 54 HUMANITY humanity VB 37158 152 55 BY by IN 37158 152 56 EXPERIMENTAL experimental NN 37158 152 57 PHYSIOLOGY PHYSIOLOGY NNS 37158 152 58 59 59 CD 37158 152 59 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 152 60 VI VI NNP 37158 152 61 MORALITY MORALITY NNP 37158 152 62 AND and CC 37158 152 63 VIVISECTION vivisection VBP 37158 152 64 72 72 CD 37158 152 65 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 152 66 VII vii NN 37158 152 67 ARE are VBP 37158 152 68 LAWS LAWS NNP 37158 152 69 REGULATING regulate VBG 37158 152 70 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 152 71 NECESSARY necessary NN 37158 152 72 ? ? . 37158 153 1 91 91 CD 37158 153 2 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 153 3 VIII viii NN 37158 153 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 153 5 AND and CC 37158 153 6 THE the DT 37158 153 7 FUTURE future NN 37158 153 8 OF of IN 37158 153 9 SCIENCE science NN 37158 153 10 97 97 CD 37158 153 11 POST post NN 37158 153 12 SCRIPTUM SCRIPTUM NNP 37158 153 13 114 114 CD 37158 153 14 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 37158 153 15 A.--DIPHTHERIA a.--diphtheria CD 37158 153 16 STATISTICS STATISTICS NNP 37158 153 17 121 121 CD 37158 153 18 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 37158 153 19 B.--BIBLIOGRAPHY B.--BIBLIOGRAPHY : 37158 153 20 124 124 CD 37158 153 21 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 37158 153 22 C.--THE c.--the NN 37158 153 23 RESEARCH RESEARCH NNP 37158 153 24 DEFENCE DEFENCE NNP 37158 153 25 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 37158 153 26 130 130 CD 37158 153 27 ILLUSTRATIONS illustrations NN 37158 153 28 " " `` 37158 153 29 LA LA NNP 37158 153 30 MORT MORT NNP 37158 153 31 . . . 37158 153 32 " " '' 37158 154 1 By by IN 37158 154 2 BARTHOLOMÉ BARTHOLOMÉ NNP 37158 154 3 , , , 37158 154 4 in in IN 37158 154 5 Père Père NNP 37158 154 6 Lachaise Lachaise NNP 37158 154 7 , , , 37158 154 8 Paris Paris NNP 37158 154 9 , , , 37158 154 10 _ _ NNP 37158 154 11 Frontispiece Frontispiece NNP 37158 154 12 _ _ NNP 37158 154 13 PASTEUR PASTEUR NNP 37158 154 14 IN in IN 37158 154 15 HIS his PRP$ 37158 154 16 LABORATORY laboratory NN 37158 154 17 , , , 37158 154 18 _ _ NNP 37158 154 19 facing face VBG 37158 154 20 page page NN 37158 154 21 _ _ NNP 37158 154 22 44 44 CD 37158 154 23 " " `` 37158 154 24 L'ENFANT L'ENFANT NNP 37158 154 25 . . . 37158 154 26 " " '' 37158 155 1 In in IN 37158 155 2 Musée Musée NNP 37158 155 3 du du NNP 37158 155 4 Luxembourg Luxembourg NNP 37158 155 5 , , , 37158 155 6 Paris Paris NNP 37158 155 7 , , , 37158 155 8 " " `` 37158 155 9 53 53 CD 37158 155 10 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 37158 155 11 The the DT 37158 155 12 object object NN 37158 155 13 of of IN 37158 155 14 this this DT 37158 155 15 book book NN 37158 155 16 is be VBZ 37158 155 17 to to TO 37158 155 18 set set VB 37158 155 19 forth forth RP 37158 155 20 , , , 37158 155 21 as as RB 37158 155 22 impartially impartially RB 37158 155 23 as as IN 37158 155 24 possible possible JJ 37158 155 25 , , , 37158 155 26 the the DT 37158 155 27 reasons reason NNS 37158 155 28 which which WDT 37158 155 29 militate militate VBP 37158 155 30 for for IN 37158 155 31 and and CC 37158 155 32 against against IN 37158 155 33 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 155 34 . . . 37158 156 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 156 2 is be VBZ 37158 156 3 , , , 37158 156 4 however however RB 37158 156 5 , , , 37158 156 6 a a DT 37158 156 7 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 156 8 who who WP 37158 156 9 is be VBZ 37158 156 10 speaking speak VBG 37158 156 11 , , , 37158 156 12 therefore therefore RB 37158 156 13 no no DT 37158 156 14 one one NN 37158 156 15 will will MD 37158 156 16 be be VB 37158 156 17 surprised surprised JJ 37158 156 18 that that IN 37158 156 19 he -PRON- PRP 37158 156 20 should should MD 37158 156 21 defend defend VB 37158 156 22 a a DT 37158 156 23 practice practice NN 37158 156 24 which which WDT 37158 156 25 is be VBZ 37158 156 26 at at IN 37158 156 27 the the DT 37158 156 28 basis basis NN 37158 156 29 of of IN 37158 156 30 the the DT 37158 156 31 science science NN 37158 156 32 he -PRON- PRP 37158 156 33 teaches teach VBZ 37158 156 34 . . . 37158 157 1 May May MD 37158 157 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 157 3 be be VB 37158 157 4 permitted permit VBN 37158 157 5 , , , 37158 157 6 at at IN 37158 157 7 the the DT 37158 157 8 same same JJ 37158 157 9 time time NN 37158 157 10 , , , 37158 157 11 to to TO 37158 157 12 express express VB 37158 157 13 the the DT 37158 157 14 high high JJ 37158 157 15 moral moral JJ 37158 157 16 esteem esteem NN 37158 157 17 which which WDT 37158 157 18 he -PRON- PRP 37158 157 19 feels feel VBZ 37158 157 20 for for IN 37158 157 21 all all PDT 37158 157 22 those those DT 37158 157 23 who who WP 37158 157 24 , , , 37158 157 25 nobly nobly RB 37158 157 26 enamoured enamour VBD 37158 157 27 of of IN 37158 157 28 a a DT 37158 157 29 very very RB 37158 157 30 high high JJ 37158 157 31 ideal ideal NN 37158 157 32 , , , 37158 157 33 deny deny VB 37158 157 34 to to IN 37158 157 35 men man NNS 37158 157 36 the the DT 37158 157 37 right right NN 37158 157 38 of of IN 37158 157 39 inflicting inflict VBG 37158 157 40 suffering suffering NN 37158 157 41 , , , 37158 157 42 or or CC 37158 157 43 even even RB 37158 157 44 death death NN 37158 157 45 , , , 37158 157 46 upon upon IN 37158 157 47 animals animal NNS 37158 157 48 ? ? . 37158 158 1 There there EX 37158 158 2 is be VBZ 37158 158 3 not not RB 37158 158 4 a a DT 37158 158 5 more more RBR 37158 158 6 generous generous JJ 37158 158 7 thought thought NN 37158 158 8 than than IN 37158 158 9 this this DT 37158 158 10 . . . 37158 159 1 Without without IN 37158 159 2 doubt doubt NN 37158 159 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 159 4 is be VBZ 37158 159 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 159 6 duty duty NN 37158 159 7 to to TO 37158 159 8 have have VB 37158 159 9 sympathy sympathy NN 37158 159 10 for for IN 37158 159 11 , , , 37158 159 12 and and CC 37158 159 13 to to TO 37158 159 14 abstain abstain VB 37158 159 15 from from IN 37158 159 16 indifference indifference NN 37158 159 17 and and CC 37158 159 18 cruelty cruelty VB 37158 159 19 in in IN 37158 159 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 159 21 dealings dealing NNS 37158 159 22 with with IN 37158 159 23 all all DT 37158 159 24 living living NN 37158 159 25 creatures creature NNS 37158 159 26 : : : 37158 159 27 might may MD 37158 159 28 does do VBZ 37158 159 29 not not RB 37158 159 30 constitute constitute VB 37158 159 31 right right RB 37158 159 32 . . . 37158 160 1 Man man NN 37158 160 2 is be VBZ 37158 160 3 stronger strong JJR 37158 160 4 than than IN 37158 160 5 the the DT 37158 160 6 animal animal NN 37158 160 7 ; ; : 37158 160 8 but but CC 37158 160 9 this this DT 37158 160 10 superiority superiority NN 37158 160 11 of of IN 37158 160 12 power power NN 37158 160 13 , , , 37158 160 14 this this DT 37158 160 15 might may MD 37158 160 16 , , , 37158 160 17 does do VBZ 37158 160 18 not not RB 37158 160 19 constitute constitute VB 37158 160 20 a a DT 37158 160 21 right right NN 37158 160 22 to to TO 37158 160 23 act act VB 37158 160 24 contrary contrary RB 37158 160 25 to to IN 37158 160 26 moral moral JJ 37158 160 27 obligation obligation NN 37158 160 28 . . . 37158 161 1 Morality morality NN 37158 161 2 does do VBZ 37158 161 3 not not RB 37158 161 4 consist consist VB 37158 161 5 solely solely RB 37158 161 6 of of IN 37158 161 7 duties duty NNS 37158 161 8 towards towards IN 37158 161 9 human human JJ 37158 161 10 beings being NNS 37158 161 11 ; ; : 37158 161 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 161 13 is be VBZ 37158 161 14 more more RBR 37158 161 15 general general JJ 37158 161 16 : : : 37158 161 17 it -PRON- PRP 37158 161 18 extends extend VBZ 37158 161 19 to to IN 37158 161 20 every every DT 37158 161 21 being be VBG 37158 161 22 capable capable JJ 37158 161 23 of of IN 37158 161 24 suffering suffer VBG 37158 161 25 . . . 37158 162 1 The the DT 37158 162 2 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 162 3 is be VBZ 37158 162 4 not not RB 37158 162 5 an an DT 37158 162 6 ignoramus ignoramus NN 37158 162 7 , , , 37158 162 8 neither neither RB 37158 162 9 is be VBZ 37158 162 10 he -PRON- PRP 37158 162 11 a a DT 37158 162 12 barbarian barbarian NN 37158 162 13 ; ; : 37158 162 14 and and CC 37158 162 15 he -PRON- PRP 37158 162 16 has have VBZ 37158 162 17 right right RB 37158 162 18 well well RB 37158 162 19 understood understand VBN 37158 162 20 this this DT 37158 162 21 duty duty NN 37158 162 22 . . . 37158 163 1 Physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 163 2 have have VBP 37158 163 3 concluded conclude VBN 37158 163 4 that that IN 37158 163 5 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 163 6 upon upon IN 37158 163 7 living live VBG 37158 163 8 animals animal NNS 37158 163 9 is be VBZ 37158 163 10 necessary necessary JJ 37158 163 11 , , , 37158 163 12 and and CC 37158 163 13 it -PRON- PRP 37158 163 14 is be VBZ 37158 163 15 the the DT 37158 163 16 many many JJ 37158 163 17 reasons reason NNS 37158 163 18 which which WDT 37158 163 19 have have VBP 37158 163 20 led lead VBN 37158 163 21 them -PRON- PRP 37158 163 22 to to IN 37158 163 23 this this DT 37158 163 24 opinion opinion NN 37158 163 25 which which WDT 37158 163 26 I -PRON- PRP 37158 163 27 propose propose VBP 37158 163 28 to to TO 37158 163 29 set set VB 37158 163 30 forth forth RB 37158 163 31 . . . 37158 164 1 But but CC 37158 164 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 164 3 will will MD 37158 164 4 , , , 37158 164 5 I -PRON- PRP 37158 164 6 hope hope VBP 37158 164 7 , , , 37158 164 8 be be VB 37158 164 9 quite quite RB 37158 164 10 understood understand VBN 37158 164 11 that that IN 37158 164 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 164 13 defence defence NN 37158 164 14 of of IN 37158 164 15 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 164 16 implies imply VBZ 37158 164 17 no no DT 37158 164 18 contempt contempt NN 37158 164 19 , , , 37158 164 20 no no DT 37158 164 21 raillery raillery NN 37158 164 22 , , , 37158 164 23 no no DT 37158 164 24 unfriendly unfriendly JJ 37158 164 25 sentiment sentiment NN 37158 164 26 towards towards IN 37158 164 27 those those DT 37158 164 28 who who WP 37158 164 29 oppose oppose VBP 37158 164 30 it -PRON- PRP 37158 164 31 . . . 37158 165 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37158 165 2 opponents opponent NNS 37158 165 3 are be VBP 37158 165 4 not not RB 37158 165 5 always always RB 37158 165 6 courteous courteous JJ 37158 165 7 or or CC 37158 165 8 loyal loyal JJ 37158 165 9 in in IN 37158 165 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 165 11 polemics polemic NNS 37158 165 12 ; ; : 37158 165 13 but but CC 37158 165 14 that that DT 37158 165 15 is be VBZ 37158 165 16 of of IN 37158 165 17 no no DT 37158 165 18 importance importance NN 37158 165 19 ; ; : 37158 165 20 and and CC 37158 165 21 I -PRON- PRP 37158 165 22 shall shall MD 37158 165 23 reply reply VB 37158 165 24 only only RB 37158 165 25 to to IN 37158 165 26 such such JJ 37158 165 27 objections objection NNS 37158 165 28 as as IN 37158 165 29 are be VBP 37158 165 30 potent potent JJ 37158 165 31 , , , 37158 165 32 able able JJ 37158 165 33 , , , 37158 165 34 and and CC 37158 165 35 rational rational JJ 37158 165 36 . . . 37158 166 1 In in IN 37158 166 2 other other JJ 37158 166 3 words word NNS 37158 166 4 , , , 37158 166 5 I -PRON- PRP 37158 166 6 shall shall MD 37158 166 7 take take VB 37158 166 8 from from IN 37158 166 9 among among IN 37158 166 10 the the DT 37158 166 11 arguments argument NNS 37158 166 12 of of IN 37158 166 13 anti anti NNS 37158 166 14 - - NNS 37158 166 15 vivisectionists vivisectionist VBZ 37158 166 16 those those DT 37158 166 17 only only RB 37158 166 18 which which WDT 37158 166 19 can can MD 37158 166 20 be be VB 37158 166 21 called call VBN 37158 166 22 legitimate legitimate JJ 37158 166 23 , , , 37158 166 24 those those DT 37158 166 25 which which WDT 37158 166 26 deserve deserve VBP 37158 166 27 to to TO 37158 166 28 be be VB 37158 166 29 studied study VBN 37158 166 30 methodically methodically RB 37158 166 31 and and CC 37158 166 32 profoundly profoundly RB 37158 166 33 by by IN 37158 166 34 every every DT 37158 166 35 man man NN 37158 166 36 of of IN 37158 166 37 good good JJ 37158 166 38 faith faith NN 37158 166 39 . . . 37158 167 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 167 2 shall shall MD 37158 167 3 deliberately deliberately RB 37158 167 4 put put VB 37158 167 5 on on RP 37158 167 6 one one CD 37158 167 7 side side NN 37158 167 8 both both DT 37158 167 9 abuse abuse NN 37158 167 10 and and CC 37158 167 11 nonsense nonsense NN 37158 167 12 . . . 37158 168 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 168 2 should should MD 37158 168 3 here here RB 37158 168 4 mention mention VB 37158 168 5 an an DT 37158 168 6 anonymous anonymous JJ 37158 168 7 leaflet leaflet NN 37158 168 8 which which WDT 37158 168 9 has have VBZ 37158 168 10 received receive VBN 37158 168 11 a a DT 37158 168 12 considerable considerable JJ 37158 168 13 amount amount NN 37158 168 14 of of IN 37158 168 15 publicity publicity NN 37158 168 16 in in IN 37158 168 17 England England NNP 37158 168 18 ( ( -LRB- 37158 168 19 " " `` 37158 168 20 How how WRB 37158 168 21 Scientific Scientific NNP 37158 168 22 Cruelty Cruelty NNP 37158 168 23 is be VBZ 37158 168 24 defended defend VBN 37158 168 25 , , , 37158 168 26 " " '' 37158 168 27 London London NNP 37158 168 28 , , , 37158 168 29 1907 1907 CD 37158 168 30 , , , 37158 168 31 4 4 CD 37158 168 32 pp pp NNP 37158 168 33 . . . 37158 168 34 ) ) -RRB- 37158 168 35 . . . 37158 169 1 In in IN 37158 169 2 this this DT 37158 169 3 leaflet leaflet NN 37158 169 4 , , , 37158 169 5 a a DT 37158 169 6 reply reply NN 37158 169 7 is be VBZ 37158 169 8 given give VBN 37158 169 9 to to IN 37158 169 10 an an DT 37158 169 11 article article NN 37158 169 12 which which WDT 37158 169 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 169 14 once once RB 37158 169 15 published publish VBD 37158 169 16 on on IN 37158 169 17 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 169 18 . . . 37158 170 1 Certainly certainly RB 37158 170 2 , , , 37158 170 3 after after IN 37158 170 4 a a DT 37158 170 5 lapse lapse NN 37158 170 6 of of IN 37158 170 7 twenty twenty CD 37158 170 8 - - HYPH 37158 170 9 six six CD 37158 170 10 years year NNS 37158 170 11 , , , 37158 170 12 I -PRON- PRP 37158 170 13 might may MD 37158 170 14 claim claim VB 37158 170 15 the the DT 37158 170 16 right right NN 37158 170 17 to to TO 37158 170 18 abjure abjure VB 37158 170 19 some some DT 37158 170 20 of of IN 37158 170 21 the the DT 37158 170 22 notions notion NNS 37158 170 23 of of IN 37158 170 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 170 25 youth youth NN 37158 170 26 . . . 37158 171 1 Taken take VBN 37158 171 2 as as IN 37158 171 3 a a DT 37158 171 4 whole whole NN 37158 171 5 , , , 37158 171 6 however however RB 37158 171 7 , , , 37158 171 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 171 9 ideas idea NNS 37158 171 10 concerning concern VBG 37158 171 11 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 171 12 have have VBP 37158 171 13 changed change VBN 37158 171 14 but but CC 37158 171 15 little little JJ 37158 171 16 , , , 37158 171 17 and and CC 37158 171 18 I -PRON- PRP 37158 171 19 still still RB 37158 171 20 consider consider VBP 37158 171 21 it -PRON- PRP 37158 171 22 to to TO 37158 171 23 be be VB 37158 171 24 necessary necessary JJ 37158 171 25 . . . 37158 172 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 172 2 of of IN 37158 172 3 course course NN 37158 172 4 recognise recognise NN 37158 172 5 that that IN 37158 172 6 the the DT 37158 172 7 number number NN 37158 172 8 of of IN 37158 172 9 physiological physiological JJ 37158 172 10 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 172 11 , , , 37158 172 12 which which WDT 37158 172 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 172 14 estimated estimate VBD 37158 172 15 at at IN 37158 172 16 thirty thirty CD 37158 172 17 in in IN 37158 172 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 172 19 article article NN 37158 172 20 , , , 37158 172 21 is be VBZ 37158 172 22 for for IN 37158 172 23 present present JJ 37158 172 24 - - HYPH 37158 172 25 day day NN 37158 172 26 purposes purpose NNS 37158 172 27 too too RB 37158 172 28 low low JJ 37158 172 29 . . . 37158 173 1 During during IN 37158 173 2 the the DT 37158 173 3 last last JJ 37158 173 4 twenty twenty CD 37158 173 5 - - HYPH 37158 173 6 six six CD 37158 173 7 years year NNS 37158 173 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 173 9 number number NN 37158 173 10 has have VBZ 37158 173 11 very very RB 37158 173 12 considerably considerably RB 37158 173 13 increased increase VBN 37158 173 14 . . . 37158 174 1 But but CC 37158 174 2 a a DT 37158 174 3 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 174 4 of of IN 37158 174 5 physiology physiology NN 37158 174 6 does do VBZ 37158 174 7 not not RB 37158 174 8 necessarily necessarily RB 37158 174 9 mean mean VB 37158 174 10 a a DT 37158 174 11 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 174 12 of of IN 37158 174 13 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 174 14 . . . 37158 175 1 There there EX 37158 175 2 is be VBZ 37158 175 3 the the DT 37158 175 4 whole whole JJ 37158 175 5 range range NN 37158 175 6 of of IN 37158 175 7 physiological physiological JJ 37158 175 8 chemistry chemistry NN 37158 175 9 , , , 37158 175 10 the the DT 37158 175 11 study study NN 37158 175 12 of of IN 37158 175 13 ferments ferment NNS 37158 175 14 and and CC 37158 175 15 psychological psychological JJ 37158 175 16 physiology physiology NN 37158 175 17 , , , 37158 175 18 not not RB 37158 175 19 one one CD 37158 175 20 of of IN 37158 175 21 which which WDT 37158 175 22 makes make VBZ 37158 175 23 any any DT 37158 175 24 demands demand NNS 37158 175 25 on on IN 37158 175 26 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 175 27 . . . 37158 176 1 Many many JJ 37158 176 2 eminent eminent JJ 37158 176 3 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 176 4 -- -- : 37158 176 5 for for IN 37158 176 6 example example NN 37158 176 7 , , , 37158 176 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 176 9 former former JJ 37158 176 10 master master NN 37158 176 11 , , , 37158 176 12 M. M. NNP 37158 176 13 Marey Marey NNP 37158 176 14 -- -- : 37158 176 15 have have VBP 37158 176 16 performed perform VBN 37158 176 17 very very RB 37158 176 18 little little JJ 37158 176 19 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 176 20 . . . 37158 177 1 Even even RB 37158 177 2 in in IN 37158 177 3 those those DT 37158 177 4 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 177 5 where where WRB 37158 177 6 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 177 7 is be VBZ 37158 177 8 performed perform VBN 37158 177 9 , , , 37158 177 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 177 11 is be VBZ 37158 177 12 not not RB 37158 177 13 practised practise VBN 37158 177 14 every every DT 37158 177 15 day day NN 37158 177 16 , , , 37158 177 17 and and CC 37158 177 18 especially especially RB 37158 177 19 not not RB 37158 177 20 upon upon IN 37158 177 21 dogs dog NNS 37158 177 22 ! ! . 37158 178 1 Far far RB 37158 178 2 from from IN 37158 178 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 178 4 ! ! . 37158 179 1 In in IN 37158 179 2 Paris Paris NNP 37158 179 3 , , , 37158 179 4 for for IN 37158 179 5 example example NN 37158 179 6 , , , 37158 179 7 where where WRB 37158 179 8 every every DT 37158 179 9 dog dog NN 37158 179 10 experimented experiment VBD 37158 179 11 upon upon IN 37158 179 12 is be VBZ 37158 179 13 a a DT 37158 179 14 stray stray JJ 37158 179 15 animal animal NN 37158 179 16 handed hand VBN 37158 179 17 over over RP 37158 179 18 by by IN 37158 179 19 the the DT 37158 179 20 prefecture prefecture NN 37158 179 21 of of IN 37158 179 22 police police NNS 37158 179 23 , , , 37158 179 24 there there EX 37158 179 25 are be VBP 37158 179 26 only only RB 37158 179 27 about about RB 37158 179 28 six six CD 37158 179 29 hundred hundred CD 37158 179 30 dogs dog NNS 37158 179 31 per per IN 37158 179 32 annum annum NN 37158 179 33 thus thus RB 37158 179 34 available available JJ 37158 179 35 for for IN 37158 179 36 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 179 37 . . . 37158 180 1 Now now RB 37158 180 2 the the DT 37158 180 3 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 180 4 in in IN 37158 180 5 Paris Paris NNP 37158 180 6 represent represent VBP 37158 180 7 , , , 37158 180 8 from from IN 37158 180 9 the the DT 37158 180 10 point point NN 37158 180 11 of of IN 37158 180 12 view view NN 37158 180 13 of of IN 37158 180 14 activity activity NN 37158 180 15 , , , 37158 180 16 at at IN 37158 180 17 least least RBS 37158 180 18 half half NN 37158 180 19 of of IN 37158 180 20 all all PDT 37158 180 21 the the DT 37158 180 22 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 180 23 in in IN 37158 180 24 France France NNP 37158 180 25 put put VBD 37158 180 26 together together RB 37158 180 27 . . . 37158 181 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 181 2 is be VBZ 37158 181 3 alleged allege VBN 37158 181 4 that that IN 37158 181 5 Schiff Schiff NNP 37158 181 6 stated state VBD 37158 181 7 to to IN 37158 181 8 Mrs Mrs NNP 37158 181 9 Anna Anna NNP 37158 181 10 Kingsford Kingsford NNP 37158 181 11 that that IN 37158 181 12 he -PRON- PRP 37158 181 13 had have VBD 37158 181 14 experimented experiment VBN 37158 181 15 on on IN 37158 181 16 more more JJR 37158 181 17 than than IN 37158 181 18 14,000 14,000 CD 37158 181 19 dogs dog NNS 37158 181 20 , , , 37158 181 21 that that DT 37158 181 22 is be VBZ 37158 181 23 to to TO 37158 181 24 say say VB 37158 181 25 , , , 37158 181 26 an an DT 37158 181 27 average average NN 37158 181 28 of of IN 37158 181 29 one one CD 37158 181 30 dog dog NN 37158 181 31 a a DT 37158 181 32 day day NN 37158 181 33 for for IN 37158 181 34 fifty fifty CD 37158 181 35 years year NNS 37158 181 36 ! ! . 37158 182 1 This this DT 37158 182 2 is be VBZ 37158 182 3 obviously obviously RB 37158 182 4 an an DT 37158 182 5 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37158 182 6 , , , 37158 182 7 though though IN 37158 182 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 182 9 is be VBZ 37158 182 10 difficult difficult JJ 37158 182 11 to to TO 37158 182 12 trace trace VB 37158 182 13 now now RB 37158 182 14 who who WP 37158 182 15 was be VBD 37158 182 16 responsible responsible JJ 37158 182 17 for for IN 37158 182 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 182 19 . . . 37158 183 1 Finally finally RB 37158 183 2 , , , 37158 183 3 the the DT 37158 183 4 remaining remain VBG 37158 183 5 objections objection NNS 37158 183 6 of of IN 37158 183 7 the the DT 37158 183 8 anonymous anonymous JJ 37158 183 9 author author NN 37158 183 10 in in IN 37158 183 11 question question NN 37158 183 12 amount amount NN 37158 183 13 only only RB 37158 183 14 to to IN 37158 183 15 this this DT 37158 183 16 : : : 37158 183 17 The the DT 37158 183 18 author author NN 37158 183 19 believes believe VBZ 37158 183 20 that that IN 37158 183 21 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 183 22 work work VBP 37158 183 23 for for IN 37158 183 24 money money NN 37158 183 25 and and CC 37158 183 26 renown renown NN 37158 183 27 , , , 37158 183 28 and and CC 37158 183 29 not not RB 37158 183 30 at at RB 37158 183 31 all all RB 37158 183 32 for for IN 37158 183 33 the the DT 37158 183 34 sake sake NN 37158 183 35 of of IN 37158 183 36 humanity humanity NN 37158 183 37 ( ( -LRB- 37158 183 38 ! ! . 37158 183 39 ! ! . 37158 183 40 ) ) -RRB- 37158 183 41 . . . 37158 184 1 Also also RB 37158 184 2 , , , 37158 184 3 that that IN 37158 184 4 young young JJ 37158 184 5 men man NNS 37158 184 6 are be VBP 37158 184 7 made make VBN 37158 184 8 cruel cruel JJ 37158 184 9 by by IN 37158 184 10 the the DT 37158 184 11 sight sight NN 37158 184 12 of of IN 37158 184 13 cruel cruel JJ 37158 184 14 experiments experiment NNS 37158 184 15 . . . 37158 185 1 But but CC 37158 185 2 the the DT 37158 185 3 author author NN 37158 185 4 simply simply RB 37158 185 5 forgets forget VBZ 37158 185 6 this this DT 37158 185 7 fact fact NN 37158 185 8 , , , 37158 185 9 that that IN 37158 185 10 there there EX 37158 185 11 is be VBZ 37158 185 12 not not RB 37158 185 13 at at IN 37158 185 14 this this DT 37158 185 15 present present JJ 37158 185 16 moment moment NN 37158 185 17 one one CD 37158 185 18 single single JJ 37158 185 19 _ _ NNP 37158 185 20 honourable honourable JJ 37158 185 21 _ _ NNP 37158 185 22 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 185 23 who who WP 37158 185 24 would would MD 37158 185 25 consent consent VB 37158 185 26 to to TO 37158 185 27 perform perform VB 37158 185 28 long long JJ 37158 185 29 and and CC 37158 185 30 distressing distress VBG 37158 185 31 experiments experiment NNS 37158 185 32 on on IN 37158 185 33 an an DT 37158 185 34 animal animal NN 37158 185 35 not not RB 37158 185 36 under under IN 37158 185 37 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 185 38 . . . 37158 186 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 186 2 hold hold VBP 37158 186 3 no no DT 37158 186 4 brief brief NN 37158 186 5 for for IN 37158 186 6 those those DT 37158 186 7 who who WP 37158 186 8 do do VBP 37158 186 9 otherwise otherwise RB 37158 186 10 , , , 37158 186 11 and and CC 37158 186 12 I -PRON- PRP 37158 186 13 disapprove disapprove VBP 37158 186 14 energetically energetically RB 37158 186 15 of of IN 37158 186 16 the the DT 37158 186 17 use use NN 37158 186 18 of of IN 37158 186 19 _ _ NNP 37158 186 20 curare curare NN 37158 186 21 _ _ NNP 37158 186 22 . . . 37158 187 1 The the DT 37158 187 2 conclusions conclusion NNS 37158 187 3 of of IN 37158 187 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 187 5 anonymous anonymous JJ 37158 187 6 critic critic NN 37158 187 7 therefore therefore RB 37158 187 8 fall fall VBP 37158 187 9 to to IN 37158 187 10 the the DT 37158 187 11 ground ground NN 37158 187 12 . . . 37158 188 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 188 2 confess confess VBP 37158 188 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 188 4 do do VBP 37158 188 5 not not RB 37158 188 6 understand understand VB 37158 188 7 the the DT 37158 188 8 statement statement NN 37158 188 9 that that IN 37158 188 10 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 188 11 on on IN 37158 188 12 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 188 13 and and CC 37158 188 14 other other JJ 37158 188 15 animals animal NNS 37158 188 16 is be VBZ 37158 188 17 of of IN 37158 188 18 no no DT 37158 188 19 use use NN 37158 188 20 to to IN 37158 188 21 humanity humanity NN 37158 188 22 ; ; : 37158 188 23 and and CC 37158 188 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 188 25 critic critic NN 37158 188 26 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37158 188 27 from from IN 37158 188 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 188 29 point point NN 37158 188 30 of of IN 37158 188 31 view view NN 37158 188 32 has have VBZ 37158 188 33 selected select VBN 37158 188 34 Claude Claude NNP 37158 188 35 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 188 36 's 's POS 37158 188 37 experiments experiment NNS 37158 188 38 as as IN 37158 188 39 an an DT 37158 188 40 example example NN 37158 188 41 of of IN 37158 188 42 uselessness uselessness NN 37158 188 43 . . . 37158 189 1 Does do VBZ 37158 189 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 189 3 not not RB 37158 189 4 know know VB 37158 189 5 that that IN 37158 189 6 Claude Claude NNP 37158 189 7 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 189 8 discovered discover VBD 37158 189 9 the the DT 37158 189 10 presence presence NN 37158 189 11 of of IN 37158 189 12 sugar sugar NN 37158 189 13 in in IN 37158 189 14 the the DT 37158 189 15 blood blood NN 37158 189 16 , , , 37158 189 17 of of IN 37158 189 18 glycogen glycogen NN 37158 189 19 in in IN 37158 189 20 the the DT 37158 189 21 liver liver NN 37158 189 22 , , , 37158 189 23 of of IN 37158 189 24 diabetes diabete NNS 37158 189 25 produced produce VBN 37158 189 26 through through IN 37158 189 27 nervous nervous JJ 37158 189 28 action action NN 37158 189 29 , , , 37158 189 30 of of IN 37158 189 31 the the DT 37158 189 32 action action NN 37158 189 33 of of IN 37158 189 34 oxygen oxygen NN 37158 189 35 and and CC 37158 189 36 of of IN 37158 189 37 carbonic carbonic JJ 37158 189 38 oxide oxide NN 37158 189 39 on on IN 37158 189 40 the the DT 37158 189 41 red red JJ 37158 189 42 blood blood NN 37158 189 43 corpuscles corpuscle NNS 37158 189 44 , , , 37158 189 45 the the DT 37158 189 46 action action NN 37158 189 47 of of IN 37158 189 48 the the DT 37158 189 49 pancreatic pancreatic JJ 37158 189 50 juice juice NN 37158 189 51 on on IN 37158 189 52 fat fat NN 37158 189 53 , , , 37158 189 54 the the DT 37158 189 55 part part NN 37158 189 56 played play VBN 37158 189 57 by by IN 37158 189 58 the the DT 37158 189 59 pneumogastric pneumogastric JJ 37158 189 60 nerve nerve NN 37158 189 61 in in IN 37158 189 62 the the DT 37158 189 63 innervation innervation NN 37158 189 64 of of IN 37158 189 65 the the DT 37158 189 66 heart heart NN 37158 189 67 ? ? . 37158 190 1 These these DT 37158 190 2 discoveries discovery NNS 37158 190 3 not not RB 37158 190 4 only only RB 37158 190 5 rejuvenated rejuvenated JJ 37158 190 6 physiology physiology NN 37158 190 7 , , , 37158 190 8 but but CC 37158 190 9 exercise exercise VB 37158 190 10 a a DT 37158 190 11 permanent permanent JJ 37158 190 12 influence influence NN 37158 190 13 over over IN 37158 190 14 the the DT 37158 190 15 whole whole NN 37158 190 16 of of IN 37158 190 17 medicine medicine NN 37158 190 18 , , , 37158 190 19 and and CC 37158 190 20 over over IN 37158 190 21 the the DT 37158 190 22 entire entire JJ 37158 190 23 realm realm NN 37158 190 24 of of IN 37158 190 25 therapeutics therapeutic NNS 37158 190 26 ! ! . 37158 191 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 191 2 refuse refuse VBP 37158 191 3 to to TO 37158 191 4 accept accept VB 37158 191 5 the the DT 37158 191 6 antiquated antiquated JJ 37158 191 7 conception conception NN 37158 191 8 of of IN 37158 191 9 an an DT 37158 191 10 empirical empirical JJ 37158 191 11 medicine medicine NN 37158 191 12 which which WDT 37158 191 13 does do VBZ 37158 191 14 not not RB 37158 191 15 aim aim VB 37158 191 16 at at IN 37158 191 17 discovering discover VBG 37158 191 18 the the DT 37158 191 19 truth truth NN 37158 191 20 ; ; : 37158 191 21 which which WDT 37158 191 22 thinks think VBZ 37158 191 23 solely solely RB 37158 191 24 of of IN 37158 191 25 clumsy clumsy JJ 37158 191 26 practical practical JJ 37158 191 27 application application NN 37158 191 28 ; ; : 37158 191 29 and and CC 37158 191 30 which which WDT 37158 191 31 regards regard VBZ 37158 191 32 as as IN 37158 191 33 useful useful JJ 37158 191 34 only only RB 37158 191 35 that that DT 37158 191 36 which which WDT 37158 191 37 leads lead VBZ 37158 191 38 immediately immediately RB 37158 191 39 and and CC 37158 191 40 directly directly RB 37158 191 41 to to IN 37158 191 42 the the DT 37158 191 43 cure cure NN 37158 191 44 of of IN 37158 191 45 a a DT 37158 191 46 given give VBN 37158 191 47 illness illness NN 37158 191 48 . . . 37158 192 1 All all DT 37158 192 2 truth truth NN 37158 192 3 is be VBZ 37158 192 4 useful useful JJ 37158 192 5 ; ; : 37158 192 6 all all DT 37158 192 7 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 192 8 is be VBZ 37158 192 9 baneful baneful JJ 37158 192 10 ; ; : 37158 192 11 and and CC 37158 192 12 the the DT 37158 192 13 sole sole JJ 37158 192 14 limit limit NN 37158 192 15 to to IN 37158 192 16 man man NN 37158 192 17 's 's POS 37158 192 18 power power NN 37158 192 19 lies lie VBZ 37158 192 20 in in IN 37158 192 21 the the DT 37158 192 22 extent extent NN 37158 192 23 of of IN 37158 192 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 192 25 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 192 26 . . . 37158 193 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 193 2 must must MD 37158 193 3 forego forego VB 37158 193 4 discussion discussion NN 37158 193 5 with with IN 37158 193 6 those those DT 37158 193 7 who who WP 37158 193 8 can can MD 37158 193 9 not not RB 37158 193 10 understand understand VB 37158 193 11 this this DT 37158 193 12 fundamental fundamental JJ 37158 193 13 notion notion NN 37158 193 14 . . . 37158 194 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 194 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 194 3 THE the DT 37158 194 4 NECESSARY necessary NN 37158 194 5 LIMITS limit NNS 37158 194 6 OF of IN 37158 194 7 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 194 8 First first RB 37158 194 9 of of IN 37158 194 10 all all DT 37158 194 11 I -PRON- PRP 37158 194 12 declare declare VBP 37158 194 13 , , , 37158 194 14 without without IN 37158 194 15 fear fear NN 37158 194 16 of of IN 37158 194 17 being be VBG 37158 194 18 contradicted contradict VBN 37158 194 19 by by IN 37158 194 20 any any DT 37158 194 21 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 194 22 , , , 37158 194 23 that that IN 37158 194 24 the the DT 37158 194 25 past past NN 37158 194 26 has have VBZ 37158 194 27 witnessed witness VBN 37158 194 28 much much JJ 37158 194 29 excess excess NN 37158 194 30 , , , 37158 194 31 almost almost RB 37158 194 32 guilty guilty JJ 37158 194 33 excess excess NN 37158 194 34 , , , 37158 194 35 and and CC 37158 194 36 that that IN 37158 194 37 at at IN 37158 194 38 the the DT 37158 194 39 present present JJ 37158 194 40 time time NN 37158 194 41 excess excess NN 37158 194 42 might may MD 37158 194 43 still still RB 37158 194 44 be be VB 37158 194 45 pointed point VBN 37158 194 46 out out RP 37158 194 47 . . . 37158 195 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 195 2 quite quite RB 37158 195 3 believe believe VBP 37158 195 4 that that IN 37158 195 5 , , , 37158 195 6 even even RB 37158 195 7 to to IN 37158 195 8 - - HYPH 37158 195 9 day day NN 37158 195 10 , , , 37158 195 11 here here RB 37158 195 12 and and CC 37158 195 13 there there RB 37158 195 14 in in IN 37158 195 15 the the DT 37158 195 16 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 195 17 of of IN 37158 195 18 physiology physiology NN 37158 195 19 , , , 37158 195 20 young young JJ 37158 195 21 men man NNS 37158 195 22 may may MD 37158 195 23 be be VB 37158 195 24 found find VBN 37158 195 25 who who WP 37158 195 26 are be VBP 37158 195 27 no no RB 37158 195 28 doubt doubt RB 37158 195 29 enamoured enamour VBN 37158 195 30 of of IN 37158 195 31 science science NN 37158 195 32 , , , 37158 195 33 but but CC 37158 195 34 who who WP 37158 195 35 have have VBP 37158 195 36 not not RB 37158 195 37 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37158 195 38 reflected reflect VBN 37158 195 39 on on IN 37158 195 40 the the DT 37158 195 41 nature nature NN 37158 195 42 of of IN 37158 195 43 pain pain NN 37158 195 44 , , , 37158 195 45 and and CC 37158 195 46 consequently consequently RB 37158 195 47 , , , 37158 195 48 through through IN 37158 195 49 lack lack NN 37158 195 50 of of IN 37158 195 51 sympathy sympathy NN 37158 195 52 , , , 37158 195 53 are be VBP 37158 195 54 callous callous JJ 37158 195 55 and and CC 37158 195 56 indifferent indifferent JJ 37158 195 57 about about IN 37158 195 58 inflicting inflict VBG 37158 195 59 useless useless JJ 37158 195 60 , , , 37158 195 61 or or CC 37158 195 62 almost almost RB 37158 195 63 useless useless JJ 37158 195 64 , , , 37158 195 65 tortures torture NNS 37158 195 66 on on IN 37158 195 67 innocent innocent JJ 37158 195 68 animals animal NNS 37158 195 69 . . . 37158 196 1 On on IN 37158 196 2 this this DT 37158 196 3 point point NN 37158 196 4 I -PRON- PRP 37158 196 5 might may MD 37158 196 6 mention mention VB 37158 196 7 numerous numerous JJ 37158 196 8 facts fact NNS 37158 196 9 which which WDT 37158 196 10 are be VBP 37158 196 11 extremely extremely RB 37158 196 12 painful painful JJ 37158 196 13 to to TO 37158 196 14 relate relate VB 37158 196 15 , , , 37158 196 16 but but CC 37158 196 17 which which WDT 37158 196 18 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 196 19 we -PRON- PRP 37158 196 20 must must MD 37158 196 21 have have VB 37158 196 22 the the DT 37158 196 23 courage courage NN 37158 196 24 to to TO 37158 196 25 acknowledge acknowledge VB 37158 196 26 and and CC 37158 196 27 denounce denounce VB 37158 196 28 . . . 37158 197 1 To to TO 37158 197 2 quote quote VB 37158 197 3 only only RB 37158 197 4 one one CD 37158 197 5 instance instance NN 37158 197 6 , , , 37158 197 7 a a DT 37158 197 8 most most RBS 37158 197 9 abominable abominable JJ 37158 197 10 one one NN 37158 197 11 , , , 37158 197 12 I -PRON- PRP 37158 197 13 will will MD 37158 197 14 mention mention VB 37158 197 15 the the DT 37158 197 16 following following NN 37158 197 17 , , , 37158 197 18 which which WDT 37158 197 19 is be VBZ 37158 197 20 old old JJ 37158 197 21 , , , 37158 197 22 dating date VBG 37158 197 23 back back RP 37158 197 24 about about IN 37158 197 25 forty forty CD 37158 197 26 years year NNS 37158 197 27 . . . 37158 198 1 In in IN 37158 198 2 the the DT 37158 198 3 veterinary veterinary JJ 37158 198 4 schools school NNS 37158 198 5 , , , 37158 198 6 surgical surgical JJ 37158 198 7 studies study NNS 37158 198 8 , , , 37158 198 9 at at IN 37158 198 10 that that DT 37158 198 11 time time NN 37158 198 12 , , , 37158 198 13 were be VBD 37158 198 14 not not RB 37158 198 15 made make VBN 37158 198 16 on on IN 37158 198 17 the the DT 37158 198 18 dead dead JJ 37158 198 19 carcase carcase NN 37158 198 20 , , , 37158 198 21 but but CC 37158 198 22 on on IN 37158 198 23 the the DT 37158 198 24 living living NN 37158 198 25 animal animal NN 37158 198 26 ; ; : 37158 198 27 so so CC 37158 198 28 that that IN 37158 198 29 the the DT 37158 198 30 wretched wretched JJ 37158 198 31 victim victim NN 37158 198 32 , , , 37158 198 33 generally generally RB 37158 198 34 a a DT 37158 198 35 horse horse NN 37158 198 36 , , , 37158 198 37 served serve VBD 37158 198 38 as as IN 37158 198 39 a a DT 37158 198 40 subject subject NN 37158 198 41 , , , 37158 198 42 while while IN 37158 198 43 yet yet RB 37158 198 44 alive alive JJ 37158 198 45 , , , 37158 198 46 for for IN 37158 198 47 all all PDT 37158 198 48 the the DT 37158 198 49 operations operation NNS 37158 198 50 which which WDT 37158 198 51 the the DT 37158 198 52 veterinary veterinary JJ 37158 198 53 surgeon surgeon NN 37158 198 54 is be VBZ 37158 198 55 called call VBN 37158 198 56 upon upon IN 37158 198 57 to to TO 37158 198 58 perform perform VB 37158 198 59 . . . 37158 199 1 The the DT 37158 199 2 detestable detestable JJ 37158 199 3 argument argument NN 37158 199 4 given give VBN 37158 199 5 at at IN 37158 199 6 that that DT 37158 199 7 time time NN 37158 199 8 to to TO 37158 199 9 qualify qualify VB 37158 199 10 this this DT 37158 199 11 barbarism barbarism NN 37158 199 12 was be VBD 37158 199 13 that that IN 37158 199 14 the the DT 37158 199 15 veterinary veterinary JJ 37158 199 16 surgeon surgeon NN 37158 199 17 should should MD 37158 199 18 be be VB 37158 199 19 familiar familiar JJ 37158 199 20 with with IN 37158 199 21 the the DT 37158 199 22 reactions reaction NNS 37158 199 23 of of IN 37158 199 24 a a DT 37158 199 25 living live VBG 37158 199 26 animal animal NN 37158 199 27 , , , 37158 199 28 and and CC 37158 199 29 that that IN 37158 199 30 , , , 37158 199 31 as as IN 37158 199 32 a a DT 37158 199 33 guarantee guarantee NN 37158 199 34 of of IN 37158 199 35 being be VBG 37158 199 36 able able JJ 37158 199 37 to to TO 37158 199 38 perform perform VB 37158 199 39 an an DT 37158 199 40 operation operation NN 37158 199 41 on on IN 37158 199 42 a a DT 37158 199 43 diseased diseased JJ 37158 199 44 horse horse NN 37158 199 45 , , , 37158 199 46 he -PRON- PRP 37158 199 47 should should MD 37158 199 48 have have VB 37158 199 49 already already RB 37158 199 50 practised practise VBN 37158 199 51 the the DT 37158 199 52 same same JJ 37158 199 53 operation operation NN 37158 199 54 several several JJ 37158 199 55 times time NNS 37158 199 56 , , , 37158 199 57 not not RB 37158 199 58 on on IN 37158 199 59 the the DT 37158 199 60 dead dead JJ 37158 199 61 body body NN 37158 199 62 , , , 37158 199 63 but but CC 37158 199 64 on on IN 37158 199 65 a a DT 37158 199 66 horse horse NN 37158 199 67 full full JJ 37158 199 68 of of IN 37158 199 69 life life NN 37158 199 70 and and CC 37158 199 71 vigour vigour NN 37158 199 72 , , , 37158 199 73 able able JJ 37158 199 74 to to TO 37158 199 75 defend defend VB 37158 199 76 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 199 77 , , , 37158 199 78 and and CC 37158 199 79 obliged oblige VBD 37158 199 80 therefore therefore RB 37158 199 81 to to TO 37158 199 82 be be VB 37158 199 83 held hold VBN 37158 199 84 down down RP 37158 199 85 motionless motionless RB 37158 199 86 by by IN 37158 199 87 special special JJ 37158 199 88 processes process NNS 37158 199 89 . . . 37158 200 1 But but CC 37158 200 2 this this DT 37158 200 3 is be VBZ 37158 200 4 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 200 5 a a DT 37158 200 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 200 7 justification justification NN 37158 200 8 . . . 37158 201 1 But but CC 37158 201 2 happily happily RB 37158 201 3 such such JJ 37158 201 4 things thing NNS 37158 201 5 no no RB 37158 201 6 longer longer RB 37158 201 7 exist exist VBP 37158 201 8 ; ; : 37158 201 9 public public JJ 37158 201 10 opinion opinion NN 37158 201 11 , , , 37158 201 12 stimulated stimulate VBD 37158 201 13 no no DT 37158 201 14 doubt doubt NN 37158 201 15 by by IN 37158 201 16 the the DT 37158 201 17 writings writing NNS 37158 201 18 of of IN 37158 201 19 anti anti JJ 37158 201 20 - - NNS 37158 201 21 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 201 22 , , , 37158 201 23 has have VBZ 37158 201 24 altered alter VBN 37158 201 25 the the DT 37158 201 26 customs custom NNS 37158 201 27 of of IN 37158 201 28 veterinary veterinary JJ 37158 201 29 experimentalists experimentalist NNS 37158 201 30 so so RB 37158 201 31 well well RB 37158 201 32 that that IN 37158 201 33 in in IN 37158 201 34 no no DT 37158 201 35 veterinary veterinary JJ 37158 201 36 school school NN 37158 201 37 to to NN 37158 201 38 - - HYPH 37158 201 39 day day NN 37158 201 40 are be VBP 37158 201 41 surgical surgical JJ 37158 201 42 exercises exercise NNS 37158 201 43 now now RB 37158 201 44 performed perform VBN 37158 201 45 on on IN 37158 201 46 other other JJ 37158 201 47 than than IN 37158 201 48 the the DT 37158 201 49 dead dead JJ 37158 201 50 body body NN 37158 201 51 . . . 37158 202 1 Thus thus RB 37158 202 2 , , , 37158 202 3 as as RB 37158 202 4 far far RB 37158 202 5 as as IN 37158 202 6 surgery surgery NN 37158 202 7 is be VBZ 37158 202 8 concerned concern VBN 37158 202 9 , , , 37158 202 10 unquestionably unquestionably RB 37158 202 11 all all DT 37158 202 12 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 202 13 should should MD 37158 202 14 rigorously rigorously RB 37158 202 15 be be VB 37158 202 16 proscribed proscribe VBN 37158 202 17 . . . 37158 203 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 203 2 will will MD 37158 203 3 discuss discuss VB 37158 203 4 later later RB 37158 203 5 the the DT 37158 203 6 point point NN 37158 203 7 as as IN 37158 203 8 to to IN 37158 203 9 whether whether IN 37158 203 10 this this DT 37158 203 11 interdiction interdiction NN 37158 203 12 should should MD 37158 203 13 be be VB 37158 203 14 moral moral JJ 37158 203 15 -- -- : 37158 203 16 that that RB 37158 203 17 is is RB 37158 203 18 , , , 37158 203 19 recommended recommend VBN 37158 203 20 as as IN 37158 203 21 a a DT 37158 203 22 precept precept NN 37158 203 23 of of IN 37158 203 24 humanity humanity NN 37158 203 25 , , , 37158 203 26 or or CC 37158 203 27 enforced enforce VBN 37158 203 28 by by IN 37158 203 29 law law NN 37158 203 30 under under IN 37158 203 31 penalty penalty NN 37158 203 32 of of IN 37158 203 33 imprisonment imprisonment NN 37158 203 34 or or CC 37158 203 35 fine fine JJ 37158 203 36 . . . 37158 204 1 For for IN 37158 204 2 the the DT 37158 204 3 moment moment NN 37158 204 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 204 5 will will MD 37158 204 6 suffice suffice VB 37158 204 7 to to TO 37158 204 8 establish establish VB 37158 204 9 the the DT 37158 204 10 point point NN 37158 204 11 that that IN 37158 204 12 no no DT 37158 204 13 living live VBG 37158 204 14 animal animal NN 37158 204 15 should should MD 37158 204 16 serve serve VB 37158 204 17 for for IN 37158 204 18 surgical surgical JJ 37158 204 19 exercises exercise NNS 37158 204 20 . . . 37158 205 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 205 2 will will MD 37158 205 3 go go VB 37158 205 4 even even RB 37158 205 5 further far RBR 37158 205 6 , , , 37158 205 7 and and CC 37158 205 8 on on IN 37158 205 9 this this DT 37158 205 10 point point NN 37158 205 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 205 12 opinion opinion NN 37158 205 13 will will MD 37158 205 14 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 205 15 clash clash VB 37158 205 16 with with IN 37158 205 17 that that DT 37158 205 18 of of IN 37158 205 19 some some DT 37158 205 20 of of IN 37158 205 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 205 22 friends friend NNS 37158 205 23 and and CC 37158 205 24 colleagues colleague NNS 37158 205 25 : : : 37158 205 26 I -PRON- PRP 37158 205 27 maintain maintain VBP 37158 205 28 that that IN 37158 205 29 no no DT 37158 205 30 experimental experimental JJ 37158 205 31 physiological physiological JJ 37158 205 32 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37158 205 33 which which WDT 37158 205 34 involve involve VBP 37158 205 35 suffering suffer VBG 37158 205 36 should should MD 37158 205 37 ever ever RB 37158 205 38 be be VB 37158 205 39 performed perform VBN 37158 205 40 . . . 37158 206 1 Much much JJ 37158 206 2 abuse abuse NN 37158 206 3 has have VBZ 37158 206 4 taken take VBN 37158 206 5 place place NN 37158 206 6 in in IN 37158 206 7 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 206 8 for for IN 37158 206 9 instruction instruction NN 37158 206 10 , , , 37158 206 11 which which WDT 37158 206 12 is be VBZ 37158 206 13 a a DT 37158 206 14 very very RB 37158 206 15 different different JJ 37158 206 16 thing thing NN 37158 206 17 from from IN 37158 206 18 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 206 19 for for IN 37158 206 20 investigation investigation NN 37158 206 21 . . . 37158 207 1 Important important JJ 37158 207 2 as as IN 37158 207 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 207 4 may may MD 37158 207 5 be be VB 37158 207 6 to to TO 37158 207 7 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37158 207 8 physiological physiological JJ 37158 207 9 facts fact NNS 37158 207 10 to to IN 37158 207 11 students student NNS 37158 207 12 , , , 37158 207 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 207 14 do do VBP 37158 207 15 not not RB 37158 207 16 consider consider VB 37158 207 17 that that IN 37158 207 18 this this DT 37158 207 19 importance importance NN 37158 207 20 is be VBZ 37158 207 21 greater great JJR 37158 207 22 than than IN 37158 207 23 the the DT 37158 207 24 suffering suffering NN 37158 207 25 of of IN 37158 207 26 an an DT 37158 207 27 animal animal NN 37158 207 28 . . . 37158 208 1 And and CC 37158 208 2 here here RB 37158 208 3 again again RB 37158 208 4 I -PRON- PRP 37158 208 5 will will MD 37158 208 6 take take VB 37158 208 7 an an DT 37158 208 8 example example NN 37158 208 9 , , , 37158 208 10 that that DT 37158 208 11 of of IN 37158 208 12 the the DT 37158 208 13 distinction distinction NN 37158 208 14 between between IN 37158 208 15 the the DT 37158 208 16 motor motor NN 37158 208 17 nerves nerve NNS 37158 208 18 and and CC 37158 208 19 the the DT 37158 208 20 sensory sensory JJ 37158 208 21 nerves nerve NNS 37158 208 22 . . . 37158 209 1 Magendie Magendie NNP 37158 209 2 , , , 37158 209 3 in in IN 37158 209 4 1811 1811 CD 37158 209 5 , , , 37158 209 6 following follow VBG 37158 209 7 up up RP 37158 209 8 an an DT 37158 209 9 idea idea NN 37158 209 10 somewhat somewhat RB 37158 209 11 hesitatingly hesitatingly RB 37158 209 12 put put VBN 37158 209 13 forth forth RP 37158 209 14 by by IN 37158 209 15 Charles Charles NNP 37158 209 16 Bell Bell NNP 37158 209 17 a a DT 37158 209 18 few few JJ 37158 209 19 years year NNS 37158 209 20 previously previously RB 37158 209 21 , , , 37158 209 22 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 37158 209 23 that that IN 37158 209 24 the the DT 37158 209 25 anterior anterior JJ 37158 209 26 nerve nerve NN 37158 209 27 roots root NNS 37158 209 28 , , , 37158 209 29 starting start VBG 37158 209 30 from from IN 37158 209 31 the the DT 37158 209 32 spinal spinal JJ 37158 209 33 cord cord NN 37158 209 34 , , , 37158 209 35 give give VBP 37158 209 36 movement movement NN 37158 209 37 to to IN 37158 209 38 the the DT 37158 209 39 muscles muscle NNS 37158 209 40 , , , 37158 209 41 whilst whilst IN 37158 209 42 the the DT 37158 209 43 posterior posterior NN 37158 209 44 roots root NNS 37158 209 45 are be VBP 37158 209 46 exclusively exclusively RB 37158 209 47 devoted devote VBN 37158 209 48 to to IN 37158 209 49 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 209 50 ; ; : 37158 209 51 so so IN 37158 209 52 that that IN 37158 209 53 there there EX 37158 209 54 are be VBP 37158 209 55 anterior anterior JJ 37158 209 56 motor motor NN 37158 209 57 nerves nerve NNS 37158 209 58 and and CC 37158 209 59 posterior posterior JJ 37158 209 60 sensory sensory JJ 37158 209 61 nerves nerve NNS 37158 209 62 . . . 37158 210 1 In in IN 37158 210 2 order order NN 37158 210 3 to to TO 37158 210 4 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37158 210 5 this this DT 37158 210 6 , , , 37158 210 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 210 8 is be VBZ 37158 210 9 evidently evidently RB 37158 210 10 necessary necessary JJ 37158 210 11 to to TO 37158 210 12 operate operate VB 37158 210 13 on on IN 37158 210 14 a a DT 37158 210 15 living living JJ 37158 210 16 and and CC 37158 210 17 sensitive sensitive JJ 37158 210 18 animal animal NN 37158 210 19 . . . 37158 211 1 The the DT 37158 211 2 discovery discovery NN 37158 211 3 was be VBD 37158 211 4 confirmed confirm VBN 37158 211 5 by by IN 37158 211 6 several several JJ 37158 211 7 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 211 8 between between IN 37158 211 9 1830 1830 CD 37158 211 10 and and CC 37158 211 11 1850 1850 CD 37158 211 12 ; ; : 37158 211 13 and and CC 37158 211 14 I -PRON- PRP 37158 211 15 do do VBP 37158 211 16 not not RB 37158 211 17 think think VB 37158 211 18 we -PRON- PRP 37158 211 19 have have VBP 37158 211 20 the the DT 37158 211 21 right right NN 37158 211 22 to to TO 37158 211 23 repeat repeat VB 37158 211 24 this this DT 37158 211 25 cruel cruel JJ 37158 211 26 experiment experiment NN 37158 211 27 for for IN 37158 211 28 the the DT 37158 211 29 sake sake NN 37158 211 30 of of IN 37158 211 31 the the DT 37158 211 32 instruction instruction NN 37158 211 33 of of IN 37158 211 34 students student NNS 37158 211 35 . . . 37158 212 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 212 2 is be VBZ 37158 212 3 not not RB 37158 212 4 only only RB 37158 212 5 cruel cruel JJ 37158 212 6 , , , 37158 212 7 but but CC 37158 212 8 also also RB 37158 212 9 useless useless JJ 37158 212 10 , , , 37158 212 11 for for IN 37158 212 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 212 13 consists consist VBZ 37158 212 14 in in IN 37158 212 15 laying lay VBG 37158 212 16 bare bare NNP 37158 212 17 the the DT 37158 212 18 anterior anterior NNP 37158 212 19 and and CC 37158 212 20 posterior posterior NN 37158 212 21 nerve nerve NN 37158 212 22 - - HYPH 37158 212 23 fibres fibre NNS 37158 212 24 of of IN 37158 212 25 the the DT 37158 212 26 spinal spinal JJ 37158 212 27 cord cord NN 37158 212 28 , , , 37158 212 29 with with IN 37158 212 30 the the DT 37158 212 31 sole sole JJ 37158 212 32 object object NN 37158 212 33 of of IN 37158 212 34 allowing allow VBG 37158 212 35 students student NNS 37158 212 36 to to TO 37158 212 37 see see VB 37158 212 38 that that IN 37158 212 39 the the DT 37158 212 40 excitation excitation NN 37158 212 41 of of IN 37158 212 42 the the DT 37158 212 43 anterior anterior JJ 37158 212 44 nerve nerve NN 37158 212 45 - - HYPH 37158 212 46 fibres fibre VBZ 37158 212 47 provokes provoke VBZ 37158 212 48 movement movement NN 37158 212 49 and and CC 37158 212 50 not not RB 37158 212 51 pain pain VB 37158 212 52 , , , 37158 212 53 whilst whilst IN 37158 212 54 the the DT 37158 212 55 excitation excitation NN 37158 212 56 of of IN 37158 212 57 posterior posterior JJ 37158 212 58 nerve nerve NN 37158 212 59 - - HYPH 37158 212 60 fibres fibre NNS 37158 212 61 provokes provoke VBZ 37158 212 62 pain pain NN 37158 212 63 and and CC 37158 212 64 not not RB 37158 212 65 movement movement NN 37158 212 66 . . . 37158 213 1 Now now RB 37158 213 2 , , , 37158 213 3 in in IN 37158 213 4 order order NN 37158 213 5 to to TO 37158 213 6 make make VB 37158 213 7 students student NNS 37158 213 8 clearly clearly RB 37158 213 9 understand understand VB 37158 213 10 this this DT 37158 213 11 distinction distinction NN 37158 213 12 between between IN 37158 213 13 the the DT 37158 213 14 motor motor NN 37158 213 15 and and CC 37158 213 16 sensory sensory JJ 37158 213 17 nerves nerve NNS 37158 213 18 , , , 37158 213 19 I -PRON- PRP 37158 213 20 require require VBP 37158 213 21 only only RB 37158 213 22 a a DT 37158 213 23 blackboard blackboard NN 37158 213 24 and and CC 37158 213 25 a a DT 37158 213 26 piece piece NN 37158 213 27 of of IN 37158 213 28 chalk chalk NN 37158 213 29 ; ; : 37158 213 30 and and CC 37158 213 31 I -PRON- PRP 37158 213 32 claim claim VBP 37158 213 33 that that IN 37158 213 34 , , , 37158 213 35 with with IN 37158 213 36 a a DT 37158 213 37 piece piece NN 37158 213 38 of of IN 37158 213 39 chalk chalk NN 37158 213 40 and and CC 37158 213 41 a a DT 37158 213 42 blackboard blackboard NN 37158 213 43 , , , 37158 213 44 I -PRON- PRP 37158 213 45 am be VBP 37158 213 46 able able JJ 37158 213 47 to to TO 37158 213 48 explain explain VB 37158 213 49 very very RB 37158 213 50 clearly clearly RB 37158 213 51 all all PDT 37158 213 52 the the DT 37158 213 53 details detail NNS 37158 213 54 of of IN 37158 213 55 this this DT 37158 213 56 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37158 213 57 . . . 37158 214 1 Not not RB 37158 214 2 only only RB 37158 214 3 does do VBZ 37158 214 4 the the DT 37158 214 5 chalk chalk JJ 37158 214 6 suffice suffice NN 37158 214 7 for for IN 37158 214 8 comprehension comprehension NN 37158 214 9 as as RB 37158 214 10 well well RB 37158 214 11 as as IN 37158 214 12 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 214 13 , , , 37158 214 14 but but CC 37158 214 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 214 16 is be VBZ 37158 214 17 better well JJR 37158 214 18 ; ; : 37158 214 19 because because IN 37158 214 20 the the DT 37158 214 21 experiment experiment NN 37158 214 22 is be VBZ 37158 214 23 so so RB 37158 214 24 delicate delicate JJ 37158 214 25 , , , 37158 214 26 so so RB 37158 214 27 difficult difficult JJ 37158 214 28 , , , 37158 214 29 and and CC 37158 214 30 , , , 37158 214 31 in in IN 37158 214 32 order order NN 37158 214 33 to to TO 37158 214 34 be be VB 37158 214 35 understood understand VBN 37158 214 36 , , , 37158 214 37 it -PRON- PRP 37158 214 38 must must MD 37158 214 39 be be VB 37158 214 40 observed observe VBN 37158 214 41 so so RB 37158 214 42 narrowly narrowly RB 37158 214 43 , , , 37158 214 44 so so RB 37158 214 45 closely closely RB 37158 214 46 , , , 37158 214 47 that that IN 37158 214 48 out out IN 37158 214 49 of of IN 37158 214 50 the the DT 37158 214 51 whole whole JJ 37158 214 52 class class NN 37158 214 53 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 214 54 two two CD 37158 214 55 or or CC 37158 214 56 three three CD 37158 214 57 students student NNS 37158 214 58 are be VBP 37158 214 59 able able JJ 37158 214 60 to to TO 37158 214 61 follow follow VB 37158 214 62 the the DT 37158 214 63 experiment experiment NN 37158 214 64 . . . 37158 215 1 The the DT 37158 215 2 rest rest NN 37158 215 3 of of IN 37158 215 4 the the DT 37158 215 5 class class NN 37158 215 6 have have VBP 37158 215 7 before before IN 37158 215 8 them -PRON- PRP 37158 215 9 only only RB 37158 215 10 the the DT 37158 215 11 frightful frightful JJ 37158 215 12 spectacle spectacle NN 37158 215 13 of of IN 37158 215 14 the the DT 37158 215 15 reactions reaction NNS 37158 215 16 of of IN 37158 215 17 a a DT 37158 215 18 mutilated mutilated JJ 37158 215 19 , , , 37158 215 20 suffering suffer VBG 37158 215 21 animal animal NN 37158 215 22 under under IN 37158 215 23 excitations excitation NNS 37158 215 24 which which WDT 37158 215 25 are be VBP 37158 215 26 made make VBN 37158 215 27 in in IN 37158 215 28 the the DT 37158 215 29 very very JJ 37158 215 30 depths depth NNS 37158 215 31 of of IN 37158 215 32 a a DT 37158 215 33 wound wound NN 37158 215 34 on on IN 37158 215 35 organs organ NNS 37158 215 36 which which WDT 37158 215 37 they -PRON- PRP 37158 215 38 do do VBP 37158 215 39 not not RB 37158 215 40 see see VB 37158 215 41 . . . 37158 216 1 This this DT 37158 216 2 experiment experiment NN 37158 216 3 is be VBZ 37158 216 4 rendered render VBN 37158 216 5 more more RBR 37158 216 6 particularly particularly RB 37158 216 7 cruel cruel JJ 37158 216 8 by by IN 37158 216 9 the the DT 37158 216 10 fact fact NN 37158 216 11 that that IN 37158 216 12 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 216 13 can can MD 37158 216 14 not not RB 37158 216 15 be be VB 37158 216 16 used use VBN 37158 216 17 , , , 37158 216 18 precisely precisely RB 37158 216 19 because because IN 37158 216 20 the the DT 37158 216 21 point point NN 37158 216 22 in in IN 37158 216 23 question question NN 37158 216 24 is be VBZ 37158 216 25 the the DT 37158 216 26 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 216 27 or or CC 37158 216 28 non non JJ 37158 216 29 - - JJ 37158 216 30 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 216 31 of of IN 37158 216 32 the the DT 37158 216 33 animal animal NN 37158 216 34 , , , 37158 216 35 and and CC 37158 216 36 consequently consequently RB 37158 216 37 by by IN 37158 216 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 216 39 very very JJ 37158 216 40 nature nature NN 37158 216 41 the the DT 37158 216 42 operation operation NN 37158 216 43 can can MD 37158 216 44 not not RB 37158 216 45 be be VB 37158 216 46 made make VBN 37158 216 47 on on IN 37158 216 48 the the DT 37158 216 49 insensible insensible JJ 37158 216 50 animal animal NN 37158 216 51 . . . 37158 217 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 217 2 1 1 CD 37158 217 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 217 4 And and CC 37158 217 5 now now RB 37158 217 6 , , , 37158 217 7 at at IN 37158 217 8 once once RB 37158 217 9 entering enter VBG 37158 217 10 further further RB 37158 217 11 into into IN 37158 217 12 the the DT 37158 217 13 difficulty difficulty NN 37158 217 14 of of IN 37158 217 15 the the DT 37158 217 16 problem problem NN 37158 217 17 of of IN 37158 217 18 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 217 19 , , , 37158 217 20 we -PRON- PRP 37158 217 21 may may MD 37158 217 22 ask ask VB 37158 217 23 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 217 24 if if IN 37158 217 25 we -PRON- PRP 37158 217 26 have have VBP 37158 217 27 the the DT 37158 217 28 right right NN 37158 217 29 to to TO 37158 217 30 allow allow VB 37158 217 31 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37158 217 32 of of IN 37158 217 33 experimental experimental JJ 37158 217 34 physiology physiology NN 37158 217 35 on on IN 37158 217 36 living live VBG 37158 217 37 animals animal NNS 37158 217 38 that that WDT 37158 217 39 have have VBP 37158 217 40 been be VBN 37158 217 41 rendered render VBN 37158 217 42 insensible insensible JJ 37158 217 43 by by IN 37158 217 44 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 217 45 . . . 37158 218 1 Although although IN 37158 218 2 , , , 37158 218 3 further further RB 37158 218 4 on on RB 37158 218 5 , , , 37158 218 6 I -PRON- PRP 37158 218 7 intend intend VBP 37158 218 8 coming come VBG 37158 218 9 back back RB 37158 218 10 to to IN 37158 218 11 this this DT 37158 218 12 important important JJ 37158 218 13 question question NN 37158 218 14 of of IN 37158 218 15 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 218 16 , , , 37158 218 17 I -PRON- PRP 37158 218 18 will will MD 37158 218 19 say say VB 37158 218 20 at at IN 37158 218 21 once once IN 37158 218 22 I -PRON- PRP 37158 218 23 do do VBP 37158 218 24 not not RB 37158 218 25 understand understand VB 37158 218 26 what what WP 37158 218 27 repugnance repugnance NN 37158 218 28 there there EX 37158 218 29 can can MD 37158 218 30 be be VB 37158 218 31 to to IN 37158 218 32 operating operate VBG 37158 218 33 upon upon IN 37158 218 34 an an DT 37158 218 35 anæsthetised anæsthetise VBN 37158 218 36 animal animal NN 37158 218 37 . . . 37158 219 1 Once once IN 37158 219 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 219 3 is be VBZ 37158 219 4 insensible insensible JJ 37158 219 5 he -PRON- PRP 37158 219 6 can can MD 37158 219 7 not not RB 37158 219 8 suffer suffer VB 37158 219 9 ; ; : 37158 219 10 why why WRB 37158 219 11 hesitate hesitate VBP 37158 219 12 , , , 37158 219 13 therefore therefore RB 37158 219 14 , , , 37158 219 15 to to TO 37158 219 16 perform perform VB 37158 219 17 prolonged prolonged JJ 37158 219 18 experiments experiment NNS 37158 219 19 upon upon IN 37158 219 20 that that DT 37158 219 21 insensible insensible JJ 37158 219 22 being be VBG 37158 219 23 ? ? . 37158 220 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 220 2 appears appear VBZ 37158 220 3 to to IN 37158 220 4 me -PRON- PRP 37158 220 5 just just RB 37158 220 6 as as IN 37158 220 7 inhuman inhuman NN 37158 220 8 to to TO 37158 220 9 boil boil VB 37158 220 10 milk milk NN 37158 220 11 as as IN 37158 220 12 to to TO 37158 220 13 excite excite VB 37158 220 14 the the DT 37158 220 15 pneumogastric pneumogastric JJ 37158 220 16 nerve nerve NN 37158 220 17 of of IN 37158 220 18 a a DT 37158 220 19 dog dog NN 37158 220 20 rendered render VBN 37158 220 21 incapable incapable JJ 37158 220 22 of of IN 37158 220 23 suffering suffer VBG 37158 220 24 . . . 37158 221 1 The the DT 37158 221 2 milk milk NN 37158 221 3 does do VBZ 37158 221 4 not not RB 37158 221 5 suffer suffer VB 37158 221 6 ; ; : 37158 221 7 the the DT 37158 221 8 dog dog NN 37158 221 9 does do VBZ 37158 221 10 not not RB 37158 221 11 suffer suffer VB 37158 221 12 ; ; : 37158 221 13 in in IN 37158 221 14 both both DT 37158 221 15 cases case NNS 37158 221 16 it -PRON- PRP 37158 221 17 is be VBZ 37158 221 18 living live VBG 37158 221 19 matter matter RB 37158 221 20 , , , 37158 221 21 but but CC 37158 221 22 insensible insensible JJ 37158 221 23 living living NN 37158 221 24 matter matter NN 37158 221 25 . . . 37158 222 1 Consequently consequently RB 37158 222 2 , , , 37158 222 3 as as RB 37158 222 4 far far RB 37158 222 5 as as IN 37158 222 6 physiological physiological JJ 37158 222 7 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37158 222 8 are be VBP 37158 222 9 concerned concern VBN 37158 222 10 , , , 37158 222 11 every every DT 37158 222 12 individual individual JJ 37158 222 13 capable capable JJ 37158 222 14 of of IN 37158 222 15 reflection reflection NN 37158 222 16 should should MD 37158 222 17 recognise recognise VB 37158 222 18 that that IN 37158 222 19 there there EX 37158 222 20 is be VBZ 37158 222 21 nothing nothing NN 37158 222 22 wrong wrong JJ 37158 222 23 in in IN 37158 222 24 experimenting experiment VBG 37158 222 25 upon upon IN 37158 222 26 animals animal NNS 37158 222 27 that that WDT 37158 222 28 can can MD 37158 222 29 not not RB 37158 222 30 suffer suffer VB 37158 222 31 . . . 37158 223 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 223 2 shall shall MD 37158 223 3 , , , 37158 223 4 however however RB 37158 223 5 , , , 37158 223 6 make make VB 37158 223 7 two two CD 37158 223 8 restrictions restriction NNS 37158 223 9 . . . 37158 224 1 The the DT 37158 224 2 first first JJ 37158 224 3 is be VBZ 37158 224 4 that that IN 37158 224 5 professors professor NNS 37158 224 6 should should MD 37158 224 7 energetically energetically RB 37158 224 8 call call VB 37158 224 9 the the DT 37158 224 10 attention attention NN 37158 224 11 of of IN 37158 224 12 the the DT 37158 224 13 pupils pupil NNS 37158 224 14 to to IN 37158 224 15 the the DT 37158 224 16 fact fact NN 37158 224 17 that that IN 37158 224 18 the the DT 37158 224 19 animal animal NN 37158 224 20 is be VBZ 37158 224 21 insensible insensible JJ 37158 224 22 , , , 37158 224 23 and and CC 37158 224 24 that that IN 37158 224 25 no no DT 37158 224 26 one one NN 37158 224 27 has have VBZ 37158 224 28 the the DT 37158 224 29 right right NN 37158 224 30 to to TO 37158 224 31 make make VB 37158 224 32 the the DT 37158 224 33 experiment experiment NN 37158 224 34 upon upon IN 37158 224 35 a a DT 37158 224 36 sensitive sensitive JJ 37158 224 37 animal animal NN 37158 224 38 ; ; : 37158 224 39 that that IN 37158 224 40 we -PRON- PRP 37158 224 41 , , , 37158 224 42 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 224 43 , , , 37158 224 44 more more RBR 37158 224 45 than than IN 37158 224 46 all all DT 37158 224 47 other other JJ 37158 224 48 men man NNS 37158 224 49 , , , 37158 224 50 are be VBP 37158 224 51 under under IN 37158 224 52 the the DT 37158 224 53 obligation obligation NN 37158 224 54 of of IN 37158 224 55 dealing deal VBG 37158 224 56 humanely humanely RB 37158 224 57 with with IN 37158 224 58 animals animal NNS 37158 224 59 . . . 37158 225 1 The the DT 37158 225 2 professor professor NN 37158 225 3 of of IN 37158 225 4 physiology physiology NN 37158 225 5 should should MD 37158 225 6 take take VB 37158 225 7 advantage advantage NN 37158 225 8 of of IN 37158 225 9 the the DT 37158 225 10 occasion occasion NN 37158 225 11 to to TO 37158 225 12 develop develop VB 37158 225 13 in in IN 37158 225 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 225 15 hearers hearer NNS 37158 225 16 the the DT 37158 225 17 best good JJS 37158 225 18 and and CC 37158 225 19 noblest noble JJR 37158 225 20 sentiments sentiment NNS 37158 225 21 , , , 37158 225 22 those those DT 37158 225 23 of of IN 37158 225 24 pity pity NN 37158 225 25 and and CC 37158 225 26 of of IN 37158 225 27 generosity generosity NN 37158 225 28 . . . 37158 226 1 In in IN 37158 226 2 a a DT 37158 226 3 word word NN 37158 226 4 , , , 37158 226 5 he -PRON- PRP 37158 226 6 should should MD 37158 226 7 excuse excuse VB 37158 226 8 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 226 9 , , , 37158 226 10 so so RB 37158 226 11 to to TO 37158 226 12 speak speak VB 37158 226 13 , , , 37158 226 14 for for IN 37158 226 15 performing perform VBG 37158 226 16 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 226 17 , , , 37158 226 18 and and CC 37158 226 19 prove prove VB 37158 226 20 that that IN 37158 226 21 such such JJ 37158 226 22 is be VBZ 37158 226 23 only only RB 37158 226 24 legitimate legitimate JJ 37158 226 25 when when WRB 37158 226 26 it -PRON- PRP 37158 226 27 entails entail VBZ 37158 226 28 no no DT 37158 226 29 suffering suffering NN 37158 226 30 . . . 37158 227 1 The the DT 37158 227 2 second second JJ 37158 227 3 restriction restriction NN 37158 227 4 is be VBZ 37158 227 5 that that IN 37158 227 6 the the DT 37158 227 7 animal animal NN 37158 227 8 thus thus RB 37158 227 9 chloroformed chloroform VBN 37158 227 10 or or CC 37158 227 11 anæsthetised anæsthetise VBN 37158 227 12 should should MD 37158 227 13 never never RB 37158 227 14 be be VB 37158 227 15 permitted permit VBN 37158 227 16 to to TO 37158 227 17 awaken awaken VB 37158 227 18 . . . 37158 228 1 If if IN 37158 228 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 228 3 shows show VBZ 37158 228 4 the the DT 37158 228 5 slightest slight JJS 37158 228 6 sign sign NN 37158 228 7 of of IN 37158 228 8 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 228 9 , , , 37158 228 10 he -PRON- PRP 37158 228 11 should should MD 37158 228 12 be be VB 37158 228 13 given give VBN 37158 228 14 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 228 15 until until IN 37158 228 16 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 228 17 is be VBZ 37158 228 18 complete complete JJ 37158 228 19 , , , 37158 228 20 and and CC 37158 228 21 , , , 37158 228 22 finally finally RB 37158 228 23 , , , 37158 228 24 he -PRON- PRP 37158 228 25 ought ought MD 37158 228 26 to to TO 37158 228 27 be be VB 37158 228 28 killed kill VBN 37158 228 29 after after IN 37158 228 30 the the DT 37158 228 31 experiment experiment NN 37158 228 32 , , , 37158 228 33 without without IN 37158 228 34 allowing allow VBG 37158 228 35 him -PRON- PRP 37158 228 36 to to TO 37158 228 37 regain regain VB 37158 228 38 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 228 39 . . . 37158 229 1 After after RB 37158 229 2 all all RB 37158 229 3 , , , 37158 229 4 death death NN 37158 229 5 under under IN 37158 229 6 these these DT 37158 229 7 conditions condition NNS 37158 229 8 is be VBZ 37158 229 9 a a DT 37158 229 10 painless painless JJ 37158 229 11 end end NN 37158 229 12 . . . 37158 230 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 230 2 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 230 3 , , , 37158 230 4 who who WP 37158 230 5 will will MD 37158 230 6 disappear disappear VB 37158 230 7 after after IN 37158 230 8 a a DT 37158 230 9 long long JJ 37158 230 10 , , , 37158 230 11 and and CC 37158 230 12 certainly certainly RB 37158 230 13 painful painful JJ 37158 230 14 , , , 37158 230 15 agony agony NNP 37158 230 16 , , , 37158 230 17 in in IN 37158 230 18 those those DT 37158 230 19 weary weary JJ 37158 230 20 moments moment NNS 37158 230 21 of of IN 37158 230 22 pain pain NN 37158 230 23 which which WDT 37158 230 24 will will MD 37158 230 25 precede precede VB 37158 230 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 230 27 end end NN 37158 230 28 , , , 37158 230 29 shall shall MD 37158 230 30 envy envy VB 37158 230 31 that that DT 37158 230 32 absence absence NN 37158 230 33 of of IN 37158 230 34 suffering suffering NN 37158 230 35 , , , 37158 230 36 that that DT 37158 230 37 rapid rapid JJ 37158 230 38 end end NN 37158 230 39 of of IN 37158 230 40 all all DT 37158 230 41 pain pain NN 37158 230 42 , , , 37158 230 43 which which WDT 37158 230 44 is be VBZ 37158 230 45 the the DT 37158 230 46 death death NN 37158 230 47 of of IN 37158 230 48 an an DT 37158 230 49 animal animal NN 37158 230 50 under under IN 37158 230 51 an an DT 37158 230 52 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 230 53 . . . 37158 231 1 Let let VB 37158 231 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 231 3 , , , 37158 231 4 therefore therefore RB 37158 231 5 , , , 37158 231 6 banish banish VBP 37158 231 7 every every DT 37158 231 8 painful painful JJ 37158 231 9 experiment experiment NN 37158 231 10 the the DT 37158 231 11 object object NN 37158 231 12 of of IN 37158 231 13 which which WDT 37158 231 14 is be VBZ 37158 231 15 purely purely RB 37158 231 16 didactic didactic JJ 37158 231 17 . . . 37158 232 1 Moreover moreover RB 37158 232 2 , , , 37158 232 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 232 4 fail fail VBP 37158 232 5 to to TO 37158 232 6 see see VB 37158 232 7 what what WP 37158 232 8 experiments experiment NNS 37158 232 9 in in IN 37158 232 10 painful painful JJ 37158 232 11 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 232 12 are be VBP 37158 232 13 necessary necessary JJ 37158 232 14 for for IN 37158 232 15 the the DT 37158 232 16 teaching teaching NN 37158 232 17 of of IN 37158 232 18 physiology physiology NN 37158 232 19 . . . 37158 233 1 Studies study NNS 37158 233 2 on on IN 37158 233 3 reflex reflex NN 37158 233 4 movement movement NN 37158 233 5 can can MD 37158 233 6 be be VB 37158 233 7 made make VBN 37158 233 8 perfectly perfectly RB 37158 233 9 well well RB 37158 233 10 on on IN 37158 233 11 a a DT 37158 233 12 decapitated decapitate VBN 37158 233 13 animal animal NN 37158 233 14 ; ; : 37158 233 15 and and CC 37158 233 16 in in IN 37158 233 17 that that DT 37158 233 18 case case NN 37158 233 19 it -PRON- PRP 37158 233 20 is be VBZ 37158 233 21 well well RB 37158 233 22 understood understand VBN 37158 233 23 that that IN 37158 233 24 there there EX 37158 233 25 can can MD 37158 233 26 be be VB 37158 233 27 no no DT 37158 233 28 question question NN 37158 233 29 of of IN 37158 233 30 pain pain NN 37158 233 31 ; ; : 37158 233 32 for for IN 37158 233 33 it -PRON- PRP 37158 233 34 would would MD 37158 233 35 be be VB 37158 233 36 absurd absurd JJ 37158 233 37 to to TO 37158 233 38 suppose suppose VB 37158 233 39 that that IN 37158 233 40 the the DT 37158 233 41 spinal spinal JJ 37158 233 42 cord cord NN 37158 233 43 possesses possess VBZ 37158 233 44 the the DT 37158 233 45 power power NN 37158 233 46 of of IN 37158 233 47 receiving receive VBG 37158 233 48 the the DT 37158 233 49 notion notion NN 37158 233 50 of of IN 37158 233 51 pain pain NN 37158 233 52 . . . 37158 234 1 Such such PDT 37158 234 2 a a DT 37158 234 3 supposition supposition NN 37158 234 4 would would MD 37158 234 5 mean mean VB 37158 234 6 the the DT 37158 234 7 negation negation NN 37158 234 8 of of IN 37158 234 9 the the DT 37158 234 10 best well RBS 37158 234 11 - - HYPH 37158 234 12 established establish VBN 37158 234 13 facts fact NNS 37158 234 14 of of IN 37158 234 15 physiology physiology NN 37158 234 16 . . . 37158 235 1 Experiments experiment NNS 37158 235 2 on on IN 37158 235 3 the the DT 37158 235 4 heart heart NN 37158 235 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 235 6 notably notably RB 37158 235 7 of of IN 37158 235 8 the the DT 37158 235 9 frog frog NN 37158 235 10 and and CC 37158 235 11 the the DT 37158 235 12 tortoise tortoise NN 37158 235 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 235 14 are be VBP 37158 235 15 performed perform VBN 37158 235 16 very very RB 37158 235 17 much much RB 37158 235 18 better well RBR 37158 235 19 on on IN 37158 235 20 a a DT 37158 235 21 decapitated decapitate VBN 37158 235 22 animal animal NN 37158 235 23 than than IN 37158 235 24 on on IN 37158 235 25 an an DT 37158 235 26 animal animal NN 37158 235 27 which which WDT 37158 235 28 is be VBZ 37158 235 29 intact intact JJ 37158 235 30 ; ; : 37158 235 31 and and CC 37158 235 32 experiments experiment NNS 37158 235 33 can can MD 37158 235 34 even even RB 37158 235 35 be be VB 37158 235 36 made make VBN 37158 235 37 on on IN 37158 235 38 the the DT 37158 235 39 heart heart NN 37158 235 40 separated separate VBN 37158 235 41 from from IN 37158 235 42 the the DT 37158 235 43 organism organism NN 37158 235 44 . . . 37158 236 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 236 2 would would MD 37158 236 3 be be VB 37158 236 4 downright downright RB 37158 236 5 puerile puerile JJ 37158 236 6 to to TO 37158 236 7 lack lack VB 37158 236 8 the the DT 37158 236 9 courage courage NN 37158 236 10 to to TO 37158 236 11 watch watch VB 37158 236 12 the the DT 37158 236 13 beating beating NN 37158 236 14 of of IN 37158 236 15 the the DT 37158 236 16 living live VBG 37158 236 17 heart heart NN 37158 236 18 of of IN 37158 236 19 a a DT 37158 236 20 dead dead JJ 37158 236 21 tortoise tortoise NN 37158 236 22 ! ! . 37158 237 1 As as IN 37158 237 2 for for IN 37158 237 3 the the DT 37158 237 4 mammalia mammalia NN 37158 237 5 , , , 37158 237 6 all all DT 37158 237 7 experiments experiment NNS 37158 237 8 on on IN 37158 237 9 the the DT 37158 237 10 heart heart NN 37158 237 11 and and CC 37158 237 12 on on IN 37158 237 13 the the DT 37158 237 14 respiration respiration NN 37158 237 15 necessary necessary JJ 37158 237 16 in in IN 37158 237 17 a a DT 37158 237 18 course course NN 37158 237 19 of of IN 37158 237 20 lectures lecture NNS 37158 237 21 on on IN 37158 237 22 physiology physiology NN 37158 237 23 are be VBP 37158 237 24 admirably admirably RB 37158 237 25 carried carry VBN 37158 237 26 out out RP 37158 237 27 on on IN 37158 237 28 an an DT 37158 237 29 animal animal NN 37158 237 30 rendered render VBN 37158 237 31 completely completely RB 37158 237 32 insensible insensible JJ 37158 237 33 . . . 37158 238 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 238 2 2 2 LS 37158 238 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 238 4 We -PRON- PRP 37158 238 5 have have VBP 37158 238 6 not not RB 37158 238 7 , , , 37158 238 8 however however RB 37158 238 9 , , , 37158 238 10 quite quite RB 37158 238 11 finished finish VBD 37158 238 12 with with IN 37158 238 13 the the DT 37158 238 14 difficulties difficulty NNS 37158 238 15 of of IN 37158 238 16 physiological physiological JJ 37158 238 17 instruction instruction NN 37158 238 18 : : : 37158 238 19 there there EX 37158 238 20 are be VBP 37158 238 21 certain certain JJ 37158 238 22 poisons poison NNS 37158 238 23 for for IN 37158 238 24 which which WDT 37158 238 25 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 238 26 can can MD 37158 238 27 not not RB 37158 238 28 be be VB 37158 238 29 used use VBN 37158 238 30 . . . 37158 239 1 As as IN 37158 239 2 the the DT 37158 239 3 essential essential JJ 37158 239 4 property property NN 37158 239 5 of of IN 37158 239 6 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 239 7 is be VBZ 37158 239 8 to to TO 37158 239 9 deaden deaden VB 37158 239 10 the the DT 37158 239 11 nervous nervous JJ 37158 239 12 cells cell NNS 37158 239 13 , , , 37158 239 14 the the DT 37158 239 15 effects effect NNS 37158 239 16 of of IN 37158 239 17 some some DT 37158 239 18 poisons poison NNS 37158 239 19 can can MD 37158 239 20 not not RB 37158 239 21 be be VB 37158 239 22 studied study VBN 37158 239 23 in in IN 37158 239 24 an an DT 37158 239 25 animal animal NN 37158 239 26 profoundly profoundly RB 37158 239 27 chloroformed chloroform VBN 37158 239 28 . . . 37158 240 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 240 2 can can MD 37158 240 3 watch watch VB 37158 240 4 very very RB 37158 240 5 well well RB 37158 240 6 indeed indeed RB 37158 240 7 the the DT 37158 240 8 effects effect NNS 37158 240 9 of of IN 37158 240 10 carbonic carbonic JJ 37158 240 11 oxide oxide NN 37158 240 12 , , , 37158 240 13 which which WDT 37158 240 14 poisons poison VBZ 37158 240 15 the the DT 37158 240 16 blood blood NN 37158 240 17 , , , 37158 240 18 but but CC 37158 240 19 many many JJ 37158 240 20 other other JJ 37158 240 21 poisons poison NNS 37158 240 22 no no RB 37158 240 23 longer longer RB 37158 240 24 produce produce VBP 37158 240 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 240 26 characteristic characteristic JJ 37158 240 27 symptoms symptom NNS 37158 240 28 ; ; : 37158 240 29 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 240 30 , , , 37158 240 31 it -PRON- PRP 37158 240 32 is be VBZ 37158 240 33 of of IN 37158 240 34 the the DT 37158 240 35 highest high JJS 37158 240 36 importance importance NN 37158 240 37 to to TO 37158 240 38 show show VB 37158 240 39 medical medical JJ 37158 240 40 students student NNS 37158 240 41 the the DT 37158 240 42 effects effect NNS 37158 240 43 of of IN 37158 240 44 certain certain JJ 37158 240 45 formidable formidable JJ 37158 240 46 toxic toxic JJ 37158 240 47 substances substance NNS 37158 240 48 . . . 37158 241 1 Permit permit VB 37158 241 2 me -PRON- PRP 37158 241 3 to to TO 37158 241 4 quote quote VB 37158 241 5 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 241 6 . . . 37158 242 1 However however RB 37158 242 2 little little JJ 37158 242 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 242 4 may may MD 37158 242 5 be be VB 37158 242 6 a a DT 37158 242 7 partisan partisan NN 37158 242 8 of of IN 37158 242 9 painful painful JJ 37158 242 10 experimental experimental JJ 37158 242 11 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37158 242 12 , , , 37158 242 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 242 14 make make VBP 37158 242 15 one one CD 37158 242 16 exception exception NN 37158 242 17 for for IN 37158 242 18 an an DT 37158 242 19 experiment experiment NN 37158 242 20 which which WDT 37158 242 21 I -PRON- PRP 37158 242 22 consider consider VBP 37158 242 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 242 24 essential essential JJ 37158 242 25 to to TO 37158 242 26 present present VB 37158 242 27 , , , 37158 242 28 in in IN 37158 242 29 all all DT 37158 242 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 242 31 horror horror NN 37158 242 32 , , , 37158 242 33 before before IN 37158 242 34 the the DT 37158 242 35 young young JJ 37158 242 36 men man NNS 37158 242 37 who who WP 37158 242 38 attend attend VBP 37158 242 39 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 242 40 lectures lecture NNS 37158 242 41 . . . 37158 243 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 243 2 refer refer VBP 37158 243 3 to to IN 37158 243 4 absinthe absinthe DT 37158 243 5 . . . 37158 244 1 If if IN 37158 244 2 two two CD 37158 244 3 or or CC 37158 244 4 three three CD 37158 244 5 drops drop NNS 37158 244 6 of of IN 37158 244 7 essence essence NN 37158 244 8 of of IN 37158 244 9 absinthe absinthe DT 37158 244 10 are be VBP 37158 244 11 injected inject VBN 37158 244 12 into into IN 37158 244 13 the the DT 37158 244 14 veins vein NNS 37158 244 15 of of IN 37158 244 16 a a DT 37158 244 17 dog dog NN 37158 244 18 , , , 37158 244 19 he -PRON- PRP 37158 244 20 is be VBZ 37158 244 21 at at IN 37158 244 22 once once RB 37158 244 23 seized seize VBN 37158 244 24 by by IN 37158 244 25 a a DT 37158 244 26 violent violent JJ 37158 244 27 attack attack NN 37158 244 28 of of IN 37158 244 29 epilepsy epilepsy NN 37158 244 30 with with IN 37158 244 31 hallucinations hallucination NNS 37158 244 32 , , , 37158 244 33 convulsions convulsion NNS 37158 244 34 , , , 37158 244 35 and and CC 37158 244 36 foaming foam VBG 37158 244 37 at at IN 37158 244 38 the the DT 37158 244 39 mouth mouth NN 37158 244 40 . . . 37158 245 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 245 2 is be VBZ 37158 245 3 truly truly RB 37158 245 4 a a DT 37158 245 5 terrible terrible JJ 37158 245 6 sight sight NN 37158 245 7 , , , 37158 245 8 one one CD 37158 245 9 which which WDT 37158 245 10 fills fill VBZ 37158 245 11 with with IN 37158 245 12 disgust disgust NN 37158 245 13 and and CC 37158 245 14 horror horror VBD 37158 245 15 all all DT 37158 245 16 who who WP 37158 245 17 have have VBP 37158 245 18 witnessed witness VBN 37158 245 19 this this DT 37158 245 20 experiment experiment NN 37158 245 21 . . . 37158 246 1 But but CC 37158 246 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 246 3 is be VBZ 37158 246 4 precisely precisely RB 37158 246 5 for for IN 37158 246 6 the the DT 37158 246 7 sake sake NN 37158 246 8 of of IN 37158 246 9 arousing arouse VBG 37158 246 10 this this DT 37158 246 11 disgust disgust NN 37158 246 12 , , , 37158 246 13 this this DT 37158 246 14 horror horror NN 37158 246 15 , , , 37158 246 16 that that IN 37158 246 17 I -PRON- PRP 37158 246 18 perform perform VBP 37158 246 19 the the DT 37158 246 20 experiment experiment NN 37158 246 21 . . . 37158 247 1 The the DT 37158 247 2 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 247 3 dog dog NN 37158 247 4 will will MD 37158 247 5 , , , 37158 247 6 during during IN 37158 247 7 ten ten CD 37158 247 8 minutes minute NNS 37158 247 9 , , , 37158 247 10 have have VBP 37158 247 11 had have VBN 37158 247 12 an an DT 37158 247 13 attack attack NN 37158 247 14 of of IN 37158 247 15 intoxication intoxication NN 37158 247 16 and and CC 37158 247 17 absinthian absinthian JJ 37158 247 18 epilepsy epilepsy NN 37158 247 19 ; ; : 37158 247 20 but but CC 37158 247 21 at at IN 37158 247 22 the the DT 37158 247 23 end end NN 37158 247 24 of of IN 37158 247 25 an an DT 37158 247 26 hour hour NN 37158 247 27 he -PRON- PRP 37158 247 28 will will MD 37158 247 29 have have VB 37158 247 30 recovered recover VBN 37158 247 31 completely completely RB 37158 247 32 . . . 37158 248 1 At at IN 37158 248 2 the the DT 37158 248 3 same same JJ 37158 248 4 time time NN 37158 248 5 , , , 37158 248 6 the the DT 37158 248 7 two two CD 37158 248 8 hundred hundred CD 37158 248 9 students student NNS 37158 248 10 who who WP 37158 248 11 have have VBP 37158 248 12 witnessed witness VBN 37158 248 13 this this DT 37158 248 14 hideous hideous JJ 37158 248 15 spectacle spectacle NN 37158 248 16 will will MD 37158 248 17 retain retain VB 37158 248 18 , , , 37158 248 19 profoundly profoundly RB 37158 248 20 engraved engrave VBN 37158 248 21 on on IN 37158 248 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 248 23 minds mind NNS 37158 248 24 , , , 37158 248 25 the the DT 37158 248 26 memory memory NN 37158 248 27 of of IN 37158 248 28 that that DT 37158 248 29 epileptic epileptic JJ 37158 248 30 fury fury NN 37158 248 31 , , , 37158 248 32 a a DT 37158 248 33 memory memory NN 37158 248 34 which which WDT 37158 248 35 will will MD 37158 248 36 remain remain VB 37158 248 37 with with IN 37158 248 38 them -PRON- PRP 37158 248 39 to to IN 37158 248 40 the the DT 37158 248 41 end end NN 37158 248 42 of of IN 37158 248 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 248 44 days day NNS 37158 248 45 . . . 37158 249 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 249 2 will will MD 37158 249 3 then then RB 37158 249 4 be be VB 37158 249 5 able able JJ 37158 249 6 , , , 37158 249 7 by by IN 37158 249 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 249 9 propaganda propaganda NN 37158 249 10 against against IN 37158 249 11 absinthe absinthe DT 37158 249 12 , , , 37158 249 13 to to TO 37158 249 14 exercise exercise VB 37158 249 15 around around IN 37158 249 16 them -PRON- PRP 37158 249 17 a a DT 37158 249 18 salutary salutary JJ 37158 249 19 influence influence NN 37158 249 20 , , , 37158 249 21 to to TO 37158 249 22 prevent prevent VB 37158 249 23 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 249 24 ten ten CD 37158 249 25 , , , 37158 249 26 fifteen fifteen CD 37158 249 27 , , , 37158 249 28 one one CD 37158 249 29 hundred hundred CD 37158 249 30 human human JJ 37158 249 31 personalities personality NNS 37158 249 32 from from IN 37158 249 33 destroying destroy VBG 37158 249 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 249 35 by by IN 37158 249 36 the the DT 37158 249 37 use use NN 37158 249 38 of of IN 37158 249 39 this this DT 37158 249 40 abominable abominable JJ 37158 249 41 poison poison NN 37158 249 42 . . . 37158 250 1 After after RB 37158 250 2 all all RB 37158 250 3 , , , 37158 250 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 250 5 is be VBZ 37158 250 6 better well JJR 37158 250 7 to to TO 37158 250 8 give give VB 37158 250 9 a a DT 37158 250 10 dog dog NN 37158 250 11 ten ten CD 37158 250 12 minutes minute NNS 37158 250 13 of of IN 37158 250 14 absinthism absinthism NN 37158 250 15 than than IN 37158 250 16 to to TO 37158 250 17 allow allow VB 37158 250 18 twenty twenty CD 37158 250 19 human human JJ 37158 250 20 families family NNS 37158 250 21 to to TO 37158 250 22 be be VB 37158 250 23 plunged plunge VBN 37158 250 24 , , , 37158 250 25 by by IN 37158 250 26 absinthism absinthism NN 37158 250 27 , , , 37158 250 28 into into IN 37158 250 29 degradation degradation NN 37158 250 30 and and CC 37158 250 31 misery misery NN 37158 250 32 . . . 37158 251 1 Finally finally RB 37158 251 2 , , , 37158 251 3 as as RB 37158 251 4 far far RB 37158 251 5 as as IN 37158 251 6 surgical surgical JJ 37158 251 7 exercises exercise NNS 37158 251 8 are be VBP 37158 251 9 concerned concern VBN 37158 251 10 , , , 37158 251 11 _ _ NNP 37158 251 12 they -PRON- PRP 37158 251 13 should should MD 37158 251 14 never never RB 37158 251 15 be be VB 37158 251 16 made make VBN 37158 251 17 on on IN 37158 251 18 a a DT 37158 251 19 living living NN 37158 251 20 animal animal NN 37158 251 21 _ _ NN 37158 251 22 ; ; : 37158 251 23 as as IN 37158 251 24 regards regard VBZ 37158 251 25 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37158 251 26 of of IN 37158 251 27 experimental experimental JJ 37158 251 28 physiology physiology NN 37158 251 29 intended intend VBN 37158 251 30 for for IN 37158 251 31 instruction instruction NN 37158 251 32 , , , 37158 251 33 _ _ NNP 37158 251 34 they -PRON- PRP 37158 251 35 should should MD 37158 251 36 be be VB 37158 251 37 made make VBN 37158 251 38 only only RB 37158 251 39 on on IN 37158 251 40 decapitated decapitate VBN 37158 251 41 or or CC 37158 251 42 anæsthetised anæsthetise VBN 37158 251 43 animals animal NNS 37158 251 44 _ _ NNP 37158 251 45 ; ; : 37158 251 46 and and CC 37158 251 47 as as IN 37158 251 48 for for IN 37158 251 49 intoxications,[3 intoxications,[3 NN 37158 251 50 ] ] -RRB- 37158 251 51 save save VB 37158 251 52 on on IN 37158 251 53 very very RB 37158 251 54 rare rare JJ 37158 251 55 and and CC 37158 251 56 altogether altogether RB 37158 251 57 exceptional exceptional JJ 37158 251 58 occasions occasion NNS 37158 251 59 , , , 37158 251 60 _ _ NNP 37158 251 61 they -PRON- PRP 37158 251 62 should should MD 37158 251 63 not not RB 37158 251 64 be be VB 37158 251 65 made make VBN 37158 251 66 the the DT 37158 251 67 object object NN 37158 251 68 of of IN 37158 251 69 experimental experimental JJ 37158 251 70 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37158 251 71 _ _ NNP 37158 251 72 . . . 37158 252 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 252 2 seems seem VBZ 37158 252 3 to to IN 37158 252 4 me -PRON- PRP 37158 252 5 that that IN 37158 252 6 these these DT 37158 252 7 formal formal JJ 37158 252 8 declarations declaration NNS 37158 252 9 might may MD 37158 252 10 be be VB 37158 252 11 accepted accept VBN 37158 252 12 by by IN 37158 252 13 every every DT 37158 252 14 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 252 15 as as RB 37158 252 16 well well RB 37158 252 17 as as IN 37158 252 18 by by IN 37158 252 19 every every DT 37158 252 20 anti anti JJ 37158 252 21 - - NN 37158 252 22 vivisectionist vivisectionist JJ 37158 252 23 . . . 37158 253 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 37158 253 2 : : : 37158 253 3 [ [ -LRB- 37158 253 4 1 1 LS 37158 253 5 ] ] -RRB- 37158 253 6 The the DT 37158 253 7 usages usage NNS 37158 253 8 in in IN 37158 253 9 English English NNP 37158 253 10 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 253 11 in in IN 37158 253 12 relation relation NN 37158 253 13 to to IN 37158 253 14 this this DT 37158 253 15 experiment experiment NN 37158 253 16 are be VBP 37158 253 17 in in IN 37158 253 18 accord accord NN 37158 253 19 with with IN 37158 253 20 Professor Professor NNP 37158 253 21 Richet Richet NNP 37158 253 22 's 's POS 37158 253 23 views.--(W. views.--(w. ADD 37158 254 1 D. D. NNP 37158 254 2 H. H. NNP 37158 254 3 ) ) -RRB- 37158 254 4 [ [ -LRB- 37158 254 5 2 2 CD 37158 254 6 ] ] -RRB- 37158 254 7 It -PRON- PRP 37158 254 8 may may MD 37158 254 9 not not RB 37158 254 10 be be VB 37158 254 11 known know VBN 37158 254 12 to to IN 37158 254 13 many many JJ 37158 254 14 readers reader NNS 37158 254 15 , , , 37158 254 16 that that IN 37158 254 17 it -PRON- PRP 37158 254 18 is be VBZ 37158 254 19 possible possible JJ 37158 254 20 to to TO 37158 254 21 keep keep VB 37158 254 22 alive alive JJ 37158 254 23 for for IN 37158 254 24 hours hour NNS 37158 254 25 and and CC 37158 254 26 even even RB 37158 254 27 days day NNS 37158 254 28 the the DT 37158 254 29 heart heart NN 37158 254 30 entirely entirely RB 37158 254 31 removed remove VBD 37158 254 32 from from IN 37158 254 33 the the DT 37158 254 34 body body NN 37158 254 35 of of IN 37158 254 36 a a DT 37158 254 37 dead dead JJ 37158 254 38 mammal mammal NN 37158 254 39 . . . 37158 255 1 On on IN 37158 255 2 such such PDT 37158 255 3 a a DT 37158 255 4 heart heart NN 37158 255 5 the the DT 37158 255 6 action action NN 37158 255 7 of of IN 37158 255 8 drugs drug NNS 37158 255 9 can can MD 37158 255 10 be be VB 37158 255 11 admirably admirably RB 37158 255 12 studied study VBN 37158 255 13 and and CC 37158 255 14 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 37158 255 15 . . . 37158 256 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 256 2 once once RB 37158 256 3 had have VBD 37158 256 4 in in IN 37158 256 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 256 6 own own JJ 37158 256 7 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 256 8 a a DT 37158 256 9 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 256 10 's 's POS 37158 256 11 heart heart NN 37158 256 12 that that WDT 37158 256 13 continued continue VBD 37158 256 14 to to TO 37158 256 15 beat beat VB 37158 256 16 for for IN 37158 256 17 nearly nearly RB 37158 256 18 five five CD 37158 256 19 days day NNS 37158 256 20 after after IN 37158 256 21 the the DT 37158 256 22 remainder remainder NN 37158 256 23 of of IN 37158 256 24 the the DT 37158 256 25 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 256 26 had have VBD 37158 256 27 served serve VBN 37158 256 28 for for IN 37158 256 29 the the DT 37158 256 30 dinner dinner NN 37158 256 31 of of IN 37158 256 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 256 33 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 256 34 attendant.--(W. attendant.--(w. ADD 37158 257 1 D. D. NNP 37158 257 2 H. H. NNP 37158 257 3 ) ) -RRB- 37158 257 4 [ [ -LRB- 37158 257 5 3 3 LS 37158 257 6 ] ] -RRB- 37158 257 7 The the DT 37158 257 8 word word NN 37158 257 9 intoxication intoxication NN 37158 257 10 here here RB 37158 257 11 and and CC 37158 257 12 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37158 257 13 is be VBZ 37158 257 14 used use VBN 37158 257 15 in in IN 37158 257 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 257 17 literal literal JJ 37158 257 18 sense sense NN 37158 257 19 , , , 37158 257 20 viz viz NNP 37158 257 21 . . NNP 37158 257 22 , , , 37158 257 23 poisoning poisoning NN 37158 257 24 . . . 37158 258 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 258 2 is be VBZ 37158 258 3 not not RB 37158 258 4 limited limited JJ 37158 258 5 , , , 37158 258 6 as as IN 37158 258 7 in in IN 37158 258 8 popular popular JJ 37158 258 9 parlance parlance NN 37158 258 10 , , , 37158 258 11 to to IN 37158 258 12 the the DT 37158 258 13 poisonous poisonous JJ 37158 258 14 effects effect NNS 37158 258 15 of of IN 37158 258 16 alcohol.--(W. alcohol.--(w. ADD 37158 259 1 D. D. NNP 37158 259 2 H. H. NNP 37158 259 3 ) ) -RRB- 37158 259 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37158 259 5 II II NNP 37158 259 6 PAIN PAIN NNP 37158 259 7 AND and CC 37158 259 8 DEATH death NN 37158 259 9 We -PRON- PRP 37158 259 10 have have VBP 37158 259 11 not not RB 37158 259 12 yet yet RB 37158 259 13 touched touch VBN 37158 259 14 at at IN 37158 259 15 the the DT 37158 259 16 root root NN 37158 259 17 of of IN 37158 259 18 the the DT 37158 259 19 problem problem NN 37158 259 20 , , , 37158 259 21 for for IN 37158 259 22 physiology physiology NN 37158 259 23 is be VBZ 37158 259 24 not not RB 37158 259 25 mere mere JJ 37158 259 26 demonstration demonstration NN 37158 259 27 . . . 37158 260 1 The the DT 37158 260 2 real real JJ 37158 260 3 point point NN 37158 260 4 at at IN 37158 260 5 issue issue NN 37158 260 6 is be VBZ 37158 260 7 the the DT 37158 260 8 search search NN 37158 260 9 for for IN 37158 260 10 new new JJ 37158 260 11 truths truth NNS 37158 260 12 . . . 37158 261 1 The the DT 37158 261 2 demonstration demonstration NN 37158 261 3 of of IN 37158 261 4 an an DT 37158 261 5 acquired acquire VBN 37158 261 6 truth truth NN 37158 261 7 , , , 37158 261 8 however however RB 37158 261 9 important important JJ 37158 261 10 this this DT 37158 261 11 may may MD 37158 261 12 be be VB 37158 261 13 , , , 37158 261 14 must must MD 37158 261 15 not not RB 37158 261 16 be be VB 37158 261 17 confused confuse VBN 37158 261 18 with with IN 37158 261 19 the the DT 37158 261 20 research research NN 37158 261 21 for for IN 37158 261 22 an an DT 37158 261 23 unknown unknown JJ 37158 261 24 truth truth NN 37158 261 25 . . . 37158 262 1 Now now RB 37158 262 2 , , , 37158 262 3 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 262 4 claim claim VBP 37158 262 5 that that IN 37158 262 6 they -PRON- PRP 37158 262 7 have have VBP 37158 262 8 not not RB 37158 262 9 only only RB 37158 262 10 the the DT 37158 262 11 right right NN 37158 262 12 -- -- : 37158 262 13 but but CC 37158 262 14 that that IN 37158 262 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 262 16 is be VBZ 37158 262 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 262 18 duty duty NN 37158 262 19 -- -- : 37158 262 20 to to TO 37158 262 21 inflict inflict VB 37158 262 22 some some DT 37158 262 23 suffering suffering NN 37158 262 24 on on IN 37158 262 25 animals animal NNS 37158 262 26 , , , 37158 262 27 if if IN 37158 262 28 by by IN 37158 262 29 so so RB 37158 262 30 doing do VBG 37158 262 31 they -PRON- PRP 37158 262 32 diminish diminish VBP 37158 262 33 human human JJ 37158 262 34 suffering suffering NN 37158 262 35 . . . 37158 263 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 263 2 am be VBP 37158 263 3 going go VBG 37158 263 4 to to TO 37158 263 5 put put VB 37158 263 6 this this DT 37158 263 7 proposition proposition NN 37158 263 8 to to IN 37158 263 9 the the DT 37158 263 10 test test NN 37158 263 11 . . . 37158 264 1 1 1 LS 37158 264 2 . . . 37158 265 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 265 2 is be VBZ 37158 265 3 universally universally RB 37158 265 4 recognised recognise VBN 37158 265 5 , , , 37158 265 6 except except IN 37158 265 7 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 265 8 by by IN 37158 265 9 the the DT 37158 265 10 Brahmans Brahmans NNPS 37158 265 11 , , , 37158 265 12 that that IN 37158 265 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 265 14 have have VBP 37158 265 15 the the DT 37158 265 16 right right NN 37158 265 17 to to TO 37158 265 18 kill kill VB 37158 265 19 dangerous dangerous JJ 37158 265 20 or or CC 37158 265 21 offensive offensive JJ 37158 265 22 animals animal NNS 37158 265 23 . . . 37158 266 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 266 2 do do VBP 37158 266 3 not not RB 37158 266 4 believe believe VB 37158 266 5 there there EX 37158 266 6 is be VBZ 37158 266 7 a a DT 37158 266 8 man man NN 37158 266 9 foolish foolish JJ 37158 266 10 enough enough RB 37158 266 11 not not RB 37158 266 12 to to TO 37158 266 13 kill kill VB 37158 266 14 a a DT 37158 266 15 mosquito mosquito NN 37158 266 16 which which WDT 37158 266 17 is be VBZ 37158 266 18 stinging sting VBG 37158 266 19 him -PRON- PRP 37158 266 20 . . . 37158 267 1 No no DT 37158 267 2 one one PRP 37158 267 3 would would MD 37158 267 4 hesitate hesitate VB 37158 267 5 to to TO 37158 267 6 crush crush VB 37158 267 7 a a DT 37158 267 8 viper viper NN 37158 267 9 which which WDT 37158 267 10 is be VBZ 37158 267 11 on on IN 37158 267 12 the the DT 37158 267 13 point point NN 37158 267 14 of of IN 37158 267 15 biting bite VBG 37158 267 16 him -PRON- PRP 37158 267 17 , , , 37158 267 18 or or CC 37158 267 19 the the DT 37158 267 20 caterpillar caterpillar NN 37158 267 21 which which WDT 37158 267 22 is be VBZ 37158 267 23 eating eat VBG 37158 267 24 the the DT 37158 267 25 leaves leave NNS 37158 267 26 of of IN 37158 267 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 267 28 fruit fruit NN 37158 267 29 trees tree NNS 37158 267 30 . . . 37158 268 1 If if IN 37158 268 2 an an DT 37158 268 3 invasion invasion NN 37158 268 4 of of IN 37158 268 5 locusts locust NNS 37158 268 6 threatens threaten VBZ 37158 268 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 268 8 harvest harvest NN 37158 268 9 , , , 37158 268 10 we -PRON- PRP 37158 268 11 have have VBP 37158 268 12 the the DT 37158 268 13 right right NN 37158 268 14 to to TO 37158 268 15 stamp stamp VB 37158 268 16 out out RP 37158 268 17 these these DT 37158 268 18 legions legion NNS 37158 268 19 of of IN 37158 268 20 enemies enemy NNS 37158 268 21 . . . 37158 269 1 To to TO 37158 269 2 refuse refuse VB 37158 269 3 man man NN 37158 269 4 the the DT 37158 269 5 right right NN 37158 269 6 to to TO 37158 269 7 defend defend VB 37158 269 8 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 269 9 against against IN 37158 269 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 269 11 animal animal NN 37158 269 12 foes foe NNS 37158 269 13 is be VBZ 37158 269 14 such such PDT 37158 269 15 a a DT 37158 269 16 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 37158 269 17 proposition proposition NN 37158 269 18 that that IN 37158 269 19 it -PRON- PRP 37158 269 20 is be VBZ 37158 269 21 useless useless JJ 37158 269 22 even even RB 37158 269 23 to to TO 37158 269 24 attempt attempt VB 37158 269 25 to to TO 37158 269 26 combat combat VB 37158 269 27 it -PRON- PRP 37158 269 28 . . . 37158 270 1 Not not RB 37158 270 2 only only RB 37158 270 3 have have VBP 37158 270 4 we -PRON- PRP 37158 270 5 the the DT 37158 270 6 right right NN 37158 270 7 to to TO 37158 270 8 wage wage VB 37158 270 9 war war NN 37158 270 10 against against IN 37158 270 11 offensive offensive JJ 37158 270 12 animals animal NNS 37158 270 13 , , , 37158 270 14 such such JJ 37158 270 15 as as IN 37158 270 16 rats rat NNS 37158 270 17 , , , 37158 270 18 mice mouse NNS 37158 270 19 , , , 37158 270 20 caterpillars caterpillar NNS 37158 270 21 , , , 37158 270 22 locusts locust NNS 37158 270 23 , , , 37158 270 24 bugs bug NNS 37158 270 25 , , , 37158 270 26 mosquitoes mosquito NNS 37158 270 27 , , , 37158 270 28 serpents serpent NNS 37158 270 29 , , , 37158 270 30 wolves wolf NNS 37158 270 31 , , , 37158 270 32 tigers tiger NNS 37158 270 33 , , , 37158 270 34 hyaenas hyaenas NNP 37158 270 35 , , , 37158 270 36 and and CC 37158 270 37 all all DT 37158 270 38 ferocious ferocious JJ 37158 270 39 and and CC 37158 270 40 mischievous mischievous JJ 37158 270 41 animals animal NNS 37158 270 42 , , , 37158 270 43 but but CC 37158 270 44 we -PRON- PRP 37158 270 45 have have VBP 37158 270 46 also also RB 37158 270 47 the the DT 37158 270 48 right right NN 37158 270 49 to to TO 37158 270 50 kill kill VB 37158 270 51 such such JJ 37158 270 52 animals animal NNS 37158 270 53 as as IN 37158 270 54 are be VBP 37158 270 55 necessary necessary JJ 37158 270 56 for for IN 37158 270 57 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 270 58 nourishment nourishment NN 37158 270 59 . . . 37158 271 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 271 2 am be VBP 37158 271 3 quite quite RB 37158 271 4 aware aware JJ 37158 271 5 of of IN 37158 271 6 the the DT 37158 271 7 fact fact NN 37158 271 8 that that IN 37158 271 9 certain certain JJ 37158 271 10 religions religion NNS 37158 271 11 proscribe proscribe VBP 37158 271 12 the the DT 37158 271 13 use use NN 37158 271 14 of of IN 37158 271 15 meat meat NN 37158 271 16 . . . 