id sid tid token lemma pos 37231 1 1 SUPERNATURAL supernatural JJ 37231 1 2 RELIGION religion NN 37231 1 3 : : : 37231 1 4 AN an DT 37231 1 5 INQUIRY INQUIRY NNP 37231 1 6 THE the DT 37231 1 7 REALITY reality NN 37231 1 8 OF of IN 37231 1 9 DIVINE DIVINE NNP 37231 1 10 REVELATION REVELATION NNP 37231 1 11 By by IN 37231 1 12 Walter Walter NNP 37231 1 13 Richard Richard NNP 37231 1 14 Cassels Cassels NNP 37231 1 15 In in IN 37231 1 16 Three Three NNP 37231 1 17 Volumes Volumes NNPS 37231 1 18 : : : 37231 1 19 Vol Vol NNP 37231 1 20 . . . 37231 2 1 I. I. NNP 37231 3 1 Complete Complete NNP 37231 3 2 Edition Edition NNP 37231 3 3 . . . 37231 4 1 Carefully carefully RB 37231 4 2 Revised revise VBN 37231 4 3 . . . 37231 5 1 London London NNP 37231 5 2 : : : 37231 5 3 Longmans Longmans NNPS 37231 5 4 , , , 37231 5 5 Green Green NNP 37231 5 6 , , , 37231 5 7 And and CC 37231 5 8 Co. Co. NNP 37231 5 9 , , , 37231 5 10 1879 1879 CD 37231 5 11 . . . 37231 6 1 PG PG NNP 37231 6 2 EDITOR EDITOR NNP 37231 6 3 'S 's POS 37231 6 4 NOTE note NN 37231 6 5 : : : 37231 6 6 This this DT 37231 6 7 file file NN 37231 6 8 has have VBZ 37231 6 9 been be VBN 37231 6 10 provided provide VBN 37231 6 11 with with IN 37231 6 12 an an DT 37231 6 13 image image NN 37231 6 14 of of IN 37231 6 15 the the DT 37231 6 16 original original JJ 37231 6 17 scan scan NN 37231 6 18 for for IN 37231 6 19 each each DT 37231 6 20 page page NN 37231 6 21 which which WDT 37231 6 22 is be VBZ 37231 6 23 linked link VBN 37231 6 24 to to IN 37231 6 25 the the DT 37231 6 26 page page NN 37231 6 27 number number NN 37231 6 28 in in IN 37231 6 29 the the DT 37231 6 30 html html NNP 37231 6 31 file file NN 37231 6 32 . . . 37231 7 1 Nearly nearly RB 37231 7 2 every every DT 37231 7 3 page page NN 37231 7 4 in in IN 37231 7 5 the the DT 37231 7 6 text text NN 37231 7 7 has have VBZ 37231 7 8 many many JJ 37231 7 9 Greek greek JJ 37231 7 10 passages passage NNS 37231 7 11 which which WDT 37231 7 12 have have VBP 37231 7 13 been be VBN 37231 7 14 indicated indicate VBN 37231 7 15 where where WRB 37231 7 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 7 17 occur occur VBP 37231 7 18 by by IN 37231 7 19 [ [ -LRB- 37231 7 20 � � NN 37231 7 21 � � NNS 37231 7 22 � � , 37231 7 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 7 24 as as IN 37231 7 25 have have VBP 37231 7 26 many many JJ 37231 7 27 complex complex JJ 37231 7 28 tables table NNS 37231 7 29 ; ; : 37231 7 30 these these DT 37231 7 31 passages passage NNS 37231 7 32 may may MD 37231 7 33 be be VB 37231 7 34 viewed view VBN 37231 7 35 in in IN 37231 7 36 the the DT 37231 7 37 page page NN 37231 7 38 images image NNS 37231 7 39 . . . 37231 8 1 Some some DT 37231 8 2 of of IN 37231 8 3 the the DT 37231 8 4 pages page NNS 37231 8 5 have have VBP 37231 8 6 only only RB 37231 8 7 a a DT 37231 8 8 few few JJ 37231 8 9 lines line NNS 37231 8 10 of of IN 37231 8 11 text text NN 37231 8 12 and and CC 37231 8 13 then then RB 37231 8 14 the the DT 37231 8 15 rest rest NN 37231 8 16 of of IN 37231 8 17 the the DT 37231 8 18 page page NN 37231 8 19 is be VBZ 37231 8 20 taken take VBN 37231 8 21 up up RP 37231 8 22 with with IN 37231 8 23 complex complex JJ 37231 8 24 footnotes footnote NNS 37231 8 25 in in IN 37231 8 26 English English NNP 37231 8 27 , , , 37231 8 28 Greek Greek NNP 37231 8 29 and and CC 37231 8 30 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 8 31 . . . 37231 9 1 The the DT 37231 9 2 reader reader NN 37231 9 3 may may MD 37231 9 4 click click VB 37231 9 5 on on IN 37231 9 6 the the DT 37231 9 7 page page NN 37231 9 8 numbers number NNS 37231 9 9 in in IN 37231 9 10 the the DT 37231 9 11 html html NNP 37231 9 12 file file NN 37231 9 13 to to TO 37231 9 14 see see VB 37231 9 15 the the DT 37231 9 16 entire entire JJ 37231 9 17 page page NN 37231 9 18 with with IN 37231 9 19 the the DT 37231 9 20 footnotes footnote NNS 37231 9 21 . . . 37231 10 1 � � : 37231 10 2 DW DW NNP 37231 10 3 PREFACE PREFACE NNP 37231 10 4 TO to IN 37231 10 5 THE the DT 37231 10 6 COMPLETE COMPLETE NNP 37231 10 7 EDITION edition NN 37231 10 8 In in IN 37231 10 9 preparing prepare VBG 37231 10 10 a a DT 37231 10 11 complete complete JJ 37231 10 12 edition edition NN 37231 10 13 of of IN 37231 10 14 this this DT 37231 10 15 work work NN 37231 10 16 , , , 37231 10 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 10 18 have have VBP 37231 10 19 revised revise VBN 37231 10 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 10 21 throughout throughout IN 37231 10 22 . . . 37231 11 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 11 2 have have VBP 37231 11 3 not not RB 37231 11 4 hesitated hesitate VBN 37231 11 5 to to TO 37231 11 6 make make VB 37231 11 7 any any DT 37231 11 8 alterations alteration NNS 37231 11 9 , , , 37231 11 10 omissions omission NNS 37231 11 11 or or CC 37231 11 12 additions addition NNS 37231 11 13 which which WDT 37231 11 14 seemed seem VBD 37231 11 15 to to IN 37231 11 16 me -PRON- PRP 37231 11 17 likely likely JJ 37231 11 18 to to TO 37231 11 19 improve improve VB 37231 11 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 11 21 . . . 37231 12 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 12 2 have have VBP 37231 12 3 endeavoured endeavour VBN 37231 12 4 as as RB 37231 12 5 much much RB 37231 12 6 as as IN 37231 12 7 possible possible JJ 37231 12 8 to to TO 37231 12 9 avoid avoid VB 37231 12 10 presenting present VBG 37231 12 11 openings opening NNS 37231 12 12 for for IN 37231 12 13 side side NN 37231 12 14 issues issue NNS 37231 12 15 , , , 37231 12 16 and and CC 37231 12 17 , , , 37231 12 18 with with IN 37231 12 19 this this DT 37231 12 20 object object NN 37231 12 21 , , , 37231 12 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 12 23 have have VBP 37231 12 24 softened soften VBN 37231 12 25 statements statement NNS 37231 12 26 which which WDT 37231 12 27 , , , 37231 12 28 however however RB 37231 12 29 sustainable sustainable JJ 37231 12 30 in in IN 37231 12 31 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 12 32 , , , 37231 12 33 might may MD 37231 12 34 give give VB 37231 12 35 rise rise NN 37231 12 36 to to IN 37231 12 37 discussions discussion NNS 37231 12 38 apart apart RB 37231 12 39 from from IN 37231 12 40 the the DT 37231 12 41 direct direct JJ 37231 12 42 purpose purpose NN 37231 12 43 of of IN 37231 12 44 the the DT 37231 12 45 Inquiry Inquiry NNP 37231 12 46 . . . 37231 13 1 Wherever wherever WRB 37231 13 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 13 3 argument argument NN 37231 13 4 has have VBZ 37231 13 5 appeared appear VBN 37231 13 6 to to IN 37231 13 7 me -PRON- PRP 37231 13 8 either either CC 37231 13 9 involved involved JJ 37231 13 10 or or CC 37231 13 11 insufficiently insufficiently RB 37231 13 12 expressed express VBN 37231 13 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 13 14 have have VBP 37231 13 15 as as RB 37231 13 16 freely freely RB 37231 13 17 recast recast VBN 37231 13 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 13 19 as as IN 37231 13 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 13 21 limits limit NNS 37231 13 22 permitted permit VBD 37231 13 23 , , , 37231 13 24 and and CC 37231 13 25 I -PRON- PRP 37231 13 26 have have VBP 37231 13 27 in in IN 37231 13 28 several several JJ 37231 13 29 parts part NNS 37231 13 30 introduced introduce VBD 37231 13 31 new new JJ 37231 13 32 data datum NNS 37231 13 33 discovered discover VBN 37231 13 34 or or CC 37231 13 35 elaborated elaborate VBN 37231 13 36 since since IN 37231 13 37 the the DT 37231 13 38 work work NN 37231 13 39 was be VBD 37231 13 40 first first RB 37231 13 41 written write VBN 37231 13 42 , , , 37231 13 43 or or CC 37231 13 44 which which WDT 37231 13 45 I -PRON- PRP 37231 13 46 may may MD 37231 13 47 then then RB 37231 13 48 have have VB 37231 13 49 overlooked overlook VBN 37231 13 50 . . . 37231 14 1 In in IN 37231 14 2 one one CD 37231 14 3 instance instance NN 37231 14 4 only only RB 37231 14 5 has have VBZ 37231 14 6 any any DT 37231 14 7 alteration alteration NN 37231 14 8 been be VBN 37231 14 9 requisite requisite JJ 37231 14 10 which which WDT 37231 14 11 demands demand VBZ 37231 14 12 special special JJ 37231 14 13 mention mention NN 37231 14 14 here here RB 37231 14 15 . . . 37231 15 1 Since since IN 37231 15 2 the the DT 37231 15 3 sixth sixth JJ 37231 15 4 edition edition NN 37231 15 5 was be VBD 37231 15 6 published publish VBN 37231 15 7 , , , 37231 15 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 15 9 have have VBP 37231 15 10 been be VBN 37231 15 11 convinced convince VBN 37231 15 12 that that IN 37231 15 13 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 15 14 's 's POS 37231 15 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 15 16 was be VBD 37231 15 17 based base VBN 37231 15 18 upon upon IN 37231 15 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 15 20 third third JJ 37231 15 21 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 15 22 , , , 37231 15 23 and and CC 37231 15 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 15 25 have have VBP 37231 15 26 accordingly accordingly RB 37231 15 27 so so RB 37231 15 28 far far RB 37231 15 29 modified modify VBN 37231 15 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 15 31 results result NNS 37231 15 32 . . . 37231 16 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 16 2 may may MD 37231 16 3 not not RB 37231 16 4 be be VB 37231 16 5 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 16 6 , , , 37231 16 7 however however RB 37231 16 8 , , , 37231 16 9 plainly plainly RB 37231 16 10 to to TO 37231 16 11 repeat repeat VB 37231 16 12 that that DT 37231 16 13 , , , 37231 16 14 with with IN 37231 16 15 this this DT 37231 16 16 exception exception NN 37231 16 17 , , , 37231 16 18 which which WDT 37231 16 19 is be VBZ 37231 16 20 not not RB 37231 16 21 of of IN 37231 16 22 material material JJ 37231 16 23 consequence consequence NN 37231 16 24 , , , 37231 16 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 16 26 convictions conviction NNS 37231 16 27 not not RB 37231 16 28 only only RB 37231 16 29 remain remain VBP 37231 16 30 fundamentally fundamentally RB 37231 16 31 unchanged unchanged JJ 37231 16 32 , , , 37231 16 33 but but CC 37231 16 34 have have VBP 37231 16 35 been be VBN 37231 16 36 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 16 37 and and CC 37231 16 38 strengthened strengthen VBN 37231 16 39 both both CC 37231 16 40 by by IN 37231 16 41 thorough thorough JJ 37231 16 42 reconsideration reconsideration NN 37231 16 43 of of IN 37231 16 44 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 16 45 own own JJ 37231 16 46 argument argument NN 37231 16 47 , , , 37231 16 48 and and CC 37231 16 49 by by IN 37231 16 50 careful careful JJ 37231 16 51 attention attention NN 37231 16 52 to to IN 37231 16 53 the the DT 37231 16 54 replies reply NNS 37231 16 55 made make VBN 37231 16 56 by by IN 37231 16 57 able able JJ 37231 16 58 official official JJ 37231 16 59 apologists apologist NNS 37231 16 60 . . . 37231 17 1 As as IN 37231 17 2 regards regard VBZ 37231 17 3 the the DT 37231 17 4 philosophical philosophical JJ 37231 17 5 and and CC 37231 17 6 other other JJ 37231 17 7 objections objection NNS 37231 17 8 to to IN 37231 17 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 17 10 , , , 37231 17 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 17 12 cogency cogency NN 37231 17 13 is be VBZ 37231 17 14 so so RB 37231 17 15 fully fully RB 37231 17 16 recognized recognize VBN 37231 17 17 that that IN 37231 17 18 Bampton Bampton NNP 37231 17 19 Lecturers Lecturers NNPS 37231 17 20 and and CC 37231 17 21 eminent eminent JJ 37231 17 22 Churchmen churchman NNS 37231 17 23 practically practically RB 37231 17 24 abandon abandon VBP 37231 17 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 17 26 as as IN 37231 17 27 evidence evidence NN 37231 17 28 , , , 37231 17 29 and and CC 37231 17 30 press press VB 37231 17 31 upon upon IN 37231 17 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 17 33 brethren brother NNS 37231 17 34 the the DT 37231 17 35 necessity necessity NN 37231 17 36 of of IN 37231 17 37 reconstructing reconstruct VBG 37231 17 38 the the DT 37231 17 39 Christian christian JJ 37231 17 40 argument argument NN 37231 17 41 The the DT 37231 17 42 necessity necessity NN 37231 17 43 of of IN 37231 17 44 reconstruction reconstruction NN 37231 17 45 is be VBZ 37231 17 46 indeed indeed RB 37231 17 47 apparent apparent JJ 37231 17 48 , , , 37231 17 49 but but CC 37231 17 50 the the DT 37231 17 51 materials material NNS 37231 17 52 have have VBP 37231 17 53 not not RB 37231 17 54 yet yet RB 37231 17 55 been be VBN 37231 17 56 made make VBN 37231 17 57 manifest manifest JJ 37231 17 58 . . . 37231 18 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 37231 18 2 , , , 37231 18 3 such such JJ 37231 18 4 apologists apologist NNS 37231 18 5 have have VBP 37231 18 6 been be VBN 37231 18 7 forced force VBN 37231 18 8 virtually virtually RB 37231 18 9 to to TO 37231 18 10 repudiate repudiate VB 37231 18 11 the the DT 37231 18 12 great great JJ 37231 18 13 Christian christian JJ 37231 18 14 representatives representative NNS 37231 18 15 who who WP 37231 18 16 have have VBP 37231 18 17 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 18 18 defended defend VBN 37231 18 19 the the DT 37231 18 20 Faith Faith NNP 37231 18 21 . . . 37231 19 1 The the DT 37231 19 2 case case NN 37231 19 3 may may MD 37231 19 4 fairly fairly RB 37231 19 5 be be VB 37231 19 6 considered consider VBN 37231 19 7 desperate desperate JJ 37231 19 8 when when WRB 37231 19 9 the the DT 37231 19 10 crew crew NN 37231 19 11 throw throw VBP 37231 19 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 19 13 officers officer NNS 37231 19 14 overboard overboard RB 37231 19 15 by by IN 37231 19 16 way way NN 37231 19 17 of of IN 37231 19 18 lightening lighten VBG 37231 19 19 the the DT 37231 19 20 ship ship NN 37231 19 21 . . . 37231 20 1 The the DT 37231 20 2 historical historical JJ 37231 20 3 argument argument NN 37231 20 4 is be VBZ 37231 20 5 not not RB 37231 20 6 in in IN 37231 20 7 a a DT 37231 20 8 better well JJR 37231 20 9 position position NN 37231 20 10 . . . 37231 21 1 The the DT 37231 21 2 learned learn VBN 37231 21 3 professors professor NNS 37231 21 4 and and CC 37231 21 5 critics critic NNS 37231 21 6 who who WP 37231 21 7 have have VBP 37231 21 8 undertaken undertake VBN 37231 21 9 to to TO 37231 21 10 deal deal VB 37231 21 11 with with IN 37231 21 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 21 13 do do VBP 37231 21 14 not not RB 37231 21 15 even even RB 37231 21 16 pretend pretend VB 37231 21 17 , , , 37231 21 18 except except IN 37231 21 19 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 21 20 in in IN 37231 21 21 the the DT 37231 21 22 case case NN 37231 21 23 of of IN 37231 21 24 Papias Papias NNP 37231 21 25 , , , 37231 21 26 to to TO 37231 21 27 do do VB 37231 21 28 more more JJR 37231 21 29 than than IN 37231 21 30 assert assert VB 37231 21 31 the the DT 37231 21 32 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 21 33 use use NN 37231 21 34 of of IN 37231 21 35 the the DT 37231 21 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 21 37 by by IN 37231 21 38 some some DT 37231 21 39 of of IN 37231 21 40 the the DT 37231 21 41 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 21 42 , , , 37231 21 43 and and CC 37231 21 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 21 45 consequent consequent JJ 37231 21 46 existence existence NN 37231 21 47 ; ; , 37231 21 48 but but CC 37231 21 49 , , , 37231 21 50 if if IN 37231 21 51 this this DT 37231 21 52 were be VBD 37231 21 53 established establish VBN 37231 21 54 , , , 37231 21 55 what what WDT 37231 21 56 support support NN 37231 21 57 could could MD 37231 21 58 that that DT 37231 21 59 give give VB 37231 21 60 to to IN 37231 21 61 the the DT 37231 21 62 record record NN 37231 21 63 of of IN 37231 21 64 miracles miracle NNS 37231 21 65 ? ? . 37231 22 1 As as IN 37231 22 2 for for IN 37231 22 3 Papias Papias NNP 37231 22 4 , , , 37231 22 5 with with IN 37231 22 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 22 7 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 22 8 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 22 9 and and CC 37231 22 10 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 37231 22 11 indirect indirect JJ 37231 22 12 Mark Mark NNP 37231 22 13 , , , 37231 22 14 even even RB 37231 22 15 if if IN 37231 22 16 secured secure VBN 37231 22 17 as as IN 37231 22 18 a a DT 37231 22 19 solitary solitary JJ 37231 22 20 witness witness NN 37231 22 21 to to IN 37231 22 22 the the DT 37231 22 23 composition composition NN 37231 22 24 of of IN 37231 22 25 two two CD 37231 22 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 22 27 , , , 37231 22 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 22 29 would would MD 37231 22 30 prove prove VB 37231 22 31 but but CC 37231 22 32 a a DT 37231 22 33 fatal fatal JJ 37231 22 34 friend friend NN 37231 22 35 to to IN 37231 22 36 the the DT 37231 22 37 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 22 38 cause cause NN 37231 22 39 . . . 37231 23 1 The the DT 37231 23 2 " " `` 37231 23 3 Conclusions Conclusions NNPS 37231 23 4 " " '' 37231 23 5 have have VBP 37231 23 6 been be VBN 37231 23 7 almost almost RB 37231 23 8 entirely entirely RB 37231 23 9 rewritten rewrite VBN 37231 23 10 . . . 37231 24 1 This this DT 37231 24 2 was be VBD 37231 24 3 essential essential JJ 37231 24 4 to to IN 37231 24 5 the the DT 37231 24 6 finished finished JJ 37231 24 7 work work NN 37231 24 8 ; ; : 37231 24 9 but but CC 37231 24 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 24 11 was be VBD 37231 24 12 further further RB 37231 24 13 necessary necessary JJ 37231 24 14 in in IN 37231 24 15 order order NN 37231 24 16 more more RBR 37231 24 17 adequately adequately RB 37231 24 18 to to TO 37231 24 19 convey convey VB 37231 24 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 24 21 own own JJ 37231 24 22 views view NNS 37231 24 23 , , , 37231 24 24 and and CC 37231 24 25 to to TO 37231 24 26 withdraw withdraw VB 37231 24 27 expressions expression NNS 37231 24 28 regarding regard VBG 37231 24 29 the the DT 37231 24 30 Unknowable Unknowable NNP 37231 24 31 , , , 37231 24 32 hitherto hitherto NNP 37231 24 33 used use VBN 37231 24 34 from from IN 37231 24 35 consideration consideration NN 37231 24 36 for for IN 37231 24 37 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 24 38 ideas idea NNS 37231 24 39 and and CC 37231 24 40 feelings feeling NNS 37231 24 41 , , , 37231 24 42 which which WDT 37231 24 43 I -PRON- PRP 37231 24 44 now now RB 37231 24 45 recognize recognize VBP 37231 24 46 to to TO 37231 24 47 have have VB 37231 24 48 been be VBN 37231 24 49 too too RB 37231 24 50 definite definite JJ 37231 24 51 and and CC 37231 24 52 calculated calculate VBN 37231 24 53 to to TO 37231 24 54 mislead mislead VB 37231 24 55 . . . 37231 25 1 PREFACE preface VB 37231 25 2 TO to IN 37231 25 3 THE the DT 37231 25 4 SIXTH SIXTH NNP 37231 25 5 EDITION EDITION NNP 37231 25 6 . . . 37231 26 1 This this DT 37231 26 2 work work NN 37231 26 3 has have VBZ 37231 26 4 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 26 5 yet yet RB 37231 26 6 been be VBN 37231 26 7 twelve twelve CD 37231 26 8 months month NNS 37231 26 9 before before IN 37231 26 10 the the DT 37231 26 11 public public NN 37231 26 12 , , , 37231 26 13 but but CC 37231 26 14 both both DT 37231 26 15 in in IN 37231 26 16 this this DT 37231 26 17 country country NN 37231 26 18 , , , 37231 26 19 and and CC 37231 26 20 in in IN 37231 26 21 America America NNP 37231 26 22 and and CC 37231 26 23 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 26 24 , , , 37231 26 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 26 26 has have VBZ 37231 26 27 been be VBN 37231 26 28 subjected subject VBN 37231 26 29 to to IN 37231 26 30 such such JJ 37231 26 31 wide wide JJ 37231 26 32 and and CC 37231 26 33 searching search VBG 37231 26 34 criticism criticism NN 37231 26 35 by by IN 37231 26 36 writers writer NNS 37231 26 37 of of IN 37231 26 38 all all DT 37231 26 39 shades shade NNS 37231 26 40 of of IN 37231 26 41 opinion opinion NN 37231 26 42 , , , 37231 26 43 that that IN 37231 26 44 I -PRON- PRP 37231 26 45 may may MD 37231 26 46 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 26 47 be be VB 37231 26 48 permitted permit VBN 37231 26 49 to to TO 37231 26 50 make make VB 37231 26 51 a a DT 37231 26 52 few few JJ 37231 26 53 remarks remark NNS 37231 26 54 , , , 37231 26 55 and and CC 37231 26 56 to to TO 37231 26 57 review review VB 37231 26 58 some some DT 37231 26 59 of of IN 37231 26 60 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 26 61 Reviewers Reviewers NNPS 37231 26 62 . . . 37231 27 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 27 2 must must MD 37231 27 3 first first RB 37231 27 4 , , , 37231 27 5 however however RB 37231 27 6 , , , 37231 27 7 beg beg NNP 37231 27 8 leave leave VB 37231 27 9 to to TO 37231 27 10 express express VB 37231 27 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 27 12 gratitude gratitude NN 37231 27 13 to to IN 37231 27 14 that that DT 37231 27 15 large large JJ 37231 27 16 majority majority NN 37231 27 17 of of IN 37231 27 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 27 19 critics critic NNS 37231 27 20 who who WP 37231 27 21 have have VBP 37231 27 22 bestowed bestow VBN 37231 27 23 generous generous JJ 37231 27 24 commendation commendation NN 37231 27 25 upon upon IN 37231 27 26 the the DT 37231 27 27 work work NN 37231 27 28 , , , 37231 27 29 and and CC 37231 27 30 liberally liberally RB 37231 27 31 encouraged encourage VBD 37231 27 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 27 33 completion completion NN 37231 27 34 . . . 37231 28 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 28 2 have have VBP 37231 28 3 to to TO 37231 28 4 thank thank VB 37231 28 5 others other NNS 37231 28 6 , , , 37231 28 7 who who WP 37231 28 8 , , , 37231 28 9 differing differ VBG 37231 28 10 totally totally RB 37231 28 11 from from IN 37231 28 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 28 13 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 28 14 , , , 37231 28 15 have have VBP 37231 28 16 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 28 17 temperately temperately RB 37231 28 18 argued argue VBN 37231 28 19 against against IN 37231 28 20 them -PRON- PRP 37231 28 21 , , , 37231 28 22 for for IN 37231 28 23 the the DT 37231 28 24 courtesy courtesy NN 37231 28 25 with with IN 37231 28 26 which which WDT 37231 28 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 28 28 have have VBP 37231 28 29 treated treat VBN 37231 28 30 an an DT 37231 28 31 opponent opponent NN 37231 28 32 whose whose WP$ 37231 28 33 views view NNS 37231 28 34 must must MD 37231 28 35 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 28 36 have have VB 37231 28 37 offended offend VBN 37231 28 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 28 39 , , , 37231 28 40 and and CC 37231 28 41 I -PRON- PRP 37231 28 42 can can MD 37231 28 43 only only RB 37231 28 44 say say VB 37231 28 45 that that IN 37231 28 46 , , , 37231 28 47 whilst whilst IN 37231 28 48 such such PDT 37231 28 49 a a DT 37231 28 50 course course NN 37231 28 51 has have VBZ 37231 28 52 commanded command VBN 37231 28 53 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 28 54 unfeigned unfeigned JJ 37231 28 55 respect respect NN 37231 28 56 , , , 37231 28 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 28 58 has have VBZ 37231 28 59 certainly certainly RB 37231 28 60 not not RB 37231 28 61 diminished diminish VBN 37231 28 62 the the DT 37231 28 63 attention attention NN 37231 28 64 with with IN 37231 28 65 which which WDT 37231 28 66 I -PRON- PRP 37231 28 67 have have VBP 37231 28 68 followed follow VBN 37231 28 69 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 28 70 arguments argument NNS 37231 28 71 . . . 37231 29 1 There there EX 37231 29 2 are be VBP 37231 29 3 two two CD 37231 29 4 serious serious JJ 37231 29 5 misapprehensions misapprehension NNS 37231 29 6 of of IN 37231 29 7 the the DT 37231 29 8 purpose purpose NN 37231 29 9 and and CC 37231 29 10 line line NN 37231 29 11 of of IN 37231 29 12 argument argument NN 37231 29 13 of of IN 37231 29 14 this this DT 37231 29 15 work work NN 37231 29 16 which which WDT 37231 29 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 29 18 desire desire VBP 37231 29 19 to to TO 37231 29 20 correct correct VB 37231 29 21 . . . 37231 30 1 Some some DT 37231 30 2 critics critic NNS 37231 30 3 have have VBP 37231 30 4 objected object VBN 37231 30 5 that that IN 37231 30 6 , , , 37231 30 7 if if IN 37231 30 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 30 9 had have VBD 37231 30 10 succeeded succeed VBN 37231 30 11 in in IN 37231 30 12 establishing establish VBG 37231 30 13 the the DT 37231 30 14 proposition proposition NN 37231 30 15 advanced advance VBN 37231 30 16 in in IN 37231 30 17 the the DT 37231 30 18 first first JJ 37231 30 19 part part NN 37231 30 20 , , , 37231 30 21 the the DT 37231 30 22 second second JJ 37231 30 23 and and CC 37231 30 24 third third JJ 37231 30 25 parts part NNS 37231 30 26 need need VBP 37231 30 27 not not RB 37231 30 28 have have VB 37231 30 29 been be VBN 37231 30 30 written write VBN 37231 30 31 : : : 37231 30 32 in in IN 37231 30 33 fact fact NN 37231 30 34 , , , 37231 30 35 that that IN 37231 30 36 the the DT 37231 30 37 historical historical JJ 37231 30 38 argument argument NN 37231 30 39 against against IN 37231 30 40 miracles miracle NNS 37231 30 41 is be VBZ 37231 30 42 only only RB 37231 30 43 necessary necessary JJ 37231 30 44 in in IN 37231 30 45 consequence consequence NN 37231 30 46 of of IN 37231 30 47 the the DT 37231 30 48 failure failure NN 37231 30 49 of of IN 37231 30 50 the the DT 37231 30 51 philosophical philosophical JJ 37231 30 52 . . . 37231 31 1 Now now RB 37231 31 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 31 3 contend contend VBP 37231 31 4 that that IN 37231 31 5 the the DT 37231 31 6 historical historical JJ 37231 31 7 is be VBZ 37231 31 8 the the DT 37231 31 9 necessary necessary JJ 37231 31 10 complement complement NN 37231 31 11 of of IN 37231 31 12 the the DT 37231 31 13 philosophical philosophical JJ 37231 31 14 argument argument NN 37231 31 15 , , , 37231 31 16 and and CC 37231 31 17 that that IN 37231 31 18 both both DT 37231 31 19 are be VBP 37231 31 20 equally equally RB 37231 31 21 requisite requisite JJ 37231 31 22 to to TO 37231 31 23 completeness completeness VB 37231 31 24 in in IN 37231 31 25 dealing deal VBG 37231 31 26 with with IN 37231 31 27 the the DT 37231 31 28 subject subject NN 37231 31 29 . . . 37231 32 1 The the DT 37231 32 2 preliminary preliminary JJ 37231 32 3 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 32 4 is be VBZ 37231 32 5 not not RB 37231 32 6 that that IN 37231 32 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 32 8 are be VBP 37231 32 9 impossible impossible JJ 37231 32 10 , , , 37231 32 11 but but CC 37231 32 12 that that IN 37231 32 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 32 14 are be VBP 37231 32 15 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 32 16 incredible incredible JJ 37231 32 17 . . . 37231 33 1 The the DT 37231 33 2 counter counter NN 37231 33 3 allegation allegation NN 37231 33 4 is be VBZ 37231 33 5 that that IN 37231 33 6 , , , 37231 33 7 although although IN 37231 33 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 33 9 may may MD 37231 33 10 be be VB 37231 33 11 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 33 12 incredible incredible JJ 37231 33 13 , , , 37231 33 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 33 15 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 33 16 actually actually RB 37231 33 17 took take VBD 37231 33 18 place place NN 37231 33 19 . . . 37231 34 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 34 2 is be VBZ 37231 34 3 , , , 37231 34 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 34 5 , , , 37231 34 6 necessary necessary JJ 37231 34 7 , , , 37231 34 8 not not RB 37231 34 9 only only RB 37231 34 10 to to TO 37231 34 11 establish establish VB 37231 34 12 the the DT 37231 34 13 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 34 14 incredibility incredibility NN 37231 34 15 , , , 37231 34 16 but but CC 37231 34 17 to to TO 37231 34 18 examine examine VB 37231 34 19 the the DT 37231 34 20 validity validity NN 37231 34 21 of of IN 37231 34 22 the the DT 37231 34 23 allegation allegation NN 37231 34 24 that that IN 37231 34 25 certain certain JJ 37231 34 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 34 27 occurred occur VBD 37231 34 28 , , , 37231 34 29 and and CC 37231 34 30 this this DT 37231 34 31 involves involve VBZ 37231 34 32 the the DT 37231 34 33 historical historical JJ 37231 34 34 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 34 35 into into IN 37231 34 36 the the DT 37231 34 37 evidence evidence NN 37231 34 38 for for IN 37231 34 39 the the DT 37231 34 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 34 41 which which WDT 37231 34 42 occupies occupy VBZ 37231 34 43 the the DT 37231 34 44 second second JJ 37231 34 45 and and CC 37231 34 46 third third JJ 37231 34 47 parts part NNS 37231 34 48 . . . 37231 35 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 35 2 , , , 37231 35 3 many many JJ 37231 35 4 will will MD 37231 35 5 not not RB 37231 35 6 acknowledge acknowledge VB 37231 35 7 the the DT 37231 35 8 case case NN 37231 35 9 to to TO 37231 35 10 be be VB 37231 35 11 complete complete JJ 37231 35 12 until until IN 37231 35 13 other other JJ 37231 35 14 witnesses witness NNS 37231 35 15 are be VBP 37231 35 16 questioned question VBN 37231 35 17 in in IN 37231 35 18 a a DT 37231 35 19 succeeding succeed VBG 37231 35 20 volume volume NN 37231 35 21 . . . 37231 36 1 The the DT 37231 36 2 view view NN 37231 36 3 I -PRON- PRP 37231 36 4 have have VBP 37231 36 5 taken take VBN 37231 36 6 is be VBZ 37231 36 7 clearly clearly RB 37231 36 8 supported support VBN 37231 36 9 by by IN 37231 36 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 36 11 Mill Mill NNP 37231 36 12 . . . 37231 37 1 In in IN 37231 37 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 37 3 recently recently RB 37231 37 4 published publish VBN 37231 37 5 " " `` 37231 37 6 Essays essay NNS 37231 37 7 on on IN 37231 37 8 Religion religion NN 37231 37 9 , , , 37231 37 10 " " '' 37231 37 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 37 12 directly directly RB 37231 37 13 replies reply VBZ 37231 37 14 to to IN 37231 37 15 the the DT 37231 37 16 question question NN 37231 37 17 whether whether IN 37231 37 18 any any DT 37231 37 19 evidence evidence NN 37231 37 20 can can MD 37231 37 21 suffice suffice VB 37231 37 22 to to TO 37231 37 23 prove prove VB 37231 37 24 a a DT 37231 37 25 Divine Divine NNP 37231 37 26 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 37 27 , , , 37231 37 28 and and CC 37231 37 29 defines define VBZ 37231 37 30 what what WP 37231 37 31 the the DT 37231 37 32 nature nature NN 37231 37 33 and and CC 37231 37 34 amount amount NN 37231 37 35 of of IN 37231 37 36 that that DT 37231 37 37 evidence evidence NN 37231 37 38 must must MD 37231 37 39 be be VB 37231 37 40 . . . 37231 38 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 38 2 shows show VBZ 37231 38 3 that that IN 37231 38 4 internal internal JJ 37231 38 5 evidences evidence NNS 37231 38 6 , , , 37231 38 7 that that DT 37231 38 8 is be VBZ 37231 38 9 to to TO 37231 38 10 say say VB 37231 38 11 , , , 37231 38 12 the the DT 37231 38 13 indications indication NNS 37231 38 14 which which WDT 37231 38 15 the the DT 37231 38 16 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 38 17 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 38 18 is be VBZ 37231 38 19 thought think VBN 37231 38 20 to to TO 37231 38 21 furnish furnish VB 37231 38 22 of of IN 37231 38 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 38 24 divine divine JJ 37231 38 25 origin origin NN 37231 38 26 , , , 37231 38 27 can can MD 37231 38 28 only only RB 37231 38 29 be be VB 37231 38 30 negative negative JJ 37231 38 31 . . . 37231 39 1 The the DT 37231 39 2 bad bad JJ 37231 39 3 moral moral JJ 37231 39 4 character character NN 37231 39 5 of of IN 37231 39 6 the the DT 37231 39 7 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 39 8 of of IN 37231 39 9 an an DT 37231 39 10 alleged allege VBN 37231 39 11 Revelation revelation NN 37231 39 12 , , , 37231 39 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 39 14 considers consider VBZ 37231 39 15 , , , 37231 39 16 may may MD 37231 39 17 be be VB 37231 39 18 good good JJ 37231 39 19 reason reason NN 37231 39 20 for for IN 37231 39 21 rejecting reject VBG 37231 39 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 39 23 , , , 37231 39 24 " " '' 37231 39 25 but but CC 37231 39 26 the the DT 37231 39 27 excellence excellence NN 37231 39 28 of of IN 37231 39 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 39 30 morality morality NN 37231 39 31 can can MD 37231 39 32 never never RB 37231 39 33 entitle entitle VB 37231 39 34 us -PRON- PRP 37231 39 35 to to TO 37231 39 36 ascribe ascribe VB 37231 39 37 to to IN 37231 39 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 39 39 a a DT 37231 39 40 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 39 41 origin origin NN 37231 39 42 : : : 37231 39 43 for for IN 37231 39 44 we -PRON- PRP 37231 39 45 can can MD 37231 39 46 not not RB 37231 39 47 have have VB 37231 39 48 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 39 49 reason reason NN 37231 39 50 for for IN 37231 39 51 believing believe VBG 37231 39 52 that that IN 37231 39 53 the the DT 37231 39 54 human human JJ 37231 39 55 faculties faculty NNS 37231 39 56 were be VBD 37231 39 57 incompetent incompetent JJ 37231 39 58 to to TO 37231 39 59 find find VB 37231 39 60 out out RP 37231 39 61 moral moral JJ 37231 39 62 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 39 63 of of IN 37231 39 64 which which WDT 37231 39 65 the the DT 37231 39 66 human human JJ 37231 39 67 faculties faculty NNS 37231 39 68 can can MD 37231 39 69 perceive perceive VB 37231 39 70 and and CC 37231 39 71 recognise recognise VB 37231 39 72 the the DT 37231 39 73 excellence excellence NN 37231 39 74 . . . 37231 40 1 A a DT 37231 40 2 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 40 3 , , , 37231 40 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 40 5 , , , 37231 40 6 " " '' 37231 40 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 40 8 decides decide VBZ 37231 40 9 , , , 37231 40 10 " " `` 37231 40 11 can can MD 37231 40 12 not not RB 37231 40 13 be be VB 37231 40 14 proved prove VBN 37231 40 15 divine divine JJ 37231 40 16 unless unless IN 37231 40 17 by by IN 37231 40 18 external external JJ 37231 40 19 evidence evidence NN 37231 40 20 ; ; : 37231 40 21 that that RB 37231 40 22 is is RB 37231 40 23 , , , 37231 40 24 by by IN 37231 40 25 the the DT 37231 40 26 exhibition exhibition NN 37231 40 27 of of IN 37231 40 28 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 40 29 facts fact NNS 37231 40 30 . . . 37231 41 1 " " `` 37231 41 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 41 3 1 1 LS 37231 41 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 41 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 41 6 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 41 7 that that IN 37231 41 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 41 9 is be VBZ 37231 41 10 possible possible JJ 37231 41 11 to to TO 37231 41 12 prove prove VB 37231 41 13 the the DT 37231 41 14 reality reality NN 37231 41 15 of of IN 37231 41 16 a a DT 37231 41 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 41 18 fact fact NN 37231 41 19 if if IN 37231 41 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 41 21 actually actually RB 37231 41 22 occurred occur VBD 37231 41 23 ; ; : 37231 41 24 and and CC 37231 41 25 after after IN 37231 41 26 showing show VBG 37231 41 27 the the DT 37231 41 28 great great JJ 37231 41 29 preponderance preponderance NN 37231 41 30 of of IN 37231 41 31 evidence evidence NN 37231 41 32 against against IN 37231 41 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 41 34 , , , 37231 41 35 or or CC 37231 41 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 41 37 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 41 38 incredibility incredibility NN 37231 41 39 , , , 37231 41 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 41 41 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 41 42 : : : 37231 41 43 " " `` 37231 41 44 Against against IN 37231 41 45 this this DT 37231 41 46 weight weight NN 37231 41 47 of of IN 37231 41 48 negative negative JJ 37231 41 49 evidence evidence NN 37231 41 50 we -PRON- PRP 37231 41 51 have have VBP 37231 41 52 to to TO 37231 41 53 set set VB 37231 41 54 such such JJ 37231 41 55 positive positive JJ 37231 41 56 evidence evidence NN 37231 41 57 as as IN 37231 41 58 is be VBZ 37231 41 59 produced produce VBN 37231 41 60 in in IN 37231 41 61 attestation attestation NN 37231 41 62 of of IN 37231 41 63 exceptions exception NNS 37231 41 64 ; ; : 37231 41 65 in in IN 37231 41 66 other other JJ 37231 41 67 words word NNS 37231 41 68 , , , 37231 41 69 the the DT 37231 41 70 positive positive JJ 37231 41 71 evidences evidence NNS 37231 41 72 of of IN 37231 41 73 miracles"(2 miracles"(2 NNP 37231 41 74 ) ) -RRB- 37231 41 75 This this DT 37231 41 76 is be VBZ 37231 41 77 precisely precisely RB 37231 41 78 what what WP 37231 41 79 I -PRON- PRP 37231 41 80 have have VBP 37231 41 81 done do VBN 37231 41 82 . . . 37231 42 1 In in IN 37231 42 2 order order NN 37231 42 3 to to TO 37231 42 4 show show VB 37231 42 5 that that IN 37231 42 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 42 7 Mill Mill NNP 37231 42 8 's 's POS 37231 42 9 estimate estimate NN 37231 42 10 of of IN 37231 42 11 the the DT 37231 42 12 nature nature NN 37231 42 13 of of IN 37231 42 14 this this DT 37231 42 15 positive positive JJ 37231 42 16 evidence evidence NN 37231 42 17 for for IN 37231 42 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 42 19 does do VBZ 37231 42 20 not not RB 37231 42 21 essentially essentially RB 37231 42 22 differ differ VB 37231 42 23 from from IN 37231 42 24 the the DT 37231 42 25 results result NNS 37231 42 26 of of IN 37231 42 27 this this DT 37231 42 28 work work NN 37231 42 29 , , , 37231 42 30 the the DT 37231 42 31 following follow VBG 37231 42 32 lines line NNS 37231 42 33 may may MD 37231 42 34 be be VB 37231 42 35 quoted quote VBN 37231 42 36 : : : 37231 42 37 � � ADD 37231 42 38 " " `` 37231 42 39 But but CC 37231 42 40 the the DT 37231 42 41 evidence evidence NN 37231 42 42 of of IN 37231 42 43 miracles miracle NNS 37231 42 44 , , , 37231 42 45 at at IN 37231 42 46 least least JJS 37231 42 47 to to IN 37231 42 48 Protestant Protestant NNP 37231 42 49 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 42 50 , , , 37231 42 51 is be VBZ 37231 42 52 not not RB 37231 42 53 , , , 37231 42 54 in in IN 37231 42 55 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 42 56 day day NN 37231 42 57 , , , 37231 42 58 of of IN 37231 42 59 this this DT 37231 42 60 cogent cogent JJ 37231 42 61 description description NN 37231 42 62 . . . 37231 43 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 43 2 is be VBZ 37231 43 3 not not RB 37231 43 4 the the DT 37231 43 5 evidence evidence NN 37231 43 6 of of IN 37231 43 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 43 8 senses sense NNS 37231 43 9 , , , 37231 43 10 but but CC 37231 43 11 of of IN 37231 43 12 witnesses witness NNS 37231 43 13 , , , 37231 43 14 and and CC 37231 43 15 even even RB 37231 43 16 this this DT 37231 43 17 not not RB 37231 43 18 at at IN 37231 43 19 first first JJ 37231 43 20 hand hand NN 37231 43 21 , , , 37231 43 22 but but CC 37231 43 23 resting rest VBG 37231 43 24 on on IN 37231 43 25 the the DT 37231 43 26 attestation attestation NN 37231 43 27 of of IN 37231 43 28 books book NNS 37231 43 29 and and CC 37231 43 30 traditions tradition NNS 37231 43 31 . . . 37231 44 1 And and CC 37231 44 2 even even RB 37231 44 3 in in IN 37231 44 4 the the DT 37231 44 5 case case NN 37231 44 6 of of IN 37231 44 7 the the DT 37231 44 8 original original JJ 37231 44 9 eye eye NN 37231 44 10 - - HYPH 37231 44 11 witnesses witness NNS 37231 44 12 , , , 37231 44 13 the the DT 37231 44 14 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 44 15 facts fact NNS 37231 44 16 asserted assert VBD 37231 44 17 on on IN 37231 44 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 44 19 alleged allege VBN 37231 44 20 testimony testimony NN 37231 44 21 , , , 37231 44 22 are be VBP 37231 44 23 not not RB 37231 44 24 of of IN 37231 44 25 the the DT 37231 44 26 transcendent transcendent NN 37231 44 27 character character NN 37231 44 28 supposed suppose VBN 37231 44 29 in in IN 37231 44 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 44 31 example example NN 37231 44 32 , , , 37231 44 33 about about IN 37231 44 34 the the DT 37231 44 35 nature nature NN 37231 44 36 of of IN 37231 44 37 which which WDT 37231 44 38 , , , 37231 44 39 or or CC 37231 44 40 the the DT 37231 44 41 impossibility impossibility NN 37231 44 42 of of IN 37231 44 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 44 44 having have VBG 37231 44 45 had have VBN 37231 44 46 a a DT 37231 44 47 natural natural JJ 37231 44 48 origin origin NN 37231 44 49 , , , 37231 44 50 there there EX 37231 44 51 could could MD 37231 44 52 be be VB 37231 44 53 little little JJ 37231 44 54 room room NN 37231 44 55 for for IN 37231 44 56 doubt doubt NN 37231 44 57 . . . 37231 45 1 On on IN 37231 45 2 the the DT 37231 45 3 contrary contrary NN 37231 45 4 , , , 37231 45 5 the the DT 37231 45 6 recorded record VBN 37231 45 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 45 8 are be VBP 37231 45 9 , , , 37231 45 10 in in IN 37231 45 11 the the DT 37231 45 12 first first JJ 37231 45 13 place place NN 37231 45 14 , , , 37231 45 15 generally generally RB 37231 45 16 such such JJ 37231 45 17 as as IN 37231 45 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 45 19 would would MD 37231 45 20 have have VB 37231 45 21 been be VBN 37231 45 22 extremely extremely RB 37231 45 23 difficult difficult JJ 37231 45 24 to to TO 37231 45 25 verify verify VB 37231 45 26 as as IN 37231 45 27 matters matter NNS 37231 45 28 of of IN 37231 45 29 fact fact NN 37231 45 30 , , , 37231 45 31 and and CC 37231 45 32 in in IN 37231 45 33 the the DT 37231 45 34 next next JJ 37231 45 35 place place NN 37231 45 36 , , , 37231 45 37 are be VBP 37231 45 38 hardly hardly RB 37231 45 39 ever ever RB 37231 45 40 beyond beyond IN 37231 45 41 the the DT 37231 45 42 possibility possibility NN 37231 45 43 of of IN 37231 45 44 having have VBG 37231 45 45 been be VBN 37231 45 46 brought bring VBN 37231 45 47 about about RP 37231 45 48 by by IN 37231 45 49 human human JJ 37231 45 50 means mean NNS 37231 45 51 or or CC 37231 45 52 by by IN 37231 45 53 the the DT 37231 45 54 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 37231 45 55 agencies agency NNS 37231 45 56 of of IN 37231 45 57 nature nature NN 37231 45 58 . . . 37231 45 59 " " '' 37231 46 1 The the DT 37231 46 2 second second JJ 37231 46 3 point point NN 37231 46 4 to to TO 37231 46 5 which which WDT 37231 46 6 I -PRON- PRP 37231 46 7 desire desire VBP 37231 46 8 to to TO 37231 46 9 refer refer VB 37231 46 10 is be VBZ 37231 46 11 a a DT 37231 46 12 statement statement NN 37231 46 13 which which WDT 37231 46 14 has have VBZ 37231 46 15 frequently frequently RB 37231 46 16 been be VBN 37231 46 17 made make VBN 37231 46 18 that that IN 37231 46 19 , , , 37231 46 20 in in IN 37231 46 21 the the DT 37231 46 22 second second JJ 37231 46 23 and and CC 37231 46 24 third third JJ 37231 46 25 parts part NNS 37231 46 26 , , , 37231 46 27 I -PRON- PRP 37231 46 28 endeavour endeavour VBP 37231 46 29 to to TO 37231 46 30 prove prove VB 37231 46 31 that that IN 37231 46 32 the the DT 37231 46 33 four four CD 37231 46 34 canonical canonical JJ 37231 46 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 46 36 were be VBD 37231 46 37 not not RB 37231 46 38 written write VBN 37231 46 39 until until IN 37231 46 40 the the DT 37231 46 41 end end NN 37231 46 42 of of IN 37231 46 43 the the DT 37231 46 44 second second JJ 37231 46 45 century century NN 37231 46 46 . . . 37231 47 1 This this DT 37231 47 2 error error NN 37231 47 3 is be VBZ 37231 47 4 of of IN 37231 47 5 course course NN 37231 47 6 closely closely RB 37231 47 7 connected connect VBN 37231 47 8 with with IN 37231 47 9 that that DT 37231 47 10 which which WDT 37231 47 11 has have VBZ 37231 47 12 just just RB 37231 47 13 been be VBN 37231 47 14 discussed discuss VBN 37231 47 15 , , , 37231 47 16 but but CC 37231 47 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 47 18 is be VBZ 37231 47 19 difficult difficult JJ 37231 47 20 to to TO 37231 47 21 understand understand VB 37231 47 22 how how WRB 37231 47 23 any any DT 37231 47 24 one one NN 37231 47 25 who who WP 37231 47 26 had have VBD 37231 47 27 taken take VBN 37231 47 28 the the DT 37231 47 29 slightest slight JJS 37231 47 30 trouble trouble NN 37231 47 31 to to TO 37231 47 32 ascertain ascertain VB 37231 47 33 the the DT 37231 47 34 nature nature NN 37231 47 35 of of IN 37231 47 36 the the DT 37231 47 37 argument argument NN 37231 47 38 , , , 37231 47 39 and and CC 37231 47 40 to to TO 37231 47 41 state state VB 37231 47 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 47 43 fairly fairly RB 37231 47 44 , , , 37231 47 45 could could MD 37231 47 46 have have VB 37231 47 47 fallen fall VBN 37231 47 48 into into IN 37231 47 49 it -PRON- PRP 37231 47 50 . . . 37231 48 1 The the DT 37231 48 2 fact fact NN 37231 48 3 is be VBZ 37231 48 4 that that IN 37231 48 5 no no DT 37231 48 6 attempt attempt NN 37231 48 7 is be VBZ 37231 48 8 made make VBN 37231 48 9 to to TO 37231 48 10 prove prove VB 37231 48 11 anything anything NN 37231 48 12 with with IN 37231 48 13 regard regard NN 37231 48 14 to to IN 37231 48 15 the the DT 37231 48 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 48 17 . . . 37231 49 1 The the DT 37231 49 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 49 3 for for IN 37231 49 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 49 5 is be VBZ 37231 49 6 merely merely RB 37231 49 7 examined examine VBN 37231 49 8 , , , 37231 49 9 and and CC 37231 49 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 49 11 is be VBZ 37231 49 12 found find VBN 37231 49 13 that that IN 37231 49 14 , , , 37231 49 15 so so RB 37231 49 16 far far RB 37231 49 17 from from IN 37231 49 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 49 19 affording afford VBG 37231 49 20 { { -LRB- 37231 49 21 viii viii NN 37231 49 22 } } -RRB- 37231 49 23 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 49 24 testimony testimony NN 37231 49 25 to to IN 37231 49 26 warrant warrant VB 37231 49 27 belief belief NN 37231 49 28 in in IN 37231 49 29 the the DT 37231 49 30 actual actual JJ 37231 49 31 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 49 32 of of IN 37231 49 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 49 34 declared declare VBD 37231 49 35 to to TO 37231 49 36 be be VB 37231 49 37 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 49 38 incredible incredible JJ 37231 49 39 , , , 37231 49 40 there there EX 37231 49 41 is be VBZ 37231 49 42 not not RB 37231 49 43 a a DT 37231 49 44 certain certain JJ 37231 49 45 trace trace NN 37231 49 46 even even RB 37231 49 47 of of IN 37231 49 48 the the DT 37231 49 49 existence existence NN 37231 49 50 of of IN 37231 49 51 the the DT 37231 49 52 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 49 53 for for IN 37231 49 54 a a DT 37231 49 55 century century NN 37231 49 56 and and CC 37231 49 57 a a DT 37231 49 58 half half NN 37231 49 59 after after IN 37231 49 60 those those DT 37231 49 61 miracles miracle NNS 37231 49 62 are be VBP 37231 49 63 alleged allege VBN 37231 49 64 to to TO 37231 49 65 have have VB 37231 49 66 occurred occur VBN 37231 49 67 , , , 37231 49 68 and and CC 37231 49 69 nothing nothing NN 37231 49 70 whatever whatever WDT 37231 49 71 to to TO 37231 49 72 attest attest VB 37231 49 73 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 49 74 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 49 75 and and CC 37231 49 76 truth truth NN 37231 49 77 . . . 37231 50 1 This this DT 37231 50 2 is be VBZ 37231 50 3 a a DT 37231 50 4 very very RB 37231 50 5 different different JJ 37231 50 6 thing thing NN 37231 50 7 from from IN 37231 50 8 an an DT 37231 50 9 endeavour endeavour NN 37231 50 10 to to TO 37231 50 11 establish establish VB 37231 50 12 some some DT 37231 50 13 special special JJ 37231 50 14 theory theory NN 37231 50 15 of of IN 37231 50 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 50 17 own own JJ 37231 50 18 , , , 37231 50 19 and and CC 37231 50 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 50 21 is be VBZ 37231 50 22 because because IN 37231 50 23 this this DT 37231 50 24 line line NN 37231 50 25 of of IN 37231 50 26 argument argument NN 37231 50 27 has have VBZ 37231 50 28 not not RB 37231 50 29 been be VBN 37231 50 30 understood understand VBN 37231 50 31 , , , 37231 50 32 that that IN 37231 50 33 some some DT 37231 50 34 critics critic NNS 37231 50 35 have have VBP 37231 50 36 expressed express VBN 37231 50 37 surprise surprise NN 37231 50 38 at at IN 37231 50 39 the the DT 37231 50 40 decisive decisive JJ 37231 50 41 rejection rejection NN 37231 50 42 of of IN 37231 50 43 mere mere JJ 37231 50 44 conjectures conjecture NNS 37231 50 45 and and CC 37231 50 46 possibilities possibility NNS 37231 50 47 as as IN 37231 50 48 evidence evidence NN 37231 50 49 . . . 37231 51 1 In in IN 37231 51 2 a a DT 37231 51 3 case case NN 37231 51 4 of of IN 37231 51 5 such such JJ 37231 51 6 importance importance NN 37231 51 7 , , , 37231 51 8 no no DT 37231 51 9 testimony testimony NN 37231 51 10 which which WDT 37231 51 11 is be VBZ 37231 51 12 not not RB 37231 51 13 clear clear JJ 37231 51 14 and and CC 37231 51 15 indubitable indubitable JJ 37231 51 16 could could MD 37231 51 17 be be VB 37231 51 18 of of IN 37231 51 19 any any DT 37231 51 20 value value NN 37231 51 21 , , , 37231 51 22 but but CC 37231 51 23 the the DT 37231 51 24 evidence evidence NN 37231 51 25 producible producible JJ 37231 51 26 for for IN 37231 51 27 the the DT 37231 51 28 canonical canonical JJ 37231 51 29 Gospels Gospels NNP 37231 51 30 falls fall VBZ 37231 51 31 very very RB 37231 51 32 far far RB 37231 51 33 short short JJ 37231 51 34 even even RB 37231 51 35 of of IN 37231 51 36 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 51 37 requirements requirement NNS 37231 51 38 , , , 37231 51 39 and and CC 37231 51 40 in in IN 37231 51 41 relation relation NN 37231 51 42 to to IN 37231 51 43 miracles miracle NNS 37231 51 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 51 45 is be VBZ 37231 51 46 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 51 47 deserving deserve VBG 37231 51 48 of of IN 37231 51 49 serious serious JJ 37231 51 50 consideration consideration NN 37231 51 51 . . . 37231 52 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 52 2 has have VBZ 37231 52 3 been be VBN 37231 52 4 argued argue VBN 37231 52 5 that that IN 37231 52 6 , , , 37231 52 7 even even RB 37231 52 8 if if IN 37231 52 9 there there EX 37231 52 10 be be VBP 37231 52 11 no no DT 37231 52 12 evidence evidence NN 37231 52 13 for for IN 37231 52 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 52 15 special special JJ 37231 52 16 gospels gospel NNS 37231 52 17 , , , 37231 52 18 I -PRON- PRP 37231 52 19 admit admit VBP 37231 52 20 that that IN 37231 52 21 gospels gospel NNS 37231 52 22 very very RB 37231 52 23 similar similar JJ 37231 52 24 must must MD 37231 52 25 early early RB 37231 52 26 have have VB 37231 52 27 been be VBN 37231 52 28 in in IN 37231 52 29 existence existence NN 37231 52 30 , , , 37231 52 31 and and CC 37231 52 32 that that IN 37231 52 33 these these DT 37231 52 34 equally equally RB 37231 52 35 represent represent VBP 37231 52 36 the the DT 37231 52 37 same same JJ 37231 52 38 prevailing prevailing JJ 37231 52 39 belief belief NN 37231 52 40 as as IN 37231 52 41 the the DT 37231 52 42 canonical canonical JJ 37231 52 43 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 52 44 : : : 37231 52 45 consequently consequently RB 37231 52 46 that that IN 37231 52 47 I -PRON- PRP 37231 52 48 merely merely RB 37231 52 49 change change VBP 37231 52 50 , , , 37231 52 51 without without IN 37231 52 52 shaking shake VBG 37231 52 53 , , , 37231 52 54 the the DT 37231 52 55 witnesses witness NNS 37231 52 56 . . . 37231 53 1 Those those DT 37231 53 2 who who WP 37231 53 3 advance advance VBP 37231 53 4 this this DT 37231 53 5 argument argument NN 37231 53 6 , , , 37231 53 7 however however RB 37231 53 8 , , , 37231 53 9 totally totally RB 37231 53 10 overlook overlook VBP 37231 53 11 the the DT 37231 53 12 fact fact NN 37231 53 13 that that IN 37231 53 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 53 15 is be VBZ 37231 53 16 not not RB 37231 53 17 the the DT 37231 53 18 reality reality NN 37231 53 19 of of IN 37231 53 20 the the DT 37231 53 21 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 53 22 belief belief NN 37231 53 23 which which WDT 37231 53 24 is be VBZ 37231 53 25 in in IN 37231 53 26 question question NN 37231 53 27 , , , 37231 53 28 but but CC 37231 53 29 the the DT 37231 53 30 reality reality NN 37231 53 31 of of IN 37231 53 32 the the DT 37231 53 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 53 34 , , , 37231 53 35 and and CC 37231 53 36 the the DT 37231 53 37 sufficiency sufficiency NN 37231 53 38 of of IN 37231 53 39 the the DT 37231 53 40 witnesses witness NNS 37231 53 41 to to TO 37231 53 42 establish establish VB 37231 53 43 them -PRON- PRP 37231 53 44 . . . 37231 54 1 What what WP 37231 54 2 such such JJ 37231 54 3 objectors objector NNS 37231 54 4 urge urge VBP 37231 54 5 practically practically RB 37231 54 6 amounts amount VBZ 37231 54 7 to to IN 37231 54 8 this this DT 37231 54 9 : : : 37231 54 10 that that IN 37231 54 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 54 12 should should MD 37231 54 13 believe believe VB 37231 54 14 in in IN 37231 54 15 the the DT 37231 54 16 actual actual JJ 37231 54 17 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 54 18 of of IN 37231 54 19 certain certain JJ 37231 54 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 54 21 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 54 22 to to IN 37231 54 23 all all DT 37231 54 24 experience experience NN 37231 54 25 , , , 37231 54 26 out out IN 37231 54 27 of of IN 37231 54 28 a a DT 37231 54 29 mass mass NN 37231 54 30 of of IN 37231 54 31 false false JJ 37231 54 32 miracles miracle NNS 37231 54 33 which which WDT 37231 54 34 are be VBP 37231 54 35 reported report VBN 37231 54 36 but but CC 37231 54 37 never never RB 37231 54 38 really really RB 37231 54 39 took take VBD 37231 54 40 place place NN 37231 54 41 , , , 37231 54 42 because because IN 37231 54 43 some some DT 37231 54 44 unknown unknown JJ 37231 54 45 persons person NNS 37231 54 46 in in IN 37231 54 47 an an DT 37231 54 48 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 54 49 and and CC 37231 54 50 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 54 51 age age NN 37231 54 52 , , , 37231 54 53 who who WP 37231 54 54 give give VBP 37231 54 55 no no DT 37231 54 56 evidence evidence NN 37231 54 57 of of IN 37231 54 58 personal personal JJ 37231 54 59 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 54 60 , , , 37231 54 61 or or CC 37231 54 62 of of IN 37231 54 63 careful careful JJ 37231 54 64 investigation investigation NN 37231 54 65 , , , 37231 54 66 have have VBP 37231 54 67 written write VBN 37231 54 68 an an DT 37231 54 69 account account NN 37231 54 70 of of IN 37231 54 71 them -PRON- PRP 37231 54 72 , , , 37231 54 73 and and CC 37231 54 74 other other JJ 37231 54 75 { { -LRB- 37231 54 76 ix ix NNP 37231 54 77 } } -RRB- 37231 54 78 persons person NNS 37231 54 79 , , , 37231 54 80 equally equally RB 37231 54 81 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 54 82 and and CC 37231 54 83 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 54 84 , , , 37231 54 85 have have VBP 37231 54 86 believed believe VBN 37231 54 87 them -PRON- PRP 37231 54 88 . . . 37231 55 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 55 2 venture venture VBP 37231 55 3 to to TO 37231 55 4 say say VB 37231 55 5 that that IN 37231 55 6 no no DT 37231 55 7 one one NN 37231 55 8 who who WP 37231 55 9 advances advance VBZ 37231 55 10 the the DT 37231 55 11 argument argument NN 37231 55 12 to to TO 37231 55 13 which which WDT 37231 55 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 55 15 am be VBP 37231 55 16 referring refer VBG 37231 55 17 can can MD 37231 55 18 have have VB 37231 55 19 realized realize VBN 37231 55 20 the the DT 37231 55 21 nature nature NN 37231 55 22 of of IN 37231 55 23 the the DT 37231 55 24 question question NN 37231 55 25 at at IN 37231 55 26 issue issue NN 37231 55 27 , , , 37231 55 28 and and CC 37231 55 29 the the DT 37231 55 30 relation relation NN 37231 55 31 of of IN 37231 55 32 miracles miracle NNS 37231 55 33 to to IN 37231 55 34 the the DT 37231 55 35 order order NN 37231 55 36 of of IN 37231 55 37 nature nature NN 37231 55 38 . . . 37231 56 1 The the DT 37231 56 2 last last JJ 37231 56 3 of of IN 37231 56 4 these these DT 37231 56 5 general general JJ 37231 56 6 objections objection NNS 37231 56 7 to to TO 37231 56 8 which which WDT 37231 56 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 56 10 need need VBP 37231 56 11 now now RB 37231 56 12 refer refer VB 37231 56 13 is be VBZ 37231 56 14 the the DT 37231 56 15 statement statement NN 37231 56 16 , , , 37231 56 17 that that IN 37231 56 18 the the DT 37231 56 19 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 56 20 with with IN 37231 56 21 regard regard NN 37231 56 22 to to IN 37231 56 23 the the DT 37231 56 24 Gospels Gospels NNP 37231 56 25 commences commence NNS 37231 56 26 precisely precisely RB 37231 56 27 where where WRB 37231 56 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 56 29 examination examination NN 37231 56 30 ends end VBZ 37231 56 31 , , , 37231 56 32 and and CC 37231 56 33 that that IN 37231 56 34 I -PRON- PRP 37231 56 35 am be VBP 37231 56 36 bound bind VBN 37231 56 37 to to TO 37231 56 38 explain explain VB 37231 56 39 how how WRB 37231 56 40 , , , 37231 56 41 if if IN 37231 56 42 no no DT 37231 56 43 trace trace NN 37231 56 44 of of IN 37231 56 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 56 46 existence existence NN 37231 56 47 is be VBZ 37231 56 48 previously previously RB 37231 56 49 discoverable discoverable JJ 37231 56 50 , , , 37231 56 51 the the DT 37231 56 52 four four CD 37231 56 53 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 56 54 are be VBP 37231 56 55 suddenly suddenly RB 37231 56 56 found find VBN 37231 56 57 in in IN 37231 56 58 general general JJ 37231 56 59 circulation circulation NN 37231 56 60 at at IN 37231 56 61 the the DT 37231 56 62 end end NN 37231 56 63 of of IN 37231 56 64 the the DT 37231 56 65 second second JJ 37231 56 66 century century NN 37231 56 67 , , , 37231 56 68 and and CC 37231 56 69 quoted quote VBN 37231 56 70 as as IN 37231 56 71 authoritative authoritative JJ 37231 56 72 documents document NNS 37231 56 73 by by IN 37231 56 74 such such JJ 37231 56 75 writers writer NNS 37231 56 76 as as IN 37231 56 77 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 56 78 . . . 37231 57 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 57 2 reply reply NN 37231 57 3 is be VBZ 37231 57 4 that that IN 37231 57 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 57 6 is be VBZ 37231 57 7 totally totally RB 37231 57 8 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 57 9 for for IN 37231 57 10 me -PRON- PRP 37231 57 11 to to TO 37231 57 12 account account VB 37231 57 13 for for IN 37231 57 14 this this DT 37231 57 15 . . . 37231 58 1 No no DT 37231 58 2 one one NN 37231 58 3 acquainted acquaint VBD 37231 58 4 with with IN 37231 58 5 the the DT 37231 58 6 history history NN 37231 58 7 of of IN 37231 58 8 pseudonymic pseudonymic JJ 37231 58 9 literature literature NN 37231 58 10 in in IN 37231 58 11 the the DT 37231 58 12 second second JJ 37231 58 13 century century NN 37231 58 14 , , , 37231 58 15 and and CC 37231 58 16 with with IN 37231 58 17 the the DT 37231 58 18 rapid rapid JJ 37231 58 19 circulation circulation NN 37231 58 20 and and CC 37231 58 21 ready ready JJ 37231 58 22 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 58 23 of of IN 37231 58 24 spurious spurious JJ 37231 58 25 works work NNS 37231 58 26 tending tend VBG 37231 58 27 to to IN 37231 58 28 edification edification NN 37231 58 29 , , , 37231 58 30 could could MD 37231 58 31 for for IN 37231 58 32 a a DT 37231 58 33 moment moment NN 37231 58 34 regard regard VB 37231 58 35 the the DT 37231 58 36 canonical canonical JJ 37231 58 37 position position NN 37231 58 38 of of IN 37231 58 39 any any DT 37231 58 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 58 41 at at IN 37231 58 42 the the DT 37231 58 43 end end NN 37231 58 44 of of IN 37231 58 45 that that DT 37231 58 46 century century NN 37231 58 47 either either CC 37231 58 48 as as IN 37231 58 49 evidence evidence NN 37231 58 50 of of IN 37231 58 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 58 52 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 58 53 or or CC 37231 58 54 early early JJ 37231 58 55 origin origin NN 37231 58 56 . . . 37231 59 1 That that DT 37231 59 2 which which WDT 37231 59 3 concerns concern VBZ 37231 59 4 us -PRON- PRP 37231 59 5 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 59 6 is be VBZ 37231 59 7 not not RB 37231 59 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 59 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 59 10 the the DT 37231 59 11 end end NN 37231 59 12 of of IN 37231 59 13 the the DT 37231 59 14 second second JJ 37231 59 15 but but CC 37231 59 16 the the DT 37231 59 17 beginning beginning NN 37231 59 18 of of IN 37231 59 19 the the DT 37231 59 20 first first JJ 37231 59 21 century century NN 37231 59 22 . . . 37231 60 1 Even even RB 37231 60 2 if if IN 37231 60 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 60 4 took take VBD 37231 60 5 the the DT 37231 60 6 statements statement NNS 37231 60 7 of of IN 37231 60 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 60 9 , , , 37231 60 10 and and CC 37231 60 11 later late JJR 37231 60 12 Fathers father NNS 37231 60 13 like like IN 37231 60 14 the the DT 37231 60 15 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 37231 60 16 Clement Clement NNP 37231 60 17 , , , 37231 60 18 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 60 19 , , , 37231 60 20 and and CC 37231 60 21 Origen Origen NNP 37231 60 22 , , , 37231 60 23 about about IN 37231 60 24 the the DT 37231 60 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 60 26 , , , 37231 60 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 60 28 are be VBP 37231 60 29 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 60 30 without without IN 37231 60 31 value value NN 37231 60 32 except except IN 37231 60 33 as as IN 37231 60 34 personal personal JJ 37231 60 35 opinion opinion NN 37231 60 36 at at IN 37231 60 37 a a DT 37231 60 38 late late JJ 37231 60 39 date date NN 37231 60 40 , , , 37231 60 41 for for IN 37231 60 42 which which WDT 37231 60 43 no no DT 37231 60 44 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 60 45 grounds ground NNS 37231 60 46 are be VBP 37231 60 47 shown show VBN 37231 60 48 . . . 37231 61 1 Of of IN 37231 61 2 the the DT 37231 61 3 earlier early JJR 37231 61 4 history history NN 37231 61 5 of of IN 37231 61 6 those those DT 37231 61 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 61 8 there there EX 37231 61 9 is be VBZ 37231 61 10 not not RB 37231 61 11 a a DT 37231 61 12 distinct distinct JJ 37231 61 13 trace trace NN 37231 61 14 , , , 37231 61 15 except except IN 37231 61 16 of of IN 37231 61 17 a a DT 37231 61 18 nature nature NN 37231 61 19 which which WDT 37231 61 20 altogether altogether RB 37231 61 21 discredits discredit VBZ 37231 61 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 61 23 as as IN 37231 61 24 witnesses witness NNS 37231 61 25 for for IN 37231 61 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 61 27 . . . 37231 62 1 After after IN 37231 62 2 having have VBG 37231 62 3 carefully carefully RB 37231 62 4 weighed weigh VBN 37231 62 5 the the DT 37231 62 6 arguments argument NNS 37231 62 7 which which WDT 37231 62 8 have have VBP 37231 62 9 been be VBN 37231 62 10 advanced advance VBN 37231 62 11 against against IN 37231 62 12 this this DT 37231 62 13 work work NN 37231 62 14 , , , 37231 62 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 62 16 venture venture VBP 37231 62 17 to to TO 37231 62 18 express express VB 37231 62 19 strengthened strengthened JJ 37231 62 20 conviction conviction NN 37231 62 21 of of IN 37231 62 22 the the DT 37231 62 23 truth truth NN 37231 62 24 of of IN 37231 62 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 62 26 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 62 27 . . . 37231 63 1 { { -LRB- 37231 63 2 x x LS 37231 63 3 } } -RRB- 37231 63 4 The the DT 37231 63 5 best good JJS 37231 63 6 and and CC 37231 63 7 most most RBS 37231 63 8 powerful powerful JJ 37231 63 9 reasons reason NNS 37231 63 10 which which WDT 37231 63 11 able able JJ 37231 63 12 divines divine NNS 37231 63 13 and and CC 37231 63 14 apologists apologist NNS 37231 63 15 have have VBP 37231 63 16 been be VBN 37231 63 17 able able JJ 37231 63 18 to to TO 37231 63 19 bring bring VB 37231 63 20 forward forward RB 37231 63 21 against against IN 37231 63 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 63 23 main main JJ 37231 63 24 argument argument NN 37231 63 25 have have VBP 37231 63 26 , , , 37231 63 27 I -PRON- PRP 37231 63 28 submit submit VBP 37231 63 29 , , , 37231 63 30 not not RB 37231 63 31 only only RB 37231 63 32 failed fail VBD 37231 63 33 to to TO 37231 63 34 shake shake VB 37231 63 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 63 36 , , , 37231 63 37 but but CC 37231 63 38 have have VBP 37231 63 39 , , , 37231 63 40 by by IN 37231 63 41 inference inference NN 37231 63 42 , , , 37231 63 43 shown show VBD 37231 63 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 63 45 to to TO 37231 63 46 be be VB 37231 63 47 unassailable unassailable JJ 37231 63 48 . . . 37231 64 1 Very very RB 37231 64 2 many many JJ 37231 64 3 of of IN 37231 64 4 those those DT 37231 64 5 who who WP 37231 64 6 have have VBP 37231 64 7 professedly professedly RB 37231 64 8 advanced advance VBN 37231 64 9 against against IN 37231 64 10 the the DT 37231 64 11 citadel citadel NN 37231 64 12 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 64 13 have have VBP 37231 64 14 practically practically RB 37231 64 15 attacked attack VBN 37231 64 16 nothing nothing NN 37231 64 17 but but IN 37231 64 18 some some DT 37231 64 19 outlying outlying JJ 37231 64 20 fort fort NN 37231 64 21 , , , 37231 64 22 which which WDT 37231 64 23 was be VBD 37231 64 24 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 64 25 worth worth JJ 37231 64 26 defence defence NN 37231 64 27 , , , 37231 64 28 whilst whilst IN 37231 64 29 others other NNS 37231 64 30 , , , 37231 64 31 who who WP 37231 64 32 have have VBP 37231 64 33 seriously seriously RB 37231 64 34 attempted attempt VBN 37231 64 35 an an DT 37231 64 36 assault assault NN 37231 64 37 , , , 37231 64 38 have have VBP 37231 64 39 shown show VBN 37231 64 40 that that IN 37231 64 41 the the DT 37231 64 42 Church Church NNP 37231 64 43 has have VBZ 37231 64 44 no no DT 37231 64 45 artillery artillery NN 37231 64 46 capable capable JJ 37231 64 47 of of IN 37231 64 48 making make VBG 37231 64 49 a a DT 37231 64 50 practicable practicable JJ 37231 64 51 breach breach NN 37231 64 52 in in IN 37231 64 53 the the DT 37231 64 54 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 37231 64 55 stronghold stronghold NN 37231 64 56 . . . 37231 65 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 65 2 say say VBP 37231 65 3 this this DT 37231 65 4 solely solely RB 37231 65 5 in in IN 37231 65 6 reference reference NN 37231 65 7 to to IN 37231 65 8 the the DT 37231 65 9 argument argument NN 37231 65 10 which which WDT 37231 65 11 I -PRON- PRP 37231 65 12 have have VBP 37231 65 13 taken take VBN 37231 65 14 upon upon IN 37231 65 15 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 65 16 to to TO 37231 65 17 represent represent VB 37231 65 18 , , , 37231 65 19 and and CC 37231 65 20 in in IN 37231 65 21 no no DT 37231 65 22 sense sense NN 37231 65 23 of of IN 37231 65 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 65 25 own own JJ 37231 65 26 individual individual JJ 37231 65 27 share share NN 37231 65 28 in in IN 37231 65 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 65 30 maintenance maintenance NN 37231 65 31 . . . 37231 66 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 66 2 must must MD 37231 66 3 now now RB 37231 66 4 address address VB 37231 66 5 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 66 6 more more RBR 37231 66 7 particularly particularly RB 37231 66 8 to to IN 37231 66 9 two two CD 37231 66 10 of of IN 37231 66 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 66 12 critics critic NNS 37231 66 13 who who WP 37231 66 14 , , , 37231 66 15 with with IN 37231 66 16 great great JJ 37231 66 17 ability ability NN 37231 66 18 and and CC 37231 66 19 learning learning NN 37231 66 20 , , , 37231 66 21 have have VBP 37231 66 22 subjected subject VBN 37231 66 23 this this DT 37231 66 24 work work NN 37231 66 25 to to IN 37231 66 26 the the DT 37231 66 27 most most RBS 37231 66 28 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 66 29 and and CC 37231 66 30 microscopic microscopic JJ 37231 66 31 criticism criticism NN 37231 66 32 of of IN 37231 66 33 which which WDT 37231 66 34 personal personal JJ 37231 66 35 earnestness earnestness NN 37231 66 36 and and CC 37231 66 37 official official JJ 37231 66 38 zeal zeal NN 37231 66 39 are be VBP 37231 66 40 capable capable JJ 37231 66 41 . . . 37231 67 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 67 2 am be VBP 37231 67 3 sincerely sincerely RB 37231 67 4 obliged oblige VBN 37231 67 5 to to IN 37231 67 6 Professor Professor NNP 37231 67 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 67 8 and and CC 37231 67 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 67 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 67 11 for for IN 37231 67 12 the the DT 37231 67 13 minute minute JJ 37231 67 14 attention attention NN 37231 67 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 67 16 have have VBP 37231 67 17 bestowed bestow VBN 37231 67 18 upon upon IN 37231 67 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 67 20 book book NN 37231 67 21 . . . 37231 68 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 68 2 had have VBD 37231 68 3 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 68 4 directly directly RB 37231 68 5 attacked attack VBN 37231 68 6 the the DT 37231 68 7 views view NNS 37231 68 8 of of IN 37231 68 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 68 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 68 11 , , , 37231 68 12 and and CC 37231 68 13 of of IN 37231 68 14 course course NN 37231 68 15 could could MD 37231 68 16 only only RB 37231 68 17 expect expect VB 37231 68 18 him -PRON- PRP 37231 68 19 to to TO 37231 68 20 do do VB 37231 68 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 68 22 best good JJS 37231 68 23 or or CC 37231 68 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 68 25 worst bad JJS 37231 68 26 against against IN 37231 68 27 me -PRON- PRP 37231 68 28 in in IN 37231 68 29 reply reply NN 37231 68 30 ; ; : 37231 68 31 and and CC 37231 68 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 68 33 am be VBP 37231 68 34 not not RB 37231 68 35 surprised surprised JJ 37231 68 36 at at IN 37231 68 37 the the DT 37231 68 38 vigour vigour NN 37231 68 39 with with IN 37231 68 40 which which WDT 37231 68 41 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 68 42 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 68 43 has have VBZ 37231 68 44 assailed assail VBN 37231 68 45 a a DT 37231 68 46 work work NN 37231 68 47 so so RB 37231 68 48 opposed oppose VBN 37231 68 49 to to IN 37231 68 50 principles principle NNS 37231 68 51 which which WDT 37231 68 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 68 53 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 68 54 holds hold VBZ 37231 68 55 sacred sacred JJ 37231 68 56 , , , 37231 68 57 although although IN 37231 68 58 I -PRON- PRP 37231 68 59 may may MD 37231 68 60 be be VB 37231 68 61 permitted permit VBN 37231 68 62 to to TO 37231 68 63 express express VB 37231 68 64 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 68 65 regret regret NN 37231 68 66 that that IN 37231 68 67 he -PRON- PRP 37231 68 68 has have VBZ 37231 68 69 not not RB 37231 68 70 done do VBN 37231 68 71 so so RB 37231 68 72 in in IN 37231 68 73 a a DT 37231 68 74 spirit spirit NN 37231 68 75 more more RBR 37231 68 76 worthy worthy JJ 37231 68 77 of of IN 37231 68 78 the the DT 37231 68 79 cause cause NN 37231 68 80 which which WDT 37231 68 81 he -PRON- PRP 37231 68 82 defends defend VBZ 37231 68 83 . . . 37231 69 1 In in IN 37231 69 2 spite spite NN 37231 69 3 of of IN 37231 69 4 hostile hostile JJ 37231 69 5 criticism criticism NN 37231 69 6 of of IN 37231 69 7 very very RB 37231 69 8 unusual unusual JJ 37231 69 9 minuteness minuteness NN 37231 69 10 and and CC 37231 69 11 ability ability NN 37231 69 12 , , , 37231 69 13 no no DT 37231 69 14 flaw flaw NN 37231 69 15 or or CC 37231 69 16 error error NN 37231 69 17 has have VBZ 37231 69 18 been be VBN 37231 69 19 pointed point VBN 37231 69 20 out out RP 37231 69 21 which which WDT 37231 69 22 in in IN 37231 69 23 the the DT 37231 69 24 slightest slight JJS 37231 69 25 degree degree NN 37231 69 26 affects affect VBZ 37231 69 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 69 28 main main JJ 37231 69 29 argument argument NN 37231 69 30 , , , 37231 69 31 and and CC 37231 69 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 69 33 consider consider VBP 37231 69 34 that that IN 37231 69 35 every every DT 37231 69 36 point point NN 37231 69 37 yet yet RB 37231 69 38 objected object VBN 37231 69 39 to to IN 37231 69 40 by by IN 37231 69 41 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 69 42 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 69 43 , , , 37231 69 44 or or CC 37231 69 45 indicated indicate VBN 37231 69 46 by by IN 37231 69 47 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 69 48 { { -LRB- 37231 69 49 xi xi NNP 37231 69 50 } } -RRB- 37231 69 51 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 69 52 , , , 37231 69 53 might may MD 37231 69 54 be be VB 37231 69 55 withdrawn withdraw VBN 37231 69 56 without without IN 37231 69 57 at at RB 37231 69 58 all all RB 37231 69 59 weakening weaken VBG 37231 69 60 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 69 61 position position NN 37231 69 62 . . . 37231 70 1 These these DT 37231 70 2 objections objection NNS 37231 70 3 , , , 37231 70 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 70 5 may may MD 37231 70 6 say say VB 37231 70 7 , , , 37231 70 8 refer refer VBP 37231 70 9 solely solely RB 37231 70 10 to to IN 37231 70 11 details detail NNS 37231 70 12 , , , 37231 70 13 and and CC 37231 70 14 only only RB 37231 70 15 follow follow VBP 37231 70 16 side side NN 37231 70 17 issues issue NNS 37231 70 18 , , , 37231 70 19 but but CC 37231 70 20 the the DT 37231 70 21 attack attack NN 37231 70 22 , , , 37231 70 23 if if IN 37231 70 24 impotent impotent NN 37231 70 25 against against IN 37231 70 26 the the DT 37231 70 27 main main JJ 37231 70 28 position position NN 37231 70 29 , , , 37231 70 30 has have VBZ 37231 70 31 in in IN 37231 70 32 many many JJ 37231 70 33 cases case NNS 37231 70 34 been be VBN 37231 70 35 insidiously insidiously RB 37231 70 36 directed direct VBN 37231 70 37 against against IN 37231 70 38 notes note NNS 37231 70 39 and and CC 37231 70 40 passing pass VBG 37231 70 41 references reference NNS 37231 70 42 , , , 37231 70 43 and and CC 37231 70 44 a a DT 37231 70 45 plentiful plentiful JJ 37231 70 46 sprinkling sprinkling NN 37231 70 47 of of IN 37231 70 48 such such JJ 37231 70 49 words word NNS 37231 70 50 as as IN 37231 70 51 " " `` 37231 70 52 misstatements misstatement NNS 37231 70 53 " " '' 37231 70 54 and and CC 37231 70 55 " " `` 37231 70 56 misrepresentations misrepresentation NNS 37231 70 57 " " '' 37231 70 58 along along IN 37231 70 59 the the DT 37231 70 60 line line NN 37231 70 61 may may MD 37231 70 62 have have VB 37231 70 63 given give VBN 37231 70 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 70 65 a a DT 37231 70 66 formidable formidable JJ 37231 70 67 appearance appearance NN 37231 70 68 , , , 37231 70 69 and and CC 37231 70 70 malicious malicious JJ 37231 70 71 effect effect NN 37231 70 72 , , , 37231 70 73 which which WDT 37231 70 74 render render VBP 37231 70 75 it -PRON- PRP 37231 70 76 worth worth JJ 37231 70 77 while while IN 37231 70 78 once once RB 37231 70 79 for for IN 37231 70 80 all all DT 37231 70 81 to to TO 37231 70 82 meet meet VB 37231 70 83 it -PRON- PRP 37231 70 84 in in IN 37231 70 85 detail detail NN 37231 70 86 . . . 37231 71 1 The the DT 37231 71 2 first first JJ 37231 71 3 point point NN 37231 71 4 ( ( -LRB- 37231 71 5 1 1 CD 37231 71 6 ) ) -RRB- 37231 71 7 to to TO 37231 71 8 which which WDT 37231 71 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 71 10 shall shall MD 37231 71 11 refer refer VB 37231 71 12 is be VBZ 37231 71 13 an an DT 37231 71 14 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 71 15 argument argument NN 37231 71 16 by by IN 37231 71 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 71 18 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 71 19 regarding regard VBG 37231 71 20 the the DT 37231 71 21 " " `` 37231 71 22 Silence Silence NNP 37231 71 23 of of IN 37231 71 24 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 71 25 . . . 37231 71 26 " " '' 37231 72 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 72 2 2 2 LS 37231 72 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 72 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 72 5 had have VBD 37231 72 6 called call VBN 37231 72 7 attention attention NN 37231 72 8 to to IN 37231 72 9 the the DT 37231 72 10 importance importance NN 37231 72 11 of of IN 37231 72 12 considering consider VBG 37231 72 13 the the DT 37231 72 14 silence silence NN 37231 72 15 of of IN 37231 72 16 the the DT 37231 72 17 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 72 18 , , , 37231 72 19 under under IN 37231 72 20 certain certain JJ 37231 72 21 conditions;(3 conditions;(3 NN 37231 72 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 72 23 and and CC 37231 72 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 72 25 might may MD 37231 72 26 , , , 37231 72 27 omitting omit VBG 37231 72 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 72 29 curious curious JJ 37231 72 30 limitation limitation NN 37231 72 31 , , , 37231 72 32 adopt adopt VB 37231 72 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 72 34 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 72 35 's 's POS 37231 72 36 opening opening NN 37231 72 37 comment comment NN 37231 72 38 upon upon IN 37231 72 39 this this DT 37231 72 40 as as IN 37231 72 41 singularly singularly RB 37231 72 42 descriptive descriptive JJ 37231 72 43 of of IN 37231 72 44 the the DT 37231 72 45 state state NN 37231 72 46 of of IN 37231 72 47 the the DT 37231 72 48 case case NN 37231 72 49 : : : 37231 72 50 " " `` 37231 72 51 In in IN 37231 72 52 one one CD 37231 72 53 province province NN 37231 72 54 more more RBR 37231 72 55 especially especially RB 37231 72 56 , , , 37231 72 57 relating relate VBG 37231 72 58 to to IN 37231 72 59 the the DT 37231 72 60 external external JJ 37231 72 61 evidences evidence NNS 37231 72 62 for for IN 37231 72 63 the the DT 37231 72 64 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 72 65 , , , 37231 72 66 silence silence VB 37231 72 67 occupies occupy VBZ 37231 72 68 a a DT 37231 72 69 prominent prominent JJ 37231 72 70 place place NN 37231 72 71 . . . 37231 72 72 " " '' 37231 73 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 73 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 73 3 proposes propose VBZ 37231 73 4 to to TO 37231 73 5 interrogate interrogate VB 37231 73 6 this this DT 37231 73 7 " " `` 37231 73 8 mysterious mysterious JJ 37231 73 9 oracle oracle NN 37231 73 10 , , , 37231 73 11 " " '' 37231 73 12 and and CC 37231 73 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 73 14 considers consider VBZ 37231 73 15 that that IN 37231 73 16 " " `` 37231 73 17 the the DT 37231 73 18 response response NN 37231 73 19 elicited elicit VBD 37231 73 20 will will MD 37231 73 21 not not RB 37231 73 22 be be VB 37231 73 23 at at RB 37231 73 24 all all RB 37231 73 25 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 37231 73 26 . . . 37231 73 27 " " '' 37231 74 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 74 2 might may MD 37231 74 3 again again RB 37231 74 4 agree agree VB 37231 74 5 with with IN 37231 74 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 74 7 , , , 37231 74 8 but but CC 37231 74 9 that that IN 37231 74 10 unambiguous unambiguous JJ 37231 74 11 response response NN 37231 74 12 can can MD 37231 74 13 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 74 14 be be VB 37231 74 15 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 74 16 very very RB 37231 74 17 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 37231 74 18 for for IN 37231 74 19 the the DT 37231 74 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 74 21 . . . 37231 75 1 Such such JJ 37231 75 2 silence silence NN 37231 75 3 may may MD 37231 75 4 be be VB 37231 75 5 very very RB 37231 75 6 eloquent eloquent JJ 37231 75 7 , , , 37231 75 8 but but CC 37231 75 9 after after IN 37231 75 10 all all DT 37231 75 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 75 12 is be VBZ 37231 75 13 only only RB 37231 75 14 the the DT 37231 75 15 eloquence eloquence NN 37231 75 16 of of IN 37231 75 17 -- -- : 37231 75 18 silence silence NN 37231 75 19 . . . 37231 76 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 76 2 have have VBP 37231 76 3 not not RB 37231 76 4 yet yet RB 37231 76 5 met meet VBN 37231 76 6 with with IN 37231 76 7 the the DT 37231 76 8 argument argument NN 37231 76 9 anywhere anywhere RB 37231 76 10 that that IN 37231 76 11 , , , 37231 76 12 because because IN 37231 76 13 none none NN 37231 76 14 of of IN 37231 76 15 the the DT 37231 76 16 early early JJ 37231 76 17 Fathers father NNS 37231 76 18 quote quote VBP 37231 76 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 76 20 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 76 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 76 22 , , , 37231 76 23 or or CC 37231 76 24 say say VB 37231 76 25 anything anything NN 37231 76 26 with with IN 37231 76 27 regard regard NN 37231 76 28 to to IN 37231 76 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 76 30 , , , 37231 76 31 the the DT 37231 76 32 fact fact NN 37231 76 33 is be VBZ 37231 76 34 unambiguous unambiguous JJ 37231 76 35 { { -LRB- 37231 76 36 xii xii NNP 37231 76 37 } } -RRB- 37231 76 38 evidence evidence NN 37231 76 39 that that IN 37231 76 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 76 41 were be VBD 37231 76 42 well well RB 37231 76 43 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 76 44 with with IN 37231 76 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 76 46 , , , 37231 76 47 and and CC 37231 76 48 considered consider VBD 37231 76 49 them -PRON- PRP 37231 76 50 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 76 51 and and CC 37231 76 52 authoritative authoritative JJ 37231 76 53 . . . 37231 77 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 77 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 77 3 's 's POS 37231 77 4 argument argument NN 37231 77 5 from from IN 37231 77 6 Silence Silence NNP 37231 77 7 is be VBZ 37231 77 8 , , , 37231 77 9 for for IN 37231 77 10 the the DT 37231 77 11 present present NN 37231 77 12 at at IN 37231 77 13 least least JJS 37231 77 14 , , , 37231 77 15 limited limit VBN 37231 77 16 to to IN 37231 77 17 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 77 18 . . . 37231 78 1 The the DT 37231 78 2 point point NN 37231 78 3 on on IN 37231 78 4 which which WDT 37231 78 5 the the DT 37231 78 6 argument argument NN 37231 78 7 turns turn VBZ 37231 78 8 is be VBZ 37231 78 9 this this DT 37231 78 10 : : : 37231 78 11 After after IN 37231 78 12 examining examine VBG 37231 78 13 the the DT 37231 78 14 whole whole NN 37231 78 15 of of IN 37231 78 16 the the DT 37231 78 17 extant extant JJ 37231 78 18 writings writing NNS 37231 78 19 of of IN 37231 78 20 the the DT 37231 78 21 early early JJ 37231 78 22 Fathers father NNS 37231 78 23 , , , 37231 78 24 and and CC 37231 78 25 finding find VBG 37231 78 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 78 27 a a DT 37231 78 28 complete complete JJ 37231 78 29 blank blank NN 37231 78 30 as as IN 37231 78 31 regards regard VBZ 37231 78 32 the the DT 37231 78 33 canonical canonical JJ 37231 78 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 78 35 , , , 37231 78 36 if if IN 37231 78 37 , , , 37231 78 38 by by IN 37231 78 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 78 40 use use NN 37231 78 41 of of IN 37231 78 42 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 78 43 works work NNS 37231 78 44 and and CC 37231 78 45 other other JJ 37231 78 46 indications indication NNS 37231 78 47 they -PRON- PRP 37231 78 48 are be VBP 37231 78 49 not not RB 37231 78 50 evidence evidence NN 37231 78 51 against against IN 37231 78 52 them -PRON- PRP 37231 78 53 , , , 37231 78 54 I -PRON- PRP 37231 78 55 supplement supplement VBD 37231 78 56 this this DT 37231 78 57 , , , 37231 78 58 in in IN 37231 78 59 the the DT 37231 78 60 case case NN 37231 78 61 of of IN 37231 78 62 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 78 63 , , , 37231 78 64 Papias Papias NNP 37231 78 65 , , , 37231 78 66 and and CC 37231 78 67 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 78 68 of of IN 37231 78 69 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 78 70 , , , 37231 78 71 by by IN 37231 78 72 the the DT 37231 78 73 inference inference NN 37231 78 74 that that IN 37231 78 75 , , , 37231 78 76 as as IN 37231 78 77 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 78 78 does do VBZ 37231 78 79 not not RB 37231 78 80 state state VB 37231 78 81 that that IN 37231 78 82 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 78 83 lost lose VBN 37231 78 84 works work NNS 37231 78 85 contained contain VBD 37231 78 86 any any DT 37231 78 87 evidence evidence NN 37231 78 88 for for IN 37231 78 89 the the DT 37231 78 90 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 78 91 , , , 37231 78 92 they -PRON- PRP 37231 78 93 actually actually RB 37231 78 94 did do VBD 37231 78 95 not not RB 37231 78 96 contain contain VB 37231 78 97 any any DT 37231 78 98 . . . 37231 79 1 But but CC 37231 79 2 before before IN 37231 79 3 proceeding proceed VBG 37231 79 4 to to TO 37231 79 5 discuss discuss VB 37231 79 6 the the DT 37231 79 7 point point NN 37231 79 8 , , , 37231 79 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 79 10 is be VBZ 37231 79 11 necessary necessary JJ 37231 79 12 that that IN 37231 79 13 a a DT 37231 79 14 proper proper JJ 37231 79 15 estimate estimate NN 37231 79 16 should should MD 37231 79 17 be be VB 37231 79 18 formed form VBN 37231 79 19 of of IN 37231 79 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 79 21 importance importance NN 37231 79 22 to to IN 37231 79 23 the the DT 37231 79 24 main main JJ 37231 79 25 argument argument NN 37231 79 26 of of IN 37231 79 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 79 28 work work NN 37231 79 29 . . . 37231 80 1 The the DT 37231 80 2 evident evident JJ 37231 80 3 labour labour NN 37231 80 4 which which WDT 37231 80 5 Professor Professor NNP 37231 80 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 80 7 has have VBZ 37231 80 8 expended expend VBN 37231 80 9 upon upon IN 37231 80 10 the the DT 37231 80 11 preparation preparation NN 37231 80 12 of of IN 37231 80 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 80 14 attack attack NN 37231 80 15 , , , 37231 80 16 the the DT 37231 80 17 space space NN 37231 80 18 devoted devote VBN 37231 80 19 to to IN 37231 80 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 80 21 , , , 37231 80 22 and and CC 37231 80 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 80 24 own own JJ 37231 80 25 express express JJ 37231 80 26 words word NNS 37231 80 27 , , , 37231 80 28 would would MD 37231 80 29 naturally naturally RB 37231 80 30 lead lead VB 37231 80 31 most most JJS 37231 80 32 readers reader NNS 37231 80 33 to to TO 37231 80 34 suppose suppose VB 37231 80 35 that that IN 37231 80 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 80 37 has have VBZ 37231 80 38 almost almost RB 37231 80 39 a a DT 37231 80 40 vital vital JJ 37231 80 41 bearing bearing NN 37231 80 42 upon upon IN 37231 80 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 80 44 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 80 45 . . . 37231 81 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 81 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 81 3 says say VBZ 37231 81 4 , , , 37231 81 5 after after IN 37231 81 6 quoting quote VBG 37231 81 7 the the DT 37231 81 8 passages passage NNS 37231 81 9 in in IN 37231 81 10 which which WDT 37231 81 11 I -PRON- PRP 37231 81 12 appeal appeal VBP 37231 81 13 to to IN 37231 81 14 the the DT 37231 81 15 silence silence NN 37231 81 16 of of IN 37231 81 17 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 81 18 : : : 37231 81 19 " " `` 37231 81 20 This this DT 37231 81 21 indeed indeed RB 37231 81 22 is be VBZ 37231 81 23 the the DT 37231 81 24 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 81 25 assumption assumption NN 37231 81 26 which which WDT 37231 81 27 lies lie VBZ 37231 81 28 at at IN 37231 81 29 the the DT 37231 81 30 basis basis NN 37231 81 31 of of IN 37231 81 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 81 33 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 81 34 ; ; : 37231 81 35 and and CC 37231 81 36 the the DT 37231 81 37 reader reader NN 37231 81 38 will will MD 37231 81 39 not not RB 37231 81 40 need need VB 37231 81 41 to to TO 37231 81 42 be be VB 37231 81 43 reminded remind VBN 37231 81 44 how how WRB 37231 81 45 much much JJ 37231 81 46 of of IN 37231 81 47 the the DT 37231 81 48 argument argument NN 37231 81 49 falls fall VBZ 37231 81 50 to to IN 37231 81 51 pieces piece NNS 37231 81 52 , , , 37231 81 53 if if IN 37231 81 54 this this DT 37231 81 55 basis basis NN 37231 81 56 should should MD 37231 81 57 prove prove VB 37231 81 58 to to TO 37231 81 59 be be VB 37231 81 60 unsound unsound JJ 37231 81 61 . . . 37231 82 1 A a DT 37231 82 2 wise wise JJ 37231 82 3 master master NN 37231 82 4 - - HYPH 37231 82 5 builder builder NN 37231 82 6 would would MD 37231 82 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 82 8 have have VB 37231 82 9 looked look VBN 37231 82 10 to to IN 37231 82 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 82 12 foundations foundation NNS 37231 82 13 first first RB 37231 82 14 , , , 37231 82 15 and and CC 37231 82 16 assured assure VBD 37231 82 17 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 82 18 of of IN 37231 82 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 82 20 strength strength NN 37231 82 21 , , , 37231 82 22 before before IN 37231 82 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 82 24 piled pile VBD 37231 82 25 up up RP 37231 82 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 82 27 fabric fabric NN 37231 82 28 to to IN 37231 82 29 this this DT 37231 82 30 height height NN 37231 82 31 . . . 37231 83 1 This this DT 37231 83 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 83 3 author author NN 37231 83 4 has have VBZ 37231 83 5 altogether altogether RB 37231 83 6 neglected neglect VBN 37231 83 7 to to TO 37231 83 8 do do VB 37231 83 9 . . . 37231 83 10 " " '' 37231 84 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 84 2 1 1 LS 37231 84 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 84 4 Towards towards IN 37231 84 5 the the DT 37231 84 6 close close NN 37231 84 7 of of IN 37231 84 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 84 9 article article NN 37231 84 10 , , , 37231 84 11 after after IN 37231 84 12 triumphantly triumphantly RB 37231 84 13 expressing express VBG 37231 84 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 84 15 belief belief NN 37231 84 16 that that IN 37231 84 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 84 18 " " `` 37231 84 19 main main JJ 37231 84 20 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 84 21 are be VBP 37231 84 22 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 37231 84 23 , , , 37231 84 24 " " '' 37231 84 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 84 26 further further RB 37231 84 27 says say VBZ 37231 84 28 : : : 37231 84 29 { { -LRB- 37231 84 30 xiii xiii NNP 37231 84 31 } } -RRB- 37231 84 32 " " `` 37231 84 33 If if IN 37231 84 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 84 35 are be VBP 37231 84 36 , , , 37231 84 37 then then RB 37231 84 38 the the DT 37231 84 39 reader reader NN 37231 84 40 will will MD 37231 84 41 not not RB 37231 84 42 fail fail VB 37231 84 43 to to TO 37231 84 44 see see VB 37231 84 45 how how WRB 37231 84 46 large large JJ 37231 84 47 a a DT 37231 84 48 part part NN 37231 84 49 of of IN 37231 84 50 the the DT 37231 84 51 argument argument NN 37231 84 52 in in IN 37231 84 53 ' ' `` 37231 84 54 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 37231 84 55 Religion Religion NNP 37231 84 56 ' ' '' 37231 84 57 has have VBZ 37231 84 58 crumbled crumble VBN 37231 84 59 to to IN 37231 84 60 pieces piece NNS 37231 84 61 . . . 37231 84 62 " " '' 37231 85 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 85 2 1 1 LS 37231 85 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 85 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 85 5 do do VBP 37231 85 6 not not RB 37231 85 7 doubt doubt VB 37231 85 8 that that IN 37231 85 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 85 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 85 11 sincerely sincerely RB 37231 85 12 believes believe VBZ 37231 85 13 this this DT 37231 85 14 , , , 37231 85 15 but but CC 37231 85 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 85 17 must must MD 37231 85 18 allow allow VB 37231 85 19 me -PRON- PRP 37231 85 20 to to TO 37231 85 21 say say VB 37231 85 22 that that IN 37231 85 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 85 24 is be VBZ 37231 85 25 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 85 26 mistaken mistaken JJ 37231 85 27 in in IN 37231 85 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 85 29 estimate estimate NN 37231 85 30 of of IN 37231 85 31 the the DT 37231 85 32 importance importance NN 37231 85 33 of of IN 37231 85 34 the the DT 37231 85 35 point point NN 37231 85 36 , , , 37231 85 37 and and CC 37231 85 38 that that IN 37231 85 39 , , , 37231 85 40 as as IN 37231 85 41 regards regard VBZ 37231 85 42 this this DT 37231 85 43 work work NN 37231 85 44 , , , 37231 85 45 the the DT 37231 85 46 representations representation NNS 37231 85 47 made make VBN 37231 85 48 in in IN 37231 85 49 the the DT 37231 85 50 above above JJ 37231 85 51 passages passage NNS 37231 85 52 are be VBP 37231 85 53 a a DT 37231 85 54 very very RB 37231 85 55 strange strange JJ 37231 85 56 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37231 85 57 . . . 37231 86 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 86 2 am be VBP 37231 86 3 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37231 86 4 too too RB 37231 86 5 familiar familiar JJ 37231 86 6 , , , 37231 86 7 in in IN 37231 86 8 connection connection NN 37231 86 9 with with IN 37231 86 10 criticism criticism NN 37231 86 11 on on IN 37231 86 12 this this DT 37231 86 13 book book NN 37231 86 14 , , , 37231 86 15 with with IN 37231 86 16 instances instance NNS 37231 86 17 of of IN 37231 86 18 vast vast JJ 37231 86 19 expenditure expenditure NN 37231 86 20 of of IN 37231 86 21 time time NN 37231 86 22 and and CC 37231 86 23 strength strength NN 37231 86 24 in in IN 37231 86 25 attacking attack VBG 37231 86 26 points point NNS 37231 86 27 to to TO 37231 86 28 which which WDT 37231 86 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 86 30 attach attach VBP 37231 86 31 no no DT 37231 86 32 importance importance NN 37231 86 33 whatever whatever WDT 37231 86 34 , , , 37231 86 35 and and CC 37231 86 36 which which WDT 37231 86 37 in in IN 37231 86 38 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 86 39 have have VBP 37231 86 40 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 86 41 any any DT 37231 86 42 value value NN 37231 86 43 . . . 37231 87 1 When when WRB 37231 87 2 writers writer NNS 37231 87 3 , , , 37231 87 4 after after IN 37231 87 5 an an DT 37231 87 6 amount amount NN 37231 87 7 of of IN 37231 87 8 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 87 9 which which WDT 37231 87 10 must must MD 37231 87 11 have have VB 37231 87 12 conveyed convey VBN 37231 87 13 the the DT 37231 87 14 impression impression NN 37231 87 15 that that IN 37231 87 16 vital vital JJ 37231 87 17 interests interest NNS 37231 87 18 were be VBD 37231 87 19 at at IN 37231 87 20 stake stake NN 37231 87 21 , , , 37231 87 22 have have VBP 37231 87 23 , , , 37231 87 24 at at IN 37231 87 25 least least JJS 37231 87 26 in in IN 37231 87 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 87 28 own own JJ 37231 87 29 opinion opinion NN 37231 87 30 , , , 37231 87 31 proved prove VBD 37231 87 32 that that IN 37231 87 33 I -PRON- PRP 37231 87 34 have have VBP 37231 87 35 omitted omit VBN 37231 87 36 to to TO 37231 87 37 dot dot VB 37231 87 38 an an DT 37231 87 39 " " `` 37231 87 40 i i PRP 37231 87 41 , , , 37231 87 42 " " '' 37231 87 43 cross cross VB 37231 87 44 a a DT 37231 87 45 " " `` 37231 87 46 t t NN 37231 87 47 , , , 37231 87 48 " " '' 37231 87 49 or or CC 37231 87 50 insert insert VB 37231 87 51 an an DT 37231 87 52 inverted invert VBN 37231 87 53 comma comma NN 37231 87 54 , , , 37231 87 55 they -PRON- PRP 37231 87 56 have have VBP 37231 87 57 really really RB 37231 87 58 left leave VBN 37231 87 59 the the DT 37231 87 60 question question NN 37231 87 61 precisely precisely RB 37231 87 62 where where WRB 37231 87 63 it -PRON- PRP 37231 87 64 was be VBD 37231 87 65 . . . 37231 88 1 Now now RB 37231 88 2 , , , 37231 88 3 in in IN 37231 88 4 the the DT 37231 88 5 present present JJ 37231 88 6 instance instance NN 37231 88 7 , , , 37231 88 8 the the DT 37231 88 9 whole whole JJ 37231 88 10 extent extent NN 37231 88 11 of of IN 37231 88 12 the the DT 37231 88 13 argument argument NN 37231 88 14 which which WDT 37231 88 15 is be VBZ 37231 88 16 based base VBN 37231 88 17 upon upon IN 37231 88 18 the the DT 37231 88 19 silence silence NN 37231 88 20 of of IN 37231 88 21 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 88 22 is be VBZ 37231 88 23 an an DT 37231 88 24 inference inference NN 37231 88 25 regarding regard VBG 37231 88 26 some some DT 37231 88 27 lost lose VBN 37231 88 28 works work NNS 37231 88 29 of of IN 37231 88 30 three three CD 37231 88 31 writers writer NNS 37231 88 32 only only RB 37231 88 33 , , , 37231 88 34 which which WDT 37231 88 35 might may MD 37231 88 36 altogether altogether RB 37231 88 37 be be VB 37231 88 38 withdrawn withdraw VBN 37231 88 39 without without IN 37231 88 40 affecting affect VBG 37231 88 41 the the DT 37231 88 42 case case NN 37231 88 43 . . . 37231 89 1 The the DT 37231 89 2 object object NN 37231 89 3 of of IN 37231 89 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 89 5 investigation investigation NN 37231 89 6 is be VBZ 37231 89 7 to to TO 37231 89 8 discover discover VB 37231 89 9 what what WP 37231 89 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 89 11 actually actually RB 37231 89 12 exists exist VBZ 37231 89 13 in in IN 37231 89 14 the the DT 37231 89 15 works work NNS 37231 89 16 of of IN 37231 89 17 early early JJ 37231 89 18 writers writer NNS 37231 89 19 regarding regard VBG 37231 89 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 89 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 89 22 . . . 37231 90 1 In in IN 37231 90 2 the the DT 37231 90 3 fragments fragment NNS 37231 90 4 which which WDT 37231 90 5 remain remain VBP 37231 90 6 of of IN 37231 90 7 the the DT 37231 90 8 works work NNS 37231 90 9 of of IN 37231 90 10 three three CD 37231 90 11 writers writer NNS 37231 90 12 , , , 37231 90 13 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 90 14 , , , 37231 90 15 Papias Papias NNP 37231 90 16 , , , 37231 90 17 and and CC 37231 90 18 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 90 19 of of IN 37231 90 20 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 90 21 , , , 37231 90 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 90 23 do do VBP 37231 90 24 not not RB 37231 90 25 find find VB 37231 90 26 any any DT 37231 90 27 evidence evidence NN 37231 90 28 of of IN 37231 90 29 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 90 30 with with IN 37231 90 31 these these DT 37231 90 32 Gospels,--the gospels,--the PRP$ 37231 90 33 works work NNS 37231 90 34 mentioned mention VBN 37231 90 35 by by IN 37231 90 36 Papias Papias NNP 37231 90 37 being be VBG 37231 90 38 , , , 37231 90 39 I -PRON- PRP 37231 90 40 contend contend VBP 37231 90 41 , , , 37231 90 42 different different JJ 37231 90 43 from from IN 37231 90 44 the the DT 37231 90 45 existing exist VBG 37231 90 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 90 47 attributed attribute VBD 37231 90 48 to to IN 37231 90 49 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 90 50 and and CC 37231 90 51 Mark Mark NNP 37231 90 52 . . . 37231 91 1 Whether whether IN 37231 91 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 91 3 am be VBP 37231 91 4 right right JJ 37231 91 5 or or CC 37231 91 6 not not RB 37231 91 7 in in IN 37231 91 8 this this DT 37231 91 9 does do VBZ 37231 91 10 not not RB 37231 91 11 affect affect VB 37231 91 12 the the DT 37231 91 13 present present JJ 37231 91 14 discussion discussion NN 37231 91 15 . . . 37231 92 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 92 2 is be VBZ 37231 92 3 an an DT 37231 92 4 unquestioned unquestioned JJ 37231 92 5 fact fact NN 37231 92 6 that that IN 37231 92 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 92 8 does do VBZ 37231 92 9 not not RB 37231 92 10 mention mention VB 37231 92 11 that that IN 37231 92 12 the the DT 37231 92 13 lost lost JJ 37231 92 14 works work NNS 37231 92 15 of of IN 37231 92 16 these these DT 37231 92 17 { { -LRB- 37231 92 18 xiv xiv NNP 37231 92 19 } } -RRB- 37231 92 20 writers writer NNS 37231 92 21 contained contain VBD 37231 92 22 any any DT 37231 92 23 reference reference NN 37231 92 24 to to IN 37231 92 25 , , , 37231 92 26 or or CC 37231 92 27 information information NN 37231 92 28 about about IN 37231 92 29 , , , 37231 92 30 the the DT 37231 92 31 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 92 32 , , , 37231 92 33 nor nor CC 37231 92 34 have have VBP 37231 92 35 we -PRON- PRP 37231 92 36 any any DT 37231 92 37 statement statement NN 37231 92 38 from from IN 37231 92 39 any any DT 37231 92 40 other other JJ 37231 92 41 author author NN 37231 92 42 to to IN 37231 92 43 that that DT 37231 92 44 effect effect NN 37231 92 45 . . . 37231 93 1 The the DT 37231 93 2 objection objection NN 37231 93 3 of of IN 37231 93 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 93 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 93 6 is be VBZ 37231 93 7 limited limit VBN 37231 93 8 to to IN 37231 93 9 a a DT 37231 93 10 denial denial NN 37231 93 11 that that IN 37231 93 12 the the DT 37231 93 13 silence silence NN 37231 93 14 of of IN 37231 93 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 93 16 warrants warrant VBZ 37231 93 17 the the DT 37231 93 18 inference inference NN 37231 93 19 that that IN 37231 93 20 , , , 37231 93 21 because because IN 37231 93 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 93 23 does do VBZ 37231 93 24 not not RB 37231 93 25 state state VB 37231 93 26 that that IN 37231 93 27 these these DT 37231 93 28 writers writer NNS 37231 93 29 made make VBD 37231 93 30 quotations quotation NNS 37231 93 31 from from IN 37231 93 32 or or CC 37231 93 33 references reference NNS 37231 93 34 to to IN 37231 93 35 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 93 36 canonical canonical JJ 37231 93 37 books book NNS 37231 93 38 , , , 37231 93 39 the the DT 37231 93 40 lost lost JJ 37231 93 41 works work NNS 37231 93 42 did do VBD 37231 93 43 not not RB 37231 93 44 contain contain VB 37231 93 45 any any DT 37231 93 46 ; ; : 37231 93 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 93 48 does do VBZ 37231 93 49 not not RB 37231 93 50 , , , 37231 93 51 however however RB 37231 93 52 , , , 37231 93 53 extend extend VBP 37231 93 54 to to IN 37231 93 55 interesting interesting JJ 37231 93 56 information information NN 37231 93 57 regarding regard VBG 37231 93 58 those those DT 37231 93 59 books book NNS 37231 93 60 , , , 37231 93 61 which which WDT 37231 93 62 he -PRON- PRP 37231 93 63 admits admit VBZ 37231 93 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 93 65 was be VBD 37231 93 66 the the DT 37231 93 67 purpose purpose NN 37231 93 68 of of IN 37231 93 69 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 93 70 to to TO 37231 93 71 record record VB 37231 93 72 . . . 37231 94 1 To to TO 37231 94 2 give give VB 37231 94 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 94 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 94 5 's 's POS 37231 94 6 statements statement NNS 37231 94 7 , , , 37231 94 8 which which WDT 37231 94 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 94 10 am be VBP 37231 94 11 examining examine VBG 37231 94 12 , , , 37231 94 13 the the DT 37231 94 14 fullest full JJS 37231 94 15 possible possible JJ 37231 94 16 support support NN 37231 94 17 , , , 37231 94 18 however however RB 37231 94 19 , , , 37231 94 20 suppose suppose VB 37231 94 21 that that IN 37231 94 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 94 23 abandon abandon VBP 37231 94 24 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 94 25 altogether altogether RB 37231 94 26 , , , 37231 94 27 and and CC 37231 94 28 do do VBP 37231 94 29 not not RB 37231 94 30 draw draw VB 37231 94 31 any any DT 37231 94 32 inference inference NN 37231 94 33 of of IN 37231 94 34 any any DT 37231 94 35 kind kind NN 37231 94 36 from from IN 37231 94 37 him -PRON- PRP 37231 94 38 beyond beyond IN 37231 94 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 94 40 positive positive JJ 37231 94 41 statements statement NNS 37231 94 42 , , , 37231 94 43 how how WRB 37231 94 44 would would MD 37231 94 45 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 94 46 case case NN 37231 94 47 stand stand VB 37231 94 48 ? ? . 37231 95 1 Simply simply RB 37231 95 2 as as RB 37231 95 3 complete complete JJ 37231 95 4 as as IN 37231 95 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 95 6 well well RB 37231 95 7 could could MD 37231 95 8 be be VB 37231 95 9 : : : 37231 95 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 95 11 , , , 37231 95 12 Papias Papias NNP 37231 95 13 , , , 37231 95 14 and and CC 37231 95 15 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 95 16 do do VBP 37231 95 17 not not RB 37231 95 18 furnish furnish VB 37231 95 19 any any DT 37231 95 20 evidence evidence NN 37231 95 21 in in IN 37231 95 22 favour favour NN 37231 95 23 of of IN 37231 95 24 the the DT 37231 95 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 95 26 . . . 37231 96 1 The the DT 37231 96 2 reader reader NN 37231 96 3 , , , 37231 96 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 96 5 , , , 37231 96 6 will will MD 37231 96 7 not not RB 37231 96 8 fail fail VB 37231 96 9 to to TO 37231 96 10 see see VB 37231 96 11 how how WRB 37231 96 12 serious serious JJ 37231 96 13 a a DT 37231 96 14 misstatement misstatement NN 37231 96 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 96 16 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 96 17 has have VBZ 37231 96 18 made make VBN 37231 96 19 , , , 37231 96 20 and and CC 37231 96 21 how how WRB 37231 96 22 little little JJ 37231 96 23 the the DT 37231 96 24 argument argument NN 37231 96 25 of of IN 37231 96 26 " " `` 37231 96 27 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 37231 96 28 Religion Religion NNP 37231 96 29 " " '' 37231 96 30 would would MD 37231 96 31 be be VB 37231 96 32 affected affect VBN 37231 96 33 even even RB 37231 96 34 if if IN 37231 96 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 96 36 established establish VBD 37231 96 37 much much RB 37231 96 38 more more JJR 37231 96 39 than than IN 37231 96 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 96 41 has have VBZ 37231 96 42 attempted attempt VBN 37231 96 43 to to TO 37231 96 44 do do VB 37231 96 45 . . . 37231 97 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 97 2 may may MD 37231 97 3 now now RB 37231 97 4 proceed proceed VB 37231 97 5 to to TO 37231 97 6 consider consider VB 37231 97 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 97 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 97 9 's 's POS 37231 97 10 argument argument NN 37231 97 11 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 97 12 . . . 37231 98 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 98 2 carefully carefully RB 37231 98 3 and and CC 37231 98 4 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 98 5 defines define VBZ 37231 98 6 what what WP 37231 98 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 98 8 understands understand VBZ 37231 98 9 to to TO 37231 98 10 be be VB 37231 98 11 the the DT 37231 98 12 declared declare VBN 37231 98 13 intention intention NN 37231 98 14 of of IN 37231 98 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 98 16 in in IN 37231 98 17 composing compose VBG 37231 98 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 98 19 history history NN 37231 98 20 , , , 37231 98 21 as as IN 37231 98 22 regards regard VBZ 37231 98 23 the the DT 37231 98 24 mention mention NN 37231 98 25 or or CC 37231 98 26 use use NN 37231 98 27 of of IN 37231 98 28 the the DT 37231 98 29 disputed disputed JJ 37231 98 30 and and CC 37231 98 31 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 98 32 canonical canonical JJ 37231 98 33 books book NNS 37231 98 34 in in IN 37231 98 35 the the DT 37231 98 36 writings writing NNS 37231 98 37 of of IN 37231 98 38 the the DT 37231 98 39 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 98 40 , , , 37231 98 41 and and CC 37231 98 42 in in IN 37231 98 43 order order NN 37231 98 44 to to TO 37231 98 45 do do VB 37231 98 46 him -PRON- PRP 37231 98 47 full full JJ 37231 98 48 justice justice NN 37231 98 49 I -PRON- PRP 37231 98 50 will will MD 37231 98 51 quote quote VB 37231 98 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 98 53 words word NNS 37231 98 54 , , , 37231 98 55 merely merely RB 37231 98 56 taking take VBG 37231 98 57 the the DT 37231 98 58 liberty liberty NN 37231 98 59 , , , 37231 98 60 for for IN 37231 98 61 facility facility NN 37231 98 62 of of IN 37231 98 63 reference reference NN 37231 98 64 , , , 37231 98 65 of of IN 37231 98 66 dividing divide VBG 37231 98 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 98 68 statement statement NN 37231 98 69 into into IN 37231 98 70 three three CD 37231 98 71 paragraphs paragraph NNS 37231 98 72 . . . 37231 99 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 99 2 says say VBZ 37231 99 3 : : : 37231 99 4 " " `` 37231 99 5 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 99 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 99 7 proposes propose VBZ 37231 99 8 to to TO 37231 99 9 treat treat VB 37231 99 10 these these DT 37231 99 11 two two CD 37231 99 12 classes class NNS 37231 99 13 of of IN 37231 99 14 writings writing NNS 37231 99 15 in in IN 37231 99 16 two two CD 37231 99 17 different different JJ 37231 99 18 ways way NNS 37231 99 19 . . . 37231 100 1 This this DT 37231 100 2 is be VBZ 37231 100 3 the the DT 37231 100 4 cardinal cardinal JJ 37231 100 5 point point NN 37231 100 6 of of IN 37231 100 7 the the DT 37231 100 8 passage passage NN 37231 100 9 . . . 37231 101 1 { { -LRB- 37231 101 2 xv xv NNP 37231 101 3 } } -RRB- 37231 101 4 ( ( -LRB- 37231 101 5 1 1 CD 37231 101 6 ) ) -RRB- 37231 101 7 Of of IN 37231 101 8 the the DT 37231 101 9 Antilegomena Antilegomena NNP 37231 101 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 101 11 pledges pledge VBZ 37231 101 12 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 101 13 to to TO 37231 101 14 record record VB 37231 101 15 when when WRB 37231 101 16 any any DT 37231 101 17 ancient ancient JJ 37231 101 18 writer writer NN 37231 101 19 employs employ VBZ 37231 101 20 any any DT 37231 101 21 book book NN 37231 101 22 belonging belong VBG 37231 101 23 to to IN 37231 101 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 101 25 class class NN 37231 101 26 [ [ -LRB- 37231 101 27 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 101 28 ] ] -RRB- 37231 101 29 ; ; , 37231 101 30 ( ( -LRB- 37231 101 31 2 2 LS 37231 101 32 ) ) -RRB- 37231 101 33 but but CC 37231 101 34 as as IN 37231 101 35 regards regard VBZ 37231 101 36 the the DT 37231 101 37 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 101 38 Canonical canonical JJ 37231 101 39 books book NNS 37231 101 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 101 41 only only RB 37231 101 42 professes profess VBZ 37231 101 43 to to TO 37231 101 44 mention mention VB 37231 101 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 101 46 , , , 37231 101 47 when when WRB 37231 101 48 such such PDT 37231 101 49 a a DT 37231 101 50 writer writer NN 37231 101 51 has have VBZ 37231 101 52 something something NN 37231 101 53 to to TO 37231 101 54 tell tell VB 37231 101 55 about about IN 37231 101 56 them -PRON- PRP 37231 101 57 [ [ -LRB- 37231 101 58 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 101 59 ] ] -RRB- 37231 101 60 . . . 37231 102 1 Any any DT 37231 102 2 anecdote anecdote NN 37231 102 3 of of IN 37231 102 4 interest interest NN 37231 102 5 respecting respect VBG 37231 102 6 them -PRON- PRP 37231 102 7 , , , 37231 102 8 as as IN 37231 102 9 also also RB 37231 102 10 respecting respect VBG 37231 102 11 the the DT 37231 102 12 others other NNS 37231 102 13 [ [ -LRB- 37231 102 14 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 102 15 ] ] -RRB- 37231 102 16 , , , 37231 102 17 will will MD 37231 102 18 be be VB 37231 102 19 recorded record VBN 37231 102 20 . . . 37231 103 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 103 2 3 3 LS 37231 103 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 103 4 But but CC 37231 103 5 in in IN 37231 103 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 103 7 case case NN 37231 103 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 103 9 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 103 10 leads lead VBZ 37231 103 11 us -PRON- PRP 37231 103 12 to to TO 37231 103 13 expect expect VB 37231 103 14 that that IN 37231 103 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 103 16 will will MD 37231 103 17 allude allude VB 37231 103 18 to to IN 37231 103 19 mere mere JJ 37231 103 20 quotations quotation NNS 37231 103 21 however however RB 37231 103 22 numerous numerous JJ 37231 103 23 and and CC 37231 103 24 however however RB 37231 103 25 precise precise JJ 37231 103 26 . . . 37231 104 1 " " `` 37231 104 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 104 3 1 1 LS 37231 104 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 104 5 In in IN 37231 104 6 order order NN 37231 104 7 to to TO 37231 104 8 dispose dispose VB 37231 104 9 of of IN 37231 104 10 the the DT 37231 104 11 only only JJ 37231 104 12 one one CD 37231 104 13 of of IN 37231 104 14 these these DT 37231 104 15 points point NNS 37231 104 16 upon upon IN 37231 104 17 which which WDT 37231 104 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 104 19 can can MD 37231 104 20 differ differ VB 37231 104 21 , , , 37231 104 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 104 23 will will MD 37231 104 24 first first RB 37231 104 25 refer refer VB 37231 104 26 to to IN 37231 104 27 the the DT 37231 104 28 third third JJ 37231 104 29 . . . 37231 105 1 Did do VBD 37231 105 2 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 105 3 intend intend VB 37231 105 4 to to TO 37231 105 5 point point VB 37231 105 6 out out RP 37231 105 7 mere mere JJ 37231 105 8 quotations quotation NNS 37231 105 9 of of IN 37231 105 10 the the DT 37231 105 11 books book NNS 37231 105 12 which which WDT 37231 105 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 105 14 considered consider VBD 37231 105 15 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 105 16 " " '' 37231 105 17 ? ? . 37231 106 1 As as IN 37231 106 2 a a DT 37231 106 3 matter matter NN 37231 106 4 of of IN 37231 106 5 fact fact NN 37231 106 6 , , , 37231 106 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 106 8 actually actually RB 37231 106 9 did do VBD 37231 106 10 point point VB 37231 106 11 such such JJ 37231 106 12 out out IN 37231 106 13 in in IN 37231 106 14 the the DT 37231 106 15 case case NN 37231 106 16 of of IN 37231 106 17 the the DT 37231 106 18 1st 1st JJ 37231 106 19 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 106 20 of of IN 37231 106 21 Peter Peter NNP 37231 106 22 and and CC 37231 106 23 1st 1st NNP 37231 106 24 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 106 25 of of IN 37231 106 26 John John NNP 37231 106 27 , , , 37231 106 28 which which WDT 37231 106 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 106 30 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 106 31 and and CC 37231 106 32 in in IN 37231 106 33 the the DT 37231 106 34 most most RBS 37231 106 35 emphatic emphatic JJ 37231 106 36 manner manner NN 37231 106 37 declared declare VBD 37231 106 38 to to TO 37231 106 39 be be VB 37231 106 40 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 106 41 . . . 37231 107 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 107 2 2 2 LS 37231 107 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 107 4 This this DT 37231 107 5 is be VBZ 37231 107 6 admitted admit VBN 37231 107 7 by by IN 37231 107 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 107 9 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 107 10 . . . 37231 108 1 That that IN 37231 108 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 108 3 omitted omit VBD 37231 108 4 to to TO 37231 108 5 mention mention VB 37231 108 6 a a DT 37231 108 7 reference reference NN 37231 108 8 to to IN 37231 108 9 the the DT 37231 108 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 108 11 to to IN 37231 108 12 the the DT 37231 108 13 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 108 14 in in IN 37231 108 15 the the DT 37231 108 16 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 108 17 of of IN 37231 108 18 Clement Clement NNP 37231 108 19 of of IN 37231 108 20 Rome Rome NNP 37231 108 21 , , , 37231 108 22 or or CC 37231 108 23 the the DT 37231 108 24 reference reference NN 37231 108 25 by by IN 37231 108 26 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 37231 108 27 to to IN 37231 108 28 the the DT 37231 108 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 108 30 of of IN 37231 108 31 John John NNP 37231 108 32 , , , 37231 108 33 and and CC 37231 108 34 other other JJ 37231 108 35 supposed suppose VBN 37231 108 36 quotations quotation NNS 37231 108 37 , , , 37231 108 38 might may MD 37231 108 39 be be VB 37231 108 40 set set VBN 37231 108 41 down down RP 37231 108 42 as as RB 37231 108 43 much much JJ 37231 108 44 to to IN 37231 108 45 oversight oversight NN 37231 108 46 as as IN 37231 108 47 intention intention NN 37231 108 48 . . . 37231 109 1 On on IN 37231 109 2 the the DT 37231 109 3 other other JJ 37231 109 4 hand hand NN 37231 109 5 , , , 37231 109 6 that that IN 37231 109 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 109 8 did do VBD 37231 109 9 mention mention VB 37231 109 10 disputed dispute VBN 37231 109 11 books book NNS 37231 109 12 is be VBZ 37231 109 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 109 14 only only RB 37231 109 15 that that IN 37231 109 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 109 17 not not RB 37231 109 18 only only RB 37231 109 19 pledged pledge VBD 37231 109 20 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 109 21 to to TO 37231 109 22 do do VB 37231 109 23 so so RB 37231 109 24 , , , 37231 109 25 but but CC 37231 109 26 actually actually RB 37231 109 27 fulfilled fulfil VBD 37231 109 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 109 29 promise promise NN 37231 109 30 . . . 37231 110 1 Although although IN 37231 110 2 much much JJ 37231 110 3 might may MD 37231 110 4 be be VB 37231 110 5 said say VBN 37231 110 6 upon upon IN 37231 110 7 this this DT 37231 110 8 point point NN 37231 110 9 , , , 37231 110 10 therefore therefore RB 37231 110 11 , , , 37231 110 12 I -PRON- PRP 37231 110 13 consider consider VBP 37231 110 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 110 15 of of IN 37231 110 16 so so RB 37231 110 17 little little JJ 37231 110 18 importance importance NN 37231 110 19 that that WDT 37231 110 20 I -PRON- PRP 37231 110 21 do do VBP 37231 110 22 not not RB 37231 110 23 intend intend VB 37231 110 24 to to TO 37231 110 25 waste waste VB 37231 110 26 time time NN 37231 110 27 in in IN 37231 110 28 minutely minutely RB 37231 110 29 discussing discuss VBG 37231 110 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 110 31 . . . 37231 111 1 If if IN 37231 111 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 111 3 assertions assertion NNS 37231 111 4 with with IN 37231 111 5 regard regard NN 37231 111 6 to to IN 37231 111 7 the the DT 37231 111 8 silence silence NN 37231 111 9 of of IN 37231 111 10 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 111 11 likewise likewise RB 37231 111 12 include include VBP 37231 111 13 the the DT 37231 111 14 supposition supposition NN 37231 111 15 that that IN 37231 111 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 111 17 proposed propose VBD 37231 111 18 to to TO 37231 111 19 mention mention VB 37231 111 20 mere mere JJ 37231 111 21 quotations quotation NNS 37231 111 22 of of IN 37231 111 23 the the DT 37231 111 24 " " `` 37231 111 25 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 111 26 " " '' 37231 111 27 books book NNS 37231 111 28 , , , 37231 111 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 111 30 are be VBP 37231 111 31 so so RB 37231 111 32 far far RB 37231 111 33 from from IN 37231 111 34 limited limited JJ 37231 111 35 to to IN 37231 111 36 this this DT 37231 111 37 very very RB 37231 111 38 subsidiary subsidiary JJ 37231 111 39 testimony testimony NN 37231 111 40 that that WDT 37231 111 41 I -PRON- PRP 37231 111 42 2 2 CD 37231 111 43 I -PRON- PRP 37231 111 44 regret regret VBP 37231 111 45 very very RB 37231 111 46 much much RB 37231 111 47 that that IN 37231 111 48 some some DT 37231 111 49 ambiguity ambiguity NN 37231 111 50 in in IN 37231 111 51 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 111 52 language language NN 37231 111 53 ( ( -LRB- 37231 111 54 S. S. NNP 37231 111 55 R. R. NNP 37231 111 56 , , , 37231 111 57 i. i. NNP 37231 111 58 p. p. NN 37231 111 59 483 483 CD 37231 111 60 ) ) -RRB- 37231 111 61 should should MD 37231 111 62 have have VB 37231 111 63 misled mislead VBN 37231 111 64 , , , 37231 111 65 and and CC 37231 111 66 given give VBN 37231 111 67 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 111 68 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 111 69 much much JJ 37231 111 70 trouble trouble NN 37231 111 71 . . . 37231 112 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 112 2 used use VBD 37231 112 3 the the DT 37231 112 4 word word NN 37231 112 5 " " `` 37231 112 6 quotation quotation NN 37231 112 7 " " '' 37231 112 8 in in IN 37231 112 9 the the DT 37231 112 10 sense sense NN 37231 112 11 of of IN 37231 112 12 a a DT 37231 112 13 use use NN 37231 112 14 of of IN 37231 112 15 the the DT 37231 112 16 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 112 17 of of IN 37231 112 18 Peter Peter NNP 37231 112 19 , , , 37231 112 20 and and CC 37231 112 21 not not RB 37231 112 22 in in IN 37231 112 23 reference reference NN 37231 112 24 to to IN 37231 112 25 any any DT 37231 112 26 one one CD 37231 112 27 sentence sentence NN 37231 112 28 in in IN 37231 112 29 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 112 30 . . . 37231 113 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 113 2 trust trust VBP 37231 113 3 that that IN 37231 113 4 in in IN 37231 113 5 this this DT 37231 113 6 edition edition NN 37231 113 7 I -PRON- PRP 37231 113 8 have have VBP 37231 113 9 made make VBN 37231 113 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 113 11 meaning meaning NN 37231 113 12 clear clear JJ 37231 113 13 . . . 37231 114 1 { { -LRB- 37231 114 2 xvi xvi NNP 37231 114 3 } } -RRB- 37231 114 4 should should MD 37231 114 5 have have VB 37231 114 6 no no DT 37231 114 7 reluctance reluctance NN 37231 114 8 in in IN 37231 114 9 waiving waive VBG 37231 114 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 114 11 altogether altogether RB 37231 114 12 . . . 37231 115 1 Even even RB 37231 115 2 if if IN 37231 115 3 the the DT 37231 115 4 most most RBS 37231 115 5 distinct distinct JJ 37231 115 6 quotations quotation NNS 37231 115 7 of of IN 37231 115 8 this this DT 37231 115 9 kind kind NN 37231 115 10 had have VBD 37231 115 11 occurred occur VBN 37231 115 12 in in IN 37231 115 13 the the DT 37231 115 14 lost lost JJ 37231 115 15 works work NNS 37231 115 16 of of IN 37231 115 17 the the DT 37231 115 18 three three CD 37231 115 19 writers writer NNS 37231 115 20 in in IN 37231 115 21 question question NN 37231 115 22 , , , 37231 115 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 115 24 could could MD 37231 115 25 have have VB 37231 115 26 proved prove VBN 37231 115 27 nothing nothing NN 37231 115 28 beyond beyond IN 37231 115 29 the the DT 37231 115 30 mere mere JJ 37231 115 31 existence existence NN 37231 115 32 of of IN 37231 115 33 the the DT 37231 115 34 book book NN 37231 115 35 quoted quote VBN 37231 115 36 , , , 37231 115 37 at at IN 37231 115 38 the the DT 37231 115 39 time time NN 37231 115 40 that that WDT 37231 115 41 work work NN 37231 115 42 was be VBD 37231 115 43 written write VBN 37231 115 44 , , , 37231 115 45 but but CC 37231 115 46 would would MD 37231 115 47 have have VB 37231 115 48 done do VBN 37231 115 49 nothing nothing NN 37231 115 50 to to TO 37231 115 51 establish establish VB 37231 115 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 115 53 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 115 54 and and CC 37231 115 55 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 37231 115 56 . . . 37231 116 1 In in IN 37231 116 2 the the DT 37231 116 3 evidential evidential JJ 37231 116 4 destitution destitution NN 37231 116 5 of of IN 37231 116 6 the the DT 37231 116 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 116 8 , , , 37231 116 9 apologists apologist NNS 37231 116 10 would would MD 37231 116 11 thankfully thankfully RB 37231 116 12 have have VB 37231 116 13 received receive VBN 37231 116 14 even even RB 37231 116 15 such such JJ 37231 116 16 vague vague JJ 37231 116 17 indications indication NNS 37231 116 18 , , , 37231 116 19 indeed indeed RB 37231 116 20 there there EX 37231 116 21 is be VBZ 37231 116 22 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 116 23 any any DT 37231 116 24 other other JJ 37231 116 25 evidence evidence NN 37231 116 26 , , , 37231 116 27 but but CC 37231 116 28 something something NN 37231 116 29 much much RB 37231 116 30 more more RBR 37231 116 31 definite definite JJ 37231 116 32 is be VBZ 37231 116 33 required require VBN 37231 116 34 to to TO 37231 116 35 establish establish VB 37231 116 36 the the DT 37231 116 37 reality reality NN 37231 116 38 of of IN 37231 116 39 miracles miracle NNS 37231 116 40 and and CC 37231 116 41 Divine Divine NNP 37231 116 42 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 116 43 . . . 37231 117 1 If if IN 37231 117 2 this this DT 37231 117 3 point point NN 37231 117 4 be be VB 37231 117 5 , , , 37231 117 6 for for IN 37231 117 7 the the DT 37231 117 8 sake sake NN 37231 117 9 of of IN 37231 117 10 argument argument NN 37231 117 11 , , , 37231 117 12 set set VBN 37231 117 13 aside aside RB 37231 117 14 , , , 37231 117 15 what what WP 37231 117 16 is be VBZ 37231 117 17 the the DT 37231 117 18 position position NN 37231 117 19 ? ? . 37231 118 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 118 2 are be VBP 37231 118 3 not not RB 37231 118 4 entitled entitle VBN 37231 118 5 to to TO 37231 118 6 infer infer VB 37231 118 7 that that IN 37231 118 8 there there EX 37231 118 9 were be VBD 37231 118 10 no no DT 37231 118 11 quotations quotation NNS 37231 118 12 from from IN 37231 118 13 the the DT 37231 118 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 118 15 in in IN 37231 118 16 the the DT 37231 118 17 works work NNS 37231 118 18 of of IN 37231 118 19 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 118 20 , , , 37231 118 21 Papias Papias NNP 37231 118 22 , , , 37231 118 23 and and CC 37231 118 24 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 118 25 of of IN 37231 118 26 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 118 27 , , , 37231 118 28 because because IN 37231 118 29 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 118 30 does do VBZ 37231 118 31 not not RB 37231 118 32 record record VB 37231 118 33 them -PRON- PRP 37231 118 34 ; ; : 37231 118 35 but but CC 37231 118 36 , , , 37231 118 37 on on IN 37231 118 38 the the DT 37231 118 39 other other JJ 37231 118 40 hand hand NN 37231 118 41 , , , 37231 118 42 we -PRON- PRP 37231 118 43 are be VBP 37231 118 44 still still RB 37231 118 45 less less RBR 37231 118 46 entitled entitled JJ 37231 118 47 to to TO 37231 118 48 infer infer VB 37231 118 49 that that IN 37231 118 50 there there EX 37231 118 51 were be VBD 37231 118 52 any any DT 37231 118 53 . . . 37231 119 1 The the DT 37231 119 2 only only JJ 37231 119 3 inference inference NN 37231 119 4 which which WDT 37231 119 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 119 6 care care VBP 37231 119 7 to to TO 37231 119 8 draw draw VB 37231 119 9 from from IN 37231 119 10 the the DT 37231 119 11 silence silence NN 37231 119 12 of of IN 37231 119 13 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 119 14 is be VBZ 37231 119 15 precisely precisely RB 37231 119 16 that that IN 37231 119 17 which which WDT 37231 119 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 119 19 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 119 20 admits admit VBZ 37231 119 21 that that IN 37231 119 22 , , , 37231 119 23 both both DT 37231 119 24 from from IN 37231 119 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 119 26 promise promise NN 37231 119 27 and and CC 37231 119 28 practice practice NN 37231 119 29 , , , 37231 119 30 I -PRON- PRP 37231 119 31 am be VBP 37231 119 32 entitled entitle VBN 37231 119 33 to to TO 37231 119 34 deduce deduce VB 37231 119 35 : : : 37231 119 36 when when WRB 37231 119 37 any any DT 37231 119 38 ancient ancient JJ 37231 119 39 writer writer NN 37231 119 40 " " '' 37231 119 41 has have VBZ 37231 119 42 something something NN 37231 119 43 to to TO 37231 119 44 _ _ NNP 37231 119 45 tell tell VB 37231 119 46 about about IN 37231 119 47 _ _ NNP 37231 119 48 " " `` 37231 119 49 the the DT 37231 119 50 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 119 51 , , , 37231 119 52 " " '' 37231 119 53 any any DT 37231 119 54 _ _ NNP 37231 119 55 anecdote anecdote NN 37231 119 56 _ _ NNP 37231 119 57 of of IN 37231 119 58 interest interest NN 37231 119 59 respecting respect VBG 37231 119 60 them -PRON- PRP 37231 119 61 , , , 37231 119 62 " " `` 37231 119 63 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 119 64 will will MD 37231 119 65 record record VB 37231 119 66 it -PRON- PRP 37231 119 67 . . . 37231 120 1 This this DT 37231 120 2 is be VBZ 37231 120 3 the the DT 37231 120 4 only only JJ 37231 120 5 information information NN 37231 120 6 of of IN 37231 120 7 the the DT 37231 120 8 slightest slight JJS 37231 120 9 value value NN 37231 120 10 to to IN 37231 120 11 this this DT 37231 120 12 work work NN 37231 120 13 which which WDT 37231 120 14 could could MD 37231 120 15 be be VB 37231 120 16 looked look VBN 37231 120 17 for for IN 37231 120 18 in in IN 37231 120 19 these these DT 37231 120 20 writers writer NNS 37231 120 21 . . . 37231 121 1 So so RB 37231 121 2 far far RB 37231 121 3 , , , 37231 121 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 121 5 , , , 37231 121 6 from from IN 37231 121 7 producing produce VBG 37231 121 8 the the DT 37231 121 9 destructive destructive JJ 37231 121 10 effect effect NN 37231 121 11 upon upon IN 37231 121 12 some some DT 37231 121 13 of of IN 37231 121 14 the the DT 37231 121 15 arguments argument NNS 37231 121 16 of of IN 37231 121 17 " " `` 37231 121 18 Supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 121 19 Religion religion NN 37231 121 20 , , , 37231 121 21 " " '' 37231 121 22 upon upon IN 37231 121 23 which which WDT 37231 121 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 121 25 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 121 26 prematurely prematurely RB 37231 121 27 congratulates congratulate VBZ 37231 121 28 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 121 29 , , , 37231 121 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 121 31 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 121 32 's 's POS 37231 121 33 elaborate elaborate NN 37231 121 34 and and CC 37231 121 35 learned learn VBD 37231 121 36 article article NN 37231 121 37 on on IN 37231 121 38 the the DT 37231 121 39 silence silence NN 37231 121 40 of of IN 37231 121 41 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 121 42 supports support VBZ 37231 121 43 them -PRON- PRP 37231 121 44 in in IN 37231 121 45 the the DT 37231 121 46 most most RBS 37231 121 47 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 121 48 manner manner NN 37231 121 49 . . . 37231 122 1 { { -LRB- 37231 122 2 xvii xvii NN 37231 122 3 } } -RRB- 37231 122 4 Before before IN 37231 122 5 proceeding proceed VBG 37231 122 6 to to TO 37231 122 7 speak speak VB 37231 122 8 more more RBR 37231 122 9 directly directly RB 37231 122 10 of of IN 37231 122 11 the the DT 37231 122 12 three three CD 37231 122 13 writers writer NNS 37231 122 14 under under IN 37231 122 15 discussion discussion NN 37231 122 16 , , , 37231 122 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 122 18 may may MD 37231 122 19 be be VB 37231 122 20 well well JJ 37231 122 21 to to TO 37231 122 22 glance glance VB 37231 122 23 a a DT 37231 122 24 little little JJ 37231 122 25 at at IN 37231 122 26 the the DT 37231 122 27 procedure procedure NN 37231 122 28 of of IN 37231 122 29 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 122 30 , , , 37231 122 31 and and CC 37231 122 32 note note VB 37231 122 33 , , , 37231 122 34 for for IN 37231 122 35 those those DT 37231 122 36 who who WP 37231 122 37 care care VBP 37231 122 38 to to TO 37231 122 39 go go VB 37231 122 40 more more RBR 37231 122 41 closely closely RB 37231 122 42 into into IN 37231 122 43 the the DT 37231 122 44 matter matter NN 37231 122 45 , , , 37231 122 46 how how WRB 37231 122 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 122 48 fulfils fulfil VBZ 37231 122 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 122 50 promise promise NN 37231 122 51 to to TO 37231 122 52 record record VB 37231 122 53 what what WP 37231 122 54 the the DT 37231 122 55 Fathers father NNS 37231 122 56 have have VBP 37231 122 57 to to TO 37231 122 58 tell tell VB 37231 122 59 about about IN 37231 122 60 the the DT 37231 122 61 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 122 62 . . . 37231 123 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 123 2 may may MD 37231 123 3 mention mention VB 37231 123 4 , , , 37231 123 5 in in IN 37231 123 6 the the DT 37231 123 7 first first JJ 37231 123 8 place place NN 37231 123 9 , , , 37231 123 10 that that IN 37231 123 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 123 12 states state VBZ 37231 123 13 what what WP 37231 123 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 123 15 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 123 16 knows know VBZ 37231 123 17 of of IN 37231 123 18 the the DT 37231 123 19 composition composition NN 37231 123 20 of of IN 37231 123 21 the the DT 37231 123 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 123 23 and and CC 37231 123 24 other other JJ 37231 123 25 canonical canonical JJ 37231 123 26 works work NNS 37231 123 27 . . . 37231 124 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 124 2 1 1 LS 37231 124 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 124 4 Upon upon IN 37231 124 5 two two CD 37231 124 6 occasions occasion NNS 37231 124 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 124 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 124 9 the the DT 37231 124 10 account account NN 37231 124 11 which which WDT 37231 124 12 Clement Clement NNP 37231 124 13 of of IN 37231 124 14 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 124 15 gives give VBZ 37231 124 16 of of IN 37231 124 17 the the DT 37231 124 18 composition composition NN 37231 124 19 of of IN 37231 124 20 Mark Mark NNP 37231 124 21 's 's POS 37231 124 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 124 23 , , , 37231 124 24 and and CC 37231 124 25 also also RB 37231 124 26 cites cite VBZ 37231 124 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 124 28 statements statement NNS 37231 124 29 regarding regard VBG 37231 124 30 the the DT 37231 124 31 other other JJ 37231 124 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 124 33 . . . 37231 125 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 125 2 2 2 LS 37231 125 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 125 4 In in IN 37231 125 5 like like JJ 37231 125 6 manner manner NN 37231 125 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 125 8 records record VBZ 37231 125 9 the the DT 37231 125 10 information information NN 37231 125 11 , , , 37231 125 12 such such JJ 37231 125 13 as as IN 37231 125 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 125 15 is be VBZ 37231 125 16 , , , 37231 125 17 which which WDT 37231 125 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 125 19 has have VBZ 37231 125 20 to to TO 37231 125 21 impart impart VB 37231 125 22 about about IN 37231 125 23 the the DT 37231 125 24 four four CD 37231 125 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 125 26 and and CC 37231 125 27 other other JJ 37231 125 28 works,(3 works,(3 NNP 37231 125 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 125 30 and and CC 37231 125 31 what what WP 37231 125 32 Origen Origen NNP 37231 125 33 has have VBZ 37231 125 34 to to TO 37231 125 35 say say VB 37231 125 36 concerning concern VBG 37231 125 37 them -PRON- PRP 37231 125 38 . . . 37231 126 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 126 2 4 4 LS 37231 126 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 126 4 Interrogating interrogate VBG 37231 126 5 extant extant JJ 37231 126 6 works work NNS 37231 126 7 , , , 37231 126 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 126 9 find find VBP 37231 126 10 in in IN 37231 126 11 fact fact NN 37231 126 12 that that IN 37231 126 13 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 126 14 does do VBZ 37231 126 15 not not RB 37231 126 16 neglect neglect VB 37231 126 17 to to TO 37231 126 18 quote quote VB 37231 126 19 anything anything NN 37231 126 20 useful useful JJ 37231 126 21 or or CC 37231 126 22 interesting interesting JJ 37231 126 23 regarding regard VBG 37231 126 24 these these DT 37231 126 25 books book NNS 37231 126 26 from from IN 37231 126 27 early early JJ 37231 126 28 writers writer NNS 37231 126 29 . . . 37231 127 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 127 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 127 3 says say VBZ 37231 127 4 that that IN 37231 127 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 127 6 " " `` 37231 127 7 restricts restrict VBZ 37231 127 8 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 127 9 to to IN 37231 127 10 the the DT 37231 127 11 narrowest narrow JJS 37231 127 12 limits limit NNS 37231 127 13 which which WDT 37231 127 14 justice justice NN 37231 127 15 to to IN 37231 127 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 127 17 subject subject NN 37231 127 18 will will MD 37231 127 19 allow allow VB 37231 127 20 , , , 37231 127 21 " " '' 37231 127 22 and and CC 37231 127 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 127 24 illustrates illustrate VBZ 37231 127 25 this this DT 37231 127 26 by by IN 37231 127 27 the the DT 37231 127 28 case case NN 37231 127 29 of of IN 37231 127 30 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 127 31 . . . 37231 128 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 128 2 says say VBZ 37231 128 3 : : : 37231 128 4 " " `` 37231 128 5 Though though IN 37231 128 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 128 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 128 8 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 128 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 128 10 gives give VBZ 37231 128 11 the the DT 37231 128 12 principal principal JJ 37231 128 13 passage passage NN 37231 128 14 in in IN 37231 128 15 this this DT 37231 128 16 author author NN 37231 128 17 relating relate VBG 37231 128 18 to to IN 37231 128 19 the the DT 37231 128 20 Four Four NNP 37231 128 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 128 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 128 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 128 24 , , , 37231 128 25 Ady Ady NNP 37231 128 26 . . . 37231 129 1 ILer iler UH 37231 129 2 . . . 37231 130 1 iii iii NNP 37231 130 2 . . . 37231 131 1 1 1 CD 37231 131 2 , , , 37231 131 3 1 1 CD 37231 131 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 131 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 131 6 omits omit VBZ 37231 131 7 to to TO 37231 131 8 mention mention VB 37231 131 9 others other NNS 37231 131 10 which which WDT 37231 131 11 contain contain VBP 37231 131 12 interesting interesting JJ 37231 131 13 statements statement NNS 37231 131 14 directly directly RB 37231 131 15 or or CC 37231 131 16 indirectly indirectly RB 37231 131 17 affecting affect VBG 37231 131 18 the the DT 37231 131 19 question question NN 37231 131 20 , , , 37231 131 21 e.g. e.g. RB 37231 132 1 that that IN 37231 132 2 St. St. NNP 37231 132 3 John John NNP 37231 132 4 wrote write VBD 37231 132 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 132 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 132 7 to to TO 37231 132 8 counteract counteract VB 37231 132 9 the the DT 37231 132 10 errors error NNS 37231 132 11 of of IN 37231 132 12 Cerinthus Cerinthus NNP 37231 132 13 and and CC 37231 132 14 the the DT 37231 132 15 Nicolaitans Nicolaitans NNPS 37231 132 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 132 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 132 18 , , , 37231 132 19 Adv Adv NNP 37231 132 20 . . . 37231 133 1 Hær Hær NNP 37231 133 2 . . . 37231 134 1 iii iii NNP 37231 134 2 . . . 37231 135 1 11 11 CD 37231 135 2 , , , 37231 135 3 1 1 CD 37231 135 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 135 5 . . . 37231 135 6 " " '' 37231 136 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 136 2 must must MD 37231 136 3 explain explain VB 37231 136 4 , , , 37231 136 5 however however RB 37231 136 6 , , , 37231 136 7 that that IN 37231 136 8 the the DT 37231 136 9 " " `` 37231 136 10 interesting interesting JJ 37231 136 11 statement statement NN 37231 136 12 " " '' 37231 136 13 omitted omit VBN 37231 136 14 , , , 37231 136 15 which which WDT 37231 136 16 is be VBZ 37231 136 17 not not RB 37231 136 18 in in IN 37231 136 19 the the DT 37231 136 20 context context NN 37231 136 21 of of IN 37231 136 22 the the DT 37231 136 23 part part NN 37231 136 24 quoted quote VBN 37231 136 25 , , , 37231 136 26 is be VBZ 37231 136 27 not not RB 37231 136 28 advanced advance VBN 37231 136 29 as as IN 37231 136 30 information information NN 37231 136 31 derived derive VBN 37231 136 32 from from IN 37231 136 33 any any DT 37231 136 34 authority authority NN 37231 136 35 , , , 37231 136 36 but but CC 37231 136 37 only only RB 37231 136 38 in in IN 37231 136 39 the the DT 37231 136 40 course course NN 37231 136 41 of of IN 37231 136 42 argument argument NN 37231 136 43 , , , 37231 136 44 and and CC 37231 136 45 there there EX 37231 136 46 is be VBZ 37231 136 47 nothing nothing NN 37231 136 48 to to TO 37231 136 49 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 136 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 136 51 from from IN 37231 136 52 mere mere JJ 37231 136 53 personal personal JJ 37231 136 54 opinion opinion NN 37231 136 55 , , , 37231 136 56 so so IN 37231 136 57 that that IN 37231 136 58 on on IN 37231 136 59 this this DT 37231 136 60 ground ground NN 37231 136 61 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 136 62 may may MD 37231 136 63 well well RB 37231 136 64 have have VB 37231 136 65 passed pass VBN 37231 136 66 it -PRON- PRP 37231 136 67 over over RP 37231 136 68 . . . 37231 137 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 137 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 137 3 farther farther RB 37231 137 4 says say VBZ 37231 137 5 : : : 37231 137 6 " " `` 37231 137 7 Thus thus RB 37231 137 8 too too RB 37231 137 9 when when WRB 37231 137 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 137 11 quotes quote VBZ 37231 137 12 a a DT 37231 137 13 few few JJ 37231 137 14 lines line NNS 37231 137 15 alluding allude VBG 37231 137 16 to to IN 37231 137 17 the the DT 37231 137 18 unanimous unanimous JJ 37231 137 19 tradition tradition NN 37231 137 20 of of IN 37231 137 21 the the DT 37231 137 22 Asiatic asiatic JJ 37231 137 23 Elders Elders NNPS 37231 137 24 who who WP 37231 137 25 were be VBD 37231 137 26 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 137 27 with with IN 37231 137 28 St. St. NNP 37231 137 29 John,(6 John,(6 NNP 37231 137 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 137 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 137 32 omits omit VBZ 37231 137 33 the the DT 37231 137 34 context context NN 37231 137 35 , , , 37231 137 36 from from IN 37231 137 37 which which WDT 37231 137 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 137 39 find find VBP 37231 137 40 that that IN 37231 137 41 this this DT 37231 137 42 tradition tradition NN 37231 137 43 had have VBD 37231 137 44 an an DT 37231 137 45 important important JJ 37231 137 46 bearing bearing NN 37231 137 47 on on IN 37231 137 48 the the DT 37231 137 49 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 137 50 of of IN 37231 137 51 the the DT 37231 137 52 fourth fourth JJ 37231 137 53 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 137 54 , , , 37231 137 55 for for IN 37231 137 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 137 57 declared declare VBD 37231 137 58 that that IN 37231 137 59 Christ Christ NNP 37231 137 60 's 's POS 37231 137 61 ministry ministry NN 37231 137 62 extended extend VBD 37231 137 63 much much RB 37231 137 64 beyond beyond IN 37231 137 65 a a DT 37231 137 66 single single JJ 37231 137 67 year year NN 37231 137 68 , , , 37231 137 69 thus thus RB 37231 137 70 confirming confirm VBG 37231 137 71 the the DT 37231 137 72 obvious obvious JJ 37231 137 73 chronology chronology NN 37231 137 74 of of IN 37231 137 75 the the DT 37231 137 76 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 137 77 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 137 78 against against IN 37231 137 79 the the DT 37231 137 80 apparent apparent JJ 37231 137 81 chronology chronology NN 37231 137 82 of of IN 37231 137 83 the the DT 37231 137 84 Synoptists Synoptists NNPS 37231 137 85 . . . 37231 138 1 " " `` 37231 138 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 138 3 7 7 LS 37231 138 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 138 5 Nothing nothing NN 37231 138 6 , , , 37231 138 7 however however RB 37231 138 8 , , , 37231 138 9 could could MD 37231 138 10 be be VB 37231 138 11 further further JJ 37231 138 12 from from IN 37231 138 13 the the DT 37231 138 14 desire desire NN 37231 138 15 or or CC 37231 138 16 intention intention NN 37231 138 17 of of IN 37231 138 18 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 138 19 than than IN 37231 138 20 to to TO 37231 138 21 represent represent VB 37231 138 22 any any DT 37231 138 23 discordance discordance NN 37231 138 24 between between IN 37231 138 25 the the DT 37231 138 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 138 27 , , , 37231 138 28 or or CC 37231 138 29 to to TO 37231 138 30 support support VB 37231 138 31 the the DT 37231 138 32 one one NN 37231 138 33 at at IN 37231 138 34 the the DT 37231 138 35 expense expense NN 37231 138 36 of of IN 37231 138 37 the the DT 37231 138 38 others other NNS 37231 138 39 . . . 37231 139 1 On on IN 37231 139 2 the the DT 37231 139 3 contrary contrary NN 37231 139 4 , , , 37231 139 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 139 6 enters enter VBZ 37231 139 7 into into IN 37231 139 8 an an DT 37231 139 9 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 139 10 explanation explanation NN 37231 139 11 in in IN 37231 139 12 order order NN 37231 139 13 to to TO 37231 139 14 show show VB 37231 139 15 that that IN 37231 139 16 there there EX 37231 139 17 is be VBZ 37231 139 18 no no DT 37231 139 19 discrepancy discrepancy NN 37231 139 20 between between IN 37231 139 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 139 22 , , , 37231 139 23 affirming affirm VBG 37231 139 24 , , , 37231 139 25 and and CC 37231 139 26 supporting support VBG 37231 139 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 139 28 view view NN 37231 139 29 by by IN 37231 139 30 singular singular JJ 37231 139 31 quotations quotation NNS 37231 139 32 , , , 37231 139 33 that that IN 37231 139 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 139 35 was be VBD 37231 139 36 evidently evidently RB 37231 139 37 the the DT 37231 139 38 intention intention NN 37231 139 39 of of IN 37231 139 40 the the DT 37231 139 41 three three CD 37231 139 42 Synoptists Synoptists NNPS 37231 139 43 only only RB 37231 139 44 to to TO 37231 139 45 write write VB 37231 139 46 the the DT 37231 139 47 doings doing NNS 37231 139 48 of of IN 37231 139 49 the the DT 37231 139 50 Lord Lord NNP 37231 139 51 for for IN 37231 139 52 one one CD 37231 139 53 year year NN 37231 139 54 after after IN 37231 139 55 { { -LRB- 37231 139 56 xviii xviii NN 37231 139 57 } } -RRB- 37231 139 58 the the DT 37231 139 59 imprisonment imprisonment NN 37231 139 60 of of IN 37231 139 61 John John NNP 37231 139 62 the the DT 37231 139 63 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 139 64 , , , 37231 139 65 and and CC 37231 139 66 that that IN 37231 139 67 John John NNP 37231 139 68 , , , 37231 139 69 having have VBG 37231 139 70 the the DT 37231 139 71 other other JJ 37231 139 72 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 139 73 before before IN 37231 139 74 him -PRON- PRP 37231 139 75 , , , 37231 139 76 wrote write VBD 37231 139 77 an an DT 37231 139 78 account account NN 37231 139 79 of of IN 37231 139 80 the the DT 37231 139 81 period period NN 37231 139 82 not not RB 37231 139 83 embraced embrace VBN 37231 139 84 by by IN 37231 139 85 the the DT 37231 139 86 other other JJ 37231 139 87 evangelists evangelist NNS 37231 139 88 . . . 37231 140 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 140 2 1 1 LS 37231 140 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 140 4 Moreover moreover RB 37231 140 5 , , , 37231 140 6 the the DT 37231 140 7 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 140 8 assertions assertion NNS 37231 140 9 of of IN 37231 140 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 140 11 not not RB 37231 140 12 only only RB 37231 140 13 contradict contradict VBP 37231 140 14 the the DT 37231 140 15 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 140 16 , , , 37231 140 17 but but CC 37231 140 18 also also RB 37231 140 19 the the DT 37231 140 20 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 140 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 140 22 , , , 37231 140 23 and and CC 37231 140 24 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 140 25 certainly certainly RB 37231 140 26 could could MD 37231 140 27 not not RB 37231 140 28 have have VB 37231 140 29 felt feel VBN 37231 140 30 much much JJ 37231 140 31 inclination inclination NN 37231 140 32 to to TO 37231 140 33 quote quote VB 37231 140 34 such such JJ 37231 140 35 opinions opinion NNS 37231 140 36 , , , 37231 140 37 even even RB 37231 140 38 although although IN 37231 140 39 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 140 40 seemed seem VBD 37231 140 41 to to TO 37231 140 42 base base VB 37231 140 43 them -PRON- PRP 37231 140 44 upon upon IN 37231 140 45 traditions tradition NNS 37231 140 46 handed hand VBN 37231 140 47 down down RP 37231 140 48 by by IN 37231 140 49 the the DT 37231 140 50 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 37231 140 51 who who WP 37231 140 52 were be VBD 37231 140 53 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 140 54 with with IN 37231 140 55 John John NNP 37231 140 56 . . . 37231 141 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 141 2 being be VBG 37231 141 3 then then RB 37231 141 4 admitted admit VBN 37231 141 5 that that IN 37231 141 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 141 7 not not RB 37231 141 8 only only RB 37231 141 9 pledges pledge VBZ 37231 141 10 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 141 11 to to TO 37231 141 12 record record VB 37231 141 13 when when WRB 37231 141 14 any any DT 37231 141 15 ancient ancient JJ 37231 141 16 writer writer NN 37231 141 17 has have VBZ 37231 141 18 something something NN 37231 141 19 to to TO 37231 141 20 " " `` 37231 141 21 tell tell VB 37231 141 22 about about IN 37231 141 23 " " `` 37231 141 24 the the DT 37231 141 25 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 141 26 canonical canonical JJ 37231 141 27 books book NNS 37231 141 28 , , , 37231 141 29 but but CC 37231 141 30 that that IN 37231 141 31 , , , 37231 141 32 judged judge VBN 37231 141 33 by by IN 37231 141 34 the the DT 37231 141 35 test test NN 37231 141 36 of of IN 37231 141 37 extant extant JJ 37231 141 38 writings writing NNS 37231 141 39 which which WDT 37231 141 40 we -PRON- PRP 37231 141 41 can can MD 37231 141 42 examine examine VB 37231 141 43 , , , 37231 141 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 141 45 actually actually RB 37231 141 46 does do VBZ 37231 141 47 so so RB 37231 141 48 , , , 37231 141 49 let let VB 37231 141 50 us -PRON- PRP 37231 141 51 sec sec NNP 37231 141 52 the the DT 37231 141 53 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 141 54 which which WDT 37231 141 55 we -PRON- PRP 37231 141 56 are be VBP 37231 141 57 entitled entitle VBN 37231 141 58 to to TO 37231 141 59 draw draw VB 37231 141 60 in in IN 37231 141 61 the the DT 37231 141 62 case case NN 37231 141 63 of of IN 37231 141 64 the the DT 37231 141 65 only only JJ 37231 141 66 three three CD 37231 141 67 writers writer NNS 37231 141 68 with with IN 37231 141 69 regard regard NN 37231 141 70 to to IN 37231 141 71 whom whom WP 37231 141 72 I -PRON- PRP 37231 141 73 have have VBP 37231 141 74 inferred infer VBN 37231 141 75 anything anything NN 37231 141 76 from from IN 37231 141 77 the the DT 37231 141 78 " " `` 37231 141 79 silence silence NN 37231 141 80 of of IN 37231 141 81 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 141 82 . . . 37231 141 83 " " '' 37231 142 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 142 2 need need VBP 37231 142 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 142 4 repeat repeat VB 37231 142 5 that that IN 37231 142 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 142 7 held hold VBD 37231 142 8 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 142 9 in in IN 37231 142 10 very very RB 37231 142 11 high high JJ 37231 142 12 estimation estimation NN 37231 142 13 . . . 37231 143 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 143 2 refers refer VBZ 37231 143 3 to to IN 37231 143 4 him -PRON- PRP 37231 143 5 very very RB 37231 143 6 frequently frequently RB 37231 143 7 , , , 37231 143 8 and and CC 37231 143 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 143 10 clearly clearly RB 37231 143 11 shows show VBZ 37231 143 12 that that IN 37231 143 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 143 14 not not RB 37231 143 15 only only RB 37231 143 16 valued value VBN 37231 143 17 , , , 37231 143 18 but but CC 37231 143 19 was be VBD 37231 143 20 intimately intimately RB 37231 143 21 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 143 22 with with IN 37231 143 23 , , , 37231 143 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 143 25 writings writing NNS 37231 143 26 . . . 37231 144 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 144 2 quotes quote VBZ 37231 144 3 from from IN 37231 144 4 the the DT 37231 144 5 work work NN 37231 144 6 of of IN 37231 144 7 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 144 8 a a DT 37231 144 9 very very RB 37231 144 10 long long JJ 37231 144 11 account account NN 37231 144 12 of of IN 37231 144 13 the the DT 37231 144 14 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 144 15 of of IN 37231 144 16 James;(2 James;(2 NNP 37231 144 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 144 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 144 19 refers refer VBZ 37231 144 20 to to IN 37231 144 21 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 144 22 as as IN 37231 144 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 144 24 authority authority NN 37231 144 25 for for IN 37231 144 26 the the DT 37231 144 27 statement statement NN 37231 144 28 that that IN 37231 144 29 Simeon Simeon NNP 37231 144 30 was be VBD 37231 144 31 a a DT 37231 144 32 cousin cousin NN 37231 144 33 [ [ -LRB- 37231 144 34 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 144 35 ] ] -RRB- 37231 144 36 of of IN 37231 144 37 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 144 38 , , , 37231 144 39 Cleophas Cleophas NNP 37231 144 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 144 41 father father NN 37231 144 42 being be VBG 37231 144 43 , , , 37231 144 44 according accord VBG 37231 144 45 to to IN 37231 144 46 that that DT 37231 144 47 author author NN 37231 144 48 , , , 37231 144 49 the the DT 37231 144 50 brother brother NN 37231 144 51 of of IN 37231 144 52 Joseph;(3 Joseph;(3 NNP 37231 144 53 ) ) -RRB- 37231 144 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 144 55 confirms confirm VBZ 37231 144 56 a a DT 37231 144 57 passage passage NN 37231 144 58 in in IN 37231 144 59 the the DT 37231 144 60 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 144 61 of of IN 37231 144 62 Clement Clement NNP 37231 144 63 by by IN 37231 144 64 reference reference NN 37231 144 65 to to IN 37231 144 66 Hegesippus;(4 Hegesippus;(4 NNP 37231 144 67 ) ) -RRB- 37231 144 68 he -PRON- PRP 37231 144 69 quotes quote VBZ 37231 144 70 from from IN 37231 144 71 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 144 72 a a DT 37231 144 73 story story NN 37231 144 74 regarding regard VBG 37231 144 75 some some DT 37231 144 76 members member NNS 37231 144 77 of of IN 37231 144 78 the the DT 37231 144 79 family family NN 37231 144 80 of of IN 37231 144 81 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 144 82 , , , 37231 144 83 of of IN 37231 144 84 the the DT 37231 144 85 race race NN 37231 144 86 of of IN 37231 144 87 David David NNP 37231 144 88 , , , 37231 144 89 who who WP 37231 144 90 were be VBD 37231 144 91 brought bring VBN 37231 144 92 before before IN 37231 144 93 Domitian;(5 Domitian;(5 NNP 37231 144 94 ) ) -RRB- 37231 144 95 he -PRON- PRP 37231 144 96 cites cite VBZ 37231 144 97 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 144 98 narrative narrative NN 37231 144 99 of of IN 37231 144 100 the the DT 37231 144 101 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 144 102 of of IN 37231 144 103 Simeon Simeon NNP 37231 144 104 , , , 37231 144 105 together together RB 37231 144 106 with with IN 37231 144 107 other other JJ 37231 144 108 matters matter NNS 37231 144 109 concerning concern VBG 37231 144 110 the the DT 37231 144 111 early early JJ 37231 144 112 Church;(6 church;(6 NN 37231 144 113 ) ) -RRB- 37231 144 114 in in IN 37231 144 115 another another DT 37231 144 116 place place NN 37231 144 117 he -PRON- PRP 37231 144 118 gives give VBZ 37231 144 119 a a DT 37231 144 120 laudatory laudatory JJ 37231 144 121 account account NN 37231 144 122 of of IN 37231 144 123 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 144 124 and and CC 37231 144 125 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 144 126 writings;(7 writings;(7 NN 37231 144 127 ) ) -RRB- 37231 144 128 shortly shortly RB 37231 144 129 after after IN 37231 144 130 , , , 37231 144 131 he -PRON- PRP 37231 144 132 refers refer VBZ 37231 144 133 to to IN 37231 144 134 the the DT 37231 144 135 { { -LRB- 37231 144 136 xix xix NNP 37231 144 137 } } -RRB- 37231 144 138 statement statement NN 37231 144 139 of of IN 37231 144 140 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 144 141 that that IN 37231 144 142 he -PRON- PRP 37231 144 143 was be VBD 37231 144 144 in in IN 37231 144 145 Rome Rome NNP 37231 144 146 until until IN 37231 144 147 the the DT 37231 144 148 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 144 149 of of IN 37231 144 150 Eleutherus,(1 Eleutherus,(1 NNP 37231 144 151 ) ) -RRB- 37231 144 152 and and CC 37231 144 153 further further JJ 37231 144 154 speaks speak VBZ 37231 144 155 in in IN 37231 144 156 praise praise NN 37231 144 157 of of IN 37231 144 158 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 144 159 work work NN 37231 144 160 , , , 37231 144 161 mentions mention VBZ 37231 144 162 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 144 163 observation observation NN 37231 144 164 on on IN 37231 144 165 the the DT 37231 144 166 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 144 167 of of IN 37231 144 168 Clement Clement NNP 37231 144 169 , , , 37231 144 170 and and CC 37231 144 171 quotes quote VBZ 37231 144 172 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 144 173 remarks remark NNS 37231 144 174 about about IN 37231 144 175 the the DT 37231 144 176 Church Church NNP 37231 144 177 in in IN 37231 144 178 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 144 179 , , , 37231 144 180 the the DT 37231 144 181 succession succession NN 37231 144 182 of of IN 37231 144 183 Roman roman JJ 37231 144 184 bishops bishop NNS 37231 144 185 , , , 37231 144 186 the the DT 37231 144 187 general general JJ 37231 144 188 state state NN 37231 144 189 of of IN 37231 144 190 the the DT 37231 144 191 Church Church NNP 37231 144 192 , , , 37231 144 193 the the DT 37231 144 194 rise rise NN 37231 144 195 of of IN 37231 144 196 heresies heresy NNS 37231 144 197 , , , 37231 144 198 and and CC 37231 144 199 other other JJ 37231 144 200 matters matter NNS 37231 144 201 . . . 37231 145 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 145 2 3 3 LS 37231 145 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 145 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 145 5 mention mention VBP 37231 145 6 these these DT 37231 145 7 numerous numerous JJ 37231 145 8 references reference NNS 37231 145 9 to to IN 37231 145 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 145 11 as as IN 37231 145 12 I -PRON- PRP 37231 145 13 have have VBP 37231 145 14 noticed notice VBN 37231 145 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 145 16 in in IN 37231 145 17 turning turn VBG 37231 145 18 over over RP 37231 145 19 the the DT 37231 145 20 pages page NNS 37231 145 21 of of IN 37231 145 22 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 145 23 , , , 37231 145 24 but but CC 37231 145 25 others other NNS 37231 145 26 may may MD 37231 145 27 very very RB 37231 145 28 probably probably RB 37231 145 29 have have VB 37231 145 30 escaped escape VBN 37231 145 31 me -PRON- PRP 37231 145 32 . . . 37231 146 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 146 2 fulfils fulfil VBZ 37231 146 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 146 4 pledge pledge NN 37231 146 5 , , , 37231 146 6 and and CC 37231 146 7 states state NNS 37231 146 8 what what WP 37231 146 9 disputed dispute VBD 37231 146 10 works work NNS 37231 146 11 were be VBD 37231 146 12 used use VBN 37231 146 13 by by IN 37231 146 14 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 146 15 and and CC 37231 146 16 what what WP 37231 146 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 146 18 said say VBD 37231 146 19 about about IN 37231 146 20 them -PRON- PRP 37231 146 21 , , , 37231 146 22 and and CC 37231 146 23 one one CD 37231 146 24 of of IN 37231 146 25 these these DT 37231 146 26 was be VBD 37231 146 27 the the DT 37231 146 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 146 29 according accord VBG 37231 146 30 to to IN 37231 146 31 the the DT 37231 146 32 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 146 33 . . . 37231 147 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 147 2 does do VBZ 37231 147 3 not not RB 37231 147 4 , , , 37231 147 5 however however RB 37231 147 6 , , , 37231 147 7 record record VB 37231 147 8 a a DT 37231 147 9 single single JJ 37231 147 10 remark remark NN 37231 147 11 of of IN 37231 147 12 any any DT 37231 147 13 kind kind NN 37231 147 14 regarding regard VBG 37231 147 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 147 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 147 17 , , , 37231 147 18 and and CC 37231 147 19 the the DT 37231 147 20 legitimate legitimate JJ 37231 147 21 inference inference NN 37231 147 22 , , , 37231 147 23 and and CC 37231 147 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 147 25 is be VBZ 37231 147 26 the the DT 37231 147 27 only only JJ 37231 147 28 one one CD 37231 147 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 147 30 care care VBP 37231 147 31 to to TO 37231 147 32 draw draw VB 37231 147 33 , , , 37231 147 34 is be VBZ 37231 147 35 , , , 37231 147 36 that that IN 37231 147 37 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 147 38 did do VBD 37231 147 39 not not RB 37231 147 40 say say VB 37231 147 41 anything anything NN 37231 147 42 about about IN 37231 147 43 them -PRON- PRP 37231 147 44 . . . 37231 148 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 148 2 may may MD 37231 148 3 simply simply RB 37231 148 4 add add VB 37231 148 5 that that DT 37231 148 6 , , , 37231 148 7 as as IN 37231 148 8 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 148 9 quotes quote VBZ 37231 148 10 the the DT 37231 148 11 account account NN 37231 148 12 of of IN 37231 148 13 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 148 14 and and CC 37231 148 15 Mark Mark NNP 37231 148 16 from from IN 37231 148 17 Papias Papias NNP 37231 148 18 , , , 37231 148 19 a a DT 37231 148 20 man man NN 37231 148 21 of of IN 37231 148 22 whom whom WP 37231 148 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 148 24 expresses express VBZ 37231 148 25 something something NN 37231 148 26 like like IN 37231 148 27 contempt contempt NN 37231 148 28 , , , 37231 148 29 and and CC 37231 148 30 again again RB 37231 148 31 refers refer VBZ 37231 148 32 to to IN 37231 148 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 148 34 in in IN 37231 148 35 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 148 36 of of IN 37231 148 37 the the DT 37231 148 38 statement statement NN 37231 148 39 of of IN 37231 148 40 the the DT 37231 148 41 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 37231 148 42 Clement Clement NNP 37231 148 43 regarding regard VBG 37231 148 44 the the DT 37231 148 45 composition composition NN 37231 148 46 of of IN 37231 148 47 Mark Mark NNP 37231 148 48 's 's POS 37231 148 49 Gospel,(3 gospel,(3 NN 37231 148 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 148 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 148 52 would would MD 37231 148 53 be be VB 37231 148 54 against against IN 37231 148 55 all all DT 37231 148 56 reason reason NN 37231 148 57 , , , 37231 148 58 as as RB 37231 148 59 well well RB 37231 148 60 as as IN 37231 148 61 opposed oppose VBN 37231 148 62 to to IN 37231 148 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 148 64 pledge pledge NN 37231 148 65 and and CC 37231 148 66 general general JJ 37231 148 67 practice practice NN 37231 148 68 , , , 37231 148 69 to to TO 37231 148 70 suppose suppose VB 37231 148 71 that that IN 37231 148 72 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 148 73 would would MD 37231 148 74 have have VB 37231 148 75 omitted omit VBN 37231 148 76 to to TO 37231 148 77 record record VB 37231 148 78 any any DT 37231 148 79 information information NN 37231 148 80 given give VBN 37231 148 81 by by IN 37231 148 82 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 148 83 , , , 37231 148 84 a a DT 37231 148 85 writer writer NN 37231 148 86 with with IN 37231 148 87 whom whom WP 37231 148 88 he -PRON- PRP 37231 148 89 was be VBD 37231 148 90 so so RB 37231 148 91 well well RB 37231 148 92 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 148 93 , , , 37231 148 94 and and CC 37231 148 95 of of IN 37231 148 96 whom whom WP 37231 148 97 he -PRON- PRP 37231 148 98 speaks speak VBZ 37231 148 99 with with IN 37231 148 100 so so RB 37231 148 101 much much JJ 37231 148 102 respect respect NN 37231 148 103 . . . 37231 149 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 149 2 have have VBP 37231 149 3 said say VBN 37231 149 4 that that IN 37231 149 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 149 6 would would MD 37231 149 7 more more RBR 37231 149 8 particularly particularly RB 37231 149 9 have have VBP 37231 149 10 quoted quote VBN 37231 149 11 anything anything NN 37231 149 12 with with IN 37231 149 13 regard regard NN 37231 149 14 to to IN 37231 149 15 the the DT 37231 149 16 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 149 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 149 18 , , , 37231 149 19 and and CC 37231 149 20 for for IN 37231 149 21 those those DT 37231 149 22 who who WP 37231 149 23 care care VBP 37231 149 24 to to TO 37231 149 25 go go VB 37231 149 26 more more RBR 37231 149 27 closely closely RB 37231 149 28 into into IN 37231 149 29 the the DT 37231 149 30 point point NN 37231 149 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 149 32 reasons reason NNS 37231 149 33 may may MD 37231 149 34 be be VB 37231 149 35 briefly briefly RB 37231 149 36 given give VBN 37231 149 37 . . . 37231 150 1 No no DT 37231 150 2 one one NN 37231 150 3 can can MD 37231 150 4 read read VB 37231 150 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 150 6 attentively attentively RB 37231 150 7 without without IN 37231 150 8 noting note VBG 37231 150 9 the the DT 37231 150 10 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 150 11 care care NN 37231 150 12 with with IN 37231 150 13 which which WDT 37231 150 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 150 15 speaks speak VBZ 37231 150 16 of of IN 37231 150 17 John John NNP 37231 150 18 and and CC 37231 150 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 150 20 writings writing NNS 37231 150 21 , , , 37231 150 22 and and CC 37231 150 23 the the DT 37231 150 24 substantially substantially RB 37231 150 25 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 150 26 tone tone NN 37231 150 27 which which WDT 37231 150 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 150 29 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 150 30 in in IN 37231 150 31 regard regard NN 37231 150 32 to to IN 37231 150 33 them -PRON- PRP 37231 150 34 . . . 37231 151 1 Apart apart RB 37231 151 2 from from IN 37231 151 3 any any DT 37231 151 4 doubts doubt NNS 37231 151 5 expressed express VBN 37231 151 6 { { -LRB- 37231 151 7 xx xx CD 37231 151 8 } } -RRB- 37231 151 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 151 10 the the DT 37231 151 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 151 12 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 151 13 , , , 37231 151 14 the the DT 37231 151 15 controversy controversy NN 37231 151 16 as as IN 37231 151 17 to to IN 37231 151 18 the the DT 37231 151 19 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 151 20 of of IN 37231 151 21 the the DT 37231 151 22 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 151 23 and and CC 37231 151 24 second second JJ 37231 151 25 and and CC 37231 151 26 third third JJ 37231 151 27 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 151 28 called call VBN 37231 151 29 by by IN 37231 151 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 151 31 name name NN 37231 151 32 , , , 37231 151 33 with with IN 37231 151 34 which which WDT 37231 151 35 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 151 36 was be VBD 37231 151 37 so so RB 37231 151 38 well well RB 37231 151 39 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 151 40 , , , 37231 151 41 and and CC 37231 151 42 the the DT 37231 151 43 critical critical JJ 37231 151 44 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 151 45 as as IN 37231 151 46 to to IN 37231 151 47 the the DT 37231 151 48 impossibility impossibility NN 37231 151 49 of of IN 37231 151 50 the the DT 37231 151 51 same same JJ 37231 151 52 John John NNP 37231 151 53 having have VBG 37231 151 54 written write VBN 37231 151 55 both both DT 37231 151 56 the the DT 37231 151 57 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 151 58 and and CC 37231 151 59 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 151 60 , , , 37231 151 61 regarding regard VBG 37231 151 62 which which WDT 37231 151 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 151 64 so so RB 37231 151 65 fully fully RB 37231 151 66 quotes quote VBZ 37231 151 67 the the DT 37231 151 68 argument argument NN 37231 151 69 of of IN 37231 151 70 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 151 71 of of IN 37231 151 72 Alexandria,(1 alexandria,(1 NN 37231 151 73 ) ) -RRB- 37231 151 74 evidently evidently RB 37231 151 75 made make VBD 37231 151 76 him -PRON- PRP 37231 151 77 peculiarly peculiarly RB 37231 151 78 interested interested JJ 37231 151 79 in in IN 37231 151 80 the the DT 37231 151 81 subject subject NN 37231 151 82 , , , 37231 151 83 and and CC 37231 151 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 151 85 attention attention NN 37231 151 86 to to IN 37231 151 87 the the DT 37231 151 88 fourth fourth JJ 37231 151 89 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 151 90 was be VBD 37231 151 91 certainly certainly RB 37231 151 92 not not RB 37231 151 93 diminished diminish VBN 37231 151 94 by by IN 37231 151 95 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 151 96 recognition recognition NN 37231 151 97 of of IN 37231 151 98 the the DT 37231 151 99 essential essential JJ 37231 151 100 difference difference NN 37231 151 101 between between IN 37231 151 102 that that DT 37231 151 103 work work NN 37231 151 104 and and CC 37231 151 105 the the DT 37231 151 106 three three CD 37231 151 107 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 151 108 . . . 37231 152 1 The the DT 37231 152 2 first first JJ 37231 152 3 occasion occasion NN 37231 152 4 on on IN 37231 152 5 which which WDT 37231 152 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 152 7 speaks speak VBZ 37231 152 8 of of IN 37231 152 9 John John NNP 37231 152 10 , , , 37231 152 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 152 12 records record VBZ 37231 152 13 the the DT 37231 152 14 tradition tradition NN 37231 152 15 that that WDT 37231 152 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 152 17 was be VBD 37231 152 18 banished banish VBN 37231 152 19 to to IN 37231 152 20 Patmos Patmos NNP 37231 152 21 during during IN 37231 152 22 the the DT 37231 152 23 persecution persecution NN 37231 152 24 under under IN 37231 152 25 Domitian domitian JJ 37231 152 26 , , , 37231 152 27 and and CC 37231 152 28 refers refer VBZ 37231 152 29 to to IN 37231 152 30 the the DT 37231 152 31 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 152 32 . . . 37231 153 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 153 2 quotes quote VBZ 37231 153 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 153 4 in in IN 37231 153 5 support support NN 37231 153 6 of of IN 37231 153 7 this this DT 37231 153 8 tradition tradition NN 37231 153 9 , , , 37231 153 10 and and CC 37231 153 11 the the DT 37231 153 12 composition composition NN 37231 153 13 of of IN 37231 153 14 the the DT 37231 153 15 work work NN 37231 153 16 at at IN 37231 153 17 the the DT 37231 153 18 close close NN 37231 153 19 of of IN 37231 153 20 Domitian Domitian NNP 37231 153 21 's 's POS 37231 153 22 reign reign NN 37231 153 23 . . . 37231 154 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 154 2 3 3 LS 37231 154 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 154 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 154 5 goes go VBZ 37231 154 6 on on RP 37231 154 7 to to TO 37231 154 8 speak speak VB 37231 154 9 of of IN 37231 154 10 the the DT 37231 154 11 persecution persecution NN 37231 154 12 under under IN 37231 154 13 Domitian domitian JJ 37231 154 14 , , , 37231 154 15 and and CC 37231 154 16 quotes quote VBZ 37231 154 17 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 154 18 as as IN 37231 154 19 to to IN 37231 154 20 a a DT 37231 154 21 command command NN 37231 154 22 given give VBN 37231 154 23 by by IN 37231 154 24 that that DT 37231 154 25 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 154 26 to to TO 37231 154 27 slay slay VB 37231 154 28 all all PDT 37231 154 29 the the DT 37231 154 30 posterity posterity NN 37231 154 31 of of IN 37231 154 32 David,(3 david,(3 NN 37231 154 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 154 34 as as IN 37231 154 35 also also RB 37231 154 36 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 154 37 's 's POS 37231 154 38 account,(4 account,(4 NN 37231 154 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 154 40 winding wind VBG 37231 154 41 up up RP 37231 154 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 154 43 extracts extract NNS 37231 154 44 from from IN 37231 154 45 the the DT 37231 154 46 historians historian NNS 37231 154 47 of of IN 37231 154 48 the the DT 37231 154 49 time time NN 37231 154 50 by by IN 37231 154 51 the the DT 37231 154 52 statement statement NN 37231 154 53 that that IN 37231 154 54 , , , 37231 154 55 after after IN 37231 154 56 Nerva Nerva NNP 37231 154 57 succeeded succeed VBD 37231 154 58 Domitian Domitian NNP 37231 154 59 , , , 37231 154 60 and and CC 37231 154 61 the the DT 37231 154 62 Senate Senate NNP 37231 154 63 had have VBD 37231 154 64 revoked revoke VBN 37231 154 65 the the DT 37231 154 66 cruel cruel JJ 37231 154 67 decrees decree NNS 37231 154 68 of of IN 37231 154 69 the the DT 37231 154 70 latter latter JJ 37231 154 71 , , , 37231 154 72 the the DT 37231 154 73 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 154 74 John John NNP 37231 154 75 returned return VBD 37231 154 76 from from IN 37231 154 77 exile exile NN 37231 154 78 in in IN 37231 154 79 Patmos Patmos NNP 37231 154 80 and and CC 37231 154 81 , , , 37231 154 82 according accord VBG 37231 154 83 to to IN 37231 154 84 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 154 85 tradition tradition NN 37231 154 86 , , , 37231 154 87 settled settle VBN 37231 154 88 at at IN 37231 154 89 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 37231 154 90 . . . 37231 155 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 155 2 5 5 LS 37231 155 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 155 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 155 5 states state VBZ 37231 155 6 that that IN 37231 155 7 John John NNP 37231 155 8 , , , 37231 155 9 the the DT 37231 155 10 beloved beloved JJ 37231 155 11 disciple disciple NN 37231 155 12 , , , 37231 155 13 apostle apostle NN 37231 155 14 and and CC 37231 155 15 evangelist evangelist NN 37231 155 16 , , , 37231 155 17 governed govern VBD 37231 155 18 the the DT 37231 155 19 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 155 20 of of IN 37231 155 21 Asia Asia NNP 37231 155 22 after after IN 37231 155 23 the the DT 37231 155 24 death death NN 37231 155 25 of of IN 37231 155 26 Domitian Domitian NNP 37231 155 27 and and CC 37231 155 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 155 29 return return NN 37231 155 30 from from IN 37231 155 31 Patmos Patmos NNP 37231 155 32 , , , 37231 155 33 and and CC 37231 155 34 that that IN 37231 155 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 155 36 was be VBD 37231 155 37 still still RB 37231 155 38 living live VBG 37231 155 39 when when WRB 37231 155 40 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 155 41 succeeded succeed VBD 37231 155 42 Nerva Nerva NNP 37231 155 43 , , , 37231 155 44 and and CC 37231 155 45 for for IN 37231 155 46 the the DT 37231 155 47 truth truth NN 37231 155 48 of of IN 37231 155 49 this this DT 37231 155 50 he -PRON- PRP 37231 155 51 quotes quote VBZ 37231 155 52 passages passage NNS 37231 155 53 from from IN 37231 155 54 Iremeus Iremeus NNP 37231 155 55 and and CC 37231 155 56 Clement Clement NNP 37231 155 57 of of IN 37231 155 58 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 155 59 . . . 37231 156 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 156 2 6 6 CD 37231 156 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 156 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 156 5 then then RB 37231 156 6 gives give VBZ 37231 156 7 an an DT 37231 156 8 account account NN 37231 156 9 of of IN 37231 156 10 the the DT 37231 156 11 writings writing NNS 37231 156 12 of of IN 37231 156 13 John John NNP 37231 156 14 , , , 37231 156 15 and and CC 37231 156 16 whilst whilst IN 37231 156 17 asserting assert VBG 37231 156 18 that that IN 37231 156 19 the the DT 37231 156 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 156 21 must must MD 37231 156 22 be be VB 37231 156 23 universally universally RB 37231 156 24 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 37231 156 25 as as IN 37231 156 26 genuine genuine JJ 37231 156 27 , , , 37231 156 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 156 29 says say VBZ 37231 156 30 that that IN 37231 156 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 156 32 is be VBZ 37231 156 33 rightly rightly RB 37231 156 34 put put VBN 37231 156 35 last last RB 37231 156 36 in in IN 37231 156 37 order order NN 37231 156 38 amongst amongst IN 37231 156 39 the the DT 37231 156 40 four four CD 37231 156 41 , , , 37231 156 42 of of IN 37231 156 43 the the DT 37231 156 44 composition composition NN 37231 156 45 of of IN 37231 156 46 which which WDT 37231 156 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 156 48 gives give VBZ 37231 156 49 an an DT 37231 156 50 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 156 51 description description NN 37231 156 52 . . . 37231 157 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 157 2 is be VBZ 37231 157 3 not not RB 37231 157 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 157 5 to to TO 37231 157 6 quote quote VB 37231 157 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 157 8 account account NN 37231 157 9 of of IN 37231 157 10 the the DT 37231 157 11 fourth fourth JJ 37231 157 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 157 13 and and CC 37231 157 14 of of IN 37231 157 15 the the DT 37231 157 16 occasion occasion NN 37231 157 17 of of IN 37231 157 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 157 19 composition composition NN 37231 157 20 , , , 37231 157 21 which which WDT 37231 157 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 157 23 states state VBZ 37231 157 24 to to TO 37231 157 25 have have VB 37231 157 26 been be VBN 37231 157 27 John John NNP 37231 157 28 's 's POS 37231 157 29 receiving receive VBG 37231 157 30 the the DT 37231 157 31 other other JJ 37231 157 32 three three CD 37231 157 33 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 157 34 , , , 37231 157 35 and and CC 37231 157 36 , , , 37231 157 37 whilst whilst IN 37231 157 38 admitting admit VBG 37231 157 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 157 40 truth truth NN 37231 157 41 , , , 37231 157 42 perceiving perceive VBG 37231 157 43 that that IN 37231 157 44 they -PRON- PRP 37231 157 45 did do VBD 37231 157 46 not not RB 37231 157 47 contain contain VB 37231 157 48 a a DT 37231 157 49 narrative narrative NN 37231 157 50 of of IN 37231 157 51 the the DT 37231 157 52 earlier early JJR 37231 157 53 history history NN 37231 157 54 of of IN 37231 157 55 Christ Christ NNP 37231 157 56 . . . 37231 158 1 For for IN 37231 158 2 this this DT 37231 158 3 reason reason NN 37231 158 4 , , , 37231 158 5 being be VBG 37231 158 6 entreated entreat VBN 37231 158 7 to to TO 37231 158 8 do do VB 37231 158 9 so so RB 37231 158 10 , , , 37231 158 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 158 12 wrote write VBD 37231 158 13 an an DT 37231 158 14 account account NN 37231 158 15 of of IN 37231 158 16 the the DT 37231 158 17 doings doing NNS 37231 158 18 of of IN 37231 158 19 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 158 20 before before IN 37231 158 21 the the DT 37231 158 22 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 158 23 was be VBD 37231 158 24 cast cast VBN 37231 158 25 into into IN 37231 158 26 prison prison NN 37231 158 27 . . . 37231 159 1 After after IN 37231 159 2 some some DT 37231 159 3 very very RB 37231 159 4 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 159 5 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 159 6 , , , 37231 159 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 159 8 says say VBZ 37231 159 9 that that IN 37231 159 10 no no DT 37231 159 11 one one NN 37231 159 12 who who WP 37231 159 13 carefully carefully RB 37231 159 14 considers consider VBZ 37231 159 15 the the DT 37231 159 16 points point NNS 37231 159 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 159 18 mentions mention VBZ 37231 159 19 can can MD 37231 159 20 think think VB 37231 159 21 that that IN 37231 159 22 the the DT 37231 159 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 159 24 are be VBP 37231 159 25 at at IN 37231 159 26 variance variance NN 37231 159 27 with with IN 37231 159 28 each each DT 37231 159 29 other other JJ 37231 159 30 , , , 37231 159 31 and and CC 37231 159 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 159 33 conjectures conjecture VBZ 37231 159 34 that that IN 37231 159 35 John John NNP 37231 159 36 probably probably RB 37231 159 37 omitted omit VBD 37231 159 38 the the DT 37231 159 39 genealogies genealogy NNS 37231 159 40 because because IN 37231 159 41 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 159 42 and and CC 37231 159 43 Luke Luke NNP 37231 159 44 had have VBD 37231 159 45 given give VBN 37231 159 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 159 47 . . . 37231 160 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 160 2 7 7 LS 37231 160 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 160 4 Without without IN 37231 160 5 further further RB 37231 160 6 anticipating anticipate VBG 37231 160 7 what what WP 37231 160 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 160 9 have have VBP 37231 160 10 to to TO 37231 160 11 say say VB 37231 160 12 when when WRB 37231 160 13 speaking speak VBG 37231 160 14 of of IN 37231 160 15 Papias Papias NNP 37231 160 16 , , , 37231 160 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 160 18 is be VBZ 37231 160 19 clear clear JJ 37231 160 20 , , , 37231 160 21 I -PRON- PRP 37231 160 22 think think VBP 37231 160 23 , , , 37231 160 24 that that IN 37231 160 25 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 160 26 , , , 37231 160 27 being be VBG 37231 160 28 aware aware JJ 37231 160 29 of of IN 37231 160 30 , , , 37231 160 31 and and CC 37231 160 32 interested interested JJ 37231 160 33 in in IN 37231 160 34 , , , 37231 160 35 the the DT 37231 160 36 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 160 37 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 160 38 connected connect VBN 37231 160 39 with with IN 37231 160 40 the the DT 37231 160 41 writings writing NNS 37231 160 42 attributed attribute VBN 37231 160 43 to to IN 37231 160 44 John John NNP 37231 160 45 , , , 37231 160 46 not not RB 37231 160 47 to to TO 37231 160 48 put put VB 37231 160 49 a a DT 37231 160 50 still still RB 37231 160 51 stronger strong JJR 37231 160 52 case case NN 37231 160 53 , , , 37231 160 54 and and CC 37231 160 55 quoting quote VBG 37231 160 56 traditions tradition NNS 37231 160 57 from from IN 37231 160 58 later later RB 37231 160 59 and and CC 37231 160 60 consequently consequently RB 37231 160 61 less less RBR 37231 160 62 weighty weighty JJ 37231 160 63 authorities authority NNS 37231 160 64 , , , 37231 160 65 would would MD 37231 160 66 certainly certainly RB 37231 160 67 have have VB 37231 160 68 recorded record VBN 37231 160 69 with with IN 37231 160 70 more more RBR 37231 160 71 special special JJ 37231 160 72 readiness readiness NN 37231 160 73 any any DT 37231 160 74 information information NN 37231 160 75 on on IN 37231 160 76 the the DT 37231 160 77 subject subject NN 37231 160 78 given give VBN 37231 160 79 by by IN 37231 160 80 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 160 81 , , , 37231 160 82 whom whom WP 37231 160 83 he -PRON- PRP 37231 160 84 so so RB 37231 160 85 frequently frequently RB 37231 160 86 lays lay VBZ 37231 160 87 under under IN 37231 160 88 contribution contribution NN 37231 160 89 , , , 37231 160 90 had have VBD 37231 160 91 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 160 92 writings writing NNS 37231 160 93 contained contain VBN 37231 160 94 any any DT 37231 160 95 . . . 37231 161 1 { { -LRB- 37231 161 2 xxi xxi NNP 37231 161 3 } } -RRB- 37231 161 4 In in IN 37231 161 5 regard regard NN 37231 161 6 to to IN 37231 161 7 Papias Papias NNP 37231 161 8 the the DT 37231 161 9 case case NN 37231 161 10 is be VBZ 37231 161 11 still still RB 37231 161 12 clearer clear JJR 37231 161 13 . . . 37231 162 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 162 2 find find VBP 37231 162 3 that that IN 37231 162 4 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 162 5 quotes quote VBZ 37231 162 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 162 7 account account NN 37231 162 8 of of IN 37231 162 9 the the DT 37231 162 10 composition composition NN 37231 162 11 of of IN 37231 162 12 Gospels Gospels NNP 37231 162 13 by by IN 37231 162 14 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 162 15 and and CC 37231 162 16 Mark,(1 Mark,(1 NNP 37231 162 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 162 18 although although IN 37231 162 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 162 20 had have VBD 37231 162 21 already already RB 37231 162 22 given give VBN 37231 162 23 a a DT 37231 162 24 closely closely RB 37231 162 25 similar similar JJ 37231 162 26 narrative narrative NN 37231 162 27 regarding regard VBG 37231 162 28 Mark Mark NNP 37231 162 29 from from IN 37231 162 30 Clement Clement NNP 37231 162 31 of of IN 37231 162 32 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 162 33 , , , 37231 162 34 and and CC 37231 162 35 appealed appeal VBD 37231 162 36 to to IN 37231 162 37 Papias Papias NNP 37231 162 38 in in IN 37231 162 39 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 162 40 of of IN 37231 162 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 162 42 . . . 37231 163 1 Is be VBZ 37231 163 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 163 3 either either CC 37231 163 4 possible possible JJ 37231 163 5 or or CC 37231 163 6 permissible permissible JJ 37231 163 7 to to TO 37231 163 8 suppose suppose VB 37231 163 9 that that DT 37231 163 10 , , , 37231 163 11 had have VBD 37231 163 12 Papias Papias NNP 37231 163 13 known know VBN 37231 163 14 anything anything NN 37231 163 15 of of IN 37231 163 16 the the DT 37231 163 17 other other JJ 37231 163 18 two two CD 37231 163 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 163 20 , , , 37231 163 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 163 22 would would MD 37231 163 23 not not RB 37231 163 24 have have VB 37231 163 25 inquired inquire VBN 37231 163 26 about about IN 37231 163 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 163 28 from from IN 37231 163 29 the the DT 37231 163 30 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 37231 163 31 and and CC 37231 163 32 recorded record VBD 37231 163 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 163 34 information information NN 37231 163 35 ? ? . 37231 164 1 And and CC 37231 164 2 is be VBZ 37231 164 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 164 4 either either CC 37231 164 5 possible possible JJ 37231 164 6 or or CC 37231 164 7 permissible permissible JJ 37231 164 8 to to TO 37231 164 9 suppose suppose VB 37231 164 10 that that IN 37231 164 11 if if IN 37231 164 12 Papias Papias NNP 37231 164 13 had have VBD 37231 164 14 recorded record VBN 37231 164 15 any any DT 37231 164 16 similar similar JJ 37231 164 17 information information NN 37231 164 18 regarding regard VBG 37231 164 19 the the DT 37231 164 20 composition composition NN 37231 164 21 of of IN 37231 164 22 the the DT 37231 164 23 third third JJ 37231 164 24 and and CC 37231 164 25 fourth fourth JJ 37231 164 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 164 27 , , , 37231 164 28 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 164 29 would would MD 37231 164 30 have have VB 37231 164 31 omitted omit VBN 37231 164 32 to to TO 37231 164 33 quote quote VB 37231 164 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 164 35 ? ? . 37231 165 1 Certainly certainly RB 37231 165 2 not not RB 37231 165 3 ; ; : 37231 165 4 and and CC 37231 165 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 165 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 165 7 's 's POS 37231 165 8 article article NN 37231 165 9 proves prove VBZ 37231 165 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 165 11 . . . 37231 166 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 166 2 had have VBD 37231 166 3 not not RB 37231 166 4 only only RB 37231 166 5 pledged pledge VBN 37231 166 6 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 166 7 to to TO 37231 166 8 give give VB 37231 166 9 such such JJ 37231 166 10 information information NN 37231 166 11 , , , 37231 166 12 and and CC 37231 166 13 does do VBZ 37231 166 14 so so RB 37231 166 15 in in IN 37231 166 16 every every DT 37231 166 17 case case NN 37231 166 18 which which WDT 37231 166 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 166 20 can can MD 37231 166 21 test test VB 37231 166 22 , , , 37231 166 23 but but CC 37231 166 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 166 25 fulfils fulfil VBZ 37231 166 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 166 27 by by IN 37231 166 28 actually actually RB 37231 166 29 quoting quote VBG 37231 166 30 what what WP 37231 166 31 Papias Papias NNP 37231 166 32 had have VBD 37231 166 33 to to TO 37231 166 34 say say VB 37231 166 35 about about IN 37231 166 36 the the DT 37231 166 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 166 38 . . . 37231 167 1 Even even RB 37231 167 2 if if IN 37231 167 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 167 4 had have VBD 37231 167 5 been be VBN 37231 167 6 careless careless JJ 37231 167 7 , , , 37231 167 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 167 9 very very JJ 37231 167 10 reference reference NN 37231 167 11 to to IN 37231 167 12 the the DT 37231 167 13 first first JJ 37231 167 14 two two CD 37231 167 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 167 16 must must MD 37231 167 17 have have VB 37231 167 18 reminded remind VBN 37231 167 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 167 20 of of IN 37231 167 21 the the DT 37231 167 22 claims claim NNS 37231 167 23 of of IN 37231 167 24 the the DT 37231 167 25 rest rest NN 37231 167 26 . . . 37231 168 1 There there EX 37231 168 2 are be VBP 37231 168 3 , , , 37231 168 4 however however RB 37231 168 5 , , , 37231 168 6 special special JJ 37231 168 7 reasons reason NNS 37231 168 8 which which WDT 37231 168 9 render render VBP 37231 168 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 168 11 still still RB 37231 168 12 more more RBR 37231 168 13 certain certain JJ 37231 168 14 that that WDT 37231 168 15 had have VBD 37231 168 16 Papias Papias NNP 37231 168 17 had have VBD 37231 168 18 anything anything NN 37231 168 19 to to TO 37231 168 20 tell tell VB 37231 168 21 about about IN 37231 168 22 the the DT 37231 168 23 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 168 24 Gospel,--and Gospel,--and NNP 37231 168 25 if if IN 37231 168 26 there there EX 37231 168 27 was be VBD 37231 168 28 a a DT 37231 168 29 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 168 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 168 31 in in IN 37231 168 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 168 33 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 168 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 168 35 must must MD 37231 168 36 have have VB 37231 168 37 had have VBN 37231 168 38 something something NN 37231 168 39 to to TO 37231 168 40 tell tell VB 37231 168 41 about about IN 37231 168 42 it,--Eusebius it,--Eusebius NNP 37231 168 43 would would MD 37231 168 44 have have VB 37231 168 45 recorded record VBN 37231 168 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 168 47 . . . 37231 169 1 The the DT 37231 169 2 first first JJ 37231 169 3 quotation quotation NN 37231 169 4 which which WDT 37231 169 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 169 6 makes make VBZ 37231 169 7 from from IN 37231 169 8 Papias Papias NNP 37231 169 9 is be VBZ 37231 169 10 the the DT 37231 169 11 passage passage NN 37231 169 12 in in IN 37231 169 13 which which WDT 37231 169 14 the the DT 37231 169 15 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 169 16 of of IN 37231 169 17 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 37231 169 18 states state VBZ 37231 169 19 the the DT 37231 169 20 interest interest NN 37231 169 21 with with IN 37231 169 22 which which WDT 37231 169 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 169 24 had have VBD 37231 169 25 inquired inquire VBN 37231 169 26 about about IN 37231 169 27 the the DT 37231 169 28 words word NNS 37231 169 29 of of IN 37231 169 30 the the DT 37231 169 31 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 37231 169 32 , , , 37231 169 33 " " '' 37231 169 34 what what WP 37231 169 35 John John NNP 37231 169 36 or or CC 37231 169 37 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 169 38 or or CC 37231 169 39 what what WP 37231 169 40 any any DT 37231 169 41 other other JJ 37231 169 42 of of IN 37231 169 43 the the DT 37231 169 44 disciples disciple NNS 37231 169 45 of of IN 37231 169 46 the the DT 37231 169 47 Lord Lord NNP 37231 169 48 said say VBD 37231 169 49 , , , 37231 169 50 and and CC 37231 169 51 what what WP 37231 169 52 Aristion Aristion NNP 37231 169 53 and and CC 37231 169 54 the the DT 37231 169 55 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 169 56 John John NNP 37231 169 57 , , , 37231 169 58 disciples disciple NNS 37231 169 59 of of IN 37231 169 60 the the DT 37231 169 61 Lord Lord NNP 37231 169 62 , , , 37231 169 63 1 1 CD 37231 169 64 I -PRON- PRP 37231 169 65 am be VBP 37231 169 66 much much RB 37231 169 67 obliged oblige VBN 37231 169 68 to to IN 37231 169 69 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 169 70 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 169 71 for for IN 37231 169 72 calling call VBG 37231 169 73 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 169 74 attention attention NN 37231 169 75 to to IN 37231 169 76 the the DT 37231 169 77 accidental accidental JJ 37231 169 78 insertion insertion NN 37231 169 79 of of IN 37231 169 80 the the DT 37231 169 81 words word NNS 37231 169 82 " " '' 37231 169 83 and and CC 37231 169 84 the the DT 37231 169 85 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 169 86 " " '' 37231 169 87 ( ( -LRB- 37231 169 88 S. S. NNP 37231 169 89 E. E. NNP 37231 169 90 i. i. NNP 37231 169 91 p. p. NN 37231 169 92 433 433 CD 37231 169 93 ) ) -RRB- 37231 169 94 . . . 37231 170 1 This this DT 37231 170 2 was be VBD 37231 170 3 a a DT 37231 170 4 mere mere JJ 37231 170 5 slip slip NN 37231 170 6 of of IN 37231 170 7 the the DT 37231 170 8 pen pen NN 37231 170 9 , , , 37231 170 10 of of IN 37231 170 11 which which WDT 37231 170 12 no no DT 37231 170 13 use use NN 37231 170 14 is be VBZ 37231 170 15 made make VBN 37231 170 16 , , , 37231 170 17 and and CC 37231 170 18 the the DT 37231 170 19 error error NN 37231 170 20 is be VBZ 37231 170 21 effectually effectually RB 37231 170 22 corrected correct VBN 37231 170 23 by by IN 37231 170 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 170 25 own own JJ 37231 170 26 distinct distinct JJ 37231 170 27 statements statement NNS 37231 170 28 . . . 37231 171 1 VOL VOL NNP 37231 171 2 . . . 37231 172 1 I. I. NNP 37231 173 1 { { -LRB- 37231 173 2 xxii xxii NNP 37231 173 3 } } -RRB- 37231 173 4 say say VBP 37231 173 5 . . . 37231 174 1 " " `` 37231 174 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 174 3 l l NN 37231 174 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 174 5 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 174 6 observes observe VBZ 37231 174 7 , , , 37231 174 8 and and CC 37231 174 9 particularly particularly RB 37231 174 10 points point VBZ 37231 174 11 out out RP 37231 174 12 , , , 37231 174 13 that that IN 37231 174 14 the the DT 37231 174 15 name name NN 37231 174 16 of of IN 37231 174 17 John John NNP 37231 174 18 is be VBZ 37231 174 19 twice twice RB 37231 174 20 mentioned mention VBN 37231 174 21 in in IN 37231 174 22 the the DT 37231 174 23 passage passage NN 37231 174 24 , , , 37231 174 25 the the DT 37231 174 26 former former JJ 37231 174 27 , , , 37231 174 28 mentioned mention VBN 37231 174 29 with with IN 37231 174 30 Peter Peter NNP 37231 174 31 , , , 37231 174 32 James James NNP 37231 174 33 , , , 37231 174 34 and and CC 37231 174 35 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 174 36 , , , 37231 174 37 and and CC 37231 174 38 other other JJ 37231 174 39 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 174 40 , , , 37231 174 41 evidently evidently RB 37231 174 42 being be VBG 37231 174 43 , , , 37231 174 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 174 45 thinks think VBZ 37231 174 46 , , , 37231 174 47 the the DT 37231 174 48 Evangelist Evangelist NNP 37231 174 49 , , , 37231 174 50 and and CC 37231 174 51 the the DT 37231 174 52 latter latter JJ 37231 174 53 being be VBG 37231 174 54 clearly clearly RB 37231 174 55 distinguished distinguish VBN 37231 174 56 by by IN 37231 174 57 the the DT 37231 174 58 designation designation NN 37231 174 59 of of IN 37231 174 60 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 174 61 . . . 37231 175 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 175 2 states state VBZ 37231 175 3 that that IN 37231 175 4 this this DT 37231 175 5 proves prove VBZ 37231 175 6 the the DT 37231 175 7 truth truth NN 37231 175 8 of of IN 37231 175 9 the the DT 37231 175 10 assertion assertion NN 37231 175 11 that that IN 37231 175 12 there there EX 37231 175 13 were be VBD 37231 175 14 two two CD 37231 175 15 men man NNS 37231 175 16 of of IN 37231 175 17 the the DT 37231 175 18 name name NN 37231 175 19 of of IN 37231 175 20 John John NNP 37231 175 21 in in IN 37231 175 22 Asia Asia NNP 37231 175 23 , , , 37231 175 24 and and CC 37231 175 25 that that IN 37231 175 26 two two CD 37231 175 27 tombs tomb NNS 37231 175 28 were be VBD 37231 175 29 still still RB 37231 175 30 shown show VBN 37231 175 31 at at IN 37231 175 32 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 37231 175 33 bearing bear VBG 37231 175 34 the the DT 37231 175 35 name name NN 37231 175 36 of of IN 37231 175 37 John John NNP 37231 175 38 . . . 37231 176 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 176 2 then then RB 37231 176 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 176 4 to to TO 37231 176 5 argue argue VB 37231 176 6 that that IN 37231 176 7 probably probably RB 37231 176 8 the the DT 37231 176 9 second second JJ 37231 176 10 of of IN 37231 176 11 the the DT 37231 176 12 two two CD 37231 176 13 Johns Johns NNP 37231 176 14 , , , 37231 176 15 if if IN 37231 176 16 not not RB 37231 176 17 the the DT 37231 176 18 first first JJ 37231 176 19 , , , 37231 176 20 was be VBD 37231 176 21 the the DT 37231 176 22 man man NN 37231 176 23 who who WP 37231 176 24 saw see VBD 37231 176 25 the the DT 37231 176 26 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 176 27 . . . 37231 177 1 What what WDT 37231 177 2 an an DT 37231 177 3 occasion occasion NN 37231 177 4 for for IN 37231 177 5 quoting quote VBG 37231 177 6 any any DT 37231 177 7 information information NN 37231 177 8 bearing bear VBG 37231 177 9 at at RB 37231 177 10 all all RB 37231 177 11 on on IN 37231 177 12 the the DT 37231 177 13 subject subject NN 37231 177 14 from from IN 37231 177 15 Papias Papias NNP 37231 177 16 , , , 37231 177 17 who who WP 37231 177 18 had have VBD 37231 177 19 questioned question VBN 37231 177 20 those those DT 37231 177 21 who who WP 37231 177 22 had have VBD 37231 177 23 been be VBN 37231 177 24 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 177 25 with with IN 37231 177 26 both both DT 37231 177 27 ! ! . 37231 178 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 178 2 attention attention NN 37231 178 3 is be VBZ 37231 178 4 so so RB 37231 178 5 pointedly pointedly RB 37231 178 6 turned turn VBN 37231 178 7 to to IN 37231 178 8 John John NNP 37231 178 9 at at IN 37231 178 10 the the DT 37231 178 11 very very JJ 37231 178 12 moment moment NN 37231 178 13 when when WRB 37231 178 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 178 15 makes make VBZ 37231 178 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 178 17 quotations quotation NNS 37231 178 18 regarding regard VBG 37231 178 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 178 20 and and CC 37231 178 21 Mark Mark NNP 37231 178 22 , , , 37231 178 23 that that IN 37231 178 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 178 25 am be VBP 37231 178 26 fully fully RB 37231 178 27 warranted warrant VBN 37231 178 28 , , , 37231 178 29 both both CC 37231 178 30 by by IN 37231 178 31 the the DT 37231 178 32 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 178 33 of of IN 37231 178 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 178 35 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 178 36 and and CC 37231 178 37 the the DT 37231 178 38 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 178 39 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 178 40 of of IN 37231 178 41 the the DT 37231 178 42 case case NN 37231 178 43 , , , 37231 178 44 in in IN 37231 178 45 affirming affirm VBG 37231 178 46 that that IN 37231 178 47 the the DT 37231 178 48 silence silence NN 37231 178 49 of of IN 37231 178 50 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 178 51 proves prove VBZ 37231 178 52 that that IN 37231 178 53 Papias Papias NNP 37231 178 54 said say VBD 37231 178 55 nothing nothing NN 37231 178 56 about about IN 37231 178 57 either either CC 37231 178 58 the the DT 37231 178 59 third third JJ 37231 178 60 or or CC 37231 178 61 fourth fourth JJ 37231 178 62 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 178 63 . . . 37231 179 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 179 2 need need VBP 37231 179 3 not not RB 37231 179 4 go go VB 37231 179 5 on on RP 37231 179 6 to to TO 37231 179 7 discuss discuss VB 37231 179 8 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 179 9 of of IN 37231 179 10 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 179 11 , , , 37231 179 12 for for IN 37231 179 13 the the DT 37231 179 14 same same JJ 37231 179 15 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 179 16 equally equally RB 37231 179 17 applies apply VBZ 37231 179 18 to to IN 37231 179 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 179 20 case case NN 37231 179 21 . . . 37231 180 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 180 2 have have VBP 37231 180 3 , , , 37231 180 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 180 5 , , , 37231 180 6 only only RB 37231 180 7 a a DT 37231 180 8 very very RB 37231 180 9 few few JJ 37231 180 10 more more JJR 37231 180 11 words word NNS 37231 180 12 to to TO 37231 180 13 say say VB 37231 180 14 on on IN 37231 180 15 the the DT 37231 180 16 subject subject NN 37231 180 17 of of IN 37231 180 18 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 180 19 . . . 37231 181 1 Not not RB 37231 181 2 content content JJ 37231 181 3 with with IN 37231 181 4 what what WP 37231 181 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 181 6 intended intend VBD 37231 181 7 to to TO 37231 181 8 be be VB 37231 181 9 destructive destructive JJ 37231 181 10 criticism criticism NN 37231 181 11 , , , 37231 181 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 181 13 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 181 14 valiantly valiantly RB 37231 181 15 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 181 16 to to IN 37231 181 17 the the DT 37231 181 18 constructive constructive JJ 37231 181 19 and and CC 37231 181 20 , , , 37231 181 21 " " '' 37231 181 22 as as IN 37231 181 23 a a DT 37231 181 24 sober sober JJ 37231 181 25 deduction deduction NN 37231 181 26 from from IN 37231 181 27 facts fact NNS 37231 181 28 , , , 37231 181 29 " " '' 37231 181 30 makes make VBZ 37231 181 31 the the DT 37231 181 32 following follow VBG 37231 181 33 statement statement NN 37231 181 34 , , , 37231 181 35 which which WDT 37231 181 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 181 37 prints print VBZ 37231 181 38 in in IN 37231 181 39 italics italic NNS 37231 181 40 : : : 37231 181 41 _ _ NNP 37231 181 42 " " `` 37231 181 43 The the DT 37231 181 44 silence silence NN 37231 181 45 of of IN 37231 181 46 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 181 47 _ _ NNP 37231 181 48 respecting respect VBG 37231 181 49 early early JJ 37231 181 50 witnesses witness NNS 37231 181 51 to to IN 37231 181 52 the the DT 37231 181 53 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 181 54 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 181 55 is be VBZ 37231 181 56 an an DT 37231 181 57 evidence evidence NN 37231 181 58 in in IN 37231 181 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 181 60 favour favour NN 37231 181 61 . . . 37231 182 1 " " `` 37231 182 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 182 3 2 2 LS 37231 182 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 182 5 Now now RB 37231 182 6 , , , 37231 182 7 interpreted interpret VBN 37231 182 8 even even RB 37231 182 9 by by IN 37231 182 10 the the DT 37231 182 11 rules rule NNS 37231 182 12 laid lay VBN 37231 182 13 down down RP 37231 182 14 ( ( -LRB- 37231 182 15 xxiii xxiii NN 37231 182 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 182 17 by by IN 37231 182 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 182 19 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 182 20 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 182 21 , , , 37231 182 22 what what WP 37231 182 23 does do VBZ 37231 182 24 this this DT 37231 182 25 silence silence NN 37231 182 26 really really RB 37231 182 27 mean mean VB 37231 182 28 ? ? . 37231 183 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 183 2 means mean VBZ 37231 183 3 , , , 37231 183 4 not not RB 37231 183 5 that that IN 37231 183 6 the the DT 37231 183 7 early early JJ 37231 183 8 writers writer NNS 37231 183 9 about about IN 37231 183 10 whom whom WP 37231 183 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 183 12 is be VBZ 37231 183 13 supposed suppose VBN 37231 183 14 to to TO 37231 183 15 be be VB 37231 183 16 silent silent JJ 37231 183 17 are be VBP 37231 183 18 witnesses witness NNS 37231 183 19 about about IN 37231 183 20 anything anything NN 37231 183 21 connected connect VBN 37231 183 22 with with IN 37231 183 23 the the DT 37231 183 24 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 183 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 183 26 , , , 37231 183 27 but but CC 37231 183 28 simply simply RB 37231 183 29 that that IN 37231 183 30 if if IN 37231 183 31 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 183 32 noticed notice VBD 37231 183 33 and and CC 37231 183 34 did do VBD 37231 183 35 not not RB 37231 183 36 record record VB 37231 183 37 the the DT 37231 183 38 mere mere JJ 37231 183 39 use use NN 37231 183 40 of of IN 37231 183 41 that that DT 37231 183 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 183 43 by by IN 37231 183 44 any any DT 37231 183 45 one one CD 37231 183 46 , , , 37231 183 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 183 48 thereby thereby RB 37231 183 49 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 183 50 that that IN 37231 183 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 183 52 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 183 53 , , , 37231 183 54 in in IN 37231 183 55 the the DT 37231 183 56 fourth fourth JJ 37231 183 57 century century NN 37231 183 58 , , , 37231 183 59 classed class VBD 37231 183 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 183 61 amongst amongst IN 37231 183 62 the the DT 37231 183 63 undisputed undisputed JJ 37231 183 64 books book NNS 37231 183 65 , , , 37231 183 66 the the DT 37231 183 67 mere mere JJ 37231 183 68 use use NN 37231 183 69 of of IN 37231 183 70 which which WDT 37231 183 71 he -PRON- PRP 37231 183 72 does do VBZ 37231 183 73 not not RB 37231 183 74 undertake undertake VB 37231 183 75 to to TO 37231 183 76 mention mention VB 37231 183 77 . . . 37231 184 1 The the DT 37231 184 2 value value NN 37231 184 3 of of IN 37231 184 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 184 5 opinion opinion NN 37231 184 6 at at IN 37231 184 7 so so RB 37231 184 8 late late RB 37231 184 9 a a DT 37231 184 10 date date NN 37231 184 11 is be VBZ 37231 184 12 very very RB 37231 184 13 small small JJ 37231 184 14 . . . 37231 185 1 Professor Professor NNP 37231 185 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 185 3 next next RB 37231 185 4 makes make VBZ 37231 185 5 a a DT 37231 185 6 vehement vehement JJ 37231 185 7 attack attack NN 37231 185 8 upon upon IN 37231 185 9 me -PRON- PRP 37231 185 10 in in IN 37231 185 11 connection connection NN 37231 185 12 with with IN 37231 185 13 " " `` 37231 185 14 The the DT 37231 185 15 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 185 16 Epistles,"(1 epistles,"(1 NN 37231 185 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 185 18 which which WDT 37231 185 19 is be VBZ 37231 185 20 equally equally RB 37231 185 21 abortive abortive JJ 37231 185 22 and and CC 37231 185 23 limited limited JJ 37231 185 24 to to IN 37231 185 25 details detail NNS 37231 185 26 . . . 37231 186 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 186 2 do do VBP 37231 186 3 not not RB 37231 186 4 intend intend VB 37231 186 5 to to TO 37231 186 6 complain complain VB 37231 186 7 of of IN 37231 186 8 the the DT 37231 186 9 spirit spirit NN 37231 186 10 in in IN 37231 186 11 which which WDT 37231 186 12 the the DT 37231 186 13 article article NN 37231 186 14 is be VBZ 37231 186 15 written write VBN 37231 186 16 , , , 37231 186 17 nor nor CC 37231 186 18 of of IN 37231 186 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 186 20 unfairness unfairness NN 37231 186 21 . . . 37231 187 1 On on IN 37231 187 2 the the DT 37231 187 3 whole whole NN 37231 187 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 187 5 think think VBP 37231 187 6 that that IN 37231 187 7 readers reader NNS 37231 187 8 may may MD 37231 187 9 safely safely RB 37231 187 10 be be VB 37231 187 11 left leave VBN 37231 187 12 to to TO 37231 187 13 judge judge VB 37231 187 14 of of IN 37231 187 15 the the DT 37231 187 16 tone tone NN 37231 187 17 in in IN 37231 187 18 which which WDT 37231 187 19 a a DT 37231 187 20 controversy controversy NN 37231 187 21 is be VBZ 37231 187 22 carried carry VBN 37231 187 23 on on RP 37231 187 24 . . . 37231 188 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 37231 188 2 , , , 37231 188 3 however however RB 37231 188 4 , , , 37231 188 5 the the DT 37231 188 6 perpetual perpetual JJ 37231 188 7 accusation accusation NN 37231 188 8 of of IN 37231 188 9 mis mis NNP 37231 188 10 - - HYPH 37231 188 11 statement statement NN 37231 188 12 brought bring VBD 37231 188 13 against against IN 37231 188 14 me -PRON- PRP 37231 188 15 in in IN 37231 188 16 this this DT 37231 188 17 article article NN 37231 188 18 , , , 37231 188 19 and and CC 37231 188 20 based base VBN 37231 188 21 upon upon IN 37231 188 22 minute minute JJ 37231 188 23 criticism criticism NN 37231 188 24 into into IN 37231 188 25 which which WDT 37231 188 26 few few JJ 37231 188 27 care care NN 37231 188 28 to to TO 37231 188 29 follow follow VB 37231 188 30 , , , 37231 188 31 is be VBZ 37231 188 32 apt apt JJ 37231 188 33 to to TO 37231 188 34 leave leave VB 37231 188 35 the the DT 37231 188 36 impression impression NN 37231 188 37 that that IN 37231 188 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 188 39 is be VBZ 37231 188 40 well well RB 37231 188 41 - - HYPH 37231 188 42 founded found VBN 37231 188 43 , , , 37231 188 44 for for IN 37231 188 45 there there EX 37231 188 46 is be VBZ 37231 188 47 the the DT 37231 188 48 very very RB 37231 188 49 natural natural JJ 37231 188 50 feeling feeling NN 37231 188 51 in in IN 37231 188 52 most most JJS 37231 188 53 right right JJ 37231 188 54 minds mind NNS 37231 188 55 that that WDT 37231 188 56 no no DT 37231 188 57 one one NN 37231 188 58 would would MD 37231 188 59 recklessly recklessly RB 37231 188 60 scatter scatter VB 37231 188 61 such such JJ 37231 188 62 insinuations insinuation NNS 37231 188 63 . . . 37231 189 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 189 2 is be VBZ 37231 189 3 this this DT 37231 189 4 which which WDT 37231 189 5 alone alone RB 37231 189 6 makes make VBZ 37231 189 7 such such PDT 37231 189 8 an an DT 37231 189 9 attack attack NN 37231 189 10 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 189 11 . . . 37231 190 1 Now now RB 37231 190 2 in in IN 37231 190 3 a a DT 37231 190 4 work work NN 37231 190 5 like like IN 37231 190 6 this this DT 37231 190 7 , , , 37231 190 8 dealing deal VBG 37231 190 9 with with IN 37231 190 10 so so RB 37231 190 11 many many JJ 37231 190 12 details detail NNS 37231 190 13 , , , 37231 190 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 190 15 must must MD 37231 190 16 be be VB 37231 190 17 obvious obvious JJ 37231 190 18 that that IN 37231 190 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 190 20 is be VBZ 37231 190 21 not not RB 37231 190 22 possible possible JJ 37231 190 23 altogether altogether RB 37231 190 24 to to TO 37231 190 25 escape escape VB 37231 190 26 errors error NNS 37231 190 27 . . . 37231 191 1 A a DT 37231 191 2 critic critic NN 37231 191 3 or or CC 37231 191 4 opponent opponent NN 37231 191 5 is be VBZ 37231 191 6 of of IN 37231 191 7 course course NN 37231 191 8 entitled entitle VBN 37231 191 9 to to TO 37231 191 10 point point VB 37231 191 11 these these DT 37231 191 12 out out RP 37231 191 13 , , , 37231 191 14 although although IN 37231 191 15 , , , 37231 191 16 if if IN 37231 191 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 191 18 be be VB 37231 191 19 high high RB 37231 191 20 - - HYPH 37231 191 21 minded minded JJ 37231 191 22 or or CC 37231 191 23 even even RB 37231 191 24 alive alive JJ 37231 191 25 to to IN 37231 191 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 191 27 own own JJ 37231 191 28 interests interest NNS 37231 191 29 , , , 37231 191 30 I -PRON- PRP 37231 191 31 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 191 32 think think VBP 37231 191 33 that that IN 37231 191 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 191 35 will will MD 37231 191 36 do do VB 37231 191 37 so so RB 37231 191 38 in in IN 37231 191 39 a a DT 37231 191 40 spirit spirit NN 37231 191 41 of of IN 37231 191 42 unfair unfair JJ 37231 191 43 detraction detraction NN 37231 191 44 . . . 37231 192 1 But but CC 37231 192 2 in in IN 37231 192 3 doing do VBG 37231 192 4 this this DT 37231 192 5 a a DT 37231 192 6 writer writer NN 37231 192 7 is be VBZ 37231 192 8 bound bind VBN 37231 192 9 to to TO 37231 192 10 be be VB 37231 192 11 accurate accurate JJ 37231 192 12 , , , 37231 192 13 for for CC 37231 192 14 if if IN 37231 192 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 192 16 be be VB 37231 192 17 liberal liberal JJ 37231 192 18 of of IN 37231 192 19 such such JJ 37231 192 20 accusations accusation NNS 37231 192 21 { { -LRB- 37231 192 22 xxiv xxiv NNP 37231 192 23 } } -RRB- 37231 192 24 and and CC 37231 192 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 192 26 can can MD 37231 192 27 be be VB 37231 192 28 shown show VBN 37231 192 29 that that IN 37231 192 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 192 31 charges charge NNS 37231 192 32 are be VBP 37231 192 33 unfounded unfounded JJ 37231 192 34 , , , 37231 192 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 192 36 recoil recoil VBP 37231 192 37 with with IN 37231 192 38 double double JJ 37231 192 39 force force NN 37231 192 40 upon upon IN 37231 192 41 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 192 42 . . . 37231 193 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 193 2 propose propose VBP 37231 193 3 , , , 37231 193 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 193 5 , , , 37231 193 6 as as IN 37231 193 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 193 8 is be VBZ 37231 193 9 impossible impossible JJ 37231 193 10 for for IN 37231 193 11 me -PRON- PRP 37231 193 12 to to TO 37231 193 13 reply reply VB 37231 193 14 to to IN 37231 193 15 all all DT 37231 193 16 such such JJ 37231 193 17 attacks attack NNS 37231 193 18 , , , 37231 193 19 to to TO 37231 193 20 follow follow VB 37231 193 21 Professor Professor NNP 37231 193 22 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 193 23 and and CC 37231 193 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 193 25 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 193 26 with with IN 37231 193 27 some some DT 37231 193 28 minuteness minuteness NN 37231 193 29 in in IN 37231 193 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 193 31 discussion discussion NN 37231 193 32 of of IN 37231 193 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 193 34 treatment treatment NN 37231 193 35 of of IN 37231 193 36 the the DT 37231 193 37 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 193 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 193 39 , , , 37231 193 40 and and CC 37231 193 41 once once RB 37231 193 42 for for IN 37231 193 43 all all DT 37231 193 44 to to TO 37231 193 45 show show VB 37231 193 46 the the DT 37231 193 47 grave grave JJ 37231 193 48 mis mis NN 37231 193 49 - - HYPH 37231 193 50 statements statement NNS 37231 193 51 to to TO 37231 193 52 which which WDT 37231 193 53 they -PRON- PRP 37231 193 54 commit commit VBP 37231 193 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 193 56 . . . 37231 194 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 194 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 194 3 does do VBZ 37231 194 4 not not RB 37231 194 5 ignore ignore VB 37231 194 6 the the DT 37231 194 7 character character NN 37231 194 8 of of IN 37231 194 9 the the DT 37231 194 10 discussion discussion NN 37231 194 11 upon upon IN 37231 194 12 which which WDT 37231 194 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 194 14 enters enter VBZ 37231 194 15 , , , 37231 194 16 but but CC 37231 194 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 194 18 will will MD 37231 194 19 be be VB 37231 194 20 seen see VBN 37231 194 21 that that IN 37231 194 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 194 23 appreciation appreciation NN 37231 194 24 of of IN 37231 194 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 194 26 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 194 27 by by IN 37231 194 28 no no DT 37231 194 29 means means NN 37231 194 30 inspires inspire VBZ 37231 194 31 him -PRON- PRP 37231 194 32 with with IN 37231 194 33 charitable charitable JJ 37231 194 34 emotions emotion NNS 37231 194 35 . . . 37231 195 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 195 2 says say VBZ 37231 195 3 : : : 37231 195 4 " " `` 37231 195 5 The the DT 37231 195 6 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 195 7 question question NN 37231 195 8 is be VBZ 37231 195 9 the the DT 37231 195 10 most most RBS 37231 195 11 perplexing perplexing JJ 37231 195 12 which which WDT 37231 195 13 confronts confront VBZ 37231 195 14 the the DT 37231 195 15 student student NN 37231 195 16 of of IN 37231 195 17 earlier early JJR 37231 195 18 Christian christian JJ 37231 195 19 history history NN 37231 195 20 . . . 37231 196 1 The the DT 37231 196 2 literature literature NN 37231 196 3 is be VBZ 37231 196 4 voluminous voluminous JJ 37231 196 5 ; ; : 37231 196 6 the the DT 37231 196 7 considerations consideration NNS 37231 196 8 involved involve VBN 37231 196 9 are be VBP 37231 196 10 very very RB 37231 196 11 wide wide JJ 37231 196 12 , , , 37231 196 13 very very RB 37231 196 14 varied varied JJ 37231 196 15 , , , 37231 196 16 and and CC 37231 196 17 very very RB 37231 196 18 intricate intricate JJ 37231 196 19 . . . 37231 197 1 A a DT 37231 197 2 writer writer NN 37231 197 3 , , , 37231 197 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 197 5 , , , 37231 197 6 may may MD 37231 197 7 well well RB 37231 197 8 be be VB 37231 197 9 pardoned pardon VBN 37231 197 10 if if IN 37231 197 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 197 12 betrays betray VBZ 37231 197 13 a a DT 37231 197 14 want want NN 37231 197 15 of of IN 37231 197 16 familiarity familiarity NN 37231 197 17 with with IN 37231 197 18 this this DT 37231 197 19 subject subject NN 37231 197 20 But but CC 37231 197 21 in in IN 37231 197 22 this this DT 37231 197 23 case case NN 37231 197 24 the the DT 37231 197 25 reader reader NN 37231 197 26 naturally naturally RB 37231 197 27 expects expect VBZ 37231 197 28 that that IN 37231 197 29 the the DT 37231 197 30 opinions opinion NNS 37231 197 31 at at IN 37231 197 32 which which WDT 37231 197 33 he -PRON- PRP 37231 197 34 has have VBZ 37231 197 35 arrived arrive VBN 37231 197 36 will will MD 37231 197 37 be be VB 37231 197 38 stated state VBN 37231 197 39 with with IN 37231 197 40 some some DT 37231 197 41 diffidence diffidence NN 37231 197 42 . . . 37231 198 1 " " `` 37231 198 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 198 3 1 1 LS 37231 198 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 198 5 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 198 6 critic critic NN 37231 198 7 objects object VBZ 37231 198 8 that that WDT 37231 198 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 198 10 express express VBP 37231 198 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 198 12 opinions opinion NNS 37231 198 13 with with IN 37231 198 14 decision decision NN 37231 198 15 . . . 37231 199 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 199 2 shall shall MD 37231 199 3 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 199 4 justify justify VB 37231 199 5 this this DT 37231 199 6 decision decision NN 37231 199 7 , , , 37231 199 8 but but CC 37231 199 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 199 10 would would MD 37231 199 11 here here RB 37231 199 12 point point VB 37231 199 13 out out RP 37231 199 14 that that IN 37231 199 15 the the DT 37231 199 16 very very JJ 37231 199 17 reasons reason NNS 37231 199 18 which which WDT 37231 199 19 render render VBP 37231 199 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 199 21 difficult difficult JJ 37231 199 22 for for IN 37231 199 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 199 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 199 25 to to TO 37231 199 26 form form VB 37231 199 27 a a DT 37231 199 28 final final JJ 37231 199 29 and and CC 37231 199 30 decisive decisive JJ 37231 199 31 judgment judgment NN 37231 199 32 on on IN 37231 199 33 the the DT 37231 199 34 question question NN 37231 199 35 make make VBP 37231 199 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 199 37 easy easy JJ 37231 199 38 for for IN 37231 199 39 me -PRON- PRP 37231 199 40 . . . 37231 200 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 200 2 requires require VBZ 37231 200 3 but but CC 37231 200 4 little little JJ 37231 200 5 logical logical JJ 37231 200 6 perception perception NN 37231 200 7 to to TO 37231 200 8 recognize recognize VB 37231 200 9 that that IN 37231 200 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 200 11 , , , 37231 200 12 the the DT 37231 200 13 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 200 14 of of IN 37231 200 15 which which WDT 37231 200 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 200 17 is be VBZ 37231 200 18 so so RB 37231 200 19 difficult difficult JJ 37231 200 20 to to TO 37231 200 21 establish establish VB 37231 200 22 , , , 37231 200 23 can can MD 37231 200 24 not not RB 37231 200 25 have have VB 37231 200 26 much much JJ 37231 200 27 influence influence NN 37231 200 28 as as IN 37231 200 29 testimony testimony NN 37231 200 30 for for IN 37231 200 31 the the DT 37231 200 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 200 33 . . . 37231 201 1 The the DT 37231 201 2 statement statement NN 37231 201 3 just just RB 37231 201 4 quoted quote VBD 37231 201 5 , , , 37231 201 6 however however RB 37231 201 7 , , , 37231 201 8 is be VBZ 37231 201 9 made make VBN 37231 201 10 the the DT 37231 201 11 base base NN 37231 201 12 of of IN 37231 201 13 the the DT 37231 201 14 attack attack NN 37231 201 15 , , , 37231 201 16 and and CC 37231 201 17 war war NN 37231 201 18 is be VBZ 37231 201 19 declared declare VBN 37231 201 20 in in IN 37231 201 21 the the DT 37231 201 22 following follow VBG 37231 201 23 terms:-- terms:-- JJS 37231 201 24 { { -LRB- 37231 201 25 xxv xxv NNP 37231 201 26 } } -RRB- 37231 201 27 " " `` 37231 201 28 The the DT 37231 201 29 reader reader NN 37231 201 30 is be VBZ 37231 201 31 naturally naturally RB 37231 201 32 led lead VBN 37231 201 33 to to TO 37231 201 34 think think VB 37231 201 35 that that IN 37231 201 36 a a DT 37231 201 37 writer writer NN 37231 201 38 would would MD 37231 201 39 not not RB 37231 201 40 use use VB 37231 201 41 such such JJ 37231 201 42 very very RB 37231 201 43 decided decided JJ 37231 201 44 language language NN 37231 201 45 unless unless IN 37231 201 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 201 47 had have VBD 37231 201 48 obtained obtain VBN 37231 201 49 a a DT 37231 201 50 thorough thorough JJ 37231 201 51 mastery mastery NN 37231 201 52 of of IN 37231 201 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 201 54 subject subject NN 37231 201 55 ; ; : 37231 201 56 and and CC 37231 201 57 when when WRB 37231 201 58 he -PRON- PRP 37231 201 59 finds find VBZ 37231 201 60 the the DT 37231 201 61 notes note NNS 37231 201 62 thronged throng VBD 37231 201 63 with with IN 37231 201 64 references reference NNS 37231 201 65 to to IN 37231 201 66 the the DT 37231 201 67 most most RBS 37231 201 68 recondite recondite JJ 37231 201 69 sources source NNS 37231 201 70 of of IN 37231 201 71 information information NN 37231 201 72 , , , 37231 201 73 he -PRON- PRP 37231 201 74 at at IN 37231 201 75 once once RB 37231 201 76 credits credit VBZ 37231 201 77 the the DT 37231 201 78 author author NN 37231 201 79 with with IN 37231 201 80 an an DT 37231 201 81 ' ' `` 37231 201 82 exhaustive exhaustive JJ 37231 201 83 ' ' '' 37231 201 84 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 201 85 of of IN 37231 201 86 the the DT 37231 201 87 literature literature NN 37231 201 88 bearing bear VBG 37231 201 89 upon upon IN 37231 201 90 it -PRON- PRP 37231 201 91 . . . 37231 202 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 202 2 becomes become VBZ 37231 202 3 important important JJ 37231 202 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 202 5 to to TO 37231 202 6 inquire inquire VB 37231 202 7 whether whether IN 37231 202 8 the the DT 37231 202 9 writer writer NN 37231 202 10 shows show VBZ 37231 202 11 that that IN 37231 202 12 accurate accurate JJ 37231 202 13 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 202 14 with with IN 37231 202 15 the the DT 37231 202 16 subject subject NN 37231 202 17 , , , 37231 202 18 which which WDT 37231 202 19 justifies justify VBZ 37231 202 20 us -PRON- PRP 37231 202 21 in in IN 37231 202 22 attaching attach VBG 37231 202 23 weight weight NN 37231 202 24 to to IN 37231 202 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 202 26 dicta dicta NN 37231 202 27 as as IN 37231 202 28 distinguished distinguish VBN 37231 202 29 from from IN 37231 202 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 202 31 arguments argument NNS 37231 202 32 . . . 37231 203 1 " " `` 37231 203 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 203 3 l l NN 37231 203 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 203 5 This this DT 37231 203 6 sentence sentence NN 37231 203 7 shows show VBZ 37231 203 8 the the DT 37231 203 9 scope scope NN 37231 203 10 of of IN 37231 203 11 the the DT 37231 203 12 discussion discussion NN 37231 203 13 . . . 37231 204 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 204 2 dicta dicta NN 37231 204 3 , , , 37231 204 4 however however RB 37231 204 5 , , , 37231 204 6 play play VB 37231 204 7 a a DT 37231 204 8 very very RB 37231 204 9 subordinate subordinate JJ 37231 204 10 part part NN 37231 204 11 throughout throughout IN 37231 204 12 , , , 37231 204 13 and and CC 37231 204 14 even even RB 37231 204 15 if if IN 37231 204 16 no no DT 37231 204 17 weight weight NN 37231 204 18 be be VB 37231 204 19 attached attach VBN 37231 204 20 to to IN 37231 204 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 204 22 , , , 37231 204 23 and and CC 37231 204 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 204 25 have have VBP 37231 204 26 never never RB 37231 204 27 desired desire VBN 37231 204 28 that that IN 37231 204 29 any any DT 37231 204 30 should should MD 37231 204 31 be be VB 37231 204 32 , , , 37231 204 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 204 34 argument argument NN 37231 204 35 would would MD 37231 204 36 not not RB 37231 204 37 be be VB 37231 204 38 in in IN 37231 204 39 the the DT 37231 204 40 least least JJS 37231 204 41 degree degree NN 37231 204 42 affected affect VBN 37231 204 43 . . . 37231 205 1 The the DT 37231 205 2 first first JJ 37231 205 3 point point NN 37231 205 4 attacked attack VBD 37231 205 5 , , , 37231 205 6 like like IN 37231 205 7 most most JJS 37231 205 8 of of IN 37231 205 9 those those DT 37231 205 10 subsequently subsequently RB 37231 205 11 assailed assail VBN 37231 205 12 , , , 37231 205 13 is be VBZ 37231 205 14 one one CD 37231 205 15 of of IN 37231 205 16 mere mere JJ 37231 205 17 critical critical JJ 37231 205 18 history history NN 37231 205 19 . . . 37231 206 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 206 2 wrote write VBD 37231 206 3 : : : 37231 206 4 " " `` 37231 206 5 The the DT 37231 206 6 strongest strong JJS 37231 206 7 internal internal JJ 37231 206 8 , , , 37231 206 9 as as RB 37231 206 10 well well RB 37231 206 11 as as IN 37231 206 12 other other JJ 37231 206 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 206 14 , , , 37231 206 15 into into IN 37231 206 16 which which WDT 37231 206 17 space space NN 37231 206 18 forbids forbid NNS 37231 206 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 206 20 going go VBG 37231 206 21 in in IN 37231 206 22 detail detail NN 37231 206 23 , , , 37231 206 24 has have VBZ 37231 206 25 led lead VBN 37231 206 26 ( ( -LRB- 37231 206 27 1 1 LS 37231 206 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 206 29 the the DT 37231 206 30 majority majority NN 37231 206 31 of of IN 37231 206 32 critics critic NNS 37231 206 33 to to TO 37231 206 34 recognize recognize VB 37231 206 35 the the DT 37231 206 36 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 206 37 version version NN 37231 206 38 as as IN 37231 206 39 the the DT 37231 206 40 most most RBS 37231 206 41 genuine genuine JJ 37231 206 42 form form NN 37231 206 43 of of IN 37231 206 44 the the DT 37231 206 45 letters letter NNS 37231 206 46 of of IN 37231 206 47 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 206 48 extant extant JJ 37231 206 49 , , , 37231 206 50 and and CC 37231 206 51 ( ( -LRB- 37231 206 52 2 2 LS 37231 206 53 ) ) -RRB- 37231 206 54 this this DT 37231 206 55 is be VBZ 37231 206 56 admitted admit VBN 37231 206 57 by by IN 37231 206 58 most most JJS 37231 206 59 of of IN 37231 206 60 those those DT 37231 206 61 who who WP 37231 206 62 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 206 63 deny deny VBP 37231 206 64 the the DT 37231 206 65 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 206 66 of of IN 37231 206 67 any any DT 37231 206 68 of of IN 37231 206 69 the the DT 37231 206 70 epistles epistle NNS 37231 206 71 . . . 37231 207 1 " " `` 37231 207 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 207 3 2 2 LS 37231 207 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 207 5 Upon upon IN 37231 207 6 this this DT 37231 207 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 207 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 207 9 remarks:-- remarks:-- VBZ 37231 207 10 " " `` 37231 207 11 No no DT 37231 207 12 statement statement NN 37231 207 13 could could MD 37231 207 14 be be VB 37231 207 15 more more RBR 37231 207 16 erroneous erroneous JJ 37231 207 17 as as IN 37231 207 18 a a DT 37231 207 19 summary summary NN 37231 207 20 of of IN 37231 207 21 the the DT 37231 207 22 results result NNS 37231 207 23 of of IN 37231 207 24 the the DT 37231 207 25 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 207 26 controversy controversy NN 37231 207 27 since since IN 37231 207 28 the the DT 37231 207 29 publication publication NN 37231 207 30 of of IN 37231 207 31 the the DT 37231 207 32 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 207 33 epistles epistle NNS 37231 207 34 than than IN 37231 207 35 this this DT 37231 207 36 . . . 37231 208 1 " " `` 37231 208 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 208 3 1 1 LS 37231 208 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 208 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 208 6 will will MD 37231 208 7 be be VB 37231 208 8 admitted admit VBN 37231 208 9 that that IN 37231 208 10 this this DT 37231 208 11 is be VBZ 37231 208 12 pretty pretty RB 37231 208 13 " " `` 37231 208 14 decided decided JJ 37231 208 15 language language NN 37231 208 16 " " '' 37231 208 17 for for IN 37231 208 18 one one CD 37231 208 19 who who WP 37231 208 20 is be VBZ 37231 208 21 preaching preach VBG 37231 208 22 " " `` 37231 208 23 diffidence diffidence NN 37231 208 24 . . . 37231 208 25 " " '' 37231 209 1 When when WRB 37231 209 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 209 3 come come VBP 37231 209 4 to to IN 37231 209 5 details detail NNS 37231 209 6 , , , 37231 209 7 however however RB 37231 209 8 , , , 37231 209 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 209 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 209 11 admits admit VBZ 37231 209 12 : : : 37231 209 13 " " `` 37231 209 14 Those those DT 37231 209 15 who who WP 37231 209 16 maintain maintain VBP 37231 209 17 the the DT 37231 209 18 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 209 19 of of IN 37231 209 20 the the DT 37231 209 21 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 209 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 209 23 in in IN 37231 209 24 one one CD 37231 209 25 or or CC 37231 209 26 other other JJ 37231 209 27 of of IN 37231 209 28 the the DT 37231 209 29 two two CD 37231 209 30 forms form NNS 37231 209 31 , , , 37231 209 32 may may MD 37231 209 33 be be VB 37231 209 34 said say VBN 37231 209 35 to to TO 37231 209 36 be be VB 37231 209 37 almost almost RB 37231 209 38 evenly evenly RB 37231 209 39 divided divide VBN 37231 209 40 on on IN 37231 209 41 this this DT 37231 209 42 question question NN 37231 209 43 of of IN 37231 209 44 priority priority NN 37231 209 45 . . . 37231 209 46 " " '' 37231 210 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 210 2 seems seem VBZ 37231 210 3 to to TO 37231 210 4 consider consider VB 37231 210 5 that that IN 37231 210 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 210 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 210 8 shows show VBZ 37231 210 9 this this DT 37231 210 10 when when WRB 37231 210 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 210 12 mentions mention VBZ 37231 210 13 five five CD 37231 210 14 or or CC 37231 210 15 six six CD 37231 210 16 critics critic NNS 37231 210 17 on on IN 37231 210 18 either either DT 37231 210 19 side side NN 37231 210 20 ; ; : 37231 210 21 but but CC 37231 210 22 even even RB 37231 210 23 { { -LRB- 37231 210 24 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 210 25 } } -RRB- 37231 210 26 on on IN 37231 210 27 this this DT 37231 210 28 modified modify VBN 37231 210 29 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 210 30 of of IN 37231 210 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 210 32 statement statement NN 37231 210 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 210 34 correctness correctness NN 37231 210 35 may may MD 37231 210 36 be be VB 37231 210 37 literally literally RB 37231 210 38 maintained maintain VBN 37231 210 39 . . . 37231 211 1 To to IN 37231 211 2 the the DT 37231 211 3 five five CD 37231 211 4 names name NNS 37231 211 5 quoted quote VBN 37231 211 6 as as IN 37231 211 7 recognizing recognize VBG 37231 211 8 the the DT 37231 211 9 priority priority NN 37231 211 10 of of IN 37231 211 11 the the DT 37231 211 12 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 211 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 211 14 may may MD 37231 211 15 be be VB 37231 211 16 added add VBN 37231 211 17 those those DT 37231 211 18 of of IN 37231 211 19 Milman Milman NNP 37231 211 20 , , , 37231 211 21 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 37231 211 22 , , , 37231 211 23 De De NNP 37231 211 24 Pressensé Pressensé NNP 37231 211 25 , , , 37231 211 26 and and CC 37231 211 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 211 28 Tregelles Tregelles NNP 37231 211 29 , , , 37231 211 30 which which WDT 37231 211 31 immediately immediately RB 37231 211 32 occur occur VBP 37231 211 33 to to IN 37231 211 34 me -PRON- PRP 37231 211 35 . . . 37231 212 1 But but CC 37231 212 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 212 3 must must MD 37231 212 4 ask ask VB 37231 212 5 upon upon IN 37231 212 6 what what WP 37231 212 7 ground ground NN 37231 212 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 212 9 limits limit VBZ 37231 212 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 212 11 remark remark NN 37231 212 12 to to IN 37231 212 13 those those DT 37231 212 14 who who WP 37231 212 15 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 212 16 admit admit VBP 37231 212 17 the the DT 37231 212 18 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 212 19 ? ? . 37231 213 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 213 2 certainly certainly RB 37231 213 3 do do VBP 37231 213 4 not not RB 37231 213 5 so so RB 37231 213 6 limit limit VB 37231 213 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 213 8 , , , 37231 213 9 but but CC 37231 213 10 affirm affirm VB 37231 213 11 that that IN 37231 213 12 a a DT 37231 213 13 majority majority NN 37231 213 14 prefer prefer VBP 37231 213 15 the the DT 37231 213 16 three three CD 37231 213 17 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 213 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 213 19 , , , 37231 213 20 and and CC 37231 213 21 that that IN 37231 213 22 this this DT 37231 213 23 majority majority NN 37231 213 24 is be VBZ 37231 213 25 made make VBN 37231 213 26 up up RP 37231 213 27 partly partly RB 37231 213 28 of of IN 37231 213 29 those those DT 37231 213 30 who who WP 37231 213 31 , , , 37231 213 32 denying deny VBG 37231 213 33 the the DT 37231 213 34 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 213 35 of of IN 37231 213 36 any any DT 37231 213 37 of of IN 37231 213 38 the the DT 37231 213 39 letters letter NNS 37231 213 40 , , , 37231 213 41 still still RB 37231 213 42 consider consider VB 37231 213 43 the the DT 37231 213 44 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 213 45 the the DT 37231 213 46 purest pure JJS 37231 213 47 and and CC 37231 213 48 least least JJS 37231 213 49 adulterated adulterate VBN 37231 213 50 form form NN 37231 213 51 of of IN 37231 213 52 the the DT 37231 213 53 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 213 54 . . . 37231 214 1 This this DT 37231 214 2 will will MD 37231 214 3 be be VB 37231 214 4 evident evident JJ 37231 214 5 to to IN 37231 214 6 any any DT 37231 214 7 one one NN 37231 214 8 who who WP 37231 214 9 reads read VBZ 37231 214 10 the the DT 37231 214 11 context context NN 37231 214 12 . . . 37231 215 1 With with IN 37231 215 2 regard regard NN 37231 215 3 to to IN 37231 215 4 the the DT 37231 215 5 latter latter JJ 37231 215 6 ( ( -LRB- 37231 215 7 2 2 LS 37231 215 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 215 9 part part NN 37231 215 10 of of IN 37231 215 11 the the DT 37231 215 12 sentence sentence NN 37231 215 13 , , , 37231 215 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 215 15 will will MD 37231 215 16 at at IN 37231 215 17 once once RB 37231 215 18 say say VB 37231 215 19 that that IN 37231 215 20 " " `` 37231 215 21 most most JJS 37231 215 22 " " '' 37231 215 23 is be VBZ 37231 215 24 a a DT 37231 215 25 slip slip NN 37231 215 26 of of IN 37231 215 27 the the DT 37231 215 28 pen pen NN 37231 215 29 for for IN 37231 215 30 " " `` 37231 215 31 many many JJ 37231 215 32 , , , 37231 215 33 " " '' 37231 215 34 which which WDT 37231 215 35 I -PRON- PRP 37231 215 36 correct correct VBP 37231 215 37 in in IN 37231 215 38 this this DT 37231 215 39 edition edition NN 37231 215 40 . . . 37231 216 1 Many many JJ 37231 216 2 of of IN 37231 216 3 those those DT 37231 216 4 who who WP 37231 216 5 deny deny VBP 37231 216 6 or or CC 37231 216 7 do do VBP 37231 216 8 not not RB 37231 216 9 admit admit VB 37231 216 10 the the DT 37231 216 11 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 216 12 prefer prefer VB 37231 216 13 the the DT 37231 216 14 Curetonian curetonian JJ 37231 216 15 version version NN 37231 216 16 . . . 37231 217 1 The the DT 37231 217 2 Tubingen Tubingen NNP 37231 217 3 school school NN 37231 217 4 are be VBP 37231 217 5 not not RB 37231 217 6 unanimous unanimous JJ 37231 217 7 on on IN 37231 217 8 the the DT 37231 217 9 point point NN 37231 217 10 , , , 37231 217 11 and and CC 37231 217 12 there there EX 37231 217 13 are be VBP 37231 217 14 critics critic NNS 37231 217 15 who who WP 37231 217 16 do do VBP 37231 217 17 not not RB 37231 217 18 belong belong VB 37231 217 19 to to IN 37231 217 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 217 21 . . . 37231 218 1 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 218 2 , , , 37231 218 3 for for IN 37231 218 4 instance instance NN 37231 218 5 , , , 37231 218 6 who who WP 37231 218 7 does do VBZ 37231 218 8 not not RB 37231 218 9 commit commit VB 37231 218 10 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 218 11 to to IN 37231 218 12 belief belief NN 37231 218 13 , , , 37231 218 14 considers consider VBZ 37231 218 15 the the DT 37231 218 16 priority priority NN 37231 218 17 of of IN 37231 218 18 the the DT 37231 218 19 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 218 20 " " `` 37231 218 21 i -PRON- PRP 37231 218 22 m be VBP 37231 218 23 höchsten höchsten VBD 37231 218 24 Grade Grade NNP 37231 218 25 wahrscheinlich wahrscheinlich NNP 37231 218 26 . . NNP 37231 218 27 , , , 37231 218 28 , , , 37231 218 29 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 218 30 , , , 37231 218 31 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 218 32 , , , 37231 218 33 and and CC 37231 218 34 Rumpf Rumpf NNP 37231 218 35 prefer prefer VBP 37231 218 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 218 37 . . . 37231 219 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 219 2 Light Light NNP 37231 219 3 - - HYPH 37231 219 4 foot foot NN 37231 219 5 says:-- says:-- '' 37231 219 6 " " `` 37231 219 7 The the DT 37231 219 8 case case NN 37231 219 9 of of IN 37231 219 10 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 219 11 is be VBZ 37231 219 12 especially especially RB 37231 219 13 instructive instructive JJ 37231 219 14 , , , 37231 219 15 as as IN 37231 219 16 illustrating illustrate VBG 37231 219 17 this this DT 37231 219 18 point point NN 37231 219 19 . . . 37231 220 1 Having have VBG 37231 220 2 at at IN 37231 220 3 one one CD 37231 220 4 time time NN 37231 220 5 maintained maintain VBD 37231 220 6 the the DT 37231 220 7 priority priority NN 37231 220 8 and and CC 37231 220 9 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 220 10 of of IN 37231 220 11 the the DT 37231 220 12 Curetonian curetonian JJ 37231 220 13 letters letter NNS 37231 220 14 , , , 37231 220 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 220 16 has have VBZ 37231 220 17 lately lately RB 37231 220 18 , , , 37231 220 19 if if IN 37231 220 20 I -PRON- PRP 37231 220 21 rightly rightly RB 37231 220 22 understand understand VBP 37231 220 23 him -PRON- PRP 37231 220 24 , , , 37231 220 25 retracted retract VBD 37231 220 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 220 27 former former JJ 37231 220 28 opinion opinion NN 37231 220 29 on on IN 37231 220 30 both both DT 37231 220 31 questions question NNS 37231 220 32 alike alike RB 37231 220 33 . . . 37231 221 1 " " `` 37231 221 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 221 3 2 2 LS 37231 221 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 221 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 221 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 221 7 , , , 37231 221 8 however however RB 37231 221 9 , , , 37231 221 10 has have VBZ 37231 221 11 not not RB 37231 221 12 rightly rightly RB 37231 221 13 understood understand VBN 37231 221 14 him -PRON- PRP 37231 221 15 . . . 37231 222 1 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 222 2 has have VBZ 37231 222 3 only only RB 37231 222 4 withdrawn withdraw VBN 37231 222 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 222 6 opinion opinion NN 37231 222 7 that that IN 37231 222 8 the the DT 37231 222 9 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 222 10 letters letter NNS 37231 222 11 are be VBP 37231 222 12 authentic authentic JJ 37231 222 13 , , , 37231 222 14 but but CC 37231 222 15 whilst whilst IN 37231 222 16 now now RB 37231 222 17 asserting assert VBG 37231 222 18 that that IN 37231 222 19 in in IN 37231 222 20 all all DT 37231 222 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 222 22 forms form NNS 37231 222 23 the the DT 37231 222 24 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 222 25 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 222 26 are be VBP 37231 222 27 spurious spurious JJ 37231 222 28 , , , 37231 222 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 222 30 still still RB 37231 222 31 { { -LRB- 37231 222 32 xxvii xxvii NN 37231 222 33 } } -RRB- 37231 222 34 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 222 35 the the DT 37231 222 36 priority priority NN 37231 222 37 of of IN 37231 222 38 the the DT 37231 222 39 Curetonian curetonian JJ 37231 222 40 version version NN 37231 222 41 . . . 37231 223 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 223 2 first first RB 37231 223 3 announced announce VBD 37231 223 4 this this DT 37231 223 5 change change NN 37231 223 6 of of IN 37231 223 7 view view NN 37231 223 8 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 223 9 in in IN 37231 223 10 1873 1873 CD 37231 223 11 , , , 37231 223 12 when when WRB 37231 223 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 223 14 added add VBD 37231 223 15 : : : 37231 223 16 " " `` 37231 223 17 An an DT 37231 223 18 dem dem JJ 37231 223 19 relativ relativ NN 37231 223 20 grossern grossern NN 37231 223 21 Alter Alter NNP 37231 223 22 der der NNP 37231 223 23 syrischen syrischen NNP 37231 223 24 Textgestalt Textgestalt NNP 37231 223 25 gegenuber gegenuber NNP 37231 223 26 der der NNP 37231 223 27 kürzeren kürzeren NNP 37231 223 28 griechischen griechischen NNP 37231 223 29 halte halte NNP 37231 223 30 ich ich NNP 37231 223 31 ubrigens ubrigens NNP 37231 223 32 nach nach NNP 37231 223 33 wie wie NNP 37231 223 34 vor vor NNP 37231 223 35 fest"(1 fest"(1 NNP 37231 223 36 ) ) -RRB- 37231 223 37 In in IN 37231 223 38 the the DT 37231 223 39 very very JJ 37231 223 40 paper paper NN 37231 223 41 to to TO 37231 223 42 which which WDT 37231 223 43 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 223 44 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 223 45 refers refer VBZ 37231 223 46 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 223 47 also also RB 37231 223 48 again again RB 37231 223 49 says say VBZ 37231 223 50 quite quite RB 37231 223 51 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 223 52 : : : 37231 223 53 " " `` 37231 223 54 Ich Ich NNP 37231 223 55 bin bin NNP 37231 223 56 noch noch NNP 37231 223 57 jetzt jetzt NNP 37231 223 58 überzeugt überzeugt NNP 37231 223 59 , , , 37231 223 60 dass dass NNP 37231 223 61 der der NNP 37231 223 62 Syrer Syrer NNP 37231 223 63 in in IN 37231 223 64 zahlreichen zahlreichen NNP 37231 223 65 Fallen fall VBN 37231 223 66 den den NN 37231 223 67 relativ relativ NN 37231 223 68 ursprünglichsten ursprünglichsten VBP 37231 223 69 Text Text NNP 37231 223 70 bewahrt bewahrt NN 37231 223 71 hat hat NN 37231 223 72 ( ( -LRB- 37231 223 73 vgl vgl NNP 37231 223 74 . . . 37231 224 1 meine meine NNP 37231 224 2 Nachweise Nachweise NNP 37231 224 3 in in IN 37231 224 4 Niedner Niedner NNP 37231 224 5 's 's POS 37231 224 6 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 37231 224 7 . . . 37231 225 1 S. S. NNP 37231 226 1 15fl 15fl LS 37231 226 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 226 3 . . . 37231 227 1 " " `` 37231 227 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 227 3 2 2 LS 37231 227 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 227 5 With with IN 37231 227 6 regard regard NN 37231 227 7 to to IN 37231 227 8 the the DT 37231 227 9 whole whole NN 37231 227 10 of of IN 37231 227 11 this this DT 37231 227 12 ( ( -LRB- 37231 227 13 2 2 LS 37231 227 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 227 15 point point NN 37231 227 16 , , , 37231 227 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 227 18 must must MD 37231 227 19 be be VB 37231 227 20 remembered remember VBN 37231 227 21 that that IN 37231 227 22 the the DT 37231 227 23 only only JJ 37231 227 24 matter matter NN 37231 227 25 in in IN 37231 227 26 question question NN 37231 227 27 is be VBZ 37231 227 28 simply simply RB 37231 227 29 a a DT 37231 227 30 shade shade NN 37231 227 31 of of IN 37231 227 32 opinion opinion NN 37231 227 33 amongst amongst IN 37231 227 34 critics critic NNS 37231 227 35 who who WP 37231 227 36 deny deny VBP 37231 227 37 the the DT 37231 227 38 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 227 39 of of IN 37231 227 40 the the DT 37231 227 41 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 227 42 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 227 43 in in IN 37231 227 44 all all DT 37231 227 45 forms form NNS 37231 227 46 . . . 37231 228 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 228 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 228 3 , , , 37231 228 4 however however RB 37231 228 5 , , , 37231 228 6 goes go VBZ 37231 228 7 on on IN 37231 228 8 " " `` 37231 228 9 to to TO 37231 228 10 throw throw VB 37231 228 11 some some DT 37231 228 12 light light NN 37231 228 13 on on IN 37231 228 14 this this DT 37231 228 15 point point NN 37231 228 16 " " '' 37231 228 17 by by IN 37231 228 18 analysing analyse VBG 37231 228 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 228 20 " " `` 37231 228 21 general general JJ 37231 228 22 statement statement NN 37231 228 23 of of IN 37231 228 24 the the DT 37231 228 25 course course NN 37231 228 26 of of IN 37231 228 27 opinion opinion NN 37231 228 28 on on IN 37231 228 29 this this DT 37231 228 30 subject subject NN 37231 228 31 given give VBN 37231 228 32 in in IN 37231 228 33 an an DT 37231 228 34 earlier early JJR 37231 228 35 passage passage NN 37231 228 36 . . . 37231 229 1 " " `` 37231 229 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 229 3 3 3 LS 37231 229 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 229 5 The the DT 37231 229 6 " " `` 37231 229 7 light light NN 37231 229 8 " " '' 37231 229 9 which which WDT 37231 229 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 229 11 throws throw VBZ 37231 229 12 seems seem VBZ 37231 229 13 to to TO 37231 229 14 pass pass VB 37231 229 15 through through RP 37231 229 16 so so RB 37231 229 17 peculiar peculiar RB 37231 229 18 a a DT 37231 229 19 medium medium NN 37231 229 20 , , , 37231 229 21 that that IN 37231 229 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 229 23 should should MD 37231 229 24 be be VB 37231 229 25 much much RB 37231 229 26 rather rather RB 37231 229 27 tempted tempt VBN 37231 229 28 to to TO 37231 229 29 call call VB 37231 229 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 229 31 darkness darkness NN 37231 229 32 . . . 37231 230 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 230 2 beg beg VBP 37231 230 3 the the DT 37231 230 4 reader reader NN 37231 230 5 to to TO 37231 230 6 favour favour VB 37231 230 7 me -PRON- PRP 37231 230 8 with with IN 37231 230 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 230 10 attention attention NN 37231 230 11 to to IN 37231 230 12 this this DT 37231 230 13 matter matter NN 37231 230 14 , , , 37231 230 15 for for IN 37231 230 16 here here RB 37231 230 17 commences commence VBZ 37231 230 18 a a DT 37231 230 19 serious serious JJ 37231 230 20 attack attack NN 37231 230 21 upon upon IN 37231 230 22 the the DT 37231 230 23 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 230 24 of of IN 37231 230 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 230 26 notes note NNS 37231 230 27 and and CC 37231 230 28 statements statement NNS 37231 230 29 , , , 37231 230 30 which which WDT 37231 230 31 is be VBZ 37231 230 32 singularly singularly RB 37231 230 33 full full JJ 37231 230 34 of of IN 37231 230 35 error error NN 37231 230 36 and and CC 37231 230 37 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 37231 230 38 . . . 37231 231 1 The the DT 37231 231 2 general general JJ 37231 231 3 statement statement NN 37231 231 4 referred refer VBD 37231 231 5 to to IN 37231 231 6 and and CC 37231 231 7 quoted quote VBN 37231 231 8 is be VBZ 37231 231 9 as as IN 37231 231 10 follows:-- follows:-- `` 37231 231 11 " " `` 37231 231 12 Those those DT 37231 231 13 three three CD 37231 231 14 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 231 15 epistles epistle NNS 37231 231 16 hive hive NNP 37231 231 17 been be VBN 37231 231 18 subjected subject VBN 37231 231 19 to to IN 37231 231 20 the the DT 37231 231 21 severest severe JJS 37231 231 22 scrutiny scrutiny NN 37231 231 23 , , , 37231 231 24 and and CC 37231 231 25 many many JJ 37231 231 26 of of IN 37231 231 27 the the DT 37231 231 28 ablest able JJS 37231 231 29 critics critic NNS 37231 231 30 have have VBP 37231 231 31 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 231 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 231 33 to to TO 37231 231 34 be be VB 37231 231 35 the the DT 37231 231 36 only only JJ 37231 231 37 authentic authentic JJ 37231 231 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 231 39 of of IN 37231 231 40 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 231 41 , , , 37231 231 42 whilst whilst IN 37231 231 43 others other NNS 37231 231 44 , , , 37231 231 45 who who WP 37231 231 46 do do VBP 37231 231 47 not not RB 37231 231 48 admit admit VB 37231 231 49 that that IN 37231 231 50 even even RB 37231 231 51 these these DT 37231 231 52 are be VBP 37231 231 53 genuine genuine JJ 37231 231 54 letters letter NNS 37231 231 55 emanating emanate VBG 37231 231 56 from from IN 37231 231 57 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 231 58 , , , 37231 231 59 still still RB 37231 231 60 prefer prefer VB 37231 231 61 them -PRON- PRP 37231 231 62 to to IN 37231 231 63 the the DT 37231 231 64 version version NN 37231 231 65 of of IN 37231 231 66 seven seven CD 37231 231 67 Greek greek JJ 37231 231 68 epistles epistle NNS 37231 231 69 , , , 37231 231 70 and and CC 37231 231 71 consider consider VB 37231 231 72 them -PRON- PRP 37231 231 73 the the DT 37231 231 74 most most RBS 37231 231 75 ancient ancient JJ 37231 231 76 form form NN 37231 231 77 of of IN 37231 231 78 the the DT 37231 231 79 letters letter NNS 37231 231 80 which which WDT 37231 231 81 we -PRON- PRP 37231 231 82 possess possess VBP 37231 231 83 . . . 37231 232 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 232 2 1 1 LS 37231 232 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 232 4 As as RB 37231 232 5 early early RB 37231 232 6 as as IN 37231 232 7 the the DT 37231 232 8 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 37231 232 9 century century NN 37231 232 10 , , , 37231 232 11 however however RB 37231 232 12 , , , 37231 232 13 the the DT 37231 232 14 strongest strong JJS 37231 232 15 doubts doubt NNS 37231 232 16 were be VBD 37231 232 17 expressed express VBN 37231 232 18 regarding regard VBG 37231 232 19 the the DT 37231 232 20 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 232 21 { { -LRB- 37231 232 22 xxviii xxviii NN 37231 232 23 } } -RRB- 37231 232 24 of of IN 37231 232 25 any any DT 37231 232 26 of of IN 37231 232 27 the the DT 37231 232 28 epistles epistle NNS 37231 232 29 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 232 30 to to IN 37231 232 31 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 232 32 . . . 37231 233 1 The the DT 37231 233 2 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 37231 233 3 Centuriators Centuriators NNP 37231 233 4 first first RB 37231 233 5 attacked attack VBD 37231 233 6 them -PRON- PRP 37231 233 7 , , , 37231 233 8 and and CC 37231 233 9 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 233 10 declared declare VBD 37231 233 11 ( ( -LRB- 37231 233 12 p. p. NN 37231 233 13 260 260 CD 37231 233 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 233 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 233 16 to to TO 37231 233 17 be be VB 37231 233 18 spurious,(1 spurious,(1 NN 37231 233 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 233 20 an an DT 37231 233 21 opinion opinion NN 37231 233 22 fully fully RB 37231 233 23 shared share VBN 37231 233 24 by by IN 37231 233 25 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 37231 233 26 , , , 37231 233 27 Dallseus Dallseus NNP 37231 233 28 , , , 37231 233 29 and and CC 37231 233 30 others other NNS 37231 233 31 , , , 37231 233 32 and and CC 37231 233 33 similar similar JJ 37231 233 34 doubts doubt NNS 37231 233 35 , , , 37231 233 36 more more RBR 37231 233 37 or or CC 37231 233 38 less less RBR 37231 233 39 definite definite JJ 37231 233 40 , , , 37231 233 41 were be VBD 37231 233 42 expressed express VBN 37231 233 43 throughout throughout IN 37231 233 44 the the DT 37231 233 45 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 37231 233 46 century,(2 century,(2 NNS 37231 233 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 233 48 and and CC 37231 233 49 onward onward RB 37231 233 50 to to IN 37231 233 51 comparatively comparatively RB 37231 233 52 recent recent JJ 37231 233 53 times,(3 times,(3 NN 37231 233 54 ) ) -RRB- 37231 233 55 although although IN 37231 233 56 the the DT 37231 233 57 means mean NNS 37231 233 58 of of IN 37231 233 59 forming form VBG 37231 233 60 a a DT 37231 233 61 judgment judgment NN 37231 233 62 were be VBD 37231 233 63 not not RB 37231 233 64 then then RB 37231 233 65 so so RB 37231 233 66 complete complete JJ 37231 233 67 as as IN 37231 233 68 now now RB 37231 233 69 . . . 37231 234 1 That that IN 37231 234 2 the the DT 37231 234 3 epistles epistle NNS 37231 234 4 were be VBD 37231 234 5 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 234 6 there there EX 37231 234 7 was be VBD 37231 234 8 no no DT 37231 234 9 doubt doubt NN 37231 234 10 . . . 37231 235 1 Fuller full JJR 37231 235 2 examination examination NN 37231 235 3 and and CC 37231 235 4 more more RBR 37231 235 5 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 37231 235 6 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 235 7 of of IN 37231 235 8 the the DT 37231 235 9 subject subject NN 37231 235 10 have have VBP 37231 235 11 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 235 12 earlier early JJR 37231 235 13 doubts doubt NNS 37231 235 14 , , , 37231 235 15 and and CC 37231 235 16 a a DT 37231 235 17 large large JJ 37231 235 18 mass mass NN 37231 235 19 of of IN 37231 235 20 critics critic NNS 37231 235 21 recognize recognize VBP 37231 235 22 that that IN 37231 235 23 the the DT 37231 235 24 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 235 25 of of IN 37231 235 26 none none NN 37231 235 27 of of IN 37231 235 28 these these DT 37231 235 29 epistles epistle NNS 37231 235 30 can can MD 37231 235 31 be be VB 37231 235 32 established establish VBN 37231 235 33 , , , 37231 235 34 and and CC 37231 235 35 that that IN 37231 235 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 235 37 can can MD 37231 235 38 only only RB 37231 235 39 be be VB 37231 235 40 considered consider VBN 37231 235 41 later later RB 37231 235 42 and and CC 37231 235 43 spurious spurious JJ 37231 235 44 compositions composition NNS 37231 235 45 . . . 37231 236 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 236 2 4)"(1 4)"(1 CD 37231 236 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 236 4 In in IN 37231 236 5 the the DT 37231 236 6 first first JJ 37231 236 7 note note NN 37231 236 8 ( ( -LRB- 37231 236 9 1 1 CD 37231 236 10 ) ) -RRB- 37231 236 11 on on IN 37231 236 12 p. p. NN 37231 236 13 259 259 CD 37231 236 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 236 15 referred refer VBD 37231 236 16 to to IN 37231 236 17 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 37231 236 18 , , , 37231 236 19 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 236 20 , , , 37231 236 21 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 37231 236 22 , , , 37231 236 23 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 236 24 , , , 37231 236 25 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 236 26 , , , 37231 236 27 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 236 28 , , , 37231 236 29 Milman Milman NNP 37231 236 30 , , , 37231 236 31 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 37231 236 32 , , , 37231 236 33 and and CC 37231 236 34 Weiss Weiss NNP 37231 236 35 , , , 37231 236 36 and and CC 37231 236 37 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 236 38 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 236 39 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 236 40 to to TO 37231 236 41 analyze analyze VB 37231 236 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 236 43 statements statement NNS 37231 236 44 as as IN 37231 236 45 follows follow VBZ 37231 236 46 : : : 37231 236 47 and and CC 37231 236 48 I -PRON- PRP 37231 236 49 at at IN 37231 236 50 once once RB 37231 236 51 put put VBD 37231 236 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 236 53 explanation explanation NN 37231 236 54 and and CC 37231 236 55 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 236 56 text text NN 37231 236 57 in in IN 37231 236 58 parallel parallel JJ 37231 236 59 columns column NNS 37231 236 60 , , , 37231 236 61 italicising italicise VBG 37231 236 62 parts part NNS 37231 236 63 of of IN 37231 236 64 both both DT 37231 236 65 to to TO 37231 236 66 call call VB 37231 236 67 more more RBR 37231 236 68 immediate immediate JJ 37231 236 69 attention attention NN 37231 236 70 to to IN 37231 236 71 the the DT 37231 236 72 point:-- point:-- NN 37231 236 73 The the DT 37231 236 74 Text Text NNP 37231 236 75 . . . 37231 237 1 Many many JJ 37231 237 2 of of IN 37231 237 3 the the DT 37231 237 4 ablest able JJS 37231 237 5 critics critic NNS 37231 237 6 have have VBP 37231 237 7 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 237 8 them -PRON- PRP 37231 237 9 to to TO 37231 237 10 be be VB 37231 237 11 the the DT 37231 237 12 only only JJ 37231 237 13 authentic authentic JJ 37231 237 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 237 15 of of IN 37231 237 16 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 237 17 , , , 37231 237 18 whilst whilst IN 37231 237 19 others other NNS 37231 237 20 who who WP 37231 237 21 do do VBP 37231 237 22 not not RB 37231 237 23 admit admit VB 37231 237 24 that that IN 37231 237 25 even even RB 37231 237 26 these these DT 37231 237 27 are be VBP 37231 237 28 genuine genuine JJ 37231 237 29 letters letter NNS 37231 237 30 emanating emanate VBG 37231 237 31 from from IN 37231 237 32 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 237 33 , , , 37231 237 34 still still RB 37231 237 35 prefer prefer VB 37231 237 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 237 37 to to IN 37231 237 38 the the DT 37231 237 39 version version NN 37231 237 40 of of IN 37231 237 41 seven seven CD 37231 237 42 Greek Greek NNP 37231 237 43 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 237 44 , , , 37231 237 45 and and CC 37231 237 46 consider consider VB 37231 237 47 them -PRON- PRP 37231 237 48 the the DT 37231 237 49 most most RBS 37231 237 50 ancient ancient JJ 37231 237 51 form form NN 37231 237 52 of of IN 37231 237 53 the the DT 37231 237 54 letters letter NNS 37231 237 55 which which WDT 37231 237 56 we -PRON- PRP 37231 237 57 possess possess VBP 37231 237 58 . . . 37231 238 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 238 2 1 1 LS 37231 238 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 238 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 238 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 238 6 's 's POS 37231 238 7 Statement statement NN 37231 238 8 . . . 37231 239 1 " " `` 37231 239 2 These these DT 37231 239 3 references reference NNS 37231 239 4 , , , 37231 239 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 239 6 will will MD 37231 239 7 be be VB 37231 239 8 observed observe VBN 37231 239 9 , , , 37231 239 10 are be VBP 37231 239 11 given give VBN 37231 239 12 to to TO 37231 239 13 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 239 14 more more RBR 37231 239 15 immediately immediately RB 37231 239 16 , , , 37231 239 17 though though IN 37231 239 18 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 239 19 not not RB 37231 239 20 solely solely RB 37231 239 21 , , , 37231 239 22 the the DT 37231 239 23 statement statement NN 37231 239 24 that that IN 37231 239 25 writers writer NNS 37231 239 26 ' ' `` 37231 239 27 who who WP 37231 239 28 do do VBP 37231 239 29 not not RB 37231 239 30 admit admit VB 37231 239 31 that that IN 37231 239 32 even even RB 37231 239 33 these these DT 37231 239 34 ( ( -LRB- 37231 239 35 the the DT 37231 239 36 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 239 37 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 239 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 239 39 are be VBP 37231 239 40 genuine genuine JJ 37231 239 41 letters letter NNS 37231 239 42 emanating emanate VBG 37231 239 43 from from IN 37231 239 44 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 239 45 , , , 37231 239 46 still still RB 37231 239 47 prefer prefer VB 37231 239 48 them -PRON- PRP 37231 239 49 to to IN 37231 239 50 the the DT 37231 239 51 version version NN 37231 239 52 of of IN 37231 239 53 seven seven CD 37231 239 54 Greek Greek NNP 37231 239 55 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 239 56 , , , 37231 239 57 and and CC 37231 239 58 consider consider VB 37231 239 59 them -PRON- PRP 37231 239 60 the the DT 37231 239 61 most most RBS 37231 239 62 ancient ancient JJ 37231 239 63 form form NN 37231 239 64 of of IN 37231 239 65 the the DT 37231 239 66 letters letter NNS 37231 239 67 which which WDT 37231 239 68 we -PRON- PRP 37231 239 69 possess possess VBP 37231 239 70 . . . 37231 240 1 ' ' `` 37231 240 2 " " '' 37231 240 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 240 4 2 2 LS 37231 240 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 240 6 It -PRON- PRP 37231 240 7 must must MD 37231 240 8 be be VB 37231 240 9 evident evident JJ 37231 240 10 to to IN 37231 240 11 any any DT 37231 240 12 one one NN 37231 240 13 who who WP 37231 240 14 reads read VBZ 37231 240 15 the the DT 37231 240 16 context(3 context(3 NN 37231 240 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 240 18 that that IN 37231 240 19 in in IN 37231 240 20 this this DT 37231 240 21 sentence sentence NN 37231 240 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 240 23 am be VBP 37231 240 24 stating state VBG 37231 240 25 opinions opinion NNS 37231 240 26 expressed express VBN 37231 240 27 in in IN 37231 240 28 favour favour NN 37231 240 29 of of IN 37231 240 30 the the DT 37231 240 31 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 240 32 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 240 33 , , , 37231 240 34 and and CC 37231 240 35 that that IN 37231 240 36 the the DT 37231 240 37 note note NN 37231 240 38 , , , 37231 240 39 which which WDT 37231 240 40 is be VBZ 37231 240 41 naturally naturally RB 37231 240 42 put put VBN 37231 240 43 at at IN 37231 240 44 the the DT 37231 240 45 end end NN 37231 240 46 of of IN 37231 240 47 that that DT 37231 240 48 sentence sentence NN 37231 240 49 , , , 37231 240 50 must must MD 37231 240 51 be be VB 37231 240 52 intended intend VBN 37231 240 53 to to TO 37231 240 54 represent represent VB 37231 240 55 this this DT 37231 240 56 favourable favourable JJ 37231 240 57 opinion opinion NN 37231 240 58 , , , 37231 240 59 whether whether IN 37231 240 60 of of IN 37231 240 61 those those DT 37231 240 62 who who WP 37231 240 63 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 240 64 maintain maintain VBP 37231 240 65 the the DT 37231 240 66 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 240 67 or or CC 37231 240 68 { { -LRB- 37231 240 69 xxix xxix NNP 37231 240 70 } } -RRB- 37231 240 71 merely merely RB 37231 240 72 the the DT 37231 240 73 relative relative JJ 37231 240 74 priority priority NN 37231 240 75 . . . 37231 241 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 241 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 241 3 quietly quietly RB 37231 241 4 suppresses suppress VBZ 37231 241 5 , , , 37231 241 6 in in IN 37231 241 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 241 8 comments comment NNS 37231 241 9 , , , 37231 241 10 the the DT 37231 241 11 main main JJ 37231 241 12 statement statement NN 37231 241 13 of of IN 37231 241 14 the the DT 37231 241 15 text text NN 37231 241 16 which which WDT 37231 241 17 the the DT 37231 241 18 note note NN 37231 241 19 illustrates illustrate VBZ 37231 241 20 , , , 37231 241 21 and and CC 37231 241 22 then then RB 37231 241 23 " " `` 37231 241 24 throws throw VBZ 37231 241 25 light light NN 37231 241 26 " " '' 37231 241 27 upon upon IN 37231 241 28 the the DT 37231 241 29 point point NN 37231 241 30 by by IN 37231 241 31 the the DT 37231 241 32 following follow VBG 37231 241 33 remarks:-- remarks:-- -LRB- 37231 241 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 241 35 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 241 36 's 's POS 37231 241 37 Statement statement NN 37231 241 38 : : : 37231 241 39 " " `` 37231 241 40 The the DT 37231 241 41 reader reader NN 37231 241 42 , , , 37231 241 43 therefore therefore RB 37231 241 44 , , , 37231 241 45 will will MD 37231 241 46 hardly hardly RB 37231 241 47 be be VB 37231 241 48 prepared prepared JJ 37231 241 49 to to TO 37231 241 50 hear hear VB 37231 241 51 that that IN 37231 241 52 not not RB 37231 241 53 one one CD 37231 241 54 of of IN 37231 241 55 these these DT 37231 241 56 nine nine CD 37231 241 57 writers writer NNS 37231 241 58 condemns condemn VBZ 37231 241 59 the the DT 37231 241 60 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 241 61 letters letter NNS 37231 241 62 as as RB 37231 241 63 spurious spurious JJ 37231 241 64 . . . 37231 242 1 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 242 2 alone alone RB 37231 242 3 leaves leave VBZ 37231 242 4 the the DT 37231 242 5 matter matter NN 37231 242 6 in in IN 37231 242 7 some some DT 37231 242 8 uncertainty uncertainty NN 37231 242 9 while while IN 37231 242 10 inclining incline VBG 37231 242 11 to to IN 37231 242 12 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 37231 242 13 's 's POS 37231 242 14 view view NN 37231 242 15 ; ; : 37231 242 16 the the DT 37231 242 17 other other JJ 37231 242 18 eight eight CD 37231 242 19 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 242 20 maintain maintain VB 37231 242 21 the the DT 37231 242 22 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 242 23 of of IN 37231 242 24 the the DT 37231 242 25 Curetonian curetonian JJ 37231 242 26 letters letter NNS 37231 242 27 . . . 37231 242 28 " " '' 37231 242 29 ' ' '' 37231 243 1 The the DT 37231 243 2 Truth Truth NNP 37231 243 3 : : : 37231 243 4 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 243 5 , , , 37231 243 6 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 37231 243 7 , , , 37231 243 8 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 37231 243 9 , , , 37231 243 10 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 243 11 , , , 37231 243 12 Milman Milman NNP 37231 243 13 , , , 37231 243 14 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 37231 243 15 , , , 37231 243 16 and and CC 37231 243 17 Weiss Weiss NNP 37231 243 18 maintain maintain VB 37231 243 19 both both CC 37231 243 20 the the DT 37231 243 21 priority priority NN 37231 243 22 and and CC 37231 243 23 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 243 24 of of IN 37231 243 25 the the DT 37231 243 26 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 243 27 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 243 28 . . . 37231 244 1 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 244 2 will will MD 37231 244 3 not not RB 37231 244 4 commit commit VB 37231 244 5 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 244 6 to to IN 37231 244 7 a a DT 37231 244 8 distinct distinct JJ 37231 244 9 recognition recognition NN 37231 244 10 of of IN 37231 244 11 the the DT 37231 244 12 letters letter NNS 37231 244 13 in in IN 37231 244 14 any any DT 37231 244 15 form form NN 37231 244 16 . . . 37231 245 1 Of of IN 37231 245 2 the the DT 37231 245 3 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 245 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 245 5 , , , 37231 245 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 245 7 says say VBZ 37231 245 8 : : : 37231 245 9 " " `` 37231 245 10 Aber Aber NNP 37231 245 11 auch auch NN 37231 245 12 die die VBP 37231 245 13 Echtheit Echtheit NNP 37231 245 14 dieser dieser NN 37231 245 15 Recension Recension NNP 37231 245 16 ist ist NNP 37231 245 17 keineswegs keineswegs NNP 37231 245 18 sicher sicher NN 37231 245 19 . . . 37231 245 20 " " '' 37231 246 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 246 2 considers consider VBZ 37231 246 3 the the DT 37231 246 4 priority priority NN 37231 246 5 of of IN 37231 246 6 the the DT 37231 246 7 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 246 8 " " '' 37231 246 9 in in IN 37231 246 10 the the DT 37231 246 11 highest high JJS 37231 246 12 degree degree NN 37231 246 13 probable probable JJ 37231 246 14 . . . 37231 246 15 " " '' 37231 247 1 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 247 2 rejects reject VBZ 37231 247 3 all all PDT 37231 247 4 the the DT 37231 247 5 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 247 6 , , , 37231 247 7 as as IN 37231 247 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 247 9 have have VBP 37231 247 10 already already RB 37231 247 11 said say VBN 37231 247 12 , , , 37231 247 13 but but CC 37231 247 14 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 247 15 the the DT 37231 247 16 priority priority NN 37231 247 17 of of IN 37231 247 18 the the DT 37231 247 19 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 247 20 . . . 37231 248 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 248 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 248 3 's 's POS 37231 248 4 statement statement NN 37231 248 5 , , , 37231 248 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 248 7 , , , 37231 248 8 is be VBZ 37231 248 9 a a DT 37231 248 10 total total JJ 37231 248 11 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 37231 248 12 of of IN 37231 248 13 the the DT 37231 248 14 facts fact NNS 37231 248 15 , , , 37231 248 16 and and CC 37231 248 17 of of IN 37231 248 18 that that DT 37231 248 19 mischievous mischievous JJ 37231 248 20 kind kind NN 37231 248 21 which which WDT 37231 248 22 does do VBZ 37231 248 23 most most RBS 37231 248 24 subtle subtle JJ 37231 248 25 injury injury NN 37231 248 26 . . . 37231 249 1 Not not RB 37231 249 2 one one CD 37231 249 3 reader reader NN 37231 249 4 in in IN 37231 249 5 twenty twenty CD 37231 249 6 would would MD 37231 249 7 take take VB 37231 249 8 the the DT 37231 249 9 trouble trouble NN 37231 249 10 to to TO 37231 249 11 investigate investigate VB 37231 249 12 , , , 37231 249 13 but but CC 37231 249 14 would would MD 37231 249 15 receive receive VB 37231 249 16 from from IN 37231 249 17 such such JJ 37231 249 18 positive positive JJ 37231 249 19 assertions assertion NNS 37231 249 20 an an DT 37231 249 21 impression impression NN 37231 249 22 that that IN 37231 249 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 249 24 note note NN 37231 249 25 was be VBD 37231 249 26 totally totally RB 37231 249 27 wrong wrong JJ 37231 249 28 , , , 37231 249 29 when when WRB 37231 249 30 in in IN 37231 249 31 fact fact NN 37231 249 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 249 33 is be VBZ 37231 249 34 literally literally RB 37231 249 35 correct correct JJ 37231 249 36 . . . 37231 250 1 Continuing continue VBG 37231 250 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 250 3 analysis analysis NN 37231 250 4 , , , 37231 250 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 250 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 250 7 fights fight VBZ 37231 250 8 almost almost RB 37231 250 9 every every DT 37231 250 10 inch inch NN 37231 250 11 of of IN 37231 250 12 the the DT 37231 250 13 ground ground NN 37231 250 14 in in IN 37231 250 15 the the DT 37231 250 16 very very RB 37231 250 17 same same JJ 37231 250 18 style style NN 37231 250 19 . . . 37231 251 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 251 2 can can MD 37231 251 3 not not RB 37231 251 4 contradict contradict VB 37231 251 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 251 6 statement statement NN 37231 251 7 that that WDT 37231 251 8 so so RB 37231 251 9 early early RB 37231 251 10 as as IN 37231 251 11 the the DT 37231 251 12 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 37231 251 13 century century NN 37231 251 14 the the DT 37231 251 15 strongest strong JJS 37231 251 16 doubts doubt NNS 37231 251 17 were be VBD 37231 251 18 expressed express VBN 37231 251 19 regarding regard VBG 37231 251 20 the the DT 37231 251 21 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 251 22 of of IN 37231 251 23 any any DT 37231 251 24 of of IN 37231 251 25 the the DT 37231 251 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 251 27 ascribed ascribe VBD 37231 251 28 1 1 CD 37231 251 29 " " `` 37231 251 30 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 37231 251 31 Beview Beview NNP 37231 251 32 , , , 37231 251 33 " " `` 37231 251 34 February February NNP 37231 251 35 , , , 37231 251 36 1875 1875 CD 37231 251 37 , , , 37231 251 38 p. p. NN 37231 251 39 342 342 CD 37231 251 40 . . . 37231 252 1 In in IN 37231 252 2 a a DT 37231 252 3 note note NN 37231 252 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 252 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 252 6 states state VBZ 37231 252 7 that that IN 37231 252 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 252 9 references reference NNS 37231 252 10 to to IN 37231 252 11 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 252 12 are be VBP 37231 252 13 to to IN 37231 252 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 252 15 earlier early JJR 37231 252 16 works work NNS 37231 252 17 , , , 37231 252 18 where where WRB 37231 252 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 252 20 still still RB 37231 252 21 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 252 22 the the DT 37231 252 23 priority priority NN 37231 252 24 and and CC 37231 252 25 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 252 26 of of IN 37231 252 27 the the DT 37231 252 28 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 252 29 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 252 30 . . . 37231 253 1 Certainly certainly RB 37231 253 2 they -PRON- PRP 37231 253 3 are be VBP 37231 253 4 so so RB 37231 253 5 , , , 37231 253 6 but but CC 37231 253 7 in in IN 37231 253 8 the the DT 37231 253 9 right right JJ 37231 253 10 place place NN 37231 253 11 , , , 37231 253 12 two two CD 37231 253 13 pages page NNS 37231 253 14 farther farther RB 37231 253 15 on on RB 37231 253 16 , , , 37231 253 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 253 18 refer refer VBP 37231 253 19 to to IN 37231 253 20 the the DT 37231 253 21 writings writing NNS 37231 253 22 in in IN 37231 253 23 which which WDT 37231 253 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 253 25 rejects reject VBZ 37231 253 26 the the DT 37231 253 27 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 253 28 , , , 37231 253 29 whilst whilst IN 37231 253 30 still still RB 37231 253 31 maintaining maintain VBG 37231 253 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 253 33 previous previous JJ 37231 253 34 view view NN 37231 253 35 of of IN 37231 253 36 the the DT 37231 253 37 priority priority NN 37231 253 38 of of IN 37231 253 39 these these DT 37231 253 40 letters letter NNS 37231 253 41 { { -LRB- 37231 253 42 xxx xxx NNP 37231 253 43 } } -RRB- 37231 253 44 to to IN 37231 253 45 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 253 46 , , , 37231 253 47 and and CC 37231 253 48 that that IN 37231 253 49 the the DT 37231 253 50 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 37231 253 51 Centuriators Centuriators NNPS 37231 253 52 attacked attack VBD 37231 253 53 them -PRON- PRP 37231 253 54 , , , 37231 253 55 and and CC 37231 253 56 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 253 57 declared declare VBD 37231 253 58 them -PRON- PRP 37231 253 59 to to TO 37231 253 60 be be VB 37231 253 61 spurious,(1 spurious,(1 NN 37231 253 62 ) ) -RRB- 37231 253 63 but but CC 37231 253 64 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 253 65 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 253 66 says say VBZ 37231 253 67 : : : 37231 253 68 " " `` 37231 253 69 The the DT 37231 253 70 criticisms criticism NNS 37231 253 71 of of IN 37231 253 72 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 253 73 more more RBR 37231 253 74 especially especially RB 37231 253 75 refer refer VBP 37231 253 76 to to IN 37231 253 77 those those DT 37231 253 78 passages passage NNS 37231 253 79 which which WDT 37231 253 80 were be VBD 37231 253 81 found find VBN 37231 253 82 in in IN 37231 253 83 the the DT 37231 253 84 Long Long NNP 37231 253 85 Recension Recension NNP 37231 253 86 alone alone RB 37231 253 87 . . . 37231 254 1 " " `` 37231 254 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 254 3 2 2 LS 37231 254 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 254 5 Of of RB 37231 254 6 course course RB 37231 254 7 only only RB 37231 254 8 the the DT 37231 254 9 Long Long NNP 37231 254 10 Recension Recension NNP 37231 254 11 was be VBD 37231 254 12 at at IN 37231 254 13 that that DT 37231 254 14 time time NN 37231 254 15 known know VBN 37231 254 16 . . . 37231 255 1 Rivet Rivet NNS 37231 255 2 replies reply VBZ 37231 255 3 to to IN 37231 255 4 Campianus Campianus NNP 37231 255 5 that that IN 37231 255 6 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 255 7 's 's POS 37231 255 8 objections objection NNS 37231 255 9 were be VBD 37231 255 10 not not RB 37231 255 11 against against IN 37231 255 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 255 13 but but CC 37231 255 14 the the DT 37231 255 15 Jesuits Jesuits NNPS 37231 255 16 who who WP 37231 255 17 had have VBD 37231 255 18 corrupted corrupt VBN 37231 255 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 255 20 . . . 37231 256 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 256 2 3 3 LS 37231 256 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 256 4 This this DT 37231 256 5 is be VBZ 37231 256 6 the the DT 37231 256 7 usual usual JJ 37231 256 8 retort retort NN 37231 256 9 theological theological NN 37231 256 10 , , , 37231 256 11 but but CC 37231 256 12 as as IN 37231 256 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 256 14 have have VBP 37231 256 15 quoted quote VBN 37231 256 16 the the DT 37231 256 17 words word NNS 37231 256 18 of of IN 37231 256 19 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 256 20 the the DT 37231 256 21 reader reader NN 37231 256 22 may may MD 37231 256 23 judge judge VB 37231 256 24 for for IN 37231 256 25 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 256 26 . . . 37231 257 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 257 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 257 3 then then RB 37231 257 4 says say VBZ 37231 257 5 : : : 37231 257 6 " " `` 37231 257 7 The the DT 37231 257 8 clause clause NN 37231 257 9 which which WDT 37231 257 10 follows follow VBZ 37231 257 11 contains contain VBZ 37231 257 12 a a DT 37231 257 13 direct direct JJ 37231 257 14 misstatement misstatement NN 37231 257 15 . . . 37231 258 1 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 37231 258 2 did do VBD 37231 258 3 not not RB 37231 258 4 folly folly RB 37231 258 5 share share VB 37231 258 6 the the DT 37231 258 7 opinion opinion NN 37231 258 8 that that IN 37231 258 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 258 10 were be VBD 37231 258 11 spurious spurious JJ 37231 258 12 ; ; : 37231 258 13 on on IN 37231 258 14 the the DT 37231 258 15 contrary contrary NN 37231 258 16 , , , 37231 258 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 258 18 quotes quote VBZ 37231 258 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 258 20 several several JJ 37231 258 21 times time NNS 37231 258 22 as as IN 37231 258 23 authoritative authoritative JJ 37231 258 24 ; ; : 37231 258 25 but but CC 37231 258 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 258 27 says say VBZ 37231 258 28 that that IN 37231 258 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 258 30 ' ' `` 37231 258 31 seem seem VBP 37231 258 32 to to TO 37231 258 33 have have VB 37231 258 34 been be VBN 37231 258 35 altered alter VBN 37231 258 36 in in IN 37231 258 37 many many JJ 37231 258 38 places place NNS 37231 258 39 to to TO 37231 258 40 strengthen strengthen VB 37231 258 41 the the DT 37231 258 42 position position NN 37231 258 43 of of IN 37231 258 44 the the DT 37231 258 45 Papal Papal NNP 37231 258 46 power power NN 37231 258 47 , , , 37231 258 48 do do VBP 37231 258 49 . . . 37231 258 50 ' ' '' 37231 259 1 " " `` 37231 259 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 259 3 4 4 LS 37231 259 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 259 5 Pearson Pearson NNP 37231 259 6 's 's POS 37231 259 7 statement statement NN 37231 259 8 here here RB 37231 259 9 quoted quote VBN 37231 259 10 must must MD 37231 259 11 be be VB 37231 259 12 received receive VBN 37231 259 13 with with IN 37231 259 14 reserve reserve NN 37231 259 15 , , , 37231 259 16 for for IN 37231 259 17 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 37231 259 18 rather rather RB 37231 259 19 speaks speak VBZ 37231 259 20 sarcastically sarcastically RB 37231 259 21 of of IN 37231 259 22 those those DT 37231 259 23 who who WP 37231 259 24 quote quote VBP 37231 259 25 these these DT 37231 259 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 259 27 as as IN 37231 259 28 evidence evidence NN 37231 259 29 . . . 37231 260 1 In in IN 37231 260 2 treating treat VBG 37231 260 3 them -PRON- PRP 37231 260 4 as as IN 37231 260 5 ancient ancient JJ 37231 260 6 documents document NNS 37231 260 7 or or CC 37231 260 8 speaking speaking NN 37231 260 9 of of IN 37231 260 10 parts part NNS 37231 260 11 of of IN 37231 260 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 260 13 with with IN 37231 260 14 respect respect NN 37231 260 15 , , , 37231 260 16 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 37231 260 17 does do VBZ 37231 260 18 nothing nothing NN 37231 260 19 more more JJR 37231 260 20 than than IN 37231 260 21 the the DT 37231 260 22 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 37231 260 23 Centuriators Centuriators NNP 37231 260 24 , , , 37231 260 25 but but CC 37231 260 26 this this DT 37231 260 27 is be VBZ 37231 260 28 a a DT 37231 260 29 very very RB 37231 260 30 different different JJ 37231 260 31 thing thing NN 37231 260 32 from from IN 37231 260 33 directly directly RB 37231 260 34 ascribing ascribe VBG 37231 260 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 260 36 to to IN 37231 260 37 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 260 38 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 260 39 . . . 37231 261 1 The the DT 37231 261 2 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 261 3 in in IN 37231 261 4 the the DT 37231 261 5 " " `` 37231 261 6 Long long JJ 37231 261 7 Recension Recension NNP 37231 261 8 " " '' 37231 261 9 were be VBD 37231 261 10 before before IN 37231 261 11 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 37231 261 12 both both DT 37231 261 13 in in IN 37231 261 14 the the DT 37231 261 15 Latin latin JJ 37231 261 16 and and CC 37231 261 17 Greek greek JJ 37231 261 18 forms form NNS 37231 261 19 . . . 37231 262 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 262 2 says say VBZ 37231 262 3 of of IN 37231 262 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 262 5 : : : 37231 262 6 " " `` 37231 262 7 .... .... . 37231 262 8 et et NN 37231 262 9 multas multas NNP 37231 262 10 habent habent VBP 37231 262 11 non non JJ 37231 262 12 contemnendas contemnendas NNP 37231 262 13 sententias sententias NNP 37231 262 14 , , , 37231 262 15 presertim presertim NN 37231 262 16 sicut sicut NN 37231 262 17 Graece Graece NNP 37231 262 18 leguntur leguntur NN 37231 262 19 . . . 37231 263 1 Admixta admixta JJ 37231 263 2 vero vero NN 37231 263 3 sunt sunt NN 37231 263 4 et et NNP 37231 263 5 alia alia NNP 37231 263 6 non non NNP 37231 263 7 pauca pauca NNP 37231 263 8 , , , 37231 263 9 quae quae NNP 37231 263 10 profecto profecto NNP 37231 263 11 non non AFX 37231 263 12 referunt referunt NN 37231 263 13 gravitatem gravitatem NN 37231 263 14 Apostolicam Apostolicam NNP 37231 263 15 . . . 37231 264 1 1 1 CD 37231 264 2 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 264 3 's 's POS 37231 264 4 expressions expression NNS 37231 264 5 are be VBP 37231 264 6 : : : 37231 264 7 Nihil nihil JJ 37231 264 8 moniis moniis NN 37231 264 9 illis illis NNP 37231 264 10 , , , 37231 264 11 quro quro NNP 37231 264 12 sub sub NNP 37231 264 13 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 37231 264 14 nomine nomine NN 37231 264 15 editae editae NNP 37231 264 16 sunt sunt NNP 37231 264 17 , , , 37231 264 18 putidius putidius NNP 37231 264 19 . . . 37231 265 1 Quo quo VB 37231 265 2 minus minus CC 37231 265 3 tolerabilis tolerabili VBZ 37231 265 4 est est NNP 37231 265 5 eorum eorum NNP 37231 265 6 impudentia impudentia NN 37231 265 7 , , , 37231 265 8 qui qui NNP 37231 265 9 talibus talibus NNP 37231 265 10 larvis larvis NNP 37231 265 11 ad ad NNP 37231 265 12 fallendum fallendum NN 37231 265 13 se se NNP 37231 265 14 instruunt instruunt NNP 37231 265 15 . . . 37231 266 1 Inst inst RB 37231 266 2 . . . 37231 267 1 Chr Chr NNP 37231 267 2 . . . 37231 268 1 Bel Bel NNP 37231 268 2 . . . 37231 269 1 i. i. NNP 37231 270 1 13 13 CD 37231 270 2 , , , 37231 270 3 p39 p39 CD 37231 270 4 . . . 37231 271 1 { { -LRB- 37231 271 2 xxxi xxxi NNP 37231 271 3 } } -RRB- 37231 271 4 Adulteratas Adulteratas NNP 37231 271 5 enim enim NNP 37231 271 6 jam jam NNP 37231 271 7 esse esse NNP 37231 271 8 illas illas NNP 37231 271 9 epistolas epistolas NNP 37231 271 10 , , , 37231 271 11 vel vel NNP 37231 271 12 inde inde NNP 37231 271 13 colligitur colligitur NNP 37231 271 14 . . . 37231 271 15 " " '' 37231 272 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 272 2 then then RB 37231 272 3 shows show VBZ 37231 272 4 that that IN 37231 272 5 quotations quotation NNS 37231 272 6 in in IN 37231 272 7 ancient ancient JJ 37231 272 8 writers writer NNS 37231 272 9 purporting purport VBG 37231 272 10 to to TO 37231 272 11 be be VB 37231 272 12 taken take VBN 37231 272 13 from from IN 37231 272 14 the the DT 37231 272 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 272 16 of of IN 37231 272 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 272 18 are be VBP 37231 272 19 not not RB 37231 272 20 found find VBN 37231 272 21 in in IN 37231 272 22 these these DT 37231 272 23 extant extant JJ 37231 272 24 epistles epistle NNS 37231 272 25 at at RB 37231 272 26 all all RB 37231 272 27 , , , 37231 272 28 and and CC 37231 272 29 says say VBZ 37231 272 30 : : : 37231 272 31 " " `` 37231 272 32 De De NNP 37231 272 33 Epistolis Epistolis NNP 37231 272 34 igitur igitur NN 37231 272 35 illis illis NNP 37231 272 36 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 37231 272 37 , , , 37231 272 38 quae quae RB 37231 272 39 nunc nunc NNP 37231 272 40 ejus ejus NNP 37231 272 41 titulo titulo NNP 37231 272 42 feruntur feruntur NNP 37231 272 43 , , , 37231 272 44 merito merito NNP 37231 272 45 dubitamus dubitamus NNP 37231 272 46 : : : 37231 272 47 transformatse transformatse NNP 37231 272 48 enim enim NNP 37231 272 49 videntur videntur NNP 37231 272 50 in in IN 37231 272 51 multis multis NNP 37231 272 52 locis locis NN 37231 272 53 , , , 37231 272 54 ad ad NN 37231 272 55 stabiliendum stabiliendum NN 37231 272 56 statum statum NN 37231 272 57 regni regni NNP 37231 272 58 Pontificii Pontificii NNP 37231 272 59 . . . 37231 273 1 " " `` 37231 273 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 273 3 l l NN 37231 273 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 273 5 Even even RB 37231 273 6 when when WRB 37231 273 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 273 8 speaks speak VBZ 37231 273 9 in in IN 37231 273 10 favour favour NN 37231 273 11 of of IN 37231 273 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 273 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 273 14 " " `` 37231 273 15 damns damn VBZ 37231 273 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 273 17 with with IN 37231 273 18 faint faint JJ 37231 273 19 praise praise NN 37231 273 20 . . . 37231 273 21 " " '' 37231 274 1 The the DT 37231 274 2 whole whole NN 37231 274 3 of of IN 37231 274 4 the the DT 37231 274 5 discussion discussion NN 37231 274 6 turns turn VBZ 37231 274 7 upon upon IN 37231 274 8 the the DT 37231 274 9 word word NN 37231 274 10 " " `` 37231 274 11 fully fully RB 37231 274 12 " " '' 37231 274 13 , , , 37231 274 14 and and CC 37231 274 15 is be VBZ 37231 274 16 an an DT 37231 274 17 instance instance NN 37231 274 18 of of IN 37231 274 19 the the DT 37231 274 20 minute minute JJ 37231 274 21 criticism criticism NN 37231 274 22 of of IN 37231 274 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 274 24 critic critic NN 37231 274 25 , , , 37231 274 26 who who WP 37231 274 27 evidently evidently RB 37231 274 28 is be VBZ 37231 274 29 not not RB 37231 274 30 directly directly RB 37231 274 31 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 274 32 with with IN 37231 274 33 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 37231 274 34 . . . 37231 275 1 A a DT 37231 275 2 shade shade NN 37231 275 3 more more RBR 37231 275 4 or or CC 37231 275 5 less less RBR 37231 275 6 of of IN 37231 275 7 doubt doubt NN 37231 275 8 or or CC 37231 275 9 certainty certainty NN 37231 275 10 in in IN 37231 275 11 conveying convey VBG 37231 275 12 the the DT 37231 275 13 impression impression NN 37231 275 14 received receive VBN 37231 275 15 from from IN 37231 275 16 the the DT 37231 275 17 words word NNS 37231 275 18 of of IN 37231 275 19 a a DT 37231 275 20 writer writer NN 37231 275 21 is be VBZ 37231 275 22 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 275 23 worth worth JJ 37231 275 24 much much JJ 37231 275 25 indignation indignation NN 37231 275 26 . . . 37231 276 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 276 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 276 3 makes make VBZ 37231 276 4 a a DT 37231 276 5 very very RB 37231 276 6 detailed detailed JJ 37231 276 7 attack attack NN 37231 276 8 upon upon IN 37231 276 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 276 10 next next JJ 37231 276 11 two two CD 37231 276 12 notes note NNS 37231 276 13 , , , 37231 276 14 and and CC 37231 276 15 here here RB 37231 276 16 again again RB 37231 276 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 276 18 must must MD 37231 276 19 closely closely RB 37231 276 20 follow follow VB 37231 276 21 him -PRON- PRP 37231 276 22 . . . 37231 277 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 277 2 note note NN 37231 277 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 277 4 2 2 LS 37231 277 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 277 6 p. p. NN 37231 277 7 260 260 CD 37231 277 8 reads read NNS 37231 277 9 as as IN 37231 277 10 follows:-- follows:-- -LRB- 37231 277 11 " " `` 37231 277 12 2 2 CD 37231 277 13 By by IN 37231 277 14 Bochartus Bochartus NNP 37231 277 15 , , , 37231 277 16 Aubertin Aubertin NNP 37231 277 17 , , , 37231 277 18 Blondel Blondel NNP 37231 277 19 , , , 37231 277 20 Basnage Basnage NNP 37231 277 21 , , , 37231 277 22 Casaubon Casaubon NNP 37231 277 23 , , , 37231 277 24 Cocus Cocus NNP 37231 277 25 , , , 37231 277 26 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 37231 277 27 , , , 37231 277 28 Rivetus Rivetus NNP 37231 277 29 , , , 37231 277 30 Salmasius Salmasius NNP 37231 277 31 , , , 37231 277 32 Socinus Socinus NNP 37231 277 33 ( ( -LRB- 37231 277 34 Faustus Faustus NNP 37231 277 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 277 36 , , , 37231 277 37 Parker Parker NNP 37231 277 38 , , , 37231 277 39 Petau Petau NNP 37231 277 40 , , , 37231 277 41 & & CC 37231 277 42 c c NNP 37231 277 43 ; ; : 37231 277 44 & & CC 37231 277 45 c. c. NNP 37231 277 46 ; ; : 37231 277 47 cf cf NNP 37231 277 48 . . . 37231 278 1 Jacobson Jacobson NNP 37231 278 2 , , , 37231 278 3 Patr Patr NNP 37231 278 4 . . . 37231 279 1 Apost Apost NNP 37231 279 2 . . . 37231 279 3 , , , 37231 279 4 i. i. NNP 37231 279 5 p. p. NNP 37231 280 1 jolt jolt NN 37231 280 2 . . . 37231 281 1 ; ; : 37231 281 2 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 281 3 Vindiciæ Vindiciæ NNP 37231 281 4 Ignatianæ Ignatianæ NNP 37231 281 5 , , , 37231 281 6 1846 1846 CD 37231 281 7 , , , 37231 281 8 appendix appendix NNP 37231 281 9 . . . 37231 281 10 " " '' 37231 282 1 Upon upon IN 37231 282 2 this this DT 37231 282 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 282 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 282 5 makes make VBZ 37231 282 6 the the DT 37231 282 7 following follow VBG 37231 282 8 preliminary preliminary JJ 37231 282 9 remarks remark NNS 37231 282 10 : : : 37231 282 11 " " `` 37231 282 12 But but CC 37231 282 13 the the DT 37231 282 14 most most RBS 37231 282 15 important important JJ 37231 282 16 point point NN 37231 282 17 of of IN 37231 282 18 all all DT 37231 282 19 is be VBZ 37231 282 20 the the DT 37231 282 21 purpose purpose NN 37231 282 22 for for IN 37231 282 23 which which WDT 37231 282 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 282 25 are be VBP 37231 282 26 quoted quote VBN 37231 282 27 . . . 37231 283 1 ' ' `` 37231 283 2 Similar similar JJ 37231 283 3 doubts doubt NNS 37231 283 4 ' ' '' 37231 283 5 could could MD 37231 283 6 only only RB 37231 283 7 , , , 37231 283 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 283 9 think think VBP 37231 283 10 , , , 37231 283 11 be be VB 37231 283 12 interpreted interpret VBN 37231 283 13 from from IN 37231 283 14 the the DT 37231 283 15 context context NN 37231 283 16 as as IN 37231 283 17 doubts doubt NNS 37231 283 18 ' ' `` 37231 283 19 regarding regard VBG 37231 283 20 the the DT 37231 283 21 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 283 22 of of IN 37231 283 23 any any DT 37231 283 24 of of IN 37231 283 25 the the DT 37231 283 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 283 27 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 283 28 to to IN 37231 283 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 283 30 . . . 37231 284 1 ' ' `` 37231 284 2 " " '' 37231 284 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 284 4 2 2 LS 37231 284 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 284 6 As as IN 37231 284 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 284 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 284 9 , , , 37231 284 10 in in IN 37231 284 11 the the DT 37231 284 12 first first JJ 37231 284 13 sentence sentence NN 37231 284 14 just just RB 37231 284 15 quoted quote VBN 37231 284 16 , , , 37231 284 17 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 284 18 what what WP 37231 284 19 is be VBZ 37231 284 20 " " `` 37231 284 21 the the DT 37231 284 22 most most RBS 37231 284 23 important important JJ 37231 284 24 point point NN 37231 284 25 of of IN 37231 284 26 all all DT 37231 284 27 , , , 37231 284 28 " " `` 37231 284 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 284 30 is be VBZ 37231 284 31 a a DT 37231 284 32 pity pity NN 37231 284 33 that that WDT 37231 284 34 , , , 37231 284 35 throughout throughout IN 37231 284 36 the the DT 37231 284 37 whole whole NN 37231 284 38 of of IN 37231 284 39 the the DT 37231 284 40 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 284 41 analysis analysis NN 37231 284 42 of of IN 37231 284 43 the the DT 37231 284 44 references reference NNS 37231 284 45 in in IN 37231 284 46 question question NN 37231 284 47 , , , 37231 284 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 284 49 persistently persistently RB 37231 284 50 ignores ignore VBZ 37231 284 51 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 284 52 { { -LRB- 37231 284 53 xxxii xxxii NN 37231 284 54 } } -RRB- 37231 284 55 very very RB 37231 284 56 careful careful JJ 37231 284 57 definition definition NN 37231 284 58 of of IN 37231 284 59 " " `` 37231 284 60 the the DT 37231 284 61 purpose purpose NN 37231 284 62 for for IN 37231 284 63 which which WDT 37231 284 64 they -PRON- PRP 37231 284 65 are be VBP 37231 284 66 quoted quote VBN 37231 284 67 . . . 37231 284 68 " " '' 37231 285 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 285 2 is be VBZ 37231 285 3 difficult difficult JJ 37231 285 4 , , , 37231 285 5 without without IN 37231 285 6 entering enter VBG 37231 285 7 into into IN 37231 285 8 minute minute NN 37231 285 9 classifications classification NNS 37231 285 10 , , , 37231 285 11 accurately accurately RB 37231 285 12 to to TO 37231 285 13 represent represent VB 37231 285 14 in in IN 37231 285 15 a a DT 37231 285 16 few few JJ 37231 285 17 words word NNS 37231 285 18 the the DT 37231 285 19 opinions opinion NNS 37231 285 20 of of IN 37231 285 21 a a DT 37231 285 22 great great JJ 37231 285 23 number number NN 37231 285 24 of of IN 37231 285 25 writers writer NNS 37231 285 26 , , , 37231 285 27 and and CC 37231 285 28 briefly briefly RB 37231 285 29 convey convey VB 37231 285 30 a a DT 37231 285 31 fair fair JJ 37231 285 32 idea idea NN 37231 285 33 of of IN 37231 285 34 the the DT 37231 285 35 course course NN 37231 285 36 of of IN 37231 285 37 critical critical JJ 37231 285 38 judgment judgment NN 37231 285 39 . . . 37231 286 1 Desirous desirous JJ 37231 286 2 , , , 37231 286 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 286 4 , , , 37231 286 5 of of IN 37231 286 6 embracing embrace VBG 37231 286 7 a a DT 37231 286 8 large large JJ 37231 286 9 class,--for class,--for NN 37231 286 10 both both PDT 37231 286 11 this this DT 37231 286 12 note note NN 37231 286 13 and and CC 37231 286 14 the the DT 37231 286 15 next next JJ 37231 286 16 , , , 37231 286 17 with with IN 37231 286 18 mere mere JJ 37231 286 19 difference difference NN 37231 286 20 of of IN 37231 286 21 epoch epoch NNP 37231 286 22 , , , 37231 286 23 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 286 24 the the DT 37231 286 25 same same JJ 37231 286 26 statement statement NN 37231 286 27 in in IN 37231 286 28 the the DT 37231 286 29 text,--and text,--and XX 37231 286 30 not not RB 37231 286 31 to to TO 37231 286 32 overstate overstate VB 37231 286 33 the the DT 37231 286 34 case case NN 37231 286 35 on on IN 37231 286 36 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 286 37 own own JJ 37231 286 38 side side NN 37231 286 39 , , , 37231 286 40 I -PRON- PRP 37231 286 41 used use VBD 37231 286 42 what what WP 37231 286 43 seemed seem VBD 37231 286 44 to to IN 37231 286 45 me -PRON- PRP 37231 286 46 a a DT 37231 286 47 very very RB 37231 286 48 moderate moderate JJ 37231 286 49 phrase phrase NN 37231 286 50 , , , 37231 286 51 decreasing decrease VBG 37231 286 52 the the DT 37231 286 53 force force NN 37231 286 54 of of IN 37231 286 55 the the DT 37231 286 56 opinion opinion NN 37231 286 57 of of IN 37231 286 58 those those DT 37231 286 59 who who WP 37231 286 60 positively positively RB 37231 286 61 rejected reject VBD 37231 286 62 the the DT 37231 286 63 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 286 64 , , , 37231 286 65 and and CC 37231 286 66 not not RB 37231 286 67 unfairly unfairly RB 37231 286 68 representing represent VBG 37231 286 69 the the DT 37231 286 70 hesitation hesitation NN 37231 286 71 of of IN 37231 286 72 those those DT 37231 286 73 who who WP 37231 286 74 did do VBD 37231 286 75 not not RB 37231 286 76 fully fully RB 37231 286 77 accept accept VB 37231 286 78 them -PRON- PRP 37231 286 79 . . . 37231 287 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 287 2 said say VBD 37231 287 3 , , , 37231 287 4 then then RB 37231 287 5 , , , 37231 287 6 in in IN 37231 287 7 guarded guard VBN 37231 287 8 terms,--and terms,--and CC 37231 287 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 287 10 italicise italicise VBP 37231 287 11 the the DT 37231 287 12 part part NN 37231 287 13 which which WDT 37231 287 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 287 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 287 16 chooses choose VBZ 37231 287 17 to to IN 37231 287 18 suppress,--that suppress,--that NNP 37231 287 19 " " `` 37231 287 20 similar similar JJ 37231 287 21 _ _ NNP 37231 287 22 doubts doubt NNS 37231 287 23 , , , 37231 287 24 more more RBR 37231 287 25 or or CC 37231 287 26 less less RBR 37231 287 27 definite definite JJ 37231 287 28 _ _ NNP 37231 287 29 , , , 37231 287 30 " " '' 37231 287 31 were be VBD 37231 287 32 expressed express VBN 37231 287 33 by by IN 37231 287 34 the the DT 37231 287 35 writers writer NNS 37231 287 36 referred refer VBD 37231 287 37 to to IN 37231 287 38 . . . 37231 288 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 288 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 288 3 admits admit VBZ 37231 288 4 that that IN 37231 288 5 Bochart Bochart NNP 37231 288 6 directly directly RB 37231 288 7 condemns condemn VBZ 37231 288 8 one one CD 37231 288 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 288 10 , , , 37231 288 11 and and CC 37231 288 12 would would MD 37231 288 13 probably probably RB 37231 288 14 have have VB 37231 288 15 condemned condemn VBN 37231 288 16 the the DT 37231 288 17 rest rest NN 37231 288 18 also also RB 37231 288 19 ; ; : 37231 288 20 that that IN 37231 288 21 Aubertin Aubertin NNP 37231 288 22 , , , 37231 288 23 Blondel Blondel NNP 37231 288 24 , , , 37231 288 25 Basnage Basnage NNP 37231 288 26 , , , 37231 288 27 R. R. NNP 37231 288 28 Parker Parker NNP 37231 288 29 , , , 37231 288 30 and and CC 37231 288 31 Saumaise Saumaise NNP 37231 288 32 actually actually RB 37231 288 33 rejected reject VBD 37231 288 34 all all DT 37231 288 35 ; ; : 37231 288 36 and and CC 37231 288 37 that that IN 37231 288 38 Cook Cook NNP 37231 288 39 pronounces pronounce VBZ 37231 288 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 288 41 " " `` 37231 288 42 either either CC 37231 288 43 supposititious supposititious JJ 37231 288 44 or or CC 37231 288 45 shamefully shamefully RB 37231 288 46 corrupted corrupt VBN 37231 288 47 . . . 37231 288 48 " " '' 37231 289 1 So so RB 37231 289 2 far far RB 37231 289 3 , , , 37231 289 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 289 5 , , , 37231 289 6 there there EX 37231 289 7 can can MD 37231 289 8 be be VB 37231 289 9 no no DT 37231 289 10 dispute dispute NN 37231 289 11 . . . 37231 290 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 290 2 will will MD 37231 290 3 now now RB 37231 290 4 take take VB 37231 290 5 the the DT 37231 290 6 rest rest NN 37231 290 7 in in IN 37231 290 8 succession succession NN 37231 290 9 . . . 37231 291 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 291 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 291 3 says say VBZ 37231 291 4 that that IN 37231 291 5 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 37231 291 6 " " `` 37231 291 7 considers consider VBZ 37231 291 8 that that IN 37231 291 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 291 10 have have VBP 37231 291 11 been be VBN 37231 291 12 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 291 13 and and CC 37231 291 14 mutilated mutilate VBN 37231 291 15 , , , 37231 291 16 but but CC 37231 291 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 291 18 believes believe VBZ 37231 291 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 291 20 genuine genuine RB 37231 291 21 in in IN 37231 291 22 the the DT 37231 291 23 main main NN 37231 291 24 . . . 37231 291 25 " " '' 37231 292 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 292 2 Google Google NNP 37231 292 3 has have VBZ 37231 292 4 so so RB 37231 292 5 completely completely RB 37231 292 6 warped warp VBN 37231 292 7 the the DT 37231 292 8 statement statement NN 37231 292 9 in in IN 37231 292 10 the the DT 37231 292 11 text text NN 37231 292 12 , , , 37231 292 13 that that IN 37231 292 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 292 15 seems seem VBZ 37231 292 16 to to TO 37231 292 17 demand demand VB 37231 292 18 nothing nothing NN 37231 292 19 short short JJ 37231 292 20 of of IN 37231 292 21 a a DT 37231 292 22 total total JJ 37231 292 23 condemnation condemnation NN 37231 292 24 of of IN 37231 292 25 the the DT 37231 292 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 292 27 in in IN 37231 292 28 the the DT 37231 292 29 note note NN 37231 292 30 , , , 37231 292 31 but but CC 37231 292 32 had have VBD 37231 292 33 I -PRON- PRP 37231 292 34 intended intend VBN 37231 292 35 to to TO 37231 292 36 say say VB 37231 292 37 that that IN 37231 292 38 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 37231 292 39 and and CC 37231 292 40 all all DT 37231 292 41 of of IN 37231 292 42 these these DT 37231 292 43 writers writer NNS 37231 292 44 definitely definitely RB 37231 292 45 rejected reject VBD 37231 292 46 the the DT 37231 292 47 whole whole NN 37231 292 48 of of IN 37231 292 49 the the DT 37231 292 50 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 292 51 I -PRON- PRP 37231 292 52 should should MD 37231 292 53 not not RB 37231 292 54 have have VB 37231 292 55 limited limit VBN 37231 292 56 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 292 57 to to IN 37231 292 58 merely merely RB 37231 292 59 saying say VBG 37231 292 60 that that IN 37231 292 61 they -PRON- PRP 37231 292 62 expressed express VBD 37231 292 63 " " `` 37231 292 64 doubts doubt NNS 37231 292 65 more more RBR 37231 292 66 or or CC 37231 292 67 less less RBR 37231 292 68 definite definite JJ 37231 292 69 , , , 37231 292 70 " " '' 37231 292 71 which which WDT 37231 292 72 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 37231 292 73 does do VBZ 37231 292 74 . . . 37231 293 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 293 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 293 3 says say VBZ 37231 293 4 that that IN 37231 293 5 Socinus Socinus NNP 37231 293 6 " " `` 37231 293 7 denounces denounce VBZ 37231 293 8 corruptions corruption NNS 37231 293 9 and and CC 37231 293 10 { { -LRB- 37231 293 11 xxxiii xxxiii NN 37231 293 12 } } -RRB- 37231 293 13 anachronisms anachronism NNS 37231 293 14 , , , 37231 293 15 but but CC 37231 293 16 so so RB 37231 293 17 far far RB 37231 293 18 as as IN 37231 293 19 I -PRON- PRP 37231 293 20 can can MD 37231 293 21 see see VB 37231 293 22 does do VBZ 37231 293 23 not not RB 37231 293 24 question question VB 37231 293 25 a a DT 37231 293 26 nucleus nucleus NN 37231 293 27 of of IN 37231 293 28 genuine genuine JJ 37231 293 29 matter matter NN 37231 293 30 . . . 37231 293 31 " " '' 37231 294 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 294 2 very very JJ 37231 294 3 denunciations denunciation NNS 37231 294 4 , , , 37231 294 5 however however RB 37231 294 6 , , , 37231 294 7 are be VBP 37231 294 8 certainly certainly RB 37231 294 9 the the DT 37231 294 10 expression expression NN 37231 294 11 of of IN 37231 294 12 " " `` 37231 294 13 doubts doubt NNS 37231 294 14 , , , 37231 294 15 more more RBR 37231 294 16 or or CC 37231 294 17 less less RBR 37231 294 18 definite definite JJ 37231 294 19 . . . 37231 294 20 " " '' 37231 295 1 " " `` 37231 295 2 Casaubon casaubon NN 37231 295 3 , , , 37231 295 4 so so RB 37231 295 5 far far RB 37231 295 6 from from IN 37231 295 7 rejecting reject VBG 37231 295 8 them -PRON- PRP 37231 295 9 altogether altogether RB 37231 295 10 , , , 37231 295 11 " " '' 37231 295 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 295 13 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 295 14 says say VBZ 37231 295 15 , , , 37231 295 16 " " `` 37231 295 17 promises promise VBZ 37231 295 18 to to TO 37231 295 19 defend defend VB 37231 295 20 the the DT 37231 295 21 antiquity antiquity NN 37231 295 22 of of IN 37231 295 23 some some DT 37231 295 24 of of IN 37231 295 25 the the DT 37231 295 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 295 27 with with IN 37231 295 28 new new JJ 37231 295 29 arguments argument NNS 37231 295 30 . . . 37231 295 31 " " '' 37231 296 1 But but CC 37231 296 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 296 3 have have VBP 37231 296 4 never never RB 37231 296 5 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 296 6 that that IN 37231 296 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 296 8 " " `` 37231 296 9 rejected reject VBD 37231 296 10 them -PRON- PRP 37231 296 11 altogether altogether RB 37231 296 12 . . . 37231 296 13 " " '' 37231 297 1 Casaubon casaubon NN 37231 297 2 died die VBD 37231 297 3 before before IN 37231 297 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 297 5 fulfilled fulfil VBD 37231 297 6 the the DT 37231 297 7 promise promise NN 37231 297 8 referred refer VBN 37231 297 9 to to IN 37231 297 10 , , , 37231 297 11 so so IN 37231 297 12 that that IN 37231 297 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 297 14 can can MD 37231 297 15 not not RB 37231 297 16 determine determine VB 37231 297 17 what what WP 37231 297 18 arguments argument NNS 37231 297 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 297 20 might may MD 37231 297 21 have have VB 37231 297 22 used use VBN 37231 297 23 . . . 37231 298 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 298 2 must must MD 37231 298 3 point point VB 37231 298 4 out out RP 37231 298 5 , , , 37231 298 6 however however RB 37231 298 7 , , , 37231 298 8 that that IN 37231 298 9 the the DT 37231 298 10 antiquity antiquity NN 37231 298 11 does do VBZ 37231 298 12 not not RB 37231 298 13 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 298 14 involve involve VB 37231 298 15 the the DT 37231 298 16 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 298 17 of of IN 37231 298 18 a a DT 37231 298 19 document document NN 37231 298 20 . . . 37231 299 1 With with IN 37231 299 2 regard regard NN 37231 299 3 to to IN 37231 299 4 Rivet Rivet NNP 37231 299 5 the the DT 37231 299 6 case case NN 37231 299 7 is be VBZ 37231 299 8 different different JJ 37231 299 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 299 10 had have VBD 37231 299 11 overlooked overlook VBN 37231 299 12 the the DT 37231 299 13 fact fact NN 37231 299 14 that that IN 37231 299 15 in in IN 37231 299 16 a a DT 37231 299 17 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 299 18 edition edition NN 37231 299 19 of of IN 37231 299 20 the the DT 37231 299 21 work work NN 37231 299 22 referred refer VBD 37231 299 23 to to IN 37231 299 24 , , , 37231 299 25 after after IN 37231 299 26 receiving receive VBG 37231 299 27 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 299 28 Ushers Ushers NNP 37231 299 29 edition edition NN 37231 299 30 of of IN 37231 299 31 the the DT 37231 299 32 Short Short NNP 37231 299 33 Recension Recension NNP 37231 299 34 , , , 37231 299 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 299 36 had have VBD 37231 299 37 given give VBN 37231 299 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 299 39 adhesion adhesion NN 37231 299 40 to to IN 37231 299 41 " " `` 37231 299 42 that that DT 37231 299 43 form form NN 37231 299 44 of of IN 37231 299 45 the the DT 37231 299 46 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 299 47 . . . 37231 300 1 " " `` 37231 300 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 300 3 1 1 LS 37231 300 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 300 5 This this DT 37231 300 6 fact fact NN 37231 300 7 is be VBZ 37231 300 8 also also RB 37231 300 9 mentioned mention VBN 37231 300 10 by by IN 37231 300 11 Pearson Pearson NNP 37231 300 12 , , , 37231 300 13 and and CC 37231 300 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 300 15 ought ought MD 37231 300 16 to to TO 37231 300 17 have have VB 37231 300 18 observed observe VBN 37231 300 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 300 20 . . . 37231 301 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 301 2 2 2 LS 37231 301 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 301 4 Petau Petau NNP 37231 301 5 , , , 37231 301 6 the the DT 37231 301 7 last last JJ 37231 301 8 of of IN 37231 301 9 the the DT 37231 301 10 writers writer NNS 37231 301 11 referred refer VBD 37231 301 12 to to IN 37231 301 13 , , , 37231 301 14 says say VBZ 37231 301 15 : : : 37231 301 16 " " `` 37231 301 17 Equidem Equidem NNP 37231 301 18 haud haud VBP 37231 301 19 abnuerim abnuerim JJ 37231 301 20 epistolas epistolas NNP 37231 301 21 illius illius NNP 37231 301 22 varie varie NNP 37231 301 23 interpolatas interpolatas NNP 37231 301 24 et et NNP 37231 301 25 quibusdam quibusdam NNP 37231 301 26 additis additis NNP 37231 301 27 mutatas mutatas NNP 37231 301 28 , , , 37231 301 29 ac ac NNP 37231 301 30 depravatas depravatas NNP 37231 301 31 fuisse fuisse NNP 37231 301 32 : : : 37231 301 33 turn turn VB 37231 301 34 aliquas aliquas NNP 37231 301 35 esse esse NNP 37231 301 36 supposititias supposititias NNP 37231 301 37 : : : 37231 301 38 verum verum NNP 37231 301 39 nullas nullas NNP 37231 301 40 omnino omnino NNP 37231 301 41 ab ab NNP 37231 301 42 Ignatio Ignatio NNP 37231 301 43 Epistolas Epistolas NNP 37231 301 44 esse esse VBP 37231 301 45 scriptas scripta NNS 37231 301 46 , , , 37231 301 47 i -PRON- PRP 37231 301 48 d d VBD 37231 301 49 vero vero NNP 37231 301 50 nimium nimium NN 37231 301 51 temere temere RB 37231 301 52 affirmari affirmari NNP 37231 301 53 sentio sentio VBP 37231 301 54 . . . 37231 301 55 " " '' 37231 302 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 302 2 then then RB 37231 302 3 goes go VBZ 37231 302 4 on on RP 37231 302 5 to to TO 37231 302 6 mention mention VB 37231 302 7 the the DT 37231 302 8 recent recent JJ 37231 302 9 publication publication NN 37231 302 10 of of IN 37231 302 11 the the DT 37231 302 12 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 302 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 302 14 and and CC 37231 302 15 the the DT 37231 302 16 version version NN 37231 302 17 of of IN 37231 302 18 Usher Usher NNP 37231 302 19 , , , 37231 302 20 and and CC 37231 302 21 the the DT 37231 302 22 learned learn VBN 37231 302 23 Jesuit Jesuit NNP 37231 302 24 Father Father NNP 37231 302 25 has have VBZ 37231 302 26 no no DT 37231 302 27 more more RBR 37231 302 28 decided decide VBN 37231 302 29 opinion opinion NN 37231 302 30 to to TO 37231 302 31 express express VB 37231 302 32 than than IN 37231 302 33 : : : 37231 302 34 " " `` 37231 302 35 ut ut NNP 37231 302 36 haec haec NNP 37231 302 37 prudens pruden NNS 37231 302 38 , , , 37231 302 39 ac ac NNP 37231 302 40 justa justa NNP 37231 302 41 suspicio suspicio NNP 37231 302 42 sit sit NNP 37231 302 43 , , , 37231 302 44 illas illa NNS 37231 302 45 esse esse NNP 37231 302 46 genuinas genuinas NNP 37231 302 47 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 37231 302 48 epistolas epistola NNS 37231 302 49 , , , 37231 302 50 quas quas NNP 37231 302 51 antiquorum antiquorum NNP 37231 302 52 consensus consensus NNP 37231 302 53 illustribus illustribus NNP 37231 302 54 testimoniis testimoniis NNP 37231 302 55 commendatas commendatas NNP 37231 302 56 ac ac NNP 37231 302 57 approbatas approbatas NNP 37231 302 58 reliquit"(3 reliquit"(3 NNP 37231 302 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 302 60 The the DT 37231 302 61 next next JJ 37231 302 62 note note NN 37231 302 63 ( ( -LRB- 37231 302 64 3 3 CD 37231 302 65 ) ) -RRB- 37231 302 66 , , , 37231 302 67 p. p. NN 37231 302 68 260 260 CD 37231 302 69 , , , 37231 302 70 was be VBD 37231 302 71 only only RB 37231 302 72 separated separate VBN 37231 302 73 from from IN 37231 302 74 the the DT 37231 302 75 { { -LRB- 37231 302 76 xxxiv xxxiv NN 37231 302 77 } } -RRB- 37231 302 78 preceding precede VBG 37231 302 79 for for IN 37231 302 80 convenience convenience NN 37231 302 81 of of IN 37231 302 82 reference reference NN 37231 302 83 , , , 37231 302 84 and and CC 37231 302 85 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 302 86 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 302 87 quotes quote VBZ 37231 302 88 and and CC 37231 302 89 comments comment NNS 37231 302 90 upon upon IN 37231 302 91 it -PRON- PRP 37231 302 92 as as IN 37231 302 93 follows follow VBZ 37231 302 94 : : : 37231 302 95 " " `` 37231 302 96 The the DT 37231 302 97 next next JJ 37231 302 98 note note NN 37231 302 99 , , , 37231 302 100 p. p. NN 37231 302 101 260 260 CD 37231 302 102 , , , 37231 302 103 is be VBZ 37231 302 104 as as IN 37231 302 105 follows:--(See follows:--(See `` 37231 302 106 scanned scan VBN 37231 302 107 page page NN 37231 302 108 . . . 37231 303 1 Ed Ed NNP 37231 303 2 . . . 37231 303 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 304 1 The the DT 37231 304 2 brackets bracket NNS 37231 304 3 are be VBP 37231 304 4 not not RB 37231 304 5 the the DT 37231 304 6 author author NN 37231 304 7 's 's POS 37231 304 8 , , , 37231 304 9 but but CC 37231 304 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 304 11 own own JJ 37231 304 12 . . . 37231 305 1 This this DT 37231 305 2 is be VBZ 37231 305 3 doubtless doubtless RB 37231 305 4 one one CD 37231 305 5 of of IN 37231 305 6 those those DT 37231 305 7 exhibitions exhibition NNS 37231 305 8 of of IN 37231 305 9 learning learning NN 37231 305 10 which which WDT 37231 305 11 have have VBP 37231 305 12 made make VBN 37231 305 13 such such PDT 37231 305 14 a a DT 37231 305 15 deep deep JJ 37231 305 16 impression impression NN 37231 305 17 on on IN 37231 305 18 the the DT 37231 305 19 reviewers reviewer NNS 37231 305 20 . . . 37231 306 1 Certainly certainly RB 37231 306 2 , , , 37231 306 3 as as IN 37231 306 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 306 5 stands stand VBZ 37231 306 6 , , , 37231 306 7 this this DT 37231 306 8 note note NN 37231 306 9 suggests suggest VBZ 37231 306 10 a a DT 37231 306 11 thorough thorough JJ 37231 306 12 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 306 13 with with IN 37231 306 14 all all PDT 37231 306 15 the the DT 37231 306 16 by by NN 37231 306 17 - - HYPH 37231 306 18 paths path NNS 37231 306 19 of of IN 37231 306 20 the the DT 37231 306 21 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 306 22 literature literature NN 37231 306 23 , , , 37231 306 24 and and CC 37231 306 25 seems seem VBZ 37231 306 26 to to TO 37231 306 27 represent represent VB 37231 306 28 the the DT 37231 306 29 gleanings gleaning NNS 37231 306 30 of of IN 37231 306 31 many many JJ 37231 306 32 years year NNS 37231 306 33 ' ' POS 37231 306 34 reading reading NN 37231 306 35 . . . 37231 307 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 307 2 is be VBZ 37231 307 3 important important JJ 37231 307 4 to to TO 37231 307 5 observe observe VB 37231 307 6 , , , 37231 307 7 however however RB 37231 307 8 , , , 37231 307 9 that that IN 37231 307 10 every every DT 37231 307 11 one one CD 37231 307 12 of of IN 37231 307 13 these these DT 37231 307 14 references reference NNS 37231 307 15 , , , 37231 307 16 except except IN 37231 307 17 those those DT 37231 307 18 which which WDT 37231 307 19 I -PRON- PRP 37231 307 20 have have VBP 37231 307 21 included include VBN 37231 307 22 in in IN 37231 307 23 brackets bracket NNS 37231 307 24 , , , 37231 307 25 is be VBZ 37231 307 26 given give VBN 37231 307 27 in in IN 37231 307 28 the the DT 37231 307 29 appendix appendix NNP 37231 307 30 to to IN 37231 307 31 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 307 32 's 's POS 37231 307 33 _ _ NNP 37231 307 34 Vindicia Vindicia NNP 37231 307 35 Ignatianæ Ignatianæ NNP 37231 307 36 _ _ NNP 37231 307 37 , , , 37231 307 38 where where WRB 37231 307 39 the the DT 37231 307 40 passages passage NNS 37231 307 41 are be VBP 37231 307 42 quoted quote VBN 37231 307 43 in in IN 37231 307 44 full full JJ 37231 307 45 . . . 37231 308 1 Thus thus RB 37231 308 2 two two CD 37231 308 3 - - HYPH 37231 308 4 thirds third NNS 37231 308 5 of of IN 37231 308 6 this this DT 37231 308 7 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 308 8 note note NN 37231 308 9 might may MD 37231 308 10 have have VB 37231 308 11 been be VBN 37231 308 12 compiled compile VBN 37231 308 13 in in IN 37231 308 14 ten ten CD 37231 308 15 minutes minute NNS 37231 308 16 . . . 37231 309 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 309 2 author author NN 37231 309 3 has have VBZ 37231 309 4 here here RB 37231 309 5 and and CC 37231 309 6 there there EX 37231 309 7 transposed transpose VBD 37231 309 8 the the DT 37231 309 9 order order NN 37231 309 10 of of IN 37231 309 11 the the DT 37231 309 12 quotations quotation NNS 37231 309 13 , , , 37231 309 14 and and CC 37231 309 15 confused confuse VBD 37231 309 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 309 17 by by IN 37231 309 18 so so RB 37231 309 19 doing do VBG 37231 309 20 , , , 37231 309 21 for for IN 37231 309 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 309 23 is be VBZ 37231 309 24 chronological chronological JJ 37231 309 25 in in IN 37231 309 26 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 309 27 . . . 37231 310 1 But but CC 37231 310 2 what what WP 37231 310 3 purpose purpose NN 37231 310 4 was be VBD 37231 310 5 served serve VBN 37231 310 6 by by IN 37231 310 7 thus thus RB 37231 310 8 importing import VBG 37231 310 9 into into IN 37231 310 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 310 11 notes note NNS 37231 310 12 a a DT 37231 310 13 mass mass NN 37231 310 14 of of IN 37231 310 15 borrowed borrow VBN 37231 310 16 and and CC 37231 310 17 unsorted unsorted JJ 37231 310 18 references reference NNS 37231 310 19 ? ? . 37231 311 1 And and CC 37231 311 2 , , , 37231 311 3 if if IN 37231 311 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 311 5 thought think VBD 37231 311 6 fit fit JJ 37231 311 7 to to TO 37231 311 8 do do VB 37231 311 9 so so RB 37231 311 10 , , , 37231 311 11 why why WRB 37231 311 12 was be VBD 37231 311 13 the the DT 37231 311 14 key key JJ 37231 311 15 - - HYPH 37231 311 16 reference reference NN 37231 311 17 to to IN 37231 311 18 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 311 19 buried bury VBN 37231 311 20 among among IN 37231 311 21 the the DT 37231 311 22 rest rest NN 37231 311 23 , , , 37231 311 24 so so IN 37231 311 25 that that IN 37231 311 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 311 27 stands stand VBZ 37231 311 28 in in IN 37231 311 29 immediate immediate JJ 37231 311 30 connection connection NN 37231 311 31 with with IN 37231 311 32 some some DT 37231 311 33 additional additional JJ 37231 311 34 references reference NNS 37231 311 35 on on IN 37231 311 36 which which WDT 37231 311 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 311 38 has have VBZ 37231 311 39 no no DT 37231 311 40 bearing bearing NN 37231 311 41 ? ? . 37231 312 1 " " `` 37231 312 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 312 3 1 1 LS 37231 312 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 312 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 312 6 do do VBP 37231 312 7 not not RB 37231 312 8 see see VB 37231 312 9 any any DT 37231 312 10 special special JJ 37231 312 11 virtue virtue NN 37231 312 12 in in IN 37231 312 13 the the DT 37231 312 14 amount amount NN 37231 312 15 of of IN 37231 312 16 time time NN 37231 312 17 which which WDT 37231 312 18 might may MD 37231 312 19 suffice suffice VB 37231 312 20 , , , 37231 312 21 under under IN 37231 312 22 some some DT 37231 312 23 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 312 24 , , , 37231 312 25 to to TO 37231 312 26 compile compile VB 37231 312 27 a a DT 37231 312 28 note note NN 37231 312 29 , , , 37231 312 30 although although IN 37231 312 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 312 32 is be VBZ 37231 312 33 here here RB 37231 312 34 advanced advanced JJ 37231 312 35 as as IN 37231 312 36 an an DT 37231 312 37 important important JJ 37231 312 38 { { -LRB- 37231 312 39 xxxv xxxv NNS 37231 312 40 } } -RRB- 37231 312 41 point point NN 37231 312 42 to to TO 37231 312 43 observe observe VB 37231 312 44 , , , 37231 312 45 but but CC 37231 312 46 I -PRON- PRP 37231 312 47 call call VBP 37231 312 48 attention attention NN 37231 312 49 to to IN 37231 312 50 the the DT 37231 312 51 unfair unfair JJ 37231 312 52 spirit spirit NN 37231 312 53 in in IN 37231 312 54 which which WDT 37231 312 55 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 312 56 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 312 57 's 's POS 37231 312 58 criticisms criticism NNS 37231 312 59 are be VBP 37231 312 60 made make VBN 37231 312 61 . . . 37231 313 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 313 2 ask ask VBP 37231 313 3 every every DT 37231 313 4 just just RB 37231 313 5 - - HYPH 37231 313 6 minded minded JJ 37231 313 7 reader reader NN 37231 313 8 to to TO 37231 313 9 consider consider VB 37231 313 10 what what WP 37231 313 11 right right UH 37231 313 12 any any DT 37231 313 13 critic critic NN 37231 313 14 has have VBZ 37231 313 15 to to TO 37231 313 16 insinuate insinuate VB 37231 313 17 , , , 37231 313 18 if if IN 37231 313 19 not not RB 37231 313 20 directly directly RB 37231 313 21 to to TO 37231 313 22 say say VB 37231 313 23 , , , 37231 313 24 that that IN 37231 313 25 , , , 37231 313 26 because because IN 37231 313 27 some some DT 37231 313 28 of of IN 37231 313 29 the the DT 37231 313 30 references reference NNS 37231 313 31 in in IN 37231 313 32 a a DT 37231 313 33 note note NN 37231 313 34 are be VBP 37231 313 35 also also RB 37231 313 36 given give VBN 37231 313 37 by by IN 37231 313 38 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 313 39 , , , 37231 313 40 I -PRON- PRP 37231 313 41 simply simply RB 37231 313 42 took take VBD 37231 313 43 them -PRON- PRP 37231 313 44 from from IN 37231 313 45 him -PRON- PRP 37231 313 46 , , , 37231 313 47 and and CC 37231 313 48 thus thus RB 37231 313 49 " " `` 37231 313 50 imported import VBN 37231 313 51 into into IN 37231 313 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 313 53 notes note NNS 37231 313 54 a a DT 37231 313 55 mass mass NN 37231 313 56 of of IN 37231 313 57 borrowed borrow VBN 37231 313 58 and and CC 37231 313 59 unsorted unsorted JJ 37231 313 60 references reference NNS 37231 313 61 , , , 37231 313 62 " " '' 37231 313 63 and and CC 37231 313 64 further far RBR 37231 313 65 to to TO 37231 313 66 insinuate insinuate VB 37231 313 67 that that IN 37231 313 68 I -PRON- PRP 37231 313 69 " " `` 37231 313 70 here here RB 37231 313 71 and and CC 37231 313 72 there there EX 37231 313 73 transposed transpose VBD 37231 313 74 the the DT 37231 313 75 order order NN 37231 313 76 " " `` 37231 313 77 apparently apparently RB 37231 313 78 to to TO 37231 313 79 conceal conceal VB 37231 313 80 the the DT 37231 313 81 source source NN 37231 313 82 ? ? . 37231 314 1 This this DT 37231 314 2 is be VBZ 37231 314 3 a a DT 37231 314 4 kind kind NN 37231 314 5 of of IN 37231 314 6 criticism criticism NN 37231 314 7 which which WDT 37231 314 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 314 9 very very RB 37231 314 10 gladly gladly RB 37231 314 11 relinquish relinquish VBP 37231 314 12 entirely entirely RB 37231 314 13 to to IN 37231 314 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 314 15 high high JJ 37231 314 16 - - HYPH 37231 314 17 minded minded JJ 37231 314 18 and and CC 37231 314 19 reverend reverend JJ 37231 314 20 opponent opponent NN 37231 314 21 . . . 37231 315 1 Now now RB 37231 315 2 , , , 37231 315 3 as as IN 37231 315 4 full full JJ 37231 315 5 quotations quotation NNS 37231 315 6 are be VBP 37231 315 7 given give VBN 37231 315 8 in in IN 37231 315 9 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 315 10 's 's POS 37231 315 11 appendix appendix NNP 37231 315 12 , , , 37231 315 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 315 14 should should MD 37231 315 15 have have VB 37231 315 16 been be VBN 37231 315 17 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 315 18 entitled entitle VBN 37231 315 19 to to TO 37231 315 20 take take VB 37231 315 21 references reference NNS 37231 315 22 from from IN 37231 315 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 315 24 , , , 37231 315 25 had have VBD 37231 315 26 I -PRON- PRP 37231 315 27 pleased pleased JJ 37231 315 28 , , , 37231 315 29 and and CC 37231 315 30 for for IN 37231 315 31 the the DT 37231 315 32 convenience convenience NN 37231 315 33 of of IN 37231 315 34 many many JJ 37231 315 35 readers reader NNS 37231 315 36 I -PRON- PRP 37231 315 37 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 315 38 indicate indicate VBP 37231 315 39 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 315 40 's 's POS 37231 315 41 work work NN 37231 315 42 , , , 37231 315 43 in in IN 37231 315 44 the the DT 37231 315 45 note note NN 37231 315 46 , , , 37231 315 47 as as IN 37231 315 48 a a DT 37231 315 49 source source NN 37231 315 50 to to TO 37231 315 51 be be VB 37231 315 52 compared compare VBN 37231 315 53 . . . 37231 316 1 The the DT 37231 316 2 fact fact NN 37231 316 3 is be VBZ 37231 316 4 , , , 37231 316 5 however however RB 37231 316 6 , , , 37231 316 7 that that IN 37231 316 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 316 9 did do VBD 37231 316 10 not not RB 37231 316 11 take take VB 37231 316 12 the the DT 37231 316 13 references reference NNS 37231 316 14 from from IN 37231 316 15 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 316 16 , , , 37231 316 17 but but CC 37231 316 18 in in IN 37231 316 19 every every DT 37231 316 20 case case NN 37231 316 21 derived derive VBD 37231 316 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 316 23 from from IN 37231 316 24 the the DT 37231 316 25 works work NNS 37231 316 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 316 27 , , , 37231 316 28 and and CC 37231 316 29 if if IN 37231 316 30 the the DT 37231 316 31 note note NN 37231 316 32 " " `` 37231 316 33 seems seem VBZ 37231 316 34 to to TO 37231 316 35 represent represent VB 37231 316 36 the the DT 37231 316 37 gleanings gleaning NNS 37231 316 38 of of IN 37231 316 39 many many JJ 37231 316 40 years year NNS 37231 316 41 ' ' POS 37231 316 42 reading reading NN 37231 316 43 , , , 37231 316 44 " " `` 37231 316 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 316 46 certainly certainly RB 37231 316 47 does do VBZ 37231 316 48 not not RB 37231 316 49 misrepresent misrepresent VB 37231 316 50 the the DT 37231 316 51 fact fact NN 37231 316 52 , , , 37231 316 53 for for CC 37231 316 54 I -PRON- PRP 37231 316 55 took take VBD 37231 316 56 the the DT 37231 316 57 trouble trouble NN 37231 316 58 to to TO 37231 316 59 make make VB 37231 316 60 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 316 61 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 316 62 with with IN 37231 316 63 the the DT 37231 316 64 " " `` 37231 316 65 by by IN 37231 316 66 - - HYPH 37231 316 67 paths path NNS 37231 316 68 of of IN 37231 316 69 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 316 70 literature literature NN 37231 316 71 . . . 37231 316 72 " " '' 37231 317 1 Now now RB 37231 317 2 in in IN 37231 317 3 analysing analyse VBG 37231 317 4 the the DT 37231 317 5 references reference NNS 37231 317 6 in in IN 37231 317 7 this this DT 37231 317 8 note note NN 37231 317 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 317 10 must must MD 37231 317 11 be be VB 37231 317 12 borne bear VBN 37231 317 13 in in IN 37231 317 14 mind mind NN 37231 317 15 that that IN 37231 317 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 317 17 illustrate illustrate VBP 37231 317 18 the the DT 37231 317 19 statement statement NN 37231 317 20 that that IN 37231 317 21 " " `` 37231 317 22 _ _ NNP 37231 317 23 doubts doubt NNS 37231 317 24 , , , 37231 317 25 more more RBR 37231 317 26 or or CC 37231 317 27 less less RBR 37231 317 28 definite definite JJ 37231 317 29 _ _ NNP 37231 317 30 " " '' 37231 317 31 continued continue VBD 37231 317 32 to to TO 37231 317 33 be be VB 37231 317 34 expressed express VBN 37231 317 35 regarding regard VBG 37231 317 36 the the DT 37231 317 37 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 317 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 317 39 . . . 37231 318 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 318 2 am be VBP 37231 318 3 much much RB 37231 318 4 obliged oblige VBN 37231 318 5 to to IN 37231 318 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 318 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 318 8 for for IN 37231 318 9 drawing draw VBG 37231 318 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 318 11 attention attention NN 37231 318 12 to to IN 37231 318 13 Wotton Wotton NNP 37231 318 14 . . . 37231 319 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 319 2 name name NN 37231 319 3 is be VBZ 37231 319 4 the the DT 37231 319 5 first first JJ 37231 319 6 in in IN 37231 319 7 the the DT 37231 319 8 note note NN 37231 319 9 , , , 37231 319 10 and and CC 37231 319 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 319 12 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37231 319 13 was be VBD 37231 319 14 the the DT 37231 319 15 last last JJ 37231 319 16 in in IN 37231 319 17 a a DT 37231 319 18 list list NN 37231 319 19 on on IN 37231 319 20 another another DT 37231 319 21 point point NN 37231 319 22 in in IN 37231 319 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 319 24 note note NN 37231 319 25 - - HYPH 37231 319 26 book book NN 37231 319 27 , , , 37231 319 28 immediately immediately RB 37231 319 29 preceding precede VBG 37231 319 30 this this DT 37231 319 31 one one NN 37231 319 32 , , , 37231 319 33 and and CC 37231 319 34 was be VBD 37231 319 35 by by IN 37231 319 36 mistake mistake NN 37231 319 37 included include VBN 37231 319 38 in in IN 37231 319 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 319 40 . . . 37231 320 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 320 2 also also RB 37231 320 3 frankly frankly RB 37231 320 4 give give VBP 37231 320 5 up up RP 37231 320 6 Weismann Weismann NNP 37231 320 7 , , , 37231 320 8 whose whose WP$ 37231 320 9 doubts doubt NNS 37231 320 10 I -PRON- PRP 37231 320 11 find find VBP 37231 320 12 I -PRON- PRP 37231 320 13 had have VBD 37231 320 14 exaggerated exaggerate VBN 37231 320 15 , , , 37231 320 16 and and CC 37231 320 17 proceed proceed VB 37231 320 18 to to TO 37231 320 19 examine examine VB 37231 320 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 320 21 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 320 22 's 's POS 37231 320 23 further further JJ 37231 320 24 statements statement NNS 37231 320 25 . . . 37231 321 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 321 2 says say VBZ 37231 321 3 that that IN 37231 321 4 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 37231 321 5 { { -LRB- 37231 321 6 xxxvi xxxvi NNP 37231 321 7 } } -RRB- 37231 321 8 uses use VBZ 37231 321 9 the the DT 37231 321 10 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 321 11 as as IN 37231 321 12 genuine genuine JJ 37231 321 13 , , , 37231 321 14 and and CC 37231 321 15 that that IN 37231 321 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 321 17 only only JJ 37231 321 18 doubt doubt NN 37231 321 19 is be VBZ 37231 321 20 whether whether IN 37231 321 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 321 22 ought ought MD 37231 321 23 not not RB 37231 321 24 to to TO 37231 321 25 accept accept VB 37231 321 26 the the DT 37231 321 27 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 321 28 . . . 37231 322 1 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 37231 322 2 , , , 37231 322 3 however however RB 37231 322 4 , , , 37231 322 5 admits admit VBZ 37231 322 6 that that IN 37231 322 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 322 8 can can MD 37231 322 9 not not RB 37231 322 10 quote quote VB 37231 322 11 either either CC 37231 322 12 the the DT 37231 322 13 seven seven CD 37231 322 14 or or CC 37231 322 15 the the DT 37231 322 16 three three CD 37231 322 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 322 18 as as IN 37231 322 19 genuine genuine JJ 37231 322 20 . . . 37231 323 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 323 2 says say VBZ 37231 323 3 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 323 4 : : : 37231 323 5 " " `` 37231 323 6 These these DT 37231 323 7 three three CD 37231 323 8 Syriac Syriac NNPS 37231 323 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 323 10 lie lie VBP 37231 323 11 under under IN 37231 323 12 the the DT 37231 323 13 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 323 14 that that IN 37231 323 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 323 16 are be VBP 37231 323 17 not not RB 37231 323 18 an an DT 37231 323 19 older old JJR 37231 323 20 text text NN 37231 323 21 , , , 37231 323 22 but but CC 37231 323 23 merely merely RB 37231 323 24 an an DT 37231 323 25 epitome epitome NN 37231 323 26 of of IN 37231 323 27 the the DT 37231 323 28 seven seven CD 37231 323 29 , , , 37231 323 30 for for IN 37231 323 31 the the DT 37231 323 32 other other JJ 37231 323 33 notes note NNS 37231 323 34 found find VBN 37231 323 35 in in IN 37231 323 36 the the DT 37231 323 37 same same JJ 37231 323 38 MS MS NNP 37231 323 39 . . . 37231 323 40 seem seem VBP 37231 323 41 to to TO 37231 323 42 be be VB 37231 323 43 excerpts excerpt NNS 37231 323 44 . . . 37231 324 1 But but CC 37231 324 2 on on IN 37231 324 3 the the DT 37231 324 4 other other JJ 37231 324 5 hand hand NN 37231 324 6 , , , 37231 324 7 the the DT 37231 324 8 doubts doubt NNS 37231 324 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 324 10 the the DT 37231 324 11 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 324 12 of of IN 37231 324 13 the the DT 37231 324 14 seven seven CD 37231 324 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 324 16 , , , 37231 324 17 in in IN 37231 324 18 the the DT 37231 324 19 form form NN 37231 324 20 in in IN 37231 324 21 which which WDT 37231 324 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 324 23 are be VBP 37231 324 24 known know VBN 37231 324 25 since since IN 37231 324 26 Usher Usher NNP 37231 324 27 's 's POS 37231 324 28 time time NN 37231 324 29 , , , 37231 324 30 are be VBP 37231 324 31 not not RB 37231 324 32 yet yet RB 37231 324 33 entirely entirely RB 37231 324 34 removed remove VBN 37231 324 35 . . . 37231 325 1 For for IN 37231 325 2 no no DT 37231 325 3 MS MS NNP 37231 325 4 . . . 37231 325 5 has have VBZ 37231 325 6 yet yet RB 37231 325 7 been be VBN 37231 325 8 found find VBN 37231 325 9 which which WDT 37231 325 10 contains contain VBZ 37231 325 11 _ _ NNP 37231 325 12 only only RB 37231 325 13 _ _ NNP 37231 325 14 the the DT 37231 325 15 seven seven CD 37231 325 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 325 17 attested attest VBN 37231 325 18 by by IN 37231 325 19 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 325 20 , , , 37231 325 21 a a DT 37231 325 22 MS MS NNP 37231 325 23 . . . 37231 325 24 such such JJ 37231 325 25 as as IN 37231 325 26 lay lie VBN 37231 325 27 before before IN 37231 325 28 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 325 29 . . . 37231 326 1 " " `` 37231 326 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 326 3 1 1 LS 37231 326 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 326 5 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 37231 326 6 , , , 37231 326 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 326 8 , , , 37231 326 9 does do VBZ 37231 326 10 express express VB 37231 326 11 " " `` 37231 326 12 doubts doubt NNS 37231 326 13 , , , 37231 326 14 more more RBR 37231 326 15 or or CC 37231 326 16 less less RBR 37231 326 17 definite definite JJ 37231 326 18 . . . 37231 326 19 " " '' 37231 327 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 327 2 Light Light NNP 37231 327 3 - - HYPH 37231 327 4 foot foot NN 37231 327 5 then then RB 37231 327 6 continues continue VBZ 37231 327 7 : : : 37231 327 8 " " `` 37231 327 9 Of of IN 37231 327 10 the the DT 37231 327 11 rest rest NN 37231 327 12 a a DT 37231 327 13 considerable considerable JJ 37231 327 14 number number NN 37231 327 15 , , , 37231 327 16 as as IN 37231 327 17 , , , 37231 327 18 for for IN 37231 327 19 instance instance NN 37231 327 20 , , , 37231 327 21 Lardner Lardner NNP 37231 327 22 , , , 37231 327 23 Beausobre Beausobre NNP 37231 327 24 , , , 37231 327 25 Schroeckh Schroeckh NNP 37231 327 26 , , , 37231 327 27 Griesbach Griesbach NNP 37231 327 28 , , , 37231 327 29 Kestner Kestner NNP 37231 327 30 , , , 37231 327 31 Neander Neander NNP 37231 327 32 , , , 37231 327 33 and and CC 37231 327 34 Baumgarten Baumgarten NNP 37231 327 35 - - HYPH 37231 327 36 Crusius Crusius NNP 37231 327 37 , , , 37231 327 38 _ _ NNP 37231 327 39 with with IN 37231 327 40 different different JJ 37231 327 41 degrees degree NNS 37231 327 42 of of IN 37231 327 43 certainty certainty NN 37231 327 44 or or CC 37231 327 45 uncertainty uncertainty NN 37231 327 46 _ _ NNP 37231 327 47 , , , 37231 327 48 pronounce pronounce VBP 37231 327 49 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 327 50 in in IN 37231 327 51 favour favour NN 37231 327 52 of of IN 37231 327 53 a a DT 37231 327 54 genuine genuine JJ 37231 327 55 nucleus nucleus NN 37231 327 56 . . . 37231 328 1 " " `` 37231 328 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 328 3 2 2 LS 37231 328 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 328 5 The the DT 37231 328 6 words word NNS 37231 328 7 which which WDT 37231 328 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 328 9 have have VBP 37231 328 10 italicised italicise VBN 37231 328 11 are be VBP 37231 328 12 a a DT 37231 328 13 mere mere JJ 37231 328 14 paraphrase paraphrase NN 37231 328 15 of of IN 37231 328 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 328 17 words word NNS 37231 328 18 descriptive descriptive JJ 37231 328 19 of of IN 37231 328 20 the the DT 37231 328 21 doubts doubt NNS 37231 328 22 entertained entertain VBN 37231 328 23 . . . 37231 329 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 329 2 must must MD 37231 329 3 point point VB 37231 329 4 out out RP 37231 329 5 that that IN 37231 329 6 a a DT 37231 329 7 leaning lean VBG 37231 329 8 towards towards IN 37231 329 9 belief belief NN 37231 329 10 in in IN 37231 329 11 a a DT 37231 329 12 genuine genuine JJ 37231 329 13 " " `` 37231 329 14 nucleus nucleus NN 37231 329 15 " " '' 37231 329 16 on on IN 37231 329 17 the the DT 37231 329 18 part part NN 37231 329 19 of of IN 37231 329 20 some some DT 37231 329 21 of of IN 37231 329 22 these these DT 37231 329 23 writers writer NNS 37231 329 24 , , , 37231 329 25 by by IN 37231 329 26 no no DT 37231 329 27 means means NN 37231 329 28 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 329 29 the the DT 37231 329 30 expression expression NN 37231 329 31 of of IN 37231 329 32 " " `` 37231 329 33 _ _ NNP 37231 329 34 doubts doubt NNS 37231 329 35 , , , 37231 329 36 more more RBR 37231 329 37 or or CC 37231 329 38 less less RBR 37231 329 39 definite definite JJ 37231 329 40 _ _ NNP 37231 329 41 , , , 37231 329 42 " " '' 37231 329 43 which which WDT 37231 329 44 is be VBZ 37231 329 45 all all DT 37231 329 46 I -PRON- PRP 37231 329 47 quote quote VBP 37231 329 48 them -PRON- PRP 37231 329 49 for for IN 37231 329 50 . . . 37231 330 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 330 2 will will MD 37231 330 3 take take VB 37231 330 4 each each DT 37231 330 5 name name NN 37231 330 6 in in IN 37231 330 7 order order NN 37231 330 8 . . . 37231 331 1 _ _ NNP 37231 331 2 Lardner Lardner NNP 37231 331 3 _ _ NNP 37231 331 4 says say VBZ 37231 331 5 : : : 37231 331 6 " " `` 37231 331 7 But but CC 37231 331 8 whether whether IN 37231 331 9 the the DT 37231 331 10 smaller small JJR 37231 331 11 ( ( -LRB- 37231 331 12 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 331 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 331 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 331 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 331 16 are be VBP 37231 331 17 the the DT 37231 331 18 genuine genuine JJ 37231 331 19 writings writing NNS 37231 331 20 of of IN 37231 331 21 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 331 22 , , , 37231 331 23 bishop bishop NN 37231 331 24 of of IN 37231 331 25 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 331 26 , , , 37231 331 27 is be VBZ 37231 331 28 a a DT 37231 331 29 question question NN 37231 331 30 that that WDT 37231 331 31 has have VBZ 37231 331 32 been be VBN 37231 331 33 much much RB 37231 331 34 disputed dispute VBN 37231 331 35 , , , 37231 331 36 and and CC 37231 331 37 has have VBZ 37231 331 38 employed employ VBN 37231 331 39 the the DT 37231 331 40 pens pen NNS 37231 331 41 of of IN 37231 331 42 the the DT 37231 331 43 ablest able JJS 37231 331 44 critics critic NNS 37231 331 45 . . . 37231 332 1 And and CC 37231 332 2 whatever whatever WDT 37231 332 3 positiveness positiveness NN 37231 332 4 some some DT 37231 332 5 may may MD 37231 332 6 have have VB 37231 332 7 { { -LRB- 37231 332 8 xxxvii xxxvii NN 37231 332 9 } } -RRB- 37231 332 10 shown show VBN 37231 332 11 on on IN 37231 332 12 either either DT 37231 332 13 side side NN 37231 332 14 , , , 37231 332 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 332 16 must must MD 37231 332 17 own own VB 37231 332 18 I -PRON- PRP 37231 332 19 have have VBP 37231 332 20 found find VBN 37231 332 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 332 22 a a DT 37231 332 23 very very RB 37231 332 24 difficult difficult JJ 37231 332 25 question question NN 37231 332 26 . . . 37231 332 27 " " '' 37231 333 1 The the DT 37231 333 2 opinion opinion NN 37231 333 3 which which WDT 37231 333 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 333 5 expresses express VBZ 37231 333 6 finally finally RB 37231 333 7 is be VBZ 37231 333 8 merely merely RB 37231 333 9 : : : 37231 333 10 " " `` 37231 333 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 333 12 appears appear VBZ 37231 333 13 to to IN 37231 333 14 me -PRON- PRP 37231 333 15 _ _ NNP 37231 333 16 probable probable JJ 37231 333 17 _ _ NNP 37231 333 18 , , , 37231 333 19 that that IN 37231 333 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 333 21 are be VBP 37231 333 22 _ _ NNP 37231 333 23 for for IN 37231 333 24 the the DT 37231 333 25 main main JJ 37231 333 26 _ _ NNP 37231 333 27 the the DT 37231 333 28 genuine genuine JJ 37231 333 29 epistles epistle NNS 37231 333 30 of of IN 37231 333 31 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 333 32 . . . 37231 333 33 " " '' 37231 334 1 _ _ NNP 37231 334 2 Beausobre Beausobre NNP 37231 334 3 _ _ NNP 37231 334 4 says say VBZ 37231 334 5 : : : 37231 334 6 " " `` 37231 334 7 Je Je NNP 37231 334 8 ne ne NNP 37231 334 9 veux veux NN 37231 334 10 , , , 37231 334 11 ni ni NNP 37231 334 12 defendre defendre NNP 37231 334 13 , , , 37231 334 14 ni ni NNP 37231 334 15 combattre combattre NNP 37231 334 16 l'authenticite l'authenticite NNP 37231 334 17 ' ' '' 37231 334 18 des des NNP 37231 334 19 _ _ NNP 37231 334 20 Lettres Lettres NNP 37231 334 21 de de NNP 37231 334 22 St. St. NNP 37231 334 23 Ignace Ignace NNP 37231 334 24 _ _ NNP 37231 334 25 . . . 37231 335 1 Si Si NNP 37231 335 2 elles elles NNP 37231 335 3 ne ne NNP 37231 335 4 sont sont NNP 37231 335 5 pas pas NNP 37231 335 6 veritables veritable NNS 37231 335 7 , , , 37231 335 8 elles elles NNP 37231 335 9 ne ne NNP 37231 335 10 laissent laissent NNP 37231 335 11 pas pas NNP 37231 335 12 d'etre d'etre NNP 37231 335 13 fort fort NNP 37231 335 14 anciennes anciennes NNPS 37231 335 15 ; ; : 37231 335 16 et et NN 37231 335 17 l'opinion l'opinion NN 37231 335 18 , , , 37231 335 19 qui qui VBD 37231 335 20 me -PRON- PRP 37231 335 21 paroit paroit NNP 37231 335 22 la la NNP 37231 335 23 plus plus CC 37231 335 24 raisonnable raisonnable JJ 37231 335 25 , , , 37231 335 26 est est NNP 37231 335 27 que que NNP 37231 335 28 les les NNP 37231 335 29 plus plus NNP 37231 335 30 pures pures NNP 37231 335 31 ont ont CC 37231 335 32 été été NNP 37231 335 33 inter inter NN 37231 335 34 - - NN 37231 335 35 poises poise NNS 37231 335 36 . . . 37231 335 37 " " '' 37231 336 1 _ _ NNP 37231 336 2 Schroeckh Schroeckh NNP 37231 336 3 _ _ NNP 37231 336 4 says say VBZ 37231 336 5 that that IN 37231 336 6 along along IN 37231 336 7 with with IN 37231 336 8 the the DT 37231 336 9 favourable favourable JJ 37231 336 10 considerations consideration NNS 37231 336 11 for for IN 37231 336 12 the the DT 37231 336 13 shorter short JJR 37231 336 14 ( ( -LRB- 37231 336 15 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 336 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 336 17 Epistles Epistles NNP 37231 336 18 " " `` 37231 336 19 many many JJ 37231 336 20 doubts doubt NNS 37231 336 21 arise arise VBP 37231 336 22 which which WDT 37231 336 23 make make VBP 37231 336 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 336 25 suspicious suspicious JJ 37231 336 26 . . . 37231 336 27 " " '' 37231 337 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 337 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 337 3 to to TO 37231 337 4 point point VB 37231 337 5 out out RP 37231 337 6 many many JJ 37231 337 7 grave grave JJ 37231 337 8 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 337 9 , , , 37231 337 10 and and CC 37231 337 11 anachronisms anachronism NNS 37231 337 12 which which WDT 37231 337 13 cast cast VBD 37231 337 14 doubt doubt NN 37231 337 15 both both DT 37231 337 16 on on IN 37231 337 17 individual individual JJ 37231 337 18 epistles epistle NNS 37231 337 19 and and CC 37231 337 20 upon upon IN 37231 337 21 the the DT 37231 337 22 whole whole NN 37231 337 23 , , , 37231 337 24 and and CC 37231 337 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 337 26 remarks remark VBZ 37231 337 27 that that IN 37231 337 28 a a DT 37231 337 29 very very RB 37231 337 30 common common JJ 37231 337 31 way way NN 37231 337 32 of of IN 37231 337 33 evading evade VBG 37231 337 34 these these DT 37231 337 35 and and CC 37231 337 36 other other JJ 37231 337 37 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 337 38 is be VBZ 37231 337 39 to to TO 37231 337 40 affirm affirm VB 37231 337 41 that that IN 37231 337 42 all all PDT 37231 337 43 the the DT 37231 337 44 passages passage NNS 37231 337 45 which which WDT 37231 337 46 can can MD 37231 337 47 not not RB 37231 337 48 be be VB 37231 337 49 reconciled reconcile VBN 37231 337 50 with with IN 37231 337 51 the the DT 37231 337 52 mode mode NN 37231 337 53 of of IN 37231 337 54 thought thought NN 37231 337 55 of of IN 37231 337 56 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 337 57 are be VBP 37231 337 58 interpolations interpolation NNS 37231 337 59 of of IN 37231 337 60 a a DT 37231 337 61 later later JJ 37231 337 62 time time NN 37231 337 63 . . . 37231 338 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 338 2 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 338 3 with with IN 37231 338 4 the the DT 37231 338 5 pertinent pertinent JJ 37231 338 6 observation observation NN 37231 338 7 : : : 37231 338 8 " " `` 37231 338 9 However however RB 37231 338 10 probable probable JJ 37231 338 11 this this DT 37231 338 12 is be VBZ 37231 338 13 , , , 37231 338 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 338 15 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 338 16 remains remain VBZ 37231 338 17 as as RB 37231 338 18 difficult difficult JJ 37231 338 19 to to TO 37231 338 20 prove prove VB 37231 338 21 which which WDT 37231 338 22 are be VBP 37231 338 23 the the DT 37231 338 24 interpolated interpolated JJ 37231 338 25 passages passage NNS 37231 338 26 . . . 37231 338 27 " " '' 37231 339 1 In in IN 37231 339 2 fact fact NN 37231 339 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 339 4 would would MD 37231 339 5 be be VB 37231 339 6 difficult difficult JJ 37231 339 7 to to TO 37231 339 8 point point VB 37231 339 9 out out RP 37231 339 10 any any DT 37231 339 11 writer writer NN 37231 339 12 who who WP 37231 339 13 more more RBR 37231 339 14 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 339 15 doubts doubt NNS 37231 339 16 , , , 37231 339 17 without without IN 37231 339 18 definitely definitely RB 37231 339 19 rejecting reject VBG 37231 339 20 , , , 37231 339 21 all all PDT 37231 339 22 the the DT 37231 339 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 339 24 . . . 37231 340 1 _ _ NNP 37231 340 2 Grtesbach Grtesbach NNP 37231 340 3 _ _ NNP 37231 340 4 and and CC 37231 340 5 _ _ NNP 37231 340 6 Kestner Kestner NNP 37231 340 7 _ _ NNP 37231 340 8 both both CC 37231 340 9 express express VBP 37231 340 10 " " `` 37231 340 11 doubts doubt NNS 37231 340 12 more more RBR 37231 340 13 or or CC 37231 340 14 less less RBR 37231 340 15 definite definite JJ 37231 340 16 , , , 37231 340 17 " " '' 37231 340 18 but but CC 37231 340 19 to to TO 37231 340 20 make make VB 37231 340 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 340 22 extracts extract NNS 37231 340 23 to to TO 37231 340 24 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 340 25 this this DT 37231 340 26 would would MD 37231 340 27 occupy occupy VB 37231 340 28 too too RB 37231 340 29 much much JJ 37231 340 30 space space NN 37231 340 31 . . . 37231 341 1 _ _ NNP 37231 341 2 Neander_.--Dr Neander_.--Dr NNP 37231 341 3 . . . 37231 342 1 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 342 2 has have VBZ 37231 342 3 been be VBN 37231 342 4 misled mislead VBN 37231 342 5 by by IN 37231 342 6 the the DT 37231 342 7 short short JJ 37231 342 8 extract extract NN 37231 342 9 from from IN 37231 342 10 the the DT 37231 342 11 English english JJ 37231 342 12 translation translation NN 37231 342 13 of of IN 37231 342 14 the the DT 37231 342 15 first first JJ 37231 342 16 { { -LRB- 37231 342 17 xxxviii xxxviii NN 37231 342 18 } } -RRB- 37231 342 19 edition edition NN 37231 342 20 of of IN 37231 342 21 Neander Neander NNP 37231 342 22 's 's POS 37231 342 23 History history NN 37231 342 24 given give VBN 37231 342 25 by by IN 37231 342 26 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 342 27 in in IN 37231 342 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 342 29 Appendix Appendix NNP 37231 342 30 , , , 37231 342 31 has have VBZ 37231 342 32 not not RB 37231 342 33 attended attend VBN 37231 342 34 to to IN 37231 342 35 the the DT 37231 342 36 brief brief JJ 37231 342 37 German german JJ 37231 342 38 quotation quotation NN 37231 342 39 from from IN 37231 342 40 the the DT 37231 342 41 second second JJ 37231 342 42 edition edition NN 37231 342 43 , , , 37231 342 44 and and CC 37231 342 45 has have VBZ 37231 342 46 not not RB 37231 342 47 examined examine VBN 37231 342 48 the the DT 37231 342 49 original original NN 37231 342 50 at at RB 37231 342 51 all all RB 37231 342 52 , , , 37231 342 53 or or CC 37231 342 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 342 55 would would MD 37231 342 56 have have VB 37231 342 57 seen see VBN 37231 342 58 that that DT 37231 342 59 , , , 37231 342 60 so so RB 37231 342 61 far far RB 37231 342 62 from from IN 37231 342 63 pronouncing pronounce VBG 37231 342 64 " " '' 37231 342 65 in in IN 37231 342 66 favour favour NN 37231 342 67 of of IN 37231 342 68 a a DT 37231 342 69 genuine genuine JJ 37231 342 70 nucleus nucleus NN 37231 342 71 , , , 37231 342 72 " " `` 37231 342 73 Neander Neander NNP 37231 342 74 might may MD 37231 342 75 well well RB 37231 342 76 have have VB 37231 342 77 been be VBN 37231 342 78 classed class VBN 37231 342 79 by by IN 37231 342 80 me -PRON- PRP 37231 342 81 amongst amongst IN 37231 342 82 those those DT 37231 342 83 who who WP 37231 342 84 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 342 85 reject reject VBP 37231 342 86 the the DT 37231 342 87 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 342 88 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 342 89 , , , 37231 342 90 instead instead RB 37231 342 91 of of IN 37231 342 92 being be VBG 37231 342 93 moderately moderately RB 37231 342 94 quoted quote VBN 37231 342 95 amongst amongst IN 37231 342 96 those those DT 37231 342 97 who who WP 37231 342 98 merely merely RB 37231 342 99 express express VBP 37231 342 100 doubt doubt NN 37231 342 101 . . . 37231 343 1 Neander Neander NNP 37231 343 2 says say VBZ 37231 343 3 : : : 37231 343 4 " " `` 37231 343 5 As as IN 37231 343 6 the the DT 37231 343 7 account account NN 37231 343 8 of of IN 37231 343 9 the the DT 37231 343 10 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 343 11 of of IN 37231 343 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 343 13 is be VBZ 37231 343 14 very very RB 37231 343 15 suspicious suspicious JJ 37231 343 16 , , , 37231 343 17 so so RB 37231 343 18 also also RB 37231 343 19 the the DT 37231 343 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 343 21 which which WDT 37231 343 22 suppose suppose VBP 37231 343 23 the the DT 37231 343 24 correctness correctness NN 37231 343 25 of of IN 37231 343 26 this this DT 37231 343 27 suspicious suspicious JJ 37231 343 28 legend legend NN 37231 343 29 , , , 37231 343 30 do do VB 37231 343 31 not not RB 37231 343 32 bear bear VB 37231 343 33 throughout throughout IN 37231 343 34 the the DT 37231 343 35 impress impress NN 37231 343 36 of of IN 37231 343 37 a a DT 37231 343 38 distinct distinct JJ 37231 343 39 individuality individuality NN 37231 343 40 , , , 37231 343 41 and and CC 37231 343 42 of of IN 37231 343 43 a a DT 37231 343 44 man man NN 37231 343 45 of of IN 37231 343 46 that that DT 37231 343 47 time time NN 37231 343 48 who who WP 37231 343 49 is be VBZ 37231 343 50 addressing address VBG 37231 343 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 343 52 last last JJ 37231 343 53 words word NNS 37231 343 54 to to IN 37231 343 55 the the DT 37231 343 56 communities community NNS 37231 343 57 . . . 37231 344 1 A a DT 37231 344 2 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 37231 344 3 purpose purpose NN 37231 344 4 is be VBZ 37231 344 5 not not RB 37231 344 6 to to TO 37231 344 7 be be VB 37231 344 8 mistaken mistaken JJ 37231 344 9 . . . 37231 344 10 " " '' 37231 345 1 In in IN 37231 345 2 an an DT 37231 345 3 earlier early JJR 37231 345 4 part part NN 37231 345 5 of of IN 37231 345 6 the the DT 37231 345 7 work work NN 37231 345 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 345 9 still still RB 37231 345 10 more more RBR 37231 345 11 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 345 12 says say VBZ 37231 345 13 that that IN 37231 345 14 , , , 37231 345 15 " " `` 37231 345 16 in in IN 37231 345 17 the the DT 37231 345 18 so so RB 37231 345 19 - - HYPH 37231 345 20 called call VBN 37231 345 21 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 345 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 345 23 , , , 37231 345 24 " " '' 37231 345 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 345 26 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 345 27 a a DT 37231 345 28 decided decided JJ 37231 345 29 " " `` 37231 345 30 design design NN 37231 345 31 " " '' 37231 345 32 ( ( -LRB- 37231 345 33 absichtlichkeit absichtlichkeit NNP 37231 345 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 345 35 and and CC 37231 345 36 then then RB 37231 345 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 345 38 continues continue VBZ 37231 345 39 : : : 37231 345 40 " " `` 37231 345 41 as as IN 37231 345 42 the the DT 37231 345 43 tradition tradition NN 37231 345 44 regarding regard VBG 37231 345 45 the the DT 37231 345 46 journey journey NN 37231 345 47 of of IN 37231 345 48 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 345 49 to to IN 37231 345 50 Rome Rome NNP 37231 345 51 , , , 37231 345 52 there there RB 37231 345 53 to to TO 37231 345 54 be be VB 37231 345 55 cast cast VBN 37231 345 56 to to IN 37231 345 57 the the DT 37231 345 58 wild wild JJ 37231 345 59 beasts beast NNS 37231 345 60 , , , 37231 345 61 seems seem VBZ 37231 345 62 to to IN 37231 345 63 me -PRON- PRP 37231 345 64 for for IN 37231 345 65 the the DT 37231 345 66 above above RB 37231 345 67 - - HYPH 37231 345 68 mentioned mention VBN 37231 345 69 reasons reason NNS 37231 345 70 very very RB 37231 345 71 suspicious suspicious JJ 37231 345 72 , , , 37231 345 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 345 74 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 345 75 , , , 37231 345 76 which which WDT 37231 345 77 pre pre VB 37231 345 78 - - VB 37231 345 79 suppose suppose VB 37231 345 80 the the DT 37231 345 81 truth truth NN 37231 345 82 of of IN 37231 345 83 this this DT 37231 345 84 tradition tradition NN 37231 345 85 , , , 37231 345 86 can can MD 37231 345 87 no no RB 37231 345 88 longer long RBR 37231 345 89 inspire inspire VB 37231 345 90 me -PRON- PRP 37231 345 91 with with IN 37231 345 92 faith faith NN 37231 345 93 in in IN 37231 345 94 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 345 95 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 345 96 . . . 37231 345 97 " " '' 37231 346 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 346 2 goes go VBZ 37231 346 3 on on IN 37231 346 4 to to IN 37231 346 5 state state VB 37231 346 6 additional additional JJ 37231 346 7 grounds ground NNS 37231 346 8 for for IN 37231 346 9 disbelief disbelief NN 37231 346 10 . . . 37231 347 1 _ _ NNP 37231 347 2 Baumgarten Baumgarten NNP 37231 347 3 - - HYPH 37231 347 4 Crusius Crusius NNP 37231 347 5 _ _ NNP 37231 347 6 stated state VBD 37231 347 7 in in IN 37231 347 8 one one CD 37231 347 9 place place NN 37231 347 10 , , , 37231 347 11 in in IN 37231 347 12 regard regard NN 37231 347 13 to to IN 37231 347 14 the the DT 37231 347 15 seven seven CD 37231 347 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 347 17 , , , 37231 347 18 that that IN 37231 347 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 347 20 is be VBZ 37231 347 21 no no RB 37231 347 22 longer long RBR 37231 347 23 possible possible JJ 37231 347 24 to to TO 37231 347 25 ascertain ascertain VB 37231 347 26 how how WRB 37231 347 27 much much JJ 37231 347 28 of of IN 37231 347 29 the the DT 37231 347 30 extant extant JJ 37231 347 31 may may MD 37231 347 32 have have VB 37231 347 33 formed form VBN 37231 347 34 part part NN 37231 347 35 of of IN 37231 347 36 the the DT 37231 347 37 original original JJ 37231 347 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 347 39 , , , 37231 347 40 and and CC 37231 347 41 in in IN 37231 347 42 a a DT 37231 347 43 note note NN 37231 347 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 347 45 excepts except VBZ 37231 347 46 only only RB 37231 347 47 the the DT 37231 347 48 passages passage NNS 37231 347 49 quoted quote VBN 37231 347 50 by by IN 37231 347 51 the the DT 37231 347 52 Fathers father NNS 37231 347 53 . . . 37231 348 1 { { -LRB- 37231 348 2 xxxix xxxix NN 37231 348 3 } } -RRB- 37231 348 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 348 5 seems seem VBZ 37231 348 6 to to TO 37231 348 7 agree agree VB 37231 348 8 with with IN 37231 348 9 Semler Semler NNP 37231 348 10 and and CC 37231 348 11 others other NNS 37231 348 12 that that IN 37231 348 13 the the DT 37231 348 14 two two CD 37231 348 15 Recensions recension NNS 37231 348 16 are be VBP 37231 348 17 probably probably RB 37231 348 18 the the DT 37231 348 19 result result NN 37231 348 20 of of IN 37231 348 21 manipulations manipulation NNS 37231 348 22 of of IN 37231 348 23 the the DT 37231 348 24 original original JJ 37231 348 25 , , , 37231 348 26 the the DT 37231 348 27 shorter short JJR 37231 348 28 form form NN 37231 348 29 being be VBG 37231 348 30 more more RBR 37231 348 31 in in IN 37231 348 32 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 348 33 , , , 37231 348 34 the the DT 37231 348 35 longer long JJR 37231 348 36 in in IN 37231 348 37 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 348 38 interest interest NN 37231 348 39 . . . 37231 349 1 Some some DT 37231 349 2 years year NNS 37231 349 3 later later RBR 37231 349 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 349 5 remarked remark VBD 37231 349 6 that that IN 37231 349 7 inquiries inquiry NNS 37231 349 8 into into IN 37231 349 9 the the DT 37231 349 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 349 11 , , , 37231 349 12 although although IN 37231 349 13 not not RB 37231 349 14 yet yet RB 37231 349 15 concluded conclude VBN 37231 349 16 , , , 37231 349 17 had have VBD 37231 349 18 rather rather RB 37231 349 19 tended tend VBN 37231 349 20 towards towards IN 37231 349 21 the the DT 37231 349 22 earlier early JJR 37231 349 23 view view NN 37231 349 24 that that IN 37231 349 25 the the DT 37231 349 26 Shorter Shorter NNP 37231 349 27 Recension recension NN 37231 349 28 was be VBD 37231 349 29 more more RBR 37231 349 30 original original JJ 37231 349 31 than than IN 37231 349 32 the the DT 37231 349 33 Long long JJ 37231 349 34 , , , 37231 349 35 but but CC 37231 349 36 that that IN 37231 349 37 even even RB 37231 349 38 the the DT 37231 349 39 shorter short JJR 37231 349 40 may may MD 37231 349 41 have have VB 37231 349 42 suffered suffer VBN 37231 349 43 , , , 37231 349 44 if if IN 37231 349 45 not not RB 37231 349 46 from from IN 37231 349 47 manipulations manipulation NNS 37231 349 48 ( ( -LRB- 37231 349 49 Ueberarbeitungen Ueberarbeitungen NNP 37231 349 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 349 51 from from IN 37231 349 52 interpolations interpolation NNS 37231 349 53 . . . 37231 350 1 This this DT 37231 350 2 very very RB 37231 350 3 cautious cautious JJ 37231 350 4 statement statement NN 37231 350 5 , , , 37231 350 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 350 7 will will MD 37231 350 8 be be VB 37231 350 9 observed observe VBN 37231 350 10 , , , 37231 350 11 is be VBZ 37231 350 12 wholly wholly RB 37231 350 13 relative relative JJ 37231 350 14 , , , 37231 350 15 and and CC 37231 350 16 does do VBZ 37231 350 17 not not RB 37231 350 18 in in IN 37231 350 19 the the DT 37231 350 20 least least JJS 37231 350 21 modify modify VB 37231 350 22 the the DT 37231 350 23 previous previous JJ 37231 350 24 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 350 25 that that IN 37231 350 26 the the DT 37231 350 27 original original JJ 37231 350 28 material material NN 37231 350 29 of of IN 37231 350 30 the the DT 37231 350 31 letters letter NNS 37231 350 32 can can MD 37231 350 33 not not RB 37231 350 34 be be VB 37231 350 35 ascertained ascertain VBN 37231 350 36 . . . 37231 351 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 351 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 351 3 's 's POS 37231 351 4 objections objection NNS 37231 351 5 regarding regard VBG 37231 351 6 these these DT 37231 351 7 seven seven CD 37231 351 8 writers writer NNS 37231 351 9 are be VBP 37231 351 10 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 351 11 unfounded unfounded JJ 37231 351 12 , , , 37231 351 13 and and CC 37231 351 14 in in IN 37231 351 15 most most JJS 37231 351 16 cases case NNS 37231 351 17 glaringly glaringly RB 37231 351 18 erroneous erroneous JJ 37231 351 19 . . . 37231 352 1 1 1 CD 37231 352 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 352 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 352 4 doubts doubt NNS 37231 352 5 , , , 37231 352 6 and and CC 37231 352 7 a a DT 37231 352 8 large large JJ 37231 352 9 mass mass NN 37231 352 10 of of IN 37231 352 11 critics critic NNS 37231 352 12 recognize recognize VBP 37231 352 13 _ _ NNP 37231 352 14 that that IN 37231 352 15 the the DT 37231 352 16 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 352 17 of of IN 37231 352 18 none none NN 37231 352 19 _ _ NNP 37231 352 20 of of IN 37231 352 21 these these DT 37231 352 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 352 23 _ _ NNP 37231 352 24 can can MD 37231 352 25 be be VB 37231 352 26 established establish VBN 37231 352 27 _ _ NNP 37231 352 28 and and CC 37231 352 29 that that IN 37231 352 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 352 31 can can MD 37231 352 32 only only RB 37231 352 33 be be VB 37231 352 34 considered consider VBN 37231 352 35 later later RB 37231 352 36 and and CC 37231 352 37 spurious spurious JJ 37231 352 38 compositions composition NNS 37231 352 39 . . . 37231 352 40 " " '' 37231 353 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 353 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 353 3 to to IN 37231 353 4 the the DT 37231 353 5 next next JJ 37231 353 6 " " `` 37231 353 7 note note NN 37231 353 8 ( ( -LRB- 37231 353 9 4 4 CD 37231 353 10 ) ) -RRB- 37231 353 11 " " '' 37231 353 12 with with IN 37231 353 13 the the DT 37231 353 14 same same JJ 37231 353 15 unhesitating unhesitating JJ 37231 353 16 vigour vigour NN 37231 353 17 , , , 37231 353 18 and and CC 37231 353 19 characterizes characterize VBZ 37231 353 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 353 21 as as IN 37231 353 22 " " `` 37231 353 23 equally equally RB 37231 353 24 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37231 353 25 . . . 37231 353 26 " " '' 37231 354 1 Wherever wherever WRB 37231 354 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 354 3 has have VBZ 37231 354 4 been be VBN 37231 354 5 possible possible JJ 37231 354 6 , , , 37231 354 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 354 8 Light Light NNP 37231 354 9 - - HYPH 37231 354 10 foot foot NN 37231 354 11 has have VBZ 37231 354 12 succeeded succeed VBN 37231 354 13 in in IN 37231 354 14 misrepresenting misrepresent VBG 37231 354 15 the the DT 37231 354 16 " " `` 37231 354 17 purpose purpose NN 37231 354 18 " " '' 37231 354 19 of of IN 37231 354 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 354 21 notes note NNS 37231 354 22 , , , 37231 354 23 although although IN 37231 354 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 354 25 has have VBZ 37231 354 26 recognized recognize VBN 37231 354 27 how how WRB 37231 354 28 important important JJ 37231 354 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 354 30 is be VBZ 37231 354 31 to to TO 37231 354 32 ascertain ascertain VB 37231 354 33 this this DT 37231 354 34 correctly correctly RB 37231 354 35 , , , 37231 354 36 and and CC 37231 354 37 in in IN 37231 354 38 this this DT 37231 354 39 instance instance NN 37231 354 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 354 41 has have VBZ 37231 354 42 done do VBN 37231 354 43 so so RB 37231 354 44 again again RB 37231 354 45 . . . 37231 355 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 355 2 will will MD 37231 355 3 put put VB 37231 355 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 355 5 text text NN 37231 355 6 and and CC 37231 355 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 355 8 explanation explanation NN 37231 355 9 , , , 37231 355 10 upon upon IN 37231 355 11 the the DT 37231 355 12 basis basis NN 37231 355 13 of of IN 37231 355 14 which which WDT 37231 355 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 355 16 analyses analyse VBZ 37231 355 17 the the DT 37231 355 18 note note NN 37231 355 19 , , , 37231 355 20 in in IN 37231 355 21 juxtaposition juxtaposition NN 37231 355 22 , , , 37231 355 23 italicising italicise VBG 37231 355 24 part part NN 37231 355 25 of of IN 37231 355 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 355 27 own own JJ 37231 355 28 statement statement NN 37231 355 29 which which WDT 37231 355 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 355 31 altogether altogether RB 37231 355 32 disregards:-- disregards:-- VBP 37231 355 33 " " `` 37231 355 34 Further further JJ 37231 355 35 examination examination NN 37231 355 36 and and CC 37231 355 37 more more JJR 37231 355 38 References reference NNS 37231 355 39 to to TO 37231 355 40 twenty twenty CD 37231 355 41 authorities authority NNS 37231 355 42 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 37231 355 43 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 355 44 of of IN 37231 355 45 the the DT 37231 355 46 are be VBP 37231 355 47 then then RB 37231 355 48 given give VBN 37231 355 49 , , , 37231 355 50 as as IN 37231 355 51 belonging belong VBG 37231 355 52 to to IN 37231 355 53 the the DT 37231 355 54 subject subject NN 37231 355 55 have have VBP 37231 355 56 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 355 57 earlier early RBR 37231 355 58 a a DT 37231 355 59 large large JJ 37231 355 60 mass mass NN 37231 355 61 of of IN 37231 355 62 critics critic NNS 37231 355 63 who who WP 37231 355 64 recognize recognize VBP 37231 355 65 { { -LRB- 37231 355 66 xl xl NNP 37231 355 67 } } -RRB- 37231 355 68 that that IN 37231 355 69 the the DT 37231 355 70 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 355 71 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 355 72 , , , 37231 355 73 ' ' '' 37231 355 74 can can MD 37231 355 75 only only RB 37231 355 76 be be VB 37231 355 77 considered consider VBN 37231 355 78 later later RB 37231 355 79 and and CC 37231 355 80 spurious spurious JJ 37231 355 81 compositions composition NNS 37231 355 82 . . . 37231 356 1 ' ' '' 37231 356 2 " " '' 37231 356 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 356 4 1 1 LS 37231 356 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 356 6 There there EX 37231 356 7 are be VBP 37231 356 8 here here RB 37231 356 9 , , , 37231 356 10 in in IN 37231 356 11 order order NN 37231 356 12 to to TO 37231 356 13 embrace embrace VB 37231 356 14 a a DT 37231 356 15 number number NN 37231 356 16 of of IN 37231 356 17 references reference NNS 37231 356 18 , , , 37231 356 19 two two CD 37231 356 20 approximate approximate JJ 37231 356 21 states state NNS 37231 356 22 of of IN 37231 356 23 opinion opinion NN 37231 356 24 represented represent VBD 37231 356 25 : : : 37231 356 26 the the DT 37231 356 27 first first JJ 37231 356 28 , , , 37231 356 29 which which WDT 37231 356 30 leaves leave VBZ 37231 356 31 the the DT 37231 356 32 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 356 33 in in IN 37231 356 34 permanent permanent JJ 37231 356 35 doubt doubt NN 37231 356 36 , , , 37231 356 37 as as IN 37231 356 38 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 356 39 evidence evidence NN 37231 356 40 is be VBZ 37231 356 41 not not RB 37231 356 42 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 37231 356 43 to to TO 37231 356 44 establish establish VB 37231 356 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 356 46 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 356 47 ; ; : 37231 356 48 and and CC 37231 356 49 the the DT 37231 356 50 second second JJ 37231 356 51 , , , 37231 356 52 which which WDT 37231 356 53 positively positively RB 37231 356 54 pronounces pronounce VBZ 37231 356 55 them -PRON- PRP 37231 356 56 to to TO 37231 356 57 be be VB 37231 356 58 spurious spurious JJ 37231 356 59 . . . 37231 357 1 Out out IN 37231 357 2 of of IN 37231 357 3 the the DT 37231 357 4 twenty twenty CD 37231 357 5 authorities authority NNS 37231 357 6 referred refer VBD 37231 357 7 to to IN 37231 357 8 , , , 37231 357 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 357 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 357 11 objects object VBZ 37231 357 12 to to IN 37231 357 13 six six CD 37231 357 14 as as RB 37231 357 15 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 357 16 or or CC 37231 357 17 not not RB 37231 357 18 confirming confirm VBG 37231 357 19 what what WP 37231 357 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 357 21 states state VBZ 37231 357 22 to to TO 37231 357 23 be be VB 37231 357 24 the the DT 37231 357 25 purpose purpose NN 37231 357 26 of of IN 37231 357 27 the the DT 37231 357 28 note note NN 37231 357 29 . . . 37231 358 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 358 2 seems seem VBZ 37231 358 3 to to TO 37231 358 4 consider consider VB 37231 358 5 that that IN 37231 358 6 a a DT 37231 358 7 reservation reservation NN 37231 358 8 for for IN 37231 358 9 the the DT 37231 358 10 possibility possibility NN 37231 358 11 of of IN 37231 358 12 a a DT 37231 358 13 genuine genuine JJ 37231 358 14 substratum substratum NN 37231 358 15 which which WDT 37231 358 16 can can MD 37231 358 17 not not RB 37231 358 18 be be VB 37231 358 19 defined define VBN 37231 358 20 invalidates invalidate VBZ 37231 358 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 358 22 reference reference NN 37231 358 23 . . . 37231 359 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 359 2 maintain maintain VBP 37231 359 3 , , , 37231 359 4 however however RB 37231 359 5 , , , 37231 359 6 that that IN 37231 359 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 359 8 does do VBZ 37231 359 9 not not RB 37231 359 10 . . . 37231 360 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 360 2 is be VBZ 37231 360 3 quite quite RB 37231 360 4 possible possible JJ 37231 360 5 to to TO 37231 360 6 consider consider VB 37231 360 7 that that IN 37231 360 8 the the DT 37231 360 9 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 360 10 of of IN 37231 360 11 the the DT 37231 360 12 extant extant JJ 37231 360 13 , , , 37231 360 14 letters letter NNS 37231 360 15 can can MD 37231 360 16 not not RB 37231 360 17 be be VB 37231 360 18 established establish VBN 37231 360 19 without without IN 37231 360 20 denying deny VBG 37231 360 21 that that IN 37231 360 22 there there EX 37231 360 23 may may MD 37231 360 24 have have VB 37231 360 25 been be VBN 37231 360 26 some some DT 37231 360 27 original original JJ 37231 360 28 nucleus nucleus NN 37231 360 29 upon upon IN 37231 360 30 which which WDT 37231 360 31 these these DT 37231 360 32 actual actual JJ 37231 360 33 documents document NNS 37231 360 34 may may MD 37231 360 35 have have VB 37231 360 36 been be VBN 37231 360 37 based base VBN 37231 360 38 . . . 37231 361 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 361 2 will will MD 37231 361 3 analyse analyse VB 37231 361 4 the the DT 37231 361 5 six six CD 37231 361 6 references reference NNS 37231 361 7 . . . 37231 362 1 Bleek.--Dr Bleek.--Dr NNP 37231 362 2 . . . 37231 363 1 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 363 2 says say VBZ 37231 363 3 : : : 37231 363 4 " " `` 37231 363 5 Of of IN 37231 363 6 these these DT 37231 363 7 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 363 8 ( ( -LRB- 37231 363 9 already already RB 37231 363 10 cited cite VBN 37231 363 11 in in IN 37231 363 12 a a DT 37231 363 13 previous previous JJ 37231 363 14 note note NN 37231 363 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 363 16 expresses express VBZ 37231 363 17 no no DT 37231 363 18 definite definite JJ 37231 363 19 opinion opinion NN 37231 363 20 . . . 37231 363 21 " " '' 37231 364 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 364 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 364 3 omits omit VBZ 37231 364 4 to to TO 37231 364 5 mention mention VB 37231 364 6 that that IN 37231 364 7 I -PRON- PRP 37231 364 8 do do VBP 37231 364 9 not not RB 37231 364 10 refer refer VB 37231 364 11 to to IN 37231 364 12 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 364 13 directly directly RB 37231 364 14 , , , 37231 364 15 but but CC 37231 364 16 by by IN 37231 364 17 " " `` 37231 364 18 Cf Cf NNP 37231 364 19 . . . 37231 364 20 " " '' 37231 365 1 merely merely RB 37231 365 2 request request VBP 37231 365 3 consideration consideration NN 37231 365 4 of of IN 37231 365 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 365 6 opinions opinion NNS 37231 365 7 . . . 37231 366 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 366 2 have have VBP 37231 366 3 already already RB 37231 366 4 partly partly RB 37231 366 5 stated state VBN 37231 366 6 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 366 7 's 's POS 37231 366 8 view view NN 37231 366 9 . . . 37231 367 1 After after IN 37231 367 2 pointing point VBG 37231 367 3 out out RP 37231 367 4 some some DT 37231 367 5 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 367 6 , , , 37231 367 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 367 8 says say VBZ 37231 367 9 generally generally RB 37231 367 10 : : : 37231 367 11 " " `` 37231 367 12 It -PRON- PRP 37231 367 13 comes come VBZ 37231 367 14 to to IN 37231 367 15 this this DT 37231 367 16 , , , 37231 367 17 that that IN 37231 367 18 the the DT 37231 367 19 origin origin NN 37231 367 20 of of IN 37231 367 21 the the DT 37231 367 22 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 367 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 367 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 367 25 is be VBZ 37231 367 26 still still RB 37231 367 27 very very RB 37231 367 28 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 367 29 . . . 37231 367 30 " " '' 37231 368 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 368 2 refuses refuse VBZ 37231 368 3 { { -LRB- 37231 368 4 xli xli NN 37231 368 5 } } -RRB- 37231 368 6 to to TO 37231 368 7 make make VB 37231 368 8 use use NN 37231 368 9 of of IN 37231 368 10 a a DT 37231 368 11 passage passage NN 37231 368 12 because because IN 37231 368 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 368 14 is be VBZ 37231 368 15 only only RB 37231 368 16 found find VBN 37231 368 17 in in IN 37231 368 18 the the DT 37231 368 19 Long Long NNP 37231 368 20 Recension Recension NNP 37231 368 21 , , , 37231 368 22 and and CC 37231 368 23 another another DT 37231 368 24 which which WDT 37231 368 25 occurs occur VBZ 37231 368 26 in in IN 37231 368 27 the the DT 37231 368 28 Shorter Shorter NNP 37231 368 29 Recension Recension NNP 37231 368 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 368 31 does do VBZ 37231 368 32 not not RB 37231 368 33 consider consider VB 37231 368 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 368 35 , , , 37231 368 36 because because IN 37231 368 37 , , , 37231 368 38 first first RB 37231 368 39 , , , 37231 368 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 368 41 says say VBZ 37231 368 42 , , , 37231 368 43 " " `` 37231 368 44 The the DT 37231 368 45 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 368 46 of of IN 37231 368 47 this this DT 37231 368 48 Recension Recension NNP 37231 368 49 also also RB 37231 368 50 is be VBZ 37231 368 51 by by IN 37231 368 52 no no DT 37231 368 53 means mean NNS 37231 368 54 certain certain JJ 37231 368 55 , , , 37231 368 56 " " '' 37231 368 57 and and CC 37231 368 58 , , , 37231 368 59 next next RB 37231 368 60 , , , 37231 368 61 the the DT 37231 368 62 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 368 63 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 368 64 discredit discredit VBP 37231 368 65 the the DT 37231 368 66 others other NNS 37231 368 67 . . . 37231 369 1 " " `` 37231 369 2 Whether whether IN 37231 369 3 this this DT 37231 369 4 Recension recension NN 37231 369 5 ( ( -LRB- 37231 369 6 the the DT 37231 369 7 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 369 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 369 9 is be VBZ 37231 369 10 more more RBR 37231 369 11 original original JJ 37231 369 12 than than IN 37231 369 13 the the DT 37231 369 14 shorter short JJR 37231 369 15 Greek Greek NNP 37231 369 16 is be VBZ 37231 369 17 certainly certainly RB 37231 369 18 not not RB 37231 369 19 altogether altogether RB 37231 369 20 certain certain JJ 37231 369 21 , , , 37231 369 22 but but CC 37231 369 23 .... .... NFP 37231 369 24 in in IN 37231 369 25 the the DT 37231 369 26 highest high JJS 37231 369 27 degree degree NN 37231 369 28 probable probable JJ 37231 369 29 . . . 37231 369 30 " " '' 37231 370 1 In in IN 37231 370 2 another another DT 37231 370 3 place place NN 37231 370 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 370 5 refuses refuse VBZ 37231 370 6 to to TO 37231 370 7 make make VB 37231 370 8 use use NN 37231 370 9 of of IN 37231 370 10 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 37231 370 11 in in IN 37231 370 12 the the DT 37231 370 13 " " `` 37231 370 14 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 370 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 370 16 , , , 37231 370 17 " " '' 37231 370 18 " " `` 37231 370 19 because because IN 37231 370 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 370 21 is be VBZ 37231 370 22 still still RB 37231 370 23 very very RB 37231 370 24 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 370 25 how how WRB 37231 370 26 the the DT 37231 370 27 case case NN 37231 370 28 stands stand VBZ 37231 370 29 as as IN 37231 370 30 regards regard VBZ 37231 370 31 the the DT 37231 370 32 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 370 33 and and CC 37231 370 34 integrity integrity NN 37231 370 35 of of IN 37231 370 36 these these DT 37231 370 37 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 370 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 370 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 370 40 , , , 37231 370 41 in in IN 37231 370 42 the the DT 37231 370 43 different different JJ 37231 370 44 Recensions recension NNS 37231 370 45 in in IN 37231 370 46 which which WDT 37231 370 47 we -PRON- PRP 37231 370 48 possess possess VBP 37231 370 49 them -PRON- PRP 37231 370 50 . . . 37231 371 1 " " `` 37231 371 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 371 3 1 1 LS 37231 371 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 371 5 In in IN 37231 371 6 fact fact NN 37231 371 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 371 8 did do VBD 37231 371 9 not not RB 37231 371 10 consider consider VB 37231 371 11 that that IN 37231 371 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 371 13 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 371 14 could could MD 37231 371 15 be be VB 37231 371 16 established establish VBN 37231 371 17 . . . 37231 372 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 372 2 do do VBP 37231 372 3 not not RB 37231 372 4 , , , 37231 372 5 however however RB 37231 372 6 , , , 37231 372 7 include include VBP 37231 372 8 him -PRON- PRP 37231 372 9 here here RB 37231 372 10 at at RB 37231 372 11 all all RB 37231 372 12 . . . 37231 373 1 _ _ NNP 37231 373 2 Gfrörer_.--Dr Gfrörer_.--Dr NNP 37231 373 3 . . . 37231 374 1 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 374 2 , , , 37231 374 3 again again RB 37231 374 4 , , , 37231 374 5 omits omit VBZ 37231 374 6 to to IN 37231 374 7 state state NN 37231 374 8 that that IN 37231 374 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 374 10 do do VBP 37231 374 11 not not RB 37231 374 12 cite cite VB 37231 374 13 this this DT 37231 374 14 writer writer NN 37231 374 15 like like IN 37231 374 16 the the DT 37231 374 17 others other NNS 37231 374 18 , , , 37231 374 19 but but CC 37231 374 20 by by IN 37231 374 21 a a DT 37231 374 22 " " `` 37231 374 23 Cf Cf NNP 37231 374 24 . . . 37231 374 25 " " '' 37231 375 1 merely merely RB 37231 375 2 suggest suggest VBP 37231 375 3 a a DT 37231 375 4 reference reference NN 37231 375 5 to to IN 37231 375 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 375 7 remarks remark NNS 37231 375 8 . . . 37231 376 1 _ _ NNP 37231 376 2 Harless Harless NNP 37231 376 3 _ _ NNP 37231 376 4 , , , 37231 376 5 according accord VBG 37231 376 6 to to IN 37231 376 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 376 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 376 9 , , , 37231 376 10 " " '' 37231 376 11 avows avow VBZ 37231 376 12 that that IN 37231 376 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 376 14 must must MD 37231 376 15 ' ' `` 37231 376 16 decidedly decidedly RB 37231 376 17 reject reject VB 37231 376 18 with with IN 37231 376 19 the the DT 37231 376 20 most most RBS 37231 376 21 considerable considerable JJ 37231 376 22 critics critic NNS 37231 376 23 of of IN 37231 376 24 older old JJR 37231 376 25 and and CC 37231 376 26 more more JJR 37231 376 27 recent recent JJ 37231 376 28 times time NNS 37231 376 29 ' ' POS 37231 376 30 the the DT 37231 376 31 opinion opinion NN 37231 376 32 maintained maintain VBN 37231 376 33 by by IN 37231 376 34 certain certain JJ 37231 376 35 persons person NNS 37231 376 36 that that WDT 37231 376 37 the the DT 37231 376 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 376 39 are be VBP 37231 376 40 ' ' `` 37231 376 41 altogether altogether RB 37231 376 42 spurious spurious JJ 37231 376 43 , , , 37231 376 44 ' ' '' 37231 376 45 and and CC 37231 376 46 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 376 47 to to TO 37231 376 48 treat treat VB 37231 376 49 a a DT 37231 376 50 passage passage NN 37231 376 51 as as RB 37231 376 52 genuine genuine JJ 37231 376 53 because because IN 37231 376 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 376 55 stands stand VBZ 37231 376 56 in in IN 37231 376 57 the the DT 37231 376 58 Vossian vossian JJ 37231 376 59 letters letter NNS 37231 376 60 as as RB 37231 376 61 well well RB 37231 376 62 as as IN 37231 376 63 in in IN 37231 376 64 the the DT 37231 376 65 Long Long NNP 37231 376 66 Recension Recension NNP 37231 376 67 . . . 37231 376 68 " " '' 37231 377 1 This this DT 37231 377 2 is be VBZ 37231 377 3 a a DT 37231 377 4 mistake mistake NN 37231 377 5 . . . 37231 378 1 Harless Harless NNP 37231 378 2 quotes quote VBZ 37231 378 3 a a DT 37231 378 4 passage passage NN 37231 378 5 in in IN 37231 378 6 connection connection NN 37231 378 7 with with IN 37231 378 8 Paul Paul NNP 37231 378 9 's 's POS 37231 378 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 378 11 to to IN 37231 378 12 the the DT 37231 378 13 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 378 14 with with IN 37231 378 15 the the DT 37231 378 16 distinct distinct JJ 37231 378 17 remark remark NN 37231 378 18 : : : 37231 378 19 " " `` 37231 378 20 In in IN 37231 378 21 this this DT 37231 378 22 case case NN 37231 378 23 the the DT 37231 378 24 disadvantage disadvantage NN 37231 378 25 of of IN 37231 378 26 the the DT 37231 378 27 uncertainty uncertainty NN 37231 378 28 regarding regard VBG 37231 378 29 the the DT 37231 378 30 Recensions Recensions NNPS 37231 378 31 is be VBZ 37231 378 32 in in IN 37231 378 33 { { -LRB- 37231 378 34 xlii xlii NN 37231 378 35 } } -RRB- 37231 378 36 part part NN 37231 378 37 removed remove VBN 37231 378 38 through through IN 37231 378 39 the the DT 37231 378 40 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 378 41 that that WDT 37231 378 42 both both DT 37231 378 43 Recensions recension NNS 37231 378 44 have have VBP 37231 378 45 the the DT 37231 378 46 passage passage NN 37231 378 47 . . . 37231 378 48 " " '' 37231 379 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 379 2 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 379 3 that that IN 37231 379 4 the the DT 37231 379 5 completeness completeness NN 37231 379 6 of of IN 37231 379 7 the the DT 37231 379 8 proof proof NN 37231 379 9 that that IN 37231 379 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 379 11 tradition tradition NN 37231 379 12 goes go VBZ 37231 379 13 back back RB 37231 379 14 beyond beyond IN 37231 379 15 the the DT 37231 379 16 time time NN 37231 379 17 of of IN 37231 379 18 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 379 19 is be VBZ 37231 379 20 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 379 21 wanting want VBG 37231 379 22 from from IN 37231 379 23 the the DT 37231 379 24 uncertainty uncertainty NN 37231 379 25 regarding regard VBG 37231 379 26 the the DT 37231 379 27 text text NN 37231 379 28 of of IN 37231 379 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 379 30 . . . 37231 380 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 380 2 did do VBD 37231 380 3 not not RB 37231 380 4 in in IN 37231 380 5 fact fact NN 37231 380 6 venture venture NN 37231 380 7 to to TO 37231 380 8 consider consider VB 37231 380 9 the the DT 37231 380 10 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 380 11 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 380 12 evidence evidence NN 37231 380 13 even even RB 37231 380 14 for for IN 37231 380 15 the the DT 37231 380 16 first first JJ 37231 380 17 half half NN 37231 380 18 of of IN 37231 380 19 the the DT 37231 380 20 second second JJ 37231 380 21 century century NN 37231 380 22 . . . 37231 381 1 _ _ NNP 37231 381 2 Schliemann Schliemann NNP 37231 381 3 _ _ NNP 37231 381 4 , , , 37231 381 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 381 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 381 7 states state VBZ 37231 381 8 , , , 37231 381 9 " " '' 37231 381 10 says say VBZ 37231 381 11 that that IN 37231 381 12 ' ' '' 37231 381 13 the the DT 37231 381 14 external external JJ 37231 381 15 testimonies testimony NNS 37231 381 16 oblige oblige VBP 37231 381 17 him -PRON- PRP 37231 381 18 to to TO 37231 381 19 recognize recognize VB 37231 381 20 a a DT 37231 381 21 genuine genuine JJ 37231 381 22 substratum substratum NN 37231 381 23 , , , 37231 381 24 ' ' '' 37231 381 25 though though IN 37231 381 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 381 27 is be VBZ 37231 381 28 not not RB 37231 381 29 satisfied satisfied JJ 37231 381 30 with with IN 37231 381 31 either either CC 37231 381 32 existing exist VBG 37231 381 33 recension recension NN 37231 381 34 . . . 37231 381 35 " " '' 37231 382 1 Now now RB 37231 382 2 what what WP 37231 382 3 Schliemann Schliemann NNP 37231 382 4 says say VBZ 37231 382 5 is be VBZ 37231 382 6 this this DT 37231 382 7 : : : 37231 382 8 " " `` 37231 382 9 Certainly certainly RB 37231 382 10 neither neither CC 37231 382 11 the the DT 37231 382 12 Shorter Shorter NNP 37231 382 13 and and CC 37231 382 14 still still RB 37231 382 15 less less RBR 37231 382 16 the the DT 37231 382 17 Longer long JJR 37231 382 18 Recension recension NN 37231 382 19 in in IN 37231 382 20 which which WDT 37231 382 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 382 22 possess possess VBP 37231 382 23 these these DT 37231 382 24 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 382 25 can can MD 37231 382 26 lay lay VB 37231 382 27 claim claim NN 37231 382 28 to to IN 37231 382 29 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 382 30 . . . 37231 383 1 Only only RB 37231 383 2 if if IN 37231 383 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 383 4 must must MD 37231 383 5 , , , 37231 383 6 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 383 7 , , , 37231 383 8 without without IN 37231 383 9 doubt doubt NN 37231 383 10 suppose suppose VBP 37231 383 11 a a DT 37231 383 12 genuine genuine JJ 37231 383 13 substratum substratum NN 37231 383 14 , , , 37231 383 15 " " '' 37231 383 16 & & CC 37231 383 17 c. c. NNP 37231 383 18 In in IN 37231 383 19 a a DT 37231 383 20 note note NN 37231 383 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 383 22 adds add VBZ 37231 383 23 : : : 37231 383 24 " " `` 37231 383 25 The the DT 37231 383 26 external external JJ 37231 383 27 testimonies testimony NNS 37231 383 28 oblige oblige VBP 37231 383 29 me -PRON- PRP 37231 383 30 to to TO 37231 383 31 recognize recognize VB 37231 383 32 a a DT 37231 383 33 genuine genuine JJ 37231 383 34 substratum substratum NN 37231 383 35 -- -- : 37231 383 36 Poly Poly NNP 37231 383 37 - - HYPH 37231 383 38 carp carp NN 37231 383 39 already already RB 37231 383 40 speaks speak VBZ 37231 383 41 of of IN 37231 383 42 the the DT 37231 383 43 same same JJ 37231 383 44 in in IN 37231 383 45 Ch Ch NNP 37231 383 46 . . . 37231 384 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 384 2 . . . 37231 385 1 of of IN 37231 385 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 385 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 385 4 . . . 37231 386 1 But but CC 37231 386 2 that that IN 37231 386 3 in in IN 37231 386 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 386 5 present present JJ 37231 386 6 form form NN 37231 386 7 they -PRON- PRP 37231 386 8 do do VBP 37231 386 9 not not RB 37231 386 10 proceed proceed VB 37231 386 11 from from IN 37231 386 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 386 13 the the DT 37231 386 14 contents content NNS 37231 386 15 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 386 16 show show VBP 37231 386 17 . . . 37231 386 18 " " '' 37231 387 1 _ _ NNP 37231 387 2 Hase Hase NNP 37231 387 3 _ _ NNP 37231 387 4 , , , 37231 387 5 according accord VBG 37231 387 6 to to IN 37231 387 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 387 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 387 9 , , , 37231 387 10 " " '' 37231 387 11 commits commit VBZ 37231 387 12 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 387 13 to to IN 37231 387 14 no no DT 37231 387 15 opinion opinion NN 37231 387 16 . . . 37231 387 17 " " '' 37231 388 1 If if IN 37231 388 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 388 3 does do VBZ 37231 388 4 not not RB 37231 388 5 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 388 6 and and CC 37231 388 7 directly directly RB 37231 388 8 do do VBP 37231 388 9 so so RB 37231 388 10 , , , 37231 388 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 388 12 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 388 13 what what WP 37231 388 14 that that DT 37231 388 15 opinion opinion NN 37231 388 16 is be VBZ 37231 388 17 with with IN 37231 388 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 388 19 clearness clearness NN 37231 388 20 . . . 37231 389 1 The the DT 37231 389 2 Long Long NNP 37231 389 3 Recension Recension NNP 37231 389 4 , , , 37231 389 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 389 6 says say VBZ 37231 389 7 , , , 37231 389 8 bears bear VBZ 37231 389 9 the the DT 37231 389 10 marks mark NNS 37231 389 11 of of IN 37231 389 12 later late JJR 37231 389 13 manipulation manipulation NN 37231 389 14 , , , 37231 389 15 and and CC 37231 389 16 excites excite VBZ 37231 389 17 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 389 18 of of IN 37231 389 19 an an DT 37231 389 20 invention invention NN 37231 389 21 in in IN 37231 389 22 favour favour NN 37231 389 23 of of IN 37231 389 24 Episcopacy Episcopacy NNP 37231 389 25 , , , 37231 389 26 and and CC 37231 389 27 the the DT 37231 389 28 shorter short JJR 37231 389 29 text text NN 37231 389 30 is be VBZ 37231 389 31 not not RB 37231 389 32 fully fully RB 37231 389 33 attested attest VBN 37231 389 34 either either RB 37231 389 35 . . . 37231 390 1 The the DT 37231 390 2 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 390 3 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 390 4 with with IN 37231 390 5 the the DT 37231 390 6 shortest short JJS 37231 390 7 and and CC 37231 390 8 least least JJS 37231 390 9 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 37231 390 10 text text NN 37231 390 11 give give VB 37231 390 12 the the DT 37231 390 13 impression impression NN 37231 390 14 of of IN 37231 390 15 being be VBG 37231 390 16 an an DT 37231 390 17 epitome epitome NN 37231 390 18 . . . 37231 391 1 " " `` 37231 391 2 But but CC 37231 391 3 { { -LRB- 37231 391 4 xliii xliii NN 37231 391 5 } } -RRB- 37231 391 6 even even RB 37231 391 7 if if IN 37231 391 8 no no DT 37231 391 9 authentic authentic JJ 37231 391 10 kernel kernel NN 37231 391 11 lay lie VBD 37231 391 12 at at IN 37231 391 13 the the DT 37231 391 14 basis basis NN 37231 391 15 of of IN 37231 391 16 these these DT 37231 391 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 391 18 , , , 37231 391 19 yet yet CC 37231 391 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 391 21 would would MD 37231 391 22 be be VB 37231 391 23 a a DT 37231 391 24 significant significant JJ 37231 391 25 document document NN 37231 391 26 at at IN 37231 391 27 latest late JJS 37231 391 28 out out IN 37231 391 29 of of IN 37231 391 30 the the DT 37231 391 31 middle middle NN 37231 391 32 of of IN 37231 391 33 the the DT 37231 391 34 second second JJ 37231 391 35 century century NN 37231 391 36 . . . 37231 391 37 " " '' 37231 392 1 These these DT 37231 392 2 last last JJ 37231 392 3 words word NNS 37231 392 4 are be VBP 37231 392 5 a a DT 37231 392 6 clear clear JJ 37231 392 7 admission admission NN 37231 392 8 of of IN 37231 392 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 392 10 opinion opinion NN 37231 392 11 that that IN 37231 392 12 the the DT 37231 392 13 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 392 14 can can MD 37231 392 15 not not RB 37231 392 16 be be VB 37231 392 17 established establish VBN 37231 392 18 . . . 37231 393 1 _ _ NNP 37231 393 2 Lechler Lechler NNP 37231 393 3 _ _ NNP 37231 393 4 candidly candidly RB 37231 393 5 confesses confess VBZ 37231 393 6 that that IN 37231 393 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 393 8 commenced commence VBD 37231 393 9 with with IN 37231 393 10 a a DT 37231 393 11 prejudice prejudice NN 37231 393 12 in in IN 37231 393 13 favour favour NN 37231 393 14 of of IN 37231 393 15 the the DT 37231 393 16 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 393 17 of of IN 37231 393 18 the the DT 37231 393 19 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 393 20 in in IN 37231 393 21 the the DT 37231 393 22 Shorter Shorter NNP 37231 393 23 Recension Recension NNP 37231 393 24 , , , 37231 393 25 but but CC 37231 393 26 on on IN 37231 393 27 reading read VBG 37231 393 28 them -PRON- PRP 37231 393 29 through through RP 37231 393 30 , , , 37231 393 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 393 32 says say VBZ 37231 393 33 that that IN 37231 393 34 an an DT 37231 393 35 impression impression NN 37231 393 36 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 37231 393 37 to to IN 37231 393 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 393 39 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 393 40 was be VBD 37231 393 41 produced produce VBN 37231 393 42 upon upon IN 37231 393 43 him -PRON- PRP 37231 393 44 which which WDT 37231 393 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 393 46 had have VBD 37231 393 47 not not RB 37231 393 48 been be VBN 37231 393 49 able able JJ 37231 393 50 to to TO 37231 393 51 shake shake VB 37231 393 52 off off RP 37231 393 53 . . . 37231 394 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 394 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 394 3 to to TO 37231 394 4 point point VB 37231 394 5 out out RP 37231 394 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 394 7 internal internal JJ 37231 394 8 improbability improbability NN 37231 394 9 , , , 37231 394 10 and and CC 37231 394 11 other other JJ 37231 394 12 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 394 13 connected connect VBN 37231 394 14 with with IN 37231 394 15 the the DT 37231 394 16 supposed suppose VBN 37231 394 17 journey journey NN 37231 394 18 , , , 37231 394 19 which which WDT 37231 394 20 make make VBP 37231 394 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 394 22 " " `` 37231 394 23 still still RB 37231 394 24 more more RBR 37231 394 25 improbable improbable JJ 37231 394 26 that that IN 37231 394 27 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 394 28 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 394 29 can can MD 37231 394 30 really really RB 37231 394 31 have have VB 37231 394 32 written write VBN 37231 394 33 these these DT 37231 394 34 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 394 35 in in IN 37231 394 36 this this DT 37231 394 37 situation situation NN 37231 394 38 . . . 37231 394 39 " " '' 37231 395 1 Lechler lechler NN 37231 395 2 does do VBZ 37231 395 3 not not RB 37231 395 4 consider consider VB 37231 395 5 that that IN 37231 395 6 the the DT 37231 395 7 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 395 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 395 9 strengthen strengthen VB 37231 395 10 the the DT 37231 395 11 case case NN 37231 395 12 ; ; , 37231 395 13 and and CC 37231 395 14 although although IN 37231 395 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 395 16 admits admit VBZ 37231 395 17 that that IN 37231 395 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 395 19 can can MD 37231 395 20 not not RB 37231 395 21 congratulate congratulate VB 37231 395 22 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 395 23 on on IN 37231 395 24 the the DT 37231 395 25 possession possession NN 37231 395 26 of of IN 37231 395 27 " " `` 37231 395 28 certainty certainty NNP 37231 395 29 and and CC 37231 395 30 cheerfulness cheerfulness NN 37231 395 31 of of IN 37231 395 32 conviction conviction NN 37231 395 33 " " '' 37231 395 34 of of IN 37231 395 35 the the DT 37231 395 36 inauthenticity inauthenticity NN 37231 395 37 of of IN 37231 395 38 the the DT 37231 395 39 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 395 40 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 395 41 , , , 37231 395 42 he -PRON- PRP 37231 395 43 at at RB 37231 395 44 least least JJS 37231 395 45 very very RB 37231 395 46 clearly clearly RB 37231 395 47 justifies justify VBZ 37231 395 48 the the DT 37231 395 49 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 395 50 that that IN 37231 395 51 the the DT 37231 395 52 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 395 53 can can MD 37231 395 54 not not RB 37231 395 55 be be VB 37231 395 56 established establish VBN 37231 395 57 . . . 37231 396 1 Now now RB 37231 396 2 what what WP 37231 396 3 has have VBZ 37231 396 4 been be VBN 37231 396 5 the the DT 37231 396 6 result result NN 37231 396 7 of of IN 37231 396 8 this this DT 37231 396 9 minute minute NN 37231 396 10 and and CC 37231 396 11 prejudiced prejudiced JJ 37231 396 12 attack attack NN 37231 396 13 upon upon IN 37231 396 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 396 15 notes note NNS 37231 396 16 ? ? . 37231 397 1 Out out IN 37231 397 2 of of IN 37231 397 3 nearly nearly RB 37231 397 4 seventy seventy CD 37231 397 5 critics critic NNS 37231 397 6 and and CC 37231 397 7 writers writer NNS 37231 397 8 in in IN 37231 397 9 connection connection NN 37231 397 10 with with IN 37231 397 11 what what WP 37231 397 12 is be VBZ 37231 397 13 admitted admit VBN 37231 397 14 to to TO 37231 397 15 be be VB 37231 397 16 one one CD 37231 397 17 of of IN 37231 397 18 the the DT 37231 397 19 most most RBS 37231 397 20 intricate intricate JJ 37231 397 21 questions question NNS 37231 397 22 of of IN 37231 397 23 Christian christian JJ 37231 397 24 literature literature NN 37231 397 25 , , , 37231 397 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 397 27 appears appear VBZ 37231 397 28 that that DT 37231 397 29 -- -- : 37231 397 30 much much RB 37231 397 31 to to IN 37231 397 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 397 33 regret regret NN 37231 397 34 -- -- : 37231 397 35 I -PRON- PRP 37231 397 36 have have VBP 37231 397 37 inserted insert VBN 37231 397 38 one one CD 37231 397 39 name name NN 37231 397 40 totally totally RB 37231 397 41 by by IN 37231 397 42 accident accident NN 37231 397 43 , , , 37231 397 44 overlooked overlook VBD 37231 397 45 that that IN 37231 397 46 the the DT 37231 397 47 doubts doubt NNS 37231 397 48 of of IN 37231 397 49 another another DT 37231 397 50 had have VBD 37231 397 51 been be VBN 37231 397 52 removed remove VBN 37231 397 53 by by IN 37231 397 54 the the DT 37231 397 55 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 397 56 publication publication NN 37231 397 57 of of IN 37231 397 58 the the DT 37231 397 59 Short Short NNP 37231 397 60 Recension Recension NNP 37231 397 61 and and CC 37231 397 62 consequently consequently RB 37231 397 63 { { -LRB- 37231 397 64 xliv xliv NNP 37231 397 65 } } -RRB- 37231 397 66 erroneously erroneously RB 37231 397 67 classed class VBD 37231 397 68 him -PRON- PRP 37231 397 69 , , , 37231 397 70 and and CC 37231 397 71 I -PRON- PRP 37231 397 72 withdraw withdraw VBP 37231 397 73 a a DT 37231 397 74 third third NN 37231 397 75 whose whose WP$ 37231 397 76 doubts doubt NNS 37231 397 77 I -PRON- PRP 37231 397 78 consider consider VBP 37231 397 79 that that IN 37231 397 80 I -PRON- PRP 37231 397 81 have have VBP 37231 397 82 overrated overrate VBN 37231 397 83 . . . 37231 398 1 Mistakes mistake NNS 37231 398 2 to to IN 37231 398 3 this this DT 37231 398 4 extent extent NN 37231 398 5 in in IN 37231 398 6 dealing deal VBG 37231 398 7 with with IN 37231 398 8 such such PDT 37231 398 9 a a DT 37231 398 10 mass mass NN 37231 398 11 of of IN 37231 398 12 references reference NNS 37231 398 13 , , , 37231 398 14 or or CC 37231 398 15 a a DT 37231 398 16 difference difference NN 37231 398 17 of of IN 37231 398 18 a a DT 37231 398 19 shade shade NN 37231 398 20 more more RBR 37231 398 21 or or CC 37231 398 22 less less RBR 37231 398 23 in in IN 37231 398 24 the the DT 37231 398 25 representation representation NN 37231 398 26 of of IN 37231 398 27 critical critical JJ 37231 398 28 opinions opinion NNS 37231 398 29 , , , 37231 398 30 not not RB 37231 398 31 always always RB 37231 398 32 clearly clearly RB 37231 398 33 expressed express VBN 37231 398 34 , , , 37231 398 35 may may MD 37231 398 36 , , , 37231 398 37 I -PRON- PRP 37231 398 38 hope hope VBP 37231 398 39 , , , 37231 398 40 be be VB 37231 398 41 excusable excusable JJ 37231 398 42 , , , 37231 398 43 and and CC 37231 398 44 I -PRON- PRP 37231 398 45 can can MD 37231 398 46 only only RB 37231 398 47 say say VB 37231 398 48 that that IN 37231 398 49 I -PRON- PRP 37231 398 50 am be VBP 37231 398 51 only only RB 37231 398 52 too too RB 37231 398 53 glad glad JJ 37231 398 54 to to TO 37231 398 55 correct correct VB 37231 398 56 such such JJ 37231 398 57 errors error NNS 37231 398 58 . . . 37231 399 1 On on IN 37231 399 2 the the DT 37231 399 3 other other JJ 37231 399 4 hand hand NN 37231 399 5 , , , 37231 399 6 a a DT 37231 399 7 critic critic NN 37231 399 8 who who WP 37231 399 9 attacks attack VBZ 37231 399 10 such such JJ 37231 399 11 references reference NNS 37231 399 12 , , , 37231 399 13 in in IN 37231 399 14 such such PDT 37231 399 15 a a DT 37231 399 16 tone tone NN 37231 399 17 , , , 37231 399 18 and and CC 37231 399 19 with with IN 37231 399 20 such such JJ 37231 399 21 wholesale wholesale JJ 37231 399 22 accusations accusation NNS 37231 399 23 of of IN 37231 399 24 " " `` 37231 399 25 misstatement misstatement NN 37231 399 26 " " '' 37231 399 27 and and CC 37231 399 28 " " `` 37231 399 29 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 37231 399 30 , , , 37231 399 31 " " '' 37231 399 32 was be VBD 37231 399 33 bound bind VBN 37231 399 34 to to TO 37231 399 35 be be VB 37231 399 36 accurate accurate JJ 37231 399 37 , , , 37231 399 38 and and CC 37231 399 39 I -PRON- PRP 37231 399 40 have have VBP 37231 399 41 shown show VBN 37231 399 42 that that IN 37231 399 43 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 399 44 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 399 45 is be VBZ 37231 399 46 not not RB 37231 399 47 only only RB 37231 399 48 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 37231 399 49 in in IN 37231 399 50 matters matter NNS 37231 399 51 of of IN 37231 399 52 fact fact NN 37231 399 53 , , , 37231 399 54 but but CC 37231 399 55 unfair unfair JJ 37231 399 56 in in IN 37231 399 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 399 58 statements statement NNS 37231 399 59 of of IN 37231 399 60 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 399 61 purpose purpose NN 37231 399 62 . . . 37231 400 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 400 2 am be VBP 37231 400 3 happy happy JJ 37231 400 4 , , , 37231 400 5 however however RB 37231 400 6 , , , 37231 400 7 to to TO 37231 400 8 be be VB 37231 400 9 able able JJ 37231 400 10 to to TO 37231 400 11 make make VB 37231 400 12 use use NN 37231 400 13 of of IN 37231 400 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 400 15 own own JJ 37231 400 16 words word NNS 37231 400 17 and and CC 37231 400 18 say say VB 37231 400 19 : : : 37231 400 20 " " `` 37231 400 21 I -PRON- PRP 37231 400 22 may may MD 37231 400 23 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 400 24 have have VB 37231 400 25 fallen fall VBN 37231 400 26 into into IN 37231 400 27 some some DT 37231 400 28 errors error NNS 37231 400 29 of of IN 37231 400 30 detail detail NN 37231 400 31 , , , 37231 400 32 though though IN 37231 400 33 I -PRON- PRP 37231 400 34 have have VBP 37231 400 35 endeavoured endeavour VBN 37231 400 36 to to TO 37231 400 37 avoid avoid VB 37231 400 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 400 39 , , , 37231 400 40 but but CC 37231 400 41 the the DT 37231 400 42 main main JJ 37231 400 43 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 400 44 are be VBP 37231 400 45 , , , 37231 400 46 I -PRON- PRP 37231 400 47 believe believe VBP 37231 400 48 , , , 37231 400 49 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 37231 400 50 . . . 37231 401 1 " " `` 37231 401 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 401 3 l l NN 37231 401 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 401 5 There there EX 37231 401 6 are be VBP 37231 401 7 further further JJ 37231 401 8 misstatements misstatement NNS 37231 401 9 made make VBN 37231 401 10 by by IN 37231 401 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 401 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 401 13 to to TO 37231 401 14 which which WDT 37231 401 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 401 16 must must MD 37231 401 17 briefly briefly RB 37231 401 18 refer refer VB 37231 401 19 before before IN 37231 401 20 turning turn VBG 37231 401 21 to to IN 37231 401 22 other other JJ 37231 401 23 matters matter NNS 37231 401 24 . . . 37231 402 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 402 2 says say VBZ 37231 402 3 , , , 37231 402 4 with with IN 37231 402 5 unhesitating unhesitate VBG 37231 402 6 boldness:-- boldness:-- UH 37231 402 7 One one CD 37231 402 8 highly highly RB 37231 402 9 important important JJ 37231 402 10 omission omission NN 37231 402 11 is be VBZ 37231 402 12 significant significant JJ 37231 402 13 . . . 37231 403 1 There there EX 37231 403 2 is be VBZ 37231 403 3 no no DT 37231 403 4 mention mention NN 37231 403 5 , , , 37231 403 6 from from IN 37231 403 7 first first RB 37231 403 8 to to IN 37231 403 9 last last JJ 37231 403 10 , , , 37231 403 11 of of IN 37231 403 12 the the DT 37231 403 13 Armenian armenian JJ 37231 403 14 version version NN 37231 403 15 . . . 37231 404 1 Now now RB 37231 404 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 404 3 happens happen VBZ 37231 404 4 that that IN 37231 404 5 this this DT 37231 404 6 version version NN 37231 404 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 404 8 so so RB 37231 404 9 far far RB 37231 404 10 as as IN 37231 404 11 regards regard VBZ 37231 404 12 the the DT 37231 404 13 documentary documentary JJ 37231 404 14 evidence evidence NN 37231 404 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 404 16 _ _ NNP 37231 404 17 has have VBZ 37231 404 18 been be VBN 37231 404 19 felt feel VBN 37231 404 20 to to TO 37231 404 21 be be VB 37231 404 22 the the DT 37231 404 23 key key NN 37231 404 24 to to IN 37231 404 25 the the DT 37231 404 26 position position NN 37231 404 27 , , , 37231 404 28 and and CC 37231 404 29 around around IN 37231 404 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 404 31 the the DT 37231 404 32 battle battle NN 37231 404 33 has have VBZ 37231 404 34 raged rage VBN 37231 404 35 fiercely fiercely RB 37231 404 36 since since IN 37231 404 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 404 38 publication publication NN 37231 404 39 _ _ NNP 37231 404 40 . . . 37231 405 1 One one CD 37231 405 2 who who WP 37231 405 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 405 4 like like IN 37231 405 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 405 6 author author NN 37231 405 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 405 8 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 405 9 the the DT 37231 405 10 priority priority NN 37231 405 11 of of IN 37231 405 12 the the DT 37231 405 13 Curetonian curetonian JJ 37231 405 14 letters letter NNS 37231 405 15 , , , 37231 405 16 was be VBD 37231 405 17 especially especially RB 37231 405 18 bound bind VBN 37231 405 19 to to TO 37231 405 20 give give VB 37231 405 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 405 22 some some DT 37231 405 23 consideration consideration NN 37231 405 24 , , , 37231 405 25 for for IN 37231 405 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 405 27 furnishes furnish VBZ 37231 405 28 the the DT 37231 405 29 most most RBS 37231 405 30 formidable formidable JJ 37231 405 31 argument argument NN 37231 405 32 to to IN 37231 405 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 405 34 opponents opponent NNS 37231 405 35 . . . 37231 406 1 This this DT 37231 406 2 version version NN 37231 406 3 was be VBD 37231 406 4 given give VBN 37231 406 5 to to IN 37231 406 6 the the DT 37231 406 7 world world NN 37231 406 8 by by IN 37231 406 9 Petermann Petermann NNP 37231 406 10 in in IN 37231 406 11 1849 1849 CD 37231 406 12 , , , 37231 406 13 the the DT 37231 406 14 same same JJ 37231 406 15 year year NN 37231 406 16 in in IN 37231 406 17 which which WDT 37231 406 18 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 406 19 's 's POS 37231 406 20 later later JJ 37231 406 21 work work NN 37231 406 22 , , , 37231 406 23 the the DT 37231 406 24 _ _ NNP 37231 406 25 Corpus Corpus NNP 37231 406 26 Ignatianum Ignatianum NNP 37231 406 27 _ _ NNP 37231 406 28 , , , 37231 406 29 appeared appear VBD 37231 406 30 , , , 37231 406 31 and and CC 37231 406 32 therefore therefore RB 37231 406 33 was be VBD 37231 406 34 unknown unknown JJ 37231 406 35 to to IN 37231 406 36 him -PRON- PRP 37231 406 37 . . . 37231 407 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 407 2 _ _ NNP 37231 407 3 bearing bearing NN 37231 407 4 occupies occupy VBZ 37231 407 5 a a DT 37231 407 6 more more RBR 37231 407 7 or or CC 37231 407 8 less less RBR 37231 407 9 prominent prominent JJ 37231 407 10 place place NN 37231 407 11 in in IN 37231 407 12 all all DT 37231 407 13 , , , 37231 407 14 or or CC 37231 407 15 nearly nearly RB 37231 407 16 all all DT 37231 407 17 , , , 37231 407 18 the the DT 37231 407 19 writers writer NNS 37231 407 20 who who WP 37231 407 21 have have VBP 37231 407 22 specially specially RB 37231 407 23 discussed discuss VBN 37231 407 24 the the DT 37231 407 25 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 407 26 question question NN 37231 407 27 during during IN 37231 407 28 the the DT 37231 407 29 last last JJ 37231 407 30 quarter quarter NN 37231 407 31 of of IN 37231 407 32 a a DT 37231 407 33 century century NN 37231 407 34 . . . 37231 408 1 This this DT 37231 408 2 is be VBZ 37231 408 3 true true JJ 37231 408 4 of of IN 37231 408 5 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 408 6 and and CC 37231 408 7 Weiss Weiss NNP 37231 408 8 and and CC 37231 408 9 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 408 10 and and CC 37231 408 11 Uhlhom Uhlhom NNP 37231 408 12 , , , 37231 408 13 whom whom WP 37231 408 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 408 15 cites cite VBZ 37231 408 16 , , , 37231 408 17 not not RB 37231 408 18 less less JJR 37231 408 19 than than IN 37231 408 20 of of IN 37231 408 21 Merx Merx NNP 37231 408 22 and and CC 37231 408 23 Denzinger Denzinger NNP 37231 408 24 and and CC 37231 408 25 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 408 26 , , , 37231 408 27 whom whom WP 37231 408 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 408 29 neglects neglect VBZ 37231 408 30 to to TO 37231 408 31 cite cite VB 37231 408 32 _ _ NNP 37231 408 33 . . . 37231 409 1 Now now RB 37231 409 2 first first RB 37231 409 3 as as IN 37231 409 4 regards regard VBZ 37231 409 5 the the DT 37231 409 6 facts fact NNS 37231 409 7 . . . 37231 410 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 410 2 do do VBP 37231 410 3 not not RB 37231 410 4 maintain maintain VB 37231 410 5 the the DT 37231 410 6 1 1 CD 37231 410 7 " " `` 37231 410 8 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 37231 410 9 Review Review NNP 37231 410 10 , , , 37231 410 11 " " '' 37231 410 12 February February NNP 37231 410 13 , , , 37231 410 14 1875 1875 CD 37231 410 15 , , , 37231 410 16 p. p. NN 37231 410 17 183 183 CD 37231 410 18 . . . 37231 411 1 { { -LRB- 37231 411 2 xlv xlv NNP 37231 411 3 } } -RRB- 37231 411 4 priority priority NN 37231 411 5 of of IN 37231 411 6 the the DT 37231 411 7 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 411 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 411 9 in in IN 37231 411 10 this this DT 37231 411 11 book book NN 37231 411 12 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 411 13 , , , 37231 411 14 indeed indeed RB 37231 411 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 411 16 express express VBP 37231 411 17 no no DT 37231 411 18 personal personal JJ 37231 411 19 opinion opinion NN 37231 411 20 whatever whatever WDT 37231 411 21 regarding regard VBG 37231 411 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 411 23 which which WDT 37231 411 24 is be VBZ 37231 411 25 not not RB 37231 411 26 contained contain VBN 37231 411 27 in in IN 37231 411 28 that that DT 37231 411 29 general general JJ 37231 411 30 declaration declaration NNP 37231 411 31 of of IN 37231 411 32 belief belief NNP 37231 411 33 , , , 37231 411 34 the the DT 37231 411 35 decision decision NN 37231 411 36 of of IN 37231 411 37 which which WDT 37231 411 38 excites excite VBZ 37231 411 39 the the DT 37231 411 40 wrath wrath NN 37231 411 41 of of IN 37231 411 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 411 43 diffident diffident NN 37231 411 44 critic critic NN 37231 411 45 , , , 37231 411 46 that that IN 37231 411 47 the the DT 37231 411 48 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 411 49 in in IN 37231 411 50 no no DT 37231 411 51 form form NN 37231 411 52 have have VBP 37231 411 53 " " `` 37231 411 54 any any DT 37231 411 55 value value NN 37231 411 56 as as IN 37231 411 57 evidence evidence NN 37231 411 58 for for IN 37231 411 59 an an DT 37231 411 60 earlier early JJR 37231 411 61 period period NN 37231 411 62 than than IN 37231 411 63 the the DT 37231 411 64 end end NN 37231 411 65 of of IN 37231 411 66 the the DT 37231 411 67 second second JJ 37231 411 68 or or CC 37231 411 69 beginning beginning NN 37231 411 70 of of IN 37231 411 71 the the DT 37231 411 72 third third JJ 37231 411 73 century century NN 37231 411 74 , , , 37231 411 75 even even RB 37231 411 76 if if IN 37231 411 77 they -PRON- PRP 37231 411 78 have have VBP 37231 411 79 any any DT 37231 411 80 value value NN 37231 411 81 at at RB 37231 411 82 all all RB 37231 411 83 . . . 37231 411 84 " " '' 37231 412 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 412 2 merely merely RB 37231 412 3 represent represent VBP 37231 412 4 the the DT 37231 412 5 opinion opinion NN 37231 412 6 of of IN 37231 412 7 others other NNS 37231 412 8 regarding regard VBG 37231 412 9 those those DT 37231 412 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 412 11 . . . 37231 413 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 413 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 413 3 very very RB 37231 413 4 greatly greatly RB 37231 413 5 exaggerates exaggerate VBZ 37231 413 6 the the DT 37231 413 7 importance importance NN 37231 413 8 attached attach VBN 37231 413 9 to to IN 37231 413 10 the the DT 37231 413 11 Armenian armenian JJ 37231 413 12 version version NN 37231 413 13 , , , 37231 413 14 and and CC 37231 413 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 413 16 call call VBP 37231 413 17 special special JJ 37231 413 18 attention attention NN 37231 413 19 to to IN 37231 413 20 the the DT 37231 413 21 passages passage NNS 37231 413 22 in in IN 37231 413 23 the the DT 37231 413 24 above above JJ 37231 413 25 quotation quotation NN 37231 413 26 which which WDT 37231 413 27 I -PRON- PRP 37231 413 28 have have VBP 37231 413 29 taken take VBN 37231 413 30 the the DT 37231 413 31 liberty liberty NN 37231 413 32 of of IN 37231 413 33 italicising italicising NN 37231 413 34 . . . 37231 414 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 414 2 venture venture VBP 37231 414 3 to to TO 37231 414 4 say say VB 37231 414 5 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 414 6 that that DT 37231 414 7 , , , 37231 414 8 so so RB 37231 414 9 far far RB 37231 414 10 from from IN 37231 414 11 being be VBG 37231 414 12 considered consider VBN 37231 414 13 the the DT 37231 414 14 " " `` 37231 414 15 key key NN 37231 414 16 of of IN 37231 414 17 the the DT 37231 414 18 position position NN 37231 414 19 , , , 37231 414 20 " " '' 37231 414 21 this this DT 37231 414 22 version version NN 37231 414 23 has have VBZ 37231 414 24 , , , 37231 414 25 with with IN 37231 414 26 some some DT 37231 414 27 exceptions exception NNS 37231 414 28 , , , 37231 414 29 played play VBD 37231 414 30 a a DT 37231 414 31 most most RBS 37231 414 32 subordinate subordinate JJ 37231 414 33 and and CC 37231 414 34 insignificant insignificant JJ 37231 414 35 part part NN 37231 414 36 in in IN 37231 414 37 the the DT 37231 414 38 controversy controversy NN 37231 414 39 , , , 37231 414 40 and and CC 37231 414 41 as as IN 37231 414 42 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 414 43 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 414 44 has have VBZ 37231 414 45 expressly expressly RB 37231 414 46 mentioned mention VBN 37231 414 47 certain certain JJ 37231 414 48 writers writer NNS 37231 414 49 , , , 37231 414 50 I -PRON- PRP 37231 414 51 will will MD 37231 414 52 state state VB 37231 414 53 how how WRB 37231 414 54 the the DT 37231 414 55 case case NN 37231 414 56 stands stand VBZ 37231 414 57 with with IN 37231 414 58 regard regard NN 37231 414 59 to to IN 37231 414 60 them -PRON- PRP 37231 414 61 . . . 37231 415 1 Weiss Weiss NNP 37231 415 2 , , , 37231 415 3 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 37231 415 4 , , , 37231 415 5 Uhlhorn Uhlhorn NNP 37231 415 6 , , , 37231 415 7 Merx Merx NNP 37231 415 8 , , , 37231 415 9 and and CC 37231 415 10 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 415 11 certainly certainly RB 37231 415 12 " " `` 37231 415 13 more more RBR 37231 415 14 or or CC 37231 415 15 less less RBR 37231 415 16 prominently prominently RB 37231 415 17 " " `` 37231 415 18 deal deal NN 37231 415 19 with with IN 37231 415 20 them -PRON- PRP 37231 415 21 . . . 37231 416 1 Denzinger Denzinger NNP 37231 416 2 , , , 37231 416 3 however however RB 37231 416 4 , , , 37231 416 5 only only RB 37231 416 6 refers refer VBZ 37231 416 7 to to IN 37231 416 8 Petermann Petermann NNP 37231 416 9 's 's POS 37231 416 10 publication publication NN 37231 416 11 , , , 37231 416 12 which which WDT 37231 416 13 appeared appear VBD 37231 416 14 while while IN 37231 416 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 416 16 own own JJ 37231 416 17 _ _ NNP 37231 416 18 brochure brochure NN 37231 416 19 _ _ NNP 37231 416 20 was be VBD 37231 416 21 passing pass VBG 37231 416 22 through through IN 37231 416 23 the the DT 37231 416 24 press press NN 37231 416 25 , , , 37231 416 26 in in IN 37231 416 27 a a DT 37231 416 28 short short JJ 37231 416 29 note note NN 37231 416 30 at at IN 37231 416 31 the the DT 37231 416 32 end end NN 37231 416 33 , , , 37231 416 34 and and CC 37231 416 35 in in IN 37231 416 36 again again RB 37231 416 37 writing write VBG 37231 416 38 on on IN 37231 416 39 the the DT 37231 416 40 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 416 41 question question NN 37231 416 42 , , , 37231 416 43 two two CD 37231 416 44 years year NNS 37231 416 45 after,(1 after,(1 NNP 37231 416 46 ) ) -RRB- 37231 416 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 416 48 does do VBZ 37231 416 49 not not RB 37231 416 50 even even RB 37231 416 51 allude allude VB 37231 416 52 to to IN 37231 416 53 the the DT 37231 416 54 Armenian armenian JJ 37231 416 55 version version NN 37231 416 56 . . . 37231 417 1 Beyond beyond IN 37231 417 2 the the DT 37231 417 3 barest bare JJS 37231 417 4 historical historical JJ 37231 417 5 reference reference NN 37231 417 6 to to IN 37231 417 7 Petermann Petermann NNP 37231 417 8 's 's POS 37231 417 9 work work NN 37231 417 10 , , , 37231 417 11 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 417 12 does do VBZ 37231 417 13 not not RB 37231 417 14 discuss discuss VB 37231 417 15 the the DT 37231 417 16 Armenian armenian JJ 37231 417 17 version version NN 37231 417 18 at at RB 37231 417 19 all all RB 37231 417 20 So so RB 37231 417 21 much much JJ 37231 417 22 for for IN 37231 417 23 the the DT 37231 417 24 writers writer NNS 37231 417 25 actually actually RB 37231 417 26 mentioned mention VBN 37231 417 27 by by IN 37231 417 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 417 29 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 417 30 . . . 37231 418 1 As as IN 37231 418 2 for for IN 37231 418 3 " " `` 37231 418 4 the the DT 37231 418 5 writers writer NNS 37231 418 6 who who WP 37231 418 7 have have VBP 37231 418 8 specially specially RB 37231 418 9 discussed discuss VBN 37231 418 10 the the DT 37231 418 11 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 418 12 question question NN 37231 418 13 during during IN 37231 418 14 the the DT 37231 418 15 last last JJ 37231 418 16 quarter quarter NN 37231 418 17 of of IN 37231 418 18 a a DT 37231 418 19 century century NN 37231 418 20 " " '' 37231 418 21 : : : 37231 418 22 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 418 23 apparently apparently RB 37231 418 24 did do VBD 37231 418 25 not not RB 37231 418 26 think think VB 37231 418 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 418 28 worth worth JJ 37231 418 29 while while IN 37231 418 30 to to TO 37231 418 31 add add VB 37231 418 32 anything anything NN 37231 418 33 regarding regard VBG 37231 418 34 the the DT 37231 418 35 Armenian armenian JJ 37231 418 36 version version NN 37231 418 37 of of IN 37231 418 38 Petermann Petermann NNP 37231 418 39 { { -LRB- 37231 418 40 xlvi xlvi NNP 37231 418 41 } } -RRB- 37231 418 42 after after IN 37231 418 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 418 44 appearance appearance NN 37231 418 45 ; ; : 37231 418 46 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 37231 418 47 refutes refute VBZ 37231 418 48 Petermann Petermann NNP 37231 418 49 's 's POS 37231 418 50 arguments argument NNS 37231 418 51 in in IN 37231 418 52 a a DT 37231 418 53 few few JJ 37231 418 54 pages page NNS 37231 418 55 of of IN 37231 418 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 418 57 " " `` 37231 418 58 Hippolytus";(1 Hippolytus";(1 NNP 37231 418 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 418 60 Baur Baur NNP 37231 418 61 , , , 37231 418 62 who who WP 37231 418 63 wrote write VBD 37231 418 64 against against IN 37231 418 65 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 37231 418 66 and and CC 37231 418 67 the the DT 37231 418 68 Curetonian curetonian JJ 37231 418 69 letters letter NNS 37231 418 70 , , , 37231 418 71 and and CC 37231 418 72 , , , 37231 418 73 according accord VBG 37231 418 74 to to IN 37231 418 75 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 418 76 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 418 77 's 's POS 37231 418 78 representation representation NN 37231 418 79 , , , 37231 418 80 should should MD 37231 418 81 have have VB 37231 418 82 found find VBN 37231 418 83 this this DT 37231 418 84 " " `` 37231 418 85 the the DT 37231 418 86 most most RBS 37231 418 87 formidable formidable JJ 37231 418 88 argument argument NN 37231 418 89 " " '' 37231 418 90 against against IN 37231 418 91 them -PRON- PRP 37231 418 92 , , , 37231 418 93 does do VBZ 37231 418 94 not not RB 37231 418 95 anywhere anywhere RB 37231 418 96 , , , 37231 418 97 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 418 98 to to IN 37231 418 99 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 418 100 publication publication NN 37231 418 101 , , , 37231 418 102 even even RB 37231 418 103 allude allude VB 37231 418 104 to to IN 37231 418 105 the the DT 37231 418 106 Armenian Armenian NNP 37231 418 107 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 418 108 ; ; : 37231 418 109 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 418 110 , , , 37231 418 111 in in IN 37231 418 112 a a DT 37231 418 113 note note NN 37231 418 114 of of IN 37231 418 115 a a DT 37231 418 116 couple couple NN 37231 418 117 of of IN 37231 418 118 lines,(2 lines,(2 NNS 37231 418 119 ) ) -RRB- 37231 418 120 refers refer VBZ 37231 418 121 to to IN 37231 418 122 Petermann Petermann NNP 37231 418 123 's 's POS 37231 418 124 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 418 125 as as RB 37231 418 126 identical identical JJ 37231 418 127 with with IN 37231 418 128 a a DT 37231 418 129 post post JJ 37231 418 130 - - JJ 37231 418 131 Eusebian eusebian JJ 37231 418 132 manipulated manipulate VBN 37231 418 133 form form NN 37231 418 134 of of IN 37231 418 135 the the DT 37231 418 136 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 418 137 which which WDT 37231 418 138 he -PRON- PRP 37231 418 139 mentions mention VBZ 37231 418 140 in in IN 37231 418 141 a a DT 37231 418 142 sentence sentence NN 37231 418 143 in in IN 37231 418 144 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 418 145 text text NN 37231 418 146 ; ; : 37231 418 147 Dressel Dressel NNP 37231 418 148 devotes devote VBZ 37231 418 149 a a DT 37231 418 150 few few JJ 37231 418 151 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 37231 418 152 lines line NNS 37231 418 153 to to IN 37231 418 154 them;(3 them;(3 NNP 37231 418 155 ) ) -RRB- 37231 418 156 Hefele(4 Hefele(4 NNP 37231 418 157 ) ) -RRB- 37231 418 158 supports support VBZ 37231 418 159 them -PRON- PRP 37231 418 160 at at IN 37231 418 161 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 418 162 greater great JJR 37231 418 163 length length NN 37231 418 164 ; ; : 37231 418 165 but but CC 37231 418 166 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 418 167 , , , 37231 418 168 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 418 169 , , , 37231 418 170 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 418 171 , , , 37231 418 172 Bohringer Bohringer NNP 37231 418 173 , , , 37231 418 174 Scholten Scholten NNP 37231 418 175 , , , 37231 418 176 and and CC 37231 418 177 others other NNS 37231 418 178 have have VBP 37231 418 179 not not RB 37231 418 180 thought think VBN 37231 418 181 them -PRON- PRP 37231 418 182 worthy worthy JJ 37231 418 183 of of IN 37231 418 184 special special JJ 37231 418 185 notice notice NN 37231 418 186 , , , 37231 418 187 at at IN 37231 418 188 any any DT 37231 418 189 rate rate NN 37231 418 190 none none NN 37231 418 191 of of IN 37231 418 192 these these DT 37231 418 193 nor nor CC 37231 418 194 any any DT 37231 418 195 other other JJ 37231 418 196 writers writer NNS 37231 418 197 of of IN 37231 418 198 any any DT 37231 418 199 weight weight NN 37231 418 200 have have VBP 37231 418 201 , , , 37231 418 202 so so RB 37231 418 203 far far RB 37231 418 204 as as IN 37231 418 205 I -PRON- PRP 37231 418 206 am be VBP 37231 418 207 aware aware JJ 37231 418 208 , , , 37231 418 209 introduced introduce VBD 37231 418 210 them -PRON- PRP 37231 418 211 into into IN 37231 418 212 the the DT 37231 418 213 controversy controversy NN 37231 418 214 at at RB 37231 418 215 all all RB 37231 418 216 . . . 37231 419 1 The the DT 37231 419 2 argument argument NN 37231 419 3 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 419 4 did do VBD 37231 419 5 not not RB 37231 419 6 seem seem VB 37231 419 7 to to IN 37231 419 8 me -PRON- PRP 37231 419 9 of of IN 37231 419 10 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 419 11 importance importance NN 37231 419 12 to to TO 37231 419 13 introduce introduce VB 37231 419 14 into into IN 37231 419 15 a a DT 37231 419 16 discussion discussion NN 37231 419 17 already already RB 37231 419 18 too too RB 37231 419 19 long long JJ 37231 419 20 and and CC 37231 419 21 complicated complicated JJ 37231 419 22 , , , 37231 419 23 and and CC 37231 419 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 419 25 refer refer VBP 37231 419 26 the the DT 37231 419 27 reader reader NN 37231 419 28 to to IN 37231 419 29 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 37231 419 30 's 's POS 37231 419 31 reply reply NN 37231 419 32 to to IN 37231 419 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 419 34 , , , 37231 419 35 from from IN 37231 419 36 which which WDT 37231 419 37 , , , 37231 419 38 however however RB 37231 419 39 , , , 37231 419 40 I -PRON- PRP 37231 419 41 may may MD 37231 419 42 quote quote VB 37231 419 43 the the DT 37231 419 44 following follow VBG 37231 419 45 lines line NNS 37231 419 46 : : : 37231 419 47 " " `` 37231 419 48 But but CC 37231 419 49 it -PRON- PRP 37231 419 50 appears appear VBZ 37231 419 51 to to IN 37231 419 52 me -PRON- PRP 37231 419 53 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 419 54 serious serious JJ 37231 419 55 to to TO 37231 419 56 say say VB 37231 419 57 : : : 37231 419 58 there there EX 37231 419 59 are be VBP 37231 419 60 the the DT 37231 419 61 Seven Seven NNP 37231 419 62 Letters Letters NNPS 37231 419 63 in in IN 37231 419 64 Armenian Armenian NNP 37231 419 65 , , , 37231 419 66 and and CC 37231 419 67 I -PRON- PRP 37231 419 68 maintain maintain VBP 37231 419 69 , , , 37231 419 70 they -PRON- PRP 37231 419 71 prove prove VBP 37231 419 72 that that IN 37231 419 73 Coreton Coreton NNP 37231 419 74 's 's POS 37231 419 75 text text NN 37231 419 76 is be VBZ 37231 419 77 an an DT 37231 419 78 incomplete incomplete JJ 37231 419 79 extract extract NN 37231 419 80 , , , 37231 419 81 because because IN 37231 419 82 , , , 37231 419 83 I -PRON- PRP 37231 419 84 think think VBP 37231 419 85 , , , 37231 419 86 I -PRON- PRP 37231 419 87 have have VBP 37231 419 88 found find VBN 37231 419 89 some some DT 37231 419 90 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 419 91 idioms idiom NNS 37231 419 92 in in IN 37231 419 93 the the DT 37231 419 94 Armenian armenian JJ 37231 419 95 text text NN 37231 419 96 ! ! . 37231 420 1 Well well UH 37231 420 2 , , , 37231 420 3 if if IN 37231 420 4 that that DT 37231 420 5 is be VBZ 37231 420 6 not not RB 37231 420 7 a a DT 37231 420 8 joke joke NN 37231 420 9 , , , 37231 420 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 420 11 simply simply RB 37231 420 12 proves prove VBZ 37231 420 13 , , , 37231 420 14 according accord VBG 37231 420 15 to to IN 37231 420 16 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 420 17 logic logic NN 37231 420 18 , , , 37231 420 19 that that IN 37231 420 20 the the DT 37231 420 21 Seven Seven NNP 37231 420 22 Letters Letters NNPS 37231 420 23 must must MD 37231 420 24 have have VB 37231 420 25 once once RB 37231 420 26 been be VBN 37231 420 27 translated translate VBN 37231 420 28 into into IN 37231 420 29 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 420 30 . . . 37231 421 1 But but CC 37231 421 2 how how WRB 37231 421 3 can can MD 37231 421 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 421 5 prove prove VB 37231 421 6 that that IN 37231 421 7 the the DT 37231 421 8 Greek greek JJ 37231 421 9 original original NN 37231 421 10 of of IN 37231 421 11 { { -LRB- 37231 421 12 xlvii xlvii NN 37231 421 13 } } -RRB- 37231 421 14 this this DT 37231 421 15 supposed suppose VBN 37231 421 16 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 421 17 version version NN 37231 421 18 is be VBZ 37231 421 19 the the DT 37231 421 20 genuine genuine JJ 37231 421 21 text text NN 37231 421 22 , , , 37231 421 23 and and CC 37231 421 24 not not RB 37231 421 25 an an DT 37231 421 26 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 421 27 and and CC 37231 421 28 partially partially RB 37231 421 29 forged forge VBD 37231 421 30 one one NN 37231 421 31 ? ? . 37231 421 32 " " '' 37231 422 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 422 2 l l NN 37231 422 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 422 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 422 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 422 6 blames blame VBZ 37231 422 7 me -PRON- PRP 37231 422 8 for for IN 37231 422 9 omitting omit VBG 37231 422 10 to to TO 37231 422 11 introduce introduce VB 37231 422 12 this this DT 37231 422 13 argument argument NN 37231 422 14 , , , 37231 422 15 on on IN 37231 422 16 the the DT 37231 422 17 ground ground NN 37231 422 18 that that IN 37231 422 19 " " `` 37231 422 20 a a DT 37231 422 21 discussion discussion NN 37231 422 22 which which WDT 37231 422 23 , , , 37231 422 24 while while IN 37231 422 25 assuming assume VBG 37231 422 26 the the DT 37231 422 27 priority priority NN 37231 422 28 of of IN 37231 422 29 the the DT 37231 422 30 Curetonian curetonian JJ 37231 422 31 letters letter NNS 37231 422 32 , , , 37231 422 33 ignores ignore VBZ 37231 422 34 this this DT 37231 422 35 version version NN 37231 422 36 altogether altogether RB 37231 422 37 , , , 37231 422 38 has have VBZ 37231 422 39 omitted omit VBN 37231 422 40 a a DT 37231 422 41 vital vital JJ 37231 422 42 problem problem NN 37231 422 43 of of IN 37231 422 44 which which WDT 37231 422 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 422 46 was be VBD 37231 422 47 bound bind VBN 37231 422 48 to to TO 37231 422 49 give give VB 37231 422 50 an an DT 37231 422 51 account account NN 37231 422 52 " " `` 37231 422 53 Now now RB 37231 422 54 all all PDT 37231 422 55 this this DT 37231 422 56 is be VBZ 37231 422 57 sheer sheer JJ 37231 422 58 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 37231 422 59 . . . 37231 423 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 423 2 do do VBP 37231 423 3 not not RB 37231 423 4 assume assume VB 37231 423 5 the the DT 37231 423 6 priority priority NN 37231 423 7 of of IN 37231 423 8 the the DT 37231 423 9 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 37231 423 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 423 11 , , , 37231 423 12 and and CC 37231 423 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 423 14 examine examine VBP 37231 423 15 all all PDT 37231 423 16 the the DT 37231 423 17 passages passage NNS 37231 423 18 contained contain VBN 37231 423 19 in in IN 37231 423 20 the the DT 37231 423 21 seven seven CD 37231 423 22 Greek Greek NNP 37231 423 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 423 24 which which WDT 37231 423 25 have have VBP 37231 423 26 any any DT 37231 423 27 bearing bearing NN 37231 423 28 upon upon IN 37231 423 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 423 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 423 31 . . . 37231 424 1 Passing pass VBG 37231 424 2 on on RP 37231 424 3 to to IN 37231 424 4 another another DT 37231 424 5 point point NN 37231 424 6 , , , 37231 424 7 I -PRON- PRP 37231 424 8 say say VBP 37231 424 9 : : : 37231 424 10 " " `` 37231 424 11 Seven Seven NNP 37231 424 12 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 424 13 have have VBP 37231 424 14 been be VBN 37231 424 15 selected select VBN 37231 424 16 out out IN 37231 424 17 of of IN 37231 424 18 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 424 19 extant extant JJ 37231 424 20 , , , 37231 424 21 all all DT 37231 424 22 equally equally RB 37231 424 23 purporting purport VBG 37231 424 24 to to TO 37231 424 25 be be VB 37231 424 26 by by IN 37231 424 27 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 424 28 , , , 37231 424 29 simply simply RB 37231 424 30 because because IN 37231 424 31 only only RB 37231 424 32 that that DT 37231 424 33 number number NN 37231 424 34 were be VBD 37231 424 35 mentioned mention VBN 37231 424 36 by by IN 37231 424 37 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 424 38 . . . 37231 425 1 " " `` 37231 425 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 425 3 2 2 LS 37231 425 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 425 5 Another another DT 37231 425 6 passage passage NN 37231 425 7 is be VBZ 37231 425 8 also also RB 37231 425 9 quoted quote VBN 37231 425 10 by by IN 37231 425 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 425 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 425 13 , , , 37231 425 14 which which WDT 37231 425 15 will will MD 37231 425 16 be be VB 37231 425 17 found find VBN 37231 425 18 a a DT 37231 425 19 little little JJ 37231 425 20 further further RB 37231 425 21 on on RB 37231 425 22 , , , 37231 425 23 where where WRB 37231 425 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 425 25 is be VBZ 37231 425 26 taken take VBN 37231 425 27 for for IN 37231 425 28 facility facility NN 37231 425 29 of of IN 37231 425 30 reference reference NN 37231 425 31 . . . 37231 426 1 Upon upon IN 37231 426 2 this this DT 37231 426 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 426 4 writes write VBZ 37231 426 5 as as IN 37231 426 6 follows follow VBZ 37231 426 7 : : : 37231 426 8 This this DT 37231 426 9 attempt attempt NN 37231 426 10 to to TO 37231 426 11 confound confound VB 37231 426 12 the the DT 37231 426 13 seven seven CD 37231 426 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 426 15 mentioned mention VBN 37231 426 16 by by IN 37231 426 17 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 426 18 with with IN 37231 426 19 the the DT 37231 426 20 other other JJ 37231 426 21 confessedly confessedly RB 37231 426 22 spurious spurious JJ 37231 426 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 426 24 , , , 37231 426 25 as as IN 37231 426 26 if if IN 37231 426 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 426 28 presented present VBD 37231 426 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 426 30 to to IN 37231 426 31 us -PRON- PRP 37231 426 32 with with IN 37231 426 33 the the DT 37231 426 34 same same JJ 37231 426 35 credentials credential NNS 37231 426 36 , , , 37231 426 37 ignores ignore VBZ 37231 426 38 all all PDT 37231 426 39 the the DT 37231 426 40 important important JJ 37231 426 41 facts fact NNS 37231 426 42 bearing bear VBG 37231 426 43 on on IN 37231 426 44 the the DT 37231 426 45 question question NN 37231 426 46 . . . 37231 427 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 427 2 1 1 CD 37231 427 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 427 4 . . . 37231 428 1 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 37231 428 2 , , , 37231 428 3 a a DT 37231 428 4 century century NN 37231 428 5 after after IN 37231 428 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 428 7 , , , 37231 428 8 betrays betray VBZ 37231 428 9 no no DT 37231 428 10 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 428 11 of of IN 37231 428 12 any any DT 37231 428 13 other other JJ 37231 428 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 428 15 , , , 37231 428 16 and and CC 37231 428 17 there there EX 37231 428 18 is be VBZ 37231 428 19 no no DT 37231 428 20 distinct distinct JJ 37231 428 21 trace trace NN 37231 428 22 of of IN 37231 428 23 the the DT 37231 428 24 use use NN 37231 428 25 of of IN 37231 428 26 the the DT 37231 428 27 confessedly confessedly RB 37231 428 28 spurious spurious JJ 37231 428 29 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 428 30 till till IN 37231 428 31 late late RB 37231 428 32 in in IN 37231 428 33 the the DT 37231 428 34 sixth sixth JJ 37231 428 35 century century NN 37231 428 36 at at IN 37231 428 37 the the DT 37231 428 38 earliest early JJS 37231 428 39 . . . 37231 429 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 429 2 2 2 CD 37231 429 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 429 4 . . . 37231 430 1 The the DT 37231 430 2 confessedly confessedly RB 37231 430 3 spurious spurious JJ 37231 430 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 430 5 differ differ VBP 37231 430 6 widely widely RB 37231 430 7 in in IN 37231 430 8 style style NN 37231 430 9 from from IN 37231 430 10 the the DT 37231 430 11 seven seven CD 37231 430 12 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 430 13 , , , 37231 430 14 and and CC 37231 430 15 betray betray VB 37231 430 16 the the DT 37231 430 17 same same JJ 37231 430 18 hand hand NN 37231 430 19 which which WDT 37231 430 20 interpolated interpolate VBD 37231 430 21 the the DT 37231 430 22 seven seven CD 37231 430 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 430 24 . . . 37231 431 1 In in IN 37231 431 2 other other JJ 37231 431 3 words word NNS 37231 431 4 , , , 37231 431 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 431 6 clearly clearly RB 37231 431 7 formed form VBD 37231 431 8 part part NN 37231 431 9 of of IN 37231 431 10 the the DT 37231 431 11 Long Long NNP 37231 431 12 Recension Recension NNP 37231 431 13 in in IN 37231 431 14 the the DT 37231 431 15 first first JJ 37231 431 16 instance instance NN 37231 431 17 . . . 37231 432 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 432 2 3 3 CD 37231 432 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 432 4 . . . 37231 433 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 433 2 abound abound VBP 37231 433 3 in in IN 37231 433 4 anachronisms anachronism NNS 37231 433 5 which which WDT 37231 433 6 point point VBP 37231 433 7 to to IN 37231 433 8 an an DT 37231 433 9 age age NN 37231 433 10 later later RB 37231 433 11 than than IN 37231 433 12 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 433 13 , , , 37231 433 14 as as IN 37231 433 15 the the DT 37231 433 16 date date NN 37231 433 17 of of IN 37231 433 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 433 19 composition composition NN 37231 433 20 . . . 37231 434 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 434 2 3 3 LS 37231 434 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 434 4 Although although IN 37231 434 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 434 6 do do VBP 37231 434 7 not not RB 37231 434 8 really really RB 37231 434 9 say say VB 37231 434 10 in in IN 37231 434 11 the the DT 37231 434 12 above above JJ 37231 434 13 that that IN 37231 434 14 no no DT 37231 434 15 other other JJ 37231 434 16 pleas plea NNS 37231 434 17 are be VBP 37231 434 18 advanced advanced JJ 37231 434 19 in in IN 37231 434 20 favour favour NN 37231 434 21 of of IN 37231 434 22 the the DT 37231 434 23 seven seven CD 37231 434 24 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 434 25 , , , 37231 434 26 { { -LRB- 37231 434 27 xlviii xlviii NN 37231 434 28 } } -RRB- 37231 434 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 434 30 contend contend VBP 37231 434 31 that that IN 37231 434 32 , , , 37231 434 33 reduced reduce VBN 37231 434 34 to to IN 37231 434 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 434 36 simplest simple JJS 37231 434 37 form form NN 37231 434 38 , , , 37231 434 39 the the DT 37231 434 40 argument argument NN 37231 434 41 for for IN 37231 434 42 that that DT 37231 434 43 special special JJ 37231 434 44 number number NN 37231 434 45 rests rest NNS 37231 434 46 mainly mainly RB 37231 434 47 , , , 37231 434 48 if if IN 37231 434 49 not not RB 37231 434 50 altogether altogether RB 37231 434 51 , , , 37231 434 52 upon upon IN 37231 434 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 434 54 mention mention NN 37231 434 55 by by IN 37231 434 56 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 434 57 . . . 37231 435 1 The the DT 37231 435 2 very very RB 37231 435 3 first first JJ 37231 435 4 reason reason NN 37231 435 5 ( ( -LRB- 37231 435 6 1 1 CD 37231 435 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 435 8 advanced advance VBN 37231 435 9 by by IN 37231 435 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 435 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 435 12 to to TO 37231 435 13 refute refute VB 37231 435 14 me -PRON- PRP 37231 435 15 is be VBZ 37231 435 16 a a DT 37231 435 17 practical practical JJ 37231 435 18 admission admission NN 37231 435 19 of of IN 37231 435 20 the the DT 37231 435 21 correctness correctness NN 37231 435 22 of of IN 37231 435 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 435 24 statement statement NN 37231 435 25 , , , 37231 435 26 for for IN 37231 435 27 the the DT 37231 435 28 eight eight CD 37231 435 29 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 435 30 are be VBP 37231 435 31 put put VBN 37231 435 32 out out IN 37231 435 33 of of IN 37231 435 34 court court NN 37231 435 35 because because IN 37231 435 36 even even RB 37231 435 37 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 37231 435 38 , , , 37231 435 39 a a DT 37231 435 40 century century NN 37231 435 41 after after IN 37231 435 42 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 435 43 , , , 37231 435 44 does do VBZ 37231 435 45 not not RB 37231 435 46 betray betray VB 37231 435 47 any any DT 37231 435 48 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 435 49 of of IN 37231 435 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 435 51 , , , 37231 435 52 but but CC 37231 435 53 the the DT 37231 435 54 " " `` 37231 435 55 silence silence NN 37231 435 56 of of IN 37231 435 57 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 435 58 , , , 37231 435 59 " " '' 37231 435 60 the the DT 37231 435 61 earlier early JJR 37231 435 62 witness witness NN 37231 435 63 , , , 37231 435 64 is be VBZ 37231 435 65 infinitely infinitely RB 37231 435 66 more more RBR 37231 435 67 important important JJ 37231 435 68 , , , 37231 435 69 and and CC 37231 435 70 it -PRON- PRP 37231 435 71 merely merely RB 37231 435 72 receives receive VBZ 37231 435 73 some some DT 37231 435 74 increase increase NN 37231 435 75 of of IN 37231 435 76 significance significance NN 37231 435 77 from from IN 37231 435 78 the the DT 37231 435 79 silence silence NN 37231 435 80 of of IN 37231 435 81 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 37231 435 82 . . . 37231 436 1 Suppose suppose VB 37231 436 2 , , , 37231 436 3 however however RB 37231 436 4 , , , 37231 436 5 that that IN 37231 436 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 436 7 had have VBD 37231 436 8 referred refer VBN 37231 436 9 to to IN 37231 436 10 any any DT 37231 436 11 of of IN 37231 436 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 436 13 , , , 37231 436 14 how how WRB 37231 436 15 changed change VBD 37231 436 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 436 17 position position NN 37231 436 18 would would MD 37231 436 19 have have VB 37231 436 20 been be VBN 37231 436 21 ! ! . 37231 437 1 The the DT 37231 437 2 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 437 3 referred refer VBD 37231 437 4 to to TO 37231 437 5 would would MD 37231 437 6 have have VB 37231 437 7 attained attain VBN 37231 437 8 the the DT 37231 437 9 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 437 10 distinction distinction NN 37231 437 11 which which WDT 37231 437 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 437 13 mention mention NN 37231 437 14 has have VBZ 37231 437 15 conferred confer VBN 37231 437 16 upon upon IN 37231 437 17 the the DT 37231 437 18 rest rest NN 37231 437 19 The the DT 37231 437 20 fact fact NN 37231 437 21 is be VBZ 37231 437 22 , , , 37231 437 23 moreover moreover RB 37231 437 24 , , , 37231 437 25 that that IN 37231 437 26 , , , 37231 437 27 throughout throughout IN 37231 437 28 the the DT 37231 437 29 controversy controversy NN 37231 437 30 , , , 37231 437 31 the the DT 37231 437 32 two two CD 37231 437 33 divisions division NNS 37231 437 34 of of IN 37231 437 35 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 437 36 are be VBP 37231 437 37 commonly commonly RB 37231 437 38 designated designate VBN 37231 437 39 the the DT 37231 437 40 " " `` 37231 437 41 prae- prae- JJ 37231 437 42 " " '' 37231 437 43 and and CC 37231 437 44 " " `` 37231 437 45 post post JJ 37231 437 46 - - JJ 37231 437 47 Eusebian eusebian JJ 37231 437 48 , , , 37231 437 49 " " '' 37231 437 50 making make VBG 37231 437 51 him -PRON- PRP 37231 437 52 the the DT 37231 437 53 turning turning NN 37231 437 54 - - HYPH 37231 437 55 point point NN 37231 437 56 of of IN 37231 437 57 the the DT 37231 437 58 controversy controversy NN 37231 437 59 . . . 37231 438 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 438 2 , , , 37231 438 3 further further RB 37231 438 4 on on RB 37231 438 5 , , , 37231 438 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 438 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 438 8 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 438 9 admits admit VBZ 37231 438 10 : : : 37231 438 11 " " `` 37231 438 12 The the DT 37231 438 13 testimony testimony NN 37231 438 14 of of IN 37231 438 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 438 16 first first RB 37231 438 17 differentiates differentiate VBZ 37231 438 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 438 19 . . . 37231 439 1 " " `` 37231 439 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 439 3 1 1 LS 37231 439 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 439 5 The the DT 37231 439 6 argument argument NN 37231 439 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 439 8 2 2 CD 37231 439 9 and and CC 37231 439 10 3 3 CD 37231 439 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 439 12 that that IN 37231 439 13 the the DT 37231 439 14 eight eight CD 37231 439 15 rejected reject VBN 37231 439 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 439 17 betray betray NN 37231 439 18 anachronisms anachronism NNS 37231 439 19 and and CC 37231 439 20 interpolations interpolation NNS 37231 439 21 , , , 37231 439 22 is be VBZ 37231 439 23 no no DT 37231 439 24 refutation refutation NN 37231 439 25 of of IN 37231 439 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 439 27 statement statement NN 37231 439 28 , , , 37231 439 29 for for IN 37231 439 30 the the DT 37231 439 31 same same JJ 37231 439 32 accusation accusation NN 37231 439 33 is be VBZ 37231 439 34 brought bring VBN 37231 439 35 by by IN 37231 439 36 the the DT 37231 439 37 majority majority NN 37231 439 38 of of IN 37231 439 39 critics critic NNS 37231 439 40 against against IN 37231 439 41 the the DT 37231 439 42 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 439 43 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 439 44 . . . 37231 440 1 The the DT 37231 440 2 fourth fourth JJ 37231 440 3 and and CC 37231 440 4 last last JJ 37231 440 5 argument argument NN 37231 440 6 seems seem VBZ 37231 440 7 more more RBR 37231 440 8 directly directly RB 37231 440 9 addressed address VBN 37231 440 10 to to IN 37231 440 11 a a DT 37231 440 12 second second JJ 37231 440 13 paragraph paragraph NN 37231 440 14 quoted quote VBN 37231 440 15 by by IN 37231 440 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 440 17 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 440 18 , , , 37231 440 19 to to TO 37231 440 20 which which WDT 37231 440 21 I -PRON- PRP 37231 440 22 refer refer VBP 37231 440 23 above above IN 37231 440 24 , , , 37231 440 25 and and CC 37231 440 26 which which WDT 37231 440 27 I -PRON- PRP 37231 440 28 have have VBP 37231 440 29 reserved reserve VBN 37231 440 30 till till IN 37231 440 31 now now RB 37231 440 32 as as IN 37231 440 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 440 34 requires require VBZ 37231 440 35 more more RBR 37231 440 36 detailed detailed JJ 37231 440 37 notice notice NN 37231 440 38 . . . 37231 441 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 441 2 is be VBZ 37231 441 3 this this DT 37231 441 4 : : : 37231 441 5 " " `` 37231 441 6 It -PRON- PRP 37231 441 7 is be VBZ 37231 441 8 a a DT 37231 441 9 total total JJ 37231 441 10 mistake mistake NN 37231 441 11 to to TO 37231 441 12 suppose suppose VB 37231 441 13 that that IN 37231 441 14 the the DT 37231 441 15 seven seven CD 37231 441 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 441 17 mentioned mention VBN 37231 441 18 by by IN 37231 441 19 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 441 20 have have VBP 37231 441 21 been be VBN 37231 441 22 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 441 23 to to IN 37231 441 24 us -PRON- PRP 37231 441 25 in in IN 37231 441 26 any any DT 37231 441 27 special special JJ 37231 441 28 way way NN 37231 441 29 . . . 37231 442 1 These these DT 37231 442 2 Epistles epistle NNS 37231 442 3 are be VBP 37231 442 4 mixed mix VBN 37231 442 5 up up RP 37231 442 6 in in IN 37231 442 7 the the DT 37231 442 8 Medicean Medicean NNP 37231 442 9 and and CC 37231 442 10 corresponding corresponding JJ 37231 442 11 ancient ancient JJ 37231 442 12 Latin Latin NNP 37231 442 13 MSS MSS NNP 37231 442 14 . . . 37231 443 1 with with IN 37231 443 2 the the DT 37231 443 3 other other JJ 37231 443 4 eight eight CD 37231 443 5 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 443 6 , , , 37231 443 7 universally universally RB 37231 443 8 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 443 9 to to TO 37231 443 10 be be VB 37231 443 11 spurious spurious JJ 37231 443 12 , , , 37231 443 13 without without IN 37231 443 14 distinction distinction NN 37231 443 15 of of IN 37231 443 16 any any DT 37231 443 17 kind kind NN 37231 443 18 , , , 37231 443 19 and and CC 37231 443 20 all all DT 37231 443 21 have have VBP 37231 443 22 equal equal JJ 37231 443 23 honour honour NN 37231 443 24 . . . 37231 444 1 " " `` 37231 444 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 444 3 2 2 LS 37231 444 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 444 5 { { -LRB- 37231 444 6 xlix xlix NN 37231 444 7 } } -RRB- 37231 444 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 444 9 will will MD 37231 444 10 at at IN 37231 444 11 once once RB 37231 444 12 give give VB 37231 444 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 444 14 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 444 15 's 's POS 37231 444 16 comment comment NN 37231 444 17 on on IN 37231 444 18 this this DT 37231 444 19 , , , 37231 444 20 in in IN 37231 444 21 contrast contrast NN 37231 444 22 with with IN 37231 444 23 the the DT 37231 444 24 statement statement NN 37231 444 25 of of IN 37231 444 26 a a DT 37231 444 27 writer writer NN 37231 444 28 equally equally RB 37231 444 29 distinguished distinguish VBN 37231 444 30 for for IN 37231 444 31 learning learning NN 37231 444 32 and and CC 37231 444 33 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 37231 444 34 -- -- . 37231 444 35 Dr Dr NNP 37231 444 36 . . . 37231 444 37 Tregelles tregelle NNS 37231 444 38 : : : 37231 444 39 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 444 40 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 444 41 . . . 37231 445 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 445 2 4 4 CD 37231 445 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 445 4 . . . 37231 446 1 " " `` 37231 446 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 446 3 is be VBZ 37231 446 4 not not RB 37231 446 5 strictly strictly RB 37231 446 6 true true JJ 37231 446 7 that that IN 37231 446 8 the the DT 37231 446 9 seven seven CD 37231 446 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 446 11 are be VBP 37231 446 12 mixed mix VBN 37231 446 13 up up RP 37231 446 14 with with IN 37231 446 15 the the DT 37231 446 16 confessedly confessedly RB 37231 446 17 spurious spurious JJ 37231 446 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 446 19 . . . 37231 447 1 In in IN 37231 447 2 the the DT 37231 447 3 Greek Greek NNP 37231 447 4 and and CC 37231 447 5 Latin Latin NNP 37231 447 6 MSS MSS NNP 37231 447 7 . . . 37231 447 8 , , , 37231 447 9 as as RB 37231 447 10 also also RB 37231 447 11 in in IN 37231 447 12 the the DT 37231 447 13 Armenian armenian JJ 37231 447 14 version version NN 37231 447 15 , , , 37231 447 16 the the DT 37231 447 17 spurious spurious JJ 37231 447 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 447 19 come come VBP 37231 447 20 after after IN 37231 447 21 the the DT 37231 447 22 others other NNS 37231 447 23 ; ; : 37231 447 24 and and CC 37231 447 25 this this DT 37231 447 26 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 447 27 , , , 37231 447 28 combined combine VBN 37231 447 29 with with IN 37231 447 30 the the DT 37231 447 31 facts fact NNS 37231 447 32 already already RB 37231 447 33 mentioned mention VBN 37231 447 34 , , , 37231 447 35 plainly plainly RB 37231 447 36 shows show VBZ 37231 447 37 that that IN 37231 447 38 they -PRON- PRP 37231 447 39 were be VBD 37231 447 40 a a DT 37231 447 41 later later JJ 37231 447 42 addition addition NN 37231 447 43 , , , 37231 447 44 borrowed borrow VBN 37231 447 45 from from IN 37231 447 46 the the DT 37231 447 47 Long Long NNP 37231 447 48 Recension Recension NNP 37231 447 49 to to TO 37231 447 50 complete complete VB 37231 447 51 the the DT 37231 447 52 body body NN 37231 447 53 of of IN 37231 447 54 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 447 55 letters letter NNS 37231 447 56 . . . 37231 448 1 " " `` 37231 448 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 448 3 1 1 LS 37231 448 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 448 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 448 6 Tregelles Tregelles NNP 37231 448 7 . . . 37231 449 1 " " `` 37231 449 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 449 3 is be VBZ 37231 449 4 a a DT 37231 449 5 mistake mistake NN 37231 449 6 to to TO 37231 449 7 speak speak VB 37231 449 8 of of IN 37231 449 9 seven seven CD 37231 449 10 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 449 11 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 449 12 in in IN 37231 449 13 Greek Greek NNP 37231 449 14 having have VBG 37231 449 15 been be VBN 37231 449 16 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 449 17 to to IN 37231 449 18 us -PRON- PRP 37231 449 19 , , , 37231 449 20 for for IN 37231 449 21 no no DT 37231 449 22 such such JJ 37231 449 23 seven seven CD 37231 449 24 exist exist NN 37231 449 25 , , , 37231 449 26 except except IN 37231 449 27 through through IN 37231 449 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 449 29 having have VBG 37231 449 30 been be VBN 37231 449 31 selected select VBN 37231 449 32 by by IN 37231 449 33 editors editor NNS 37231 449 34 from from IN 37231 449 35 the the DT 37231 449 36 Medicean Medicean NNP 37231 449 37 MS MS NNP 37231 449 38 . . . 37231 449 39 which which WDT 37231 449 40 contains contain VBZ 37231 449 41 so so RB 37231 449 42 much much RB 37231 449 43 that that DT 37231 449 44 is be VBZ 37231 449 45 confessedly confessedly RB 37231 449 46 spurious;--a spurious;--a JJ 37231 449 47 fact fact NN 37231 449 48 which which WDT 37231 449 49 some some DT 37231 449 50 who who WP 37231 449 51 imagine imagine VBP 37231 449 52 a a DT 37231 449 53 diplomatic diplomatic JJ 37231 449 54 transmission transmission NN 37231 449 55 of of IN 37231 449 56 seven seven CD 37231 449 57 have have VBP 37231 449 58 overlooked overlook VBN 37231 449 59 . . . 37231 450 1 " " `` 37231 450 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 450 3 2 2 LS 37231 450 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 450 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 450 6 will will MD 37231 450 7 further further RB 37231 450 8 quote quote VB 37231 450 9 the the DT 37231 450 10 words word NNS 37231 450 11 of of IN 37231 450 12 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 450 13 , , , 37231 450 14 for for IN 37231 450 15 as as IN 37231 450 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 450 17 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 450 18 advances advance VBZ 37231 450 19 nothing nothing NN 37231 450 20 but but IN 37231 450 21 assertions assertion NNS 37231 450 22 , , , 37231 450 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 450 24 is be VBZ 37231 450 25 well well JJ 37231 450 26 to to TO 37231 450 27 meet meet VB 37231 450 28 him -PRON- PRP 37231 450 29 with with IN 37231 450 30 the the DT 37231 450 31 testimony testimony NN 37231 450 32 of of IN 37231 450 33 others other NNS 37231 450 34 rather rather RB 37231 450 35 than than IN 37231 450 36 the the DT 37231 450 37 mere mere JJ 37231 450 38 reiteration reiteration NN 37231 450 39 of of IN 37231 450 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 450 41 own own JJ 37231 450 42 statement statement NN 37231 450 43 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 450 44 says say VBZ 37231 450 45 : : : 37231 450 46 " " `` 37231 450 47 Again again RB 37231 450 48 , , , 37231 450 49 there there EX 37231 450 50 is be VBZ 37231 450 51 another another DT 37231 450 52 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 450 53 which which WDT 37231 450 54 will will MD 37231 450 55 naturally naturally RB 37231 450 56 lead lead VB 37231 450 57 us -PRON- PRP 37231 450 58 to to TO 37231 450 59 look look VB 37231 450 60 with with IN 37231 450 61 some some DT 37231 450 62 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 450 63 upon upon IN 37231 450 64 the the DT 37231 450 65 recension recension NN 37231 450 66 of of IN 37231 450 67 the the DT 37231 450 68 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 450 69 of of IN 37231 450 70 St. St. NNP 37231 450 71 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 450 72 , , , 37231 450 73 as as IN 37231 450 74 exhibited exhibit VBN 37231 450 75 in in IN 37231 450 76 the the DT 37231 450 77 Medicean Medicean NNP 37231 450 78 MS MS NNP 37231 450 79 . . NNP 37231 450 80 , , , 37231 450 81 and and CC 37231 450 82 in in IN 37231 450 83 the the DT 37231 450 84 ancient ancient JJ 37231 450 85 Latin Latin NNP 37231 450 86 version version NN 37231 450 87 corresponding correspond VBG 37231 450 88 with with IN 37231 450 89 it -PRON- PRP 37231 450 90 , , , 37231 450 91 which which WDT 37231 450 92 is be VBZ 37231 450 93 , , , 37231 450 94 that that IN 37231 450 95 the the DT 37231 450 96 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 450 97 presumed presume VBN 37231 450 98 to to TO 37231 450 99 be be VB 37231 450 100 the the DT 37231 450 101 genuine genuine JJ 37231 450 102 production production NN 37231 450 103 of of IN 37231 450 104 that that DT 37231 450 105 holy holy NNP 37231 450 106 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 450 107 are be VBP 37231 450 108 mixed mix VBN 37231 450 109 up up RP 37231 450 110 with with IN 37231 450 111 others other NNS 37231 450 112 , , , 37231 450 113 which which WDT 37231 450 114 are be VBP 37231 450 115 almost almost RB 37231 450 116 universally universally RB 37231 450 117 allowed allow VBN 37231 450 118 to to TO 37231 450 119 be be VB 37231 450 120 spurious spurious JJ 37231 450 121 . . . 37231 451 1 Both both DT 37231 451 2 in in IN 37231 451 3 the the DT 37231 451 4 Greek Greek NNP 37231 451 5 and and CC 37231 451 6 Latin Latin NNP 37231 451 7 MSS MSS NNP 37231 451 8 . . . 37231 452 1 all all PDT 37231 452 2 these these DT 37231 452 3 are be VBP 37231 452 4 placed place VBN 37231 452 5 upon upon IN 37231 452 6 the the DT 37231 452 7 same same JJ 37231 452 8 footing footing NN 37231 452 9 , , , 37231 452 10 and and CC 37231 452 11 no no DT 37231 452 12 distinction distinction NN 37231 452 13 is be VBZ 37231 452 14 drawn draw VBN 37231 452 15 between between IN 37231 452 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 452 17 ; ; : 37231 452 18 and and CC 37231 452 19 the the DT 37231 452 20 only only JJ 37231 452 21 ground ground NN 37231 452 22 which which WDT 37231 452 23 has have VBZ 37231 452 24 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 452 25 been be VBN 37231 452 26 a a DT 37231 452 27 Note note NN 37231 452 28 to to TO 37231 452 29 " " `` 37231 452 30 Home Home NNP 37231 452 31 's 's POS 37231 452 32 Int Int NNP 37231 452 33 . . . 37231 453 1 to to IN 37231 453 2 the the DT 37231 453 3 Holy Holy NNP 37231 453 4 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 37231 453 5 , , , 37231 453 6 " " '' 37231 453 7 12th 12th JJ 37231 453 8 ed ed NNP 37231 453 9 . . NNP 37231 453 10 , , , 37231 453 11 1869 1869 CD 37231 453 12 , , , 37231 453 13 iv iv NNP 37231 453 14 . . . 37231 454 1 p. p. NN 37231 454 2 332 332 CD 37231 454 3 , , , 37231 454 4 note note VB 37231 454 5 1 1 CD 37231 454 6 . . . 37231 455 1 The the DT 37231 455 2 italics italic NNS 37231 455 3 are be VBP 37231 455 4 in in IN 37231 455 5 the the DT 37231 455 6 original original NN 37231 455 7 . . . 37231 456 1 1 1 LS 37231 456 2 " " `` 37231 456 3 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 37231 456 4 Beview Beview NNP 37231 456 5 , , , 37231 456 6 " " `` 37231 456 7 February February NNP 37231 456 8 , , , 37231 456 9 1875 1875 CD 37231 456 10 , , , 37231 456 11 p. p. NN 37231 456 12 347 347 CD 37231 456 13 . . . 37231 457 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 457 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 457 3 makes make VBZ 37231 457 4 the the DT 37231 457 5 following follow VBG 37231 457 6 important important JJ 37231 457 7 admission admission NN 37231 457 8 in in IN 37231 457 9 a a DT 37231 457 10 note note NN 37231 457 11 : : : 37231 457 12 " " `` 37231 457 13 The the DT 37231 457 14 Roman Roman NNP 37231 457 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 457 16 indeed indeed RB 37231 457 17 has have VBZ 37231 457 18 been be VBN 37231 457 19 separated separate VBN 37231 457 20 from from IN 37231 457 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 457 22 companions companion NNS 37231 457 23 , , , 37231 457 24 and and CC 37231 457 25 is be VBZ 37231 457 26 embedded embed VBN 37231 457 27 in in IN 37231 457 28 the the DT 37231 457 29 Martyrology Martyrology NNP 37231 457 30 which which WDT 37231 457 31 stands stand VBZ 37231 457 32 at at IN 37231 457 33 the the DT 37231 457 34 end end NN 37231 457 35 of of IN 37231 457 36 this this DT 37231 457 37 collection collection NN 37231 457 38 in in IN 37231 457 39 the the DT 37231 457 40 Latin Latin NNP 37231 457 41 Version Version NNP 37231 457 42 , , , 37231 457 43 where where WRB 37231 457 44 doubtless doubtless RB 37231 457 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 457 46 stood stand VBD 37231 457 47 also also RB 37231 457 48 in in IN 37231 457 49 the the DT 37231 457 50 Greek Greek NNP 37231 457 51 , , , 37231 457 52 before before IN 37231 457 53 the the DT 37231 457 54 MS MS NNP 37231 457 55 . . NNP 37231 457 56 of of IN 37231 457 57 this this DT 37231 457 58 latter latter NN 37231 457 59 was be VBD 37231 457 60 mutilated mutilate VBN 37231 457 61 . . . 37231 458 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 37231 458 2 the the DT 37231 458 3 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 458 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 458 5 come come VB 37231 458 6 together together RB 37231 458 7 , , , 37231 458 8 and and CC 37231 458 9 are be VBP 37231 458 10 followed follow VBN 37231 458 11 by by IN 37231 458 12 the the DT 37231 458 13 confessedly confessedly RB 37231 458 14 spurious spurious JJ 37231 458 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 458 16 in in IN 37231 458 17 the the DT 37231 458 18 Greek Greek NNP 37231 458 19 and and CC 37231 458 20 Latin Latin NNP 37231 458 21 MSS MSS NNP 37231 458 22 . . . 37231 459 1 In in IN 37231 459 2 the the DT 37231 459 3 Armenian armenian NN 37231 459 4 all all PDT 37231 459 5 the the DT 37231 459 6 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 459 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 459 8 are be VBP 37231 459 9 together together RB 37231 459 10 , , , 37231 459 11 and and CC 37231 459 12 the the DT 37231 459 13 confessedly confessedly RB 37231 459 14 spurious spurious JJ 37231 459 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 459 16 follow follow VBP 37231 459 17 . . . 37231 460 1 See see VB 37231 460 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 460 3 , , , 37231 460 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 460 5 von von NNP 37231 460 6 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 37231 460 7 , , , 37231 460 8 p. p. NN 37231 461 1 111 111 CD 37231 461 2 . . . 37231 461 3 " " '' 37231 462 1 { { -LRB- 37231 462 2 l l NN 37231 462 3 } } -RRB- 37231 462 4 assumed assume VBN 37231 462 5 for for IN 37231 462 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 462 7 separation separation NN 37231 462 8 has have VBZ 37231 462 9 been be VBN 37231 462 10 the the DT 37231 462 11 specification specification NN 37231 462 12 of of IN 37231 462 13 some some DT 37231 462 14 of of IN 37231 462 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 462 16 by by IN 37231 462 17 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 462 18 and and CC 37231 462 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 462 20 omission omission NN 37231 462 21 of of IN 37231 462 22 any any DT 37231 462 23 mention mention NN 37231 462 24 of of IN 37231 462 25 the the DT 37231 462 26 others other NNS 37231 462 27 . . . 37231 462 28 " " '' 37231 462 29 ' ' '' 37231 463 1 " " `` 37231 463 2 The the DT 37231 463 3 external external JJ 37231 463 4 evidence evidence NN 37231 463 5 from from IN 37231 463 6 the the DT 37231 463 7 testimony testimony NN 37231 463 8 of of IN 37231 463 9 manuscripts manuscript NNS 37231 463 10 in in IN 37231 463 11 favour favour NN 37231 463 12 of of IN 37231 463 13 the the DT 37231 463 14 rejected reject VBN 37231 463 15 Greek Greek NNP 37231 463 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 463 17 , , , 37231 463 18 with with IN 37231 463 19 the the DT 37231 463 20 exception exception NN 37231 463 21 of of IN 37231 463 22 that that DT 37231 463 23 to to IN 37231 463 24 the the DT 37231 463 25 Philip Philip NNP 37231 463 26 - - HYPH 37231 463 27 pians pian NNS 37231 463 28 , , , 37231 463 29 is be VBZ 37231 463 30 certainly certainly RB 37231 463 31 greater great JJR 37231 463 32 than than IN 37231 463 33 that that DT 37231 463 34 in in IN 37231 463 35 favour favour NN 37231 463 36 of of IN 37231 463 37 those those DT 37231 463 38 which which WDT 37231 463 39 have have VBP 37231 463 40 been be VBN 37231 463 41 received receive VBN 37231 463 42 . . . 37231 463 43 ' ' '' 37231 464 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 464 2 are be VBP 37231 464 3 found find VBN 37231 464 4 in in IN 37231 464 5 all all PDT 37231 464 6 the the DT 37231 464 7 manuscripts manuscript NNS 37231 464 8 , , , 37231 464 9 both both DT 37231 464 10 Greek Greek NNP 37231 464 11 and and CC 37231 464 12 Latin Latin NNP 37231 464 13 , , , 37231 464 14 in in IN 37231 464 15 the the DT 37231 464 16 same same JJ 37231 464 17 form form NN 37231 464 18 ; ; : 37231 464 19 while while IN 37231 464 20 the the DT 37231 464 21 others other NNS 37231 464 22 exhibit exhibit VBP 37231 464 23 two two CD 37231 464 24 distinct distinct JJ 37231 464 25 and and CC 37231 464 26 very very RB 37231 464 27 different different JJ 37231 464 28 recensions recension NNS 37231 464 29 , , , 37231 464 30 if if IN 37231 464 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 464 32 except except IN 37231 464 33 the the DT 37231 464 34 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 464 35 to to IN 37231 464 36 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 464 37 , , , 37231 464 38 in in IN 37231 464 39 which which WDT 37231 464 40 the the DT 37231 464 41 variations variation NNS 37231 464 42 are be VBP 37231 464 43 very very RB 37231 464 44 few few JJ 37231 464 45 . . . 37231 465 1 Of of IN 37231 465 2 these these DT 37231 465 3 two two CD 37231 465 4 recensions recension NNS 37231 465 5 the the DT 37231 465 6 shorter short JJR 37231 465 7 has have VBZ 37231 465 8 been be VBN 37231 465 9 most most RBS 37231 465 10 generally generally RB 37231 465 11 received receive VBN 37231 465 12 : : : 37231 465 13 the the DT 37231 465 14 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 465 15 of of IN 37231 465 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 465 17 being be VBG 37231 465 18 shorter short JJR 37231 465 19 seems seem VBZ 37231 465 20 much much JJ 37231 465 21 to to TO 37231 465 22 have have VB 37231 465 23 influenced influence VBN 37231 465 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 465 25 reception reception NN 37231 465 26 ; ; : 37231 465 27 and and CC 37231 465 28 the the DT 37231 465 29 text text NN 37231 465 30 of of IN 37231 465 31 the the DT 37231 465 32 Medicean Medicean NNP 37231 465 33 Codex Codex NNP 37231 465 34 and and CC 37231 465 35 of of IN 37231 465 36 the the DT 37231 465 37 two two CD 37231 465 38 copies copy NNS 37231 465 39 of of IN 37231 465 40 the the DT 37231 465 41 corresponding correspond VBG 37231 465 42 Latin latin JJ 37231 465 43 version version NN 37231 465 44 belonging belong VBG 37231 465 45 to to IN 37231 465 46 Cains Cains NNP 37231 465 47 College College NNP 37231 465 48 , , , 37231 465 49 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 37231 465 50 , , , 37231 465 51 and and CC 37231 465 52 Corpus Corpus NNP 37231 465 53 Christi Christi NNP 37231 465 54 College College NNP 37231 465 55 , , , 37231 465 56 Oxford Oxford NNP 37231 465 57 , , , 37231 465 58 has have VBZ 37231 465 59 been be VBN 37231 465 60 adopted adopt VBN 37231 465 61 .... .... . 37231 466 1 In in IN 37231 466 2 all all PDT 37231 466 3 these these DT 37231 466 4 there there EX 37231 466 5 is be VBZ 37231 466 6 no no DT 37231 466 7 distinction distinction NN 37231 466 8 whatever whatever WDT 37231 466 9 drawn draw VBN 37231 466 10 between between IN 37231 466 11 the the DT 37231 466 12 former former JJ 37231 466 13 and and CC 37231 466 14 latter latter JJ 37231 466 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 466 16 : : : 37231 466 17 all all DT 37231 466 18 are be VBP 37231 466 19 placed place VBN 37231 466 20 upon upon IN 37231 466 21 the the DT 37231 466 22 same same JJ 37231 466 23 basis basis NN 37231 466 24 ; ; : 37231 466 25 and and CC 37231 466 26 there there EX 37231 466 27 is be VBZ 37231 466 28 no no DT 37231 466 29 ground ground NN 37231 466 30 whatever whatever WDT 37231 466 31 to to TO 37231 466 32 conclude conclude VB 37231 466 33 either either CC 37231 466 34 that that IN 37231 466 35 the the DT 37231 466 36 arranger arranger NN 37231 466 37 of of IN 37231 466 38 the the DT 37231 466 39 Greek greek JJ 37231 466 40 recension recension NN 37231 466 41 or or CC 37231 466 42 the the DT 37231 466 43 translator translator NN 37231 466 44 of of IN 37231 466 45 the the DT 37231 466 46 Latin Latin NNP 37231 466 47 version version NN 37231 466 48 esteemed esteem VBD 37231 466 49 one one CD 37231 466 50 to to TO 37231 466 51 be be VB 37231 466 52 better well JJR 37231 466 53 or or CC 37231 466 54 more more RBR 37231 466 55 genuine genuine JJ 37231 466 56 than than IN 37231 466 57 another another DT 37231 466 58 . . . 37231 467 1 Nor nor CC 37231 467 2 can can MD 37231 467 3 any any DT 37231 467 4 prejudice prejudice NN 37231 467 5 result result VB 37231 467 6 to to IN 37231 467 7 the the DT 37231 467 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 467 9 to to IN 37231 467 10 the the DT 37231 467 11 Tarsians Tarsians NNPS 37231 467 12 , , , 37231 467 13 to to IN 37231 467 14 the the DT 37231 467 15 Antiochians Antiochians NNPS 37231 467 16 , , , 37231 467 17 and and CC 37231 467 18 to to IN 37231 467 19 Hero Hero NNP 37231 467 20 , , , 37231 467 21 from from IN 37231 467 22 the the DT 37231 467 23 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 467 24 of of IN 37231 467 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 467 26 being be VBG 37231 467 27 placed place VBN 37231 467 28 after after IN 37231 467 29 the the DT 37231 467 30 others other NNS 37231 467 31 in in IN 37231 467 32 the the DT 37231 467 33 collection collection NN 37231 467 34 ; ; : 37231 467 35 for for CC 37231 467 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 467 37 are be VBP 37231 467 38 evidently evidently RB 37231 467 39 arranged arrange VBN 37231 467 40 in in IN 37231 467 41 chronological chronological JJ 37231 467 42 order order NN 37231 467 43 , , , 37231 467 44 and and CC 37231 467 45 rank rank NN 37231 467 46 after after IN 37231 467 47 the the DT 37231 467 48 rest rest NN 37231 467 49 as as IN 37231 467 50 having have VBG 37231 467 51 been be VBN 37231 467 52 written write VBN 37231 467 53 from from IN 37231 467 54 Philippi Philippi NNP 37231 467 55 , , , 37231 467 56 at at IN 37231 467 57 which which WDT 37231 467 58 place place NN 37231 467 59 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 467 60 is be VBZ 37231 467 61 said say VBN 37231 467 62 to to TO 37231 467 63 have have VB 37231 467 64 arrived arrive VBN 37231 467 65 after after IN 37231 467 66 he -PRON- PRP 37231 467 67 had have VBD 37231 467 68 despatched despatch VBN 37231 467 69 the the DT 37231 467 70 previous previous JJ 37231 467 71 Letters letter NNS 37231 467 72 . . . 