37158 272 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 272 2 am be VBP 37158 272 3 also also RB 37158 272 4 aware aware JJ 37158 272 5 that that IN 37158 272 6 an an DT 37158 272 7 exclusively exclusively RB 37158 272 8 vegetable vegetable JJ 37158 272 9 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 272 10 might may MD 37158 272 11 be be VB 37158 272 12 substituted substitute VBN 37158 272 13 for for IN 37158 272 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 272 15 customary customary JJ 37158 272 16 mixed mix VBN 37158 272 17 diet diet NN 37158 272 18 , , , 37158 272 19 which which WDT 37158 272 20 is be VBZ 37158 272 21 both both DT 37158 272 22 animal animal NN 37158 272 23 and and CC 37158 272 24 vegetable vegetable JJ 37158 272 25 . . . 37158 273 1 But but CC 37158 273 2 , , , 37158 273 3 though though IN 37158 273 4 a a DT 37158 273 5 vegetable vegetable NN 37158 273 6 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 273 7 is be VBZ 37158 273 8 possible possible JJ 37158 273 9 , , , 37158 273 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 273 11 western western JJ 37158 273 12 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 273 13 is be VBZ 37158 273 14 bound bind VBN 37158 273 15 up up RP 37158 273 16 with with IN 37158 273 17 the the DT 37158 273 18 principle principle NN 37158 273 19 of of IN 37158 273 20 a a DT 37158 273 21 mixed mixed JJ 37158 273 22 diet diet NN 37158 273 23 in in IN 37158 273 24 the the DT 37158 273 25 ordinary ordinary JJ 37158 273 26 conditions condition NNS 37158 273 27 of of IN 37158 273 28 life life NN 37158 273 29 . . . 37158 274 1 If if IN 37158 274 2 , , , 37158 274 3 indeed indeed RB 37158 274 4 , , , 37158 274 5 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 274 6 should should MD 37158 274 7 be be VB 37158 274 8 exclusively exclusively RB 37158 274 9 vegetable vegetable JJ 37158 274 10 , , , 37158 274 11 it -PRON- PRP 37158 274 12 would would MD 37158 274 13 be be VB 37158 274 14 useless useless JJ 37158 274 15 to to TO 37158 274 16 hunt hunt VB 37158 274 17 , , , 37158 274 18 to to TO 37158 274 19 fish fish VB 37158 274 20 , , , 37158 274 21 to to TO 37158 274 22 rear rear VB 37158 274 23 poultry poultry NN 37158 274 24 , , , 37158 274 25 to to TO 37158 274 26 breed breed VB 37158 274 27 cattle cattle NNS 37158 274 28 for for IN 37158 274 29 the the DT 37158 274 30 market market NN 37158 274 31 ; ; , 37158 274 32 and and CC 37158 274 33 it -PRON- PRP 37158 274 34 would would MD 37158 274 35 be be VB 37158 274 36 necessary necessary JJ 37158 274 37 to to TO 37158 274 38 confine confine VB 37158 274 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 274 40 nutriment nutriment NN 37158 274 41 exclusively exclusively RB 37158 274 42 to to IN 37158 274 43 wheat wheat NN 37158 274 44 , , , 37158 274 45 corn corn NN 37158 274 46 , , , 37158 274 47 maize maize NN 37158 274 48 , , , 37158 274 49 rice rice NN 37158 274 50 , , , 37158 274 51 herbs herb NNS 37158 274 52 , , , 37158 274 53 and and CC 37158 274 54 fruits fruit NNS 37158 274 55 . . . 37158 275 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly JJ 37158 275 2 man man NN 37158 275 3 , , , 37158 275 4 thus thus RB 37158 275 5 nourished nourish VBN 37158 275 6 , , , 37158 275 7 could could MD 37158 275 8 live live VB 37158 275 9 , , , 37158 275 10 and and CC 37158 275 11 indeed indeed RB 37158 275 12 live live VB 37158 275 13 very very RB 37158 275 14 well well RB 37158 275 15 ; ; : 37158 275 16 but but CC 37158 275 17 vegetarianism vegetarianism NN 37158 275 18 would would MD 37158 275 19 be be VB 37158 275 20 such such PDT 37158 275 21 a a DT 37158 275 22 radical radical JJ 37158 275 23 reform reform NN 37158 275 24 in in IN 37158 275 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 275 26 customs custom NNS 37158 275 27 that that WDT 37158 275 28 in in IN 37158 275 29 an an DT 37158 275 30 article article NN 37158 275 31 bearing bearing NN 37158 275 32 solely solely RB 37158 275 33 upon upon IN 37158 275 34 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 275 35 I -PRON- PRP 37158 275 36 can can MD 37158 275 37 not not RB 37158 275 38 handle handle VB 37158 275 39 such such PDT 37158 275 40 a a DT 37158 275 41 vast vast JJ 37158 275 42 problem problem NN 37158 275 43 . . . 37158 276 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 276 2 recognise recognise VBP 37158 276 3 that that IN 37158 276 4 those those DT 37158 276 5 anti anti NNS 37158 276 6 - - NNS 37158 276 7 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 276 8 who who WP 37158 276 9 are be VBP 37158 276 10 at at IN 37158 276 11 the the DT 37158 276 12 same same JJ 37158 276 13 time time NN 37158 276 14 strict strict JJ 37158 276 15 vegetarians vegetarian NNS 37158 276 16 are be VBP 37158 276 17 consistent consistent JJ 37158 276 18 ; ; : 37158 276 19 they -PRON- PRP 37158 276 20 live live VBP 37158 276 21 entirely entirely RB 37158 276 22 on on IN 37158 276 23 fruit fruit NN 37158 276 24 and and CC 37158 276 25 vegetables vegetable NNS 37158 276 26 , , , 37158 276 27 make make VB 37158 276 28 no no DT 37158 276 29 use use NN 37158 276 30 of of IN 37158 276 31 animal animal NN 37158 276 32 flesh flesh NN 37158 276 33 , , , 37158 276 34 for for IN 37158 276 35 they -PRON- PRP 37158 276 36 contest contest VBP 37158 276 37 the the DT 37158 276 38 right right NN 37158 276 39 of of IN 37158 276 40 man man NN 37158 276 41 to to TO 37158 276 42 kill kill VB 37158 276 43 an an DT 37158 276 44 animal animal NN 37158 276 45 for for IN 37158 276 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 276 47 nourishment nourishment NN 37158 276 48 . . . 37158 277 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 277 2 is be VBZ 37158 277 3 difficult difficult JJ 37158 277 4 to to TO 37158 277 5 reply reply VB 37158 277 6 to to IN 37158 277 7 such such JJ 37158 277 8 vegetarian,[4 vegetarian,[4 NN 37158 277 9 ] ] -RRB- 37158 277 10 for for IN 37158 277 11 , , , 37158 277 12 after after RB 37158 277 13 all all RB 37158 277 14 , , , 37158 277 15 animal animal NN 37158 277 16 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 277 17 is be VBZ 37158 277 18 not not RB 37158 277 19 indispensable indispensable JJ 37158 277 20 to to IN 37158 277 21 human human JJ 37158 277 22 life life NN 37158 277 23 . . . 37158 278 1 But but CC 37158 278 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 278 3 must must MD 37158 278 4 take take VB 37158 278 5 things thing NNS 37158 278 6 as as IN 37158 278 7 they -PRON- PRP 37158 278 8 actually actually RB 37158 278 9 exist exist VBP 37158 278 10 . . . 37158 279 1 The the DT 37158 279 2 bulk bulk NN 37158 279 3 of of IN 37158 279 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 279 5 readers reader NNS 37158 279 6 and and CC 37158 279 7 the the DT 37158 279 8 majority majority NN 37158 279 9 of of IN 37158 279 10 anti anti NNS 37158 279 11 - - NNS 37158 279 12 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 279 13 are be VBP 37158 279 14 not not RB 37158 279 15 vegetarians vegetarian NNS 37158 279 16 ; ; : 37158 279 17 and and CC 37158 279 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 279 19 is be VBZ 37158 279 20 only only RB 37158 279 21 an an DT 37158 279 22 innocent innocent JJ 37158 279 23 pastime pastime NN 37158 279 24 to to TO 37158 279 25 build build VB 37158 279 26 up up RP 37158 279 27 new new JJ 37158 279 28 civilisations civilisation NNS 37158 279 29 in in IN 37158 279 30 the the DT 37158 279 31 fantastic fantastic JJ 37158 279 32 realms realm NNS 37158 279 33 of of IN 37158 279 34 Utopia Utopia NNP 37158 279 35 . . . 37158 280 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 280 2 are be VBP 37158 280 3 not not RB 37158 280 4 , , , 37158 280 5 then then RB 37158 280 6 , , , 37158 280 7 addressing address VBG 37158 280 8 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 280 9 to to IN 37158 280 10 vegetarians vegetarian NNS 37158 280 11 , , , 37158 280 12 but but CC 37158 280 13 to to IN 37158 280 14 those those DT 37158 280 15 anti anti NNS 37158 280 16 - - NNS 37158 280 17 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 280 18 who who WP 37158 280 19 feel feel VBP 37158 280 20 no no DT 37158 280 21 compunction compunction NN 37158 280 22 in in IN 37158 280 23 drinking drink VBG 37158 280 24 broth broth NN 37158 280 25 or or CC 37158 280 26 milk milk NN 37158 280 27 or or CC 37158 280 28 eating eat VBG 37158 280 29 the the DT 37158 280 30 wing wing NN 37158 280 31 of of IN 37158 280 32 a a DT 37158 280 33 chicken chicken NN 37158 280 34 , , , 37158 280 35 who who WP 37158 280 36 do do VBP 37158 280 37 not not RB 37158 280 38 shrink shrink VB 37158 280 39 with with IN 37158 280 40 horror horror NN 37158 280 41 from from IN 37158 280 42 the the DT 37158 280 43 sight sight NN 37158 280 44 of of IN 37158 280 45 a a DT 37158 280 46 cutlet cutlet NN 37158 280 47 , , , 37158 280 48 and and CC 37158 280 49 who who WP 37158 280 50 are be VBP 37158 280 51 capable capable JJ 37158 280 52 of of IN 37158 280 53 eating eat VBG 37158 280 54 meat meat NN 37158 280 55 twice twice PDT 37158 280 56 a a DT 37158 280 57 day day NN 37158 280 58 throughout throughout IN 37158 280 59 the the DT 37158 280 60 whole whole JJ 37158 280 61 term term NN 37158 280 62 of of IN 37158 280 63 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 280 64 existence existence NN 37158 280 65 . . . 37158 281 1 These these DT 37158 281 2 people people NNS 37158 281 3 know know VBP 37158 281 4 full full JJ 37158 281 5 well well RB 37158 281 6 that that IN 37158 281 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 281 8 was be VBD 37158 281 9 necessary necessary JJ 37158 281 10 to to TO 37158 281 11 kill kill VB 37158 281 12 the the DT 37158 281 13 animal animal NN 37158 281 14 which which WDT 37158 281 15 serves serve VBZ 37158 281 16 them -PRON- PRP 37158 281 17 for for IN 37158 281 18 food food NN 37158 281 19 : : : 37158 281 20 the the DT 37158 281 21 ox ox NNP 37158 281 22 was be VBD 37158 281 23 beaten beat VBN 37158 281 24 to to IN 37158 281 25 death death NN 37158 281 26 ; ; : 37158 281 27 the the DT 37158 281 28 sheep sheep NN 37158 281 29 had have VBD 37158 281 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 281 31 throat throat NN 37158 281 32 cut cut VBN 37158 281 33 open open JJ 37158 281 34 ; ; : 37158 281 35 the the DT 37158 281 36 pig pig NN 37158 281 37 was be VBD 37158 281 38 bled bleed VBN 37158 281 39 to to IN 37158 281 40 death death NN 37158 281 41 ; ; : 37158 281 42 the the DT 37158 281 43 cod cod NN 37158 281 44 and and CC 37158 281 45 the the DT 37158 281 46 sardine sardine NN 37158 281 47 were be VBD 37158 281 48 suffocated suffocate VBN 37158 281 49 . . . 37158 282 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 282 2 pass pass VBP 37158 282 3 over over RP 37158 282 4 the the DT 37158 282 5 tortures torture NNS 37158 282 6 which which WDT 37158 282 7 special special JJ 37158 282 8 preparations preparation NNS 37158 282 9 and and CC 37158 282 10 elegant elegant JJ 37158 282 11 sports sport NNS 37158 282 12 inflict inflict NN 37158 282 13 on on IN 37158 282 14 the the DT 37158 282 15 animal animal NN 37158 282 16 for for IN 37158 282 17 the the DT 37158 282 18 mere mere JJ 37158 282 19 savour savour NN 37158 282 20 of of IN 37158 282 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 282 22 meals meal NNS 37158 282 23 : : : 37158 282 24 geese geese NNPS 37158 282 25 stuffed stuff VBN 37158 282 26 by by IN 37158 282 27 force force NN 37158 282 28 for for IN 37158 282 29 months month NNS 37158 282 30 whilst whilst IN 37158 282 31 nailed nail VBD 37158 282 32 down down RP 37158 282 33 to to IN 37158 282 34 boards board NNS 37158 282 35 ; ; : 37158 282 36 pheasants pheasant NNS 37158 282 37 , , , 37158 282 38 partridges partridge NNS 37158 282 39 , , , 37158 282 40 hares hare NNS 37158 282 41 , , , 37158 282 42 slaughtered slaughter VBN 37158 282 43 in in IN 37158 282 44 the the DT 37158 282 45 hunt hunt NN 37158 282 46 ; ; : 37158 282 47 fish fish NN 37158 282 48 thrown throw VBN 37158 282 49 into into IN 37158 282 50 boats boat NNS 37158 282 51 , , , 37158 282 52 gasping gasping NN 37158 282 53 and and CC 37158 282 54 finally finally RB 37158 282 55 dying die VBG 37158 282 56 after after IN 37158 282 57 long long JJ 37158 282 58 , , , 37158 282 59 agonising agonising JJ 37158 282 60 struggles struggle NNS 37158 282 61 . . . 37158 283 1 All all PDT 37158 283 2 these these DT 37158 283 3 and and CC 37158 283 4 other other JJ 37158 283 5 tortures torture NNS 37158 283 6 are be VBP 37158 283 7 inflicted inflict VBN 37158 283 8 by by IN 37158 283 9 man man NN 37158 283 10 on on IN 37158 283 11 the the DT 37158 283 12 animal animal NN 37158 283 13 in in IN 37158 283 14 order order NN 37158 283 15 to to TO 37158 283 16 satisfy satisfy VB 37158 283 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 283 18 pleasure pleasure NN 37158 283 19 and and CC 37158 283 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 283 21 appetite appetite NN 37158 283 22 . . . 37158 284 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 37158 284 2 these these DT 37158 284 3 anti anti NNS 37158 284 4 - - NNS 37158 284 5 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 284 6 have have VBP 37158 284 7 never never RB 37158 284 8 visited visit VBN 37158 284 9 a a DT 37158 284 10 slaughter slaughter NN 37158 284 11 - - HYPH 37158 284 12 house house NN 37158 284 13 when when WRB 37158 284 14 the the DT 37158 284 15 moment moment NN 37158 284 16 for for IN 37158 284 17 killing kill VBG 37158 284 18 the the DT 37158 284 19 sheep sheep NNS 37158 284 20 has have VBZ 37158 284 21 arrived arrive VBN 37158 284 22 . . . 37158 285 1 There there RB 37158 285 2 , , , 37158 285 3 bound bind VBN 37158 285 4 and and CC 37158 285 5 stretched stretch VBD 37158 285 6 out out RP 37158 285 7 on on IN 37158 285 8 an an DT 37158 285 9 immense immense JJ 37158 285 10 table table NN 37158 285 11 , , , 37158 285 12 are be VBP 37158 285 13 to to TO 37158 285 14 be be VB 37158 285 15 seen see VBN 37158 285 16 five five CD 37158 285 17 hundred hundred CD 37158 285 18 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 285 19 sheep sheep NN 37158 285 20 , , , 37158 285 21 with with IN 37158 285 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 285 23 throats throat NNS 37158 285 24 thrust thrust VBN 37158 285 25 forth forth RB 37158 285 26 . . . 37158 286 1 The the DT 37158 286 2 butcher butcher NN 37158 286 3 passes pass VBZ 37158 286 4 in in IN 37158 286 5 front front NN 37158 286 6 and and CC 37158 286 7 , , , 37158 286 8 with with IN 37158 286 9 a a DT 37158 286 10 stroke stroke NN 37158 286 11 of of IN 37158 286 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 286 13 knife knife NN 37158 286 14 , , , 37158 286 15 slashes slash VBZ 37158 286 16 open open VBP 37158 286 17 the the DT 37158 286 18 neck neck NN 37158 286 19 and and CC 37158 286 20 throat throat NN 37158 286 21 of of IN 37158 286 22 the the DT 37158 286 23 poor poor JJ 37158 286 24 wretches wretch NNS 37158 286 25 ; ; : 37158 286 26 the the DT 37158 286 27 blood blood NN 37158 286 28 spouts spout VBZ 37158 286 29 out out RP 37158 286 30 , , , 37158 286 31 convulsions convulsion NNS 37158 286 32 rend rend VBP 37158 286 33 the the DT 37158 286 34 body body NN 37158 286 35 , , , 37158 286 36 and and CC 37158 286 37 only only RB 37158 286 38 at at IN 37158 286 39 the the DT 37158 286 40 end end NN 37158 286 41 of of IN 37158 286 42 one one CD 37158 286 43 minute minute NN 37158 286 44 or or CC 37158 286 45 one one CD 37158 286 46 and and CC 37158 286 47 a a DT 37158 286 48 half half NN 37158 286 49 minutes minute NNS 37158 286 50 does do VBZ 37158 286 51 death death NN 37158 286 52 supervene supervene NN 37158 286 53 . . . 37158 287 1 This this DT 37158 287 2 is be VBZ 37158 287 3 death death NN 37158 287 4 in in IN 37158 287 5 all all DT 37158 287 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 287 7 savage savage JJ 37158 287 8 horror horror NN 37158 287 9 inflicted inflict VBN 37158 287 10 by by IN 37158 287 11 man man NN 37158 287 12 on on IN 37158 287 13 the the DT 37158 287 14 animal animal NN 37158 287 15 . . . 37158 288 1 There there EX 37158 288 2 are be VBP 37158 288 3 anti anti JJ 37158 288 4 - - NNS 37158 288 5 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 288 6 who who WP 37158 288 7 accept accept VBP 37158 288 8 this this DT 37158 288 9 . . . 37158 289 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 289 2 , , , 37158 289 3 they -PRON- PRP 37158 289 4 recognise recognise VBP 37158 289 5 implicitly implicitly RB 37158 289 6 man man NN 37158 289 7 's 's POS 37158 289 8 right right NN 37158 289 9 to to TO 37158 289 10 kill kill VB 37158 289 11 animals animal NNS 37158 289 12 , , , 37158 289 13 since since IN 37158 289 14 they -PRON- PRP 37158 289 15 profit profit VBP 37158 289 16 by by IN 37158 289 17 such such JJ 37158 289 18 slaughter slaughter NN 37158 289 19 for for IN 37158 289 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 289 21 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 289 22 ; ; : 37158 289 23 they -PRON- PRP 37158 289 24 add add VBP 37158 289 25 , , , 37158 289 26 however however RB 37158 289 27 , , , 37158 289 28 that that IN 37158 289 29 though though IN 37158 289 30 man man NN 37158 289 31 has have VBZ 37158 289 32 a a DT 37158 289 33 right right NN 37158 289 34 to to TO 37158 289 35 kill kill VB 37158 289 36 , , , 37158 289 37 he -PRON- PRP 37158 289 38 has have VBZ 37158 289 39 no no DT 37158 289 40 right right NN 37158 289 41 to to TO 37158 289 42 cause cause VB 37158 289 43 suffering suffering NN 37158 289 44 . . . 37158 290 1 Is be VBZ 37158 290 2 there there EX 37158 290 3 no no DT 37158 290 4 suffering suffering NN 37158 290 5 in in IN 37158 290 6 the the DT 37158 290 7 slaughter slaughter NN 37158 290 8 - - HYPH 37158 290 9 house house NN 37158 290 10 ? ? . 37158 291 1 Are be VBP 37158 291 2 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 291 3 ever ever RB 37158 291 4 dreamt dreamt NN 37158 291 5 of of IN 37158 291 6 there there RB 37158 291 7 ? ? . 37158 292 1 2 2 LS 37158 292 2 . . . 37158 293 1 Now now RB 37158 293 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 293 3 is be VBZ 37158 293 4 impossible impossible JJ 37158 293 5 to to TO 37158 293 6 point point VB 37158 293 7 out out RP 37158 293 8 the the DT 37158 293 9 boundary boundary JJ 37158 293 10 line line NN 37158 293 11 which which WDT 37158 293 12 separates separate VBZ 37158 293 13 the the DT 37158 293 14 being being NN 37158 293 15 that that WDT 37158 293 16 suffers suffer VBZ 37158 293 17 from from IN 37158 293 18 the the DT 37158 293 19 being being NN 37158 293 20 that that WDT 37158 293 21 does do VBZ 37158 293 22 not not RB 37158 293 23 suffer suffer VB 37158 293 24 ; ; : 37158 293 25 and and CC 37158 293 26 I -PRON- PRP 37158 293 27 defy defy VBP 37158 293 28 any any DT 37158 293 29 one one NN 37158 293 30 to to TO 37158 293 31 establish establish VB 37158 293 32 any any DT 37158 293 33 line line NN 37158 293 34 of of IN 37158 293 35 demarcation demarcation NN 37158 293 36 whatsoever whatsoever RB 37158 293 37 between between IN 37158 293 38 a a DT 37158 293 39 being be VBG 37158 293 40 capable capable JJ 37158 293 41 of of IN 37158 293 42 pain pain NN 37158 293 43 and and CC 37158 293 44 a a DT 37158 293 45 being be VBG 37158 293 46 incapable incapable JJ 37158 293 47 of of IN 37158 293 48 pain pain NN 37158 293 49 . . . 37158 294 1 Plants plant NNS 37158 294 2 certainly certainly RB 37158 294 3 do do VBP 37158 294 4 not not RB 37158 294 5 suffer suffer VB 37158 294 6 . . . 37158 295 1 Already already RB 37158 295 2 , , , 37158 295 3 however however RB 37158 295 4 , , , 37158 295 5 there there EX 37158 295 6 are be VBP 37158 295 7 certain certain JJ 37158 295 8 difficulties difficulty NNS 37158 295 9 in in IN 37158 295 10 the the DT 37158 295 11 way way NN 37158 295 12 of of IN 37158 295 13 determining determine VBG 37158 295 14 the the DT 37158 295 15 exact exact JJ 37158 295 16 boundary boundary JJ 37158 295 17 line line NN 37158 295 18 between between IN 37158 295 19 the the DT 37158 295 20 animal animal NN 37158 295 21 and and CC 37158 295 22 the the DT 37158 295 23 plant plant NN 37158 295 24 . . . 37158 296 1 When when WRB 37158 296 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 296 3 expose expose VBP 37158 296 4 an an DT 37158 296 5 infusion infusion NN 37158 296 6 of of IN 37158 296 7 hay hay NN 37158 296 8 to to IN 37158 296 9 the the DT 37158 296 10 air air NN 37158 296 11 , , , 37158 296 12 for for IN 37158 296 13 instance instance NN 37158 296 14 , , , 37158 296 15 various various JJ 37158 296 16 microbes microbe NNS 37158 296 17 develop develop VBP 37158 296 18 therein therein RB 37158 296 19 . . . 37158 297 1 A a DT 37158 297 2 learned learned JJ 37158 297 3 and and CC 37158 297 4 minute minute NN 37158 297 5 analysis analysis NN 37158 297 6 allows allow VBZ 37158 297 7 us -PRON- PRP 37158 297 8 to to TO 37158 297 9 distinguish distinguish VB 37158 297 10 both both DT 37158 297 11 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 297 12 and and CC 37158 297 13 infusoria infusoria NNS 37158 297 14 among among IN 37158 297 15 the the DT 37158 297 16 innumerable innumerable JJ 37158 297 17 micro micro JJ 37158 297 18 - - HYPH 37158 297 19 organisms organism NNS 37158 297 20 which which WDT 37158 297 21 swarm swarm VBP 37158 297 22 in in IN 37158 297 23 the the DT 37158 297 24 infusion infusion NN 37158 297 25 . . . 37158 298 1 Now now RB 37158 298 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 298 3 know know VBP 37158 298 4 that that IN 37158 298 5 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 298 6 are be VBP 37158 298 7 plants plant NNS 37158 298 8 and and CC 37158 298 9 infusoria infusoria NNS 37158 298 10 are be VBP 37158 298 11 animals animal NNS 37158 298 12 . . . 37158 299 1 If if IN 37158 299 2 , , , 37158 299 3 therefore therefore RB 37158 299 4 , , , 37158 299 5 all all DT 37158 299 6 animal animal NN 37158 299 7 life life NN 37158 299 8 were be VBD 37158 299 9 eliminated eliminate VBN 37158 299 10 from from IN 37158 299 11 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 299 12 , , , 37158 299 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 299 14 should should MD 37158 299 15 have have VB 37158 299 16 no no DT 37158 299 17 right right NN 37158 299 18 to to TO 37158 299 19 boil boil VB 37158 299 20 an an DT 37158 299 21 infusion infusion NN 37158 299 22 of of IN 37158 299 23 hay hay NN 37158 299 24 , , , 37158 299 25 because because IN 37158 299 26 we -PRON- PRP 37158 299 27 know know VBP 37158 299 28 that that IN 37158 299 29 it -PRON- PRP 37158 299 30 contains contain VBZ 37158 299 31 infusoria infusoria NNS 37158 299 32 which which WDT 37158 299 33 are be VBP 37158 299 34 animals animal NNS 37158 299 35 . . . 37158 300 1 These these DT 37158 300 2 infusoria infusoria NNS 37158 300 3 are be VBP 37158 300 4 so so RB 37158 300 5 closely closely RB 37158 300 6 related related JJ 37158 300 7 to to IN 37158 300 8 bacteria bacteria NNS 37158 300 9 that that IN 37158 300 10 they -PRON- PRP 37158 300 11 may may MD 37158 300 12 be be VB 37158 300 13 confused confuse VBN 37158 300 14 with with IN 37158 300 15 the the DT 37158 300 16 latter latter JJ 37158 300 17 , , , 37158 300 18 as as IN 37158 300 19 indeed indeed RB 37158 300 20 has have VBZ 37158 300 21 been be VBN 37158 300 22 the the DT 37158 300 23 case case NN 37158 300 24 up up IN 37158 300 25 to to IN 37158 300 26 the the DT 37158 300 27 last last JJ 37158 300 28 few few JJ 37158 300 29 years year NNS 37158 300 30 . . . 37158 301 1 A a DT 37158 301 2 number number NN 37158 301 3 of of IN 37158 301 4 inferior inferior JJ 37158 301 5 beings being NNS 37158 301 6 were be VBD 37158 301 7 formerly formerly RB 37158 301 8 called call VBN 37158 301 9 zoophytes zoophyte NNS 37158 301 10 , , , 37158 301 11 that that DT 37158 301 12 is be VBZ 37158 301 13 to to TO 37158 301 14 say say VB 37158 301 15 , , , 37158 301 16 animal animal NN 37158 301 17 plants plant NNS 37158 301 18 ; ; : 37158 301 19 and and CC 37158 301 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 301 21 is be VBZ 37158 301 22 sheer sheer JJ 37158 301 23 nonsense nonsense NN 37158 301 24 to to TO 37158 301 25 suppose suppose VB 37158 301 26 that that IN 37158 301 27 they -PRON- PRP 37158 301 28 are be VBP 37158 301 29 conscious conscious JJ 37158 301 30 of of IN 37158 301 31 pain pain NN 37158 301 32 . . . 37158 302 1 Sponges sponge NNS 37158 302 2 , , , 37158 302 3 corals coral NNS 37158 302 4 , , , 37158 302 5 sea sea NN 37158 302 6 - - HYPH 37158 302 7 anemones anemone NNS 37158 302 8 , , , 37158 302 9 star star NN 37158 302 10 - - HYPH 37158 302 11 fishes fish NNS 37158 302 12 , , , 37158 302 13 sea sea NN 37158 302 14 - - HYPH 37158 302 15 urchins urchin NNS 37158 302 16 , , , 37158 302 17 possess possess VBP 37158 302 18 a a DT 37158 302 19 nervous nervous JJ 37158 302 20 system system NN 37158 302 21 which which WDT 37158 302 22 is be VBZ 37158 302 23 so so RB 37158 302 24 little little JJ 37158 302 25 developed developed JJ 37158 302 26 , , , 37158 302 27 and and CC 37158 302 28 reactions reaction NNS 37158 302 29 which which WDT 37158 302 30 are be VBP 37158 302 31 so so RB 37158 302 32 indistinct indistinct JJ 37158 302 33 , , , 37158 302 34 that that IN 37158 302 35 we -PRON- PRP 37158 302 36 can can MD 37158 302 37 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 302 38 suppose suppose VB 37158 302 39 they -PRON- PRP 37158 302 40 possess possess VBP 37158 302 41 an an DT 37158 302 42 intelligent intelligent JJ 37158 302 43 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 302 44 , , , 37158 302 45 and and CC 37158 302 46 , , , 37158 302 47 consequently consequently RB 37158 302 48 , , , 37158 302 49 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 302 50 to to TO 37158 302 51 pain pain VB 37158 302 52 . . . 37158 303 1 Moreover moreover RB 37158 303 2 , , , 37158 303 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 303 4 do do VBP 37158 303 5 not not RB 37158 303 6 see see VB 37158 303 7 how how WRB 37158 303 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 303 9 reactions reaction NNS 37158 303 10 would would MD 37158 303 11 differ differ VB 37158 303 12 if if IN 37158 303 13 they -PRON- PRP 37158 303 14 possessed possess VBD 37158 303 15 the the DT 37158 303 16 notion notion NN 37158 303 17 of of IN 37158 303 18 pain pain NN 37158 303 19 . . . 37158 304 1 When when WRB 37158 304 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 304 3 touch touch VBP 37158 304 4 the the DT 37158 304 5 tentacles tentacle NNS 37158 304 6 of of IN 37158 304 7 a a DT 37158 304 8 star star NN 37158 304 9 - - HYPH 37158 304 10 fish fish NN 37158 304 11 , , , 37158 304 12 we -PRON- PRP 37158 304 13 notice notice VBP 37158 304 14 , , , 37158 304 15 near near IN 37158 304 16 the the DT 37158 304 17 tentacles tentacle NNS 37158 304 18 touched touch VBD 37158 304 19 , , , 37158 304 20 a a DT 37158 304 21 sort sort NN 37158 304 22 of of IN 37158 304 23 agitation agitation NN 37158 304 24 set set VBN 37158 304 25 up up RP 37158 304 26 among among IN 37158 304 27 the the DT 37158 304 28 neighbouring neighbour VBG 37158 304 29 tentacles tentacle NNS 37158 304 30 , , , 37158 304 31 but but CC 37158 304 32 this this DT 37158 304 33 agitation agitation NN 37158 304 34 does do VBZ 37158 304 35 not not RB 37158 304 36 extend extend VB 37158 304 37 to to IN 37158 304 38 the the DT 37158 304 39 tentacles tentacle NNS 37158 304 40 of of IN 37158 304 41 the the DT 37158 304 42 others other NNS 37158 304 43 ' ' POS 37158 304 44 arms arm NNS 37158 304 45 ; ; : 37158 304 46 so so CC 37158 304 47 that that IN 37158 304 48 a a DT 37158 304 49 general general JJ 37158 304 50 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 304 51 does do VBZ 37158 304 52 not not RB 37158 304 53 appear appear VB 37158 304 54 to to TO 37158 304 55 exist exist VB 37158 304 56 , , , 37158 304 57 unless unless IN 37158 304 58 it -PRON- PRP 37158 304 59 be be VBP 37158 304 60 in in IN 37158 304 61 a a DT 37158 304 62 prodigiously prodigiously RB 37158 304 63 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 37158 304 64 state state NN 37158 304 65 , , , 37158 304 66 among among IN 37158 304 67 inferior inferior JJ 37158 304 68 beings being NNS 37158 304 69 . . . 37158 305 1 In in IN 37158 305 2 certain certain JJ 37158 305 3 classes class NNS 37158 305 4 of of IN 37158 305 5 the the DT 37158 305 6 mollusca mollusca NN 37158 305 7 there there EX 37158 305 8 is be VBZ 37158 305 9 no no DT 37158 305 10 head head NN 37158 305 11 . . . 37158 306 1 Thus thus RB 37158 306 2 oysters oyster NNS 37158 306 3 and and CC 37158 306 4 mussels mussel NNS 37158 306 5 , , , 37158 306 6 named name VBN 37158 306 7 on on IN 37158 306 8 that that DT 37158 306 9 account account NN 37158 306 10 _ _ NNP 37158 306 11 acephala acephala NN 37158 306 12 _ _ NNP 37158 306 13 , , , 37158 306 14 have have VBP 37158 306 15 in in IN 37158 306 16 all all DT 37158 306 17 probability probability NN 37158 306 18 no no DT 37158 306 19 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 306 20 . . . 37158 307 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 307 2 would would MD 37158 307 3 have have VB 37158 307 4 no no DT 37158 307 5 scruple scruple NN 37158 307 6 , , , 37158 307 7 therefore therefore RB 37158 307 8 , , , 37158 307 9 either either CC 37158 307 10 in in IN 37158 307 11 eating eat VBG 37158 307 12 living living NN 37158 307 13 oysters oyster NNS 37158 307 14 , , , 37158 307 15 or or CC 37158 307 16 in in IN 37158 307 17 experimenting experiment VBG 37158 307 18 upon upon IN 37158 307 19 living live VBG 37158 307 20 oysters oyster NNS 37158 307 21 and and CC 37158 307 22 mussels mussel NNS 37158 307 23 , , , 37158 307 24 since since IN 37158 307 25 it -PRON- PRP 37158 307 26 seems seem VBZ 37158 307 27 to to IN 37158 307 28 me -PRON- PRP 37158 307 29 evident evident JJ 37158 307 30 that that IN 37158 307 31 the the DT 37158 307 32 notion notion NN 37158 307 33 of of IN 37158 307 34 pain pain NN 37158 307 35 does do VBZ 37158 307 36 not not RB 37158 307 37 exist exist VB 37158 307 38 in in IN 37158 307 39 them -PRON- PRP 37158 307 40 . . . 37158 308 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 308 2 is be VBZ 37158 308 3 not not RB 37158 308 4 the the DT 37158 308 5 same same JJ 37158 308 6 thing thing NN 37158 308 7 with with IN 37158 308 8 insects insect NNS 37158 308 9 ; ; : 37158 308 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 308 11 is be VBZ 37158 308 12 here here RB 37158 308 13 that that IN 37158 308 14 the the DT 37158 308 15 first first JJ 37158 308 16 signs sign NNS 37158 308 17 of of IN 37158 308 18 pain pain NN 37158 308 19 begin begin VBP 37158 308 20 to to TO 37158 308 21 appear appear VB 37158 308 22 . . . 37158 309 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 309 2 , , , 37158 309 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 309 4 must must MD 37158 309 5 be be VB 37158 309 6 careful careful JJ 37158 309 7 to to TO 37158 309 8 avoid avoid VB 37158 309 9 confusing confuse VBG 37158 309 10 pain pain NN 37158 309 11 with with IN 37158 309 12 signs sign NNS 37158 309 13 of of IN 37158 309 14 pain pain NN 37158 309 15 . . . 37158 310 1 When when WRB 37158 310 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 310 3 take take VBP 37158 310 4 a a DT 37158 310 5 worm worm NN 37158 310 6 and and CC 37158 310 7 cut cut VB 37158 310 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 310 9 into into IN 37158 310 10 three three CD 37158 310 11 segments segment NNS 37158 310 12 , , , 37158 310 13 each each DT 37158 310 14 of of IN 37158 310 15 these these DT 37158 310 16 segments segment NNS 37158 310 17 will will MD 37158 310 18 struggle struggle VB 37158 310 19 and and CC 37158 310 20 writhe writhe RBS 37158 310 21 in in IN 37158 310 22 a a DT 37158 310 23 perfect perfect JJ 37158 310 24 frenzy frenzy NN 37158 310 25 . . . 37158 311 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 311 2 would would MD 37158 311 3 , , , 37158 311 4 therefore therefore RB 37158 311 5 , , , 37158 311 6 be be VB 37158 311 7 necessary necessary JJ 37158 311 8 to to TO 37158 311 9 admit admit VB 37158 311 10 that that IN 37158 311 11 pain pain NN 37158 311 12 existed exist VBD 37158 311 13 in in IN 37158 311 14 each each DT 37158 311 15 of of IN 37158 311 16 these these DT 37158 311 17 three three CD 37158 311 18 segments segment NNS 37158 311 19 -- -- : 37158 311 20 in in IN 37158 311 21 other other JJ 37158 311 22 words word NNS 37158 311 23 , , , 37158 311 24 that that IN 37158 311 25 each each DT 37158 311 26 fragment fragment NN 37158 311 27 possesses possess VBZ 37158 311 28 a a DT 37158 311 29 central central JJ 37158 311 30 seat seat NN 37158 311 31 of of IN 37158 311 32 pain pain NN 37158 311 33 , , , 37158 311 34 which which WDT 37158 311 35 is be VBZ 37158 311 36 absurd absurd JJ 37158 311 37 ; ; : 37158 311 38 it -PRON- PRP 37158 311 39 is be VBZ 37158 311 40 much much RB 37158 311 41 more more RBR 37158 311 42 rational rational JJ 37158 311 43 to to TO 37158 311 44 suppose suppose VB 37158 311 45 that that IN 37158 311 46 the the DT 37158 311 47 perturbed perturbed JJ 37158 311 48 movements movement NNS 37158 311 49 of of IN 37158 311 50 the the DT 37158 311 51 animal animal NN 37158 311 52 are be VBP 37158 311 53 the the DT 37158 311 54 result result NN 37158 311 55 of of IN 37158 311 56 a a DT 37158 311 57 strong strong JJ 37158 311 58 nervous nervous JJ 37158 311 59 excitation excitation NN 37158 311 60 , , , 37158 311 61 and and CC 37158 311 62 that that IN 37158 311 63 the the DT 37158 311 64 injury injury NN 37158 311 65 is be VBZ 37158 311 66 accompanied accompany VBN 37158 311 67 by by IN 37158 311 68 defensive defensive JJ 37158 311 69 reflex reflex NN 37158 311 70 movements movement NNS 37158 311 71 but but CC 37158 311 72 provokes provoke VBZ 37158 311 73 no no DT 37158 311 74 painful painful JJ 37158 311 75 perception perception NN 37158 311 76 . . . 37158 312 1 Among among IN 37158 312 2 the the DT 37158 312 3 superior superior JJ 37158 312 4 animals animal NNS 37158 312 5 however however RB 37158 312 6 , , , 37158 312 7 and and CC 37158 312 8 especially especially RB 37158 312 9 among among IN 37158 312 10 the the DT 37158 312 11 vertebrata vertebrata NN 37158 312 12 , , , 37158 312 13 pain pain NN 37158 312 14 exists exist VBZ 37158 312 15 . . . 37158 313 1 There there EX 37158 313 2 can can MD 37158 313 3 be be VB 37158 313 4 no no DT 37158 313 5 doubt doubt NN 37158 313 6 about about IN 37158 313 7 this this DT 37158 313 8 , , , 37158 313 9 although although IN 37158 313 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 313 11 is be VBZ 37158 313 12 impossible impossible JJ 37158 313 13 to to TO 37158 313 14 know know VB 37158 313 15 exactly exactly RB 37158 313 16 in in IN 37158 313 17 what what WP 37158 313 18 consists consist VBZ 37158 313 19 the the DT 37158 313 20 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 313 21 of of IN 37158 313 22 pain pain NN 37158 313 23 in in IN 37158 313 24 an an DT 37158 313 25 animal animal NN 37158 313 26 ; ; : 37158 313 27 the the DT 37158 313 28 most most RBS 37158 313 29 profound profound JJ 37158 313 30 obscurity obscurity NN 37158 313 31 still still RB 37158 313 32 reigns reign VBZ 37158 313 33 , , , 37158 313 34 and and CC 37158 313 35 will will MD 37158 313 36 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 313 37 always always RB 37158 313 38 reign reign VB 37158 313 39 , , , 37158 313 40 over over IN 37158 313 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 313 42 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 313 43 and and CC 37158 313 44 sensations sensation NNS 37158 313 45 . . . 37158 314 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 314 2 would would MD 37158 314 3 be be VB 37158 314 4 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 37158 314 5 to to TO 37158 314 6 deny deny VB 37158 314 7 that that IN 37158 314 8 a a DT 37158 314 9 dog dog NN 37158 314 10 suffers suffer VBZ 37158 314 11 when when WRB 37158 314 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 314 13 paw paw NN 37158 314 14 is be VBZ 37158 314 15 crushed crush VBN 37158 314 16 . . . 37158 315 1 Certainly certainly RB 37158 315 2 , , , 37158 315 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 315 4 fully fully RB 37158 315 5 believe believe VBP 37158 315 6 that that IN 37158 315 7 all all DT 37158 315 8 pain pain NN 37158 315 9 is be VBZ 37158 315 10 much much RB 37158 315 11 less less RBR 37158 315 12 clearly clearly RB 37158 315 13 perceived perceive VBN 37158 315 14 by by IN 37158 315 15 the the DT 37158 315 16 dog dog NN 37158 315 17 than than IN 37158 315 18 by by IN 37158 315 19 man man NN 37158 315 20 . . . 37158 316 1 But but CC 37158 316 2 , , , 37158 316 3 after after RB 37158 316 4 all all RB 37158 316 5 , , , 37158 316 6 it -PRON- PRP 37158 316 7 is be VBZ 37158 316 8 a a DT 37158 316 9 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37158 316 10 of of IN 37158 316 11 the the DT 37158 316 12 same same JJ 37158 316 13 order order NN 37158 316 14 and and CC 37158 316 15 identical identical JJ 37158 316 16 , , , 37158 316 17 save save VB 37158 316 18 in in IN 37158 316 19 intensity intensity NN 37158 316 20 . . . 37158 317 1 Now now RB 37158 317 2 pain pain NN 37158 317 3 , , , 37158 317 4 taken take VBN 37158 317 5 in in IN 37158 317 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 317 7 profoundest profoundest NN 37158 317 8 sense sense NN 37158 317 9 , , , 37158 317 10 consists consist VBZ 37158 317 11 of of IN 37158 317 12 two two CD 37158 317 13 essential essential JJ 37158 317 14 elements element NNS 37158 317 15 : : : 37158 317 16 a a DT 37158 317 17 shock shock NN 37158 317 18 to to IN 37158 317 19 the the DT 37158 317 20 conscious conscious JJ 37158 317 21 self self NN 37158 317 22 , , , 37158 317 23 the the DT 37158 317 24 _ _ NNP 37158 317 25 ego ego NN 37158 317 26 _ _ NNP 37158 317 27 , , , 37158 317 28 in in IN 37158 317 29 the the DT 37158 317 30 first first JJ 37158 317 31 place place NN 37158 317 32 ; ; : 37158 317 33 and and CC 37158 317 34 , , , 37158 317 35 in in IN 37158 317 36 the the DT 37158 317 37 second second JJ 37158 317 38 place place NN 37158 317 39 , , , 37158 317 40 the the DT 37158 317 41 prolongation prolongation NN 37158 317 42 of of IN 37158 317 43 the the DT 37158 317 44 shock shock NN 37158 317 45 . . . 37158 318 1 If if IN 37158 318 2 the the DT 37158 318 3 self self NN 37158 318 4 is be VBZ 37158 318 5 not not RB 37158 318 6 distinctly distinctly RB 37158 318 7 conscious conscious JJ 37158 318 8 , , , 37158 318 9 if if IN 37158 318 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 318 11 does do VBZ 37158 318 12 not not RB 37158 318 13 go go VB 37158 318 14 so so RB 37158 318 15 far far RB 37158 318 16 as as IN 37158 318 17 to to TO 37158 318 18 assert assert VB 37158 318 19 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 318 20 by by IN 37158 318 21 the the DT 37158 318 22 separation separation NN 37158 318 23 of of IN 37158 318 24 that that DT 37158 318 25 self self NN 37158 318 26 from from IN 37158 318 27 the the DT 37158 318 28 external external JJ 37158 318 29 world world NN 37158 318 30 , , , 37158 318 31 we -PRON- PRP 37158 318 32 can can MD 37158 318 33 not not RB 37158 318 34 say say VB 37158 318 35 that that IN 37158 318 36 pain pain NN 37158 318 37 is be VBZ 37158 318 38 possible possible JJ 37158 318 39 . . . 37158 319 1 The the DT 37158 319 2 _ _ NNP 37158 319 3 ego ego NN 37158 319 4 _ _ NNP 37158 319 5 never never RB 37158 319 6 asserts assert VBZ 37158 319 7 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 319 8 with with IN 37158 319 9 so so RB 37158 319 10 much much JJ 37158 319 11 force force NN 37158 319 12 as as IN 37158 319 13 under under IN 37158 319 14 a a DT 37158 319 15 very very RB 37158 319 16 painful painful JJ 37158 319 17 impression impression NN 37158 319 18 . . . 37158 320 1 So so RB 37158 320 2 that that IN 37158 320 3 among among IN 37158 320 4 beings being NNS 37158 320 5 whose whose WP$ 37158 320 6 reactions reaction NNS 37158 320 7 are be VBP 37158 320 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 37158 320 9 , , , 37158 320 10 automatic automatic JJ 37158 320 11 , , , 37158 320 12 governed govern VBN 37158 320 13 by by IN 37158 320 14 other other JJ 37158 320 15 forces force NNS 37158 320 16 than than IN 37158 320 17 by by IN 37158 320 18 the the DT 37158 320 19 assertion assertion NN 37158 320 20 of of IN 37158 320 21 the the DT 37158 320 22 self self NN 37158 320 23 and and CC 37158 320 24 a a DT 37158 320 25 freely freely RB 37158 320 26 deliberate deliberate JJ 37158 320 27 will will NN 37158 320 28 , , , 37158 320 29 pain pain NN 37158 320 30 becomes become VBZ 37158 320 31 so so RB 37158 320 32 indistinct indistinct JJ 37158 320 33 , , , 37158 320 34 so so RB 37158 320 35 confused confused JJ 37158 320 36 , , , 37158 320 37 that that IN 37158 320 38 it -PRON- PRP 37158 320 39 probably probably RB 37158 320 40 does do VBZ 37158 320 41 not not RB 37158 320 42 exist exist VB 37158 320 43 in in IN 37158 320 44 the the DT 37158 320 45 strict strict JJ 37158 320 46 psychological psychological JJ 37158 320 47 sense sense NN 37158 320 48 at at RB 37158 320 49 all all RB 37158 320 50 . . . 37158 321 1 The the DT 37158 321 2 greatest great JJS 37158 321 3 philosopher philosopher NN 37158 321 4 of of IN 37158 321 5 modern modern JJ 37158 321 6 times time NNS 37158 321 7 , , , 37158 321 8 Descartes Descartes NNPS 37158 321 9 , , , 37158 321 10 imagined imagine VBD 37158 321 11 a a DT 37158 321 12 system system NN 37158 321 13 of of IN 37158 321 14 machine machine NN 37158 321 15 - - HYPH 37158 321 16 animals animal NNS 37158 321 17 ; ; : 37158 321 18 this this DT 37158 321 19 idea idea NN 37158 321 20 has have VBZ 37158 321 21 been be VBN 37158 321 22 turned turn VBN 37158 321 23 into into IN 37158 321 24 ridicule ridicule NN 37158 321 25 by by IN 37158 321 26 the the DT 37158 321 27 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 321 28 , , , 37158 321 29 but but CC 37158 321 30 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 321 31 we -PRON- PRP 37158 321 32 are be VBP 37158 321 33 almost almost RB 37158 321 34 forced force VBN 37158 321 35 to to TO 37158 321 36 return return VB 37158 321 37 to to IN 37158 321 38 it -PRON- PRP 37158 321 39 when when WRB 37158 321 40 we -PRON- PRP 37158 321 41 dive dive VBP 37158 321 42 to to IN 37158 321 43 the the DT 37158 321 44 bottom bottom NN 37158 321 45 of of IN 37158 321 46 reflex reflex JJ 37158 321 47 movements movement NNS 37158 321 48 . . . 37158 322 1 Now now RB 37158 322 2 , , , 37158 322 3 if if IN 37158 322 4 we -PRON- PRP 37158 322 5 are be VBP 37158 322 6 able able JJ 37158 322 7 to to TO 37158 322 8 admit admit VB 37158 322 9 that that IN 37158 322 10 there there EX 37158 322 11 is be VBZ 37158 322 12 a a DT 37158 322 13 vague vague JJ 37158 322 14 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 322 15 of of IN 37158 322 16 the the DT 37158 322 17 selfhood selfhood NN 37158 322 18 among among IN 37158 322 19 superior superior JJ 37158 322 20 animals animal NNS 37158 322 21 , , , 37158 322 22 such such JJ 37158 322 23 as as IN 37158 322 24 the the DT 37158 322 25 mammalia mammalia NN 37158 322 26 and and CC 37158 322 27 birds bird NNS 37158 322 28 , , , 37158 322 29 this this DT 37158 322 30 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 322 31 , , , 37158 322 32 as as RB 37158 322 33 far far RB 37158 322 34 as as IN 37158 322 35 concerns concern NNS 37158 322 36 the the DT 37158 322 37 inferior inferior JJ 37158 322 38 vertebrata vertebrata NN 37158 322 39 , , , 37158 322 40 is be VBZ 37158 322 41 most most RBS 37158 322 42 certainly certainly RB 37158 322 43 extremely extremely RB 37158 322 44 hazy hazy JJ 37158 322 45 , , , 37158 322 46 if if IN 37158 322 47 , , , 37158 322 48 indeed indeed RB 37158 322 49 , , , 37158 322 50 it -PRON- PRP 37158 322 51 exists exist VBZ 37158 322 52 at at RB 37158 322 53 all all RB 37158 322 54 . . . 37158 323 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 323 2 have have VBP 37158 323 3 difficulty difficulty NN 37158 323 4 in in IN 37158 323 5 conceiving conceive VBG 37158 323 6 that that IN 37158 323 7 a a DT 37158 323 8 frog frog NN 37158 323 9 is be VBZ 37158 323 10 able able JJ 37158 323 11 to to TO 37158 323 12 ponder ponder VB 37158 323 13 over over IN 37158 323 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 323 15 _ _ NNP 37158 323 16 ego ego NN 37158 323 17 _ _ NNP 37158 323 18 , , , 37158 323 19 assert assert VB 37158 323 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 323 21 existence existence NN 37158 323 22 in in IN 37158 323 23 presence presence NN 37158 323 24 of of IN 37158 323 25 the the DT 37158 323 26 external external JJ 37158 323 27 world world NN 37158 323 28 , , , 37158 323 29 and and CC 37158 323 30 say say VB 37158 323 31 or or CC 37158 323 32 think think VBP 37158 323 33 , , , 37158 323 34 I -PRON- PRP 37158 323 35 SUFFER suffer VBP 37158 323 36 . . . 37158 324 1 No no DT 37158 324 2 being be VBG 37158 324 3 suffers suffer NNS 37158 324 4 unless unless IN 37158 324 5 he -PRON- PRP 37158 324 6 is be VBZ 37158 324 7 able able JJ 37158 324 8 to to TO 37158 324 9 think think VB 37158 324 10 that that IN 37158 324 11 he -PRON- PRP 37158 324 12 suffers suffer VBZ 37158 324 13 , , , 37158 324 14 and and CC 37158 324 15 meditate meditate VB 37158 324 16 on on IN 37158 324 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 324 18 suffering suffering NN 37158 324 19 . . . 37158 325 1 To to TO 37158 325 2 suffer suffer VB 37158 325 3 means mean NNS 37158 325 4 to to TO 37158 325 5 have have VB 37158 325 6 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 325 7 ; ; : 37158 325 8 and and CC 37158 325 9 as as RB 37158 325 10 far far RB 37158 325 11 as as IN 37158 325 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 325 13 is be VBZ 37158 325 14 permissible permissible JJ 37158 325 15 for for IN 37158 325 16 a a DT 37158 325 17 man man NN 37158 325 18 to to TO 37158 325 19 picture picture VB 37158 325 20 to to IN 37158 325 21 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 325 22 the the DT 37158 325 23 sensations sensation NNS 37158 325 24 of of IN 37158 325 25 a a DT 37158 325 26 frog frog NN 37158 325 27 , , , 37158 325 28 I -PRON- PRP 37158 325 29 should should MD 37158 325 30 say say VB 37158 325 31 that that IN 37158 325 32 the the DT 37158 325 33 frog frog NN 37158 325 34 has have VBZ 37158 325 35 no no DT 37158 325 36 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 325 37 of of IN 37158 325 38 suffering suffering NN 37158 325 39 . . . 37158 326 1 Even even RB 37158 326 2 as as IN 37158 326 3 regards regard VBZ 37158 326 4 the the DT 37158 326 5 more more RBR 37158 326 6 highly highly RB 37158 326 7 developed develop VBN 37158 326 8 vertebrata vertebrata NN 37158 326 9 , , , 37158 326 10 such such JJ 37158 326 11 as as IN 37158 326 12 birds bird NNS 37158 326 13 , , , 37158 326 14 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 326 15 , , , 37158 326 16 and and CC 37158 326 17 guinea guinea NN 37158 326 18 - - HYPH 37158 326 19 pigs pig NNS 37158 326 20 , , , 37158 326 21 suffering suffering NN 37158 326 22 is be VBZ 37158 326 23 probably probably RB 37158 326 24 of of IN 37158 326 25 a a DT 37158 326 26 very very RB 37158 326 27 obscure obscure JJ 37158 326 28 nature nature NN 37158 326 29 . . . 37158 327 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 327 2 is be VBZ 37158 327 3 not not RB 37158 327 4 enough enough JJ 37158 327 5 to to TO 37158 327 6 say say VB 37158 327 7 that that IN 37158 327 8 an an DT 37158 327 9 animal animal NN 37158 327 10 suffers suffer VBZ 37158 327 11 because because IN 37158 327 12 we -PRON- PRP 37158 327 13 see see VBP 37158 327 14 him -PRON- PRP 37158 327 15 animated animate VBN 37158 327 16 by by IN 37158 327 17 the the DT 37158 327 18 contortions contortion NNS 37158 327 19 and and CC 37158 327 20 reactions reaction NNS 37158 327 21 of of IN 37158 327 22 defence defence NN 37158 327 23 . . . 37158 328 1 The the DT 37158 328 2 new new RB 37158 328 3 - - HYPH 37158 328 4 born bear VBN 37158 328 5 infant infant NN 37158 328 6 , , , 37158 328 7 which which WDT 37158 328 8 has have VBZ 37158 328 9 neither neither CC 37158 328 10 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 328 11 nor nor CC 37158 328 12 memory memory NN 37158 328 13 nor nor CC 37158 328 14 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 328 15 , , , 37158 328 16 is be VBZ 37158 328 17 probably probably RB 37158 328 18 incapable incapable JJ 37158 328 19 of of IN 37158 328 20 real real JJ 37158 328 21 conscious conscious JJ 37158 328 22 suffering suffering NN 37158 328 23 , , , 37158 328 24 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 328 25 it -PRON- PRP 37158 328 26 screams scream VBZ 37158 328 27 and and CC 37158 328 28 cries cry VBZ 37158 328 29 when when WRB 37158 328 30 it -PRON- PRP 37158 328 31 is be VBZ 37158 328 32 hungry hungry JJ 37158 328 33 or or CC 37158 328 34 when when WRB 37158 328 35 it -PRON- PRP 37158 328 36 is be VBZ 37158 328 37 pricked prick VBN 37158 328 38 . . . 37158 329 1 But but CC 37158 329 2 these these DT 37158 329 3 screams scream NNS 37158 329 4 and and CC 37158 329 5 tears tear NNS 37158 329 6 do do VBP 37158 329 7 not not RB 37158 329 8 suffice suffice VB 37158 329 9 to to TO 37158 329 10 allow allow VB 37158 329 11 us -PRON- PRP 37158 329 12 to to TO 37158 329 13 affirm affirm VB 37158 329 14 that that IN 37158 329 15 the the DT 37158 329 16 child child NN 37158 329 17 is be VBZ 37158 329 18 suffering suffer VBG 37158 329 19 real real JJ 37158 329 20 pain pain NN 37158 329 21 . . . 37158 330 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 330 2 is be VBZ 37158 330 3 a a DT 37158 330 4 nervous nervous JJ 37158 330 5 excitation excitation NN 37158 330 6 which which WDT 37158 330 7 is be VBZ 37158 330 8 translated translate VBN 37158 330 9 by by IN 37158 330 10 the the DT 37158 330 11 reactions reaction NNS 37158 330 12 of of IN 37158 330 13 defence defence NN 37158 330 14 ; ; : 37158 330 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 330 16 is be VBZ 37158 330 17 not not RB 37158 330 18 the the DT 37158 330 19 conscious conscious JJ 37158 330 20 assertion assertion NN 37158 330 21 of of IN 37158 330 22 an an DT 37158 330 23 _ _ NNP 37158 330 24 ego ego NN 37158 330 25 _ _ NNP 37158 330 26 which which WDT 37158 330 27 has have VBZ 37158 330 28 been be VBN 37158 330 29 painfully painfully RB 37158 330 30 perturbed perturb VBN 37158 330 31 . . . 37158 331 1 Further further RB 37158 331 2 , , , 37158 331 3 for for IN 37158 331 4 pain pain NN 37158 331 5 to to TO 37158 331 6 exist exist VB 37158 331 7 the the DT 37158 331 8 impression impression NN 37158 331 9 must must MD 37158 331 10 be be VB 37158 331 11 durable durable JJ 37158 331 12 and and CC 37158 331 13 not not RB 37158 331 14 fugitive fugitive JJ 37158 331 15 . . . 37158 332 1 The the DT 37158 332 2 assertion assertion NN 37158 332 3 of of IN 37158 332 4 the the DT 37158 332 5 _ _ NNP 37158 332 6 ego ego NN 37158 332 7 _ _ NNP 37158 332 8 is be VBZ 37158 332 9 not not RB 37158 332 10 enough enough JJ 37158 332 11 . . . 37158 333 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 333 2 must must MD 37158 333 3 be be VB 37158 333 4 prolonged prolong VBN 37158 333 5 . . . 37158 334 1 A a DT 37158 334 2 pain pain NN 37158 334 3 , , , 37158 334 4 however however RB 37158 334 5 intense intense JJ 37158 334 6 we -PRON- PRP 37158 334 7 may may MD 37158 334 8 suppose suppose VB 37158 334 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 334 10 to to TO 37158 334 11 be be VB 37158 334 12 , , , 37158 334 13 which which WDT 37158 334 14 traverses traverse VBZ 37158 334 15 the the DT 37158 334 16 organism organism NN 37158 334 17 for for IN 37158 334 18 a a DT 37158 334 19 second second JJ 37158 334 20 and and CC 37158 334 21 which which WDT 37158 334 22 leaves leave VBZ 37158 334 23 no no DT 37158 334 24 painful painful JJ 37158 334 25 echo echo NN 37158 334 26 behind behind IN 37158 334 27 it -PRON- PRP 37158 334 28 , , , 37158 334 29 is be VBZ 37158 334 30 no no DT 37158 334 31 real real JJ 37158 334 32 pain pain NN 37158 334 33 . . . 37158 335 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 335 2 will will MD 37158 335 3 allow allow VB 37158 335 4 any any DT 37158 335 5 one one NN 37158 335 6 to to TO 37158 335 7 inflict inflict VB 37158 335 8 the the DT 37158 335 9 most most RBS 37158 335 10 excruciating excruciating JJ 37158 335 11 tortures torture NNS 37158 335 12 on on IN 37158 335 13 me -PRON- PRP 37158 335 14 if if IN 37158 335 15 he -PRON- PRP 37158 335 16 can can MD 37158 335 17 assure assure VB 37158 335 18 me -PRON- PRP 37158 335 19 that that IN 37158 335 20 , , , 37158 335 21 at at IN 37158 335 22 the the DT 37158 335 23 end end NN 37158 335 24 of of IN 37158 335 25 one one CD 37158 335 26 second second NN 37158 335 27 , , , 37158 335 28 I -PRON- PRP 37158 335 29 shall shall MD 37158 335 30 have have VB 37158 335 31 lost lose VBN 37158 335 32 all all DT 37158 335 33 recollection recollection NN 37158 335 34 of of IN 37158 335 35 the the DT 37158 335 36 suffering suffering NN 37158 335 37 and and CC 37158 335 38 that that IN 37158 335 39 no no DT 37158 335 40 trace trace NN 37158 335 41 of of IN 37158 335 42 the the DT 37158 335 43 torture torture NN 37158 335 44 will will MD 37158 335 45 remain remain VB 37158 335 46 . . . 37158 336 1 The the DT 37158 336 2 extraction extraction NN 37158 336 3 of of IN 37158 336 4 a a DT 37158 336 5 tooth tooth NN 37158 336 6 lasts last VBZ 37158 336 7 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 336 8 only only RB 37158 336 9 half half PDT 37158 336 10 a a DT 37158 336 11 second second JJ 37158 336 12 , , , 37158 336 13 but but CC 37158 336 14 you -PRON- PRP 37158 336 15 remember remember VBP 37158 336 16 it -PRON- PRP 37158 336 17 all all DT 37158 336 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 37158 336 19 life life NN 37158 336 20 . . . 37158 337 1 In in IN 37158 337 2 any any DT 37158 337 3 case case NN 37158 337 4 , , , 37158 337 5 for for IN 37158 337 6 several several JJ 37158 337 7 minutes minute NNS 37158 337 8 the the DT 37158 337 9 pain pain NN 37158 337 10 continues continue VBZ 37158 337 11 to to TO 37158 337 12 be be VB 37158 337 13 atrocious atrocious JJ 37158 337 14 . . . 37158 338 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 338 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 338 3 may may MD 37158 338 4 certainly certainly RB 37158 338 5 consider consider VB 37158 338 6 that that DT 37158 338 7 pain pain NN 37158 338 8 is be VBZ 37158 338 9 a a DT 37158 338 10 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37158 338 11 of of IN 37158 338 12 memory memory NN 37158 338 13 . . . 37158 339 1 Pain pain NN 37158 339 2 is be VBZ 37158 339 3 an an DT 37158 339 4 empty empty JJ 37158 339 5 word word NN 37158 339 6 for for IN 37158 339 7 every every DT 37158 339 8 being being NN 37158 339 9 that that WDT 37158 339 10 has have VBZ 37158 339 11 no no DT 37158 339 12 memory memory NN 37158 339 13 . . . 37158 340 1 From from IN 37158 340 2 these these DT 37158 340 3 facts fact NNS 37158 340 4 we -PRON- PRP 37158 340 5 may may MD 37158 340 6 evolve evolve VB 37158 340 7 the the DT 37158 340 8 general general JJ 37158 340 9 conclusion conclusion NN 37158 340 10 that that IN 37158 340 11 , , , 37158 340 12 under under IN 37158 340 13 penalty penalty NN 37158 340 14 of of IN 37158 340 15 falling fall VBG 37158 340 16 into into IN 37158 340 17 vulgar vulgar JJ 37158 340 18 anthromorphism anthromorphism NN 37158 340 19 , , , 37158 340 20 we -PRON- PRP 37158 340 21 can can MD 37158 340 22 not not RB 37158 340 23 apply apply VB 37158 340 24 to to IN 37158 340 25 the the DT 37158 340 26 pain pain NN 37158 340 27 of of IN 37158 340 28 animals animal NNS 37158 340 29 the the DT 37158 340 30 data datum NNS 37158 340 31 which which WDT 37158 340 32 have have VBP 37158 340 33 been be VBN 37158 340 34 gathered gather VBN 37158 340 35 on on IN 37158 340 36 human human JJ 37158 340 37 pain pain NN 37158 340 38 . . . 37158 341 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 341 2 5 5 CD 37158 341 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 341 4 With with IN 37158 341 5 man man NN 37158 341 6 , , , 37158 341 7 the the DT 37158 341 8 developed develop VBN 37158 341 9 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 341 10 and and CC 37158 341 11 vivacious vivacious JJ 37158 341 12 memory memory NN 37158 341 13 enable enable VBP 37158 341 14 pain pain NN 37158 341 15 to to TO 37158 341 16 acquire acquire VB 37158 341 17 an an DT 37158 341 18 extreme extreme JJ 37158 341 19 intensity intensity NN 37158 341 20 . . . 37158 342 1 But but CC 37158 342 2 with with IN 37158 342 3 animals animal NNS 37158 342 4 , , , 37158 342 5 in in IN 37158 342 6 proportion proportion NN 37158 342 7 as as IN 37158 342 8 the the DT 37158 342 9 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 342 10 lessens lessen VBZ 37158 342 11 and and CC 37158 342 12 the the DT 37158 342 13 memory memory NN 37158 342 14 becomes become VBZ 37158 342 15 more more RBR 37158 342 16 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 37158 342 17 , , , 37158 342 18 so so RB 37158 342 19 does do VBZ 37158 342 20 pain pain NN 37158 342 21 diminish diminish NN 37158 342 22 , , , 37158 342 23 and and CC 37158 342 24 , , , 37158 342 25 without without IN 37158 342 26 having have VBG 37158 342 27 the the DT 37158 342 28 right right NN 37158 342 29 to to TO 37158 342 30 be be VB 37158 342 31 very very RB 37158 342 32 affirmative affirmative JJ 37158 342 33 , , , 37158 342 34 as as IN 37158 342 35 we -PRON- PRP 37158 342 36 are be VBP 37158 342 37 in in IN 37158 342 38 profound profound JJ 37158 342 39 darkness darkness NN 37158 342 40 concerning concern VBG 37158 342 41 the the DT 37158 342 42 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 342 43 of of IN 37158 342 44 animals animal NNS 37158 342 45 , , , 37158 342 46 it -PRON- PRP 37158 342 47 appears appear VBZ 37158 342 48 to to IN 37158 342 49 me -PRON- PRP 37158 342 50 that that DT 37158 342 51 , , , 37158 342 52 as as IN 37158 342 53 we -PRON- PRP 37158 342 54 descend descend VBP 37158 342 55 the the DT 37158 342 56 scale scale NN 37158 342 57 of of IN 37158 342 58 the the DT 37158 342 59 animal animal NN 37158 342 60 kingdom kingdom NN 37158 342 61 , , , 37158 342 62 pain pain NN 37158 342 63 rapidly rapidly RB 37158 342 64 becomes become VBZ 37158 342 65 very very RB 37158 342 66 hazy hazy JJ 37158 342 67 , , , 37158 342 68 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 342 69 perceived perceive VBN 37158 342 70 , , , 37158 342 71 and and CC 37158 342 72 as as RB 37158 342 73 indistinct indistinct JJ 37158 342 74 as as IN 37158 342 75 the the DT 37158 342 76 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 342 77 of of IN 37158 342 78 the the DT 37158 342 79 _ _ NNP 37158 342 80 ego ego NN 37158 342 81 _ _ NNP 37158 342 82 . . . 37158 343 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 343 2 have have VBP 37158 343 3 , , , 37158 343 4 therefore therefore RB 37158 343 5 , , , 37158 343 6 the the DT 37158 343 7 right right NN 37158 343 8 to to TO 37158 343 9 perform perform VB 37158 343 10 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 343 11 on on IN 37158 343 12 beings being NNS 37158 343 13 which which WDT 37158 343 14 , , , 37158 343 15 because because IN 37158 343 16 they -PRON- PRP 37158 343 17 possess possess VBP 37158 343 18 no no DT 37158 343 19 _ _ NNP 37158 343 20 selfhood selfhood NN 37158 343 21 _ _ NNP 37158 343 22 , , , 37158 343 23 do do VBP 37158 343 24 not not RB 37158 343 25 suffer suffer VB 37158 343 26 . . . 37158 344 1 Now now RB 37158 344 2 , , , 37158 344 3 this this DT 37158 344 4 absence absence NN 37158 344 5 of of IN 37158 344 6 memory memory NN 37158 344 7 , , , 37158 344 8 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 344 9 , , , 37158 344 10 and and CC 37158 344 11 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 344 12 extends extend VBZ 37158 344 13 assuredly assuredly RB 37158 344 14 over over IN 37158 344 15 the the DT 37158 344 16 whole whole NN 37158 344 17 of of IN 37158 344 18 the the DT 37158 344 19 vegetable vegetable NN 37158 344 20 kingdom kingdom NN 37158 344 21 , , , 37158 344 22 almost almost RB 37158 344 23 certainly certainly RB 37158 344 24 over over IN 37158 344 25 all all PDT 37158 344 26 the the DT 37158 344 27 groups group NNS 37158 344 28 of of IN 37158 344 29 the the DT 37158 344 30 invertebrata invertebrata NN 37158 344 31 , , , 37158 344 32 and and CC 37158 344 33 also also RB 37158 344 34 probably probably RB 37158 344 35 over over IN 37158 344 36 all all PDT 37158 344 37 the the DT 37158 344 38 inferior inferior JJ 37158 344 39 vertebrata vertebrata NN 37158 344 40 . . . 37158 345 1 Finally finally RB 37158 345 2 , , , 37158 345 3 there there EX 37158 345 4 remain remain VBP 37158 345 5 only only RB 37158 345 6 the the DT 37158 345 7 mammalia mammalia NN 37158 345 8 and and CC 37158 345 9 birds bird NNS 37158 345 10 which which WDT 37158 345 11 are be VBP 37158 345 12 capable capable JJ 37158 345 13 of of IN 37158 345 14 real real JJ 37158 345 15 pain pain NN 37158 345 16 . . . 37158 346 1 Although although IN 37158 346 2 this this DT 37158 346 3 pain pain NN 37158 346 4 may may MD 37158 346 5 be be VB 37158 346 6 obscure obscure JJ 37158 346 7 and and CC 37158 346 8 indistinct indistinct JJ 37158 346 9 , , , 37158 346 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 346 11 is be VBZ 37158 346 12 certain certain JJ 37158 346 13 ; ; : 37158 346 14 and and CC 37158 346 15 we -PRON- PRP 37158 346 16 must must MD 37158 346 17 take take VB 37158 346 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 346 19 into into IN 37158 346 20 consideration consideration NN 37158 346 21 or or CC 37158 346 22 fall fall VB 37158 346 23 into into IN 37158 346 24 barbarism barbarism NN 37158 346 25 ; ; : 37158 346 26 therefore therefore RB 37158 346 27 we -PRON- PRP 37158 346 28 shall shall MD 37158 346 29 restrict restrict VB 37158 346 30 the the DT 37158 346 31 problem problem NN 37158 346 32 of of IN 37158 346 33 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 346 34 to to IN 37158 346 35 the the DT 37158 346 36 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 346 37 of of IN 37158 346 38 superior superior JJ 37158 346 39 animals animal NNS 37158 346 40 , , , 37158 346 41 who who WP 37158 346 42 , , , 37158 346 43 alone alone RB 37158 346 44 , , , 37158 346 45 are be VBP 37158 346 46 capable capable JJ 37158 346 47 of of IN 37158 346 48 suffering suffer VBG 37158 346 49 . . . 37158 347 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 37158 347 2 : : : 37158 347 3 [ [ -LRB- 37158 347 4 4 4 LS 37158 347 5 ] ] -RRB- 37158 347 6 The the DT 37158 347 7 true true JJ 37158 347 8 vegetarian vegetarian NN 37158 347 9 is be VBZ 37158 347 10 an an DT 37158 347 11 extremely extremely RB 37158 347 12 rare rare JJ 37158 347 13 person person NN 37158 347 14 . . . 37158 348 1 The the DT 37158 348 2 usual usual JJ 37158 348 3 so so RB 37158 348 4 - - HYPH 37158 348 5 called call VBN 37158 348 6 vegetarian vegetarian NN 37158 348 7 ought ought MD 37158 348 8 more more RBR 37158 348 9 properly properly RB 37158 348 10 to to TO 37158 348 11 be be VB 37158 348 12 called call VBN 37158 348 13 a a DT 37158 348 14 non non JJ 37158 348 15 - - JJ 37158 348 16 meat meat JJ 37158 348 17 eater eater NN 37158 348 18 , , , 37158 348 19 for for IN 37158 348 20 he -PRON- PRP 37158 348 21 does do VBZ 37158 348 22 not not RB 37158 348 23 scruple scruple VB 37158 348 24 to to TO 37158 348 25 consume consume VB 37158 348 26 milk milk NN 37158 348 27 ( ( -LRB- 37158 348 28 intended intend VBN 37158 348 29 by by IN 37158 348 30 nature nature NN 37158 348 31 for for IN 37158 348 32 the the DT 37158 348 33 calf calf NN 37158 348 34 ) ) -RRB- 37158 348 35 and and CC 37158 348 36 milk milk NN 37158 348 37 products product NNS 37158 348 38 ( ( -LRB- 37158 348 39 cream cream NN 37158 348 40 , , , 37158 348 41 cheese cheese NN 37158 348 42 , , , 37158 348 43 and and CC 37158 348 44 butter butter NN 37158 348 45 ) ) -RRB- 37158 348 46 and and CC 37158 348 47 eggs egg NNS 37158 348 48 , , , 37158 348 49 nor nor CC 37158 348 50 to to TO 37158 348 51 wear wear VB 37158 348 52 garments garment NNS 37158 348 53 made make VBN 37158 348 54 of of IN 37158 348 55 wool wool NN 37158 348 56 and and CC 37158 348 57 leather.--(W. leather.--(w. ADD 37158 349 1 D. D. NNP 37158 349 2 H. H. NNP 37158 349 3 ) ) -RRB- 37158 349 4 [ [ -LRB- 37158 349 5 5 5 CD 37158 349 6 ] ] -RRB- 37158 349 7 In in IN 37158 349 8 the the DT 37158 349 9 little little JJ 37158 349 10 leaflet leaflet NN 37158 349 11 already already RB 37158 349 12 referred refer VBD 37158 349 13 to to IN 37158 349 14 , , , 37158 349 15 quotation quotation NN 37158 349 16 is be VBZ 37158 349 17 made make VBN 37158 349 18 of of IN 37158 349 19 a a DT 37158 349 20 sentence sentence NN 37158 349 21 from from IN 37158 349 22 Professor Professor NNP 37158 349 23 Pritchard Pritchard NNP 37158 349 24 , , , 37158 349 25 which which WDT 37158 349 26 says say VBZ 37158 349 27 that that IN 37158 349 28 the the DT 37158 349 29 various various JJ 37158 349 30 animals animal NNS 37158 349 31 have have VBP 37158 349 32 a a DT 37158 349 33 skin skin NN 37158 349 34 of of IN 37158 349 35 different different JJ 37158 349 36 thickness thickness NN 37158 349 37 , , , 37158 349 38 but but CC 37158 349 39 that that DT 37158 349 40 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 349 41 is be VBZ 37158 349 42 the the DT 37158 349 43 same same JJ 37158 349 44 among among IN 37158 349 45 all all RB 37158 349 46 , , , 37158 349 47 including include VBG 37158 349 48 man man NN 37158 349 49 . . . 37158 350 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 350 2 seems seem VBZ 37158 350 3 to to IN 37158 350 4 me -PRON- PRP 37158 350 5 that that IN 37158 350 6 Professor Professor NNP 37158 350 7 Pritchard Pritchard NNP 37158 350 8 has have VBZ 37158 350 9 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 350 10 looked look VBN 37158 350 11 into into IN 37158 350 12 the the DT 37158 350 13 questions question NNS 37158 350 14 of of IN 37158 350 15 general general JJ 37158 350 16 psychology psychology NN 37158 350 17 . . . 37158 351 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37158 351 2 III iii CD 37158 351 3 CONCERNING concern VBG 37158 351 4 ANÆSTHESIA ANÆSTHESIA NNS 37158 351 5 IN in IN 37158 351 6 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 351 7 A a DT 37158 351 8 few few JJ 37158 351 9 words word NNS 37158 351 10 are be VBP 37158 351 11 first first JJ 37158 351 12 of of IN 37158 351 13 all all DT 37158 351 14 necessary necessary JJ 37158 351 15 to to TO 37158 351 16 indicate indicate VB 37158 351 17 precisely precisely RB 37158 351 18 what what WP 37158 351 19 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 351 20 is be VBZ 37158 351 21 . . . 37158 352 1 By by IN 37158 352 2 definition definition NN 37158 352 3 , , , 37158 352 4 an an DT 37158 352 5 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 352 6 is be VBZ 37158 352 7 a a DT 37158 352 8 substance substance NN 37158 352 9 which which WDT 37158 352 10 , , , 37158 352 11 without without IN 37158 352 12 paralysing paralyse VBG 37158 352 13 the the DT 37158 352 14 activity activity NN 37158 352 15 of of IN 37158 352 16 the the DT 37158 352 17 heart heart NN 37158 352 18 and and CC 37158 352 19 the the DT 37158 352 20 respiration respiration NN 37158 352 21 , , , 37158 352 22 abolishes abolish VBZ 37158 352 23 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 352 24 . . . 37158 353 1 Indeed indeed RB 37158 353 2 , , , 37158 353 3 whenever whenever WRB 37158 353 4 general general JJ 37158 353 5 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 353 6 is be VBZ 37158 353 7 abolished abolish VBN 37158 353 8 , , , 37158 353 9 there there EX 37158 353 10 is be VBZ 37158 353 11 , , , 37158 353 12 at at IN 37158 353 13 the the DT 37158 353 14 same same JJ 37158 353 15 time time NN 37158 353 16 , , , 37158 353 17 abolition abolition NN 37158 353 18 of of IN 37158 353 19 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 353 20 , , , 37158 353 21 of of IN 37158 353 22 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 353 23 , , , 37158 353 24 and and CC 37158 353 25 of of IN 37158 353 26 memory memory NN 37158 353 27 . . . 37158 354 1 Another another DT 37158 354 2 characteristic characteristic NN 37158 354 3 of of IN 37158 354 4 an an DT 37158 354 5 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 354 6 is be VBZ 37158 354 7 that that IN 37158 354 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 354 9 action action NN 37158 354 10 is be VBZ 37158 354 11 of of IN 37158 354 12 a a DT 37158 354 13 transient transient JJ 37158 354 14 nature nature NN 37158 354 15 . . . 37158 355 1 At at IN 37158 355 2 the the DT 37158 355 3 end end NN 37158 355 4 of of IN 37158 355 5 a a DT 37158 355 6 certain certain JJ 37158 355 7 time time NN 37158 355 8 , , , 37158 355 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 355 10 disappears disappear VBZ 37158 355 11 ; ; : 37158 355 12 and and CC 37158 355 13 then then RB 37158 355 14 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 355 15 , , , 37158 355 16 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 355 17 , , , 37158 355 18 and and CC 37158 355 19 memory memory NN 37158 355 20 return return NN 37158 355 21 gradually gradually RB 37158 355 22 with with IN 37158 355 23 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 355 24 . . . 37158 356 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 356 2 is be VBZ 37158 356 3 well well RB 37158 356 4 known know VBN 37158 356 5 that that IN 37158 356 6 the the DT 37158 356 7 admirable admirable JJ 37158 356 8 discovery discovery NN 37158 356 9 of of IN 37158 356 10 general general JJ 37158 356 11 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 356 12 , , , 37158 356 13 allowing allow VBG 37158 356 14 operations operation NNS 37158 356 15 to to TO 37158 356 16 be be VB 37158 356 17 performed perform VBN 37158 356 18 on on IN 37158 356 19 man man NN 37158 356 20 without without IN 37158 356 21 the the DT 37158 356 22 accompaniment accompaniment NN 37158 356 23 of of IN 37158 356 24 pain pain NN 37158 356 25 , , , 37158 356 26 was be VBD 37158 356 27 due due JJ 37158 356 28 to to IN 37158 356 29 chance chance NN 37158 356 30 . . . 37158 357 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 357 2 was be VBD 37158 357 3 an an DT 37158 357 4 American american JJ 37158 357 5 dentist dentist NN 37158 357 6 , , , 37158 357 7 Horace Horace NNP 37158 357 8 Wells Wells NNP 37158 357 9 , , , 37158 357 10 and and CC 37158 357 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 357 12 colleague colleague NN 37158 357 13 , , , 37158 357 14 Morton Morton NNP 37158 357 15 ( ( -LRB- 37158 357 16 and and CC 37158 357 17 others other NNS 37158 357 18 also also RB 37158 357 19 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 357 20 ) ) -RRB- 37158 357 21 , , , 37158 357 22 who who WP 37158 357 23 discovered discover VBD 37158 357 24 by by IN 37158 357 25 chance chance NN 37158 357 26 that that IN 37158 357 27 protoxide protoxide NN 37158 357 28 of of IN 37158 357 29 nitrogen nitrogen NN 37158 357 30 ( ( -LRB- 37158 357 31 commonly commonly RB 37158 357 32 called call VBN 37158 357 33 laughing laugh VBG 37158 357 34 gas gas NN 37158 357 35 ) ) -RRB- 37158 357 36 has have VBZ 37158 357 37 the the DT 37158 357 38 power power NN 37158 357 39 , , , 37158 357 40 when when WRB 37158 357 41 inhaled inhale VBN 37158 357 42 , , , 37158 357 43 of of IN 37158 357 44 annulling annul VBG 37158 357 45 all all DT 37158 357 46 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 357 47 to to TO 37158 357 48 pain pain VB 37158 357 49 for for IN 37158 357 50 a a DT 37158 357 51 certain certain JJ 37158 357 52 length length NN 37158 357 53 of of IN 37158 357 54 time time NN 37158 357 55 -- -- : 37158 357 56 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37158 357 57 long long RB 37158 357 58 for for IN 37158 357 59 a a DT 37158 357 60 surgical surgical JJ 37158 357 61 operation operation NN 37158 357 62 ( ( -LRB- 37158 357 63 1840 1840 CD 37158 357 64 ) ) -RRB- 37158 357 65 . . . 37158 358 1 Then then RB 37158 358 2 they -PRON- PRP 37158 358 3 discovered discover VBD 37158 358 4 the the DT 37158 358 5 effects effect NNS 37158 358 6 of of IN 37158 358 7 ether ether NN 37158 358 8 ( ( -LRB- 37158 358 9 1842 1842 CD 37158 358 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 358 11 . . . 37158 359 1 Since since IN 37158 359 2 then then RB 37158 359 3 , , , 37158 359 4 many many JJ 37158 359 5 other other JJ 37158 359 6 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 359 7 have have VBP 37158 359 8 been be VBN 37158 359 9 introduced introduce VBN 37158 359 10 , , , 37158 359 11 notably notably RB 37158 359 12 chloroform chloroform JJ 37158 359 13 , , , 37158 359 14 prepared prepare VBN 37158 359 15 by by IN 37158 359 16 Soubeiran Soubeiran NNP 37158 359 17 in in IN 37158 359 18 1832 1832 CD 37158 359 19 , , , 37158 359 20 but but CC 37158 359 21 the the DT 37158 359 22 anæsthetic anæsthetic JJ 37158 359 23 properties property NNS 37158 359 24 of of IN 37158 359 25 which which WDT 37158 359 26 were be VBD 37158 359 27 only only RB 37158 359 28 discovered discover VBN 37158 359 29 in in IN 37158 359 30 1847 1847 CD 37158 359 31 by by IN 37158 359 32 Flourens Flourens NNP 37158 359 33 and and CC 37158 359 34 Simpson Simpson NNP 37158 359 35 ; ; : 37158 359 36 so so CC 37158 359 37 that that IN 37158 359 38 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 359 39 and and CC 37158 359 40 surgeons surgeon NNS 37158 359 41 are be VBP 37158 359 42 now now RB 37158 359 43 quite quite RB 37158 359 44 familiar familiar JJ 37158 359 45 with with IN 37158 359 46 the the DT 37158 359 47 mode mode NN 37158 359 48 of of IN 37158 359 49 action action NN 37158 359 50 of of IN 37158 359 51 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 359 52 . . . 37158 360 1 Anæsthetics Anæsthetics NNP 37158 360 2 , , , 37158 360 3 in in IN 37158 360 4 appropriate appropriate JJ 37158 360 5 doses dose NNS 37158 360 6 , , , 37158 360 7 poison poison VB 37158 360 8 the the DT 37158 360 9 nervous nervous JJ 37158 360 10 cells cell NNS 37158 360 11 , , , 37158 360 12 which which WDT 37158 360 13 are be VBP 37158 360 14 the the DT 37158 360 15 seat seat NN 37158 360 16 of of IN 37158 360 17 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 360 18 and and CC 37158 360 19 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 360 20 , , , 37158 360 21 but but CC 37158 360 22 leave leave VB 37158 360 23 unimpaired unimpaire VBN 37158 360 24 the the DT 37158 360 25 functions function NNS 37158 360 26 of of IN 37158 360 27 the the DT 37158 360 28 cardiac cardiac JJ 37158 360 29 nervous nervous JJ 37158 360 30 system system NN 37158 360 31 and and CC 37158 360 32 of of IN 37158 360 33 the the DT 37158 360 34 nervous nervous JJ 37158 360 35 system system NN 37158 360 36 governing govern VBG 37158 360 37 the the DT 37158 360 38 respiration respiration NN 37158 360 39 . . . 37158 361 1 An an DT 37158 361 2 individual individual NN 37158 361 3 under under IN 37158 361 4 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 361 5 breathes breathe VBZ 37158 361 6 regularly regularly RB 37158 361 7 ; ; : 37158 361 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 361 9 heart heart NN 37158 361 10 beats beat VBZ 37158 361 11 rhythmically rhythmically RB 37158 361 12 , , , 37158 361 13 but but CC 37158 361 14 all all DT 37158 361 15 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 361 16 has have VBZ 37158 361 17 disappeared disappear VBN 37158 361 18 ; ; : 37158 361 19 he -PRON- PRP 37158 361 20 has have VBZ 37158 361 21 no no RB 37158 361 22 longer long RBR 37158 361 23 any any DT 37158 361 24 will will NN 37158 361 25 or or CC 37158 361 26 memory memory NN 37158 361 27 or or CC 37158 361 28 reflex reflex JJ 37158 361 29 actions action NNS 37158 361 30 , , , 37158 361 31 and and CC 37158 361 32 the the DT 37158 361 33 most most RBS 37158 361 34 painful painful JJ 37158 361 35 operations operation NNS 37158 361 36 can can MD 37158 361 37 be be VB 37158 361 38 performed perform VBN 37158 361 39 on on IN 37158 361 40 him -PRON- PRP 37158 361 41 without without IN 37158 361 42 provoking provoke VBG 37158 361 43 the the DT 37158 361 44 smallest small JJS 37158 361 45 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37158 361 46 of of IN 37158 361 47 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 361 48 . . . 37158 362 1 Further further RB 37158 362 2 , , , 37158 362 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 362 4 have have VBP 37158 362 5 no no DT 37158 362 6 hesitation hesitation NN 37158 362 7 in in IN 37158 362 8 asserting assert VBG 37158 362 9 that that IN 37158 362 10 the the DT 37158 362 11 anæsthetised anæsthetise VBN 37158 362 12 animal animal NN 37158 362 13 behaves behave NNS 37158 362 14 like like IN 37158 362 15 the the DT 37158 362 16 anæsthetised anæsthetised JJ 37158 362 17 man man NN 37158 362 18 ; ; : 37158 362 19 that that DT 37158 362 20 is be VBZ 37158 362 21 to to TO 37158 362 22 say say VB 37158 362 23 , , , 37158 362 24 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 362 25 given give VBN 37158 362 26 to to IN 37158 362 27 an an DT 37158 362 28 animal animal NN 37158 362 29 abolishes abolish VBZ 37158 362 30 all all DT 37158 362 31 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 362 32 to to TO 37158 362 33 pain pain VB 37158 362 34 . . . 37158 363 1 Vivisection vivisection NN 37158 363 2 , , , 37158 363 3 therefore therefore RB 37158 363 4 , , , 37158 363 5 on on IN 37158 363 6 an an DT 37158 363 7 anæsthetised anæsthetise VBN 37158 363 8 animal animal NN 37158 363 9 , , , 37158 363 10 does do VBZ 37158 363 11 not not RB 37158 363 12 provoke provoke VB 37158 363 13 any any DT 37158 363 14 pain pain NN 37158 363 15 . . . 37158 364 1 Physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 364 2 are be VBP 37158 364 3 so so RB 37158 364 4 convinced convinced JJ 37158 364 5 of of IN 37158 364 6 this this DT 37158 364 7 that that DT 37158 364 8 , , , 37158 364 9 however however RB 37158 364 10 humane humane JJ 37158 364 11 they -PRON- PRP 37158 364 12 may may MD 37158 364 13 be be VB 37158 364 14 , , , 37158 364 15 they -PRON- PRP 37158 364 16 have have VBP 37158 364 17 no no DT 37158 364 18 scruple scruple NN 37158 364 19 in in IN 37158 364 20 performing perform VBG 37158 364 21 lengthy lengthy JJ 37158 364 22 vivisections vivisection NNS 37158 364 23 on on IN 37158 364 24 an an DT 37158 364 25 animal animal NN 37158 364 26 which which WDT 37158 364 27 is be VBZ 37158 364 28 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 364 29 anæsthetised anæsthetise VBN 37158 364 30 . . . 37158 365 1 If if IN 37158 365 2 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 365 3 , , , 37158 365 4 for for IN 37158 365 5 some some DT 37158 365 6 reason reason NN 37158 365 7 or or CC 37158 365 8 other other JJ 37158 365 9 , , , 37158 365 10 can can MD 37158 365 11 not not RB 37158 365 12 be be VB 37158 365 13 employed employ VBN 37158 365 14 , , , 37158 365 15 many many JJ 37158 365 16 other other JJ 37158 365 17 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 365 18 , , , 37158 365 19 such such JJ 37158 365 20 as as IN 37158 365 21 chloral chloral JJ 37158 365 22 and and CC 37158 365 23 morphia morphia JJ 37158 365 24 , , , 37158 365 25 may may MD 37158 365 26 be be VB 37158 365 27 used use VBN 37158 365 28 . . . 37158 366 1 Chloral chloral JJ 37158 366 2 , , , 37158 366 3 in in IN 37158 366 4 certain certain JJ 37158 366 5 doses dose NNS 37158 366 6 , , , 37158 366 7 produces produce VBZ 37158 366 8 complete complete JJ 37158 366 9 anæsthesia anæsthesia NN 37158 366 10 , , , 37158 366 11 and and CC 37158 366 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 366 13 is be VBZ 37158 366 14 easier easy JJR 37158 366 15 to to TO 37158 366 16 administer administer VB 37158 366 17 than than IN 37158 366 18 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 366 19 . . . 37158 367 1 Formerly formerly RB 37158 367 2 , , , 37158 367 3 chloral chloral JJ 37158 367 4 was be VBD 37158 367 5 injected inject VBN 37158 367 6 , , , 37158 367 7 by by IN 37158 367 8 a a DT 37158 367 9 small small JJ 37158 367 10 puncture puncture NN 37158 367 11 , , , 37158 367 12 into into IN 37158 367 13 the the DT 37158 367 14 veins vein NNS 37158 367 15 of of IN 37158 367 16 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 367 17 and and CC 37158 367 18 dogs dog NNS 37158 367 19 . . . 37158 368 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 368 2 pointed point VBD 37158 368 3 out out RP 37158 368 4 another another DT 37158 368 5 method method NN 37158 368 6 which which WDT 37158 368 7 allows allow VBZ 37158 368 8 one one PRP 37158 368 9 to to TO 37158 368 10 avoid avoid VB 37158 368 11 even even RB 37158 368 12 the the DT 37158 368 13 puncture puncture NN 37158 368 14 ; ; : 37158 368 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 368 16 is be VBZ 37158 368 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 368 18 to to TO 37158 368 19 make make VB 37158 368 20 a a DT 37158 368 21 rectal rectal JJ 37158 368 22 injection injection NN 37158 368 23 of of IN 37158 368 24 the the DT 37158 368 25 solution solution NN 37158 368 26 of of IN 37158 368 27 chloral chloral NN 37158 368 28 . . . 37158 369 1 In in IN 37158 369 2 two two CD 37158 369 3 or or CC 37158 369 4 three three CD 37158 369 5 minutes minute NNS 37158 369 6 , , , 37158 369 7 the the DT 37158 369 8 dog dog NN 37158 369 9 , , , 37158 369 10 the the DT 37158 369 11 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 369 12 , , , 37158 369 13 or or CC 37158 369 14 the the DT 37158 369 15 guinea guinea NN 37158 369 16 - - HYPH 37158 369 17 pig pig NN 37158 369 18 , , , 37158 369 19 is be VBZ 37158 369 20 seized seize VBN 37158 369 21 with with IN 37158 369 22 a a DT 37158 369 23 kind kind NN 37158 369 24 of of IN 37158 369 25 inebriety inebriety NN 37158 369 26 ; ; : 37158 369 27 he -PRON- PRP 37158 369 28 staggers stagger VBZ 37158 369 29 , , , 37158 369 30 falls fall VBZ 37158 369 31 to to IN 37158 369 32 the the DT 37158 369 33 ground ground NN 37158 369 34 , , , 37158 369 35 and and CC 37158 369 36 in in IN 37158 369 37 about about RB 37158 369 38 ten ten CD 37158 369 39 minutes minute NNS 37158 369 40 he -PRON- PRP 37158 369 41 is be VBZ 37158 369 42 completely completely RB 37158 369 43 anæsthetised anæsthetise VBN 37158 369 44 . . . 37158 370 1 Large large JJ 37158 370 2 doses dose NNS 37158 370 3 of of IN 37158 370 4 morphia morphia NNS 37158 370 5 can can MD 37158 370 6 be be VB 37158 370 7 injected inject VBN 37158 370 8 into into IN 37158 370 9 animals animal NNS 37158 370 10 without without IN 37158 370 11 causing cause VBG 37158 370 12 immediate immediate JJ 37158 370 13 death death NN 37158 370 14 . . . 37158 371 1 An an DT 37158 371 2 animal animal NN 37158 371 3 under under IN 37158 371 4 a a DT 37158 371 5 moderate moderate JJ 37158 371 6 dose dose NN 37158 371 7 of of IN 37158 371 8 morphia morphia NN 37158 371 9 does do VBZ 37158 371 10 not not RB 37158 371 11 absolutely absolutely RB 37158 371 12 lose lose VB 37158 371 13 all all DT 37158 371 14 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 371 15 to to TO 37158 371 16 pain pain VB 37158 371 17 ; ; : 37158 371 18 but but CC 37158 371 19 the the DT 37158 371 20 slight slight JJ 37158 371 21 pain pain NN 37158 371 22 which which WDT 37158 371 23 he -PRON- PRP 37158 371 24 then then RB 37158 371 25 feels feel VBZ 37158 371 26 is be VBZ 37158 371 27 very very RB 37158 371 28 transient transient JJ 37158 371 29 . . . 37158 372 1 If if IN 37158 372 2 the the DT 37158 372 3 animal animal NN 37158 372 4 is be VBZ 37158 372 5 submitted submit VBN 37158 372 6 to to IN 37158 372 7 strong strong JJ 37158 372 8 excitation excitation NN 37158 372 9 , , , 37158 372 10 he -PRON- PRP 37158 372 11 wakens waken VBZ 37158 372 12 for for IN 37158 372 13 a a DT 37158 372 14 few few JJ 37158 372 15 seconds second NNS 37158 372 16 , , , 37158 372 17 but but CC 37158 372 18 soon soon RB 37158 372 19 falls fall VBZ 37158 372 20 back back RB 37158 372 21 again again RB 37158 372 22 into into IN 37158 372 23 profound profound JJ 37158 372 24 slumber slumber NN 37158 372 25 . . . 37158 373 1 Morphia Morphia NNP 37158 373 2 in in IN 37158 373 3 moderate moderate JJ 37158 373 4 doses dose NNS 37158 373 5 is be VBZ 37158 373 6 not not RB 37158 373 7 such such PDT 37158 373 8 a a DT 37158 373 9 perfect perfect JJ 37158 373 10 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 373 11 as as IN 37158 373 12 chloral chloral JJ 37158 373 13 or or CC 37158 373 14 chloroform chloroform JJ 37158 373 15 ; ; : 37158 373 16 it -PRON- PRP 37158 373 17 is be VBZ 37158 373 18 therefore therefore RB 37158 373 19 usual usual JJ 37158 373 20 under under IN 37158 373 21 such such JJ 37158 373 22 circumstances circumstance NNS 37158 373 23 to to TO 37158 373 24 administer administer VB 37158 373 25 also also RB 37158 373 26 volatile volatile JJ 37158 373 27 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 373 28 like like IN 37158 373 29 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 373 30 , , , 37158 373 31 and and CC 37158 373 32 quite quite RB 37158 373 33 small small JJ 37158 373 34 quantities quantity NNS 37158 373 35 of of IN 37158 373 36 the the DT 37158 373 37 latter latter JJ 37158 373 38 will will MD 37158 373 39 then then RB 37158 373 40 produce produce VB 37158 373 41 perfect perfect JJ 37158 373 42 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 373 43 . . . 37158 374 1 If if IN 37158 374 2 , , , 37158 374 3 however however RB 37158 374 4 , , , 37158 374 5 morphia morphia NNP 37158 374 6 is be VBZ 37158 374 7 given give VBN 37158 374 8 in in IN 37158 374 9 lethal lethal JJ 37158 374 10 doses dose NNS 37158 374 11 , , , 37158 374 12 as as IN 37158 374 13 is be VBZ 37158 374 14 sometimes sometimes RB 37158 374 15 done do VBN 37158 374 16 for for IN 37158 374 17 comparatively comparatively RB 37158 374 18 short short JJ 37158 374 19 experiments experiment NNS 37158 374 20 , , , 37158 374 21 it -PRON- PRP 37158 374 22 is be VBZ 37158 374 23 an an DT 37158 374 24 absolutely absolutely RB 37158 374 25 complete complete JJ 37158 374 26 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 374 27 in in IN 37158 374 28 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 374 29 , , , 37158 374 30 just just RB 37158 374 31 as as IN 37158 374 32 it -PRON- PRP 37158 374 33 is be VBZ 37158 374 34 when when WRB 37158 374 35 a a DT 37158 374 36 man man NN 37158 374 37 takes take VBZ 37158 374 38 a a DT 37158 374 39 fatal fatal JJ 37158 374 40 dose dose NN 37158 374 41 of of IN 37158 374 42 morphia morphia NN 37158 374 43 , , , 37158 374 44 or or CC 37158 374 45 of of IN 37158 374 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 374 47 parent parent NN 37158 374 48 substance substance NN 37158 374 49 , , , 37158 374 50 opium opium NN 37158 374 51 . . . 37158 375 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 375 2 , , , 37158 375 3 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 375 4 , , , 37158 375 5 chloral chloral JJ 37158 375 6 , , , 37158 375 7 and and CC 37158 375 8 ether ether NN 37158 375 9 have have VBP 37158 375 10 a a DT 37158 375 11 very very RB 37158 375 12 serious serious JJ 37158 375 13 disadvantage disadvantage NN 37158 375 14 for for IN 37158 375 15 the the DT 37158 375 16 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 375 17 . . . 37158 376 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 376 2 abolish abolish VBP 37158 376 3 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 376 4 , , , 37158 376 5 but but CC 37158 376 6 , , , 37158 376 7 at at IN 37158 376 8 the the DT 37158 376 9 same same JJ 37158 376 10 time time NN 37158 376 11 , , , 37158 376 12 they -PRON- PRP 37158 376 13 abolish abolish VBP 37158 376 14 the the DT 37158 376 15 majority majority NN 37158 376 16 of of IN 37158 376 17 the the DT 37158 376 18 reflex reflex NNP 37158 376 19 actions action NNS 37158 376 20 in in IN 37158 376 21 which which WDT 37158 376 22 voluntary voluntary JJ 37158 376 23 muscles muscle NNS 37158 376 24 are be VBP 37158 376 25 concerned concern VBN 37158 376 26 . . . 37158 377 1 Now now RB 37158 377 2 , , , 37158 377 3 in in IN 37158 377 4 many many JJ 37158 377 5 experiments experiment NNS 37158 377 6 , , , 37158 377 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 377 8 is be VBZ 37158 377 9 indispensable indispensable JJ 37158 377 10 to to TO 37158 377 11 be be VB 37158 377 12 able able JJ 37158 377 13 to to TO 37158 377 14 study study VB 37158 377 15 such such JJ 37158 377 16 reflex reflex JJ 37158 377 17 movements movement NNS 37158 377 18 , , , 37158 377 19 that that DT 37158 377 20 is be VBZ 37158 377 21 to to TO 37158 377 22 say say VB 37158 377 23 , , , 37158 377 24 the the DT 37158 377 25 fundamental fundamental JJ 37158 377 26 reactions reaction NNS 37158 377 27 of of IN 37158 377 28 the the DT 37158 377 29 nervous nervous JJ 37158 377 30 system system NN 37158 377 31 . . . 37158 378 1 Thus thus RB 37158 378 2 , , , 37158 378 3 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 378 4 , , , 37158 378 5 more more RBR 37158 378 6 preoccupied preoccupied JJ 37158 378 7 , , , 37158 378 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 378 9 must must MD 37158 378 10 be be VB 37158 378 11 said say VBN 37158 378 12 , , , 37158 378 13 with with IN 37158 378 14 assuring assure VBG 37158 378 15 the the DT 37158 378 16 immobility immobility NN 37158 378 17 than than IN 37158 378 18 the the DT 37158 378 19 insensibility insensibility NN 37158 378 20 of of IN 37158 378 21 the the DT 37158 378 22 animal animal NN 37158 378 23 , , , 37158 378 24 have have VBP 37158 378 25 had have VBN 37158 378 26 recourse recourse VBN 37158 378 27 to to IN 37158 378 28 another another DT 37158 378 29 substance substance NN 37158 378 30 , , , 37158 378 31 _ _ NNP 37158 378 32 curare curare NN 37158 378 33 _ _ NNP 37158 378 34 , , , 37158 378 35 the the DT 37158 378 36 properties property NNS 37158 378 37 of of IN 37158 378 38 which which WDT 37158 378 39 were be VBD 37158 378 40 investigated investigate VBN 37158 378 41 by by IN 37158 378 42 Claude Claude NNP 37158 378 43 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 378 44 . . . 37158 379 1 Curare Curare NNP 37158 379 2 is be VBZ 37158 379 3 a a DT 37158 379 4 poison poison NN 37158 379 5 which which WDT 37158 379 6 the the DT 37158 379 7 natives native NNS 37158 379 8 on on IN 37158 379 9 the the DT 37158 379 10 banks bank NNS 37158 379 11 of of IN 37158 379 12 the the DT 37158 379 13 Amazon Amazon NNP 37158 379 14 prepare prepare VBP 37158 379 15 from from IN 37158 379 16 a a DT 37158 379 17 bind bind NN 37158 379 18 - - HYPH 37158 379 19 weed weed NN 37158 379 20 of of IN 37158 379 21 the the DT 37158 379 22 strychnia strychnia NNP 37158 379 23 family family NN 37158 379 24 . . . 37158 380 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 380 2 boil boil VBP 37158 380 3 the the DT 37158 380 4 plant plant NN 37158 380 5 with with IN 37158 380 6 several several JJ 37158 380 7 ingredients ingredient NNS 37158 380 8 , , , 37158 380 9 finally finally RB 37158 380 10 obtaining obtain VBG 37158 380 11 a a DT 37158 380 12 sort sort NN 37158 380 13 of of IN 37158 380 14 blackish blackish JJ 37158 380 15 resin resin NN 37158 380 16 , , , 37158 380 17 or or CC 37158 380 18 gummy gummy JJ 37158 380 19 juice juice NN 37158 380 20 , , , 37158 380 21 which which WDT 37158 380 22 they -PRON- PRP 37158 380 23 place place VBP 37158 380 24 in in IN 37158 380 25 little little JJ 37158 380 26 gourds gourd NNS 37158 380 27 , , , 37158 380 28 which which WDT 37158 380 29 can can MD 37158 380 30 be be VB 37158 380 31 procured procure VBN 37158 380 32 also also RB 37158 380 33 in in IN 37158 380 34 Europe Europe NNP 37158 380 35 . . . 37158 381 1 This this DT 37158 381 2 juice juice NN 37158 381 3 is be VBZ 37158 381 4 used use VBN 37158 381 5 by by IN 37158 381 6 South South NNP 37158 381 7 American American NNP 37158 381 8 Indians Indians NNPS 37158 381 9 for for IN 37158 381 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 381 11 arrows arrow NNS 37158 381 12 , , , 37158 381 13 and and CC 37158 381 14 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 381 15 use use VBP 37158 381 16 it -PRON- PRP 37158 381 17 to to TO 37158 381 18 ensure ensure VB 37158 381 19 the the DT 37158 381 20 immobility immobility NN 37158 381 21 of of IN 37158 381 22 the the DT 37158 381 23 animal animal NN 37158 381 24 on on IN 37158 381 25 which which WDT 37158 381 26 they -PRON- PRP 37158 381 27 are be VBP 37158 381 28 experimenting experiment VBG 37158 381 29 . . . 37158 382 1 Curare curare NN 37158 382 2 dissolves dissolve VBZ 37158 382 3 in in IN 37158 382 4 water water NN 37158 382 5 , , , 37158 382 6 and and CC 37158 382 7 a a DT 37158 382 8 solution solution NN 37158 382 9 of of IN 37158 382 10 a a DT 37158 382 11 few few JJ 37158 382 12 centigrams centigram NNS 37158 382 13 injected inject VBN 37158 382 14 under under IN 37158 382 15 the the DT 37158 382 16 skin skin NN 37158 382 17 of of IN 37158 382 18 a a DT 37158 382 19 dog dog NN 37158 382 20 , , , 37158 382 21 a a DT 37158 382 22 cat cat NN 37158 382 23 , , , 37158 382 24 a a DT 37158 382 25 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 382 26 , , , 37158 382 27 will will MD 37158 382 28 bring bring VB 37158 382 29 about about RP 37158 382 30 the the DT 37158 382 31 death death NN 37158 382 32 of of IN 37158 382 33 the the DT 37158 382 34 animal animal NN 37158 382 35 in in IN 37158 382 36 a a DT 37158 382 37 few few JJ 37158 382 38 minutes minute NNS 37158 382 39 . . . 37158 383 1 But but CC 37158 383 2 death death NN 37158 383 3 is be VBZ 37158 383 4 not not RB 37158 383 5 due due JJ 37158 383 6 to to IN 37158 383 7 the the DT 37158 383 8 arrest arrest NN 37158 383 9 of of IN 37158 383 10 the the DT 37158 383 11 heart heart NN 37158 383 12 's 's POS 37158 383 13 action action NN 37158 383 14 , , , 37158 383 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 383 16 is be VBZ 37158 383 17 due due JJ 37158 383 18 entirely entirely RB 37158 383 19 to to IN 37158 383 20 paralysis paralysis NN 37158 383 21 of of IN 37158 383 22 the the DT 37158 383 23 respiration respiration NN 37158 383 24 . . . 37158 384 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 384 2 the the DT 37158 384 3 curarised curarise VBN 37158 384 4 animal animal NN 37158 384 5 can can MD 37158 384 6 continue continue VB 37158 384 7 to to TO 37158 384 8 live live VB 37158 384 9 for for IN 37158 384 10 several several JJ 37158 384 11 hours hour NNS 37158 384 12 if if IN 37158 384 13 _ _ NNP 37158 384 14 artificial artificial JJ 37158 384 15 _ _ NNP 37158 384 16 breathing breathing NN 37158 384 17 be be VB 37158 384 18 substituted substitute VBN 37158 384 19 for for IN 37158 384 20 the the DT 37158 384 21 natural natural JJ 37158 384 22 breathing breathing NN 37158 384 23 which which WDT 37158 384 24 is be VBZ 37158 384 25 paralysed paralyse VBN 37158 384 26 . . . 37158 385 1 For for IN 37158 385 2 several several JJ 37158 385 3 hours hour NNS 37158 385 4 the the DT 37158 385 5 animal animal NN 37158 385 6 is be VBZ 37158 385 7 completely completely RB 37158 385 8 motionless motionless JJ 37158 385 9 ; ; : 37158 385 10 the the DT 37158 385 11 heart heart NN 37158 385 12 beats beat VBZ 37158 385 13 with with IN 37158 385 14 force force NN 37158 385 15 and and CC 37158 385 16 regularity regularity NN 37158 385 17 , , , 37158 385 18 provided provide VBD 37158 385 19 that that IN 37158 385 20 the the DT 37158 385 21 insufflation insufflation NN 37158 385 22 of of IN 37158 385 23 air air NN 37158 385 24 into into IN 37158 385 25 the the DT 37158 385 26 lungs lung NNS 37158 385 27 introduces introduce NNS 37158 385 28 into into IN 37158 385 29 the the DT 37158 385 30 blood blood NN 37158 385 31 the the DT 37158 385 32 quantity quantity NN 37158 385 33 of of IN 37158 385 34 oxygen oxygen NN 37158 385 35 necessary necessary JJ 37158 385 36 for for IN 37158 385 37 the the DT 37158 385 38 life life NN 37158 385 39 of of IN 37158 385 40 the the DT 37158 385 41 tissues tissue NNS 37158 385 42 . . . 37158 386 1 Now now RB 37158 386 2 , , , 37158 386 3 under under IN 37158 386 4 these these DT 37158 386 5 conditions condition NNS 37158 386 6 , , , 37158 386 7 as as IN 37158 386 8 Claude Claude NNP 37158 386 9 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 386 10 has have VBZ 37158 386 11 so so RB 37158 386 12 well well RB 37158 386 13 demonstrated demonstrated JJ 37158 386 14 , , , 37158 386 15 we -PRON- PRP 37158 386 16 have have VBP 37158 386 17 no no DT 37158 386 18 proof proof NN 37158 386 19 that that DT 37158 386 20 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 386 21 is be VBZ 37158 386 22 abolished abolish VBN 37158 386 23 also also RB 37158 386 24 . . . 37158 387 1 There there EX 37158 387 2 is be VBZ 37158 387 3 immobility immobility NN 37158 387 4 ; ; : 37158 387 5 there there EX 37158 387 6 is be VBZ 37158 387 7 no no DT 37158 387 8 true true JJ 37158 387 9 anæsthesia anæsthesia NN 37158 387 10 . . . 37158 388 1 Take take VB 37158 388 2 two two CD 37158 388 3 animals animal NNS 37158 388 4 , , , 37158 388 5 one one CD 37158 388 6 chloroformed chloroform VBN 37158 388 7 , , , 37158 388 8 the the DT 37158 388 9 other other JJ 37158 388 10 curarised curarise VBN 37158 388 11 ; ; : 37158 388 12 both both DT 37158 388 13 are be VBP 37158 388 14 equally equally RB 37158 388 15 inert inert JJ 37158 388 16 ; ; : 37158 388 17 but but CC 37158 388 18 the the DT 37158 388 19 chloroformed chloroformed JJ 37158 388 20 animal animal NN 37158 388 21 is be VBZ 37158 388 22 insensible insensible JJ 37158 388 23 , , , 37158 388 24 whilst whilst IN 37158 388 25 the the DT 37158 388 26 curarised curarise VBN 37158 388 27 animal animal NN 37158 388 28 retains retain NNS 37158 388 29 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 388 30 . . . 37158 389 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 389 2 is be VBZ 37158 389 3 impossible impossible JJ 37158 389 4 , , , 37158 389 5 therefore therefore RB 37158 389 6 , , , 37158 389 7 to to TO 37158 389 8 say say VB 37158 389 9 that that IN 37158 389 10 curare curare NN 37158 389 11 replaces replace VBZ 37158 389 12 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 389 13 , , , 37158 389 14 because because IN 37158 389 15 _ _ NNP 37158 389 16 curare curare NN 37158 389 17 is be VBZ 37158 389 18 not not RB 37158 389 19 an an DT 37158 389 20 anæsthetic anæsthetic JJ 37158 389 21 _ _ NNP 37158 389 22 . . . 37158 390 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 390 2 6 6 CD 37158 390 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 390 4 Now now RB 37158 390 5 , , , 37158 390 6 in in IN 37158 390 7 1894 1894 CD 37158 390 8 I -PRON- PRP 37158 390 9 was be VBD 37158 390 10 able able JJ 37158 390 11 to to TO 37158 390 12 discover discover VB 37158 390 13 a a DT 37158 390 14 substance substance NN 37158 390 15 which which WDT 37158 390 16 has have VBZ 37158 390 17 all all PDT 37158 390 18 the the DT 37158 390 19 anæsthetic anæsthetic JJ 37158 390 20 properties property NNS 37158 390 21 of of IN 37158 390 22 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 390 23 , , , 37158 390 24 and and CC 37158 390 25 which which WDT 37158 390 26 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 390 27 does do VBZ 37158 390 28 not not RB 37158 390 29 abolish abolish VB 37158 390 30 reflex reflex JJ 37158 390 31 actions action NNS 37158 390 32 , , , 37158 390 33 so so IN 37158 390 34 that that IN 37158 390 35 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 390 36 are be VBP 37158 390 37 able able JJ 37158 390 38 to to TO 37158 390 39 use use VB 37158 390 40 it -PRON- PRP 37158 390 41 for for IN 37158 390 42 experiments experiment NNS 37158 390 43 which which WDT 37158 390 44 , , , 37158 390 45 formerly formerly RB 37158 390 46 , , , 37158 390 47 necessitated necessitate VBD 37158 390 48 the the DT 37158 390 49 use use NN 37158 390 50 of of IN 37158 390 51 curare curare NN 37158 390 52 . . . 37158 391 1 This this DT 37158 391 2 substance substance NN 37158 391 3 is be VBZ 37158 391 4 called call VBN 37158 391 5 _ _ NNP 37158 391 6 chloralose chloralose NNP 37158 391 7 _ _ NNP 37158 391 8 ; ; : 37158 391 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 391 10 is be VBZ 37158 391 11 obtained obtain VBN 37158 391 12 by by IN 37158 391 13 mixing mix VBG 37158 391 14 anhydrous anhydrous JJ 37158 391 15 chloral chloral NN 37158 391 16 with with IN 37158 391 17 glucose glucose NN 37158 391 18 . . . 37158 392 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 392 2 is be VBZ 37158 392 3 not not RB 37158 392 4 necessary necessary JJ 37158 392 5 for for IN 37158 392 6 me -PRON- PRP 37158 392 7 to to TO 37158 392 8 describe describe VB 37158 392 9 here here RB 37158 392 10 in in IN 37158 392 11 detail detail NN 37158 392 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 392 13 chemical chemical NN 37158 392 14 or or CC 37158 392 15 physiological physiological JJ 37158 392 16 properties property NNS 37158 392 17 ; ; : 37158 392 18 I -PRON- PRP 37158 392 19 will will MD 37158 392 20 only only RB 37158 392 21 say say VB 37158 392 22 that that IN 37158 392 23 in in IN 37158 392 24 very very RB 37158 392 25 small small JJ 37158 392 26 doses dose NNS 37158 392 27 ( ( -LRB- 37158 392 28 about about RB 37158 392 29 twenty twenty CD 37158 392 30 - - HYPH 37158 392 31 five five CD 37158 392 32 centigrams centigram NNS 37158 392 33 ) ) -RRB- 37158 392 34 it -PRON- PRP 37158 392 35 is be VBZ 37158 392 36 an an DT 37158 392 37 excellent excellent JJ 37158 392 38 hypnotic hypnotic NN 37158 392 39 for for IN 37158 392 40 man man NN 37158 392 41 , , , 37158 392 42 and and CC 37158 392 43 that that IN 37158 392 44 in in IN 37158 392 45 larger large JJR 37158 392 46 doses dose NNS 37158 392 47 , , , 37158 392 48 injected inject VBN 37158 392 49 into into IN 37158 392 50 the the DT 37158 392 51 vein vein NN 37158 392 52 of of IN 37158 392 53 a a DT 37158 392 54 dog dog NN 37158 392 55 or or CC 37158 392 56 a a DT 37158 392 57 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 392 58 , , , 37158 392 59 it -PRON- PRP 37158 392 60 brings bring VBZ 37158 392 61 about about RP 37158 392 62 complete complete JJ 37158 392 63 anæsthesia anæsthesia NN 37158 392 64 without without IN 37158 392 65 affecting affect VBG 37158 392 66 either either CC 37158 392 67 the the DT 37158 392 68 breathing breathing NN 37158 392 69 , , , 37158 392 70 the the DT 37158 392 71 heart heart NN 37158 392 72 , , , 37158 392 73 or or CC 37158 392 74 the the DT 37158 392 75 reflex reflex JJ 37158 392 76 actions action NNS 37158 392 77 . . . 