37231 468 1 So so RB 37231 468 2 far far RB 37231 468 3 , , , 37231 468 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 468 5 , , , 37231 468 6 as as IN 37231 468 7 the the DT 37231 468 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 468 9 of of IN 37231 468 10 all all PDT 37231 468 11 the the DT 37231 468 12 existing exist VBG 37231 468 13 copies copy NNS 37231 468 14 , , , 37231 468 15 Latin Latin NNP 37231 468 16 as as RB 37231 468 17 well well RB 37231 468 18 as as IN 37231 468 19 Greek Greek NNP 37231 468 20 , , , 37231 468 21 of of IN 37231 468 22 both both PDT 37231 468 23 the the DT 37231 468 24 recensions recension NNS 37231 468 25 is be VBZ 37231 468 26 to to TO 37231 468 27 be be VB 37231 468 28 considered consider VBN 37231 468 29 , , , 37231 468 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 468 31 is be VBZ 37231 468 32 certainly certainly RB 37231 468 33 in in IN 37231 468 34 favour favour NN 37231 468 35 of of IN 37231 468 36 the the DT 37231 468 37 rejected reject VBN 37231 468 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 468 39 , , , 37231 468 40 rather rather RB 37231 468 41 than than IN 37231 468 42 of of IN 37231 468 43 those those DT 37231 468 44 which which WDT 37231 468 45 have have VBP 37231 468 46 been be VBN 37231 468 47 retained retain VBN 37231 468 48 . . . 37231 468 49 " " '' 37231 469 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 469 2 2 2 LS 37231 469 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 469 4 Proceeding proceed VBG 37231 469 5 from from IN 37231 469 6 counter counter NN 37231 469 7 - - NNS 37231 469 8 statements statement NNS 37231 469 9 to to IN 37231 469 10 actual actual JJ 37231 469 11 facts fact NNS 37231 469 12 , , , 37231 469 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 469 14 will will MD 37231 469 15 very very RB 37231 469 16 briefly briefly RB 37231 469 17 show show VB 37231 469 18 the the DT 37231 469 19 order order NN 37231 469 20 in in IN 37231 469 21 which which WDT 37231 469 22 these these DT 37231 469 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 469 24 have have VBP 37231 469 25 been be VBN 37231 469 26 found find VBN 37231 469 27 in in IN 37231 469 28 some some DT 37231 469 29 of of IN 37231 469 30 the the DT 37231 469 31 principal principal JJ 37231 469 32 MSS MSS NNP 37231 469 33 . . . 37231 470 1 One one CD 37231 470 2 of of IN 37231 470 3 the the DT 37231 470 4 earliest early JJS 37231 470 5 published publish VBN 37231 470 6 was be VBD 37231 470 7 the the DT 37231 470 8 ancient ancient JJ 37231 470 9 Latin Latin NNP 37231 470 10 version version NN 37231 470 11 of of IN 37231 470 12 eleven eleven CD 37231 470 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 470 14 edited edit VBN 37231 470 15 by by IN 37231 470 16 J. J. NNP 37231 470 17 Faber Faber NNP 37231 470 18 Stapulensis Stapulensis NNP 37231 470 19 in in IN 37231 470 20 1498 1498 CD 37231 470 21 , , , 37231 470 22 which which WDT 37231 470 23 was be VBD 37231 470 24 at at RB 37231 470 25 least least RBS 37231 470 26 quoted quote VBN 37231 470 27 in in IN 37231 470 28 the the DT 37231 470 29 ninth ninth JJ 37231 470 30 century century NN 37231 470 31 , , , 37231 470 32 and and CC 37231 470 33 which which WDT 37231 470 34 in in IN 37231 470 35 the the DT 37231 470 36 subjoined subjoin VBN 37231 470 37 table table NN 37231 470 38 I -PRON- PRP 37231 470 39 shall shall MD 37231 470 40 mark mark VB 37231 470 41 A,(3 A,(3 NNP 37231 470 42 ) ) -RRB- 37231 470 43 and and CC 37231 470 44 which which WDT 37231 470 45 also also RB 37231 470 46 exhibits exhibit VBZ 37231 470 47 the the DT 37231 470 48 order order NN 37231 470 49 of of IN 37231 470 50 Cod cod NN 37231 470 51 . . . 37231 471 1 Vat Vat NNP 37231 471 2 859 859 CD 37231 471 3 , , , 37231 471 4 assigned assign VBN 37231 471 5 to to IN 37231 471 6 the the DT 37231 471 7 eleventh eleventh JJ 37231 471 8 century century NN 37231 471 9 . . . 37231 472 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 472 2 4 4 LS 37231 472 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 472 4 The the DT 37231 472 5 next next JJ 37231 472 6 ( ( -LRB- 37231 472 7 B b NN 37231 472 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 472 9 is be VBZ 37231 472 10 a a DT 37231 472 11 Greek Greek NNP 37231 472 12 MS MS NNP 37231 472 13 . . . 37231 472 14 edited edit VBN 37231 472 15 by by IN 37231 472 16 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 37231 472 17 Pacæus Pacæus NNP 37231 472 18 in in IN 37231 472 19 1557,(5 1557,(5 NNP 37231 472 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 472 21 and and CC 37231 472 22 the the DT 37231 472 23 order order NN 37231 472 24 at at IN 37231 472 25 { { -LRB- 37231 472 26 li li NNP 37231 472 27 } } -RRB- 37231 472 28 the the DT 37231 472 29 same same JJ 37231 472 30 time time NN 37231 472 31 represents represent VBZ 37231 472 32 that that DT 37231 472 33 of of IN 37231 472 34 the the DT 37231 472 35 Cod cod NN 37231 472 36 . . . 37231 473 1 Pal Pal NNP 37231 473 2 . . . 37231 474 1 150 150 CD 37231 474 2 . . . 37231 475 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 475 2 1 1 LS 37231 475 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 475 4 The the DT 37231 475 5 third third JJ 37231 475 6 ( ( -LRB- 37231 475 7 C c NN 37231 475 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 475 9 is be VBZ 37231 475 10 the the DT 37231 475 11 ancient ancient JJ 37231 475 12 Latin latin JJ 37231 475 13 translation translation NN 37231 475 14 , , , 37231 475 15 referred refer VBD 37231 475 16 to to IN 37231 475 17 above above RB 37231 475 18 , , , 37231 475 19 published publish VBN 37231 475 20 by by IN 37231 475 21 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 475 22 Usher Usher NNP 37231 475 23 . . . 37231 476 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 476 2 2 2 LS 37231 476 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 476 4 The the DT 37231 476 5 fourth fourth JJ 37231 476 6 ( ( -LRB- 37231 476 7 D d NN 37231 476 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 476 9 is be VBZ 37231 476 10 the the DT 37231 476 11 celebrated celebrated JJ 37231 476 12 Medicean Medicean NNP 37231 476 13 MS MS NNP 37231 476 14 . . NNP 37231 476 15 assigned assign VBN 37231 476 16 to to IN 37231 476 17 the the DT 37231 476 18 eleventh eleventh JJ 37231 476 19 century century NN 37231 476 20 , , , 37231 476 21 and and CC 37231 476 22 published publish VBN 37231 476 23 by by IN 37231 476 24 Vossiusin Vossiusin NNP 37231 476 25 1646 1646 CD 37231 476 26 . . . 37231 477 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 477 2 3 3 LS 37231 477 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 477 4 This this DT 37231 477 5 also also RB 37231 477 6 represents represent VBZ 37231 477 7 the the DT 37231 477 8 order order NN 37231 477 9 of of IN 37231 477 10 the the DT 37231 477 11 Cod cod NN 37231 477 12 . . . 37231 478 1 Casanatensis Casanatensis NNP 37231 478 2 G. G. NNP 37231 478 3 V. V. NNP 37231 479 1 14 14 CD 37231 479 2 . . . 37231 480 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 480 2 4 4 LS 37231 480 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 480 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 480 5 italicise italicise VBP 37231 480 6 the the DT 37231 480 7 rejected reject VBN 37231 480 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 480 9 : : : 37231 480 10 ( ( -LRB- 37231 480 11 See see VB 37231 480 12 scanned scan VBN 37231 480 13 page page NN 37231 480 14 in in IN 37231 480 15 the the DT 37231 480 16 html html NN 37231 480 17 file file NN 37231 480 18 , , , 37231 480 19 Ed Ed NNP 37231 480 20 . . . 37231 480 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 481 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 481 2 have have VBP 37231 481 3 given give VBN 37231 481 4 the the DT 37231 481 5 order order NN 37231 481 6 in in IN 37231 481 7 MSS MSS NNP 37231 481 8 . . . 37231 482 1 containing contain VBG 37231 482 2 the the DT 37231 482 3 " " `` 37231 482 4 Long long JJ 37231 482 5 Recension Recension NNP 37231 482 6 " " '' 37231 482 7 as as RB 37231 482 8 well well RB 37231 482 9 as as IN 37231 482 10 the the DT 37231 482 11 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 482 12 , , , 37231 482 13 because because IN 37231 482 14 , , , 37231 482 15 however however RB 37231 482 16 much much RB 37231 482 17 some some DT 37231 482 18 may may MD 37231 482 19 desire desire VB 37231 482 20 to to TO 37231 482 21 exclude exclude VB 37231 482 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 482 23 , , , 37231 482 24 the the DT 37231 482 25 variety variety NN 37231 482 26 of of IN 37231 482 27 arrangement arrangement NN 37231 482 28 is be VBZ 37231 482 29 notable notable JJ 37231 482 30 , , , 37231 482 31 and and CC 37231 482 32 presents present NNS 37231 482 33 features feature NNS 37231 482 34 which which WDT 37231 482 35 have have VBP 37231 482 36 an an DT 37231 482 37 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 482 38 bearing bearing NN 37231 482 39 upon upon IN 37231 482 40 this this DT 37231 482 41 question question NN 37231 482 42 . . . 37231 483 1 Taking take VBG 37231 483 2 the the DT 37231 483 3 Vossian vossian JJ 37231 483 4 MS MS NNP 37231 483 5 . . NNP 37231 483 6 , , , 37231 483 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 483 8 is be VBZ 37231 483 9 obvious obvious JJ 37231 483 10 that that IN 37231 483 11 , , , 37231 483 12 without without IN 37231 483 13 any any DT 37231 483 14 distinction distinction NN 37231 483 15 whatever whatever WDT 37231 483 16 between between IN 37231 483 17 the the DT 37231 483 18 genuine genuine NN 37231 483 19 and and CC 37231 483 20 the the DT 37231 483 21 spurious spurious JJ 37231 483 22 , , , 37231 483 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 483 24 contains contain VBZ 37231 483 25 { { -LRB- 37231 483 26 lii lii NN 37231 483 27 } } -RRB- 37231 483 28 three three CD 37231 483 29 of of IN 37231 483 30 the the DT 37231 483 31 false false JJ 37231 483 32 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 483 33 , , , 37231 483 34 and and CC 37231 483 35 _ _ NNP 37231 483 36 does do VBZ 37231 483 37 not not RB 37231 483 38 contain contain VB 37231 483 39 the the DT 37231 483 40 so so RB 37231 483 41 - - HYPH 37231 483 42 called call VBN 37231 483 43 genuine genuine JJ 37231 483 44 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 483 45 to to IN 37231 483 46 the the DT 37231 483 47 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 483 48 at at RB 37231 483 49 all all RB 37231 483 50 _ _ NNP 37231 483 51 . . . 37231 484 1 The the DT 37231 484 2 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 484 3 to to IN 37231 484 4 the the DT 37231 484 5 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 484 6 , , , 37231 484 7 in in IN 37231 484 8 fact fact NN 37231 484 9 , , , 37231 484 10 is be VBZ 37231 484 11 , , , 37231 484 12 to to TO 37231 484 13 use use VB 37231 484 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 484 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 484 16 's 's POS 37231 484 17 own own JJ 37231 484 18 expression expression NN 37231 484 19 , , , 37231 484 20 " " '' 37231 484 21 embedded embed VBN 37231 484 22 in in IN 37231 484 23 the the DT 37231 484 24 Martyrology Martyrology NNP 37231 484 25 , , , 37231 484 26 " " '' 37231 484 27 which which WDT 37231 484 28 is be VBZ 37231 484 29 as as RB 37231 484 30 spurious spurious JJ 37231 484 31 as as IN 37231 484 32 any any DT 37231 484 33 of of IN 37231 484 34 the the DT 37231 484 35 epistles epistle NNS 37231 484 36 . . . 37231 485 1 This this DT 37231 485 2 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 485 3 alone alone RB 37231 485 4 would would MD 37231 485 5 justify justify VB 37231 485 6 the the DT 37231 485 7 assertion assertion NN 37231 485 8 which which WDT 37231 485 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 485 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 485 11 contradicts contradict VBZ 37231 485 12 . . . 37231 486 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 486 2 must must MD 37231 486 3 now now RB 37231 486 4 , , , 37231 486 5 in in IN 37231 486 6 order order NN 37231 486 7 finally finally RB 37231 486 8 to to TO 37231 486 9 dispose dispose VB 37231 486 10 of of IN 37231 486 11 this this DT 37231 486 12 matter matter NN 37231 486 13 of of IN 37231 486 14 notes note NNS 37231 486 15 , , , 37231 486 16 turn turn VBP 37231 486 17 for for IN 37231 486 18 a a DT 37231 486 19 short short JJ 37231 486 20 time time NN 37231 486 21 to to TO 37231 486 22 consider consider VB 37231 486 23 objections objection NNS 37231 486 24 raised raise VBN 37231 486 25 by by IN 37231 486 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 486 27 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 486 28 . . . 37231 487 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 487 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 487 3 have have VBP 37231 487 4 to to TO 37231 487 5 thank thank VB 37231 487 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 487 7 for for IN 37231 487 8 greater great JJR 37231 487 9 courtesy courtesy NN 37231 487 10 , , , 37231 487 11 I -PRON- PRP 37231 487 12 regret regret VBP 37231 487 13 that that IN 37231 487 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 487 15 must must MD 37231 487 16 point point VB 37231 487 17 out out RP 37231 487 18 serious serious JJ 37231 487 19 errors error NNS 37231 487 20 into into IN 37231 487 21 which which WDT 37231 487 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 487 23 has have VBZ 37231 487 24 fallen fall VBN 37231 487 25 in in IN 37231 487 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 487 27 statements statement NNS 37231 487 28 regarding regard VBG 37231 487 29 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 487 30 references reference NNS 37231 487 31 which which WDT 37231 487 32 , , , 37231 487 33 as as IN 37231 487 34 matters matter NNS 37231 487 35 of of IN 37231 487 36 fact fact NN 37231 487 37 , , , 37231 487 38 admit admit VBP 37231 487 39 of of IN 37231 487 40 practical practical JJ 37231 487 41 test test NN 37231 487 42 . . . 37231 488 1 Before before IN 37231 488 2 proceeding proceed VBG 37231 488 3 to to IN 37231 488 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 488 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 488 6 may may MD 37231 488 7 make make VB 37231 488 8 one one CD 37231 488 9 or or CC 37231 488 10 two two CD 37231 488 11 general general JJ 37231 488 12 observations observation NNS 37231 488 13 . . . 37231 489 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 489 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 489 3 says say VBZ 37231 489 4 : : : 37231 489 5 " " `` 37231 489 6 I -PRON- PRP 37231 489 7 may may MD 37231 489 8 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 489 9 express express VB 37231 489 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 489 11 surprise surprise NN 37231 489 12 that that IN 37231 489 13 a a DT 37231 489 14 writer writer NN 37231 489 15 who who WP 37231 489 16 is be VBZ 37231 489 17 quite quite RB 37231 489 18 capable capable JJ 37231 489 19 of of IN 37231 489 20 thinking think VBG 37231 489 21 for for IN 37231 489 22 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 489 23 should should MD 37231 489 24 have have VB 37231 489 25 considered consider VBN 37231 489 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 489 27 worth worth JJ 37231 489 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 489 29 while while NN 37231 489 30 to to TO 37231 489 31 burden burden VB 37231 489 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 489 33 pages page NNS 37231 489 34 with with IN 37231 489 35 lists list NNS 37231 489 36 of of IN 37231 489 37 names name NNS 37231 489 38 and and CC 37231 489 39 writings writing NNS 37231 489 40 , , , 37231 489 41 arranged arrange VBD 37231 489 42 , , , 37231 489 43 for for IN 37231 489 44 the the DT 37231 489 45 most most JJS 37231 489 46 part part NN 37231 489 47 , , , 37231 489 48 alphabetically alphabetically RB 37231 489 49 , , , 37231 489 50 which which WDT 37231 489 51 have have VBP 37231 489 52 in in IN 37231 489 53 very very RB 37231 489 54 many many JJ 37231 489 55 cases case NNS 37231 489 56 no no DT 37231 489 57 value value NN 37231 489 58 whatever whatever WDT 37231 489 59 for for IN 37231 489 60 a a DT 37231 489 61 scholar scholar NN 37231 489 62 , , , 37231 489 63 while while IN 37231 489 64 they -PRON- PRP 37231 489 65 can can MD 37231 489 66 only only RB 37231 489 67 oppress oppress VB 37231 489 68 the the DT 37231 489 69 general general JJ 37231 489 70 reader reader NN 37231 489 71 with with IN 37231 489 72 a a DT 37231 489 73 vague vague JJ 37231 489 74 feeling feeling NN 37231 489 75 that that IN 37231 489 76 all all DT 37231 489 77 ' ' `` 37231 489 78 profound profound JJ 37231 489 79 ' ' '' 37231 489 80 critics critic NNS 37231 489 81 are be VBP 37231 489 82 on on IN 37231 489 83 one one CD 37231 489 84 side side NN 37231 489 85 . . . 37231 490 1 The the DT 37231 490 2 questions question NNS 37231 490 3 to to TO 37231 490 4 be be VB 37231 490 5 discussed discuss VBN 37231 490 6 must must MD 37231 490 7 be be VB 37231 490 8 decided decide VBN 37231 490 9 by by IN 37231 490 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 490 11 and and CC 37231 490 12 by by IN 37231 490 13 argument argument NN 37231 490 14 and and CC 37231 490 15 not not RB 37231 490 16 by by IN 37231 490 17 authority authority NN 37231 490 18 . . . 37231 491 1 " " `` 37231 491 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 491 3 1 1 LS 37231 491 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 491 5 Now now RB 37231 491 6 the the DT 37231 491 7 fact fact NN 37231 491 8 is be VBZ 37231 491 9 that that DT 37231 491 10 hitherto hitherto NNP 37231 491 11 , , , 37231 491 12 in in IN 37231 491 13 England England NNP 37231 491 14 , , , 37231 491 15 argument argument NN 37231 491 16 and and CC 37231 491 17 evidence evidence NN 37231 491 18 have have VBP 37231 491 19 almost almost RB 37231 491 20 been be VBN 37231 491 21 ignored ignore VBN 37231 491 22 in in IN 37231 491 23 connection connection NN 37231 491 24 with with IN 37231 491 25 the the DT 37231 491 26 great great JJ 37231 491 27 question question NN 37231 491 28 discussed discuss VBN 37231 491 29 in in IN 37231 491 30 this this DT 37231 491 31 work work NN 37231 491 32 , , , 37231 491 33 and and CC 37231 491 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 491 35 has have VBZ 37231 491 36 practically practically RB 37231 491 37 been be VBN 37231 491 38 decided decide VBN 37231 491 39 by by IN 37231 491 40 the the DT 37231 491 41 authority authority NN 37231 491 42 of of IN 37231 491 43 the the DT 37231 491 44 Church Church NNP 37231 491 45 , , , 37231 491 46 rendered render VBN 37231 491 47 doubly doubly RB 37231 491 48 potent potent JJ 37231 491 49 by by IN 37231 491 50 force force NN 37231 491 51 of of IN 37231 491 52 habit habit NN 37231 491 53 and and CC 37231 491 54 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 491 55 reverence reverence NN 37231 491 56 . . . 37231 492 1 The the DT 37231 492 2 orthodox orthodox JJ 37231 492 3 works work VBZ 37231 492 4 usually usually RB 37231 492 5 written write VBN 37231 492 6 on on IN 37231 492 7 the the DT 37231 492 8 subject subject NN 37231 492 9 have have VBP 37231 492 10 , , , 37231 492 11 to to IN 37231 492 12 a a DT 37231 492 13 very very RB 37231 492 14 great great JJ 37231 492 15 extent extent NN 37231 492 16 , , , 37231 492 17 suppressed suppress VBD 37231 492 18 the the DT 37231 492 19 objections objection NNS 37231 492 20 raised raise VBN 37231 492 21 by by IN 37231 492 22 a a DT 37231 492 23 mass mass NN 37231 492 24 of of IN 37231 492 25 learned learned JJ 37231 492 26 and and CC 37231 492 27 independent independent JJ 37231 492 28 critics critic NNS 37231 492 29 , , , 37231 492 30 or or CC 37231 492 31 treated treat VBD 37231 492 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 492 33 as as IN 37231 492 34 insignificant insignificant JJ 37231 492 35 , , , 37231 492 36 and and CC 37231 492 37 worthy worthy JJ 37231 492 38 of of IN 37231 492 39 little little JJ 37231 492 40 more more JJR 37231 492 41 than than IN 37231 492 42 a a DT 37231 492 43 passing pass VBG 37231 492 44 word word NN 37231 492 45 of of IN 37231 492 46 pious pious JJ 37231 492 47 indignation indignation NN 37231 492 48 . . . 37231 493 1 At at IN 37231 493 2 the the DT 37231 493 3 same same JJ 37231 493 4 time time NN 37231 493 5 , , , 37231 493 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 493 7 , , , 37231 493 8 that that IN 37231 493 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 493 10 endeavour endeavour VBP 37231 493 11 , , , 37231 493 12 to to IN 37231 493 13 { { -LRB- 37231 493 14 liii liii NN 37231 493 15 } } -RRB- 37231 493 16 the the DT 37231 493 17 best good JJS 37231 493 18 of of IN 37231 493 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 493 20 ability ability NN 37231 493 21 , , , 37231 493 22 to to TO 37231 493 23 decide decide VB 37231 493 24 these these DT 37231 493 25 questions question NNS 37231 493 26 by by IN 37231 493 27 evidence evidence NN 37231 493 28 and and CC 37231 493 29 argument argument NN 37231 493 30 , , , 37231 493 31 in in IN 37231 493 32 opposition opposition NN 37231 493 33 to to IN 37231 493 34 mere mere JJ 37231 493 35 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 493 36 authority authority NN 37231 493 37 , , , 37231 493 38 I -PRON- PRP 37231 493 39 refer refer VBP 37231 493 40 readers reader NNS 37231 493 41 desirous desirous JJ 37231 493 42 of of IN 37231 493 43 further further RB 37231 493 44 pursuing pursue VBG 37231 493 45 the the DT 37231 493 46 subject subject NN 37231 493 47 to to IN 37231 493 48 works work NNS 37231 493 49 where where WRB 37231 493 50 they -PRON- PRP 37231 493 51 may may MD 37231 493 52 find find VB 37231 493 53 them -PRON- PRP 37231 493 54 dis- dis- RB 37231 493 55 . . . 37231 494 1 cussed cuss VBD 37231 494 2 . . . 37231 495 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 495 2 must must MD 37231 495 3 be be VB 37231 495 4 permitted permit VBN 37231 495 5 to to TO 37231 495 6 add add VB 37231 495 7 , , , 37231 495 8 that that IN 37231 495 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 495 10 do do VBP 37231 495 11 not not RB 37231 495 12 consider consider VB 37231 495 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 495 14 uselessly uselessly RB 37231 495 15 burden burden VBP 37231 495 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 495 17 pages page NNS 37231 495 18 by by IN 37231 495 19 references reference NNS 37231 495 20 to to IN 37231 495 21 critics critic NNS 37231 495 22 who who WP 37231 495 23 confirm confirm VBP 37231 495 24 the the DT 37231 495 25 views view NNS 37231 495 26 in in IN 37231 495 27 the the DT 37231 495 28 text text NN 37231 495 29 or or CC 37231 495 30 discuss discuss VB 37231 495 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 495 32 , , , 37231 495 33 for for IN 37231 495 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 495 35 is be VBZ 37231 495 36 right right JJ 37231 495 37 that that IN 37231 495 38 earnest earnest JJ 37231 495 39 thinkers thinker NNS 37231 495 40 should should MD 37231 495 41 be be VB 37231 495 42 told tell VBN 37231 495 43 the the DT 37231 495 44 state state NN 37231 495 45 of of IN 37231 495 46 opinion opinion NN 37231 495 47 , , , 37231 495 48 and and CC 37231 495 49 recognize recognize VB 37231 495 50 that that DT 37231 495 51 belief belief NN 37231 495 52 is be VBZ 37231 495 53 not not RB 37231 495 54 so so RB 37231 495 55 easy easy JJ 37231 495 56 and and CC 37231 495 57 matter matter RB 37231 495 58 of of RB 37231 495 59 course course NN 37231 495 60 a a DT 37231 495 61 thing thing NN 37231 495 62 as as IN 37231 495 63 they -PRON- PRP 37231 495 64 have have VBP 37231 495 65 been be VBN 37231 495 66 led lead VBN 37231 495 67 to to TO 37231 495 68 suppose suppose VB 37231 495 69 , , , 37231 495 70 or or CC 37231 495 71 the the DT 37231 495 72 unanimity unanimity NN 37231 495 73 quite quite RB 37231 495 74 so so RB 37231 495 75 complete complete JJ 37231 495 76 as as IN 37231 495 77 English english JJ 37231 495 78 divines divine NNS 37231 495 79 have have VBP 37231 495 80 often often RB 37231 495 81 seemed seem VBN 37231 495 82 to to TO 37231 495 83 represent represent VB 37231 495 84 it -PRON- PRP 37231 495 85 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 495 86 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 495 87 , , , 37231 495 88 however however RB 37231 495 89 , , , 37231 495 90 omits omit VBZ 37231 495 91 to to IN 37231 495 92 state state NN 37231 495 93 that that IN 37231 495 94 I -PRON- PRP 37231 495 95 as as IN 37231 495 96 persistently persistently RB 37231 495 97 refer refer VBP 37231 495 98 to to IN 37231 495 99 writers writer NNS 37231 495 100 who who WP 37231 495 101 oppose oppose VBP 37231 495 102 , , , 37231 495 103 as as IN 37231 495 104 to to IN 37231 495 105 those those DT 37231 495 106 who who WP 37231 495 107 favour favour VBP 37231 495 108 , , , 37231 495 109 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 495 110 own own JJ 37231 495 111 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 495 112 . . . 37231 496 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 496 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 496 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 496 4 to to TO 37231 496 5 make make VB 37231 496 6 the the DT 37231 496 7 accusation accusation NN 37231 496 8 which which WDT 37231 496 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 496 10 now now RB 37231 496 11 desire desire VBP 37231 496 12 to to TO 37231 496 13 investigate investigate VB 37231 496 14 . . . 37231 497 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 497 2 says say VBZ 37231 497 3 : : : 37231 497 4 " " `` 37231 497 5 Writers writer NNS 37231 497 6 are be VBP 37231 497 7 quoted quote VBN 37231 497 8 as as IN 37231 497 9 holding hold VBG 37231 497 10 on on IN 37231 497 11 independent independent JJ 37231 497 12 grounds ground NNS 37231 497 13 an an DT 37231 497 14 opinion opinion NN 37231 497 15 which which WDT 37231 497 16 is be VBZ 37231 497 17 involved involve VBN 37231 497 18 in in IN 37231 497 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 497 20 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 497 21 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 497 22 . . . 37231 498 1 And and CC 37231 498 2 more more JJR 37231 498 3 than than IN 37231 498 4 this this DT 37231 498 5 , , , 37231 498 6 the the DT 37231 498 7 references reference NNS 37231 498 8 are be VBP 37231 498 9 not not RB 37231 498 10 unfrequently unfrequently RB 37231 498 11 actually actually RB 37231 498 12 misleading misleading JJ 37231 498 13 . . . 37231 499 1 One one CD 37231 499 2 example example NN 37231 499 3 will will MD 37231 499 4 show show VB 37231 499 5 that that IN 37231 499 6 I -PRON- PRP 37231 499 7 do do VBP 37231 499 8 not not RB 37231 499 9 speak speak VB 37231 499 10 too too RB 37231 499 11 strongly strongly RB 37231 499 12 . . . 37231 500 1 " " `` 37231 500 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 500 3 l l NN 37231 500 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 500 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 500 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 500 7 has have VBZ 37231 500 8 scrutinized scrutinize VBN 37231 500 9 this this DT 37231 500 10 work work NN 37231 500 11 with with IN 37231 500 12 great great JJ 37231 500 13 minuteness minuteness NN 37231 500 14 , , , 37231 500 15 and and CC 37231 500 16 , , , 37231 500 17 as as IN 37231 500 18 I -PRON- PRP 37231 500 19 shall shall MD 37231 500 20 presently presently RB 37231 500 21 explain explain VB 37231 500 22 , , , 37231 500 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 500 24 has have VBZ 37231 500 25 selected select VBN 37231 500 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 500 27 example example NN 37231 500 28 with with IN 37231 500 29 evident evident JJ 37231 500 30 care care NN 37231 500 31 . . . 37231 501 1 The the DT 37231 501 2 idea idea NN 37231 501 3 of of IN 37231 501 4 illustrating illustrate VBG 37231 501 5 the the DT 37231 501 6 vast vast JJ 37231 501 7 mass mass NN 37231 501 8 of of IN 37231 501 9 references reference NNS 37231 501 10 in in IN 37231 501 11 these these DT 37231 501 12 volumes volume NNS 37231 501 13 by by IN 37231 501 14 a a DT 37231 501 15 single single JJ 37231 501 16 instance instance NN 37231 501 17 is be VBZ 37231 501 18 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 501 19 startling startling JJ 37231 501 20 , , , 37231 501 21 but but CC 37231 501 22 to to TO 37231 501 23 insinuate insinuate VB 37231 501 24 that that IN 37231 501 25 a a DT 37231 501 26 supposed suppose VBN 37231 501 27 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 501 28 pointed point VBD 37231 501 29 out out RP 37231 501 30 in in IN 37231 501 31 one one CD 37231 501 32 note note NN 37231 501 33 runs run VBZ 37231 501 34 through through IN 37231 501 35 the the DT 37231 501 36 whole whole JJ 37231 501 37 work work NN 37231 501 38 , , , 37231 501 39 as as IN 37231 501 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 501 41 does do VBZ 37231 501 42 , , , 37231 501 43 if if IN 37231 501 44 I -PRON- PRP 37231 501 45 rightly rightly RB 37231 501 46 understand understand VBP 37231 501 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 501 48 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 501 49 expressions expression NNS 37231 501 50 , , , 37231 501 51 is be VBZ 37231 501 52 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 501 53 worthy worthy JJ 37231 501 54 of of IN 37231 501 55 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 501 56 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 501 57 , , , 37231 501 58 although although IN 37231 501 59 I -PRON- PRP 37231 501 60 am be VBP 37231 501 61 sure sure JJ 37231 501 62 he -PRON- PRP 37231 501 63 does do VBZ 37231 501 64 not not RB 37231 501 65 mean mean VB 37231 501 66 to to TO 37231 501 67 be be VB 37231 501 68 unfair unfair JJ 37231 501 69 . . . 37231 502 1 The the DT 37231 502 2 example example NN 37231 502 3 selected select VBN 37231 502 4 is be VBZ 37231 502 5 as as IN 37231 502 6 follows follow VBZ 37231 502 7 : : : 37231 502 8 " " `` 37231 502 9 It -PRON- PRP 37231 502 10 has have VBZ 37231 502 11 been be VBN 37231 502 12 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 502 13 that that IN 37231 502 14 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 502 15 was be VBD 37231 502 16 not not RB 37231 502 17 sent send VBN 37231 502 18 to to IN 37231 502 19 Rome Rome NNP 37231 502 20 at at RB 37231 502 21 all all RB 37231 502 22 , , , 37231 502 23 but but CC 37231 502 24 suffered suffer VBN 37231 502 25 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 502 26 in in IN 37231 502 27 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 502 28 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 502 29 on on IN 37231 502 30 the the DT 37231 502 31 2()th 2()th CD 37231 502 32 December December NNP 37231 502 33 , , , 37231 502 34 a.d a.d NNP 37231 502 35 . . NNP 37231 502 36 115 115 CD 37231 502 37 { { -LRB- 37231 502 38 liv liv NN 37231 502 39 } } -RRB- 37231 502 40 when when WRB 37231 502 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 502 42 was be VBD 37231 502 43 condemned condemn VBN 37231 502 44 to to TO 37231 502 45 be be VB 37231 502 46 cast cast VBN 37231 502 47 to to IN 37231 502 48 wild wild JJ 37231 502 49 beasts beast NNS 37231 502 50 in in IN 37231 502 51 the the DT 37231 502 52 amphitheatre amphitheatre NNP 37231 502 53 , , , 37231 502 54 in in IN 37231 502 55 consequence consequence NN 37231 502 56 of of IN 37231 502 57 the the DT 37231 502 58 fanatical fanatical JJ 37231 502 59 excitement excitement NN 37231 502 60 produced produce VBN 37231 502 61 by by IN 37231 502 62 the the DT 37231 502 63 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 502 64 which which WDT 37231 502 65 took take VBD 37231 502 66 place place NN 37231 502 67 on on IN 37231 502 68 the the DT 37231 502 69 13th 13th NN 37231 502 70 of of IN 37231 502 71 that that DT 37231 502 72 month.4 month.4 NN 37231 502 73 " " '' 37231 502 74 ' ' `` 37231 502 75 The the DT 37231 502 76 references reference NNS 37231 502 77 in in IN 37231 502 78 support support NN 37231 502 79 of of IN 37231 502 80 these these DT 37231 502 81 statements statement NNS 37231 502 82 are be VBP 37231 502 83 the the DT 37231 502 84 following follow VBG 37231 502 85 : : : 37231 502 86 8 8 CD 37231 502 87 Baur Baur NNP 37231 502 88 , , , 37231 502 89 Urspr Urspr NNP 37231 502 90 . . . 37231 503 1 d. d. NNP 37231 503 2 Epiec Epiec NNP 37231 503 3 . . . 37231 503 4 Tub Tub NNP 37231 503 5 . . . 37231 504 1 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 37231 504 2 . . . 37231 505 1 f f LS 37231 505 2 . . . 37231 505 3 Theol Theol NNP 37231 505 4 . . . 37231 506 1 1838 1838 CD 37231 506 2 , , , 37231 506 3 H. H. NNP 37231 506 4 3 3 CD 37231 506 5 , , , 37231 506 6 p. p. NN 37231 506 7 155 155 CD 37231 506 8 anm anm NN 37231 506 9 . . . 37231 507 1 ; ; : 37231 507 2 Bretschneider Bretschneider NNP 37231 507 3 , , , 37231 507 4 Probabilia Probabilia NNP 37231 507 5 , , , 37231 507 6 & & CC 37231 507 7 c c NNP 37231 507 8 , , , 37231 507 9 p. p. NN 37231 507 10 185 185 CD 37231 507 11 ; ; : 37231 507 12 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 507 13 , , , 37231 507 14 Einl Einl NNP 37231 507 15 . . . 37231 507 16 N. N. NNP 37231 508 1 T. T. NNP 37231 508 2 , , , 37231 508 3 p. p. NN 37231 508 4 144 144 CD 37231 508 5 ; ; : 37231 508 6 Guericke Guericke NNP 37231 508 7 , , , 37231 508 8 H*bucht H*bucht NNP 37231 508 9 Kt Kt NNP 37231 508 10 # # NNP 37231 508 11 . . . 37231 508 12 , , , 37231 508 13 i i PRP 37231 508 14 p. p. NN 37231 508 15 148 148 CD 37231 508 16 ; ; : 37231 508 17 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 37231 508 18 , , , 37231 508 19 K. K. NNP 37231 508 20 G. G. NNP 37231 508 21 , , , 37231 508 22 i. i. NNP 37231 508 23 p. p. NN 37231 508 24 113 113 CD 37231 508 25 f. f. NNP 37231 508 26 ; ; : 37231 508 27 Davidson Davidson NNP 37231 508 28 , , , 37231 508 29 Introd Introd NNP 37231 508 30 . . . 37231 509 1 N. N. NNP 37231 509 2 T.,i T.,i NNP 37231 509 3 . . . 37231 510 1 p. p. NN 37231 510 2 19 19 CD 37231 510 3 ; ; : 37231 510 4 Mayerhoff Mayerhoff NNP 37231 510 5 , , , 37231 510 6 Eitll Eitll NNP 37231 510 7 . . . 37231 511 1 petr petr NN 37231 511 2 . . . 37231 512 1 Schr Schr NNP 37231 512 2 . . NNP 37231 512 3 , , , 37231 512 4 p. p. NN 37231 512 5 79 79 CD 37231 512 6 ; ; : 37231 512 7 Scholten Scholten NNP 37231 512 8 , , , 37231 512 9 Die Die NNP 37231 512 10 Sit Sit NNP 37231 512 11 . . . 37231 513 1 Zeugnisse zeugnisse NN 37231 513 2 , , , 37231 513 3 p. p. NN 37231 513 4 40 40 CD 37231 513 5 , , , 37231 513 6 p. p. NN 37231 513 7 50 50 CD 37231 513 8 f. f. NNS 37231 513 9 ; ; : 37231 513 10 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 513 11 , , , 37231 513 12 Der Der NNP 37231 513 13 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 37231 513 14 , , , 37231 513 15 p. p. NN 37231 513 16 52 52 CD 37231 513 17 ; ; : 37231 513 18 R'buch R'buch NNP 37231 513 19 Einl Einl NNP 37231 513 20 . . . 37231 514 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 37231 514 2 . . . 37231 514 3 , , , 37231 514 4 i. i. NNP 37231 514 5 p. p. NNP 37231 514 6 121 121 CD 37231 514 7 f. f. NNS 37231 514 8 , , , 37231 514 9 p. p. NN 37231 514 10 136 136 CD 37231 514 11 . . . 37231 515 1 4 4 CD 37231 515 2 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 515 3 , , , 37231 515 4 Wuch Wuch NNP 37231 515 5 Einl Einl NNP 37231 515 6 . . . 37231 516 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 37231 516 2 . . . 37231 516 3 , , , 37231 516 4 i. i. NNP 37231 516 5 p. p. NNP 37231 516 6 121 121 CD 37231 516 7 ff ff NNP 37231 516 8 . . NNP 37231 516 9 , , , 37231 516 10 136 136 CD 37231 516 11 f. f. NNS 37231 516 12 ; ; : 37231 516 13 Der Der NNP 37231 516 14 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 37231 516 15 , , , 37231 516 16 p. p. NN 37231 516 17 52 52 CD 37231 516 18 ff ff NN 37231 516 19 . . . 37231 517 1 ; ; : 37231 517 2 Baur Baur NNP 37231 517 3 , , , 37231 517 4 Ursp Ursp NNP 37231 517 5 . . . 37231 518 1 d. d. NNP 37231 518 2 Episc Episc NNP 37231 518 3 . . . 37231 519 1 Tub Tub NNP 37231 519 2 . . . 37231 520 1 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 37231 520 2 . . . 37231 521 1 f. f. NNP 37231 521 2 Th Th NNP 37231 521 3 . . . 37231 522 1 1838 1838 CD 37231 522 2 , , , 37231 522 3 H. H. NNP 37231 522 4 3 3 CD 37231 522 5 , , , 37231 522 6 p. p. NN 37231 522 7 149 149 CD 37231 522 8 f. f. NNS 37231 522 9 ; ; : 37231 522 10 Gesch Gesch NNP 37231 522 11 . . . 37231 523 1 chr chr NNP 37231 523 2 . . . 37231 524 1 Kirehe Kirehe NNP 37231 524 2 , , , 37231 524 3 1863 1863 CD 37231 524 4 , , , 37231 524 5 i. i. NNP 37231 524 6 p. p. NN 37231 524 7 440 440 CD 37231 524 8 , , , 37231 524 9 anm anm NN 37231 524 10 . . . 37231 525 1 1 1 CD 37231 525 2 . . . 37231 525 3 ; ; : 37231 525 4 Davidson Davidson NNP 37231 525 5 , , , 37231 525 6 Introd Introd NNP 37231 525 7 . . . 37231 526 1 N. N. NNP 37231 526 2 T. T. NNP 37231 526 3 , , , 37231 526 4 Lp Lp NNP 37231 526 5 . . . 37231 527 1 19 19 CD 37231 527 2 ; ; : 37231 527 3 Scholten scholten VB 37231 527 4 , , , 37231 527 5 Die die VB 37231 527 6 Hit hit VB 37231 527 7 . . . 37231 528 1 Zeugnisse zeugnisse NN 37231 528 2 , , , 37231 528 3 p. p. NN 37231 528 4 51 51 CD 37231 528 5 f. f. NNS 37231 528 6 ; ; : 37231 528 7 cf cf NNP 37231 528 8 . . . 37231 529 1 Francke Francke NNP 37231 529 2 , , , 37231 529 3 Zur Zur NNP 37231 529 4 Gesch Gesch NNP 37231 529 5 . . . 37231 530 1 Trojans trojan NNS 37231 530 2 , , , 37231 530 3 u. u. NNP 37231 530 4 s. s. NNP 37231 530 5 w. w. NNP 37231 530 6 1840 1840 CD 37231 530 7 , , , 37231 530 8 p. p. NN 37231 530 9 253 253 CD 37231 530 10 f. f. NNS 37231 530 11 ; ; : 37231 530 12 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 530 13 , , , 37231 530 14 Die Die NNP 37231 530 15 ap ap NNP 37231 530 16 . . . 37231 531 1 Vster Vster NNP 37231 531 2 , , , 37231 531 3 p. p. NN 37231 531 4 214 214 CD 37231 531 5 . . . 37231 532 1 Upon upon IN 37231 532 2 this this DT 37231 532 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 532 4 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 532 5 remarks remark VBZ 37231 532 6 : : : 37231 532 7 " " `` 37231 532 8 Such such PDT 37231 532 9 an an DT 37231 532 10 array array NN 37231 532 11 of of IN 37231 532 12 authorities authority NNS 37231 532 13 , , , 37231 532 14 drawn draw VBN 37231 532 15 from from IN 37231 532 16 different different JJ 37231 532 17 schools school NNS 37231 532 18 , , , 37231 532 19 can can MD 37231 532 20 not not RB 37231 532 21 but but CC 37231 532 22 appear appear VB 37231 532 23 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 37231 532 24 ; ; : 37231 532 25 and and CC 37231 532 26 the the DT 37231 532 27 fact fact NN 37231 532 28 that that IN 37231 532 29 about about IN 37231 532 30 half half NN 37231 532 31 of of IN 37231 532 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 532 33 are be VBP 37231 532 34 quoted quote VBN 37231 532 35 twice twice RB 37231 532 36 over over RB 37231 532 37 emphasizes emphasize VBZ 37231 532 38 the the DT 37231 532 39 implied implied JJ 37231 532 40 precision precision NN 37231 532 41 of of IN 37231 532 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 532 43 testimony testimony NN 37231 532 44 as as IN 37231 532 45 to to IN 37231 532 46 the the DT 37231 532 47 two two CD 37231 532 48 points point NNS 37231 532 49 affirmed affirm VBD 37231 532 50 . . . 37231 532 51 " " '' 37231 533 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 533 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 533 3 , , , 37231 533 4 however however RB 37231 533 5 , , , 37231 533 6 has have VBZ 37231 533 7 either either CC 37231 533 8 overlooked overlook VBN 37231 533 9 or or CC 37231 533 10 omitted omit VBN 37231 533 11 to to TO 37231 533 12 state state VB 37231 533 13 the the DT 37231 533 14 fact fact NN 37231 533 15 that that IN 37231 533 16 , , , 37231 533 17 although although IN 37231 533 18 some some DT 37231 533 19 of of IN 37231 533 20 the the DT 37231 533 21 writers writer NNS 37231 533 22 are be VBP 37231 533 23 quoted quote VBN 37231 533 24 twice twice RB 37231 533 25 , , , 37231 533 26 the the DT 37231 533 27 two two CD 37231 533 28 notes note NNS 37231 533 29 differ differ VBP 37231 533 30 in in IN 37231 533 31 almost almost RB 37231 533 32 every every DT 37231 533 33 particular particular JJ 37231 533 34 , , , 37231 533 35 many many JJ 37231 533 36 of of IN 37231 533 37 the the DT 37231 533 38 names name NNS 37231 533 39 in in IN 37231 533 40 note note NN 37231 533 41 3 3 CD 37231 533 42 being be VBG 37231 533 43 absent absent JJ 37231 533 44 from from IN 37231 533 45 note note NN 37231 533 46 4 4 CD 37231 533 47 , , , 37231 533 48 other other JJ 37231 533 49 names name NNS 37231 533 50 being be VBG 37231 533 51 inserted insert VBN 37231 533 52 in in IN 37231 533 53 the the DT 37231 533 54 latter latter JJ 37231 533 55 which which WDT 37231 533 56 do do VBP 37231 533 57 not not RB 37231 533 58 appear appear VB 37231 533 59 in in IN 37231 533 60 the the DT 37231 533 61 former former JJ 37231 533 62 , , , 37231 533 63 an an DT 37231 533 64 alteration alteration NN 37231 533 65 being be VBG 37231 533 66 in in IN 37231 533 67 most most JJS 37231 533 68 cases case NNS 37231 533 69 made make VBN 37231 533 70 in in IN 37231 533 71 the the DT 37231 533 72 place place NN 37231 533 73 referred refer VBN 37231 533 74 to to IN 37231 533 75 , , , 37231 533 76 and and CC 37231 533 77 the the DT 37231 533 78 order order NN 37231 533 79 in in IN 37231 533 80 which which WDT 37231 533 81 the the DT 37231 533 82 authorities authority NNS 37231 533 83 are be VBP 37231 533 84 placed place VBN 37231 533 85 being be VBG 37231 533 86 significantly significantly RB 37231 533 87 varied varied JJ 37231 533 88 . . . 37231 534 1 For for IN 37231 534 2 instance instance NN 37231 534 3 , , , 37231 534 4 in in IN 37231 534 5 note note NN 37231 534 6 3 3 CD 37231 534 7 the the DT 37231 534 8 reference reference NN 37231 534 9 to to IN 37231 534 10 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 534 11 is be VBZ 37231 534 12 the the DT 37231 534 13 last last JJ 37231 534 14 , , , 37231 534 15 but but CC 37231 534 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 534 17 is be VBZ 37231 534 18 the the DT 37231 534 19 first first JJ 37231 534 20 in in IN 37231 534 21 note note NN 37231 534 22 4 4 CD 37231 534 23 ; ; : 37231 534 24 whilst whilst IN 37231 534 25 a a DT 37231 534 26 similar similar JJ 37231 534 27 transposition transposition NN 37231 534 28 of of IN 37231 534 29 order order NN 37231 534 30 takes take VBZ 37231 534 31 place place NN 37231 534 32 in in IN 37231 534 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 534 34 works work NNS 37231 534 35 , , , 37231 534 36 and and CC 37231 534 37 alterations alteration NNS 37231 534 38 in in IN 37231 534 39 the the DT 37231 534 40 pages page NNS 37231 534 41 . . . 37231 535 1 The the DT 37231 535 2 references reference NNS 37231 535 3 in in IN 37231 535 4 note note NN 37231 535 5 3 3 CD 37231 535 6 , , , 37231 535 7 in in IN 37231 535 8 fact fact NN 37231 535 9 , , , 37231 535 10 are be VBP 37231 535 11 given give VBN 37231 535 12 for for IN 37231 535 13 the the DT 37231 535 14 date date NN 37231 535 15 occurring occur VBG 37231 535 16 in in IN 37231 535 17 the the DT 37231 535 18 course course NN 37231 535 19 of of IN 37231 535 20 the the DT 37231 535 21 sentence sentence NN 37231 535 22 , , , 37231 535 23 whilst whilst IN 37231 535 24 those those DT 37231 535 25 in in IN 37231 535 26 note note NN 37231 535 27 4 4 CD 37231 535 28 , , , 37231 535 29 placed place VBN 37231 535 30 at at IN 37231 535 31 the the DT 37231 535 32 end end NN 37231 535 33 , , , 37231 535 34 are be VBP 37231 535 35 intended intend VBN 37231 535 36 to to TO 37231 535 37 support support VB 37231 535 38 the the DT 37231 535 39 whole whole JJ 37231 535 40 statement statement NN 37231 535 41 which which WDT 37231 535 42 is be VBZ 37231 535 43 { { -LRB- 37231 535 44 lv lv NNP 37231 535 45 } } -RRB- 37231 535 46 made make VBN 37231 535 47 . . . 37231 536 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 536 2 must must MD 37231 536 3 , , , 37231 536 4 however however RB 37231 536 5 , , , 37231 536 6 explain explain VB 37231 536 7 an an DT 37231 536 8 omission omission NN 37231 536 9 , , , 37231 536 10 which which WDT 37231 536 11 is be VBZ 37231 536 12 pretty pretty RB 37231 536 13 obvious obvious JJ 37231 536 14 , , , 37231 536 15 but but CC 37231 536 16 which which WDT 37231 536 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 536 18 regret regret VBP 37231 536 19 may may MD 37231 536 20 have have VB 37231 536 21 misled mislead VBN 37231 536 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 536 23 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 536 24 in in IN 37231 536 25 regard regard NN 37231 536 26 to to TO 37231 536 27 note note VB 37231 536 28 3 3 CD 37231 536 29 , , , 37231 536 30 although although IN 37231 536 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 536 32 does do VBZ 37231 536 33 not not RB 37231 536 34 affect affect VB 37231 536 35 note note NN 37231 536 36 4 4 CD 37231 536 37 . . . 37231 537 1 Headers header NNS 37231 537 2 are be VBP 37231 537 3 probably probably RB 37231 537 4 aware aware JJ 37231 537 5 that that IN 37231 537 6 there there EX 37231 537 7 has have VBZ 37231 537 8 been be VBN 37231 537 9 , , , 37231 537 10 amongst amongst IN 37231 537 11 other other JJ 37231 537 12 points point NNS 37231 537 13 , , , 37231 537 14 a a DT 37231 537 15 difference difference NN 37231 537 16 of of IN 37231 537 17 opinion opinion NN 37231 537 18 not not RB 37231 537 19 only only RB 37231 537 20 as as IN 37231 537 21 to to IN 37231 537 22 the the DT 37231 537 23 place place NN 37231 537 24 , , , 37231 537 25 but but CC 37231 537 26 also also RB 37231 537 27 the the DT 37231 537 28 date date NN 37231 537 29 of of IN 37231 537 30 the the DT 37231 537 31 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 537 32 of of IN 37231 537 33 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 537 34 . . . 37231 538 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 538 2 have have VBP 37231 538 3 in in IN 37231 538 4 every every DT 37231 538 5 other other JJ 37231 538 6 case case NN 37231 538 7 carefully carefully RB 37231 538 8 stated state VBD 37231 538 9 the the DT 37231 538 10 question question NN 37231 538 11 of of IN 37231 538 12 date date NN 37231 538 13 , , , 37231 538 14 and and CC 37231 538 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 538 16 omission omission NN 37231 538 17 in in IN 37231 538 18 this this DT 37231 538 19 instance instance NN 37231 538 20 is be VBZ 37231 538 21 , , , 37231 538 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 538 23 think think VBP 37231 538 24 , , , 37231 538 25 the the DT 37231 538 26 only only JJ 37231 538 27 exception exception NN 37231 538 28 in in IN 37231 538 29 the the DT 37231 538 30 book book NN 37231 538 31 . . . 37231 539 1 The the DT 37231 539 2 fact fact NN 37231 539 3 is be VBZ 37231 539 4 , , , 37231 539 5 that that IN 37231 539 6 I -PRON- PRP 37231 539 7 had have VBD 37231 539 8 originally originally RB 37231 539 9 in in IN 37231 539 10 the the DT 37231 539 11 text text NN 37231 539 12 the the DT 37231 539 13 words word NNS 37231 539 14 which which WDT 37231 539 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 539 16 now now RB 37231 539 17 add add VBP 37231 539 18 to to IN 37231 539 19 the the DT 37231 539 20 note note NN 37231 539 21 : : : 37231 539 22 " " `` 37231 539 23 The the DT 37231 539 24 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 539 25 has have VBZ 37231 539 26 been be VBN 37231 539 27 variously variously RB 37231 539 28 dated date VBN 37231 539 29 about about IN 37231 539 30 a.d a.d NNP 37231 539 31 . . NNP 37231 539 32 107 107 CD 37231 539 33 , , , 37231 539 34 or or CC 37231 539 35 a.d a.d NNP 37231 539 36 . . NNP 37231 539 37 115 115 CD 37231 539 38 - - SYM 37231 539 39 116 116 CD 37231 539 40 , , , 37231 539 41 but but CC 37231 539 42 whether whether IN 37231 539 43 assigning assign VBG 37231 539 44 the the DT 37231 539 45 event event NN 37231 539 46 to to IN 37231 539 47 Home home NN 37231 539 48 or or CC 37231 539 49 to to IN 37231 539 50 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 539 51 a a DT 37231 539 52 majority majority NN 37231 539 53 of of IN 37231 539 54 critics critic NNS 37231 539 55 of of IN 37231 539 56 all all DT 37231 539 57 shades shade NNS 37231 539 58 of of IN 37231 539 59 opinion opinion NN 37231 539 60 have have VBP 37231 539 61 adopted adopt VBN 37231 539 62 the the DT 37231 539 63 later later JJ 37231 539 64 date date NN 37231 539 65 . . . 37231 539 66 " " '' 37231 540 1 Thinking think VBG 37231 540 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 540 3 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 540 4 , , , 37231 540 5 under under IN 37231 540 6 the the DT 37231 540 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 540 8 , , , 37231 540 9 to to TO 37231 540 10 burden burden VB 37231 540 11 the the DT 37231 540 12 text text NN 37231 540 13 with with IN 37231 540 14 this this DT 37231 540 15 , , , 37231 540 16 I -PRON- PRP 37231 540 17 removed remove VBD 37231 540 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 540 19 with with IN 37231 540 20 the the DT 37231 540 21 design design NN 37231 540 22 of of IN 37231 540 23 putting put VBG 37231 540 24 the the DT 37231 540 25 statement statement NN 37231 540 26 at at IN 37231 540 27 the the DT 37231 540 28 head head NN 37231 540 29 of of IN 37231 540 30 note note NN 37231 540 31 3 3 CD 37231 540 32 , , , 37231 540 33 with with IN 37231 540 34 reference reference NN 37231 540 35 to to IN 37231 540 36 " " `` 37231 540 37 a.d a.d NNP 37231 540 38 . . NNP 37231 540 39 115 115 CD 37231 540 40 " " `` 37231 540 41 in in IN 37231 540 42 the the DT 37231 540 43 text text NN 37231 540 44 , , , 37231 540 45 but but CC 37231 540 46 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37231 540 47 an an DT 37231 540 48 interruption interruption NN 37231 540 49 at at IN 37231 540 50 the the DT 37231 540 51 time time NN 37231 540 52 prevented prevent VBD 37231 540 53 the the DT 37231 540 54 completion completion NN 37231 540 55 of of IN 37231 540 56 this this DT 37231 540 57 intention intention NN 37231 540 58 , , , 37231 540 59 as as IN 37231 540 60 well.as well.as ADD 37231 540 61 the the DT 37231 540 62 addition addition NN 37231 540 63 of of IN 37231 540 64 some some DT 37231 540 65 fuller full JJR 37231 540 66 references reference NNS 37231 540 67 to to IN 37231 540 68 the the DT 37231 540 69 writers writer NNS 37231 540 70 quoted quote VBN 37231 540 71 , , , 37231 540 72 which which WDT 37231 540 73 had have VBD 37231 540 74 been be VBN 37231 540 75 omitted omit VBN 37231 540 76 , , , 37231 540 77 and and CC 37231 540 78 the the DT 37231 540 79 point point NN 37231 540 80 , , , 37231 540 81 to to IN 37231 540 82 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 540 83 infinite infinite JJ 37231 540 84 regret regret NN 37231 540 85 , , , 37231 540 86 was be VBD 37231 540 87 overlooked overlook VBN 37231 540 88 . . . 37231 541 1 The the DT 37231 541 2 whole whole NN 37231 541 3 of of IN 37231 541 4 the the DT 37231 541 5 authorities authority NNS 37231 541 6 in in IN 37231 541 7 note note NN 37231 541 8 3 3 CD 37231 541 9 , , , 37231 541 10 therefore therefore RB 37231 541 11 , , , 37231 541 12 do do VBP 37231 541 13 not not RB 37231 541 14 support support VB 37231 541 15 the the DT 37231 541 16 apparent apparent JJ 37231 541 17 statement statement NN 37231 541 18 of of IN 37231 541 19 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 541 20 in in IN 37231 541 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 541 22 , , , 37231 541 23 although although IN 37231 541 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 541 25 all all DT 37231 541 26 confirm confirm VBP 37231 541 27 the the DT 37231 541 28 date date NN 37231 541 29 , , , 37231 541 30 for for IN 37231 541 31 which which WDT 37231 541 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 541 33 really really RB 37231 541 34 referred refer VBD 37231 541 35 to to IN 37231 541 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 541 37 . . . 37231 542 1 With with IN 37231 542 2 this this DT 37231 542 3 explanation explanation NN 37231 542 4 , , , 37231 542 5 and and CC 37231 542 6 marking mark VBG 37231 542 7 the the DT 37231 542 8 omitted omit VBN 37231 542 9 references(1 references(1 NN 37231 542 10 ) ) -RRB- 37231 542 11 by by IN 37231 542 12 placing place VBG 37231 542 13 them -PRON- PRP 37231 542 14 within within IN 37231 542 15 brackets bracket NNS 37231 542 16 , , , 37231 542 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 542 18 proceed proceed VBP 37231 542 19 to to TO 37231 542 20 analyze analyze VB 37231 542 21 the the DT 37231 542 22 two two CD 37231 542 23 notes note NNS 37231 542 24 in in IN 37231 542 25 contrast contrast NN 37231 542 26 with with IN 37231 542 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 542 28 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 542 29 's 's POS 37231 542 30 statements statement NNS 37231 542 31 . . . 37231 543 1 1 1 LS 37231 543 2 These these DT 37231 543 3 consist consist VBP 37231 543 4 only only RB 37231 543 5 of of IN 37231 543 6 an an DT 37231 543 7 additional additional JJ 37231 543 8 page page NN 37231 543 9 of of IN 37231 543 10 Baur Baur NNP 37231 543 11 's 's POS 37231 543 12 work work NN 37231 543 13 first first RB 37231 543 14 quoted quote VBD 37231 543 15 , , , 37231 543 16 and and CC 37231 543 17 a a DT 37231 543 18 reference reference NN 37231 543 19 to to IN 37231 543 20 another another DT 37231 543 21 of of IN 37231 543 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 543 23 works work NNS 37231 543 24 quoted quote VBN 37231 543 25 in in IN 37231 543 26 the the DT 37231 543 27 second second JJ 37231 543 28 note note NN 37231 543 29 , , , 37231 543 30 but but CC 37231 543 31 accidentally accidentally RB 37231 543 32 left leave VBD 37231 543 33 out out IN 37231 543 34 of of IN 37231 543 35 the the DT 37231 543 36 note note NN 37231 543 37 3 3 CD 37231 543 38 . . . 37231 544 1 { { -LRB- 37231 544 2 lvi lvi NNP 37231 544 3 } } -RRB- 37231 544 4 See see VB 37231 544 5 page page NN 37231 544 6 scan scan JJ 37231 544 7 , , , 37231 544 8 Ed Ed NNP 37231 544 9 . . . 37231 545 1 { { -LRB- 37231 545 2 lvii lvii NN 37231 545 3 } } -RRB- 37231 545 4 See see VB 37231 545 5 page page NN 37231 545 6 scan scan JJ 37231 545 7 , , , 37231 545 8 Ed Ed NNP 37231 545 9 . . . 37231 546 1 { { -LRB- 37231 546 2 lviii lviii NNP 37231 546 3 } } -RRB- 37231 546 4 See see VB 37231 546 5 page page NN 37231 546 6 scan scan JJ 37231 546 7 , , , 37231 546 8 Ed Ed NNP 37231 546 9 . . . 37231 547 1 { { -LRB- 37231 547 2 lix lix NN 37231 547 3 } } -RRB- 37231 547 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 547 5 will will MD 37231 547 6 thus thus RB 37231 547 7 be be VB 37231 547 8 seen see VBN 37231 547 9 that that IN 37231 547 10 the the DT 37231 547 11 whole whole NN 37231 547 12 of of IN 37231 547 13 these these DT 37231 547 14 authorities authority NNS 37231 547 15 confirm confirm VBP 37231 547 16 the the DT 37231 547 17 later later JJ 37231 547 18 date date NN 37231 547 19 assigned assign VBN 37231 547 20 to to IN 37231 547 21 the the DT 37231 547 22 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 547 23 , , , 37231 547 24 and and CC 37231 547 25 that that IN 37231 547 26 Baur Baur NNP 37231 547 27 , , , 37231 547 28 in in IN 37231 547 29 the the DT 37231 547 30 note note NN 37231 547 31 in in IN 37231 547 32 which which WDT 37231 547 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 547 34 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 547 35 finds find VBZ 37231 547 36 " " `` 37231 547 37 nothing nothing NN 37231 547 38 in in IN 37231 547 39 any any DT 37231 547 40 way way NN 37231 547 41 bearing bear VBG 37231 547 42 upon upon IN 37231 547 43 the the DT 37231 547 44 history history NN 37231 547 45 except except IN 37231 547 46 a a DT 37231 547 47 passing pass VBG 37231 547 48 supposition supposition NN 37231 547 49 , , , 37231 547 50 " " '' 37231 547 51 really really RB 37231 547 52 advances advance VBZ 37231 547 53 a a DT 37231 547 54 weighty weighty JJ 37231 547 55 argument argument NN 37231 547 56 for for IN 37231 547 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 547 58 and and CC 37231 547 59 against against IN 37231 547 60 the the DT 37231 547 61 earlier early JJR 37231 547 62 date date NN 37231 547 63 , , , 37231 547 64 and and CC 37231 547 65 as as IN 37231 547 66 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 547 67 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 547 68 considers consider VBZ 37231 547 69 , , , 37231 547 70 rightly rightly RB 37231 547 71 , , , 37231 547 72 that that DT 37231 547 73 argument argument NN 37231 547 74 should should MD 37231 547 75 decide decide VB 37231 547 76 everything everything NN 37231 547 77 , , , 37231 547 78 I -PRON- PRP 37231 547 79 am be VBP 37231 547 80 surprised surprised JJ 37231 547 81 that that IN 37231 547 82 he -PRON- PRP 37231 547 83 has have VBZ 37231 547 84 not not RB 37231 547 85 perceived perceive VBN 37231 547 86 the the DT 37231 547 87 propriety propriety NN 37231 547 88 of of IN 37231 547 89 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 547 90 referring referring NN 37231 547 91 to to IN 37231 547 92 arguments argument NNS 37231 547 93 as as RB 37231 547 94 well well RB 37231 547 95 as as IN 37231 547 96 statements statement NNS 37231 547 97 of of IN 37231 547 98 evidence evidence NN 37231 547 99 . . . 37231 548 1 To to TO 37231 548 2 sum sum VB 37231 548 3 up up RP 37231 548 4 the the DT 37231 548 5 opinions opinion NNS 37231 548 6 expressed express VBN 37231 548 7 , , , 37231 548 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 548 9 may may MD 37231 548 10 state state VB 37231 548 11 that that IN 37231 548 12 whilst whilst IN 37231 548 13 all all PDT 37231 548 14 the the DT 37231 548 15 nine nine CD 37231 548 16 writers writer NNS 37231 548 17 support support VBP 37231 548 18 the the DT 37231 548 19 later later JJ 37231 548 20 date date NN 37231 548 21 , , , 37231 548 22 for for IN 37231 548 23 which which WDT 37231 548 24 purpose purpose NN 37231 548 25 they -PRON- PRP 37231 548 26 were be VBD 37231 548 27 quoted quote VBN 37231 548 28 , , , 37231 548 29 three three CD 37231 548 30 of of IN 37231 548 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 548 32 ( ( -LRB- 37231 548 33 Bleek Bleek NNP 37231 548 34 , , , 37231 548 35 Guericke Guericke NNP 37231 548 36 , , , 37231 548 37 and and CC 37231 548 38 Mayerhoff Mayerhoff NNP 37231 548 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 548 40 ascribe ascribe VBP 37231 548 41 the the DT 37231 548 42 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 548 43 to to IN 37231 548 44 Rome Rome NNP 37231 548 45 , , , 37231 548 46 one one CD 37231 548 47 ( ( -LRB- 37231 548 48 Brctschneider Brctschneider NNP 37231 548 49 ) ) -RRB- 37231 548 50 mentions mention VBZ 37231 548 51 no no DT 37231 548 52 place place NN 37231 548 53 , , , 37231 548 54 one one CD 37231 548 55 ( ( -LRB- 37231 548 56 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 37231 548 57 ) ) -RRB- 37231 548 58 is be VBZ 37231 548 59 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 548 60 , , , 37231 548 61 but but CC 37231 548 62 leans lean VBZ 37231 548 63 to to IN 37231 548 64 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 548 65 , , , 37231 548 66 and and CC 37231 548 67 the the DT 37231 548 68 other other JJ 37231 548 69 four four CD 37231 548 70 declare declare NN 37231 548 71 for for IN 37231 548 72 the the DT 37231 548 73 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 548 74 in in IN 37231 548 75 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 548 76 . . . 37231 549 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 549 2 , , , 37231 549 3 however however RB 37231 549 4 , , , 37231 549 5 could could MD 37231 549 6 show show VB 37231 549 7 more more RBR 37231 549 8 conclusively conclusively RB 37231 549 9 the the DT 37231 549 10 purpose purpose NN 37231 549 11 of of IN 37231 549 12 note note NN 37231 549 13 3 3 CD 37231 549 14 , , , 37231 549 15 which which WDT 37231 549 16 I -PRON- PRP 37231 549 17 have have VBP 37231 549 18 explained explain VBN 37231 549 19 , , , 37231 549 20 than than IN 37231 549 21 this this DT 37231 549 22 very very JJ 37231 549 23 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 549 24 , , , 37231 549 25 and and CC 37231 549 26 the the DT 37231 549 27 fact fact NN 37231 549 28 that that IN 37231 549 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 549 30 claim claim VBP 37231 549 31 for for IN 37231 549 32 the the DT 37231 549 33 general general JJ 37231 549 34 statement statement NN 37231 549 35 in in IN 37231 549 36 the the DT 37231 549 37 text text NN 37231 549 38 , , , 37231 549 39 regarding regard VBG 37231 549 40 the the DT 37231 549 41 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 549 42 in in IN 37231 549 43 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 549 44 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 549 45 in in IN 37231 549 46 opposition opposition NN 37231 549 47 to to IN 37231 549 48 the the DT 37231 549 49 legend legend NN 37231 549 50 of of IN 37231 549 51 the the DT 37231 549 52 journey journey NN 37231 549 53 to to IN 37231 549 54 and and CC 37231 549 55 death death NN 37231 549 56 in in IN 37231 549 57 Rome Rome NNP 37231 549 58 , , , 37231 549 59 only only RB 37231 549 60 the the DT 37231 549 61 authorities authority NNS 37231 549 62 in in IN 37231 549 63 note note NN 37231 549 64 4 4 CD 37231 549 65 , , , 37231 549 66 which which WDT 37231 549 67 I -PRON- PRP 37231 549 68 shall shall MD 37231 549 69 now now RB 37231 549 70 proceed proceed VB 37231 549 71 to to TO 37231 549 72 analyse analyse VB 37231 549 73 in in IN 37231 549 74 contrast contrast NN 37231 549 75 with with IN 37231 549 76 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 549 77 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 549 78 's 's POS 37231 549 79 statements statement NNS 37231 549 80 , , , 37231 549 81 and and CC 37231 549 82 here here RB 37231 549 83 1 1 CD 37231 549 84 beg beg VB 37231 549 85 the the DT 37231 549 86 favour favour NN 37231 549 87 of of IN 37231 549 88 the the DT 37231 549 89 readers reader NNS 37231 549 90 attention attention NN 37231 549 91 . . . 37231 550 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 550 2 See see VB 37231 550 3 page page NN 37231 550 4 scans scan NNS 37231 550 5 , , , 37231 550 6 lix lix VBP 37231 550 7 to to IN 37231 550 8 lxii lxii NN 37231 550 9 Ed Ed NNP 37231 550 10 . . . 37231 550 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 551 1 { { -LRB- 37231 551 2 lxiii lxiii NN 37231 551 3 } } -RRB- 37231 551 4 At at IN 37231 551 5 the the DT 37231 551 6 close close NN 37231 551 7 of of IN 37231 551 8 this this DT 37231 551 9 analysis analysis NN 37231 551 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 551 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 551 12 sums sum VBZ 37231 551 13 up up RP 37231 551 14 the the DT 37231 551 15 result result NN 37231 551 16 as as IN 37231 551 17 follows follow VBZ 37231 551 18 : : : 37231 551 19 " " `` 37231 551 20 In in IN 37231 551 21 this this DT 37231 551 22 case case NN 37231 551 23 , , , 37231 551 24 therefore therefore RB 37231 551 25 , , , 37231 551 26 again again RB 37231 551 27 , , , 37231 551 28 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 551 29 alone alone RB 37231 551 30 offers offer VBZ 37231 551 31 any any DT 37231 551 32 arguments argument NNS 37231 551 33 in in IN 37231 551 34 support support NN 37231 551 35 of of IN 37231 551 36 the the DT 37231 551 37 statement statement NN 37231 551 38 in in IN 37231 551 39 the the DT 37231 551 40 text text NN 37231 551 41 ; ; : 37231 551 42 and and CC 37231 551 43 the the DT 37231 551 44 final final JJ 37231 551 45 result result NN 37231 551 46 of of IN 37231 551 47 the the DT 37231 551 48 references reference NNS 37231 551 49 is be VBZ 37231 551 50 , , , 37231 551 51 that that IN 37231 551 52 the the DT 37231 551 53 alleged allege VBN 37231 551 54 ' ' `` 37231 551 55 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 551 56 ' ' '' 37231 551 57 is be VBZ 37231 551 58 , , , 37231 551 59 at at IN 37231 551 60 the the DT 37231 551 61 most most JJS 37231 551 62 , , , 37231 551 63 what what WP 37231 551 64 Scholten Scholten NNP 37231 551 65 calls call VBZ 37231 551 66 ' ' '' 37231 551 67 a a DT 37231 551 68 not not RB 37231 551 69 groundless groundless JJ 37231 551 70 conjecture conjecture NN 37231 551 71 . . . 37231 552 1 ' ' '' 37231 552 2 " " '' 37231 552 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 552 4 3 3 CD 37231 552 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 552 6 3 3 CD 37231 552 7 On on IN 37231 552 8 the the DT 37231 552 9 Canon Canon NNP 37231 552 10 , , , 37231 552 11 Preface Preface NNP 37231 552 12 4th 4th JJ 37231 552 13 ed ed NN 37231 552 14 . . . 37231 553 1 p. p. NNP 37231 553 2 xxiv xxiv NNP 37231 553 3 . . . 37231 554 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 554 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 554 3 adds add VBZ 37231 554 4 , , , 37231 554 5 in in IN 37231 554 6 a a DT 37231 554 7 note note NN 37231 554 8 , , , 37231 554 9 " " `` 37231 554 10 It -PRON- PRP 37231 554 11 may may MD 37231 554 12 be be VB 37231 554 13 worth worth JJ 37231 554 14 while while IN 37231 554 15 to to TO 37231 554 16 add add VB 37231 554 17 that that IN 37231 554 18 in in IN 37231 554 19 spite spite NN 37231 554 20 of of IN 37231 554 21 the the DT 37231 554 22 profuse profuse NN 37231 554 23 display display NN 37231 554 24 of of IN 37231 554 25 learning learn VBG 37231 554 26 in in IN 37231 554 27 connexion connexion NN 37231 554 28 with with IN 37231 554 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 554 30 , , , 37231 554 31 I -PRON- PRP 37231 554 32 do do VBP 37231 554 33 not not RB 37231 554 34 see see VB 37231 554 35 even even RB 37231 554 36 in in IN 37231 554 37 the the DT 37231 554 38 second second JJ 37231 554 39 edition edition NN 37231 554 40 any any DT 37231 554 41 reference reference NN 37231 554 42 to to IN 37231 554 43 the the DT 37231 554 44 full full JJ 37231 554 45 and and CC 37231 554 46 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 554 47 work work NN 37231 554 48 of of IN 37231 554 49 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 554 50 . . . 37231 554 51 " " '' 37231 555 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 555 2 might may MD 37231 555 3 reply reply VB 37231 555 4 to to IN 37231 555 5 this this DT 37231 555 6 that that IN 37231 555 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 555 8 MS MS NNP 37231 555 9 . . NNP 37231 555 10 had have VBD 37231 555 11 left leave VBN 37231 555 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 555 13 hands hand NNS 37231 555 14 before before IN 37231 555 15 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 555 16 's 's POS 37231 555 17 work work NN 37231 555 18 had have VBD 37231 555 19 reached reach VBN 37231 555 20 England England NNP 37231 555 21 , , , 37231 555 22 but but CC 37231 555 23 , , , 37231 555 24 moreover moreover RB 37231 555 25 , , , 37231 555 26 the the DT 37231 555 27 work work NN 37231 555 28 contains contain VBZ 37231 555 29 nothing nothing NN 37231 555 30 new new JJ 37231 555 31 to to TO 37231 555 32 which which WDT 37231 555 33 reference reference NN 37231 555 34 was be VBD 37231 555 35 necessary necessary JJ 37231 555 36 . . . 37231 556 1 { { -LRB- 37231 556 2 lxiv lxiv NNP 37231 556 3 } } -RRB- 37231 556 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 556 5 is be VBZ 37231 556 6 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 556 7 possible possible JJ 37231 556 8 to to TO 37231 556 9 imagine imagine VB 37231 556 10 a a DT 37231 556 11 more more RBR 37231 556 12 complete complete JJ 37231 556 13 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 37231 556 14 of of IN 37231 556 15 the the DT 37231 556 16 fact fact NN 37231 556 17 than than IN 37231 556 18 the the DT 37231 556 19 statement statement NN 37231 556 20 that that IN 37231 556 21 " " `` 37231 556 22 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 556 23 alone alone RB 37231 556 24 offers offer VBZ 37231 556 25 any any DT 37231 556 26 arguments argument NNS 37231 556 27 in in IN 37231 556 28 support support NN 37231 556 29 of of IN 37231 556 30 the the DT 37231 556 31 statement statement NN 37231 556 32 in in IN 37231 556 33 the the DT 37231 556 34 text text NN 37231 556 35 , , , 37231 556 36 " " '' 37231 556 37 and and CC 37231 556 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 556 39 is be VBZ 37231 556 40 incomprehensible incomprehensible JJ 37231 556 41 upon upon IN 37231 556 42 any any DT 37231 556 43 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 556 44 theory theory NN 37231 556 45 . . . 37231 557 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 557 2 mere mere JJ 37231 557 3 sketch sketch NN 37231 557 4 can can MD 37231 557 5 not not RB 37231 557 6 possibly possibly RB 37231 557 7 convey convey VB 37231 557 8 an an DT 37231 557 9 adequate adequate JJ 37231 557 10 idea idea NN 37231 557 11 of of IN 37231 557 12 the the DT 37231 557 13 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 557 14 arguments argument NNS 37231 557 15 of of IN 37231 557 16 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 557 17 , , , 37231 557 18 Baur Baur NNP 37231 557 19 , , , 37231 557 20 and and CC 37231 557 21 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 557 22 , , , 37231 557 23 but but CC 37231 557 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 557 25 hope hope VBP 37231 557 26 to to TO 37231 557 27 state state VB 37231 557 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 557 29 main main JJ 37231 557 30 features feature NNS 37231 557 31 , , , 37231 557 32 a a DT 37231 557 33 few few JJ 37231 557 34 pages page NNS 37231 557 35 on on IN 37231 557 36 . . . 37231 558 1 With with IN 37231 558 2 regard regard NN 37231 558 3 to to IN 37231 558 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 558 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 558 6 's 's POS 37231 558 7 remark remark NN 37231 558 8 on on IN 37231 558 9 the the DT 37231 558 10 " " `` 37231 558 11 alleged allege VBN 37231 558 12 ' ' '' 37231 558 13 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 558 14 , , , 37231 558 15 ' ' '' 37231 558 16 " " `` 37231 558 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 558 18 must must MD 37231 558 19 be be VB 37231 558 20 evident evident JJ 37231 558 21 that that IN 37231 558 22 when when WRB 37231 558 23 a a DT 37231 558 24 writer writer NN 37231 558 25 states state VBZ 37231 558 26 anything anything NN 37231 558 27 to to TO 37231 558 28 be be VB 37231 558 29 " " `` 37231 558 30 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 558 31 " " '' 37231 558 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 558 33 expresses express VBZ 37231 558 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 558 35 own own JJ 37231 558 36 belief belief NN 37231 558 37 . . . 37231 559 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 559 2 is be VBZ 37231 559 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 559 4 to to TO 37231 559 5 secure secure VB 37231 559 6 absolute absolute JJ 37231 559 7 unanimity unanimity NN 37231 559 8 of of IN 37231 559 9 opinion opinion NN 37231 559 10 , , , 37231 559 11 and and CC 37231 559 12 the the DT 37231 559 13 only only JJ 37231 559 14 question question NN 37231 559 15 in in IN 37231 559 16 such such PDT 37231 559 17 a a DT 37231 559 18 case case NN 37231 559 19 is be VBZ 37231 559 20 whether whether IN 37231 559 21 I -PRON- PRP 37231 559 22 refer refer VBP 37231 559 23 to to IN 37231 559 24 writers writer NNS 37231 559 25 , , , 37231 559 26 in in IN 37231 559 27 connection connection NN 37231 559 28 with with IN 37231 559 29 the the DT 37231 559 30 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 559 31 which which WDT 37231 559 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 559 33 affirm affirm VBP 37231 559 34 to to TO 37231 559 35 be be VB 37231 559 36 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 559 37 , , , 37231 559 38 who who WP 37231 559 39 advance advance VBP 37231 559 40 arguments argument NNS 37231 559 41 and and CC 37231 559 42 evidence evidence NN 37231 559 43 bearing bear VBG 37231 559 44 upon upon IN 37231 559 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 559 46 . . . 37231 560 1 A a DT 37231 560 2 critic critic NN 37231 560 3 is be VBZ 37231 560 4 quite quite RB 37231 560 5 at at IN 37231 560 6 liberty liberty NN 37231 560 7 to to TO 37231 560 8 say say VB 37231 560 9 that that IN 37231 560 10 the the DT 37231 560 11 arguments argument NNS 37231 560 12 are be VBP 37231 560 13 insufficient insufficient JJ 37231 560 14 , , , 37231 560 15 but but CC 37231 560 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 560 17 is be VBZ 37231 560 18 not not RB 37231 560 19 at at IN 37231 560 20 liberty liberty NN 37231 560 21 to to TO 37231 560 22 deny deny VB 37231 560 23 that that IN 37231 560 24 there there EX 37231 560 25 are be VBP 37231 560 26 any any DT 37231 560 27 arguments argument NNS 37231 560 28 at at RB 37231 560 29 all all RB 37231 560 30 when when WRB 37231 560 31 the the DT 37231 560 32 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 560 33 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 560 34 of of IN 37231 560 35 men man NNS 37231 560 36 like like IN 37231 560 37 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 560 38 , , , 37231 560 39 Baur Baur NNP 37231 560 40 and and CC 37231 560 41 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 560 42 is be VBZ 37231 560 43 referred refer VBN 37231 560 44 to to IN 37231 560 45 . . . 37231 561 1 Therefore therefore RB 37231 561 2 , , , 37231 561 3 when when WRB 37231 561 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 561 5 goes go VBZ 37231 561 6 on on RP 37231 561 7 to to TO 37231 561 8 say say VB 37231 561 9 : : : 37231 561 10 " " `` 37231 561 11 It -PRON- PRP 37231 561 12 seems seem VBZ 37231 561 13 quite quite RB 37231 561 14 needless needless JJ 37231 561 15 to to TO 37231 561 16 multiply multiply VB 37231 561 17 comments comment NNS 37231 561 18 on on IN 37231 561 19 these these DT 37231 561 20 results result NNS 37231 561 21 . . . 37231 562 1 Any any DT 37231 562 2 one one NN 37231 562 3 who who WP 37231 562 4 will will MD 37231 562 5 candidly candidly RB 37231 562 6 consider consider VB 37231 562 7 this this DT 37231 562 8 analysis analysis NN 37231 562 9 will will MD 37231 562 10 , , , 37231 562 11 I -PRON- PRP 37231 562 12 believe believe VBP 37231 562 13 , , , 37231 562 14 agree agree VBP 37231 562 15 with with IN 37231 562 16 me -PRON- PRP 37231 562 17 in in IN 37231 562 18 thinking think VBG 37231 562 19 that that IN 37231 562 20 such such PDT 37231 562 21 a a DT 37231 562 22 style style NN 37231 562 23 of of IN 37231 562 24 annotation annotation NN 37231 562 25 , , , 37231 562 26 which which WDT 37231 562 27 runs run VBZ 37231 562 28 through through IN 37231 562 29 the the DT 37231 562 30 whole whole JJ 37231 562 31 work work NN 37231 562 32 , , , 37231 562 33 is be VBZ 37231 562 34 justly justly RB 37231 562 35 characterized characterize VBN 37231 562 36 as as IN 37231 562 37 frivolous frivolous JJ 37231 562 38 and and CC 37231 562 39 misleading misleading JJ 37231 562 40 . . . 37231 563 1 " " `` 37231 563 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 563 3 1 1 LS 37231 563 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 563 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 563 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 563 7 must must MD 37231 563 8 excuse excuse VB 37231 563 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 563 10 retorting retorting NN 37231 563 11 that that IN 37231 563 12 , , , 37231 563 13 not not RB 37231 563 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 563 15 annotation annotation NN 37231 563 16 , , , 37231 563 17 but but CC 37231 563 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 563 19 own own JJ 37231 563 20 criticism criticism NN 37231 563 21 of of IN 37231 563 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 563 23 , , , 37231 563 24 endorsed endorse VBN 37231 563 25 by by IN 37231 563 26 Professor Professor NNP 37231 563 27 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 563 28 , , , 37231 563 29 is be VBZ 37231 563 30 " " `` 37231 563 31 frivolous frivolous JJ 37231 563 32 and and CC 37231 563 33 misleading misleading JJ 37231 563 34 , , , 37231 563 35 " " '' 37231 563 36 and and CC 37231 563 37 I -PRON- PRP 37231 563 38 venture venture VBP 37231 563 39 to to TO 37231 563 40 hope hope VB 37231 563 41 that that IN 37231 563 42 this this DT 37231 563 43 analysis analysis NN 37231 563 44 , , , 37231 563 45 tedious tedious JJ 37231 563 46 as as IN 37231 563 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 563 48 has have VBZ 37231 563 49 been be VBN 37231 563 50 , , , 37231 563 51 may may MD 37231 563 52 once once RB 37231 563 53 for for IN 37231 563 54 all all DT 37231 563 55 establish establish VB 37231 563 56 the the DT 37231 563 57 propriety propriety JJ 37231 563 58 and and CC 37231 563 59 substantial substantial JJ 37231 563 60 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 563 61 of of IN 37231 563 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 563 63 references reference NNS 37231 563 64 . . . 37231 564 1 As as IN 37231 564 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 564 3 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 564 4 does do VBZ 37231 564 5 not not RB 37231 564 6 advance advance VB 37231 564 7 any any DT 37231 564 8 further further JJ 37231 564 9 arguments argument NNS 37231 564 10 { { -LRB- 37231 564 11 lxv lxv NNP 37231 564 12 } } -RRB- 37231 564 13 of of IN 37231 564 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 564 15 own own JJ 37231 564 16 in in IN 37231 564 17 regard regard NN 37231 564 18 to to IN 37231 564 19 the the DT 37231 564 20 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 564 21 controversy controversy NN 37231 564 22 , , , 37231 564 23 I -PRON- PRP 37231 564 24 may may MD 37231 564 25 now now RB 37231 564 26 return return VB 37231 564 27 to to IN 37231 564 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 564 29 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 564 30 , , , 37231 564 31 and and CC 37231 564 32 complete complete VB 37231 564 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 564 34 reply reply NN 37231 564 35 to to IN 37231 564 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 564 37 objections objection NNS 37231 564 38 ; ; : 37231 564 39 but but CC 37231 564 40 I -PRON- PRP 37231 564 41 must must MD 37231 564 42 do do VB 37231 564 43 so so RB 37231 564 44 with with IN 37231 564 45 extreme extreme JJ 37231 564 46 brevity brevity NN 37231 564 47 , , , 37231 564 48 as as IN 37231 564 49 I -PRON- PRP 37231 564 50 have have VBP 37231 564 51 already already RB 37231 564 52 devoted devote VBN 37231 564 53 too too RB 37231 564 54 much much JJ 37231 564 55 space space NN 37231 564 56 to to IN 37231 564 57 this this DT 37231 564 58 subject subject NN 37231 564 59 , , , 37231 564 60 and and CC 37231 564 61 must must MD 37231 564 62 now now RB 37231 564 63 come come VB 37231 564 64 to to IN 37231 564 65 a a DT 37231 564 66 close close NN 37231 564 67 . . . 37231 565 1 To to IN 37231 565 2 the the DT 37231 565 3 argument argument NN 37231 565 4 that that IN 37231 565 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 565 6 is be VBZ 37231 565 7 impossible impossible JJ 37231 565 8 to to TO 37231 565 9 suppose suppose VB 37231 565 10 that that IN 37231 565 11 soldiers soldier NNS 37231 565 12 such such JJ 37231 565 13 as as IN 37231 565 14 the the DT 37231 565 15 " " `` 37231 565 16 ten ten CD 37231 565 17 leopards leopard NNS 37231 565 18 " " '' 37231 565 19 described describe VBN 37231 565 20 in in IN 37231 565 21 the the DT 37231 565 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 565 23 would would MD 37231 565 24 allow allow VB 37231 565 25 a a DT 37231 565 26 prisoner prisoner NN 37231 565 27 , , , 37231 565 28 condemned condemn VBN 37231 565 29 to to IN 37231 565 30 wild wild JJ 37231 565 31 beasts beast NNS 37231 565 32 for for IN 37231 565 33 professing profess VBG 37231 565 34 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 565 35 , , , 37231 565 36 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 565 37 to to TO 37231 565 38 write write VB 37231 565 39 long long JJ 37231 565 40 epistles epistle NNS 37231 565 41 at at IN 37231 565 42 every every DT 37231 565 43 stage stage NN 37231 565 44 of of IN 37231 565 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 565 46 journey journey NN 37231 565 47 , , , 37231 565 48 promulgating promulgate VBG 37231 565 49 the the DT 37231 565 50 very very JJ 37231 565 51 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 565 52 for for IN 37231 565 53 which which WDT 37231 565 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 565 55 was be VBD 37231 565 56 condemned condemn VBN 37231 565 57 , , , 37231 565 58 as as RB 37231 565 59 well well RB 37231 565 60 as as IN 37231 565 61 to to TO 37231 565 62 hold hold VB 37231 565 63 the the DT 37231 565 64 freest free JJS 37231 565 65 intercourse intercourse NN 37231 565 66 with with IN 37231 565 67 deputations deputation NNS 37231 565 68 from from IN 37231 565 69 the the DT 37231 565 70 various various JJ 37231 565 71 churches church NNS 37231 565 72 , , , 37231 565 73 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 565 74 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 565 75 advances advance VBZ 37231 565 76 arguments argument NNS 37231 565 77 , , , 37231 565 78 derived derive VBN 37231 565 79 from from IN 37231 565 80 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 565 81 , , , 37231 565 82 regarding regard VBG 37231 565 83 the the DT 37231 565 84 Roman roman JJ 37231 565 85 procedure procedure NN 37231 565 86 in in IN 37231 565 87 cases case NNS 37231 565 88 that that WDT 37231 565 89 are be VBP 37231 565 90 said say VBN 37231 565 91 to to TO 37231 565 92 be be VB 37231 565 93 " " `` 37231 565 94 known know VBN 37231 565 95 . . . 37231 565 96 " " '' 37231 566 1 These these DT 37231 566 2 cases case NNS 37231 566 3 , , , 37231 566 4 however however RB 37231 566 5 , , , 37231 566 6 are be VBP 37231 566 7 neither neither RB 37231 566 8 analogous analogous JJ 37231 566 9 , , , 37231 566 10 nor nor CC 37231 566 11 have have VBP 37231 566 12 they -PRON- PRP 37231 566 13 the the DT 37231 566 14 force force NN 37231 566 15 which which WDT 37231 566 16 is be VBZ 37231 566 17 assumed assume VBN 37231 566 18 . . . 37231 567 1 That that IN 37231 567 2 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 567 3 imprisoned imprison VBD 37231 567 4 for for IN 37231 567 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 567 6 religious religious JJ 37231 567 7 belief belief NN 37231 567 8 should should MD 37231 567 9 receive receive VB 37231 567 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 567 11 nourishment nourishment NN 37231 567 12 , , , 37231 567 13 while while IN 37231 567 14 in in IN 37231 567 15 prison prison NN 37231 567 16 , , , 37231 567 17 from from IN 37231 567 18 friends friend NNS 37231 567 19 , , , 37231 567 20 is be VBZ 37231 567 21 anything anything NN 37231 567 22 but but IN 37231 567 23 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 567 24 , , , 37231 567 25 and and CC 37231 567 26 that that IN 37231 567 27 bribes bribe NNS 37231 567 28 should should MD 37231 567 29 secure secure VB 37231 567 30 access access NN 37231 567 31 to to IN 37231 567 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 567 33 in in IN 37231 567 34 many many JJ 37231 567 35 cases case NNS 37231 567 36 , , , 37231 567 37 and and CC 37231 567 38 some some DT 37231 567 39 mitigation mitigation NN 37231 567 40 of of IN 37231 567 41 suffering suffering NN 37231 567 42 , , , 37231 567 43 is be VBZ 37231 567 44 possible possible JJ 37231 567 45 . . . 37231 568 1 The the DT 37231 568 2 case case NN 37231 568 3 of of IN 37231 568 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 568 5 , , , 37231 568 6 however however RB 37231 568 7 , , , 37231 568 8 is be VBZ 37231 568 9 very very RB 37231 568 10 different different JJ 37231 568 11 . . . 37231 569 1 If if IN 37231 569 2 the the DT 37231 569 3 meaning meaning NN 37231 569 4 of of IN 37231 569 5 [ [ -LRB- 37231 569 6 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 569 7 ] ] -RRB- 37231 569 8 be be VB 37231 569 9 that that IN 37231 569 10 , , , 37231 569 11 although although IN 37231 569 12 receiving receive VBG 37231 569 13 bribes bribe NNS 37231 569 14 , , , 37231 569 15 the the DT 37231 569 16 " " `` 37231 569 17 ten ten CD 37231 569 18 leopards leopard NNS 37231 569 19 " " '' 37231 569 20 only only RB 37231 569 21 became become VBD 37231 569 22 more more RBR 37231 569 23 cruel cruel JJ 37231 569 24 , , , 37231 569 25 the the DT 37231 569 26 very very RB 37231 569 27 reverse reverse NN 37231 569 28 of of IN 37231 569 29 the the DT 37231 569 30 leniency leniency NN 37231 569 31 and and CC 37231 569 32 mild mild JJ 37231 569 33 treatment treatment NN 37231 569 34 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 569 35 to to IN 37231 569 36 the the DT 37231 569 37 Roman roman JJ 37231 569 38 procedure procedure NN 37231 569 39 is be VBZ 37231 569 40 described describe VBN 37231 569 41 by by IN 37231 569 42 the the DT 37231 569 43 writer writer NN 37231 569 44 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 569 45 as as IN 37231 569 46 actually actually RB 37231 569 47 taking take VBG 37231 569 48 place place NN 37231 569 49 , , , 37231 569 50 and and CC 37231 569 51 certainly certainly RB 37231 569 52 nothing nothing NN 37231 569 53 approaching approach VBG 37231 569 54 a a DT 37231 569 55 parallel parallel NN 37231 569 56 to to IN 37231 569 57 the the DT 37231 569 58 correspondence correspondence NN 37231 569 59 of of IN 37231 569 60 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 569 61 - - NNP 37231 569 62 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 569 63 can can MD 37231 569 64 be be VB 37231 569 65 pointed point VBN 37231 569 66 out out RP 37231 569 67 in in IN 37231 569 68 any any DT 37231 569 69 known know VBN 37231 569 70 instance instance NN 37231 569 71 . . . 37231 570 1 The the DT 37231 570 2 case case NN 37231 570 3 of of IN 37231 570 4 Saturus Saturus NNP 37231 570 5 and and CC 37231 570 6 Perpetua Perpetua NNP 37231 570 7 , , , 37231 570 8 even even RB 37231 570 9 if if IN 37231 570 10 true true JJ 37231 570 11 , , , 37231 570 12 is be VBZ 37231 570 13 no no DT 37231 570 14 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 570 15 , , , 37231 570 16 the the DT 37231 570 17 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 570 18 being be VBG 37231 570 19 very very RB 37231 570 20 different different JJ 37231 570 21 ; ; : 37231 570 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 570 23 l l NN 37231 570 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 570 25 but but CC 37231 570 26 in in IN 37231 570 27 { { -LRB- 37231 570 28 lxvi lxvi JJ 37231 570 29 } } -RRB- 37231 570 30 fact fact NN 37231 570 31 there there EX 37231 570 32 is be VBZ 37231 570 33 no no DT 37231 570 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 570 35 whatever whatever WDT 37231 570 36 that that IN 37231 570 37 the the DT 37231 570 38 extant extant JJ 37231 570 39 history history NN 37231 570 40 was be VBD 37231 570 41 written write VBN 37231 570 42 by by IN 37231 570 43 either either DT 37231 570 44 of of IN 37231 570 45 them,(1 them,(1 NN 37231 570 46 ) ) -RRB- 37231 570 47 but but CC 37231 570 48 on on IN 37231 570 49 the the DT 37231 570 50 contrary contrary NN 37231 570 51 , , , 37231 570 52 I -PRON- PRP 37231 570 53 maintain maintain VBP 37231 570 54 , , , 37231 570 55 every every DT 37231 570 56 reason reason NN 37231 570 57 to to TO 37231 570 58 believe believe VB 37231 570 59 that that IN 37231 570 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 570 61 was be VBD 37231 570 62 not not RB 37231 570 63 . . . 37231 571 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 571 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 571 3 advances advance VBZ 37231 571 4 the the DT 37231 571 5 instance instance NN 37231 571 6 of of IN 37231 571 7 Paul Paul NNP 37231 571 8 as as IN 37231 571 9 a a DT 37231 571 10 case case NN 37231 571 11 in in IN 37231 571 12 point point NN 37231 571 13 of of IN 37231 571 14 a a DT 37231 571 15 Christian christian JJ 37231 571 16 prisoner prisoner NN 37231 571 17 treated treat VBN 37231 571 18 with with IN 37231 571 19 great great JJ 37231 571 20 consideration consideration NN 37231 571 21 , , , 37231 571 22 and and CC 37231 571 23 who who WP 37231 571 24 " " `` 37231 571 25 writes write VBZ 37231 571 26 letters letter NNS 37231 571 27 freely freely RB 37231 571 28 , , , 37231 571 29 receives receive VBZ 37231 571 30 visits visit NNS 37231 571 31 from from IN 37231 571 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 571 33 friends friend NNS 37231 571 34 , , , 37231 571 35 communicates communicate VBZ 37231 571 36 with with IN 37231 571 37 churches church NNS 37231 571 38 and and CC 37231 571 39 individuals individual NNS 37231 571 40 as as IN 37231 571 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 571 42 desires desire VBZ 37231 571 43 . . . 37231 572 1 " " `` 37231 572 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 572 3 2 2 LS 37231 572 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 572 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 572 6 is be VBZ 37231 572 7 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 572 8 possible possible JJ 37231 572 9 to to TO 37231 572 10 imagine imagine VB 37231 572 11 two two CD 37231 572 12 cases case NNS 37231 572 13 more more RBR 37231 572 14 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 37231 572 15 than than IN 37231 572 16 those those DT 37231 572 17 of of IN 37231 572 18 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 572 19 - - HYPH 37231 572 20 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 572 21 and and CC 37231 572 22 Paul Paul NNP 37231 572 23 , , , 37231 572 24 as as IN 37231 572 25 narrated narrate VBN 37231 572 26 in in IN 37231 572 27 the the DT 37231 572 28 " " `` 37231 572 29 Acts act NNS 37231 572 30 of of IN 37231 572 31 the the DT 37231 572 32 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 572 33 , , , 37231 572 34 " " '' 37231 572 35 although although IN 37231 572 36 doubtless doubtless RB 37231 572 37 the the DT 37231 572 38 story story NN 37231 572 39 of of IN 37231 572 40 the the DT 37231 572 41 former former JJ 37231 572 42 has have VBZ 37231 572 43 been be VBN 37231 572 44 framed frame VBN 37231 572 45 upon upon IN 37231 572 46 some some DT 37231 572 47 of of IN 37231 572 48 the the DT 37231 572 49 lines line NNS 37231 572 50 of of IN 37231 572 51 the the DT 37231 572 52 latter latter JJ 37231 572 53 . . . 37231 573 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 573 2 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 573 3 is be VBZ 37231 573 4 condemned condemn VBN 37231 573 5 to to TO 37231 573 6 be be VB 37231 573 7 cast cast VBN 37231 573 8 to to IN 37231 573 9 the the DT 37231 573 10 wild wild JJ 37231 573 11 beasts beast NNS 37231 573 12 as as IN 37231 573 13 a a DT 37231 573 14 Christian Christian NNP 37231 573 15 , , , 37231 573 16 Paul Paul NNP 37231 573 17 is be VBZ 37231 573 18 not not RB 37231 573 19 condemned condemn VBN 37231 573 20 at at RB 37231 573 21 all all RB 37231 573 22 , , , 37231 573 23 but but CC 37231 573 24 stands stand VBZ 37231 573 25 in in IN 37231 573 26 the the DT 37231 573 27 position position NN 37231 573 28 of of IN 37231 573 29 a a DT 37231 573 30 Roman roman JJ 37231 573 31 citizen citizen NN 37231 573 32 , , , 37231 573 33 rescued rescue VBN 37231 573 34 from from IN 37231 573 35 infuriated infuriate VBN 37231 573 36 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 573 37 ( ( -LRB- 37231 573 38 xxiii xxiii NN 37231 573 39 . . . 37231 574 1 27 27 CD 37231 574 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 574 3 , , , 37231 574 4 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 574 5 declared declare VBN 37231 574 6 by by IN 37231 574 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 574 8 judges judge NNS 37231 574 9 to to TO 37231 574 10 have have VB 37231 574 11 done do VBN 37231 574 12 nothing nothing NN 37231 574 13 worthy worthy JJ 37231 574 14 of of IN 37231 574 15 death death NN 37231 574 16 or or CC 37231 574 17 of of IN 37231 574 18 bonds bond NNS 37231 574 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 574 20 xxv xxv NNP 37231 574 21 . . . 37231 575 1 25 25 CD 37231 575 2 , , , 37231 575 3 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 575 4 . . . 37231 576 1 31 31 CD 37231 576 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 576 3 , , , 37231 576 4 and and CC 37231 576 5 who who WP 37231 576 6 might may MD 37231 576 7 have have VB 37231 576 8 been be VBN 37231 576 9 set set VBN 37231 576 10 at at IN 37231 576 11 liberty liberty NN 37231 576 12 but but CC 37231 576 13 that that IN 37231 576 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 576 15 had have VBD 37231 576 16 appealed appeal VBN 37231 576 17 to to IN 37231 576 18 Cæsar Cæsar NNP 37231 576 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 576 20 xxv xxv NNP 37231 576 21 . . . 37231 577 1 11 11 CD 37231 577 2 f. f. NNP 37231 577 3 , , , 37231 577 4 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 577 5 . . . 37231 578 1 32 32 CD 37231 578 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 578 3 . . . 37231 579 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 579 2 position position NN 37231 579 3 was be VBD 37231 579 4 one one CD 37231 579 5 which which WDT 37231 579 6 secured secure VBD 37231 579 7 the the DT 37231 579 8 sympathy sympathy NN 37231 579 9 of of IN 37231 579 10 the the DT 37231 579 11 Roman roman JJ 37231 579 12 soldiers soldier NNS 37231 579 13 . . . 37231 580 1 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 580 2 ' ' POS 37231 580 3 fights fight VBZ 37231 580 4 with with IN 37231 580 5 beasts beast NNS 37231 580 6 from from IN 37231 580 7 Syria Syria NNP 37231 580 8 even even RB 37231 580 9 unto unto IN 37231 580 10 Rome Rome NNP 37231 580 11 , , , 37231 580 12 ' ' '' 37231 580 13 and and CC 37231 580 14 is be VBZ 37231 580 15 cruelly cruelly RB 37231 580 16 treated treat VBN 37231 580 17 by by IN 37231 580 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 580 19 " " `` 37231 580 20 ten ten CD 37231 580 21 leopards leopard NNS 37231 580 22 , , , 37231 580 23 " " '' 37231 580 24 but but CC 37231 580 25 Paul Paul NNP 37231 580 26 is be VBZ 37231 580 27 represented represent VBN 37231 580 28 as as IN 37231 580 29 receiving receive VBG 37231 580 30 very very RB 37231 580 31 different different JJ 37231 580 32 treatment treatment NN 37231 580 33 . . . 37231 581 1 Felix Felix NNP 37231 581 2 commands command VBZ 37231 581 3 that that WDT 37231 581 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 581 5 own own JJ 37231 581 6 people people NNS 37231 581 7 should should MD 37231 581 8 be be VB 37231 581 9 allowed allow VBN 37231 581 10 to to TO 37231 581 11 come come VB 37231 581 12 and and CC 37231 581 13 minister minister VB 37231 581 14 to to IN 37231 581 15 him -PRON- PRP 37231 581 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 581 17 xxiv xxiv NNP 37231 581 18 . . . 37231 582 1 23 23 CD 37231 582 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 582 3 , , , 37231 582 4 and and CC 37231 582 5 when when WRB 37231 582 6 the the DT 37231 582 7 voyage voyage NN 37231 582 8 is be VBZ 37231 582 9 commenced commence VBN 37231 582 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 582 11 is be VBZ 37231 582 12 said say VBN 37231 582 13 that that IN 37231 582 14 Julius Julius NNP 37231 582 15 , , , 37231 582 16 who who WP 37231 582 17 had have VBD 37231 582 18 charge charge NN 37231 582 19 of of IN 37231 582 20 Paul Paul NNP 37231 582 21 , , , 37231 582 22 treated treat VBD 37231 582 23 him -PRON- PRP 37231 582 24 courteously courteously RB 37231 582 25 , , , 37231 582 26 and and CC 37231 582 27 gave give VBD 37231 582 28 him -PRON- PRP 37231 582 29 liberty liberty NN 37231 582 30 to to TO 37231 582 31 go go VB 37231 582 32 to to TO 37231 582 33 see see VB 37231 582 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 582 35 friends friend NNS 37231 582 36 at at IN 37231 582 37 Sidon Sidon NNP 37231 582 38 ( ( -LRB- 37231 582 39 xxvii xxvii NN 37231 582 40 . . . 37231 583 1 3 3 LS 37231 583 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 583 3 . . . 37231 584 1 At at IN 37231 584 2 Rome Rome NNP 37231 584 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 584 4 was be VBD 37231 584 5 allowed allow VBN 37231 584 6 to to TO 37231 584 7 live live VB 37231 584 8 by by IN 37231 584 9 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 584 10 with with IN 37231 584 11 a a DT 37231 584 12 single single JJ 37231 584 13 soldier soldier NN 37231 584 14 to to TO 37231 584 15 guard guard VB 37231 584 16 him -PRON- PRP 37231 584 17 ( ( -LRB- 37231 584 18 xxviii xxviii NNP 37231 584 19 . . . 37231 585 1 16 16 CD 37231 585 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 585 3 , , , 37231 585 4 and and CC 37231 585 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 585 6 continued continue VBD 37231 585 7 for for IN 37231 585 8 two two CD 37231 585 9 years year NNS 37231 585 10 in in IN 37231 585 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 585 12 own own JJ 37231 585 13 hired hire VBN 37231 585 14 house house NN 37231 585 15 . . . 37231 586 1 { { -LRB- 37231 586 2 lxvii lxvii NN 37231 586 3 } } -RRB- 37231 586 4 These these DT 37231 586 5 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 586 6 are be VBP 37231 586 7 totally totally RB 37231 586 8 different different JJ 37231 586 9 from from IN 37231 586 10 those those DT 37231 586 11 under under IN 37231 586 12 which which WDT 37231 586 13 the the DT 37231 586 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 586 15 of of IN 37231 586 16 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 586 17 are be VBP 37231 586 18 said say VBN 37231 586 19 to to TO 37231 586 20 have have VB 37231 586 21 been be VBN 37231 586 22 written write VBN 37231 586 23 . . . 37231 587 1 " " `` 37231 587 2 But but CC 37231 587 3 the the DT 37231 587 4 most most RBS 37231 587 5 powerful powerful JJ 37231 587 6 testimony testimony NN 37231 587 7 , , , 37231 587 8 " " '' 37231 587 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 587 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 587 11 goes go VBZ 37231 587 12 on on RP 37231 587 13 to to TO 37231 587 14 say say VB 37231 587 15 , , , 37231 587 16 " " '' 37231 587 17 is be VBZ 37231 587 18 derived derive VBN 37231 587 19 from from IN 37231 587 20 the the DT 37231 587 21 representations representation NNS 37231 587 22 of of IN 37231 587 23 a a DT 37231 587 24 heathen heathen NNP 37231 587 25 writer writer NN 37231 587 26 . . . 37231 588 1 " " `` 37231 588 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 588 3 1 1 LS 37231 588 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 588 5 The the DT 37231 588 6 case case NN 37231 588 7 of of IN 37231 588 8 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 588 9 , , , 37231 588 10 to to TO 37231 588 11 which which WDT 37231 588 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 588 13 refers refer VBZ 37231 588 14 , , , 37231 588 15 seems seem VBZ 37231 588 16 to to IN 37231 588 17 me -PRON- PRP 37231 588 18 even even RB 37231 588 19 more more RBR 37231 588 20 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37231 588 21 than than IN 37231 588 22 that that DT 37231 588 23 of of IN 37231 588 24 Paul Paul NNP 37231 588 25 . . . 37231 589 1 Of of IN 37231 589 2 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 589 3 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 589 4 , , , 37231 589 5 historically historically RB 37231 589 6 , , , 37231 589 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 589 8 really really RB 37231 589 9 know know VBP 37231 589 10 little little JJ 37231 589 11 or or CC 37231 589 12 nothing nothing NN 37231 589 13 , , , 37231 589 14 for for IN 37231 589 15 the the DT 37231 589 16 account account NN 37231 589 17 of of IN 37231 589 18 Lucian Lucian NNP 37231 589 19 is be VBZ 37231 589 20 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 589 21 received receive VBN 37231 589 22 as as RB 37231 589 23 serious serious JJ 37231 589 24 by by IN 37231 589 25 any any DT 37231 589 26 one one CD 37231 589 27 . . . 37231 590 1 Lucian lucian JJ 37231 590 2 narrates narrate NNS 37231 590 3 that that IN 37231 590 4 this this DT 37231 590 5 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 590 6 Proteus Proteus NNP 37231 590 7 , , , 37231 590 8 a a DT 37231 590 9 cynic cynic JJ 37231 590 10 philosopher philosopher NN 37231 590 11 , , , 37231 590 12 having have VBG 37231 590 13 been be VBN 37231 590 14 guilty guilty JJ 37231 590 15 of of IN 37231 590 16 parricide parricide JJ 37231 590 17 and and CC 37231 590 18 other other JJ 37231 590 19 crimes crime NNS 37231 590 20 , , , 37231 590 21 found find VBD 37231 590 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 590 23 convenient convenient JJ 37231 590 24 to to TO 37231 590 25 leave leave VB 37231 590 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 590 27 own own JJ 37231 590 28 country country NN 37231 590 29 . . . 37231 591 1 In in IN 37231 591 2 the the DT 37231 591 3 course course NN 37231 591 4 of of IN 37231 591 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 591 6 travels travel NNS 37231 591 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 591 8 fell fall VBD 37231 591 9 in in RP 37231 591 10 with with IN 37231 591 11 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 591 12 and and CC 37231 591 13 learnt learn VBD 37231 591 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 591 15 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 591 16 , , , 37231 591 17 and and CC 37231 591 18 , , , 37231 591 19 according accord VBG 37231 591 20 to to IN 37231 591 21 Lucian Lucian NNP 37231 591 22 , , , 37231 591 23 the the DT 37231 591 24 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 591 25 soon soon RB 37231 591 26 were be VBD 37231 591 27 mere mere JJ 37231 591 28 children child NNS 37231 591 29 in in IN 37231 591 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 591 31 hands hand NNS 37231 591 32 , , , 37231 591 33 so so IN 37231 591 34 that that IN 37231 591 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 591 36 became become VBD 37231 591 37 in in IN 37231 591 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 591 39 own own JJ 37231 591 40 person person NN 37231 591 41 " " '' 37231 591 42 prophet prophet NN 37231 591 43 , , , 37231 591 44 high high JJ 37231 591 45 - - HYPH 37231 591 46 priest priest NN 37231 591 47 , , , 37231 591 48 and and CC 37231 591 49 ruler ruler NN 37231 591 50 of of IN 37231 591 51 a a DT 37231 591 52 synagogue synagogue NN 37231 591 53 , , , 37231 591 54 " " `` 37231 591 55 and and CC 37231 591 56 further far RBR 37231 591 57 " " '' 37231 591 58 they -PRON- PRP 37231 591 59 spoke speak VBD 37231 591 60 of of IN 37231 591 61 him -PRON- PRP 37231 591 62 as as IN 37231 591 63 a a DT 37231 591 64 god god NNP 37231 591 65 , , , 37231 591 66 used use VBD 37231 591 67 him -PRON- PRP 37231 591 68 as as IN 37231 591 69 a a DT 37231 591 70 law law NN 37231 591 71 - - HYPH 37231 591 72 giver giver NN 37231 591 73 , , , 37231 591 74 and and CC 37231 591 75 elected elect VBD 37231 591 76 him -PRON- PRP 37231 591 77 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 591 78 chief chief JJ 37231 591 79 man man NN 37231 591 80 . . . 37231 592 1 " " `` 37231 592 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 592 3 2 2 LS 37231 592 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 592 5 After after IN 37231 592 6 a a DT 37231 592 7 time time NN 37231 592 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 592 9 was be VBD 37231 592 10 put put VBN 37231 592 11 in in IN 37231 592 12 prison prison NN 37231 592 13 for for IN 37231 592 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 592 15 new new JJ 37231 592 16 faith faith NN 37231 592 17 , , , 37231 592 18 which which WDT 37231 592 19 Lucian Lucian NNP 37231 592 20 says say VBZ 37231 592 21 was be VBD 37231 592 22 a a DT 37231 592 23 real real JJ 37231 592 24 service service NN 37231 592 25 to to IN 37231 592 26 him -PRON- PRP 37231 592 27 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 592 28 in in IN 37231 592 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 592 30 impostures imposture NNS 37231 592 31 . . . 37231 593 1 During during IN 37231 593 2 the the DT 37231 593 3 time time NN 37231 593 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 593 5 was be VBD 37231 593 6 in in IN 37231 593 7 prison prison NN 37231 593 8 , , , 37231 593 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 593 10 is be VBZ 37231 593 11 said say VBN 37231 593 12 to to TO 37231 593 13 have have VB 37231 593 14 received receive VBN 37231 593 15 those those DT 37231 593 16 services service NNS 37231 593 17 from from IN 37231 593 18 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 593 19 which which WDT 37231 593 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 593 21 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 593 22 quotes quote VBZ 37231 593 23 . . . 37231 594 1 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 594 2 was be VBD 37231 594 3 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 594 4 set set VBN 37231 594 5 at at IN 37231 594 6 liberty liberty NN 37231 594 7 by by IN 37231 594 8 the the DT 37231 594 9 Governor Governor NNP 37231 594 10 of of IN 37231 594 11 Syria Syria NNP 37231 594 12 , , , 37231 594 13 who who WP 37231 594 14 loved love VBD 37231 594 15 philosophy,(3 philosophy,(3 NN 37231 594 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 594 17 and and CC 37231 594 18 travelled travel VBD 37231 594 19 about about IN 37231 594 20 living live VBG 37231 594 21 in in IN 37231 594 22 great great JJ 37231 594 23 comfort comfort NN 37231 594 24 at at IN 37231 594 25 the the DT 37231 594 26 expense expense NN 37231 594 27 of of IN 37231 594 28 the the DT 37231 594 29 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 594 30 , , , 37231 594 31 until until IN 37231 594 32 at at IN 37231 594 33 last last RB 37231 594 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 594 35 quarrelled quarrel VBD 37231 594 36 in in IN 37231 594 37 consequence consequence NN 37231 594 38 , , , 37231 594 39 Lucian Lucian NNP 37231 594 40 thinks think VBZ 37231 594 41 , , , 37231 594 42 of of IN 37231 594 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 594 44 eating eat VBG 37231 594 45 some some DT 37231 594 46 forbidden forbid VBN 37231 594 47 food food NN 37231 594 48 . . . 37231 595 1 Finally finally RB 37231 595 2 , , , 37231 595 3 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 595 4 ended end VBD 37231 595 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 595 6 career career NN 37231 595 7 by by IN 37231 595 8 throwing throw VBG 37231 595 9 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 595 10 into into IN 37231 595 11 the the DT 37231 595 12 flames flame NNS 37231 595 13 of of IN 37231 595 14 a a DT 37231 595 15 funeral funeral NN 37231 595 16 pile pile NN 37231 595 17 during during IN 37231 595 18 the the DT 37231 595 19 Olympian olympian JJ 37231 595 20 games game NNS 37231 595 21 . . . 37231 596 1 An an DT 37231 596 2 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 596 3 is be VBZ 37231 596 4 said say VBN 37231 596 5 to to TO 37231 596 6 have have VB 37231 596 7 taken take VBN 37231 596 8 { { -LRB- 37231 596 9 lxviii lxviii NN 37231 596 10 } } -RRB- 37231 596 11 place place NN 37231 596 12 at at IN 37231 596 13 the the DT 37231 596 14 time time NN 37231 596 15 ; ; : 37231 596 16 a a DT 37231 596 17 vulture vulture NN 37231 596 18 flew fly VBD 37231 596 19 out out RP 37231 596 20 from from IN 37231 596 21 the the DT 37231 596 22 pile pile NN 37231 596 23 crying cry VBG 37231 596 24 out out RP 37231 596 25 with with IN 37231 596 26 a a DT 37231 596 27 human human JJ 37231 596 28 voice voice NN 37231 596 29 ; ; , 37231 596 30 and and CC 37231 596 31 shortly shortly RB 37231 596 32 after after IN 37231 596 33 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 596 34 rose rise VBD 37231 596 35 again again RB 37231 596 36 and and CC 37231 596 37 appeared appear VBD 37231 596 38 clothed clothe VBN 37231 596 39 in in IN 37231 596 40 white white JJ 37231 596 41 raiment raiment NN 37231 596 42 unhurt unhurt JJ 37231 596 43 by by IN 37231 596 44 the the DT 37231 596 45 fire fire NN 37231 596 46 . . . 37231 597 1 Now now RB 37231 597 2 this this DT 37231 597 3 writing writing NN 37231 597 4 , , , 37231 597 5 of of IN 37231 597 6 which which WDT 37231 597 7 I -PRON- PRP 37231 597 8 have have VBP 37231 597 9 given give VBN 37231 597 10 the the DT 37231 597 11 barest bare JJS 37231 597 12 sketch sketch NN 37231 597 13 , , , 37231 597 14 is be VBZ 37231 597 15 a a DT 37231 597 16 direct direct JJ 37231 597 17 satire satire NN 37231 597 18 upon upon IN 37231 597 19 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 597 20 , , , 37231 597 21 or or CC 37231 597 22 even even RB 37231 597 23 , , , 37231 597 24 as as IN 37231 597 25 Baur baur JJ 37231 597 26 affirms affirm NNS 37231 597 27 , , , 37231 597 28 " " '' 37231 597 29 a a DT 37231 597 30 parody parody NN 37231 597 31 of of IN 37231 597 32 the the DT 37231 597 33 history history NN 37231 597 34 of of IN 37231 597 35 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 597 36 . . . 37231 598 1 " " `` 37231 598 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 598 3 1 1 LS 37231 598 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 598 5 There there EX 37231 598 6 are be VBP 37231 598 7 no no DT 37231 598 8 means means NN 37231 598 9 of of IN 37231 598 10 ascertaining ascertaining NN 37231 598 11 that that IN 37231 598 12 any any DT 37231 598 13 of of IN 37231 598 14 the the DT 37231 598 15 events event NNS 37231 598 16 of of IN 37231 598 17 the the DT 37231 598 18 Christian christian JJ 37231 598 19 career career NN 37231 598 20 of of IN 37231 598 21 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 598 22 were be VBD 37231 598 23 true true JJ 37231 598 24 , , , 37231 598 25 but but CC 37231 598 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 598 27 is be VBZ 37231 598 28 obvious obvious JJ 37231 598 29 that that IN 37231 598 30 , , , 37231 598 31 Lucian Lucian NNP 37231 598 32 's 's POS 37231 598 33 policy policy NN 37231 598 34 was be VBD 37231 598 35 to to TO 37231 598 36 exaggerate exaggerate VB 37231 598 37 the the DT 37231 598 38 facility facility NN 37231 598 39 of of IN 37231 598 40 access access NN 37231 598 41 to to IN 37231 598 42 prisoners prisoner NNS 37231 598 43 , , , 37231 598 44 as as RB 37231 598 45 well well RB 37231 598 46 as as IN 37231 598 47 the the DT 37231 598 48 assiduity assiduity NN 37231 598 49 and and CC 37231 598 50 attention attention NN 37231 598 51 of of IN 37231 598 52 the the DT 37231 598 53 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 598 54 to to IN 37231 598 55 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 598 56 , , , 37231 598 57 the the DT 37231 598 58 ease ease NN 37231 598 59 with with IN 37231 598 60 which which WDT 37231 598 61 they -PRON- PRP 37231 598 62 were be VBD 37231 598 63 duped dupe VBN 37231 598 64 being be VBG 37231 598 65 the the DT 37231 598 66 chief chief JJ 37231 598 67 point point NN 37231 598 68 of of IN 37231 598 69 the the DT 37231 598 70 satire satire NN 37231 598 71 . . . 37231 599 1 There there EX 37231 599 2 is be VBZ 37231 599 3 another another DT 37231 599 4 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 599 5 which which WDT 37231 599 6 must must MD 37231 599 7 be be VB 37231 599 8 mentioned mention VBN 37231 599 9 . . . 37231 600 1 Lucian Lucian NNP 37231 600 2 's 's POS 37231 600 3 account account NN 37231 600 4 of of IN 37231 600 5 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 600 6 is be VBZ 37231 600 7 claimed claim VBN 37231 600 8 by by IN 37231 600 9 supporters supporter NNS 37231 600 10 of of IN 37231 600 11 the the DT 37231 600 12 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 600 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 600 14 as as IN 37231 600 15 evidence evidence NN 37231 600 16 for for IN 37231 600 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 600 18 . . . 37231 601 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 601 2 2 2 LS 37231 601 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 601 4 " " `` 37231 601 5 The the DT 37231 601 6 singular singular JJ 37231 601 7 correspondence correspondence NN 37231 601 8 in in IN 37231 601 9 this this DT 37231 601 10 narrative narrative NN 37231 601 11 with with IN 37231 601 12 the the DT 37231 601 13 account account NN 37231 601 14 of of IN 37231 601 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 601 16 , , , 37231 601 17 combined combine VBN 37231 601 18 with with IN 37231 601 19 some some DT 37231 601 20 striking strike VBG 37231 601 21 coincidences coincidence NNS 37231 601 22 of of IN 37231 601 23 expression expression NN 37231 601 24 , , , 37231 601 25 " " '' 37231 601 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 601 27 argue argue VBP 37231 601 28 , , , 37231 601 29 show show VBP 37231 601 30 " " '' 37231 601 31 that that IN 37231 601 32 Lucian Lucian NNP 37231 601 33 was be VBD 37231 601 34 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 601 35 with with IN 37231 601 36 the the DT 37231 601 37 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 601 38 history history NN 37231 601 39 , , , 37231 601 40 if if IN 37231 601 41 not not RB 37231 601 42 with with IN 37231 601 43 the the DT 37231 601 44 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 601 45 letters letter NNS 37231 601 46 . . . 37231 601 47 " " '' 37231 602 1 These these DT 37231 602 2 are be VBP 37231 602 3 the the DT 37231 602 4 words word NNS 37231 602 5 of of IN 37231 602 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 602 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 602 8 , , , 37231 602 9 although although IN 37231 602 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 602 11 guards guard VBZ 37231 602 12 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 602 13 , , , 37231 602 14 in in IN 37231 602 15 referring refer VBG 37231 602 16 to to IN 37231 602 17 this this DT 37231 602 18 argument argument NN 37231 602 19 , , , 37231 602 20 by by IN 37231 602 21 the the DT 37231 602 22 words word NNS 37231 602 23 : : : 37231 602 24 " " `` 37231 602 25 if if IN 37231 602 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 602 27 be be VB 37231 602 28 true true JJ 37231 602 29 , , , 37231 602 30 " " '' 37231 602 31 and and CC 37231 602 32 does do VBZ 37231 602 33 not not RB 37231 602 34 express express VB 37231 602 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 602 36 own own JJ 37231 602 37 opinion opinion NN 37231 602 38 ; ; : 37231 602 39 but but CC 37231 602 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 602 41 goes go VBZ 37231 602 42 on on RP 37231 602 43 to to TO 37231 602 44 say say VB 37231 602 45 : : : 37231 602 46 " " `` 37231 602 47 At at IN 37231 602 48 all all DT 37231 602 49 events event NNS 37231 602 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 602 51 is be VBZ 37231 602 52 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 602 53 for for IN 37231 602 54 the the DT 37231 602 55 matter matter NN 37231 602 56 in in IN 37231 602 57 hand hand NN 37231 602 58 , , , 37231 602 59 as as IN 37231 602 60 showing show VBG 37231 602 61 that that IN 37231 602 62 Christian christian JJ 37231 602 63 prisoners prisoner NNS 37231 602 64 were be VBD 37231 602 65 treated treat VBN 37231 602 66 in in IN 37231 602 67 the the DT 37231 602 68 very very JJ 37231 602 69 way way NN 37231 602 70 described describe VBN 37231 602 71 in in IN 37231 602 72 these these DT 37231 602 73 epistles epistle NNS 37231 602 74 . . . 37231 603 1 " " `` 37231 603 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 603 3 3 3 LS 37231 603 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 603 5 On on IN 37231 603 6 the the DT 37231 603 7 contrary contrary NN 37231 603 8 , , , 37231 603 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 603 10 is be VBZ 37231 603 11 in in IN 37231 603 12 no no DT 37231 603 13 case case NN 37231 603 14 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 603 15 of of IN 37231 603 16 anything anything NN 37231 603 17 . . . 37231 604 1 If if IN 37231 604 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 604 3 were be VBD 37231 604 4 true true JJ 37231 604 5 that that IN 37231 604 6 Lucian lucian JJ 37231 604 7 employed employ VBN 37231 604 8 , , , 37231 604 9 as as IN 37231 604 10 the the DT 37231 604 11 basis basis NN 37231 604 12 of of IN 37231 604 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 604 14 satire satire NN 37231 604 15 , , , 37231 604 16 the the DT 37231 604 17 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 604 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 604 19 and and CC 37231 604 20 Martyrology Martyrology NNP 37231 604 21 , , , 37231 604 22 { { -LRB- 37231 604 23 lxix lxix NN 37231 604 24 } } -RRB- 37231 604 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 604 26 is be VBZ 37231 604 27 clear clear JJ 37231 604 28 that that IN 37231 604 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 604 30 narrative narrative NN 37231 604 31 can can MD 37231 604 32 not not RB 37231 604 33 be be VB 37231 604 34 used use VBN 37231 604 35 as as IN 37231 604 36 independent independent JJ 37231 604 37 testimony testimony NN 37231 604 38 for for IN 37231 604 39 the the DT 37231 604 40 truth truth NN 37231 604 41 of of IN 37231 604 42 the the DT 37231 604 43 statements statement NNS 37231 604 44 regarding regard VBG 37231 604 45 the the DT 37231 604 46 treatment treatment NN 37231 604 47 of of IN 37231 604 48 Christian christian JJ 37231 604 49 prisoners prisoner NNS 37231 604 50 . . . 37231 605 1 On on IN 37231 605 2 the the DT 37231 605 3 other other JJ 37231 605 4 hand hand NN 37231 605 5 , , , 37231 605 6 as as IN 37231 605 7 this this DT 37231 605 8 can can MD 37231 605 9 not not RB 37231 605 10 be be VB 37231 605 11 shown show VBN 37231 605 12 , , , 37231 605 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 605 14 story story NN 37231 605 15 remains remain VBZ 37231 605 16 a a DT 37231 605 17 mere mere JJ 37231 605 18 satire satire NN 37231 605 19 with with IN 37231 605 20 very very RB 37231 605 21 little little JJ 37231 605 22 historical historical JJ 37231 605 23 value value NN 37231 605 24 . . . 37231 606 1 Apart apart RB 37231 606 2 from from IN 37231 606 3 all all PDT 37231 606 4 this this DT 37231 606 5 , , , 37231 606 6 however however RB 37231 606 7 , , , 37231 606 8 the the DT 37231 606 9 case case NN 37231 606 10 of of IN 37231 606 11 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 606 12 , , , 37231 606 13 a a DT 37231 606 14 man man NN 37231 606 15 confined confine VBN 37231 606 16 in in IN 37231 606 17 prison prison NN 37231 606 18 for for IN 37231 606 19 a a DT 37231 606 20 short short JJ 37231 606 21 time time NN 37231 606 22 , , , 37231 606 23 under under IN 37231 606 24 a a DT 37231 606 25 favourable favourable JJ 37231 606 26 governor governor NN 37231 606 27 , , , 37231 606 28 and and CC 37231 606 29 not not RB 37231 606 30 pursued pursue VBN 37231 606 31 with with IN 37231 606 32 any any DT 37231 606 33 severity severity NN 37231 606 34 , , , 37231 606 35 is be VBZ 37231 606 36 no no DT 37231 606 37 parallel parallel NN 37231 606 38 to to IN 37231 606 39 that that DT 37231 606 40 of of IN 37231 606 41 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 606 42 condemned condemn VBD 37231 606 43 _ _ NNP 37231 606 44 ad ad NN 37231 606 45 bestias bestia NNS 37231 606 46 _ _ NNP 37231 606 47 and and CC 37231 606 48 , , , 37231 606 49 according accord VBG 37231 606 50 to to IN 37231 606 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 606 52 own own JJ 37231 606 53 express express JJ 37231 606 54 statement statement NN 37231 606 55 , , , 37231 606 56 cruelly cruelly RB 37231 606 57 treated treat VBN 37231 606 58 by by IN 37231 606 59 the the DT 37231 606 60 " " `` 37231 606 61 ten ten CD 37231 606 62 leopards leopard NNS 37231 606 63 " " '' 37231 606 64 ; ; : 37231 606 65 and and CC 37231 606 66 further further RB 37231 606 67 the the DT 37231 606 68 liberty liberty NN 37231 606 69 of of IN 37231 606 70 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 606 71 - - NNP 37231 606 72 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 606 73 must must MD 37231 606 74 greatly greatly RB 37231 606 75 have have VB 37231 606 76 exceeded exceed VBN 37231 606 77 all all PDT 37231 606 78 that that WDT 37231 606 79 is be VBZ 37231 606 80 said say VBN 37231 606 81 of of IN 37231 606 82 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 37231 606 83 , , , 37231 606 84 if if IN 37231 606 85 he -PRON- PRP 37231 606 86 was be VBD 37231 606 87 able able JJ 37231 606 88 to to TO 37231 606 89 write write VB 37231 606 90 such such JJ 37231 606 91 epistles epistle NNS 37231 606 92 , , , 37231 606 93 and and CC 37231 606 94 hold hold VB 37231 606 95 such such JJ 37231 606 96 free free JJ 37231 606 97 intercourse intercourse NN 37231 606 98 as as IN 37231 606 99 they -PRON- PRP 37231 606 100 represent represent VBP 37231 606 101 . . . 37231 607 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 607 2 will will MD 37231 607 3 now now RB 37231 607 4 , , , 37231 607 5 in in IN 37231 607 6 the the DT 37231 607 7 briefest brief JJS 37231 607 8 manner manner NN 37231 607 9 possible possible JJ 37231 607 10 , , , 37231 607 11 indicate indicate VBP 37231 607 12 the the DT 37231 607 13 arguments argument NNS 37231 607 14 of of IN 37231 607 15 the the DT 37231 607 16 writers writer NNS 37231 607 17 referred refer VBD 37231 607 18 to to IN 37231 607 19 in in IN 37231 607 20 the the DT 37231 607 21 note(l note(l NN 37231 607 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 607 23 attacked attack VBN 37231 607 24 by by IN 37231 607 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 607 26 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 607 27 , , , 37231 607 28 in in IN 37231 607 29 which which WDT 37231 607 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 607 31 can can MD 37231 607 32 not not RB 37231 607 33 find find VB 37231 607 34 any any DT 37231 607 35 relevancy relevancy NN 37231 607 36 , , , 37231 607 37 but but CC 37231 607 38 which which WDT 37231 607 39 , , , 37231 607 40 in in IN 37231 607 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 607 42 opinion opinion NN 37231 607 43 , , , 37231 607 44 demonstrate demonstrate VBP 37231 607 45 that that IN 37231 607 46 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 607 47 was be VBD 37231 607 48 not not RB 37231 607 49 sent send VBN 37231 607 50 to to IN 37231 607 51 Rome Rome NNP 37231 607 52 at at RB 37231 607 53 all all RB 37231 607 54 , , , 37231 607 55 but but CC 37231 607 56 suffered suffer VBN 37231 607 57 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 607 58 in in IN 37231 607 59 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 607 60 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 607 61 . . . 37231 608 1 The the DT 37231 608 2 reader reader NN 37231 608 3 who who WP 37231 608 4 wishes wish VBZ 37231 608 5 to to TO 37231 608 6 go go VB 37231 608 7 minutely minutely RB 37231 608 8 into into IN 37231 608 9 the the DT 37231 608 10 matter matter NN 37231 608 11 must must MD 37231 608 12 be be VB 37231 608 13 good good JJ 37231 608 14 enough enough RB 37231 608 15 to to TO 37231 608 16 consult consult VB 37231 608 17 the the DT 37231 608 18 writers writer NNS 37231 608 19 there there RB 37231 608 20 cited cite VBD 37231 608 21 , , , 37231 608 22 and and CC 37231 608 23 I -PRON- PRP 37231 608 24 will will MD 37231 608 25 only only RB 37231 608 26 sketch sketch VB 37231 608 27 the the DT 37231 608 28 case case NN 37231 608 29 here here RB 37231 608 30 , , , 37231 608 31 without without IN 37231 608 32 specifically specifically RB 37231 608 33 indicating indicate VBG 37231 608 34 the the DT 37231 608 35 source source NN 37231 608 36 of of IN 37231 608 37 each each DT 37231 608 38 argument argument NN 37231 608 39 . . . 37231 609 1 Where where WRB 37231 609 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 609 3 add add VBP 37231 609 4 any any DT 37231 609 5 particulars particular NNS 37231 609 6 I -PRON- PRP 37231 609 7 will will MD 37231 609 8 , , , 37231 609 9 when when WRB 37231 609 10 necessary necessary JJ 37231 609 11 , , , 37231 609 12 give give VB 37231 609 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 609 14 authorities authority NNS 37231 609 15 . . . 37231 610 1 The the DT 37231 610 2 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 610 3 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 610 4 and and CC 37231 610 5 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 37231 610 6 set set VBP 37231 610 7 forth forth RP 37231 610 8 that that IN 37231 610 9 , , , 37231 610 10 during during IN 37231 610 11 a a DT 37231 610 12 general general JJ 37231 610 13 persecution persecution NN 37231 610 14 of of IN 37231 610 15 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 610 16 , , , 37231 610 17 in in IN 37231 610 18 Syria Syria NNP 37231 610 19 at at IN 37231 610 20 least least JJS 37231 610 21 , , , 37231 610 22 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 610 23 was be VBD 37231 610 24 condemned condemn VBN 37231 610 25 by by IN 37231 610 26 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 610 27 , , , 37231 610 28 when when WRB 37231 610 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 610 30 wintered winter VBD 37231 610 31 in in IN 37231 610 32 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 610 33 during during IN 37231 610 34 the the DT 37231 610 35 Parthian Parthian NNP 37231 610 36 War War NNP 37231 610 37 , , , 37231 610 38 to to TO 37231 610 39 be be VB 37231 610 40 taken take VBN 37231 610 41 to to IN 37231 610 42 Rome Rome NNP 37231 610 43 and and CC 37231 610 44 cast cast VBD 37231 610 45 to to IN 37231 610 46 wild wild JJ 37231 610 47 beasts beast NNS 37231 610 48 in in IN 37231 610 49 the the DT 37231 610 50 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 37231 610 51 . . . 37231 611 1 Instead instead RB 37231 611 2 of of IN 37231 611 3 being be VBG 37231 611 4 sent send VBN 37231 611 5 to to IN 37231 611 6 Rome Rome NNP 37231 611 7 by by IN 37231 611 8 the the DT 37231 611 9 short short NNP 37231 611 10 sea sea NN 37231 611 11 voyage voyage NN 37231 611 12 , , , 37231 611 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 611 14 is be VBZ 37231 611 15 represented represent VBN 37231 611 16 as as IN 37231 611 17 taken take VBN 37231 611 18 thither thither NN 37231 611 19 by by IN 37231 611 20 the the DT 37231 611 21 long long JJ 37231 611 22 and and CC 37231 611 23 incomparably incomparably RB 37231 611 24 more more RBR 37231 611 25 difficult difficult JJ 37231 611 26 land land NN 37231 611 27 route route NN 37231 611 28 . . . 37231 612 1 The the DT 37231 612 2 ten ten CD 37231 612 3 soldiers soldier NNS 37231 612 4 who who WP 37231 612 5 { { -LRB- 37231 612 6 lxx lxx NN 37231 612 7 } } -RRB- 37231 612 8 guard guard NN 37231 612 9 him -PRON- PRP 37231 612 10 are be VBP 37231 612 11 described describe VBN 37231 612 12 by by IN 37231 612 13 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 612 14 as as IN 37231 612 15 only only RB 37231 612 16 rendered render VBN 37231 612 17 more more RBR 37231 612 18 cruel cruel JJ 37231 612 19 by by IN 37231 612 20 the the DT 37231 612 21 presents present NNS 37231 612 22 made make VBN 37231 612 23 to to IN 37231 612 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 612 25 to to TO 37231 612 26 secure secure VB 37231 612 27 kind kind JJ 37231 612 28 treatment treatment NN 37231 612 29 for for IN 37231 612 30 him -PRON- PRP 37231 612 31 , , , 37231 612 32 so so IN 37231 612 33 that that IN 37231 612 34 not not RB 37231 612 35 in in IN 37231 612 36 the the DT 37231 612 37 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 37231 612 38 only only RB 37231 612 39 , , , 37231 612 40 but but CC 37231 612 41 all all PDT 37231 612 42 the the DT 37231 612 43 way way NN 37231 612 44 from from IN 37231 612 45 Syria Syria NNP 37231 612 46 to to IN 37231 612 47 Rome Rome NNP 37231 612 48 , , , 37231 612 49 by by IN 37231 612 50 night night NN 37231 612 51 and and CC 37231 612 52 day day NN 37231 612 53 , , , 37231 612 54 by by IN 37231 612 55 sea sea NN 37231 612 56 and and CC 37231 612 57 land land NN 37231 612 58 , , , 37231 612 59 he -PRON- PRP 37231 612 60 " " `` 37231 612 61 fights fight VBZ 37231 612 62 with with IN 37231 612 63 beasts beast NNS 37231 612 64 . . . 37231 612 65 " " '' 37231 613 1 Notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 37231 613 2 this this DT 37231 613 3 severity severity NN 37231 613 4 , , , 37231 613 5 the the DT 37231 613 6 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 613 7 freely freely RB 37231 613 8 receives receive VBZ 37231 613 9 deputations deputation NNS 37231 613 10 from from IN 37231 613 11 the the DT 37231 613 12 various various JJ 37231 613 13 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 613 14 , , , 37231 613 15 who who WP 37231 613 16 , , , 37231 613 17 far far RB 37231 613 18 from from IN 37231 613 19 being be VBG 37231 613 20 molested molest VBN 37231 613 21 , , , 37231 613 22 are be VBP 37231 613 23 able able JJ 37231 613 24 to to TO 37231 613 25 have have VB 37231 613 26 constant constant JJ 37231 613 27 intercourse intercourse NN 37231 613 28 with with IN 37231 613 29 him -PRON- PRP 37231 613 30 , , , 37231 613 31 and and CC 37231 613 32 even even RB 37231 613 33 to to TO 37231 613 34 accompany accompany VB 37231 613 35 him -PRON- PRP 37231 613 36 in in IN 37231 613 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 613 38 journey journey NN 37231 613 39 . . . 37231 614 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 614 2 not not RB 37231 614 3 only only RB 37231 614 4 converses converse VBZ 37231 614 5 with with IN 37231 614 6 these these DT 37231 614 7 freely freely RB 37231 614 8 , , , 37231 614 9 but but CC 37231 614 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 614 11 is be VBZ 37231 614 12 represented represent VBN 37231 614 13 as as IN 37231 614 14 writing write VBG 37231 614 15 long long RB 37231 614 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 614 17 to to IN 37231 614 18 the the DT 37231 614 19 various various JJ 37231 614 20 Churches church NNS 37231 614 21 which which WDT 37231 614 22 , , , 37231 614 23 instead instead RB 37231 614 24 of of IN 37231 614 25 containing contain VBG 37231 614 26 the the DT 37231 614 27 last last JJ 37231 614 28 exhortations exhortation NNS 37231 614 29 and and CC 37231 614 30 farewell farewell JJ 37231 614 31 words word NNS 37231 614 32 which which WDT 37231 614 33 might may MD 37231 614 34 be be VB 37231 614 35 considered consider VBN 37231 614 36 natural natural JJ 37231 614 37 from from IN 37231 614 38 the the DT 37231 614 39 expectant expectant JJ 37231 614 40 martyr martyr NN 37231 614 41 , , , 37231 614 42 are be VBP 37231 614 43 filled fill VBN 37231 614 44 with with IN 37231 614 45 advanced advanced JJ 37231 614 46 views view NNS 37231 614 47 of of IN 37231 614 48 Church Church NNP 37231 614 49 government government NN 37231 614 50 , , , 37231 614 51 and and CC 37231 614 52 the the DT 37231 614 53 dignity dignity NN 37231 614 54 of of IN 37231 614 55 the the DT 37231 614 56 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 614 57 . . . 37231 615 1 These these DT 37231 615 2 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 615 3 , , , 37231 615 4 at at IN 37231 615 5 the the DT 37231 615 6 outset outset NN 37231 615 7 , , , 37231 615 8 excite excite VB 37231 615 9 grave grave JJ 37231 615 10 suspicions suspicion NNS 37231 615 11 of of IN 37231 615 12 the the DT 37231 615 13 truth truth NN 37231 615 14 of of IN 37231 615 15 the the DT 37231 615 16 documents document NNS 37231 615 17 , , , 37231 615 18 and and CC 37231 615 19 of of IN 37231 615 20 the the DT 37231 615 21 story story NN 37231 615 22 which which WDT 37231 615 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 615 24 set set VBD 37231 615 25 forth forth RB 37231 615 26 . . . 37231 616 1 When when WRB 37231 616 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 616 3 inquire inquire VBP 37231 616 4 whether whether IN 37231 616 5 the the DT 37231 616 6 alleged allege VBN 37231 616 7 facts fact NNS 37231 616 8 of of IN 37231 616 9 the the DT 37231 616 10 case case NN 37231 616 11 are be VBP 37231 616 12 supported support VBN 37231 616 13 by by IN 37231 616 14 historical historical JJ 37231 616 15 data datum NNS 37231 616 16 , , , 37231 616 17 the the DT 37231 616 18 reply reply NN 37231 616 19 is be VBZ 37231 616 20 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 616 21 adverse adverse JJ 37231 616 22 . . . 37231 617 1 All all DT 37231 617 2 that that WDT 37231 617 3 is be VBZ 37231 617 4 known know VBN 37231 617 5 of of IN 37231 617 6 the the DT 37231 617 7 treatment treatment NN 37231 617 8 of of IN 37231 617 9 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 617 10 during during IN 37231 617 11 the the DT 37231 617 12 reign reign NN 37231 617 13 of of IN 37231 617 14 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 617 15 , , , 37231 617 16 as as RB 37231 617 17 well well RB 37231 617 18 as as IN 37231 617 19 of of IN 37231 617 20 the the DT 37231 617 21 character character NN 37231 617 22 of of IN 37231 617 23 the the DT 37231 617 24 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 617 25 , , , 37231 617 26 is be VBZ 37231 617 27 opposed oppose VBN 37231 617 28 to to IN 37231 617 29 the the DT 37231 617 30 supposition supposition NN 37231 617 31 that that IN 37231 617 32 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 617 33 could could MD 37231 617 34 have have VB 37231 617 35 been be VBN 37231 617 36 condemned condemn VBN 37231 617 37 by by IN 37231 617 38 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 617 39 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 617 40 , , , 37231 617 41 or or CC 37231 617 42 even even RB 37231 617 43 by by IN 37231 617 44 a a DT 37231 617 45 provincial provincial JJ 37231 617 46 governor governor NN 37231 617 47 , , , 37231 617 48 to to TO 37231 617 49 be be VB 37231 617 50 taken take VBN 37231 617 51 to to IN 37231 617 52 Rome Rome NNP 37231 617 53 and and CC 37231 617 54 there there RB 37231 617 55 cast cast VBD 37231 617 56 to to IN 37231 617 57 the the DT 37231 617 58 beasts beast NNS 37231 617 59 . . . 37231 618 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 618 2 is be VBZ 37231 618 3 well well RB 37231 618 4 known know VBN 37231 618 5 that that IN 37231 618 6 under under IN 37231 618 7 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 618 8 there there EX 37231 618 9 was be VBD 37231 618 10 no no DT 37231 618 11 general general JJ 37231 618 12 persecution persecution NN 37231 618 13 of of IN 37231 618 14 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 618 15 , , , 37231 618 16 although although IN 37231 618 17 there there EX 37231 618 18 may may MD 37231 618 19 have have VB 37231 618 20 been be VBN 37231 618 21 instances instance NNS 37231 618 22 in in IN 37231 618 23 which which WDT 37231 618 24 prominent prominent JJ 37231 618 25 members member NNS 37231 618 26 of of IN 37231 618 27 the the DT 37231 618 28 body body NN 37231 618 29 were be VBD 37231 618 30 either either CC 37231 618 31 punished punish VBN 37231 618 32 or or CC 37231 618 33 fell fall VBD 37231 618 34 victims victim NNS 37231 618 35 to to IN 37231 618 36 popular popular JJ 37231 618 37 fury fury NN 37231 618 38 and and CC 37231 618 39 superstition superstition NN 37231 618 40 . . . 37231 619 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 619 2 1 1 CD 37231 619 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 619 4 1 1 CD 37231 619 5 Dean Dean NNP 37231 619 6 Milman Milman NNP 37231 619 7 says say VBZ 37231 619 8 : : : 37231 619 9 " " `` 37231 619 10 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 619 11 , , , 37231 619 12 indeed indeed RB 37231 619 13 , , , 37231 619 14 is be VBZ 37231 619 15 absolved absolve VBN 37231 619 16 , , , 37231 619 17 at at IN 37231 619 18 least least JJS 37231 619 19 by by IN 37231 619 20 the the DT 37231 619 21 almost almost RB 37231 619 22 general general JJ 37231 619 23 voice voice NN 37231 619 24 of of IN 37231 619 25 antiquity antiquity NN 37231 619 26 , , , 37231 619 27 from from IN 37231 619 28 the the DT 37231 619 29 crime crime NN 37231 619 30 of of IN 37231 619 31 persecuting persecute VBG 37231 619 32 the the DT 37231 619 33 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 619 34 . . . 37231 619 35 " " '' 37231 620 1 In in IN 37231 620 2 a a DT 37231 620 3 note note NN 37231 620 4 , , , 37231 620 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 620 6 adds add VBZ 37231 620 7 : : : 37231 620 8 " " `` 37231 620 9 Excepting Excepting NNP 37231 620 10 of of IN 37231 620 11 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 620 12 , , , 37231 620 13 probably probably RB 37231 620 14 of of IN 37231 620 15 Simeon Simeon NNP 37231 620 16 of of IN 37231 620 17 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 620 18 , , , 37231 620 19 there there EX 37231 620 20 is be VBZ 37231 620 21 no no DT 37231 620 22 authentic authentic JJ 37231 620 23 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 620 24 in in IN 37231 620 25 the the DT 37231 620 26 reign reign NN 37231 620 27 of of IN 37231 620 28 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 620 29 . . . 37231 620 30 " " '' 37231 621 1 --Hist --Hist NNP 37231 621 2 , , , 37231 621 3 of of IN 37231 621 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 621 5 , , , 37231 621 6 1867 1867 CD 37231 621 7 , , , 37231 621 8 ii ii NNP 37231 621 9 . . . 37231 622 1 p. p. NN 37231 622 2 103 103 CD 37231 622 3 . . . 37231 623 1 { { -LRB- 37231 623 2 lxxi lxxi NN 37231 623 3 } } -RRB- 37231 623 4 An an DT 37231 623 5 instance instance NN 37231 623 6 of of IN 37231 623 7 this this DT 37231 623 8 kind kind NN 37231 623 9 was be VBD 37231 623 10 the the DT 37231 623 11 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 623 12 of of IN 37231 623 13 Simeon Simeon NNP 37231 623 14 , , , 37231 623 15 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 623 16 of of IN 37231 623 17 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 623 18 , , , 37231 623 19 reported report VBN 37231 623 20 by by IN 37231 623 21 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 623 22 . . . 37231 624 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 624 2 was be VBD 37231 624 3 not not RB 37231 624 4 condemned condemn VBN 37231 624 5 _ _ NNP 37231 624 6 ad ad NN 37231 624 7 bestias bestia NNS 37231 624 8 _ _ NNP 37231 624 9 , , , 37231 624 10 however however RB 37231 624 11 , , , 37231 624 12 and and CC 37231 624 13 much much RB 37231 624 14 less less RBR 37231 624 15 deported deported JJ 37231 624 16 to to IN 37231 624 17 Rome Rome NNP 37231 624 18 for for IN 37231 624 19 the the DT 37231 624 20 purpose purpose NN 37231 624 21 . . . 37231 625 1 Why why WRB 37231 625 2 should should MD 37231 625 3 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 625 4 have have VB 37231 625 5 been be VBN 37231 625 6 so so RB 37231 625 7 exceptionally exceptionally RB 37231 625 8 treated treat VBN 37231 625 9 ? ? . 37231 626 1 In in IN 37231 626 2 fact fact NN 37231 626 3 , , , 37231 626 4 even even RB 37231 626 5 during during IN 37231 626 6 the the DT 37231 626 7 persecutions persecution NNS 37231 626 8 under under IN 37231 626 9 Marcus Marcus NNP 37231 626 10 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 626 11 , , , 37231 626 12 although although IN 37231 626 13 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 626 14 in in IN 37231 626 15 Syria Syria NNP 37231 626 16 were be VBD 37231 626 17 frequently frequently RB 37231 626 18 enough enough RB 37231 626 19 cast cast VBN 37231 626 20 to to IN 37231 626 21 the the DT 37231 626 22 beasts beast NNS 37231 626 23 , , , 37231 626 24 there there EX 37231 626 25 is be VBZ 37231 626 26 no no DT 37231 626 27 instance instance NN 37231 626 28 recorded record VBN 37231 626 29 in in IN 37231 626 30 which which WDT 37231 626 31 any any DT 37231 626 32 one one CD 37231 626 33 condemned condemn VBN 37231 626 34 to to IN 37231 626 35 this this DT 37231 626 36 fate fate NN 37231 626 37 was be VBD 37231 626 38 sent send VBN 37231 626 39 to to IN 37231 626 40 Rome Rome NNP 37231 626 41 . . . 37231 627 1 Such such PDT 37231 627 2 a a DT 37231 627 3 sentence sentence NN 37231 627 4 is be VBZ 37231 627 5 quite quite RB 37231 627 6 at at IN 37231 627 7 variance variance NN 37231 627 8 with with IN 37231 627 9 the the DT 37231 627 10 clement clement JJ 37231 627 11 character character NN 37231 627 12 of of IN 37231 627 13 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 627 14 and and CC 37231 627 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 627 16 principles principle NNS 37231 627 17 of of IN 37231 627 18 government government NN 37231 627 19 . . . 37231 628 1 Neander neander NN 37231 628 2 , , , 37231 628 3 in in IN 37231 628 4 a a DT 37231 628 5 passage passage NN 37231 628 6 quoted quote VBN 37231 628 7 by by IN 37231 628 8 Baur Baur NNP 37231 628 9 , , , 37231 628 10 says say VBZ 37231 628 11 : : : 37231 628 12 " " `` 37231 628 13 As as IN 37231 628 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 628 15 ( ( -LRB- 37231 628 16 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 628 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 628 18 , , , 37231 628 19 like like IN 37231 628 20 Pliny Pliny NNP 37231 628 21 , , , 37231 628 22 considered consider VBN 37231 628 23 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 628 24 mere mere JJ 37231 628 25 fanaticism fanaticism NN 37231 628 26 , , , 37231 628 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 628 28 also also RB 37231 628 29 probably probably RB 37231 628 30 thought think VBD 37231 628 31 that that IN 37231 628 32 if if IN 37231 628 33 severity severity NN 37231 628 34 were be VBD 37231 628 35 combined combine VBN 37231 628 36 with with IN 37231 628 37 clemency clemency NN 37231 628 38 , , , 37231 628 39 if if IN 37231 628 40 too too RB 37231 628 41 much much JJ 37231 628 42 noise noise NN 37231 628 43 were be VBD 37231 628 44 not not RB 37231 628 45 made make VBN 37231 628 46 about about IN 37231 628 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 628 48 , , , 37231 628 49 the the DT 37231 628 50 open open JJ 37231 628 51 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 628 52 not not RB 37231 628 53 left leave VBN 37231 628 54 unpunished unpunished JJ 37231 628 55 but but CC 37231 628 56 also also RB 37231 628 57 minds mind NNS 37231 628 58 not not RB 37231 628 59 stirred stir VBN 37231 628 60 up up RP 37231 628 61 by by IN 37231 628 62 persecution persecution NN 37231 628 63 , , , 37231 628 64 the the DT 37231 628 65 fanatical fanatical JJ 37231 628 66 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 37231 628 67 would would MD 37231 628 68 most most RBS 37231 628 69 easily easily RB 37231 628 70 cool cool JJ 37231 628 71 down down RP 37231 628 72 , , , 37231 628 73 and and CC 37231 628 74 the the DT 37231 628 75 matter matter NN 37231 628 76 by by IN 37231 628 77 degrees degree NNS 37231 628 78 come come VBP 37231 628 79 to to IN 37231 628 80 an an DT 37231 628 81 end end NN 37231 628 82 . . . 37231 629 1 " " `` 37231 629 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 629 3 1 1 LS 37231 629 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 629 5 This this DT 37231 629 6 was be VBD 37231 629 7 certainly certainly RB 37231 629 8 the the DT 37231 629 9 policy policy NN 37231 629 10 which which WDT 37231 629 11 mainly mainly RB 37231 629 12 characterized characterize VBD 37231 629 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 629 14 reign reign NN 37231 629 15 . . . 37231 630 1 Now now RB 37231 630 2 not not RB 37231 630 3 only only RB 37231 630 4 would would MD 37231 630 5 such such PDT 37231 630 6 a a DT 37231 630 7 severe severe JJ 37231 630 8 sentence sentence NN 37231 630 9 have have VBP 37231 630 10 been be VBN 37231 630 11 contrary contrary JJ 37231 630 12 to to IN 37231 630 13 such such JJ 37231 630 14 principles principle NNS 37231 630 15 , , , 37231 630 16 but but CC 37231 630 17 the the DT 37231 630 18 agitation agitation NN 37231 630 19 excited excite VBN 37231 630 20 would would MD 37231 630 21 have have VB 37231 630 22 been be VBN 37231 630 23 enormously enormously RB 37231 630 24 increased increase VBN 37231 630 25 by by IN 37231 630 26 sending send VBG 37231 630 27 the the DT 37231 630 28 martyr martyr NN 37231 630 29 a a DT 37231 630 30 long long JJ 37231 630 31 journey journey NN 37231 630 32 by by IN 37231 630 33 land land NN 37231 630 34 through through IN 37231 630 35 Asia Asia NNP 37231 630 36 , , , 37231 630 37 and and CC 37231 630 38 allowing allow VBG 37231 630 39 him -PRON- PRP 37231 630 40 to to TO 37231 630 41 pass pass VB 37231 630 42 through through RP 37231 630 43 some some DT 37231 630 44 of of IN 37231 630 45 the the DT 37231 630 46 principal principal JJ 37231 630 47 cities city NNS 37231 630 48 , , , 37231 630 49 hold hold VB 37231 630 50 constant constant JJ 37231 630 51 intercourse intercourse NN 37231 630 52 with with IN 37231 630 53 the the DT 37231 630 54 various various JJ 37231 630 55 Christian christian JJ 37231 630 56 communities community NNS 37231 630 57 , , , 37231 630 58 and and CC 37231 630 59 address address NN 37231 630 60 long long JJ 37231 630 61 epistles epistle NNS 37231 630 62 to to IN 37231 630 63 them -PRON- PRP 37231 630 64 . . . 37231 631 1 With with IN 37231 631 2 the the DT 37231 631 3 fervid fervid JJ 37231 631 4 desire desire NN 37231 631 5 for for IN 37231 631 6 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 631 7 then then RB 37231 631 8 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 631 9 , , , 37231 631 10 such such PDT 37231 631 11 a a DT 37231 631 12 journey journey NN 37231 631 13 would would MD 37231 631 14 have have VB 37231 631 15 been be VBN 37231 631 16 a a DT 37231 631 17 triumphal triumphal NN 37231 631 18 progress progress NN 37231 631 19 , , , 37231 631 20 spreading spread VBG 37231 631 21 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 631 22 excitement excitement NN 37231 631 23 and and CC 37231 631 24 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 37231 631 25 . . . 37231 632 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 632 2 may may MD 37231 632 3 not not RB 37231 632 4 be be VB 37231 632 5 out out IN 37231 632 6 of of IN 37231 632 7 place place NN 37231 632 8 , , , 37231 632 9 as as IN 37231 632 10 an an DT 37231 632 11 indication indication NN 37231 632 12 of of IN 37231 632 13 the the DT 37231 632 14 results result NNS 37231 632 15 of of IN 37231 632 16 impartial impartial JJ 37231 632 17 examination examination NN 37231 632 18 , , , 37231 632 19 to to IN 37231 632 20 { { -LRB- 37231 632 21 lxxii lxxii NN 37231 632 22 } } -RRB- 37231 632 23 point point NN 37231 632 24 out out RP 37231 632 25 that that IN 37231 632 26 Neander Neander NNP 37231 632 27 's 's POS 37231 632 28 inability inability NN 37231 632 29 to to TO 37231 632 30 accept accept VB 37231 632 31 the the DT 37231 632 32 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 632 33 epistles epistle NNS 37231 632 34 largely largely RB 37231 632 35 rests rest VBZ 37231 632 36 on on IN 37231 632 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 632 38 disbelief disbelief NN 37231 632 39 of of IN 37231 632 40 the the DT 37231 632 41 whole whole JJ 37231 632 42 tradition tradition NN 37231 632 43 of of IN 37231 632 44 this this DT 37231 632 45 sentence sentence NN 37231 632 46 and and CC 37231 632 47 martyr martyr NN 37231 632 48 - - HYPH 37231 632 49 journey journey NN 37231 632 50 . . . 37231 633 1 " " `` 37231 633 2 We -PRON- PRP 37231 633 3 do do VBP 37231 633 4 not not RB 37231 633 5 recognize recognize VB 37231 633 6 the the DT 37231 633 7 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 633 8 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 633 9 in in IN 37231 633 10 this this DT 37231 633 11 narrative narrative NN 37231 633 12 , , , 37231 633 13 " " '' 37231 633 14 ( ( -LRB- 37231 633 15 the the DT 37231 633 16 martyrology martyrology NN 37231 633 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 633 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 633 19 says say VBZ 37231 633 20 , , , 37231 633 21 " " `` 37231 633 22 therefore therefore RB 37231 633 23 can can MD 37231 633 24 not not RB 37231 633 25 but but RB 37231 633 26 doubt doubt VB 37231 633 27 every every DT 37231 633 28 thing thing NN 37231 633 29 which which WDT 37231 633 30 is be VBZ 37231 633 31 related relate VBN 37231 633 32 by by IN 37231 633 33 this this DT 37231 633 34 document document NN 37231 633 35 , , , 37231 633 36 as as RB 37231 633 37 well well RB 37231 633 38 as as IN 37231 633 39 that that DT 37231 633 40 , , , 37231 633 41 during during IN 37231 633 42 this this DT 37231 633 43 reign reign NN 37231 633 44 , , , 37231 633 45 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 633 46 can can MD 37231 633 47 have have VB 37231 633 48 been be VBN 37231 633 49 cast cast VBN 37231 633 50 to to IN 37231 633 51 the the DT 37231 633 52 wild wild JJ 37231 633 53 beasts beast NNS 37231 633 54 . . . 37231 634 1 " " `` 37231 634 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 634 3 1 1 LS 37231 634 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 634 5 If if IN 37231 634 6 , , , 37231 634 7 for for IN 37231 634 8 a a DT 37231 634 9 moment moment NN 37231 634 10 , , , 37231 634 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 634 12 suppose suppose VBP 37231 634 13 that that IN 37231 634 14 , , , 37231 634 15 instead instead RB 37231 634 16 of of IN 37231 634 17 being be VBG 37231 634 18 condemned condemn VBN 37231 634 19 by by IN 37231 634 20 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 634 21 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 634 22 , , , 37231 634 23 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 634 24 received receive VBD 37231 634 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 634 26 sentence sentence NN 37231 634 27 from from IN 37231 634 28 a a DT 37231 634 29 provincial provincial JJ 37231 634 30 governor governor NN 37231 634 31 , , , 37231 634 32 the the DT 37231 634 33 story story NN 37231 634 34 does do VBZ 37231 634 35 not not RB 37231 634 36 gain gain VB 37231 634 37 greater great JJR 37231 634 38 probability probability NN 37231 634 39 . . . 37231 635 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 635 2 is be VBZ 37231 635 3 not not RB 37231 635 4 credible credible JJ 37231 635 5 that that IN 37231 635 6 such such PDT 37231 635 7 an an DT 37231 635 8 official official NN 37231 635 9 would would MD 37231 635 10 have have VB 37231 635 11 ventured venture VBN 37231 635 12 to to TO 37231 635 13 act act VB 37231 635 14 so so RB 37231 635 15 much much RB 37231 635 16 in in IN 37231 635 17 opposition opposition NN 37231 635 18 to to IN 37231 635 19 the the DT 37231 635 20 spirit spirit NN 37231 635 21 of of IN 37231 635 22 the the DT 37231 635 23 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 635 24 's 's POS 37231 635 25 government government NN 37231 635 26 Besides besides IN 37231 635 27 , , , 37231 635 28 if if IN 37231 635 29 such such PDT 37231 635 30 a a DT 37231 635 31 governor governor NN 37231 635 32 did do VBD 37231 635 33 pronounce pronounce NN 37231 635 34 so so RB 37231 635 35 severe severe JJ 37231 635 36 a a DT 37231 635 37 sentence sentence NN 37231 635 38 , , , 37231 635 39 why why WRB 37231 635 40 did do VBD 37231 635 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 635 42 not not RB 37231 635 43 execute execute VB 37231 635 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 635 45 in in IN 37231 635 46 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 635 47 ? ? . 37231 636 1 Why why WRB 37231 636 2 send send VB 37231 636 3 the the DT 37231 636 4 prisoner prisoner NN 37231 636 5 to to IN 37231 636 6 Rome Rome NNP 37231 636 7 ? ? . 37231 637 1 By by IN 37231 637 2 doing do VBG 37231 637 3 so so RB 37231 637 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 637 5 made make VBD 37231 637 6 all all PDT 37231 637 7 the the DT 37231 637 8 more more RBR 37231 637 9 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 37231 637 10 a a DT 37231 637 11 severity severity NN 37231 637 12 which which WDT 37231 637 13 was be VBD 37231 637 14 not not RB 37231 637 15 likely likely JJ 37231 637 16 to to TO 37231 637 17 be be VB 37231 637 18 pleasing pleasing JJ 37231 637 19 to to IN 37231 637 20 the the DT 37231 637 21 clement clement JJ 37231 637 22 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 637 23 . . . 37231 638 1 The the DT 37231 638 2 cruelty cruelty NN 37231 638 3 which which WDT 37231 638 4 dictated dictate VBD 37231 638 5 a a DT 37231 638 6 condemnation condemnation NN 37231 638 7 _ _ NNP 37231 638 8 ad ad NN 37231 638 9 bestias bestia NNS 37231 638 10 _ _ NNP 37231 638 11 would would MD 37231 638 12 have have VB 37231 638 13 been be VBN 37231 638 14 more more RBR 37231 638 15 gratified gratified JJ 37231 638 16 by by IN 37231 638 17 execution execution NN 37231 638 18 on on IN 37231 638 19 the the DT 37231 638 20 spot spot NN 37231 638 21 , , , 37231 638 22 and and CC 37231 638 23 there there EX 37231 638 24 is be VBZ 37231 638 25 besides besides IN 37231 638 26 no no DT 37231 638 27 instance instance NN 37231 638 28 known know VBN 37231 638 29 , , , 37231 638 30 even even RB 37231 638 31 during during IN 37231 638 32 the the DT 37231 638 33 following follow VBG 37231 638 34 general general JJ 37231 638 35 persecution persecution NN 37231 638 36 , , , 37231 638 37 of of IN 37231 638 38 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 638 39 being be VBG 37231 638 40 sent send VBN 37231 638 41 for for IN 37231 638 42 execution execution NN 37231 638 43 in in IN 37231 638 44 Rome Rome NNP 37231 638 45 . . . 37231 639 1 The the DT 37231 639 2 transport transport NN 37231 639 3 to to IN 37231 639 4 Rome Rome NNP 37231 639 5 is be VBZ 37231 639 6 in in IN 37231 639 7 no no DT 37231 639 8 case case NN 37231 639 9 credible credible JJ 37231 639 10 , , , 37231 639 11 and and CC 37231 639 12 the the DT 37231 639 13 utmost utmost JJ 37231 639 14 that that WDT 37231 639 15 can can MD 37231 639 16 be be VB 37231 639 17 admitted admit VBN 37231 639 18 is be VBZ 37231 639 19 , , , 37231 639 20 that that IN 37231 639 21 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 639 22 , , , 37231 639 23 like like IN 37231 639 24 Simeon Simeon NNP 37231 639 25 of of IN 37231 639 26 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 639 27 , , , 37231 639 28 may may MD 37231 639 29 have have VB 37231 639 30 been be VBN 37231 639 31 condemned condemn VBN 37231 639 32 to to IN 37231 639 33 death death NN 37231 639 34 during during IN 37231 639 35 this this DT 37231 639 36 reign reign NN 37231 639 37 , , , 37231 639 38 more more RBR 37231 639 39 especially especially RB 37231 639 40 if if IN 37231 639 41 the the DT 37231 639 42 event event NN 37231 639 43 be be VB 37231 639 44 associated associate VBN 37231 639 45 with with IN 37231 639 46 some some DT 37231 639 47 sudden sudden JJ 37231 639 48 outbreak outbreak NN 37231 639 49 of of IN 37231 639 50 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 639 51 fury fury NN 37231 639 52 against against IN 37231 639 53 the the DT 37231 639 54 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 639 55 , , , 37231 639 56 to to TO 37231 639 57 which which WDT 37231 639 58 the the DT 37231 639 59 martyr martyr NN 37231 639 60 may may MD 37231 639 61 at at IN 37231 639 62 once once RB 37231 639 63 have have VBP 37231 639 64 fallen fall VBN 37231 639 65 a a DT 37231 639 66 victim victim NN 37231 639 67 . . . 37231 640 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 640 2 are be VBP 37231 640 3 not not RB 37231 640 4 without without IN 37231 640 5 indications indication NNS 37231 640 6 of of IN 37231 640 7 such such PDT 37231 640 8 a a DT 37231 640 9 cause cause NN 37231 640 10 operating operate VBG 37231 640 11 in in IN 37231 640 12 the the DT 37231 640 13 case case NN 37231 640 14 of of IN 37231 640 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 640 16 . . . 37231 641 1 { { -LRB- 37231 641 2 lxxiii lxxiii NN 37231 641 3 } } -RRB- 37231 641 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 641 5 is be VBZ 37231 641 6 generally generally RB 37231 641 7 admitted admit VBN 37231 641 8 that that IN 37231 641 9 the the DT 37231 641 10 date date NN 37231 641 11 of of IN 37231 641 12 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 641 13 's 's POS 37231 641 14 visit visit NN 37231 641 15 to to IN 37231 641 16 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 641 17 is be VBZ 37231 641 18 a.d a.d NNP 37231 641 19 . . NNP 37231 641 20 115 115 CD 37231 641 21 , , , 37231 641 22 when when WRB 37231 641 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 641 24 wintered winter VBD 37231 641 25 there there RB 37231 641 26 during during IN 37231 641 27 the the DT 37231 641 28 Parthian Parthian NNP 37231 641 29 War War NNP 37231 641 30 . . . 37231 642 1 An an DT 37231 642 2 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 642 3 occurred occur VBD 37231 642 4 on on IN 37231 642 5 the the DT 37231 642 6 13th 13th JJ 37231 642 7 December December NNP 37231 642 8 of of IN 37231 642 9 that that DT 37231 642 10 year year NN 37231 642 11 , , , 37231 642 12 which which WDT 37231 642 13 was be VBD 37231 642 14 well well RB 37231 642 15 calculated calculate VBN 37231 642 16 to to TO 37231 642 17 excite excite VB 37231 642 18 popular popular JJ 37231 642 19 superstition superstition NN 37231 642 20 . . . 37231 643 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 643 2 may may MD 37231 643 3 not not RB 37231 643 4 be be VB 37231 643 5 out out IN 37231 643 6 of of IN 37231 643 7 place place NN 37231 643 8 to to TO 37231 643 9 quote quote VB 37231 643 10 here here RB 37231 643 11 the the DT 37231 643 12 account account NN 37231 643 13 of of IN 37231 643 14 the the DT 37231 643 15 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 643 16 given give VBN 37231 643 17 by by IN 37231 643 18 Dean Dean NNP 37231 643 19 Milmau Milmau NNP 37231 643 20 , , , 37231 643 21 who who WP 37231 643 22 , , , 37231 643 23 although although IN 37231 643 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 643 25 mentions mention VBZ 37231 643 26 a a DT 37231 643 27 different different JJ 37231 643 28 date date NN 37231 643 29 , , , 37231 643 30 and and CC 37231 643 31 adheres adhere VBZ 37231 643 32 to to IN 37231 643 33 the the DT 37231 643 34 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 643 35 in in IN 37231 643 36 Rome Rome NNP 37231 643 37 , , , 37231 643 38 still still RB 37231 643 39 associates associate VBZ 37231 643 40 the the DT 37231 643 41 condemnation condemnation NN 37231 643 42 of of IN 37231 643 43 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 643 44 with with IN 37231 643 45 the the DT 37231 643 46 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 643 47 . . . 37231 644 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 644 2 says say VBZ 37231 644 3 : : : 37231 644 4 " " `` 37231 644 5 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 644 6 , , , 37231 644 7 at at IN 37231 644 8 that that DT 37231 644 9 time time NN 37231 644 10 there there EX 37231 644 11 were be VBD 37231 644 12 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 644 13 which which WDT 37231 644 14 account account VBP 37231 644 15 with with IN 37231 644 16 singular singular JJ 37231 644 17 likelihood likelihood NN 37231 644 18 for for IN 37231 644 19 that that DT 37231 644 20 sudden sudden JJ 37231 644 21 outburst outburst NN 37231 644 22 of of IN 37231 644 23 persecution persecution NN 37231 644 24 in in IN 37231 644 25 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 644 26 .... .... . 37231 644 27 At at IN 37231 644 28 this this DT 37231 644 29 very very JJ 37231 644 30 time time NN 37231 644 31 an an DT 37231 644 32 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 644 33 , , , 37231 644 34 more more JJR 37231 644 35 than than IN 37231 644 36 usually usually RB 37231 644 37 terrible terrible JJ 37231 644 38 and and CC 37231 644 39 destructive destructive JJ 37231 644 40 , , , 37231 644 41 shook shake VBD 37231 644 42 the the DT 37231 644 43 cities city NNS 37231 644 44 of of IN 37231 644 45 the the DT 37231 644 46 East East NNP 37231 644 47 . . . 37231 645 1 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 645 2 suffered suffer VBD 37231 645 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 645 4 most most RBS 37231 645 5 appalling appalling JJ 37231 645 6 ravages ravage NNS 37231 645 7 -- -- : 37231 645 8 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 645 9 , , , 37231 645 10 crowded crowd VBD 37231 645 11 with with IN 37231 645 12 the the DT 37231 645 13 legionaries legionary NNS 37231 645 14 prepared prepare VBN 37231 645 15 for for IN 37231 645 16 the the DT 37231 645 17 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 645 18 's 's POS 37231 645 19 invasion invasion NN 37231 645 20 of of IN 37231 645 21 the the DT 37231 645 22 East East NNP 37231 645 23 , , , 37231 645 24 with with IN 37231 645 25 ambassadors ambassador NNS 37231 645 26 and and CC 37231 645 27 tributary tributary JJ 37231 645 28 kings king NNS 37231 645 29 from from IN 37231 645 30 all all DT 37231 645 31 parts part NNS 37231 645 32 of of IN 37231 645 33 the the DT 37231 645 34 East East NNP 37231 645 35 . . . 37231 646 1 The the DT 37231 646 2 city city NN 37231 646 3 shook shake VBD 37231 646 4 through through IN 37231 646 5 all all DT 37231 646 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 646 7 streets street NNS 37231 646 8 ; ; : 37231 646 9 houses house NNS 37231 646 10 , , , 37231 646 11 palaces palace NNS 37231 646 12 , , , 37231 646 13 theatres theatre NNS 37231 646 14 , , , 37231 646 15 temples temple NNS 37231 646 16 fell fall VBD 37231 646 17 crashing crash VBG 37231 646 18 down down RP 37231 646 19 . . . 37231 647 1 Many many JJ 37231 647 2 were be VBD 37231 647 3 killed kill VBN 37231 647 4 : : : 37231 647 5 the the DT 37231 647 6 Consul Consul NNP 37231 647 7 Pedo Pedo NNP 37231 647 8 died die VBD 37231 647 9 of of IN 37231 647 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 647 11 hurts hurt NNS 37231 647 12 . . . 37231 648 1 The the DT 37231 648 2 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 648 3 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 648 4 hardly hardly RB 37231 648 5 escaped escape VBD 37231 648 6 through through IN 37231 648 7 a a DT 37231 648 8 window window NN 37231 648 9 , , , 37231 648 10 and and CC 37231 648 11 took take VBD 37231 648 12 refuge refuge NN 37231 648 13 in in IN 37231 648 14 the the DT 37231 648 15 Circus Circus NNP 37231 648 16 , , , 37231 648 17 where where WRB 37231 648 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 648 19 passed pass VBD 37231 648 20 some some DT 37231 648 21 days day NNS 37231 648 22 in in IN 37231 648 23 the the DT 37231 648 24 open open JJ 37231 648 25 air air NN 37231 648 26 . . . 37231 649 1 Whence whence UH 37231 649 2 this this DT 37231 649 3 terrible terrible JJ 37231 649 4 blow blow NN 37231 649 5 but but CC 37231 649 6 from from IN 37231 649 7 the the DT 37231 649 8 wrath wrath NN 37231 649 9 of of IN 37231 649 10 the the DT 37231 649 11 Gods Gods NNPS 37231 649 12 , , , 37231 649 13 who who WP 37231 649 14 must must MD 37231 649 15 be be VB 37231 649 16 appeased appease VBN 37231 649 17 by by IN 37231 649 18 unusual unusual JJ 37231 649 19 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 37231 649 20 ? ? . 37231 650 1 This this DT 37231 650 2 was be VBD 37231 650 3 towards towards IN 37231 650 4 the the DT 37231 650 5 end end NN 37231 650 6 of of IN 37231 650 7 January January NNP 37231 650 8 ; ; : 37231 650 9 early early RB 37231 650 10 in in IN 37231 650 11 February February NNP 37231 650 12 the the DT 37231 650 13 Christian Christian NNP 37231 650 14 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 650 15 , , , 37231 650 16 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 650 17 , , , 37231 650 18 was be VBD 37231 650 19 arrested arrest VBN 37231 650 20 . . . 37231 651 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 651 2 know know VBP 37231 651 3 how how WRB 37231 651 4 , , , 37231 651 5 during during IN 37231 651 6 this this DT 37231 651 7 century century NN 37231 651 8 , , , 37231 651 9 at at IN 37231 651 10 every every DT 37231 651 11 period period NN 37231 651 12 of of IN 37231 651 13 public public JJ 37231 651 14 calamity calamity NN 37231 651 15 , , , 37231 651 16 whatever whatever WDT 37231 651 17 that that DT 37231 651 18 calamity calamity NN 37231 651 19 might may MD 37231 651 20 be be VB 37231 651 21 , , , 37231 651 22 the the DT 37231 651 23 cry cry NN 37231 651 24 of of IN 37231 651 25 the the DT 37231 651 26 panic panic NN 37231 651 27 - - HYPH 37231 651 28 stricken stricken VBN 37231 651 29 Heathens Heathens NNPS 37231 651 30 was be VBD 37231 651 31 , , , 37231 651 32 ' ' '' 37231 651 33 The the DT 37231 651 34 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 651 35 to to IN 37231 651 36 the the DT 37231 651 37 lions lion NNS 37231 651 38 ! ! . 37231 651 39 ' ' '' 37231 652 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 652 2 may may MD 37231 652 3 be be VB 37231 652 4 that that IN 37231 652 5 , , , 37231 652 6 in in IN 37231 652 7 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 652 8 's 's POS 37231 652 9 humanity humanity NN 37231 652 10 , , , 37231 652 11 in in IN 37231 652 12 order order NN 37231 652 13 to to TO 37231 652 14 prevent prevent VB 37231 652 15 a a DT 37231 652 16 general general JJ 37231 652 17 massacre massacre NN 37231 652 18 by by IN 37231 652 19 the the DT 37231 652 20 infuriated infuriate VBN 37231 652 21 populace populace NN 37231 652 22 , , , 37231 652 23 or or CC 37231 652 24 to to TO 37231 652 25 give give VB 37231 652 26 greater great JJR 37231 652 27 solemnity solemnity NN 37231 652 28 to to IN 37231 652 29 the the DT 37231 652 30 sacrifice sacrifice NN 37231 652 31 , , , 37231 652 32 the the DT 37231 652 33 execution execution NN 37231 652 34 was be VBD 37231 652 35 ordered order VBN 37231 652 36 to to IN 37231 652 37 { { -LRB- 37231 652 38 lxxiv lxxiv NN 37231 652 39 } } -RRB- 37231 652 40 take take VB 37231 652 41 place place NN 37231 652 42 , , , 37231 652 43 not not RB 37231 652 44 in in IN 37231 652 45 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 652 46 , , , 37231 652 47 but but CC 37231 652 48 in in IN 37231 652 49 Rome Rome NNP 37231 652 50 . . . 37231 653 1 " " `` 37231 653 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 653 3 1 1 LS 37231 653 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 653 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 653 6 contend contend VBP 37231 653 7 that that IN 37231 653 8 these these DT 37231 653 9 reasons reason NNS 37231 653 10 , , , 37231 653 11 on on IN 37231 653 12 the the DT 37231 653 13 contrary contrary NN 37231 653 14 , , , 37231 653 15 render render VB 37231 653 16 execution execution NN 37231 653 17 in in IN 37231 653 18 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 653 19 infinitely infinitely RB 37231 653 20 more more RBR 37231 653 21 probable probable JJ 37231 653 22 . . . 37231 654 1 To to TO 37231 654 2 continue continue VB 37231 654 3 , , , 37231 654 4 however however RB 37231 654 5 : : : 37231 654 6 the the DT 37231 654 7 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 654 8 occurred occur VBD 37231 654 9 on on IN 37231 654 10 the the DT 37231 654 11 13th 13th NN 37231 654 12 , , , 37231 654 13 and and CC 37231 654 14 the the DT 37231 654 15 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 654 16 of of IN 37231 654 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 654 18 took take VBD 37231 654 19 place place NN 37231 654 20 on on IN 37231 654 21 the the DT 37231 654 22 20th 20th JJ 37231 654 23 December December NNP 37231 654 24 , , , 37231 654 25 just just RB 37231 654 26 a a DT 37231 654 27 week week NN 37231 654 28 after after IN 37231 654 29 the the DT 37231 654 30 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 654 31 . . . 37231 655 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 655 2 remains remain NNS 37231 655 3 , , , 37231 655 4 as as IN 37231 655 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 655 6 know know VBP 37231 655 7 from from IN 37231 655 8 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 37231 655 9 and and CC 37231 655 10 others other NNS 37231 655 11 , , , 37231 655 12 were be VBD 37231 655 13 , , , 37231 655 14 as as IN 37231 655 15 an an DT 37231 655 16 actual actual JJ 37231 655 17 fact fact NN 37231 655 18 , , , 37231 655 19 interred inter VBN 37231 655 20 at at IN 37231 655 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 655 22 . . . 37231 656 1 The the DT 37231 656 2 natural natural JJ 37231 656 3 inference inference NN 37231 656 4 is be VBZ 37231 656 5 that that IN 37231 656 6 the the DT 37231 656 7 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 656 8 , , , 37231 656 9 the the DT 37231 656 10 only only JJ 37231 656 11 part part NN 37231 656 12 of of IN 37231 656 13 the the DT 37231 656 14 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 656 15 story story NN 37231 656 16 which which WDT 37231 656 17 is be VBZ 37231 656 18 credible credible JJ 37231 656 19 , , , 37231 656 20 occurred occur VBD 37231 656 21 not not RB 37231 656 22 in in IN 37231 656 23 Rome Rome NNP 37231 656 24 but but CC 37231 656 25 in in IN 37231 656 26 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 656 27 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 656 28 , , , 37231 656 29 in in IN 37231 656 30 consequence consequence NN 37231 656 31 of of IN 37231 656 32 the the DT 37231 656 33 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 656 34 fury fury NN 37231 656 35 against against IN 37231 656 36 the the DT 37231 656 37 [ [ -LRB- 37231 656 38 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 656 39 ] ] -RRB- 37231 656 40 aroused arouse VBN 37231 656 41 by by IN 37231 656 42 the the DT 37231 656 43 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 656 44 . . . 37231 657 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 657 2 will will MD 37231 657 3 now now RB 37231 657 4 go go VB 37231 657 5 more more RBR 37231 657 6 into into IN 37231 657 7 the the DT 37231 657 8 details detail NNS 37231 657 9 of of IN 37231 657 10 the the DT 37231 657 11 brief brief JJ 37231 657 12 statements statement NNS 37231 657 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 657 14 have have VBP 37231 657 15 just just RB 37231 657 16 made make VBN 37231 657 17 , , , 37231 657 18 and and CC 37231 657 19 here here RB 37231 657 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 657 21 come come VBP 37231 657 22 for for IN 37231 657 23 the the DT 37231 657 24 first first JJ 37231 657 25 time time NN 37231 657 26 to to IN 37231 657 27 John John NNP 37231 657 28 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 657 29 . . . 37231 658 1 In in IN 37231 658 2 the the DT 37231 658 3 first first JJ 37231 658 4 place place NN 37231 658 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 658 6 mentions mention VBZ 37231 658 7 the the DT 37231 658 8 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 658 9 of of IN 37231 658 10 the the DT 37231 658 11 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 658 12 on on IN 37231 658 13 the the DT 37231 658 14 13 13 CD 37231 658 15 th th NN 37231 658 16 December December NNP 37231 658 17 . . . 37231 659 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 659 2 will will MD 37231 659 3 quote quote VB 37231 659 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 659 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 659 6 's 's POS 37231 659 7 own own JJ 37231 659 8 rendering rendering NN 37231 659 9 of of IN 37231 659 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 659 11 further further JJ 37231 659 12 important important JJ 37231 659 13 statement statement NN 37231 659 14 . . . 37231 660 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 660 2 says say VBZ 37231 660 3 : : : 37231 660 4 " " `` 37231 660 5 The the DT 37231 660 6 words word NNS 37231 660 7 of of IN 37231 660 8 John John NNP 37231 660 9 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 660 10 are be VBP 37231 660 11 : : : 37231 660 12 ' ' '' 37231 660 13 The the DT 37231 660 14 same same JJ 37231 660 15 king king NN 37231 660 16 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 660 17 was be VBD 37231 660 18 residing reside VBG 37231 660 19 in in IN 37231 660 20 the the DT 37231 660 21 same same JJ 37231 660 22 city city NN 37231 660 23 ( ( -LRB- 37231 660 24 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 660 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 660 26 when when WRB 37231 660 27 the the DT 37231 660 28 visitation visitation NN 37231 660 29 of of IN 37231 660 30 God God NNP 37231 660 31 ( ( -LRB- 37231 660 32 i.e. i.e. FW 37231 661 1 the the DT 37231 661 2 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 661 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 661 4 occurred occur VBD 37231 661 5 . . . 37231 662 1 And and CC 37231 662 2 at at IN 37231 662 3 that that DT 37231 662 4 time time NN 37231 662 5 the the DT 37231 662 6 holy holy NNP 37231 662 7 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 662 8 , , , 37231 662 9 the the DT 37231 662 10 bishop bishop NN 37231 662 11 of of IN 37231 662 12 the the DT 37231 662 13 city city NN 37231 662 14 of of IN 37231 662 15 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 662 16 , , , 37231 662 17 was be VBD 37231 662 18 martyred martyr VBN 37231 662 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 662 20 or or CC 37231 662 21 bore bore NN 37231 662 22 testimony testimony NN 37231 662 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 662 24 , , , 37231 662 25 [ [ -LRB- 37231 662 26 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 662 27 ] ] -RRB- 37231 662 28 before before IN 37231 662 29 him -PRON- PRP 37231 662 30 [ [ -LRB- 37231 662 31 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 662 32 ] ] -RRB- 37231 662 33 ; ; : 37231 662 34 for for IN 37231 662 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 662 36 was be VBD 37231 662 37 exasperated exasperate VBN 37231 662 38 against against IN 37231 662 39 him -PRON- PRP 37231 662 40 , , , 37231 662 41 because because IN 37231 662 42 he -PRON- PRP 37231 662 43 reviled revile VBD 37231 662 44 him -PRON- PRP 37231 662 45 . . . 37231 663 1 ' ' `` 37231 663 2 " " '' 37231 663 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 663 4 2 2 LS 37231 663 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 663 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 663 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 663 8 endeavours endeavour VBZ 37231 663 9 in in IN 37231 663 10 every every DT 37231 663 11 way way NN 37231 663 12 to to TO 37231 663 13 discredit discredit VB 37231 663 14 this this DT 37231 663 15 statement statement NN 37231 663 16 . . . 37231 664 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 664 2 argues argue VBZ 37231 664 3 that that IN 37231 664 4 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 664 5 tells tell VBZ 37231 664 6 foolish foolish JJ 37231 664 7 stories story NNS 37231 664 8 about about IN 37231 664 9 other other JJ 37231 664 10 matters matter NNS 37231 664 11 , , , 37231 664 12 and and CC 37231 664 13 , , , 37231 664 14 therefore therefore RB 37231 664 15 , , , 37231 664 16 is be VBZ 37231 664 17 not not RB 37231 664 18 to to TO 37231 664 19 be be VB 37231 664 20 believed believe VBN 37231 664 21 here here RB 37231 664 22 ; ; : 37231 664 23 but but CC 37231 664 24 so so RB 37231 664 25 simple simple JJ 37231 664 26 a a DT 37231 664 27 piece piece NN 37231 664 28 of of IN 37231 664 29 information information NN 37231 664 30 may may MD 37231 664 31 well well RB 37231 664 32 be be VB 37231 664 33 correctly correctly RB 37231 664 34 conveyed convey VBN 37231 664 35 by by IN 37231 664 36 a a DT 37231 664 37 writer writer NN 37231 664 38 who who WP 37231 664 39 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 664 40 may may MD 37231 664 41 record record VB 37231 664 42 stupid stupid JJ 37231 664 43 traditions tradition NNS 37231 664 44 . . . 37231 665 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 665 2 3 3 LS 37231 665 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 665 4 If if IN 37231 665 5 the the DT 37231 665 6 narrative narrative NN 37231 665 7 of of IN 37231 665 8 foolish foolish JJ 37231 665 9 stories story NNS 37231 665 10 and and CC 37231 665 11 fabulous fabulous JJ 37231 665 12 traditions tradition NNS 37231 665 13 is be VBZ 37231 665 14 to to TO 37231 665 15 exclude exclude VB 37231 665 16 belief belief NN 37231 665 17 in in IN 37231 665 18 everything everything NN 37231 665 19 else else RB 37231 665 20 stated state VBN 37231 665 21 by by IN 37231 665 22 those those DT 37231 665 23 who who WP 37231 665 24 relate relate VBP 37231 665 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 665 26 , , , 37231 665 27 the the DT 37231 665 28 { { -LRB- 37231 665 29 lxxv lxxv NNS 37231 665 30 } } -RRB- 37231 665 31 whole whole NN 37231 665 32 of of IN 37231 665 33 the the DT 37231 665 34 Fathers father NNS 37231 665 35 are be VBP 37231 665 36 disposed dispose VBN 37231 665 37 of of IN 37231 665 38 at at IN 37231 665 39 one one CD 37231 665 40 fell fell JJ 37231 665 41 swoop swoop NN 37231 665 42 , , , 37231 665 43 for for IN 37231 665 44 they -PRON- PRP 37231 665 45 all all DT 37231 665 46 do do VBP 37231 665 47 so so RB 37231 665 48 . . . 37231 666 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 666 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 666 3 also also RB 37231 666 4 asserts assert VBZ 37231 666 5 that that IN 37231 666 6 the the DT 37231 666 7 theory theory NN 37231 666 8 of of IN 37231 666 9 the the DT 37231 666 10 cause cause NN 37231 666 11 of of IN 37231 666 12 the the DT 37231 666 13 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 666 14 advanced advance VBN 37231 666 15 by by IN 37231 666 16 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 666 17 " " `` 37231 666 18 receives receive VBZ 37231 666 19 no no DT 37231 666 20 countenance countenance NN 37231 666 21 from from IN 37231 666 22 the the DT 37231 666 23 story story NN 37231 666 24 of of IN 37231 666 25 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 666 26 , , , 37231 666 27 who who WP 37231 666 28 gives give VBZ 37231 666 29 a a DT 37231 666 30 wholly wholly RB 37231 666 31 different different JJ 37231 666 32 reason reason NN 37231 666 33 -- -- : 37231 666 34 the the DT 37231 666 35 irritating irritate VBG 37231 666 36 language language NN 37231 666 37 used use VBN 37231 666 38 to to IN 37231 666 39 the the DT 37231 666 40 emperor emperor NN 37231 666 41 . . . 37231 667 1 " " `` 37231 667 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 667 3 l l NN 37231 667 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 667 5 On on IN 37231 667 6 the the DT 37231 667 7 other other JJ 37231 667 8 hand hand NN 37231 667 9 , , , 37231 667 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 667 11 in in IN 37231 667 12 no no DT 37231 667 13 way way NN 37231 667 14 contradicts contradict VBZ 37231 667 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 667 16 , , , 37231 667 17 for for IN 37231 667 18 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 667 19 can can MD 37231 667 20 only only RB 37231 667 21 have have VB 37231 667 22 " " `` 37231 667 23 reviled revile VBN 37231 667 24 " " '' 37231 667 25 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 667 26 when when WRB 37231 667 27 brought bring VBD 37231 667 28 before before IN 37231 667 29 him -PRON- PRP 37231 667 30 , , , 37231 667 31 and and CC 37231 667 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 667 33 being be VBG 37231 667 34 taken take VBN 37231 667 35 before before IN 37231 667 36 him -PRON- PRP 37231 667 37 may may MD 37231 667 38 well well RB 37231 667 39 have have VB 37231 667 40 been be VBN 37231 667 41 caused cause VBN 37231 667 42 by by IN 37231 667 43 the the DT 37231 667 44 fury fury NN 37231 667 45 excited excite VBN 37231 667 46 by by IN 37231 667 47 the the DT 37231 667 48 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 667 49 , , , 37231 667 50 even even RB 37231 667 51 if if IN 37231 667 52 the the DT 37231 667 53 language language NN 37231 667 54 of of IN 37231 667 55 the the DT 37231 667 56 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 667 57 influenced influence VBD 37231 667 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 667 59 condemnation condemnation NN 37231 667 60 ; ; : 37231 667 61 the the DT 37231 667 62 whole whole JJ 37231 667 63 statement statement NN 37231 667 64 of of IN 37231 667 65 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 667 66 is be VBZ 37231 667 67 in in IN 37231 667 68 perfect perfect JJ 37231 667 69 harmony harmony NN 37231 667 70 with with IN 37231 667 71 the the DT 37231 667 72 theory theory NN 37231 667 73 in in IN 37231 667 74 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 667 75 details detail NNS 37231 667 76 , , , 37231 667 77 and and CC 37231 667 78 in in IN 37231 667 79 the the DT 37231 667 80 main main JJ 37231 667 81 , , , 37231 667 82 of of IN 37231 667 83 course course NN 37231 667 84 , , , 37231 667 85 directly directly RB 37231 667 86 supports support VBZ 37231 667 87 it -PRON- PRP 37231 667 88 . . . 37231 668 1 Then then RB 37231 668 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 668 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 668 4 actually actually RB 37231 668 5 makes make VBZ 37231 668 6 use use NN 37231 668 7 of of IN 37231 668 8 the the DT 37231 668 9 following follow VBG 37231 668 10 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 668 11 argument argument NN 37231 668 12 : : : 37231 668 13 " " `` 37231 668 14 But but CC 37231 668 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 668 16 may may MD 37231 668 17 be be VB 37231 668 18 worth worth JJ 37231 668 19 while while IN 37231 668 20 adding add VBG 37231 668 21 that that IN 37231 668 22 the the DT 37231 668 23 error error NN 37231 668 24 of of IN 37231 668 25 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 668 26 is be VBZ 37231 668 27 capable capable JJ 37231 668 28 of of IN 37231 668 29 easy easy JJ 37231 668 30 explanation explanation NN 37231 668 31 . . . 37231 669 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 669 2 has have VBZ 37231 669 3 probably probably RB 37231 669 4 misinterpreted misinterpret VBN 37231 669 5 some some DT 37231 669 6 earlier early JJR 37231 669 7 authority authority NN 37231 669 8 , , , 37231 669 9 whose whose WP$ 37231 669 10 language language NN 37231 669 11 lent lend VBD 37231 669 12 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 669 13 to to IN 37231 669 14 misinterpretation misinterpretation NN 37231 669 15 . . . 37231 670 1 The the DT 37231 670 2 words word NNS 37231 670 3 [ [ -LRB- 37231 670 4 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 670 5 ] ] -RRB- 37231 670 6 , , , 37231 670 7 which which WDT 37231 670 8 were be VBD 37231 670 9 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 670 10 used use VBN 37231 670 11 especially especially RB 37231 670 12 of of IN 37231 670 13 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 670 14 , , , 37231 670 15 had have VBD 37231 670 16 in in IN 37231 670 17 the the DT 37231 670 18 earlier early JJR 37231 670 19 ages age NNS 37231 670 20 a a DT 37231 670 21 wider wide JJR 37231 670 22 sense sense NN 37231 670 23 , , , 37231 670 24 including include VBG 37231 670 25 other other JJ 37231 670 26 modes mode NNS 37231 670 27 of of IN 37231 670 28 witnessing witness VBG 37231 670 29 to to IN 37231 670 30 the the DT 37231 670 31 faith faith NN 37231 670 32 : : : 37231 670 33 the the DT 37231 670 34 expression expression NN 37231 670 35 [ [ -LRB- 37231 670 36 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 670 37 ] ] -RRB- 37231 670 38 again again RB 37231 670 39 is be VBZ 37231 670 40 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 37231 670 41 and and CC 37231 670 42 might may MD 37231 670 43 denote denote VB 37231 670 44 either either CC 37231 670 45 ' ' `` 37231 670 46 during during IN 37231 670 47 the the DT 37231 670 48 reign reign NN 37231 670 49 of of IN 37231 670 50 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 670 51 , , , 37231 670 52 ' ' '' 37231 670 53 or or CC 37231 670 54 ' ' '' 37231 670 55 in in IN 37231 670 56 the the DT 37231 670 57 presence presence NN 37231 670 58 of of IN 37231 670 59 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 670 60 . . . 37231 670 61 ' ' '' 37231 671 1 A a DT 37231 671 2 blundering blundering NN 37231 671 3 writer writer NN 37231 671 4 like like IN 37231 671 5 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 671 6 might may MD 37231 671 7 have have VB 37231 671 8 stumbled stumble VBN 37231 671 9 over over IN 37231 671 10 either either DT 37231 671 11 expression expression NN 37231 671 12 . . . 37231 672 1 " " `` 37231 672 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 672 3 2 2 LS 37231 672 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 672 5 This this DT 37231 672 6 is be VBZ 37231 672 7 a a DT 37231 672 8 favourite favourite JJ 37231 672 9 device device NN 37231 672 10 . . . 37231 673 1 In in IN 37231 673 2 case case NN 37231 673 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 673 4 abuse abuse NN 37231 673 5 of of IN 37231 673 6 poor poor JJ 37231 673 7 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 673 8 should should MD 37231 673 9 not not RB 37231 673 10 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 673 11 discredit discredit VB 37231 673 12 him -PRON- PRP 37231 673 13 , , , 37231 673 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 673 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 673 16 attempts attempt VBZ 37231 673 17 to to TO 37231 673 18 explain explain VB 37231 673 19 away away RB 37231 673 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 673 21 language language NN 37231 673 22 . . . 37231 674 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 674 2 would would MD 37231 674 3 be be VB 37231 674 4 difficult difficult JJ 37231 674 5 indeed indeed RB 37231 674 6 to to TO 37231 674 7 show show VB 37231 674 8 that that IN 37231 674 9 the the DT 37231 674 10 words word NNS 37231 674 11 [ [ -LRB- 37231 674 12 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 674 13 ] ] -RRB- 37231 674 14 , , , 37231 674 15 already already RB 37231 674 16 used use VBN 37231 674 17 in in IN 37231 674 18 that that DT 37231 674 19 sense sense NN 37231 674 20 in in IN 37231 674 21 the the DT 37231 674 22 New New NNP 37231 674 23 Testament Testament NNP 37231 674 24 , , , 37231 674 25 were be VBD 37231 674 26 not not RB 37231 674 27 , , , 37231 674 28 at at IN 37231 674 29 the the DT 37231 674 30 date date NN 37231 674 31 at at IN 37231 674 32 which which WDT 37231 674 33 any any DT 37231 674 34 record record NN 37231 674 35 of of IN 37231 674 36 the the DT 37231 674 37 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 674 38 of of IN 37231 674 39 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 674 40 which which WDT 37231 674 41 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 674 42 could could MD 37231 674 43 have have VB 37231 674 44 had have VBN 37231 674 45 before before IN 37231 674 46 him -PRON- PRP 37231 674 47 was be VBD 37231 674 48 written write VBN 37231 674 49 , , , 37231 674 50 employed employ VBN 37231 674 51 to to TO 37231 674 52 express express VB 37231 674 53 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 674 54 , , , 37231 674 55 when when WRB 37231 674 56 applied apply VBN 37231 674 57 to to IN 37231 674 58 such such PDT 37231 674 59 a a DT 37231 674 60 case case NN 37231 674 61 , , , 37231 674 62 as as IN 37231 674 63 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 674 64 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 674 65 indeed indeed RB 37231 674 66 has have VBZ 37231 674 67 in in IN 37231 674 68 the the DT 37231 674 69 { { -LRB- 37231 674 70 lxxvi lxxvi NN 37231 674 71 } } -RRB- 37231 674 72 first first JJ 37231 674 73 instance instance NN 37231 674 74 rendered render VBD 37231 674 75 the the DT 37231 674 76 phrase phrase NN 37231 674 77 . . . 37231 675 1 Even even RB 37231 675 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 675 3 , , , 37231 675 4 whom whom WP 37231 675 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 675 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 675 7 so so RB 37231 675 8 implicitly implicitly RB 37231 675 9 follows follow VBZ 37231 675 10 , , , 37231 675 11 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 675 12 decides decide VBZ 37231 675 13 against against IN 37231 675 14 him -PRON- PRP 37231 675 15 on on IN 37231 675 16 both both DT 37231 675 17 points point NNS 37231 675 18 . . . 37231 676 1 " " `` 37231 676 2 The the DT 37231 676 3 [ [ -LRB- 37231 676 4 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 676 5 ] ] -RRB- 37231 676 6 together together RB 37231 676 7 with with IN 37231 676 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 676 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 676 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 676 11 can can MD 37231 676 12 only only RB 37231 676 13 signify signify VB 37231 676 14 ' ' '' 37231 676 15 coram coram NNP 37231 676 16 Trajano Trajano NNP 37231 676 17 ' ' '' 37231 676 18 ( ( -LRB- 37231 676 19 ' ' `` 37231 676 20 in in IN 37231 676 21 the the DT 37231 676 22 presence presence NN 37231 676 23 of of IN 37231 676 24 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 676 25 ' ' '' 37231 676 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 676 27 , , , 37231 676 28 and and CC 37231 676 29 [ [ -LRB- 37231 676 30 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 676 31 ] ] -RRB- 37231 676 32 only only RB 37231 676 33 the the DT 37231 676 34 execution execution NN 37231 676 35 . . . 37231 677 1 " " `` 37231 677 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 677 3 1 1 LS 37231 677 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 677 5 Let let VB 37231 677 6 any any DT 37231 677 7 one one NN 37231 677 8 simply simply RB 37231 677 9 read read VBN 37231 677 10 over over IN 37231 677 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 677 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 677 13 's 's POS 37231 677 14 own own JJ 37231 677 15 rendering rendering NN 37231 677 16 , , , 37231 677 17 which which WDT 37231 677 18 I -PRON- PRP 37231 677 19 have have VBP 37231 677 20 quoted quote VBN 37231 677 21 above above RB 37231 677 22 , , , 37231 677 23 and and CC 37231 677 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 677 25 will will MD 37231 677 26 see see VB 37231 677 27 that that IN 37231 677 28 such such JJ 37231 677 29 quibbles quibble NNS 37231 677 30 are be VBP 37231 677 31 excluded exclude VBN 37231 677 32 , , , 37231 677 33 and and CC 37231 677 34 that that IN 37231 677 35 , , , 37231 677 36 on on IN 37231 677 37 the the DT 37231 677 38 contrary contrary NN 37231 677 39 , , , 37231 677 40 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 677 41 seems seem VBZ 37231 677 42 excellently excellently RB 37231 677 43 well well JJ 37231 677 44 and and CC 37231 677 45 directly directly RB 37231 677 46 to to TO 37231 677 47 have have VB 37231 677 48 interpreted interpret VBN 37231 677 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 677 50 earlier early JJR 37231 677 51 authority authority NN 37231 677 52 . . . 37231 678 1 That that IN 37231 678 2 the the DT 37231 678 3 statement statement NN 37231 678 4 of of IN 37231 678 5 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 678 6 does do VBZ 37231 678 7 not not RB 37231 678 8 agree agree VB 37231 678 9 with with IN 37231 678 10 the the DT 37231 678 11 reports report NNS 37231 678 12 of of IN 37231 678 13 the the DT 37231 678 14 Fathers father NNS 37231 678 15 is be VBZ 37231 678 16 no no DT 37231 678 17 real real JJ 37231 678 18 objection objection NN 37231 678 19 , , , 37231 678 20 for for IN 37231 678 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 678 22 have have VBP 37231 678 23 good good JJ 37231 678 24 reason reason NN 37231 678 25 to to TO 37231 678 26 believe believe VB 37231 678 27 that that IN 37231 678 28 none none NN 37231 678 29 of of IN 37231 678 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 678 31 had have VBD 37231 678 32 information information NN 37231 678 33 from from IN 37231 678 34 any any DT 37231 678 35 other other JJ 37231 678 36 source source NN 37231 678 37 than than IN 37231 678 38 the the DT 37231 678 39 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 678 40 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 678 41 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 678 42 , , , 37231 678 43 or or CC 37231 678 44 tradition tradition NN 37231 678 45 . . . 37231 679 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 679 2 evidently evidently RB 37231 679 3 had have VBD 37231 679 4 not not RB 37231 679 5 . . . 37231 680 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 680 2 , , , 37231 680 3 Origen Origen NNP 37231 680 4 , , , 37231 680 5 and and CC 37231 680 6 some some DT 37231 680 7 later later JJ 37231 680 8 Fathers father NNS 37231 680 9 tell tell VBP 37231 680 10 us -PRON- PRP 37231 680 11 nothing nothing NN 37231 680 12 about about IN 37231 680 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 680 14 . . . 37231 681 1 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 681 2 and and CC 37231 681 3 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 37231 681 4 clearly clearly RB 37231 681 5 take take VBP 37231 681 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 681 7 accounts account NNS 37231 681 8 from from IN 37231 681 9 these these DT 37231 681 10 sources source NNS 37231 681 11 . . . 37231 682 1 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 682 2 is be VBZ 37231 682 3 the the DT 37231 682 4 first first JJ 37231 682 5 who who WP 37231 682 6 , , , 37231 682 7 by by IN 37231 682 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 682 9 variation variation NN 37231 682 10 , , , 37231 682 11 proves prove VBZ 37231 682 12 that that IN 37231 682 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 682 14 had have VBD 37231 682 15 another another DT 37231 682 16 and and CC 37231 682 17 different different JJ 37231 682 18 authority authority NN 37231 682 19 before before IN 37231 682 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 682 21 , , , 37231 682 22 and and CC 37231 682 23 in in IN 37231 682 24 abandoning abandon VBG 37231 682 25 the the DT 37231 682 26 martyr martyr NN 37231 682 27 - - HYPH 37231 682 28 journey journey NN 37231 682 29 to to IN 37231 682 30 Rome Rome NNP 37231 682 31 , , , 37231 682 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 682 33 account account NN 37231 682 34 has have VBZ 37231 682 35 infinitely infinitely RB 37231 682 36 greater great JJR 37231 682 37 apparent apparent JJ 37231 682 38 probability probability NN 37231 682 39 . . . 37231 683 1 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 683 2 lived live VBD 37231 683 3 at at IN 37231 683 4 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 683 5 , , , 37231 683 6 which which WDT 37231 683 7 adds add VBZ 37231 683 8 some some DT 37231 683 9 weight weight NN 37231 683 10 to to IN 37231 683 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 683 12 statement statement NN 37231 683 13 . . . 37231 684 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 684 2 is be VBZ 37231 684 3 objected object VBN 37231 684 4 that that IN 37231 684 5 so so RB 37231 684 6 also also RB 37231 684 7 did do VBD 37231 684 8 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 37231 684 9 , , , 37231 684 10 and and CC 37231 684 11 at at IN 37231 684 12 an an DT 37231 684 13 earlier early JJR 37231 684 14 period period NN 37231 684 15 , , , 37231 684 16 and and CC 37231 684 17 yet yet RB 37231 684 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 684 19 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 684 20 the the DT 37231 684 21 Roman roman JJ 37231 684 22 story story NN 37231 684 23 . . . 37231 685 1 This this DT 37231 685 2 , , , 37231 685 3 however however RB 37231 685 4 , , , 37231 685 5 is be VBZ 37231 685 6 no no DT 37231 685 7 valid valid JJ 37231 685 8 argument argument NN 37231 685 9 against against IN 37231 685 10 Malalas Malalas NNP 37231 685 11 . . . 37231 686 1 Chrysostom chrysostom NN 37231 686 2 was be VBD 37231 686 3 too too RB 37231 686 4 good good JJ 37231 686 5 a a DT 37231 686 6 churchman churchman NN 37231 686 7 to to TO 37231 686 8 doubt doubt VB 37231 686 9 the the DT 37231 686 10 story story NN 37231 686 11 of of IN 37231 686 12 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 686 13 so so RB 37231 686 14 much much RB 37231 686 15 tending tend VBG 37231 686 16 to to IN 37231 686 17 edification edification NN 37231 686 18 , , , 37231 686 19 which which WDT 37231 686 20 were be VBD 37231 686 21 in in IN 37231 686 22 wide wide JJ 37231 686 23 circulation circulation NN 37231 686 24 , , , 37231 686 25 and and CC 37231 686 26 had have VBD 37231 686 27 been be VBN 37231 686 28 quoted quote VBN 37231 686 29 by by IN 37231 686 30 earlier early JJR 37231 686 31 Fathers father NNS 37231 686 32 . . . 37231 687 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 687 2 is be VBZ 37231 687 3 in in IN 37231 687 4 no no DT 37231 687 5 way way NN 37231 687 6 surprising surprising JJ 37231 687 7 that that IN 37231 687 8 , , , 37231 687 9 some some DT 37231 687 10 two two CD 37231 687 11 centuries century NNS 37231 687 12 and and CC 37231 687 13 a a DT 37231 687 14 half half NN 37231 687 15 after after IN 37231 687 16 the the DT 37231 687 17 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 687 18 , , , 37231 687 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 687 20 should should MD 37231 687 21 quietly quietly RB 37231 687 22 have have VB 37231 687 23 accepted accept VBN 37231 687 24 the the DT 37231 687 25 representations representation NNS 37231 687 26 of of IN 37231 687 27 the the DT 37231 687 28 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 687 29 purporting purport VBG 37231 687 30 to to TO 37231 687 31 have have VB 37231 687 32 been be VBN 37231 687 33 { { -LRB- 37231 687 34 lxxvii lxxvii NN 37231 687 35 } } -RRB- 37231 687 36 written write VBN 37231 687 37 by by IN 37231 687 38 the the DT 37231 687 39 martyr martyr NN 37231 687 40 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 687 41 , , , 37231 687 42 and and CC 37231 687 43 that that IN 37231 687 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 687 45 story story NN 37231 687 46 should should MD 37231 687 47 have have VB 37231 687 48 shaped shape VBN 37231 687 49 the the DT 37231 687 50 prevailing prevail VBG 37231 687 51 tradition tradition NN 37231 687 52 . . . 37231 688 1 The the DT 37231 688 2 remains remain NNS 37231 688 3 of of IN 37231 688 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 688 5 , , , 37231 688 6 as as IN 37231 688 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 688 8 are be VBP 37231 688 9 informed inform VBN 37231 688 10 by by IN 37231 688 11 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 37231 688 12 and and CC 37231 688 13 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 688 14 , , , 37231 688 15 long long RB 37231 688 16 remained remain VBD 37231 688 17 interred interred JJ 37231 688 18 in in IN 37231 688 19 the the DT 37231 688 20 cemetery cemetery NN 37231 688 21 of of IN 37231 688 22 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 688 23 , , , 37231 688 24 but but CC 37231 688 25 finally,--in finally,--in VBD 37231 688 26 the the DT 37231 688 27 time time NN 37231 688 28 of of IN 37231 688 29 Theodosius Theodosius NNP 37231 688 30 , , , 37231 688 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 688 32 is be VBZ 37231 688 33 said,--were said,--were NNP 37231 688 34 translated translate VBN 37231 688 35 with with IN 37231 688 36 great great JJ 37231 688 37 pomp pomp NN 37231 688 38 and and CC 37231 688 39 ceremony ceremony NN 37231 688 40 to to IN 37231 688 41 a a DT 37231 688 42 building building NN 37231 688 43 which,--such which,--such , 37231 688 44 is be VBZ 37231 688 45 the the DT 37231 688 46 irony irony NN 37231 688 47 of of IN 37231 688 48 events,--had events,--had VBN 37231 688 49 previously previously RB 37231 688 50 been be VBN 37231 688 51 a a DT 37231 688 52 Temple Temple NNP 37231 688 53 of of IN 37231 688 54 Fortune Fortune NNP 37231 688 55 . . . 37231 689 1 The the DT 37231 689 2 story story NN 37231 689 3 told tell VBD 37231 689 4 , , , 37231 689 5 of of IN 37231 689 6 course course NN 37231 689 7 , , , 37231 689 8 is be VBZ 37231 689 9 that that IN 37231 689 10 the the DT 37231 689 11 relics relic NNS 37231 689 12 of of IN 37231 689 13 the the DT 37231 689 14 martyr martyr NN 37231 689 15 had have VBD 37231 689 16 been be VBN 37231 689 17 carefully carefully RB 37231 689 18 collected collect VBN 37231 689 19 in in IN 37231 689 20 the the DT 37231 689 21 Coliseum Coliseum NNP 37231 689 22 and and CC 37231 689 23 carried carry VBN 37231 689 24 from from IN 37231 689 25 Rome Rome NNP 37231 689 26 to to IN 37231 689 27 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 689 28 . . . 37231 690 1 After after IN 37231 690 2 reposing repose VBG 37231 690 3 there there RB 37231 690 4 for for IN 37231 690 5 some some DT 37231 690 6 centuries century NNS 37231 690 7 , , , 37231 690 8 the the DT 37231 690 9 relics relic NNS 37231 690 10 , , , 37231 690 11 which which WDT 37231 690 12 are be VBP 37231 690 13 said say VBN 37231 690 14 to to TO 37231 690 15 have have VB 37231 690 16 been be VBN 37231 690 17 transported transport VBN 37231 690 18 from from IN 37231 690 19 Rome Rome NNP 37231 690 20 to to IN 37231 690 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 690 22 , , , 37231 690 23 were be VBD 37231 690 24 , , , 37231 690 25 about about IN 37231 690 26 the the DT 37231 690 27 seventh seventh JJ 37231 690 28 century century NN 37231 690 29 , , , 37231 690 30 carried carry VBD 37231 690 31 back back RB 37231 690 32 from from IN 37231 690 33 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 690 34 to to IN 37231 690 35 Rome Rome NNP 37231 690 36 . . . 37231 691 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 691 2 1 1 LS 37231 691 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 691 4 The the DT 37231 691 5 natural natural JJ 37231 691 6 and and CC 37231 691 7 more more JJR 37231 691 8 simple simple JJ 37231 691 9 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 691 10 is be VBZ 37231 691 11 that that IN 37231 691 12 , , , 37231 691 13 instead instead RB 37231 691 14 of of IN 37231 691 15 this this DT 37231 691 16 double double JJ 37231 691 17 translation translation NN 37231 691 18 , , , 37231 691 19 the the DT 37231 691 20 bones bone NNS 37231 691 21 of of IN 37231 691 22 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 691 23 had have VBD 37231 691 24 always always RB 37231 691 25 remained remain VBN 37231 691 26 in in IN 37231 691 27 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 691 28 , , , 37231 691 29 where where WRB 37231 691 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 691 31 had have VBD 37231 691 32 suffered suffer VBN 37231 691 33 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 691 34 , , , 37231 691 35 and and CC 37231 691 36 the the DT 37231 691 37 tradition tradition NN 37231 691 38 that that WDT 37231 691 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 691 40 had have VBD 37231 691 41 been be VBN 37231 691 42 brought bring VBN 37231 691 43 back back RB 37231 691 44 from from IN 37231 691 45 Rome Rome NNP 37231 691 46 was be VBD 37231 691 47 merely merely RB 37231 691 48 the the DT 37231 691 49 explanation explanation NN 37231 691 50 which which WDT 37231 691 51 reconciled reconcile VBD 37231 691 52 the the DT 37231 691 53 fact fact NN 37231 691 54 of of IN 37231 691 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 691 56 actually actually RB 37231 691 57 being be VBG 37231 691 58 in in IN 37231 691 59 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 691 60 with with IN 37231 691 61 the the DT 37231 691 62 legend legend NN 37231 691 63 of of IN 37231 691 64 the the DT 37231 691 65 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 691 66 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 691 67 . . . 37231 692 1 The the DT 37231 692 2 20th 20th NN 37231 692 3 of of IN 37231 692 4 December December NNP 37231 692 5 is be VBZ 37231 692 6 the the DT 37231 692 7 date date NN 37231 692 8 assigned assign VBN 37231 692 9 to to IN 37231 692 10 the the DT 37231 692 11 death death NN 37231 692 12 of of IN 37231 692 13 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 692 14 in in IN 37231 692 15 the the DT 37231 692 16 Martyrology,(2 Martyrology,(2 NNP 37231 692 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 692 18 and and CC 37231 692 19 Zahn Zahn NNP 37231 692 20 admits admit VBZ 37231 692 21 that that IN 37231 692 22 this this DT 37231 692 23 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 692 24 is be VBZ 37231 692 25 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 692 26 . . . 37231 693 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 693 2 3 3 LS 37231 693 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 693 4 Moreover moreover RB 37231 693 5 , , , 37231 693 6 the the DT 37231 693 7 anniversary anniversary NN 37231 693 8 of of IN 37231 693 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 693 10 death death NN 37231 693 11 was be VBD 37231 693 12 celebrated celebrate VBN 37231 693 13 on on IN 37231 693 14 that that DT 37231 693 15 day day NN 37231 693 16 in in IN 37231 693 17 the the DT 37231 693 18 Greek Greek NNP 37231 693 19 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 693 20 and and CC 37231 693 21 throughout throughout IN 37231 693 22 the the DT 37231 693 23 East East NNP 37231 693 24 . . . 37231 694 1 In in IN 37231 694 2 the the DT 37231 694 3 Latin Latin NNP 37231 694 4 Church Church NNP 37231 694 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 694 6 is be VBZ 37231 694 7 kept keep VBN 37231 694 8 on on IN 37231 694 9 the the DT 37231 694 10 1st 1st NN 37231 694 11 of of IN 37231 694 12 February February NNP 37231 694 13 . . . 37231 695 1 There there EX 37231 695 2 can can MD 37231 695 3 be be VB 37231 695 4 little little JJ 37231 695 5 doubt doubt NN 37231 695 6 that that IN 37231 695 7 this this DT 37231 695 8 was be VBD 37231 695 9 the the DT 37231 695 10 day day NN 37231 695 11 of of IN 37231 695 12 the the DT 37231 695 13 translation translation NN 37231 695 14 of of IN 37231 695 15 the the DT 37231 695 16 relics relic NNS 37231 695 17 to to IN 37231 695 18 Rome Rome NNP 37231 695 19 , , , 37231 695 20 and and CC 37231 695 21 this this DT 37231 695 22 was be VBD 37231 695 23 evidently evidently RB 37231 695 24 the the DT 37231 695 25 1 1 CD 37231 695 26 I -PRON- PRP 37231 695 27 need nee MD 37231 695 28 not not RB 37231 695 29 refer refer VB 37231 695 30 to to IN 37231 695 31 the the DT 37231 695 32 statement statement NN 37231 695 33 of of IN 37231 695 34 Nicephorus Nicephorus NNP 37231 695 35 that that IN 37231 695 36 these these DT 37231 695 37 relics relic NNS 37231 695 38 were be VBD 37231 695 39 first first RB 37231 695 40 brought bring VBN 37231 695 41 from from IN 37231 695 42 Rome Rome NNP 37231 695 43 to to IN 37231 695 44 Constantinople Constantinople NNP 37231 695 45 and and CC 37231 695 46 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 695 47 translated translate VBN 37231 695 48 to to IN 37231 695 49 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 695 50 . . . 37231 696 1 { { -LRB- 37231 696 2 lxxviii lxxviii NNP 37231 696 3 } } -RRB- 37231 696 4 view view NN 37231 696 5 of of IN 37231 696 6 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 37231 696 7 , , , 37231 696 8 who who WP 37231 696 9 , , , 37231 696 10 although although IN 37231 696 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 696 12 could could MD 37231 696 13 not not RB 37231 696 14 positively positively RB 37231 696 15 contradict contradict VB 37231 696 16 the the DT 37231 696 17 views view NNS 37231 696 18 of of IN 37231 696 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 696 20 own own JJ 37231 696 21 Church Church NNP 37231 696 22 , , , 37231 696 23 says say VBZ 37231 696 24 : : : 37231 696 25 " " `` 37231 696 26 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 37231 696 27 festum festum JJ 37231 696 28 Graeci Graeci NNPS 37231 696 29 vigesima vigesima NN 37231 696 30 die die VBP 37231 696 31 mensis mensis NNP 37231 696 32 Decembris Decembris NNP 37231 696 33 celebrant celebrant NN 37231 696 34 , , , 37231 696 35 quo quo NNP 37231 696 36 ipsum ipsum NNP 37231 696 37 passum passum NNP 37231 696 38 fuisse fuisse NNP 37231 696 39 Acta Acta NNP 37231 696 40 testantur testantur NN 37231 696 41 ; ; : 37231 696 42 Latini latini NN 37231 696 43 vero vero NN 37231 696 44 die die VBP 37231 696 45 prima prima NNP 37231 696 46 Februarii Februarii NNP 37231 696 47 , , , 37231 696 48 an an DT 37231 696 49 ob ob NNP 37231 696 50 aliquam aliquam NNP 37231 696 51 sacrarum sacrarum NNP 37231 696 52 ejus ejus NNP 37231 696 53 reli reli NNP 37231 696 54 - - HYPH 37231 696 55 quiarum quiarum NN 37231 696 56 translationem translationem NN 37231 696 57 ? ? . 37231 697 1 plures plure VBZ 37231 697 2 enim enim NNP 37231 697 3 fuisse fuisse NNP 37231 697 4 constat constat NNP 37231 697 5 . . . 37231 698 1 " " `` 37231 698 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 698 3 1 1 LS 37231 698 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 698 5 Zahn(2 Zahn(2 NNP 37231 698 6 ) ) -RRB- 37231 698 7 states state VBZ 37231 698 8 that that IN 37231 698 9 the the DT 37231 698 10 Feast Feast NNP 37231 698 11 of of IN 37231 698 12 the the DT 37231 698 13 translation translation NN 37231 698 14 in in IN 37231 698 15 later later JJ 37231 698 16 calendars calendar NNS 37231 698 17 was be VBD 37231 698 18 celebrated celebrate VBN 37231 698 19 on on IN 37231 698 20 the the DT 37231 698 21 29th 29th JJ 37231 698 22 January January NNP 37231 698 23 , , , 37231 698 24 and and CC 37231 698 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 698 26 points point VBZ 37231 698 27 out out RP 37231 698 28 the the DT 37231 698 29 evident evident JJ 37231 698 30 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 698 31 which which WDT 37231 698 32 prevailed prevail VBD 37231 698 33 in in IN 37231 698 34 the the DT 37231 698 35 West West NNP 37231 698 36 regarding regard VBG 37231 698 37 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 698 38 . . . 37231 699 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 699 2 3 3 LS 37231 699 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 699 4 On on IN 37231 699 5 the the DT 37231 699 6 one one CD 37231 699 7 hand hand NN 37231 699 8 , , , 37231 699 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 699 10 , , , 37231 699 11 all all PDT 37231 699 12 the the DT 37231 699 13 historical historical JJ 37231 699 14 data datum NNS 37231 699 15 which which WDT 37231 699 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 699 17 possess possess VBP 37231 699 18 regarding regard VBG 37231 699 19 the the DT 37231 699 20 reign reign NN 37231 699 21 and and CC 37231 699 22 character character NN 37231 699 23 of of IN 37231 699 24 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 699 25 discredit discredit VB 37231 699 26 the the DT 37231 699 27 story story NN 37231 699 28 that that WDT 37231 699 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 699 30 was be VBD 37231 699 31 sent send VBN 37231 699 32 to to IN 37231 699 33 Rme Rme NNP 37231 699 34 to to TO 37231 699 35 be be VB 37231 699 36 exposed expose VBN 37231 699 37 to to IN 37231 699 38 beasts beast NNS 37231 699 39 in in IN 37231 699 40 the the DT 37231 699 41 Coliseum Coliseum NNP 37231 699 42 ; ; : 37231 699 43 and and CC 37231 699 44 all all PDT 37231 699 45 the the DT 37231 699 46 positive positive JJ 37231 699 47 evidence evidence NN 37231 699 48 which which WDT 37231 699 49 exists exist VBZ 37231 699 50 , , , 37231 699 51 independent independent JJ 37231 699 52 of of IN 37231 699 53 the the DT 37231 699 54 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 699 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 699 56 , , , 37231 699 57 tends tend VBZ 37231 699 58 to to TO 37231 699 59 establish establish VB 37231 699 60 the the DT 37231 699 61 fact fact NN 37231 699 62 that that IN 37231 699 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 699 64 suffered suffer VBD 37231 699 65 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 699 66 in in IN 37231 699 67 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 699 68 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 699 69 . . . 37231 700 1 On on IN 37231 700 2 the the DT 37231 700 3 other other JJ 37231 700 4 hand hand NN 37231 700 5 , , , 37231 700 6 all all PDT 37231 700 7 the the DT 37231 700 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 700 9 which which WDT 37231 700 10 is be VBZ 37231 700 11 offered offer VBN 37231 700 12 for for IN 37231 700 13 the the DT 37231 700 14 statement statement NN 37231 700 15 that that IN 37231 700 16 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 700 17 was be VBD 37231 700 18 sent send VBN 37231 700 19 to to IN 37231 700 20 Rme Rme NNP 37231 700 21 is be VBZ 37231 700 22 more more RBR 37231 700 23 or or CC 37231 700 24 less less RBR 37231 700 25 directly directly RB 37231 700 26 based base VBN 37231 700 27 upon upon IN 37231 700 28 the the DT 37231 700 29 representations representation NNS 37231 700 30 of of IN 37231 700 31 the the DT 37231 700 32 letters letter NNS 37231 700 33 , , , 37231 700 34 the the DT 37231 700 35 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 700 36 of of IN 37231 700 37 which which WDT 37231 700 38 is be VBZ 37231 700 39 in in IN 37231 700 40 discussion discussion NN 37231 700 41 , , , 37231 700 42 and and CC 37231 700 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 700 44 is be VBZ 37231 700 45 surrounded surround VBN 37231 700 46 with with IN 37231 700 47 improbabilities improbability NNS 37231 700 48 of of IN 37231 700 49 every every DT 37231 700 50 kind kind NN 37231 700 51 . . . 37231 701 1 And and CC 37231 701 2 what what WP 37231 701 3 is be VBZ 37231 701 4 the the DT 37231 701 5 value value NN 37231 701 6 of of IN 37231 701 7 any any DT 37231 701 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 701 9 emanating emanate VBG 37231 701 10 from from IN 37231 701 11 the the DT 37231 701 12 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 701 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 701 14 and and CC 37231 701 15 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 37231 701 16 ? ? . 37231 702 1 There there EX 37231 702 2 are be VBP 37231 702 3 three three CD 37231 702 4 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 37231 702 5 which which WDT 37231 702 6 , , , 37231 702 7 as as IN 37231 702 8 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 702 9 says say VBZ 37231 702 10 , , , 37231 702 11 are be VBP 37231 702 12 " " `` 37231 702 13 the the DT 37231 702 14 one one CD 37231 702 15 more more RBR 37231 702 16 fabulous fabulous JJ 37231 702 17 than than IN 37231 702 18 the the DT 37231 702 19 other other JJ 37231 702 20 . . . 37231 702 21 " " '' 37231 703 1 There there EX 37231 703 2 are be VBP 37231 703 3 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 703 4 Epistles epistle NNS 37231 703 5 all all RB 37231 703 6 equally equally RB 37231 703 7 purporting purport VBG 37231 703 8 to to TO 37231 703 9 be be VB 37231 703 10 by by IN 37231 703 11 { { -LRB- 37231 703 12 xxix xxix NNP 37231 703 13 } } -RRB- 37231 703 14 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 703 15 , , , 37231 703 16 and and CC 37231 703 17 most most JJS 37231 703 18 of of IN 37231 703 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 703 20 handed hand VBD 37231 703 21 down down RP 37231 703 22 together together RB 37231 703 23 in in IN 37231 703 24 MSS MSS NNP 37231 703 25 . . . 37231 703 26 , , , 37231 703 27 without without IN 37231 703 28 any any DT 37231 703 29 distinction distinction NN 37231 703 30 . . . 37231 704 1 Three three CD 37231 704 2 of of IN 37231 704 3 these these DT 37231 704 4 , , , 37231 704 5 in in IN 37231 704 6 Latin Latin NNP 37231 704 7 only only RB 37231 704 8 , , , 37231 704 9 are be VBP 37231 704 10 universally universally RB 37231 704 11 rejected reject VBN 37231 704 12 , , , 37231 704 13 as as IN 37231 704 14 are be VBP 37231 704 15 also also RB 37231 704 16 other other JJ 37231 704 17 five five CD 37231 704 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 704 19 , , , 37231 704 20 of of IN 37231 704 21 which which WDT 37231 704 22 there there EX 37231 704 23 are be VBP 37231 704 24 Greek greek JJ 37231 704 25 , , , 37231 704 26 Latin Latin NNP 37231 704 27 , , , 37231 704 28 and and CC 37231 704 29 other other JJ 37231 704 30 versions version NNS 37231 704 31 . . . 37231 705 1 Of of IN 37231 705 2 the the DT 37231 705 3 remaining remain VBG 37231 705 4 seven seven CD 37231 705 5 there there EX 37231 705 6 are be VBP 37231 705 7 two two CD 37231 705 8 forms form NNS 37231 705 9 , , , 37231 705 10 one one PRP 37231 705 11 called call VBD 37231 705 12 the the DT 37231 705 13 Long Long NNP 37231 705 14 Recension Recension NNP 37231 705 15 and and CC 37231 705 16 another another DT 37231 705 17 shorter short JJR 37231 705 18 , , , 37231 705 19 known know VBN 37231 705 20 as as IN 37231 705 21 the the DT 37231 705 22 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 705 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 705 24 . . . 37231 706 1 The the DT 37231 706 2 former former JJ 37231 706 3 is be VBZ 37231 706 4 almost almost RB 37231 706 5 unanimously unanimously RB 37231 706 6 rejected reject VBN 37231 706 7 as as IN 37231 706 8 shamefully shamefully RB 37231 706 9 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 706 10 and and CC 37231 706 11 falsified falsify VBN 37231 706 12 ; ; : 37231 706 13 and and CC 37231 706 14 a a DT 37231 706 15 majority majority NN 37231 706 16 of of IN 37231 706 17 critics critic NNS 37231 706 18 assert assert VBP 37231 706 19 that that IN 37231 706 20 the the DT 37231 706 21 text text NN 37231 706 22 of of IN 37231 706 23 the the DT 37231 706 24 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 706 25 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 706 26 is be VBZ 37231 706 27 likewise likewise RB 37231 706 28 very very RB 37231 706 29 impure impure NN 37231 706 30 . . . 37231 707 1 Besides besides IN 37231 707 2 these these DT 37231 707 3 there there EX 37231 707 4 is be VBZ 37231 707 5 a a DT 37231 707 6 still still RB 37231 707 7 shorter short JJR 37231 707 8 version version NN 37231 707 9 of of IN 37231 707 10 three three CD 37231 707 11 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 707 12 only only RB 37231 707 13 , , , 37231 707 14 the the DT 37231 707 15 Cure Cure NNP 37231 707 16 - - HYPH 37231 707 17 tonian tonian NNP 37231 707 18 , , , 37231 707 19 which which WDT 37231 707 20 many many JJ 37231 707 21 able able JJ 37231 707 22 critics critic NNS 37231 707 23 declare declare VBP 37231 707 24 to to TO 37231 707 25 be be VB 37231 707 26 the the DT 37231 707 27 only only JJ 37231 707 28 genuine genuine JJ 37231 707 29 letters letter NNS 37231 707 30 of of IN 37231 707 31 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 707 32 , , , 37231 707 33 whilst whilst IN 37231 707 34 a a DT 37231 707 35 still still RB 37231 707 36 greater great JJR 37231 707 37 number number NN 37231 707 38 , , , 37231 707 39 both both CC 37231 707 40 from from IN 37231 707 41 internal internal JJ 37231 707 42 and and CC 37231 707 43 external external JJ 37231 707 44 reasons reason NNS 37231 707 45 , , , 37231 707 46 deny deny VB 37231 707 47 the the DT 37231 707 48 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 707 49 of of IN 37231 707 50 the the DT 37231 707 51 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 707 52 in in IN 37231 707 53 any any DT 37231 707 54 form form NN 37231 707 55 . . . 37231 708 1 The the DT 37231 708 2 second second JJ 37231 708 3 and and CC 37231 708 4 third third JJ 37231 708 5 centuries century NNS 37231 708 6 teem teem VBP 37231 708 7 with with IN 37231 708 8 pseudonymic pseudonymic JJ 37231 708 9 literature literature NN 37231 708 10 , , , 37231 708 11 but but CC 37231 708 12 I -PRON- PRP 37231 708 13 venture venture VBP 37231 708 14 to to TO 37231 708 15 say say VB 37231 708 16 that that IN 37231 708 17 pious pious JJ 37231 708 18 fraud fraud NN 37231 708 19 has have VBZ 37231 708 20 never never RB 37231 708 21 been be VBN 37231 708 22 more more RBR 37231 708 23 busy busy JJ 37231 708 24 and and CC 37231 708 25 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 37231 708 26 than than IN 37231 708 27 in in IN 37231 708 28 dealing deal VBG 37231 708 29 with with IN 37231 708 30 the the DT 37231 708 31 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 708 32 of of IN 37231 708 33 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 708 34 . . . 37231 709 1 The the DT 37231 709 2 mere mere JJ 37231 709 3 statement statement NN 37231 709 4 of of IN 37231 709 5 the the DT 37231 709 6 simple simple JJ 37231 709 7 and and CC 37231 709 8 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 37231 709 9 facts fact NNS 37231 709 10 regarding regard VBG 37231 709 11 the the DT 37231 709 12 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 709 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 709 14 is be VBZ 37231 709 15 ample ample JJ 37231 709 16 justification justification NN 37231 709 17 of of IN 37231 709 18 the the DT 37231 709 19 assertion assertion NN 37231 709 20 , , , 37231 709 21 which which WDT 37231 709 22 so so RB 37231 709 23 mightily mightily RB 37231 709 24 offends offend VBZ 37231 709 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 709 26 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 709 27 , , , 37231 709 28 that that IN 37231 709 29 " " `` 37231 709 30 the the DT 37231 709 31 whole whole NN 37231 709 32 of of IN 37231 709 33 the the DT 37231 709 34 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 709 35 literature literature NN 37231 709 36 is be VBZ 37231 709 37 a a DT 37231 709 38 mass mass NN 37231 709 39 of of IN 37231 709 40 falsification falsification NN 37231 709 41 and and CC 37231 709 42 fraud fraud NN 37231 709 43 . . . 37231 709 44 " " '' 37231 710 1 Even even RB 37231 710 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 710 3 indignant indignant JJ 37231 710 4 critic critic NN 37231 710 5 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 710 6 has have VBZ 37231 710 7 not not RB 37231 710 8 ventured venture VBN 37231 710 9 to to TO 37231 710 10 use use VB 37231 710 11 as as RB 37231 710 12 genuine genuine JJ 37231 710 13 more more JJR 37231 710 14 than than IN 37231 710 15 the the DT 37231 710 16 three three CD 37231 710 17 short short JJ 37231 710 18 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 710 19 letters(1 letters(1 NN 37231 710 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 710 21 out out IN 37231 710 22 of of IN 37231 710 23 this this DT 37231 710 24 mass mass NN 37231 710 25 of of IN 37231 710 26 forgery forgery NN 37231 710 27 which which WDT 37231 710 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 710 29 rebukes rebuke VBZ 37231 710 30 me -PRON- PRP 37231 710 31 for for IN 37231 710 32 holding hold VBG 37231 710 33 so so RB 37231 710 34 cheap cheap JJ 37231 710 35 . . . 37231 711 1 Documents document NNS 37231 711 2 which which WDT 37231 711 3 lie lie VBP 37231 711 4 under under IN 37231 711 5 such such JJ 37231 711 6 grave grave JJ 37231 711 7 and and CC 37231 711 8 permanent permanent JJ 37231 711 9 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 711 10 can can MD 37231 711 11 not not RB 37231 711 12 prove prove VB 37231 711 13 anything anything NN 37231 711 14 . . . 37231 712 1 As as IN 37231 712 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 712 3 have have VBP 37231 712 4 shown show VBN 37231 712 5 , , , 37231 712 6 however however RB 37231 712 7 , , , 37231 712 8 the the DT 37231 712 9 Vossian Vossian NNP 37231 712 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 712 11 , , , 37231 712 12 whatever whatever WDT 37231 712 13 the the DT 37231 712 14 value value NN 37231 712 15 of of IN 37231 712 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 712 17 testimony testimony NN 37231 712 18 , , , 37231 712 19 so so RB 37231 712 20 far far RB 37231 712 21 from from IN 37231 712 22 supporting support VBG 37231 712 23 the the DT 37231 712 24 claims claim NNS 37231 712 25 advanced advance VBN 37231 712 26 in in IN 37231 712 27 favour favour NN 37231 712 28 of of IN 37231 712 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 712 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 712 31 , , , 37231 712 32 rather rather RB 37231 712 33 discredit discredit VB 37231 712 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 712 35 . . . 37231 713 1 { { -LRB- 37231 713 2 lxxx lxxx NNP 37231 713 3 } } -RRB- 37231 713 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 713 5 have have VBP 37231 713 6 now now RB 37231 713 7 minutely minutely RB 37231 713 8 followed follow VBN 37231 713 9 Professor Professor NNP 37231 713 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 713 11 and and CC 37231 713 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 713 13 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 713 14 in in IN 37231 713 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 713 16 attacks attack NNS 37231 713 17 upon upon IN 37231 713 18 me -PRON- PRP 37231 713 19 in in IN 37231 713 20 connection connection NN 37231 713 21 with with IN 37231 713 22 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 713 23 and and CC 37231 713 24 the the DT 37231 713 25 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 713 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 713 27 , , , 37231 713 28 and and CC 37231 713 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 713 30 trust trust VBP 37231 713 31 that that IN 37231 713 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 713 33 have have VBP 37231 713 34 shown show VBN 37231 713 35 once once RB 37231 713 36 for for IN 37231 713 37 all all DT 37231 713 38 that that WDT 37231 713 39 the the DT 37231 713 40 charges charge NNS 37231 713 41 of of IN 37231 713 42 " " `` 37231 713 43 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 37231 713 44 " " '' 37231 713 45 and and CC 37231 713 46 " " `` 37231 713 47 misstatement misstatement NN 37231 713 48 " " '' 37231 713 49 so so RB 37231 713 50 lightly lightly RB 37231 713 51 and and CC 37231 713 52 liberally liberally RB 37231 713 53 advanced advanced JJ 37231 713 54 , , , 37231 713 55 far far RB 37231 713 56 from from IN 37231 713 57 being be VBG 37231 713 58 well well RB 37231 713 59 - - HYPH 37231 713 60 founded found VBN 37231 713 61 , , , 37231 713 62 recoil recoil VB 37231 713 63 upon upon IN 37231 713 64 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 713 65 . . . 37231 714 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 714 2 is be VBZ 37231 714 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 714 4 in in IN 37231 714 5 a a DT 37231 714 6 work work NN 37231 714 7 like like IN 37231 714 8 this this DT 37231 714 9 , , , 37231 714 10 dealing deal VBG 37231 714 11 with with IN 37231 714 12 such such JJ 37231 714 13 voluminous voluminous JJ 37231 714 14 materials material NNS 37231 714 15 , , , 37231 714 16 to to TO 37231 714 17 escape escape VB 37231 714 18 errors error NNS 37231 714 19 of of IN 37231 714 20 detail detail NN 37231 714 21 , , , 37231 714 22 as as IN 37231 714 23 both both DT 37231 714 24 of of IN 37231 714 25 these these DT 37231 714 26 gentlemen gentleman NNS 37231 714 27 bear bear VBP 37231 714 28 witness witness NN 37231 714 29 , , , 37231 714 30 but but CC 37231 714 31 I -PRON- PRP 37231 714 32 have have VBP 37231 714 33 at at IN 37231 714 34 least least JJS 37231 714 35 conscientiously conscientiously RB 37231 714 36 endeavoured endeavour VBN 37231 714 37 to to TO 37231 714 38 be be VB 37231 714 39 fair fair JJ 37231 714 40 , , , 37231 714 41 and and CC 37231 714 42 I -PRON- PRP 37231 714 43 venture venture VBP 37231 714 44 to to TO 37231 714 45 think think VB 37231 714 46 that that IN 37231 714 47 few few JJ 37231 714 48 writers writer NNS 37231 714 49 have have VBP 37231 714 50 ever ever RB 37231 714 51 more more RBR 37231 714 52 fully fully RB 37231 714 53 laid lay VBN 37231 714 54 before before IN 37231 714 55 readers reader NNS 37231 714 56 the the DT 37231 714 57 actual actual JJ 37231 714 58 means mean NNS 37231 714 59 of of IN 37231 714 60 judging judging NN 37231 714 61 of of IN 37231 714 62 the the DT 37231 714 63 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 714 64 of of IN 37231 714 65 every every DT 37231 714 66 statement statement NN 37231 714 67 which which WDT 37231 714 68 has have VBZ 37231 714 69 been be VBN 37231 714 70 made make VBN 37231 714 71 . . . 37231 715 1 Before before IN 37231 715 2 closing closing NN 37231 715 3 , , , 37231 715 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 715 5 must must MD 37231 715 6 say say VB 37231 715 7 a a DT 37231 715 8 few few JJ 37231 715 9 words word NNS 37231 715 10 regarding regard VBG 37231 715 11 another another DT 37231 715 12 of of IN 37231 715 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 715 14 critics critic NNS 37231 715 15 , , , 37231 715 16 who who WP 37231 715 17 is be VBZ 37231 715 18 , , , 37231 715 19 however however RB 37231 715 20 , , , 37231 715 21 of of IN 37231 715 22 a a DT 37231 715 23 very very RB 37231 715 24 different different JJ 37231 715 25 order order NN 37231 715 26 . . . 37231 716 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 716 2 system system NN 37231 716 3 of of IN 37231 716 4 criticism criticism NN 37231 716 5 is be VBZ 37231 716 6 naturally naturally RB 37231 716 7 uncongenial uncongenial JJ 37231 716 8 to to IN 37231 716 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 716 10 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 716 11 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 716 12 , , , 37231 716 13 but but CC 37231 716 14 while while IN 37231 716 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 716 16 says say VBZ 37231 716 17 so so RB 37231 716 18 with with IN 37231 716 19 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 716 20 vigour vigour NN 37231 716 21 , , , 37231 716 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 716 23 likewise likewise RB 37231 716 24 speaks speak VBZ 37231 716 25 of of IN 37231 716 26 this this DT 37231 716 27 work work NN 37231 716 28 with with IN 37231 716 29 equally equally RB 37231 716 30 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 716 31 generosity generosity NN 37231 716 32 , , , 37231 716 33 and and CC 37231 716 34 I -PRON- PRP 37231 716 35 cordially cordially RB 37231 716 36 thank thank VBP 37231 716 37 him -PRON- PRP 37231 716 38 . . . 37231 717 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 717 2 could could MD 37231 717 3 only only RB 37231 717 4 be be VB 37231 717 5 classed class VBN 37231 717 6 by by IN 37231 717 7 mistake mistake NN 37231 717 8 amongst amongst IN 37231 717 9 the the DT 37231 717 10 " " `` 37231 717 11 objectors objector NNS 37231 717 12 " " '' 37231 717 13 to to IN 37231 717 14 " " `` 37231 717 15 Literature Literature NNP 37231 717 16 and and CC 37231 717 17 Dogma Dogma NNP 37231 717 18 , , , 37231 717 19 " " '' 37231 717 20 and and CC 37231 717 21 however however RB 37231 717 22 different different JJ 37231 717 23 may may MD 37231 717 24 be be VB 37231 717 25 the the DT 37231 717 26 procedure procedure NN 37231 717 27 in in IN 37231 717 28 " " `` 37231 717 29 Supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 717 30 Religion religion NN 37231 717 31 , , , 37231 717 32 " " '' 37231 717 33 there there EX 37231 717 34 is be VBZ 37231 717 35 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 717 36 agreement agreement NN 37231 717 37 between between IN 37231 717 38 the the DT 37231 717 39 two two CD 37231 717 40 works work NNS 37231 717 41 , , , 37231 717 42 and and CC 37231 717 43 the the DT 37231 717 44 one one NN 37231 717 45 may may MD 37231 717 46 be be VB 37231 717 47 considered consider VBN 37231 717 48 the the DT 37231 717 49 complement complement NN 37231 717 50 of of IN 37231 717 51 the the DT 37231 717 52 other other JJ 37231 717 53 . . . 37231 718 1 Some some DT 37231 718 2 one one PRP 37231 718 3 must must MD 37231 718 4 do do VB 37231 718 5 the the DT 37231 718 6 " " `` 37231 718 7 pounding pounding NN 37231 718 8 , , , 37231 718 9 " " '' 37231 718 10 if if IN 37231 718 11 religion religion NN 37231 718 12 is be VBZ 37231 718 13 to to TO 37231 718 14 be be VB 37231 718 15 a a DT 37231 718 16 matter matter NN 37231 718 17 of of IN 37231 718 18 belief belief NN 37231 718 19 and and CC 37231 718 20 not not RB 37231 718 21 of of IN 37231 718 22 mere mere JJ 37231 718 23 shifty shifty NN 37231 718 24 opinion opinion NN 37231 718 25 . . . 37231 719 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 719 2 really really RB 37231 719 3 address address VBP 37231 719 4 two two CD 37231 719 5 distinct distinct JJ 37231 719 6 classes class NNS 37231 719 7 of of IN 37231 719 8 readers reader NNS 37231 719 9 . . . 37231 720 1 The the DT 37231 720 2 reader reader NN 37231 720 3 who who WP 37231 720 4 " " `` 37231 720 5 has have VBZ 37231 720 6 read read VBN 37231 720 7 _ _ NNP 37231 720 8 and and CC 37231 720 9 accepted accept VBD 37231 720 10 _ _ NNP 37231 720 11 " " '' 37231 720 12 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 720 13 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 720 14 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 720 15 's 's POS 37231 720 16 " " `` 37231 720 17 half half JJ 37231 720 18 dozen dozen NN 37231 720 19 lines line NNS 37231 720 20 about about IN 37231 720 21 the the DT 37231 720 22 composition composition NN 37231 720 23 of of IN 37231 720 24 the the DT 37231 720 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 720 26 , , , 37231 720 27 " " '' 37231 720 28 and and CC 37231 720 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 720 30 " " `` 37231 720 31 half half JJ 37231 720 32 dozen dozen NN 37231 720 33 pages page NNS 37231 720 34 about about IN 37231 720 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 720 36 , , , 37231 720 37 " " '' 37231 720 38 may may MD 37231 720 39 in in IN 37231 720 40 one one CD 37231 720 41 sense sense NN 37231 720 42 be be VB 37231 720 43 " " `` 37231 720 44 just just RB 37231 720 45 in in IN 37231 720 46 the the DT 37231 720 47 same same JJ 37231 720 48 position position NN 37231 720 49 as as IN 37231 720 50 when when WRB 37231 720 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 720 52 has have VBZ 37231 720 53 read read VBN 37231 720 54 " " `` 37231 720 55 the the DT 37231 720 56 whole whole NN 37231 720 57 of of IN 37231 720 58 this this DT 37231 720 59 work,(1 work,(1 NN 37231 720 60 ) ) -RRB- 37231 720 61 but but CC 37231 720 62 { { -LRB- 37231 720 63 lxxxi lxxxi NN 37231 720 64 } } -RRB- 37231 720 65 I -PRON- PRP 37231 720 66 have have VBP 37231 720 67 written write VBN 37231 720 68 for for IN 37231 720 69 those those DT 37231 720 70 who who WP 37231 720 71 do do VBP 37231 720 72 not not RB 37231 720 73 accept accept VB 37231 720 74 them -PRON- PRP 37231 720 75 , , , 37231 720 76 and and CC 37231 720 77 who,--as who,--as NNP 37231 720 78 I -PRON- PRP 37231 720 79 think think VBP 37231 720 80 rightly,--distrust rightly,--distrust IN 37231 720 81 the the DT 37231 720 82 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 720 83 merely merely RB 37231 720 84 forced force VBD 37231 720 85 upon upon IN 37231 720 86 them -PRON- PRP 37231 720 87 by by IN 37231 720 88 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 720 89 " " `` 37231 720 90 reflection reflection NN 37231 720 91 and and CC 37231 720 92 experience experience NN 37231 720 93 , , , 37231 720 94 " " '' 37231 720 95 and and CC 37231 720 96 in in IN 37231 720 97 such such JJ 37231 720 98 important important JJ 37231 720 99 matters matter NNS 37231 720 100 demand demand VBP 37231 720 101 evidence evidence NN 37231 720 102 of of IN 37231 720 103 a a DT 37231 720 104 much much RB 37231 720 105 more more RBR 37231 720 106 tangible tangible JJ 37231 720 107 kind kind NN 37231 720 108 . . . 37231 721 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 721 2 would would MD 37231 721 3 put put VB 37231 721 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 721 5 to to IN 37231 721 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 721 7 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 721 8 whether whether IN 37231 721 9 , , , 37231 721 10 in in IN 37231 721 11 seeming seem VBG 37231 721 12 to to TO 37231 721 13 depreciate depreciate VB 37231 721 14 any any DT 37231 721 15 attempt attempt NN 37231 721 16 to to TO 37231 721 17 systematize systematize VB 37231 721 18 and and CC 37231 721 19 carry carry VB 37231 721 20 to to IN 37231 721 21 logical logical JJ 37231 721 22 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 721 23 the the DT 37231 721 24 whole whole JJ 37231 721 25 argument argument NN 37231 721 26 regarding regard VBG 37231 721 27 the the DT 37231 721 28 reality reality NN 37231 721 29 of of IN 37231 721 30 Miracles Miracles NNPS 37231 721 31 and and CC 37231 721 32 Divine Divine NNP 37231 721 33 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 721 34 , , , 37231 721 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 721 36 does do VBZ 37231 721 37 not not RB 37231 721 38 do do VB 37231 721 39 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 721 40 injustice injustice VB 37231 721 41 , , , 37231 721 42 and and CC 37231 721 43 enunciate enunciate VB 37231 721 44 a a DT 37231 721 45 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 721 46 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 721 47 . . . 37231 722 1 No no RB 37231 722 2 doubt doubt RB 37231 722 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 722 4 own own JJ 37231 722 5 clear clear JJ 37231 722 6 insight insight NN 37231 722 7 and and CC 37231 722 8 wide wide JJ 37231 722 9 culture culture NN 37231 722 10 have have VBP 37231 722 11 enabled enable VBN 37231 722 12 him -PRON- PRP 37231 722 13 to to TO 37231 722 14 discern discern VB 37231 722 15 truth truth NN 37231 722 16 more more RBR 37231 722 17 surely surely RB 37231 722 18 , , , 37231 722 19 and and CC 37231 722 20 with with IN 37231 722 21 less less JJR 37231 722 22 apparent apparent JJ 37231 722 23 effort effort NN 37231 722 24 , , , 37231 722 25 than than IN 37231 722 26 most most JJS 37231 722 27 of of IN 37231 722 28 those those DT 37231 722 29 whom whom WP 37231 722 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 722 31 addresses address VBZ 37231 722 32 , , , 37231 722 33 but but CC 37231 722 34 in in IN 37231 722 35 encouraging encourage VBG 37231 722 36 , , , 37231 722 37 as as IN 37231 722 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 722 39 thus thus RB 37231 722 40 practically practically RB 37231 722 41 does do VBZ 37231 722 42 , , , 37231 722 43 the the DT 37231 722 44 adoption adoption NN 37231 722 45 by by IN 37231 722 46 others other NNS 37231 722 47 of of IN 37231 722 48 religious religious JJ 37231 722 49 views view NNS 37231 722 50 with with IN 37231 722 51 very very RB 37231 722 52 little little JJ 37231 722 53 trouble trouble NN 37231 722 54 or or CC 37231 722 55 thought thought NN 37231 722 56 , , , 37231 722 57 which which WDT 37231 722 58 have have VBP 37231 722 59 certainly certainly RB 37231 722 60 cost cost VBN 37231 722 61 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 722 62 years year NNS 37231 722 63 of of IN 37231 722 64 training training NN 37231 722 65 and and CC 37231 722 66 study study NN 37231 722 67 , , , 37231 722 68 he -PRON- PRP 37231 722 69 both both DT 37231 722 70 cheapens cheapen VBZ 37231 722 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 722 72 own own JJ 37231 722 73 intellectual intellectual JJ 37231 722 74 labour labour NN 37231 722 75 , , , 37231 722 76 and and CC 37231 722 77 advocates advocate VBZ 37231 722 78 a a DT 37231 722 79 superficiality superficiality NN 37231 722 80 which which WDT 37231 722 81 already already RB 37231 722 82 has have VBZ 37231 722 83 too too RB 37231 722 84 many many JJ 37231 722 85 attractions attraction NNS 37231 722 86 . . . 37231 723 1 Whether whether IN 37231 723 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 723 3 address address NN 37231 723 4 readers reader NNS 37231 723 5 whose whose WP$ 37231 723 6 belief belief NN 37231 723 7 is be VBZ 37231 723 8 already already RB 37231 723 9 established establish VBN 37231 723 10 , , , 37231 723 11 or or CC 37231 723 12 those those DT 37231 723 13 who who WP 37231 723 14 are be VBP 37231 723 15 ready ready JJ 37231 723 16 to to TO 37231 723 17 accept accept VB 37231 723 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 723 19 second second JJ 37231 723 20 hand hand NN 37231 723 21 from from IN 37231 723 22 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 723 23 , , , 37231 723 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 723 25 seems seem VBZ 37231 723 26 to to IN 37231 723 27 me -PRON- PRP 37231 723 28 that that IN 37231 723 29 no no DT 37231 723 30 work work NN 37231 723 31 should should MD 37231 723 32 be be VB 37231 723 33 unwelcome unwelcome JJ 37231 723 34 which which WDT 37231 723 35 supplies supply VBZ 37231 723 36 evidence evidence NN 37231 723 37 of of IN 37231 723 38 the the DT 37231 723 39 results result NNS 37231 723 40 , , , 37231 723 41 which which WDT 37231 723 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 723 43 has have VBZ 37231 723 44 suited suit VBN 37231 723 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 723 46 own own JJ 37231 723 47 immediate immediate JJ 37231 723 48 purpose purpose NN 37231 723 49 merely merely RB 37231 723 50 to to TO 37231 723 51 assume assume VB 37231 723 52 . . . 37231 724 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 724 2 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 724 3 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 724 4 objects object VBZ 37231 724 5 that that IN 37231 724 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 724 7 book book NN 37231 724 8 leaves leave VBZ 37231 724 9 the the DT 37231 724 10 reader reader NN 37231 724 11 " " '' 37231 724 12 with with IN 37231 724 13 the the DT 37231 724 14 feeling feeling NN 37231 724 15 that that IN 37231 724 16 the the DT 37231 724 17 Bible Bible NNP 37231 724 18 stands stand VBZ 37231 724 19 before before IN 37231 724 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 724 21 like like IN 37231 724 22 a a DT 37231 724 23 fair fair JJ 37231 724 24 tree tree NN 37231 724 25 all all DT 37231 724 26 stripped strip VBD 37231 724 27 , , , 37231 724 28 torn tear VBN 37231 724 29 and and CC 37231 724 30 defaced deface VBN 37231 724 31 , , , 37231 724 32 not not RB 37231 724 33 at at RB 37231 724 34 all all RB 37231 724 35 like like IN 37231 724 36 a a DT 37231 724 37 tree tree NN 37231 724 38 whose whose WP$ 37231 724 39 leaves leave NNS 37231 724 40 are be VBP 37231 724 41 for for IN 37231 724 42 the the DT 37231 724 43 healing healing NN 37231 724 44 of of IN 37231 724 45 the the DT 37231 724 46 nations,"(1 nations,"(1 ADD 37231 724 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 724 48 but but CC 37231 724 49 if if IN 37231 724 50 this this DT 37231 724 51 be be VB 37231 724 52 the the DT 37231 724 53 case case NN 37231 724 54 , , , 37231 724 55 I -PRON- PRP 37231 724 56 submit submit VBP 37231 724 57 that that IN 37231 724 58 it -PRON- PRP 37231 724 59 is be VBZ 37231 724 60 a a DT 37231 724 61 necessary necessary JJ 37231 724 62 process process NN 37231 724 63 through through IN 37231 724 64 which which WDT 37231 724 65 the the DT 37231 724 66 Bible Bible NNP 37231 724 67 must must MD 37231 724 68 go go VB 37231 724 69 , , , 37231 724 70 before before IN 37231 724 71 it -PRON- PRP 37231 724 72 can can MD 37231 724 73 be be VB 37231 724 74 successfully successfully RB 37231 724 75 transplanted transplant VBN 37231 724 76 into into IN 37231 724 77 that that DT 37231 724 78 healthy healthy JJ 37231 724 79 soil soil NN 37231 724 80 , , , 37231 724 81 in in IN 37231 724 82 which which WDT 37231 724 83 alone alone RB 37231 724 84 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 724 85 leaves leave NNS 37231 724 86 can can MD 37231 724 87 truly truly RB 37231 724 88 be be VB 37231 724 89 for for IN 37231 724 90 the the DT 37231 724 91 44 44 CD 37231 724 92 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 37231 724 93 Boviow Boviow NNP 37231 724 94 , , , 37231 724 95 " " '' 37231 724 96 October October NNP 37231 724 97 , , , 37231 724 98 1874 1874 CD 37231 724 99 , , , 37231 724 100 p. p. NN 37231 724 101 798 798 CD 37231 724 102 . . . 37231 725 1 { { -LRB- 37231 725 2 lxxxii lxxxii NN 37231 725 3 } } -RRB- 37231 725 4 healing healing NN 37231 725 5 of of IN 37231 725 6 any any DT 37231 725 7 one one CD 37231 725 8 . . . 37231 726 1 Under under IN 37231 726 2 such such JJ 37231 726 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 726 4 , , , 37231 726 5 destructive destructive JJ 37231 726 6 must must MD 37231 726 7 precede precede VB 37231 726 8 constructive constructive JJ 37231 726 9 criticism criticism NN 37231 726 10 . . . 37231 727 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 727 2 is be VBZ 37231 727 3 only only RB 37231 727 4 when when WRB 37231 727 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 727 6 clearly clearly RB 37231 727 7 recognize recognize VBP 37231 727 8 that that IN 37231 727 9 the the DT 37231 727 10 Bible Bible NNP 37231 727 11 is be VBZ 37231 727 12 not not RB 37231 727 13 the the DT 37231 727 14 " " `` 37231 727 15 word word NN 37231 727 16 of of IN 37231 727 17 God God NNP 37231 727 18 " " '' 37231 727 19 that that IN 37231 727 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 727 21 can can MD 37231 727 22 worthily worthily VB 37231 727 23 honour honour VB 37231 727 24 and and CC 37231 727 25 " " `` 37231 727 26 enjoy enjoy VB 37231 727 27 " " '' 37231 727 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 727 29 as as IN 37231 727 30 the the DT 37231 727 31 word word NN 37231 727 32 of of IN 37231 727 33 Man Man NNP 37231 727 34 . . . 37231 728 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 728 2 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 728 3 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 728 4 finely finely RB 37231 728 5 says say VBZ 37231 728 6 , , , 37231 728 7 with with IN 37231 728 8 regard regard NN 37231 728 9 to to IN 37231 728 10 what what WP 37231 728 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 728 12 said say VBD 37231 728 13 and and CC 37231 728 14 did do VBD 37231 728 15 , , , 37231 728 16 that that DT 37231 728 17 : : : 37231 728 18 " " `` 37231 728 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 728 20 reporters reporter NNS 37231 728 21 were be VBD 37231 728 22 incapable incapable JJ 37231 728 23 of of IN 37231 728 24 rendering render VBG 37231 728 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 728 26 , , , 37231 728 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 728 28 was be VBD 37231 728 29 so so RB 37231 728 30 much much JJ 37231 728 31 above above IN 37231 728 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 728 33 " " '' 37231 728 34 ; ; : 37231 728 35 and and CC 37231 728 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 728 37 rightly rightly RB 37231 728 38 considers consider VBZ 37231 728 39 that that IN 37231 728 40 the the DT 37231 728 41 governing govern VBG 37231 728 42 idea idea NN 37231 728 43 of of IN 37231 728 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 728 45 criticism criticism NN 37231 728 46 of of IN 37231 728 47 the the DT 37231 728 48 four four CD 37231 728 49 Evangelists Evangelists NNPS 37231 728 50 should should MD 37231 728 51 be be VB 37231 728 52 " " `` 37231 728 53 to to TO 37231 728 54 make make VB 37231 728 55 out out RP 37231 728 56 what what WP 37231 728 57 in in IN 37231 728 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 728 59 report report NN 37231 728 60 of of IN 37231 728 61 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 728 62 , , , 37231 728 63 is be VBZ 37231 728 64 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 728 65 , , , 37231 728 66 and and CC 37231 728 67 what what WP 37231 728 68 is be VBZ 37231 728 69 the the DT 37231 728 70 reporters reporter NNS 37231 728 71 . . . 37231 728 72 " " '' 37231 729 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 729 2 hold hold VBP 37231 729 3 , , , 37231 729 4 however however RB 37231 729 5 , , , 37231 729 6 that that IN 37231 729 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 729 8 is be VBZ 37231 729 9 only only RB 37231 729 10 after after IN 37231 729 11 such such PDT 37231 729 12 an an DT 37231 729 13 examination examination NN 37231 729 14 as as IN 37231 729 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 729 16 have have VBP 37231 729 17 endeavoured endeavour VBN 37231 729 18 to to TO 37231 729 19 carry carry VB 37231 729 20 out out RP 37231 729 21 , , , 37231 729 22 and and CC 37231 729 23 which which WDT 37231 729 24 for for IN 37231 729 25 the the DT 37231 729 26 time time NN 37231 729 27 must must MD 37231 729 28 seem seem VB 37231 729 29 hard hard RB 37231 729 30 and and CC 37231 729 31 wanting want VBG 37231 729 32 in in IN 37231 729 33 sympathetic sympathetic JJ 37231 729 34 appreciation appreciation NN 37231 729 35 , , , 37231 729 36 that that IN 37231 729 37 most most JJS 37231 729 38 persons person NNS 37231 729 39 educated educate VBN 37231 729 40 in in IN 37231 729 41 Christendom Christendom NNP 37231 729 42 can can MD 37231 729 43 rightly rightly RB 37231 729 44 put put VB 37231 729 45 any any DT 37231 729 46 such such JJ 37231 729 47 governing govern VBG 37231 729 48 idea idea NN 37231 729 49 into into IN 37231 729 50 practice practice NN 37231 729 51 . . . 37231 730 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 730 2 is be VBZ 37231 730 3 only only RB 37231 730 4 when when WRB 37231 730 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 730 6 are be VBP 37231 730 7 entitled entitle VBN 37231 730 8 to to TO 37231 730 9 reject reject VB 37231 730 10 the the DT 37231 730 11 theory theory NN 37231 730 12 of of IN 37231 730 13 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 730 14 Divine Divine NNP 37231 730 15 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 730 16 that that IN 37231 730 17 the the DT 37231 730 18 Bible Bible NNP 37231 730 19 attains attain VBZ 37231 730 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 730 21 full full JJ 37231 730 22 beauty beauty NN 37231 730 23 , , , 37231 730 24 losing lose VBG 37231 730 25 the the DT 37231 730 26 blots blot NNS 37231 730 27 and and CC 37231 730 28 anomalies anomaly NNS 37231 730 29 which which WDT 37231 730 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 730 31 presented present VBD 37231 730 32 in in IN 37231 730 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 730 34 former former JJ 37231 730 35 character character NN 37231 730 36 , , , 37231 730 37 and and CC 37231 730 38 acquiring acquire VBG 37231 730 39 wondrous wondrous JJ 37231 730 40 significance significance NN 37231 730 41 as as IN 37231 730 42 the the DT 37231 730 43 expression expression NN 37231 730 44 of of IN 37231 730 45 the the DT 37231 730 46 hopes hope NNS 37231 730 47 and and CC 37231 730 48 aspirations aspiration NNS 37231 730 49 of of IN 37231 730 50 humanity humanity NN 37231 730 51 , , , 37231 730 52 from from IN 37231 730 53 which which WDT 37231 730 54 every every DT 37231 730 55 man man NN 37231 730 56 may may MD 37231 730 57 learn learn VB 37231 730 58 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 730 59 and and CC 37231 730 60 derive derive VB 37231 730 61 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 730 62 . . . 37231 731 1 The the DT 37231 731 2 value value NN 37231 731 3 of of IN 37231 731 4 such such PDT 37231 731 5 a a DT 37231 731 6 Book Book NNP 37231 731 7 seems seem VBZ 37231 731 8 to to IN 37231 731 9 me -PRON- PRP 37231 731 10 indestructible indestructible JJ 37231 731 11 . . . 37231 732 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 732 2 heartily heartily RB 37231 732 3 sympathise sympathise VBP 37231 732 4 with with IN 37231 732 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 732 6 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 732 7 's 's POS 37231 732 8 desire desire NN 37231 732 9 to to TO 37231 732 10 secure secure VB 37231 732 11 due due JJ 37231 732 12 appreciation appreciation NN 37231 732 13 for for IN 37231 732 14 the the DT 37231 732 15 venerable venerable JJ 37231 732 16 volume volume NN 37231 732 17 , , , 37231 732 18 of of IN 37231 732 19 the the DT 37231 732 20 beauty beauty NN 37231 732 21 of of IN 37231 732 22 which which WDT 37231 732 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 732 24 has have VBZ 37231 732 25 so so RB 37231 732 26 fine fine JJ 37231 732 27 and and CC 37231 732 28 delicate delicate VB 37231 732 29 a a DT 37231 732 30 perception perception NN 37231 732 31 . . . 37231 733 1 A a DT 37231 733 2 truer truer NN 37231 733 3 insight insight NN 37231 733 4 into into IN 37231 733 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 733 6 meaning meaning NN 37231 733 7 may may MD 37231 733 8 certainly certainly RB 37231 733 9 be be VB 37231 733 10 imparted impart VBN 37231 733 11 by by IN 37231 733 12 such such JJ 37231 733 13 eloquent eloquent NN 37231 733 14 and and CC 37231 733 15 appreciating appreciate VBG 37231 733 16 criticism criticism NN 37231 733 17 , , , 37231 733 18 and and CC 37231 733 19 no no DT 37231 733 20 one one NN 37231 733 21 is be VBZ 37231 733 22 a a DT 37231 733 23 better well JJR 37231 733 24 judge judge NN 37231 733 25 than than IN 37231 733 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 733 27 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 733 28 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 733 29 of of IN 37231 733 30 the the DT 37231 733 31 necessity necessity NN 37231 733 32 to to TO 37231 733 33 plead plead VB 37231 733 34 for for IN 37231 733 35 the the DT 37231 733 36 Book Book NNP 37231 733 37 , , , 37231 733 38 with with IN 37231 733 39 those those DT 37231 733 40 who who WP 37231 733 41 are be VBP 37231 733 42 inclined incline VBN 37231 733 43 thoughtlessly thoughtlessly RB 37231 733 44 to to TO 37231 733 45 reject reject VB 37231 733 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 733 47 along along IN 37231 733 48 with with IN 37231 733 49 the the DT 37231 733 50 errors error NNS 37231 733 51 which which WDT 37231 733 52 have have VBP 37231 733 53 grown grow VBN 37231 733 54 with with IN 37231 733 55 and and CC 37231 733 56 been be VBN 37231 733 57 based base VBN 37231 733 58 upon upon IN 37231 733 59 it -PRON- PRP 37231 733 60 . . . 37231 734 1 But but CC 37231 734 2 , , , 37231 734 3 in in IN 37231 734 4 the the DT 37231 734 5 end end NN 37231 734 6 , , , 37231 734 7 every every DT 37231 734 8 man man NN 37231 734 9 who who WP 37231 734 10 { { -LRB- 37231 734 11 lxxxiii lxxxiii NN 37231 734 12 } } -RRB- 37231 734 13 has have VBZ 37231 734 14 a a DT 37231 734 15 mind mind NN 37231 734 16 and and CC 37231 734 17 a a DT 37231 734 18 heart heart NN 37231 734 19 must must MD 37231 734 20 love love VB 37231 734 21 and and CC 37231 734 22 honour honour VB 37231 734 23 the the DT 37231 734 24 Bible Bible NNP 37231 734 25 , , , 37231 734 26 and and CC 37231 734 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 734 28 who who WP 37231 734 29 has have VBZ 37231 734 30 neither neither CC 37231 734 31 is be VBZ 37231 734 32 beyond beyond IN 37231 734 33 the the DT 37231 734 34 reach reach NN 37231 734 35 of of IN 37231 734 36 persuasion persuasion NN 37231 734 37 . . . 37231 735 1 This this DT 37231 735 2 work work NN 37231 735 3 has have VBZ 37231 735 4 been be VBN 37231 735 5 revised revise VBN 37231 735 6 throughout throughout IN 37231 735 7 . . . 37231 736 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 736 2 1 1 LS 37231 736 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 736 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 736 5 was be VBD 37231 736 6 , , , 37231 736 7 as as IN 37231 736 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 736 9 stated state VBD 37231 736 10 at at IN 37231 736 11 the the DT 37231 736 12 time time NN 37231 736 13 , , , 37231 736 14 originally originally RB 37231 736 15 carried carry VBN 37231 736 16 through through IN 37231 736 17 the the DT 37231 736 18 press press NN 37231 736 19 under under IN 37231 736 20 very very RB 37231 736 21 great great JJ 37231 736 22 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 736 23 , , , 37231 736 24 and and CC 37231 736 25 the the DT 37231 736 26 revision revision NN 37231 736 27 of of IN 37231 736 28 details detail NNS 37231 736 29 , , , 37231 736 30 upon upon IN 37231 736 31 which which WDT 37231 736 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 736 33 had have VBD 37231 736 34 counted count VBN 37231 736 35 , , , 37231 736 36 was be VBD 37231 736 37 not not RB 37231 736 38 only only RB 37231 736 39 prevented prevent VBN 37231 736 40 , , , 37231 736 41 but but CC 37231 736 42 , , , 37231 736 43 beyond beyond IN 37231 736 44 a a DT 37231 736 45 careful careful JJ 37231 736 46 revision revision NN 37231 736 47 of of IN 37231 736 48 the the DT 37231 736 49 First First NNP 37231 736 50 Part Part NNP 37231 736 51 for for IN 37231 736 52 the the DT 37231 736 53 second second JJ 37231 736 54 edition edition NN 37231 736 55 , , , 37231 736 56 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 736 57 have have VBP 37231 736 58 until until IN 37231 736 59 now now RB 37231 736 60 even even RB 37231 736 61 prevented prevent VBN 37231 736 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 736 63 seriously seriously RB 37231 736 64 reading read VBG 37231 736 65 through through IN 37231 736 66 the the DT 37231 736 67 work work NN 37231 736 68 since since IN 37231 736 69 it -PRON- PRP 37231 736 70 has have VBZ 37231 736 71 been be VBN 37231 736 72 in in IN 37231 736 73 print print NN 37231 736 74 . . . 37231 737 1 To to IN 37231 737 2 those those DT 37231 737 3 who who WP 37231 737 4 have have VBP 37231 737 5 been be VBN 37231 737 6 good good JJ 37231 737 7 enough enough RB 37231 737 8 to to TO 37231 737 9 call call VB 37231 737 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 737 11 attention attention NN 37231 737 12 to to IN 37231 737 13 errors error NNS 37231 737 14 , , , 37231 737 15 or or CC 37231 737 16 to to TO 37231 737 17 suggest suggest VB 37231 737 18 improvements improvement NNS 37231 737 19 , , , 37231 737 20 I -PRON- PRP 37231 737 21 return return VBP 37231 737 22 very very RB 37231 737 23 sincere sincere JJ 37231 737 24 thanks thank NNS 37231 737 25 . . . 37231 738 1 In in IN 37231 738 2 making make VBG 37231 738 3 this this DT 37231 738 4 revision revision NN 37231 738 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 738 6 have have VBP 37231 738 7 endeavoured endeavour VBN 37231 738 8 to to TO 37231 738 9 modify modify VB 37231 738 10 unimportant unimportant JJ 37231 738 11 points point NNS 37231 738 12 , , , 37231 738 13 in in IN 37231 738 14 some some DT 37231 738 15 of of IN 37231 738 16 which which WDT 37231 738 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 738 18 have have VBP 37231 738 19 been be VBN 37231 738 20 misunderstood misunderstood NN 37231 738 21 , , , 37231 738 22 so so IN 37231 738 23 as as IN 37231 738 24 to to TO 37231 738 25 avoid avoid VB 37231 738 26 as as RB 37231 738 27 far far RB 37231 738 28 as as IN 37231 738 29 possible possible JJ 37231 738 30 raising raise VBG 37231 738 31 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 738 32 , , , 37231 738 33 or or CC 37231 738 34 inviting invite VBG 37231 738 35 discussion discussion NN 37231 738 36 without without IN 37231 738 37 real real JJ 37231 738 38 bearing bearing NN 37231 738 39 upon upon IN 37231 738 40 the the DT 37231 738 41 main main JJ 37231 738 42 argument argument NN 37231 738 43 . . . 37231 739 1 As as IN 37231 739 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 739 3 know know VBP 37231 739 4 the the DT 37231 739 5 alacrity alacrity NN 37231 739 6 with with IN 37231 739 7 which which WDT 37231 739 8 some some DT 37231 739 9 critics critic NNS 37231 739 10 seize seize VBP 37231 739 11 upon upon IN 37231 739 12 such such JJ 37231 739 13 points point NNS 37231 739 14 as as IN 37231 739 15 serious serious JJ 37231 739 16 concessions concession NNS 37231 739 17 , , , 37231 739 18 I -PRON- PRP 37231 739 19 beg beg VBP 37231 739 20 leave leave VBP 37231 739 21 to to TO 37231 739 22 say say VB 37231 739 23 that that IN 37231 739 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 739 25 have have VBP 37231 739 26 not not RB 37231 739 27 altered alter VBN 37231 739 28 anything anything NN 37231 739 29 from from IN 37231 739 30 change change NN 37231 739 31 of of IN 37231 739 32 opinion opinion NN 37231 739 33 . . . 37231 740 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 740 2 trust trust VBP 37231 740 3 that that IN 37231 740 4 greater great JJR 37231 740 5 clearness clearness NN 37231 740 6 and and CC 37231 740 7 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 740 8 may may MD 37231 740 9 have have VB 37231 740 10 been be VBN 37231 740 11 secured secure VBN 37231 740 12 . . . 37231 741 1 March March NNP 37231 741 2 15th 15th NN 37231 741 3 , , , 37231 741 4 1875 1875 CD 37231 741 5 . . . 37231 742 1 1 1 LS 37231 742 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 742 3 is be VBZ 37231 742 4 right right JJ 37231 742 5 to to TO 37231 742 6 mention mention VB 37231 742 7 that that IN 37231 742 8 , , , 37231 742 9 whilst whilst IN 37231 742 10 I -PRON- PRP 37231 742 11 have have VBP 37231 742 12 examined examine VBN 37231 742 13 a a DT 37231 742 14 great great JJ 37231 742 15 many many JJ 37231 742 16 of of IN 37231 742 17 the the DT 37231 742 18 references reference NNS 37231 742 19 , , , 37231 742 20 I -PRON- PRP 37231 742 21 have have VBP 37231 742 22 not not RB 37231 742 23 had have VBN 37231 742 24 time time NN 37231 742 25 to to TO 37231 742 26 verify verify VB 37231 742 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 742 28 all all DT 37231 742 29 . . . 37231 743 1 PREFACE preface VB 37231 743 2 TO to IN 37231 743 3 THE the DT 37231 743 4 FIRST FIRST NNP 37231 743 5 EDITION EDITION NNP 37231 743 6 . . . 37231 744 1 The the DT 37231 744 2 present present JJ 37231 744 3 work work NN 37231 744 4 is be VBZ 37231 744 5 the the DT 37231 744 6 result result NN 37231 744 7 of of IN 37231 744 8 many many JJ 37231 744 9 years year NNS 37231 744 10 of of IN 37231 744 11 earnest earnest JJ 37231 744 12 and and CC 37231 744 13 serious serious JJ 37231 744 14 investigation investigation NN 37231 744 15 , , , 37231 744 16 undertaken undertake VBN 37231 744 17 in in IN 37231 744 18 the the DT 37231 744 19 first first JJ 37231 744 20 instance instance NN 37231 744 21 for for IN 37231 744 22 the the DT 37231 744 23 regulation regulation NN 37231 744 24 of of IN 37231 744 25 personal personal JJ 37231 744 26 belief belief NN 37231 744 27 , , , 37231 744 28 and and CC 37231 744 29 now now RB 37231 744 30 published publish VBN 37231 744 31 as as IN 37231 744 32 a a DT 37231 744 33 contribution contribution NN 37231 744 34 towards towards IN 37231 744 35 the the DT 37231 744 36 establishment establishment NN 37231 744 37 of of IN 37231 744 38 Truth Truth NNP 37231 744 39 in in IN 37231 744 40 the the DT 37231 744 41 minds mind NNS 37231 744 42 of of IN 37231 744 43 others other NNS 37231 744 44 who who WP 37231 744 45 are be VBP 37231 744 46 seeking seek VBG 37231 744 47 for for IN 37231 744 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 744 49 . . . 37231 745 1 The the DT 37231 745 2 author author NN 37231 745 3 's 's POS 37231 745 4 main main JJ 37231 745 5 object object NN 37231 745 6 has have VBZ 37231 745 7 been be VBN 37231 745 8 conscientiously conscientiously RB 37231 745 9 and and CC 37231 745 10 fully fully RB 37231 745 11 to to TO 37231 745 12 state state VB 37231 745 13 the the DT 37231 745 14 facts fact NNS 37231 745 15 of of IN 37231 745 16 the the DT 37231 745 17 case case NN 37231 745 18 , , , 37231 745 19 to to TO 37231 745 20 make make VB 37231 745 21 no no DT 37231 745 22 assertions assertion NNS 37231 745 23 the the DT 37231 745 24 grounds ground NNS 37231 745 25 for for IN 37231 745 26 which which WDT 37231 745 27 are be VBP 37231 745 28 not not RB 37231 745 29 clearly clearly RB 37231 745 30 given give VBN 37231 745 31 , , , 37231 745 32 and and CC 37231 745 33 as as RB 37231 745 34 far far RB 37231 745 35 as as IN 37231 745 36 possible possible JJ 37231 745 37 to to TO 37231 745 38 place place VB 37231 745 39 before before IN 37231 745 40 the the DT 37231 745 41 reader reader NN 37231 745 42 the the DT 37231 745 43 materials material NNS 37231 745 44 from from IN 37231 745 45 which which WDT 37231 745 46 a a DT 37231 745 47 judgment judgment NN 37231 745 48 may may MD 37231 745 49 be be VB 37231 745 50 intelligently intelligently RB 37231 745 51 formed form VBN 37231 745 52 regarding regard VBG 37231 745 53 the the DT 37231 745 54 important important JJ 37231 745 55 subject subject NN 37231 745 56 discussed discuss VBN 37231 745 57 . . . 37231 746 1 The the DT 37231 746 2 great great JJ 37231 746 3 Teacher teacher NN 37231 746 4 is be VBZ 37231 746 5 reported report VBN 37231 746 6 to to TO 37231 746 7 have have VB 37231 746 8 said say VBD 37231 746 9 : : : 37231 746 10 " " `` 37231 746 11 Be be VB 37231 746 12 ye ye NNP 37231 746 13 approved approve VBN 37231 746 14 money money NN 37231 746 15 - - HYPH 37231 746 16 changers changer NNS 37231 746 17 , , , 37231 746 18 " " '' 37231 746 19 wisely wisely RB 37231 746 20 discerning discern VBG 37231 746 21 the the DT 37231 746 22 gold gold NN 37231 746 23 of of IN 37231 746 24 Truth Truth NNP 37231 746 25 , , , 37231 746 26 and and CC 37231 746 27 no no DT 37231 746 28 man man NN 37231 746 29 need nee MD 37231 746 30 hesitate hesitate VB 37231 746 31 honestly honestly RB 37231 746 32 to to TO 37231 746 33 test test VB 37231 746 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 746 35 reality reality NN 37231 746 36 , , , 37231 746 37 and and CC 37231 746 38 unflinchingly unflinchingly RB 37231 746 39 to to TO 37231 746 40 reject reject VB 37231 746 41 base base NN 37231 746 42 counterfeits counterfeit NNS 37231 746 43 . . . 37231 747 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 747 2 is be VBZ 37231 747 3 obvious obvious JJ 37231 747 4 that that IN 37231 747 5 the the DT 37231 747 6 most most RBS 37231 747 7 indispensable indispensable JJ 37231 747 8 requisite requisite NN 37231 747 9 in in IN 37231 747 10 regard regard NN 37231 747 11 to to IN 37231 747 12 Religion religion NN 37231 747 13 is be VBZ 37231 747 14 that that IN 37231 747 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 747 16 should should MD 37231 747 17 be be VB 37231 747 18 true true JJ 37231 747 19 . . . 37231 748 1 No no DT 37231 748 2 specious specious JJ 37231 748 3 hopes hope NNS 37231 748 4 or or CC 37231 748 5 flattering flattering JJ 37231 748 6 promises promise NNS 37231 748 7 can can MD 37231 748 8 have have VB 37231 748 9 the the DT 37231 748 10 slightest slight JJS 37231 748 11 value value NN 37231 748 12 unless unless IN 37231 748 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 748 14 be be VBP 37231 748 15 genuine genuine JJ 37231 748 16 and and CC 37231 748 17 based base VBN 37231 748 18 upon upon IN 37231 748 19 substantial substantial JJ 37231 748 20 realities reality NNS 37231 748 21 . . . 37231 749 1 Fear fear NN 37231 749 2 of of IN 37231 749 3 the the DT 37231 749 4 results result NNS 37231 749 5 of of IN 37231 749 6 investigation investigation NN 37231 749 7 , , , 37231 749 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 749 9 , , , 37231 749 10 should should MD 37231 749 11 deter deter VB 37231 749 12 no no DT 37231 749 13 man man NN 37231 749 14 , , , 37231 749 15 for for IN 37231 749 16 the the DT 37231 749 17 issue issue NN 37231 749 18 in in IN 37231 749 19 any any DT 37231 749 20 case case NN 37231 749 21 is be VBZ 37231 749 22 gain gain NN 37231 749 23 : : : 37231 749 24 emancipation emancipation NN 37231 749 25 from from IN 37231 749 26 delusion delusion NN 37231 749 27 , , , 37231 749 28 or or CC 37231 749 29 increase increase NN 37231 749 30 of of IN 37231 749 31 assurance assurance NN 37231 749 32 . . . 37231 750 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 750 2 is be VBZ 37231 750 3 poor poor JJ 37231 750 4 honour honour NN 37231 750 5 to to TO 37231 750 6 sequester sequester VB 37231 750 7 a a DT 37231 750 8 creed creed NN 37231 750 9 from from IN 37231 750 10 healthy healthy JJ 37231 750 11 handling handling NN 37231 750 12 , , , 37231 750 13 or or CC 37231 750 14 to to TO 37231 750 15 shrink shrink VB 37231 750 16 from from IN 37231 750 17 the the DT 37231 750 18 serious serious JJ 37231 750 19 examination examination NN 37231 750 20 of of IN 37231 750 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 750 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 750 23 . . . 37231 751 1 That that DT 37231 751 2 which which WDT 37231 751 3 is be VBZ 37231 751 4 true true JJ 37231 751 5 in in IN 37231 751 6 Religion religion NN 37231 751 7 can can MD 37231 751 8 not not RB 37231 751 9 be be VB 37231 751 10 shaken shake VBN 37231 751 11 ; ; : 37231 751 12 that that IN 37231 751 13 which which WDT 37231 751 14 is be VBZ 37231 751 15 false false JJ 37231 751 16 no no DT 37231 751 17 one one NN 37231 751 18 can can MD 37231 751 19 desire desire VB 37231 751 20 to to TO 37231 751 21 preserve preserve VB 37231 751 22 . . . 37231 752 1 { { -LRB- 37231 752 2 lxxxvi lxxxvi NNP 37231 752 3 } } -RRB- 37231 752 4 PREFACE PREFACE NNP 37231 752 5 TO to IN 37231 752 6 THE the DT 37231 752 7 SECOND second JJ 37231 752 8 EDITION edition NN 37231 752 9 . . . 37231 753 1 The the DT 37231 753 2 Author author NN 37231 753 3 has have VBZ 37231 753 4 taken take VBN 37231 753 5 advantage advantage NN 37231 753 6 of of IN 37231 753 7 the the DT 37231 753 8 issue issue NN 37231 753 9 of of IN 37231 753 10 a a DT 37231 753 11 second second JJ 37231 753 12 edition edition NN 37231 753 13 to to TO 37231 753 14 revise revise VB 37231 753 15 this this DT 37231 753 16 work work NN 37231 753 17 . . . 37231 754 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 754 2 has have VBZ 37231 754 3 re re VBN 37231 754 4 - - VBN 37231 754 5 written write VBN 37231 754 6 portions portion NNS 37231 754 7 of of IN 37231 754 8 the the DT 37231 754 9 first first JJ 37231 754 10 part part NN 37231 754 11 , , , 37231 754 12 and and CC 37231 754 13 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 754 14 re re VB 37231 754 15 - - VBD 37231 754 16 arranged arrange VBD 37231 754 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 754 18 . . . 37231 755 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 755 2 hopes hope VBZ 37231 755 3 that that IN 37231 755 4 the the DT 37231 755 5 argument argument NN 37231 755 6 has have VBZ 37231 755 7 thus thus RB 37231 755 8 been be VBN 37231 755 9 made make VBN 37231 755 10 more more RBR 37231 755 11 clear clear JJ 37231 755 12 and and CC 37231 755 13 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 755 14 . . . 37231 756 1 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 37231 756 2 . . . 37231 757 1 Theoretically theoretically RB 37231 757 2 , , , 37231 757 3 the the DT 37231 757 4 duty duty NN 37231 757 5 of of IN 37231 757 6 adequate adequate JJ 37231 757 7 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 757 8 into into IN 37231 757 9 the the DT 37231 757 10 truth truth NN 37231 757 11 of of IN 37231 757 12 any any DT 37231 757 13 statement statement NN 37231 757 14 of of IN 37231 757 15 serious serious JJ 37231 757 16 importance importance NN 37231 757 17 before before IN 37231 757 18 believing believe VBG 37231 757 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 757 20 is be VBZ 37231 757 21 universally universally RB 37231 757 22 admitted admit VBN 37231 757 23 . . . 37231 758 1 Practically practically RB 37231 758 2 , , , 37231 758 3 no no DT 37231 758 4 duty duty NN 37231 758 5 is be VBZ 37231 758 6 more more RBR 37231 758 7 universally universally RB 37231 758 8 neglected neglect VBN 37231 758 9 . . . 37231 759 1 This this DT 37231 759 2 is be VBZ 37231 759 3 more more RBR 37231 759 4 especially especially RB 37231 759 5 the the DT 37231 759 6 case case NN 37231 759 7 in in IN 37231 759 8 regard regard NN 37231 759 9 to to IN 37231 759 10 Religion religion NN 37231 759 11 , , , 37231 759 12 in in IN 37231 759 13 which which WDT 37231 759 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 759 15 concern concern NN 37231 759 16 is be VBZ 37231 759 17 so so RB 37231 759 18 great great JJ 37231 759 19 , , , 37231 759 20 yet yet CC 37231 759 21 the the DT 37231 759 22 credentials credential NNS 37231 759 23 of of IN 37231 759 24 which which WDT 37231 759 25 so so RB 37231 759 26 few few JJ 37231 759 27 personally personally RB 37231 759 28 examine examine VBP 37231 759 29 . . . 37231 760 1 The the DT 37231 760 2 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 760 3 of of IN 37231 760 4 such such PDT 37231 760 5 an an DT 37231 760 6 investigation investigation NN 37231 760 7 and and CC 37231 760 8 the the DT 37231 760 9 inability inability NN 37231 760 10 of of IN 37231 760 11 most most JJS 37231 760 12 men man NNS 37231 760 13 to to TO 37231 760 14 pursue pursue VB 37231 760 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 760 16 , , , 37231 760 17 whether whether IN 37231 760 18 from from IN 37231 760 19 want want NN 37231 760 20 of of IN 37231 760 21 opportunity opportunity NN 37231 760 22 or or CC 37231 760 23 want want NN 37231 760 24 of of IN 37231 760 25 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 760 26 , , , 37231 760 27 are be VBP 37231 760 28 no no RB 37231 760 29 doubt doubt RB 37231 760 30 the the DT 37231 760 31 chief chief JJ 37231 760 32 reasons reason NNS 37231 760 33 for for IN 37231 760 34 this this DT 37231 760 35 neglect neglect NN 37231 760 36 ; ; : 37231 760 37 but but CC 37231 760 38 another another DT 37231 760 39 , , , 37231 760 40 and and CC 37231 760 41 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 760 42 less less RBR 37231 760 43 potent potent JJ 37231 760 44 , , , 37231 760 45 obstacle obstacle NN 37231 760 46 has have VBZ 37231 760 47 probably probably RB 37231 760 48 been be VBN 37231 760 49 the the DT 37231 760 50 odium odium NN 37231 760 51 which which WDT 37231 760 52 has have VBZ 37231 760 53 been be VBN 37231 760 54 attached attach VBN 37231 760 55 to to IN 37231 760 56 any any DT 37231 760 57 doubt doubt NN 37231 760 58 regarding regard VBG 37231 760 59 the the DT 37231 760 60 dominant dominant JJ 37231 760 61 religion religion NN 37231 760 62 , , , 37231 760 63 as as RB 37231 760 64 well well RB 37231 760 65 as as IN 37231 760 66 the the DT 37231 760 67 serious serious JJ 37231 760 68 , , , 37231 760 69 though though IN 37231 760 70 covert covert JJ 37231 760 71 , , , 37231 760 72 discouragement discouragement NN 37231 760 73 of of IN 37231 760 74 the the DT 37231 760 75 Church Church NNP 37231 760 76 to to IN 37231 760 77 all all DT 37231 760 78 critical critical JJ 37231 760 79 examination examination NN 37231 760 80 of of IN 37231 760 81 the the DT 37231 760 82 title title NN 37231 760 83 - - HYPH 37231 760 84 deeds deed NNS 37231 760 85 of of IN 37231 760 86 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 760 87 . . . 37231 761 1 The the DT 37231 761 2 spirit spirit NN 37231 761 3 of of IN 37231 761 4 doubt doubt NN 37231 761 5 , , , 37231 761 6 if if IN 37231 761 7 not not RB 37231 761 8 of of IN 37231 761 9 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 761 10 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 761 11 , , , 37231 761 12 has have VBZ 37231 761 13 , , , 37231 761 14 however however RB 37231 761 15 , , , 37231 761 16 of of IN 37231 761 17 late late JJ 37231 761 18 years year NNS 37231 761 19 become become VBP 37231 761 20 too too RB 37231 761 21 strong strong JJ 37231 761 22 for for IN 37231 761 23 repression repression NN 37231 761 24 , , , 37231 761 25 and and CC 37231 761 26 , , , 37231 761 27 at at IN 37231 761 28 the the DT 37231 761 29 present present JJ 37231 761 30 day day NN 37231 761 31 , , , 37231 761 32 the the DT 37231 761 33 pertinency pertinency NN 37231 761 34 of of IN 37231 761 35 the the DT 37231 761 36 question question NN 37231 761 37 of of IN 37231 761 38 a a DT 37231 761 39 German german JJ 37231 761 40 writer writer NN 37231 761 41 : : : 37231 761 42 " " `` 37231 761 43 Are be VBP 37231 761 44 we -PRON- PRP 37231 761 45 still still RB 37231 761 46 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 761 47 ? ? . 37231 761 48 " " '' 37231 762 1 receives receive VBZ 37231 762 2 unconscious unconscious JJ 37231 762 3 { { -LRB- 37231 762 4 xcii xcii NNP 37231 762 5 } } -RRB- 37231 762 6 illustration illustration NN 37231 762 7 from from IN 37231 762 8 many many JJ 37231 762 9 a a DT 37231 762 10 popular popular JJ 37231 762 11 pulpit pulpit NN 37231 762 12 , , , 37231 762 13 and and CC 37231 762 14 many many PDT 37231 762 15 a a DT 37231 762 16 social social JJ 37231 762 17 discussion discussion NN 37231 762 18 . . . 37231 763 1 The the DT 37231 763 2 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 763 3 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 763 4 of of IN 37231 763 5 popular popular JJ 37231 763 6 theology theology NN 37231 763 7 in in IN 37231 763 8 England England NNP 37231 763 9 , , , 37231 763 10 at at IN 37231 763 11 this this DT 37231 763 12 time time NN 37231 763 13 , , , 37231 763 14 may may MD 37231 763 15 be be VB 37231 763 16 said say VBN 37231 763 17 to to TO 37231 763 18 be be VB 37231 763 19 a a DT 37231 763 20 tendency tendency NN 37231 763 21 to to TO 37231 763 22 eliminate eliminate VB 37231 763 23 from from IN 37231 763 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 763 25 , , , 37231 763 26 with with IN 37231 763 27 thoughtless thoughtless JJ 37231 763 28 dexterity dexterity NN 37231 763 29 , , , 37231 763 30 every every DT 37231 763 31 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 763 32 element element NN 37231 763 33 which which WDT 37231 763 34 does do VBZ 37231 763 35 not not RB 37231 763 36 quite quite RB 37231 763 37 accord accord VB 37231 763 38 with with IN 37231 763 39 current current JJ 37231 763 40 opinion opinion NN 37231 763 41 , , , 37231 763 42 and and CC 37231 763 43 yet yet RB 37231 763 44 to to TO 37231 763 45 ignore ignore VB 37231 763 46 the the DT 37231 763 47 fact fact NN 37231 763 48 that that IN 37231 763 49 , , , 37231 763 50 in in IN 37231 763 51 so so RB 37231 763 52 doing do VBG 37231 763 53 , , , 37231 763 54 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 763 55 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 763 56 has have VBZ 37231 763 57 practically practically RB 37231 763 58 been be VBN 37231 763 59 altogether altogether RB 37231 763 60 abandoned abandon VBN 37231 763 61 . . . 37231 764 1 This this DT 37231 764 2 tendency tendency NN 37231 764 3 is be VBZ 37231 764 4 fostered foster VBN 37231 764 5 with with IN 37231 764 6 profoundly profoundly RB 37231 764 7 illogical illogical JJ 37231 764 8 zeal zeal NN 37231 764 9 by by IN 37231 764 10 many many JJ 37231 764 11 distinguished distinguished JJ 37231 764 12 men man NNS 37231 764 13 within within IN 37231 764 14 the the DT 37231 764 15 Church Church NNP 37231 764 16 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 764 17 , , , 37231 764 18 who who WP 37231 764 19 endeavour endeavour VBP 37231 764 20 to to TO 37231 764 21 arrest arrest VB 37231 764 22 for for IN 37231 764 23 a a DT 37231 764 24 moment moment NN 37231 764 25 the the DT 37231 764 26 pursuing pursue VBG 37231 764 27 wolves wolf NNS 37231 764 28 of of IN 37231 764 29 doubt doubt NN 37231 764 30 and and CC 37231 764 31 unbelief unbelief NN 37231 764 32 which which WDT 37231 764 33 press press VBP 37231 764 34 upon upon IN 37231 764 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 764 36 , , , 37231 764 37 by by IN 37231 764 38 practically practically RB 37231 764 39 throwing throw VBG 37231 764 40 to to IN 37231 764 41 them -PRON- PRP 37231 764 42 , , , 37231 764 43 scrap scrap NN 37231 764 44 by by IN 37231 764 45 scrap scrap NN 37231 764 46 , , , 37231 764 47 the the DT 37231 764 48 very very JJ 37231 764 49 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 764 50 which which WDT 37231 764 51 constitute constitute VBP 37231 764 52 the the DT 37231 764 53 claims claim NNS 37231 764 54 of of IN 37231 764 55 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 764 56 to to TO 37231 764 57 be be VB 37231 764 58 regarded regard VBN 37231 764 59 as as IN 37231 764 60 a a DT 37231 764 61 Divine Divine NNP 37231 764 62 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 764 63 at at RB 37231 764 64 all all RB 37231 764 65 . . . 37231 765 1 The the DT 37231 765 2 moral moral JJ 37231 765 3 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 765 4 which which WDT 37231 765 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 765 6 hope hope VBP 37231 765 7 to to TO 37231 765 8 preserve preserve VB 37231 765 9 , , , 37231 765 10 noble noble JJ 37231 765 11 though though IN 37231 765 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 765 13 be be VB 37231 765 14 , , , 37231 765 15 has have VBZ 37231 765 16 not not RB 37231 765 17 one one CD 37231 765 18 feature feature NN 37231 765 19 left leave VBN 37231 765 20 to to TO 37231 765 21 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 765 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 765 23 as as IN 37231 765 24 a a DT 37231 765 25 miraculously miraculously RB 37231 765 26 communicated communicate VBN 37231 765 27 religion religion NN 37231 765 28 . . . 37231 766 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 766 2 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 766 3 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 766 4 pretends pretend VBZ 37231 766 5 to to TO 37231 766 6 be be VB 37231 766 7 a a DT 37231 766 8 direct direct JJ 37231 766 9 Divine Divine NNP 37231 766 10 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 766 11 of of IN 37231 766 12 truths truth NNS 37231 766 13 beyond beyond IN 37231 766 14 the the DT 37231 766 15 natural natural JJ 37231 766 16 attainment attainment NN 37231 766 17 of of IN 37231 766 18 the the DT 37231 766 19 human human JJ 37231 766 20 intellect intellect NN 37231 766 21 . . . 37231 767 1 To to TO 37231 767 2 submit submit VB 37231 767 3 the the DT 37231 767 4 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 767 5 thus thus RB 37231 767 6 revealed reveal VBN 37231 767 7 , , , 37231 767 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 767 9 , , , 37231 767 10 to to IN 37231 767 11 criticism criticism NN 37231 767 12 , , , 37231 767 13 and and CC 37231 767 14 to to TO 37231 767 15 clip clip VB 37231 767 16 and and CC 37231 767 17 prune prune VB 37231 767 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 767 19 down down RP 37231 767 20 to to IN 37231 767 21 the the DT 37231 767 22 standard standard NN 37231 767 23 of of IN 37231 767 24 human human JJ 37231 767 25 reason reason NN 37231 767 26 , , , 37231 767 27 whilst whilst IN 37231 767 28 at at IN 37231 767 29 the the DT 37231 767 30 same same JJ 37231 767 31 time time NN 37231 767 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 767 33 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 767 34 character character NN 37231 767 35 is be VBZ 37231 767 36 maintained maintain VBN 37231 767 37 , , , 37231 767 38 is be VBZ 37231 767 39 an an DT 37231 767 40 obvious obvious JJ 37231 767 41 absurdity absurdity NN 37231 767 42 . . . 37231 768 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 768 2 must must MD 37231 768 3 either either CC 37231 768 4 be be VB 37231 768 5 recognized recognize VBN 37231 768 6 to to TO 37231 768 7 be be VB 37231 768 8 a a DT 37231 768 9 Divine Divine NNP 37231 768 10 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 768 11 beyond beyond IN 37231 768 12 man man NN 37231 768 13 's 's POS 37231 768 14 criticism criticism NN 37231 768 15 , , , 37231 768 16 and and CC 37231 768 17 in in IN 37231 768 18 that that DT 37231 768 19 case case NN 37231 768 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 768 21 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 768 22 must must MD 37231 768 23 be be VB 37231 768 24 received receive VBN 37231 768 25 even even RB 37231 768 26 though though IN 37231 768 27 Reason reason NN 37231 768 28 can can MD 37231 768 29 not not RB 37231 768 30 be be VB 37231 768 31 satisfied satisfied JJ 37231 768 32 , , , 37231 768 33 or or CC 37231 768 34 the the DT 37231 768 35 claims claim NNS 37231 768 36 of of IN 37231 768 37 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 768 38 to to TO 37231 768 39 be be VB 37231 768 40 such such PDT 37231 768 41 a a DT 37231 768 42 Divine Divine NNP 37231 768 43 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 768 44 must must MD 37231 768 45 be be VB 37231 768 46 disallowed disallow VBN 37231 768 47 , , , 37231 768 48 in in IN 37231 768 49 which which WDT 37231 768 50 case case NN 37231 768 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 768 52 becomes become VBZ 37231 768 53 the the DT 37231 768 54 legitimate legitimate JJ 37231 768 55 subject subject NN 37231 768 56 of of IN 37231 768 57 criticism criticism NN 37231 768 58 like like IN 37231 768 59 every every DT 37231 768 60 other other JJ 37231 768 61 human human JJ 37231 768 62 system system NN 37231 768 63 . . . 37231 769 1 One one CD 37231 769 2 or or CC 37231 769 3 other other JJ 37231 769 4 of of IN 37231 769 5 these these DT 37231 769 6 alternatives alternative NNS 37231 769 7 must must MD 37231 769 8 be be VB 37231 769 9 adopted adopt VBN 37231 769 10 , , , 37231 769 11 but but CC 37231 769 12 to to IN 37231 769 13 { { -LRB- 37231 769 14 xciii xciii NN 37231 769 15 } } -RRB- 37231 769 16 assert assert NN 37231 769 17 that that IN 37231 769 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 769 19 is be VBZ 37231 769 20 Divine Divine NNP 37231 769 21 , , , 37231 769 22 and and CC 37231 769 23 yet yet RB 37231 769 24 to to TO 37231 769 25 deal deal VB 37231 769 26 with with IN 37231 769 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 769 28 as as IN 37231 769 29 human human JJ 37231 769 30 , , , 37231 769 31 is be VBZ 37231 769 32 illogical illogical JJ 37231 769 33 and and CC 37231 769 34 wrong wrong JJ 37231 769 35 . . . 37231 770 1 When when WRB 37231 770 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 770 3 consider consider VBP 37231 770 4 the the DT 37231 770 5 vast vast JJ 37231 770 6 importance importance NN 37231 770 7 of of IN 37231 770 8 the the DT 37231 770 9 interests interest NNS 37231 770 10 involved involve VBN 37231 770 11 , , , 37231 770 12 therefore therefore RB 37231 770 13 , , , 37231 770 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 770 15 must must MD 37231 770 16 be be VB 37231 770 17 apparent apparent JJ 37231 770 18 that that IN 37231 770 19 there there EX 37231 770 20 can can MD 37231 770 21 be be VB 37231 770 22 no no DT 37231 770 23 more more RBR 37231 770 24 urgent urgent JJ 37231 770 25 problem problem NN 37231 770 26 for for IN 37231 770 27 humanity humanity NN 37231 770 28 to to TO 37231 770 29 solve solve VB 37231 770 30 than than IN 37231 770 31 the the DT 37231 770 32 question question NN 37231 770 33 : : : 37231 770 34 Is be VBZ 37231 770 35 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 770 36 a a DT 37231 770 37 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 770 38 Divine Divine NNP 37231 770 39 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 770 40 or or CC 37231 770 41 not not RB 37231 770 42 ? ? . 37231 771 1 To to IN 37231 771 2 this this DT 37231 771 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 771 4 may may MD 37231 771 5 demand demand VB 37231 771 6 a a DT 37231 771 7 clear clear JJ 37231 771 8 and and CC 37231 771 9 decisive decisive JJ 37231 771 10 answer answer NN 37231 771 11 . . . 37231 772 1 The the DT 37231 772 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 772 3 must must MD 37231 772 4 be be VB 37231 772 5 of of IN 37231 772 6 no no DT 37231 772 7 uncertain uncertain JJ 37231 772 8 character character NN 37231 772 9 which which WDT 37231 772 10 can can MD 37231 772 11 warrant warrant VB 37231 772 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 772 13 abandoning abandon VBG 37231 772 14 the the DT 37231 772 15 guidance guidance NN 37231 772 16 of of IN 37231 772 17 Reason Reason NNP 37231 772 18 , , , 37231 772 19 and and CC 37231 772 20 blindly blindly RB 37231 772 21 accepting accept VBG 37231 772 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 772 23 which which WDT 37231 772 24 , , , 37231 772 25 if if IN 37231 772 26 not not RB 37231 772 27 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 772 28 truths truth NNS 37231 772 29 , , , 37231 772 30 must must MD 37231 772 31 be be VB 37231 772 32 rejected reject VBN 37231 772 33 by by IN 37231 772 34 the the DT 37231 772 35 human human JJ 37231 772 36 intellect intellect NN 37231 772 37 as as IN 37231 772 38 monstrous monstrous JJ 37231 772 39 delusions delusion NNS 37231 772 40 . . . 37231 773 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 773 2 propose propose VBP 37231 773 3 in in IN 37231 773 4 this this DT 37231 773 5 work work NN 37231 773 6 to to TO 37231 773 7 seek seek VB 37231 773 8 a a DT 37231 773 9 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 773 10 answer answer NN 37231 773 11 to to IN 37231 773 12 this this DT 37231 773 13 momentous momentous JJ 37231 773 14 question question NN 37231 773 15 . . . 37231 774 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 774 2 appears appear VBZ 37231 774 3 to to IN 37231 774 4 us -PRON- PRP 37231 774 5 that that IN 37231 774 6 at at IN 37231 774 7 no no DT 37231 774 8 time time NN 37231 774 9 has have VBZ 37231 774 10 such such PDT 37231 774 11 an an DT 37231 774 12 investigation investigation NN 37231 774 13 been be VBN 37231 774 14 more more RBR 37231 774 15 requisite requisite JJ 37231 774 16 . . . 37231 775 1 The the DT 37231 775 2 results result NNS 37231 775 3 of of IN 37231 775 4 scientific scientific JJ 37231 775 5 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 775 6 and and CC 37231 775 7 of of IN 37231 775 8 Biblical biblical JJ 37231 775 9 criticism criticism NN 37231 775 10 have have VBP 37231 775 11 created create VBN 37231 775 12 wide wide RB 37231 775 13 - - HYPH 37231 775 14 spread spread NN 37231 775 15 doubt doubt NN 37231 775 16 regarding regard VBG 37231 775 17 the the DT 37231 775 18 most most JJS 37231 775 19 material material JJ 37231 775 20 part part NN 37231 775 21 of of IN 37231 775 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 775 23 considered consider VBD 37231 775 24 as as IN 37231 775 25 a a DT 37231 775 26 Divine Divine NNP 37231 775 27 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 775 28 . . . 37231 776 1 The the DT 37231 776 2 mass mass NN 37231 776 3 of of IN 37231 776 4 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 776 5 men man NNS 37231 776 6 in in IN 37231 776 7 England England NNP 37231 776 8 are be VBP 37231 776 9 halting halt VBG 37231 776 10 between between IN 37231 776 11 two two CD 37231 776 12 opinions opinion NNS 37231 776 13 , , , 37231 776 14 and and CC 37231 776 15 standing stand VBG 37231 776 16 in in IN 37231 776 17 what what WP 37231 776 18 seems seem VBZ 37231 776 19 to to IN 37231 776 20 us -PRON- PRP 37231 776 21 the the DT 37231 776 22 most most RBS 37231 776 23 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 37231 776 24 position position NN 37231 776 25 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 776 26 : : : 37231 776 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 776 28 abandon abandon VBP 37231 776 29 , , , 37231 776 30 before before IN 37231 776 31 a a DT 37231 776 32 kind kind NN 37231 776 33 of of IN 37231 776 34 vague vague JJ 37231 776 35 and and CC 37231 776 36 indefinite indefinite JJ 37231 776 37 , , , 37231 776 38 if if IN 37231 776 39 irresistible irresistible JJ 37231 776 40 , , , 37231 776 41 conviction conviction NN 37231 776 42 , , , 37231 776 43 some some DT 37231 776 44 of of IN 37231 776 45 the the DT 37231 776 46 most most RBS 37231 776 47 central central JJ 37231 776 48 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 776 49 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 776 50 of of IN 37231 776 51 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 776 52 ; ; : 37231 776 53 they -PRON- PRP 37231 776 54 try try VBP 37231 776 55 to to TO 37231 776 56 spiritualize spiritualize VB 37231 776 57 or or CC 37231 776 58 dilute dilute VB 37231 776 59 the the DT 37231 776 60 rest rest NN 37231 776 61 into into IN 37231 776 62 a a DT 37231 776 63 form form NN 37231 776 64 which which WDT 37231 776 65 does do VBZ 37231 776 66 not not RB 37231 776 67 shock shock VB 37231 776 68 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 776 69 reason reason NN 37231 776 70 ; ; : 37231 776 71 and and CC 37231 776 72 yet yet RB 37231 776 73 they -PRON- PRP 37231 776 74 cling cling VBP 37231 776 75 to to IN 37231 776 76 the the DT 37231 776 77 delusion delusion NN 37231 776 78 , , , 37231 776 79 that that IN 37231 776 80 they -PRON- PRP 37231 776 81 still still RB 37231 776 82 retain retain VBP 37231 776 83 the the DT 37231 776 84 consolation consolation NN 37231 776 85 and and CC 37231 776 86 the the DT 37231 776 87 hope hope NN 37231 776 88 of of IN 37231 776 89 truths truth NNS 37231 776 90 which which WDT 37231 776 91 , , , 37231 776 92 if if IN 37231 776 93 not not RB 37231 776 94 divinely divinely RB 37231 776 95 revealed reveal VBN 37231 776 96 , , , 37231 776 97 are be VBP 37231 776 98 mere mere JJ 37231 776 99 human human JJ 37231 776 100 speculation speculation NN 37231 776 101 regarding regard VBG 37231 776 102 matters matter NNS 37231 776 103 beyond beyond IN 37231 776 104 reason reason NN 37231 776 105 . . . 37231 777 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 777 2 have have VBP 37231 777 3 , , , 37231 777 4 in in IN 37231 777 5 fact fact NN 37231 777 6 , , , 37231 777 7 as as IN 37231 777 8 little little JJ 37231 777 9 warrant warrant NN 37231 777 10 to to TO 37231 777 11 abandon abandon VB 37231 777 12 the the DT 37231 777 13 one one CD 37231 777 14 part part NN 37231 777 15 as as IN 37231 777 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 777 17 have have VBP 37231 777 18 to to TO 37231 777 19 retain retain VB 37231 777 20 the the DT 37231 777 21 other other JJ 37231 777 22 . . . 37231 778 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 778 2 build build VBP 37231 778 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 778 4 house house NN 37231 778 5 upon upon IN 37231 778 6 the the DT 37231 778 7 sand sand NN 37231 778 8 , , , 37231 778 9 and and CC 37231 778 10 the the DT 37231 778 11 waves wave NNS 37231 778 12 which which WDT 37231 778 13 have have VBP 37231 778 14 already already RB 37231 778 15 carried carry VBN 37231 778 16 away away RB 37231 778 17 so so RB 37231 778 18 much much JJ 37231 778 19 may may MD 37231 778 20 any any DT 37231 778 21 day day NN 37231 778 22 engulf engulf VB 37231 778 23 the the DT 37231 778 24 rest rest NN 37231 778 25 . . . 37231 779 1 At at IN 37231 779 2 the the DT 37231 779 3 same same JJ 37231 779 4 time time NN 37231 779 5 , , , 37231 779 6 amid amid IN 37231 779 7 this this DT 37231 779 8 general general JJ 37231 779 9 eclipse eclipse NN 37231 779 10 of of IN 37231 779 11 faith faith NN 37231 779 12 , , , 37231 779 13 many many JJ 37231 779 14 { { -LRB- 37231 779 15 xciv xciv NN 37231 779 16 } } -RRB- 37231 779 17 an an DT 37231 779 18 earnest earnest JJ 37231 779 19 mind mind NN 37231 779 20 , , , 37231 779 21 eagerly eagerly RB 37231 779 22 seeking seek VBG 37231 779 23 for for IN 37231 779 24 truth truth NN 37231 779 25 , , , 37231 779 26 endures endure VBZ 37231 779 27 much much JJ 37231 779 28 bitter bitter JJ 37231 779 29 pain,--unable pain,--unable , 37231 779 30 to to TO 37231 779 31 believe believe VB 37231 779 32 -- -- : 37231 779 33 unable unable JJ 37231 779 34 freely freely RB 37231 779 35 to to TO 37231 779 36 reject reject VB 37231 779 37 -- -- : 37231 779 38 and and CC 37231 779 39 yet yet RB 37231 779 40 without without IN 37231 779 41 the the DT 37231 779 42 means mean NNS 37231 779 43 of of IN 37231 779 44 securing secure VBG 37231 779 45 any any DT 37231 779 46 clear clear JJ 37231 779 47 and and CC 37231 779 48 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 779 49 reply reply NN 37231 779 50 to to IN 37231 779 51 the the DT 37231 779 52 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 779 53 : : : 37231 779 54 " " `` 37231 779 55 What what WP 37231 779 56 is be VBZ 37231 779 57 truth truth NN 37231 779 58 ? ? . 37231 779 59 " " '' 37231 780 1 Any any DT 37231 780 2 distinct distinct JJ 37231 780 3 assurance assurance NN 37231 780 4 , , , 37231 780 5 whatever whatever WDT 37231 780 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 780 7 nature nature NN 37231 780 8 , , , 37231 780 9 based base VBN 37231 780 10 upon upon IN 37231 780 11 solid solid JJ 37231 780 12 grounds ground NNS 37231 780 13 , , , 37231 780 14 would would MD 37231 780 15 be be VB 37231 780 16 preferable preferable JJ 37231 780 17 to to IN 37231 780 18 such such PDT 37231 780 19 a a DT 37231 780 20 state state NN 37231 780 21 of of IN 37231 780 22 doubt doubt NN 37231 780 23 and and CC 37231 780 24 hesitation hesitation NN 37231 780 25 . . . 37231 781 1 Once once RB 37231 781 2 persuaded persuade VBD 37231 781 3 that that IN 37231 781 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 781 5 have have VBP 37231 781 6 attained attain VBN 37231 781 7 truth truth NN 37231 781 8 , , , 37231 781 9 there there EX 37231 781 10 can can MD 37231 781 11 be be VB 37231 781 12 no no DT 37231 781 13 permanent permanent JJ 37231 781 14 regret regret NN 37231 781 15 for for IN 37231 781 16 vanished vanished JJ 37231 781 17 illusions illusion NNS 37231 781 18 . . . 37231 782 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 782 2 must must MD 37231 782 3 , , , 37231 782 4 however however RB 37231 782 5 , , , 37231 782 6 by by IN 37231 782 7 careful careful JJ 37231 782 8 and and CC 37231 782 9 impartial impartial JJ 37231 782 10 investigation investigation NN 37231 782 11 , , , 37231 782 12 acquire acquire VB 37231 782 13 the the DT 37231 782 14 right right NN 37231 782 15 to to IN 37231 782 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 782 17 belief belief NN 37231 782 18 , , , 37231 782 19 whatever whatever WDT 37231 782 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 782 21 may may MD 37231 782 22 be be VB 37231 782 23 , , , 37231 782 24 and and CC 37231 782 25 not not RB 37231 782 26 float float VB 37231 782 27 like like IN 37231 782 28 a a DT 37231 782 29 mere mere JJ 37231 782 30 waif waif NN 37231 782 31 into into IN 37231 782 32 the the DT 37231 782 33 nearest near JJS 37231 782 34 haven haven NN 37231 782 35 . . . 37231 783 1 Flippant flippant JJ 37231 783 2 unbelief unbelief NN 37231 783 3 is be VBZ 37231 783 4 much much RB 37231 783 5 worse bad JJR 37231 783 6 than than IN 37231 783 7 earnest earnest JJ 37231 783 8 credulity credulity NN 37231 783 9 . . . 37231 784 1 The the DT 37231 784 2 time time NN 37231 784 3 is be VBZ 37231 784 4 ripe ripe JJ 37231 784 5 for for IN 37231 784 6 arriving arrive VBG 37231 784 7 at at IN 37231 784 8 a a DT 37231 784 9 definite definite JJ 37231 784 10 conviction conviction NN 37231 784 11 as as IN 37231 784 12 to to IN 37231 784 13 the the DT 37231 784 14 character character NN 37231 784 15 of of IN 37231 784 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 784 17 . . . 37231 785 1 There there EX 37231 785 2 is be VBZ 37231 785 3 no no DT 37231 785 4 lack lack NN 37231 785 5 of of IN 37231 785 6 materials material NNS 37231 785 7 for for IN 37231 785 8 a a DT 37231 785 9 final final JJ 37231 785 10 decision decision NN 37231 785 11 , , , 37231 785 12 although although IN 37231 785 13 hitherto hitherto RB 37231 785 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 785 15 have have VBP 37231 785 16 been be VBN 37231 785 17 beyond beyond IN 37231 785 18 the the DT 37231 785 19 reach reach NN 37231 785 20 of of IN 37231 785 21 most most JJS 37231 785 22 English english JJ 37231 785 23 readers reader NNS 37231 785 24 , , , 37231 785 25 and and CC 37231 785 26 a a DT 37231 785 27 careful careful JJ 37231 785 28 and and CC 37231 785 29 honest honest JJ 37231 785 30 examination examination NN 37231 785 31 of of IN 37231 785 32 the the DT 37231 785 33 subject subject NN 37231 785 34 , , , 37231 785 35 even even RB 37231 785 36 if if IN 37231 785 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 785 38 be be VBP 37231 785 39 not not RB 37231 785 40 final final JJ 37231 785 41 , , , 37231 785 42 can can MD 37231 785 43 not not RB 37231 785 44 fail fail VB 37231 785 45 to to TO 37231 785 46 contribute contribute VB 37231 785 47 towards towards IN 37231 785 48 a a DT 37231 785 49 result result NN 37231 785 50 more more RBR 37231 785 51 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 37231 785 52 than than IN 37231 785 53 the the DT 37231 785 54 generally generally RB 37231 785 55 vague vague JJ 37231 785 56 and and CC 37231 785 57 illogical illogical JJ 37231 785 58 religious religious JJ 37231 785 59 opinion opinion NN 37231 785 60 of of IN 37231 785 61 the the DT 37231 785 62 present present JJ 37231 785 63 day day NN 37231 785 64 . . . 37231 786 1 Even even RB 37231 786 2 true true JJ 37231 786 3 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 786 4 which which WDT 37231 786 5 are be VBP 37231 786 6 arrived arrive VBN 37231 786 7 at at IN 37231 786 8 either either CC 37231 786 9 accidentally accidentally RB 37231 786 10 or or CC 37231 786 11 by by IN 37231 786 12 wrong wrong JJ 37231 786 13 methods method NNS 37231 786 14 are be VBP 37231 786 15 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 786 16 . . . 37231 787 1 The the DT 37231 787 2 current current NN 37231 787 3 which which WDT 37231 787 4 by by IN 37231 787 5 good good JJ 37231 787 6 fortune fortune NN 37231 787 7 led lead VBN 37231 787 8 to to IN 37231 787 9 - - HYPH 37231 787 10 day day NN 37231 787 11 to to IN 37231 787 12 truth truth NN 37231 787 13 may may MD 37231 787 14 to to IN 37231 787 15 - - HYPH 37231 787 16 morrow morrow NNP 37231 787 17 waft waft VB 37231 787 18 us -PRON- PRP 37231 787 19 to to IN 37231 787 20 falsehood falsehood VB 37231 787 21 . . . 37231 788 1 That that IN 37231 788 2 such such PDT 37231 788 3 an an DT 37231 788 4 investigation investigation NN 37231 788 5 can can MD 37231 788 6 not not RB 37231 788 7 , , , 37231 788 8 even even RB 37231 788 9 at at IN 37231 788 10 the the DT 37231 788 11 present present JJ 37231 788 12 time time NN 37231 788 13 , , , 37231 788 14 be be VB 37231 788 15 carried carry VBN 37231 788 16 on on RP 37231 788 17 in in IN 37231 788 18 England England NNP 37231 788 19 without without IN 37231 788 20 incurring incur VBG 37231 788 21 much much JJ 37231 788 22 enmity enmity NN 37231 788 23 and and CC 37231 788 24 opposition opposition NN 37231 788 25 need nee MD 37231 788 26 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 788 27 be be VB 37231 788 28 remarked remark VBN 37231 788 29 , , , 37231 788 30 however however RB 37231 788 31 loudly loudly RB 37231 788 32 the the DT 37231 788 33 duty duty NN 37231 788 34 and and CC 37231 788 35 liberty liberty NN 37231 788 36 of of IN 37231 788 37 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 788 38 be be VB 37231 788 39 theoretically theoretically RB 37231 788 40 proclaimed proclaim VBN 37231 788 41 , , , 37231 788 42 and and CC 37231 788 43 the the DT 37231 788 44 reason reason NN 37231 788 45 is be VBZ 37231 788 46 obvious obvious JJ 37231 788 47 . . . 37231 789 1 If if IN 37231 789 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 789 3 look look VBP 37231 789 4 at at IN 37231 789 5 the the DT 37231 789 6 singular singular JJ 37231 789 7 diversity diversity NN 37231 789 8 of of IN 37231 789 9 views view NNS 37231 789 10 entertained entertain VBN 37231 789 11 , , , 37231 789 12 not not RB 37231 789 13 only only RB 37231 789 14 with with IN 37231 789 15 regard regard NN 37231 789 16 to to IN 37231 789 17 the the DT 37231 789 18 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 789 19 , , , 37231 789 20 but but CC 37231 789 21 also also RB 37231 789 22 to to IN 37231 789 23 the the DT 37231 789 24 evidences evidence NNS 37231 789 25 , , , 37231 789 26 of of IN 37231 789 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 789 28 , , , 37231 789 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 789 30 can can MD 37231 789 31 not not RB 37231 789 32 but but CC 37231 789 33 be be VB 37231 789 34 struck strike VBN 37231 789 35 by by IN 37231 789 36 the the DT 37231 789 37 helpless helpless JJ 37231 789 38 position position NN 37231 789 39 in in IN 37231 789 40 which which WDT 37231 789 41 Divine Divine NNP 37231 789 42 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 789 43 is be VBZ 37231 789 44 now now RB 37231 789 45 placed place VBN 37231 789 46 . . . 37231 790 1 { { -LRB- 37231 790 2 xcv xcv NNP 37231 790 3 } } -RRB- 37231 790 4 Orthodox Orthodox NNP 37231 790 5 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 790 6 at at IN 37231 790 7 the the DT 37231 790 8 present present JJ 37231 790 9 day day NN 37231 790 10 may may MD 37231 790 11 be be VB 37231 790 12 divided divide VBN 37231 790 13 into into IN 37231 790 14 two two CD 37231 790 15 broad broad JJ 37231 790 16 classes class NNS 37231 790 17 , , , 37231 790 18 one one CD 37231 790 19 of of IN 37231 790 20 which which WDT 37231 790 21 professes profess VBZ 37231 790 22 to to TO 37231 790 23 base base VB 37231 790 24 the the DT 37231 790 25 Church Church NNP 37231 790 26 upon upon IN 37231 790 27 the the DT 37231 790 28 Bible Bible NNP 37231 790 29 , , , 37231 790 30 and and CC 37231 790 31 the the DT 37231 790 32 other other JJ 37231 790 33 the the DT 37231 790 34 Bible Bible NNP 37231 790 35 upon upon IN 37231 790 36 the the DT 37231 790 37 Church Church NNP 37231 790 38 . . . 37231 791 1 The the DT 37231 791 2 one one CD 37231 791 3 party party NN 37231 791 4 assert assert NN 37231 791 5 that that IN 37231 791 6 the the DT 37231 791 7 Bible Bible NNP 37231 791 8 is be VBZ 37231 791 9 fully fully RB 37231 791 10 and and CC 37231 791 11 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 791 12 inspired inspire VBN 37231 791 13 , , , 37231 791 14 that that IN 37231 791 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 791 16 contains contain VBZ 37231 791 17 God God NNP 37231 791 18 's 's POS 37231 791 19 revelation revelation NN 37231 791 20 to to IN 37231 791 21 man man NN 37231 791 22 , , , 37231 791 23 and and CC 37231 791 24 that that IN 37231 791 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 791 26 is be VBZ 37231 791 27 the the DT 37231 791 28 only only JJ 37231 791 29 and and CC 37231 791 30 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 791 31 ground ground NN 37231 791 32 for for IN 37231 791 33 all all DT 37231 791 34 religious religious JJ 37231 791 35 belief belief NN 37231 791 36 ; ; : 37231 791 37 and and CC 37231 791 38 they -PRON- PRP 37231 791 39 maintain maintain VBP 37231 791 40 that that IN 37231 791 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 791 42 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 791 43 is be VBZ 37231 791 44 proved prove VBN 37231 791 45 by by IN 37231 791 46 the the DT 37231 791 47 most most RBS 37231 791 48 ample ample JJ 37231 791 49 and and CC 37231 791 50 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 37231 791 51 external external JJ 37231 791 52 as as RB 37231 791 53 well well RB 37231 791 54 as as IN 37231 791 55 internal internal JJ 37231 791 56 evidence evidence NN 37231 791 57 . . . 37231 792 1 What what WP 37231 792 2 then then RB 37231 792 3 must must MD 37231 792 4 be be VB 37231 792 5 the the DT 37231 792 6 feeling feeling NN 37231 792 7 of of IN 37231 792 8 any any DT 37231 792 9 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 792 10 mind mind NN 37231 792 11 on on IN 37231 792 12 hearing hearing NN 37231 792 13 , , , 37231 792 14 on on IN 37231 792 15 the the DT 37231 792 16 other other JJ 37231 792 17 hand hand NN 37231 792 18 , , , 37231 792 19 that that IN 37231 792 20 men man NNS 37231 792 21 of of IN 37231 792 22 undoubted undoubted JJ 37231 792 23 piety piety NN 37231 792 24 and and CC 37231 792 25 learning learning NN 37231 792 26 , , , 37231 792 27 as as RB 37231 792 28 well well RB 37231 792 29 as as IN 37231 792 30 unquestioned unquestioned JJ 37231 792 31 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 37231 792 32 , , , 37231 792 33 within within IN 37231 792 34 the the DT 37231 792 35 Church Church NNP 37231 792 36 of of IN 37231 792 37 England England NNP 37231 792 38 , , , 37231 792 39 admit admit VBP 37231 792 40 that that IN 37231 792 41 the the DT 37231 792 42 Bible Bible NNP 37231 792 43 is be VBZ 37231 792 44 totally totally RB 37231 792 45 without without IN 37231 792 46 literary literary JJ 37231 792 47 or or CC 37231 792 48 historical historical JJ 37231 792 49 evidence evidence NN 37231 792 50 , , , 37231 792 51 and and CC 37231 792 52 can can MD 37231 792 53 not not RB 37231 792 54 for for IN 37231 792 55 a a DT 37231 792 56 moment moment NN 37231 792 57 be be VB 37231 792 58 upheld uphold VBN 37231 792 59 upon upon IN 37231 792 60 any any DT 37231 792 61 such such JJ 37231 792 62 grounds ground NNS 37231 792 63 as as IN 37231 792 64 the the DT 37231 792 65 revealed reveal VBN 37231 792 66 word word NN 37231 792 67 of of IN 37231 792 68 God God NNP 37231 792 69 ; ; : 37231 792 70 that that IN 37231 792 71 none none NN 37231 792 72 of of IN 37231 792 73 the the DT 37231 792 74 great great JJ 37231 792 75 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 792 76 of of IN 37231 792 77 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 792 78 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 792 79 can can MD 37231 792 80 be be VB 37231 792 81 deduced deduce VBN 37231 792 82 from from IN 37231 792 83 the the DT 37231 792 84 Bible Bible NNP 37231 792 85 alone;(1 alone;(1 NNP 37231 792 86 ) ) -RRB- 37231 792 87 and and CC 37231 792 88 that that IN 37231 792 89 , , , 37231 792 90 " " `` 37231 792 91 if if IN 37231 792 92 it -PRON- PRP 37231 792 93 be be VB 37231 792 94 impossible impossible JJ 37231 792 95 to to TO 37231 792 96 accept accept VB 37231 792 97 the the DT 37231 792 98 literary literary JJ 37231 792 99 method method NN 37231 792 100 of of IN 37231 792 101 dealing deal VBG 37231 792 102 with with IN 37231 792 103 Holy Holy NNP 37231 792 104 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 792 105 , , , 37231 792 106 the the DT 37231 792 107 usual usual JJ 37231 792 108 mode mode NN 37231 792 109 of of IN 37231 792 110 arguing argue VBG 37231 792 111 the the DT 37231 792 112 truth truth NN 37231 792 113 of of IN 37231 792 114 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 792 115 , , , 37231 792 116 _ _ NNP 37231 792 117 ab ab NNP 37231 792 118 extra extra JJ 37231 792 119 _ _ NNP 37231 792 120 , , , 37231 792 121 merely merely RB 37231 792 122 from from IN 37231 792 123 what what WP 37231 792 124 are be VBP 37231 792 125 called call VBN 37231 792 126 ' ' '' 37231 792 127 Evidences'--whether evidences'--whether IN 37231 792 128 of of IN 37231 792 129 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 792 130 done do VBN 37231 792 131 or or CC 37231 792 132 Prophecies prophecy NNS 37231 792 133 uttered utter VBD 37231 792 134 thousands thousand NNS 37231 792 135 of of IN 37231 792 136 years year NNS 37231 792 137 ago,--must ago,--must VBN 37231 792 138 also also RB 37231 792 139 be be VB 37231 792 140 insufficient insufficient JJ 37231 792 141 . . . 37231 792 142 " " '' 37231 792 143 ? ? . 37231 793 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 793 2 2 2 LS 37231 793 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 793 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 793 5 can can MD 37231 793 6 not not RB 37231 793 7 be be VB 37231 793 8 much much JJ 37231 793 9 comfort comfort NN 37231 793 10 to to TO 37231 793 11 be be VB 37231 793 12 assured assure VBN 37231 793 13 by by IN 37231 793 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 793 15 that that IN 37231 793 16 , , , 37231 793 17 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 37231 793 18 this this DT 37231 793 19 absence absence NN 37231 793 20 of of IN 37231 793 21 external external JJ 37231 793 22 and and CC 37231 793 23 internal internal JJ 37231 793 24 evidence evidence NN 37231 793 25 , , , 37231 793 26 this this DT 37231 793 27 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 793 28 stands stand VBZ 37231 793 29 upon upon IN 37231 793 30 the the DT 37231 793 31 sure sure JJ 37231 793 32 basis basis NN 37231 793 33 of of IN 37231 793 34 the the DT 37231 793 35 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 793 36 of of IN 37231 793 37 a a DT 37231 793 38 Church Church NNP 37231 793 39 , , , 37231 793 40 which which WDT 37231 793 41 has have VBZ 37231 793 42 so so RB 37231 793 43 little little JJ 37231 793 44 ground ground NN 37231 793 45 in in IN 37231 793 46 history history NN 37231 793 47 for for IN 37231 793 48 any any DT 37231 793 49 claim claim NN 37231 793 50 to to IN 37231 793 51 infallibility infallibility NN 37231 793 52 . . . 37231 794 1 The the DT 37231 794 2 unsupported unsupported JJ 37231 794 3 testimony testimony NN 37231 794 4 of of IN 37231 794 5 a a DT 37231 794 6 Church church NN 37231 794 7 which which WDT 37231 794 8 in in IN 37231 794 9 every every DT 37231 794 10 age age NN 37231 794 11 has have VBZ 37231 794 12 vehemently vehemently RB 37231 794 13 maintained maintain VBN 37231 794 14 errors error NNS 37231 794 15 and and CC 37231 794 16 denounced denounce VBD 37231 794 17 truths truth NNS 37231 794 18 which which WDT 37231 794 19 are be VBP 37231 794 20 now now RB 37231 794 21 universally universally RB 37231 794 22 recognized recognize VBN 37231 794 23 is be VBZ 37231 794 24 no no DT 37231 794 25 { { -LRB- 37231 794 26 xcvi xcvi NNP 37231 794 27 } } -RRB- 37231 794 28 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 794 29 guarantee guarantee NN 37231 794 30 of of IN 37231 794 31 Divine Divine NNP 37231 794 32 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 794 33 . . . 37231 795 1 Obviously obviously RB 37231 795 2 , , , 37231 795 3 there there EX 37231 795 4 is be VBZ 37231 795 5 no no DT 37231 795 6 ground ground NN 37231 795 7 for for IN 37231 795 8 accepting accept VBG 37231 795 9 from from IN 37231 795 10 a a DT 37231 795 11 fallible fallible JJ 37231 795 12 Church Church NNP 37231 795 13 and and CC 37231 795 14 fallacious fallacious JJ 37231 795 15 tradition tradition NN 37231 795 16 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 795 17 which which WDT 37231 795 18 , , , 37231 795 19 avowedly avowedly RB 37231 795 20 , , , 37231 795 21 are be VBP 37231 795 22 beyond beyond IN 37231 795 23 the the DT 37231 795 24 criterion criterion NN 37231 795 25 of of IN 37231 795 26 reason reason NN 37231 795 27 , , , 37231 795 28 and and CC 37231 795 29 therefore therefore RB 37231 795 30 require require VBP 37231 795 31 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 795 32 evidence evidence NN 37231 795 33 . . . 37231 796 1 With with IN 37231 796 2 belief belief NN 37231 796 3 based base VBN 37231 796 4 upon upon IN 37231 796 5 such such JJ 37231 796 6 uncertain uncertain JJ 37231 796 7 grounds ground NNS 37231 796 8 , , , 37231 796 9 and and CC 37231 796 10 with with IN 37231 796 11 such such JJ 37231 796 12 vital vital JJ 37231 796 13 difference difference NN 37231 796 14 of of IN 37231 796 15 views view NNS 37231 796 16 regarding regard VBG 37231 796 17 evidence evidence NN 37231 796 18 , , , 37231 796 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 796 20 is be VBZ 37231 796 21 not not RB 37231 796 22 surprising surprising JJ 37231 796 23 that that IN 37231 796 24 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 796 25 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 796 26 has have VBZ 37231 796 27 felt feel VBN 37231 796 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 796 29 own own JJ 37231 796 30 weakness weakness NN 37231 796 31 , , , 37231 796 32 and and CC 37231 796 33 entrenched entrench VBD 37231 796 34 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 796 35 against against IN 37231 796 36 the the DT 37231 796 37 assaults assault NNS 37231 796 38 of of IN 37231 796 39 investigation investigation NN 37231 796 40 . . . 37231 797 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 797 2 is be VBZ 37231 797 3 not not RB 37231 797 4 strange strange JJ 37231 797 5 that that IN 37231 797 6 intellectual intellectual JJ 37231 797 7 vigour vigour NN 37231 797 8 in in IN 37231 797 9 any any DT 37231 797 10 direction direction NN 37231 797 11 should should MD 37231 797 12 , , , 37231 797 13 almost almost RB 37231 797 14 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 797 15 , , , 37231 797 16 have have VBP 37231 797 17 been be VBN 37231 797 18 regarded regard VBN 37231 797 19 as as RB 37231 797 20 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 797 21 to to IN 37231 797 22 the the DT 37231 797 23 repose repose NN 37231 797 24 and and CC 37231 797 25 authority authority NN 37231 797 26 of of IN 37231 797 27 the the DT 37231 797 28 Church Church NNP 37231 797 29 , , , 37231 797 30 and and CC 37231 797 31 that that IN 37231 797 32 , , , 37231 797 33 instead instead RB 37231 797 34 of of IN 37231 797 35 being be VBG 37231 797 36 welcomed welcome VBN 37231 797 37 as as IN 37231 797 38 a a DT 37231 797 39 virtue virtue NN 37231 797 40 , , , 37231 797 41 religious religious JJ 37231 797 42 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 797 43 has have VBZ 37231 797 44 almost almost RB 37231 797 45 been be VBN 37231 797 46 repelled repel VBN 37231 797 47 as as IN 37231 797 48 a a DT 37231 797 49 crime crime NN 37231 797 50 . . . 37231 798 1 Such such JJ 37231 798 2 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 798 3 , , , 37231 798 4 however however RB 37231 798 5 , , , 37231 798 6 can can MD 37231 798 7 not not RB 37231 798 8 be be VB 37231 798 9 suppressed suppress VBN 37231 798 10 . . . 37231 799 1 Mere mere JJ 37231 799 2 scientific scientific JJ 37231 799 3 questions question NNS 37231 799 4 may may MD 37231 799 5 be be VB 37231 799 6 regarded regard VBN 37231 799 7 with with IN 37231 799 8 apathy apathy NN 37231 799 9 by by IN 37231 799 10 those those DT 37231 799 11 who who WP 37231 799 12 do do VBP 37231 799 13 not not RB 37231 799 14 feel feel VB 37231 799 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 799 16 personal personal JJ 37231 799 17 bearing bearing NN 37231 799 18 . . . 37231 800 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 800 2 may may MD 37231 800 3 possibly possibly RB 37231 800 4 seem seem VB 37231 800 5 to to IN 37231 800 6 some some DT 37231 800 7 a a DT 37231 800 8 matter matter NN 37231 800 9 of of IN 37231 800 10 little little JJ 37231 800 11 practical practical JJ 37231 800 12 importance importance NN 37231 800 13 to to IN 37231 800 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 800 15 to to TO 37231 800 16 determine determine VB 37231 800 17 whether whether IN 37231 800 18 the the DT 37231 800 19 earth earth NN 37231 800 20 revolves revolve VBZ 37231 800 21 round round IN 37231 800 22 the the DT 37231 800 23 sun sun NN 37231 800 24 , , , 37231 800 25 or or CC 37231 800 26 the the DT 37231 800 27 sun sun NN 37231 800 28 round round IN 37231 800 29 the the DT 37231 800 30 earth earth NN 37231 800 31 ; ; : 37231 800 32 but but CC 37231 800 33 no no DT 37231 800 34 earnest earnest JJ 37231 800 35 mind mind NN 37231 800 36 can can MD 37231 800 37 fail fail VB 37231 800 38 to to TO 37231 800 39 perceive perceive VB 37231 800 40 the the DT 37231 800 41 immense immense JJ 37231 800 42 personal personal JJ 37231 800 43 importance importance NN 37231 800 44 of of IN 37231 800 45 Truth Truth NNP 37231 800 46 in in IN 37231 800 47 regard regard NN 37231 800 48 to to IN 37231 800 49 Religion religion NN 37231 800 50 -- -- : 37231 800 51 the the DT 37231 800 52 necessity necessity NN 37231 800 53 of of IN 37231 800 54 investigating investigate VBG 37231 800 55 , , , 37231 800 56 before before IN 37231 800 57 accepting accept VBG 37231 800 58 , , , 37231 800 59 dogmas dogmas NNP 37231 800 60 , , , 37231 800 61 the the DT 37231 800 62 right right JJ 37231 800 63 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 800 64 of of IN 37231 800 65 which which WDT 37231 800 66 is be VBZ 37231 800 67 represented represent VBN 37231 800 68 as as RB 37231 800 69 necessary necessary JJ 37231 800 70 to to IN 37231 800 71 salvation,--and salvation,--and VB 37231 800 72 the the DT 37231 800 73 clear clear JJ 37231 800 74 duty duty NN 37231 800 75 , , , 37231 800 76 before before IN 37231 800 77 abandoning abandon VBG 37231 800 78 reason reason NN 37231 800 79 for for IN 37231 800 80 faith faith NN 37231 800 81 , , , 37231 800 82 to to TO 37231 800 83 exercise exercise VB 37231 800 84 reason reason NN 37231 800 85 , , , 37231 800 86 in in IN 37231 800 87 order order NN 37231 800 88 that that DT 37231 800 89 faith faith NN 37231 800 90 may may MD 37231 800 91 not not RB 37231 800 92 be be VB 37231 800 93 mere mere JJ 37231 800 94 credulity credulity NN 37231 800 95 . . . 37231 801 1 As as IN 37231 801 2 Bacon Bacon NNP 37231 801 3 remarked remark VBD 37231 801 4 , , , 37231 801 5 the the DT 37231 801 6 injunction injunction NN 37231 801 7 : : : 37231 801 8 " " `` 37231 801 9 Hold hold VB 37231 801 10 fast fast JJ 37231 801 11 that that IN 37231 801 12 which which WDT 37231 801 13 is be VBZ 37231 801 14 good good JJ 37231 801 15 , , , 37231 801 16 " " '' 37231 801 17 must must MD 37231 801 18 always always RB 37231 801 19 be be VB 37231 801 20 preceded precede VBN 37231 801 21 by by IN 37231 801 22 the the DT 37231 801 23 maxim maxim NN 37231 801 24 : : : 37231 801 25 " " `` 37231 801 26 Prove prove VB 37231 801 27 all all DT 37231 801 28 things thing NNS 37231 801 29 . . . 37231 801 30 " " '' 37231 802 1 Even even RB 37231 802 2 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 802 3 Trench Trench NNP 37231 802 4 has have VBZ 37231 802 5 said say VBN 37231 802 6 : : : 37231 802 7 " " `` 37231 802 8 Credulity credulity NN 37231 802 9 is be VBZ 37231 802 10 as as RB 37231 802 11 real real JJ 37231 802 12 , , , 37231 802 13 if if IN 37231 802 14 not not RB 37231 802 15 so so RB 37231 802 16 great great JJ 37231 802 17 , , , 37231 802 18 a a DT 37231 802 19 sin sin NN 37231 802 20 as as IN 37231 802 21 unbelief unbelief NN 37231 802 22 , , , 37231 802 23 " " '' 37231 802 24 applying apply VBG 37231 802 25 the the DT 37231 802 26 observation observation NN 37231 802 27 to to IN 37231 802 28 the the DT 37231 802 29 duty duty NN 37231 802 30 of of IN 37231 802 31 demanding demand VBG 37231 802 32 a a DT 37231 802 33 " " `` 37231 802 34 sign sign NN 37231 802 35 " " '' 37231 802 36 from from IN 37231 802 37 any any DT 37231 802 38 one one CD 37231 802 39 professing profess VBG 37231 802 40 to to TO 37231 802 41 be be VB 37231 802 42 the the DT 37231 802 43 utterer utterer NN 37231 802 44 of of IN 37231 802 45 a a DT 37231 802 46 revelation revelation NN 37231 802 47 : : : 37231 802 48 " " `` 37231 802 49 Else else RB 37231 802 50 might may MD 37231 802 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 802 52 lightly lightly RB 37231 802 53 { { -LRB- 37231 802 54 xcvii xcvii NN 37231 802 55 } } -RRB- 37231 802 56 be be VB 37231 802 57 persuaded persuade VBN 37231 802 58 to to TO 37231 802 59 receive receive VB 37231 802 60 that that IN 37231 802 61 as as IN 37231 802 62 from from IN 37231 802 63 God God NNP 37231 802 64 , , , 37231 802 65 which which WDT 37231 802 66 , , , 37231 802 67 indeed indeed RB 37231 802 68 , , , 37231 802 69 was be VBD 37231 802 70 only only RB 37231 802 71 the the DT 37231 802 72 word word NN 37231 802 73 of of IN 37231 802 74 man man NN 37231 802 75 . . . 37231 803 1 " " `` 37231 803 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 803 3 1 1 LS 37231 803 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 803 5 The the DT 37231 803 6 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 803 7 of of IN 37231 803 8 any any DT 37231 803 9 revelation revelation NN 37231 803 10 or or CC 37231 803 11 dogma dogma NN 37231 803 12 , , , 37231 803 13 however however RB 37231 803 14 apparently apparently RB 37231 803 15 true true JJ 37231 803 16 in in IN 37231 803 17 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 803 18 , , , 37231 803 19 without without IN 37231 803 20 " " `` 37231 803 21 sign"--without sign"--without NN 37231 803 22 evidence evidence NN 37231 803 23 satisfying satisfy VBG 37231 803 24 the the DT 37231 803 25 reason reason NN 37231 803 26 , , , 37231 803 27 is be VBZ 37231 803 28 absolute absolute JJ 37231 803 29 credulity credulity NN 37231 803 30 . . . 37231 804 1 Even even RB 37231 804 2 the the DT 37231 804 3 most most RBS 37231 804 4 thorough thorough JJ 37231 804 5 advocate advocate NN 37231 804 6 of of IN 37231 804 7 Faith Faith NNP 37231 804 8 must must MD 37231 804 9 recognise recognise VB 37231 804 10 that that DT 37231 804 11 reason reason NN 37231 804 12 must must MD 37231 804 13 be be VB 37231 804 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 804 15 basis basis NN 37231 804 16 , , , 37231 804 17 and and CC 37231 804 18 that that DT 37231 804 19 faith faith NN 37231 804 20 can can MD 37231 804 21 only only RB 37231 804 22 legitimately legitimately RB 37231 804 23 commence commence VB 37231 804 24 where where WRB 37231 804 25 reason reason NN 37231 804 26 fails fail VBZ 37231 804 27 . . . 37231 805 1 The the DT 37231 805 2 appeal appeal NN 37231 805 3 is be VBZ 37231 805 4 first first JJ 37231 805 5 to to TO 37231 805 6 reason reason VB 37231 805 7 if if IN 37231 805 8 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 805 9 to to IN 37231 805 10 faith faith NN 37231 805 11 , , , 37231 805 12 and and CC 37231 805 13 no no DT 37231 805 14 man man NN 37231 805 15 pretending pretend VBG 37231 805 16 to to IN 37231 805 17 intellectual intellectual JJ 37231 805 18 conscience conscience NN 37231 805 19 can can MD 37231 805 20 overlook overlook VB 37231 805 21 the the DT 37231 805 22 primary primary JJ 37231 805 23 claim claim NN 37231 805 24 of of IN 37231 805 25 reason reason NN 37231 805 26 . . . 37231 806 1 If if IN 37231 806 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 806 3 is be VBZ 37231 806 4 to to TO 37231 806 5 be be VB 37231 806 6 more more JJR 37231 806 7 than than IN 37231 806 8 a a DT 37231 806 9 mere mere JJ 37231 806 10 question question NN 37231 806 11 of of IN 37231 806 12 priority priority NN 37231 806 13 of of IN 37231 806 14 presentation presentation NN 37231 806 15 whether whether IN 37231 806 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 806 17 are be VBP 37231 806 18 to to TO 37231 806 19 accept accept VB 37231 806 20 Buddhism Buddhism NNP 37231 806 21 , , , 37231 806 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 806 23 , , , 37231 806 24 or or CC 37231 806 25 Mahometanism Mahometanism NNP 37231 806 26 , , , 37231 806 27 we -PRON- PRP 37231 806 28 must must MD 37231 806 29 strictly strictly RB 37231 806 30 and and CC 37231 806 31 fearlessly fearlessly RB 37231 806 32 examine examine VB 37231 806 33 the the DT 37231 806 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 806 35 upon upon IN 37231 806 36 which which WDT 37231 806 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 806 38 profess profess VBP 37231 806 39 to to TO 37231 806 40 stand stand VB 37231 806 41 . . . 37231 807 1 The the DT 37231 807 2 neglect neglect NN 37231 807 3 of of IN 37231 807 4 examination examination NN 37231 807 5 can can MD 37231 807 6 never never RB 37231 807 7 advance advance VB 37231 807 8 truth truth NN 37231 807 9 , , , 37231 807 10 as as IN 37231 807 11 the the DT 37231 807 12 severest severe JJS 37231 807 13 scrutiny scrutiny NN 37231 807 14 can can MD 37231 807 15 never never RB 37231 807 16 retard retard VB 37231 807 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 807 18 , , , 37231 807 19 but but CC 37231 807 20 belief belief NN 37231 807 21 without without IN 37231 807 22 discrimination discrimination NN 37231 807 23 can can MD 37231 807 24 only only RB 37231 807 25 foster foster VB 37231 807 26 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 807 27 and and CC 37231 807 28 superstition superstition NN 37231 807 29 . . . 37231 808 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 808 2 was be VBD 37231 808 3 in in IN 37231 808 4 this this DT 37231 808 5 conviction conviction NN 37231 808 6 that that IN 37231 808 7 the the DT 37231 808 8 following follow VBG 37231 808 9 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 808 10 into into IN 37231 808 11 the the DT 37231 808 12 reality reality NN 37231 808 13 of of IN 37231 808 14 Divine Divine NNP 37231 808 15 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 808 16 was be VBD 37231 808 17 originally originally RB 37231 808 18 undertaken undertake VBN 37231 808 19 , , , 37231 808 20 and and CC 37231 808 21 that that IN 37231 808 22 others other NNS 37231 808 23 should should MD 37231 808 24 enter enter VB 37231 808 25 upon upon IN 37231 808 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 808 27 . . . 37231 809 1 An an DT 37231 809 2 able able JJ 37231 809 3 writer writer NN 37231 809 4 , , , 37231 809 5 who who WP 37231 809 6 will will MD 37231 809 7 not not RB 37231 809 8 be be VB 37231 809 9 suspected suspect VBN 37231 809 10 of of IN 37231 809 11 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37231 809 12 on on IN 37231 809 13 this this DT 37231 809 14 subject subject NN 37231 809 15 , , , 37231 809 16 has have VBZ 37231 809 17 said say VBD 37231 809 18 : : : 37231 809 19 " " `` 37231 809 20 The the DT 37231 809 21 majority majority NN 37231 809 22 of of IN 37231 809 23 mankind mankind NN 37231 809 24 , , , 37231 809 25 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 809 26 , , , 37231 809 27 owe owe VBP 37231 809 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 809 29 belief belief NN 37231 809 30 rather rather RB 37231 809 31 to to IN 37231 809 32 the the DT 37231 809 33 outward outward JJ 37231 809 34 influence influence NN 37231 809 35 of of IN 37231 809 36 custom custom NN 37231 809 37 and and CC 37231 809 38 education education NN 37231 809 39 , , , 37231 809 40 than than IN 37231 809 41 to to IN 37231 809 42 any any DT 37231 809 43 strong strong JJ 37231 809 44 principle principle NN 37231 809 45 of of IN 37231 809 46 faith faith NN 37231 809 47 within within IN 37231 809 48 ; ; : 37231 809 49 and and CC 37231 809 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 809 51 is be VBZ 37231 809 52 to to TO 37231 809 53 be be VB 37231 809 54 feared fear VBN 37231 809 55 that that IN 37231 809 56 many many JJ 37231 809 57 if if IN 37231 809 58 they -PRON- PRP 37231 809 59 came come VBD 37231 809 60 to to TO 37231 809 61 perceive perceive VB 37231 809 62 how how WRB 37231 809 63 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 809 64 what what WP 37231 809 65 they -PRON- PRP 37231 809 66 believed believe VBD 37231 809 67 was be VBD 37231 809 68 , , , 37231 809 69 would would MD 37231 809 70 not not RB 37231 809 71 find find VB 37231 809 72 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 809 73 belief belief NN 37231 809 74 so so RB 37231 809 75 easy easy RB 37231 809 76 , , , 37231 809 77 and and CC 37231 809 78 so so RB 37231 809 79 matter matter JJ 37231 809 80 - - HYPH 37231 809 81 of of IN 37231 809 82 - - HYPH 37231 809 83 course course NN 37231 809 84 a a DT 37231 809 85 thing thing NN 37231 809 86 as as IN 37231 809 87 they -PRON- PRP 37231 809 88 appear appear VBP 37231 809 89 to to TO 37231 809 90 find find VB 37231 809 91 it -PRON- PRP 37231 809 92 . . . 37231 810 1 " " `` 37231 810 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 810 3 2 2 LS 37231 810 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 810 5 To to IN 37231 810 6 no no DT 37231 810 7 earnest earnest JJ 37231 810 8 mind mind NN 37231 810 9 can can MD 37231 810 10 such such JJ 37231 810 11 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 810 12 be be VB 37231 810 13 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 810 14 than than IN 37231 810 15 a a DT 37231 810 16 serious serious JJ 37231 810 17 and and CC 37231 810 18 often often RB 37231 810 19 a a DT 37231 810 20 { { -LRB- 37231 810 21 xcviii xcviii NN 37231 810 22 } } -RRB- 37231 810 23 painful painful JJ 37231 810 24 task task NN 37231 810 25 , , , 37231 810 26 but but CC 37231 810 27 , , , 37231 810 28 dismissing dismiss VBG 37231 810 29 preconceived preconceived JJ 37231 810 30 ideas idea NNS 37231 810 31 and and CC 37231 810 32 preferences preference NNS 37231 810 33 derived derive VBN 37231 810 34 from from IN 37231 810 35 habit habit NN 37231 810 36 and and CC 37231 810 37 education education NN 37231 810 38 , , , 37231 810 39 and and CC 37231 810 40 seeking seek VBG 37231 810 41 only only RB 37231 810 42 the the DT 37231 810 43 Truth truth NN 37231 810 44 , , , 37231 810 45 holding hold VBG 37231 810 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 810 47 , , , 37231 810 48 whatever whatever WDT 37231 810 49 it -PRON- PRP 37231 810 50 may may MD 37231 810 51 be be VB 37231 810 52 , , , 37231 810 53 to to TO 37231 810 54 be be VB 37231 810 55 the the DT 37231 810 56 only only JJ 37231 810 57 object object NN 37231 810 58 worthy worthy JJ 37231 810 59 of of IN 37231 810 60 desire desire NN 37231 810 61 , , , 37231 810 62 or or CC 37231 810 63 capable capable JJ 37231 810 64 of of IN 37231 810 65 satisfying satisfy VBG 37231 810 66 a a DT 37231 810 67 rational rational JJ 37231 810 68 mind mind NN 37231 810 69 , , , 37231 810 70 the the DT 37231 810 71 quest quest NN 37231 810 72 can can MD 37231 810 73 not not RB 37231 810 74 but but RB 37231 810 75 end end VB 37231 810 76 in in IN 37231 810 77 peace peace NN 37231 810 78 and and CC 37231 810 79 satisfaction satisfaction NN 37231 810 80 . . . 37231 811 1 In in IN 37231 811 2 such such PDT 37231 811 3 an an DT 37231 811 4 investigation investigation NN 37231 811 5 , , , 37231 811 6 however however RB 37231 811 7 , , , 37231 811 8 to to TO 37231 811 9 quote quote VB 37231 811 10 words word NNS 37231 811 11 of of IN 37231 811 12 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 811 13 Whately whately RB 37231 811 14 : : : 37231 811 15 " " `` 37231 811 16 It -PRON- PRP 37231 811 17 makes make VBZ 37231 811 18 all all PDT 37231 811 19 the the DT 37231 811 20 difference difference NN 37231 811 21 in in IN 37231 811 22 the the DT 37231 811 23 world world NN 37231 811 24 whether whether IN 37231 811 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 811 26 place place VBP 37231 811 27 Truth truth NN 37231 811 28 in in IN 37231 811 29 the the DT 37231 811 30 first first JJ 37231 811 31 place place NN 37231 811 32 or or CC 37231 811 33 in in IN 37231 811 34 the the DT 37231 811 35 second second JJ 37231 811 36 place place NN 37231 811 37 . . . 37231 811 38 " " '' 37231 812 1 --for --for NFP 37231 812 2 if if IN 37231 812 3 Truth Truth NNP 37231 812 4 acquired acquire VBN 37231 812 5 do do VBP 37231 812 6 not not RB 37231 812 7 compensate compensate VB 37231 812 8 for for IN 37231 812 9 every every DT 37231 812 10 pet pet JJ 37231 812 11 illusion illusion NN 37231 812 12 dispelled dispel VBN 37231 812 13 , , , 37231 812 14 the the DT 37231 812 15 path path NN 37231 812 16 is be VBZ 37231 812 17 thorny thorny JJ 37231 812 18 indeed indeed RB 37231 812 19 , , , 37231 812 20 although although IN 37231 812 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 812 22 must must MD 37231 812 23 still still RB 37231 812 24 be be VB 37231 812 25 faithfully faithfully RB 37231 812 26 trodden trodden JJ 37231 812 27 . . . 37231 813 1 AN an DT 37231 813 2 INQUIRY INQUIRY NNP 37231 813 3 INTO into VBP 37231 813 4 THE the DT 37231 813 5 REALITY reality NN 37231 813 6 OF of IN 37231 813 7 DIVINE DIVINE NNP 37231 813 8 REVELATION REVELATION NNP 37231 813 9 . . . 37231 814 1 PART PART NNP 37231 814 2 I. I. NNP 37231 815 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 37231 815 2 I. i. NN 37231 815 3 MIRACLES MIRACLES NNP 37231 815 4 IN in IN 37231 815 5 RELATION relation NN 37231 815 6 TO to IN 37231 815 7 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 37231 815 8 At at IN 37231 815 9 the the DT 37231 815 10 very very JJ 37231 815 11 outset outset NN 37231 815 12 of of IN 37231 815 13 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 815 14 into into IN 37231 815 15 the the DT 37231 815 16 origin origin NN 37231 815 17 and and CC 37231 815 18 true true JJ 37231 815 19 character character NN 37231 815 20 of of IN 37231 815 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 815 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 815 23 are be VBP 37231 815 24 brought bring VBN 37231 815 25 face face NN 37231 815 26 to to IN 37231 815 27 face face NN 37231 815 28 with with IN 37231 815 29 the the DT 37231 815 30 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 37231 815 31 . . . 37231 816 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 816 2 professes profess VBZ 37231 816 3 to to TO 37231 816 4 be be VB 37231 816 5 a a DT 37231 816 6 Divine Divine NNP 37231 816 7 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 816 8 of of IN 37231 816 9 truths truth NNS 37231 816 10 which which WDT 37231 816 11 the the DT 37231 816 12 human human JJ 37231 816 13 intellect intellect NN 37231 816 14 could could MD 37231 816 15 not not RB 37231 816 16 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 816 17 have have VB 37231 816 18 discovered discover VBN 37231 816 19 . . . 37231 817 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 817 2 is be VBZ 37231 817 3 not not RB 37231 817 4 a a DT 37231 817 5 form form NN 37231 817 6 of of IN 37231 817 7 religion religion NN 37231 817 8 developed develop VBN 37231 817 9 by by IN 37231 817 10 the the DT 37231 817 11 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 817 12 of of IN 37231 817 13 man man NN 37231 817 14 and and CC 37231 817 15 appealing appeal VBG 37231 817 16 to to IN 37231 817 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 817 18 reason reason NN 37231 817 19 , , , 37231 817 20 but but CC 37231 817 21 a a DT 37231 817 22 system system NN 37231 817 23 miraculously miraculously RB 37231 817 24 communicated communicate VBN 37231 817 25 to to IN 37231 817 26 the the DT 37231 817 27 human human JJ 37231 817 28 race race NN 37231 817 29 , , , 37231 817 30 the the DT 37231 817 31 central central JJ 37231 817 32 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 817 33 of of IN 37231 817 34 which which WDT 37231 817 35 are be VBP 37231 817 36 either either CC 37231 817 37 superhuman superhuman JJ 37231 817 38 or or CC 37231 817 39 untenable untenable JJ 37231 817 40 . . . 37231 818 1 If if IN 37231 818 2 the the DT 37231 818 3 truths truth NNS 37231 818 4 said say VBD 37231 818 5 to to TO 37231 818 6 be be VB 37231 818 7 revealed reveal VBN 37231 818 8 were be VBD 37231 818 9 either either RB 37231 818 10 of of IN 37231 818 11 an an DT 37231 818 12 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 818 13 character character NN 37231 818 14 or or CC 37231 818 15 naturally naturally RB 37231 818 16 attainable attainable JJ 37231 818 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 818 18 would would MD 37231 818 19 at at IN 37231 818 20 once once RB 37231 818 21 discredit discredit VB 37231 818 22 the the DT 37231 818 23 claim claim NN 37231 818 24 to to IN 37231 818 25 a a DT 37231 818 26 Divine Divine NNP 37231 818 27 origin origin NN 37231 818 28 . . . 37231 819 1 No no DT 37231 819 2 one one PRP 37231 819 3 could could MD 37231 819 4 maintain maintain VB 37231 819 5 that that IN 37231 819 6 a a DT 37231 819 7 system system NN 37231 819 8 discoverable discoverable JJ 37231 819 9 by by IN 37231 819 10 Reason reason NN 37231 819 11 would would MD 37231 819 12 be be VB 37231 819 13 supernaturally supernaturally RB 37231 819 14 communicated communicate VBN 37231 819 15 . . . 37231 820 1 The the DT 37231 820 2 whole whole JJ 37231 820 3 argument argument NN 37231 820 4 for for IN 37231 820 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 820 6 turns turn VBZ 37231 820 7 upon upon IN 37231 820 8 the the DT 37231 820 9 necessity necessity NN 37231 820 10 of of IN 37231 820 11 such such PDT 37231 820 12 a a DT 37231 820 13 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 820 14 and and CC 37231 820 15 the the DT 37231 820 16 consequent consequent JJ 37231 820 17 probability probability NN 37231 820 18 that that IN 37231 820 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 820 20 would would MD 37231 820 21 be be VB 37231 820 22 made make VBN 37231 820 23 . . . 37231 821 1 { { -LRB- 37231 821 2 2 2 LS 37231 821 3 } } -RRB- 37231 821 4 There there EX 37231 821 5 is be VBZ 37231 821 6 nothing nothing NN 37231 821 7 singular singular JJ 37231 821 8 , , , 37231 821 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 821 10 may may MD 37231 821 11 be be VB 37231 821 12 remarked remark VBN 37231 821 13 , , , 37231 821 14 in in IN 37231 821 15 the the DT 37231 821 16 claim claim NN 37231 821 17 of of IN 37231 821 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 821 19 to to TO 37231 821 20 be be VB 37231 821 21 a a DT 37231 821 22 direct direct JJ 37231 821 23 Revelation revelation NN 37231 821 24 from from IN 37231 821 25 God God NNP 37231 821 26 . . . 37231 822 1 With with IN 37231 822 2 the the DT 37231 822 3 exception exception NN 37231 822 4 of of IN 37231 822 5 the the DT 37231 822 6 religions religion NNS 37231 822 7 of of IN 37231 822 8 Greece Greece NNP 37231 822 9 and and CC 37231 822 10 Rome Rome NNP 37231 822 11 , , , 37231 822 12 which which WDT 37231 822 13 , , , 37231 822 14 however however RB 37231 822 15 , , , 37231 822 16 also also RB 37231 822 17 had have VBD 37231 822 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 822 19 subsidiary subsidiary NN 37231 822 20 supposition supposition NN 37231 822 21 of of IN 37231 822 22 divine divine JJ 37231 822 23 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 822 24 , , , 37231 822 25 there there EX 37231 822 26 has have VBZ 37231 822 27 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 822 28 been be VBN 37231 822 29 any any DT 37231 822 30 system system NN 37231 822 31 of of IN 37231 822 32 Religion religion NN 37231 822 33 which which WDT 37231 822 34 has have VBZ 37231 822 35 not not RB 37231 822 36 been be VBN 37231 822 37 proclaimed proclaim VBN 37231 822 38 to to IN 37231 822 39 the the DT 37231 822 40 world world NN 37231 822 41 as as IN 37231 822 42 a a DT 37231 822 43 direct direct JJ 37231 822 44 divine divine JJ 37231 822 45 communication communication NN 37231 822 46 . . . 37231 823 1 Long long RB 37231 823 2 before before IN 37231 823 3 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 823 4 claimed claim VBD 37231 823 5 this this DT 37231 823 6 character character NN 37231 823 7 , , , 37231 823 8 the the DT 37231 823 9 religions religion NNS 37231 823 10 of of IN 37231 823 11 India India NNP 37231 823 12 had have VBD 37231 823 13 anticipated anticipate VBN 37231 823 14 the the DT 37231 823 15 idea idea NN 37231 823 16 . . . 37231 824 1 To to TO 37231 824 2 quote quote VB 37231 824 3 the the DT 37231 824 4 words word NNS 37231 824 5 of of IN 37231 824 6 an an DT 37231 824 7 accomplished accomplish VBN 37231 824 8 scholar:--"According scholar:--"According : 37231 824 9 to to IN 37231 824 10 the the DT 37231 824 11 orthodox orthodox JJ 37231 824 12 views view NNS 37231 824 13 of of IN 37231 824 14 Indian indian JJ 37231 824 15 theologians theologian NNS 37231 824 16 , , , 37231 824 17 not not RB 37231 824 18 a a DT 37231 824 19 single single JJ 37231 824 20 line line NN 37231 824 21 of of IN 37231 824 22 the the DT 37231 824 23 Veda Veda NNP 37231 824 24 was be VBD 37231 824 25 the the DT 37231 824 26 work work NN 37231 824 27 of of IN 37231 824 28 human human JJ 37231 824 29 authors author NNS 37231 824 30 . . . 37231 825 1 The the DT 37231 825 2 whole whole JJ 37231 825 3 Veda Veda NNP 37231 825 4 is be VBZ 37231 825 5 in in IN 37231 825 6 some some DT 37231 825 7 way way NN 37231 825 8 or or CC 37231 825 9 other other JJ 37231 825 10 the the DT 37231 825 11 work work NN 37231 825 12 of of IN 37231 825 13 the the DT 37231 825 14 Deity Deity NNP 37231 825 15 ; ; : 37231 825 16 and and CC 37231 825 17 even even RB 37231 825 18 those those DT 37231 825 19 who who WP 37231 825 20 received receive VBD 37231 825 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 825 22 were be VBD 37231 825 23 not not RB 37231 825 24 supposed suppose VBN 37231 825 25 to to TO 37231 825 26 be be VB 37231 825 27 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 825 28 mortals mortal NNS 37231 825 29 , , , 37231 825 30 but but CC 37231 825 31 beings being NNS 37231 825 32 raised raise VBN 37231 825 33 above above IN 37231 825 34 the the DT 37231 825 35 level level NN 37231 825 36 of of IN 37231 825 37 common common JJ 37231 825 38 humanity humanity NN 37231 825 39 , , , 37231 825 40 and and CC 37231 825 41 less less RBR 37231 825 42 liable liable JJ 37231 825 43 , , , 37231 825 44 therefore therefore RB 37231 825 45 , , , 37231 825 46 to to TO 37231 825 47 error error VB 37231 825 48 in in IN 37231 825 49 the the DT 37231 825 50 reception reception NN 37231 825 51 of of IN 37231 825 52 revealed reveal VBN 37231 825 53 truth truth NN 37231 825 54 . . . 37231 826 1 " " `` 37231 826 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 826 3 1 1 LS 37231 826 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 826 5 The the DT 37231 826 6 same same JJ 37231 826 7 origin origin NN 37231 826 8 is be VBZ 37231 826 9 claimed claim VBN 37231 826 10 for for IN 37231 826 11 the the DT 37231 826 12 religion religion NN 37231 826 13 of of IN 37231 826 14 Zoroaster Zoroaster NNP 37231 826 15 , , , 37231 826 16 whose whose WP$ 37231 826 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 826 18 , , , 37231 826 19 beyond beyond IN 37231 826 20 doubt doubt NN 37231 826 21 , , , 37231 826 22 exercised exercise VBN 37231 826 23 great great JJ 37231 826 24 influence influence NN 37231 826 25 at at IN 37231 826 26 least least JJS 37231 826 27 upon upon IN 37231 826 28 later later JJ 37231 826 29 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 826 30 theology theology NN 37231 826 31 , , , 37231 826 32 and and CC 37231 826 33 whose whose WP$ 37231 826 34 Magian magian JJ 37231 826 35 followers follower NNS 37231 826 36 are be VBP 37231 826 37 appropriately appropriately RB 37231 826 38 introduced introduce VBN 37231 826 39 beside beside IN 37231 826 40 the the DT 37231 826 41 cradle cradle NN 37231 826 42 of of IN 37231 826 43 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 826 44 , , , 37231 826 45 as as IN 37231 826 46 the the DT 37231 826 47 first first JJ 37231 826 48 to to TO 37231 826 49 do do VB 37231 826 50 honour honour NN 37231 826 51 to to IN 37231 826 52 the the DT 37231 826 53 birth birth NN 37231 826 54 of of IN 37231 826 55 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 826 56 . . . 37231 827 1 In in IN 37231 827 2 the the DT 37231 827 3 same same JJ 37231 827 4 way way NN 37231 827 5 Mahomet Mahomet NNP 37231 827 6 announced announce VBD 37231 827 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 827 8 religion religion NN 37231 827 9 as as RB 37231 827 10 directly directly RB 37231 827 11 communicated communicate VBN 37231 827 12 from from IN 37231 827 13 heaven heaven NNP 37231 827 14 . . . 37231 828 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 828 2 , , , 37231 828 3 however however RB 37231 828 4 , , , 37231 828 5 as as IN 37231 828 6 a a DT 37231 828 7 religion religion NN 37231 828 8 professing profess VBG 37231 828 9 to to TO 37231 828 10 be be VB 37231 828 11 divinely divinely RB 37231 828 12 revealed reveal VBN 37231 828 13 , , , 37231 828 14 is be VBZ 37231 828 15 not not RB 37231 828 16 only only RB 37231 828 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 828 18 in in IN 37231 828 19 origin origin NN 37231 828 20 and and CC 37231 828 21 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 828 22 , , , 37231 828 23 but but CC 37231 828 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 828 25 claim claim NN 37231 828 26 to to IN 37231 828 27 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 828 28 is be VBZ 37231 828 29 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 828 30 based base VBN 37231 828 31 upon upon IN 37231 828 32 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 828 33 evidence evidence NN 37231 828 34 ; ; : 37231 828 35 for for IN 37231 828 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 828 37 is be VBZ 37231 828 38 obvious obvious JJ 37231 828 39 that that IN 37231 828 40 truths truth NNS 37231 828 41 which which WDT 37231 828 42 require require VBP 37231 828 43 to to TO 37231 828 44 be be VB 37231 828 45 miraculously miraculously RB 37231 828 46 communicated communicate VBN 37231 828 47 do do VB 37231 828 48 not not RB 37231 828 49 come come VB 37231 828 50 within within IN 37231 828 51 the the DT 37231 828 52 range range NN 37231 828 53 of of IN 37231 828 54 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 828 55 intellect intellect NN 37231 828 56 , , , 37231 828 57 and and CC 37231 828 58 can can MD 37231 828 59 not not RB 37231 828 60 , , , 37231 828 61 therefore therefore RB 37231 828 62 , , , 37231 828 63 be be VB 37231 828 64 intelligently intelligently RB 37231 828 65 received receive VBN 37231 828 66 upon upon IN 37231 828 67 internal internal JJ 37231 828 68 testimony testimony NN 37231 828 69 . . . 37231 829 1 " " `` 37231 829 2 And and CC 37231 829 3 , , , 37231 829 4 certainly certainly RB 37231 829 5 , , , 37231 829 6 " " '' 37231 829 7 says say VBZ 37231 829 8 a a DT 37231 829 9 recent recent JJ 37231 829 10 able able JJ 37231 829 11 Bampton Bampton NNP 37231 829 12 Lecturer Lecturer NNP 37231 829 13 , , , 37231 829 14 " " `` 37231 829 15 if if IN 37231 829 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 829 17 was be VBD 37231 829 18 the the DT 37231 829 19 will will NN 37231 829 20 of of IN 37231 829 21 God God NNP 37231 829 22 to to TO 37231 829 23 give give VB 37231 829 24 a a DT 37231 829 25 revelation revelation NN 37231 829 26 , , , 37231 829 27 there there EX 37231 829 28 are be VBP 37231 829 29 { { -LRB- 37231 829 30 3 3 CD 37231 829 31 } } -RRB- 37231 829 32 plain plain JJ 37231 829 33 and and CC 37231 829 34 obvious obvious JJ 37231 829 35 reasons reason NNS 37231 829 36 for for IN 37231 829 37 asserting assert VBG 37231 829 38 that that IN 37231 829 39 miracles miracle NNS 37231 829 40 are be VBP 37231 829 41 necessary necessary JJ 37231 829 42 as as IN 37231 829 43 the the DT 37231 829 44 guarantee guarantee NN 37231 829 45 and and CC 37231 829 46 voucher voucher NN 37231 829 47 for for IN 37231 829 48 that that DT 37231 829 49 revelation revelation NN 37231 829 50 . . . 37231 830 1 A a DT 37231 830 2 revelation revelation NN 37231 830 3 is be VBZ 37231 830 4 , , , 37231 830 5 properly properly RB 37231 830 6 speaking speak VBG 37231 830 7 , , , 37231 830 8 such such JJ 37231 830 9 only only RB 37231 830 10 by by IN 37231 830 11 virtue virtue NN 37231 830 12 of of IN 37231 830 13 telling tell VBG 37231 830 14 us -PRON- PRP 37231 830 15 something something NN 37231 830 16 which which WDT 37231 830 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 830 18 could could MD 37231 830 19 not not RB 37231 830 20 know know VB 37231 830 21 without without IN 37231 830 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 830 23 . . . 37231 831 1 But but CC 37231 831 2 how how WRB 37231 831 3 do do VBP 37231 831 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 831 5 know know VB 37231 831 6 that that IN 37231 831 7 that that DT 37231 831 8 communication communication NN 37231 831 9 of of IN 37231 831 10 what what WP 37231 831 11 is be VBZ 37231 831 12 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 37231 831 13 by by IN 37231 831 14 human human JJ 37231 831 15 reason reason NN 37231 831 16 is be VBZ 37231 831 17 true true JJ 37231 831 18 ? ? . 37231 832 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 832 2 reason reason NN 37231 832 3 can can MD 37231 832 4 not not RB 37231 832 5 prove prove VB 37231 832 6 the the DT 37231 832 7 truth truth NN 37231 832 8 of of IN 37231 832 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 832 10 , , , 37231 832 11 for for IN 37231 832 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 832 13 is be VBZ 37231 832 14 by by IN 37231 832 15 the the DT 37231 832 16 very very JJ 37231 832 17 supposition supposition NN 37231 832 18 beyond beyond IN 37231 832 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 832 20 reason reason NN 37231 832 21 . . . 37231 833 1 There there EX 37231 833 2 must must MD 37231 833 3 be be VB 37231 833 4 , , , 37231 833 5 then then RB 37231 833 6 , , , 37231 833 7 some some DT 37231 833 8 note note NN 37231 833 9 or or CC 37231 833 10 sign sign VB 37231 833 11 to to TO 37231 833 12 certify certify VB 37231 833 13 to to IN 37231 833 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 833 15 and and CC 37231 833 16 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 833 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 833 18 as as IN 37231 833 19 a a DT 37231 833 20 true true JJ 37231 833 21 communication communication NN 37231 833 22 from from IN 37231 833 23 God God NNP 37231 833 24 , , , 37231 833 25 which which WDT 37231 833 26 note note VBP 37231 833 27 can can MD 37231 833 28 be be VB 37231 833 29 nothing nothing NN 37231 833 30 else else RB 37231 833 31 than than IN 37231 833 32 a a DT 37231 833 33 miracle miracle NN 37231 833 34 . . . 37231 834 1 " " `` 37231 834 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 834 3 1 1 CD 37231 834 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 834 5 In in IN 37231 834 6 another another DT 37231 834 7 place place NN 37231 834 8 the the DT 37231 834 9 same same JJ 37231 834 10 Lecturer Lecturer NNP 37231 834 11 stigmatizes stigmatize VBZ 37231 834 12 the the DT 37231 834 13 belief belief NN 37231 834 14 of of IN 37231 834 15 the the DT 37231 834 16 Mahometan Mahometan NNP 37231 834 17 " " '' 37231 834 18 as as IN 37231 834 19 in in IN 37231 834 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 834 21 very very RB 37231 834 22 principle principle JJ 37231 834 23 irrational irrational NN 37231 834 24 , , , 37231 834 25 " " '' 37231 834 26 because because IN 37231 834 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 834 28 accepts accept VBZ 37231 834 29 the the DT 37231 834 30 account account NN 37231 834 31 which which WDT 37231 834 32 Mahomet Mahomet NNP 37231 834 33 gave give VBD 37231 834 34 of of IN 37231 834 35 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 834 36 , , , 37231 834 37 without without IN 37231 834 38 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 834 39 evidence evidence NN 37231 834 40 . . . 37231 835 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 835 2 2 2 LS 37231 835 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 835 4 The the DT 37231 835 5 belief belief NN 37231 835 6 of of IN 37231 835 7 the the DT 37231 835 8 Christian Christian NNP 37231 835 9 is be VBZ 37231 835 10 contrasted contrast VBN 37231 835 11 with with IN 37231 835 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 835 13 as as IN 37231 835 14 rational rational JJ 37231 835 15 , , , 37231 835 16 " " '' 37231 835 17 because because IN 37231 835 18 the the DT 37231 835 19 Christian Christian NNP 37231 835 20 believes believe VBZ 37231 835 21 in in IN 37231 835 22 a a DT 37231 835 23 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 835 24 dispensation dispensation NN 37231 835 25 upon upon IN 37231 835 26 the the DT 37231 835 27 proper proper JJ 37231 835 28 evidence evidence NN 37231 835 29 of of IN 37231 835 30 such such PDT 37231 835 31 a a DT 37231 835 32 dispensation dispensation NN 37231 835 33 , , , 37231 835 34 viz viz NNP 37231 835 35 . . NNP 37231 835 36 , , , 37231 835 37 the the DT 37231 835 38 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 835 39 . . . 37231 836 1 " " `` 37231 836 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 836 3 3 3 LS 37231 836 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 836 5 Mahomet Mahomet NNP 37231 836 6 is be VBZ 37231 836 7 reproached reproach VBN 37231 836 8 with with IN 37231 836 9 having have VBG 37231 836 10 " " `` 37231 836 11 an an DT 37231 836 12 utterly utterly RB 37231 836 13 barbarous barbarous JJ 37231 836 14 idea idea NN 37231 836 15 of of IN 37231 836 16 evidence evidence NN 37231 836 17 , , , 37231 836 18 and and CC 37231 836 19 a a DT 37231 836 20 total total JJ 37231 836 21 miscalculation miscalculation NN 37231 836 22 of of IN 37231 836 23 the the DT 37231 836 24 claims claim NNS 37231 836 25 of of IN 37231 836 26 reason reason NN 37231 836 27 , , , 37231 836 28 " " '' 37231 836 29 because because IN 37231 836 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 836 31 did do VBD 37231 836 32 not not RB 37231 836 33 consider consider VB 37231 836 34 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 836 35 evidence evidence NN 37231 836 36 necessary necessary JJ 37231 836 37 to to TO 37231 836 38 attest attest VB 37231 836 39 a a DT 37231 836 40 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 836 41 dispensation dispensation NN 37231 836 42 ; ; : 37231 836 43 " " `` 37231 836 44 whereas whereas IN 37231 836 45 the the DT 37231 836 46 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 836 47 is be VBZ 37231 836 48 adapted adapt VBN 37231 836 49 to to IN 37231 836 50 perpetuity perpetuity NN 37231 836 51 for for IN 37231 836 52 this this DT 37231 836 53 cause cause NN 37231 836 54 especially especially RB 37231 836 55 , , , 37231 836 56 with with IN 37231 836 57 others other NNS 37231 836 58 , , , 37231 836 59 that that IN 37231 836 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 836 61 was be VBD 37231 836 62 founded found VBN 37231 836 63 upon upon IN 37231 836 64 a a DT 37231 836 65 true true JJ 37231 836 66 calculation calculation NN 37231 836 67 , , , 37231 836 68 and and CC 37231 836 69 a a DT 37231 836 70 foresight foresight NN 37231 836 71 of of IN 37231 836 72 the the DT 37231 836 73 permanent permanent JJ 37231 836 74 need need NN 37231 836 75 of of IN 37231 836 76 evidence evidence NN 37231 836 77 ; ; : 37231 836 78 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 836 79 Lord Lord NNP 37231 836 80 admitting admit VBG 37231 836 81 the the DT 37231 836 82 inadequacy inadequacy NN 37231 836 83 of of IN 37231 836 84 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 836 85 own own JJ 37231 836 86 mere mere JJ 37231 836 87 word word NN 37231 836 88 , , , 37231 836 89 and and CC 37231 836 90 the the DT 37231 836 91 necessity necessity NN 37231 836 92 of of IN 37231 836 93 a a DT 37231 836 94 rational rational JJ 37231 836 95 guarantee guarantee NN 37231 836 96 to to IN 37231 836 97 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 836 98 revelation revelation NN 37231 836 99 of of IN 37231 836 100 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 836 101 own own JJ 37231 836 102 nature nature NN 37231 836 103 and and CC 37231 836 104 commission commission NN 37231 836 105 . . . 37231 837 1 " " `` 37231 837 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 837 3 4 4 CD 37231 837 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 837 5 { { -LRB- 37231 837 6 4 4 CD 37231 837 7 } } -RRB- 37231 837 8 The the DT 37231 837 9 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 37231 837 10 offer offer NN 37231 837 11 of of IN 37231 837 12 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 837 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 837 14 , , , 37231 837 15 indeed indeed RB 37231 837 16 , , , 37231 837 17 has have VBZ 37231 837 18 always always RB 37231 837 19 been be VBN 37231 837 20 advanced advance VBN 37231 837 21 as as IN 37231 837 22 a a DT 37231 837 23 special special JJ 37231 837 24 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 837 25 of of IN 37231 837 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 837 27 , , , 37231 837 28 logically logically RB 37231 837 29 entitling entitle VBG 37231 837 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 837 31 to to IN 37231 837 32 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 837 33 in in IN 37231 837 34 contradistinction contradistinction NN 37231 837 35 to to IN 37231 837 36 all all DT 37231 837 37 other other JJ 37231 837 38 religions religion NNS 37231 837 39 . . . 37231 838 1 " " `` 37231 838 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 838 3 is be VBZ 37231 838 4 an an DT 37231 838 5 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 37231 838 6 historical historical JJ 37231 838 7 fact fact NN 37231 838 8 , , , 37231 838 9 " " '' 37231 838 10 says say VBZ 37231 838 11 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 838 12 Butler Butler NNP 37231 838 13 , , , 37231 838 14 " " '' 37231 838 15 that that IN 37231 838 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 838 17 offered offer VBD 37231 838 18 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 838 19 to to IN 37231 838 20 the the DT 37231 838 21 world world NN 37231 838 22 , , , 37231 838 23 and and CC 37231 838 24 demanded demand VBD 37231 838 25 to to TO 37231 838 26 be be VB 37231 838 27 received receive VBN 37231 838 28 , , , 37231 838 29 upon upon IN 37231 838 30 the the DT 37231 838 31 allegation allegation NN 37231 838 32 , , , 37231 838 33 i. i. NNP 37231 838 34 e e NNP 37231 838 35 , , , 37231 838 36 , , , 37231 838 37 as as IN 37231 838 38 unbelievers unbeliever NNS 37231 838 39 would would MD 37231 838 40 speak speak VB 37231 838 41 , , , 37231 838 42 upon upon IN 37231 838 43 the the DT 37231 838 44 pretence pretence NN 37231 838 45 , , , 37231 838 46 of of IN 37231 838 47 miracles miracle NNS 37231 838 48 , , , 37231 838 49 publicly publicly RB 37231 838 50 wrought work VBN 37231 838 51 to to TO 37231 838 52 attest attest VB 37231 838 53 the the DT 37231 838 54 truth truth NN 37231 838 55 of of IN 37231 838 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 838 57 in in IN 37231 838 58 such such PDT 37231 838 59 an an DT 37231 838 60 age age NN 37231 838 61 ; ; , 37231 838 62 ... ... : 37231 838 63 and and CC 37231 838 64 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 838 65 , , , 37231 838 66 including include VBG 37231 838 67 the the DT 37231 838 68 dispensation dispensation NN 37231 838 69 of of IN 37231 838 70 the the DT 37231 838 71 Old Old NNP 37231 838 72 Testament Testament NNP 37231 838 73 , , , 37231 838 74 seems seem VBZ 37231 838 75 distinguished distinguish VBN 37231 838 76 by by IN 37231 838 77 this this DT 37231 838 78 from from IN 37231 838 79 all all DT 37231 838 80 other other JJ 37231 838 81 religions religion NNS 37231 838 82 . . . 37231 839 1 " " `` 37231 839 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 839 3 1 1 LS 37231 839 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 839 5 Most Most JJS 37231 839 6 of of IN 37231 839 7 the the DT 37231 839 8 great great JJ 37231 839 9 English english JJ 37231 839 10 divines divine NNS 37231 839 11 have have VBP 37231 839 12 clearly clearly RB 37231 839 13 recognized recognize VBN 37231 839 14 and and CC 37231 839 15 asserted assert VBN 37231 839 16 the the DT 37231 839 17 necessity necessity NN 37231 839 18 of of IN 37231 839 19 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 839 20 evidence evidence NN 37231 839 21 to to TO 37231 839 22 establish establish VB 37231 839 23 the the DT 37231 839 24 reality reality NN 37231 839 25 of of IN 37231 839 26 a a DT 37231 839 27 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 839 28 revelation revelation NN 37231 839 29 . . . 37231 840 1 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 840 2 Butler Butler NNP 37231 840 3 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 840 4 miracles miracle NNS 37231 840 5 and and CC 37231 840 6 the the DT 37231 840 7 completion completion NN 37231 840 8 of of IN 37231 840 9 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 840 10 to to TO 37231 840 11 be be VB 37231 840 12 the the DT 37231 840 13 " " `` 37231 840 14 direct direct JJ 37231 840 15 and and CC 37231 840 16 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 840 17 proofs proof NNS 37231 840 18 " " '' 37231 840 19 of of IN 37231 840 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 840 21 . . . 37231 841 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 841 2 2 2 LS 37231 841 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 841 4 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 841 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 841 6 says say VBZ 37231 841 7 : : : 37231 841 8 " " `` 37231 841 9 The the DT 37231 841 10 notion notion NN 37231 841 11 of of IN 37231 841 12 a a DT 37231 841 13 miracle miracle NN 37231 841 14 , , , 37231 841 15 considered consider VBN 37231 841 16 as as IN 37231 841 17 a a DT 37231 841 18 proof proof NN 37231 841 19 of of IN 37231 841 20 a a DT 37231 841 21 divine divine JJ 37231 841 22 mission mission NN 37231 841 23 , , , 37231 841 24 has have VBZ 37231 841 25 been be VBN 37231 841 26 stated state VBN 37231 841 27 with with IN 37231 841 28 great great JJ 37231 841 29 exactness exactness NN 37231 841 30 by by IN 37231 841 31 divines divine NNS 37231 841 32 , , , 37231 841 33 and and CC 37231 841 34 is be VBZ 37231 841 35 , , , 37231 841 36 I -PRON- PRP 37231 841 37 think think VBP 37231 841 38 , , , 37231 841 39 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 841 40 understood understand VBN 37231 841 41 by by IN 37231 841 42 every every DT 37231 841 43 one one CD 37231 841 44 . . . 37231 842 1 There there EX 37231 842 2 are be VBP 37231 842 3 also also RB 37231 842 4 invisible invisible JJ 37231 842 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 842 6 , , , 37231 842 7 the the DT 37231 842 8 Incarnation Incarnation NNP 37231 842 9 of of IN 37231 842 10 Christ Christ NNP 37231 842 11 , , , 37231 842 12 for for IN 37231 842 13 instance instance NN 37231 842 14 , , , 37231 842 15 which which WDT 37231 842 16 , , , 37231 842 17 being be VBG 37231 842 18 secret secret JJ 37231 842 19 , , , 37231 842 20 can can MD 37231 842 21 not not RB 37231 842 22 be be VB 37231 842 23 alleged allege VBN 37231 842 24 as as IN 37231 842 25 a a DT 37231 842 26 proof proof NN 37231 842 27 of of IN 37231 842 28 such such PDT 37231 842 29 a a DT 37231 842 30 mission mission NN 37231 842 31 ; ; : 37231 842 32 but but CC 37231 842 33 require require VBP 37231 842 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 842 35 to to TO 37231 842 36 be be VB 37231 842 37 proved prove VBN 37231 842 38 by by IN 37231 842 39 visible visible JJ 37231 842 40 miracles miracle NNS 37231 842 41 . . . 37231 843 1 Revelation revelation NN 37231 843 2 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 843 3 , , , 37231 843 4 too too RB 37231 843 5 , , , 37231 843 6 is be VBZ 37231 843 7 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 843 8 ; ; : 37231 843 9 and and CC 37231 843 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 843 11 are be VBP 37231 843 12 the the DT 37231 843 13 proof proof NN 37231 843 14 of of IN 37231 843 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 843 16 . . . 37231 844 1 " " `` 37231 844 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 844 3 3 3 LS 37231 844 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 844 5 Paley Paley NNP 37231 844 6 states state VBZ 37231 844 7 the the DT 37231 844 8 case case NN 37231 844 9 with with IN 37231 844 10 equal equal JJ 37231 844 11 clearness clearness NN 37231 844 12 : : : 37231 844 13 " " `` 37231 844 14 In in IN 37231 844 15 what what WDT 37231 844 16 way way NN 37231 844 17 can can MD 37231 844 18 a a DT 37231 844 19 revelation revelation NN 37231 844 20 be be VB 37231 844 21 made make VBN 37231 844 22 but but CC 37231 844 23 by by IN 37231 844 24 miracles miracle NNS 37231 844 25 ? ? . 37231 845 1 In in IN 37231 845 2 none none NN 37231 845 3 which which WDT 37231 845 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 845 5 are be VBP 37231 845 6 able able JJ 37231 845 7 to to TO 37231 845 8 conceive conceive VB 37231 845 9 . . . 37231 846 1 " " `` 37231 846 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 846 3 4 4 LS 37231 846 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 846 5 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 846 6 argument argument NN 37231 846 7 in in IN 37231 846 8 fact fact NN 37231 846 9 is be VBZ 37231 846 10 founded found VBN 37231 846 11 upon upon IN 37231 846 12 the the DT 37231 846 13 principle principle NN 37231 846 14 that that DT 37231 846 15 : : : 37231 846 16 " " `` 37231 846 17 nothing nothing NN 37231 846 18 but but IN 37231 846 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 846 20 { { -LRB- 37231 846 21 5 5 CD 37231 846 22 } } -RRB- 37231 846 23 could could MD 37231 846 24 decide decide VB 37231 846 25 the the DT 37231 846 26 authority authority NN 37231 846 27 " " '' 37231 846 28 of of IN 37231 846 29 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 846 30 . . . 37231 847 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 847 2 1 1 LS 37231 847 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 847 4 In in IN 37231 847 5 another another DT 37231 847 6 work work NN 37231 847 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 847 8 asserts assert VBZ 37231 847 9 that that IN 37231 847 10 no no DT 37231 847 11 man man NN 37231 847 12 can can MD 37231 847 13 prove prove VB 37231 847 14 a a DT 37231 847 15 future future JJ 37231 847 16 retribution retribution NN 37231 847 17 , , , 37231 847 18 but but CC 37231 847 19 the the DT 37231 847 20 teacher teacher NN 37231 847 21 " " `` 37231 847 22 who who WP 37231 847 23 testifies testify VBZ 37231 847 24 by by IN 37231 847 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 847 26 that that WDT 37231 847 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 847 28 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 847 29 comes come VBZ 37231 847 30 from from IN 37231 847 31 God God NNP 37231 847 32 . . . 37231 848 1 " " `` 37231 848 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 848 3 2 2 LS 37231 848 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 848 5 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 848 6 Atterbury Atterbury NNP 37231 848 7 , , , 37231 848 8 again again RB 37231 848 9 , , , 37231 848 10 referring refer VBG 37231 848 11 to to IN 37231 848 12 the the DT 37231 848 13 principal principal JJ 37231 848 14 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 848 15 of of IN 37231 848 16 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 848 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 848 18 , , , 37231 848 19 says say VBZ 37231 848 20 : : : 37231 848 21 " " `` 37231 848 22 It -PRON- PRP 37231 848 23 is be VBZ 37231 848 24 this this DT 37231 848 25 kind kind NN 37231 848 26 of of IN 37231 848 27 Truth truth NN 37231 848 28 that that WDT 37231 848 29 God God NNP 37231 848 30 is be VBZ 37231 848 31 properly properly RB 37231 848 32 said say VBN 37231 848 33 to to TO 37231 848 34 reveal reveal VB 37231 848 35 ; ; : 37231 848 36 Truths truth NNS 37231 848 37 , , , 37231 848 38 of of IN 37231 848 39 which which WDT 37231 848 40 , , , 37231 848 41 unless unless IN 37231 848 42 revealed reveal VBN 37231 848 43 , , , 37231 848 44 we -PRON- PRP 37231 848 45 should should MD 37231 848 46 have have VB 37231 848 47 always always RB 37231 848 48 continued continue VBN 37231 848 49 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 848 50 ; ; : 37231 848 51 and and CC 37231 848 52 ' ' `` 37231 848 53 tis tis CC 37231 848 54 in in IN 37231 848 55 order order NN 37231 848 56 only only RB 37231 848 57 to to TO 37231 848 58 prove prove VB 37231 848 59 these these DT 37231 848 60 Truths truth NNS 37231 848 61 to to TO 37231 848 62 have have VB 37231 848 63 been be VBN 37231 848 64 really really RB 37231 848 65 revealed reveal VBN 37231 848 66 , , , 37231 848 67 that that IN 37231 848 68 we -PRON- PRP 37231 848 69 affirm affirm VBP 37231 848 70 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 848 71 to to TO 37231 848 72 be be VB 37231 848 73 Necessary necessary JJ 37231 848 74 . . . 37231 849 1 " " `` 37231 849 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 849 3 3 3 LS 37231 849 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 849 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 849 6 Heurtley Heurtley NNP 37231 849 7 , , , 37231 849 8 the the DT 37231 849 9 Margaret Margaret NNP 37231 849 10 Professor Professor NNP 37231 849 11 of of IN 37231 849 12 Divinity Divinity NNP 37231 849 13 in in IN 37231 849 14 the the DT 37231 849 15 University University NNP 37231 849 16 of of IN 37231 849 17 Oxford Oxford NNP 37231 849 18 , , , 37231 849 19 after after IN 37231 849 20 pointing point VBG 37231 849 21 out out RP 37231 849 22 that that IN 37231 849 23 the the DT 37231 849 24 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 849 25 taught teach VBN 37231 849 26 as as IN 37231 849 27 the the DT 37231 849 28 Christian Christian NNP 37231 849 29 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 849 30 are be VBP 37231 849 31 such such JJ 37231 849 32 as as IN 37231 849 33 could could MD 37231 849 34 not not RB 37231 849 35 by by IN 37231 849 36 any any DT 37231 849 37 possibility possibility NN 37231 849 38 have have VBP 37231 849 39 been be VBN 37231 849 40 attained attain VBN 37231 849 41 by by IN 37231 849 42 the the DT 37231 849 43 unassisted unassisted JJ 37231 849 44 human human JJ 37231 849 45 reason reason NN 37231 849 46 , , , 37231 849 47 and and CC 37231 849 48 that that IN 37231 849 49 , , , 37231 849 50 consequently consequently RB 37231 849 51 , , , 37231 849 52 it -PRON- PRP 37231 849 53 is be VBZ 37231 849 54 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 849 55 that that IN 37231 849 56 they -PRON- PRP 37231 849 57 should should MD 37231 849 58 be be VB 37231 849 59 attested attest VBN 37231 849 60 by by IN 37231 849 61 miracles miracle NNS 37231 849 62 , , , 37231 849 63 continues continue VBZ 37231 849 64 : : : 37231 849 65 " " `` 37231 849 66 Indeed indeed RB 37231 849 67 , , , 37231 849 68 it -PRON- PRP 37231 849 69 seems seem VBZ 37231 849 70 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 37231 849 71 how how WRB 37231 849 72 without without IN 37231 849 73 miracles miracle NNS 37231 849 74 -- -- : 37231 849 75 including include VBG 37231 849 76 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 849 77 in in IN 37231 849 78 the the DT 37231 849 79 notion notion NN 37231 849 80 of of IN 37231 849 81 a a DT 37231 849 82 miracle miracle NN 37231 849 83 -- -- : 37231 849 84 it -PRON- PRP 37231 849 85 could could MD 37231 849 86 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 849 87 have have VB 37231 849 88 commended commend VBN 37231 849 89 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 849 90 to to IN 37231 849 91 men man NNS 37231 849 92 's 's POS 37231 849 93 belief belief NN 37231 849 94 ? ? . 37231 850 1 Who who WP 37231 850 2 would would MD 37231 850 3 believe believe VB 37231 850 4 , , , 37231 850 5 or or CC 37231 850 6 would would MD 37231 850 7 be be VB 37231 850 8 justified justify VBN 37231 850 9 in in IN 37231 850 10 believing believe VBG 37231 850 11 , , , 37231 850 12 the the DT 37231 850 13 great great JJ 37231 850 14 facts fact NNS 37231 850 15 which which WDT 37231 850 16 constitute constitute VBP 37231 850 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 850 18 substance substance NN 37231 850 19 on on IN 37231 850 20 the the DT 37231 850 21 _ _ NNP 37231 850 22 ipse ipse NNP 37231 850 23 dixit dixit NNP 37231 850 24 _ _ NNP 37231 850 25 of of IN 37231 850 26 an an DT 37231 850 27 unaccredited unaccredited JJ 37231 850 28 teacher teacher NN 37231 850 29 ? ? . 37231 851 1 and and CC 37231 851 2 how how WRB 37231 851 3 , , , 37231 851 4 except except IN 37231 851 5 by by IN 37231 851 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 851 7 , , , 37231 851 8 could could MD 37231 851 9 the the DT 37231 851 10 first first JJ 37231 851 11 teacher teacher NN 37231 851 12 be be VB 37231 851 13 accredited accredit VBN 37231 851 14 ? ? . 37231 852 1 Paley Paley NNP 37231 852 2 , , , 37231 852 3 then then RB 37231 852 4 , , , 37231 852 5 was be VBD 37231 852 6 fully fully RB 37231 852 7 warranted warrant VBN 37231 852 8 in in IN 37231 852 9 the the DT 37231 852 10 assertion assertion NN 37231 852 11 .... .... NFP 37231 852 12 that that DT 37231 852 13 ' ' `` 37231 852 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 852 15 can can MD 37231 852 16 not not RB 37231 852 17 conceive conceive VB 37231 852 18 a a DT 37231 852 19 revelation'--such revelation'--such NN 37231 852 20 a a DT 37231 852 21 revelation revelation NN 37231 852 22 of of IN 37231 852 23 course course NN 37231 852 24 as as IN 37231 852 25 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 852 26 professes profess VBZ 37231 852 27 to to TO 37231 852 28 be be VB 37231 852 29 , , , 37231 852 30 a a DT 37231 852 31 revelation revelation NN 37231 852 32 of of IN 37231 852 33 truths truth NNS 37231 852 34 which which WDT 37231 852 35 transcend transcend VBP 37231 852 36 man man NN 37231 852 37 's 's POS 37231 852 38 ability ability NN 37231 852 39 to to IN 37231 852 40 discover,-- discover,-- NNS 37231 852 41 ' ' '' 37231 852 42 to to TO 37231 852 43 be be VB 37231 852 44 { { -LRB- 37231 852 45 6 6 CD 37231 852 46 } } -RRB- 37231 852 47 substantiated substantiate VBD 37231 852 48 without without IN 37231 852 49 miracles miracle NNS 37231 852 50 . . . 37231 852 51 ' ' '' 37231 853 1 Other other JJ 37231 853 2 credentials credential NNS 37231 853 3 , , , 37231 853 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 853 5 is be VBZ 37231 853 6 true true JJ 37231 853 7 , , , 37231 853 8 might may MD 37231 853 9 be be VB 37231 853 10 exhibited exhibit VBN 37231 853 11 _ _ NNP 37231 853 12 in in IN 37231 853 13 addition addition NN 37231 853 14 _ _ NNP 37231 853 15 to to IN 37231 853 16 miracles,--and miracles,--and NNP 37231 853 17 such such JJ 37231 853 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 853 19 would would MD 37231 853 20 be be VB 37231 853 21 natural natural JJ 37231 853 22 to to TO 37231 853 23 look look VB 37231 853 24 for,--but for,--but IN 37231 853 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 853 26 seems seem VBZ 37231 853 27 impossible impossible JJ 37231 853 28 that that IN 37231 853 29 miracles miracle NNS 37231 853 30 could could MD 37231 853 31 be be VB 37231 853 32 dispensed dispense VBN 37231 853 33 with with IN 37231 853 34 . . . 37231 854 1 " " `` 37231 854 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 854 3 1 1 LS 37231 854 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 854 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 854 6 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 854 7 , , , 37231 854 8 the the DT 37231 854 9 late late JJ 37231 854 10 Dean Dean NNP 37231 854 11 of of IN 37231 854 12 St. St. NNP 37231 854 13 Paul Paul NNP 37231 854 14 's 's POS 37231 854 15 , , , 37231 854 16 bears bear VBZ 37231 854 17 similar similar JJ 37231 854 18 testimony testimony NN 37231 854 19 : : : 37231 854 20 " " `` 37231 854 21 A a DT 37231 854 22 teacher teacher NN 37231 854 23 who who WP 37231 854 24 proclaims proclaim VBZ 37231 854 25 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 854 26 to to TO 37231 854 27 be be VB 37231 854 28 specially specially RB 37231 854 29 sent send VBN 37231 854 30 by by IN 37231 854 31 God God NNP 37231 854 32 , , , 37231 854 33 and and CC 37231 854 34 whose whose WP$ 37231 854 35 teaching teaching NN 37231 854 36 is be VBZ 37231 854 37 to to TO 37231 854 38 be be VB 37231 854 39 received receive VBN 37231 854 40 on on IN 37231 854 41 the the DT 37231 854 42 authority authority NN 37231 854 43 of of IN 37231 854 44 that that DT 37231 854 45 mission mission NN 37231 854 46 , , , 37231 854 47 must must MD 37231 854 48 , , , 37231 854 49 from from IN 37231 854 50 the the DT 37231 854 51 nature nature NN 37231 854 52 of of IN 37231 854 53 the the DT 37231 854 54 case case NN 37231 854 55 , , , 37231 854 56 establish establish VB 37231 854 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 854 58 claim claim NN 37231 854 59 by by IN 37231 854 60 proofs proof NNS 37231 854 61 of of IN 37231 854 62 another another DT 37231 854 63 kind kind NN 37231 854 64 than than IN 37231 854 65 those those DT 37231 854 66 which which WDT 37231 854 67 merely merely RB 37231 854 68 evince evince VBP 37231 854 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 854 70 human human JJ 37231 854 71 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 854 72 or or CC 37231 854 73 goodness goodness NN 37231 854 74 . . . 37231 855 1 A a DT 37231 855 2 superhuman superhuman JJ 37231 855 3 authority authority NN 37231 855 4 needs need VBZ 37231 855 5 to to TO 37231 855 6 be be VB 37231 855 7 substantiated substantiate VBN 37231 855 8 by by IN 37231 855 9 superhuman superhuman JJ 37231 855 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 855 11 ; ; , 37231 855 12 and and CC 37231 855 13 what what WP 37231 855 14 is be VBZ 37231 855 15 superhuman superhuman JJ 37231 855 16 is be VBZ 37231 855 17 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 855 18 . . . 37231 856 1 " " `` 37231 856 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 856 3 2 2 LS 37231 856 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 856 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 856 6 J. J. NNP 37231 856 7 H. H. NNP 37231 856 8 Newman Newman NNP 37231 856 9 , , , 37231 856 10 in in IN 37231 856 11 discussing discuss VBG 37231 856 12 the the DT 37231 856 13 idea idea NN 37231 856 14 and and CC 37231 856 15 scope scope NN 37231 856 16 of of IN 37231 856 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 856 18 , , , 37231 856 19 says say VBZ 37231 856 20 : : : 37231 856 21 " " `` 37231 856 22 A a DT 37231 856 23 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 856 24 , , , 37231 856 25 that that RB 37231 856 26 is is RB 37231 856 27 , , , 37231 856 28 a a DT 37231 856 29 direct direct JJ 37231 856 30 message message NN 37231 856 31 from from IN 37231 856 32 God God NNP 37231 856 33 to to TO 37231 856 34 man man NN 37231 856 35 , , , 37231 856 36 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 856 37 bears bear VBZ 37231 856 38 in in IN 37231 856 39 some some DT 37231 856 40 degree degree NN 37231 856 41 a a DT 37231 856 42 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 856 43 character character NN 37231 856 44 ; ; , 37231 856 45 ... ... : 37231 856 46 And and CC 37231 856 47 as as IN 37231 856 48 a a DT 37231 856 49 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 856 50 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 856 51 , , , 37231 856 52 so so RB 37231 856 53 again again RB 37231 856 54 the the DT 37231 856 55 evidences evidence NNS 37231 856 56 of of IN 37231 856 57 a a DT 37231 856 58 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 856 59 may may MD 37231 856 60 all all RB 37231 856 61 more more RBR 37231 856 62 or or CC 37231 856 63 less less RBR 37231 856 64 be be VB 37231 856 65 considered consider VBN 37231 856 66 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 856 67 .... .... . 37231 857 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 857 2 might may MD 37231 857 3 even even RB 37231 857 4 be be VB 37231 857 5 said say VBN 37231 857 6 that that IN 37231 857 7 , , , 37231 857 8 strictly strictly RB 37231 857 9 speaking speak VBG 37231 857 10 , , , 37231 857 11 no no DT 37231 857 12 evidence evidence NN 37231 857 13 of of IN 37231 857 14 a a DT 37231 857 15 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 857 16 is be VBZ 37231 857 17 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 857 18 which which WDT 37231 857 19 does do VBZ 37231 857 20 not not RB 37231 857 21 partake partake VB 37231 857 22 of of IN 37231 857 23 the the DT 37231 857 24 character character NN 37231 857 25 of of IN 37231 857 26 a a DT 37231 857 27 Miracle miracle NN 37231 857 28 ; ; : 37231 857 29 since since IN 37231 857 30 nothing nothing NN 37231 857 31 but but IN 37231 857 32 a a DT 37231 857 33 display display NN 37231 857 34 of of IN 37231 857 35 power power NN 37231 857 36 over over IN 37231 857 37 the the DT 37231 857 38 existing exist VBG 37231 857 39 system system NN 37231 857 40 of of IN 37231 857 41 things thing NNS 37231 857 42 can can MD 37231 857 43 attest attest VB 37231 857 44 the the DT 37231 857 45 immediate immediate JJ 37231 857 46 presence presence NN 37231 857 47 of of IN 37231 857 48 Him -PRON- PRP 37231 857 49 by by IN 37231 857 50 whom whom WP 37231 857 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 857 52 was be VBD 37231 857 53 originally originally RB 37231 857 54 established establish VBN 37231 857 55 . . . 37231 858 1 " " `` 37231 858 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 858 3 3 3 LS 37231 858 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 858 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 858 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 858 7 has have VBZ 37231 858 8 stated state VBN 37231 858 9 in in IN 37231 858 10 still still RB 37231 858 11 stronger strong JJR 37231 858 12 terms term NNS 37231 858 13 the the DT 37231 858 14 necessity necessity NN 37231 858 15 that that WDT 37231 858 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 858 17 should should MD 37231 858 18 be be VB 37231 858 19 authenticated authenticate VBN 37231 858 20 by by IN 37231 858 21 the the DT 37231 858 22 evidence evidence NN 37231 858 23 of of IN 37231 858 24 miracles miracle NNS 37231 858 25 . . . 37231 859 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 859 2 supposes suppose VBZ 37231 859 3 the the DT 37231 859 4 case case NN 37231 859 5 that that IN 37231 859 6 a a DT 37231 859 7 person person NN 37231 859 8 of of IN 37231 859 9 evident evident JJ 37231 859 10 integrity integrity NN 37231 859 11 and and CC 37231 859 12 loftiness loftiness NN 37231 859 13 of of IN 37231 859 14 character character NN 37231 859 15 had have VBD 37231 859 16 appeared appear VBN 37231 859 17 , , , 37231 859 18 eighteen eighteen CD 37231 859 19 centuries century NNS 37231 859 20 ago ago RB 37231 859 21 , , , 37231 859 22 announcing announce VBG 37231 859 23 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 859 24 as as IN 37231 859 25 pre pre JJ 37231 859 26 - - NN 37231 859 27 existent existent NN 37231 859 28 from from IN 37231 859 29 all all DT 37231 859 30 eternity eternity NN 37231 859 31 , , , 37231 859 32 the the DT 37231 859 33 Son Son NNP 37231 859 34 of of IN 37231 859 35 God God NNP 37231 859 36 , , , 37231 859 37 Maker Maker NNP 37231 859 38 { { -LRB- 37231 859 39 7 7 CD 37231 859 40 } } -RRB- 37231 859 41 of of IN 37231 859 42 the the DT 37231 859 43 world world NN 37231 859 44 , , , 37231 859 45 who who WP 37231 859 46 had have VBD 37231 859 47 come come VBN 37231 859 48 down down RP 37231 859 49 from from IN 37231 859 50 heaven heaven NNP 37231 859 51 and and CC 37231 859 52 assumed assume VBD 37231 859 53 the the DT 37231 859 54 form form NN 37231 859 55 and and CC 37231 859 56 nature nature NN 37231 859 57 of of IN 37231 859 58 man man NN 37231 859 59 in in IN 37231 859 60 order order NN 37231 859 61 to to TO 37231 859 62 be be VB 37231 859 63 the the DT 37231 859 64 Lamb Lamb NNP 37231 859 65 of of IN 37231 859 66 God God NNP 37231 859 67 that that WDT 37231 859 68 taketh taketh VBZ 37231 859 69 away away RB 37231 859 70 the the DT 37231 859 71 sins sin NNS 37231 859 72 of of IN 37231 859 73 the the DT 37231 859 74 world world NN 37231 859 75 , , , 37231 859 76 and and CC 37231 859 77 so so RB 37231 859 78 on on RB 37231 859 79 , , , 37231 859 80 enumerating enumerate VBG 37231 859 81 other other JJ 37231 859 82 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 859 83 of of IN 37231 859 84 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 859 85 . . . 37231 860 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 860 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 860 3 then then RB 37231 860 4 asks ask VBZ 37231 860 5 : : : 37231 860 6 " " `` 37231 860 7 What what WP 37231 860 8 would would MD 37231 860 9 be be VB 37231 860 10 the the DT 37231 860 11 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 860 12 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 860 13 of of IN 37231 860 14 sober sober JJ 37231 860 15 reason reason NN 37231 860 16 respecting respect VBG 37231 860 17 that that DT 37231 860 18 person person NN 37231 860 19 ? ? . 37231 861 1 The the DT 37231 861 2 necessary necessary JJ 37231 861 3 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 861 4 of of IN 37231 861 5 sober sober JJ 37231 861 6 reason reason NN 37231 861 7 respecting respect VBG 37231 861 8 that that DT 37231 861 9 person person NN 37231 861 10 would would MD 37231 861 11 be be VB 37231 861 12 that that IN 37231 861 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 861 14 was be VBD 37231 861 15 disordered disorder VBN 37231 861 16 in in IN 37231 861 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 861 18 understanding understanding NN 37231 861 19 ... ... : 37231 861 20 By by IN 37231 861 21 no no DT 37231 861 22 rational rational JJ 37231 861 23 being being NN 37231 861 24 could could MD 37231 861 25 a a DT 37231 861 26 just just RB 37231 861 27 and and CC 37231 861 28 benevolent benevolent JJ 37231 861 29 life life NN 37231 861 30 be be VB 37231 861 31 accepted accept VBN 37231 861 32 as as IN 37231 861 33 proof proof NN 37231 861 34 of of IN 37231 861 35 such such JJ 37231 861 36 astonishing astonishing JJ 37231 861 37 announcements announcement NNS 37231 861 38 . . . 37231 862 1 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 862 2 are be VBP 37231 862 3 the the DT 37231 862 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 862 5 complement complement NN 37231 862 6 , , , 37231 862 7 then then RB 37231 862 8 , , , 37231 862 9 of of IN 37231 862 10 the the DT 37231 862 11 truth truth NN 37231 862 12 of of IN 37231 862 13 such such JJ 37231 862 14 announcements announcement NNS 37231 862 15 , , , 37231 862 16 which which WDT 37231 862 17 , , , 37231 862 18 without without IN 37231 862 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 862 20 , , , 37231 862 21 are be VBP 37231 862 22 purposeless purposeless JJ 37231 862 23 and and CC 37231 862 24 abortive abortive JJ 37231 862 25 , , , 37231 862 26 the the DT 37231 862 27 unfinished unfinished JJ 37231 862 28 fragments fragment NNS 37231 862 29 of of IN 37231 862 30 a a DT 37231 862 31 design design NN 37231 862 32 which which WDT 37231 862 33 is be VBZ 37231 862 34 nothing nothing NN 37231 862 35 unless unless IN 37231 862 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 862 37 is be VBZ 37231 862 38 the the DT 37231 862 39 whole whole NN 37231 862 40 . . . 37231 863 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 863 2 are be VBP 37231 863 3 necessary necessary JJ 37231 863 4 to to IN 37231 863 5 the the DT 37231 863 6 justification justification NN 37231 863 7 of of IN 37231 863 8 such such JJ 37231 863 9 announcements announcement NNS 37231 863 10 , , , 37231 863 11 which which WDT 37231 863 12 indeed indeed RB 37231 863 13 , , , 37231 863 14 unless unless IN 37231 863 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 863 16 are be VBP 37231 863 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 863 18 truths truth NNS 37231 863 19 , , , 37231 863 20 are be VBP 37231 863 21 the the DT 37231 863 22 wildest wild JJS 37231 863 23 delusions delusion NNS 37231 863 24 . . . 37231 864 1 " " `` 37231 864 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 864 3 1 1 LS 37231 864 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 864 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 864 6 , , , 37231 864 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 864 8 , , , 37231 864 9 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 864 10 that that DT 37231 864 11 : : : 37231 864 12 " " `` 37231 864 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 864 14 can can MD 37231 864 15 not not RB 37231 864 16 be be VB 37231 864 17 maintained maintain VBN 37231 864 18 as as IN 37231 864 19 a a DT 37231 864 20 revelation revelation NN 37231 864 21 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 37231 864 22 by by IN 37231 864 23 human human JJ 37231 864 24 reason reason NN 37231 864 25 , , , 37231 864 26 a a DT 37231 864 27 revelation revelation NN 37231 864 28 of of IN 37231 864 29 a a DT 37231 864 30 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 864 31 scheme scheme NN 37231 864 32 for for IN 37231 864 33 man man NN 37231 864 34 's 's POS 37231 864 35 salvation salvation NN 37231 864 36 , , , 37231 864 37 without without IN 37231 864 38 the the DT 37231 864 39 evidence evidence NN 37231 864 40 of of IN 37231 864 41 miracles miracle NNS 37231 864 42 . . . 37231 865 1 " " `` 37231 865 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 865 3 2 2 LS 37231 865 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 865 5 In in IN 37231 865 6 all all DT 37231 865 7 points point NNS 37231 865 8 , , , 37231 865 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 865 10 is be VBZ 37231 865 11 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 865 12 a a DT 37231 865 13 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 37231 865 14 Religion Religion NNP 37231 865 15 claiming claim VBG 37231 865 16 to to TO 37231 865 17 be be VB 37231 865 18 divine divine JJ 37231 865 19 in in IN 37231 865 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 865 21 origin origin NN 37231 865 22 , , , 37231 865 23 superhuman superhuman NN 37231 865 24 in in IN 37231 865 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 865 26 essence essence NN 37231 865 27 and and CC 37231 865 28 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 865 29 in in IN 37231 865 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 865 31 evidence evidence NN 37231 865 32 . . . 37231 866 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 866 2 can can MD 37231 866 3 not not RB 37231 866 4 be be VB 37231 866 5 accepted accept VBN 37231 866 6 without without IN 37231 866 7 an an DT 37231 866 8 absolute absolute JJ 37231 866 9 belief belief NN 37231 866 10 in in IN 37231 866 11 Miracles Miracles NNP 37231 866 12 , , , 37231 866 13 and and CC 37231 866 14 those those DT 37231 866 15 who who WP 37231 866 16 profess profess VBP 37231 866 17 to to TO 37231 866 18 hold hold VB 37231 866 19 the the DT 37231 866 20 religion religion NN 37231 866 21 whilst whilst IN 37231 866 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 866 23 discredit discredit VBP 37231 866 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 866 25 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 866 26 elements element NNS 37231 866 27 -- -- : 37231 866 28 and and CC 37231 866 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 866 30 are be VBP 37231 866 31 many many JJ 37231 866 32 at at IN 37231 866 33 the the DT 37231 866 34 present present JJ 37231 866 35 day day NN 37231 866 36 -- -- : 37231 866 37 have have VBP 37231 866 38 widely widely RB 37231 866 39 seceded secede VBN 37231 866 40 from from IN 37231 866 41 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 866 42 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 866 43 . . . 37231 867 1 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 867 2 , , , 37231 867 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 867 4 is be VBZ 37231 867 5 true true JJ 37231 867 6 , , , 37231 867 7 are be VBP 37231 867 8 external external JJ 37231 867 9 to to IN 37231 867 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 867 11 in in IN 37231 867 12 so so RB 37231 867 13 far far RB 37231 867 14 as as IN 37231 867 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 867 16 are be VBP 37231 867 17 evidential evidential JJ 37231 867 18 , , , 37231 867 19 but but CC 37231 867 20 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37231 867 21 as as IN 37231 867 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 867 23 is be VBZ 37231 867 24 admitted admit VBN 37231 867 25 that that IN 37231 867 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 867 27 alone alone RB 37231 867 28 can can MD 37231 867 29 attest attest VB 37231 867 30 the the DT 37231 867 31 reality reality NN 37231 867 32 of of IN 37231 867 33 Divine Divine NNP 37231 867 34 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 867 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 867 36 are be VBP 37231 867 37 still still RB 37231 867 38 inseparable inseparable JJ 37231 867 39 { { -LRB- 37231 867 40 8 8 CD 37231 867 41 } } -RRB- 37231 867 42 from from IN 37231 867 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 867 44 ; ; : 37231 867 45 and and CC 37231 867 46 as as IN 37231 867 47 the the DT 37231 867 48 contents content NNS 37231 867 49 of of IN 37231 867 50 the the DT 37231 867 51 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 867 52 are be VBP 37231 867 53 so so RB 37231 867 54 to to TO 37231 867 55 say say VB 37231 867 56 more more RBR 37231 867 57 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 867 58 than than IN 37231 867 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 867 60 attesting attest VBG 37231 867 61 miracles miracle NNS 37231 867 62 , , , 37231 867 63 the the DT 37231 867 64 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 867 65 enters enter NNS 37231 867 66 into into IN 37231 867 67 the the DT 37231 867 68 very very JJ 37231 867 69 substance substance NN 37231 867 70 of of IN 37231 867 71 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 867 72 and and CC 37231 867 73 can can MD 37231 867 74 not not RB 37231 867 75 be be VB 37231 867 76 eliminated eliminate VBN 37231 867 77 . . . 37231 868 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 868 2 is be VBZ 37231 868 3 obvious obvious JJ 37231 868 4 , , , 37231 868 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 868 6 , , , 37231 868 7 that that IN 37231 868 8 the the DT 37231 868 9 reality reality NN 37231 868 10 of of IN 37231 868 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 868 12 is be VBZ 37231 868 13 the the DT 37231 868 14 vital vital JJ 37231 868 15 point point NN 37231 868 16 in in IN 37231 868 17 the the DT 37231 868 18 investigation investigation NN 37231 868 19 which which WDT 37231 868 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 868 21 have have VBP 37231 868 22 undertaken undertake VBN 37231 868 23 . . . 37231 869 1 If if IN 37231 869 2 the the DT 37231 869 3 reality reality NN 37231 869 4 of of IN 37231 869 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 869 6 can can MD 37231 869 7 not not RB 37231 869 8 be be VB 37231 869 9 established establish VBN 37231 869 10 , , , 37231 869 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 869 12 loses lose VBZ 37231 869 13 the the DT 37231 869 14 only only JJ 37231 869 15 evidence evidence NN 37231 869 16 by by IN 37231 869 17 which which WDT 37231 869 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 869 19 truth truth NN 37231 869 20 can can MD 37231 869 21 be be VB 37231 869 22 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 869 23 attested attest VBN 37231 869 24 . . . 37231 870 1 If if IN 37231 870 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 870 3 be be VBP 37231 870 4 incredible incredible JJ 37231 870 5 the the DT 37231 870 6 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 870 7 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 870 8 and and CC 37231 870 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 870 10 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 870 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 870 12 must must MD 37231 870 13 together together RB 37231 870 14 be be VB 37231 870 15 rejected reject VBN 37231 870 16 . . . 37231 871 1 This this DT 37231 871 2 fact fact NN 37231 871 3 is be VBZ 37231 871 4 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 871 5 recognized recognize VBN 37231 871 6 by by IN 37231 871 7 the the DT 37231 871 8 ablest able JJS 37231 871 9 Christian christian JJ 37231 871 10 divines divine NNS 37231 871 11 . . . 37231 872 1 Dean Dean NNP 37231 872 2 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 872 3 , , , 37231 872 4 speaking speak VBG 37231 872 5 of of IN 37231 872 6 the the DT 37231 872 7 position position NN 37231 872 8 of of IN 37231 872 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 872 10 in in IN 37231 872 11 regard regard NN 37231 872 12 to to IN 37231 872 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 872 14 , , , 37231 872 15 says say VBZ 37231 872 16 : : : 37231 872 17 " " `` 37231 872 18 The the DT 37231 872 19 question question NN 37231 872 20 , , , 37231 872 21 however however RB 37231 872 22 , , , 37231 872 23 assumes assume VBZ 37231 872 24 a a DT 37231 872 25 very very RB 37231 872 26 different different JJ 37231 872 27 character character NN 37231 872 28 when when WRB 37231 872 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 872 30 relates relate VBZ 37231 872 31 , , , 37231 872 32 not not RB 37231 872 33 to to IN 37231 872 34 the the DT 37231 872 35 comparative comparative JJ 37231 872 36 importance importance NN 37231 872 37 of of IN 37231 872 38 miracles miracle NNS 37231 872 39 as as IN 37231 872 40 evidences evidence NNS 37231 872 41 , , , 37231 872 42 but but CC 37231 872 43 to to IN 37231 872 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 872 45 reality reality NN 37231 872 46 as as IN 37231 872 47 facts fact NNS 37231 872 48 , , , 37231 872 49 and and CC 37231 872 50 as as IN 37231 872 51 facts fact NNS 37231 872 52 of of IN 37231 872 53 a a DT 37231 872 54 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 872 55 kind kind NN 37231 872 56 . . . 37231 873 1 For for IN 37231 873 2 if if IN 37231 873 3 this this DT 37231 873 4 is be VBZ 37231 873 5 denied deny VBN 37231 873 6 , , , 37231 873 7 the the DT 37231 873 8 denial denial NN 37231 873 9 does do VBZ 37231 873 10 not not RB 37231 873 11 merely merely RB 37231 873 12 remove remove VB 37231 873 13 one one CD 37231 873 14 of of IN 37231 873 15 the the DT 37231 873 16 supports support NNS 37231 873 17 of of IN 37231 873 18 a a DT 37231 873 19 faith faith NN 37231 873 20 which which WDT 37231 873 21 may may MD 37231 873 22 yet yet RB 37231 873 23 rest rest VB 37231 873 24 securely securely RB 37231 873 25 on on IN 37231 873 26 other other JJ 37231 873 27 grounds ground NNS 37231 873 28 . . . 37231 874 1 On on IN 37231 874 2 the the DT 37231 874 3 contrary contrary NN 37231 874 4 , , , 37231 874 5 the the DT 37231 874 6 whole whole JJ 37231 874 7 system system NN 37231 874 8 of of IN 37231 874 9 Christian christian JJ 37231 874 10 belief belief NN 37231 874 11 with with IN 37231 874 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 874 13 evidences evidence NNS 37231 874 14 ... ... NFP 37231 874 15 all all DT 37231 874 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 874 17 in in IN 37231 874 18 short short JJ 37231 874 19 , , , 37231 874 20 so so RB 37231 874 21 far far RB 37231 874 22 as as IN 37231 874 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 874 24 has have VBZ 37231 874 25 any any DT 37231 874 26 title title NN 37231 874 27 to to IN 37231 874 28 that that DT 37231 874 29 name name NN 37231 874 30 , , , 37231 874 31 so so RB 37231 874 32 far far RB 37231 874 33 as as IN 37231 874 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 874 35 has have VBZ 37231 874 36 any any DT 37231 874 37 special special JJ 37231 874 38 relation relation NN 37231 874 39 to to IN 37231 874 40 the the DT 37231 874 41 person person NN 37231 874 42 or or CC 37231 874 43 the the DT 37231 874 44 teaching teaching NN 37231 874 45 of of IN 37231 874 46 Christ Christ NNP 37231 874 47 , , , 37231 874 48 is be VBZ 37231 874 49 overthrown overthrow VBN 37231 874 50 at at IN 37231 874 51 the the DT 37231 874 52 same same JJ 37231 874 53 time time NN 37231 874 54 . . . 37231 875 1 " " `` 37231 875 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 875 3 1 1 LS 37231 875 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 875 5 A a DT 37231 875 6 little little JJ 37231 875 7 further further RB 37231 875 8 on on IN 37231 875 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 875 10 says say VBZ 37231 875 11 : : : 37231 875 12 " " `` 37231 875 13 If if IN 37231 875 14 there there EX 37231 875 15 be be VB 37231 875 16 one one CD 37231 875 17 fact fact NN 37231 875 18 recorded record VBN 37231 875 19 in in IN 37231 875 20 Scripture scripture NN 37231 875 21 which which WDT 37231 875 22 is be VBZ 37231 875 23 entitled entitle VBN 37231 875 24 , , , 37231 875 25 in in IN 37231 875 26 the the DT 37231 875 27 fullest full JJS 37231 875 28 sense sense NN 37231 875 29 of of IN 37231 875 30 the the DT 37231 875 31 word word NN 37231 875 32 , , , 37231 875 33 to to IN 37231 875 34 the the DT 37231 875 35 name name NN 37231 875 36 of of IN 37231 875 37 a a DT 37231 875 38 Miracle Miracle NNP 37231 875 39 , , , 37231 875 40 the the DT 37231 875 41 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 875 42 of of IN 37231 875 43 Christ Christ NNP 37231 875 44 is be VBZ 37231 875 45 that that DT 37231 875 46 fact fact NN 37231 875 47 . . . 37231 876 1 Here here RB 37231 876 2 , , , 37231 876 3 at at IN 37231 876 4 least least JJS 37231 876 5 , , , 37231 876 6 is be VBZ 37231 876 7 an an DT 37231 876 8 instance instance NN 37231 876 9 in in IN 37231 876 10 which which WDT 37231 876 11 the the DT 37231 876 12 entire entire JJ 37231 876 13 Christian christian JJ 37231 876 14 faith faith NN 37231 876 15 must must MD 37231 876 16 stand stand VB 37231 876 17 or or CC 37231 876 18 fall fall VB 37231 876 19 with with IN 37231 876 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 876 21 belief belief NN 37231 876 22 in in IN 37231 876 23 the the DT 37231 876 24 supernatural supernatural NN 37231 876 25 . . . 37231 877 1 " " `` 37231 877 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 877 3 2 2 LS 37231 877 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 877 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 877 6 , , , 37231 877 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 877 8 , , , 37231 877 9 properly properly RB 37231 877 10 repudiates repudiate VBZ 37231 877 11 the the DT 37231 877 12 view view NN 37231 877 13 , , , 37231 877 14 " " '' 37231 877 15 which which WDT 37231 877 16 represents represent VBZ 37231 877 17 the the DT 37231 877 18 question question NN 37231 877 19 of of IN 37231 877 20 the the DT 37231 877 21 possibility possibility NN 37231 877 22 { { -LRB- 37231 877 23 9 9 CD 37231 877 24 } } -RRB- 37231 877 25 of of IN 37231 877 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 877 27 as as IN 37231 877 28 one one CD 37231 877 29 which which WDT 37231 877 30 merely merely RB 37231 877 31 affects affect VBZ 37231 877 32 the the DT 37231 877 33 _ _ NNP 37231 877 34 external external JJ 37231 877 35 accessories accessory NNS 37231 877 36 _ _ NNP 37231 877 37 of of IN 37231 877 38 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 877 39 , , , 37231 877 40 leaving leave VBG 37231 877 41 the the DT 37231 877 42 _ _ NNP 37231 877 43 essential essential JJ 37231 877 44 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 877 45 _ _ NNP 37231 877 46 untouched untouched JJ 37231 877 47 . . . 37231 878 1 " " `` 37231 878 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 878 3 1 1 LS 37231 878 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 878 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 878 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 878 7 in in IN 37231 878 8 a a DT 37231 878 9 similar similar JJ 37231 878 10 manner manner NN 37231 878 11 argues argue VBZ 37231 878 12 the the DT 37231 878 13 inseparable inseparable JJ 37231 878 14 union union NN 37231 878 15 of of IN 37231 878 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 878 17 with with IN 37231 878 18 the the DT 37231 878 19 Christian christian JJ 37231 878 20 faith faith NN 37231 878 21 . . . 37231 879 1 " " `` 37231 879 2 Indeed indeed RB 37231 879 3 not not RB 37231 879 4 only only RB 37231 879 5 are be VBP 37231 879 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 879 7 _ _ NNP 37231 879 8 conjoined conjoin VBD 37231 879 9 _ _ NNP 37231 879 10 with with IN 37231 879 11 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 879 12 in in IN 37231 879 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 879 14 , , , 37231 879 15 but but CC 37231 879 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 879 17 are be VBP 37231 879 18 inserted insert VBN 37231 879 19 _ _ NNP 37231 879 20 in in IN 37231 879 21 _ _ NNP 37231 879 22 the the DT 37231 879 23 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 879 24 and and CC 37231 879 25 are be VBP 37231 879 26 part part NN 37231 879 27 of of IN 37231 879 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 879 29 contents content NNS 37231 879 30 . . . 37231 880 1 A a DT 37231 880 2 man man NN 37231 880 3 can can MD 37231 880 4 not not RB 37231 880 5 state state VB 37231 880 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 880 7 belief belief NN 37231 880 8 as as IN 37231 880 9 a a DT 37231 880 10 Christian Christian NNP 37231 880 11 in in IN 37231 880 12 the the DT 37231 880 13 terms term NNS 37231 880 14 of of IN 37231 880 15 the the DT 37231 880 16 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 880 17 ' ' POS 37231 880 18 Creed Creed NNP 37231 880 19 without without IN 37231 880 20 asserting assert VBG 37231 880 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 880 22 . . . 37231 881 1 Can Can MD 37231 881 2 the the DT 37231 881 3 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 881 4 of of IN 37231 881 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 881 6 Lord Lord NNP 37231 881 7 's 's POS 37231 881 8 Incarnation Incarnation NNP 37231 881 9 be be VB 37231 881 10 disjoined disjoin VBN 37231 881 11 from from IN 37231 881 12 one one CD 37231 881 13 physical physical JJ 37231 881 14 miracle miracle NN 37231 881 15 ? ? . 37231 882 1 Can Can MD 37231 882 2 the the DT 37231 882 3 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 882 4 of of IN 37231 882 5 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 882 6 justification justification NN 37231 882 7 of of IN 37231 882 8 us -PRON- PRP 37231 882 9 and and CC 37231 882 10 intercession intercession NN 37231 882 11 for for IN 37231 882 12 us -PRON- PRP 37231 882 13 , , , 37231 882 14 be be VB 37231 882 15 disjoined disjoin VBN 37231 882 16 from from IN 37231 882 17 another another DT 37231 882 18 ? ? . 37231 882 19 ... ... . 37231 883 1 If if IN 37231 883 2 a a DT 37231 883 3 miracle miracle NN 37231 883 4 is be VBZ 37231 883 5 incorporated incorporate VBN 37231 883 6 as as IN 37231 883 7 an an DT 37231 883 8 article article NN 37231 883 9 in in IN 37231 883 10 a a DT 37231 883 11 creed creed NN 37231 883 12 , , , 37231 883 13 that that DT 37231 883 14 article article NN 37231 883 15 of of IN 37231 883 16 the the DT 37231 883 17 creed creed NN 37231 883 18 , , , 37231 883 19 the the DT 37231 883 20 miracle miracle NN 37231 883 21 , , , 37231 883 22 and and CC 37231 883 23 the the DT 37231 883 24 proof proof NN 37231 883 25 of of IN 37231 883 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 883 27 by by IN 37231 883 28 a a DT 37231 883 29 miracle miracle NN 37231 883 30 , , , 37231 883 31 are be VBP 37231 883 32 all all DT 37231 883 33 one one CD 37231 883 34 thing thing NN 37231 883 35 . . . 37231 884 1 The the DT 37231 884 2 great great JJ 37231 884 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 884 4 , , , 37231 884 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 884 6 , , , 37231 884 7 upon upon IN 37231 884 8 the the DT 37231 884 9 evidence evidence NN 37231 884 10 of of IN 37231 884 11 which which WDT 37231 884 12 the the DT 37231 884 13 Christian christian JJ 37231 884 14 scheme scheme NN 37231 884 15 rested rest VBD 37231 884 16 , , , 37231 884 17 being be VBG 37231 884 18 thus thus RB 37231 884 19 inserted insert VBN 37231 884 20 in in IN 37231 884 21 the the DT 37231 884 22 Christian Christian NNP 37231 884 23 Creed Creed NNP 37231 884 24 , , , 37231 884 25 the the DT 37231 884 26 belief belief NN 37231 884 27 in in IN 37231 884 28 the the DT 37231 884 29 Creed Creed NNP 37231 884 30 was be VBD 37231 884 31 of of IN 37231 884 32 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 884 33 the the DT 37231 884 34 belief belief NN 37231 884 35 in in IN 37231 884 36 the the DT 37231 884 37 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 884 38 evidence evidence NN 37231 884 39 of of IN 37231 884 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 884 41 .... .... . 37231 885 1 Thus thus RB 37231 885 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 885 3 and and CC 37231 885 4 the the DT 37231 885 5 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 885 6 contents content NNS 37231 885 7 of of IN 37231 885 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 885 9 must must MD 37231 885 10 stand stand VB 37231 885 11 or or CC 37231 885 12 fall fall VB 37231 885 13 together together RB 37231 885 14 . . . 37231 886 1 " " `` 37231 886 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 886 3 2 2 LS 37231 886 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 886 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 886 6 Heurtley Heurtley NNP 37231 886 7 , , , 37231 886 8 referring refer VBG 37231 886 9 to to IN 37231 886 10 the the DT 37231 886 11 discussion discussion NN 37231 886 12 of of IN 37231 886 13 the the DT 37231 886 14 reality reality NN 37231 886 15 of of IN 37231 886 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 886 17 , , , 37231 886 18 exclaims exclaim VBZ 37231 886 19 : : : 37231 886 20 " " `` 37231 886 21 It -PRON- PRP 37231 886 22 is be VBZ 37231 886 23 not not RB 37231 886 24 too too RB 37231 886 25 much much JJ 37231 886 26 to to TO 37231 886 27 say say VB 37231 886 28 , , , 37231 886 29 therefore therefore RB 37231 886 30 , , , 37231 886 31 that that IN 37231 886 32 the the DT 37231 886 33 question question NN 37231 886 34 is be VBZ 37231 886 35 vital vital JJ 37231 886 36 as as IN 37231 886 37 regards regard VBZ 37231 886 38 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 886 39 . . . 37231 887 1 " " `` 37231 887 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 887 3 3 3 LS 37231 887 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 887 5 Canon Canon NNP 37231 887 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 887 7 not not RB 37231 887 8 less less RBR 37231 887 9 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 887 10 makes make VBZ 37231 887 11 the the DT 37231 887 12 same same JJ 37231 887 13 statement statement NN 37231 887 14 . . . 37231 888 1 " " `` 37231 888 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 888 3 is be VBZ 37231 888 4 evident evident JJ 37231 888 5 , , , 37231 888 6 " " '' 37231 888 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 888 8 says say VBZ 37231 888 9 , , , 37231 888 10 " " `` 37231 888 11 that that IN 37231 888 12 if if IN 37231 888 13 the the DT 37231 888 14 claim claim NN 37231 888 15 to to TO 37231 888 16 be be VB 37231 888 17 a a DT 37231 888 18 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 888 19 religion religion NN 37231 888 20 is be VBZ 37231 888 21 essentially essentially RB 37231 888 22 incredible incredible JJ 37231 888 23 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 888 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 888 25 is be VBZ 37231 888 26 simply simply RB 37231 888 27 false false JJ 37231 888 28 .... .... . 37231 889 1 The the DT 37231 889 2 essence essence NN 37231 889 3 of of IN 37231 889 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 889 5 lies lie VBZ 37231 889 6 in in IN 37231 889 7 a a DT 37231 889 8 miracle miracle NN 37231 889 9 ; ; : 37231 889 10 and and CC 37231 889 11 if if IN 37231 889 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 889 13 can can MD 37231 889 14 be be VB 37231 889 15 shown show VBN 37231 889 16 that that IN 37231 889 17 a a DT 37231 889 18 miracle miracle NN 37231 889 19 is be VBZ 37231 889 20 either either CC 37231 889 21 impossible impossible JJ 37231 889 22 or or CC 37231 889 23 incredible incredible JJ 37231 889 24 , , , 37231 889 25 all all DT 37231 889 26 further further JJ 37231 889 27 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 889 28 into into IN 37231 889 29 the the DT 37231 889 30 details detail NNS 37231 889 31 of of IN 37231 889 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 889 33 history history NN 37231 889 34 is be VBZ 37231 889 35 superfluous superfluous JJ 37231 889 36 { { -LRB- 37231 889 37 10 10 CD 37231 889 38 } } -RRB- 37231 889 39 in in IN 37231 889 40 a a DT 37231 889 41 religious religious JJ 37231 889 42 point point NN 37231 889 43 of of IN 37231 889 44 view view NN 37231 889 45 . . . 37231 890 1 " " `` 37231 890 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 890 3 1 1 LS 37231 890 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 890 5 Similarly similarly RB 37231 890 6 , , , 37231 890 7 a a DT 37231 890 8 recent recent JJ 37231 890 9 Hulsean hulsean JJ 37231 890 10 lecturer lecturer NN 37231 890 11 , , , 37231 890 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 890 13 Farrar Farrar NNP 37231 890 14 , , , 37231 890 15 has have VBZ 37231 890 16 said say VBD 37231 890 17 : : : 37231 890 18 " " `` 37231 890 19 However however RB 37231 890 20 skilfully skilfully RB 37231 890 21 the the DT 37231 890 22 modern modern JJ 37231 890 23 ingenuity ingenuity NN 37231 890 24 of of IN 37231 890 25 semi semi JJ 37231 890 26 - - NN 37231 890 27 belief belief NN 37231 890 28 may may MD 37231 890 29 have have VB 37231 890 30 tampered tamper VBN 37231 890 31 with with IN 37231 890 32 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 890 33 interpositions interposition NNS 37231 890 34 , , , 37231 890 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 890 36 is be VBZ 37231 890 37 clear clear JJ 37231 890 38 to to IN 37231 890 39 every every DT 37231 890 40 honest honest JJ 37231 890 41 and and CC 37231 890 42 unsophisticated unsophisticated JJ 37231 890 43 mind mind NN 37231 890 44 that that IN 37231 890 45 , , , 37231 890 46 if if IN 37231 890 47 miracles miracle NNS 37231 890 48 be be VB 37231 890 49 incredible incredible JJ 37231 890 50 , , , 37231 890 51 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 890 52 is be VBZ 37231 890 53 false false JJ 37231 890 54 . . . 37231 891 1 If if IN 37231 891 2 Christ Christ NNP 37231 891 3 wrought work VBD 37231 891 4 no no DT 37231 891 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 891 6 , , , 37231 891 7 then then RB 37231 891 8 the the DT 37231 891 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 891 10 are be VBP 37231 891 11 untrustworthy untrustworthy JJ 37231 891 12 ; ; : 37231 891 13 ... ... . 37231 892 1 If if IN 37231 892 2 the the DT 37231 892 3 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 892 4 be be VB 37231 892 5 merely merely RB 37231 892 6 a a DT 37231 892 7 spiritual spiritual JJ 37231 892 8 idea idea NN 37231 892 9 , , , 37231 892 10 or or CC 37231 892 11 a a DT 37231 892 12 mythicized mythicized JJ 37231 892 13 hallucination hallucination NN 37231 892 14 , , , 37231 892 15 then then RB 37231 892 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 892 17 religion religion NN 37231 892 18 has have VBZ 37231 892 19 been be VBN 37231 892 20 founded found VBN 37231 892 21 on on IN 37231 892 22 an an DT 37231 892 23 error error NN 37231 892 24 .... .... NFP 37231 892 25 " " '' 37231 892 26 ( ( -LRB- 37231 892 27 2 2 LS 37231 892 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 892 29 It -PRON- PRP 37231 892 30 has have VBZ 37231 892 31 been be VBN 37231 892 32 necessary necessary JJ 37231 892 33 clearly clearly RB 37231 892 34 to to TO 37231 892 35 point point VB 37231 892 36 out out RP 37231 892 37 this this DT 37231 892 38 indissoluble indissoluble JJ 37231 892 39 connection connection NN 37231 892 40 between between IN 37231 892 41 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 892 42 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 892 43 and and CC 37231 892 44 the the DT 37231 892 45 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 892 46 , , , 37231 892 47 in in IN 37231 892 48 order order NN 37231 892 49 that that IN 37231 892 50 the the DT 37231 892 51 paramount paramount JJ 37231 892 52 importance importance NN 37231 892 53 of of IN 37231 892 54 the the DT 37231 892 55 question question NN 37231 892 56 as as IN 37231 892 57 to to IN 37231 892 58 the the DT 37231 892 59 credibility credibility NN 37231 892 60 of of IN 37231 892 61 miracles miracle NNS 37231 892 62 should should MD 37231 892 63 be be VB 37231 892 64 duly duly RB 37231 892 65 appreciated appreciate VBN 37231 892 66 . . . 37231 893 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 893 2 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 893 3 into into IN 37231 893 4 the the DT 37231 893 5 reality reality NN 37231 893 6 of of IN 37231 893 7 Divine Divine NNP 37231 893 8 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 893 9 , , , 37231 893 10 then then RB 37231 893 11 , , , 37231 893 12 whether whether IN 37231 893 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 893 14 consider consider VBP 37231 893 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 893 16 contents content NNS 37231 893 17 or or CC 37231 893 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 893 19 evidence evidence NN 37231 893 20 , , , 37231 893 21 practically practically RB 37231 893 22 reduces reduce VBZ 37231 893 23 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 893 24 to to IN 37231 893 25 the the DT 37231 893 26 very very RB 37231 893 27 simple simple JJ 37231 893 28 issue issue NN 37231 893 29 : : : 37231 893 30 Are be VBP 37231 893 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 893 32 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 893 33 credible credible JJ 37231 893 34 ? ? . 37231 894 1 Did do VBD 37231 894 2 they -PRON- PRP 37231 894 3 ever ever RB 37231 894 4 really really RB 37231 894 5 take take VB 37231 894 6 place place NN 37231 894 7 ? ? . 37231 895 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 895 2 do do VBP 37231 895 3 not not RB 37231 895 4 intend intend VB 37231 895 5 to to TO 37231 895 6 confine confine VB 37231 895 7 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 895 8 merely merely RB 37231 895 9 to to IN 37231 895 10 a a DT 37231 895 11 discussion discussion NN 37231 895 12 of of IN 37231 895 13 the the DT 37231 895 14 abstract abstract JJ 37231 895 15 question question NN 37231 895 16 , , , 37231 895 17 but but CC 37231 895 18 shall shall MD 37231 895 19 also also RB 37231 895 20 endeavour endeavour VB 37231 895 21 to to TO 37231 895 22 form form VB 37231 895 23 a a DT 37231 895 24 correct correct JJ 37231 895 25 estimate estimate NN 37231 895 26 of of IN 37231 895 27 the the DT 37231 895 28 value value NN 37231 895 29 of of IN 37231 895 30 the the DT 37231 895 31 specific specific JJ 37231 895 32 allegations allegation NNS 37231 895 33 which which WDT 37231 895 34 are be VBP 37231 895 35 advanced advance VBN 37231 895 36 . . . 37231 896 1 2 2 LS 37231 896 2 . . . 37231 897 1 Having have VBG 37231 897 2 then then RB 37231 897 3 ascertained ascertain VBN 37231 897 4 that that IN 37231 897 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 897 6 are be VBP 37231 897 7 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 897 8 necessary necessary JJ 37231 897 9 to to TO 37231 897 10 attest attest VB 37231 897 11 the the DT 37231 897 12 reality reality NN 37231 897 13 of of IN 37231 897 14 Divine Divine NNP 37231 897 15 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 897 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 897 17 may may MD 37231 897 18 proceed proceed VB 37231 897 19 to to TO 37231 897 20 examine examine VB 37231 897 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 897 22 more more RBR 37231 897 23 closely closely RB 37231 897 24 , , , 37231 897 25 and and CC 37231 897 26 for for IN 37231 897 27 the the DT 37231 897 28 present present NN 37231 897 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 897 30 shall shall MD 37231 897 31 confine confine VB 37231 897 32 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 897 33 to to IN 37231 897 34 the the DT 37231 897 35 representations representation NNS 37231 897 36 of of IN 37231 897 37 these these DT 37231 897 38 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 897 39 which which WDT 37231 897 40 are be VBP 37231 897 41 given give VBN 37231 897 42 in in IN 37231 897 43 the the DT 37231 897 44 Bible Bible NNP 37231 897 45 . . . 37231 898 1 Throughout throughout IN 37231 898 2 the the DT 37231 898 3 Old Old NNP 37231 898 4 Testament Testament NNP 37231 898 5 the the DT 37231 898 6 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 898 7 is be VBZ 37231 898 8 inculcated inculcate VBN 37231 898 9 { { -LRB- 37231 898 10 11 11 CD 37231 898 11 } } -RRB- 37231 898 12 that that IN 37231 898 13 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 898 14 communications communication NNS 37231 898 15 must must MD 37231 898 16 have have VB 37231 898 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 898 18 attestation attestation NN 37231 898 19 . . . 37231 899 1 God God NNP 37231 899 2 is be VBZ 37231 899 3 described describe VBN 37231 899 4 as as IN 37231 899 5 arming arm VBG 37231 899 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 899 7 servants servant NNS 37231 899 8 with with IN 37231 899 9 power power NN 37231 899 10 to to TO 37231 899 11 perform perform VB 37231 899 12 wonders wonder NNS 37231 899 13 , , , 37231 899 14 in in IN 37231 899 15 order order NN 37231 899 16 that that IN 37231 899 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 899 18 may may MD 37231 899 19 thus thus RB 37231 899 20 be be VB 37231 899 21 accredited accredit VBN 37231 899 22 as as IN 37231 899 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 899 24 special special JJ 37231 899 25 messengers messenger NNS 37231 899 26 . . . 37231 900 1 The the DT 37231 900 2 Patriarchs Patriarchs NNPS 37231 900 3 and and CC 37231 900 4 the the DT 37231 900 5 people people NNS 37231 900 6 of of IN 37231 900 7 Israel Israel NNP 37231 900 8 generally generally RB 37231 900 9 are be VBP 37231 900 10 represented represent VBN 37231 900 11 as as IN 37231 900 12 demanding demand VBG 37231 900 13 " " `` 37231 900 14 a a DT 37231 900 15 sign sign NN 37231 900 16 " " '' 37231 900 17 of of IN 37231 900 18 the the DT 37231 900 19 reality reality NN 37231 900 20 of of IN 37231 900 21 communications communication NNS 37231 900 22 said say VBD 37231 900 23 to to TO 37231 900 24 come come VB 37231 900 25 from from IN 37231 900 26 God God NNP 37231 900 27 , , , 37231 900 28 without without IN 37231 900 29 which which WDT 37231 900 30 , , , 37231 900 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 900 32 are be VBP 37231 900 33 led lead VBN 37231 900 34 to to TO 37231 900 35 suppose suppose VB 37231 900 36 , , , 37231 900 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 900 38 not not RB 37231 900 39 only only RB 37231 900 40 would would MD 37231 900 41 not not RB 37231 900 42 have have VB 37231 900 43 believed believe VBN 37231 900 44 , , , 37231 900 45 but but CC 37231 900 46 would would MD 37231 900 47 have have VB 37231 900 48 been be VBN 37231 900 49 justified justify VBN 37231 900 50 in in IN 37231 900 51 disbelieving disbelieving NN 37231 900 52 , , , 37231 900 53 that that IN 37231 900 54 the the DT 37231 900 55 message message NN 37231 900 56 actually actually RB 37231 900 57 came come VBD 37231 900 58 from from IN 37231 900 59 him -PRON- PRP 37231 900 60 . . . 37231 901 1 Thus thus RB 37231 901 2 Gideon(1 gideon(1 NN 37231 901 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 901 4 asks ask VBZ 37231 901 5 for for IN 37231 901 6 a a DT 37231 901 7 sign sign NN 37231 901 8 that that IN 37231 901 9 the the DT 37231 901 10 Lord Lord NNP 37231 901 11 talked talk VBD 37231 901 12 with with IN 37231 901 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 901 14 , , , 37231 901 15 and and CC 37231 901 16 Hezekiah(2 hezekiah(2 NN 37231 901 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 901 18 demands demand VBZ 37231 901 19 proof proof NN 37231 901 20 of of IN 37231 901 21 the the DT 37231 901 22 truth truth NN 37231 901 23 of of IN 37231 901 24 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 37231 901 25 's 's POS 37231 901 26 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 901 27 that that IN 37231 901 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 901 29 should should MD 37231 901 30 be be VB 37231 901 31 restored restore VBN 37231 901 32 to to IN 37231 901 33 health health NN 37231 901 34 . . . 37231 902 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 902 2 is be VBZ 37231 902 3 , , , 37231 902 4 however however RB 37231 902 5 , , , 37231 902 6 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 902 7 to to TO 37231 902 8 refer refer VB 37231 902 9 to to IN 37231 902 10 instances instance NNS 37231 902 11 , , , 37231 902 12 for for IN 37231 902 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 902 14 may may MD 37231 902 15 be be VB 37231 902 16 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 902 17 that that IN 37231 902 18 upon upon IN 37231 902 19 all all DT 37231 902 20 occasions occasion NNS 37231 902 21 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 902 22 evidence evidence NN 37231 902 23 of of IN 37231 902 24 an an DT 37231 902 25 alleged allege VBN 37231 902 26 divine divine JJ 37231 902 27 mission mission NN 37231 902 28 is be VBZ 37231 902 29 stated state VBN 37231 902 30 to to TO 37231 902 31 have have VB 37231 902 32 been be VBN 37231 902 33 required require VBN 37231 902 34 and and CC 37231 902 35 accorded accord VBN 37231 902 36 . . . 37231 903 1 The the DT 37231 903 2 startling startling JJ 37231 903 3 information information NN 37231 903 4 is be VBZ 37231 903 5 at at IN 37231 903 6 the the DT 37231 903 7 same same JJ 37231 903 8 time time NN 37231 903 9 given give VBN 37231 903 10 , , , 37231 903 11 however however RB 37231 903 12 , , , 37231 903 13 that that IN 37231 903 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 903 15 may may MD 37231 903 16 be be VB 37231 903 17 wrought work VBN 37231 903 18 to to TO 37231 903 19 attest attest VB 37231 903 20 what what WP 37231 903 21 is be VBZ 37231 903 22 false false JJ 37231 903 23 as as RB 37231 903 24 well well RB 37231 903 25 as as IN 37231 903 26 to to TO 37231 903 27 accredit accredit VB 37231 903 28 what what WP 37231 903 29 is be VBZ 37231 903 30 true true JJ 37231 903 31 . . . 37231 904 1 In in IN 37231 904 2 one one CD 37231 904 3 place,(3 place,(3 NN 37231 904 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 904 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 904 6 is be VBZ 37231 904 7 declared declare VBN 37231 904 8 that that IN 37231 904 9 if if IN 37231 904 10 a a DT 37231 904 11 prophet prophet NN 37231 904 12 actually actually RB 37231 904 13 gives give VBZ 37231 904 14 a a DT 37231 904 15 sign sign NN 37231 904 16 or or CC 37231 904 17 wonder wonder NN 37231 904 18 and and CC 37231 904 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 904 20 comes come VBZ 37231 904 21 to to TO 37231 904 22 pass pass VB 37231 904 23 , , , 37231 904 24 but but CC 37231 904 25 teaches teach VBZ 37231 904 26 the the DT 37231 904 27 people people NNS 37231 904 28 , , , 37231 904 29 on on IN 37231 904 30 the the DT 37231 904 31 strength strength NN 37231 904 32 of of IN 37231 904 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 904 34 , , , 37231 904 35 to to TO 37231 904 36 follow follow VB 37231 904 37 other other JJ 37231 904 38 gods god NNS 37231 904 39 , , , 37231 904 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 904 41 are be VBP 37231 904 42 not not RB 37231 904 43 to to TO 37231 904 44 hearken hearken VB 37231 904 45 to to IN 37231 904 46 him -PRON- PRP 37231 904 47 , , , 37231 904 48 and and CC 37231 904 49 the the DT 37231 904 50 prophet prophet NN 37231 904 51 is be VBZ 37231 904 52 to to TO 37231 904 53 be be VB 37231 904 54 put put VBN 37231 904 55 to to IN 37231 904 56 death death NN 37231 904 57 . . . 37231 905 1 The the DT 37231 905 2 false false JJ 37231 905 3 miracle miracle NN 37231 905 4 is be VBZ 37231 905 5 , , , 37231 905 6 here,(4 here,(4 NNP 37231 905 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 905 8 attributed attribute VBD 37231 905 9 to to IN 37231 905 10 God God NNP 37231 905 11 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 905 12 : : : 37231 905 13 " " `` 37231 905 14 For for IN 37231 905 15 the the DT 37231 905 16 Lord Lord NNP 37231 905 17 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 905 18 God God NNP 37231 905 19 proveth proveth VB 37231 905 20 you -PRON- PRP 37231 905 21 , , , 37231 905 22 to to TO 37231 905 23 know know VB 37231 905 24 whether whether IN 37231 905 25 ye ye NNP 37231 905 26 love love VBP 37231 905 27 the the DT 37231 905 28 Lord Lord NNP 37231 905 29 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 905 30 God God NNP 37231 905 31 with with IN 37231 905 32 all all DT 37231 905 33 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 905 34 heart heart NN 37231 905 35 and and CC 37231 905 36 with with IN 37231 905 37 all all DT 37231 905 38 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 905 39 soul soul NN 37231 905 40 . . . 37231 905 41 " " '' 37231 906 1 In in IN 37231 906 2 the the DT 37231 906 3 book book NN 37231 906 4 of of IN 37231 906 5 the the DT 37231 906 6 Prophet Prophet NNP 37231 906 7 Ezekiel Ezekiel NNP 37231 906 8 , , , 37231 906 9 the the DT 37231 906 10 case case NN 37231 906 11 is be VBZ 37231 906 12 stated state VBN 37231 906 13 in in IN 37231 906 14 a a DT 37231 906 15 still still RB 37231 906 16 stronger strong JJR 37231 906 17 way way NN 37231 906 18 , , , 37231 906 19 and and CC 37231 906 20 God God NNP 37231 906 21 is be VBZ 37231 906 22 represented represent VBN 37231 906 23 as as IN 37231 906 24 directly directly RB 37231 906 25 deceiving deceive VBG 37231 906 26 the the DT 37231 906 27 prophet prophet NN 37231 906 28 : : : 37231 906 29 " " `` 37231 906 30 And and CC 37231 906 31 if if IN 37231 906 32 the the DT 37231 906 33 prophet prophet NN 37231 906 34 be be VB 37231 906 35 deceived deceive VBN 37231 906 36 when when WRB 37231 906 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 906 38 hath hath VBP 37231 906 39 spoken speak VBD 37231 906 40 a a DT 37231 906 41 thing thing NN 37231 906 42 , , , 37231 906 43 I -PRON- PRP 37231 906 44 the the DT 37231 906 45 Lord Lord NNP 37231 906 46 have have VBP 37231 906 47 deceived deceive VBN 37231 906 48 that that DT 37231 906 49 prophet prophet NN 37231 906 50 , , , 37231 906 51 and and CC 37231 906 52 I -PRON- PRP 37231 906 53 will will MD 37231 906 54 { { -LRB- 37231 906 55 12 12 CD 37231 906 56 } } -RRB- 37231 906 57 stretch stretch VB 37231 906 58 out out RP 37231 906 59 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 906 60 hand hand NN 37231 906 61 upon upon IN 37231 906 62 him -PRON- PRP 37231 906 63 , , , 37231 906 64 and and CC 37231 906 65 will will MD 37231 906 66 destroy destroy VB 37231 906 67 him -PRON- PRP 37231 906 68 from from IN 37231 906 69 the the DT 37231 906 70 midst midst NN 37231 906 71 of of IN 37231 906 72 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 906 73 people people NNS 37231 906 74 Israel Israel NNP 37231 906 75 . . . 37231 907 1 " " `` 37231 907 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 907 3 1 1 LS 37231 907 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 907 5 God God NNP 37231 907 6 , , , 37231 907 7 in in IN 37231 907 8 fact fact NN 37231 907 9 , , , 37231 907 10 is be VBZ 37231 907 11 represented represent VBN 37231 907 12 as as IN 37231 907 13 exerting exert VBG 37231 907 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 907 15 almighty almighty JJ 37231 907 16 power power NN 37231 907 17 to to TO 37231 907 18 deceive deceive VB 37231 907 19 a a DT 37231 907 20 man man NN 37231 907 21 and and CC 37231 907 22 then then RB 37231 907 23 as as IN 37231 907 24 destroying destroy VBG 37231 907 25 him -PRON- PRP 37231 907 26 for for IN 37231 907 27 being be VBG 37231 907 28 deceived deceive VBN 37231 907 29 . . . 37231 908 1 In in IN 37231 908 2 the the DT 37231 908 3 same same JJ 37231 908 4 spirit spirit NN 37231 908 5 is be VBZ 37231 908 6 the the DT 37231 908 7 passage(2 passage(2 NNP 37231 908 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 908 9 in in IN 37231 908 10 which which WDT 37231 908 11 Micaiah Micaiah NNP 37231 908 12 describes describe VBZ 37231 908 13 the the DT 37231 908 14 Lord Lord NNP 37231 908 15 as as IN 37231 908 16 putting put VBG 37231 908 17 a a DT 37231 908 18 lying lie VBG 37231 908 19 spirit spirit NN 37231 908 20 into into IN 37231 908 21 the the DT 37231 908 22 mouths mouth NNS 37231 908 23 of of IN 37231 908 24 the the DT 37231 908 25 prophets prophet NNS 37231 908 26 who who WP 37231 908 27 incited incite VBD 37231 908 28 Ahab Ahab NNP 37231 908 29 to to TO 37231 908 30 go go VB 37231 908 31 to to IN 37231 908 32 Ramoth Ramoth NNP 37231 908 33 - - HYPH 37231 908 34 Gilead Gilead NNP 37231 908 35 . . . 37231 909 1 Elsewhere,(3 elsewhere,(3 NN 37231 909 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 909 3 and and CC 37231 909 4 notably notably RB 37231 909 5 in in IN 37231 909 6 the the DT 37231 909 7 New New NNP 37231 909 8 Testament Testament NNP 37231 909 9 , , , 37231 909 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 909 11 find find VBP 37231 909 12 an an DT 37231 909 13 ascription ascription NN 37231 909 14 of of IN 37231 909 15 real real JJ 37231 909 16 signs sign NNS 37231 909 17 and and CC 37231 909 18 wonders wonder NNS 37231 909 19 to to IN 37231 909 20 another another DT 37231 909 21 power power NN 37231 909 22 than than IN 37231 909 23 God God NNP 37231 909 24 . . . 37231 910 1 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 910 2 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 910 3 is be VBZ 37231 910 4 represented represent VBN 37231 910 5 as as IN 37231 910 6 warning warn VBG 37231 910 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 910 8 disciples disciple NNS 37231 910 9 against against IN 37231 910 10 false false JJ 37231 910 11 prophets prophet NNS 37231 910 12 , , , 37231 910 13 who who WP 37231 910 14 work work VBP 37231 910 15 signs sign NNS 37231 910 16 and and CC 37231 910 17 wonders wonder NNS 37231 910 18 : : : 37231 910 19 " " `` 37231 910 20 Many many JJ 37231 910 21 will will MD 37231 910 22 say say VB 37231 910 23 to to IN 37231 910 24 me -PRON- PRP 37231 910 25 in in IN 37231 910 26 that that DT 37231 910 27 day day NN 37231 910 28 , , , 37231 910 29 Lord Lord NNP 37231 910 30 , , , 37231 910 31 Lord Lord NNP 37231 910 32 , , , 37231 910 33 have have VBP 37231 910 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 910 35 not not RB 37231 910 36 prophesied prophesy VBN 37231 910 37 in in IN 37231 910 38 thy thy PRP$ 37231 910 39 name name NN 37231 910 40 ? ? . 37231 911 1 and and CC 37231 911 2 in in IN 37231 911 3 thy thy PRP$ 37231 911 4 name name NN 37231 911 5 cast cast VBD 37231 911 6 out out RP 37231 911 7 devils devil NNS 37231 911 8 ? ? . 37231 912 1 and and CC 37231 912 2 in in IN 37231 912 3 thy thy PRP$ 37231 912 4 name name NN 37231 912 5 done do VBD 37231 912 6 many many JJ 37231 912 7 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 912 8 works work NNS 37231 912 9 ? ? . 37231 912 10 " " '' 37231 913 1 of of IN 37231 913 2 whom whom WP 37231 913 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 913 4 should should MD 37231 913 5 say say VB 37231 913 6 : : : 37231 913 7 " " `` 37231 913 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 913 9 never never RB 37231 913 10 knew know VBD 37231 913 11 you -PRON- PRP 37231 913 12 ; ; : 37231 913 13 depart depart VB 37231 913 14 from from IN 37231 913 15 me -PRON- PRP 37231 913 16 , , , 37231 913 17 ye ye VB 37231 913 18 that that IN 37231 913 19 work work NN 37231 913 20 iniquity iniquity NN 37231 913 21 . . . 37231 914 1 " " `` 37231 914 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 914 3 4 4 CD 37231 914 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 914 5 And and CC 37231 914 6 again again RB 37231 914 7 in in IN 37231 914 8 another another DT 37231 914 9 place place NN 37231 914 10 : : : 37231 914 11 " " `` 37231 914 12 For for IN 37231 914 13 false false JJ 37231 914 14 prophets prophet NNS 37231 914 15 shall shall MD 37231 914 16 arise arise VB 37231 914 17 , , , 37231 914 18 and and CC 37231 914 19 shall shall MD 37231 914 20 work work VB 37231 914 21 signs sign NNS 37231 914 22 and and CC 37231 914 23 wonders wonder NNS 37231 914 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 914 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 914 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 914 27 to to TO 37231 914 28 seduce seduce VB 37231 914 29 , , , 37231 914 30 if if IN 37231 914 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 914 32 were be VBD 37231 914 33 possible possible JJ 37231 914 34 , , , 37231 914 35 the the DT 37231 914 36 elect elect NN 37231 914 37 . . . 37231 915 1 " " `` 37231 915 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 915 3 5 5 CD 37231 915 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 915 5 Also also RB 37231 915 6 , , , 37231 915 7 when when WRB 37231 915 8 the the DT 37231 915 9 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 915 10 accuse accuse VBP 37231 915 11 him -PRON- PRP 37231 915 12 of of IN 37231 915 13 casting cast VBG 37231 915 14 out out RP 37231 915 15 devils devil NNS 37231 915 16 by by IN 37231 915 17 Beelzebub Beelzebub NNP 37231 915 18 the the DT 37231 915 19 prince prince NN 37231 915 20 of of IN 37231 915 21 the the DT 37231 915 22 devils devil NNS 37231 915 23 , , , 37231 915 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 915 25 asks ask VBZ 37231 915 26 : : : 37231 915 27 " " `` 37231 915 28 By by IN 37231 915 29 whom whom WP 37231 915 30 do do VBP 37231 915 31 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 915 32 children child NNS 37231 915 33 cast cast VB 37231 915 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 915 35 out out RP 37231 915 36 ? ? . 37231 916 1 " " `` 37231 916 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 916 3 6 6 LS 37231 916 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 916 5 a a DT 37231 916 6 reply reply NN 37231 916 7 which which WDT 37231 916 8 would would MD 37231 916 9 lose lose VB 37231 916 10 all all PDT 37231 916 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 916 12 point point NN 37231 916 13 if if IN 37231 916 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 916 15 were be VBD 37231 916 16 not not RB 37231 916 17 admitted admit VBN 37231 916 18 to to TO 37231 916 19 be be VB 37231 916 20 able able JJ 37231 916 21 to to TO 37231 916 22 cast cast VB 37231 916 23 out out RP 37231 916 24 devils devil NNS 37231 916 25 . . . 37231 917 1 In in IN 37231 917 2 another another DT 37231 917 3 passage passage NN 37231 917 4 John John NNP 37231 917 5 is be VBZ 37231 917 6 described describe VBN 37231 917 7 as as IN 37231 917 8 saying say VBG 37231 917 9 : : : 37231 917 10 " " `` 37231 917 11 Master Master NNP 37231 917 12 , , , 37231 917 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 917 14 saw see VBD 37231 917 15 one one CD 37231 917 16 casting cast VBG 37231 917 17 out out RP 37231 917 18 devils devil NNS 37231 917 19 in in IN 37231 917 20 thy thy PRP$ 37231 917 21 name name NN 37231 917 22 , , , 37231 917 23 who who WP 37231 917 24 followeth followeth VBD 37231 917 25 not not RB 37231 917 26 us -PRON- PRP 37231 917 27 , , , 37231 917 28 and and CC 37231 917 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 917 30 forbad forbad VBP 37231 917 31 him -PRON- PRP 37231 917 32 . . . 37231 918 1 " " `` 37231 918 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 918 3 7 7 LS 37231 918 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 918 5 Without without IN 37231 918 6 multiplying multiply VBG 37231 918 7 instances instance NNS 37231 918 8 , , , 37231 918 9 however however RB 37231 918 10 , , , 37231 918 11 there there EX 37231 918 12 can can MD 37231 918 13 be be VB 37231 918 14 no no DT 37231 918 15 doubt doubt NN 37231 918 16 of of IN 37231 918 17 the the DT 37231 918 18 fact fact NN 37231 918 19 { { -LRB- 37231 918 20 13 13 CD 37231 918 21 } } -RRB- 37231 918 22 that that IN 37231 918 23 the the DT 37231 918 24 reality reality NN 37231 918 25 of of IN 37231 918 26 false false JJ 37231 918 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 918 28 and and CC 37231 918 29 lying lie VBG 37231 918 30 wonders wonder NNS 37231 918 31 is be VBZ 37231 918 32 admitted admit VBN 37231 918 33 in in IN 37231 918 34 the the DT 37231 918 35 Bible Bible NNP 37231 918 36 . . . 37231 919 1 The the DT 37231 919 2 obvious obvious JJ 37231 919 3 deduction deduction NN 37231 919 4 from from IN 37231 919 5 this this DT 37231 919 6 representation representation NN 37231 919 7 of of IN 37231 919 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 919 9 is be VBZ 37231 919 10 that that IN 37231 919 11 the the DT 37231 919 12 source source NN 37231 919 13 and and CC 37231 919 14 purpose purpose NN 37231 919 15 of of IN 37231 919 16 such such JJ 37231 919 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 919 18 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 919 19 must must MD 37231 919 20 always always RB 37231 919 21 be be VB 37231 919 22 exceedingly exceedingly RB 37231 919 23 uncertain uncertain JJ 37231 919 24 . . . 37231 920 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 920 2 1 1 LS 37231 920 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 920 4 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 920 5 evidential evidential JJ 37231 920 6 value value NN 37231 920 7 is be VBZ 37231 920 8 , , , 37231 920 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 920 10 , , , 37231 920 11 profoundly profoundly RB 37231 920 12 affected affect VBN 37231 920 13 , , , 37231 920 14 " " '' 37231 920 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 920 16 being be VBG 37231 920 17 , , , 37231 920 18 " " '' 37231 920 19 as as IN 37231 920 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 920 21 Newman Newman NNP 37231 920 22 has have VBZ 37231 920 23 said say VBN 37231 920 24 of of IN 37231 920 25 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 37231 920 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 920 27 , , , 37231 920 28 " " '' 37231 920 29 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 920 30 improbable improbable JJ 37231 920 31 that that IN 37231 920 32 the the DT 37231 920 33 Almighty Almighty NNP 37231 920 34 should should MD 37231 920 35 rest rest VB 37231 920 36 the the DT 37231 920 37 credit credit NN 37231 920 38 of of IN 37231 920 39 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 920 40 Revelation revelation NN 37231 920 41 upon upon IN 37231 920 42 events event NNS 37231 920 43 which which WDT 37231 920 44 but but CC 37231 920 45 obscurely obscurely RB 37231 920 46 implied imply VBD 37231 920 47 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 920 48 immediate immediate JJ 37231 920 49 presence presence NN 37231 920 50 . . . 37231 921 1 " " `` 37231 921 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 921 3 2 2 LS 37231 921 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 921 5 As as IN 37231 921 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 921 7 is be VBZ 37231 921 8 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 921 9 that that IN 37231 921 10 other other JJ 37231 921 11 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 921 12 beings being NNS 37231 921 13 exist exist VBP 37231 921 14 , , , 37231 921 15 as as RB 37231 921 16 well well RB 37231 921 17 as as IN 37231 921 18 an an DT 37231 921 19 assumed assume VBN 37231 921 20 Personal Personal NNP 37231 921 21 God God NNP 37231 921 22 , , , 37231 921 23 by by IN 37231 921 24 whose whose WP$ 37231 921 25 agency agency NN 37231 921 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 921 27 are be VBP 37231 921 28 performed perform VBN 37231 921 29 , , , 37231 921 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 921 31 is be VBZ 37231 921 32 impossible impossible JJ 37231 921 33 to to TO 37231 921 34 argue argue VB 37231 921 35 with with IN 37231 921 36 reason reason NN 37231 921 37 that that IN 37231 921 38 such such JJ 37231 921 39 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 921 40 are be VBP 37231 921 41 at at IN 37231 921 42 any any DT 37231 921 43 time time NN 37231 921 44 specially specially RB 37231 921 45 due due IN 37231 921 46 to to IN 37231 921 47 the the DT 37231 921 48 intervention intervention NN 37231 921 49 of of IN 37231 921 50 the the DT 37231 921 51 Deity Deity NNP 37231 921 52 . . . 37231 922 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 922 2 Newman Newman NNP 37231 922 3 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 922 4 this this DT 37231 922 5 , , , 37231 922 6 but but CC 37231 922 7 passes pass VBZ 37231 922 8 over over IN 37231 922 9 the the DT 37231 922 10 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 922 11 with with IN 37231 922 12 masterly masterly JJ 37231 922 13 lightness lightness NN 37231 922 14 of of IN 37231 922 15 touch touch NN 37231 922 16 . . . 37231 923 1 After after IN 37231 923 2 advancing advance VBG 37231 923 3 the the DT 37231 923 4 singular singular JJ 37231 923 5 argument argument NN 37231 923 6 that that IN 37231 923 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 923 8 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 923 9 of of IN 37231 923 10 spirits spirit NNS 37231 923 11 is be VBZ 37231 923 12 only only RB 37231 923 13 derived derive VBN 37231 923 14 from from IN 37231 923 15 Scripture scripture NN 37231 923 16 , , , 37231 923 17 and and CC 37231 923 18 that that IN 37231 923 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 923 20 existence existence NN 37231 923 21 can can MD 37231 923 22 not not RB 37231 923 23 be be VB 37231 923 24 deduced deduce VBN 37231 923 25 from from IN 37231 923 26 nature nature NN 37231 923 27 , , , 37231 923 28 whilst whilst IN 37231 923 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 923 30 asserts assert VBZ 37231 923 31 that that IN 37231 923 32 the the DT 37231 923 33 being being NN 37231 923 34 of of IN 37231 923 35 a a DT 37231 923 36 God God NNP 37231 923 37 -- -- : 37231 923 38 a a DT 37231 923 39 Personal personal JJ 37231 923 40 God God NNP 37231 923 41 be be VB 37231 923 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 923 43 remembered remember VBN 37231 923 44 -- -- : 37231 923 45 can can MD 37231 923 46 be be VB 37231 923 47 so so RB 37231 923 48 discovered discover VBN 37231 923 49 , , , 37231 923 50 and and CC 37231 923 51 that that IN 37231 923 52 , , , 37231 923 53 therefore therefore RB 37231 923 54 , , , 37231 923 55 miracles miracle NNS 37231 923 56 can can MD 37231 923 57 only only RB 37231 923 58 properly properly RB 37231 923 59 be be VB 37231 923 60 attributed attribute VBN 37231 923 61 to to IN 37231 923 62 him -PRON- PRP 37231 923 63 , , , 37231 923 64 he -PRON- PRP 37231 923 65 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 923 66 : : : 37231 923 67 " " `` 37231 923 68 Still still RB 37231 923 69 it -PRON- PRP 37231 923 70 may may MD 37231 923 71 be be VB 37231 923 72 necessary necessary JJ 37231 923 73 to to TO 37231 923 74 show show VB 37231 923 75 that that DT 37231 923 76 on on IN 37231 923 77 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 923 78 own own JJ 37231 923 79 principles principle NNS 37231 923 80 we -PRON- PRP 37231 923 81 are be VBP 37231 923 82 not not RB 37231 923 83 open open JJ 37231 923 84 to to IN 37231 923 85 inconsistency inconsistency NN 37231 923 86 . . . 37231 924 1 That that RB 37231 924 2 is is RB 37231 924 3 , , , 37231 924 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 924 5 has have VBZ 37231 924 6 been be VBN 37231 924 7 questioned question VBN 37231 924 8 whether whether IN 37231 924 9 , , , 37231 924 10 in in IN 37231 924 11 admitting admit VBG 37231 924 12 the the DT 37231 924 13 existence existence NN 37231 924 14 and and CC 37231 924 15 power power NN 37231 924 16 of of IN 37231 924 17 Spirits Spirits NNPS 37231 924 18 on on IN 37231 924 19 the the DT 37231 924 20 authority authority NN 37231 924 21 of of IN 37231 924 22 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 924 23 , , , 37231 924 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 924 25 are be VBP 37231 924 26 not not RB 37231 924 27 in in IN 37231 924 28 danger danger NN 37231 924 29 of of IN 37231 924 30 { { -LRB- 37231 924 31 14 14 CD 37231 924 32 } } -RRB- 37231 924 33 invalidating invalidate VBG 37231 924 34 the the DT 37231 924 35 evidence evidence NN 37231 924 36 upon upon IN 37231 924 37 which which WDT 37231 924 38 that that DT 37231 924 39 authority authority NN 37231 924 40 rests rest VBZ 37231 924 41 . . . 37231 925 1 For for IN 37231 925 2 the the DT 37231 925 3 cogency cogency NN 37231 925 4 of of IN 37231 925 5 the the DT 37231 925 6 argument argument NN 37231 925 7 for for IN 37231 925 8 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 925 9 depends depend VBZ 37231 925 10 on on IN 37231 925 11 the the DT 37231 925 12 assumption assumption NN 37231 925 13 , , , 37231 925 14 that that IN 37231 925 15 interruptions interruption NNS 37231 925 16 in in IN 37231 925 17 the the DT 37231 925 18 course course NN 37231 925 19 of of IN 37231 925 20 nature nature NN 37231 925 21 must must MD 37231 925 22 ultimately ultimately RB 37231 925 23 proceed proceed VB 37231 925 24 from from IN 37231 925 25 God God NNP 37231 925 26 ; ; : 37231 925 27 which which WDT 37231 925 28 is be VBZ 37231 925 29 not not RB 37231 925 30 true true JJ 37231 925 31 , , , 37231 925 32 if if IN 37231 925 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 925 34 may may MD 37231 925 35 be be VB 37231 925 36 effected effect VBN 37231 925 37 by by IN 37231 925 38 other other JJ 37231 925 39 beings being NNS 37231 925 40 without without IN 37231 925 41 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 925 42 sanction sanction NN 37231 925 43 . . . 37231 926 1 And and CC 37231 926 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 926 3 must must MD 37231 926 4 be be VB 37231 926 5 conceded concede VBN 37231 926 6 , , , 37231 926 7 that that IN 37231 926 8 , , , 37231 926 9 explicit explicit JJ 37231 926 10 as as IN 37231 926 11 Scripture scripture NN 37231 926 12 is be VBZ 37231 926 13 in in IN 37231 926 14 considering consider VBG 37231 926 15 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 926 16 as as IN 37231 926 17 signs sign NNS 37231 926 18 of of IN 37231 926 19 divine divine JJ 37231 926 20 agency agency NN 37231 926 21 , , , 37231 926 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 926 23 still still RB 37231 926 24 does do VBZ 37231 926 25 seem seem VB 37231 926 26 to to TO 37231 926 27 give give VB 37231 926 28 created create VBN 37231 926 29 Spirits spirit NNS 37231 926 30 some some DT 37231 926 31 power power NN 37231 926 32 of of IN 37231 926 33 working work VBG 37231 926 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 926 35 ; ; : 37231 926 36 and and CC 37231 926 37 even even RB 37231 926 38 , , , 37231 926 39 in in IN 37231 926 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 926 41 most most RBS 37231 926 42 literal literal JJ 37231 926 43 sense sense NN 37231 926 44 , , , 37231 926 45 intimates intimate VBZ 37231 926 46 the the DT 37231 926 47 possibility possibility NN 37231 926 48 of of IN 37231 926 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 926 50 working work VBG 37231 926 51 them -PRON- PRP 37231 926 52 in in IN 37231 926 53 opposition opposition NN 37231 926 54 to to IN 37231 926 55 the the DT 37231 926 56 true true JJ 37231 926 57 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 926 58 . . . 37231 927 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 927 2 Deut deut VB 37231 927 3 . . . 37231 928 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 928 2 . . . 37231 929 1 1 1 CD 37231 929 2 - - SYM 37231 929 3 3 3 CD 37231 929 4 ; ; : 37231 929 5 Matt Matt NNP 37231 929 6 . . . 37231 930 1 xxiv xxiv NNP 37231 930 2 . . . 37231 931 1 24 24 CD 37231 931 2 ; ; : 37231 931 3 2 2 CD 37231 931 4 Thess thess NN 37231 931 5 . . . 37231 932 1 ii ii LS 37231 932 2 . . . 37231 933 1 9-ll 9-ll CD 37231 933 2 . . . 37231 934 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 934 2 " " `` 37231 934 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 934 4 1 1 CD 37231 934 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 934 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 934 7 Newman Newman NNP 37231 934 8 repudiates repudiate VBZ 37231 934 9 the the DT 37231 934 10 attempts attempt NNS 37231 934 11 of of IN 37231 934 12 various various JJ 37231 934 13 writers writer NNS 37231 934 14 to to TO 37231 934 15 overcome overcome VB 37231 934 16 this this DT 37231 934 17 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 934 18 by by IN 37231 934 19 making make VBG 37231 934 20 a a DT 37231 934 21 distinction distinction NN 37231 934 22 between between IN 37231 934 23 great great JJ 37231 934 24 miracles miracle NNS 37231 934 25 and and CC 37231 934 26 small small JJ 37231 934 27 , , , 37231 934 28 many many JJ 37231 934 29 miracles miracle NNS 37231 934 30 and and CC 37231 934 31 few few JJ 37231 934 32 , , , 37231 934 33 or or CC 37231 934 34 by by IN 37231 934 35 referring refer VBG 37231 934 36 to to IN 37231 934 37 the the DT 37231 934 38 nature nature NN 37231 934 39 of of IN 37231 934 40 the the DT 37231 934 41 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 934 42 attested attest VBN 37231 934 43 in in IN 37231 934 44 order order NN 37231 934 45 to to TO 37231 934 46 determine determine VB 37231 934 47 the the DT 37231 934 48 author author NN 37231 934 49 of of IN 37231 934 50 the the DT 37231 934 51 miracle miracle NN 37231 934 52 , , , 37231 934 53 or or CC 37231 934 54 by by IN 37231 934 55 denying deny VBG 37231 934 56 the the DT 37231 934 57 power power NN 37231 934 58 of of IN 37231 934 59 spirits spirit NNS 37231 934 60 altogether altogether RB 37231 934 61 , , , 37231 934 62 and and CC 37231 934 63 explaining explain VBG 37231 934 64 away away RP 37231 934 65 Scripture scripture NN 37231 934 66 statements statement NNS 37231 934 67 of of IN 37231 934 68 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 934 69 possession possession NN 37231 934 70 and and CC 37231 934 71 the the DT 37231 934 72 narrative narrative NN 37231 934 73 of of IN 37231 934 74 the the DT 37231 934 75 Lord Lord NNP 37231 934 76 's 's POS 37231 934 77 Temptation Temptation NNP 37231 934 78 . . . 37231 935 1 " " `` 37231 935 2 Without without IN 37231 935 3 having have VBG 37231 935 4 recourse recourse JJ 37231 935 5 to to IN 37231 935 6 any any DT 37231 935 7 of of IN 37231 935 8 these these DT 37231 935 9 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 935 10 modes mode NNS 37231 935 11 of of IN 37231 935 12 answering answer VBG 37231 935 13 the the DT 37231 935 14 objection objection NN 37231 935 15 , , , 37231 935 16 " " '' 37231 935 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 935 18 says say VBZ 37231 935 19 , , , 37231 935 20 " " `` 37231 935 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 935 22 may may MD 37231 935 23 be be VB 37231 935 24 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 935 25 to to TO 37231 935 26 reply reply VB 37231 935 27 , , , 37231 935 28 that that IN 37231 935 29 , , , 37231 935 30 since since RB 37231 935 31 , , , 37231 935 32 agreeably agreeably RB 37231 935 33 to to IN 37231 935 34 the the DT 37231 935 35 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 935 36 sentiment sentiment NN 37231 935 37 of of IN 37231 935 38 reason reason NN 37231 935 39 , , , 37231 935 40 God God NNP 37231 935 41 has have VBZ 37231 935 42 adopted adopt VBN 37231 935 43 miracles miracle NNS 37231 935 44 as as IN 37231 935 45 the the DT 37231 935 46 seal seal NN 37231 935 47 of of IN 37231 935 48 a a DT 37231 935 49 divine divine JJ 37231 935 50 message message NN 37231 935 51 , , , 37231 935 52 we -PRON- PRP 37231 935 53 believe believe VBP 37231 935 54 He -PRON- PRP 37231 935 55 will will MD 37231 935 56 never never RB 37231 935 57 suffer suffer VB 37231 935 58 them -PRON- PRP 37231 935 59 to to TO 37231 935 60 be be VB 37231 935 61 so so RB 37231 935 62 counterfeited counterfeit VBN 37231 935 63 as as IN 37231 935 64 to to TO 37231 935 65 deceive deceive VB 37231 935 66 the the DT 37231 935 67 humble humble JJ 37231 935 68 inquirer inquirer NN 37231 935 69 . . . 37231 936 1 " " `` 37231 936 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 936 3 2 2 LS 37231 936 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 936 5 This this DT 37231 936 6 is be VBZ 37231 936 7 the the DT 37231 936 8 only only JJ 37231 936 9 reply reply NN 37231 936 10 which which WDT 37231 936 11 even even RB 37231 936 12 so so RB 37231 936 13 powerful powerful JJ 37231 936 14 a a DT 37231 936 15 reasoner reasoner NN 37231 936 16 as as IN 37231 936 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 936 18 Newman Newman NNP 37231 936 19 can can MD 37231 936 20 give give VB 37231 936 21 to to IN 37231 936 22 an an DT 37231 936 23 objection objection NN 37231 936 24 based base VBN 37231 936 25 on on IN 37231 936 26 distinct distinct JJ 37231 936 27 statements statement NNS 37231 936 28 of of IN 37231 936 29 Scripture scripture NN 37231 936 30 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 936 31 . . . 37231 937 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 937 2 can can MD 37231 937 3 not not RB 37231 937 4 deny deny VB 37231 937 5 the the DT 37231 937 6 validity validity NN 37231 937 7 of of IN 37231 937 8 the the DT 37231 937 9 objection objection NN 37231 937 10 , , , 37231 937 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 937 12 can can MD 37231 937 13 only only RB 37231 937 14 hope hope VB 37231 937 15 or or CC 37231 937 16 believe believe VB 37231 937 17 in in IN 37231 937 18 spite spite NN 37231 937 19 of of IN 37231 937 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 937 21 Personal personal JJ 37231 937 22 belief belief NN 37231 937 23 independent independent NN 37231 937 24 of of IN 37231 937 25 evidence evidence NN 37231 937 26 is be VBZ 37231 937 27 the the DT 37231 937 28 most most RBS 37231 937 29 common common JJ 37231 937 30 and and CC 37231 937 31 the the DT 37231 937 32 weakest weak JJS 37231 937 33 of of IN 37231 937 34 arguments argument NNS 37231 937 35 ; ; : 37231 937 36 at at IN 37231 937 37 the the DT 37231 937 38 { { -LRB- 37231 937 39 15 15 CD 37231 937 40 } } -RRB- 37231 937 41 best well RBS 37231 937 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 937 43 is be VBZ 37231 937 44 prejudice prejudice NN 37231 937 45 masked mask VBN 37231 937 46 in in IN 37231 937 47 the the DT 37231 937 48 garb garb NN 37231 937 49 of of IN 37231 937 50 Reason reason NN 37231 937 51 . . . 37231 938 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 938 2 is be VBZ 37231 938 3 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 938 4 clear clear JJ 37231 938 5 that that IN 37231 938 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 938 7 being be VBG 37231 938 8 thus thus RB 37231 938 9 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 37231 938 10 to to TO 37231 938 11 be be VB 37231 938 12 common common JJ 37231 938 13 both both DT 37231 938 14 to to IN 37231 938 15 God God NNP 37231 938 16 and and CC 37231 938 17 to to IN 37231 938 18 other other JJ 37231 938 19 spirits spirit NNS 37231 938 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 938 21 can can MD 37231 938 22 not not RB 37231 938 23 be be VB 37231 938 24 considered consider VBN 37231 938 25 a a DT 37231 938 26 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 938 27 attestation attestation NN 37231 938 28 of of IN 37231 938 29 divine divine JJ 37231 938 30 intervention intervention NN 37231 938 31 ; ; : 37231 938 32 and and CC 37231 938 33 , , , 37231 938 34 as as IN 37231 938 35 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 37231 938 36 finely finely RB 37231 938 37 argued argue VBD 37231 938 38 , , , 37231 938 39 not not RB 37231 938 40 even even RB 37231 938 41 the the DT 37231 938 42 mere mere JJ 37231 938 43 existence existence NN 37231 938 44 of of IN 37231 938 45 God God NNP 37231 938 46 can can MD 37231 938 47 be be VB 37231 938 48 inferred infer VBN 37231 938 49 from from IN 37231 938 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 938 51 ; ; : 37231 938 52 for for IN 37231 938 53 as as IN 37231 938 54 a a DT 37231 938 55 miracle miracle NN 37231 938 56 is be VBZ 37231 938 57 a a DT 37231 938 58 limited limited JJ 37231 938 59 act act NN 37231 938 60 , , , 37231 938 61 and and CC 37231 938 62 never never RB 37231 938 63 expresses express VBZ 37231 938 64 more more JJR 37231 938 65 than than IN 37231 938 66 a a DT 37231 938 67 certain certain JJ 37231 938 68 and and CC 37231 938 69 limited limited JJ 37231 938 70 power power NN 37231 938 71 , , , 37231 938 72 it -PRON- PRP 37231 938 73 is be VBZ 37231 938 74 certain certain JJ 37231 938 75 that that IN 37231 938 76 we -PRON- PRP 37231 938 77 can can MD 37231 938 78 not not RB 37231 938 79 from from IN 37231 938 80 such such PDT 37231 938 81 an an DT 37231 938 82 effect effect NN 37231 938 83 , , , 37231 938 84 conclude conclude VB 37231 938 85 even even RB 37231 938 86 the the DT 37231 938 87 existence existence NN 37231 938 88 of of IN 37231 938 89 a a DT 37231 938 90 cause cause NN 37231 938 91 whose whose WP$ 37231 938 92 power power NN 37231 938 93 is be VBZ 37231 938 94 infinite infinite JJ 37231 938 95 . . . 37231 939 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 939 2 1 1 LS 37231 939 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 939 4 This this DT 37231 939 5 dual dual JJ 37231 939 6 character character NN 37231 939 7 obviously obviously RB 37231 939 8 leads lead VBZ 37231 939 9 to to IN 37231 939 10 many many JJ 37231 939 11 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 939 12 in in IN 37231 939 13 defining define VBG 37231 939 14 the the DT 37231 939 15 evidential evidential JJ 37231 939 16 function function NN 37231 939 17 and and CC 37231 939 18 force force NN 37231 939 19 of of IN 37231 939 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 939 21 , , , 37231 939 22 and and CC 37231 939 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 939 24 may may MD 37231 939 25 best well RBS 37231 939 26 appreciate appreciate VB 37231 939 27 the the DT 37231 939 28 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 939 29 which which WDT 37231 939 30 is be VBZ 37231 939 31 involved involve VBN 37231 939 32 by by IN 37231 939 33 continuing continue VBG 37231 939 34 to to TO 37231 939 35 follow follow VB 37231 939 36 the the DT 37231 939 37 statements statement NNS 37231 939 38 and and CC 37231 939 39 arguments argument NNS 37231 939 40 of of IN 37231 939 41 divines divine NNS 37231 939 42 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 939 43 . . . 37231 940 1 To to IN 37231 940 2 the the DT 37231 940 3 question question NN 37231 940 4 whether whether IN 37231 940 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 940 6 are be VBP 37231 940 7 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 940 8 to to TO 37231 940 9 command command VB 37231 940 10 the the DT 37231 940 11 obedience obedience NN 37231 940 12 of of IN 37231 940 13 those those DT 37231 940 14 in in IN 37231 940 15 whose whose WP$ 37231 940 16 sight sight NN 37231 940 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 940 18 are be VBP 37231 940 19 performed perform VBN 37231 940 20 , , , 37231 940 21 and and CC 37231 940 22 whether whether IN 37231 940 23 , , , 37231 940 24 upon upon IN 37231 940 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 940 26 attestation attestation NN 37231 940 27 , , , 37231 940 28 the the DT 37231 940 29 doer doer NNP 37231 940 30 and and CC 37231 940 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 940 32 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 940 33 are be VBP 37231 940 34 to to TO 37231 940 35 be be VB 37231 940 36 accepted accept VBN 37231 940 37 as as IN 37231 940 38 of of IN 37231 940 39 God God NNP 37231 940 40 , , , 37231 940 41 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 940 42 Trench Trench NNP 37231 940 43 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 37231 940 44 replies reply VBZ 37231 940 45 : : : 37231 940 46 " " `` 37231 940 47 It -PRON- PRP 37231 940 48 can can MD 37231 940 49 not not RB 37231 940 50 be be VB 37231 940 51 so so RB 37231 940 52 , , , 37231 940 53 for for IN 37231 940 54 side side NN 37231 940 55 by by IN 37231 940 56 side side NN 37231 940 57 with with IN 37231 940 58 the the DT 37231 940 59 miracles miracle NNS 37231 940 60 which which WDT 37231 940 61 serve serve VBP 37231 940 62 for for IN 37231 940 63 the the DT 37231 940 64 furthering furthering NN 37231 940 65 of of IN 37231 940 66 the the DT 37231 940 67 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 940 68 of of IN 37231 940 69 God God NNP 37231 940 70 runs run VBZ 37231 940 71 another another DT 37231 940 72 line line NN 37231 940 73 of of IN 37231 940 74 wonders wonder NNS 37231 940 75 , , , 37231 940 76 the the DT 37231 940 77 counter counter NN 37231 940 78 - - NNS 37231 940 79 workings working NNS 37231 940 80 of of IN 37231 940 81 him -PRON- PRP 37231 940 82 who who WP 37231 940 83 is be VBZ 37231 940 84 ever ever RB 37231 940 85 the the DT 37231 940 86 ape ape NN 37231 940 87 of of IN 37231 940 88 the the DT 37231 940 89 Most most RBS 37231 940 90 High high JJ 37231 940 91 . . . 37231 941 1 " " `` 37231 941 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 941 3 2 2 LS 37231 941 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 941 5 The the DT 37231 941 6 deduction deduction NN 37231 941 7 is be VBZ 37231 941 8 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 941 9 logical logical JJ 37231 941 10 and and CC 37231 941 11 can can MD 37231 941 12 not not RB 37231 941 13 be be VB 37231 941 14 denied deny VBN 37231 941 15 . . . 37231 942 1 " " `` 37231 942 2 This this DT 37231 942 3 fact fact NN 37231 942 4 , , , 37231 942 5 " " '' 37231 942 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 942 7 says say VBZ 37231 942 8 , , , 37231 942 9 " " `` 37231 942 10 that that IN 37231 942 11 the the DT 37231 942 12 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 942 13 of of IN 37231 942 14 lies lie NNS 37231 942 15 has have VBZ 37231 942 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 942 17 wonders wonder NNS 37231 942 18 no no RB 37231 942 19 less less JJR 37231 942 20 than than IN 37231 942 21 the the DT 37231 942 22 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 942 23 of of IN 37231 942 24 truth truth NNP 37231 942 25 , , , 37231 942 26 is be VBZ 37231 942 27 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 942 28 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 942 29 evidence evidence NN 37231 942 30 that that IN 37231 942 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 942 32 can can MD 37231 942 33 not not RB 37231 942 34 be be VB 37231 942 35 appealed appeal VBN 37231 942 36 { { -LRB- 37231 942 37 16 16 CD 37231 942 38 } } -RRB- 37231 942 39 to to TO 37231 942 40 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 942 41 and and CC 37231 942 42 finally finally RB 37231 942 43 , , , 37231 942 44 in in IN 37231 942 45 proof proof NN 37231 942 46 of of IN 37231 942 47 the the DT 37231 942 48 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 942 49 which which WDT 37231 942 50 the the DT 37231 942 51 worker worker NN 37231 942 52 of of IN 37231 942 53 them -PRON- PRP 37231 942 54 proclaims proclaim VBZ 37231 942 55 . . . 37231 942 56 " " '' 37231 943 1 This this DT 37231 943 2 being be VBG 37231 943 3 the the DT 37231 943 4 case case NN 37231 943 5 , , , 37231 943 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 943 7 is be VBZ 37231 943 8 important important JJ 37231 943 9 to to TO 37231 943 10 discover discover VB 37231 943 11 how how WRB 37231 943 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 943 13 perform perform VBP 37231 943 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 943 15 function function NN 37231 943 16 as as IN 37231 943 17 the the DT 37231 943 18 indispensable indispensable JJ 37231 943 19 evidence evidence NN 37231 943 20 for for IN 37231 943 21 a a DT 37231 943 22 Divine Divine NNP 37231 943 23 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 943 24 , , , 37231 943 25 for for IN 37231 943 26 with with IN 37231 943 27 this this DT 37231 943 28 disability disability NN 37231 943 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 943 30 do do VBP 37231 943 31 not not RB 37231 943 32 seem seem VB 37231 943 33 to to TO 37231 943 34 possess possess VB 37231 943 35 much much JJ 37231 943 36 potentiality potentiality NN 37231 943 37 . . . 37231 944 1 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 944 2 Trench Trench NNP 37231 944 3 , , , 37231 944 4 then then RB 37231 944 5 , , , 37231 944 6 offers offer VBZ 37231 944 7 the the DT 37231 944 8 following follow VBG 37231 944 9 definition definition NN 37231 944 10 of of IN 37231 944 11 the the DT 37231 944 12 function function NN 37231 944 13 of of IN 37231 944 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 944 15 : : : 37231 944 16 " " `` 37231 944 17 A a DT 37231 944 18 miracle miracle NN 37231 944 19 does do VBZ 37231 944 20 not not RB 37231 944 21 prove prove VB 37231 944 22 the the DT 37231 944 23 truth truth NN 37231 944 24 of of IN 37231 944 25 a a DT 37231 944 26 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 944 27 , , , 37231 944 28 or or CC 37231 944 29 the the DT 37231 944 30 divine divine JJ 37231 944 31 mission mission NN 37231 944 32 of of IN 37231 944 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 944 34 that that WDT 37231 944 35 brings bring VBZ 37231 944 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 944 37 to to TO 37231 944 38 pass pass VB 37231 944 39 . . . 37231 945 1 That that DT 37231 945 2 which which WDT 37231 945 3 alone alone RB 37231 945 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 945 5 claims claim VBZ 37231 945 6 for for IN 37231 945 7 him -PRON- PRP 37231 945 8 at at IN 37231 945 9 the the DT 37231 945 10 first first JJ 37231 945 11 is be VBZ 37231 945 12 a a DT 37231 945 13 right right NN 37231 945 14 to to TO 37231 945 15 be be VB 37231 945 16 listened listen VBN 37231 945 17 to to IN 37231 945 18 : : : 37231 945 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 945 20 puts put VBZ 37231 945 21 him -PRON- PRP 37231 945 22 in in IN 37231 945 23 the the DT 37231 945 24 alternative alternative NN 37231 945 25 of of IN 37231 945 26 being be VBG 37231 945 27 from from IN 37231 945 28 heaven heaven NNP 37231 945 29 or or CC 37231 945 30 from from IN 37231 945 31 hell hell NNP 37231 945 32 . . . 37231 946 1 The the DT 37231 946 2 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 946 3 must must MD 37231 946 4 first first RB 37231 946 5 commend commend VB 37231 946 6 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 946 7 to to IN 37231 946 8 the the DT 37231 946 9 conscience conscience NN 37231 946 10 as as IN 37231 946 11 being be VBG 37231 946 12 _ _ NNP 37231 946 13 good good JJ 37231 946 14 _ _ NNP 37231 946 15 , , , 37231 946 16 and and CC 37231 946 17 only only RB 37231 946 18 then then RB 37231 946 19 can can MD 37231 946 20 the the DT 37231 946 21 miracle miracle NN 37231 946 22 seal seal VB 37231 946 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 946 24 as as IN 37231 946 25 _ _ NNP 37231 946 26 divine divine JJ 37231 946 27 _ _ NNP 37231 946 28 . . . 37231 947 1 But but CC 37231 947 2 the the DT 37231 947 3 first first JJ 37231 947 4 appeal appeal NN 37231 947 5 is be VBZ 37231 947 6 from from IN 37231 947 7 the the DT 37231 947 8 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 947 9 to to IN 37231 947 10 the the DT 37231 947 11 conscience conscience NN 37231 947 12 , , , 37231 947 13 to to IN 37231 947 14 the the DT 37231 947 15 moral moral JJ 37231 947 16 nature nature NN 37231 947 17 of of IN 37231 947 18 man man NN 37231 947 19 . . . 37231 948 1 " " `` 37231 948 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 948 3 1 1 LS 37231 948 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 948 5 Under under IN 37231 948 6 certain certain JJ 37231 948 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 948 8 , , , 37231 948 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 948 10 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 948 11 , , , 37231 948 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 948 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 948 14 is be VBZ 37231 948 15 utterly utterly RB 37231 948 16 to to TO 37231 948 17 be be VB 37231 948 18 rejected reject VBN 37231 948 19 . . . 37231 949 1 " " `` 37231 949 2 But but CC 37231 949 3 the the DT 37231 949 4 purpose purpose NN 37231 949 5 of of IN 37231 949 6 the the DT 37231 949 7 miracle miracle NN 37231 949 8 , , , 37231 949 9 " " '' 37231 949 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 949 11 says say VBZ 37231 949 12 , , , 37231 949 13 " " `` 37231 949 14 being be VBG 37231 949 15 , , , 37231 949 16 as as IN 37231 949 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 949 18 have have VBP 37231 949 19 seen see VBN 37231 949 20 , , , 37231 949 21 to to TO 37231 949 22 confirm confirm VB 37231 949 23 that that IN 37231 949 24 which which WDT 37231 949 25 is be VBZ 37231 949 26 good good JJ 37231 949 27 , , , 37231 949 28 so so CC 37231 949 29 , , , 37231 949 30 upon upon IN 37231 949 31 the the DT 37231 949 32 other other JJ 37231 949 33 hand hand NN 37231 949 34 , , , 37231 949 35 where where WRB 37231 949 36 the the DT 37231 949 37 mind mind NN 37231 949 38 and and CC 37231 949 39 conscience conscience NN 37231 949 40 witness witness NN 37231 949 41 against against IN 37231 949 42 the the DT 37231 949 43 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 949 44 , , , 37231 949 45 not not RB 37231 949 46 all all PDT 37231 949 47 the the DT 37231 949 48 miracles miracle NNS 37231 949 49 in in IN 37231 949 50 the the DT 37231 949 51 world world NN 37231 949 52 have have VBP 37231 949 53 a a DT 37231 949 54 right right NN 37231 949 55 to to TO 37231 949 56 demand demand VB 37231 949 57 submission submission NN 37231 949 58 to to IN 37231 949 59 the the DT 37231 949 60 word word NN 37231 949 61 which which WDT 37231 949 62 they -PRON- PRP 37231 949 63 seal seal VBP 37231 949 64 . . . 37231 950 1 On on IN 37231 950 2 the the DT 37231 950 3 contrary contrary NN 37231 950 4 , , , 37231 950 5 the the DT 37231 950 6 great great JJ 37231 950 7 act act NN 37231 950 8 of of IN 37231 950 9 faith faith NN 37231 950 10 { { -LRB- 37231 950 11 17 17 CD 37231 950 12 } } -RRB- 37231 950 13 is be VBZ 37231 950 14 to to TO 37231 950 15 believe believe VB 37231 950 16 , , , 37231 950 17 against against IN 37231 950 18 , , , 37231 950 19 and and CC 37231 950 20 in in IN 37231 950 21 despite despite IN 37231 950 22 of of IN 37231 950 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 950 24 all all DT 37231 950 25 , , , 37231 950 26 in in IN 37231 950 27 what what WP 37231 950 28 God God NNP 37231 950 29 has have VBZ 37231 950 30 revealed reveal VBN 37231 950 31 to to IN 37231 950 32 , , , 37231 950 33 and and CC 37231 950 34 implanted implant VBN 37231 950 35 in in IN 37231 950 36 the the DT 37231 950 37 soul soul NN 37231 950 38 of of IN 37231 950 39 the the DT 37231 950 40 holy holy JJ 37231 950 41 and and CC 37231 950 42 the the DT 37231 950 43 true true JJ 37231 950 44 ; ; : 37231 950 45 not not RB 37231 950 46 to to TO 37231 950 47 believe believe VB 37231 950 48 another another DT 37231 950 49 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 950 50 , , , 37231 950 51 though though IN 37231 950 52 an an DT 37231 950 53 Angel Angel NNP 37231 950 54 from from IN 37231 950 55 heaven heaven NNP 37231 950 56 , , , 37231 950 57 or or CC 37231 950 58 one one CD 37231 950 59 transformed transform VBD 37231 950 60 into into IN 37231 950 61 such such JJ 37231 950 62 , , , 37231 950 63 should should MD 37231 950 64 bring bring VB 37231 950 65 it -PRON- PRP 37231 950 66 ( ( -LRB- 37231 950 67 Deut deut VB 37231 950 68 . . . 37231 951 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 951 2 . . . 37231 952 1 3 3 LS 37231 952 2 ; ; : 37231 952 3 Gal Gal NNP 37231 952 4 . . . 37231 953 1 i. i. NNP 37231 954 1 8) 8) CD 37231 954 2 ; ; : 37231 954 3 and and CC 37231 954 4 instead instead RB 37231 954 5 of of IN 37231 954 6 compelling compelling JJ 37231 954 7 assent assent NN 37231 954 8 , , , 37231 954 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 954 10 are be VBP 37231 954 11 then then RB 37231 954 12 rather rather RB 37231 954 13 warnings warning NNS 37231 954 14 to to IN 37231 954 15 us -PRON- PRP 37231 954 16 that that IN 37231 954 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 954 18 keep keep VBP 37231 954 19 aloof aloof JJ 37231 954 20 , , , 37231 954 21 for for IN 37231 954 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 954 23 tell tell VBP 37231 954 24 us -PRON- PRP 37231 954 25 that that IN 37231 954 26 not not RB 37231 954 27 merely merely RB 37231 954 28 lies lie NNS 37231 954 29 are be VBP 37231 954 30 here here RB 37231 954 31 , , , 37231 954 32 for for IN 37231 954 33 to to IN 37231 954 34 that that DT 37231 954 35 the the DT 37231 954 36 conscience conscience NN 37231 954 37 bore bear VBD 37231 954 38 witness witness NN 37231 954 39 already already RB 37231 954 40 , , , 37231 954 41 but but CC 37231 954 42 that that IN 37231 954 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 954 44 who who WP 37231 954 45 utters utter VBZ 37231 954 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 954 47 is be VBZ 37231 954 48 more more JJR 37231 954 49 than than IN 37231 954 50 a a DT 37231 954 51 common common JJ 37231 954 52 deceiver deceiver NN 37231 954 53 , , , 37231 954 54 is be VBZ 37231 954 55 eminently eminently RB 37231 954 56 ' ' `` 37231 954 57 a a DT 37231 954 58 liar liar NN 37231 954 59 and and CC 37231 954 60 an an DT 37231 954 61 Anti Anti NNP 37231 954 62 - - NNP 37231 954 63 christ christ NNP 37231 954 64 , , , 37231 954 65 ' ' '' 37231 954 66 a a DT 37231 954 67 false false JJ 37231 954 68 prophet prophet NN 37231 954 69 , , , 37231 954 70 --standing --stande VBG 37231 954 71 in in IN 37231 954 72 more more JJR 37231 954 73 immediate immediate JJ 37231 954 74 connection connection NN 37231 954 75 than than IN 37231 954 76 other other JJ 37231 954 77 deceived deceive VBN 37231 954 78 and and CC 37231 954 79 evil evil JJ 37231 954 80 men man NNS 37231 954 81 to to IN 37231 954 82 the the DT 37231 954 83 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 954 84 of of IN 37231 954 85 darkness darkness NN 37231 954 86 , , , 37231 954 87 so so IN 37231 954 88 that that IN 37231 954 89 Satan Satan NNP 37231 954 90 has have VBZ 37231 954 91 given give VBN 37231 954 92 him -PRON- PRP 37231 954 93 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 954 94 power power NN 37231 954 95 ( ( -LRB- 37231 954 96 Rev. Rev. NNP 37231 955 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 955 2 . . . 37231 956 1 2 2 LS 37231 956 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 956 3 , , , 37231 956 4 is be VBZ 37231 956 5 using use VBG 37231 956 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 956 7 to to TO 37231 956 8 be be VB 37231 956 9 an an DT 37231 956 10 especial especial JJ 37231 956 11 organ organ NN 37231 956 12 of of IN 37231 956 13 his -PRON- PRP 37231 956 14 , , , 37231 956 15 and and CC 37231 956 16 to to TO 37231 956 17 do do VB 37231 956 18 a a DT 37231 956 19 special special JJ 37231 956 20 work work NN 37231 956 21 for for IN 37231 956 22 him -PRON- PRP 37231 956 23 . . . 37231 957 1 " " `` 37231 957 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 957 3 1 1 CD 37231 957 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 957 5 And and CC 37231 957 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 957 7 lays lay VBZ 37231 957 8 down down IN 37231 957 9 the the DT 37231 957 10 distinct distinct JJ 37231 957 11 principle principle NN 37231 957 12 that that DT 37231 957 13 : : : 37231 957 14 " " `` 37231 957 15 The the DT 37231 957 16 miracle miracle NN 37231 957 17 must must MD 37231 957 18 witness witness VB 37231 957 19 for for IN 37231 957 20 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 957 21 , , , 37231 957 22 and and CC 37231 957 23 the the DT 37231 957 24 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 957 25 must must MD 37231 957 26 witness witness VB 37231 957 27 for for IN 37231 957 28 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 957 29 , , , 37231 957 30 and and CC 37231 957 31 then then RB 37231 957 32 , , , 37231 957 33 and and CC 37231 957 34 then then RB 37231 957 35 only only RB 37231 957 36 , , , 37231 957 37 the the DT 37231 957 38 first first JJ 37231 957 39 is be VBZ 37231 957 40 capable capable JJ 37231 957 41 of of IN 37231 957 42 witnessing witness VBG 37231 957 43 for for IN 37231 957 44 the the DT 37231 957 45 second second JJ 37231 957 46 . . . 37231 958 1 " " `` 37231 958 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 958 3 2 2 LS 37231 958 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 958 5 These these DT 37231 958 6 opinions opinion NNS 37231 958 7 are be VBP 37231 958 8 not not RB 37231 958 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 958 10 to to IN 37231 958 11 the the DT 37231 958 12 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 958 13 of of IN 37231 958 14 Dublin Dublin NNP 37231 958 15 , , , 37231 958 16 but but CC 37231 958 17 are be VBP 37231 958 18 generally generally RB 37231 958 19 held hold VBN 37231 958 20 by by IN 37231 958 21 divines divine NNS 37231 958 22 , , , 37231 958 23 although although IN 37231 958 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 958 25 Trench Trench NNP 37231 958 26 expresses express VBZ 37231 958 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 958 28 with with IN 37231 958 29 unusual unusual JJ 37231 958 30 absence absence NN 37231 958 31 of of IN 37231 958 32 reserve reserve NN 37231 958 33 . . . 37231 959 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 959 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 959 3 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 959 4 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 959 5 the the DT 37231 959 6 same same JJ 37231 959 7 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 959 8 when when WRB 37231 959 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 959 10 says say VBZ 37231 959 11 : : : 37231 959 12 " " `` 37231 959 13 A a DT 37231 959 14 miracle miracle NN 37231 959 15 can can MD 37231 959 16 not not RB 37231 959 17 oblige oblige VB 37231 959 18 us -PRON- PRP 37231 959 19 to to TO 37231 959 20 accept accept VB 37231 959 21 any any DT 37231 959 22 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 959 23 which which WDT 37231 959 24 is be VBZ 37231 959 25 contrary contrary JJ 37231 959 26 to to IN 37231 959 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 959 28 moral moral JJ 37231 959 29 nature nature NN 37231 959 30 , , , 37231 959 31 or or CC 37231 959 32 to to IN 37231 959 33 a a DT 37231 959 34 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 959 35 principle principle NN 37231 959 36 of of IN 37231 959 37 religion religion NN 37231 959 38 . . . 37231 960 1 " " `` 37231 960 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 960 3 3 3 LS 37231 960 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 960 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 960 6 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 960 7 speaks speak VBZ 37231 960 8 to to IN 37231 960 9 the the DT 37231 960 10 same same JJ 37231 960 11 effect effect NN 37231 960 12 : : : 37231 960 13 " " `` 37231 960 14 If if IN 37231 960 15 a a DT 37231 960 16 teacher teacher NN 37231 960 17 claiming claim VBG 37231 960 18 to to TO 37231 960 19 work work VB 37231 960 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 960 21 proclaims proclaim VBZ 37231 960 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 960 23 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 960 24 to to IN 37231 960 25 previously previously RB 37231 960 26 established establish VBN 37231 960 27 truths truth NNS 37231 960 28 , , , 37231 960 29 whether whether IN 37231 960 30 to to IN 37231 960 31 the the DT 37231 960 32 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 960 33 of of IN 37231 960 34 natural natural JJ 37231 960 35 religion religion NN 37231 960 36 or or CC 37231 960 37 to to IN 37231 960 38 the the DT 37231 960 39 teaching teaching NN 37231 960 40 of of IN 37231 960 41 a a DT 37231 960 42 former former JJ 37231 960 43 revelation revelation NN 37231 960 44 , , , 37231 960 45 such such PDT 37231 960 46 a a DT 37231 960 47 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 960 48 is be VBZ 37231 960 49 allowed allow VBN 37231 960 50 even even RB 37231 960 51 by by IN 37231 960 52 the the DT 37231 960 53 most most RBS 37231 960 54 zealous zealous JJ 37231 960 55 defenders defender NNS 37231 960 56 of of IN 37231 960 57 the the DT 37231 960 58 evidential evidential JJ 37231 960 59 value value NN 37231 960 60 of of IN 37231 960 61 miracles miracle NNS 37231 960 62 , , , 37231 960 63 to to IN 37231 960 64 { { -LRB- 37231 960 65 18 18 CD 37231 960 66 } } -RRB- 37231 960 67 invalidate invalidate VBP 37231 960 68 the the DT 37231 960 69 authority authority NN 37231 960 70 of of IN 37231 960 71 the the DT 37231 960 72 teacher teacher NN 37231 960 73 . . . 37231 961 1 But but CC 37231 961 2 the the DT 37231 961 3 right right JJ 37231 961 4 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 961 5 from from IN 37231 961 6 this this DT 37231 961 7 admission admission NN 37231 961 8 is be VBZ 37231 961 9 not not RB 37231 961 10 that that RB 37231 961 11 true true JJ 37231 961 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 961 13 are be VBP 37231 961 14 invalid invalid JJ 37231 961 15 as as IN 37231 961 16 evidences evidence NNS 37231 961 17 , , , 37231 961 18 but but CC 37231 961 19 that that IN 37231 961 20 the the DT 37231 961 21 supposed suppose VBN 37231 961 22 miracles miracle NNS 37231 961 23 in in IN 37231 961 24 this this DT 37231 961 25 case case NN 37231 961 26 are be VBP 37231 961 27 not not RB 37231 961 28 true true JJ 37231 961 29 miracles miracle NNS 37231 961 30 at at RB 37231 961 31 all all RB 37231 961 32 ; ; : 37231 961 33 i. i. NNP 37231 961 34 e. e. NNP 37231 961 35 , , , 37231 961 36 are be VBP 37231 961 37 not not RB 37231 961 38 the the DT 37231 961 39 effects effect NNS 37231 961 40 of of IN 37231 961 41 Divine divine JJ 37231 961 42 power power NN 37231 961 43 , , , 37231 961 44 but but CC 37231 961 45 of of IN 37231 961 46 human human JJ 37231 961 47 deception deception NN 37231 961 48 or or CC 37231 961 49 of of IN 37231 961 50 some some DT 37231 961 51 other other JJ 37231 961 52 agency agency NN 37231 961 53 . . . 