37158 393 1 Since since IN 37158 393 2 this this DT 37158 393 3 discovery discovery NN 37158 393 4 , , , 37158 393 5 many many JJ 37158 393 6 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 393 7 -- -- : 37158 393 8 and and CC 37158 393 9 I -PRON- PRP 37158 393 10 regret regret VBP 37158 393 11 not not RB 37158 393 12 to to TO 37158 393 13 be be VB 37158 393 14 able able JJ 37158 393 15 to to TO 37158 393 16 say say VB 37158 393 17 so so RB 37158 393 18 of of IN 37158 393 19 every every DT 37158 393 20 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 393 21 -- -- : 37158 393 22 have have VBP 37158 393 23 given give VBN 37158 393 24 up up RP 37158 393 25 curare curare NN 37158 393 26 and and CC 37158 393 27 use use VB 37158 393 28 nothing nothing NN 37158 393 29 but but IN 37158 393 30 chloralose chloralose NNP 37158 393 31 , , , 37158 393 32 which which WDT 37158 393 33 is be VBZ 37158 393 34 a a DT 37158 393 35 perfect perfect JJ 37158 393 36 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 393 37 , , , 37158 393 38 and and CC 37158 393 39 which which WDT 37158 393 40 allows allow VBZ 37158 393 41 the the DT 37158 393 42 reflex reflex JJ 37158 393 43 actions action NNS 37158 393 44 to to TO 37158 393 45 be be VB 37158 393 46 studied study VBN 37158 393 47 although although IN 37158 393 48 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 393 49 is be VBZ 37158 393 50 perfect perfect JJ 37158 393 51 . . . 37158 394 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 394 2 may may MD 37158 394 3 be be VB 37158 394 4 objected object VBN 37158 394 5 that that IN 37158 394 6 a a DT 37158 394 7 tiny tiny JJ 37158 394 8 puncture puncture NN 37158 394 9 has have VBZ 37158 394 10 to to TO 37158 394 11 be be VB 37158 394 12 made make VBN 37158 394 13 in in IN 37158 394 14 the the DT 37158 394 15 vein vein NN 37158 394 16 to to TO 37158 394 17 introduce introduce VB 37158 394 18 the the DT 37158 394 19 chloralose chloralose NNP 37158 394 20 into into IN 37158 394 21 the the DT 37158 394 22 circulation circulation NN 37158 394 23 ; ; : 37158 394 24 but but CC 37158 394 25 this this DT 37158 394 26 puncture puncture NN 37158 394 27 is be VBZ 37158 394 28 really really RB 37158 394 29 such such PDT 37158 394 30 a a DT 37158 394 31 trifle trifle NN 37158 394 32 that that IN 37158 394 33 it -PRON- PRP 37158 394 34 would would MD 37158 394 35 be be VB 37158 394 36 sheer sheer JJ 37158 394 37 childishness childishness NN 37158 394 38 to to TO 37158 394 39 pay pay VB 37158 394 40 any any DT 37158 394 41 attention attention NN 37158 394 42 to to IN 37158 394 43 it -PRON- PRP 37158 394 44 . . . 37158 395 1 What what WDT 37158 395 2 doctor doctor NN 37158 395 3 would would MD 37158 395 4 hesitate hesitate VB 37158 395 5 to to TO 37158 395 6 make make VB 37158 395 7 a a DT 37158 395 8 puncture puncture NN 37158 395 9 in in IN 37158 395 10 the the DT 37158 395 11 skin skin NN 37158 395 12 of of IN 37158 395 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 395 14 patient patient NN 37158 395 15 for for IN 37158 395 16 the the DT 37158 395 17 injection injection NN 37158 395 18 of of IN 37158 395 19 a a DT 37158 395 20 solution solution NN 37158 395 21 of of IN 37158 395 22 morphia morphia NN 37158 395 23 ? ? . 37158 396 1 However however RB 37158 396 2 , , , 37158 396 3 if if IN 37158 396 4 sentimentality sentimentality NN 37158 396 5 be be VB 37158 396 6 pushed push VBN 37158 396 7 to to IN 37158 396 8 such such PDT 37158 396 9 a a DT 37158 396 10 degree degree NN 37158 396 11 as as IN 37158 396 12 to to TO 37158 396 13 shrink shrink VB 37158 396 14 from from IN 37158 396 15 touching touch VBG 37158 396 16 the the DT 37158 396 17 vein vein NN 37158 396 18 of of IN 37158 396 19 a a DT 37158 396 20 dog dog NN 37158 396 21 in in IN 37158 396 22 order order NN 37158 396 23 to to TO 37158 396 24 put put VB 37158 396 25 him -PRON- PRP 37158 396 26 to to TO 37158 396 27 sleep sleep VB 37158 396 28 , , , 37158 396 29 even even RB 37158 396 30 this this DT 37158 396 31 tiny tiny JJ 37158 396 32 puncture puncture NN 37158 396 33 can can MD 37158 396 34 be be VB 37158 396 35 avoided avoid VBN 37158 396 36 by by IN 37158 396 37 mixing mix VBG 37158 396 38 the the DT 37158 396 39 chloralose chloralose NN 37158 396 40 with with IN 37158 396 41 the the DT 37158 396 42 food food NN 37158 396 43 of of IN 37158 396 44 the the DT 37158 396 45 animal animal NN 37158 396 46 to to TO 37158 396 47 be be VB 37158 396 48 experimented experiment VBN 37158 396 49 upon upon IN 37158 396 50 . . . 37158 397 1 In in IN 37158 397 2 half half PDT 37158 397 3 an an DT 37158 397 4 hour hour NN 37158 397 5 or or CC 37158 397 6 three three CD 37158 397 7 - - HYPH 37158 397 8 quarters quarter NNS 37158 397 9 of of IN 37158 397 10 an an DT 37158 397 11 hour hour NN 37158 397 12 after after IN 37158 397 13 the the DT 37158 397 14 mixture mixture NN 37158 397 15 is be VBZ 37158 397 16 given give VBN 37158 397 17 he -PRON- PRP 37158 397 18 is be VBZ 37158 397 19 in in IN 37158 397 20 a a DT 37158 397 21 state state NN 37158 397 22 of of IN 37158 397 23 perfect perfect JJ 37158 397 24 anæsthesia anæsthesia NN 37158 397 25 . . . 37158 398 1 For for IN 37158 398 2 these these DT 37158 398 3 reasons reason NNS 37158 398 4 , , , 37158 398 5 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 398 6 with with IN 37158 398 7 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 398 8 seems seem VBZ 37158 398 9 to to IN 37158 398 10 me -PRON- PRP 37158 398 11 to to TO 37158 398 12 be be VB 37158 398 13 quite quite RB 37158 398 14 legitimate legitimate JJ 37158 398 15 . . . 37158 399 1 As as RB 37158 399 2 soon soon RB 37158 399 3 as as IN 37158 399 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 399 5 is be VBZ 37158 399 6 recognised recognise VBN 37158 399 7 that that DT 37158 399 8 man man NN 37158 399 9 has have VBZ 37158 399 10 the the DT 37158 399 11 right right NN 37158 399 12 to to TO 37158 399 13 kill kill VB 37158 399 14 the the DT 37158 399 15 animal animal NN 37158 399 16 , , , 37158 399 17 he -PRON- PRP 37158 399 18 has have VBZ 37158 399 19 the the DT 37158 399 20 right right NN 37158 399 21 to to TO 37158 399 22 kill kill VB 37158 399 23 him -PRON- PRP 37158 399 24 as as IN 37158 399 25 he -PRON- PRP 37158 399 26 pleases please VBZ 37158 399 27 , , , 37158 399 28 provided provide VBN 37158 399 29 he -PRON- PRP 37158 399 30 spares spare VBZ 37158 399 31 him -PRON- PRP 37158 399 32 all all DT 37158 399 33 suffering suffer VBG 37158 399 34 . . . 37158 400 1 Let let VB 37158 400 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 400 3 also also RB 37158 400 4 reflect reflect VB 37158 400 5 a a DT 37158 400 6 little little JJ 37158 400 7 on on IN 37158 400 8 this this DT 37158 400 9 point point NN 37158 400 10 : : : 37158 400 11 an an DT 37158 400 12 animal animal NN 37158 400 13 has have VBZ 37158 400 14 to to TO 37158 400 15 die die VB 37158 400 16 just just RB 37158 400 17 as as RB 37158 400 18 much much RB 37158 400 19 as as IN 37158 400 20 we -PRON- PRP 37158 400 21 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 400 22 . . . 37158 401 1 Now now RB 37158 401 2 , , , 37158 401 3 natural natural JJ 37158 401 4 death death NN 37158 401 5 would would MD 37158 401 6 certainly certainly RB 37158 401 7 be be VB 37158 401 8 for for IN 37158 401 9 him -PRON- PRP 37158 401 10 a a DT 37158 401 11 long long JJ 37158 401 12 and and CC 37158 401 13 cruel cruel JJ 37158 401 14 agony agony NN 37158 401 15 , , , 37158 401 16 lasting last VBG 37158 401 17 several several JJ 37158 401 18 hours hour NNS 37158 401 19 , , , 37158 401 20 several several JJ 37158 401 21 days day NNS 37158 401 22 , , , 37158 401 23 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 401 24 several several JJ 37158 401 25 weeks week NNS 37158 401 26 . . . 37158 402 1 Well well UH 37158 402 2 , , , 37158 402 3 then then RB 37158 402 4 , , , 37158 402 5 we -PRON- PRP 37158 402 6 replace replace VBP 37158 402 7 hideous hideous JJ 37158 402 8 old old JJ 37158 402 9 age age NN 37158 402 10 , , , 37158 402 11 the the DT 37158 402 12 agony agony NN 37158 402 13 of of IN 37158 402 14 prolonged prolonged JJ 37158 402 15 tortures torture NNS 37158 402 16 due due JJ 37158 402 17 to to IN 37158 402 18 disease disease NN 37158 402 19 , , , 37158 402 20 by by IN 37158 402 21 a a DT 37158 402 22 dreamless dreamless NN 37158 402 23 sleep sleep NN 37158 402 24 , , , 37158 402 25 which which WDT 37158 402 26 at at IN 37158 402 27 once once RB 37158 402 28 plunges plunge VBZ 37158 402 29 the the DT 37158 402 30 animal animal NN 37158 402 31 into into IN 37158 402 32 nothingness nothingness NN 37158 402 33 , , , 37158 402 34 without without IN 37158 402 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 402 36 passing passing NN 37158 402 37 through through IN 37158 402 38 the the DT 37158 402 39 intermediary intermediary JJ 37158 402 40 stage stage NN 37158 402 41 of of IN 37158 402 42 necessary necessary JJ 37158 402 43 suffering suffering NN 37158 402 44 . . . 37158 403 1 Is be VBZ 37158 403 2 this this DT 37158 403 3 what what WP 37158 403 4 is be VBZ 37158 403 5 called call VBN 37158 403 6 being be VBG 37158 403 7 inhuman inhuman JJ 37158 403 8 ? ? . 37158 404 1 For for IN 37158 404 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 404 3 part part NN 37158 404 4 , , , 37158 404 5 I -PRON- PRP 37158 404 6 shall shall MD 37158 404 7 regret regret VB 37158 404 8 on on IN 37158 404 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 404 10 death death NN 37158 404 11 - - HYPH 37158 404 12 bed bed NN 37158 404 13 that that IN 37158 404 14 no no DT 37158 404 15 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 404 16 will will MD 37158 404 17 be be VB 37158 404 18 found find VBN 37158 404 19 whose whose WP$ 37158 404 20 conscience conscience NN 37158 404 21 will will MD 37158 404 22 permit permit VB 37158 404 23 him -PRON- PRP 37158 404 24 , , , 37158 404 25 or or CC 37158 404 26 , , , 37158 404 27 if if IN 37158 404 28 so so RB 37158 404 29 , , , 37158 404 30 who who WP 37158 404 31 would would MD 37158 404 32 have have VB 37158 404 33 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 404 34 courage courage NN 37158 404 35 to to TO 37158 404 36 help help VB 37158 404 37 me -PRON- PRP 37158 404 38 to to TO 37158 404 39 pass pass VB 37158 404 40 away away RB 37158 404 41 under under IN 37158 404 42 the the DT 37158 404 43 influence influence NN 37158 404 44 of of IN 37158 404 45 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 404 46 , , , 37158 404 47 ether ether NN 37158 404 48 , , , 37158 404 49 chloralose chloralose NNP 37158 404 50 , , , 37158 404 51 morphia morphia NN 37158 404 52 , , , 37158 404 53 or or CC 37158 404 54 chloral chloral JJ 37158 404 55 , , , 37158 404 56 thus thus RB 37158 404 57 saving save VBG 37158 404 58 me -PRON- PRP 37158 404 59 from from IN 37158 404 60 the the DT 37158 404 61 throes throe NNS 37158 404 62 of of IN 37158 404 63 the the DT 37158 404 64 final final JJ 37158 404 65 struggle struggle NN 37158 404 66 , , , 37158 404 67 and and CC 37158 404 68 bestowing bestow VBG 37158 404 69 upon upon IN 37158 404 70 me -PRON- PRP 37158 404 71 a a DT 37158 404 72 peaceful peaceful JJ 37158 404 73 death death NN 37158 404 74 and and CC 37158 404 75 an an DT 37158 404 76 easy easy JJ 37158 404 77 termination termination NN 37158 404 78 of of IN 37158 404 79 all all DT 37158 404 80 suffering suffering NN 37158 404 81 . . . 37158 405 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 37158 405 2 : : : 37158 405 3 [ [ -LRB- 37158 405 4 6 6 CD 37158 405 5 ] ] -RRB- 37158 405 6 In in IN 37158 405 7 England England NNP 37158 405 8 , , , 37158 405 9 the the DT 37158 405 10 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 405 11 Act Act NNP 37158 405 12 expressly expressly RB 37158 405 13 states state VBZ 37158 405 14 that that IN 37158 405 15 curare curare NN 37158 405 16 is be VBZ 37158 405 17 not not RB 37158 405 18 to to TO 37158 405 19 be be VB 37158 405 20 regarded regard VBN 37158 405 21 as as IN 37158 405 22 an an DT 37158 405 23 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 405 24 , , , 37158 405 25 and and CC 37158 405 26 this this DT 37158 405 27 proviso proviso NN 37158 405 28 has have VBZ 37158 405 29 been be VBN 37158 405 30 loyally loyally RB 37158 405 31 accepted accept VBN 37158 405 32 by by IN 37158 405 33 English english JJ 37158 405 34 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 405 35 . . . 37158 406 1 On on IN 37158 406 2 those those DT 37158 406 3 rare rare JJ 37158 406 4 occasions occasion NNS 37158 406 5 when when WRB 37158 406 6 curare curare NNP 37158 406 7 is be VBZ 37158 406 8 used use VBN 37158 406 9 , , , 37158 406 10 and and CC 37158 406 11 the the DT 37158 406 12 occasions occasion NNS 37158 406 13 are be VBP 37158 406 14 very very RB 37158 406 15 rare rare JJ 37158 406 16 indeed indeed RB 37158 406 17 , , , 37158 406 18 and and CC 37158 406 19 year year NN 37158 406 20 by by IN 37158 406 21 year year NN 37158 406 22 they -PRON- PRP 37158 406 23 become become VBP 37158 406 24 rarer rare JJR 37158 406 25 , , , 37158 406 26 a a DT 37158 406 27 volatile volatile JJ 37158 406 28 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 406 29 such such JJ 37158 406 30 as as IN 37158 406 31 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 406 32 or or CC 37158 406 33 A.C.E. A.C.E. NNP 37158 407 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 407 2 alcohol alcohol NN 37158 407 3 , , , 37158 407 4 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 407 5 , , , 37158 407 6 ether ether NN 37158 407 7 ) ) -RRB- 37158 407 8 mixture mixture NN 37158 407 9 is be VBZ 37158 407 10 administered administer VBN 37158 407 11 at at IN 37158 407 12 the the DT 37158 407 13 same same JJ 37158 407 14 time time NN 37158 407 15 in in IN 37158 407 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 407 17 amount amount NN 37158 407 18 to to TO 37158 407 19 render render VB 37158 407 20 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 407 21 absolute absolute NNP 37158 407 22 . . . 37158 408 1 One one PRP 37158 408 2 should should MD 37158 408 3 add add VB 37158 408 4 that that IN 37158 408 5 since since IN 37158 408 6 Claude Claude NNP 37158 408 7 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 408 8 's 's POS 37158 408 9 work work NN 37158 408 10 on on IN 37158 408 11 curare curare NN 37158 408 12 , , , 37158 408 13 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 408 14 have have VBP 37158 408 15 seen see VBN 37158 408 16 reason reason NN 37158 408 17 for for IN 37158 408 18 doubting doubt VBG 37158 408 19 whether whether IN 37158 408 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 408 21 leaves leave VBZ 37158 408 22 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 408 23 intact intact JJ 37158 408 24 , , , 37158 408 25 as as IN 37158 408 26 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 408 27 thought think VBD 37158 408 28 . . . 37158 409 1 But but CC 37158 409 2 as as IN 37158 409 3 there there EX 37158 409 4 is be VBZ 37158 409 5 doubt doubt NN 37158 409 6 on on IN 37158 409 7 the the DT 37158 409 8 question question NN 37158 409 9 , , , 37158 409 10 and and CC 37158 409 11 the the DT 37158 409 12 available available JJ 37158 409 13 evidence evidence NN 37158 409 14 in in IN 37158 409 15 favour favour NN 37158 409 16 of of IN 37158 409 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 409 18 lulling lulling NN 37158 409 19 sensations sensation NNS 37158 409 20 is be VBZ 37158 409 21 small small JJ 37158 409 22 , , , 37158 409 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 409 24 is be VBZ 37158 409 25 still still RB 37158 409 26 considered consider VBN 37158 409 27 advisable advisable JJ 37158 409 28 to to TO 37158 409 29 retain retain VB 37158 409 30 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 409 31 's 's POS 37158 409 32 views view NNS 37158 409 33 , , , 37158 409 34 and and CC 37158 409 35 act act VB 37158 409 36 as as IN 37158 409 37 though though IN 37158 409 38 it -PRON- PRP 37158 409 39 is be VBZ 37158 409 40 not not RB 37158 409 41 an an DT 37158 409 42 anæsthetic anæsthetic NN 37158 409 43 at at IN 37158 409 44 all.--(W. all.--(w. ADD 37158 410 1 D. D. NNP 37158 410 2 H. H. NNP 37158 410 3 ) ) -RRB- 37158 410 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37158 410 5 IV IV NNP 37158 410 6 CONCERNING concern VBG 37158 410 7 EXPERIMENTATION experimentation NN 37158 410 8 OTHER other JJ 37158 410 9 THAN than IN 37158 410 10 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 410 11 We -PRON- PRP 37158 410 12 must must MD 37158 410 13 , , , 37158 410 14 however however RB 37158 410 15 , , , 37158 410 16 give give VB 37158 410 17 to to IN 37158 410 18 the the DT 37158 410 19 word word NN 37158 410 20 " " `` 37158 410 21 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 410 22 " " '' 37158 410 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 410 24 largest large JJS 37158 410 25 acceptation acceptation NN 37158 410 26 . . . 37158 411 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 411 2 is be VBZ 37158 411 3 not not RB 37158 411 4 only only RB 37158 411 5 a a DT 37158 411 6 question question NN 37158 411 7 of of IN 37158 411 8 cutting cut VBG 37158 411 9 nerves nerve NNS 37158 411 10 , , , 37158 411 11 of of IN 37158 411 12 stimulating stimulate VBG 37158 411 13 the the DT 37158 411 14 glands gland NNS 37158 411 15 , , , 37158 411 16 or or CC 37158 411 17 of of IN 37158 411 18 exciting excite VBG 37158 411 19 the the DT 37158 411 20 muscles muscle NNS 37158 411 21 . . . 37158 412 1 There there EX 37158 412 2 are be VBP 37158 412 3 experiments experiment NNS 37158 412 4 of of IN 37158 412 5 much much RB 37158 412 6 longer long JJR 37158 412 7 duration duration NN 37158 412 8 in in IN 37158 412 9 which which WDT 37158 412 10 there there EX 37158 412 11 is be VBZ 37158 412 12 no no DT 37158 412 13 mutilation mutilation NN 37158 412 14 properly properly RB 37158 412 15 speaking speak VBG 37158 412 16 , , , 37158 412 17 but but CC 37158 412 18 _ _ NNP 37158 412 19 intoxication_,[7 intoxication_,[7 NNP 37158 412 20 ] ] -RRB- 37158 412 21 produced produce VBN 37158 412 22 by by IN 37158 412 23 the the DT 37158 412 24 injection injection NN 37158 412 25 of of IN 37158 412 26 poisons poison NNS 37158 412 27 and and CC 37158 412 28 disease disease NN 37158 412 29 germs germ NNS 37158 412 30 . . . 37158 413 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 413 2 is be VBZ 37158 413 3 , , , 37158 413 4 indeed indeed RB 37158 413 5 , , , 37158 413 6 evident evident JJ 37158 413 7 that that DT 37158 413 8 pain pain NN 37158 413 9 can can MD 37158 413 10 be be VB 37158 413 11 provoked provoke VBN 37158 413 12 in in IN 37158 413 13 other other JJ 37158 413 14 ways way NNS 37158 413 15 than than IN 37158 413 16 by by IN 37158 413 17 a a DT 37158 413 18 sharp sharp RB 37158 413 19 - - HYPH 37158 413 20 edged edge VBN 37158 413 21 instrument instrument NN 37158 413 22 , , , 37158 413 23 which which WDT 37158 413 24 can can MD 37158 413 25 always always RB 37158 413 26 be be VB 37158 413 27 done do VBN 37158 413 28 under under IN 37158 413 29 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 413 30 . . . 37158 414 1 But but CC 37158 414 2 may may MD 37158 414 3 inoculation inoculation NN 37158 414 4 be be VB 37158 414 5 performed perform VBN 37158 414 6 ? ? . 37158 415 1 May May MD 37158 415 2 prolonged prolong VBD 37158 415 3 _ _ NNP 37158 415 4 intoxication intoxication NN 37158 415 5 _ _ NNP 37158 415 6 be be VB 37158 415 7 caused cause VBN 37158 415 8 ? ? . 37158 416 1 To to TO 37158 416 2 treat treat VB 37158 416 3 the the DT 37158 416 4 question question NN 37158 416 5 in in IN 37158 416 6 all all DT 37158 416 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 416 8 fulness fulness NN 37158 416 9 , , , 37158 416 10 we -PRON- PRP 37158 416 11 will will MD 37158 416 12 put put VB 37158 416 13 the the DT 37158 416 14 problem problem NN 37158 416 15 in in IN 37158 416 16 the the DT 37158 416 17 following follow VBG 37158 416 18 manner manner NN 37158 416 19 . . . 37158 417 1 In in IN 37158 417 2 order order NN 37158 417 3 to to TO 37158 417 4 study study VB 37158 417 5 a a DT 37158 417 6 disease disease NN 37158 417 7 , , , 37158 417 8 have have VBP 37158 417 9 we -PRON- PRP 37158 417 10 the the DT 37158 417 11 right right NN 37158 417 12 to to TO 37158 417 13 give give VB 37158 417 14 that that DT 37158 417 15 disease disease NN 37158 417 16 to to IN 37158 417 17 an an DT 37158 417 18 animal animal NN 37158 417 19 ? ? . 37158 418 1 For for IN 37158 418 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 418 3 part part NN 37158 418 4 , , , 37158 418 5 there there EX 37158 418 6 can can MD 37158 418 7 be be VB 37158 418 8 no no DT 37158 418 9 doubt doubt NN 37158 418 10 on on IN 37158 418 11 the the DT 37158 418 12 point point NN 37158 418 13 , , , 37158 418 14 and and CC 37158 418 15 I -PRON- PRP 37158 418 16 affirm affirm VBP 37158 418 17 that that IN 37158 418 18 such such JJ 37158 418 19 is be VBZ 37158 418 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 418 21 right right NN 37158 418 22 . . . 37158 419 1 As as IN 37158 419 2 a a DT 37158 419 3 matter matter NN 37158 419 4 of of IN 37158 419 5 fact fact NN 37158 419 6 , , , 37158 419 7 and and CC 37158 419 8 as as IN 37158 419 9 every every DT 37158 419 10 unbiassed unbiassed JJ 37158 419 11 person person NN 37158 419 12 is be VBZ 37158 419 13 forced force VBN 37158 419 14 to to TO 37158 419 15 recognise recognise VB 37158 419 16 , , , 37158 419 17 it -PRON- PRP 37158 419 18 is be VBZ 37158 419 19 only only RB 37158 419 20 by by IN 37158 419 21 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 419 22 that that IN 37158 419 23 these these DT 37158 419 24 diseases disease NNS 37158 419 25 can can MD 37158 419 26 be be VB 37158 419 27 studied study VBN 37158 419 28 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 419 29 . . . 37158 420 1 Clinical clinical JJ 37158 420 2 observation observation NN 37158 420 3 , , , 37158 420 4 bearing bear VBG 37158 420 5 exclusively exclusively RB 37158 420 6 upon upon IN 37158 420 7 man man NN 37158 420 8 , , , 37158 420 9 can can MD 37158 420 10 only only RB 37158 420 11 give give VB 37158 420 12 incomplete incomplete JJ 37158 420 13 results result NNS 37158 420 14 , , , 37158 420 15 much much RB 37158 420 16 poorer poor JJR 37158 420 17 , , , 37158 420 18 though though IN 37158 420 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 420 20 documents document NNS 37158 420 21 are be VBP 37158 420 22 multitudinous multitudinous JJ 37158 420 23 , , , 37158 420 24 than than IN 37158 420 25 the the DT 37158 420 26 results result NNS 37158 420 27 furnished furnish VBN 37158 420 28 by by IN 37158 420 29 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 420 30 , , , 37158 420 31 which which WDT 37158 420 32 can can MD 37158 420 33 be be VB 37158 420 34 infinitely infinitely RB 37158 420 35 varied varied JJ 37158 420 36 at at IN 37158 420 37 will will NN 37158 420 38 . . . 37158 421 1 If if IN 37158 421 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 421 3 were be VBD 37158 421 4 limited limited JJ 37158 421 5 to to IN 37158 421 6 the the DT 37158 421 7 Hippocratic hippocratic JJ 37158 421 8 method method NN 37158 421 9 of of IN 37158 421 10 observation observation NN 37158 421 11 , , , 37158 421 12 which which WDT 37158 421 13 consists consist VBZ 37158 421 14 in in IN 37158 421 15 studying study VBG 37158 421 16 the the DT 37158 421 17 symptoms symptom NNS 37158 421 18 and and CC 37158 421 19 the the DT 37158 421 20 progress progress NN 37158 421 21 of of IN 37158 421 22 a a DT 37158 421 23 morbid morbid NN 37158 421 24 affliction affliction NN 37158 421 25 , , , 37158 421 26 we -PRON- PRP 37158 421 27 should should MD 37158 421 28 be be VB 37158 421 29 reduced reduce VBN 37158 421 30 to to IN 37158 421 31 poor poor JJ 37158 421 32 enough enough JJ 37158 421 33 resources resource NNS 37158 421 34 ; ; : 37158 421 35 and and CC 37158 421 36 if if IN 37158 421 37 meditation meditation NN 37158 421 38 on on IN 37158 421 39 the the DT 37158 421 40 aphorisms aphorism NNS 37158 421 41 of of IN 37158 421 42 Hippocrates Hippocrates NNPS 37158 421 43 constituted constitute VBD 37158 421 44 the the DT 37158 421 45 whole whole JJ 37158 421 46 extent extent NN 37158 421 47 of of IN 37158 421 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 421 49 medical medical JJ 37158 421 50 science science NN 37158 421 51 , , , 37158 421 52 medical medical JJ 37158 421 53 science science NN 37158 421 54 would would MD 37158 421 55 be be VB 37158 421 56 a a DT 37158 421 57 sad sad JJ 37158 421 58 vacuum vacuum NN 37158 421 59 . . . 37158 422 1 Fortunately fortunately RB 37158 422 2 , , , 37158 422 3 however however RB 37158 422 4 , , , 37158 422 5 such such JJ 37158 422 6 is be VBZ 37158 422 7 not not RB 37158 422 8 the the DT 37158 422 9 case case NN 37158 422 10 . . . 37158 423 1 Marvellous marvellous JJ 37158 423 2 progress progress NN 37158 423 3 has have VBZ 37158 423 4 been be VBN 37158 423 5 realised realise VBN 37158 423 6 , , , 37158 423 7 which which WDT 37158 423 8 allows allow VBZ 37158 423 9 us -PRON- PRP 37158 423 10 to to TO 37158 423 11 entertain entertain VB 37158 423 12 quite quite RB 37158 423 13 other other JJ 37158 423 14 ideas idea NNS 37158 423 15 than than IN 37158 423 16 those those DT 37158 423 17 of of IN 37158 423 18 the the DT 37158 423 19 Father Father NNP 37158 423 20 of of IN 37158 423 21 Medicine Medicine NNP 37158 423 22 on on IN 37158 423 23 the the DT 37158 423 24 nature nature NN 37158 423 25 of of IN 37158 423 26 diseases disease NNS 37158 423 27 , , , 37158 423 28 and and CC 37158 423 29 consequently consequently RB 37158 423 30 on on IN 37158 423 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 423 32 treatment treatment NN 37158 423 33 and and CC 37158 423 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 423 35 prevention prevention NN 37158 423 36 . . . 37158 424 1 Those those DT 37158 424 2 very very JJ 37158 424 3 persons person NNS 37158 424 4 who who WP 37158 424 5 rise rise VBP 37158 424 6 up up RP 37158 424 7 in in IN 37158 424 8 arms arm NNS 37158 424 9 against against IN 37158 424 10 physiological physiological JJ 37158 424 11 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 424 12 would would MD 37158 424 13 not not RB 37158 424 14 , , , 37158 424 15 I -PRON- PRP 37158 424 16 imagine imagine VBP 37158 424 17 , , , 37158 424 18 desire desire VBP 37158 424 19 to to TO 37158 424 20 be be VB 37158 424 21 handed hand VBN 37158 424 22 over over RP 37158 424 23 to to IN 37158 424 24 the the DT 37158 424 25 care care NN 37158 424 26 of of IN 37158 424 27 a a DT 37158 424 28 Hippocratic hippocratic JJ 37158 424 29 doctor doctor NN 37158 424 30 if if IN 37158 424 31 they -PRON- PRP 37158 424 32 were be VBD 37158 424 33 ill ill JJ 37158 424 34 , , , 37158 424 35 to to IN 37158 424 36 a a DT 37158 424 37 doctor doctor NN 37158 424 38 who who WP 37158 424 39 took take VBD 37158 424 40 no no DT 37158 424 41 notice notice NN 37158 424 42 of of IN 37158 424 43 any any DT 37158 424 44 modern modern JJ 37158 424 45 discoveries discovery NNS 37158 424 46 under under IN 37158 424 47 the the DT 37158 424 48 pretext pretext NN 37158 424 49 that that IN 37158 424 50 they -PRON- PRP 37158 424 51 were be VBD 37158 424 52 acquired acquire VBN 37158 424 53 by by IN 37158 424 54 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 424 55 _ _ NNP 37158 424 56 in in IN 37158 424 57 anima anima NNP 37158 424 58 vili vili NNP 37158 424 59 _ _ NNP 37158 424 60 . . . 37158 425 1 If if IN 37158 425 2 , , , 37158 425 3 however however RB 37158 425 4 , , , 37158 425 5 we -PRON- PRP 37158 425 6 wish wish VBP 37158 425 7 to to TO 37158 425 8 discuss discuss VB 37158 425 9 the the DT 37158 425 10 problem problem NN 37158 425 11 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 425 12 , , , 37158 425 13 it -PRON- PRP 37158 425 14 will will MD 37158 425 15 not not RB 37158 425 16 do do VB 37158 425 17 to to TO 37158 425 18 remain remain VB 37158 425 19 on on IN 37158 425 20 indefinite indefinite JJ 37158 425 21 ground ground NN 37158 425 22 . . . 37158 426 1 Let let VB 37158 426 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 426 3 arrive arrive VB 37158 426 4 at at IN 37158 426 5 precise precise JJ 37158 426 6 facts fact NNS 37158 426 7 . . . 37158 427 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 427 2 will will MD 37158 427 3 mention mention VB 37158 427 4 only only RB 37158 427 5 three three CD 37158 427 6 discoveries discovery NNS 37158 427 7 , , , 37158 427 8 the the DT 37158 427 9 importance importance NN 37158 427 10 of of IN 37158 427 11 which which WDT 37158 427 12 is be VBZ 37158 427 13 considerable considerable JJ 37158 427 14 , , , 37158 427 15 and and CC 37158 427 16 which which WDT 37158 427 17 have have VBP 37158 427 18 been be VBN 37158 427 19 established establish VBN 37158 427 20 solely solely RB 37158 427 21 by by IN 37158 427 22 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 427 23 . . . 37158 428 1 First first RB 37158 428 2 of of IN 37158 428 3 all all DT 37158 428 4 , , , 37158 428 5 there there EX 37158 428 6 is be VBZ 37158 428 7 _ _ NNP 37158 428 8 antisepsis antisepsis NN 37158 428 9 _ _ NNP 37158 428 10 . . . 37158 429 1 For for IN 37158 429 2 centuries century NNS 37158 429 3 and and CC 37158 429 4 centuries century NNS 37158 429 5 surgeons surgeon NNS 37158 429 6 operated operate VBN 37158 429 7 without without IN 37158 429 8 understanding understanding NN 37158 429 9 why why WRB 37158 429 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 429 11 was be VBD 37158 429 12 that that DT 37158 429 13 death death NN 37158 429 14 struck strike VBD 37158 429 15 down down RP 37158 429 16 so so RB 37158 429 17 unmercifully unmercifully RB 37158 429 18 those those DT 37158 429 19 operated operate VBN 37158 429 20 upon upon IN 37158 429 21 . . . 37158 430 1 In in IN 37158 430 2 vain vain JJ 37158 430 3 did do VBD 37158 430 4 surgeons surgeon NNS 37158 430 5 display display VB 37158 430 6 great great JJ 37158 430 7 skill skill NN 37158 430 8 ; ; : 37158 430 9 in in IN 37158 430 10 vain vain JJ 37158 430 11 did do VBD 37158 430 12 the the DT 37158 430 13 operation operation NN 37158 430 14 succeed succeed VB 37158 430 15 : : : 37158 430 16 the the DT 37158 430 17 patient patient NN 37158 430 18 died die VBD 37158 430 19 . . . 37158 431 1 Erysipelas erysipela NNS 37158 431 2 , , , 37158 431 3 lock lock NN 37158 431 4 - - HYPH 37158 431 5 jaw jaw NN 37158 431 6 , , , 37158 431 7 abscess abscess NN 37158 431 8 - - HYPH 37158 431 9 formation formation NN 37158 431 10 and and CC 37158 431 11 gangrene gangrene NN 37158 431 12 reigned reign VBD 37158 431 13 supreme supreme NNP 37158 431 14 . . . 37158 432 1 Every every DT 37158 432 2 confinement confinement NN 37158 432 3 exposed expose VBD 37158 432 4 the the DT 37158 432 5 mother mother NN 37158 432 6 to to IN 37158 432 7 death death NN 37158 432 8 ; ; : 37158 432 9 the the DT 37158 432 10 slightest slight JJS 37158 432 11 wounds wound NNS 37158 432 12 were be VBD 37158 432 13 followed follow VBN 37158 432 14 by by IN 37158 432 15 the the DT 37158 432 16 most most RBS 37158 432 17 serious serious JJ 37158 432 18 after after IN 37158 432 19 - - HYPH 37158 432 20 effects effect NNS 37158 432 21 ; ; : 37158 432 22 in in IN 37158 432 23 certain certain JJ 37158 432 24 amputations amputation NNS 37158 432 25 , , , 37158 432 26 for for IN 37158 432 27 instance instance NN 37158 432 28 , , , 37158 432 29 the the DT 37158 432 30 mortality mortality NN 37158 432 31 was be VBD 37158 432 32 70 70 CD 37158 432 33 per per IN 37158 432 34 cent cent NN 37158 432 35 . . . 37158 433 1 No no DT 37158 433 2 one one NN 37158 433 3 dared dare VBD 37158 433 4 to to TO 37158 433 5 touch touch VB 37158 433 6 either either CC 37158 433 7 the the DT 37158 433 8 peritoneum peritoneum NN 37158 433 9 or or CC 37158 433 10 the the DT 37158 433 11 joints joint NNS 37158 433 12 , , , 37158 433 13 because because IN 37158 433 14 every every DT 37158 433 15 operation operation NN 37158 433 16 on on IN 37158 433 17 the the DT 37158 433 18 peritoneum peritoneum NN 37158 433 19 or or CC 37158 433 20 on on IN 37158 433 21 the the DT 37158 433 22 articulations articulation NNS 37158 433 23 was be VBD 37158 433 24 sure sure JJ 37158 433 25 to to TO 37158 433 26 prove prove VB 37158 433 27 fatal fatal JJ 37158 433 28 . . . 37158 434 1 But but CC 37158 434 2 Lister Lister NNP 37158 434 3 and and CC 37158 434 4 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 434 5 came come VBD 37158 434 6 ! ! . 37158 435 1 These these DT 37158 435 2 two two CD 37158 435 3 men man NNS 37158 435 4 , , , 37158 435 5 simultaneously simultaneously RB 37158 435 6 and and CC 37158 435 7 concurrently concurrently RB 37158 435 8 , , , 37158 435 9 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 37158 435 10 that that IN 37158 435 11 all all DT 37158 435 12 disease disease NN 37158 435 13 following follow VBG 37158 435 14 on on IN 37158 435 15 an an DT 37158 435 16 operation operation NN 37158 435 17 was be VBD 37158 435 18 the the DT 37158 435 19 result result NN 37158 435 20 of of IN 37158 435 21 infection infection NN 37158 435 22 by by IN 37158 435 23 parasites parasite NNS 37158 435 24 . . . 37158 436 1 By by IN 37158 436 2 preventing prevent VBG 37158 436 3 the the DT 37158 436 4 wounds wound NNS 37158 436 5 from from IN 37158 436 6 being be VBG 37158 436 7 contaminated contaminate VBN 37158 436 8 by by IN 37158 436 9 parasites parasite NNS 37158 436 10 , , , 37158 436 11 infection infection NN 37158 436 12 was be VBD 37158 436 13 prevented prevent VBN 37158 436 14 ; ; : 37158 436 15 for for IN 37158 436 16 the the DT 37158 436 17 wounds wound NNS 37158 436 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 436 19 are be VBP 37158 436 20 innocent innocent JJ 37158 436 21 , , , 37158 436 22 as as RB 37158 436 23 long long RB 37158 436 24 as as IN 37158 436 25 they -PRON- PRP 37158 436 26 are be VBP 37158 436 27 not not RB 37158 436 28 infected infect VBN 37158 436 29 . . . 37158 437 1 This this DT 37158 437 2 is be VBZ 37158 437 3 the the DT 37158 437 4 astounding astounding JJ 37158 437 5 and and CC 37158 437 6 simple simple JJ 37158 437 7 truth truth NN 37158 437 8 which which WDT 37158 437 9 Lister Lister NNP 37158 437 10 and and CC 37158 437 11 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 437 12 established establish VBD 37158 437 13 . . . 37158 438 1 And and CC 37158 438 2 let let VB 37158 438 3 no no DT 37158 438 4 one one NN 37158 438 5 pretend pretend VB 37158 438 6 it -PRON- PRP 37158 438 7 is be VBZ 37158 438 8 so so RB 37158 438 9 simple simple JJ 37158 438 10 that that IN 37158 438 11 the the DT 37158 438 12 data datum NNS 37158 438 13 could could MD 37158 438 14 have have VB 37158 438 15 been be VBN 37158 438 16 furnished furnish VBN 37158 438 17 by by IN 37158 438 18 clinical clinical JJ 37158 438 19 observation observation NN 37158 438 20 alone alone RB 37158 438 21 , , , 37158 438 22 for for IN 37158 438 23 such such PDT 37158 438 24 an an DT 37158 438 25 assertion assertion NN 37158 438 26 would would MD 37158 438 27 be be VB 37158 438 28 contradicted contradict VBN 37158 438 29 by by IN 37158 438 30 the the DT 37158 438 31 facts fact NNS 37158 438 32 . . . 37158 439 1 Thousands thousand NNS 37158 439 2 and and CC 37158 439 3 thousands thousand NNS 37158 439 4 of of IN 37158 439 5 surgeons surgeon NNS 37158 439 6 , , , 37158 439 7 right right RB 37158 439 8 up up IN 37158 439 9 to to IN 37158 439 10 1868 1868 CD 37158 439 11 , , , 37158 439 12 had have VBD 37158 439 13 understood understand VBN 37158 439 14 nothing nothing NN 37158 439 15 of of IN 37158 439 16 infection infection NN 37158 439 17 . . . 37158 440 1 In in IN 37158 440 2 order order NN 37158 440 3 to to TO 37158 440 4 understand understand VB 37158 440 5 this this DT 37158 440 6 big big JJ 37158 440 7 word word NN 37158 440 8 " " '' 37158 440 9 infection infection NN 37158 440 10 , , , 37158 440 11 " " '' 37158 440 12 which which WDT 37158 440 13 sums sum VBZ 37158 440 14 up up RP 37158 440 15 in in IN 37158 440 16 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 440 17 the the DT 37158 440 18 whole whole NN 37158 440 19 of of IN 37158 440 20 surgery surgery NN 37158 440 21 and and CC 37158 440 22 the the DT 37158 440 23 whole whole NN 37158 440 24 of of IN 37158 440 25 medicine medicine NN 37158 440 26 , , , 37158 440 27 it -PRON- PRP 37158 440 28 was be VBD 37158 440 29 necessary necessary JJ 37158 440 30 to to TO 37158 440 31 inject inject VB 37158 440 32 pus pus NN 37158 440 33 into into IN 37158 440 34 animals animal NNS 37158 440 35 , , , 37158 440 36 gather gather VB 37158 440 37 the the DT 37158 440 38 microbes microbe NNS 37158 440 39 which which WDT 37158 440 40 then then RB 37158 440 41 developed develop VBD 37158 440 42 in in IN 37158 440 43 the the DT 37158 440 44 blood blood NN 37158 440 45 of of IN 37158 440 46 these these DT 37158 440 47 animals animal NNS 37158 440 48 , , , 37158 440 49 isolate isolate VBP 37158 440 50 the the DT 37158 440 51 microbes microbe NNS 37158 440 52 , , , 37158 440 53 cultivate cultivate VB 37158 440 54 them -PRON- PRP 37158 440 55 , , , 37158 440 56 inject inject VB 37158 440 57 them -PRON- PRP 37158 440 58 afresh afresh RB 37158 440 59 , , , 37158 440 60 and and CC 37158 440 61 produce produce VB 37158 440 62 an an DT 37158 440 63 experimental experimental JJ 37158 440 64 disease disease NN 37158 440 65 . . . 37158 441 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 441 2 was be VBD 37158 441 3 in in IN 37158 441 4 this this DT 37158 441 5 manner manner NN 37158 441 6 only only RB 37158 441 7 that that IN 37158 441 8 we -PRON- PRP 37158 441 9 were be VBD 37158 441 10 able able JJ 37158 441 11 to to TO 37158 441 12 understand understand VB 37158 441 13 the the DT 37158 441 14 mechanism mechanism NN 37158 441 15 of of IN 37158 441 16 antisepsis antisepsis NN 37158 441 17 , , , 37158 441 18 and and CC 37158 441 19 , , , 37158 441 20 consequently consequently RB 37158 441 21 , , , 37158 441 22 apply apply VB 37158 441 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 441 24 to to IN 37158 441 25 the the DT 37158 441 26 treatment treatment NN 37158 441 27 of of IN 37158 441 28 operations operation NNS 37158 441 29 and and CC 37158 441 30 wounds wound NNS 37158 441 31 . . . 37158 442 1 Three three CD 37158 442 2 or or CC 37158 442 3 four four CD 37158 442 4 volumes volume NNS 37158 442 5 could could MD 37158 442 6 be be VB 37158 442 7 written write VBN 37158 442 8 on on IN 37158 442 9 this this DT 37158 442 10 subject subject NN 37158 442 11 alone alone RB 37158 442 12 , , , 37158 442 13 but but CC 37158 442 14 all all DT 37158 442 15 I -PRON- PRP 37158 442 16 can can MD 37158 442 17 attempt attempt VB 37158 442 18 here here RB 37158 442 19 is be VBZ 37158 442 20 a a DT 37158 442 21 summary summary NN 37158 442 22 of of IN 37158 442 23 the the DT 37158 442 24 main main JJ 37158 442 25 points point NNS 37158 442 26 . . . 37158 443 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 443 2 say say VBP 37158 443 3 without without IN 37158 443 4 hesitation hesitation NN 37158 443 5 that that IN 37158 443 6 as as RB 37158 443 7 long long RB 37158 443 8 as as IN 37158 443 9 clinical clinical JJ 37158 443 10 medicine medicine NN 37158 443 11 confined confine VBD 37158 443 12 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 443 13 only only RB 37158 443 14 to to IN 37158 443 15 the the DT 37158 443 16 observation observation NN 37158 443 17 of of IN 37158 443 18 patients patient NNS 37158 443 19 , , , 37158 443 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 443 21 was be VBD 37158 443 22 able able JJ 37158 443 23 to to TO 37158 443 24 understand understand VB 37158 443 25 nothing nothing NN 37158 443 26 , , , 37158 443 27 to to TO 37158 443 28 analyse analyse VB 37158 443 29 nothing nothing NN 37158 443 30 , , , 37158 443 31 to to TO 37158 443 32 foresee foresee VB 37158 443 33 nothing nothing NN 37158 443 34 . . . 37158 444 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 444 2 was be VBD 37158 444 3 necessary necessary JJ 37158 444 4 to to TO 37158 444 5 experiment experiment VB 37158 444 6 , , , 37158 444 7 to to TO 37158 444 8 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37158 444 9 a a DT 37158 444 10 few few JJ 37158 444 11 hundred hundred CD 37158 444 12 mice mouse NNS 37158 444 13 , , , 37158 444 14 rats rat NNS 37158 444 15 , , , 37158 444 16 and and CC 37158 444 17 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 444 18 , , , 37158 444 19 in in IN 37158 444 20 order order NN 37158 444 21 to to TO 37158 444 22 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37158 444 23 that that IN 37158 444 24 erysipelas erysipelas NNP 37158 444 25 is be VBZ 37158 444 26 an an DT 37158 444 27 inoculable inoculable JJ 37158 444 28 disease disease NN 37158 444 29 , , , 37158 444 30 that that DT 37158 444 31 puerperal puerperal JJ 37158 444 32 infection infection NN 37158 444 33 is be VBZ 37158 444 34 of of IN 37158 444 35 the the DT 37158 444 36 same same JJ 37158 444 37 nature nature NN 37158 444 38 as as IN 37158 444 39 purulent purulent NN 37158 444 40 infection infection NN 37158 444 41 , , , 37158 444 42 that that IN 37158 444 43 all all PDT 37158 444 44 these these DT 37158 444 45 diseases disease NNS 37158 444 46 are be VBP 37158 444 47 due due JJ 37158 444 48 to to IN 37158 444 49 micro micro JJ 37158 444 50 - - HYPH 37158 444 51 organisms organism NNS 37158 444 52 , , , 37158 444 53 and and CC 37158 444 54 that that IN 37158 444 55 certain certain JJ 37158 444 56 substances substance NNS 37158 444 57 , , , 37158 444 58 called call VBN 37158 444 59 antiseptics antiseptic NNS 37158 444 60 , , , 37158 444 61 can can MD 37158 444 62 stop stop VB 37158 444 63 the the DT 37158 444 64 development development NN 37158 444 65 of of IN 37158 444 66 these these DT 37158 444 67 fatal fatal JJ 37158 444 68 germs germ NNS 37158 444 69 . . . 37158 445 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 445 2 appears appear VBZ 37158 445 3 quite quite RB 37158 445 4 natural natural JJ 37158 445 5 to to IN 37158 445 6 - - HYPH 37158 445 7 day day NN 37158 445 8 ( ( -LRB- 37158 445 9 and and CC 37158 445 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 445 11 seems seem VBZ 37158 445 12 to to IN 37158 445 13 simple simple JJ 37158 445 14 minds mind NNS 37158 445 15 , , , 37158 445 16 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 445 17 of of IN 37158 445 18 the the DT 37158 445 19 past past NN 37158 445 20 and and CC 37158 445 21 powerless powerless JJ 37158 445 22 to to TO 37158 445 23 imagine imagine VB 37158 445 24 the the DT 37158 445 25 past past NN 37158 445 26 , , , 37158 445 27 that that IN 37158 445 28 these these DT 37158 445 29 notions notion NNS 37158 445 30 have have VBP 37158 445 31 been be VBN 37158 445 32 current current JJ 37158 445 33 from from IN 37158 445 34 all all DT 37158 445 35 eternity eternity NN 37158 445 36 ) ) -RRB- 37158 445 37 to to TO 37158 445 38 know know VB 37158 445 39 that that IN 37158 445 40 instruments instrument NNS 37158 445 41 , , , 37158 445 42 water water NN 37158 445 43 , , , 37158 445 44 and and CC 37158 445 45 linen linen NNP 37158 445 46 heated heat VBN 37158 445 47 to to IN 37158 445 48 120 120 CD 37158 445 49 ° ° NNS 37158 445 50 contain contain VBP 37158 445 51 no no DT 37158 445 52 living living NN 37158 445 53 germs germ NNS 37158 445 54 . . . 37158 446 1 But but CC 37158 446 2 this this DT 37158 446 3 discovery discovery NN 37158 446 4 is be VBZ 37158 446 5 not not RB 37158 446 6 so so RB 37158 446 7 very very RB 37158 446 8 old old JJ 37158 446 9 . . . 37158 447 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 447 2 was be VBD 37158 447 3 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 447 4 who who WP 37158 447 5 , , , 37158 447 6 between between IN 37158 447 7 1863 1863 CD 37158 447 8 and and CC 37158 447 9 1873 1873 CD 37158 447 10 , , , 37158 447 11 established establish VBD 37158 447 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 447 13 by by IN 37158 447 14 some some DT 37158 447 15 memorable memorable JJ 37158 447 16 experiments experiment NNS 37158 447 17 at at IN 37158 447 18 the the DT 37158 447 19 cost cost NN 37158 447 20 of of IN 37158 447 21 a a DT 37158 447 22 little little JJ 37158 447 23 disease disease NN 37158 447 24 given give VBN 37158 447 25 to to IN 37158 447 26 rats rat NNS 37158 447 27 and and CC 37158 447 28 guinea guinea NN 37158 447 29 - - HYPH 37158 447 30 pigs pig NNS 37158 447 31 . . . 37158 448 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 448 2 Illustration illustration NN 37158 448 3 : : : 37158 448 4 PASTEUR PASTEUR NNP 37158 448 5 IN in IN 37158 448 6 HIS his PRP$ 37158 448 7 LABORATORY laboratory NN 37158 448 8 . . . 37158 449 1 _ _ NNP 37158 449 2 facing face VBG 37158 449 3 p. p. NN 37158 449 4 44 44 CD 37158 449 5 . . . 37158 449 6 _ _ NNP 37158 449 7 ] ] -RRB- 37158 449 8 Now now UH 37158 449 9 -- -- : 37158 449 10 and and CC 37158 449 11 I -PRON- PRP 37158 449 12 appeal appeal VBP 37158 449 13 to to IN 37158 449 14 the the DT 37158 449 15 good good JJ 37158 449 16 sense sense NN 37158 449 17 of of IN 37158 449 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 449 19 readers reader NNS 37158 449 20 -- -- : 37158 449 21 would would MD 37158 449 22 it -PRON- PRP 37158 449 23 be be VB 37158 449 24 better well JJR 37158 449 25 to to TO 37158 449 26 efface efface VB 37158 449 27 the the DT 37158 449 28 suffering suffering NN 37158 449 29 of of IN 37158 449 30 those those DT 37158 449 31 rats rat NNS 37158 449 32 , , , 37158 449 33 those those DT 37158 449 34 guinea guinea NN 37158 449 35 - - HYPH 37158 449 36 pigs pig NNS 37158 449 37 , , , 37158 449 38 those those DT 37158 449 39 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 449 40 , , , 37158 449 41 and and CC 37158 449 42 return return VB 37158 449 43 to to IN 37158 449 44 the the DT 37158 449 45 olden olden JJ 37158 449 46 times time NNS 37158 449 47 when when WRB 37158 449 48 the the DT 37158 449 49 mortality mortality NN 37158 449 50 in in IN 37158 449 51 lying lie VBG 37158 449 52 - - HYPH 37158 449 53 in in RP 37158 449 54 hospitals hospital NNS 37158 449 55 was be VBD 37158 449 56 often often RB 37158 449 57 40 40 CD 37158 449 58 per per NN 37158 449 59 cent cent NN 37158 449 60 . . . 37158 450 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 450 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 450 3 is be VBZ 37158 450 4 to to IN 37158 450 5 - - HYPH 37158 450 6 day day NN 37158 450 7 , , , 37158 450 8 0.02 0.02 CD 37158 450 9 per per NN 37158 450 10 cent cent NN 37158 450 11 . . . 37158 450 12 ! ! . 37158 450 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 450 14 ? ? . 37158 451 1 Must Must MD 37158 451 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 451 3 condemn condemn VB 37158 451 4 Lister Lister NNP 37158 451 5 and and CC 37158 451 6 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 451 7 as as IN 37158 451 8 great great JJ 37158 451 9 criminals criminal NNS 37158 451 10 because because IN 37158 451 11 they -PRON- PRP 37158 451 12 dared dare VBD 37158 451 13 to to TO 37158 451 14 inoculate inoculate VB 37158 451 15 microbes microbe NNS 37158 451 16 into into IN 37158 451 17 a a DT 37158 451 18 few few JJ 37158 451 19 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 451 20 and and CC 37158 451 21 bring bring VBP 37158 451 22 about about RP 37158 451 23 in in IN 37158 451 24 those those DT 37158 451 25 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 451 26 animals animal NNS 37158 451 27 -- -- : 37158 451 28 they -PRON- PRP 37158 451 29 would would MD 37158 451 30 have have VB 37158 451 31 died die VBN 37158 451 32 a a DT 37158 451 33 long long JJ 37158 451 34 time time NN 37158 451 35 ago ago RB 37158 451 36 even even RB 37158 451 37 without without IN 37158 451 38 that that DT 37158 451 39 -- -- : 37158 451 40 experimental experimental JJ 37158 451 41 ailments ailment NNS 37158 451 42 in in IN 37158 451 43 order order NN 37158 451 44 to to TO 37158 451 45 ward ward VB 37158 451 46 off off RP 37158 451 47 malignant malignant JJ 37158 451 48 diseases disease NNS 37158 451 49 from from IN 37158 451 50 thousands thousand NNS 37158 451 51 and and CC 37158 451 52 thousands thousand NNS 37158 451 53 of of IN 37158 451 54 human human JJ 37158 451 55 beings being NNS 37158 451 56 ? ? . 37158 452 1 * * NFP 37158 452 2 * * NFP 37158 452 3 * * NFP 37158 452 4 * * NFP 37158 452 5 * * NFP 37158 452 6 The the DT 37158 452 7 second second JJ 37158 452 8 discovery discovery NN 37158 452 9 which which WDT 37158 452 10 I -PRON- PRP 37158 452 11 shall shall MD 37158 452 12 mention mention VB 37158 452 13 is be VBZ 37158 452 14 that that DT 37158 452 15 of of IN 37158 452 16 the the DT 37158 452 17 infectiousness infectiousness NN 37158 452 18 of of IN 37158 452 19 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 452 20 . . . 37158 453 1 Thousands thousand NNS 37158 453 2 and and CC 37158 453 3 thousands thousand NNS 37158 453 4 of of IN 37158 453 5 doctors doctor NNS 37158 453 6 had have VBD 37158 453 7 had have VBN 37158 453 8 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 453 9 patients patient NNS 37158 453 10 under under IN 37158 453 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 453 12 care care NN 37158 453 13 . . . 37158 454 1 Three three CD 37158 454 2 thousand thousand CD 37158 454 3 years year NNS 37158 454 4 ago ago RB 37158 454 5 , , , 37158 454 6 Hippocrates hippocrate NNS 37158 454 7 described describe VBD 37158 454 8 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 454 9 with with IN 37158 454 10 as as RB 37158 454 11 much much JJ 37158 454 12 precision precision NN 37158 454 13 as as IN 37158 454 14 could could MD 37158 454 15 be be VB 37158 454 16 done do VBN 37158 454 17 to to IN 37158 454 18 - - HYPH 37158 454 19 day day NN 37158 454 20 . . . 37158 455 1 Illustrious illustrious JJ 37158 455 2 physicians physician NNS 37158 455 3 in in IN 37158 455 4 every every DT 37158 455 5 land land NN 37158 455 6 had have VBD 37158 455 7 tried try VBN 37158 455 8 to to TO 37158 455 9 analyse analyse VB 37158 455 10 the the DT 37158 455 11 nature nature NN 37158 455 12 of of IN 37158 455 13 this this DT 37158 455 14 terrible terrible JJ 37158 455 15 disease disease NN 37158 455 16 and and CC 37158 455 17 to to TO 37158 455 18 unravel unravel VB 37158 455 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 455 20 cause cause NN 37158 455 21 ; ; : 37158 455 22 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 455 23 , , , 37158 455 24 they -PRON- PRP 37158 455 25 were be VBD 37158 455 26 unable unable JJ 37158 455 27 , , , 37158 455 28 from from IN 37158 455 29 clinical clinical JJ 37158 455 30 observation observation NN 37158 455 31 alone alone RB 37158 455 32 , , , 37158 455 33 to to TO 37158 455 34 prove prove VB 37158 455 35 what what WP 37158 455 36 is be VBZ 37158 455 37 to to IN 37158 455 38 - - HYPH 37158 455 39 day day NN 37158 455 40 quite quite RB 37158 455 41 commonplace commonplace JJ 37158 455 42 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 455 43 , , , 37158 455 44 viz viz NNP 37158 455 45 . . NNP 37158 455 46 , , , 37158 455 47 that that IN 37158 455 48 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 455 49 is be VBZ 37158 455 50 infectious infectious JJ 37158 455 51 . . . 37158 456 1 In in IN 37158 456 2 1864 1864 CD 37158 456 3 , , , 37158 456 4 a a DT 37158 456 5 French french JJ 37158 456 6 doctor doctor NN 37158 456 7 , , , 37158 456 8 Villemin Villemin NNP 37158 456 9 , , , 37158 456 10 conceived conceive VBD 37158 456 11 the the DT 37158 456 12 simple simple JJ 37158 456 13 and and CC 37158 456 14 ingenious ingenious JJ 37158 456 15 idea idea NN 37158 456 16 of of IN 37158 456 17 inoculating inoculate VBG 37158 456 18 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 456 19 with with IN 37158 456 20 the the DT 37158 456 21 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 456 22 matter matter NN 37158 456 23 found find VBN 37158 456 24 in in IN 37158 456 25 the the DT 37158 456 26 lungs lung NNS 37158 456 27 of of IN 37158 456 28 consumptive consumptive JJ 37158 456 29 patients patient NNS 37158 456 30 . . . 37158 457 1 These these DT 37158 457 2 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 457 3 became become VBD 37158 457 4 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 457 5 ; ; : 37158 457 6 they -PRON- PRP 37158 457 7 died die VBD 37158 457 8 in in IN 37158 457 9 a a DT 37158 457 10 few few JJ 37158 457 11 weeks week NNS 37158 457 12 with with IN 37158 457 13 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 457 14 granulations granulation NNS 37158 457 15 in in IN 37158 457 16 lungs lung NNS 37158 457 17 and and CC 37158 457 18 liver liver NN 37158 457 19 . . . 37158 458 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 458 2 was be VBD 37158 458 3 thus thus RB 37158 458 4 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37158 458 5 that that IN 37158 458 6 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 458 7 was be VBD 37158 458 8 infectious infectious JJ 37158 458 9 . . . 37158 459 1 Later later RB 37158 459 2 on on RB 37158 459 3 , , , 37158 459 4 in in IN 37158 459 5 1878 1878 CD 37158 459 6 , , , 37158 459 7 Koch Koch NNP 37158 459 8 discovered discover VBD 37158 459 9 that that IN 37158 459 10 the the DT 37158 459 11 active active JJ 37158 459 12 agent agent NN 37158 459 13 of of IN 37158 459 14 this this DT 37158 459 15 infection infection NN 37158 459 16 is be VBZ 37158 459 17 a a DT 37158 459 18 special special JJ 37158 459 19 microbe microbe NN 37158 459 20 . . . 37158 460 1 But but CC 37158 460 2 , , , 37158 460 3 however however RB 37158 460 4 important important JJ 37158 460 5 may may MD 37158 460 6 be be VB 37158 460 7 the the DT 37158 460 8 discovery discovery NN 37158 460 9 of of IN 37158 460 10 the the DT 37158 460 11 microbe microbe NN 37158 460 12 of of IN 37158 460 13 tuberculosis tuberculosis NNP 37158 460 14 ( ( -LRB- 37158 460 15 the the DT 37158 460 16 tubercle tubercle NN 37158 460 17 - - HYPH 37158 460 18 bacillus bacillus NN 37158 460 19 of of IN 37158 460 20 Koch Koch NNP 37158 460 21 ) ) -RRB- 37158 460 22 , , , 37158 460 23 the the DT 37158 460 24 essential essential JJ 37158 460 25 dominating dominating JJ 37158 460 26 fact fact NN 37158 460 27 is be VBZ 37158 460 28 that that IN 37158 460 29 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 460 30 is be VBZ 37158 460 31 infectious infectious JJ 37158 460 32 . . . 37158 461 1 As as RB 37158 461 2 soon soon RB 37158 461 3 as as IN 37158 461 4 this this DT 37158 461 5 great great JJ 37158 461 6 fact fact NN 37158 461 7 became become VBD 37158 461 8 known know VBN 37158 461 9 , , , 37158 461 10 a a DT 37158 461 11 profound profound JJ 37158 461 12 revolution revolution NN 37158 461 13 occurred occur VBD 37158 461 14 in in IN 37158 461 15 social social JJ 37158 461 16 hygiene hygiene NN 37158 461 17 , , , 37158 461 18 in in IN 37158 461 19 the the DT 37158 461 20 treatment treatment NN 37158 461 21 and and CC 37158 461 22 in in IN 37158 461 23 the the DT 37158 461 24 prevention prevention NN 37158 461 25 of of IN 37158 461 26 this this DT 37158 461 27 terrible terrible JJ 37158 461 28 evil evil NN 37158 461 29 . . . 37158 462 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 462 2 know know VBP 37158 462 3 now now RB 37158 462 4 the the DT 37158 462 5 consumptive consumptive JJ 37158 462 6 man man NN 37158 462 7 carries carry VBZ 37158 462 8 in in IN 37158 462 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 462 10 lungs lung NNS 37158 462 11 and and CC 37158 462 12 sputum sputum NN 37158 462 13 the the DT 37158 462 14 germ germ NN 37158 462 15 capable capable JJ 37158 462 16 of of IN 37158 462 17 developing develop VBG 37158 462 18 the the DT 37158 462 19 same same JJ 37158 462 20 evil evil NN 37158 462 21 in in IN 37158 462 22 others other NNS 37158 462 23 ; ; : 37158 462 24 consequently consequently RB 37158 462 25 we -PRON- PRP 37158 462 26 know know VBP 37158 462 27 how how WRB 37158 462 28 to to TO 37158 462 29 preserve preserve VB 37158 462 30 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 462 31 against against IN 37158 462 32 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 462 33 . . . 37158 463 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 463 2 must must MD 37158 463 3 purify purify VB 37158 463 4 or or CC 37158 463 5 destroy destroy VB 37158 463 6 the the DT 37158 463 7 habitations habitation NNS 37158 463 8 wherein wherein WRB 37158 463 9 consumptives consumptive NNS 37158 463 10 have have VBP 37158 463 11 lived live VBN 37158 463 12 , , , 37158 463 13 burn burn VB 37158 463 14 or or CC 37158 463 15 carbolise carbolise VBP 37158 463 16 all all PDT 37158 463 17 the the DT 37158 463 18 sputum sputum NN 37158 463 19 , , , 37158 463 20 make make VB 37158 463 21 spitting spitting NN 37158 463 22 in in IN 37158 463 23 public public JJ 37158 463 24 places place NNS 37158 463 25 a a DT 37158 463 26 punishable punishable JJ 37158 463 27 offence offence NN 37158 463 28 , , , 37158 463 29 take take VB 37158 463 30 sanitary sanitary JJ 37158 463 31 measures measure NNS 37158 463 32 against against IN 37158 463 33 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 37158 463 34 meat meat NN 37158 463 35 , , , 37158 463 36 defend defend VB 37158 463 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 463 38 children child NNS 37158 463 39 against against IN 37158 463 40 contaminated contaminate VBN 37158 463 41 milk milk NN 37158 463 42 -- -- : 37158 463 43 in in IN 37158 463 44 a a DT 37158 463 45 word word NN 37158 463 46 , , , 37158 463 47 we -PRON- PRP 37158 463 48 are be VBP 37158 463 49 armed armed JJ 37158 463 50 against against IN 37158 463 51 a a DT 37158 463 52 disease disease NN 37158 463 53 , , , 37158 463 54 the the DT 37158 463 55 sole sole JJ 37158 463 56 and and CC 37158 463 57 unique unique JJ 37158 463 58 cause cause NN 37158 463 59 of of IN 37158 463 60 which which WDT 37158 463 61 , , , 37158 463 62 as as IN 37158 463 63 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 463 64 alone alone RB 37158 463 65 has have VBZ 37158 463 66 taught teach VBN 37158 463 67 us -PRON- PRP 37158 463 68 , , , 37158 463 69 is be VBZ 37158 463 70 infection infection NN 37158 463 71 . . . 37158 464 1 Formerly formerly RB 37158 464 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 464 3 was be VBD 37158 464 4 believed believe VBN 37158 464 5 that that IN 37158 464 6 diseases disease NNS 37158 464 7 were be VBD 37158 464 8 due due JJ 37158 464 9 to to IN 37158 464 10 a a DT 37158 464 11 sort sort NN 37158 464 12 of of IN 37158 464 13 divine divine JJ 37158 464 14 anger anger NN 37158 464 15 , , , 37158 464 16 or or CC 37158 464 17 , , , 37158 464 18 what what WP 37158 464 19 amounts amount VBZ 37158 464 20 pretty pretty RB 37158 464 21 much much RB 37158 464 22 to to IN 37158 464 23 the the DT 37158 464 24 same same JJ 37158 464 25 thing thing NN 37158 464 26 , , , 37158 464 27 to to IN 37158 464 28 certain certain JJ 37158 464 29 imperceptible imperceptible JJ 37158 464 30 epidemic epidemic NN 37158 464 31 exhalations exhalation NNS 37158 464 32 stretching stretch VBG 37158 464 33 over over IN 37158 464 34 whole whole JJ 37158 464 35 populations population NNS 37158 464 36 , , , 37158 464 37 or or CC 37158 464 38 attacking attack VBG 37158 464 39 isolated isolated JJ 37158 464 40 individuals individual NNS 37158 464 41 , , , 37158 464 42 striking strike VBG 37158 464 43 like like IN 37158 464 44 an an DT 37158 464 45 exterminating exterminate VBG 37158 464 46 angel angel NN 37158 464 47 , , , 37158 464 48 as as IN 37158 464 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 464 50 fancy fancy NN 37158 464 51 chose choose VBD 37158 464 52 , , , 37158 464 53 such such JJ 37158 464 54 or or CC 37158 464 55 such such PDT 37158 464 56 an an DT 37158 464 57 unhappy unhappy JJ 37158 464 58 victim victim NN 37158 464 59 . . . 37158 465 1 A a DT 37158 465 2 sort sort NN 37158 465 3 of of RB 37158 465 4 will will NN 37158 465 5 or or CC 37158 465 6 caprice caprice NN 37158 465 7 , , , 37158 465 8 governed govern VBN 37158 465 9 only only RB 37158 465 10 by by IN 37158 465 11 chance chance NN 37158 465 12 , , , 37158 465 13 was be VBD 37158 465 14 exercised exercise VBN 37158 465 15 in in IN 37158 465 16 relation relation NN 37158 465 17 to to IN 37158 465 18 this this DT 37158 465 19 disease disease NN 37158 465 20 , , , 37158 465 21 and and CC 37158 465 22 man man NN 37158 465 23 was be VBD 37158 465 24 powerless powerless JJ 37158 465 25 , , , 37158 465 26 because because IN 37158 465 27 he -PRON- PRP 37158 465 28 was be VBD 37158 465 29 unarmed unarmed JJ 37158 465 30 against against IN 37158 465 31 chance chance NN 37158 465 32 . . . 37158 466 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 466 2 did do VBD 37158 466 3 not not RB 37158 466 4 even even RB 37158 466 5 think think VB 37158 466 6 of of IN 37158 466 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 466 8 . . . 37158 467 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 467 2 resigned resign VBD 37158 467 3 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 467 4 to to IN 37158 467 5 being be VBG 37158 467 6 ill ill JJ 37158 467 7 , , , 37158 467 8 and and CC 37158 467 9 waited wait VBD 37158 467 10 for for IN 37158 467 11 the the DT 37158 467 12 disease disease NN 37158 467 13 , , , 37158 467 14 without without IN 37158 467 15 doing do VBG 37158 467 16 anything anything NN 37158 467 17 to to TO 37158 467 18 fight fight VB 37158 467 19 against against IN 37158 467 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 467 21 , , , 37158 467 22 benumbed benumb VBN 37158 467 23 under under IN 37158 467 24 a a DT 37158 467 25 kind kind NN 37158 467 26 of of IN 37158 467 27 Oriental oriental JJ 37158 467 28 fatalism fatalism NN 37158 467 29 . . . 37158 468 1 The the DT 37158 468 2 doctor doctor NN 37158 468 3 shook shake VBD 37158 468 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 468 5 head head NN 37158 468 6 , , , 37158 468 7 bore bear VBD 37158 468 8 testimony testimony NN 37158 468 9 to to IN 37158 468 10 the the DT 37158 468 11 evil evil NN 37158 468 12 , , , 37158 468 13 and and CC 37158 468 14 confined confine VBD 37158 468 15 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 468 16 to to IN 37158 468 17 prescribing prescribe VBG 37158 468 18 inefficacious inefficacious JJ 37158 468 19 treatments treatment NNS 37158 468 20 which which WDT 37158 468 21 were be VBD 37158 468 22 only only RB 37158 468 23 , , , 37158 468 24 according accord VBG 37158 468 25 to to IN 37158 468 26 a a DT 37158 468 27 celebrated celebrated JJ 37158 468 28 saying saying NN 37158 468 29 , , , 37158 468 30 a a DT 37158 468 31 long long JJ 37158 468 32 meditation meditation NN 37158 468 33 on on IN 37158 468 34 death death NN 37158 468 35 . . . 37158 469 1 But but CC 37158 469 2 the the DT 37158 469 3 times time NNS 37158 469 4 have have VBP 37158 469 5 changed change VBN 37158 469 6 ; ; : 37158 469 7 there there EX 37158 469 8 is be VBZ 37158 469 9 no no DT 37158 469 10 longer long RBR 37158 469 11 any any DT 37158 469 12 fatality fatality NN 37158 469 13 in in IN 37158 469 14 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 469 15 ; ; : 37158 469 16 there there EX 37158 469 17 is be VBZ 37158 469 18 imprudence imprudence NN 37158 469 19 , , , 37158 469 20 there there EX 37158 469 21 is be VBZ 37158 469 22 error error NN 37158 469 23 , , , 37158 469 24 there there EX 37158 469 25 is be VBZ 37158 469 26 vice vice NN 37158 469 27 , , , 37158 469 28 and and CC 37158 469 29 , , , 37158 469 30 specially specially RB 37158 469 31 , , , 37158 469 32 social social JJ 37158 469 33 vice vice NN 37158 469 34 . . . 37158 470 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 470 2 may may MD 37158 470 3 almost almost RB 37158 470 4 say say VB 37158 470 5 that that IN 37158 470 6 , , , 37158 470 7 if if IN 37158 470 8 there there EX 37158 470 9 are be VBP 37158 470 10 still still RB 37158 470 11 consumptives consumptive NNS 37158 470 12 in in IN 37158 470 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 470 14 midst midst NN 37158 470 15 , , , 37158 470 16 it -PRON- PRP 37158 470 17 is be VBZ 37158 470 18 because because IN 37158 470 19 of of IN 37158 470 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 470 21 defective defective JJ 37158 470 22 social social JJ 37158 470 23 institutions institution NNS 37158 470 24 . . . 37158 471 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 471 2 leave leave VBP 37158 471 3 innumerable innumerable JJ 37158 471 4 populations population NNS 37158 471 5 steeped steep VBN 37158 471 6 in in IN 37158 471 7 misery misery NN 37158 471 8 , , , 37158 471 9 seven seven CD 37158 471 10 or or CC 37158 471 11 eight eight CD 37158 471 12 individuals individual NNS 37158 471 13 living live VBG 37158 471 14 in in IN 37158 471 15 the the DT 37158 471 16 same same JJ 37158 471 17 infected infected JJ 37158 471 18 hovel hovel NN 37158 471 19 . . . 37158 472 1 In in IN 37158 472 2 the the DT 37158 472 3 slums slum NNS 37158 472 4 of of IN 37158 472 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 472 6 large large JJ 37158 472 7 cities city NNS 37158 472 8 , , , 37158 472 9 swarms swarm NNS 37158 472 10 of of IN 37158 472 11 infants infant NNS 37158 472 12 are be VBP 37158 472 13 to to TO 37158 472 14 be be VB 37158 472 15 found find VBN 37158 472 16 morally morally RB 37158 472 17 and and CC 37158 472 18 materially materially RB 37158 472 19 perverted pervert VBN 37158 472 20 by by IN 37158 472 21 misery misery NN 37158 472 22 . . . 37158 473 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 473 2 , , , 37158 473 3 if if IN 37158 473 4 consumption consumption NN 37158 473 5 still still RB 37158 473 6 exists exist VBZ 37158 473 7 , , , 37158 473 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 473 9 is be VBZ 37158 473 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 473 11 own own JJ 37158 473 12 fault fault NN 37158 473 13 ; ; : 37158 473 14 it -PRON- PRP 37158 473 15 is be VBZ 37158 473 16 no no RB 37158 473 17 longer longer RB 37158 473 18 as as IN 37158 473 19 it -PRON- PRP 37158 473 20 was be VBD 37158 473 21 in in IN 37158 473 22 olden olden JJ 37158 473 23 times time NNS 37158 473 24 , , , 37158 473 25 when when WRB 37158 473 26 we -PRON- PRP 37158 473 27 knew know VBD 37158 473 28 not not RB 37158 473 29 , , , 37158 473 30 because because IN 37158 473 31 _ _ NNP 37158 473 32 now now RB 37158 473 33 _ _ NNP 37158 473 34 we -PRON- PRP 37158 473 35 know know VBP 37158 473 36 . . . 37158 474 1 The the DT 37158 474 2 plague plague NN 37158 474 3 can can MD 37158 474 4 be be VB 37158 474 5 battled battle VBN 37158 474 6 with with IN 37158 474 7 ; ; : 37158 474 8 and and CC 37158 474 9 if if IN 37158 474 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 474 11 still still RB 37158 474 12 has have VBZ 37158 474 13 so so RB 37158 474 14 much much JJ 37158 474 15 power power NN 37158 474 16 left leave VBN 37158 474 17 , , , 37158 474 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 474 19 is be VBZ 37158 474 20 because because IN 37158 474 21 we -PRON- PRP 37158 474 22 have have VBP 37158 474 23 not not RB 37158 474 24 the the DT 37158 474 25 courage courage NN 37158 474 26 to to TO 37158 474 27 apply apply VB 37158 474 28 to to IN 37158 474 29 public public JJ 37158 474 30 and and CC 37158 474 31 individual individual JJ 37158 474 32 hygiene hygiene NN 37158 474 33 the the DT 37158 474 34 treatment treatment NN 37158 474 35 science science NN 37158 474 36 has have VBZ 37158 474 37 definitely definitely RB 37158 474 38 shown show VBN 37158 474 39 us -PRON- PRP 37158 474 40 should should MD 37158 474 41 be be VB 37158 474 42 applied apply VBN 37158 474 43 . . . 37158 475 1 To to TO 37158 475 2 foresee foresee VB 37158 475 3 is be VBZ 37158 475 4 to to TO 37158 475 5 know know VB 37158 475 6 ; ; : 37158 475 7 and and CC 37158 475 8 now now RB 37158 475 9 that that IN 37158 475 10 we -PRON- PRP 37158 475 11 know know VBP 37158 475 12 , , , 37158 475 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 475 14 must must MD 37158 475 15 not not RB 37158 475 16 forget forget VB 37158 475 17 that that IN 37158 475 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 475 19 is be VBZ 37158 475 20 to to IN 37158 475 21 experimenters experimenter NNS 37158 475 22 , , , 37158 475 23 and and CC 37158 475 24 to to IN 37158 475 25 experimenters experimenter NNS 37158 475 26 alone alone RB 37158 475 27 , , , 37158 475 28 that that IN 37158 475 29 we -PRON- PRP 37158 475 30 are be VBP 37158 475 31 indebted indebted JJ 37158 475 32 for for IN 37158 475 33 this this DT 37158 475 34 great great JJ 37158 475 35 benefit benefit NN 37158 475 36 . . . 37158 476 1 Moreover moreover RB 37158 476 2 , , , 37158 476 3 however however RB 37158 476 4 imperfect imperfect VBP 37158 476 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 476 6 defence defence NN 37158 476 7 against against IN 37158 476 8 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 476 9 may may MD 37158 476 10 still still RB 37158 476 11 be be VB 37158 476 12 , , , 37158 476 13 it -PRON- PRP 37158 476 14 is be VBZ 37158 476 15 by by IN 37158 476 16 no no DT 37158 476 17 means means NN 37158 476 18 _ _ NNP 37158 476 19 nil nil NNP 37158 476 20 _ _ NNP 37158 476 21 ; ; : 37158 476 22 great great JJ 37158 476 23 progress progress NN 37158 476 24 has have VBZ 37158 476 25 been be VBN 37158 476 26 made make VBN 37158 476 27 ; ; : 37158 476 28 the the DT 37158 476 29 mortality mortality NN 37158 476 30 has have VBZ 37158 476 31 decreased decrease VBN 37158 476 32 in in IN 37158 476 33 a a DT 37158 476 34 considerable considerable JJ 37158 476 35 proportion proportion NN 37158 476 36 . . . 37158 477 1 During during IN 37158 477 2 the the DT 37158 477 3 last last JJ 37158 477 4 twenty twenty CD 37158 477 5 - - HYPH 37158 477 6 five five CD 37158 477 7 years year NNS 37158 477 8 , , , 37158 477 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 477 10 has have VBZ 37158 477 11 decreased decrease VBN 37158 477 12 by by IN 37158 477 13 about about RB 37158 477 14 25 25 CD 37158 477 15 per per NN 37158 477 16 cent cent NN 37158 477 17 . . . 37158 477 18 , , , 37158 477 19 and and CC 37158 477 20 notably notably RB 37158 477 21 in in IN 37158 477 22 England England NNP 37158 477 23 , , , 37158 477 24 where where WRB 37158 477 25 the the DT 37158 477 26 laws law NNS 37158 477 27 of of IN 37158 477 28 public public JJ 37158 477 29 hygiene hygiene NN 37158 477 30 , , , 37158 477 31 energetically energetically RB 37158 477 32 upheld uphold VBN 37158 477 33 by by IN 37158 477 34 the the DT 37158 477 35 good good JJ 37158 477 36 sense sense NN 37158 477 37 of of IN 37158 477 38 the the DT 37158 477 39 people people NNS 37158 477 40 , , , 37158 477 41 are be VBP 37158 477 42 strictly strictly RB 37158 477 43 applied apply VBN 37158 477 44 , , , 37158 477 45 the the DT 37158 477 46 mortality mortality NN 37158 477 47 has have VBZ 37158 477 48 diminished diminish VBN 37158 477 49 by by IN 37158 477 50 50 50 CD 37158 477 51 per per NN 37158 477 52 cent cent NN 37158 477 53 . . . 37158 478 1 This this DT 37158 478 2 is be VBZ 37158 478 3 only only RB 37158 478 4 a a DT 37158 478 5 beginning beginning NN 37158 478 6 , , , 37158 478 7 and and CC 37158 478 8 the the DT 37158 478 9 near near JJ 37158 478 10 future future NN 37158 478 11 will will MD 37158 478 12 bring bring VB 37158 478 13 about about RP 37158 478 14 the the DT 37158 478 15 complete complete JJ 37158 478 16 extermination extermination NN 37158 478 17 of of IN 37158 478 18 the the DT 37158 478 19 disease disease NN 37158 478 20 . . . 37158 479 1 Now now RB 37158 479 2 , , , 37158 479 3 honestly honestly RB 37158 479 4 , , , 37158 479 5 I -PRON- PRP 37158 479 6 ask ask VBP 37158 479 7 if if IN 37158 479 8 the the DT 37158 479 9 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 479 10 which which WDT 37158 479 11 Villemin Villemin NNP 37158 479 12 sacrificed sacrifice VBD 37158 479 13 weigh weigh NN 37158 479 14 more more RBR 37158 479 15 in in IN 37158 479 16 the the DT 37158 479 17 scales scale NNS 37158 479 18 of of IN 37158 479 19 universal universal JJ 37158 479 20 progress progress NN 37158 479 21 , , , 37158 479 22 and and CC 37158 479 23 even even RB 37158 479 24 in in IN 37158 479 25 public public JJ 37158 479 26 morality morality NN 37158 479 27 , , , 37158 479 28 than than IN 37158 479 29 the the DT 37158 479 30 three three CD 37158 479 31 millions million NNS 37158 479 32 of of IN 37158 479 33 individuals individual NNS 37158 479 34 who who WP 37158 479 35 , , , 37158 479 36 by by IN 37158 479 37 progress progress NN 37158 479 38 in in IN 37158 479 39 hygiene hygiene NN 37158 479 40 , , , 37158 479 41 have have VBP 37158 479 42 been be VBN 37158 479 43 preserved preserve VBN 37158 479 44 from from IN 37158 479 45 an an DT 37158 479 46 early early JJ 37158 479 47 and and CC 37158 479 48 painful painful JJ 37158 479 49 death death NN 37158 479 50 . . . 37158 480 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 480 2 estimate estimate VBP 37158 480 3 at at IN 37158 480 4 a a DT 37158 480 5 high high JJ 37158 480 6 price price NN 37158 480 7 the the DT 37158 480 8 life life NN 37158 480 9 and and CC 37158 480 10 the the DT 37158 480 11 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 480 12 of of IN 37158 480 13 fifty fifty CD 37158 480 14 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 480 15 , , , 37158 480 16 but but CC 37158 480 17 , , , 37158 480 18 at at IN 37158 480 19 the the DT 37158 480 20 risk risk NN 37158 480 21 of of IN 37158 480 22 appearing appear VBG 37158 480 23 a a DT 37158 480 24 barbarian barbarian NN 37158 480 25 , , , 37158 480 26 I -PRON- PRP 37158 480 27 prefer prefer VBP 37158 480 28 , , , 37158 480 29 to to IN 37158 480 30 these these DT 37158 480 31 fifty fifty CD 37158 480 32 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 480 33 , , , 37158 480 34 the the DT 37158 480 35 three three CD 37158 480 36 millions million NNS 37158 480 37 of of IN 37158 480 38 young young JJ 37158 480 39 people people NNS 37158 480 40 who who WP 37158 480 41 have have VBP 37158 480 42 been be VBN 37158 480 43 saved save VBN 37158 480 44 by by IN 37158 480 45 Villemin Villemin NNP 37158 480 46 's 's POS 37158 480 47 discovery discovery NN 37158 480 48 , , , 37158 480 49 and and CC 37158 480 50 the the DT 37158 480 51 millions million NNS 37158 480 52 which which WDT 37158 480 53 it -PRON- PRP 37158 480 54 will will MD 37158 480 55 still still RB 37158 480 56 save save VB 37158 480 57 . . . 37158 481 1 All all PDT 37158 481 2 the the DT 37158 481 3 more more RBR 37158 481 4 so so RB 37158 481 5 , , , 37158 481 6 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37158 481 7 as as IN 37158 481 8 experimental experimental JJ 37158 481 9 studies study NNS 37158 481 10 on on IN 37158 481 11 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 481 12 have have VBP 37158 481 13 not not RB 37158 481 14 only only RB 37158 481 15 preserved preserve VBN 37158 481 16 men man NNS 37158 481 17 ; ; : 37158 481 18 they -PRON- PRP 37158 481 19 have have VBP 37158 481 20 also also RB 37158 481 21 preserved preserve VBN 37158 481 22 animals animal NNS 37158 481 23 . . . 37158 482 1 Thanks thank NNS 37158 482 2 to to IN 37158 482 3 Koch Koch NNP 37158 482 4 , , , 37158 482 5 there there EX 37158 482 6 is be VBZ 37158 482 7 now now RB 37158 482 8 a a DT 37158 482 9 very very RB 37158 482 10 simple simple JJ 37158 482 11 way way NN 37158 482 12 of of IN 37158 482 13 recognising recognise VBG 37158 482 14 if if IN 37158 482 15 an an DT 37158 482 16 animal animal NN 37158 482 17 is be VBZ 37158 482 18 or or CC 37158 482 19 is be VBZ 37158 482 20 not not RB 37158 482 21 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 482 22 . . . 37158 483 1 Koch Koch NNP 37158 483 2 was be VBD 37158 483 3 able able JJ 37158 483 4 to to TO 37158 483 5 extract extract VB 37158 483 6 from from IN 37158 483 7 tubercle tubercle NN 37158 483 8 bacilli bacilli NNP 37158 483 9 , , , 37158 483 10 a a DT 37158 483 11 substance substance NN 37158 483 12 which which WDT 37158 483 13 he -PRON- PRP 37158 483 14 has have VBZ 37158 483 15 called call VBN 37158 483 16 _ _ NNP 37158 483 17 tuberculin tuberculin NN 37158 483 18 _ _ NNP 37158 483 19 . . . 37158 484 1 At at IN 37158 484 2 first first RB 37158 484 3 he -PRON- PRP 37158 484 4 thought think VBD 37158 484 5 tuberculin tuberculin NN 37158 484 6 cured cure VBD 37158 484 7 the the DT 37158 484 8 disease disease NN 37158 484 9 ; ; : 37158 484 10 but but CC 37158 484 11 this this DT 37158 484 12 was be VBD 37158 484 13 an an DT 37158 484 14 error error NN 37158 484 15 . . . 37158 485 1 Subsequent subsequent JJ 37158 485 2 experiments experiment NNS 37158 485 3 showed show VBD 37158 485 4 that that IN 37158 485 5 tuberculin tuberculin NN 37158 485 6 exercised exercise VBD 37158 485 7 quite quite PDT 37158 485 8 a a DT 37158 485 9 different different JJ 37158 485 10 action action NN 37158 485 11 to to IN 37158 485 12 that that DT 37158 485 13 of of IN 37158 485 14 healing healing NN 37158 485 15 . . . 37158 486 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 486 2 has have VBZ 37158 486 3 the the DT 37158 486 4 property property NN 37158 486 5 , , , 37158 486 6 when when WRB 37158 486 7 injected inject VBN 37158 486 8 in in IN 37158 486 9 small small JJ 37158 486 10 doses dose NNS 37158 486 11 into into IN 37158 486 12 a a DT 37158 486 13 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 486 14 animal animal NN 37158 486 15 , , , 37158 486 16 of of IN 37158 486 17 provoking provoke VBG 37158 486 18 an an DT 37158 486 19 intense intense JJ 37158 486 20 fever fever NN 37158 486 21 , , , 37158 486 22 whilst whilst IN 37158 486 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 486 24 produces produce VBZ 37158 486 25 no no DT 37158 486 26 reaction reaction NN 37158 486 27 whatsoever whatsoever RB 37158 486 28 in in IN 37158 486 29 a a DT 37158 486 30 normal normal JJ 37158 486 31 animal animal NN 37158 486 32 . . . 37158 487 1 If if IN 37158 487 2 , , , 37158 487 3 therefore therefore RB 37158 487 4 , , , 37158 487 5 tuberculin tuberculin NN 37158 487 6 is be VBZ 37158 487 7 injected inject VBN 37158 487 8 into into IN 37158 487 9 every every DT 37158 487 10 animal animal NN 37158 487 11 in in IN 37158 487 12 the the DT 37158 487 13 cattle cattle NNS 37158 487 14 shed shed VBP 37158 487 15 , , , 37158 487 16 we -PRON- PRP 37158 487 17 can can MD 37158 487 18 feel feel VB 37158 487 19 sure sure JJ 37158 487 20 -- -- : 37158 487 21 and and CC 37158 487 22 this this DT 37158 487 23 is be VBZ 37158 487 24 impossible impossible JJ 37158 487 25 otherwise otherwise RB 37158 487 26 -- -- : 37158 487 27 that that IN 37158 487 28 such such JJ 37158 487 29 or or CC 37158 487 30 such such JJ 37158 487 31 animals animal NNS 37158 487 32 are be VBP 37158 487 33 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 487 34 or or CC 37158 487 35 healthy healthy JJ 37158 487 36 . . . 37158 488 1 All all DT 37158 488 2 cows cow NNS 37158 488 3 that that WDT 37158 488 4 show show VBP 37158 488 5 a a DT 37158 488 6 rise rise NN 37158 488 7 in in IN 37158 488 8 temperature temperature NN 37158 488 9 after after IN 37158 488 10 an an DT 37158 488 11 injection injection NN 37158 488 12 of of IN 37158 488 13 tuberculin tuberculin NN 37158 488 14 are be VBP 37158 488 15 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 488 16 ; ; : 37158 488 17 the the DT 37158 488 18 others other NNS 37158 488 19 , , , 37158 488 20 on on IN 37158 488 21 the the DT 37158 488 22 contrary contrary NN 37158 488 23 , , , 37158 488 24 are be VBP 37158 488 25 in in IN 37158 488 26 good good JJ 37158 488 27 health health NN 37158 488 28 . . . 37158 489 1 Thus thus RB 37158 489 2 the the DT 37158 489 3 sanitary sanitary JJ 37158 489 4 inspection inspection NN 37158 489 5 of of IN 37158 489 6 stables stable NNS 37158 489 7 and and CC 37158 489 8 cattle cattle NNS 37158 489 9 - - HYPH 37158 489 10 sheds shed NNS 37158 489 11 can can MD 37158 489 12 be be VB 37158 489 13 carried carry VBN 37158 489 14 out out RP 37158 489 15 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 489 16 ; ; : 37158 489 17 and and CC 37158 489 18 we -PRON- PRP 37158 489 19 are be VBP 37158 489 20 now now RB 37158 489 21 able able JJ 37158 489 22 to to TO 37158 489 23 protect protect VB 37158 489 24 not not RB 37158 489 25 only only RB 37158 489 26 men man NNS 37158 489 27 but but CC 37158 489 28 also also RB 37158 489 29 animals animal NNS 37158 489 30 from from IN 37158 489 31 the the DT 37158 489 32 disease disease NN 37158 489 33 of of IN 37158 489 34 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 489 35 . . . 37158 490 1 Such such JJ 37158 490 2 results result NNS 37158 490 3 could could MD 37158 490 4 only only RB 37158 490 5 have have VB 37158 490 6 been be VBN 37158 490 7 obtained obtain VBN 37158 490 8 at at IN 37158 490 9 the the DT 37158 490 10 cost cost NN 37158 490 11 of of IN 37158 490 12 many many JJ 37158 490 13 and and CC 37158 490 14 methodical methodical JJ 37158 490 15 experiments experiment NNS 37158 490 16 . . . 37158 491 1 Whatever whatever WDT 37158 491 2 may may MD 37158 491 3 be be VB 37158 491 4 the the DT 37158 491 5 genius genius NN 37158 491 6 of of IN 37158 491 7 anti anti JJ 37158 491 8 - - NNS 37158 491 9 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 491 10 , , , 37158 491 11 they -PRON- PRP 37158 491 12 would would MD 37158 491 13 never never RB 37158 491 14 have have VB 37158 491 15 been be VBN 37158 491 16 able able JJ 37158 491 17 to to TO 37158 491 18 imagine imagine VB 37158 491 19 anything anything NN 37158 491 20 similar similar JJ 37158 491 21 had have VBD 37158 491 22 they -PRON- PRP 37158 491 23 been be VBN 37158 491 24 left leave VBN 37158 491 25 to to IN 37158 491 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 491 27 own own JJ 37158 491 28 intellectual intellectual JJ 37158 491 29 powers power NNS 37158 491 30 . . . 37158 492 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 492 2 is be VBZ 37158 492 3 not not RB 37158 492 4 in in IN 37158 492 5 the the DT 37158 492 6 study study NN 37158 492 7 that that IN 37158 492 8 we -PRON- PRP 37158 492 9 are be VBP 37158 492 10 able able JJ 37158 492 11 to to TO 37158 492 12 discover discover VB 37158 492 13 this this DT 37158 492 14 long long JJ 37158 492 15 series series NN 37158 492 16 of of IN 37158 492 17 unforeseen unforeseen JJ 37158 492 18 , , , 37158 492 19 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37158 492 20 , , , 37158 492 21 almost almost RB 37158 492 22 miraculous miraculous JJ 37158 492 23 facts fact NNS 37158 492 24 which which WDT 37158 492 25 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 492 26 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 492 27 has have VBZ 37158 492 28 been be VBN 37158 492 29 able able JJ 37158 492 30 to to TO 37158 492 31 find find VB 37158 492 32 out out RP 37158 492 33 . . . 37158 493 1 Man man NN 37158 493 2 , , , 37158 493 3 said say VBD 37158 493 4 Pascal Pascal NNP 37158 493 5 , , , 37158 493 6 tires tire NNS 37158 493 7 of of IN 37158 493 8 conceiving conceive VBG 37158 493 9 sooner soon RBR 37158 493 10 than than IN 37158 493 11 Nature nature NN 37158 493 12 tires tire NNS 37158 493 13 of of IN 37158 493 14 providing provide VBG 37158 493 15 ; ; : 37158 493 16 and and CC 37158 493 17 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 493 18 is be VBZ 37158 493 19 man man NN 37158 493 20 's 's POS 37158 493 21 method method NN 37158 493 22 of of IN 37158 493 23 interrogating interrogate VBG 37158 493 24 Nature nature NN 37158 493 25 . . . 37158 494 1 * * NFP 37158 494 2 * * NFP 37158 494 3 * * NFP 37158 494 4 * * NFP 37158 494 5 * * NFP 37158 494 6 The the DT 37158 494 7 third third JJ 37158 494 8 discovery discovery NN 37158 494 9 which which WDT 37158 494 10 I -PRON- PRP 37158 494 11 shall shall MD 37158 494 12 take take VB 37158 494 13 as as IN 37158 494 14 an an DT 37158 494 15 example example NN 37158 494 16 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 37158 494 17 the the DT 37158 494 18 value value NN 37158 494 19 of of IN 37158 494 20 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 494 21 , , , 37158 494 22 is be VBZ 37158 494 23 the the DT 37158 494 24 history history NN 37158 494 25 of of IN 37158 494 26 _ _ NNP 37158 494 27 Serotherapy Serotherapy NNP 37158 494 28 _ _ NNP 37158 494 29 . . . 37158 495 1 And and CC 37158 495 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 495 3 may may MD 37158 495 4 be be VB 37158 495 5 permitted permit VBN 37158 495 6 to to TO 37158 495 7 dwell dwell VB 37158 495 8 somewhat somewhat RB 37158 495 9 on on IN 37158 495 10 this this DT 37158 495 11 subject subject NN 37158 495 12 as as IN 37158 495 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 495 14 had have VBD 37158 495 15 the the DT 37158 495 16 good good JJ 37158 495 17 fortune fortune NN 37158 495 18 , , , 37158 495 19 in in IN 37158 495 20 1888 1888 CD 37158 495 21 , , , 37158 495 22 of of IN 37158 495 23 making make VBG 37158 495 24 the the DT 37158 495 25 decisive decisive JJ 37158 495 26 experiment experiment NN 37158 495 27 which which WDT 37158 495 28 was be VBD 37158 495 29 the the DT 37158 495 30 beginning beginning NN 37158 495 31 of of IN 37158 495 32 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 495 33 . . . 37158 496 1 Whilst whilst IN 37158 496 2 inoculating inoculate VBG 37158 496 3 some some DT 37158 496 4 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 496 5 and and CC 37158 496 6 dogs dog NNS 37158 496 7 with with IN 37158 496 8 a a DT 37158 496 9 microbe microbe NN 37158 496 10 taken take VBN 37158 496 11 from from IN 37158 496 12 pus pus NNP 37158 496 13 ( ( -LRB- 37158 496 14 _ _ NNP 37158 496 15 Staphylococcus Staphylococcus NNP 37158 496 16 pyosepticus pyosepticus NN 37158 496 17 _ _ NNP 37158 496 18 ) ) -RRB- 37158 496 19 , , , 37158 496 20 I -PRON- PRP 37158 496 21 developed develop VBD 37158 496 22 a a DT 37158 496 23 certain certain JJ 37158 496 24 disease disease NN 37158 496 25 both both DT 37158 496 26 in in IN 37158 496 27 the the DT 37158 496 28 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 496 29 and and CC 37158 496 30 in in IN 37158 496 31 the the DT 37158 496 32 dogs dog NNS 37158 496 33 . . . 37158 497 1 But but CC 37158 497 2 the the DT 37158 497 3 dogs dog NNS 37158 497 4 did do VBD 37158 497 5 not not RB 37158 497 6 die die VB 37158 497 7 , , , 37158 497 8 whilst whilst IN 37158 497 9 all all PDT 37158 497 10 the the DT 37158 497 11 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 497 12 died die VBD 37158 497 13 from from IN 37158 497 14 the the DT 37158 497 15 results result NNS 37158 497 16 of of IN 37158 497 17 the the DT 37158 497 18 inoculation inoculation NN 37158 497 19 . . . 37158 498 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 498 2 thought think VBD 37158 498 3 then then RB 37158 498 4 that that DT 37158 498 5 , , , 37158 498 6 the the DT 37158 498 7 cause cause NN 37158 498 8 of of IN 37158 498 9 that that DT 37158 498 10 resistance resistance NN 37158 498 11 being be VBG 37158 498 12 due due IN 37158 498 13 to to IN 37158 498 14 the the DT 37158 498 15 difference difference NN 37158 498 16 of of IN 37158 498 17 blood blood NN 37158 498 18 , , , 37158 498 19 I -PRON- PRP 37158 498 20 might may MD 37158 498 21 be be VB 37158 498 22 able able JJ 37158 498 23 to to TO 37158 498 24 make make VB 37158 498 25 the the DT 37158 498 26 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 498 27 refractory refractory NN 37158 498 28 to to IN 37158 498 29 the the DT 37158 498 30 infection infection NN 37158 498 31 by by IN 37158 498 32 injecting inject VBG 37158 498 33 it -PRON- PRP 37158 498 34 with with IN 37158 498 35 the the DT 37158 498 36 blood blood NN 37158 498 37 of of IN 37158 498 38 a a DT 37158 498 39 dog dog NN 37158 498 40 in in IN 37158 498 41 normal normal JJ 37158 498 42 health health NN 37158 498 43 . . . 37158 499 1 The the DT 37158 499 2 experiment experiment NN 37158 499 3 succeeded succeed VBD 37158 499 4 . . . 37158 500 1 The the DT 37158 500 2 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 500 3 which which WDT 37158 500 4 had have VBD 37158 500 5 received receive VBN 37158 500 6 the the DT 37158 500 7 blood blood NN 37158 500 8 of of IN 37158 500 9 the the DT 37158 500 10 dog dog NN 37158 500 11 , , , 37158 500 12 when when WRB 37158 500 13 they -PRON- PRP 37158 500 14 were be VBD 37158 500 15 afterwards afterwards RB 37158 500 16 infected infect VBN 37158 500 17 with with IN 37158 500 18 the the DT 37158 500 19 staphylococcus staphylococcus NN 37158 500 20 , , , 37158 500 21 became become VBD 37158 500 22 very very RB 37158 500 23 ill ill JJ 37158 500 24 but but CC 37158 500 25 did do VBD 37158 500 26 not not RB 37158 500 27 die die VB 37158 500 28 . . . 37158 501 1 Later later RB 37158 501 2 on on RB 37158 501 3 , , , 37158 501 4 I -PRON- PRP 37158 501 5 took take VBD 37158 501 6 , , , 37158 501 7 not not RB 37158 501 8 the the DT 37158 501 9 blood blood NN 37158 501 10 of of IN 37158 501 11 a a DT 37158 501 12 dog dog NN 37158 501 13 in in IN 37158 501 14 normal normal JJ 37158 501 15 health health NN 37158 501 16 , , , 37158 501 17 but but CC 37158 501 18 the the DT 37158 501 19 blood blood NN 37158 501 20 of of IN 37158 501 21 a a DT 37158 501 22 dog dog NN 37158 501 23 that that WDT 37158 501 24 had have VBD 37158 501 25 received receive VBN 37158 501 26 the the DT 37158 501 27 infection infection NN 37158 501 28 of of IN 37158 501 29 the the DT 37158 501 30 staphylococcus staphylococcus NN 37158 501 31 and and CC 37158 501 32 had have VBD 37158 501 33 recovered recover VBN 37158 501 34 from from IN 37158 501 35 that that DT 37158 501 36 infection infection NN 37158 501 37 , , , 37158 501 38 and and CC 37158 501 39 I -PRON- PRP 37158 501 40 injected inject VBD 37158 501 41 this this DT 37158 501 42 blood blood NN 37158 501 43 into into IN 37158 501 44 the the DT 37158 501 45 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 501 46 . . . 37158 502 1 _ _ NNP 37158 502 2 Now now RB 37158 502 3 the the DT 37158 502 4 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 502 5 that that WDT 37158 502 6 received receive VBD 37158 502 7 the the DT 37158 502 8 blood blood NN 37158 502 9 of of IN 37158 502 10 the the DT 37158 502 11 infected infect VBN 37158 502 12 , , , 37158 502 13 healed heal VBN 37158 502 14 dog dog NN 37158 502 15 had have VBD 37158 502 16 acquired acquire VBN 37158 502 17 complete complete JJ 37158 502 18 immunity immunity NN 37158 502 19 to to IN 37158 502 20 this this DT 37158 502 21 form form NN 37158 502 22 of of IN 37158 502 23 microbe microbe NN 37158 502 24 infection infection NN 37158 502 25 _ _ NNP 37158 502 26 : : : 37158 502 27 the the DT 37158 502 28 principle principle NN 37158 502 29 of of IN 37158 502 30 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 502 31 was be VBD 37158 502 32 discovered discover VBN 37158 502 33 ( ( -LRB- 37158 502 34 5th 5th JJ 37158 502 35 Nov. November NNP 37158 502 36 1888 1888 CD 37158 502 37 ) ) -RRB- 37158 502 38 . . . 37158 503 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 503 2 Illustration illustration NN 37158 503 3 : : : 37158 503 4 " " `` 37158 503 5 L'ENFANT L'ENFANT NNP 37158 503 6 . . . 37158 503 7 " " '' 37158 504 1 _ _ NNP 37158 504 2 In in IN 37158 504 3 Musée Musée NNP 37158 504 4 du du NNP 37158 504 5 Luxembourg Luxembourg NNP 37158 504 6 , , , 37158 504 7 Paris Paris NNP 37158 504 8 . . . 37158 504 9 _ _ NNP 37158 504 10 _ _ NNP 37158 504 11 facing face VBG 37158 504 12 p. p. NN 37158 504 13 53 53 CD 37158 504 14 . . . 37158 504 15 _ _ NNP 37158 504 16 ] ] -RRB- 37158 504 17 Since since IN 37158 504 18 then then RB 37158 504 19 , , , 37158 504 20 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 504 21 has have VBZ 37158 504 22 been be VBN 37158 504 23 applied apply VBN 37158 504 24 , , , 37158 504 25 by by IN 37158 504 26 Behring behre VBG 37158 504 27 in in IN 37158 504 28 Germany Germany NNP 37158 504 29 and and CC 37158 504 30 by by IN 37158 504 31 Roux Roux NNP 37158 504 32 in in IN 37158 504 33 France France NNP 37158 504 34 , , , 37158 504 35 to to IN 37158 504 36 diphtheria diphtheria NNP 37158 504 37 ( ( -LRB- 37158 504 38 1892 1892 CD 37158 504 39 ) ) -RRB- 37158 504 40 . . . 37158 505 1 These these DT 37158 505 2 two two CD 37158 505 3 savants savant NNS 37158 505 4 showed show VBD 37158 505 5 that that IN 37158 505 6 the the DT 37158 505 7 blood blood NN 37158 505 8 of of IN 37158 505 9 animals animal NNS 37158 505 10 , , , 37158 505 11 and and CC 37158 505 12 especially especially RB 37158 505 13 of of IN 37158 505 14 horses horse NNS 37158 505 15 , , , 37158 505 16 that that WDT 37158 505 17 had have VBD 37158 505 18 been be VBN 37158 505 19 infected infect VBN 37158 505 20 with with IN 37158 505 21 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 505 22 and and CC 37158 505 23 cured cure VBN 37158 505 24 , , , 37158 505 25 could could MD 37158 505 26 , , , 37158 505 27 when when WRB 37158 505 28 injected inject VBN 37158 505 29 into into IN 37158 505 30 patients patient NNS 37158 505 31 attacked attack VBN 37158 505 32 by by IN 37158 505 33 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 505 34 , , , 37158 505 35 diminish diminish NNP 37158 505 36 , , , 37158 505 37 in in IN 37158 505 38 an an DT 37158 505 39 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37158 505 40 proportion proportion NN 37158 505 41 , , , 37158 505 42 the the DT 37158 505 43 duration duration NN 37158 505 44 and and CC 37158 505 45 intensity intensity NN 37158 505 46 of of IN 37158 505 47 the the DT 37158 505 48 disease disease NN 37158 505 49 . . . 37158 506 1 There there EX 37158 506 2 is be VBZ 37158 506 3 no no DT 37158 506 4 other other JJ 37158 506 5 treatment treatment NN 37158 506 6 for for IN 37158 506 7 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 506 8 to to NNP 37158 506 9 - - HYPH 37158 506 10 day day NN 37158 506 11 . . . 37158 507 1 A a DT 37158 507 2 doctor doctor NN 37158 507 3 is be VBZ 37158 507 4 guilty guilty JJ 37158 507 5 , , , 37158 507 6 and and CC 37158 507 7 even even RB 37158 507 8 criminal criminal JJ 37158 507 9 , , , 37158 507 10 if if IN 37158 507 11 he -PRON- PRP 37158 507 12 does do VBZ 37158 507 13 not not RB 37158 507 14 use use VB 37158 507 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 507 16 , , , 37158 507 17 for for IN 37158 507 18 the the DT 37158 507 19 therapeutic therapeutic JJ 37158 507 20 results result NNS 37158 507 21 of of IN 37158 507 22 this this DT 37158 507 23 treatment treatment NN 37158 507 24 are be VBP 37158 507 25 marvellous marvellous JJ 37158 507 26 . . . 37158 508 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 508 2 do do VBP 37158 508 3 not not RB 37158 508 4 speak speak VB 37158 508 5 of of IN 37158 508 6 clinical clinical JJ 37158 508 7 observation observation NN 37158 508 8 only only RB 37158 508 9 . . . 37158 509 1 All all PDT 37158 509 2 those those DT 37158 509 3 who who WP 37158 509 4 have have VBP 37158 509 5 seen see VBN 37158 509 6 the the DT 37158 509 7 effects effect NNS 37158 509 8 of of IN 37158 509 9 one one CD 37158 509 10 of of IN 37158 509 11 these these DT 37158 509 12 injections injection NNS 37158 509 13 of of IN 37158 509 14 serum serum NN 37158 509 15 on on IN 37158 509 16 children child NNS 37158 509 17 down down RP 37158 509 18 with with IN 37158 509 19 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 509 20 are be VBP 37158 509 21 veritably veritably RB 37158 509 22 stupefied stupefy VBN 37158 509 23 at at IN 37158 509 24 the the DT 37158 509 25 resurrection resurrection NN 37158 509 26 which which WDT 37158 509 27 they -PRON- PRP 37158 509 28 witness witness VBP 37158 509 29 only only RB 37158 509 30 a a DT 37158 509 31 few few JJ 37158 509 32 minutes minute NNS 37158 509 33 after after IN 37158 509 34 the the DT 37158 509 35 injection injection NN 37158 509 36 . . . 37158 510 1 The the DT 37158 510 2 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 510 3 child child NN 37158 510 4 with with IN 37158 510 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 510 6 purple purple JJ 37158 510 7 face face NN 37158 510 8 and and CC 37158 510 9 convulsed convulsed JJ 37158 510 10 limbs limb NNS 37158 510 11 , , , 37158 510 12 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 510 13 breathing breathe VBG 37158 510 14 , , , 37158 510 15 comes come VBZ 37158 510 16 back back RB 37158 510 17 to to IN 37158 510 18 fresh fresh JJ 37158 510 19 life life NN 37158 510 20 as as RB 37158 510 21 soon soon RB 37158 510 22 as as IN 37158 510 23 he -PRON- PRP 37158 510 24 has have VBZ 37158 510 25 received receive VBN 37158 510 26 the the DT 37158 510 27 beneficent beneficent JJ 37158 510 28 injection injection NN 37158 510 29 of of IN 37158 510 30 serum serum NN 37158 510 31 . . . 37158 511 1 The the DT 37158 511 2 facts fact NNS 37158 511 3 are be VBP 37158 511 4 so so RB 37158 511 5 decisively decisively RB 37158 511 6 clear clear JJ 37158 511 7 that that IN 37158 511 8 even even RB 37158 511 9 if if IN 37158 511 10 we -PRON- PRP 37158 511 11 have have VBP 37158 511 12 only only RB 37158 511 13 seen see VBN 37158 511 14 them -PRON- PRP 37158 511 15 once once IN 37158 511 16 we -PRON- PRP 37158 511 17 can can MD 37158 511 18 never never RB 37158 511 19 again again RB 37158 511 20 forget forget VB 37158 511 21 them -PRON- PRP 37158 511 22 . . . 37158 512 1 But but CC 37158 512 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 512 3 shall shall MD 37158 512 4 simply simply RB 37158 512 5 call call VB 37158 512 6 the the DT 37158 512 7 attention attention NN 37158 512 8 of of IN 37158 512 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 512 10 readers reader NNS 37158 512 11 to to IN 37158 512 12 the the DT 37158 512 13 following follow VBG 37158 512 14 statistics statistic NNS 37158 512 15 , , , 37158 512 16 the the DT 37158 512 17 result result NN 37158 512 18 of of IN 37158 512 19 more more JJR 37158 512 20 than than IN 37158 512 21 500,000 500,000 CD 37158 512 22 observations observation NNS 37158 512 23 made make VBN 37158 512 24 in in IN 37158 512 25 England England NNP 37158 512 26 , , , 37158 512 27 in in IN 37158 512 28 the the DT 37158 512 29 United United NNP 37158 512 30 States States NNP 37158 512 31 , , , 37158 512 32 in in IN 37158 512 33 France France NNP 37158 512 34 , , , 37158 512 35 in in IN 37158 512 36 Russia Russia NNP 37158 512 37 , , , 37158 512 38 in in IN 37158 512 39 Germany Germany NNP 37158 512 40 , , , 37158 512 41 in in IN 37158 512 42 Italy Italy NNP 37158 512 43 , , , 37158 512 44 in in IN 37158 512 45 Austria Austria NNP 37158 512 46 , , , 37158 512 47 in in IN 37158 512 48 fact fact NN 37158 512 49 everywhere everywhere RB 37158 512 50 : : : 37158 512 51 the the DT 37158 512 52 death death NN 37158 512 53 - - HYPH 37158 512 54 rate rate NN 37158 512 55 in in IN 37158 512 56 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 512 57 before before IN 37158 512 58 1892 1892 CD 37158 512 59 ( ( -LRB- 37158 512 60 for for IN 37158 512 61 the the DT 37158 512 62 serotherapic serotherapic JJ 37158 512 63 method method NN 37158 512 64 took take VBD 37158 512 65 four four CD 37158 512 66 years year NNS 37158 512 67 to to TO 37158 512 68 become become VB 37158 512 69 known know VBN 37158 512 70 and and CC 37158 512 71 practised practised JJ 37158 512 72 ) ) -RRB- 37158 512 73 was be VBD 37158 512 74 45 45 CD 37158 512 75 per per NN 37158 512 76 cent cent NN 37158 512 77 . . . 37158 513 1 After after IN 37158 513 2 1892 1892 CD 37158 513 3 , , , 37158 513 4 this this DT 37158 513 5 death death NN 37158 513 6 - - HYPH 37158 513 7 rate rate NN 37158 513 8 fell fall VBD 37158 513 9 to to IN 37158 513 10 12 12 CD 37158 513 11 per per NN 37158 513 12 cent cent NN 37158 513 13 . . . 37158 514 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 514 2 8 8 CD 37158 514 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 514 4 Consequently consequently RB 37158 514 5 , , , 37158 514 6 out out IN 37158 514 7 of of IN 37158 514 8 every every DT 37158 514 9 hundred hundred CD 37158 514 10 patients patient NNS 37158 514 11 suffering suffer VBG 37158 514 12 from from IN 37158 514 13 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 514 14 , , , 37158 514 15 thirty thirty CD 37158 514 16 are be VBP 37158 514 17 saved save VBN 37158 514 18 by by IN 37158 514 19 the the DT 37158 514 20 serotherapic serotherapic JJ 37158 514 21 treatment treatment NN 37158 514 22 . . . 37158 515 1 Let let VB 37158 515 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 515 3 stop stop VB 37158 515 4 for for IN 37158 515 5 a a DT 37158 515 6 moment moment NN 37158 515 7 to to TO 37158 515 8 consider consider VB 37158 515 9 these these DT 37158 515 10 figures figure NNS 37158 515 11 , , , 37158 515 12 which which WDT 37158 515 13 seem seem VBP 37158 515 14 mere mere JJ 37158 515 15 abstractions abstraction NNS 37158 515 16 to to IN 37158 515 17 those those DT 37158 515 18 who who WP 37158 515 19 have have VBP 37158 515 20 not not RB 37158 515 21 reflected reflect VBN 37158 515 22 . . . 37158 516 1 At at IN 37158 516 2 the the DT 37158 516 3 present present JJ 37158 516 4 time time NN 37158 516 5 , , , 37158 516 6 about about RB 37158 516 7 300,000 300,000 CD 37158 516 8 children child NNS 37158 516 9 per per IN 37158 516 10 annum annum NN 37158 516 11 in in IN 37158 516 12 France France NNP 37158 516 13 are be VBP 37158 516 14 attacked attack VBN 37158 516 15 by by IN 37158 516 16 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 516 17 ; ; : 37158 516 18 that that DT 37158 516 19 makes make VBZ 37158 516 20 4,500,000 4,500,000 CD 37158 516 21 from from IN 37158 516 22 1892 1892 CD 37158 516 23 to to IN 37158 516 24 1907 1907 CD 37158 516 25 . . . 37158 517 1 The the DT 37158 517 2 proportion proportion NN 37158 517 3 of of IN 37158 517 4 30 30 CD 37158 517 5 per per NN 37158 517 6 cent cent NN 37158 517 7 . . . 37158 518 1 is be VBZ 37158 518 2 therefore therefore RB 37158 518 3 1,350,000 1,350,000 CD 37158 518 4 . . . 37158 519 1 The the DT 37158 519 2 number number NN 37158 519 3 of of IN 37158 519 4 children child NNS 37158 519 5 who who WP 37158 519 6 have have VBP 37158 519 7 been be VBN 37158 519 8 saved save VBN 37158 519 9 in in IN 37158 519 10 France France NNP 37158 519 11 alone alone RB 37158 519 12 by by IN 37158 519 13 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 519 14 in in IN 37158 519 15 fifteen fifteen CD 37158 519 16 years year NNS 37158 519 17 is be VBZ 37158 519 18 therefore therefore RB 37158 519 19 1,350,000 1,350,000 CD 37158 519 20 . . . 37158 520 1 Let let VB 37158 520 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 520 3 put put VB 37158 520 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 520 5 in in IN 37158 520 6 round round JJ 37158 520 7 numbers number NNS 37158 520 8 at at IN 37158 520 9 one one CD 37158 520 10 million million CD 37158 520 11 only only RB 37158 520 12 ; ; : 37158 520 13 this this DT 37158 520 14 would would MD 37158 520 15 be be VB 37158 520 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 520 17 to to TO 37158 520 18 justify justify VB 37158 520 19 the the DT 37158 520 20 death death NN 37158 520 21 of of IN 37158 520 22 the the DT 37158 520 23 twenty twenty CD 37158 520 24 - - HYPH 37158 520 25 five five CD 37158 520 26 dogs dog NNS 37158 520 27 and and CC 37158 520 28 the the DT 37158 520 29 one one CD 37158 520 30 hundred hundred CD 37158 520 31 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 520 32 which which WDT 37158 520 33 I -PRON- PRP 37158 520 34 sacrificed sacrifice VBD 37158 520 35 , , , 37158 520 36 and and CC 37158 520 37 of of IN 37158 520 38 the the DT 37158 520 39 two two CD 37158 520 40 hundred hundred CD 37158 520 41 horses horse NNS 37158 520 42 which which WDT 37158 520 43 Behring behre VBG 37158 520 44 and and CC 37158 520 45 Roux Roux NNP 37158 520 46 used use VBN 37158 520 47 for for IN 37158 520 48 the the DT 37158 520 49 preparation preparation NN 37158 520 50 of of IN 37158 520 51 the the DT 37158 520 52 anti anti JJ 37158 520 53 - - JJ 37158 520 54 diphtheria diphtheria JJ 37158 520 55 serum serum NN 37158 520 56 . . . 