37231 962 1 " " `` 37231 962 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 962 3 1 1 LS 37231 962 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 962 5 A a DT 37231 962 6 passage passage NN 37231 962 7 from from IN 37231 962 8 a a DT 37231 962 9 letter letter NN 37231 962 10 written write VBN 37231 962 11 by by IN 37231 962 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 962 13 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 962 14 which which WDT 37231 962 15 is be VBZ 37231 962 16 quoted quote VBN 37231 962 17 by by IN 37231 962 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 962 19 Trench Trench NNP 37231 962 20 in in IN 37231 962 21 support support NN 37231 962 22 of of IN 37231 962 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 962 24 views view NNS 37231 962 25 , , , 37231 962 26 both both DT 37231 962 27 illustrates illustrate VBZ 37231 962 28 the the DT 37231 962 29 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 962 30 and and CC 37231 962 31 the the DT 37231 962 32 necessity necessity NN 37231 962 33 which which WDT 37231 962 34 has have VBZ 37231 962 35 led lead VBN 37231 962 36 to to IN 37231 962 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 962 38 adoption adoption NN 37231 962 39 : : : 37231 962 40 " " `` 37231 962 41 You -PRON- PRP 37231 962 42 complain complain VBP 37231 962 43 , , , 37231 962 44 " " '' 37231 962 45 says say VBZ 37231 962 46 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 962 47 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 962 48 , , , 37231 962 49 writing write VBG 37231 962 50 to to IN 37231 962 51 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 962 52 Hawkins Hawkins NNP 37231 962 53 , , , 37231 962 54 " " `` 37231 962 55 of of IN 37231 962 56 those those DT 37231 962 57 persons person NNS 37231 962 58 who who WP 37231 962 59 judge judge VBP 37231 962 60 of of IN 37231 962 61 a a DT 37231 962 62 revelation revelation NN 37231 962 63 not not RB 37231 962 64 by by IN 37231 962 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 962 66 evidence evidence NN 37231 962 67 , , , 37231 962 68 but but CC 37231 962 69 by by IN 37231 962 70 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 962 71 substance substance NN 37231 962 72 . . . 37231 963 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 963 2 has have VBZ 37231 963 3 always always RB 37231 963 4 seemed seem VBN 37231 963 5 to to IN 37231 963 6 me -PRON- PRP 37231 963 7 that that IN 37231 963 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 963 9 substance substance NN 37231 963 10 is be VBZ 37231 963 11 a a DT 37231 963 12 most most RBS 37231 963 13 essential essential JJ 37231 963 14 part part NN 37231 963 15 of of IN 37231 963 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 963 17 evidence evidence NN 37231 963 18 ; ; , 37231 963 19 and and CC 37231 963 20 that that IN 37231 963 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 963 22 wrought work VBD 37231 963 23 in in IN 37231 963 24 favour favour NN 37231 963 25 of of IN 37231 963 26 what what WP 37231 963 27 was be VBD 37231 963 28 foolish foolish JJ 37231 963 29 or or CC 37231 963 30 wicked wicked JJ 37231 963 31 would would MD 37231 963 32 only only RB 37231 963 33 prove prove VB 37231 963 34 Manicheism Manicheism NNP 37231 963 35 . . . 37231 964 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 964 2 are be VBP 37231 964 3 so so RB 37231 964 4 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 964 5 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 964 6 of of IN 37231 964 7 the the DT 37231 964 8 unseen unseen JJ 37231 964 9 world world NN 37231 964 10 , , , 37231 964 11 that that IN 37231 964 12 the the DT 37231 964 13 character character NN 37231 964 14 of of IN 37231 964 15 any any DT 37231 964 16 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 964 17 power power NN 37231 964 18 can can MD 37231 964 19 only only RB 37231 964 20 be be VB 37231 964 21 judged judge VBN 37231 964 22 by by IN 37231 964 23 the the DT 37231 964 24 moral moral JJ 37231 964 25 character character NN 37231 964 26 of of IN 37231 964 27 the the DT 37231 964 28 statements statement NNS 37231 964 29 which which WDT 37231 964 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 964 31 sanctions sanction VBZ 37231 964 32 . . . 37231 965 1 Thus thus RB 37231 965 2 only only RB 37231 965 3 can can MD 37231 965 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 965 5 tell tell VB 37231 965 6 whether whether IN 37231 965 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 965 8 be be VB 37231 965 9 a a DT 37231 965 10 revelation revelation NN 37231 965 11 from from IN 37231 965 12 God God NNP 37231 965 13 or or CC 37231 965 14 from from IN 37231 965 15 the the DT 37231 965 16 Devil Devil NNP 37231 965 17 . . . 37231 966 1 " " `` 37231 966 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 966 3 2 2 LS 37231 966 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 966 5 In in IN 37231 966 6 another another DT 37231 966 7 place place NN 37231 966 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 966 9 Arnold Arnold NNP 37231 966 10 declares declare VBZ 37231 966 11 : : : 37231 966 12 " " `` 37231 966 13 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 966 14 must must MD 37231 966 15 not not RB 37231 966 16 be be VB 37231 966 17 allowed allow VBN 37231 966 18 to to TO 37231 966 19 overrule overrule VB 37231 966 20 the the DT 37231 966 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 966 22 ; ; : 37231 966 23 for for IN 37231 966 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 966 25 is be VBZ 37231 966 26 only only RB 37231 966 27 through through IN 37231 966 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 966 29 belief belief NN 37231 966 30 in in IN 37231 966 31 the the DT 37231 966 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 966 33 that that WDT 37231 966 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 966 35 accord accord VBP 37231 966 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 966 37 belief belief NN 37231 966 38 to to IN 37231 966 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 966 40 . . . 37231 967 1 " " `` 37231 967 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 967 3 3 3 LS 37231 967 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 967 5 { { -LRB- 37231 967 6 19 19 CD 37231 967 7 } } -RRB- 37231 967 8 It -PRON- PRP 37231 967 9 is be VBZ 37231 967 10 obvious obvious JJ 37231 967 11 that that IN 37231 967 12 the the DT 37231 967 13 mutual mutual JJ 37231 967 14 dependence dependence NN 37231 967 15 which which WDT 37231 967 16 is be VBZ 37231 967 17 thus thus RB 37231 967 18 established establish VBN 37231 967 19 between between IN 37231 967 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 967 21 and and CC 37231 967 22 the the DT 37231 967 23 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 967 24 in in IN 37231 967 25 connection connection NN 37231 967 26 with with IN 37231 967 27 which which WDT 37231 967 28 they -PRON- PRP 37231 967 29 are be VBP 37231 967 30 wrought work VBN 37231 967 31 destroys destroy VBZ 37231 967 32 the the DT 37231 967 33 evidential evidential JJ 37231 967 34 force force NN 37231 967 35 of of IN 37231 967 36 miracles miracle NNS 37231 967 37 , , , 37231 967 38 and and CC 37231 967 39 that that IN 37231 967 40 the the DT 37231 967 41 first first JJ 37231 967 42 and and CC 37231 967 43 the the DT 37231 967 44 final final JJ 37231 967 45 appeal appeal NN 37231 967 46 is be VBZ 37231 967 47 made make VBN 37231 967 48 to to TO 37231 967 49 reason reason NN 37231 967 50 . . . 37231 968 1 The the DT 37231 968 2 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 968 3 in in IN 37231 968 4 fact fact NN 37231 968 5 proves prove VBZ 37231 968 6 the the DT 37231 968 7 miracle miracle NN 37231 968 8 instead instead RB 37231 968 9 of of IN 37231 968 10 the the DT 37231 968 11 miracle miracle NN 37231 968 12 attesting attest VBG 37231 968 13 the the DT 37231 968 14 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 968 15 . . . 37231 969 1 Divines divine NNS 37231 969 2 of of IN 37231 969 3 course course NN 37231 969 4 attempt attempt NN 37231 969 5 to to TO 37231 969 6 deny deny VB 37231 969 7 this this DT 37231 969 8 , , , 37231 969 9 but but CC 37231 969 10 no no DT 37231 969 11 other other JJ 37231 969 12 deduction deduction NN 37231 969 13 from from IN 37231 969 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 969 15 own own JJ 37231 969 16 statements statement NNS 37231 969 17 is be VBZ 37231 969 18 logically logically RB 37231 969 19 possible possible JJ 37231 969 20 . . . 37231 970 1 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 970 2 , , , 37231 970 3 according accord VBG 37231 970 4 to to IN 37231 970 5 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 970 6 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 970 7 , , , 37231 970 8 are be VBP 37231 970 9 producible producible JJ 37231 970 10 by by IN 37231 970 11 various various JJ 37231 970 12 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 970 13 beings being NNS 37231 970 14 and and CC 37231 970 15 may may MD 37231 970 16 be be VB 37231 970 17 Satanic Satanic NNP 37231 970 18 as as RB 37231 970 19 well well RB 37231 970 20 as as IN 37231 970 21 Divine Divine NNP 37231 970 22 ; ; : 37231 970 23 man man NN 37231 970 24 , , , 37231 970 25 on on IN 37231 970 26 the the DT 37231 970 27 other other JJ 37231 970 28 hand hand NN 37231 970 29 , , , 37231 970 30 is be VBZ 37231 970 31 so so RB 37231 970 32 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 970 33 of of IN 37231 970 34 the the DT 37231 970 35 unseen unseen JJ 37231 970 36 world world NN 37231 970 37 that that IN 37231 970 38 avowedly avowedly RB 37231 970 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 970 40 can can MD 37231 970 41 not not RB 37231 970 42 , , , 37231 970 43 from from IN 37231 970 44 the the DT 37231 970 45 miracle miracle NN 37231 970 46 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 970 47 , , , 37231 970 48 determine determine VB 37231 970 49 the the DT 37231 970 50 agent agent NN 37231 970 51 by by IN 37231 970 52 whom whom WP 37231 970 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 970 54 was be VBD 37231 970 55 performed;(l performed;(l NN 37231 970 56 ) ) -RRB- 37231 970 57 the the DT 37231 970 58 miracle miracle NN 37231 970 59 , , , 37231 970 60 therefore therefore RB 37231 970 61 , , , 37231 970 62 has have VBZ 37231 970 63 no no DT 37231 970 64 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 37231 970 65 evidential evidential JJ 37231 970 66 value value NN 37231 970 67 . . . 37231 971 1 How how WRB 37231 971 2 , , , 37231 971 3 then then RB 37231 971 4 , , , 37231 971 5 according accord VBG 37231 971 6 to to IN 37231 971 7 divines divine NNS 37231 971 8 , , , 37231 971 9 does do VBZ 37231 971 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 971 11 attain attain VB 37231 971 12 any any DT 37231 971 13 potentiality potentiality NN 37231 971 14 ? ? . 37231 972 1 Only only RB 37231 972 2 through through IN 37231 972 3 a a DT 37231 972 4 favourable favourable JJ 37231 972 5 decision decision NN 37231 972 6 on on IN 37231 972 7 the the DT 37231 972 8 part part NN 37231 972 9 of of IN 37231 972 10 Reason Reason NNP 37231 972 11 or or CC 37231 972 12 the the DT 37231 972 13 " " `` 37231 972 14 moral moral JJ 37231 972 15 nature nature NN 37231 972 16 in in IN 37231 972 17 man man NN 37231 972 18 " " '' 37231 972 19 regarding regard VBG 37231 972 20 the the DT 37231 972 21 { { -LRB- 37231 972 22 20 20 CD 37231 972 23 } } -RRB- 37231 972 24 character character NN 37231 972 25 of of IN 37231 972 26 the the DT 37231 972 27 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 972 28 . . . 37231 973 1 The the DT 37231 973 2 result result NN 37231 973 3 of of IN 37231 973 4 the the DT 37231 973 5 appeal appeal NN 37231 973 6 to to IN 37231 973 7 Reason reason NN 37231 973 8 respecting respect VBG 37231 973 9 the the DT 37231 973 10 morality morality NN 37231 973 11 and and CC 37231 973 12 credibility credibility NN 37231 973 13 of of IN 37231 973 14 the the DT 37231 973 15 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 973 16 determines determine VBZ 37231 973 17 the the DT 37231 973 18 evidential evidential JJ 37231 973 19 status status NN 37231 973 20 of of IN 37231 973 21 the the DT 37231 973 22 miracle miracle NN 37231 973 23 . . . 37231 974 1 The the DT 37231 974 2 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 974 3 , , , 37231 974 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 974 5 , , , 37231 974 6 is be VBZ 37231 974 7 the the DT 37231 974 8 real real JJ 37231 974 9 criterion criterion NN 37231 974 10 of of IN 37231 974 11 the the DT 37231 974 12 miracle miracle NN 37231 974 13 which which WDT 37231 974 14 , , , 37231 974 15 without without IN 37231 974 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 974 17 , , , 37231 974 18 is be VBZ 37231 974 19 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 974 20 an an DT 37231 974 21 object object NN 37231 974 22 of of IN 37231 974 23 doubt doubt NN 37231 974 24 and and CC 37231 974 25 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 974 26 . . . 37231 975 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 975 2 have have VBP 37231 975 3 already already RB 37231 975 4 casually casually RB 37231 975 5 referred refer VBN 37231 975 6 to to IN 37231 975 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 975 8 Newman Newman NNP 37231 975 9 's 's POS 37231 975 10 view view NN 37231 975 11 of of IN 37231 975 12 such such PDT 37231 975 13 a a DT 37231 975 14 relation relation NN 37231 975 15 between between IN 37231 975 16 Miracle Miracle NNP 37231 975 17 and and CC 37231 975 18 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 975 19 , , , 37231 975 20 but but CC 37231 975 21 may may MD 37231 975 22 here here RB 37231 975 23 more more RBR 37231 975 24 fully fully RB 37231 975 25 quote quote VB 37231 975 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 975 27 suggestive suggestive JJ 37231 975 28 remarks remark NNS 37231 975 29 . . . 37231 976 1 " " `` 37231 976 2 Others other NNS 37231 976 3 by by IN 37231 976 4 referring refer VBG 37231 976 5 to to IN 37231 976 6 the the DT 37231 976 7 nature nature NN 37231 976 8 of of IN 37231 976 9 the the DT 37231 976 10 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 976 11 attested attest VBD 37231 976 12 , , , 37231 976 13 " " '' 37231 976 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 976 15 says say VBZ 37231 976 16 , , , 37231 976 17 " " `` 37231 976 18 in in IN 37231 976 19 order order NN 37231 976 20 to to TO 37231 976 21 determine determine VB 37231 976 22 the the DT 37231 976 23 author author NN 37231 976 24 of of IN 37231 976 25 the the DT 37231 976 26 miracle miracle NN 37231 976 27 , , , 37231 976 28 have have VBP 37231 976 29 exposed expose VBN 37231 976 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 976 31 to to IN 37231 976 32 the the DT 37231 976 33 plausible plausible JJ 37231 976 34 charge charge NN 37231 976 35 of of IN 37231 976 36 adducing adducing NN 37231 976 37 , , , 37231 976 38 first first RB 37231 976 39 the the DT 37231 976 40 miracle miracle NN 37231 976 41 to to TO 37231 976 42 attest attest VB 37231 976 43 the the DT 37231 976 44 divinity divinity NN 37231 976 45 of of IN 37231 976 46 the the DT 37231 976 47 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 976 48 , , , 37231 976 49 and and CC 37231 976 50 then then RB 37231 976 51 the the DT 37231 976 52 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 976 53 to to TO 37231 976 54 prove prove VB 37231 976 55 the the DT 37231 976 56 divinity divinity NN 37231 976 57 of of IN 37231 976 58 the the DT 37231 976 59 Miracle Miracle NNP 37231 976 60 . . . 37231 977 1 " " `` 37231 977 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 977 3 1 1 LS 37231 977 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 977 5 This this DT 37231 977 6 argument argument NN 37231 977 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 977 8 characterizes characterize VBZ 37231 977 9 as as IN 37231 977 10 one one CD 37231 977 11 of of IN 37231 977 12 the the DT 37231 977 13 " " `` 37231 977 14 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 977 15 modes mode NNS 37231 977 16 " " '' 37231 977 17 of of IN 37231 977 18 removing remove VBG 37231 977 19 a a DT 37231 977 20 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 977 21 , , , 37231 977 22 although although IN 37231 977 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 977 24 does do VBZ 37231 977 25 not not RB 37231 977 26 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 977 27 point point VB 37231 977 28 out out RP 37231 977 29 a a DT 37231 977 30 safer safe JJR 37231 977 31 , , , 37231 977 32 and and CC 37231 977 33 , , , 37231 977 34 in in IN 37231 977 35 a a DT 37231 977 36 note note NN 37231 977 37 , , , 37231 977 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 977 39 adds add VBZ 37231 977 40 : : : 37231 977 41 " " `` 37231 977 42 There there EX 37231 977 43 is be VBZ 37231 977 44 an an DT 37231 977 45 appearance appearance NN 37231 977 46 of of IN 37231 977 47 doing do VBG 37231 977 48 honour honour NN 37231 977 49 to to IN 37231 977 50 the the DT 37231 977 51 Christian christian JJ 37231 977 52 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 977 53 in in IN 37231 977 54 representing represent VBG 37231 977 55 them -PRON- PRP 37231 977 56 as as IN 37231 977 57 _ _ NNP 37231 977 58 intrinsically intrinsically RB 37231 977 59 _ _ NNP 37231 977 60 credible credible JJ 37231 977 61 , , , 37231 977 62 which which WDT 37231 977 63 leads lead VBZ 37231 977 64 many many JJ 37231 977 65 into into IN 37231 977 66 supporting support VBG 37231 977 67 opinions opinion NNS 37231 977 68 which which WDT 37231 977 69 , , , 37231 977 70 carried carry VBD 37231 977 71 to to IN 37231 977 72 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 977 73 full full JJ 37231 977 74 extent extent NN 37231 977 75 , , , 37231 977 76 supersede supersede VB 37231 977 77 the the DT 37231 977 78 need need NN 37231 977 79 of of IN 37231 977 80 Miracles Miracles NNPS 37231 977 81 altogether altogether RB 37231 977 82 . . . 37231 978 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 978 2 must must MD 37231 978 3 be be VB 37231 978 4 recollected recollect VBN 37231 978 5 , , , 37231 978 6 too too RB 37231 978 7 , , , 37231 978 8 that that IN 37231 978 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 978 10 who who WP 37231 978 11 are be VBP 37231 978 12 allowed allow VBN 37231 978 13 to to TO 37231 978 14 praise praise VB 37231 978 15 have have VB 37231 978 16 the the DT 37231 978 17 privilege privilege NN 37231 978 18 of of IN 37231 978 19 finding find VBG 37231 978 20 fault fault NN 37231 978 21 , , , 37231 978 22 and and CC 37231 978 23 may may MD 37231 978 24 reject reject VB 37231 978 25 , , , 37231 978 26 according accord VBG 37231 978 27 to to IN 37231 978 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 978 29 _ _ NNP 37231 978 30 á á PRP 37231 978 31 priori priori FW 37231 978 32 _ _ NNP 37231 978 33 notions notion NNS 37231 978 34 , , , 37231 978 35 as as RB 37231 978 36 well well RB 37231 978 37 as as IN 37231 978 38 receive receive VB 37231 978 39 . . . 37231 979 1 Doubtless doubtless RB 37231 979 2 the the DT 37231 979 3 divinity divinity NN 37231 979 4 of of IN 37231 979 5 a a DT 37231 979 6 clearly clearly RB 37231 979 7 immoral immoral JJ 37231 979 8 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 979 9 could could MD 37231 979 10 not not RB 37231 979 11 be be VB 37231 979 12 evidenced evidence VBN 37231 979 13 by by IN 37231 979 14 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 979 15 ; ; : 37231 979 16 for for IN 37231 979 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 979 18 belief belief NN 37231 979 19 in in IN 37231 979 20 the the DT 37231 979 21 moral moral JJ 37231 979 22 attributes attribute NNS 37231 979 23 of of IN 37231 979 24 God God NNP 37231 979 25 is be VBZ 37231 979 26 much much RB 37231 979 27 stronger strong JJR 37231 979 28 than than IN 37231 979 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 979 30 conviction conviction NN 37231 979 31 of of IN 37231 979 32 the the DT 37231 979 33 negative negative JJ 37231 979 34 proposition proposition NN 37231 979 35 , , , 37231 979 36 that that IN 37231 979 37 none none NN 37231 979 38 but but CC 37231 979 39 He -PRON- PRP 37231 979 40 can can MD 37231 979 41 interfere interfere VB 37231 979 42 with with IN 37231 979 43 the the DT 37231 979 44 system system NN 37231 979 45 of of IN 37231 979 46 nature nature NN 37231 979 47 . . . 37231 980 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 980 2 3 3 LS 37231 980 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 980 4 But but CC 37231 980 5 there there EX 37231 980 6 is be VBZ 37231 980 7 always always RB 37231 980 8 { { -LRB- 37231 980 9 21 21 CD 37231 980 10 } } -RRB- 37231 980 11 the the DT 37231 980 12 danger danger NN 37231 980 13 of of IN 37231 980 14 extending extend VBG 37231 980 15 this this DT 37231 980 16 admission admission NN 37231 980 17 beyond beyond IN 37231 980 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 980 19 proper proper JJ 37231 980 20 limits limit NNS 37231 980 21 , , , 37231 980 22 of of IN 37231 980 23 supposing suppose VBG 37231 980 24 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 980 25 adequate adequate JJ 37231 980 26 judges judge NNS 37231 980 27 of of IN 37231 980 28 the the DT 37231 980 29 _ _ NNP 37231 980 30 tendency tendency NN 37231 980 31 _ _ NNP 37231 980 32 of of IN 37231 980 33 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 980 34 ; ; : 37231 980 35 and and CC 37231 980 36 , , , 37231 980 37 because because IN 37231 980 38 unassisted unassisted JJ 37231 980 39 Reason reason NN 37231 980 40 informs inform VBZ 37231 980 41 us -PRON- PRP 37231 980 42 what what WP 37231 980 43 is be VBZ 37231 980 44 moral moral JJ 37231 980 45 and and CC 37231 980 46 immoral immoral JJ 37231 980 47 in in IN 37231 980 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 980 49 own own JJ 37231 980 50 case case NN 37231 980 51 , , , 37231 980 52 of of IN 37231 980 53 attempting attempt VBG 37231 980 54 to to TO 37231 980 55 decide decide VB 37231 980 56 on on IN 37231 980 57 the the DT 37231 980 58 abstract abstract JJ 37231 980 59 morality morality NN 37231 980 60 of of IN 37231 980 61 actions action NNS 37231 980 62 ; ; , 37231 980 63 ... ... : 37231 981 1 These these DT 37231 981 2 remarks remark NNS 37231 981 3 are be VBP 37231 981 4 in in IN 37231 981 5 nowise nowise NN 37231 981 6 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37231 981 7 with with IN 37231 981 8 using use VBG 37231 981 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 981 10 as as IN 37231 981 11 was be VBD 37231 981 12 done do VBN 37231 981 13 in in IN 37231 981 14 a a DT 37231 981 15 former former JJ 37231 981 16 section section NN 37231 981 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 981 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 981 19 actual actual JJ 37231 981 20 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 981 21 of of IN 37231 981 22 God God NNP 37231 981 23 's 's POS 37231 981 24 attributes attribute NNS 37231 981 25 , , , 37231 981 26 obtained obtain VBN 37231 981 27 from from IN 37231 981 28 a a DT 37231 981 29 survey survey NN 37231 981 30 of of IN 37231 981 31 nature nature NN 37231 981 32 and and CC 37231 981 33 human human JJ 37231 981 34 affairs affair NNS 37231 981 35 , , , 37231 981 36 in in IN 37231 981 37 determining determine VBG 37231 981 38 the the DT 37231 981 39 probability probability NN 37231 981 40 of of IN 37231 981 41 certain certain JJ 37231 981 42 professed professed JJ 37231 981 43 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 981 44 having have VBG 37231 981 45 proceeded proceed VBN 37231 981 46 from from IN 37231 981 47 Him -PRON- PRP 37231 981 48 . . . 37231 982 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 982 2 is be VBZ 37231 982 3 one one CD 37231 982 4 thing thing NN 37231 982 5 to to TO 37231 982 6 infer infer VB 37231 982 7 from from IN 37231 982 8 the the DT 37231 982 9 experience experience NN 37231 982 10 of of IN 37231 982 11 life life NN 37231 982 12 , , , 37231 982 13 another another DT 37231 982 14 to to TO 37231 982 15 imagine imagine VB 37231 982 16 the the DT 37231 982 17 character character NN 37231 982 18 of of IN 37231 982 19 God God NNP 37231 982 20 from from IN 37231 982 21 the the DT 37231 982 22 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 37231 982 23 conceptions conception NNS 37231 982 24 of of IN 37231 982 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 982 26 own own JJ 37231 982 27 minds mind NNS 37231 982 28 . . . 37231 983 1 " " `` 37231 983 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 983 3 1 1 LS 37231 983 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 983 5 Although although IN 37231 983 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 983 7 Newman Newman NNP 37231 983 8 apparently apparently RB 37231 983 9 fails fail VBZ 37231 983 10 to to TO 37231 983 11 perceive perceive VB 37231 983 12 that that IN 37231 983 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 983 14 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 983 15 thus thus RB 37231 983 16 makes make VBZ 37231 983 17 reason reason NN 37231 983 18 the the DT 37231 983 19 criterion criterion NN 37231 983 20 of of IN 37231 983 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 983 22 and and CC 37231 983 23 therefore therefore RB 37231 983 24 incurs incur VBZ 37231 983 25 the the DT 37231 983 26 condemnation condemnation NN 37231 983 27 with with IN 37231 983 28 which which WDT 37231 983 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 983 30 quotation quotation NN 37231 983 31 opens open VBZ 37231 983 32 , , , 37231 983 33 the the DT 37231 983 34 very very JJ 37231 983 35 indecision indecision NN 37231 983 36 of of IN 37231 983 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 983 38 argument argument NN 37231 983 39 illustrates illustrate VBZ 37231 983 40 the the DT 37231 983 41 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 983 42 in in IN 37231 983 43 which which WDT 37231 983 44 divines divine NNS 37231 983 45 are be VBP 37231 983 46 placed place VBN 37231 983 47 . . . 37231 984 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 984 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 984 3 , , , 37231 984 4 however however RB 37231 984 5 , , , 37231 984 6 still still RB 37231 984 7 more more RBR 37231 984 8 directly directly RB 37231 984 9 condemns condemn VBZ 37231 984 10 the the DT 37231 984 11 principle principle NN 37231 984 12 which which WDT 37231 984 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 984 14 are be VBP 37231 984 15 discussing discuss VBG 37231 984 16 -- -- : 37231 984 17 that that IN 37231 984 18 the the DT 37231 984 19 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 984 20 must must MD 37231 984 21 be be VB 37231 984 22 the the DT 37231 984 23 criterion criterion NN 37231 984 24 of of IN 37231 984 25 the the DT 37231 984 26 miracle miracle NN 37231 984 27 -- -- : 37231 984 28 although although IN 37231 984 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 984 30 also also RB 37231 984 31 , , , 37231 984 32 as as IN 37231 984 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 984 34 have have VBP 37231 984 35 purposes purpose NNS 37231 984 36 for for IN 37231 984 37 which which WDT 37231 984 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 984 39 never never RB 37231 984 40 was be VBD 37231 984 41 intended intend VBN 37231 984 42 , , , 37231 984 43 and and CC 37231 984 44 is be VBZ 37231 984 45 unfitted unfitted JJ 37231 984 46 . . . 37231 985 1 To to TO 37231 985 2 rationalise rationalise VB 37231 985 3 in in IN 37231 985 4 matters matter NNS 37231 985 5 of of IN 37231 985 6 Revelation revelation NN 37231 985 7 is be VBZ 37231 985 8 to to TO 37231 985 9 make make VB 37231 985 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 985 11 reason reason NN 37231 985 12 the the DT 37231 985 13 standard standard NN 37231 985 14 and and CC 37231 985 15 measure measure NN 37231 985 16 of of IN 37231 985 17 the the DT 37231 985 18 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 985 19 revealed reveal VBN 37231 985 20 ; ; : 37231 985 21 to to TO 37231 985 22 stipulate stipulate VB 37231 985 23 that that IN 37231 985 24 those those DT 37231 985 25 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 985 26 should should MD 37231 985 27 be be VB 37231 985 28 such such JJ 37231 985 29 as as IN 37231 985 30 to to TO 37231 985 31 carry carry VB 37231 985 32 with with IN 37231 985 33 them -PRON- PRP 37231 985 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 985 35 own own JJ 37231 985 36 justification justification NN 37231 985 37 ; ; : 37231 985 38 to to TO 37231 985 39 reject reject VB 37231 985 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 985 41 , , , 37231 985 42 if if IN 37231 985 43 they -PRON- PRP 37231 985 44 come come VBP 37231 985 45 in in IN 37231 985 46 collision collision NN 37231 985 47 with with IN 37231 985 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 985 49 existing exist VBG 37231 985 50 opinions opinion NNS 37231 985 51 or or CC 37231 985 52 habits habit NNS 37231 985 53 of of IN 37231 985 54 thought thought NN 37231 985 55 , , , 37231 985 56 or or CC 37231 985 57 are be VBP 37231 985 58 with with IN 37231 985 59 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 985 60 harmonised harmonise VBN 37231 985 61 with with IN 37231 985 62 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 985 63 existing exist VBG 37231 985 64 stock stock NN 37231 985 65 of of IN 37231 985 66 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 985 67 " " '' 37231 985 68 ( ( -LRB- 37231 985 69 Essays Essays NNP 37231 985 70 , , , 37231 985 71 Crit Crit NNP 37231 985 72 . . . 37231 986 1 and and CC 37231 986 2 Hist Hist NNP 37231 986 3 . . NNP 37231 986 4 , , , 37231 986 5 1872 1872 CD 37231 986 6 , , , 37231 986 7 vol vol NNP 37231 986 8 . . . 37231 987 1 i. i. NNP 37231 987 2 p. p. NNP 37231 987 3 31 31 CD 37231 987 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 987 5 ; ; : 37231 987 6 and and CC 37231 987 7 a a DT 37231 987 8 little little JJ 37231 987 9 further far RBR 37231 987 10 on on RB 37231 987 11 : : : 37231 987 12 " " `` 37231 987 13 A a DT 37231 987 14 like like JJ 37231 987 15 desire desire NN 37231 987 16 of of IN 37231 987 17 judging judge VBG 37231 987 18 for for IN 37231 987 19 one one NN 37231 987 20 's 's POS 37231 987 21 self self NN 37231 987 22 is be VBZ 37231 987 23 discernible discernible JJ 37231 987 24 in in IN 37231 987 25 the the DT 37231 987 26 original original JJ 37231 987 27 fall fall NN 37231 987 28 of of IN 37231 987 29 man man NN 37231 987 30 . . . 37231 988 1 Eve Eve NNP 37231 988 2 did do VBD 37231 988 3 not not RB 37231 988 4 believe believe VB 37231 988 5 the the DT 37231 988 6 Tempter tempter NN 37231 988 7 any any DT 37231 988 8 more more RBR 37231 988 9 than than IN 37231 988 10 God God NNP 37231 988 11 's 's POS 37231 988 12 word word NN 37231 988 13 , , , 37231 988 14 till till IN 37231 988 15 she -PRON- PRP 37231 988 16 perceived perceive VBD 37231 988 17 « « `` 37231 988 18 the the DT 37231 988 19 fruit fruit NN 37231 988 20 was be VBD 37231 988 21 good good JJ 37231 988 22 for for IN 37231 988 23 food food NN 37231 988 24 ' ' '' 37231 988 25 " " '' 37231 988 26 ( ( -LRB- 37231 988 27 76 76 CD 37231 988 28 . . CD 37231 988 29 , , , 37231 988 30 p. p. NN 37231 988 31 33 33 CD 37231 988 32 ) ) -RRB- 37231 988 33 . . . 37231 989 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 989 2 Newman Newman NNP 37231 989 3 , , , 37231 989 4 of of IN 37231 989 5 course course NN 37231 989 6 , , , 37231 989 7 wishes wish VBZ 37231 989 8 to to TO 37231 989 9 limit limit VB 37231 989 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 989 11 principle principle NN 37231 989 12 precisely precisely RB 37231 989 13 to to TO 37231 989 14 suit suit VB 37231 989 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 989 16 own own JJ 37231 989 17 convenience convenience NN 37231 989 18 , , , 37231 989 19 but but CC 37231 989 20 in in IN 37231 989 21 permitting permit VBG 37231 989 22 the the DT 37231 989 23 rejection rejection NN 37231 989 24 of of IN 37231 989 25 a a DT 37231 989 26 supposed suppose VBN 37231 989 27 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 989 28 in in IN 37231 989 29 spite spite NN 37231 989 30 of of IN 37231 989 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 989 32 , , , 37231 989 33 on on IN 37231 989 34 the the DT 37231 989 35 ground ground NN 37231 989 36 of of IN 37231 989 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 989 38 disapproval disapproval NN 37231 989 39 of of IN 37231 989 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 989 41 morality morality NN 37231 989 42 , , , 37231 989 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 989 44 is be VBZ 37231 989 45 obvious obvious JJ 37231 989 46 that that IN 37231 989 47 the the DT 37231 989 48 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 989 49 is be VBZ 37231 989 50 substantially substantially RB 37231 989 51 made make VBN 37231 989 52 the the DT 37231 989 53 final final JJ 37231 989 54 criterion criterion NN 37231 989 55 of of IN 37231 989 56 the the DT 37231 989 57 miracle miracle NN 37231 989 58 . . . 37231 990 1 { { -LRB- 37231 990 2 22 22 CD 37231 990 3 } } -RRB- 37231 990 4 seen see VBN 37231 990 5 , , , 37231 990 6 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 990 7 substantially substantially RB 37231 990 8 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 990 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 990 10 . . . 37231 991 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 991 2 says say VBZ 37231 991 3 : : : 37231 991 4 " " `` 37231 991 5 The the DT 37231 991 6 position position NN 37231 991 7 that that WDT 37231 991 8 the the DT 37231 991 9 revelation revelation NN 37231 991 10 proves prove VBZ 37231 991 11 the the DT 37231 991 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 991 13 , , , 37231 991 14 and and CC 37231 991 15 not not RB 37231 991 16 the the DT 37231 991 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 991 18 the the DT 37231 991 19 revelation revelation NN 37231 991 20 , , , 37231 991 21 admits admit VBZ 37231 991 22 of of IN 37231 991 23 a a DT 37231 991 24 good good JJ 37231 991 25 qualified qualified JJ 37231 991 26 meaning meaning NN 37231 991 27 ; ; : 37231 991 28 but but CC 37231 991 29 taken take VBN 37231 991 30 literally literally RB 37231 991 31 , , , 37231 991 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 991 33 is be VBZ 37231 991 34 a a DT 37231 991 35 double double JJ 37231 991 36 offence offence NN 37231 991 37 against against IN 37231 991 38 the the DT 37231 991 39 rule rule NN 37231 991 40 , , , 37231 991 41 that that IN 37231 991 42 things thing NNS 37231 991 43 are be VBP 37231 991 44 properly properly RB 37231 991 45 proved prove VBN 37231 991 46 by by IN 37231 991 47 the the DT 37231 991 48 proper proper JJ 37231 991 49 proof proof NN 37231 991 50 of of IN 37231 991 51 them -PRON- PRP 37231 991 52 ; ; : 37231 991 53 for for IN 37231 991 54 a a DT 37231 991 55 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 991 56 fact fact NN 37231 991 57 _ _ NNP 37231 991 58 is be VBZ 37231 991 59 _ _ NNP 37231 991 60 the the DT 37231 991 61 proper proper JJ 37231 991 62 proof proof NN 37231 991 63 of of IN 37231 991 64 a a DT 37231 991 65 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 991 66 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 991 67 ; ; : 37231 991 68 while while IN 37231 991 69 a a DT 37231 991 70 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 991 71 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 991 72 , , , 37231 991 73 on on IN 37231 991 74 the the DT 37231 991 75 other other JJ 37231 991 76 hand hand NN 37231 991 77 , , , 37231 991 78 is be VBZ 37231 991 79 certainly certainly RB 37231 991 80 _ _ NNP 37231 991 81 not not RB 37231 991 82 _ _ NNP 37231 991 83 the the DT 37231 991 84 proper proper JJ 37231 991 85 proof proof NN 37231 991 86 of of IN 37231 991 87 a a DT 37231 991 88 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 991 89 fact"(1 fact"(1 NNP 37231 991 90 ) ) -RRB- 37231 991 91 This this DT 37231 991 92 statement statement NN 37231 991 93 is be VBZ 37231 991 94 obviously obviously RB 37231 991 95 true true JJ 37231 991 96 , , , 37231 991 97 but but CC 37231 991 98 it -PRON- PRP 37231 991 99 is be VBZ 37231 991 100 equally equally RB 37231 991 101 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 991 102 that that IN 37231 991 103 , , , 37231 991 104 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 991 105 origin origin NN 37231 991 106 being be VBG 37231 991 107 uncertain uncertain JJ 37231 991 108 , , , 37231 991 109 miracles miracle NNS 37231 991 110 have have VBP 37231 991 111 no no DT 37231 991 112 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 991 113 evidential evidential JJ 37231 991 114 force force NN 37231 991 115 . . . 37231 992 1 How how WRB 37231 992 2 far far RB 37231 992 3 , , , 37231 992 4 then then RB 37231 992 5 , , , 37231 992 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 992 7 may may MD 37231 992 8 inquire inquire VB 37231 992 9 in in IN 37231 992 10 order order NN 37231 992 11 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 992 12 to to TO 37231 992 13 understand understand VB 37231 992 14 the the DT 37231 992 15 position position NN 37231 992 16 , , , 37231 992 17 can can MD 37231 992 18 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 992 19 prove prove VB 37231 992 20 the the DT 37231 992 21 reality reality NN 37231 992 22 of of IN 37231 992 23 miracles miracle NNS 37231 992 24 or or CC 37231 992 25 determine determine VB 37231 992 26 the the DT 37231 992 27 agency agency NN 37231 992 28 by by IN 37231 992 29 which which WDT 37231 992 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 992 31 are be VBP 37231 992 32 performed perform VBN 37231 992 33 ? ? . 37231 993 1 In in IN 37231 993 2 the the DT 37231 993 3 case case NN 37231 993 4 of of IN 37231 993 5 moral moral JJ 37231 993 6 truths truth NNS 37231 993 7 within within IN 37231 993 8 the the DT 37231 993 9 limits limit NNS 37231 993 10 of of IN 37231 993 11 reason reason NN 37231 993 12 , , , 37231 993 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 993 14 is be VBZ 37231 993 15 evident evident JJ 37231 993 16 that that IN 37231 993 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 993 18 which which WDT 37231 993 19 are be VBP 37231 993 20 in in IN 37231 993 21 accordance accordance NN 37231 993 22 with with IN 37231 993 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 993 24 ideas idea NNS 37231 993 25 of of IN 37231 993 26 what what WP 37231 993 27 is be VBZ 37231 993 28 good good JJ 37231 993 29 and and CC 37231 993 30 right right JJ 37231 993 31 do do VBP 37231 993 32 not not RB 37231 993 33 require require VB 37231 993 34 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 993 35 evidence evidence NN 37231 993 36 at at RB 37231 993 37 all all RB 37231 993 38 . . . 37231 994 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 994 2 can can MD 37231 994 3 secure secure VB 37231 994 4 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 994 5 by by IN 37231 994 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 994 7 own own JJ 37231 994 8 merits merit NNS 37231 994 9 alone alone JJ 37231 994 10 . . . 37231 995 1 At at IN 37231 995 2 the the DT 37231 995 3 same same JJ 37231 995 4 time time NN 37231 995 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 995 6 is be VBZ 37231 995 7 universally universally RB 37231 995 8 admitted admit VBN 37231 995 9 that that IN 37231 995 10 the the DT 37231 995 11 truth truth NN 37231 995 12 or or CC 37231 995 13 goodness goodness NN 37231 995 14 of of IN 37231 995 15 a a DT 37231 995 16 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 995 17 is be VBZ 37231 995 18 in in IN 37231 995 19 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 995 20 no no DT 37231 995 21 proof proof NN 37231 995 22 that that IN 37231 995 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 995 24 emanates emanate VBZ 37231 995 25 directly directly RB 37231 995 26 from from IN 37231 995 27 God God NNP 37231 995 28 , , , 37231 995 29 and and CC 37231 995 30 consequently consequently RB 37231 995 31 the the DT 37231 995 32 most most RBS 37231 995 33 obvious obvious JJ 37231 995 34 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 995 35 and and CC 37231 995 36 beauty beauty NN 37231 995 37 in in IN 37231 995 38 the the DT 37231 995 39 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 995 40 could could MD 37231 995 41 not not RB 37231 995 42 attest attest VB 37231 995 43 the the DT 37231 995 44 divine divine JJ 37231 995 45 origin origin NN 37231 995 46 of of IN 37231 995 47 a a DT 37231 995 48 miracle miracle NN 37231 995 49 . . . 37231 996 1 Such such JJ 37231 996 2 truths truth NNS 37231 996 3 , , , 37231 996 4 however however RB 37231 996 5 , , , 37231 996 6 have have VBP 37231 996 7 no no DT 37231 996 8 proper proper JJ 37231 996 9 connection connection NN 37231 996 10 with with IN 37231 996 11 revelation revelation NN 37231 996 12 at at RB 37231 996 13 all all RB 37231 996 14 . . . 37231 997 1 " " `` 37231 997 2 _ _ NNP 37231 997 3 These these DT 37231 997 4 _ _ NNP 37231 997 5 truths truth NNS 37231 997 6 , , , 37231 997 7 " " '' 37231 997 8 to to TO 37231 997 9 quote quote VB 37231 997 10 the the DT 37231 997 11 words word NNS 37231 997 12 of of IN 37231 997 13 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 997 14 Atterbury Atterbury NNP 37231 997 15 , , , 37231 997 16 " " '' 37231 997 17 were be VBD 37231 997 18 of of IN 37231 997 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 997 20 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 997 21 obvious obvious JJ 37231 997 22 and and CC 37231 997 23 plain plain JJ 37231 997 24 , , , 37231 997 25 and and CC 37231 997 26 needed need VBD 37231 997 27 not not RB 37231 997 28 a a DT 37231 997 29 Divine Divine NNP 37231 997 30 Testimony Testimony NNP 37231 997 31 to to TO 37231 997 32 make make VB 37231 997 33 them -PRON- PRP 37231 997 34 plainer plainer NN 37231 997 35 . . . 37231 998 1 But but CC 37231 998 2 the the DT 37231 998 3 Truths truth NNS 37231 998 4 which which WDT 37231 998 5 are be VBP 37231 998 6 necessary necessary JJ 37231 998 7 in in IN 37231 998 8 this this DT 37231 998 9 Manner Manner NNP 37231 998 10 to to TO 37231 998 11 be be VB 37231 998 12 attested attest VBN 37231 998 13 , , , 37231 998 14 are be VBP 37231 998 15 those those DT 37231 998 16 which which WDT 37231 998 17 are be VBP 37231 998 18 of of IN 37231 998 19 Positive Positive NNP 37231 998 20 Institution Institution NNP 37231 998 21 ; ; : 37231 998 22 those those DT 37231 998 23 , , , 37231 998 24 which which WDT 37231 998 25 if if IN 37231 998 26 God God NNP 37231 998 27 had have VBD 37231 998 28 not not RB 37231 998 29 pleased pleased JJ 37231 998 30 to to TO 37231 998 31 reveal reveal VB 37231 998 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 998 33 , , , 37231 998 34 Human Human NNP 37231 998 35 Reason Reason NNP 37231 998 36 could could MD 37231 998 37 not not RB 37231 998 38 { { -LRB- 37231 998 39 23 23 CD 37231 998 40 } } -RRB- 37231 998 41 have have VBP 37231 998 42 discovered discover VBN 37231 998 43 ; ; : 37231 998 44 and and CC 37231 998 45 those those DT 37231 998 46 , , , 37231 998 47 which which WDT 37231 998 48 , , , 37231 998 49 even even RB 37231 998 50 now now RB 37231 998 51 they -PRON- PRP 37231 998 52 are be VBP 37231 998 53 revealed reveal VBN 37231 998 54 , , , 37231 998 55 Human Human NNP 37231 998 56 Reason Reason NNP 37231 998 57 can can MD 37231 998 58 not not RB 37231 998 59 fully fully RB 37231 998 60 account account VB 37231 998 61 for for IN 37231 998 62 , , , 37231 998 63 and and CC 37231 998 64 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 998 65 comprehend comprehend VB 37231 998 66 . . . 37231 999 1 " " `` 37231 999 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 999 3 1 1 LS 37231 999 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 999 5 How how WRB 37231 999 6 is be VBZ 37231 999 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 999 8 possible possible JJ 37231 999 9 then then RB 37231 999 10 that that DT 37231 999 11 Reason reason NN 37231 999 12 or or CC 37231 999 13 " " `` 37231 999 14 the the DT 37231 999 15 moral moral JJ 37231 999 16 nature nature NN 37231 999 17 in in IN 37231 999 18 man man NN 37231 999 19 " " '' 37231 999 20 can can MD 37231 999 21 approve approve VB 37231 999 22 as as RB 37231 999 23 good good JJ 37231 999 24 , , , 37231 999 25 or or CC 37231 999 26 appreciate appreciate VBP 37231 999 27 the the DT 37231 999 28 fitness fitness NN 37231 999 29 of of IN 37231 999 30 , , , 37231 999 31 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 999 32 which which WDT 37231 999 33 in in IN 37231 999 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 999 35 very very JJ 37231 999 36 nature nature NN 37231 999 37 are be VBP 37231 999 38 beyond beyond IN 37231 999 39 the the DT 37231 999 40 criterion criterion NN 37231 999 41 of of IN 37231 999 42 reason reason NN 37231 999 43 ? ? . 37231 1000 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1000 2 2 2 LS 37231 1000 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1000 4 What what WP 37231 1000 5 reply reply NN 37231 1000 6 , , , 37231 1000 7 for for IN 37231 1000 8 instance instance NN 37231 1000 9 , , , 37231 1000 10 can can MD 37231 1000 11 reason reason NN 37231 1000 12 give give VB 37231 1000 13 to to IN 37231 1000 14 any any DT 37231 1000 15 appeal appeal NN 37231 1000 16 to to IN 37231 1000 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1000 18 regarding regard VBG 37231 1000 19 the the DT 37231 1000 20 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1000 21 of of IN 37231 1000 22 the the DT 37231 1000 23 Trinity Trinity NNP 37231 1000 24 or or CC 37231 1000 25 of of IN 37231 1000 26 the the DT 37231 1000 27 Incarnation Incarnation NNP 37231 1000 28 ? ? . 37231 1001 1 If if IN 37231 1001 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 1001 3 the the DT 37231 1001 4 truth truth NN 37231 1001 5 and and CC 37231 1001 6 goodness goodness NN 37231 1001 7 of of IN 37231 1001 8 which which WDT 37231 1001 9 are be VBP 37231 1001 10 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1001 11 do do VBP 37231 1001 12 not not RB 37231 1001 13 afford afford VB 37231 1001 14 any any DT 37231 1001 15 evidence evidence NN 37231 1001 16 of of IN 37231 1001 17 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1001 18 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1001 19 , , , 37231 1001 20 how how WRB 37231 1001 21 can can MD 37231 1001 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 1001 23 which which WDT 37231 1001 24 Reason reason NN 37231 1001 25 can can MD 37231 1001 26 neither neither CC 37231 1001 27 discover discover VB 37231 1001 28 nor nor CC 37231 1001 29 comprehend comprehend VB 37231 1001 30 attest attest RB 37231 1001 31 the the DT 37231 1001 32 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1001 33 origin origin NN 37231 1001 34 of of IN 37231 1001 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1001 36 ? ? . 37231 1002 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1002 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1002 3 clearly clearly RB 37231 1002 4 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 1002 5 that that IN 37231 1002 6 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1002 7 can can MD 37231 1002 8 not not RB 37231 1002 9 do do VB 37231 1002 10 so so RB 37231 1002 11 . . . 37231 1003 1 " " `` 37231 1003 2 The the DT 37231 1003 3 proof proof NN 37231 1003 4 of of IN 37231 1003 5 a a DT 37231 1003 6 revelation revelation NN 37231 1003 7 , , , 37231 1003 8 " " '' 37231 1003 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1003 10 says say VBZ 37231 1003 11 , , , 37231 1003 12 and and CC 37231 1003 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1003 14 may may MD 37231 1003 15 add add VB 37231 1003 16 , , , 37231 1003 17 " " '' 37231 1003 18 the the DT 37231 1003 19 proof proof NN 37231 1003 20 of of IN 37231 1003 21 a a DT 37231 1003 22 miracle miracle NN 37231 1003 23 -- -- : 37231 1003 24 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1003 25 a a DT 37231 1003 26 species species NN 37231 1003 27 of of IN 37231 1003 28 revelation revelation NN 37231 1003 29 -- -- : 37231 1003 30 which which WDT 37231 1003 31 is be VBZ 37231 1003 32 contained contain VBN 37231 1003 33 in in IN 37231 1003 34 the the DT 37231 1003 35 substance substance NN 37231 1003 36 of of IN 37231 1003 37 a a DT 37231 1003 38 revelation revelation NN 37231 1003 39 has have VBZ 37231 1003 40 this this DT 37231 1003 41 inherent inherent JJ 37231 1003 42 check check NN 37231 1003 43 or or CC 37231 1003 44 limit limit NN 37231 1003 45 in in IN 37231 1003 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1003 47 : : : 37231 1003 48 viz viz NN 37231 1003 49 . . . 37231 1004 1 that that IN 37231 1004 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1004 3 can can MD 37231 1004 4 not not RB 37231 1004 5 reach reach VB 37231 1004 6 to to IN 37231 1004 7 what what WP 37231 1004 8 is be VBZ 37231 1004 9 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 37231 1004 10 by by IN 37231 1004 11 reason reason NN 37231 1004 12 . . . 37231 1005 1 Internal internal JJ 37231 1005 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 1005 3 is be VBZ 37231 1005 4 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1005 5 an an DT 37231 1005 6 appeal appeal NN 37231 1005 7 to to IN 37231 1005 8 reason reason NN 37231 1005 9 , , , 37231 1005 10 because because IN 37231 1005 11 at at IN 37231 1005 12 every every DT 37231 1005 13 step step NN 37231 1005 14 the the DT 37231 1005 15 test test NN 37231 1005 16 is be VBZ 37231 1005 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1005 18 own own JJ 37231 1005 19 appreciation appreciation NN 37231 1005 20 of of IN 37231 1005 21 such such JJ 37231 1005 22 and and CC 37231 1005 23 such such JJ 37231 1005 24 an an DT 37231 1005 25 idea idea NN 37231 1005 26 or or CC 37231 1005 27 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1005 28 , , , 37231 1005 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1005 30 own own JJ 37231 1005 31 perception perception NN 37231 1005 32 of of IN 37231 1005 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1005 34 fitness fitness NN 37231 1005 35 ; ; : 37231 1005 36 but but CC 37231 1005 37 human human JJ 37231 1005 38 reason reason NN 37231 1005 39 can can MD 37231 1005 40 not not RB 37231 1005 41 in in IN 37231 1005 42 the the DT 37231 1005 43 nature nature NN 37231 1005 44 of of IN 37231 1005 45 the the DT 37231 1005 46 case case NN 37231 1005 47 prove prove VBP 37231 1005 48 that that IN 37231 1005 49 which which WDT 37231 1005 50 , , , 37231 1005 51 by by IN 37231 1005 52 the the DT 37231 1005 53 very very JJ 37231 1005 54 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1005 55 , , , 37231 1005 56 lies lie VBZ 37231 1005 57 beyond beyond IN 37231 1005 58 human human JJ 37231 1005 59 reason reason NN 37231 1005 60 . . . 37231 1006 1 " " `` 37231 1006 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1006 3 3 3 LS 37231 1006 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1006 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1006 6 naturally naturally RB 37231 1006 7 follows follow VBZ 37231 1006 8 that that IN 37231 1006 9 no no DT 37231 1006 10 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1006 11 which which WDT 37231 1006 12 lies lie VBZ 37231 1006 13 beyond beyond IN 37231 1006 14 reason reason NN 37231 1006 15 , , , 37231 1006 16 and and CC 37231 1006 17 therefore therefore RB 37231 1006 18 requires require VBZ 37231 1006 19 the the DT 37231 1006 20 attestation attestation NN 37231 1006 21 of of IN 37231 1006 22 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1006 23 , , , 37231 1006 24 can can MD 37231 1006 25 possibly possibly RB 37231 1006 26 afford afford VB 37231 1006 27 that that DT 37231 1006 28 indication indication NN 37231 1006 29 of of IN 37231 1006 30 the the DT 37231 1006 31 source source NN 37231 1006 32 and and CC 37231 1006 33 reality reality NN 37231 1006 34 of of IN 37231 1006 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1006 36 which which WDT 37231 1006 37 is be VBZ 37231 1006 38 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1006 39 to to TO 37231 1006 40 endow endow VB 37231 1006 41 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1006 42 with with IN 37231 1006 43 evidential evidential JJ 37231 1006 44 value value NN 37231 1006 45 , , , 37231 1006 46 and and CC 37231 1006 47 the the DT 37231 1006 48 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1006 49 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1006 50 must must MD 37231 1006 51 , , , 37231 1006 52 therefore therefore RB 37231 1006 53 , , , 37231 1006 54 be be VB 37231 1006 55 rejected reject VBN 37231 1006 56 in in IN 37231 1006 57 the the DT 37231 1006 58 absence absence NN 37231 1006 59 of of IN 37231 1006 60 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1006 61 evidence evidence NN 37231 1006 62 of of IN 37231 1006 63 a a DT 37231 1006 64 decisive decisive JJ 37231 1006 65 character character NN 37231 1006 66 . . . 37231 1007 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1007 2 24 24 CD 37231 1007 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1007 4 Canon Canon NNP 37231 1007 5 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1007 6 labours labour VBZ 37231 1007 7 earnestly earnestly RB 37231 1007 8 , , , 37231 1007 9 but but CC 37231 1007 10 unsuccessfully unsuccessfully RB 37231 1007 11 , , , 37231 1007 12 to to TO 37231 1007 13 restore restore VB 37231 1007 14 to to IN 37231 1007 15 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 1007 16 as as IN 37231 1007 17 evidence evidence NN 37231 1007 18 some some DT 37231 1007 19 part part NN 37231 1007 20 of of IN 37231 1007 21 that that DT 37231 1007 22 potentiality potentiality NN 37231 1007 23 of of IN 37231 1007 24 which which WDT 37231 1007 25 these these DT 37231 1007 26 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37231 1007 27 limitations limitation NNS 37231 1007 28 have have VBP 37231 1007 29 deprived deprive VBN 37231 1007 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1007 31 . . . 37231 1008 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 1008 2 on on IN 37231 1008 3 the the DT 37231 1008 4 one one CD 37231 1008 5 hand hand NN 37231 1008 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1008 7 says say VBZ 37231 1008 8 : : : 37231 1008 9 " " `` 37231 1008 10 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1008 11 must must MD 37231 1008 12 admit admit VB 37231 1008 13 , , , 37231 1008 14 indeed indeed RB 37231 1008 15 , , , 37231 1008 16 an an DT 37231 1008 17 inherent inherent JJ 37231 1008 18 modification modification NN 37231 1008 19 in in IN 37231 1008 20 the the DT 37231 1008 21 function function NN 37231 1008 22 of of IN 37231 1008 23 a a DT 37231 1008 24 miracle miracle NN 37231 1008 25 as as IN 37231 1008 26 an an DT 37231 1008 27 instrument instrument NN 37231 1008 28 of of IN 37231 1008 29 proof,"(1 proof,"(1 ADD 37231 1008 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1008 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1008 32 argues argue VBZ 37231 1008 33 that that IN 37231 1008 34 this this DT 37231 1008 35 is be VBZ 37231 1008 36 only only RB 37231 1008 37 a a DT 37231 1008 38 limitation limitation NN 37231 1008 39 , , , 37231 1008 40 and and CC 37231 1008 41 no no DT 37231 1008 42 disproof disproof NN 37231 1008 43 of of IN 37231 1008 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1008 45 , , , 37231 1008 46 and and CC 37231 1008 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1008 48 contends contend VBZ 37231 1008 49 that that DT 37231 1008 50 : : : 37231 1008 51 " " `` 37231 1008 52 The the DT 37231 1008 53 evidence evidence NN 37231 1008 54 of of IN 37231 1008 55 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1008 56 is be VBZ 37231 1008 57 not not RB 37231 1008 58 negatived negative VBN 37231 1008 59 because because IN 37231 1008 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1008 61 has have VBZ 37231 1008 62 conditions condition NNS 37231 1008 63 . . . 37231 1009 1 " " `` 37231 1009 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1009 3 2 2 LS 37231 1009 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1009 5 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1009 6 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1009 7 , , , 37231 1009 8 however however RB 37231 1009 9 , , , 37231 1009 10 is be VBZ 37231 1009 11 purely purely RB 37231 1009 12 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 1009 13 , , , 37231 1009 14 and and CC 37231 1009 15 attempts attempt NNS 37231 1009 16 by by IN 37231 1009 17 the the DT 37231 1009 18 unreal unreal JJ 37231 1009 19 analogy analogy NN 37231 1009 20 of of IN 37231 1009 21 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1009 22 limitations limitation NNS 37231 1009 23 of of IN 37231 1009 24 natural natural JJ 37231 1009 25 principles principle NNS 37231 1009 26 and and CC 37231 1009 27 evidence evidence NN 37231 1009 28 to to TO 37231 1009 29 excuse excuse VB 37231 1009 30 the the DT 37231 1009 31 disqualifying disqualify VBG 37231 1009 32 limitation limitation NN 37231 1009 33 of of IN 37231 1009 34 the the DT 37231 1009 35 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1009 36 . . . 37231 1010 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1010 2 is be VBZ 37231 1010 3 quite quite RB 37231 1010 4 conscious conscious JJ 37231 1010 5 of of IN 37231 1010 6 the the DT 37231 1010 7 serious serious JJ 37231 1010 8 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1010 9 of of IN 37231 1010 10 the the DT 37231 1010 11 position position NN 37231 1010 12 : : : 37231 1010 13 " " `` 37231 1010 14 The the DT 37231 1010 15 question question NN 37231 1010 16 , , , 37231 1010 17 " " '' 37231 1010 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1010 19 says say VBZ 37231 1010 20 , , , 37231 1010 21 " " `` 37231 1010 22 may may MD 37231 1010 23 at at IN 37231 1010 24 first first JJ 37231 1010 25 sight sight NN 37231 1010 26 create create VB 37231 1010 27 a a DT 37231 1010 28 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 1010 29 -- -- : 37231 1010 30 If if IN 37231 1010 31 a a DT 37231 1010 32 miracle miracle NN 37231 1010 33 is be VBZ 37231 1010 34 nugatory nugatory JJ 37231 1010 35 on on IN 37231 1010 36 the the DT 37231 1010 37 side side NN 37231 1010 38 of of IN 37231 1010 39 one one CD 37231 1010 40 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1010 41 , , , 37231 1010 42 what what WDT 37231 1010 43 cogency cogency NN 37231 1010 44 has have VBZ 37231 1010 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1010 46 on on IN 37231 1010 47 the the DT 37231 1010 48 side side NN 37231 1010 49 of of IN 37231 1010 50 another another DT 37231 1010 51 ? ? . 37231 1011 1 Is be VBZ 37231 1011 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1011 3 legitimate legitimate JJ 37231 1011 4 to to TO 37231 1011 5 accept accept VB 37231 1011 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1011 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 1011 8 when when WRB 37231 1011 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1011 10 please please VBP 37231 1011 11 , , , 37231 1011 12 and and CC 37231 1011 13 reject reject VB 37231 1011 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1011 15 when when WRB 37231 1011 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1011 17 please please VBP 37231 1011 18 ? ? . 37231 1011 19 " " '' 37231 1012 1 The the DT 37231 1012 2 only only JJ 37231 1012 3 reply reply NN 37231 1012 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1012 5 seems seem VBZ 37231 1012 6 able able JJ 37231 1012 7 to to TO 37231 1012 8 give give VB 37231 1012 9 to to IN 37231 1012 10 these these DT 37231 1012 11 very very RB 37231 1012 12 pertinent pertinent JJ 37231 1012 13 questions question NNS 37231 1012 14 is be VBZ 37231 1012 15 the the DT 37231 1012 16 remark remark NN 37231 1012 17 which which WDT 37231 1012 18 immediately immediately RB 37231 1012 19 follows follow VBZ 37231 1012 20 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1012 21 : : : 37231 1012 22 " " `` 37231 1012 23 But but CC 37231 1012 24 in in IN 37231 1012 25 truth truth NN 37231 1012 26 a a DT 37231 1012 27 miracle miracle NN 37231 1012 28 is be VBZ 37231 1012 29 never never RB 37231 1012 30 without without IN 37231 1012 31 an an DT 37231 1012 32 argumentative argumentative JJ 37231 1012 33 force force NN 37231 1012 34 , , , 37231 1012 35 although although IN 37231 1012 36 that that DT 37231 1012 37 force force NN 37231 1012 38 may may MD 37231 1012 39 be be VB 37231 1012 40 counterbalanced counterbalance VBN 37231 1012 41 . . . 37231 1013 1 " " `` 37231 1013 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1013 3 3 3 LS 37231 1013 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1013 5 In in IN 37231 1013 6 other other JJ 37231 1013 7 words word NNS 37231 1013 8 a a DT 37231 1013 9 miracle miracle NN 37231 1013 10 is be VBZ 37231 1013 11 always always RB 37231 1013 12 an an DT 37231 1013 13 argument argument NN 37231 1013 14 although although IN 37231 1013 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1013 16 is be VBZ 37231 1013 17 often often RB 37231 1013 18 a a DT 37231 1013 19 bad bad JJ 37231 1013 20 one one NN 37231 1013 21 . . . 37231 1014 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1014 2 is be VBZ 37231 1014 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1014 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1014 5 to to TO 37231 1014 6 go go VB 37231 1014 7 to to IN 37231 1014 8 the the DT 37231 1014 9 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1014 10 for for IN 37231 1014 11 bad bad JJ 37231 1014 12 arguments argument NNS 37231 1014 13 . . . 37231 1015 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1015 2 might may MD 37231 1015 3 naturally naturally RB 37231 1015 4 be be VB 37231 1015 5 expected expect VBN 37231 1015 6 that that IN 37231 1015 7 the the DT 37231 1015 8 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1015 9 evidence evidence NN 37231 1015 10 selected select VBN 37231 1015 11 to to TO 37231 1015 12 accredit accredit VB 37231 1015 13 a a DT 37231 1015 14 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1015 15 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1015 16 should should MD 37231 1015 17 possess possess VB 37231 1015 18 certain certain JJ 37231 1015 19 unique unique JJ 37231 1015 20 and and CC 37231 1015 21 marked marked JJ 37231 1015 22 characteristics characteristic NNS 37231 1015 23 . . . 37231 1016 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1016 2 must must MD 37231 1016 3 , , , 37231 1016 4 at at IN 37231 1016 5 least least JJS 37231 1016 6 , , , 37231 1016 7 be be VB 37231 1016 8 clearly clearly RB 37231 1016 9 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 1016 10 of of IN 37231 1016 11 Divine divine JJ 37231 1016 12 power power NN 37231 1016 13 , , , 37231 1016 14 and and CC 37231 1016 15 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 1016 16 associated associate VBN 37231 1016 17 with with IN 37231 1016 18 Divine divine JJ 37231 1016 19 truth truth NN 37231 1016 20 . . . 37231 1017 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1017 2 is be VBZ 37231 1017 3 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 37231 1017 4 that that IN 37231 1017 5 the the DT 37231 1017 6 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1017 7 , , , 37231 1017 8 deigning deign VBG 37231 1017 9 thus thus RB 37231 1017 10 to to TO 37231 1017 11 attest attest VB 37231 1017 12 { { -LRB- 37231 1017 13 25 25 CD 37231 1017 14 } } -RRB- 37231 1017 15 the the DT 37231 1017 16 reality reality NN 37231 1017 17 of of IN 37231 1017 18 a a DT 37231 1017 19 communication communication NN 37231 1017 20 from from IN 37231 1017 21 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1017 22 of of IN 37231 1017 23 truths truth NNS 37231 1017 24 beyond beyond IN 37231 1017 25 the the DT 37231 1017 26 criterion criterion NN 37231 1017 27 of of IN 37231 1017 28 reason reason NN 37231 1017 29 , , , 37231 1017 30 should should MD 37231 1017 31 not not RB 37231 1017 32 make make VB 37231 1017 33 the the DT 37231 1017 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 1017 35 simple simple JJ 37231 1017 36 and and CC 37231 1017 37 complete complete JJ 37231 1017 38 , , , 37231 1017 39 because because IN 37231 1017 40 , , , 37231 1017 41 the the DT 37231 1017 42 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 1017 43 proper proper JJ 37231 1017 44 to to IN 37231 1017 45 such such PDT 37231 1017 46 a a DT 37231 1017 47 revelation revelation NN 37231 1017 48 not not RB 37231 1017 49 being be VBG 37231 1017 50 appreciable appreciable JJ 37231 1017 51 from from IN 37231 1017 52 internal internal JJ 37231 1017 53 evidence evidence NN 37231 1017 54 , , , 37231 1017 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1017 56 is be VBZ 37231 1017 57 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1017 58 that that IN 37231 1017 59 the the DT 37231 1017 60 external external JJ 37231 1017 61 testimony testimony NN 37231 1017 62 for for IN 37231 1017 63 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1017 64 -- -- : 37231 1017 65 if if IN 37231 1017 66 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1017 67 is be VBZ 37231 1017 68 to to TO 37231 1017 69 be be VB 37231 1017 70 of of IN 37231 1017 71 any any DT 37231 1017 72 use use NN 37231 1017 73 -- -- : 37231 1017 74 must must MD 37231 1017 75 be be VB 37231 1017 76 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 37231 1017 77 and and CC 37231 1017 78 decisive decisive JJ 37231 1017 79 . . . 37231 1018 1 The the DT 37231 1018 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 1018 3 which which WDT 37231 1018 4 is be VBZ 37231 1018 5 actually actually RB 37231 1018 6 produced produce VBN 37231 1018 7 , , , 37231 1018 8 however however RB 37231 1018 9 , , , 37231 1018 10 so so RB 37231 1018 11 far far RB 37231 1018 12 from from IN 37231 1018 13 satisfying satisfy VBG 37231 1018 14 these these DT 37231 1018 15 legitimate legitimate JJ 37231 1018 16 anticipations anticipation NNS 37231 1018 17 , , , 37231 1018 18 lacks lack VBZ 37231 1018 19 every every DT 37231 1018 20 one one CD 37231 1018 21 of of IN 37231 1018 22 the the DT 37231 1018 23 qualifications qualification NNS 37231 1018 24 which which WDT 37231 1018 25 reason reason NN 37231 1018 26 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1018 27 declares declare VBZ 37231 1018 28 to to TO 37231 1018 29 be be VB 37231 1018 30 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1018 31 . . . 37231 1019 1 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 1019 2 are be VBP 37231 1019 3 not not RB 37231 1019 4 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 1019 5 of of IN 37231 1019 6 Divine divine JJ 37231 1019 7 power power NN 37231 1019 8 but but CC 37231 1019 9 are be VBP 37231 1019 10 common common JJ 37231 1019 11 to to IN 37231 1019 12 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1019 13 , , , 37231 1019 14 and and CC 37231 1019 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1019 16 are be VBP 37231 1019 17 admitted admit VBN 37231 1019 18 to to TO 37231 1019 19 be be VB 37231 1019 20 performed perform VBN 37231 1019 21 in in IN 37231 1019 22 support support NN 37231 1019 23 of of IN 37231 1019 24 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1019 25 as as RB 37231 1019 26 well well RB 37231 1019 27 as as IN 37231 1019 28 in in IN 37231 1019 29 the the DT 37231 1019 30 service service NN 37231 1019 31 of of IN 37231 1019 32 truth truth NN 37231 1019 33 . . . 37231 1020 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1020 2 bear bear VBP 37231 1020 3 , , , 37231 1020 4 indeed indeed RB 37231 1020 5 , , , 37231 1020 6 so so RB 37231 1020 7 little little JJ 37231 1020 8 upon upon IN 37231 1020 9 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1020 10 the the DT 37231 1020 11 impress impress NN 37231 1020 12 of of IN 37231 1020 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1020 14 origin origin NN 37231 1020 15 and and CC 37231 1020 16 true true JJ 37231 1020 17 character character NN 37231 1020 18 , , , 37231 1020 19 that that IN 37231 1020 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1020 21 arc arc VBP 37231 1020 22 dependent dependent JJ 37231 1020 23 for for IN 37231 1020 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1020 25 recognition recognition NN 37231 1020 26 upon upon IN 37231 1020 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1020 28 judgment judgment NN 37231 1020 29 of of IN 37231 1020 30 the the DT 37231 1020 31 very very JJ 37231 1020 32 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 1020 33 to to TO 37231 1020 34 attest attest VB 37231 1020 35 which which WDT 37231 1020 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1020 37 are be VBP 37231 1020 38 said say VBN 37231 1020 39 to to TO 37231 1020 40 have have VB 37231 1020 41 been be VBN 37231 1020 42 designed design VBN 37231 1020 43 . . . 37231 1021 1 Even even RB 37231 1021 2 taking take VBG 37231 1021 3 the the DT 37231 1021 4 representation representation NN 37231 1021 5 of of IN 37231 1021 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1021 7 , , , 37231 1021 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 1021 9 , , , 37231 1021 10 which which WDT 37231 1021 11 divines divine VBZ 37231 1021 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1021 13 give give VBP 37231 1021 14 , , , 37231 1021 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1021 16 are be VBP 37231 1021 17 utterly utterly RB 37231 1021 18 incompetent incompetent JJ 37231 1021 19 to to TO 37231 1021 20 perform perform VB 37231 1021 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1021 22 contemplated contemplate VBN 37231 1021 23 functions function NNS 37231 1021 24 . . . 37231 1022 1 If if IN 37231 1022 2 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1022 3 are be VBP 37231 1022 4 superhuman superhuman JJ 37231 1022 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1022 6 are be VBP 37231 1022 7 not not RB 37231 1022 8 super super JJ 37231 1022 9 - - JJ 37231 1022 10 satanic satanic JJ 37231 1022 11 , , , 37231 1022 12 and and CC 37231 1022 13 there there EX 37231 1022 14 is be VBZ 37231 1022 15 no no DT 37231 1022 16 sense sense NN 37231 1022 17 in in IN 37231 1022 18 which which WDT 37231 1022 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1022 20 can can MD 37231 1022 21 be be VB 37231 1022 22 considered consider VBN 37231 1022 23 miraculously miraculously RB 37231 1022 24 evidential evidential JJ 37231 1022 25 of of IN 37231 1022 26 anything anything NN 37231 1022 27 . . . 37231 1023 1 To to TO 37231 1023 2 argue argue VB 37231 1023 3 , , , 37231 1023 4 as as IN 37231 1023 5 theologians theologian NNS 37231 1023 6 do do VBP 37231 1023 7 , , , 37231 1023 8 that that IN 37231 1023 9 the the DT 37231 1023 10 ambiguity ambiguity NN 37231 1023 11 of of IN 37231 1023 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1023 13 testimony testimony NN 37231 1023 14 is be VBZ 37231 1023 15 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 1023 16 intended intend VBN 37231 1023 17 as as IN 37231 1023 18 a a DT 37231 1023 19 trial trial NN 37231 1023 20 of of IN 37231 1023 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1023 22 faith faith NN 37231 1023 23 is be VBZ 37231 1023 24 absurd absurd JJ 37231 1023 25 , , , 37231 1023 26 for for IN 37231 1023 27 Reason reason NN 37231 1023 28 being be VBG 37231 1023 29 unable unable JJ 37231 1023 30 to to TO 37231 1023 31 judge judge VB 37231 1023 32 of of IN 37231 1023 33 the the DT 37231 1023 34 nature nature NN 37231 1023 35 either either CC 37231 1023 36 of of IN 37231 1023 37 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1023 38 fact fact NN 37231 1023 39 or or CC 37231 1023 40 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1023 41 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1023 42 , , , 37231 1023 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1023 44 would would MD 37231 1023 45 be be VB 37231 1023 46 mere mere JJ 37231 1023 47 folly folly NN 37231 1023 48 and and CC 37231 1023 49 injustice injustice NN 37231 1023 50 to to TO 37231 1023 51 subject subject VB 37231 1023 52 to to IN 37231 1023 53 such such PDT 37231 1023 54 a a DT 37231 1023 55 test test NN 37231 1023 56 beings being NNS 37231 1023 57 avowedly avowedly RB 37231 1023 58 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1023 59 of of IN 37231 1023 60 sustaining sustain VBG 37231 1023 61 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1023 62 . . . 37231 1024 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 1024 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1024 3 is be VBZ 37231 1024 4 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 1024 5 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1024 6 , , , 37231 1024 7 then then RB 37231 1024 8 , , , 37231 1024 9 that that IN 37231 1024 10 a a DT 37231 1024 11 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1024 12 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1024 13 should should MD 37231 1024 14 be be VB 37231 1024 15 attested attest VBN 37231 1024 16 by by IN 37231 1024 17 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1024 18 evidence evidence NN 37231 1024 19 to to TO 37231 1024 20 justify justify VB 37231 1024 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1024 22 believing believe VBG 37231 1024 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1024 24 the the DT 37231 1024 25 testimony testimony NN 37231 1024 26 so so RB 37231 1024 27 called call VBD 37231 1024 28 seems seem VBZ 37231 1024 29 in in IN 37231 1024 30 all all DT 37231 1024 31 respects respect NNS 37231 1024 32 { { -LRB- 37231 1024 33 26 26 CD 37231 1024 34 } } -RRB- 37231 1024 35 unworthy unworthy JJ 37231 1024 36 of of IN 37231 1024 37 the the DT 37231 1024 38 name name NN 37231 1024 39 , , , 37231 1024 40 and and CC 37231 1024 41 presents present VBZ 37231 1024 42 anomalies anomaly NNS 37231 1024 43 much much RB 37231 1024 44 more more JJR 37231 1024 45 suggestive suggestive JJ 37231 1024 46 of of IN 37231 1024 47 human human JJ 37231 1024 48 invention invention NN 37231 1024 49 than than IN 37231 1024 50 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1024 51 originality originality NN 37231 1024 52 . . . 37231 1025 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1025 2 are be VBP 37231 1025 3 , , , 37231 1025 4 in in IN 37231 1025 5 fact fact NN 37231 1025 6 , , , 37231 1025 7 prepared prepare VBN 37231 1025 8 even even RB 37231 1025 9 by by IN 37231 1025 10 the the DT 37231 1025 11 Scriptural Scriptural NNP 37231 1025 12 account account NN 37231 1025 13 of of IN 37231 1025 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1025 15 to to TO 37231 1025 16 expect expect VB 37231 1025 17 that that IN 37231 1025 18 further further JJ 37231 1025 19 examination examination NN 37231 1025 20 will will MD 37231 1025 21 supply supply VB 37231 1025 22 an an DT 37231 1025 23 explanation explanation NN 37231 1025 24 of of IN 37231 1025 25 such such JJ 37231 1025 26 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1025 27 which which WDT 37231 1025 28 will will MD 37231 1025 29 wholly wholly RB 37231 1025 30 remove remove VB 37231 1025 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1025 32 from from IN 37231 1025 33 the the DT 37231 1025 34 region region NN 37231 1025 35 of of IN 37231 1025 36 the the DT 37231 1025 37 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1025 38 . . . 37231 1026 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1026 2 27 27 CD 37231 1026 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1026 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 1026 5 II II NNP 37231 1026 6 . . . 37231 1027 1 MIRACLES miracle NNS 37231 1027 2 IN in IN 37231 1027 3 RELATION relation NN 37231 1027 4 TO to IN 37231 1027 5 THE the DT 37231 1027 6 ORDER order NN 37231 1027 7 OF of IN 37231 1027 8 NATURE nature NN 37231 1027 9 Without without IN 37231 1027 10 at at IN 37231 1027 11 present present NN 37231 1027 12 touching touch VBG 37231 1027 13 the the DT 37231 1027 14 question question NN 37231 1027 15 as as IN 37231 1027 16 to to IN 37231 1027 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1027 18 reality reality NN 37231 1027 19 , , , 37231 1027 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 21 may may MD 37231 1027 22 be be VB 37231 1027 23 well well JJ 37231 1027 24 to to TO 37231 1027 25 ascertain ascertain VB 37231 1027 26 what what WP 37231 1027 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1027 28 are be VBP 37231 1027 29 considered consider VBN 37231 1027 30 to to TO 37231 1027 31 be be VB 37231 1027 32 , , , 37231 1027 33 and and CC 37231 1027 34 how how WRB 37231 1027 35 far far RB 37231 1027 36 , , , 37231 1027 37 and and CC 37231 1027 38 in in IN 37231 1027 39 what what WDT 37231 1027 40 sense sense NN 37231 1027 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 42 is be VBZ 37231 1027 43 asserted assert VBN 37231 1027 44 that that IN 37231 1027 45 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 46 are be VBP 37231 1027 47 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1027 48 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 49 have have VBP 37231 1027 50 , , , 37231 1027 51 hitherto hitherto NNP 37231 1027 52 , , , 37231 1027 53 almost almost RB 37231 1027 54 entirely entirely RB 37231 1027 55 confined confine VBD 37231 1027 56 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1027 57 attention attention NN 37231 1027 58 to to IN 37231 1027 59 the the DT 37231 1027 60 arguments argument NNS 37231 1027 61 of of IN 37231 1027 62 English english JJ 37231 1027 63 divines divine NNS 37231 1027 64 , , , 37231 1027 65 and and CC 37231 1027 66 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 67 must must MD 37231 1027 68 for for IN 37231 1027 69 the the DT 37231 1027 70 present present NN 37231 1027 71 continue continue VBP 37231 1027 72 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 1027 73 to to TO 37231 1027 74 deal deal VB 37231 1027 75 with with IN 37231 1027 76 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 77 , , , 37231 1027 78 for for IN 37231 1027 79 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 80 may may MD 37231 1027 81 broadly broadly RB 37231 1027 82 be be VB 37231 1027 83 said say VBN 37231 1027 84 , , , 37231 1027 85 that that IN 37231 1027 86 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1027 87 alone alone RB 37231 1027 88 , , , 37231 1027 89 at at IN 37231 1027 90 the the DT 37231 1027 91 present present JJ 37231 1027 92 day day NN 37231 1027 93 , , , 37231 1027 94 maintain maintain VB 37231 1027 95 the the DT 37231 1027 96 reality reality NN 37231 1027 97 and and CC 37231 1027 98 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1027 99 character character NN 37231 1027 100 of of IN 37231 1027 101 such such JJ 37231 1027 102 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1027 103 . . . 37231 1028 1 No no DT 37231 1028 2 thoughtful thoughtful JJ 37231 1028 3 mind mind NN 37231 1028 4 can can MD 37231 1028 5 fail fail VB 37231 1028 6 to to TO 37231 1028 7 see see VB 37231 1028 8 that that IN 37231 1028 9 , , , 37231 1028 10 considering consider VBG 37231 1028 11 the the DT 37231 1028 12 function function NN 37231 1028 13 of of IN 37231 1028 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1028 15 , , , 37231 1028 16 this this DT 37231 1028 17 is be VBZ 37231 1028 18 the the DT 37231 1028 19 only only JJ 37231 1028 20 logical logical JJ 37231 1028 21 and and CC 37231 1028 22 consistent consistent JJ 37231 1028 23 course course NN 37231 1028 24 . . . 37231 1029 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1029 2 1 1 LS 37231 1029 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1029 4 The the DT 37231 1029 5 insuperable insuperable JJ 37231 1029 6 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 1029 7 in in IN 37231 1029 8 the the DT 37231 1029 9 way way NN 37231 1029 10 of of IN 37231 1029 11 admitting admit VBG 37231 1029 12 the the DT 37231 1029 13 reality reality NN 37231 1029 14 of of IN 37231 1029 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1029 16 , , , 37231 1029 17 however however RB 37231 1029 18 , , , 37231 1029 19 have have VBP 37231 1029 20 driven drive VBN 37231 1029 21 the the DT 37231 1029 22 great great JJ 37231 1029 23 majority majority NN 37231 1029 24 of of IN 37231 1029 25 continental continental NNP 37231 1029 26 , , , 37231 1029 27 as as RB 37231 1029 28 well well RB 37231 1029 29 as as IN 37231 1029 30 very very RB 37231 1029 31 many many JJ 37231 1029 32 English English NNP 37231 1029 33 , , , 37231 1029 34 theologians theologian NNS 37231 1029 35 who who WP 37231 1029 36 still still RB 37231 1029 37 pretend pretend VBP 37231 1029 38 to to IN 37231 1029 39 a a DT 37231 1029 40 certain certain JJ 37231 1029 41 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 37231 1029 42 , , , 37231 1029 43 either either CC 37231 1029 44 to to TO 37231 1029 45 explain explain VB 37231 1029 46 the the DT 37231 1029 47 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1029 48 of of IN 37231 1029 49 the the DT 37231 1029 50 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1029 51 naturally naturally RB 37231 1029 52 , , , 37231 1029 53 or or CC 37231 1029 54 to to TO 37231 1029 55 suppress suppress VB 37231 1029 56 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1029 57 altogether altogether RB 37231 1029 58 . . . 37231 1030 1 Since since IN 37231 1030 2 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 37231 1030 3 denounced denounce VBD 37231 1030 4 the the DT 37231 1030 5 idea idea NN 37231 1030 6 of of IN 37231 1030 7 Divine divine JJ 37231 1030 8 interruptions interruption NNS 37231 1030 9 of of IN 37231 1030 10 the the DT 37231 1030 11 order order NN 37231 1030 12 of of IN 37231 1030 13 nature nature NN 37231 1030 14 , , , 37231 1030 15 and and CC 37231 1030 16 explained explain VBD 37231 1030 17 away away RP 37231 1030 18 the the DT 37231 1030 19 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1030 20 character character NN 37231 1030 21 { { -LRB- 37231 1030 22 28 28 CD 37231 1030 23 } } -RRB- 37231 1030 24 of of IN 37231 1030 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1030 26 , , , 37231 1030 27 by by IN 37231 1030 28 defining define VBG 37231 1030 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1030 30 as as RB 37231 1030 31 merely merely RB 37231 1030 32 relative relative JJ 37231 1030 33 : : : 37231 1030 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1030 35 to to IN 37231 1030 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1030 37 , , , 37231 1030 38 but but CC 37231 1030 39 in in IN 37231 1030 40 reality reality NN 37231 1030 41 mere mere JJ 37231 1030 42 anticipations anticipation NNS 37231 1030 43 of of IN 37231 1030 44 human human JJ 37231 1030 45 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1030 46 and and CC 37231 1030 47 power power NN 37231 1030 48 , , , 37231 1030 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1030 50 example example NN 37231 1030 51 has have VBZ 37231 1030 52 been be VBN 37231 1030 53 more more RBR 37231 1030 54 or or CC 37231 1030 55 less less RBR 37231 1030 56 followed follow VBN 37231 1030 57 throughout throughout IN 37231 1030 58 Germany Germany NNP 37231 1030 59 , , , 37231 1030 60 and and CC 37231 1030 61 almost almost RB 37231 1030 62 every every DT 37231 1030 63 expedient expedient NN 37231 1030 64 has have VBZ 37231 1030 65 been be VBN 37231 1030 66 adopted adopt VBN 37231 1030 67 , , , 37231 1030 68 by by IN 37231 1030 69 would would MD 37231 1030 70 - - HYPH 37231 1030 71 be be VB 37231 1030 72 orthodox orthodox JJ 37231 1030 73 writers writer NNS 37231 1030 74 , , , 37231 1030 75 to to TO 37231 1030 76 reduce reduce VB 37231 1030 77 or or CC 37231 1030 78 altogether altogether RB 37231 1030 79 eliminate eliminate VB 37231 1030 80 the the DT 37231 1030 81 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1030 82 elements element NNS 37231 1030 83 . . . 37231 1031 1 The the DT 37231 1031 2 attempts attempt NNS 37231 1031 3 which which WDT 37231 1031 4 have have VBP 37231 1031 5 been be VBN 37231 1031 6 made make VBN 37231 1031 7 to to TO 37231 1031 8 do do VB 37231 1031 9 this this DT 37231 1031 10 , , , 37231 1031 11 and and CC 37231 1031 12 yet yet RB 37231 1031 13 to to TO 37231 1031 14 maintain maintain VB 37231 1031 15 the the DT 37231 1031 16 semblance semblance NN 37231 1031 17 of of IN 37231 1031 18 unshaken unshaken JJ 37231 1031 19 belief belief NN 37231 1031 20 in in IN 37231 1031 21 the the DT 37231 1031 22 main main JJ 37231 1031 23 points point NNS 37231 1031 24 of of IN 37231 1031 25 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 1031 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1031 27 , , , 37231 1031 28 have have VBP 37231 1031 29 lamentably lamentably RB 37231 1031 30 failed fail VBN 37231 1031 31 , , , 37231 1031 32 from from IN 37231 1031 33 the the DT 37231 1031 34 hopeless hopeless JJ 37231 1031 35 nature nature NN 37231 1031 36 of of IN 37231 1031 37 the the DT 37231 1031 38 task task NN 37231 1031 39 and and CC 37231 1031 40 the the DT 37231 1031 41 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 1031 42 error error NN 37231 1031 43 of of IN 37231 1031 44 the the DT 37231 1031 45 conception conception NN 37231 1031 46 . . . 37231 1032 1 The the DT 37231 1032 2 endeavour endeavour NN 37231 1032 3 of of IN 37231 1032 4 Paulus Paulus NNP 37231 1032 5 and and CC 37231 1032 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1032 7 school school NN 37231 1032 8 to to TO 37231 1032 9 get get VB 37231 1032 10 rid rid VBN 37231 1032 11 of of IN 37231 1032 12 the the DT 37231 1032 13 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1032 14 by by IN 37231 1032 15 a a DT 37231 1032 16 bold bold JJ 37231 1032 17 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 37231 1032 18 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 1032 19 of of IN 37231 1032 20 the the DT 37231 1032 21 language language NN 37231 1032 22 of of IN 37231 1032 23 the the DT 37231 1032 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1032 25 narratives narrative NNS 37231 1032 26 , , , 37231 1032 27 whilst whilst IN 37231 1032 28 the the DT 37231 1032 29 credibility credibility NN 37231 1032 30 of of IN 37231 1032 31 the the DT 37231 1032 32 record record NN 37231 1032 33 was be VBD 37231 1032 34 represented represent VBN 37231 1032 35 as as IN 37231 1032 36 intact intact JJ 37231 1032 37 , , , 37231 1032 38 was be VBD 37231 1032 39 too too RB 37231 1032 40 glaring glare VBG 37231 1032 41 an an DT 37231 1032 42 outrage outrage NN 37231 1032 43 upon upon IN 37231 1032 44 common common JJ 37231 1032 45 sense sense NN 37231 1032 46 to to TO 37231 1032 47 be be VB 37231 1032 48 successful successful JJ 37231 1032 49 , , , 37231 1032 50 but but CC 37231 1032 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1032 52 was be VBD 37231 1032 53 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1032 54 more more RBR 37231 1032 55 illogical illogical JJ 37231 1032 56 than than IN 37231 1032 57 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 1032 58 efforts effort NNS 37231 1032 59 to to TO 37231 1032 60 suppress suppress VB 37231 1032 61 the the DT 37231 1032 62 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1032 63 , , , 37231 1032 64 yet yet CC 37231 1032 65 retain retain VB 37231 1032 66 the the DT 37231 1032 67 creed creed NN 37231 1032 68 . . . 37231 1033 1 The the DT 37231 1033 2 great great JJ 37231 1033 3 majority majority NN 37231 1033 4 of of IN 37231 1033 5 modern modern JJ 37231 1033 6 German german JJ 37231 1033 7 critics critic NNS 37231 1033 8 , , , 37231 1033 9 however however RB 37231 1033 10 , , , 37231 1033 11 reject reject VBP 37231 1033 12 the the DT 37231 1033 13 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1033 14 altogether altogether RB 37231 1033 15 , , , 37231 1033 16 and and CC 37231 1033 17 consider consider VB 37231 1033 18 the the DT 37231 1033 19 question question NN 37231 1033 20 as as IN 37231 1033 21 no no RB 37231 1033 22 longer long RBR 37231 1033 23 worthy worthy JJ 37231 1033 24 of of IN 37231 1033 25 discussion discussion NN 37231 1033 26 , , , 37231 1033 27 and and CC 37231 1033 28 most most JJS 37231 1033 29 of of IN 37231 1033 30 those those DT 37231 1033 31 who who WP 37231 1033 32 have have VBP 37231 1033 33 not not RB 37231 1033 34 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 1033 35 expressed express VBN 37231 1033 36 this this DT 37231 1033 37 view view NN 37231 1033 38 either either DT 37231 1033 39 resort resort NN 37231 1033 40 to to IN 37231 1033 41 every every DT 37231 1033 42 linguistic linguistic JJ 37231 1033 43 device device NN 37231 1033 44 to to TO 37231 1033 45 evade evade VB 37231 1033 46 the the DT 37231 1033 47 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1033 48 , , , 37231 1033 49 or or CC 37231 1033 50 betray betray VB 37231 1033 51 , , , 37231 1033 52 by by IN 37231 1033 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1033 54 hesitation hesitation NN 37231 1033 55 , , , 37231 1033 56 the the DT 37231 1033 57 feebleness feebleness NN 37231 1033 58 of of IN 37231 1033 59 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1033 60 belief belief NN 37231 1033 61 . . . 37231 1034 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1034 2 1 1 LS 37231 1034 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1034 4 In in IN 37231 1034 5 dealing deal VBG 37231 1034 6 with with IN 37231 1034 7 the the DT 37231 1034 8 { { -LRB- 37231 1034 9 29 29 CD 37231 1034 10 } } -RRB- 37231 1034 11 question question NN 37231 1034 12 of of IN 37231 1034 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1034 14 , , , 37231 1034 15 therefore therefore RB 37231 1034 16 , , , 37231 1034 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1034 18 is be VBZ 37231 1034 19 not not RB 37231 1034 20 to to IN 37231 1034 21 Germany Germany NNP 37231 1034 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1034 23 must must MD 37231 1034 24 turn turn VB 37231 1034 25 , , , 37231 1034 26 but but CC 37231 1034 27 to to IN 37231 1034 28 England England NNP 37231 1034 29 , , , 37231 1034 30 where where WRB 37231 1034 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1034 32 reality reality NN 37231 1034 33 is be VBZ 37231 1034 34 still still RB 37231 1034 35 maintained maintain VBN 37231 1034 36 . . . 37231 1035 1 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1035 2 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1035 3 rejects reject VBZ 37231 1035 4 with with IN 37231 1035 5 disdain disdain NN 37231 1035 6 the the DT 37231 1035 7 attempts attempt NNS 37231 1035 8 of of IN 37231 1035 9 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 37231 1035 10 and and CC 37231 1035 11 others other NNS 37231 1035 12 to to TO 37231 1035 13 get get VB 37231 1035 14 rid rid VBN 37231 1035 15 of of IN 37231 1035 16 the the DT 37231 1035 17 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1035 18 elements element NNS 37231 1035 19 of of IN 37231 1035 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1035 21 , , , 37231 1035 22 by by IN 37231 1035 23 making make VBG 37231 1035 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1035 25 relative relative JJ 37231 1035 26 , , , 37231 1035 27 which which WDT 37231 1035 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1035 29 rightly rightly RB 37231 1035 30 considers consider VBZ 37231 1035 31 to to TO 37231 1035 32 be be VB 37231 1035 33 merely merely RB 37231 1035 34 " " `` 37231 1035 35 a a DT 37231 1035 36 decently decently RB 37231 1035 37 veiled veil VBN 37231 1035 38 denial denial NN 37231 1035 39 of of IN 37231 1035 40 the the DT 37231 1035 41 miracle miracle NN 37231 1035 42 altogether;"(1 altogether;"(1 '' 37231 1035 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1035 44 and and CC 37231 1035 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1035 46 will will MD 37231 1035 47 not not RB 37231 1035 48 accept accept VB 37231 1035 49 any any DT 37231 1035 50 reconciliation reconciliation NN 37231 1035 51 which which WDT 37231 1035 52 sacrifices sacrifice VBZ 37231 1035 53 the the DT 37231 1035 54 miracle miracle NN 37231 1035 55 , , , 37231 1035 56 " " '' 37231 1035 57 which which WDT 37231 1035 58 , , , 37231 1035 59 " " '' 37231 1035 60 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1035 61 logically logically RB 37231 1035 62 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 1035 63 , , , 37231 1035 64 " " `` 37231 1035 65 is be VBZ 37231 1035 66 , , , 37231 1035 67 in in IN 37231 1035 68 fact fact NN 37231 1035 69 , , , 37231 1035 70 no no DT 37231 1035 71 miracle miracle NN 37231 1035 72 , , , 37231 1035 73 if if IN 37231 1035 74 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1035 75 lay lie VBD 37231 1035 76 in in IN 37231 1035 77 nature nature NN 37231 1035 78 already already RB 37231 1035 79 , , , 37231 1035 80 if if IN 37231 1035 81 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1035 82 was be VBD 37231 1035 83 only only RB 37231 1035 84 the the DT 37231 1035 85 evoking evoking NN 37231 1035 86 of of IN 37231 1035 87 forces force NNS 37231 1035 88 latent latent NN 37231 1035 89 therein therein RB 37231 1035 90 , , , 37231 1035 91 not not RB 37231 1035 92 a a DT 37231 1035 93 new new JJ 37231 1035 94 thing thing NN 37231 1035 95 , , , 37231 1035 96 not not RB 37231 1035 97 the the DT 37231 1035 98 bringing bringing NN 37231 1035 99 in in RP 37231 1035 100 of of IN 37231 1035 101 the the DT 37231 1035 102 novel novel JJ 37231 1035 103 powers power NNS 37231 1035 104 of of IN 37231 1035 105 a a DT 37231 1035 106 higher high JJR 37231 1035 107 world world NN 37231 1035 108 ; ; : 37231 1035 109 if if IN 37231 1035 110 the the DT 37231 1035 111 mysterious mysterious JJ 37231 1035 112 processes process NNS 37231 1035 113 and and CC 37231 1035 114 powers power NNS 37231 1035 115 by by IN 37231 1035 116 which which WDT 37231 1035 117 those those DT 37231 1035 118 works work NNS 37231 1035 119 were be VBD 37231 1035 120 brought bring VBN 37231 1035 121 about about RP 37231 1035 122 had have VBD 37231 1035 123 been be VBN 37231 1035 124 only only RB 37231 1035 125 undiscovered undiscovered JJ 37231 1035 126 hitherto hitherto NNP 37231 1035 127 , , , 37231 1035 128 and and CC 37231 1035 129 not not RB 37231 1035 130 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 37231 1035 131 , , , 37231 1035 132 by by IN 37231 1035 133 the the DT 37231 1035 134 efforts effort NNS 37231 1035 135 of of IN 37231 1035 136 human human JJ 37231 1035 137 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 1035 138 . . . 37231 1036 1 " " `` 37231 1036 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1036 3 2 2 LS 37231 1036 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1036 5 When when WRB 37231 1036 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1036 7 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1036 8 tries try VBZ 37231 1036 9 to to TO 37231 1036 10 define define VB 37231 1036 11 what what WP 37231 1036 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1036 13 considers consider VBZ 37231 1036 14 the the DT 37231 1036 15 real real JJ 37231 1036 16 character character NN 37231 1036 17 of of IN 37231 1036 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1036 19 , , , 37231 1036 20 however however RB 37231 1036 21 , , , 37231 1036 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1036 23 becomes become VBZ 37231 1036 24 , , , 37231 1036 25 as as IN 37231 1036 26 might may MD 37231 1036 27 be be VB 37231 1036 28 expected expect VBN 37231 1036 29 , , , 37231 1036 30 { { -LRB- 37231 1036 31 30 30 CD 37231 1036 32 } } -RRB- 37231 1036 33 voluminous voluminous JJ 37231 1036 34 and and CC 37231 1036 35 obscure obscure JJ 37231 1036 36 . . . 37231 1037 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1037 2 says say VBZ 37231 1037 3 : : : 37231 1037 4 " " `` 37231 1037 5 An an DT 37231 1037 6 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 1037 7 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1037 8 casualty casualty NN 37231 1037 9 , , , 37231 1037 10 and and CC 37231 1037 11 not not RB 37231 1037 12 that that DT 37231 1037 13 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 1037 14 which which WDT 37231 1037 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1037 16 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 37231 1037 17 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 1037 18 , , , 37231 1037 19 and and CC 37231 1037 20 in in IN 37231 1037 21 everything everything NN 37231 1037 22 , , , 37231 1037 23 belongs belong VBZ 37231 1037 24 , , , 37231 1037 25 then then RB 37231 1037 26 , , , 37231 1037 27 to to IN 37231 1037 28 the the DT 37231 1037 29 essence essence NN 37231 1037 30 of of IN 37231 1037 31 the the DT 37231 1037 32 miracle miracle NN 37231 1037 33 ; ; : 37231 1037 34 powers power NNS 37231 1037 35 of of IN 37231 1037 36 God God NNP 37231 1037 37 other other JJ 37231 1037 38 than than IN 37231 1037 39 those those DT 37231 1037 40 which which WDT 37231 1037 41 have have VBP 37231 1037 42 always always RB 37231 1037 43 been be VBN 37231 1037 44 working work VBG 37231 1037 45 ; ; : 37231 1037 46 such such JJ 37231 1037 47 , , , 37231 1037 48 indeed indeed RB 37231 1037 49 , , , 37231 1037 50 as as IN 37231 1037 51 most most RBS 37231 1037 52 seldom seldom RB 37231 1037 53 or or CC 37231 1037 54 never never RB 37231 1037 55 have have VBP 37231 1037 56 been be VBN 37231 1037 57 working work VBG 37231 1037 58 before before RB 37231 1037 59 . . . 37231 1038 1 The the DT 37231 1038 2 unresting unreste VBG 37231 1038 3 activity activity NN 37231 1038 4 of of IN 37231 1038 5 God God NNP 37231 1038 6 , , , 37231 1038 7 which which WDT 37231 1038 8 at at IN 37231 1038 9 other other JJ 37231 1038 10 times time NNS 37231 1038 11 hides hide VBZ 37231 1038 12 and and CC 37231 1038 13 conceals conceal NNS 37231 1038 14 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1038 15 behind behind IN 37231 1038 16 the the DT 37231 1038 17 veil veil NN 37231 1038 18 of of IN 37231 1038 19 what what WP 37231 1038 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1038 21 term term VBP 37231 1038 22 natural natural JJ 37231 1038 23 laws law NNS 37231 1038 24 , , , 37231 1038 25 does do VBZ 37231 1038 26 in in IN 37231 1038 27 the the DT 37231 1038 28 miracle miracle NN 37231 1038 29 unveil unveil VB 37231 1038 30 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1038 31 ; ; : 37231 1038 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1038 33 steps step VBZ 37231 1038 34 out out RP 37231 1038 35 from from IN 37231 1038 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1038 37 concealment concealment NN 37231 1038 38 , , , 37231 1038 39 and and CC 37231 1038 40 the the DT 37231 1038 41 hand hand NN 37231 1038 42 which which WDT 37231 1038 43 works work VBZ 37231 1038 44 is be VBZ 37231 1038 45 laid lay VBN 37231 1038 46 bare bare JJ 37231 1038 47 . . . 37231 1039 1 Beside beside IN 37231 1039 2 and and CC 37231 1039 3 beyond beyond IN 37231 1039 4 the the DT 37231 1039 5 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 1039 6 operation operation NN 37231 1039 7 of of IN 37231 1039 8 nature nature NN 37231 1039 9 , , , 37231 1039 10 higher high JJR 37231 1039 11 powers power NNS 37231 1039 12 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1039 13 higher high JJR 37231 1039 14 , , , 37231 1039 15 not not RB 37231 1039 16 as as IN 37231 1039 17 coming come VBG 37231 1039 18 from from IN 37231 1039 19 a a DT 37231 1039 20 higher high JJR 37231 1039 21 source source NN 37231 1039 22 , , , 37231 1039 23 but but CC 37231 1039 24 as as IN 37231 1039 25 bearing bear VBG 37231 1039 26 upon upon IN 37231 1039 27 higher high JJR 37231 1039 28 ends end NNS 37231 1039 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1039 30 intrude intrude VB 37231 1039 31 and and CC 37231 1039 32 make make VB 37231 1039 33 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1039 34 felt feel VBD 37231 1039 35 even even RB 37231 1039 36 at at IN 37231 1039 37 the the DT 37231 1039 38 very very RB 37231 1039 39 springs spring NNS 37231 1039 40 and and CC 37231 1039 41 sources source NNS 37231 1039 42 of of IN 37231 1039 43 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1039 44 power power NN 37231 1039 45 . . . 37231 1040 1 " " `` 37231 1040 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1040 3 1 1 LS 37231 1040 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1040 5 " " `` 37231 1040 6 Not not RB 37231 1040 7 , , , 37231 1040 8 as as IN 37231 1040 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1040 10 shall shall MD 37231 1040 11 see see VB 37231 1040 12 the the DT 37231 1040 13 greatest great JJS 37231 1040 14 theologians theologian NNS 37231 1040 15 have have VBP 37231 1040 16 always always RB 37231 1040 17 earnestly earnestly RB 37231 1040 18 contended contend VBN 37231 1040 19 , , , 37231 1040 20 _ _ NNP 37231 1040 21 contra contra NNP 37231 1040 22 _ _ NNP 37231 1040 23 naturam naturam NNP 37231 1040 24 , , , 37231 1040 25 but but CC 37231 1040 26 _ _ NNP 37231 1040 27 præter præter NN 37231 1040 28 _ _ NNP 37231 1040 29 naturam naturam NNP 37231 1040 30 , , , 37231 1040 31 and and CC 37231 1040 32 _ _ NNP 37231 1040 33 supra supra NNP 37231 1040 34 _ _ NNP 37231 1040 35 naturam naturam NNP 37231 1040 36 . . . 37231 1041 1 " " `` 37231 1041 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1041 3 2 2 LS 37231 1041 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1041 5 Further further RB 37231 1041 6 on on IN 37231 1041 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1041 8 adds add VBZ 37231 1041 9 : : : 37231 1041 10 " " `` 37231 1041 11 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 12 Beyond Beyond NNP 37231 1041 13 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 14 nature nature NN 37231 1041 15 , , , 37231 1041 16 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 17 beyond beyond IN 37231 1041 18 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 19 and and CC 37231 1041 20 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 21 above above IN 37231 1041 22 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 23 the the DT 37231 1041 24 nature nature NN 37231 1041 25 which which WDT 37231 1041 26 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1041 27 know know VBP 37231 1041 28 , , , 37231 1041 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1041 30 are be VBP 37231 1041 31 , , , 37231 1041 32 but but CC 37231 1041 33 not not RB 37231 1041 34 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 35 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1041 36 _ _ NNP 37231 1041 37 to to IN 37231 1041 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1041 39 . . . 37231 1042 1 " " `` 37231 1042 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1042 3 3 3 LS 37231 1042 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1042 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1042 6 Newman Newman NNP 37231 1042 7 , , , 37231 1042 8 in in IN 37231 1042 9 a a DT 37231 1042 10 similar similar JJ 37231 1042 11 strain strain NN 37231 1042 12 , , , 37231 1042 13 though though IN 37231 1042 14 with with IN 37231 1042 15 greater great JJR 37231 1042 16 directness directness NN 37231 1042 17 , , , 37231 1042 18 says say VBZ 37231 1042 19 : : : 37231 1042 20 " " `` 37231 1042 21 The the DT 37231 1042 22 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1042 23 of of IN 37231 1042 24 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1042 25 are be VBP 37231 1042 26 undeniably undeniably RB 37231 1042 27 beyond beyond IN 37231 1042 28 nature nature NN 37231 1042 29 ; ; : 37231 1042 30 " " '' 37231 1042 31 and and CC 37231 1042 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1042 33 explains explain VBZ 37231 1042 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1042 35 as as IN 37231 1042 36 " " `` 37231 1042 37 wrought work VBN 37231 1042 38 by by IN 37231 1042 39 persons person NNS 37231 1042 40 consciously consciously RB 37231 1042 41 exercising exercise VBG 37231 1042 42 , , , 37231 1042 43 under under IN 37231 1042 44 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1042 45 guidance guidance NN 37231 1042 46 , , , 37231 1042 47 a a DT 37231 1042 48 power power NN 37231 1042 49 committed commit VBN 37231 1042 50 to to IN 37231 1042 51 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1042 52 for for IN 37231 1042 53 definite definite JJ 37231 1042 54 ends end NNS 37231 1042 55 , , , 37231 1042 56 professing profess VBG 37231 1042 57 to to TO 37231 1042 58 be be VB 37231 1042 59 immediate immediate JJ 37231 1042 60 messengers messenger NNS 37231 1042 61 from from IN 37231 1042 62 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1042 63 , , , 37231 1042 64 and and CC 37231 1042 65 to to TO 37231 1042 66 be be VB 37231 1042 67 evidencing evidence VBG 37231 1042 68 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1042 69 mission mission NN 37231 1042 70 by by IN 37231 1042 71 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1042 72 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1042 73 . . . 37231 1043 1 " " `` 37231 1043 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1043 3 4 4 LS 37231 1043 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1043 5 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 1043 6 are be VBP 37231 1043 7 here here RB 37231 1043 8 described describe VBN 37231 1043 9 as as IN 37231 1043 10 " " `` 37231 1043 11 beside beside RB 37231 1043 12 , , , 37231 1043 13 " " '' 37231 1043 14 and and CC 37231 1043 15 " " `` 37231 1043 16 beyond beyond IN 37231 1043 17 , , , 37231 1043 18 " " '' 37231 1043 19 and and CC 37231 1043 20 " " `` 37231 1043 21 above above JJ 37231 1043 22 " " '' 37231 1043 23 nature nature NN 37231 1043 24 , , , 37231 1043 25 but but CC 37231 1043 26 a a DT 37231 1043 27 moment moment NN 37231 1043 28 's 's POS 37231 1043 29 consideration consideration NN 37231 1043 30 must must MD 37231 1043 31 { { -LRB- 37231 1043 32 31 31 CD 37231 1043 33 } } -RRB- 37231 1043 34 show show VBP 37231 1043 35 that that IN 37231 1043 36 , , , 37231 1043 37 in in IN 37231 1043 38 so so RB 37231 1043 39 far far RB 37231 1043 40 as as IN 37231 1043 41 these these DT 37231 1043 42 terms term NNS 37231 1043 43 have have VBP 37231 1043 44 any any DT 37231 1043 45 meaning meaning NN 37231 1043 46 at at RB 37231 1043 47 all all RB 37231 1043 48 , , , 37231 1043 49 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1043 50 are be VBP 37231 1043 51 simply simply RB 37231 1043 52 evasions evasion NNS 37231 1043 53 , , , 37231 1043 54 not not RB 37231 1043 55 solutions solution NNS 37231 1043 56 , , , 37231 1043 57 of of IN 37231 1043 58 a a DT 37231 1043 59 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1043 60 . . . 37231 1044 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1044 2 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1044 3 is be VBZ 37231 1044 4 quite quite RB 37231 1044 5 sensible sensible JJ 37231 1044 6 of of IN 37231 1044 7 the the DT 37231 1044 8 danger danger NN 37231 1044 9 in in IN 37231 1044 10 which which WDT 37231 1044 11 the the DT 37231 1044 12 definition definition NN 37231 1044 13 of of IN 37231 1044 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1044 15 places place VBZ 37231 1044 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1044 17 , , , 37231 1044 18 and and CC 37231 1044 19 how how WRB 37231 1044 20 fatal fatal JJ 37231 1044 21 to to IN 37231 1044 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1044 23 argument argument NN 37231 1044 24 is be VBZ 37231 1044 25 would would MD 37231 1044 26 be be VB 37231 1044 27 to to TO 37231 1044 28 admit admit VB 37231 1044 29 that that IN 37231 1044 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1044 31 are be VBP 37231 1044 32 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1044 33 to to IN 37231 1044 34 the the DT 37231 1044 35 order order NN 37231 1044 36 of of IN 37231 1044 37 nature nature NN 37231 1044 38 . . . 37231 1045 1 " " `` 37231 1045 2 The the DT 37231 1045 3 miracle miracle NN 37231 1045 4 , , , 37231 1045 5 " " '' 37231 1045 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1045 7 protests protest VBZ 37231 1045 8 , , , 37231 1045 9 " " '' 37231 1045 10 is be VBZ 37231 1045 11 not not RB 37231 1045 12 thus thus RB 37231 1045 13 _ _ NNP 37231 1045 14 unnatural unnatural JJ 37231 1045 15 _ _ NNP 37231 1045 16 ; ; : 37231 1045 17 nor nor CC 37231 1045 18 could could MD 37231 1045 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1045 20 be be VB 37231 1045 21 such such JJ 37231 1045 22 , , , 37231 1045 23 since since IN 37231 1045 24 the the DT 37231 1045 25 unnatural unnatural NN 37231 1045 26 , , , 37231 1045 27 the the DT 37231 1045 28 contrary contrary NN 37231 1045 29 to to TO 37231 1045 30 order order NN 37231 1045 31 , , , 37231 1045 32 is be VBZ 37231 1045 33 of of IN 37231 1045 34 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1045 35 the the DT 37231 1045 36 ungodly ungodly JJ 37231 1045 37 , , , 37231 1045 38 and and CC 37231 1045 39 can can MD 37231 1045 40 in in IN 37231 1045 41 no no DT 37231 1045 42 way way NN 37231 1045 43 , , , 37231 1045 44 therefore therefore RB 37231 1045 45 , , , 37231 1045 46 be be VB 37231 1045 47 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 1045 48 of of IN 37231 1045 49 a a DT 37231 1045 50 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1045 51 work work NN 37231 1045 52 , , , 37231 1045 53 such such JJ 37231 1045 54 as as IN 37231 1045 55 that that DT 37231 1045 56 with with IN 37231 1045 57 which which WDT 37231 1045 58 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1045 59 have have VBP 37231 1045 60 to to TO 37231 1045 61 do do VB 37231 1045 62 . . . 37231 1046 1 " " `` 37231 1046 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1046 3 1 1 LS 37231 1046 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1046 5 The the DT 37231 1046 6 archbishop archbishop NN 37231 1046 7 in in IN 37231 1046 8 this this DT 37231 1046 9 ; ; : 37231 1046 10 however however RB 37231 1046 11 , , , 37231 1046 12 is be VBZ 37231 1046 13 clearly clearly RB 37231 1046 14 arguing argue VBG 37231 1046 15 from from IN 37231 1046 16 nature nature NN 37231 1046 17 to to IN 37231 1046 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1046 19 , , , 37231 1046 20 and and CC 37231 1046 21 not not RB 37231 1046 22 from from IN 37231 1046 23 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1046 24 to to IN 37231 1046 25 nature nature NN 37231 1046 26 . . . 37231 1047 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1047 2 does do VBZ 37231 1047 3 not not RB 37231 1047 4 , , , 37231 1047 5 of of IN 37231 1047 6 course course NN 37231 1047 7 , , , 37231 1047 8 know know VB 37231 1047 9 what what WP 37231 1047 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1047 11 really really RB 37231 1047 12 are be VBP 37231 1047 13 , , , 37231 1047 14 but but CC 37231 1047 15 as as IN 37231 1047 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1047 17 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 1047 18 that that IN 37231 1047 19 the the DT 37231 1047 20 order order NN 37231 1047 21 of of IN 37231 1047 22 nature nature NN 37231 1047 23 must must MD 37231 1047 24 be be VB 37231 1047 25 maintained maintain VBN 37231 1047 26 , , , 37231 1047 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1047 28 is be VBZ 37231 1047 29 forced force VBN 37231 1047 30 to to TO 37231 1047 31 assert assert VB 37231 1047 32 that that IN 37231 1047 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1047 34 are be VBP 37231 1047 35 not not RB 37231 1047 36 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1047 37 to to IN 37231 1047 38 nature nature NN 37231 1047 39 . . . 37231 1048 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1048 2 repudiates repudiate VBZ 37231 1048 3 the the DT 37231 1048 4 idea idea NN 37231 1048 5 of of IN 37231 1048 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1048 7 being be VBG 37231 1048 8 natural natural JJ 37231 1048 9 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1048 10 ; ; : 37231 1048 11 and and CC 37231 1048 12 yet yet RB 37231 1048 13 attempts attempt VBZ 37231 1048 14 to to TO 37231 1048 15 deny deny VB 37231 1048 16 that that IN 37231 1048 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1048 18 are be VBP 37231 1048 19 unnatural unnatural JJ 37231 1048 20 . . . 37231 1049 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1049 2 must must MD 37231 1049 3 either either CC 37231 1049 4 be be VB 37231 1049 5 the the DT 37231 1049 6 one one CD 37231 1049 7 or or CC 37231 1049 8 the the DT 37231 1049 9 other other JJ 37231 1049 10 . . . 37231 1050 1 The the DT 37231 1050 2 archbishop archbishop NN 37231 1050 3 , , , 37231 1050 4 besides besides RB 37231 1050 5 ; ; , 37231 1050 6 forgets forget VBZ 37231 1050 7 that that IN 37231 1050 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1050 9 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 1050 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1050 11 to to IN 37231 1050 12 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1050 13 as as RB 37231 1050 14 well well RB 37231 1050 15 as as IN 37231 1050 16 to to IN 37231 1050 17 God God NNP 37231 1050 18 . . . 37231 1051 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 1051 2 , , , 37231 1051 3 that that IN 37231 1051 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1051 5 distinction distinction NN 37231 1051 6 is be VBZ 37231 1051 7 purely purely RB 37231 1051 8 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 1051 9 , , , 37231 1051 10 and and CC 37231 1051 11 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37231 1051 12 with with IN 37231 1051 13 the the DT 37231 1051 14 alleged allege VBN 37231 1051 15 facts fact NNS 37231 1051 16 of of IN 37231 1051 17 Scriptural scriptural JJ 37231 1051 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1051 19 , , , 37231 1051 20 is be VBZ 37231 1051 21 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1051 22 from from IN 37231 1051 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1051 24 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1051 25 's 's POS 37231 1051 26 own own JJ 37231 1051 27 illustrations illustration NNS 37231 1051 28 ; ; : 37231 1051 29 The the DT 37231 1051 30 whole whole JJ 37231 1051 31 argument argument NN 37231 1051 32 is be VBZ 37231 1051 33 a a DT 37231 1051 34 mere mere JJ 37231 1051 35 quibble quibble NN 37231 1051 36 of of IN 37231 1051 37 words word NNS 37231 1051 38 to to TO 37231 1051 39 evade evade VB 37231 1051 40 a a DT 37231 1051 41 palpable palpable JJ 37231 1051 42 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 1051 43 . . . 37231 1052 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1052 2 Newman Newman NNP 37231 1052 3 does do VBZ 37231 1052 4 not not RB 37231 1052 5 fall fall VB 37231 1052 6 into into IN 37231 1052 7 this this DT 37231 1052 8 error error NN 37231 1052 9 , , , 37231 1052 10 and and CC 37231 1052 11 more more RBR 37231 1052 12 boldly boldly RB 37231 1052 13 faces face VBZ 37231 1052 14 the the DT 37231 1052 15 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1052 16 . . . 37231 1053 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1053 2 admits admit VBZ 37231 1053 3 that that IN 37231 1053 4 the the DT 37231 1053 5 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1053 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1053 7 " " `` 37231 1053 8 innovate innovate VBP 37231 1053 9 upon upon IN 37231 1053 10 the the DT 37231 1053 11 impressions impression NNS 37231 1053 12 which which WDT 37231 1053 13 are be VBP 37231 1053 14 made make VBN 37231 1053 15 upon upon IN 37231 1053 16 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1053 17 by by IN 37231 1053 18 the the DT 37231 1053 19 order order NN 37231 1053 20 and and CC 37231 1053 21 the the DT 37231 1053 22 laws law NNS 37231 1053 23 of of IN 37231 1053 24 the the DT 37231 1053 25 natural natural JJ 37231 1053 26 world;"(2 world;"(2 ADD 37231 1053 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1053 28 and and CC 37231 1053 29 that that IN 37231 1053 30 " " `` 37231 1053 31 walking walk VBG 37231 1053 32 on on IN 37231 1053 33 the the DT 37231 1053 34 sea sea NN 37231 1053 35 , , , 37231 1053 36 or or CC 37231 1053 37 the the DT 37231 1053 38 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 1053 39 of of IN 37231 1053 40 the the DT 37231 1053 41 dead dead NN 37231 1053 42 , , , 37231 1053 43 is be VBZ 37231 1053 44 a a DT 37231 1053 45 plain plain JJ 37231 1053 46 reversal reversal NN 37231 1053 47 of of IN 37231 1053 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1053 49 laws law NNS 37231 1053 50 . . . 37231 1054 1 " " `` 37231 1054 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1054 3 3 3 LS 37231 1054 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1054 5 { { -LRB- 37231 1054 6 32 32 CD 37231 1054 7 } } -RRB- 37231 1054 8 Take take VB 37231 1054 9 , , , 37231 1054 10 for for IN 37231 1054 11 instance instance NN 37231 1054 12 , , , 37231 1054 13 the the DT 37231 1054 14 multiplication multiplication NN 37231 1054 15 of of IN 37231 1054 16 loaves loaf NNS 37231 1054 17 and and CC 37231 1054 18 fishes fish NNS 37231 1054 19 . . . 37231 1055 1 Five five CD 37231 1055 2 thousand thousand CD 37231 1055 3 people people NNS 37231 1055 4 are be VBP 37231 1055 5 fed feed VBN 37231 1055 6 upon upon IN 37231 1055 7 five five CD 37231 1055 8 barley barley NN 37231 1055 9 loaves loaf NNS 37231 1055 10 and and CC 37231 1055 11 two two CD 37231 1055 12 small small JJ 37231 1055 13 fishes fish NNS 37231 1055 14 : : : 37231 1055 15 " " `` 37231 1055 16 and and CC 37231 1055 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1055 18 took take VBD 37231 1055 19 up up RP 37231 1055 20 of of IN 37231 1055 21 the the DT 37231 1055 22 fragments fragment NNS 37231 1055 23 which which WDT 37231 1055 24 remained remain VBD 37231 1055 25 twelve twelve CD 37231 1055 26 baskets basket NNS 37231 1055 27 full full JJ 37231 1055 28 . . . 37231 1056 1 " " `` 37231 1056 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1056 3 1 1 LS 37231 1056 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1056 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1056 6 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1056 7 is be VBZ 37231 1056 8 forced force VBN 37231 1056 9 to to TO 37231 1056 10 renounce renounce VB 37231 1056 11 all all DT 37231 1056 12 help help NN 37231 1056 13 in in IN 37231 1056 14 explaining explain VBG 37231 1056 15 this this DT 37231 1056 16 miracle miracle NN 37231 1056 17 from from IN 37231 1056 18 natural natural JJ 37231 1056 19 analogies analogy NNS 37231 1056 20 , , , 37231 1056 21 and and CC 37231 1056 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1056 23 admits admit VBZ 37231 1056 24 : : : 37231 1056 25 " " `` 37231 1056 26 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1056 27 must must MD 37231 1056 28 simply simply RB 37231 1056 29 behold behold VB 37231 1056 30 in in RP 37231 1056 31 the the DT 37231 1056 32 multiplying multiplying NN 37231 1056 33 of of IN 37231 1056 34 the the DT 37231 1056 35 bread bread NN 37231 1056 36 " " '' 37231 1056 37 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1056 38 and and CC 37231 1056 39 fishes fish NNS 37231 1056 40 ? ? . 37231 1056 41 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1056 42 " " '' 37231 1057 1 an an DT 37231 1057 2 act act NN 37231 1057 3 of of IN 37231 1057 4 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1057 5 omnipotence omnipotence NN 37231 1057 6 on on IN 37231 1057 7 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1057 8 part part NN 37231 1057 9 who who WP 37231 1057 10 was be VBD 37231 1057 11 the the DT 37231 1057 12 Word Word NNP 37231 1057 13 of of IN 37231 1057 14 God,--not God,--not NNP 37231 1057 15 , , , 37231 1057 16 indeed indeed RB 37231 1057 17 , , , 37231 1057 18 now now RB 37231 1057 19 as as IN 37231 1057 20 at at IN 37231 1057 21 the the DT 37231 1057 22 first first JJ 37231 1057 23 , , , 37231 1057 24 of of IN 37231 1057 25 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1057 26 creation creation NN 37231 1057 27 out out IN 37231 1057 28 of of IN 37231 1057 29 nothing nothing NN 37231 1057 30 , , , 37231 1057 31 since since IN 37231 1057 32 there there EX 37231 1057 33 was be VBD 37231 1057 34 a a DT 37231 1057 35 substratum substratum NN 37231 1057 36 to to TO 37231 1057 37 work work VB 37231 1057 38 on on IN 37231 1057 39 in in IN 37231 1057 40 the the DT 37231 1057 41 original original JJ 37231 1057 42 loaves loaf NNS 37231 1057 43 and and CC 37231 1057 44 fishes fish NNS 37231 1057 45 , , , 37231 1057 46 but but CC 37231 1057 47 an an DT 37231 1057 48 act act NN 37231 1057 49 of of IN 37231 1057 50 creative creative JJ 37231 1057 51 accretion accretion NN 37231 1057 52 . . . 37231 1058 1 " " `` 37231 1058 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1058 3 2 2 LS 37231 1058 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1058 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1058 6 will will MD 37231 1058 7 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1058 8 be be VB 37231 1058 9 argued argue VBN 37231 1058 10 by by IN 37231 1058 11 any any DT 37231 1058 12 one one NN 37231 1058 13 that that WDT 37231 1058 14 such such PDT 37231 1058 15 an an DT 37231 1058 16 " " `` 37231 1058 17 act act NN 37231 1058 18 of of IN 37231 1058 19 Divine divine JJ 37231 1058 20 omnipotence omnipotence NN 37231 1058 21 " " '' 37231 1058 22 and and CC 37231 1058 23 " " `` 37231 1058 24 creative creative JJ 37231 1058 25 accretion accretion NN 37231 1058 26 " " '' 37231 1058 27 as as IN 37231 1058 28 this this DT 37231 1058 29 multiplication multiplication NN 37231 1058 30 of of IN 37231 1058 31 five five CD 37231 1058 32 baked baked JJ 37231 1058 33 loaves loaf NNS 37231 1058 34 and and CC 37231 1058 35 two two CD 37231 1058 36 small small JJ 37231 1058 37 fishes fish NNS 37231 1058 38 is be VBZ 37231 1058 39 not not RB 37231 1058 40 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1058 41 to to IN 37231 1058 42 the the DT 37231 1058 43 order order NN 37231 1058 44 of of IN 37231 1058 45 nature nature NN 37231 1058 46 . . . 37231 1059 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1059 2 3 3 LS 37231 1059 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1059 4 For for IN 37231 1059 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1059 6 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1059 7 has have VBZ 37231 1059 8 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1059 9 pointed point VBN 37231 1059 10 out out RP 37231 1059 11 that that IN 37231 1059 12 there there EX 37231 1059 13 must must MD 37231 1059 14 be be VB 37231 1059 15 interposition interposition NN 37231 1059 16 of of IN 37231 1059 17 man man NN 37231 1059 18 's 's POS 37231 1059 19 art art NN 37231 1059 20 here here RB 37231 1059 21 , , , 37231 1059 22 and and CC 37231 1059 23 that that IN 37231 1059 24 " " `` 37231 1059 25 a a DT 37231 1059 26 grain grain NN 37231 1059 27 of of IN 37231 1059 28 wheat wheat NN 37231 1059 29 could could MD 37231 1059 30 never never RB 37231 1059 31 by by IN 37231 1059 32 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1059 33 , , , 37231 1059 34 and and CC 37231 1059 35 according accord VBG 37231 1059 36 to to IN 37231 1059 37 the the DT 37231 1059 38 laws law NNS 37231 1059 39 of of IN 37231 1059 40 natural natural JJ 37231 1059 41 development development NN 37231 1059 42 , , , 37231 1059 43 issue issue NN 37231 1059 44 in in IN 37231 1059 45 a a DT 37231 1059 46 loaf loaf NN 37231 1059 47 of of IN 37231 1059 48 bread bread NN 37231 1059 49 . . . 37231 1060 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1060 2 4 4 LS 37231 1060 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1060 4 Undaunted undaunte VBN 37231 1060 5 by by IN 37231 1060 6 , , , 37231 1060 7 or or CC 37231 1060 8 rather rather RB 37231 1060 9 unconscious unconscious JJ 37231 1060 10 of of IN 37231 1060 11 , , , 37231 1060 12 such such JJ 37231 1060 13 contradictions contradiction NNS 37231 1060 14 , , , 37231 1060 15 the the DT 37231 1060 16 archbishop archbishop NN 37231 1060 17 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1060 18 with with IN 37231 1060 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1060 20 argument argument NN 37231 1060 21 , , , 37231 1060 22 and and CC 37231 1060 23 with with IN 37231 1060 24 new new JJ 37231 1060 25 definitions definition NNS 37231 1060 26 of of IN 37231 1060 27 the the DT 37231 1060 28 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1060 29 . . . 37231 1061 1 So so RB 37231 1061 2 far far RB 37231 1061 3 from from IN 37231 1061 4 being be VBG 37231 1061 5 disorder disorder NN 37231 1061 6 of of IN 37231 1061 7 nature nature NN 37231 1061 8 , , , 37231 1061 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1061 10 continues continue VBZ 37231 1061 11 with with IN 37231 1061 12 audacious audacious JJ 37231 1061 13 precision precision NN 37231 1061 14 : : : 37231 1061 15 " " `` 37231 1061 16 the the DT 37231 1061 17 true true JJ 37231 1061 18 miracle miracle NN 37231 1061 19 is be VBZ 37231 1061 20 a a DT 37231 1061 21 higher high JJR 37231 1061 22 and and CC 37231 1061 23 a a DT 37231 1061 24 purer purer NN 37231 1061 25 { { -LRB- 37231 1061 26 33 33 CD 37231 1061 27 } } -RRB- 37231 1061 28 nature nature NN 37231 1061 29 coming come VBG 37231 1061 30 down down RP 37231 1061 31 out out IN 37231 1061 32 of of IN 37231 1061 33 the the DT 37231 1061 34 world world NN 37231 1061 35 of of IN 37231 1061 36 untroubled untroubled JJ 37231 1061 37 harmonies harmony NNS 37231 1061 38 into into IN 37231 1061 39 this this DT 37231 1061 40 world world NN 37231 1061 41 of of IN 37231 1061 42 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 1061 43 , , , 37231 1061 44 which which WDT 37231 1061 45 so so RB 37231 1061 46 many many JJ 37231 1061 47 discords discord NNS 37231 1061 48 have have VBP 37231 1061 49 jarred jar VBN 37231 1061 50 and and CC 37231 1061 51 disturbed disturb VBN 37231 1061 52 , , , 37231 1061 53 and and CC 37231 1061 54 bringing bring VBG 37231 1061 55 this this DT 37231 1061 56 back back RP 37231 1061 57 again again RB 37231 1061 58 , , , 37231 1061 59 though though IN 37231 1061 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1061 61 be be VB 37231 1061 62 but but CC 37231 1061 63 for for IN 37231 1061 64 one one CD 37231 1061 65 mysterious mysterious JJ 37231 1061 66 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 1061 67 moment moment NN 37231 1061 68 , , , 37231 1061 69 into into IN 37231 1061 70 harmony harmony NN 37231 1061 71 with with IN 37231 1061 72 that that DT 37231 1061 73 higher high JJR 37231 1061 74 . . . 37231 1062 1 " " `` 37231 1062 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1062 3 1 1 LS 37231 1062 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1062 5 In in IN 37231 1062 6 that that DT 37231 1062 7 " " `` 37231 1062 8 higher high JJR 37231 1062 9 and and CC 37231 1062 10 purer purer NN 37231 1062 11 nature nature NN 37231 1062 12 " " '' 37231 1062 13 can can MD 37231 1062 14 a a DT 37231 1062 15 grain grain NN 37231 1062 16 of of IN 37231 1062 17 wheat wheat NN 37231 1062 18 issue issue NN 37231 1062 19 in in IN 37231 1062 20 a a DT 37231 1062 21 loaf loaf NN 37231 1062 22 of of IN 37231 1062 23 bread bread NN 37231 1062 24 ? ? . 37231 1063 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1063 2 have have VBP 37231 1063 3 only only RB 37231 1063 4 to to TO 37231 1063 5 apply apply VB 37231 1063 6 this this DT 37231 1063 7 theory theory NN 37231 1063 8 to to IN 37231 1063 9 the the DT 37231 1063 10 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1063 11 multiplication multiplication NN 37231 1063 12 of of IN 37231 1063 13 loaves loaf NNS 37231 1063 14 and and CC 37231 1063 15 fishes fish VBZ 37231 1063 16 to to TO 37231 1063 17 perceive perceive VB 37231 1063 18 how how WRB 37231 1063 19 completely completely RB 37231 1063 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1063 21 is be VBZ 37231 1063 22 the the DT 37231 1063 23 creation creation NN 37231 1063 24 of of IN 37231 1063 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1063 26 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1063 27 's 's POS 37231 1063 28 poetical poetical JJ 37231 1063 29 fancy fancy NN 37231 1063 30 . . . 37231 1064 1 These these DT 37231 1064 2 passages passage NNS 37231 1064 3 fairly fairly RB 37231 1064 4 illustrate illustrate VBP 37231 1064 5 the the DT 37231 1064 6 purely purely RB 37231 1064 7 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 1064 8 and and CC 37231 1064 9 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 1064 10 nature nature NN 37231 1064 11 of of IN 37231 1064 12 the the DT 37231 1064 13 definitions definition NNS 37231 1064 14 which which WDT 37231 1064 15 those those DT 37231 1064 16 who who WP 37231 1064 17 maintain maintain VBP 37231 1064 18 the the DT 37231 1064 19 reality reality NN 37231 1064 20 and and CC 37231 1064 21 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1064 22 character character NN 37231 1064 23 of of IN 37231 1064 24 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1064 25 give give VBP 37231 1064 26 of of IN 37231 1064 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1064 28 . . . 37231 1065 1 That that DT 37231 1065 2 explanation explanation NN 37231 1065 3 is be VBZ 37231 1065 4 generally generally RB 37231 1065 5 adopted adopt VBN 37231 1065 6 which which WDT 37231 1065 7 seems seem VBZ 37231 1065 8 most most RBS 37231 1065 9 convenient convenient JJ 37231 1065 10 at at IN 37231 1065 11 the the DT 37231 1065 12 moment moment NN 37231 1065 13 , , , 37231 1065 14 and and CC 37231 1065 15 none none NN 37231 1065 16 ever ever RB 37231 1065 17 passes pass VBZ 37231 1065 18 , , , 37231 1065 19 or or CC 37231 1065 20 , , , 37231 1065 21 indeed indeed RB 37231 1065 22 , , , 37231 1065 23 ever ever RB 37231 1065 24 can can MD 37231 1065 25 pass pass VB 37231 1065 26 , , , 37231 1065 27 beyond beyond IN 37231 1065 28 the the DT 37231 1065 29 limits limit NNS 37231 1065 30 of of IN 37231 1065 31 assumption assumption NN 37231 1065 32 . . . 37231 1066 1 The the DT 37231 1066 2 favourite favourite JJ 37231 1066 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1066 4 is be VBZ 37231 1066 5 that that DT 37231 1066 6 which which WDT 37231 1066 7 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 1066 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1066 9 to to IN 37231 1066 10 the the DT 37231 1066 11 action action NN 37231 1066 12 of of IN 37231 1066 13 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1066 14 law law NN 37231 1066 15 . . . 37231 1067 1 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1067 2 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1067 3 naturally naturally RB 37231 1067 4 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 1067 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1067 6 : : : 37231 1067 7 " " `` 37231 1067 8 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1067 9 should should MD 37231 1067 10 see see VB 37231 1067 11 in in IN 37231 1067 12 the the DT 37231 1067 13 miracle miracle NN 37231 1067 14 , , , 37231 1067 15 " " '' 37231 1067 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1067 17 says say VBZ 37231 1067 18 , , , 37231 1067 19 " " `` 37231 1067 20 not not RB 37231 1067 21 the the DT 37231 1067 22 infraction infraction NN 37231 1067 23 of of IN 37231 1067 24 a a DT 37231 1067 25 law law NN 37231 1067 26 , , , 37231 1067 27 but but CC 37231 1067 28 the the DT 37231 1067 29 neutralizing neutralizing NN 37231 1067 30 of of IN 37231 1067 31 a a DT 37231 1067 32 lower low JJR 37231 1067 33 law law NN 37231 1067 34 , , , 37231 1067 35 the the DT 37231 1067 36 suspension suspension NN 37231 1067 37 of of IN 37231 1067 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1067 39 for for IN 37231 1067 40 a a DT 37231 1067 41 time time NN 37231 1067 42 by by IN 37231 1067 43 a a DT 37231 1067 44 higher high JJR 37231 1067 45 ; ; : 37231 1067 46 " " `` 37231 1067 47 and and CC 37231 1067 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1067 49 asks ask VBZ 37231 1067 50 with with IN 37231 1067 51 indignation indignation NN 37231 1067 52 , , , 37231 1067 53 whence whence NN 37231 1067 54 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1067 55 dare dare VBP 37231 1067 56 conclude conclude VB 37231 1067 57 that that IN 37231 1067 58 , , , 37231 1067 59 because because IN 37231 1067 60 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1067 61 know know VBP 37231 1067 62 of of IN 37231 1067 63 no no DT 37231 1067 64 powers power NNS 37231 1067 65 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1067 66 to to TO 37231 1067 67 produce produce VB 37231 1067 68 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1067 69 , , , 37231 1067 70 none none NN 37231 1067 71 exist exist VBP 37231 1067 72 . . . 37231 1068 1 " " `` 37231 1068 2 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1068 3 exceed exceed VBP 37231 1068 4 the the DT 37231 1068 5 laws law NNS 37231 1068 6 of of IN 37231 1068 7 _ _ NNP 37231 1068 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1068 9 _ _ NNP 37231 1068 10 nature nature NN 37231 1068 11 ; ; : 37231 1068 12 but but CC 37231 1068 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1068 14 does do VBZ 37231 1068 15 not not RB 37231 1068 16 therefore therefore RB 37231 1068 17 follow follow VB 37231 1068 18 that that IN 37231 1068 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1068 20 exceed exceed VBP 37231 1068 21 the the DT 37231 1068 22 laws law NNS 37231 1068 23 of of IN 37231 1068 24 _ _ NNP 37231 1068 25 all all DT 37231 1068 26 _ _ NNP 37231 1068 27 nature nature NN 37231 1068 28 . . . 37231 1069 1 " " `` 37231 1069 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1069 3 2 2 LS 37231 1069 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1069 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1069 6 is be VBZ 37231 1069 7 not not RB 37231 1069 8 easy easy JJ 37231 1069 9 { { -LRB- 37231 1069 10 34 34 CD 37231 1069 11 } } -RRB- 37231 1069 12 to to TO 37231 1069 13 follow follow VB 37231 1069 14 the the DT 37231 1069 15 distinction distinction NN 37231 1069 16 here here RB 37231 1069 17 between between IN 37231 1069 18 " " `` 37231 1069 19 _ _ NNP 37231 1069 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1069 21 _ _ NNP 37231 1069 22 nature nature NN 37231 1069 23 " " '' 37231 1069 24 and and CC 37231 1069 25 " " `` 37231 1069 26 _ _ NNP 37231 1069 27 all all DT 37231 1069 28 nature nature NN 37231 1069 29 _ _ NNP 37231 1069 30 , , , 37231 1069 31 " " `` 37231 1069 32 since since IN 37231 1069 33 the the DT 37231 1069 34 order order NN 37231 1069 35 of of IN 37231 1069 36 nature nature NN 37231 1069 37 , , , 37231 1069 38 by by IN 37231 1069 39 which which WDT 37231 1069 40 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1069 41 are be VBP 37231 1069 42 judged judge VBN 37231 1069 43 , , , 37231 1069 44 is be VBZ 37231 1069 45 , , , 37231 1069 46 so so RB 37231 1069 47 far far RB 37231 1069 48 as as IN 37231 1069 49 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1069 50 goes go VBZ 37231 1069 51 , , , 37231 1069 52 universal universal JJ 37231 1069 53 , , , 37231 1069 54 and and CC 37231 1069 55 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1069 56 have have VBP 37231 1069 57 no no DT 37231 1069 58 grounds ground NNS 37231 1069 59 for for IN 37231 1069 60 assuming assume VBG 37231 1069 61 that that IN 37231 1069 62 there there EX 37231 1069 63 is be VBZ 37231 1069 64 any any DT 37231 1069 65 other other JJ 37231 1069 66 . . . 37231 1070 1 The the DT 37231 1070 2 same same JJ 37231 1070 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1070 4 is be VBZ 37231 1070 5 elaborated elaborate VBN 37231 1070 6 by by IN 37231 1070 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1070 8 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1070 9 . . . 37231 1071 1 Assuming assume VBG 37231 1071 2 the the DT 37231 1071 3 facts fact NNS 37231 1071 4 of of IN 37231 1071 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1071 6 , , , 37231 1071 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1071 8 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1071 9 to to TO 37231 1071 10 discuss discuss VB 37231 1071 11 the the DT 37231 1071 12 question question NN 37231 1071 13 of of IN 37231 1071 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1071 15 " " `` 37231 1071 16 referribleness referribleness JJ 37231 1071 17 to to IN 37231 1071 18 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1071 19 law law NN 37231 1071 20 , , , 37231 1071 21 " " '' 37231 1071 22 in in IN 37231 1071 23 which which WDT 37231 1071 24 expression expression NN 37231 1071 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1071 26 includes include VBZ 37231 1071 27 both both DT 37231 1071 28 " " `` 37231 1071 29 _ _ NNP 37231 1071 30 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1071 31 law law NN 37231 1071 32 _ _ NNP 37231 1071 33 , , , 37231 1071 34 or or CC 37231 1071 35 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1071 36 connexion connexion NN 37231 1071 37 with with IN 37231 1071 38 _ _ NNP 37231 1071 39 known know VBN 37231 1071 40 _ _ NNP 37231 1071 41 law law NN 37231 1071 42 . . . 37231 1072 1 " " `` 37231 1072 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1072 3 1 1 LS 37231 1072 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1072 5 Taking take VBG 37231 1072 6 first first RB 37231 1072 7 the the DT 37231 1072 8 supposition supposition NN 37231 1072 9 of of IN 37231 1072 10 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1072 11 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1072 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1072 13 connection connection NN 37231 1072 14 with with IN 37231 1072 15 known know VBN 37231 1072 16 law law NN 37231 1072 17 , , , 37231 1072 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1072 19 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1072 20 argues argue VBZ 37231 1072 21 that that IN 37231 1072 22 , , , 37231 1072 23 as as IN 37231 1072 24 a a DT 37231 1072 25 law law NN 37231 1072 26 of of IN 37231 1072 27 nature nature NN 37231 1072 28 , , , 37231 1072 29 in in IN 37231 1072 30 the the DT 37231 1072 31 scientific scientific JJ 37231 1072 32 sense sense NN 37231 1072 33 , , , 37231 1072 34 can can MD 37231 1072 35 not not RB 37231 1072 36 possibly possibly RB 37231 1072 37 produce produce VB 37231 1072 38 single single JJ 37231 1072 39 or or CC 37231 1072 40 isolated isolated JJ 37231 1072 41 facts fact NNS 37231 1072 42 , , , 37231 1072 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1072 44 follows follow VBZ 37231 1072 45 that that IN 37231 1072 46 no no DT 37231 1072 47 isolated isolated JJ 37231 1072 48 or or CC 37231 1072 49 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 1072 50 event event NN 37231 1072 51 can can MD 37231 1072 52 come come VB 37231 1072 53 under under IN 37231 1072 54 a a DT 37231 1072 55 law law NN 37231 1072 56 of of IN 37231 1072 57 nature nature NN 37231 1072 58 _ _ NNP 37231 1072 59 by by IN 37231 1072 60 direct direct JJ 37231 1072 61 observation observation NN 37231 1072 62 _ _ NNP 37231 1072 63 , , , 37231 1072 64 but but CC 37231 1072 65 , , , 37231 1072 66 if if IN 37231 1072 67 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1072 68 comes come VBZ 37231 1072 69 under under IN 37231 1072 70 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1072 71 at at RB 37231 1072 72 all all RB 37231 1072 73 , , , 37231 1072 74 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1072 75 can can MD 37231 1072 76 only only RB 37231 1072 77 do do VB 37231 1072 78 so so RB 37231 1072 79 by by IN 37231 1072 80 some some DT 37231 1072 81 _ _ NNP 37231 1072 82 explanation explanation NN 37231 1072 83 _ _ NNP 37231 1072 84 , , , 37231 1072 85 which which WDT 37231 1072 86 takes take VBZ 37231 1072 87 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1072 88 out out IN 37231 1072 89 of of IN 37231 1072 90 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1072 91 isolation isolation NN 37231 1072 92 and and CC 37231 1072 93 joins join VBZ 37231 1072 94 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1072 95 to to IN 37231 1072 96 a a DT 37231 1072 97 class class NN 37231 1072 98 of of IN 37231 1072 99 facts fact NNS 37231 1072 100 , , , 37231 1072 101 whose whose WP$ 37231 1072 102 recurrence recurrence NN 37231 1072 103 indeed indeed RB 37231 1072 104 constitutes constitute VBZ 37231 1072 105 the the DT 37231 1072 106 law law NN 37231 1072 107 . . . 37231 1073 1 Now now RB 37231 1073 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1073 3 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1073 4 admits admit VBZ 37231 1073 5 that that IN 37231 1073 6 no no DT 37231 1073 7 explanation explanation NN 37231 1073 8 can can MD 37231 1073 9 be be VB 37231 1073 10 given give VBN 37231 1073 11 by by IN 37231 1073 12 which which WDT 37231 1073 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1073 14 can can MD 37231 1073 15 have have VB 37231 1073 16 an an DT 37231 1073 17 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1073 18 connexion connexion NN 37231 1073 19 with with IN 37231 1073 20 known known JJ 37231 1073 21 law law NN 37231 1073 22 . . . 37231 1074 1 Taking take VBG 37231 1074 2 the the DT 37231 1074 3 largest large JJS 37231 1074 4 class class NN 37231 1074 5 of of IN 37231 1074 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1074 7 , , , 37231 1074 8 bodily bodily RB 37231 1074 9 cures cure NNS 37231 1074 10 , , , 37231 1074 11 the the DT 37231 1074 12 correspondence correspondence NN 37231 1074 13 between between IN 37231 1074 14 a a DT 37231 1074 15 simple simple JJ 37231 1074 16 command command NN 37231 1074 17 or or CC 37231 1074 18 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 1074 19 notification notification NN 37231 1074 20 and and CC 37231 1074 21 the the DT 37231 1074 22 cure cure NN 37231 1074 23 is be VBZ 37231 1074 24 the the DT 37231 1074 25 chief chief JJ 37231 1074 26 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 1074 27 of of IN 37231 1074 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1074 29 , , , 37231 1074 30 and and CC 37231 1074 31 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 37231 1074 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1074 33 from from IN 37231 1074 34 mere mere JJ 37231 1074 35 marvels marvel NNS 37231 1074 36 . . . 37231 1075 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1075 2 35 35 CD 37231 1075 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1075 4 No no DT 37231 1075 5 violation violation NN 37231 1075 6 of of IN 37231 1075 7 any any DT 37231 1075 8 law law NN 37231 1075 9 of of IN 37231 1075 10 nature nature NN 37231 1075 11 takes take VBZ 37231 1075 12 place place NN 37231 1075 13 in in IN 37231 1075 14 either either CC 37231 1075 15 the the DT 37231 1075 16 cure cure NN 37231 1075 17 or or CC 37231 1075 18 the the DT 37231 1075 19 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 1075 20 announcement announcement NN 37231 1075 21 taken take VBN 37231 1075 22 separately separately RB 37231 1075 23 , , , 37231 1075 24 but but CC 37231 1075 25 the the DT 37231 1075 26 two two CD 37231 1075 27 , , , 37231 1075 28 taken take VBN 37231 1075 29 together together RB 37231 1075 30 , , , 37231 1075 31 are be VBP 37231 1075 32 the the DT 37231 1075 33 proof proof NN 37231 1075 34 of of IN 37231 1075 35 superhuman superhuman JJ 37231 1075 36 agency agency NN 37231 1075 37 . . . 37231 1076 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1076 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1076 3 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 1076 4 that that IN 37231 1076 5 no no DT 37231 1076 6 physical physical JJ 37231 1076 7 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1076 8 can can MD 37231 1076 9 be be VB 37231 1076 10 framed frame VBN 37231 1076 11 accounting account VBG 37231 1076 12 for for IN 37231 1076 13 the the DT 37231 1076 14 superhuman superhuman JJ 37231 1076 15 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1076 16 and and CC 37231 1076 17 power power NN 37231 1076 18 involved involve VBN 37231 1076 19 in in IN 37231 1076 20 this this DT 37231 1076 21 class class NN 37231 1076 22 of of IN 37231 1076 23 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1076 24 , , , 37231 1076 25 supposing suppose VBG 37231 1076 26 the the DT 37231 1076 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1076 28 to to TO 37231 1076 29 stand stand VB 37231 1076 30 as as IN 37231 1076 31 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1076 32 are be VBP 37231 1076 33 recorded record VBN 37231 1076 34 in in IN 37231 1076 35 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1076 36 . . . 37231 1077 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1077 2 1 1 LS 37231 1077 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1077 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1077 5 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1077 6 then then RB 37231 1077 7 shifts shift VBZ 37231 1077 8 the the DT 37231 1077 9 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 1077 10 to to IN 37231 1077 11 the the DT 37231 1077 12 other other JJ 37231 1077 13 and and CC 37231 1077 14 different different JJ 37231 1077 15 question question NN 37231 1077 16 , , , 37231 1077 17 whether whether IN 37231 1077 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1077 19 may may MD 37231 1077 20 not not RB 37231 1077 21 be be VB 37231 1077 22 instances instance NNS 37231 1077 23 of of IN 37231 1077 24 laws law NNS 37231 1077 25 which which WDT 37231 1077 26 are be VBP 37231 1077 27 as as RB 37231 1077 28 yet yet RB 37231 1077 29 wholly wholly RB 37231 1077 30 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1077 31 . . . 37231 1078 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1078 2 2 2 LS 37231 1078 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1078 4 This this DT 37231 1078 5 is be VBZ 37231 1078 6 generally generally RB 37231 1078 7 called call VBN 37231 1078 8 a a DT 37231 1078 9 question question NN 37231 1078 10 of of IN 37231 1078 11 " " `` 37231 1078 12 higher high JJR 37231 1078 13 law law NN 37231 1078 14 , , , 37231 1078 15 " " '' 37231 1078 16 --that --that NN 37231 1078 17 is be VBZ 37231 1078 18 to to TO 37231 1078 19 say say VB 37231 1078 20 , , , 37231 1078 21 a a DT 37231 1078 22 law law NN 37231 1078 23 which which WDT 37231 1078 24 comprehends comprehend VBZ 37231 1078 25 under under IN 37231 1078 26 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1078 27 two two CD 37231 1078 28 or or CC 37231 1078 29 more more RBR 37231 1078 30 lower lower RBR 37231 1078 31 or or CC 37231 1078 32 less less RBR 37231 1078 33 wide wide JJ 37231 1078 34 laws law NNS 37231 1078 35 . . . 37231 1079 1 And and CC 37231 1079 2 the the DT 37231 1079 3 principle principle NN 37231 1079 4 would would MD 37231 1079 5 be be VB 37231 1079 6 applicable applicable JJ 37231 1079 7 to to IN 37231 1079 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1079 9 by by IN 37231 1079 10 supposing suppose VBG 37231 1079 11 the the DT 37231 1079 12 existence existence NN 37231 1079 13 of of IN 37231 1079 14 an an DT 37231 1079 15 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1079 16 law law NN 37231 1079 17 , , , 37231 1079 18 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 1079 19 to to TO 37231 1079 20 be be VB 37231 1079 21 discovered discover VBN 37231 1079 22 , , , 37231 1079 23 under under IN 37231 1079 24 which which WDT 37231 1079 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1079 26 would would MD 37231 1079 27 come come VB 37231 1079 28 , , , 37231 1079 29 and and CC 37231 1079 30 then then RB 37231 1079 31 considering consider VBG 37231 1079 32 whether whether IN 37231 1079 33 this this DT 37231 1079 34 new new JJ 37231 1079 35 law law NN 37231 1079 36 of of IN 37231 1079 37 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1079 38 , , , 37231 1079 39 and and CC 37231 1079 40 the the DT 37231 1079 41 old old JJ 37231 1079 42 law law NN 37231 1079 43 of of IN 37231 1079 44 common common JJ 37231 1079 45 facts fact NNS 37231 1079 46 , , , 37231 1079 47 might may MD 37231 1079 48 not not RB 37231 1079 49 both both DT 37231 1079 50 be be VB 37231 1079 51 reducible reducible JJ 37231 1079 52 to to IN 37231 1079 53 a a DT 37231 1079 54 still still RB 37231 1079 55 more more RBR 37231 1079 56 general general JJ 37231 1079 57 law law NN 37231 1079 58 which which WDT 37231 1079 59 comprehended comprehend VBD 37231 1079 60 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1079 61 both both DT 37231 1079 62 . . . 37231 1080 1 Now now RB 37231 1080 2 a a DT 37231 1080 3 law law NN 37231 1080 4 of of IN 37231 1080 5 nature nature NN 37231 1080 6 , , , 37231 1080 7 in in IN 37231 1080 8 the the DT 37231 1080 9 scientific scientific JJ 37231 1080 10 sense sense NN 37231 1080 11 , , , 37231 1080 12 can can MD 37231 1080 13 not not RB 37231 1080 14 exist exist VB 37231 1080 15 without without IN 37231 1080 16 a a DT 37231 1080 17 class class NN 37231 1080 18 of of IN 37231 1080 19 facts fact NNS 37231 1080 20 which which WDT 37231 1080 21 comes come VBZ 37231 1080 22 under under IN 37231 1080 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1080 24 , , , 37231 1080 25 and and CC 37231 1080 26 in in IN 37231 1080 27 reality reality NN 37231 1080 28 constitutes constitute VBZ 37231 1080 29 the the DT 37231 1080 30 law law NN 37231 1080 31 ; ; : 37231 1080 32 but but CC 37231 1080 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1080 34 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1080 35 of of IN 37231 1080 36 course course NN 37231 1080 37 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 1080 38 that that IN 37231 1080 39 the the DT 37231 1080 40 discovery discovery NN 37231 1080 41 of of IN 37231 1080 42 such such PDT 37231 1080 43 a a DT 37231 1080 44 law law NN 37231 1080 45 of of IN 37231 1080 46 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1080 47 would would MD 37231 1080 48 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 1080 49 involve involve VB 37231 1080 50 the the DT 37231 1080 51 discovery discovery NN 37231 1080 52 of of IN 37231 1080 53 fresh fresh JJ 37231 1080 54 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1080 55 , , , 37231 1080 56 for for IN 37231 1080 57 to to TO 37231 1080 58 talk talk VB 37231 1080 59 of of IN 37231 1080 60 a a DT 37231 1080 61 law law NN 37231 1080 62 of of IN 37231 1080 63 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1080 64 without without IN 37231 1080 65 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1080 66 would would MD 37231 1080 67 be be VB 37231 1080 68 an an DT 37231 1080 69 absurdity absurdity NN 37231 1080 70 . . . 37231 1081 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1081 2 3 3 LS 37231 1081 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1081 4 The the DT 37231 1081 5 supposition supposition NN 37231 1081 6 of of IN 37231 1081 7 the the DT 37231 1081 8 discovery discovery NN 37231 1081 9 of of IN 37231 1081 10 such such PDT 37231 1081 11 a a DT 37231 1081 12 law law NN 37231 1081 13 of of IN 37231 1081 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1081 15 , , , 37231 1081 16 however however RB 37231 1081 17 , , , 37231 1081 18 would would MD 37231 1081 19 be be VB 37231 1081 20 tantamount tantamount JJ 37231 1081 21 to to IN 37231 1081 22 the the DT 37231 1081 23 supposition supposition NN 37231 1081 24 of of IN 37231 1081 25 a a DT 37231 1081 26 future future JJ 37231 1081 27 new new JJ 37231 1081 28 order order NN 37231 1081 29 of of IN 37231 1081 30 nature nature NN 37231 1081 31 , , , 37231 1081 32 from from IN 37231 1081 33 which which WDT 37231 1081 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1081 35 immediately immediately RB 37231 1081 36 follows follow VBZ 37231 1081 37 that that IN 37231 1081 38 the the DT 37231 1081 39 whole whole JJ 37231 1081 40 supposition supposition NN 37231 1081 41 is be VBZ 37231 1081 42 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 37231 1081 43 and and CC 37231 1081 44 futile futile JJ 37231 1081 45 as as IN 37231 1081 46 regards regard VBZ 37231 1081 47 the the DT 37231 1081 48 present present JJ 37231 1081 49 question question NN 37231 1081 50 . . . 37231 1082 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1082 2 4 4 LS 37231 1082 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1082 4 { { -LRB- 37231 1082 5 36 36 CD 37231 1082 6 } } -RRB- 37231 1082 7 For for IN 37231 1082 8 no no DT 37231 1082 9 new new JJ 37231 1082 10 order order NN 37231 1082 11 of of IN 37231 1082 12 things thing NNS 37231 1082 13 could could MD 37231 1082 14 make make VB 37231 1082 15 the the DT 37231 1082 16 present present JJ 37231 1082 17 order order NN 37231 1082 18 different different JJ 37231 1082 19 , , , 37231 1082 20 and and CC 37231 1082 21 a a DT 37231 1082 22 miracle miracle NN 37231 1082 23 , , , 37231 1082 24 could could MD 37231 1082 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1082 26 suppose suppose VB 37231 1082 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1082 28 becoming become VBG 37231 1082 29 the the DT 37231 1082 30 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 1082 31 fact fact NN 37231 1082 32 of of IN 37231 1082 33 another another DT 37231 1082 34 different different JJ 37231 1082 35 order order NN 37231 1082 36 of of IN 37231 1082 37 nature nature NN 37231 1082 38 , , , 37231 1082 39 would would MD 37231 1082 40 not not RB 37231 1082 41 be be VB 37231 1082 42 less less JJR 37231 1082 43 a a DT 37231 1082 44 violation violation NN 37231 1082 45 of of IN 37231 1082 46 the the DT 37231 1082 47 laws law NNS 37231 1082 48 of of IN 37231 1082 49 nature nature NN 37231 1082 50 in in IN 37231 1082 51 the the DT 37231 1082 52 present present JJ 37231 1082 53 one one CD 37231 1082 54 . . . 37231 1083 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1083 2 1 1 LS 37231 1083 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1083 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1083 5 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1083 6 also also RB 37231 1083 7 rejects reject VBZ 37231 1083 8 this this DT 37231 1083 9 explanation explanation NN 37231 1083 10 . . . 37231 1084 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1084 2 pause pause VBP 37231 1084 3 here here RB 37231 1084 4 to to TO 37231 1084 5 remark remark VB 37231 1084 6 that that IN 37231 1084 7 , , , 37231 1084 8 throughout throughout IN 37231 1084 9 the the DT 37231 1084 10 whole whole JJ 37231 1084 11 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 1084 12 into into IN 37231 1084 13 the the DT 37231 1084 14 question question NN 37231 1084 15 of of IN 37231 1084 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1084 17 , , , 37231 1084 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1084 19 meet meet VBP 37231 1084 20 with with IN 37231 1084 21 nothing nothing NN 37231 1084 22 from from IN 37231 1084 23 theologians theologian NNS 37231 1084 24 but but CC 37231 1084 25 mere mere JJ 37231 1084 26 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1084 27 , , , 37231 1084 28 against against IN 37231 1084 29 which which WDT 37231 1084 30 the the DT 37231 1084 31 invariability invariability NN 37231 1084 32 of of IN 37231 1084 33 the the DT 37231 1084 34 known know VBN 37231 1084 35 order order NN 37231 1084 36 of of IN 37231 1084 37 nature nature NN 37231 1084 38 steadily steadily RB 37231 1084 39 opposes oppose VBZ 37231 1084 40 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1084 41 . . . 37231 1085 1 The the DT 37231 1085 2 facts fact NNS 37231 1085 3 of of IN 37231 1085 4 the the DT 37231 1085 5 narrative narrative NN 37231 1085 6 of of IN 37231 1085 7 the the DT 37231 1085 8 miracle miracle NN 37231 1085 9 are be VBP 37231 1085 10 first first RB 37231 1085 11 assumed assume VBN 37231 1085 12 , , , 37231 1085 13 and and CC 37231 1085 14 so so RB 37231 1085 15 are be VBP 37231 1085 16 the the DT 37231 1085 17 theories theory NNS 37231 1085 18 by by IN 37231 1085 19 which which WDT 37231 1085 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1085 21 is be VBZ 37231 1085 22 explained explain VBN 37231 1085 23 . . . 37231 1086 1 Now now RB 37231 1086 2 , , , 37231 1086 3 with with IN 37231 1086 4 regard regard NN 37231 1086 5 to to IN 37231 1086 6 every every DT 37231 1086 7 theory theory NN 37231 1086 8 which which WDT 37231 1086 9 seeks seek VBZ 37231 1086 10 to to TO 37231 1086 11 explain explain VB 37231 1086 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1086 13 by by IN 37231 1086 14 assumption assumption NN 37231 1086 15 , , , 37231 1086 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1086 17 may may MD 37231 1086 18 quote quote VB 37231 1086 19 words word NNS 37231 1086 20 applied apply VBN 37231 1086 21 by by IN 37231 1086 22 one one CD 37231 1086 23 of of IN 37231 1086 24 the the DT 37231 1086 25 ablest able JJS 37231 1086 26 defenders defender NNS 37231 1086 27 of of IN 37231 1086 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1086 29 to to IN 37231 1086 30 some some DT 37231 1086 31 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1086 32 of of IN 37231 1086 33 straw straw NN 37231 1086 34 , , , 37231 1086 35 which which WDT 37231 1086 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1086 37 placed place VBD 37231 1086 38 in in IN 37231 1086 39 the the DT 37231 1086 40 mouth mouth NN 37231 1086 41 of of IN 37231 1086 42 an an DT 37231 1086 43 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 1086 44 antagonist antagonist NN 37231 1086 45 in in IN 37231 1086 46 order order NN 37231 1086 47 that that IN 37231 1086 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1086 49 might may MD 37231 1086 50 refute refute VB 37231 1086 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1086 52 : : : 37231 1086 53 " " `` 37231 1086 54 But but CC 37231 1086 55 the the DT 37231 1086 56 question question NN 37231 1086 57 is be VBZ 37231 1086 58 , , , 37231 1086 59 " " '' 37231 1086 60 said say VBD 37231 1086 61 the the DT 37231 1086 62 late late JJ 37231 1086 63 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1086 64 of of IN 37231 1086 65 St. St. NNP 37231 1086 66 Paul Paul NNP 37231 1086 67 's 's POS 37231 1086 68 , , , 37231 1086 69 " " `` 37231 1086 70 not not RB 37231 1086 71 whether whether IN 37231 1086 72 such such PDT 37231 1086 73 a a DT 37231 1086 74 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1086 75 has have VBZ 37231 1086 76 been be VBN 37231 1086 77 asserted assert VBN 37231 1086 78 , , , 37231 1086 79 as as RB 37231 1086 80 many many JJ 37231 1086 81 other other JJ 37231 1086 82 absurdities absurdity NNS 37231 1086 83 have have VBP 37231 1086 84 been be VBN 37231 1086 85 asserted assert VBN 37231 1086 86 , , , 37231 1086 87 by by IN 37231 1086 88 the the DT 37231 1086 89 advocates advocate NNS 37231 1086 90 of of IN 37231 1086 91 a a DT 37231 1086 92 theory theory NN 37231 1086 93 , , , 37231 1086 94 but but CC 37231 1086 95 whether whether IN 37231 1086 96 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1086 97 has have VBZ 37231 1086 98 been be VBN 37231 1086 99 established establish VBN 37231 1086 100 on on IN 37231 1086 101 such such JJ 37231 1086 102 scientific scientific JJ 37231 1086 103 grounds ground NNS 37231 1086 104 as as IN 37231 1086 105 to to TO 37231 1086 106 be be VB 37231 1086 107 entitled entitle VBN 37231 1086 108 to to IN 37231 1086 109 the the DT 37231 1086 110 assent assent NN 37231 1086 111 of of IN 37231 1086 112 all all DT 37231 1086 113 duly duly RB 37231 1086 114 cultivated cultivate VBN 37231 1086 115 minds mind NNS 37231 1086 116 , , , 37231 1086 117 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1086 118 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1086 119 own own JJ 37231 1086 120 consciences conscience NNS 37231 1086 121 may may MD 37231 1086 122 say say VB 37231 1086 123 to to IN 37231 1086 124 the the DT 37231 1086 125 contrary contrary NN 37231 1086 126 . . . 37231 1087 1 " " `` 37231 1087 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1087 3 2 2 LS 37231 1087 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1087 5 Divines divine NNS 37231 1087 6 are be VBP 37231 1087 7 very very RB 37231 1087 8 strict strict JJ 37231 1087 9 in in IN 37231 1087 10 demanding demand VBG 37231 1087 11 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1087 12 demonstrations demonstration NNS 37231 1087 13 from from IN 37231 1087 14 men man NNS 37231 1087 15 of of IN 37231 1087 16 science science NN 37231 1087 17 and and CC 37231 1087 18 others other NNS 37231 1087 19 , , , 37231 1087 20 but but CC 37231 1087 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1087 22 do do VBP 37231 1087 23 not not RB 37231 1087 24 find find VB 37231 1087 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1087 26 at at RB 37231 1087 27 all all RB 37231 1087 28 ready ready JJ 37231 1087 29 to to TO 37231 1087 30 furnish furnish VB 37231 1087 31 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1087 32 of of IN 37231 1087 33 similar similar JJ 37231 1087 34 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 1087 35 regarding regard VBG 37231 1087 36 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 1087 37 theology theology NN 37231 1087 38 . . . 37231 1088 1 Immediately immediately RB 37231 1088 2 after after IN 37231 1088 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1088 4 indignant indignant JJ 37231 1088 5 demand demand NN 37231 1088 6 for for IN 37231 1088 7 scientific scientific JJ 37231 1088 8 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 1088 9 of of IN 37231 1088 10 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 1088 11 , , , 37231 1088 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1088 13 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1088 14 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1088 15 to to TO 37231 1088 16 argue argue VB 37231 1088 17 as as IN 37231 1088 18 follows follow VBZ 37231 1088 19 : : : 37231 1088 20 In in IN 37231 1088 21 the the DT 37231 1088 22 will will NN 37231 1088 23 of of IN 37231 1088 24 man man NN 37231 1088 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1088 26 have have VBP 37231 1088 27 the the DT 37231 1088 28 solitary solitary JJ 37231 1088 29 instance instance NN 37231 1088 30 of of IN 37231 1088 31 an an DT 37231 1088 32 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1088 33 cause cause NN 37231 1088 34 , , , 37231 1088 35 in in IN 37231 1088 36 the the DT 37231 1088 37 highest high JJS 37231 1088 38 sense sense NN 37231 1088 39 of of IN 37231 1088 40 the the DT 37231 1088 41 { { -LRB- 37231 1088 42 37 37 CD 37231 1088 43 } } -RRB- 37231 1088 44 term term NN 37231 1088 45 , , , 37231 1088 46 acting act VBG 37231 1088 47 among among IN 37231 1088 48 the the DT 37231 1088 49 physical physical JJ 37231 1088 50 causes cause NNS 37231 1088 51 of of IN 37231 1088 52 the the DT 37231 1088 53 material material NN 37231 1088 54 world world NN 37231 1088 55 , , , 37231 1088 56 and and CC 37231 1088 57 producing produce VBG 37231 1088 58 results result NNS 37231 1088 59 which which WDT 37231 1088 60 could could MD 37231 1088 61 not not RB 37231 1088 62 have have VB 37231 1088 63 been be VBN 37231 1088 64 brought bring VBN 37231 1088 65 about about RP 37231 1088 66 by by IN 37231 1088 67 any any DT 37231 1088 68 mere mere JJ 37231 1088 69 sequence sequence NN 37231 1088 70 of of IN 37231 1088 71 physical physical JJ 37231 1088 72 causes cause NNS 37231 1088 73 . . . 37231 1089 1 If if IN 37231 1089 2 a a DT 37231 1089 3 man man NN 37231 1089 4 of of IN 37231 1089 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1089 6 own own JJ 37231 1089 7 will will MD 37231 1089 8 throw throw VB 37231 1089 9 a a DT 37231 1089 10 stone stone NN 37231 1089 11 into into IN 37231 1089 12 the the DT 37231 1089 13 air air NN 37231 1089 14 , , , 37231 1089 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1089 16 motion motion NN 37231 1089 17 , , , 37231 1089 18 as as RB 37231 1089 19 soon soon RB 37231 1089 20 as as IN 37231 1089 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1089 22 has have VBZ 37231 1089 23 left leave VBN 37231 1089 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1089 25 hand hand NN 37231 1089 26 , , , 37231 1089 27 is be VBZ 37231 1089 28 determined determine VBN 37231 1089 29 by by IN 37231 1089 30 a a DT 37231 1089 31 combination combination NN 37231 1089 32 of of IN 37231 1089 33 purely purely RB 37231 1089 34 material material JJ 37231 1089 35 laws law NNS 37231 1089 36 ; ; : 37231 1089 37 but but CC 37231 1089 38 by by IN 37231 1089 39 what what WP 37231 1089 40 _ _ NNP 37231 1089 41 law law NN 37231 1089 42 _ _ NNP 37231 1089 43 came come VBD 37231 1089 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1089 45 to to TO 37231 1089 46 be be VB 37231 1089 47 thrown throw VBN 37231 1089 48 at at RB 37231 1089 49 all all RB 37231 1089 50 ? ? . 37231 1090 1 The the DT 37231 1090 2 law law NN 37231 1090 3 of of IN 37231 1090 4 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1090 5 , , , 37231 1090 6 no no RB 37231 1090 7 doubt doubt RB 37231 1090 8 , , , 37231 1090 9 remains remain VBZ 37231 1090 10 constant constant JJ 37231 1090 11 and and CC 37231 1090 12 unbroken unbroken JJ 37231 1090 13 , , , 37231 1090 14 whether whether IN 37231 1090 15 the the DT 37231 1090 16 stone stone NN 37231 1090 17 is be VBZ 37231 1090 18 lying lie VBG 37231 1090 19 on on IN 37231 1090 20 the the DT 37231 1090 21 ground ground NN 37231 1090 22 , , , 37231 1090 23 or or CC 37231 1090 24 moving move VBG 37231 1090 25 through through IN 37231 1090 26 the the DT 37231 1090 27 air air NN 37231 1090 28 , , , 37231 1090 29 but but CC 37231 1090 30 all all PDT 37231 1090 31 the the DT 37231 1090 32 laws law NNS 37231 1090 33 of of IN 37231 1090 34 matter matter NN 37231 1090 35 could could MD 37231 1090 36 not not RB 37231 1090 37 have have VB 37231 1090 38 brought bring VBN 37231 1090 39 about about RP 37231 1090 40 the the DT 37231 1090 41 particular particular JJ 37231 1090 42 result result NN 37231 1090 43 without without IN 37231 1090 44 the the DT 37231 1090 45 interposition interposition NN 37231 1090 46 of of IN 37231 1090 47 the the DT 37231 1090 48 free free JJ 37231 1090 49 will will NN 37231 1090 50 of of IN 37231 1090 51 the the DT 37231 1090 52 man man NN 37231 1090 53 who who WP 37231 1090 54 throws throw VBZ 37231 1090 55 the the DT 37231 1090 56 stone stone NN 37231 1090 57 . . . 37231 1091 1 Substitute substitute VB 37231 1091 2 the the DT 37231 1091 3 will will NN 37231 1091 4 of of IN 37231 1091 5 God God NNP 37231 1091 6 for for IN 37231 1091 7 the the DT 37231 1091 8 will will NN 37231 1091 9 of of IN 37231 1091 10 man man NN 37231 1091 11 , , , 37231 1091 12 and and CC 37231 1091 13 the the DT 37231 1091 14 argument argument NN 37231 1091 15 becomes become VBZ 37231 1091 16 applicable applicable JJ 37231 1091 17 to to IN 37231 1091 18 the the DT 37231 1091 19 whole whole JJ 37231 1091 20 extent extent NN 37231 1091 21 of of IN 37231 1091 22 Creation Creation NNP 37231 1091 23 and and CC 37231 1091 24 to to IN 37231 1091 25 all all PDT 37231 1091 26 the the DT 37231 1091 27 phenomena phenomena NN 37231 1091 28 which which WDT 37231 1091 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1091 30 embraces embrace VBZ 37231 1091 31 . . . 37231 1092 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1092 2 1 1 LS 37231 1092 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1092 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1092 5 is be VBZ 37231 1092 6 evident evident JJ 37231 1092 7 that that IN 37231 1092 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1092 9 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1092 10 's 's POS 37231 1092 11 argument argument NN 37231 1092 12 merely merely RB 37231 1092 13 tends tend VBZ 37231 1092 14 to to TO 37231 1092 15 prove prove VB 37231 1092 16 that that IN 37231 1092 17 every every DT 37231 1092 18 effect effect NN 37231 1092 19 must must MD 37231 1092 20 have have VB 37231 1092 21 a a DT 37231 1092 22 cause cause NN 37231 1092 23 , , , 37231 1092 24 a a DT 37231 1092 25 proposition proposition NN 37231 1092 26 too too RB 37231 1092 27 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1092 28 to to TO 37231 1092 29 require require VB 37231 1092 30 any any DT 37231 1092 31 argument argument NN 37231 1092 32 at at RB 37231 1092 33 all all RB 37231 1092 34 . . . 37231 1093 1 If if IN 37231 1093 2 a a DT 37231 1093 3 man man NN 37231 1093 4 had have VBD 37231 1093 5 not not RB 37231 1093 6 thrown throw VBN 37231 1093 7 the the DT 37231 1093 8 stone stone NN 37231 1093 9 , , , 37231 1093 10 the the DT 37231 1093 11 stone stone NN 37231 1093 12 would would MD 37231 1093 13 have have VB 37231 1093 14 remained remain VBN 37231 1093 15 lying lie VBG 37231 1093 16 on on IN 37231 1093 17 the the DT 37231 1093 18 ground ground NN 37231 1093 19 . . . 37231 1094 1 No no DT 37231 1094 2 one one NN 37231 1094 3 doubts doubt VBZ 37231 1094 4 this this DT 37231 1094 5 . . . 37231 1095 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1095 2 have have VBP 37231 1095 3 here here RB 37231 1095 4 , , , 37231 1095 5 however however RB 37231 1095 6 , , , 37231 1095 7 this this DT 37231 1095 8 " " `` 37231 1095 9 solitary solitary JJ 37231 1095 10 instance instance NN 37231 1095 11 of of IN 37231 1095 12 an an DT 37231 1095 13 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1095 14 cause cause NN 37231 1095 15 acting act VBG 37231 1095 16 among among IN 37231 1095 17 the the DT 37231 1095 18 physical physical JJ 37231 1095 19 causes cause NNS 37231 1095 20 of of IN 37231 1095 21 the the DT 37231 1095 22 material material NN 37231 1095 23 world world NN 37231 1095 24 , , , 37231 1095 25 " " '' 37231 1095 26 producing produce VBG 37231 1095 27 results result NNS 37231 1095 28 which which WDT 37231 1095 29 are be VBP 37231 1095 30 wholly wholly RB 37231 1095 31 determined determine VBN 37231 1095 32 by by IN 37231 1095 33 material material NN 37231 1095 34 laws,(2 laws,(2 NNP 37231 1095 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1095 36 and and CC 37231 1095 37 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1095 38 of of IN 37231 1095 39 producing produce VBG 37231 1095 40 any any DT 37231 1095 41 opposed opposed JJ 37231 1095 42 to to IN 37231 1095 43 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1095 44 . . . 37231 1096 1 If if IN 37231 1096 2 , , , 37231 1096 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 1096 4 , , , 37231 1096 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1096 6 substitute substitute VBP 37231 1096 7 , , , 37231 1096 8 as as IN 37231 1096 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1096 10 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1096 11 desires desire VBZ 37231 1096 12 , , , 37231 1096 13 " " `` 37231 1096 14 the the DT 37231 1096 15 will will NN 37231 1096 16 of of IN 37231 1096 17 God God NNP 37231 1096 18 " " '' 37231 1096 19 for for IN 37231 1096 20 " " `` 37231 1096 21 the the DT 37231 1096 22 will will NN 37231 1096 23 of of IN 37231 1096 24 man man NN 37231 1096 25 , , , 37231 1096 26 " " `` 37231 1096 27 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1096 28 arrive arrive VBP 37231 1096 29 at at IN 37231 1096 30 no no DT 37231 1096 31 results result NNS 37231 1096 32 which which WDT 37231 1096 33 are be VBP 37231 1096 34 not not RB 37231 1096 35 in in IN 37231 1096 36 harmony harmony NN 37231 1096 37 { { -LRB- 37231 1096 38 38 38 CD 37231 1096 39 } } -RRB- 37231 1096 40 with with IN 37231 1096 41 the the DT 37231 1096 42 order order NN 37231 1096 43 of of IN 37231 1096 44 nature nature NN 37231 1096 45 . . . 37231 1097 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1097 2 have have VBP 37231 1097 3 no no DT 37231 1097 4 ground ground NN 37231 1097 5 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1097 6 for for IN 37231 1097 7 assuming assume VBG 37231 1097 8 any any DT 37231 1097 9 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1097 10 cause cause NN 37231 1097 11 acting act VBG 37231 1097 12 in in IN 37231 1097 13 any any DT 37231 1097 14 other other JJ 37231 1097 15 way way NN 37231 1097 16 than than IN 37231 1097 17 in in IN 37231 1097 18 accordance accordance NN 37231 1097 19 with with IN 37231 1097 20 the the DT 37231 1097 21 laws law NNS 37231 1097 22 of of IN 37231 1097 23 nature nature NN 37231 1097 24 . . . 37231 1098 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1098 2 is be VBZ 37231 1098 3 , , , 37231 1098 4 how how WRB 37231 1098 5 - - HYPH 37231 1098 6 fever fever NN 37231 1098 7 , , , 37231 1098 8 one one CD 37231 1098 9 of of IN 37231 1098 10 the the DT 37231 1098 11 gross gross JJ 37231 1098 12 fallacies fallacy NNS 37231 1098 13 of of IN 37231 1098 14 this this DT 37231 1098 15 argument argument NN 37231 1098 16 , , , 37231 1098 17 as as IN 37231 1098 18 applied apply VBN 37231 1098 19 to to IN 37231 1098 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1098 21 , , , 37231 1098 22 to to TO 37231 1098 23 pass pass VB 37231 1098 24 from from IN 37231 1098 25 the the DT 37231 1098 26 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1098 27 cause cause NN 37231 1098 28 producing produce VBG 37231 1098 29 results result NNS 37231 1098 30 which which WDT 37231 1098 31 are be VBP 37231 1098 32 strictly strictly RB 37231 1098 33 in in IN 37231 1098 34 accordance accordance NN 37231 1098 35 with with IN 37231 1098 36 natural natural JJ 37231 1098 37 laws law NNS 37231 1098 38 , , , 37231 1098 39 and and CC 37231 1098 40 determined determine VBN 37231 1098 41 by by IN 37231 1098 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1098 43 , , , 37231 1098 44 to to IN 37231 1098 45 an an DT 37231 1098 46 assumed assume VBN 37231 1098 47 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1098 48 cause cause NN 37231 1098 49 producing produce VBG 37231 1098 50 effects effect NNS 37231 1098 51 which which WDT 37231 1098 52 are be VBP 37231 1098 53 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1098 54 to to IN 37231 1098 55 natural natural JJ 37231 1098 56 law law NN 37231 1098 57 . . . 37231 1099 1 The the DT 37231 1099 2 restoration restoration NN 37231 1099 3 to to IN 37231 1099 4 life life NN 37231 1099 5 of of IN 37231 1099 6 a a DT 37231 1099 7 decomposed decompose VBN 37231 1099 8 human human JJ 37231 1099 9 body body NN 37231 1099 10 and and CC 37231 1099 11 the the DT 37231 1099 12 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1099 13 multiplication multiplication NN 37231 1099 14 of of IN 37231 1099 15 loaves loaf NNS 37231 1099 16 and and CC 37231 1099 17 fishes fish NNS 37231 1099 18 are be VBP 37231 1099 19 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1099 20 to to IN 37231 1099 21 natural natural JJ 37231 1099 22 laws law NNS 37231 1099 23 , , , 37231 1099 24 and and CC 37231 1099 25 no no DT 37231 1099 26 assumed assume VBN 37231 1099 27 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1099 28 cause cause NN 37231 1099 29 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 1099 30 to to IN 37231 1099 31 which which WDT 37231 1099 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1099 33 may may MD 37231 1099 34 be be VB 37231 1099 35 referred refer VBN 37231 1099 36 can can MD 37231 1099 37 harmonize harmonize VB 37231 1099 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1099 39 . . . 37231 1100 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1100 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1100 3 continues continue VBZ 37231 1100 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1100 5 argument argument NN 37231 1100 6 in in IN 37231 1100 7 a a DT 37231 1100 8 similar similar JJ 37231 1100 9 way way NN 37231 1100 10 . . . 37231 1101 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1101 2 inquires inquire VBZ 37231 1101 3 : : : 37231 1101 4 " " `` 37231 1101 5 Is be VBZ 37231 1101 6 the the DT 37231 1101 7 suspension suspension NN 37231 1101 8 of of IN 37231 1101 9 physical physical JJ 37231 1101 10 and and CC 37231 1101 11 material material JJ 37231 1101 12 laws law NNS 37231 1101 13 by by IN 37231 1101 14 a a DT 37231 1101 15 Spiritual Spiritual NNP 37231 1101 16 Being be VBG 37231 1101 17 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 37231 1101 18 ? ? . 37231 1102 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1102 2 reply reply VBP 37231 1102 3 that that IN 37231 1102 4 , , , 37231 1102 5 however however RB 37231 1102 6 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 37231 1102 7 this this DT 37231 1102 8 kind kind NN 37231 1102 9 of of IN 37231 1102 10 suspension suspension NN 37231 1102 11 of of IN 37231 1102 12 physical physical JJ 37231 1102 13 law law NN 37231 1102 14 is be VBZ 37231 1102 15 , , , 37231 1102 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1102 17 is be VBZ 37231 1102 18 a a DT 37231 1102 19 fact fact NN 37231 1102 20 . . . 37231 1103 1 Physical physical JJ 37231 1103 2 laws law NNS 37231 1103 3 are be VBP 37231 1103 4 suspended suspend VBN 37231 1103 5 any any DT 37231 1103 6 time time NN 37231 1103 7 an an DT 37231 1103 8 animate animate NN 37231 1103 9 being be VBG 37231 1103 10 moves move NNS 37231 1103 11 any any DT 37231 1103 12 part part NN 37231 1103 13 of of IN 37231 1103 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1103 15 body body NN 37231 1103 16 ; ; : 37231 1103 17 the the DT 37231 1103 18 laws law NNS 37231 1103 19 of of IN 37231 1103 20 matter matter NN 37231 1103 21 are be VBP 37231 1103 22 suspended suspend VBN 37231 1103 23 by by IN 37231 1103 24 the the DT 37231 1103 25 laws law NNS 37231 1103 26 of of IN 37231 1103 27 life life NN 37231 1103 28 . . . 37231 1104 1 " " `` 37231 1104 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1104 3 l l NN 37231 1104 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1104 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1104 6 goes go VBZ 37231 1104 7 on on RP 37231 1104 8 to to TO 37231 1104 9 maintain maintain VB 37231 1104 10 that that IN 37231 1104 11 , , , 37231 1104 12 although although IN 37231 1104 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1104 14 is be VBZ 37231 1104 15 true true JJ 37231 1104 16 that that IN 37231 1104 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1104 18 spirit spirit NN 37231 1104 19 is be VBZ 37231 1104 20 united united JJ 37231 1104 21 with with IN 37231 1104 22 the the DT 37231 1104 23 matter matter NN 37231 1104 24 in in IN 37231 1104 25 which which WDT 37231 1104 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1104 27 moves move VBZ 37231 1104 28 in in IN 37231 1104 29 a a DT 37231 1104 30 way way NN 37231 1104 31 in in IN 37231 1104 32 which which WDT 37231 1104 33 the the DT 37231 1104 34 Great Great NNP 37231 1104 35 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 1104 36 who who WP 37231 1104 37 acts act VBZ 37231 1104 38 on on IN 37231 1104 39 matter matter NN 37231 1104 40 in in IN 37231 1104 41 the the DT 37231 1104 42 miracle miracle NN 37231 1104 43 is be VBZ 37231 1104 44 not not RB 37231 1104 45 , , , 37231 1104 46 yet yet CC 37231 1104 47 the the DT 37231 1104 48 action action NN 37231 1104 49 of of IN 37231 1104 50 God God NNP 37231 1104 51 's 's POS 37231 1104 52 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 1104 53 in in IN 37231 1104 54 the the DT 37231 1104 55 miracle miracle NN 37231 1104 56 of of IN 37231 1104 57 walking walk VBG 37231 1104 58 on on IN 37231 1104 59 the the DT 37231 1104 60 water water NN 37231 1104 61 is be VBZ 37231 1104 62 no no DT 37231 1104 63 more more RBR 37231 1104 64 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 37231 1104 65 than than IN 37231 1104 66 the the DT 37231 1104 67 action action NN 37231 1104 68 of of IN 37231 1104 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1104 70 own own JJ 37231 1104 71 spirit spirit NN 37231 1104 72 in in IN 37231 1104 73 holding hold VBG 37231 1104 74 up up RP 37231 1104 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1104 76 own own JJ 37231 1104 77 hand hand NN 37231 1104 78 . . . 37231 1105 1 " " `` 37231 1105 2 Antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1105 3 , , , 37231 1105 4 one one CD 37231 1105 5 step step NN 37231 1105 6 on on IN 37231 1105 7 the the DT 37231 1105 8 ground ground NN 37231 1105 9 and and CC 37231 1105 10 an an DT 37231 1105 11 ascent ascent NN 37231 1105 12 to to IN 37231 1105 13 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1105 14 are be VBP 37231 1105 15 alike alike RB 37231 1105 16 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1105 17 . . . 37231 1106 1 But but CC 37231 1106 2 this this DT 37231 1106 3 appearance appearance NN 37231 1106 4 of of IN 37231 1106 5 incredibility incredibility NN 37231 1106 6 is be VBZ 37231 1106 7 answered answer VBN 37231 1106 8 in in IN 37231 1106 9 one one CD 37231 1106 10 case case NN 37231 1106 11 literally literally RB 37231 1106 12 _ _ NNP 37231 1106 13 ambulando ambulando NNP 37231 1106 14 _ _ NNP 37231 1106 15 . . . 37231 1107 1 How how WRB 37231 1107 2 can can MD 37231 1107 3 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1107 4 place place VB 37231 1107 5 any any DT 37231 1107 6 reliance reliance NN 37231 1107 7 upon upon IN 37231 1107 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1107 9 in in IN 37231 1107 10 the the DT 37231 1107 11 other other JJ 37231 1107 12 ? ? . 37231 1108 1 " " `` 37231 1108 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1108 3 2 2 LS 37231 1108 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1108 5 From from IN 37231 1108 6 this this DT 37231 1108 7 illustration illustration NN 37231 1108 8 , , , 37231 1108 9 { { -LRB- 37231 1108 10 39 39 CD 37231 1108 11 } } -RRB- 37231 1108 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1108 13 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1108 14 , , , 37231 1108 15 with with IN 37231 1108 16 a a DT 37231 1108 17 haste haste NN 37231 1108 18 very very RB 37231 1108 19 unlike unlike IN 37231 1108 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1108 21 previous previous JJ 37231 1108 22 careful careful JJ 37231 1108 23 procedure procedure NN 37231 1108 24 , , , 37231 1108 25 jumps jump VBZ 37231 1108 26 at at IN 37231 1108 27 the the DT 37231 1108 28 following following JJ 37231 1108 29 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1108 30 : : : 37231 1108 31 " " `` 37231 1108 32 The the DT 37231 1108 33 constitution constitution NN 37231 1108 34 of of IN 37231 1108 35 nature nature NN 37231 1108 36 , , , 37231 1108 37 then then RB 37231 1108 38 , , , 37231 1108 39 disproved disprove VBD 37231 1108 40 the the DT 37231 1108 41 incredibility incredibility NN 37231 1108 42 of of IN 37231 1108 43 the the DT 37231 1108 44 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1108 45 suspension suspension NN 37231 1108 46 of of IN 37231 1108 47 physical physical JJ 37231 1108 48 law law NN 37231 1108 49 ; ; : 37231 1108 50 but but CC 37231 1108 51 more more JJR 37231 1108 52 than than IN 37231 1108 53 this this DT 37231 1108 54 , , , 37231 1108 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1108 56 creates create VBZ 37231 1108 57 a a DT 37231 1108 58 presumption presumption NN 37231 1108 59 for for IN 37231 1108 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1108 61 . . . 37231 1109 1 " " `` 37231 1109 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1109 3 l l NN 37231 1109 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1109 5 The the DT 37231 1109 6 laws law NNS 37231 1109 7 of of IN 37231 1109 8 life life NN 37231 1109 9 of of IN 37231 1109 10 which which WDT 37231 1109 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1109 12 have have VBP 37231 1109 13 experience experience NN 37231 1109 14 , , , 37231 1109 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1109 16 argues argue VBZ 37231 1109 17 , , , 37231 1109 18 are be VBP 37231 1109 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1109 20 in in IN 37231 1109 21 an an DT 37231 1109 22 ascending ascend VBG 37231 1109 23 scale scale NN 37231 1109 24 . . . 37231 1110 1 First first RB 37231 1110 2 come come VB 37231 1110 3 the the DT 37231 1110 4 laws law NNS 37231 1110 5 which which WDT 37231 1110 6 regulate regulate VBP 37231 1110 7 unorganized unorganized JJ 37231 1110 8 matter matter NN 37231 1110 9 ; ; , 37231 1110 10 next next IN 37231 1110 11 the the DT 37231 1110 12 laws law NNS 37231 1110 13 of of IN 37231 1110 14 vegetation vegetation NN 37231 1110 15 ; ; : 37231 1110 16 then then RB 37231 1110 17 the the DT 37231 1110 18 laws law NNS 37231 1110 19 of of IN 37231 1110 20 animal animal NN 37231 1110 21 life life NN 37231 1110 22 , , , 37231 1110 23 with with IN 37231 1110 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1110 25 voluntary voluntary JJ 37231 1110 26 motion motion NN 37231 1110 27 ; ; : 37231 1110 28 and and CC 37231 1110 29 above above IN 37231 1110 30 these these DT 37231 1110 31 again again RB 37231 1110 32 , , , 37231 1110 33 the the DT 37231 1110 34 laws law NNS 37231 1110 35 of of IN 37231 1110 36 moral moral JJ 37231 1110 37 being being NN 37231 1110 38 . . . 37231 1111 1 A a DT 37231 1111 2 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1111 3 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 1111 4 being be VBG 37231 1111 5 whose whose WP$ 37231 1111 6 experience experience NN 37231 1111 7 was be VBD 37231 1111 8 limited limit VBN 37231 1111 9 to to IN 37231 1111 10 one one CD 37231 1111 11 or or CC 37231 1111 12 more more JJR 37231 1111 13 classes class NNS 37231 1111 14 in in IN 37231 1111 15 this this DT 37231 1111 16 ascending ascend VBG 37231 1111 17 scale scale NN 37231 1111 18 of of IN 37231 1111 19 laws law NNS 37231 1111 20 would would MD 37231 1111 21 be be VB 37231 1111 22 totally totally RB 37231 1111 23 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1111 24 of of IN 37231 1111 25 conceiving conceive VBG 37231 1111 26 the the DT 37231 1111 27 action action NN 37231 1111 28 of of IN 37231 1111 29 the the DT 37231 1111 30 higher high JJR 37231 1111 31 classes class NNS 37231 1111 32 . . . 37231 1112 1 The the DT 37231 1112 2 progressive progressive JJ 37231 1112 3 succession succession NN 37231 1112 4 of of IN 37231 1112 5 laws law NNS 37231 1112 6 is be VBZ 37231 1112 7 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 1112 8 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 1112 9 backward backward RB 37231 1112 10 , , , 37231 1112 11 but but CC 37231 1112 12 an an DT 37231 1112 13 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1112 14 mystery mystery NN 37231 1112 15 forward forward RB 37231 1112 16 . . . 37231 1113 1 " " `` 37231 1113 2 Analogy Analogy NNP 37231 1113 3 , , , 37231 1113 4 " " '' 37231 1113 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 1113 6 , , , 37231 1113 7 when when WRB 37231 1113 8 in in IN 37231 1113 9 this this DT 37231 1113 10 ascending ascend VBG 37231 1113 11 series series NN 37231 1113 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1113 13 arrive arrive VBP 37231 1113 14 at at IN 37231 1113 15 man man NN 37231 1113 16 , , , 37231 1113 17 leads lead VBZ 37231 1113 18 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1113 19 to to TO 37231 1113 20 expect expect VB 37231 1113 21 that that IN 37231 1113 22 there there EX 37231 1113 23 is be VBZ 37231 1113 24 a a DT 37231 1113 25 higher high JJR 37231 1113 26 sphere sphere NN 37231 1113 27 of of IN 37231 1113 28 law law NN 37231 1113 29 as as RB 37231 1113 30 much much RB 37231 1113 31 above above IN 37231 1113 32 _ _ NNP 37231 1113 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1113 34 _ _ NNP 37231 1113 35 as as IN 37231 1113 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1113 37 is be VBZ 37231 1113 38 above above IN 37231 1113 39 the the DT 37231 1113 40 lower low JJR 37231 1113 41 natures nature NNS 37231 1113 42 in in IN 37231 1113 43 the the DT 37231 1113 44 scale scale NN 37231 1113 45 , , , 37231 1113 46 and and CC 37231 1113 47 " " `` 37231 1113 48 supplies supply VBZ 37231 1113 49 a a DT 37231 1113 50 presumption presumption NN 37231 1113 51 in in IN 37231 1113 52 favour favour NN 37231 1113 53 of of IN 37231 1113 54 such such PDT 37231 1113 55 a a DT 37231 1113 56 belief belief NN 37231 1113 57 . . . 37231 1114 1 " " `` 37231 1114 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1114 3 2 2 LS 37231 1114 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1114 5 And and CC 37231 1114 6 so so RB 37231 1114 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1114 8 arrive arrive VBP 37231 1114 9 at at IN 37231 1114 10 the the DT 37231 1114 11 question question NN 37231 1114 12 whether whether IN 37231 1114 13 there there EX 37231 1114 14 is be VBZ 37231 1114 15 or or CC 37231 1114 16 is be VBZ 37231 1114 17 not not RB 37231 1114 18 a a DT 37231 1114 19 God God NNP 37231 1114 20 , , , 37231 1114 21 a a DT 37231 1114 22 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1114 23 Head Head NNP 37231 1114 24 in in IN 37231 1114 25 nature nature NN 37231 1114 26 , , , 37231 1114 27 whose whose WP$ 37231 1114 28 free free JJ 37231 1114 29 will will MD 37231 1114 30 penetrates penetrate VBZ 37231 1114 31 the the DT 37231 1114 32 universal universal JJ 37231 1114 33 frame frame NN 37231 1114 34 invisibly invisibly RB 37231 1114 35 to to IN 37231 1114 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1114 37 , , , 37231 1114 38 and and CC 37231 1114 39 is be VBZ 37231 1114 40 an an DT 37231 1114 41 omnipresent omnipresent JJ 37231 1114 42 agent agent NN 37231 1114 43 . . . 37231 1115 1 If if IN 37231 1115 2 there there EX 37231 1115 3 be be VB 37231 1115 4 , , , 37231 1115 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1115 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1115 7 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 1115 8 , , , 37231 1115 9 then then RB 37231 1115 10 , , , 37231 1115 11 every every DT 37231 1115 12 miracle miracle NN 37231 1115 13 in in IN 37231 1115 14 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1115 15 is be VBZ 37231 1115 16 as as RB 37231 1115 17 natural natural JJ 37231 1115 18 an an DT 37231 1115 19 event event NN 37231 1115 20 in in IN 37231 1115 21 the the DT 37231 1115 22 universe universe NN 37231 1115 23 as as IN 37231 1115 24 any any DT 37231 1115 25 chemical chemical JJ 37231 1115 26 experiment experiment NN 37231 1115 27 in in IN 37231 1115 28 the the DT 37231 1115 29 physical physical JJ 37231 1115 30 world world NN 37231 1115 31 . . . 37231 1116 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1116 2 3 3 LS 37231 1116 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1116 4 This this DT 37231 1116 5 is be VBZ 37231 1116 6 precisely precisely RB 37231 1116 7 the the DT 37231 1116 8 argument argument NN 37231 1116 9 of of IN 37231 1116 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1116 11 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1116 12 , , , 37231 1116 13 regarding regard VBG 37231 1116 14 the the DT 37231 1116 15 " " `` 37231 1116 16 Efficient efficient JJ 37231 1116 17 Cause cause NN 37231 1116 18 , , , 37231 1116 19 " " '' 37231 1116 20 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 1116 21 elaborated elaborated JJ 37231 1116 22 , , , 37231 1116 23 but but CC 37231 1116 24 , , , 37231 1116 25 however however RB 37231 1116 26 ingeniously ingeniously RB 37231 1116 27 devised devise VBN 37231 1116 28 , , , 37231 1116 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1116 30 is be VBZ 37231 1116 31 equally equally RB 37231 1116 32 based base VBN 37231 1116 33 upon upon IN 37231 1116 34 assumption assumption NN 37231 1116 35 and and CC 37231 1116 36 defective defective JJ 37231 1116 37 in in IN 37231 1116 38 analogy analogy NN 37231 1116 39 . . . 37231 1117 1 The the DT 37231 1117 2 " " `` 37231 1117 3 classes class NNS 37231 1117 4 of of IN 37231 1117 5 { { -LRB- 37231 1117 6 40 40 CD 37231 1117 7 } } -RRB- 37231 1117 8 law law NN 37231 1117 9 " " '' 37231 1117 10 to to TO 37231 1117 11 which which WDT 37231 1117 12 the the DT 37231 1117 13 Bampton Bampton NNP 37231 1117 14 Lecturer Lecturer NNP 37231 1117 15 refers refer VBZ 37231 1117 16 work work NN 37231 1117 17 harmoniously harmoniously RB 37231 1117 18 side side NN 37231 1117 19 by by IN 37231 1117 20 side side NN 37231 1117 21 , , , 37231 1117 22 regulating regulate VBG 37231 1117 23 the the DT 37231 1117 24 matter matter NN 37231 1117 25 to to TO 37231 1117 26 which which WDT 37231 1117 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1117 28 apply apply VBP 37231 1117 29 . . . 37231 1118 1 Unorganized unorganized JJ 37231 1118 2 matter matter NN 37231 1118 3 , , , 37231 1118 4 vegetation vegetation NN 37231 1118 5 , , , 37231 1118 6 and and CC 37231 1118 7 animal animal NN 37231 1118 8 life life NN 37231 1118 9 , , , 37231 1118 10 may may MD 37231 1118 11 each each DT 37231 1118 12 have have VB 37231 1118 13 special special JJ 37231 1118 14 conditions condition NNS 37231 1118 15 modifying modify VBG 37231 1118 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1118 17 , , , 37231 1118 18 but but CC 37231 1118 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1118 20 are be VBP 37231 1118 21 all all RB 37231 1118 22 equally equally RB 37231 1118 23 subject subject JJ 37231 1118 24 to to IN 37231 1118 25 the the DT 37231 1118 26 same same JJ 37231 1118 27 general general JJ 37231 1118 28 laws law NNS 37231 1118 29 . . . 37231 1119 1 Man man NN 37231 1119 2 is be VBZ 37231 1119 3 as as RB 37231 1119 4 much much JJ 37231 1119 5 under under IN 37231 1119 6 the the DT 37231 1119 7 influence influence NN 37231 1119 8 of of IN 37231 1119 9 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1119 10 as as IN 37231 1119 11 a a DT 37231 1119 12 stone stone NN 37231 1119 13 is be VBZ 37231 1119 14 . . . 37231 1120 1 The the DT 37231 1120 2 special special JJ 37231 1120 3 operation operation NN 37231 1120 4 of of IN 37231 1120 5 physical physical JJ 37231 1120 6 laws law NNS 37231 1120 7 is be VBZ 37231 1120 8 less less JJR 37231 1120 9 a a DT 37231 1120 10 modification modification NN 37231 1120 11 of of IN 37231 1120 12 law law NN 37231 1120 13 than than IN 37231 1120 14 that that DT 37231 1120 15 law law NN 37231 1120 16 acting act VBG 37231 1120 17 under under IN 37231 1120 18 different different JJ 37231 1120 19 conditions condition NNS 37231 1120 20 . . . 37231 1121 1 The the DT 37231 1121 2 law law NN 37231 1121 3 of of IN 37231 1121 4 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1121 5 suffers suffer VBZ 37231 1121 6 no no DT 37231 1121 7 alteration alteration NN 37231 1121 8 , , , 37231 1121 9 whether whether IN 37231 1121 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1121 11 cause cause VB 37231 1121 12 the the DT 37231 1121 13 fall fall NN 37231 1121 14 of of IN 37231 1121 15 an an DT 37231 1121 16 apple apple NN 37231 1121 17 or or CC 37231 1121 18 shape shape VB 37231 1121 19 the the DT 37231 1121 20 orbit orbit NN 37231 1121 21 of of IN 37231 1121 22 a a DT 37231 1121 23 planet planet NN 37231 1121 24 . . . 37231 1122 1 The the DT 37231 1122 2 reproduction reproduction NN 37231 1122 3 of of IN 37231 1122 4 the the DT 37231 1122 5 plant plant NN 37231 1122 6 and and CC 37231 1122 7 of of IN 37231 1122 8 the the DT 37231 1122 9 animal animal NN 37231 1122 10 is be VBZ 37231 1122 11 regulated regulate VBN 37231 1122 12 by by IN 37231 1122 13 the the DT 37231 1122 14 same same JJ 37231 1122 15 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 1122 16 principle principle NN 37231 1122 17 acting act VBG 37231 1122 18 through through IN 37231 1122 19 different different JJ 37231 1122 20 organisms organism NNS 37231 1122 21 . . . 37231 1123 1 The the DT 37231 1123 2 harmonious harmonious JJ 37231 1123 3 action action NN 37231 1123 4 of of IN 37231 1123 5 physical physical JJ 37231 1123 6 laws law NNS 37231 1123 7 , , , 37231 1123 8 and and CC 37231 1123 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1123 10 adaptability adaptability NN 37231 1123 11 to to IN 37231 1123 12 an an DT 37231 1123 13 infinite infinite JJ 37231 1123 14 variety variety NN 37231 1123 15 of of IN 37231 1123 16 forms form NNS 37231 1123 17 , , , 37231 1123 18 constitute constitute VBP 37231 1123 19 the the DT 37231 1123 20 perfection perfection NN 37231 1123 21 of of IN 37231 1123 22 that that DT 37231 1123 23 code code NN 37231 1123 24 which which WDT 37231 1123 25 produces produce VBZ 37231 1123 26 the the DT 37231 1123 27 order order NN 37231 1123 28 of of IN 37231 1123 29 nature nature NN 37231 1123 30 . . . 37231 1124 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1124 2 1 1 LS 37231 1124 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1124 4 The the DT 37231 1124 5 mere mere JJ 37231 1124 6 superiority superiority NN 37231 1124 7 of of IN 37231 1124 8 man man NN 37231 1124 9 over over IN 37231 1124 10 lower low JJR 37231 1124 11 forms form NNS 37231 1124 12 of of IN 37231 1124 13 organic organic JJ 37231 1124 14 and and CC 37231 1124 15 inorganic inorganic JJ 37231 1124 16 matter matter NN 37231 1124 17 does do VBZ 37231 1124 18 not not RB 37231 1124 19 lift lift VB 37231 1124 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1124 21 above above IN 37231 1124 22 physical physical JJ 37231 1124 23 laws law NNS 37231 1124 24 , , , 37231 1124 25 and and CC 37231 1124 26 the the DT 37231 1124 27 analogy analogy NN 37231 1124 28 of of IN 37231 1124 29 every every DT 37231 1124 30 grade grade NN 37231 1124 31 in in IN 37231 1124 32 nature nature NN 37231 1124 33 forbids forbid VBZ 37231 1124 34 the the DT 37231 1124 35 presumption presumption NN 37231 1124 36 that that IN 37231 1124 37 higher high JJR 37231 1124 38 forms form NNS 37231 1124 39 may may MD 37231 1124 40 exist exist VB 37231 1124 41 which which WDT 37231 1124 42 are be VBP 37231 1124 43 exempt exempt JJ 37231 1124 44 from from IN 37231 1124 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1124 46 control control NN 37231 1124 47 . . . 37231 1125 1 If if IN 37231 1125 2 in in IN 37231 1125 3 animated animate VBN 37231 1125 4 beings being NNS 37231 1125 5 , , , 37231 1125 6 as as IN 37231 1125 7 is be VBZ 37231 1125 8 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 1125 9 , , , 37231 1125 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1125 11 had have VBD 37231 1125 12 the the DT 37231 1125 13 solitary solitary JJ 37231 1125 14 instance instance NN 37231 1125 15 of of IN 37231 1125 16 an an DT 37231 1125 17 " " `` 37231 1125 18 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1125 19 cause cause NN 37231 1125 20 " " '' 37231 1125 21 acting act VBG 37231 1125 22 among among IN 37231 1125 23 the the DT 37231 1125 24 forces force NNS 37231 1125 25 of of IN 37231 1125 26 nature nature NN 37231 1125 27 , , , 37231 1125 28 and and CC 37231 1125 29 possessing possess VBG 37231 1125 30 the the DT 37231 1125 31 power power NN 37231 1125 32 of of IN 37231 1125 33 initiation initiation NN 37231 1125 34 , , , 37231 1125 35 this this DT 37231 1125 36 " " `` 37231 1125 37 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1125 38 cause cause NN 37231 1125 39 " " '' 37231 1125 40 produces produce VBZ 37231 1125 41 no no DT 37231 1125 42 disturbance disturbance NN 37231 1125 43 of of IN 37231 1125 44 physical physical JJ 37231 1125 45 law law NN 37231 1125 46 . . . 37231 1126 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1126 2 existence existence NN 37231 1126 3 is be VBZ 37231 1126 4 as as RB 37231 1126 5 much much JJ 37231 1126 6 a a DT 37231 1126 7 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1126 8 part part NN 37231 1126 9 of of IN 37231 1126 10 the the DT 37231 1126 11 infinite infinite JJ 37231 1126 12 variety variety NN 37231 1126 13 of of IN 37231 1126 14 form form NN 37231 1126 15 within within IN 37231 1126 16 the the DT 37231 1126 17 order order NN 37231 1126 18 of of IN 37231 1126 19 nature nature NN 37231 1126 20 as as IN 37231 1126 21 the the DT 37231 1126 22 existence existence NN 37231 1126 23 of of IN 37231 1126 24 a a DT 37231 1126 25 crystal crystal NN 37231 1126 26 or or CC 37231 1126 27 a a DT 37231 1126 28 plant plant NN 37231 1126 29 ; ; : 37231 1126 30 and and CC 37231 1126 31 although although IN 37231 1126 32 the the DT 37231 1126 33 character character NN 37231 1126 34 of of IN 37231 1126 35 the the DT 37231 1126 36 force force NN 37231 1126 37 exercised exercise VBN 37231 1126 38 by by IN 37231 1126 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1126 40 may may MD 37231 1126 41 not not RB 37231 1126 42 be be VB 37231 1126 43 clearly clearly RB 37231 1126 44 understood understand VBN 37231 1126 45 , , , 37231 1126 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1126 47 effects effect NNS 37231 1126 48 are be VBP 37231 1126 49 regulated regulate VBN 37231 1126 50 by by IN 37231 1126 51 the the DT 37231 1126 52 same same JJ 37231 1126 53 laws law NNS 37231 1126 54 as as IN 37231 1126 55 { { -LRB- 37231 1126 56 41 41 CD 37231 1126 57 } } -RRB- 37231 1126 58 govern govern VBP 37231 1126 59 all all DT 37231 1126 60 other other JJ 37231 1126 61 forces force NNS 37231 1126 62 in in IN 37231 1126 63 nature nature NN 37231 1126 64 . . . 37231 1127 1 If if IN 37231 1127 2 " " `` 37231 1127 3 the the DT 37231 1127 4 laws law NNS 37231 1127 5 of of IN 37231 1127 6 matter matter NN 37231 1127 7 are be VBP 37231 1127 8 suspended suspend VBN 37231 1127 9 by by IN 37231 1127 10 the the DT 37231 1127 11 laws law NNS 37231 1127 12 of of IN 37231 1127 13 life life NN 37231 1127 14 " " '' 37231 1127 15 each each DT 37231 1127 16 time time NN 37231 1127 17 an an DT 37231 1127 18 animated animate VBN 37231 1127 19 being be VBG 37231 1127 20 moves move NNS 37231 1127 21 any any DT 37231 1127 22 part part NN 37231 1127 23 of of IN 37231 1127 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1127 25 body body NN 37231 1127 26 , , , 37231 1127 27 one one CD 37231 1127 28 physical physical JJ 37231 1127 29 law law NN 37231 1127 30 is be VBZ 37231 1127 31 counteracted counteract VBN 37231 1127 32 in in IN 37231 1127 33 precisely precisely RB 37231 1127 34 the the DT 37231 1127 35 same same JJ 37231 1127 36 manner manner NN 37231 1127 37 , , , 37231 1127 38 and and CC 37231 1127 39 to to IN 37231 1127 40 an an DT 37231 1127 41 equivalent equivalent JJ 37231 1127 42 degree degree NN 37231 1127 43 , , , 37231 1127 44 each each DT 37231 1127 45 time time NN 37231 1127 46 another another DT 37231 1127 47 physical physical JJ 37231 1127 48 law law NN 37231 1127 49 is be VBZ 37231 1127 50 called call VBN 37231 1127 51 into into IN 37231 1127 52 action action NN 37231 1127 53 . . . 37231 1128 1 The the DT 37231 1128 2 Law Law NNP 37231 1128 3 of of IN 37231 1128 4 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1128 5 , , , 37231 1128 6 for for IN 37231 1128 7 instance instance NN 37231 1128 8 , , , 37231 1128 9 is be VBZ 37231 1128 10 equally equally RB 37231 1128 11 neutralized neutralize VBN 37231 1128 12 by by IN 37231 1128 13 the the DT 37231 1128 14 law law NN 37231 1128 15 of of IN 37231 1128 16 magnetism magnetism NN 37231 1128 17 each each DT 37231 1128 18 time time NN 37231 1128 19 a a DT 37231 1128 20 magnet magnet NN 37231 1128 21 suspends suspend VBZ 37231 1128 22 a a DT 37231 1128 23 weight weight NN 37231 1128 24 in in IN 37231 1128 25 the the DT 37231 1128 26 air air NN 37231 1128 27 . . . 37231 1129 1 In in IN 37231 1129 2 each each DT 37231 1129 3 case case NN 37231 1129 4 , , , 37231 1129 5 a a DT 37231 1129 6 law law NN 37231 1129 7 is be VBZ 37231 1129 8 successfully successfully RB 37231 1129 9 resisted resist VBN 37231 1129 10 precisely precisely RB 37231 1129 11 to to IN 37231 1129 12 the the DT 37231 1129 13 extent extent NN 37231 1129 14 of of IN 37231 1129 15 the the DT 37231 1129 16 force force NN 37231 1129 17 employed employ VBN 37231 1129 18 . . . 37231 1130 1 The the DT 37231 1130 2 arm arm NN 37231 1130 3 that that WDT 37231 1130 4 is be VBZ 37231 1130 5 raised raise VBN 37231 1130 6 by by IN 37231 1130 7 the the DT 37231 1130 8 animated animate VBN 37231 1130 9 being be VBG 37231 1130 10 falls fall VBZ 37231 1130 11 again again RB 37231 1130 12 , , , 37231 1130 13 in in IN 37231 1130 14 obedience obedience NN 37231 1130 15 to to IN 37231 1130 16 law law NN 37231 1130 17 , , , 37231 1130 18 as as RB 37231 1130 19 soon soon RB 37231 1130 20 as as IN 37231 1130 21 the the DT 37231 1130 22 force force NN 37231 1130 23 which which WDT 37231 1130 24 raised raise VBD 37231 1130 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1130 26 is be VBZ 37231 1130 27 exhausted exhausted JJ 37231 1130 28 , , , 37231 1130 29 quite quite RB 37231 1130 30 as as RB 37231 1130 31 certainly certainly RB 37231 1130 32 as as IN 37231 1130 33 the the DT 37231 1130 34 weight weight NN 37231 1130 35 descends descend VBZ 37231 1130 36 when when WRB 37231 1130 37 the the DT 37231 1130 38 magnetic magnetic JJ 37231 1130 39 current current NN 37231 1130 40 fails fail VBZ 37231 1130 41 . . . 37231 1131 1 This this DT 37231 1131 2 , , , 37231 1131 3 however however RB 37231 1131 4 , , , 37231 1131 5 is be VBZ 37231 1131 6 not not RB 37231 1131 7 the the DT 37231 1131 8 suspension suspension NN 37231 1131 9 of of IN 37231 1131 10 law law NN 37231 1131 11 in in IN 37231 1131 12 the the DT 37231 1131 13 sense sense NN 37231 1131 14 of of IN 37231 1131 15 a a DT 37231 1131 16 miracle miracle NN 37231 1131 17 , , , 37231 1131 18 but but CC 37231 1131 19 , , , 37231 1131 20 on on IN 37231 1131 21 the the DT 37231 1131 22 contrary contrary NN 37231 1131 23 , , , 37231 1131 24 is be VBZ 37231 1131 25 simply simply RB 37231 1131 26 the the DT 37231 1131 27 natural natural JJ 37231 1131 28 operation operation NN 37231 1131 29 upon upon IN 37231 1131 30 each each DT 37231 1131 31 other other JJ 37231 1131 32 of of IN 37231 1131 33 co co JJ 37231 1131 34 - - JJ 37231 1131 35 existent existent JJ 37231 1131 36 laws law NNS 37231 1131 37 . . . 37231 1132 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1132 2 is be VBZ 37231 1132 3 a a DT 37231 1132 4 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1132 5 part part NN 37231 1132 6 of of IN 37231 1132 7 the the DT 37231 1132 8 order order NN 37231 1132 9 of of IN 37231 1132 10 nature,(1 nature,(1 NN 37231 1132 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1132 12 and and CC 37231 1132 13 instead instead RB 37231 1132 14 of of IN 37231 1132 15 { { -LRB- 37231 1132 16 42 42 CD 37231 1132 17 } } -RRB- 37231 1132 18 rendering render VBG 37231 1132 19 credible credible JJ 37231 1132 20 any any DT 37231 1132 21 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1132 22 suspension suspension NN 37231 1132 23 of of IN 37231 1132 24 laws law NNS 37231 1132 25 , , , 37231 1132 26 the the DT 37231 1132 27 analogy analogy NN 37231 1132 28 of of IN 37231 1132 29 animated animate VBN 37231 1132 30 beings being NNS 37231 1132 31 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 1132 32 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 1132 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1132 34 . . . 37231 1133 1 The the DT 37231 1133 2 introduction introduction NN 37231 1133 3 of of IN 37231 1133 4 life life NN 37231 1133 5 in in IN 37231 1133 6 no no DT 37231 1133 7 way way NN 37231 1133 8 changes change VBZ 37231 1133 9 the the DT 37231 1133 10 relation relation NN 37231 1133 11 between between IN 37231 1133 12 cause cause NN 37231 1133 13 and and CC 37231 1133 14 effect effect NN 37231 1133 15 , , , 37231 1133 16 which which WDT 37231 1133 17 constitutes constitute VBZ 37231 1133 18 the the DT 37231 1133 19 order order NN 37231 1133 20 of of IN 37231 1133 21 nature nature NN 37231 1133 22 , , , 37231 1133 23 and and CC 37231 1133 24 is be VBZ 37231 1133 25 the the DT 37231 1133 26 essence essence NN 37231 1133 27 of of IN 37231 1133 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1133 29 law law NN 37231 1133 30 . . . 37231 1134 1 Life life NN 37231 1134 2 favours favour VBZ 37231 1134 3 no no DT 37231 1134 4 presumption presumption NN 37231 1134 5 for for IN 37231 1134 6 the the DT 37231 1134 7 suspension suspension NN 37231 1134 8 of of IN 37231 1134 9 law law NN 37231 1134 10 , , , 37231 1134 11 but but CC 37231 1134 12 , , , 37231 1134 13 on on IN 37231 1134 14 the the DT 37231 1134 15 contrary contrary NN 37231 1134 16 , , , 37231 1134 17 whilst whilst IN 37231 1134 18 acting act VBG 37231 1134 19 in in IN 37231 1134 20 nature nature NN 37231 1134 21 , , , 37231 1134 22 universally universally RB 37231 1134 23 exhibits exhibit VBZ 37231 1134 24 the the DT 37231 1134 25 prevalence prevalence NN 37231 1134 26 and and CC 37231 1134 27 invariability invariability NN 37231 1134 28 of of IN 37231 1134 29 law law NN 37231 1134 30 . . . 37231 1135 1 The the DT 37231 1135 2 " " `` 37231 1135 3 laws law NNS 37231 1135 4 of of IN 37231 1135 5 life life NN 37231 1135 6 " " '' 37231 1135 7 may may MD 37231 1135 8 be be VB 37231 1135 9 subtle subtle JJ 37231 1135 10 , , , 37231 1135 11 but but CC 37231 1135 12 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1135 13 are be VBP 37231 1135 14 an an DT 37231 1135 15 integral integral JJ 37231 1135 16 portion portion NN 37231 1135 17 of of IN 37231 1135 18 the the DT 37231 1135 19 great great JJ 37231 1135 20 order order NN 37231 1135 21 of of IN 37231 1135 22 nature nature NN 37231 1135 23 , , , 37231 1135 24 working work VBG 37231 1135 25 harmoniously harmoniously RB 37231 1135 26 with with IN 37231 1135 27 the the DT 37231 1135 28 laws law NNS 37231 1135 29 of of IN 37231 1135 30 matter matter NN 37231 1135 31 , , , 37231 1135 32 and and CC 37231 1135 33 not not RB 37231 1135 34 one one CD 37231 1135 35 whit whit NN 37231 1135 36 more more RBR 37231 1135 37 independent independent JJ 37231 1135 38 of of IN 37231 1135 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1135 40 than than IN 37231 1135 41 any any DT 37231 1135 42 one one CD 37231 1135 43 natural natural JJ 37231 1135 44 law law NN 37231 1135 45 is be VBZ 37231 1135 46 of of IN 37231 1135 47 another another DT 37231 1135 48 . . . 37231 1136 1 The the DT 37231 1136 2 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1136 3 " " `` 37231 1136 4 Efficient efficient JJ 37231 1136 5 Cause cause NN 37231 1136 6 , , , 37231 1136 7 " " '' 37231 1136 8 is be VBZ 37231 1136 9 wholly wholly RB 37231 1136 10 circumscribed circumscribe VBN 37231 1136 11 by by IN 37231 1136 12 law law NN 37231 1136 13 . . . 37231 1137 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1137 2 is be VBZ 37231 1137 3 brought bring VBN 37231 1137 4 into into IN 37231 1137 5 existence existence NN 37231 1137 6 by by IN 37231 1137 7 the the DT 37231 1137 8 operation operation NN 37231 1137 9 of of IN 37231 1137 10 immutable immutable JJ 37231 1137 11 physical physical JJ 37231 1137 12 laws law NNS 37231 1137 13 , , , 37231 1137 14 and and CC 37231 1137 15 from from IN 37231 1137 16 the the DT 37231 1137 17 cradle cradle NN 37231 1137 18 to to IN 37231 1137 19 the the DT 37231 1137 20 grave grave NN 37231 1137 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1137 22 is be VBZ 37231 1137 23 subject subject JJ 37231 1137 24 to to IN 37231 1137 25 those those DT 37231 1137 26 laws law NNS 37231 1137 27 . . . 37231 1138 1 So so CC 37231 1138 2 inseparably inseparably RB 37231 1138 3 is be VBZ 37231 1138 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1138 5 connected connect VBN 37231 1138 6 with with IN 37231 1138 7 matter matter NN 37231 1138 8 , , , 37231 1138 9 and and CC 37231 1138 10 consequently consequently RB 37231 1138 11 with with IN 37231 1138 12 the the DT 37231 1138 13 laws law NNS 37231 1138 14 which which WDT 37231 1138 15 regulate regulate VBP 37231 1138 16 matter matter NN 37231 1138 17 , , , 37231 1138 18 that that IN 37231 1138 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1138 20 can can MD 37231 1138 21 not not RB 37231 1138 22 even even RB 37231 1138 23 become become VB 37231 1138 24 conscious conscious JJ 37231 1138 25 of of IN 37231 1138 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1138 27 own own JJ 37231 1138 28 existence existence NN 37231 1138 29 without without IN 37231 1138 30 the the DT 37231 1138 31 intervention intervention NN 37231 1138 32 of of IN 37231 1138 33 matter matter NN 37231 1138 34 . . . 37231 1139 1 The the DT 37231 1139 2 whole whole JJ 37231 1139 3 process process NN 37231 1139 4 of of IN 37231 1139 5 life life NN 37231 1139 6 is be VBZ 37231 1139 7 dependent dependent JJ 37231 1139 8 on on IN 37231 1139 9 obedience obedience NN 37231 1139 10 to to IN 37231 1139 11 natural natural JJ 37231 1139 12 laws law NNS 37231 1139 13 , , , 37231 1139 14 and and CC 37231 1139 15 so so RB 37231 1139 16 powerless powerless JJ 37231 1139 17 is be VBZ 37231 1139 18 this this DT 37231 1139 19 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1139 20 cause cause NN 37231 1139 21 to to TO 37231 1139 22 resist resist VB 37231 1139 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1139 24 jurisdiction jurisdiction NN 37231 1139 25 , , , 37231 1139 26 that that IN 37231 1139 27 , , , 37231 1139 28 in in IN 37231 1139 29 spite spite NN 37231 1139 30 of of IN 37231 1139 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1139 32 highest high JJS 37231 1139 33 efforts effort NNS 37231 1139 34 , , , 37231 1139 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1139 36 pines pine VBZ 37231 1139 37 or or CC 37231 1139 38 ceases cease VBZ 37231 1139 39 to to TO 37231 1139 40 exist exist VB 37231 1139 41 in in IN 37231 1139 42 consequence consequence NN 37231 1139 43 of of IN 37231 1139 44 the the DT 37231 1139 45 mere mere JJ 37231 1139 46 natural natural JJ 37231 1139 47 operation operation NN 37231 1139 48 of of IN 37231 1139 49 law law NN 37231 1139 50 upon upon IN 37231 1139 51 the the DT 37231 1139 52 matter matter NN 37231 1139 53 with with IN 37231 1139 54 which which WDT 37231 1139 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1139 56 is be VBZ 37231 1139 57 united united JJ 37231 1139 58 , , , 37231 1139 59 and and CC 37231 1139 60 without without IN 37231 1139 61 { { -LRB- 37231 1139 62 43 43 CD 37231 1139 63 } } -RRB- 37231 1139 64 which which WDT 37231 1139 65 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1139 66 is be VBZ 37231 1139 67 impotent impotent JJ 37231 1139 68 . . . 37231 1140 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1140 2 can can MD 37231 1140 3 not not RB 37231 1140 4 receive receive VB 37231 1140 5 an an DT 37231 1140 6 impression impression NN 37231 1140 7 from from IN 37231 1140 8 without without IN 37231 1140 9 that that DT 37231 1140 10 is be VBZ 37231 1140 11 not not RB 37231 1140 12 conveyed convey VBN 37231 1140 13 in in IN 37231 1140 14 accordance accordance NN 37231 1140 15 with with IN 37231 1140 16 law law NN 37231 1140 17 , , , 37231 1140 18 and and CC 37231 1140 19 perceived perceive VBN 37231 1140 20 by by IN 37231 1140 21 an an DT 37231 1140 22 exquisitely exquisitely RB 37231 1140 23 ordered order VBN 37231 1140 24 organism organism NN 37231 1140 25 , , , 37231 1140 26 in in IN 37231 1140 27 every every DT 37231 1140 28 part part NN 37231 1140 29 of of IN 37231 1140 30 which which WDT 37231 1140 31 law law NN 37231 1140 32 reigns reigns NNP 37231 1140 33 supreme supreme NNP 37231 1140 34 ; ; , 37231 1140 35 nor nor CC 37231 1140 36 can can MD 37231 1140 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1140 38 communicate communicate VB 37231 1140 39 from from IN 37231 1140 40 within within IN 37231 1140 41 except except IN 37231 1140 42 through through IN 37231 1140 43 channels channel NNS 37231 1140 44 equally equally RB 37231 1140 45 ordered order VBN 37231 1140 46 by by IN 37231 1140 47 law law NN 37231 1140 48 . . . 37231 1141 1 A a DT 37231 1141 2 slight slight JJ 37231 1141 3 injury injury NN 37231 1141 4 may may MD 37231 1141 5 derange derange VB 37231 1141 6 the the DT 37231 1141 7 delicate delicate JJ 37231 1141 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 37231 1141 9 contrivances contrivance NNS 37231 1141 10 of of IN 37231 1141 11 eye eye NN 37231 1141 12 , , , 37231 1141 13 ear ear NN 37231 1141 14 , , , 37231 1141 15 and and CC 37231 1141 16 vocal vocal JJ 37231 1141 17 chords chord NNS 37231 1141 18 , , , 37231 1141 19 and and CC 37231 1141 20 may may MD 37231 1141 21 further further RB 37231 1141 22 destroy destroy VB 37231 1141 23 the the DT 37231 1141 24 reason reason NN 37231 1141 25 and and CC 37231 1141 26 paralyze paralyze VB 37231 1141 27 the the DT 37231 1141 28 body body NN 37231 1141 29 , , , 37231 1141 30 reducing reduce VBG 37231 1141 31 the the DT 37231 1141 32 animated animate VBN 37231 1141 33 being be VBG 37231 1141 34 , , , 37231 1141 35 by by IN 37231 1141 36 the the DT 37231 1141 37 derangement derangement NN 37231 1141 38 of of IN 37231 1141 39 those those DT 37231 1141 40 channels channel NNS 37231 1141 41 to to TO 37231 1141 42 which which WDT 37231 1141 43 physical physical JJ 37231 1141 44 law law NN 37231 1141 45 limits limit VBZ 37231 1141 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1141 47 action action NN 37231 1141 48 , , , 37231 1141 49 to to IN 37231 1141 50 a a DT 37231 1141 51 mere mere JJ 37231 1141 52 smouldering smouldering NN 37231 1141 53 spark spark NN 37231 1141 54 of of IN 37231 1141 55 life life NN 37231 1141 56 , , , 37231 1141 57 without without IN 37231 1141 58 consciousness consciousness NN 37231 1141 59 and and CC 37231 1141 60 without without IN 37231 1141 61 expression expression NN 37231 1141 62 . . . 37231 1142 1 The the DT 37231 1142 2 " " `` 37231 1142 3 laws law NNS 37231 1142 4 of of IN 37231 1142 5 life life NN 37231 1142 6 " " '' 37231 1142 7 act act NN 37231 1142 8 amongst amongst IN 37231 1142 9 the the DT 37231 1142 10 laws law NNS 37231 1142 11 of of IN 37231 1142 12 matter matter NN 37231 1142 13 , , , 37231 1142 14 but but CC 37231 1142 15 are be VBP 37231 1142 16 not not RB 37231 1142 17 independent independent JJ 37231 1142 18 of of IN 37231 1142 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1142 20 , , , 37231 1142 21 and and CC 37231 1142 22 the the DT 37231 1142 23 action action NN 37231 1142 24 of of IN 37231 1142 25 both both DT 37231 1142 26 classes class NNS 37231 1142 27 of of IN 37231 1142 28 law law NN 37231 1142 29 is be VBZ 37231 1142 30 regulated regulate VBN 37231 1142 31 by by IN 37231 1142 32 precisely precisely RB 37231 1142 33 the the DT 37231 1142 34 same same JJ 37231 1142 35 principles principle NNS 37231 1142 36 . . . 37231 1143 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1143 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1143 3 's 's POS 37231 1143 4 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 1143 5 , , , 37231 1143 6 that that IN 37231 1143 7 _ _ NNP 37231 1143 8 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1143 9 _ _ NNP 37231 1143 10 one one CD 37231 1143 11 step step NN 37231 1143 12 on on IN 37231 1143 13 the the DT 37231 1143 14 ground ground NN 37231 1143 15 and and CC 37231 1143 16 an an DT 37231 1143 17 ascent ascent NN 37231 1143 18 to to IN 37231 1143 19 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1143 20 are be VBP 37231 1143 21 alike alike RB 37231 1143 22 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1143 23 , , , 37231 1143 24 does do VBZ 37231 1143 25 not not RB 37231 1143 26 help help VB 37231 1143 27 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1143 28 . . . 37231 1144 1 In in IN 37231 1144 2 that that DT 37231 1144 3 sense sense NN 37231 1144 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1144 5 follows follow VBZ 37231 1144 6 that that IN 37231 1144 7 there there EX 37231 1144 8 is be VBZ 37231 1144 9 nothing nothing NN 37231 1144 10 that that WDT 37231 1144 11 is be VBZ 37231 1144 12 not not RB 37231 1144 13 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1144 14 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1144 15 , , , 37231 1144 16 nothing nothing NN 37231 1144 17 credible credible JJ 37231 1144 18 until until IN 37231 1144 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1144 20 has have VBZ 37231 1144 21 happened happen VBN 37231 1144 22 . . . 37231 1145 1 This this DT 37231 1145 2 argument argument NN 37231 1145 3 , , , 37231 1145 4 however however RB 37231 1145 5 , , , 37231 1145 6 while while IN 37231 1145 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1145 8 limits limit VBZ 37231 1145 9 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1145 10 to to IN 37231 1145 11 actual actual JJ 37231 1145 12 experience experience NN 37231 1145 13 , , , 37231 1145 14 prohibits prohibit VBZ 37231 1145 15 presumptions presumption NNS 37231 1145 16 with with IN 37231 1145 17 regard regard NN 37231 1145 18 to to IN 37231 1145 19 that that DT 37231 1145 20 which which WDT 37231 1145 21 is be VBZ 37231 1145 22 beyond beyond IN 37231 1145 23 experience experience NN 37231 1145 24 . . . 37231 1146 1 To to TO 37231 1146 2 argue argue VB 37231 1146 3 that that IN 37231 1146 4 , , , 37231 1146 5 because because IN 37231 1146 6 a a DT 37231 1146 7 step step NN 37231 1146 8 on on IN 37231 1146 9 the the DT 37231 1146 10 ground ground NN 37231 1146 11 and and CC 37231 1146 12 an an DT 37231 1146 13 ascent ascent NN 37231 1146 14 to to IN 37231 1146 15 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1146 16 are be VBP 37231 1146 17 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1146 18 alike alike RB 37231 1146 19 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1146 20 , , , 37231 1146 21 yet yet CC 37231 1146 22 as as IN 37231 1146 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1146 24 subsequently subsequently RB 37231 1146 25 make make VBP 37231 1146 26 that that DT 37231 1146 27 step step NN 37231 1146 28 , , , 37231 1146 29 therefore therefore RB 37231 1146 30 the the DT 37231 1146 31 ascent ascent NN 37231 1146 32 to to IN 37231 1146 33 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1146 34 , , , 37231 1146 35 which which WDT 37231 1146 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1146 37 can can MD 37231 1146 38 not not RB 37231 1146 39 make make VB 37231 1146 40 , , , 37231 1146 41 from from IN 37231 1146 42 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1146 43 becomes become VBZ 37231 1146 44 credible credible JJ 37231 1146 45 , , , 37231 1146 46 is be VBZ 37231 1146 47 a a DT 37231 1146 48 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1146 49 in in IN 37231 1146 50 terms term NNS 37231 1146 51 . . . 37231 1147 1 If if IN 37231 1147 2 the the DT 37231 1147 3 ascent ascent NN 37231 1147 4 be be VBP 37231 1147 5 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1147 6 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1147 7 , , , 37231 1147 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1147 9 can can MD 37231 1147 10 not not RB 37231 1147 11 at at IN 37231 1147 12 the the DT 37231 1147 13 same same JJ 37231 1147 14 time time NN 37231 1147 15 be be VB 37231 1147 16 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1147 17 credible credible JJ 37231 1147 18 . . . 37231 1148 1 That that DT 37231 1148 2 which which WDT 37231 1148 3 is be VBZ 37231 1148 4 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1148 5 can can MD 37231 1148 6 not not RB 37231 1148 7 become become VB 37231 1148 8 credible credible JJ 37231 1148 9 because because IN 37231 1148 10 something something NN 37231 1148 11 else else RB 37231 1148 12 quite quite RB 37231 1148 13 different different JJ 37231 1148 14 becomes become VBZ 37231 1148 15 credible credible JJ 37231 1148 16 . . . 37231 1149 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1149 2 is be VBZ 37231 1149 3 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1149 4 that that IN 37231 1149 5 such such PDT 37231 1149 6 an an DT 37231 1149 7 argument argument NN 37231 1149 8 is be VBZ 37231 1149 9 vicious vicious JJ 37231 1149 10 . . . 37231 1150 1 Experience experience NN 37231 1150 2 comes come VBZ 37231 1150 3 { { -LRB- 37231 1150 4 44 44 CD 37231 1150 5 } } -RRB- 37231 1150 6 with with IN 37231 1150 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1150 8 sober sober JJ 37231 1150 9 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1150 10 to to TO 37231 1150 11 check check VB 37231 1150 12 such such JJ 37231 1150 13 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1150 14 . . . 37231 1151 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1151 2 believe believe VBP 37231 1151 3 in in IN 37231 1151 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1151 5 power power NN 37231 1151 6 to to TO 37231 1151 7 walk walk VB 37231 1151 8 because because IN 37231 1151 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1151 10 habitually habitually RB 37231 1151 11 exercise exercise VBP 37231 1151 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1151 13 : : : 37231 1151 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1151 15 disbelieve disbelieve VBP 37231 1151 16 in in IN 37231 1151 17 bodily bodily JJ 37231 1151 18 ascensions ascension NNS 37231 1151 19 because because IN 37231 1151 20 all all DT 37231 1151 21 experience experience NN 37231 1151 22 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 1151 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1151 24 . . . 37231 1152 1 The the DT 37231 1152 2 step step NN 37231 1152 3 is be VBZ 37231 1152 4 part part NN 37231 1152 5 of of IN 37231 1152 6 the the DT 37231 1152 7 recognised recognise VBN 37231 1152 8 order order NN 37231 1152 9 of of IN 37231 1152 10 nature nature NN 37231 1152 11 , , , 37231 1152 12 and and CC 37231 1152 13 has have VBZ 37231 1152 14 none none NN 37231 1152 15 of of IN 37231 1152 16 the the DT 37231 1152 17 elements element NNS 37231 1152 18 in in IN 37231 1152 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1152 20 of of IN 37231 1152 21 the the DT 37231 1152 22 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1152 23 . . . 37231 1153 1 But but CC 37231 1153 2 if if IN 37231 1153 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1153 4 leap leap VBP 37231 1153 5 into into IN 37231 1153 6 the the DT 37231 1153 7 air air NN 37231 1153 8 on on IN 37231 1153 9 the the DT 37231 1153 10 brink brink NN 37231 1153 11 of of IN 37231 1153 12 a a DT 37231 1153 13 precipice precipice NN 37231 1153 14 , , , 37231 1153 15 belief belief NN 37231 1153 16 in in IN 37231 1153 17 an an DT 37231 1153 18 ascent ascent NN 37231 1153 19 to to IN 37231 1153 20 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1153 21 is be VBZ 37231 1153 22 shattered shatter VBN 37231 1153 23 to to IN 37231 1153 24 pieces piece NNS 37231 1153 25 at at IN 37231 1153 26 the the DT 37231 1153 27 bottom bottom NN 37231 1153 28 to to TO 37231 1153 29 which which WDT 37231 1153 30 the the DT 37231 1153 31 law law NN 37231 1153 32 of of IN 37231 1153 33 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1153 34 infallibly infallibly RB 37231 1153 35 drags drag VBZ 37231 1153 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1153 37 . . . 37231 1154 1 There there EX 37231 1154 2 is be VBZ 37231 1154 3 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 1154 4 nothing nothing NN 37231 1154 5 in in IN 37231 1154 6 the the DT 37231 1154 7 constitution constitution NN 37231 1154 8 of of IN 37231 1154 9 nature nature NN 37231 1154 10 , , , 37231 1154 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1154 12 may may MD 37231 1154 13 say say VB 37231 1154 14 , , , 37231 1154 15 reversing reverse VBG 37231 1154 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1154 17 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1154 18 's 's POS 37231 1154 19 assertion assertion NN 37231 1154 20 , , , 37231 1154 21 which which WDT 37231 1154 22 does do VBZ 37231 1154 23 not not RB 37231 1154 24 prove prove VB 37231 1154 25 the the DT 37231 1154 26 incredibility incredibility NN 37231 1154 27 of of IN 37231 1154 28 a a DT 37231 1154 29 Divine divine JJ 37231 1154 30 suspension suspension NN 37231 1154 31 of of IN 37231 1154 32 physical physical JJ 37231 1154 33 laws law NNS 37231 1154 34 , , , 37231 1154 35 and and CC 37231 1154 36 does do VBZ 37231 1154 37 not not RB 37231 1154 38 create create VB 37231 1154 39 a a DT 37231 1154 40 presumption presumption NN 37231 1154 41 against against IN 37231 1154 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1154 43 . . . 37231 1155 1 There there EX 37231 1155 2 is be VBZ 37231 1155 3 no no DT 37231 1155 4 instance instance NN 37231 1155 5 producible producible JJ 37231 1155 6 , , , 37231 1155 7 or or CC 37231 1155 8 even even RB 37231 1155 9 logically logically RB 37231 1155 10 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 1155 11 , , , 37231 1155 12 of of IN 37231 1155 13 any any DT 37231 1155 14 power power NN 37231 1155 15 whose whose WP$ 37231 1155 16 effects effect NNS 37231 1155 17 are be VBP 37231 1155 18 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1155 19 to to IN 37231 1155 20 the the DT 37231 1155 21 ultimate ultimate JJ 37231 1155 22 ruling ruling NN 37231 1155 23 of of IN 37231 1155 24 the the DT 37231 1155 25 laws law NNS 37231 1155 26 of of IN 37231 1155 27 nature nature NN 37231 1155 28 . . . 37231 1156 1 The the DT 37231 1156 2 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1156 3 of of IN 37231 1156 4 anything anything NN 37231 1156 5 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1156 6 to to IN 37231 1156 7 those those DT 37231 1156 8 laws law NNS 37231 1156 9 is be VBZ 37231 1156 10 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1156 11 . . . 37231 1157 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1157 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1157 3 has have VBZ 37231 1157 4 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1157 5 shown show VBN 37231 1157 6 that that IN 37231 1157 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1157 8 can can MD 37231 1157 9 not not RB 37231 1157 10 be be VB 37231 1157 11 explained explain VBN 37231 1157 12 either either CC 37231 1157 13 by by IN 37231 1157 14 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1157 15 connection connection NN 37231 1157 16 with with IN 37231 1157 17 known know VBN 37231 1157 18 law law NN 37231 1157 19 , , , 37231 1157 20 or or CC 37231 1157 21 by by IN 37231 1157 22 reference reference NN 37231 1157 23 to to IN 37231 1157 24 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1157 25 law law NN 37231 1157 26 ; ; : 37231 1157 27 and and CC 37231 1157 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1157 29 renounces renounce VBZ 37231 1157 30 the the DT 37231 1157 31 explanation explanation NN 37231 1157 32 of of IN 37231 1157 33 " " `` 37231 1157 34 higher high JJR 37231 1157 35 law law NN 37231 1157 36 . . . 37231 1157 37 " " '' 37231 1158 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1158 2 distinction distinction NN 37231 1158 3 between between IN 37231 1158 4 the the DT 37231 1158 5 laws law NNS 37231 1158 6 of of IN 37231 1158 7 nature nature NN 37231 1158 8 and and CC 37231 1158 9 the the DT 37231 1158 10 " " `` 37231 1158 11 laws law NNS 37231 1158 12 of of IN 37231 1158 13 the the DT 37231 1158 14 universe,"(1 universe,"(1 CD 37231 1158 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1158 16 by by IN 37231 1158 17 which which WDT 37231 1158 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1158 19 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 1158 20 endeavours endeavour VBZ 37231 1158 21 to to TO 37231 1158 22 make make VB 37231 1158 23 a a DT 37231 1158 24 miracle miracle NN 37231 1158 25 credible credible JJ 37231 1158 26 , , , 37231 1158 27 is be VBZ 37231 1158 28 one one CD 37231 1158 29 which which WDT 37231 1158 30 is be VBZ 37231 1158 31 purely purely RB 37231 1158 32 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 1158 33 , , , 37231 1158 34 and and CC 37231 1158 35 can can MD 37231 1158 36 not not RB 37231 1158 37 affect affect VB 37231 1158 38 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1158 39 in in IN 37231 1158 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1158 41 present present JJ 37231 1158 42 position position NN 37231 1158 43 within within IN 37231 1158 44 the the DT 37231 1158 45 order order NN 37231 1158 46 of of IN 37231 1158 47 nature nature NN 37231 1158 48 . . . 37231 1159 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1159 2 know know VBP 37231 1159 3 of of IN 37231 1159 4 no no DT 37231 1159 5 laws law NNS 37231 1159 6 of of IN 37231 1159 7 the the DT 37231 1159 8 universe universe NN 37231 1159 9 differing differ VBG 37231 1159 10 from from IN 37231 1159 11 the the DT 37231 1159 12 laws law NNS 37231 1159 13 of of IN 37231 1159 14 nature nature NN 37231 1159 15 . . . 37231 1160 1 So so RB 37231 1160 2 far far RB 37231 1160 3 as as IN 37231 1160 4 human human JJ 37231 1160 5 observation observation NN 37231 1160 6 can can MD 37231 1160 7 range range VB 37231 1160 8 , , , 37231 1160 9 these these DT 37231 1160 10 laws law NNS 37231 1160 11 alone alone RB 37231 1160 12 prevail prevail VBP 37231 1160 13 . . . 37231 1161 1 For for IN 37231 1161 2 all all DT 37231 1161 3 practical practical JJ 37231 1161 4 purposes purpose NNS 37231 1161 5 , , , 37231 1161 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 1161 7 , , , 37231 1161 8 such such PDT 37231 1161 9 a a DT 37231 1161 10 distinction distinction NN 37231 1161 11 is be VBZ 37231 1161 12 futile futile JJ 37231 1161 13 , , , 37231 1161 14 and and CC 37231 1161 15 belief belief NN 37231 1161 16 is be VBZ 37231 1161 17 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 1161 18 limited limit VBN 37231 1161 19 to to IN 37231 1161 20 the the DT 37231 1161 21 actual actual JJ 37231 1161 22 operation operation NN 37231 1161 23 of of IN 37231 1161 24 natural natural JJ 37231 1161 25 laws law NNS 37231 1161 26 . . . 37231 1162 1 The the DT 37231 1162 2 occasional occasional JJ 37231 1162 3 intervention intervention NN 37231 1162 4 of of IN 37231 1162 5 an an DT 37231 1162 6 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1162 7 " " `` 37231 1162 8 efficient efficient JJ 37231 1162 9 cause cause NN 37231 1162 10 , , , 37231 1162 11 " " '' 37231 1162 12 producing produce VBG 37231 1162 13 the the DT 37231 1162 14 effects effect NNS 37231 1162 15 { { -LRB- 37231 1162 16 45 45 CD 37231 1162 17 } } -RRB- 37231 1162 18 called call VBN 37231 1162 19 " " `` 37231 1162 20 miracles"--effects miracles"--effect NNS 37231 1162 21 which which WDT 37231 1162 22 are be VBP 37231 1162 23 not not RB 37231 1162 24 referrible referrible JJ 37231 1162 25 to to IN 37231 1162 26 any any DT 37231 1162 27 known known JJ 37231 1162 28 law law NN 37231 1162 29 -- -- : 37231 1162 30 is be VBZ 37231 1162 31 totally totally RB 37231 1162 32 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1162 33 to to TO 37231 1162 34 experience experience VB 37231 1162 35 , , , 37231 1162 36 and and CC 37231 1162 37 such such PDT 37231 1162 38 a a DT 37231 1162 39 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1162 40 to to TO 37231 1162 41 explain explain VB 37231 1162 42 alleged alleged JJ 37231 1162 43 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1162 44 of of IN 37231 1162 45 a a DT 37231 1162 46 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1162 47 character character NN 37231 1162 48 can can MD 37231 1162 49 not not RB 37231 1162 50 find find VB 37231 1162 51 a a DT 37231 1162 52 legitimate legitimate JJ 37231 1162 53 place place NN 37231 1162 54 within within IN 37231 1162 55 the the DT 37231 1162 56 order order NN 37231 1162 57 of of IN 37231 1162 58 nature nature NN 37231 1162 59 . . . 37231 1163 1 2 2 LS 37231 1163 2 . . . 37231 1164 1 The the DT 37231 1164 2 proposition proposition NN 37231 1164 3 with with IN 37231 1164 4 which which WDT 37231 1164 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1164 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1164 7 commences commence VBZ 37231 1164 8 these these DT 37231 1164 9 Bampton Bampton NNP 37231 1164 10 Lectures Lectures NNPS 37231 1164 11 , , , 37231 1164 12 and and CC 37231 1164 13 for for IN 37231 1164 14 which which WDT 37231 1164 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1164 16 contends contend VBZ 37231 1164 17 to to IN 37231 1164 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1164 19 close close NN 37231 1164 20 , , , 37231 1164 21 is be VBZ 37231 1164 22 this this DT 37231 1164 23 : : : 37231 1164 24 " " `` 37231 1164 25 That that IN 37231 1164 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1164 27 , , , 37231 1164 28 or or CC 37231 1164 29 visible visible JJ 37231 1164 30 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1164 31 of of IN 37231 1164 32 the the DT 37231 1164 33 order order NN 37231 1164 34 of of IN 37231 1164 35 nature nature NN 37231 1164 36 for for IN 37231 1164 37 a a DT 37231 1164 38 providential providential JJ 37231 1164 39 purpose purpose NN 37231 1164 40 , , , 37231 1164 41 are be VBP 37231 1164 42 not not RB 37231 1164 43 in in IN 37231 1164 44 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1164 45 to to IN 37231 1164 46 reason reason NN 37231 1164 47 . . . 37231 1165 1 " " `` 37231 1165 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1165 3 1 1 LS 37231 1165 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1165 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1165 6 shows show VBZ 37231 1165 7 that that IN 37231 1165 8 , , , 37231 1165 9 the the DT 37231 1165 10 purpose purpose NN 37231 1165 11 of of IN 37231 1165 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1165 13 is be VBZ 37231 1165 14 to to TO 37231 1165 15 attest attest VB 37231 1165 16 a a DT 37231 1165 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1165 18 revelation revelation NN 37231 1165 19 , , , 37231 1165 20 which which WDT 37231 1165 21 , , , 37231 1165 22 without without IN 37231 1165 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1165 24 , , , 37231 1165 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1165 26 could could MD 37231 1165 27 not not RB 37231 1165 28 be be VB 37231 1165 29 justified justify VBN 37231 1165 30 in in IN 37231 1165 31 believing believe VBG 37231 1165 32 . . . 37231 1166 1 " " `` 37231 1166 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1166 3 , , , 37231 1166 4 " " '' 37231 1166 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1166 6 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 1166 7 states state VBZ 37231 1166 8 , , , 37231 1166 9 " " `` 37231 1166 10 can can MD 37231 1166 11 not not RB 37231 1166 12 be be VB 37231 1166 13 maintained maintain VBN 37231 1166 14 as as IN 37231 1166 15 a a DT 37231 1166 16 revelation revelation NN 37231 1166 17 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 37231 1166 18 by by IN 37231 1166 19 human human JJ 37231 1166 20 reason reason NN 37231 1166 21 -- -- : 37231 1166 22 a a DT 37231 1166 23 revelation revelation NN 37231 1166 24 of of IN 37231 1166 25 a a DT 37231 1166 26 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1166 27 scheme scheme NN 37231 1166 28 for for IN 37231 1166 29 man man NN 37231 1166 30 's 's POS 37231 1166 31 salvation salvation NN 37231 1166 32 without without IN 37231 1166 33 the the DT 37231 1166 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 1166 35 of of IN 37231 1166 36 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1166 37 . . . 37231 1167 1 " " `` 37231 1167 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1167 3 2 2 LS 37231 1167 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1167 5 Out out IN 37231 1167 6 of of IN 37231 1167 7 this this DT 37231 1167 8 very very JJ 37231 1167 9 admission admission NN 37231 1167 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1167 11 attempts attempt VBZ 37231 1167 12 to to TO 37231 1167 13 construct construct VB 37231 1167 14 an an DT 37231 1167 15 argument argument NN 37231 1167 16 in in IN 37231 1167 17 support support NN 37231 1167 18 of of IN 37231 1167 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1167 20 : : : 37231 1167 21 " " `` 37231 1167 22 Hence hence RB 37231 1167 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1167 24 follows follow VBZ 37231 1167 25 , , , 37231 1167 26 " " '' 37231 1167 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1167 28 continues continue VBZ 37231 1167 29 , , , 37231 1167 30 " " `` 37231 1167 31 that that IN 37231 1167 32 upon upon IN 37231 1167 33 the the DT 37231 1167 34 supposition supposition NN 37231 1167 35 of of IN 37231 1167 36 the the DT 37231 1167 37 Divine divine JJ 37231 1167 38 design design NN 37231 1167 39 of of IN 37231 1167 40 a a DT 37231 1167 41 revelation revelation NN 37231 1167 42 , , , 37231 1167 43 a a DT 37231 1167 44 miracle miracle NN 37231 1167 45 is be VBZ 37231 1167 46 not not RB 37231 1167 47 an an DT 37231 1167 48 anomaly anomaly JJ 37231 1167 49 or or CC 37231 1167 50 irregularity irregularity NN 37231 1167 51 , , , 37231 1167 52 but but CC 37231 1167 53 part part NN 37231 1167 54 of of IN 37231 1167 55 the the DT 37231 1167 56 system system NN 37231 1167 57 of of IN 37231 1167 58 the the DT 37231 1167 59 universe universe NN 37231 1167 60 ; ; , 37231 1167 61 because because IN 37231 1167 62 , , , 37231 1167 63 though though IN 37231 1167 64 an an DT 37231 1167 65 irregularity irregularity NN 37231 1167 66 and and CC 37231 1167 67 an an DT 37231 1167 68 anomaly anomaly NN 37231 1167 69 in in IN 37231 1167 70 relation relation NN 37231 1167 71 to to IN 37231 1167 72 either either DT 37231 1167 73 part part NN 37231 1167 74 , , , 37231 1167 75 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1167 76 has have VBZ 37231 1167 77 a a DT 37231 1167 78 complete complete JJ 37231 1167 79 adaptation adaptation NN 37231 1167 80 to to IN 37231 1167 81 the the DT 37231 1167 82 whole whole NN 37231 1167 83 . . . 37231 1168 1 There there EX 37231 1168 2 being be VBG 37231 1168 3 two two CD 37231 1168 4 worlds world NNS 37231 1168 5 , , , 37231 1168 6 a a DT 37231 1168 7 visible visible JJ 37231 1168 8 and and CC 37231 1168 9 invisible invisible JJ 37231 1168 10 , , , 37231 1168 11 and and CC 37231 1168 12 a a DT 37231 1168 13 communication communication NN 37231 1168 14 between between IN 37231 1168 15 the the DT 37231 1168 16 two two CD 37231 1168 17 being be VBG 37231 1168 18 wanted want VBN 37231 1168 19 , , , 37231 1168 20 a a DT 37231 1168 21 miracle miracle NN 37231 1168 22 is be VBZ 37231 1168 23 the the DT 37231 1168 24 instrument instrument NN 37231 1168 25 of of IN 37231 1168 26 that that DT 37231 1168 27 communication communication NN 37231 1168 28 . . . 37231 1169 1 " " `` 37231 1169 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1169 3 3 3 LS 37231 1169 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1169 5 Here here RB 37231 1169 6 , , , 37231 1169 7 again again RB 37231 1169 8 , , , 37231 1169 9 the the DT 37231 1169 10 argument argument NN 37231 1169 11 is be VBZ 37231 1169 12 based base VBN 37231 1169 13 upon upon IN 37231 1169 14 mere mere JJ 37231 1169 15 assumption assumption NN 37231 1169 16 . . . 37231 1170 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1170 2 46 46 CD 37231 1170 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1170 4 The the DT 37231 1170 5 supposition supposition NN 37231 1170 6 of of IN 37231 1170 7 the the DT 37231 1170 8 Divine divine JJ 37231 1170 9 design design NN 37231 1170 10 of of IN 37231 1170 11 a a DT 37231 1170 12 revelation revelation NN 37231 1170 13 is be VBZ 37231 1170 14 the the DT 37231 1170 15 result result NN 37231 1170 16 of of IN 37231 1170 17 a a DT 37231 1170 18 foregone foregone JJ 37231 1170 19 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1170 20 in in IN 37231 1170 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1170 22 favour favour NN 37231 1170 23 , , , 37231 1170 24 and and CC 37231 1170 25 is be VBZ 37231 1170 26 not not RB 37231 1170 27 suggested suggest VBN 37231 1170 28 by by IN 37231 1170 29 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1170 30 probability probability NN 37231 1170 31 . . . 37231 1171 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1171 2 is be VBZ 37231 1171 3 , , , 37231 1171 4 in in IN 37231 1171 5 fact fact NN 37231 1171 6 , , , 37231 1171 7 derived derive VBN 37231 1171 8 solely solely RB 37231 1171 9 from from IN 37231 1171 10 the the DT 37231 1171 11 contents content NNS 37231 1171 12 of of IN 37231 1171 13 the the DT 37231 1171 14 revelation revelation NN 37231 1171 15 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1171 16 . . . 37231 1172 1 Divines divine NNS 37231 1172 2 assume assume VBP 37231 1172 3 that that IN 37231 1172 4 a a DT 37231 1172 5 communication communication NN 37231 1172 6 of of IN 37231 1172 7 this this DT 37231 1172 8 nature nature NN 37231 1172 9 is be VBZ 37231 1172 10 in in IN 37231 1172 11 accordance accordance NN 37231 1172 12 with with IN 37231 1172 13 reason reason NN 37231 1172 14 , , , 37231 1172 15 and and CC 37231 1172 16 was be VBD 37231 1172 17 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1172 18 for for IN 37231 1172 19 the the DT 37231 1172 20 salvation salvation NN 37231 1172 21 of of IN 37231 1172 22 the the DT 37231 1172 23 human human JJ 37231 1172 24 race race NN 37231 1172 25 , , , 37231 1172 26 simply simply RB 37231 1172 27 because because IN 37231 1172 28 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1172 29 believe believe VBP 37231 1172 30 that that IN 37231 1172 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1172 32 took take VBD 37231 1172 33 place place NN 37231 1172 34 . . . 37231 1173 1 No no DT 37231 1173 2 attempt attempt NN 37231 1173 3 is be VBZ 37231 1173 4 seriously seriously RB 37231 1173 5 made make VBN 37231 1173 6 independently independently RB 37231 1173 7 to to TO 37231 1173 8 prove prove VB 37231 1173 9 the the DT 37231 1173 10 reality reality NN 37231 1173 11 of of IN 37231 1173 12 the the DT 37231 1173 13 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1173 14 " " `` 37231 1173 15 Divine divine JJ 37231 1173 16 design design NN 37231 1173 17 of of IN 37231 1173 18 a a DT 37231 1173 19 revelation revelation NN 37231 1173 20 . . . 37231 1173 21 " " '' 37231 1174 1 A a DT 37231 1174 2 revelation revelation NN 37231 1174 3 having have VBG 37231 1174 4 , , , 37231 1174 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1174 6 is be VBZ 37231 1174 7 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1174 8 , , , 37231 1174 9 been be VBN 37231 1174 10 made make VBN 37231 1174 11 , , , 37231 1174 12 that that DT 37231 1174 13 revelation revelation NN 37231 1174 14 is be VBZ 37231 1174 15 consequently consequently RB 37231 1174 16 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1174 17 to to TO 37231 1174 18 have have VB 37231 1174 19 been be VBN 37231 1174 20 contemplated contemplate VBN 37231 1174 21 , , , 37231 1174 22 and and CC 37231 1174 23 to to TO 37231 1174 24 have have VB 37231 1174 25 necessitated necessitate VBN 37231 1174 26 and and CC 37231 1174 27 justified justified JJ 37231 1174 28 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1174 29 of of IN 37231 1174 30 the the DT 37231 1174 31 order order NN 37231 1174 32 of of IN 37231 1174 33 nature nature NN 37231 1174 34 to to TO 37231 1174 35 effect effect VB 37231 1174 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1174 37 . . . 37231 1175 1 The the DT 37231 1175 2 proposition proposition NN 37231 1175 3 for for IN 37231 1175 4 which which WDT 37231 1175 5 the the DT 37231 1175 6 evidence evidence NN 37231 1175 7 of of IN 37231 1175 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1175 9 is be VBZ 37231 1175 10 demanded demand VBN 37231 1175 11 is be VBZ 37231 1175 12 viciously viciously RB 37231 1175 13 employed employ VBN 37231 1175 14 as as IN 37231 1175 15 evidence evidence NN 37231 1175 16 for for IN 37231 1175 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1175 18 . . . 37231 1176 1 The the DT 37231 1176 2 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1176 3 upon upon IN 37231 1176 4 which which WDT 37231 1176 5 the the DT 37231 1176 6 assumption assumption NN 37231 1176 7 of of IN 37231 1176 8 the the DT 37231 1176 9 necessity necessity NN 37231 1176 10 and and CC 37231 1176 11 reasonableness reasonableness NN 37231 1176 12 of of IN 37231 1176 13 a a DT 37231 1176 14 revelation revelation NN 37231 1176 15 is be VBZ 37231 1176 16 based base VBN 37231 1176 17 , , , 37231 1176 18 however however RB 37231 1176 19 , , , 37231 1176 20 are be VBP 37231 1176 21 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1176 22 , , , 37231 1176 23 and and CC 37231 1176 24 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1176 25 to to IN 37231 1176 26 reason reason NN 37231 1176 27 . . . 37231 1177 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1177 2 are be VBP 37231 1177 3 asked ask VBN 37231 1177 4 to to TO 37231 1177 5 believe believe VB 37231 1177 6 that that IN 37231 1177 7 God God NNP 37231 1177 8 made make VBD 37231 1177 9 man man NN 37231 1177 10 in in IN 37231 1177 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1177 12 own own JJ 37231 1177 13 image image NN 37231 1177 14 , , , 37231 1177 15 pure pure JJ 37231 1177 16 and and CC 37231 1177 17 sinless sinless JJ 37231 1177 18 , , , 37231 1177 19 and and CC 37231 1177 20 intended intend VBD 37231 1177 21 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1177 22 to to TO 37231 1177 23 continue continue VB 37231 1177 24 so so RB 37231 1177 25 , , , 37231 1177 26 but but CC 37231 1177 27 that that DT 37231 1177 28 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1177 29 had have VBD 37231 1177 30 this this DT 37231 1177 31 , , , 37231 1177 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1177 33 noblest noble JJS 37231 1177 34 work work NN 37231 1177 35 , , , 37231 1177 36 left leave VBD 37231 1177 37 the the DT 37231 1177 38 hands hand NNS 37231 1177 39 of of IN 37231 1177 40 the the DT 37231 1177 41 Creator Creator NNP 37231 1177 42 , , , 37231 1177 43 than than IN 37231 1177 44 man man NN 37231 1177 45 was be VBD 37231 1177 46 tempted tempt VBN 37231 1177 47 into into IN 37231 1177 48 sin sin NN 37231 1177 49 by by IN 37231 1177 50 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1177 51 , , , 37231 1177 52 an an DT 37231 1177 53 all all RB 37231 1177 54 - - HYPH 37231 1177 55 powerful powerful JJ 37231 1177 56 and and CC 37231 1177 57 persistent persistent JJ 37231 1177 58 enemy enemy NN 37231 1177 59 of of IN 37231 1177 60 God God NNP 37231 1177 61 , , , 37231 1177 62 whose whose WP$ 37231 1177 63 existence existence NN 37231 1177 64 and and CC 37231 1177 65 antagonism antagonism NN 37231 1177 66 to to IN 37231 1177 67 a a DT 37231 1177 68 Being being NN 37231 1177 69 in in IN 37231 1177 70 whose whose WP$ 37231 1177 71 eyes eye NNS 37231 1177 72 sin sin NN 37231 1177 73 is be VBZ 37231 1177 74 abomination abomination NN 37231 1177 75 are be VBP 37231 1177 76 not not RB 37231 1177 77 accounted account VBN 37231 1177 78 for for IN 37231 1177 79 and and CC 37231 1177 80 are be VBP 37231 1177 81 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1177 82 . . . 37231 1178 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1178 2 1 1 LS 37231 1178 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1178 4 Adam Adam NNP 37231 1178 5 's 's POS 37231 1178 6 fall fall NN 37231 1178 7 brought bring VBD 37231 1178 8 a a DT 37231 1178 9 curse curse NN 37231 1178 10 upon upon IN 37231 1178 11 the the DT 37231 1178 12 earth earth NN 37231 1178 13 , , , 37231 1178 14 and and CC 37231 1178 15 incurred incur VBD 37231 1178 16 the the DT 37231 1178 17 penalty penalty NN 37231 1178 18 of of IN 37231 1178 19 death death NN 37231 1178 20 for for IN 37231 1178 21 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1178 22 and and CC 37231 1178 23 for for IN 37231 1178 24 the the DT 37231 1178 25 whole whole NN 37231 1178 26 of of IN 37231 1178 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1178 28 posterity posterity NN 37231 1178 29 . . . 37231 1179 1 The the DT 37231 1179 2 human human JJ 37231 1179 3 race race NN 37231 1179 4 , , , 37231 1179 5 although although IN 37231 1179 6 created create VBN 37231 1179 7 perfect perfect JJ 37231 1179 8 and and CC 37231 1179 9 without without IN 37231 1179 10 sin sin NN 37231 1179 11 , , , 37231 1179 12 { { -LRB- 37231 1179 13 47 47 CD 37231 1179 14 } } -RRB- 37231 1179 15 thus thus RB 37231 1179 16 disappointed disappoint VBD 37231 1179 17 the the DT 37231 1179 18 expectations expectation NNS 37231 1179 19 of of IN 37231 1179 20 the the DT 37231 1179 21 Creator Creator NNP 37231 1179 22 , , , 37231 1179 23 and and CC 37231 1179 24 became become VBD 37231 1179 25 daily daily RB 37231 1179 26 more more RBR 37231 1179 27 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1179 28 , , , 37231 1179 29 the the DT 37231 1179 30 Evil Evil NNP 37231 1179 31 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 1179 32 having have VBG 37231 1179 33 succeeded succeed VBN 37231 1179 34 in in IN 37231 1179 35 frustrating frustrate VBG 37231 1179 36 the the DT 37231 1179 37 designs design NNS 37231 1179 38 of of IN 37231 1179 39 the the DT 37231 1179 40 Almighty Almighty NNP 37231 1179 41 , , , 37231 1179 42 so so IN 37231 1179 43 that that IN 37231 1179 44 God God NNP 37231 1179 45 repented repent VBD 37231 1179 46 that that IN 37231 1179 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1179 48 had have VBD 37231 1179 49 made make VBN 37231 1179 50 man man NN 37231 1179 51 , , , 37231 1179 52 and and CC 37231 1179 53 at at IN 37231 1179 54 length length NN 37231 1179 55 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 1179 56 by by IN 37231 1179 57 a a DT 37231 1179 58 deluge deluge NN 37231 1179 59 all all PDT 37231 1179 60 the the DT 37231 1179 61 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 37231 1179 62 of of IN 37231 1179 63 the the DT 37231 1179 64 earth earth NN 37231 1179 65 , , , 37231 1179 66 with with IN 37231 1179 67 the the DT 37231 1179 68 exception exception NN 37231 1179 69 of of IN 37231 1179 70 eight eight CD 37231 1179 71 persons person NNS 37231 1179 72 who who WP 37231 1179 73 feared fear VBD 37231 1179 74 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1179 75 . . . 37231 1180 1 This this DT 37231 1180 2 sweeping sweeping JJ 37231 1180 3 purification purification NN 37231 1180 4 , , , 37231 1180 5 however however RB 37231 1180 6 , , , 37231 1180 7 was be VBD 37231 1180 8 as as RB 37231 1180 9 futile futile JJ 37231 1180 10 as as IN 37231 1180 11 the the DT 37231 1180 12 original original JJ 37231 1180 13 design design NN 37231 1180 14 , , , 37231 1180 15 and and CC 37231 1180 16 the the DT 37231 1180 17 race race NN 37231 1180 18 of of IN 37231 1180 19 men man NNS 37231 1180 20 soon soon RB 37231 1180 21 became become VBD 37231 1180 22 more more RBR 37231 1180 23 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1180 24 than than IN 37231 1180 25 ever ever RB 37231 1180 26 . . . 37231 1181 1 The the DT 37231 1181 2 final final JJ 37231 1181 3 and and CC 37231 1181 4 only only JJ 37231 1181 5 adequate adequate JJ 37231 1181 6 remedy remedy NN 37231 1181 7 devised devise VBN 37231 1181 8 by by IN 37231 1181 9 God God NNP 37231 1181 10 for for IN 37231 1181 11 the the DT 37231 1181 12 salvation salvation NN 37231 1181 13 of of IN 37231 1181 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1181 15 creatures creature NNS 37231 1181 16 , , , 37231 1181 17 become become VBP 37231 1181 18 so so RB 37231 1181 19 desperately desperately RB 37231 1181 20 and and CC 37231 1181 21 hopelessly hopelessly RB 37231 1181 22 evil evil JJ 37231 1181 23 , , , 37231 1181 24 was be VBD 37231 1181 25 the the DT 37231 1181 26 incarnation incarnation NN 37231 1181 27 of of IN 37231 1181 28 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1181 29 in in IN 37231 1181 30 the the DT 37231 1181 31 person person NN 37231 1181 32 of of IN 37231 1181 33 " " `` 37231 1181 34 the the DT 37231 1181 35 Son Son NNP 37231 1181 36 , , , 37231 1181 37 " " '' 37231 1181 38 the the DT 37231 1181 39 second second JJ 37231 1181 40 person person NN 37231 1181 41 in in IN 37231 1181 42 a a DT 37231 1181 43 mysterious mysterious JJ 37231 1181 44 Trinity Trinity NNP 37231 1181 45 of of IN 37231 1181 46 which which WDT 37231 1181 47 the the DT 37231 1181 48 Godhead Godhead NNP 37231 1181 49 is be VBZ 37231 1181 50 said say VBN 37231 1181 51 to to TO 37231 1181 52 be be VB 37231 1181 53 composed compose VBN 37231 1181 54 , , , 37231 1181 55 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1181 56 who who WP 37231 1181 57 was be VBD 37231 1181 58 conceived conceive VBN 37231 1181 59 by by IN 37231 1181 60 the the DT 37231 1181 61 Holy Holy NNP 37231 1181 62 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 1181 63 , , , 37231 1181 64 and and CC 37231 1181 65 born bear VBN 37231 1181 66 of of IN 37231 1181 67 the the DT 37231 1181 68 Virgin Virgin NNP 37231 1181 69 Mary Mary NNP 37231 1181 70 , , , 37231 1181 71 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1181 72 and and CC 37231 1181 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1181 74 death death NN 37231 1181 75 upon upon IN 37231 1181 76 the the DT 37231 1181 77 cross cross NN 37231 1181 78 as as IN 37231 1181 79 a a DT 37231 1181 80 vicarious vicarious JJ 37231 1181 81 expiation expiation NN 37231 1181 82 of of IN 37231 1181 83 the the DT 37231 1181 84 sins sin NNS 37231 1181 85 of of IN 37231 1181 86 the the DT 37231 1181 87 world world NN 37231 1181 88 , , , 37231 1181 89 without without IN 37231 1181 90 which which WDT 37231 1181 91 supposed suppose VBD 37231 1181 92 satisfaction satisfaction NN 37231 1181 93 of of IN 37231 1181 94 the the DT 37231 1181 95 justice justice NN 37231 1181 96 of of IN 37231 1181 97 God God NNP 37231 1181 98 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1181 99 mercy mercy NN 37231 1181 100 could could MD 37231 1181 101 not not RB 37231 1181 102 possibly possibly RB 37231 1181 103 have have VB 37231 1181 104 been be VBN 37231 1181 105 extended extend VBN 37231 1181 106 to to IN 37231 1181 107 the the DT 37231 1181 108 frail frail NN 37231 1181 109 and and CC 37231 1181 110 sinful sinful JJ 37231 1181 111 work work NN 37231 1181 112 of of IN 37231 1181 113 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1181 114 own own JJ 37231 1181 115 hands hand NNS 37231 1181 116 . . . 37231 1182 1 The the DT 37231 1182 2 crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 1182 3 of of IN 37231 1182 4 the the DT 37231 1182 5 incarnate incarnate JJ 37231 1182 6 God God NNP 37231 1182 7 was be VBD 37231 1182 8 the the DT 37231 1182 9 crowning crowning JJ 37231 1182 10 guilt guilt NN 37231 1182 11 of of IN 37231 1182 12 a a DT 37231 1182 13 nation nation NN 37231 1182 14 whom whom WP 37231 1182 15 God God NNP 37231 1182 16 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1182 17 had have VBD 37231 1182 18 selected select VBN 37231 1182 19 as as IN 37231 1182 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1182 21 own own JJ 37231 1182 22 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 1182 23 people people NNS 37231 1182 24 , , , 37231 1182 25 and and CC 37231 1182 26 whom whom WP 37231 1182 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1182 28 had have VBD 37231 1182 29 condescended condescend VBN 37231 1182 30 to to TO 37231 1182 31 guide guide VB 37231 1182 32 by by IN 37231 1182 33 constant constant JJ 37231 1182 34 direct direct JJ 37231 1182 35 revelations revelation NNS 37231 1182 36 of of IN 37231 1182 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1182 38 will will NN 37231 1182 39 , , , 37231 1182 40 but but CC 37231 1182 41 who who WP 37231 1182 42 , , , 37231 1182 43 from from IN 37231 1182 44 the the DT 37231 1182 45 first first JJ 37231 1182 46 , , , 37231 1182 47 had have VBD 37231 1182 48 displayed display VBN 37231 1182 49 the the DT 37231 1182 50 most most RBS 37231 1182 51 persistent persistent JJ 37231 1182 52 and and CC 37231 1182 53 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 1182 54 proclivity proclivity NN 37231 1182 55 to to TO 37231 1182 56 sin sin VB 37231 1182 57 against against IN 37231 1182 58 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1182 59 , , , 37231 1182 60 and and CC 37231 1182 61 , , , 37231 1182 62 in in IN 37231 1182 63 spite spite NN 37231 1182 64 of of IN 37231 1182 65 the the DT 37231 1182 66 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 1182 67 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1182 68 wrought work VBD 37231 1182 69 on on IN 37231 1182 70 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1182 71 behalf behalf NN 37231 1182 72 , , , 37231 1182 73 to to TO 37231 1182 74 forsake forsake VB 37231 1182 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1182 76 service service NN 37231 1182 77 for for IN 37231 1182 78 the the DT 37231 1182 79 worship worship NN 37231 1182 80 of of IN 37231 1182 81 other other JJ 37231 1182 82 gods god NNS 37231 1182 83 . . . 37231 1183 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1183 2 are be VBP 37231 1183 3 asked ask VBN 37231 1183 4 to to TO 37231 1183 5 believe believe VB 37231 1183 6 , , , 37231 1183 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 1183 8 , , , 37231 1183 9 in in IN 37231 1183 10 the the DT 37231 1183 11 frustration frustration NN 37231 1183 12 of of IN 37231 1183 13 the the DT 37231 1183 14 Divine divine JJ 37231 1183 15 design design NN 37231 1183 16 of of IN 37231 1183 17 creation creation NN 37231 1183 18 , , , 37231 1183 19 and and CC 37231 1183 20 in in IN 37231 1183 21 the the DT 37231 1183 22 fall fall NN 37231 1183 23 of of IN 37231 1183 24 man man NN 37231 1183 25 into into IN 37231 1183 26 a a DT 37231 1183 27 state state NN 37231 1183 28 of of IN 37231 1183 29 wickedness wickedness NN 37231 1183 30 hateful hateful JJ 37231 1183 31 to to IN 37231 1183 32 God God NNP 37231 1183 33 , , , 37231 1183 34 requiring require VBG 37231 1183 35 and and CC 37231 1183 36 justifying justify VBG 37231 1183 37 the the DT 37231 1183 38 Divine divine JJ 37231 1183 39 design design NN 37231 1183 40 of of IN 37231 1183 41 a a DT 37231 1183 42 revelation revelation NN 37231 1183 43 , , , 37231 1183 44 and and CC 37231 1183 45 such such PDT 37231 1183 46 a a DT 37231 1183 47 revelation revelation NN 37231 1183 48 as as IN 37231 1183 49 this this DT 37231 1183 50 , , , 37231 1183 51 as as IN 37231 1183 52 a a DT 37231 1183 53 preliminary preliminary NN 37231 1183 54 to to IN 37231 1183 55 the the DT 37231 1183 56 further further JJ 37231 1183 57 proposition proposition NN 37231 1183 58 that that IN 37231 1183 59 , , , 37231 1183 60 on on IN 37231 1183 61 the the DT 37231 1183 62 supposition supposition NN 37231 1183 63 of of IN 37231 1183 64 such such PDT 37231 1183 65 a a DT 37231 1183 66 design design NN 37231 1183 67 , , , 37231 1183 68 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1183 69 would would MD 37231 1183 70 not not RB 37231 1183 71 be be VB 37231 1183 72 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1183 73 to to IN 37231 1183 74 reason reason NN 37231 1183 75 . . . 37231 1184 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1184 2 48 48 CD 37231 1184 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1184 4 Antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1184 5 , , , 37231 1184 6 nothing nothing NN 37231 1184 7 could could MD 37231 1184 8 be be VB 37231 1184 9 more more RBR 37231 1184 10 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 1184 11 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1184 12 or or CC 37231 1184 13 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1184 14 to to IN 37231 1184 15 reason reason NN 37231 1184 16 than than IN 37231 1184 17 these these DT 37231 1184 18 statements statement NNS 37231 1184 19 , , , 37231 1184 20 or or CC 37231 1184 21 the the DT 37231 1184 22 supposition supposition NN 37231 1184 23 of of IN 37231 1184 24 such such PDT 37231 1184 25 a a DT 37231 1184 26 design design NN 37231 1184 27 . . . 37231 1185 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1185 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1185 3 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1185 4 admits admit VBZ 37231 1185 5 that that IN 37231 1185 6 , , , 37231 1185 7 as as IN 37231 1185 8 human human JJ 37231 1185 9 announcements announcement NNS 37231 1185 10 , , , 37231 1185 11 the the DT 37231 1185 12 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 1185 13 of of IN 37231 1185 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1185 15 would would MD 37231 1185 16 be be VB 37231 1185 17 the the DT 37231 1185 18 " " `` 37231 1185 19 wildest wildest JJ 37231 1185 20 delusions delusion NNS 37231 1185 21 , , , 37231 1185 22 " " '' 37231 1185 23 which which WDT 37231 1185 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1185 25 could could MD 37231 1185 26 not not RB 37231 1185 27 be be VB 37231 1185 28 justified justify VBN 37231 1185 29 in in IN 37231 1185 30 believing believe VBG 37231 1185 31 , , , 37231 1185 32 and and CC 37231 1185 33 that that IN 37231 1185 34 such such PDT 37231 1185 35 a a DT 37231 1185 36 scheme scheme NN 37231 1185 37 could could MD 37231 1185 38 not not RB 37231 1185 39 be be VB 37231 1185 40 maintained maintain VBN 37231 1185 41 without without IN 37231 1185 42 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1185 43 evidence evidence NN 37231 1185 44 . . . 37231 1186 1 The the DT 37231 1186 2 supposition supposition NN 37231 1186 3 of of IN 37231 1186 4 the the DT 37231 1186 5 Divine divine JJ 37231 1186 6 design design NN 37231 1186 7 of of IN 37231 1186 8 the the DT 37231 1186 9 revelation revelation NN 37231 1186 10 is be VBZ 37231 1186 11 solely solely RB 37231 1186 12 derived derive VBN 37231 1186 13 from from IN 37231 1186 14 the the DT 37231 1186 15 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 1186 16 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1186 17 to to TO 37231 1186 18 have have VB 37231 1186 19 been be VBN 37231 1186 20 revealed reveal VBN 37231 1186 21 , , , 37231 1186 22 and and CC 37231 1186 23 , , , 37231 1186 24 indeed indeed RB 37231 1186 25 , , , 37231 1186 26 that that IN 37231 1186 27 design design NN 37231 1186 28 forms form NNS 37231 1186 29 part part NN 37231 1186 30 of of IN 37231 1186 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1186 32 . . . 37231 1187 1 Until until IN 37231 1187 2 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1187 3 are be VBP 37231 1187 4 proved prove VBN 37231 1187 5 to to TO 37231 1187 6 be be VB 37231 1187 7 Divine divine JJ 37231 1187 8 truths truth NNS 37231 1187 9 , , , 37231 1187 10 these these DT 37231 1187 11 statements statement NNS 37231 1187 12 must must MD 37231 1187 13 obviously obviously RB 37231 1187 14 be be VB 37231 1187 15 considered consider VBN 37231 1187 16 human human JJ 37231 1187 17 announcements announcement NNS 37231 1187 18 , , , 37231 1187 19 and and CC 37231 1187 20 consequently consequently RB 37231 1187 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1187 22 are be VBP 37231 1187 23 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1187 24 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1187 25 , , , 37231 1187 26 and and CC 37231 1187 27 the the DT 37231 1187 28 " " `` 37231 1187 29 wildest wildest JJ 37231 1187 30 delusions delusion NNS 37231 1187 31 . . . 37231 1187 32 " " '' 37231 1188 1 As as IN 37231 1188 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1188 3 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1188 4 does do VBZ 37231 1188 5 not not RB 37231 1188 6 pretend pretend VB 37231 1188 7 that that IN 37231 1188 8 there there EX 37231 1188 9 is be VBZ 37231 1188 10 anything anything NN 37231 1188 11 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1188 12 credible credible JJ 37231 1188 13 upon upon IN 37231 1188 14 which which WDT 37231 1188 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1188 16 can can MD 37231 1188 17 base base VB 37231 1188 18 an an DT 37231 1188 19 assertion assertion NN 37231 1188 20 that that IN 37231 1188 21 there there EX 37231 1188 22 was be VBD 37231 1188 23 actually actually RB 37231 1188 24 { { -LRB- 37231 1188 25 49 49 CD 37231 1188 26 } } -RRB- 37231 1188 27 any any DT 37231 1188 28 " " `` 37231 1188 29 Divine divine JJ 37231 1188 30 design design NN 37231 1188 31 of of IN 37231 1188 32 a a DT 37231 1188 33 revelation revelation NN 37231 1188 34 , , , 37231 1188 35 " " '' 37231 1188 36 or or CC 37231 1188 37 that that IN 37231 1188 38 any any DT 37231 1188 39 " " `` 37231 1188 40 communication communication NN 37231 1188 41 between between IN 37231 1188 42 the the DT 37231 1188 43 two two CD 37231 1188 44 worlds world NNS 37231 1188 45 " " '' 37231 1188 46 was be VBD 37231 1188 47 requisite requisite JJ 37231 1188 48 , , , 37231 1188 49 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1188 50 is be VBZ 37231 1188 51 therefore therefore RB 37231 1188 52 clear clear JJ 37231 1188 53 that that IN 37231 1188 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1188 55 argument argument NN 37231 1188 56 consists consist VBZ 37231 1188 57 merely merely RB 37231 1188 58 of of IN 37231 1188 59 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1188 60 admitted admit VBN 37231 1188 61 to to TO 37231 1188 62 be be VB 37231 1188 63 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1188 64 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1188 65 . . . 37231 1189 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1189 2 advances advance VBZ 37231 1189 3 a a DT 37231 1189 4 supposition supposition NN 37231 1189 5 of of IN 37231 1189 6 that that DT 37231 1189 7 which which WDT 37231 1189 8 is be VBZ 37231 1189 9 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1189 10 to to IN 37231 1189 11 reason reason NN 37231 1189 12 to to TO 37231 1189 13 justify justify VB 37231 1189 14 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1189 15 visible visible JJ 37231 1189 16 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1189 17 of of IN 37231 1189 18 the the DT 37231 1189 19 order order NN 37231 1189 20 of of IN 37231 1189 21 nature nature NN 37231 1189 22 , , , 37231 1189 23 which which WDT 37231 1189 24 are be VBP 37231 1189 25 also also RB 37231 1189 26 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1189 27 to to IN 37231 1189 28 reason reason NN 37231 1189 29 . . . 37231 1190 1 Incredible incredible JJ 37231 1190 2 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1190 3 can can MD 37231 1190 4 not not RB 37231 1190 5 give give VB 37231 1190 6 probability probability NN 37231 1190 7 to to TO 37231 1190 8 incredible incredible VB 37231 1190 9 evidence- evidence- VBZ 37231 1190 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 1190 11 's 's POS 37231 1190 12 audacious audacious JJ 37231 1190 13 paradox paradox NN 37231 1190 14 : : : 37231 1190 15 " " `` 37231 1190 16 Credo credo NN 37231 1190 17 quia quia NN 37231 1190 18 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1190 19 , , , 37231 1190 20 " " '' 37231 1190 21 of of IN 37231 1190 22 which which WDT 37231 1190 23 such such JJ 37231 1190 24 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1190 25 is be VBZ 37231 1190 26 illustrative illustrative JJ 37231 1190 27 , , , 37231 1190 28 is be VBZ 37231 1190 29 but but CC 37231 1190 30 the the DT 37231 1190 31 cry cry NN 37231 1190 32 of of IN 37231 1190 33 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 37231 1190 34 credulity credulity NN 37231 1190 35 . . . 37231 1191 1 The the DT 37231 1191 2 whole whole JJ 37231 1191 3 theory theory NN 37231 1191 4 of of IN 37231 1191 5 this this DT 37231 1191 6 abortive abortive JJ 37231 1191 7 design design NN 37231 1191 8 of of IN 37231 1191 9 creation creation NN 37231 1191 10 , , , 37231 1191 11 with with IN 37231 1191 12 such such JJ 37231 1191 13 impotent impotent JJ 37231 1191 14 efforts effort NNS 37231 1191 15 to to TO 37231 1191 16 amend amend VB 37231 1191 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1191 18 , , , 37231 1191 19 is be VBZ 37231 1191 20 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 1191 21 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 1191 22 by by IN 37231 1191 23 the the DT 37231 1191 24 glorious glorious JJ 37231 1191 25 perfection perfection NN 37231 1191 26 and and CC 37231 1191 27 invariability invariability NN 37231 1191 28 of of IN 37231 1191 29 the the DT 37231 1191 30 order order NN 37231 1191 31 of of IN 37231 1191 32 nature nature NN 37231 1191 33 . . . 37231 1192 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1192 2 is be VBZ 37231 1192 3 difficult difficult JJ 37231 1192 4 to to TO 37231 1192 5 say say VB 37231 1192 6 whether whether IN 37231 1192 7 the the DT 37231 1192 8 details detail NNS 37231 1192 9 of of IN 37231 1192 10 the the DT 37231 1192 11 scheme scheme NN 37231 1192 12 , , , 37231 1192 13 or or CC 37231 1192 14 the the DT 37231 1192 15 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1192 16 which which WDT 37231 1192 17 are be VBP 37231 1192 18 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1192 19 to to TO 37231 1192 20 have have VB 37231 1192 21 led lead VBN 37231 1192 22 to to IN 37231 1192 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1192 24 adoption adoption NN 37231 1192 25 , , , 37231 1192 26 are be VBP 37231 1192 27 more more RBR 37231 1192 28 shocking shocking JJ 37231 1192 29 to to IN 37231 1192 30 reason reason NN 37231 1192 31 or or CC 37231 1192 32 to to IN 37231 1192 33 moral moral JJ 37231 1192 34 sense sense NN 37231 1192 35 . . . 37231 1193 1 The the DT 37231 1193 2 imperfection imperfection NN 37231 1193 3 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1193 4 to to IN 37231 1193 5 the the DT 37231 1193 6 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1193 7 work work NN 37231 1193 8 is be VBZ 37231 1193 9 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1193 10 more more JJR 37231 1193 11 derogatory derogatory JJ 37231 1193 12 to to IN 37231 1193 13 the the DT 37231 1193 14 power power NN 37231 1193 15 and and CC 37231 1193 16 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1193 17 of of IN 37231 1193 18 the the DT 37231 1193 19 Creator Creator NNP 37231 1193 20 , , , 37231 1193 21 than than IN 37231 1193 22 the the DT 37231 1193 23 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1193 24 satisfaction satisfaction NN 37231 1193 25 of of IN 37231 1193 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1193 27 justice justice NN 37231 1193 28 in in IN 37231 1193 29 the the DT 37231 1193 30 death death NN 37231 1193 31 of of IN 37231 1193 32 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1193 33 incarnate incarnate JJ 37231 1193 34 , , , 37231 1193 35 the the DT 37231 1193 36 innocent innocent JJ 37231 1193 37 for for IN 37231 1193 38 the the DT 37231 1193 39 guilty guilty JJ 37231 1193 40 , , , 37231 1193 41 is be VBZ 37231 1193 42 degrading degrade VBG 37231 1193 43 to to IN 37231 1193 44 the the DT 37231 1193 45 idea idea NN 37231 1193 46 of of IN 37231 1193 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1193 48 moral moral JJ 37231 1193 49 perfection perfection NN 37231 1193 50 . . . 37231 1194 1 The the DT 37231 1194 2 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1194 3 necessity necessity NN 37231 1194 4 for for IN 37231 1194 5 repeated repeat VBN 37231 1194 6 interference interference NN 37231 1194 7 to to TO 37231 1194 8 correct correct VB 37231 1194 9 the the DT 37231 1194 10 imperfection imperfection NN 37231 1194 11 of of IN 37231 1194 12 the the DT 37231 1194 13 original original JJ 37231 1194 14 creation creation NN 37231 1194 15 , , , 37231 1194 16 the the DT 37231 1194 17 nature nature NN 37231 1194 18 of of IN 37231 1194 19 the the DT 37231 1194 20 means mean NNS 37231 1194 21 employed employ VBN 37231 1194 22 , , , 37231 1194 23 and and CC 37231 1194 24 the the DT 37231 1194 25 triumphant triumphant JJ 37231 1194 26 opposition opposition NN 37231 1194 27 of of IN 37231 1194 28 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1194 29 , , , 37231 1194 30 are be VBP 37231 1194 31 anthropomorphic anthropomorphic JJ 37231 1194 32 conceptions conception NNS 37231 1194 33 totally totally RB 37231 1194 34 incompatible incompatible JJ 37231 1194 35 with with IN 37231 1194 36 the the DT 37231 1194 37 idea idea NN 37231 1194 38 of of IN 37231 1194 39 an an DT 37231 1194 40 Infinitely Infinitely NNP 37231 1194 41 Wise Wise NNP 37231 1194 42 and and CC 37231 1194 43 Almighty Almighty NNP 37231 1194 44 Being Being NNP 37231 1194 45 . . . 37231 1195 1 The the DT 37231 1195 2 constitution constitution NN 37231 1195 3 of of IN 37231 1195 4 nature nature NN 37231 1195 5 , , , 37231 1195 6 so so RB 37231 1195 7 far far RB 37231 1195 8 from from IN 37231 1195 9 favouring favour VBG 37231 1195 10 any any DT 37231 1195 11 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1195 12 of of IN 37231 1195 13 original original JJ 37231 1195 14 perfection perfection NN 37231 1195 15 and and CC 37231 1195 16 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 1195 17 deterioration deterioration NN 37231 1195 18 , , , 37231 1195 19 bears bear VBZ 37231 1195 20 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 1195 21 the the DT 37231 1195 22 record record NN 37231 1195 23 of of IN 37231 1195 24 systematic systematic JJ 37231 1195 25 upward upward JJ 37231 1195 26 progression progression NN 37231 1195 27 . . . 37231 1196 1 Not not RB 37231 1196 2 only only RB 37231 1196 3 is be VBZ 37231 1196 4 the the DT 37231 1196 5 assumption assumption NN 37231 1196 6 , , , 37231 1196 7 that that IN 37231 1196 8 any any DT 37231 1196 9 revelation revelation NN 37231 1196 10 of of IN 37231 1196 11 the the DT 37231 1196 12 nature nature NN 37231 1196 13 of of IN 37231 1196 14 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 1196 15 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1196 16 was be VBD 37231 1196 17 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1196 18 , , , 37231 1196 19 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1196 20 upon upon IN 37231 1196 21 { { -LRB- 37231 1196 22 50 50 CD 37231 1196 23 } } -RRB- 37231 1196 24 philosophical philosophical JJ 37231 1196 25 grounds ground NNS 37231 1196 26 , , , 37231 1196 27 but but CC 37231 1196 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1196 29 is be VBZ 37231 1196 30 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 1196 31 by by IN 37231 1196 32 the the DT 37231 1196 33 whole whole JJ 37231 1196 34 operation operation NN 37231 1196 35 of of IN 37231 1196 36 natural natural JJ 37231 1196 37 laws law NNS 37231 1196 38 , , , 37231 1196 39 which which WDT 37231 1196 40 contain contain VBP 37231 1196 41 in in IN 37231 1196 42 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1196 43 inexorable inexorable JJ 37231 1196 44 penalties penalty NNS 37231 1196 45 against against IN 37231 1196 46 natural natural JJ 37231 1196 47 retrogression retrogression NN 37231 1196 48 , , , 37231 1196 49 or or CC 37231 1196 50 even even RB 37231 1196 51 unprogressiveness unprogressiveness JJ 37231 1196 52 , , , 37231 1196 53 and and CC 37231 1196 54 furnish furnish VB 37231 1196 55 the the DT 37231 1196 56 only only JJ 37231 1196 57 requisite requisite JJ 37231 1196 58 stimulus stimulus NN 37231 1196 59 to to IN 37231 1196 60 improvement improvement NN 37231 1196 61 . . . 37231 1197 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1197 2 1 1 LS 37231 1197 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1197 4 The the DT 37231 1197 5 survival survival NN 37231 1197 6 only only RB 37231 1197 7 of of IN 37231 1197 8 the the DT 37231 1197 9 fittest fit JJS 37231 1197 10 is be VBZ 37231 1197 11 the the DT 37231 1197 12 1 1 CD 37231 1197 13 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1197 14 venture venture NN 37231 1197 15 to to TO 37231 1197 16 add add VB 37231 1197 17 a a DT 37231 1197 18 passage passage NN 37231 1197 19 from from IN 37231 1197 20 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1197 21 Herbert Herbert NNP 37231 1197 22 Spencer Spencer NNP 37231 1197 23 's 's POS 37231 1197 24 " " `` 37231 1197 25 Social Social NNP 37231 1197 26 Statics Statics NNPS 37231 1197 27 , , , 37231 1197 28 " " '' 37231 1197 29 which which WDT 37231 1197 30 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1197 31 have have VBP 37231 1197 32 met meet VBN 37231 1197 33 with with IN 37231 1197 34 for for IN 37231 1197 35 the the DT 37231 1197 36 first first JJ 37231 1197 37 time time NN 37231 1197 38 since since IN 37231 1197 39 this this DT 37231 1197 40 work work NN 37231 1197 41 was be VBD 37231 1197 42 published publish VBN 37231 1197 43 , , , 37231 1197 44 in in IN 37231 1197 45 illustration illustration NN 37231 1197 46 of of IN 37231 1197 47 this this DT 37231 1197 48 assertion assertion NN 37231 1197 49 . . . 37231 1198 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1198 2 Spencer Spencer NNP 37231 1198 3 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 1198 4 " " `` 37231 1198 5 the the DT 37231 1198 6 evanescence evanescence NN 37231 1198 7 of of IN 37231 1198 8 evil evil NN 37231 1198 9 " " '' 37231 1198 10 and and CC 37231 1198 11 the the DT 37231 1198 12 perfectibility perfectibility NN 37231 1198 13 of of IN 37231 1198 14 man man NN 37231 1198 15 , , , 37231 1198 16 upon upon IN 37231 1198 17 the the DT 37231 1198 18 ground ground NN 37231 1198 19 that that WDT 37231 1198 20 : : : 37231 1198 21 " " `` 37231 1198 22 All all DT 37231 1198 23 evil evil JJ 37231 1198 24 results result NNS 37231 1198 25 from from IN 37231 1198 26 the the DT 37231 1198 27 non non JJ 37231 1198 28 - - NN 37231 1198 29 adaptation adaptation NN 37231 1198 30 of of IN 37231 1198 31 constitution constitution NN 37231 1198 32 to to IN 37231 1198 33 conditions condition NNS 37231 1198 34 . . . 37231 1198 35 " " '' 37231 1199 1 After after IN 37231 1199 2 an an DT 37231 1199 3 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 1199 4 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 1199 5 of of IN 37231 1199 6 this this DT 37231 1199 7 , , , 37231 1199 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1199 9 resumes resume VBZ 37231 1199 10 as as IN 37231 1199 11 follows follow VBZ 37231 1199 12 : : : 37231 1199 13 " " `` 37231 1199 14 If if IN 37231 1199 15 there there EX 37231 1199 16 be be VBP 37231 1199 17 any any DT 37231 1199 18 conclusiveness conclusiveness NN 37231 1199 19 in in IN 37231 1199 20 the the DT 37231 1199 21 foregoing forego VBG 37231 1199 22 arguments argument NNS 37231 1199 23 , , , 37231 1199 24 such such PDT 37231 1199 25 a a DT 37231 1199 26 faith faith NN 37231 1199 27 is be VBZ 37231 1199 28 well well RB 37231 1199 29 founded found VBN 37231 1199 30 . . . 37231 1200 1 As as IN 37231 1200 2 commonly commonly RB 37231 1200 3 supported support VBN 37231 1200 4 by by IN 37231 1200 5 evidence evidence NN 37231 1200 6 drawn draw VBN 37231 1200 7 from from IN 37231 1200 8 history history NN 37231 1200 9 , , , 37231 1200 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1200 11 can can MD 37231 1200 12 not not RB 37231 1200 13 be be VB 37231 1200 14 considered consider VBN 37231 1200 15 indisputable indisputable JJ 37231 1200 16 . . . 37231 1201 1 The the DT 37231 1201 2 inference inference NN 37231 1201 3 that that IN 37231 1201 4 as as IN 37231 1201 5 adyancement adyancement NN 37231 1201 6 has have VBZ 37231 1201 7 been be VBN 37231 1201 8 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 1201 9 the the DT 37231 1201 10 rule rule NN 37231 1201 11 , , , 37231 1201 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1201 13 will will MD 37231 1201 14 be be VB 37231 1201 15 the the DT 37231 1201 16 rule rule NN 37231 1201 17 henceforth henceforth RB 37231 1201 18 , , , 37231 1201 19 may may MD 37231 1201 20 be be VB 37231 1201 21 called call VBN 37231 1201 22 a a DT 37231 1201 23 plausible plausible JJ 37231 1201 24 speculation speculation NN 37231 1201 25 . . . 37231 1202 1 But but CC 37231 1202 2 when when WRB 37231 1202 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1202 4 is be VBZ 37231 1202 5 shown show VBN 37231 1202 6 that that IN 37231 1202 7 this this DT 37231 1202 8 adyancement adyancement NN 37231 1202 9 is be VBZ 37231 1202 10 due due JJ 37231 1202 11 to to IN 37231 1202 12 the the DT 37231 1202 13 working working NN 37231 1202 14 of of IN 37231 1202 15 a a DT 37231 1202 16 universal universal JJ 37231 1202 17 law law NN 37231 1202 18 ; ; : 37231 1202 19 and and CC 37231 1202 20 that that IN 37231 1202 21 in in IN 37231 1202 22 virtue virtue NN 37231 1202 23 of of IN 37231 1202 24 that that DT 37231 1202 25 law law NN 37231 1202 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1202 27 must must MD 37231 1202 28 continue continue VB 37231 1202 29 until until IN 37231 1202 30 the the DT 37231 1202 31 state state NN 37231 1202 32 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1202 33 call call VBP 37231 1202 34 perfection perfection NN 37231 1202 35 is be VBZ 37231 1202 36 reached reach VBN 37231 1202 37 , , , 37231 1202 38 then then RB 37231 1202 39 the the DT 37231 1202 40 advent advent NN 37231 1202 41 of of IN 37231 1202 42 such such PDT 37231 1202 43 a a DT 37231 1202 44 state state NN 37231 1202 45 is be VBZ 37231 1202 46 removed remove VBN 37231 1202 47 out out IN 37231 1202 48 of of IN 37231 1202 49 the the DT 37231 1202 50 region region NN 37231 1202 51 of of IN 37231 1202 52 probability probability NN 37231 1202 53 into into IN 37231 1202 54 that that DT 37231 1202 55 of of IN 37231 1202 56 certainty certainty NN 37231 1202 57 . . . 37231 1203 1 If if IN 37231 1203 2 any any DT 37231 1203 3 one one CD 37231 1203 4 demurs demur VBZ 37231 1203 5 to to IN 37231 1203 6 this this DT 37231 1203 7 let let VB 37231 1203 8 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1203 9 point point VB 37231 1203 10 out out RP 37231 1203 11 the the DT 37231 1203 12 error error NN 37231 1203 13 . . . 37231 1204 1 Here here RB 37231 1204 2 are be VBP 37231 1204 3 the the DT 37231 1204 4 several several JJ 37231 1204 5 steps step NNS 37231 1204 6 of of IN 37231 1204 7 the the DT 37231 1204 8 argument argument NN 37231 1204 9 . . . 37231 1205 1 All all DT 37231 1205 2 imperfection imperfection NN 37231 1205 3 is be VBZ 37231 1205 4 unfitness unfitness NN 37231 1205 5 to to IN 37231 1205 6 the the DT 37231 1205 7 conditions condition NNS 37231 1205 8 of of IN 37231 1205 9 existence existence NN 37231 1205 10 . . . 37231 1206 1 This this DT 37231 1206 2 unfitness unfitness NN 37231 1206 3 must must MD 37231 1206 4 consist consist VB 37231 1206 5 either either CC 37231 1206 6 in in IN 37231 1206 7 having have VBG 37231 1206 8 a a DT 37231 1206 9 faculty faculty NN 37231 1206 10 or or CC 37231 1206 11 faculties faculty NNS 37231 1206 12 in in IN 37231 1206 13 excess excess NN 37231 1206 14 ; ; , 37231 1206 15 or or CC 37231 1206 16 in in IN 37231 1206 17 having have VBG 37231 1206 18 a a DT 37231 1206 19 faculty faculty NN 37231 1206 20 or or CC 37231 1206 21 faculties facultie VBZ 37231 1206 22 deficient deficient JJ 37231 1206 23 ; ; : 37231 1206 24 or or CC 37231 1206 25 in in IN 37231 1206 26 both both DT 37231 1206 27 . . . 37231 1207 1 A a DT 37231 1207 2 faculty faculty NN 37231 1207 3 in in IN 37231 1207 4 excess excess NN 37231 1207 5 is be VBZ 37231 1207 6 one one CD 37231 1207 7 which which WDT 37231 1207 8 the the DT 37231 1207 9 conditions condition NNS 37231 1207 10 of of IN 37231 1207 11 existence existence NN 37231 1207 12 do do VBP 37231 1207 13 not not RB 37231 1207 14 afford afford VB 37231 1207 15 full full JJ 37231 1207 16 exercise exercise NN 37231 1207 17 to to TO 37231 1207 18 ; ; : 37231 1207 19 and and CC 37231 1207 20 a a DT 37231 1207 21 faculty faculty NN 37231 1207 22 that that WDT 37231 1207 23 is be VBZ 37231 1207 24 deficient deficient JJ 37231 1207 25 is be VBZ 37231 1207 26 one one CD 37231 1207 27 from from IN 37231 1207 28 which which WDT 37231 1207 29 the the DT 37231 1207 30 conditions condition NNS 37231 1207 31 of of IN 37231 1207 32 existence existence NN 37231 1207 33 demand demand VBP 37231 1207 34 more more JJR 37231 1207 35 than than IN 37231 1207 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1207 37 can can MD 37231 1207 38 perform perform VB 37231 1207 39 . . . 37231 1208 1 But but CC 37231 1208 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1208 3 is be VBZ 37231 1208 4 an an DT 37231 1208 5 essential essential JJ 37231 1208 6 principle principle NN 37231 1208 7 of of IN 37231 1208 8 life life NN 37231 1208 9 that that WDT 37231 1208 10 a a DT 37231 1208 11 faculty faculty NN 37231 1208 12 to to TO 37231 1208 13 which which WDT 37231 1208 14 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1208 15 do do VBP 37231 1208 16 not not RB 37231 1208 17 allow allow VB 37231 1208 18 full full JJ 37231 1208 19 exercise exercise NN 37231 1208 20 diminishes diminishe NNS 37231 1208 21 ; ; : 37231 1208 22 and and CC 37231 1208 23 that that IN 37231 1208 24 a a DT 37231 1208 25 faculty faculty NN 37231 1208 26 on on IN 37231 1208 27 which which WDT 37231 1208 28 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1208 29 make make VBP 37231 1208 30 excessive excessive JJ 37231 1208 31 demands demand NNS 37231 1208 32 increases increase NNS 37231 1208 33 . . . 37231 1209 1 And and CC 37231 1209 2 so so RB 37231 1209 3 long long RB 37231 1209 4 as as IN 37231 1209 5 this this DT 37231 1209 6 excess excess NN 37231 1209 7 and and CC 37231 1209 8 this this DT 37231 1209 9 deficiency deficiency NN 37231 1209 10 continue continue VBP 37231 1209 11 , , , 37231 1209 12 there there EX 37231 1209 13 must must MD 37231 1209 14 continue continue VB 37231 1209 15 decrease decrease NN 37231 1209 16 on on IN 37231 1209 17 the the DT 37231 1209 18 one one CD 37231 1209 19 hand hand NN 37231 1209 20 , , , 37231 1209 21 and and CC 37231 1209 22 growth growth NN 37231 1209 23 on on IN 37231 1209 24 the the DT 37231 1209 25 other other JJ 37231 1209 26 . . . 37231 1210 1 Finally finally RB 37231 1210 2 all all DT 37231 1210 3 excess excess JJ 37231 1210 4 and and CC 37231 1210 5 all all DT 37231 1210 6 deficiency deficiency NN 37231 1210 7 must must MD 37231 1210 8 disappear disappear VB 37231 1210 9 , , , 37231 1210 10 that that RB 37231 1210 11 is is RB 37231 1210 12 , , , 37231 1210 13 all all DT 37231 1210 14 unfitness unfitness NN 37231 1210 15 must must MD 37231 1210 16 disappear disappear VB 37231 1210 17 ; ; : 37231 1210 18 that that RB 37231 1210 19 is is RB 37231 1210 20 , , , 37231 1210 21 all all DT 37231 1210 22 imperfection imperfection NN 37231 1210 23 must must MD 37231 1210 24 disappear disappear VB 37231 1210 25 . . . 37231 1211 1 Thus thus RB 37231 1211 2 the the DT 37231 1211 3 ultimate ultimate JJ 37231 1211 4 development development NN 37231 1211 5 of of IN 37231 1211 6 the the DT 37231 1211 7 ideal ideal JJ 37231 1211 8 man man NN 37231 1211 9 is be VBZ 37231 1211 10 logically logically RB 37231 1211 11 certain certain JJ 37231 1211 12 � � NNP 37231 1211 13 as as RB 37231 1211 14 certain certain JJ 37231 1211 15 as as IN 37231 1211 16 any any DT 37231 1211 17 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1211 18 in in IN 37231 1211 19 which which WDT 37231 1211 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1211 21 place place VBP 37231 1211 22 the the DT 37231 1211 23 most most RBS 37231 1211 24 implicit implicit JJ 37231 1211 25 faith faith NN 37231 1211 26 ; ; : 37231 1211 27 for for IN 37231 1211 28 instance instance NN 37231 1211 29 , , , 37231 1211 30 that that IN 37231 1211 31 all all DT 37231 1211 32 men man NNS 37231 1211 33 will will MD 37231 1211 34 die die VB 37231 1211 35 . . . 37231 1212 1 For for IN 37231 1212 2 why why WRB 37231 1212 3 do do VBP 37231 1212 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1212 5 infer infer VB 37231 1212 6 that that IN 37231 1212 7 all all DT 37231 1212 8 men man NNS 37231 1212 9 will will MD 37231 1212 10 die die VB 37231 1212 11 P p NN 37231 1212 12 Simply simply RB 37231 1212 13 because because IN 37231 1212 14 , , , 37231 1212 15 in in IN 37231 1212 16 an an DT 37231 1212 17 immense immense JJ 37231 1212 18 number number NN 37231 1212 19 of of IN 37231 1212 20 past past JJ 37231 1212 21 experiences experience NNS 37231 1212 22 , , , 37231 1212 23 death death NN 37231 1212 24 has have VBZ 37231 1212 25 uniformly uniformly RB 37231 1212 26 occurred occur VBN 37231 1212 27 . . . 37231 1213 1 Similarly similarly RB 37231 1213 2 then then RB 37231 1213 3 as as IN 37231 1213 4 the the DT 37231 1213 5 experiences experience NNS 37231 1213 6 of of IN 37231 1213 7 all all DT 37231 1213 8 people people NNS 37231 1213 9 in in IN 37231 1213 10 all all DT 37231 1213 11 times time NNS 37231 1213 12 � � NNP 37231 1213 13 experiences experience NNS 37231 1213 14 that that WDT 37231 1213 15 are be VBP 37231 1213 16 embodied embody VBN 37231 1213 17 in in IN 37231 1213 18 maxims maxim NNS 37231 1213 19 , , , 37231 1213 20 proverbs proverb NNS 37231 1213 21 , , , 37231 1213 22 and and CC 37231 1213 23 moral moral JJ 37231 1213 24 precepts precept NNS 37231 1213 25 , , , 37231 1213 26 and and CC 37231 1213 27 that that WDT 37231 1213 28 are be VBP 37231 1213 29 illustrated illustrate VBN 37231 1213 30 in in IN 37231 1213 31 biographies biography NNS 37231 1213 32 and and CC 37231 1213 33 histories history NNS 37231 1213 34 , , , 37231 1213 35 go go VB 37231 1213 36 to to TO 37231 1213 37 prove prove VB 37231 1213 38 that that IN 37231 1213 39 organs organ NNS 37231 1213 40 , , , 37231 1213 41 faculties faculty NNS 37231 1213 42 , , , 37231 1213 43 powers power NNS 37231 1213 44 , , , 37231 1213 45 capacities capacity NNS 37231 1213 46 , , , 37231 1213 47 or or CC 37231 1213 48 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1213 49 else else RB 37231 1213 50 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1213 51 call call VBP 37231 1213 52 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1213 53 grow grow VB 37231 1213 54 by by IN 37231 1213 55 use use NN 37231 1213 56 and and CC 37231 1213 57 diminish diminish VBP 37231 1213 58 from from IN 37231 1213 59 disuse disuse NN 37231 1213 60 , , , 37231 1213 61 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1213 62 is be VBZ 37231 1213 63 inferred infer VBN 37231 1213 64 that that IN 37231 1213 65 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1213 66 will will MD 37231 1213 67 continue continue VB 37231 1213 68 to to TO 37231 1213 69 do do VB 37231 1213 70 so so RB 37231 1213 71 . . . 37231 1214 1 And and CC 37231 1214 2 if if IN 37231 1214 3 this this DT 37231 1214 4 inference inference NN 37231 1214 5 is be VBZ 37231 1214 6 unquestionable unquestionable JJ 37231 1214 7 , , , 37231 1214 8 then then RB 37231 1214 9 is be VBZ 37231 1214 10 the the DT 37231 1214 11 one one NN 37231 1214 12 above above RB 37231 1214 13 deduced deduce VBN 37231 1214 14 from from IN 37231 1214 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1214 16 -- -- : 37231 1214 17 that that IN 37231 1214 18 humanity humanity NN 37231 1214 19 must must MD 37231 1214 20 in in IN 37231 1214 21 the the DT 37231 1214 22 end end NN 37231 1214 23 become become VB 37231 1214 24 completely completely RB 37231 1214 25 adapted adapted JJ 37231 1214 26 to to IN 37231 1214 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1214 28 conditions-- conditions-- NN 37231 1214 29 unquestionable unquestionable NN 37231 1214 30 also also RB 37231 1214 31 . . . 37231 1215 1 Progress progress NN 37231 1215 2 , , , 37231 1215 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 1215 4 , , , 37231 1215 5 is be VBZ 37231 1215 6 not not RB 37231 1215 7 an an DT 37231 1215 8 accident accident NN 37231 1215 9 , , , 37231 1215 10 but but CC 37231 1215 11 a a DT 37231 1215 12 necessity necessity NN 37231 1215 13 . . . 37231 1216 1 Instead instead RB 37231 1216 2 of of IN 37231 1216 3 civilization civilization NN 37231 1216 4 being be VBG 37231 1216 5 artificial artificial JJ 37231 1216 6 , , , 37231 1216 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1216 8 is be VBZ 37231 1216 9 a a DT 37231 1216 10 part part NN 37231 1216 11 of of IN 37231 1216 12 nature nature NN 37231 1216 13 ; ; : 37231 1216 14 all all DT 37231 1216 15 of of IN 37231 1216 16 a a DT 37231 1216 17 piece piece NN 37231 1216 18 with with IN 37231 1216 19 the the DT 37231 1216 20 development development NN 37231 1216 21 of of IN 37231 1216 22 the the DT 37231 1216 23 embryo embryo NN 37231 1216 24 or or CC 37231 1216 25 the the DT 37231 1216 26 unfolding unfolding NN 37231 1216 27 of of IN 37231 1216 28 a a DT 37231 1216 29 flower flower NN 37231 1216 30 . . . 37231 1217 1 The the DT 37231 1217 2 modifications modification NNS 37231 1217 3 mankind mankind NN 37231 1217 4 have have VBP 37231 1217 5 undergone undergo VBN 37231 1217 6 , , , 37231 1217 7 and and CC 37231 1217 8 are be VBP 37231 1217 9 still still RB 37231 1217 10 undergoing undergo VBG 37231 1217 11 , , , 37231 1217 12 result result VBP 37231 1217 13 from from IN 37231 1217 14 a a DT 37231 1217 15 law law NN 37231 1217 16 underlying underlie VBG 37231 1217 17 the the DT 37231 1217 18 whole whole JJ 37231 1217 19 organic organic JJ 37231 1217 20 creation creation NN 37231 1217 21 ; ; , 37231 1217 22 and and CC 37231 1217 23 provided provide VBD 37231 1217 24 the the DT 37231 1217 25 human human JJ 37231 1217 26 race race NN 37231 1217 27 continues continue VBZ 37231 1217 28 , , , 37231 1217 29 and and CC 37231 1217 30 the the DT 37231 1217 31 constitution constitution NN 37231 1217 32 of of IN 37231 1217 33 things thing NNS 37231 1217 34 remains remain VBZ 37231 1217 35 the the DT 37231 1217 36 same same JJ 37231 1217 37 , , , 37231 1217 38 those those DT 37231 1217 39 modifications modification NNS 37231 1217 40 must must MD 37231 1217 41 end end VB 37231 1217 42 in in IN 37231 1217 43 completeness completeness NNP 37231 1217 44 . . . 37231 1218 1 As as RB 37231 1218 2 surely surely RB 37231 1218 3 as as IN 37231 1218 4 the the DT 37231 1218 5 tree tree NN 37231 1218 6 becomes become VBZ 37231 1218 7 bulky bulky JJ 37231 1218 8 when when WRB 37231 1218 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1218 10 stands stand VBZ 37231 1218 11 alone alone JJ 37231 1218 12 , , , 37231 1218 13 and and CC 37231 1218 14 slender slend JJR 37231 1218 15 if if IN 37231 1218 16 one one CD 37231 1218 17 of of IN 37231 1218 18 a a DT 37231 1218 19 group group NN 37231 1218 20 ; ; : 37231 1218 21 as as RB 37231 1218 22 surely surely RB 37231 1218 23 as as IN 37231 1218 24 the the DT 37231 1218 25 same same JJ 37231 1218 26 creature creature NN 37231 1218 27 assumes assume VBZ 37231 1218 28 the the DT 37231 1218 29 different different JJ 37231 1218 30 forms form NNS 37231 1218 31 of of IN 37231 1218 32 cart cart NN 37231 1218 33 - - HYPH 37231 1218 34 horse horse NN 37231 1218 35 and and CC 37231 1218 36 racehorse racehorse NN 37231 1218 37 , , , 37231 1218 38 according accord VBG 37231 1218 39 as as IN 37231 1218 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1218 41 habits habit NNS 37231 1218 42 demand demand VBP 37231 1218 43 strength strength NN 37231 1218 44 or or CC 37231 1218 45 speed speed NN 37231 1218 46 ; ; : 37231 1218 47 as as RB 37231 1218 48 surely surely RB 37231 1218 49 as as IN 37231 1218 50 a a DT 37231 1218 51 blacksmith blacksmith NN 37231 1218 52 's 's POS 37231 1218 53 arm arm NN 37231 1218 54 grows grow VBZ 37231 1218 55 large large JJ 37231 1218 56 , , , 37231 1218 57 and and CC 37231 1218 58 the the DT 37231 1218 59 skin skin NN 37231 1218 60 of of IN 37231 1218 61 a a DT 37231 1218 62 labourer labourer NN 37231 1218 63 's 's POS 37231 1218 64 hand hand NN 37231 1218 65 thick thick RB 37231 1218 66 ; ; : 37231 1218 67 as as RB 37231 1218 68 surely surely RB 37231 1218 69 as as IN 37231 1218 70 the the DT 37231 1218 71 eye eye NN 37231 1218 72 tends tend VBZ 37231 1218 73 to to TO 37231 1218 74 become become VB 37231 1218 75 long long RB 37231 1218 76 - - HYPH 37231 1218 77 sighted sighted JJ 37231 1218 78 in in IN 37231 1218 79 the the DT 37231 1218 80 sailor sailor NN 37231 1218 81 , , , 37231 1218 82 and and CC 37231 1218 83 shortsighted shortsighte VBN 37231 1218 84 in in IN 37231 1218 85 the the DT 37231 1218 86 student student NN 37231 1218 87 ; ; : 37231 1218 88 as as RB 37231 1218 89 surely surely RB 37231 1218 90 as as IN 37231 1218 91 the the DT 37231 1218 92 blind blind JJ 37231 1218 93 attain attain VBP 37231 1218 94 a a DT 37231 1218 95 more more RBR 37231 1218 96 delicate delicate JJ 37231 1218 97 sense sense NN 37231 1218 98 of of IN 37231 1218 99 touch touch NN 37231 1218 100 ; ; : 37231 1218 101 as as RB 37231 1218 102 surely surely RB 37231 1218 103 as as IN 37231 1218 104 a a DT 37231 1218 105 clerk clerk NN 37231 1218 106 acquires acquire VBZ 37231 1218 107 rapidity rapidity NN 37231 1218 108 in in IN 37231 1218 109 writing writing NN 37231 1218 110 and and CC 37231 1218 111 calculation calculation NN 37231 1218 112 ; ; : 37231 1218 113 as as RB 37231 1218 114 surely surely RB 37231 1218 115 as as IN 37231 1218 116 the the DT 37231 1218 117 musician musician NN 37231 1218 118 learns learn VBZ 37231 1218 119 to to TO 37231 1218 120 detect detect VB 37231 1218 121 an an DT 37231 1218 122 error error NN 37231 1218 123 of of IN 37231 1218 124 a a DT 37231 1218 125 semitone semitone NN 37231 1218 126 amidst amidst IN 37231 1218 127 what what WP 37231 1218 128 seems seem VBZ 37231 1218 129 to to IN 37231 1218 130 others other NNS 37231 1218 131 a a DT 37231 1218 132 very very RB 37231 1218 133 babel babel NN 37231 1218 134 of of IN 37231 1218 135 sounds sound NNS 37231 1218 136 ; ; : 37231 1218 137 as as RB 37231 1218 138 surely surely RB 37231 1218 139 as as IN 37231 1218 140 a a DT 37231 1218 141 passion passion NN 37231 1218 142 grows grow VBZ 37231 1218 143 by by IN 37231 1218 144 indulgence indulgence NN 37231 1218 145 and and CC 37231 1218 146 diminishes diminishe NNS 37231 1218 147 when when WRB 37231 1218 148 restrained restrain VBN 37231 1218 149 ; ; : 37231 1218 150 as as RB 37231 1218 151 surely surely RB 37231 1218 152 as as IN 37231 1218 153 a a DT 37231 1218 154 disregarded disregard VBN 37231 1218 155 conscience conscience NN 37231 1218 156 becomes become VBZ 37231 1218 157 inert inert RB 37231 1218 158 , , , 37231 1218 159 and and CC 37231 1218 160 one one NN 37231 1218 161 that that WDT 37231 1218 162 is be VBZ 37231 1218 163 obeyed obeyed JJ 37231 1218 164 active active JJ 37231 1218 165 ; ; : 37231 1218 166 as as RB 37231 1218 167 surely surely RB 37231 1218 168 as as IN 37231 1218 169 there there EX 37231 1218 170 is be VBZ 37231 1218 171 any any DT 37231 1218 172 efficacy efficacy NN 37231 1218 173 in in IN 37231 1218 174 educational educational JJ 37231 1218 175 culture culture NN 37231 1218 176 , , , 37231 1218 177 or or CC 37231 1218 178 any any DT 37231 1218 179 meaning meaning NN 37231 1218 180 in in IN 37231 1218 181 such such JJ 37231 1218 182 terms term NNS 37231 1218 183 as as IN 37231 1218 184 habit habit NN 37231 1218 185 , , , 37231 1218 186 custom custom NN 37231 1218 187 , , , 37231 1218 188 practice practice NN 37231 1218 189 ; ; : 37231 1218 190 so so RB 37231 1218 191 surely surely RB 37231 1218 192 must must MD 37231 1218 193 the the DT 37231 1218 194 human human JJ 37231 1218 195 faculties faculty NNS 37231 1218 196 be be VB 37231 1218 197 moulded mould VBN 37231 1218 198 into into IN 37231 1218 199 complete complete JJ 37231 1218 200 fitness fitness NN 37231 1218 201 for for IN 37231 1218 202 the the DT 37231 1218 203 social social JJ 37231 1218 204 state state NN 37231 1218 205 ; ; : 37231 1218 206 so so RB 37231 1218 207 surely surely RB 37231 1218 208 must must MD 37231 1218 209 the the DT 37231 1218 210 things thing NNS 37231 1218 211 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1218 212 call call VBP 37231 1218 213 evil evil NN 37231 1218 214 and and CC 37231 1218 215 immorality immorality NN 37231 1218 216 disappear disappear VBP 37231 1218 217 ; ; : 37231 1218 218 so so RB 37231 1218 219 surely surely RB 37231 1218 220 must must MD 37231 1218 221 man man NN 37231 1218 222 become become VB 37231 1218 223 perfect perfect JJ 37231 1218 224 . . . 37231 1218 225 " " '' 37231 1219 1 Social Social NNP 37231 1219 2 Statics Statics NNP 37231 1219 3 , , , 37231 1219 4 stereotyped stereotype VBD 37231 1219 5 ed ed NNP 37231 1219 6 . . . 37231 1220 1 1868 1868 CD 37231 1220 2 , , , 37231 1220 3 p. p. NN 37231 1220 4 78 78 CD 37231 1220 5 f. f. NNP 37231 1220 6 { { -LRB- 37231 1220 7 51 51 CD 37231 1220 8 } } -RRB- 37231 1220 9 stern stern JJ 37231 1220 10 decree decree NN 37231 1220 11 of of IN 37231 1220 12 nature nature NN 37231 1220 13 . . . 37231 1221 1 The the DT 37231 1221 2 invariable invariable JJ 37231 1221 3 action action NN 37231 1221 4 of of IN 37231 1221 5 law law NN 37231 1221 6 of of IN 37231 1221 7 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1221 8 eliminates eliminate VBZ 37231 1221 9 the the DT 37231 1221 10 unfit unfit JJ 37231 1221 11 Progress Progress NNP 37231 1221 12 is be VBZ 37231 1221 13 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1221 14 to to TO 37231 1221 15 existence existence VB 37231 1221 16 ; ; : 37231 1221 17 extinction extinction NN 37231 1221 18 is be VBZ 37231 1221 19 the the DT 37231 1221 20 doom doom NN 37231 1221 21 of of IN 37231 1221 22 retrogression retrogression NN 37231 1221 23 . . . 37231 1222 1 The the DT 37231 1222 2 highest high JJS 37231 1222 3 effect effect NN 37231 1222 4 contemplated contemplate VBN 37231 1222 5 by by IN 37231 1222 6 the the DT 37231 1222 7 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1222 8 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1222 9 is be VBZ 37231 1222 10 to to TO 37231 1222 11 bring bring VB 37231 1222 12 man man NN 37231 1222 13 into into IN 37231 1222 14 perfect perfect JJ 37231 1222 15 harmony harmony NN 37231 1222 16 with with IN 37231 1222 17 law law NN 37231 1222 18 , , , 37231 1222 19 and and CC 37231 1222 20 this this DT 37231 1222 21 is be VBZ 37231 1222 22 ensured ensure VBN 37231 1222 23 by by IN 37231 1222 24 law law NN 37231 1222 25 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1222 26 acting act VBG 37231 1222 27 upon upon IN 37231 1222 28 intelligence intelligence NN 37231 1222 29 . . . 37231 1223 1 Only only RB 37231 1223 2 in in IN 37231 1223 3 obedience obedience NN 37231 1223 4 to to IN 37231 1223 5 law law NN 37231 1223 6 is be VBZ 37231 1223 7 there there RB 37231 1223 8 life life NN 37231 1223 9 and and CC 37231 1223 10 safety safety NN 37231 1223 11 . . . 37231 1224 1 Knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1224 2 of of IN 37231 1224 3 law law NN 37231 1224 4 is be VBZ 37231 1224 5 imperatively imperatively RB 37231 1224 6 demanded demand VBN 37231 1224 7 by by IN 37231 1224 8 nature nature NN 37231 1224 9 . . . 37231 1225 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1225 2 of of IN 37231 1225 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1225 4 is be VBZ 37231 1225 5 a a DT 37231 1225 6 capital capital NN 37231 1225 7 offence offence NN 37231 1225 8 . . . 37231 1226 1 If if IN 37231 1226 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1226 3 ignore ignore VBP 37231 1226 4 the the DT 37231 1226 5 law law NN 37231 1226 6 of of IN 37231 1226 7 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1226 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1226 9 are be VBP 37231 1226 10 dashed dash VBN 37231 1226 11 to to IN 37231 1226 12 pieces piece NNS 37231 1226 13 at at IN 37231 1226 14 the the DT 37231 1226 15 foot foot NN 37231 1226 16 of of IN 37231 1226 17 a a DT 37231 1226 18 precipice precipice NN 37231 1226 19 , , , 37231 1226 20 or or CC 37231 1226 21 are be VBP 37231 1226 22 crushed crush VBN 37231 1226 23 by by IN 37231 1226 24 a a DT 37231 1226 25 falling fall VBG 37231 1226 26 rock rock NN 37231 1226 27 ; ; : 37231 1226 28 if if IN 37231 1226 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1226 30 neglect neglect VBP 37231 1226 31 sanatory sanatory NN 37231 1226 32 law law NN 37231 1226 33 , , , 37231 1226 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1226 35 are be VBP 37231 1226 36 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 1226 37 by by IN 37231 1226 38 a a DT 37231 1226 39 pestilence pestilence NN 37231 1226 40 ; ; : 37231 1226 41 if if IN 37231 1226 42 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1226 43 disregard disregard VBP 37231 1226 44 chemical chemical JJ 37231 1226 45 laws law NNS 37231 1226 46 , , , 37231 1226 47 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1226 48 are be VBP 37231 1226 49 poisoned poison VBN 37231 1226 50 by by IN 37231 1226 51 a a DT 37231 1226 52 vapour vapour NN 37231 1226 53 . . . 37231 1227 1 There there EX 37231 1227 2 is be VBZ 37231 1227 3 not not RB 37231 1227 4 , , , 37231 1227 5 in in IN 37231 1227 6 reality reality NN 37231 1227 7 , , , 37231 1227 8 a a DT 37231 1227 9 gradation gradation NN 37231 1227 10 of of IN 37231 1227 11 breach breach NN 37231 1227 12 of of IN 37231 1227 13 law law NN 37231 1227 14 that that WDT 37231 1227 15 is be VBZ 37231 1227 16 not not RB 37231 1227 17 followed follow VBN 37231 1227 18 by by IN 37231 1227 19 an an DT 37231 1227 20 equivalent equivalent JJ 37231 1227 21 gradation gradation NN 37231 1227 22 of of IN 37231 1227 23 punishment punishment NN 37231 1227 24 . . . 37231 1228 1 Civilization civilization NN 37231 1228 2 is be VBZ 37231 1228 3 nothing nothing NN 37231 1228 4 but but IN 37231 1228 5 the the DT 37231 1228 6 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1228 7 and and CC 37231 1228 8 observance observance NN 37231 1228 9 of of IN 37231 1228 10 natural natural JJ 37231 1228 11 laws law NNS 37231 1228 12 . . . 37231 1229 1 The the DT 37231 1229 2 savage savage NN 37231 1229 3 must must MD 37231 1229 4 learn learn VB 37231 1229 5 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1229 6 or or CC 37231 1229 7 be be VB 37231 1229 8 extinguished extinguish VBN 37231 1229 9 ; ; : 37231 1229 10 the the DT 37231 1229 11 cultivated cultivate VBN 37231 1229 12 must must MD 37231 1229 13 observe observe VB 37231 1229 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1229 15 or or CC 37231 1229 16 die die VB 37231 1229 17 . . . 37231 1230 1 The the DT 37231 1230 2 balance balance NN 37231 1230 3 of of IN 37231 1230 4 moral moral JJ 37231 1230 5 and and CC 37231 1230 6 physical physical JJ 37231 1230 7 development development NN 37231 1230 8 can can MD 37231 1230 9 not not RB 37231 1230 10 be be VB 37231 1230 11 deranged derange VBN 37231 1230 12 with with IN 37231 1230 13 impunity impunity NN 37231 1230 14 . . . 37231 1231 1 In in IN 37231 1231 2 the the DT 37231 1231 3 spiritual spiritual NN 37231 1231 4 as as RB 37231 1231 5 well well RB 37231 1231 6 as as IN 37231 1231 7 the the DT 37231 1231 8 physical physical JJ 37231 1231 9 sense sense NN 37231 1231 10 only only RB 37231 1231 11 the the DT 37231 1231 12 fittest fit JJS 37231 1231 13 eventually eventually RB 37231 1231 14 can can MD 37231 1231 15 survive survive VB 37231 1231 16 in in IN 37231 1231 17 the the DT 37231 1231 18 struggle struggle NN 37231 1231 19 for for IN 37231 1231 20 existence existence NN 37231 1231 21 . . . 37231 1232 1 There there EX 37231 1232 2 is be VBZ 37231 1232 3 , , , 37231 1232 4 in in IN 37231 1232 5 fact fact NN 37231 1232 6 , , , 37231 1232 7 an an DT 37231 1232 8 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1232 9 upward upward JJ 37231 1232 10 impulse impulse NN 37231 1232 11 to to IN 37231 1232 12 the the DT 37231 1232 13 whole whole JJ 37231 1232 14 human human JJ 37231 1232 15 race race NN 37231 1232 16 supplied supply VBN 37231 1232 17 by by IN 37231 1232 18 the the DT 37231 1232 19 invariable invariable JJ 37231 1232 20 operation operation NN 37231 1232 21 of of IN 37231 1232 22 the the DT 37231 1232 23 laws law NNS 37231 1232 24 of of IN 37231 1232 25 nature nature NN 37231 1232 26 acting act VBG 37231 1232 27 upon upon IN 37231 1232 28 the the DT 37231 1232 29 common common JJ 37231 1232 30 instinct instinct NN 37231 1232 31 of of IN 37231 1232 32 self self NN 37231 1232 33 - - HYPH 37231 1232 34 preservation preservation NN 37231 1232 35 . . . 37231 1233 1 As as IN 37231 1233 2 , , , 37231 1233 3 on on IN 37231 1233 4 the the DT 37231 1233 5 one one CD 37231 1233 6 hand hand NN 37231 1233 7 , , , 37231 1233 8 the the DT 37231 1233 9 highest high JJS 37231 1233 10 human human JJ 37231 1233 11 conception conception NN 37231 1233 12 of of IN 37231 1233 13 infinite infinite JJ 37231 1233 14 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1233 15 and and CC 37231 1233 16 power power NN 37231 1233 17 is be VBZ 37231 1233 18 derived derive VBN 37231 1233 19 from from IN 37231 1233 20 the the DT 37231 1233 21 universality universality NN 37231 1233 22 and and CC 37231 1233 23 invariability invariability NN 37231 1233 24 of of IN 37231 1233 25 law law NN 37231 1233 26 , , , 37231 1233 27 so so IN 37231 1233 28 that that IN 37231 1233 29 universality universality NN 37231 1233 30 and and CC 37231 1233 31 invariability invariability NN 37231 1233 32 , , , 37231 1233 33 on on IN 37231 1233 34 the the DT 37231 1233 35 other other JJ 37231 1233 36 hand hand NN 37231 1233 37 , , , 37231 1233 38 exclude exclude VB 37231 1233 39 the the DT 37231 1233 40 idea idea NN 37231 1233 41 of of IN 37231 1233 42 interruption interruption NN 37231 1233 43 or or CC 37231 1233 44 occasional occasional JJ 37231 1233 45 suspension suspension NN 37231 1233 46 of of IN 37231 1233 47 law law NN 37231 1233 48 for for IN 37231 1233 49 any any DT 37231 1233 50 purpose purpose NN 37231 1233 51 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1233 52 , , , 37231 1233 53 and and CC 37231 1233 54 more more RBR 37231 1233 55 especially especially RB 37231 1233 56 for for IN 37231 1233 57 the the DT 37231 1233 58 correction correction NN 37231 1233 59 of of IN 37231 1233 60 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1233 61 original original JJ 37231 1233 62 errors error NNS 37231 1233 63 of of IN 37231 1233 64 design design NN 37231 1233 65 which which WDT 37231 1233 66 can can MD 37231 1233 67 not not RB 37231 1233 68 have have VB 37231 1233 69 existed exist VBN 37231 1233 70 , , , 37231 1233 71 or or CC 37231 1233 72 for for IN 37231 1233 73 the the DT 37231 1233 74 attainment attainment NN 37231 1233 75 of of IN 37231 1233 76 objects object NNS 37231 1233 77 already already RB 37231 1233 78 provided provide VBN 37231 1233 79 for for IN 37231 1233 80 in in IN 37231 1233 81 the the DT 37231 1233 82 order order NN 37231 1233 83 of of IN 37231 1233 84 nature nature NN 37231 1233 85 . . . 37231 1234 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1234 2 52 52 CD 37231 1234 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1234 4 Upon upon IN 37231 1234 5 the the DT 37231 1234 6 first first JJ 37231 1234 7 groundless groundless JJ 37231 1234 8 assumption assumption NN 37231 1234 9 of of IN 37231 1234 10 a a DT 37231 1234 11 Divine divine JJ 37231 1234 12 design design NN 37231 1234 13 of of IN 37231 1234 14 such such PDT 37231 1234 15 a a DT 37231 1234 16 revelation revelation NN 37231 1234 17 follows follow VBZ 37231 1234 18 the the DT 37231 1234 19 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 37231 1234 20 inference inference NN 37231 1234 21 that that IN 37231 1234 22 , , , 37231 1234 23 for for IN 37231 1234 24 the the DT 37231 1234 25 purpose purpose NN 37231 1234 26 of of IN 37231 1234 27 making make VBG 37231 1234 28 the the DT 37231 1234 29 communication communication NN 37231 1234 30 from from IN 37231 1234 31 the the DT 37231 1234 32 unseen unseen JJ 37231 1234 33 world world NN 37231 1234 34 , , , 37231 1234 35 a a DT 37231 1234 36 miracle miracle NN 37231 1234 37 or or CC 37231 1234 38 visible visible JJ 37231 1234 39 suspension suspension NN 37231 1234 40 of of IN 37231 1234 41 the the DT 37231 1234 42 order order NN 37231 1234 43 or or CC 37231 1234 44 nature nature NN 37231 1234 45 is be VBZ 37231 1234 46 no no DT 37231 1234 47 irregularity irregularity NN 37231 1234 48 , , , 37231 1234 49 but but CC 37231 1234 50 part part NN 37231 1234 51 of of IN 37231 1234 52 the the DT 37231 1234 53 system system NN 37231 1234 54 of of IN 37231 1234 55 the the DT 37231 1234 56 universe universe NN 37231 1234 57 . . . 37231 1235 1 This this DT 37231 1235 2 , , , 37231 1235 3 however however RB 37231 1235 4 , , , 37231 1235 5 is be VBZ 37231 1235 6 a a DT 37231 1235 7 mere mere JJ 37231 1235 8 assertion assertion NN 37231 1235 9 , , , 37231 1235 10 and and CC 37231 1235 11 no no DT 37231 1235 12 argument argument NN 37231 1235 13 An an DT 37231 1235 14 avowed avowed JJ 37231 1235 15 assumption assumption NN 37231 1235 16 which which WDT 37231 1235 17 is be VBZ 37231 1235 18 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1235 19 to to IN 37231 1235 20 reason reason NN 37231 1235 21 is be VBZ 37231 1235 22 followed follow VBN 37231 1235 23 by by IN 37231 1235 24 another another DT 37231 1235 25 which which WDT 37231 1235 26 is be VBZ 37231 1235 27 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1235 28 to to TO 37231 1235 29 experience experience VB 37231 1235 30 . . . 37231 1236 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1236 2 is be VBZ 37231 1236 3 simply simply RB 37231 1236 4 absurd absurd JJ 37231 1236 5 to to TO 37231 1236 6 speak speak VB 37231 1236 7 of of IN 37231 1236 8 a a DT 37231 1236 9 visible visible JJ 37231 1236 10 suspension suspension NN 37231 1236 11 of of IN 37231 1236 12 the the DT 37231 1236 13 order order NN 37231 1236 14 of of IN 37231 1236 15 nature nature NN 37231 1236 16 being be VBG 37231 1236 17 part part NN 37231 1236 18 of of IN 37231 1236 19 the the DT 37231 1236 20 system system NN 37231 1236 21 of of IN 37231 1236 22 the the DT 37231 1236 23 universe universe NN 37231 1236 24 . . . 37231 1237 1 Such such PDT 37231 1237 2 a a DT 37231 1237 3 statement statement NN 37231 1237 4 has have VBZ 37231 1237 5 no no DT 37231 1237 6 meaning meaning NN 37231 1237 7 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1237 8 within within IN 37231 1237 9 the the DT 37231 1237 10 range range NN 37231 1237 11 of of IN 37231 1237 12 human human JJ 37231 1237 13 conception conception NN 37231 1237 14 . . . 37231 1238 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 1238 2 , , , 37231 1238 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1238 4 must must MD 37231 1238 5 be be VB 37231 1238 6 remembered remember VBN 37231 1238 7 that that IN 37231 1238 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1238 9 -- -- : 37231 1238 10 or or CC 37231 1238 11 " " `` 37231 1238 12 visible visible JJ 37231 1238 13 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1238 14 of of IN 37231 1238 15 the the DT 37231 1238 16 order order NN 37231 1238 17 of of IN 37231 1238 18 nature"--are nature"--are NNP 37231 1238 19 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1238 20 indifferently indifferently RB 37231 1238 21 to to IN 37231 1238 22 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1238 23 and and CC 37231 1238 24 to to IN 37231 1238 25 Satanic Satanic NNP 37231 1238 26 agency agency NN 37231 1238 27 . . . 37231 1239 1 If if IN 37231 1239 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1239 3 are be VBP 37231 1239 4 not not RB 37231 1239 5 an an DT 37231 1239 6 anomaly anomaly JJ 37231 1239 7 or or CC 37231 1239 8 irregularity irregularity NN 37231 1239 9 on on IN 37231 1239 10 the the DT 37231 1239 11 supposition supposition NN 37231 1239 12 of of IN 37231 1239 13 the the DT 37231 1239 14 Divine divine JJ 37231 1239 15 design design NN 37231 1239 16 of of IN 37231 1239 17 a a DT 37231 1239 18 revelation revelation NN 37231 1239 19 , , , 37231 1239 20 upon upon IN 37231 1239 21 what what WDT 37231 1239 22 supposition supposition NN 37231 1239 23 do do VBP 37231 1239 24 Satanic satanic JJ 37231 1239 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1239 26 cease cease VB 37231 1239 27 to to TO 37231 1239 28 be be VB 37231 1239 29 irregularities irregularity NNS 37231 1239 30 ? ? . 37231 1240 1 Is be VBZ 37231 1240 2 the the DT 37231 1240 3 order order NN 37231 1240 4 of of IN 37231 1240 5 nature nature NN 37231 1240 6 , , , 37231 1240 7 which which WDT 37231 1240 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1240 9 is be VBZ 37231 1240 10 asserted assert VBN 37231 1240 11 is be VBZ 37231 1240 12 under under IN 37231 1240 13 the the DT 37231 1240 14 personal personal JJ 37231 1240 15 control control NN 37231 1240 16 of of IN 37231 1240 17 God God NNP 37231 1240 18 , , , 37231 1240 19 at at IN 37231 1240 20 the the DT 37231 1240 21 same same JJ 37231 1240 22 time time NN 37231 1240 23 at at IN 37231 1240 24 the the DT 37231 1240 25 mercy mercy NN 37231 1240 26 of of IN 37231 1240 27 the the DT 37231 1240 28 Devil Devil NNP 37231 1240 29 ? ? . 37231 1241 1 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1241 2 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1241 3 has have VBZ 37231 1241 4 , , , 37231 1241 5 as as IN 37231 1241 6 usual usual JJ 37231 1241 7 , , , 37231 1241 8 a a DT 37231 1241 9 singular singular JJ 37231 1241 10 way way NN 37231 1241 11 of of IN 37231 1241 12 overcoming overcome VBG 37231 1241 13 the the DT 37231 1241 14 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1241 15 . . . 37231 1242 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1242 2 says:--"So says:--"so RB 37231 1242 3 long long RB 37231 1242 4 as as IN 37231 1242 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1242 6 abide abide VBP 37231 1242 7 in in IN 37231 1242 8 the the DT 37231 1242 9 region region NN 37231 1242 10 of of IN 37231 1242 11 nature nature NN 37231 1242 12 , , , 37231 1242 13 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1242 14 and and CC 37231 1242 15 improbable improbable JJ 37231 1242 16 , , , 37231 1242 17 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1242 18 and and CC 37231 1242 19 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1242 20 may may MD 37231 1242 21 be be VB 37231 1242 22 admitted admit VBN 37231 1242 23 as as IN 37231 1242 24 convertible convertible JJ 37231 1242 25 terms term NNS 37231 1242 26 . . . 37231 1243 1 But but CC 37231 1243 2 once once RB 37231 1243 3 lift lift VB 37231 1243 4 up up RP 37231 1243 5 the the DT 37231 1243 6 whole whole JJ 37231 1243 7 discussion discussion NN 37231 1243 8 into into IN 37231 1243 9 a a DT 37231 1243 10 higher high JJR 37231 1243 11 region region NN 37231 1243 12 , , , 37231 1243 13 once once RB 37231 1243 14 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 37231 1243 15 something something NN 37231 1243 16 higher high JJR 37231 1243 17 than than IN 37231 1243 18 nature nature NN 37231 1243 19 , , , 37231 1243 20 a a DT 37231 1243 21 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 1243 22 of of IN 37231 1243 23 God God NNP 37231 1243 24 , , , 37231 1243 25 and and CC 37231 1243 26 men man NNS 37231 1243 27 the the DT 37231 1243 28 intended intend VBN 37231 1243 29 denizens denizen NNS 37231 1243 30 of of IN 37231 1243 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1243 32 , , , 37231 1243 33 and and CC 37231 1243 34 the the DT 37231 1243 35 whole whole JJ 37231 1243 36 argument argument NN 37231 1243 37 loses lose VBZ 37231 1243 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1243 39 strength strength NN 37231 1243 40 and and CC 37231 1243 41 the the DT 37231 1243 42 force force NN 37231 1243 43 of of IN 37231 1243 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1243 45 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1243 46 .... .... . 37231 1244 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 2 who who WP 37231 1244 3 already already RB 37231 1244 4 counts count VBZ 37231 1244 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 6 likely likely JJ 37231 1244 7 that that IN 37231 1244 8 God God NNP 37231 1244 9 will will MD 37231 1244 10 interfere interfere VB 37231 1244 11 for for IN 37231 1244 12 the the DT 37231 1244 13 higher high JJR 37231 1244 14 welfare welfare NN 37231 1244 15 of of IN 37231 1244 16 men man NNS 37231 1244 17 , , , 37231 1244 18 who who WP 37231 1244 19 believes believe VBZ 37231 1244 20 that that IN 37231 1244 21 there there EX 37231 1244 22 is be VBZ 37231 1244 23 a a DT 37231 1244 24 { { -LRB- 37231 1244 25 53 53 CD 37231 1244 26 } } -RRB- 37231 1244 27 nobler nobler NN 37231 1244 28 world world NN 37231 1244 29 - - HYPH 37231 1244 30 order order NN 37231 1244 31 than than IN 37231 1244 32 that that DT 37231 1244 33 in in IN 37231 1244 34 which which WDT 37231 1244 35 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 36 live live VBP 37231 1244 37 and and CC 37231 1244 38 move move VBP 37231 1244 39 , , , 37231 1244 40 and and CC 37231 1244 41 that that IN 37231 1244 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 43 would would MD 37231 1244 44 be be VB 37231 1244 45 the the DT 37231 1244 46 blessing blessing NN 37231 1244 47 of of IN 37231 1244 48 blessings blessing NNS 37231 1244 49 for for IN 37231 1244 50 that that DT 37231 1244 51 nobler nobler NN 37231 1244 52 to to TO 37231 1244 53 intrude intrude VB 37231 1244 54 into into IN 37231 1244 55 and and CC 37231 1244 56 to to TO 37231 1244 57 make make VB 37231 1244 58 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 59 felt feel VBN 37231 1244 60 in in IN 37231 1244 61 the the DT 37231 1244 62 region region NN 37231 1244 63 of of IN 37231 1244 64 this this DT 37231 1244 65 lower low JJR 37231 1244 66 , , , 37231 1244 67 who who WP 37231 1244 68 has have VBZ 37231 1244 69 found find VBN 37231 1244 70 that that IN 37231 1244 71 here here RB 37231 1244 72 in in IN 37231 1244 73 this this DT 37231 1244 74 world world NN 37231 1244 75 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 76 are be VBP 37231 1244 77 bound bind VBN 37231 1244 78 by by IN 37231 1244 79 heavy heavy JJ 37231 1244 80 laws law NNS 37231 1244 81 of of IN 37231 1244 82 nature nature NN 37231 1244 83 , , , 37231 1244 84 of of IN 37231 1244 85 sin sin NN 37231 1244 86 , , , 37231 1244 87 of of IN 37231 1244 88 death death NN 37231 1244 89 , , , 37231 1244 90 which which WDT 37231 1244 91 no no DT 37231 1244 92 powers power NNS 37231 1244 93 that that WDT 37231 1244 94 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 95 now now RB 37231 1244 96 possess possess VBP 37231 1244 97 can can MD 37231 1244 98 break break VB 37231 1244 99 , , , 37231 1244 100 yet yet CC 37231 1244 101 which which WDT 37231 1244 102 must must MD 37231 1244 103 be be VB 37231 1244 104 broken break VBN 37231 1244 105 if if IN 37231 1244 106 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 107 are be VBP 37231 1244 108 truly truly RB 37231 1244 109 to to IN 37231 1244 110 live,--he live,--he NNP 37231 1244 111 will will MD 37231 1244 112 not not RB 37231 1244 113 find find VB 37231 1244 114 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 115 hard hard JJ 37231 1244 116 to to TO 37231 1244 117 believe believe VB 37231 1244 118 the the DT 37231 1244 119 great great JJ 37231 1244 120 miracle miracle NN 37231 1244 121 , , , 37231 1244 122 the the DT 37231 1244 123 coming coming NN 37231 1244 124 of of IN 37231 1244 125 the the DT 37231 1244 126 Son Son NNP 37231 1244 127 of of IN 37231 1244 128 God God NNP 37231 1244 129 in in IN 37231 1244 130 the the DT 37231 1244 131 flesh flesh NN 37231 1244 132 , , , 37231 1244 133 & & CC 37231 1244 134 c c NNP 37231 1244 135 ... ... : 37231 1244 136 And and CC 37231 1244 137 as as IN 37231 1244 138 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 139 believes believe VBZ 37231 1244 140 that that IN 37231 1244 141 greatest great JJS 37231 1244 142 miracle miracle NN 37231 1244 143 , , , 37231 1244 144 so so RB 37231 1244 145 will will MD 37231 1244 146 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 147 believe believe VB 37231 1244 148 all all DT 37231 1244 149 other other JJ 37231 1244 150 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1244 151 , , , 37231 1244 152 & & CC 37231 1244 153 c c NNP 37231 1244 154 . . . 37231 1244 155 "(1 "(1 NNP 37231 1244 156 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1244 157 In in IN 37231 1244 158 other other JJ 37231 1244 159 words word NNS 37231 1244 160 , , , 37231 1244 161 if if IN 37231 1244 162 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 163 already already RB 37231 1244 164 believe believe VBP 37231 1244 165 the the DT 37231 1244 166 premises premise NNS 37231 1244 167 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 168 shall shall MD 37231 1244 169 not not RB 37231 1244 170 find find VB 37231 1244 171 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 172 difficult difficult JJ 37231 1244 173 to to TO 37231 1244 174 adopt adopt VB 37231 1244 175 the the DT 37231 1244 176 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1244 177 -- -- : 37231 1244 178 if if IN 37231 1244 179 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 180 already already RB 37231 1244 181 believe believe VBP 37231 1244 182 the the DT 37231 1244 183 greatest great JJS 37231 1244 184 miracle miracle NN 37231 1244 185 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 186 shall shall MD 37231 1244 187 not not RB 37231 1244 188 hesitate hesitate VB 37231 1244 189 to to TO 37231 1244 190 believe believe VB 37231 1244 191 the the DT 37231 1244 192 less less JJR 37231 1244 193 -- -- : 37231 1244 194 if if IN 37231 1244 195 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 196 already already RB 37231 1244 197 believe believe VBP 37231 1244 198 the the DT 37231 1244 199 dogmas dogmas NN 37231 1244 200 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 201 shall shall MD 37231 1244 202 not not RB 37231 1244 203 find find VB 37231 1244 204 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 205 hard hard JJ 37231 1244 206 to to TO 37231 1244 207 believe believe VB 37231 1244 208 the the DT 37231 1244 209 evidence evidence NN 37231 1244 210 by by IN 37231 1244 211 which which WDT 37231 1244 212 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1244 213 are be VBP 37231 1244 214 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1244 215 to to TO 37231 1244 216 be be VB 37231 1244 217 authenticated authenticate VBN 37231 1244 218 . . . 37231 1245 1 As as IN 37231 1245 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1245 3 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 1245 4 do do VBP 37231 1245 5 abide abide VB 37231 1245 6 in in IN 37231 1245 7 the the DT 37231 1245 8 { { -LRB- 37231 1245 9 54 54 CD 37231 1245 10 } } -RRB- 37231 1245 11 region region NN 37231 1245 12 of of IN 37231 1245 13 nature nature NN 37231 1245 14 , , , 37231 1245 15 in in IN 37231 1245 16 which which WDT 37231 1245 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1245 18 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1245 19 admits admit VBZ 37231 1245 20 that that IN 37231 1245 21 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1245 22 and and CC 37231 1245 23 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1245 24 are be VBP 37231 1245 25 convertible convertible JJ 37231 1245 26 terms term NNS 37231 1245 27 , , , 37231 1245 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1245 29 would would MD 37231 1245 30 seem seem VB 37231 1245 31 rather rather RB 37231 1245 32 difficult difficult JJ 37231 1245 33 to to TO 37231 1245 34 lift lift VB 37231 1245 35 the the DT 37231 1245 36 discussion discussion NN 37231 1245 37 into into IN 37231 1245 38 the the DT 37231 1245 39 higher high JJR 37231 1245 40 region region NN 37231 1245 41 here here RB 37231 1245 42 described describe VBN 37231 1245 43 without without IN 37231 1245 44 having have VBG 37231 1245 45 already already RB 37231 1245 46 abandoned abandon VBN 37231 1245 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1245 48 altogether altogether RB 37231 1245 49 . . . 37231 1246 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1246 2 55 55 CD 37231 1246 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1246 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 1246 5 III III NNP 37231 1246 6 . . . 37231 1247 1 REASON reason NN 37231 1247 2 IN in IN 37231 1247 3 RELATION relation NN 37231 1247 4 TO to IN 37231 1247 5 THE the DT 37231 1247 6 ORDER order NN 37231 1247 7 OF of IN 37231 1247 8 NATURE NATURE NNP 37231 1247 9 The the DT 37231 1247 10 argument argument NN 37231 1247 11 of of IN 37231 1247 12 those those DT 37231 1247 13 who who WP 37231 1247 14 assert assert VBP 37231 1247 15 the the DT 37231 1247 16 possibility possibility NN 37231 1247 17 and and CC 37231 1247 18 reality reality NN 37231 1247 19 of of IN 37231 1247 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1247 21 generally generally RB 37231 1247 22 takes take VBZ 37231 1247 23 the the DT 37231 1247 24 shape shape NN 37231 1247 25 of of IN 37231 1247 26 an an DT 37231 1247 27 attack attack NN 37231 1247 28 , , , 37231 1247 29 more more RBR 37231 1247 30 or or CC 37231 1247 31 less less RBR 37231 1247 32 direct direct JJ 37231 1247 33 , , , 37231 1247 34 upon upon IN 37231 1247 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1247 36 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1247 37 of of IN 37231 1247 38 the the DT 37231 1247 39 order order NN 37231 1247 40 of of IN 37231 1247 41 nature nature NN 37231 1247 42 . . . 37231 1248 1 To to TO 37231 1248 2 establish establish VB 37231 1248 3 an an DT 37231 1248 4 exception exception NN 37231 1248 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1248 6 contest contest VBP 37231 1248 7 the the DT 37231 1248 8 rule rule NN 37231 1248 9 . . . 37231 1249 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1249 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1249 3 , , , 37231 1249 4 however however RB 37231 1249 5 , , , 37231 1249 6 is be VBZ 37231 1249 7 not not RB 37231 1249 8 content content JJ 37231 1249 9 with with IN 37231 1249 10 the the DT 37231 1249 11 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 1249 12 objections objection NNS 37231 1249 13 advanced advance VBN 37231 1249 14 by by IN 37231 1249 15 apologists apologist NNS 37231 1249 16 but but CC 37231 1249 17 , , , 37231 1249 18 boldly boldly RB 37231 1249 19 entering enter VBG 37231 1249 20 into into IN 37231 1249 21 the the DT 37231 1249 22 mazes maze NNS 37231 1249 23 of of IN 37231 1249 24 a a DT 37231 1249 25 delicate delicate JJ 37231 1249 26 philosophical philosophical JJ 37231 1249 27 problem problem NN 37231 1249 28 , , , 37231 1249 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1249 30 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 1249 31 sceptical sceptical JJ 37231 1249 32 arguments argument NNS 37231 1249 33 and and CC 37231 1249 34 seeks seek VBZ 37231 1249 35 to to TO 37231 1249 36 turn turn VB 37231 1249 37 the the DT 37231 1249 38 flank flank NN 37231 1249 39 of of IN 37231 1249 40 the the DT 37231 1249 41 enemy enemy NN 37231 1249 42 upon upon IN 37231 1249 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1249 44 own own JJ 37231 1249 45 ground ground NN 37231 1249 46 . . . 37231 1250 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1250 2 conducts conduct VBZ 37231 1250 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1250 4 attack attack NN 37231 1250 5 with with IN 37231 1250 6 unusual unusual JJ 37231 1250 7 force force NN 37231 1250 8 and and CC 37231 1250 9 ability ability NN 37231 1250 10 . . . 37231 1251 1 " " `` 37231 1251 2 Whatever whatever WDT 37231 1251 3 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1251 4 there there EX 37231 1251 5 is be VBZ 37231 1251 6 in in IN 37231 1251 7 believing believe VBG 37231 1251 8 in in IN 37231 1251 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1251 10 in in IN 37231 1251 11 general general JJ 37231 1251 12 , , , 37231 1251 13 " " '' 37231 1251 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1251 15 says say VBZ 37231 1251 16 , , , 37231 1251 17 " " `` 37231 1251 18 arises arise VBZ 37231 1251 19 from from IN 37231 1251 20 the the DT 37231 1251 21 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 1251 22 that that IN 37231 1251 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1251 24 are be VBP 37231 1251 25 in in IN 37231 1251 26 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1251 27 to to IN 37231 1251 28 or or CC 37231 1251 29 unlike unlike IN 37231 1251 30 the the DT 37231 1251 31 order order NN 37231 1251 32 of of IN 37231 1251 33 nature nature NN 37231 1251 34 . . . 37231 1252 1 To to TO 37231 1252 2 estimate estimate VB 37231 1252 3 the the DT 37231 1252 4 force force NN 37231 1252 5 of of IN 37231 1252 6 this this DT 37231 1252 7 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1252 8 , , , 37231 1252 9 then then RB 37231 1252 10 , , , 37231 1252 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1252 12 must must MD 37231 1252 13 first first RB 37231 1252 14 understand understand VB 37231 1252 15 what what WP 37231 1252 16 kind kind NN 37231 1252 17 of of IN 37231 1252 18 belief belief NN 37231 1252 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1252 20 is be VBZ 37231 1252 21 which which WDT 37231 1252 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1252 23 have have VBP 37231 1252 24 in in IN 37231 1252 25 the the DT 37231 1252 26 order order NN 37231 1252 27 of of IN 37231 1252 28 nature nature NN 37231 1252 29 ; ; : 37231 1252 30 for for IN 37231 1252 31 the the DT 37231 1252 32 weight weight NN 37231 1252 33 of of IN 37231 1252 34 the the DT 37231 1252 35 objection objection NN 37231 1252 36 to to IN 37231 1252 37 the the DT 37231 1252 38 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1252 39 must must MD 37231 1252 40 depend depend VB 37231 1252 41 on on IN 37231 1252 42 the the DT 37231 1252 43 nature nature NN 37231 1252 44 of of IN 37231 1252 45 the the DT 37231 1252 46 belief belief NN 37231 1252 47 to to TO 37231 1252 48 which which WDT 37231 1252 49 the the DT 37231 1252 50 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1252 51 is be VBZ 37231 1252 52 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1252 53 . . . 37231 1253 1 " " `` 37231 1253 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1253 3 1 1 LS 37231 1253 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1253 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1253 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1253 7 defines define VBZ 37231 1253 8 the the DT 37231 1253 9 meaning meaning NN 37231 1253 10 of of IN 37231 1253 11 the the DT 37231 1253 12 phrase phrase NN 37231 1253 13 , , , 37231 1253 14 " " `` 37231 1253 15 order order NN 37231 1253 16 of of IN 37231 1253 17 nature nature NN 37231 1253 18 " " '' 37231 1253 19 as as IN 37231 1253 20 the the DT 37231 1253 21 _ _ NNP 37231 1253 22 connection connection NN 37231 1253 23 _ _ NNP 37231 1253 24 of of IN 37231 1253 25 that that DT 37231 1253 26 part part NN 37231 1253 27 of of IN 37231 1253 28 the the DT 37231 1253 29 order order NN 37231 1253 30 of of IN 37231 1253 31 nature nature NN 37231 1253 32 of of IN 37231 1253 33 which which WDT 37231 1253 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1253 35 are be VBP 37231 1253 36 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 1253 37 with with IN 37231 1253 38 that that DT 37231 1253 39 part part NN 37231 1253 40 of of IN 37231 1253 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1253 42 which which WDT 37231 1253 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1253 44 know know VBP 37231 1253 45 , , , 37231 1253 46 the the DT 37231 1253 47 former former JJ 37231 1253 48 being be VBG 37231 1253 49 expected expect VBN 37231 1253 50 to to TO 37231 1253 51 be be VB 37231 1253 52 such such JJ 37231 1253 53 and and CC 37231 1253 54 such such JJ 37231 1253 55 , , , 37231 1253 56 _ _ NNP 37231 1253 57 because because IN 37231 1253 58 _ _ NNP 37231 1253 59 the the DT 37231 1253 60 latter latter NN 37231 1253 61 is be VBZ 37231 1253 62 . . . 37231 1254 1 But but CC 37231 1254 2 how how WRB 37231 1254 3 do do VBP 37231 1254 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1254 5 justify justify VB 37231 1254 6 this this DT 37231 1254 7 expectation expectation NN 37231 1254 8 of of IN 37231 1254 9 { { -LRB- 37231 1254 10 56 56 CD 37231 1254 11 } } -RRB- 37231 1254 12 _ _ NN 37231 1254 13 likeness likeness NN 37231 1254 14 ? ? . 37231 1254 15 _ _ NNP 37231 1254 16 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1254 17 can can MD 37231 1254 18 not not RB 37231 1254 19 do do VB 37231 1254 20 so so RB 37231 1254 21 , , , 37231 1254 22 and and CC 37231 1254 23 all all PDT 37231 1254 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1254 25 arguments argument NNS 37231 1254 26 are be VBP 37231 1254 27 mere mere JJ 37231 1254 28 statements statement NNS 37231 1254 29 of of IN 37231 1254 30 the the DT 37231 1254 31 belief belief NN 37231 1254 32 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1254 33 , , , 37231 1254 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1254 35 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 1254 36 , , , 37231 1254 37 and and CC 37231 1254 38 not not RB 37231 1254 39 reasons reason NNS 37231 1254 40 to to TO 37231 1254 41 account account VB 37231 1254 42 for for IN 37231 1254 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1254 44 . . . 37231 1255 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1255 2 may may MD 37231 1255 3 be be VB 37231 1255 4 said say VBN 37231 1255 5 , , , 37231 1255 6 e.g. e.g. RB 37231 1255 7 , , , 37231 1255 8 that that IN 37231 1255 9 when when WRB 37231 1255 10 a a DT 37231 1255 11 fact fact NN 37231 1255 12 of of IN 37231 1255 13 nature nature NN 37231 1255 14 has have VBZ 37231 1255 15 gone go VBN 37231 1255 16 on on RP 37231 1255 17 repeating repeat VBG 37231 1255 18 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1255 19 a a DT 37231 1255 20 certain certain JJ 37231 1255 21 time time NN 37231 1255 22 , , , 37231 1255 23 such such JJ 37231 1255 24 repetition repetition NN 37231 1255 25 shows show VBZ 37231 1255 26 that that IN 37231 1255 27 there there EX 37231 1255 28 is be VBZ 37231 1255 29 a a DT 37231 1255 30 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1255 31 cause cause NN 37231 1255 32 at at IN 37231 1255 33 work work NN 37231 1255 34 , , , 37231 1255 35 and and CC 37231 1255 36 that that IN 37231 1255 37 a a DT 37231 1255 38 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1255 39 cause cause NN 37231 1255 40 produces produce VBZ 37231 1255 41 permanently permanently RB 37231 1255 42 recurring recur VBG 37231 1255 43 effects effect NNS 37231 1255 44 . . . 37231 1256 1 But but CC 37231 1256 2 what what WP 37231 1256 3 is be VBZ 37231 1256 4 there there RB 37231 1256 5 to to TO 37231 1256 6 show show VB 37231 1256 7 the the DT 37231 1256 8 existence existence NN 37231 1256 9 of of IN 37231 1256 10 a a DT 37231 1256 11 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1256 12 cause cause NN 37231 1256 13 ? ? . 37231 1257 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 1257 2 . . . 37231 1258 1 The the DT 37231 1258 2 effects effect NNS 37231 1258 3 which which WDT 37231 1258 4 have have VBP 37231 1258 5 taken take VBN 37231 1258 6 place place NN 37231 1258 7 show show VB 37231 1258 8 a a DT 37231 1258 9 cause cause NN 37231 1258 10 at at IN 37231 1258 11 work work NN 37231 1258 12 to to IN 37231 1258 13 the the DT 37231 1258 14 extent extent NN 37231 1258 15 of of IN 37231 1258 16 these these DT 37231 1258 17 effects effect NNS 37231 1258 18 , , , 37231 1258 19 but but CC 37231 1258 20 not not RB 37231 1258 21 further further RB 37231 1258 22 . . . 37231 1259 1 That that IN 37231 1259 2 this this DT 37231 1259 3 cause cause NN 37231 1259 4 is be VBZ 37231 1259 5 of of IN 37231 1259 6 a a DT 37231 1259 7 more more RBR 37231 1259 8 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1259 9 nature nature NN 37231 1259 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1259 11 have have VBP 37231 1259 12 no no DT 37231 1259 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 1259 14 . . . 37231 1260 1 Why why WRB 37231 1260 2 then then RB 37231 1260 3 do do VBP 37231 1260 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1260 5 expect expect VB 37231 1260 6 the the DT 37231 1260 7 further further JJ 37231 1260 8 continuance continuance NN 37231 1260 9 of of IN 37231 1260 10 these these DT 37231 1260 11 effects effect NNS 37231 1260 12 . . . 37231 1261 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1261 2 2 2 LS 37231 1261 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1261 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1261 5 can can MD 37231 1261 6 only only RB 37231 1261 7 say say VB 37231 1261 8 : : : 37231 1261 9 because because IN 37231 1261 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1261 11 believe believe VBP 37231 1261 12 the the DT 37231 1261 13 future future NN 37231 1261 14 will will MD 37231 1261 15 be be VB 37231 1261 16 like like IN 37231 1261 17 the the DT 37231 1261 18 past past NN 37231 1261 19 . . . 37231 1262 1 After after IN 37231 1262 2 a a DT 37231 1262 3 physical physical JJ 37231 1262 4 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 1262 5 has have VBZ 37231 1262 6 even even RB 37231 1262 7 occurred occur VBN 37231 1262 8 every every DT 37231 1262 9 day day NN 37231 1262 10 for for IN 37231 1262 11 years year NNS 37231 1262 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1262 13 have have VBP 37231 1262 14 nothing nothing NN 37231 1262 15 but but IN 37231 1262 16 the the DT 37231 1262 17 past past JJ 37231 1262 18 repetition repetition NN 37231 1262 19 to to TO 37231 1262 20 justify justify VB 37231 1262 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1262 22 certain certain JJ 37231 1262 23 expectation expectation NN 37231 1262 24 of of IN 37231 1262 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1262 26 future future JJ 37231 1262 27 repetition repetition NN 37231 1262 28 . . . 37231 1263 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1263 2 3 3 LS 37231 1263 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1263 4 Do do VBP 37231 1263 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1263 6 think think VB 37231 1263 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1263 8 giving give VBG 37231 1263 9 a a DT 37231 1263 10 reason reason NN 37231 1263 11 for for IN 37231 1263 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1263 13 confidence confidence NN 37231 1263 14 in in IN 37231 1263 15 the the DT 37231 1263 16 future future NN 37231 1263 17 to to TO 37231 1263 18 say say VB 37231 1263 19 that that IN 37231 1263 20 , , , 37231 1263 21 though though IN 37231 1263 22 no no DT 37231 1263 23 man man NN 37231 1263 24 has have VBZ 37231 1263 25 had have VBN 37231 1263 26 experience experience NN 37231 1263 27 of of IN 37231 1263 28 what what WP 37231 1263 29 is be VBZ 37231 1263 30 future future JJ 37231 1263 31 , , , 37231 1263 32 every every DT 37231 1263 33 man man NN 37231 1263 34 has have VBZ 37231 1263 35 had have VBN 37231 1263 36 experience experience NN 37231 1263 37 of of IN 37231 1263 38 what what WP 37231 1263 39 was be VBD 37231 1263 40 future future JJ 37231 1263 41 ? ? . 37231 1264 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1264 2 is be VBZ 37231 1264 3 true true JJ 37231 1264 4 that that IN 37231 1264 5 what what WP 37231 1264 6 is be VBZ 37231 1264 7 future future JJ 37231 1264 8 becomes become VBZ 37231 1264 9 at at IN 37231 1264 10 every every DT 37231 1264 11 step step NN 37231 1264 12 of of IN 37231 1264 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1264 14 advance advance NN 37231 1264 15 what what WP 37231 1264 16 was be VBD 37231 1264 17 future future JJ 37231 1264 18 , , , 37231 1264 19 but but CC 37231 1264 20 that that DT 37231 1264 21 which which WDT 37231 1264 22 is be VBZ 37231 1264 23 now now RB 37231 1264 24 still still RB 37231 1264 25 future future JJ 37231 1264 26 is be VBZ 37231 1264 27 not not RB 37231 1264 28 the the DT 37231 1264 29 least least JJS 37231 1264 30 altered alter VBN 37231 1264 31 by by IN 37231 1264 32 that that DT 37231 1264 33 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 1264 34 ; ; : 37231 1264 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1264 36 is be VBZ 37231 1264 37 as as RB 37231 1264 38 invisible invisible JJ 37231 1264 39 , , , 37231 1264 40 as as IN 37231 1264 41 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1264 42 , , , 37231 1264 43 and and CC 37231 1264 44 as as RB 37231 1264 45 unexplored unexplored JJ 37231 1264 46 as as IN 37231 1264 47 if if IN 37231 1264 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1264 49 were be VBD 37231 1264 50 the the DT 37231 1264 51 very very RB 37231 1264 52 beginning beginning NN 37231 1264 53 and and CC 37231 1264 54 the the DT 37231 1264 55 very very RB 37231 1264 56 starting starting NN 37231 1264 57 - - HYPH 37231 1264 58 point point NN 37231 1264 59 of of IN 37231 1264 60 nature nature NN 37231 1264 61 . . . 37231 1265 1 At at IN 37231 1265 2 this this DT 37231 1265 3 starting starting NN 37231 1265 4 - - HYPH 37231 1265 5 point point NN 37231 1265 6 of of IN 37231 1265 7 nature nature NN 37231 1265 8 what what WP 37231 1265 9 would would MD 37231 1265 10 a a DT 37231 1265 11 man man NN 37231 1265 12 know know VB 37231 1265 13 of of IN 37231 1265 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1265 15 future future JJ 37231 1265 16 course course NN 37231 1265 17 ? ? . 37231 1266 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 1266 2 . . . 37231 1267 1 At at IN 37231 1267 2 this this DT 37231 1267 3 moment moment NN 37231 1267 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1267 5 knows know VBZ 37231 1267 6 no no DT 37231 1267 7 more more JJR 37231 1267 8 . . . 37231 1268 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1268 2 4 4 LS 37231 1268 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1268 4 What what WP 37231 1268 5 ground ground NN 37231 1268 6 of of IN 37231 1268 7 reason reason NN 37231 1268 8 , , , 37231 1268 9 then then RB 37231 1268 10 , , , 37231 1268 11 can can MD 37231 1268 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1268 13 assign assign VB 37231 1268 14 for for IN 37231 1268 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1268 16 expectation expectation NN 37231 1268 17 that that IN 37231 1268 18 any any DT 37231 1268 19 part part NN 37231 1268 20 of of IN 37231 1268 21 the the DT 37231 1268 22 course course NN 37231 1268 23 of of IN 37231 1268 24 nature nature NN 37231 1268 25 will will MD 37231 1268 26 the the DT 37231 1268 27 next next JJ 37231 1268 28 moment moment NN 37231 1268 29 be be VB 37231 1268 30 like like IN 37231 1268 31 what what WP 37231 1268 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1268 33 has have VBZ 37231 1268 34 been be VBN 37231 1268 35 up up IN 37231 1268 36 to to IN 37231 1268 37 this this DT 37231 1268 38 moment moment NN 37231 1268 39 , , , 37231 1268 40 i.e. i.e. FW 37231 1268 41 , , , 37231 1268 42 for for IN 37231 1268 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1268 44 belief belief NN 37231 1268 45 { { -LRB- 37231 1268 46 57 57 CD 37231 1268 47 } } -RRB- 37231 1268 48 in in IN 37231 1268 49 the the DT 37231 1268 50 uniformity uniformity NN 37231 1268 51 of of IN 37231 1268 52 nature nature NN 37231 1268 53 ? ? . 37231 1269 1 None none NN 37231 1269 2 . . . 37231 1270 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1270 2 is be VBZ 37231 1270 3 without without IN 37231 1270 4 a a DT 37231 1270 5 reason reason NN 37231 1270 6 . . . 37231 1271 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1271 2 rests rest VBZ 37231 1271 3 upon upon IN 37231 1271 4 no no DT 37231 1271 5 rational rational JJ 37231 1271 6 ground ground NN 37231 1271 7 , , , 37231 1271 8 and and CC 37231 1271 9 can can MD 37231 1271 10 be be VB 37231 1271 11 traced trace VBN 37231 1271 12 to to IN 37231 1271 13 no no DT 37231 1271 14 rational rational JJ 37231 1271 15 principle principle NN 37231 1271 16 . . . 37231 1272 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1272 2 1 1 LS 37231 1272 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1272 4 The the DT 37231 1272 5 belief belief NN 37231 1272 6 in in IN 37231 1272 7 the the DT 37231 1272 8 order order NN 37231 1272 9 of of IN 37231 1272 10 nature nature NN 37231 1272 11 being be VBG 37231 1272 12 thus thus RB 37231 1272 13 an an DT 37231 1272 14 " " `` 37231 1272 15 unintelligent unintelligent JJ 37231 1272 16 impulse impulse NN 37231 1272 17 " " '' 37231 1272 18 of of IN 37231 1272 19 which which WDT 37231 1272 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1272 21 can can MD 37231 1272 22 not not RB 37231 1272 23 give give VB 37231 1272 24 any any DT 37231 1272 25 rational rational JJ 37231 1272 26 account account NN 37231 1272 27 , , , 37231 1272 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1272 29 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1272 30 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 1272 31 , , , 37231 1272 32 the the DT 37231 1272 33 ground ground NN 37231 1272 34 is be VBZ 37231 1272 35 gone go VBN 37231 1272 36 upon upon IN 37231 1272 37 which which WDT 37231 1272 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1272 39 could could MD 37231 1272 40 be be VB 37231 1272 41 maintained maintain VBN 37231 1272 42 that that IN 37231 1272 43 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1272 44 , , , 37231 1272 45 as as IN 37231 1272 46 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1272 47 to to IN 37231 1272 48 the the DT 37231 1272 49 order order NN 37231 1272 50 of of IN 37231 1272 51 nature nature NN 37231 1272 52 , , , 37231 1272 53 were be VBD 37231 1272 54 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1272 55 to to IN 37231 1272 56 reason reason NN 37231 1272 57 . . . 37231 1273 1 A a DT 37231 1273 2 miracle miracle NN 37231 1273 3 in in IN 37231 1273 4 being be VBG 37231 1273 5 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1273 6 to to IN 37231 1273 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1273 8 experience experience NN 37231 1273 9 is be VBZ 37231 1273 10 not not RB 37231 1273 11 only only RB 37231 1273 12 not not RB 37231 1273 13 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1273 14 to to IN 37231 1273 15 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1273 16 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1273 17 , , , 37231 1273 18 but but CC 37231 1273 19 to to IN 37231 1273 20 any any DT 37231 1273 21 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1273 22 . . . 37231 1274 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1274 2 2 2 LS 37231 1274 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1274 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1274 5 need need VBP 37231 1274 6 not not RB 37231 1274 7 further further RB 37231 1274 8 follow follow VB 37231 1274 9 the the DT 37231 1274 10 Bampton Bampton NNP 37231 1274 11 Lecturer Lecturer NNP 37231 1274 12 , , , 37231 1274 13 as as IN 37231 1274 14 with with IN 37231 1274 15 clearness clearness NN 37231 1274 16 and and CC 37231 1274 17 ability ability NN 37231 1274 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1274 19 applies apply VBZ 37231 1274 20 this this DT 37231 1274 21 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1274 22 to to IN 37231 1274 23 the the DT 37231 1274 24 argument argument NN 37231 1274 25 of of IN 37231 1274 26 " " `` 37231 1274 27 Experience Experience NNP 37231 1274 28 , , , 37231 1274 29 " " '' 37231 1274 30 until until IN 37231 1274 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1274 32 pauses pause VBZ 37231 1274 33 triumphantly triumphantly RB 37231 1274 34 to to TO 37231 1274 35 exclaim exclaim VB 37231 1274 36 : : : 37231 1274 37 " " `` 37231 1274 38 Thus thus RB 37231 1274 39 step step NN 37231 1274 40 by by IN 37231 1274 41 step step NN 37231 1274 42 has have VBZ 37231 1274 43 philosophy philosophy NN 37231 1274 44 loosened loosen VBD 37231 1274 45 the the DT 37231 1274 46 connection connection NN 37231 1274 47 of of IN 37231 1274 48 the the DT 37231 1274 49 order order NN 37231 1274 50 of of IN 37231 1274 51 nature nature NN 37231 1274 52 with with IN 37231 1274 53 the the DT 37231 1274 54 ground ground NN 37231 1274 55 of of IN 37231 1274 56 reason reason NN 37231 1274 57 , , , 37231 1274 58 befriending befriending NN 37231 1274 59 , , , 37231 1274 60 in in IN 37231 1274 61 exact exact JJ 37231 1274 62 proportion proportion NN 37231 1274 63 as as IN 37231 1274 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1274 65 has have VBZ 37231 1274 66 done do VBN 37231 1274 67 this this DT 37231 1274 68 , , , 37231 1274 69 the the DT 37231 1274 70 principle principle NN 37231 1274 71 of of IN 37231 1274 72 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1274 73 . . . 37231 1275 1 " " `` 37231 1275 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1275 3 3 3 LS 37231 1275 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1275 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1275 6 need need VBP 37231 1275 7 not not RB 37231 1275 8 here here RB 37231 1275 9 enter enter VB 37231 1275 10 upon upon IN 37231 1275 11 any any DT 37231 1275 12 abstract abstract JJ 37231 1275 13 argument argument NN 37231 1275 14 regarding regard VBG 37231 1275 15 the the DT 37231 1275 16 permanence permanence NN 37231 1275 17 or or CC 37231 1275 18 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 1275 19 of of IN 37231 1275 20 cause cause NN 37231 1275 21 : : : 37231 1275 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1275 23 will will MD 37231 1275 24 be be VB 37231 1275 25 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1275 26 to to TO 37231 1275 27 deal deal VB 37231 1275 28 with with IN 37231 1275 29 these these DT 37231 1275 30 objections objection NNS 37231 1275 31 in in IN 37231 1275 32 a a DT 37231 1275 33 simpler simple JJR 37231 1275 34 and and CC 37231 1275 35 more more JJR 37231 1275 36 direct direct JJ 37231 1275 37 way way NN 37231 1275 38 . . . 37231 1276 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1276 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1276 3 , , , 37231 1276 4 of of IN 37231 1276 5 course course NN 37231 1276 6 , , , 37231 1276 7 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 37231 1276 8 that that IN 37231 1276 9 the the DT 37231 1276 10 principle principle NN 37231 1276 11 of of IN 37231 1276 12 the the DT 37231 1276 13 argument argument NN 37231 1276 14 from from IN 37231 1276 15 experience experience NN 37231 1276 16 is be VBZ 37231 1276 17 that that IN 37231 1276 18 " " `` 37231 1276 19 which which WDT 37231 1276 20 makes make VBZ 37231 1276 21 human human JJ 37231 1276 22 life life NN 37231 1276 23 practicable practicable JJ 37231 1276 24 ; ; : 37231 1276 25 which which WDT 37231 1276 26 utilizes utilize VBZ 37231 1276 27 all all PDT 37231 1276 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1276 29 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1276 30 ; ; : 37231 1276 31 which which WDT 37231 1276 32 makes make VBZ 37231 1276 33 the the DT 37231 1276 34 past past JJ 37231 1276 35 anything anything NN 37231 1276 36 more more JJR 37231 1276 37 than than IN 37231 1276 38 an an DT 37231 1276 39 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 37231 1276 40 picture picture NN 37231 1276 41 to to IN 37231 1276 42 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1276 43 ; ; : 37231 1276 44 for for IN 37231 1276 45 of of IN 37231 1276 46 what what WDT 37231 1276 47 use use NN 37231 1276 48 is be VBZ 37231 1276 49 the the DT 37231 1276 50 experience experience NN 37231 1276 51 of of IN 37231 1276 52 the the DT 37231 1276 53 past past NN 37231 1276 54 to to IN 37231 1276 55 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1276 56 unless unless IN 37231 1276 57 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1276 58 believe believe VBP 37231 1276 59 the the DT 37231 1276 60 future future NN 37231 1276 61 will will MD 37231 1276 62 be be VB 37231 1276 63 like like IN 37231 1276 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1276 65 ? ? . 37231 1277 1 ' ' `` 37231 1277 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1277 3 4 4 LS 37231 1277 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1277 5 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1277 6 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1277 7 in in IN 37231 1277 8 all all DT 37231 1277 9 things thing NNS 37231 1277 10 is be VBZ 37231 1277 11 relative relative JJ 37231 1277 12 , , , 37231 1277 13 and and CC 37231 1277 14 there there EX 37231 1277 15 are be VBP 37231 1277 16 sharp sharp JJ 37231 1277 17 and and CC 37231 1277 18 narrow narrow JJ 37231 1277 19 limits limit NNS 37231 1277 20 to to IN 37231 1277 21 human human JJ 37231 1277 22 thought thought NN 37231 1277 23 . . . 37231 1278 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1278 2 is be VBZ 37231 1278 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 1278 4 evident evident JJ 37231 1278 5 that that IN 37231 1278 6 , , , 37231 1278 7 in in IN 37231 1278 8 the the DT 37231 1278 9 absence absence NN 37231 1278 10 of of IN 37231 1278 11 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1278 12 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1278 13 , , , 37231 1278 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1278 15 belief belief NN 37231 1278 16 must must MD 37231 1278 17 be be VB 37231 1278 18 accorded accord VBN 37231 1278 19 to to IN 37231 1278 20 that that DT 37231 1278 21 of of IN 37231 1278 22 which which WDT 37231 1278 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1278 24 have have VBP 37231 1278 25 { { -LRB- 37231 1278 26 58 58 CD 37231 1278 27 } } -RRB- 37231 1278 28 more more RBR 37231 1278 29 full full JJ 37231 1278 30 cognizance cognizance NN 37231 1278 31 rather rather RB 37231 1278 32 than than IN 37231 1278 33 to to IN 37231 1278 34 that that DT 37231 1278 35 which which WDT 37231 1278 36 is be VBZ 37231 1278 37 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 1278 38 by by IN 37231 1278 39 all all DT 37231 1278 40 that that WDT 37231 1278 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1278 42 do do VBP 37231 1278 43 know know VB 37231 1278 44 . . . 37231 1279 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1279 2 may may MD 37231 1279 3 be be VB 37231 1279 4 " " `` 37231 1279 5 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1279 6 " " '' 37231 1279 7 to to TO 37231 1279 8 feel feel VB 37231 1279 9 entire entire JJ 37231 1279 10 confidence confidence NN 37231 1279 11 that that IN 37231 1279 12 the the DT 37231 1279 13 sun sun NN 37231 1279 14 will will MD 37231 1279 15 " " `` 37231 1279 16 rise rise VB 37231 1279 17 " " '' 37231 1279 18 tomorrow tomorrow NN 37231 1279 19 , , , 37231 1279 20 or or CC 37231 1279 21 that that IN 37231 1279 22 the the DT 37231 1279 23 moon moon NN 37231 1279 24 will will MD 37231 1279 25 continue continue VB 37231 1279 26 to to TO 37231 1279 27 wax wax VB 37231 1279 28 and and CC 37231 1279 29 wane wane VB 37231 1279 30 as as IN 37231 1279 31 in in IN 37231 1279 32 the the DT 37231 1279 33 past past NN 37231 1279 34 , , , 37231 1279 35 but but CC 37231 1279 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1279 37 shall shall MD 37231 1279 38 without without IN 37231 1279 39 doubt doubt NN 37231 1279 40 retain retain VB 37231 1279 41 this this DT 37231 1279 42 belief belief NN 37231 1279 43 , , , 37231 1279 44 and and CC 37231 1279 45 reject reject VBP 37231 1279 46 any any DT 37231 1279 47 assertion assertion NN 37231 1279 48 , , , 37231 1279 49 however however RB 37231 1279 50 positive positive JJ 37231 1279 51 , , , 37231 1279 52 that that IN 37231 1279 53 the the DT 37231 1279 54 earth earth NN 37231 1279 55 will will MD 37231 1279 56 stand stand VB 37231 1279 57 still still RB 37231 1279 58 to to IN 37231 1279 59 - - HYPH 37231 1279 60 morrow morrow NN 37231 1279 61 , , , 37231 1279 62 or or CC 37231 1279 63 that that IN 37231 1279 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1279 65 did do VBD 37231 1279 66 so so RB 37231 1279 67 some some DT 37231 1279 68 thousands thousand NNS 37231 1279 69 of of IN 37231 1279 70 years year NNS 37231 1279 71 ago ago RB 37231 1279 72 . . . 37231 1280 1 Evidence evidence NN 37231 1280 2 must must MD 37231 1280 3 take take VB 37231 1280 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1280 5 relative relative JJ 37231 1280 6 place place NN 37231 1280 7 in in IN 37231 1280 8 the the DT 37231 1280 9 finite finite JJ 37231 1280 10 scale scale NN 37231 1280 11 of of IN 37231 1280 12 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1280 13 and and CC 37231 1280 14 thought thought NN 37231 1280 15 , , , 37231 1280 16 and and CC 37231 1280 17 if if IN 37231 1280 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1280 19 do do VBP 37231 1280 20 not not RB 37231 1280 21 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 1280 22 know know VB 37231 1280 23 anything anything NN 37231 1280 24 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1280 25 , , , 37231 1280 26 so so RB 37231 1280 27 long long RB 37231 1280 28 as as IN 37231 1280 29 one one CD 37231 1280 30 thing thing NN 37231 1280 31 is be VBZ 37231 1280 32 more more RBR 37231 1280 33 fully fully RB 37231 1280 34 established establish VBN 37231 1280 35 than than IN 37231 1280 36 another another DT 37231 1280 37 , , , 37231 1280 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1280 39 must must MD 37231 1280 40 hold hold VB 37231 1280 41 to to IN 37231 1280 42 that that DT 37231 1280 43 which which WDT 37231 1280 44 rests rest VBZ 37231 1280 45 upon upon IN 37231 1280 46 the the DT 37231 1280 47 more more RBR 37231 1280 48 certain certain JJ 37231 1280 49 basis basis NN 37231 1280 50 . . . 37231 1281 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1281 2 belief belief NN 37231 1281 3 in in IN 37231 1281 4 the the DT 37231 1281 5 invariability invariability NN 37231 1281 6 of of IN 37231 1281 7 the the DT 37231 1281 8 order order NN 37231 1281 9 of of IN 37231 1281 10 nature nature NN 37231 1281 11 , , , 37231 1281 12 therefore therefore RB 37231 1281 13 , , , 37231 1281 14 being be VBG 37231 1281 15 based base VBN 37231 1281 16 upon upon IN 37231 1281 17 more more JJR 37231 1281 18 certain certain JJ 37231 1281 19 grounds ground NNS 37231 1281 20 than than IN 37231 1281 21 any any DT 37231 1281 22 other other JJ 37231 1281 23 human human JJ 37231 1281 24 opinion opinion NN 37231 1281 25 , , , 37231 1281 26 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1281 27 must must MD 37231 1281 28 of of IN 37231 1281 29 necessity necessity NN 37231 1281 30 refuse refuse VBP 37231 1281 31 credence credence NN 37231 1281 32 to to IN 37231 1281 33 a a DT 37231 1281 34 statement statement NN 37231 1281 35 supported support VBN 37231 1281 36 by by IN 37231 1281 37 infinitely infinitely RB 37231 1281 38 less less RBR 37231 1281 39 complete complete JJ 37231 1281 40 testimony testimony NN 37231 1281 41 , , , 37231 1281 42 and and CC 37231 1281 43 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 1281 44 by by IN 37231 1281 45 universal universal JJ 37231 1281 46 experience experience NN 37231 1281 47 , , , 37231 1281 48 that that DT 37231 1281 49 phenomena phenomena NNP 37231 1281 50 subversive subversive JJ 37231 1281 51 of of IN 37231 1281 52 that that DT 37231 1281 53 order order NN 37231 1281 54 occurred occur VBD 37231 1281 55 many many JJ 37231 1281 56 years year NNS 37231 1281 57 ago ago RB 37231 1281 58 , , , 37231 1281 59 or or CC 37231 1281 60 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1281 61 must must MD 37231 1281 62 cease cease VB 37231 1281 63 to to TO 37231 1281 64 believe believe VB 37231 1281 65 anything anything NN 37231 1281 66 at at RB 37231 1281 67 all all RB 37231 1281 68 . . . 37231 1282 1 If if IN 37231 1282 2 belief belief NN 37231 1282 3 based base VBN 37231 1282 4 upon upon IN 37231 1282 5 unvarying unvarye VBG 37231 1282 6 experience experience NN 37231 1282 7 be be VB 37231 1282 8 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1282 9 , , , 37231 1282 10 how how WRB 37231 1282 11 much much RB 37231 1282 12 more more RBR 37231 1282 13 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1282 14 must must MD 37231 1282 15 belief belief NN 37231 1282 16 be be VB 37231 1282 17 which which WDT 37231 1282 18 is be VBZ 37231 1282 19 opposed opposed JJ 37231 1282 20 to to IN 37231 1282 21 that that DT 37231 1282 22 experience experience NN 37231 1282 23 . . . 37231 1283 1 According accord VBG 37231 1283 2 to to IN 37231 1283 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1283 4 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1283 5 , , , 37231 1283 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1283 7 is be VBZ 37231 1283 8 quite quite RB 37231 1283 9 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1283 10 to to TO 37231 1283 11 believe believe VB 37231 1283 12 that that IN 37231 1283 13 a a DT 37231 1283 14 stone stone NN 37231 1283 15 dropped drop VBD 37231 1283 16 from from IN 37231 1283 17 the the DT 37231 1283 18 hand hand NN 37231 1283 19 , , , 37231 1283 20 for for IN 37231 1283 21 instance instance NN 37231 1283 22 , , , 37231 1283 23 will will MD 37231 1283 24 fall fall VB 37231 1283 25 to to IN 37231 1283 26 the the DT 37231 1283 27 ground ground NN 37231 1283 28 . . . 37231 1284 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1284 2 is be VBZ 37231 1284 3 true true JJ 37231 1284 4 that that IN 37231 1284 5 all all PDT 37231 1284 6 the the DT 37231 1284 7 stones stone NNS 37231 1284 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1284 9 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1284 10 have have VBP 37231 1284 11 ever ever RB 37231 1284 12 dropped drop VBN 37231 1284 13 , , , 37231 1284 14 or or CC 37231 1284 15 seen see VBN 37231 1284 16 dropped drop VBN 37231 1284 17 , , , 37231 1284 18 have have VBP 37231 1284 19 so so RB 37231 1284 20 fallen fall VBN 37231 1284 21 , , , 37231 1284 22 and and CC 37231 1284 23 equally equally RB 37231 1284 24 true true JJ 37231 1284 25 that that IN 37231 1284 26 all all DT 37231 1284 27 stones stone NNS 37231 1284 28 so so RB 37231 1284 29 dropped drop VBD 37231 1284 30 as as RB 37231 1284 31 far far RB 37231 1284 32 back back RB 37231 1284 33 as as IN 37231 1284 34 historic historic JJ 37231 1284 35 records record NNS 37231 1284 36 , , , 37231 1284 37 and and CC 37231 1284 38 those those DT 37231 1284 39 still still RB 37231 1284 40 more more RBR 37231 1284 41 authentic authentic JJ 37231 1284 42 and and CC 37231 1284 43 ancient ancient JJ 37231 1284 44 records record NNS 37231 1284 45 of of IN 37231 1284 46 earth earth NN 37231 1284 47 's 's POS 37231 1284 48 crust crust NN 37231 1284 49 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1284 50 go go VBP 37231 1284 51 , , , 37231 1284 52 have have VBP 37231 1284 53 done do VBN 37231 1284 54 the the DT 37231 1284 55 same same JJ 37231 1284 56 , , , 37231 1284 57 but but CC 37231 1284 58 that that DT 37231 1284 59 does do VBZ 37231 1284 60 not not RB 37231 1284 61 justify justify VB 37231 1284 62 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1284 63 belief belief NN 37231 1284 64 , , , 37231 1284 65 upon upon IN 37231 1284 66 any any DT 37231 1284 67 grounds ground NNS 37231 1284 68 of of IN 37231 1284 69 reason reason NN 37231 1284 70 , , , 37231 1284 71 that that IN 37231 1284 72 the the DT 37231 1284 73 next next JJ 37231 1284 74 stone stone NN 37231 1284 75 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1284 76 drop drop VBP 37231 1284 77 will will MD 37231 1284 78 do do VB 37231 1284 79 so so RB 37231 1284 80 . . . 37231 1285 1 If if IN 37231 1285 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1285 3 be be VBP 37231 1285 4 told tell VBN 37231 1285 5 , , , 37231 1285 6 however however RB 37231 1285 7 , , , 37231 1285 8 that that IN 37231 1285 9 upon upon IN 37231 1285 10 one one CD 37231 1285 11 occasion occasion NN 37231 1285 12 a a DT 37231 1285 13 stone stone NN 37231 1285 14 so so RB 37231 1285 15 dropped drop VBD 37231 1285 16 , , , 37231 1285 17 instead instead RB 37231 1285 18 of of IN 37231 1285 19 falling fall VBG 37231 1285 20 to to IN 37231 1285 21 the the DT 37231 1285 22 ground ground NN 37231 1285 23 , , , 37231 1285 24 rose rise VBD 37231 1285 25 { { -LRB- 37231 1285 26 59 59 CD 37231 1285 27 } } -RRB- 37231 1285 28 up up RB 37231 1285 29 into into IN 37231 1285 30 the the DT 37231 1285 31 air air NN 37231 1285 32 and and CC 37231 1285 33 continued continue VBD 37231 1285 34 there there RB 37231 1285 35 , , , 37231 1285 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1285 37 have have VBP 37231 1285 38 only only RB 37231 1285 39 two two CD 37231 1285 40 courses course NNS 37231 1285 41 open open JJ 37231 1285 42 to to IN 37231 1285 43 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1285 44 : : : 37231 1285 45 either either CC 37231 1285 46 to to TO 37231 1285 47 disbelieve disbelieve VB 37231 1285 48 the the DT 37231 1285 49 fact fact NN 37231 1285 50 , , , 37231 1285 51 and and CC 37231 1285 52 attribute attribute VB 37231 1285 53 the the DT 37231 1285 54 statement statement NN 37231 1285 55 to to IN 37231 1285 56 error error NN 37231 1285 57 of of IN 37231 1285 58 observation observation NN 37231 1285 59 , , , 37231 1285 60 or or CC 37231 1285 61 to to TO 37231 1285 62 reduce reduce VB 37231 1285 63 the the DT 37231 1285 64 past past NN 37231 1285 65 to to IN 37231 1285 66 a a DT 37231 1285 67 mere mere JJ 37231 1285 68 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 37231 1285 69 picture picture NN 37231 1285 70 , , , 37231 1285 71 and and CC 37231 1285 72 the the DT 37231 1285 73 mind mind NN 37231 1285 74 to to IN 37231 1285 75 a a DT 37231 1285 76 blank blank JJ 37231 1285 77 page page NN 37231 1285 78 equally equally RB 37231 1285 79 devoid devoid JJ 37231 1285 80 of of IN 37231 1285 81 all all DT 37231 1285 82 belief belief NN 37231 1285 83 and and CC 37231 1285 84 of of IN 37231 1285 85 all all DT 37231 1285 86 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 1285 87 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1285 88 . . . 37231 1286 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1286 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1286 3 's 's POS 37231 1286 4 argument argument NN 37231 1286 5 , , , 37231 1286 6 however however RB 37231 1286 7 , , , 37231 1286 8 is be VBZ 37231 1286 9 fatal fatal JJ 37231 1286 10 to to IN 37231 1286 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1286 12 own own JJ 37231 1286 13 cause cause NN 37231 1286 14 . . . 37231 1287 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1287 2 is be VBZ 37231 1287 3 admitted admit VBN 37231 1287 4 that that IN 37231 1287 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1287 6 , , , 37231 1287 7 " " '' 37231 1287 8 or or CC 37231 1287 9 visible visible JJ 37231 1287 10 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1287 11 of of IN 37231 1287 12 the the DT 37231 1287 13 order order NN 37231 1287 14 of of IN 37231 1287 15 nature,"(1 nature,"(1 NNP 37231 1287 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1287 17 can can MD 37231 1287 18 not not RB 37231 1287 19 have have VB 37231 1287 20 any any DT 37231 1287 21 evidential evidential JJ 37231 1287 22 force force NN 37231 1287 23 unless unless IN 37231 1287 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1287 25 be be VBP 37231 1287 26 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1287 27 , , , 37231 1287 28 and and CC 37231 1287 29 out out IN 37231 1287 30 of of IN 37231 1287 31 the the DT 37231 1287 32 natural natural JJ 37231 1287 33 sequence sequence NN 37231 1287 34 of of IN 37231 1287 35 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 1287 36 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1287 37 . . . 37231 1288 1 Now now RB 37231 1288 2 , , , 37231 1288 3 unless unless IN 37231 1288 4 there there EX 37231 1288 5 be be VB 37231 1288 6 an an DT 37231 1288 7 actual actual JJ 37231 1288 8 order order NN 37231 1288 9 of of IN 37231 1288 10 nature nature NN 37231 1288 11 , , , 37231 1288 12 how how WRB 37231 1288 13 can can MD 37231 1288 14 there there EX 37231 1288 15 be be VB 37231 1288 16 any any DT 37231 1288 17 exception exception NN 37231 1288 18 to to IN 37231 1288 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1288 20 ? ? . 37231 1289 1 If if IN 37231 1289 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1289 3 belief belief NN 37231 1289 4 in in IN 37231 1289 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1289 6 be be VB 37231 1289 7 not not RB 37231 1289 8 based base VBN 37231 1289 9 upon upon IN 37231 1289 10 any any DT 37231 1289 11 ground ground NN 37231 1289 12 of of IN 37231 1289 13 reason,--as reason,--as NNP 37231 1289 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1289 15 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1289 16 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 1289 17 , , , 37231 1289 18 in in IN 37231 1289 19 order order NN 37231 1289 20 to to TO 37231 1289 21 assert assert VB 37231 1289 22 that that IN 37231 1289 23 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1289 24 or or CC 37231 1289 25 visible visible JJ 37231 1289 26 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1289 27 of of IN 37231 1289 28 that that DT 37231 1289 29 order order NN 37231 1289 30 are be VBP 37231 1289 31 not not RB 37231 1289 32 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1289 33 to to IN 37231 1289 34 reason,--how reason,--how NNP 37231 1289 35 can can MD 37231 1289 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1289 37 be be VB 37231 1289 38 asserted assert VBN 37231 1289 39 that that IN 37231 1289 40 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1289 41 are be VBP 37231 1289 42 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1289 43 ? ? . 37231 1290 1 If if IN 37231 1290 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1290 3 have have VBP 37231 1290 4 no no DT 37231 1290 5 rational rational JJ 37231 1290 6 ground ground NN 37231 1290 7 for for IN 37231 1290 8 believing believe VBG 37231 1290 9 that that IN 37231 1290 10 the the DT 37231 1290 11 future future NN 37231 1290 12 will will MD 37231 1290 13 be be VB 37231 1290 14 like like IN 37231 1290 15 the the DT 37231 1290 16 past past NN 37231 1290 17 , , , 37231 1290 18 what what WDT 37231 1290 19 rational rational JJ 37231 1290 20 ground ground NN 37231 1290 21 can can MD 37231 1290 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1290 23 have have VB 37231 1290 24 for for IN 37231 1290 25 thinking think VBG 37231 1290 26 that that IN 37231 1290 27 anything anything NN 37231 1290 28 which which WDT 37231 1290 29 happens happen VBZ 37231 1290 30 is be VBZ 37231 1290 31 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 1290 32 , , , 37231 1290 33 and and CC 37231 1290 34 out out IN 37231 1290 35 of of IN 37231 1290 36 the the DT 37231 1290 37 common common JJ 37231 1290 38 course course NN 37231 1290 39 of of IN 37231 1290 40 nature nature NN 37231 1290 41 ? ? . 37231 1291 1 Because because IN 37231 1291 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1291 3 has have VBZ 37231 1291 4 not not RB 37231 1291 5 happened happen VBN 37231 1291 6 before before RB 37231 1291 7 ? ? . 37231 1292 1 That that DT 37231 1292 2 is be VBZ 37231 1292 3 no no DT 37231 1292 4 reason reason NN 37231 1292 5 whatever whatever RB 37231 1292 6 ; ; : 37231 1292 7 because because IN 37231 1292 8 the the DT 37231 1292 9 fact fact NN 37231 1292 10 that that IN 37231 1292 11 a a DT 37231 1292 12 thing thing NN 37231 1292 13 has have VBZ 37231 1292 14 happened happen VBN 37231 1292 15 ten ten CD 37231 1292 16 millions million NNS 37231 1292 17 of of IN 37231 1292 18 times time NNS 37231 1292 19 is be VBZ 37231 1292 20 no no DT 37231 1292 21 rational rational JJ 37231 1292 22 justification justification NN 37231 1292 23 of of IN 37231 1292 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1292 25 expectation expectation NN 37231 1292 26 that that IN 37231 1292 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1292 28 will will MD 37231 1292 29 happen happen VB 37231 1292 30 again again RB 37231 1292 31 . . . 37231 1293 1 If if IN 37231 1293 2 the the DT 37231 1293 3 reverse reverse NN 37231 1293 4 of of IN 37231 1293 5 that that DT 37231 1293 6 which which WDT 37231 1293 7 had have VBD 37231 1293 8 happened happen VBN 37231 1293 9 previously previously RB 37231 1293 10 took take VBD 37231 1293 11 place place NN 37231 1293 12 on on IN 37231 1293 13 the the DT 37231 1293 14 ten ten CD 37231 1293 15 million million CD 37231 1293 16 and and CC 37231 1293 17 first first JJ 37231 1293 18 time time NN 37231 1293 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1293 20 should should MD 37231 1293 21 have have VB 37231 1293 22 no no DT 37231 1293 23 rational rational JJ 37231 1293 24 ground ground NN 37231 1293 25 for for IN 37231 1293 26 surprise surprise NN 37231 1293 27 , , , 37231 1293 28 and and CC 37231 1293 29 no no DT 37231 1293 30 reason reason NN 37231 1293 31 for for IN 37231 1293 32 affirming affirming NN 37231 1293 33 that that IN 37231 1293 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1293 35 did do VBD 37231 1293 36 not not RB 37231 1293 37 occur occur VB 37231 1293 38 in in IN 37231 1293 39 the the DT 37231 1293 40 most most RBS 37231 1293 41 natural natural JJ 37231 1293 42 manner manner NN 37231 1293 43 . . . 37231 1294 1 Because because IN 37231 1294 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1294 3 can can MD 37231 1294 4 not not RB 37231 1294 5 explain explain VB 37231 1294 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1294 7 cause cause NN 37231 1294 8 ? ? . 37231 1295 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1295 2 can can MD 37231 1295 3 not not RB 37231 1295 4 explain explain VB 37231 1295 5 the the DT 37231 1295 6 cause cause NN 37231 1295 7 of of IN 37231 1295 8 anything anything NN 37231 1295 9 . . . 37231 1296 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1296 2 belief belief NN 37231 1296 3 that that IN 37231 1296 4 there there EX 37231 1296 5 is be VBZ 37231 1296 6 any any DT 37231 1296 7 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1296 8 cause cause NN 37231 1296 9 is be VBZ 37231 1296 10 a a DT 37231 1296 11 mere mere JJ 37231 1296 12 unintelligent unintelligent JJ 37231 1296 13 impulse impulse NN 37231 1296 14 . . . 37231 1297 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1297 2 can can MD 37231 1297 3 only only RB 37231 1297 4 say say VB 37231 1297 5 that that IN 37231 1297 6 there there EX 37231 1297 7 is be VBZ 37231 1297 8 a a DT 37231 1297 9 cause cause NN 37231 1297 10 { { -LRB- 37231 1297 11 60 60 CD 37231 1297 12 } } -RRB- 37231 1297 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1297 14 to to TO 37231 1297 15 produce produce VB 37231 1297 16 an an DT 37231 1297 17 isolated isolated JJ 37231 1297 18 effect effect NN 37231 1297 19 , , , 37231 1297 20 but but CC 37231 1297 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1297 22 do do VBP 37231 1297 23 not not RB 37231 1297 24 know know VB 37231 1297 25 the the DT 37231 1297 26 nature nature NN 37231 1297 27 of of IN 37231 1297 28 that that DT 37231 1297 29 cause cause NN 37231 1297 30 , , , 37231 1297 31 and and CC 37231 1297 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1297 33 is be VBZ 37231 1297 34 a a DT 37231 1297 35 mere mere JJ 37231 1297 36 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1297 37 instinct instinct NN 37231 1297 38 to to TO 37231 1297 39 suppose suppose VB 37231 1297 40 that that IN 37231 1297 41 any any DT 37231 1297 42 cause cause NN 37231 1297 43 produces produce VBZ 37231 1297 44 continuous continuous JJ 37231 1297 45 effects effect NNS 37231 1297 46 , , , 37231 1297 47 or or CC 37231 1297 48 is be VBZ 37231 1297 49 more more JJR 37231 1297 50 than than IN 37231 1297 51 momentary momentary JJ 37231 1297 52 . . . 37231 1298 1 A a DT 37231 1298 2 miracle miracle NN 37231 1298 3 , , , 37231 1298 4 consequently consequently RB 37231 1298 5 , , , 37231 1298 6 becomes become VBZ 37231 1298 7 a a DT 37231 1298 8 mere mere JJ 37231 1298 9 isolated isolate VBN 37231 1298 10 effect effect NN 37231 1298 11 from from IN 37231 1298 12 an an DT 37231 1298 13 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1298 14 cause cause NN 37231 1298 15 , , , 37231 1298 16 in in IN 37231 1298 17 the the DT 37231 1298 18 midst midst NN 37231 1298 19 of of IN 37231 1298 20 other other JJ 37231 1298 21 merely merely RB 37231 1298 22 isolated isolate VBN 37231 1298 23 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1298 24 from from IN 37231 1298 25 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1298 26 causes cause NNS 37231 1298 27 , , , 37231 1298 28 and and CC 37231 1298 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1298 30 is be VBZ 37231 1298 31 as as RB 37231 1298 32 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1298 33 to to TO 37231 1298 34 wonder wonder VB 37231 1298 35 at at IN 37231 1298 36 the the DT 37231 1298 37 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1298 38 of of IN 37231 1298 39 what what WP 37231 1298 40 is be VBZ 37231 1298 41 new new JJ 37231 1298 42 , , , 37231 1298 43 as as IN 37231 1298 44 to to TO 37231 1298 45 expect expect VB 37231 1298 46 the the DT 37231 1298 47 recurrence recurrence NN 37231 1298 48 of of IN 37231 1298 49 what what WP 37231 1298 50 is be VBZ 37231 1298 51 old old JJ 37231 1298 52 . . . 37231 1299 1 In in IN 37231 1299 2 fact fact NN 37231 1299 3 , , , 37231 1299 4 an an DT 37231 1299 5 order order NN 37231 1299 6 of of IN 37231 1299 7 nature nature NN 37231 1299 8 is be VBZ 37231 1299 9 at at IN 37231 1299 10 once once RB 37231 1299 11 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1299 12 , , , 37231 1299 13 and and CC 37231 1299 14 fatal fatal JJ 37231 1299 15 , , , 37231 1299 16 to to IN 37231 1299 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1299 18 . . . 37231 1300 1 If if IN 37231 1300 2 there there EX 37231 1300 3 be be VB 37231 1300 4 no no DT 37231 1300 5 order order NN 37231 1300 6 of of IN 37231 1300 7 nature nature NN 37231 1300 8 , , , 37231 1300 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1300 10 can can MD 37231 1300 11 not not RB 37231 1300 12 be be VB 37231 1300 13 considered consider VBN 37231 1300 14 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1300 15 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1300 16 , , , 37231 1300 17 and and CC 37231 1300 18 have have VBP 37231 1300 19 no no DT 37231 1300 20 evidential evidential JJ 37231 1300 21 value value NN 37231 1300 22 ; ; : 37231 1300 23 if if IN 37231 1300 24 there there EX 37231 1300 25 be be VB 37231 1300 26 an an DT 37231 1300 27 order order NN 37231 1300 28 of of IN 37231 1300 29 nature nature NN 37231 1300 30 , , , 37231 1300 31 the the DT 37231 1300 32 evidence evidence NN 37231 1300 33 for for IN 37231 1300 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1300 35 immutability immutability NN 37231 1300 36 must must MD 37231 1300 37 consequently consequently RB 37231 1300 38 exceed exceed VB 37231 1300 39 the the DT 37231 1300 40 evidence evidence NN 37231 1300 41 for for IN 37231 1300 42 these these DT 37231 1300 43 isolated isolate VBN 37231 1300 44 deviations deviation NNS 37231 1300 45 from from IN 37231 1300 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1300 47 . . . 37231 1301 1 If if IN 37231 1301 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1301 3 are be VBP 37231 1301 4 unable unable JJ 37231 1301 5 rationally rationally RB 37231 1301 6 to to TO 37231 1301 7 form form VB 37231 1301 8 expectations expectation NNS 37231 1301 9 of of IN 37231 1301 10 the the DT 37231 1301 11 future future NN 37231 1301 12 from from IN 37231 1301 13 unvarying unvarye VBG 37231 1301 14 experience experience NN 37231 1301 15 in in IN 37231 1301 16 the the DT 37231 1301 17 past past NN 37231 1301 18 , , , 37231 1301 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1301 20 is be VBZ 37231 1301 21 still still RB 37231 1301 22 more more RBR 37231 1301 23 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1301 24 to to TO 37231 1301 25 call call VB 37231 1301 26 that that DT 37231 1301 27 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1301 28 which which WDT 37231 1301 29 is be VBZ 37231 1301 30 merely merely RB 37231 1301 31 different different JJ 37231 1301 32 from from IN 37231 1301 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1301 34 past past JJ 37231 1301 35 experience experience NN 37231 1301 36 . . . 37231 1302 1 Take take VB 37231 1302 2 , , , 37231 1302 3 for for IN 37231 1302 4 instance instance NN 37231 1302 5 , , , 37231 1302 6 the the DT 37231 1302 7 case case NN 37231 1302 8 of of IN 37231 1302 9 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1302 10 exemption exemption NN 37231 1302 11 from from IN 37231 1302 12 the the DT 37231 1302 13 action action NN 37231 1302 14 of of IN 37231 1302 15 the the DT 37231 1302 16 law law NN 37231 1302 17 of of IN 37231 1302 18 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1302 19 , , , 37231 1302 20 which which WDT 37231 1302 21 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1302 22 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1302 23 calls call VBZ 37231 1302 24 " " `` 37231 1302 25 a a DT 37231 1302 26 lost lose VBN 37231 1302 27 prerogative prerogative NN 37231 1302 28 of of IN 37231 1302 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1302 30 race:"(1 race:"(1 NN 37231 1302 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1302 32 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1302 33 can can MD 37231 1302 34 not not RB 37231 1302 35 rationally rationally RB 37231 1302 36 affirm affirm VB 37231 1302 37 that that IN 37231 1302 38 next next JJ 37231 1302 39 week week NN 37231 1302 40 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1302 41 may may MD 37231 1302 42 not not RB 37231 1302 43 be be VB 37231 1302 44 able able JJ 37231 1302 45 to to TO 37231 1302 46 walk walk VB 37231 1302 47 on on IN 37231 1302 48 the the DT 37231 1302 49 sea sea NN 37231 1302 50 , , , 37231 1302 51 or or CC 37231 1302 52 ascend ascend VBP 37231 1302 53 bodily bodily RB 37231 1302 54 into into IN 37231 1302 55 the the DT 37231 1302 56 air air NN 37231 1302 57 . . . 37231 1303 1 To to TO 37231 1303 2 deny deny VB 37231 1303 3 this this DT 37231 1303 4 because because IN 37231 1303 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1303 6 have have VBP 37231 1303 7 not not RB 37231 1303 8 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 1303 9 been be VBN 37231 1303 10 able able JJ 37231 1303 11 to to TO 37231 1303 12 do do VB 37231 1303 13 so so RB 37231 1303 14 is be VBZ 37231 1303 15 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 1303 16 ; ; : 37231 1303 17 for for IN 37231 1303 18 , , , 37231 1303 19 as as IN 37231 1303 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1303 21 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1303 22 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 1303 23 , , , 37231 1303 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1303 25 is be VBZ 37231 1303 26 a a DT 37231 1303 27 mere mere JJ 37231 1303 28 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1303 29 impulse impulse NN 37231 1303 30 which which WDT 37231 1303 31 expects expect VBZ 37231 1303 32 that that IN 37231 1303 33 which which WDT 37231 1303 34 has have VBZ 37231 1303 35 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 1303 36 happened happen VBN 37231 1303 37 , , , 37231 1303 38 when when WRB 37231 1303 39 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1303 40 have have VBP 37231 1303 41 made make VBN 37231 1303 42 such such JJ 37231 1303 43 attempts attempt NNS 37231 1303 44 , , , 37231 1303 45 to to TO 37231 1303 46 happen happen VB 37231 1303 47 again again RB 37231 1303 48 next next JJ 37231 1303 49 week week NN 37231 1303 50 . . . 37231 1304 1 If if IN 37231 1304 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1304 3 can can MD 37231 1304 4 not not RB 37231 1304 5 rationally rationally RB 37231 1304 6 deny deny VB 37231 1304 7 the the DT 37231 1304 8 possibility possibility NN 37231 1304 9 , , , 37231 1304 10 however however RB 37231 1304 11 , , , 37231 1304 12 that that IN 37231 1304 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1304 14 may may MD 37231 1304 15 be be VB 37231 1304 16 able able JJ 37231 1304 17 at at IN 37231 1304 18 some some DT 37231 1304 19 future future JJ 37231 1304 20 time time NN 37231 1304 21 to to TO 37231 1304 22 walk walk VB 37231 1304 23 on on IN 37231 1304 24 the the DT 37231 1304 25 sea sea NN 37231 1304 26 or or CC 37231 1304 27 ascend ascend VB 37231 1304 28 into into IN 37231 1304 29 the the DT 37231 1304 30 air air NN 37231 1304 31 , , , 37231 1304 32 the the DT 37231 1304 33 statement statement NN 37231 1304 34 that that IN 37231 1304 35 these these DT 37231 1304 36 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1304 37 have have VBP 37231 1304 38 already already RB 37231 1304 39 occurred occur VBN 37231 1304 40 loses lose VBZ 37231 1304 41 all all PDT 37231 1304 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1304 43 force force NN 37231 1304 44 , , , 37231 1304 45 and and CC 37231 1304 46 such such JJ 37231 1304 47 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1304 48 { { -LRB- 37231 1304 49 61 61 CD 37231 1304 50 } } -RRB- 37231 1304 51 cease cease NN 37231 1304 52 to to TO 37231 1304 53 be be VB 37231 1304 54 in in IN 37231 1304 55 any any DT 37231 1304 56 way way NN 37231 1304 57 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1304 58 . . . 37231 1305 1 If if IN 37231 1305 2 , , , 37231 1305 3 on on IN 37231 1305 4 the the DT 37231 1305 5 other other JJ 37231 1305 6 hand hand NN 37231 1305 7 , , , 37231 1305 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1305 9 would would MD 37231 1305 10 be be VB 37231 1305 11 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1305 12 to to TO 37231 1305 13 affirm affirm VB 37231 1305 14 that that IN 37231 1305 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1305 16 may may MD 37231 1305 17 next next JJ 37231 1305 18 week week NN 37231 1305 19 become become VB 37231 1305 20 exempt exempt JJ 37231 1305 21 from from IN 37231 1305 22 the the DT 37231 1305 23 operation operation NN 37231 1305 24 of of IN 37231 1305 25 the the DT 37231 1305 26 law law NN 37231 1305 27 of of IN 37231 1305 28 gravitation gravitation NN 37231 1305 29 , , , 37231 1305 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1305 31 can can MD 37231 1305 32 only only RB 37231 1305 33 be be VB 37231 1305 34 so so RB 37231 1305 35 by by IN 37231 1305 36 the the DT 37231 1305 37 admission admission NN 37231 1305 38 that that IN 37231 1305 39 unvarying unvarye VBG 37231 1305 40 experience experience NN 37231 1305 41 forbids forbid VBZ 37231 1305 42 the the DT 37231 1305 43 entertainment entertainment NN 37231 1305 44 of of IN 37231 1305 45 such such PDT 37231 1305 46 a a DT 37231 1305 47 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1305 48 , , , 37231 1305 49 and and CC 37231 1305 50 in in IN 37231 1305 51 that that DT 37231 1305 52 case case NN 37231 1305 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1305 54 equally equally RB 37231 1305 55 forbids forbid VBZ 37231 1305 56 belief belief NN 37231 1305 57 in in IN 37231 1305 58 the the DT 37231 1305 59 statement statement NN 37231 1305 60 that that IN 37231 1305 61 such such JJ 37231 1305 62 acts act NNS 37231 1305 63 ever ever RB 37231 1305 64 actually actually RB 37231 1305 65 took take VBD 37231 1305 66 place place NN 37231 1305 67 . . . 37231 1306 1 If if IN 37231 1306 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1306 3 deny deny VBP 37231 1306 4 the the DT 37231 1306 5 future future JJ 37231 1306 6 possibility possibility NN 37231 1306 7 on on IN 37231 1306 8 any any DT 37231 1306 9 ground ground NN 37231 1306 10 of of IN 37231 1306 11 reason reason NN 37231 1306 12 , , , 37231 1306 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1306 14 admit admit VBP 37231 1306 15 that that IN 37231 1306 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1306 17 have have VBP 37231 1306 18 grounds ground NNS 37231 1306 19 of of IN 37231 1306 20 reason reason NN 37231 1306 21 for for IN 37231 1306 22 expecting expect VBG 37231 1306 23 the the DT 37231 1306 24 future future NN 37231 1306 25 to to TO 37231 1306 26 be be VB 37231 1306 27 like like IN 37231 1306 28 the the DT 37231 1306 29 past past NN 37231 1306 30 , , , 37231 1306 31 and and CC 37231 1306 32 therefore therefore RB 37231 1306 33 contradict contradict VB 37231 1306 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1306 35 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1306 36 's 's POS 37231 1306 37 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1306 38 ; ; : 37231 1306 39 and and CC 37231 1306 40 if if IN 37231 1306 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1306 42 can can MD 37231 1306 43 not not RB 37231 1306 44 deny deny VB 37231 1306 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1306 46 upon upon IN 37231 1306 47 any any DT 37231 1306 48 ground ground NN 37231 1306 49 of of IN 37231 1306 50 reason reason NN 37231 1306 51 , , , 37231 1306 52 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1306 53 extinguish extinguish VBP 37231 1306 54 the the DT 37231 1306 55 claim claim NN 37231 1306 56 of of IN 37231 1306 57 such such JJ 37231 1306 58 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1306 59 in in IN 37231 1306 60 the the DT 37231 1306 61 past past NN 37231 1306 62 to to IN 37231 1306 63 any any DT 37231 1306 64 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1306 65 character character NN 37231 1306 66 . . . 37231 1307 1 Any any DT 37231 1307 2 argument argument NN 37231 1307 3 which which WDT 37231 1307 4 could could MD 37231 1307 5 destroy destroy VB 37231 1307 6 faith faith NN 37231 1307 7 in in IN 37231 1307 8 the the DT 37231 1307 9 order order NN 37231 1307 10 of of IN 37231 1307 11 nature nature NN 37231 1307 12 would would MD 37231 1307 13 be be VB 37231 1307 14 equally equally RB 37231 1307 15 destructive destructive JJ 37231 1307 16 to to IN 37231 1307 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1307 18 . . . 37231 1308 1 If if IN 37231 1308 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1308 3 have have VBP 37231 1308 4 no no DT 37231 1308 5 right right NN 37231 1308 6 to to TO 37231 1308 7 believe believe VB 37231 1308 8 in in IN 37231 1308 9 a a DT 37231 1308 10 rule rule NN 37231 1308 11 , , , 37231 1308 12 there there EX 37231 1308 13 can can MD 37231 1308 14 be be VB 37231 1308 15 no no DT 37231 1308 16 right right NN 37231 1308 17 to to TO 37231 1308 18 speak speak VB 37231 1308 19 of of IN 37231 1308 20 exceptions exception NNS 37231 1308 21 . . . 37231 1309 1 The the DT 37231 1309 2 result result NN 37231 1309 3 in in IN 37231 1309 4 any any DT 37231 1309 5 case case NN 37231 1309 6 is be VBZ 37231 1309 7 this this DT 37231 1309 8 , , , 37231 1309 9 that that IN 37231 1309 10 whether whether IN 37231 1309 11 the the DT 37231 1309 12 principle principle NN 37231 1309 13 of of IN 37231 1309 14 the the DT 37231 1309 15 order order NN 37231 1309 16 of of IN 37231 1309 17 nature nature NN 37231 1309 18 be be VB 37231 1309 19 established establish VBN 37231 1309 20 or or CC 37231 1309 21 refuted refute VBN 37231 1309 22 , , , 37231 1309 23 the the DT 37231 1309 24 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1309 25 pretensions pretension NNS 37231 1309 26 of of IN 37231 1309 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1309 28 are be VBP 37231 1309 29 disallowed disallow VBN 37231 1309 30 . . . 37231 1310 1 More More JJR 37231 1310 2 than than IN 37231 1310 3 this this DT 37231 1310 4 , , , 37231 1310 5 however however RB 37231 1310 6 , , , 37231 1310 7 must must MD 37231 1310 8 inevitably inevitably RB 37231 1310 9 be be VB 37231 1310 10 deduced deduce VBN 37231 1310 11 from from IN 37231 1310 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1310 13 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1310 14 's 's POS 37231 1310 15 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1310 16 . . . 37231 1311 1 In in IN 37231 1311 2 denying deny VBG 37231 1311 3 , , , 37231 1311 4 as as IN 37231 1311 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1311 6 does do VBZ 37231 1311 7 , , , 37231 1311 8 the the DT 37231 1311 9 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1311 10 of of IN 37231 1311 11 a a DT 37231 1311 12 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1311 13 cause cause NN 37231 1311 14 , , , 37231 1311 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1311 16 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1311 17 must must MD 37231 1311 18 equally equally RB 37231 1311 19 renounce renounce VB 37231 1311 20 , , , 37231 1311 21 as as IN 37231 1311 22 without without IN 37231 1311 23 foundation foundation NN 37231 1311 24 in in IN 37231 1311 25 reason reason NN 37231 1311 26 , , , 37231 1311 27 the the DT 37231 1311 28 assumption assumption NN 37231 1311 29 of of IN 37231 1311 30 a a DT 37231 1311 31 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1311 32 agent agent NN 37231 1311 33 working work VBG 37231 1311 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1311 35 . . . 37231 1312 1 Not not RB 37231 1312 2 only only RB 37231 1312 3 do do VBP 37231 1312 4 the the DT 37231 1312 5 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1312 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1312 7 , , , 37231 1312 8 in in IN 37231 1312 9 the the DT 37231 1312 10 complete complete JJ 37231 1312 11 isolation isolation NN 37231 1312 12 of of IN 37231 1312 13 all all DT 37231 1312 14 effects effect NNS 37231 1312 15 , , , 37231 1312 16 cease cease VB 37231 1312 17 to to TO 37231 1312 18 be be VB 37231 1312 19 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1312 20 or or CC 37231 1312 21 even even RB 37231 1312 22 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 1312 23 , , , 37231 1312 24 but but CC 37231 1312 25 as as IN 37231 1312 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1312 27 can can MD 37231 1312 28 not not RB 37231 1312 29 be be VB 37231 1312 30 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 1312 31 that that IN 37231 1312 32 there there EX 37231 1312 33 is be VBZ 37231 1312 34 any any DT 37231 1312 35 cause cause NN 37231 1312 36 of of IN 37231 1312 37 a a DT 37231 1312 38 nature nature NN 37231 1312 39 more more RBR 37231 1312 40 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1312 41 than than IN 37231 1312 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1312 43 existing exist VBG 37231 1312 44 or or CC 37231 1312 45 known know VBN 37231 1312 46 effects effect NNS 37231 1312 47 , , , 37231 1312 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1312 49 is be VBZ 37231 1312 50 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1312 51 that that IN 37231 1312 52 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1312 53 can can MD 37231 1312 54 not not RB 37231 1312 55 be be VB 37231 1312 56 traced trace VBN 37231 1312 57 to to IN 37231 1312 58 an an DT 37231 1312 59 eternal eternal JJ 37231 1312 60 Being being NN 37231 1312 61 of of IN 37231 1312 62 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1312 63 omnipotence omnipotence NN 37231 1312 64 . . . 37231 1313 1 If if IN 37231 1313 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1313 3 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1313 4 , , , 37231 1313 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 1313 6 , , , 37231 1313 7 be be VB 37231 1313 8 understood understand VBN 37231 1313 9 to to TO 37231 1313 10 adopt adopt VB 37231 1313 11 this this DT 37231 1313 12 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1313 13 as as IN 37231 1313 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1313 15 own own JJ 37231 1313 16 , , , 37231 1313 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1313 18 has have VBZ 37231 1313 19 involved involve VBN 37231 1313 20 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1313 21 , , , 37231 1313 22 in in IN 37231 1313 23 the the DT 37231 1313 24 { { -LRB- 37231 1313 25 62 62 CD 37231 1313 26 } } -RRB- 37231 1313 27 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1313 28 abandonment abandonment NN 37231 1313 29 both both DT 37231 1313 30 of of IN 37231 1313 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1313 32 as as IN 37231 1313 33 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1313 34 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1313 35 , , , 37231 1313 36 and and CC 37231 1313 37 of of IN 37231 1313 38 a a DT 37231 1313 39 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1313 40 and and CC 37231 1313 41 unlimited unlimited JJ 37231 1313 42 cause cause NN 37231 1313 43 of of IN 37231 1313 44 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1313 45 . . . 37231 1314 1 If if IN 37231 1314 2 , , , 37231 1314 3 on on IN 37231 1314 4 the the DT 37231 1314 5 other other JJ 37231 1314 6 hand hand NN 37231 1314 7 , , , 37231 1314 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1314 9 has have VBZ 37231 1314 10 merely merely RB 37231 1314 11 snatched snatch VBN 37231 1314 12 the the DT 37231 1314 13 sword sword NN 37231 1314 14 of of IN 37231 1314 15 an an DT 37231 1314 16 adversary adversary NN 37231 1314 17 to to TO 37231 1314 18 turn turn VB 37231 1314 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1314 20 against against IN 37231 1314 21 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1314 22 , , , 37231 1314 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1314 24 has have VBZ 37231 1314 25 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37231 1314 26 impaled impale VBN 37231 1314 27 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1314 28 upon upon IN 37231 1314 29 the the DT 37231 1314 30 borrowed borrow VBN 37231 1314 31 weapon weapon NN 37231 1314 32 . . . 37231 1315 1 2 2 LS 37231 1315 2 . . . 37231 1316 1 Throughout throughout IN 37231 1316 2 the the DT 37231 1316 3 whole whole NN 37231 1316 4 of of IN 37231 1316 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1316 6 argument argument NN 37231 1316 7 against against IN 37231 1316 8 the the DT 37231 1316 9 rationality rationality NN 37231 1316 10 of of IN 37231 1316 11 belief belief NN 37231 1316 12 in in IN 37231 1316 13 the the DT 37231 1316 14 order order NN 37231 1316 15 of of IN 37231 1316 16 nature nature NN 37231 1316 17 , , , 37231 1316 18 the the DT 37231 1316 19 rigorous rigorous JJ 37231 1316 20 precision precision NN 37231 1316 21 which which WDT 37231 1316 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1316 23 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1316 24 unrelentingly unrelentingly RB 37231 1316 25 demands demand VBZ 37231 1316 26 from from IN 37231 1316 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1316 28 antagonists antagonist NNS 37231 1316 29 is be VBZ 37231 1316 30 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 1316 31 . . . 37231 1317 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1317 2 are be VBP 37231 1317 3 not not RB 37231 1317 4 permitted permit VBN 37231 1317 5 to to TO 37231 1317 6 deviate deviate VB 37231 1317 7 by by IN 37231 1317 8 a a DT 37231 1317 9 hair hair NN 37231 1317 10 's 's POS 37231 1317 11 breadth breadth NN 37231 1317 12 from from IN 37231 1317 13 the the DT 37231 1317 14 line line NN 37231 1317 15 of of IN 37231 1317 16 strict strict JJ 37231 1317 17 logic logic NN 37231 1317 18 , , , 37231 1317 19 and and CC 37231 1317 20 the the DT 37231 1317 21 most most RBS 37231 1317 22 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1317 23 exactness exactness NN 37231 1317 24 of of IN 37231 1317 25 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 1317 26 is be VBZ 37231 1317 27 required require VBN 37231 1317 28 . . . 37231 1318 1 Anything anything NN 37231 1318 2 like like IN 37231 1318 3 an an DT 37231 1318 4 assumption assumption NN 37231 1318 5 or or CC 37231 1318 6 argument argument NN 37231 1318 7 from from IN 37231 1318 8 analogy analogy NN 37231 1318 9 is be VBZ 37231 1318 10 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1318 11 ; ; : 37231 1318 12 induction induction NN 37231 1318 13 is be VBZ 37231 1318 14 allowed allow VBN 37231 1318 15 to to TO 37231 1318 16 add add VB 37231 1318 17 no no DT 37231 1318 18 reason reason NN 37231 1318 19 to to TO 37231 1318 20 bare bare VB 37231 1318 21 and and CC 37231 1318 22 isolated isolated JJ 37231 1318 23 facts fact NNS 37231 1318 24 ; ; : 37231 1318 25 and and CC 37231 1318 26 the the DT 37231 1318 27 belief belief NN 37231 1318 28 that that IN 37231 1318 29 the the DT 37231 1318 30 sun sun NN 37231 1318 31 will will MD 37231 1318 32 rise rise VB 37231 1318 33 to to IN 37231 1318 34 - - HYPH 37231 1318 35 morrow morrow NN 37231 1318 36 morning morning NN 37231 1318 37 is be VBZ 37231 1318 38 , , , 37231 1318 39 with with IN 37231 1318 40 pitiless pitiless NN 37231 1318 41 severity severity NN 37231 1318 42 , , , 37231 1318 43 written write VBN 37231 1318 44 down down RP 37231 1318 45 as as IN 37231 1318 46 mere mere JJ 37231 1318 47 unintelligent unintelligent JJ 37231 1318 48 impulse impulse NN 37231 1318 49 . . . 37231 1319 1 Belief belief NN 37231 1319 2 in in IN 37231 1319 3 the the DT 37231 1319 4 return return NN 37231 1319 5 of of IN 37231 1319 6 day day NN 37231 1319 7 , , , 37231 1319 8 based base VBN 37231 1319 9 upon upon IN 37231 1319 10 the the DT 37231 1319 11 unvarying unvarying NN 37231 1319 12 experience experience NN 37231 1319 13 of of IN 37231 1319 14 all all DT 37231 1319 15 past past JJ 37231 1319 16 time time NN 37231 1319 17 , , , 37231 1319 18 is be VBZ 37231 1319 19 declared declare VBN 37231 1319 20 to to TO 37231 1319 21 be be VB 37231 1319 22 without without IN 37231 1319 23 any any DT 37231 1319 24 ground ground NN 37231 1319 25 of of IN 37231 1319 26 reason reason NN 37231 1319 27 . . . 37231 1320 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1320 2 find find VBP 37231 1320 3 anything anything NN 37231 1320 4 but but IN 37231 1320 5 fault fault NN 37231 1320 6 with with IN 37231 1320 7 strictness strictness NN 37231 1320 8 of of IN 37231 1320 9 argument argument NN 37231 1320 10 ; ; : 37231 1320 11 but but CC 37231 1320 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1320 13 is be VBZ 37231 1320 14 fair fair JJ 37231 1320 15 that that IN 37231 1320 16 equal equal JJ 37231 1320 17 precision precision NN 37231 1320 18 should should MD 37231 1320 19 be be VB 37231 1320 20 observed observe VBN 37231 1320 21 by by IN 37231 1320 22 those those DT 37231 1320 23 who who WP 37231 1320 24 assert assert VBP 37231 1320 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1320 26 , , , 37231 1320 27 and and CC 37231 1320 28 that that IN 37231 1320 29 assumption assumption NN 37231 1320 30 and and CC 37231 1320 31 inaccuracy inaccuracy NN 37231 1320 32 should should MD 37231 1320 33 be be VB 37231 1320 34 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1320 35 . . . 37231 1321 1 Hitherto Hitherto NNP 37231 1321 2 , , , 37231 1321 3 as as IN 37231 1321 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1321 5 have have VBP 37231 1321 6 frequently frequently RB 37231 1321 7 pointed point VBN 37231 1321 8 out out RP 37231 1321 9 , , , 37231 1321 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1321 11 have have VBP 37231 1321 12 met meet VBN 37231 1321 13 with with IN 37231 1321 14 very very RB 37231 1321 15 little little JJ 37231 1321 16 or or CC 37231 1321 17 nothing nothing NN 37231 1321 18 but but IN 37231 1321 19 assumption assumption NN 37231 1321 20 in in IN 37231 1321 21 support support NN 37231 1321 22 of of IN 37231 1321 23 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1321 24 ; ; : 37231 1321 25 but but CC 37231 1321 26 , , , 37231 1321 27 encouraged encourage VBN 37231 1321 28 by by IN 37231 1321 29 the the DT 37231 1321 30 inflexible inflexible JJ 37231 1321 31 spirit spirit NN 37231 1321 32 of of IN 37231 1321 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1321 34 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1321 35 's 's POS 37231 1321 36 attack attack NN 37231 1321 37 upon upon IN 37231 1321 38 the the DT 37231 1321 39 argument argument NN 37231 1321 40 from from IN 37231 1321 41 experience experience NN 37231 1321 42 , , , 37231 1321 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1321 44 may may MD 37231 1321 45 look look VB 37231 1321 46 for for IN 37231 1321 47 similar similar JJ 37231 1321 48 precision precision NN 37231 1321 49 from from IN 37231 1321 50 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1321 51 . . . 37231 1322 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1322 2 63 63 CD 37231 1322 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1322 4 Proceeding Proceeding NNP 37231 1322 5 , , , 37231 1322 6 however however RB 37231 1322 7 , , , 37231 1322 8 from from IN 37231 1322 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1322 10 argument argument NN 37231 1322 11 against against IN 37231 1322 12 the the DT 37231 1322 13 rationality rationality NN 37231 1322 14 of of IN 37231 1322 15 belief belief NN 37231 1322 16 in in IN 37231 1322 17 the the DT 37231 1322 18 order order NN 37231 1322 19 of of IN 37231 1322 20 nature nature NN 37231 1322 21 to to IN 37231 1322 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1322 23 more more RBR 37231 1322 24 direct direct JJ 37231 1322 25 argument argument NN 37231 1322 26 for for IN 37231 1322 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1322 28 , , , 37231 1322 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1322 30 are be VBP 37231 1322 31 astonished astonish VBN 37231 1322 32 to to TO 37231 1322 33 find find VB 37231 1322 34 a a DT 37231 1322 35 total total JJ 37231 1322 36 abandonment abandonment NN 37231 1322 37 of of IN 37231 1322 38 the the DT 37231 1322 39 rigorous rigorous JJ 37231 1322 40 exactness exactness NN 37231 1322 41 imposed impose VBN 37231 1322 42 upon upon IN 37231 1322 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1322 44 antagonists antagonist NNS 37231 1322 45 , , , 37231 1322 46 and and CC 37231 1322 47 a a DT 37231 1322 48 complete complete JJ 37231 1322 49 relapse relapse NN 37231 1322 50 into into IN 37231 1322 51 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1322 52 . . . 37231 1323 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1323 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1323 3 does do VBZ 37231 1323 4 not not RB 37231 1323 5 conceal conceal VB 37231 1323 6 the the DT 37231 1323 7 fact fact NN 37231 1323 8 . . . 37231 1324 1 " " `` 37231 1324 2 The the DT 37231 1324 3 peculiarity peculiarity NN 37231 1324 4 of of IN 37231 1324 5 the the DT 37231 1324 6 argument argument NN 37231 1324 7 of of IN 37231 1324 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1324 9 , , , 37231 1324 10 " " '' 37231 1324 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1324 12 frankly frankly RB 37231 1324 13 admits admit VBZ 37231 1324 14 , , , 37231 1324 15 " " `` 37231 1324 16 is be VBZ 37231 1324 17 , , , 37231 1324 18 that that IN 37231 1324 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1324 20 begins begin VBZ 37231 1324 21 and and CC 37231 1324 22 ends end VBZ 37231 1324 23 with with IN 37231 1324 24 an an DT 37231 1324 25 assumption assumption NN 37231 1324 26 ; ; : 37231 1324 27 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1324 28 mean mean VBP 37231 1324 29 relatively relatively RB 37231 1324 30 to to IN 37231 1324 31 that that DT 37231 1324 32 argument argument NN 37231 1324 33 . . . 37231 1325 1 " " `` 37231 1325 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1325 3 1 1 LS 37231 1325 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1325 5 Such such PDT 37231 1325 6 an an DT 37231 1325 7 argument argument NN 37231 1325 8 is be VBZ 37231 1325 9 no no DT 37231 1325 10 argument argument NN 37231 1325 11 at at RB 37231 1325 12 all all RB 37231 1325 13 ; ; : 37231 1325 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1325 15 is be VBZ 37231 1325 16 a a DT 37231 1325 17 mere mere JJ 37231 1325 18 _ _ NNP 37231 1325 19 petitio petitio NNP 37231 1325 20 principii principii NNP 37231 1325 21 _ _ NNP 37231 1325 22 , , , 37231 1325 23 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1325 24 of of IN 37231 1325 25 proving prove VBG 37231 1325 26 anything anything NN 37231 1325 27 . . . 37231 1326 1 The the DT 37231 1326 2 nature nature NN 37231 1326 3 of of IN 37231 1326 4 the the DT 37231 1326 5 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1326 6 obviously obviously RB 37231 1326 7 does do VBZ 37231 1326 8 not not RB 37231 1326 9 in in IN 37231 1326 10 the the DT 37231 1326 11 slightest slight JJS 37231 1326 12 degree degree NN 37231 1326 13 affect affect VBP 37231 1326 14 this this DT 37231 1326 15 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1326 16 . . . 37231 1327 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1327 2 is be VBZ 37231 1327 3 true true JJ 37231 1327 4 that that IN 37231 1327 5 the the DT 37231 1327 6 statement statement NN 37231 1327 7 of of IN 37231 1327 8 the the DT 37231 1327 9 particular particular JJ 37231 1327 10 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1327 11 may may MD 37231 1327 12 constitute constitute VB 37231 1327 13 an an DT 37231 1327 14 appeal appeal NN 37231 1327 15 to to IN 37231 1327 16 belief belief NN 37231 1327 17 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 1327 18 derived derive VBN 37231 1327 19 , , , 37231 1327 20 and and CC 37231 1327 21 evolve evolve VB 37231 1327 22 feelings feeling NNS 37231 1327 23 which which WDT 37231 1327 24 may may MD 37231 1327 25 render render VB 37231 1327 26 the the DT 37231 1327 27 calm calm JJ 37231 1327 28 exercise exercise NN 37231 1327 29 of of IN 37231 1327 30 judgment judgment NN 37231 1327 31 more more RBR 37231 1327 32 difficult difficult JJ 37231 1327 33 , , , 37231 1327 34 but but CC 37231 1327 35 the the DT 37231 1327 36 fact fact NN 37231 1327 37 remains remain VBZ 37231 1327 38 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1327 39 , , , 37231 1327 40 that that IN 37231 1327 41 an an DT 37231 1327 42 argument argument NN 37231 1327 43 which which WDT 37231 1327 44 " " `` 37231 1327 45 begins begin VBZ 37231 1327 46 and and CC 37231 1327 47 ends end VBZ 37231 1327 48 with with IN 37231 1327 49 an an DT 37231 1327 50 assumption assumption NN 37231 1327 51 " " `` 37231 1327 52 is be VBZ 37231 1327 53 totally totally RB 37231 1327 54 impotent impotent JJ 37231 1327 55 . . . 37231 1328 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1328 2 remains remain VBZ 37231 1328 3 an an DT 37231 1328 4 assumption assumption NN 37231 1328 5 , , , 37231 1328 6 and and CC 37231 1328 7 is be VBZ 37231 1328 8 not not RB 37231 1328 9 an an DT 37231 1328 10 argument argument NN 37231 1328 11 at at RB 37231 1328 12 all all RB 37231 1328 13 . . . 37231 1329 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1329 2 64 64 CD 37231 1329 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1329 4 Notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 37231 1329 5 this this DT 37231 1329 6 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37231 1329 7 and and CC 37231 1329 8 disqualifying disqualify VBG 37231 1329 9 " " `` 37231 1329 10 peculiarity peculiarity NN 37231 1329 11 " " '' 37231 1329 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1329 13 may may MD 37231 1329 14 examine examine VB 37231 1329 15 the the DT 37231 1329 16 argument argument NN 37231 1329 17 . . . 37231 1330 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1330 2 is be VBZ 37231 1330 3 as as IN 37231 1330 4 follows follow VBZ 37231 1330 5 : : : 37231 1330 6 " " `` 37231 1330 7 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1330 8 assume assume VBP 37231 1330 9 the the DT 37231 1330 10 existence existence NN 37231 1330 11 of of IN 37231 1330 12 a a DT 37231 1330 13 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1330 14 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1330 15 prior prior RB 37231 1330 16 to to IN 37231 1330 17 the the DT 37231 1330 18 proof proof NN 37231 1330 19 of of IN 37231 1330 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1330 21 in in IN 37231 1330 22 the the DT 37231 1330 23 religious religious JJ 37231 1330 24 sense sense NN 37231 1330 25 ; ; : 37231 1330 26 but but CC 37231 1330 27 with with IN 37231 1330 28 this this DT 37231 1330 29 assumption assumption NN 37231 1330 30 the the DT 37231 1330 31 question question NN 37231 1330 32 of of IN 37231 1330 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1330 34 is be VBZ 37231 1330 35 at at IN 37231 1330 36 an an DT 37231 1330 37 end end NN 37231 1330 38 ; ; : 37231 1330 39 because because IN 37231 1330 40 such such PDT 37231 1330 41 a a DT 37231 1330 42 Being being NN 37231 1330 43 has have VBZ 37231 1330 44 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 1330 45 the the DT 37231 1330 46 power power NN 37231 1330 47 to to TO 37231 1330 48 suspend suspend VB 37231 1330 49 those those DT 37231 1330 50 laws law NNS 37231 1330 51 of of IN 37231 1330 52 nature nature NN 37231 1330 53 which which WDT 37231 1330 54 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1330 55 has have VBZ 37231 1330 56 Himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1330 57 enacted enact VBN 37231 1330 58 . . . 37231 1331 1 " " `` 37231 1331 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1331 3 1 1 LS 37231 1331 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1331 5 The the DT 37231 1331 6 " " `` 37231 1331 7 question question NN 37231 1331 8 of of IN 37231 1331 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1331 10 , , , 37231 1331 11 " " '' 37231 1331 12 which which WDT 37231 1331 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1331 14 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1331 15 here here RB 37231 1331 16 asserts assert VBZ 37231 1331 17 to to TO 37231 1331 18 be be VB 37231 1331 19 at at IN 37231 1331 20 an an DT 37231 1331 21 end end NN 37231 1331 22 on on IN 37231 1331 23 the the DT 37231 1331 24 assumption assumption NN 37231 1331 25 of of IN 37231 1331 26 a a DT 37231 1331 27 " " `` 37231 1331 28 Personal personal JJ 37231 1331 29 Deity deity NN 37231 1331 30 , , , 37231 1331 31 " " '' 37231 1331 32 is be VBZ 37231 1331 33 of of IN 37231 1331 34 course course NN 37231 1331 35 merely merely RB 37231 1331 36 that that DT 37231 1331 37 of of IN 37231 1331 38 the the DT 37231 1331 39 _ _ NNP 37231 1331 40 possibility possibility NN 37231 1331 41 _ _ NNP 37231 1331 42 of of IN 37231 1331 43 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1331 44 ; ; : 37231 1331 45 but but CC 37231 1331 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1331 47 is be VBZ 37231 1331 48 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1331 49 that that IN 37231 1331 50 , , , 37231 1331 51 even even RB 37231 1331 52 with with IN 37231 1331 53 the the DT 37231 1331 54 precise precise JJ 37231 1331 55 definition definition NN 37231 1331 56 of of IN 37231 1331 57 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1331 58 which which WDT 37231 1331 59 is be VBZ 37231 1331 60 assumed assume VBN 37231 1331 61 , , , 37231 1331 62 instead instead RB 37231 1331 63 of of IN 37231 1331 64 the the DT 37231 1331 65 real real JJ 37231 1331 66 " " `` 37231 1331 67 question question NN 37231 1331 68 " " '' 37231 1331 69 being be VBG 37231 1331 70 at at IN 37231 1331 71 an an DT 37231 1331 72 end end NN 37231 1331 73 , , , 37231 1331 74 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1331 75 only only RB 37231 1331 76 commences commence VBZ 37231 1331 77 . . . 37231 1332 1 The the DT 37231 1332 2 power power NN 37231 1332 3 to to TO 37231 1332 4 suspend suspend VB 37231 1332 5 the the DT 37231 1332 6 laws law NNS 37231 1332 7 of of IN 37231 1332 8 nature nature NN 37231 1332 9 being be VBG 37231 1332 10 assumed assume VBN 37231 1332 11 , , , 37231 1332 12 the the DT 37231 1332 13 will will NN 37231 1332 14 to to TO 37231 1332 15 suspend suspend VB 37231 1332 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1332 17 has have VBZ 37231 1332 18 to to TO 37231 1332 19 be be VB 37231 1332 20 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 1332 21 , , , 37231 1332 22 and and CC 37231 1332 23 the the DT 37231 1332 24 actual actual JJ 37231 1332 25 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1332 26 of of IN 37231 1332 27 any any DT 37231 1332 28 such such JJ 37231 1332 29 suspension suspension NN 37231 1332 30 , , , 37231 1332 31 which which WDT 37231 1332 32 , , , 37231 1332 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1332 34 has have VBZ 37231 1332 35 already already RB 37231 1332 36 been be VBN 37231 1332 37 shown show VBN 37231 1332 38 , , , 37231 1332 39 is be VBZ 37231 1332 40 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1332 41 to to IN 37231 1332 42 reason reason NN 37231 1332 43 . . . 37231 1333 1 The the DT 37231 1333 2 subject subject NN 37231 1333 3 is be VBZ 37231 1333 4 , , , 37231 1333 5 moreover moreover RB 37231 1333 6 , , , 37231 1333 7 complicated complicate VBN 37231 1333 8 by by IN 37231 1333 9 the the DT 37231 1333 10 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1333 11 of of IN 37231 1333 12 Satanic Satanic NNP 37231 1333 13 as as RB 37231 1333 14 well well RB 37231 1333 15 as as IN 37231 1333 16 Divine divine JJ 37231 1333 17 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1333 18 of of IN 37231 1333 19 the the DT 37231 1333 20 order order NN 37231 1333 21 of of IN 37231 1333 22 nature nature NN 37231 1333 23 , , , 37231 1333 24 and and CC 37231 1333 25 by by IN 37231 1333 26 the the DT 37231 1333 27 necessity necessity NN 37231 1333 28 of of IN 37231 1333 29 assuming assume VBG 37231 1333 30 a a DT 37231 1333 31 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1333 32 Devil Devil NNP 37231 1333 33 as as RB 37231 1333 34 well well RB 37231 1333 35 as as IN 37231 1333 36 a a DT 37231 1333 37 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1333 38 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1333 39 , , , 37231 1333 40 and and CC 37231 1333 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1333 42 power power NN 37231 1333 43 to to TO 37231 1333 44 usurp usurp VB 37231 1333 45 that that DT 37231 1333 46 control control NN 37231 1333 47 over over IN 37231 1333 48 the the DT 37231 1333 49 laws law NNS 37231 1333 50 of of IN 37231 1333 51 nature nature NN 37231 1333 52 , , , 37231 1333 53 which which WDT 37231 1333 54 is be VBZ 37231 1333 55 assumed assume VBN 37231 1333 56 as as IN 37231 1333 57 the the DT 37231 1333 58 prerogative prerogative NN 37231 1333 59 of of IN 37231 1333 60 the the DT 37231 1333 61 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1333 62 , , , 37231 1333 63 and and CC 37231 1333 64 to to TO 37231 1333 65 suspend suspend VB 37231 1333 66 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1333 67 in in IN 37231 1333 68 direct direct JJ 37231 1333 69 opposition opposition NN 37231 1333 70 to to IN 37231 1333 71 God God NNP 37231 1333 72 . . . 37231 1334 1 The the DT 37231 1334 2 express express JJ 37231 1334 3 ascription ascription NN 37231 1334 4 of of IN 37231 1334 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1334 6 to to IN 37231 1334 7 the the DT 37231 1334 8 special special JJ 37231 1334 9 intervention intervention NN 37231 1334 10 of of IN 37231 1334 11 a a DT 37231 1334 12 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1334 13 God God NNP 37231 1334 14 is be VBZ 37231 1334 15 also also RB 37231 1334 16 , , , 37231 1334 17 as as IN 37231 1334 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1334 19 have have VBP 37231 1334 20 seen see VBN 37231 1334 21 , , , 37231 1334 22 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1334 23 by by IN 37231 1334 24 the the DT 37231 1334 25 Scriptural Scriptural NNP 37231 1334 26 admission admission NN 37231 1334 27 that that IN 37231 1334 28 there there EX 37231 1334 29 are be VBP 37231 1334 30 other other JJ 37231 1334 31 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1334 32 beings being NNS 37231 1334 33 capable capable JJ 37231 1334 34 of of IN 37231 1334 35 performing perform VBG 37231 1334 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1334 37 . . . 37231 1335 1 Even even RB 37231 1335 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1335 3 Newman Newman NNP 37231 1335 4 has have VBZ 37231 1335 5 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1335 6 this this DT 37231 1335 7 , , , 37231 1335 8 and and CC 37231 1335 9 , , , 37231 1335 10 in in IN 37231 1335 11 a a DT 37231 1335 12 passage passage NN 37231 1335 13 already already RB 37231 1335 14 quoted quote VBN 37231 1335 15 , , , 37231 1335 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1335 17 says say VBZ 37231 1335 18 : : : 37231 1335 19 " " `` 37231 1335 20 For for IN 37231 1335 21 the the DT 37231 1335 22 cogency cogency NN 37231 1335 23 of of IN 37231 1335 24 the the DT 37231 1335 25 argument argument NN 37231 1335 26 from from IN 37231 1335 27 Miracles Miracles NNP 37231 1335 28 depends depend VBZ 37231 1335 29 on on IN 37231 1335 30 the the DT 37231 1335 31 assumption assumption NN 37231 1335 32 , , , 37231 1335 33 that that IN 37231 1335 34 interruptions interruption NNS 37231 1335 35 in in IN 37231 1335 36 the the DT 37231 1335 37 course course NN 37231 1335 38 of of IN 37231 1335 39 nature nature NN 37231 1335 40 must must MD 37231 1335 41 ultimately ultimately RB 37231 1335 42 proceed proceed VB 37231 1335 43 from from IN 37231 1335 44 God God NNP 37231 1335 45 ; ; : 37231 1335 46 which which WDT 37231 1335 47 is be VBZ 37231 1335 48 not not RB 37231 1335 49 true true JJ 37231 1335 50 , , , 37231 1335 51 if if IN 37231 1335 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1335 53 may may MD 37231 1335 54 be be VB 37231 1335 55 { { -LRB- 37231 1335 56 65 65 CD 37231 1335 57 } } -RRB- 37231 1335 58 effected effect VBN 37231 1335 59 by by IN 37231 1335 60 other other JJ 37231 1335 61 beings being NNS 37231 1335 62 without without IN 37231 1335 63 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1335 64 sanction sanction NN 37231 1335 65 . . . 37231 1336 1 " " `` 37231 1336 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1336 3 1 1 LS 37231 1336 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1336 5 The the DT 37231 1336 6 first first JJ 37231 1336 7 assumption assumption NN 37231 1336 8 , , , 37231 1336 9 in in IN 37231 1336 10 fact fact NN 37231 1336 11 , , , 37231 1336 12 leads lead VBZ 37231 1336 13 to to IN 37231 1336 14 nothing nothing NN 37231 1336 15 but but IN 37231 1336 16 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1336 17 connected connect VBN 37231 1336 18 with with IN 37231 1336 19 the the DT 37231 1336 20 unseen unseen JJ 37231 1336 21 , , , 37231 1336 22 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1336 23 and and CC 37231 1336 24 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1336 25 , , , 37231 1336 26 which which WDT 37231 1336 27 are be VBP 37231 1336 28 beyond beyond IN 37231 1336 29 the the DT 37231 1336 30 limits limit NNS 37231 1336 31 of of IN 37231 1336 32 reason reason NN 37231 1336 33 . . . 37231 1337 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1337 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1337 3 is be VBZ 37231 1337 4 well well RB 37231 1337 5 aware aware JJ 37231 1337 6 that that IN 37231 1337 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1337 8 assumption assumption NN 37231 1337 9 of of IN 37231 1337 10 a a DT 37231 1337 11 " " `` 37231 1337 12 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1337 13 " " '' 37231 1337 14 Deity deity NN 37231 1337 15 is be VBZ 37231 1337 16 not not RB 37231 1337 17 susceptible susceptible JJ 37231 1337 18 of of IN 37231 1337 19 proof;(2 proof;(2 NN 37231 1337 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1337 21 indeed indeed RB 37231 1337 22 , , , 37231 1337 23 this this DT 37231 1337 24 is be VBZ 37231 1337 25 admitted admit VBN 37231 1337 26 in in IN 37231 1337 27 the the DT 37231 1337 28 statement statement NN 37231 1337 29 that that IN 37231 1337 30 the the DT 37231 1337 31 definition definition NN 37231 1337 32 is be VBZ 37231 1337 33 an an DT 37231 1337 34 " " `` 37231 1337 35 assumption assumption NN 37231 1337 36 . . . 37231 1337 37 " " '' 37231 1338 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1338 2 quotes quote VBZ 37231 1338 3 the the DT 37231 1338 4 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1338 5 reply reply NN 37231 1338 6 which which WDT 37231 1338 7 may may MD 37231 1338 8 be be VB 37231 1338 9 made make VBN 37231 1338 10 regarding regard VBG 37231 1338 11 this this DT 37231 1338 12 assumption:--"Everybody assumption:--"everybody NN 37231 1338 13 must must MD 37231 1338 14 collect collect VB 37231 1338 15 from from IN 37231 1338 16 the the DT 37231 1338 17 harmony harmony NN 37231 1338 18 of of IN 37231 1338 19 the the DT 37231 1338 20 physical physical JJ 37231 1338 21 universe universe NN 37231 1338 22 the the DT 37231 1338 23 existence existence NN 37231 1338 24 of of IN 37231 1338 25 a a DT 37231 1338 26 God God NNP 37231 1338 27 , , , 37231 1338 28 but but CC 37231 1338 29 in in IN 37231 1338 30 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 37231 1338 31 a a DT 37231 1338 32 God God NNP 37231 1338 33 , , , 37231 1338 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1338 35 do do VBP 37231 1338 36 not not RB 37231 1338 37 thereby thereby RB 37231 1338 38 acknowledge acknowledge VB 37231 1338 39 this this DT 37231 1338 40 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 1338 41 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 37231 1338 42 conception conception NN 37231 1338 43 of of IN 37231 1338 44 a a DT 37231 1338 45 God God NNP 37231 1338 46 . . . 37231 1339 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1339 2 see see VBP 37231 1339 3 in in IN 37231 1339 4 the the DT 37231 1339 5 structure structure NN 37231 1339 6 of of IN 37231 1339 7 nature nature NN 37231 1339 8 a a DT 37231 1339 9 mind mind NN 37231 1339 10 -- -- : 37231 1339 11 a a DT 37231 1339 12 universal universal JJ 37231 1339 13 mind mind NN 37231 1339 14 -- -- : 37231 1339 15 but but CC 37231 1339 16 still still RB 37231 1339 17 a a DT 37231 1339 18 mind mind NN 37231 1339 19 which which WDT 37231 1339 20 only only RB 37231 1339 21 operates operate VBZ 37231 1339 22 and and CC 37231 1339 23 expresses express VBZ 37231 1339 24 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1339 25 by by IN 37231 1339 26 law law NN 37231 1339 27 . . . 37231 1340 1 Nature nature NN 37231 1340 2 only only RB 37231 1340 3 does do VBZ 37231 1340 4 and and CC 37231 1340 5 only only RB 37231 1340 6 can can MD 37231 1340 7 inform inform VB 37231 1340 8 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1340 9 of of IN 37231 1340 10 mind mind NN 37231 1340 11 _ _ NNP 37231 1340 12 in in IN 37231 1340 13 _ _ NNP 37231 1340 14 nature nature NN 37231 1340 15 , , , 37231 1340 16 the the DT 37231 1340 17 partner partner NN 37231 1340 18 and and CC 37231 1340 19 correlative correlative JJ 37231 1340 20 of of IN 37231 1340 21 organized organized JJ 37231 1340 22 matter matter NN 37231 1340 23 . . . 37231 1341 1 Nature nature NN 37231 1341 2 , , , 37231 1341 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 1341 4 , , , 37231 1341 5 can can MD 37231 1341 6 speak speak VB 37231 1341 7 to to IN 37231 1341 8 the the DT 37231 1341 9 existence existence NN 37231 1341 10 of of IN 37231 1341 11 a a DT 37231 1341 12 God God NNP 37231 1341 13 in in IN 37231 1341 14 this this DT 37231 1341 15 sense sense NN 37231 1341 16 , , , 37231 1341 17 and and CC 37231 1341 18 can can MD 37231 1341 19 speak speak VB 37231 1341 20 to to IN 37231 1341 21 the the DT 37231 1341 22 omnipotence omnipotence NN 37231 1341 23 of of IN 37231 1341 24 God God NNP 37231 1341 25 in in IN 37231 1341 26 a a DT 37231 1341 27 sense sense NN 37231 1341 28 coinciding coincide VBG 37231 1341 29 with with IN 37231 1341 30 the the DT 37231 1341 31 actual actual JJ 37231 1341 32 facts fact NNS 37231 1341 33 of of IN 37231 1341 34 nature nature NN 37231 1341 35 ; ; : 37231 1341 36 but but CC 37231 1341 37 in in IN 37231 1341 38 no no DT 37231 1341 39 other other JJ 37231 1341 40 sense sense NN 37231 1341 41 does do VBZ 37231 1341 42 nature nature VB 37231 1341 43 witness witness NN 37231 1341 44 to to IN 37231 1341 45 the the DT 37231 1341 46 existence existence NN 37231 1341 47 of of IN 37231 1341 48 an an DT 37231 1341 49 Omnipotent Omnipotent NNP 37231 1341 50 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1341 51 Being Being NNP 37231 1341 52 . . . 37231 1342 1 Of of IN 37231 1342 2 a a DT 37231 1342 3 universal universal JJ 37231 1342 4 Mind mind NN 37231 1342 5 out out IN 37231 1342 6 of of IN 37231 1342 7 nature nature NN 37231 1342 8 , , , 37231 1342 9 nature nature NN 37231 1342 10 says say VBZ 37231 1342 11 nothing nothing NN 37231 1342 12 , , , 37231 1342 13 and and CC 37231 1342 14 of of IN 37231 1342 15 an an DT 37231 1342 16 Omnipotence Omnipotence NNP 37231 1342 17 which which WDT 37231 1342 18 does do VBZ 37231 1342 19 not not RB 37231 1342 20 possess possess VB 37231 1342 21 an an DT 37231 1342 22 inherent inherent JJ 37231 1342 23 limit limit NN 37231 1342 24 in in IN 37231 1342 25 nature nature NN 37231 1342 26 , , , 37231 1342 27 she -PRON- PRP 37231 1342 28 says say VBZ 37231 1342 29 nothing nothing NN 37231 1342 30 either either RB 37231 1342 31 . . . 37231 1343 1 And and CC 37231 1343 2 , , , 37231 1343 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 1343 4 , , , 37231 1343 5 that that IN 37231 1343 6 conception conception NN 37231 1343 7 of of IN 37231 1343 8 a a DT 37231 1343 9 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1343 10 Being Being NNP 37231 1343 11 which which WDT 37231 1343 12 represents represent VBZ 37231 1343 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1343 14 as as IN 37231 1343 15 a a DT 37231 1343 16 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 1343 17 { { -LRB- 37231 1343 18 66 66 CD 37231 1343 19 } } -RRB- 37231 1343 20 independent independent JJ 37231 1343 21 of of IN 37231 1343 22 the the DT 37231 1343 23 physical physical JJ 37231 1343 24 universe universe NN 37231 1343 25 , , , 37231 1343 26 and and CC 37231 1343 27 able able JJ 37231 1343 28 from from IN 37231 1343 29 a a DT 37231 1343 30 standing standing NN 37231 1343 31 - - HYPH 37231 1343 32 place place NN 37231 1343 33 external external JJ 37231 1343 34 to to IN 37231 1343 35 nature nature NN 37231 1343 36 to to TO 37231 1343 37 interrupt interrupt VB 37231 1343 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1343 39 order order NN 37231 1343 40 , , , 37231 1343 41 is be VBZ 37231 1343 42 a a DT 37231 1343 43 conception conception NN 37231 1343 44 of of IN 37231 1343 45 God God NNP 37231 1343 46 for for IN 37231 1343 47 which which WDT 37231 1343 48 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1343 49 must must MD 37231 1343 50 go go VB 37231 1343 51 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 1343 52 . . . 37231 1344 1 That that DT 37231 1344 2 conception conception NN 37231 1344 3 is be VBZ 37231 1344 4 obtained obtain VBN 37231 1344 5 from from IN 37231 1344 6 revelation revelation NN 37231 1344 7 which which WDT 37231 1344 8 is be VBZ 37231 1344 9 asserted assert VBN 37231 1344 10 to to TO 37231 1344 11 be be VB 37231 1344 12 proved prove VBN 37231 1344 13 by by IN 37231 1344 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1344 15 . . . 37231 1345 1 But but CC 37231 1345 2 that that IN 37231 1345 3 being be VBG 37231 1345 4 the the DT 37231 1345 5 case case NN 37231 1345 6 , , , 37231 1345 7 this this DT 37231 1345 8 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1345 9 of of IN 37231 1345 10 Theism Theism NNP 37231 1345 11 rests rest VBZ 37231 1345 12 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1345 13 upon upon IN 37231 1345 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1345 15 , , , 37231 1345 16 and and CC 37231 1345 17 , , , 37231 1345 18 therefore therefore RB 37231 1345 19 , , , 37231 1345 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1345 21 can can MD 37231 1345 22 not not RB 37231 1345 23 rest rest VB 37231 1345 24 upon upon IN 37231 1345 25 this this DT 37231 1345 26 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1345 27 of of IN 37231 1345 28 Theism theism NN 37231 1345 29 . . . 37231 1346 1 " " `` 37231 1346 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1346 3 1 1 LS 37231 1346 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1346 5 With with IN 37231 1346 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1346 7 usual usual JJ 37231 1346 8 fairness fairness NN 37231 1346 9 , , , 37231 1346 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1346 11 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1346 12 , , , 37231 1346 13 while while IN 37231 1346 14 questioning question VBG 37231 1346 15 the the DT 37231 1346 16 correctness correctness NN 37231 1346 17 of of IN 37231 1346 18 the the DT 37231 1346 19 premiss premiss NN 37231 1346 20 of of IN 37231 1346 21 this this DT 37231 1346 22 argument argument NN 37231 1346 23 , , , 37231 1346 24 admits admit VBZ 37231 1346 25 that that IN 37231 1346 26 , , , 37231 1346 27 if if IN 37231 1346 28 established establish VBN 37231 1346 29 , , , 37231 1346 30 the the DT 37231 1346 31 consequence consequence NN 37231 1346 32 stated state VBD 37231 1346 33 would would MD 37231 1346 34 follow follow VB 37231 1346 35 , , , 37231 1346 36 " " '' 37231 1346 37 and and CC 37231 1346 38 more more JJR 37231 1346 39 , , , 37231 1346 40 for for IN 37231 1346 41 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1346 42 being be VBG 37231 1346 43 thrown throw VBN 37231 1346 44 back back RB 37231 1346 45 upon upon IN 37231 1346 46 the the DT 37231 1346 47 same same JJ 37231 1346 48 ground ground NN 37231 1346 49 on on IN 37231 1346 50 which which WDT 37231 1346 51 Theism Theism NNP 37231 1346 52 is be VBZ 37231 1346 53 , , , 37231 1346 54 the the DT 37231 1346 55 whole whole JJ 37231 1346 56 evidence evidence NN 37231 1346 57 of of IN 37231 1346 58 revelation revelation NN 37231 1346 59 becomes become VBZ 37231 1346 60 a a DT 37231 1346 61 vicious vicious JJ 37231 1346 62 circle circle NN 37231 1346 63 , , , 37231 1346 64 and and CC 37231 1346 65 the the DT 37231 1346 66 fabric fabric NN 37231 1346 67 is be VBZ 37231 1346 68 left leave VBN 37231 1346 69 suspended suspend VBN 37231 1346 70 in in IN 37231 1346 71 space space NN 37231 1346 72 , , , 37231 1346 73 revelation revelation NN 37231 1346 74 resting rest VBG 37231 1346 75 on on IN 37231 1346 76 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1346 77 and and CC 37231 1346 78 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1346 79 resting rest VBG 37231 1346 80 on on IN 37231 1346 81 revelation revelation NN 37231 1346 82 . . . 37231 1347 1 " " `` 37231 1347 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1347 3 2 2 LS 37231 1347 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1347 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1347 6 not not RB 37231 1347 7 only only RB 37231 1347 8 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 1347 9 , , , 37231 1347 10 however however RB 37231 1347 11 , , , 37231 1347 12 that that IN 37231 1347 13 the the DT 37231 1347 14 conception conception NN 37231 1347 15 of of IN 37231 1347 16 a a DT 37231 1347 17 Person person NN 37231 1347 18 al al NNP 37231 1347 19 " " `` 37231 1347 20 Deity deity NN 37231 1347 21 can can MD 37231 1347 22 not not RB 37231 1347 23 be be VB 37231 1347 24 proved prove VBN 37231 1347 25 , , , 37231 1347 26 but but CC 37231 1347 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1347 28 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 1347 29 confesses confess VBZ 37231 1347 30 that that IN 37231 1347 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1347 32 was be VBD 37231 1347 33 obtained obtain VBN 37231 1347 34 from from IN 37231 1347 35 revelation,(3 revelation,(3 NNP 37231 1347 36 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1347 37 and and CC 37231 1347 38 from from IN 37231 1347 39 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 1347 40 else else RB 37231 1347 41 , , , 37231 1347 42 and and CC 37231 1347 43 these these DT 37231 1347 44 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1347 45 admissions admission NNS 37231 1347 46 obviously obviously RB 37231 1347 47 establish establish VBP 37231 1347 48 the the DT 37231 1347 49 correctness correctness NN 37231 1347 50 of of IN 37231 1347 51 the the DT 37231 1347 52 premiss premiss NNP 37231 1347 53 , , , 37231 1347 54 and and CC 37231 1347 55 involve involve VBP 37231 1347 56 the the DT 37231 1347 57 consequence consequence NN 37231 1347 58 pointed point VBD 37231 1347 59 out out RP 37231 1347 60 , , , 37231 1347 61 that that IN 37231 1347 62 the the DT 37231 1347 63 evidence evidence NN 37231 1347 64 of of IN 37231 1347 65 revelation revelation NN 37231 1347 66 is be VBZ 37231 1347 67 a a DT 37231 1347 68 mere mere JJ 37231 1347 69 vicious vicious JJ 37231 1347 70 circle circle NN 37231 1347 71 . . . 37231 1348 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1348 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1348 3 attempts attempt VBZ 37231 1348 4 to to TO 37231 1348 5 argue argue VB 37231 1348 6 that that IN 37231 1348 7 , , , 37231 1348 8 although although IN 37231 1348 9 the the DT 37231 1348 10 idea idea NN 37231 1348 11 was be VBD 37231 1348 12 first first RB 37231 1348 13 obtained obtain VBN 37231 1348 14 through through IN 37231 1348 15 this this DT 37231 1348 16 channel channel NN 37231 1348 17 , , , 37231 1348 18 " " `` 37231 1348 19 the the DT 37231 1348 20 truth truth NN 37231 1348 21 once once RB 37231 1348 22 possessed possess VBD 37231 1348 23 is be VBZ 37231 1348 24 seen see VBN 37231 1348 25 to to TO 37231 1348 26 rest rest VB 37231 1348 27 upon upon IN 37231 1348 28 grounds ground NNS 37231 1348 29 of of IN 37231 1348 30 natural natural JJ 37231 1348 31 reason reason NN 37231 1348 32 . . . 37231 1349 1 " " `` 37231 1349 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1349 3 4 4 LS 37231 1349 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1349 5 Why why WRB 37231 1349 6 , , , 37231 1349 7 then then RB 37231 1349 8 , , , 37231 1349 9 does do VBZ 37231 1349 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1349 11 call call VB 37231 1349 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1349 13 an an DT 37231 1349 14 assumption assumption NN 37231 1349 15 ? ? . 37231 1350 1 The the DT 37231 1350 2 argument argument NN 37231 1350 3 by by IN 37231 1350 4 which which WDT 37231 1350 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1350 6 seeks seek VBZ 37231 1350 7 to to TO 37231 1350 8 show show VB 37231 1350 9 that that IN 37231 1350 10 the the DT 37231 1350 11 conception conception NN 37231 1350 12 is be VBZ 37231 1350 13 seen see VBN 37231 1350 14 to to TO 37231 1350 15 rest rest VB 37231 1350 16 upon upon IN 37231 1350 17 grounds ground NNS 37231 1350 18 of of IN 37231 1350 19 natural natural JJ 37231 1350 20 reason reason NN 37231 1350 21 is be VBZ 37231 1350 22 : : : 37231 1350 23 " " `` 37231 1350 24 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1350 25 naturally naturally RB 37231 1350 26 attribute attribute VBP 37231 1350 27 to to IN 37231 1350 28 the the DT 37231 1350 29 design design NN 37231 1350 30 of of IN 37231 1350 31 a a DT 37231 1350 32 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1350 33 Being be VBG 37231 1350 34 a a DT 37231 1350 35 contrivance contrivance NN 37231 1350 36 which which WDT 37231 1350 37 is be VBZ 37231 1350 38 directed direct VBN 37231 1350 39 to to IN 37231 1350 40 the the DT 37231 1350 41 existence existence NN 37231 1350 42 of of IN 37231 1350 43 a a DT 37231 1350 44 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1350 45 Being Being NNP 37231 1350 46 .... .... NFP 37231 1350 47 From from IN 37231 1350 48 personality personality NN 37231 1350 49 { { -LRB- 37231 1350 50 67 67 CD 37231 1350 51 } } -RRB- 37231 1350 52 at at IN 37231 1350 53 one one CD 37231 1350 54 end end NN 37231 1350 55 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1350 56 infer infer VBP 37231 1350 57 personality personality NN 37231 1350 58 at at IN 37231 1350 59 the the DT 37231 1350 60 other other JJ 37231 1350 61 . . . 37231 1350 62 " " '' 37231 1351 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1351 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1351 3 's 's POS 37231 1351 4 own own JJ 37231 1351 5 sense sense NN 37231 1351 6 of of IN 37231 1351 7 the the DT 37231 1351 8 weakness weakness NN 37231 1351 9 of of IN 37231 1351 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1351 11 argument argument NN 37231 1351 12 , , , 37231 1351 13 however however RB 37231 1351 14 , , , 37231 1351 15 and and CC 37231 1351 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1351 17 natural natural JJ 37231 1351 18 honesty honesty NN 37231 1351 19 of of IN 37231 1351 20 mind mind NN 37231 1351 21 oblige oblige VB 37231 1351 22 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1351 23 continually continually RB 37231 1351 24 to to TO 37231 1351 25 confess confess VB 37231 1351 26 the the DT 37231 1351 27 absence absence NN 37231 1351 28 of of IN 37231 1351 29 evidence evidence NN 37231 1351 30 . . . 37231 1352 1 A a DT 37231 1352 2 few few JJ 37231 1352 3 paragraphs paragraph NNS 37231 1352 4 further further RB 37231 1352 5 on on IN 37231 1352 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1352 7 admits:--"Not admits:--"Not VBZ 37231 1352 8 , , , 37231 1352 9 however however RB 37231 1352 10 , , , 37231 1352 11 that that IN 37231 1352 12 the the DT 37231 1352 13 existence existence NN 37231 1352 14 of of IN 37231 1352 15 a a DT 37231 1352 16 God God NNP 37231 1352 17 is be VBZ 37231 1352 18 so so RB 37231 1352 19 clearly clearly RB 37231 1352 20 seen see VBN 37231 1352 21 by by IN 37231 1352 22 reason reason NN 37231 1352 23 as as IN 37231 1352 24 to to TO 37231 1352 25 dispense dispense VB 37231 1352 26 with with IN 37231 1352 27 faith;"(1 faith;"(1 NN 37231 1352 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1352 29 but but CC 37231 1352 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1352 31 endeavours endeavour VBZ 37231 1352 32 to to TO 37231 1352 33 convince convince VB 37231 1352 34 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1352 35 that that DT 37231 1352 36 faith faith NN 37231 1352 37 is be VBZ 37231 1352 38 reason reason NN 37231 1352 39 , , , 37231 1352 40 only only RB 37231 1352 41 reason reason NN 37231 1352 42 acting act VBG 37231 1352 43 under under IN 37231 1352 44 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 1352 45 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1352 46 : : : 37231 1352 47 when when WRB 37231 1352 48 reason reason NN 37231 1352 49 draws draw VBZ 37231 1352 50 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1352 51 which which WDT 37231 1352 52 are be VBP 37231 1352 53 not not RB 37231 1352 54 backed back VBN 37231 1352 55 by by IN 37231 1352 56 experience experience NN 37231 1352 57 , , , 37231 1352 58 reason reason NN 37231 1352 59 is be VBZ 37231 1352 60 then then RB 37231 1352 61 called call VBN 37231 1352 62 faith faith NN 37231 1352 63 . . . 37231 1353 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1353 2 2 2 LS 37231 1353 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1353 4 The the DT 37231 1353 5 issue issue NN 37231 1353 6 of of IN 37231 1353 7 the the DT 37231 1353 8 argument argument NN 37231 1353 9 , , , 37231 1353 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1353 11 contends contend VBZ 37231 1353 12 , , , 37231 1353 13 is be VBZ 37231 1353 14 so so RB 37231 1353 15 amazing amazing JJ 37231 1353 16 , , , 37231 1353 17 that that IN 37231 1353 18 if if IN 37231 1353 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1353 20 do do VBP 37231 1353 21 not not RB 37231 1353 22 tremble tremble VB 37231 1353 23 for for IN 37231 1353 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1353 25 safety safety NN 37231 1353 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1353 27 must must MD 37231 1353 28 be be VB 37231 1353 29 on on IN 37231 1353 30 account account NN 37231 1353 31 of of IN 37231 1353 32 a a DT 37231 1353 33 practical practical JJ 37231 1353 34 principle principle NN 37231 1353 35 , , , 37231 1353 36 which which WDT 37231 1353 37 makes make VBZ 37231 1353 38 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1353 39 confide confide JJ 37231 1353 40 and and CC 37231 1353 41 trust trust VB 37231 1353 42 in in IN 37231 1353 43 reasons reason NNS 37231 1353 44 , , , 37231 1353 45 and and CC 37231 1353 46 that that IN 37231 1353 47 principle principle NN 37231 1353 48 is be VBZ 37231 1353 49 faith faith NN 37231 1353 50 . . . 37231 1354 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1354 2 are be VBP 37231 1354 3 not not RB 37231 1354 4 aware aware JJ 37231 1354 5 that that IN 37231 1354 6 conviction conviction NN 37231 1354 7 can can MD 37231 1354 8 be be VB 37231 1354 9 arrived arrive VBN 37231 1354 10 at at IN 37231 1354 11 regarding regard VBG 37231 1354 12 any any DT 37231 1354 13 matter matter NN 37231 1354 14 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 1354 15 than than IN 37231 1354 16 by by IN 37231 1354 17 confidence confidence NN 37231 1354 18 in in IN 37231 1354 19 the the DT 37231 1354 20 correctness correctness NN 37231 1354 21 of of IN 37231 1354 22 the the DT 37231 1354 23 reasons reason NNS 37231 1354 24 , , , 37231 1354 25 and and CC 37231 1354 26 what what WP 37231 1354 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1354 28 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1354 29 really really RB 37231 1354 30 means mean VBZ 37231 1354 31 by by IN 37231 1354 32 faith faith NN 37231 1354 33 , , , 37231 1354 34 here here RB 37231 1354 35 , , , 37231 1354 36 is be VBZ 37231 1354 37 confidence confidence NN 37231 1354 38 and and CC 37231 1354 39 trust trust NN 37231 1354 40 in in IN 37231 1354 41 a a DT 37231 1354 42 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1354 43 for for IN 37231 1354 44 which which WDT 37231 1354 45 there there EX 37231 1354 46 are be VBP 37231 1354 47 no no DT 37231 1354 48 reasons reason NNS 37231 1354 49 . . . 37231 1355 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1355 2 is be VBZ 37231 1355 3 almost almost RB 37231 1355 4 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1355 5 that that IN 37231 1355 6 the the DT 37231 1355 7 same same JJ 37231 1355 8 person person NN 37231 1355 9 who who WP 37231 1355 10 had have VBD 37231 1355 11 just just RB 37231 1355 12 been be VBN 37231 1355 13 denying deny VBG 37231 1355 14 grounds ground NNS 37231 1355 15 of of IN 37231 1355 16 reason reason NN 37231 1355 17 to to IN 37231 1355 18 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1355 19 from from IN 37231 1355 20 unvarying unvarye VBG 37231 1355 21 experience experience NN 37231 1355 22 , , , 37231 1355 23 and and CC 37231 1355 24 excluding exclude VBG 37231 1355 25 from from IN 37231 1355 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1355 27 the the DT 37231 1355 28 results result NNS 37231 1355 29 of of IN 37231 1355 30 inductive inductive JJ 37231 1355 31 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1355 32 -- -- : 37231 1355 33 who who WP 37231 1355 34 had have VBD 37231 1355 35 denounced denounce VBN 37231 1355 36 as as IN 37231 1355 37 unintelligent unintelligent JJ 37231 1355 38 impulse impulse NN 37231 1355 39 and and CC 37231 1355 40 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1355 41 instinct instinct NN 37231 1355 42 the the DT 37231 1355 43 faith faith NN 37231 1355 44 that that WDT 37231 1355 45 the the DT 37231 1355 46 sun sun NN 37231 1355 47 , , , 37231 1355 48 which which WDT 37231 1355 49 has have VBZ 37231 1355 50 risen rise VBN 37231 1355 51 without without IN 37231 1355 52 fail fail NN 37231 1355 53 every every DT 37231 1355 54 morning morning NN 37231 1355 55 since since IN 37231 1355 56 time time NN 37231 1355 57 began begin VBD 37231 1355 58 , , , 37231 1355 59 will will MD 37231 1355 60 rise rise VB 37231 1355 61 again again RB 37231 1355 62 to to IN 37231 1355 63 - - HYPH 37231 1355 64 morrow morrow NNP 37231 1355 65 , , , 37231 1355 66 could could MD 37231 1355 67 thus thus RB 37231 1355 68 argue argue VB 37231 1355 69 . . . 37231 1356 1 In in IN 37231 1356 2 fact fact NN 37231 1356 3 , , , 37231 1356 4 from from IN 37231 1356 5 the the DT 37231 1356 6 very very JJ 37231 1356 7 commencement commencement NN 37231 1356 8 of of IN 37231 1356 9 the the DT 37231 1356 10 direct direct JJ 37231 1356 11 plea plea NN 37231 1356 12 for for IN 37231 1356 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1356 14 , , , 37231 1356 15 calm calm JJ 37231 1356 16 logical logical JJ 37231 1356 17 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1356 18 is be VBZ 37231 1356 19 abandoned abandon VBN 37231 1356 20 , , , 37231 1356 21 and and CC 37231 1356 22 the the DT 37231 1356 23 argument argument NN 37231 1356 24 becomes become VBZ 37231 1356 25 entirely entirely RB 37231 1356 26 _ _ NNP 37231 1356 27 ad ad NN 37231 1356 28 hominem hominem NNP 37231 1356 29 _ _ NNP 37231 1356 30 . . . 37231 1357 1 Mere mere JJ 37231 1357 2 feeling feeling NN 37231 1357 3 is be VBZ 37231 1357 4 substituted substitute VBN 37231 1357 5 for for IN 37231 1357 6 thought thought NN 37231 1357 7 , , , 37231 1357 8 and and CC 37231 1357 9 in in IN 37231 1357 10 the the DT 37231 1357 11 inability inability NN 37231 1357 12 to to TO 37231 1357 13 be be VB 37231 1357 14 precise precise JJ 37231 1357 15 and and CC 37231 1357 16 logical logical JJ 37231 1357 17 , , , 37231 1357 18 the the DT 37231 1357 19 lecturer lecturer NN 37231 1357 20 appeals appeal NNS 37231 1357 21 { { -LRB- 37231 1357 22 68 68 CD 37231 1357 23 } } -RRB- 37231 1357 24 to to IN 37231 1357 25 the the DT 37231 1357 26 generally generally RB 37231 1357 27 prevailing prevail VBG 37231 1357 28 inaccuracy inaccuracy NN 37231 1357 29 of of IN 37231 1357 30 thought thought NN 37231 1357 31 . . . 37231 1358 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1358 2 1 1 LS 37231 1358 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1358 4 " " `` 37231 1358 5 Faith faith NN 37231 1358 6 , , , 37231 1358 7 then then RB 37231 1358 8 , , , 37231 1358 9 " " '' 37231 1358 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1358 11 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 1358 12 , , , 37231 1358 13 " " `` 37231 1358 14 is be VBZ 37231 1358 15 _ _ NNP 37231 1358 16 unverified unverified JJ 37231 1358 17 _ _ NNP 37231 1358 18 reason reason NN 37231 1358 19 ; ; : 37231 1358 20 reason reason NN 37231 1358 21 which which WDT 37231 1358 22 has have VBZ 37231 1358 23 not not RB 37231 1358 24 yet yet RB 37231 1358 25 received receive VBN 37231 1358 26 the the DT 37231 1358 27 verification verification NN 37231 1358 28 of of IN 37231 1358 29 the the DT 37231 1358 30 final final JJ 37231 1358 31 test test NN 37231 1358 32 , , , 37231 1358 33 but but CC 37231 1358 34 is be VBZ 37231 1358 35 still still RB 37231 1358 36 expectant expectant JJ 37231 1358 37 . . . 37231 1358 38 " " '' 37231 1359 1 In in IN 37231 1359 2 science science NN 37231 1359 3 this this DT 37231 1359 4 , , , 37231 1359 5 at at IN 37231 1359 6 the the DT 37231 1359 7 best good JJS 37231 1359 8 , , , 37231 1359 9 would would MD 37231 1359 10 be be VB 37231 1359 11 called call VBN 37231 1359 12 mere mere JJ 37231 1359 13 " " `` 37231 1359 14 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1359 15 , , , 37231 1359 16 " " '' 37231 1359 17 but but CC 37231 1359 18 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 1359 19 can can MD 37231 1359 20 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1359 21 be be VB 37231 1359 22 expected expect VBN 37231 1359 23 where where WRB 37231 1359 24 the the DT 37231 1359 25 argument argument NN 37231 1359 26 continues continue VBZ 37231 1359 27 : : : 37231 1359 28 " " `` 37231 1359 29 Indeed indeed RB 37231 1359 30 , , , 37231 1359 31 does do VBZ 37231 1359 32 not not RB 37231 1359 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1359 34 heart heart NN 37231 1359 35 bear bear VB 37231 1359 36 witness witness NN 37231 1359 37 to to IN 37231 1359 38 the the DT 37231 1359 39 fact fact NN 37231 1359 40 that that IN 37231 1359 41 to to TO 37231 1359 42 believe believe VB 37231 1359 43 in in IN 37231 1359 44 a a DT 37231 1359 45 God"--i God"--i NNP 37231 1359 46 . . . 37231 1359 47 e. e. NNP 37231 1359 48 , , , 37231 1359 49 a a DT 37231 1359 50 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1359 51 God God NNP 37231 1359 52 --"is --"is , 37231 1359 53 an an DT 37231 1359 54 exercise exercise NN 37231 1359 55 of of IN 37231 1359 56 faith faith NN 37231 1359 57 ? ? . 37231 1359 58 " " '' 37231 1360 1 & & CC 37231 1360 2 c.(2 c.(2 NNP 37231 1360 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1360 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1360 5 does do VBZ 37231 1360 6 not not RB 37231 1360 7 help help VB 37231 1360 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1360 9 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1360 10 that that IN 37231 1360 11 Butler Butler NNP 37231 1360 12 , , , 37231 1360 13 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1360 14 , , , 37231 1360 15 and and CC 37231 1360 16 all all DT 37231 1360 17 other other JJ 37231 1360 18 divines divine NNS 37231 1360 19 have have VBP 37231 1360 20 equally equally RB 37231 1360 21 been be VBN 37231 1360 22 obliged oblige VBN 37231 1360 23 to to TO 37231 1360 24 commence commence VB 37231 1360 25 with with IN 37231 1360 26 the the DT 37231 1360 27 same same JJ 37231 1360 28 assumption assumption NN 37231 1360 29 ; ; : 37231 1360 30 and and CC 37231 1360 31 , , , 37231 1360 32 indeed indeed RB 37231 1360 33 , , , 37231 1360 34 as as IN 37231 1360 35 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1360 36 have have VBP 37231 1360 37 already already RB 37231 1360 38 remarked remark VBN 37231 1360 39 , , , 37231 1360 40 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1360 41 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1360 42 honestly honestly RB 37231 1360 43 admits admit VBZ 37231 1360 44 the the DT 37231 1360 45 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1360 46 of of IN 37231 1360 47 the the DT 37231 1360 48 case case NN 37231 1360 49 , , , 37231 1360 50 and and CC 37231 1360 51 while while IN 37231 1360 52 naturally naturally RB 37231 1360 53 making make VBG 37231 1360 54 the the DT 37231 1360 55 most most JJS 37231 1360 56 of of IN 37231 1360 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1360 58 own own JJ 37231 1360 59 views view NNS 37231 1360 60 , , , 37231 1360 61 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1360 62 does do VBZ 37231 1360 63 not not RB 37231 1360 64 disguise disguise VB 37231 1360 65 the the DT 37231 1360 66 insecurity insecurity NN 37231 1360 67 of of IN 37231 1360 68 the the DT 37231 1360 69 position position NN 37231 1360 70 . . . 37231 1361 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1361 2 deprecates deprecate VBZ 37231 1361 3 that that IN 37231 1361 4 school school NN 37231 1361 5 which which WDT 37231 1361 6 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 1361 7 that that IN 37231 1361 8 any any DT 37231 1361 9 average average JJ 37231 1361 10 man man NN 37231 1361 11 , , , 37231 1361 12 taken take VBN 37231 1361 13 out out IN 37231 1361 14 of of IN 37231 1361 15 a a DT 37231 1361 16 crowd crowd NN 37231 1361 17 , , , 37231 1361 18 who who WP 37231 1361 19 has have VBZ 37231 1361 20 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1361 21 common common JJ 37231 1361 22 sense sense NN 37231 1361 23 to to TO 37231 1361 24 manage manage VB 37231 1361 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1361 26 own own JJ 37231 1361 27 affairs affair NNS 37231 1361 28 , , , 37231 1361 29 is be VBZ 37231 1361 30 a a DT 37231 1361 31 fit fit JJ 37231 1361 32 judge judge NN 37231 1361 33 , , , 37231 1361 34 and and CC 37231 1361 35 such such PDT 37231 1361 36 a a DT 37231 1361 37 judge judge NN 37231 1361 38 as as IN 37231 1361 39 was be VBD 37231 1361 40 originally originally RB 37231 1361 41 contemplated contemplate VBN 37231 1361 42 , , , 37231 1361 43 of of IN 37231 1361 44 the the DT 37231 1361 45 Christian Christian NNP 37231 1361 46 evidences;(3 evidences;(3 NNP 37231 1361 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1361 48 and and CC 37231 1361 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1361 50 says say VBZ 37231 1361 51 : : : 37231 1361 52 " " `` 37231 1361 53 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1361 54 is be VBZ 37231 1361 55 not not RB 37231 1361 56 , , , 37231 1361 57 indeed indeed RB 37231 1361 58 , , , 37231 1361 59 consistent consistent JJ 37231 1361 60 with with IN 37231 1361 61 truth truth NN 37231 1361 62 , , , 37231 1361 63 nor nor CC 37231 1361 64 would would MD 37231 1361 65 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1361 66 conduce conduce VB 37231 1361 67 to to IN 37231 1361 68 the the DT 37231 1361 69 real real JJ 37231 1361 70 defence defence NN 37231 1361 71 of of IN 37231 1361 72 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1361 73 , , , 37231 1361 74 to to TO 37231 1361 75 underrate underrate VB 37231 1361 76 the the DT 37231 1361 77 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 1361 78 of of IN 37231 1361 79 the the DT 37231 1361 80 Christian christian JJ 37231 1361 81 evidence evidence NN 37231 1361 82 ; ; : 37231 1361 83 or or CC 37231 1361 84 to to TO 37231 1361 85 disguise disguise VB 37231 1361 86 this this DT 37231 1361 87 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 1361 88 of of IN 37231 1361 89 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1361 90 , , , 37231 1361 91 that that IN 37231 1361 92 the the DT 37231 1361 93 very very JJ 37231 1361 94 facts fact NNS 37231 1361 95 which which WDT 37231 1361 96 constitute constitute VBP 37231 1361 97 the the DT 37231 1361 98 evidence evidence NN 37231 1361 99 of of IN 37231 1361 100 revelation revelation NN 37231 1361 101 have have VBP 37231 1361 102 to to TO 37231 1361 103 be be VB 37231 1361 104 accepted accept VBN 37231 1361 105 by by IN 37231 1361 106 an an DT 37231 1361 107 act act NN 37231 1361 108 of of IN 37231 1361 109 faith faith NN 37231 1361 110 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1361 111 , , , 37231 1361 112 before before IN 37231 1361 113 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1361 114 can can MD 37231 1361 115 operate operate VB 37231 1361 116 as as IN 37231 1361 117 a a DT 37231 1361 118 proof proof NN 37231 1361 119 of of IN 37231 1361 120 that that DT 37231 1361 121 further further JJ 37231 1361 122 truth truth NN 37231 1361 123 . . . 37231 1362 1 " " `` 37231 1362 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1362 3 4 4 LS 37231 1362 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1362 5 Such such JJ 37231 1362 6 evidence evidence NN 37231 1362 7 is be VBZ 37231 1362 8 manifestly manifestly RB 37231 1362 9 worthless worthless JJ 37231 1362 10 . . . 37231 1363 1 After after IN 37231 1363 2 all all PDT 37231 1363 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1363 4 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1363 5 , , , 37231 1363 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1363 7 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1363 8 is be VBZ 37231 1363 9 reduced reduce VBN 37231 1363 10 to to IN 37231 1363 11 the the DT 37231 1363 12 necessity necessity NN 37231 1363 13 of of IN 37231 1363 14 pleading plead VBG 37231 1363 15 : : : 37231 1363 16 " " `` 37231 1363 17 A a DT 37231 1363 18 probable probable JJ 37231 1363 19 fact fact NN 37231 1363 20 is be VBZ 37231 1363 21 a a DT 37231 1363 22 probable probable JJ 37231 1363 23 evidence evidence NN 37231 1363 24 . . . 37231 1364 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1364 2 may may MD 37231 1364 3 , , , 37231 1364 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 1364 5 , , , 37231 1364 6 use use VB 37231 1364 7 a a DT 37231 1364 8 miracle miracle NN 37231 1364 9 as as IN 37231 1364 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 1364 11 of of IN 37231 1364 12 a a DT 37231 1364 13 revelation revelation NN 37231 1364 14 , , , 37231 1364 15 though though IN 37231 1364 16 { { -LRB- 37231 1364 17 69 69 CD 37231 1364 18 } } -RRB- 37231 1364 19 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1364 20 have have VBP 37231 1364 21 only only RB 37231 1364 22 probable probable JJ 37231 1364 23 evidence evidence NN 37231 1364 24 for for IN 37231 1364 25 the the DT 37231 1364 26 miracle miracle NN 37231 1364 27 . . . 37231 1365 1 " " `` 37231 1365 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1365 3 1 1 LS 37231 1365 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1365 5 The the DT 37231 1365 6 probability probability NN 37231 1365 7 of of IN 37231 1365 8 the the DT 37231 1365 9 miracle miracle NN 37231 1365 10 , , , 37231 1365 11 however however RB 37231 1365 12 , , , 37231 1365 13 is be VBZ 37231 1365 14 precisely precisely RB 37231 1365 15 what what WP 37231 1365 16 is be VBZ 37231 1365 17 denied deny VBN 37231 1365 18 , , , 37231 1365 19 as as IN 37231 1365 20 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1365 21 to to IN 37231 1365 22 reason reason NN 37231 1365 23 and and CC 37231 1365 24 experience experience NN 37231 1365 25 , , , 37231 1365 26 and and CC 37231 1365 27 incompatible incompatible JJ 37231 1365 28 with with IN 37231 1365 29 the the DT 37231 1365 30 order order NN 37231 1365 31 of of IN 37231 1365 32 nature nature NN 37231 1365 33 . . . 37231 1366 1 A a DT 37231 1366 2 cause cause NN 37231 1366 3 is be VBZ 37231 1366 4 , , , 37231 1366 5 indeed indeed RB 37231 1366 6 , , , 37231 1366 7 weak weak JJ 37231 1366 8 when when WRB 37231 1366 9 so so RB 37231 1366 10 able able JJ 37231 1366 11 an an DT 37231 1366 12 advocate advocate NN 37231 1366 13 is be VBZ 37231 1366 14 reduced reduce VBN 37231 1366 15 to to IN 37231 1366 16 such such JJ 37231 1366 17 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1366 18 . . . 37231 1367 1 The the DT 37231 1367 2 deduction deduction NN 37231 1367 3 which which WDT 37231 1367 4 is be VBZ 37231 1367 5 drawn draw VBN 37231 1367 6 from from IN 37231 1367 7 the the DT 37231 1367 8 assumption assumption NN 37231 1367 9 of of IN 37231 1367 10 a a DT 37231 1367 11 " " `` 37231 1367 12 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1367 13 " " '' 37231 1367 14 Deity deity NN 37231 1367 15 is be VBZ 37231 1367 16 , , , 37231 1367 17 as as IN 37231 1367 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1367 19 have have VBP 37231 1367 20 seen see VBN 37231 1367 21 , , , 37231 1367 22 merely merely RB 37231 1367 23 the the DT 37231 1367 24 possibility possibility NN 37231 1367 25 of of IN 37231 1367 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1367 27 . . . 37231 1368 1 " " `` 37231 1368 2 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1368 3 's 's POS 37231 1368 4 criticism criticism NN 37231 1368 5 , , , 37231 1368 6 " " '' 37231 1368 7 said say VBD 37231 1368 8 the the DT 37231 1368 9 late late JJ 37231 1368 10 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1368 11 of of IN 37231 1368 12 St. St. NNP 37231 1368 13 Paul Paul NNP 37231 1368 14 's 's POS 37231 1368 15 , , , 37231 1368 16 " " `` 37231 1368 17 is be VBZ 37231 1368 18 , , , 37231 1368 19 after after RB 37231 1368 20 all all RB 37231 1368 21 , , , 37231 1368 22 the the DT 37231 1368 23 true true JJ 37231 1368 24 one--'once one--'once NN 37231 1368 25 believe believe VBP 37231 1368 26 that that IN 37231 1368 27 there there EX 37231 1368 28 is be VBZ 37231 1368 29 a a DT 37231 1368 30 God God NNP 37231 1368 31 , , , 37231 1368 32 and and CC 37231 1368 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1368 34 are be VBP 37231 1368 35 not not RB 37231 1368 36 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1368 37 . . . 37231 1369 1 ' ' `` 37231 1369 2 " " '' 37231 1369 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1369 4 2 2 LS 37231 1369 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1369 6 The the DT 37231 1369 7 assumption assumption NN 37231 1369 8 , , , 37231 1369 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 1369 10 , , , 37231 1369 11 although although IN 37231 1369 12 of of IN 37231 1369 13 vital vital JJ 37231 1369 14 importance importance NN 37231 1369 15 in in IN 37231 1369 16 the the DT 37231 1369 17 event event NN 37231 1369 18 of of IN 37231 1369 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1369 20 rejection rejection NN 37231 1369 21 , , , 37231 1369 22 does do VBZ 37231 1369 23 not not RB 37231 1369 24 very very RB 37231 1369 25 materially materially RB 37231 1369 26 advance advance JJ 37231 1369 27 the the DT 37231 1369 28 cause cause NN 37231 1369 29 of of IN 37231 1369 30 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1369 31 if if IN 37231 1369 32 established establish VBN 37231 1369 33 . . . 37231 1370 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1370 2 have have VBP 37231 1370 3 already already RB 37231 1370 4 seen see VBN 37231 1370 5 that that IN 37231 1370 6 the the DT 37231 1370 7 assumption assumption NN 37231 1370 8 is be VBZ 37231 1370 9 avowedly avowedly RB 37231 1370 10 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1370 11 of of IN 37231 1370 12 proof proof NN 37231 1370 13 , , , 37231 1370 14 but but CC 37231 1370 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1370 16 may may MD 37231 1370 17 be be VB 37231 1370 18 well well JJ 37231 1370 19 to to TO 37231 1370 20 examine examine VB 37231 1370 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1370 22 a a DT 37231 1370 23 little little RB 37231 1370 24 more more RBR 37231 1370 25 closely closely RB 37231 1370 26 in in IN 37231 1370 27 connection connection NN 37231 1370 28 with with IN 37231 1370 29 the the DT 37231 1370 30 inferences inference NNS 37231 1370 31 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1370 32 to to TO 37231 1370 33 be be VB 37231 1370 34 derivable derivable JJ 37231 1370 35 from from IN 37231 1370 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1370 37 . . . 37231 1371 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1371 2 must must MD 37231 1371 3 , , , 37231 1371 4 however however RB 37231 1371 5 , , , 37231 1371 6 in in IN 37231 1371 7 doing do VBG 37231 1371 8 so so RB 37231 1371 9 carefully carefully RB 37231 1371 10 avoid avoid VB 37231 1371 11 being be VBG 37231 1371 12 led lead VBN 37231 1371 13 into into IN 37231 1371 14 a a DT 37231 1371 15 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 37231 1371 16 argument argument NN 37231 1371 17 , , , 37231 1371 18 which which WDT 37231 1371 19 would would MD 37231 1371 20 be be VB 37231 1371 21 foreign foreign JJ 37231 1371 22 to to IN 37231 1371 23 the the DT 37231 1371 24 purpose purpose NN 37231 1371 25 of of IN 37231 1371 26 this this DT 37231 1371 27 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 1371 28 . . . 37231 1372 1 In in IN 37231 1372 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1372 3 Bampton Bampton NNP 37231 1372 4 Lectures Lectures NNP 37231 1372 5 on on IN 37231 1372 6 " " `` 37231 1372 7 The the DT 37231 1372 8 Limit Limit NNP 37231 1372 9 of of IN 37231 1372 10 Religious religious JJ 37231 1372 11 Thought Thought NNP 37231 1372 12 , , , 37231 1372 13 " " '' 37231 1372 14 delivered deliver VBN 37231 1372 15 in in IN 37231 1372 16 1858 1858 CD 37231 1372 17 , , , 37231 1372 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1372 19 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1372 20 , , , 37231 1372 21 the the DT 37231 1372 22 very very RB 37231 1372 23 able able JJ 37231 1372 24 editor editor NN 37231 1372 25 and and CC 37231 1372 26 disciple disciple NN 37231 1372 27 of of IN 37231 1372 28 Sir Sir NNP 37231 1372 29 William William NNP 37231 1372 30 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 37231 1372 31 , , , 37231 1372 32 discussed discuss VBD 37231 1372 33 this this DT 37231 1372 34 subject subject NN 37231 1372 35 with with IN 37231 1372 36 great great JJ 37231 1372 37 minuteness minuteness NN 37231 1372 38 , , , 37231 1372 39 and and CC 37231 1372 40 although although IN 37231 1372 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1372 42 can can MD 37231 1372 43 not not RB 37231 1372 44 pretend pretend VB 37231 1372 45 here here RB 37231 1372 46 to to TO 37231 1372 47 follow follow VB 37231 1372 48 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1372 49 through through IN 37231 1372 50 the the DT 37231 1372 51 whole whole NN 37231 1372 52 of of IN 37231 1372 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1372 54 singular singular JJ 37231 1372 55 argument argument NN 37231 1372 56 -- -- : 37231 1372 57 a a DT 37231 1372 58 theological theological JJ 37231 1372 59 application application NN 37231 1372 60 of of IN 37231 1372 61 Sir Sir NNP 37231 1372 62 William William NNP 37231 1372 63 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 37231 1372 64 's 's POS 37231 1372 65 philosophy philosophy NN 37231 1372 66 -- -- : 37231 1372 67 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1372 68 must must MD 37231 1372 69 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 1372 70 represent represent VB 37231 1372 71 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1372 72 . . . 37231 1373 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1373 2 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1373 3 argues argue VBZ 37231 1373 4 : : : 37231 1373 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1373 6 are be VBP 37231 1373 7 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 1373 8 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1373 9 of of IN 37231 1373 10 conceiving conceive VBG 37231 1373 11 or or CC 37231 1373 12 proving prove VBG 37231 1373 13 the the DT 37231 1373 14 existence existence NN 37231 1373 15 of of IN 37231 1373 16 God God NNP 37231 1373 17 as as IN 37231 1373 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1373 19 is be VBZ 37231 1373 20 ; ; : 37231 1373 21 and and CC 37231 1373 22 so so RB 37231 1373 23 far far RB 37231 1373 24 is be VBZ 37231 1373 25 human human JJ 37231 1373 26 reason reason NN 37231 1373 27 from from IN 37231 1373 28 being be VBG 37231 1373 29 able able JJ 37231 1373 30 to to IN 37231 1373 31 { { -LRB- 37231 1373 32 70 70 CD 37231 1373 33 } } -RRB- 37231 1373 34 construct construct VBP 37231 1373 35 a a DT 37231 1373 36 theology theology NN 37231 1373 37 independent independent JJ 37231 1373 38 of of IN 37231 1373 39 revelation revelation NN 37231 1373 40 that that IN 37231 1373 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1373 42 can can MD 37231 1373 43 not not RB 37231 1373 44 even even RB 37231 1373 45 read read VB 37231 1373 46 the the DT 37231 1373 47 alphabet alphabet NN 37231 1373 48 out out IN 37231 1373 49 of of IN 37231 1373 50 which which WDT 37231 1373 51 that that DT 37231 1373 52 theology theology NN 37231 1373 53 must must MD 37231 1373 54 be be VB 37231 1373 55 formed form VBN 37231 1373 56 . . . 37231 1374 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1374 2 1 1 LS 37231 1374 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1374 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1374 5 are be VBP 37231 1374 6 compelled compel VBN 37231 1374 7 , , , 37231 1374 8 by by IN 37231 1374 9 the the DT 37231 1374 10 constitution constitution NN 37231 1374 11 of of IN 37231 1374 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1374 13 minds mind NNS 37231 1374 14 , , , 37231 1374 15 to to TO 37231 1374 16 believe believe VB 37231 1374 17 in in IN 37231 1374 18 the the DT 37231 1374 19 existence existence NN 37231 1374 20 of of IN 37231 1374 21 an an DT 37231 1374 22 Absolute Absolute NNP 37231 1374 23 and and CC 37231 1374 24 Infinite Infinite NNP 37231 1374 25 Being Being NNP 37231 1374 26 ; ; : 37231 1374 27 but but CC 37231 1374 28 the the DT 37231 1374 29 instant instant NN 37231 1374 30 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1374 31 attempt attempt VBP 37231 1374 32 to to TO 37231 1374 33 analyse analyse VB 37231 1374 34 , , , 37231 1374 35 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1374 36 are be VBP 37231 1374 37 involved involve VBN 37231 1374 38 in in IN 37231 1374 39 inextricable inextricable JJ 37231 1374 40 confusion confusion NN 37231 1374 41 . . . 37231 1375 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1375 2 2 2 LS 37231 1375 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1375 4 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1375 5 moral moral JJ 37231 1375 6 consciousness consciousness NN 37231 1375 7 demands demand VBZ 37231 1375 8 that that IN 37231 1375 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1375 10 should should MD 37231 1375 11 conceive conceive VB 37231 1375 12 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1375 13 as as IN 37231 1375 14 a a DT 37231 1375 15 Personality Personality NNP 37231 1375 16 , , , 37231 1375 17 but but CC 37231 1375 18 personality personality NN 37231 1375 19 , , , 37231 1375 20 as as IN 37231 1375 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1375 22 conceive conceive VBP 37231 1375 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1375 24 , , , 37231 1375 25 is be VBZ 37231 1375 26 essentially essentially RB 37231 1375 27 a a DT 37231 1375 28 limitation limitation NN 37231 1375 29 ; ; : 37231 1375 30 to to TO 37231 1375 31 speak speak VB 37231 1375 32 of of IN 37231 1375 33 an an DT 37231 1375 34 Absolute Absolute NNP 37231 1375 35 and and CC 37231 1375 36 Infinite Infinite NNP 37231 1375 37 Person Person NNP 37231 1375 38 is be VBZ 37231 1375 39 simply simply RB 37231 1375 40 to to TO 37231 1375 41 use use VB 37231 1375 42 language language NN 37231 1375 43 to to TO 37231 1375 44 which which WDT 37231 1375 45 no no DT 37231 1375 46 mode mode NN 37231 1375 47 of of IN 37231 1375 48 human human JJ 37231 1375 49 thought thought NN 37231 1375 50 can can MD 37231 1375 51 possibly possibly RB 37231 1375 52 attach attach VB 37231 1375 53 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1375 54 . . . 37231 1376 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1376 2 3 3 LS 37231 1376 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1376 4 This this DT 37231 1376 5 amounts amount VBZ 37231 1376 6 simply simply RB 37231 1376 7 to to IN 37231 1376 8 an an DT 37231 1376 9 admission admission NN 37231 1376 10 that that IN 37231 1376 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1376 12 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1376 13 of of IN 37231 1376 14 God God NNP 37231 1376 15 does do VBZ 37231 1376 16 not not RB 37231 1376 17 satisfy satisfy VB 37231 1376 18 the the DT 37231 1376 19 conditions condition NNS 37231 1376 20 of of IN 37231 1376 21 speculative speculative JJ 37231 1376 22 philosophy philosophy NN 37231 1376 23 , , , 37231 1376 24 and and CC 37231 1376 25 is be VBZ 37231 1376 26 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1376 27 of of IN 37231 1376 28 reduction reduction NN 37231 1376 29 to to IN 37231 1376 30 an an DT 37231 1376 31 ultimate ultimate JJ 37231 1376 32 and and CC 37231 1376 33 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1376 34 truth truth NN 37231 1376 35 . . . 37231 1377 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1377 2 4 4 LS 37231 1377 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1377 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1377 5 is be VBZ 37231 1377 6 , , , 37231 1377 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 1377 8 , , , 37231 1377 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 1377 10 that that IN 37231 1377 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1377 12 should should MD 37231 1377 13 expect expect VB 37231 1377 14 to to TO 37231 1377 15 find find VB 37231 1377 16 that that IN 37231 1377 17 the the DT 37231 1377 18 revealed reveal VBN 37231 1377 19 manifestation manifestation NN 37231 1377 20 of of IN 37231 1377 21 the the DT 37231 1377 22 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1377 23 nature nature NN 37231 1377 24 and and CC 37231 1377 25 attributes attribute NNS 37231 1377 26 should should MD 37231 1377 27 likewise likewise RB 37231 1377 28 carry carry VB 37231 1377 29 the the DT 37231 1377 30 marks mark NNS 37231 1377 31 of of IN 37231 1377 32 subordination subordination NN 37231 1377 33 to to IN 37231 1377 34 some some DT 37231 1377 35 higher high JJR 37231 1377 36 truth truth NN 37231 1377 37 , , , 37231 1377 38 of of IN 37231 1377 39 which which WDT 37231 1377 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1377 41 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 1377 42 the the DT 37231 1377 43 existence existence NN 37231 1377 44 , , , 37231 1377 45 but but CC 37231 1377 46 does do VBZ 37231 1377 47 not not RB 37231 1377 48 make make VB 37231 1377 49 known know VBN 37231 1377 50 the the DT 37231 1377 51 substance substance NN 37231 1377 52 ; ; : 37231 1377 53 and and CC 37231 1377 54 that that IN 37231 1377 55 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1377 56 apprehension apprehension NN 37231 1377 57 of of IN 37231 1377 58 the the DT 37231 1377 59 revealed reveal VBN 37231 1377 60 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1377 61 should should MD 37231 1377 62 involve involve VB 37231 1377 63 mysteries mystery NNS 37231 1377 64 inscrutable inscrutable JJ 37231 1377 65 , , , 37231 1377 66 and and CC 37231 1377 67 { { -LRB- 37231 1377 68 71 71 CD 37231 1377 69 } } -RRB- 37231 1377 70 doubts doubt VBZ 37231 1377 71 insoluble insoluble JJ 37231 1377 72 by by IN 37231 1377 73 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1377 74 present present JJ 37231 1377 75 faculties faculty NNS 37231 1377 76 , , , 37231 1377 77 while while IN 37231 1377 78 at at IN 37231 1377 79 the the DT 37231 1377 80 same same JJ 37231 1377 81 time time NN 37231 1377 82 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1377 83 inculcates inculcate VBZ 37231 1377 84 the the DT 37231 1377 85 true true JJ 37231 1377 86 spirit spirit NN 37231 1377 87 in in IN 37231 1377 88 which which WDT 37231 1377 89 doubt doubt NN 37231 1377 90 should should MD 37231 1377 91 be be VB 37231 1377 92 dealt deal VBN 37231 1377 93 with with IN 37231 1377 94 by by IN 37231 1377 95 warning warn VBG 37231 1377 96 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1377 97 that that IN 37231 1377 98 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1377 99 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1377 100 of of IN 37231 1377 101 God God NNP 37231 1377 102 , , , 37231 1377 103 though though IN 37231 1377 104 revealed reveal VBN 37231 1377 105 by by IN 37231 1377 106 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1377 107 , , , 37231 1377 108 is be VBZ 37231 1377 109 revealed reveal VBN 37231 1377 110 in in IN 37231 1377 111 relation relation NN 37231 1377 112 to to IN 37231 1377 113 human human JJ 37231 1377 114 faculties faculty NNS 37231 1377 115 , , , 37231 1377 116 and and CC 37231 1377 117 subject subject JJ 37231 1377 118 to to IN 37231 1377 119 the the DT 37231 1377 120 limitations limitation NNS 37231 1377 121 and and CC 37231 1377 122 imperfections imperfection NNS 37231 1377 123 inseparable inseparable JJ 37231 1377 124 from from IN 37231 1377 125 the the DT 37231 1377 126 constitution constitution NN 37231 1377 127 of of IN 37231 1377 128 the the DT 37231 1377 129 human human JJ 37231 1377 130 mind mind NN 37231 1377 131 . . . 37231 1378 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1378 2 1 1 LS 37231 1378 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1378 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1378 5 need need VBP 37231 1378 6 not not RB 37231 1378 7 , , , 37231 1378 8 of of IN 37231 1378 9 course course NN 37231 1378 10 , , , 37231 1378 11 point point VB 37231 1378 12 out out RP 37231 1378 13 that that IN 37231 1378 14 the the DT 37231 1378 15 reality reality NN 37231 1378 16 of of IN 37231 1378 17 revelation revelation NN 37231 1378 18 is be VBZ 37231 1378 19 here here RB 37231 1378 20 assumed assume VBN 37231 1378 21 . . . 37231 1379 1 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 1379 2 , , , 37231 1379 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1379 4 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1379 5 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 1379 6 that that DT 37231 1379 7 philosophy philosophy NN 37231 1379 8 , , , 37231 1379 9 by by IN 37231 1379 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1379 11 own own JJ 37231 1379 12 incongruities incongruity NNS 37231 1379 13 , , , 37231 1379 14 has have VBZ 37231 1379 15 no no DT 37231 1379 16 claim claim NN 37231 1379 17 to to TO 37231 1379 18 be be VB 37231 1379 19 accepted accept VBN 37231 1379 20 as as IN 37231 1379 21 a a DT 37231 1379 22 competent competent JJ 37231 1379 23 witness witness NN 37231 1379 24 ; ; : 37231 1379 25 and and CC 37231 1379 26 , , , 37231 1379 27 on on IN 37231 1379 28 the the DT 37231 1379 29 other other JJ 37231 1379 30 hand hand NN 37231 1379 31 , , , 37231 1379 32 human human JJ 37231 1379 33 personality personality NN 37231 1379 34 can can MD 37231 1379 35 not not RB 37231 1379 36 be be VB 37231 1379 37 assumed assume VBN 37231 1379 38 as as IN 37231 1379 39 an an DT 37231 1379 40 exact exact JJ 37231 1379 41 copy copy NN 37231 1379 42 of of IN 37231 1379 43 the the DT 37231 1379 44 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1379 45 , , , 37231 1379 46 but but CC 37231 1379 47 only only RB 37231 1379 48 as as IN 37231 1379 49 that that DT 37231 1379 50 which which WDT 37231 1379 51 is be VBZ 37231 1379 52 most most RBS 37231 1379 53 nearly nearly RB 37231 1379 54 analogous analogous JJ 37231 1379 55 to to IN 37231 1379 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1379 57 among among IN 37231 1379 58 finite finite JJ 37231 1379 59 things thing NNS 37231 1379 60 . . . 37231 1380 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1380 2 2 2 LS 37231 1380 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1380 4 As as IN 37231 1380 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1380 6 are be VBP 37231 1380 7 , , , 37231 1380 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 1380 9 , , , 37231 1380 10 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1380 11 on on IN 37231 1380 12 the the DT 37231 1380 13 one one CD 37231 1380 14 hand hand NN 37231 1380 15 of of IN 37231 1380 16 a a DT 37231 1380 17 clear clear JJ 37231 1380 18 conception conception NN 37231 1380 19 of of IN 37231 1380 20 the the DT 37231 1380 21 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1380 22 Being Being NNP 37231 1380 23 , , , 37231 1380 24 and and CC 37231 1380 25 have have VBP 37231 1380 26 only only RB 37231 1380 27 analogy analogy NN 37231 1380 28 to to TO 37231 1380 29 guide guide VB 37231 1380 30 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1380 31 in in IN 37231 1380 32 conceiving conceive VBG 37231 1380 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1380 34 attributes attribute NNS 37231 1380 35 , , , 37231 1380 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1380 37 have have VBP 37231 1380 38 no no DT 37231 1380 39 criterion criterion NN 37231 1380 40 of of IN 37231 1380 41 religious religious JJ 37231 1380 42 truth truth NN 37231 1380 43 or or CC 37231 1380 44 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1380 45 , , , 37231 1380 46 enabling enable VBG 37231 1380 47 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1380 48 to to TO 37231 1380 49 judge judge VB 37231 1380 50 of of IN 37231 1380 51 the the DT 37231 1380 52 ways way NNS 37231 1380 53 of of IN 37231 1380 54 God God NNP 37231 1380 55 , , , 37231 1380 56 represented represent VBN 37231 1380 57 by by IN 37231 1380 58 revelation,(3 revelation,(3 NNP 37231 1380 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1380 60 and and CC 37231 1380 61 have have VBP 37231 1380 62 no no DT 37231 1380 63 right right NN 37231 1380 64 to to TO 37231 1380 65 judge judge VB 37231 1380 66 of of IN 37231 1380 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1380 68 justice justice NN 37231 1380 69 , , , 37231 1380 70 or or CC 37231 1380 71 mercy mercy NN 37231 1380 72 , , , 37231 1380 73 or or CC 37231 1380 74 goodness goodness NN 37231 1380 75 , , , 37231 1380 76 by by IN 37231 1380 77 the the DT 37231 1380 78 standard standard NN 37231 1380 79 of of IN 37231 1380 80 human human JJ 37231 1380 81 morality morality NN 37231 1380 82 . . . 37231 1381 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1381 2 is be VBZ 37231 1381 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1381 4 to to TO 37231 1381 5 conceive conceive VB 37231 1381 6 an an DT 37231 1381 7 argument argument NN 37231 1381 8 more more RBR 37231 1381 9 vicious vicious JJ 37231 1381 10 , , , 37231 1381 11 or or CC 37231 1381 12 more more RBR 37231 1381 13 obviously obviously RB 37231 1381 14 warped warped JJ 37231 1381 15 to to TO 37231 1381 16 favour favour VB 37231 1381 17 already already RB 37231 1381 18 accepted accept VBN 37231 1381 19 { { -LRB- 37231 1381 20 72 72 CD 37231 1381 21 } } -RRB- 37231 1381 22 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1381 23 of of IN 37231 1381 24 revelation:--As revelation:--As NNP 37231 1381 25 finite finite JJ 37231 1381 26 beings being NNS 37231 1381 27 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1381 28 are be VBP 37231 1381 29 not not RB 37231 1381 30 only only RB 37231 1381 31 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1381 32 of of IN 37231 1381 33 proving prove VBG 37231 1381 34 the the DT 37231 1381 35 existence existence NN 37231 1381 36 of of IN 37231 1381 37 God God NNP 37231 1381 38 , , , 37231 1381 39 but but CC 37231 1381 40 even even RB 37231 1381 41 of of IN 37231 1381 42 conceiving conceive VBG 37231 1381 43 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1381 44 as as IN 37231 1381 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1381 46 is be VBZ 37231 1381 47 ; ; : 37231 1381 48 therefore therefore RB 37231 1381 49 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1381 50 may may MD 37231 1381 51 conceive conceive VB 37231 1381 52 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1381 53 as as IN 37231 1381 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1381 55 is be VBZ 37231 1381 56 not not RB 37231 1381 57 . . . 37231 1382 1 To to TO 37231 1382 2 attribute attribute VB 37231 1382 3 personality personality NN 37231 1382 4 to to IN 37231 1382 5 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1382 6 is be VBZ 37231 1382 7 a a DT 37231 1382 8 limitation limitation NN 37231 1382 9 totally totally RB 37231 1382 10 incompatible incompatible JJ 37231 1382 11 with with IN 37231 1382 12 the the DT 37231 1382 13 idea idea NN 37231 1382 14 of of IN 37231 1382 15 an an DT 37231 1382 16 Absolute Absolute NNP 37231 1382 17 and and CC 37231 1382 18 Infinite Infinite NNP 37231 1382 19 Being Being NNP 37231 1382 20 , , , 37231 1382 21 in in IN 37231 1382 22 which which WDT 37231 1382 23 " " `` 37231 1382 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1382 25 are be VBP 37231 1382 26 compelled compel VBN 37231 1382 27 by by IN 37231 1382 28 the the DT 37231 1382 29 constitution constitution NN 37231 1382 30 of of IN 37231 1382 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1382 32 minds mind NNS 37231 1382 33 to to TO 37231 1382 34 believe believe VB 37231 1382 35 ; ; : 37231 1382 36 " " `` 37231 1382 37 and and CC 37231 1382 38 to to TO 37231 1382 39 speak speak VB 37231 1382 40 of of IN 37231 1382 41 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1382 42 as as IN 37231 1382 43 a a DT 37231 1382 44 personality personality NN 37231 1382 45 is be VBZ 37231 1382 46 " " `` 37231 1382 47 to to TO 37231 1382 48 use use VB 37231 1382 49 language language NN 37231 1382 50 to to TO 37231 1382 51 which which WDT 37231 1382 52 no no DT 37231 1382 53 mode mode NN 37231 1382 54 of of IN 37231 1382 55 human human JJ 37231 1382 56 thought thought NN 37231 1382 57 can can MD 37231 1382 58 possibly possibly RB 37231 1382 59 attach attach VB 37231 1382 60 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1382 61 ; ; : 37231 1382 62 " " `` 37231 1382 63 but but CC 37231 1382 64 , , , 37231 1382 65 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 1382 66 , , , 37231 1382 67 to to TO 37231 1382 68 satisfy satisfy VB 37231 1382 69 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1382 70 demands demand NNS 37231 1382 71 of of IN 37231 1382 72 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1382 73 moral moral JJ 37231 1382 74 consciousness consciousness NN 37231 1382 75 , , , 37231 1382 76 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1382 77 are be VBP 37231 1382 78 to to TO 37231 1382 79 conceive conceive VB 37231 1382 80 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1382 81 as as IN 37231 1382 82 a a DT 37231 1382 83 personality personality NN 37231 1382 84 . . . 