37158 521 1 A a DT 37158 521 2 million million CD 37158 521 3 families family NNS 37158 521 4 in in IN 37158 521 5 mourning mourning NN 37158 521 6 , , , 37158 521 7 a a DT 37158 521 8 million million CD 37158 521 9 hopes hope NNS 37158 521 10 mowed mow VBN 37158 521 11 down down RP 37158 521 12 in in IN 37158 521 13 the the DT 37158 521 14 bud bud NN 37158 521 15 ! ! . 37158 522 1 Only only JJ 37158 522 2 fanatics fanatic NNS 37158 522 3 would would MD 37158 522 4 dare dare VB 37158 522 5 to to TO 37158 522 6 say say VB 37158 522 7 this this DT 37158 522 8 weighs weigh NNS 37158 522 9 for for IN 37158 522 10 nought nought NN 37158 522 11 in in IN 37158 522 12 the the DT 37158 522 13 balance balance NN 37158 522 14 . . . 37158 523 1 Moreover moreover RB 37158 523 2 -- -- : 37158 523 3 and and CC 37158 523 4 why why WRB 37158 523 5 should should MD 37158 523 6 I -PRON- PRP 37158 523 7 not not RB 37158 523 8 say say VB 37158 523 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 523 10 aloud?--this aloud?--this NNP 37158 523 11 so so RB 37158 523 12 - - HYPH 37158 523 13 called call VBN 37158 523 14 humanity humanity NN 37158 523 15 of of IN 37158 523 16 anti anti JJ 37158 523 17 - - NN 37158 523 18 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 523 19 seems seem VBZ 37158 523 20 to to IN 37158 523 21 me -PRON- PRP 37158 523 22 the the DT 37158 523 23 antithesis antithesis NN 37158 523 24 of of IN 37158 523 25 humanity humanity NN 37158 523 26 . . . 37158 524 1 To to TO 37158 524 2 satisfy satisfy VB 37158 524 3 a a DT 37158 524 4 conception conception NN 37158 524 5 which which WDT 37158 524 6 they -PRON- PRP 37158 524 7 have have VBP 37158 524 8 forged forge VBN 37158 524 9 out out IN 37158 524 10 of of IN 37158 524 11 a a DT 37158 524 12 certain certain JJ 37158 524 13 hazy hazy NN 37158 524 14 ideal ideal NN 37158 524 15 , , , 37158 524 16 they -PRON- PRP 37158 524 17 make make VBP 37158 524 18 quick quick JJ 37158 524 19 shrift shrift NN 37158 524 20 of of IN 37158 524 21 human human JJ 37158 524 22 life life NN 37158 524 23 and and CC 37158 524 24 suffering suffering NN 37158 524 25 . . . 37158 525 1 A a DT 37158 525 2 hundred hundred CD 37158 525 3 weeping weeping NN 37158 525 4 mothers mother NNS 37158 525 5 , , , 37158 525 6 a a DT 37158 525 7 hundred hundred CD 37158 525 8 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 525 9 children child NNS 37158 525 10 with with IN 37158 525 11 gaping gape VBG 37158 525 12 throats throat NNS 37158 525 13 , , , 37158 525 14 suffocating suffocate VBG 37158 525 15 , , , 37158 525 16 gasping gasping NN 37158 525 17 , , , 37158 525 18 the the DT 37158 525 19 death death NN 37158 525 20 - - HYPH 37158 525 21 rattle rattle NN 37158 525 22 at at IN 37158 525 23 hand hand NN 37158 525 24 -- -- : 37158 525 25 that that DT 37158 525 26 is be VBZ 37158 525 27 what what WP 37158 525 28 these these DT 37158 525 29 sensitive sensitive JJ 37158 525 30 souls soul NNS 37158 525 31 declare declare VBP 37158 525 32 is be VBZ 37158 525 33 nothing nothing NN 37158 525 34 beside beside IN 37158 525 35 one one CD 37158 525 36 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 525 37 which which WDT 37158 525 38 has have VBZ 37158 525 39 had have VBN 37158 525 40 to to TO 37158 525 41 receive receive VB 37158 525 42 a a DT 37158 525 43 little little JJ 37158 525 44 blood blood NN 37158 525 45 of of IN 37158 525 46 a a DT 37158 525 47 dog dog NN 37158 525 48 into into IN 37158 525 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 525 50 abdomen abdoman NNS 37158 525 51 ! ! . 37158 526 1 These these DT 37158 526 2 philanthropists philanthropist NNS 37158 526 3 are be VBP 37158 526 4 creatures creature NNS 37158 526 5 of of IN 37158 526 6 a a DT 37158 526 7 fixed fix VBN 37158 526 8 idea idea NN 37158 526 9 ! ! . 37158 527 1 Let let VB 37158 527 2 humanity humanity NN 37158 527 3 suffer suffer VB 37158 527 4 , , , 37158 527 5 weep weep VB 37158 527 6 and and CC 37158 527 7 die die VB 37158 527 8 ! ! . 37158 528 1 What what WP 37158 528 2 does do VBZ 37158 528 3 that that DT 37158 528 4 matter matter NN 37158 528 5 , , , 37158 528 6 provided provide VBD 37158 528 7 that that IN 37158 528 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 528 9 fixed fix VBN 37158 528 10 idea idea NN 37158 528 11 , , , 37158 528 12 driven drive VBN 37158 528 13 right right RB 37158 528 14 up up IN 37158 528 15 to to IN 37158 528 16 the the DT 37158 528 17 hilt hilt NN 37158 528 18 of of IN 37158 528 19 delirium delirium NN 37158 528 20 , , , 37158 528 21 triumphs triumph NNS 37158 528 22 ! ! . 37158 529 1 After after RB 37158 529 2 all all RB 37158 529 3 , , , 37158 529 4 if if IN 37158 529 5 they -PRON- PRP 37158 529 6 persist persist VBP 37158 529 7 in in IN 37158 529 8 believing believe VBG 37158 529 9 that that IN 37158 529 10 the the DT 37158 529 11 faint faint JJ 37158 529 12 and and CC 37158 529 13 uncertain uncertain JJ 37158 529 14 suffering suffering NN 37158 529 15 of of IN 37158 529 16 a a DT 37158 529 17 sick sick JJ 37158 529 18 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 529 19 is be VBZ 37158 529 20 not not RB 37158 529 21 worth worth JJ 37158 529 22 the the DT 37158 529 23 certain certain JJ 37158 529 24 and and CC 37158 529 25 excruciating excruciating JJ 37158 529 26 suffering suffering NN 37158 529 27 of of IN 37158 529 28 a a DT 37158 529 29 thousand thousand CD 37158 529 30 human human JJ 37158 529 31 creatures creature NNS 37158 529 32 , , , 37158 529 33 I -PRON- PRP 37158 529 34 can can MD 37158 529 35 say say VB 37158 529 36 but but CC 37158 529 37 one one CD 37158 529 38 thing thing NN 37158 529 39 : : : 37158 529 40 I -PRON- PRP 37158 529 41 pity pity VBP 37158 529 42 them -PRON- PRP 37158 529 43 from from IN 37158 529 44 the the DT 37158 529 45 very very JJ 37158 529 46 bottom bottom NN 37158 529 47 of of IN 37158 529 48 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 529 49 heart heart NN 37158 529 50 . . . 37158 530 1 * * NFP 37158 530 2 * * NFP 37158 530 3 * * NFP 37158 530 4 * * NFP 37158 530 5 * * NFP 37158 530 6 These these DT 37158 530 7 examples example NNS 37158 530 8 -- -- : 37158 530 9 antisepsis antisepsis NN 37158 530 10 , , , 37158 530 11 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 530 12 , , , 37158 530 13 and and CC 37158 530 14 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 530 15 -- -- : 37158 530 16 will will MD 37158 530 17 suffice suffice VB 37158 530 18 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 530 19 to to TO 37158 530 20 justify justify VB 37158 530 21 experimental experimental JJ 37158 530 22 pathology pathology NN 37158 530 23 . . . 37158 531 1 There there EX 37158 531 2 is be VBZ 37158 531 3 now now RB 37158 531 4 another another DT 37158 531 5 experimental experimental JJ 37158 531 6 science science NN 37158 531 7 which which WDT 37158 531 8 I -PRON- PRP 37158 531 9 am be VBP 37158 531 10 going go VBG 37158 531 11 to to TO 37158 531 12 try try VB 37158 531 13 to to TO 37158 531 14 justify justify VB 37158 531 15 also also RB 37158 531 16 . . . 37158 532 1 This this DT 37158 532 2 is be VBZ 37158 532 3 _ _ NNP 37158 532 4 Therapeutics Therapeutics NNP 37158 532 5 _ _ NNP 37158 532 6 . . . 37158 533 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 533 2 are be VBP 37158 533 3 only only RB 37158 533 4 able able JJ 37158 533 5 to to TO 37158 533 6 learn learn VB 37158 533 7 the the DT 37158 533 8 action action NN 37158 533 9 of of IN 37158 533 10 medicaments medicament NNS 37158 533 11 by by IN 37158 533 12 studying study VBG 37158 533 13 the the DT 37158 533 14 action action NN 37158 533 15 of of IN 37158 533 16 poisons poison NNS 37158 533 17 , , , 37158 533 18 for for IN 37158 533 19 all all DT 37158 533 20 medicaments medicament NNS 37158 533 21 in in IN 37158 533 22 strong strong JJ 37158 533 23 doses dose NNS 37158 533 24 are be VBP 37158 533 25 poisonous poisonous JJ 37158 533 26 . . . 37158 534 1 Now now RB 37158 534 2 , , , 37158 534 3 to to TO 37158 534 4 understand understand VB 37158 534 5 a a DT 37158 534 6 poison poison NN 37158 534 7 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 534 8 , , , 37158 534 9 we -PRON- PRP 37158 534 10 must must MD 37158 534 11 experiment experiment VB 37158 534 12 with with IN 37158 534 13 it -PRON- PRP 37158 534 14 on on IN 37158 534 15 the the DT 37158 534 16 animal animal NN 37158 534 17 . . . 37158 535 1 Simpson Simpson NNP 37158 535 2 administered administer VBD 37158 535 3 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 535 4 to to IN 37158 535 5 men man NNS 37158 535 6 only only RB 37158 535 7 after after IN 37158 535 8 Flourens Flourens NNP 37158 535 9 had have VBD 37158 535 10 determined determine VBN 37158 535 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 535 12 anæsthesic anæsthesic JJ 37158 535 13 properties property NNS 37158 535 14 on on IN 37158 535 15 animals animal NNS 37158 535 16 . . . 37158 536 1 Liebreich Liebreich NNP 37158 536 2 , , , 37158 536 3 after after IN 37158 536 4 he -PRON- PRP 37158 536 5 discovered discover VBD 37158 536 6 chloral chloral NN 37158 536 7 , , , 37158 536 8 studied study VBD 37158 536 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 536 10 physiological physiological JJ 37158 536 11 properties property NNS 37158 536 12 on on IN 37158 536 13 animals animal NNS 37158 536 14 , , , 37158 536 15 and and CC 37158 536 16 only only RB 37158 536 17 after after IN 37158 536 18 long long JJ 37158 536 19 and and CC 37158 536 20 learned learn VBN 37158 536 21 studies study NNS 37158 536 22 was be VBD 37158 536 23 he -PRON- PRP 37158 536 24 able able JJ 37158 536 25 to to TO 37158 536 26 give give VB 37158 536 27 it -PRON- PRP 37158 536 28 a a DT 37158 536 29 place place NN 37158 536 30 in in IN 37158 536 31 human human JJ 37158 536 32 therapeutics therapeutic NNS 37158 536 33 . . . 37158 537 1 At at IN 37158 537 2 the the DT 37158 537 3 present present JJ 37158 537 4 day day NN 37158 537 5 , , , 37158 537 6 chloral chloral JJ 37158 537 7 is be VBZ 37158 537 8 one one CD 37158 537 9 of of IN 37158 537 10 the the DT 37158 537 11 most most RBS 37158 537 12 extensively extensively RB 37158 537 13 used use VBN 37158 537 14 medicines medicine NNS 37158 537 15 , , , 37158 537 16 one one CD 37158 537 17 which which WDT 37158 537 18 has have VBZ 37158 537 19 relieved relieve VBN 37158 537 20 innumerable innumerable JJ 37158 537 21 patients patient NNS 37158 537 22 . . . 37158 538 1 When when WRB 37158 538 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 538 3 carried carry VBD 37158 538 4 out out RP 37158 538 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 538 6 research research NN 37158 538 7 on on IN 37158 538 8 chloralose chloralose NNP 37158 538 9 , , , 37158 538 10 before before IN 37158 538 11 studying study VBG 37158 538 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 538 13 effects effect NNS 37158 538 14 on on IN 37158 538 15 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 538 16 , , , 37158 538 17 I -PRON- PRP 37158 538 18 began begin VBD 37158 538 19 by by IN 37158 538 20 giving give VBG 37158 538 21 it -PRON- PRP 37158 538 22 to to IN 37158 538 23 cats cat NNS 37158 538 24 and and CC 37158 538 25 fowls fowl NNS 37158 538 26 . . . 37158 539 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 539 2 was be VBD 37158 539 3 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 539 4 of of IN 37158 539 5 the the DT 37158 539 6 degree degree NN 37158 539 7 of of IN 37158 539 8 toxic toxic JJ 37158 539 9 power power NN 37158 539 10 of of IN 37158 539 11 this this DT 37158 539 12 new new JJ 37158 539 13 , , , 37158 539 14 still still RB 37158 539 15 unknown unknown JJ 37158 539 16 substance substance NN 37158 539 17 , , , 37158 539 18 and and CC 37158 539 19 , , , 37158 539 20 at at IN 37158 539 21 the the DT 37158 539 22 risk risk NN 37158 539 23 of of IN 37158 539 24 appearing appear VBG 37158 539 25 very very RB 37158 539 26 pusillanimous pusillanimous JJ 37158 539 27 , , , 37158 539 28 I -PRON- PRP 37158 539 29 did do VBD 37158 539 30 not not RB 37158 539 31 wish wish VB 37158 539 32 to to TO 37158 539 33 begin begin VB 37158 539 34 on on IN 37158 539 35 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 539 36 ; ; : 37158 539 37 I -PRON- PRP 37158 539 38 preferred prefer VBD 37158 539 39 trying try VBG 37158 539 40 it -PRON- PRP 37158 539 41 on on IN 37158 539 42 a a DT 37158 539 43 fowl fowl NN 37158 539 44 . . . 37158 540 1 Not not RB 37158 540 2 that that IN 37158 540 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 540 4 estimate estimate VBP 37158 540 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 540 6 life life NN 37158 540 7 very very RB 37158 540 8 highly highly RB 37158 540 9 , , , 37158 540 10 but but CC 37158 540 11 after after RB 37158 540 12 all all RB 37158 540 13 , , , 37158 540 14 however however RB 37158 540 15 low low JJ 37158 540 16 an an DT 37158 540 17 estimate estimate NN 37158 540 18 I -PRON- PRP 37158 540 19 may may MD 37158 540 20 place place VB 37158 540 21 on on IN 37158 540 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 540 23 own own JJ 37158 540 24 life life NN 37158 540 25 , , , 37158 540 26 I -PRON- PRP 37158 540 27 think think VBP 37158 540 28 it -PRON- PRP 37158 540 29 is be VBZ 37158 540 30 worth worth JJ 37158 540 31 more more JJR 37158 540 32 than than IN 37158 540 33 that that DT 37158 540 34 of of IN 37158 540 35 a a DT 37158 540 36 fowl fowl NN 37158 540 37 . . . 37158 541 1 Many many JJ 37158 541 2 other other JJ 37158 541 3 medicines medicine NNS 37158 541 4 have have VBP 37158 541 5 been be VBN 37158 541 6 thus thus RB 37158 541 7 experimented experiment VBN 37158 541 8 with with IN 37158 541 9 on on IN 37158 541 10 animals animal NNS 37158 541 11 before before IN 37158 541 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 541 13 was be VBD 37158 541 14 possible possible JJ 37158 541 15 to to TO 37158 541 16 ascertain ascertain VB 37158 541 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 541 18 effects effect NNS 37158 541 19 on on IN 37158 541 20 man man NN 37158 541 21 . . . 37158 542 1 Kocher Kocher NNP 37158 542 2 discovered discover VBD 37158 542 3 cocaine cocaine NN 37158 542 4 , , , 37158 542 5 Knorr Knorr NNP 37158 542 6 antipyrine antipyrine VBP 37158 542 7 ; ; : 37158 542 8 and and CC 37158 542 9 these these DT 37158 542 10 two two CD 37158 542 11 admirable admirable JJ 37158 542 12 medicines medicine NNS 37158 542 13 did do VBD 37158 542 14 not not RB 37158 542 15 find find VB 37158 542 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 542 17 way way NN 37158 542 18 into into IN 37158 542 19 therapeutics therapeutic NNS 37158 542 20 until until IN 37158 542 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 542 22 mode mode NN 37158 542 23 of of IN 37158 542 24 action action NN 37158 542 25 and and CC 37158 542 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 542 27 toxic toxic JJ 37158 542 28 power power NN 37158 542 29 had have VBD 37158 542 30 been be VBN 37158 542 31 ascertained ascertain VBN 37158 542 32 on on IN 37158 542 33 animals animal NNS 37158 542 34 . . . 37158 543 1 In in IN 37158 543 2 a a DT 37158 543 3 word word NN 37158 543 4 , , , 37158 543 5 the the DT 37158 543 6 whole whole NN 37158 543 7 of of IN 37158 543 8 present present JJ 37158 543 9 - - HYPH 37158 543 10 day day NN 37158 543 11 therapeutics therapeutic NNS 37158 543 12 has have VBZ 37158 543 13 for for IN 37158 543 14 foundation foundation NN 37158 543 15 , , , 37158 543 16 not not RB 37158 543 17 only only RB 37158 543 18 ancient ancient JJ 37158 543 19 clinical clinical JJ 37158 543 20 observation observation NN 37158 543 21 , , , 37158 543 22 which which WDT 37158 543 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 543 24 would would MD 37158 543 25 be be VB 37158 543 26 supremely supremely RB 37158 543 27 foolish foolish JJ 37158 543 28 to to TO 37158 543 29 disdain disdain VB 37158 543 30 , , , 37158 543 31 but but CC 37158 543 32 also also RB 37158 543 33 the the DT 37158 543 34 experiments experiment NNS 37158 543 35 of of IN 37158 543 36 modern modern JJ 37158 543 37 times time NNS 37158 543 38 , , , 37158 543 39 which which WDT 37158 543 40 it -PRON- PRP 37158 543 41 would would MD 37158 543 42 be be VB 37158 543 43 equally equally RB 37158 543 44 foolish foolish JJ 37158 543 45 to to TO 37158 543 46 proscribe proscribe VB 37158 543 47 . . . 37158 544 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 37158 544 2 certain certain JJ 37158 544 3 people people NNS 37158 544 4 imagine imagine VBP 37158 544 5 that that IN 37158 544 6 there there EX 37158 544 7 are be VBP 37158 544 8 no no DT 37158 544 9 therapeutics therapeutic NNS 37158 544 10 , , , 37158 544 11 and and CC 37158 544 12 that that IN 37158 544 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 544 14 can can MD 37158 544 15 replace replace VB 37158 544 16 by by IN 37158 544 17 auto auto NN 37158 544 18 - - HYPH 37158 544 19 suggestion suggestion NN 37158 544 20 , , , 37158 544 21 prayer prayer NN 37158 544 22 , , , 37158 544 23 or or CC 37158 544 24 hypnotisation hypnotisation NN 37158 544 25 , , , 37158 544 26 everything everything NN 37158 544 27 which which WDT 37158 544 28 doctors doctor NNS 37158 544 29 generally generally RB 37158 544 30 use use VBP 37158 544 31 to to TO 37158 544 32 cure cure VB 37158 544 33 or or CC 37158 544 34 allay allay VB 37158 544 35 disease disease NN 37158 544 36 . . . 37158 545 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 545 2 is be VBZ 37158 545 3 difficult difficult JJ 37158 545 4 to to TO 37158 545 5 reply reply VB 37158 545 6 to to IN 37158 545 7 such such JJ 37158 545 8 objections objection NNS 37158 545 9 , , , 37158 545 10 because because IN 37158 545 11 those those DT 37158 545 12 who who WP 37158 545 13 make make VBP 37158 545 14 them -PRON- PRP 37158 545 15 have have VB 37158 545 16 never never RB 37158 545 17 opened open VBN 37158 545 18 a a DT 37158 545 19 work work NN 37158 545 20 of of IN 37158 545 21 science science NN 37158 545 22 nor nor CC 37158 545 23 seen see VBN 37158 545 24 a a DT 37158 545 25 patient patient NN 37158 545 26 . . . 37158 546 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 546 2 see see VBP 37158 546 3 things thing NNS 37158 546 4 as as IN 37158 546 5 they -PRON- PRP 37158 546 6 wish wish VBP 37158 546 7 to to TO 37158 546 8 see see VB 37158 546 9 them -PRON- PRP 37158 546 10 . . . 37158 547 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 547 2 imagine imagine VBP 37158 547 3 that that IN 37158 547 4 the the DT 37158 547 5 exterior exterior JJ 37158 547 6 world world NN 37158 547 7 is be VBZ 37158 547 8 constructed construct VBN 37158 547 9 according accord VBG 37158 547 10 to to IN 37158 547 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 547 12 interior interior JJ 37158 547 13 vision vision NN 37158 547 14 , , , 37158 547 15 and and CC 37158 547 16 they -PRON- PRP 37158 547 17 do do VBP 37158 547 18 not not RB 37158 547 19 deign deign VB 37158 547 20 to to TO 37158 547 21 come come VB 37158 547 22 into into IN 37158 547 23 contact contact NN 37158 547 24 with with IN 37158 547 25 reality reality NN 37158 547 26 . . . 37158 548 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 548 2 believe believe VBP 37158 548 3 that that IN 37158 548 4 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 37158 548 5 can can MD 37158 548 6 supply supply VB 37158 548 7 the the DT 37158 548 8 place place NN 37158 548 9 of of IN 37158 548 10 instruction instruction NN 37158 548 11 , , , 37158 548 12 and and CC 37158 548 13 that that IN 37158 548 14 a a DT 37158 548 15 certain certain JJ 37158 548 16 doubtful doubtful JJ 37158 548 17 generosity generosity NN 37158 548 18 can can MD 37158 548 19 replace replace VB 37158 548 20 profound profound JJ 37158 548 21 and and CC 37158 548 22 patient patient JJ 37158 548 23 study study NN 37158 548 24 . . . 37158 549 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 549 2 maintain maintain VBP 37158 549 3 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 549 4 that that DT 37158 549 5 chloral chloral NN 37158 549 6 does do VBZ 37158 549 7 not not RB 37158 549 8 make make VB 37158 549 9 one one CD 37158 549 10 sleep sleep NN 37158 549 11 , , , 37158 549 12 that that DT 37158 549 13 salicylate salicylate NN 37158 549 14 of of IN 37158 549 15 soda soda NN 37158 549 16 does do VBZ 37158 549 17 not not RB 37158 549 18 alleviate alleviate VB 37158 549 19 rheumatic rheumatic JJ 37158 549 20 pains pain NNS 37158 549 21 , , , 37158 549 22 that that DT 37158 549 23 bromide bromide NN 37158 549 24 of of IN 37158 549 25 potassium potassium NN 37158 549 26 does do VBZ 37158 549 27 not not RB 37158 549 28 check check VB 37158 549 29 attacks attack NNS 37158 549 30 of of IN 37158 549 31 epilepsy epilepsy NN 37158 549 32 . . . 37158 550 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 37158 550 2 they -PRON- PRP 37158 550 3 will will MD 37158 550 4 even even RB 37158 550 5 continue continue VB 37158 550 6 to to TO 37158 550 7 say say VB 37158 550 8 so so RB 37158 550 9 for for IN 37158 550 10 a a DT 37158 550 11 long long JJ 37158 550 12 time time NN 37158 550 13 to to TO 37158 550 14 come come VB 37158 550 15 . . . 37158 551 1 Let let VB 37158 551 2 them -PRON- PRP 37158 551 3 talk talk VB 37158 551 4 ; ; : 37158 551 5 progress progress NN 37158 551 6 will will MD 37158 551 7 be be VB 37158 551 8 made make VBN 37158 551 9 without without IN 37158 551 10 them -PRON- PRP 37158 551 11 . . . 37158 552 1 _ _ NNP 37158 552 2 Les Les NNP 37158 552 3 chiens chien VBZ 37158 552 4 aboient aboient JJ 37158 552 5 et et FW 37158 552 6 la la NNP 37158 552 7 caravane caravane NNP 37158 552 8 passe passe NNP 37158 552 9 . . . 37158 552 10 _ _ NNP 37158 552 11 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 37158 552 12 : : : 37158 552 13 [ [ -LRB- 37158 552 14 7 7 LS 37158 552 15 ] ] -RRB- 37158 552 16 See see VB 37158 552 17 footnote footnote NN 37158 552 18 , , , 37158 552 19 p. p. NN 37158 552 20 17 17 CD 37158 552 21 . . . 37158 553 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 553 2 8 8 LS 37158 553 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 553 4 These these DT 37158 553 5 statistics statistic NNS 37158 553 6 can can MD 37158 553 7 be be VB 37158 553 8 found find VBN 37158 553 9 in in IN 37158 553 10 all all DT 37158 553 11 technical technical JJ 37158 553 12 works work NNS 37158 553 13 ; ; : 37158 553 14 and and CC 37158 553 15 I -PRON- PRP 37158 553 16 refer refer VBP 37158 553 17 those those DT 37158 553 18 who who WP 37158 553 19 may may MD 37158 553 20 be be VB 37158 553 21 curious curious JJ 37158 553 22 to to TO 37158 553 23 study study VB 37158 553 24 them -PRON- PRP 37158 553 25 in in IN 37158 553 26 detail detail NN 37158 553 27 to to IN 37158 553 28 the the DT 37158 553 29 special special JJ 37158 553 30 memoirs memoir NNS 37158 553 31 and and CC 37158 553 32 excellent excellent JJ 37158 553 33 treatises treatise NNS 37158 553 34 on on IN 37158 553 35 pathology pathology NN 37158 553 36 which which WDT 37158 553 37 have have VBP 37158 553 38 been be VBN 37158 553 39 published publish VBN 37158 553 40 in in IN 37158 553 41 England England NNP 37158 553 42 , , , 37158 553 43 France France NNP 37158 553 44 , , , 37158 553 45 and and CC 37158 553 46 Germany Germany NNP 37158 553 47 . . . 37158 554 1 See see VB 37158 554 2 also also RB 37158 554 3 appendix appendix NNP 37158 554 4 . . . 37158 555 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 555 2 V V NNP 37158 555 3 SERVICES services NN 37158 555 4 RENDERED rendered NN 37158 555 5 TO to IN 37158 555 6 SCIENCE science NN 37158 555 7 AND and CC 37158 555 8 HUMANITY humanity VB 37158 555 9 BY by IN 37158 555 10 EXPERIMENTAL experimental NN 37158 555 11 PHYSIOLOGY PHYSIOLOGY NNS 37158 555 12 I -PRON- PRP 37158 555 13 now now RB 37158 555 14 come come VBP 37158 555 15 to to IN 37158 555 16 a a DT 37158 555 17 favourite favourite JJ 37158 555 18 theme theme NN 37158 555 19 of of IN 37158 555 20 anti anti JJ 37158 555 21 - - NNS 37158 555 22 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 555 23 , , , 37158 555 24 viz viz NNP 37158 555 25 . . NNP 37158 555 26 , , , 37158 555 27 that that IN 37158 555 28 experimental experimental JJ 37158 555 29 physiology physiology NN 37158 555 30 has have VBZ 37158 555 31 produced produce VBN 37158 555 32 nothing nothing NN 37158 555 33 , , , 37158 555 34 and and CC 37158 555 35 that that IN 37158 555 36 the the DT 37158 555 37 differences difference NNS 37158 555 38 of of IN 37158 555 39 opinion opinion NN 37158 555 40 among among IN 37158 555 41 _ _ NNP 37158 555 42 savants savant NNS 37158 555 43 _ _ NNP 37158 555 44 are be VBP 37158 555 45 so so RB 37158 555 46 considerable considerable JJ 37158 555 47 that that IN 37158 555 48 this this DT 37158 555 49 alone alone RB 37158 555 50 proves prove VBZ 37158 555 51 the the DT 37158 555 52 impossibility impossibility NN 37158 555 53 of of IN 37158 555 54 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 555 55 ever ever RB 37158 555 56 establishing establish VBG 37158 555 57 anything anything NN 37158 555 58 permanent permanent JJ 37158 555 59 . . . 37158 556 1 Here here RB 37158 556 2 again again RB 37158 556 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 556 4 is be VBZ 37158 556 5 difficult difficult JJ 37158 556 6 to to TO 37158 556 7 reply reply VB 37158 556 8 because because IN 37158 556 9 of of IN 37158 556 10 the the DT 37158 556 11 very very JJ 37158 556 12 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 556 13 of of IN 37158 556 14 the the DT 37158 556 15 honourable honourable JJ 37158 556 16 gentlemen gentleman NNS 37158 556 17 who who WP 37158 556 18 criticise criticise VBP 37158 556 19 us -PRON- PRP 37158 556 20 . . . 37158 557 1 Most most RBS 37158 557 2 certainly certainly RB 37158 557 3 there there EX 37158 557 4 still still RB 37158 557 5 remain remain VBP 37158 557 6 many many JJ 37158 557 7 disputed disputed JJ 37158 557 8 and and CC 37158 557 9 disputable disputable JJ 37158 557 10 points point NNS 37158 557 11 in in IN 37158 557 12 physiology physiology NN 37158 557 13 , , , 37158 557 14 and and CC 37158 557 15 nothing nothing NN 37158 557 16 is be VBZ 37158 557 17 easier easy JJR 37158 557 18 than than IN 37158 557 19 to to TO 37158 557 20 find find VB 37158 557 21 therein therein RB 37158 557 22 striking striking JJ 37158 557 23 and and CC 37158 557 24 abundant abundant JJ 37158 557 25 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 557 26 . . . 37158 558 1 If if IN 37158 558 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 558 3 wished wish VBD 37158 558 4 to to TO 37158 558 5 amuse amuse VB 37158 558 6 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 558 7 , , , 37158 558 8 we -PRON- PRP 37158 558 9 might may MD 37158 558 10 write write VB 37158 558 11 five five CD 37158 558 12 or or CC 37158 558 13 six six CD 37158 558 14 big big JJ 37158 558 15 volumes volume NNS 37158 558 16 on on IN 37158 558 17 the the DT 37158 558 18 subject subject NN 37158 558 19 ; ; : 37158 558 20 but but CC 37158 558 21 let let VB 37158 558 22 us -PRON- PRP 37158 558 23 leave leave VB 37158 558 24 this this DT 37158 558 25 tedious tedious JJ 37158 558 26 and and CC 37158 558 27 useless useless JJ 37158 558 28 labour labour NN 37158 558 29 to to IN 37158 558 30 the the DT 37158 558 31 anti anti NNS 37158 558 32 - - NNS 37158 558 33 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 558 34 to to TO 37158 558 35 accomplish accomplish VB 37158 558 36 to to IN 37158 558 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 558 38 hearts heart NNS 37158 558 39 ' ' POS 37158 558 40 content content NN 37158 558 41 . . . 37158 559 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 559 2 prefer prefer VBP 37158 559 3 to to TO 37158 559 4 tell tell VB 37158 559 5 them -PRON- PRP 37158 559 6 , , , 37158 559 7 what what WP 37158 559 8 they -PRON- PRP 37158 559 9 do do VBP 37158 559 10 not not RB 37158 559 11 wish wish VB 37158 559 12 to to TO 37158 559 13 know know VB 37158 559 14 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 559 15 , , , 37158 559 16 that that IN 37158 559 17 contradiction contradiction NN 37158 559 18 is be VBZ 37158 559 19 the the DT 37158 559 20 very very JJ 37158 559 21 essence essence NN 37158 559 22 of of IN 37158 559 23 science science NN 37158 559 24 . . . 37158 560 1 As as IN 37158 560 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 560 3 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37158 560 4 appeal appeal VBP 37158 560 5 not not RB 37158 560 6 to to IN 37158 560 7 faith faith NN 37158 560 8 but but CC 37158 560 9 to to IN 37158 560 10 reason reason NN 37158 560 11 ; ; : 37158 560 12 as as IN 37158 560 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 560 14 admit admit VBP 37158 560 15 free free JJ 37158 560 16 discussion discussion NN 37158 560 17 , , , 37158 560 18 free free JJ 37158 560 19 investigation investigation NN 37158 560 20 from from IN 37158 560 21 every every DT 37158 560 22 side side NN 37158 560 23 ; ; : 37158 560 24 any any DT 37158 560 25 proposition proposition NN 37158 560 26 must must MD 37158 560 27 have have VB 37158 560 28 multitudinous multitudinous JJ 37158 560 29 and and CC 37158 560 30 positive positive JJ 37158 560 31 proofs proof NNS 37158 560 32 in in IN 37158 560 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 560 34 favour favour NN 37158 560 35 before before IN 37158 560 36 it -PRON- PRP 37158 560 37 can can MD 37158 560 38 be be VB 37158 560 39 adopted adopt VBN 37158 560 40 without without IN 37158 560 41 hesitation hesitation NN 37158 560 42 . . . 37158 561 1 Even even RB 37158 561 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 561 3 opinions opinion NNS 37158 561 4 were be VBD 37158 561 5 never never RB 37158 561 6 prescribed prescribe VBN 37158 561 7 by by IN 37158 561 8 faith faith NN 37158 561 9 or or CC 37158 561 10 violence violence NN 37158 561 11 ; ; : 37158 561 12 we -PRON- PRP 37158 561 13 take take VBP 37158 561 14 pleasure pleasure NN 37158 561 15 in in IN 37158 561 16 provoking provoke VBG 37158 561 17 discussion discussion NN 37158 561 18 and and CC 37158 561 19 contradiction contradiction NN 37158 561 20 . . . 37158 562 1 With with IN 37158 562 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 562 3 adversaries adversary NNS 37158 562 4 ' ' POS 37158 562 5 leave leave VB 37158 562 6 be be VB 37158 562 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 562 8 said say VBN 37158 562 9 that that IN 37158 562 10 a a DT 37158 562 11 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37158 562 12 , , , 37158 562 13 irreproachable irreproachable JJ 37158 562 14 book book NN 37158 562 15 , , , 37158 562 16 where where WRB 37158 562 17 there there EX 37158 562 18 was be VBD 37158 562 19 no no DT 37158 562 20 place place NN 37158 562 21 for for IN 37158 562 22 hesitation hesitation NN 37158 562 23 or or CC 37158 562 24 doubt doubt NN 37158 562 25 , , , 37158 562 26 would would MD 37158 562 27 be be VB 37158 562 28 the the DT 37158 562 29 very very JJ 37158 562 30 negation negation NN 37158 562 31 of of IN 37158 562 32 science science NN 37158 562 33 . . . 37158 563 1 Even even RB 37158 563 2 the the DT 37158 563 3 treatises treatise NNS 37158 563 4 of of IN 37158 563 5 geometry geometry NN 37158 563 6 and and CC 37158 563 7 mechanics mechanic NNS 37158 563 8 , , , 37158 563 9 although although IN 37158 563 10 non non JJ 37158 563 11 - - JJ 37158 563 12 experimental experimental JJ 37158 563 13 , , , 37158 563 14 rational rational JJ 37158 563 15 sciences science NNS 37158 563 16 , , , 37158 563 17 sometimes sometimes RB 37158 563 18 contradict contradict VBP 37158 563 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 563 20 . . . 37158 564 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 564 2 has have VBZ 37158 564 3 been be VBN 37158 564 4 rightly rightly RB 37158 564 5 said say VBN 37158 564 6 that that IN 37158 564 7 the the DT 37158 564 8 history history NN 37158 564 9 of of IN 37158 564 10 science science NN 37158 564 11 is be VBZ 37158 564 12 the the DT 37158 564 13 history history NN 37158 564 14 of of IN 37158 564 15 human human JJ 37158 564 16 errors error NNS 37158 564 17 -- -- : 37158 564 18 errors error NNS 37158 564 19 which which WDT 37158 564 20 , , , 37158 564 21 little little JJ 37158 564 22 by by IN 37158 564 23 little little JJ 37158 564 24 , , , 37158 564 25 draw draw VB 37158 564 26 nearer nearer NN 37158 564 27 and and CC 37158 564 28 nearer near RBR 37158 564 29 to to IN 37158 564 30 supreme supreme NNP 37158 564 31 truth truth NNP 37158 564 32 without without IN 37158 564 33 ever ever RB 37158 564 34 attaining attain VBG 37158 564 35 it -PRON- PRP 37158 564 36 . . . 37158 565 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 565 2 must must MD 37158 565 3 understand understand VB 37158 565 4 this this DT 37158 565 5 , , , 37158 565 6 or or CC 37158 565 7 we -PRON- PRP 37158 565 8 shall shall MD 37158 565 9 be be VB 37158 565 10 rebelling rebel VBG 37158 565 11 against against IN 37158 565 12 the the DT 37158 565 13 conception conception NN 37158 565 14 of of IN 37158 565 15 scientific scientific JJ 37158 565 16 truth truth NN 37158 565 17 . . . 37158 566 1 Now now RB 37158 566 2 , , , 37158 566 3 in in IN 37158 566 4 treatises treatise NNS 37158 566 5 on on IN 37158 566 6 physiology physiology NN 37158 566 7 , , , 37158 566 8 we -PRON- PRP 37158 566 9 find find VBP 37158 566 10 a a DT 37158 566 11 number number NN 37158 566 12 of of IN 37158 566 13 well well RB 37158 566 14 - - HYPH 37158 566 15 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37158 566 16 truths truth NNS 37158 566 17 , , , 37158 566 18 and and CC 37158 566 19 a a DT 37158 566 20 still still RB 37158 566 21 larger large JJR 37158 566 22 number number NN 37158 566 23 of of IN 37158 566 24 truths truth NNS 37158 566 25 only only RB 37158 566 26 half half PDT 37158 566 27 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 37158 566 28 , , , 37158 566 29 and and CC 37158 566 30 , , , 37158 566 31 consequently consequently RB 37158 566 32 , , , 37158 566 33 contested contest VBN 37158 566 34 . . . 37158 567 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 567 2 successors successor NNS 37158 567 3 will will MD 37158 567 4 also also RB 37158 567 5 certainly certainly RB 37158 567 6 find find VB 37158 567 7 in in IN 37158 567 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 567 9 books book NNS 37158 567 10 of of IN 37158 567 11 to to IN 37158 567 12 - - HYPH 37158 567 13 day day NN 37158 567 14 an an DT 37158 567 15 enormous enormous JJ 37158 567 16 number number NN 37158 567 17 of of IN 37158 567 18 errors error NNS 37158 567 19 . . . 37158 568 1 What what WDT 37158 568 2 conclusion conclusion NN 37158 568 3 is be VBZ 37158 568 4 to to TO 37158 568 5 be be VB 37158 568 6 drawn draw VBN 37158 568 7 from from IN 37158 568 8 this this DT 37158 568 9 fact fact NN 37158 568 10 ? ? . 37158 569 1 Have have VBP 37158 569 2 those those DT 37158 569 3 who who WP 37158 569 4 reproach reproach VBP 37158 569 5 the the DT 37158 569 6 science science NN 37158 569 7 of of IN 37158 569 8 physiology physiology NN 37158 569 9 with with IN 37158 569 10 being be VBG 37158 569 11 only only RB 37158 569 12 a a DT 37158 569 13 tissue tissue NN 37158 569 14 of of IN 37158 569 15 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 569 16 and and CC 37158 569 17 errors error NNS 37158 569 18 ever ever RB 37158 569 19 opened open VBD 37158 569 20 a a DT 37158 569 21 book book NN 37158 569 22 on on IN 37158 569 23 physiology physiology NN 37158 569 24 ( ( -LRB- 37158 569 25 for for IN 37158 569 26 example example NN 37158 569 27 , , , 37158 569 28 the the DT 37158 569 29 text text NN 37158 569 30 - - HYPH 37158 569 31 book book NN 37158 569 32 of of IN 37158 569 33 Schaefer Schaefer NNP 37158 569 34 , , , 37158 569 35 in in IN 37158 569 36 two two CD 37158 569 37 large large JJ 37158 569 38 , , , 37158 569 39 compact compact JJ 37158 569 40 , , , 37158 569 41 closely closely RB 37158 569 42 written write VBN 37158 569 43 volumes volume NNS 37158 569 44 of of IN 37158 569 45 1000 1000 CD 37158 569 46 pages page NNS 37158 569 47 each each DT 37158 569 48 ) ) -RRB- 37158 569 49 ? ? . 37158 570 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 570 2 would would MD 37158 570 3 there there RB 37158 570 4 find find VB 37158 570 5 thousands thousand NNS 37158 570 6 of of IN 37158 570 7 positive positive JJ 37158 570 8 , , , 37158 570 9 incontestable incontestable JJ 37158 570 10 facts fact NNS 37158 570 11 on on IN 37158 570 12 all all PDT 37158 570 13 the the DT 37158 570 14 questions question NNS 37158 570 15 which which WDT 37158 570 16 concern concern NN 37158 570 17 physiology physiology NN 37158 570 18 . . . 37158 571 1 Let let VB 37158 571 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 571 3 take take VB 37158 571 4 , , , 37158 571 5 each each DT 37158 571 6 in in IN 37158 571 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 571 8 turn turn NN 37158 571 9 , , , 37158 571 10 the the DT 37158 571 11 great great JJ 37158 571 12 functions function NNS 37158 571 13 of of IN 37158 571 14 life life NN 37158 571 15 , , , 37158 571 16 and and CC 37158 571 17 we -PRON- PRP 37158 571 18 shall shall MD 37158 571 19 see see VB 37158 571 20 that that IN 37158 571 21 they -PRON- PRP 37158 571 22 have have VBP 37158 571 23 become become VBN 37158 571 24 known know VBN 37158 571 25 only only RB 37158 571 26 by by IN 37158 571 27 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 571 28 . . . 37158 572 1 1 1 LS 37158 572 2 . . . 37158 573 1 _ _ NNP 37158 573 2 The the DT 37158 573 3 Circulation Circulation NNP 37158 573 4 of of IN 37158 573 5 the the DT 37158 573 6 Blood Blood NNP 37158 573 7 _ _ NNP 37158 573 8 , , , 37158 573 9 suspected suspect VBN 37158 573 10 by by IN 37158 573 11 Michel Michel NNP 37158 573 12 Servet Servet NNP 37158 573 13 , , , 37158 573 14 Realdo Realdo NNP 37158 573 15 Colombo Colombo NNP 37158 573 16 , , , 37158 573 17 and and CC 37158 573 18 Andreas Andreas NNP 37158 573 19 Cesalpin Cesalpin NNP 37158 573 20 , , , 37158 573 21 was be VBD 37158 573 22 really really RB 37158 573 23 established establish VBN 37158 573 24 by by IN 37158 573 25 Harvey Harvey NNP 37158 573 26 in in IN 37158 573 27 1628 1628 CD 37158 573 28 . . . 37158 574 1 Yet yet CC 37158 574 2 Harvey Harvey NNP 37158 574 3 was be VBD 37158 574 4 only only RB 37158 574 5 able able JJ 37158 574 6 to to TO 37158 574 7 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37158 574 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 574 9 by by IN 37158 574 10 experiments experiment NNS 37158 574 11 performed perform VBN 37158 574 12 on on IN 37158 574 13 the the DT 37158 574 14 living live VBG 37158 574 15 bodies body NNS 37158 574 16 of of IN 37158 574 17 frogs frog NNS 37158 574 18 and and CC 37158 574 19 deer deer NN 37158 574 20 . . . 37158 575 1 Since since IN 37158 575 2 Harvey Harvey NNP 37158 575 3 's 's POS 37158 575 4 time time NN 37158 575 5 , , , 37158 575 6 the the DT 37158 575 7 laws law NNS 37158 575 8 of of IN 37158 575 9 the the DT 37158 575 10 circulation circulation NN 37158 575 11 have have VBP 37158 575 12 been be VBN 37158 575 13 established establish VBN 37158 575 14 with with IN 37158 575 15 admirable admirable JJ 37158 575 16 precision precision NN 37158 575 17 . . . 37158 576 1 Hales hale NNS 37158 576 2 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 37158 576 3 the the DT 37158 576 4 pressure pressure NN 37158 576 5 of of IN 37158 576 6 blood blood NN 37158 576 7 in in IN 37158 576 8 the the DT 37158 576 9 vessels vessel NNS 37158 576 10 . . . 37158 577 1 Chauveau Chauveau NNP 37158 577 2 and and CC 37158 577 3 Marey Marey NNP 37158 577 4 introduced introduce VBD 37158 577 5 into into IN 37158 577 6 the the DT 37158 577 7 heart heart NN 37158 577 8 of of IN 37158 577 9 a a DT 37158 577 10 horse horse NN 37158 577 11 an an DT 37158 577 12 apparatus apparatus NN 37158 577 13 which which WDT 37158 577 14 enabled enable VBD 37158 577 15 the the DT 37158 577 16 pressure pressure NN 37158 577 17 of of IN 37158 577 18 the the DT 37158 577 19 blood blood NN 37158 577 20 in in IN 37158 577 21 the the DT 37158 577 22 heart heart NN 37158 577 23 , , , 37158 577 24 in in IN 37158 577 25 the the DT 37158 577 26 arteries artery NNS 37158 577 27 , , , 37158 577 28 and and CC 37158 577 29 in in IN 37158 577 30 the the DT 37158 577 31 veins vein NNS 37158 577 32 , , , 37158 577 33 to to TO 37158 577 34 be be VB 37158 577 35 measured measure VBN 37158 577 36 . . . 37158 578 1 Weber Weber NNP 37158 578 2 found find VBD 37158 578 3 that that IN 37158 578 4 the the DT 37158 578 5 pneumogastric pneumogastric JJ 37158 578 6 nerve nerve NN 37158 578 7 stopped stop VBD 37158 578 8 the the DT 37158 578 9 heart heart NN 37158 578 10 's 's POS 37158 578 11 action action NN 37158 578 12 . . . 37158 579 1 Ludwig Ludwig NNP 37158 579 2 applied apply VBD 37158 579 3 the the DT 37158 579 4 graphic graphic JJ 37158 579 5 method method NN 37158 579 6 to to IN 37158 579 7 the the DT 37158 579 8 circulation circulation NN 37158 579 9 . . . 37158 580 1 Delicate delicate JJ 37158 580 2 instruments instrument NNS 37158 580 3 have have VBP 37158 580 4 been be VBN 37158 580 5 constructed construct VBN 37158 580 6 which which WDT 37158 580 7 give give VBP 37158 580 8 diagrams diagram NNS 37158 580 9 of of IN 37158 580 10 the the DT 37158 580 11 pulsations pulsation NNS 37158 580 12 and and CC 37158 580 13 measure measure VB 37158 580 14 the the DT 37158 580 15 pressure pressure NN 37158 580 16 of of IN 37158 580 17 the the DT 37158 580 18 blood blood NN 37158 580 19 in in IN 37158 580 20 the the DT 37158 580 21 arteries artery NNS 37158 580 22 and and CC 37158 580 23 in in IN 37158 580 24 the the DT 37158 580 25 heart heart NN 37158 580 26 of of IN 37158 580 27 man man NN 37158 580 28 . . . 37158 581 1 Claude Claude NNP 37158 581 2 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 581 3 discovered discover VBD 37158 581 4 the the DT 37158 581 5 nerves nerve NNS 37158 581 6 which which WDT 37158 581 7 regulate regulate VBP 37158 581 8 the the DT 37158 581 9 movements movement NNS 37158 581 10 of of IN 37158 581 11 the the DT 37158 581 12 vessel vessel NN 37158 581 13 walls wall NNS 37158 581 14 . . . 37158 582 1 In in IN 37158 582 2 short short JJ 37158 582 3 , , , 37158 582 4 the the DT 37158 582 5 whole whole JJ 37158 582 6 history history NN 37158 582 7 of of IN 37158 582 8 the the DT 37158 582 9 circulation circulation NN 37158 582 10 is be VBZ 37158 582 11 due due JJ 37158 582 12 solely solely RB 37158 582 13 to to IN 37158 582 14 vivisections vivisection NNS 37158 582 15 , , , 37158 582 16 and and CC 37158 582 17 it -PRON- PRP 37158 582 18 would would MD 37158 582 19 be be VB 37158 582 20 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 37158 582 21 to to TO 37158 582 22 speak speak VB 37158 582 23 of of IN 37158 582 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 582 25 uncertainties uncertainty NNS 37158 582 26 in in IN 37158 582 27 this this DT 37158 582 28 respect respect NN 37158 582 29 ; ; : 37158 582 30 for for IN 37158 582 31 the the DT 37158 582 32 essential essential JJ 37158 582 33 mechanical mechanical JJ 37158 582 34 or or CC 37158 582 35 nervous nervous JJ 37158 582 36 laws law NNS 37158 582 37 of of IN 37158 582 38 the the DT 37158 582 39 circulation circulation NN 37158 582 40 are be VBP 37158 582 41 as as RB 37158 582 42 well well RB 37158 582 43 known known JJ 37158 582 44 now now RB 37158 582 45 as as IN 37158 582 46 those those DT 37158 582 47 of of IN 37158 582 48 the the DT 37158 582 49 combinations combination NNS 37158 582 50 of of IN 37158 582 51 nitrogen nitrogen NN 37158 582 52 with with IN 37158 582 53 oxygen oxygen NN 37158 582 54 . . . 37158 583 1 2 2 LS 37158 583 2 . . . 37158 584 1 _ _ NNP 37158 584 2 The the DT 37158 584 3 Respiration Respiration NNP 37158 584 4 _ _ NNP 37158 584 5 remained remain VBD 37158 584 6 profoundly profoundly RB 37158 584 7 unknown unknown JJ 37158 584 8 , , , 37158 584 9 as as IN 37158 584 10 to to IN 37158 584 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 584 12 inmost inmost JJ 37158 584 13 nature nature NN 37158 584 14 , , , 37158 584 15 right right RB 37158 584 16 up up IN 37158 584 17 to to IN 37158 584 18 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 37158 584 19 's 's POS 37158 584 20 time time NN 37158 584 21 . . . 37158 585 1 Lavoisier lavoisier NN 37158 585 2 placed place VBD 37158 585 3 some some DT 37158 585 4 guinea guinea NN 37158 585 5 - - HYPH 37158 585 6 pigs pig NNS 37158 585 7 in in IN 37158 585 8 a a DT 37158 585 9 box box NN 37158 585 10 filled fill VBN 37158 585 11 with with IN 37158 585 12 ice ice NN 37158 585 13 , , , 37158 585 14 measured measure VBD 37158 585 15 the the DT 37158 585 16 quantity quantity NN 37158 585 17 of of IN 37158 585 18 heat heat NN 37158 585 19 thrown throw VBN 37158 585 20 off off RP 37158 585 21 , , , 37158 585 22 the the DT 37158 585 23 quantity quantity NN 37158 585 24 of of IN 37158 585 25 oxygen oxygen NN 37158 585 26 consumed consume VBN 37158 585 27 , , , 37158 585 28 the the DT 37158 585 29 quantity quantity NN 37158 585 30 of of IN 37158 585 31 carbonic carbonic JJ 37158 585 32 acid acid NN 37158 585 33 produced produce VBN 37158 585 34 ; ; : 37158 585 35 and and CC 37158 585 36 he -PRON- PRP 37158 585 37 was be VBD 37158 585 38 thus thus RB 37158 585 39 able able JJ 37158 585 40 to to TO 37158 585 41 deduce deduce VB 37158 585 42 a a DT 37158 585 43 fundamental fundamental JJ 37158 585 44 law law NN 37158 585 45 of of IN 37158 585 46 life life NN 37158 585 47 , , , 37158 585 48 viz viz NNP 37158 585 49 . . NNP 37158 585 50 , , , 37158 585 51 that that DT 37158 585 52 life life NN 37158 585 53 is be VBZ 37158 585 54 essentially essentially RB 37158 585 55 combustion combustion NN 37158 585 56 . . . 37158 586 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 586 2 made make VBD 37158 586 3 experiments experiment NNS 37158 586 4 on on IN 37158 586 5 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 586 6 also also RB 37158 586 7 ; ; : 37158 586 8 but but CC 37158 586 9 however however RB 37158 586 10 great great JJ 37158 586 11 one one PRP 37158 586 12 's 's POS 37158 586 13 respect respect NN 37158 586 14 for for IN 37158 586 15 the the DT 37158 586 16 life life NN 37158 586 17 of of IN 37158 586 18 a a DT 37158 586 19 guinea guinea NN 37158 586 20 - - HYPH 37158 586 21 pig pig NN 37158 586 22 may may MD 37158 586 23 be be VB 37158 586 24 , , , 37158 586 25 must must MD 37158 586 26 it -PRON- PRP 37158 586 27 be be VB 37158 586 28 considered consider VBN 37158 586 29 wrong wrong JJ 37158 586 30 that that IN 37158 586 31 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 37158 586 32 should should MD 37158 586 33 have have VB 37158 586 34 experimented experiment VBN 37158 586 35 on on IN 37158 586 36 the the DT 37158 586 37 guinea guinea NN 37158 586 38 - - HYPH 37158 586 39 pig pig NN 37158 586 40 before before IN 37158 586 41 experimenting experiment VBG 37158 586 42 on on IN 37158 586 43 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 586 44 ? ? . 37158 587 1 As as IN 37158 587 2 for for IN 37158 587 3 the the DT 37158 587 4 laws law NNS 37158 587 5 which which WDT 37158 587 6 regulate regulate VBP 37158 587 7 this this DT 37158 587 8 consumption consumption NN 37158 587 9 of of IN 37158 587 10 oxygen oxygen NN 37158 587 11 and and CC 37158 587 12 this this DT 37158 587 13 production production NN 37158 587 14 of of IN 37158 587 15 carbonic carbonic JJ 37158 587 16 acid acid NN 37158 587 17 , , , 37158 587 18 to to TO 37158 587 19 discover discover VB 37158 587 20 these these DT 37158 587 21 it -PRON- PRP 37158 587 22 was be VBD 37158 587 23 necessary necessary JJ 37158 587 24 to to TO 37158 587 25 put put VB 37158 587 26 into into IN 37158 587 27 cages cage NNS 37158 587 28 animals animal NNS 37158 587 29 of of IN 37158 587 30 every every DT 37158 587 31 species specie NNS 37158 587 32 and and CC 37158 587 33 of of IN 37158 587 34 every every DT 37158 587 35 size size NN 37158 587 36 . . . 37158 588 1 And and CC 37158 588 2 there there EX 37158 588 3 is be VBZ 37158 588 4 , , , 37158 588 5 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 588 6 , , , 37158 588 7 not not RB 37158 588 8 a a DT 37158 588 9 single single JJ 37158 588 10 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 588 11 who who WP 37158 588 12 has have VBZ 37158 588 13 not not RB 37158 588 14 made make VBN 37158 588 15 this this DT 37158 588 16 experiment experiment NN 37158 588 17 , , , 37158 588 18 at at IN 37158 588 19 the the DT 37158 588 20 risk risk NN 37158 588 21 of of IN 37158 588 22 annoying annoy VBG 37158 588 23 the the DT 37158 588 24 cats cat NNS 37158 588 25 and and CC 37158 588 26 dogs dog NNS 37158 588 27 thus thus RB 37158 588 28 exposed expose VBN 37158 588 29 -- -- : 37158 588 30 without without IN 37158 588 31 , , , 37158 588 32 as as RB 37158 588 33 far far RB 37158 588 34 as as IN 37158 588 35 that that DT 37158 588 36 goes go VBZ 37158 588 37 , , , 37158 588 38 doing do VBG 37158 588 39 them -PRON- PRP 37158 588 40 any any DT 37158 588 41 harm harm NN 37158 588 42 -- -- : 37158 588 43 to to IN 37158 588 44 varied varied JJ 37158 588 45 temperatures temperature NNS 37158 588 46 or or CC 37158 588 47 to to IN 37158 588 48 different different JJ 37158 588 49 diets diet NNS 37158 588 50 . . . 37158 589 1 Moreover moreover RB 37158 589 2 , , , 37158 589 3 in in IN 37158 589 4 order order NN 37158 589 5 to to TO 37158 589 6 study study VB 37158 589 7 the the DT 37158 589 8 respiratory respiratory JJ 37158 589 9 exchanges exchange NNS 37158 589 10 , , , 37158 589 11 physiologists physiologist VBZ 37158 589 12 experiment experiment NN 37158 589 13 on on IN 37158 589 14 man man NN 37158 589 15 as as RB 37158 589 16 well well RB 37158 589 17 ; ; : 37158 589 18 is be VBZ 37158 589 19 , , , 37158 589 20 therefore therefore RB 37158 589 21 , , , 37158 589 22 the the DT 37158 589 23 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37158 589 24 scruple scruple NN 37158 589 25 against against IN 37158 589 26 experimenting experiment VBG 37158 589 27 on on IN 37158 589 28 animals animal NNS 37158 589 29 to to TO 37158 589 30 be be VB 37158 589 31 imposed impose VBN 37158 589 32 upon upon IN 37158 589 33 them -PRON- PRP 37158 589 34 also also RB 37158 589 35 ? ? . 37158 590 1 To to TO 37158 590 2 take take VB 37158 590 3 an an DT 37158 590 4 excellent excellent JJ 37158 590 5 example example NN 37158 590 6 of of IN 37158 590 7 the the DT 37158 590 8 services service NNS 37158 590 9 which which WDT 37158 590 10 experimental experimental JJ 37158 590 11 physiology physiology NN 37158 590 12 can can MD 37158 590 13 render render VB 37158 590 14 not not RB 37158 590 15 to to TO 37158 590 16 science science VB 37158 590 17 only only RB 37158 590 18 -- -- : 37158 590 19 which which WDT 37158 590 20 would would MD 37158 590 21 , , , 37158 590 22 indeed indeed RB 37158 590 23 , , , 37158 590 24 be be VB 37158 590 25 quite quite RB 37158 590 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 590 27 to to TO 37158 590 28 justify justify VB 37158 590 29 them -PRON- PRP 37158 590 30 -- -- : 37158 590 31 but but CC 37158 590 32 to to IN 37158 590 33 humanity humanity NN 37158 590 34 , , , 37158 590 35 I -PRON- PRP 37158 590 36 will will MD 37158 590 37 cite cite VB 37158 590 38 the the DT 37158 590 39 experiments experiment NNS 37158 590 40 of of IN 37158 590 41 Paul Paul NNP 37158 590 42 Bert Bert NNP 37158 590 43 with with IN 37158 590 44 relation relation NN 37158 590 45 to to IN 37158 590 46 elevated elevated JJ 37158 590 47 atmospheric atmospheric JJ 37158 590 48 pressures pressure NNS 37158 590 49 . . . 37158 591 1 There there EX 37158 591 2 are be VBP 37158 591 3 certain certain JJ 37158 591 4 workmen workman NNS 37158 591 5 who who WP 37158 591 6 are be VBP 37158 591 7 obliged oblige VBN 37158 591 8 to to TO 37158 591 9 work work VB 37158 591 10 under under IN 37158 591 11 water water NN 37158 591 12 , , , 37158 591 13 at at IN 37158 591 14 a a DT 37158 591 15 depth depth NN 37158 591 16 of of IN 37158 591 17 20 20 CD 37158 591 18 to to TO 37158 591 19 30 30 CD 37158 591 20 yards yard NNS 37158 591 21 , , , 37158 591 22 for for IN 37158 591 23 the the DT 37158 591 24 construction construction NN 37158 591 25 of of IN 37158 591 26 piers pier NNS 37158 591 27 and and CC 37158 591 28 bridges bridge NNS 37158 591 29 , , , 37158 591 30 or or CC 37158 591 31 the the DT 37158 591 32 exploration exploration NN 37158 591 33 of of IN 37158 591 34 sunken sunken JJ 37158 591 35 vessels vessel NNS 37158 591 36 . . . 37158 592 1 Now now RB 37158 592 2 , , , 37158 592 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 592 4 had have VBD 37158 592 5 long long RB 37158 592 6 been be VBN 37158 592 7 observed observe VBN 37158 592 8 that that IN 37158 592 9 some some DT 37158 592 10 of of IN 37158 592 11 these these DT 37158 592 12 men man NNS 37158 592 13 died die VBD 37158 592 14 suddenly suddenly RB 37158 592 15 on on IN 37158 592 16 returning return VBG 37158 592 17 to to IN 37158 592 18 the the DT 37158 592 19 surface surface NN 37158 592 20 . . . 37158 593 1 Experimental experimental JJ 37158 593 2 physiology physiology NN 37158 593 3 was be VBD 37158 593 4 able able JJ 37158 593 5 to to TO 37158 593 6 discover discover VB 37158 593 7 the the DT 37158 593 8 cause cause NN 37158 593 9 of of IN 37158 593 10 that that DT 37158 593 11 sudden sudden JJ 37158 593 12 death death NN 37158 593 13 . . . 37158 594 1 When when WRB 37158 594 2 a a DT 37158 594 3 man man NN 37158 594 4 ( ( -LRB- 37158 594 5 or or CC 37158 594 6 an an DT 37158 594 7 animal animal NN 37158 594 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 594 9 , , , 37158 594 10 after after IN 37158 594 11 having have VBG 37158 594 12 been be VBN 37158 594 13 subjected subject VBN 37158 594 14 to to IN 37158 594 15 several several JJ 37158 594 16 times time NNS 37158 594 17 the the DT 37158 594 18 normal normal JJ 37158 594 19 atmospheric atmospheric JJ 37158 594 20 pressure pressure NN 37158 594 21 , , , 37158 594 22 is be VBZ 37158 594 23 suddenly suddenly RB 37158 594 24 released release VBN 37158 594 25 from from IN 37158 594 26 this this DT 37158 594 27 pressure pressure NN 37158 594 28 , , , 37158 594 29 the the DT 37158 594 30 nitrogen nitrogen NN 37158 594 31 dissolved dissolve VBN 37158 594 32 in in IN 37158 594 33 the the DT 37158 594 34 blood blood NN 37158 594 35 is be VBZ 37158 594 36 disengaged disengage VBN 37158 594 37 suddenly suddenly RB 37158 594 38 : : : 37158 594 39 this this DT 37158 594 40 produces produce VBZ 37158 594 41 gaseous gaseous JJ 37158 594 42 embolism embolism NN 37158 594 43 , , , 37158 594 44 that that DT 37158 594 45 is be VBZ 37158 594 46 to to TO 37158 594 47 say say VB 37158 594 48 , , , 37158 594 49 bubbles bubble NNS 37158 594 50 of of IN 37158 594 51 gas gas NN 37158 594 52 are be VBP 37158 594 53 formed form VBN 37158 594 54 , , , 37158 594 55 which which WDT 37158 594 56 block block VBP 37158 594 57 the the DT 37158 594 58 blood blood NN 37158 594 59 - - HYPH 37158 594 60 vessels vessel NNS 37158 594 61 and and CC 37158 594 62 prevent prevent VB 37158 594 63 the the DT 37158 594 64 blood blood NN 37158 594 65 circulating circulate VBG 37158 594 66 in in IN 37158 594 67 the the DT 37158 594 68 capillaries capillary NNS 37158 594 69 . . . 37158 595 1 Knowing know VBG 37158 595 2 this this DT 37158 595 3 , , , 37158 595 4 the the DT 37158 595 5 death death NN 37158 595 6 of of IN 37158 595 7 men man NNS 37158 595 8 working work VBG 37158 595 9 at at IN 37158 595 10 a a DT 37158 595 11 pressure pressure NN 37158 595 12 of of IN 37158 595 13 four four CD 37158 595 14 atmospheres atmosphere NNS 37158 595 15 could could MD 37158 595 16 then then RB 37158 595 17 be be VB 37158 595 18 avoided avoid VBN 37158 595 19 by by IN 37158 595 20 releasing release VBG 37158 595 21 them -PRON- PRP 37158 595 22 slowly slowly RB 37158 595 23 , , , 37158 595 24 that that DT 37158 595 25 is be VBZ 37158 595 26 by by IN 37158 595 27 bringing bring VBG 37158 595 28 them -PRON- PRP 37158 595 29 slowly slowly RB 37158 595 30 back back RB 37158 595 31 to to IN 37158 595 32 the the DT 37158 595 33 normal normal JJ 37158 595 34 atmospheric atmospheric JJ 37158 595 35 pressure pressure NN 37158 595 36 . . . 37158 596 1 Is be VBZ 37158 596 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 596 3 barbarous barbarous JJ 37158 596 4 to to TO 37158 596 5 attach attach VB 37158 596 6 more more JJR 37158 596 7 importance importance NN 37158 596 8 to to IN 37158 596 9 the the DT 37158 596 10 death death NN 37158 596 11 of of IN 37158 596 12 these these DT 37158 596 13 men man NNS 37158 596 14 than than IN 37158 596 15 to to IN 37158 596 16 the the DT 37158 596 17 death death NN 37158 596 18 of of IN 37158 596 19 the the DT 37158 596 20 few few JJ 37158 596 21 dogs dog NNS 37158 596 22 and and CC 37158 596 23 mice mouse NNS 37158 596 24 that that WDT 37158 596 25 served serve VBD 37158 596 26 to to TO 37158 596 27 establish establish VB 37158 596 28 this this DT 37158 596 29 law law NN 37158 596 30 ? ? . 37158 597 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 597 2 was be VBD 37158 597 3 able able JJ 37158 597 4 to to TO 37158 597 5 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37158 597 6 that that IN 37158 597 7 , , , 37158 597 8 if if IN 37158 597 9 the the DT 37158 597 10 temperature temperature NN 37158 597 11 of of IN 37158 597 12 the the DT 37158 597 13 air air NN 37158 597 14 is be VBZ 37158 597 15 very very RB 37158 597 16 high high JJ 37158 597 17 , , , 37158 597 18 as as IN 37158 597 19 in in IN 37158 597 20 the the DT 37158 597 21 hottest hot JJS 37158 597 22 days day NNS 37158 597 23 of of IN 37158 597 24 summer summer NN 37158 597 25 , , , 37158 597 26 dogs dog NNS 37158 597 27 that that WDT 37158 597 28 are be VBP 37158 597 29 muzzled muzzle VBN 37158 597 30 die die VBP 37158 597 31 rapidly rapidly RB 37158 597 32 of of IN 37158 597 33 hyperpyrexia hyperpyrexia NNP 37158 597 34 ( ( -LRB- 37158 597 35 _ _ NNP 37158 597 36 i.e. i.e. FW 37158 597 37 _ _ NNP 37158 597 38 high high JJ 37158 597 39 fever fever NN 37158 597 40 ) ) -RRB- 37158 597 41 , , , 37158 597 42 for for IN 37158 597 43 they -PRON- PRP 37158 597 44 are be VBP 37158 597 45 no no RB 37158 597 46 longer long RBR 37158 597 47 able able JJ 37158 597 48 to to TO 37158 597 49 cool cool VB 37158 597 50 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 597 51 by by IN 37158 597 52 panting pant VBG 37158 597 53 . . . 37158 598 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 598 2 is be VBZ 37158 598 3 true true JJ 37158 598 4 that that IN 37158 598 5 this this DT 37158 598 6 experiment experiment NN 37158 598 7 cost cost VBD 37158 598 8 the the DT 37158 598 9 lives life NNS 37158 598 10 of of IN 37158 598 11 a a DT 37158 598 12 few few JJ 37158 598 13 dogs dog NNS 37158 598 14 , , , 37158 598 15 but but CC 37158 598 16 has have VBZ 37158 598 17 it -PRON- PRP 37158 598 18 not not RB 37158 598 19 saved save VBN 37158 598 20 many many JJ 37158 598 21 others other NNS 37158 598 22 by by IN 37158 598 23 pointing point VBG 37158 598 24 out out RP 37158 598 25 that that IN 37158 598 26 dogs dog NNS 37158 598 27 should should MD 37158 598 28 not not RB 37158 598 29 be be VB 37158 598 30 muzzled muzzle VBN 37158 598 31 under under IN 37158 598 32 certain certain JJ 37158 598 33 conditions condition NNS 37158 598 34 ? ? . 37158 599 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 599 2 goes go VBZ 37158 599 3 without without IN 37158 599 4 saying say VBG 37158 599 5 I -PRON- PRP 37158 599 6 am be VBP 37158 599 7 not not RB 37158 599 8 speaking speak VBG 37158 599 9 of of IN 37158 599 10 the the DT 37158 599 11 theoretical theoretical JJ 37158 599 12 consequences consequence NNS 37158 599 13 of of IN 37158 599 14 this this DT 37158 599 15 experiment experiment NN 37158 599 16 . . . 37158 600 1 Artificial artificial JJ 37158 600 2 respiration respiration NN 37158 600 3 , , , 37158 600 4 which which WDT 37158 600 5 can can MD 37158 600 6 restore restore VB 37158 600 7 to to IN 37158 600 8 life life NN 37158 600 9 the the DT 37158 600 10 apparently apparently RB 37158 600 11 drowned drown VBN 37158 600 12 , , , 37158 600 13 is be VBZ 37158 600 14 one one CD 37158 600 15 , , , 37158 600 16 of of IN 37158 600 17 the the DT 37158 600 18 conquests conquest NNS 37158 600 19 of of IN 37158 600 20 experimental experimental JJ 37158 600 21 physiology physiology NN 37158 600 22 ; ; : 37158 600 23 for for IN 37158 600 24 we -PRON- PRP 37158 600 25 have have VBP 37158 600 26 been be VBN 37158 600 27 able able JJ 37158 600 28 to to TO 37158 600 29 determine determine VB 37158 600 30 the the DT 37158 600 31 best good JJS 37158 600 32 method method NN 37158 600 33 and and CC 37158 600 34 the the DT 37158 600 35 essential essential JJ 37158 600 36 conditions condition NNS 37158 600 37 ( ( -LRB- 37158 600 38 for for IN 37158 600 39 artificial artificial JJ 37158 600 40 breathing breathing NN 37158 600 41 ) ) -RRB- 37158 600 42 by by IN 37158 600 43 experiments experiment NNS 37158 600 44 of of IN 37158 600 45 a a DT 37158 600 46 very very RB 37158 600 47 precise precise JJ 37158 600 48 nature nature NN 37158 600 49 . . . 37158 601 1 Is be VBZ 37158 601 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 601 3 nothing nothing NN 37158 601 4 to to TO 37158 601 5 know know VB 37158 601 6 how how WRB 37158 601 7 to to TO 37158 601 8 restore restore VB 37158 601 9 to to IN 37158 601 10 life life NN 37158 601 11 the the DT 37158 601 12 apparently apparently RB 37158 601 13 drowned drown VBN 37158 601 14 ? ? . 37158 602 1 3 3 LS 37158 602 2 . . . 37158 603 1 _ _ NNP 37158 603 2 The the DT 37158 603 3 Process Process NNP 37158 603 4 of of IN 37158 603 5 Digestion Digestion NNP 37158 603 6 _ _ NNP 37158 603 7 has have VBZ 37158 603 8 also also RB 37158 603 9 been be VBN 37158 603 10 learned learn VBN 37158 603 11 solely solely RB 37158 603 12 by by IN 37158 603 13 experiment experiment NN 37158 603 14 . . . 37158 604 1 In in IN 37158 604 2 the the DT 37158 604 3 history history NN 37158 604 4 of of IN 37158 604 5 science science NN 37158 604 6 there there EX 37158 604 7 are be VBP 37158 604 8 two two CD 37158 604 9 or or CC 37158 604 10 three three CD 37158 604 11 cases case NNS 37158 604 12 of of IN 37158 604 13 individuals individual NNS 37158 604 14 in in IN 37158 604 15 whom whom WP 37158 604 16 a a DT 37158 604 17 wound wound NN 37158 604 18 or or CC 37158 604 19 an an DT 37158 604 20 operation operation NN 37158 604 21 has have VBZ 37158 604 22 produced produce VBN 37158 604 23 a a DT 37158 604 24 gastric gastric JJ 37158 604 25 fistula fistula NN 37158 604 26 , , , 37158 604 27 that that DT 37158 604 28 is be VBZ 37158 604 29 to to TO 37158 604 30 say say VB 37158 604 31 an an DT 37158 604 32 abdominal abdominal JJ 37158 604 33 opening opening NN 37158 604 34 through through IN 37158 604 35 which which WDT 37158 604 36 the the DT 37158 604 37 stomach stomach NN 37158 604 38 can can MD 37158 604 39 be be VB 37158 604 40 reached reach VBN 37158 604 41 and and CC 37158 604 42 food food NN 37158 604 43 introduced introduce VBN 37158 604 44 . . . 37158 605 1 Had have VBD 37158 605 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 605 3 remained remain VBN 37158 605 4 satisfied satisfied JJ 37158 605 5 with with IN 37158 605 6 these these DT 37158 605 7 accidental accidental JJ 37158 605 8 observations observation NNS 37158 605 9 , , , 37158 605 10 we -PRON- PRP 37158 605 11 should should MD 37158 605 12 have have VB 37158 605 13 obtained obtain VBN 37158 605 14 but but CC 37158 605 15 mediocre mediocre JJ 37158 605 16 results result NNS 37158 605 17 . . . 37158 606 1 Physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 606 2 therefore therefore RB 37158 606 3 have have VBP 37158 606 4 made make VBN 37158 606 5 experimental experimental JJ 37158 606 6 gastric gastric JJ 37158 606 7 fistulæ fistulæ NN 37158 606 8 . . . 37158 607 1 Dogs Dogs NNP 37158 607 2 thus thus RB 37158 607 3 operated operate VBD 37158 607 4 on on IN 37158 607 5 , , , 37158 607 6 after after IN 37158 607 7 an an DT 37158 607 8 illness illness NN 37158 607 9 of of IN 37158 607 10 a a DT 37158 607 11 few few JJ 37158 607 12 days day NNS 37158 607 13 , , , 37158 607 14 recover recover VB 37158 607 15 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 607 16 . . . 37158 608 1 Some some DT 37158 608 2 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 608 3 have have VBP 37158 608 4 kept keep VBN 37158 608 5 dogs dog NNS 37158 608 6 for for IN 37158 608 7 several several JJ 37158 608 8 years year NNS 37158 608 9 in in IN 37158 608 10 this this DT 37158 608 11 condition condition NN 37158 608 12 : : : 37158 608 13 gay gay NN 37158 608 14 , , , 37158 608 15 caressing caressing NN 37158 608 16 , , , 37158 608 17 docile docile NN 37158 608 18 , , , 37158 608 19 they -PRON- PRP 37158 608 20 did do VBD 37158 608 21 not not RB 37158 608 22 appear appear VB 37158 608 23 to to TO 37158 608 24 complain complain VB 37158 608 25 of of IN 37158 608 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 608 27 lot lot NN 37158 608 28 . . . 37158 609 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 609 2 were be VBD 37158 609 3 better well RBR 37158 609 4 nourished nourish VBN 37158 609 5 , , , 37158 609 6 more more RBR 37158 609 7 petted pet VBN 37158 609 8 and and CC 37158 609 9 loved love VBD 37158 609 10 than than IN 37158 609 11 the the DT 37158 609 12 many many JJ 37158 609 13 starving starve VBG 37158 609 14 dogs dog NNS 37158 609 15 which which WDT 37158 609 16 roam roam VBP 37158 609 17 about about IN 37158 609 18 the the DT 37158 609 19 country country NN 37158 609 20 . . . 37158 610 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 610 2 were be VBD 37158 610 3 not not RB 37158 610 4 a a DT 37158 610 5 whit whit NN 37158 610 6 more more RBR 37158 610 7 unhappy unhappy JJ 37158 610 8 than than IN 37158 610 9 was be VBD 37158 610 10 Alexis Alexis NNP 37158 610 11 St St NNP 37158 610 12 Martin Martin NNP 37158 610 13 ( ( -LRB- 37158 610 14 observed observe VBN 37158 610 15 in in IN 37158 610 16 1831 1831 CD 37158 610 17 by by IN 37158 610 18 Dr Dr NNP 37158 610 19 Beaumont Beaumont NNP 37158 610 20 ) ) -RRB- 37158 610 21 and and CC 37158 610 22 Marcellin Marcellin NNP 37158 610 23 ( ( -LRB- 37158 610 24 whom whom WP 37158 610 25 I -PRON- PRP 37158 610 26 observed observe VBD 37158 610 27 in in IN 37158 610 28 1878 1878 CD 37158 610 29 , , , 37158 610 30 at at IN 37158 610 31 the the DT 37158 610 32 beginning beginning NN 37158 610 33 of of IN 37158 610 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 610 35 career career NN 37158 610 36 ) ) -RRB- 37158 610 37 . . . 37158 611 1 Quite quite RB 37158 611 2 recently recently RB 37158 611 3 an an DT 37158 611 4 eminent eminent JJ 37158 611 5 Russian russian JJ 37158 611 6 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 611 7 , , , 37158 611 8 Pawloff Pawloff NNP 37158 611 9 , , , 37158 611 10 has have VBZ 37158 611 11 , , , 37158 611 12 by by IN 37158 611 13 making make VBG 37158 611 14 gastric gastric JJ 37158 611 15 fistulæ fistulæ NN 37158 611 16 in in IN 37158 611 17 animals animal NNS 37158 611 18 , , , 37158 611 19 been be VBN 37158 611 20 able able JJ 37158 611 21 to to TO 37158 611 22 discover discover VB 37158 611 23 a a DT 37158 611 24 number number NN 37158 611 25 of of IN 37158 611 26 important important JJ 37158 611 27 facts fact NNS 37158 611 28 , , , 37158 611 29 absolutely absolutely RB 37158 611 30 necessary necessary JJ 37158 611 31 to to TO 37158 611 32 be be VB 37158 611 33 known know VBN 37158 611 34 for for IN 37158 611 35 the the DT 37158 611 36 treatment treatment NN 37158 611 37 of of IN 37158 611 38 diseases disease NNS 37158 611 39 of of IN 37158 611 40 the the DT 37158 611 41 stomach stomach NN 37158 611 42 , , , 37158 611 43 and and CC 37158 611 44 even even RB 37158 611 45 for for IN 37158 611 46 the the DT 37158 611 47 establishment establishment NN 37158 611 48 of of IN 37158 611 49 a a DT 37158 611 50 normal normal JJ 37158 611 51 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 611 52 . . . 37158 612 1 The the DT 37158 612 2 problem problem NN 37158 612 3 of of IN 37158 612 4 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 612 5 is be VBZ 37158 612 6 , , , 37158 612 7 indeed indeed RB 37158 612 8 , , , 37158 612 9 one one CD 37158 612 10 of of IN 37158 612 11 the the DT 37158 612 12 most most RBS 37158 612 13 essential essential JJ 37158 612 14 , , , 37158 612 15 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 612 16 the the DT 37158 612 17 most most RBS 37158 612 18 essential essential JJ 37158 612 19 , , , 37158 612 20 in in IN 37158 612 21 the the DT 37158 612 22 history history NN 37158 612 23 of of IN 37158 612 24 humanity humanity NN 37158 612 25 . . . 37158 613 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 613 2 suppose suppose VBP 37158 613 3 that that IN 37158 613 4 anti anti NNS 37158 613 5 - - NNS 37158 613 6 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 613 7 are be VBP 37158 613 8 aware aware JJ 37158 613 9 of of IN 37158 613 10 the the DT 37158 613 11 fact fact NN 37158 613 12 that that IN 37158 613 13 , , , 37158 613 14 even even RB 37158 613 15 in in IN 37158 613 16 Europe Europe NNP 37158 613 17 , , , 37158 613 18 large large JJ 37158 613 19 populations population NNS 37158 613 20 exist exist VBP 37158 613 21 who who WP 37158 613 22 are be VBP 37158 613 23 insufficiently insufficiently RB 37158 613 24 nourished nourish VBN 37158 613 25 . . . 37158 614 1 Under under IN 37158 614 2 these these DT 37158 614 3 conditions condition NNS 37158 614 4 , , , 37158 614 5 is be VBZ 37158 614 6 it -PRON- PRP 37158 614 7 not not RB 37158 614 8 desirable desirable JJ 37158 614 9 to to TO 37158 614 10 know know VB 37158 614 11 exactly exactly RB 37158 614 12 the the DT 37158 614 13 quantities quantity NNS 37158 614 14 of of IN 37158 614 15 carbon carbon NN 37158 614 16 , , , 37158 614 17 nitrogen nitrogen NN 37158 614 18 , , , 37158 614 19 salt salt NN 37158 614 20 , , , 37158 614 21 lime lime NN 37158 614 22 , , , 37158 614 23 and and CC 37158 614 24 phosphorus phosphorus NN 37158 614 25 which which WDT 37158 614 26 are be VBP 37158 614 27 necessary necessary JJ 37158 614 28 for for IN 37158 614 29 animals animal NNS 37158 614 30 , , , 37158 614 31 and and CC 37158 614 32 consequently consequently RB 37158 614 33 for for IN 37158 614 34 man man NN 37158 614 35 ? ? . 37158 615 1 Should Should MD 37158 615 2 not not RB 37158 615 3 anti anti JJ 37158 615 4 - - JJ 37158 615 5 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 615 6 , , , 37158 615 7 interested interested JJ 37158 615 8 in in IN 37158 615 9 vegetarianism vegetarianism NN 37158 615 10 , , , 37158 615 11 before before IN 37158 615 12 venturing venture VBG 37158 615 13 to to TO 37158 615 14 institute institute VB 37158 615 15 a a DT 37158 615 16 vegetable vegetable JJ 37158 615 17 diet diet NN 37158 615 18 for for IN 37158 615 19 man man NN 37158 615 20 , , , 37158 615 21 try try VB 37158 615 22 it -PRON- PRP 37158 615 23 first first RB 37158 615 24 of of IN 37158 615 25 all all DT 37158 615 26 upon upon IN 37158 615 27 carnivorous carnivorous JJ 37158 615 28 animals animal NNS 37158 615 29 , , , 37158 615 30 so so IN 37158 615 31 as as IN 37158 615 32 to to TO 37158 615 33 know know VB 37158 615 34 how how WRB 37158 615 35 a a DT 37158 615 36 mixed mixed JJ 37158 615 37 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 615 38 can can MD 37158 615 39 be be VB 37158 615 40 modified modify VBN 37158 615 41 by by IN 37158 615 42 a a DT 37158 615 43 vegetable vegetable NN 37158 615 44 alimentation alimentation NN 37158 615 45 , , , 37158 615 46 and and CC 37158 615 47 to to TO 37158 615 48 what what WDT 37158 615 49 extent extent NN 37158 615 50 those those DT 37158 615 51 modifications modification NNS 37158 615 52 are be VBP 37158 615 53 compatible compatible JJ 37158 615 54 with with IN 37158 615 55 health health NN 37158 615 56 ? ? . 37158 616 1 4 4 LS 37158 616 2 . . . 37158 617 1 _ _ NNP 37158 617 2 The the DT 37158 617 3 Nervous Nervous NNP 37158 617 4 System System NNP 37158 617 5 _ _ NNP 37158 617 6 is be VBZ 37158 617 7 not not RB 37158 617 8 so so RB 37158 617 9 well well RB 37158 617 10 known known JJ 37158 617 11 , , , 37158 617 12 so so RB 37158 617 13 far far RB 37158 617 14 as as IN 37158 617 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 617 16 functions function NNS 37158 617 17 are be VBP 37158 617 18 concerned concern VBN 37158 617 19 , , , 37158 617 20 as as IN 37158 617 21 the the DT 37158 617 22 circulatory circulatory JJ 37158 617 23 system system NN 37158 617 24 or or CC 37158 617 25 the the DT 37158 617 26 digestive digestive JJ 37158 617 27 system system NN 37158 617 28 . . . 37158 618 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 618 2 , , , 37158 618 3 positive positive JJ 37158 618 4 discoveries discovery NNS 37158 618 5 are be VBP 37158 618 6 extremely extremely RB 37158 618 7 numerous numerous JJ 37158 618 8 : : : 37158 618 9 the the DT 37158 618 10 action action NN 37158 618 11 of of IN 37158 618 12 the the DT 37158 618 13 nerves nerve NNS 37158 618 14 on on IN 37158 618 15 the the DT 37158 618 16 glands gland NNS 37158 618 17 and and CC 37158 618 18 on on IN 37158 618 19 the the DT 37158 618 20 muscles muscle NNS 37158 618 21 ; ; : 37158 618 22 the the DT 37158 618 23 part part NN 37158 618 24 played play VBN 37158 618 25 by by IN 37158 618 26 the the DT 37158 618 27 different different JJ 37158 618 28 portions portion NNS 37158 618 29 of of IN 37158 618 30 the the DT 37158 618 31 brain brain NN 37158 618 32 ; ; : 37158 618 33 nervous nervous JJ 37158 618 34 degenerations degeneration NNS 37158 618 35 ; ; : 37158 618 36 the the DT 37158 618 37 laws law NNS 37158 618 38 governing govern VBG 37158 618 39 reflex reflex JJ 37158 618 40 actions action NNS 37158 618 41 -- -- : 37158 618 42 all all PDT 37158 618 43 this this DT 37158 618 44 constitutes constitute VBZ 37158 618 45 a a DT 37158 618 46 formidable formidable JJ 37158 618 47 body body NN 37158 618 48 of of IN 37158 618 49 well well RB 37158 618 50 - - HYPH 37158 618 51 established establish VBN 37158 618 52 facts fact NNS 37158 618 53 . . . 37158 619 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 619 2 do do VBP 37158 619 3 not not RB 37158 619 4 pretend pretend VB 37158 619 5 that that IN 37158 619 6 everything everything NN 37158 619 7 is be VBZ 37158 619 8 known know VBN 37158 619 9 . . . 37158 620 1 Alas alas UH 37158 620 2 ! ! . 37158 621 1 No no UH 37158 621 2 ! ! . 37158 622 1 There there EX 37158 622 2 are be VBP 37158 622 3 still still RB 37158 622 4 innumerable innumerable JJ 37158 622 5 truths truth NNS 37158 622 6 to to TO 37158 622 7 be be VB 37158 622 8 discovered discover VBN 37158 622 9 , , , 37158 622 10 and and CC 37158 622 11 serious serious JJ 37158 622 12 errors error NNS 37158 622 13 are be VBP 37158 622 14 doubtless doubtless RB 37158 622 15 most most RBS 37158 622 16 learnedly learnedly RB 37158 622 17 taught teach VBN 37158 622 18 , , , 37158 622 19 with with IN 37158 622 20 many many JJ 37158 622 21 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 622 22 , , , 37158 622 23 much much JJ 37158 622 24 uncertainty uncertainty NN 37158 622 25 , , , 37158 622 26 much much JJ 37158 622 27 confusion confusion NN 37158 622 28 -- -- : 37158 622 29 all all DT 37158 622 30 of of IN 37158 622 31 which which WDT 37158 622 32 simply simply RB 37158 622 33 proves prove VBZ 37158 622 34 that that IN 37158 622 35 physiology physiology NN 37158 622 36 is be VBZ 37158 622 37 not not RB 37158 622 38 a a DT 37158 622 39 science science NN 37158 622 40 whose whose WP$ 37158 622 41 last last JJ 37158 622 42 chapter chapter NN 37158 622 43 has have VBZ 37158 622 44 yet yet RB 37158 622 45 been be VBN 37158 622 46 written write VBN 37158 622 47 , , , 37158 622 48 that that IN 37158 622 49 the the DT 37158 622 50 last last JJ 37158 622 51 word word NN 37158 622 52 of of IN 37158 622 53 this this DT 37158 622 54 science science NN 37158 622 55 has have VBZ 37158 622 56 not not RB 37158 622 57 yet yet RB 37158 622 58 been be VBN 37158 622 59 pronounced pronounce VBN 37158 622 60 . . . 37158 623 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 623 2 , , , 37158 623 3 blind blind JJ 37158 623 4 indeed indeed RB 37158 623 5 would would MD 37158 623 6 the the DT 37158 623 7 man man NN 37158 623 8 be be VB 37158 623 9 who who WP 37158 623 10 would would MD 37158 623 11 venture venture VB 37158 623 12 to to TO 37158 623 13 conclude conclude VB 37158 623 14 that that DT 37158 623 15 physiology physiology NN 37158 623 16 was be VBD 37158 623 17 not not RB 37158 623 18 a a DT 37158 623 19 science science NN 37158 623 20 ; ; : 37158 623 21 or or CC 37158 623 22 to to TO 37158 623 23 assert assert VB 37158 623 24 that that DT 37158 623 25 physiology physiology NN 37158 623 26 is be VBZ 37158 623 27 a a DT 37158 623 28 science science NN 37158 623 29 of of IN 37158 623 30 little little JJ 37158 623 31 importance importance NN 37158 623 32 ; ; : 37158 623 33 that that IN 37158 623 34 the the DT 37158 623 35 rôle rôle NN 37158 623 36 of of IN 37158 623 37 the the DT 37158 623 38 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 623 39 , , , 37158 623 40 from from IN 37158 623 41 the the DT 37158 623 42 point point NN 37158 623 43 of of IN 37158 623 44 view view NN 37158 623 45 of of IN 37158 623 46 the the DT 37158 623 47 alleviation alleviation NN 37158 623 48 of of IN 37158 623 49 human human JJ 37158 623 50 miseries misery NNS 37158 623 51 , , , 37158 623 52 is be VBZ 37158 623 53 null null JJ 37158 623 54 ; ; : 37158 623 55 and and CC 37158 623 56 that that IN 37158 623 57 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 623 58 of of IN 37158 623 59 physiological physiological JJ 37158 623 60 facts fact NNS 37158 623 61 is be VBZ 37158 623 62 useless useless JJ 37158 623 63 . . . 37158 624 1 Will Will MD 37158 624 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 624 3 be be VB 37158 624 4 claimed claim VBN 37158 624 5 that that IN 37158 624 6 the the DT 37158 624 7 doctor doctor NN 37158 624 8 has have VBZ 37158 624 9 no no DT 37158 624 10 need need NN 37158 624 11 of of IN 37158 624 12 a a DT 37158 624 13 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 624 14 of of IN 37158 624 15 physiology physiology NN 37158 624 16 ? ? . 37158 625 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 625 2 will will MD 37158 625 3 reply reply VB 37158 625 4 by by IN 37158 625 5 a a DT 37158 625 6 comparison comparison NN 37158 625 7 I -PRON- PRP 37158 625 8 am be VBP 37158 625 9 accustomed accustom VBN 37158 625 10 to to TO 37158 625 11 make make VB 37158 625 12 before before IN 37158 625 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 625 14 medical medical JJ 37158 625 15 students student NNS 37158 625 16 when when WRB 37158 625 17 I -PRON- PRP 37158 625 18 wish wish VBP 37158 625 19 to to TO 37158 625 20 make make VB 37158 625 21 them -PRON- PRP 37158 625 22 understand understand VB 37158 625 23 the the DT 37158 625 24 necessity necessity NN 37158 625 25 of of IN 37158 625 26 a a DT 37158 625 27 sound sound JJ 37158 625 28 physiological physiological JJ 37158 625 29 education education NN 37158 625 30 . . . 37158 626 1 Let let VB 37158 626 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 626 3 suppose suppose VB 37158 626 4 that that IN 37158 626 5 a a DT 37158 626 6 watchmaker watchmaker NN 37158 626 7 claimed claim VBD 37158 626 8 to to TO 37158 626 9 be be VB 37158 626 10 able able JJ 37158 626 11 to to TO 37158 626 12 cure cure VB 37158 626 13 disordered disorder VBN 37158 626 14 watches watch NNS 37158 626 15 , , , 37158 626 16 but but CC 37158 626 17 at at IN 37158 626 18 the the DT 37158 626 19 same same JJ 37158 626 20 time time NN 37158 626 21 declared declare VBD 37158 626 22 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 626 23 unable unable JJ 37158 626 24 to to TO 37158 626 25 tell tell VB 37158 626 26 by by IN 37158 626 27 what what WP 37158 626 28 springs spring NNS 37158 626 29 and and CC 37158 626 30 by by IN 37158 626 31 what what WP 37158 626 32 mysterious mysterious JJ 37158 626 33 mechanism mechanism NN 37158 626 34 a a DT 37158 626 35 healthy healthy JJ 37158 626 36 watch watch NN 37158 626 37 should should MD 37158 626 38 mark mark VB 37158 626 39 the the DT 37158 626 40 hour hour NN 37158 626 41 ; ; : 37158 626 42 that that IN 37158 626 43 watchmaker watchmaker NNP 37158 626 44 would would MD 37158 626 45 inspire inspire VB 37158 626 46 me -PRON- PRP 37158 626 47 with with IN 37158 626 48 a a DT 37158 626 49 very very RB 37158 626 50 small small JJ 37158 626 51 amount amount NN 37158 626 52 of of IN 37158 626 53 confidence confidence NN 37158 626 54 , , , 37158 626 55 and and CC 37158 626 56 I -PRON- PRP 37158 626 57 would would MD 37158 626 58 not not RB 37158 626 59 go go VB 37158 626 60 to to IN 37158 626 61 him -PRON- PRP 37158 626 62 ; ; : 37158 626 63 for for IN 37158 626 64 , , , 37158 626 65 until until IN 37158 626 66 the the DT 37158 626 67 contrary contrary NN 37158 626 68 is be VBZ 37158 626 69 proved prove VBN 37158 626 70 to to IN 37158 626 71 me -PRON- PRP 37158 626 72 , , , 37158 626 73 I -PRON- PRP 37158 626 74 believe believe VBP 37158 626 75 that that IN 37158 626 76 an an DT 37158 626 77 indispensable indispensable JJ 37158 626 78 condition condition NN 37158 626 79 for for IN 37158 626 80 repairing repair VBG 37158 626 81 a a DT 37158 626 82 watch watch NN 37158 626 83 when when WRB 37158 626 84 out out IN 37158 626 85 of of IN 37158 626 86 order order NN 37158 626 87 is be VBZ 37158 626 88 to to TO 37158 626 89 know know VB 37158 626 90 how how WRB 37158 626 91 a a DT 37158 626 92 watch watch NN 37158 626 93 should should MD 37158 626 94 work work VB 37158 626 95 when when WRB 37158 626 96 in in IN 37158 626 97 good good JJ 37158 626 98 repair repair NN 37158 626 99 . . . 37158 627 1 Physiology physiology NN 37158 627 2 exists exist VBZ 37158 627 3 only only RB 37158 627 4 because because IN 37158 627 5 there there EX 37158 627 6 have have VBP 37158 627 7 been be VBN 37158 627 8 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 627 9 . . . 37158 628 1 By by IN 37158 628 2 that that DT 37158 628 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 628 4 do do VBP 37158 628 5 not not RB 37158 628 6 mean mean VB 37158 628 7 to to TO 37158 628 8 say say VB 37158 628 9 that that IN 37158 628 10 all all PDT 37158 628 11 the the DT 37158 628 12 truths truth NNS 37158 628 13 of of IN 37158 628 14 physiology physiology NN 37158 628 15 are be VBP 37158 628 16 due due JJ 37158 628 17 exclusively exclusively RB 37158 628 18 to to IN 37158 628 19 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 628 20 . . . 37158 629 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 629 2 only only RB 37158 629 3 claim claim VBP 37158 629 4 that that IN 37158 629 5 physiology physiology NN 37158 629 6 without without IN 37158 629 7 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 629 8 would would MD 37158 629 9 be be VB 37158 629 10 strangely strangely RB 37158 629 11 clumsy clumsy JJ 37158 629 12 , , , 37158 629 13 limited limited JJ 37158 629 14 to to IN 37158 629 15 a a DT 37158 629 16 few few JJ 37158 629 17 empirical empirical JJ 37158 629 18 facts fact NNS 37158 629 19 , , , 37158 629 20 and and CC 37158 629 21 that that IN 37158 629 22 , , , 37158 629 23 if if IN 37158 629 24 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 629 25 be be VB 37158 629 26 proscribed proscribe VBN 37158 629 27 , , , 37158 629 28 we -PRON- PRP 37158 629 29 must must MD 37158 629 30 resolutely resolutely RB 37158 629 31 give give VB 37158 629 32 up up RP 37158 629 33 classing classing NN 37158 629 34 physiology physiology NN 37158 629 35 among among IN 37158 629 36 the the DT 37158 629 37 sciences science NNS 37158 629 38 . . . 37158 630 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 630 2 may may MD 37158 630 3 study study VB 37158 630 4 the the DT 37158 630 5 stars star NNS 37158 630 6 and and CC 37158 630 7 the the DT 37158 630 8 earth earth NN 37158 630 9 , , , 37158 630 10 electricity electricity NN 37158 630 11 and and CC 37158 630 12 heat heat NN 37158 630 13 , , , 37158 630 14 geography geography NN 37158 630 15 and and CC 37158 630 16 history history NN 37158 630 17 , , , 37158 630 18 and and CC 37158 630 19 are be VBP 37158 630 20 we -PRON- PRP 37158 630 21 to to TO 37158 630 22 be be VB 37158 630 23 forbidden forbid VBN 37158 630 24 to to TO 37158 630 25 study study VB 37158 630 26 the the DT 37158 630 27 functions function NNS 37158 630 28 of of IN 37158 630 29 living living NN 37158 630 30 matter matter NN 37158 630 31 ? ? . 37158 631 1 Such such PDT 37158 631 2 a a DT 37158 631 3 proposal proposal NN 37158 631 4 is be VBZ 37158 631 5 obviously obviously RB 37158 631 6 absurd absurd JJ 37158 631 7 , , , 37158 631 8 for for IN 37158 631 9 of of IN 37158 631 10 all all PDT 37158 631 11 the the DT 37158 631 12 sciences science NNS 37158 631 13 accessible accessible JJ 37158 631 14 to to IN 37158 631 15 man man NN 37158 631 16 , , , 37158 631 17 physiology physiology NN 37158 631 18 is be VBZ 37158 631 19 that that DT 37158 631 20 which which WDT 37158 631 21 is be VBZ 37158 631 22 nearest near JJS 37158 631 23 to to IN 37158 631 24 him -PRON- PRP 37158 631 25 . . . 37158 632 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 632 2 is be VBZ 37158 632 3 only only RB 37158 632 4 the the DT 37158 632 5 ignorant ignorant NN 37158 632 6 who who WP 37158 632 7 dare dare VBP 37158 632 8 assert assert VB 37158 632 9 that that DT 37158 632 10 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 632 11 on on IN 37158 632 12 animals animal NNS 37158 632 13 can can MD 37158 632 14 not not RB 37158 632 15 be be VB 37158 632 16 applied apply VBN 37158 632 17 to to IN 37158 632 18 man man NN 37158 632 19 . . . 37158 633 1 There there EX 37158 633 2 are be VBP 37158 633 3 of of IN 37158 633 4 course course NN 37158 633 5 differences difference NNS 37158 633 6 which which WDT 37158 633 7 physiologists physiologist VBZ 37158 633 8 train train VBP 37158 633 9 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 633 10 to to IN 37158 633 11 perceive perceive VB 37158 633 12 ; ; : 37158 633 13 for for IN 37158 633 14 example example NN 37158 633 15 , , , 37158 633 16 certain certain JJ 37158 633 17 poisons poison NNS 37158 633 18 are be VBP 37158 633 19 almost almost RB 37158 633 20 innocuous innocuous JJ 37158 633 21 to to IN 37158 633 22 some some DT 37158 633 23 animals animal NNS 37158 633 24 , , , 37158 633 25 and and CC 37158 633 26 are be VBP 37158 633 27 very very RB 37158 633 28 fatal fatal JJ 37158 633 29 to to TO 37158 633 30 man man VB 37158 633 31 . . . 37158 634 1 The the DT 37158 634 2 alkaloid alkaloid NN 37158 634 3 of of IN 37158 634 4 belladonna belladonna NNP 37158 634 5 , , , 37158 634 6 atropine atropine NNP 37158 634 7 , , , 37158 634 8 is be VBZ 37158 634 9 a a DT 37158 634 10 thousand thousand CD 37158 634 11 times time NNS 37158 634 12 more more RBR 37158 634 13 toxic toxic JJ 37158 634 14 for for IN 37158 634 15 a a DT 37158 634 16 man man NN 37158 634 17 than than IN 37158 634 18 for for IN 37158 634 19 a a DT 37158 634 20 goat goat NN 37158 634 21 . . . 37158 635 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 635 2 is be VBZ 37158 635 3 difficult difficult JJ 37158 635 4 to to TO 37158 635 5 kill kill VB 37158 635 6 a a DT 37158 635 7 goat goat NN 37158 635 8 with with IN 37158 635 9 morphia morphia NNP 37158 635 10 , , , 37158 635 11 whilst whilst IN 37158 635 12 a a DT 37158 635 13 drop drop NN 37158 635 14 of of IN 37158 635 15 laudanum laudanum NN 37158 635 16 kills kill VBZ 37158 635 17 a a DT 37158 635 18 new new RB 37158 635 19 - - HYPH 37158 635 20 born bear VBN 37158 635 21 babe babe NN 37158 635 22 . . . 37158 636 1 Carbonic carbonic JJ 37158 636 2 oxide oxide NN 37158 636 3 is be VBZ 37158 636 4 absolutely absolutely RB 37158 636 5 harmless harmless JJ 37158 636 6 for for IN 37158 636 7 the the DT 37158 636 8 invertebrata invertebrata NN 37158 636 9 which which WDT 37158 636 10 have have VBP 37158 636 11 no no DT 37158 636 12 blood blood NN 37158 636 13 . . . 37158 637 1 Crayfish crayfish NN 37158 637 2 and and CC 37158 637 3 snails snail NNS 37158 637 4 live live VBP 37158 637 5 with with IN 37158 637 6 impunity impunity NN 37158 637 7 in in IN 37158 637 8 pure pure JJ 37158 637 9 oxide oxide NN 37158 637 10 of of IN 37158 637 11 carbon carbon NN 37158 637 12 . . . 37158 638 1 And and CC 37158 638 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 638 3 could could MD 37158 638 4 cite cite VB 37158 638 5 a a DT 37158 638 6 number number NN 37158 638 7 of of IN 37158 638 8 other other JJ 37158 638 9 facts fact NNS 37158 638 10 which which WDT 37158 638 11 are be VBP 37158 638 12 described describe VBN 37158 638 13 in in IN 37158 638 14 detail detail NN 37158 638 15 in in IN 37158 638 16 every every DT 37158 638 17 treatise treatise NN 37158 638 18 of of IN 37158 638 19 physiology physiology NN 37158 638 20 or or CC 37158 638 21 pharmacology pharmacology NN 37158 638 22 . . . 37158 639 1 But but CC 37158 639 2 what what WP 37158 639 3 does do VBZ 37158 639 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 639 5 matter matter VB 37158 639 6 to to IN 37158 639 7 us -PRON- PRP 37158 639 8 if if IN 37158 639 9 we -PRON- PRP 37158 639 10 know know VBP 37158 639 11 it?--and it?--and UH 37158 639 12 we -PRON- PRP 37158 639 13 can can MD 37158 639 14 nearly nearly RB 37158 639 15 always always RB 37158 639 16 know know VB 37158 639 17 it -PRON- PRP 37158 639 18 . . . 37158 640 1 There there EX 37158 640 2 are be VBP 37158 640 3 functional functional JJ 37158 640 4 differences difference NNS 37158 640 5 between between IN 37158 640 6 men man NNS 37158 640 7 and and CC 37158 640 8 animals animal NNS 37158 640 9 ; ; , 37158 640 10 and and CC 37158 640 11 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 640 12 know know VBP 37158 640 13 these these DT 37158 640 14 perfectly perfectly RB 37158 640 15 well well RB 37158 640 16 by by IN 37158 640 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 640 18 training training NN 37158 640 19 ; ; : 37158 640 20 but but CC 37158 640 21 there there EX 37158 640 22 are be VBP 37158 640 23 , , , 37158 640 24 above above IN 37158 640 25 all all DT 37158 640 26 things thing NNS 37158 640 27 , , , 37158 640 28 much much RB 37158 640 29 more more RBR 37158 640 30 striking striking JJ 37158 640 31 resemblances resemblance NNS 37158 640 32 . . . 37158 641 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 641 2 would would MD 37158 641 3 be be VB 37158 641 4 , , , 37158 641 5 for for IN 37158 641 6 instance instance NN 37158 641 7 , , , 37158 641 8 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 37158 641 9 to to TO 37158 641 10 suppose suppose VB 37158 641 11 that that DT 37158 641 12 oxygen oxygen NN 37158 641 13 did do VBD 37158 641 14 not not RB 37158 641 15 dissolve dissolve VB 37158 641 16 in in IN 37158 641 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 641 18 blood blood NN 37158 641 19 in in IN 37158 641 20 about about IN 37158 641 21 the the DT 37158 641 22 same same JJ 37158 641 23 way way NN 37158 641 24 in in IN 37158 641 25 which which WDT 37158 641 26 it -PRON- PRP 37158 641 27 dissolves dissolve VBZ 37158 641 28 in in IN 37158 641 29 the the DT 37158 641 30 blood blood NN 37158 641 31 of of IN 37158 641 32 a a DT 37158 641 33 cat cat NN 37158 641 34 or or CC 37158 641 35 a a DT 37158 641 36 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 641 37 ; ; : 37158 641 38 that that IN 37158 641 39 the the DT 37158 641 40 pneumogastric pneumogastric JJ 37158 641 41 nerve nerve NN 37158 641 42 , , , 37158 641 43 which which WDT 37158 641 44 stops stop VBZ 37158 641 45 the the DT 37158 641 46 heart heart NN 37158 641 47 of of IN 37158 641 48 the the DT 37158 641 49 cat cat NN 37158 641 50 and and CC 37158 641 51 the the DT 37158 641 52 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 641 53 , , , 37158 641 54 will will MD 37158 641 55 not not RB 37158 641 56 stop stop VB 37158 641 57 the the DT 37158 641 58 heart heart NN 37158 641 59 of of IN 37158 641 60 man man NN 37158 641 61 ; ; : 37158 641 62 that that IN 37158 641 63 the the DT 37158 641 64 arterial arterial JJ 37158 641 65 pressure pressure NN 37158 641 66 , , , 37158 641 67 which which WDT 37158 641 68 is be VBZ 37158 641 69 16 16 CD 37158 641 70 c.m c.m NNP 37158 641 71 . . . 37158 642 1 of of IN 37158 642 2 mercury mercury NNP 37158 642 3 in in IN 37158 642 4 the the DT 37158 642 5 horse horse NN 37158 642 6 , , , 37158 642 7 the the DT 37158 642 8 dog dog NN 37158 642 9 , , , 37158 642 10 and and CC 37158 642 11 the the DT 37158 642 12 cat cat NN 37158 642 13 , , , 37158 642 14 is be VBZ 37158 642 15 1 1 CD 37158 642 16 c.m c.m NNP 37158 642 17 . . . 37158 643 1 or or CC 37158 643 2 1.60 1.60 CD 37158 643 3 c.m c.m NNP 37158 643 4 . . . 37158 644 1 in in IN 37158 644 2 man man NN 37158 644 3 ; ; : 37158 644 4 that that IN 37158 644 5 the the DT 37158 644 6 transformation transformation NN 37158 644 7 of of IN 37158 644 8 albuminous albuminous JJ 37158 644 9 matters matter NNS 37158 644 10 into into IN 37158 644 11 urea urea NNP 37158 644 12 takes take VBZ 37158 644 13 place place NN 37158 644 14 differently differently RB 37158 644 15 in in IN 37158 644 16 the the DT 37158 644 17 dog dog NN 37158 644 18 and and CC 37158 644 19 in in IN 37158 644 20 man man NN 37158 644 21 . . . 37158 645 1 On on IN 37158 645 2 the the DT 37158 645 3 contrary contrary NN 37158 645 4 , , , 37158 645 5 everything everything NN 37158 645 6 goes go VBZ 37158 645 7 to to TO 37158 645 8 prove prove VB 37158 645 9 the the DT 37158 645 10 general general JJ 37158 645 11 laws law NNS 37158 645 12 are be VBP 37158 645 13 the the DT 37158 645 14 same same JJ 37158 645 15 , , , 37158 645 16 and and CC 37158 645 17 that that IN 37158 645 18 the the DT 37158 645 19 physiology physiology NN 37158 645 20 of of IN 37158 645 21 man man NN 37158 645 22 , , , 37158 645 23 whilst whilst IN 37158 645 24 not not RB 37158 645 25 rigorously rigorously RB 37158 645 26 identical identical JJ 37158 645 27 in in IN 37158 645 28 every every DT 37158 645 29 respect respect NN 37158 645 30 with with IN 37158 645 31 the the DT 37158 645 32 physiology physiology NN 37158 645 33 of of IN 37158 645 34 the the DT 37158 645 35 animal animal NN 37158 645 36 , , , 37158 645 37 is be VBZ 37158 645 38 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 645 39 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37158 645 40 analogous analogous JJ 37158 645 41 to to TO 37158 645 42 enable enable VB 37158 645 43 a a DT 37158 645 44 _ _ NNP 37158 645 45 general general JJ 37158 645 46 physiology physiology NN 37158 645 47 _ _ NNP 37158 645 48 to to TO 37158 645 49 comprise comprise VB 37158 645 50 in in IN 37158 645 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 645 52 vast vast JJ 37158 645 53 laws law NNS 37158 645 54 the the DT 37158 645 55 functions function NNS 37158 645 56 of of IN 37158 645 57 every every DT 37158 645 58 living live VBG 37158 645 59 being being NN 37158 645 60 , , , 37158 645 61 man man NN 37158 645 62 , , , 37158 645 63 mammal mammal JJ 37158 645 64 , , , 37158 645 65 vertebrata vertebrata NN 37158 645 66 , , , 37158 645 67 invertebrata invertebrata NN 37158 645 68 , , , 37158 645 69 and and CC 37158 645 70 even even RB 37158 645 71 every every DT 37158 645 72 living live VBG 37158 645 73 cell cell NN 37158 645 74 . . . 37158 646 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 646 2 VI VI NNP 37158 646 3 MORALITY MORALITY NNP 37158 646 4 AND and CC 37158 646 5 VIVISECTION vivisection VBP 37158 646 6 If if IN 37158 646 7 we -PRON- PRP 37158 646 8 took take VBD 37158 646 9 the the DT 37158 646 10 assertions assertion NNS 37158 646 11 of of IN 37158 646 12 anti anti JJ 37158 646 13 - - NNS 37158 646 14 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 646 15 literally literally RB 37158 646 16 , , , 37158 646 17 we -PRON- PRP 37158 646 18 should should MD 37158 646 19 arrive arrive VB 37158 646 20 at at IN 37158 646 21 the the DT 37158 646 22 strange strange JJ 37158 646 23 conclusion conclusion NN 37158 646 24 , , , 37158 646 25 that that IN 37158 646 26 the the DT 37158 646 27 victims victim NNS 37158 646 28 of of IN 37158 646 29 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 646 30 are be VBP 37158 646 31 immensely immensely RB 37158 646 32 numerous numerous JJ 37158 646 33 , , , 37158 646 34 and and CC 37158 646 35 that that IN 37158 646 36 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 646 37 is be VBZ 37158 646 38 one one CD 37158 646 39 of of IN 37158 646 40 the the DT 37158 646 41 calamities calamity NNS 37158 646 42 of of IN 37158 646 43 the the DT 37158 646 44 century century NN 37158 646 45 . . . 37158 647 1 As as IN 37158 647 2 a a DT 37158 647 3 matter matter NN 37158 647 4 of of IN 37158 647 5 fact fact NN 37158 647 6 , , , 37158 647 7 the the DT 37158 647 8 number number NN 37158 647 9 of of IN 37158 647 10 victims victim NNS 37158 647 11 due due JJ 37158 647 12 to to IN 37158 647 13 physiology physiology NN 37158 647 14 is be VBZ 37158 647 15 very very RB 37158 647 16 low low JJ 37158 647 17 . . . 37158 648 1 Let let VB 37158 648 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 648 3 try try VB 37158 648 4 to to TO 37158 648 5 count count VB 37158 648 6 them -PRON- PRP 37158 648 7 up up RP 37158 648 8 . . . 37158 649 1 There there EX 37158 649 2 are be VBP 37158 649 3 only only RB 37158 649 4 about about RB 37158 649 5 twenty twenty CD 37158 649 6 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 649 7 in in IN 37158 649 8 France France NNP 37158 649 9 where where WRB 37158 649 10 experiments experiment NNS 37158 649 11 on on IN 37158 649 12 animals animal NNS 37158 649 13 are be VBP 37158 649 14 made make VBN 37158 649 15 . . . 37158 650 1 Let let VB 37158 650 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 650 3 allow allow VB 37158 650 4 that that IN 37158 650 5 there there EX 37158 650 6 are be VBP 37158 650 7 twenty twenty CD 37158 650 8 in in IN 37158 650 9 England England NNP 37158 650 10 , , , 37158 650 11 twenty twenty CD 37158 650 12 in in IN 37158 650 13 Italy Italy NNP 37158 650 14 , , , 37158 650 15 forty forty CD 37158 650 16 in in IN 37158 650 17 Germany Germany NNP 37158 650 18 , , , 37158 650 19 and and CC 37158 650 20 fifty fifty CD 37158 650 21 in in IN 37158 650 22 other other JJ 37158 650 23 countries country NNS 37158 650 24 , , , 37158 650 25 making make VBG 37158 650 26 a a DT 37158 650 27 total total NN 37158 650 28 of of IN 37158 650 29 150 150 CD 37158 650 30 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 650 31 . . . 37158 651 1 If if IN 37158 651 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 651 3 suppose suppose VBP 37158 651 4 that that IN 37158 651 5 a a DT 37158 651 6 dog dog NN 37158 651 7 , , , 37158 651 8 a a DT 37158 651 9 cat cat NN 37158 651 10 , , , 37158 651 11 and and CC 37158 651 12 a a DT 37158 651 13 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 651 14 are be VBP 37158 651 15 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 37158 651 16 every every DT 37158 651 17 day day NN 37158 651 18 in in IN 37158 651 19 each each DT 37158 651 20 of of IN 37158 651 21 these these DT 37158 651 22 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 651 23 , , , 37158 651 24 we -PRON- PRP 37158 651 25 should should MD 37158 651 26 certainly certainly RB 37158 651 27 exaggerate exaggerate VB 37158 651 28 . . . 37158 652 1 Let let VB 37158 652 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 652 3 suppose suppose VB 37158 652 4 , , , 37158 652 5 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 652 6 , , , 37158 652 7 that that IN 37158 652 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 652 9 is be VBZ 37158 652 10 so so RB 37158 652 11 ; ; : 37158 652 12 and and CC 37158 652 13 let let VB 37158 652 14 us -PRON- PRP 37158 652 15 even even RB 37158 652 16 admit admit VB 37158 652 17 five five CD 37158 652 18 victims victim NNS 37158 652 19 a a DT 37158 652 20 day day NN 37158 652 21 , , , 37158 652 22 with with IN 37158 652 23 300 300 CD 37158 652 24 working working NN 37158 652 25 days day NNS 37158 652 26 in in IN 37158 652 27 the the DT 37158 652 28 year year NN 37158 652 29 , , , 37158 652 30 which which WDT 37158 652 31 is be VBZ 37158 652 32 also also RB 37158 652 33 an an DT 37158 652 34 evident evident JJ 37158 652 35 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37158 652 36 : : : 37158 652 37 this this DT 37158 652 38 will will MD 37158 652 39 make make VB 37158 652 40 about about IN 37158 652 41 200,000 200,000 CD 37158 652 42 victims victim NNS 37158 652 43 a a DT 37158 652 44 year year NN 37158 652 45 . . . 37158 653 1 This this DT 37158 653 2 number number NN 37158 653 3 , , , 37158 653 4 which which WDT 37158 653 5 seems seem VBZ 37158 653 6 very very RB 37158 653 7 considerable considerable JJ 37158 653 8 , , , 37158 653 9 is be VBZ 37158 653 10 in in IN 37158 653 11 reality reality NN 37158 653 12 very very RB 37158 653 13 small small JJ 37158 653 14 , , , 37158 653 15 if if IN 37158 653 16 we -PRON- PRP 37158 653 17 put put VBP 37158 653 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 653 19 against against IN 37158 653 20 the the DT 37158 653 21 enormous enormous JJ 37158 653 22 number number NN 37158 653 23 of of IN 37158 653 24 living live VBG 37158 653 25 beings being NNS 37158 653 26 . . . 37158 654 1 Probably probably RB 37158 654 2 about about RB 37158 654 3 two two CD 37158 654 4 thousand thousand CD 37158 654 5 millions million NNS 37158 654 6 of of IN 37158 654 7 mammals mammal NNS 37158 654 8 die die VBP 37158 654 9 every every DT 37158 654 10 year year NN 37158 654 11 , , , 37158 654 12 so so IN 37158 654 13 that that IN 37158 654 14 the the DT 37158 654 15 proportion proportion NN 37158 654 16 of of IN 37158 654 17 animals animal NNS 37158 654 18 that that WDT 37158 654 19 suffer suffer VBP 37158 654 20 a a DT 37158 654 21 little little JJ 37158 654 22 ( ( -LRB- 37158 654 23 and and CC 37158 654 24 very very RB 37158 654 25 little little JJ 37158 654 26 ) ) -RRB- 37158 654 27 through through IN 37158 654 28 the the DT 37158 654 29 act act NN 37158 654 30 of of IN 37158 654 31 man man NN 37158 654 32 in in IN 37158 654 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 654 34 search search NN 37158 654 35 for for IN 37158 654 36 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 654 37 is be VBZ 37158 654 38 one one CD 37158 654 39 in in IN 37158 654 40 10,000 10,000 CD 37158 654 41 , , , 37158 654 42 in in IN 37158 654 43 other other JJ 37158 654 44 words word NNS 37158 654 45 , , , 37158 654 46 a a DT 37158 654 47 negligible negligible JJ 37158 654 48 quantity quantity NN 37158 654 49 . . . 37158 655 1 In in IN 37158 655 2 the the DT 37158 655 3 immense immense JJ 37158 655 4 earthly earthly JJ 37158 655 5 universe universe NN 37158 655 6 are be VBP 37158 655 7 thousands thousand NNS 37158 655 8 and and CC 37158 655 9 thousands thousand NNS 37158 655 10 of of IN 37158 655 11 pains pain NNS 37158 655 12 , , , 37158 655 13 of of IN 37158 655 14 fierce fierce JJ 37158 655 15 , , , 37158 655 16 incessant incessant JJ 37158 655 17 struggles struggle NNS 37158 655 18 between between IN 37158 655 19 living live VBG 37158 655 20 animals animal NNS 37158 655 21 . . . 