37231 1383 1 Although although IN 37231 1383 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1383 3 must must MD 37231 1383 4 define define VB 37231 1383 5 the the DT 37231 1383 6 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1383 7 Being Being NNP 37231 1383 8 as as IN 37231 1383 9 a a DT 37231 1383 10 personality personality NN 37231 1383 11 to to TO 37231 1383 12 satisfy satisfy VB 37231 1383 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1383 14 moral moral JJ 37231 1383 15 consciousness consciousness NN 37231 1383 16 , , , 37231 1383 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1383 18 must must MD 37231 1383 19 not not RB 37231 1383 20 , , , 37231 1383 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1383 22 are be VBP 37231 1383 23 told tell VBN 37231 1383 24 , , , 37231 1383 25 make make VB 37231 1383 26 the the DT 37231 1383 27 same same JJ 37231 1383 28 moral moral JJ 37231 1383 29 consciousness consciousness NN 37231 1383 30 the the DT 37231 1383 31 criterion criterion NN 37231 1383 32 of of IN 37231 1383 33 the the DT 37231 1383 34 attributes attribute NNS 37231 1383 35 of of IN 37231 1383 36 that that DT 37231 1383 37 personality personality NN 37231 1383 38 . . . 37231 1384 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 2 must must MD 37231 1384 3 not not RB 37231 1384 4 suppose suppose VB 37231 1384 5 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 6 to to TO 37231 1384 7 be be VB 37231 1384 8 endowed endow VBN 37231 1384 9 , , , 37231 1384 10 for for IN 37231 1384 11 instance instance NN 37231 1384 12 , , , 37231 1384 13 with with IN 37231 1384 14 the the DT 37231 1384 15 perfection perfection NN 37231 1384 16 of of IN 37231 1384 17 morality morality NN 37231 1384 18 according accord VBG 37231 1384 19 to to IN 37231 1384 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1384 21 ideas idea NNS 37231 1384 22 of of IN 37231 1384 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 24 ; ; : 37231 1384 25 but but CC 37231 1384 26 , , , 37231 1384 27 on on IN 37231 1384 28 the the DT 37231 1384 29 contrary contrary NN 37231 1384 30 , , , 37231 1384 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 32 must must MD 37231 1384 33 hold hold VB 37231 1384 34 that that IN 37231 1384 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1384 36 moral moral JJ 37231 1384 37 perfections perfection NNS 37231 1384 38 are be VBP 37231 1384 39 at at IN 37231 1384 40 best good JJS 37231 1384 41 only only RB 37231 1384 42 analogous analogous JJ 37231 1384 43 , , , 37231 1384 44 and and CC 37231 1384 45 often often RB 37231 1384 46 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1384 47 , , , 37231 1384 48 to to IN 37231 1384 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1384 50 standard standard NN 37231 1384 51 of of IN 37231 1384 52 morality.1 morality.1 CD 37231 1384 53 As as RB 37231 1384 54 soon soon RB 37231 1384 55 as as IN 37231 1384 56 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 57 conceive conceive VBP 37231 1384 58 a a DT 37231 1384 59 Personal personal JJ 37231 1384 60 Deity deity NN 37231 1384 61 to to TO 37231 1384 62 satisfy satisfy VB 37231 1384 63 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1384 64 moral moral JJ 37231 1384 65 consciousness consciousness NN 37231 1384 66 , , , 37231 1384 67 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 68 have have VBP 37231 1384 69 to to TO 37231 1384 70 abandon abandon VB 37231 1384 71 the the DT 37231 1384 72 personality personality NN 37231 1384 73 which which WDT 37231 1384 74 satisfies satisfie NNS 37231 1384 75 that that DT 37231 1384 76 consciousness consciousness NN 37231 1384 77 , , , 37231 1384 78 in in IN 37231 1384 79 order order NN 37231 1384 80 to to TO 37231 1384 81 accept accept VB 37231 1384 82 the the DT 37231 1384 83 characteristics characteristic NNS 37231 1384 84 of of IN 37231 1384 85 a a DT 37231 1384 86 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1384 87 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1384 88 , , , 37231 1384 89 to to TO 37231 1384 90 reconcile reconcile VB 37231 1384 91 certain certain JJ 37231 1384 92 statements statement NNS 37231 1384 93 of of IN 37231 1384 94 which which WDT 37231 1384 95 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 96 must must MD 37231 1384 97 admit admit VB 37231 1384 98 that that IN 37231 1384 99 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 100 have have VBP 37231 1384 101 no no DT 37231 1384 102 criterion criterion NN 37231 1384 103 of of IN 37231 1384 104 truth truth NN 37231 1384 105 or or CC 37231 1384 106 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1384 107 enabling enable VBG 37231 1384 108 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1384 109 to to TO 37231 1384 110 judge judge VB 37231 1384 111 of of IN 37231 1384 112 the the DT 37231 1384 113 ways way NNS 37231 1384 114 of of IN 37231 1384 115 God God NNP 37231 1384 116 . . . 37231 1385 1 Now now RB 37231 1385 2 , , , 37231 1385 3 in in IN 37231 1385 4 reference reference NN 37231 1385 5 to to IN 37231 1385 6 the the DT 37231 1385 7 assumption assumption NN 37231 1385 8 of of IN 37231 1385 9 a a DT 37231 1385 10 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1385 11 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1385 12 as as IN 37231 1385 13 a a DT 37231 1385 14 preliminary preliminary NN 37231 1385 15 to to IN 37231 1385 16 the the DT 37231 1385 17 proof proof NN 37231 1385 18 of of IN 37231 1385 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1385 20 , , , 37231 1385 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1385 22 must must MD 37231 1385 23 be be VB 37231 1385 24 clearly clearly RB 37231 1385 25 remembered remember VBN 37231 1385 26 that that IN 37231 1385 27 the the DT 37231 1385 28 contents content NNS 37231 1385 29 of of IN 37231 1385 30 the the DT 37231 1385 31 revelation revelation NN 37231 1385 32 which which WDT 37231 1385 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1385 34 are be VBP 37231 1385 35 to to TO 37231 1385 36 authenticate authenticate VB 37231 1385 37 can can MD 37231 1385 38 not not RB 37231 1385 39 { { -LRB- 37231 1385 40 73 73 CD 37231 1385 41 } } -RRB- 37231 1385 42 have have VBP 37231 1385 43 any any DT 37231 1385 44 weight weight NN 37231 1385 45 . . . 37231 1386 1 Antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1386 2 , , , 37231 1386 3 then then RB 37231 1386 4 , , , 37231 1386 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1386 6 is be VBZ 37231 1386 7 admitted admit VBN 37231 1386 8 that that IN 37231 1386 9 personality personality NN 37231 1386 10 is be VBZ 37231 1386 11 a a DT 37231 1386 12 limitation limitation NN 37231 1386 13 which which WDT 37231 1386 14 is be VBZ 37231 1386 15 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 1386 16 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1386 17 by by IN 37231 1386 18 the the DT 37231 1386 19 ideas idea NNS 37231 1386 20 of of IN 37231 1386 21 the the DT 37231 1386 22 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1386 23 , , , 37231 1386 24 which which WDT 37231 1386 25 , , , 37231 1386 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1386 27 is be VBZ 37231 1386 28 asserted assert VBN 37231 1386 29 , , , 37231 1386 30 the the DT 37231 1386 31 constitution constitution NN 37231 1386 32 of of IN 37231 1386 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1386 34 minds mind NNS 37231 1386 35 compete compete VBP 37231 1386 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1386 37 to to TO 37231 1386 38 form form VB 37231 1386 39 . . . 37231 1387 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1387 2 can can MD 37231 1387 3 not not RB 37231 1387 4 , , , 37231 1387 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 1387 6 , , , 37231 1387 7 be be VB 37231 1387 8 rationally rationally RB 37231 1387 9 assumed assume VBN 37231 1387 10 . . . 37231 1388 1 To to TO 37231 1388 2 admit admit VB 37231 1388 3 that that IN 37231 1388 4 such such PDT 37231 1388 5 a a DT 37231 1388 6 conception conception NN 37231 1388 7 is be VBZ 37231 1388 8 false false JJ 37231 1388 9 , , , 37231 1388 10 and and CC 37231 1388 11 then then RB 37231 1388 12 to to TO 37231 1388 13 base base VB 37231 1388 14 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1388 15 upon upon IN 37231 1388 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1388 17 , , , 37231 1388 18 as as IN 37231 1388 19 though though IN 37231 1388 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1388 21 were be VBD 37231 1388 22 true true JJ 37231 1388 23 , , , 37231 1388 24 is be VBZ 37231 1388 25 absurd absurd JJ 37231 1388 26 . . . 37231 1389 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1389 2 is be VBZ 37231 1389 3 child child NN 37231 1389 4 's 's POS 37231 1389 5 play play NN 37231 1389 6 to to TO 37231 1389 7 satisfy satisfy VB 37231 1389 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1389 9 feeling feeling NN 37231 1389 10 and and CC 37231 1389 11 imagination imagination NN 37231 1389 12 by by IN 37231 1389 13 the the DT 37231 1389 14 conscious conscious JJ 37231 1389 15 sacrifice sacrifice NN 37231 1389 16 of of IN 37231 1389 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1389 18 reason reason NN 37231 1389 19 . . . 37231 1390 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 1390 2 , , , 37231 1390 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1390 4 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1390 5 admits admit VBZ 37231 1390 6 that that IN 37231 1390 7 the the DT 37231 1390 8 conception conception NN 37231 1390 9 of of IN 37231 1390 10 a a DT 37231 1390 11 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1390 12 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1390 13 is be VBZ 37231 1390 14 really really RB 37231 1390 15 derived derive VBN 37231 1390 16 from from IN 37231 1390 17 the the DT 37231 1390 18 revelation revelation NN 37231 1390 19 , , , 37231 1390 20 which which WDT 37231 1390 21 has have VBZ 37231 1390 22 to to TO 37231 1390 23 be be VB 37231 1390 24 rendered render VBN 37231 1390 25 credible credible JJ 37231 1390 26 by by IN 37231 1390 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1390 28 ; ; : 37231 1390 29 therefore therefore RB 37231 1390 30 the the DT 37231 1390 31 consequence consequence NN 37231 1390 32 already already RB 37231 1390 33 pointed point VBD 37231 1390 34 out out RP 37231 1390 35 ensues ensue NNS 37231 1390 36 , , , 37231 1390 37 that that IN 37231 1390 38 the the DT 37231 1390 39 assumption assumption NN 37231 1390 40 can can MD 37231 1390 41 not not RB 37231 1390 42 be be VB 37231 1390 43 used use VBN 37231 1390 44 to to TO 37231 1390 45 prove prove VB 37231 1390 46 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1390 47 . . . 37231 1391 1 " " `` 37231 1391 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1391 3 must must MD 37231 1391 4 be be VB 37231 1391 5 allowed allow VBN 37231 1391 6 that that IN 37231 1391 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1391 8 is be VBZ 37231 1391 9 not not RB 37231 1391 10 through through IN 37231 1391 11 reasoning reason VBG 37231 1391 12 that that IN 37231 1391 13 men man NNS 37231 1391 14 obtain obtain VBP 37231 1391 15 the the DT 37231 1391 16 first first JJ 37231 1391 17 intimation intimation NN 37231 1391 18 of of IN 37231 1391 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1391 20 relation relation NN 37231 1391 21 to to IN 37231 1391 22 the the DT 37231 1391 23 Deity deity NN 37231 1391 24 ; ; : 37231 1391 25 and and CC 37231 1391 26 that that DT 37231 1391 27 , , , 37231 1391 28 had have VBD 37231 1391 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1391 30 been be VBN 37231 1391 31 left leave VBN 37231 1391 32 to to IN 37231 1391 33 the the DT 37231 1391 34 guidance guidance NN 37231 1391 35 of of IN 37231 1391 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1391 37 intellectual intellectual JJ 37231 1391 38 faculties faculty NNS 37231 1391 39 alone alone RB 37231 1391 40 , , , 37231 1391 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1391 42 is be VBZ 37231 1391 43 possible possible JJ 37231 1391 44 that that IN 37231 1391 45 no no DT 37231 1391 46 such such JJ 37231 1391 47 intimation intimation NN 37231 1391 48 might may MD 37231 1391 49 have have VB 37231 1391 50 taken take VBN 37231 1391 51 place place NN 37231 1391 52 ; ; : 37231 1391 53 or or CC 37231 1391 54 at at IN 37231 1391 55 best good JJS 37231 1391 56 , , , 37231 1391 57 that that IN 37231 1391 58 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1391 59 would would MD 37231 1391 60 have have VB 37231 1391 61 been be VBN 37231 1391 62 but but CC 37231 1391 63 as as IN 37231 1391 64 one one CD 37231 1391 65 guess guess NN 37231 1391 66 , , , 37231 1391 67 out out IN 37231 1391 68 of of IN 37231 1391 69 many many JJ 37231 1391 70 equally equally RB 37231 1391 71 plausible plausible JJ 37231 1391 72 and and CC 37231 1391 73 equally equally RB 37231 1391 74 natural natural JJ 37231 1391 75 . . . 37231 1392 1 " " `` 37231 1392 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1392 3 1 1 LS 37231 1392 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1392 5 The the DT 37231 1392 6 vicious vicious JJ 37231 1392 7 circle circle NN 37231 1392 8 of of IN 37231 1392 9 the the DT 37231 1392 10 argument argument NN 37231 1392 11 is be VBZ 37231 1392 12 here here RB 37231 1392 13 again again RB 37231 1392 14 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1392 15 , , , 37231 1392 16 and and CC 37231 1392 17 the the DT 37231 1392 18 singular singular JJ 37231 1392 19 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1392 20 by by IN 37231 1392 21 which which WDT 37231 1392 22 the the DT 37231 1392 23 late late JJ 37231 1392 24 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1392 25 of of IN 37231 1392 26 St. St. NNP 37231 1392 27 Paul Paul NNP 37231 1392 28 's 's POS 37231 1392 29 seeks seek NNS 37231 1392 30 to to TO 37231 1392 31 drive drive VB 37231 1392 32 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1392 33 into into IN 37231 1392 34 an an DT 37231 1392 35 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 1392 36 of of IN 37231 1392 37 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1392 38 is be VBZ 37231 1392 39 really really RB 37231 1392 40 the the DT 37231 1392 41 strongest strong JJS 37231 1392 42 argument argument NN 37231 1392 43 against against IN 37231 1392 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1392 45 . . . 37231 1393 1 The the DT 37231 1393 2 impossibility impossibility NN 37231 1393 3 of of IN 37231 1393 4 conceiving conceive VBG 37231 1393 5 God God NNP 37231 1393 6 as as IN 37231 1393 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1393 8 is,(2 is,(2 VBD 37231 1393 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1393 10 which which WDT 37231 1393 11 is be VBZ 37231 1393 12 insisted insist VBN 37231 1393 13 upon upon IN 37231 1393 14 , , , 37231 1393 15 instead instead RB 37231 1393 16 of of IN 37231 1393 17 being be VBG 37231 1393 18 a a DT 37231 1393 19 { { -LRB- 37231 1393 20 74 74 CD 37231 1393 21 } } -RRB- 37231 1393 22 reason reason NN 37231 1393 23 for for IN 37231 1393 24 assuming assume VBG 37231 1393 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1393 26 personality personality NN 37231 1393 27 , , , 37231 1393 28 or or CC 37231 1393 29 for for IN 37231 1393 30 accepting accept VBG 37231 1393 31 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1393 32 conceptions conception NNS 37231 1393 33 of of IN 37231 1393 34 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1393 35 , , , 37231 1393 36 totally totally RB 37231 1393 37 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 1393 38 such such PDT 37231 1393 39 an an DT 37231 1393 40 assumption assumption NN 37231 1393 41 . . . 37231 1394 1 This this DT 37231 1394 2 " " `` 37231 1394 3 great great JJ 37231 1394 4 religious religious JJ 37231 1394 5 assumption"(1 assumption"(1 NNP 37231 1394 6 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1394 7 is be VBZ 37231 1394 8 not not RB 37231 1394 9 suggested suggest VBN 37231 1394 10 by by IN 37231 1394 11 any any DT 37231 1394 12 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1394 13 considerations consideration NNS 37231 1394 14 , , , 37231 1394 15 but but CC 37231 1394 16 is be VBZ 37231 1394 17 required require VBN 37231 1394 18 to to TO 37231 1394 19 account account VB 37231 1394 20 for for IN 37231 1394 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1394 22 , , , 37231 1394 23 and and CC 37231 1394 24 is be VBZ 37231 1394 25 derived derive VBN 37231 1394 26 from from IN 37231 1394 27 the the DT 37231 1394 28 very very JJ 37231 1394 29 Revelation revelation NN 37231 1394 30 which which WDT 37231 1394 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1394 32 are be VBP 37231 1394 33 to to TO 37231 1394 34 attest attest VB 37231 1394 35 . . . 37231 1395 1 " " `` 37231 1395 2 In in IN 37231 1395 3 nature nature NN 37231 1395 4 and and CC 37231 1395 5 from from IN 37231 1395 6 nature nature NN 37231 1395 7 , , , 37231 1395 8 " " '' 37231 1395 9 to to TO 37231 1395 10 quote quote VB 37231 1395 11 Words word NNS 37231 1395 12 of of IN 37231 1395 13 Professor Professor NNP 37231 1395 14 Baden Baden NNP 37231 1395 15 Powell Powell NNP 37231 1395 16 , , , 37231 1395 17 " " `` 37231 1395 18 by by IN 37231 1395 19 science science NN 37231 1395 20 and and CC 37231 1395 21 by by IN 37231 1395 22 reason reason NN 37231 1395 23 , , , 37231 1395 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1395 25 neither neither CC 37231 1395 26 have have VBP 37231 1395 27 nor nor CC 37231 1395 28 can can MD 37231 1395 29 possibly possibly RB 37231 1395 30 have have VB 37231 1395 31 any any DT 37231 1395 32 evidence evidence NN 37231 1395 33 of of IN 37231 1395 34 a a DT 37231 1395 35 _ _ NNP 37231 1395 36 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1395 37 working work VBG 37231 1395 38 _ _ NNP 37231 1395 39 miracles;--for miracles;--for IN 37231 1395 40 that that IN 37231 1395 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1395 42 must must MD 37231 1395 43 go go VB 37231 1395 44 out out IN 37231 1395 45 of of IN 37231 1395 46 nature nature NN 37231 1395 47 and and CC 37231 1395 48 beyond beyond IN 37231 1395 49 science science NN 37231 1395 50 . . . 37231 1396 1 If if IN 37231 1396 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1396 3 could could MD 37231 1396 4 have have VB 37231 1396 5 any any DT 37231 1396 6 such such JJ 37231 1396 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 1396 8 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 9 from from IN 37231 1396 10 nature nature NN 37231 1396 11 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 12 , , , 37231 1396 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1396 14 could could MD 37231 1396 15 only only RB 37231 1396 16 prove prove VB 37231 1396 17 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 1396 18 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 19 natural natural JJ 37231 1396 20 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 21 effects effect NNS 37231 1396 22 , , , 37231 1396 23 which which WDT 37231 1396 24 would would MD 37231 1396 25 not not RB 37231 1396 26 be be VB 37231 1396 27 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1396 29 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 30 in in IN 37231 1396 31 the the DT 37231 1396 32 old old JJ 37231 1396 33 theological theological JJ 37231 1396 34 sense sense NN 37231 1396 35 , , , 37231 1396 36 as as IN 37231 1396 37 isolated isolated JJ 37231 1396 38 , , , 37231 1396 39 unrelated unrelated JJ 37231 1396 40 , , , 37231 1396 41 and and CC 37231 1396 42 uncaused uncaused JJ 37231 1396 43 ; ; : 37231 1396 44 whereas whereas IN 37231 1396 45 no no DT 37231 1396 46 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 47 physical physical NN 37231 1396 48 _ _ NNP 37231 1396 49 fact fact NN 37231 1396 50 can can MD 37231 1396 51 be be VB 37231 1396 52 conceived conceive VBN 37231 1396 53 as as RB 37231 1396 54 unique unique JJ 37231 1396 55 , , , 37231 1396 56 or or CC 37231 1396 57 without without IN 37231 1396 58 analogy analogy NN 37231 1396 59 and and CC 37231 1396 60 relation relation NN 37231 1396 61 to to IN 37231 1396 62 others other NNS 37231 1396 63 , , , 37231 1396 64 and and CC 37231 1396 65 to to IN 37231 1396 66 the the DT 37231 1396 67 whole whole JJ 37231 1396 68 system system NN 37231 1396 69 of of IN 37231 1396 70 natural natural JJ 37231 1396 71 causes cause NNS 37231 1396 72 . . . 37231 1397 1 " " `` 37231 1397 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1397 3 2 2 LS 37231 1397 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1397 5 Being be VBG 37231 1397 6 , , , 37231 1397 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 1397 8 , , , 37231 1397 9 limited limit VBN 37231 1397 10 to to IN 37231 1397 11 Reason Reason NNP 37231 1397 12 for for IN 37231 1397 13 any any DT 37231 1397 14 feeble feeble JJ 37231 1397 15 conception conception NN 37231 1397 16 of of IN 37231 1397 17 a a DT 37231 1397 18 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1397 19 Being Being NNP 37231 1397 20 of of IN 37231 1397 21 which which WDT 37231 1397 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1397 23 may may MD 37231 1397 24 be be VB 37231 1397 25 capable capable JJ 37231 1397 26 , , , 37231 1397 27 and and CC 37231 1397 28 Reason reason NN 37231 1397 29 being be VBG 37231 1397 30 totally totally RB 37231 1397 31 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1397 32 to to IN 37231 1397 33 the the DT 37231 1397 34 idea idea NN 37231 1397 35 of of IN 37231 1397 36 an an DT 37231 1397 37 order order NN 37231 1397 38 of of IN 37231 1397 39 nature nature NN 37231 1397 40 so so RB 37231 1397 41 imperfect imperfect JJ 37231 1397 42 as as IN 37231 1397 43 to to TO 37231 1397 44 require require VB 37231 1397 45 or or CC 37231 1397 46 permit permit VB 37231 1397 47 repeated repeat VBN 37231 1397 48 interference interference NN 37231 1397 49 , , , 37231 1397 50 and and CC 37231 1397 51 rejecting reject VBG 37231 1397 52 the the DT 37231 1397 53 supposition supposition NN 37231 1397 54 of of IN 37231 1397 55 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 1397 56 { { -LRB- 37231 1397 57 75 75 CD 37231 1397 58 } } -RRB- 37231 1397 59 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1397 60 of of IN 37231 1397 61 Law Law NNP 37231 1397 62 , , , 37231 1397 63 such such PDT 37231 1397 64 a a DT 37231 1397 65 conception conception NN 37231 1397 66 of of IN 37231 1397 67 a a DT 37231 1397 68 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1397 69 as as IN 37231 1397 70 is be VBZ 37231 1397 71 proposed propose VBN 37231 1397 72 by by IN 37231 1397 73 theologians theologian NNS 37231 1397 74 must must MD 37231 1397 75 be be VB 37231 1397 76 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 1397 77 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1397 78 and and CC 37231 1397 79 derogatory derogatory JJ 37231 1397 80 . . . 37231 1398 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1398 2 is be VBZ 37231 1398 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1398 4 for for IN 37231 1398 5 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1398 6 to to TO 37231 1398 7 conceive conceive VB 37231 1398 8 a a DT 37231 1398 9 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1398 10 Being Being NNP 37231 1398 11 acting act VBG 37231 1398 12 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 1398 13 than than IN 37231 1398 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1398 15 actually actually RB 37231 1398 16 see see VBP 37231 1398 17 in in IN 37231 1398 18 nature nature NN 37231 1398 19 , , , 37231 1398 20 and and CC 37231 1398 21 if if IN 37231 1398 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1398 23 recognize recognize VBP 37231 1398 24 in in IN 37231 1398 25 the the DT 37231 1398 26 universe universe NN 37231 1398 27 the the DT 37231 1398 28 operation operation NN 37231 1398 29 of of IN 37231 1398 30 infinite infinite JJ 37231 1398 31 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1398 32 and and CC 37231 1398 33 power power NN 37231 1398 34 , , , 37231 1398 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1398 36 is be VBZ 37231 1398 37 in in IN 37231 1398 38 the the DT 37231 1398 39 immutable immutable JJ 37231 1398 40 order order NN 37231 1398 41 and and CC 37231 1398 42 regularity regularity NN 37231 1398 43 of of IN 37231 1398 44 all all DT 37231 1398 45 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1398 46 , , , 37231 1398 47 and and CC 37231 1398 48 in in IN 37231 1398 49 the the DT 37231 1398 50 eternal eternal JJ 37231 1398 51 prevalence prevalence NN 37231 1398 52 of of IN 37231 1398 53 Law Law NNP 37231 1398 54 , , , 37231 1398 55 that that IN 37231 1398 56 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1398 57 see see VBP 37231 1398 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1398 59 highest high JJS 37231 1398 60 manifestation manifestation NN 37231 1398 61 . . . 37231 1399 1 This this DT 37231 1399 2 is be VBZ 37231 1399 3 no no DT 37231 1399 4 conception conception NN 37231 1399 5 based base VBN 37231 1399 6 merely merely RB 37231 1399 7 upon upon IN 37231 1399 8 observation observation NN 37231 1399 9 of of IN 37231 1399 10 law law NN 37231 1399 11 and and CC 37231 1399 12 order order NN 37231 1399 13 in in IN 37231 1399 14 the the DT 37231 1399 15 material material NN 37231 1399 16 world world NN 37231 1399 17 , , , 37231 1399 18 as as IN 37231 1399 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1399 20 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1399 21 insinuates,(1 insinuates,(1 NNP 37231 1399 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1399 23 but but CC 37231 1399 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1399 25 is be VBZ 37231 1399 26 likewise likewise RB 37231 1399 27 the the DT 37231 1399 28 result result NN 37231 1399 29 of of IN 37231 1399 30 the the DT 37231 1399 31 highest high JJS 37231 1399 32 exercise exercise NN 37231 1399 33 of of IN 37231 1399 34 mind mind NN 37231 1399 35 . . . 37231 1400 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1400 2 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1400 3 " " `` 37231 1400 4 does do VBZ 37231 1400 5 not not RB 37231 1400 6 hesitate hesitate VB 37231 1400 7 to to TO 37231 1400 8 affirm affirm VB 37231 1400 9 with with IN 37231 1400 10 Sir Sir NNP 37231 1400 11 William William NNP 37231 1400 12 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 37231 1400 13 " " '' 37231 1400 14 that that IN 37231 1400 15 the the DT 37231 1400 16 class class NN 37231 1400 17 of of IN 37231 1400 18 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1400 19 which which WDT 37231 1400 20 requires require VBZ 37231 1400 21 that that DT 37231 1400 22 kind kind NN 37231 1400 23 of of RB 37231 1400 24 cause cause IN 37231 1400 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1400 26 denominate denominate VBP 37231 1400 27 a a DT 37231 1400 28 Deity deity NN 37231 1400 29 is be VBZ 37231 1400 30 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 1400 31 given give VBN 37231 1400 32 in in IN 37231 1400 33 the the DT 37231 1400 34 phenomena phenomena NN 37231 1400 35 of of IN 37231 1400 36 mind mind NN 37231 1400 37 ; ; : 37231 1400 38 that that IN 37231 1400 39 the the DT 37231 1400 40 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1400 41 of of IN 37231 1400 42 matter matter NN 37231 1400 43 , , , 37231 1400 44 taken take VBN 37231 1400 45 by by IN 37231 1400 46 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1400 47 , , , 37231 1400 48 do do VBP 37231 1400 49 not not RB 37231 1400 50 warrant warrant VB 37231 1400 51 any any DT 37231 1400 52 inference inference NN 37231 1400 53 to to IN 37231 1400 54 the the DT 37231 1400 55 existence existence NN 37231 1400 56 of of IN 37231 1400 57 a a DT 37231 1400 58 God God NNP 37231 1400 59 . . . 37231 1401 1 " " `` 37231 1401 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1401 3 2 2 LS 37231 1401 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1401 5 After after IN 37231 1401 6 declaring declare VBG 37231 1401 7 a a DT 37231 1401 8 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1401 9 Being Being NNP 37231 1401 10 , , , 37231 1401 11 from from IN 37231 1401 12 every every DT 37231 1401 13 point point NN 37231 1401 14 of of IN 37231 1401 15 view view NN 37231 1401 16 , , , 37231 1401 17 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 37231 1401 18 by by IN 37231 1401 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1401 20 finite finite JJ 37231 1401 21 minds mind NNS 37231 1401 22 , , , 37231 1401 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1401 24 is be VBZ 37231 1401 25 singular singular JJ 37231 1401 26 to to TO 37231 1401 27 find find VB 37231 1401 28 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1401 29 thrusting thrust VBG 37231 1401 30 upon upon IN 37231 1401 31 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1401 32 , , , 37231 1401 33 in in IN 37231 1401 34 consequence consequence NNP 37231 1401 35 , , , 37231 1401 36 a a DT 37231 1401 37 conception conception NN 37231 1401 38 of of IN 37231 1401 39 that that DT 37231 1401 40 Being being NN 37231 1401 41 which which WDT 37231 1401 42 almost almost RB 37231 1401 43 makes make VBZ 37231 1401 44 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1401 45 exclaim exclaim VB 37231 1401 46 with with IN 37231 1401 47 Bacon Bacon NNP 37231 1401 48 : : : 37231 1401 49 " " `` 37231 1401 50 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1401 51 were be VBD 37231 1401 52 better well JJR 37231 1401 53 to to TO 37231 1401 54 have have VB 37231 1401 55 no no DT 37231 1401 56 opinion opinion NN 37231 1401 57 of of IN 37231 1401 58 God God NNP 37231 1401 59 at at RB 37231 1401 60 all all RB 37231 1401 61 than than IN 37231 1401 62 such such PDT 37231 1401 63 an an DT 37231 1401 64 opinion opinion NN 37231 1401 65 as as IN 37231 1401 66 is be VBZ 37231 1401 67 unworthy unworthy JJ 37231 1401 68 of of IN 37231 1401 69 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1401 70 ; ; : 37231 1401 71 for for IN 37231 1401 72 the the DT 37231 1401 73 one one NN 37231 1401 74 is be VBZ 37231 1401 75 unbelief unbelief JJ 37231 1401 76 , , , 37231 1401 77 the the DT 37231 1401 78 other other JJ 37231 1401 79 is be VBZ 37231 1401 80 contumely contumely RB 37231 1401 81 . . . 37231 1402 1 " " `` 37231 1402 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1402 3 3 3 LS 37231 1402 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1402 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1402 6 Mansel Mansel NNP 37231 1402 7 asks ask VBZ 37231 1402 8 : : : 37231 1402 9 " " `` 37231 1402 10 Is be VBZ 37231 1402 11 matter matter NN 37231 1402 12 or or CC 37231 1402 13 mind mind VB 37231 1402 14 the the DT 37231 1402 15 truer truer NN 37231 1402 16 image image NN 37231 1402 17 of of IN 37231 1402 18 God God NNP 37231 1402 19 ? ? . 37231 1403 1 " " `` 37231 1403 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1403 3 4 4 LS 37231 1403 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1403 5 But but CC 37231 1403 6 both both CC 37231 1403 7 matter matter NN 37231 1403 8 and and CC 37231 1403 9 mind mind NN 37231 1403 10 unite unite VBP 37231 1403 11 in in IN 37231 1403 12 repudiating repudiate VBG 37231 1403 13 so so RB 37231 1403 14 unworthy unworthy JJ 37231 1403 15 a a DT 37231 1403 16 conception conception NN 37231 1403 17 of of IN 37231 1403 18 a a DT 37231 1403 19 God God NNP 37231 1403 20 , , , 37231 1403 21 and and CC 37231 1403 22 in in IN 37231 1403 23 rejecting reject VBG 37231 1403 24 the the DT 37231 1403 25 idea idea NN 37231 1403 26 of of IN 37231 1403 27 suspensions suspension NNS 37231 1403 28 of of IN 37231 1403 29 Law Law NNP 37231 1403 30 . . . 37231 1404 1 In in IN 37231 1404 2 the the DT 37231 1404 3 words word NNS 37231 1404 4 of of IN 37231 1404 5 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 37231 1404 6 : : : 37231 1404 7 " " `` 37231 1404 8 From from IN 37231 1404 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1404 10 { { -LRB- 37231 1404 11 76 76 CD 37231 1404 12 } } -RRB- 37231 1404 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1404 14 can can MD 37231 1404 15 neither neither CC 37231 1404 16 infer infer VB 37231 1404 17 the the DT 37231 1404 18 nature nature NN 37231 1404 19 , , , 37231 1404 20 the the DT 37231 1404 21 existence existence NN 37231 1404 22 , , , 37231 1404 23 nor nor CC 37231 1404 24 the the DT 37231 1404 25 providence providence NN 37231 1404 26 of of IN 37231 1404 27 God God NNP 37231 1404 28 , , , 37231 1404 29 but but CC 37231 1404 30 , , , 37231 1404 31 on on IN 37231 1404 32 the the DT 37231 1404 33 contrary contrary NN 37231 1404 34 , , , 37231 1404 35 these these DT 37231 1404 36 may may MD 37231 1404 37 be be VB 37231 1404 38 much much RB 37231 1404 39 better well RBR 37231 1404 40 comprehended comprehend VBN 37231 1404 41 from from IN 37231 1404 42 the the DT 37231 1404 43 fixed fix VBN 37231 1404 44 and and CC 37231 1404 45 immutable immutable JJ 37231 1404 46 order order NN 37231 1404 47 of of IN 37231 1404 48 nature;"(1 nature;"(1 NNP 37231 1404 49 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1404 50 indeed indeed RB 37231 1404 51 , , , 37231 1404 52 as as IN 37231 1404 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1404 54 adds add VBZ 37231 1404 55 , , , 37231 1404 56 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1404 57 , , , 37231 1404 58 as as IN 37231 1404 59 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1404 60 to to IN 37231 1404 61 the the DT 37231 1404 62 order order NN 37231 1404 63 of of IN 37231 1404 64 nature nature NN 37231 1404 65 , , , 37231 1404 66 would would MD 37231 1404 67 rather rather RB 37231 1404 68 lead lead VB 37231 1404 69 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1404 70 to to TO 37231 1404 71 doubt doubt VB 37231 1404 72 the the DT 37231 1404 73 existence existence NN 37231 1404 74 of of IN 37231 1404 75 God God NNP 37231 1404 76 . . . 37231 1405 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1405 2 2 2 LS 37231 1405 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1405 4 Six six CD 37231 1405 5 centuries century NNS 37231 1405 6 before before IN 37231 1405 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1405 8 era era NN 37231 1405 9 , , , 37231 1405 10 a a DT 37231 1405 11 noble noble JJ 37231 1405 12 thinker thinker NN 37231 1405 13 , , , 37231 1405 14 Xenophanes Xenophanes NNP 37231 1405 15 of of IN 37231 1405 16 Colophon Colophon NNP 37231 1405 17 , , , 37231 1405 18 whose whose WP$ 37231 1405 19 pure pure JJ 37231 1405 20 mind mind NN 37231 1405 21 soared soar VBD 37231 1405 22 far far RB 37231 1405 23 above above IN 37231 1405 24 the the DT 37231 1405 25 base base NN 37231 1405 26 anthropomorphic anthropomorphic JJ 37231 1405 27 mythologies mythology NNS 37231 1405 28 of of IN 37231 1405 29 Homer Homer NNP 37231 1405 30 and and CC 37231 1405 31 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 37231 1405 32 , , , 37231 1405 33 and and CC 37231 1405 34 anticipated anticipate VBD 37231 1405 35 some some DT 37231 1405 36 of of IN 37231 1405 37 the the DT 37231 1405 38 highest high JJS 37231 1405 39 results result NNS 37231 1405 40 of of IN 37231 1405 41 the the DT 37231 1405 42 Platonic platonic JJ 37231 1405 43 philosophy philosophy NN 37231 1405 44 , , , 37231 1405 45 finely finely RB 37231 1405 46 said:-- said:-- VB 37231 1405 47 " " `` 37231 1405 48 There there EX 37231 1405 49 is be VBZ 37231 1405 50 one one CD 37231 1405 51 God God NNP 37231 1405 52 supreme supreme RB 37231 1405 53 over over IN 37231 1405 54 all all DT 37231 1405 55 gods god NNS 37231 1405 56 , , , 37231 1405 57 diviner diviner NN 37231 1405 58 than than IN 37231 1405 59 mortals mortal NNS 37231 1405 60 , , , 37231 1405 61 Whose whose WP$ 37231 1405 62 form form NN 37231 1405 63 is be VBZ 37231 1405 64 not not RB 37231 1405 65 like like IN 37231 1405 66 unto unto IN 37231 1405 67 man man NN 37231 1405 68 's 's POS 37231 1405 69 , , , 37231 1405 70 and and CC 37231 1405 71 as as IN 37231 1405 72 unlike unlike IN 37231 1405 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1405 74 nature nature NN 37231 1405 75 ; ; : 37231 1405 76 But but CC 37231 1405 77 vain vain JJ 37231 1405 78 mortals mortal NNS 37231 1405 79 imagine imagine VBP 37231 1405 80 that that IN 37231 1405 81 gods god NNS 37231 1405 82 like like IN 37231 1405 83 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1405 84 are be VBP 37231 1405 85 begotten begotten JJ 37231 1405 86 , , , 37231 1405 87 With with IN 37231 1405 88 human human JJ 37231 1405 89 sensations sensation NNS 37231 1405 90 , , , 37231 1405 91 and and CC 37231 1405 92 voice voice NN 37231 1405 93 , , , 37231 1405 94 and and CC 37231 1405 95 corporeal corporeal NN 37231 1405 96 members member NNS 37231 1405 97 ; ; : 37231 1405 98 ' ' '' 37231 1405 99 So so RB 37231 1405 100 if if IN 37231 1405 101 oxen oxen NN 37231 1405 102 or or CC 37231 1405 103 lions lion NNS 37231 1405 104 had have VBD 37231 1405 105 hands hand NNS 37231 1405 106 and and CC 37231 1405 107 could could MD 37231 1405 108 work work VB 37231 1405 109 iu iu NNP 37231 1405 110 man man NN 37231 1405 111 's 's POS 37231 1405 112 fashion fashion NN 37231 1405 113 , , , 37231 1405 114 And and CC 37231 1405 115 trace trace VB 37231 1405 116 out out RP 37231 1405 117 with with IN 37231 1405 118 chisel chisel NN 37231 1405 119 or or CC 37231 1405 120 brush brush VB 37231 1405 121 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1405 122 conception conception NN 37231 1405 123 of of IN 37231 1405 124 Godhead Godhead NNP 37231 1405 125 , , , 37231 1405 126 Then then RB 37231 1405 127 would would MD 37231 1405 128 horses horse NNS 37231 1405 129 depict depict VB 37231 1405 130 gods god NNS 37231 1405 131 like like IN 37231 1405 132 horses horse NNS 37231 1405 133 , , , 37231 1405 134 and and CC 37231 1405 135 oxen oxen NN 37231 1405 136 like like IN 37231 1405 137 oxen oxen NN 37231 1405 138 , , , 37231 1405 139 Each each DT 37231 1405 140 kind kind NN 37231 1405 141 the the DT 37231 1405 142 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1405 143 with with IN 37231 1405 144 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1405 145 own own JJ 37231 1405 146 form form NN 37231 1405 147 and and CC 37231 1405 148 nature nature NN 37231 1405 149 endowing endowing NN 37231 1405 150 . . . 37231 1406 1 " " `` 37231 1406 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1406 3 4 4 LS 37231 1406 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1406 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1406 6 illustrates illustrate VBZ 37231 1406 7 this this DT 37231 1406 8 profound profound JJ 37231 1406 9 observation observation NN 37231 1406 10 by by IN 37231 1406 11 pointing point VBG 37231 1406 12 out out RP 37231 1406 13 that that IN 37231 1406 14 the the DT 37231 1406 15 Ethiopians Ethiopians NNPS 37231 1406 16 represent represent VBP 37231 1406 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1406 18 deities deity NNS 37231 1406 19 as as IN 37231 1406 20 black black JJ 37231 1406 21 with with IN 37231 1406 22 flat flat JJ 37231 1406 23 noses nose NNS 37231 1406 24 , , , 37231 1406 25 while while IN 37231 1406 26 the the DT 37231 1406 27 Thracians Thracians NNPS 37231 1406 28 make make VBP 37231 1406 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1406 30 blue blue JJ 37231 1406 31 - - HYPH 37231 1406 32 eyed eyed JJ 37231 1406 33 with with IN 37231 1406 34 ruddy ruddy NN 37231 1406 35 complexions complexion NNS 37231 1406 36 , , , 37231 1406 37 and and CC 37231 1406 38 , , , 37231 1406 39 similarly similarly RB 37231 1406 40 , , , 37231 1406 41 the the DT 37231 1406 42 Medes Medes NNP 37231 1406 43 and and CC 37231 1406 44 the the DT 37231 1406 45 Persians Persians NNPS 37231 1406 46 and and CC 37231 1406 47 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 37231 1406 48 portray portray VBP 37231 1406 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1406 50 gods god NNS 37231 1406 51 like like IN 37231 1406 52 { { -LRB- 37231 1406 53 77 77 CD 37231 1406 54 } } -RRB- 37231 1406 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1406 56 . . . 37231 1407 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1407 2 1 1 LS 37231 1407 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1407 4 The the DT 37231 1407 5 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1407 6 idea idea NN 37231 1407 7 of of IN 37231 1407 8 God God NNP 37231 1407 9 was be VBD 37231 1407 10 equally equally RB 37231 1407 11 anthropomorphic anthropomorphic JJ 37231 1407 12 ; ; : 37231 1407 13 but but CC 37231 1407 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1407 15 highest high JJS 37231 1407 16 conception conception NN 37231 1407 17 was be VBD 37231 1407 18 certainly certainly RB 37231 1407 19 that that IN 37231 1407 20 which which WDT 37231 1407 21 the the DT 37231 1407 22 least least RBS 37231 1407 23 resembled resemble VBD 37231 1407 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1407 25 , , , 37231 1407 26 and and CC 37231 1407 27 which which WDT 37231 1407 28 described describe VBD 37231 1407 29 the the DT 37231 1407 30 Almighty Almighty NNP 37231 1407 31 as as IN 37231 1407 32 " " `` 37231 1407 33 without without IN 37231 1407 34 variableness variableness NN 37231 1407 35 or or CC 37231 1407 36 shadow shadow NN 37231 1407 37 of of IN 37231 1407 38 turning turning NN 37231 1407 39 , , , 37231 1407 40 " " '' 37231 1407 41 and and CC 37231 1407 42 as as IN 37231 1407 43 giving give VBG 37231 1407 44 a a DT 37231 1407 45 law law NN 37231 1407 46 to to IN 37231 1407 47 the the DT 37231 1407 48 universe universe NN 37231 1407 49 which which WDT 37231 1407 50 shall shall MD 37231 1407 51 not not RB 37231 1407 52 be be VB 37231 1407 53 broken break VBN 37231 1407 54 . . . 37231 1408 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1408 2 2 2 CD 37231 1408 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1408 4 3 3 CD 37231 1408 5 . . . 37231 1409 1 None none NN 37231 1409 2 of of IN 37231 1409 3 the the DT 37231 1409 4 arguments argument NNS 37231 1409 5 with with IN 37231 1409 6 which which WDT 37231 1409 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1409 8 have have VBP 37231 1409 9 yet yet RB 37231 1409 10 met meet VBN 37231 1409 11 have have VBP 37231 1409 12 succeeded succeed VBN 37231 1409 13 in in IN 37231 1409 14 making make VBG 37231 1409 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1409 16 in in IN 37231 1409 17 the the DT 37231 1409 18 least least JJS 37231 1409 19 degree degree NN 37231 1409 20 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1409 21 credible credible JJ 37231 1409 22 . . . 37231 1410 1 On on IN 37231 1410 2 the the DT 37231 1410 3 contrary contrary NN 37231 1410 4 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1410 5 have have VBP 37231 1410 6 been be VBN 37231 1410 7 based base VBN 37231 1410 8 upon upon IN 37231 1410 9 mere mere JJ 37231 1410 10 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 1410 11 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1410 12 of of IN 37231 1410 13 proof proof NN 37231 1410 14 and and CC 37231 1410 15 devoid devoid JJ 37231 1410 16 of of IN 37231 1410 17 probability probability NN 37231 1410 18 . . . 37231 1411 1 On on IN 37231 1411 2 the the DT 37231 1411 3 other other JJ 37231 1411 4 hand hand NN 37231 1411 5 there there EX 37231 1411 6 are be VBP 37231 1411 7 the the DT 37231 1411 8 strongest strong JJS 37231 1411 9 reasons reason NNS 37231 1411 10 for for IN 37231 1411 11 affirming affirm VBG 37231 1411 12 that that IN 37231 1411 13 such such JJ 37231 1411 14 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1411 15 are be VBP 37231 1411 16 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1411 17 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1411 18 . . . 37231 1412 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1412 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 1412 3 's 's POS 37231 1412 4 attack attack NN 37231 1412 5 which which WDT 37231 1412 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1412 7 discussed discuss VBD 37231 1412 8 in in IN 37231 1412 9 the the DT 37231 1412 10 first first JJ 37231 1412 11 part part NN 37231 1412 12 of of IN 37231 1412 13 this this DT 37231 1412 14 chapter chapter NN 37231 1412 15 , , , 37231 1412 16 and and CC 37231 1412 17 which which WDT 37231 1412 18 of of IN 37231 1412 19 course course NN 37231 1412 20 was be VBD 37231 1412 21 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 1412 22 based base VBN 37231 1412 23 upon upon IN 37231 1412 24 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1412 25 's 's POS 37231 1412 26 celebrated celebrated JJ 37231 1412 27 argument argument NN 37231 1412 28 , , , 37231 1412 29 { { -LRB- 37231 1412 30 78 78 CD 37231 1412 31 } } -RRB- 37231 1412 32 never never RB 37231 1412 33 seriously seriously RB 37231 1412 34 grappled grapple VBD 37231 1412 35 the the DT 37231 1412 36 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1412 37 at at RB 37231 1412 38 all all RB 37231 1412 39 . . . 37231 1413 1 The the DT 37231 1413 2 principle principle NN 37231 1413 3 which which WDT 37231 1413 4 opposes oppose VBZ 37231 1413 5 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1413 6 to to IN 37231 1413 7 belief belief NN 37231 1413 8 in in IN 37231 1413 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1413 10 is be VBZ 37231 1413 11 very very RB 37231 1413 12 simple simple JJ 37231 1413 13 . . . 37231 1414 1 Whatever whatever WDT 37231 1414 2 is be VBZ 37231 1414 3 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1414 4 to to IN 37231 1414 5 universal universal JJ 37231 1414 6 and and CC 37231 1414 7 invariable invariable JJ 37231 1414 8 experience experience NN 37231 1414 9 is be VBZ 37231 1414 10 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1414 11 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1414 12 , , , 37231 1414 13 and and CC 37231 1414 14 as as IN 37231 1414 15 that that DT 37231 1414 16 sequence sequence NN 37231 1414 17 of of IN 37231 1414 18 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1414 19 which which WDT 37231 1414 20 is be VBZ 37231 1414 21 called call VBN 37231 1414 22 the the DT 37231 1414 23 order order NN 37231 1414 24 of of IN 37231 1414 25 nature nature NN 37231 1414 26 is be VBZ 37231 1414 27 established establish VBN 37231 1414 28 by by IN 37231 1414 29 and and CC 37231 1414 30 in in IN 37231 1414 31 accordance accordance NN 37231 1414 32 with with IN 37231 1414 33 universal universal JJ 37231 1414 34 experience experience NN 37231 1414 35 , , , 37231 1414 36 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1414 37 or or CC 37231 1414 38 alleged alleged JJ 37231 1414 39 violations violation NNS 37231 1414 40 of of IN 37231 1414 41 that that DT 37231 1414 42 order order NN 37231 1414 43 , , , 37231 1414 44 by by IN 37231 1414 45 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1414 46 name name NN 37231 1414 47 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1414 48 may may MD 37231 1414 49 be be VB 37231 1414 50 called call VBN 37231 1414 51 , , , 37231 1414 52 or or CC 37231 1414 53 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1414 54 definition definition NN 37231 1414 55 may may MD 37231 1414 56 be be VB 37231 1414 57 given give VBN 37231 1414 58 of of IN 37231 1414 59 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1414 60 characteristics characteristic NNS 37231 1414 61 or or CC 37231 1414 62 object object NN 37231 1414 63 , , , 37231 1414 64 are be VBP 37231 1414 65 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1414 66 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1414 67 . . . 37231 1415 1 The the DT 37231 1415 2 preponderance preponderance NN 37231 1415 3 of of IN 37231 1415 4 evidence evidence NN 37231 1415 5 for for IN 37231 1415 6 the the DT 37231 1415 7 invariability invariability NN 37231 1415 8 of of IN 37231 1415 9 the the DT 37231 1415 10 order order NN 37231 1415 11 of of IN 37231 1415 12 nature nature NN 37231 1415 13 , , , 37231 1415 14 in in IN 37231 1415 15 fact fact NN 37231 1415 16 , , , 37231 1415 17 is be VBZ 37231 1415 18 so so RB 37231 1415 19 enormous enormous JJ 37231 1415 20 that that IN 37231 1415 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1415 22 is be VBZ 37231 1415 23 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1415 24 to to TO 37231 1415 25 credit credit VB 37231 1415 26 the the DT 37231 1415 27 reality reality NN 37231 1415 28 of of IN 37231 1415 29 such such JJ 37231 1415 30 variations variation NNS 37231 1415 31 from from IN 37231 1415 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1415 33 , , , 37231 1415 34 and and CC 37231 1415 35 reason reason NN 37231 1415 36 and and CC 37231 1415 37 experience experience NN 37231 1415 38 concur concur VBP 37231 1415 39 in in IN 37231 1415 40 attributing attribute VBG 37231 1415 41 the the DT 37231 1415 42 ascription ascription NN 37231 1415 43 of of IN 37231 1415 44 a a DT 37231 1415 45 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1415 46 character character NN 37231 1415 47 to to IN 37231 1415 48 any any DT 37231 1415 49 actual actual JJ 37231 1415 50 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1415 51 which which WDT 37231 1415 52 may may MD 37231 1415 53 have have VB 37231 1415 54 been be VBN 37231 1415 55 witnessed witness VBN 37231 1415 56 to to TO 37231 1415 57 imperfect imperfect VB 37231 1415 58 observation observation NN 37231 1415 59 , , , 37231 1415 60 mistaken mistaken JJ 37231 1415 61 inference inference NN 37231 1415 62 or or CC 37231 1415 63 some some DT 37231 1415 64 other other JJ 37231 1415 65 of of IN 37231 1415 66 the the DT 37231 1415 67 numerous numerous JJ 37231 1415 68 sources source NNS 37231 1415 69 of of IN 37231 1415 70 error error NN 37231 1415 71 . . . 37231 1416 1 Any any DT 37231 1416 2 allegation allegation NN 37231 1416 3 of of IN 37231 1416 4 the the DT 37231 1416 5 interference interference NN 37231 1416 6 of of IN 37231 1416 7 a a DT 37231 1416 8 new new JJ 37231 1416 9 and and CC 37231 1416 10 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1416 11 agent agent NN 37231 1416 12 , , , 37231 1416 13 upon upon IN 37231 1416 14 such such PDT 37231 1416 15 an an DT 37231 1416 16 occasion occasion NN 37231 1416 17 , , , 37231 1416 18 to to TO 37231 1416 19 account account VB 37231 1416 20 for for IN 37231 1416 21 results result NNS 37231 1416 22 , , , 37231 1416 23 in in IN 37231 1416 24 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1416 25 of of IN 37231 1416 26 the the DT 37231 1416 27 known know VBN 37231 1416 28 sequence sequence NN 37231 1416 29 of of IN 37231 1416 30 cause cause NN 37231 1416 31 and and CC 37231 1416 32 effect effect NN 37231 1416 33 , , , 37231 1416 34 is be VBZ 37231 1416 35 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1416 36 by by IN 37231 1416 37 the the DT 37231 1416 38 very very RB 37231 1416 39 same same JJ 37231 1416 40 principle principle NN 37231 1416 41 , , , 37231 1416 42 for for IN 37231 1416 43 invariable invariable JJ 37231 1416 44 experience experience NN 37231 1416 45 being be VBG 37231 1416 46 as as RB 37231 1416 47 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1416 48 to to IN 37231 1416 49 the the DT 37231 1416 50 assertion assertion NN 37231 1416 51 that that IN 37231 1416 52 such such JJ 37231 1416 53 interference interference NN 37231 1416 54 ever ever RB 37231 1416 55 takes take VBZ 37231 1416 56 place place NN 37231 1416 57 as as IN 37231 1416 58 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1416 59 is be VBZ 37231 1416 60 to to IN 37231 1416 61 the the DT 37231 1416 62 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1416 63 of of IN 37231 1416 64 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1416 65 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1416 66 , , , 37231 1416 67 the the DT 37231 1416 68 allegation allegation NN 37231 1416 69 is be VBZ 37231 1416 70 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 1416 71 disbelieved disbelieve VBN 37231 1416 72 . . . 37231 1417 1 Apologists apologist NNS 37231 1417 2 find find VBP 37231 1417 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1417 4 much much RB 37231 1417 5 more more RBR 37231 1417 6 convenient convenient JJ 37231 1417 7 to to TO 37231 1417 8 evade evade VB 37231 1417 9 the the DT 37231 1417 10 simple simple JJ 37231 1417 11 but but CC 37231 1417 12 effective effective JJ 37231 1417 13 arguments argument NNS 37231 1417 14 of of IN 37231 1417 15 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1417 16 than than IN 37231 1417 17 to to TO 37231 1417 18 answer answer VB 37231 1417 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1417 20 , , , 37231 1417 21 and and CC 37231 1417 22 where where WRB 37231 1417 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1417 24 is be VBZ 37231 1417 25 possible possible JJ 37231 1417 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1417 27 dismiss dismiss VBP 37231 1417 28 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1417 29 with with IN 37231 1417 30 a a DT 37231 1417 31 sneer sneer NN 37231 1417 32 , , , 37231 1417 33 and and CC 37231 1417 34 hasten hasten VB 37231 1417 35 on on RP 37231 1417 36 to to IN 37231 1417 37 less less RBR 37231 1417 38 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 1417 39 ground ground NN 37231 1417 40 . . . 37231 1418 1 For for IN 37231 1418 2 instance instance NN 37231 1418 3 , , , 37231 1418 4 a a DT 37231 1418 5 recent recent JJ 37231 1418 6 Hulsean Hulsean NNP 37231 1418 7 Lecturer Lecturer NNP 37231 1418 8 , , , 37231 1418 9 arguing argue VBG 37231 1418 10 the the DT 37231 1418 11 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1418 12 credibility credibility NN 37231 1418 13 of of IN 37231 1418 14 the the DT 37231 1418 15 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1418 16 , , , 37231 1418 17 makes make VBZ 37231 1418 18 the the DT 37231 1418 19 following follow VBG 37231 1418 20 remarks remark NNS 37231 1418 21 : : : 37231 1418 22 " " `` 37231 1418 23 Now now RB 37231 1418 24 , , , 37231 1418 25 as as IN 37231 1418 26 regards regard VBZ 37231 1418 27 the the DT 37231 1418 28 inadequacy inadequacy NN 37231 1418 29 of of IN 37231 1418 30 testimony testimony NN 37231 1418 31 to to TO 37231 1418 32 establish establish VB 37231 1418 33 a a DT 37231 1418 34 miracle miracle NN 37231 1418 35 , , , 37231 1418 36 modern modern JJ 37231 1418 37 scepticism scepticism NN 37231 1418 38 has have VBZ 37231 1418 39 not not RB 37231 1418 40 advanced advance VBN 37231 1418 41 { { -LRB- 37231 1418 42 79 79 CD 37231 1418 43 } } -RRB- 37231 1418 44 one one CD 37231 1418 45 single single JJ 37231 1418 46 step step NN 37231 1418 47 beyond beyond IN 37231 1418 48 the the DT 37231 1418 49 blank blank JJ 37231 1418 50 assertion assertion NN 37231 1418 51 . . . 37231 1419 1 And and CC 37231 1419 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1419 3 is be VBZ 37231 1419 4 astonishing astonish VBG 37231 1419 5 that that IN 37231 1419 6 this this DT 37231 1419 7 assertion assertion NN 37231 1419 8 should should MD 37231 1419 9 still still RB 37231 1419 10 be be VB 37231 1419 11 considered consider VBN 37231 1419 12 cogent cogent JJ 37231 1419 13 , , , 37231 1419 14 when when WRB 37231 1419 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1419 16 logical logical JJ 37231 1419 17 consistency consistency NN 37231 1419 18 has have VBZ 37231 1419 19 been be VBN 37231 1419 20 shattered shatter VBN 37231 1419 21 to to IN 37231 1419 22 pieces piece NNS 37231 1419 23 by by IN 37231 1419 24 a a DT 37231 1419 25 host host NN 37231 1419 26 of of IN 37231 1419 27 writers writer NNS 37231 1419 28 as as RB 37231 1419 29 well well RB 37231 1419 30 sceptical sceptical JJ 37231 1419 31 as as IN 37231 1419 32 Christian Christian NNP 37231 1419 33 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1419 34 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1419 35 's 's POS 37231 1419 36 _ _ NNP 37231 1419 37 Logic Logic NNP 37231 1419 38 _ _ NNP 37231 1419 39 , , , 37231 1419 40 ii ii NNP 37231 1419 41 . . NNP 37231 1419 42 , , , 37231 1419 43 157 157 CD 37231 1419 44 - - HYPH 37231 1419 45 -160 -160 NN 37231 1419 46 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1419 47 . . . 37231 1420 1 For for IN 37231 1420 2 , , , 37231 1420 3 as as IN 37231 1420 4 the the DT 37231 1420 5 greatest great JJS 37231 1420 6 of of IN 37231 1420 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1420 8 living living NN 37231 1420 9 logicians logicians NNPS 37231 1420 10 has have VBZ 37231 1420 11 remarked remark VBN 37231 1420 12 , , , 37231 1420 13 the the DT 37231 1420 14 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1420 15 recondite recondite JJ 37231 1420 16 and and CC 37231 1420 17 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 1420 18 formula formula NN 37231 1420 19 of of IN 37231 1420 20 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1420 21 -- -- : 37231 1420 22 that that IN 37231 1420 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1420 24 is be VBZ 37231 1420 25 more more RBR 37231 1420 26 probable probable JJ 37231 1420 27 that that IN 37231 1420 28 testimony testimony NN 37231 1420 29 should should MD 37231 1420 30 be be VB 37231 1420 31 mistaken mistaken JJ 37231 1420 32 than than IN 37231 1420 33 that that DT 37231 1420 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1420 35 should should MD 37231 1420 36 be be VB 37231 1420 37 true true JJ 37231 1420 38 -- -- : 37231 1420 39 reduces reduce VBZ 37231 1420 40 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1420 41 to to IN 37231 1420 42 the the DT 37231 1420 43 very very RB 37231 1420 44 harmless harmless JJ 37231 1420 45 proposition proposition NN 37231 1420 46 that that IN 37231 1420 47 anything anything NN 37231 1420 48 is be VBZ 37231 1420 49 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1420 50 which which WDT 37231 1420 51 is be VBZ 37231 1420 52 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1420 53 to to IN 37231 1420 54 a a DT 37231 1420 55 complete complete JJ 37231 1420 56 induction induction NN 37231 1420 57 . . . 37231 1421 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1421 2 is be VBZ 37231 1421 3 in in IN 37231 1421 4 fact fact NN 37231 1421 5 a a DT 37231 1421 6 _ _ NNP 37231 1421 7 flagrant flagrant NN 37231 1421 8 petitio petitio NNP 37231 1421 9 principii principii NNP 37231 1421 10 _ _ NNP 37231 1421 11 , , , 37231 1421 12 used use VBN 37231 1421 13 to to TO 37231 1421 14 support support VB 37231 1421 15 a a DT 37231 1421 16 wholly wholly RB 37231 1421 17 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 37231 1421 18 assertion assertion NN 37231 1421 19 . . . 37231 1422 1 " " `` 37231 1422 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1422 3 1 1 LS 37231 1422 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1422 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1422 6 is be VBZ 37231 1422 7 much much RB 37231 1422 8 more more RBR 37231 1422 9 astonishing astonishing JJ 37231 1422 10 that that IN 37231 1422 11 so so RB 37231 1422 12 able able JJ 37231 1422 13 a a DT 37231 1422 14 man man NN 37231 1422 15 as as IN 37231 1422 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1422 17 Farrar Farrar NNP 37231 1422 18 could could MD 37231 1422 19 so so RB 37231 1422 20 misunderstand misunderstand VB 37231 1422 21 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1422 22 's 's POS 37231 1422 23 argument argument NN 37231 1422 24 and and CC 37231 1422 25 so so RB 37231 1422 26 misinterpret misinterpret NNP 37231 1422 27 and and CC 37231 1422 28 mis mis JJ 37231 1422 29 - - HYPH 37231 1422 30 state state NN 37231 1422 31 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1422 32 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1422 33 's 's POS 37231 1422 34 remarks remark NNS 37231 1422 35 upon upon IN 37231 1422 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1422 37 . . . 37231 1423 1 So so RB 37231 1423 2 far far RB 37231 1423 3 from from IN 37231 1423 4 shattering shatter VBG 37231 1423 5 to to IN 37231 1423 6 pieces piece NNS 37231 1423 7 the the DT 37231 1423 8 logical logical JJ 37231 1423 9 consistency consistency NN 37231 1423 10 of of IN 37231 1423 11 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1423 12 's 's POS 37231 1423 13 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1423 14 , , , 37231 1423 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1423 16 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1423 17 substantially substantially RB 37231 1423 18 confirms confirm VBZ 37231 1423 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1423 20 , , , 37231 1423 21 and and CC 37231 1423 22 pertinently pertinently RB 37231 1423 23 remarks remark VBZ 37231 1423 24 that that IN 37231 1423 25 " " `` 37231 1423 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1423 27 speaks speak VBZ 37231 1423 28 ill ill JJ 37231 1423 29 for for IN 37231 1423 30 the the DT 37231 1423 31 state state NN 37231 1423 32 of of IN 37231 1423 33 philosophical philosophical JJ 37231 1423 34 speculation speculation NN 37231 1423 35 on on IN 37231 1423 36 such such JJ 37231 1423 37 subjects subject NNS 37231 1423 38 " " '' 37231 1423 39 that that WDT 37231 1423 40 so so RB 37231 1423 41 simple simple JJ 37231 1423 42 and and CC 37231 1423 43 evident evident JJ 37231 1423 44 a a DT 37231 1423 45 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1423 46 should should MD 37231 1423 47 have have VB 37231 1423 48 been be VBN 37231 1423 49 accounted account VBN 37231 1423 50 a a DT 37231 1423 51 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 1423 52 heresy heresy NN 37231 1423 53 . . . 37231 1424 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1424 2 is be VBZ 37231 1424 3 , , , 37231 1424 4 in in IN 37231 1424 5 fact fact NN 37231 1424 6 , , , 37231 1424 7 the the DT 37231 1424 8 statement statement NN 37231 1424 9 of of IN 37231 1424 10 a a DT 37231 1424 11 truth truth NN 37231 1424 12 which which WDT 37231 1424 13 should should MD 37231 1424 14 have have VB 37231 1424 15 been be VBN 37231 1424 16 universally universally RB 37231 1424 17 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1424 18 , , , 37231 1424 19 and and CC 37231 1424 20 would would MD 37231 1424 21 have have VB 37231 1424 22 been be VBN 37231 1424 23 so so RB 37231 1424 24 , , , 37231 1424 25 but but CC 37231 1424 26 for for IN 37231 1424 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1424 28 unwelcome unwelcome JJ 37231 1424 29 and and CC 37231 1424 30 destructive destructive JJ 37231 1424 31 bearing bearing NN 37231 1424 32 upon upon IN 37231 1424 33 popular popular JJ 37231 1424 34 theology theology NN 37231 1424 35 . . . 37231 1425 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1425 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1425 3 states state VBZ 37231 1425 4 the the DT 37231 1425 5 evident evident JJ 37231 1425 6 principle principle NN 37231 1425 7 , , , 37231 1425 8 that--"If that--"if VB 37231 1425 9 an an DT 37231 1425 10 alleged alleged JJ 37231 1425 11 fact fact NN 37231 1425 12 be be VB 37231 1425 13 in in IN 37231 1425 14 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1425 15 , , , 37231 1425 16 not not RB 37231 1425 17 to to IN 37231 1425 18 any any DT 37231 1425 19 number number NN 37231 1425 20 of of IN 37231 1425 21 approximate approximate JJ 37231 1425 22 generalizations generalization NNS 37231 1425 23 , , , 37231 1425 24 but but CC 37231 1425 25 to to IN 37231 1425 26 a a DT 37231 1425 27 completed complete VBN 37231 1425 28 generalization generalization NN 37231 1425 29 grounded ground VBN 37231 1425 30 on on IN 37231 1425 31 a a DT 37231 1425 32 rigorous rigorous JJ 37231 1425 33 induction induction NN 37231 1425 34 , , , 37231 1425 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1425 36 is be VBZ 37231 1425 37 said say VBN 37231 1425 38 to to TO 37231 1425 39 be be VB 37231 1425 40 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1425 41 , , , 37231 1425 42 and and CC 37231 1425 43 is be VBZ 37231 1425 44 to to TO 37231 1425 45 be be VB 37231 1425 46 disbelieved disbelieve VBN 37231 1425 47 totally totally RB 37231 1425 48 . . . 37231 1425 49 " " '' 37231 1426 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1426 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1426 3 continues continue VBZ 37231 1426 4 . . . 37231 1427 1 : : : 37231 1427 2 " " `` 37231 1427 3 This this DT 37231 1427 4 last last JJ 37231 1427 5 principle principle NN 37231 1427 6 , , , 37231 1427 7 simple simple JJ 37231 1427 8 and and CC 37231 1427 9 evident evident JJ 37231 1427 10 as as IN 37231 1427 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1427 12 { { -LRB- 37231 1427 13 80 80 CD 37231 1427 14 } } -RRB- 37231 1427 15 appears appear VBZ 37231 1427 16 , , , 37231 1427 17 is be VBZ 37231 1427 18 the the DT 37231 1427 19 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1427 20 which which WDT 37231 1427 21 , , , 37231 1427 22 on on IN 37231 1427 23 the the DT 37231 1427 24 occasion occasion NN 37231 1427 25 of of IN 37231 1427 26 an an DT 37231 1427 27 attempt attempt NN 37231 1427 28 to to TO 37231 1427 29 apply apply VB 37231 1427 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1427 31 to to IN 37231 1427 32 the the DT 37231 1427 33 question question NN 37231 1427 34 of of IN 37231 1427 35 the the DT 37231 1427 36 credibility credibility NN 37231 1427 37 of of IN 37231 1427 38 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1427 39 , , , 37231 1427 40 excited excited JJ 37231 1427 41 so so RB 37231 1427 42 violent violent JJ 37231 1427 43 a a DT 37231 1427 44 controversy controversy NN 37231 1427 45 . . . 37231 1428 1 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1428 2 's 's POS 37231 1428 3 celebrated celebrated JJ 37231 1428 4 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1428 5 , , , 37231 1428 6 that that IN 37231 1428 7 nothing nothing NN 37231 1428 8 is be VBZ 37231 1428 9 credible credible JJ 37231 1428 10 which which WDT 37231 1428 11 is be VBZ 37231 1428 12 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1428 13 to to TO 37231 1428 14 experience experience VB 37231 1428 15 or or CC 37231 1428 16 at at IN 37231 1428 17 variance variance NN 37231 1428 18 with with IN 37231 1428 19 laws law NNS 37231 1428 20 of of IN 37231 1428 21 nature nature NN 37231 1428 22 , , , 37231 1428 23 is be VBZ 37231 1428 24 merely merely RB 37231 1428 25 this this DT 37231 1428 26 very very RB 37231 1428 27 plain plain JJ 37231 1428 28 and and CC 37231 1428 29 harmless harmless JJ 37231 1428 30 proposition proposition NN 37231 1428 31 , , , 37231 1428 32 that that IN 37231 1428 33 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1428 34 is be VBZ 37231 1428 35 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1428 36 to to IN 37231 1428 37 a a DT 37231 1428 38 complete complete JJ 37231 1428 39 induction induction NN 37231 1428 40 is be VBZ 37231 1428 41 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1428 42 . . . 37231 1429 1 " " `` 37231 1429 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1429 3 1 1 LS 37231 1429 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1429 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1429 6 then then RB 37231 1429 7 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1429 8 to to TO 37231 1429 9 meet meet VB 37231 1429 10 possible possible JJ 37231 1429 11 objections objection NNS 37231 1429 12 : : : 37231 1429 13 " " `` 37231 1429 14 But but CC 37231 1429 15 does do VBZ 37231 1429 16 not not RB 37231 1429 17 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1429 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1429 19 may may MD 37231 1429 20 be be VB 37231 1429 21 asked ask VBN 37231 1429 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1429 23 the the DT 37231 1429 24 very very JJ 37231 1429 25 statement statement NN 37231 1429 26 of of IN 37231 1429 27 the the DT 37231 1429 28 proposition proposition NN 37231 1429 29 imply imply VBP 37231 1429 30 a a DT 37231 1429 31 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1429 32 ? ? . 37231 1430 1 An an DT 37231 1430 2 alleged alleged JJ 37231 1430 3 fact fact NN 37231 1430 4 according accord VBG 37231 1430 5 to to IN 37231 1430 6 this this DT 37231 1430 7 theory theory NN 37231 1430 8 is be VBZ 37231 1430 9 not not RB 37231 1430 10 to to TO 37231 1430 11 be be VB 37231 1430 12 believed believe VBN 37231 1430 13 if if IN 37231 1430 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1430 15 contradict contradict VBP 37231 1430 16 a a DT 37231 1430 17 complete complete JJ 37231 1430 18 induction induction NN 37231 1430 19 . . . 37231 1431 1 But but CC 37231 1431 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1431 3 is be VBZ 37231 1431 4 essential essential JJ 37231 1431 5 to to IN 37231 1431 6 the the DT 37231 1431 7 completeness completeness NN 37231 1431 8 of of IN 37231 1431 9 an an DT 37231 1431 10 induction induction NN 37231 1431 11 that that IN 37231 1431 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1431 13 should should MD 37231 1431 14 not not RB 37231 1431 15 contradict contradict VB 37231 1431 16 any any DT 37231 1431 17 known know VBN 37231 1431 18 fact fact NN 37231 1431 19 . . . 37231 1432 1 Is be VBZ 37231 1432 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1432 3 not not RB 37231 1432 4 , , , 37231 1432 5 then then RB 37231 1432 6 , , , 37231 1432 7 a a DT 37231 1432 8 _ _ NNP 37231 1432 9 petitio petitio NNP 37231 1432 10 principii principii NN 37231 1432 11 _ _ NNP 37231 1432 12 to to TO 37231 1432 13 say say VB 37231 1432 14 , , , 37231 1432 15 that that IN 37231 1432 16 the the DT 37231 1432 17 fact fact NN 37231 1432 18 ought ought MD 37231 1432 19 to to TO 37231 1432 20 be be VB 37231 1432 21 disbelieved disbelieve VBN 37231 1432 22 because because IN 37231 1432 23 the the DT 37231 1432 24 induction induction NN 37231 1432 25 to to IN 37231 1432 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1432 27 is be VBZ 37231 1432 28 complete complete JJ 37231 1432 29 ? ? . 37231 1433 1 How how WRB 37231 1433 2 can can MD 37231 1433 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1433 4 have have VB 37231 1433 5 a a DT 37231 1433 6 right right NN 37231 1433 7 to to TO 37231 1433 8 declare declare VB 37231 1433 9 the the DT 37231 1433 10 induction induction NN 37231 1433 11 complete complete JJ 37231 1433 12 , , , 37231 1433 13 while while IN 37231 1433 14 facts fact NNS 37231 1433 15 , , , 37231 1433 16 supported support VBN 37231 1433 17 by by IN 37231 1433 18 credible credible JJ 37231 1433 19 evidence evidence NN 37231 1433 20 , , , 37231 1433 21 present present VB 37231 1433 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1433 23 in in IN 37231 1433 24 opposition opposition NN 37231 1433 25 to to IN 37231 1433 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1433 27 ? ? . 37231 1434 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1434 2 answer answer VBP 37231 1434 3 , , , 37231 1434 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1434 5 have have VBP 37231 1434 6 that that DT 37231 1434 7 right right RB 37231 1434 8 whenever whenever WRB 37231 1434 9 the the DT 37231 1434 10 scientific scientific JJ 37231 1434 11 canons canon NNS 37231 1434 12 of of IN 37231 1434 13 induction induction NN 37231 1434 14 give give VBP 37231 1434 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1434 16 to to IN 37231 1434 17 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1434 18 ; ; : 37231 1434 19 that that RB 37231 1434 20 is is RB 37231 1434 21 , , , 37231 1434 22 whenever whenever WRB 37231 1434 23 the the DT 37231 1434 24 induction induction NN 37231 1434 25 can can MD 37231 1434 26 be be VB 37231 1434 27 complete complete JJ 37231 1434 28 . . . 37231 1435 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1435 2 have have VBP 37231 1435 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1435 4 , , , 37231 1435 5 for for IN 37231 1435 6 example example NN 37231 1435 7 , , , 37231 1435 8 in in IN 37231 1435 9 a a DT 37231 1435 10 case case NN 37231 1435 11 of of IN 37231 1435 12 causation causation NN 37231 1435 13 in in IN 37231 1435 14 which which WDT 37231 1435 15 there there EX 37231 1435 16 has have VBZ 37231 1435 17 been be VBN 37231 1435 18 an an DT 37231 1435 19 _ _ NNP 37231 1435 20 experimentum experimentum IN 37231 1435 21 cruris cruris NNP 37231 1435 22 _ _ NNP 37231 1435 23 . . . 37231 1435 24 " " '' 37231 1436 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1436 2 will will MD 37231 1436 3 be be VB 37231 1436 4 remarked remark VBN 37231 1436 5 that that IN 37231 1436 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1436 7 Farrar Farrar NNP 37231 1436 8 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 1436 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1436 10 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1436 11 's 's POS 37231 1436 12 phraseology phraseology NN 37231 1436 13 in in IN 37231 1436 14 one one CD 37231 1436 15 of of IN 37231 1436 16 the the DT 37231 1436 17 above above JJ 37231 1436 18 questions question NNS 37231 1436 19 to to TO 37231 1436 20 affirm affirm VB 37231 1436 21 the the DT 37231 1436 22 reverse reverse NN 37231 1436 23 of of IN 37231 1436 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1436 25 opinion opinion NN 37231 1436 26 . . . 37231 1437 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1437 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1437 3 decides decide VBZ 37231 1437 4 that that IN 37231 1437 5 the the DT 37231 1437 6 proposition proposition NN 37231 1437 7 is be VBZ 37231 1437 8 not not RB 37231 1437 9 a a DT 37231 1437 10 _ _ NNP 37231 1437 11 petitio petitio NNP 37231 1437 12 principii principii NN 37231 1437 13 _ _ NNP 37231 1437 14 ; ; : 37231 1437 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1437 16 Farrar Farrar NNP 37231 1437 17 says say VBZ 37231 1437 18 , , , 37231 1437 19 as as IN 37231 1437 20 in in IN 37231 1437 21 continuation continuation NN 37231 1437 22 of of IN 37231 1437 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1437 24 reference reference NN 37231 1437 25 to to IN 37231 1437 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1437 27 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1437 28 , , , 37231 1437 29 that that IN 37231 1437 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1437 31 is be VBZ 37231 1437 32 a a DT 37231 1437 33 flagrant flagrant JJ 37231 1437 34 _ _ NNP 37231 1437 35 petitio petitio NNP 37231 1437 36 principii principii NNP 37231 1437 37 _ _ NNP 37231 1437 38 . . . 37231 1438 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1438 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1438 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1438 4 to to TO 37231 1438 5 prove prove VB 37231 1438 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1438 7 statement statement NN 37231 1438 8 , , , 37231 1438 9 and and CC 37231 1438 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1438 11 naturally naturally RB 37231 1438 12 argues argue VBZ 37231 1438 13 that that IN 37231 1438 14 , , , 37231 1438 15 if if IN 37231 1438 16 observations observation NNS 37231 1438 17 or or CC 37231 1438 18 experiments experiment NNS 37231 1438 19 have have VBP 37231 1438 20 been be VBN 37231 1438 21 repeated repeat VBN 37231 1438 22 so so RB 37231 1438 23 often often RB 37231 1438 24 , , , 37231 1438 25 and and CC 37231 1438 26 by by IN 37231 1438 27 so so RB 37231 1438 28 many many JJ 37231 1438 29 persons person NNS 37231 1438 30 , , , 37231 1438 31 as as IN 37231 1438 32 to to TO 37231 1438 33 exclude exclude VB 37231 1438 34 all all DT 37231 1438 35 supposition supposition NN 37231 1438 36 of of IN 37231 1438 37 { { -LRB- 37231 1438 38 81 81 CD 37231 1438 39 } } -RRB- 37231 1438 40 error error NN 37231 1438 41 in in IN 37231 1438 42 the the DT 37231 1438 43 observer observer NN 37231 1438 44 , , , 37231 1438 45 a a DT 37231 1438 46 law law NN 37231 1438 47 of of IN 37231 1438 48 nature nature NN 37231 1438 49 is be VBZ 37231 1438 50 established establish VBN 37231 1438 51 ; ; : 37231 1438 52 and and CC 37231 1438 53 so so RB 37231 1438 54 long long RB 37231 1438 55 as as IN 37231 1438 56 this this DT 37231 1438 57 law law NN 37231 1438 58 is be VBZ 37231 1438 59 received receive VBN 37231 1438 60 as as RB 37231 1438 61 such such JJ 37231 1438 62 , , , 37231 1438 63 the the DT 37231 1438 64 assertion assertion NN 37231 1438 65 that that IN 37231 1438 66 on on IN 37231 1438 67 any any DT 37231 1438 68 particular particular JJ 37231 1438 69 occasion occasion NN 37231 1438 70 the the DT 37231 1438 71 cause cause NN 37231 1438 72 A a DT 37231 1438 73 took take VBD 37231 1438 74 place place NN 37231 1438 75 and and CC 37231 1438 76 yet yet RB 37231 1438 77 the the DT 37231 1438 78 effect effect NN 37231 1438 79 B b NN 37231 1438 80 did do VBD 37231 1438 81 not not RB 37231 1438 82 follow follow VB 37231 1438 83 , , , 37231 1438 84 _ _ NNP 37231 1438 85 without without IN 37231 1438 86 any any DT 37231 1438 87 counteracting counteracting NN 37231 1438 88 cause cause IN 37231 1438 89 _ _ NNP 37231 1438 90 , , , 37231 1438 91 must must MD 37231 1438 92 be be VB 37231 1438 93 disbelieved disbelieve VBN 37231 1438 94 . . . 37231 1439 1 In in IN 37231 1439 2 fact fact NN 37231 1439 3 , , , 37231 1439 4 as as IN 37231 1439 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1439 6 winds wind VBZ 37231 1439 7 up up RP 37231 1439 8 this this DT 37231 1439 9 part part NN 37231 1439 10 of of IN 37231 1439 11 the the DT 37231 1439 12 argument argument NN 37231 1439 13 by by IN 37231 1439 14 saying say VBG 37231 1439 15 : : : 37231 1439 16 " " `` 37231 1439 17 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1439 18 can can MD 37231 1439 19 not not RB 37231 1439 20 admit admit VB 37231 1439 21 a a DT 37231 1439 22 proposition proposition NN 37231 1439 23 as as IN 37231 1439 24 a a DT 37231 1439 25 law law NN 37231 1439 26 of of IN 37231 1439 27 nature nature NN 37231 1439 28 , , , 37231 1439 29 and and CC 37231 1439 30 yet yet RB 37231 1439 31 believe believe VB 37231 1439 32 a a DT 37231 1439 33 fact fact NN 37231 1439 34 in in IN 37231 1439 35 real real JJ 37231 1439 36 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1439 37 to to IN 37231 1439 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1439 39 . . . 37231 1440 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1440 2 must must MD 37231 1440 3 disbelieve disbelieve VB 37231 1440 4 the the DT 37231 1440 5 alleged allege VBN 37231 1440 6 fact fact NN 37231 1440 7 , , , 37231 1440 8 or or CC 37231 1440 9 believe believe VBP 37231 1440 10 that that IN 37231 1440 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1440 12 were be VBD 37231 1440 13 mistaken mistake VBN 37231 1440 14 in in IN 37231 1440 15 admitting admit VBG 37231 1440 16 the the DT 37231 1440 17 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1440 18 law law NN 37231 1440 19 . . . 37231 1441 1 " " `` 37231 1441 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1441 3 1 1 LS 37231 1441 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1441 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1441 6 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1441 7 points point VBZ 37231 1441 8 out out RP 37231 1441 9 , , , 37231 1441 10 however however RB 37231 1441 11 , , , 37231 1441 12 that that IN 37231 1441 13 , , , 37231 1441 14 in in IN 37231 1441 15 order order NN 37231 1441 16 that that IN 37231 1441 17 any any DT 37231 1441 18 alleged alleged JJ 37231 1441 19 fact fact NN 37231 1441 20 should should MD 37231 1441 21 be be VB 37231 1441 22 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1441 23 to to IN 37231 1441 24 a a DT 37231 1441 25 law law NN 37231 1441 26 of of IN 37231 1441 27 causation causation NN 37231 1441 28 , , , 37231 1441 29 the the DT 37231 1441 30 allegation allegation NN 37231 1441 31 must must MD 37231 1441 32 be be VB 37231 1441 33 not not RB 37231 1441 34 simply simply RB 37231 1441 35 that that IN 37231 1441 36 the the DT 37231 1441 37 cause cause NN 37231 1441 38 existed exist VBD 37231 1441 39 without without IN 37231 1441 40 being be VBG 37231 1441 41 followed follow VBN 37231 1441 42 by by IN 37231 1441 43 the the DT 37231 1441 44 effect effect NN 37231 1441 45 , , , 37231 1441 46 but but CC 37231 1441 47 that that IN 37231 1441 48 this this DT 37231 1441 49 happened happen VBD 37231 1441 50 in in IN 37231 1441 51 the the DT 37231 1441 52 absence absence NN 37231 1441 53 of of IN 37231 1441 54 any any DT 37231 1441 55 adequate adequate JJ 37231 1441 56 counteracting counteracting NN 37231 1441 57 cause cause NN 37231 1441 58 . . . 37231 1442 1 " " `` 37231 1442 2 Now now RB 37231 1442 3 , , , 37231 1442 4 in in IN 37231 1442 5 the the DT 37231 1442 6 case case NN 37231 1442 7 of of IN 37231 1442 8 an an DT 37231 1442 9 alleged alleged JJ 37231 1442 10 miracle miracle NN 37231 1442 11 , , , 37231 1442 12 the the DT 37231 1442 13 assertion assertion NN 37231 1442 14 is be VBZ 37231 1442 15 the the DT 37231 1442 16 exact exact JJ 37231 1442 17 opposite opposite NN 37231 1442 18 of of IN 37231 1442 19 this this DT 37231 1442 20 . . . 37231 1443 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1443 2 is be VBZ 37231 1443 3 , , , 37231 1443 4 that that IN 37231 1443 5 the the DT 37231 1443 6 effect effect NN 37231 1443 7 was be VBD 37231 1443 8 defeated defeat VBN 37231 1443 9 , , , 37231 1443 10 not not RB 37231 1443 11 in in IN 37231 1443 12 the the DT 37231 1443 13 absence absence NN 37231 1443 14 , , , 37231 1443 15 but but CC 37231 1443 16 in in IN 37231 1443 17 consequence consequence NN 37231 1443 18 of of IN 37231 1443 19 a a DT 37231 1443 20 counteracting counteracting NN 37231 1443 21 cause cause NN 37231 1443 22 , , , 37231 1443 23 namely namely RB 37231 1443 24 , , , 37231 1443 25 a a DT 37231 1443 26 direct direct JJ 37231 1443 27 interposition interposition NN 37231 1443 28 of of IN 37231 1443 29 an an DT 37231 1443 30 act act NN 37231 1443 31 of of IN 37231 1443 32 the the DT 37231 1443 33 will will NN 37231 1443 34 of of IN 37231 1443 35 some some DT 37231 1443 36 being be VBG 37231 1443 37 who who WP 37231 1443 38 has have VBZ 37231 1443 39 power power NN 37231 1443 40 over over IN 37231 1443 41 nature nature NN 37231 1443 42 ; ; : 37231 1443 43 and and CC 37231 1443 44 in in IN 37231 1443 45 particular particular JJ 37231 1443 46 of of IN 37231 1443 47 a a DT 37231 1443 48 Being Being NNP 37231 1443 49 , , , 37231 1443 50 whose whose WP$ 37231 1443 51 will will NN 37231 1443 52 being be VBG 37231 1443 53 assumed assume VBN 37231 1443 54 to to TO 37231 1443 55 have have VB 37231 1443 56 endowed endow VBN 37231 1443 57 all all PDT 37231 1443 58 the the DT 37231 1443 59 causes cause NNS 37231 1443 60 with with IN 37231 1443 61 the the DT 37231 1443 62 powers power NNS 37231 1443 63 by by IN 37231 1443 64 which which WDT 37231 1443 65 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1443 66 produce produce VBP 37231 1443 67 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1443 68 effects effect NNS 37231 1443 69 , , , 37231 1443 70 may may MD 37231 1443 71 well well RB 37231 1443 72 be be VB 37231 1443 73 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1443 74 able able JJ 37231 1443 75 to to TO 37231 1443 76 counteract counteract VB 37231 1443 77 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1443 78 . . . 37231 1444 1 " " `` 37231 1444 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1444 3 2 2 LS 37231 1444 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1444 5 A a DT 37231 1444 6 miracle miracle NN 37231 1444 7 , , , 37231 1444 8 then then RB 37231 1444 9 , , , 37231 1444 10 is be VBZ 37231 1444 11 no no DT 37231 1444 12 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1444 13 to to IN 37231 1444 14 the the DT 37231 1444 15 law law NN 37231 1444 16 of of IN 37231 1444 17 cause cause NN 37231 1444 18 and and CC 37231 1444 19 effect effect NN 37231 1444 20 ; ; : 37231 1444 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1444 22 is be VBZ 37231 1444 23 merely merely RB 37231 1444 24 a a DT 37231 1444 25 new new JJ 37231 1444 26 effect effect NN 37231 1444 27 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1444 28 to to TO 37231 1444 29 be be VB 37231 1444 30 introduced introduce VBN 37231 1444 31 by by IN 37231 1444 32 the the DT 37231 1444 33 introduction introduction NN 37231 1444 34 of of IN 37231 1444 35 a a DT 37231 1444 36 new new JJ 37231 1444 37 cause cause NN 37231 1444 38 ; ; : 37231 1444 39 " " `` 37231 1444 40 of of IN 37231 1444 41 the the DT 37231 1444 42 adequacy adequacy NN 37231 1444 43 of of IN 37231 1444 44 that that DT 37231 1444 45 cause cause NN 37231 1444 46 _ _ NNP 37231 1444 47 if if IN 37231 1444 48 present,_(3 present,_(3 NNP 37231 1444 49 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1444 50 there there EX 37231 1444 51 can can MD 37231 1444 52 be be VB 37231 1444 53 no no RB 37231 1444 54 doubt doubt RB 37231 1444 55 ; ; : 37231 1444 56 and and CC 37231 1444 57 the the DT 37231 1444 58 only only JJ 37231 1444 59 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1444 60 improbability improbability NN 37231 1444 61 which which WDT 37231 1444 62 can can MD 37231 1444 63 be be VB 37231 1444 64 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1444 65 to to IN 37231 1444 66 the the DT 37231 1444 67 miracle miracle NN 37231 1444 68 is be VBZ 37231 1444 69 the the DT 37231 1444 70 improbability improbability NN 37231 1444 71 that that WDT 37231 1444 72 any any DT 37231 1444 73 such such JJ 37231 1444 74 cause cause NN 37231 1444 75 existed exist VBD 37231 1444 76 . . . 37231 1444 77 " " '' 37231 1445 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1445 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1445 3 then then RB 37231 1445 4 continues continue VBZ 37231 1445 5 , , , 37231 1445 6 resuming resume VBG 37231 1445 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1445 8 criticism criticism NN 37231 1445 9 on on IN 37231 1445 10 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1445 11 's 's POS 37231 1445 12 argument argument NN 37231 1445 13 : : : 37231 1445 14 { { -LRB- 37231 1445 15 82 82 CD 37231 1445 16 } } -RRB- 37231 1445 17 " " `` 37231 1445 18 All all DT 37231 1445 19 , , , 37231 1445 20 therefore therefore RB 37231 1445 21 , , , 37231 1445 22 which which WDT 37231 1445 23 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1445 24 has have VBZ 37231 1445 25 made make VBN 37231 1445 26 out out RP 37231 1445 27 , , , 37231 1445 28 and and CC 37231 1445 29 this this DT 37231 1445 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1445 31 must must MD 37231 1445 32 be be VB 37231 1445 33 considered consider VBN 37231 1445 34 to to TO 37231 1445 35 have have VB 37231 1445 36 made make VBN 37231 1445 37 out out RP 37231 1445 38 , , , 37231 1445 39 is be VBZ 37231 1445 40 that that DT 37231 1445 41 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1445 42 at at IN 37231 1445 43 least least JJS 37231 1445 44 in in IN 37231 1445 45 the the DT 37231 1445 46 imperfect imperfect JJ 37231 1445 47 state state NN 37231 1445 48 of of IN 37231 1445 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1445 50 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1445 51 of of IN 37231 1445 52 natural natural JJ 37231 1445 53 agencies agency NNS 37231 1445 54 , , , 37231 1445 55 which which WDT 37231 1445 56 leaves leave VBZ 37231 1445 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1445 58 always always RB 37231 1445 59 possible possible JJ 37231 1445 60 that that IN 37231 1445 61 some some DT 37231 1445 62 of of IN 37231 1445 63 the the DT 37231 1445 64 physical physical JJ 37231 1445 65 antecedents antecedent NNS 37231 1445 66 may may MD 37231 1445 67 have have VB 37231 1445 68 been be VBN 37231 1445 69 hidden hide VBN 37231 1445 70 from from IN 37231 1445 71 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1445 72 , , , 37231 1445 73 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1445 74 no no DT 37231 1445 75 evidence evidence NN 37231 1445 76 can can MD 37231 1445 77 prove prove VB 37231 1445 78 a a DT 37231 1445 79 miracle miracle NN 37231 1445 80 to to IN 37231 1445 81 any any DT 37231 1445 82 one one NN 37231 1445 83 who who WP 37231 1445 84 did do VBD 37231 1445 85 not not RB 37231 1445 86 previously previously RB 37231 1445 87 believe believe VB 37231 1445 88 the the DT 37231 1445 89 existence existence NN 37231 1445 90 of of IN 37231 1445 91 a a DT 37231 1445 92 being being NN 37231 1445 93 or or CC 37231 1445 94 beings being NNS 37231 1445 95 with with IN 37231 1445 96 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1445 97 power power NN 37231 1445 98 ; ; : 37231 1445 99 or or CC 37231 1445 100 who who WP 37231 1445 101 believes believe VBZ 37231 1445 102 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1445 103 to to TO 37231 1445 104 have have VB 37231 1445 105 full full JJ 37231 1445 106 proof proof NN 37231 1445 107 that that IN 37231 1445 108 the the DT 37231 1445 109 character character NN 37231 1445 110 of of IN 37231 1445 111 the the DT 37231 1445 112 Being be VBG 37231 1445 113 whom whom WP 37231 1445 114 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1445 115 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 1445 116 is be VBZ 37231 1445 117 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37231 1445 118 with with IN 37231 1445 119 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1445 120 having have VBG 37231 1445 121 seen see VBN 37231 1445 122 fit fit JJ 37231 1445 123 to to TO 37231 1445 124 interfere interfere VB 37231 1445 125 on on IN 37231 1445 126 the the DT 37231 1445 127 occasion occasion NN 37231 1445 128 in in IN 37231 1445 129 question question NN 37231 1445 130 . . . 37231 1445 131 " " '' 37231 1446 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1446 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1446 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1446 4 to to TO 37231 1446 5 enlarge enlarge VB 37231 1446 6 on on IN 37231 1446 7 this this DT 37231 1446 8 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1446 9 . . . 37231 1447 1 " " `` 37231 1447 2 If if IN 37231 1447 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1447 4 do do VBP 37231 1447 5 not not RB 37231 1447 6 already already RB 37231 1447 7 believe believe VB 37231 1447 8 in in IN 37231 1447 9 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1447 10 agencies agency NNS 37231 1447 11 , , , 37231 1447 12 no no DT 37231 1447 13 miracle miracle NN 37231 1447 14 can can MD 37231 1447 15 prove prove VB 37231 1447 16 to to IN 37231 1447 17 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1447 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1447 19 existence existence NN 37231 1447 20 . . . 37231 1448 1 The the DT 37231 1448 2 miracle miracle NN 37231 1448 3 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1448 4 , , , 37231 1448 5 considered consider VBN 37231 1448 6 merely merely RB 37231 1448 7 as as IN 37231 1448 8 an an DT 37231 1448 9 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 1448 10 fact fact NN 37231 1448 11 , , , 37231 1448 12 may may MD 37231 1448 13 be be VB 37231 1448 14 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 37231 1448 15 certified certify VBN 37231 1448 16 by by IN 37231 1448 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1448 18 senses sense NNS 37231 1448 19 or or CC 37231 1448 20 by by IN 37231 1448 21 testimony testimony NN 37231 1448 22 ; ; : 37231 1448 23 but but CC 37231 1448 24 nothing nothing NN 37231 1448 25 can can MD 37231 1448 26 ever ever RB 37231 1448 27 prove prove VB 37231 1448 28 that that IN 37231 1448 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1448 30 is be VBZ 37231 1448 31 a a DT 37231 1448 32 miracle miracle NN 37231 1448 33 : : : 37231 1448 34 there there EX 37231 1448 35 is be VBZ 37231 1448 36 still still RB 37231 1448 37 another another DT 37231 1448 38 possible possible JJ 37231 1448 39 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1448 40 , , , 37231 1448 41 that that DT 37231 1448 42 of of IN 37231 1448 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1448 44 being be VBG 37231 1448 45 the the DT 37231 1448 46 result result NN 37231 1448 47 of of IN 37231 1448 48 some some DT 37231 1448 49 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1448 50 natural natural JJ 37231 1448 51 cause cause NN 37231 1448 52 : : : 37231 1448 53 and and CC 37231 1448 54 this this DT 37231 1448 55 possibility possibility NN 37231 1448 56 can can MD 37231 1448 57 not not RB 37231 1448 58 be be VB 37231 1448 59 so so RB 37231 1448 60 completely completely RB 37231 1448 61 shut shut VBN 37231 1448 62 out out RP 37231 1448 63 as as IN 37231 1448 64 to to TO 37231 1448 65 leave leave VB 37231 1448 66 no no DT 37231 1448 67 alternative alternative NN 37231 1448 68 but but CC 37231 1448 69 that that IN 37231 1448 70 of of IN 37231 1448 71 admitting admit VBG 37231 1448 72 the the DT 37231 1448 73 existence existence NN 37231 1448 74 and and CC 37231 1448 75 intervention intervention NN 37231 1448 76 of of IN 37231 1448 77 a a DT 37231 1448 78 being be VBG 37231 1448 79 superior superior JJ 37231 1448 80 to to IN 37231 1448 81 nature nature NN 37231 1448 82 . . . 37231 1449 1 Those those DT 37231 1449 2 , , , 37231 1449 3 however however RB 37231 1449 4 , , , 37231 1449 5 who who WP 37231 1449 6 already already RB 37231 1449 7 believe believe VBP 37231 1449 8 in in IN 37231 1449 9 such such PDT 37231 1449 10 a a DT 37231 1449 11 being being NN 37231 1449 12 have have VB 37231 1449 13 two two CD 37231 1449 14 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 37231 1449 15 to to TO 37231 1449 16 choose choose VB 37231 1449 17 from from IN 37231 1449 18 , , , 37231 1449 19 a a DT 37231 1449 20 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1449 21 , , , 37231 1449 22 and and CC 37231 1449 23 an an DT 37231 1449 24 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1449 25 natural natural JJ 37231 1449 26 agency agency NN 37231 1449 27 ; ; : 37231 1449 28 and and CC 37231 1449 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1449 30 have have VBP 37231 1449 31 to to TO 37231 1449 32 judge judge VB 37231 1449 33 which which WDT 37231 1449 34 of of IN 37231 1449 35 the the DT 37231 1449 36 two two CD 37231 1449 37 is be VBZ 37231 1449 38 the the DT 37231 1449 39 most most RBS 37231 1449 40 probable probable JJ 37231 1449 41 in in IN 37231 1449 42 the the DT 37231 1449 43 particular particular JJ 37231 1449 44 case case NN 37231 1449 45 . . . 37231 1450 1 In in IN 37231 1450 2 forming form VBG 37231 1450 3 this this DT 37231 1450 4 judgment judgment NN 37231 1450 5 , , , 37231 1450 6 an an DT 37231 1450 7 important important JJ 37231 1450 8 element element NN 37231 1450 9 of of IN 37231 1450 10 the the DT 37231 1450 11 question question NN 37231 1450 12 will will MD 37231 1450 13 be be VB 37231 1450 14 the the DT 37231 1450 15 conformity conformity NN 37231 1450 16 of of IN 37231 1450 17 the the DT 37231 1450 18 result result NN 37231 1450 19 to to IN 37231 1450 20 the the DT 37231 1450 21 laws law NNS 37231 1450 22 of of IN 37231 1450 23 the the DT 37231 1450 24 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1450 25 agent agent NN 37231 1450 26 ; ; : 37231 1450 27 that that RB 37231 1450 28 is is RB 37231 1450 29 , , , 37231 1450 30 to to IN 37231 1450 31 the the DT 37231 1450 32 character character NN 37231 1450 33 of of IN 37231 1450 34 the the DT 37231 1450 35 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1450 36 as as IN 37231 1450 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1450 38 conceive conceive VBP 37231 1450 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1450 40 . . . 37231 1451 1 But but CC 37231 1451 2 , , , 37231 1451 3 with with IN 37231 1451 4 the the DT 37231 1451 5 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1451 6 which which WDT 37231 1451 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1451 8 now now RB 37231 1451 9 possess possess VBP 37231 1451 10 of of IN 37231 1451 11 the the DT 37231 1451 12 general general JJ 37231 1451 13 uniformity uniformity NN 37231 1451 14 of of IN 37231 1451 15 the the DT 37231 1451 16 course course NN 37231 1451 17 of of IN 37231 1451 18 nature nature NN 37231 1451 19 , , , 37231 1451 20 religion religion NN 37231 1451 21 , , , 37231 1451 22 following follow VBG 37231 1451 23 in in IN 37231 1451 24 the the DT 37231 1451 25 wake wake NN 37231 1451 26 of of IN 37231 1451 27 science science NN 37231 1451 28 , , , 37231 1451 29 has have VBZ 37231 1451 30 been be VBN 37231 1451 31 compelled compel VBN 37231 1451 32 to to TO 37231 1451 33 acknowledge acknowledge VB 37231 1451 34 the the DT 37231 1451 35 government government NN 37231 1451 36 of of IN 37231 1451 37 the the DT 37231 1451 38 universe universe NN 37231 1451 39 as as IN 37231 1451 40 { { -LRB- 37231 1451 41 83 83 CD 37231 1451 42 } } -RRB- 37231 1451 43 being be VBG 37231 1451 44 on on IN 37231 1451 45 the the DT 37231 1451 46 whole whole NN 37231 1451 47 carried carry VBN 37231 1451 48 on on RP 37231 1451 49 by by IN 37231 1451 50 general general JJ 37231 1451 51 laws law NNS 37231 1451 52 , , , 37231 1451 53 and and CC 37231 1451 54 not not RB 37231 1451 55 by by IN 37231 1451 56 special special JJ 37231 1451 57 interpositions interposition NNS 37231 1451 58 . . . 37231 1452 1 To to IN 37231 1452 2 whoever whoever WP 37231 1452 3 holds hold VBZ 37231 1452 4 this this DT 37231 1452 5 belief belief NN 37231 1452 6 , , , 37231 1452 7 there there EX 37231 1452 8 is be VBZ 37231 1452 9 a a DT 37231 1452 10 general general JJ 37231 1452 11 presumption presumption NN 37231 1452 12 against against IN 37231 1452 13 any any DT 37231 1452 14 supposition supposition NN 37231 1452 15 of of IN 37231 1452 16 divine divine JJ 37231 1452 17 agency agency NN 37231 1452 18 not not RB 37231 1452 19 operating operate VBG 37231 1452 20 through through IN 37231 1452 21 general general JJ 37231 1452 22 laws law NNS 37231 1452 23 , , , 37231 1452 24 or or CC 37231 1452 25 , , , 37231 1452 26 in in IN 37231 1452 27 other other JJ 37231 1452 28 words word NNS 37231 1452 29 , , , 37231 1452 30 there there EX 37231 1452 31 is be VBZ 37231 1452 32 an an DT 37231 1452 33 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1452 34 improbability improbability NN 37231 1452 35 in in IN 37231 1452 36 every every DT 37231 1452 37 miracle miracle NN 37231 1452 38 , , , 37231 1452 39 which which WDT 37231 1452 40 , , , 37231 1452 41 in in IN 37231 1452 42 order order NN 37231 1452 43 to to TO 37231 1452 44 outweigh outweigh VB 37231 1452 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1452 46 , , , 37231 1452 47 requires require VBZ 37231 1452 48 an an DT 37231 1452 49 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 1452 50 strength strength NN 37231 1452 51 of of IN 37231 1452 52 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1452 53 probability probability NN 37231 1452 54 derived derive VBN 37231 1452 55 from from IN 37231 1452 56 the the DT 37231 1452 57 special special JJ 37231 1452 58 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1452 59 of of IN 37231 1452 60 the the DT 37231 1452 61 case case NN 37231 1452 62 . . . 37231 1453 1 " " `` 37231 1453 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1453 3 1 1 LS 37231 1453 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1453 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1453 6 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1453 7 rightly rightly RB 37231 1453 8 considers consider VBZ 37231 1453 9 that that IN 37231 1453 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1453 11 is be VBZ 37231 1453 12 not not RB 37231 1453 13 more more RBR 37231 1453 14 difficult difficult JJ 37231 1453 15 to to TO 37231 1453 16 estimate estimate VB 37231 1453 17 this this DT 37231 1453 18 than than IN 37231 1453 19 in in IN 37231 1453 20 the the DT 37231 1453 21 case case NN 37231 1453 22 of of IN 37231 1453 23 other other JJ 37231 1453 24 probabilities probability NNS 37231 1453 25 . . . 37231 1454 1 " " `` 37231 1454 2 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1454 3 are be VBP 37231 1454 4 seldom seldom RB 37231 1454 5 , , , 37231 1454 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 1454 7 , , , 37231 1454 8 without without IN 37231 1454 9 the the DT 37231 1454 10 means mean NNS 37231 1454 11 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1454 12 when when WRB 37231 1454 13 the the DT 37231 1454 14 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1454 15 of of IN 37231 1454 16 the the DT 37231 1454 17 case case NN 37231 1454 18 are be VBP 37231 1454 19 at at RB 37231 1454 20 all all RB 37231 1454 21 known know VBN 37231 1454 22 to to IN 37231 1454 23 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1454 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1454 25 of of IN 37231 1454 26 judging judge VBG 37231 1454 27 how how WRB 37231 1454 28 far far RB 37231 1454 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1454 30 is be VBZ 37231 1454 31 likely likely JJ 37231 1454 32 that that IN 37231 1454 33 such such PDT 37231 1454 34 a a DT 37231 1454 35 cause cause NN 37231 1454 36 should should MD 37231 1454 37 have have VB 37231 1454 38 existed exist VBN 37231 1454 39 at at IN 37231 1454 40 that that DT 37231 1454 41 time time NN 37231 1454 42 and and CC 37231 1454 43 place place NN 37231 1454 44 without without IN 37231 1454 45 manifesting manifest VBG 37231 1454 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1454 47 presence presence NN 37231 1454 48 by by IN 37231 1454 49 some some DT 37231 1454 50 other other JJ 37231 1454 51 marks mark NNS 37231 1454 52 , , , 37231 1454 53 and and CC 37231 1454 54 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1454 55 in in IN 37231 1454 56 the the DT 37231 1454 57 case case NN 37231 1454 58 of of IN 37231 1454 59 an an DT 37231 1454 60 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1454 61 cause cause NN 37231 1454 62 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1454 63 without without IN 37231 1454 64 having have VBG 37231 1454 65 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 1454 66 manifested manifest VBN 37231 1454 67 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1454 68 existence existence NN 37231 1454 69 in in IN 37231 1454 70 any any DT 37231 1454 71 other other JJ 37231 1454 72 instance instance NN 37231 1454 73 . . . 37231 1455 1 According accord VBG 37231 1455 2 as as IN 37231 1455 3 this this DT 37231 1455 4 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 1455 5 , , , 37231 1455 6 or or CC 37231 1455 7 the the DT 37231 1455 8 falsity falsity NN 37231 1455 9 of of IN 37231 1455 10 the the DT 37231 1455 11 testimony testimony NN 37231 1455 12 , , , 37231 1455 13 appears appear VBZ 37231 1455 14 more more RBR 37231 1455 15 improbable improbable JJ 37231 1455 16 , , , 37231 1455 17 that that RB 37231 1455 18 is is RB 37231 1455 19 , , , 37231 1455 20 conflicts conflict NNS 37231 1455 21 with with IN 37231 1455 22 an an DT 37231 1455 23 approximate approximate JJ 37231 1455 24 generalization generalization NN 37231 1455 25 of of IN 37231 1455 26 a a DT 37231 1455 27 higher high JJR 37231 1455 28 order order NN 37231 1455 29 , , , 37231 1455 30 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1455 31 believe believe VBP 37231 1455 32 the the DT 37231 1455 33 testimony testimony NN 37231 1455 34 , , , 37231 1455 35 or or CC 37231 1455 36 disbelieve disbelieve VB 37231 1455 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1455 38 ; ; : 37231 1455 39 with with IN 37231 1455 40 a a DT 37231 1455 41 stronger strong JJR 37231 1455 42 or or CC 37231 1455 43 weaker weak JJR 37231 1455 44 degree degree NN 37231 1455 45 of of IN 37231 1455 46 conviction conviction NN 37231 1455 47 , , , 37231 1455 48 according accord VBG 37231 1455 49 to to IN 37231 1455 50 the the DT 37231 1455 51 preponderance preponderance NN 37231 1455 52 : : : 37231 1455 53 at at IN 37231 1455 54 least least JJS 37231 1455 55 until until IN 37231 1455 56 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1455 57 have have VBP 37231 1455 58 sifted sift VBN 37231 1455 59 the the DT 37231 1455 60 matter matter NN 37231 1455 61 further further RB 37231 1455 62 . . . 37231 1456 1 " " `` 37231 1456 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1456 3 2 2 LS 37231 1456 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1456 5 This this DT 37231 1456 6 is be VBZ 37231 1456 7 precisely precisely RB 37231 1456 8 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1456 9 's 's POS 37231 1456 10 argument argument NN 37231 1456 11 weakened weaken VBN 37231 1456 12 by by IN 37231 1456 13 the the DT 37231 1456 14 introduction introduction NN 37231 1456 15 of of IN 37231 1456 16 reservations reservation NNS 37231 1456 17 which which WDT 37231 1456 18 have have VBP 37231 1456 19 no no DT 37231 1456 20 cogency cogency NN 37231 1456 21 . . . 37231 1457 1 " " `` 37231 1457 2 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1457 3 have have VBP 37231 1457 4 wished wish VBN 37231 1457 5 to to TO 37231 1457 6 avoid avoid VB 37231 1457 7 interrupting interrupt VBG 37231 1457 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1457 9 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1457 10 's 's POS 37231 1457 11 train train NN 37231 1457 12 of of IN 37231 1457 13 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1457 14 by by IN 37231 1457 15 any any DT 37231 1457 16 remarks remark NNS 37231 1457 17 of of IN 37231 1457 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1457 19 own own JJ 37231 1457 20 , , , 37231 1457 21 and and CC 37231 1457 22 have have VBP 37231 1457 23 , , , 37231 1457 24 therefore therefore RB 37231 1457 25 , , , 37231 1457 26 deferred defer VBN 37231 1457 27 till till IN 37231 1457 28 now now RB 37231 1457 29 the the DT 37231 1457 30 following follow VBG 37231 1457 31 observations observation NNS 37231 1457 32 regarding regard VBG 37231 1457 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1457 34 criticism criticism NN 37231 1457 35 on on IN 37231 1457 36 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1457 37 's 's POS 37231 1457 38 argument argument NN 37231 1457 39 . . . 37231 1458 1 In in IN 37231 1458 2 reducing reduce VBG 37231 1458 3 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1458 4 's 's POS 37231 1458 5 celebrated celebrated JJ 37231 1458 6 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1458 7 to to IN 37231 1458 8 the the DT 37231 1458 9 very very RB 37231 1458 10 plain plain JJ 37231 1458 11 proposition proposition NN 37231 1458 12 that that IN 37231 1458 13 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1458 14 is be VBZ 37231 1458 15 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1458 16 to to IN 37231 1458 17 a a DT 37231 1458 18 complete complete JJ 37231 1458 19 induction induction NN 37231 1458 20 is be VBZ 37231 1458 21 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1458 22 , , , 37231 1458 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1458 24 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1458 25 in in IN 37231 1458 26 no no DT 37231 1458 27 way way NN 37231 1458 28 { { -LRB- 37231 1458 29 84 84 CD 37231 1458 30 } } -RRB- 37231 1458 31 diminishes diminish VBZ 37231 1458 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1458 33 potency potency NN 37231 1458 34 against against IN 37231 1458 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1458 36 ; ; : 37231 1458 37 and and CC 37231 1458 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1458 39 does do VBZ 37231 1458 40 not not RB 37231 1458 41 call call VB 37231 1458 42 that that DT 37231 1458 43 proposition proposition NN 37231 1458 44 " " `` 37231 1458 45 harmless harmless JJ 37231 1458 46 " " '' 37231 1458 47 in in IN 37231 1458 48 reference reference NN 37231 1458 49 to to IN 37231 1458 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1458 51 bearing bearing NN 37231 1458 52 on on IN 37231 1458 53 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1458 54 , , , 37231 1458 55 as as IN 37231 1458 56 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1458 57 Farrar Farrar NNP 37231 1458 58 evidently evidently RB 37231 1458 59 supposes suppose VBZ 37231 1458 60 , , , 37231 1458 61 but but CC 37231 1458 62 merely merely RB 37231 1458 63 in in IN 37231 1458 64 opposition opposition NN 37231 1458 65 to to IN 37231 1458 66 the the DT 37231 1458 67 character character NN 37231 1458 68 of of IN 37231 1458 69 a a DT 37231 1458 70 recondite recondite NN 37231 1458 71 and and CC 37231 1458 72 " " `` 37231 1458 73 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 1458 74 heresy heresy NN 37231 1458 75 " " '' 37231 1458 76 assigned assign VBN 37231 1458 77 by by IN 37231 1458 78 dismayed dismayed JJ 37231 1458 79 theologians theologian NNS 37231 1458 80 to to IN 37231 1458 81 so so RB 37231 1458 82 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1458 83 and and CC 37231 1458 84 simple simple JJ 37231 1458 85 a a DT 37231 1458 86 principle principle NN 37231 1458 87 . . . 37231 1459 1 The the DT 37231 1459 2 proposition proposition NN 37231 1459 3 , , , 37231 1459 4 however however RB 37231 1459 5 , , , 37231 1459 6 whilst whilst IN 37231 1459 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1459 8 reduces reduce VBZ 37231 1459 9 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1459 10 's 's POS 37231 1459 11 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1459 12 in in IN 37231 1459 13 the the DT 37231 1459 14 abstract abstract NN 37231 1459 15 to to IN 37231 1459 16 more more RBR 37231 1459 17 technical technical JJ 37231 1459 18 terms term NNS 37231 1459 19 , , , 37231 1459 20 does do VBZ 37231 1459 21 not not RB 37231 1459 22 altogether altogether RB 37231 1459 23 represent represent VB 37231 1459 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1459 25 argument argument NN 37231 1459 26 . . . 37231 1460 1 Without without IN 37231 1460 2 asserting assert VBG 37231 1460 3 that that DT 37231 1460 4 experience experience NN 37231 1460 5 is be VBZ 37231 1460 6 an an DT 37231 1460 7 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 1460 8 infallible infallible JJ 37231 1460 9 guide guide NN 37231 1460 10 , , , 37231 1460 11 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1460 12 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 1460 13 that-- that-- NN 37231 1460 14 " " `` 37231 1460 15 A a DT 37231 1460 16 wise wise JJ 37231 1460 17 man man NN 37231 1460 18 proportions proportion VBZ 37231 1460 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1460 20 belief belief NN 37231 1460 21 to to IN 37231 1460 22 the the DT 37231 1460 23 evidence evidence NN 37231 1460 24 . . . 37231 1461 1 In in IN 37231 1461 2 such such JJ 37231 1461 3 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1461 4 as as IN 37231 1461 5 are be VBP 37231 1461 6 founded found VBN 37231 1461 7 on on IN 37231 1461 8 an an DT 37231 1461 9 infallible infallible JJ 37231 1461 10 experience experience NN 37231 1461 11 , , , 37231 1461 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1461 13 expects expect VBZ 37231 1461 14 the the DT 37231 1461 15 event event NN 37231 1461 16 with with IN 37231 1461 17 the the DT 37231 1461 18 last last JJ 37231 1461 19 degree degree NN 37231 1461 20 of of IN 37231 1461 21 assurance assurance NN 37231 1461 22 , , , 37231 1461 23 and and CC 37231 1461 24 regards regard VBZ 37231 1461 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1461 26 past past JJ 37231 1461 27 experience experience NN 37231 1461 28 as as IN 37231 1461 29 a a DT 37231 1461 30 full full JJ 37231 1461 31 proof proof NN 37231 1461 32 of of IN 37231 1461 33 the the DT 37231 1461 34 future future JJ 37231 1461 35 existence existence NN 37231 1461 36 of of IN 37231 1461 37 that that DT 37231 1461 38 event event NN 37231 1461 39 . . . 37231 1462 1 In in IN 37231 1462 2 other other JJ 37231 1462 3 cases case NNS 37231 1462 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1462 5 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1462 6 with with IN 37231 1462 7 more more JJR 37231 1462 8 caution caution NN 37231 1462 9 , , , 37231 1462 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1462 11 weighs weigh VBZ 37231 1462 12 the the DT 37231 1462 13 opposite opposite JJ 37231 1462 14 experiments experiment NNS 37231 1462 15 : : : 37231 1462 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1462 17 considers consider VBZ 37231 1462 18 which which WDT 37231 1462 19 side side NN 37231 1462 20 is be VBZ 37231 1462 21 supported support VBN 37231 1462 22 by by IN 37231 1462 23 the the DT 37231 1462 24 greater great JJR 37231 1462 25 number number NN 37231 1462 26 of of IN 37231 1462 27 experiments experiment NNS 37231 1462 28 : : : 37231 1462 29 to to IN 37231 1462 30 that that DT 37231 1462 31 side side NN 37231 1462 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1462 33 inclines incline VBZ 37231 1462 34 with with IN 37231 1462 35 doubt doubt NN 37231 1462 36 and and CC 37231 1462 37 hesitation hesitation NN 37231 1462 38 ; ; : 37231 1462 39 and and CC 37231 1462 40 when when WRB 37231 1462 41 at at IN 37231 1462 42 last last RB 37231 1462 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1462 44 fixes fix VBZ 37231 1462 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1462 46 judgment judgment NN 37231 1462 47 , , , 37231 1462 48 the the DT 37231 1462 49 evidence evidence NN 37231 1462 50 exceeds exceed VBZ 37231 1462 51 not not RB 37231 1462 52 what what WP 37231 1462 53 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1462 54 properly properly RB 37231 1462 55 call call VBP 37231 1462 56 _ _ NNP 37231 1462 57 probability probability NN 37231 1462 58 _ _ NNP 37231 1462 59 . . . 37231 1463 1 All all DT 37231 1463 2 probability probability NN 37231 1463 3 , , , 37231 1463 4 then then RB 37231 1463 5 , , , 37231 1463 6 supposes suppose VBZ 37231 1463 7 an an DT 37231 1463 8 opposition opposition NN 37231 1463 9 of of IN 37231 1463 10 experiments experiment NNS 37231 1463 11 and and CC 37231 1463 12 observations observation NNS 37231 1463 13 , , , 37231 1463 14 where where WRB 37231 1463 15 the the DT 37231 1463 16 one one CD 37231 1463 17 side side NN 37231 1463 18 is be VBZ 37231 1463 19 found find VBN 37231 1463 20 to to TO 37231 1463 21 overbalance overbalance VB 37231 1463 22 the the DT 37231 1463 23 other other JJ 37231 1463 24 , , , 37231 1463 25 and and CC 37231 1463 26 to to TO 37231 1463 27 produce produce VB 37231 1463 28 a a DT 37231 1463 29 degree degree NN 37231 1463 30 of of IN 37231 1463 31 evidence evidence NN 37231 1463 32 proportioned proportion VBD 37231 1463 33 to to IN 37231 1463 34 the the DT 37231 1463 35 superiority superiority NN 37231 1463 36 . . . 37231 1464 1 " " `` 37231 1464 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1464 3 l l NN 37231 1464 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1464 5 After after IN 37231 1464 6 elaborating elaborate VBG 37231 1464 7 this this DT 37231 1464 8 proposition proposition NN 37231 1464 9 , , , 37231 1464 10 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1464 11 continues continue VBZ 37231 1464 12 : : : 37231 1464 13 " " `` 37231 1464 14 A a DT 37231 1464 15 miracle miracle NN 37231 1464 16 is be VBZ 37231 1464 17 a a DT 37231 1464 18 violation violation NN 37231 1464 19 of of IN 37231 1464 20 the the DT 37231 1464 21 laws law NNS 37231 1464 22 of of IN 37231 1464 23 nature nature NN 37231 1464 24 ; ; : 37231 1464 25 and and CC 37231 1464 26 as as IN 37231 1464 27 a a DT 37231 1464 28 firm firm JJ 37231 1464 29 and and CC 37231 1464 30 unalterable unalterable JJ 37231 1464 31 experience experience NN 37231 1464 32 has have VBZ 37231 1464 33 established establish VBN 37231 1464 34 these these DT 37231 1464 35 laws law NNS 37231 1464 36 , , , 37231 1464 37 the the DT 37231 1464 38 proof proof NN 37231 1464 39 against against IN 37231 1464 40 a a DT 37231 1464 41 miracle miracle NN 37231 1464 42 , , , 37231 1464 43 from from IN 37231 1464 44 the the DT 37231 1464 45 very very JJ 37231 1464 46 nature nature NN 37231 1464 47 of of IN 37231 1464 48 the the DT 37231 1464 49 fact fact NN 37231 1464 50 , , , 37231 1464 51 is be VBZ 37231 1464 52 as as RB 37231 1464 53 entire entire JJ 37231 1464 54 as as IN 37231 1464 55 any any DT 37231 1464 56 argument argument NN 37231 1464 57 from from IN 37231 1464 58 experience experience NN 37231 1464 59 can can MD 37231 1464 60 possibly possibly RB 37231 1464 61 be be VB 37231 1464 62 imagined imagine VBN 37231 1464 63 . . . 37231 1465 1 Why why WRB 37231 1465 2 is be VBZ 37231 1465 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1465 4 more more JJR 37231 1465 5 than than IN 37231 1465 6 probable probable JJ 37231 1465 7 that that IN 37231 1465 8 all all DT 37231 1465 9 men man NNS 37231 1465 10 must must MD 37231 1465 11 die die VB 37231 1465 12 ; ; : 37231 1465 13 that that DT 37231 1465 14 lead lead VBP 37231 1465 15 { { -LRB- 37231 1465 16 85 85 CD 37231 1465 17 } } -RRB- 37231 1465 18 can can MD 37231 1465 19 not not RB 37231 1465 20 , , , 37231 1465 21 of of IN 37231 1465 22 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1465 23 , , , 37231 1465 24 remain remain VBP 37231 1465 25 suspended suspend VBN 37231 1465 26 in in IN 37231 1465 27 the the DT 37231 1465 28 air air NN 37231 1465 29 ; ; : 37231 1465 30 that that DT 37231 1465 31 fire fire NN 37231 1465 32 consumes consume VBZ 37231 1465 33 wood wood NN 37231 1465 34 , , , 37231 1465 35 and and CC 37231 1465 36 is be VBZ 37231 1465 37 extinguished extinguish VBN 37231 1465 38 by by IN 37231 1465 39 water water NN 37231 1465 40 ; ; : 37231 1465 41 unless unless IN 37231 1465 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1465 43 be be VBP 37231 1465 44 that that IN 37231 1465 45 these these DT 37231 1465 46 events event NNS 37231 1465 47 are be VBP 37231 1465 48 found find VBN 37231 1465 49 agreeable agreeable JJ 37231 1465 50 to to IN 37231 1465 51 the the DT 37231 1465 52 laws law NNS 37231 1465 53 of of IN 37231 1465 54 nature nature NN 37231 1465 55 , , , 37231 1465 56 and and CC 37231 1465 57 there there EX 37231 1465 58 is be VBZ 37231 1465 59 required require VBN 37231 1465 60 a a DT 37231 1465 61 violation violation NN 37231 1465 62 of of IN 37231 1465 63 these these DT 37231 1465 64 laws law NNS 37231 1465 65 , , , 37231 1465 66 or or CC 37231 1465 67 , , , 37231 1465 68 in in IN 37231 1465 69 other other JJ 37231 1465 70 words word NNS 37231 1465 71 , , , 37231 1465 72 a a DT 37231 1465 73 miracle miracle NN 37231 1465 74 , , , 37231 1465 75 to to TO 37231 1465 76 prevent prevent VB 37231 1465 77 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1465 78 ? ? . 37231 1466 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 1466 2 is be VBZ 37231 1466 3 esteemed esteem VBN 37231 1466 4 a a DT 37231 1466 5 miracle miracle NN 37231 1466 6 if if IN 37231 1466 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1466 8 ever ever RB 37231 1466 9 happen happen VBP 37231 1466 10 in in IN 37231 1466 11 the the DT 37231 1466 12 common common JJ 37231 1466 13 course course NN 37231 1466 14 of of IN 37231 1466 15 nature nature NN 37231 1466 16 . . . 37231 1467 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1467 2 is be VBZ 37231 1467 3 no no DT 37231 1467 4 miracle miracle NN 37231 1467 5 that that IN 37231 1467 6 a a DT 37231 1467 7 man man NN 37231 1467 8 seemingly seemingly RB 37231 1467 9 in in IN 37231 1467 10 good good JJ 37231 1467 11 health health NN 37231 1467 12 should should MD 37231 1467 13 die die VB 37231 1467 14 on on IN 37231 1467 15 a a DT 37231 1467 16 sudden sudden JJ 37231 1467 17 ; ; : 37231 1467 18 because because IN 37231 1467 19 such such PDT 37231 1467 20 a a DT 37231 1467 21 kind kind NN 37231 1467 22 of of IN 37231 1467 23 death death NN 37231 1467 24 , , , 37231 1467 25 though though IN 37231 1467 26 more more RBR 37231 1467 27 unusual unusual JJ 37231 1467 28 than than IN 37231 1467 29 any any DT 37231 1467 30 other other JJ 37231 1467 31 , , , 37231 1467 32 has have VBZ 37231 1467 33 yet yet RB 37231 1467 34 been be VBN 37231 1467 35 frequently frequently RB 37231 1467 36 observed observe VBN 37231 1467 37 to to TO 37231 1467 38 happen happen VB 37231 1467 39 . . . 37231 1468 1 But but CC 37231 1468 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1468 3 is be VBZ 37231 1468 4 a a DT 37231 1468 5 miracle miracle NN 37231 1468 6 that that IN 37231 1468 7 a a DT 37231 1468 8 dead dead JJ 37231 1468 9 man man NN 37231 1468 10 should should MD 37231 1468 11 come come VB 37231 1468 12 to to IN 37231 1468 13 life life NN 37231 1468 14 ; ; : 37231 1468 15 because because IN 37231 1468 16 that that DT 37231 1468 17 has have VBZ 37231 1468 18 never never RB 37231 1468 19 been be VBN 37231 1468 20 observed observe VBN 37231 1468 21 in in IN 37231 1468 22 any any DT 37231 1468 23 age age NN 37231 1468 24 or or CC 37231 1468 25 country country NN 37231 1468 26 . . . 37231 1469 1 There there EX 37231 1469 2 must must MD 37231 1469 3 , , , 37231 1469 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 1469 5 , , , 37231 1469 6 be be VB 37231 1469 7 an an DT 37231 1469 8 uniform uniform JJ 37231 1469 9 experience experience NN 37231 1469 10 against against IN 37231 1469 11 every every DT 37231 1469 12 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1469 13 event event NN 37231 1469 14 , , , 37231 1469 15 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 1469 16 the the DT 37231 1469 17 event event NN 37231 1469 18 would would MD 37231 1469 19 not not RB 37231 1469 20 merit merit VB 37231 1469 21 that that DT 37231 1469 22 appellation appellation NN 37231 1469 23 . . . 37231 1470 1 And and CC 37231 1470 2 as as IN 37231 1470 3 an an DT 37231 1470 4 uniform uniform JJ 37231 1470 5 experience experience NN 37231 1470 6 amounts amount VBZ 37231 1470 7 to to IN 37231 1470 8 a a DT 37231 1470 9 proof proof NN 37231 1470 10 , , , 37231 1470 11 there there EX 37231 1470 12 is be VBZ 37231 1470 13 here here RB 37231 1470 14 a a DT 37231 1470 15 direct direct JJ 37231 1470 16 and and CC 37231 1470 17 full full JJ 37231 1470 18 _ _ NNP 37231 1470 19 proof proof NN 37231 1470 20 _ _ NNP 37231 1470 21 , , , 37231 1470 22 from from IN 37231 1470 23 the the DT 37231 1470 24 nature nature NN 37231 1470 25 of of IN 37231 1470 26 the the DT 37231 1470 27 fact fact NN 37231 1470 28 , , , 37231 1470 29 against against IN 37231 1470 30 the the DT 37231 1470 31 existence existence NN 37231 1470 32 of of IN 37231 1470 33 any any DT 37231 1470 34 miracle miracle NN 37231 1470 35 ; ; : 37231 1470 36 nor nor CC 37231 1470 37 can can MD 37231 1470 38 such such PDT 37231 1470 39 a a DT 37231 1470 40 proof proof NN 37231 1470 41 be be VB 37231 1470 42 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 1470 43 , , , 37231 1470 44 or or CC 37231 1470 45 the the DT 37231 1470 46 miracle miracle NN 37231 1470 47 rendered render VBN 37231 1470 48 credible credible JJ 37231 1470 49 , , , 37231 1470 50 but but CC 37231 1470 51 by by IN 37231 1470 52 an an DT 37231 1470 53 opposite opposite JJ 37231 1470 54 proof proof NN 37231 1470 55 which which WDT 37231 1470 56 is be VBZ 37231 1470 57 superior superior JJ 37231 1470 58 . . . 37231 1471 1 The the DT 37231 1471 2 plain plain JJ 37231 1471 3 consequence consequence NN 37231 1471 4 is be VBZ 37231 1471 5 , , , 37231 1471 6 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1471 7 and and CC 37231 1471 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1471 9 is be VBZ 37231 1471 10 a a DT 37231 1471 11 general general JJ 37231 1471 12 maxim maxim NN 37231 1471 13 worthy worthy JJ 37231 1471 14 of of IN 37231 1471 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1471 16 attention attention NN 37231 1471 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1471 18 , , , 37231 1471 19 ' ' '' 37231 1471 20 That that IN 37231 1471 21 no no DT 37231 1471 22 testimony testimony NN 37231 1471 23 is be VBZ 37231 1471 24 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1471 25 to to TO 37231 1471 26 establish establish VB 37231 1471 27 a a DT 37231 1471 28 miracle miracle NN 37231 1471 29 , , , 37231 1471 30 unless unless IN 37231 1471 31 the the DT 37231 1471 32 testimony testimony NN 37231 1471 33 be be VB 37231 1471 34 of of IN 37231 1471 35 such such PDT 37231 1471 36 a a DT 37231 1471 37 kind kind NN 37231 1471 38 , , , 37231 1471 39 that that IN 37231 1471 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1471 41 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1471 42 would would MD 37231 1471 43 be be VB 37231 1471 44 more more RBR 37231 1471 45 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1471 46 than than IN 37231 1471 47 the the DT 37231 1471 48 fact fact NN 37231 1471 49 which which WDT 37231 1471 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1471 51 endeavours endeavour VBZ 37231 1471 52 to to TO 37231 1471 53 establish establish VB 37231 1471 54 : : : 37231 1471 55 and and CC 37231 1471 56 even even RB 37231 1471 57 in in IN 37231 1471 58 that that DT 37231 1471 59 case case NN 37231 1471 60 there there EX 37231 1471 61 is be VBZ 37231 1471 62 a a DT 37231 1471 63 mutual mutual JJ 37231 1471 64 destruction destruction NN 37231 1471 65 of of IN 37231 1471 66 arguments argument NNS 37231 1471 67 , , , 37231 1471 68 and and CC 37231 1471 69 the the DT 37231 1471 70 superior superior JJ 37231 1471 71 only only RB 37231 1471 72 gives give VBZ 37231 1471 73 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1471 74 an an DT 37231 1471 75 assurance assurance NN 37231 1471 76 suitable suitable JJ 37231 1471 77 to to IN 37231 1471 78 that that DT 37231 1471 79 degree degree NN 37231 1471 80 of of IN 37231 1471 81 force force NN 37231 1471 82 which which WDT 37231 1471 83 remains remain VBZ 37231 1471 84 after after IN 37231 1471 85 deducting deduct VBG 37231 1471 86 the the DT 37231 1471 87 inferior inferior JJ 37231 1471 88 . . . 37231 1471 89 ' ' '' 37231 1472 1 When when WRB 37231 1472 2 any any DT 37231 1472 3 one one NN 37231 1472 4 tells tell VBZ 37231 1472 5 me -PRON- PRP 37231 1472 6 that that IN 37231 1472 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1472 8 saw see VBD 37231 1472 9 a a DT 37231 1472 10 dead dead JJ 37231 1472 11 man man NN 37231 1472 12 restored restore VBN 37231 1472 13 to to IN 37231 1472 14 life life NN 37231 1472 15 , , , 37231 1472 16 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1472 17 immediately immediately RB 37231 1472 18 consider consider VBP 37231 1472 19 with with IN 37231 1472 20 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 1472 21 whether whether IN 37231 1472 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1472 23 be be VBP 37231 1472 24 more more RBR 37231 1472 25 probable probable JJ 37231 1472 26 that that IN 37231 1472 27 this this DT 37231 1472 28 person person NN 37231 1472 29 should should MD 37231 1472 30 either either CC 37231 1472 31 deceive deceive VB 37231 1472 32 or or CC 37231 1472 33 be be VB 37231 1472 34 deceived deceive VBN 37231 1472 35 , , , 37231 1472 36 or or CC 37231 1472 37 that that IN 37231 1472 38 the the DT 37231 1472 39 fact fact NN 37231 1472 40 which which WDT 37231 1472 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1472 42 relates relate VBZ 37231 1472 43 should should MD 37231 1472 44 really really RB 37231 1472 45 have have VB 37231 1472 46 happened happen VBN 37231 1472 47 . . . 37231 1473 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1473 2 weigh weigh VBP 37231 1473 3 the the DT 37231 1473 4 one one CD 37231 1473 5 miracle miracle NN 37231 1473 6 against against IN 37231 1473 7 the the DT 37231 1473 8 { { -LRB- 37231 1473 9 86 86 CD 37231 1473 10 } } -RRB- 37231 1473 11 other other JJ 37231 1473 12 ; ; : 37231 1473 13 and and CC 37231 1473 14 according accord VBG 37231 1473 15 to to IN 37231 1473 16 the the DT 37231 1473 17 superiority superiority NN 37231 1473 18 which which WDT 37231 1473 19 1 1 CD 37231 1473 20 discover discover VBP 37231 1473 21 , , , 37231 1473 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1473 23 pronounce pronounce VBP 37231 1473 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1473 25 decision decision NN 37231 1473 26 , , , 37231 1473 27 and and CC 37231 1473 28 always always RB 37231 1473 29 reject reject VB 37231 1473 30 the the DT 37231 1473 31 greater great JJR 37231 1473 32 miracle miracle NN 37231 1473 33 . . . 37231 1474 1 If if IN 37231 1474 2 the the DT 37231 1474 3 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1474 4 of of IN 37231 1474 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1474 6 testimony testimony NN 37231 1474 7 would would MD 37231 1474 8 be be VB 37231 1474 9 more more RBR 37231 1474 10 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1474 11 than than IN 37231 1474 12 the the DT 37231 1474 13 event event NN 37231 1474 14 which which WDT 37231 1474 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1474 16 relates relate VBZ 37231 1474 17 , , , 37231 1474 18 then then RB 37231 1474 19 , , , 37231 1474 20 and and CC 37231 1474 21 not not RB 37231 1474 22 till till IN 37231 1474 23 then then RB 37231 1474 24 , , , 37231 1474 25 can can MD 37231 1474 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1474 27 pretend pretend VB 37231 1474 28 to to TO 37231 1474 29 command command VB 37231 1474 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1474 31 belief belief NN 37231 1474 32 or or CC 37231 1474 33 opinion opinion NN 37231 1474 34 . . . 37231 1475 1 " " `` 37231 1475 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1475 3 1 1 LS 37231 1475 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1475 5 The the DT 37231 1475 6 ground ground NN 37231 1475 7 upon upon IN 37231 1475 8 which which WDT 37231 1475 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1475 10 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1475 11 admits admit VBZ 37231 1475 12 that that IN 37231 1475 13 a a DT 37231 1475 14 miracle miracle NN 37231 1475 15 may may MD 37231 1475 16 not not RB 37231 1475 17 be be VB 37231 1475 18 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1475 19 to to TO 37231 1475 20 complete complete VB 37231 1475 21 induction induction NN 37231 1475 22 is be VBZ 37231 1475 23 that that IN 37231 1475 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1475 25 is be VBZ 37231 1475 26 not not RB 37231 1475 27 an an DT 37231 1475 28 assertion assertion NN 37231 1475 29 that that IN 37231 1475 30 a a DT 37231 1475 31 certain certain JJ 37231 1475 32 cause cause NN 37231 1475 33 was be VBD 37231 1475 34 not not RB 37231 1475 35 followed follow VBN 37231 1475 36 by by IN 37231 1475 37 a a DT 37231 1475 38 certain certain JJ 37231 1475 39 effect effect NN 37231 1475 40 , , , 37231 1475 41 but but CC 37231 1475 42 an an DT 37231 1475 43 allegation allegation NN 37231 1475 44 of of IN 37231 1475 45 the the DT 37231 1475 46 interference interference NN 37231 1475 47 of of IN 37231 1475 48 an an DT 37231 1475 49 adequate adequate JJ 37231 1475 50 counteracting counteracting NN 37231 1475 51 cause cause NN 37231 1475 52 . . . 37231 1476 1 This this DT 37231 1476 2 does do VBZ 37231 1476 3 not not RB 37231 1476 4 , , , 37231 1476 5 however however RB 37231 1476 6 , , , 37231 1476 7 by by IN 37231 1476 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1476 9 own own JJ 37231 1476 10 showing showing NN 37231 1476 11 , , , 37231 1476 12 remove remove VB 37231 1476 13 a a DT 37231 1476 14 miracle miracle NN 37231 1476 15 from from IN 37231 1476 16 the the DT 37231 1476 17 action action NN 37231 1476 18 of of IN 37231 1476 19 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1476 20 's 's POS 37231 1476 21 principle principle NN 37231 1476 22 , , , 37231 1476 23 but but CC 37231 1476 24 simply simply RB 37231 1476 25 modifies modify VBZ 37231 1476 26 the the DT 37231 1476 27 nature nature NN 37231 1476 28 of of IN 37231 1476 29 the the DT 37231 1476 30 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1476 31 improbability improbability NN 37231 1476 32 . . . 37231 1477 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1477 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1477 3 qualifies qualify VBZ 37231 1477 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1477 5 admission admission NN 37231 1477 6 regarding regard VBG 37231 1477 7 the the DT 37231 1477 8 effect effect NN 37231 1477 9 of of IN 37231 1477 10 the the DT 37231 1477 11 alleged allege VBN 37231 1477 12 counteracting counteracting NN 37231 1477 13 cause cause NN 37231 1477 14 , , , 37231 1477 15 by by IN 37231 1477 16 the the DT 37231 1477 17 all all RB 37231 1477 18 - - HYPH 37231 1477 19 important important JJ 37231 1477 20 words word NNS 37231 1477 21 " " '' 37231 1477 22 if if IN 37231 1477 23 present present NN 37231 1477 24 ; ; : 37231 1477 25 " " '' 37231 1477 26 for for IN 37231 1477 27 , , , 37231 1477 28 in in IN 37231 1477 29 order order NN 37231 1477 30 to to TO 37231 1477 31 be be VB 37231 1477 32 valid valid JJ 37231 1477 33 , , , 37231 1477 34 the the DT 37231 1477 35 reality reality NN 37231 1477 36 of of IN 37231 1477 37 the the DT 37231 1477 38 alleged allege VBN 37231 1477 39 counteracting counteract VBG 37231 1477 40 cause cause NN 37231 1477 41 must must MD 37231 1477 42 be be VB 37231 1477 43 established establish VBN 37231 1477 44 , , , 37231 1477 45 which which WDT 37231 1477 46 is be VBZ 37231 1477 47 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1477 48 , , , 37231 1477 49 therefore therefore RB 37231 1477 50 the the DT 37231 1477 51 allegations allegation NNS 37231 1477 52 fall fall VBP 37231 1477 53 to to IN 37231 1477 54 the the DT 37231 1477 55 ground ground NN 37231 1477 56 . . . 37231 1478 1 No no DT 37231 1478 2 one one NN 37231 1478 3 knows know VBZ 37231 1478 4 better well RBR 37231 1478 5 than than IN 37231 1478 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1478 7 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1478 8 that that IN 37231 1478 9 the the DT 37231 1478 10 assertion assertion NN 37231 1478 11 of of IN 37231 1478 12 a a DT 37231 1478 13 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1478 14 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1478 15 working work VBG 37231 1478 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1478 17 , , , 37231 1478 18 upon upon IN 37231 1478 19 which which WDT 37231 1478 20 a a DT 37231 1478 21 miracle miracle NN 37231 1478 22 is be VBZ 37231 1478 23 allowed allow VBN 37231 1478 24 for for IN 37231 1478 25 a a DT 37231 1478 26 moment moment NN 37231 1478 27 to to TO 37231 1478 28 come come VB 37231 1478 29 into into IN 37231 1478 30 court court NN 37231 1478 31 , , , 37231 1478 32 can can MD 37231 1478 33 not not RB 37231 1478 34 be be VB 37231 1478 35 proved prove VBN 37231 1478 36 , , , 37231 1478 37 and and CC 37231 1478 38 , , , 37231 1478 39 therefore therefore RB 37231 1478 40 , , , 37231 1478 41 that that IN 37231 1478 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1478 43 can can MD 37231 1478 44 not not RB 37231 1478 45 stand stand VB 37231 1478 46 in in IN 37231 1478 47 opposition opposition NN 37231 1478 48 to to TO 37231 1478 49 complete complete VB 37231 1478 50 induction induction NN 37231 1478 51 which which WDT 37231 1478 52 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1478 53 takes take VBZ 37231 1478 54 as as IN 37231 1478 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1478 56 standard standard NN 37231 1478 57 . . . 37231 1479 1 In in IN 37231 1479 2 admitting admit VBG 37231 1479 3 that that IN 37231 1479 4 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1479 5 has have VBZ 37231 1479 6 made make VBN 37231 1479 7 out out RP 37231 1479 8 , , , 37231 1479 9 that that IN 37231 1479 10 no no DT 37231 1479 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 1479 12 can can MD 37231 1479 13 prove prove VB 37231 1479 14 a a DT 37231 1479 15 miracle miracle NN 37231 1479 16 to to IN 37231 1479 17 any any DT 37231 1479 18 one one NN 37231 1479 19 who who WP 37231 1479 20 does do VBZ 37231 1479 21 not not RB 37231 1479 22 previously previously RB 37231 1479 23 believe believe VB 37231 1479 24 in in IN 37231 1479 25 a a DT 37231 1479 26 being being NN 37231 1479 27 of of IN 37231 1479 28 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1479 29 power power NN 37231 1479 30 willing willing JJ 37231 1479 31 to to TO 37231 1479 32 work work VB 37231 1479 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1479 34 , , , 37231 1479 35 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1479 36 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1479 37 concedes concede VBZ 37231 1479 38 everything everything NN 37231 1479 39 to to IN 37231 1479 40 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1479 41 , , , 37231 1479 42 for for IN 37231 1479 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1479 44 only only JJ 37231 1479 45 limitation limitation NN 37231 1479 46 is be VBZ 37231 1479 47 based base VBN 37231 1479 48 upon upon IN 37231 1479 49 a a DT 37231 1479 50 supposition supposition NN 37231 1479 51 of of IN 37231 1479 52 mere mere JJ 37231 1479 53 personal personal JJ 37231 1479 54 belief belief NN 37231 1479 55 in in IN 37231 1479 56 something something NN 37231 1479 57 which which WDT 37231 1479 58 is be VBZ 37231 1479 59 not not RB 37231 1479 60 capable capable JJ 37231 1479 61 of of IN 37231 1479 62 proof proof NN 37231 1479 63 , , , 37231 1479 64 and and CC 37231 1479 65 which which WDT 37231 1479 66 belief belief NN 37231 1479 67 , , , 37231 1479 68 therefore therefore RB 37231 1479 69 , , , 37231 1479 70 is be VBZ 37231 1479 71 not not RB 37231 1479 72 { { -LRB- 37231 1479 73 87 87 CD 37231 1479 74 } } -RRB- 37231 1479 75 more more RBR 37231 1479 76 valid valid JJ 37231 1479 77 than than IN 37231 1479 78 any any DT 37231 1479 79 other other JJ 37231 1479 80 purely purely RB 37231 1479 81 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 1479 82 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1479 83 . . . 37231 1480 1 The the DT 37231 1480 2 belief belief NN 37231 1480 3 may may MD 37231 1480 4 seem seem VB 37231 1480 5 substantial substantial JJ 37231 1480 6 to to IN 37231 1480 7 the the DT 37231 1480 8 individual individual JJ 37231 1480 9 entertaining entertain VBG 37231 1480 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1480 11 , , , 37231 1480 12 but but CC 37231 1480 13 , , , 37231 1480 14 not not RB 37231 1480 15 being be VBG 37231 1480 16 capable capable JJ 37231 1480 17 of of IN 37231 1480 18 proof proof NN 37231 1480 19 , , , 37231 1480 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1480 21 can can MD 37231 1480 22 not not RB 37231 1480 23 have have VB 37231 1480 24 weight weight NN 37231 1480 25 with with IN 37231 1480 26 others other NNS 37231 1480 27 , , , 37231 1480 28 or or CC 37231 1480 29 in in IN 37231 1480 30 any any DT 37231 1480 31 way way NN 37231 1480 32 affect affect VB 37231 1480 33 the the DT 37231 1480 34 Value Value NNP 37231 1480 35 of of IN 37231 1480 36 evidence evidence NN 37231 1480 37 in in IN 37231 1480 38 the the DT 37231 1480 39 abstract abstract NN 37231 1480 40 . . . 37231 1481 1 That that DT 37231 1481 2 mere mere JJ 37231 1481 3 individual individual JJ 37231 1481 4 belief belief NN 37231 1481 5 , , , 37231 1481 6 apart apart RB 37231 1481 7 from from IN 37231 1481 8 proof proof NN 37231 1481 9 , , , 37231 1481 10 should should MD 37231 1481 11 thus thus RB 37231 1481 12 be be VB 37231 1481 13 advanced advance VBN 37231 1481 14 in in IN 37231 1481 15 limitation limitation NN 37231 1481 16 of of IN 37231 1481 17 a a DT 37231 1481 18 logical logical JJ 37231 1481 19 principle principle NN 37231 1481 20 , , , 37231 1481 21 seems seem VBZ 37231 1481 22 to to IN 37231 1481 23 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1481 24 most most RBS 37231 1481 25 unwarranted unwarranted JJ 37231 1481 26 , , , 37231 1481 27 and and CC 37231 1481 28 at at IN 37231 1481 29 the the DT 37231 1481 30 most most JJS 37231 1481 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1481 32 can can MD 37231 1481 33 only only RB 37231 1481 34 be be VB 37231 1481 35 received receive VBN 37231 1481 36 as as IN 37231 1481 37 a a DT 37231 1481 38 statement statement NN 37231 1481 39 of of IN 37231 1481 40 what what WP 37231 1481 41 practically practically RB 37231 1481 42 takes take VBZ 37231 1481 43 place place NN 37231 1481 44 amongst amongst IN 37231 1481 45 illogical illogical JJ 37231 1481 46 reason reason NN 37231 1481 47 ers er NNS 37231 1481 48 . . . 37231 1482 1 The the DT 37231 1482 2 assumption assumption NN 37231 1482 3 of of IN 37231 1482 4 a a DT 37231 1482 5 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1482 6 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1482 7 working work VBG 37231 1482 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1482 9 is be VBZ 37231 1482 10 , , , 37231 1482 11 in in IN 37231 1482 12 fact fact NN 37231 1482 13 , , , 37231 1482 14 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1482 15 by by IN 37231 1482 16 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1482 17 's 's POS 37231 1482 18 argument argument NN 37231 1482 19 , , , 37231 1482 20 and and CC 37231 1482 21 , , , 37231 1482 22 although although IN 37231 1482 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1482 24 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1482 25 apparently apparently RB 37231 1482 26 overlooks overlook VBZ 37231 1482 27 the the DT 37231 1482 28 fact fact NN 37231 1482 29 , , , 37231 1482 30 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1482 31 has have VBZ 37231 1482 32 not not RB 37231 1482 33 only only RB 37231 1482 34 anticipated anticipate VBN 37231 1482 35 but but CC 37231 1482 36 refuted refute VBN 37231 1482 37 the the DT 37231 1482 38 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1482 39 which which WDT 37231 1482 40 is be VBZ 37231 1482 41 based base VBN 37231 1482 42 upon upon IN 37231 1482 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1482 44 . . . 37231 1483 1 In in IN 37231 1483 2 the the DT 37231 1483 3 succeeding succeed VBG 37231 1483 4 chapter chapter NN 37231 1483 5 on on IN 37231 1483 6 a a DT 37231 1483 7 Particular Particular NNP 37231 1483 8 Providence Providence NNP 37231 1483 9 and and CC 37231 1483 10 a a DT 37231 1483 11 Future Future NNP 37231 1483 12 State State NNP 37231 1483 13 , , , 37231 1483 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1483 15 directly directly RB 37231 1483 16 disposes dispose VBZ 37231 1483 17 of of IN 37231 1483 18 such such PDT 37231 1483 19 an an DT 37231 1483 20 assumption assumption NN 37231 1483 21 , , , 37231 1483 22 but but CC 37231 1483 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1483 24 does do VBZ 37231 1483 25 so so RB 37231 1483 26 with with IN 37231 1483 27 equal equal JJ 37231 1483 28 effect effect NN 37231 1483 29 also also RB 37231 1483 30 in in IN 37231 1483 31 the the DT 37231 1483 32 Essay Essay NNP 37231 1483 33 which which WDT 37231 1483 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1483 35 are be VBP 37231 1483 36 discussing discuss VBG 37231 1483 37 . . . 37231 1484 1 Taking take VBG 37231 1484 2 an an DT 37231 1484 3 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 1484 4 miracle miracle NN 37231 1484 5 as as IN 37231 1484 6 an an DT 37231 1484 7 illustration illustration NN 37231 1484 8 , , , 37231 1484 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1484 10 argues argue VBZ 37231 1484 11 : : : 37231 1484 12 " " `` 37231 1484 13 Though though IN 37231 1484 14 the the DT 37231 1484 15 being being NN 37231 1484 16 to to TO 37231 1484 17 whom whom WP 37231 1484 18 the the DT 37231 1484 19 miracle miracle NN 37231 1484 20 is be VBZ 37231 1484 21 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1484 22 be be VBP 37231 1484 23 in in IN 37231 1484 24 this this DT 37231 1484 25 case case NN 37231 1484 26 Almighty Almighty NNP 37231 1484 27 , , , 37231 1484 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1484 29 does do VBZ 37231 1484 30 not not RB 37231 1484 31 , , , 37231 1484 32 upon upon IN 37231 1484 33 that that DT 37231 1484 34 account account NN 37231 1484 35 , , , 37231 1484 36 become become VB 37231 1484 37 a a DT 37231 1484 38 whit whit NN 37231 1484 39 more more RBR 37231 1484 40 probable probable JJ 37231 1484 41 ; ; : 37231 1484 42 since since IN 37231 1484 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1484 44 is be VBZ 37231 1484 45 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1484 46 for for IN 37231 1484 47 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1484 48 to to TO 37231 1484 49 know know VB 37231 1484 50 the the DT 37231 1484 51 attributes attribute NNS 37231 1484 52 or or CC 37231 1484 53 actions action NNS 37231 1484 54 of of IN 37231 1484 55 such such PDT 37231 1484 56 a a DT 37231 1484 57 Being Being NNP 37231 1484 58 , , , 37231 1484 59 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 1484 60 than than IN 37231 1484 61 from from IN 37231 1484 62 the the DT 37231 1484 63 experience experience NN 37231 1484 64 which which WDT 37231 1484 65 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1484 66 have have VBP 37231 1484 67 of of IN 37231 1484 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1484 69 productions production NNS 37231 1484 70 in in IN 37231 1484 71 the the DT 37231 1484 72 usual usual JJ 37231 1484 73 course course NN 37231 1484 74 of of IN 37231 1484 75 nature nature NN 37231 1484 76 . . . 37231 1485 1 This this DT 37231 1485 2 still still RB 37231 1485 3 reduces reduce VBZ 37231 1485 4 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1485 5 to to IN 37231 1485 6 past past JJ 37231 1485 7 observation observation NN 37231 1485 8 , , , 37231 1485 9 and and CC 37231 1485 10 obliges oblige VBZ 37231 1485 11 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1485 12 to to TO 37231 1485 13 compare compare VB 37231 1485 14 the the DT 37231 1485 15 instances instance NNS 37231 1485 16 of of IN 37231 1485 17 the the DT 37231 1485 18 violation violation NN 37231 1485 19 of of IN 37231 1485 20 truth truth NN 37231 1485 21 in in IN 37231 1485 22 the the DT 37231 1485 23 testimony testimony NN 37231 1485 24 of of IN 37231 1485 25 men man NNS 37231 1485 26 , , , 37231 1485 27 with with IN 37231 1485 28 those those DT 37231 1485 29 of of IN 37231 1485 30 the the DT 37231 1485 31 violation violation NN 37231 1485 32 of of IN 37231 1485 33 the the DT 37231 1485 34 laws law NNS 37231 1485 35 of of IN 37231 1485 36 nature nature NN 37231 1485 37 by by IN 37231 1485 38 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1485 39 , , , 37231 1485 40 in in IN 37231 1485 41 order order NN 37231 1485 42 to to TO 37231 1485 43 judge judge VB 37231 1485 44 which which WDT 37231 1485 45 of of IN 37231 1485 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1485 47 is be VBZ 37231 1485 48 most most RBS 37231 1485 49 likely likely JJ 37231 1485 50 and and CC 37231 1485 51 probable probable JJ 37231 1485 52 . . . 37231 1486 1 As as IN 37231 1486 2 the the DT 37231 1486 3 violations violation NNS 37231 1486 4 of of IN 37231 1486 5 truth truth NN 37231 1486 6 are be VBP 37231 1486 7 more more RBR 37231 1486 8 common common JJ 37231 1486 9 in in IN 37231 1486 10 the the DT 37231 1486 11 testimony testimony NN 37231 1486 12 concerning concern VBG 37231 1486 13 religious religious JJ 37231 1486 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1486 15 than than IN 37231 1486 16 in in IN 37231 1486 17 that that DT 37231 1486 18 concerning concern VBG 37231 1486 19 any any DT 37231 1486 20 other other JJ 37231 1486 21 matter matter NN 37231 1486 22 of of IN 37231 1486 23 fact fact NN 37231 1486 24 , , , 37231 1486 25 this this DT 37231 1486 26 must must MD 37231 1486 27 diminish diminish VB 37231 1486 28 very very RB 37231 1486 29 much much RB 37231 1486 30 the the DT 37231 1486 31 authority authority NN 37231 1486 32 of of IN 37231 1486 33 the the DT 37231 1486 34 former former JJ 37231 1486 35 testimony testimony NN 37231 1486 36 , , , 37231 1486 37 and and CC 37231 1486 38 { { -LRB- 37231 1486 39 88 88 CD 37231 1486 40 } } -RRB- 37231 1486 41 make make VB 37231 1486 42 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1486 43 form form VB 37231 1486 44 a a DT 37231 1486 45 general general JJ 37231 1486 46 resolution resolution NN 37231 1486 47 never never RB 37231 1486 48 to to TO 37231 1486 49 lend lend VB 37231 1486 50 any any DT 37231 1486 51 attention attention NN 37231 1486 52 to to IN 37231 1486 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1486 54 , , , 37231 1486 55 with with IN 37231 1486 56 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1486 57 specious specious JJ 37231 1486 58 pretence pretence NN 37231 1486 59 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1486 60 may may MD 37231 1486 61 be be VB 37231 1486 62 covered cover VBN 37231 1486 63 . . . 37231 1487 1 " " `` 37231 1487 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1487 3 1 1 LS 37231 1487 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1487 5 A a DT 37231 1487 6 person person NN 37231 1487 7 who who WP 37231 1487 8 believes believe VBZ 37231 1487 9 anything anything NN 37231 1487 10 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1487 11 to to IN 37231 1487 12 a a DT 37231 1487 13 complete complete JJ 37231 1487 14 induction induction NN 37231 1487 15 merely merely RB 37231 1487 16 on on IN 37231 1487 17 the the DT 37231 1487 18 strength strength NN 37231 1487 19 of of IN 37231 1487 20 an an DT 37231 1487 21 assumption assumption NN 37231 1487 22 which which WDT 37231 1487 23 is be VBZ 37231 1487 24 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1487 25 of of IN 37231 1487 26 proof proof NN 37231 1487 27 is be VBZ 37231 1487 28 simply simply RB 37231 1487 29 credulous credulous JJ 37231 1487 30 , , , 37231 1487 31 but but CC 37231 1487 32 such such PDT 37231 1487 33 an an DT 37231 1487 34 assumption assumption NN 37231 1487 35 can can MD 37231 1487 36 not not RB 37231 1487 37 affect affect VB 37231 1487 38 the the DT 37231 1487 39 real real JJ 37231 1487 40 evidence evidence NN 37231 1487 41 for for IN 37231 1487 42 that that DT 37231 1487 43 thing thing NN 37231 1487 44 . . . 37231 1488 1 The the DT 37231 1488 2 argument argument NN 37231 1488 3 of of IN 37231 1488 4 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1488 5 against against IN 37231 1488 6 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1488 7 is be VBZ 37231 1488 8 an an DT 37231 1488 9 illustration illustration NN 37231 1488 10 of of IN 37231 1488 11 the the DT 37231 1488 12 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1488 13 suggested suggest VBN 37231 1488 14 by by IN 37231 1488 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1488 16 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1488 17 . . . 37231 1489 1 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1489 2 alleges allege VBZ 37231 1489 3 the the DT 37231 1489 4 interposition interposition NN 37231 1489 5 of of IN 37231 1489 6 a a DT 37231 1489 7 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1489 8 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1489 9 in in IN 37231 1489 10 explanation explanation NN 37231 1489 11 of of IN 37231 1489 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1489 13 , , , 37231 1489 14 but but CC 37231 1489 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1489 16 protests protest VBZ 37231 1489 17 that that IN 37231 1489 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1489 19 does do VBZ 37231 1489 20 not not RB 37231 1489 21 assume assume VB 37231 1489 22 the the DT 37231 1489 23 attributes attribute NNS 37231 1489 24 of of IN 37231 1489 25 the the DT 37231 1489 26 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1489 27 or or CC 37231 1489 28 the the DT 37231 1489 29 existence existence NN 37231 1489 30 of of IN 37231 1489 31 a a DT 37231 1489 32 future future JJ 37231 1489 33 state state NN 37231 1489 34 in in IN 37231 1489 35 order order NN 37231 1489 36 to to IN 37231 1489 37 _ _ NNP 37231 1489 38 prove prove VB 37231 1489 39 _ _ IN 37231 1489 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1489 41 reality reality NN 37231 1489 42 . . . 37231 1490 1 " " `` 37231 1490 2 That that DT 37231 1490 3 reality reality NN 37231 1490 4 , , , 37231 1490 5 " " '' 37231 1490 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1490 7 admits admit VBZ 37231 1490 8 , , , 37231 1490 9 " " `` 37231 1490 10 always always RB 37231 1490 11 must must MD 37231 1490 12 be be VB 37231 1490 13 proved prove VBN 37231 1490 14 by by IN 37231 1490 15 evidence evidence NN 37231 1490 16 . . . 37231 1491 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1491 2 assert assert VBP 37231 1491 3 only only RB 37231 1491 4 that that IN 37231 1491 5 in in IN 37231 1491 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1491 7 adduced adduce VBN 37231 1491 8 in in IN 37231 1491 9 support support NN 37231 1491 10 of of IN 37231 1491 11 revelation revelation NN 37231 1491 12 there there EX 37231 1491 13 is be VBZ 37231 1491 14 not not RB 37231 1491 15 such such JJ 37231 1491 16 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1491 17 improbability improbability NN 37231 1491 18 as as IN 37231 1491 19 no no DT 37231 1491 20 testimony testimony NN 37231 1491 21 can can MD 37231 1491 22 surmount surmount VB 37231 1491 23 . . . 37231 1491 24 " " '' 37231 1492 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1492 2 argument argument NN 37231 1492 3 culminates culminate VBZ 37231 1492 4 in in IN 37231 1492 5 the the DT 37231 1492 6 short short JJ 37231 1492 7 statement statement NN 37231 1492 8 : : : 37231 1492 9 " " `` 37231 1492 10 In in IN 37231 1492 11 a a DT 37231 1492 12 word word NN 37231 1492 13 , , , 37231 1492 14 once once RB 37231 1492 15 believe believe VBP 37231 1492 16 that that IN 37231 1492 17 there there EX 37231 1492 18 is be VBZ 37231 1492 19 a a DT 37231 1492 20 God God NNP 37231 1492 21 " " '' 37231 1492 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1492 23 i.e. i.e. FW 37231 1492 24 , , , 37231 1492 25 a a DT 37231 1492 26 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1492 27 God God NNP 37231 1492 28 working work VBG 37231 1492 29 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1492 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1492 31 , , , 37231 1492 32 " " '' 37231 1492 33 and and CC 37231 1492 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1492 35 are be VBP 37231 1492 36 not not RB 37231 1492 37 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1492 38 . . . 37231 1493 1 " " `` 37231 1493 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1493 3 2 2 LS 37231 1493 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1493 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1493 6 have have VBP 37231 1493 7 already already RB 37231 1493 8 quoted quote VBN 37231 1493 9 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1493 10 's 's POS 37231 1493 11 refutation refutation NN 37231 1493 12 of of IN 37231 1493 13 this this DT 37231 1493 14 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1493 15 , , , 37231 1493 16 and and CC 37231 1493 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1493 18 may may MD 37231 1493 19 at at IN 37231 1493 20 once once RB 37231 1493 21 proceed proceed VB 37231 1493 22 to to IN 37231 1493 23 the the DT 37231 1493 24 final final JJ 37231 1493 25 argument argument NN 37231 1493 26 by by IN 37231 1493 27 which which WDT 37231 1493 28 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1493 29 endeavours endeavour VBZ 37231 1493 30 to to TO 37231 1493 31 overthrow overthrow VB 37231 1493 32 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1493 33 's 's POS 37231 1493 34 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1493 35 , , , 37231 1493 36 and and CC 37231 1493 37 upon upon IN 37231 1493 38 which which WDT 37231 1493 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1493 40 mainly mainly RB 37231 1493 41 rests rest VBZ 37231 1493 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1493 43 case case NN 37231 1493 44 . . . 37231 1494 1 " " `` 37231 1494 2 But but CC 37231 1494 3 the the DT 37231 1494 4 short short JJ 37231 1494 5 consideration consideration NN 37231 1494 6 , , , 37231 1494 7 " " '' 37231 1494 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1494 9 says say VBZ 37231 1494 10 , , , 37231 1494 11 " " `` 37231 1494 12 which which WDT 37231 1494 13 , , , 37231 1494 14 independently independently RB 37231 1494 15 of of IN 37231 1494 16 every every DT 37231 1494 17 other other JJ 37231 1494 18 , , , 37231 1494 19 convinces convince VBZ 37231 1494 20 me -PRON- PRP 37231 1494 21 that that IN 37231 1494 22 there there EX 37231 1494 23 is be VBZ 37231 1494 24 no no DT 37231 1494 25 solid solid JJ 37231 1494 26 foundation foundation NN 37231 1494 27 in in IN 37231 1494 28 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1494 29 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1494 30 's 's POS 37231 1494 31 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1494 32 , , , 37231 1494 33 is be VBZ 37231 1494 34 the the DT 37231 1494 35 following follow VBG 37231 1494 36 : : : 37231 1494 37 When when WRB 37231 1494 38 a a DT 37231 1494 39 theorem theorem NN 37231 1494 40 is be VBZ 37231 1494 41 proposed propose VBN 37231 1494 42 to to IN 37231 1494 43 a a DT 37231 1494 44 mathematician mathematician NN 37231 1494 45 , , , 37231 1494 46 the the DT 37231 1494 47 first first JJ 37231 1494 48 thing thing NN 37231 1494 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1494 50 does do VBZ 37231 1494 51 with with IN 37231 1494 52 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1494 53 is be VBZ 37231 1494 54 to to TO 37231 1494 55 try try VB 37231 1494 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1494 57 upon upon IN 37231 1494 58 a a DT 37231 1494 59 simple simple JJ 37231 1494 60 case case NN 37231 1494 61 , , , 37231 1494 62 and and CC 37231 1494 63 if if IN 37231 1494 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1494 65 produces produce VBZ 37231 1494 66 a a DT 37231 1494 67 false false JJ 37231 1494 68 result result NN 37231 1494 69 , , , 37231 1494 70 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1494 71 is be VBZ 37231 1494 72 sure sure JJ 37231 1494 73 that that IN 37231 1494 74 there there RB 37231 1494 75 { { -LRB- 37231 1494 76 89 89 CD 37231 1494 77 } } -RRB- 37231 1494 78 must must MD 37231 1494 79 be be VB 37231 1494 80 some some DT 37231 1494 81 mistake mistake NN 37231 1494 82 in in IN 37231 1494 83 the the DT 37231 1494 84 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 1494 85 . . . 37231 1495 1 Now now RB 37231 1495 2 , , , 37231 1495 3 to to TO 37231 1495 4 proceed proceed VB 37231 1495 5 in in IN 37231 1495 6 this this DT 37231 1495 7 way way NN 37231 1495 8 with with IN 37231 1495 9 what what WP 37231 1495 10 may may MD 37231 1495 11 be be VB 37231 1495 12 called call VBN 37231 1495 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1495 14 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1495 15 's 's POS 37231 1495 16 theorem theorem NN 37231 1495 17 . . . 37231 1496 1 If if IN 37231 1496 2 twelve twelve CD 37231 1496 3 men man NNS 37231 1496 4 , , , 37231 1496 5 whose whose WP$ 37231 1496 6 probity probity NN 37231 1496 7 and and CC 37231 1496 8 good good JJ 37231 1496 9 sense sense NN 37231 1496 10 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 11 had have VBD 37231 1496 12 long long RB 37231 1496 13 known know VBN 37231 1496 14 , , , 37231 1496 15 should should MD 37231 1496 16 seriously seriously RB 37231 1496 17 and and CC 37231 1496 18 circumstantially circumstantially RB 37231 1496 19 relate relate VB 37231 1496 20 to to IN 37231 1496 21 me -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 22 an an DT 37231 1496 23 account account NN 37231 1496 24 of of IN 37231 1496 25 a a DT 37231 1496 26 miracle miracle NN 37231 1496 27 wrought work VBN 37231 1496 28 before before IN 37231 1496 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1496 30 eyes eye NNS 37231 1496 31 , , , 37231 1496 32 and and CC 37231 1496 33 in in IN 37231 1496 34 which which WDT 37231 1496 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 36 was be VBD 37231 1496 37 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1496 38 that that IN 37231 1496 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 40 should should MD 37231 1496 41 be be VB 37231 1496 42 deceived deceive VBN 37231 1496 43 ; ; : 37231 1496 44 if if IN 37231 1496 45 the the DT 37231 1496 46 governor governor NN 37231 1496 47 of of IN 37231 1496 48 the the DT 37231 1496 49 country country NN 37231 1496 50 , , , 37231 1496 51 hearing hear VBG 37231 1496 52 a a DT 37231 1496 53 rumour rumour NN 37231 1496 54 of of IN 37231 1496 55 this this DT 37231 1496 56 account account NN 37231 1496 57 , , , 37231 1496 58 should should MD 37231 1496 59 call call VB 37231 1496 60 these these DT 37231 1496 61 men man NNS 37231 1496 62 into into IN 37231 1496 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1496 64 presence presence NN 37231 1496 65 , , , 37231 1496 66 and and CC 37231 1496 67 offer offer VB 37231 1496 68 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 69 a a DT 37231 1496 70 short short JJ 37231 1496 71 proposal proposal NN 37231 1496 72 , , , 37231 1496 73 either either CC 37231 1496 74 to to TO 37231 1496 75 confess confess VB 37231 1496 76 the the DT 37231 1496 77 imposture imposture NN 37231 1496 78 or or CC 37231 1496 79 submit submit VB 37231 1496 80 to to TO 37231 1496 81 be be VB 37231 1496 82 tied tie VBN 37231 1496 83 up up RP 37231 1496 84 to to IN 37231 1496 85 a a DT 37231 1496 86 gibbet gibbet NN 37231 1496 87 ; ; : 37231 1496 88 if if IN 37231 1496 89 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 90 should should MD 37231 1496 91 refuse refuse VB 37231 1496 92 with with IN 37231 1496 93 one one CD 37231 1496 94 voice voice NN 37231 1496 95 to to TO 37231 1496 96 acknowledge acknowledge VB 37231 1496 97 that that IN 37231 1496 98 there there EX 37231 1496 99 existed exist VBD 37231 1496 100 any any DT 37231 1496 101 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1496 102 or or CC 37231 1496 103 imposture imposture NN 37231 1496 104 in in IN 37231 1496 105 the the DT 37231 1496 106 case case NN 37231 1496 107 ; ; : 37231 1496 108 if if IN 37231 1496 109 this this DT 37231 1496 110 threat threat NN 37231 1496 111 was be VBD 37231 1496 112 communicated communicate VBN 37231 1496 113 to to IN 37231 1496 114 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 115 separately separately RB 37231 1496 116 , , , 37231 1496 117 yet yet CC 37231 1496 118 with with IN 37231 1496 119 no no DT 37231 1496 120 different different JJ 37231 1496 121 effect effect NN 37231 1496 122 ; ; : 37231 1496 123 if if IN 37231 1496 124 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 125 was be VBD 37231 1496 126 at at IN 37231 1496 127 last last JJ 37231 1496 128 executed execute VBN 37231 1496 129 ; ; : 37231 1496 130 if if IN 37231 1496 131 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 132 myself -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 133 saw see VBD 37231 1496 134 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 135 , , , 37231 1496 136 one one CD 37231 1496 137 after after IN 37231 1496 138 another another DT 37231 1496 139 , , , 37231 1496 140 consenting consent VBG 37231 1496 141 to to TO 37231 1496 142 be be VB 37231 1496 143 racked rack VBN 37231 1496 144 , , , 37231 1496 145 burned burn VBN 37231 1496 146 , , , 37231 1496 147 or or CC 37231 1496 148 strangled strangle VBD 37231 1496 149 , , , 37231 1496 150 rather rather RB 37231 1496 151 than than IN 37231 1496 152 give give VB 37231 1496 153 up up RP 37231 1496 154 the the DT 37231 1496 155 truth truth NN 37231 1496 156 of of IN 37231 1496 157 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1496 158 account,--still account,--still NN 37231 1496 159 , , , 37231 1496 160 if if IN 37231 1496 161 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1496 162 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1496 163 's 's POS 37231 1496 164 rule rule NN 37231 1496 165 be be VB 37231 1496 166 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1496 167 guide guide NN 37231 1496 168 , , , 37231 1496 169 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 170 am be VBP 37231 1496 171 not not RB 37231 1496 172 to to TO 37231 1496 173 believe believe VB 37231 1496 174 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1496 175 . . . 37231 1497 1 Now now RB 37231 1497 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1497 3 undertake undertake VBP 37231 1497 4 to to TO 37231 1497 5 say say VB 37231 1497 6 that that IN 37231 1497 7 there there EX 37231 1497 8 exists exist VBZ 37231 1497 9 not not RB 37231 1497 10 a a DT 37231 1497 11 sceptic sceptic NN 37231 1497 12 in in IN 37231 1497 13 the the DT 37231 1497 14 world world NN 37231 1497 15 who who WP 37231 1497 16 would would MD 37231 1497 17 not not RB 37231 1497 18 believe believe VB 37231 1497 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1497 20 , , , 37231 1497 21 or or CC 37231 1497 22 who who WP 37231 1497 23 would would MD 37231 1497 24 defend defend VB 37231 1497 25 such such JJ 37231 1497 26 incredulity incredulity NN 37231 1497 27 . . . 37231 1498 1 " " `` 37231 1498 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1498 3 1 1 LS 37231 1498 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1498 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1498 6 is be VBZ 37231 1498 7 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1498 8 that that IN 37231 1498 9 this this DT 37231 1498 10 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1498 11 , , , 37231 1498 12 besides besides IN 37231 1498 13 being be VBG 37231 1498 14 purely purely RB 37231 1498 15 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 37231 1498 16 , , , 37231 1498 17 is be VBZ 37231 1498 18 utterly utterly RB 37231 1498 19 without without IN 37231 1498 20 cogency cogency NN 37231 1498 21 against against IN 37231 1498 22 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1498 23 's 's POS 37231 1498 24 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 1498 25 . . . 37231 1499 1 In in IN 37231 1499 2 the the DT 37231 1499 3 first first JJ 37231 1499 4 place place NN 37231 1499 5 , , , 37231 1499 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1499 7 is be VBZ 37231 1499 8 clear clear JJ 37231 1499 9 that that IN 37231 1499 10 no no DT 37231 1499 11 assertion assertion NN 37231 1499 12 of of IN 37231 1499 13 any any DT 37231 1499 14 twelve twelve CD 37231 1499 15 men man NNS 37231 1499 16 would would MD 37231 1499 17 be be VB 37231 1499 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1499 19 to to TO 37231 1499 20 overthrow overthrow VB 37231 1499 21 a a DT 37231 1499 22 law law NN 37231 1499 23 of of IN 37231 1499 24 nature nature NN 37231 1499 25 , , , 37231 1499 26 which which WDT 37231 1499 27 is be VBZ 37231 1499 28 the the DT 37231 1499 29 result result NN 37231 1499 30 of of IN 37231 1499 31 a a DT 37231 1499 32 complete complete JJ 37231 1499 33 induction induction NN 37231 1499 34 , , , 37231 1499 35 and and CC 37231 1499 36 in in IN 37231 1499 37 order order NN 37231 1499 38 to to TO 37231 1499 39 establish establish VB 37231 1499 40 the the DT 37231 1499 41 reality reality NN 37231 1499 42 of of IN 37231 1499 43 a a DT 37231 1499 44 miracle miracle NN 37231 1499 45 or or CC 37231 1499 46 the the DT 37231 1499 47 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1499 48 on on IN 37231 1499 49 one one CD 37231 1499 50 occasion occasion NN 37231 1499 51 of of IN 37231 1499 52 an an DT 37231 1499 53 unprecedented unprecedented JJ 37231 1499 54 effect effect NN 37231 1499 55 , , , 37231 1499 56 from from IN 37231 1499 57 any any DT 37231 1499 58 cause cause NN 37231 1499 59 , , , 37231 1499 60 not not RB 37231 1499 61 in in IN 37231 1499 62 accordance accordance NN 37231 1499 63 with with IN 37231 1499 64 natural natural JJ 37231 1499 65 law law NN 37231 1499 66 , , , 37231 1499 67 no no DT 37231 1499 68 smaller small JJR 37231 1499 69 amount amount NN 37231 1499 70 of of IN 37231 1499 71 evidence evidence NN 37231 1499 72 would would MD 37231 1499 73 suffice suffice VB 37231 1499 74 than than IN 37231 1499 75 would would MD 37231 1499 76 serve serve VB 37231 1499 77 to to TO 37231 1499 78 refute refute VB 37231 1499 79 the the DT 37231 1499 80 complete complete JJ 37231 1499 81 induction induction NN 37231 1499 82 . . . 37231 1500 1 The the DT 37231 1500 2 allegation allegation NN 37231 1500 3 of of IN 37231 1500 4 such such PDT 37231 1500 5 an an DT 37231 1500 6 intervening intervening NN 37231 1500 7 cause cause NN 37231 1500 8 as as IN 37231 1500 9 a a DT 37231 1500 10 Personal Personal NNP 37231 1500 11 { { -LRB- 37231 1500 12 90 90 CD 37231 1500 13 } } -RRB- 37231 1500 14 Deity deity NN 37231 1500 15 working working NN 37231 1500 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1500 17 is be VBZ 37231 1500 18 excluded exclude VBN 37231 1500 19 as as IN 37231 1500 20 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1500 21 to to IN 37231 1500 22 a a DT 37231 1500 23 complete complete JJ 37231 1500 24 induction induction NN 37231 1500 25 . . . 37231 1501 1 So so RB 37231 1501 2 long long RB 37231 1501 3 as as IN 37231 1501 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1501 5 maintain maintain VBP 37231 1501 6 the the DT 37231 1501 7 law law NN 37231 1501 8 , , , 37231 1501 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1501 10 are be VBP 37231 1501 11 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 1501 12 compelled compel VBN 37231 1501 13 to to TO 37231 1501 14 reject reject VB 37231 1501 15 any any DT 37231 1501 16 evidence evidence NN 37231 1501 17 which which WDT 37231 1501 18 contradicts contradict VBZ 37231 1501 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1501 20 . . . 37231 1502 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1502 2 can can MD 37231 1502 3 not not RB 37231 1502 4 at at IN 37231 1502 5 the the DT 37231 1502 6 same same JJ 37231 1502 7 time time NN 37231 1502 8 believe believe VBP 37231 1502 9 the the DT 37231 1502 10 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1502 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 1502 12 , , , 37231 1502 13 and and CC 37231 1502 14 yet yet RB 37231 1502 15 assert assert VB 37231 1502 16 the the DT 37231 1502 17 truth truth NN 37231 1502 18 of of IN 37231 1502 19 the the DT 37231 1502 20 law law NN 37231 1502 21 . . . 37231 1503 1 The the DT 37231 1503 2 specific specific JJ 37231 1503 3 allegation allegation NN 37231 1503 4 , , , 37231 1503 5 moreover moreover RB 37231 1503 6 , , , 37231 1503 7 is be VBZ 37231 1503 8 completely completely RB 37231 1503 9 prohibited prohibit VBN 37231 1503 10 by by IN 37231 1503 11 the the DT 37231 1503 12 Scriptural Scriptural NNP 37231 1503 13 admission admission NN 37231 1503 14 that that IN 37231 1503 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1503 16 are be VBP 37231 1503 17 also also RB 37231 1503 18 performed perform VBN 37231 1503 19 by by IN 37231 1503 20 other other JJ 37231 1503 21 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1503 22 beings being NNS 37231 1503 23 in in IN 37231 1503 24 opposition opposition NN 37231 1503 25 to to IN 37231 1503 26 the the DT 37231 1503 27 Deity Deity NNP 37231 1503 28 . . . 37231 1504 1 The the DT 37231 1504 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 1504 3 of of IN 37231 1504 4 the the DT 37231 1504 5 twelve twelve CD 37231 1504 6 men man NNS 37231 1504 7 , , , 37231 1504 8 however however RB 37231 1504 9 , , , 37231 1504 10 simply simply RB 37231 1504 11 amounts amount VBZ 37231 1504 12 to to IN 37231 1504 13 a a DT 37231 1504 14 statement statement NN 37231 1504 15 that that WDT 37231 1504 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1504 17 saw see VBD 37231 1504 18 , , , 37231 1504 19 or or CC 37231 1504 20 fancied fancy VBD 37231 1504 21 that that IN 37231 1504 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1504 23 saw see VBD 37231 1504 24 , , , 37231 1504 25 a a DT 37231 1504 26 certain certain JJ 37231 1504 27 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1504 28 in in IN 37231 1504 29 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 1504 30 to to IN 37231 1504 31 the the DT 37231 1504 32 law law NN 37231 1504 33 , , , 37231 1504 34 but but CC 37231 1504 35 that that IN 37231 1504 36 which which WDT 37231 1504 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1504 38 actually actually RB 37231 1504 39 saw see VBD 37231 1504 40 was be VBD 37231 1504 41 only only RB 37231 1504 42 an an DT 37231 1504 43 external external JJ 37231 1504 44 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 1504 45 , , , 37231 1504 46 the the DT 37231 1504 47 real real JJ 37231 1504 48 nature nature NN 37231 1504 49 of of IN 37231 1504 50 which which WDT 37231 1504 51 is be VBZ 37231 1504 52 a a DT 37231 1504 53 mere mere JJ 37231 1504 54 inference inference NN 37231 1504 55 , , , 37231 1504 56 and and CC 37231 1504 57 an an DT 37231 1504 58 inference inference NN 37231 1504 59 which which WDT 37231 1504 60 , , , 37231 1504 61 from from IN 37231 1504 62 the the DT 37231 1504 63 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 1504 64 isolated isolate VBN 37231 1504 65 position position NN 37231 1504 66 of of IN 37231 1504 67 the the DT 37231 1504 68 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1504 69 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 1504 70 , , , 37231 1504 71 is be VBZ 37231 1504 72 neither neither DT 37231 1504 73 supported support VBN 37231 1504 74 by by IN 37231 1504 75 other other JJ 37231 1504 76 instances instance NNS 37231 1504 77 capable capable JJ 37231 1504 78 of of IN 37231 1504 79 forming form VBG 37231 1504 80 a a DT 37231 1504 81 complete complete JJ 37231 1504 82 counter counter NN 37231 1504 83 induction induction NN 37231 1504 84 , , , 37231 1504 85 nor nor CC 37231 1504 86 by by IN 37231 1504 87 analogies analogy NNS 37231 1504 88 within within IN 37231 1504 89 the the DT 37231 1504 90 order order NN 37231 1504 91 of of IN 37231 1504 92 nature.1 nature.1 NN 37231 1504 93 The the DT 37231 1504 94 bare bare JJ 37231 1504 95 inference inference NN 37231 1504 96 from from IN 37231 1504 97 an an DT 37231 1504 98 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1504 99 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1504 100 to to TO 37231 1504 101 have have VB 37231 1504 102 been be VBN 37231 1504 103 witnessed witness VBN 37231 1504 104 by by IN 37231 1504 105 twelve twelve CD 37231 1504 106 men man NNS 37231 1504 107 is be VBZ 37231 1504 108 all all DT 37231 1504 109 that that WDT 37231 1504 110 is be VBZ 37231 1504 111 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1504 112 to to IN 37231 1504 113 the the DT 37231 1504 114 law law NN 37231 1504 115 of of IN 37231 1504 116 nature nature NN 37231 1504 117 , , , 37231 1504 118 which which WDT 37231 1504 119 is be VBZ 37231 1504 120 based base VBN 37231 1504 121 upon upon IN 37231 1504 122 a a DT 37231 1504 123 complete complete JJ 37231 1504 124 induction induction NN 37231 1504 125 , , , 37231 1504 126 and and CC 37231 1504 127 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1504 128 is be VBZ 37231 1504 129 , , , 37231 1504 130 therefore therefore RB 37231 1504 131 , , , 37231 1504 132 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1504 133 . . . 37231 1505 1 If if IN 37231 1505 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1505 3 proceed proceed VBP 37231 1505 4 to to TO 37231 1505 5 examine examine VB 37231 1505 6 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1505 7 's 's POS 37231 1505 8 " " `` 37231 1505 9 simple simple JJ 37231 1505 10 case case NN 37231 1505 11 " " '' 37231 1505 12 a a DT 37231 1505 13 little little RB 37231 1505 14 more more RBR 37231 1505 15 closely closely RB 37231 1505 16 , , , 37231 1505 17 however however RB 37231 1505 18 , , , 37231 1505 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1505 20 find find VBP 37231 1505 21 that that IN 37231 1505 22 not not RB 37231 1505 23 only only RB 37231 1505 24 is be VBZ 37231 1505 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1505 26 utterly utterly RB 37231 1505 27 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 37231 1505 28 as as IN 37231 1505 29 a a DT 37231 1505 30 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1505 31 , , , 37231 1505 32 but but CC 37231 1505 33 that that IN 37231 1505 34 as as IN 37231 1505 35 an an DT 37231 1505 36 illustration illustration NN 37231 1505 37 of of IN 37231 1505 38 the the DT 37231 1505 39 case case NN 37231 1505 40 of of IN 37231 1505 41 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1505 42 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1505 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1505 44 is be VBZ 37231 1505 45 completely completely RB 37231 1505 46 devoid devoid JJ 37231 1505 47 of of IN 37231 1505 48 relevancy relevancy NN 37231 1505 49 and and CC 37231 1505 50 argumentative argumentative JJ 37231 1505 51 force force NN 37231 1505 52 . . . 37231 1506 1 The the DT 37231 1506 2 only only JJ 37231 1506 3 point point NN 37231 1506 4 which which WDT 37231 1506 5 gives give VBZ 37231 1506 6 a a DT 37231 1506 7 momentary momentary JJ 37231 1506 8 value value NN 37231 1506 9 to to IN 37231 1506 10 the the DT 37231 1506 11 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1506 12 instance instance NN 37231 1506 13 is be VBZ 37231 1506 14 the the DT 37231 1506 15 condition condition NN 37231 1506 16 attached attach VBN 37231 1506 17 to to IN 37231 1506 18 the the DT 37231 1506 19 account account NN 37231 1506 20 of of IN 37231 1506 21 the the DT 37231 1506 22 miracle miracle NN 37231 1506 23 related relate VBN 37231 1506 24 by by IN 37231 1506 25 the the DT 37231 1506 26 twelve twelve CD 37231 1506 27 men man NNS 37231 1506 28 , , , 37231 1506 29 that that IN 37231 1506 30 not not RB 37231 1506 31 only only RB 37231 1506 32 was be VBD 37231 1506 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1506 34 wrought work VBN 37231 1506 35 before before IN 37231 1506 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1506 37 eyes eye NNS 37231 1506 38 , , , 37231 1506 39 but but CC 37231 1506 40 that that IN 37231 1506 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1506 42 was be VBD 37231 1506 43 one one CD 37231 1506 44 " " '' 37231 1506 45 in in IN 37231 1506 46 which which WDT 37231 1506 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1506 48 was be VBD 37231 1506 49 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1506 50 that that IN 37231 1506 51 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1506 52 should should MD 37231 1506 53 be be VB 37231 1506 54 deceived deceive VBN 37231 1506 55 . . . 37231 1506 56 " " '' 37231 1507 1 Now now RB 37231 1507 2 { { -LRB- 37231 1507 3 91 91 CD 37231 1507 4 } } -RRB- 37231 1507 5 this this DT 37231 1507 6 qualification qualification NN 37231 1507 7 of of IN 37231 1507 8 infallibility infallibility NN 37231 1507 9 on on IN 37231 1507 10 the the DT 37231 1507 11 part part NN 37231 1507 12 of of IN 37231 1507 13 the the DT 37231 1507 14 twelve twelve CD 37231 1507 15 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1507 16 is be VBZ 37231 1507 17 as as RB 37231 1507 18 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1507 19 as as IN 37231 1507 20 the the DT 37231 1507 21 miracle miracle NN 37231 1507 22 which which WDT 37231 1507 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1507 24 are be VBP 37231 1507 25 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1507 26 to to TO 37231 1507 27 attest attest VB 37231 1507 28 . . . 37231 1508 1 The the DT 37231 1508 2 existence existence NN 37231 1508 3 of of IN 37231 1508 4 twelve twelve CD 37231 1508 5 men man NNS 37231 1508 6 incapable incapable JJ 37231 1508 7 of of IN 37231 1508 8 error error NN 37231 1508 9 or or CC 37231 1508 10 mistake mistake NN 37231 1508 11 is be VBZ 37231 1508 12 as as RB 37231 1508 13 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1508 14 to to TO 37231 1508 15 experience experience VB 37231 1508 16 as as IN 37231 1508 17 the the DT 37231 1508 18 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 1508 19 of of IN 37231 1508 20 a a DT 37231 1508 21 miracle miracle NN 37231 1508 22 in in IN 37231 1508 23 which which WDT 37231 1508 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1508 25 is be VBZ 37231 1508 26 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1508 27 for for IN 37231 1508 28 the the DT 37231 1508 29 twelve twelve CD 37231 1508 30 men man NNS 37231 1508 31 to to TO 37231 1508 32 be be VB 37231 1508 33 deceived deceive VBN 37231 1508 34 is be VBZ 37231 1508 35 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1508 36 to to IN 37231 1508 37 reason reason NN 37231 1508 38 . . . 37231 1509 1 The the DT 37231 1509 2 exclusion exclusion NN 37231 1509 3 of of IN 37231 1509 4 all all DT 37231 1509 5 error error NN 37231 1509 6 in in IN 37231 1509 7 the the DT 37231 1509 8 observation observation NN 37231 1509 9 of of IN 37231 1509 10 the the DT 37231 1509 11 actual actual JJ 37231 1509 12 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1509 13 and and CC 37231 1509 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1509 15 antecedents antecedent NNS 37231 1509 16 and and CC 37231 1509 17 consequences consequence NNS 37231 1509 18 , , , 37231 1509 19 whose whose WP$ 37231 1509 20 united united NNP 37231 1509 21 sum sum NNP 37231 1509 22 constitutes constitute VBZ 37231 1509 23 the the DT 37231 1509 24 miracle miracle NN 37231 1509 25 , , , 37231 1509 26 is be VBZ 37231 1509 27 an an DT 37231 1509 28 assumption assumption NN 37231 1509 29 which which WDT 37231 1509 30 deprives deprive VBZ 37231 1509 31 the the DT 37231 1509 32 argument argument NN 37231 1509 33 of of IN 37231 1509 34 all all DT 37231 1509 35 potency potency NN 37231 1509 36 . . . 37231 1510 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1510 2 can can MD 37231 1510 3 not not RB 37231 1510 4 be be VB 37231 1510 5 entertained entertain VBN 37231 1510 6 . . . 37231 1511 1 On on IN 37231 1511 2 the the DT 37231 1511 3 other other JJ 37231 1511 4 hand hand NN 37231 1511 5 , , , 37231 1511 6 the the DT 37231 1511 7 moment moment NN 37231 1511 8 the the DT 37231 1511 9 possibility possibility NN 37231 1511 10 of of IN 37231 1511 11 error error NN 37231 1511 12 is be VBZ 37231 1511 13 admitted admit VBN 37231 1511 14 , , , 37231 1511 15 the the DT 37231 1511 16 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 1511 17 breaks break VBZ 37231 1511 18 down down RP 37231 1511 19 , , , 37231 1511 20 for for IN 37231 1511 21 the the DT 37231 1511 22 probability probability NN 37231 1511 23 of of IN 37231 1511 24 error error NN 37231 1511 25 on on IN 37231 1511 26 the the DT 37231 1511 27 part part NN 37231 1511 28 of of IN 37231 1511 29 the the DT 37231 1511 30 observers observer NNS 37231 1511 31 , , , 37231 1511 32 either either CC 37231 1511 33 as as IN 37231 1511 34 regards regard VBZ 37231 1511 35 the the DT 37231 1511 36 external external JJ 37231 1511 37 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1511 38 , , , 37231 1511 39 or or CC 37231 1511 40 the the DT 37231 1511 41 inferences inference NNS 37231 1511 42 drawn draw VBN 37231 1511 43 from from IN 37231 1511 44 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1511 45 , , , 37231 1511 46 being be VBG 37231 1511 47 so so RB 37231 1511 48 infinitely infinitely RB 37231 1511 49 greater great JJR 37231 1511 50 than than IN 37231 1511 51 the the DT 37231 1511 52 probability probability NN 37231 1511 53 of of IN 37231 1511 54 mistake mistake NN 37231 1511 55 in in IN 37231 1511 56 the the DT 37231 1511 57 complete complete JJ 37231 1511 58 induction induction NN 37231 1511 59 , , , 37231 1511 60 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1511 61 must must MD 37231 1511 62 unquestionably unquestionably RB 37231 1511 63 hold hold VB 37231 1511 64 by by IN 37231 1511 65 the the DT 37231 1511 66 law law NN 37231 1511 67 and and CC 37231 1511 68 reject reject VB 37231 1511 69 the the DT 37231 1511 70 testimony testimony NN 37231 1511 71 of of IN 37231 1511 72 the the DT 37231 1511 73 twelve twelve CD 37231 1511 74 men man NNS 37231 1511 75 . . . 37231 1512 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1512 2 need nee MD 37231 1512 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1512 4 be be VB 37231 1512 5 said say VBN 37231 1512 6 that that IN 37231 1512 7 the the DT 37231 1512 8 assertion assertion NN 37231 1512 9 of of IN 37231 1512 10 liability liability NN 37231 1512 11 to to TO 37231 1512 12 error error VB 37231 1512 13 on on IN 37231 1512 14 the the DT 37231 1512 15 part part NN 37231 1512 16 of of IN 37231 1512 17 the the DT 37231 1512 18 observers observer NNS 37231 1512 19 by by IN 37231 1512 20 no no DT 37231 1512 21 means means NN 37231 1512 22 involves involve VBZ 37231 1512 23 any any DT 37231 1512 24 insinuation insinuation NN 37231 1512 25 of of IN 37231 1512 26 wilful wilful JJ 37231 1512 27 " " '' 37231 1512 28 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1512 29 or or CC 37231 1512 30 imposture imposture NN 37231 1512 31 in in IN 37231 1512 32 the the DT 37231 1512 33 case case NN 37231 1512 34 . . . 37231 1512 35 " " '' 37231 1513 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1513 2 is be VBZ 37231 1513 3 quite quite RB 37231 1513 4 intelligible intelligible JJ 37231 1513 5 that that IN 37231 1513 6 twelve twelve CD 37231 1513 7 men man NNS 37231 1513 8 might may MD 37231 1513 9 witness witness VB 37231 1513 10 an an DT 37231 1513 11 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1513 12 which which WDT 37231 1513 13 might may MD 37231 1513 14 seem seem VB 37231 1513 15 to to IN 37231 1513 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1513 17 and and CC 37231 1513 18 others other NNS 37231 1513 19 miraculous,--but miraculous,--but RB 37231 1513 20 which which WDT 37231 1513 21 was be VBD 37231 1513 22 susceptible susceptible JJ 37231 1513 23 of of IN 37231 1513 24 a a DT 37231 1513 25 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 1513 26 natural natural JJ 37231 1513 27 explanation,--and explanation,--and XX 37231 1513 28 truthfully truthfully RB 37231 1513 29 relate relate VBP 37231 1513 30 what what WP 37231 1513 31 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1513 32 believed believe VBD 37231 1513 33 to to TO 37231 1513 34 have have VB 37231 1513 35 seen see VBN 37231 1513 36 , , , 37231 1513 37 and and CC 37231 1513 38 that that IN 37231 1513 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1513 40 might may MD 37231 1513 41 , , , 37231 1513 42 therefore therefore RB 37231 1513 43 , , , 37231 1513 44 refuse refuse VBP 37231 1513 45 " " `` 37231 1513 46 with with IN 37231 1513 47 one one CD 37231 1513 48 voice voice NN 37231 1513 49 to to TO 37231 1513 50 acknowledge acknowledge VB 37231 1513 51 that that IN 37231 1513 52 there there EX 37231 1513 53 existed exist VBD 37231 1513 54 any any DT 37231 1513 55 falsehood falsehood NN 37231 1513 56 or or CC 37231 1513 57 imposture imposture NN 37231 1513 58 in in IN 37231 1513 59 the the DT 37231 1513 60 case case NN 37231 1513 61 , , , 37231 1513 62 " " `` 37231 1513 63 even even RB 37231 1513 64 although although IN 37231 1513 65 the the DT 37231 1513 66 alternative alternative NN 37231 1513 67 might may MD 37231 1513 68 be be VB 37231 1513 69 death death NN 37231 1513 70 on on IN 37231 1513 71 a a DT 37231 1513 72 gibbet gibbet NN 37231 1513 73 . . . 37231 1514 1 This this DT 37231 1514 2 , , , 37231 1514 3 however however RB 37231 1514 4 , , , 37231 1514 5 would would MD 37231 1514 6 in in IN 37231 1514 7 no no DT 37231 1514 8 way way NN 37231 1514 9 affect affect VB 37231 1514 10 the the DT 37231 1514 11 character character NN 37231 1514 12 of of IN 37231 1514 13 the the DT 37231 1514 14 actual actual JJ 37231 1514 15 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1514 16 . . . 37231 1515 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1515 2 would would MD 37231 1515 3 not not RB 37231 1515 4 convert convert VB 37231 1515 5 a a DT 37231 1515 6 natural natural JJ 37231 1515 7 , , , 37231 1515 8 though though RB 37231 1515 9 by by IN 37231 1515 10 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1515 11 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 37231 1515 12 , , , 37231 1515 13 phenomenon phenomenon VB 37231 1515 14 into into IN 37231 1515 15 a a DT 37231 1515 16 miracle miracle NN 37231 1515 17 . . . 37231 1516 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1516 2 constancy constancy NN 37231 1516 3 in in IN 37231 1516 4 adhering adhere VBG 37231 1516 5 to to IN 37231 1516 6 the the DT 37231 1516 7 account account NN 37231 1516 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1516 9 had have VBD 37231 1516 10 { { -LRB- 37231 1516 11 92 92 CD 37231 1516 12 } } -RRB- 37231 1516 13 given give VBN 37231 1516 14 would would MD 37231 1516 15 merely merely RB 37231 1516 16 bear bear VB 37231 1516 17 upon upon IN 37231 1516 18 the the DT 37231 1516 19 truth truth NN 37231 1516 20 of of IN 37231 1516 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1516 22 own own JJ 37231 1516 23 statements statement NNS 37231 1516 24 , , , 37231 1516 25 and and CC 37231 1516 26 the the DT 37231 1516 27 fact fact NN 37231 1516 28 of of IN 37231 1516 29 seeing see VBG 37231 1516 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1516 31 " " `` 37231 1516 32 one one CD 37231 1516 33 after after IN 37231 1516 34 another another DT 37231 1516 35 consenting consenting NN 37231 1516 36 to to TO 37231 1516 37 be be VB 37231 1516 38 racked rack VBN 37231 1516 39 , , , 37231 1516 40 burned burn VBN 37231 1516 41 , , , 37231 1516 42 or or CC 37231 1516 43 strangled strangle VBD 37231 1516 44 , , , 37231 1516 45 rather rather RB 37231 1516 46 than than IN 37231 1516 47 give give VB 37231 1516 48 up up RP 37231 1516 49 the the DT 37231 1516 50 truth truth NN 37231 1516 51 of of IN 37231 1516 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1516 53 account account NN 37231 1516 54 , , , 37231 1516 55 " " `` 37231 1516 56 would would MD 37231 1516 57 not not RB 37231 1516 58 in in IN 37231 1516 59 the the DT 37231 1516 60 least least JJS 37231 1516 61 justify justify VB 37231 1516 62 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1516 63 believing believe VBG 37231 1516 64 in in IN 37231 1516 65 a a DT 37231 1516 66 miracle miracle NN 37231 1516 67 . . . 37231 1517 1 Even even RB 37231 1517 2 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 1517 3 can can MD 37231 1517 4 not not RB 37231 1517 5 transform transform VB 37231 1517 6 imaginations imagination NNS 37231 1517 7 into into IN 37231 1517 8 facts fact NNS 37231 1517 9 . . . 37231 1518 1 The the DT 37231 1518 2 truth truth NN 37231 1518 3 of of IN 37231 1518 4 a a DT 37231 1518 5 narrative narrative NN 37231 1518 6 is be VBZ 37231 1518 7 no no DT 37231 1518 8 guarantee guarantee NN 37231 1518 9 for for IN 37231 1518 10 the the DT 37231 1518 11 correctness correctness NN 37231 1518 12 of of IN 37231 1518 13 an an DT 37231 1518 14 inference inference NN 37231 1518 15 . . . 37231 1519 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1519 2 seems seem VBZ 37231 1519 3 almost almost RB 37231 1519 4 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1519 5 that that IN 37231 1519 6 arguments argument NNS 37231 1519 7 like like IN 37231 1519 8 these these DT 37231 1519 9 should should MD 37231 1519 10 for for IN 37231 1519 11 so so RB 37231 1519 12 many many JJ 37231 1519 13 years year NNS 37231 1519 14 have have VBP 37231 1519 15 been be VBN 37231 1519 16 tolerated tolerate VBN 37231 1519 17 in in IN 37231 1519 18 the the DT 37231 1519 19 text text NN 37231 1519 20 - - HYPH 37231 1519 21 book book NN 37231 1519 22 of of IN 37231 1519 23 a a DT 37231 1519 24 University University NNP 37231 1519 25 . . . 37231 1520 1 As as IN 37231 1520 2 regards regard VBZ 37231 1520 3 the the DT 37231 1520 4 applicability applicability NN 37231 1520 5 of of IN 37231 1520 6 Paleys Paleys NNP 37231 1520 7 illustration illustration NN 37231 1520 8 to to IN 37231 1520 9 the the DT 37231 1520 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1520 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1520 12 , , , 37231 1520 13 the the DT 37231 1520 14 failure failure NN 37231 1520 15 of of IN 37231 1520 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1520 17 analogy analogy NN 37231 1520 18 is be VBZ 37231 1520 19 complete complete JJ 37231 1520 20 . . . 37231 1521 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1521 2 shall shall MD 37231 1521 3 presently presently RB 37231 1521 4 see see VB 37231 1521 5 the the DT 37231 1521 6 condition condition NN 37231 1521 7 of of IN 37231 1521 8 the the DT 37231 1521 9 people people NNS 37231 1521 10 amongst amongst IN 37231 1521 11 whom whom WP 37231 1521 12 these these DT 37231 1521 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1521 14 are be VBP 37231 1521 15 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1521 16 to to TO 37231 1521 17 have have VB 37231 1521 18 occurred occur VBN 37231 1521 19 , , , 37231 1521 20 and and CC 37231 1521 21 that that IN 37231 1521 22 , , , 37231 1521 23 so so RB 37231 1521 24 far far RB 37231 1521 25 from from IN 37231 1521 26 the the DT 37231 1521 27 nature nature NN 37231 1521 28 of of IN 37231 1521 29 the the DT 37231 1521 30 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1521 31 , , , 37231 1521 32 and and CC 37231 1521 33 the the DT 37231 1521 34 character character NN 37231 1521 35 of of IN 37231 1521 36 the the DT 37231 1521 37 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1521 38 , , , 37231 1521 39 supporting support VBG 37231 1521 40 the the DT 37231 1521 41 inference inference NN 37231 1521 42 that that IN 37231 1521 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1521 44 was be VBD 37231 1521 45 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1521 46 that that IN 37231 1521 47 the the DT 37231 1521 48 observers observer NNS 37231 1521 49 could could MD 37231 1521 50 have have VB 37231 1521 51 been be VBN 37231 1521 52 deceived deceive VBN 37231 1521 53 , , , 37231 1521 54 there there EX 37231 1521 55 is be VBZ 37231 1521 56 every every DT 37231 1521 57 reason reason NN 37231 1521 58 for for IN 37231 1521 59 concluding conclude VBG 37231 1521 60 with with IN 37231 1521 61 certainty certainty NN 37231 1521 62 that that IN 37231 1521 63 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1521 64 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1521 65 of of IN 37231 1521 66 natural natural JJ 37231 1521 67 laws law NNS 37231 1521 68 , , , 37231 1521 69 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1521 70 proneness proneness NN 37231 1521 71 to to IN 37231 1521 72 superstition superstition NN 37231 1521 73 , , , 37231 1521 74 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1521 75 love love NN 37231 1521 76 of of IN 37231 1521 77 the the DT 37231 1521 78 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 1521 79 , , , 37231 1521 80 and and CC 37231 1521 81 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1521 82 extreme extreme JJ 37231 1521 83 religious religious JJ 37231 1521 84 excitement excitement NN 37231 1521 85 , , , 37231 1521 86 rendered render VBD 37231 1521 87 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1521 88 peculiarly peculiarly RB 37231 1521 89 liable liable JJ 37231 1521 90 to to IN 37231 1521 91 incorrectness incorrectness NN 37231 1521 92 in in IN 37231 1521 93 the the DT 37231 1521 94 observation observation NN 37231 1521 95 of of IN 37231 1521 96 the the DT 37231 1521 97 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1521 98 , , , 37231 1521 99 and and CC 37231 1521 100 to to TO 37231 1521 101 error error VB 37231 1521 102 in in IN 37231 1521 103 the the DT 37231 1521 104 inferences inference NNS 37231 1521 105 drawn draw VBN 37231 1521 106 from from IN 37231 1521 107 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1521 108 . . . 37231 1522 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1522 2 shall shall MD 37231 1522 3 likewise likewise RB 37231 1522 4 see see VB 37231 1522 5 that that IN 37231 1522 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1522 7 have have VBP 37231 1522 8 no no DT 37231 1522 9 serious serious JJ 37231 1522 10 and and CC 37231 1522 11 circumstantial circumstantial JJ 37231 1522 12 accounts account NNS 37231 1522 13 of of IN 37231 1522 14 those those DT 37231 1522 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1522 16 from from IN 37231 1522 17 eye eye NN 37231 1522 18 - - HYPH 37231 1522 19 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1522 20 of of IN 37231 1522 21 whose whose WP$ 37231 1522 22 probity probity NN 37231 1522 23 and and CC 37231 1522 24 good good JJ 37231 1522 25 sense sense NN 37231 1522 26 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1522 27 have have VBP 37231 1522 28 any any DT 37231 1522 29 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1522 30 , , , 37231 1522 31 but but CC 37231 1522 32 that that IN 37231 1522 33 , , , 37231 1522 34 on on IN 37231 1522 35 the the DT 37231 1522 36 contrary contrary NN 37231 1522 37 , , , 37231 1522 38 the the DT 37231 1522 39 narratives narrative NNS 37231 1522 40 of of IN 37231 1522 41 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1522 42 which which WDT 37231 1522 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1522 44 possess possess VBP 37231 1522 45 were be VBD 37231 1522 46 composed compose VBN 37231 1522 47 by by IN 37231 1522 48 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1522 49 persons person NNS 37231 1522 50 , , , 37231 1522 51 who who WP 37231 1522 52 were be VBD 37231 1522 53 not not RB 37231 1522 54 eyewitnesses eyewitness NNS 37231 1522 55 at at RB 37231 1522 56 all all RB 37231 1522 57 , , , 37231 1522 58 but but CC 37231 1522 59 wrote write VBD 37231 1522 60 very very RB 37231 1522 61 long long RB 37231 1522 62 after after IN 37231 1522 63 the the DT 37231 1522 64 events event NNS 37231 1522 65 related relate VBD 37231 1522 66 , , , 37231 1522 67 and and CC 37231 1522 68 in in IN 37231 1522 69 that that DT 37231 1522 70 mythic mythic JJ 37231 1522 71 period period NN 37231 1522 72 " " '' 37231 1522 73 in in IN 37231 1522 74 which which WDT 37231 1522 75 reality reality NN 37231 1522 76 melted melt VBN 37231 1522 77 into into IN 37231 1522 78 fable fable JJ 37231 1522 79 , , , 37231 1522 80 and and CC 37231 1522 81 invention invention NN 37231 1522 82 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 1522 83 trespassed trespass VBD 37231 1522 84 on on IN 37231 1522 85 the the DT 37231 1522 86 province province NN 37231 1522 87 of of IN 37231 1522 88 history history NN 37231 1522 89 . . . 37231 1522 90 " " '' 37231 1523 1 The the DT 37231 1523 2 proposition proposition NN 37231 1523 3 : : : 37231 1523 4 " " `` 37231 1523 5 That that IN 37231 1523 6 { { -LRB- 37231 1523 7 93 93 CD 37231 1523 8 } } -RRB- 37231 1523 9 there there EX 37231 1523 10 is be VBZ 37231 1523 11 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 37231 1523 12 evidence evidence NN 37231 1523 13 that that IN 37231 1523 14 many many JJ 37231 1523 15 , , , 37231 1523 16 professing profess VBG 37231 1523 17 to to TO 37231 1523 18 be be VB 37231 1523 19 original original JJ 37231 1523 20 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1523 21 of of IN 37231 1523 22 the the DT 37231 1523 23 Christian christian JJ 37231 1523 24 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1523 25 , , , 37231 1523 26 passed pass VBD 37231 1523 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1523 28 lives life NNS 37231 1523 29 in in IN 37231 1523 30 labours labour NNS 37231 1523 31 , , , 37231 1523 32 dangers danger NNS 37231 1523 33 , , , 37231 1523 34 and and CC 37231 1523 35 sufferings suffering NNS 37231 1523 36 , , , 37231 1523 37 voluntarily voluntarily RB 37231 1523 38 undergone undergone JJ 37231 1523 39 in in IN 37231 1523 40 attestation attestation NN 37231 1523 41 of of IN 37231 1523 42 the the DT 37231 1523 43 accounts account NNS 37231 1523 44 which which WDT 37231 1523 45 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1523 46 delivered deliver VBD 37231 1523 47 , , , 37231 1523 48 and and CC 37231 1523 49 solely solely RB 37231 1523 50 in in IN 37231 1523 51 consequence consequence NN 37231 1523 52 of of IN 37231 1523 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1523 54 belief belief NN 37231 1523 55 of of IN 37231 1523 56 these these DT 37231 1523 57 accounts account NNS 37231 1523 58 ; ; : 37231 1523 59 and and CC 37231 1523 60 that that IN 37231 1523 61 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1523 62 also also RB 37231 1523 63 submitted submit VBD 37231 1523 64 , , , 37231 1523 65 from from IN 37231 1523 66 the the DT 37231 1523 67 same same JJ 37231 1523 68 motives motive NNS 37231 1523 69 , , , 37231 1523 70 to to IN 37231 1523 71 new new JJ 37231 1523 72 rules rule NNS 37231 1523 73 of of IN 37231 1523 74 conduct conduct NN 37231 1523 75 , , , 37231 1523 76 " " '' 37231 1523 77 is be VBZ 37231 1523 78 made make VBN 37231 1523 79 by by IN 37231 1523 80 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1523 81 the the DT 37231 1523 82 argument argument NN 37231 1523 83 of of IN 37231 1523 84 the the DT 37231 1523 85 first first JJ 37231 1523 86 nine nine CD 37231 1523 87 chapters chapter NNS 37231 1523 88 of of IN 37231 1523 89 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1523 90 work work NN 37231 1523 91 , , , 37231 1523 92 as as IN 37231 1523 93 the the DT 37231 1523 94 converse converse NN 37231 1523 95 of of IN 37231 1523 96 the the DT 37231 1523 97 proposition proposition NN 37231 1523 98 , , , 37231 1523 99 that that IN 37231 1523 100 similar similar JJ 37231 1523 101 attestation attestation NN 37231 1523 102 of of IN 37231 1523 103 other other JJ 37231 1523 104 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1523 105 can can MD 37231 1523 106 not not RB 37231 1523 107 be be VB 37231 1523 108 produced produce VBN 37231 1523 109 , , , 37231 1523 110 is be VBZ 37231 1523 111 of of IN 37231 1523 112 the the DT 37231 1523 113 following following JJ 37231 1523 114 two two CD 37231 1523 115 . . . 37231 1524 1 This this DT 37231 1524 2 shows show VBZ 37231 1524 3 the the DT 37231 1524 4 importance importance NN 37231 1524 5 which which WDT 37231 1524 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1524 7 attaches attach VBZ 37231 1524 8 to to IN 37231 1524 9 the the DT 37231 1524 10 point point NN 37231 1524 11 ; ; : 37231 1524 12 but but CC 37231 1524 13 , , , 37231 1524 14 notwithstanding notwithstanding RB 37231 1524 15 , , , 37231 1524 16 even even RB 37231 1524 17 if if IN 37231 1524 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1524 19 could could MD 37231 1524 20 substantiate substantiate VB 37231 1524 21 this this DT 37231 1524 22 statement statement NN 37231 1524 23 , , , 37231 1524 24 the the DT 37231 1524 25 cause cause NN 37231 1524 26 of of IN 37231 1524 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1524 28 would would MD 37231 1524 29 not not RB 37231 1524 30 be be VB 37231 1524 31 one one CD 37231 1524 32 whit whit NN 37231 1524 33 advanced advance VBN 37231 1524 34 . . . 37231 1525 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1525 2 have have VBP 37231 1525 3 freely freely RB 37231 1525 4 quoted quote VBN 37231 1525 5 these these DT 37231 1525 6 arguments argument NNS 37231 1525 7 in in IN 37231 1525 8 order order NN 37231 1525 9 to to TO 37231 1525 10 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 1525 11 the the DT 37231 1525 12 real real JJ 37231 1525 13 position position NN 37231 1525 14 of of IN 37231 1525 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1525 16 ; ; : 37231 1525 17 and and CC 37231 1525 18 no no DT 37231 1525 19 one one NN 37231 1525 20 who who WP 37231 1525 21 has have VBZ 37231 1525 22 seriously seriously RB 37231 1525 23 considered consider VBN 37231 1525 24 the the DT 37231 1525 25 matter matter NN 37231 1525 26 can can MD 37231 1525 27 doubt doubt VB 37231 1525 28 the the DT 37231 1525 29 necessity necessity NN 37231 1525 30 for for IN 37231 1525 31 very very RB 37231 1525 32 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 1525 33 evidence evidence NN 37231 1525 34 , , , 37231 1525 35 even even RB 37231 1525 36 to to TO 37231 1525 37 render render VB 37231 1525 38 the the DT 37231 1525 39 report report NN 37231 1525 40 of of IN 37231 1525 41 such such JJ 37231 1525 42 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1525 43 worthy worthy JJ 37231 1525 44 of of IN 37231 1525 45 a a DT 37231 1525 46 moment moment NN 37231 1525 47 's 's POS 37231 1525 48 attention attention NN 37231 1525 49 . . . 37231 1526 1 The the DT 37231 1526 2 argument argument NN 37231 1526 3 for for IN 37231 1526 4 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1526 5 , , , 37231 1526 6 however however RB 37231 1526 7 , , , 37231 1526 8 has have VBZ 37231 1526 9 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 1526 10 proceeded proceed VBN 37231 1526 11 upon upon IN 37231 1526 12 the the DT 37231 1526 13 merest mere JJS 37231 1526 14 assumption assumption NN 37231 1526 15 , , , 37231 1526 16 and and CC 37231 1526 17 , , , 37231 1526 18 as as IN 37231 1526 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1526 20 shall shall MD 37231 1526 21 further further RB 37231 1526 22 see see VB 37231 1526 23 , , , 37231 1526 24 the the DT 37231 1526 25 utmost utmost JJ 37231 1526 26 that that WDT 37231 1526 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1526 28 can can MD 37231 1526 29 do do VB 37231 1526 30 who who WP 37231 1526 31 support support VB 37231 1526 32 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1526 33 , , , 37231 1526 34 under under IN 37231 1526 35 the the DT 37231 1526 36 fatal fatal JJ 37231 1526 37 disadvantage disadvantage NN 37231 1526 38 of of IN 37231 1526 39 being be VBG 37231 1526 40 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1526 41 to to TO 37231 1526 42 uniform uniform VB 37231 1526 43 experience experience NN 37231 1526 44 , , , 37231 1526 45 is be VBZ 37231 1526 46 to to TO 37231 1526 47 refer refer VB 37231 1526 48 to to IN 37231 1526 49 the the DT 37231 1526 50 alleged alleged JJ 37231 1526 51 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 37231 1526 52 nature nature NN 37231 1526 53 of of IN 37231 1526 54 the the DT 37231 1526 55 evidence evidence NN 37231 1526 56 for for IN 37231 1526 57 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1526 58 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1526 59 , , , 37231 1526 60 and and CC 37231 1526 61 to to IN 37231 1526 62 the the DT 37231 1526 63 character character NN 37231 1526 64 of of IN 37231 1526 65 the the DT 37231 1526 66 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1526 67 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1526 68 . . . 37231 1527 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1527 2 Mill Mill NNP 37231 1527 3 has have VBZ 37231 1527 4 ably ably RB 37231 1527 5 shown show VBN 37231 1527 6 the the DT 37231 1527 7 serious serious JJ 37231 1527 8 misapprehension misapprehension NN 37231 1527 9 of of IN 37231 1527 10 so so RB 37231 1527 11 many many JJ 37231 1527 12 writers writer NNS 37231 1527 13 against against IN 37231 1527 14 Hume Hume NNP 37231 1527 15 's 's POS 37231 1527 16 " " `` 37231 1527 17 Essay Essay NNP 37231 1527 18 on on IN 37231 1527 19 Miracles Miracles NNPS 37231 1527 20 , , , 37231 1527 21 " " '' 37231 1527 22 which which WDT 37231 1527 23 has have VBZ 37231 1527 24 led lead VBN 37231 1527 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1527 26 to to IN 37231 1527 27 what what WP 37231 1527 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1527 29 calls call VBZ 37231 1527 30 " " `` 37231 1527 31 the the DT 37231 1527 32 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 1527 33 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1527 34 , , , 37231 1527 35 that that IN 37231 1527 36 nothing nothing NN 37231 1527 37 supported support VBN 37231 1527 38 by by IN 37231 1527 39 credible credible JJ 37231 1527 40 testimony testimony NN 37231 1527 41 ought ought MD 37231 1527 42 ever ever RB 37231 1527 43 to to TO 37231 1527 44 be be VB 37231 1527 45 disbelieved disbelieve VBN 37231 1527 46 . . . 37231 1528 1 " " `` 37231 1528 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1528 3 1 1 LS 37231 1528 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1528 5 In in IN 37231 1528 6 regard regard NN 37231 1528 7 to to IN 37231 1528 8 historical historical JJ 37231 1528 9 facts fact NNS 37231 1528 10 , , , 37231 1528 11 not not RB 37231 1528 12 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1528 13 to to IN 37231 1528 14 all all DT 37231 1528 15 { { -LRB- 37231 1528 16 94 94 CD 37231 1528 17 } } -RRB- 37231 1528 18 experience experience NN 37231 1528 19 , , , 37231 1528 20 simple simple JJ 37231 1528 21 and and CC 37231 1528 22 impartial impartial JJ 37231 1528 23 testimony testimony NN 37231 1528 24 may may MD 37231 1528 25 be be VB 37231 1528 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1528 27 to to TO 37231 1528 28 warrant warrant VB 37231 1528 29 belief belief NN 37231 1528 30 , , , 37231 1528 31 but but CC 37231 1528 32 even even RB 37231 1528 33 such such JJ 37231 1528 34 qualities quality NNS 37231 1528 35 as as IN 37231 1528 36 these these DT 37231 1528 37 can can MD 37231 1528 38 go go VB 37231 1528 39 but but CC 37231 1528 40 a a DT 37231 1528 41 very very RB 37231 1528 42 small small JJ 37231 1528 43 way way NN 37231 1528 44 towards towards IN 37231 1528 45 establishing establish VBG 37231 1528 46 the the DT 37231 1528 47 reality reality NN 37231 1528 48 of of IN 37231 1528 49 an an DT 37231 1528 50 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1528 51 which which WDT 37231 1528 52 is be VBZ 37231 1528 53 opposed oppose VBN 37231 1528 54 to to TO 37231 1528 55 complete complete VB 37231 1528 56 induction induction NN 37231 1528 57 . . . 37231 1529 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1529 2 1 1 LS 37231 1529 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1529 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1529 5 is be VBZ 37231 1529 6 admitted admit VBN 37231 1529 7 that that IN 37231 1529 8 the the DT 37231 1529 9 evidence evidence NN 37231 1529 10 requisite requisite JJ 37231 1529 11 to to TO 37231 1529 12 establish establish VB 37231 1529 13 the the DT 37231 1529 14 reality reality NN 37231 1529 15 of of IN 37231 1529 16 a a DT 37231 1529 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1529 18 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1529 19 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1529 20 of of IN 37231 1529 21 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 1529 22 beyond beyond IN 37231 1529 23 human human JJ 37231 1529 24 reason reason NN 37231 1529 25 , , , 37231 1529 26 and and CC 37231 1529 27 comprising comprise VBG 37231 1529 28 in in IN 37231 1529 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1529 30 very very JJ 37231 1529 31 essence essence NN 37231 1529 32 such such JJ 37231 1529 33 stupendous stupendous JJ 37231 1529 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1529 35 as as IN 37231 1529 36 the the DT 37231 1529 37 Incarnation Incarnation NNP 37231 1529 38 , , , 37231 1529 39 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 1529 40 , , , 37231 1529 41 and and CC 37231 1529 42 Ascension ascension NN 37231 1529 43 , , , 37231 1529 44 must must MD 37231 1529 45 be be VB 37231 1529 46 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1529 47 . . . 37231 1530 1 The the DT 37231 1530 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 1530 3 for for IN 37231 1530 4 the the DT 37231 1530 5 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1530 6 evidence evidence NN 37231 1530 7 , , , 37231 1530 8 which which WDT 37231 1530 9 is be VBZ 37231 1530 10 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1530 11 less less RBR 37231 1530 12 astounding astounding JJ 37231 1530 13 than than IN 37231 1530 14 the the DT 37231 1530 15 contents content NNS 37231 1530 16 of of IN 37231 1530 17 the the DT 37231 1530 18 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1530 19 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1530 20 , , , 37231 1530 21 must must MD 37231 1530 22 , , , 37231 1530 23 logically logically RB 37231 1530 24 , , , 37231 1530 25 be be VB 37231 1530 26 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1530 27 also also RB 37231 1530 28 , , , 37231 1530 29 for for IN 37231 1530 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1530 31 is be VBZ 37231 1530 32 not not RB 37231 1530 33 a a DT 37231 1530 34 whit whit NN 37231 1530 35 more more RBR 37231 1530 36 easy easy JJ 37231 1530 37 to to TO 37231 1530 38 prove prove VB 37231 1530 39 the the DT 37231 1530 40 reality reality NN 37231 1530 41 of of IN 37231 1530 42 an an DT 37231 1530 43 evidential evidential JJ 37231 1530 44 miracle miracle NN 37231 1530 45 than than IN 37231 1530 46 of of IN 37231 1530 47 a a DT 37231 1530 48 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 1530 49 miracle miracle NN 37231 1530 50 . . . 37231 1531 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1531 2 is be VBZ 37231 1531 3 evident evident JJ 37231 1531 4 that that IN 37231 1531 5 the the DT 37231 1531 6 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 1531 7 of of IN 37231 1531 8 Lazarus Lazarus NNP 37231 1531 9 , , , 37231 1531 10 for for IN 37231 1531 11 instance instance NN 37231 1531 12 , , , 37231 1531 13 is be VBZ 37231 1531 14 as as RB 37231 1531 15 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 1531 16 to to TO 37231 1531 17 complete complete VB 37231 1531 18 induction induction NN 37231 1531 19 as as IN 37231 1531 20 the the DT 37231 1531 21 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 1531 22 of of IN 37231 1531 23 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1531 24 . . . 37231 1532 1 Both both DT 37231 1532 2 the the DT 37231 1532 3 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 37231 1532 4 Religion Religion NNP 37231 1532 5 , , , 37231 1532 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 1532 7 , , , 37231 1532 8 and and CC 37231 1532 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1532 10 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1532 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 1532 12 labour labour NN 37231 1532 13 under under IN 37231 1532 14 the the DT 37231 1532 15 fatal fatal JJ 37231 1532 16 disability disability NN 37231 1532 17 of of IN 37231 1532 18 being be VBG 37231 1532 19 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1532 20 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1532 21 . . . 37231 1533 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1533 2 95 95 CD 37231 1533 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1533 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 1533 5 IV IV NNP 37231 1533 6 . . . 37231 1534 1 THE the DT 37231 1534 2 AGE age NN 37231 1534 3 OF of IN 37231 1534 4 MIRACLES MIRACLES NNP 37231 1534 5 Let let VB 37231 1534 6 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1534 7 now now RB 37231 1534 8 , , , 37231 1534 9 however however RB 37231 1534 10 , , , 37231 1534 11 proceed proceed VB 37231 1534 12 to to TO 37231 1534 13 examine examine VB 37231 1534 14 the the DT 37231 1534 15 evidence evidence NN 37231 1534 16 for for IN 37231 1534 17 the the DT 37231 1534 18 reality reality NN 37231 1534 19 of of IN 37231 1534 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1534 21 , , , 37231 1534 22 and and CC 37231 1534 23 to to TO 37231 1534 24 inquire inquire VB 37231 1534 25 whether whether IN 37231 1534 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1534 27 are be VBP 37231 1534 28 supported support VBN 37231 1534 29 by by IN 37231 1534 30 such such PDT 37231 1534 31 an an DT 37231 1534 32 amount amount NN 37231 1534 33 of of IN 37231 1534 34 testimony testimony NN 37231 1534 35 as as IN 37231 1534 36 can can MD 37231 1534 37 in in IN 37231 1534 38 any any DT 37231 1534 39 degree degree NN 37231 1534 40 outweigh outweigh VB 37231 1534 41 the the DT 37231 1534 42 reasons reason NNS 37231 1534 43 which which WDT 37231 1534 44 , , , 37231 1534 45 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 1534 46 , , , 37231 1534 47 seem seem VBP 37231 1534 48 to to TO 37231 1534 49 render render VB 37231 1534 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1534 51 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1534 52 . . . 37231 1535 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1535 2 is be VBZ 37231 1535 3 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 1535 4 that that IN 37231 1535 5 belief belief NN 37231 1535 6 in in IN 37231 1535 7 the the DT 37231 1535 8 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1535 9 has have VBZ 37231 1535 10 gradually gradually RB 37231 1535 11 been be VBN 37231 1535 12 dispelled dispel VBN 37231 1535 13 , , , 37231 1535 14 and and CC 37231 1535 15 that that IN 37231 1535 16 , , , 37231 1535 17 as as IN 37231 1535 18 a a DT 37231 1535 19 general general JJ 37231 1535 20 rule rule NN 37231 1535 21 , , , 37231 1535 22 the the DT 37231 1535 23 only only JJ 37231 1535 24 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1535 25 which which WDT 37231 1535 26 are be VBP 37231 1535 27 now now RB 37231 1535 28 maintained maintain VBN 37231 1535 29 are be VBP 37231 1535 30 limited limited JJ 37231 1535 31 to to IN 37231 1535 32 brief brief JJ 37231 1535 33 and and CC 37231 1535 34 distant distant JJ 37231 1535 35 periods period NNS 37231 1535 36 of of IN 37231 1535 37 time time NN 37231 1535 38 . . . 37231 1536 1 Faith faith NN 37231 1536 2 in in IN 37231 1536 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1536 4 reality reality NN 37231 1536 5 , , , 37231 1536 6 once once RB 37231 1536 7 so so RB 37231 1536 8 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 37231 1536 9 , , , 37231 1536 10 does do VBZ 37231 1536 11 not not RB 37231 1536 12 , , , 37231 1536 13 except except IN 37231 1536 14 amongst amongst IN 37231 1536 15 a a DT 37231 1536 16 certain certain JJ 37231 1536 17 class class NN 37231 1536 18 , , , 37231 1536 19 extend extend VB 37231 1536 20 beyond beyond IN 37231 1536 21 the the DT 37231 1536 22 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1536 23 of of IN 37231 1536 24 the the DT 37231 1536 25 New New NNP 37231 1536 26 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1536 27 and and CC 37231 1536 28 a a DT 37231 1536 29 few few JJ 37231 1536 30 of of IN 37231 1536 31 those those DT 37231 1536 32 of of IN 37231 1536 33 the the DT 37231 1536 34 Old,(1 Old,(1 NNP 37231 1536 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1536 36 and and CC 37231 1536 37 the the DT 37231 1536 38 countless countless JJ 37231 1536 39 myriads myriad NNS 37231 1536 40 of of IN 37231 1536 41 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 1536 42 { { -LRB- 37231 1536 43 96 96 CD 37231 1536 44 } } -RRB- 37231 1536 45 and and CC 37231 1536 46 other other JJ 37231 1536 47 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1536 48 , , , 37231 1536 49 for for IN 37231 1536 50 centuries century NNS 37231 1536 51 devoutly devoutly RB 37231 1536 52 and and CC 37231 1536 53 implicitly implicitly RB 37231 1536 54 believed believe VBN 37231 1536 55 , , , 37231 1536 56 are be VBP 37231 1536 57 now now RB 37231 1536 58 commonly commonly RB 37231 1536 59 repudiated repudiate VBN 37231 1536 60 , , , 37231 1536 61 and and CC 37231 1536 62 have have VBP 37231 1536 63 sunk sink VBN 37231 1536 64 into into IN 37231 1536 65 discredit discredit NN 37231 1536 66 and and CC 37231 1536 67 contempt contempt NN 37231 1536 68 . . . 37231 1537 1 The the DT 37231 1537 2 question question NN 37231 1537 3 is be VBZ 37231 1537 4 inevitably inevitably RB 37231 1537 5 suggested suggest VBN 37231 1537 6 how how WRB 37231 1537 7 so so RB 37231 1537 8 much much JJ 37231 1537 9 can can MD 37231 1537 10 be be VB 37231 1537 11 abandoned abandon VBN 37231 1537 12 and and CC 37231 1537 13 the the DT 37231 1537 14 remnant remnant NN 37231 1537 15 still still RB 37231 1537 16 be be VB 37231 1537 17 upheld uphold VBN 37231 1537 18 . . . 37231 1538 1 As as IN 37231 1538 2 an an DT 37231 1538 3 essential essential JJ 37231 1538 4 part part NN 37231 1538 5 of of IN 37231 1538 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1538 7 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 1538 8 into into IN 37231 1538 9 the the DT 37231 1538 10 value value NN 37231 1538 11 of of IN 37231 1538 12 the the DT 37231 1538 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 1538 14 for for IN 37231 1538 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1538 16 , , , 37231 1538 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1538 18 must must MD 37231 1538 19 endeavour endeavour VB 37231 1538 20 to to TO 37231 1538 21 ascertain ascertain VB 37231 1538 22 whether whether IN 37231 1538 23 those those DT 37231 1538 24 who who WP 37231 1538 25 are be VBP 37231 1538 26 said say VBN 37231 1538 27 to to TO 37231 1538 28 have have VB 37231 1538 29 witnessed witness VBN 37231 1538 30 the the DT 37231 1538 31 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1538 32 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1538 33 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1538 34 were be VBD 37231 1538 35 either either CC 37231 1538 36 competent competent JJ 37231 1538 37 to to TO 37231 1538 38 appreciate appreciate VB 37231 1538 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1538 40 aright aright VBD 37231 1538 41 , , , 37231 1538 42 or or CC 37231 1538 43 likely likely JJ 37231 1538 44 to to TO 37231 1538 45 report report VB 37231 1538 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1538 47 without without IN 37231 1538 48 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37231 1538 49 . . . 37231 1539 1 For for IN 37231 1539 2 this this DT 37231 1539 3 purpose purpose NN 37231 1539 4 , , , 37231 1539 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1539 6 must must MD 37231 1539 7 consider consider VB 37231 1539 8 what what WP 37231 1539 9 was be VBD 37231 1539 10 known know VBN 37231 1539 11 of of IN 37231 1539 12 the the DT 37231 1539 13 order order NN 37231 1539 14 of of IN 37231 1539 15 nature nature NN 37231 1539 16 in in IN 37231 1539 17 the the DT 37231 1539 18 age age NN 37231 1539 19 in in IN 37231 1539 20 which which WDT 37231 1539 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1539 22 are be VBP 37231 1539 23 said say VBN 37231 1539 24 to to TO 37231 1539 25 have have VB 37231 1539 26 taken take VBN 37231 1539 27 place place NN 37231 1539 28 , , , 37231 1539 29 and and CC 37231 1539 30 what what WP 37231 1539 31 was be VBD 37231 1539 32 the the DT 37231 1539 33 intellectual intellectual JJ 37231 1539 34 character character NN 37231 1539 35 of of IN 37231 1539 36 the the DT 37231 1539 37 people people NNS 37231 1539 38 amongst amongst IN 37231 1539 39 whom whom WP 37231 1539 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1539 41 are be VBP 37231 1539 42 reported report VBN 37231 1539 43 to to TO 37231 1539 44 have have VB 37231 1539 45 been be VBN 37231 1539 46 performed perform VBN 37231 1539 47 . . . 37231 1540 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 1540 2 is be VBZ 37231 1540 3 more more RBR 37231 1540 4 rare rare JJ 37231 1540 5 , , , 37231 1540 6 even even RB 37231 1540 7 amongst amongst IN 37231 1540 8 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 1540 9 and and CC 37231 1540 10 cultivated cultivate VBN 37231 1540 11 men man NNS 37231 1540 12 , , , 37231 1540 13 than than IN 37231 1540 14 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 1540 15 of of IN 37231 1540 16 observation observation NN 37231 1540 17 and and CC 37231 1540 18 correctness correctness NN 37231 1540 19 of of IN 37231 1540 20 report report NN 37231 1540 21 , , , 37231 1540 22 even even RB 37231 1540 23 in in IN 37231 1540 24 matters matter NNS 37231 1540 25 of of IN 37231 1540 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1540 27 importance importance NN 37231 1540 28 to to TO 37231 1540 29 attract attract VB 37231 1540 30 vivid vivid JJ 37231 1540 31 attention attention NN 37231 1540 32 , , , 37231 1540 33 and and CC 37231 1540 34 in in IN 37231 1540 35 which which WDT 37231 1540 36 there there EX 37231 1540 37 is be VBZ 37231 1540 38 no no DT 37231 1540 39 special special JJ 37231 1540 40 interest interest NN 37231 1540 41 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 1540 42 to to TO 37231 1540 43 bias bias VB 37231 1540 44 the the DT 37231 1540 45 observer observer NN 37231 1540 46 . . . 37231 1541 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1541 2 will will MD 37231 1541 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1541 4 be be VB 37231 1541 5 denied deny VBN 37231 1541 6 , , , 37231 1541 7 however however RB 37231 1541 8 , , , 37231 1541 9 that that IN 37231 1541 10 in in IN 37231 1541 11 persons person NNS 37231 1541 12 of of IN 37231 1541 13 fervid fervid JJ 37231 1541 14 imagination imagination NN 37231 1541 15 , , , 37231 1541 16 and and CC 37231 1541 17 with with IN 37231 1541 18 a a DT 37231 1541 19 strong strong JJ 37231 1541 20 natural natural JJ 37231 1541 21 love love NN 37231 1541 22 of of IN 37231 1541 23 the the DT 37231 1541 24 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 1541 25 , , , 37231 1541 26 whose whose WP$ 37231 1541 27 minds mind NNS 37231 1541 28 are be VBP 37231 1541 29 not not RB 37231 1541 30 only only RB 37231 1541 31 unrestrained unrestraine VBN 37231 1541 32 by by IN 37231 1541 33 specific specific JJ 37231 1541 34 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1541 35 , , , 37231 1541 36 but but CC 37231 1541 37 predisposed predispose VBN 37231 1541 38 by by IN 37231 1541 39 superstition superstition NN 37231 1541 40 towards towards IN 37231 1541 41 false false JJ 37231 1541 42 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 1541 43 , , , 37231 1541 44 the the DT 37231 1541 45 probability probability NN 37231 1541 46 of of IN 37231 1541 47 inaccuracy inaccuracy NN 37231 1541 48 and and CC 37231 1541 49 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37231 1541 50 is be VBZ 37231 1541 51 enormously enormously RB 37231 1541 52 { { -LRB- 37231 1541 53 97 97 CD 37231 1541 54 } } -RRB- 37231 1541 55 increased increase VBD 37231 1541 56 . . . 37231 1542 1 If if IN 37231 1542 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1542 3 add add VBP 37231 1542 4 to to IN 37231 1542 5 this this DT 37231 1542 6 such such PDT 37231 1542 7 a a DT 37231 1542 8 disturbing disturbing JJ 37231 1542 9 element element NN 37231 1542 10 as as IN 37231 1542 11 religious religious JJ 37231 1542 12 excitement excitement NN 37231 1542 13 , , , 37231 1542 14 inaccuracy inaccuracy NN 37231 1542 15 , , , 37231 1542 16 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37231 1542 17 , , , 37231 1542 18 and and CC 37231 1542 19 extravagance extravagance NN 37231 1542 20 are be VBP 37231 1542 21 certain certain JJ 37231 1542 22 to to TO 37231 1542 23 occur occur VB 37231 1542 24 . . . 37231 1543 1 The the DT 37231 1543 2 effect effect NN 37231 1543 3 of of IN 37231 1543 4 even even RB 37231 1543 5 one one CD 37231 1543 6 of of IN 37231 1543 7 these these DT 37231 1543 8 influences influence NNS 37231 1543 9 , , , 37231 1543 10 religious religious JJ 37231 1543 11 feeling feeling NN 37231 1543 12 , , , 37231 1543 13 in in IN 37231 1543 14 warping warp VBG 37231 1543 15 the the DT 37231 1543 16 judgment judgment NN 37231 1543 17 , , , 37231 1543 18 is be VBZ 37231 1543 19 admitted admit VBN 37231 1543 20 by by IN 37231 1543 21 one one CD 37231 1543 22 of of IN 37231 1543 23 the the DT 37231 1543 24 most most RBS 37231 1543 25 uncompromising uncompromising JJ 37231 1543 26 supporters supporter NNS 37231 1543 27 of of IN 37231 1543 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1543 29 . . . 37231 1544 1 " " `` 37231 1544 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1544 3 is be VBZ 37231 1544 4 doubtless doubtless RB 37231 1544 5 the the DT 37231 1544 6 tendency tendency NN 37231 1544 7 of of IN 37231 1544 8 religious religious JJ 37231 1544 9 minds mind NNS 37231 1544 10 , , , 37231 1544 11 " " '' 37231 1544 12 says say VBZ 37231 1544 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1544 14 Newman Newman NNP 37231 1544 15 , , , 37231 1544 16 " " `` 37231 1544 17 to to TO 37231 1544 18 imagine imagine VB 37231 1544 19 mysteries mystery NNS 37231 1544 20 and and CC 37231 1544 21 wonders wonder NNS 37231 1544 22 where where WRB 37231 1544 23 there there EX 37231 1544 24 are be VBP 37231 1544 25 none none NN 37231 1544 26 ; ; : 37231 1544 27 and and CC 37231 1544 28 much much RB 37231 1544 29 more more JJR 37231 1544 30 , , , 37231 1544 31 where where WRB 37231 1544 32 causes cause NNS 37231 1544 33 of of IN 37231 1544 34 awe awe NNP 37231 1544 35 really really RB 37231 1544 36 exist exist VB 37231 1544 37 , , , 37231 1544 38 will will MD 37231 1544 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1544 40 unintentionally unintentionally RB 37231 1544 41 mis mis VB 37231 1544 42 - - HYPH 37231 1544 43 state state NN 37231 1544 44 , , , 37231 1544 45 exaggerate exaggerate VB 37231 1544 46 , , , 37231 1544 47 and and CC 37231 1544 48 embellish embellish JJ 37231 1544 49 , , , 37231 1544 50 when when WRB 37231 1544 51 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1544 52 set set VBD 37231 1544 53 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1544 54 to to TO 37231 1544 55 relate relate VB 37231 1544 56 what what WP 37231 1544 57 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1544 58 have have VBP 37231 1544 59 witnessed witness VBN 37231 1544 60 or or CC 37231 1544 61 have have VBP 37231 1544 62 heard hear VBN 37231 1544 63 ; ; : 37231 1544 64 " " `` 37231 1544 65 and and CC 37231 1544 66 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1544 67 adds add VBZ 37231 1544 68 : : : 37231 1544 69 " " `` 37231 1544 70 and and CC 37231 1544 71 further far RBR 37231 1544 72 , , , 37231 1544 73 the the DT 37231 1544 74 imagination imagination NN 37231 1544 75 , , , 37231 1544 76 as as IN 37231 1544 77 is be VBZ 37231 1544 78 well well RB 37231 1544 79 known know VBN 37231 1544 80 , , , 37231 1544 81 is be VBZ 37231 1544 82 a a DT 37231 1544 83 fruitful fruitful JJ 37231 1544 84 cause cause NN 37231 1544 85 of of IN 37231 1544 86 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1544 87 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1544 88 . . . 37231 1545 1 " " `` 37231 1545 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1545 3 1 1 LS 37231 1545 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1545 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1545 6 need need VBP 37231 1545 7 not not RB 37231 1545 8 offer offer VB 37231 1545 9 any any DT 37231 1545 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 1545 11 that that IN 37231 1545 12 the the DT 37231 1545 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1545 14 which which WDT 37231 1545 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1545 16 have have VBP 37231 1545 17 to to TO 37231 1545 18 examine examine VB 37231 1545 19 were be VBD 37231 1545 20 witnessed witness VBN 37231 1545 21 and and CC 37231 1545 22 reported report VBN 37231 1545 23 by by IN 37231 1545 24 persons person NNS 37231 1545 25 exposed expose VBN 37231 1545 26 to to IN 37231 1545 27 the the DT 37231 1545 28 effects effect NNS 37231 1545 29 of of IN 37231 1545 30 the the DT 37231 1545 31 strongest strong JJS 37231 1545 32 possible possible JJ 37231 1545 33 religious religious JJ 37231 1545 34 feeling feeling NN 37231 1545 35 and and CC 37231 1545 36 excitement excitement NN 37231 1545 37 , , , 37231 1545 38 and and CC 37231 1545 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1545 40 attention attention NN 37231 1545 41 may may MD 37231 1545 42 , , , 37231 1545 43 therefore therefore RB 37231 1545 44 , , , 37231 1545 45 be be VB 37231 1545 46 more more RBR 37231 1545 47 freely freely RB 37231 1545 48 directed direct VBN 37231 1545 49 to to IN 37231 1545 50 the the DT 37231 1545 51 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 1545 52 how how WRB 37231 1545 53 far far RB 37231 1545 54 this this DT 37231 1545 55 influence influence NN 37231 1545 56 was be VBD 37231 1545 57 modified modify VBN 37231 1545 58 by by IN 37231 1545 59 other other JJ 37231 1545 60 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1545 61 . . . 37231 1546 1 Did do VBD 37231 1546 2 the the DT 37231 1546 3 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1546 4 at at IN 37231 1546 5 the the DT 37231 1546 6 time time NN 37231 1546 7 of of IN 37231 1546 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1546 9 possess possess VBP 37231 1546 10 such such JJ 37231 1546 11 calmness calmness NN 37231 1546 12 of of IN 37231 1546 13 judgment judgment NN 37231 1546 14 and and CC 37231 1546 15 sobriety sobriety NN 37231 1546 16 of of IN 37231 1546 17 imagination imagination NN 37231 1546 18 as as IN 37231 1546 19 to to TO 37231 1546 20 inspire inspire VB 37231 1546 21 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1546 22 with with IN 37231 1546 23 any any DT 37231 1546 24 confidence confidence NN 37231 1546 25 in in IN 37231 1546 26 accounts account NNS 37231 1546 27 of of IN 37231 1546 28 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 1546 29 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1546 30 , , , 37231 1546 31 unwitnessed unwitnesse VBN 37231 1546 32 except except IN 37231 1546 33 by by IN 37231 1546 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1546 35 , , , 37231 1546 36 and and CC 37231 1546 37 limited limit VBN 37231 1546 38 to to IN 37231 1546 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1546 40 time time NN 37231 1546 41 , , , 37231 1546 42 which which WDT 37231 1546 43 contradict contradict VBP 37231 1546 44 all all DT 37231 1546 45 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1546 46 and and CC 37231 1546 47 all all DT 37231 1546 48 experience experience NN 37231 1546 49 ? ? . 37231 1547 1 Were be VBD 37231 1547 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1547 3 minds mind NNS 37231 1547 4 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 1547 5 enlightened enlighten VBN 37231 1547 6 and and CC 37231 1547 7 free free JJ 37231 1547 8 from from IN 37231 1547 9 superstition superstition NN 37231 1547 10 to to TO 37231 1547 11 warrant warrant VB 37231 1547 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1547 13 attaching attach VBG 37231 1547 14 weight weight NN 37231 1547 15 to to IN 37231 1547 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1547 17 report report NN 37231 1547 18 of of IN 37231 1547 19 events event NNS 37231 1547 20 of of IN 37231 1547 21 such such PDT 37231 1547 22 an an DT 37231 1547 23 astounding astounding JJ 37231 1547 24 nature nature NN 37231 1547 25 ? ? . 37231 1548 1 and and CC 37231 1548 2 were be VBD 37231 1548 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1548 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1548 5 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 1548 6 impressed impress VBD 37231 1548 7 with with IN 37231 1548 8 the the DT 37231 1548 9 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 1548 10 character character NN 37231 1548 11 of of IN 37231 1548 12 { { -LRB- 37231 1548 13 98 98 CD 37231 1548 14 } } -RRB- 37231 1548 15 any any DT 37231 1548 16 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1548 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1548 18 and and CC 37231 1548 19 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1548 20 interference interference NN 37231 1548 21 with with IN 37231 1548 22 the the DT 37231 1548 23 order order NN 37231 1548 24 of of IN 37231 1548 25 nature nature NN 37231 1548 26 ? ? . 37231 1549 1 Let let VB 37231 1549 2 an an DT 37231 1549 3 English english JJ 37231 1549 4 historian historian NN 37231 1549 5 and and CC 37231 1549 6 divine divine JJ 37231 1549 7 , , , 37231 1549 8 who who WP 37231 1549 9 will will MD 37231 1549 10 be be VB 37231 1549 11 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 37231 1549 12 as as IN 37231 1549 13 no no DT 37231 1549 14 prejudiced prejudiced JJ 37231 1549 15 witness witness NN 37231 1549 16 , , , 37231 1549 17 bear bear VB 37231 1549 18 testimony testimony NN 37231 1549 19 upon upon IN 37231 1549 20 some some DT 37231 1549 21 of of IN 37231 1549 22 these these DT 37231 1549 23 points point NNS 37231 1549 24 . . . 37231 1550 1 " " `` 37231 1550 2 Nor nor CC 37231 1550 3 is be VBZ 37231 1550 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1550 5 less less RBR 37231 1550 6 important important JJ 37231 1550 7 , , , 37231 1550 8 " " '' 37231 1550 9 says say VBZ 37231 1550 10 the the DT 37231 1550 11 late late JJ 37231 1550 12 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1550 13 Milman Milman NNP 37231 1550 14 , , , 37231 1550 15 " " '' 37231 1550 16 throughout throughout IN 37231 1550 17 the the DT 37231 1550 18 early early JJ 37231 1550 19 history history NN 37231 1550 20 of of IN 37231 1550 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1550 22 , , , 37231 1550 23 to to TO 37231 1550 24 seize seize VB 37231 1550 25 the the DT 37231 1550 26 spirit spirit NN 37231 1550 27 of of IN 37231 1550 28 the the DT 37231 1550 29 times time NNS 37231 1550 30 . . . 37231 1551 1 Events event NNS 37231 1551 2 which which WDT 37231 1551 3 appear appear VBP 37231 1551 4 to to IN 37231 1551 5 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1551 6 so so RB 37231 1551 7 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 1551 8 , , , 37231 1551 9 that that IN 37231 1551 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1551 11 can can MD 37231 1551 12 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1551 13 conceive conceive VB 37231 1551 14 that that IN 37231 1551 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1551 16 should should MD 37231 1551 17 either either CC 37231 1551 18 fail fail VB 37231 1551 19 in in IN 37231 1551 20 exciting excite VBG 37231 1551 21 a a DT 37231 1551 22 powerful powerful JJ 37231 1551 23 sensation sensation NN 37231 1551 24 , , , 37231 1551 25 or or CC 37231 1551 26 ever ever RB 37231 1551 27 be be VB 37231 1551 28 obliterated obliterate VBN 37231 1551 29 from from IN 37231 1551 30 the the DT 37231 1551 31 popular popular JJ 37231 1551 32 remembrance remembrance NN 37231 1551 33 , , , 37231 1551 34 in in IN 37231 1551 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1551 36 own own JJ 37231 1551 37 day day NN 37231 1551 38 might may MD 37231 1551 39 pass pass VB 37231 1551 40 off off RP 37231 1551 41 as as IN 37231 1551 42 of of IN 37231 1551 43 little little JJ 37231 1551 44 more more JJR 37231 1551 45 than than IN 37231 1551 46 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 1551 47 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1551 48 . . . 37231 1552 1 During during IN 37231 1552 2 the the DT 37231 1552 3 whole whole JJ 37231 1552 4 life life NN 37231 1552 5 of of IN 37231 1552 6 Christ Christ NNP 37231 1552 7 , , , 37231 1552 8 and and CC 37231 1552 9 the the DT 37231 1552 10 early early JJ 37231 1552 11 propagation propagation NN 37231 1552 12 of of IN 37231 1552 13 the the DT 37231 1552 14 religion religion NN 37231 1552 15 , , , 37231 1552 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1552 17 must must MD 37231 1552 18 be be VB 37231 1552 19 borne bear VBN 37231 1552 20 in in IN 37231 1552 21 mind mind NN 37231 1552 22 that that IN 37231 1552 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1552 24 took take VBD 37231 1552 25 place place NN 37231 1552 26 in in IN 37231 1552 27 an an DT 37231 1552 28 age age NN 37231 1552 29 , , , 37231 1552 30 and and CC 37231 1552 31 among among IN 37231 1552 32 a a DT 37231 1552 33 people people NNS 37231 1552 34 , , , 37231 1552 35 which which WDT 37231 1552 36 superstition superstition NN 37231 1552 37 had have VBD 37231 1552 38 made make VBN 37231 1552 39 so so RB 37231 1552 40 familiar familiar JJ 37231 1552 41 with with IN 37231 1552 42 what what WP 37231 1552 43 were be VBD 37231 1552 44 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1552 45 to to TO 37231 1552 46 be be VB 37231 1552 47 preternatural preternatural JJ 37231 1552 48 events event NNS 37231 1552 49 , , , 37231 1552 50 that that WDT 37231 1552 51 wonders wonder NNS 37231 1552 52 awakened awaken VBD 37231 1552 53 no no DT 37231 1552 54 emotion emotion NN 37231 1552 55 , , , 37231 1552 56 or or CC 37231 1552 57 were be VBD 37231 1552 58 speedily speedily RB 37231 1552 59 superseded supersede VBN 37231 1552 60 by by IN 37231 1552 61 some some DT 37231 1552 62 new new JJ 37231 1552 63 demand demand NN 37231 1552 64 on on IN 37231 1552 65 the the DT 37231 1552 66 ever ever RB 37231 1552 67 - - HYPH 37231 1552 68 ready ready JJ 37231 1552 69 belief belief NN 37231 1552 70 . . . 37231 1553 1 The the DT 37231 1553 2 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1553 3 of of IN 37231 1553 4 that that DT 37231 1553 5 period period NN 37231 1553 6 not not RB 37231 1553 7 only only RB 37231 1553 8 believed believe VBD 37231 1553 9 that that IN 37231 1553 10 the the DT 37231 1553 11 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1553 12 Being Being NNP 37231 1553 13 had have VBD 37231 1553 14 the the DT 37231 1553 15 power power NN 37231 1553 16 of of IN 37231 1553 17 controlling control VBG 37231 1553 18 the the DT 37231 1553 19 course course NN 37231 1553 20 of of IN 37231 1553 21 nature nature NN 37231 1553 22 , , , 37231 1553 23 but but CC 37231 1553 24 that that IN 37231 1553 25 the the DT 37231 1553 26 same same JJ 37231 1553 27 influence influence NN 37231 1553 28 was be VBD 37231 1553 29 possessed possess VBN 37231 1553 30 by by IN 37231 1553 31 multitudes multitude NNS 37231 1553 32 of of IN 37231 1553 33 subordinate subordinate JJ 37231 1553 34 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1553 35 , , , 37231 1553 36 both both CC 37231 1553 37 good good JJ 37231 1553 38 and and CC 37231 1553 39 evil evil NN 37231 1553 40 . . . 37231 1554 1 Where where WRB 37231 1554 2 the the DT 37231 1554 3 pious pious JJ 37231 1554 4 Christian Christian NNP 37231 1554 5 of of IN 37231 1554 6 the the DT 37231 1554 7 present present JJ 37231 1554 8 day day NN 37231 1554 9 would would MD 37231 1554 10 behold behold VB 37231 1554 11 the the DT 37231 1554 12 direct direct JJ 37231 1554 13 agency agency NN 37231 1554 14 of of IN 37231 1554 15 the the DT 37231 1554 16 Almighty Almighty NNP 37231 1554 17 , , , 37231 1554 18 the the DT 37231 1554 19 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1554 20 would would MD 37231 1554 21 invariably invariably RB 37231 1554 22 have have VB 37231 1554 23 interposed interpose VBN 37231 1554 24 an an DT 37231 1554 25 angel angel NN 37231 1554 26 as as IN 37231 1554 27 the the DT 37231 1554 28 author author NN 37231 1554 29 or or CC 37231 1554 30 ministerial ministerial JJ 37231 1554 31 agent agent NN 37231 1554 32 in in IN 37231 1554 33 the the DT 37231 1554 34 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 1554 35 transaction transaction NN 37231 1554 36 . . . 37231 1555 1 Where where WRB 37231 1555 2 the the DT 37231 1555 3 Christian christian JJ 37231 1555 4 moralist moralist NN 37231 1555 5 would would MD 37231 1555 6 condemn condemn VB 37231 1555 7 the the DT 37231 1555 8 fierce fierce JJ 37231 1555 9 passion passion NN 37231 1555 10 , , , 37231 1555 11 the the DT 37231 1555 12 ungovernable ungovernable JJ 37231 1555 13 lust lust NN 37231 1555 14 , , , 37231 1555 15 or or CC 37231 1555 16 the the DT 37231 1555 17 inhuman inhuman NNP 37231 1555 18 temper temper NN 37231 1555 19 , , , 37231 1555 20 the the DT 37231 1555 21 Jew Jew NNP 37231 1555 22 discerned discern VBD 37231 1555 23 the the DT 37231 1555 24 workings working NNS 37231 1555 25 of of IN 37231 1555 26 diabolical diabolical JJ 37231 1555 27 possession possession NN 37231 1555 28 . . . 37231 1556 1 Scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1556 2 a a DT 37231 1556 3 malady malady NN 37231 1556 4 was be VBD 37231 1556 5 endured endure VBN 37231 1556 6 , , , 37231 1556 7 or or CC 37231 1556 8 crime crime NN 37231 1556 9 committed commit VBD 37231 1556 10 , , , 37231 1556 11 but but CC 37231 1556 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1556 13 was be VBD 37231 1556 14 traced trace VBN 37231 1556 15 to to IN 37231 1556 16 the the DT 37231 1556 17 operation operation NN 37231 1556 18 of of IN 37231 1556 19 one one CD 37231 1556 20 of of IN 37231 1556 21 these these DT 37231 1556 22 myriad myriad JJ 37231 1556 23 daemons daemon NNS 37231 1556 24 , , , 37231 1556 25 who who WP 37231 1556 26 watched watch VBD 37231 1556 27 every every DT 37231 1556 28 opportunity opportunity NN 37231 1556 29 { { -LRB- 37231 1556 30 99 99 CD 37231 1556 31 } } -RRB- 37231 1556 32 of of IN 37231 1556 33 exercising exercise VBG 37231 1556 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1556 35 malice malice NN 37231 1556 36 in in IN 37231 1556 37 the the DT 37231 1556 38 sufferings suffering NNS 37231 1556 39 and and CC 37231 1556 40 the the DT 37231 1556 41 sins sin NNS 37231 1556 42 of of IN 37231 1556 43 men man NNS 37231 1556 44 . . . 37231 1557 1 " " `` 37231 1557 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1557 3 1 1 LS 37231 1557 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1557 5 Another another DT 37231 1557 6 English English NNP 37231 1557 7 divine divine NN 37231 1557 8 , , , 37231 1557 9 of of IN 37231 1557 10 certainly certainly RB 37231 1557 11 not not RB 37231 1557 12 less less RBR 37231 1557 13 orthodoxy orthodoxy JJ 37231 1557 14 , , , 37231 1557 15 but but CC 37231 1557 16 of of IN 37231 1557 17 much much RB 37231 1557 18 greater great JJR 37231 1557 19 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1557 20 of of IN 37231 1557 21 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 1557 22 literature literature NN 37231 1557 23 , , , 37231 1557 24 bears bear VBZ 37231 1557 25 similar similar JJ 37231 1557 26 testimony testimony NN 37231 1557 27 regarding regard VBG 37231 1557 28 the the DT 37231 1557 29 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1557 30 nation nation NN 37231 1557 31 at at IN 37231 1557 32 the the DT 37231 1557 33 same same JJ 37231 1557 34 period period NN 37231 1557 35 . . . 