37158 656 1 Every every DT 37158 656 2 rock rock NN 37158 656 3 in in IN 37158 656 4 the the DT 37158 656 5 ocean ocean NN 37158 656 6 , , , 37158 656 7 every every DT 37158 656 8 tree tree NN 37158 656 9 in in IN 37158 656 10 the the DT 37158 656 11 forest forest NN 37158 656 12 , , , 37158 656 13 shelters shelter VBZ 37158 656 14 ferocious ferocious JJ 37158 656 15 combats combat NNS 37158 656 16 , , , 37158 656 17 and and CC 37158 656 18 is be VBZ 37158 656 19 the the DT 37158 656 20 constant constant JJ 37158 656 21 scene scene NN 37158 656 22 of of IN 37158 656 23 painful painful JJ 37158 656 24 death death NN 37158 656 25 - - HYPH 37158 656 26 agonies agony NNS 37158 656 27 . . . 37158 657 1 Darwin Darwin NNP 37158 657 2 has have VBZ 37158 657 3 admirably admirably RB 37158 657 4 shown show VBN 37158 657 5 that that IN 37158 657 6 life life NN 37158 657 7 is be VBZ 37158 657 8 a a DT 37158 657 9 struggle struggle NN 37158 657 10 for for IN 37158 657 11 life life NN 37158 657 12 , , , 37158 657 13 that that IN 37158 657 14 the the DT 37158 657 15 weak weak JJ 37158 657 16 are be VBP 37158 657 17 crushed crush VBN 37158 657 18 by by IN 37158 657 19 the the DT 37158 657 20 strong strong JJ 37158 657 21 , , , 37158 657 22 and and CC 37158 657 23 that that IN 37158 657 24 the the DT 37158 657 25 voice voice NN 37158 657 26 of of IN 37158 657 27 living living NN 37158 657 28 nature nature NN 37158 657 29 is be VBZ 37158 657 30 a a DT 37158 657 31 cry cry NN 37158 657 32 of of IN 37158 657 33 distress distress NN 37158 657 34 rather rather RB 37158 657 35 than than IN 37158 657 36 a a DT 37158 657 37 hymn hymn NN 37158 657 38 of of IN 37158 657 39 joy joy NN 37158 657 40 . . . 37158 658 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 658 2 , , , 37158 658 3 in in IN 37158 658 4 this this DT 37158 658 5 universal universal JJ 37158 658 6 concert concert NN 37158 658 7 of of IN 37158 658 8 animal animal NN 37158 658 9 pain pain NN 37158 658 10 and and CC 37158 658 11 of of IN 37158 658 12 human human JJ 37158 658 13 pain pain NN 37158 658 14 , , , 37158 658 15 the the DT 37158 658 16 slight slight JJ 37158 658 17 pain pain NN 37158 658 18 of of IN 37158 658 19 animals animal NNS 37158 658 20 experimented experiment VBN 37158 658 21 upon upon IN 37158 658 22 is be VBZ 37158 658 23 a a DT 37158 658 24 little little JJ 37158 658 25 thing thing NN 37158 658 26 , , , 37158 658 27 and and CC 37158 658 28 from from IN 37158 658 29 an an DT 37158 658 30 absolute absolute JJ 37158 658 31 point point NN 37158 658 32 of of IN 37158 658 33 view view NN 37158 658 34 we -PRON- PRP 37158 658 35 have have VBP 37158 658 36 the the DT 37158 658 37 right right NN 37158 658 38 to to TO 37158 658 39 disregard disregard VB 37158 658 40 it -PRON- PRP 37158 658 41 . . . 37158 659 1 Think think VB 37158 659 2 well well RB 37158 659 3 over over IN 37158 659 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 659 5 all all DT 37158 659 6 for for IN 37158 659 7 a a DT 37158 659 8 moment moment NN 37158 659 9 . . . 37158 660 1 By by IN 37158 660 2 giving give VBG 37158 660 3 an an DT 37158 660 4 experimental experimental JJ 37158 660 5 disease disease NN 37158 660 6 to to IN 37158 660 7 a a DT 37158 660 8 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 660 9 , , , 37158 660 10 for for IN 37158 660 11 example example NN 37158 660 12 , , , 37158 660 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 660 14 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 660 15 change change VBP 37158 660 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 660 17 lot lot NN 37158 660 18 . . . 37158 661 1 If if IN 37158 661 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 661 3 had have VBD 37158 661 4 left leave VBN 37158 661 5 it -PRON- PRP 37158 661 6 to to IN 37158 661 7 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 661 8 , , , 37158 661 9 in in IN 37158 661 10 one one CD 37158 661 11 , , , 37158 661 12 two two CD 37158 661 13 , , , 37158 661 14 or or CC 37158 661 15 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 661 16 three three CD 37158 661 17 years year NNS 37158 661 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 661 19 would would MD 37158 661 20 have have VB 37158 661 21 been be VBN 37158 661 22 attacked attack VBN 37158 661 23 by by IN 37158 661 24 another another DT 37158 661 25 disease disease NN 37158 661 26 , , , 37158 661 27 probably probably RB 37158 661 28 more more RBR 37158 661 29 cruel cruel JJ 37158 661 30 than than IN 37158 661 31 the the DT 37158 661 32 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 661 33 with with IN 37158 661 34 which which WDT 37158 661 35 I -PRON- PRP 37158 661 36 infected infect VBD 37158 661 37 it -PRON- PRP 37158 661 38 . . . 37158 662 1 The the DT 37158 662 2 lot lot NN 37158 662 3 of of IN 37158 662 4 dogs dog NNS 37158 662 5 which which WDT 37158 662 6 die die VBP 37158 662 7 of of IN 37158 662 8 old old JJ 37158 662 9 age age NN 37158 662 10 is be VBZ 37158 662 11 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 662 12 enviable enviable JJ 37158 662 13 . . . 37158 663 1 How how WRB 37158 663 2 many many JJ 37158 663 3 poor poor JJ 37158 663 4 old old JJ 37158 663 5 dogs dog NNS 37158 663 6 have have VBP 37158 663 7 I -PRON- PRP 37158 663 8 seen see VBN 37158 663 9 , , , 37158 663 10 impotent impotent JJ 37158 663 11 from from IN 37158 663 12 rheumatism rheumatism NN 37158 663 13 , , , 37158 663 14 completely completely RB 37158 663 15 blind blind JJ 37158 663 16 , , , 37158 663 17 no no RB 37158 663 18 longer long RBR 37158 663 19 able able JJ 37158 663 20 to to TO 37158 663 21 crawl crawl VB 37158 663 22 about about IN 37158 663 23 , , , 37158 663 24 covered cover VBN 37158 663 25 with with IN 37158 663 26 disgusting disgust VBG 37158 663 27 ulcers ulcer NNS 37158 663 28 , , , 37158 663 29 seeming seem VBG 37158 663 30 to to TO 37158 663 31 beg beg VB 37158 663 32 for for IN 37158 663 33 the the DT 37158 663 34 finishing finish VBG 37158 663 35 stroke stroke NN 37158 663 36 which which WDT 37158 663 37 would would MD 37158 663 38 put put VB 37158 663 39 an an DT 37158 663 40 end end NN 37158 663 41 to to IN 37158 663 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 663 43 misery misery NN 37158 663 44 ! ! . 37158 664 1 And and CC 37158 664 2 old old JJ 37158 664 3 , , , 37158 664 4 worn wear VBN 37158 664 5 - - HYPH 37158 664 6 out out RP 37158 664 7 horses horse NNS 37158 664 8 ! ! . 37158 665 1 What what WDT 37158 665 2 a a DT 37158 665 3 spectacle spectacle NN 37158 665 4 ! ! . 37158 666 1 This this DT 37158 666 2 residuum residuum NN 37158 666 3 of of IN 37158 666 4 existence existence NN 37158 666 5 of of IN 37158 666 6 old old JJ 37158 666 7 animals animal NNS 37158 666 8 is be VBZ 37158 666 9 truly truly RB 37158 666 10 pitiable pitiable JJ 37158 666 11 , , , 37158 666 12 and and CC 37158 666 13 , , , 37158 666 14 taking take VBG 37158 666 15 everything everything NN 37158 666 16 into into IN 37158 666 17 consideration consideration NN 37158 666 18 , , , 37158 666 19 it -PRON- PRP 37158 666 20 is be VBZ 37158 666 21 not not RB 37158 666 22 an an DT 37158 666 23 enormous enormous JJ 37158 666 24 dose dose NN 37158 666 25 of of IN 37158 666 26 happiness happiness NN 37158 666 27 we -PRON- PRP 37158 666 28 have have VBP 37158 666 29 left leave VBN 37158 666 30 them -PRON- PRP 37158 666 31 in in IN 37158 666 32 not not RB 37158 666 33 sacrificing sacrifice VBG 37158 666 34 them -PRON- PRP 37158 666 35 when when WRB 37158 666 36 they -PRON- PRP 37158 666 37 were be VBD 37158 666 38 young young JJ 37158 666 39 . . . 37158 667 1 But but CC 37158 667 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 667 3 shall shall MD 37158 667 4 not not RB 37158 667 5 dwell dwell VB 37158 667 6 upon upon IN 37158 667 7 this this DT 37158 667 8 argument argument NN 37158 667 9 , , , 37158 667 10 for for IN 37158 667 11 it -PRON- PRP 37158 667 12 might may MD 37158 667 13 also also RB 37158 667 14 be be VB 37158 667 15 applied apply VBN 37158 667 16 to to IN 37158 667 17 human human JJ 37158 667 18 beings being NNS 37158 667 19 . . . 37158 668 1 The the DT 37158 668 2 Greeks Greeks NNPS 37158 668 3 said say VBD 37158 668 4 : : : 37158 668 5 " " `` 37158 668 6 Happy happy JJ 37158 668 7 are be VBP 37158 668 8 they -PRON- PRP 37158 668 9 who who WP 37158 668 10 die die VBP 37158 668 11 young young JJ 37158 668 12 , , , 37158 668 13 for for IN 37158 668 14 they -PRON- PRP 37158 668 15 are be VBP 37158 668 16 beloved beloved JJ 37158 668 17 of of IN 37158 668 18 the the DT 37158 668 19 gods god NNS 37158 668 20 . . . 37158 668 21 " " '' 37158 669 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 37158 669 2 some some DT 37158 669 3 day day NN 37158 669 4 human human JJ 37158 669 5 ethics ethic NNS 37158 669 6 will will MD 37158 669 7 allow allow VB 37158 669 8 us -PRON- PRP 37158 669 9 to to TO 37158 669 10 spare spare VB 37158 669 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 669 12 dear dear JJ 37158 669 13 ones one NNS 37158 669 14 the the DT 37158 669 15 cruel cruel JJ 37158 669 16 and and CC 37158 669 17 useless useless JJ 37158 669 18 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 669 19 of of IN 37158 669 20 old old JJ 37158 669 21 age age NN 37158 669 22 ! ! . 37158 670 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 670 2 know know VBP 37158 670 3 not not RB 37158 670 4 . . . 37158 671 1 But but CC 37158 671 2 what what WP 37158 671 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 671 4 do do VBP 37158 671 5 know know VB 37158 671 6 is be VBZ 37158 671 7 that that IN 37158 671 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 671 9 is be VBZ 37158 671 10 not not RB 37158 671 11 inhuman inhuman JJ 37158 671 12 to to TO 37158 671 13 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37158 671 14 an an DT 37158 671 15 old old JJ 37158 671 16 horse horse NN 37158 671 17 or or CC 37158 671 18 an an DT 37158 671 19 old old JJ 37158 671 20 dog dog NN 37158 671 21 in in IN 37158 671 22 order order NN 37158 671 23 to to TO 37158 671 24 save save VB 37158 671 25 it -PRON- PRP 37158 671 26 from from IN 37158 671 27 going go VBG 37158 671 28 through through IN 37158 671 29 all all PDT 37158 671 30 the the DT 37158 671 31 tortures torture NNS 37158 671 32 which which WDT 37158 671 33 old old JJ 37158 671 34 age age NN 37158 671 35 and and CC 37158 671 36 disease disease NN 37158 671 37 hold hold VBP 37158 671 38 in in IN 37158 671 39 reserve reserve NN 37158 671 40 for for IN 37158 671 41 him -PRON- PRP 37158 671 42 . . . 37158 672 1 In in IN 37158 672 2 any any DT 37158 672 3 case case NN 37158 672 4 , , , 37158 672 5 the the DT 37158 672 6 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 672 7 produced produce VBN 37158 672 8 by by IN 37158 672 9 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 672 10 who who WP 37158 672 11 inoculate inoculate VBP 37158 672 12 diseases disease NNS 37158 672 13 into into IN 37158 672 14 animals animal NNS 37158 672 15 weigh weigh VBP 37158 672 16 very very RB 37158 672 17 little little JJ 37158 672 18 in in IN 37158 672 19 comparison comparison NN 37158 672 20 with with IN 37158 672 21 natural natural JJ 37158 672 22 suffering suffering NN 37158 672 23 , , , 37158 672 24 not not RB 37158 672 25 only only RB 37158 672 26 because because IN 37158 672 27 the the DT 37158 672 28 suffering suffering NN 37158 672 29 of of IN 37158 672 30 animals animal NNS 37158 672 31 is be VBZ 37158 672 32 always always RB 37158 672 33 more more RBR 37158 672 34 or or CC 37158 672 35 less less RBR 37158 672 36 immersed immersed JJ 37158 672 37 in in IN 37158 672 38 the the DT 37158 672 39 nihilism nihilism NN 37158 672 40 of of IN 37158 672 41 semi semi JJ 37158 672 42 - - NN 37158 672 43 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 672 44 , , , 37158 672 45 but but CC 37158 672 46 also also RB 37158 672 47 because because IN 37158 672 48 these these DT 37158 672 49 experimental experimental JJ 37158 672 50 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 672 51 are be VBP 37158 672 52 less less JJR 37158 672 53 than than IN 37158 672 54 natural natural JJ 37158 672 55 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 672 56 , , , 37158 672 57 and and CC 37158 672 58 extend extend VB 37158 672 59 over over IN 37158 672 60 a a DT 37158 672 61 very very RB 37158 672 62 small small JJ 37158 672 63 number number NN 37158 672 64 of of IN 37158 672 65 victims victim NNS 37158 672 66 . . . 37158 673 1 _ _ NNP 37158 673 2 But but CC 37158 673 3 the the DT 37158 673 4 question question NN 37158 673 5 does do VBZ 37158 673 6 not not RB 37158 673 7 lie lie VB 37158 673 8 there there RB 37158 673 9 . . . 37158 673 10 _ _ NNP 37158 673 11 The the DT 37158 673 12 point point NN 37158 673 13 is be VBZ 37158 673 14 not not RB 37158 673 15 whether whether IN 37158 673 16 the the DT 37158 673 17 suffering suffering NN 37158 673 18 of of IN 37158 673 19 animals animal NNS 37158 673 20 be be VB 37158 673 21 a a DT 37158 673 22 large large JJ 37158 673 23 or or CC 37158 673 24 small small JJ 37158 673 25 quantity quantity NN 37158 673 26 in in IN 37158 673 27 nature nature NN 37158 673 28 from from IN 37158 673 29 an an DT 37158 673 30 absolute absolute JJ 37158 673 31 standpoint standpoint NN 37158 673 32 ; ; : 37158 673 33 the the DT 37158 673 34 question question NN 37158 673 35 is be VBZ 37158 673 36 a a DT 37158 673 37 higher high JJR 37158 673 38 one one NN 37158 673 39 : : : 37158 673 40 we -PRON- PRP 37158 673 41 must must MD 37158 673 42 ask ask VB 37158 673 43 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 673 44 if if IN 37158 673 45 the the DT 37158 673 46 fact fact NN 37158 673 47 of of IN 37158 673 48 inflicting inflict VBG 37158 673 49 pain pain NN 37158 673 50 is be VBZ 37158 673 51 compatible compatible JJ 37158 673 52 with with IN 37158 673 53 human human JJ 37158 673 54 morality morality NN 37158 673 55 . . . 37158 674 1 Tolstoi Tolstoi NNP 37158 674 2 says say VBZ 37158 674 3 somewhere somewhere RB 37158 674 4 that that IN 37158 674 5 the the DT 37158 674 6 sciences science NNS 37158 674 7 are be VBP 37158 674 8 nothing nothing NN 37158 674 9 , , , 37158 674 10 that that DT 37158 674 11 art art NN 37158 674 12 is be VBZ 37158 674 13 nothing nothing NN 37158 674 14 , , , 37158 674 15 that that IN 37158 674 16 the the DT 37158 674 17 true true JJ 37158 674 18 science science NN 37158 674 19 is be VBZ 37158 674 20 that that DT 37158 674 21 of of IN 37158 674 22 good good JJ 37158 674 23 and and CC 37158 674 24 evil evil NN 37158 674 25 , , , 37158 674 26 of of IN 37158 674 27 justice justice NN 37158 674 28 and and CC 37158 674 29 injustice injustice NN 37158 674 30 . . . 37158 675 1 Everything everything NN 37158 675 2 sinks sink VBZ 37158 675 3 into into IN 37158 675 4 insignificance insignificance NN 37158 675 5 in in IN 37158 675 6 presence presence NN 37158 675 7 of of IN 37158 675 8 this this DT 37158 675 9 great great JJ 37158 675 10 duty duty NN 37158 675 11 , , , 37158 675 12 or or CC 37158 675 13 rather rather RB 37158 675 14 life life NN 37158 675 15 has have VBZ 37158 675 16 no no DT 37158 675 17 other other JJ 37158 675 18 object object NN 37158 675 19 . . . 37158 676 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 676 2 should should MD 37158 676 3 be be VB 37158 676 4 entirely entirely RB 37158 676 5 engrossed engross VBN 37158 676 6 in in IN 37158 676 7 doing do VBG 37158 676 8 good good NN 37158 676 9 ; ; : 37158 676 10 justice justice NN 37158 676 11 should should MD 37158 676 12 be be VB 37158 676 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 676 14 sole sole JJ 37158 676 15 preoccupation preoccupation NN 37158 676 16 . . . 37158 677 1 If if IN 37158 677 2 , , , 37158 677 3 then then RB 37158 677 4 , , , 37158 677 5 from from IN 37158 677 6 an an DT 37158 677 7 absolute absolute JJ 37158 677 8 point point NN 37158 677 9 of of IN 37158 677 10 view view NN 37158 677 11 the the DT 37158 677 12 suffering suffering NN 37158 677 13 of of IN 37158 677 14 frogs frog NNS 37158 677 15 and and CC 37158 677 16 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 677 17 does do VBZ 37158 677 18 not not RB 37158 677 19 count count VB 37158 677 20 , , , 37158 677 21 it -PRON- PRP 37158 677 22 counts count VBZ 37158 677 23 a a DT 37158 677 24 lot lot NN 37158 677 25 from from IN 37158 677 26 the the DT 37158 677 27 point point NN 37158 677 28 of of IN 37158 677 29 view view NN 37158 677 30 of of IN 37158 677 31 human human JJ 37158 677 32 morality morality NN 37158 677 33 . . . 37158 678 1 If if IN 37158 678 2 a a DT 37158 678 3 bad bad JJ 37158 678 4 child child NN 37158 678 5 should should MD 37158 678 6 martyrise martyrise VB 37158 678 7 a a DT 37158 678 8 toad toad NN 37158 678 9 , , , 37158 678 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 678 11 is be VBZ 37158 678 12 not not RB 37158 678 13 the the DT 37158 678 14 toad toad NN 37158 678 15 which which WDT 37158 678 16 would would MD 37158 678 17 interest interest VB 37158 678 18 me -PRON- PRP 37158 678 19 : : : 37158 678 20 poor poor JJ 37158 678 21 creature creature NN 37158 678 22 of of IN 37158 678 23 diffused diffused JJ 37158 678 24 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 678 25 , , , 37158 678 26 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 678 27 even even RB 37158 678 28 of of IN 37158 678 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 678 30 own own JJ 37158 678 31 pain pain NN 37158 678 32 , , , 37158 678 33 such such PDT 37158 678 34 a a DT 37158 678 35 tiny tiny JJ 37158 678 36 pain pain NN 37158 678 37 , , , 37158 678 38 too too RB 37158 678 39 , , , 37158 678 40 in in IN 37158 678 41 comparison comparison NN 37158 678 42 with with IN 37158 678 43 the the DT 37158 678 44 immense immense JJ 37158 678 45 pains pain NNS 37158 678 46 which which WDT 37158 678 47 the the DT 37158 678 48 beings being NNS 37158 678 49 of of IN 37158 678 50 this this DT 37158 678 51 great great JJ 37158 678 52 universe universe NN 37158 678 53 are be VBP 37158 678 54 suffering suffer VBG 37158 678 55 at at IN 37158 678 56 this this DT 37158 678 57 moment moment NN 37158 678 58 ! ! . 37158 679 1 No no UH 37158 679 2 ; ; : 37158 679 3 the the DT 37158 679 4 toad toad NN 37158 679 5 would would MD 37158 679 6 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 679 7 exist exist VB 37158 679 8 for for IN 37158 679 9 me -PRON- PRP 37158 679 10 . . . 37158 680 1 The the DT 37158 680 2 child child NN 37158 680 3 would would MD 37158 680 4 interest interest VB 37158 680 5 me -PRON- PRP 37158 680 6 greatly greatly RB 37158 680 7 ; ; : 37158 680 8 and and CC 37158 680 9 all all DT 37158 680 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 680 11 pity pity NN 37158 680 12 would would MD 37158 680 13 be be VB 37158 680 14 turned turn VBN 37158 680 15 upon upon IN 37158 680 16 that that DT 37158 680 17 cruel cruel JJ 37158 680 18 child child NN 37158 680 19 . . . 37158 681 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37158 681 2 efforts effort NNS 37158 681 3 would would MD 37158 681 4 tend tend VB 37158 681 5 much much RB 37158 681 6 less less JJR 37158 681 7 towards towards IN 37158 681 8 preventing prevent VBG 37158 681 9 the the DT 37158 681 10 toad toad NN 37158 681 11 from from IN 37158 681 12 suffering suffer VBG 37158 681 13 than than IN 37158 681 14 towards towards IN 37158 681 15 preventing prevent VBG 37158 681 16 that that DT 37158 681 17 human human NN 37158 681 18 being be VBG 37158 681 19 from from IN 37158 681 20 becoming become VBG 37158 681 21 a a DT 37158 681 22 barbarian barbarian NN 37158 681 23 . . . 37158 682 1 If if IN 37158 682 2 the the DT 37158 682 3 anti anti NNS 37158 682 4 - - NNS 37158 682 5 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 682 6 were be VBD 37158 682 7 true true JJ 37158 682 8 moralists moralist NNS 37158 682 9 and and CC 37158 682 10 not not RB 37158 682 11 fanatics fanatic NNS 37158 682 12 they -PRON- PRP 37158 682 13 would would MD 37158 682 14 say say VB 37158 682 15 : : : 37158 682 16 " " `` 37158 682 17 To to TO 37158 682 18 provoke provoke VB 37158 682 19 suffering suffering NN 37158 682 20 to to TO 37158 682 21 produce produce VB 37158 682 22 disease disease NN 37158 682 23 , , , 37158 682 24 to to TO 37158 682 25 inflict inflict VB 37158 682 26 tortures torture NNS 37158 682 27 , , , 37158 682 28 is be VBZ 37158 682 29 an an DT 37158 682 30 execrable execrable JJ 37158 682 31 moral moral JJ 37158 682 32 lesson lesson NN 37158 682 33 . . . 37158 683 1 Whilst whilst IN 37158 683 2 the the DT 37158 683 3 first first JJ 37158 683 4 duty duty NN 37158 683 5 of of IN 37158 683 6 man man NN 37158 683 7 is be VBZ 37158 683 8 to to TO 37158 683 9 be be VB 37158 683 10 good good JJ 37158 683 11 , , , 37158 683 12 you -PRON- PRP 37158 683 13 instruct instruct VBP 37158 683 14 young young JJ 37158 683 15 men man NNS 37158 683 16 to to TO 37158 683 17 be be VB 37158 683 18 wicked wicked JJ 37158 683 19 . . . 37158 684 1 The the DT 37158 684 2 doctor doctor NN 37158 684 3 , , , 37158 684 4 who who WP 37158 684 5 ought ought MD 37158 684 6 to to TO 37158 684 7 be be VB 37158 684 8 compassionate compassionate JJ 37158 684 9 for for IN 37158 684 10 human human JJ 37158 684 11 suffering suffering NN 37158 684 12 , , , 37158 684 13 should should MD 37158 684 14 not not RB 37158 684 15 serve serve VB 37158 684 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 684 17 apprenticeship apprenticeship NN 37158 684 18 in in IN 37158 684 19 that that DT 37158 684 20 noble noble JJ 37158 684 21 profession profession NN 37158 684 22 by by IN 37158 684 23 showing show VBG 37158 684 24 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 684 25 devoid devoid JJ 37158 684 26 of of IN 37158 684 27 pity pity NN 37158 684 28 for for IN 37158 684 29 the the DT 37158 684 30 suffering suffering NN 37158 684 31 of of IN 37158 684 32 innocent innocent JJ 37158 684 33 victims victim NNS 37158 684 34 . . . 37158 685 1 A a DT 37158 685 2 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 685 3 which which WDT 37158 685 4 allows allow VBZ 37158 685 5 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 685 6 to to TO 37158 685 7 inflict inflict VB 37158 685 8 death death NN 37158 685 9 and and CC 37158 685 10 torture torture NN 37158 685 11 on on IN 37158 685 12 living live VBG 37158 685 13 beings being NNS 37158 685 14 can can MD 37158 685 15 be be VB 37158 685 16 only only RB 37158 685 17 a a DT 37158 685 18 barbarous barbarous JJ 37158 685 19 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 685 20 . . . 37158 685 21 " " '' 37158 686 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 686 2 recognise recognise VBP 37158 686 3 the the DT 37158 686 4 force force NN 37158 686 5 of of IN 37158 686 6 that that DT 37158 686 7 argument argument NN 37158 686 8 . . . 37158 687 1 And and CC 37158 687 2 whilst whilst IN 37158 687 3 not not RB 37158 687 4 a a DT 37158 687 5 single single JJ 37158 687 6 one one CD 37158 687 7 of of IN 37158 687 8 the the DT 37158 687 9 preceding precede VBG 37158 687 10 assertions assertion NNS 37158 687 11 of of IN 37158 687 12 the the DT 37158 687 13 anti anti NNS 37158 687 14 - - NNS 37158 687 15 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 687 16 had have VBD 37158 687 17 succeeded succeed VBN 37158 687 18 in in IN 37158 687 19 moving move VBG 37158 687 20 me -PRON- PRP 37158 687 21 , , , 37158 687 22 I -PRON- PRP 37158 687 23 confess confess VBP 37158 687 24 that that IN 37158 687 25 this this DT 37158 687 26 objection objection NN 37158 687 27 of of IN 37158 687 28 human human JJ 37158 687 29 morality morality NN 37158 687 30 is be VBZ 37158 687 31 a a DT 37158 687 32 most most RBS 37158 687 33 powerful powerful JJ 37158 687 34 one one NN 37158 687 35 . . . 37158 688 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 688 2 am be VBP 37158 688 3 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37158 688 4 going go VBG 37158 688 5 to to TO 37158 688 6 try try VB 37158 688 7 to to TO 37158 688 8 show show VB 37158 688 9 that that IN 37158 688 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 688 11 is be VBZ 37158 688 12 not not RB 37158 688 13 admissible admissible JJ 37158 688 14 . . . 37158 689 1 And and CC 37158 689 2 first first RB 37158 689 3 of of IN 37158 689 4 all all DT 37158 689 5 , , , 37158 689 6 because because IN 37158 689 7 there there EX 37158 689 8 is be VBZ 37158 689 9 in in IN 37158 689 10 this this DT 37158 689 11 world world NN 37158 689 12 much much JJ 37158 689 13 suffering suffer VBG 37158 689 14 , , , 37158 689 15 human human JJ 37158 689 16 suffering suffering NN 37158 689 17 , , , 37158 689 18 which which WDT 37158 689 19 it -PRON- PRP 37158 689 20 is be VBZ 37158 689 21 more more RBR 37158 689 22 important important JJ 37158 689 23 to to TO 37158 689 24 allay allay VB 37158 689 25 than than IN 37158 689 26 that that DT 37158 689 27 of of IN 37158 689 28 the the DT 37158 689 29 victims victim NNS 37158 689 30 of of IN 37158 689 31 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 689 32 . . . 37158 690 1 If if IN 37158 690 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 690 3 sole sole JJ 37158 690 4 care care NN 37158 690 5 were be VBD 37158 690 6 that that DT 37158 690 7 of of IN 37158 690 8 morality morality NN 37158 690 9 , , , 37158 690 10 what what WP 37158 690 11 battles battle NNS 37158 690 12 would would MD 37158 690 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 690 14 not not RB 37158 690 15 have have VB 37158 690 16 to to TO 37158 690 17 fight fight VB 37158 690 18 ! ! . 37158 691 1 There there EX 37158 691 2 are be VBP 37158 691 3 thousands thousand NNS 37158 691 4 of of IN 37158 691 5 people people NNS 37158 691 6 in in IN 37158 691 7 India India NNP 37158 691 8 who who WP 37158 691 9 die die VBP 37158 691 10 of of IN 37158 691 11 hunger hunger NN 37158 691 12 ; ; : 37158 691 13 and and CC 37158 691 14 throughout throughout IN 37158 691 15 Asia Asia NNP 37158 691 16 whole whole JJ 37158 691 17 populations population NNS 37158 691 18 perish perish NN 37158 691 19 of of IN 37158 691 20 disease disease NN 37158 691 21 which which WDT 37158 691 22 a a DT 37158 691 23 little little JJ 37158 691 24 hygiene hygiene NN 37158 691 25 could could MD 37158 691 26 prevent prevent VB 37158 691 27 . . . 37158 692 1 The the DT 37158 692 2 hunger hunger NN 37158 692 3 - - HYPH 37158 692 4 evil evil NN 37158 692 5 is be VBZ 37158 692 6 rife rife NN 37158 692 7 in in IN 37158 692 8 Russia Russia NNP 37158 692 9 ; ; , 37158 692 10 most most JJS 37158 692 11 of of IN 37158 692 12 the the DT 37158 692 13 peasants peasant NNS 37158 692 14 in in IN 37158 692 15 Sicily Sicily NNP 37158 692 16 also also RB 37158 692 17 never never RB 37158 692 18 know know VBP 37158 692 19 what what WP 37158 692 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 692 21 is be VBZ 37158 692 22 to to TO 37158 692 23 satisfy satisfy VB 37158 692 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 692 25 hunger hunger NN 37158 692 26 . . . 37158 693 1 The the DT 37158 693 2 misery misery NN 37158 693 3 of of IN 37158 693 4 children child NNS 37158 693 5 is be VBZ 37158 693 6 lamentable lamentable JJ 37158 693 7 everywhere everywhere RB 37158 693 8 : : : 37158 693 9 in in IN 37158 693 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 693 11 large large JJ 37158 693 12 cities city NNS 37158 693 13 , , , 37158 693 14 Paris Paris NNP 37158 693 15 , , , 37158 693 16 Berlin Berlin NNP 37158 693 17 , , , 37158 693 18 London London NNP 37158 693 19 , , , 37158 693 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 693 21 is be VBZ 37158 693 22 not not RB 37158 693 23 exceptional exceptional JJ 37158 693 24 , , , 37158 693 25 alas alas UH 37158 693 26 ! ! . 37158 694 1 to to TO 37158 694 2 come come VB 37158 694 3 across across IN 37158 694 4 people people NNS 37158 694 5 dying die VBG 37158 694 6 of of IN 37158 694 7 hunger hunger NN 37158 694 8 . . . 37158 695 1 The the DT 37158 695 2 terribly terribly RB 37158 695 3 high high JJ 37158 695 4 rate rate NN 37158 695 5 of of IN 37158 695 6 mortality mortality NN 37158 695 7 among among IN 37158 695 8 children child NNS 37158 695 9 less less JJR 37158 695 10 than than IN 37158 695 11 a a DT 37158 695 12 year year NN 37158 695 13 old old JJ 37158 695 14 is be VBZ 37158 695 15 due due JJ 37158 695 16 to to IN 37158 695 17 hunger hunger NN 37158 695 18 and and CC 37158 695 19 to to TO 37158 695 20 hunger hunger VB 37158 695 21 alone alone RB 37158 695 22 . . . 37158 696 1 In in IN 37158 696 2 Europe Europe NNP 37158 696 3 two two CD 37158 696 4 million million CD 37158 696 5 children child NNS 37158 696 6 , , , 37158 696 7 under under IN 37158 696 8 one one CD 37158 696 9 year year NN 37158 696 10 of of IN 37158 696 11 age age NN 37158 696 12 , , , 37158 696 13 die die VBP 37158 696 14 every every DT 37158 696 15 year year NN 37158 696 16 solely solely RB 37158 696 17 because because IN 37158 696 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 696 19 parents parent NNS 37158 696 20 are be VBP 37158 696 21 plunged plunge VBN 37158 696 22 in in IN 37158 696 23 misery misery NN 37158 696 24 , , , 37158 696 25 because because IN 37158 696 26 the the DT 37158 696 27 mother mother NN 37158 696 28 , , , 37158 696 29 instead instead RB 37158 696 30 of of IN 37158 696 31 nursing nurse VBG 37158 696 32 her -PRON- PRP$ 37158 696 33 child child NN 37158 696 34 , , , 37158 696 35 is be VBZ 37158 696 36 forced force VBN 37158 696 37 to to TO 37158 696 38 work work VB 37158 696 39 , , , 37158 696 40 to to TO 37158 696 41 earn earn VB 37158 696 42 her -PRON- PRP 37158 696 43 living live VBG 37158 696 44 at at IN 37158 696 45 manual manual JJ 37158 696 46 labour labour NN 37158 696 47 , , , 37158 696 48 which which WDT 37158 696 49 dries dry VBZ 37158 696 50 up up RP 37158 696 51 her -PRON- PRP$ 37158 696 52 milk milk NN 37158 696 53 . . . 37158 697 1 _ _ NNP 37158 697 2 These these DT 37158 697 3 two two CD 37158 697 4 million million CD 37158 697 5 children child NNS 37158 697 6 who who WP 37158 697 7 die die VBP 37158 697 8 of of IN 37158 697 9 hunger hunger NN 37158 697 10 are be VBP 37158 697 11 the the DT 37158 697 12 disgrace disgrace NN 37158 697 13 of of IN 37158 697 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 697 15 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 697 16 . . . 37158 697 17 _ _ NNP 37158 697 18 And and CC 37158 697 19 yet yet RB 37158 697 20 we -PRON- PRP 37158 697 21 continue continue VBP 37158 697 22 to to TO 37158 697 23 live live VB 37158 697 24 in in IN 37158 697 25 luxury luxury NN 37158 697 26 , , , 37158 697 27 we -PRON- PRP 37158 697 28 look look VBP 37158 697 29 on on IN 37158 697 30 calmly calmly RB 37158 697 31 and and CC 37158 697 32 indifferently indifferently RB 37158 697 33 at at IN 37158 697 34 the the DT 37158 697 35 agony agony NN 37158 697 36 of of IN 37158 697 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 697 38 human human JJ 37158 697 39 brothers brother NNS 37158 697 40 , , , 37158 697 41 an an DT 37158 697 42 agony agony NN 37158 697 43 which which WDT 37158 697 44 we -PRON- PRP 37158 697 45 could could MD 37158 697 46 easily easily RB 37158 697 47 alleviate alleviate VB 37158 697 48 . . . 37158 698 1 For for IN 37158 698 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 698 3 part part NN 37158 698 4 , , , 37158 698 5 willingly willingly RB 37158 698 6 shall shall MD 37158 698 7 I -PRON- PRP 37158 698 8 allow allow VB 37158 698 9 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 698 10 to to TO 37158 698 11 be be VB 37158 698 12 melted melt VBN 37158 698 13 with with IN 37158 698 14 pity pity NN 37158 698 15 at at IN 37158 698 16 the the DT 37158 698 17 sight sight NN 37158 698 18 of of IN 37158 698 19 tuberculous tuberculous JJ 37158 698 20 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 698 21 when when WRB 37158 698 22 I -PRON- PRP 37158 698 23 see see VBP 37158 698 24 those those DT 37158 698 25 persons person NNS 37158 698 26 who who WP 37158 698 27 champion champion VBP 37158 698 28 these these DT 37158 698 29 same same JJ 37158 698 30 rabbits rabbit NNS 37158 698 31 , , , 37158 698 32 develop develop VB 37158 698 33 within within IN 37158 698 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 698 35 some some DT 37158 698 36 pity pity NN 37158 698 37 for for IN 37158 698 38 human human JJ 37158 698 39 suffering suffering NN 37158 698 40 , , , 37158 698 41 a a DT 37158 698 42 pity pity NN 37158 698 43 grown grow VBN 37158 698 44 so so RB 37158 698 45 deep deep JJ 37158 698 46 , , , 37158 698 47 so so RB 37158 698 48 powerful powerful JJ 37158 698 49 , , , 37158 698 50 that that IN 37158 698 51 they -PRON- PRP 37158 698 52 devote devote VBP 37158 698 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 698 54 entire entire JJ 37158 698 55 fortune fortune NN 37158 698 56 towards towards IN 37158 698 57 rescuing rescue VBG 37158 698 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 698 59 brethren brother NNS 37158 698 60 from from IN 37158 698 61 death death NN 37158 698 62 through through IN 37158 698 63 hunger hunger NN 37158 698 64 . . . 37158 699 1 There there EX 37158 699 2 is be VBZ 37158 699 3 not not RB 37158 699 4 only only RB 37158 699 5 famine famine NN 37158 699 6 and and CC 37158 699 7 want want VBP 37158 699 8 . . . 37158 700 1 There there EX 37158 700 2 are be VBP 37158 700 3 many many JJ 37158 700 4 other other JJ 37158 700 5 social social JJ 37158 700 6 scourges scourge NNS 37158 700 7 ; ; : 37158 700 8 and and CC 37158 700 9 these these DT 37158 700 10 scourges scourge NNS 37158 700 11 are be VBP 37158 700 12 much much RB 37158 700 13 more more RBR 37158 700 14 serious serious JJ 37158 700 15 than than IN 37158 700 16 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 700 17 can can MD 37158 700 18 ever ever RB 37158 700 19 become become VB 37158 700 20 . . . 37158 701 1 There there EX 37158 701 2 is be VBZ 37158 701 3 alcoholism alcoholism NN 37158 701 4 , , , 37158 701 5 prostitution prostitution NN 37158 701 6 , , , 37158 701 7 war war NN 37158 701 8 . . . 37158 702 1 And and CC 37158 702 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 702 3 have have VBP 37158 702 4 no no DT 37158 702 5 need need NN 37158 702 6 to to TO 37158 702 7 say say VB 37158 702 8 that that IN 37158 702 9 alcoholism alcoholism NN 37158 702 10 is be VBZ 37158 702 11 an an DT 37158 702 12 evil evil NN 37158 702 13 , , , 37158 702 14 that that DT 37158 702 15 prostitution prostitution NN 37158 702 16 is be VBZ 37158 702 17 an an DT 37158 702 18 evil evil NN 37158 702 19 , , , 37158 702 20 that that DT 37158 702 21 war war NN 37158 702 22 is be VBZ 37158 702 23 an an DT 37158 702 24 evil evil NN 37158 702 25 . . . 37158 703 1 When when WRB 37158 703 2 human human JJ 37158 703 3 morality morality NN 37158 703 4 has have VBZ 37158 703 5 been be VBN 37158 703 6 developed develop VBN 37158 703 7 to to IN 37158 703 8 such such PDT 37158 703 9 a a DT 37158 703 10 pitch pitch NN 37158 703 11 that that DT 37158 703 12 man man NN 37158 703 13 will will MD 37158 703 14 no no RB 37158 703 15 longer longer RB 37158 703 16 be be VB 37158 703 17 able able JJ 37158 703 18 to to TO 37158 703 19 look look VB 37158 703 20 on on IN 37158 703 21 these these DT 37158 703 22 great great JJ 37158 703 23 social social JJ 37158 703 24 miseries misery NNS 37158 703 25 without without IN 37158 703 26 horror horror NN 37158 703 27 , , , 37158 703 28 it -PRON- PRP 37158 703 29 will will MD 37158 703 30 be be VB 37158 703 31 time time NN 37158 703 32 enough enough RB 37158 703 33 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 703 34 to to TO 37158 703 35 ask ask VB 37158 703 36 if if IN 37158 703 37 it -PRON- PRP 37158 703 38 be be VB 37158 703 39 permissible permissible JJ 37158 703 40 to to TO 37158 703 41 seek seek VB 37158 703 42 for for IN 37158 703 43 truth truth NN 37158 703 44 at at IN 37158 703 45 the the DT 37158 703 46 expense expense NN 37158 703 47 of of IN 37158 703 48 a a DT 37158 703 49 little little JJ 37158 703 50 animal animal NN 37158 703 51 suffering suffering NN 37158 703 52 . . . 37158 704 1 But but CC 37158 704 2 until until IN 37158 704 3 then then RB 37158 704 4 I -PRON- PRP 37158 704 5 have have VBP 37158 704 6 the the DT 37158 704 7 right right NN 37158 704 8 to to TO 37158 704 9 stigmatise stigmatise VB 37158 704 10 as as IN 37158 704 11 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 37158 704 12 all all PDT 37158 704 13 that that IN 37158 704 14 immense immense JJ 37158 704 15 pity pity NN 37158 704 16 which which WDT 37158 704 17 certain certain JJ 37158 704 18 people people NNS 37158 704 19 profess profess JJ 37158 704 20 for for IN 37158 704 21 dogs dog NNS 37158 704 22 , , , 37158 704 23 side side NN 37158 704 24 by by IN 37158 704 25 side side NN 37158 704 26 with with IN 37158 704 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 704 28 immense immense JJ 37158 704 29 heedlessness heedlessness NN 37158 704 30 , , , 37158 704 31 which which WDT 37158 704 32 they -PRON- PRP 37158 704 33 do do VBP 37158 704 34 not not RB 37158 704 35 fear fear VB 37158 704 36 to to TO 37158 704 37 display display VB 37158 704 38 , , , 37158 704 39 towards towards IN 37158 704 40 the the DT 37158 704 41 fate fate NN 37158 704 42 of of IN 37158 704 43 so so RB 37158 704 44 many many JJ 37158 704 45 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 704 46 human human JJ 37158 704 47 beings being NNS 37158 704 48 . . . 37158 705 1 If if IN 37158 705 2 anti anti NNS 37158 705 3 - - NNS 37158 705 4 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 705 5 were be VBD 37158 705 6 animated animate VBN 37158 705 7 by by IN 37158 705 8 a a DT 37158 705 9 great great JJ 37158 705 10 desire desire NN 37158 705 11 for for IN 37158 705 12 morality morality NN 37158 705 13 , , , 37158 705 14 they -PRON- PRP 37158 705 15 would would MD 37158 705 16 endeavour endeavour VB 37158 705 17 to to TO 37158 705 18 reform reform VB 37158 705 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 705 20 social social JJ 37158 705 21 condition condition NN 37158 705 22 , , , 37158 705 23 which which WDT 37158 705 24 is be VBZ 37158 705 25 abominable abominable JJ 37158 705 26 and and CC 37158 705 27 full full JJ 37158 705 28 of of IN 37158 705 29 horrors horror NNS 37158 705 30 ; ; : 37158 705 31 they -PRON- PRP 37158 705 32 would would MD 37158 705 33 strive strive VB 37158 705 34 to to IN 37158 705 35 impart impart VB 37158 705 36 into into IN 37158 705 37 youth youth NN 37158 705 38 other other JJ 37158 705 39 notions notion NNS 37158 705 40 than than IN 37158 705 41 that that DT 37158 705 42 of of IN 37158 705 43 smug smug JJ 37158 705 44 satisfaction satisfaction NN 37158 705 45 with with IN 37158 705 46 the the DT 37158 705 47 present present JJ 37158 705 48 social social JJ 37158 705 49 conditions condition NNS 37158 705 50 . . . 37158 706 1 As as RB 37158 706 2 long long RB 37158 706 3 as as IN 37158 706 4 we -PRON- PRP 37158 706 5 have have VBP 37158 706 6 not not RB 37158 706 7 faced face VBN 37158 706 8 the the DT 37158 706 9 profound profound JJ 37158 706 10 evils evil NNS 37158 706 11 which which WDT 37158 706 12 gnaw gnaw VBP 37158 706 13 at at IN 37158 706 14 the the DT 37158 706 15 root root NN 37158 706 16 of of IN 37158 706 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 706 18 social social JJ 37158 706 19 system system NN 37158 706 20 , , , 37158 706 21 as as RB 37158 706 22 long long RB 37158 706 23 as as IN 37158 706 24 we -PRON- PRP 37158 706 25 take take VBP 37158 706 26 a a DT 37158 706 27 delight delight NN 37158 706 28 in in IN 37158 706 29 the the DT 37158 706 30 egotistical egotistical JJ 37158 706 31 satisfaction satisfaction NN 37158 706 32 of of IN 37158 706 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 706 34 capitalist capitalist JJ 37158 706 35 and and CC 37158 706 36 martial martial JJ 37158 706 37 society society NN 37158 706 38 , , , 37158 706 39 it -PRON- PRP 37158 706 40 is be VBZ 37158 706 41 not not RB 37158 706 42 permissible permissible JJ 37158 706 43 , , , 37158 706 44 if if IN 37158 706 45 we -PRON- PRP 37158 706 46 would would MD 37158 706 47 not not RB 37158 706 48 be be VB 37158 706 49 accused accuse VBN 37158 706 50 of of IN 37158 706 51 scandalous scandalous JJ 37158 706 52 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 37158 706 53 , , , 37158 706 54 to to TO 37158 706 55 affect affect VB 37158 706 56 pretensions pretension NNS 37158 706 57 to to IN 37158 706 58 morality morality NN 37158 706 59 . . . 37158 707 1 Even even RB 37158 707 2 from from IN 37158 707 3 the the DT 37158 707 4 very very RB 37158 707 5 exclusive exclusive JJ 37158 707 6 and and CC 37158 707 7 rather rather RB 37158 707 8 paltry paltry NN 37158 707 9 point point NN 37158 707 10 of of IN 37158 707 11 view view NN 37158 707 12 of of IN 37158 707 13 animals animal NNS 37158 707 14 ' ' POS 37158 707 15 rights right NNS 37158 707 16 , , , 37158 707 17 are be VBP 37158 707 18 there there EX 37158 707 19 not not RB 37158 707 20 among among IN 37158 707 21 anti anti NNS 37158 707 22 - - NNS 37158 707 23 vivisectionists vivisectionist VBZ 37158 707 24 those those DT 37158 707 25 of of IN 37158 707 26 social social JJ 37158 707 27 position position NN 37158 707 28 who who WP 37158 707 29 make make VBP 37158 707 30 no no DT 37158 707 31 scruple scruple NN 37158 707 32 in in IN 37158 707 33 amusing amuse VBG 37158 707 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 707 35 by by IN 37158 707 36 fishing fishing NN 37158 707 37 and and CC 37158 707 38 hunting hunting NN 37158 707 39 ? ? . 37158 708 1 In in IN 37158 708 2 this this DT 37158 708 3 case case NN 37158 708 4 they -PRON- PRP 37158 708 5 kill kill VBP 37158 708 6 , , , 37158 708 7 they -PRON- PRP 37158 708 8 martyrise martyrise VBP 37158 708 9 , , , 37158 708 10 not not RB 37158 708 11 to to TO 37158 708 12 conquer conquer VB 37158 708 13 new new JJ 37158 708 14 truths truth NNS 37158 708 15 , , , 37158 708 16 but but CC 37158 708 17 for for IN 37158 708 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 708 19 amusement amusement NN 37158 708 20 and and CC 37158 708 21 recreation recreation NN 37158 708 22 . . . 37158 709 1 The the DT 37158 709 2 hunter hunter NN 37158 709 3 who who WP 37158 709 4 fires fire VBZ 37158 709 5 at at IN 37158 709 6 a a DT 37158 709 7 hare hare NN 37158 709 8 sends send VBZ 37158 709 9 after after IN 37158 709 10 the the DT 37158 709 11 wounded wound VBN 37158 709 12 animal animal NN 37158 709 13 a a DT 37158 709 14 savage savage NN 37158 709 15 dog dog NN 37158 709 16 , , , 37158 709 17 trained train VBN 37158 709 18 to to TO 37158 709 19 fierceness fierceness VB 37158 709 20 for for IN 37158 709 21 this this DT 37158 709 22 pursuit pursuit NN 37158 709 23 , , , 37158 709 24 and and CC 37158 709 25 he -PRON- PRP 37158 709 26 looks look VBZ 37158 709 27 on on IN 37158 709 28 at at IN 37158 709 29 the the DT 37158 709 30 chase chase NN 37158 709 31 with with IN 37158 709 32 delight delight NN 37158 709 33 . . . 37158 710 1 The the DT 37158 710 2 angler angler NN 37158 710 3 who who WP 37158 710 4 has have VBZ 37158 710 5 hooked hook VBN 37158 710 6 a a DT 37158 710 7 fish fish NN 37158 710 8 feels feel VBZ 37158 710 9 a a DT 37158 710 10 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 37158 710 11 emotion emotion NN 37158 710 12 when when WRB 37158 710 13 he -PRON- PRP 37158 710 14 holds hold VBZ 37158 710 15 in in IN 37158 710 16 the the DT 37158 710 17 palm palm NN 37158 710 18 of of IN 37158 710 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 710 20 hand hand NN 37158 710 21 the the DT 37158 710 22 struggling struggling NN 37158 710 23 , , , 37158 710 24 writhing writhe VBG 37158 710 25 being be VBG 37158 710 26 . . . 37158 711 1 Elegant elegant JJ 37158 711 2 sportsmen sportsman NNS 37158 711 3 aim aim VBP 37158 711 4 at at IN 37158 711 5 pigeons pigeon NNS 37158 711 6 to to TO 37158 711 7 give give VB 37158 711 8 proofs proof NNS 37158 711 9 of of IN 37158 711 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 711 11 dexterity dexterity NN 37158 711 12 . . . 37158 712 1 A a DT 37158 712 2 large large JJ 37158 712 3 number number NN 37158 712 4 of of IN 37158 712 5 victims victim NNS 37158 712 6 do do VBP 37158 712 7 not not RB 37158 712 8 die die VB 37158 712 9 on on IN 37158 712 10 the the DT 37158 712 11 spot spot NN 37158 712 12 , , , 37158 712 13 but but CC 37158 712 14 , , , 37158 712 15 with with IN 37158 712 16 wounded wound VBN 37158 712 17 wing wing NN 37158 712 18 , , , 37158 712 19 or or CC 37158 712 20 chest chest NN 37158 712 21 pierced pierce VBN 37158 712 22 with with IN 37158 712 23 lead lead NN 37158 712 24 , , , 37158 712 25 creep creep VB 37158 712 26 away away RB 37158 712 27 to to TO 37158 712 28 die die VB 37158 712 29 in in IN 37158 712 30 agony agony NN 37158 712 31 in in IN 37158 712 32 the the DT 37158 712 33 neighbouring neighbour VBG 37158 712 34 woods wood NNS 37158 712 35 . . . 37158 713 1 Quite quite PDT 37158 713 2 a a DT 37158 713 3 large large JJ 37158 713 4 gathering gathering NN 37158 713 5 of of IN 37158 713 6 fashionable fashionable JJ 37158 713 7 young young JJ 37158 713 8 women woman NNS 37158 713 9 and and CC 37158 713 10 distinguished distinguished JJ 37158 713 11 young young JJ 37158 713 12 men man NNS 37158 713 13 follow follow VB 37158 713 14 on on IN 37158 713 15 horseback horseback NN 37158 713 16 the the DT 37158 713 17 tortures torture NNS 37158 713 18 of of IN 37158 713 19 a a DT 37158 713 20 wretched wretched JJ 37158 713 21 stag stag NN 37158 713 22 pursued pursue VBN 37158 713 23 by by IN 37158 713 24 a a DT 37158 713 25 furious furious JJ 37158 713 26 pack pack NN 37158 713 27 of of IN 37158 713 28 hounds hound NNS 37158 713 29 . . . 37158 714 1 And and CC 37158 714 2 , , , 37158 714 3 finally finally RB 37158 714 4 , , , 37158 714 5 the the DT 37158 714 6 entire entire JJ 37158 714 7 population population NN 37158 714 8 of of IN 37158 714 9 a a DT 37158 714 10 large large JJ 37158 714 11 city city NN 37158 714 12 ( ( -LRB- 37158 714 13 Seville Seville NNP 37158 714 14 or or CC 37158 714 15 Madrid Madrid NNP 37158 714 16 , , , 37158 714 17 San San NNP 37158 714 18 Sebastian Sebastian NNP 37158 714 19 or or CC 37158 714 20 Valencia Valencia NNP 37158 714 21 ) ) -RRB- 37158 714 22 , , , 37158 714 23 men man NNS 37158 714 24 and and CC 37158 714 25 women woman NNS 37158 714 26 , , , 37158 714 27 old old JJ 37158 714 28 and and CC 37158 714 29 young young JJ 37158 714 30 , , , 37158 714 31 go go VB 37158 714 32 crazy crazy JJ 37158 714 33 with with IN 37158 714 34 delight delight NN 37158 714 35 at at IN 37158 714 36 the the DT 37158 714 37 hideous hideous JJ 37158 714 38 spectacle spectacle NN 37158 714 39 of of IN 37158 714 40 a a DT 37158 714 41 noble noble JJ 37158 714 42 bull bull NN 37158 714 43 disembowelling disembowel VBG 37158 714 44 horses horse NNS 37158 714 45 , , , 37158 714 46 tormented torment VBN 37158 714 47 by by IN 37158 714 48 the the DT 37158 714 49 picadors picador NNS 37158 714 50 , , , 37158 714 51 and and CC 37158 714 52 finally finally RB 37158 714 53 succumbing succumb VBG 37158 714 54 , , , 37158 714 55 exhausted exhausted JJ 37158 714 56 , , , 37158 714 57 done do VBN 37158 714 58 to to IN 37158 714 59 death death NN 37158 714 60 by by IN 37158 714 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 714 62 cowardly cowardly JJ 37158 714 63 enemies enemy NNS 37158 714 64 . . . 37158 715 1 There there EX 37158 715 2 are be VBP 37158 715 3 sights sight NNS 37158 715 4 for for IN 37158 715 5 you -PRON- PRP 37158 715 6 ! ! . 37158 716 1 there there EX 37158 716 2 are be VBP 37158 716 3 amusements amusement NNS 37158 716 4 for for IN 37158 716 5 you -PRON- PRP 37158 716 6 if if IN 37158 716 7 you -PRON- PRP 37158 716 8 like like VBP 37158 716 9 , , , 37158 716 10 which which WDT 37158 716 11 reflect reflect VBP 37158 716 12 scant scant JJ 37158 716 13 honour honour NN 37158 716 14 on on IN 37158 716 15 human human JJ 37158 716 16 ethics ethic NNS 37158 716 17 ; ; : 37158 716 18 and and CC 37158 716 19 well well RB 37158 716 20 do do VBP 37158 716 21 I -PRON- PRP 37158 716 22 understand understand VB 37158 716 23 generous generous JJ 37158 716 24 - - HYPH 37158 716 25 hearted hearted JJ 37158 716 26 men man NNS 37158 716 27 and and CC 37158 716 28 women woman NNS 37158 716 29 forming form VBG 37158 716 30 societies society NNS 37158 716 31 to to TO 37158 716 32 combat combat VB 37158 716 33 war war NN 37158 716 34 , , , 37158 716 35 alcoholism alcoholism NN 37158 716 36 , , , 37158 716 37 prostitution prostitution NN 37158 716 38 , , , 37158 716 39 distributing distribute VBG 37158 716 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 716 41 wealth wealth NN 37158 716 42 among among IN 37158 716 43 the the DT 37158 716 44 starving starve VBG 37158 716 45 populations population NNS 37158 716 46 , , , 37158 716 47 also also RB 37158 716 48 turning turn VBG 37158 716 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 716 50 energies energy NNS 37158 716 51 against against IN 37158 716 52 hunting hunting NN 37158 716 53 , , , 37158 716 54 angling angling NN 37158 716 55 , , , 37158 716 56 pigeon pigeon NN 37158 716 57 - - HYPH 37158 716 58 shooting shooting NN 37158 716 59 , , , 37158 716 60 and and CC 37158 716 61 bullfights bullfight NNS 37158 716 62 . . . 37158 717 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 717 2 is be VBZ 37158 717 3 a a DT 37158 717 4 noble noble JJ 37158 717 5 programme programme NN 37158 717 6 of of IN 37158 717 7 life life NN 37158 717 8 which which WDT 37158 717 9 they -PRON- PRP 37158 717 10 have have VBP 37158 717 11 drawn draw VBN 37158 717 12 up up RP 37158 717 13 for for IN 37158 717 14 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 717 15 , , , 37158 717 16 and and CC 37158 717 17 such such JJ 37158 717 18 people people NNS 37158 717 19 merit merit VBP 37158 717 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 717 21 highest high JJS 37158 717 22 admiration admiration NN 37158 717 23 . . . 37158 718 1 Societies society NNS 37158 718 2 for for IN 37158 718 3 the the DT 37158 718 4 prevention prevention NN 37158 718 5 of of IN 37158 718 6 cruelty cruelty NNP 37158 718 7 to to IN 37158 718 8 animals animal NNS 37158 718 9 are be VBP 37158 718 10 admirable admirable JJ 37158 718 11 and and CC 37158 718 12 irreproachable irreproachable JJ 37158 718 13 when when WRB 37158 718 14 they -PRON- PRP 37158 718 15 defend defend VBP 37158 718 16 animals animal NNS 37158 718 17 against against IN 37158 718 18 human human JJ 37158 718 19 savagery savagery NN 37158 718 20 : : : 37158 718 21 for for IN 37158 718 22 example example NN 37158 718 23 , , , 37158 718 24 when when WRB 37158 718 25 they -PRON- PRP 37158 718 26 prevent prevent VBP 37158 718 27 carters carter NNS 37158 718 28 from from IN 37158 718 29 lashing lash VBG 37158 718 30 into into IN 37158 718 31 ribbons ribbon NNS 37158 718 32 the the DT 37158 718 33 skin skin NN 37158 718 34 of of IN 37158 718 35 the the DT 37158 718 36 miserable miserable JJ 37158 718 37 horses horse NNS 37158 718 38 under under IN 37158 718 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 718 40 charge charge NN 37158 718 41 ; ; : 37158 718 42 or or CC 37158 718 43 when when WRB 37158 718 44 they -PRON- PRP 37158 718 45 put put VBD 37158 718 46 down down RP 37158 718 47 the the DT 37158 718 48 practice practice NN 37158 718 49 of of IN 37158 718 50 harnessing harness VBG 37158 718 51 a a DT 37158 718 52 horse horse NN 37158 718 53 to to IN 37158 718 54 a a DT 37158 718 55 cart cart NN 37158 718 56 too too RB 37158 718 57 heavily heavily RB 37158 718 58 loaded loaded JJ 37158 718 59 ; ; : 37158 718 60 or or CC 37158 718 61 when when WRB 37158 718 62 they -PRON- PRP 37158 718 63 interdict interdict VBP 37158 718 64 cock cock NN 37158 718 65 - - HYPH 37158 718 66 fighting fighting NN 37158 718 67 and and CC 37158 718 68 bull bull NN 37158 718 69 - - HYPH 37158 718 70 baiting baiting NN 37158 718 71 . . . 37158 719 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 719 2 will will MD 37158 719 3 even even RB 37158 719 4 point point VB 37158 719 5 out out RP 37158 719 6 to to IN 37158 719 7 these these DT 37158 719 8 same same JJ 37158 719 9 societies society NNS 37158 719 10 , , , 37158 719 11 so so RB 37158 719 12 enamoured enamour VBN 37158 719 13 of of IN 37158 719 14 animals animal NNS 37158 719 15 ' ' POS 37158 719 16 rights right NNS 37158 719 17 , , , 37158 719 18 a a DT 37158 719 19 new new JJ 37158 719 20 kind kind NN 37158 719 21 of of IN 37158 719 22 protection protection NN 37158 719 23 of of IN 37158 719 24 quite quite PDT 37158 719 25 a a DT 37158 719 26 special special JJ 37158 719 27 nature nature NN 37158 719 28 . . . 37158 720 1 There there EX 37158 720 2 exist exist VBP 37158 720 3 a a DT 37158 720 4 number number NN 37158 720 5 of of IN 37158 720 6 species specie NNS 37158 720 7 of of IN 37158 720 8 animals animal NNS 37158 720 9 which which WDT 37158 720 10 , , , 37158 720 11 hunted hunt VBN 37158 720 12 and and CC 37158 720 13 hemmed hem VBN 37158 720 14 in in IN 37158 720 15 by by IN 37158 720 16 man man NN 37158 720 17 , , , 37158 720 18 are be VBP 37158 720 19 on on IN 37158 720 20 the the DT 37158 720 21 point point NN 37158 720 22 of of IN 37158 720 23 extinction extinction NN 37158 720 24 . . . 37158 721 1 How how WRB 37158 721 2 many many JJ 37158 721 3 , , , 37158 721 4 alas alas UH 37158 721 5 ! ! . 37158 722 1 have have VBP 37158 722 2 for for IN 37158 722 3 ever ever RB 37158 722 4 disappeared disappear VBN 37158 722 5 ; ; : 37158 722 6 and and CC 37158 722 7 no no DT 37158 722 8 human human JJ 37158 722 9 power power NN 37158 722 10 will will MD 37158 722 11 ever ever RB 37158 722 12 be be VB 37158 722 13 able able JJ 37158 722 14 to to TO 37158 722 15 bring bring VB 37158 722 16 back back RB 37158 722 17 to to IN 37158 722 18 life life NN 37158 722 19 an an DT 37158 722 20 animal animal NN 37158 722 21 species species NN 37158 722 22 once once RB 37158 722 23 extinct extinct VBD 37158 722 24 . . . 37158 723 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 723 2 is be VBZ 37158 723 3 a a DT 37158 723 4 great great JJ 37158 723 5 pity pity NN 37158 723 6 ; ; : 37158 723 7 for for IN 37158 723 8 these these DT 37158 723 9 charming charming JJ 37158 723 10 forms form NNS 37158 723 11 , , , 37158 723 12 the the DT 37158 723 13 joy joy NN 37158 723 14 of of IN 37158 723 15 the the DT 37158 723 16 eyes eye NNS 37158 723 17 , , , 37158 723 18 provided provide VBN 37158 723 19 with with IN 37158 723 20 curious curious JJ 37158 723 21 and and CC 37158 723 22 delicate delicate JJ 37158 723 23 instincts instinct NNS 37158 723 24 , , , 37158 723 25 have have VBP 37158 723 26 been be VBN 37158 723 27 annihilated annihilate VBN 37158 723 28 for for IN 37158 723 29 ever ever RB 37158 723 30 . . . 37158 724 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 724 2 will will MD 37158 724 3 give give VB 37158 724 4 some some DT 37158 724 5 examples example NNS 37158 724 6 to to TO 37158 724 7 show show VB 37158 724 8 to to IN 37158 724 9 what what WP 37158 724 10 an an DT 37158 724 11 extent extent NN 37158 724 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 724 13 is be VBZ 37158 724 14 necessary necessary JJ 37158 724 15 for for IN 37158 724 16 man man NN 37158 724 17 to to TO 37158 724 18 protect protect VB 37158 724 19 the the DT 37158 724 20 animal animal NN 37158 724 21 against against IN 37158 724 22 man man NN 37158 724 23 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 724 24 . . . 37158 725 1 Man man NN 37158 725 2 has have VBZ 37158 725 3 the the DT 37158 725 4 taste taste NN 37158 725 5 for for IN 37158 725 6 devastation devastation NN 37158 725 7 ; ; : 37158 725 8 and and CC 37158 725 9 when when WRB 37158 725 10 he -PRON- PRP 37158 725 11 is be VBZ 37158 725 12 excited excited JJ 37158 725 13 , , , 37158 725 14 either either CC 37158 725 15 by by IN 37158 725 16 the the DT 37158 725 17 fury fury NN 37158 725 18 of of IN 37158 725 19 the the DT 37158 725 20 hunt hunt NN 37158 725 21 or or CC 37158 725 22 the the DT 37158 725 23 bait bait NN 37158 725 24 of of IN 37158 725 25 gain gain NN 37158 725 26 , , , 37158 725 27 he -PRON- PRP 37158 725 28 does do VBZ 37158 725 29 not not RB 37158 725 30 hesitate hesitate VB 37158 725 31 to to TO 37158 725 32 make make VB 37158 725 33 many many JJ 37158 725 34 victims victim NNS 37158 725 35 without without IN 37158 725 36 asking ask VBG 37158 725 37 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 725 38 if if IN 37158 725 39 these these DT 37158 725 40 furious furious JJ 37158 725 41 ravages ravage NNS 37158 725 42 will will MD 37158 725 43 not not RB 37158 725 44 find find VB 37158 725 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 725 46 consummation consummation NN 37158 725 47 in in IN 37158 725 48 the the DT 37158 725 49 destruction destruction NN 37158 725 50 of of IN 37158 725 51 an an DT 37158 725 52 entire entire JJ 37158 725 53 race race NN 37158 725 54 of of IN 37158 725 55 animals animal NNS 37158 725 56 . . . 37158 726 1 Already already RB 37158 726 2 in in IN 37158 726 3 the the DT 37158 726 4 Polar polar JJ 37158 726 5 regions region NNS 37158 726 6 , , , 37158 726 7 some some DT 37158 726 8 fine fine JJ 37158 726 9 species specie NNS 37158 726 10 of of IN 37158 726 11 animals animal NNS 37158 726 12 have have VBP 37158 726 13 disappeared disappear VBN 37158 726 14 . . . 37158 727 1 The the DT 37158 727 2 great great JJ 37158 727 3 auk auk NN 37158 727 4 ( ( -LRB- 37158 727 5 extinct extinct VBN 37158 727 6 since since IN 37158 727 7 1844 1844 CD 37158 727 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 727 9 exists exist VBZ 37158 727 10 no no RB 37158 727 11 longer long RBR 37158 727 12 . . . 37158 728 1 One one CD 37158 728 2 species species NN 37158 728 3 of of IN 37158 728 4 walrus walrus NNP 37158 728 5 has have VBZ 37158 728 6 also also RB 37158 728 7 disappeared disappear VBN 37158 728 8 . . . 37158 729 1 The the DT 37158 729 2 seal seal NN 37158 729 3 is be VBZ 37158 729 4 on on IN 37158 729 5 the the DT 37158 729 6 road road NN 37158 729 7 to to IN 37158 729 8 extinction extinction NN 37158 729 9 ; ; : 37158 729 10 fishermen fisherman NNS 37158 729 11 have have VBP 37158 729 12 indulged indulge VBN 37158 729 13 in in IN 37158 729 14 such such JJ 37158 729 15 orgies orgy NNS 37158 729 16 of of IN 37158 729 17 destruction destruction NN 37158 729 18 that that IN 37158 729 19 international international JJ 37158 729 20 measures measure NNS 37158 729 21 have have VBP 37158 729 22 had have VBN 37158 729 23 to to TO 37158 729 24 be be VB 37158 729 25 taken take VBN 37158 729 26 to to TO 37158 729 27 prevent prevent VB 37158 729 28 the the DT 37158 729 29 total total JJ 37158 729 30 destruction destruction NN 37158 729 31 of of IN 37158 729 32 the the DT 37158 729 33 species specie NNS 37158 729 34 . . . 37158 730 1 And and CC 37158 730 2 indeed indeed RB 37158 730 3 be be VB 37158 730 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 730 5 not not RB 37158 730 6 forgotten forget VBN 37158 730 7 that that IN 37158 730 8 if if IN 37158 730 9 the the DT 37158 730 10 Governments Governments NNPS 37158 730 11 of of IN 37158 730 12 England England NNP 37158 730 13 and and CC 37158 730 14 of of IN 37158 730 15 the the DT 37158 730 16 United United NNP 37158 730 17 States States NNP 37158 730 18 have have VBP 37158 730 19 made make VBN 37158 730 20 regulations regulation NNS 37158 730 21 restricting restrict VBG 37158 730 22 the the DT 37158 730 23 massacre massacre NN 37158 730 24 of of IN 37158 730 25 seals seal NNS 37158 730 26 , , , 37158 730 27 it -PRON- PRP 37158 730 28 is be VBZ 37158 730 29 not not RB 37158 730 30 by by IN 37158 730 31 any any DT 37158 730 32 means mean NNS 37158 730 33 in in IN 37158 730 34 order order NN 37158 730 35 to to TO 37158 730 36 stem stem VB 37158 730 37 the the DT 37158 730 38 tide tide NN 37158 730 39 of of IN 37158 730 40 destruction destruction NN 37158 730 41 of of IN 37158 730 42 an an DT 37158 730 43 animal animal NN 37158 730 44 species specie NNS 37158 730 45 interesting interesting JJ 37158 730 46 in in IN 37158 730 47 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 730 48 , , , 37158 730 49 but but CC 37158 730 50 solely solely RB 37158 730 51 because because IN 37158 730 52 such such JJ 37158 730 53 destruction destruction NN 37158 730 54 would would MD 37158 730 55 put put VB 37158 730 56 an an DT 37158 730 57 end end NN 37158 730 58 to to IN 37158 730 59 a a DT 37158 730 60 source source NN 37158 730 61 of of IN 37158 730 62 very very RB 37158 730 63 considerable considerable JJ 37158 730 64 commercial commercial JJ 37158 730 65 profit profit NN 37158 730 66 . . . 37158 731 1 A a DT 37158 731 2 hundred hundred CD 37158 731 3 years year NNS 37158 731 4 ago ago RB 37158 731 5 , , , 37158 731 6 whales whale NNS 37158 731 7 were be VBD 37158 731 8 so so RB 37158 731 9 abundant abundant JJ 37158 731 10 that that IN 37158 731 11 30,000 30,000 CD 37158 731 12 fishermen fisherman NNS 37158 731 13 earned earn VBD 37158 731 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 731 15 living living NN 37158 731 16 by by IN 37158 731 17 whale whale NN 37158 731 18 - - HYPH 37158 731 19 hunting hunting NN 37158 731 20 . . . 37158 732 1 Now now RB 37158 732 2 , , , 37158 732 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 732 4 means mean NNS 37158 732 5 of of IN 37158 732 6 warfare warfare NN 37158 732 7 against against IN 37158 732 8 the the DT 37158 732 9 cetacea cetacea NNS 37158 732 10 have have VBP 37158 732 11 become become VBN 37158 732 12 so so RB 37158 732 13 effective effective JJ 37158 732 14 that that IN 37158 732 15 whales whale NNS 37158 732 16 can can MD 37158 732 17 no no RB 37158 732 18 longer longer RB 37158 732 19 defend defend VB 37158 732 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 732 21 , , , 37158 732 22 and and CC 37158 732 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 732 24 number number NN 37158 732 25 is be VBZ 37158 732 26 decreasing decrease VBG 37158 732 27 every every DT 37158 732 28 day day NN 37158 732 29 to to IN 37158 732 30 such such PDT 37158 732 31 an an DT 37158 732 32 extent extent NN 37158 732 33 that that IN 37158 732 34 we -PRON- PRP 37158 732 35 can can MD 37158 732 36 almost almost RB 37158 732 37 foretell foretell VB 37158 732 38 the the DT 37158 732 39 moment moment NN 37158 732 40 when when WRB 37158 732 41 the the DT 37158 732 42 whale whale NN 37158 732 43 will will MD 37158 732 44 have have VB 37158 732 45 ceased cease VBN 37158 732 46 to to TO 37158 732 47 exist exist VB 37158 732 48 . . . 37158 733 1 In in IN 37158 733 2 America America NNP 37158 733 3 , , , 37158 733 4 vast vast JJ 37158 733 5 regions region NNS 37158 733 6 were be VBD 37158 733 7 overrun overrun NN 37158 733 8 by by IN 37158 733 9 immense immense JJ 37158 733 10 herds herd NNS 37158 733 11 of of IN 37158 733 12 bisons bison NNS 37158 733 13 . . . 37158 734 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 734 2 have have VBP 37158 734 3 been be VBN 37158 734 4 massacred massacre VBN 37158 734 5 with with IN 37158 734 6 such such JJ 37158 734 7 mad mad JJ 37158 734 8 and and CC 37158 734 9 blind blind JJ 37158 734 10 ardour ardour NN 37158 734 11 that that IN 37158 734 12 if if IN 37158 734 13 the the DT 37158 734 14 Government Government NNP 37158 734 15 had have VBD 37158 734 16 not not RB 37158 734 17 finally finally RB 37158 734 18 taken take VBN 37158 734 19 some some DT 37158 734 20 tardy tardy JJ 37158 734 21 and and CC 37158 734 22 insufficient insufficient JJ 37158 734 23 measures measure NNS 37158 734 24 of of IN 37158 734 25 precaution precaution NN 37158 734 26 , , , 37158 734 27 the the DT 37158 734 28 bison bison NN 37158 734 29 would would MD 37158 734 30 be be VB 37158 734 31 extinct extinct VBN 37158 734 32 too too RB 37158 734 33 . . . 37158 735 1 Aurochs Aurochs NNP 37158 735 2 , , , 37158 735 3 elks elk NNS 37158 735 4 , , , 37158 735 5 chamois chamois NNP 37158 735 6 , , , 37158 735 7 bears bear NNS 37158 735 8 have have VBP 37158 735 9 almost almost RB 37158 735 10 disappeared disappear VBN 37158 735 11 , , , 37158 735 12 whereas whereas IN 37158 735 13 a a DT 37158 735 14 century century NN 37158 735 15 ago ago RB 37158 735 16 they -PRON- PRP 37158 735 17 were be VBD 37158 735 18 widely widely RB 37158 735 19 diffused diffuse VBN 37158 735 20 in in IN 37158 735 21 Europe Europe NNP 37158 735 22 . . . 37158 736 1 In in IN 37158 736 2 proportion proportion NN 37158 736 3 as as IN 37158 736 4 man man NN 37158 736 5 takes take VBZ 37158 736 6 possession possession NN 37158 736 7 of of IN 37158 736 8 the the DT 37158 736 9 earth earth NN 37158 736 10 to to TO 37158 736 11 cultivate cultivate VB 37158 736 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 736 13 , , , 37158 736 14 he -PRON- PRP 37158 736 15 kills kill VBZ 37158 736 16 off off RP 37158 736 17 every every DT 37158 736 18 wild wild JJ 37158 736 19 species specie NNS 37158 736 20 and and CC 37158 736 21 replaces replace VBZ 37158 736 22 them -PRON- PRP 37158 736 23 by by IN 37158 736 24 domestic domestic JJ 37158 736 25 species specie NNS 37158 736 26 where where WRB 37158 736 27 race race NN 37158 736 28 loses lose VBZ 37158 736 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 736 30 value value NN 37158 736 31 . . . 37158 737 1 If if IN 37158 737 2 this this DT 37158 737 3 goes go VBZ 37158 737 4 on on RP 37158 737 5 , , , 37158 737 6 a a DT 37158 737 7 time time NN 37158 737 8 will will MD 37158 737 9 come come VB 37158 737 10 , , , 37158 737 11 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37158 737 12 , , , 37158 737 13 when when WRB 37158 737 14 all all RB 37158 737 15 - - HYPH 37158 737 16 powerful powerful JJ 37158 737 17 man man NN 37158 737 18 , , , 37158 737 19 having have VBG 37158 737 20 given give VBN 37158 737 21 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 737 22 up up RP 37158 737 23 to to IN 37158 737 24 the the DT 37158 737 25 thoughtless thoughtless JJ 37158 737 26 destruction destruction NN 37158 737 27 of of IN 37158 737 28 everything everything NN 37158 737 29 not not RB 37158 737 30 of of IN 37158 737 31 immediate immediate JJ 37158 737 32 use use NN 37158 737 33 to to IN 37158 737 34 him -PRON- PRP 37158 737 35 , , , 37158 737 36 will will MD 37158 737 37 have have VB 37158 737 38 wiped wipe VBN 37158 737 39 off off RP 37158 737 40 the the DT 37158 737 41 face face NN 37158 737 42 of of IN 37158 737 43 the the DT 37158 737 44 earth earth NN 37158 737 45 all all DT 37158 737 46 save save VB 37158 737 47 domestic domestic JJ 37158 737 48 animals animal NNS 37158 737 49 . . . 37158 738 1 There there EX 37158 738 2 will will MD 37158 738 3 be be VB 37158 738 4 hens hen NNS 37158 738 5 , , , 37158 738 6 ducks duck NNS 37158 738 7 , , , 37158 738 8 geese geese JJ 37158 738 9 , , , 37158 738 10 turkeys turkey NNS 37158 738 11 , , , 37158 738 12 and and CC 37158 738 13 guinea guinea NN 37158 738 14 - - HYPH 37158 738 15 fowls fowl NNS 37158 738 16 , , , 37158 738 17 sheep sheep NN 37158 738 18 , , , 37158 738 19 oxen oxen NN 37158 738 20 , , , 37158 738 21 donkeys donkey NNS 37158 738 22 , , , 37158 738 23 horses horse NNS 37158 738 24 , , , 37158 738 25 cows cow NNS 37158 738 26 . . . 37158 739 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 37158 739 2 for for IN 37158 739 3 the the DT 37158 739 4 pleasure pleasure NN 37158 739 5 of of IN 37158 739 6 hunting hunting NN 37158 739 7 , , , 37158 739 8 a a DT 37158 739 9 few few JJ 37158 739 10 deer deer NN 37158 739 11 and and CC 37158 739 12 a a DT 37158 739 13 few few JJ 37158 739 14 hares hare NNS 37158 739 15 will will MD 37158 739 16 be be VB 37158 739 17 preserved preserve VBN 37158 739 18 ; ; : 37158 739 19 but but CC 37158 739 20 all all DT 37158 739 21 wild wild JJ 37158 739 22 species specie NNS 37158 739 23 which which WDT 37158 739 24 can can MD 37158 739 25 not not RB 37158 739 26 be be VB 37158 739 27 reproduced reproduce VBN 37158 739 28 in in IN 37158 739 29 captivity captivity NN 37158 739 30 will will MD 37158 739 31 have have VB 37158 739 32 disappeared disappear VBN 37158 739 33 , , , 37158 739 34 will will MD 37158 739 35 no no RB 37158 739 36 longer longer RB 37158 739 37 be be VB 37158 739 38 there there RB 37158 739 39 to to TO 37158 739 40 delight delight VB 37158 739 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 739 42 gaze gaze NN 37158 739 43 . . . 37158 740 1 In in IN 37158 740 2 France France NNP 37158 740 3 , , , 37158 740 4 the the DT 37158 740 5 small small JJ 37158 740 6 birds bird NNS 37158 740 7 are be VBP 37158 740 8 destroyed destroy VBN 37158 740 9 in in IN 37158 740 10 rank rank NN 37158 740 11 fury fury NN 37158 740 12 , , , 37158 740 13 and and CC 37158 740 14 every every DT 37158 740 15 measure measure NN 37158 740 16 taken take VBN 37158 740 17 to to TO 37158 740 18 protect protect VB 37158 740 19 them -PRON- PRP 37158 740 20 is be VBZ 37158 740 21 inefficacious inefficacious JJ 37158 740 22 , , , 37158 740 23 thanks thank NNS 37158 740 24 to to IN 37158 740 25 the the DT 37158 740 26 rage rage NN 37158 740 27 for for IN 37158 740 28 destruction destruction NN 37158 740 29 among among IN 37158 740 30 the the DT 37158 740 31 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 37158 740 32 . . . 37158 741 1 Asia Asia NNP 37158 741 2 and and CC 37158 741 3 Africa Africa NNP 37158 741 4 once once RB 37158 741 5 upon upon IN 37158 741 6 a a DT 37158 741 7 time time NN 37158 741 8 -- -- : 37158 741 9 when when WRB 37158 741 10 almost almost RB 37158 741 11 unknown unknown JJ 37158 741 12 and and CC 37158 741 13 unexplored unexplore VBN 37158 741 14 by by IN 37158 741 15 Europeans Europeans NNPS 37158 741 16 -- -- : 37158 741 17 sheltered shelter VBD 37158 741 18 many many PDT 37158 741 19 a a DT 37158 741 20 noble noble JJ 37158 741 21 animal animal NN 37158 741 22 species specie NNS 37158 741 23 to to IN 37158 741 24 - - HYPH 37158 741 25 day day NN 37158 741 26 well well JJ 37158 741 27 - - HYPH 37158 741 28 nigh nigh NN 37158 741 29 extinct extinct NN 37158 741 30 , , , 37158 741 31 and and CC 37158 741 32 which which WDT 37158 741 33 , , , 37158 741 34 if if IN 37158 741 35 strict strict JJ 37158 741 36 measures measure NNS 37158 741 37 of of IN 37158 741 38 precaution precaution NN 37158 741 39 be be VBP 37158 741 40 not not RB 37158 741 41 speedily speedily RB 37158 741 42 taken take VBN 37158 741 43 , , , 37158 741 44 will will MD 37158 741 45 soon soon RB 37158 741 46 have have VB 37158 741 47 disappeared disappear VBN 37158 741 48 for for IN 37158 741 49 ever ever RB 37158 741 50 . . . 37158 742 1 The the DT 37158 742 2 large large JJ 37158 742 3 monkeys monkey NNS 37158 742 4 , , , 37158 742 5 the the DT 37158 742 6 ostrich ostrich NN 37158 742 7 , , , 37158 742 8 the the DT 37158 742 9 giraffe giraffe NN 37158 742 10 , , , 37158 742 11 and and CC 37158 742 12 especially especially RB 37158 742 13 the the DT 37158 742 14 elephant elephant NN 37158 742 15 , , , 37158 742 16 shun shun VB 37158 742 17 the the DT 37158 742 18 haunts haunt NNS 37158 742 19 of of IN 37158 742 20 man man NN 37158 742 21 , , , 37158 742 22 for for IN 37158 742 23 man man NN 37158 742 24 is be VBZ 37158 742 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 742 26 ruthless ruthless JJ 37158 742 27 enemy enemy NN 37158 742 28 . . . 37158 743 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 743 2 looks look VBZ 37158 743 3 as as IN 37158 743 4 though though IN 37158 743 5 a a DT 37158 743 6 hundred hundred CD 37158 743 7 years year NNS 37158 743 8 hence hence RB 37158 743 9 , , , 37158 743 10 not not RB 37158 743 11 one one CD 37158 743 12 will will MD 37158 743 13 be be VB 37158 743 14 left leave VBN 37158 743 15 . . . 37158 744 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 744 2 is be VBZ 37158 744 3 not not RB 37158 744 4 without without IN 37158 744 5 sadness sadness NN 37158 744 6 we -PRON- PRP 37158 744 7 think think VBP 37158 744 8 of of IN 37158 744 9 that that DT 37158 744 10 future future JJ 37158 744 11 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 744 12 , , , 37158 744 13 a a DT 37158 744 14 brilliant brilliant JJ 37158 744 15 one one NN 37158 744 16 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 744 17 from from IN 37158 744 18 several several JJ 37158 744 19 points point NNS 37158 744 20 of of IN 37158 744 21 view view NN 37158 744 22 , , , 37158 744 23 but but CC 37158 744 24 monotonous monotonous JJ 37158 744 25 and and CC 37158 744 26 tame tame JJ 37158 744 27 , , , 37158 744 28 as as IN 37158 744 29 it -PRON- PRP 37158 744 30 will will MD 37158 744 31 no no RB 37158 744 32 longer longer RB 37158 744 33 possess possess VB 37158 744 34 this this DT 37158 744 35 marvellous marvellous JJ 37158 744 36 variety variety NN 37158 744 37 of of IN 37158 744 38 different different JJ 37158 744 39 animal animal NN 37158 744 40 species specie NNS 37158 744 41 which which WDT 37158 744 42 is be VBZ 37158 744 43 as as IN 37158 744 44 one one CD 37158 744 45 of of IN 37158 744 46 the the DT 37158 744 47 smiles smile NNS 37158 744 48 of of IN 37158 744 49 nature nature NN 37158 744 50 . . . 37158 745 1 A a DT 37158 745 2 pitiable pitiable JJ 37158 745 3 uniformity uniformity NN 37158 745 4 will will MD 37158 745 5 replace replace VB 37158 745 6 the the DT 37158 745 7 varied varied JJ 37158 745 8 forms form NNS 37158 745 9 which which WDT 37158 745 10 natural natural JJ 37158 745 11 selection selection NN 37158 745 12 has have VBZ 37158 745 13 taken take VBN 37158 745 14 thousands thousand NNS 37158 745 15 of of IN 37158 745 16 years year NNS 37158 745 17 to to TO 37158 745 18 bring bring VB 37158 745 19 forth forth RB 37158 745 20 ; ; : 37158 745 21 and and CC 37158 745 22 then then RB 37158 745 23 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 745 24 some some DT 37158 745 25 tardy tardy JJ 37158 745 26 poet poet NN 37158 745 27 , , , 37158 745 28 in in IN 37158 745 29 contemplation contemplation NN 37158 745 30 before before IN 37158 745 31 the the DT 37158 745 32 vast vast JJ 37158 745 33 sheepfolds sheepfold NNS 37158 745 34 and and CC 37158 745 35 poultry poultry NN 37158 745 36 farms farm NNS 37158 745 37 , , , 37158 745 38 where where WRB 37158 745 39 man man NN 37158 745 40 will will MD 37158 745 41 cultivate cultivate VB 37158 745 42 the the DT 37158 745 43 species specie NNS 37158 745 44 of of IN 37158 745 45 use use NN 37158 745 46 to to IN 37158 745 47 him -PRON- PRP 37158 745 48 , , , 37158 745 49 will will MD 37158 745 50 regret regret VB 37158 745 51 those those DT 37158 745 52 far far RB 37158 745 53 - - HYPH 37158 745 54 off off RP 37158 745 55 days day NNS 37158 745 56 when when WRB 37158 745 57 birds bird NNS 37158 745 58 of of IN 37158 745 59 all all DT 37158 745 60 kinds kind NNS 37158 745 61 sang sing VBD 37158 745 62 in in IN 37158 745 63 the the DT 37158 745 64 forests forest NNS 37158 745 65 , , , 37158 745 66 blending blend VBG 37158 745 67 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 745 68 gambols gambol NNS 37158 745 69 with with IN 37158 745 70 those those DT 37158 745 71 of of IN 37158 745 72 the the DT 37158 745 73 graceful graceful JJ 37158 745 74 animals animal NNS 37158 745 75 which which WDT 37158 745 76 human human JJ 37158 745 77 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 745 78 will will MD 37158 745 79 have have VB 37158 745 80 annihilated annihilate VBN 37158 745 81 . . . 37158 746 1 There there RB 37158 746 2 , , , 37158 746 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 746 4 fancy fancy VBP 37158 746 5 , , , 37158 746 6 is be VBZ 37158 746 7 a a DT 37158 746 8 fertile fertile JJ 37158 746 9 subject subject NN 37158 746 10 for for IN 37158 746 11 meditation meditation NN 37158 746 12 , , , 37158 746 13 and and CC 37158 746 14 interesting interesting JJ 37158 746 15 initiative initiative NN 37158 746 16 for for IN 37158 746 17 all all PDT 37158 746 18 those those DT 37158 746 19 who who WP 37158 746 20 have have VBP 37158 746 21 at at IN 37158 746 22 heart heart NN 37158 746 23 the the DT 37158 746 24 rights right NNS 37158 746 25 of of IN 37158 746 26 animals animal NNS 37158 746 27 , , , 37158 746 28 and and CC 37158 746 29 , , , 37158 746 30 if if IN 37158 746 31 I -PRON- PRP 37158 746 32 may may MD 37158 746 33 express express VB 37158 746 34 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 746 35 thus thus RB 37158 746 36 , , , 37158 746 37 the the DT 37158 746 38 future future NN 37158 746 39 of of IN 37158 746 40 animality animality NN 37158 746 41 . . . 37158 747 1 But but CC 37158 747 2 the the DT 37158 747 3 sight sight NN 37158 747 4 of of IN 37158 747 5 a a DT 37158 747 6 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 747 7 , , , 37158 747 8 the the DT 37158 747 9 preparation preparation NN 37158 747 10 of of IN 37158 747 11 a a DT 37158 747 12 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 747 13 experiment experiment NN 37158 747 14 can can MD 37158 747 15 not not RB 37158 747 16 be be VB 37158 747 17 compared compare VBN 37158 747 18 with with IN 37158 747 19 the the DT 37158 747 20 stupid stupid JJ 37158 747 21 and and CC 37158 747 22 mischievous mischievous JJ 37158 747 23 pleasures pleasure NNS 37158 747 24 of of IN 37158 747 25 angling angling NN 37158 747 26 and and CC 37158 747 27 hunting hunting NN 37158 747 28 . . . 37158 748 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 748 2 is be VBZ 37158 748 3 not not RB 37158 748 4 a a DT 37158 748 5 question question NN 37158 748 6 of of IN 37158 748 7 amusing amuse VBG 37158 748 8 oneself oneself PRP 37158 748 9 , , , 37158 748 10 of of IN 37158 748 11 killing kill VBG 37158 748 12 time time NN 37158 748 13 , , , 37158 748 14 of of IN 37158 748 15 diversion diversion NN 37158 748 16 , , , 37158 748 17 of of IN 37158 748 18 finding find VBG 37158 748 19 in in IN 37158 748 20 the the DT 37158 748 21 sight sight NN 37158 748 22 of of IN 37158 748 23 blood blood NN 37158 748 24 or or CC 37158 748 25 pain pain VB 37158 748 26 a a DT 37158 748 27 recreation recreation NN 37158 748 28 for for IN 37158 748 29 boredom boredom NN 37158 748 30 . . . 37158 749 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 749 2 is be VBZ 37158 749 3 quite quite PDT 37158 749 4 another another DT 37158 749 5 motive motive NN 37158 749 6 which which WDT 37158 749 7 animates animate VBZ 37158 749 8 the the DT 37158 749 9 _ _ NNP 37158 749 10 savant savant JJ 37158 749 11 _ _ NNP 37158 749 12 . . . 37158 750 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 750 2 has have VBZ 37158 750 3 ever ever RB 37158 750 4 before before IN 37158 750 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 750 6 mind mind NN 37158 750 7 the the DT 37158 750 8 thought thought NN 37158 750 9 that that IN 37158 750 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 750 11 efforts effort NNS 37158 750 12 are be VBP 37158 750 13 going go VBG 37158 750 14 to to TO 37158 750 15 bring bring VB 37158 750 16 a a DT 37158 750 17 little little JJ 37158 750 18 alleviation alleviation NN 37158 750 19 to to IN 37158 750 20 the the DT 37158 750 21 great great JJ 37158 750 22 sum sum NN 37158 750 23 of of IN 37158 750 24 human human JJ 37158 750 25 suffering suffering NN 37158 750 26 . . . 37158 751 1 If if IN 37158 751 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 751 3 inoculates inoculate VBZ 37158 751 4 a a DT 37158 751 5 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 751 6 with with IN 37158 751 7 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 751 8 , , , 37158 751 9 he -PRON- PRP 37158 751 10 can can MD 37158 751 11 not not RB 37158 751 12 help help VB 37158 751 13 thinking think VBG 37158 751 14 of of IN 37158 751 15 all all PDT 37158 751 16 the the DT 37158 751 17 wretched wretched JJ 37158 751 18 consumptives consumptive NNS 37158 751 19 who who WP 37158 751 20 are be VBP 37158 751 21 at at IN 37158 751 22 that that DT 37158 751 23 moment moment NN 37158 751 24 in in IN 37158 751 25 the the DT 37158 751 26 throes throe NNS 37158 751 27 of of IN 37158 751 28 death death NN 37158 751 29 . . . 37158 752 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 752 2 knows know VBZ 37158 752 3 well well RB 37158 752 4 that that IN 37158 752 5 each each DT 37158 752 6 time time NN 37158 752 7 he -PRON- PRP 37158 752 8 discovers discover VBZ 37158 752 9 even even RB 37158 752 10 only only RB 37158 752 11 a a DT 37158 752 12 particle particle NN 37158 752 13 of of IN 37158 752 14 truth truth NN 37158 752 15 , , , 37158 752 16 that that DT 37158 752 17 little little JJ 37158 752 18 bit bit NN 37158 752 19 of of IN 37158 752 20 new new JJ 37158 752 21 truth truth NN 37158 752 22 is be VBZ 37158 752 23 going go VBG 37158 752 24 to to TO 37158 752 25 bring bring VB 37158 752 26 in in RB 37158 752 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 752 28 train train NN 37158 752 29 some some DT 37158 752 30 consequence consequence NN 37158 752 31 which which WDT 37158 752 32 will will MD 37158 752 33 bear bear VB 37158 752 34 fruit fruit NN 37158 752 35 in in IN 37158 752 36 the the DT 37158 752 37 healing healing NN 37158 752 38 of of IN 37158 752 39 suffering suffer VBG 37158 752 40 mankind mankind NN 37158 752 41 . . . 37158 753 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 753 2 is be VBZ 37158 753 3 with with IN 37158 753 4 no no DT 37158 753 5 light light JJ 37158 753 6 - - HYPH 37158 753 7 heartedness heartedness NN 37158 753 8 that that WDT 37158 753 9 the the DT 37158 753 10 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 753 11 causes cause VBZ 37158 753 12 the the DT 37158 753 13 blood blood NN 37158 753 14 to to TO 37158 753 15 flow flow VB 37158 753 16 , , , 37158 753 17 inoculates inoculate VBZ 37158 753 18 disease disease NN 37158 753 19 , , , 37158 753 20 injects inject VBZ 37158 753 21 poisons poison NNS 37158 753 22 . . . 37158 754 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 754 2 know know VBP 37158 754 3 the the DT 37158 754 4 thought thought NN 37158 754 5 which which WDT 37158 754 6 animates animate VBZ 37158 754 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 754 8 friends friend NNS 37158 754 9 and and CC 37158 754 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 754 11 colleagues colleague NNS 37158 754 12 when when WRB 37158 754 13 they -PRON- PRP 37158 754 14 make make VBP 37158 754 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 754 16 experiments experiment NNS 37158 754 17 : : : 37158 754 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 754 19 is be VBZ 37158 754 20 never never RB 37158 754 21 without without IN 37158 754 22 the the DT 37158 754 23 most most RBS 37158 754 24 profound profound JJ 37158 754 25 pity pity NN 37158 754 26 that that WDT 37158 754 27 we -PRON- PRP 37158 754 28 dare dare VBP 37158 754 29 to to TO 37158 754 30 take take VB 37158 754 31 a a DT 37158 754 32 healthy healthy JJ 37158 754 33 , , , 37158 754 34 gay gay JJ 37158 754 35 , , , 37158 754 36 confiding confide VBG 37158 754 37 animal animal NN 37158 754 38 , , , 37158 754 39 and and CC 37158 754 40 give give VB 37158 754 41 him -PRON- PRP 37158 754 42 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 754 43 , , , 37158 754 44 or or CC 37158 754 45 inject inject VB 37158 754 46 a a DT 37158 754 47 poison poison NN 37158 754 48 into into IN 37158 754 49 him -PRON- PRP 37158 754 50 . . . 37158 755 1 This this DT 37158 755 2 respect respect NN 37158 755 3 for for IN 37158 755 4 pain pain NN 37158 755 5 , , , 37158 755 6 far far RB 37158 755 7 from from IN 37158 755 8 decreasing decrease VBG 37158 755 9 with with IN 37158 755 10 age age NN 37158 755 11 , , , 37158 755 12 on on IN 37158 755 13 the the DT 37158 755 14 contrary contrary NN 37158 755 15 goes go VBZ 37158 755 16 on on RP 37158 755 17 increasing increase VBG 37158 755 18 . . . 37158 756 1 Just just RB 37158 756 2 as as IN 37158 756 3 the the DT 37158 756 4 doctor doctor NN 37158 756 5 as as IN 37158 756 6 he -PRON- PRP 37158 756 7 grows grow VBZ 37158 756 8 older old JJR 37158 756 9 becomes become VBZ 37158 756 10 more more JJR 37158 756 11 and and CC 37158 756 12 more more RBR 37158 756 13 sensitive sensitive JJ 37158 756 14 to to IN 37158 756 15 the the DT 37158 756 16 sight sight NN 37158 756 17 of of IN 37158 756 18 human human JJ 37158 756 19 suffering suffering NN 37158 756 20 , , , 37158 756 21 so so CC 37158 756 22 the the DT 37158 756 23 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 756 24 who who WP 37158 756 25 has have VBZ 37158 756 26 performed perform VBN 37158 756 27 many many JJ 37158 756 28 experiments experiment NNS 37158 756 29 understands understand VBZ 37158 756 30 more more RBR 37158 756 31 and and CC 37158 756 32 more more RBR 37158 756 33 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 756 34 the the DT 37158 756 35 seriousness seriousness NN 37158 756 36 of of IN 37158 756 37 pain pain NN 37158 756 38 . . . 37158 757 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 757 2 feels feel VBZ 37158 757 3 all all PDT 37158 757 4 the the DT 37158 757 5 weight weight NN 37158 757 6 of of IN 37158 757 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 757 8 : : : 37158 757 9 he -PRON- PRP 37158 757 10 has have VBZ 37158 757 11 a a DT 37158 757 12 greater great JJR 37158 757 13 responsibility responsibility NN 37158 757 14 . . . 37158 758 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37158 758 2 morality morality NN 37158 758 3 has have VBZ 37158 758 4 become become VBN 37158 758 5 higher high JJR 37158 758 6 and and CC 37158 758 7 higher high JJR 37158 758 8 , , , 37158 758 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 758 10 sensibility sensibility NN 37158 758 11 has have VBZ 37158 758 12 increased increase VBN 37158 758 13 . . . 37158 759 1 Often often RB 37158 759 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 759 3 repeats repeat VBZ 37158 759 4 to to IN 37158 759 5 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 759 6 this this DT 37158 759 7 line line NN 37158 759 8 of of IN 37158 759 9 Virgil's:-- virgil's:-- NN 37158 759 10 " " `` 37158 759 11 _ _ NNP 37158 759 12 Non Non NNP 37158 759 13 ignara ignara NNP 37158 759 14 mali mali NNP 37158 759 15 miseris miseris NNP 37158 759 16 succurrere succurrere NNP 37158 759 17 disco disco NNP 37158 759 18 . . . 37158 759 19 _ _ NNP 37158 759 20 " " '' 37158 759 21 ( ( -LRB- 37158 759 22 Knowing Knowing NNP 37158 759 23 misfortune misfortune NN 37158 759 24 , , , 37158 759 25 I -PRON- PRP 37158 759 26 teach teach VBP 37158 759 27 the the DT 37158 759 28 succour succour NN 37158 759 29 of of IN 37158 759 30 the the DT 37158 759 31 wretched wretched NN 37158 759 32 . . . 37158 759 33 ) ) -RRB- 37158 760 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 760 2 would would MD 37158 760 3 , , , 37158 760 4 therefore therefore RB 37158 760 5 , , , 37158 760 6 be be VB 37158 760 7 altogether altogether RB 37158 760 8 unjust unjust JJ 37158 760 9 to to TO 37158 760 10 reproach reproach VB 37158 760 11 the the DT 37158 760 12 experimenter experimenter NN 37158 760 13 with with IN 37158 760 14 barbarism barbarism NN 37158 760 15 or or CC 37158 760 16 inhumanity inhumanity NN 37158 760 17 ; ; , 37158 760 18 for for IN 37158 760 19 more more JJR 37158 760 20 than than IN 37158 760 21 any any DT 37158 760 22 one one NN 37158 760 23 else else RB 37158 760 24 does do VBZ 37158 760 25 he -PRON- PRP 37158 760 26 possess possess VB 37158 760 27 the the DT 37158 760 28 sentiment sentiment NN 37158 760 29 of of IN 37158 760 30 the the DT 37158 760 31 immense immense JJ 37158 760 32 misfortunes misfortune NNS 37158 760 33 of of IN 37158 760 34 humanity humanity NN 37158 760 35 , , , 37158 760 36 and and CC 37158 760 37 if if IN 37158 760 38 he -PRON- PRP 37158 760 39 resigns resign VBZ 37158 760 40 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 760 41 to to IN 37158 760 42 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 760 43 , , , 37158 760 44 it -PRON- PRP 37158 760 45 is be VBZ 37158 760 46 because because IN 37158 760 47 he -PRON- PRP 37158 760 48 sees see VBZ 37158 760 49 behind behind IN 37158 760 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 760 51 experiment experiment NN 37158 760 52 an an DT 37158 760 53 alleviation alleviation NN 37158 760 54 of of IN 37158 760 55 the the DT 37158 760 56 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 760 57 of of IN 37158 760 58 both both DT 37158 760 59 man man NN 37158 760 60 and and CC 37158 760 61 beast beast NN 37158 760 62 . . . 37158 761 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 761 2 is be VBZ 37158 761 3 related relate VBN 37158 761 4 that that IN 37158 761 5 , , , 37158 761 6 in in IN 37158 761 7 one one CD 37158 761 8 of of IN 37158 761 9 the the DT 37158 761 10 great great JJ 37158 761 11 battles battle NNS 37158 761 12 of of IN 37158 761 13 the the DT 37158 761 14 last last JJ 37158 761 15 century century NN 37158 761 16 , , , 37158 761 17 a a DT 37158 761 18 general general NN 37158 761 19 , , , 37158 761 20 in in IN 37158 761 21 order order NN 37158 761 22 to to TO 37158 761 23 protect protect VB 37158 761 24 the the DT 37158 761 25 retreat retreat NN 37158 761 26 of of IN 37158 761 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 761 28 army army NN 37158 761 29 , , , 37158 761 30 was be VBD 37158 761 31 obliged oblige VBN 37158 761 32 to to TO 37158 761 33 send send VB 37158 761 34 a a DT 37158 761 35 squadron squadron NN 37158 761 36 of of IN 37158 761 37 cavalry cavalry NNP 37158 761 38 to to TO 37158 761 39 make make VB 37158 761 40 a a DT 37158 761 41 hopeless hopeless JJ 37158 761 42 charge charge NN 37158 761 43 upon upon IN 37158 761 44 the the DT 37158 761 45 enemy enemy NN 37158 761 46 's 's POS 37158 761 47 infantry infantry NN 37158 761 48 . . . 37158 762 1 This this DT 37158 762 2 meant mean VBD 37158 762 3 sending send VBG 37158 762 4 those those DT 37158 762 5 brave brave JJ 37158 762 6 fellows fellow NNS 37158 762 7 to to IN 37158 762 8 certain certain JJ 37158 762 9 death death NN 37158 762 10 . . . 37158 763 1 Yet yet CC 37158 763 2 he -PRON- PRP 37158 763 3 did do VBD 37158 763 4 not not RB 37158 763 5 hesitate hesitate VB 37158 763 6 ; ; : 37158 763 7 and and CC 37158 763 8 with with IN 37158 763 9 tears tear NNS 37158 763 10 in in IN 37158 763 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 763 12 eyes eye NNS 37158 763 13 he -PRON- PRP 37158 763 14 gave give VBD 37158 763 15 the the DT 37158 763 16 order order NN 37158 763 17 to to TO 37158 763 18 charge charge VB 37158 763 19 , , , 37158 763 20 convinced convinced JJ 37158 763 21 , , , 37158 763 22 as as IN 37158 763 23 every every DT 37158 763 24 general general NN 37158 763 25 should should MD 37158 763 26 be be VB 37158 763 27 , , , 37158 763 28 that that IN 37158 763 29 it -PRON- PRP 37158 763 30 is be VBZ 37158 763 31 sometimes sometimes RB 37158 763 32 necessary necessary JJ 37158 763 33 to to TO 37158 763 34 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37158 763 35 a a DT 37158 763 36 few few JJ 37158 763 37 human human JJ 37158 763 38 lives life NNS 37158 763 39 for for IN 37158 763 40 the the DT 37158 763 41 salvation salvation NN 37158 763 42 of of IN 37158 763 43 the the DT 37158 763 44 army army NN 37158 763 45 , , , 37158 763 46 for for IN 37158 763 47 the the DT 37158 763 48 salvation salvation NN 37158 763 49 of of IN 37158 763 50 the the DT 37158 763 51 country country NN 37158 763 52 . . . 37158 764 1 Well well UH 37158 764 2 , , , 37158 764 3 then then RB 37158 764 4 ! ! . 37158 765 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 765 2 consider consider VBP 37158 765 3 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 765 4 as as IN 37158 765 5 soldiers soldier NNS 37158 765 6 waging wage VBG 37158 765 7 battle battle NN 37158 765 8 against against IN 37158 765 9 the the DT 37158 765 10 blind blind JJ 37158 765 11 , , , 37158 765 12 malefic malefic JJ 37158 765 13 forces force NNS 37158 765 14 of of IN 37158 765 15 nature nature NN 37158 765 16 . . . 37158 766 1 On on IN 37158 766 2 certain certain JJ 37158 766 3 days day NNS 37158 766 4 , , , 37158 766 5 so so IN 37158 766 6 as as IN 37158 766 7 to to TO 37158 766 8 triumph triumph VB 37158 766 9 over over IN 37158 766 10 disease disease NN 37158 766 11 and and CC 37158 766 12 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 766 13 , , , 37158 766 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 766 15 must must MD 37158 766 16 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37158 766 17 a a DT 37158 766 18 few few JJ 37158 766 19 victims victim NNS 37158 766 20 . . . 37158 767 1 Then then RB 37158 767 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 767 3 do do VBP 37158 767 4 not not RB 37158 767 5 hesitate hesitate VB 37158 767 6 , , , 37158 767 7 and and CC 37158 767 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 767 9 is be VBZ 37158 767 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 767 11 duty duty NN 37158 767 12 not not RB 37158 767 13 to to TO 37158 767 14 hesitate hesitate VB 37158 767 15 . . . 37158 768 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 768 2 even even RB 37158 768 3 seems seem VBZ 37158 768 4 to to IN 37158 768 5 me -PRON- PRP 37158 768 6 that that IN 37158 768 7 those those DT 37158 768 8 men man NNS 37158 768 9 who who WP 37158 768 10 pass pass VBP 37158 768 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 768 12 lives life NNS 37158 768 13 in in IN 37158 768 14 nauseous nauseous JJ 37158 768 15 rooms room NNS 37158 768 16 , , , 37158 768 17 amidst amidst IN 37158 768 18 poison poison NN 37158 768 19 and and CC 37158 768 20 virus virus NN 37158 768 21 , , , 37158 768 22 receiving receive VBG 37158 768 23 no no DT 37158 768 24 other other JJ 37158 768 25 recompense recompense NN 37158 768 26 for for IN 37158 768 27 long long JJ 37158 768 28 labours labour NNS 37158 768 29 than than IN 37158 768 30 the the DT 37158 768 31 satisfaction satisfaction NN 37158 768 32 of of IN 37158 768 33 duty duty NN 37158 768 34 accomplished accomplish VBN 37158 768 35 , , , 37158 768 36 merit merit VB 37158 768 37 the the DT 37158 768 38 esteem esteem NN 37158 768 39 and and CC 37158 768 40 respect respect NN 37158 768 41 of of IN 37158 768 42 every every DT 37158 768 43 one one CD 37158 768 44 . . . 37158 769 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 769 2 seek seek VBP 37158 769 3 neither neither CC 37158 769 4 wealth wealth NN 37158 769 5 nor nor CC 37158 769 6 honours honour NNS 37158 769 7 . . . 37158 770 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 770 2 is be VBZ 37158 770 3 not not RB 37158 770 4 in in IN 37158 770 5 the the DT 37158 770 6 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 770 7 of of IN 37158 770 8 physiology physiology NN 37158 770 9 that that WDT 37158 770 10 a a DT 37158 770 11 man man NN 37158 770 12 grows grow VBZ 37158 770 13 rich rich JJ 37158 770 14 . . . 37158 771 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 771 2 is be VBZ 37158 771 3 not not RB 37158 771 4 in in IN 37158 771 5 the the DT 37158 771 6 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 771 7 of of IN 37158 771 8 physiology physiology NN 37158 771 9 that that WDT 37158 771 10 man man NN 37158 771 11 wins win VBZ 37158 771 12 high high JJ 37158 771 13 social social JJ 37158 771 14 positions position NNS 37158 771 15 . . . 37158 772 1 But but CC 37158 772 2 what what WP 37158 772 3 matter matter NN 37158 772 4 ! ! . 37158 773 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 773 2 has have VBZ 37158 773 3 used use VBN 37158 773 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 773 5 life life NN 37158 773 6 to to TO 37158 773 7 alleviate alleviate VB 37158 773 8 the the DT 37158 773 9 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 773 10 of of IN 37158 773 11 others other NNS 37158 773 12 . . . 37158 774 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 774 2 has have VBZ 37158 774 3 had have VBN 37158 774 4 ever ever RB 37158 774 5 before before IN 37158 774 6 him -PRON- PRP 37158 774 7 another another DT 37158 774 8 ideal ideal NN 37158 774 9 than than IN 37158 774 10 that that DT 37158 774 11 of of IN 37158 774 12 the the DT 37158 774 13 anti anti NNS 37158 774 14 - - NNS 37158 774 15 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 774 16 , , , 37158 774 17 the the DT 37158 774 18 ideal ideal NN 37158 774 19 of of IN 37158 774 20 human human JJ 37158 774 21 suffering suffering NN 37158 774 22 , , , 37158 774 23 which which WDT 37158 774 24 is be VBZ 37158 774 25 much much RB 37158 774 26 more more JJR 37158 774 27 to to TO 37158 774 28 be be VB 37158 774 29 respected respect VBN 37158 774 30 than than IN 37158 774 31 animal animal NN 37158 774 32 suffering suffering NN 37158 774 33 in in IN 37158 774 34 spite spite NN 37158 774 35 of of IN 37158 774 36 all all DT 37158 774 37 empty empty JJ 37158 774 38 words word NNS 37158 774 39 and and CC 37158 774 40 phrases phrase NNS 37158 774 41 . . . 37158 775 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 775 2 , , , 37158 775 3 when when WRB 37158 775 4 we -PRON- PRP 37158 775 5 speak speak VBP 37158 775 6 of of IN 37158 775 7 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 775 8 or or CC 37158 775 9 of of IN 37158 775 10 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 775 11 before before IN 37158 775 12 young young JJ 37158 775 13 men man NNS 37158 775 14 , , , 37158 775 15 we -PRON- PRP 37158 775 16 must must MD 37158 775 17 not not RB 37158 775 18 be be VB 37158 775 19 taxed tax VBN 37158 775 20 with with IN 37158 775 21 immorality immorality NN 37158 775 22 ; ; : 37158 775 23 because because IN 37158 775 24 work work NN 37158 775 25 , , , 37158 775 26 the the DT 37158 775 27 search search NN 37158 775 28 for for IN 37158 775 29 truth truth NN 37158 775 30 , , , 37158 775 31 pity pity NN 37158 775 32 for for IN 37158 775 33 the the DT 37158 775 34 misfortunes misfortune NNS 37158 775 35 of of IN 37158 775 36 man man NN 37158 775 37 , , , 37158 775 38 pity pity NN 37158 775 39 also also RB 37158 775 40 for for IN 37158 775 41 the the DT 37158 775 42 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 775 43 animals animal NNS 37158 775 44 -- -- : 37158 775 45 these these DT 37158 775 46 I -PRON- PRP 37158 775 47 think think VBP 37158 775 48 are be VBP 37158 775 49 subjects subject NNS 37158 775 50 which which WDT 37158 775 51 should should MD 37158 775 52 ennoble ennoble VB 37158 775 53 the the DT 37158 775 54 minds mind NNS 37158 775 55 of of IN 37158 775 56 the the DT 37158 775 57 young young JJ 37158 775 58 men man NNS 37158 775 59 who who WP 37158 775 60 listen listen VBP 37158 775 61 to to IN 37158 775 62 us -PRON- PRP 37158 775 63 . . . 37158 776 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 776 2 VII vii NN 37158 776 3 ARE are VBP 37158 776 4 LAWS LAWS NNP 37158 776 5 REGULATING regulate VBG 37158 776 6 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 776 7 NECESSARY necessary NN 37158 776 8 ? ? . 37158 777 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 777 2 will will MD 37158 777 3 now now RB 37158 777 4 briefly briefly RB 37158 777 5 consider consider VB 37158 777 6 an an DT 37158 777 7 interesting interesting JJ 37158 777 8 and and CC 37158 777 9 highly highly RB 37158 777 10 practical practical JJ 37158 777 11 side side NN 37158 777 12 of of IN 37158 777 13 the the DT 37158 777 14 question question NN 37158 777 15 . . . 37158 778 1 In in IN 37158 778 2 certain certain JJ 37158 778 3 countries country NNS 37158 778 4 , , , 37158 778 5 as as IN 37158 778 6 in in IN 37158 778 7 England England NNP 37158 778 8 , , , 37158 778 9 there there EX 37158 778 10 are be VBP 37158 778 11 laws law NNS 37158 778 12 regulating regulate VBG 37158 778 13 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 778 14 . . . 37158 779 1 In in IN 37158 779 2 other other JJ 37158 779 3 countries country NNS 37158 779 4 , , , 37158 779 5 as as IN 37158 779 6 in in IN 37158 779 7 France France NNP 37158 779 8 , , , 37158 779 9 Germany Germany NNP 37158 779 10 , , , 37158 779 11 and and CC 37158 779 12 Italy Italy NNP 37158 779 13 , , , 37158 779 14 there there EX 37158 779 15 is be VBZ 37158 779 16 nothing nothing NN 37158 779 17 analogous analogous JJ 37158 779 18 ; ; : 37158 779 19 consequently consequently RB 37158 779 20 public public JJ 37158 779 21 opinion opinion NN 37158 779 22 on on IN 37158 779 23 this this DT 37158 779 24 point point NN 37158 779 25 is be VBZ 37158 779 26 uncertain uncertain JJ 37158 779 27 . . . 37158 780 1 In in IN 37158 780 2 the the DT 37158 780 3 beginning beginning NN 37158 780 4 of of IN 37158 780 5 this this DT 37158 780 6 book book NN 37158 780 7 , , , 37158 780 8 I -PRON- PRP 37158 780 9 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 37158 780 10 that that IN 37158 780 11 , , , 37158 780 12 in in IN 37158 780 13 spite spite NN 37158 780 14 of of IN 37158 780 15 the the DT 37158 780 16 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37158 780 17 of of IN 37158 780 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 780 19 complaints complaint NNS 37158 780 20 , , , 37158 780 21 anti anti NNS 37158 780 22 - - NNS 37158 780 23 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 780 24 had have VBD 37158 780 25 rendered render VBN 37158 780 26 real real JJ 37158 780 27 service service NN 37158 780 28 to to IN 37158 780 29 general general JJ 37158 780 30 morality morality NN 37158 780 31 by by IN 37158 780 32 calling call VBG 37158 780 33 attention attention NN 37158 780 34 to to IN 37158 780 35 the the DT 37158 780 36 excesses excess NNS 37158 780 37 committed commit VBN 37158 780 38 by by IN 37158 780 39 a a DT 37158 780 40 few few JJ 37158 780 41 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 780 42 in in IN 37158 780 43 the the DT 37158 780 44 past past NN 37158 780 45 . . . 37158 781 1 No no DT 37158 781 2 one one NN 37158 781 3 recognises recognise VBZ 37158 781 4 this this DT 37158 781 5 benefit benefit NN 37158 781 6 more more RBR 37158 781 7 than than IN 37158 781 8 I -PRON- PRP 37158 781 9 , , , 37158 781 10 and and CC 37158 781 11 I -PRON- PRP 37158 781 12 willingly willingly RB 37158 781 13 grant grant VBP 37158 781 14 that that IN 37158 781 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 781 16 preaching preaching NN 37158 781 17 has have VBZ 37158 781 18 , , , 37158 781 19 on on IN 37158 781 20 the the DT 37158 781 21 whole whole NN 37158 781 22 , , , 37158 781 23 had have VBD 37158 781 24 a a DT 37158 781 25 happy happy JJ 37158 781 26 result result NN 37158 781 27 . . . 37158 782 1 Is be VBZ 37158 782 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 782 3 however however RB 37158 782 4 , , , 37158 782 5 expedient expedient NN 37158 782 6 to to TO 37158 782 7 go go VB 37158 782 8 further far RBR 37158 782 9 , , , 37158 782 10 and and CC 37158 782 11 to to TO 37158 782 12 prohibit prohibit VB 37158 782 13 or or CC 37158 782 14 simply simply RB 37158 782 15 to to TO 37158 782 16 regulate regulate VB 37158 782 17 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 782 18 ? ? . 37158 783 1 For for IN 37158 783 2 reasons reason NNS 37158 783 3 given give VBN 37158 783 4 above above RB 37158 783 5 , , , 37158 783 6 it -PRON- PRP 37158 783 7 seems seem VBZ 37158 783 8 to to IN 37158 783 9 me -PRON- PRP 37158 783 10 that that DT 37158 783 11 prohibition prohibition NN 37158 783 12 would would MD 37158 783 13 be be VB 37158 783 14 absurd absurd JJ 37158 783 15 and and CC 37158 783 16 injurious injurious JJ 37158 783 17 , , , 37158 783 18 as as RB 37158 783 19 well well RB 37158 783 20 in in IN 37158 783 21 the the DT 37158 783 22 land land NN 37158 783 23 of of IN 37158 783 24 Harvey Harvey NNP 37158 783 25 and and CC 37158 783 26 Hunter Hunter NNP 37158 783 27 as as IN 37158 783 28 in in IN 37158 783 29 the the DT 37158 783 30 lands land NNS 37158 783 31 of of IN 37158 783 32 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 783 33 and and CC 37158 783 34 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 783 35 , , , 37158 783 36 of of IN 37158 783 37 Galvani Galvani NNP 37158 783 38 and and CC 37158 783 39 Spallanzani Spallanzani NNP 37158 783 40 , , , 37158 783 41 of of IN 37158 783 42 Johannes Johannes NNP 37158 783 43 Müller Müller NNP 37158 783 44 and and CC 37158 783 45 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 37158 783 46 . . . 37158 784 1 Prohibition prohibition NN 37158 784 2 would would MD 37158 784 3 mean mean VB 37158 784 4 closing close VBG 37158 784 5 the the DT 37158 784 6 book book NN 37158 784 7 of of IN 37158 784 8 science science NN 37158 784 9 , , , 37158 784 10 stemming stem VBG 37158 784 11 all all DT 37158 784 12 progress progress NN 37158 784 13 , , , 37158 784 14 condemning condemn VBG 37158 784 15 humanity humanity NN 37158 784 16 eternally eternally RB 37158 784 17 to to IN 37158 784 18 the the DT 37158 784 19 same same JJ 37158 784 20 miseries misery NNS 37158 784 21 , , , 37158 784 22 to to IN 37158 784 23 writhe writhe JJS 37158 784 24 , , , 37158 784 25 powerless powerless JJ 37158 784 26 , , , 37158 784 27 in in IN 37158 784 28 the the DT 37158 784 29 same same JJ 37158 784 30 old old JJ 37158 784 31 track track NN 37158 784 32 . . . 37158 785 1 Fortunately fortunately RB 37158 785 2 , , , 37158 785 3 no no DT 37158 785 4 one one NN 37158 785 5 thinks think VBZ 37158 785 6 seriously seriously RB 37158 785 7 of of IN 37158 785 8 suppressing suppress VBG 37158 785 9 physiological physiological JJ 37158 785 10 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 785 11 ; ; : 37158 785 12 and and CC 37158 785 13 , , , 37158 785 14 therefore therefore RB 37158 785 15 , , , 37158 785 16 we -PRON- PRP 37158 785 17 have have VBP 37158 785 18 no no DT 37158 785 19 need need NN 37158 785 20 to to TO 37158 785 21 dwell dwell VB 37158 785 22 on on IN 37158 785 23 this this DT 37158 785 24 point point NN 37158 785 25 . . . 37158 786 1 But but CC 37158 786 2 regulation regulation NN 37158 786 3 is be VBZ 37158 786 4 quite quite PDT 37158 786 5 a a DT 37158 786 6 different different JJ 37158 786 7 thing thing NN 37158 786 8 from from IN 37158 786 9 prohibition prohibition NN 37158 786 10 . . . 37158 787 1 Now now RB 37158 787 2 , , , 37158 787 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 787 4 showed show VBD 37158 787 5 that that IN 37158 787 6 certain certain JJ 37158 787 7 practices practice NNS 37158 787 8 should should MD 37158 787 9 be be VB 37158 787 10 condemned condemn VBN 37158 787 11 . . . 37158 788 1 Should Should MD 37158 788 2 they -PRON- PRP 37158 788 3 , , , 37158 788 4 however however RB 37158 788 5 , , , 37158 788 6 be be VB 37158 788 7 condemned condemn VBN 37158 788 8 by by IN 37158 788 9 law law NN 37158 788 10 ? ? . 37158 789 1 Why why WRB 37158 789 2 should should MD 37158 789 3 the the DT 37158 789 4 law law NN 37158 789 5 be be VB 37158 789 6 substituted substitute VBN 37158 789 7 for for IN 37158 789 8 the the DT 37158 789 9 exigencies exigency NNS 37158 789 10 of of IN 37158 789 11 science science NN 37158 789 12 ? ? . 37158 790 1 Here here RB 37158 790 2 is be VBZ 37158 790 3 a a DT 37158 790 4 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 790 5 , , , 37158 790 6 fully fully RB 37158 790 7 conscious conscious JJ 37158 790 8 of of IN 37158 790 9 the the DT 37158 790 10 magnitude magnitude NN 37158 790 11 of of IN 37158 790 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 790 13 task task NN 37158 790 14 , , , 37158 790 15 to to TO 37158 790 16 whom whom WP 37158 790 17 the the DT 37158 790 18 government government NN 37158 790 19 or or CC 37158 790 20 a a DT 37158 790 21 university university NN 37158 790 22 has have VBZ 37158 790 23 confided confide VBN 37158 790 24 the the DT 37158 790 25 direction direction NN 37158 790 26 of of IN 37158 790 27 a a DT 37158 790 28 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 790 29 , , , 37158 790 30 who who WP 37158 790 31 finds find VBZ 37158 790 32 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 790 33 face face NN 37158 790 34 to to IN 37158 790 35 face face NN 37158 790 36 with with IN 37158 790 37 a a DT 37158 790 38 problem problem NN 37158 790 39 needing need VBG 37158 790 40 to to TO 37158 790 41 be be VB 37158 790 42 solved solve VBN 37158 790 43 . . . 37158 791 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 791 2 is be VBZ 37158 791 3 impossible impossible JJ 37158 791 4 to to TO 37158 791 5 limit limit VB 37158 791 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 791 7 efforts effort NNS 37158 791 8 and and CC 37158 791 9 to to TO 37158 791 10 lay lay VB 37158 791 11 down down RP 37158 791 12 principles principle NNS 37158 791 13 from from IN 37158 791 14 which which WDT 37158 791 15 he -PRON- PRP 37158 791 16 could could MD 37158 791 17 not not RB 37158 791 18 turn turn VB 37158 791 19 aside aside RB 37158 791 20 . . . 37158 792 1 Just just RB 37158 792 2 as as IN 37158 792 3 he -PRON- PRP 37158 792 4 is be VBZ 37158 792 5 referred refer VBN 37158 792 6 to to IN 37158 792 7 for for IN 37158 792 8 the the DT 37158 792 9 purchase purchase NN 37158 792 10 of of IN 37158 792 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 792 12 instruments instrument NNS 37158 792 13 and and CC 37158 792 14 the the DT 37158 792 15 nomination nomination NN 37158 792 16 of of IN 37158 792 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 792 18 staff staff NN 37158 792 19 , , , 37158 792 20 so so RB 37158 792 21 must must MD 37158 792 22 he -PRON- PRP 37158 792 23 be be VB 37158 792 24 left leave VBN 37158 792 25 full full JJ 37158 792 26 latitude latitude NN 37158 792 27 in in IN 37158 792 28 the the DT 37158 792 29 arrangement arrangement NN 37158 792 30 of of IN 37158 792 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 792 32 experiments experiment NNS 37158 792 33 . . . 37158 793 1 Nothing nothing NN 37158 793 2 is be VBZ 37158 793 3 so so RB 37158 793 4 pernicious pernicious JJ 37158 793 5 in in IN 37158 793 6 matters matter NNS 37158 793 7 of of IN 37158 793 8 science science NN 37158 793 9 as as IN 37158 793 10 official official JJ 37158 793 11 regulation regulation NN 37158 793 12 ; ; : 37158 793 13 it -PRON- PRP 37158 793 14 takes take VBZ 37158 793 15 away away RB 37158 793 16 all all DT 37158 793 17 initiative initiative NN 37158 793 18 , , , 37158 793 19 and and CC 37158 793 20 does do VBZ 37158 793 21 not not RB 37158 793 22 allow allow VB 37158 793 23 the the DT 37158 793 24 genius genius NN 37158 793 25 of of IN 37158 793 26 the the DT 37158 793 27 inventor inventor NN 37158 793 28 to to TO 37158 793 29 have have VB 37158 793 30 full full JJ 37158 793 31 play play NN 37158 793 32 . . . 37158 794 1 As as IN 37158 794 2 a a DT 37158 794 3 matter matter NN 37158 794 4 of of IN 37158 794 5 fact fact NN 37158 794 6 , , , 37158 794 7 even even RB 37158 794 8 in in IN 37158 794 9 England England NNP 37158 794 10 , , , 37158 794 11 the the DT 37158 794 12 only only JJ 37158 794 13 country country NN 37158 794 14 where where WRB 37158 794 15 up up IN 37158 794 16 to to IN 37158 794 17 the the DT 37158 794 18 present present NN 37158 794 19 the the DT 37158 794 20 conditions condition NNS 37158 794 21 of of IN 37158 794 22 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 794 23 have have VBP 37158 794 24 been be VBN 37158 794 25 regulated regulate VBN 37158 794 26 by by IN 37158 794 27 law law NN 37158 794 28 , , , 37158 794 29 no no DT 37158 794 30 one one NN 37158 794 31 has have VBZ 37158 794 32 ventured venture VBN 37158 794 33 to to TO 37158 794 34 confine confine VB 37158 794 35 the the DT 37158 794 36 initiative initiative NN 37158 794 37 of of IN 37158 794 38 the the DT 37158 794 39 experimenter experimenter NN 37158 794 40 within within IN 37158 794 41 narrow narrow JJ 37158 794 42 regulations regulation NNS 37158 794 43 . . . 37158 795 1 And and CC 37158 795 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 795 3 is be VBZ 37158 795 4 fortunate fortunate JJ 37158 795 5 that that IN 37158 795 6 no no DT 37158 795 7 one one NN 37158 795 8 has have VBZ 37158 795 9 ventured venture VBN 37158 795 10 to to TO 37158 795 11 define define VB 37158 795 12 the the DT 37158 795 13 limits limit NNS 37158 795 14 of of IN 37158 795 15 experimental experimental JJ 37158 795 16 investigation investigation NN 37158 795 17 , , , 37158 795 18 for for IN 37158 795 19 most most JJS 37158 795 20 excellent excellent JJ 37158 795 21 work work NN 37158 795 22 is be VBZ 37158 795 23 due due JJ 37158 795 24 to to IN 37158 795 25 contemporary contemporary JJ 37158 795 26 English English NNP 37158 795 27 Physiologists Physiologists NNPS 37158 795 28 -- -- : 37158 795 29 Schäfer schäfer VB 37158 795 30 , , , 37158 795 31 Horsley Horsley NNP 37158 795 32 , , , 37158 795 33 Sherrington Sherrington NNP 37158 795 34 , , , 37158 795 35 Langley Langley NNP 37158 795 36 , , , 37158 795 37 Bayliss Bayliss NNP 37158 795 38 , , , 37158 795 39 Starling Starling NNP 37158 795 40 , , , 37158 795 41 Stirling Stirling NNP 37158 795 42 , , , 37158 795 43 etc etc FW 37158 795 44 . . . 37158 796 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 796 2 have have VBP 37158 796 3 been be VBN 37158 796 4 able able JJ 37158 796 5 to to TO 37158 796 6 pursue pursue VB 37158 796 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 796 8 researches research NNS 37158 796 9 freely freely RB 37158 796 10 , , , 37158 796 11 to to IN 37158 796 12 the the DT 37158 796 13 very very RB 37158 796 14 great great JJ 37158 796 15 advantage advantage NN 37158 796 16 of of IN 37158 796 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 796 18 science science NN 37158 796 19 . . . 37158 797 1 One one PRP 37158 797 2 should should MD 37158 797 3 not not RB 37158 797 4 , , , 37158 797 5 then then RB 37158 797 6 , , , 37158 797 7 think think VB 37158 797 8 of of IN 37158 797 9 prohibiting prohibit VBG 37158 797 10 such such JJ 37158 797 11 or or CC 37158 797 12 such such PDT 37158 797 13 a a DT 37158 797 14 proceeding proceeding NN 37158 797 15 in in IN 37158 797 16 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 797 17 . . . 37158 798 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 798 2 may may MD 37158 798 3 even even RB 37158 798 4 be be VB 37158 798 5 dangerous dangerous JJ 37158 798 6 to to TO 37158 798 7 absolutely absolutely RB 37158 798 8 prohibit prohibit VB 37158 798 9 vivisections vivisection NNS 37158 798 10 without without IN 37158 798 11 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 798 12 . . . 37158 799 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 799 2 make make VBP 37158 799 3 no no DT 37158 799 4 mystery mystery NN 37158 799 5 of of IN 37158 799 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 799 7 opinion opinion NN 37158 799 8 on on IN 37158 799 9 this this DT 37158 799 10 point point NN 37158 799 11 , , , 37158 799 12 since since IN 37158 799 13 I -PRON- PRP 37158 799 14 have have VBP 37158 799 15 distinctly distinctly RB 37158 799 16 declared declare VBN 37158 799 17 further further RB 37158 799 18 back back RB 37158 799 19 that that IN 37158 799 20 no no DT 37158 799 21 sensitive sensitive JJ 37158 799 22 animal animal NN 37158 799 23 should should MD 37158 799 24 ever ever RB 37158 799 25 be be VB 37158 799 26 operated operate VBN 37158 799 27 upon upon IN 37158 799 28 . . . 37158 800 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 800 2 regard regard VBP 37158 800 3 as as IN 37158 800 4 a a DT 37158 800 5 moral moral JJ 37158 800 6 error error NN 37158 800 7 all all DT 37158 800 8 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 800 9 made make VBN 37158 800 10 on on IN 37158 800 11 an an DT 37158 800 12 animal animal NN 37158 800 13 capable capable JJ 37158 800 14 of of IN 37158 800 15 suffering suffer VBG 37158 800 16 . . . 37158 801 1 But but CC 37158 801 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 801 3 would would MD 37158 801 4 leave leave VB 37158 801 5 the the DT 37158 801 6 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 801 7 to to TO 37158 801 8 be be VB 37158 801 9 the the DT 37158 801 10 judge judge NN 37158 801 11 in in IN 37158 801 12 the the DT 37158 801 13 matter matter NN 37158 801 14 . . . 37158 802 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 802 2 do do VBP 37158 802 3 not not RB 37158 802 4 believe believe VB 37158 802 5 the the DT 37158 802 6 law law NN 37158 802 7 should should MD 37158 802 8 take take VB 37158 802 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 802 10 place place NN 37158 802 11 ; ; : 37158 802 12 for for IN 37158 802 13 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 802 14 cases case NNS 37158 802 15 will will MD 37158 802 16 occur occur VB 37158 802 17 where where WRB 37158 802 18 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 802 19 is be VBZ 37158 802 20 impossible impossible JJ 37158 802 21 , , , 37158 802 22 and and CC 37158 802 23 he -PRON- PRP 37158 802 24 can can MD 37158 802 25 not not RB 37158 802 26 be be VB 37158 802 27 placed place VBN 37158 802 28 under under IN 37158 802 29 the the DT 37158 802 30 hard hard JJ 37158 802 31 alternative alternative NN 37158 802 32 of of IN 37158 802 33 not not RB 37158 802 34 making make VBG 37158 802 35 an an DT 37158 802 36 experiment experiment NN 37158 802 37 which which WDT 37158 802 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 802 39 conscience conscience NN 37158 802 40 as as IN 37158 802 41 a a DT 37158 802 42 _ _ NNP 37158 802 43 savant savant JJ 37158 802 44 _ _ NNP 37158 802 45 judges judge NNS 37158 802 46 to to TO 37158 802 47 be be VB 37158 802 48 useful useful JJ 37158 802 49 , , , 37158 802 50 or or CC 37158 802 51 of of IN 37158 802 52 disobeying disobey VBG 37158 802 53 the the DT 37158 802 54 law law NN 37158 802 55 . . . 37158 803 1 Moreover moreover RB 37158 803 2 , , , 37158 803 3 how how WRB 37158 803 4 are be VBP 37158 803 5 the the DT 37158 803 6 many many JJ 37158 803 7 possible possible JJ 37158 803 8 conditions condition NNS 37158 803 9 of of IN 37158 803 10 an an DT 37158 803 11 experiment experiment NN 37158 803 12 to to TO 37158 803 13 be be VB 37158 803 14 precisely precisely RB 37158 803 15 laid lay VBN 37158 803 16 down down RP 37158 803 17 ? ? . 37158 804 1 Is be VBZ 37158 804 2 the the DT 37158 804 3 law law NN 37158 804 4 to to TO 37158 804 5 indicate indicate VB 37158 804 6 the the DT 37158 804 7 kind kind NN 37158 804 8 of of IN 37158 804 9 anæsthetic anæsthetic JJ 37158 804 10 to to TO 37158 804 11 be be VB 37158 804 12 used use VBN 37158 804 13 , , , 37158 804 14 and and CC 37158 804 15 the the DT 37158 804 16 degree degree NN 37158 804 17 of of IN 37158 804 18 anæsthesia anæsthesia NNP 37158 804 19 to to TO 37158 804 20 be be VB 37158 804 21 attained attain VBN 37158 804 22 ? ? . 37158 805 1 Is be VBZ 37158 805 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 805 3 to to TO 37158 805 4 prohibit prohibit VB 37158 805 5 all all DT 37158 805 6 experiments experiment NNS 37158 805 7 on on IN 37158 805 8 toxic toxic JJ 37158 805 9 actions action NNS 37158 805 10 ? ? . 37158 806 1 Many many JJ 37158 806 2 insoluble insoluble JJ 37158 806 3 difficulties difficulty NNS 37158 806 4 would would MD 37158 806 5 be be VB 37158 806 6 encountered encounter VBN 37158 806 7 , , , 37158 806 8 the the DT 37158 806 9 sole sole JJ 37158 806 10 result result NN 37158 806 11 of of IN 37158 806 12 which which WDT 37158 806 13 would would MD 37158 806 14 be be VB 37158 806 15 to to TO 37158 806 16 paralyse paralyse VB 37158 806 17 the the DT 37158 806 18 _ _ NNP 37158 806 19 savant savant JJ 37158 806 20 _ _ NNP 37158 806 21 in in IN 37158 806 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 806 23 researches research NNS 37158 806 24 or or CC 37158 806 25 to to TO 37158 806 26 cause cause VB 37158 806 27 him -PRON- PRP 37158 806 28 to to TO 37158 806 29 break break VB 37158 806 30 the the DT 37158 806 31 laws law NNS 37158 806 32 of of IN 37158 806 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 806 34 country country NN 37158 806 35 . . . 37158 807 1 And and CC 37158 807 2 yet yet RB 37158 807 3 I -PRON- PRP 37158 807 4 recognise recognise VBP 37158 807 5 that that DT 37158 807 6 regulation regulation NN 37158 807 7 is be VBZ 37158 807 8 indispensable indispensable JJ 37158 807 9 , , , 37158 807 10 but but CC 37158 807 11 it -PRON- PRP 37158 807 12 ought ought MD 37158 807 13 not not RB 37158 807 14 to to TO 37158 807 15 bear bear VB 37158 807 16 on on IN 37158 807 17 the the DT 37158 807 18 nature nature NN 37158 807 19 of of IN 37158 807 20 the the DT 37158 807 21 experiment experiment NN 37158 807 22 ; ; : 37158 807 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 807 24 should should MD 37158 807 25 deal deal VB 37158 807 26 solely solely RB 37158 807 27 with with IN 37158 807 28 the the DT 37158 807 29 person person NN 37158 807 30 experimenting experiment VBG 37158 807 31 . . . 37158 808 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 808 2 believe believe VBP 37158 808 3 the the DT 37158 808 4 right right NN 37158 808 5 of of IN 37158 808 6 practising practise VBG 37158 808 7 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 808 8 should should MD 37158 808 9 not not RB 37158 808 10 be be VB 37158 808 11 accorded accord VBN 37158 808 12 to to IN 37158 808 13 every every DT 37158 808 14 citizen citizen NN 37158 808 15 , , , 37158 808 16 to to IN 37158 808 17 every every DT 37158 808 18 medical medical JJ 37158 808 19 student student NN 37158 808 20 ; ; : 37158 808 21 it -PRON- PRP 37158 808 22 should should MD 37158 808 23 not not RB 37158 808 24 be be VB 37158 808 25 permissible permissible JJ 37158 808 26 for for IN 37158 808 27 any any DT 37158 808 28 chance chance NN 37158 808 29 person person NN 37158 808 30 to to TO 37158 808 31 take take VB 37158 808 32 a a DT 37158 808 33 dog dog NN 37158 808 34 , , , 37158 808 35 to to TO 37158 808 36 fasten fasten VB 37158 808 37 him -PRON- PRP 37158 808 38 down down RP 37158 808 39 on on IN 37158 808 40 the the DT 37158 808 41 operating operating NN 37158 808 42 table table NN 37158 808 43 , , , 37158 808 44 and and CC 37158 808 45 to to TO 37158 808 46 experiment experiment VB 37158 808 47 on on IN 37158 808 48 the the DT 37158 808 49 brain brain NN 37158 808 50 , , , 37158 808 51 the the DT 37158 808 52 glands gland NNS 37158 808 53 , , , 37158 808 54 the the DT 37158 808 55 muscles muscle NNS 37158 808 56 of of IN 37158 808 57 that that DT 37158 808 58 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37158 808 59 animal animal NN 37158 808 60 , , , 37158 808 61 for for IN 37158 808 62 that that DT 37158 808 63 chance chance NN 37158 808 64 person person NN 37158 808 65 is be VBZ 37158 808 66 , , , 37158 808 67 in in IN 37158 808 68 all all DT 37158 808 69 probability probability NN 37158 808 70 , , , 37158 808 71 a a DT 37158 808 72 clumsy clumsy JJ 37158 808 73 and and CC 37158 808 74 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 808 75 man man NN 37158 808 76 . . . 37158 809 1 Vivisection vivisection NN 37158 809 2 may may MD 37158 809 3 not not RB 37158 809 4 be be VB 37158 809 5 undertaken undertake VBN 37158 809 6 in in IN 37158 809 7 a a DT 37158 809 8 light light JJ 37158 809 9 - - HYPH 37158 809 10 hearted hearted JJ 37158 809 11 fashion fashion NN 37158 809 12 . . . 37158 810 1 After after RB 37158 810 2 all all RB 37158 810 3 , , , 37158 810 4 science science NN 37158 810 5 would would MD 37158 810 6 lose lose VB 37158 810 7 nothing nothing NN 37158 810 8 if if IN 37158 810 9 such such PDT 37158 810 10 an an DT 37158 810 11 experiment experiment NN 37158 810 12 were be VBD 37158 810 13 not not RB 37158 810 14 made make VBN 37158 810 15 , , , 37158 810 16 and and CC 37158 810 17 I -PRON- PRP 37158 810 18 see see VBP 37158 810 19 no no DT 37158 810 20 advantage advantage NN 37158 810 21 in in IN 37158 810 22 encouraging encourage VBG 37158 810 23 attempts attempt NNS 37158 810 24 of of IN 37158 810 25 this this DT 37158 810 26 sort sort NN 37158 810 27 which which WDT 37158 810 28 are be VBP 37158 810 29 condemned condemn VBN 37158 810 30 beforehand beforehand RB 37158 810 31 to to TO 37158 810 32 be be VB 37158 810 33 fruitless fruitless JJ 37158 810 34 . . . 37158 811 1 But but CC 37158 811 2 in in IN 37158 811 3 a a DT 37158 811 4 laboratory laboratory NN 37158 811 5 of of IN 37158 811 6 physiology physiology NN 37158 811 7 , , , 37158 811 8 under under IN 37158 811 9 the the DT 37158 811 10 direction direction NN 37158 811 11 of of IN 37158 811 12 the the DT 37158 811 13 professor professor NN 37158 811 14 and and CC 37158 811 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 811 16 assistants assistant NNS 37158 811 17 , , , 37158 811 18 under under IN 37158 811 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 811 20 moral moral JJ 37158 811 21 responsibility responsibility NN 37158 811 22 , , , 37158 811 23 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 811 24 should should MD 37158 811 25 not not RB 37158 811 26 be be VB 37158 811 27 prohibited prohibit VBN 37158 811 28 ; ; : 37158 811 29 the the DT 37158 811 30 number number NN 37158 811 31 of of IN 37158 811 32 vivisections vivisection NNS 37158 811 33 should should MD 37158 811 34 not not RB 37158 811 35 be be VB 37158 811 36 limited limit VBN 37158 811 37 , , , 37158 811 38 and and CC 37158 811 39 no no DT 37158 811 40 restrictions restriction NNS 37158 811 41 ought ought MD 37158 811 42 to to TO 37158 811 43 be be VB 37158 811 44 imposed impose VBN 37158 811 45 . . . 37158 812 1 As as IN 37158 812 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 812 3 have have VBP 37158 812 4 no no DT 37158 812 5 intention intention NN 37158 812 6 of of IN 37158 812 7 formulating formulate VBG 37158 812 8 or or CC 37158 812 9 drawing draw VBG 37158 812 10 up up RP 37158 812 11 regulations regulation NNS 37158 812 12 or or CC 37158 812 13 enacting enact VBG 37158 812 14 laws law NNS 37158 812 15 , , , 37158 812 16 I -PRON- PRP 37158 812 17 shall shall MD 37158 812 18 not not RB 37158 812 19 indicate indicate VB 37158 812 20 the the DT 37158 812 21 penalties penalty NNS 37158 812 22 to to TO 37158 812 23 which which WDT 37158 812 24 those those DT 37158 812 25 who who WP 37158 812 26 violate violate VBP 37158 812 27 the the DT 37158 812 28 law law NN 37158 812 29 should should MD 37158 812 30 be be VB 37158 812 31 liable liable JJ 37158 812 32 . . . 37158 813 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 813 2 shall shall MD 37158 813 3 content content VB 37158 813 4 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 813 5 with with IN 37158 813 6 enunciating enunciate VBG 37158 813 7 this this DT 37158 813 8 double double JJ 37158 813 9 principle principle NN 37158 813 10 : : : 37158 813 11 entire entire JJ 37158 813 12 liberty liberty NN 37158 813 13 in in IN 37158 813 14 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 813 15 for for IN 37158 813 16 professors professor NNS 37158 813 17 of of IN 37158 813 18 physiology physiology NN 37158 813 19 and and CC 37158 813 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 813 21 assistants assistant NNS 37158 813 22 ; ; : 37158 813 23 prohibition prohibition NN 37158 813 24 of of IN 37158 813 25 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 813 26 for for IN 37158 813 27 all all DT 37158 813 28 others other NNS 37158 813 29 . . . 37158 814 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 37158 814 2 VIII viii NN 37158 814 3 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 814 4 AND and CC 37158 814 5 THE the DT 37158 814 6 FUTURE future NN 37158 814 7 OF of IN 37158 814 8 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNS 37158 814 9 Let let VBP 37158 814 10 us -PRON- PRP 37158 814 11 now now RB 37158 814 12 leave leave VB 37158 814 13 the the DT 37158 814 14 opinions opinion NNS 37158 814 15 of of IN 37158 814 16 anti anti JJ 37158 814 17 - - NNS 37158 814 18 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 814 19 , , , 37158 814 20 and and CC 37158 814 21 carry carry VB 37158 814 22 the the DT 37158 814 23 problem problem NN 37158 814 24 on on RP 37158 814 25 to to IN 37158 814 26 higher high JJR 37158 814 27 ground ground NN 37158 814 28 . . . 37158 815 1 Let let VB 37158 815 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 815 3 see see VB 37158 815 4 what what WP 37158 815 5 are be VBP 37158 815 6 the the DT 37158 815 7 rights right NNS 37158 815 8 of of IN 37158 815 9 man man NN 37158 815 10 in in IN 37158 815 11 Nature Nature NNP 37158 815 12 , , , 37158 815 13 and and CC 37158 815 14 what what WP 37158 815 15 is be VBZ 37158 815 16 the the DT 37158 815 17 purpose purpose NN 37158 815 18 of of IN 37158 815 19 human human JJ 37158 815 20 life life NN 37158 815 21 . . . 37158 816 1 Amidst amidst IN 37158 816 2 all all PDT 37158 816 3 the the DT 37158 816 4 unsettled unsettled JJ 37158 816 5 and and CC 37158 816 6 contradictory contradictory JJ 37158 816 7 theories theory NNS 37158 816 8 accumulated accumulate VBN 37158 816 9 by by IN 37158 816 10 philosophers philosopher NNS 37158 816 11 , , , 37158 816 12 thinkers thinker NNS 37158 816 13 and and CC 37158 816 14 founders founder NNS 37158 816 15 of of IN 37158 816 16 religion religion NN 37158 816 17 , , , 37158 816 18 there there EX 37158 816 19 remains remain VBZ 37158 816 20 scarcely scarcely RB 37158 816 21 any any DT 37158 816 22 fixed fixed JJ 37158 816 23 and and CC 37158 816 24 immutable immutable JJ 37158 816 25 theory theory NN 37158 816 26 save save IN 37158 816 27 that that DT 37158 816 28 of of IN 37158 816 29 one one CD 37158 816 30 dominating dominate VBG 37158 816 31 principle principle NN 37158 816 32 : : : 37158 816 33 The the DT 37158 816 34 respect respect NN 37158 816 35 and and CC 37158 816 36 love love NN 37158 816 37 of of IN 37158 816 38 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 816 39 brothers brother NNS 37158 816 40 in in IN 37158 816 41 humanity humanity NN 37158 816 42 . . . 37158 817 1 All all DT 37158 817 2 else else RB 37158 817 3 is be VBZ 37158 817 4 contestable contestable JJ 37158 817 5 and and CC 37158 817 6 contested contested JJ 37158 817 7 . . . 37158 818 1 Though though IN 37158 818 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 818 3 are be VBP 37158 818 4 unable unable JJ 37158 818 5 to to TO 37158 818 6 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37158 818 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 818 8 formally formally RB 37158 818 9 , , , 37158 818 10 there there EX 37158 818 11 is be VBZ 37158 818 12 one one CD 37158 818 13 universal universal JJ 37158 818 14 moral moral JJ 37158 818 15 law law NN 37158 818 16 ( ( -LRB- 37158 818 17 the the DT 37158 818 18 great great JJ 37158 818 19 Categorical Categorical NNP 37158 818 20 Imperative Imperative NNP 37158 818 21 of of IN 37158 818 22 Kant Kant NNP 37158 818 23 ) ) -RRB- 37158 818 24 which which WDT 37158 818 25 commands command VBZ 37158 818 26 us -PRON- PRP 37158 818 27 to to TO 37158 818 28 be be VB 37158 818 29 just just RB 37158 818 30 and and CC 37158 818 31 beneficent beneficent JJ 37158 818 32 to to IN 37158 818 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 818 34 fellow fellow NN 37158 818 35 - - HYPH 37158 818 36 creatures creature NNS 37158 818 37 . . . 37158 819 1 All all PDT 37158 819 2 the the DT 37158 819 3 most most RBS 37158 819 4 subtle subtle JJ 37158 819 5 sophisms sophism NNS 37158 819 6 will will MD 37158 819 7 never never RB 37158 819 8 be be VB 37158 819 9 able able JJ 37158 819 10 to to TO 37158 819 11 persuade persuade VB 37158 819 12 me -PRON- PRP 37158 819 13 that that IN 37158 819 14 I -PRON- PRP 37158 819 15 ought ought MD 37158 819 16 not not RB 37158 819 17 , , , 37158 819 18 above above IN 37158 819 19 all all DT 37158 819 20 things thing NNS 37158 819 21 , , , 37158 819 22 to to TO 37158 819 23 feel feel VB 37158 819 24 solicitude solicitude JJ 37158 819 25 for for IN 37158 819 26 the the DT 37158 819 27 lives life NNS 37158 819 28 and and CC 37158 819 29 happiness happiness NN 37158 819 30 of of IN 37158 819 31 men man NNS 37158 819 32 . . . 37158 820 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 820 2 willingly willingly RB 37158 820 3 admit admit VBP 37158 820 4 that that IN 37158 820 5 beside beside DT 37158 820 6 man man NN 37158 820 7 there there EX 37158 820 8 is be VBZ 37158 820 9 the the DT 37158 820 10 animal animal NN 37158 820 11 , , , 37158 820 12 _ _ NNP 37158 820 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 820 14 inferior inferior JJ 37158 820 15 brother brother NN 37158 820 16 _ _ NNP 37158 820 17 as as IN 37158 820 18 it -PRON- PRP 37158 820 19 has have VBZ 37158 820 20 been be VBN 37158 820 21 ingeniously ingeniously RB 37158 820 22 called call VBN 37158 820 23 , , , 37158 820 24 so so IN 37158 820 25 that that IN 37158 820 26 we -PRON- PRP 37158 820 27 have have VBP 37158 820 28 also also RB 37158 820 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 820 30 duties duty NNS 37158 820 31 towards towards IN 37158 820 32 these these DT 37158 820 33 inferior inferior JJ 37158 820 34 brothers brother NNS 37158 820 35 . . . 37158 821 1 But but CC 37158 821 2 _ _ NNP 37158 821 3 this this DT 37158 821 4 must must MD 37158 821 5 never never RB 37158 821 6 be be VB 37158 821 7 to to IN 37158 821 8 the the DT 37158 821 9 detriment detriment NN 37158 821 10 of of IN 37158 821 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 821 12 real real JJ 37158 821 13 brothers brother NNS 37158 821 14 _ _ NNP 37158 821 15 . . . 37158 822 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 822 2 seems seem VBZ 37158 822 3 to to IN 37158 822 4 me -PRON- PRP 37158 822 5 insane insane JJ 37158 822 6 to to TO 37158 822 7 consider consider VB 37158 822 8 the the DT 37158 822 9 life life NN 37158 822 10 of of IN 37158 822 11 a a DT 37158 822 12 cat cat NN 37158 822 13 of of IN 37158 822 14 more more JJR 37158 822 15 account account NN 37158 822 16 than than IN 37158 822 17 that that DT 37158 822 18 of of IN 37158 822 19 a a DT 37158 822 20 man man NN 37158 822 21 ; ; : 37158 822 22 the the DT 37158 822 23 pain pain NN 37158 822 24 of of IN 37158 822 25 a a DT 37158 822 26 dog dog NN 37158 822 27 than than IN 37158 822 28 that that DT 37158 822 29 of of IN 37158 822 30 a a DT 37158 822 31 child child NN 37158 822 32 . . . 37158 823 1 All all PDT 37158 823 2 the the DT 37158 823 3 more more RBR 37158 823 4 so so RB 37158 823 5 because because IN 37158 823 6 living living NN 37158 823 7 matter matter NN 37158 823 8 , , , 37158 823 9 if if IN 37158 823 10 I -PRON- PRP 37158 823 11 may may MD 37158 823 12 use use VB 37158 823 13 that that DT 37158 823 14 expression expression NN 37158 823 15 , , , 37158 823 16 possesses possess VBZ 37158 823 17 varying vary VBG 37158 823 18 degrees degree NNS 37158 823 19 of of IN 37158 823 20 perfection perfection NN 37158 823 21 ; ; : 37158 823 22 from from IN 37158 823 23 the the DT 37158 823 24 sea sea NN 37158 823 25 - - HYPH 37158 823 26 weed weed NN 37158 823 27 up up RB 37158 823 28 to to IN 37158 823 29 man man NN 37158 823 30 there there EX 37158 823 31 are be VBP 37158 823 32 successive successive JJ 37158 823 33 stages stage NNS 37158 823 34 of of IN 37158 823 35 living living NN 37158 823 36 forms form NNS 37158 823 37 which which WDT 37158 823 38 constitute constitute VBP 37158 823 39 an an DT 37158 823 40 uninterrupted uninterrupted JJ 37158 823 41 chain chain NN 37158 823 42 ending end VBG 37158 823 43 in in IN 37158 823 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 823 45 final final JJ 37158 823 46 phase phase NN 37158 823 47 , , , 37158 823 48 which which WDT 37158 823 49 is be VBZ 37158 823 50 man man NN 37158 823 51 . . . 37158 824 1 Man man NN 37158 824 2 , , , 37158 824 3 by by IN 37158 824 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 824 5 power power NN 37158 824 6 of of IN 37158 824 7 thought thought NN 37158 824 8 , , , 37158 824 9 and and CC 37158 824 10 consequently consequently RB 37158 824 11 of of IN 37158 824 12 suffering suffering NN 37158 824 13 , , , 37158 824 14 by by IN 37158 824 15 the the DT 37158 824 16 conception conception NN 37158 824 17 which which WDT 37158 824 18 he -PRON- PRP 37158 824 19 is be VBZ 37158 824 20 able able JJ 37158 824 21 to to TO 37158 824 22 make make VB 37158 824 23 of of IN 37158 824 24 the the DT 37158 824 25 non non JJ 37158 824 26 - - NN 37158 824 27 self self JJ 37158 824 28 , , , 37158 824 29 by by IN 37158 824 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 824 31 faculties faculty NNS 37158 824 32 of of IN 37158 824 33 abstraction abstraction NN 37158 824 34 and and CC 37158 824 35 the the DT 37158 824 36 notion notion NN 37158 824 37 of of IN 37158 824 38 good good JJ 37158 824 39 and and CC 37158 824 40 evil evil NN 37158 824 41 , , , 37158 824 42 is be VBZ 37158 824 43 vastly vastly RB 37158 824 44 superior superior JJ 37158 824 45 to to IN 37158 824 46 every every DT 37158 824 47 other other JJ 37158 824 48 living living NN 37158 824 49 being being NN 37158 824 50 . . . 37158 825 1 So so RB 37158 825 2 that that DT 37158 825 3 , , , 37158 825 4 for for IN 37158 825 5 respecting respect VBG 37158 825 6 , , , 37158 825 7 defending defend VBG 37158 825 8 and and CC 37158 825 9 loving love VBG 37158 825 10 men man NNS 37158 825 11 , , , 37158 825 12 I -PRON- PRP 37158 825 13 have have VBP 37158 825 14 not not RB 37158 825 15 only only RB 37158 825 16 the the DT 37158 825 17 reason reason NN 37158 825 18 that that DT 37158 825 19 man man NN 37158 825 20 is be VBZ 37158 825 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 825 22 brother brother NN 37158 825 23 , , , 37158 825 24 but but CC 37158 825 25 also also RB 37158 825 26 that that IN 37158 825 27 this this DT 37158 825 28 brother brother NN 37158 825 29 is be VBZ 37158 825 30 superior superior JJ 37158 825 31 to to IN 37158 825 32 every every DT 37158 825 33 other other JJ 37158 825 34 living living NN 37158 825 35 thing thing NN 37158 825 36 . . . 37158 826 1 That that DT 37158 826 2 is be VBZ 37158 826 3 why why WRB 37158 826 4 a a DT 37158 826 5 moral moral JJ 37158 826 6 code code NN 37158 826 7 must must MD 37158 826 8 be be VB 37158 826 9 essentially essentially RB 37158 826 10 human human JJ 37158 826 11 , , , 37158 826 12 having have VBG 37158 826 13 for for IN 37158 826 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 826 15 highest high JJS 37158 826 16 object object NN 37158 826 17 the the DT 37158 826 18 happiness happiness NN 37158 826 19 of of IN 37158 826 20 other other JJ 37158 826 21 men man NNS 37158 826 22 . . . 37158 827 1 Every every DT 37158 827 2 other other JJ 37158 827 3 code code NN 37158 827 4 of of IN 37158 827 5 morals moral NNS 37158 827 6 , , , 37158 827 7 having have VBG 37158 827 8 in in IN 37158 827 9 view view NN 37158 827 10 a a DT 37158 827 11 different different JJ 37158 827 12 purpose purpose NN 37158 827 13 supporting support VBG 37158 827 14 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 827 15 on on IN 37158 827 16 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 37158 827 17 lucubrations lucubration NNS 37158 827 18 or or CC 37158 827 19 haunted haunt VBN 37158 827 20 by by IN 37158 827 21 puerile puerile JJ 37158 827 22 anxieties anxiety NNS 37158 827 23 , , , 37158 827 24 such such JJ 37158 827 25 as as IN 37158 827 26 the the DT 37158 827 27 adoration adoration NN 37158 827 28 of of IN 37158 827 29 beasts beast NNS 37158 827 30 , , , 37158 827 31 appears appear VBZ 37158 827 32 to to IN 37158 827 33 me -PRON- PRP 37158 827 34 to to TO 37158 827 35 bear bear VB 37158 827 36 the the DT 37158 827 37 stamp stamp NN 37158 827 38 of of IN 37158 827 39 fetishism fetishism NN 37158 827 40 . . . 37158 828 1 An an DT 37158 828 2 unknown unknown JJ 37158 828 3 power power NN 37158 828 4 has have VBZ 37158 828 5 caused cause VBN 37158 828 6 us -PRON- PRP 37158 828 7 to to TO 37158 828 8 be be VB 37158 828 9 born bear VBN 37158 828 10 ; ; : 37158 828 11 we -PRON- PRP 37158 828 12 are be VBP 37158 828 13 entirely entirely RB 37158 828 14 ignorant ignorant JJ 37158 828 15 of of IN 37158 828 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 828 17 destinies destiny NNS 37158 828 18 , , , 37158 828 19 we -PRON- PRP 37158 828 20 know know VBP 37158 828 21 not not RB 37158 828 22 why why WRB 37158 828 23 we -PRON- PRP 37158 828 24 were be VBD 37158 828 25 born bear VBN 37158 828 26 , , , 37158 828 27 why why WRB 37158 828 28 we -PRON- PRP 37158 828 29 die die VBP 37158 828 30 , , , 37158 828 31 why why WRB 37158 828 32 , , , 37158 828 33 following follow VBG 37158 828 34 in in IN 37158 828 35 the the DT 37158 828 36 wake wake NN 37158 828 37 of of IN 37158 828 38 countless countless JJ 37158 828 39 generations generation NNS 37158 828 40 , , , 37158 828 41 we -PRON- PRP 37158 828 42 transmit transmit VBP 37158 828 43 the the DT 37158 828 44 vital vital JJ 37158 828 45 spark spark NN 37158 828 46 to to IN 37158 828 47 countless countless JJ 37158 828 48 succeeding succeed VBG 37158 828 49 generations generation NNS 37158 828 50 . . . 37158 829 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 829 2 know know VBP 37158 829 3 nothing nothing NN 37158 829 4 of of IN 37158 829 5 all all DT 37158 829 6 that that DT 37158 829 7 ; ; : 37158 829 8 but but CC 37158 829 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 829 10 matters matter VBZ 37158 829 11 little little JJ 37158 829 12 from from IN 37158 829 13 the the DT 37158 829 14 point point NN 37158 829 15 of of IN 37158 829 16 view view NN 37158 829 17 of of IN 37158 829 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 829 19 duty duty NN 37158 829 20 . . . 37158 830 1 Duty duty NN 37158 830 2 is be VBZ 37158 830 3 independent independent JJ 37158 830 4 of of IN 37158 830 5 all all DT 37158 830 6 theory theory NN 37158 830 7 . . . 37158 831 1 No no DT 37158 831 2 mere mere JJ 37158 831 3 religion religion NN 37158 831 4 is be VBZ 37158 831 5 necessary necessary JJ 37158 831 6 to to TO 37158 831 7 constitute constitute VB 37158 831 8 a a DT 37158 831 9 moral moral JJ 37158 831 10 code code NN 37158 831 11 . . . 37158 832 1 _ _ NNP 37158 832 2 Homo Homo NNP 37158 832 3 sum sum NN 37158 832 4 , , , 37158 832 5 humani humani NNP 37158 832 6 nihil nihil NNP 37158 832 7 a a DT 37158 832 8 me -PRON- PRP 37158 832 9 alienum alienum NNP 37158 832 10 puto puto NNP 37158 832 11 _ _ NNP 37158 832 12 , , , 37158 832 13 or or CC 37158 832 14 rather rather RB 37158 832 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 832 16 moral moral JJ 37158 832 17 code code NN 37158 832 18 , , , 37158 832 19 will will MD 37158 832 20 be be VB 37158 832 21 the the DT 37158 832 22 religion religion NN 37158 832 23 of of IN 37158 832 24 humanity humanity NN 37158 832 25 . . . 37158 833 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 833 2 does do VBZ 37158 833 3 not not RB 37158 833 4 seem seem VB 37158 833 5 to to IN 37158 833 6 me -PRON- PRP 37158 833 7 possible possible JJ 37158 833 8 to to TO 37158 833 9 conceive conceive VB 37158 833 10 of of IN 37158 833 11 any any DT 37158 833 12 other other JJ 37158 833 13 . . . 37158 834 1 And and CC 37158 834 2 when when WRB 37158 834 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 834 4 say say VBP 37158 834 5 humanity humanity NN 37158 834 6 , , , 37158 834 7 we -PRON- PRP 37158 834 8 take take VBP 37158 834 9 that that DT 37158 834 10 word word NN 37158 834 11 in in IN 37158 834 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 834 13 largest large JJS 37158 834 14 acceptation acceptation NN 37158 834 15 . . . 37158 835 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 835 2 is be VBZ 37158 835 3 not not RB 37158 835 4 a a DT 37158 835 5 question question NN 37158 835 6 of of IN 37158 835 7 compatriots compatriot NNS 37158 835 8 , , , 37158 835 9 nor nor CC 37158 835 10 of of IN 37158 835 11 Europeans Europeans NNPS 37158 835 12 , , , 37158 835 13 nor nor CC 37158 835 14 even even RB 37158 835 15 of of IN 37158 835 16 humanity humanity NN 37158 835 17 of of IN 37158 835 18 to to IN 37158 835 19 - - HYPH 37158 835 20 day day NN 37158 835 21 . . . 37158 836 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 836 2 is be VBZ 37158 836 3 also also RB 37158 836 4 a a DT 37158 836 5 question question NN 37158 836 6 of of IN 37158 836 7 the the DT 37158 836 8 humanity humanity NN 37158 836 9 of of IN 37158 836 10 the the DT 37158 836 11 future future NN 37158 836 12 . . . 37158 837 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 837 2 have have VBP 37158 837 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 837 4 duties duty NNS 37158 837 5 towards towards IN 37158 837 6 the the DT 37158 837 7 man man NN 37158 837 8 of of IN 37158 837 9 to to IN 37158 837 10 - - HYPH 37158 837 11 day day NN 37158 837 12 ; ; : 37158 837 13 but but CC 37158 837 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 837 15 have have VBP 37158 837 16 also also RB 37158 837 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 837 18 duties duty NNS 37158 837 19 towards towards IN 37158 837 20 the the DT 37158 837 21 man man NN 37158 837 22 who who WP 37158 837 23 will will MD 37158 837 24 live live VB 37158 837 25 in in IN 37158 837 26 the the DT 37158 837 27 centuries century NNS 37158 837 28 to to TO 37158 837 29 come come VB 37158 837 30 . . . 37158 838 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 838 2 should should MD 37158 838 3 prepare prepare VB 37158 838 4 the the DT 37158 838 5 way way NN 37158 838 6 for for IN 37158 838 7 a a DT 37158 838 8 happier happy JJR 37158 838 9 and and CC 37158 838 10 better well JJR 37158 838 11 humanity humanity NN 37158 838 12 . . . 37158 839 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 839 2 task task NN 37158 839 3 is be VBZ 37158 839 4 not not RB 37158 839 5 limited limit VBN 37158 839 6 to to IN 37158 839 7 the the DT 37158 839 8 present present JJ 37158 839 9 hour hour NN 37158 839 10 ; ; : 37158 839 11 it -PRON- PRP 37158 839 12 extends extend VBZ 37158 839 13 to to IN 37158 839 14 all all PDT 37158 839 15 those those DT 37158 839 16 human human JJ 37158 839 17 beings being NNS 37158 839 18 who who WP 37158 839 19 will will MD 37158 839 20 come come VB 37158 839 21 after after IN 37158 839 22 us -PRON- PRP 37158 839 23 . . . 37158 840 1 Inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37158 840 2 as as IN 37158 840 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 840 4 of of IN 37158 840 5 to to IN 37158 840 6 - - HYPH 37158 840 7 day day NN 37158 840 8 , , , 37158 840 9 at at IN 37158 840 10 every every DT 37158 840 11 moment moment NN 37158 840 12 of of IN 37158 840 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 840 14 lives life NNS 37158 840 15 , , , 37158 840 16 benefit benefit VBP 37158 840 17 from from IN 37158 840 18 the the DT 37158 840 19 accumulated accumulate VBN 37158 840 20 services service NNS 37158 840 21 of of IN 37158 840 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 840 23 ancestors ancestor NNS 37158 840 24 , , , 37158 840 25 so so CC 37158 840 26 the the DT 37158 840 27 men man NNS 37158 840 28 to to TO 37158 840 29 come come VB 37158 840 30 will will MD 37158 840 31 profit profit VB 37158 840 32 by by IN 37158 840 33 the the DT 37158 840 34 benefits benefit NNS 37158 840 35 which which WDT 37158 840 36 we -PRON- PRP 37158 840 37 are be VBP 37158 840 38 endeavouring endeavour VBG 37158 840 39 to to TO 37158 840 40 prepare prepare VB 37158 840 41 for for IN 37158 840 42 them -PRON- PRP 37158 840 43 . . . 37158 841 1 Assuredly assuredly RB 37158 841 2 , , , 37158 841 3 Humanity humanity NN 37158 841 4 will will MD 37158 841 5 not not RB 37158 841 6 be be VB 37158 841 7 eternal eternal JJ 37158 841 8 , , , 37158 841 9 and and CC 37158 841 10 Science Science NNP 37158 841 11 seems seem VBZ 37158 841 12 to to TO 37158 841 13 prove prove VB 37158 841 14 that that IN 37158 841 15 a a DT 37158 841 16 time time NN 37158 841 17 will will MD 37158 841 18 come come VB 37158 841 19 when when WRB 37158 841 20 the the DT 37158 841 21 sun sun NN 37158 841 22 's 's POS 37158 841 23 heat heat NN 37158 841 24 will will MD 37158 841 25 be be VB 37158 841 26 insufficient insufficient JJ 37158 841 27 to to TO 37158 841 28 develop develop VB 37158 841 29 life life NN 37158 841 30 on on IN 37158 841 31 the the DT 37158 841 32 surface surface NN 37158 841 33 of of IN 37158 841 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 841 35 puny puny JJ 37158 841 36 planet planet NN 37158 841 37 . . . 37158 842 1 A a DT 37158 842 2 time time NN 37158 842 3 will will MD 37158 842 4 come come VB 37158 842 5 when when WRB 37158 842 6 the the DT 37158 842 7 earth earth NN 37158 842 8 will will MD 37158 842 9 have have VB 37158 842 10 cooled cool VBN 37158 842 11 down down RP 37158 842 12 and and CC 37158 842 13 become become VB 37158 842 14 like like IN 37158 842 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 842 16 pale pale JJ 37158 842 17 satellite satellite NN 37158 842 18 , , , 37158 842 19 the the DT 37158 842 20 moon moon NN 37158 842 21 , , , 37158 842 22 a a DT 37158 842 23 dead dead JJ 37158 842 24 star star NN 37158 842 25 , , , 37158 842 26 where where WRB 37158 842 27 the the DT 37158 842 28 debris debris NN 37158 842 29 of of IN 37158 842 30 extinct extinct JJ 37158 842 31 multitudinous multitudinous JJ 37158 842 32 civilisations civilisation NNS 37158 842 33 will will MD 37158 842 34 disappear disappear VB 37158 842 35 under under IN 37158 842 36 the the DT 37158 842 37 ice ice NN 37158 842 38 . . . 37158 843 1 But but CC 37158 843 2 what what WP 37158 843 3 matter matter NN 37158 843 4 ! ! . 37158 844 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 844 2 have have VBP 37158 844 3 not not RB 37158 844 4 to to TO 37158 844 5 trouble trouble VB 37158 844 6 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 844 7 about about IN 37158 844 8 those those DT 37158 844 9 far far RB 37158 844 10 - - HYPH 37158 844 11 off off RP 37158 844 12 times time NNS 37158 844 13 . . . 37158 845 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 845 2 have have VBP 37158 845 3 to to TO 37158 845 4 think think VB 37158 845 5 of of IN 37158 845 6 the the DT 37158 845 7 man man NN 37158 845 8 of of IN 37158 845 9 the the DT 37158 845 10 coming come VBG 37158 845 11 centuries century NNS 37158 845 12 , , , 37158 845 13 and and CC 37158 845 14 , , , 37158 845 15 at at IN 37158 845 16 the the DT 37158 845 17 same same JJ 37158 845 18 time time NN 37158 845 19 , , , 37158 845 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 845 21 goes go VBZ 37158 845 22 without without IN 37158 845 23 saying say VBG 37158 845 24 , , , 37158 845 25 of of IN 37158 845 26 the the DT 37158 845 27 man man NN 37158 845 28 of of IN 37158 845 29 to to IN 37158 845 30 - - HYPH 37158 845 31 day day NN 37158 845 32 . . . 37158 846 1 To to TO 37158 846 2 lessen lessen VB 37158 846 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 846 4 misery misery NN 37158 846 5 , , , 37158 846 6 to to TO 37158 846 7 make make VB 37158 846 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 846 9 existence existence NN 37158 846 10 less less RBR 37158 846 11 lamentable lamentable JJ 37158 846 12 , , , 37158 846 13 to to TO 37158 846 14 develop develop VB 37158 846 15 within within IN 37158 846 16 them -PRON- PRP 37158 846 17 the the DT 37158 846 18 sentiments sentiment NNS 37158 846 19 of of IN 37158 846 20 justice justice NN 37158 846 21 and and CC 37158 846 22 brotherhood brotherhood NN 37158 846 23 , , , 37158 846 24 to to TO 37158 846 25 secure secure VB 37158 846 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 846 27 moral moral JJ 37158 846 28 welfare welfare NN 37158 846 29 and and CC 37158 846 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 846 31 material material NN 37158 846 32 welfare welfare NN 37158 846 33 , , , 37158 846 34 that that DT 37158 846 35 is be VBZ 37158 846 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 846 37 strict strict JJ 37158 846 38 and and CC 37158 846 39 sole sole JJ 37158 846 40 duty duty NN 37158 846 41 . . . 37158 847 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 847 2 recognise recognise VBP 37158 847 3 no no DT 37158 847 4 other other JJ 37158 847 5 . . . 37158 848 1 Now now RB 37158 848 2 , , , 37158 848 3 there there EX 37158 848 4 is be VBZ 37158 848 5 but but CC 37158 848 6 one one CD 37158 848 7 way way NN 37158 848 8 open open JJ 37158 848 9 to to TO 37158 848 10 attain attain VB 37158 848 11 this this DT 37158 848 12 noble noble JJ 37158 848 13 goal goal NN 37158 848 14 : : : 37158 848 15 Science science NN 37158 848 16 . . . 37158 849 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 849 2 are be VBP 37158 849 3 plunged plunge VBN 37158 849 4 in in IN 37158 849 5 an an DT 37158 849 6 ocean ocean NN 37158 849 7 of of IN 37158 849 8 gloom gloom NN 37158 849 9 . . . 37158 850 1 All all DT 37158 850 2 is be VBZ 37158 850 3 dark dark JJ 37158 850 4 , , , 37158 850 5 unknown unknown JJ 37158 850 6 , , , 37158 850 7 disturbing disturbing JJ 37158 850 8 . . . 37158 851 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 851 2 have have VBP 37158 851 3 not not RB 37158 851 4 yet yet RB 37158 851 5 understood understand VBN 37158 851 6 anything anything NN 37158 851 7 of of IN 37158 851 8 the the DT 37158 851 9 blind blind JJ 37158 851 10 forces force NNS 37158 851 11 surrounding surround VBG 37158 851 12 us -PRON- PRP 37158 851 13 on on IN 37158 851 14 all all DT 37158 851 15 sides side NNS 37158 851 16 . . . 37158 852 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 852 2 are be VBP 37158 852 3 but but CC 37158 852 4 feeble feeble JJ 37158 852 5 beings being NNS 37158 852 6 cast cast VBN 37158 852 7 into into IN 37158 852 8 the the DT 37158 852 9 midst midst NN 37158 852 10 of of IN 37158 852 11 sovereign sovereign JJ 37158 852 12 powers power NNS 37158 852 13 which which WDT 37158 852 14 overwhelm overwhelm VBP 37158 852 15 and and CC 37158 852 16 bear bear VBP 37158 852 17 us -PRON- PRP 37158 852 18 down down RP 37158 852 19 . . . 37158 853 1 Now now RB 37158 853 2 , , , 37158 853 3 to to TO 37158 853 4 avoid avoid VB 37158 853 5 being be VBG 37158 853 6 completely completely RB 37158 853 7 and and CC 37158 853 8 definitely definitely RB 37158 853 9 crushed crush VBN 37158 853 10 out out IN 37158 853 11 of of IN 37158 853 12 existence existence NN 37158 853 13 , , , 37158 853 14 it -PRON- PRP 37158 853 15 is be VBZ 37158 853 16 necessary necessary JJ 37158 853 17 to to TO 37158 853 18 penetrate penetrate VB 37158 853 19 into into IN 37158 853 20 the the DT 37158 853 21 nature nature NN 37158 853 22 of of IN 37158 853 23 these these DT 37158 853 24 forces force NNS 37158 853 25 . . . 37158 854 1 Alas alas UH 37158 854 2 ! ! . 37158 855 1 we -PRON- PRP 37158 855 2 shall shall MD 37158 855 3 never never RB 37158 855 4 penetrate penetrate VB 37158 855 5 into into IN 37158 855 6 them -PRON- PRP 37158 855 7 , , , 37158 855 8 for for IN 37158 855 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 855 10 is be VBZ 37158 855 11 madness madness NN 37158 855 12 to to TO 37158 855 13 think think VB 37158 855 14 that that IN 37158 855 15 a a DT 37158 855 16 particle particle NN 37158 855 17 of of IN 37158 855 18 the the DT 37158 855 19 whole whole NN 37158 855 20 can can MD 37158 855 21 ever ever RB 37158 855 22 fully fully RB 37158 855 23 cognise cognise VB 37158 855 24 the the DT 37158 855 25 whole whole NN 37158 855 26 ; ; : 37158 855 27 but but CC 37158 855 28 we -PRON- PRP 37158 855 29 may may MD 37158 855 30 at at IN 37158 855 31 least least JJS 37158 855 32 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37158 855 33 some some DT 37158 855 34 facts fact NNS 37158 855 35 , , , 37158 855 36 fathom fathom VB 37158 855 37 some some DT 37158 855 38 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37158 855 39 , , , 37158 855 40 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 855 41 trace trace VB 37158 855 42 a a DT 37158 855 43 few few JJ 37158 855 44 of of IN 37158 855 45 the the DT 37158 855 46 features feature NNS 37158 855 47 of of IN 37158 855 48 certain certain JJ 37158 855 49 laws law NNS 37158 855 50 . . . 37158 856 1 That that DT 37158 856 2 is be VBZ 37158 856 3 enough enough JJ 37158 856 4 to to TO 37158 856 5 make make VB 37158 856 6 us -PRON- PRP 37158 856 7 instantly instantly RB 37158 856 8 the the DT 37158 856 9 masters master NNS 37158 856 10 of of IN 37158 856 11 matter matter NN 37158 856 12 and and CC 37158 856 13 not not RB 37158 856 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 856 15 slaves slave NNS 37158 856 16 . . . 37158 857 1 Every every DT 37158 857 2 new new JJ 37158 857 3 truth truth NN 37158 857 4 at at IN 37158 857 5 once once RB 37158 857 6 brings bring VBZ 37158 857 7 about about RP 37158 857 8 an an DT 37158 857 9 amelioration amelioration NN 37158 857 10 in in IN 37158 857 11 human human JJ 37158 857 12 conditions condition NNS 37158 857 13 . . . 37158 858 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 858 2 may may MD 37158 858 3 be be VB 37158 858 4 said say VBN 37158 858 5 that that IN 37158 858 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 858 7 _ _ NNP 37158 858 8 happiness happiness NN 37158 858 9 is be VBZ 37158 858 10 made make VBN 37158 858 11 up up RP 37158 858 12 of of IN 37158 858 13 truth truth NN 37158 858 14 _ _ NNP 37158 858 15 . . . 37158 859 1 Let let VB 37158 859 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 859 3 suppose suppose VB 37158 859 4 what what WP 37158 859 5 is be VBZ 37158 859 6 improbable improbable JJ 37158 859 7 , , , 37158 859 8 that that DT 37158 859 9 is be VBZ 37158 859 10 to to TO 37158 859 11 say say VB 37158 859 12 , , , 37158 859 13 that that IN 37158 859 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 859 15 have have VBP 37158 859 16 come come VBN 37158 859 17 to to TO 37158 859 18 know know VB 37158 859 19 all all PDT 37158 859 20 the the DT 37158 859 21 laws law NNS 37158 859 22 of of IN 37158 859 23 Nature Nature NNP 37158 859 24 , , , 37158 859 25 should should MD 37158 859 26 we -PRON- PRP 37158 859 27 not not RB 37158 859 28 immediately immediately RB 37158 859 29 become become VB 37158 859 30 all all RB 37158 859 31 - - HYPH 37158 859 32 powerful powerful JJ 37158 859 33 ? ? . 37158 860 1 Should Should MD 37158 860 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 860 3 not not RB 37158 860 4 be be VB 37158 860 5 the the DT 37158 860 6 sovereign sovereign JJ 37158 860 7 masters master NNS 37158 860 8 of of IN 37158 860 9 disease disease NN 37158 860 10 and and CC 37158 860 11 pain pain NN 37158 860 12 , , , 37158 860 13 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 860 14 of of IN 37158 860 15 old old JJ 37158 860 16 age age NN 37158 860 17 and and CC 37158 860 18 death death NN 37158 860 19 ? ? . 37158 861 1 Such such JJ 37158 861 2 , , , 37158 861 3 indeed indeed RB 37158 861 4 , , , 37158 861 5 appears appear VBZ 37158 861 6 to to TO 37158 861 7 be be VB 37158 861 8 the the DT 37158 861 9 conviction conviction NN 37158 861 10 of of IN 37158 861 11 the the DT 37158 861 12 human human JJ 37158 861 13 societies society NNS 37158 861 14 which which WDT 37158 861 15 assign assign VBP 37158 861 16 a a DT 37158 861 17 preponderating preponderating NN 37158 861 18 rôle rôle NN 37158 861 19 to to IN 37158 861 20 Science Science NNP 37158 861 21 . . . 37158 862 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 862 2 have have VBP 37158 862 3 understood understand VBN 37158 862 4 that that IN 37158 862 5 there there EX 37158 862 6 is be VBZ 37158 862 7 no no DT 37158 862 8 better well JJR 37158 862 9 future future NN 37158 862 10 in in IN 37158 862 11 store store NN 37158 862 12 for for IN 37158 862 13 the the DT 37158 862 14 human human NN 37158 862 15 being being NN 37158 862 16 than than IN 37158 862 17 that that DT 37158 862 18 which which WDT 37158 862 19 Science Science NNP 37158 862 20 will will MD 37158 862 21 bring bring VB 37158 862 22 about about RP 37158 862 23 for for IN 37158 862 24 him -PRON- PRP 37158 862 25 . . . 37158 863 1 To to TO 37158 863 2 be be VB 37158 863 3 able able JJ 37158 863 4 to to TO 37158 863 5 appreciate appreciate VB 37158 863 6 the the DT 37158 863 7 extent extent NN 37158 863 8 to to TO 37158 863 9 which which WDT 37158 863 10 the the DT 37158 863 11 man man NN 37158 863 12 of of IN 37158 863 13 to to IN 37158 863 14 - - HYPH 37158 863 15 day day NN 37158 863 16 is be VBZ 37158 863 17 materially materially RB 37158 863 18 and and CC 37158 863 19 morally morally RB 37158 863 20 happier happy JJR 37158 863 21 than than IN 37158 863 22 the the DT 37158 863 23 man man NN 37158 863 24 of of IN 37158 863 25 past past JJ 37158 863 26 ages age NNS 37158 863 27 , , , 37158 863 28 we -PRON- PRP 37158 863 29 have have VBP 37158 863 30 only only RB 37158 863 31 to to TO 37158 863 32 compare compare VB 37158 863 33 the the DT 37158 863 34 present present JJ 37158 863 35 state state NN 37158 863 36 of of IN 37158 863 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 863 38 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 863 39 with with IN 37158 863 40 the the DT 37158 863 41 state state NN 37158 863 42 of of IN 37158 863 43 past past JJ 37158 863 44 civilisations civilisation NNS 37158 863 45 . . . 37158 864 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 864 2 may may MD 37158 864 3 say say VB 37158 864 4 that that IN 37158 864 5 an an DT 37158 864 6 English english JJ 37158 864 7 labourer labourer NN 37158 864 8 of of IN 37158 864 9 to to IN 37158 864 10 - - HYPH 37158 864 11 day day NN 37158 864 12 has have VBZ 37158 864 13 a a DT 37158 864 14 much much RB 37158 864 15 easier easy JJR 37158 864 16 existence existence NN 37158 864 17 than than IN 37158 864 18 had have VBD 37158 864 19 an an DT 37158 864 20 Italian italian JJ 37158 864 21 prince prince NN 37158 864 22 of of IN 37158 864 23 the the DT 37158 864 24 fourteenth fourteenth JJ 37158 864 25 century century NN 37158 864 26 . . . 37158 865 1 Everywhere everywhere RB 37158 865 2 , , , 37158 865 3 the the DT 37158 865 4 progress progress NN 37158 865 5 achieved achieve VBN 37158 865 6 by by IN 37158 865 7 Science Science NNP 37158 865 8 has have VBZ 37158 865 9 entered enter VBN 37158 865 10 into into IN 37158 865 11 the the DT 37158 865 12 life life NN 37158 865 13 of of IN 37158 865 14 each each DT 37158 865 15 individual individual NN 37158 865 16 . . . 37158 866 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 866 2 find find VBP 37158 866 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 866 4 in in IN 37158 866 5 the the DT 37158 866 6 book book NN 37158 866 7 we -PRON- PRP 37158 866 8 read read VBP 37158 866 9 , , , 37158 866 10 in in IN 37158 866 11 the the DT 37158 866 12 electricity electricity NN 37158 866 13 which which WDT 37158 866 14 gives give VBZ 37158 866 15 us -PRON- PRP 37158 866 16 light light NN 37158 866 17 , , , 37158 866 18 in in IN 37158 866 19 the the DT 37158 866 20 train train NN 37158 866 21 or or CC 37158 866 22 the the DT 37158 866 23 steamer steamer NN 37158 866 24 which which WDT 37158 866 25 carries carry VBZ 37158 866 26 us -PRON- PRP 37158 866 27 to to IN 37158 866 28 the the DT 37158 866 29 uttermost uttermost NN 37158 866 30 corners corner NNS 37158 866 31 of of IN 37158 866 32 the the DT 37158 866 33 earth earth NN 37158 866 34 in in IN 37158 866 35 little little JJ 37158 866 36 time time NN 37158 866 37 and and CC 37158 866 38 at at IN 37158 866 39 little little JJ 37158 866 40 cost cost NN 37158 866 41 . . . 37158 867 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 867 2 is be VBZ 37158 867 3 the the DT 37158 867 4 same same JJ 37158 867 5 thing thing NN 37158 867 6 also also RB 37158 867 7 with with IN 37158 867 8 medicaments medicament NNS 37158 867 9 , , , 37158 867 10 which which WDT 37158 867 11 are be VBP 37158 867 12 certainly certainly RB 37158 867 13 able able JJ 37158 867 14 to to TO 37158 867 15 lessen lessen VB 37158 867 16 the the DT 37158 867 17 pain pain NN 37158 867 18 of of IN 37158 867 19 disease disease NN 37158 867 20 . . . 37158 868 1 Moral moral JJ 37158 868 2 progress progress NN 37158 868 3 has have VBZ 37158 868 4 kept keep VBN 37158 868 5 pace pace NN 37158 868 6 with with IN 37158 868 7 material material JJ 37158 868 8 progress progress NN 37158 868 9 . . . 37158 869 1 At at IN 37158 869 2 the the DT 37158 869 3 same same JJ 37158 869 4 time time NN 37158 869 5 that that WDT 37158 869 6 matter matter NN 37158 869 7 has have VBZ 37158 869 8 been be VBN 37158 869 9 overcome overcome VBN 37158 869 10 , , , 37158 869 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 869 12 customs custom NNS 37158 869 13 have have VBP 37158 869 14 become become VBN 37158 869 15 gentler gentler JJ 37158 869 16 ; ; , 37158 869 17 individual individual JJ 37158 869 18 liberty liberty NN 37158 869 19 is be VBZ 37158 869 20 a a DT 37158 869 21 sacred sacred JJ 37158 869 22 thing thing NN 37158 869 23 ; ; : 37158 869 24 each each DT 37158 869 25 citizen citizen NN 37158 869 26 takes take VBZ 37158 869 27 part part NN 37158 869 28 in in IN 37158 869 29 the the DT 37158 869 30 decisions decision NNS 37158 869 31 of of IN 37158 869 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 869 33 government government NN 37158 869 34 ; ; : 37158 869 35 there there EX 37158 869 36 is be VBZ 37158 869 37 no no DT 37158 869 38 longer long RBR 37158 869 39 either either CC 37158 869 40 slavery slavery NN 37158 869 41 or or CC 37158 869 42 torture torture NN 37158 869 43 or or CC 37158 869 44 tyranny tyranny NN 37158 869 45 of of IN 37158 869 46 conscience conscience NN 37158 869 47 . . . 37158 870 1 In in IN 37158 870 2 a a DT 37158 870 3 word word NN 37158 870 4 , , , 37158 870 5 the the DT 37158 870 6 man man NN 37158 870 7 of of IN 37158 870 8 to to IN 37158 870 9 - - HYPH 37158 870 10 day day NN 37158 870 11 is be VBZ 37158 870 12 happier happy JJR 37158 870 13 and and CC 37158 870 14 more more RBR 37158 870 15 powerful powerful JJ 37158 870 16 than than IN 37158 870 17 the the DT 37158 870 18 man man NN 37158 870 19 of of IN 37158 870 20 bygone bygone NNP 37158 870 21 days day NNS 37158 870 22 . . . 37158 871 1 This this DT 37158 871 2 happiness happiness NN 37158 871 3 has have VBZ 37158 871 4 not not RB 37158 871 5 been be VBN 37158 871 6 acquired acquire VBN 37158 871 7 through through IN 37158 871 8 any any DT 37158 871 9 providential providential JJ 37158 871 10 " " `` 37158 871 11 miracles miracle NNS 37158 871 12 . . . 37158 871 13 " " '' 37158 872 1 No no UH 37158 872 2 God God NNP 37158 872 3 came come VBD 37158 872 4 down down RP 37158 872 5 from from IN 37158 872 6 His -PRON- PRP$ 37158 872 7 Heaven Heaven NNP 37158 872 8 to to TO 37158 872 9 alleviate alleviate VB 37158 872 10 human human JJ 37158 872 11 misfortunes misfortune NNS 37158 872 12 . . . 37158 873 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 873 2 is be VBZ 37158 873 3 man man NN 37158 873 4 , , , 37158 873 5 and and CC 37158 873 6 man man VB 37158 873 7 alone alone RB 37158 873 8 , , , 37158 873 9 who who WP 37158 873 10 , , , 37158 873 11 by by IN 37158 873 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 873 13 genius genius NN 37158 873 14 and and CC 37158 873 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 873 16 labours labour NNS 37158 873 17 , , , 37158 873 18 has have VBZ 37158 873 19 been be VBN 37158 873 20 able able JJ 37158 873 21 to to TO 37158 873 22 make make VB 37158 873 23 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 873 24 master master NN 37158 873 25 of of IN 37158 873 26 the the DT 37158 873 27 forces force NNS 37158 873 28 which which WDT 37158 873 29 , , , 37158 873 30 even even RB 37158 873 31 yesterday yesterday NN 37158 873 32 , , , 37158 873 33 held hold VBD 37158 873 34 him -PRON- PRP 37158 873 35 in in IN 37158 873 36 bondage bondage NN 37158 873 37 . . . 37158 874 1 And and CC 37158 874 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 874 3 can can MD 37158 874 4 not not RB 37158 874 5 be be VB 37158 874 6 too too RB 37158 874 7 grateful grateful JJ 37158 874 8 to to IN 37158 874 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 874 10 fathers father NNS 37158 874 11 for for IN 37158 874 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 874 13 immense immense JJ 37158 874 14 and and CC 37158 874 15 fruitful fruitful JJ 37158 874 16 labours labour NNS 37158 874 17 , , , 37158 874 18 by by IN 37158 874 19 which which WDT 37158 874 20 they -PRON- PRP 37158 874 21 succeeded succeed VBD 37158 874 22 in in IN 37158 874 23 constructing construct VBG 37158 874 24 the the DT 37158 874 25 society society NN 37158 874 26 in in IN 37158 874 27 the the DT 37158 874 28 midst midst NN 37158 874 29 of of IN 37158 874 30 which which WDT 37158 874 31 we -PRON- PRP 37158 874 32 live live VBP 37158 874 33 . . . 37158 875 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 875 2 is be VBZ 37158 875 3 still still RB 37158 875 4 wretched wretched JJ 37158 875 5 enough enough RB 37158 875 6 , , , 37158 875 7 this this DT 37158 875 8 society society NN 37158 875 9 of of IN 37158 875 10 ours our NNS 37158 875 11 , , , 37158 875 12 afflicted afflict VBN 37158 875 13 with with IN 37158 875 14 crimes crime NNS 37158 875 15 and and CC 37158 875 16 horrors horror NNS 37158 875 17 , , , 37158 875 18 the the DT 37158 875 19 infamy infamy NN 37158 875 20 of of IN 37158 875 21 which which WDT 37158 875 22 we -PRON- PRP 37158 875 23 understand understand VBP 37158 875 24 full full JJ 37158 875 25 well well RB 37158 875 26 ; ; : 37158 875 27 but but CC 37158 875 28 however however RB 37158 875 29 wretched wretched JJ 37158 875 30 it -PRON- PRP 37158 875 31 may may MD 37158 875 32 be be VB 37158 875 33 , , , 37158 875 34 it -PRON- PRP 37158 875 35 is be VBZ 37158 875 36 a a DT 37158 875 37 thousand thousand CD 37158 875 38 times time NNS 37158 875 39 less less RBR 37158 875 40 wretched wretched JJ 37158 875 41 than than IN 37158 875 42 was be VBD 37158 875 43 society society NN 37158 875 44 of of IN 37158 875 45 yore yore NN 37158 875 46 . . . 37158 876 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 876 2 , , , 37158 876 3 this this DT 37158 876 4 formal formal JJ 37158 876 5 conclusion conclusion NN 37158 876 6 may may MD 37158 876 7 at at IN 37158 876 8 once once RB 37158 876 9 be be VB 37158 876 10 deduced deduce VBN 37158 876 11 ; ; : 37158 876 12 we -PRON- PRP 37158 876 13 must must MD 37158 876 14 do do VB 37158 876 15 for for IN 37158 876 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 876 17 descendants descendant NNS 37158 876 18 what what WP 37158 876 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 876 20 fathers father NNS 37158 876 21 did do VBD 37158 876 22 for for IN 37158 876 23 us -PRON- PRP 37158 876 24 . . . 37158 877 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 877 2 would would MD 37158 877 3 be be VB 37158 877 4 without without IN 37158 877 5 excuse excuse NN 37158 877 6 if if IN 37158 877 7 we -PRON- PRP 37158 877 8 rested rest VBD 37158 877 9 content content NN 37158 877 10 to to TO 37158 877 11 benefit benefit VB 37158 877 12 from from IN 37158 877 13 the the DT 37158 877 14 works work NNS 37158 877 15 of of IN 37158 877 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 877 17 predecessors predecessor NNS 37158 877 18 without without IN 37158 877 19 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 877 20 also also RB 37158 877 21 creating create VBG 37158 877 22 something something NN 37158 877 23 , , , 37158 877 24 without without IN 37158 877 25 leaving leave VBG 37158 877 26 , , , 37158 877 27 by by IN 37158 877 28 means mean NNS 37158 877 29 of of IN 37158 877 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 877 31 personal personal JJ 37158 877 32 labours labour NNS 37158 877 33 , , , 37158 877 34 a a DT 37158 877 35 better well JJR 37158 877 36 lot lot NN 37158 877 37 to to IN 37158 877 38 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 877 39 descendants descendant NNS 37158 877 40 . . . 37158 878 1 The the DT 37158 878 2 man man NN 37158 878 3 who who WP 37158 878 4 has have VBZ 37158 878 5 not not RB 37158 878 6 understood understand VBN 37158 878 7 this this DT 37158 878 8 supreme supreme JJ 37158 878 9 duty duty NN 37158 878 10 is be VBZ 37158 878 11 truly truly RB 37158 878 12 unworthy unworthy JJ 37158 878 13 of of IN 37158 878 14 being be VBG 37158 878 15 a a DT 37158 878 16 man man NN 37158 878 17 . . . 37158 879 1 Verily verily RB 37158 879 2 , , , 37158 879 3 every every DT 37158 879 4 individual individual NN 37158 879 5 , , , 37158 879 6 when when WRB 37158 879 7 he -PRON- PRP 37158 879 8 has have VBZ 37158 879 9 arrived arrive VBN 37158 879 10 at at IN 37158 879 11 the the DT 37158 879 12 end end NN 37158 879 13 of of IN 37158 879 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 879 15 life life NN 37158 879 16 , , , 37158 879 17 should should MD 37158 879 18 examine examine VB 37158 879 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 879 20 conscience conscience NN 37158 879 21 and and CC 37158 879 22 ask ask VB 37158 879 23 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 879 24 if if IN 37158 879 25 in in IN 37158 879 26 the the DT 37158 879 27 humble humble JJ 37158 879 28 sphere sphere NN 37158 879 29 of of IN 37158 879 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 879 31 action action NN 37158 879 32 , , , 37158 879 33 he -PRON- PRP 37158 879 34 has have VBZ 37158 879 35 not not RB 37158 879 36 , , , 37158 879 37 even even RB 37158 879 38 he -PRON- PRP 37158 879 39 also also RB 37158 879 40 , , , 37158 879 41 contributed contribute VBD 37158 879 42 a a DT 37158 879 43 stone stone NN 37158 879 44 to to IN 37158 879 45 the the DT 37158 879 46 human human JJ 37158 879 47 edifice edifice NN 37158 879 48 , , , 37158 879 49 if if IN 37158 879 50 he -PRON- PRP 37158 879 51 has have VBZ 37158 879 52 not not RB 37158 879 53 done do VBN 37158 879 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 879 55 share share NN 37158 879 56 in in IN 37158 879 57 promoting promote VBG 37158 879 58 and and CC 37158 879 59 increasing increase VBG 37158 879 60 the the DT 37158 879 61 forces force NNS 37158 879 62 of of IN 37158 879 63 humanity humanity NN 37158 879 64 . . . 37158 880 1 Since since IN 37158 880 2 matters matter NNS 37158 880 3 stand stand VBP 37158 880 4 thus thus RB 37158 880 5 , , , 37158 880 6 since since IN 37158 880 7 the the DT 37158 880 8 development development NN 37158 880 9 of of IN 37158 880 10 Science Science NNP 37158 880 11 is be VBZ 37158 880 12 the the DT 37158 880 13 fundamental fundamental JJ 37158 880 14 condition condition NN 37158 880 15 of of IN 37158 880 16 the the DT 37158 880 17 happiness happiness NN 37158 880 18 of of IN 37158 880 19 man man NN 37158 880 20 , , , 37158 880 21 we -PRON- PRP 37158 880 22 must must MD 37158 880 23 resolutely resolutely RB 37158 880 24 put put VB 37158 880 25 Science Science NNP 37158 880 26 at at IN 37158 880 27 the the DT 37158 880 28 basis basis NN 37158 880 29 of of IN 37158 880 30 every every DT 37158 880 31 civilisation civilisation NN 37158 880 32 . . . 37158 881 1 Alas alas UH 37158 881 2 ! ! . 37158 882 1 it -PRON- PRP 37158 882 2 has have VBZ 37158 882 3 not not RB 37158 882 4 been be VBN 37158 882 5 so so RB 37158 882 6 up up IN 37158 882 7 to to IN 37158 882 8 the the DT 37158 882 9 present present NN 37158 882 10 ; ; : 37158 882 11 and and CC 37158 882 12 if if IN 37158 882 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 882 14 study study VBP 37158 882 15 the the DT 37158 882 16 development development NN 37158 882 17 of of IN 37158 882 18 human human JJ 37158 882 19 societies society NNS 37158 882 20 , , , 37158 882 21 we -PRON- PRP 37158 882 22 see see VBP 37158 882 23 that that IN 37158 882 24 they -PRON- PRP 37158 882 25 are be VBP 37158 882 26 above above IN 37158 882 27 all all DT 37158 882 28 things thing NNS 37158 882 29 attracted attract VBN 37158 882 30 to to IN 37158 882 31 war war NN 37158 882 32 . . . 37158 883 1 Science science NN 37158 883 2 has have VBZ 37158 883 3 had have VBN 37158 883 4 only only RB 37158 883 5 the the DT 37158 883 6 leavings leaving NNS 37158 883 7 . . . 37158 884 1 But but CC 37158 884 2 the the DT 37158 884 3 time time NN 37158 884 4 has have VBZ 37158 884 5 come come VBN 37158 884 6 when when WRB 37158 884 7 man man NN 37158 884 8 should should MD 37158 884 9 no no RB 37158 884 10 longer longer RB 37158 884 11 believe believe VB 37158 884 12 that that IN 37158 884 13 the the DT 37158 884 14 principle principle NN 37158 884 15 of of IN 37158 884 16 morality morality NN 37158 884 17 is be VBZ 37158 884 18 man man NN 37158 884 19 's 's POS 37158 884 20 struggle struggle NN 37158 884 21 against against IN 37158 884 22 man man NN 37158 884 23 . . . 37158 885 1 That that DT 37158 885 2 was be VBD 37158 885 3 the the DT 37158 885 4 history history NN 37158 885 5 of of IN 37158 885 6 bye bye NN 37158 885 7 - - HYPH 37158 885 8 gone go VBN 37158 885 9 times time NNS 37158 885 10 . . . 37158 886 1 The the DT 37158 886 2 history history NN 37158 886 3 of of IN 37158 886 4 to to IN 37158 886 5 - - HYPH 37158 886 6 day day NN 37158 886 7 , , , 37158 886 8 and and CC 37158 886 9 especially especially RB 37158 886 10 the the DT 37158 886 11 history history NN 37158 886 12 of of IN 37158 886 13 to to IN 37158 886 14 - - HYPH 37158 886 15 morrow morrow NNP 37158 886 16 , , , 37158 886 17 is be VBZ 37158 886 18 the the DT 37158 886 19 struggle struggle NN 37158 886 20 of of IN 37158 886 21 man man NN 37158 886 22 against against IN 37158 886 23 matter matter NN 37158 886 24 , , , 37158 886 25 the the DT 37158 886 26 subjection subjection NN 37158 886 27 of of IN 37158 886 28 natural natural JJ 37158 886 29 forces force NNS 37158 886 30 to to IN 37158 886 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 886 32 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 886 33 . . . 37158 887 1 And and CC 37158 887 2 there there EX 37158 887 3 is be VBZ 37158 887 4 no no DT 37158 887 5 other other JJ 37158 887 6 way way NN 37158 887 7 to to TO 37158 887 8 subjugate subjugate VB 37158 887 9 these these DT 37158 887 10 forces force NNS 37158 887 11 than than IN 37158 887 12 by by IN 37158 887 13 learning learn VBG 37158 887 14 to to TO 37158 887 15 know know VB 37158 887 16 them -PRON- PRP 37158 887 17 . . . 37158 888 1 Then then RB 37158 888 2 Science Science NNP 37158 888 3 will will MD 37158 888 4 be be VB 37158 888 5 put put VBN 37158 888 6 in in IN 37158 888 7 the the DT 37158 888 8 foreground foreground NN 37158 888 9 . . . 37158 889 1 And and CC 37158 889 2 without without IN 37158 889 3 making make VBG 37158 889 4 any any DT 37158 889 5 classification classification NN 37158 889 6 which which WDT 37158 889 7 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 37158 889 8 between between IN 37158 889 9 the the DT 37158 889 10 sciences science NNS 37158 889 11 , , , 37158 889 12 which which WDT 37158 889 13 are be VBP 37158 889 14 all all DT 37158 889 15 useful useful JJ 37158 889 16 , , , 37158 889 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 37158 889 18 , , , 37158 889 19 and and CC 37158 889 20 noble noble JJ 37158 889 21 , , , 37158 889 22 for for IN 37158 889 23 all all DT 37158 889 24 contain contain VB 37158 889 25 a a DT 37158 889 26 portion portion NN 37158 889 27 of of IN 37158 889 28 truth truth NN 37158 889 29 , , , 37158 889 30 we -PRON- PRP 37158 889 31 shall shall MD 37158 889 32 be be VB 37158 889 33 permitted permit VBN 37158 889 34 to to TO 37158 889 35 say say VB 37158 889 36 that that IN 37158 889 37 the the DT 37158 889 38 Science Science NNP 37158 889 39 of of IN 37158 889 40 life life NN 37158 889 41 is be VBZ 37158 889 42 one one CD 37158 889 43 of of IN 37158 889 44 the the DT 37158 889 45 most most RBS 37158 889 46 useful useful JJ 37158 889 47 , , , 37158 889 48 the the DT 37158 889 49 most most RBS 37158 889 50 noble noble JJ 37158 889 51 , , , 37158 889 52 and and CC 37158 889 53 the the DT 37158 889 54 most most RBS 37158 889 55 beautiful beautiful JJ 37158 889 56 . . . 37158 890 1 Now now RB 37158 890 2 , , , 37158 890 3 the the DT 37158 890 4 Science Science NNP 37158 890 5 of of IN 37158 890 6 life life NN 37158 890 7 is be VBZ 37158 890 8 Physiology physiology NN 37158 890 9 , , , 37158 890 10 taking take VBG 37158 890 11 physiology physiology NN 37158 890 12 in in IN 37158 890 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 890 14 widest wide JJS 37158 890 15 sense sense NN 37158 890 16 , , , 37158 890 17 that that DT 37158 890 18 is be VBZ 37158 890 19 to to TO 37158 890 20 say say VB 37158 890 21 , , , 37158 890 22 the the DT 37158 890 23 study study NN 37158 890 24 of of IN 37158 890 25 normal normal JJ 37158 890 26 beings being NNS 37158 890 27 and and CC 37158 890 28 of of IN 37158 890 29 diseased diseased JJ 37158 890 30 beings being NNS 37158 890 31 . . . 37158 891 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 891 2 is be VBZ 37158 891 3 proved prove VBN 37158 891 4 by by IN 37158 891 5 innumerable innumerable JJ 37158 891 6 facts fact NNS 37158 891 7 , , , 37158 891 8 facts fact NNS 37158 891 9 which which WDT 37158 891 10 only only RB 37158 891 11 bad bad JJ 37158 891 12 faith faith NN 37158 891 13 and and CC 37158 891 14 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 891 15 can can MD 37158 891 16 call call VB 37158 891 17 into into IN 37158 891 18 question question NN 37158 891 19 , , , 37158 891 20 that that IN 37158 891 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 891 22 physiological physiological JJ 37158 891 23 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 891 24 is be VBZ 37158 891 25 due due JJ 37158 891 26 , , , 37158 891 27 in in IN 37158 891 28 a a DT 37158 891 29 very very RB 37158 891 30 large large JJ 37158 891 31 measure measure NN 37158 891 32 , , , 37158 891 33 to to IN 37158 891 34 experimentation experimentation VB 37158 891 35 . . . 37158 892 1 If if IN 37158 892 2 in in IN 37158 892 3 thought thought NN 37158 892 4 we -PRON- PRP 37158 892 5 suppressed suppress VBD 37158 892 6 the the DT 37158 892 7 scientific scientific JJ 37158 892 8 results result NNS 37158 892 9 which which WDT 37158 892 10 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 892 11 has have VBZ 37158 892 12 conquered conquer VBN 37158 892 13 , , , 37158 892 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 892 15 should should MD 37158 892 16 have have VB 37158 892 17 but but CC 37158 892 18 an an DT 37158 892 19 inferior inferior JJ 37158 892 20 science science NN 37158 892 21 , , , 37158 892 22 within within IN 37158 892 23 the the DT 37158 892 24 reach reach NN 37158 892 25 of of IN 37158 892 26 the the DT 37158 892 27 Brahmans Brahmans NNPS 37158 892 28 may may MD 37158 892 29 be be VB 37158 892 30 , , , 37158 892 31 but but CC 37158 892 32 unworthy unworthy JJ 37158 892 33 of of IN 37158 892 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 892 35 present present JJ 37158 892 36 scientific scientific JJ 37158 892 37 standing standing NN 37158 892 38 . . . 37158 893 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 893 2 should should MD 37158 893 3 know know VB 37158 893 4 nothing nothing NN 37158 893 5 of of IN 37158 893 6 the the DT 37158 893 7 circulation circulation NN 37158 893 8 of of IN 37158 893 9 the the DT 37158 893 10 blood blood NN 37158 893 11 , , , 37158 893 12 nor nor CC 37158 893 13 the the DT 37158 893 14 function function NN 37158 893 15 of of IN 37158 893 16 the the DT 37158 893 17 blood blood NN 37158 893 18 corpuscles corpuscle NNS 37158 893 19 , , , 37158 893 20 nor nor CC 37158 893 21 the the DT 37158 893 22 formation formation NN 37158 893 23 of of IN 37158 893 24 sugar sugar NN 37158 893 25 , , , 37158 893 26 nor nor CC 37158 893 27 the the DT 37158 893 28 innervation innervation NN 37158 893 29 of of IN 37158 893 30 the the DT 37158 893 31 glands gland NNS 37158 893 32 , , , 37158 893 33 nor nor CC 37158 893 34 the the DT 37158 893 35 contagiousness contagiousness NN 37158 893 36 of of IN 37158 893 37 disease disease NN 37158 893 38 , , , 37158 893 39 nor nor CC 37158 893 40 the the DT 37158 893 41 power power NN 37158 893 42 of of IN 37158 893 43 poisons poison NNS 37158 893 44 ; ; : 37158 893 45 we -PRON- PRP 37158 893 46 should should MD 37158 893 47 be be VB 37158 893 48 reduced reduce VBN 37158 893 49 to to IN 37158 893 50 the the DT 37158 893 51 notions notion NNS 37158 893 52 of of IN 37158 893 53 Hippocrates Hippocrates NNPS 37158 893 54 , , , 37158 893 55 we -PRON- PRP 37158 893 56 should should MD 37158 893 57 be be VB 37158 893 58 less less RBR 37158 893 59 advanced advanced JJ 37158 893 60 than than IN 37158 893 61 Galileo Galileo NNP 37158 893 62 , , , 37158 893 63 the the DT 37158 893 64 first first JJ 37158 893 65 ingenious ingenious JJ 37158 893 66 experimenter experimenter NN 37158 893 67 who who WP 37158 893 68 indicated indicate VBD 37158 893 69 , , , 37158 893 70 less less JJR 37158 893 71 by by IN 37158 893 72 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 893 73 writings writing NNS 37158 893 74 than than IN 37158 893 75 by by IN 37158 893 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 893 77 experiments experiment NNS 37158 893 78 , , , 37158 893 79 that that IN 37158 893 80 the the DT 37158 893 81 basis basis NN 37158 893 82 of of IN 37158 893 83 physiology physiology NN 37158 893 84 , , , 37158 893 85 and and CC 37158 893 86 consequently consequently RB 37158 893 87 of of IN 37158 893 88 the the DT 37158 893 89 whole whole NN 37158 893 90 of of IN 37158 893 91 pathology pathology NN 37158 893 92 , , , 37158 893 93 is be VBZ 37158 893 94 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 893 95 on on IN 37158 893 96 animals animal NNS 37158 893 97 . . . 37158 894 1 Those those DT 37158 894 2 most most RBS 37158 894 3 sincere sincere JJ 37158 894 4 persons person NNS 37158 894 5 who who WP 37158 894 6 wish wish VBP 37158 894 7 to to TO 37158 894 8 banish banish VB 37158 894 9 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 894 10 from from IN 37158 894 11 Science Science NNP 37158 894 12 are be VBP 37158 894 13 consequently consequently RB 37158 894 14 , , , 37158 894 15 I -PRON- PRP 37158 894 16 do do VBP 37158 894 17 not not RB 37158 894 18 fear fear VB 37158 894 19 to to TO 37158 894 20 say say VB 37158 894 21 it -PRON- PRP 37158 894 22 , , , 37158 894 23 standing stand VBG 37158 894 24 in in IN 37158 894 25 the the DT 37158 894 26 position position NN 37158 894 27 of of IN 37158 894 28 direct direct JJ 37158 894 29 contradiction contradiction NN 37158 894 30 to to IN 37158 894 31 true true JJ 37158 894 32 morality morality NN 37158 894 33 . . . 37158 895 1 To to TO 37158 895 2 refuse refuse VB 37158 895 3 man man NN 37158 895 4 the the DT 37158 895 5 right right NN 37158 895 6 to to TO 37158 895 7 study study VB 37158 895 8 living live VBG 37158 895 9 nature nature NN 37158 895 10 , , , 37158 895 11 is be VBZ 37158 895 12 as as IN 37158 895 13 though though IN 37158 895 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 895 15 declared declare VBD 37158 895 16 that that IN 37158 895 17 living live VBG 37158 895 18 nature nature NN 37158 895 19 ought ought MD 37158 895 20 not not RB 37158 895 21 to to TO 37158 895 22 be be VB 37158 895 23 known know VBN 37158 895 24 . . . 37158 896 1 Alas alas UH 37158 896 2 ! ! . 37158 897 1 anti anti NNS 37158 897 2 - - NNS 37158 897 3 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 897 4 will will MD 37158 897 5 not not RB 37158 897 6 listen listen VB 37158 897 7 . . . 37158 898 1 In in IN 37158 898 2 vain vain JJ 37158 898 3 do do VBP 37158 898 4 we -PRON- PRP 37158 898 5 tell tell VB 37158 898 6 them -PRON- PRP 37158 898 7 that that IN 37158 898 8 we -PRON- PRP 37158 898 9 , , , 37158 898 10 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 898 11 , , , 37158 898 12 preserve preserve VB 37158 898 13 man man NN 37158 898 14 from from IN 37158 898 15 disease disease NNP 37158 898 16 ; ; : 37158 898 17 that that IN 37158 898 18 we -PRON- PRP 37158 898 19 have have VBP 37158 898 20 alleviated alleviate VBN 37158 898 21 the the DT 37158 898 22 ills ill NNS 37158 898 23 of of IN 37158 898 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 898 25 human human JJ 37158 898 26 brothers brother NNS 37158 898 27 . . . 37158 899 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 899 2 stop stop VBP 37158 899 3 up up RP 37158 899 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 899 5 ears ear NNS 37158 899 6 ; ; : 37158 899 7 they -PRON- PRP 37158 899 8 shut shut VBD 37158 899 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 899 10 eyes eye NNS 37158 899 11 ; ; : 37158 899 12 they -PRON- PRP 37158 899 13 have have VBP 37158 899 14 no no DT 37158 899 15 pity pity NN 37158 899 16 for for IN 37158 899 17 the the DT 37158 899 18 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 899 19 of of IN 37158 899 20 human human JJ 37158 899 21 beings being NNS 37158 899 22 . . . 37158 900 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 900 2 seems seem VBZ 37158 900 3 as as IN 37158 900 4 though though IN 37158 900 5 the the DT 37158 900 6 tears tear NNS 37158 900 7 of of IN 37158 900 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 900 9 brethren brother NNS 37158 900 10 were be VBD 37158 900 11 profoundly profoundly RB 37158 900 12 indifferent indifferent JJ 37158 900 13 to to IN 37158 900 14 them -PRON- PRP 37158 900 15 . . . 37158 901 1 Is be VBZ 37158 901 2 this this DT 37158 901 3 a a DT 37158 901 4 high high JJ 37158 901 5 morality morality NN 37158 901 6 ? ? . 37158 902 1 Is be VBZ 37158 902 2 this this DT 37158 902 3 a a DT 37158 902 4 realisation realisation NN 37158 902 5 of of IN 37158 902 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 902 7 duty duty NN 37158 902 8 as as IN 37158 902 9 men man NNS 37158 902 10 ? ? . 37158 903 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 903 2 cover cover VBP 37158 903 3 with with IN 37158 903 4 opprobrium opprobrium NN 37158 903 5 the the DT 37158 903 6 names name NNS 37158 903 7 of of IN 37158 903 8 Harvey Harvey NNP 37158 903 9 and and CC 37158 903 10 Jenner Jenner NNP 37158 903 11 , , , 37158 903 12 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 903 13 and and CC 37158 903 14 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 903 15 , , , 37158 903 16 Spallanzani Spallanzani NNP 37158 903 17 and and CC 37158 903 18 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 37158 903 19 . . . 37158 904 1 What what WDT 37158 904 2 base base NN 37158 904 3 ingratitude ingratitude NN 37158 904 4 ! ! . 37158 905 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 905 2 is be VBZ 37158 905 3 these these DT 37158 905 4 great great JJ 37158 905 5 men man NNS 37158 905 6 who who WP 37158 905 7 have have VBP 37158 905 8 turned turn VBN 37158 905 9 aside aside RB 37158 905 10 many many JJ 37158 905 11 excruciating excruciating JJ 37158 905 12 sufferings suffering NNS 37158 905 13 from from IN 37158 905 14 humanity humanity NN 37158 905 15 ; ; : 37158 905 16 it -PRON- PRP 37158 905 17 is be VBZ 37158 905 18 these these DT 37158 905 19 grand grand JJ 37158 905 20 men man NNS 37158 905 21 who who WP 37158 905 22 have have VBP 37158 905 23 bestowed bestow VBN 37158 905 24 a a DT 37158 905 25 better well JJR 37158 905 26 lot lot NN 37158 905 27 on on IN 37158 905 28 so so RB 37158 905 29 many many JJ 37158 905 30 human human JJ 37158 905 31 beings being NNS 37158 905 32 . . . 37158 906 1 When when WRB 37158 906 2 , , , 37158 906 3 therefore therefore RB 37158 906 4 , , , 37158 906 5 they -PRON- PRP 37158 906 6 dare dare VBP 37158 906 7 to to TO 37158 906 8 calumniate calumniate VB 37158 906 9 the the DT 37158 906 10 masters master NNS 37158 906 11 who who WP 37158 906 12 have have VBP 37158 906 13 scattered scatter VBN 37158 906 14 over over IN 37158 906 15 us -PRON- PRP 37158 906 16 so so RB 37158 906 17 much much JJ 37158 906 18 beneficence beneficence NN 37158 906 19 , , , 37158 906 20 anti anti JJ 37158 906 21 - - NNS 37158 906 22 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 906 23 seem seem VBP 37158 906 24 to to IN 37158 906 25 me -PRON- PRP 37158 906 26 to to TO 37158 906 27 be be VB 37158 906 28 not not RB 37158 906 29 only only RB 37158 906 30 the the DT 37158 906 31 most most RBS 37158 906 32 ungrateful ungrateful JJ 37158 906 33 but but CC 37158 906 34 even even RB 37158 906 35 the the DT 37158 906 36 cruellest cruell JJS 37158 906 37 of of IN 37158 906 38 men man NNS 37158 906 39 . . . 37158 907 1 Fortunately fortunately RB 37158 907 2 the the DT 37158 907 3 conquering conquer VBG 37158 907 4 march march NN 37158 907 5 of of IN 37158 907 6 Science Science NNP 37158 907 7 will will MD 37158 907 8 not not RB 37158 907 9 be be VB 37158 907 10 hindered hinder VBN 37158 907 11 . . . 37158 908 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 908 2 shall shall MD 37158 908 3 never never RB 37158 908 4 return return VB 37158 908 5 to to IN 37158 908 6 those those DT 37158 908 7 sinister sinister JJ 37158 908 8 times time NNS 37158 908 9 when when WRB 37158 908 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 908 11 great great JJ 37158 908 12 Vesalius Vesalius NNP 37158 908 13 had have VBD 37158 908 14 to to TO 37158 908 15 forfeit forfeit VB 37158 908 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 908 17 life life NN 37158 908 18 for for IN 37158 908 19 having have VBG 37158 908 20 dared dare VBN 37158 908 21 to to TO 37158 908 22 dissect dissect VB 37158 908 23 a a DT 37158 908 24 human human JJ 37158 908 25 corpse corpse NN 37158 908 26 . . . 37158 909 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 909 2 shall shall MD 37158 909 3 continue continue VB 37158 909 4 to to TO 37158 909 5 make make VB 37158 909 6 Science Science NNP 37158 909 7 advance advance NN 37158 909 8 towards towards IN 37158 909 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 909 10 great great JJ 37158 909 11 aim aim NN 37158 909 12 , , , 37158 909 13 the the DT 37158 909 14 good good NN 37158 909 15 of of IN 37158 909 16 man man NN 37158 909 17 . . . 37158 910 1 And and CC 37158 910 2 this this DT 37158 910 3 is be VBZ 37158 910 4 the the DT 37158 910 5 moment moment NN 37158 910 6 which which WDT 37158 910 7 has have VBZ 37158 910 8 been be VBN 37158 910 9 chosen choose VBN 37158 910 10 for for IN 37158 910 11 striving strive VBG 37158 910 12 to to TO 37158 910 13 arrest arrest VB 37158 910 14 the the DT 37158 910 15 march march NN 37158 910 16 of of IN 37158 910 17 Science Science NNP 37158 910 18 : : : 37158 910 19 when when WRB 37158 910 20 epidemic epidemic NN 37158 910 21 disease disease NN 37158 910 22 , , , 37158 910 23 such such JJ 37158 910 24 as as IN 37158 910 25 the the DT 37158 910 26 plague plague NN 37158 910 27 and and CC 37158 910 28 cholera cholera NNP 37158 910 29 , , , 37158 910 30 is be VBZ 37158 910 31 checked check VBN 37158 910 32 ; ; : 37158 910 33 tuberculosis tuberculosis NNP 37158 910 34 half half RB 37158 910 35 - - HYPH 37158 910 36 conquered conquered JJ 37158 910 37 ; ; : 37158 910 38 diptheria diptheria NNP 37158 910 39 rendered render VBD 37158 910 40 inoffensive inoffensive JJ 37158 910 41 ; ; : 37158 910 42 operations operation NNS 37158 910 43 become become VBP 37158 910 44 almost almost RB 37158 910 45 harmless harmless JJ 37158 910 46 ; ; : 37158 910 47 cancer cancer NN 37158 910 48 on on IN 37158 910 49 the the DT 37158 910 50 eve eve NN 37158 910 51 of of IN 37158 910 52 being be VBG 37158 910 53 understood understand VBN 37158 910 54 and and CC 37158 910 55 subjugated subjugate VBD 37158 910 56 ! ! . 37158 911 1 And and CC 37158 911 2 are be VBP 37158 911 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 911 4 to to TO 37158 911 5 stop stop VB 37158 911 6 there there RB 37158 911 7 ? ? . 37158 912 1 Are be VBP 37158 912 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 912 3 not not RB 37158 912 4 to to TO 37158 912 5 seek seek VB 37158 912 6 to to TO 37158 912 7 fathom fathom VB 37158 912 8 the the DT 37158 912 9 many many JJ 37158 912 10 problems problem NNS 37158 912 11 still still RB 37158 912 12 waiting wait VBG 37158 912 13 to to TO 37158 912 14 be be VB 37158 912 15 solved solve VBN 37158 912 16 , , , 37158 912 17 and and CC 37158 912 18 on on IN 37158 912 19 which which WDT 37158 912 20 depend depend VBP 37158 912 21 the the DT 37158 912 22 lives life NNS 37158 912 23 of of IN 37158 912 24 so so RB 37158 912 25 many many JJ 37158 912 26 human human JJ 37158 912 27 beings being NNS 37158 912 28 , , , 37158 912 29 and and CC 37158 912 30 so so RB 37158 912 31 much much JJ 37158 912 32 human human JJ 37158 912 33 happiness happiness NN 37158 912 34 ? ? . 37158 913 1 Do do VBP 37158 913 2 you -PRON- PRP 37158 913 3 believe believe VB 37158 913 4 that that IN 37158 913 5 Science Science NNP 37158 913 6 has have VBZ 37158 913 7 come come VBN 37158 913 8 to to IN 37158 913 9 an an DT 37158 913 10 end end NN 37158 913 11 ? ? . 37158 914 1 Certainly certainly RB 37158 914 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 914 3 already already RB 37158 914 4 know know VBP 37158 914 5 a a DT 37158 914 6 great great JJ 37158 914 7 deal deal NN 37158 914 8 ; ; : 37158 914 9 but but CC 37158 914 10 what what WP 37158 914 11 we -PRON- PRP 37158 914 12 know know VBP 37158 914 13 is be VBZ 37158 914 14 as as IN 37158 914 15 nothing nothing NN 37158 914 16 compared compare VBN 37158 914 17 to to IN 37158 914 18 what what WP 37158 914 19 we -PRON- PRP 37158 914 20 do do VBP 37158 914 21 not not RB 37158 914 22 know know VB 37158 914 23 . . . 37158 915 1 An an DT 37158 915 2 immense immense JJ 37158 915 3 domain domain NN 37158 915 4 of of IN 37158 915 5 unknown unknown JJ 37158 915 6 truths truth NNS 37158 915 7 lies lie VBZ 37158 915 8 open open JJ 37158 915 9 to to IN 37158 915 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 915 11 activity activity NN 37158 915 12 . . . 37158 916 1 And and CC 37158 916 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 916 3 are be VBP 37158 916 4 able able JJ 37158 916 5 to to TO 37158 916 6 forsee forsee VB 37158 916 7 what what WP 37158 916 8 inexpressible inexpressible JJ 37158 916 9 benefits benefit NNS 37158 916 10 these these DT 37158 916 11 new new JJ 37158 916 12 truths truth NNS 37158 916 13 will will MD 37158 916 14 scatter scatter VB 37158 916 15 over over IN 37158 916 16 suffering suffer VBG 37158 916 17 humanity humanity NN 37158 916 18 . . . 37158 917 1 Consequently consequently RB 37158 917 2 , , , 37158 917 3 everyone everyone NN 37158 917 4 , , , 37158 917 5 every every DT 37158 917 6 man man NN 37158 917 7 enamoured enamour VBD 37158 917 8 of of IN 37158 917 9 goodness goodness NN 37158 917 10 and and CC 37158 917 11 justice justice NN 37158 917 12 , , , 37158 917 13 should should MD 37158 917 14 be be VB 37158 917 15 filled fill VBN 37158 917 16 with with IN 37158 917 17 respect respect NN 37158 917 18 for for IN 37158 917 19 Science Science NNP 37158 917 20 , , , 37158 917 21 and and CC 37158 917 22 set set VBD 37158 917 23 all all PDT 37158 917 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 917 25 hopes hope NNS 37158 917 26 on on IN 37158 917 27 her -PRON- PRP 37158 917 28 . . . 37158 918 1 At at IN 37158 918 2 the the DT 37158 918 3 same same JJ 37158 918 4 time time NN 37158 918 5 , , , 37158 918 6 however however WRB 37158 918 7 great great JJ 37158 918 8 may may MD 37158 918 9 be be VB 37158 918 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 918 11 adoration adoration NN 37158 918 12 for for IN 37158 918 13 Science Science NNP 37158 918 14 , , , 37158 918 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 918 16 must must MD 37158 918 17 not not RB 37158 918 18 be be VB 37158 918 19 at at IN 37158 918 20 the the DT 37158 918 21 expense expense NN 37158 918 22 of of IN 37158 918 23 human human JJ 37158 918 24 personalities personality NNS 37158 918 25 , , , 37158 918 26 or or CC 37158 918 27 , , , 37158 918 28 let let VB 37158 918 29 us -PRON- PRP 37158 918 30 say say VB 37158 918 31 it -PRON- PRP 37158 918 32 distinctly distinctly RB 37158 918 33 , , , 37158 918 34 at at IN 37158 918 35 the the DT 37158 918 36 expense expense NN 37158 918 37 of of IN 37158 918 38 animal animal NN 37158 918 39 personalities personality NNS 37158 918 40 , , , 37158 918 41 which which WDT 37158 918 42 although although IN 37158 918 43 uncertain uncertain JJ 37158 918 44 and and CC 37158 918 45 indistinct indistinct JJ 37158 918 46 , , , 37158 918 47 still still RB 37158 918 48 merit merit VB 37158 918 49 a a DT 37158 918 50 share share NN 37158 918 51 , , , 37158 918 52 and and CC 37158 918 53 a a DT 37158 918 54 large large JJ 37158 918 55 share share NN 37158 918 56 , , , 37158 918 57 of of IN 37158 918 58 justice justice NN 37158 918 59 and and CC 37158 918 60 of of IN 37158 918 61 pity pity NN 37158 918 62 . . . 37158 919 1 As as IN 37158 919 2 for for IN 37158 919 3 human human JJ 37158 919 4 personalities personality NNS 37158 919 5 , , , 37158 919 6 without without IN 37158 919 7 the the DT 37158 919 8 slightest slight JJS 37158 919 9 doubt doubt NN 37158 919 10 , , , 37158 919 11 we -PRON- PRP 37158 919 12 have have VBP 37158 919 13 not not RB 37158 919 14 the the DT 37158 919 15 right right NN 37158 919 16 to to TO 37158 919 17 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37158 919 18 an an DT 37158 919 19 innocent innocent JJ 37158 919 20 creature creature NN 37158 919 21 for for IN 37158 919 22 Science Science NNP 37158 919 23 . . . 37158 920 1 Every every DT 37158 920 2 human human NN 37158 920 3 being being NN 37158 920 4 ought ought MD 37158 920 5 to to TO 37158 920 6 be be VB 37158 920 7 treated treat VBN 37158 920 8 with with IN 37158 920 9 respect respect NN 37158 920 10 , , , 37158 920 11 and and CC 37158 920 12 we -PRON- PRP 37158 920 13 have have VBP 37158 920 14 not not RB 37158 920 15 the the DT 37158 920 16 right right NN 37158 920 17 to to TO 37158 920 18 kill kill VB 37158 920 19 and and CC 37158 920 20 martyrise martyrise VB 37158 920 21 a a DT 37158 920 22 human human NN 37158 920 23 being be VBG 37158 920 24 even even RB 37158 920 25 if if IN 37158 920 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 920 27 death death NN 37158 920 28 and and CC 37158 920 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 920 30 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37158 920 31 might may MD 37158 920 32 serve serve VB 37158 920 33 the the DT 37158 920 34 cause cause NN 37158 920 35 of of IN 37158 920 36 Science Science NNP 37158 920 37 . . . 37158 921 1 As as IN 37158 921 2 for for IN 37158 921 3 animal animal NN 37158 921 4 personalities personality NNS 37158 921 5 , , , 37158 921 6 the the DT 37158 921 7 question question NN 37158 921 8 becomes become VBZ 37158 921 9 much much RB 37158 921 10 more more RBR 37158 921 11 doubtful doubtful JJ 37158 921 12 . . . 37158 922 1 For for IN 37158 922 2 inferior inferior JJ 37158 922 3 beings being NNS 37158 922 4 with with IN 37158 922 5 indistinct indistinct JJ 37158 922 6 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 922 7 , , , 37158 922 8 and and CC 37158 922 9 , , , 37158 922 10 without without IN 37158 922 11 a a DT 37158 922 12 doubt doubt NN 37158 922 13 powerless powerless JJ 37158 922 14 to to TO 37158 922 15 perceive perceive VB 37158 922 16 pain pain NN 37158 922 17 , , , 37158 922 18 no no DT 37158 922 19 scruple scruple NN 37158 922 20 should should MD 37158 922 21 hold hold VB 37158 922 22 us -PRON- PRP 37158 922 23 back back RB 37158 922 24 . . . 37158 923 1 But but CC 37158 923 2 if if IN 37158 923 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 923 4 concerns concern VBZ 37158 923 5 beings being NNS 37158 923 6 nearer nearer RB 37158 923 7 to to IN 37158 923 8 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 923 9 , , , 37158 923 10 such such JJ 37158 923 11 as as IN 37158 923 12 monkeys monkey NNS 37158 923 13 , , , 37158 923 14 cats cat NNS 37158 923 15 , , , 37158 923 16 dogs dog NNS 37158 923 17 , , , 37158 923 18 horses horse NNS 37158 923 19 , , , 37158 923 20 all all DT 37158 923 21 certainly certainly RB 37158 923 22 capable capable JJ 37158 923 23 of of IN 37158 923 24 feeling feel VBG 37158 923 25 pain pain NN 37158 923 26 , , , 37158 923 27 we -PRON- PRP 37158 923 28 must must MD 37158 923 29 be be VB 37158 923 30 chary chary JJ 37158 923 31 of of IN 37158 923 32 inflicting inflict VBG 37158 923 33 pain pain NN 37158 923 34 , , , 37158 923 35 and and CC 37158 923 36 experiment experiment NN 37158 923 37 only only RB 37158 923 38 after after IN 37158 923 39 having have VBG 37158 923 40 totally totally RB 37158 923 41 abolished abolish VBN 37158 923 42 in in IN 37158 923 43 them -PRON- PRP 37158 923 44 all all DT 37158 923 45 sensation sensation NN 37158 923 46 of of IN 37158 923 47 pain pain NN 37158 923 48 . . . 37158 924 1 But but CC 37158 924 2 under under IN 37158 924 3 penalty penalty NN 37158 924 4 of of IN 37158 924 5 falling fall VBG 37158 924 6 into into IN 37158 924 7 fetishism fetishism NN 37158 924 8 , , , 37158 924 9 we -PRON- PRP 37158 924 10 must must MD 37158 924 11 not not RB 37158 924 12 fear fear VB 37158 924 13 to to TO 37158 924 14 use use VB 37158 924 15 the the DT 37158 924 16 life life NN 37158 924 17 of of IN 37158 924 18 these these DT 37158 924 19 beings being NNS 37158 924 20 in in IN 37158 924 21 order order NN 37158 924 22 to to TO 37158 924 23 prolong prolong VB 37158 924 24 the the DT 37158 924 25 life life NN 37158 924 26 of of IN 37158 924 27 man man NN 37158 924 28 . . . 37158 925 1 Every every DT 37158 925 2 time time NN 37158 925 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 925 4 propose propose VBP 37158 925 5 to to TO 37158 925 6 make make VB 37158 925 7 an an DT 37158 925 8 experiment experiment NN 37158 925 9 , , , 37158 925 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 925 11 is be VBZ 37158 925 12 as as IN 37158 925 13 though though IN 37158 925 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 925 15 put put VBP 37158 925 16 this this DT 37158 925 17 question question NN 37158 925 18 to to IN 37158 925 19 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 925 20 : : : 37158 925 21 is be VBZ 37158 925 22 this this DT 37158 925 23 dog dog NN 37158 925 24 worth worth NN 37158 925 25 more more JJR 37158 925 26 than than IN 37158 925 27 a a DT 37158 925 28 man man NN 37158 925 29 ? ? . 37158 926 1 or or CC 37158 926 2 than than IN 37158 926 3 a a DT 37158 926 4 hundred hundred CD 37158 926 5 men man NNS 37158 926 6 ? ? . 37158 927 1 or or CC 37158 927 2 than than IN 37158 927 3 the the DT 37158 927 4 whole whole NN 37158 927 5 of of IN 37158 927 6 humanity humanity NN 37158 927 7 to to TO 37158 927 8 come come VB 37158 927 9 ? ? . 37158 928 1 Thus thus RB 37158 928 2 put put VBN 37158 928 3 , , , 37158 928 4 the the DT 37158 928 5 problem problem NN 37158 928 6 bears bear VBZ 37158 928 7 only only RB 37158 928 8 one one CD 37158 928 9 solution solution NN 37158 928 10 : : : 37158 928 11 Avoid avoid VB 37158 928 12 giving give VBG 37158 928 13 pain pain NN 37158 928 14 to to IN 37158 928 15 the the DT 37158 928 16 animal animal NN 37158 928 17 on on IN 37158 928 18 condition condition NN 37158 928 19 that that IN 37158 928 20 it -PRON- PRP 37158 928 21 is be VBZ 37158 928 22 not not RB 37158 928 23 at at IN 37158 928 24 the the DT 37158 928 25 cost cost NN 37158 928 26 of of IN 37158 928 27 innumerable innumerable JJ 37158 928 28 human human JJ 37158 928 29 pains pain NNS 37158 928 30 . . . 37158 929 1 Moreover moreover RB 37158 929 2 , , , 37158 929 3 it -PRON- PRP 37158 929 4 is be VBZ 37158 929 5 the the DT 37158 929 6 same same JJ 37158 929 7 here here RB 37158 929 8 as as IN 37158 929 9 in in IN 37158 929 10 every every DT 37158 929 11 question question NN 37158 929 12 we -PRON- PRP 37158 929 13 may may MD 37158 929 14 wish wish VB 37158 929 15 to to TO 37158 929 16 investigate investigate VB 37158 929 17 : : : 37158 929 18 Each each DT 37158 929 19 of of IN 37158 929 20 the the DT 37158 929 21 two two CD 37158 929 22 adversaries adversary NNS 37158 929 23 set set VBD 37158 929 24 out out RP 37158 929 25 from from IN 37158 929 26 a a DT 37158 929 27 just just RB 37158 929 28 principle principle NN 37158 929 29 , , , 37158 929 30 incontestably incontestably RB 37158 929 31 just just RB 37158 929 32 . . . 37158 930 1 But but CC 37158 930 2 each each DT 37158 930 3 one one NN 37158 930 4 pushes push VBZ 37158 930 5 the the DT 37158 930 6 just just RB 37158 930 7 principle principle NN 37158 930 8 so so RB 37158 930 9 far far RB 37158 930 10 that that IN 37158 930 11 he -PRON- PRP 37158 930 12 ends end VBZ 37158 930 13 by by IN 37158 930 14 transforming transform VBG 37158 930 15 it -PRON- PRP 37158 930 16 into into IN 37158 930 17 a a DT 37158 930 18 colossal colossal JJ 37158 930 19 absurdity absurdity NN 37158 930 20 . . . 37158 931 1 In in IN 37158 931 2 the the DT 37158 931 3 present present JJ 37158 931 4 case case NN 37158 931 5 , , , 37158 931 6 the the DT 37158 931 7 anti anti NNS 37158 931 8 - - NNS 37158 931 9 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 931 10 say say VBP 37158 931 11 : : : 37158 931 12 pain pain NN 37158 931 13 is be VBZ 37158 931 14 an an DT 37158 931 15 evil evil NN 37158 931 16 , , , 37158 931 17 even even RB 37158 931 18 the the DT 37158 931 19 obscure obscure JJ 37158 931 20 pain pain NN 37158 931 21 of of IN 37158 931 22 the the DT 37158 931 23 lowest low JJS 37158 931 24 animal animal NN 37158 931 25 is be VBZ 37158 931 26 an an DT 37158 931 27 evil evil NN 37158 931 28 . . . 37158 932 1 Now now RB 37158 932 2 , , , 37158 932 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 932 4 should should MD 37158 932 5 do do VB 37158 932 6 no no DT 37158 932 7 evil evil NN 37158 932 8 ; ; : 37158 932 9 therefore therefore RB 37158 932 10 we -PRON- PRP 37158 932 11 should should MD 37158 932 12 not not RB 37158 932 13 at at IN 37158 932 14 any any DT 37158 932 15 price price NN 37158 932 16 inflict inflict NN 37158 932 17 any any DT 37158 932 18 pain pain NN 37158 932 19 whatsoever whatsoever RB 37158 932 20 , , , 37158 932 21 however however RB 37158 932 22 light light JJ 37158 932 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 932 24 may may MD 37158 932 25 be be VB 37158 932 26 , , , 37158 932 27 on on IN 37158 932 28 even even RB 37158 932 29 the the DT 37158 932 30 lowest low JJS 37158 932 31 animal animal NN 37158 932 32 . . . 37158 933 1 That that DT 37158 933 2 is be VBZ 37158 933 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 933 4 syllogism syllogism NN 37158 933 5 . . . 37158 934 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 934 2 can can MD 37158 934 3 not not RB 37158 934 4 be be VB 37158 934 5 replied reply VBN 37158 934 6 to to IN 37158 934 7 , , , 37158 934 8 for for IN 37158 934 9 it -PRON- PRP 37158 934 10 is be VBZ 37158 934 11 perfectly perfectly RB 37158 934 12 correct correct JJ 37158 934 13 . . . 37158 935 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 935 2 on on IN 37158 935 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 935 4 side side NN 37158 935 5 say say VBP 37158 935 6 : : : 37158 935 7 The the DT 37158 935 8 suffering suffering NN 37158 935 9 of of IN 37158 935 10 man man NN 37158 935 11 is be VBZ 37158 935 12 a a DT 37158 935 13 sacred sacred JJ 37158 935 14 thing thing NN 37158 935 15 . . . 37158 936 1 Science science NN 37158 936 2 casts cast VBZ 37158 936 3 aside aside RB 37158 936 4 suffering suffer VBG 37158 936 5 from from IN 37158 936 6 man man NN 37158 936 7 . . . 37158 937 1 Therefore therefore RB 37158 937 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 937 3 ought ought MD 37158 937 4 to to TO 37158 937 5 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37158 937 6 inferior inferior JJ 37158 937 7 beings being NNS 37158 937 8 to to IN 37158 937 9 the the DT 37158 937 10 cause cause NN 37158 937 11 of of IN 37158 937 12 Science Science NNP 37158 937 13 , , , 37158 937 14 that that DT 37158 937 15 is be VBZ 37158 937 16 to to TO 37158 937 17 say say VB 37158 937 18 to to IN 37158 937 19 the the DT 37158 937 20 happiness happiness NN 37158 937 21 of of IN 37158 937 22 man man NN 37158 937 23 . . . 37158 938 1 There there EX 37158 938 2 again again RB 37158 938 3 lies lie VBZ 37158 938 4 an an DT 37158 938 5 irreproachable irreproachable JJ 37158 938 6 syllogism syllogism NN 37158 938 7 . . . 37158 939 1 But but CC 37158 939 2 these these DT 37158 939 3 two two CD 37158 939 4 syllogisms syllogism NNS 37158 939 5 , , , 37158 939 6 if if IN 37158 939 7 driven drive VBN 37158 939 8 up up RP 37158 939 9 to to IN 37158 939 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 939 11 ultimate ultimate JJ 37158 939 12 conclusions conclusion NNS 37158 939 13 , , , 37158 939 14 would would MD 37158 939 15 lead lead VB 37158 939 16 to to IN 37158 939 17 nonsense nonsense NN 37158 939 18 on on IN 37158 939 19 the the DT 37158 939 20 one one CD 37158 939 21 hand hand NN 37158 939 22 and and CC 37158 939 23 cruelty cruelty VB 37158 939 24 on on IN 37158 939 25 the the DT 37158 939 26 other other JJ 37158 939 27 . . . 37158 940 1 If if IN 37158 940 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 940 3 were be VBD 37158 940 4 to to TO 37158 940 5 listen listen VB 37158 940 6 only only RB 37158 940 7 to to IN 37158 940 8 the the DT 37158 940 9 friends friend NNS 37158 940 10 of of IN 37158 940 11 animals animal NNS 37158 940 12 , , , 37158 940 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 940 14 should should MD 37158 940 15 not not RB 37158 940 16 have have VB 37158 940 17 the the DT 37158 940 18 right right NN 37158 940 19 to to TO 37158 940 20 bleed bleed VB 37158 940 21 a a DT 37158 940 22 horse horse NN 37158 940 23 in in IN 37158 940 24 order order NN 37158 940 25 to to TO 37158 940 26 save save VB 37158 940 27 the the DT 37158 940 28 lives life NNS 37158 940 29 of of IN 37158 940 30 400 400 CD 37158 940 31 children child NNS 37158 940 32 ; ; : 37158 940 33 and and CC 37158 940 34 this this DT 37158 940 35 contention contention NN 37158 940 36 would would MD 37158 940 37 be be VB 37158 940 38 both both CC 37158 940 39 foolish foolish JJ 37158 940 40 and and CC 37158 940 41 cruel cruel JJ 37158 940 42 . . . 37158 941 1 If if IN 37158 941 2 we -PRON- PRP 37158 941 3 were be VBD 37158 941 4 to to TO 37158 941 5 listen listen VB 37158 941 6 only only RB 37158 941 7 to to IN 37158 941 8 the the DT 37158 941 9 friends friend NNS 37158 941 10 of of IN 37158 941 11 man man NN 37158 941 12 , , , 37158 941 13 we -PRON- PRP 37158 941 14 should should MD 37158 941 15 have have VB 37158 941 16 the the DT 37158 941 17 right right NN 37158 941 18 , , , 37158 941 19 simply simply RB 37158 941 20 as as IN 37158 941 21 dictated dictate VBN 37158 941 22 by by IN 37158 941 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 941 24 might might NN 37158 941 25 and and CC 37158 941 26 fancy fancy JJ 37158 941 27 , , , 37158 941 28 to to TO 37158 941 29 cause cause VB 37158 941 30 suffering suffer VBG 37158 941 31 to to IN 37158 941 32 dogs dog NNS 37158 941 33 , , , 37158 941 34 cats cat NNS 37158 941 35 , , , 37158 941 36 monkeys monkey NNS 37158 941 37 , , , 37158 941 38 all all DT 37158 941 39 innocent innocent JJ 37158 941 40 and and CC 37158 941 41 sensitive sensitive JJ 37158 941 42 animals animal NNS 37158 941 43 , , , 37158 941 44 under under IN 37158 941 45 pretext pretext NN 37158 941 46 that that IN 37158 941 47 these these DT 37158 941 48 tortures torture NNS 37158 941 49 are be VBP 37158 941 50 capable capable JJ 37158 941 51 of of IN 37158 941 52 alleviating alleviate VBG 37158 941 53 human human JJ 37158 941 54 pain pain NN 37158 941 55 . . . 37158 942 1 That that DT 37158 942 2 also also RB 37158 942 3 would would MD 37158 942 4 be be VB 37158 942 5 folly folly JJ 37158 942 6 and and CC 37158 942 7 cruelty cruelty VB 37158 942 8 . . . 37158 943 1 Fortunately fortunately RB 37158 943 2 , , , 37158 943 3 wisdom wisdom NN 37158 943 4 avoids avoid VBZ 37158 943 5 both both CC 37158 943 6 extremes extreme NNS 37158 943 7 ; ; : 37158 943 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 943 9 fears fear VBZ 37158 943 10 the the DT 37158 943 11 brutality brutality NN 37158 943 12 of of IN 37158 943 13 hard hard JJ 37158 943 14 and and CC 37158 943 15 fast fast JJ 37158 943 16 syllogisms syllogism NNS 37158 943 17 , , , 37158 943 18 which which WDT 37158 943 19 are be VBP 37158 943 20 absurd absurd JJ 37158 943 21 even even RB 37158 943 22 by by IN 37158 943 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 943 24 very very JJ 37158 943 25 severity severity NN 37158 943 26 . . . 37158 944 1 Yes yes UH 37158 944 2 , , , 37158 944 3 there there EX 37158 944 4 are be VBP 37158 944 5 the the DT 37158 944 6 rights right NNS 37158 944 7 of of IN 37158 944 8 man man NN 37158 944 9 ; ; : 37158 944 10 yes yes UH 37158 944 11 , , , 37158 944 12 there there EX 37158 944 13 are be VBP 37158 944 14 the the DT 37158 944 15 rights right NNS 37158 944 16 of of IN 37158 944 17 animals animal NNS 37158 944 18 ; ; : 37158 944 19 and and CC 37158 944 20 all all PDT 37158 944 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 944 22 efforts effort NNS 37158 944 23 should should MD 37158 944 24 consist consist VB 37158 944 25 in in IN 37158 944 26 holding hold VBG 37158 944 27 an an DT 37158 944 28 even even JJ 37158 944 29 balance balance NN 37158 944 30 between between IN 37158 944 31 these these DT 37158 944 32 two two CD 37158 944 33 sometimes sometimes RB 37158 944 34 antagonistic antagonistic JJ 37158 944 35 rights right NNS 37158 944 36 . . . 37158 945 1 Do do VB 37158 945 2 not not RB 37158 945 3 let let VB 37158 945 4 us -PRON- PRP 37158 945 5 push push VB 37158 945 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 945 7 reasonings reasoning NNS 37158 945 8 to to IN 37158 945 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 945 10 logical logical JJ 37158 945 11 but but CC 37158 945 12 absurd absurd JJ 37158 945 13 extremes extreme NNS 37158 945 14 . . . 37158 946 1 Pre pre JJ 37158 946 2 - - NN 37158 946 3 occupation occupation NN 37158 946 4 for for IN 37158 946 5 the the DT 37158 946 6 welfare welfare NN 37158 946 7 of of IN 37158 946 8 future future JJ 37158 946 9 humanity humanity NN 37158 946 10 and and CC 37158 946 11 of of IN 37158 946 12 Science Science NNP 37158 946 13 does do VBZ 37158 946 14 not not RB 37158 946 15 authorise authorise VB 37158 946 16 us -PRON- PRP 37158 946 17 to to TO 37158 946 18 be be VB 37158 946 19 wicked wicked JJ 37158 946 20 and and CC 37158 946 21 unjust unjust JJ 37158 946 22 towards towards IN 37158 946 23 the the DT 37158 946 24 men man NNS 37158 946 25 of of IN 37158 946 26 to to IN 37158 946 27 - - HYPH 37158 946 28 day day NN 37158 946 29 , , , 37158 946 30 even even RB 37158 946 31 towards towards IN 37158 946 32 one one CD 37158 946 33 single single JJ 37158 946 34 man man NN 37158 946 35 . . . 37158 947 1 So so RB 37158 947 2 that that IN 37158 947 3 , , , 37158 947 4 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 37158 947 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 947 6 worship worship NN 37158 947 7 of of IN 37158 947 8 Science Science NNP 37158 947 9 , , , 37158 947 10 I -PRON- PRP 37158 947 11 would would MD 37158 947 12 not not RB 37158 947 13 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37158 947 14 human human JJ 37158 947 15 lives life NNS 37158 947 16 to to IN 37158 947 17 her -PRON- PRP 37158 947 18 . . . 37158 948 1 And and CC 37158 948 2 , , , 37158 948 3 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 37158 948 4 all all DT 37158 948 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 948 6 respect respect NN 37158 948 7 for for IN 37158 948 8 animal animal NN 37158 948 9 pain pain NN 37158 948 10 , , , 37158 948 11 I -PRON- PRP 37158 948 12 would would MD 37158 948 13 look look VB 37158 948 14 upon upon IN 37158 948 15 the the DT 37158 948 16 man man NN 37158 948 17 as as RB 37158 948 18 supremely supremely RB 37158 948 19 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 37158 948 20 , , , 37158 948 21 even even RB 37158 948 22 guilty guilty JJ 37158 948 23 , , , 37158 948 24 who who WP 37158 948 25 would would MD 37158 948 26 not not RB 37158 948 27 innoculate innoculate VB 37158 948 28 a a DT 37158 948 29 microbe microbe NN 37158 948 30 into into IN 37158 948 31 a a DT 37158 948 32 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 948 33 to to TO 37158 948 34 achieve achieve VB 37158 948 35 a a DT 37158 948 36 great great JJ 37158 948 37 discovery discovery NN 37158 948 38 for for IN 37158 948 39 humanity humanity NN 37158 948 40 . . . 37158 949 1 Wisdom wisdom NN 37158 949 2 , , , 37158 949 3 therefore therefore RB 37158 949 4 , , , 37158 949 5 consists consist VBZ 37158 949 6 precisely precisely RB 37158 949 7 in in IN 37158 949 8 this this DT 37158 949 9 : : : 37158 949 10 to to TO 37158 949 11 know know VB 37158 949 12 where where WRB 37158 949 13 to to TO 37158 949 14 stop stop VB 37158 949 15 in in IN 37158 949 16 pushing push VBG 37158 949 17 a a DT 37158 949 18 reasoning reasoning NN 37158 949 19 to to IN 37158 949 20 extremes extreme NNS 37158 949 21 . . . 37158 950 1 This this DT 37158 950 2 is be VBZ 37158 950 3 what what WP 37158 950 4 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 950 5 have have VBP 37158 950 6 sought seek VBN 37158 950 7 and and CC 37158 950 8 are be VBP 37158 950 9 seeking seek VBG 37158 950 10 to to TO 37158 950 11 do do VB 37158 950 12 . . . 37158 951 1 In in IN 37158 951 2 any any DT 37158 951 3 case case NN 37158 951 4 , , , 37158 951 5 and and CC 37158 951 6 as as IN 37158 951 7 a a DT 37158 951 8 last last JJ 37158 951 9 conclusion conclusion NN 37158 951 10 , , , 37158 951 11 Science Science NNP 37158 951 12 ought ought MD 37158 951 13 not not RB 37158 951 14 to to TO 37158 951 15 be be VB 37158 951 16 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 37158 951 17 . . . 37158 952 1 Now now RB 37158 952 2 , , , 37158 952 3 the the DT 37158 952 4 death death NN 37158 952 5 - - HYPH 37158 952 6 knell knell NN 37158 952 7 of of IN 37158 952 8 science science NNP 37158 952 9 will will MD 37158 952 10 have have VB 37158 952 11 sounded sound VBN 37158 952 12 when when WRB 37158 952 13 _ _ NNP 37158 952 14 savants savant NNS 37158 952 15 _ _ NNP 37158 952 16 are be VBP 37158 952 17 prevented prevent VBN 37158 952 18 from from IN 37158 952 19 pursuing pursue VBG 37158 952 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 952 21 investigations investigation NNS 37158 952 22 on on IN 37158 952 23 living live VBG 37158 952 24 beings being NNS 37158 952 25 . . . 37158 953 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 953 2 who who WP 37158 953 3 , , , 37158 953 4 in in IN 37158 953 5 full full JJ 37158 953 6 confidence confidence NN 37158 953 7 , , , 37158 953 8 hope hope NN 37158 953 9 for for IN 37158 953 10 a a DT 37158 953 11 happier happy JJR 37158 953 12 and and CC 37158 953 13 better well JJR 37158 953 14 humanity humanity NN 37158 953 15 , , , 37158 953 16 will will MD 37158 953 17 never never RB 37158 953 18 resign resign VB 37158 953 19 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37158 953 20 to to IN 37158 953 21 closing close VBG 37158 953 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 953 23 laboratories laboratory NNS 37158 953 24 , , , 37158 953 25 to to IN 37158 953 26 burning burn VBG 37158 953 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 953 28 books book NNS 37158 953 29 . . . 37158 954 1 On on IN 37158 954 2 the the DT 37158 954 3 contrary contrary NN 37158 954 4 , , , 37158 954 5 we -PRON- PRP 37158 954 6 are be VBP 37158 954 7 determined determined JJ 37158 954 8 , , , 37158 954 9 every every DT 37158 954 10 one one CD 37158 954 11 of of IN 37158 954 12 us -PRON- PRP 37158 954 13 , , , 37158 954 14 to to TO 37158 954 15 continue continue VB 37158 954 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 954 17 hard hard JJ 37158 954 18 labours labour NNS 37158 954 19 for for IN 37158 954 20 the the DT 37158 954 21 great great JJ 37158 954 22 good good NN 37158 954 23 of of IN 37158 954 24 the the DT 37158 954 25 men man NNS 37158 954 26 of of IN 37158 954 27 to to IN 37158 954 28 - - HYPH 37158 954 29 day day NN 37158 954 30 and and CC 37158 954 31 of of IN 37158 954 32 the the DT 37158 954 33 generations generation NNS 37158 954 34 to to TO 37158 954 35 come come VB 37158 954 36 . . . 37158 955 1 And and CC 37158 955 2 when when WRB 37158 955 3 we -PRON- PRP 37158 955 4 speak speak VBP 37158 955 5 of of IN 37158 955 6 Science Science NNP 37158 955 7 , , , 37158 955 8 we -PRON- PRP 37158 955 9 do do VBP 37158 955 10 not not RB 37158 955 11 mean mean VB 37158 955 12 only only RB 37158 955 13 the the DT 37158 955 14 material material NN 37158 955 15 benefits benefit NNS 37158 955 16 she -PRON- PRP 37158 955 17 scatters scatter VBZ 37158 955 18 abroad abroad RB 37158 955 19 ; ; : 37158 955 20 we -PRON- PRP 37158 955 21 think think VBP 37158 955 22 also also RB 37158 955 23 of of IN 37158 955 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 37158 955 25 power power NN 37158 955 26 as as IN 37158 955 27 a a DT 37158 955 28 moral moral JJ 37158 955 29 force force NN 37158 955 30 . . . 37158 956 1 Material material NN 37158 956 2 and and CC 37158 956 3 moral moral JJ 37158 956 4 conquests conquest NNS 37158 956 5 walk walk VBP 37158 956 6 hand hand NN 37158 956 7 in in IN 37158 956 8 hand hand NN 37158 956 9 . . . 37158 957 1 Science science NN 37158 957 2 is be VBZ 37158 957 3 the the DT 37158 957 4 basis basis NN 37158 957 5 of of IN 37158 957 6 the the DT 37158 957 7 moral moral JJ 37158 957 8 law law NN 37158 957 9 . . . 37158 958 1 The the DT 37158 958 2 universal universal JJ 37158 958 3 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 958 4 of of IN 37158 958 5 humanity humanity NN 37158 958 6 grows grow VBZ 37158 958 7 greater great JJR 37158 958 8 by by IN 37158 958 9 the the DT 37158 958 10 acquisition acquisition NN 37158 958 11 of of IN 37158 958 12 new new JJ 37158 958 13 truths truth NNS 37158 958 14 . . . 37158 959 1 Each each DT 37158 959 2 individual individual JJ 37158 959 3 , , , 37158 959 4 by by IN 37158 959 5 the the DT 37158 959 6 very very JJ 37158 959 7 fact fact NN 37158 959 8 that that IN 37158 959 9 he -PRON- PRP 37158 959 10 loves love VBZ 37158 959 11 truth truth NN 37158 959 12 , , , 37158 959 13 has have VBZ 37158 959 14 come come VBN 37158 959 15 to to TO 37158 959 16 understand understand VB 37158 959 17 the the DT 37158 959 18 moral moral JJ 37158 959 19 ideal ideal NN 37158 959 20 which which WDT 37158 959 21 should should MD 37158 959 22 be be VB 37158 959 23 ever ever RB 37158 959 24 before before IN 37158 959 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37158 959 26 eyes eye NNS 37158 959 27 . . . 37158 960 1 And and CC 37158 960 2 then then RB 37158 960 3 , , , 37158 960 4 in in IN 37158 960 5 a a DT 37158 960 6 just just JJ 37158 960 7 measure measure NN 37158 960 8 , , , 37158 960 9 full full JJ 37158 960 10 of of IN 37158 960 11 pity pity NN 37158 960 12 for for IN 37158 960 13 all all DT 37158 960 14 suffering suffering NN 37158 960 15 , , , 37158 960 16 but but CC 37158 960 17 placing place VBG 37158 960 18 the the DT 37158 960 19 suffering suffering NN 37158 960 20 of of IN 37158 960 21 man man NN 37158 960 22 at at IN 37158 960 23 a a DT 37158 960 24 higher high JJR 37158 960 25 price price NN 37158 960 26 than than IN 37158 960 27 the the DT 37158 960 28 suffering suffering NN 37158 960 29 of of IN 37158 960 30 the the DT 37158 960 31 animal animal NN 37158 960 32 , , , 37158 960 33 we -PRON- PRP 37158 960 34 shall shall MD 37158 960 35 strive strive VB 37158 960 36 to to TO 37158 960 37 make make VB 37158 960 38 the the DT 37158 960 39 respect respect NN 37158 960 40 of of IN 37158 960 41 animal animal NN 37158 960 42 suffering suffering NN 37158 960 43 accord accord NN 37158 960 44 with with IN 37158 960 45 the the DT 37158 960 46 search search NN 37158 960 47 for for IN 37158 960 48 the the DT 37158 960 49 splendid splendid JJ 37158 960 50 and and CC 37158 960 51 indispensable indispensable JJ 37158 960 52 and and CC 37158 960 53 divine divine JJ 37158 960 54 TRUTH truth NN 37158 960 55 . . . 37158 961 1 POST post JJ 37158 961 2 SCRIPTUM SCRIPTUM NNP 37158 961 3 In in IN 37158 961 4 the the DT 37158 961 5 various various JJ 37158 961 6 works work NNS 37158 961 7 , , , 37158 961 8 notices notice NNS 37158 961 9 , , , 37158 961 10 discourses discourse NNS 37158 961 11 , , , 37158 961 12 etc etc FW 37158 961 13 . . FW 37158 961 14 , , , 37158 961 15 which which WDT 37158 961 16 have have VBP 37158 961 17 been be VBN 37158 961 18 published publish VBN 37158 961 19 upon upon IN 37158 961 20 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 961 21 , , , 37158 961 22 generally generally RB 37158 961 23 against against IN 37158 961 24 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 961 25 , , , 37158 961 26 I -PRON- PRP 37158 961 27 find find VBP 37158 961 28 various various JJ 37158 961 29 erroneous erroneous JJ 37158 961 30 assertions assertion NNS 37158 961 31 which which WDT 37158 961 32 it -PRON- PRP 37158 961 33 is be VBZ 37158 961 34 important important JJ 37158 961 35 should should MD 37158 961 36 be be VB 37158 961 37 pointed point VBN 37158 961 38 out out RP 37158 961 39 . . . 37158 962 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 962 2 will will MD 37158 962 3 do do VB 37158 962 4 so so RB 37158 962 5 briefly briefly RB 37158 962 6 . . . 37158 963 1 There there EX 37158 963 2 is be VBZ 37158 963 3 , , , 37158 963 4 however however RB 37158 963 5 , , , 37158 963 6 one one CD 37158 963 7 assertion assertion NN 37158 963 8 which which WDT 37158 963 9 appears appear VBZ 37158 963 10 fairly fairly RB 37158 963 11 just just RB 37158 963 12 to to IN 37158 963 13 me -PRON- PRP 37158 963 14 . . . 37158 964 1 This this DT 37158 964 2 is be VBZ 37158 964 3 that that IN 37158 964 4 in in IN 37158 964 5 treatises treatise NNS 37158 964 6 on on IN 37158 964 7 physiology physiology NN 37158 964 8 , , , 37158 964 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 964 10 mention mention NN 37158 964 11 is be VBZ 37158 964 12 not not RB 37158 964 13 made make VBN 37158 964 14 of of IN 37158 964 15 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 964 16 , , , 37158 964 17 of of IN 37158 964 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 964 19 limits limit NNS 37158 964 20 and and CC 37158 964 21 of of IN 37158 964 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 964 23 abuses abuse NNS 37158 964 24 . . . 37158 965 1 At at IN 37158 965 2 the the DT 37158 965 3 beginning beginning NN 37158 965 4 of of IN 37158 965 5 a a DT 37158 965 6 treatise treatise NN 37158 965 7 on on IN 37158 965 8 physiology physiology NN 37158 965 9 , , , 37158 965 10 the the DT 37158 965 11 author author NN 37158 965 12 should should MD 37158 965 13 distinctly distinctly RB 37158 965 14 declare declare VB 37158 965 15 there there EX 37158 965 16 is be VBZ 37158 965 17 always always RB 37158 965 18 cruelty cruelty JJ 37158 965 19 in in IN 37158 965 20 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 965 21 conducted conduct VBN 37158 965 22 without without IN 37158 965 23 chloroform chloroform NN 37158 965 24 or or CC 37158 965 25 chloralose chloralose VB 37158 965 26 ; ; , 37158 965 27 the the DT 37158 965 28 author author NN 37158 965 29 should should MD 37158 965 30 indicate indicate VB 37158 965 31 that that IN 37158 965 32 these these DT 37158 965 33 anæsthetics anæsthetic NNS 37158 965 34 ought ought MD 37158 965 35 to to TO 37158 965 36 be be VB 37158 965 37 administered administer VBN 37158 965 38 under under IN 37158 965 39 such such JJ 37158 965 40 or or CC 37158 965 41 such such JJ 37158 965 42 conditions condition NNS 37158 965 43 . . . 37158 966 1 Before before IN 37158 966 2 initiating initiate VBG 37158 966 3 medical medical JJ 37158 966 4 students student NNS 37158 966 5 into into IN 37158 966 6 the the DT 37158 966 7 study study NN 37158 966 8 of of IN 37158 966 9 life life NN 37158 966 10 , , , 37158 966 11 it -PRON- PRP 37158 966 12 is be VBZ 37158 966 13 also also RB 37158 966 14 well well JJ 37158 966 15 to to TO 37158 966 16 teach teach VB 37158 966 17 them -PRON- PRP 37158 966 18 to to TO 37158 966 19 have have VB 37158 966 20 respect respect NN 37158 966 21 for for IN 37158 966 22 animal animal NN 37158 966 23 suffering suffering NN 37158 966 24 . . . 37158 967 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 967 2 would would MD 37158 967 3 that that IN 37158 967 4 it -PRON- PRP 37158 967 5 might may MD 37158 967 6 be be VB 37158 967 7 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37158 967 8 understood understand VBN 37158 967 9 that that IN 37158 967 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 967 11 is be VBZ 37158 967 12 a a DT 37158 967 13 matter matter NN 37158 967 14 of of IN 37158 967 15 absolute absolute JJ 37158 967 16 necessity necessity NN 37158 967 17 to to TO 37158 967 18 operate operate VB 37158 967 19 upon upon IN 37158 967 20 the the DT 37158 967 21 animal animal NN 37158 967 22 ; ; : 37158 967 23 and and CC 37158 967 24 that that IN 37158 967 25 when when WRB 37158 967 26 the the DT 37158 967 27 physiologist physiologist NN 37158 967 28 resigns resign VBZ 37158 967 29 himself -PRON- PRP 37158 967 30 to to IN 37158 967 31 this this DT 37158 967 32 necessity necessity NN 37158 967 33 he -PRON- PRP 37158 967 34 ought ought MD 37158 967 35 to to TO 37158 967 36 perform perform VB 37158 967 37 the the DT 37158 967 38 operation operation NN 37158 967 39 with with IN 37158 967 40 sufficient sufficient JJ 37158 967 41 humanity humanity NN 37158 967 42 to to TO 37158 967 43 prevent prevent VB 37158 967 44 the the DT 37158 967 45 animal animal NN 37158 967 46 from from IN 37158 967 47 suffering suffer VBG 37158 967 48 . . . 37158 968 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 968 2 willingly willingly RB 37158 968 3 recognise recognise VBP 37158 968 4 that that IN 37158 968 5 the the DT 37158 968 6 absence absence NN 37158 968 7 of of IN 37158 968 8 this this DT 37158 968 9 first first JJ 37158 968 10 moral moral JJ 37158 968 11 precept precept NN 37158 968 12 is be VBZ 37158 968 13 a a DT 37158 968 14 great great JJ 37158 968 15 gap gap NN 37158 968 16 in in IN 37158 968 17 most most JJS 37158 968 18 treatises treatise NNS 37158 968 19 on on IN 37158 968 20 physiology physiology NN 37158 968 21 . . . 37158 969 1 This this DT 37158 969 2 , , , 37158 969 3 however however RB 37158 969 4 , , , 37158 969 5 is be VBZ 37158 969 6 about about IN 37158 969 7 all all DT 37158 969 8 I -PRON- PRP 37158 969 9 can can MD 37158 969 10 concede concede VB 37158 969 11 to to IN 37158 969 12 anti anti JJ 37158 969 13 - - JJ 37158 969 14 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 969 15 ; ; : 37158 969 16 for for IN 37158 969 17 truly truly RB 37158 969 18 they -PRON- PRP 37158 969 19 indulge indulge VBP 37158 969 20 in in IN 37158 969 21 such such JJ 37158 969 22 queer queer NN 37158 969 23 , , , 37158 969 24 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37158 969 25 assertions assertion NNS 37158 969 26 that that IN 37158 969 27 we -PRON- PRP 37158 969 28 are be VBP 37158 969 29 completely completely RB 37158 969 30 disconcerted disconcert VBN 37158 969 31 . . . 37158 970 1 Some some DT 37158 970 2 of of IN 37158 970 3 these these DT 37158 970 4 fanatics fanatic NNS 37158 970 5 pretend pretend VBP 37158 970 6 , , , 37158 970 7 for for IN 37158 970 8 example example NN 37158 970 9 , , , 37158 970 10 that that IN 37158 970 11 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 970 12 should should MD 37158 970 13 practise practise VB 37158 970 14 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 970 15 upon upon IN 37158 970 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 37158 970 17 . . . 37158 971 1 To to TO 37158 971 2 torture torture VB 37158 971 3 a a DT 37158 971 4 dog dog NN 37158 971 5 is be VBZ 37158 971 6 as as RB 37158 971 7 criminal criminal JJ 37158 971 8 as as IN 37158 971 9 to to TO 37158 971 10 torture torture VB 37158 971 11 a a DT 37158 971 12 child child NN 37158 971 13 , , , 37158 971 14 according accord VBG 37158 971 15 to to IN 37158 971 16 them -PRON- PRP 37158 971 17 ; ; : 37158 971 18 and and CC 37158 971 19 animal animal NN 37158 971 20 suffering suffering NN 37158 971 21 is be VBZ 37158 971 22 as as RB 37158 971 23 much much JJ 37158 971 24 to to TO 37158 971 25 be be VB 37158 971 26 respected respect VBN 37158 971 27 as as IN 37158 971 28 human human JJ 37158 971 29 suffering suffering NN 37158 971 30 ! ! . 37158 972 1 Truly truly RB 37158 972 2 such such PDT 37158 972 3 a a DT 37158 972 4 paradox paradox NN 37158 972 5 can can MD 37158 972 6 not not RB 37158 972 7 be be VB 37158 972 8 taken take VBN 37158 972 9 seriously seriously RB 37158 972 10 ; ; : 37158 972 11 if if IN 37158 972 12 it -PRON- PRP 37158 972 13 were be VBD 37158 972 14 admitted admit VBN 37158 972 15 , , , 37158 972 16 evidently evidently RB 37158 972 17 the the DT 37158 972 18 question question NN 37158 972 19 is be VBZ 37158 972 20 settled settle VBN 37158 972 21 . . . 37158 973 1 But but CC 37158 973 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 973 3 can can MD 37158 973 4 not not RB 37158 973 5 be be VB 37158 973 6 admitted admit VBN 37158 973 7 , , , 37158 973 8 and and CC 37158 973 9 the the DT 37158 973 10 whole whole NN 37158 973 11 of of IN 37158 973 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 973 13 argument argument NN 37158 973 14 rests rest VBZ 37158 973 15 upon upon IN 37158 973 16 this this DT 37158 973 17 principle principle NN 37158 973 18 , , , 37158 973 19 which which WDT 37158 973 20 appears appear VBZ 37158 973 21 quite quite RB 37158 973 22 evident evident JJ 37158 973 23 , , , 37158 973 24 that that IN 37158 973 25 living live VBG 37158 973 26 beings being NNS 37158 973 27 occupy occupy VBP 37158 973 28 different different JJ 37158 973 29 positions position NNS 37158 973 30 in in IN 37158 973 31 the the DT 37158 973 32 hierarchy hierarchy NN 37158 973 33 of of IN 37158 973 34 nature nature NN 37158 973 35 . . . 37158 974 1 Let let VB 37158 974 2 us -PRON- PRP 37158 974 3 take take VB 37158 974 4 a a DT 37158 974 5 besieged besiege VBN 37158 974 6 city city NN 37158 974 7 reduced reduce VBN 37158 974 8 to to IN 37158 974 9 famine famine NN 37158 974 10 : : : 37158 974 11 will will MD 37158 974 12 anyone anyone NN 37158 974 13 pretend pretend VB 37158 974 14 that that IN 37158 974 15 the the DT 37158 974 16 soldiers soldier NNS 37158 974 17 must must MD 37158 974 18 be be VB 37158 974 19 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 37158 974 20 before before IN 37158 974 21 the the DT 37158 974 22 horses horse NNS 37158 974 23 , , , 37158 974 24 the the DT 37158 974 25 mules mule NNS 37158 974 26 , , , 37158 974 27 etc etc FW 37158 974 28 . . . 37158 975 1 Yet yet RB 37158 975 2 the the DT 37158 975 3 case case NN 37158 975 4 is be VBZ 37158 975 5 exactly exactly RB 37158 975 6 the the DT 37158 975 7 same same JJ 37158 975 8 . . . 37158 976 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 976 2 is be VBZ 37158 976 3 in in IN 37158 976 4 order order NN 37158 976 5 to to TO 37158 976 6 avoid avoid VB 37158 976 7 the the DT 37158 976 8 death death NN 37158 976 9 of of IN 37158 976 10 human human JJ 37158 976 11 beings being NNS 37158 976 12 that that WDT 37158 976 13 mice mouse NNS 37158 976 14 and and CC 37158 976 15 guinea guinea NN 37158 976 16 - - HYPH 37158 976 17 pigs pig NNS 37158 976 18 are be VBP 37158 976 19 put put VBN 37158 976 20 to to IN 37158 976 21 death death NN 37158 976 22 . . . 37158 977 1 To to TO 37158 977 2 deny deny VB 37158 977 3 the the DT 37158 977 4 difference difference NN 37158 977 5 in in IN 37158 977 6 rank rank NN 37158 977 7 of of IN 37158 977 8 living live VBG 37158 977 9 beings being NNS 37158 977 10 is be VBZ 37158 977 11 to to TO 37158 977 12 deny deny VB 37158 977 13 evidence evidence NN 37158 977 14 . . . 37158 978 1 A a DT 37158 978 2 frog frog NN 37158 978 3 is be VBZ 37158 978 4 a a DT 37158 978 5 nobler noble JJR 37158 978 6 animal animal NN 37158 978 7 than than IN 37158 978 8 a a DT 37158 978 9 sea sea NN 37158 978 10 - - HYPH 37158 978 11 urchin urchin NN 37158 978 12 ; ; : 37158 978 13 a a DT 37158 978 14 dog dog NN 37158 978 15 is be VBZ 37158 978 16 a a DT 37158 978 17 nobler noble JJR 37158 978 18 animal animal NN 37158 978 19 than than IN 37158 978 20 a a DT 37158 978 21 frog frog NN 37158 978 22 ; ; : 37158 978 23 for for IN 37158 978 24 there there EX 37158 978 25 are be VBP 37158 978 26 degrees degree NNS 37158 978 27 in in IN 37158 978 28 the the DT 37158 978 29 intelligence intelligence NN 37158 978 30 , , , 37158 978 31 and and CC 37158 978 32 consequently consequently RB 37158 978 33 , , , 37158 978 34 in in IN 37158 978 35 the the DT 37158 978 36 capacity capacity NN 37158 978 37 to to TO 37158 978 38 suffer suffer VB 37158 978 39 , , , 37158 978 40 and and CC 37158 978 41 in in IN 37158 978 42 the the DT 37158 978 43 _ _ NNP 37158 978 44 quality quality NN 37158 978 45 _ _ NNP 37158 978 46 of of IN 37158 978 47 suffering suffering NN 37158 978 48 among among IN 37158 978 49 the the DT 37158 978 50 four four CD 37158 978 51 animal animal NN 37158 978 52 groups group NNS 37158 978 53 : : : 37158 978 54 the the DT 37158 978 55 sea sea NN 37158 978 56 - - HYPH 37158 978 57 urchin urchin NNP 37158 978 58 , , , 37158 978 59 the the DT 37158 978 60 frog frog NN 37158 978 61 , , , 37158 978 62 the the DT 37158 978 63 dog dog NN 37158 978 64 , , , 37158 978 65 and and CC 37158 978 66 man man NN 37158 978 67 . . . 37158 979 1 Anti Anti NNS 37158 979 2 - - NNS 37158 979 3 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 979 4 do do VBP 37158 979 5 not not RB 37158 979 6 admit admit VB 37158 979 7 reflex reflex JJ 37158 979 8 movements movement NNS 37158 979 9 ( ( -LRB- 37158 979 10 which which WDT 37158 979 11 , , , 37158 979 12 moreover moreover RB 37158 979 13 , , , 37158 979 14 they -PRON- PRP 37158 979 15 do do VBP 37158 979 16 not not RB 37158 979 17 understand understand VB 37158 979 18 ) ) -RRB- 37158 979 19 ; ; : 37158 979 20 and and CC 37158 979 21 they -PRON- PRP 37158 979 22 bewail bewail VBP 37158 979 23 the the DT 37158 979 24 dogs dog NNS 37158 979 25 that that WDT 37158 979 26 Goltz Goltz NNP 37158 979 27 and and CC 37158 979 28 Ewald Ewald NNP 37158 979 29 subjected subject VBD 37158 979 30 to to IN 37158 979 31 cerebral cerebral JJ 37158 979 32 mutilations mutilation NNS 37158 979 33 which which WDT 37158 979 34 took take VBD 37158 979 35 away away RB 37158 979 36 all all DT 37158 979 37 intellectual intellectual JJ 37158 979 38 spontaneity spontaneity NN 37158 979 39 and and CC 37158 979 40 prevented prevent VBD 37158 979 41 them -PRON- PRP 37158 979 42 from from IN 37158 979 43 eating eat VBG 37158 979 44 spontaneously spontaneously RB 37158 979 45 . . . 37158 980 1 But but CC 37158 980 2 in in IN 37158 980 3 those those DT 37158 980 4 very very JJ 37158 980 5 dogs dog NNS 37158 980 6 , , , 37158 980 7 precisely precisely RB 37158 980 8 because because IN 37158 980 9 there there EX 37158 980 10 is be VBZ 37158 980 11 no no DT 37158 980 12 spontaneity spontaneity NN 37158 980 13 , , , 37158 980 14 so so CC 37158 980 15 there there EX 37158 980 16 is be VBZ 37158 980 17 no no DT 37158 980 18 longer long RBR 37158 980 19 any any DT 37158 980 20 consciousness consciousness NN 37158 980 21 of of IN 37158 980 22 pain pain NN 37158 980 23 . . . 37158 981 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 981 2 are be VBP 37158 981 3 , , , 37158 981 4 therefore therefore RB 37158 981 5 , , , 37158 981 6 of of IN 37158 981 7 all all PDT 37158 981 8 the the DT 37158 981 9 beings being NNS 37158 981 10 in in IN 37158 981 11 creation creation NN 37158 981 12 those those DT 37158 981 13 which which WDT 37158 981 14 deserve deserve VBP 37158 981 15 the the DT 37158 981 16 least least JJS 37158 981 17 commiseration commiseration NN 37158 981 18 ; ; : 37158 981 19 for for IN 37158 981 20 they -PRON- PRP 37158 981 21 are be VBP 37158 981 22 protected protect VBN 37158 981 23 against against IN 37158 981 24 pain pain NN 37158 981 25 by by IN 37158 981 26 that that DT 37158 981 27 very very JJ 37158 981 28 ablation ablation NN 37158 981 29 of of IN 37158 981 30 the the DT 37158 981 31 brain brain NN 37158 981 32 , , , 37158 981 33 the the DT 37158 981 34 seat seat NN 37158 981 35 of of IN 37158 981 36 pain pain NN 37158 981 37 . . . 37158 982 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 982 2 are be VBP 37158 982 3 told tell VBN 37158 982 4 that that IN 37158 982 5 it -PRON- PRP 37158 982 6 is be VBZ 37158 982 7 through through IN 37158 982 8 cowardice cowardice NN 37158 982 9 , , , 37158 982 10 through through IN 37158 982 11 the the DT 37158 982 12 fear fear NN 37158 982 13 of of IN 37158 982 14 disease disease NN 37158 982 15 , , , 37158 982 16 that that DT 37158 982 17 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 982 18 is be VBZ 37158 982 19 practised practise VBN 37158 982 20 . . . 37158 983 1 But but CC 37158 983 2 fear fear NN 37158 983 3 of of IN 37158 983 4 disease disease NN 37158 983 5 is be VBZ 37158 983 6 not not RB 37158 983 7 cowardice cowardice NN 37158 983 8 . . . 37158 984 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 984 2 am be VBP 37158 984 3 neither neither CC 37158 984 4 poltroon poltroon NNP 37158 984 5 nor nor CC 37158 984 6 coward coward NN 37158 984 7 , , , 37158 984 8 but but CC 37158 984 9 I -PRON- PRP 37158 984 10 would would MD 37158 984 11 be be VB 37158 984 12 very very RB 37158 984 13 sorry sorry JJ 37158 984 14 to to TO 37158 984 15 be be VB 37158 984 16 attacked attack VBN 37158 984 17 by by IN 37158 984 18 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 984 19 or or CC 37158 984 20 cancer cancer NN 37158 984 21 . . . 37158 985 1 I -PRON- PRP 37158 985 2 do do VBP 37158 985 3 not not RB 37158 985 4 blush blush VB 37158 985 5 to to TO 37158 985 6 confess confess VB 37158 985 7 that that IN 37158 985 8 it -PRON- PRP 37158 985 9 would would MD 37158 985 10 be be VB 37158 985 11 very very RB 37158 985 12 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 37158 985 13 for for IN 37158 985 14 me -PRON- PRP 37158 985 15 to to TO 37158 985 16 be be VB 37158 985 17 hanged hang VBN 37158 985 18 , , , 37158 985 19 though though IN 37158 985 20 hanging hang VBG 37158 985 21 is be VBZ 37158 985 22 much much RB 37158 985 23 less less RBR 37158 985 24 painful painful JJ 37158 985 25 than than IN 37158 985 26 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 985 27 or or CC 37158 985 28 cancer cancer NN 37158 985 29 . . . 37158 986 1 If if IN 37158 986 2 it -PRON- PRP 37158 986 3 were be VBD 37158 986 4 necessary necessary JJ 37158 986 5 to to TO 37158 986 6 have have VB 37158 986 7 a a DT 37158 986 8 hanged hanged JJ 37158 986 9 victim victim NN 37158 986 10 , , , 37158 986 11 I -PRON- PRP 37158 986 12 would would MD 37158 986 13 much much RB 37158 986 14 prefer prefer VB 37158 986 15 that that IN 37158 986 16 a a DT 37158 986 17 rabbit rabbit NN 37158 986 18 were be VBD 37158 986 19 taken take VBN 37158 986 20 in in IN 37158 986 21 preference preference NN 37158 986 22 to to IN 37158 986 23 myself -PRON- PRP 37158 986 24 ; ; : 37158 986 25 and and CC 37158 986 26 I -PRON- PRP 37158 986 27 would would MD 37158 986 28 certainly certainly RB 37158 986 29 not not RB 37158 986 30 put put VB 37158 986 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 986 32 own own JJ 37158 986 33 neck neck NN 37158 986 34 in in IN 37158 986 35 the the DT 37158 986 36 cord cord NN 37158 986 37 to to TO 37158 986 38 save save VB 37158 986 39 a a DT 37158 986 40 dog dog NN 37158 986 41 from from IN 37158 986 42 torture torture NN 37158 986 43 . . . 37158 987 1 The the DT 37158 987 2 state state NN 37158 987 3 of of IN 37158 987 4 mind mind NN 37158 987 5 of of IN 37158 987 6 anti anti JJ 37158 987 7 - - JJ 37158 987 8 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 987 9 appears appear VBZ 37158 987 10 to to IN 37158 987 11 me -PRON- PRP 37158 987 12 rather rather RB 37158 987 13 singular singular JJ 37158 987 14 , , , 37158 987 15 since since IN 37158 987 16 they -PRON- PRP 37158 987 17 are be VBP 37158 987 18 not not RB 37158 987 19 at at RB 37158 987 20 all all RB 37158 987 21 afraid afraid JJ 37158 987 22 of of IN 37158 987 23 disease disease NN 37158 987 24 as as RB 37158 987 25 far far RB 37158 987 26 as as IN 37158 987 27 man man NN 37158 987 28 is be VBZ 37158 987 29 concerned concern VBN 37158 987 30 , , , 37158 987 31 but but CC 37158 987 32 they -PRON- PRP 37158 987 33 have have VBP 37158 987 34 great great JJ 37158 987 35 fear fear NN 37158 987 36 of of IN 37158 987 37 it -PRON- PRP 37158 987 38 for for IN 37158 987 39 animals animal NNS 37158 987 40 . . . 37158 988 1 If if IN 37158 988 2 pain pain NN 37158 988 3 is be VBZ 37158 988 4 but but CC 37158 988 5 an an DT 37158 988 6 empty empty JJ 37158 988 7 word word NN 37158 988 8 , , , 37158 988 9 according accord VBG 37158 988 10 to to IN 37158 988 11 the the DT 37158 988 12 celebrated celebrated JJ 37158 988 13 phrase phrase NN 37158 988 14 of of IN 37158 988 15 Zeno Zeno NNP 37158 988 16 , , , 37158 988 17 why why WRB 37158 988 18 not not RB 37158 988 19 apply apply VB 37158 988 20 that that IN 37158 988 21 fine fine JJ 37158 988 22 maxim maxim NN 37158 988 23 to to IN 37158 988 24 the the DT 37158 988 25 animal animal NN 37158 988 26 ? ? . 37158 989 1 Sir Sir NNP 37158 989 2 James James NNP 37158 989 3 Thornton Thornton NNP 37158 989 4 ( ( -LRB- 37158 989 5 _ _ NNP 37158 989 6 The the DT 37158 989 7 Principal Principal NNP 37158 989 8 Claims Claims NNPS 37158 989 9 on on IN 37158 989 10 behalf behalf NN 37158 989 11 of of IN 37158 989 12 Vivisection Vivisection NNP 37158 989 13 _ _ NNP 37158 989 14 , , , 37158 989 15 London London NNP 37158 989 16 , , , 37158 989 17 1907 1907 CD 37158 989 18 ) ) -RRB- 37158 989 19 , , , 37158 989 20 has have VBZ 37158 989 21 endeavoured endeavour VBN 37158 989 22 to to TO 37158 989 23 compile compile VB 37158 989 24 a a DT 37158 989 25 list list NN 37158 989 26 of of IN 37158 989 27 the the DT 37158 989 28 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 989 29 to to TO 37158 989 30 be be VB 37158 989 31 found find VBN 37158 989 32 in in IN 37158 989 33 the the DT 37158 989 34 treatises treatise NNS 37158 989 35 of of IN 37158 989 36 physiology physiology NN 37158 989 37 . . . 37158 990 1 He -PRON- PRP 37158 990 2 could could MD 37158 990 3 have have VB 37158 990 4 added add VBN 37158 990 5 considerably considerably RB 37158 990 6 to to IN 37158 990 7 the the DT 37158 990 8 length length NN 37158 990 9 of of IN 37158 990 10 this this DT 37158 990 11 chapter chapter NN 37158 990 12 , , , 37158 990 13 for for IN 37158 990 14 the the DT 37158 990 15 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 990 16 are be VBP 37158 990 17 innumerable innumerable JJ 37158 990 18 ; ; : 37158 990 19 which which WDT 37158 990 20 only only RB 37158 990 21 proves prove VBZ 37158 990 22 , , , 37158 990 23 not not RB 37158 990 24 that that IN 37158 990 25 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 990 26 is be VBZ 37158 990 27 useless useless JJ 37158 990 28 , , , 37158 990 29 but but CC 37158 990 30 that that IN 37158 990 31 it -PRON- PRP 37158 990 32 is be VBZ 37158 990 33 difficult difficult JJ 37158 990 34 . . . 37158 991 1 What what WP 37158 991 2 would would MD 37158 991 3 chemists chemist NNS 37158 991 4 say say VB 37158 991 5 if if IN 37158 991 6 it -PRON- PRP 37158 991 7 were be VBD 37158 991 8 maintained maintain VBN 37158 991 9 that that IN 37158 991 10 chemical chemical NN 37158 991 11 analysis analysis NN 37158 991 12 was be VBD 37158 991 13 absurd absurd JJ 37158 991 14 because because IN 37158 991 15 of of IN 37158 991 16 the the DT 37158 991 17 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 991 18 between between IN 37158 991 19 chemists chemist NNS 37158 991 20 ? ? . 37158 992 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 992 2 would would MD 37158 992 3 , , , 37158 992 4 and and CC 37158 992 5 rightly rightly RB 37158 992 6 so so RB 37158 992 7 , , , 37158 992 8 continue continue VB 37158 992 9 to to TO 37158 992 10 make make VB 37158 992 11 analyses analysis NNS 37158 992 12 ; ; : 37158 992 13 for for IN 37158 992 14 they -PRON- PRP 37158 992 15 know know VBP 37158 992 16 that that IN 37158 992 17 analysis analysis NN 37158 992 18 is be VBZ 37158 992 19 a a DT 37158 992 20 necessary necessary JJ 37158 992 21 , , , 37158 992 22 though though IN 37158 992 23 an an DT 37158 992 24 imperfect imperfect NN 37158 992 25 , , , 37158 992 26 instrument instrument NN 37158 992 27 . . . 37158 993 1 In in IN 37158 993 2 the the DT 37158 993 3 same same JJ 37158 993 4 manner manner NN 37158 993 5 , , , 37158 993 6 we -PRON- PRP 37158 993 7 shall shall MD 37158 993 8 continue continue VB 37158 993 9 to to TO 37158 993 10 practise practise VB 37158 993 11 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 993 12 , , , 37158 993 13 though though IN 37158 993 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 993 15 know know VBP 37158 993 16 right right UH 37158 993 17 well well UH 37158 993 18 that that DT 37158 993 19 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 993 20 is be VBZ 37158 993 21 an an DT 37158 993 22 imperfect imperfect NN 37158 993 23 , , , 37158 993 24 though though IN 37158 993 25 a a DT 37158 993 26 necessary necessary JJ 37158 993 27 , , , 37158 993 28 instrument instrument NN 37158 993 29 . . . 37158 994 1 In in IN 37158 994 2 the the DT 37158 994 3 course course NN 37158 994 4 of of IN 37158 994 5 a a DT 37158 994 6 recent recent JJ 37158 994 7 debate debate NN 37158 994 8 on on IN 37158 994 9 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 994 10 , , , 37158 994 11 a a DT 37158 994 12 voice voice NN 37158 994 13 was be VBD 37158 994 14 heard hear VBN 37158 994 15 to to TO 37158 994 16 call call VB 37158 994 17 out out RP 37158 994 18 that that IN 37158 994 19 Lister Lister NNP 37158 994 20 was be VBD 37158 994 21 a a DT 37158 994 22 brute brute NN 37158 994 23 . . . 37158 995 1 That that IN 37158 995 2 " " `` 37158 995 3 crowns crown VBZ 37158 995 4 " " `` 37158 995 5 everything everything NN 37158 995 6 , , , 37158 995 7 and and CC 37158 995 8 one one PRP 37158 995 9 would would MD 37158 995 10 think think VB 37158 995 11 that that IN 37158 995 12 nothing nothing NN 37158 995 13 more more RBR 37158 995 14 inept inept JJ 37158 995 15 could could MD 37158 995 16 be be VB 37158 995 17 imagined imagine VBN 37158 995 18 . . . 37158 996 1 Alas alas UH 37158 996 2 ! ! . 37158 997 1 something something NN 37158 997 2 more more RBR 37158 997 3 inept inept JJ 37158 997 4 still still RB 37158 997 5 has have VBZ 37158 997 6 been be VBN 37158 997 7 said say VBN 37158 997 8 , , , 37158 997 9 and and CC 37158 997 10 I -PRON- PRP 37158 997 11 hand hand VBP 37158 997 12 over over RP 37158 997 13 this this DT 37158 997 14 prodigious prodigious JJ 37158 997 15 and and CC 37158 997 16 audacious audacious JJ 37158 997 17 assertion assertion NN 37158 997 18 to to IN 37158 997 19 the the DT 37158 997 20 judgment judgment NN 37158 997 21 of of IN 37158 997 22 every every DT 37158 997 23 man man NN 37158 997 24 of of IN 37158 997 25 heart heart NN 37158 997 26 and and CC 37158 997 27 common common JJ 37158 997 28 sense sense NN 37158 997 29 . . . 37158 998 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 998 2 refers refer VBZ 37158 998 3 to to IN 37158 998 4 bacteriology bacteriology NN 37158 998 5 . . . 37158 999 1 The the DT 37158 999 2 author author NN 37158 999 3 , , , 37158 999 4 after after IN 37158 999 5 having have VBG 37158 999 6 said say VBD 37158 999 7 that that IN 37158 999 8 microbes microbe NNS 37158 999 9 are be VBP 37158 999 10 not not RB 37158 999 11 the the DT 37158 999 12 cause cause NN 37158 999 13 of of IN 37158 999 14 disease disease NN 37158 999 15 , , , 37158 999 16 takes take VBZ 37158 999 17 refuge refuge NN 37158 999 18 behind behind IN 37158 999 19 the the DT 37158 999 20 opinion opinion NN 37158 999 21 of of IN 37158 999 22 Lawson Lawson NNP 37158 999 23 Tait Tait NNP 37158 999 24 ( ( -LRB- 37158 999 25 quoted quote VBN 37158 999 26 by by IN 37158 999 27 Mona Mona NNP 37158 999 28 Caird Caird NNP 37158 999 29 , , , 37158 999 30 _ _ NNP 37158 999 31 The the DT 37158 999 32 Inquisition Inquisition NNP 37158 999 33 of of IN 37158 999 34 Science Science NNP 37158 999 35 _ _ NNP 37158 999 36 , , , 37158 999 37 p. p. NN 37158 999 38 20 20 CD 37158 999 39 ) ) -RRB- 37158 999 40 . . . 37158 1000 1 " " `` 37158 1000 2 Such such JJ 37158 1000 3 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1000 4 never never RB 37158 1000 5 have have VBP 37158 1000 6 succeeded succeed VBN 37158 1000 7 , , , 37158 1000 8 never never RB 37158 1000 9 can can MD 37158 1000 10 : : : 37158 1000 11 and and CC 37158 1000 12 they -PRON- PRP 37158 1000 13 have have VBP 37158 1000 14 , , , 37158 1000 15 as as IN 37158 1000 16 in in IN 37158 1000 17 the the DT 37158 1000 18 cases case NNS 37158 1000 19 of of IN 37158 1000 20 Koch Koch NNP 37158 1000 21 , , , 37158 1000 22 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 1000 23 , , , 37158 1000 24 and and CC 37158 1000 25 Lister Lister NNP 37158 1000 26 , , , 37158 1000 27 not not RB 37158 1000 28 only only RB 37158 1000 29 hindered hinder VBN 37158 1000 30 true true JJ 37158 1000 31 progress progress NN 37158 1000 32 , , , 37158 1000 33 but but CC 37158 1000 34 they -PRON- PRP 37158 1000 35 have have VBP 37158 1000 36 covered cover VBN 37158 1000 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1000 38 profession profession NN 37158 1000 39 with with IN 37158 1000 40 ridicule ridicule NN 37158 1000 41 . . . 37158 1000 42 " " '' 37158 1001 1 That that DT 37158 1001 2 is be VBZ 37158 1001 3 something something NN 37158 1001 4 which which WDT 37158 1001 5 may may MD 37158 1001 6 well well RB 37158 1001 7 confound confound VB 37158 1001 8 us -PRON- PRP 37158 1001 9 , , , 37158 1001 10 is be VBZ 37158 1001 11 it -PRON- PRP 37158 1001 12 not not RB 37158 1001 13 ? ? . 37158 1002 1 and and CC 37158 1002 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 1002 3 believe believe VBP 37158 1002 4 those those DT 37158 1002 5 great great JJ 37158 1002 6 benefactors benefactor NNS 37158 1002 7 of of IN 37158 1002 8 humanity humanity NN 37158 1002 9 , , , 37158 1002 10 Koch Koch NNP 37158 1002 11 , , , 37158 1002 12 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 1002 13 and and CC 37158 1002 14 Lister Lister NNP 37158 1002 15 , , , 37158 1002 16 may may MD 37158 1002 17 indeed indeed RB 37158 1002 18 murmur murmur VB 37158 1002 19 : : : 37158 1002 20 " " `` 37158 1002 21 Forgive forgive VB 37158 1002 22 them -PRON- PRP 37158 1002 23 ; ; : 37158 1002 24 for for IN 37158 1002 25 they -PRON- PRP 37158 1002 26 know know VBP 37158 1002 27 not not RB 37158 1002 28 what what WP 37158 1002 29 they -PRON- PRP 37158 1002 30 say say VBP 37158 1002 31 . . . 37158 1002 32 " " '' 37158 1003 1 To to TO 37158 1003 2 sum sum VB 37158 1003 3 up up RP 37158 1003 4 : : : 37158 1003 5 the the DT 37158 1003 6 objections objection NNS 37158 1003 7 of of IN 37158 1003 8 anti anti JJ 37158 1003 9 - - NNS 37158 1003 10 vivisectionists vivisectionist NNS 37158 1003 11 are be VBP 37158 1003 12 irrefutable irrefutable JJ 37158 1003 13 if if IN 37158 1003 14 we -PRON- PRP 37158 1003 15 admit admit VBP 37158 1003 16 , , , 37158 1003 17 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1003 18 1 1 LS 37158 1003 19 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1003 20 that that DT 37158 1003 21 man man NN 37158 1003 22 has have VBZ 37158 1003 23 not not RB 37158 1003 24 the the DT 37158 1003 25 right right NN 37158 1003 26 to to TO 37158 1003 27 kill kill VB 37158 1003 28 an an DT 37158 1003 29 animal animal NN 37158 1003 30 either either CC 37158 1003 31 in in IN 37158 1003 32 self self NN 37158 1003 33 - - HYPH 37158 1003 34 defence defence NN 37158 1003 35 or or CC 37158 1003 36 for for IN 37158 1003 37 nourishment nourishment NN 37158 1003 38 ; ; : 37158 1003 39 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1003 40 2 2 LS 37158 1003 41 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1003 42 that that IN 37158 1003 43 the the DT 37158 1003 44 suffering suffering NN 37158 1003 45 of of IN 37158 1003 46 an an DT 37158 1003 47 animal animal NN 37158 1003 48 is be VBZ 37158 1003 49 as as RB 37158 1003 50 worthy worthy JJ 37158 1003 51 of of IN 37158 1003 52 respect respect NN 37158 1003 53 as as IN 37158 1003 54 the the DT 37158 1003 55 suffering suffering NN 37158 1003 56 of of IN 37158 1003 57 a a DT 37158 1003 58 man man NN 37158 1003 59 ; ; : 37158 1003 60 and and CC 37158 1003 61 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1003 62 3 3 LS 37158 1003 63 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1003 64 that that IN 37158 1003 65 the the DT 37158 1003 66 misery misery NN 37158 1003 67 of of IN 37158 1003 68 one one CD 37158 1003 69 individual individual NN 37158 1003 70 is be VBZ 37158 1003 71 as as RB 37158 1003 72 sacred sacred JJ 37158 1003 73 as as IN 37158 1003 74 the the DT 37158 1003 75 misery misery NN 37158 1003 76 of of IN 37158 1003 77 a a DT 37158 1003 78 thousand thousand CD 37158 1003 79 individuals individual NNS 37158 1003 80 . . . 37158 1004 1 No no DT 37158 1004 2 logical logical JJ 37158 1004 3 reply reply NN 37158 1004 4 can can MD 37158 1004 5 be be VB 37158 1004 6 made make VBN 37158 1004 7 to to IN 37158 1004 8 these these DT 37158 1004 9 three three CD 37158 1004 10 assertions assertion NNS 37158 1004 11 , , , 37158 1004 12 which which WDT 37158 1004 13 , , , 37158 1004 14 according accord VBG 37158 1004 15 to to IN 37158 1004 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1004 17 reasoning reasoning NN 37158 1004 18 , , , 37158 1004 19 constitute constitute VBP 37158 1004 20 an an DT 37158 1004 21 offence offence NN 37158 1004 22 against against IN 37158 1004 23 the the DT 37158 1004 24 most most RBS 37158 1004 25 elementary elementary JJ 37158 1004 26 common common JJ 37158 1004 27 sense sense NN 37158 1004 28 . . . 37158 1005 1 But but CC 37158 1005 2 I -PRON- PRP 37158 1005 3 doubt doubt VBP 37158 1005 4 very very RB 37158 1005 5 much much RB 37158 1005 6 if if IN 37158 1005 7 we -PRON- PRP 37158 1005 8 shall shall MD 37158 1005 9 ever ever RB 37158 1005 10 arrive arrive VB 37158 1005 11 at at IN 37158 1005 12 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 37158 1005 13 that that IN 37158 1005 14 it -PRON- PRP 37158 1005 15 is be VBZ 37158 1005 16 better well JJR 37158 1005 17 to to TO 37158 1005 18 allow allow VB 37158 1005 19 one one CD 37158 1005 20 hundred hundred CD 37158 1005 21 children child NNS 37158 1005 22 to to TO 37158 1005 23 die die VB 37158 1005 24 from from IN 37158 1005 25 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 1005 26 rather rather RB 37158 1005 27 than than IN 37158 1005 28 draw draw VB 37158 1005 29 a a DT 37158 1005 30 little little JJ 37158 1005 31 blood blood NN 37158 1005 32 from from IN 37158 1005 33 a a DT 37158 1005 34 horse horse NN 37158 1005 35 ; ; : 37158 1005 36 or or CC 37158 1005 37 that that IN 37158 1005 38 we -PRON- PRP 37158 1005 39 should should MD 37158 1005 40 practise practise VB 37158 1005 41 vivisection vivisection NN 37158 1005 42 on on IN 37158 1005 43 man man NN 37158 1005 44 so so IN 37158 1005 45 as as IN 37158 1005 46 to to TO 37158 1005 47 alleviate alleviate VB 37158 1005 48 the the DT 37158 1005 49 diseases disease NNS 37158 1005 50 of of IN 37158 1005 51 dogs dog NNS 37158 1005 52 . . . 37158 1006 1 Concerning concern VBG 37158 1006 2 the the DT 37158 1006 3 polemics polemic NNS 37158 1006 4 of of IN 37158 1006 5 anti anti NNS 37158 1006 6 - - NNS 37158 1006 7 vivisectionists vivisectionist VBZ 37158 1006 8 as as IN 37158 1006 9 to to IN 37158 1006 10 the the DT 37158 1006 11 uselessness uselessness NN 37158 1006 12 of of IN 37158 1006 13 physiology physiology NN 37158 1006 14 , , , 37158 1006 15 and and CC 37158 1006 16 the the DT 37158 1006 17 contradictions contradiction NNS 37158 1006 18 of of IN 37158 1006 19 physiologists physiologist NNS 37158 1006 20 , , , 37158 1006 21 they -PRON- PRP 37158 1006 22 are be VBP 37158 1006 23 nothing nothing NN 37158 1006 24 but but IN 37158 1006 25 a a DT 37158 1006 26 tissue tissue NN 37158 1006 27 of of IN 37158 1006 28 error error NN 37158 1006 29 and and CC 37158 1006 30 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 1006 31 . . . 37158 1007 1 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 37158 1007 2 A a DT 37158 1007 3 We -PRON- PRP 37158 1007 4 give give VBP 37158 1007 5 herewith herewith NNP 37158 1007 6 a a DT 37158 1007 7 table table NN 37158 1007 8 showing show VBG 37158 1007 9 the the DT 37158 1007 10 absolute absolute JJ 37158 1007 11 and and CC 37158 1007 12 relative relative JJ 37158 1007 13 mortality mortality NN 37158 1007 14 due due JJ 37158 1007 15 to to IN 37158 1007 16 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 1007 17 in in IN 37158 1007 18 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1007 19 from from IN 37158 1007 20 1872 1872 CD 37158 1007 21 to to IN 37158 1007 22 1905 1905 CD 37158 1007 23 , , , 37158 1007 24 out out IN 37158 1007 25 of of IN 37158 1007 26 a a DT 37158 1007 27 population population NN 37158 1007 28 of of IN 37158 1007 29 2,500,000 2,500,000 CD 37158 1007 30 inhabitants:-- inhabitants:-- : 37158 1007 31 ABSOLUTE ABSOLUTE NNP 37158 1007 32 . . . 37158 1008 1 PER per IN 37158 1008 2 100,000 100,000 CD 37158 1008 3 INHABITANTS inhabitant NNS 37158 1008 4 . . . 37158 1009 1 1872 1872 CD 37158 1009 2 1135 1135 CD 37158 1009 3 61 61 CD 37158 1009 4 1873 1873 CD 37158 1009 5 1164 1164 CD 37158 1009 6 62 62 CD 37158 1009 7 1874 1874 CD 37158 1009 8 1008 1008 CD 37158 1009 9 52 52 CD 37158 1009 10 1875 1875 CD 37158 1009 11 1328 1328 CD 37158 1009 12 68 68 CD 37158 1009 13 1876 1876 CD 37158 1009 14 1572 1572 CD 37158 1009 15 79 79 CD 37158 1009 16 1877 1877 CD 37158 1009 17 2393 2393 CD 37158 1009 18 117 117 CD 37158 1009 19 1878 1878 CD 37158 1009 20 1995 1995 CD 37158 1009 21 95 95 CD 37158 1009 22 1879 1879 CD 37158 1009 23 1783 1783 CD 37158 1009 24 83 83 CD 37158 1009 25 1880 1880 CD 37158 1009 26 2048 2048 CD 37158 1009 27 94 94 CD 37158 1009 28 1881 1881 CD 37158 1009 29 2211 2211 CD 37158 1009 30 99 99 CD 37158 1009 31 1882 1882 CD 37158 1009 32 2244 2244 CD 37158 1009 33 100 100 CD 37158 1009 34 1883 1883 CD 37158 1009 35 1781 1781 CD 37158 1009 36 79 79 CD 37158 1009 37 1884 1884 CD 37158 1009 38 1928 1928 CD 37158 1009 39 86 86 CD 37158 1009 40 1885 1885 CD 37158 1009 41 1655 1655 CD 37158 1009 42 74 74 CD 37158 1009 43 1886 1886 CD 37158 1009 44 1512 1512 CD 37158 1009 45 67 67 CD 37158 1009 46 1887 1887 CD 37158 1009 47 1585 1585 CD 37158 1009 48 70 70 CD 37158 1009 49 1888 1888 CD 37158 1009 50 1729 1729 CD 37158 1009 51 74 74 CD 37158 1009 52 1889 1889 CD 37158 1009 53 1706 1706 CD 37158 1009 54 72 72 CD 37158 1009 55 1890 1890 CD 37158 1009 56 1668 1668 CD 37158 1009 57 70 70 CD 37158 1009 58 1891 1891 CD 37158 1009 59 1361 1361 CD 37158 1009 60 56 56 CD 37158 1009 61 1892 1892 CD 37158 1009 62 1403 1403 CD 37158 1009 63 58 58 CD 37158 1009 64 1893 1893 CD 37158 1009 65 1266 1266 CD 37158 1009 66 52 52 CD 37158 1009 67 1894 1894 CD 37158 1009 68 1009 1009 CD 37158 1009 69 41 41 CD 37158 1009 70 1895 1895 CD 37158 1009 71 435 435 CD 37158 1009 72 17 17 CD 37158 1009 73 1896 1896 CD 37158 1009 74 444 444 CD 37158 1009 75 17 17 CD 37158 1009 76 1897 1897 CD 37158 1009 77 298 298 CD 37158 1009 78 12 12 CD 37158 1009 79 1898 1898 CD 37158 1009 80 259 259 CD 37158 1009 81 10 10 CD 37158 1009 82 1899 1899 CD 37158 1009 83 339 339 CD 37158 1009 84 13 13 CD 37158 1009 85 1900 1900 CD 37158 1009 86 294 294 CD 37158 1009 87 11 11 CD 37158 1009 88 1901 1901 CD 37158 1009 89 736 736 CD 37158 1009 90 28 28 CD 37158 1009 91 1902 1902 CD 37158 1009 92 709 709 CD 37158 1009 93 26 26 CD 37158 1009 94 1903 1903 CD 37158 1009 95 399 399 CD 37158 1009 96 15 15 CD 37158 1009 97 1904 1904 CD 37158 1009 98 260 260 CD 37158 1009 99 10 10 CD 37158 1009 100 1905 1905 CD 37158 1009 101 204 204 CD 37158 1009 102 7 7 CD 37158 1009 103 Let let VB 37158 1009 104 us -PRON- PRP 37158 1009 105 divide divide VB 37158 1009 106 this this DT 37158 1009 107 mortality mortality NN 37158 1009 108 due due IN 37158 1009 109 to to IN 37158 1009 110 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 1009 111 into into IN 37158 1009 112 three three CD 37158 1009 113 groups group NNS 37158 1009 114 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1009 115 in in IN 37158 1009 116 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1009 117 per per IN 37158 1009 118 100,000 100,000 CD 37158 1009 119 inhabitants):-- inhabitants):-- NNP 37158 1009 120 A. a. NN 37158 1010 1 Before before IN 37158 1010 2 the the DT 37158 1010 3 discovery discovery NN 37158 1010 4 of of IN 37158 1010 5 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 1010 6 , , , 37158 1010 7 from from IN 37158 1010 8 1872 1872 CD 37158 1010 9 to to IN 37158 1010 10 1888 1888 CD 37158 1010 11 . . . 37158 1011 1 B. B. NNP 37158 1012 1 During during IN 37158 1012 2 the the DT 37158 1012 3 period period NN 37158 1012 4 of of IN 37158 1012 5 experimentation experimentation NN 37158 1012 6 with with IN 37158 1012 7 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 1012 8 , , , 37158 1012 9 from from IN 37158 1012 10 1889 1889 CD 37158 1012 11 to to IN 37158 1012 12 1894 1894 CD 37158 1012 13 . . . 37158 1013 1 C. C. NNP 37158 1013 2 After after IN 37158 1013 3 the the DT 37158 1013 4 generalisation generalisation NN 37158 1013 5 of of IN 37158 1013 6 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 1013 7 , , , 37158 1013 8 from from IN 37158 1013 9 1895 1895 CD 37158 1013 10 to to IN 37158 1013 11 1905 1905 CD 37158 1013 12 . . . 37158 1014 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 1014 2 have have VBP 37158 1014 3 then then RB 37158 1014 4 the the DT 37158 1014 5 following follow VBG 37158 1014 6 averages:-- averages:-- JJR 37158 1014 7 ABSOLUTE ABSOLUTE NNP 37158 1014 8 . . . 37158 1015 1 PER per IN 37158 1015 2 100,000 100,000 CD 37158 1015 3 INHABITANTS inhabitant NNS 37158 1015 4 . . . 37158 1016 1 Before before IN 37158 1016 2 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 1016 3 1657 1657 CD 37158 1016 4 80 80 CD 37158 1016 5 Intermediary intermediary JJ 37158 1016 6 period period NN 37158 1016 7 1402 1402 CD 37158 1016 8 58 58 CD 37158 1016 9 After after IN 37158 1016 10 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 1016 11 398 398 CD 37158 1016 12 15 15 CD 37158 1016 13 And and CC 37158 1016 14 should should MD 37158 1016 15 these these DT 37158 1016 16 figures figure NNS 37158 1016 17 not not RB 37158 1016 18 seem seem VB 37158 1016 19 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37158 1016 20 eloquent eloquent JJ 37158 1016 21 , , , 37158 1016 22 let let VB 37158 1016 23 us -PRON- PRP 37158 1016 24 set set VB 37158 1016 25 them -PRON- PRP 37158 1016 26 forth forth RB 37158 1016 27 in in IN 37158 1016 28 another another DT 37158 1016 29 form:-- form:-- `` 37158 1016 30 ABSOLUTE ABSOLUTE NNP 37158 1016 31 MORTALITY MORTALITY NNP 37158 1016 32 . . . 37158 1017 1 Before before IN 37158 1017 2 the the DT 37158 1017 3 discovery discovery NN 37158 1017 4 of of IN 37158 1017 5 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 1017 6 , , , 37158 1017 7 1888 1888 CD 37158 1017 8 1729 1729 CD 37158 1017 9 1st 1st NNP 37158 1017 10 year year NN 37158 1017 11 of of IN 37158 1017 12 serotherapy serotherapy NNP 37158 1017 13 , , , 37158 1017 14 1889 1889 CD 37158 1017 15 1706 1706 CD 37158 1017 16 2nd 2nd JJ 37158 1017 17 " " '' 37158 1017 18 " " `` 37158 1017 19 1890 1890 CD 37158 1017 20 1668 1668 CD 37158 1017 21 3rd 3rd NN 37158 1017 22 " " '' 37158 1017 23 " " `` 37158 1017 24 1891 1891 CD 37158 1017 25 1361 1361 CD 37158 1017 26 4th 4th NN 37158 1017 27 " " '' 37158 1017 28 " " `` 37158 1017 29 1892 1892 CD 37158 1017 30 1463 1463 CD 37158 1017 31 5th 5th NN 37158 1017 32 " " '' 37158 1017 33 " " `` 37158 1017 34 1893 1893 CD 37158 1017 35 1266 1266 CD 37158 1017 36 6th 6th JJ 37158 1017 37 " " '' 37158 1017 38 " " `` 37158 1017 39 1894 1894 CD 37158 1017 40 1009 1009 CD 37158 1017 41 At at IN 37158 1017 42 this this DT 37158 1017 43 moment moment NN 37158 1017 44 the the DT 37158 1017 45 practice practice NN 37158 1017 46 of of IN 37158 1017 47 serotherapy serotherapy NN 37158 1017 48 , , , 37158 1017 49 thanks thank NNS 37158 1017 50 to to IN 37158 1017 51 Roux Roux NNP 37158 1017 52 , , , 37158 1017 53 became become VBD 37158 1017 54 general general JJ 37158 1017 55 in in IN 37158 1017 56 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1017 57 . . . 37158 1018 1 1st 1st NNP 37158 1018 2 year year NN 37158 1018 3 , , , 37158 1018 4 1895 1895 CD 37158 1018 5 - - HYPH 37158 1018 6 -435 -435 NNS 37158 1018 7 . . . 37158 1019 1 2nd 2nd JJ 37158 1019 2 " " `` 37158 1019 3 1896 1896 CD 37158 1019 4 - - HYPH 37158 1019 5 -444 -444 NN 37158 1019 6 . . . 37158 1020 1 During during IN 37158 1020 2 the the DT 37158 1020 3 next next JJ 37158 1020 4 six six CD 37158 1020 5 years year NNS 37158 1020 6 there there EX 37158 1020 7 were be VBD 37158 1020 8 still still RB 37158 1020 9 hesitations hesitation NNS 37158 1020 10 and and CC 37158 1020 11 uncertainties uncertainty NNS 37158 1020 12 as as IN 37158 1020 13 to to IN 37158 1020 14 the the DT 37158 1020 15 best good JJS 37158 1020 16 method method NN 37158 1020 17 to to TO 37158 1020 18 be be VB 37158 1020 19 employed employ VBN 37158 1020 20 . . . 37158 1021 1 The the DT 37158 1021 2 mortality mortality NN 37158 1021 3 during during IN 37158 1021 4 these these DT 37158 1021 5 six six CD 37158 1021 6 years year NNS 37158 1021 7 , , , 37158 1021 8 1897 1897 CD 37158 1021 9 - - SYM 37158 1021 10 1902 1902 CD 37158 1021 11 - - HYPH 37158 1021 12 -439 -439 NN 37158 1021 13 . . . 37158 1022 1 Then then RB 37158 1022 2 the the DT 37158 1022 3 practice practice NN 37158 1022 4 was be VBD 37158 1022 5 definitely definitely RB 37158 1022 6 established establish VBN 37158 1022 7 . . . 37158 1023 1 The the DT 37158 1023 2 mortality mortality NN 37158 1023 3 for for IN 37158 1023 4 the the DT 37158 1023 5 three three CD 37158 1023 6 years year NNS 37158 1023 7 , , , 37158 1023 8 1903 1903 CD 37158 1023 9 - - SYM 37158 1023 10 1905 1905 CD 37158 1023 11 - - HYPH 37158 1023 12 -288 -288 NN 37158 1023 13 . . . 37158 1024 1 These these DT 37158 1024 2 figures figure NNS 37158 1024 3 are be VBP 37158 1024 4 so so RB 37158 1024 5 eloquent eloquent JJ 37158 1024 6 , , , 37158 1024 7 so so RB 37158 1024 8 striking striking JJ 37158 1024 9 , , , 37158 1024 10 so so RB 37158 1024 11 precise precise JJ 37158 1024 12 , , , 37158 1024 13 that that IN 37158 1024 14 it -PRON- PRP 37158 1024 15 is be VBZ 37158 1024 16 not not RB 37158 1024 17 possible possible JJ 37158 1024 18 to to TO 37158 1024 19 misunderstand misunderstand VB 37158 1024 20 them -PRON- PRP 37158 1024 21 . . . 37158 1025 1 They -PRON- PRP 37158 1025 2 can can MD 37158 1025 3 not not RB 37158 1025 4 be be VB 37158 1025 5 ignored ignore VBN 37158 1025 6 ; ; : 37158 1025 7 and and CC 37158 1025 8 when when WRB 37158 1025 9 once once IN 37158 1025 10 they -PRON- PRP 37158 1025 11 have have VBP 37158 1025 12 been be VBN 37158 1025 13 set set VBN 37158 1025 14 forth forth RP 37158 1025 15 , , , 37158 1025 16 ignorance ignorance NN 37158 1025 17 is be VBZ 37158 1025 18 no no DT 37158 1025 19 longer long RBR 37158 1025 20 permissible permissible JJ 37158 1025 21 , , , 37158 1025 22 and and CC 37158 1025 23 it -PRON- PRP 37158 1025 24 is be VBZ 37158 1025 25 for for IN 37158 1025 26 that that DT 37158 1025 27 reason reason NN 37158 1025 28 we -PRON- PRP 37158 1025 29 have have VBP 37158 1025 30 here here RB 37158 1025 31 given give VBN 37158 1025 32 them -PRON- PRP 37158 1025 33 . . . 37158 1026 1 In in IN 37158 1026 2 Berlin Berlin NNP 37158 1026 3 and and CC 37158 1026 4 in in IN 37158 1026 5 Vienna Vienna NNP 37158 1026 6 , , , 37158 1026 7 it -PRON- PRP 37158 1026 8 is be VBZ 37158 1026 9 the the DT 37158 1026 10 same same JJ 37158 1026 11 thing thing NN 37158 1026 12 . . . 37158 1027 1 From from IN 37158 1027 2 1894 1894 CD 37158 1027 3 the the DT 37158 1027 4 mortality mortality NN 37158 1027 5 due due IN 37158 1027 6 to to IN 37158 1027 7 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 1027 8 has have VBZ 37158 1027 9 diminished diminish VBN 37158 1027 10 to to IN 37158 1027 11 the the DT 37158 1027 12 extent extent NN 37158 1027 13 of of IN 37158 1027 14 150 150 CD 37158 1027 15 per per NN 37158 1027 16 cent cent NN 37158 1027 17 . . . 37158 1028 1 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 37158 1028 2 B B NNP 37158 1028 3 BIBLIOGRAPHY BIBLIOGRAPHY NNP 37158 1028 4 Adams Adams NNP 37158 1028 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1028 6 C. C. NNP 37158 1028 7 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1028 8 . . . 37158 1029 1 HUNTER HUNTER NNP 37158 1029 2 AND and CC 37158 1029 3 THE the DT 37158 1029 4 STAG STAG NNP 37158 1029 5 . . . 37158 1030 1 _ _ NNP 37158 1030 2 A a DT 37158 1030 3 reply reply NN 37158 1030 4 to to IN 37158 1030 5 Prof. Prof. NNP 37158 1030 6 Owen Owen NNP 37158 1030 7 . . . 37158 1030 8 _ _ NNP 37158 1030 9 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1030 10 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1030 11 , , , 37158 1030 12 London London NNP 37158 1030 13 , , , 37158 1030 14 1881 1881 CD 37158 1030 15 . . . 37158 1030 16 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1031 1 Adler Adler NNP 37158 1031 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1031 3 H. H. NNP 37158 1031 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1031 5 . . . 37158 1032 1 ZUR ZUR NNP 37158 1032 2 FRAGE FRAGE NNP 37158 1032 3 DER DER NNP 37158 1032 4 V. V. NNP 37158 1032 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1032 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1032 7 Wien Wien NNP 37158 1032 8 med med NNP 37158 1032 9 . . . 37158 1033 1 Woch Woch NNP 37158 1033 2 . . . 37158 1033 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1033 4 , , , 37158 1033 5 1879 1879 CD 37158 1033 6 , , , 37158 1033 7 1161 1161 CD 37158 1033 8 , , , 37158 1033 9 1211 1211 CD 37158 1033 10 , , , 37158 1033 11 1241 1241 CD 37158 1033 12 . . . 37158 1033 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1034 1 Anstie Anstie NNP 37158 1034 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1034 3 F. F. NNP 37158 1034 4 E. E. NNP 37158 1034 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1034 6 THE the DT 37158 1034 7 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1034 8 CONTROVERSY CONTROVERSY NNP 37158 1034 9 . . . 37158 1035 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1035 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1035 3 Practitioner Practitioner NNP 37158 1035 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1035 5 , , , 37158 1035 6 1874 1874 CD 37158 1035 7 , , , 37158 1035 8 38 38 CD 37158 1035 9 and and CC 37158 1035 10 321 321 CD 37158 1035 11 . . . 37158 1035 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1036 1 Apinus Apinus NNP 37158 1036 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1036 3 S. S. NNP 37158 1037 1 J. J. NNP 37158 1037 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1037 3 . . . 37158 1038 1 DISS DISS NNP 37158 1038 2 . . . 37158 1039 1 EX EX NNP 37158 1039 2 JURE JURE NNP 37158 1039 3 NATURAE NATURAE NNP 37158 1039 4 : : : 37158 1039 5 AN an DT 37158 1039 6 LICEAT liceat NN 37158 1039 7 BRUTORUM brutorum NN 37158 1039 8 CORPORA corpora NN 37158 1039 9 MUTILARE MUTILARE NNP 37158 1039 10 ET et NN 37158 1039 11 SPECIATIM SPECIATIM NNP 37158 1039 12 OB OB NNP 37158 1039 13 ES es NN 37158 1039 14 RECHT RECHT NNP 37158 1039 15 SEY SEY NNP 37158 1039 16 DASS DASS NNP 37158 1039 17 MAN MAN NNP 37158 1039 18 DEN DEN NNP 37158 1039 19 HUNDEN HUNDEN NNP 37158 1039 20 DIE DIE NNP 37158 1039 21 OHREN OHREN NNP 37158 1039 22 ABSCHNEIDE ABSCHNEIDE NNP 37158 1039 23 , , , 37158 1039 24 VARIIS variis RB 37158 1039 25 OBSERVATIONIBUS observationibu VBD 37158 1039 26 AUCTA AUCTA NNP 37158 1039 27 . . . 37158 1040 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1040 2 Altorphii Altorphii NNP 37158 1040 3 Noricorum Noricorum NNP 37158 1040 4 , , , 37158 1040 5 1722 1722 CD 37158 1040 6 . . . 37158 1040 7 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1041 1 Basch Basch NNP 37158 1041 2 ZUR ZUR NNP 37158 1041 3 V. V. NNP 37158 1041 4 FRAGE frage NN 37158 1041 5 . . . 37158 1042 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1042 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1042 3 Wien Wien NNP 37158 1042 4 med med NNP 37158 1042 5 . . . 37158 1043 1 Blätter Blätter NNP 37158 1043 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1043 3 , , , 37158 1043 4 1879 1879 CD 37158 1043 5 , , , 37158 1043 6 2 2 CD 37158 1043 7 , , , 37158 1043 8 73 73 CD 37158 1043 9 . . . 37158 1043 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1044 1 Beck Beck NNP 37158 1044 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1044 3 J. J. NNP 37158 1044 4 M. M. NNP 37158 1044 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1044 6 . . . 37158 1045 1 THE the DT 37158 1045 2 LEGAL LEGAL NNP 37158 1045 3 ASPECTS ASPECTS NNP 37158 1045 4 OF of IN 37158 1045 5 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1045 6 . . . 37158 1046 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1046 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1046 3 Medical Medical NNP 37158 1046 4 News News NNP 37158 1046 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1046 6 , , , 37158 1046 7 1890 1890 CD 37158 1046 8 , , , 37158 1046 9 pp pp NNP 37158 1046 10 . . . 37158 1047 1 280 280 CD 37158 1047 2 - - SYM 37158 1047 3 282 282 CD 37158 1047 4 . . . 37158 1047 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1048 1 Bedtnitz Bedtnitz NNP 37158 1048 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1048 3 A. A. NNP 37158 1048 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1048 5 . . . 37158 1049 1 DIE DIE NNP 37158 1049 2 V. V. NNP 37158 1049 3 GAUKLER GAUKLER NNP 37158 1049 4 . . . 37158 1050 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1050 2 Wien Wien NNP 37158 1050 3 , , , 37158 1050 4 8vo 8vo NN 37158 1050 5 , , , 37158 1050 6 1883 1883 CD 37158 1050 7 . . . 37158 1050 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1051 1 Berdoe Berdoe NNP 37158 1051 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1051 3 E. E. NNP 37158 1051 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1051 5 . . . 37158 1052 1 THE the DT 37158 1052 2 FUTILITY FUTILITY NNP 37158 1052 3 OF of IN 37158 1052 4 EXPERIMENTS experiment NNS 37158 1052 5 WITH with IN 37158 1052 6 DRUGS drugs NN 37158 1052 7 ON on NN 37158 1052 8 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1052 9 . . . 37158 1053 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1053 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1053 3 , , , 37158 1053 4 London London NNP 37158 1053 5 , , , 37158 1053 6 1889 1889 CD 37158 1053 7 . . . 37158 1053 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1054 1 ---- ---- NFP 37158 1054 2 THE the DT 37158 1054 3 HEALING HEALING NNP 37158 1054 4 ART ART NNP 37158 1054 5 AND and CC 37158 1054 6 THE the DT 37158 1054 7 CLAIMS claim NNS 37158 1054 8 OF of IN 37158 1054 9 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1054 10 . . . 37158 1055 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1055 2 12mo 12mo JJ 37158 1055 3 , , , 37158 1055 4 London London NNP 37158 1055 5 , , , 37158 1055 6 1890 1890 CD 37158 1055 7 . . . 37158 1055 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1056 1 A a DT 37158 1056 2 TRIUMPH TRIUMPH NNP 37158 1056 3 OF of IN 37158 1056 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1056 5 . . . 37158 1057 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1057 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1057 3 , , , 37158 1057 4 London London NNP 37158 1057 5 , , , 37158 1057 6 1890 1890 CD 37158 1057 7 . . . 37158 1057 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1058 1 Bernard Bernard NNP 37158 1058 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1058 3 Claude Claude NNP 37158 1058 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1058 5 . . . 37158 1059 1 LES LES NNP 37158 1059 2 VIVISECTIONS VIVISECTIONS NNP 37158 1059 3 . . . 37158 1060 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1060 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1060 3 Union Union NNP 37158 1060 4 médicale médicale NN 37158 1060 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1060 6 , , , 37158 1060 7 1865 1865 CD 37158 1060 8 , , , 37158 1060 9 305 305 CD 37158 1060 10 - - SYM 37158 1060 11 310 310 CD 37158 1060 12 _ _ NNP 37158 1060 13 et et NNP 37158 1060 14 Revue Revue NNP 37158 1060 15 Scientifique Scientifique NNP 37158 1060 16 _ _ NNP 37158 1060 17 , , , 37158 1060 18 1878 1878 CD 37158 1060 19 , , , 37158 1060 20 799 799 CD 37158 1060 21 - - HYPH 37158 1060 22 802 802 CD 37158 1060 23 . . . 37158 1060 24 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1061 1 Bigelow Bigelow NNP 37158 1061 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1061 3 H. H. NNP 37158 1061 4 R. R. NNP 37158 1061 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1061 6 . . . 37158 1062 1 THE the DT 37158 1062 2 PRACTICAL PRACTICAL NNP 37158 1062 3 UTILITY UTILITY NNP 37158 1062 4 OF of IN 37158 1062 5 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1062 6 . . . 37158 1063 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1063 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1063 3 Maryland Maryland NNP 37158 1063 4 Med Med NNP 37158 1063 5 . . . 37158 1064 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1064 2 . . . 37158 1064 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1064 4 , , , 37158 1064 5 1880 1880 CD 37158 1064 6 , , , 37158 1064 7 246 246 CD 37158 1064 8 - - SYM 37158 1064 9 249 249 CD 37158 1064 10 . . . 37158 1064 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1065 1 Bowditch Bowditch NNP 37158 1065 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1065 3 H. H. NNP 37158 1065 4 P. P. NNP 37158 1065 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1065 6 . . . 37158 1066 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1066 2 JUSTIFIABLE JUSTIFIABLE NNP 37158 1066 3 . . . 37158 1067 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1067 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1067 3 Sanitar Sanitar NNP 37158 1067 4 . . . 37158 1068 1 New New NNP 37158 1068 2 York York NNP 37158 1068 3 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1068 4 . . . 37158 1068 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1068 6 , , , 37158 1068 7 1896 1896 CD 37158 1068 8 , , , 37158 1068 9 229 229 CD 37158 1068 10 - - SYM 37158 1068 11 243 243 CD 37158 1068 12 . . . 37158 1068 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1069 1 Bos Bos NNP 37158 1069 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1069 3 A. A. NNP 37158 1069 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1069 5 . . . 37158 1070 1 SULLE SULLE NNP 37158 1070 2 V. V. NNP 37158 1070 3 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1070 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1070 5 Imparziale Imparziale NNP 37158 1070 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1070 7 , , , 37158 1070 8 1874 1874 CD 37158 1070 9 , , , 37158 1070 10 225 225 CD 37158 1070 11 - - SYM 37158 1070 12 231 231 CD 37158 1070 13 . . . 37158 1070 14 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1071 1 Brown Brown NNP 37158 1071 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1071 3 J. J. NNP 37158 1071 4 M. M. NNP 37158 1071 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1071 6 . . . 37158 1072 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1072 2 , , , 37158 1072 3 A a DT 37158 1072 4 REPLY reply NN 37158 1072 5 TO to IN 37158 1072 6 DR DR NNP 37158 1072 7 KEEN KEEN NNP 37158 1072 8 . . . 37158 1073 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1073 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1073 3 J. J. NNP 37158 1074 1 Am Am NNP 37158 1074 2 . . . 37158 1075 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1075 2 . . . 37158 1076 1 Ass Ass NNP 37158 1076 2 . . . 37158 1076 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1076 4 , , , 37158 1076 5 1901 1901 CD 37158 1076 6 , , , 37158 1076 7 592 592 CD 37158 1076 8 . . . 37158 1076 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1077 1 Bryan Bryan NNP 37158 1077 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1077 3 B. B. NNP 37158 1077 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1077 5 . . . 37158 1078 1 THE the DT 37158 1078 2 BRITISH BRITISH NNP 37158 1078 3 VIVISECTOR VIVISECTOR NNP 37158 1078 4 'S 's POS 37158 1078 5 DIRECTORY DIRECTORY NNP 37158 1078 6 , , , 37158 1078 7 A a DT 37158 1078 8 BLACK BLACK NNP 37158 1078 9 BOOK BOOK NNS 37158 1078 10 FOR for IN 37158 1078 11 THE the DT 37158 1078 12 UNITED UNITED NNP 37158 1078 13 KINGDOM KINGDOM NNP 37158 1078 14 . . . 37158 1079 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1079 2 12mo 12mo JJ 37158 1079 3 , , , 37158 1079 4 London London NNP 37158 1079 5 , , , 37158 1079 6 1890 1890 CD 37158 1079 7 . . . 37158 1079 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1080 1 Burt Burt NNP 37158 1080 2 . . . 37158 1081 1 THE the DT 37158 1081 2 ETHICS ethic NNS 37158 1081 3 OF of IN 37158 1081 4 EXPERIMENTATION experimentation NN 37158 1081 5 UPON upon IN 37158 1081 6 LIVING live VBG 37158 1081 7 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1081 8 . . . 37158 1082 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1082 2 Post post JJ 37158 1082 3 - - JJ 37158 1082 4 graduate graduate JJ 37158 1082 5 , , , 37158 1082 6 1890 1890 CD 37158 1082 7 , , , 37158 1082 8 53 53 CD 37158 1082 9 - - SYM 37158 1082 10 55 55 CD 37158 1082 11 . . . 37158 1082 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1083 1 Carpenter Carpenter NNP 37158 1083 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1083 3 W. W. NNP 37158 1084 1 B. B. NNP 37158 1084 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1084 3 . . . 37158 1085 1 THE the DT 37158 1085 2 ETHICS ethic NNS 37158 1085 3 OF of IN 37158 1085 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1085 5 . . . 37158 1086 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1086 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1086 3 Fortnightly Fortnightly NNP 37158 1086 4 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1086 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1086 6 , , , 37158 1086 7 1882 1882 CD 37158 1086 8 , , , 37158 1086 9 237 237 CD 37158 1086 10 - - SYM 37158 1086 11 246 246 CD 37158 1086 12 . . . 37158 1086 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1087 1 Cejon Cejon NNP 37158 1087 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1087 3 E. E. NNP 37158 1087 4 de de NNP 37158 1087 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1087 6 . . . 37158 1088 1 THE the DT 37158 1088 2 ANTI anti JJ 37158 1088 3 - - HYPH 37158 1088 4 VIVISECTIONIST vivisectionist JJ 37158 1088 5 AGITATION agitation NN 37158 1088 6 . . . 37158 1089 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1089 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1089 3 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 37158 1089 4 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1089 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1089 6 , , , 37158 1089 7 1883 1883 CD 37158 1089 8 , , , 37158 1089 9 498 498 CD 37158 1089 10 - - SYM 37158 1089 11 910 910 CD 37158 1089 12 . . . 37158 1089 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1090 1 Coats coat NNS 37158 1090 2 . . . 37158 1091 1 ON ON NNP 37158 1091 2 LUDWIG LUDWIG NNP 37158 1091 3 AND and CC 37158 1091 4 PASTEUR PASTEUR NNP 37158 1091 5 , , , 37158 1091 6 AND and CC 37158 1091 7 ON on IN 37158 1091 8 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1091 9 . . . 37158 1092 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1092 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1092 3 Glasg Glasg NNP 37158 1092 4 . . . 37158 1093 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1093 2 . . . 37158 1094 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1094 2 . . . 37158 1094 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1094 4 , , , 37158 1094 5 1895 1895 CD 37158 1094 6 , , , 37158 1094 7 330 330 CD 37158 1094 8 - - SYM 37158 1094 9 335 335 CD 37158 1094 10 . . . 37158 1094 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1095 1 Cobbe Cobbe NNP 37158 1095 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1095 3 Fr Fr NNP 37158 1095 4 . . . 37158 1096 1 P. P. NNP 37158 1096 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1096 3 . . . 37158 1097 1 ILLUSTRATIONS illustrations JJ 37158 1097 2 OF of IN 37158 1097 3 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1097 4 . . . 37158 1098 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1098 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1098 3 , , , 37158 1098 4 Philadelphia Philadelphia NNP 37158 1098 5 , , , 37158 1098 6 1887 1887 CD 37158 1098 7 . . . 37158 1098 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1099 1 Cobbe Cobbe NNP 37158 1099 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1099 3 Fr Fr NNP 37158 1099 4 . . . 37158 1099 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1099 6 . . . 37158 1100 1 THE the DT 37158 1100 2 MODERN MODERN NNS 37158 1100 3 RACK RACK NNS 37158 1100 4 ; ; : 37158 1100 5 PAPERS paper NNS 37158 1100 6 ON on IN 37158 1100 7 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1100 8 . . . 37158 1101 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1101 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1101 3 , , , 37158 1101 4 London London NNP 37158 1101 5 , , , 37158 1101 6 1889 1889 CD 37158 1101 7 . . . 37158 1101 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1102 1 Cobbe Cobbe NNP 37158 1102 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1102 3 Fr Fr NNP 37158 1102 4 . . . 37158 1103 1 P. P. NNP 37158 1103 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1103 3 . . . 37158 1104 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1104 2 ; ; : 37158 1104 3 FOUR four CD 37158 1104 4 REPLIES reply NNS 37158 1104 5 . . . 37158 1105 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1105 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1105 3 Fortnightly Fortnightly NNP 37158 1105 4 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1105 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1105 6 , , , 37158 1105 7 1882 1882 CD 37158 1105 8 , , , 37158 1105 9 88 88 CD 37158 1105 10 - - SYM 37158 1105 11 104 104 CD 37158 1105 12 , , , 37158 1105 13 and and CC 37158 1105 14 _ _ NNP 37158 1105 15 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 37158 1105 16 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1105 17 _ _ NNP 37158 1105 18 , , , 37158 1105 19 1882 1882 CD 37158 1105 20 , , , 37158 1105 21 610 610 CD 37158 1105 22 - - SYM 37158 1105 23 626 626 CD 37158 1105 24 . . . 37158 1105 25 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1106 1 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 37158 1106 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1106 3 Lord Lord NNP 37158 1106 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1106 5 . . . 37158 1107 1 THE the DT 37158 1107 2 NINETEENTH NINETEENTH NNP 37158 1107 3 CENTURY century NN 37158 1107 4 DEFENDERS defender NNS 37158 1107 5 OF of IN 37158 1107 6 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1107 7 . . . 37158 1108 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1108 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1108 3 Fortnightly Fortnightly NNP 37158 1108 4 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1108 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1108 6 , , , 37158 1108 7 1882 1882 CD 37158 1108 8 , , , 37158 1108 9 225 225 CD 37158 1108 10 - - SYM 37158 1108 11 236 236 CD 37158 1108 12 . . . 37158 1108 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1109 1 Dalton Dalton NNP 37158 1109 2 . . . 37158 1110 1 EXPERIMENTATION experimentation NN 37158 1110 2 ON on IN 37158 1110 3 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1110 4 . . . 37158 1111 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1111 2 12mo 12mo JJ 37158 1111 3 , , , 37158 1111 4 New New NNP 37158 1111 5 York York NNP 37158 1111 6 , , , 37158 1111 7 1875 1875 CD 37158 1111 8 . . . 37158 1111 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1112 1 Dalton Dalton NNP 37158 1112 2 . . . 37158 1113 1 MAGENDIE MAGENDIE NNP 37158 1113 2 AS as IN 37158 1113 3 A a DT 37158 1113 4 PHYSIOLOGIST PHYSIOLOGIST NNP 37158 1113 5 . . . 37158 1114 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1114 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1114 3 Internat Internat NNP 37158 1114 4 . . . 37158 1115 1 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1115 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1115 3 , , , 37158 1115 4 1880 1880 CD 37158 1115 5 , , , 37158 1115 6 120 120 CD 37158 1115 7 - - SYM 37158 1115 8 129 129 CD 37158 1115 9 . . . 37158 1115 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1116 1 Dalton Dalton NNP 37158 1116 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1116 3 J. J. NNP 37158 1117 1 C C NNP 37158 1117 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1117 3 . . . 37158 1118 1 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1118 2 : : : 37158 1118 3 WHAT what WP 37158 1118 4 IT it PRP 37158 1118 5 IS be VBZ 37158 1118 6 AND and CC 37158 1118 7 WHAT what WP 37158 1118 8 IT it PRP 37158 1118 9 HAS have VBZ 37158 1118 10 ACCOMPLISHED accomplished JJ 37158 1118 11 . . . 37158 1119 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1119 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1119 3 Bull Bull NNP 37158 1119 4 . . . 37158 1120 1 B. B. NNP 37158 1120 2 York York NNP 37158 1120 3 Acad Acad NNP 37158 1120 4 . . . 37158 1121 1 med med NNP 37158 1121 2 . . . 37158 1121 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1121 4 , , , 37158 1121 5 1866 1866 CD 37158 1121 6 , , , 37158 1121 7 159 159 CD 37158 1121 8 - - SYM 37158 1121 9 198 198 CD 37158 1121 10 . . . 37158 1121 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1122 1 Darwin Darwin NNP 37158 1122 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1122 3 Ch Ch NNP 37158 1122 4 . . . 37158 1122 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1122 6 . . . 37158 1123 1 VIEWS VIEWS NNP 37158 1123 2 ON ON NNP 37158 1123 3 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1123 4 . . . 37158 1124 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1124 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1124 3 Pop Pop NNP 37158 1124 4 . . . 37158 1125 1 Sc sc RB 37158 1125 2 . . . 37158 1126 1 Monthly Monthly NNP 37158 1126 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1126 3 , , , 37158 1126 4 1881 1881 CD 37158 1126 5 , , , 37158 1126 6 424 424 CD 37158 1126 7 ; ; : 37158 1126 8 et et NN 37158 1126 9 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1127 1 Scient Scient NNP 37158 1127 2 . . . 37158 1127 3 , , , 37158 1127 4 1881 1881 CD 37158 1127 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1127 6 1 1 CD 37158 1127 7 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1127 8 , , , 37158 1127 9 731 731 CD 37158 1127 10 . . . 37158 1127 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1128 1 Davis Davis NNP 37158 1128 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1128 3 N. N. NNP 37158 1129 1 B. B. NNP 37158 1129 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1129 3 . . . 37158 1130 1 THE the DT 37158 1130 2 MORAL moral JJ 37158 1130 3 ASPECTS aspect NNS 37158 1130 4 OF of IN 37158 1130 5 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1130 6 . . . 37158 1131 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1131 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1131 3 North North NNP 37158 1131 4 Americ Americ NNP 37158 1131 5 . . . 37158 1132 1 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1132 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1132 3 , , , 37158 1132 4 1885 1885 CD 37158 1132 5 , , , 37158 1132 6 203 203 CD 37158 1132 7 - - SYM 37158 1132 8 220 220 CD 37158 1132 9 . . . 37158 1132 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1133 1 Delolm Delolm NNP 37158 1133 2 de de NNP 37158 1133 3 Lalaubie Lalaubie NNP 37158 1133 4 . . . 37158 1134 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1134 2 , , , 37158 1134 3 DISS DISS NNP 37158 1134 4 . . . 37158 1135 1 IN in IN 37158 1135 2 . . . 37158 1136 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1136 2 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1136 3 , , , 37158 1136 4 1868 1868 CD 37158 1136 5 . . . 37158 1136 6 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1137 1 Deswattines deswattine NNS 37158 1137 2 . . . 37158 1138 1 SUGGESTIF SUGGESTIF NNP 37158 1138 2 PETIT PETIT NNP 37158 1138 3 TABLEAU TABLEAU NNP 37158 1138 4 DE DE NNP 37158 1138 5 LA LA NNP 37158 1138 6 CRUELLE CRUELLE NNP 37158 1138 7 ET ET NNP 37158 1138 8 INUTILÉ inutilé NN 37158 1138 9 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1138 10 . . . 37158 1139 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1139 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1139 3 Médecin Médecin NNP 37158 1139 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1139 5 , , , 37158 1139 6 1904 1904 CD 37158 1139 7 , , , 37158 1139 8 35 35 CD 37158 1139 9 . . . 37158 1139 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1140 1 Ferguson Ferguson NNP 37158 1140 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1140 3 Sir Sir NNP 37158 1140 4 W. W. NNP 37158 1140 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1140 6 . . . 37158 1141 1 OPINIONS opinions NN 37158 1141 2 OF of IN 37158 1141 3 EMINENT EMINENT NNP 37158 1141 4 SURGEONS surgeon NNS 37158 1141 5 , , , 37158 1141 6 PHYSIOLOGISTS physiologist NNS 37158 1141 7 AND and CC 37158 1141 8 OTHERS other NNS 37158 1141 9 , , , 37158 1141 10 AS as IN 37158 1141 11 TO to IN 37158 1141 12 THE the DT 37158 1141 13 FOLLY FOLLY NNP 37158 1141 14 AND and CC 37158 1141 15 MISLEADING MISLEADING NNP 37158 1141 16 AND and CC 37158 1141 17 DEMORALISING demoralising NN 37158 1141 18 RESULTS results NN 37158 1141 19 OF of IN 37158 1141 20 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1141 21 . . . 37158 1142 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1142 2 London London NNP 37158 1142 3 , , , 37158 1142 4 1880 1880 CD 37158 1142 5 . . . 37158 1142 6 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1143 1 Fletcher Fletcher NNP 37158 1143 2 . . . 37158 1144 1 A a DT 37158 1144 2 FEW FEW NNP 37158 1144 3 NOTES note NNS 37158 1144 4 ON on IN 37158 1144 5 CRUELTY CRUELTY NNS 37158 1144 6 TO to IN 37158 1144 7 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1144 8 , , , 37158 1144 9 ON on IN 37158 1144 10 THE the DT 37158 1144 11 INADEQUACY INADEQUACY NNP 37158 1144 12 OF of IN 37158 1144 13 PENAL PENAL NNP 37158 1144 14 LAW law NN 37158 1144 15 . . . 37158 1145 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1145 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1145 3 , , , 37158 1145 4 London London NNP 37158 1145 5 , , , 37158 1145 6 1846 1846 CD 37158 1145 7 . . . 37158 1145 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1146 1 Foreau Foreau NNP 37158 1146 2 de de NNP 37158 1146 3 Courmelles Courmelles NNP 37158 1146 4 . . . 37158 1147 1 ESSAI ESSAI NNP 37158 1147 2 DE DE NNP 37158 1147 3 LIMITATION LIMITATION NNP 37158 1147 4 SCIENTIFIQUE SCIENTIFIQUE NNP 37158 1147 5 DE DE NNP 37158 1147 6 LA LA NNP 37158 1147 7 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1147 8 . . . 37158 1148 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1148 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1148 3 Revue Revue NNP 37158 1148 4 méd méd NNP 37158 1148 5 . . . 37158 1148 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1148 7 , , , 37158 1148 8 1902 1902 CD 37158 1148 9 , , , 37158 1148 10 481 481 CD 37158 1148 11 - - SYM 37158 1148 12 484 484 CD 37158 1148 13 . . . 37158 1148 14 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1149 1 Foster Foster NNP 37158 1149 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1149 3 M. M. NNP 37158 1149 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1149 5 . . . 37158 1150 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1150 2 . . . 37158 1151 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1151 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1151 3 Pop Pop NNP 37158 1151 4 . . . 37158 1152 1 Sc sc RB 37158 1152 2 . . . 37158 1153 1 Monthly Monthly NNP 37158 1153 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1153 3 , , , 37158 1153 4 1873 1873 CD 37158 1153 5 , , , 37158 1153 6 pp pp NNP 37158 1153 7 . . . 37158 1154 1 672 672 CD 37158 1154 2 - - SYM 37158 1154 3 685 685 CD 37158 1154 4 . . . 37158 1154 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1155 1 Gamgee Gamgee NNP 37158 1155 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1155 3 S. S. NNP 37158 1155 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1155 5 . . . 37158 1156 1 ON ON NNP 37158 1156 2 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1156 3 AND and CC 37158 1156 4 SCIENTIFIC SCIENTIFIC NNP 37158 1156 5 SURGERY SURGERY NNP 37158 1156 6 . . . 37158 1157 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1157 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1157 3 Brit Brit NNP 37158 1157 4 . . . 37158 1158 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1158 2 . . . 37158 1159 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1159 2 . . . 37158 1159 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1159 4 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1159 5 2 2 CD 37158 1159 6 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1159 7 , , , 37158 1159 8 1876 1876 CD 37158 1159 9 , , , 37158 1159 10 104 104 CD 37158 1159 11 . . . 37158 1159 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1160 1 Gützlaw Gützlaw NNP 37158 1160 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1160 3 V. V. NNP 37158 1160 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1160 5 . . . 37158 1161 1 SCHOPENHAUER SCHOPENHAUER NNP 37158 1161 2 ÜBER ÜBER VBD 37158 1161 3 DIE die NN 37158 1161 4 THIERE THIERE NNS 37158 1161 5 UND UND NNP 37158 1161 6 DER DER NNP 37158 1161 7 THIERSCHUTZ THIERSCHUTZ NNP 37158 1161 8 . . . 37158 1162 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1162 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1162 3 , , , 37158 1162 4 Berlin Berlin NNP 37158 1162 5 , , , 37158 1162 6 1879 1879 CD 37158 1162 7 . . . 37158 1162 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1163 1 Harnack Harnack NNP 37158 1163 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1163 3 E. E. NNP 37158 1163 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1163 5 . . . 37158 1164 1 WIDER WIDER NNP 37158 1164 2 DIE die VBP 37158 1164 3 V.-GEGNER v.-gegner NN 37158 1164 4 . . . 37158 1165 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1165 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1165 3 D. D. NNP 37158 1166 1 med med JJ 37158 1166 2 . . . 37158 1167 1 Woch Woch NNP 37158 1167 2 . . . 37158 1167 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1167 4 , , , 37158 1167 5 1905 1905 CD 37158 1167 6 , , , 37158 1167 7 1115 1115 CD 37158 1167 8 - - SYM 37158 1167 9 1116 1116 CD 37158 1167 10 . . . 37158 1167 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1168 1 Harvey harvey NN 37158 1168 2 . . . 37158 1169 1 THE the DT 37158 1169 2 PASTEUR PASTEUR NNP 37158 1169 3 INSTITUTE INSTITUTE NNP 37158 1169 4 AND and CC 37158 1169 5 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1169 6 . . . 37158 1170 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1170 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1170 3 Ind Ind NNP 37158 1170 4 . . . 37158 1171 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1171 2 . . . 37158 1172 1 Gaz Gaz NNP 37158 1172 2 . . . 37158 1172 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1172 4 , , , 37158 1172 5 1895 1895 CD 37158 1172 6 , , , 37158 1172 7 49 49 CD 37158 1172 8 - - SYM 37158 1172 9 57 57 CD 37158 1172 10 . . . 37158 1172 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1173 1 Hehir Hehir NNP 37158 1173 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1173 3 P. P. NNP 37158 1173 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1173 5 . . . 37158 1174 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1174 2 SO SO NNP 37158 1174 3 CALLED call VBN 37158 1174 4 , , , 37158 1174 5 ITS its PRP$ 37158 1174 6 ROLE role NN 37158 1174 7 IN in IN 37158 1174 8 THE the DT 37158 1174 9 SERVICE SERVICE NNP 37158 1174 10 OF of IN 37158 1174 11 MAN MAN NNP 37158 1174 12 AND and CC 37158 1174 13 BEAST BEAST NNP 37158 1174 14 . . . 37158 1175 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1175 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1175 3 Ind Ind NNP 37158 1175 4 . . . 37158 1176 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1176 2 . . . 37158 1177 1 Gaz Gaz NNP 37158 1177 2 . . . 37158 1177 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1177 4 , , , 37158 1177 5 1897 1897 CD 37158 1177 6 , , , 37158 1177 7 91 91 CD 37158 1177 8 . . . 37158 1177 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1178 1 Heidenhain Heidenhain NNP 37158 1178 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1178 3 R. R. NNP 37158 1178 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1178 5 . . . 37158 1179 1 DIE DIE NNP 37158 1179 2 V. V. NNP 37158 1179 3 IM IM NNP 37158 1179 4 DIENSTE DIENSTE NNP 37158 1179 5 DER DER NNP 37158 1179 6 HEILKUNDE HEILKUNDE NNS 37158 1179 7 . . . 37158 1180 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1180 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1180 3 , , , 37158 1180 4 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 37158 1180 5 , , , 37158 1180 6 1879 1879 CD 37158 1180 7 . . . 37158 1180 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1181 1 Hermann Hermann NNP 37158 1181 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1181 3 L. L. NNP 37158 1181 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1181 5 . . . 37158 1182 1 DIE DIE NNP 37158 1182 2 V. V. NNP 37158 1182 3 FRAGE frage NN 37158 1182 4 . . . 37158 1183 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1183 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1183 3 , , , 37158 1183 4 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 37158 1183 5 , , , 37158 1183 6 1877 1877 CD 37158 1183 7 . . . 37158 1183 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1184 1 Hodge hodge UH 37158 1184 2 . . . 37158 1185 1 THE the DT 37158 1185 2 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1185 3 QUESTION QUESTION VBD 37158 1185 4 . . . 37158 1186 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1186 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1186 3 Pop Pop NNP 37158 1186 4 . . . 37158 1187 1 Sc sc RB 37158 1187 2 . . . 37158 1188 1 Monthly Monthly NNP 37158 1188 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1188 3 , , , 37158 1188 4 1896 1896 CD 37158 1188 5 , , , 37158 1188 6 614 614 CD 37158 1188 7 - - SYM 37158 1188 8 630 630 CD 37158 1188 9 , , , 37158 1188 10 771 771 CD 37158 1188 11 - - SYM 37158 1188 12 786 786 CD 37158 1188 13 . . . 37158 1188 14 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1189 1 Horsley Horsley NNP 37158 1189 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1189 3 V. V. NNP 37158 1189 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1189 5 . . . 37158 1190 1 and and CC 37158 1190 2 Rutter Rutter NNP 37158 1190 3 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1190 4 A. A. NNP 37158 1190 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1190 6 . . . 37158 1191 1 THE the DT 37158 1191 2 MORALITY MORALITY NNP 37158 1191 3 OF of IN 37158 1191 4 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1191 5 . . . 37158 1192 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1192 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1192 3 Nineteenth Nineteenth NNP 37158 1192 4 Century Century NNP 37158 1192 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1192 6 , , , 37158 1192 7 1892 1892 CD 37158 1192 8 , , , 37158 1192 9 pp pp NNP 37158 1192 10 . . . 37158 1193 1 804 804 CD 37158 1193 2 - - SYM 37158 1193 3 817 817 CD 37158 1193 4 . . . 37158 1193 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1194 1 Hutton Hutton NNP 37158 1194 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1194 3 R. R. NNP 37158 1194 4 H. H. NNP 37158 1194 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1194 6 . . . 37158 1195 1 THE the DT 37158 1195 2 BIOLOGISTS BIOLOGISTS NNP 37158 1195 3 ON on IN 37158 1195 4 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1195 5 . . . 37158 1196 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1196 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1196 3 Nineteenth Nineteenth NNP 37158 1196 4 Century Century NNP 37158 1196 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1196 6 , , , 37158 1196 7 1882 1882 CD 37158 1196 8 , , , 37158 1196 9 29 29 CD 37158 1196 10 - - SYM 37158 1196 11 39 39 CD 37158 1196 12 , , , 37158 1196 13 and and CC 37158 1196 14 _ _ NNP 37158 1196 15 Contemp Contemp NNP 37158 1196 16 . . . 37158 1197 1 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1197 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1197 3 , , , 37158 1197 4 1883 1883 CD 37158 1197 5 , , , 37158 1197 6 510 510 CD 37158 1197 7 - - SYM 37158 1197 8 516 516 CD 37158 1197 9 . . . 37158 1197 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1198 1 Jäger Jäger NNP 37158 1198 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1198 3 G. G. NNP 37158 1198 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1198 5 . . . 37158 1199 1 V. V. NNP 37158 1199 2 UND UND NNP 37158 1199 3 HEILKUNST HEILKUNST NNP 37158 1199 4 . . . 37158 1200 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1200 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1200 3 Jägers Jägers NNP 37158 1200 4 Monatsbl Monatsbl NNP 37158 1200 5 . . . 37158 1200 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1200 7 , , , 37158 1200 8 1905 1905 CD 37158 1200 9 , , , 37158 1200 10 137 137 CD 37158 1200 11 - - SYM 37158 1200 12 141 141 CD 37158 1200 13 , , , 37158 1200 14 173 173 CD 37158 1200 15 - - SYM 37158 1200 16 183 183 CD 37158 1200 17 , , , 37158 1200 18 197 197 CD 37158 1200 19 - - SYM 37158 1200 20 203 203 CD 37158 1200 21 . . . 37158 1200 22 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1201 1 Keen Keen NNP 37158 1201 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1201 3 W. W. NNP 37158 1201 4 W. W. NNP 37158 1201 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1201 6 . . . 37158 1202 1 OUR our PRP$ 37158 1202 2 RECENT recent JJ 37158 1202 3 DEBTS debt NNS 37158 1202 4 TO to IN 37158 1202 5 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1202 6 . . . 37158 1203 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1203 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1203 3 Pop Pop NNP 37158 1203 4 . . . 37158 1204 1 Sc sc RB 37158 1204 2 . . . 37158 1205 1 Monthly Monthly NNP 37158 1205 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1205 3 , , , 37158 1205 4 1889 1889 CD 37158 1205 5 , , , 37158 1205 6 1 1 CD 37158 1205 7 - - SYM 37158 1205 8 15 15 CD 37158 1205 9 and and CC 37158 1205 10 _ _ NNP 37158 1205 11 Harper Harper NNP 37158 1205 12 's 's POS 37158 1205 13 Mag Mag NNP 37158 1205 14 . . . 37158 1205 15 _ _ NNP 37158 1205 16 , , , 37158 1205 17 1893 1893 CD 37158 1205 18 , , , 37158 1205 19 pp pp NNP 37158 1205 20 . . . 37158 1206 1 28 28 CD 37158 1206 2 - - SYM 37158 1206 3 139 139 CD 37158 1206 4 . . . 37158 1206 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1207 1 Keen Keen NNP 37158 1207 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1207 3 W. W. NNP 37158 1207 4 W. W. NNP 37158 1207 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1207 6 . . . 37158 1208 1 MISSTATEMENTS misstatement NNS 37158 1208 2 OF of IN 37158 1208 3 THE the DT 37158 1208 4 ANTI anti JJ 37158 1208 5 - - HYPH 37158 1208 6 VIVISECTIONISTS vivisectionists NN 37158 1208 7 AGAIN again RB 37158 1208 8 . . . 37158 1209 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1209 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1209 3 Phil Phil NNP 37158 1209 4 . . . 37158 1210 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1210 2 . . . 37158 1211 1 Jour Jour NNP 37158 1211 2 . . NNP 37158 1211 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1211 4 , , , 37158 1211 5 1901 1901 CD 37158 1211 6 , , , 37158 1211 7 204 204 CD 37158 1211 8 - - SYM 37158 1211 9 206 206 CD 37158 1211 10 . . . 37158 1211 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1212 1 Kingsford Kingsford NNP 37158 1212 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1212 3 A. A. NNP 37158 1212 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1212 5 . . . 37158 1213 1 THE the DT 37158 1213 2 USELESSNESS USELESSNESS NNP 37158 1213 3 OF of IN 37158 1213 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1213 5 . . . 37158 1214 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1214 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1214 3 Nineteenth Nineteenth NNP 37158 1214 4 Century Century NNP 37158 1214 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1214 6 , , , 37158 1214 7 1882 1882 CD 37158 1214 8 , , , 37158 1214 9 171 171 CD 37158 1214 10 - - SYM 37158 1214 11 183 183 CD 37158 1214 12 . . . 37158 1214 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1215 1 Kleffer Kleffer NNP 37158 1215 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1215 3 H. H. NNP 37158 1215 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1215 5 . . . 37158 1216 1 LA LA NNP 37158 1216 2 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1216 3 , , , 37158 1216 4 SON SON NNP 37158 1216 5 UTILITÉ UTILITÉ NNP 37158 1216 6 , , , 37158 1216 7 SA SA NNP 37158 1216 8 MORALE MORALE NNS 37158 1216 9 . . . 37158 1217 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1217 2 GENÈVE GENÈVE NNP 37158 1217 3 , , , 37158 1217 4 GEORG GEORG NNP 37158 1217 5 , , , 37158 1217 6 12mo 12mo NN 37158 1217 7 , , , 37158 1217 8 1883 1883 CD 37158 1217 9 . . . 37158 1217 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1218 1 Lawson Lawson NNP 37158 1218 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1218 3 H. H. NNP 37158 1218 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1218 5 . . . 37158 1219 1 THE the DT 37158 1219 2 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1219 3 CLAMOUR clamour NN 37158 1219 4 . . . 37158 1220 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1220 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1220 3 Pop Pop NNP 37158 1220 4 . . . 37158 1221 1 Sc sc RB 37158 1221 2 . . . 37158 1222 1 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1222 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1222 3 , , , 37158 1222 4 1876 1876 CD 37158 1222 5 , , , 37158 1222 6 398 398 CD 37158 1222 7 - - SYM 37158 1222 8 405 405 CD 37158 1222 9 . . . 37158 1222 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1223 1 Leffingwell Leffingwell NNP 37158 1223 2 . . . 37158 1224 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1224 2 , , , 37158 1224 3 A a DT 37158 1224 4 REPLY REPLY NNP 37158 1224 5 TO to IN 37158 1224 6 PROF PROF NNP 37158 1224 7 . . NNP 37158 1224 8 H. H. NNP 37158 1224 9 WOOD WOOD NNP 37158 1224 10 . . . 37158 1225 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1225 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1225 3 Bost Bost NNP 37158 1225 4 . . . 37158 1226 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1226 2 . . . 37158 1227 1 and and CC 37158 1227 2 Surg Surg NNP 37158 1227 3 . . . 37158 1228 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1228 2 . . . 37158 1228 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1228 4 , , , 37158 1228 5 1899 1899 CD 37158 1228 6 , , , 37158 1228 7 371 371 CD 37158 1228 8 . . . 37158 1228 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1229 1 Leneveu Leneveu NNP 37158 1229 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1229 3 G. G. NNP 37158 1229 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1229 5 . . . 37158 1230 1 DE DE NNP 37158 1230 2 L'UTILITÉ L'UTILITÉ NNP 37158 1230 3 DE DE NNP 37158 1230 4 LA LA NNP 37158 1230 5 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1230 6 . . . 37158 1231 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1231 2 Diss Diss NNP 37158 1231 3 , , , 37158 1231 4 in in IN 37158 1231 5 . . NNP 37158 1231 6 , , , 37158 1231 7 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1231 8 , , , 37158 1231 9 1883 1883 CD 37158 1231 10 . . . 37158 1231 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1232 1 Lund Lund NNP 37158 1232 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1232 3 P. P. NNP 37158 1232 4 W. W. NNP 37158 1232 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1232 6 . . . 37158 1233 1 PHYSIOLOGISCHE PHYSIOLOGISCHE NNP 37158 1233 2 RESULTATE RESULTATE NNP 37158 1233 3 DER DER NNP 37158 1233 4 V. V. NNP 37158 1233 5 NEUERER NEUERER NNP 37158 1233 6 ZEIT ZEIT NNP 37158 1233 7 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1233 8 _ _ NNP 37158 1233 9 trad trad NN 37158 1233 10 . . . 37158 1234 1 du du NNP 37158 1234 2 Danois Danois NNP 37158 1234 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1234 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1234 5 . . . 37158 1235 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1235 2 Kopenhagen Kopenhagen NNP 37158 1235 3 , , , 37158 1235 4 1825 1825 CD 37158 1235 5 . . . 37158 1235 6 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1236 1 Macphail Macphail NNP 37158 1236 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1236 3 J. J. NNP 37158 1237 1 A. A. NNP 37158 1237 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1237 3 . . . 37158 1238 1 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1238 2 . . . 37158 1239 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1239 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1239 3 Montreal Montreal NNP 37158 1239 4 Med Med NNP 37158 1239 5 . . . 37158 1240 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1240 2 . . . 37158 1240 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1240 4 , , , 37158 1240 5 1890 1890 CD 37158 1240 6 , , , 37158 1240 7 895 895 CD 37158 1240 8 - - SYM 37158 1240 9 919 919 CD 37158 1240 10 . . . 37158 1240 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1241 1 Magnan Magnan NNP 37158 1241 2 . . . 37158 1242 1 DE DE NNP 37158 1242 2 LA LA NNP 37158 1242 3 FOLIE FOLIE NNP 37158 1242 4 DES DES NNP 37158 1242 5 ANTIVIVISECTIONNISTES antivivisectionniste NNS 37158 1242 6 . . . 37158 1243 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1243 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1243 3 C. C. NNP 37158 1244 1 R. R. NNP 37158 1244 2 de de NNP 37158 1244 3 la la NNP 37158 1244 4 Soc Soc NNP 37158 1244 5 . . . 37158 1245 1 de de NNP 37158 1245 2 Biol Biol NNP 37158 1245 3 . . . 37158 1246 1 de de NNP 37158 1246 2 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1246 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1246 4 , , , 37158 1246 5 1884 1884 CD 37158 1246 6 , , , 37158 1246 7 101 101 CD 37158 1246 8 - - SYM 37158 1246 9 104 104 CD 37158 1246 10 . . . 37158 1246 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1247 1 Maréchal Maréchal NNP 37158 1247 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1247 3 Ph Ph NNP 37158 1247 4 . . NNP 37158 1247 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1247 6 . . . 37158 1248 1 LA LA NNP 37158 1248 2 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1248 3 . . . 37158 1249 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1249 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1249 3 Médecin Médecin NNP 37158 1249 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1249 5 , , , 37158 1249 6 1904 1904 CD 37158 1249 7 , , , 37158 1249 8 35 35 CD 37158 1249 9 , , , 37158 1249 10 and and CC 37158 1249 11 _ _ NNP 37158 1249 12 Revue Revue NNP 37158 1249 13 du du NNP 37158 1249 14 Cien Cien NNP 37158 1249 15 _ _ NNP 37158 1249 16 , , , 37158 1249 17 13 13 CD 37158 1249 18 - - SYM 37158 1249 19 15 15 CD 37158 1249 20 . . . 37158 1249 21 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1250 1 Maurel Maurel NNP 37158 1250 2 . . . 37158 1251 1 LA LA NNP 37158 1251 2 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1251 3 EST EST NNP 37158 1251 4 ELLE ELLE NNP 37158 1251 5 INDISPENSABLE INDISPENSABLE NNP 37158 1251 6 . . . 37158 1252 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1252 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1252 3 Ass Ass NNP 37158 1252 4 . . . 37158 1253 1 pour pour NNP 37158 1253 2 l'ac l'ac NNP 37158 1253 3 . . . 37158 1254 1 des des NNP 37158 1254 2 sciences sciences NNP 37158 1254 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1254 4 , , , 37158 1254 5 1901 1901 CD 37158 1254 6 , , , 37158 1254 7 294 294 CD 37158 1254 8 . . . 37158 1254 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1255 1 Merbach Merbach NNP 37158 1255 2 . . . 37158 1256 1 UEBER UEBER NNP 37158 1256 2 DIE die VBP 37158 1256 3 GESCHICHTE GESCHICHTE NNP 37158 1256 4 DER DER NNP 37158 1256 5 V. V. NNP 37158 1256 6 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1256 7 _ _ NNP 37158 1256 8 Jahresb Jahresb NNP 37158 1256 9 . . . 37158 1257 1 d. d. NNP 37158 1257 2 Ges Ges NNP 37158 1257 3 . . . 37158 1258 1 f. f. NNP 37158 1258 2 Nat Nat NNP 37158 1258 3 . . . 37158 1259 1 u. u. NNP 37158 1259 2 Heilk Heilk NNP 37158 1259 3 . . . 37158 1260 1 in in IN 37158 1260 2 Dresd Dresd NNP 37158 1260 3 . . . 37158 1260 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1260 5 1878 1878 CD 37158 1260 6 , , , 37158 1260 7 98 98 CD 37158 1260 8 - - SYM 37158 1260 9 103 103 CD 37158 1260 10 . . . 37158 1260 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1261 1 Metzger Metzger NNP 37158 1261 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1261 3 D. D. NNP 37158 1261 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1261 5 . . . 37158 1262 1 LA LA NNP 37158 1262 2 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1262 3 , , , 37158 1262 4 LES LES NNP 37158 1262 5 DANGERS DANGERS NNP 37158 1262 6 , , , 37158 1262 7 ET ET NNP 37158 1262 8 LES LES NNP 37158 1262 9 CRIMES CRIMES NNP 37158 1262 10 . . . 37158 1263 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1263 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1263 3 , , , 37158 1263 4 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1263 5 , , , 37158 1263 6 1891 1891 CD 37158 1263 7 . . . 37158 1263 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1264 1 Moore Moore NNP 37158 1264 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1264 3 W. W. NNP 37158 1265 1 J. J. NNP 37158 1265 2 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1265 3 . . . 37158 1266 1 HARVEY HARVEY NNP 37158 1266 2 AND and CC 37158 1266 3 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1266 4 . . . 37158 1267 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1267 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1267 3 Ind Ind NNP 37158 1267 4 . . . 37158 1268 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1268 2 . . . 37158 1269 1 Gaz Gaz NNP 37158 1269 2 . . . 37158 1269 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1269 4 , , , 37158 1269 5 1876 1876 CD 37158 1269 6 , , , 37158 1269 7 230 230 CD 37158 1269 8 - - SYM 37158 1269 9 233 233 CD 37158 1269 10 . . . 37158 1269 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1270 1 Moquin Moquin NNP 37158 1270 2 Tandon Tandon NNP 37158 1270 3 . . . 37158 1271 1 RAPPORT rapport NN 37158 1271 2 SUR sur NN 37158 1271 3 LES LES NNP 37158 1271 4 VIVISECTIONS VIVISECTIONS NNP 37158 1271 5 . . . 37158 1272 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1272 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1272 3 Bull Bull NNP 37158 1272 4 . . . 37158 1273 1 de de NNP 37158 1273 2 l'ac l'ac NNP 37158 1273 3 . . . 37158 1274 1 de de NNP 37158 1274 2 Médecine Médecine NNP 37158 1274 3 de de NNP 37158 1274 4 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1274 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1274 6 , , , 37158 1274 7 1862 1862 CD 37158 1274 8 , , , 37158 1274 9 948 948 CD 37158 1274 10 - - SYM 37158 1274 11 960 960 CD 37158 1274 12 . . . 37158 1274 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1275 1 Nagel Nagel NNP 37158 1275 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1275 3 R. R. NNP 37158 1275 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1275 5 . . . 37158 1276 1 DER DER NNP 37158 1276 2 WISSENSCHAFTLICHE WISSENSCHAFTLICHE NNP 37158 1276 3 UNWERTH UNWERTH VBD 37158 1276 4 DER der RP 37158 1276 5 V v NN 37158 1276 6 IN in NN 37158 1276 7 ALLEN ALLEN NNP 37158 1276 8 IHREN IHREN NNP 37158 1276 9 ARTEN ARTEN NNP 37158 1276 10 . . . 37158 1277 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1277 2 8vo 8vo NNP 37158 1277 3 , , , 37158 1277 4 Berlin Berlin NNP 37158 1277 5 , , , 37158 1277 6 1881 1881 CD 37158 1277 7 . . . 37158 1277 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1278 1 Novi Novi NNP 37158 1278 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1278 3 J. J. NNP 37158 1278 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1278 5 . . . 37158 1279 1 SULLA SULLA NNP 37158 1279 2 V. V. NNP 37158 1279 3 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1279 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1279 5 Boll Boll NNP 37158 1279 6 . . . 37158 1280 1 d. d. NNP 37158 1280 2 sc sc NNP 37158 1280 3 . . . 37158 1281 1 med med JJ 37158 1281 2 . . . 37158 1282 1 di di NNP 37158 1282 2 Bologne Bologne NNP 37158 1282 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1282 4 , , , 37158 1282 5 1893 1893 CD 37158 1282 6 , , , 37158 1282 7 263 263 CD 37158 1282 8 , , , 37158 1282 9 421 421 CD 37158 1282 10 . . . 37158 1282 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1283 1 Paget Paget NNP 37158 1283 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1283 3 Stephen Stephen NNP 37158 1283 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1283 5 . . . 37158 1284 1 EXPERIMENTS experiment NNS 37158 1284 2 ON on IN 37158 1284 3 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1284 4 . . . 37158 1285 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1285 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1285 3 Murray Murray NNP 37158 1285 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1285 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1285 6 . . . 37158 1286 1 Renault Renault NNP 37158 1286 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1286 3 E. E. NNP 37158 1286 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1286 5 . . . 37158 1287 1 LA LA NNP 37158 1287 2 SOC SOC NNP 37158 1287 3 . . . 37158 1288 1 PROTECTS PROTECTS NNP 37158 1288 2 . . . 37158 1289 1 DES DES NNP 37158 1289 2 ANIMAUX ANIMAUX NNP 37158 1289 3 ET ET NNP 37158 1289 4 LA LA NNP 37158 1289 5 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1289 6 . . . 37158 1290 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1290 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1290 3 Rec Rec NNP 37158 1290 4 . . . 37158 1291 1 de de NNP 37158 1291 2 Méd Méd NNP 37158 1291 3 . . . 37158 1292 1 vétérin vétérin NNP 37158 1292 2 . . . 37158 1292 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1292 4 , , , 37158 1292 5 1862 1862 CD 37158 1292 6 , , , 37158 1292 7 231 231 CD 37158 1292 8 - - SYM 37158 1292 9 247 247 CD 37158 1292 10 . . . 37158 1292 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1293 1 Renooz Renooz NNP 37158 1293 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1293 3 C C NNP 37158 1293 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1293 5 . . . 37158 1294 1 A a DT 37158 1294 2 PROPOS PROPOS NNP 37158 1294 3 DE DE NNP 37158 1294 4 LA LA NNP 37158 1294 5 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1294 6 . . . 37158 1295 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1295 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1295 3 Médecin Médecin NNP 37158 1295 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1295 5 , , , 37158 1295 6 1904 1904 CD 37158 1295 7 , , , 37158 1295 8 178 178 CD 37158 1295 9 - - SYM 37158 1295 10 179 179 CD 37158 1295 11 . . . 37158 1295 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1296 1 Richet Richet NNP 37158 1296 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1296 3 Ch Ch NNP 37158 1296 4 . . . 37158 1296 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1296 6 . . . 37158 1297 1 MAN MAN NNP 37158 1297 2 'S 'S NNP 37158 1297 3 RIGHT right NN 37158 1297 4 OVER over IN 37158 1297 5 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1297 6 . . . 37158 1298 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1298 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1298 3 Pop Pop NNP 37158 1298 4 . . . 37158 1299 1 Sc sc RB 37158 1299 2 . . . 37158 1300 1 Monthly Monthly NNP 37158 1300 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1300 3 , , , 37158 1300 4 1884 1884 CD 37158 1300 5 , , , 37158 1300 6 xxv xxv NNP 37158 1300 7 . . NNP 37158 1300 8 , , , 37158 1300 9 759 759 CD 37158 1300 10 - - SYM 37158 1300 11 766 766 CD 37158 1300 12 . . . 37158 1300 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1301 1 Smith Smith NNP 37158 1301 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1301 3 R. R. NNP 37158 1301 4 M. M. NNP 37158 1301 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1301 6 . . . 37158 1302 1 MATERIA materia NN 37158 1302 2 MEDICA MEDICA NNP 37158 1302 3 AND and CC 37158 1302 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1302 5 . . . 37158 1303 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1303 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1303 3 Merck Merck NNP 37158 1303 4 's 's POS 37158 1303 5 Arch Arch NNP 37158 1303 6 . . . 37158 1303 7 _ _ NNP 37158 1303 8 , , , 37158 1303 9 1900 1900 CD 37158 1303 10 , , , 37158 1303 11 44 44 CD 37158 1303 12 - - SYM 37158 1303 13 47 47 CD 37158 1303 14 . . . 37158 1303 15 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1304 1 Smith Smith NNP 37158 1304 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1304 3 R. R. NNP 37158 1304 4 M. M. NNP 37158 1304 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1304 6 . . . 37158 1305 1 SHOULD SHOULD MD 37158 1305 2 EXPERIMENTS experiment NNS 37158 1305 3 ON on IN 37158 1305 4 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1305 5 BE be NN 37158 1305 6 RESTRICTED restrict VBN 37158 1305 7 OR or CC 37158 1305 8 ABOLISHED ABOLISHED NNS 37158 1305 9 ? ? . 37158 1306 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1306 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1306 3 Therap Therap NNP 37158 1306 4 . . . 37158 1307 1 Gaz Gaz NNP 37158 1307 2 . . . 37158 1307 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1307 4 , , , 37158 1307 5 1884 1884 CD 37158 1307 6 , , , 37158 1307 7 497 497 CD 37158 1307 8 , , , 37158 1307 9 533 533 CD 37158 1307 10 . . . 37158 1307 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1308 1 Smith Smith NNP 37158 1308 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1308 3 Pye Pye NNP 37158 1308 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1308 5 . . . 37158 1309 1 ON ON NNP 37158 1309 2 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1309 3 . . . 37158 1310 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1310 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1310 3 Brit Brit NNP 37158 1310 4 . . . 37158 1311 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1311 2 . . . 37158 1312 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1312 2 . . . 37158 1312 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1312 4 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1312 5 2 2 CD 37158 1312 6 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1312 7 , , , 37158 1312 8 1879 1879 CD 37158 1312 9 , , , 37158 1312 10 349 349 CD 37158 1312 11 . . . 37158 1312 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1313 1 Stuser Stuser NNP 37158 1313 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1313 3 E. E. NNP 37158 1313 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1313 5 . . . 37158 1314 1 IS be VBZ 37158 1314 2 VIVISECTION vivisection VB 37158 1314 3 A a DT 37158 1314 4 BENEFIT benefit NN 37158 1314 5 TO to IN 37158 1314 6 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1314 7 AND and CC 37158 1314 8 MAN man NN 37158 1314 9 , , , 37158 1314 10 AND and CC 37158 1314 11 JUSTIFIABLE JUSTIFIABLE NNP 37158 1314 12 ? ? . 37158 1315 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1315 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1315 3 Med Med NNP 37158 1315 4 . . . 37158 1316 1 News News NNP 37158 1316 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1316 3 , , , 37158 1316 4 1902 1902 CD 37158 1316 5 , , , 37158 1316 6 108 108 CD 37158 1316 7 - - SYM 37158 1316 8 111 111 CD 37158 1316 9 . . . 37158 1316 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1317 1 Tait Tait NNP 37158 1317 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1317 3 Lawson Lawson NNP 37158 1317 4 . . . 37158 1317 5 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1317 6 . . . 37158 1318 1 THE the DT 37158 1318 2 USELESSNESS USELESSNESS NNP 37158 1318 3 OF of IN 37158 1318 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1318 5 UPON upon IN 37158 1318 6 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1318 7 AS as IN 37158 1318 8 A a DT 37158 1318 9 METHOD method NN 37158 1318 10 OF of IN 37158 1318 11 SCIENTIFIC scientific JJ 37158 1318 12 RESEARCH research NN 37158 1318 13 . . . 37158 1319 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1319 2 London London NNP 37158 1319 3 , , , 37158 1319 4 8vo 8vo NN 37158 1319 5 , , , 37158 1319 6 1883 1883 CD 37158 1319 7 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1319 8 ? ? . 37158 1319 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1319 10 . . . 37158 1319 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1320 1 Tuckermann Tuckermann NNP 37158 1320 2 . . . 37158 1321 1 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT NNP 37158 1321 2 OF of IN 37158 1321 3 THE the DT 37158 1321 4 REPORT REPORT NNP 37158 1321 5 OF of IN 37158 1321 6 THE the DT 37158 1321 7 COMMITTEE COMMITTEE NNP 37158 1321 8 ON on IN 37158 1321 9 VIVISECTION VIVISECTION NNP 37158 1321 10 . . . 37158 1322 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1322 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1322 3 Columb Columb NNP 37158 1322 4 . . . 37158 1323 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1323 2 . . . 37158 1324 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1324 2 . . . 37158 1324 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1324 4 , , , 37158 1324 5 1897 1897 CD 37158 1324 6 , , , 37158 1324 7 237 237 CD 37158 1324 8 - - SYM 37158 1324 9 243 243 CD 37158 1324 10 . . . 37158 1324 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1325 1 Weber Weber NNP 37158 1325 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1325 3 E. E. NNP 37158 1325 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1325 5 . . . 37158 1326 1 LES LES NNP 37158 1326 2 CHAMBRES CHAMBRES NNP 37158 1326 3 DE DE NNP 37158 1326 4 TORTURE TORTURE NNP 37158 1326 5 DE DE NNP 37158 1326 6 LA LA NNP 37158 1326 7 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 37158 1326 8 . . . 37158 1327 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1327 2 Paris Paris NNP 37158 1327 3 , , , 37158 1327 4 Leroux Leroux NNP 37158 1327 5 , , , 37158 1327 6 8vo 8vo NN 37158 1327 7 , , , 37158 1327 8 1879 1879 CD 37158 1327 9 . . . 37158 1327 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1328 1 Wilberforce Wilberforce NNP 37158 1328 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1328 3 C C NNP 37158 1328 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1328 5 . . . 37158 1329 1 WOMEN WOMEN NNP 37158 1329 2 , , , 37158 1329 3 CLERGYMEN CLERGYMEN NNP 37158 1329 4 AND and CC 37158 1329 5 DOCTORS DOCTORS NNP 37158 1329 6 . . . 37158 1330 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1330 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1330 3 New New NNP 37158 1330 4 Review Review NNP 37158 1330 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1330 6 , , , 37158 1330 7 1893 1893 CD 37158 1330 8 , , , 37158 1330 9 85 85 CD 37158 1330 10 - - SYM 37158 1330 11 95 95 CD 37158 1330 12 . . . 37158 1330 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1331 1 Wilks wilk NNS 37158 1331 2 . . . 37158 1332 1 THE the DT 37158 1332 2 ETHICS ethic NNS 37158 1332 3 OF of IN 37158 1332 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1332 5 . . . 37158 1333 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1333 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1333 3 Pop Pop NNP 37158 1333 4 . . . 37158 1334 1 Sc sc RB 37158 1334 2 . . . 37158 1335 1 Monthly Monthly NNP 37158 1335 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1335 3 , , , 37158 1335 4 1882 1882 CD 37158 1335 5 , , , 37158 1335 6 xxi xxi NNP 37158 1335 7 . . NNP 37158 1335 8 , , , 37158 1335 9 344 344 CD 37158 1335 10 - - SYM 37158 1335 11 350 350 CD 37158 1335 12 . . . 37158 1335 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1336 1 Williams Williams NNP 37158 1336 2 . . . 37158 1337 1 A a DT 37158 1337 2 FEW FEW NNP 37158 1337 3 PERSONAL personal JJ 37158 1337 4 FACTS facts NN 37158 1337 5 CONCERNING concern VBG 37158 1337 6 EXPERIMENTS experiment NNS 37158 1337 7 ON on IN 37158 1337 8 ANIMALS animal NNS 37158 1337 9 OPPOSED oppose VBN 37158 1337 10 TO to IN 37158 1337 11 THE the DT 37158 1337 12 FALSE false JJ 37158 1337 13 FANCIES fancy NNS 37158 1337 14 OF of IN 37158 1337 15 THE the DT 37158 1337 16 PERSECUTORS PERSECUTORS NNP 37158 1337 17 OF of IN 37158 1337 18 VIVISECTORS VIVISECTORS NNP 37158 1337 19 . . . 37158 1338 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1338 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1338 3 Brit Brit NNP 37158 1338 4 . . . 37158 1339 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1339 2 . . . 37158 1340 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1340 2 . . . 37158 1340 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1340 4 , , , 37158 1340 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1340 6 2 2 CD 37158 1340 7 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1340 8 , , , 37158 1340 9 1876 1876 CD 37158 1340 10 , , , 37158 1340 11 104 104 CD 37158 1340 12 . . . 37158 1340 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1341 1 Wolff wolff RB 37158 1341 2 . . . 37158 1342 1 DISPUTATIO disputatio JJ 37158 1342 2 PHILOSOPHICA PHILOSOPHICA NNP 37158 1342 3 DE DE NNP 37158 1342 4 MORALITATE MORALITATE NNP 37158 1342 5 ANATOMES ANATOMES NNP 37158 1342 6 CIRCA CIRCA NNP 37158 1342 7 ANIMALIA animalia VBP 37158 1342 8 VICA VICA NNP 37158 1342 9 OCCUPATAE OCCUPATAE NNP 37158 1342 10 . . . 37158 1343 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1343 2 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 37158 1343 3 , , , 37158 1343 4 1709 1709 CD 37158 1343 5 . . . 37158 1343 6 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1344 1 Wood Wood NNP 37158 1344 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1344 3 H. H. NNP 37158 1344 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1344 5 . . . 37158 1345 1 THE the DT 37158 1345 2 CONTROL control NN 37158 1345 3 OF of IN 37158 1345 4 VIVISECTION vivisection NN 37158 1345 5 . . . 37158 1346 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1346 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1346 3 Bost Bost NNP 37158 1346 4 . . . 37158 1347 1 Med Med NNP 37158 1347 2 . . . 37158 1348 1 and and CC 37158 1348 2 Surg Surg NNP 37158 1348 3 . . . 37158 1349 1 Journ Journ NNP 37158 1349 2 . . . 37158 1349 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1349 4 , , , 37158 1349 5 1895 1895 CD 37158 1349 6 , , , 37158 1349 7 342 342 CD 37158 1349 8 . . . 37158 1349 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1350 1 Zöllner Zöllner NNP 37158 1350 2 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1350 3 F. F. NNP 37158 1350 4 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1350 5 . . . 37158 1351 1 UEBER UEBER NNP 37158 1351 2 DER DER NNP 37158 1351 3 WISSENSCHAFTLICHEN WISSENSCHAFTLICHEN NNP 37158 1351 4 MISSBRAUCH MISSBRAUCH NNP 37158 1351 5 DER DER NNP 37158 1351 6 V. V. NNP 37158 1351 7 , , , 37158 1351 8 MIT MIT NNP 37158 1351 9 HISTORISCHEN HISTORISCHEN NNP 37158 1351 10 DOCUMENTEN DOCUMENTEN NNP 37158 1351 11 ÜBER ÜBER NNP 37158 1351 12 DIE DIE NNP 37158 1351 13 V. V. NNP 37158 1351 14 VON VON NNP 37158 1351 15 MENSCHEN MENSCHEN NNP 37158 1351 16 . . . 37158 1352 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1352 2 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 37158 1352 3 , , , 37158 1352 4 8vo 8vo NN 37158 1352 5 , , , 37158 1352 6 1880 1880 CD 37158 1352 7 , , , 37158 1352 8 2nd 2nd NNP 37158 1352 9 ed ed NNP 37158 1352 10 . . NNP 37158 1352 11 , , , 37158 1352 12 1885 1885 CD 37158 1352 13 . . . 37158 1352 14 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1353 1 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 37158 1353 2 C C NNP 37158 1353 3 THE the DT 37158 1353 4 RESEARCH research NN 37158 1353 5 DEFENCE defence NN 37158 1353 6 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 37158 1353 7 In in IN 37158 1353 8 January January NNP 37158 1353 9 1908 1908 CD 37158 1353 10 , , , 37158 1353 11 a a DT 37158 1353 12 Society Society NNP 37158 1353 13 with with IN 37158 1353 14 the the DT 37158 1353 15 above above JJ 37158 1353 16 name name NN 37158 1353 17 was be VBD 37158 1353 18 formed form VBN 37158 1353 19 in in IN 37158 1353 20 England England NNP 37158 1353 21 , , , 37158 1353 22 the the DT 37158 1353 23 aims aim NNS 37158 1353 24 and and CC 37158 1353 25 objects object NNS 37158 1353 26 of of IN 37158 1353 27 which which WDT 37158 1353 28 are be VBP 37158 1353 29 clearly clearly RB 37158 1353 30 stated state VBN 37158 1353 31 in in IN 37158 1353 32 the the DT 37158 1353 33 following following JJ 37158 1353 34 letter letter NN 37158 1353 35 from from IN 37158 1353 36 Lord Lord NNP 37158 1353 37 Cromer Cromer NNP 37158 1353 38 , , , 37158 1353 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1353 40 President President NNP 37158 1353 41 ; ; : 37158 1353 42 this this DT 37158 1353 43 letter letter NN 37158 1353 44 was be VBD 37158 1353 45 published publish VBN 37158 1353 46 in in IN 37158 1353 47 the the DT 37158 1353 48 English english JJ 37158 1353 49 newspapers newspaper NNS 37158 1353 50 on on IN 37158 1353 51 24th 24th JJ 37158 1353 52 April April NNP 37158 1353 53 1908:-- 1908:-- NNP 37158 1353 54 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1353 55 , , , 37158 1353 56 A A NNP 37158 1353 57 Society Society NNP 37158 1353 58 has have VBZ 37158 1353 59 been be VBN 37158 1353 60 formed form VBN 37158 1353 61 , , , 37158 1353 62 with with IN 37158 1353 63 the the DT 37158 1353 64 name name NN 37158 1353 65 of of IN 37158 1353 66 the the DT 37158 1353 67 Research Research NNP 37158 1353 68 Defence Defence NNP 37158 1353 69 Society Society NNP 37158 1353 70 , , , 37158 1353 71 to to TO 37158 1353 72 make make VB 37158 1353 73 known known JJ 37158 1353 74 the the DT 37158 1353 75 facts fact NNS 37158 1353 76 as as IN 37158 1353 77 to to IN 37158 1353 78 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1353 79 on on IN 37158 1353 80 animals animal NNS 37158 1353 81 in in IN 37158 1353 82 this this DT 37158 1353 83 country country NN 37158 1353 84 ; ; : 37158 1353 85 the the DT 37158 1353 86 immense immense JJ 37158 1353 87 importance importance NN 37158 1353 88 to to IN 37158 1353 89 the the DT 37158 1353 90 welfare welfare NN 37158 1353 91 of of IN 37158 1353 92 mankind mankind NN 37158 1353 93 of of IN 37158 1353 94 such such JJ 37158 1353 95 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1353 96 ; ; : 37158 1353 97 and and CC 37158 1353 98 the the DT 37158 1353 99 great great JJ 37158 1353 100 saving saving NN 37158 1353 101 of of IN 37158 1353 102 human human JJ 37158 1353 103 life life NN 37158 1353 104 and and CC 37158 1353 105 health health NN 37158 1353 106 directly directly RB 37158 1353 107 attributable attributable JJ 37158 1353 108 to to IN 37158 1353 109 them -PRON- PRP 37158 1353 110 . . . 37158 1354 1 The the DT 37158 1354 2 great great JJ 37158 1354 3 advance advance NN 37158 1354 4 that that WDT 37158 1354 5 has have VBZ 37158 1354 6 been be VBN 37158 1354 7 made make VBN 37158 1354 8 during during IN 37158 1354 9 the the DT 37158 1354 10 last last JJ 37158 1354 11 quarter quarter NN 37158 1354 12 of of IN 37158 1354 13 a a DT 37158 1354 14 century century NN 37158 1354 15 in in IN 37158 1354 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1354 17 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 1354 18 of of IN 37158 1354 19 the the DT 37158 1354 20 functions function NNS 37158 1354 21 of of IN 37158 1354 22 the the DT 37158 1354 23 body body NN 37158 1354 24 , , , 37158 1354 25 and and CC 37158 1354 26 of of IN 37158 1354 27 the the DT 37158 1354 28 causes cause NNS 37158 1354 29 of of IN 37158 1354 30 disease disease NN 37158 1354 31 , , , 37158 1354 32 would would MD 37158 1354 33 have have VB 37158 1354 34 been be VBN 37158 1354 35 impossible impossible JJ 37158 1354 36 without without IN 37158 1354 37 a a DT 37158 1354 38 combination combination NN 37158 1354 39 of of IN 37158 1354 40 experiment experiment NN 37158 1354 41 and and CC 37158 1354 42 observation observation NN 37158 1354 43 . . . 37158 1355 1 The the DT 37158 1355 2 use use NN 37158 1355 3 of of IN 37158 1355 4 antiseptics antiseptic NNS 37158 1355 5 , , , 37158 1355 6 and and CC 37158 1355 7 the the DT 37158 1355 8 modern modern JJ 37158 1355 9 treatment treatment NN 37158 1355 10 of of IN 37158 1355 11 wounds wound NNS 37158 1355 12 , , , 37158 1355 13 is be VBZ 37158 1355 14 the the DT 37158 1355 15 direct direct JJ 37158 1355 16 outcome outcome NN 37158 1355 17 of of IN 37158 1355 18 the the DT 37158 1355 19 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1355 20 of of IN 37158 1355 21 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 1355 22 and and CC 37158 1355 23 Lister Lister NNP 37158 1355 24 . . . 37158 1356 1 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 37158 1356 2 's 's POS 37158 1356 3 discovery discovery NN 37158 1356 4 of of IN 37158 1356 5 the the DT 37158 1356 6 microbial microbial JJ 37158 1356 7 cause cause NN 37158 1356 8 of of IN 37158 1356 9 puerperal puerperal JJ 37158 1356 10 fever fever NN 37158 1356 11 has have VBZ 37158 1356 12 in in IN 37158 1356 13 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 1356 14 enormously enormously RB 37158 1356 15 reduced reduce VBD 37158 1356 16 the the DT 37158 1356 17 deaths death NNS 37158 1356 18 of of IN 37158 1356 19 women woman NNS 37158 1356 20 in in IN 37158 1356 21 child child NN 37158 1356 22 - - HYPH 37158 1356 23 birth birth NN 37158 1356 24 . . . 37158 1357 1 The the DT 37158 1357 2 nature nature NN 37158 1357 3 of of IN 37158 1357 4 tuberculosis tuberculosis NN 37158 1357 5 is be VBZ 37158 1357 6 now now RB 37158 1357 7 known know VBN 37158 1357 8 , , , 37158 1357 9 and and CC 37158 1357 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1357 11 incidence incidence NN 37158 1357 12 has have VBZ 37158 1357 13 materially materially RB 37158 1357 14 diminished diminish VBN 37158 1357 15 . . . 37158 1358 1 We -PRON- PRP 37158 1358 2 owe owe VBP 37158 1358 3 the the DT 37158 1358 4 invention invention NN 37158 1358 5 of of IN 37158 1358 6 diphtheria diphtheria NNP 37158 1358 7 antitoxin antitoxin NNP 37158 1358 8 entirely entirely RB 37158 1358 9 to to IN 37158 1358 10 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1358 11 on on IN 37158 1358 12 animals animal NNS 37158 1358 13 . . . 37158 1359 1 The the DT 37158 1359 2 causes cause NNS 37158 1359 3 of of IN 37158 1359 4 plague plague NN 37158 1359 5 , , , 37158 1359 6 cholera cholera NNP 37158 1359 7 , , , 37158 1359 8 typhoid typhoid NN 37158 1359 9 , , , 37158 1359 10 Mediterranean Mediterranean NNP 37158 1359 11 fever fever NN 37158 1359 12 , , , 37158 1359 13 and and CC 37158 1359 14 sleeping sleep VBG 37158 1359 15 sickness sickness NN 37158 1359 16 , , , 37158 1359 17 have have VBP 37158 1359 18 been be VBN 37158 1359 19 discovered discover VBN 37158 1359 20 solely solely RB 37158 1359 21 by by IN 37158 1359 22 the the DT 37158 1359 23 experimental experimental JJ 37158 1359 24 method method NN 37158 1359 25 . . . 37158 1360 1 Not not RB 37158 1360 2 only only RB 37158 1360 3 have have VBP 37158 1360 4 a a DT 37158 1360 5 large large JJ 37158 1360 6 number number NN 37158 1360 7 of of IN 37158 1360 8 drugs drug NNS 37158 1360 9 been be VBN 37158 1360 10 placed place VBN 37158 1360 11 at at IN 37158 1360 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1360 13 disposal disposal NN 37158 1360 14 , , , 37158 1360 15 but but CC 37158 1360 16 accurate accurate JJ 37158 1360 17 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 1360 18 has have VBZ 37158 1360 19 replaced replace VBN 37158 1360 20 the the DT 37158 1360 21 empirical empirical JJ 37158 1360 22 use use NN 37158 1360 23 of of IN 37158 1360 24 many many JJ 37158 1360 25 of of IN 37158 1360 26 those those DT 37158 1360 27 previously previously RB 37158 1360 28 known know VBN 37158 1360 29 . . . 37158 1361 1 The the DT 37158 1361 2 evidence evidence NN 37158 1361 3 before before IN 37158 1361 4 the the DT 37158 1361 5 Royal Royal NNP 37158 1361 6 Commission Commission NNP 37158 1361 7 has have VBZ 37158 1361 8 shown show VBN 37158 1361 9 that that IN 37158 1361 10 these these DT 37158 1361 11 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1361 12 are be VBP 37158 1361 13 conducted conduct VBN 37158 1361 14 with with IN 37158 1361 15 proper proper JJ 37158 1361 16 care care NN 37158 1361 17 ; ; : 37158 1361 18 the the DT 37158 1361 19 small small JJ 37158 1361 20 amount amount NN 37158 1361 21 of of IN 37158 1361 22 pain pain NN 37158 1361 23 or or CC 37158 1361 24 discomfort discomfort NN 37158 1361 25 inflicted inflict VBN 37158 1361 26 is be VBZ 37158 1361 27 insignificant insignificant JJ 37158 1361 28 compared compare VBN 37158 1361 29 with with IN 37158 1361 30 the the DT 37158 1361 31 great great JJ 37158 1361 32 gain gain NN 37158 1361 33 to to IN 37158 1361 34 knowledge knowledge NN 37158 1361 35 and and CC 37158 1361 36 the the DT 37158 1361 37 direct direct JJ 37158 1361 38 advantage advantage NN 37158 1361 39 to to IN 37158 1361 40 humanity humanity NN 37158 1361 41 . . . 37158 1362 1 While while IN 37158 1362 2 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 37158 1362 3 in in IN 37158 1362 4 general general JJ 37158 1362 5 the the DT 37158 1362 6 utility utility NN 37158 1362 7 of of IN 37158 1362 8 the the DT 37158 1362 9 experimental experimental JJ 37158 1362 10 method method NN 37158 1362 11 , , , 37158 1362 12 efforts effort NNS 37158 1362 13 have have VBP 37158 1362 14 been be VBN 37158 1362 15 made make VBN 37158 1362 16 by by IN 37158 1362 17 a a DT 37158 1362 18 section section NN 37158 1362 19 of of IN 37158 1362 20 the the DT 37158 1362 21 public public NN 37158 1362 22 to to TO 37158 1362 23 throw throw VB 37158 1362 24 discredit discredit NN 37158 1362 25 on on IN 37158 1362 26 all all DT 37158 1362 27 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1362 28 involving involve VBG 37158 1362 29 the the DT 37158 1362 30 use use NN 37158 1362 31 of of IN 37158 1362 32 animals animal NNS 37158 1362 33 . . . 37158 1363 1 The the DT 37158 1363 2 Research Research NNP 37158 1363 3 Defence Defence NNP 37158 1363 4 Society Society NNP 37158 1363 5 will will MD 37158 1363 6 therefore therefore RB 37158 1363 7 endeavour endeavour VB 37158 1363 8 to to TO 37158 1363 9 make make VB 37158 1363 10 it -PRON- PRP 37158 1363 11 clear clear JJ 37158 1363 12 that that IN 37158 1363 13 medical medical JJ 37158 1363 14 and and CC 37158 1363 15 other other JJ 37158 1363 16 scientific scientific JJ 37158 1363 17 men man NNS 37158 1363 18 who who WP 37158 1363 19 employ employ VBP 37158 1363 20 these these DT 37158 1363 21 methods method NNS 37158 1363 22 are be VBP 37158 1363 23 not not RB 37158 1363 24 less less RBR 37158 1363 25 humane humane JJ 37158 1363 26 than than IN 37158 1363 27 the the DT 37158 1363 28 rest rest NN 37158 1363 29 of of IN 37158 1363 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1363 31 countrymen countryman NNS 37158 1363 32 , , , 37158 1363 33 who who WP 37158 1363 34 daily daily RB 37158 1363 35 , , , 37158 1363 36 though though IN 37158 1363 37 perhaps perhaps RB 37158 1363 38 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37158 1363 39 , , , 37158 1363 40 profit profit NN 37158 1363 41 by by IN 37158 1363 42 them -PRON- PRP 37158 1363 43 . . . 37158 1364 1 The the DT 37158 1364 2 Society Society NNP 37158 1364 3 proposes propose VBZ 37158 1364 4 to to TO 37158 1364 5 give give VB 37158 1364 6 information information NN 37158 1364 7 to to IN 37158 1364 8 all all DT 37158 1364 9 enquirers enquirer NNS 37158 1364 10 , , , 37158 1364 11 to to TO 37158 1364 12 publish publish VB 37158 1364 13 _ _ NNP 37158 1364 14 précis précis NN 37158 1364 15 _ _ NNP 37158 1364 16 , , , 37158 1364 17 articles article NNS 37158 1364 18 , , , 37158 1364 19 and and CC 37158 1364 20 leaflets leaflet NNS 37158 1364 21 , , , 37158 1364 22 to to TO 37158 1364 23 make make VB 37158 1364 24 arrangements arrangement NNS 37158 1364 25 for for IN 37158 1364 26 lectures lecture NNS 37158 1364 27 , , , 37158 1364 28 to to TO 37158 1364 29 send send VB 37158 1364 30 speakers speaker NNS 37158 1364 31 , , , 37158 1364 32 if if IN 37158 1364 33 required require VBN 37158 1364 34 , , , 37158 1364 35 to to IN 37158 1364 36 debates debate NNS 37158 1364 37 , , , 37158 1364 38 and and CC 37158 1364 39 to to TO 37158 1364 40 assist assist VB 37158 1364 41 all all DT 37158 1364 42 who who WP 37158 1364 43 desire desire VBP 37158 1364 44 to to TO 37158 1364 45 examine examine VB 37158 1364 46 the the DT 37158 1364 47 arguments argument NNS 37158 1364 48 on on IN 37158 1364 49 behalf behalf NN 37158 1364 50 of of IN 37158 1364 51 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1364 52 on on IN 37158 1364 53 animals animal NNS 37158 1364 54 . . . 37158 1365 1 It -PRON- PRP 37158 1365 2 hopes hope VBZ 37158 1365 3 to to TO 37158 1365 4 establish establish VB 37158 1365 5 branches branch NNS 37158 1365 6 in in IN 37158 1365 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1365 8 chief chief JJ 37158 1365 9 cities city NNS 37158 1365 10 , , , 37158 1365 11 and and CC 37158 1365 12 thus thus RB 37158 1365 13 to to TO 37158 1365 14 be be VB 37158 1365 15 in in IN 37158 1365 16 touch touch NN 37158 1365 17 with with IN 37158 1365 18 all all DT 37158 1365 19 parts part NNS 37158 1365 20 of of IN 37158 1365 21 the the DT 37158 1365 22 kingdom kingdom NN 37158 1365 23 ; ; , 37158 1365 24 and and CC 37158 1365 25 to to TO 37158 1365 26 be be VB 37158 1365 27 at at IN 37158 1365 28 the the DT 37158 1365 29 service service NN 37158 1365 30 of of IN 37158 1365 31 municipal municipal JJ 37158 1365 32 bodies body NNS 37158 1365 33 , , , 37158 1365 34 hospitals hospital NNS 37158 1365 35 , , , 37158 1365 36 and and CC 37158 1365 37 other other JJ 37158 1365 38 public public JJ 37158 1365 39 institutions institution NNS 37158 1365 40 . . . 37158 1366 1 The the DT 37158 1366 2 Society Society NNP 37158 1366 3 was be VBD 37158 1366 4 formed form VBN 37158 1366 5 on on IN 37158 1366 6 27th 27th JJ 37158 1366 7 January January NNP 37158 1366 8 of of IN 37158 1366 9 the the DT 37158 1366 10 present present JJ 37158 1366 11 year year NN 37158 1366 12 , , , 37158 1366 13 and and CC 37158 1366 14 already already RB 37158 1366 15 numbers number VBZ 37158 1366 16 more more JJR 37158 1366 17 than than IN 37158 1366 18 800 800 CD 37158 1366 19 members member NNS 37158 1366 20 . . . 37158 1367 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 1367 2 9 9 CD 37158 1367 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 1367 4 It -PRON- PRP 37158 1367 5 is be VBZ 37158 1367 6 not not RB 37158 1367 7 an an DT 37158 1367 8 association association NN 37158 1367 9 of of IN 37158 1367 10 men man NNS 37158 1367 11 of of IN 37158 1367 12 science science NN 37158 1367 13 or or CC 37158 1367 14 of of IN 37158 1367 15 medical medical JJ 37158 1367 16 men man NNS 37158 1367 17 alone alone RB 37158 1367 18 ; ; : 37158 1367 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 37158 1367 20 membership membership NN 37158 1367 21 has have VBZ 37158 1367 22 been be VBN 37158 1367 23 drawn draw VBN 37158 1367 24 from from IN 37158 1367 25 all all DT 37158 1367 26 departments department NNS 37158 1367 27 of of IN 37158 1367 28 public public JJ 37158 1367 29 life life NN 37158 1367 30 , , , 37158 1367 31 and and CC 37158 1367 32 includes include VBZ 37158 1367 33 representatives representative NNS 37158 1367 34 of of IN 37158 1367 35 every every DT 37158 1367 36 class class NN 37158 1367 37 of of IN 37158 1367 38 educated educate VBN 37158 1367 39 Englishmen Englishmen NNP 37158 1367 40 and and CC 37158 1367 41 Englishwomen Englishwomen NNP 37158 1367 42 , , , 37158 1367 43 including include VBG 37158 1367 44 many many JJ 37158 1367 45 who who WP 37158 1367 46 have have VBP 37158 1367 47 taken take VBN 37158 1367 48 an an DT 37158 1367 49 active active JJ 37158 1367 50 part part NN 37158 1367 51 in in IN 37158 1367 52 the the DT 37158 1367 53 prevention prevention NN 37158 1367 54 of of IN 37158 1367 55 cruelty cruelty NNP 37158 1367 56 to to IN 37158 1367 57 animals animal NNS 37158 1367 58 . . . 37158 1368 1 This this DT 37158 1368 2 fact fact NN 37158 1368 3 is be VBZ 37158 1368 4 in in IN 37158 1368 5 itself -PRON- PRP 37158 1368 6 a a DT 37158 1368 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 37158 1368 8 protest protest NN 37158 1368 9 against against IN 37158 1368 10 the the DT 37158 1368 11 attacks attack NNS 37158 1368 12 which which WDT 37158 1368 13 have have VBP 37158 1368 14 been be VBN 37158 1368 15 made make VBN 37158 1368 16 on on IN 37158 1368 17 the the DT 37158 1368 18 researches research NNS 37158 1368 19 that that WDT 37158 1368 20 the the DT 37158 1368 21 Society Society NNP 37158 1368 22 has have VBZ 37158 1368 23 been be VBN 37158 1368 24 formed form VBN 37158 1368 25 to to TO 37158 1368 26 defend defend VB 37158 1368 27 . . . 37158 1369 1 The the DT 37158 1369 2 annual annual JJ 37158 1369 3 subscription subscription NN 37158 1369 4 is be VBZ 37158 1369 5 five five CD 37158 1369 6 shillings shilling NNS 37158 1369 7 to to TO 37158 1369 8 cover cover VB 37158 1369 9 working working NN 37158 1369 10 expenses expense NNS 37158 1369 11 : : : 37158 1369 12 but but CC 37158 1369 13 larger large JJR 37158 1369 14 subscriptions subscription NNS 37158 1369 15 , , , 37158 1369 16 or or CC 37158 1369 17 donations donation NNS 37158 1369 18 , , , 37158 1369 19 will will MD 37158 1369 20 be be VB 37158 1369 21 gladly gladly RB 37158 1369 22 received receive VBN 37158 1369 23 . . . 37158 1370 1 The the DT 37158 1370 2 acting act VBG 37158 1370 3 Hon Hon NNP 37158 1370 4 . . . 37158 1371 1 Treasurer treasurer NN 37158 1371 2 , , , 37158 1371 3 _ _ NNP 37158 1371 4 pro pro JJ 37158 1371 5 tem tem NN 37158 1371 6 . . . 37158 1371 7 _ _ NNP 37158 1371 8 , , , 37158 1371 9 is be VBZ 37158 1371 10 Mr Mr NNP 37158 1371 11 J. J. NNP 37158 1371 12 Luard Luard NNP 37158 1371 13 Pattisson Pattisson NNP 37158 1371 14 , , , 37158 1371 15 C.B. C.B. NNP 37158 1372 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1372 2 of of IN 37158 1372 3 the the DT 37158 1372 4 Lister Lister NNP 37158 1372 5 Institute),[10 institute),[10 NN 37158 1372 6 ] ] -RRB- 37158 1372 7 and and CC 37158 1372 8 an an DT 37158 1372 9 account account NN 37158 1372 10 in in IN 37158 1372 11 the the DT 37158 1372 12 Society Society NNP 37158 1372 13 's 's POS 37158 1372 14 name name NN 37158 1372 15 has have VBZ 37158 1372 16 been be VBN 37158 1372 17 opened open VBN 37158 1372 18 with with IN 37158 1372 19 Messrs Messrs NNP 37158 1372 20 Coutts Coutts NNP 37158 1372 21 & & CC 37158 1372 22 Co. Co. NNP 37158 1372 23 , , , 37158 1372 24 440 440 CD 37158 1372 25 Strand Strand NNP 37158 1372 26 . . . 37158 1373 1 The the DT 37158 1373 2 Hon Hon NNP 37158 1373 3 . . . 37158 1374 1 Secretary Secretary NNP 37158 1374 2 is be VBZ 37158 1374 3 Mr Mr NNP 37158 1374 4 Stephen Stephen NNP 37158 1374 5 Paget Paget NNP 37158 1374 6 , , , 37158 1374 7 70 70 CD 37158 1374 8 Harley Harley NNP 37158 1374 9 Street Street NNP 37158 1374 10 , , , 37158 1374 11 W. W. NNP 37158 1374 12 , , , 37158 1374 13 to to IN 37158 1374 14 whom whom WP 37158 1374 15 all all DT 37158 1374 16 communications communication NNS 37158 1374 17 should should MD 37158 1374 18 be be VB 37158 1374 19 addressed address VBN 37158 1374 20 . . . 37158 1375 1 Yours -PRON- PRP 37158 1375 2 faithfully faithfully RB 37158 1375 3 , , , 37158 1375 4 CROMER CROMER NNP 37158 1375 5 , , , 37158 1375 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1375 7 President President NNP 37158 1375 8 _ _ NNP 37158 1375 9 . . . 37158 1376 1 The the DT 37158 1376 2 following follow VBG 37158 1376 3 is be VBZ 37158 1376 4 a a DT 37158 1376 5 list list NN 37158 1376 6 of of IN 37158 1376 7 the the DT 37158 1376 8 pamphlets pamphlet NNS 37158 1376 9 already already RB 37158 1376 10 issued issue VBN 37158 1376 11 by by IN 37158 1376 12 the the DT 37158 1376 13 Society:-- Society:-- NNP 37158 1376 14 1 1 CD 37158 1376 15 . . . 37158 1377 1 Letter letter NN 37158 1377 2 from from IN 37158 1377 3 the the DT 37158 1377 4 President President NNP 37158 1377 5 announcing announce VBG 37158 1377 6 the the DT 37158 1377 7 formation formation NN 37158 1377 8 of of IN 37158 1377 9 the the DT 37158 1377 10 Society Society NNP 37158 1377 11 , , , 37158 1377 12 April April NNP 37158 1377 13 24 24 CD 37158 1377 14 . . . 37158 1378 1 2 2 LS 37158 1378 2 . . . 37158 1379 1 Report report NN 37158 1379 2 of of IN 37158 1379 3 the the DT 37158 1379 4 inaugural inaugural JJ 37158 1379 5 meeting meeting NN 37158 1379 6 . . . 37158 1380 1 3 3 LS 37158 1380 2 . . . 37158 1381 1 Experiments experiment NNS 37158 1381 2 on on IN 37158 1381 3 animals animal NNS 37158 1381 4 during during IN 37158 1381 5 1907 1907 CD 37158 1381 6 in in IN 37158 1381 7 Great Great NNP 37158 1381 8 Britain Britain NNP 37158 1381 9 and and CC 37158 1381 10 Ireland Ireland NNP 37158 1381 11 . . . 37158 1382 1 4 4 LS 37158 1382 2 . . . 37158 1383 1 Some some DT 37158 1383 2 facts fact NNS 37158 1383 3 as as IN 37158 1383 4 to to IN 37158 1383 5 the the DT 37158 1383 6 administration administration NN 37158 1383 7 of of IN 37158 1383 8 the the DT 37158 1383 9 Act Act NNP 37158 1383 10 . . . 37158 1384 1 5 5 CD 37158 1384 2 . . . 37158 1385 1 The the DT 37158 1385 2 value value NN 37158 1385 3 of of IN 37158 1385 4 antitoxin antitoxin NN 37158 1385 5 in in IN 37158 1385 6 the the DT 37158 1385 7 treatment treatment NN 37158 1385 8 of of IN 37158 1385 9 diphtheria diphtheria NN 37158 1385 10 . . . 37158 1386 1 6 6 CD 37158 1386 2 . . . 37158 1387 1 Evidence evidence NN 37158 1387 2 of of IN 37158 1387 3 Sir Sir NNP 37158 1387 4 Frederick Frederick NNP 37158 1387 5 Treves Treves NNP 37158 1387 6 . . . 37158 1388 1 7 7 LS 37158 1388 2 . . . 37158 1389 1 Yellow yellow JJ 37158 1389 2 fever fever NN 37158 1389 3 and and CC 37158 1389 4 malaria malaria NN 37158 1389 5 . . . 37158 1390 1 8 8 LS 37158 1390 2 . . . 37158 1391 1 Extinction Extinction NNP 37158 1391 2 of of IN 37158 1391 3 Malta Malta NNP 37158 1391 4 fever fever NN 37158 1391 5 . . . 37158 1392 1 9 9 CD 37158 1392 2 . . . 37158 1393 1 Have have VBP 37158 1393 2 experiments experiment NNS 37158 1393 3 on on IN 37158 1393 4 animals animal NNS 37158 1393 5 advanced advanced JJ 37158 1393 6 Therapeutics therapeutic NNS 37158 1393 7 ? ? . 37158 1394 1 10 10 CD 37158 1394 2 . . . 37158 1395 1 The the DT 37158 1395 2 work work NN 37158 1395 3 of of IN 37158 1395 4 the the DT 37158 1395 5 Research Research NNP 37158 1395 6 Defence Defence NNP 37158 1395 7 Society Society NNP 37158 1395 8 . . . 37158 1396 1 11 11 CD 37158 1396 2 . . . 37158 1397 1 Vivisection vivisection NN 37158 1397 2 and and CC 37158 1397 3 medicine medicine NN 37158 1397 4 . . . 37158 1398 1 Evidence evidence NN 37158 1398 2 of of IN 37158 1398 3 Lord Lord NNP 37158 1398 4 Justice Justice NNP 37158 1398 5 Fletcher Fletcher NNP 37158 1398 6 Moulton Moulton NNP 37158 1398 7 before before IN 37158 1398 8 the the DT 37158 1398 9 Royal Royal NNP 37158 1398 10 Commission Commission NNP 37158 1398 11 . . . 37158 1399 1 All all DT 37158 1399 2 or or CC 37158 1399 3 any any DT 37158 1399 4 of of IN 37158 1399 5 these these DT 37158 1399 6 will will MD 37158 1399 7 be be VB 37158 1399 8 forwarded forward VBN 37158 1399 9 on on IN 37158 1399 10 application application NN 37158 1399 11 to to IN 37158 1399 12 the the DT 37158 1399 13 Hon Hon NNP 37158 1399 14 . . . 37158 1400 1 Secretary Secretary NNP 37158 1400 2 , , , 37158 1400 3 Mr Mr NNP 37158 1400 4 Stephen Stephen NNP 37158 1400 5 Paget Paget NNP 37158 1400 6 , , , 37158 1400 7 70 70 CD 37158 1400 8 Harley Harley NNP 37158 1400 9 Street Street NNP 37158 1400 10 , , , 37158 1400 11 London London NNP 37158 1400 12 , , , 37158 1400 13 W. W. NNP 37158 1400 14 Other other JJ 37158 1400 15 pamphlets pamphlet NNS 37158 1400 16 are be VBP 37158 1400 17 in in IN 37158 1400 18 active active JJ 37158 1400 19 preparation preparation NN 37158 1400 20 ; ; : 37158 1400 21 arrangements arrangement NNS 37158 1400 22 are be VBP 37158 1400 23 also also RB 37158 1400 24 being be VBG 37158 1400 25 made make VBN 37158 1400 26 for for IN 37158 1400 27 meetings meeting NNS 37158 1400 28 , , , 37158 1400 29 and and CC 37158 1400 30 for for IN 37158 1400 31 the the DT 37158 1400 32 organisation organisation NN 37158 1400 33 of of IN 37158 1400 34 Branch Branch NNP 37158 1400 35 Societies Societies NNPS 37158 1400 36 in in IN 37158 1400 37 many many JJ 37158 1400 38 parts part NNS 37158 1400 39 of of IN 37158 1400 40 the the DT 37158 1400 41 kingdom kingdom NN 37158 1400 42 ; ; : 37158 1400 43 the the DT 37158 1400 44 Society Society NNP 37158 1400 45 is be VBZ 37158 1400 46 also also RB 37158 1400 47 concerned concerned JJ 37158 1400 48 in in IN 37158 1400 49 the the DT 37158 1400 50 institution institution NN 37158 1400 51 of of IN 37158 1400 52 a a DT 37158 1400 53 similar similar JJ 37158 1400 54 movement movement NN 37158 1400 55 for for IN 37158 1400 56 the the DT 37158 1400 57 defence defence NN 37158 1400 58 of of IN 37158 1400 59 research research NN 37158 1400 60 in in IN 37158 1400 61 America America NNP 37158 1400 62 . . . 37158 1401 1 Space space NN 37158 1401 2 does do VBZ 37158 1401 3 not not RB 37158 1401 4 permit permit VB 37158 1401 5 the the DT 37158 1401 6 publication publication NN 37158 1401 7 of of IN 37158 1401 8 the the DT 37158 1401 9 full full JJ 37158 1401 10 list list NN 37158 1401 11 of of IN 37158 1401 12 members member NNS 37158 1401 13 of of IN 37158 1401 14 the the DT 37158 1401 15 Society Society NNP 37158 1401 16 . . . 37158 1402 1 The the DT 37158 1402 2 following following JJ 37158 1402 3 list list NN 37158 1402 4 of of IN 37158 1402 5 the the DT 37158 1402 6 President President NNP 37158 1402 7 and and CC 37158 1402 8 Vice Vice NNP 37158 1402 9 - - HYPH 37158 1402 10 Presidents Presidents NNPS 37158 1402 11 , , , 37158 1402 12 however however RB 37158 1402 13 , , , 37158 1402 14 will will MD 37158 1402 15 show show VB 37158 1402 16 that that IN 37158 1402 17 those those DT 37158 1402 18 who who WP 37158 1402 19 have have VBP 37158 1402 20 joined join VBN 37158 1402 21 are be VBP 37158 1402 22 representative representative JJ 37158 1402 23 not not RB 37158 1402 24 only only RB 37158 1402 25 of of IN 37158 1402 26 the the DT 37158 1402 27 leading lead VBG 37158 1402 28 men man NNS 37158 1402 29 and and CC 37158 1402 30 women woman NNS 37158 1402 31 in in IN 37158 1402 32 the the DT 37158 1402 33 medical medical JJ 37158 1402 34 profession profession NN 37158 1402 35 , , , 37158 1402 36 but but CC 37158 1402 37 also also RB 37158 1402 38 of of IN 37158 1402 39 those those DT 37158 1402 40 who who WP 37158 1402 41 are be VBP 37158 1402 42 pre pre JJ 37158 1402 43 - - JJ 37158 1402 44 eminent eminent JJ 37158 1402 45 in in IN 37158 1402 46 various various JJ 37158 1402 47 other other JJ 37158 1402 48 branches branch NNS 37158 1402 49 of of IN 37158 1402 50 science science NN 37158 1402 51 , , , 37158 1402 52 in in IN 37158 1402 53 literature literature NN 37158 1402 54 , , , 37158 1402 55 politics politic NNS 37158 1402 56 , , , 37158 1402 57 art art NN 37158 1402 58 , , , 37158 1402 59 and and CC 37158 1402 60 theology theology NN 37158 1402 61 . . . 37158 1403 1 PRESIDENT PRESIDENT NNP 37158 1403 2 THE the DT 37158 1403 3 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1403 4 OF of IN 37158 1403 5 CROMER CROMER NNP 37158 1403 6 , , , 37158 1403 7 G.C.B. G.C.B. NNP 37158 1403 8 , , , 37158 1403 9 G.C.M.G. G.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1403 10 , , , 37158 1403 11 O.M. O.M. NNP 37158 1404 1 VICE VICE NNP 37158 1404 2 - - HYPH 37158 1404 3 PRESIDENTS presidents NN 37158 1404 4 HIS his PRP$ 37158 1404 5 GRACE grace NN 37158 1404 6 THE the DT 37158 1404 7 DUKE duke NN 37158 1404 8 OF of IN 37158 1404 9 ABERCORN ABERCORN NNP 37158 1404 10 , , , 37158 1404 11 K.G. K.G. NNP 37158 1405 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1405 2 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNP 37158 1405 3 ABNEY ABNEY NNP 37158 1405 4 , , , 37158 1405 5 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1405 6 , , , 37158 1405 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1406 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1406 2 T. T. NNP 37158 1406 3 CLIFFORD CLIFFORD NNP 37158 1406 4 ALLBUTT ALLBUTT NNP 37158 1406 5 , , , 37158 1406 6 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1406 7 , , , 37158 1406 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1407 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1407 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1407 3 Regius Regius NNP 37158 1407 4 Professor Professor NNP 37158 1407 5 of of IN 37158 1407 6 Physic Physic NNP 37158 1407 7 , , , 37158 1407 8 University University NNP 37158 1407 9 of of IN 37158 1407 10 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 37158 1407 11 _ _ NNP 37158 1407 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1407 13 . . . 37158 1408 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1408 2 L. L. NNP 37158 1408 3 ALMA ALMA NNP 37158 1408 4 - - HYPH 37158 1408 5 TADEMA TADEMA NNP 37158 1408 6 , , , 37158 1408 7 O.M. O.M. NNP 37158 1408 8 , , , 37158 1408 9 R.A. R.A. NNP 37158 1408 10 MRS MRS NNP 37158 1408 11 GARRETT GARRETT NNP 37158 1408 12 ANDERSON ANDERSON NNP 37158 1408 13 , , , 37158 1408 14 M.D. M.D. NNP 37158 1409 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1409 2 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNP 37158 1409 3 ANSON ANSON NNP 37158 1409 4 , , , 37158 1409 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1409 6 . . NNP 37158 1409 7 , , , 37158 1409 8 D.C.L. D.C.L. NNP 37158 1409 9 , , , 37158 1409 10 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1410 1 THE the DT 37158 1410 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1410 3 . . . 37158 1411 1 HON hon NN 37158 1411 2 . . . 37158 1412 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1412 2 AVEBURY AVEBURY NNP 37158 1412 3 , , , 37158 1412 4 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1413 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 1413 2 A]SIR A]SIR NNP 37158 1413 3 JOHN JOHN NNP 37158 1413 4 BANKS BANKS NNP 37158 1413 5 , , , 37158 1413 6 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1413 7 , , , 37158 1413 8 M.D. M.D. NNP 37158 1414 1 THE the DT 37158 1414 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1414 3 . . . 37158 1415 1 HON hon NN 37158 1415 2 . . . 37158 1416 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1416 2 BARRYMORE BARRYMORE NNP 37158 1416 3 . . . 37158 1417 1 THE the DT 37158 1417 2 MARQUIS MARQUIS NNP 37158 1417 3 OF of IN 37158 1417 4 BATH BATH NNP 37158 1417 5 . . . 37158 1418 1 LADY LADY NNP 37158 1418 2 BLISS BLISS NNP 37158 1418 3 . . . 37158 1419 1 LADY LADY NNP 37158 1419 2 BUCKLEY BUCKLEY NNP 37158 1419 3 . . . 37158 1420 1 LADY LADY NNP 37158 1420 2 BURDON BURDON NNP 37158 1420 3 - - HYPH 37158 1420 4 SANDERSON SANDERSON NNP 37158 1420 5 . . . 37158 1421 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1421 2 BLYTH BLYTH NNP 37158 1421 3 . . . 37158 1422 1 THE the DT 37158 1422 2 VERY VERY NNP 37158 1422 3 REV REV NNP 37158 1422 4 . . . 37158 1423 1 THE the DT 37158 1423 2 DEAN DEAN NNP 37158 1423 3 OF of IN 37158 1423 4 CANTERBURY CANTERBURY NNP 37158 1423 5 , , , 37158 1423 6 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1424 1 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1424 2 CATHCART CATHCART NNP 37158 1424 3 . . . 37158 1425 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1425 2 ROBERT ROBERT NNP 37158 1425 3 CECIL CECIL NNP 37158 1425 4 , , , 37158 1425 5 K.C. K.C. NNP 37158 1425 6 , , , 37158 1425 7 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1426 1 THE the DT 37158 1426 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1426 3 . . . 37158 1427 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1427 2 . . . 37158 1428 1 THE the DT 37158 1428 2 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1428 3 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1428 4 OF of IN 37158 1428 5 CHESTER CHESTER NNP 37158 1428 6 , , , 37158 1428 7 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1429 1 THE the DT 37158 1429 2 VERY VERY NNP 37158 1429 3 REV REV NNP 37158 1429 4 . . . 37158 1430 1 THE the DT 37158 1430 2 DEAN DEAN NNP 37158 1430 3 OF of IN 37158 1430 4 CHESTER CHESTER NNP 37158 1430 5 , , , 37158 1430 6 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1431 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1431 2 CHEYLESMORE CHEYLESMORE NNP 37158 1431 3 , , , 37158 1431 4 C.V.O. C.V.O. NNP 37158 1432 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1432 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1432 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1432 4 , , , 37158 1432 5 Middlesex Middlesex NNP 37158 1432 6 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1432 7 _ _ NNP 37158 1432 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1432 9 . . . 37158 1433 1 THE the DT 37158 1433 2 VERY VERY NNP 37158 1433 3 REV REV NNP 37158 1433 4 . . . 37158 1434 1 THE the DT 37158 1434 2 DEAN DEAN NNP 37158 1434 3 OF of IN 37158 1434 4 CHRIST CHRIST NNP 37158 1434 5 CHURCH CHURCH NNP 37158 1434 6 , , , 37158 1434 7 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1435 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1435 2 JAMES JAMES NNP 37158 1435 3 CRICHTON CRICHTON NNP 37158 1435 4 - - HYPH 37158 1435 5 BROWNE BROWNE NNP 37158 1435 6 , , , 37158 1435 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1436 1 THE the DT 37158 1436 2 COUNTESS COUNTESS NNP 37158 1436 3 OF of IN 37158 1436 4 CROMER CROMER NNP 37158 1436 5 . . . 37158 1437 1 THE the DT 37158 1437 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1437 3 . . . 37158 1438 1 HON hon NN 37158 1438 2 . . . 37158 1439 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1439 2 SAVILE SAVILE NNP 37158 1439 3 CROSSLEY CROSSLEY NNP 37158 1439 4 , , , 37158 1439 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1439 6 . . NNP 37158 1439 7 , , , 37158 1439 8 M.V.O. M.V.O. NNP 37158 1440 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1440 2 EDMUND EDMUND NNP 37158 1440 3 HAY HAY NNP 37158 1440 4 CURRIE CURRIE NNP 37158 1440 5 . . . 37158 1441 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1441 2 CURZON CURZON NNP 37158 1441 3 OF of IN 37158 1441 4 KEDLESTON KEDLESTON NNP 37158 1441 5 , , , 37158 1441 6 G.C.S.I. G.C.S.I. NNP 37158 1441 7 , , , 37158 1441 8 G.C.I.E. G.C.I.E. NNP 37158 1441 9 , , , 37158 1441 10 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1442 1 THE the DT 37158 1442 2 REV REV NNP 37158 1442 3 . . . 37158 1443 1 DR DR NNP 37158 1443 2 DALLINGER DALLINGER NNP 37158 1443 3 , , , 37158 1443 4 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1444 1 FRANCIS FRANCIS NNP 37158 1444 2 DARWIN DARWIN NNP 37158 1444 3 , , , 37158 1444 4 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1444 5 . . NNP 37158 1444 6 , , , 37158 1444 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1445 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1445 2 GEORGE GEORGE NNP 37158 1445 3 H. H. NNP 37158 1445 4 DARWIN DARWIN NNP 37158 1445 5 , , , 37158 1445 6 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1445 7 , , , 37158 1445 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1446 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1446 2 JAMES JAMES NNP 37158 1446 3 DEWAR DEWAR NNP 37158 1446 4 , , , 37158 1446 5 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1447 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1447 2 A. a. NN 37158 1447 3 CONAN CONAN NNP 37158 1447 4 DOYLE DOYLE NNP 37158 1447 5 , , , 37158 1447 6 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1448 1 THE the DT 37158 1448 2 REV REV NNP 37158 1448 3 . . . 37158 1449 1 CANON CANON NNP 37158 1449 2 DUCKWORTH DUCKWORTH NNP 37158 1449 3 , , , 37158 1449 4 C.V.O. C.V.O. NNP 37158 1450 1 THE the DT 37158 1450 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1450 3 . . . 37158 1451 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1451 2 . . . 37158 1452 1 THE the DT 37158 1452 2 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1452 3 OF of IN 37158 1452 4 EDINBURGH EDINBURGH NNP 37158 1452 5 , , , 37158 1452 6 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1453 1 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1453 2 EGERTON EGERTON NNP 37158 1453 3 . . . 37158 1454 1 THE the DT 37158 1454 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1454 3 . . . 37158 1455 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1455 2 . . . 37158 1456 1 THE the DT 37158 1456 2 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1456 3 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1456 4 OF of IN 37158 1456 5 EXETER EXETER NNP 37158 1456 6 , , , 37158 1456 7 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1457 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1457 2 FABER FABER NNP 37158 1457 3 . . . 37158 1458 1 THE the DT 37158 1458 2 REV REV NNP 37158 1458 3 . . . 37158 1459 1 A. A. NNP 37158 1459 2 M. M. NNP 37158 1459 3 FAIRBAIRN FAIRBAIRN NNP 37158 1459 4 , , , 37158 1459 5 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1459 6 , , , 37158 1459 7 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1460 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1460 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1460 3 Principal Principal NNP 37158 1460 4 of of IN 37158 1460 5 Mansfield Mansfield NNP 37158 1460 6 College College NNP 37158 1460 7 , , , 37158 1460 8 Oxford Oxford NNP 37158 1460 9 _ _ NNP 37158 1460 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1460 11 . . . 37158 1461 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1461 2 FARRER FARRER NNP 37158 1461 3 . . . 37158 1462 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1462 2 LUKE LUKE NNP 37158 1462 3 FILDES FILDES NNP 37158 1462 4 , , , 37158 1462 5 R.A. R.A. NNP 37158 1462 6 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1462 7 FORTESCUE FORTESCUE NNP 37158 1462 8 . . . 37158 1463 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1463 2 THOMAS THOMAS NNP 37158 1463 3 FRASER FRASER NNP 37158 1463 4 , , , 37158 1463 5 M.D. M.D. NNP 37158 1463 6 , , , 37158 1463 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1464 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1464 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1464 3 Professor Professor NNP 37158 1464 4 of of IN 37158 1464 5 Clinical Clinical NNP 37158 1464 6 Medicine Medicine NNP 37158 1464 7 , , , 37158 1464 8 University University NNP 37158 1464 9 of of IN 37158 1464 10 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP 37158 1464 11 _ _ NNP 37158 1464 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1464 13 . . . 37158 1465 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1465 2 DAVID DAVID NNP 37158 1465 3 GILL GILL NNP 37158 1465 4 , , , 37158 1465 5 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1465 6 , , , 37158 1465 7 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1465 8 , , , 37158 1465 9 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1466 1 THE the DT 37158 1466 2 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1466 3 OF of IN 37158 1466 4 GLASGOW GLASGOW NNP 37158 1466 5 , , , 37158 1466 6 G.C.M.G. G.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1467 1 THE the DT 37158 1467 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1467 3 . . . 37158 1468 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1468 2 . . . 37158 1469 1 THE the DT 37158 1469 2 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1469 3 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1469 4 OF of IN 37158 1469 5 GRANTHAM GRANTHAM NNP 37158 1469 6 , , , 37158 1469 7 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1470 1 FIELD FIELD NNP 37158 1470 2 - - HYPH 37158 1470 3 MARSHAL marshal NN 37158 1470 4 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1470 5 GRENFELL GRENFELL NNP 37158 1470 6 , , , 37158 1470 7 G.C.B. G.C.B. NNP 37158 1470 8 , , , 37158 1470 9 G.C.M.G. G.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1471 1 THE the DT 37158 1471 2 HON hon NN 37158 1471 3 . . . 37158 1472 1 WALTER WALTER NNP 37158 1472 2 GUINNESS GUINNESS NNP 37158 1472 3 , , , 37158 1472 4 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1473 1 THE the DT 37158 1473 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1473 3 . . . 37158 1474 1 HON hon NN 37158 1474 2 . . . 37158 1475 1 THE the DT 37158 1475 2 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1475 3 OF of IN 37158 1475 4 HALSBURY HALSBURY NNP 37158 1475 5 , , , 37158 1475 6 K.B. K.B. NNP 37158 1475 7 , , , 37158 1475 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1476 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1476 2 CLAUD CLAUD NNP 37158 1476 3 HAMILTON HAMILTON NNP 37158 1476 4 . . . 37158 1477 1 H. H. NNP 37158 1477 2 A. A. NNP 37158 1477 3 HARBEN HARBEN NNP 37158 1477 4 , , , 37158 1477 5 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1477 6 . . . 37158 1478 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1478 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1478 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1478 4 , , , 37158 1478 5 St St NNP 37158 1478 6 Mary Mary NNP 37158 1478 7 's 's POS 37158 1478 8 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1478 9 _ _ NNP 37158 1478 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1478 11 . . . 37158 1479 1 J. J. NNP 37158 1479 2 T. T. NNP 37158 1479 3 HELBY HELBY NNP 37158 1479 4 , , , 37158 1479 5 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1479 6 . . . 37158 1480 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1480 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1480 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1480 4 , , , 37158 1480 5 Metropolitan Metropolitan NNP 37158 1480 6 Asylums Asylums NNP 37158 1480 7 Board Board NNP 37158 1480 8 _ _ NNP 37158 1480 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1480 10 . . . 37158 1481 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1481 2 SAMUEL SAMUEL NNP 37158 1481 3 HOARE HOARE NNP 37158 1481 4 , , , 37158 1481 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1481 6 . . . 37158 1482 1 THE the DT 37158 1482 2 HON hon NN 37158 1482 3 . . . 37158 1483 1 SYDNEY SYDNEY NNP 37158 1483 2 HOLLAND HOLLAND NNP 37158 1483 3 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1483 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1483 5 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1483 6 , , , 37158 1483 7 London London NNP 37158 1483 8 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1483 9 _ _ NNP 37158 1483 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1483 11 . . . 37158 1484 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1484 2 JOSEPH JOSEPH NNP 37158 1484 3 DALTON DALTON NNP 37158 1484 4 HOOKER HOOKER NNP 37158 1484 5 , , , 37158 1484 6 G.C.S.I. G.C.S.I. NNP 37158 1484 7 , , , 37158 1484 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1484 9 , , , 37158 1484 10 O.M. O.M. NNP 37158 1485 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1485 2 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNP 37158 1485 3 HUGGINS HUGGINS NNP 37158 1485 4 , , , 37158 1485 5 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1485 6 , , , 37158 1485 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1485 8 , , , 37158 1485 9 O.M. O.M. NNP 37158 1486 1 J. J. NNP 37158 1486 2 HUGHLINGS HUGHLINGS NNP 37158 1486 3 JACKSON JACKSON NNP 37158 1486 4 , , , 37158 1486 5 M.D. M.D. NNP 37158 1486 6 , , , 37158 1486 7 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1486 8 , , , 37158 1486 9 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1487 1 MONTAGUE MONTAGUE NNP 37158 1487 2 RHODES RHODES NNP 37158 1487 3 JAMES JAMES NNP 37158 1487 4 , , , 37158 1487 5 LITT.D. litt.d. XX 37158 1488 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1488 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1488 3 Provost Provost NNP 37158 1488 4 of of IN 37158 1488 5 King King NNP 37158 1488 6 's 's POS 37158 1488 7 College College NNP 37158 1488 8 , , , 37158 1488 9 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 37158 1488 10 _ _ NNP 37158 1488 11 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1488 12 . . . 37158 1489 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1489 2 ALFRED ALFRED NNP 37158 1489 3 JONES JONES NNP 37158 1489 4 , , , 37158 1489 5 K.C.M.G. K.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1490 1 THE the DT 37158 1490 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1490 3 . . . 37158 1491 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1491 2 . . . 37158 1492 1 THE the DT 37158 1492 2 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1492 3 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1492 4 OF of IN 37158 1492 5 KINGSTON KINGSTON NNP 37158 1492 6 . . . 37158 1493 1 THE the DT 37158 1493 2 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1493 3 OF of IN 37158 1493 4 KILMOREY KILMOREY NNP 37158 1493 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1493 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1493 7 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1493 8 , , , 37158 1493 9 Charing Charing NNP 37158 1493 10 Cross Cross NNP 37158 1493 11 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1493 12 _ _ NNP 37158 1493 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1493 14 . . . 37158 1494 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1494 2 LAMINGTON LAMINGTON NNP 37158 1494 3 , , , 37158 1494 4 G.C.M.G. G.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1495 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1495 2 E. E. NNP 37158 1495 3 RAY RAY NNP 37158 1495 4 LANKESTER LANKESTER NNP 37158 1495 5 , , , 37158 1495 6 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1495 7 , , , 37158 1495 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1496 1 R. R. NNP 37158 1496 2 F. F. NNP 37158 1496 3 C. C. NNP 37158 1496 4 LEITH LEITH NNP 37158 1496 5 , , , 37158 1496 6 M.SC M.SC NNP 37158 1496 7 . . NNP 37158 1496 8 , , , 37158 1496 9 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1496 10 _ _ NNP 37158 1496 11 Professor Professor NNP 37158 1496 12 of of IN 37158 1496 13 Pathology Pathology NNP 37158 1496 14 , , , 37158 1496 15 Birmingham Birmingham NNP 37158 1496 16 _ _ NNP 37158 1496 17 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1496 18 . . . 37158 1497 1 THE the DT 37158 1497 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1497 3 . . . 37158 1498 1 HON hon NN 37158 1498 2 . . . 37158 1499 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1499 2 LINDLEY LINDLEY NNP 37158 1499 3 , , , 37158 1499 4 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1499 5 , , , 37158 1499 6 D.C.L. D.C.L. NNP 37158 1499 7 , , , 37158 1499 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1500 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1500 2 NORMAN NORMAN NNP 37158 1500 3 LOCKYER LOCKYER NNP 37158 1500 4 , , , 37158 1500 5 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1500 6 , , , 37158 1500 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1501 1 THE the DT 37158 1501 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1501 3 . . . 37158 1502 1 HON hon NN 37158 1502 2 . . . 37158 1503 1 WALTER WALTER NNP 37158 1503 2 LONG LONG NNP 37158 1503 3 , , , 37158 1503 4 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1504 1 HENRY HENRY NNP 37158 1504 2 LUCAS LUCAS NNP 37158 1504 3 , , , 37158 1504 4 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1504 5 . . . 37158 1505 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1505 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1505 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1505 4 , , , 37158 1505 5 University University NNP 37158 1505 6 College College NNP 37158 1505 7 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1505 8 _ _ NNP 37158 1505 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1505 10 . . . 37158 1506 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1506 2 LUDLOW LUDLOW NNP 37158 1506 3 . . . 37158 1507 1 THE the DT 37158 1507 2 HON hon NN 37158 1507 3 . . . 37158 1508 1 G. G. NNP 37158 1508 2 W. W. NNP 37158 1508 3 SPENCER SPENCER NNP 37158 1508 4 LYTTELTON LYTTELTON NNP 37158 1508 5 , , , 37158 1508 6 C.B. C.B. NNP 37158 1509 1 FREDERICK FREDERICK NNP 37158 1509 2 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 37158 1509 3 , , , 37158 1509 4 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1509 5 . . . 37158 1510 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1510 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1510 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1510 4 , , , 37158 1510 5 National National NNP 37158 1510 6 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1510 7 for for IN 37158 1510 8 the the DT 37158 1510 9 Paralysed Paralysed NNP 37158 1510 10 and and CC 37158 1510 11 Epileptic Epileptic NNP 37158 1510 12 _ _ NNP 37158 1510 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1510 14 . . . 37158 1511 1 THE the DT 37158 1511 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1511 3 . . . 37158 1512 1 HON hon NN 37158 1512 2 . . . 37158 1513 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1513 2 HERBERT HERBERT NNP 37158 1513 3 E. E. NNP 37158 1513 4 MAXWELL MAXWELL NNP 37158 1513 5 , , , 37158 1513 6 BT BT NNP 37158 1513 7 . . NNP 37158 1513 8 , , , 37158 1513 9 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1514 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1514 2 METHUEN METHUEN NNP 37158 1514 3 , , , 37158 1514 4 G.C.B. G.C.B. NNP 37158 1514 5 , , , 37158 1514 6 K.C.V.O. K.C.V.O. NNP 37158 1515 1 HER her PRP 37158 1515 2 GRACE grace VBP 37158 1515 3 THE the DT 37158 1515 4 DUCHESS DUCHESS NNP 37158 1515 5 OF of IN 37158 1515 6 MONTROSE MONTROSE NNP 37158 1515 7 . . . 37158 1516 1 LADY LADY NNP 37158 1516 2 DOROTHY DOROTHY NNP 37158 1516 3 NEVILL NEVILL NNP 37158 1516 4 . . . 37158 1517 1 THE the DT 37158 1517 2 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1517 3 OF of IN 37158 1517 4 NORTHBROOK NORTHBROOK NNP 37158 1517 5 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1517 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1517 7 President President NNP 37158 1517 8 , , , 37158 1517 9 Cancer Cancer NNP 37158 1517 10 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1517 11 _ _ NNP 37158 1517 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1517 13 . . . 37158 1518 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1518 2 NORTHCLIFFE NORTHCLIFFE NNP 37158 1518 3 . . . 37158 1519 1 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNP 37158 1519 2 OSLER OSLER NNP 37158 1519 3 , , , 37158 1519 4 M.D. M.D. NNP 37158 1519 5 , , , 37158 1519 6 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1520 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1520 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1520 3 Regius Regius NNP 37158 1520 4 Professor Professor NNP 37158 1520 5 of of IN 37158 1520 6 Medicine Medicine NNP 37158 1520 7 , , , 37158 1520 8 University University NNP 37158 1520 9 of of IN 37158 1520 10 Oxford Oxford NNP 37158 1520 11 _ _ NNP 37158 1520 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1520 13 . . . 37158 1521 1 THE the DT 37158 1521 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1521 3 . . . 37158 1522 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1522 2 . . . 37158 1523 1 THE the DT 37158 1523 2 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1523 3 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1523 4 OF of IN 37158 1523 5 OXFORD OXFORD NNP 37158 1523 6 , , , 37158 1523 7 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1524 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1524 2 GILBERT GILBERT NNP 37158 1524 3 PARKER PARKER NNP 37158 1524 4 , , , 37158 1524 5 D.C.L. D.C.L. NNP 37158 1524 6 , , , 37158 1524 7 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1525 1 EDEN EDEN NNP 37158 1525 2 PHILLPOTTS PHILLPOTTS NNP 37158 1525 3 , , , 37158 1525 4 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1525 5 . . . 37158 1526 1 COUNT count NN 37158 1526 2 PLUNKETT PLUNKETT NNP 37158 1526 3 . . . 37158 1527 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1527 2 FREDERICK FREDERICK NNP 37158 1527 3 POLLOCK POLLOCK NNP 37158 1527 4 , , , 37158 1527 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1527 6 . . NNP 37158 1527 7 , , , 37158 1527 8 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1527 9 , , , 37158 1527 10 D.C.L. D.C.L. NNP 37158 1528 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1528 2 JOHN JOHN NNP 37158 1528 3 DICKSON DICKSON NNP 37158 1528 4 POYNDER POYNDER NNP 37158 1528 5 , , , 37158 1528 6 BT BT NNP 37158 1528 7 . . NNP 37158 1528 8 , , , 37158 1528 9 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1529 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1529 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1529 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1529 4 , , , 37158 1529 5 Great Great NNP 37158 1529 6 Northern Northern NNP 37158 1529 7 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1529 8 _ _ NNP 37158 1529 9 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1529 10 . . . 37158 1530 1 LADY LADY NNP 37158 1530 2 PRIESTLEY PRIESTLEY NNP 37158 1530 3 . . . 37158 1531 1 THE the DT 37158 1531 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1531 3 . . . 37158 1532 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1532 2 . . . 37158 1533 1 THE the DT 37158 1533 2 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1533 3 OF of IN 37158 1533 4 NORTH NORTH NNP 37158 1533 5 QUEENSLAND QUEENSLAND NNP 37158 1533 6 , , , 37158 1533 7 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1534 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1534 2 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNP 37158 1534 3 RAMSAY RAMSAY NNP 37158 1534 4 , , , 37158 1534 5 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1534 6 , , , 37158 1534 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1535 1 THE the DT 37158 1535 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1535 3 . . . 37158 1536 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1536 2 . . . 37158 1537 1 THE the DT 37158 1537 2 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1537 3 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1537 4 OF of IN 37158 1537 5 RANGOON RANGOON NNP 37158 1537 6 . . . 37158 1538 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1538 2 JAMES JAMES NNP 37158 1538 3 REID REID NNP 37158 1538 4 , , , 37158 1538 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1538 6 . . NNP 37158 1538 7 , , , 37158 1538 8 G.C.V.O. G.C.V.O. NNP 37158 1539 1 LADY LADY NNP 37158 1539 2 RUSSELL RUSSELL NNP 37158 1539 3 REYNOLDS REYNOLDS NNP 37158 1539 4 . . . 37158 1540 1 THE the DT 37158 1540 2 VERY VERY NNP 37158 1540 3 REV REV NNP 37158 1540 4 . . . 37158 1541 1 HON hon NN 37158 1541 2 . . . 37158 1542 1 THE the DT 37158 1542 2 DEAN DEAN NNP 37158 1542 3 OF of IN 37158 1542 4 RIPON RIPON NNP 37158 1542 5 , , , 37158 1542 6 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1543 1 BRITON BRITON NNP 37158 1543 2 RIVIERE RIVIERE NNP 37158 1543 3 , , , 37158 1543 4 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1543 5 . . NNP 37158 1543 6 , , , 37158 1543 7 R.A. R.A. NNP 37158 1543 8 , , , 37158 1543 9 D.C.L. D.C.L. NNP 37158 1544 1 MRS MRS NNP 37158 1544 2 ROGET ROGET NNP 37158 1544 3 . . . 37158 1545 1 MRS MRS NNP 37158 1545 2 ROMANES ROMANES NNP 37158 1545 3 . . . 37158 1546 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1546 2 HENRY HENRY NNP 37158 1546 3 ROSCOE ROSCOE NNP 37158 1546 4 , , , 37158 1546 5 D.C.L. D.C.L. NNP 37158 1546 6 , , , 37158 1546 7 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1546 8 , , , 37158 1546 9 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1547 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 1547 2 A]THE A]THE NNP 37158 1547 3 RT RT NNP 37158 1547 4 . . . 37158 1548 1 HON hon NN 37158 1548 2 . . . 37158 1549 1 THE the DT 37158 1549 2 EARL EARL NNP 37158 1549 3 OF of IN 37158 1549 4 ROSSE ROSSE NNP 37158 1549 5 , , , 37158 1549 6 K.P. K.P. NNP 37158 1549 7 , , , 37158 1549 8 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 37158 1549 9 , , , 37158 1549 10 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1550 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1550 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1550 3 Chancellor Chancellor NNP 37158 1550 4 of of IN 37158 1550 5 the the DT 37158 1550 6 University University NNP 37158 1550 7 of of IN 37158 1550 8 Dublin Dublin NNP 37158 1550 9 _ _ NNP 37158 1550 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1550 11 . . . 37158 1551 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1551 2 ROTHSCHILD ROTHSCHILD NNP 37158 1551 3 , , , 37158 1551 4 G.C.V.O. G.C.V.O. NNP 37158 1552 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1552 2 ARTHUR ARTHUR NNP 37158 1552 3 RÜCKER RÜCKER NNP 37158 1552 4 , , , 37158 1552 5 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1553 1 THE the DT 37158 1553 2 VERY VERY NNP 37158 1553 3 REV REV NNP 37158 1553 4 . . . 37158 1554 1 THE the DT 37158 1554 2 DEAN DEAN NNP 37158 1554 3 OF of IN 37158 1554 4 SALISBURY SALISBURY NNP 37158 1554 5 , , , 37158 1554 6 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1555 1 THE the DT 37158 1555 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1555 3 . . . 37158 1556 1 HON hon NN 37158 1556 2 . . . 37158 1557 1 THE the DT 37158 1557 2 MARQUIS MARQUIS NNP 37158 1557 3 OF of IN 37158 1557 4 SALISBURY SALISBURY NNP 37158 1557 5 . . . 37158 1558 1 THE the DT 37158 1558 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1558 3 . . . 37158 1559 1 HON hon NN 37158 1559 2 . . . 37158 1560 1 THE the DT 37158 1560 2 MARQUIS MARQUIS NNP 37158 1560 3 OF of IN 37158 1560 4 SLIGO sligo NN 37158 1560 5 . . . 37158 1561 1 ISABEL ISABEL NNP 37158 1561 2 MARCHIONESS marchiones NNS 37158 1561 3 OF of IN 37158 1561 4 SLIGO sligo NN 37158 1561 5 . . . 37158 1562 1 THE the DT 37158 1562 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1562 3 . . . 37158 1563 1 HON hon NN 37158 1563 2 . . . 37158 1564 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1564 2 CECIL CECIL NNP 37158 1564 3 CLEMENTI CLEMENTI NNP 37158 1564 4 SMITH SMITH NNP 37158 1564 5 , , , 37158 1564 6 G.C.M.G. G.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1565 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1565 2 THOMAS THOMAS NNP 37158 1565 3 SMITH SMITH NNP 37158 1565 4 , , , 37158 1565 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1565 6 . . NNP 37158 1565 7 , , , 37158 1565 8 K.C.V.O. K.C.V.O. NNP 37158 1566 1 THE the DT 37158 1566 2 HON hon NN 37158 1566 3 . . . 37158 1567 1 W. W. NNP 37158 1567 2 F. F. NNP 37158 1567 3 D. D. NNP 37158 1567 4 SMITH SMITH NNP 37158 1567 5 , , , 37158 1567 6 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1568 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1568 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1568 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1568 4 , , , 37158 1568 5 Removal Removal NNP 37158 1568 6 Fund Fund NNP 37158 1568 7 , , , 37158 1568 8 King King NNP 37158 1568 9 's 's POS 37158 1568 10 College College NNP 37158 1568 11 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1568 12 _ _ NNP 37158 1568 13 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1568 14 . . . 37158 1569 1 THE the DT 37158 1569 2 HON hon NN 37158 1569 3 . . . 37158 1570 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1570 2 RICHARD RICHARD NNP 37158 1570 3 SOLOMON SOLOMON NNP 37158 1570 4 , , , 37158 1570 5 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1570 6 , , , 37158 1570 7 K.C.M.G. K.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1571 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1571 2 EDGAR EDGAR NNP 37158 1571 3 SPEYER SPEYER NNP 37158 1571 4 , , , 37158 1571 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1571 6 . . . 37158 1572 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1572 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1572 3 President President NNP 37158 1572 4 , , , 37158 1572 5 Poplar Poplar NNP 37158 1572 6 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1572 7 _ _ NNP 37158 1572 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1572 9 . . . 37158 1573 1 THE the DT 37158 1573 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1573 3 . . . 37158 1574 1 HON hon NN 37158 1574 2 . . . 37158 1575 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1575 2 STALBRIDGE STALBRIDGE NNP 37158 1575 3 . . . 37158 1576 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1576 2 STANLEY STANLEY NNP 37158 1576 3 , , , 37158 1576 4 K.C.V.O. K.C.V.O. NNP 37158 1577 1 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1577 2 STRATHCONA STRATHCONA NNP 37158 1577 3 , , , 37158 1577 4 G.C.M.G. G.C.M.G. NNP 37158 1578 1 LADY LADY NNP 37158 1578 2 SUTTON SUTTON NNP 37158 1578 3 . . . 37158 1579 1 MAJ.-GEN maj.-gen LS 37158 1579 2 . . . 37158 1579 3 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1579 4 REGINALD REGINALD VBD 37158 1579 5 TALBOT TALBOT NNP 37158 1579 6 , , , 37158 1579 7 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1580 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1580 2 FREDERICK FREDERICK NNP 37158 1580 3 TREVES TREVES NNP 37158 1580 4 , , , 37158 1580 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1580 6 . . NNP 37158 1580 7 , , , 37158 1580 8 G.C.V.O. G.C.V.O. NNP 37158 1581 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1581 2 JOHN JOHN NNP 37158 1581 3 BATTY BATTY NNS 37158 1581 4 TUKE TUKE NNP 37158 1581 5 , , , 37158 1581 6 M.P. M.P. NNP 37158 1582 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1582 2 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNP 37158 1582 3 TURNER TURNER NNP 37158 1582 4 , , , 37158 1582 5 K.C.B. K.C.B. NNP 37158 1582 6 , , , 37158 1582 7 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1583 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1583 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1583 3 Principal Principal NNP 37158 1583 4 of of IN 37158 1583 5 the the DT 37158 1583 6 University University NNP 37158 1583 7 of of IN 37158 1583 8 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP 37158 1583 9 _ _ NNP 37158 1583 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1583 11 . . . 37158 1584 1 JAMES JAMES NNP 37158 1584 2 G. G. NNP 37158 1584 3 WAINWRIGHT WAINWRIGHT NNP 37158 1584 4 , , , 37158 1584 5 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1584 6 . . . 37158 1585 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1585 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1585 3 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1585 4 , , , 37158 1585 5 St St NNP 37158 1585 6 Thomas Thomas NNP 37158 1585 7 's 's POS 37158 1585 8 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1585 9 _ _ NNP 37158 1585 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1585 11 . . . 37158 1586 1 _ _ NNP 37158 1586 2 Earl Earl NNP 37158 1586 3 Waldegrave Waldegrave NNP 37158 1586 4 . . . 37158 1586 5 _ _ NNP 37158 1586 6 _ _ NNP 37158 1586 7 The the DT 37158 1586 8 Rt Rt NNP 37158 1586 9 . . . 37158 1587 1 Rev. Rev. NNP 37158 1588 1 Bishop Bishop NNP 37158 1588 2 Welldon Welldon NNP 37158 1588 3 . . . 37158 1588 4 _ _ NNP 37158 1588 5 HIS his PRP$ 37158 1588 6 GRACE GRACE NNP 37158 1588 7 THE the DT 37158 1588 8 DUKE DUKE NNP 37158 1588 9 OF of IN 37158 1588 10 WELLINGTON WELLINGTON NNP 37158 1588 11 , , , 37158 1588 12 K.G. K.G. NNP 37158 1589 1 A. A. NNP 37158 1589 2 W. W. NNP 37158 1589 3 WEST WEST NNP 37158 1589 4 , , , 37158 1589 5 ESQ ESQ NNP 37158 1589 6 . . . 37158 1590 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1590 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1590 3 Treasurer Treasurer NNP 37158 1590 4 and and CC 37158 1590 5 Chairman Chairman NNP 37158 1590 6 , , , 37158 1590 7 St St NNP 37158 1590 8 George George NNP 37158 1590 9 's 's POS 37158 1590 10 Hospital Hospital NNP 37158 1590 11 _ _ NNP 37158 1590 12 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1590 13 . . . 37158 1591 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1591 2 JAMES JAMES NNP 37158 1591 3 WHITEHEAD WHITEHEAD NNP 37158 1591 4 , , , 37158 1591 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1591 6 . . . 37158 1592 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1592 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1592 3 First First NNP 37158 1592 4 President President NNP 37158 1592 5 of of IN 37158 1592 6 the the DT 37158 1592 7 Lister Lister NNP 37158 1592 8 Institute Institute NNP 37158 1592 9 _ _ NNP 37158 1592 10 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1592 11 . . . 37158 1593 1 MRS MRS NNP 37158 1593 2 ROBERT ROBERT NNP 37158 1593 3 PEEL peel NN 37158 1593 4 WETHERED wethered JJ 37158 1593 5 . . . 37158 1594 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1594 2 SAMUEL SAMUEL NNP 37158 1594 3 WILKS WILKS NNP 37158 1594 4 , , , 37158 1594 5 BT BT NNP 37158 1594 6 . . NNP 37158 1594 7 , , , 37158 1594 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 37158 1595 1 THE the DT 37158 1595 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1595 3 . . . 37158 1596 1 HON hon NN 37158 1596 2 . . . 37158 1597 1 SIR SIR NNP 37158 1597 2 ALFRED ALFRED NNP 37158 1597 3 WILLS WILLS NNP 37158 1597 4 . . . 37158 1598 1 THE the DT 37158 1598 2 RT RT NNP 37158 1598 3 . . . 37158 1599 1 REV REV NNP 37158 1599 2 . . . 37158 1600 1 THE the DT 37158 1600 2 LORD LORD NNP 37158 1600 3 BISHOP BISHOP NNP 37158 1600 4 OF of IN 37158 1600 5 WINCHESTER WINCHESTER NNP 37158 1600 6 . . . 37158 1601 1 THE the DT 37158 1601 2 REV REV NNP 37158 1601 3 . . . 37158 1602 1 H. H. NNP 37158 1602 2 G. G. NNP 37158 1602 3 WOODS WOODS NNP 37158 1602 4 , , , 37158 1602 5 D.D. D.D. NNP 37158 1603 1 ( ( -LRB- 37158 1603 2 _ _ NNP 37158 1603 3 Master Master NNP 37158 1603 4 of of IN 37158 1603 5 the the DT 37158 1603 6 Temple Temple NNP 37158 1603 7 _ _ NNP 37158 1603 8 ) ) -RRB- 37158 1603 9 . . . 37158 1604 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 1604 2 Note note VB 37158 1604 3 A a NN 37158 1604 4 : : : 37158 1604 5 Since since IN 37158 1604 6 deceased deceased JJ 37158 1604 7 . . . 37158 1604 8 ] ] -RRB- 37158 1605 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 37158 1605 2 : : : 37158 1605 3 [ [ -LRB- 37158 1605 4 9 9 CD 37158 1605 5 ] ] -RRB- 37158 1605 6 22nd 22nd CD 37158 1605 7 October October NNP 37158 1605 8 1908 1908 CD 37158 1605 9 . . . 37158 1606 1 The the DT 37158 1606 2 number number NN 37158 1606 3 of of IN 37158 1606 4 members member NNS 37158 1606 5 is be VBZ 37158 1606 6 now now RB 37158 1606 7 over over IN 37158 1606 8 1530 1530 CD 37158 1606 9 , , , 37158 1606 10 of of IN 37158 1606 11 whom whom WP 37158 1606 12 160 160 CD 37158 1606 13 are be VBP 37158 1606 14 ladies lady NNS 37158 1606 15 . . . 37158 1607 1 [ [ -LRB- 37158 1607 2 10 10 CD 37158 1607 3 ] ] -RRB- 37158 1607 4 27th 27th NN 37158 1607 5 May. May NNP 37158 1608 1 Dr Dr NNP 37158 1608 2 Sandwith Sandwith NNP 37158 1608 3 , , , 37158 1608 4 31 31 CD 37158 1608 5 Cavendish Cavendish NNP 37158 1608 6 Square Square NNP 37158 1608 7 , , , 37158 1608 8 London London NNP 37158 1608 9 , , , 37158 1608 10 W. W. NNP 37158 1608 11 , , , 37158 1608 12 is be VBZ 37158 1608 13 now now RB 37158 1608 14 Hon Hon NNP 37158 1608 15 . . . 37158 1609 1 Treasurer treasurer NN 37158 1609 2 . . . 37158 1610 1 TURNBULL TURNBULL NNP 37158 1610 2 AND and CC 37158 1610 3 SPEARS SPEARS NNP 37158 1610 4 , , , 37158 1610 5 PRINTERS PRINTERS NNP 37158 1610 6 , , , 37158 1610 7 EDINBURGH EDINBURGH NNP 37158 1610 8 . . .