37231 1558 1 " " `` 37231 1558 2 Not not RB 37231 1558 3 to to TO 37231 1558 4 be be VB 37231 1558 5 more more RBR 37231 1558 6 tedious tedious JJ 37231 1558 7 , , , 37231 1558 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 1558 9 , , , 37231 1558 10 in in IN 37231 1558 11 this this DT 37231 1558 12 matter matter NN 37231 1558 13 , , , 37231 1558 14 " " '' 37231 1558 15 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1558 16 regarding regard VBG 37231 1558 17 the the DT 37231 1558 18 Bath Bath NNP 37231 1558 19 Kol Kol NNP 37231 1558 20 , , , 37231 1558 21 a a DT 37231 1558 22 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1558 23 superstition superstition NN 37231 1558 24 , , , 37231 1558 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1558 26 " " `` 37231 1558 27 let let VB 37231 1558 28 two two CD 37231 1558 29 things thing NNS 37231 1558 30 only only RB 37231 1558 31 be be VB 37231 1558 32 observed observe VBN 37231 1558 33 : : : 37231 1558 34 I. I. NNP 37231 1559 1 That that IN 37231 1559 2 the the DT 37231 1559 3 nation nation NN 37231 1559 4 , , , 37231 1559 5 under under IN 37231 1559 6 the the DT 37231 1559 7 second second JJ 37231 1559 8 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1559 9 , , , 37231 1559 10 was be VBD 37231 1559 11 given give VBN 37231 1559 12 to to IN 37231 1559 13 magical magical JJ 37231 1559 14 arts art NNS 37231 1559 15 beyond beyond IN 37231 1559 16 measure measure NN 37231 1559 17 ; ; : 37231 1559 18 and and CC 37231 1559 19 , , , 37231 1559 20 II ii CD 37231 1559 21 . . . 37231 1560 1 That that IN 37231 1560 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1560 3 was be VBD 37231 1560 4 given give VBN 37231 1560 5 to to IN 37231 1560 6 an an DT 37231 1560 7 easiness easiness NN 37231 1560 8 of of IN 37231 1560 9 believing believe VBG 37231 1560 10 all all DT 37231 1560 11 manner manner NN 37231 1560 12 of of IN 37231 1560 13 delusions delusion NNS 37231 1560 14 beyond beyond IN 37231 1560 15 measure measure NN 37231 1560 16 . . . 37231 1561 1 " " `` 37231 1561 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1561 3 2 2 CD 37231 1561 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1561 5 And and CC 37231 1561 6 in in IN 37231 1561 7 another another DT 37231 1561 8 place place NN 37231 1561 9 : : : 37231 1561 10 " " `` 37231 1561 11 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1561 12 is be VBZ 37231 1561 13 a a DT 37231 1561 14 disputable disputable JJ 37231 1561 15 case case NN 37231 1561 16 , , , 37231 1561 17 whether whether IN 37231 1561 18 the the DT 37231 1561 19 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1561 20 nation nation NN 37231 1561 21 were be VBD 37231 1561 22 more more RBR 37231 1561 23 mad mad JJ 37231 1561 24 with with IN 37231 1561 25 superstition superstition NN 37231 1561 26 in in IN 37231 1561 27 matters matter NNS 37231 1561 28 of of IN 37231 1561 29 religion religion NN 37231 1561 30 , , , 37231 1561 31 or or CC 37231 1561 32 with with IN 37231 1561 33 superstition superstition NN 37231 1561 34 in in IN 37231 1561 35 curious curious JJ 37231 1561 36 arts:--I. arts:--I. NNS 37231 1562 1 There there EX 37231 1562 2 was be VBD 37231 1562 3 not not RB 37231 1562 4 a a DT 37231 1562 5 people people NNS 37231 1562 6 upon upon IN 37231 1562 7 earth earth NN 37231 1562 8 that that WDT 37231 1562 9 studied study VBD 37231 1562 10 or or CC 37231 1562 11 attributed attribute VBD 37231 1562 12 more more RBR 37231 1562 13 to to IN 37231 1562 14 dreams dream NNS 37231 1562 15 than than IN 37231 1562 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1562 17 . . . 37231 1563 1 II ii CD 37231 1563 2 . . . 37231 1564 1 There there EX 37231 1564 2 was be VBD 37231 1564 3 hardly hardly RB 37231 1564 4 any any DT 37231 1564 5 people people NNS 37231 1564 6 in in IN 37231 1564 7 the the DT 37231 1564 8 whole whole JJ 37231 1564 9 world world NN 37231 1564 10 that that IN 37231 1564 11 more more RBR 37231 1564 12 used use VBN 37231 1564 13 , , , 37231 1564 14 or or CC 37231 1564 15 were be VBD 37231 1564 16 more more RBR 37231 1564 17 fond fond JJ 37231 1564 18 of of IN 37231 1564 19 , , , 37231 1564 20 amulets amulet NNS 37231 1564 21 , , , 37231 1564 22 charms charm NNS 37231 1564 23 , , , 37231 1564 24 mutterings muttering NNS 37231 1564 25 , , , 37231 1564 26 exorcisms exorcism NNS 37231 1564 27 , , , 37231 1564 28 and and CC 37231 1564 29 all all DT 37231 1564 30 kinds kind NNS 37231 1564 31 of of IN 37231 1564 32 enchantments enchantment NNS 37231 1564 33 . . . 37231 1565 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1565 2 might may MD 37231 1565 3 here here RB 37231 1565 4 produce produce VB 37231 1565 5 innumerable innumerable JJ 37231 1565 6 instances instance NNS 37231 1565 7 . . . 37231 1566 1 " " `` 37231 1566 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1566 3 3 3 LS 37231 1566 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1566 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1566 6 shall shall MD 37231 1566 7 presently presently RB 37231 1566 8 see see VB 37231 1566 9 that that IN 37231 1566 10 these these DT 37231 1566 11 statements statement NNS 37231 1566 12 are be VBP 37231 1566 13 far far RB 37231 1566 14 from from IN 37231 1566 15 being be VBG 37231 1566 16 exaggerated exaggerate VBN 37231 1566 17 . . . 37231 1567 1 No no DT 37231 1567 2 reader reader NN 37231 1567 3 of of IN 37231 1567 4 the the DT 37231 1567 5 Old Old NNP 37231 1567 6 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1567 7 can can MD 37231 1567 8 fail fail VB 37231 1567 9 to to TO 37231 1567 10 have have VB 37231 1567 11 been be VBN 37231 1567 12 struck strike VBN 37231 1567 13 by by IN 37231 1567 14 the the DT 37231 1567 15 singularly singularly RB 37231 1567 16 credulous credulous JJ 37231 1567 17 fickleness fickleness NN 37231 1567 18 of of IN 37231 1567 19 the the DT 37231 1567 20 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1567 21 mind mind NN 37231 1567 22 . . . 37231 1568 1 Although although IN 37231 1568 2 claiming claim VBG 37231 1568 3 the the DT 37231 1568 4 title title NN 37231 1568 5 of of IN 37231 1568 6 the the DT 37231 1568 7 specially specially RB 37231 1568 8 selected select VBN 37231 1568 9 people people NNS 37231 1568 10 of of IN 37231 1568 11 Jehovah Jehovah NNP 37231 1568 12 , , , 37231 1568 13 the the DT 37231 1568 14 Israelites Israelites NNPS 37231 1568 15 exhibited exhibit VBD 37231 1568 16 a a DT 37231 1568 17 constant constant JJ 37231 1568 18 and and CC 37231 1568 19 inveterate inveterate JJ 37231 1568 20 tendency tendency NN 37231 1568 21 to to TO 37231 1568 22 forsake forsake VB 37231 1568 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1568 24 service service NN 37231 1568 25 for for IN 37231 1568 26 the the DT 37231 1568 27 worship worship NN 37231 1568 28 of of IN 37231 1568 29 other other JJ 37231 1568 30 gods god NNS 37231 1568 31 . . . 37231 1569 1 The the DT 37231 1569 2 mighty mighty JJ 37231 1569 3 " " `` 37231 1569 4 signs sign NNS 37231 1569 5 and and CC 37231 1569 6 wonders wonder NNS 37231 1569 7 " " '' 37231 1569 8 which which WDT 37231 1569 9 God God NNP 37231 1569 10 is be VBZ 37231 1569 11 represented represent VBN 37231 1569 12 as as IN 37231 1569 13 incessantly incessantly RB 37231 1569 14 working work VBG 37231 1569 15 { { -LRB- 37231 1569 16 100 100 CD 37231 1569 17 } } -RRB- 37231 1569 18 on on IN 37231 1569 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1569 20 behalf behalf NN 37231 1569 21 , , , 37231 1569 22 and and CC 37231 1569 23 in in IN 37231 1569 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1569 25 sight sight NN 37231 1569 26 , , , 37231 1569 27 had have VBD 37231 1569 28 apparently apparently RB 37231 1569 29 no no DT 37231 1569 30 effect effect NN 37231 1569 31 upon upon IN 37231 1569 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1569 33 . . . 37231 1570 1 The the DT 37231 1570 2 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1570 3 even even RB 37231 1570 4 then then RB 37231 1570 5 had have VBD 37231 1570 6 , , , 37231 1570 7 as as IN 37231 1570 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1570 9 would would MD 37231 1570 10 seem seem VB 37231 1570 11 , , , 37231 1570 12 already already RB 37231 1570 13 lost lose VBN 37231 1570 14 all all DT 37231 1570 15 novelty novelty NN 37231 1570 16 , , , 37231 1570 17 and and CC 37231 1570 18 ceased cease VBD 37231 1570 19 , , , 37231 1570 20 according accord VBG 37231 1570 21 to to IN 37231 1570 22 the the DT 37231 1570 23 records record NNS 37231 1570 24 , , , 37231 1570 25 to to TO 37231 1570 26 excite excite VB 37231 1570 27 more more JJR 37231 1570 28 than than IN 37231 1570 29 mere mere JJ 37231 1570 30 passing pass VBG 37231 1570 31 astonishment astonishment NN 37231 1570 32 . . . 37231 1571 1 The the DT 37231 1571 2 leaders leader NNS 37231 1571 3 and and CC 37231 1571 4 prophets prophet NNS 37231 1571 5 of of IN 37231 1571 6 Israel Israel NNP 37231 1571 7 had have VBD 37231 1571 8 a a DT 37231 1571 9 perpetual perpetual JJ 37231 1571 10 struggle struggle NN 37231 1571 11 to to TO 37231 1571 12 restrain restrain VB 37231 1571 13 the the DT 37231 1571 14 people people NNS 37231 1571 15 from from IN 37231 1571 16 " " `` 37231 1571 17 following follow VBG 37231 1571 18 after after IN 37231 1571 19 " " `` 37231 1571 20 heathen heathen NNP 37231 1571 21 deities deity NNS 37231 1571 22 , , , 37231 1571 23 and and CC 37231 1571 24 whilst whilst IN 37231 1571 25 the the DT 37231 1571 26 burden burden NN 37231 1571 27 of of IN 37231 1571 28 the the DT 37231 1571 29 Prophets Prophets NNPS 37231 1571 30 is be VBZ 37231 1571 31 one one CD 37231 1571 32 grand grand JJ 37231 1571 33 denunciation denunciation NN 37231 1571 34 of of IN 37231 1571 35 the the DT 37231 1571 36 idolatry idolatry NN 37231 1571 37 into into IN 37231 1571 38 which which WDT 37231 1571 39 the the DT 37231 1571 40 nation nation NN 37231 1571 41 was be VBD 37231 1571 42 incessantly incessantly RB 37231 1571 43 falling fall VBG 37231 1571 44 , , , 37231 1571 45 the the DT 37231 1571 46 verdict verdict NN 37231 1571 47 of of IN 37231 1571 48 the the DT 37231 1571 49 historical historical JJ 37231 1571 50 books book NNS 37231 1571 51 upon upon IN 37231 1571 52 the the DT 37231 1571 53 several several JJ 37231 1571 54 kings king NNS 37231 1571 55 and and CC 37231 1571 56 rulers ruler NNS 37231 1571 57 of of IN 37231 1571 58 Israel Israel NNP 37231 1571 59 proves prove VBZ 37231 1571 60 how how WRB 37231 1571 61 common common JJ 37231 1571 62 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1571 63 was be VBD 37231 1571 64 , , , 37231 1571 65 and and CC 37231 1571 66 how how WRB 37231 1571 67 rare rare JJ 37231 1571 68 even even RB 37231 1571 69 the the DT 37231 1571 70 nominal nominal JJ 37231 1571 71 service service NN 37231 1571 72 of of IN 37231 1571 73 Jehovah Jehovah NNP 37231 1571 74 . . . 37231 1572 1 At at IN 37231 1572 2 the the DT 37231 1572 3 best good JJS 37231 1572 4 the the DT 37231 1572 5 mind mind NN 37231 1572 6 of of IN 37231 1572 7 the the DT 37231 1572 8 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1572 9 nation nation NN 37231 1572 10 only only RB 37231 1572 11 after after IN 37231 1572 12 long long JJ 37231 1572 13 and and CC 37231 1572 14 slow slow JJ 37231 1572 15 progression progression NN 37231 1572 16 , , , 37231 1572 17 attained attain VBD 37231 1572 18 the the DT 37231 1572 19 idea idea NN 37231 1572 20 of of IN 37231 1572 21 a a DT 37231 1572 22 perfect perfect JJ 37231 1572 23 monotheism monotheism NN 37231 1572 24 , , , 37231 1572 25 but but CC 37231 1572 26 added add VBD 37231 1572 27 to to IN 37231 1572 28 the the DT 37231 1572 29 belief belief NN 37231 1572 30 in in IN 37231 1572 31 Jehovah Jehovah NNP 37231 1572 32 the the DT 37231 1572 33 recognition recognition NN 37231 1572 34 of of IN 37231 1572 35 a a DT 37231 1572 36 host host NN 37231 1572 37 of of IN 37231 1572 38 other other JJ 37231 1572 39 gods god NNS 37231 1572 40 , , , 37231 1572 41 over over IN 37231 1572 42 whom whom WP 37231 1572 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1572 44 merely merely RB 37231 1572 45 gave give VBD 37231 1572 46 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1572 47 supremacy supremacy NN 37231 1572 48 . . . 37231 1573 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1573 2 1 1 LS 37231 1573 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1573 4 This this DT 37231 1573 5 is be VBZ 37231 1573 6 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1573 7 even even RB 37231 1573 8 in in IN 37231 1573 9 the the DT 37231 1573 10 first first JJ 37231 1573 11 commandment commandment NN 37231 1573 12 : : : 37231 1573 13 " " `` 37231 1573 14 Thou Thou NNP 37231 1573 15 shalt shalt NN 37231 1573 16 have have VBP 37231 1573 17 no no DT 37231 1573 18 other other JJ 37231 1573 19 gods god NNS 37231 1573 20 before before IN 37231 1573 21 me -PRON- PRP 37231 1573 22 ; ; : 37231 1573 23 " " `` 37231 1573 24 and and CC 37231 1573 25 the the DT 37231 1573 26 necessity necessity NN 37231 1573 27 for for IN 37231 1573 28 such such PDT 37231 1573 29 a a DT 37231 1573 30 law law NN 37231 1573 31 received receive VBD 37231 1573 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1573 33 illustration illustration NN 37231 1573 34 from from IN 37231 1573 35 a a DT 37231 1573 36 people people NNS 37231 1573 37 who who WP 37231 1573 38 are be VBP 37231 1573 39 represented represent VBN 37231 1573 40 as as IN 37231 1573 41 actually actually RB 37231 1573 42 worshipping worship VBG 37231 1573 43 the the DT 37231 1573 44 golden golden JJ 37231 1573 45 calf calf NN 37231 1573 46 , , , 37231 1573 47 made make VBN 37231 1573 48 for for IN 37231 1573 49 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1573 50 by by IN 37231 1573 51 the the DT 37231 1573 52 complaisant complaisant JJ 37231 1573 53 Aaron Aaron NNP 37231 1573 54 , , , 37231 1573 55 during during IN 37231 1573 56 the the DT 37231 1573 57 very very JJ 37231 1573 58 time time NN 37231 1573 59 that that IN 37231 1573 60 the the DT 37231 1573 61 great great JJ 37231 1573 62 Decalogue Decalogue NNP 37231 1573 63 was be VBD 37231 1573 64 being be VBG 37231 1573 65 written write VBN 37231 1573 66 on on IN 37231 1573 67 the the DT 37231 1573 68 Mount Mount NNP 37231 1573 69 by by IN 37231 1573 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1573 71 colleague colleague NN 37231 1573 72 Moses Moses NNP 37231 1573 73 . . . 37231 1574 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1574 2 2 2 LS 37231 1574 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1574 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1574 5 is be VBZ 37231 1574 6 not not RB 37231 1574 7 , , , 37231 1574 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 1574 9 , , , 37231 1574 10 to to TO 37231 1574 11 be be VB 37231 1574 12 wondered wonder VBN 37231 1574 13 at at IN 37231 1574 14 that that DT 37231 1574 15 , , , 37231 1574 16 at at IN 37231 1574 17 a a DT 37231 1574 18 later later JJ 37231 1574 19 period period NN 37231 1574 20 , , , 37231 1574 21 and and CC 37231 1574 22 throughout throughout IN 37231 1574 23 patristic patristic JJ 37231 1574 24 days day NNS 37231 1574 25 , , , 37231 1574 26 the the DT 37231 1574 27 gods god NNS 37231 1574 28 of of IN 37231 1574 29 the the DT 37231 1574 30 Greeks Greeks NNPS 37231 1574 31 and and CC 37231 1574 32 other other JJ 37231 1574 33 heathen heathen NNP 37231 1574 34 nations nation NNS 37231 1574 35 were be VBD 37231 1574 36 so so RB 37231 1574 37 far far RB 37231 1574 38 gently gently RB 37231 1574 39 treated treat VBN 37231 1574 40 , , , 37231 1574 41 that that IN 37231 1574 42 , , , 37231 1574 43 although although IN 37231 1574 44 repudiated repudiate VBN 37231 1574 45 as as IN 37231 1574 46 Deities deity NNS 37231 1574 47 , , , 37231 1574 48 { { -LRB- 37231 1574 49 101 101 CD 37231 1574 50 } } -RRB- 37231 1574 51 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1574 52 were be VBD 37231 1574 53 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1574 54 as as IN 37231 1574 55 Demons demon NNS 37231 1574 56 . . . 37231 1575 1 In in IN 37231 1575 2 the the DT 37231 1575 3 Septuagint Septuagint NNP 37231 1575 4 version version NN 37231 1575 5 of of IN 37231 1575 6 the the DT 37231 1575 7 Old Old NNP 37231 1575 8 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1575 9 , , , 37231 1575 10 where where WRB 37231 1575 11 " " `` 37231 1575 12 idols idol NNS 37231 1575 13 " " '' 37231 1575 14 are be VBP 37231 1575 15 spoken speak VBN 37231 1575 16 of of IN 37231 1575 17 in in IN 37231 1575 18 the the DT 37231 1575 19 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 1575 20 , , , 37231 1575 21 the the DT 37231 1575 22 word word NN 37231 1575 23 is be VBZ 37231 1575 24 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1575 25 translated translate VBN 37231 1575 26 " " '' 37231 1575 27 demons demon NNS 37231 1575 28 ; ; : 37231 1575 29 " " '' 37231 1575 30 as as IN 37231 1575 31 , , , 37231 1575 32 for for IN 37231 1575 33 instance instance NN 37231 1575 34 , , , 37231 1575 35 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 1575 36 xcvi xcvi NNP 37231 1575 37 . . . 37231 1576 1 5 5 CD 37231 1576 2 is be VBZ 37231 1576 3 rendered render VBN 37231 1576 4 : : : 37231 1576 5 " " `` 37231 1576 6 For for IN 37231 1576 7 all all PDT 37231 1576 8 the the DT 37231 1576 9 gods god NNS 37231 1576 10 of of IN 37231 1576 11 the the DT 37231 1576 12 nations nation NNS 37231 1576 13 are be VBP 37231 1576 14 demons demon NNS 37231 1576 15 . . . 37231 1577 1 " " `` 37231 1577 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1577 3 l l NN 37231 1577 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1577 5 The the DT 37231 1577 6 national national JJ 37231 1577 7 superstition superstition NN 37231 1577 8 betrays betray VBZ 37231 1577 9 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1577 10 in in IN 37231 1577 11 this this DT 37231 1577 12 and and CC 37231 1577 13 many many JJ 37231 1577 14 other other JJ 37231 1577 15 passages passage NNS 37231 1577 16 of of IN 37231 1577 17 this this DT 37231 1577 18 version version NN 37231 1577 19 , , , 37231 1577 20 which which WDT 37231 1577 21 so so RB 37231 1577 22 well well RB 37231 1577 23 represented represent VBD 37231 1577 24 the the DT 37231 1577 25 views view NNS 37231 1577 26 of of IN 37231 1577 27 the the DT 37231 1577 28 first first JJ 37231 1577 29 ages age NNS 37231 1577 30 of of IN 37231 1577 31 the the DT 37231 1577 32 Church Church NNP 37231 1577 33 that that WDT 37231 1577 34 the the DT 37231 1577 35 Fathers father NNS 37231 1577 36 regarded regard VBD 37231 1577 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1577 38 as as RB 37231 1577 39 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1577 40 . . . 37231 1578 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 1578 2 relates relate VBZ 37231 1578 3 how how WRB 37231 1578 4 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 37231 1578 5 , , , 37231 1578 6 the the DT 37231 1578 7 son son NN 37231 1578 8 of of IN 37231 1578 9 Lagus Lagus NNP 37231 1578 10 , , , 37231 1578 11 brought bring VBD 37231 1578 12 seventy seventy CD 37231 1578 13 of of IN 37231 1578 14 the the DT 37231 1578 15 elders elder NNS 37231 1578 16 of of IN 37231 1578 17 the the DT 37231 1578 18 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1578 19 together together RB 37231 1578 20 to to IN 37231 1578 21 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 1578 22 in in IN 37231 1578 23 order order NN 37231 1578 24 to to TO 37231 1578 25 translate translate VB 37231 1578 26 the the DT 37231 1578 27 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 1578 28 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 37231 1578 29 into into IN 37231 1578 30 Greek Greek NNP 37231 1578 31 , , , 37231 1578 32 but but CC 37231 1578 33 fearing fear VBG 37231 1578 34 that that IN 37231 1578 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1578 36 might may MD 37231 1578 37 agree agree VB 37231 1578 38 amongst amongst IN 37231 1578 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1578 40 to to TO 37231 1578 41 conceal conceal VB 37231 1578 42 the the DT 37231 1578 43 real real JJ 37231 1578 44 meaning meaning NN 37231 1578 45 of of IN 37231 1578 46 the the DT 37231 1578 47 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 1578 48 , , , 37231 1578 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1578 50 separated separate VBD 37231 1578 51 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1578 52 , , , 37231 1578 53 and and CC 37231 1578 54 commanded command VBD 37231 1578 55 each each DT 37231 1578 56 to to TO 37231 1578 57 make make VB 37231 1578 58 a a DT 37231 1578 59 translation translation NN 37231 1578 60 . . . 37231 1579 1 When when WRB 37231 1579 2 the the DT 37231 1579 3 seventy seventy CD 37231 1579 4 translations translation NNS 37231 1579 5 of of IN 37231 1579 6 the the DT 37231 1579 7 Bible Bible NNP 37231 1579 8 were be VBD 37231 1579 9 completed complete VBN 37231 1579 10 and and CC 37231 1579 11 compared compare VBN 37231 1579 12 , , , 37231 1579 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1579 14 was be VBD 37231 1579 15 found find VBN 37231 1579 16 that that IN 37231 1579 17 , , , 37231 1579 18 by by IN 37231 1579 19 the the DT 37231 1579 20 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 1579 21 of of IN 37231 1579 22 God God NNP 37231 1579 23 , , , 37231 1579 24 the the DT 37231 1579 25 very very RB 37231 1579 26 same same JJ 37231 1579 27 words word NNS 37231 1579 28 and and CC 37231 1579 29 the the DT 37231 1579 30 very very RB 37231 1579 31 same same JJ 37231 1579 32 names name NNS 37231 1579 33 from from IN 37231 1579 34 beginning begin VBG 37231 1579 35 to to IN 37231 1579 36 end end NN 37231 1579 37 had have VBD 37231 1579 38 been be VBN 37231 1579 39 used use VBN 37231 1579 40 by by IN 37231 1579 41 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1579 42 all all DT 37231 1579 43 . . . 37231 1580 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1580 2 2 2 LS 37231 1580 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1580 4 The the DT 37231 1580 5 same same JJ 37231 1580 6 superstition superstition NN 37231 1580 7 is be VBZ 37231 1580 8 quite quite RB 37231 1580 9 as as RB 37231 1580 10 clearly clearly RB 37231 1580 11 expressed express VBN 37231 1580 12 in in IN 37231 1580 13 the the DT 37231 1580 14 New New NNP 37231 1580 15 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1580 16 . . . 37231 1581 1 The the DT 37231 1581 2 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 1581 3 Paul Paul NNP 37231 1581 4 , , , 37231 1581 5 for for IN 37231 1581 6 instance instance NN 37231 1581 7 , , , 37231 1581 8 speaking speak VBG 37231 1581 9 of of IN 37231 1581 10 things thing NNS 37231 1581 11 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 37231 1581 12 to to IN 37231 1581 13 idols idol NNS 37231 1581 14 , , , 37231 1581 15 says say VBZ 37231 1581 16 : : : 37231 1581 17 " " `` 37231 1581 18 But but CC 37231 1581 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1581 20 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1581 21 say say VBP 37231 1581 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1581 23 that that IN 37231 1581 24 the the DT 37231 1581 25 things thing NNS 37231 1581 26 which which WDT 37231 1581 27 the the DT 37231 1581 28 Gentiles Gentiles NNP 37231 1581 29 sacrifice sacrifice NN 37231 1581 30 , , , 37231 1581 31 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1581 32 sacrifice sacrifice VBP 37231 1581 33 to to IN 37231 1581 34 demons demon NNS 37231 1581 35 , , , 37231 1581 36 and and CC 37231 1581 37 not not RB 37231 1581 38 to to IN 37231 1581 39 God God NNP 37231 1581 40 ; ; : 37231 1581 41 and and CC 37231 1581 42 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1581 43 would would MD 37231 1581 44 not not RB 37231 1581 45 that that IN 37231 1581 46 ye ye NNP 37231 1581 47 should should MD 37231 1581 48 be be VB 37231 1581 49 partakers partaker NNS 37231 1581 50 with with IN 37231 1581 51 { { -LRB- 37231 1581 52 102 102 CD 37231 1581 53 } } -RRB- 37231 1581 54 demons demon NNS 37231 1581 55 . . . 37231 1582 1 Ye Ye NNP 37231 1582 2 can can MD 37231 1582 3 not not RB 37231 1582 4 drink drink VB 37231 1582 5 the the DT 37231 1582 6 cup cup NN 37231 1582 7 of of IN 37231 1582 8 the the DT 37231 1582 9 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1582 10 , , , 37231 1582 11 and and CC 37231 1582 12 the the DT 37231 1582 13 cup cup NN 37231 1582 14 of of IN 37231 1582 15 demons demon NNS 37231 1582 16 ; ; : 37231 1582 17 ye ye NNP 37231 1582 18 can can MD 37231 1582 19 not not RB 37231 1582 20 partake partake VB 37231 1582 21 of of IN 37231 1582 22 the the DT 37231 1582 23 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1582 24 's 's POS 37231 1582 25 table table NN 37231 1582 26 , , , 37231 1582 27 and and CC 37231 1582 28 of of IN 37231 1582 29 the the DT 37231 1582 30 table table NN 37231 1582 31 of of IN 37231 1582 32 demons demon NNS 37231 1582 33 . . . 37231 1583 1 " " `` 37231 1583 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1583 3 l l NN 37231 1583 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1583 5 The the DT 37231 1583 6 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 1583 7 Book Book NNP 37231 1583 8 of of IN 37231 1583 9 Tobit Tobit NNP 37231 1583 10 affords afford VBZ 37231 1583 11 some some DT 37231 1583 12 illustration illustration NN 37231 1583 13 of of IN 37231 1583 14 the the DT 37231 1583 15 opinions opinion NNS 37231 1583 16 of of IN 37231 1583 17 the the DT 37231 1583 18 more more RBR 37231 1583 19 enlightened enlightened JJ 37231 1583 20 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1583 21 during during IN 37231 1583 22 the the DT 37231 1583 23 last last JJ 37231 1583 24 century century NN 37231 1583 25 before before IN 37231 1583 26 the the DT 37231 1583 27 commencement commencement NN 37231 1583 28 of of IN 37231 1583 29 the the DT 37231 1583 30 Christian christian JJ 37231 1583 31 era era NN 37231 1583 32 . . . 37231 1584 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1584 2 2 2 LS 37231 1584 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1584 4 The the DT 37231 1584 5 angel angel NN 37231 1584 6 Raphael Raphael NNP 37231 1584 7 prescribes prescribe VBZ 37231 1584 8 , , , 37231 1584 9 as as IN 37231 1584 10 an an DT 37231 1584 11 infallible infallible JJ 37231 1584 12 means mean NNS 37231 1584 13 of of IN 37231 1584 14 driving drive VBG 37231 1584 15 a a DT 37231 1584 16 demon demon NN 37231 1584 17 out out IN 37231 1584 18 of of IN 37231 1584 19 man man NN 37231 1584 20 or or CC 37231 1584 21 woman woman NN 37231 1584 22 so so RB 37231 1584 23 effectually effectually RB 37231 1584 24 that that IN 37231 1584 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1584 26 should should MD 37231 1584 27 never never RB 37231 1584 28 more more RBR 37231 1584 29 come come VB 37231 1584 30 back back RB 37231 1584 31 , , , 37231 1584 32 fumigation fumigation NN 37231 1584 33 with with IN 37231 1584 34 the the DT 37231 1584 35 heart heart NN 37231 1584 36 and and CC 37231 1584 37 liver liver NN 37231 1584 38 of of IN 37231 1584 39 a a DT 37231 1584 40 fish fish NN 37231 1584 41 . . . 37231 1585 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1585 2 3 3 LS 37231 1585 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1585 4 By by IN 37231 1585 5 this this DT 37231 1585 6 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1585 7 the the DT 37231 1585 8 demon demon NN 37231 1585 9 Asmodeus Asmodeus NNP 37231 1585 10 , , , 37231 1585 11 who who WP 37231 1585 12 from from IN 37231 1585 13 love love NN 37231 1585 14 of of IN 37231 1585 15 Sara Sara NNP 37231 1585 16 , , , 37231 1585 17 the the DT 37231 1585 18 daughter daughter NN 37231 1585 19 of of IN 37231 1585 20 Raguel Raguel NNP 37231 1585 21 , , , 37231 1585 22 has have VBZ 37231 1585 23 strangled strangle VBN 37231 1585 24 seven seven CD 37231 1585 25 husbands husband NNS 37231 1585 26 who who WP 37231 1585 27 attempted attempt VBD 37231 1585 28 to to TO 37231 1585 29 marry marry VB 37231 1585 30 her,(4 her,(4 NNP 37231 1585 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1585 32 is be VBZ 37231 1585 33 overcome overcome VBN 37231 1585 34 , , , 37231 1585 35 and and CC 37231 1585 36 flies fly VBZ 37231 1585 37 into into IN 37231 1585 38 " " `` 37231 1585 39 the the DT 37231 1585 40 uttermost uttermost NN 37231 1585 41 parts part NNS 37231 1585 42 of of IN 37231 1585 43 Egypt Egypt NNP 37231 1585 44 , , , 37231 1585 45 " " `` 37231 1585 46 where where WRB 37231 1585 47 the the DT 37231 1585 48 angel angel NN 37231 1585 49 binds bind VBZ 37231 1585 50 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1585 51 . . . 37231 1586 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1586 2 5 5 LS 37231 1586 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1586 4 The the DT 37231 1586 5 belief belief NN 37231 1586 6 in in IN 37231 1586 7 demons demon NNS 37231 1586 8 , , , 37231 1586 9 and and CC 37231 1586 10 in in IN 37231 1586 11 the the DT 37231 1586 12 necessity necessity NN 37231 1586 13 of of IN 37231 1586 14 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1586 15 , , , 37231 1586 16 is be VBZ 37231 1586 17 so so RB 37231 1586 18 complete complete JJ 37231 1586 19 that that IN 37231 1586 20 the the DT 37231 1586 21 author author NN 37231 1586 22 sees see VBZ 37231 1586 23 no no DT 37231 1586 24 incongruity incongruity NN 37231 1586 25 in in IN 37231 1586 26 describing describe VBG 37231 1586 27 the the DT 37231 1586 28 angel angel NN 37231 1586 29 Raphael Raphael NNP 37231 1586 30 , , , 37231 1586 31 who who WP 37231 1586 32 has have VBZ 37231 1586 33 been be VBN 37231 1586 34 sent send VBN 37231 1586 35 , , , 37231 1586 36 in in IN 37231 1586 37 answer answer NN 37231 1586 38 to to IN 37231 1586 39 prayer prayer NN 37231 1586 40 , , , 37231 1586 41 specially specially RB 37231 1586 42 to to TO 37231 1586 43 help help VB 37231 1586 44 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1586 45 , , , 37231 1586 46 as as IN 37231 1586 47 instructing instruct VBG 37231 1586 48 Tobias Tobias NNP 37231 1586 49 to to TO 37231 1586 50 adopt adopt VB 37231 1586 51 such such JJ 37231 1586 52 means mean NNS 37231 1586 53 of of IN 37231 1586 54 subjecting subject VBG 37231 1586 55 demons demon NNS 37231 1586 56 . . . 37231 1587 1 Raphael Raphael NNP 37231 1587 2 is be VBZ 37231 1587 3 described describe VBN 37231 1587 4 in in IN 37231 1587 5 this this DT 37231 1587 6 book book NN 37231 1587 7 as as IN 37231 1587 8 the the DT 37231 1587 9 angel angel NN 37231 1587 10 of of IN 37231 1587 11 healing,(6 healing,(6 NNP 37231 1587 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1587 13 the the DT 37231 1587 14 office office NN 37231 1587 15 generally generally RB 37231 1587 16 assigned assign VBN 37231 1587 17 to to IN 37231 1587 18 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1587 19 by by IN 37231 1587 20 the the DT 37231 1587 21 Fathers father NNS 37231 1587 22 . . . 37231 1588 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1588 2 is be VBZ 37231 1588 3 also also RB 37231 1588 4 represented represent VBN 37231 1588 5 as as IN 37231 1588 6 saying say VBG 37231 1588 7 of of IN 37231 1588 8 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1588 9 that that IN 37231 1588 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1588 11 is be VBZ 37231 1588 12 one one CD 37231 1588 13 of of IN 37231 1588 14 the the DT 37231 1588 15 seven seven CD 37231 1588 16 holy holy JJ 37231 1588 17 angels angel NNS 37231 1588 18 which which WDT 37231 1588 19 present present VBP 37231 1588 20 the the DT 37231 1588 21 prayers prayer NNS 37231 1588 22 of of IN 37231 1588 23 the the DT 37231 1588 24 saints saint NNS 37231 1588 25 to to IN 37231 1588 26 God God NNP 37231 1588 27 . . . 37231 1589 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1589 2 7 7 LS 37231 1589 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1589 4 { { -LRB- 37231 1589 5 103 103 CD 37231 1589 6 } } -RRB- 37231 1589 7 There there EX 37231 1589 8 are be VBP 37231 1589 9 many many JJ 37231 1589 10 curious curious JJ 37231 1589 11 particulars particular NNS 37231 1589 12 regarding regard VBG 37231 1589 13 angels angel NNS 37231 1589 14 and and CC 37231 1589 15 demons demon NNS 37231 1589 16 in in IN 37231 1589 17 the the DT 37231 1589 18 Book Book NNP 37231 1589 19 of of IN 37231 1589 20 Enoch Enoch NNP 37231 1589 21 . . . 37231 1590 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1590 2 1 1 LS 37231 1590 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1590 4 This this DT 37231 1590 5 work work NN 37231 1590 6 , , , 37231 1590 7 which which WDT 37231 1590 8 is be VBZ 37231 1590 9 quoted quote VBN 37231 1590 10 by by IN 37231 1590 11 the the DT 37231 1590 12 author author NN 37231 1590 13 of of IN 37231 1590 14 the the DT 37231 1590 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 1590 16 of of IN 37231 1590 17 Jude,(2 Jude,(2 NNP 37231 1590 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1590 19 and and CC 37231 1590 20 by by IN 37231 1590 21 some some DT 37231 1590 22 of of IN 37231 1590 23 the the DT 37231 1590 24 Fathers father NNS 37231 1590 25 , , , 37231 1590 26 as as IN 37231 1590 27 inspired inspire VBN 37231 1590 28 Scripture,(3 Scripture,(3 NNP 37231 1590 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1590 30 was be VBD 37231 1590 31 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1590 32 by by IN 37231 1590 33 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 1590 34 to to TO 37231 1590 35 have have VB 37231 1590 36 survived survive VBN 37231 1590 37 the the DT 37231 1590 38 universal universal JJ 37231 1590 39 deluge deluge NN 37231 1590 40 , , , 37231 1590 41 or or CC 37231 1590 42 to to TO 37231 1590 43 have have VB 37231 1590 44 been be VBN 37231 1590 45 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 1590 46 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 1590 47 by by IN 37231 1590 48 means mean NNS 37231 1590 49 of of IN 37231 1590 50 Noah Noah NNP 37231 1590 51 , , , 37231 1590 52 the the DT 37231 1590 53 great great JJ 37231 1590 54 - - HYPH 37231 1590 55 grandson grandson NN 37231 1590 56 of of IN 37231 1590 57 the the DT 37231 1590 58 author author NN 37231 1590 59 Enoch Enoch NNP 37231 1590 60 . . . 37231 1591 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1591 2 4 4 LS 37231 1591 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1591 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1591 5 may may MD 37231 1591 6 be be VB 37231 1591 7 assigned assign VBN 37231 1591 8 to to IN 37231 1591 9 about about IN 37231 1591 10 a a DT 37231 1591 11 century century NN 37231 1591 12 before before IN 37231 1591 13 Christ Christ NNP 37231 1591 14 , , , 37231 1591 15 but but CC 37231 1591 16 additions addition NNS 37231 1591 17 were be VBD 37231 1591 18 made make VBN 37231 1591 19 to to IN 37231 1591 20 the the DT 37231 1591 21 text text NN 37231 1591 22 , , , 37231 1591 23 and and CC 37231 1591 24 more more RBR 37231 1591 25 especially especially RB 37231 1591 26 to to IN 37231 1591 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1591 28 angelology angelology NN 37231 1591 29 , , , 37231 1591 30 extending extend VBG 37231 1591 31 probably probably RB 37231 1591 32 to to TO 37231 1591 33 after after IN 37231 1591 34 the the DT 37231 1591 35 commencement commencement NN 37231 1591 36 of of IN 37231 1591 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1591 38 era era NN 37231 1591 39 . . . 37231 1592 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1592 2 5 5 LS 37231 1592 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1592 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1592 5 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 37231 1592 6 represents represent VBZ 37231 1592 7 views view NNS 37231 1592 8 popularly popularly RB 37231 1592 9 prevailing prevail VBG 37231 1592 10 about about IN 37231 1592 11 the the DT 37231 1592 12 epoch epoch NN 37231 1592 13 in in IN 37231 1592 14 which which WDT 37231 1592 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1592 16 are be VBP 37231 1592 17 interested interested JJ 37231 1592 18 . . . 37231 1593 1 The the DT 37231 1593 2 author author NN 37231 1593 3 not not RB 37231 1593 4 only only RB 37231 1593 5 relates relate VBZ 37231 1593 6 the the DT 37231 1593 7 fall fall NN 37231 1593 8 of of IN 37231 1593 9 the the DT 37231 1593 10 angels angel NNS 37231 1593 11 through through IN 37231 1593 12 love love NN 37231 1593 13 for for IN 37231 1593 14 the the DT 37231 1593 15 daughters daughter NNS 37231 1593 16 of of IN 37231 1593 17 men man NNS 37231 1593 18 , , , 37231 1593 19 but but CC 37231 1593 20 gives give VBZ 37231 1593 21 the the DT 37231 1593 22 names name NNS 37231 1593 23 of of IN 37231 1593 24 twenty twenty CD 37231 1593 25 - - HYPH 37231 1593 26 one one CD 37231 1593 27 of of IN 37231 1593 28 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1593 29 and and CC 37231 1593 30 of of IN 37231 1593 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1593 32 leaders leader NNS 37231 1593 33 ; ; : 37231 1593 34 of of IN 37231 1593 35 whom whom WP 37231 1593 36 Jequn Jequn NNP 37231 1593 37 was be VBD 37231 1593 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1593 39 who who WP 37231 1593 40 seduced seduce VBD 37231 1593 41 the the DT 37231 1593 42 holy holy JJ 37231 1593 43 angels angel NNS 37231 1593 44 , , , 37231 1593 45 and and CC 37231 1593 46 Ashbeêl Ashbeêl NNP 37231 1593 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1593 48 was be VBD 37231 1593 49 who who WP 37231 1593 50 gave give VBD 37231 1593 51 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1593 52 evil evil JJ 37231 1593 53 counsel counsel NN 37231 1593 54 and and CC 37231 1593 55 corrupted corrupt VBD 37231 1593 56 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1593 57 . . . 37231 1594 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1594 2 6 6 LS 37231 1594 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1594 4 A a DT 37231 1594 5 third third JJ 37231 1594 6 , , , 37231 1594 7 Gadreel,(7 Gadreel,(7 NNP 37231 1594 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1594 9 was be VBD 37231 1594 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1594 11 who who WP 37231 1594 12 seduced seduce VBD 37231 1594 13 Eve Eve NNP 37231 1594 14 . . . 37231 1595 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1595 2 also also RB 37231 1595 3 taught teach VBD 37231 1595 4 to to IN 37231 1595 5 the the DT 37231 1595 6 children child NNS 37231 1595 7 of of IN 37231 1595 8 men man NNS 37231 1595 9 the the DT 37231 1595 10 use use NN 37231 1595 11 and and CC 37231 1595 12 manufacture manufacture NN 37231 1595 13 of of IN 37231 1595 14 all all DT 37231 1595 15 murderous murderous JJ 37231 1595 16 weapons weapon NNS 37231 1595 17 , , , 37231 1595 18 of of IN 37231 1595 19 coats coat NNS 37231 1595 20 of of IN 37231 1595 21 mail mail NN 37231 1595 22 , , , 37231 1595 23 shields shield NNS 37231 1595 24 , , , 37231 1595 25 { { -LRB- 37231 1595 26 104 104 CD 37231 1595 27 } } -RRB- 37231 1595 28 swords sword NNS 37231 1595 29 , , , 37231 1595 30 and and CC 37231 1595 31 of of IN 37231 1595 32 all all PDT 37231 1595 33 the the DT 37231 1595 34 implements implement NNS 37231 1595 35 of of IN 37231 1595 36 death death NN 37231 1595 37 . . . 37231 1596 1 Another another DT 37231 1596 2 evil evil JJ 37231 1596 3 angel angel NN 37231 1596 4 , , , 37231 1596 5 named name VBN 37231 1596 6 Pênêmuê Pênêmuê NNP 37231 1596 7 , , , 37231 1596 8 taught teach VBD 37231 1596 9 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1596 10 many many JJ 37231 1596 11 mysteries mystery NNS 37231 1596 12 of of IN 37231 1596 13 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1596 14 . . . 37231 1597 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1597 2 instructed instruct VBD 37231 1597 3 men man NNS 37231 1597 4 in in IN 37231 1597 5 the the DT 37231 1597 6 art art NN 37231 1597 7 of of IN 37231 1597 8 writing write VBG 37231 1597 9 with with IN 37231 1597 10 paper paper NN 37231 1597 11 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1597 12 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1597 13 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1597 14 and and CC 37231 1597 15 ink ink VB 37231 1597 16 , , , 37231 1597 17 by by IN 37231 1597 18 means mean NNS 37231 1597 19 of of IN 37231 1597 20 which which WDT 37231 1597 21 , , , 37231 1597 22 the the DT 37231 1597 23 author author NN 37231 1597 24 remarks remark VBZ 37231 1597 25 , , , 37231 1597 26 many many JJ 37231 1597 27 fall fall VBP 37231 1597 28 into into IN 37231 1597 29 sin sin NN 37231 1597 30 even even RB 37231 1597 31 to to IN 37231 1597 32 the the DT 37231 1597 33 present present JJ 37231 1597 34 day day NN 37231 1597 35 . . . 37231 1598 1 Kaodejâ kaodejâ UH 37231 1598 2 , , , 37231 1598 3 another another DT 37231 1598 4 evil evil JJ 37231 1598 5 angel angel NN 37231 1598 6 , , , 37231 1598 7 taught teach VBD 37231 1598 8 the the DT 37231 1598 9 human human JJ 37231 1598 10 race race NN 37231 1598 11 all all PDT 37231 1598 12 the the DT 37231 1598 13 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1598 14 practices practice NNS 37231 1598 15 of of IN 37231 1598 16 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1598 17 and and CC 37231 1598 18 demons,(1 demons,(1 NNP 37231 1598 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1598 20 and and CC 37231 1598 21 also also RB 37231 1598 22 magic magic NN 37231 1598 23 and and CC 37231 1598 24 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1598 25 . . . 37231 1599 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1599 2 2 2 LS 37231 1599 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1599 4 The the DT 37231 1599 5 offspring offspring NN 37231 1599 6 of of IN 37231 1599 7 the the DT 37231 1599 8 fallen fall VBN 37231 1599 9 angels angel NNS 37231 1599 10 and and CC 37231 1599 11 of of IN 37231 1599 12 the the DT 37231 1599 13 daughters daughter NNS 37231 1599 14 of of IN 37231 1599 15 men man NNS 37231 1599 16 were be VBD 37231 1599 17 giants giant NNS 37231 1599 18 , , , 37231 1599 19 whose whose WP$ 37231 1599 20 height height NN 37231 1599 21 was be VBD 37231 1599 22 3000 3000 CD 37231 1599 23 ells;(3 ells;(3 RB 37231 1599 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1599 25 of of IN 37231 1599 26 these these DT 37231 1599 27 are be VBP 37231 1599 28 the the DT 37231 1599 29 demons demon NNS 37231 1599 30 working work VBG 37231 1599 31 evil evil NN 37231 1599 32 upon upon IN 37231 1599 33 earth earth NN 37231 1599 34 . . . 37231 1600 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1600 2 4 4 LS 37231 1600 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1600 4 Azazel Azazel NNP 37231 1600 5 taught teach VBD 37231 1600 6 men man NNS 37231 1600 7 various various JJ 37231 1600 8 arts art NNS 37231 1600 9 : : : 37231 1600 10 the the DT 37231 1600 11 making making NN 37231 1600 12 of of IN 37231 1600 13 bracelets bracelet NNS 37231 1600 14 and and CC 37231 1600 15 ornaments ornament NNS 37231 1600 16 ; ; : 37231 1600 17 the the DT 37231 1600 18 use use NN 37231 1600 19 of of IN 37231 1600 20 cosmetics cosmetic NNS 37231 1600 21 , , , 37231 1600 22 the the DT 37231 1600 23 way way NN 37231 1600 24 to to TO 37231 1600 25 beautify beautify VB 37231 1600 26 the the DT 37231 1600 27 eyebrows eyebrow NNS 37231 1600 28 ; ; : 37231 1600 29 precious precious JJ 37231 1600 30 stones stone NNS 37231 1600 31 , , , 37231 1600 32 and and CC 37231 1600 33 all all DT 37231 1600 34 dye dye NN 37231 1600 35 - - HYPH 37231 1600 36 stuffs stuff NNS 37231 1600 37 and and CC 37231 1600 38 metals metal NNS 37231 1600 39 ; ; , 37231 1600 40 whilst whilst IN 37231 1600 41 other other JJ 37231 1600 42 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1600 43 angels angel NNS 37231 1600 44 instructed instruct VBD 37231 1600 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1600 46 in in IN 37231 1600 47 all all DT 37231 1600 48 kinds kind NNS 37231 1600 49 of of IN 37231 1600 50 pernicious pernicious JJ 37231 1600 51 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1600 52 . . . 37231 1601 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1601 2 5 5 LS 37231 1601 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1601 4 The the DT 37231 1601 5 elements element NNS 37231 1601 6 and and CC 37231 1601 7 all all PDT 37231 1601 8 the the DT 37231 1601 9 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1601 10 of of IN 37231 1601 11 nature nature NN 37231 1601 12 are be VBP 37231 1601 13 controlled control VBN 37231 1601 14 and and CC 37231 1601 15 produced produce VBN 37231 1601 16 by by IN 37231 1601 17 the the DT 37231 1601 18 agency agency NN 37231 1601 19 of of IN 37231 1601 20 angels angel NNS 37231 1601 21 . . . 37231 1602 1 Uriel Uriel NNP 37231 1602 2 is be VBZ 37231 1602 3 the the DT 37231 1602 4 angel angel NN 37231 1602 5 of of IN 37231 1602 6 thunder thunder NN 37231 1602 7 and and CC 37231 1602 8 earthquakes earthquake NNS 37231 1602 9 ; ; : 37231 1602 10 Raphael Raphael NNP 37231 1602 11 , , , 37231 1602 12 of of IN 37231 1602 13 the the DT 37231 1602 14 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1602 15 of of IN 37231 1602 16 men man NNS 37231 1602 17 ; ; : 37231 1602 18 Raguel Raguel NNP 37231 1602 19 is be VBZ 37231 1602 20 the the DT 37231 1602 21 angel angel NN 37231 1602 22 who who WP 37231 1602 23 executes execute VBZ 37231 1602 24 vengeance vengeance NN 37231 1602 25 on on IN 37231 1602 26 the the DT 37231 1602 27 world world NN 37231 1602 28 and and CC 37231 1602 29 the the DT 37231 1602 30 stars star NNS 37231 1602 31 ; ; : 37231 1602 32 Michael Michael NNP 37231 1602 33 is be VBZ 37231 1602 34 set set VBN 37231 1602 35 over over IN 37231 1602 36 the the DT 37231 1602 37 best good JJS 37231 1602 38 of of IN 37231 1602 39 mankind mankind NN 37231 1602 40 , , , 37231 1602 41 i.e. i.e. FW 37231 1602 42 , , , 37231 1602 43 over over IN 37231 1602 44 the the DT 37231 1602 45 people people NNS 37231 1602 46 of of IN 37231 1602 47 Israel;(6 Israel;(6 NNP 37231 1602 48 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1602 49 Saraqâel Saraqâel NNP 37231 1602 50 , , , 37231 1602 51 over over IN 37231 1602 52 the the DT 37231 1602 53 souls soul NNS 37231 1602 54 of of IN 37231 1602 55 the the DT 37231 1602 56 children child NNS 37231 1602 57 of of IN 37231 1602 58 men man NNS 37231 1602 59 , , , 37231 1602 60 who who WP 37231 1602 61 are be VBP 37231 1602 62 misled mislead VBN 37231 1602 63 by by IN 37231 1602 64 the the DT 37231 1602 65 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1602 66 of of IN 37231 1602 67 sin sin NN 37231 1602 68 ; ; : 37231 1602 69 and and CC 37231 1602 70 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 1602 71 is be VBZ 37231 1602 72 over over IN 37231 1602 73 serpents serpent NNS 37231 1602 74 and and CC 37231 1602 75 over over IN 37231 1602 76 Paradise Paradise NNP 37231 1602 77 , , , 37231 1602 78 and and CC 37231 1602 79 over over IN 37231 1602 80 the the DT 37231 1602 81 Cherubim Cherubim NNP 37231 1602 82 . . . 37231 1603 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1603 2 7 7 LS 37231 1603 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1603 4 Enoch Enoch NNP 37231 1603 5 is be VBZ 37231 1603 6 shown show VBN 37231 1603 7 the the DT 37231 1603 8 mystery mystery NN 37231 1603 9 of of IN 37231 1603 10 all all PDT 37231 1603 11 the the DT 37231 1603 12 operations operation NNS 37231 1603 13 of of IN 37231 1603 14 nature nature NN 37231 1603 15 , , , 37231 1603 16 and and CC 37231 1603 17 the the DT 37231 1603 18 action action NN 37231 1603 19 of of IN 37231 1603 20 the the DT 37231 1603 21 elements element NNS 37231 1603 22 , , , 37231 1603 23 and and CC 37231 1603 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1603 25 describes describe VBZ 37231 1603 26 the the DT 37231 1603 27 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1603 28 which which WDT 37231 1603 29 guide guide VBP 37231 1603 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1603 31 , , , 37231 1603 32 and and CC 37231 1603 33 control control VB 37231 1603 34 the the DT 37231 1603 35 thunder thunder NN 37231 1603 36 and and CC 37231 1603 37 lightning lightning NN 37231 1603 38 and and CC 37231 1603 39 the the DT 37231 1603 40 winds wind NNS 37231 1603 41 ; ; : 37231 1603 42 the the DT 37231 1603 43 spirit spirit NN 37231 1603 44 of of IN 37231 1603 45 the the DT 37231 1603 46 seas sea NNS 37231 1603 47 , , , 37231 1603 48 who who WP 37231 1603 49 curbs curb VBZ 37231 1603 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1603 51 with with IN 37231 1603 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1603 53 might might NN 37231 1603 54 , , , 37231 1603 55 or or CC 37231 1603 56 tosses toss VBZ 37231 1603 57 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1603 58 forth forth RB 37231 1603 59 and and CC 37231 1603 60 scatters scatter VBZ 37231 1603 61 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1603 62 through through IN 37231 1603 63 the the DT 37231 1603 64 mountains mountain NNS 37231 1603 65 of of IN 37231 1603 66 the the DT 37231 1603 67 earth earth NN 37231 1603 68 ; ; : 37231 1603 69 the the DT 37231 1603 70 { { -LRB- 37231 1603 71 105 105 CD 37231 1603 72 } } -RRB- 37231 1603 73 spirit spirit NN 37231 1603 74 of of IN 37231 1603 75 hoar hoar UH 37231 1603 76 frost frost NN 37231 1603 77 , , , 37231 1603 78 and and CC 37231 1603 79 the the DT 37231 1603 80 spirit spirit NN 37231 1603 81 of of IN 37231 1603 82 hail hail NN 37231 1603 83 , , , 37231 1603 84 and and CC 37231 1603 85 the the DT 37231 1603 86 spirit spirit NN 37231 1603 87 of of IN 37231 1603 88 snow snow NN 37231 1603 89 . . . 37231 1604 1 There there EX 37231 1604 2 are be VBP 37231 1604 3 , , , 37231 1604 4 in in IN 37231 1604 5 fact fact NN 37231 1604 6 , , , 37231 1604 7 special special JJ 37231 1604 8 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1604 9 set set VBN 37231 1604 10 over over RP 37231 1604 11 every every DT 37231 1604 12 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 1604 13 of of IN 37231 1604 14 nature nature NN 37231 1604 15 -- -- : 37231 1604 16 frost frost NN 37231 1604 17 , , , 37231 1604 18 thaw thaw NN 37231 1604 19 , , , 37231 1604 20 mist mist NN 37231 1604 21 , , , 37231 1604 22 rain rain NN 37231 1604 23 , , , 37231 1604 24 light light NN 37231 1604 25 , , , 37231 1604 26 and and CC 37231 1604 27 so so RB 37231 1604 28 on on RB 37231 1604 29 . . . 37231 1605 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1605 2 1 1 LS 37231 1605 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1605 4 The the DT 37231 1605 5 heavens heavens NNPS 37231 1605 6 and and CC 37231 1605 7 the the DT 37231 1605 8 earth earth NN 37231 1605 9 are be VBP 37231 1605 10 filled fill VBN 37231 1605 11 with with IN 37231 1605 12 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1605 13 . . . 37231 1606 1 Raphael Raphael NNP 37231 1606 2 is be VBZ 37231 1606 3 the the DT 37231 1606 4 angel angel NN 37231 1606 5 set set VBN 37231 1606 6 over over IN 37231 1606 7 all all PDT 37231 1606 8 the the DT 37231 1606 9 diseases disease NNS 37231 1606 10 and and CC 37231 1606 11 wounds wound NNS 37231 1606 12 of of IN 37231 1606 13 mankind mankind NN 37231 1606 14 , , , 37231 1606 15 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 1606 16 over over IN 37231 1606 17 all all DT 37231 1606 18 powers power NNS 37231 1606 19 , , , 37231 1606 20 and and CC 37231 1606 21 Fanuel Fanuel NNP 37231 1606 22 over over IN 37231 1606 23 the the DT 37231 1606 24 penitence penitence NN 37231 1606 25 and and CC 37231 1606 26 the the DT 37231 1606 27 hope hope NN 37231 1606 28 of of IN 37231 1606 29 those those DT 37231 1606 30 who who WP 37231 1606 31 inherit inherit VBP 37231 1606 32 eternal eternal JJ 37231 1606 33 life life NN 37231 1606 34 . . . 37231 1607 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1607 2 2 2 LS 37231 1607 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1607 4 The the DT 37231 1607 5 decree decree NN 37231 1607 6 for for IN 37231 1607 7 the the DT 37231 1607 8 destruction destruction NN 37231 1607 9 of of IN 37231 1607 10 the the DT 37231 1607 11 human human JJ 37231 1607 12 race race NN 37231 1607 13 goes go VBZ 37231 1607 14 forth forth RB 37231 1607 15 from from IN 37231 1607 16 the the DT 37231 1607 17 presence presence NN 37231 1607 18 of of IN 37231 1607 19 the the DT 37231 1607 20 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1607 21 , , , 37231 1607 22 because because IN 37231 1607 23 men man NNS 37231 1607 24 know know VBP 37231 1607 25 all all PDT 37231 1607 26 the the DT 37231 1607 27 mysteries mystery NNS 37231 1607 28 of of IN 37231 1607 29 the the DT 37231 1607 30 angels angel NNS 37231 1607 31 , , , 37231 1607 32 all all PDT 37231 1607 33 the the DT 37231 1607 34 evil evil JJ 37231 1607 35 works work NNS 37231 1607 36 of of IN 37231 1607 37 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1607 38 , , , 37231 1607 39 and and CC 37231 1607 40 all all PDT 37231 1607 41 the the DT 37231 1607 42 secret secret JJ 37231 1607 43 might might NN 37231 1607 44 and and CC 37231 1607 45 power power NN 37231 1607 46 of of IN 37231 1607 47 those those DT 37231 1607 48 who who WP 37231 1607 49 practise practise VBP 37231 1607 50 the the DT 37231 1607 51 art art NN 37231 1607 52 of of IN 37231 1607 53 magic magic NN 37231 1607 54 , , , 37231 1607 55 and and CC 37231 1607 56 the the DT 37231 1607 57 power power NN 37231 1607 58 of of IN 37231 1607 59 conjuring conjuring NN 37231 1607 60 , , , 37231 1607 61 and and CC 37231 1607 62 such such JJ 37231 1607 63 arts art NNS 37231 1607 64 . . . 37231 1608 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1608 2 3 3 LS 37231 1608 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1608 4 The the DT 37231 1608 5 stars star NNS 37231 1608 6 are be VBP 37231 1608 7 represented represent VBN 37231 1608 8 as as IN 37231 1608 9 animated animate VBN 37231 1608 10 beings being NNS 37231 1608 11 . . . 37231 1609 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1609 2 4 4 LS 37231 1609 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1609 4 Enoch Enoch NNP 37231 1609 5 sees see VBZ 37231 1609 6 seven seven CD 37231 1609 7 stars star NNS 37231 1609 8 bound bind VBN 37231 1609 9 together together RB 37231 1609 10 in in IN 37231 1609 11 space space NN 37231 1609 12 like like IN 37231 1609 13 great great JJ 37231 1609 14 mountains mountain NNS 37231 1609 15 , , , 37231 1609 16 and and CC 37231 1609 17 flaming flame VBG 37231 1609 18 as as IN 37231 1609 19 with with IN 37231 1609 20 fire fire NN 37231 1609 21 ; ; : 37231 1609 22 and and CC 37231 1609 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1609 24 inquires inquire VBZ 37231 1609 25 of of IN 37231 1609 26 the the DT 37231 1609 27 angel angel NN 37231 1609 28 who who WP 37231 1609 29 leads lead VBZ 37231 1609 30 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1609 31 , , , 37231 1609 32 on on IN 37231 1609 33 account account NN 37231 1609 34 of of IN 37231 1609 35 what what WP 37231 1609 36 sin sin NN 37231 1609 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1609 38 are be VBP 37231 1609 39 so so RB 37231 1609 40 bound bound JJ 37231 1609 41 ? ? . 37231 1610 1 Uriel Uriel NNP 37231 1610 2 informs inform VBZ 37231 1610 3 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1610 4 that that IN 37231 1610 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1610 6 are be VBP 37231 1610 7 stars star NNS 37231 1610 8 which which WDT 37231 1610 9 have have VBP 37231 1610 10 transgressed transgress VBN 37231 1610 11 the the DT 37231 1610 12 commands command NNS 37231 1610 13 of of IN 37231 1610 14 the the DT 37231 1610 15 Highest high JJS 37231 1610 16 God God NNP 37231 1610 17 , , , 37231 1610 18 and and CC 37231 1610 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1610 20 are be VBP 37231 1610 21 thus thus RB 37231 1610 22 bound bind VBN 37231 1610 23 until until IN 37231 1610 24 ten ten CD 37231 1610 25 thousand thousand CD 37231 1610 26 worlds world NNS 37231 1610 27 , , , 37231 1610 28 the the DT 37231 1610 29 number number NN 37231 1610 30 of of IN 37231 1610 31 the the DT 37231 1610 32 days day NNS 37231 1610 33 of of IN 37231 1610 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1610 35 transgression transgression NN 37231 1610 36 , , , 37231 1610 37 shall shall MD 37231 1610 38 be be VB 37231 1610 39 accomplished accomplish VBN 37231 1610 40 . . . 37231 1611 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1611 2 5 5 LS 37231 1611 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1611 4 The the DT 37231 1611 5 belief belief NN 37231 1611 6 that that IN 37231 1611 7 sun sun NN 37231 1611 8 , , , 37231 1611 9 moon moon NN 37231 1611 10 , , , 37231 1611 11 and and CC 37231 1611 12 stars star NNS 37231 1611 13 were be VBD 37231 1611 14 living live VBG 37231 1611 15 entities entity NNS 37231 1611 16 possessed possess VBN 37231 1611 17 of of IN 37231 1611 18 souls soul NNS 37231 1611 19 was be VBD 37231 1611 20 generally generally RB 37231 1611 21 held hold VBN 37231 1611 22 by by IN 37231 1611 23 the the DT 37231 1611 24 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1611 25 at at IN 37231 1611 26 the the DT 37231 1611 27 beginning beginning NN 37231 1611 28 of of IN 37231 1611 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1611 30 era era NN 37231 1611 31 , , , 37231 1611 32 along along IN 37231 1611 33 with with IN 37231 1611 34 Greek greek JJ 37231 1611 35 philosophers philosopher NNS 37231 1611 36 , , , 37231 1611 37 and and CC 37231 1611 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1611 39 shall shall MD 37231 1611 40 presently presently RB 37231 1611 41 see see VB 37231 1611 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1611 43 expressed express VBN 37231 1611 44 by by IN 37231 1611 45 the the DT 37231 1611 46 Fathers father NNS 37231 1611 47 . . . 37231 1612 1 Philo Philo NNP 37231 1612 2 Judaeus Judaeus NNP 37231 1612 3 considers consider VBZ 37231 1612 4 the the DT 37231 1612 5 stars star NNS 37231 1612 6 spiritual spiritual JJ 37231 1612 7 beings being NNS 37231 1612 8 full full JJ 37231 1612 9 of of IN 37231 1612 10 virtue virtue NN 37231 1612 11 and and CC 37231 1612 12 perfection,(6 perfection,(6 NNPS 37231 1612 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1612 14 and and CC 37231 1612 15 that that IN 37231 1612 16 to to IN 37231 1612 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1612 18 is be VBZ 37231 1612 19 granted grant VBN 37231 1612 20 lordship lordship NN 37231 1612 21 over over IN 37231 1612 22 other other JJ 37231 1612 23 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 1612 24 bodies body NNS 37231 1612 25 , , , 37231 1612 26 not not RB 37231 1612 27 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1612 28 , , , 37231 1612 29 but but CC 37231 1612 30 as as IN 37231 1612 31 viceroys viceroy NNS 37231 1612 32 under under IN 37231 1612 33 the the DT 37231 1612 34 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1612 35 { { -LRB- 37231 1612 36 106 106 CD 37231 1612 37 } } -RRB- 37231 1612 38 Being being NN 37231 1612 39 . . . 37231 1613 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1613 2 1 1 LS 37231 1613 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1613 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1613 5 find find VBP 37231 1613 6 a a DT 37231 1613 7 similar similar JJ 37231 1613 8 view view NN 37231 1613 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 1613 10 the the DT 37231 1613 11 nature nature NN 37231 1613 12 of of IN 37231 1613 13 the the DT 37231 1613 14 stars star NNS 37231 1613 15 expressed express VBN 37231 1613 16 in in IN 37231 1613 17 the the DT 37231 1613 18 Apocalypse,(2 Apocalypse,(2 NNP 37231 1613 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1613 20 and and CC 37231 1613 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1613 22 constantly constantly RB 37231 1613 23 appears appear VBZ 37231 1613 24 in in IN 37231 1613 25 the the DT 37231 1613 26 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1613 27 and and CC 37231 1613 28 Targums targum NNS 37231 1613 29 . . . 37231 1614 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1614 2 3 3 LS 37231 1614 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1614 4 An an DT 37231 1614 5 angel angel NN 37231 1614 6 of of IN 37231 1614 7 the the DT 37231 1614 8 sun sun NN 37231 1614 9 and and CC 37231 1614 10 moon moon NN 37231 1614 11 is be VBZ 37231 1614 12 described describe VBN 37231 1614 13 in in IN 37231 1614 14 the the DT 37231 1614 15 Ascensio Ascensio NNP 37231 1614 16 Isaiae Isaiae NNP 37231 1614 17 . . . 37231 1615 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1615 2 4 4 LS 37231 1615 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1615 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1615 5 are be VBP 37231 1615 6 able able JJ 37231 1615 7 to to TO 37231 1615 8 obtain obtain VB 37231 1615 9 a a DT 37231 1615 10 full full JJ 37231 1615 11 and and CC 37231 1615 12 minute minute JJ 37231 1615 13 conception conception NN 37231 1615 14 of of IN 37231 1615 15 the the DT 37231 1615 16 belief belief NN 37231 1615 17 regarding regard VBG 37231 1615 18 angels angel NNS 37231 1615 19 and and CC 37231 1615 20 demons demon NNS 37231 1615 21 and and CC 37231 1615 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1615 23 influence influence NN 37231 1615 24 over over IN 37231 1615 25 cosmical cosmical JJ 37231 1615 26 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1615 27 , , , 37231 1615 28 as as RB 37231 1615 29 well well RB 37231 1615 30 as as IN 37231 1615 31 of of IN 37231 1615 32 other other JJ 37231 1615 33 superstitions superstition NNS 37231 1615 34 current current JJ 37231 1615 35 amongst amongst IN 37231 1615 36 the the DT 37231 1615 37 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1615 38 at at IN 37231 1615 39 the the DT 37231 1615 40 time time NN 37231 1615 41 of of IN 37231 1615 42 Jesus,(5 jesus,(5 NN 37231 1615 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1615 44 from from IN 37231 1615 45 the the DT 37231 1615 46 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1615 47 , , , 37231 1615 48 Targums targum NNS 37231 1615 49 , , , 37231 1615 50 and and CC 37231 1615 51 other other JJ 37231 1615 52 Rabbinical rabbinical JJ 37231 1615 53 sources source NNS 37231 1615 54 . . . 37231 1616 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1616 2 can can MD 37231 1616 3 not not RB 37231 1616 4 , , , 37231 1616 5 however however RB 37231 1616 6 , , , 37231 1616 7 do do VBP 37231 1616 8 more more JJR 37231 1616 9 , , , 37231 1616 10 here here RB 37231 1616 11 , , , 37231 1616 12 than than IN 37231 1616 13 merely merely RB 37231 1616 14 glance glance NN 37231 1616 15 at at IN 37231 1616 16 these these DT 37231 1616 17 voluminous voluminous JJ 37231 1616 18 materials material NNS 37231 1616 19 . . . 37231 1617 1 The the DT 37231 1617 2 angels angel NNS 37231 1617 3 are be VBP 37231 1617 4 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 1617 5 pure pure JJ 37231 1617 6 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1617 7 , , , 37231 1617 8 without without IN 37231 1617 9 sin sin NN 37231 1617 10 , , , 37231 1617 11 and and CC 37231 1617 12 not not RB 37231 1617 13 visible visible JJ 37231 1617 14 to to IN 37231 1617 15 mortal mortal JJ 37231 1617 16 eyes eye NNS 37231 1617 17 . . . 37231 1618 1 When when WRB 37231 1618 2 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1618 3 come come VBP 37231 1618 4 down down RP 37231 1618 5 to to IN 37231 1618 6 earth earth NN 37231 1618 7 on on IN 37231 1618 8 any any DT 37231 1618 9 mission mission NN 37231 1618 10 , , , 37231 1618 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1618 12 are be VBP 37231 1618 13 clad clothe VBN 37231 1618 14 in in IN 37231 1618 15 light light NN 37231 1618 16 and and CC 37231 1618 17 veiled veil VBN 37231 1618 18 in in IN 37231 1618 19 air air NN 37231 1618 20 . . . 37231 1619 1 If if IN 37231 1619 2 , , , 37231 1619 3 however however RB 37231 1619 4 , , , 37231 1619 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1619 6 remain remain VBP 37231 1619 7 longer long JJR 37231 1619 8 than than IN 37231 1619 9 seven seven CD 37231 1619 10 days day NNS 37231 1619 11 on on IN 37231 1619 12 earth earth NN 37231 1619 13 , , , 37231 1619 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1619 15 become become VBP 37231 1619 16 so so RB 37231 1619 17 clogged clogged JJ 37231 1619 18 with with IN 37231 1619 19 the the DT 37231 1619 20 earthly earthly JJ 37231 1619 21 matter matter NN 37231 1619 22 in in IN 37231 1619 23 which which WDT 37231 1619 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1619 25 have have VBP 37231 1619 26 been be VBN 37231 1619 27 immersed immerse VBN 37231 1619 28 that that IN 37231 1619 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1619 30 can can MD 37231 1619 31 not not RB 37231 1619 32 again again RB 37231 1619 33 ascend ascend VB 37231 1619 34 to to IN 37231 1619 35 the the DT 37231 1619 36 upper upper JJ 37231 1619 37 heavens heavens NNPS 37231 1619 38 . . . 37231 1620 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1620 2 6 6 LS 37231 1620 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1620 4 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1620 5 multitude multitude NN 37231 1620 6 is be VBZ 37231 1620 7 innumerable,(7 innumerable,(7 NNPS 37231 1620 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1620 9 and and CC 37231 1620 10 new new JJ 37231 1620 11 angels angel NNS 37231 1620 12 are be VBP 37231 1620 13 every every DT 37231 1620 14 day day NN 37231 1620 15 created create VBN 37231 1620 16 , , , 37231 1620 17 who who WP 37231 1620 18 in in IN 37231 1620 19 succession succession NN 37231 1620 20 praise praise NN 37231 1620 21 { { -LRB- 37231 1620 22 107 107 CD 37231 1620 23 } } -RRB- 37231 1620 24 God God NNP 37231 1620 25 and and CC 37231 1620 26 make make VB 37231 1620 27 way way NN 37231 1620 28 for for IN 37231 1620 29 others other NNS 37231 1620 30 . . . 37231 1621 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1621 2 1 1 LS 37231 1621 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1621 4 The the DT 37231 1621 5 expression expression NN 37231 1621 6 , , , 37231 1621 7 " " '' 37231 1621 8 host host NN 37231 1621 9 of of IN 37231 1621 10 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1621 11 , , , 37231 1621 12 " " '' 37231 1621 13 is be VBZ 37231 1621 14 a a DT 37231 1621 15 common common JJ 37231 1621 16 one one NN 37231 1621 17 in in IN 37231 1621 18 the the DT 37231 1621 19 Old Old NNP 37231 1621 20 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1621 21 , , , 37231 1621 22 and and CC 37231 1621 23 the the DT 37231 1621 24 idea idea NN 37231 1621 25 was be VBD 37231 1621 26 developed develop VBN 37231 1621 27 into into IN 37231 1621 28 a a DT 37231 1621 29 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 1621 30 army army NN 37231 1621 31 . . . 37231 1622 1 The the DT 37231 1622 2 first first JJ 37231 1622 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1622 4 represents represent VBZ 37231 1622 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1622 6 as as IN 37231 1622 7 speaking speak VBG 37231 1622 8 of of IN 37231 1622 9 " " `` 37231 1622 10 more more JJR 37231 1622 11 than than IN 37231 1622 12 twelve twelve CD 37231 1622 13 legions legion NNS 37231 1622 14 of of IN 37231 1622 15 angels angel NNS 37231 1622 16 . . . 37231 1623 1 " " `` 37231 1623 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1623 3 2 2 LS 37231 1623 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1623 5 Every every DT 37231 1623 6 angel angel NN 37231 1623 7 has have VBZ 37231 1623 8 one one CD 37231 1623 9 particular particular JJ 37231 1623 10 duty duty NN 37231 1623 11 to to TO 37231 1623 12 perform perform VB 37231 1623 13 , , , 37231 1623 14 and and CC 37231 1623 15 no no RB 37231 1623 16 more more JJR 37231 1623 17 ; ; : 37231 1623 18 thus thus RB 37231 1623 19 of of IN 37231 1623 20 the the DT 37231 1623 21 three three CD 37231 1623 22 angels angel NNS 37231 1623 23 who who WP 37231 1623 24 appeared appear VBD 37231 1623 25 to to IN 37231 1623 26 Abraham Abraham NNP 37231 1623 27 , , , 37231 1623 28 one one CD 37231 1623 29 was be VBD 37231 1623 30 sent send VBN 37231 1623 31 to to TO 37231 1623 32 announce announce VB 37231 1623 33 that that IN 37231 1623 34 Sarah Sarah NNP 37231 1623 35 should should MD 37231 1623 36 have have VB 37231 1623 37 a a DT 37231 1623 38 son son NN 37231 1623 39 , , , 37231 1623 40 the the DT 37231 1623 41 second second JJ 37231 1623 42 to to TO 37231 1623 43 rescue rescue VB 37231 1623 44 Lot Lot NNP 37231 1623 45 , , , 37231 1623 46 and and CC 37231 1623 47 the the DT 37231 1623 48 third third JJ 37231 1623 49 to to TO 37231 1623 50 destroy destroy VB 37231 1623 51 Sodom Sodom NNP 37231 1623 52 and and CC 37231 1623 53 Gomorrah Gomorrah NNP 37231 1623 54 . . . 37231 1624 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1624 2 3 3 LS 37231 1624 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1624 4 The the DT 37231 1624 5 angels angel NNS 37231 1624 6 serve serve VBP 37231 1624 7 God God NNP 37231 1624 8 in in IN 37231 1624 9 the the DT 37231 1624 10 administration administration NN 37231 1624 11 of of IN 37231 1624 12 the the DT 37231 1624 13 universe universe NN 37231 1624 14 , , , 37231 1624 15 and and CC 37231 1624 16 to to IN 37231 1624 17 special special JJ 37231 1624 18 angels angel NNS 37231 1624 19 are be VBP 37231 1624 20 assigned assign VBN 37231 1624 21 the the DT 37231 1624 22 different different JJ 37231 1624 23 parts part NNS 37231 1624 24 of of IN 37231 1624 25 nature nature NN 37231 1624 26 . . . 37231 1625 1 " " `` 37231 1625 2 There there EX 37231 1625 3 is be VBZ 37231 1625 4 not not RB 37231 1625 5 a a DT 37231 1625 6 thing thing NN 37231 1625 7 in in IN 37231 1625 8 the the DT 37231 1625 9 world world NN 37231 1625 10 , , , 37231 1625 11 not not RB 37231 1625 12 even even RB 37231 1625 13 a a DT 37231 1625 14 little little JJ 37231 1625 15 herb herb NN 37231 1625 16 , , , 37231 1625 17 over over IN 37231 1625 18 which which WDT 37231 1625 19 there there EX 37231 1625 20 is be VBZ 37231 1625 21 not not RB 37231 1625 22 an an DT 37231 1625 23 angel angel NN 37231 1625 24 set set NN 37231 1625 25 , , , 37231 1625 26 and and CC 37231 1625 27 everything everything NN 37231 1625 28 happens happen VBZ 37231 1625 29 according accord VBG 37231 1625 30 to to IN 37231 1625 31 the the DT 37231 1625 32 command command NN 37231 1625 33 of of IN 37231 1625 34 these these DT 37231 1625 35 appointed appoint VBN 37231 1625 36 angels angel NNS 37231 1625 37 . . . 37231 1626 1 " " `` 37231 1626 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1626 3 4 4 LS 37231 1626 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1626 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1626 6 will will MD 37231 1626 7 be be VB 37231 1626 8 remembered remember VBN 37231 1626 9 that that IN 37231 1626 10 the the DT 37231 1626 11 agency agency NN 37231 1626 12 of of IN 37231 1626 13 angels angel NNS 37231 1626 14 is be VBZ 37231 1626 15 frequently frequently RB 37231 1626 16 introduced introduce VBN 37231 1626 17 in in IN 37231 1626 18 the the DT 37231 1626 19 Old Old NNP 37231 1626 20 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1626 21 , , , 37231 1626 22 and and CC 37231 1626 23 still still RB 37231 1626 24 more more RBR 37231 1626 25 so so RB 37231 1626 26 in in IN 37231 1626 27 the the DT 37231 1626 28 Septuagint Septuagint NNP 37231 1626 29 version version NN 37231 1626 30 , , , 37231 1626 31 by by IN 37231 1626 32 alterations alteration NNS 37231 1626 33 of of IN 37231 1626 34 the the DT 37231 1626 35 text text NN 37231 1626 36 . . . 37231 1627 1 One one CD 37231 1627 2 notable notable JJ 37231 1627 3 case case NN 37231 1627 4 of of IN 37231 1627 5 such such JJ 37231 1627 6 agency agency NN 37231 1627 7 may may MD 37231 1627 8 be be VB 37231 1627 9 referred refer VBN 37231 1627 10 to to IN 37231 1627 11 , , , 37231 1627 12 where where WRB 37231 1627 13 the the DT 37231 1627 14 pestilence pestilence NN 37231 1627 15 which which WDT 37231 1627 16 is be VBZ 37231 1627 17 sent send VBN 37231 1627 18 to to TO 37231 1627 19 punish punish VB 37231 1627 20 David David NNP 37231 1627 21 for for IN 37231 1627 22 numbering number VBG 37231 1627 23 the the DT 37231 1627 24 people people NNS 37231 1627 25 is be VBZ 37231 1627 26 said say VBN 37231 1627 27 to to TO 37231 1627 28 be be VB 37231 1627 29 caused cause VBN 37231 1627 30 by by IN 37231 1627 31 an an DT 37231 1627 32 angel angel NN 37231 1627 33 , , , 37231 1627 34 whom whom WP 37231 1627 35 David David NNP 37231 1627 36 even even RB 37231 1627 37 sees see VBZ 37231 1627 38 . . . 37231 1628 1 The the DT 37231 1628 2 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1628 3 is be VBZ 37231 1628 4 represented represent VBN 37231 1628 5 as as IN 37231 1628 6 repenting repent VBG 37231 1628 7 of of IN 37231 1628 8 the the DT 37231 1628 9 evil evil NN 37231 1628 10 , , , 37231 1628 11 when when WRB 37231 1628 12 the the DT 37231 1628 13 angel angel NN 37231 1628 14 was be VBD 37231 1628 15 stretching stretch VBG 37231 1628 16 forth forth RB 37231 1628 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1628 18 hand hand NN 37231 1628 19 against against IN 37231 1628 20 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 1628 21 , , , 37231 1628 22 and and CC 37231 1628 23 bidding bid VBG 37231 1628 24 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1628 25 stay stay VBP 37231 1628 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1628 27 hand hand NN 37231 1628 28 after after IN 37231 1628 29 the the DT 37231 1628 30 angel angel NN 37231 1628 31 had have VBD 37231 1628 32 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 1628 33 seventy seventy CD 37231 1628 34 thousand thousand CD 37231 1628 35 men man NNS 37231 1628 36 by by IN 37231 1628 37 the the DT 37231 1628 38 pestilence pestilence NN 37231 1628 39 . . . 37231 1629 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1629 2 5 5 LS 37231 1629 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1629 4 This this DT 37231 1629 5 theory theory NN 37231 1629 6 of of IN 37231 1629 7 disease disease NN 37231 1629 8 has have VBZ 37231 1629 9 prevailed prevail VBN 37231 1629 10 until until IN 37231 1629 11 comparatively comparatively RB 37231 1629 12 recent recent JJ 37231 1629 13 times time NNS 37231 1629 14 . . . 37231 1630 1 The the DT 37231 1630 2 names name NNS 37231 1630 3 of of IN 37231 1630 4 many many JJ 37231 1630 5 of of IN 37231 1630 6 the the DT 37231 1630 7 superintending superintend VBG 37231 1630 8 angels angel NNS 37231 1630 9 are be VBP 37231 1630 10 given give VBN 37231 1630 11 , , , 37231 1630 12 as as IN 37231 1630 13 , , , 37231 1630 14 for for IN 37231 1630 15 instance instance NN 37231 1630 16 : : : 37231 1630 17 Jehuel Jehuel NNP 37231 1630 18 { { -LRB- 37231 1630 19 108 108 CD 37231 1630 20 } } -RRB- 37231 1630 21 is be VBZ 37231 1630 22 set set VBN 37231 1630 23 over over IN 37231 1630 24 fire fire NN 37231 1630 25 , , , 37231 1630 26 Michael Michael NNP 37231 1630 27 over over IN 37231 1630 28 water water NN 37231 1630 29 , , , 37231 1630 30 Jechiel Jechiel NNP 37231 1630 31 over over IN 37231 1630 32 wild wild JJ 37231 1630 33 beasts beast NNS 37231 1630 34 , , , 37231 1630 35 and and CC 37231 1630 36 Anpiel Anpiel NNP 37231 1630 37 over over IN 37231 1630 38 birds bird NNS 37231 1630 39 . . . 37231 1631 1 Over over IN 37231 1631 2 cattle cattle NNS 37231 1631 3 Hariel Hariel NNP 37231 1631 4 is be VBZ 37231 1631 5 appointed appoint VBN 37231 1631 6 , , , 37231 1631 7 and and CC 37231 1631 8 Samniel Samniel NNP 37231 1631 9 over over IN 37231 1631 10 created create VBD 37231 1631 11 things thing NNS 37231 1631 12 moving move VBG 37231 1631 13 in in IN 37231 1631 14 the the DT 37231 1631 15 waters water NNS 37231 1631 16 , , , 37231 1631 17 and and CC 37231 1631 18 over over IN 37231 1631 19 the the DT 37231 1631 20 face face NN 37231 1631 21 of of IN 37231 1631 22 the the DT 37231 1631 23 earth earth NN 37231 1631 24 ; ; : 37231 1631 25 Messannahel Messannahel NNP 37231 1631 26 over over IN 37231 1631 27 reptiles reptile NNS 37231 1631 28 , , , 37231 1631 29 Deliel Deliel NNP 37231 1631 30 over over IN 37231 1631 31 fish fish NN 37231 1631 32 . . . 37231 1632 1 Ruchiel Ruchiel NNP 37231 1632 2 is be VBZ 37231 1632 3 set set VBN 37231 1632 4 over over IN 37231 1632 5 the the DT 37231 1632 6 winds wind NNS 37231 1632 7 , , , 37231 1632 8 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 1632 9 over over IN 37231 1632 10 thunder thunder NN 37231 1632 11 and and CC 37231 1632 12 also also RB 37231 1632 13 over over IN 37231 1632 14 fire fire NN 37231 1632 15 , , , 37231 1632 16 and and CC 37231 1632 17 over over IN 37231 1632 18 the the DT 37231 1632 19 ripening ripening NN 37231 1632 20 of of IN 37231 1632 21 fruit fruit NN 37231 1632 22 , , , 37231 1632 23 Xuriel Xuriel NNP 37231 1632 24 over over IN 37231 1632 25 hail hail NN 37231 1632 26 , , , 37231 1632 27 Makturiel Makturiel NNP 37231 1632 28 over over IN 37231 1632 29 rocks rock NNS 37231 1632 30 , , , 37231 1632 31 Alpiel Alpiel NNP 37231 1632 32 over over IN 37231 1632 33 fruit fruit NN 37231 1632 34 - - HYPH 37231 1632 35 bearing bearing NN 37231 1632 36 trees tree NNS 37231 1632 37 , , , 37231 1632 38 Saroel Saroel NNP 37231 1632 39 over over IN 37231 1632 40 those those DT 37231 1632 41 which which WDT 37231 1632 42 do do VBP 37231 1632 43 not not RB 37231 1632 44 bear bear VB 37231 1632 45 fruit fruit NN 37231 1632 46 , , , 37231 1632 47 and and CC 37231 1632 48 Sandalfon Sandalfon NNP 37231 1632 49 over over IN 37231 1632 50 the the DT 37231 1632 51 human human JJ 37231 1632 52 race race NN 37231 1632 53 ; ; : 37231 1632 54 and and CC 37231 1632 55 under under IN 37231 1632 56 each each DT 37231 1632 57 of of IN 37231 1632 58 these these DT 37231 1632 59 there there EX 37231 1632 60 are be VBP 37231 1632 61 subordinate subordinate JJ 37231 1632 62 angels angel NNS 37231 1632 63 . . . 37231 1633 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1633 2 1 1 LS 37231 1633 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1633 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1633 5 was be VBD 37231 1633 6 believed believe VBN 37231 1633 7 that that IN 37231 1633 8 there there EX 37231 1633 9 were be VBD 37231 1633 10 two two CD 37231 1633 11 angels angel NNS 37231 1633 12 of of IN 37231 1633 13 Death death NN 37231 1633 14 , , , 37231 1633 15 one one CD 37231 1633 16 for for IN 37231 1633 17 those those DT 37231 1633 18 who who WP 37231 1633 19 died die VBD 37231 1633 20 out out IN 37231 1633 21 of of IN 37231 1633 22 the the DT 37231 1633 23 land land NN 37231 1633 24 of of IN 37231 1633 25 Israel Israel NNP 37231 1633 26 , , , 37231 1633 27 who who WP 37231 1633 28 was be VBD 37231 1633 29 an an DT 37231 1633 30 evil evil JJ 37231 1633 31 angel angel NN 37231 1633 32 , , , 37231 1633 33 called call VBN 37231 1633 34 Samaël Samaël NNP 37231 1633 35 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1633 36 and and CC 37231 1633 37 at at IN 37231 1633 38 other other JJ 37231 1633 39 times time NNS 37231 1633 40 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1633 41 , , , 37231 1633 42 Asmodeus Asmodeus NNP 37231 1633 43 , , , 37231 1633 44 & & CC 37231 1633 45 c c NNP 37231 1633 46 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1633 47 , , , 37231 1633 48 and and CC 37231 1633 49 the the DT 37231 1633 50 other other JJ 37231 1633 51 , , , 37231 1633 52 who who WP 37231 1633 53 presided preside VBD 37231 1633 54 over over IN 37231 1633 55 the the DT 37231 1633 56 dead dead NN 37231 1633 57 of of IN 37231 1633 58 the the DT 37231 1633 59 land land NN 37231 1633 60 of of IN 37231 1633 61 Israel Israel NNP 37231 1633 62 , , , 37231 1633 63 the the DT 37231 1633 64 holy holy JJ 37231 1633 65 angel angel NN 37231 1633 66 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 1633 67 ; ; : 37231 1633 68 and and CC 37231 1633 69 under under IN 37231 1633 70 these these DT 37231 1633 71 there there EX 37231 1633 72 was be VBD 37231 1633 73 a a DT 37231 1633 74 host host NN 37231 1633 75 of of IN 37231 1633 76 evil evil JJ 37231 1633 77 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1633 78 and and CC 37231 1633 79 angels angel NNS 37231 1633 80 . . . 37231 1634 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1634 2 2 2 LS 37231 1634 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1634 4 The the DT 37231 1634 5 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1634 6 were be VBD 37231 1634 7 unanimous unanimous JJ 37231 1634 8 in in IN 37231 1634 9 asserting assert VBG 37231 1634 10 that that IN 37231 1634 11 angels angel NNS 37231 1634 12 superintend superintend VBP 37231 1634 13 the the DT 37231 1634 14 various various JJ 37231 1634 15 operations operation NNS 37231 1634 16 of of IN 37231 1634 17 nature nature NN 37231 1634 18 , , , 37231 1634 19 although although IN 37231 1634 20 there there EX 37231 1634 21 is be VBZ 37231 1634 22 some some DT 37231 1634 23 difference difference NN 37231 1634 24 in in IN 37231 1634 25 the the DT 37231 1634 26 names name NNS 37231 1634 27 assigned assign VBN 37231 1634 28 to to IN 37231 1634 29 these these DT 37231 1634 30 angels angel NNS 37231 1634 31 . . . 37231 1635 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1635 2 3 3 LS 37231 1635 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1635 4 The the DT 37231 1635 5 Sohar Sohar NNP 37231 1635 6 on on IN 37231 1635 7 Numbers Numbers NNPS 37231 1635 8 states state VBZ 37231 1635 9 that that IN 37231 1635 10 " " `` 37231 1635 11 Michael Michael NNP 37231 1635 12 , , , 37231 1635 13 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 1635 14 , , , 37231 1635 15 Nuriel Nuriel NNP 37231 1635 16 , , , 37231 1635 17 Raphael Raphael NNP 37231 1635 18 are be VBP 37231 1635 19 set set VBN 37231 1635 20 over over IN 37231 1635 21 the the DT 37231 1635 22 four four CD 37231 1635 23 elements element NNS 37231 1635 24 , , , 37231 1635 25 water water NN 37231 1635 26 , , , 37231 1635 27 fire fire NN 37231 1635 28 , , , 37231 1635 29 air air NN 37231 1635 30 , , , 37231 1635 31 earth earth NN 37231 1635 32 . . . 37231 1636 1 " " `` 37231 1636 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1636 3 4 4 LS 37231 1636 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1636 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1636 6 shall shall MD 37231 1636 7 presently presently RB 37231 1636 8 sec sec VB 37231 1636 9 how how WRB 37231 1636 10 general general JJ 37231 1636 11 this this DT 37231 1636 12 belief belief NN 37231 1636 13 regarding regard VBG 37231 1636 14 angels angel NNS 37231 1636 15 was be VBD 37231 1636 16 amongst amongst IN 37231 1636 17 the the DT 37231 1636 18 Fathers father NNS 37231 1636 19 , , , 37231 1636 20 but but CC 37231 1636 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1636 22 is be VBZ 37231 1636 23 also also RB 37231 1636 24 expressed express VBN 37231 1636 25 in in IN 37231 1636 26 the the DT 37231 1636 27 New New NNP 37231 1636 28 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1636 29 . . . 37231 1637 1 In in IN 37231 1637 2 the the DT 37231 1637 3 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 1637 4 there there EX 37231 1637 5 appears appear VBZ 37231 1637 6 an an DT 37231 1637 7 angel angel NN 37231 1637 8 { { -LRB- 37231 1637 9 109 109 CD 37231 1637 10 } } -RRB- 37231 1637 11 who who WP 37231 1637 12 has have VBZ 37231 1637 13 power power NN 37231 1637 14 over over IN 37231 1637 15 fire,(1 fire,(1 NNP 37231 1637 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1637 17 and and CC 37231 1637 18 in in IN 37231 1637 19 another another DT 37231 1637 20 place place NN 37231 1637 21 four four CD 37231 1637 22 angels angel NNS 37231 1637 23 have have VBP 37231 1637 24 power power NN 37231 1637 25 to to TO 37231 1637 26 hurt hurt VB 37231 1637 27 the the DT 37231 1637 28 earth earth NN 37231 1637 29 and and CC 37231 1637 30 the the DT 37231 1637 31 sea sea NN 37231 1637 32 . . . 37231 1638 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1638 2 2 2 LS 37231 1638 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1638 4 The the DT 37231 1638 5 angels angel NNS 37231 1638 6 were be VBD 37231 1638 7 likewise likewise RB 37231 1638 8 the the DT 37231 1638 9 instructors instructor NNS 37231 1638 10 of of IN 37231 1638 11 men man NNS 37231 1638 12 , , , 37231 1638 13 and and CC 37231 1638 14 communicated communicate VBN 37231 1638 15 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1638 16 to to IN 37231 1638 17 the the DT 37231 1638 18 Patriarchs Patriarchs NNP 37231 1638 19 . . . 37231 1639 1 The the DT 37231 1639 2 angel angel NN 37231 1639 3 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 1639 4 taught teach VBD 37231 1639 5 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 1639 6 the the DT 37231 1639 7 seventy seventy CD 37231 1639 8 languages language NNS 37231 1639 9 of of IN 37231 1639 10 the the DT 37231 1639 11 earth earth NN 37231 1639 12 . . . 37231 1640 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1640 2 3 3 LS 37231 1640 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1640 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1640 5 appears appear VBZ 37231 1640 6 , , , 37231 1640 7 however however RB 37231 1640 8 , , , 37231 1640 9 that that IN 37231 1640 10 there there EX 37231 1640 11 was be VBD 37231 1640 12 one one CD 37231 1640 13 language language NN 37231 1640 14 -- -- : 37231 1640 15 the the DT 37231 1640 16 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 1640 17 -- -- : 37231 1640 18 which which WDT 37231 1640 19 the the DT 37231 1640 20 angels angel NNS 37231 1640 21 do do VBP 37231 1640 22 not not RB 37231 1640 23 understand understand VB 37231 1640 24 , , , 37231 1640 25 and and CC 37231 1640 26 for for IN 37231 1640 27 this this DT 37231 1640 28 reason reason NN 37231 1640 29 men man NNS 37231 1640 30 were be VBD 37231 1640 31 not not RB 37231 1640 32 permitted permit VBN 37231 1640 33 to to TO 37231 1640 34 pray pray VB 37231 1640 35 for for IN 37231 1640 36 things thing NNS 37231 1640 37 needful needful JJ 37231 1640 38 , , , 37231 1640 39 in in IN 37231 1640 40 that that DT 37231 1640 41 tongue tongue NN 37231 1640 42 . . . 37231 1641 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1641 2 4 4 LS 37231 1641 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1641 4 Angels angel NNS 37231 1641 5 are be VBP 37231 1641 6 appointed appoint VBN 37231 1641 7 as as IN 37231 1641 8 princes prince NNS 37231 1641 9 over over IN 37231 1641 10 the the DT 37231 1641 11 seventy seventy CD 37231 1641 12 nations nation NNS 37231 1641 13 of of IN 37231 1641 14 the the DT 37231 1641 15 world world NN 37231 1641 16 ; ; : 37231 1641 17 but but CC 37231 1641 18 the the DT 37231 1641 19 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1641 20 consider consider VBP 37231 1641 21 the the DT 37231 1641 22 angels angel NNS 37231 1641 23 set set VBN 37231 1641 24 over over RP 37231 1641 25 Gentile Gentile NNP 37231 1641 26 nations nation NNS 37231 1641 27 merely merely RB 37231 1641 28 demons demon NNS 37231 1641 29 . . . 37231 1642 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1642 2 6 6 LS 37231 1642 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1642 4 The the DT 37231 1642 5 Septuagint Septuagint NNP 37231 1642 6 translation translation NN 37231 1642 7 of of IN 37231 1642 8 Deuteronomy Deuteronomy NNP 37231 1642 9 xxxii xxxii NN 37231 1642 10 . . . 37231 1643 1 8 8 CD 37231 1643 2 introduces introduce VBZ 37231 1643 3 the the DT 37231 1643 4 statement statement NN 37231 1643 5 into into IN 37231 1643 6 the the DT 37231 1643 7 Old Old NNP 37231 1643 8 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1643 9 . . . 37231 1644 1 Instead instead RB 37231 1644 2 of of IN 37231 1644 3 the the DT 37231 1644 4 Most most RBS 37231 1644 5 High high JJ 37231 1644 6 , , , 37231 1644 7 when when WRB 37231 1644 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1644 9 divided divide VBD 37231 1644 10 to to IN 37231 1644 11 the the DT 37231 1644 12 nations nation NNS 37231 1644 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1644 14 inheritance inheritance NN 37231 1644 15 , , , 37231 1644 16 setting set VBG 37231 1644 17 the the DT 37231 1644 18 bounds bound NNS 37231 1644 19 of of IN 37231 1644 20 the the DT 37231 1644 21 people people NNS 37231 1644 22 " " '' 37231 1644 23 according accord VBG 37231 1644 24 to to IN 37231 1644 25 the the DT 37231 1644 26 number number NN 37231 1644 27 of of IN 37231 1644 28 the the DT 37231 1644 29 children child NNS 37231 1644 30 of of IN 37231 1644 31 Israel Israel NNP 37231 1644 32 , , , 37231 1644 33 " " '' 37231 1644 34 the the DT 37231 1644 35 passage passage NN 37231 1644 36 becomes become VBZ 37231 1644 37 , , , 37231 1644 38 " " '' 37231 1644 39 according accord VBG 37231 1644 40 to to IN 37231 1644 41 the the DT 37231 1644 42 number number NN 37231 1644 43 of of IN 37231 1644 44 the the DT 37231 1644 45 angels angel NNS 37231 1644 46 of of IN 37231 1644 47 God God NNP 37231 1644 48 " " '' 37231 1644 49 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1644 50 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1644 51 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1644 52 . . . 37231 1645 1 The the DT 37231 1645 2 number number NN 37231 1645 3 of of IN 37231 1645 4 the the DT 37231 1645 5 nations nation NNS 37231 1645 6 was be VBD 37231 1645 7 fixed fix VBN 37231 1645 8 at at IN 37231 1645 9 seventy seventy CD 37231 1645 10 , , , 37231 1645 11 the the DT 37231 1645 12 number number NN 37231 1645 13 of of IN 37231 1645 14 the the DT 37231 1645 15 souls soul NNS 37231 1645 16 who who WP 37231 1645 17 went go VBD 37231 1645 18 down down RP 37231 1645 19 into into IN 37231 1645 20 Egypt Egypt NNP 37231 1645 21 . . . 37231 1646 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1646 2 6 6 LS 37231 1646 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1646 4 The the DT 37231 1646 5 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 1646 6 Targum Targum NNP 37231 1646 7 on on IN 37231 1646 8 Genesis Genesis NNP 37231 1646 9 xi xi NNP 37231 1646 10 . . . 37231 1647 1 7 7 CD 37231 1647 2 , , , 37231 1647 3 8 8 CD 37231 1647 4 , , , 37231 1647 5 reads read VBZ 37231 1647 6 as as IN 37231 1647 7 follows follow VBZ 37231 1647 8 : : : 37231 1647 9 " " `` 37231 1647 10 God God NNP 37231 1647 11 spake spake VBD 37231 1647 12 to to IN 37231 1647 13 the the DT 37231 1647 14 seventy seventy CD 37231 1647 15 angels angel NNS 37231 1647 16 which which WDT 37231 1647 17 stand stand VBP 37231 1647 18 before before IN 37231 1647 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1647 20 : : : 37231 1647 21 Come come VB 37231 1647 22 , , , 37231 1647 23 let let VB 37231 1647 24 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1647 25 go go VB 37231 1647 26 down down RP 37231 1647 27 and and CC 37231 1647 28 confound confound VB 37231 1647 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1647 30 language language NN 37231 1647 31 that that IN 37231 1647 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1647 33 may may MD 37231 1647 34 not not RB 37231 1647 35 understand understand VB 37231 1647 36 each each DT 37231 1647 37 other other JJ 37231 1647 38 . . . 37231 1648 1 And and CC 37231 1648 2 the the DT 37231 1648 3 Word Word NNP 37231 1648 4 of of IN 37231 1648 5 the the DT 37231 1648 6 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1648 7 appeared appear VBD 37231 1648 8 there there RB 37231 1648 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1648 10 at at IN 37231 1648 11 Babel Babel NNP 37231 1648 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1648 13 , , , 37231 1648 14 with with IN 37231 1648 15 the the DT 37231 1648 16 seventy seventy CD 37231 1648 17 angels angel NNS 37231 1648 18 , , , 37231 1648 19 according accord VBG 37231 1648 20 to to IN 37231 1648 21 the the DT 37231 1648 22 seventy seventy CD 37231 1648 23 nations nation NNS 37231 1648 24 , , , 37231 1648 25 and and CC 37231 1648 26 { { -LRB- 37231 1648 27 110 110 CD 37231 1648 28 } } -RRB- 37231 1648 29 each each DT 37231 1648 30 had have VBD 37231 1648 31 the the DT 37231 1648 32 language language NN 37231 1648 33 of of IN 37231 1648 34 the the DT 37231 1648 35 people people NNS 37231 1648 36 which which WDT 37231 1648 37 was be VBD 37231 1648 38 allotted allot VBN 37231 1648 39 to to IN 37231 1648 40 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1648 41 , , , 37231 1648 42 and and CC 37231 1648 43 the the DT 37231 1648 44 record record NN 37231 1648 45 of of IN 37231 1648 46 the the DT 37231 1648 47 writing writing NN 37231 1648 48 in in IN 37231 1648 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1648 50 hand hand NN 37231 1648 51 , , , 37231 1648 52 and and CC 37231 1648 53 scattered scatter VBD 37231 1648 54 the the DT 37231 1648 55 nations nation NNS 37231 1648 56 from from IN 37231 1648 57 thence thence NN 37231 1648 58 over over IN 37231 1648 59 the the DT 37231 1648 60 whole whole JJ 37231 1648 61 earth earth NN 37231 1648 62 , , , 37231 1648 63 in in IN 37231 1648 64 seventy seventy CD 37231 1648 65 languages language NNS 37231 1648 66 , , , 37231 1648 67 so so IN 37231 1648 68 that that IN 37231 1648 69 the the DT 37231 1648 70 one one NN 37231 1648 71 did do VBD 37231 1648 72 not not RB 37231 1648 73 understand understand VB 37231 1648 74 what what WP 37231 1648 75 the the DT 37231 1648 76 other other JJ 37231 1648 77 said say VBD 37231 1648 78 . . . 37231 1649 1 " " `` 37231 1649 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1649 3 l l NN 37231 1649 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1649 5 Michael Michael NNP 37231 1649 6 was be VBD 37231 1649 7 the the DT 37231 1649 8 angel angel NN 37231 1649 9 of of IN 37231 1649 10 the the DT 37231 1649 11 people people NNS 37231 1649 12 of of IN 37231 1649 13 Israel,(2 Israel,(2 NNP 37231 1649 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1649 15 and and CC 37231 1649 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1649 17 is be VBZ 37231 1649 18 always always RB 37231 1649 19 set set VBN 37231 1649 20 in in IN 37231 1649 21 the the DT 37231 1649 22 highest high JJS 37231 1649 23 place place NN 37231 1649 24 amongst amongst IN 37231 1649 25 the the DT 37231 1649 26 angels angel NNS 37231 1649 27 , , , 37231 1649 28 and and CC 37231 1649 29 often often RB 37231 1649 30 called call VBD 37231 1649 31 the the DT 37231 1649 32 High High NNP 37231 1649 33 Priest Priest NNP 37231 1649 34 of of IN 37231 1649 35 Heaven Heaven NNP 37231 1649 36 . . . 37231 1650 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1650 2 3 3 LS 37231 1650 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1650 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1650 5 was be VBD 37231 1650 6 believed believe VBN 37231 1650 7 that that IN 37231 1650 8 the the DT 37231 1650 9 angels angel NNS 37231 1650 10 of of IN 37231 1650 11 the the DT 37231 1650 12 nations nation NNS 37231 1650 13 fought fight VBD 37231 1650 14 in in IN 37231 1650 15 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1650 16 when when WRB 37231 1650 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1650 18 allotted allot VBN 37231 1650 19 peoples people NNS 37231 1650 20 made make VBD 37231 1650 21 war war NN 37231 1650 22 on on IN 37231 1650 23 earth earth NN 37231 1650 24 . . . 37231 1651 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1651 2 see see VBP 37231 1651 3 an an DT 37231 1651 4 allusion allusion NN 37231 1651 5 to to IN 37231 1651 6 this this DT 37231 1651 7 in in IN 37231 1651 8 the the DT 37231 1651 9 Book Book NNP 37231 1651 10 of of IN 37231 1651 11 Daniel,(4 daniel,(4 NN 37231 1651 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1651 13 and and CC 37231 1651 14 in in IN 37231 1651 15 the the DT 37231 1651 16 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 1651 17 there there EX 37231 1651 18 is be VBZ 37231 1651 19 " " `` 37231 1651 20 war war NN 37231 1651 21 in in IN 37231 1651 22 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1651 23 ; ; : 37231 1651 24 Michael Michael NNP 37231 1651 25 and and CC 37231 1651 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1651 27 angels angel NNS 37231 1651 28 fought fight VBD 37231 1651 29 against against IN 37231 1651 30 the the DT 37231 1651 31 dragon dragon NN 37231 1651 32 ; ; : 37231 1651 33 and and CC 37231 1651 34 the the DT 37231 1651 35 dragon dragon NN 37231 1651 36 fought fight VBD 37231 1651 37 , , , 37231 1651 38 and and CC 37231 1651 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1651 40 angels angel NNS 37231 1651 41 . . . 37231 1652 1 " " `` 37231 1652 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1652 3 5 5 LS 37231 1652 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1652 5 The the DT 37231 1652 6 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1652 7 of of IN 37231 1652 8 the the DT 37231 1652 9 time time NN 37231 1652 10 of of IN 37231 1652 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1652 12 not not RB 37231 1652 13 only only RB 37231 1652 14 held hold VBD 37231 1652 15 that that IN 37231 1652 16 there there EX 37231 1652 17 were be VBD 37231 1652 18 angels angel NNS 37231 1652 19 set set VBN 37231 1652 20 over over IN 37231 1652 21 the the DT 37231 1652 22 nations nation NNS 37231 1652 23 , , , 37231 1652 24 but but CC 37231 1652 25 also also RB 37231 1652 26 that that IN 37231 1652 27 each each DT 37231 1652 28 individual individual NN 37231 1652 29 had have VBD 37231 1652 30 a a DT 37231 1652 31 guardian guardian NN 37231 1652 32 angel angel NN 37231 1652 33 . . . 37231 1653 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1653 2 6 6 LS 37231 1653 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1653 4 This this DT 37231 1653 5 belief belief NN 37231 1653 6 appears appear VBZ 37231 1653 7 in in IN 37231 1653 8 several several JJ 37231 1653 9 places place NNS 37231 1653 10 in in IN 37231 1653 11 the the DT 37231 1653 12 New New NNP 37231 1653 13 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1653 14 . . . 37231 1654 1 For for IN 37231 1654 2 instance instance NN 37231 1654 3 , , , 37231 1654 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1654 5 is be VBZ 37231 1654 6 represented represent VBN 37231 1654 7 as as IN 37231 1654 8 saying say VBG 37231 1654 9 of of IN 37231 1654 10 the the DT 37231 1654 11 children child NNS 37231 1654 12 : : : 37231 1654 13 " " `` 37231 1654 14 For for IN 37231 1654 15 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1654 16 say say VBP 37231 1654 17 unto unto IN 37231 1654 18 you -PRON- PRP 37231 1654 19 that that IN 37231 1654 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1654 21 angels angel NNS 37231 1654 22 do do VBP 37231 1654 23 always always RB 37231 1654 24 behold behold VB 37231 1654 25 the the DT 37231 1654 26 face face NN 37231 1654 27 of of IN 37231 1654 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1654 29 Father Father NNP 37231 1654 30 which which WDT 37231 1654 31 is be VBZ 37231 1654 32 in in IN 37231 1654 33 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1654 34 . . . 37231 1655 1 " " `` 37231 1655 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1655 3 7 7 LS 37231 1655 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1655 5 Again again RB 37231 1655 6 , , , 37231 1655 7 in in IN 37231 1655 8 the the DT 37231 1655 9 Acts Acts NNPS 37231 1655 10 of of IN 37231 1655 11 the the DT 37231 1655 12 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 1655 13 , , , 37231 1655 14 when when WRB 37231 1655 15 Peter Peter NNP 37231 1655 16 is be VBZ 37231 1655 17 delivered deliver VBN 37231 1655 18 from from IN 37231 1655 19 prison prison NN 37231 1655 20 by by IN 37231 1655 21 an an DT 37231 1655 22 angel angel NN 37231 1655 23 , , , 37231 1655 24 and and CC 37231 1655 25 comes come VBZ 37231 1655 26 to to IN 37231 1655 27 the the DT 37231 1655 28 house house NN 37231 1655 29 of of IN 37231 1655 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1655 31 friend friend NN 37231 1655 32 , , , 37231 1655 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1655 34 will will MD 37231 1655 35 not not RB 37231 1655 36 believe believe VB 37231 1655 37 the the DT 37231 1655 38 maid maid NN 37231 1655 39 who who WP 37231 1655 40 had have VBD 37231 1655 41 opened open VBN 37231 1655 42 the the DT 37231 1655 43 gate gate NN 37231 1655 44 and and CC 37231 1655 45 seen see VBD 37231 1655 46 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1655 47 , , , 37231 1655 48 but but CC 37231 1655 49 say say VB 37231 1655 50 : : : 37231 1655 51 " " `` 37231 1655 52 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1655 53 is be VBZ 37231 1655 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1655 55 angel angel NN 37231 1655 56 " " '' 37231 1655 57 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1655 58 --Greek--].8 --Greek--].8 . 37231 1655 59 The the DT 37231 1655 60 passage passage NN 37231 1655 61 in in IN 37231 1655 62 the the DT 37231 1655 63 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 1655 64 to to IN 37231 1655 65 the the DT 37231 1655 66 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 1655 67 will will MD 37231 1655 68 likewise likewise RB 37231 1655 69 be be VB 37231 1655 70 remembered remember VBN 37231 1655 71 , , , 37231 1655 72 where where WRB 37231 1655 73 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1655 74 is be VBZ 37231 1655 75 said say VBN 37231 1655 76 of of IN 37231 1655 77 the the DT 37231 1655 78 angels angel NNS 37231 1655 79 : : : 37231 1655 80 " " `` 37231 1655 81 Are be VBP 37231 1655 82 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1655 83 not not RB 37231 1655 84 all all DT 37231 1655 85 ministering minister VBG 37231 1655 86 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1655 87 sent send VBN 37231 1655 88 forth forth RB 37231 1655 89 for for IN 37231 1655 90 ministry ministry NN 37231 1655 91 on on IN 37231 1655 92 { { -LRB- 37231 1655 93 111 111 CD 37231 1655 94 } } -RRB- 37231 1655 95 account account NN 37231 1655 96 of of IN 37231 1655 97 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1655 98 who who WP 37231 1655 99 shall shall MD 37231 1655 100 be be VB 37231 1655 101 heirs heir NNS 37231 1655 102 of of IN 37231 1655 103 salvation salvation NN 37231 1655 104 . . . 37231 1656 1 " " `` 37231 1656 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1656 3 1 1 LS 37231 1656 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1656 5 There there EX 37231 1656 6 was be VBD 37231 1656 7 at at IN 37231 1656 8 the the DT 37231 1656 9 same same JJ 37231 1656 10 time time NN 37231 1656 11 a a DT 37231 1656 12 singular singular JJ 37231 1656 13 belief belief NN 37231 1656 14 that that IN 37231 1656 15 when when WRB 37231 1656 16 any any DT 37231 1656 17 person person NN 37231 1656 18 went go VBD 37231 1656 19 into into IN 37231 1656 20 the the DT 37231 1656 21 private private JJ 37231 1656 22 closet closet NN 37231 1656 23 , , , 37231 1656 24 the the DT 37231 1656 25 guardian guardian NN 37231 1656 26 angel angel NN 37231 1656 27 remained remain VBD 37231 1656 28 at at IN 37231 1656 29 the the DT 37231 1656 30 door door NN 37231 1656 31 till till IN 37231 1656 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1656 33 came come VBD 37231 1656 34 out out RP 37231 1656 35 again again RB 37231 1656 36 , , , 37231 1656 37 and and CC 37231 1656 38 in in IN 37231 1656 39 the the DT 37231 1656 40 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1656 41 a a DT 37231 1656 42 prayer prayer NN 37231 1656 43 is be VBZ 37231 1656 44 given give VBN 37231 1656 45 for for IN 37231 1656 46 strength strength NN 37231 1656 47 and and CC 37231 1656 48 help help NN 37231 1656 49 under under IN 37231 1656 50 the the DT 37231 1656 51 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1656 52 , , , 37231 1656 53 and and CC 37231 1656 54 that that IN 37231 1656 55 the the DT 37231 1656 56 guardian guardian NN 37231 1656 57 angel angel NN 37231 1656 58 may may MD 37231 1656 59 wait wait VB 37231 1656 60 while while IN 37231 1656 61 the the DT 37231 1656 62 person person NN 37231 1656 63 is be VBZ 37231 1656 64 there there RB 37231 1656 65 . . . 37231 1657 1 The the DT 37231 1657 2 reason reason NN 37231 1657 3 why why WRB 37231 1657 4 the the DT 37231 1657 5 angel angel NN 37231 1657 6 does do VBZ 37231 1657 7 not not RB 37231 1657 8 enter enter VB 37231 1657 9 is be VBZ 37231 1657 10 that that IN 37231 1657 11 such such JJ 37231 1657 12 places place NNS 37231 1657 13 are be VBP 37231 1657 14 haunted haunt VBN 37231 1657 15 by by IN 37231 1657 16 demons demon NNS 37231 1657 17 . . . 37231 1658 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1658 2 2 2 LS 37231 1658 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1658 4 The the DT 37231 1658 5 belief belief NN 37231 1658 6 in in IN 37231 1658 7 demons demon NNS 37231 1658 8 at at IN 37231 1658 9 the the DT 37231 1658 10 time time NN 37231 1658 11 of of IN 37231 1658 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1658 13 was be VBD 37231 1658 14 equally equally RB 37231 1658 15 emphatic emphatic JJ 37231 1658 16 and and CC 37231 1658 17 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 37231 1658 18 , , , 37231 1658 19 and and CC 37231 1658 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1658 21 need need VBP 37231 1658 22 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1658 23 mention mention VB 37231 1658 24 that that IN 37231 1658 25 the the DT 37231 1658 26 New New NNP 37231 1658 27 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1658 28 is be VBZ 37231 1658 29 full full JJ 37231 1658 30 of of IN 37231 1658 31 references reference NNS 37231 1658 32 to to IN 37231 1658 33 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1658 34 . . . 37231 1659 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1659 2 3 3 LS 37231 1659 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1659 4 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1659 5 are be VBP 37231 1659 6 in in IN 37231 1659 7 the the DT 37231 1659 8 air air NN 37231 1659 9 , , , 37231 1659 10 on on IN 37231 1659 11 earth earth NN 37231 1659 12 , , , 37231 1659 13 in in IN 37231 1659 14 the the DT 37231 1659 15 bodies body NNS 37231 1659 16 of of IN 37231 1659 17 men man NNS 37231 1659 18 and and CC 37231 1659 19 animals animal NNS 37231 1659 20 , , , 37231 1659 21 and and CC 37231 1659 22 even even RB 37231 1659 23 at at IN 37231 1659 24 the the DT 37231 1659 25 bottom bottom NN 37231 1659 26 of of IN 37231 1659 27 the the DT 37231 1659 28 sea sea NN 37231 1659 29 . . . 37231 1660 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1660 2 4 4 LS 37231 1660 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1660 4 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1660 5 are be VBP 37231 1660 6 the the DT 37231 1660 7 offspring offspring NN 37231 1660 8 of of IN 37231 1660 9 the the DT 37231 1660 10 fallen fall VBN 37231 1660 11 angels angel NNS 37231 1660 12 who who WP 37231 1660 13 loved love VBD 37231 1660 14 the the DT 37231 1660 15 daughters daughter NNS 37231 1660 16 of of IN 37231 1660 17 men man NNS 37231 1660 18 . . . 37231 1661 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1661 2 5 5 LS 37231 1661 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1661 4 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1661 5 have have VBP 37231 1661 6 wings wing NNS 37231 1661 7 like like IN 37231 1661 8 the the DT 37231 1661 9 angels angel NNS 37231 1661 10 , , , 37231 1661 11 and and CC 37231 1661 12 can can MD 37231 1661 13 fly fly VB 37231 1661 14 from from IN 37231 1661 15 one one CD 37231 1661 16 end end NN 37231 1661 17 of of IN 37231 1661 18 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1661 19 to to IN 37231 1661 20 another another DT 37231 1661 21 ; ; : 37231 1661 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1661 23 obtain obtain VBP 37231 1661 24 a a DT 37231 1661 25 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1661 26 of of IN 37231 1661 27 the the DT 37231 1661 28 future future NN 37231 1661 29 , , , 37231 1661 30 like like IN 37231 1661 31 the the DT 37231 1661 32 angels angel NNS 37231 1661 33 , , , 37231 1661 34 by by IN 37231 1661 35 listening listen VBG 37231 1661 36 behind behind IN 37231 1661 37 the the DT 37231 1661 38 veil veil NN 37231 1661 39 of of IN 37231 1661 40 the the DT 37231 1661 41 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1661 42 of of IN 37231 1661 43 God God NNP 37231 1661 44 in in IN 37231 1661 45 Heaven Heaven NNP 37231 1661 46 . . . 37231 1662 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1662 2 6 6 LS 37231 1662 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1662 4 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1662 5 number number NN 37231 1662 6 is be VBZ 37231 1662 7 infinite infinite JJ 37231 1662 8 . . . 37231 1663 1 The the DT 37231 1663 2 earth earth NN 37231 1663 3 is be VBZ 37231 1663 4 so so RB 37231 1663 5 full full JJ 37231 1663 6 of of IN 37231 1663 7 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1663 8 that that IN 37231 1663 9 if if IN 37231 1663 10 man man NN 37231 1663 11 had have VBD 37231 1663 12 power power NN 37231 1663 13 to to TO 37231 1663 14 see see VB 37231 1663 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1663 16 could could MD 37231 1663 17 not not RB 37231 1663 18 exist exist VB 37231 1663 19 , , , 37231 1663 20 on on IN 37231 1663 21 account account NN 37231 1663 22 of of IN 37231 1663 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1663 24 ; ; : 37231 1663 25 there there EX 37231 1663 26 are be VBP 37231 1663 27 more more JJR 37231 1663 28 demons demon NNS 37231 1663 29 than than IN 37231 1663 30 men man NNS 37231 1663 31 , , , 37231 1663 32 and and CC 37231 1663 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1663 34 are be VBP 37231 1663 35 about about RB 37231 1663 36 as as RB 37231 1663 37 close close JJ 37231 1663 38 as as IN 37231 1663 39 the the DT 37231 1663 40 earth earth NN 37231 1663 41 thrown throw VBN 37231 1663 42 up up RP 37231 1663 43 out out IN 37231 1663 44 of of IN 37231 1663 45 a a DT 37231 1663 46 newly newly RB 37231 1663 47 - - HYPH 37231 1663 48 made make VBN 37231 1663 49 grave grave NN 37231 1663 50 . . . 37231 1664 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1664 2 7 7 LS 37231 1664 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1664 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1664 5 is be VBZ 37231 1664 6 stated state VBN 37231 1664 7 that that IN 37231 1664 8 each each DT 37231 1664 9 man man NN 37231 1664 10 has have VBZ 37231 1664 11 10,000 10,000 CD 37231 1664 12 demons demon NNS 37231 1664 13 at at IN 37231 1664 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1664 15 right right JJ 37231 1664 16 hand hand NN 37231 1664 17 , , , 37231 1664 18 and and CC 37231 1664 19 1,000 1,000 CD 37231 1664 20 on on IN 37231 1664 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1664 22 left left NN 37231 1664 23 , , , 37231 1664 24 and and CC 37231 1664 25 the the DT 37231 1664 26 passage passage NN 37231 1664 27 continues continue VBZ 37231 1664 28 : : : 37231 1664 29 " " `` 37231 1664 30 The the DT 37231 1664 31 crush crush NN 37231 1664 32 on on IN 37231 1664 33 the the DT 37231 1664 34 Sabbath Sabbath NNP 37231 1664 35 in in IN 37231 1664 36 the the DT 37231 1664 37 Synagogue Synagogue NNP 37231 1664 38 arises arise VBZ 37231 1664 39 from from IN 37231 1664 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1664 41 , , , 37231 1664 42 also also RB 37231 1664 43 the the DT 37231 1664 44 dresses dress NNS 37231 1664 45 of of IN 37231 1664 46 the the DT 37231 1664 47 Rabbins Rabbins NNPS 37231 1664 48 become become VBN 37231 1664 49 so so RB 37231 1664 50 soon soon RB 37231 1664 51 old old JJ 37231 1664 52 and and CC 37231 1664 53 torn tear VBD 37231 1664 54 through through IN 37231 1664 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1664 56 rubbing rubbing NN 37231 1664 57 ; ; : 37231 1664 58 in in IN 37231 1664 59 like like IN 37231 1664 60 manner manner NN 37231 1664 61 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1664 62 cause cause VBP 37231 1664 63 the the DT 37231 1664 64 tottering tottering NN 37231 1664 65 of of IN 37231 1664 66 the the DT 37231 1664 67 feet foot NNS 37231 1664 68 . . . 37231 1665 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1665 2 who who WP 37231 1665 3 wishes wish VBZ 37231 1665 4 to to TO 37231 1665 5 discover discover VB 37231 1665 6 these these DT 37231 1665 7 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1665 8 must must MD 37231 1665 9 take take VB 37231 1665 10 sifted sift VBN 37231 1665 11 ashes ashe NNS 37231 1665 12 and and CC 37231 1665 13 strew strew VBD 37231 1665 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1665 15 about about IN 37231 1665 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1665 17 bed bed NN 37231 1665 18 , , , 37231 1665 19 and and CC 37231 1665 20 in in IN 37231 1665 21 the the DT 37231 1665 22 morning morning NN 37231 1665 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1665 24 will will MD 37231 1665 25 perceive perceive VB 37231 1665 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1665 27 footprints footprint NNS 37231 1665 28 upon upon IN 37231 1665 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1665 30 like like IN 37231 1665 31 a a DT 37231 1665 32 cock cock NN 37231 1665 33 's 's POS 37231 1665 34 tread tread NN 37231 1665 35 . . . 37231 1666 1 If if IN 37231 1666 2 any any DT 37231 1666 3 one one CD 37231 1666 4 wish wish NN 37231 1666 5 to to TO 37231 1666 6 see see VB 37231 1666 7 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1666 8 , , , 37231 1666 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1666 10 must must MD 37231 1666 11 take take VB 37231 1666 12 the the DT 37231 1666 13 afterbirth afterbirth NN 37231 1666 14 of of IN 37231 1666 15 a a DT 37231 1666 16 black black JJ 37231 1666 17 cat cat NN 37231 1666 18 , , , 37231 1666 19 which which WDT 37231 1666 20 has have VBZ 37231 1666 21 been be VBN 37231 1666 22 littered litter VBN 37231 1666 23 by by IN 37231 1666 24 a a DT 37231 1666 25 first first RB 37231 1666 26 - - HYPH 37231 1666 27 born bear VBN 37231 1666 28 black black JJ 37231 1666 29 cat cat NN 37231 1666 30 , , , 37231 1666 31 whose whose WP$ 37231 1666 32 mother mother NN 37231 1666 33 was be VBD 37231 1666 34 also also RB 37231 1666 35 a a DT 37231 1666 36 first first JJ 37231 1666 37 - - HYPH 37231 1666 38 birth birth NN 37231 1666 39 , , , 37231 1666 40 burn burn VB 37231 1666 41 and and CC 37231 1666 42 reduce reduce VB 37231 1666 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1666 44 to to IN 37231 1666 45 powder powder VB 37231 1666 46 , , , 37231 1666 47 and and CC 37231 1666 48 put put VBD 37231 1666 49 some some DT 37231 1666 50 of of IN 37231 1666 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1666 52 in in IN 37231 1666 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1666 54 eyes eye NNS 37231 1666 55 , , , 37231 1666 56 and and CC 37231 1666 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1666 58 will will MD 37231 1666 59 see see VB 37231 1666 60 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1666 61 . . . 37231 1667 1 " " `` 37231 1667 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1667 3 l l NN 37231 1667 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1667 5 Sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1667 6 demons demon NNS 37231 1667 7 assume assume VBP 37231 1667 8 the the DT 37231 1667 9 form form NN 37231 1667 10 of of IN 37231 1667 11 a a DT 37231 1667 12 goat goat NN 37231 1667 13 . . . 37231 1668 1 Evil evil JJ 37231 1668 2 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1668 3 fly fly VBP 37231 1668 4 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 1668 5 during during IN 37231 1668 6 the the DT 37231 1668 7 darkness darkness NN 37231 1668 8 , , , 37231 1668 9 for for IN 37231 1668 10 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1668 11 are be VBP 37231 1668 12 children child NNS 37231 1668 13 of of IN 37231 1668 14 night night NN 37231 1668 15 . . . 37231 1669 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1669 2 2 2 LS 37231 1669 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1669 4 For for IN 37231 1669 5 this this DT 37231 1669 6 reason reason NN 37231 1669 7 the the DT 37231 1669 8 Talmud talmud JJ 37231 1669 9 states state NNS 37231 1669 10 that that IN 37231 1669 11 men man NNS 37231 1669 12 are be VBP 37231 1669 13 forbidden forbid VBN 37231 1669 14 to to TO 37231 1669 15 greet greet VB 37231 1669 16 any any DT 37231 1669 17 one one CD 37231 1669 18 by by IN 37231 1669 19 night night NN 37231 1669 20 , , , 37231 1669 21 lest lest IN 37231 1669 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1669 23 might may MD 37231 1669 24 be be VB 37231 1669 25 a a DT 37231 1669 26 devil,(3 devil,(3 NN 37231 1669 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1669 28 or or CC 37231 1669 29 to to TO 37231 1669 30 go go VB 37231 1669 31 out out RP 37231 1669 32 alone alone RB 37231 1669 33 even even RB 37231 1669 34 by by IN 37231 1669 35 day day NN 37231 1669 36 , , , 37231 1669 37 but but CC 37231 1669 38 much much RB 37231 1669 39 more more JJR 37231 1669 40 by by IN 37231 1669 41 night night NN 37231 1669 42 , , , 37231 1669 43 into into IN 37231 1669 44 solitary solitary JJ 37231 1669 45 places place NNS 37231 1669 46 . . . 37231 1670 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1670 2 4 4 LS 37231 1670 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1670 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1670 5 was be VBD 37231 1670 6 likewise likewise RB 37231 1670 7 forbidden forbid VBN 37231 1670 8 for for IN 37231 1670 9 any any DT 37231 1670 10 man man NN 37231 1670 11 to to TO 37231 1670 12 sleep sleep VB 37231 1670 13 alone alone RB 37231 1670 14 in in IN 37231 1670 15 a a DT 37231 1670 16 house house NN 37231 1670 17 , , , 37231 1670 18 because because IN 37231 1670 19 any any DT 37231 1670 20 one one NN 37231 1670 21 so so RB 37231 1670 22 doing do VBG 37231 1670 23 would would MD 37231 1670 24 be be VB 37231 1670 25 seized seize VBN 37231 1670 26 by by IN 37231 1670 27 the the DT 37231 1670 28 she she NNP 37231 1670 29 - - HYPH 37231 1670 30 devil devil NNP 37231 1670 31 Lilith Lilith NNP 37231 1670 32 , , , 37231 1670 33 and and CC 37231 1670 34 die die VB 37231 1670 35 . . . 37231 1671 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1671 2 5 5 LS 37231 1671 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1671 4 Further further RB 37231 1671 5 , , , 37231 1671 6 no no DT 37231 1671 7 man man NN 37231 1671 8 should should MD 37231 1671 9 drink drink VB 37231 1671 10 water water NN 37231 1671 11 by by IN 37231 1671 12 night night NN 37231 1671 13 on on IN 37231 1671 14 account account NN 37231 1671 15 of of IN 37231 1671 16 the the DT 37231 1671 17 demon demon NN 37231 1671 18 Schafriri Schafriri NNP 37231 1671 19 , , , 37231 1671 20 the the DT 37231 1671 21 angel angel NN 37231 1671 22 of of IN 37231 1671 23 blindness blindness NN 37231 1671 24 . . . 37231 1672 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1672 2 6 6 CD 37231 1672 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1672 4 { { -LRB- 37231 1672 5 113 113 CD 37231 1672 6 } } -RRB- 37231 1672 7 An an DT 37231 1672 8 evil evil JJ 37231 1672 9 spirit spirit NN 37231 1672 10 descended descend VBD 37231 1672 11 on on IN 37231 1672 12 any any DT 37231 1672 13 one one NN 37231 1672 14 going go VBG 37231 1672 15 into into IN 37231 1672 16 a a DT 37231 1672 17 cemetery cemetery NN 37231 1672 18 by by IN 37231 1672 19 night night NN 37231 1672 20 . . . 37231 1673 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1673 2 1 1 LS 37231 1673 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1673 4 A a DT 37231 1673 5 necromancer necromancer NN 37231 1673 6 is be VBZ 37231 1673 7 defined define VBN 37231 1673 8 as as IN 37231 1673 9 one one CD 37231 1673 10 who who WP 37231 1673 11 fasts fast VBZ 37231 1673 12 and and CC 37231 1673 13 lodges lodge NNS 37231 1673 14 at at IN 37231 1673 15 night night NN 37231 1673 16 amongst amongst IN 37231 1673 17 tombs tomb NNS 37231 1673 18 in in IN 37231 1673 19 order order NN 37231 1673 20 that that IN 37231 1673 21 the the DT 37231 1673 22 evil evil JJ 37231 1673 23 spirit spirit NN 37231 1673 24 may may MD 37231 1673 25 come come VB 37231 1673 26 upon upon IN 37231 1673 27 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1673 28 . . . 37231 1674 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1674 2 2 2 LS 37231 1674 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1674 4 Demons demon NNS 37231 1674 5 , , , 37231 1674 6 however however RB 37231 1674 7 , , , 37231 1674 8 take take VB 37231 1674 9 more more JJR 37231 1674 10 especial especial JJ 37231 1674 11 delight delight NN 37231 1674 12 in in IN 37231 1674 13 foul foul JJ 37231 1674 14 and and CC 37231 1674 15 offensive offensive JJ 37231 1674 16 places place NNS 37231 1674 17 , , , 37231 1674 18 and and CC 37231 1674 19 an an DT 37231 1674 20 evil evil JJ 37231 1674 21 spirit spirit NN 37231 1674 22 inhabits inhabit VBZ 37231 1674 23 every every DT 37231 1674 24 private private JJ 37231 1674 25 closet closet NN 37231 1674 26 in in IN 37231 1674 27 the the DT 37231 1674 28 world world NN 37231 1674 29 . . . 37231 1675 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1675 2 3 3 LS 37231 1675 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1675 4 Demons demon NNS 37231 1675 5 haunt haunt VBP 37231 1675 6 deserted desert VBN 37231 1675 7 places place NNS 37231 1675 8 , , , 37231 1675 9 ruins ruin NNS 37231 1675 10 , , , 37231 1675 11 graves grave NNS 37231 1675 12 , , , 37231 1675 13 and and CC 37231 1675 14 certain certain JJ 37231 1675 15 kinds kind NNS 37231 1675 16 of of IN 37231 1675 17 trees tree NNS 37231 1675 18 . . . 37231 1676 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1676 2 4 4 LS 37231 1676 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1676 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1676 5 find find VBP 37231 1676 6 indications indication NNS 37231 1676 7 of of IN 37231 1676 8 these these DT 37231 1676 9 superstitions superstition NNS 37231 1676 10 throughout throughout IN 37231 1676 11 the the DT 37231 1676 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1676 13 . . . 37231 1677 1 The the DT 37231 1677 2 possessed possess VBN 37231 1677 3 are be VBP 37231 1677 4 represented represent VBN 37231 1677 5 as as IN 37231 1677 6 dwelling dwell VBG 37231 1677 7 among among IN 37231 1677 8 the the DT 37231 1677 9 tombs tomb NNS 37231 1677 10 , , , 37231 1677 11 and and CC 37231 1677 12 being be VBG 37231 1677 13 driven drive VBN 37231 1677 14 by by IN 37231 1677 15 the the DT 37231 1677 16 unclean unclean JJ 37231 1677 17 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1677 18 into into IN 37231 1677 19 the the DT 37231 1677 20 wilderness wilderness NN 37231 1677 21 , , , 37231 1677 22 and and CC 37231 1677 23 the the DT 37231 1677 24 demons demon NNS 37231 1677 25 can can MD 37231 1677 26 find find VB 37231 1677 27 no no DT 37231 1677 28 rest rest NN 37231 1677 29 in in IN 37231 1677 30 clean clean JJ 37231 1677 31 places place NNS 37231 1677 32 . . . 37231 1678 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1678 2 5 5 LS 37231 1678 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1678 4 Demons demon NNS 37231 1678 5 also also RB 37231 1678 6 frequented frequent VBD 37231 1678 7 springs spring NNS 37231 1678 8 and and CC 37231 1678 9 fountains fountain NNS 37231 1678 10 . . . 37231 1679 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1679 2 6 6 LS 37231 1679 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1679 4 The the DT 37231 1679 5 episode episode NN 37231 1679 6 of of IN 37231 1679 7 the the DT 37231 1679 8 angel angel NN 37231 1679 9 who who WP 37231 1679 10 was be VBD 37231 1679 11 said say VBN 37231 1679 12 to to TO 37231 1679 13 descend descend VB 37231 1679 14 at at IN 37231 1679 15 certain certain JJ 37231 1679 16 seasons season NNS 37231 1679 17 and and CC 37231 1679 18 trouble trouble NN 37231 1679 19 the the DT 37231 1679 20 water water NN 37231 1679 21 of of IN 37231 1679 22 the the DT 37231 1679 23 pool pool NN 37231 1679 24 of of IN 37231 1679 25 Bethesda Bethesda NNP 37231 1679 26 , , , 37231 1679 27 so so IN 37231 1679 28 that that IN 37231 1679 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1679 30 who who WP 37231 1679 31 first first RB 37231 1679 32 stepped step VBD 37231 1679 33 in in IN 37231 1679 34 was be VBD 37231 1679 35 cured cure VBN 37231 1679 36 of of IN 37231 1679 37 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1679 38 disease disease NN 37231 1679 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1679 40 had have VBD 37231 1679 41 , , , 37231 1679 42 may may MD 37231 1679 43 be be VB 37231 1679 44 mentioned mention VBN 37231 1679 45 here here RB 37231 1679 46 in in IN 37231 1679 47 passing pass VBG 37231 1679 48 , , , 37231 1679 49 although although IN 37231 1679 50 the the DT 37231 1679 51 passage passage NN 37231 1679 52 is be VBZ 37231 1679 53 not not RB 37231 1679 54 found find VBN 37231 1679 55 in in IN 37231 1679 56 some some DT 37231 1679 57 of of IN 37231 1679 58 the the DT 37231 1679 59 older old JJR 37231 1679 60 MSS MSS NNP 37231 1679 61 . . . 37231 1680 1 of of IN 37231 1680 2 the the DT 37231 1680 3 fourth fourth JJ 37231 1680 4 Gospel,(7 Gospel,(7 NNS 37231 1680 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1680 6 and and CC 37231 1680 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1680 8 is be VBZ 37231 1680 9 argued argue VBN 37231 1680 10 by by IN 37231 1680 11 some some DT 37231 1680 12 that that IN 37231 1680 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1680 14 is be VBZ 37231 1680 15 a a DT 37231 1680 16 later later JJ 37231 1680 17 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 1680 18 . . . 37231 1681 1 There there EX 37231 1681 2 were be VBD 37231 1681 3 demons demon NNS 37231 1681 4 who who WP 37231 1681 5 hurt hurt VBP 37231 1681 6 those those DT 37231 1681 7 who who WP 37231 1681 8 did do VBD 37231 1681 9 not not RB 37231 1681 10 wash wash VB 37231 1681 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1681 12 hands hand NNS 37231 1681 13 before before IN 37231 1681 14 meat meat NN 37231 1681 15 . . . 37231 1682 1 " " `` 37231 1682 2 Shibta Shibta NNP 37231 1682 3 is be VBZ 37231 1682 4 an an DT 37231 1682 5 evil evil JJ 37231 1682 6 spirit spirit NN 37231 1682 7 which which WDT 37231 1682 8 sits sit VBZ 37231 1682 9 upon upon IN 37231 1682 10 men man NNS 37231 1682 11 's 's POS 37231 1682 12 hands hand NNS 37231 1682 13 in in IN 37231 1682 14 the the DT 37231 1682 15 night night NN 37231 1682 16 ; ; : 37231 1682 17 and and CC 37231 1682 18 if if IN 37231 1682 19 any any DT 37231 1682 20 touch touch NN 37231 1682 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1682 22 food food NN 37231 1682 23 with with IN 37231 1682 24 unwashen unwashen JJ 37231 1682 25 hands hand NNS 37231 1682 26 , , , 37231 1682 27 that that DT 37231 1682 28 spirit spirit NNP 37231 1682 29 sits sit VBZ 37231 1682 30 upon upon IN 37231 1682 31 that that DT 37231 1682 32 food food NN 37231 1682 33 , , , 37231 1682 34 and and CC 37231 1682 35 there there EX 37231 1682 36 is be VBZ 37231 1682 37 danger danger NN 37231 1682 38 from from IN 37231 1682 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1682 40 . . . 37231 1683 1 " " `` 37231 1683 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1683 3 8 8 CD 37231 1683 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1683 5 { { -LRB- 37231 1683 6 114 114 CD 37231 1683 7 } } -RRB- 37231 1683 8 The the DT 37231 1683 9 demon demon NN 37231 1683 10 Asmodeus Asmodeus NNP 37231 1683 11 is be VBZ 37231 1683 12 frequently frequently RB 37231 1683 13 called call VBN 37231 1683 14 the the DT 37231 1683 15 king king NN 37231 1683 16 of of IN 37231 1683 17 the the DT 37231 1683 18 devils,(1 devils,(1 NNP 37231 1683 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1683 20 and and CC 37231 1683 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1683 22 was be VBD 37231 1683 23 believed believe VBN 37231 1683 24 that that IN 37231 1683 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1683 26 tempted tempt VBD 37231 1683 27 people people NNS 37231 1683 28 to to TO 37231 1683 29 apostatize apostatize VB 37231 1683 30 ; ; : 37231 1683 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1683 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1683 33 was be VBD 37231 1683 34 who who WP 37231 1683 35 enticed entice VBD 37231 1683 36 Noah Noah NNP 37231 1683 37 into into IN 37231 1683 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1683 39 drunkenness drunkenness NN 37231 1683 40 , , , 37231 1683 41 and and CC 37231 1683 42 led lead VBD 37231 1683 43 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1683 44 into into IN 37231 1683 45 sin sin NN 37231 1683 46 . . . 37231 1684 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1684 2 2 2 LS 37231 1684 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1684 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1684 5 is be VBZ 37231 1684 6 represented represent VBN 37231 1684 7 as as IN 37231 1684 8 alternately alternately RB 37231 1684 9 ascending ascend VBG 37231 1684 10 to to TO 37231 1684 11 study study VB 37231 1684 12 in in IN 37231 1684 13 the the DT 37231 1684 14 School School NNP 37231 1684 15 of of IN 37231 1684 16 the the DT 37231 1684 17 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 1684 18 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 1684 19 , , , 37231 1684 20 and and CC 37231 1684 21 descending descend VBG 37231 1684 22 to to TO 37231 1684 23 study study VB 37231 1684 24 in in IN 37231 1684 25 the the DT 37231 1684 26 school school NN 37231 1684 27 of of IN 37231 1684 28 the the DT 37231 1684 29 earth earth NN 37231 1684 30 . . . 37231 1685 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1685 2 3 3 LS 37231 1685 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1685 4 The the DT 37231 1685 5 injury injury NN 37231 1685 6 of of IN 37231 1685 7 the the DT 37231 1685 8 human human JJ 37231 1685 9 race race NN 37231 1685 10 in in IN 37231 1685 11 every every DT 37231 1685 12 possible possible JJ 37231 1685 13 way way NN 37231 1685 14 was be VBD 37231 1685 15 believed believe VBN 37231 1685 16 to to TO 37231 1685 17 be be VB 37231 1685 18 the the DT 37231 1685 19 chief chief JJ 37231 1685 20 delight delight NN 37231 1685 21 of of IN 37231 1685 22 evil evil JJ 37231 1685 23 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1685 24 . . . 37231 1686 1 The the DT 37231 1686 2 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1686 3 and and CC 37231 1686 4 other other JJ 37231 1686 5 Rabbinical rabbinical JJ 37231 1686 6 writings writing NNS 37231 1686 7 are be VBP 37231 1686 8 full full JJ 37231 1686 9 of of IN 37231 1686 10 references reference NNS 37231 1686 11 to to IN 37231 1686 12 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1686 13 possession possession NN 37231 1686 14 , , , 37231 1686 15 but but CC 37231 1686 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1686 17 need need VBP 37231 1686 18 not not RB 37231 1686 19 enter enter VB 37231 1686 20 into into IN 37231 1686 21 details detail NNS 37231 1686 22 upon upon IN 37231 1686 23 this this DT 37231 1686 24 point point NN 37231 1686 25 , , , 37231 1686 26 as as IN 37231 1686 27 the the DT 37231 1686 28 New New NNP 37231 1686 29 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1686 30 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1686 31 presents present VBZ 37231 1686 32 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1686 33 evidence evidence NN 37231 1686 34 regarding regard VBG 37231 1686 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1686 36 . . . 37231 1687 1 Not not RB 37231 1687 2 only only RB 37231 1687 3 one one CD 37231 1687 4 evil evil JJ 37231 1687 5 spirit spirit NN 37231 1687 6 could could MD 37231 1687 7 enter enter VB 37231 1687 8 into into IN 37231 1687 9 a a DT 37231 1687 10 body body NN 37231 1687 11 , , , 37231 1687 12 but but CC 37231 1687 13 many many JJ 37231 1687 14 took take VBD 37231 1687 15 possession possession NN 37231 1687 16 of of IN 37231 1687 17 the the DT 37231 1687 18 same same JJ 37231 1687 19 individual individual NN 37231 1687 20 . . . 37231 1688 1 There there EX 37231 1688 2 are be VBP 37231 1688 3 many many JJ 37231 1688 4 instances instance NNS 37231 1688 5 mentioned mention VBN 37231 1688 6 in in IN 37231 1688 7 the the DT 37231 1688 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1688 9 , , , 37231 1688 10 such such JJ 37231 1688 11 as as IN 37231 1688 12 Mary Mary NNP 37231 1688 13 Magdalene Magdalene NNP 37231 1688 14 , , , 37231 1688 15 " " '' 37231 1688 16 out out IN 37231 1688 17 of of IN 37231 1688 18 whom whom WP 37231 1688 19 went go VBD 37231 1688 20 seven seven CD 37231 1688 21 demons demon NNS 37231 1688 22 " " '' 37231 1688 23 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1688 24 --Greek--],4 --Greek--],4 : 37231 1688 25 and and CC 37231 1688 26 the the DT 37231 1688 27 man man NN 37231 1688 28 whose whose WP$ 37231 1688 29 name name NN 37231 1688 30 was be VBD 37231 1688 31 Legion Legion NNP 37231 1688 32 , , , 37231 1688 33 because because IN 37231 1688 34 " " `` 37231 1688 35 many many JJ 37231 1688 36 demons demon NNS 37231 1688 37 " " '' 37231 1688 38 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1688 39 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1688 40 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1688 41 were be VBD 37231 1688 42 entered enter VBN 37231 1688 43 into into IN 37231 1688 44 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1688 45 . . . 37231 1689 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1689 2 5 5 LS 37231 1689 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1689 4 Demons demon NNS 37231 1689 5 likewise likewise RB 37231 1689 6 entered enter VBD 37231 1689 7 into into IN 37231 1689 8 the the DT 37231 1689 9 bodies body NNS 37231 1689 10 of of IN 37231 1689 11 animals animal NNS 37231 1689 12 , , , 37231 1689 13 and and CC 37231 1689 14 in in IN 37231 1689 15 the the DT 37231 1689 16 narrative narrative NN 37231 1689 17 to to TO 37231 1689 18 which which WDT 37231 1689 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1689 20 have have VBP 37231 1689 21 just just RB 37231 1689 22 referred refer VBN 37231 1689 23 , , , 37231 1689 24 the the DT 37231 1689 25 demons demon NNS 37231 1689 26 , , , 37231 1689 27 on on IN 37231 1689 28 being be VBG 37231 1689 29 expelled expel VBN 37231 1689 30 from from IN 37231 1689 31 the the DT 37231 1689 32 man man NN 37231 1689 33 , , , 37231 1689 34 request request VBP 37231 1689 35 that that IN 37231 1689 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1689 37 may may MD 37231 1689 38 be be VB 37231 1689 39 allowed allow VBN 37231 1689 40 to to TO 37231 1689 41 enter enter VB 37231 1689 42 into into IN 37231 1689 43 the the DT 37231 1689 44 herd herd NN 37231 1689 45 of of IN 37231 1689 46 swine swine NNS 37231 1689 47 , , , 37231 1689 48 which which WDT 37231 1689 49 being be VBG 37231 1689 50 permitted permit VBN 37231 1689 51 , , , 37231 1689 52 " " '' 37231 1689 53 the the DT 37231 1689 54 demons demon NNS 37231 1689 55 went go VBD 37231 1689 56 out out IN 37231 1689 57 of of IN 37231 1689 58 { { -LRB- 37231 1689 59 115 115 CD 37231 1689 60 } } -RRB- 37231 1689 61 the the DT 37231 1689 62 man man NN 37231 1689 63 into into IN 37231 1689 64 the the DT 37231 1689 65 swine swine NN 37231 1689 66 , , , 37231 1689 67 and and CC 37231 1689 68 the the DT 37231 1689 69 herd herd NN 37231 1689 70 ran run VBD 37231 1689 71 violently violently RB 37231 1689 72 down down IN 37231 1689 73 the the DT 37231 1689 74 cliff cliff NN 37231 1689 75 into into IN 37231 1689 76 the the DT 37231 1689 77 lake lake NN 37231 1689 78 , , , 37231 1689 79 and and CC 37231 1689 80 were be VBD 37231 1689 81 drowned,"(1 drowned,"(1 , 37231 1689 82 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1689 83 the the DT 37231 1689 84 evil evil JJ 37231 1689 85 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1689 86 , , , 37231 1689 87 as as IN 37231 1689 88 usual usual JJ 37231 1689 89 , , , 37231 1689 90 taking take VBG 37231 1689 91 pleasure pleasure NN 37231 1689 92 only only RB 37231 1689 93 in in IN 37231 1689 94 the the DT 37231 1689 95 destruction destruction NN 37231 1689 96 and and CC 37231 1689 97 injury injury NN 37231 1689 98 of of IN 37231 1689 99 man man NN 37231 1689 100 and and CC 37231 1689 101 beast beast NN 37231 1689 102 . . . 37231 1690 1 Besides besides IN 37231 1690 2 " " `` 37231 1690 3 possession possession NN 37231 1690 4 , , , 37231 1690 5 " " '' 37231 1690 6 all all PDT 37231 1690 7 the the DT 37231 1690 8 diseases disease NNS 37231 1690 9 of of IN 37231 1690 10 men man NNS 37231 1690 11 and and CC 37231 1690 12 animals animal NNS 37231 1690 13 were be VBD 37231 1690 14 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1690 15 to to IN 37231 1690 16 the the DT 37231 1690 17 action action NN 37231 1690 18 of of IN 37231 1690 19 the the DT 37231 1690 20 devil devil NN 37231 1690 21 and and CC 37231 1690 22 of of IN 37231 1690 23 demons demon NNS 37231 1690 24 . . . 37231 1691 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1691 2 2 2 LS 37231 1691 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1691 4 In in IN 37231 1691 5 the the DT 37231 1691 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1691 7 , , , 37231 1691 8 for for IN 37231 1691 9 instance instance NN 37231 1691 10 , , , 37231 1691 11 the the DT 37231 1691 12 woman woman NN 37231 1691 13 with with IN 37231 1691 14 a a DT 37231 1691 15 spirit spirit NN 37231 1691 16 of of IN 37231 1691 17 infirmity infirmity NN 37231 1691 18 , , , 37231 1691 19 who who WP 37231 1691 20 was be VBD 37231 1691 21 bowed bow VBN 37231 1691 22 together together RB 37231 1691 23 and and CC 37231 1691 24 could could MD 37231 1691 25 not not RB 37231 1691 26 lift lift VB 37231 1691 27 herself -PRON- PRP 37231 1691 28 up up RP 37231 1691 29 , , , 37231 1691 30 is be VBZ 37231 1691 31 described describe VBN 37231 1691 32 as as IN 37231 1691 33 " " `` 37231 1691 34 bound bind VBN 37231 1691 35 by by IN 37231 1691 36 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1691 37 , , , 37231 1691 38 " " '' 37231 1691 39 although although IN 37231 1691 40 the the DT 37231 1691 41 case case NN 37231 1691 42 was be VBD 37231 1691 43 not not RB 37231 1691 44 one one CD 37231 1691 45 of of IN 37231 1691 46 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1691 47 possession possession NN 37231 1691 48 . . . 37231 1692 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1692 2 3 3 LS 37231 1692 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1692 4 As as IN 37231 1692 5 might may MD 37231 1692 6 be be VB 37231 1692 7 expected expect VBN 37231 1692 8 from from IN 37231 1692 9 the the DT 37231 1692 10 universality universality NN 37231 1692 11 of of IN 37231 1692 12 the the DT 37231 1692 13 belief belief NN 37231 1692 14 in in IN 37231 1692 15 demons demon NNS 37231 1692 16 and and CC 37231 1692 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1692 18 influence influence NN 37231 1692 19 over over IN 37231 1692 20 the the DT 37231 1692 21 human human JJ 37231 1692 22 race race NN 37231 1692 23 , , , 37231 1692 24 the the DT 37231 1692 25 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1692 26 at at IN 37231 1692 27 the the DT 37231 1692 28 time time NN 37231 1692 29 of of IN 37231 1692 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1692 31 occupied occupy VBD 37231 1692 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1692 33 much much RB 37231 1692 34 with with IN 37231 1692 35 the the DT 37231 1692 36 means mean NNS 37231 1692 37 of of IN 37231 1692 38 conjuring conjure VBG 37231 1692 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1692 40 . . . 37231 1693 1 " " `` 37231 1693 2 There there EX 37231 1693 3 was be VBD 37231 1693 4 hardly hardly RB 37231 1693 5 any any DT 37231 1693 6 people people NNS 37231 1693 7 in in IN 37231 1693 8 the the DT 37231 1693 9 whole whole JJ 37231 1693 10 world world NN 37231 1693 11 , , , 37231 1693 12 " " '' 37231 1693 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1693 14 have have VBP 37231 1693 15 already already RB 37231 1693 16 heard hear VBN 37231 1693 17 from from IN 37231 1693 18 a a DT 37231 1693 19 great great JJ 37231 1693 20 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 1693 21 scholar scholar NN 37231 1693 22 , , , 37231 1693 23 " " '' 37231 1693 24 that that IN 37231 1693 25 more more RBR 37231 1693 26 used use VBN 37231 1693 27 , , , 37231 1693 28 or or CC 37231 1693 29 were be VBD 37231 1693 30 more more RBR 37231 1693 31 fond fond JJ 37231 1693 32 of of IN 37231 1693 33 , , , 37231 1693 34 amulets amulet NNS 37231 1693 35 , , , 37231 1693 36 charms charm NNS 37231 1693 37 , , , 37231 1693 38 mutterings muttering NNS 37231 1693 39 , , , 37231 1693 40 exorcisms exorcism NNS 37231 1693 41 , , , 37231 1693 42 and and CC 37231 1693 43 all all DT 37231 1693 44 kinds kind NNS 37231 1693 45 of of IN 37231 1693 46 enchantments enchantment NNS 37231 1693 47 . . . 37231 1694 1 " " `` 37231 1694 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1694 3 4 4 LS 37231 1694 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1694 5 Schoettgen Schoettgen NNP 37231 1694 6 bears bear VBZ 37231 1694 7 similar similar JJ 37231 1694 8 testimony testimony NN 37231 1694 9 : : : 37231 1694 10 " " `` 37231 1694 11 Cæterum Cæterum NNP 37231 1694 12 judoeos judoeos NNP 37231 1694 13 magicis magicis NNP 37231 1694 14 artibus artibus NNP 37231 1694 15 admodum admodum NNP 37231 1694 16 deditos deditos NNP 37231 1694 17 esse esse NNP 37231 1694 18 , , , 37231 1694 19 notissimum notissimum NNP 37231 1694 20 est est NNP 37231 1694 21 . . . 37231 1695 1 " " `` 37231 1695 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1695 3 5 5 LS 37231 1695 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1695 5 All all DT 37231 1695 6 competent competent JJ 37231 1695 7 scholars scholar NNS 37231 1695 8 are be VBP 37231 1695 9 agreed agree VBN 37231 1695 10 upon upon IN 37231 1695 11 this this DT 37231 1695 12 point point NN 37231 1695 13 , , , 37231 1695 14 and and CC 37231 1695 15 the the DT 37231 1695 16 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1695 17 and and CC 37231 1695 18 Rabbinical rabbinical JJ 37231 1695 19 writings writing NNS 37231 1695 20 are be VBP 37231 1695 21 full full JJ 37231 1695 22 of of IN 37231 1695 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1695 24 . . . 37231 1696 1 The the DT 37231 1696 2 exceeding exceed VBG 37231 1696 3 prevalence prevalence NN 37231 1696 4 of of IN 37231 1696 5 such such JJ 37231 1696 6 arts art NNS 37231 1696 7 alone alone RB 37231 1696 8 proves prove VBZ 37231 1696 9 the the DT 37231 1696 10 existence existence NN 37231 1696 11 of of IN 37231 1696 12 the the DT 37231 1696 13 grossest gross JJS 37231 1696 14 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1696 15 and and CC 37231 1696 16 superstition superstition NN 37231 1696 17 . . . 37231 1697 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1697 2 116 116 CD 37231 1697 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1697 4 There there EX 37231 1697 5 are be VBP 37231 1697 6 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 1697 7 rules rule NNS 37231 1697 8 in in IN 37231 1697 9 the the DT 37231 1697 10 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1697 11 with with IN 37231 1697 12 regard regard NN 37231 1697 13 to to IN 37231 1697 14 dreams dream NNS 37231 1697 15 , , , 37231 1697 16 both both CC 37231 1697 17 as as IN 37231 1697 18 to to IN 37231 1697 19 how how WRB 37231 1697 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1697 21 are be VBP 37231 1697 22 to to TO 37231 1697 23 be be VB 37231 1697 24 obtained obtain VBN 37231 1697 25 and and CC 37231 1697 26 how how WRB 37231 1697 27 interpreted interpret VBN 37231 1697 28 . . . 37231 1698 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1698 2 1 1 LS 37231 1698 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1698 4 Fasts fast NNS 37231 1698 5 were be VBD 37231 1698 6 enjoined enjoin VBN 37231 1698 7 in in IN 37231 1698 8 order order NN 37231 1698 9 to to TO 37231 1698 10 secure secure VB 37231 1698 11 good good JJ 37231 1698 12 dreams dream NNS 37231 1698 13 , , , 37231 1698 14 and and CC 37231 1698 15 these these DT 37231 1698 16 fasts fast NNS 37231 1698 17 were be VBD 37231 1698 18 not not RB 37231 1698 19 only only RB 37231 1698 20 observed observe VBN 37231 1698 21 by by IN 37231 1698 22 the the DT 37231 1698 23 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 1698 24 , , , 37231 1698 25 but but CC 37231 1698 26 also also RB 37231 1698 27 by by IN 37231 1698 28 the the DT 37231 1698 29 principal principal JJ 37231 1698 30 Rabbins Rabbins NNPS 37231 1698 31 , , , 37231 1698 32 and and CC 37231 1698 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1698 34 were be VBD 37231 1698 35 permitted permit VBN 37231 1698 36 even even RB 37231 1698 37 on on IN 37231 1698 38 the the DT 37231 1698 39 Sabbath Sabbath NNP 37231 1698 40 , , , 37231 1698 41 which which WDT 37231 1698 42 was be VBD 37231 1698 43 unlawful unlawful JJ 37231 1698 44 in in IN 37231 1698 45 other other JJ 37231 1698 46 cases case NNS 37231 1698 47 . . . 37231 1699 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1699 2 2 2 LS 37231 1699 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1699 4 Indeed indeed RB 37231 1699 5 , , , 37231 1699 6 the the DT 37231 1699 7 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 1699 8 of of IN 37231 1699 9 dreams dream NNS 37231 1699 10 became become VBD 37231 1699 11 a a DT 37231 1699 12 public public JJ 37231 1699 13 profession profession NN 37231 1699 14 . . . 37231 1700 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1700 2 3 3 LS 37231 1700 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1700 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1700 5 would would MD 37231 1700 6 be be VB 37231 1700 7 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1700 8 within within IN 37231 1700 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1700 10 limits limit NNS 37231 1700 11 to to TO 37231 1700 12 convey convey VB 37231 1700 13 an an DT 37231 1700 14 adequate adequate JJ 37231 1700 15 idea idea NN 37231 1700 16 of of IN 37231 1700 17 the the DT 37231 1700 18 general general JJ 37231 1700 19 superstition superstition NN 37231 1700 20 prevalent prevalent NN 37231 1700 21 amongst amongst IN 37231 1700 22 the the DT 37231 1700 23 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1700 24 regarding regard VBG 37231 1700 25 things thing NNS 37231 1700 26 and and CC 37231 1700 27 actions action NNS 37231 1700 28 lucky lucky JJ 37231 1700 29 and and CC 37231 1700 30 unlucky unlucky JJ 37231 1700 31 , , , 37231 1700 32 or or CC 37231 1700 33 the the DT 37231 1700 34 minute minute NN 37231 1700 35 particulars particular NNS 37231 1700 36 in in IN 37231 1700 37 regard regard NN 37231 1700 38 to to IN 37231 1700 39 every every DT 37231 1700 40 common common JJ 37231 1700 41 act act NN 37231 1700 42 prescribed prescribe VBN 37231 1700 43 for for IN 37231 1700 44 safety safety NN 37231 1700 45 against against IN 37231 1700 46 demons demon NNS 37231 1700 47 and and CC 37231 1700 48 evil evil JJ 37231 1700 49 influences influence NNS 37231 1700 50 of of IN 37231 1700 51 all all DT 37231 1700 52 kinds kind NNS 37231 1700 53 . . . 37231 1701 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 1701 2 was be VBD 37231 1701 3 considered consider VBN 37231 1701 4 indifferent indifferent JJ 37231 1701 5 or or CC 37231 1701 6 too too RB 37231 1701 7 trifling trifle VBG 37231 1701 8 , , , 37231 1701 9 and and CC 37231 1701 10 the the DT 37231 1701 11 danger danger NN 37231 1701 12 from from IN 37231 1701 13 the the DT 37231 1701 14 most most RBS 37231 1701 15 trivial trivial JJ 37231 1701 16 movements movement NNS 37231 1701 17 or or CC 37231 1701 18 omissions omission NNS 37231 1701 19 to to TO 37231 1701 20 which which WDT 37231 1701 21 men man NNS 37231 1701 22 were be VBD 37231 1701 23 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1701 24 to to TO 37231 1701 25 be be VB 37231 1701 26 exposed expose VBN 37231 1701 27 from from IN 37231 1701 28 the the DT 37231 1701 29 malignity malignity NN 37231 1701 30 of of IN 37231 1701 31 evil evil JJ 37231 1701 32 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1701 33 was be VBD 37231 1701 34 believed believe VBN 37231 1701 35 to to TO 37231 1701 36 be be VB 37231 1701 37 great great JJ 37231 1701 38 . . . 37231 1702 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1702 2 4 4 LS 37231 1702 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1702 4 Amulets amulet NNS 37231 1702 5 , , , 37231 1702 6 consisting consist VBG 37231 1702 7 of of IN 37231 1702 8 roots root NNS 37231 1702 9 , , , 37231 1702 10 or or CC 37231 1702 11 pieces piece NNS 37231 1702 12 of of IN 37231 1702 13 paper paper NN 37231 1702 14 with with IN 37231 1702 15 charms charm NNS 37231 1702 16 written write VBN 37231 1702 17 upon upon IN 37231 1702 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1702 19 , , , 37231 1702 20 were be VBD 37231 1702 21 hung hang VBN 37231 1702 22 round round IN 37231 1702 23 the the DT 37231 1702 24 neck neck NN 37231 1702 25 of of IN 37231 1702 26 the the DT 37231 1702 27 sick sick JJ 37231 1702 28 , , , 37231 1702 29 and and CC 37231 1702 30 considered consider VBN 37231 1702 31 efficacious efficacious JJ 37231 1702 32 for for IN 37231 1702 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1702 34 cure cure NN 37231 1702 35 . . . 37231 1703 1 Charms charm NNS 37231 1703 2 , , , 37231 1703 3 mutterings muttering NNS 37231 1703 4 , , , 37231 1703 5 and and CC 37231 1703 6 spells spell NNS 37231 1703 7 were be VBD 37231 1703 8 commonly commonly RB 37231 1703 9 said say VBN 37231 1703 10 over over IN 37231 1703 11 wounds wound NNS 37231 1703 12 , , , 37231 1703 13 against against IN 37231 1703 14 unlucky unlucky JJ 37231 1703 15 meetings meeting NNS 37231 1703 16 , , , 37231 1703 17 to to TO 37231 1703 18 make make VB 37231 1703 19 people people NNS 37231 1703 20 sleep sleep VB 37231 1703 21 , , , 37231 1703 22 to to TO 37231 1703 23 heal heal VB 37231 1703 24 diseases disease NNS 37231 1703 25 , , , 37231 1703 26 and and CC 37231 1703 27 to to TO 37231 1703 28 avert avert VB 37231 1703 29 enchantments enchantment NNS 37231 1703 30 . . . 37231 1704 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1704 2 5 5 LS 37231 1704 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1704 4 The the DT 37231 1704 5 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1704 6 gives give VBZ 37231 1704 7 forms form NNS 37231 1704 8 of of IN 37231 1704 9 enchantments enchantment NNS 37231 1704 10 against against IN 37231 1704 11 mad mad JJ 37231 1704 12 dogs dog NNS 37231 1704 13 , , , 37231 1704 14 for for IN 37231 1704 15 instance instance NN 37231 1704 16 , , , 37231 1704 17 against against IN 37231 1704 18 the the DT 37231 1704 19 demon demon NN 37231 1704 20 of of IN 37231 1704 21 blindness blindness NN 37231 1704 22 , , , 37231 1704 23 and and CC 37231 1704 24 the the DT 37231 1704 25 like like JJ 37231 1704 26 , , , 37231 1704 27 as as RB 37231 1704 28 well well RB 37231 1704 29 as as IN 37231 1704 30 formulae formulae NNP 37231 1704 31 for for IN 37231 1704 32 averting avert VBG 37231 1704 33 the the DT 37231 1704 34 evil evil JJ 37231 1704 35 eye eye NN 37231 1704 36 , , , 37231 1704 37 and and CC 37231 1704 38 { { -LRB- 37231 1704 39 117 117 CD 37231 1704 40 } } -RRB- 37231 1704 41 mutterings muttering NNS 37231 1704 42 over over IN 37231 1704 43 diseases disease NNS 37231 1704 44 . . . 37231 1705 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1705 2 1 1 LS 37231 1705 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1705 4 So so RB 37231 1705 5 common common JJ 37231 1705 6 was be VBD 37231 1705 7 the the DT 37231 1705 8 practice practice NN 37231 1705 9 of of IN 37231 1705 10 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1705 11 and and CC 37231 1705 12 magic magic NN 37231 1705 13 that that IN 37231 1705 14 the the DT 37231 1705 15 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1705 16 enjoins enjoin NNS 37231 1705 17 " " '' 37231 1705 18 that that IN 37231 1705 19 the the DT 37231 1705 20 senior senior NN 37231 1705 21 who who WP 37231 1705 22 is be VBZ 37231 1705 23 chosen choose VBN 37231 1705 24 into into IN 37231 1705 25 the the DT 37231 1705 26 Council Council NNP 37231 1705 27 ought ought MD 37231 1705 28 to to TO 37231 1705 29 be be VB 37231 1705 30 skilled skilled JJ 37231 1705 31 in in IN 37231 1705 32 the the DT 37231 1705 33 arts art NNS 37231 1705 34 of of IN 37231 1705 35 astrologers astrologer NNS 37231 1705 36 , , , 37231 1705 37 jugglers juggler NNS 37231 1705 38 , , , 37231 1705 39 diviners diviner NNS 37231 1705 40 , , , 37231 1705 41 sorcerers sorcerer NNS 37231 1705 42 , , , 37231 1705 43 & & CC 37231 1705 44 c c NNP 37231 1705 45 , , , 37231 1705 46 that that IN 37231 1705 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1705 48 may may MD 37231 1705 49 be be VB 37231 1705 50 able able JJ 37231 1705 51 to to TO 37231 1705 52 judge judge VB 37231 1705 53 of of IN 37231 1705 54 those those DT 37231 1705 55 who who WP 37231 1705 56 are be VBP 37231 1705 57 guilty guilty JJ 37231 1705 58 of of IN 37231 1705 59 the the DT 37231 1705 60 same same JJ 37231 1705 61 . . . 37231 1706 1 " " `` 37231 1706 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1706 3 2 2 LS 37231 1706 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1706 5 Numerous numerous JJ 37231 1706 6 cases case NNS 37231 1706 7 are be VBP 37231 1706 8 recorded record VBN 37231 1706 9 of of IN 37231 1706 10 persons person NNS 37231 1706 11 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 1706 12 by by IN 37231 1706 13 means mean NNS 37231 1706 14 of of IN 37231 1706 15 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1706 16 . . . 37231 1707 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1707 2 3 3 LS 37231 1707 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1707 4 The the DT 37231 1707 5 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1707 6 women woman NNS 37231 1707 7 were be VBD 37231 1707 8 particularly particularly RB 37231 1707 9 addicted addict VBN 37231 1707 10 to to IN 37231 1707 11 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1707 12 , , , 37231 1707 13 and and CC 37231 1707 14 indeed indeed RB 37231 1707 15 the the DT 37231 1707 16 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1707 17 declares declare VBZ 37231 1707 18 that that IN 37231 1707 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1707 20 had have VBD 37231 1707 21 generally generally RB 37231 1707 22 fallen fall VBN 37231 1707 23 into into IN 37231 1707 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1707 25 . . . 37231 1708 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1708 2 4 4 LS 37231 1708 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1708 4 The the DT 37231 1708 5 New New NNP 37231 1708 6 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1708 7 bears bear VBZ 37231 1708 8 abundant abundant JJ 37231 1708 9 testimony testimony NN 37231 1708 10 to to IN 37231 1708 11 the the DT 37231 1708 12 prevalence prevalence NN 37231 1708 13 of of IN 37231 1708 14 magic magic NN 37231 1708 15 and and CC 37231 1708 16 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1708 17 at at IN 37231 1708 18 the the DT 37231 1708 19 time time NN 37231 1708 20 at at IN 37231 1708 21 which which WDT 37231 1708 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1708 23 books book NNS 37231 1708 24 were be VBD 37231 1708 25 written write VBN 37231 1708 26 . . . 37231 1709 1 In in IN 37231 1709 2 the the DT 37231 1709 3 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1709 4 , , , 37231 1709 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1709 6 is be VBZ 37231 1709 7 represented represent VBN 37231 1709 8 as as IN 37231 1709 9 arguing argue VBG 37231 1709 10 with with IN 37231 1709 11 the the DT 37231 1709 12 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 1709 13 , , , 37231 1709 14 who who WP 37231 1709 15 accuse accuse VBP 37231 1709 16 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1709 17 of of IN 37231 1709 18 casting cast VBG 37231 1709 19 out out RP 37231 1709 20 devils devil NNS 37231 1709 21 by by IN 37231 1709 22 Beelzebub Beelzebub NNP 37231 1709 23 , , , 37231 1709 24 the the DT 37231 1709 25 prince prince NN 37231 1709 26 of of IN 37231 1709 27 the the DT 37231 1709 28 devils devil NNS 37231 1709 29 . . . 37231 1710 1 " " `` 37231 1710 2 If if IN 37231 1710 3 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1710 4 by by IN 37231 1710 5 Beelzebub Beelzebub NNP 37231 1710 6 cast cast VBD 37231 1710 7 out out RP 37231 1710 8 the the DT 37231 1710 9 demons demon NNS 37231 1710 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1710 11 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1710 12 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1710 13 by by IN 37231 1710 14 whom whom WP 37231 1710 15 do do VBP 37231 1710 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1710 17 sons son NNS 37231 1710 18 cast cast VB 37231 1710 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1710 20 out out RP 37231 1710 21 ? ? . 37231 1711 1 Therefore therefore RB 37231 1711 2 let let VB 37231 1711 3 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1711 4 be be VB 37231 1711 5 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1711 6 judges judge NNS 37231 1711 7 . . . 37231 1712 1 " " `` 37231 1712 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1712 3 5 5 LS 37231 1712 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1712 5 The the DT 37231 1712 6 thoroughness thoroughness NN 37231 1712 7 and and CC 37231 1712 8 universality universality NN 37231 1712 9 of of IN 37231 1712 10 the the DT 37231 1712 11 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1712 12 popular popular JJ 37231 1712 13 belief belief NN 37231 1712 14 in in IN 37231 1712 15 demons demon NNS 37231 1712 16 and and CC 37231 1712 17 evil evil JJ 37231 1712 18 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1712 19 and and CC 37231 1712 20 in in IN 37231 1712 21 the the DT 37231 1712 22 power power NN 37231 1712 23 of of IN 37231 1712 24 magic magic NN 37231 1712 25 is be VBZ 37231 1712 26 exhibited exhibit VBN 37231 1712 27 in in IN 37231 1712 28 the the DT 37231 1712 29 ascription ascription NN 37231 1712 30 to to IN 37231 1712 31 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1712 32 , , , 37231 1712 33 the the DT 37231 1712 34 monarch monarch NN 37231 1712 35 in in IN 37231 1712 36 whom whom WP 37231 1712 37 the the DT 37231 1712 38 greatness greatness NN 37231 1712 39 and and CC 37231 1712 40 glory glory NN 37231 1712 41 of of IN 37231 1712 42 the the DT 37231 1712 43 nation nation NN 37231 1712 44 attained attain VBD 37231 1712 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1712 46 culminating culminate VBG 37231 1712 47 point point NN 37231 1712 48 , , , 37231 1712 49 of of IN 37231 1712 50 the the DT 37231 1712 51 character character NN 37231 1712 52 of of IN 37231 1712 53 a a DT 37231 1712 54 powerful powerful JJ 37231 1712 55 magician magician NN 37231 1712 56 . . . 37231 1713 1 The the DT 37231 1713 2 most most RBS 37231 1713 3 effectual effectual JJ 37231 1713 4 forms form NNS 37231 1713 5 of of IN 37231 1713 6 invocation invocation NN 37231 1713 7 and and CC 37231 1713 8 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1713 9 , , , 37231 1713 10 and and CC 37231 1713 11 the the DT 37231 1713 12 most most RBS 37231 1713 13 potent potent JJ 37231 1713 14 spells spell NNS 37231 1713 15 of of IN 37231 1713 16 magic magic NN 37231 1713 17 , , , 37231 1713 18 were be VBD 37231 1713 19 said say VBN 37231 1713 20 to to TO 37231 1713 21 have have VB 37231 1713 22 been be VBN 37231 1713 23 composed compose VBN 37231 1713 24 by by IN 37231 1713 25 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1713 26 , , , 37231 1713 27 and and CC 37231 1713 28 thus thus RB 37231 1713 29 the the DT 37231 1713 30 grossest gross JJS 37231 1713 31 superstition superstition NN 37231 1713 32 of of IN 37231 1713 33 the the DT 37231 1713 34 nation nation NN 37231 1713 35 acquired acquire VBD 37231 1713 36 the the DT 37231 1713 37 sanction sanction NN 37231 1713 38 of of IN 37231 1713 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1713 40 wisest wise JJS 37231 1713 41 king king NN 37231 1713 42 . . . 37231 1714 1 Rabbinical rabbinical JJ 37231 1714 2 writings writing NNS 37231 1714 3 are be VBP 37231 1714 4 { { -LRB- 37231 1714 5 118 118 CD 37231 1714 6 } } -RRB- 37231 1714 7 never never RB 37231 1714 8 weary weary JJ 37231 1714 9 of of IN 37231 1714 10 enlarging enlarge VBG 37231 1714 11 upon upon IN 37231 1714 12 the the DT 37231 1714 13 magical magical JJ 37231 1714 14 power power NN 37231 1714 15 and and CC 37231 1714 16 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1714 17 of of IN 37231 1714 18 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1714 19 . . . 37231 1715 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1715 2 was be VBD 37231 1715 3 represented represent VBN 37231 1715 4 as as IN 37231 1715 5 not not RB 37231 1715 6 only only RB 37231 1715 7 king king NN 37231 1715 8 of of IN 37231 1715 9 the the DT 37231 1715 10 whole whole JJ 37231 1715 11 earth earth NN 37231 1715 12 , , , 37231 1715 13 but but CC 37231 1715 14 also also RB 37231 1715 15 as as IN 37231 1715 16 reigning reign VBG 37231 1715 17 over over RP 37231 1715 18 devils devil NNS 37231 1715 19 and and CC 37231 1715 20 evil evil JJ 37231 1715 21 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1715 22 , , , 37231 1715 23 and and CC 37231 1715 24 having have VBG 37231 1715 25 the the DT 37231 1715 26 power power NN 37231 1715 27 of of IN 37231 1715 28 expelling expel VBG 37231 1715 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1715 30 from from IN 37231 1715 31 the the DT 37231 1715 32 bodies body NNS 37231 1715 33 of of IN 37231 1715 34 men man NNS 37231 1715 35 and and CC 37231 1715 36 animals animal NNS 37231 1715 37 , , , 37231 1715 38 and and CC 37231 1715 39 also also RB 37231 1715 40 of of IN 37231 1715 41 delivering deliver VBG 37231 1715 42 people people NNS 37231 1715 43 to to IN 37231 1715 44 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1715 45 . . . 37231 1716 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1716 2 1 1 LS 37231 1716 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1716 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1716 5 was be VBD 37231 1716 6 indeed indeed RB 37231 1716 7 believed believe VBN 37231 1716 8 that that IN 37231 1716 9 the the DT 37231 1716 10 two two CD 37231 1716 11 demons demon NNS 37231 1716 12 Asa Asa NNP 37231 1716 13 and and CC 37231 1716 14 Asael Asael NNP 37231 1716 15 taught teach VBD 37231 1716 16 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1716 17 all all DT 37231 1716 18 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1716 19 and and CC 37231 1716 20 all all DT 37231 1716 21 arts art NNS 37231 1716 22 . . . 37231 1717 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1717 2 2 2 LS 37231 1717 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1717 4 The the DT 37231 1717 5 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1717 6 relates relate VBZ 37231 1717 7 many many JJ 37231 1717 8 instances instance NNS 37231 1717 9 of of IN 37231 1717 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1717 11 power power NN 37231 1717 12 over over IN 37231 1717 13 evil evil JJ 37231 1717 14 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1717 15 , , , 37231 1717 16 and and CC 37231 1717 17 amongst amongst IN 37231 1717 18 others other NNS 37231 1717 19 how how WRB 37231 1717 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1717 21 made make VBD 37231 1717 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1717 23 assist assist VB 37231 1717 24 in in IN 37231 1717 25 building build VBG 37231 1717 26 the the DT 37231 1717 27 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1717 28 . . . 37231 1718 1 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1718 2 desired desire VBD 37231 1718 3 to to TO 37231 1718 4 have have VB 37231 1718 5 the the DT 37231 1718 6 help help NN 37231 1718 7 of of IN 37231 1718 8 the the DT 37231 1718 9 worm worm NN 37231 1718 10 Schamir Schamir NNP 37231 1718 11 in in IN 37231 1718 12 preparing prepare VBG 37231 1718 13 the the DT 37231 1718 14 stones stone NNS 37231 1718 15 for for IN 37231 1718 16 the the DT 37231 1718 17 sacred sacred JJ 37231 1718 18 building building NN 37231 1718 19 , , , 37231 1718 20 and and CC 37231 1718 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1718 22 conjured conjure VBD 37231 1718 23 up up RP 37231 1718 24 a a DT 37231 1718 25 devil devil NN 37231 1718 26 and and CC 37231 1718 27 a a DT 37231 1718 28 she -PRON- PRP 37231 1718 29 - - HYPH 37231 1718 30 devil devil NN 37231 1718 31 to to TO 37231 1718 32 inform inform VB 37231 1718 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1718 34 where where WRB 37231 1718 35 Schamir Schamir NNP 37231 1718 36 was be VBD 37231 1718 37 to to TO 37231 1718 38 be be VB 37231 1718 39 found find VBN 37231 1718 40 . . . 37231 1719 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1719 2 referred refer VBD 37231 1719 3 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1719 4 to to IN 37231 1719 5 Asmodeus Asmodeus NNP 37231 1719 6 , , , 37231 1719 7 whom whom WP 37231 1719 8 the the DT 37231 1719 9 King King NNP 37231 1719 10 craftily craftily RB 37231 1719 11 captured capture VBD 37231 1719 12 , , , 37231 1719 13 and and CC 37231 1719 14 by by IN 37231 1719 15 whom whom WP 37231 1719 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1719 17 was be VBD 37231 1719 18 informed inform VBN 37231 1719 19 that that IN 37231 1719 20 Schamir Schamir NNP 37231 1719 21 is be VBZ 37231 1719 22 under under IN 37231 1719 23 the the DT 37231 1719 24 jurisdiction jurisdiction NN 37231 1719 25 of of IN 37231 1719 26 the the DT 37231 1719 27 Prince Prince NNP 37231 1719 28 of of IN 37231 1719 29 the the DT 37231 1719 30 Seas Seas NNPS 37231 1719 31 , , , 37231 1719 32 and and CC 37231 1719 33 Asmodeus Asmodeus NNP 37231 1719 34 further further RB 37231 1719 35 told tell VBD 37231 1719 36 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1719 37 how how WRB 37231 1719 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1719 39 might may MD 37231 1719 40 be be VB 37231 1719 41 secured secure VBN 37231 1719 42 . . . 37231 1720 1 By by IN 37231 1720 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1720 3 means mean NNS 37231 1720 4 the the DT 37231 1720 5 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1720 6 was be VBD 37231 1720 7 built build VBN 37231 1720 8 , , , 37231 1720 9 but but CC 37231 1720 10 , , , 37231 1720 11 from from IN 37231 1720 12 the the DT 37231 1720 13 moment moment NN 37231 1720 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1720 15 was be VBD 37231 1720 16 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 1720 17 , , , 37231 1720 18 Schamir Schamir NNP 37231 1720 19 for for IN 37231 1720 20 ever ever RB 37231 1720 21 disappeared disappear VBN 37231 1720 22 . . . 37231 1721 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1721 2 3 3 LS 37231 1721 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1721 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1721 5 was be VBD 37231 1721 6 likewise likewise RB 37231 1721 7 believed believe VBN 37231 1721 8 that that IN 37231 1721 9 one one CD 37231 1721 10 of of IN 37231 1721 11 the the DT 37231 1721 12 Chambers Chambers NNPS 37231 1721 13 of of IN 37231 1721 14 the the DT 37231 1721 15 second second JJ 37231 1721 16 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1721 17 was be VBD 37231 1721 18 built build VBN 37231 1721 19 by by IN 37231 1721 20 a a DT 37231 1721 21 magician magician NN 37231 1721 22 called call VBN 37231 1721 23 Parvah Parvah NNP 37231 1721 24 , , , 37231 1721 25 by by IN 37231 1721 26 means mean NNS 37231 1721 27 of of IN 37231 1721 28 magic magic NN 37231 1721 29 . . . 37231 1722 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1722 2 4 4 LS 37231 1722 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1722 4 The the DT 37231 1722 5 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 1722 6 narrates narrate VBZ 37231 1722 7 many many JJ 37231 1722 8 stories story NNS 37231 1722 9 of of IN 37231 1722 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1722 11 performed perform VBN 37231 1722 12 by by IN 37231 1722 13 various various JJ 37231 1722 14 Rabbins rabbin NNS 37231 1722 15 . . . 37231 1723 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1723 2 6 6 LS 37231 1723 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1723 4 The the DT 37231 1723 5 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1723 6 historian historian NN 37231 1723 7 , , , 37231 1723 8 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1723 9 , , , 37231 1723 10 informs inform VBZ 37231 1723 11 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1723 12 that that IN 37231 1723 13 , , , 37231 1723 14 amongst amongst IN 37231 1723 15 { { -LRB- 37231 1723 16 119 119 CD 37231 1723 17 } } -RRB- 37231 1723 18 other other JJ 37231 1723 19 gifts gift NNS 37231 1723 20 , , , 37231 1723 21 God God NNP 37231 1723 22 bestowed bestow VBD 37231 1723 23 upon upon IN 37231 1723 24 King King NNP 37231 1723 25 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1723 26 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1723 27 of of IN 37231 1723 28 the the DT 37231 1723 29 way way NN 37231 1723 30 to to TO 37231 1723 31 expel expel VB 37231 1723 32 demons demon NNS 37231 1723 33 , , , 37231 1723 34 an an DT 37231 1723 35 art art NN 37231 1723 36 which which WDT 37231 1723 37 is be VBZ 37231 1723 38 useful useful JJ 37231 1723 39 and and CC 37231 1723 40 salutary salutary JJ 37231 1723 41 for for IN 37231 1723 42 mankind mankind NN 37231 1723 43 . . . 37231 1724 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1724 2 composed compose VBD 37231 1724 3 incantations incantation NNS 37231 1724 4 by by IN 37231 1724 5 which which WDT 37231 1724 6 diseases disease NNS 37231 1724 7 are be VBP 37231 1724 8 cured cure VBN 37231 1724 9 , , , 37231 1724 10 and and CC 37231 1724 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1724 12 left leave VBD 37231 1724 13 behind behind IN 37231 1724 14 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1724 15 forms form NNS 37231 1724 16 of of IN 37231 1724 17 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1724 18 by by IN 37231 1724 19 which which WDT 37231 1724 20 demons demon NNS 37231 1724 21 may may MD 37231 1724 22 be be VB 37231 1724 23 so so RB 37231 1724 24 effectually effectually RB 37231 1724 25 expelled expel VBN 37231 1724 26 that that IN 37231 1724 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1724 28 never never RB 37231 1724 29 return return VBP 37231 1724 30 , , , 37231 1724 31 a a DT 37231 1724 32 method method NN 37231 1724 33 of of IN 37231 1724 34 cure cure NN 37231 1724 35 , , , 37231 1724 36 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1724 37 adds add VBZ 37231 1724 38 , , , 37231 1724 39 which which WDT 37231 1724 40 is be VBZ 37231 1724 41 of of IN 37231 1724 42 great great JJ 37231 1724 43 efficacy efficacy NN 37231 1724 44 to to IN 37231 1724 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1724 46 own own JJ 37231 1724 47 day day NN 37231 1724 48 . . . 37231 1725 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1725 2 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1725 3 had have VBD 37231 1725 4 seen see VBN 37231 1725 5 a a DT 37231 1725 6 countryman countryman NN 37231 1725 7 of of IN 37231 1725 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1725 9 own own JJ 37231 1725 10 , , , 37231 1725 11 named name VBN 37231 1725 12 Eliezer Eliezer NNP 37231 1725 13 , , , 37231 1725 14 release release VB 37231 1725 15 people people NNS 37231 1725 16 possessed possess VBD 37231 1725 17 of of IN 37231 1725 18 devils devil NNS 37231 1725 19 in in IN 37231 1725 20 the the DT 37231 1725 21 presence presence NN 37231 1725 22 of of IN 37231 1725 23 the the DT 37231 1725 24 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 1725 25 Vespasian Vespasian NNP 37231 1725 26 and and CC 37231 1725 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1725 28 sons son NNS 37231 1725 29 , , , 37231 1725 30 and and CC 37231 1725 31 of of IN 37231 1725 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1725 33 army army NN 37231 1725 34 . . . 37231 1726 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1726 2 put put VBD 37231 1726 3 a a DT 37231 1726 4 ring ring NN 37231 1726 5 containing contain VBG 37231 1726 6 one one CD 37231 1726 7 of of IN 37231 1726 8 the the DT 37231 1726 9 roots root NNS 37231 1726 10 prescribed prescribe VBN 37231 1726 11 by by IN 37231 1726 12 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1726 13 to to IN 37231 1726 14 the the DT 37231 1726 15 nose nose NN 37231 1726 16 of of IN 37231 1726 17 the the DT 37231 1726 18 demoniac demoniac NN 37231 1726 19 , , , 37231 1726 20 and and CC 37231 1726 21 drew draw VBD 37231 1726 22 the the DT 37231 1726 23 demon demon NN 37231 1726 24 out out RP 37231 1726 25 by by IN 37231 1726 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1726 27 nostrils nostril NNS 37231 1726 28 , , , 37231 1726 29 and and CC 37231 1726 30 , , , 37231 1726 31 in in IN 37231 1726 32 the the DT 37231 1726 33 name name NN 37231 1726 34 of of IN 37231 1726 35 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1726 36 , , , 37231 1726 37 and and CC 37231 1726 38 reciting recite VBG 37231 1726 39 one one CD 37231 1726 40 of of IN 37231 1726 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1726 42 incantations incantation NNS 37231 1726 43 , , , 37231 1726 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1726 45 adjured adjure VBD 37231 1726 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1726 47 to to TO 37231 1726 48 return return VB 37231 1726 49 no no DT 37231 1726 50 more more JJR 37231 1726 51 . . . 37231 1727 1 In in IN 37231 1727 2 order order NN 37231 1727 3 to to TO 37231 1727 4 demonstrate demonstrate VB 37231 1727 5 to to IN 37231 1727 6 the the DT 37231 1727 7 spectators spectator NNS 37231 1727 8 that that WDT 37231 1727 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1727 10 had have VBD 37231 1727 11 the the DT 37231 1727 12 power power NN 37231 1727 13 to to TO 37231 1727 14 cast cast VB 37231 1727 15 out out RP 37231 1727 16 devils devil NNS 37231 1727 17 , , , 37231 1727 18 Eliezer Eliezer NNP 37231 1727 19 was be VBD 37231 1727 20 accustomed accustom VBN 37231 1727 21 to to TO 37231 1727 22 set set VB 37231 1727 23 a a DT 37231 1727 24 vessel vessel NN 37231 1727 25 full full JJ 37231 1727 26 of of IN 37231 1727 27 water water NN 37231 1727 28 a a DT 37231 1727 29 little little JJ 37231 1727 30 way way NN 37231 1727 31 off off RB 37231 1727 32 , , , 37231 1727 33 and and CC 37231 1727 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1727 35 commanded command VBD 37231 1727 36 the the DT 37231 1727 37 demon demon NN 37231 1727 38 as as IN 37231 1727 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1727 40 left leave VBD 37231 1727 41 the the DT 37231 1727 42 body body NN 37231 1727 43 of of IN 37231 1727 44 the the DT 37231 1727 45 man man NN 37231 1727 46 to to TO 37231 1727 47 overturn overturn VB 37231 1727 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1727 49 , , , 37231 1727 50 by by IN 37231 1727 51 which which WDT 37231 1727 52 means mean VBZ 37231 1727 53 , , , 37231 1727 54 says say VBZ 37231 1727 55 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1727 56 , , , 37231 1727 57 the the DT 37231 1727 58 skill skill NN 37231 1727 59 and and CC 37231 1727 60 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1727 61 of of IN 37231 1727 62 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 1727 63 were be VBD 37231 1727 64 made make VBN 37231 1727 65 very very RB 37231 1727 66 manifest manif JJS 37231 1727 67 . . . 37231 1728 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1728 2 1 1 LS 37231 1728 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1728 4 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1728 5 Rabbins Rabbins NNP 37231 1728 6 generally generally RB 37231 1728 7 were be VBD 37231 1728 8 known know VBN 37231 1728 9 as as IN 37231 1728 10 powerful powerful JJ 37231 1728 11 exorcisers exorciser NNS 37231 1728 12 , , , 37231 1728 13 practising practise VBG 37231 1728 14 the the DT 37231 1728 15 art art NN 37231 1728 16 according accord VBG 37231 1728 17 to to IN 37231 1728 18 the the DT 37231 1728 19 formulae formula NNS 37231 1728 20 of of IN 37231 1728 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1728 22 great great JJ 37231 1728 23 monarch monarch NN 37231 1728 24 . . . 37231 1729 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 1729 2 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 1729 3 reproaches reproach VBZ 37231 1729 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1729 5 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1729 6 opponent opponent NN 37231 1729 7 , , , 37231 1729 8 Tryphon Tryphon NNP 37231 1729 9 , , , 37231 1729 10 with with IN 37231 1729 11 the the DT 37231 1729 12 fact fact NN 37231 1729 13 that that IN 37231 1729 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1729 15 countrymen countryman NNS 37231 1729 16 use use VBP 37231 1729 17 the the DT 37231 1729 18 same same JJ 37231 1729 19 art art NN 37231 1729 20 as as IN 37231 1729 21 the the DT 37231 1729 22 Gentiles Gentiles NNPS 37231 1729 23 , , , 37231 1729 24 and and CC 37231 1729 25 exorcise exorcise VB 37231 1729 26 with with IN 37231 1729 27 fumigations fumigation NNS 37231 1729 28 and and CC 37231 1729 29 charms charm NNS 37231 1729 30 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1729 31 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1729 32 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1729 33 , , , 37231 1729 34 and and CC 37231 1729 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 36 shows show VBZ 37231 1729 37 the the DT 37231 1729 38 common common JJ 37231 1729 39 belief belief NN 37231 1729 40 in in IN 37231 1729 41 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1729 42 influence influence NN 37231 1729 43 " " '' 37231 1729 44 when when WRB 37231 1729 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 46 asserts assert VBZ 37231 1729 47 that that IN 37231 1729 48 , , , 37231 1729 49 while while IN 37231 1729 50 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1729 51 exorcists exorcist NNS 37231 1729 52 can can MD 37231 1729 53 not not RB 37231 1729 54 overcome overcome VB 37231 1729 55 demons demon NNS 37231 1729 56 by by IN 37231 1729 57 such such JJ 37231 1729 58 means mean NNS 37231 1729 59 , , , 37231 1729 60 or or CC 37231 1729 61 even even RB 37231 1729 62 by by IN 37231 1729 63 exorcising exorcise VBG 37231 1729 64 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 65 in in IN 37231 1729 66 the the DT 37231 1729 67 name name NN 37231 1729 68 of of IN 37231 1729 69 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1729 70 Kings king NNS 37231 1729 71 , , , 37231 1729 72 Prophets prophet NNS 37231 1729 73 , , , 37231 1729 74 or or CC 37231 1729 75 Patriarchs Patriarchs NNP 37231 1729 76 , , , 37231 1729 77 though though IN 37231 1729 78 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 79 admits admit VBZ 37231 1729 80 that that IN 37231 1729 81 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 82 might may MD 37231 1729 83 do do VB 37231 1729 84 so so RB 37231 1729 85 if if IN 37231 1729 86 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 87 adjured adjure VBD 37231 1729 88 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 89 in in IN 37231 1729 90 the the DT 37231 1729 91 name name NN 37231 1729 92 of of IN 37231 1729 93 the the DT 37231 1729 94 God God NNP 37231 1729 95 of of IN 37231 1729 96 Abraham Abraham NNP 37231 1729 97 , , , 37231 1729 98 Isaac Isaac NNP 37231 1729 99 , , , 37231 1729 100 and and CC 37231 1729 101 { { -LRB- 37231 1729 102 120 120 CD 37231 1729 103 } } -RRB- 37231 1729 104 Jacob Jacob NNP 37231 1729 105 , , , 37231 1729 106 yet yet CC 37231 1729 107 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 1729 108 at at IN 37231 1729 109 once once IN 37231 1729 110 subdued subdue VBN 37231 1729 111 demons demon NNS 37231 1729 112 by by IN 37231 1729 113 exorcising exorcise VBG 37231 1729 114 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1729 115 in in IN 37231 1729 116 the the DT 37231 1729 117 name name NN 37231 1729 118 of of IN 37231 1729 119 the the DT 37231 1729 120 Son Son NNP 37231 1729 121 of of IN 37231 1729 122 God God NNP 37231 1729 123 . . . 37231 1730 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1730 2 1 1 LS 37231 1730 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1730 4 The the DT 37231 1730 5 Jew Jew NNP 37231 1730 6 and and CC 37231 1730 7 the the DT 37231 1730 8 Christian Christian NNP 37231 1730 9 were be VBD 37231 1730 10 quite quite RB 37231 1730 11 agreed agree VBN 37231 1730 12 that that IN 37231 1730 13 demons demon NNS 37231 1730 14 were be VBD 37231 1730 15 to to TO 37231 1730 16 be be VB 37231 1730 17 exorcised exorcise VBN 37231 1730 18 , , , 37231 1730 19 and and CC 37231 1730 20 merely merely RB 37231 1730 21 differed differ VBD 37231 1730 22 as as IN 37231 1730 23 to to IN 37231 1730 24 the the DT 37231 1730 25 formula formula NN 37231 1730 26 of of IN 37231 1730 27 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1730 28 . . . 37231 1731 1 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1731 2 gives give VBZ 37231 1731 3 an an DT 37231 1731 4 account account NN 37231 1731 5 of of IN 37231 1731 6 a a DT 37231 1731 7 root root NN 37231 1731 8 potent potent JJ 37231 1731 9 against against IN 37231 1731 10 evil evil JJ 37231 1731 11 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1731 12 . . . 37231 1732 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1732 2 is be VBZ 37231 1732 3 called call VBN 37231 1732 4 Baaras Baaras NNP 37231 1732 5 , , , 37231 1732 6 and and CC 37231 1732 7 is be VBZ 37231 1732 8 flame flame NN 37231 1732 9 - - HYPH 37231 1732 10 coloured coloured JJ 37231 1732 11 , , , 37231 1732 12 and and CC 37231 1732 13 in in IN 37231 1732 14 the the DT 37231 1732 15 evening evening NN 37231 1732 16 sends send VBZ 37231 1732 17 out out RP 37231 1732 18 flashes flash NNS 37231 1732 19 like like IN 37231 1732 20 lightning lightning NN 37231 1732 21 . . . 37231 1733 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1733 2 is be VBZ 37231 1733 3 certain certain JJ 37231 1733 4 death death NN 37231 1733 5 to to TO 37231 1733 6 touch touch VB 37231 1733 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1733 8 , , , 37231 1733 9 except except IN 37231 1733 10 under under IN 37231 1733 11 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 1733 12 conditions condition NNS 37231 1733 13 . . . 37231 1734 1 One one CD 37231 1734 2 mode mode NN 37231 1734 3 of of IN 37231 1734 4 securing secure VBG 37231 1734 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1734 6 is be VBZ 37231 1734 7 to to TO 37231 1734 8 dig dig VB 37231 1734 9 down down RP 37231 1734 10 till till IN 37231 1734 11 the the DT 37231 1734 12 smaller small JJR 37231 1734 13 part part NN 37231 1734 14 of of IN 37231 1734 15 the the DT 37231 1734 16 root root NN 37231 1734 17 is be VBZ 37231 1734 18 exposed expose VBN 37231 1734 19 , , , 37231 1734 20 and and CC 37231 1734 21 then then RB 37231 1734 22 to to TO 37231 1734 23 attach attach VB 37231 1734 24 the the DT 37231 1734 25 root root NN 37231 1734 26 to to IN 37231 1734 27 a a DT 37231 1734 28 dog dog NN 37231 1734 29 's 's POS 37231 1734 30 tail tail NN 37231 1734 31 . . . 37231 1735 1 When when WRB 37231 1735 2 the the DT 37231 1735 3 dog dog NN 37231 1735 4 tries try VBZ 37231 1735 5 to to TO 37231 1735 6 follow follow VB 37231 1735 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1735 8 master master NN 37231 1735 9 from from IN 37231 1735 10 the the DT 37231 1735 11 place place NN 37231 1735 12 , , , 37231 1735 13 and and CC 37231 1735 14 pulls pull VBZ 37231 1735 15 violently violently RB 37231 1735 16 , , , 37231 1735 17 the the DT 37231 1735 18 root root NN 37231 1735 19 is be VBZ 37231 1735 20 plucked pluck VBN 37231 1735 21 up up RP 37231 1735 22 , , , 37231 1735 23 and and CC 37231 1735 24 may may MD 37231 1735 25 then then RB 37231 1735 26 be be VB 37231 1735 27 safely safely RB 37231 1735 28 handled handle VBN 37231 1735 29 , , , 37231 1735 30 but but CC 37231 1735 31 the the DT 37231 1735 32 dog dog NN 37231 1735 33 instantly instantly RB 37231 1735 34 dies die VBZ 37231 1735 35 , , , 37231 1735 36 as as IN 37231 1735 37 the the DT 37231 1735 38 man man NN 37231 1735 39 would would MD 37231 1735 40 have have VB 37231 1735 41 done do VBN 37231 1735 42 had have VBD 37231 1735 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1735 44 plucked pluck VBN 37231 1735 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1735 46 up up RP 37231 1735 47 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1735 48 . . . 37231 1736 1 When when WRB 37231 1736 2 the the DT 37231 1736 3 root root NN 37231 1736 4 is be VBZ 37231 1736 5 brought bring VBN 37231 1736 6 to to IN 37231 1736 7 sick sick JJ 37231 1736 8 people people NNS 37231 1736 9 , , , 37231 1736 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1736 11 at at IN 37231 1736 12 once once RB 37231 1736 13 expels expel NNS 37231 1736 14 demons demon NNS 37231 1736 15 . . . 37231 1737 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1737 2 2 2 LS 37231 1737 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1737 4 According accord VBG 37231 1737 5 to to IN 37231 1737 6 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1737 7 , , , 37231 1737 8 demons demon NNS 37231 1737 9 are be VBP 37231 1737 10 the the DT 37231 1737 11 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1737 12 of of IN 37231 1737 13 the the DT 37231 1737 14 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1737 15 dead dead JJ 37231 1737 16 ; ; : 37231 1737 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1737 18 enter enter VBP 37231 1737 19 into into IN 37231 1737 20 the the DT 37231 1737 21 bodies body NNS 37231 1737 22 of of IN 37231 1737 23 the the DT 37231 1737 24 living living NN 37231 1737 25 , , , 37231 1737 26 who who WP 37231 1737 27 die die VBP 37231 1737 28 , , , 37231 1737 29 unless unless IN 37231 1737 30 succour succour NN 37231 1737 31 be be VB 37231 1737 32 speedily speedily RB 37231 1737 33 obtained obtain VBN 37231 1737 34 . . . 37231 1738 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1738 2 3 3 LS 37231 1738 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1738 4 This this DT 37231 1738 5 theory theory NN 37231 1738 6 , , , 37231 1738 7 however however RB 37231 1738 8 , , , 37231 1738 9 was be VBD 37231 1738 10 not not RB 37231 1738 11 general general JJ 37231 1738 12 , , , 37231 1738 13 demons demon NNS 37231 1738 14 being be VBG 37231 1738 15 commonly commonly RB 37231 1738 16 considered consider VBN 37231 1738 17 the the DT 37231 1738 18 offspring offspring NN 37231 1738 19 of of IN 37231 1738 20 the the DT 37231 1738 21 fallen fall VBN 37231 1738 22 angels angel NNS 37231 1738 23 and and CC 37231 1738 24 of of IN 37231 1738 25 the the DT 37231 1738 26 daughters daughter NNS 37231 1738 27 of of IN 37231 1738 28 men man NNS 37231 1738 29 . . . 37231 1739 1 The the DT 37231 1739 2 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1739 3 historian historian NN 37231 1739 4 gives give VBZ 37231 1739 5 a a DT 37231 1739 6 serious serious JJ 37231 1739 7 account account NN 37231 1739 8 of of IN 37231 1739 9 the the DT 37231 1739 10 preternatural preternatural JJ 37231 1739 11 portents portent NNS 37231 1739 12 which which WDT 37231 1739 13 warned warn VBD 37231 1739 14 the the DT 37231 1739 15 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1739 16 of of IN 37231 1739 17 the the DT 37231 1739 18 approaching approach VBG 37231 1739 19 fall fall NN 37231 1739 20 of of IN 37231 1739 21 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 1739 22 , , , 37231 1739 23 and and CC 37231 1739 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1739 25 laments lament VBZ 37231 1739 26 the the DT 37231 1739 27 infatuation infatuation NN 37231 1739 28 of of IN 37231 1739 29 the the DT 37231 1739 30 people people NNS 37231 1739 31 , , , 37231 1739 32 who who WP 37231 1739 33 disregarded disregard VBD 37231 1739 34 these these DT 37231 1739 35 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1739 36 denunciations denunciation NNS 37231 1739 37 . . . 37231 1740 1 A a DT 37231 1740 2 star star NN 37231 1740 3 in in IN 37231 1740 4 the the DT 37231 1740 5 shape shape NN 37231 1740 6 of of IN 37231 1740 7 a a DT 37231 1740 8 sword sword NN 37231 1740 9 , , , 37231 1740 10 and and CC 37231 1740 11 also also RB 37231 1740 12 a a DT 37231 1740 13 comet comet NN 37231 1740 14 , , , 37231 1740 15 stood stand VBD 37231 1740 16 over over IN 37231 1740 17 the the DT 37231 1740 18 doomed doom VBN 37231 1740 19 city city NN 37231 1740 20 for for IN 37231 1740 21 the the DT 37231 1740 22 space space NN 37231 1740 23 of of IN 37231 1740 24 a a DT 37231 1740 25 whole whole JJ 37231 1740 26 year year NN 37231 1740 27 . . . 37231 1741 1 Then then RB 37231 1741 2 , , , 37231 1741 3 at at IN 37231 1741 4 the the DT 37231 1741 5 feast feast NN 37231 1741 6 of of IN 37231 1741 7 unleavened unleavened JJ 37231 1741 8 bread bread NN 37231 1741 9 , , , 37231 1741 10 before before IN 37231 1741 11 the the DT 37231 1741 12 rebellion rebellion NN 37231 1741 13 of of IN 37231 1741 14 the the DT 37231 1741 15 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1741 16 which which WDT 37231 1741 17 preceded precede VBD 37231 1741 18 the the DT 37231 1741 19 war war NN 37231 1741 20 , , , 37231 1741 21 at at IN 37231 1741 22 the the DT 37231 1741 23 ninth ninth JJ 37231 1741 24 hour hour NN 37231 1741 25 of of IN 37231 1741 26 the the DT 37231 1741 27 night night NN 37231 1741 28 a a DT 37231 1741 29 { { -LRB- 37231 1741 30 121 121 CD 37231 1741 31 } } -RRB- 37231 1741 32 great great JJ 37231 1741 33 light light NN 37231 1741 34 shone shine VBD 37231 1741 35 round round IN 37231 1741 36 the the DT 37231 1741 37 altar altar NN 37231 1741 38 and and CC 37231 1741 39 the the DT 37231 1741 40 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1741 41 , , , 37231 1741 42 so so IN 37231 1741 43 that that IN 37231 1741 44 for for IN 37231 1741 45 half half PDT 37231 1741 46 an an DT 37231 1741 47 hour hour NN 37231 1741 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1741 49 seemed seem VBD 37231 1741 50 as as IN 37231 1741 51 though though IN 37231 1741 52 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1741 53 were be VBD 37231 1741 54 brilliant brilliant JJ 37231 1741 55 daylight daylight NN 37231 1741 56 . . . 37231 1742 1 At at IN 37231 1742 2 the the DT 37231 1742 3 same same JJ 37231 1742 4 festival festival NN 37231 1742 5 other other JJ 37231 1742 6 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1742 7 warnings warning NNS 37231 1742 8 were be VBD 37231 1742 9 given give VBN 37231 1742 10 . . . 37231 1743 1 A a DT 37231 1743 2 heifer heifer NN 37231 1743 3 , , , 37231 1743 4 as as IN 37231 1743 5 she -PRON- PRP 37231 1743 6 was be VBD 37231 1743 7 led lead VBN 37231 1743 8 by by IN 37231 1743 9 the the DT 37231 1743 10 high high JJ 37231 1743 11 - - HYPH 37231 1743 12 priest priest NN 37231 1743 13 to to TO 37231 1743 14 be be VB 37231 1743 15 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 37231 1743 16 , , , 37231 1743 17 brought bring VBD 37231 1743 18 forth forth RP 37231 1743 19 a a DT 37231 1743 20 lamb lamb NN 37231 1743 21 in in IN 37231 1743 22 the the DT 37231 1743 23 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1743 24 ; ; : 37231 1743 25 moreover moreover RB 37231 1743 26 , , , 37231 1743 27 the the DT 37231 1743 28 eastern eastern JJ 37231 1743 29 gate gate NN 37231 1743 30 of of IN 37231 1743 31 the the DT 37231 1743 32 inner inner JJ 37231 1743 33 court court NN 37231 1743 34 of of IN 37231 1743 35 the the DT 37231 1743 36 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1743 37 , , , 37231 1743 38 which which WDT 37231 1743 39 was be VBD 37231 1743 40 of of IN 37231 1743 41 brass brass NN 37231 1743 42 , , , 37231 1743 43 and and CC 37231 1743 44 so so RB 37231 1743 45 ponderous ponderous JJ 37231 1743 46 that that IN 37231 1743 47 twenty twenty CD 37231 1743 48 men man NNS 37231 1743 49 had have VBD 37231 1743 50 much much JJ 37231 1743 51 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1743 52 in in IN 37231 1743 53 closing close VBG 37231 1743 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1743 55 , , , 37231 1743 56 and and CC 37231 1743 57 which which WDT 37231 1743 58 was be VBD 37231 1743 59 fastened fasten VBN 37231 1743 60 by by IN 37231 1743 61 heavy heavy JJ 37231 1743 62 bolts bolt NNS 37231 1743 63 descending descend VBG 37231 1743 64 deep deep RB 37231 1743 65 into into IN 37231 1743 66 the the DT 37231 1743 67 solid solid JJ 37231 1743 68 stone stone NN 37231 1743 69 floor floor NN 37231 1743 70 , , , 37231 1743 71 was be VBD 37231 1743 72 seen see VBN 37231 1743 73 to to TO 37231 1743 74 open open VB 37231 1743 75 of of IN 37231 1743 76 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1743 77 own own JJ 37231 1743 78 accord accord NN 37231 1743 79 , , , 37231 1743 80 about about IN 37231 1743 81 the the DT 37231 1743 82 sixth sixth JJ 37231 1743 83 hour hour NN 37231 1743 84 of of IN 37231 1743 85 the the DT 37231 1743 86 night night NN 37231 1743 87 . . . 37231 1744 1 The the DT 37231 1744 2 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 1744 3 considered consider VBD 37231 1744 4 some some DT 37231 1744 5 of of IN 37231 1744 6 these these DT 37231 1744 7 events event NNS 37231 1744 8 good good JJ 37231 1744 9 omens omen NNS 37231 1744 10 , , , 37231 1744 11 but but CC 37231 1744 12 the the DT 37231 1744 13 priests priest NNS 37231 1744 14 interpreted interpret VBD 37231 1744 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1744 16 as as IN 37231 1744 17 portents portent NNS 37231 1744 18 of of IN 37231 1744 19 evil evil NN 37231 1744 20 . . . 37231 1745 1 Another another DT 37231 1745 2 prodigious prodigious JJ 37231 1745 3 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 1745 4 occurred occur VBD 37231 1745 5 , , , 37231 1745 6 which which WDT 37231 1745 7 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1745 8 supposes suppose VBZ 37231 1745 9 would would MD 37231 1745 10 be be VB 37231 1745 11 considered consider VBN 37231 1745 12 incredible incredible JJ 37231 1745 13 were be VBD 37231 1745 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1745 15 not not RB 37231 1745 16 reported report VBN 37231 1745 17 by by IN 37231 1745 18 those those DT 37231 1745 19 who who WP 37231 1745 20 saw see VBD 37231 1745 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1745 22 , , , 37231 1745 23 and and CC 37231 1745 24 were be VBD 37231 1745 25 the the DT 37231 1745 26 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 1745 27 events event NNS 37231 1745 28 not not RB 37231 1745 29 of of IN 37231 1745 30 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1745 31 importance importance NN 37231 1745 32 to to TO 37231 1745 33 merit merit VB 37231 1745 34 such such JJ 37231 1745 35 portents portent NNS 37231 1745 36 : : : 37231 1745 37 before before IN 37231 1745 38 sunset sunset NN 37231 1745 39 , , , 37231 1745 40 chariots chariot NNS 37231 1745 41 and and CC 37231 1745 42 troops troop NNS 37231 1745 43 of of IN 37231 1745 44 soldieis soldieis NNP 37231 1745 45 in in IN 37231 1745 46 armour armour NN 37231 1745 47 were be VBD 37231 1745 48 seen see VBN 37231 1745 49 among among IN 37231 1745 50 the the DT 37231 1745 51 clouds cloud NNS 37231 1745 52 , , , 37231 1745 53 moving move VBG 37231 1745 54 about about IN 37231 1745 55 , , , 37231 1745 56 and and CC 37231 1745 57 surrounding surround VBG 37231 1745 58 cities city NNS 37231 1745 59 . . . 37231 1746 1 And and CC 37231 1746 2 further far RBR 37231 1746 3 , , , 37231 1746 4 at at IN 37231 1746 5 the the DT 37231 1746 6 feast feast NN 37231 1746 7 of of IN 37231 1746 8 Pentecost Pentecost NNP 37231 1746 9 , , , 37231 1746 10 as as IN 37231 1746 11 the the DT 37231 1746 12 priests priest NNS 37231 1746 13 were be VBD 37231 1746 14 entering enter VBG 37231 1746 15 the the DT 37231 1746 16 inner inner JJ 37231 1746 17 court court NN 37231 1746 18 of of IN 37231 1746 19 the the DT 37231 1746 20 Temple Temple NNP 37231 1746 21 to to TO 37231 1746 22 perform perform VB 37231 1746 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1746 24 sacred sacred JJ 37231 1746 25 duties duty NNS 37231 1746 26 , , , 37231 1746 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1746 28 felt feel VBD 37231 1746 29 an an DT 37231 1746 30 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 1746 31 , , , 37231 1746 32 and and CC 37231 1746 33 heard hear VBD 37231 1746 34 a a DT 37231 1746 35 great great JJ 37231 1746 36 noise noise NN 37231 1746 37 , , , 37231 1746 38 and and CC 37231 1746 39 then then RB 37231 1746 40 the the DT 37231 1746 41 sound sound NN 37231 1746 42 as as IN 37231 1746 43 of of IN 37231 1746 44 a a DT 37231 1746 45 great great JJ 37231 1746 46 multitude multitude NN 37231 1746 47 saying say VBG 37231 1746 48 : : : 37231 1746 49 " " `` 37231 1746 50 Let let VB 37231 1746 51 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1746 52 remove remove VB 37231 1746 53 hence hence RB 37231 1746 54 . . . 37231 1747 1 " " `` 37231 1747 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1747 3 l l NN 37231 1747 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1747 5 There there EX 37231 1747 6 is be VBZ 37231 1747 7 not not RB 37231 1747 8 a a DT 37231 1747 9 shadow shadow NN 37231 1747 10 of of IN 37231 1747 11 doubt doubt NN 37231 1747 12 in in IN 37231 1747 13 the the DT 37231 1747 14 mind mind NN 37231 1747 15 of of IN 37231 1747 16 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1747 17 as as IN 37231 1747 18 to to IN 37231 1747 19 the the DT 37231 1747 20 reality reality NN 37231 1747 21 of of IN 37231 1747 22 any any DT 37231 1747 23 of of IN 37231 1747 24 these these DT 37231 1747 25 wonders wonder NNS 37231 1747 26 . . . 37231 1748 1 If if IN 37231 1748 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1748 3 turn turn VBP 37231 1748 4 to to IN 37231 1748 5 patristic patristic JJ 37231 1748 6 literature literature NN 37231 1748 7 , , , 37231 1748 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1748 9 find find VBP 37231 1748 10 , , , 37231 1748 11 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 1748 12 , , , 37231 1748 13 the the DT 37231 1748 14 same same JJ 37231 1748 15 superstitions superstition NNS 37231 1748 16 and and CC 37231 1748 17 the the DT 37231 1748 18 same same JJ 37231 1748 19 theories theory NNS 37231 1748 20 of of IN 37231 1748 21 angelic angelic JJ 37231 1748 22 agency agency NN 37231 1748 23 and and CC 37231 1748 24 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1748 25 interference interference NN 37231 1748 26 in in IN 37231 1748 27 cosmical cosmical JJ 37231 1748 28 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1748 29 . . . 37231 1749 1 According accord VBG 37231 1749 2 to to IN 37231 1749 3 Justin Justin NNP 37231 1749 4 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 1749 5 , , , 37231 1749 6 after after IN 37231 1749 7 God God NNP 37231 1749 8 had have VBD 37231 1749 9 made make VBN 37231 1749 10 the the DT 37231 1749 11 world world NN 37231 1749 12 and and CC 37231 1749 13 duly duly RB 37231 1749 14 regulated regulate VBD 37231 1749 15 the the DT 37231 1749 16 elements element NNS 37231 1749 17 and and CC 37231 1749 18 the the DT 37231 1749 19 rotation rotation NN 37231 1749 20 of of IN 37231 1749 21 the the DT 37231 1749 22 seasons season NNS 37231 1749 23 , , , 37231 1749 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1749 25 committed commit VBD 37231 1749 26 man man NN 37231 1749 27 and and CC 37231 1749 28 all all DT 37231 1749 29 { { -LRB- 37231 1749 30 122 122 CD 37231 1749 31 } } -RRB- 37231 1749 32 things thing NNS 37231 1749 33 under under IN 37231 1749 34 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1749 35 to to IN 37231 1749 36 the the DT 37231 1749 37 care care NN 37231 1749 38 of of IN 37231 1749 39 angels angel NNS 37231 1749 40 . . . 37231 1750 1 Some some DT 37231 1750 2 of of IN 37231 1750 3 these these DT 37231 1750 4 angels angel NNS 37231 1750 5 , , , 37231 1750 6 however however RB 37231 1750 7 , , , 37231 1750 8 proved prove VBN 37231 1750 9 unworthy unworthy JJ 37231 1750 10 of of IN 37231 1750 11 this this DT 37231 1750 12 charge charge NN 37231 1750 13 , , , 37231 1750 14 and and CC 37231 1750 15 , , , 37231 1750 16 led lead VBN 37231 1750 17 away away RB 37231 1750 18 by by IN 37231 1750 19 love love NN 37231 1750 20 of of IN 37231 1750 21 the the DT 37231 1750 22 daughters daughter NNS 37231 1750 23 of of IN 37231 1750 24 men man NNS 37231 1750 25 , , , 37231 1750 26 begat begat NNP 37231 1750 27 children child NNS 37231 1750 28 , , , 37231 1750 29 who who WP 37231 1750 30 are be VBP 37231 1750 31 the the DT 37231 1750 32 demons demon NNS 37231 1750 33 who who WP 37231 1750 34 have have VBP 37231 1750 35 corrupted corrupt VBN 37231 1750 36 the the DT 37231 1750 37 human human JJ 37231 1750 38 race race NN 37231 1750 39 , , , 37231 1750 40 partly partly RB 37231 1750 41 by by IN 37231 1750 42 magical magical JJ 37231 1750 43 writings writing NNS 37231 1750 44 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1750 45 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1750 46 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1750 47 and and CC 37231 1750 48 partly partly RB 37231 1750 49 by by IN 37231 1750 50 fears fear NNS 37231 1750 51 and and CC 37231 1750 52 punishments punishment NNS 37231 1750 53 , , , 37231 1750 54 and and CC 37231 1750 55 who who WP 37231 1750 56 have have VBP 37231 1750 57 introduced introduce VBN 37231 1750 58 wars war NNS 37231 1750 59 , , , 37231 1750 60 murders murder NNS 37231 1750 61 , , , 37231 1750 62 and and CC 37231 1750 63 other other JJ 37231 1750 64 evils evil NNS 37231 1750 65 amongst amongst IN 37231 1750 66 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1750 67 , , , 37231 1750 68 which which WDT 37231 1750 69 are be VBP 37231 1750 70 ignorantly ignorantly RB 37231 1750 71 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1750 72 by by IN 37231 1750 73 poets poet NNS 37231 1750 74 to to IN 37231 1750 75 God God NNP 37231 1750 76 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1750 77 . . . 37231 1751 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1751 2 1 1 LS 37231 1751 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1751 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1751 5 considers consider VBZ 37231 1751 6 that that IN 37231 1751 7 demoniacs demoniac NNS 37231 1751 8 are be VBP 37231 1751 9 possessed possess VBN 37231 1751 10 and and CC 37231 1751 11 tortured torture VBN 37231 1751 12 by by IN 37231 1751 13 the the DT 37231 1751 14 souls soul NNS 37231 1751 15 of of IN 37231 1751 16 the the DT 37231 1751 17 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1751 18 dead,(2 dead,(2 NNP 37231 1751 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1751 20 and and CC 37231 1751 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1751 22 represents represent VBZ 37231 1751 23 evil evil JJ 37231 1751 24 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1751 25 as as IN 37231 1751 26 watching watch VBG 37231 1751 27 to to TO 37231 1751 28 seize seize VB 37231 1751 29 the the DT 37231 1751 30 soul soul NN 37231 1751 31 at at IN 37231 1751 32 death death NN 37231 1751 33 . . . 37231 1752 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1752 2 3 3 LS 37231 1752 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1752 4 The the DT 37231 1752 5 food food NN 37231 1752 6 of of IN 37231 1752 7 the the DT 37231 1752 8 angels angel NNS 37231 1752 9 is be VBZ 37231 1752 10 manna manna NN 37231 1752 11 . . . 37231 1753 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1753 2 4 4 LS 37231 1753 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1753 4 The the DT 37231 1753 5 angels angel NNS 37231 1753 6 , , , 37231 1753 7 says say VBZ 37231 1753 8 Clement Clement NNP 37231 1753 9 of of IN 37231 1753 10 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 1753 11 , , , 37231 1753 12 serve serve VB 37231 1753 13 God God NNP 37231 1753 14 in in IN 37231 1753 15 the the DT 37231 1753 16 administration administration NN 37231 1753 17 of of IN 37231 1753 18 earthly earthly NNP 37231 1753 19 affairs affair NNS 37231 1753 20 . . . 37231 1754 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1754 2 5 5 LS 37231 1754 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1754 4 The the DT 37231 1754 5 host host NN 37231 1754 6 of of IN 37231 1754 7 angels angel NNS 37231 1754 8 and and CC 37231 1754 9 of of IN 37231 1754 10 gods god NNS 37231 1754 11 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1754 12 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1754 13 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1754 14 is be VBZ 37231 1754 15 placed place VBN 37231 1754 16 under under IN 37231 1754 17 subjection subjection NN 37231 1754 18 to to IN 37231 1754 19 the the DT 37231 1754 20 Logos Logos NNP 37231 1754 21 . . . 37231 1755 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1755 2 6 6 CD 37231 1755 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1755 4 Presiding preside VBG 37231 1755 5 angels angel NNS 37231 1755 6 are be VBP 37231 1755 7 distributed distribute VBN 37231 1755 8 over over IN 37231 1755 9 nations nation NNS 37231 1755 10 and and CC 37231 1755 11 cities city NNS 37231 1755 12 , , , 37231 1755 13 and and CC 37231 1755 14 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 1755 15 are be VBP 37231 1755 16 also also RB 37231 1755 17 deputed depute VBN 37231 1755 18 to to IN 37231 1755 19 individuals,(7 individuals,(7 NNS 37231 1755 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1755 21 and and CC 37231 1755 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1755 23 is be VBZ 37231 1755 24 by by IN 37231 1755 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1755 26 agency agency NN 37231 1755 27 , , , 37231 1755 28 either either CC 37231 1755 29 visible visible JJ 37231 1755 30 or or CC 37231 1755 31 invisible invisible JJ 37231 1755 32 , , , 37231 1755 33 that that IN 37231 1755 34 God God NNP 37231 1755 35 gives give VBZ 37231 1755 36 all all DT 37231 1755 37 good good JJ 37231 1755 38 things thing NNS 37231 1755 39 . . . 37231 1756 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1756 2 8) 8) CD 37231 1756 3 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1756 4 accuses accuse VBZ 37231 1756 5 the the DT 37231 1756 6 Greeks Greeks NNPS 37231 1756 7 of of IN 37231 1756 8 plagiarizing plagiarize VBG 37231 1756 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1756 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1756 11 from from IN 37231 1756 12 the the DT 37231 1756 13 Bible Bible NNP 37231 1756 14 , , , 37231 1756 15 and and CC 37231 1756 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1756 17 argues argue VBZ 37231 1756 18 that that IN 37231 1756 19 if if IN 37231 1756 20 certain certain JJ 37231 1756 21 powers power NNS 37231 1756 22 do do VBP 37231 1756 23 move move VB 37231 1756 24 the the DT 37231 1756 25 winds wind NNS 37231 1756 26 and and CC 37231 1756 27 distribute distribute VB 37231 1756 28 showers shower NNS 37231 1756 29 , , , 37231 1756 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1756 31 are be VBP 37231 1756 32 agents agent NNS 37231 1756 33 subject subject JJ 37231 1756 34 to to IN 37231 1756 35 God God NNP 37231 1756 36 . . . 37231 1757 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1757 2 9 9 LS 37231 1757 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1757 4 Clement Clement NNP 37231 1757 5 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 1757 6 that that IN 37231 1757 7 the the DT 37231 1757 8 Son Son NNP 37231 1757 9 gave give VBD 37231 1757 10 philosophy philosophy NN 37231 1757 11 to to IN 37231 1757 12 the the DT 37231 1757 13 Greeks Greeks NNPS 37231 1757 14 by by IN 37231 1757 15 means mean NNS 37231 1757 16 of of IN 37231 1757 17 the the DT 37231 1757 18 inferior inferior JJ 37231 1757 19 angels,(10 angels,(10 NNP 37231 1757 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1757 21 and and CC 37231 1757 22 argues argue VBZ 37231 1757 23 that that IN 37231 1757 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1757 25 is be VBZ 37231 1757 26 absurd absurd JJ 37231 1757 27 to to TO 37231 1757 28 attribute attribute VB 37231 1757 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1757 30 to to IN 37231 1757 31 the the DT 37231 1757 32 devil devil NN 37231 1757 33 . . . 37231 1758 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1758 2 11 11 CD 37231 1758 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1758 4 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 37231 1758 5 of of IN 37231 1758 6 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 1758 7 , , , 37231 1758 8 on on IN 37231 1758 9 the the DT 37231 1758 10 other other JJ 37231 1758 11 hand hand NN 37231 1758 12 , , , 37231 1758 13 says say VBZ 37231 1758 14 that that IN 37231 1758 15 the the DT 37231 1758 16 Greek greek JJ 37231 1758 17 poets poet NNS 37231 1758 18 were be VBD 37231 1758 19 inspired inspire VBN 37231 1758 20 by by IN 37231 1758 21 demons demon NNS 37231 1758 22 . . . 37231 1759 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1759 2 12 12 CD 37231 1759 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1759 4 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 37231 1759 5 states state NNS 37231 1759 6 , , , 37231 1759 7 as as IN 37231 1759 8 one one CD 37231 1759 9 of of IN 37231 1759 10 the the DT 37231 1759 11 principal principal JJ 37231 1759 12 { { -LRB- 37231 1759 13 123 123 CD 37231 1759 14 } } -RRB- 37231 1759 15 points point NNS 37231 1759 16 of of IN 37231 1759 17 belief belief NN 37231 1759 18 among among IN 37231 1759 19 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 1759 20 , , , 37231 1759 21 that that IN 37231 1759 22 a a DT 37231 1759 23 multitude multitude NN 37231 1759 24 of of IN 37231 1759 25 angels angel NNS 37231 1759 26 and and CC 37231 1759 27 ministers minister NNS 37231 1759 28 are be VBP 37231 1759 29 distributed distribute VBN 37231 1759 30 and and CC 37231 1759 31 appointed appoint VBN 37231 1759 32 by by IN 37231 1759 33 the the DT 37231 1759 34 Logos Logos NNP 37231 1759 35 to to TO 37231 1759 36 occupy occupy VB 37231 1759 37 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1759 38 about about IN 37231 1759 39 the the DT 37231 1759 40 elements element NNS 37231 1759 41 , , , 37231 1759 42 and and CC 37231 1759 43 the the DT 37231 1759 44 heavens heavens NNPS 37231 1759 45 , , , 37231 1759 46 and and CC 37231 1759 47 the the DT 37231 1759 48 universe universe NN 37231 1759 49 and and CC 37231 1759 50 the the DT 37231 1759 51 things thing NNS 37231 1759 52 in in IN 37231 1759 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1759 54 , , , 37231 1759 55 and and CC 37231 1759 56 the the DT 37231 1759 57 regulating regulating NN 37231 1759 58 of of IN 37231 1759 59 the the DT 37231 1759 60 whole whole NN 37231 1759 61 . . . 37231 1760 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1760 2 1 1 LS 37231 1760 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1760 4 For for IN 37231 1760 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1760 6 is be VBZ 37231 1760 7 the the DT 37231 1760 8 duty duty NN 37231 1760 9 of of IN 37231 1760 10 the the DT 37231 1760 11 angels angel NNS 37231 1760 12 to to TO 37231 1760 13 exercise exercise VB 37231 1760 14 providence providence NN 37231 1760 15 over over IN 37231 1760 16 all all DT 37231 1760 17 that that WDT 37231 1760 18 God God NNP 37231 1760 19 has have VBZ 37231 1760 20 created create VBN 37231 1760 21 ; ; : 37231 1760 22 so so IN 37231 1760 23 that that IN 37231 1760 24 God God NNP 37231 1760 25 may may MD 37231 1760 26 have have VB 37231 1760 27 the the DT 37231 1760 28 universal universal JJ 37231 1760 29 care care NN 37231 1760 30 of of IN 37231 1760 31 the the DT 37231 1760 32 whole whole NN 37231 1760 33 , , , 37231 1760 34 but but CC 37231 1760 35 the the DT 37231 1760 36 several several JJ 37231 1760 37 parts part NNS 37231 1760 38 be be VB 37231 1760 39 ministered minister VBN 37231 1760 40 to to IN 37231 1760 41 by by IN 37231 1760 42 the the DT 37231 1760 43 angels angel NNS 37231 1760 44 appointed appoint VBN 37231 1760 45 over over IN 37231 1760 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1760 47 . . . 37231 1761 1 There there EX 37231 1761 2 is be VBZ 37231 1761 3 freedom freedom NN 37231 1761 4 of of IN 37231 1761 5 will will NN 37231 1761 6 amongst amongst IN 37231 1761 7 the the DT 37231 1761 8 angels angel NNS 37231 1761 9 as as IN 37231 1761 10 among among IN 37231 1761 11 human human JJ 37231 1761 12 beings being NNS 37231 1761 13 , , , 37231 1761 14 and and CC 37231 1761 15 some some DT 37231 1761 16 of of IN 37231 1761 17 the the DT 37231 1761 18 angels angel NNS 37231 1761 19 abused abuse VBD 37231 1761 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1761 21 trust trust NN 37231 1761 22 , , , 37231 1761 23 and and CC 37231 1761 24 fell fall VBD 37231 1761 25 through through IN 37231 1761 26 love love NN 37231 1761 27 of of IN 37231 1761 28 the the DT 37231 1761 29 daughters daughter NNS 37231 1761 30 of of IN 37231 1761 31 men man NNS 37231 1761 32 , , , 37231 1761 33 of of IN 37231 1761 34 whom whom WP 37231 1761 35 were be VBD 37231 1761 36 begotten beget VBN 37231 1761 37 those those DT 37231 1761 38 who who WP 37231 1761 39 are be VBP 37231 1761 40 called call VBN 37231 1761 41 Giants Giants NNPS 37231 1761 42 . . . 37231 1762 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1762 2 2 2 LS 37231 1762 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1762 4 These these DT 37231 1762 5 angels angel NNS 37231 1762 6 who who WP 37231 1762 7 have have VBP 37231 1762 8 fallen fall VBN 37231 1762 9 from from IN 37231 1762 10 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1762 11 busy busy JJ 37231 1762 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1762 13 about about IN 37231 1762 14 the the DT 37231 1762 15 air air NN 37231 1762 16 and and CC 37231 1762 17 the the DT 37231 1762 18 earth earth NN 37231 1762 19 ; ; : 37231 1762 20 and and CC 37231 1762 21 the the DT 37231 1762 22 souls soul NNS 37231 1762 23 of of IN 37231 1762 24 the the DT 37231 1762 25 Giants,(3 giants,(3 NN 37231 1762 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1762 27 which which WDT 37231 1762 28 are be VBP 37231 1762 29 the the DT 37231 1762 30 demons demon NNS 37231 1762 31 that that WDT 37231 1762 32 roam roam VBP 37231 1762 33 about about IN 37231 1762 34 the the DT 37231 1762 35 world world NN 37231 1762 36 , , , 37231 1762 37 work work VB 37231 1762 38 evil evil NN 37231 1762 39 according accord VBG 37231 1762 40 to to IN 37231 1762 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1762 42 respective respective JJ 37231 1762 43 natures nature NNS 37231 1762 44 . . . 37231 1763 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1763 2 4 4 LS 37231 1763 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1763 4 There there EX 37231 1763 5 are be VBP 37231 1763 6 powers power NNS 37231 1763 7 which which WDT 37231 1763 8 exercise exercise VBP 37231 1763 9 dominion dominion NN 37231 1763 10 over over IN 37231 1763 11 matter matter NN 37231 1763 12 , , , 37231 1763 13 and and CC 37231 1763 14 by by IN 37231 1763 15 means mean NNS 37231 1763 16 of of IN 37231 1763 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1763 18 , , , 37231 1763 19 and and CC 37231 1763 20 more more RBR 37231 1763 21 especially especially RB 37231 1763 22 one one CD 37231 1763 23 , , , 37231 1763 24 who who WP 37231 1763 25 is be VBZ 37231 1763 26 opposed opposed JJ 37231 1763 27 to to IN 37231 1763 28 God God NNP 37231 1763 29 . . . 37231 1764 1 This this DT 37231 1764 2 Prince Prince NNP 37231 1764 3 of of IN 37231 1764 4 matter matter NN 37231 1764 5 exerts exert NNS 37231 1764 6 authority authority NN 37231 1764 7 and and CC 37231 1764 8 control control NN 37231 1764 9 in in IN 37231 1764 10 opposition opposition NN 37231 1764 11 to to IN 37231 1764 12 the the DT 37231 1764 13 good good JJ 37231 1764 14 designed design VBN 37231 1764 15 by by IN 37231 1764 16 God God NNP 37231 1764 17 . . . 37231 1765 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1765 2 5 5 LS 37231 1765 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1765 4 Demons demon NNS 37231 1765 5 are be VBP 37231 1765 6 greedy greedy JJ 37231 1765 7 for for IN 37231 1765 8 sacrificial sacrificial JJ 37231 1765 9 odours odour NNS 37231 1765 10 and and CC 37231 1765 11 the the DT 37231 1765 12 blood blood NN 37231 1765 13 of of IN 37231 1765 14 the the DT 37231 1765 15 victims victim NNS 37231 1765 16 , , , 37231 1765 17 which which WDT 37231 1765 18 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1765 19 lick lick VBP 37231 1765 20 ; ; : 37231 1765 21 and and CC 37231 1765 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1765 23 influence influence VBP 37231 1765 24 the the DT 37231 1765 25 multitude multitude NN 37231 1765 26 to to IN 37231 1765 27 idolatry idolatry VB 37231 1765 28 by by IN 37231 1765 29 inspiring inspire VBG 37231 1765 30 thoughts thought NNS 37231 1765 31 and and CC 37231 1765 32 visions vision NNS 37231 1765 33 which which WDT 37231 1765 34 seem seem VBP 37231 1765 35 to to TO 37231 1765 36 come come VB 37231 1765 37 from from IN 37231 1765 38 idols idol NNS 37231 1765 39 and and CC 37231 1765 40 statues statue NNS 37231 1765 41 . . . 37231 1766 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1766 2 6 6 LS 37231 1766 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1766 4 According accord VBG 37231 1766 5 to to IN 37231 1766 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 37231 1766 7 , , , 37231 1766 8 God God NNP 37231 1766 9 made make VBD 37231 1766 10 everything everything NN 37231 1766 11 which which WDT 37231 1766 12 is be VBZ 37231 1766 13 good good JJ 37231 1766 14 , , , 37231 1766 15 but but CC 37231 1766 16 the the DT 37231 1766 17 wickedness wickedness NN 37231 1766 18 of of IN 37231 1766 19 demons demon NNS 37231 1766 20 perverts pervert NNS 37231 1766 21 { { -LRB- 37231 1766 22 124 124 CD 37231 1766 23 } } -RRB- 37231 1766 24 the the DT 37231 1766 25 productions production NNS 37231 1766 26 of of IN 37231 1766 27 nature nature NN 37231 1766 28 for for IN 37231 1766 29 bad bad JJ 37231 1766 30 purposes purpose NNS 37231 1766 31 , , , 37231 1766 32 and and CC 37231 1766 33 the the DT 37231 1766 34 evil evil NN 37231 1766 35 in in IN 37231 1766 36 these these DT 37231 1766 37 is be VBZ 37231 1766 38 due due JJ 37231 1766 39 to to IN 37231 1766 40 demons demon NNS 37231 1766 41 and and CC 37231 1766 42 not not RB 37231 1766 43 to to IN 37231 1766 44 God God NNP 37231 1766 45 . . . 37231 1767 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1767 2 1 1 LS 37231 1767 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1767 4 None none NN 37231 1767 5 of of IN 37231 1767 6 the the DT 37231 1767 7 demons demon NNS 37231 1767 8 have have VBP 37231 1767 9 bodies body NNS 37231 1767 10 ; ; : 37231 1767 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1767 12 are be VBP 37231 1767 13 spiritual spiritual JJ 37231 1767 14 , , , 37231 1767 15 like like IN 37231 1767 16 fire fire NN 37231 1767 17 or or CC 37231 1767 18 air air NN 37231 1767 19 , , , 37231 1767 20 and and CC 37231 1767 21 can can MD 37231 1767 22 only only RB 37231 1767 23 be be VB 37231 1767 24 seen see VBN 37231 1767 25 by by IN 37231 1767 26 those those DT 37231 1767 27 in in IN 37231 1767 28 whom whom WP 37231 1767 29 the the DT 37231 1767 30 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 1767 31 of of IN 37231 1767 32 God God NNP 37231 1767 33 dwells dwell VBZ 37231 1767 34 . . . 37231 1768 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1768 2 attack attack VBP 37231 1768 3 men man NNS 37231 1768 4 by by IN 37231 1768 5 means mean NNS 37231 1768 6 of of IN 37231 1768 7 lower low JJR 37231 1768 8 forms form NNS 37231 1768 9 of of IN 37231 1768 10 matter matter NN 37231 1768 11 , , , 37231 1768 12 and and CC 37231 1768 13 come come VB 37231 1768 14 to to IN 37231 1768 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1768 16 whenever whenever WRB 37231 1768 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1768 18 are be VBP 37231 1768 19 diseased disease VBN 37231 1768 20 , , , 37231 1768 21 and and CC 37231 1768 22 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1768 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1768 24 cause cause VBP 37231 1768 25 disorders disorder NNS 37231 1768 26 of of IN 37231 1768 27 the the DT 37231 1768 28 body body NN 37231 1768 29 , , , 37231 1768 30 but but CC 37231 1768 31 when when WRB 37231 1768 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1768 33 are be VBP 37231 1768 34 struck strike VBN 37231 1768 35 by by IN 37231 1768 36 the the DT 37231 1768 37 power power NN 37231 1768 38 of of IN 37231 1768 39 the the DT 37231 1768 40 word word NN 37231 1768 41 of of IN 37231 1768 42 God God NNP 37231 1768 43 , , , 37231 1768 44 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1768 45 flee flee VBP 37231 1768 46 in in IN 37231 1768 47 terror terror NN 37231 1768 48 , , , 37231 1768 49 and and CC 37231 1768 50 the the DT 37231 1768 51 sick sick JJ 37231 1768 52 person person NN 37231 1768 53 is be VBZ 37231 1768 54 healed heal VBN 37231 1768 55 . . . 37231 1769 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1769 2 2 2 LS 37231 1769 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1769 4 Various various JJ 37231 1769 5 kinds kind NNS 37231 1769 6 of of IN 37231 1769 7 roots root NNS 37231 1769 8 , , , 37231 1769 9 and and CC 37231 1769 10 the the DT 37231 1769 11 relations relation NNS 37231 1769 12 of of IN 37231 1769 13 bones bone NNS 37231 1769 14 and and CC 37231 1769 15 sinews sinew NNS 37231 1769 16 , , , 37231 1769 17 are be VBP 37231 1769 18 the the DT 37231 1769 19 material material JJ 37231 1769 20 elements element NNS 37231 1769 21 through through IN 37231 1769 22 which which WDT 37231 1769 23 demons demon NNS 37231 1769 24 work work VBP 37231 1769 25 . . . 37231 1770 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1770 2 3 3 LS 37231 1770 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1770 4 Some some DT 37231 1770 5 of of IN 37231 1770 6 those those DT 37231 1770 7 who who WP 37231 1770 8 are be VBP 37231 1770 9 called call VBN 37231 1770 10 gods god NNS 37231 1770 11 by by IN 37231 1770 12 the the DT 37231 1770 13 Greeks Greeks NNPS 37231 1770 14 , , , 37231 1770 15 but but CC 37231 1770 16 are be VBP 37231 1770 17 in in IN 37231 1770 18 reality reality NN 37231 1770 19 demons demon NNS 37231 1770 20 , , , 37231 1770 21 possess possess VBP 37231 1770 22 the the DT 37231 1770 23 bodies body NNS 37231 1770 24 of of IN 37231 1770 25 certain certain JJ 37231 1770 26 men man NNS 37231 1770 27 , , , 37231 1770 28 and and CC 37231 1770 29 then then RB 37231 1770 30 by by IN 37231 1770 31 publicly publicly RB 37231 1770 32 leaving leave VBG 37231 1770 33 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1770 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1770 35 destroy destroy VBP 37231 1770 36 the the DT 37231 1770 37 disease disease NN 37231 1770 38 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1770 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1770 40 had have VBD 37231 1770 41 created create VBN 37231 1770 42 , , , 37231 1770 43 and and CC 37231 1770 44 the the DT 37231 1770 45 sick sick NN 37231 1770 46 are be VBP 37231 1770 47 restored restore VBN 37231 1770 48 to to IN 37231 1770 49 health health NN 37231 1770 50 . . . 37231 1771 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1771 2 4 4 LS 37231 1771 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1771 4 Demons demon NNS 37231 1771 5 , , , 37231 1771 6 says say VBZ 37231 1771 7 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 37231 1771 8 of of IN 37231 1771 9 Carthage Carthage NNP 37231 1771 10 , , , 37231 1771 11 lurk lurk JJ 37231 1771 12 under under IN 37231 1771 13 consecrated consecrate VBN 37231 1771 14 statues statue NNS 37231 1771 15 , , , 37231 1771 16 and and CC 37231 1771 17 inspire inspire VB 37231 1771 18 false false JJ 37231 1771 19 oracles oracle NNS 37231 1771 20 , , , 37231 1771 21 and and CC 37231 1771 22 control control VB 37231 1771 23 the the DT 37231 1771 24 lots lot NNS 37231 1771 25 and and CC 37231 1771 26 omens omen NNS 37231 1771 27 . . . 37231 1772 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1772 2 5 5 LS 37231 1772 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1772 4 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1772 5 enter enter VBP 37231 1772 6 into into IN 37231 1772 7 human human JJ 37231 1772 8 bodies body NNS 37231 1772 9 and and CC 37231 1772 10 feign feign VB 37231 1772 11 various various JJ 37231 1772 12 maladies malady NNS 37231 1772 13 in in IN 37231 1772 14 order order NN 37231 1772 15 to to TO 37231 1772 16 induce induce VB 37231 1772 17 men man NNS 37231 1772 18 to to TO 37231 1772 19 offer offer VB 37231 1772 20 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 37231 1772 21 for for IN 37231 1772 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1772 23 recovery recovery NN 37231 1772 24 that that IN 37231 1772 25 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1772 26 may may MD 37231 1772 27 gorge gorge VB 37231 1772 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1772 29 with with IN 37231 1772 30 the the DT 37231 1772 31 fumes fume NNS 37231 1772 32 , , , 37231 1772 33 and and CC 37231 1772 34 then then RB 37231 1772 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1772 36 heal heal VBP 37231 1772 37 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1772 38 . . . 37231 1773 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1773 2 are be VBP 37231 1773 3 really really RB 37231 1773 4 the the DT 37231 1773 5 authors author NNS 37231 1773 6 of of IN 37231 1773 7 the the DT 37231 1773 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1773 9 attributed attribute VBN 37231 1773 10 to to IN 37231 1773 11 heathen heathen NNP 37231 1773 12 deities deity NNS 37231 1773 13 . . . 37231 1774 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1774 2 6 6 LS 37231 1774 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1774 4 Tertullian tertullian JJ 37231 1774 5 enters enter VBZ 37231 1774 6 into into IN 37231 1774 7 minute minute NN 37231 1774 8 details detail NNS 37231 1774 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 1774 10 angels angel NNS 37231 1774 11 and and CC 37231 1774 12 demons demon NNS 37231 1774 13 . . . 37231 1775 1 Demons demon NNS 37231 1775 2 are be VBP 37231 1775 3 the the DT 37231 1775 4 offspring offspring NN 37231 1775 5 of of IN 37231 1775 6 the the DT 37231 1775 7 fallen fall VBN 37231 1775 8 angels angel NNS 37231 1775 9 , , , 37231 1775 10 and and CC 37231 1775 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1775 12 work work NN 37231 1775 13 is be VBZ 37231 1775 14 the the DT 37231 1775 15 destruction destruction NN 37231 1775 16 of of IN 37231 1775 17 the the DT 37231 1775 18 human human JJ 37231 1775 19 race race NN 37231 1775 20 . . . 37231 1776 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1776 2 inflict inflict VBP 37231 1776 3 diseases disease NNS 37231 1776 4 and and CC 37231 1776 5 other other JJ 37231 1776 6 painful painful JJ 37231 1776 7 calamities calamity NNS 37231 1776 8 upon upon IN 37231 1776 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1776 10 bodies body NNS 37231 1776 11 , , , 37231 1776 12 and and CC 37231 1776 13 lead lead NN 37231 1776 14 astray astray VB 37231 1776 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1776 16 souls soul NNS 37231 1776 17 . . . 37231 1777 1 From from IN 37231 1777 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1777 3 { { -LRB- 37231 1777 4 125 125 CD 37231 1777 5 } } -RRB- 37231 1777 6 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 1777 7 subtleness subtleness NN 37231 1777 8 and and CC 37231 1777 9 tenuity tenuity NN 37231 1777 10 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1777 11 find find VBP 37231 1777 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1777 13 way way NN 37231 1777 14 into into IN 37231 1777 15 both both DT 37231 1777 16 parts part NNS 37231 1777 17 of of IN 37231 1777 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1777 19 composition composition NN 37231 1777 20 . . . 37231 1778 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1778 2 spirituality spirituality NN 37231 1778 3 enables enable VBZ 37231 1778 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1778 5 to to TO 37231 1778 6 do do VB 37231 1778 7 much much JJ 37231 1778 8 harm harm NN 37231 1778 9 to to IN 37231 1778 10 men man NNS 37231 1778 11 , , , 37231 1778 12 for for IN 37231 1778 13 being be VBG 37231 1778 14 invisible invisible JJ 37231 1778 15 and and CC 37231 1778 16 impalpable impalpable JJ 37231 1778 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1778 18 appear appear VBP 37231 1778 19 rather rather RB 37231 1778 20 in in IN 37231 1778 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1778 22 effects effect NNS 37231 1778 23 than than IN 37231 1778 24 in in IN 37231 1778 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1778 26 action action NN 37231 1778 27 . . . 37231 1779 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1779 2 blight blight VBP 37231 1779 3 the the DT 37231 1779 4 apples apple NNS 37231 1779 5 and and CC 37231 1779 6 the the DT 37231 1779 7 grain grain NN 37231 1779 8 while while IN 37231 1779 9 in in IN 37231 1779 10 the the DT 37231 1779 11 flower flower NN 37231 1779 12 , , , 37231 1779 13 as as IN 37231 1779 14 by by IN 37231 1779 15 some some DT 37231 1779 16 mysterious mysterious JJ 37231 1779 17 poison poison NN 37231 1779 18 in in IN 37231 1779 19 the the DT 37231 1779 20 breeze breeze NN 37231 1779 21 , , , 37231 1779 22 and and CC 37231 1779 23 kill kill VB 37231 1779 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1779 25 in in IN 37231 1779 26 the the DT 37231 1779 27 bud bud NN 37231 1779 28 , , , 37231 1779 29 or or CC 37231 1779 30 nip nip VB 37231 1779 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1779 32 before before IN 37231 1779 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1779 34 are be VBP 37231 1779 35 ripe ripe JJ 37231 1779 36 , , , 37231 1779 37 as as IN 37231 1779 38 though though IN 37231 1779 39 in in IN 37231 1779 40 some some DT 37231 1779 41 inexpressible inexpressible JJ 37231 1779 42 way way NN 37231 1779 43 the the DT 37231 1779 44 tainted taint VBN 37231 1779 45 air air NN 37231 1779 46 poured pour VBD 37231 1779 47 forth forth RP 37231 1779 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1779 49 pestilential pestilential JJ 37231 1779 50 breath breath NN 37231 1779 51 . . . 37231 1780 1 In in IN 37231 1780 2 the the DT 37231 1780 3 same same JJ 37231 1780 4 way way NN 37231 1780 5 demons demon NNS 37231 1780 6 and and CC 37231 1780 7 angels angel NNS 37231 1780 8 breathe breathe VBP 37231 1780 9 into into IN 37231 1780 10 the the DT 37231 1780 11 soul soul NN 37231 1780 12 and and CC 37231 1780 13 excite excite VB 37231 1780 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1780 15 corruptions corruption NNS 37231 1780 16 , , , 37231 1780 17 and and CC 37231 1780 18 especially especially RB 37231 1780 19 mislead mislead VBP 37231 1780 20 men man NNS 37231 1780 21 by by IN 37231 1780 22 inducing induce VBG 37231 1780 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1780 24 to to TO 37231 1780 25 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37231 1780 26 to to IN 37231 1780 27 false false JJ 37231 1780 28 deities deity NNS 37231 1780 29 in in IN 37231 1780 30 order order NN 37231 1780 31 that that IN 37231 1780 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1780 33 may may MD 37231 1780 34 thus thus RB 37231 1780 35 obtain obtain VB 37231 1780 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1780 37 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 1780 38 food food NN 37231 1780 39 of of IN 37231 1780 40 fumes fume NNS 37231 1780 41 of of IN 37231 1780 42 flesh flesh NN 37231 1780 43 and and CC 37231 1780 44 blood blood NN 37231 1780 45 . . . 37231 1781 1 Every every DT 37231 1781 2 spirit spirit NN 37231 1781 3 , , , 37231 1781 4 whether whether IN 37231 1781 5 angel angel NN 37231 1781 6 or or CC 37231 1781 7 demon demon NN 37231 1781 8 , , , 37231 1781 9 has have VBZ 37231 1781 10 wings wing NNS 37231 1781 11 ; ; : 37231 1781 12 therefore therefore RB 37231 1781 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1781 14 are be VBP 37231 1781 15 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 1781 16 in in IN 37231 1781 17 a a DT 37231 1781 18 moment moment NN 37231 1781 19 . . . 37231 1782 1 The the DT 37231 1782 2 whole whole JJ 37231 1782 3 world world NN 37231 1782 4 is be VBZ 37231 1782 5 but but CC 37231 1782 6 one one CD 37231 1782 7 place place NN 37231 1782 8 to to IN 37231 1782 9 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1782 10 , , , 37231 1782 11 and and CC 37231 1782 12 all all PDT 37231 1782 13 that that WDT 37231 1782 14 takes take VBZ 37231 1782 15 place place NN 37231 1782 16 anywhere anywhere RB 37231 1782 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1782 18 can can MD 37231 1782 19 know know VB 37231 1782 20 and and CC 37231 1782 21 report report VB 37231 1782 22 with with IN 37231 1782 23 equal equal JJ 37231 1782 24 facility facility NN 37231 1782 25 . . . 37231 1783 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1783 2 swiftness swiftness NN 37231 1783 3 is be VBZ 37231 1783 4 believed believe VBN 37231 1783 5 to to TO 37231 1783 6 be be VB 37231 1783 7 divine divine JJ 37231 1783 8 because because IN 37231 1783 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1783 10 substance substance NN 37231 1783 11 is be VBZ 37231 1783 12 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1783 13 , , , 37231 1783 14 and and CC 37231 1783 15 thus thus RB 37231 1783 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1783 17 seek seek VBP 37231 1783 18 to to TO 37231 1783 19 be be VB 37231 1783 20 considered consider VBN 37231 1783 21 the the DT 37231 1783 22 authors author NNS 37231 1783 23 of of IN 37231 1783 24 effects effect NNS 37231 1783 25 which which WDT 37231 1783 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1783 27 merely merely RB 37231 1783 28 report report VBP 37231 1783 29 , , , 37231 1783 30 as as IN 37231 1783 31 , , , 37231 1783 32 indeed indeed RB 37231 1783 33 , , , 37231 1783 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1783 35 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1783 36 are be VBP 37231 1783 37 of of IN 37231 1783 38 the the DT 37231 1783 39 evil evil NN 37231 1783 40 , , , 37231 1783 41 but but CC 37231 1783 42 never never RB 37231 1783 43 of of IN 37231 1783 44 the the DT 37231 1783 45 good good NN 37231 1783 46 . . . 37231 1784 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1784 2 gather gather VBP 37231 1784 3 intimations intimation NNS 37231 1784 4 of of IN 37231 1784 5 the the DT 37231 1784 6 future future NN 37231 1784 7 from from IN 37231 1784 8 hearing hear VBG 37231 1784 9 the the DT 37231 1784 10 Prophets prophet NNS 37231 1784 11 read read VBD 37231 1784 12 aloud aloud RB 37231 1784 13 , , , 37231 1784 14 and and CC 37231 1784 15 set set VBD 37231 1784 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1784 17 up up RP 37231 1784 18 as as IN 37231 1784 19 rivals rival NNS 37231 1784 20 of of IN 37231 1784 21 the the DT 37231 1784 22 true true JJ 37231 1784 23 God God NNP 37231 1784 24 by by IN 37231 1784 25 stealing steal VBG 37231 1784 26 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1784 27 divinations divination NNS 37231 1784 28 . . . 37231 1785 1 From from IN 37231 1785 2 inhabiting inhabit VBG 37231 1785 3 the the DT 37231 1785 4 air air NN 37231 1785 5 , , , 37231 1785 6 and and CC 37231 1785 7 from from IN 37231 1785 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1785 9 proximity proximity NN 37231 1785 10 to to IN 37231 1785 11 the the DT 37231 1785 12 stars star NNS 37231 1785 13 and and CC 37231 1785 14 commerce commerce NN 37231 1785 15 with with IN 37231 1785 16 the the DT 37231 1785 17 clouds cloud NNS 37231 1785 18 , , , 37231 1785 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1785 20 know know VBP 37231 1785 21 the the DT 37231 1785 22 preparation preparation NN 37231 1785 23 of of IN 37231 1785 24 celestial celestial JJ 37231 1785 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1785 26 , , , 37231 1785 27 and and CC 37231 1785 28 promise promise VB 37231 1785 29 beforehand beforehand IN 37231 1785 30 the the DT 37231 1785 31 rains rain NNS 37231 1785 32 which which WDT 37231 1785 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1785 34 already already RB 37231 1785 35 feel feel VBP 37231 1785 36 coming come VBG 37231 1785 37 . . . 37231 1786 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1786 2 are be VBP 37231 1786 3 very very RB 37231 1786 4 kind kind JJ 37231 1786 5 in in IN 37231 1786 6 reference reference NN 37231 1786 7 to to IN 37231 1786 8 the the DT 37231 1786 9 cure cure NN 37231 1786 10 of of IN 37231 1786 11 diseases disease NNS 37231 1786 12 , , , 37231 1786 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 1786 14 ironically ironically RB 37231 1786 15 says say VBZ 37231 1786 16 , , , 37231 1786 17 for for IN 37231 1786 18 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1786 19 first first RB 37231 1786 20 make make VBP 37231 1786 21 people people NNS 37231 1786 22 ill ill JJ 37231 1786 23 , , , 37231 1786 24 and and CC 37231 1786 25 then then RB 37231 1786 26 , , , 37231 1786 27 by by IN 37231 1786 28 way way NN 37231 1786 29 of of IN 37231 1786 30 performing perform VBG 37231 1786 31 a a DT 37231 1786 32 miracle miracle NN 37231 1786 33 , , , 37231 1786 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1786 35 prescribe prescribe VBP 37231 1786 36 remedies remedy NNS 37231 1786 37 either either CC 37231 1786 38 novel novel NN 37231 1786 39 or or CC 37231 1786 40 contrary contrary JJ 37231 1786 41 to to IN 37231 1786 42 common common JJ 37231 1786 43 experience experience NN 37231 1786 44 , , , 37231 1786 45 and and CC 37231 1786 46 then then RB 37231 1786 47 , , , 37231 1786 48 removing remove VBG 37231 1786 49 the the DT 37231 1786 50 cause cause NN 37231 1786 51 , , , 37231 1786 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1786 53 are be VBP 37231 1786 54 { { -LRB- 37231 1786 55 126 126 CD 37231 1786 56 } } -RRB- 37231 1786 57 believed believe VBD 37231 1786 58 to to TO 37231 1786 59 have have VB 37231 1786 60 healed heal VBN 37231 1786 61 the the DT 37231 1786 62 sick sick JJ 37231 1786 63 . . . 37231 1787 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1787 2 1 1 LS 37231 1787 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1787 4 If if IN 37231 1787 5 any any DT 37231 1787 6 one one CD 37231 1787 7 possessed possess VBN 37231 1787 8 by by IN 37231 1787 9 a a DT 37231 1787 10 demon demon NN 37231 1787 11 be be VB 37231 1787 12 brought bring VBN 37231 1787 13 before before IN 37231 1787 14 a a DT 37231 1787 15 tribunal tribunal NN 37231 1787 16 , , , 37231 1787 17 Tertullian tertullian JJ 37231 1787 18 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 1787 19 that that IN 37231 1787 20 the the DT 37231 1787 21 evil evil JJ 37231 1787 22 spirit spirit NN 37231 1787 23 , , , 37231 1787 24 when when WRB 37231 1787 25 ordered order VBN 37231 1787 26 by by IN 37231 1787 27 a a DT 37231 1787 28 Christian Christian NNP 37231 1787 29 , , , 37231 1787 30 will will MD 37231 1787 31 at at IN 37231 1787 32 once once RB 37231 1787 33 confess confess JJ 37231 1787 34 that that IN 37231 1787 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1787 36 is be VBZ 37231 1787 37 a a DT 37231 1787 38 demon demon NN 37231 1787 39 . . . 37231 1788 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1788 2 2 2 LS 37231 1788 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1788 4 The the DT 37231 1788 5 fallen fall VBN 37231 1788 6 angels angel NNS 37231 1788 7 were be VBD 37231 1788 8 the the DT 37231 1788 9 discoverers discoverer NNS 37231 1788 10 of of IN 37231 1788 11 astrology astrology NN 37231 1788 12 and and CC 37231 1788 13 magic magic NN 37231 1788 14 . . . 37231 1789 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1789 2 3 3 LS 37231 1789 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1789 4 Unclean unclean JJ 37231 1789 5 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1789 6 hover hover VBP 37231 1789 7 over over IN 37231 1789 8 waters water NNS 37231 1789 9 in in IN 37231 1789 10 imitation imitation NN 37231 1789 11 of of IN 37231 1789 12 the the DT 37231 1789 13 brooding brooding NN 37231 1789 14 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1789 15 gestatio gestatio NN 37231 1789 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1789 17 of of IN 37231 1789 18 the the DT 37231 1789 19 Holy Holy NNP 37231 1789 20 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 1789 21 in in IN 37231 1789 22 the the DT 37231 1789 23 beginning beginning NN 37231 1789 24 , , , 37231 1789 25 as as IN 37231 1789 26 , , , 37231 1789 27 for for IN 37231 1789 28 instance instance NN 37231 1789 29 , , , 37231 1789 30 over over IN 37231 1789 31 dark dark JJ 37231 1789 32 fountains fountain NNS 37231 1789 33 and and CC 37231 1789 34 solitary solitary JJ 37231 1789 35 streams stream NNS 37231 1789 36 , , , 37231 1789 37 and and CC 37231 1789 38 cisterns cistern NNS 37231 1789 39 in in IN 37231 1789 40 baths bath NNS 37231 1789 41 and and CC 37231 1789 42 dwelling dwell VBG 37231 1789 43 - - HYPH 37231 1789 44 houses house NNS 37231 1789 45 , , , 37231 1789 46 and and CC 37231 1789 47 similar similar JJ 37231 1789 48 places place NNS 37231 1789 49 , , , 37231 1789 50 which which WDT 37231 1789 51 are be VBP 37231 1789 52 said say VBN 37231 1789 53 to to TO 37231 1789 54 carry carry VB 37231 1789 55 one one CD 37231 1789 56 off off RP 37231 1789 57 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1789 58 rapere rapere NNP 37231 1789 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1789 60 , , , 37231 1789 61 that that DT 37231 1789 62 is be VBZ 37231 1789 63 to to TO 37231 1789 64 say say VB 37231 1789 65 , , , 37231 1789 66 by by IN 37231 1789 67 the the DT 37231 1789 68 force force NN 37231 1789 69 of of IN 37231 1789 70 the the DT 37231 1789 71 evil evil JJ 37231 1789 72 spirit spirit NNP 37231 1789 73 . . . 37231 1790 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1790 2 4 4 LS 37231 1790 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1790 4 The the DT 37231 1790 5 fallen fall VBN 37231 1790 6 angels angel NNS 37231 1790 7 disclosed disclose VBD 37231 1790 8 to to IN 37231 1790 9 the the DT 37231 1790 10 world world NN 37231 1790 11 unknown unknown JJ 37231 1790 12 material material NN 37231 1790 13 substances substance NNS 37231 1790 14 , , , 37231 1790 15 and and CC 37231 1790 16 various various JJ 37231 1790 17 arts art NNS 37231 1790 18 , , , 37231 1790 19 such such JJ 37231 1790 20 as as IN 37231 1790 21 metallurgy metallurgy NN 37231 1790 22 , , , 37231 1790 23 the the DT 37231 1790 24 properties property NNS 37231 1790 25 of of IN 37231 1790 26 herbs herb NNS 37231 1790 27 , , , 37231 1790 28 incantations incantation NNS 37231 1790 29 , , , 37231 1790 30 and and CC 37231 1790 31 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 1790 32 of of IN 37231 1790 33 the the DT 37231 1790 34 stars star NNS 37231 1790 35 ; ; : 37231 1790 36 and and CC 37231 1790 37 to to IN 37231 1790 38 women woman NNS 37231 1790 39 specially specially RB 37231 1790 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1790 41 revealed reveal VBD 37231 1790 42 all all PDT 37231 1790 43 the the DT 37231 1790 44 secrets secret NNS 37231 1790 45 of of IN 37231 1790 46 personal personal JJ 37231 1790 47 adornment adornment NN 37231 1790 48 . . . 37231 1791 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1791 2 5 5 LS 37231 1791 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1791 4 There there EX 37231 1791 5 is be VBZ 37231 1791 6 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1791 7 any any DT 37231 1791 8 man man NN 37231 1791 9 who who WP 37231 1791 10 is be VBZ 37231 1791 11 not not RB 37231 1791 12 attended attend VBN 37231 1791 13 by by IN 37231 1791 14 a a DT 37231 1791 15 demon demon NN 37231 1791 16 ; ; : 37231 1791 17 and and CC 37231 1791 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1791 19 is be VBZ 37231 1791 20 well well RB 37231 1791 21 known know VBN 37231 1791 22 that that IN 37231 1791 23 untimely untimely JJ 37231 1791 24 and and CC 37231 1791 25 violent violent JJ 37231 1791 26 deaths death NNS 37231 1791 27 , , , 37231 1791 28 which which WDT 37231 1791 29 are be VBP 37231 1791 30 attributed attribute VBN 37231 1791 31 to to IN 37231 1791 32 accidents accident NNS 37231 1791 33 , , , 37231 1791 34 are be VBP 37231 1791 35 really really RB 37231 1791 36 caused cause VBN 37231 1791 37 by by IN 37231 1791 38 demons demon NNS 37231 1791 39 . . . 37231 1792 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1792 2 6 6 LS 37231 1792 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1792 4 Those those DT 37231 1792 5 who who WP 37231 1792 6 go go VBP 37231 1792 7 to to IN 37231 1792 8 theatres theatre NNS 37231 1792 9 may may MD 37231 1792 10 become become VB 37231 1792 11 specially specially RB 37231 1792 12 accessible accessible JJ 37231 1792 13 to to IN 37231 1792 14 demons demon NNS 37231 1792 15 . . . 37231 1793 1 There there EX 37231 1793 2 is be VBZ 37231 1793 3 the the DT 37231 1793 4 instance instance NN 37231 1793 5 , , , 37231 1793 6 the the DT 37231 1793 7 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1793 8 is be VBZ 37231 1793 9 witness witness NN 37231 1793 10 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1793 11 domino domino NNP 37231 1793 12 teste teste NNP 37231 1793 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1793 14 , , , 37231 1793 15 of of IN 37231 1793 16 the the DT 37231 1793 17 woman woman NN 37231 1793 18 who who WP 37231 1793 19 went go VBD 37231 1793 20 to to IN 37231 1793 21 a a DT 37231 1793 22 theatre theatre NN 37231 1793 23 and and CC 37231 1793 24 came come VBD 37231 1793 25 back back RB 37231 1793 26 possessed possess VBN 37231 1793 27 by by IN 37231 1793 28 a a DT 37231 1793 29 demon demon NN 37231 1793 30 ; ; : 37231 1793 31 and and CC 37231 1793 32 , , , 37231 1793 33 on on IN 37231 1793 34 being be VBG 37231 1793 35 cast cast VBN 37231 1793 36 out out RP 37231 1793 37 , , , 37231 1793 38 the the DT 37231 1793 39 evil evil JJ 37231 1793 40 spirit spirit NNP 37231 1793 41 replied reply VBD 37231 1793 42 that that IN 37231 1793 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1793 44 had have VBD 37231 1793 45 a a DT 37231 1793 46 right right NN 37231 1793 47 to to TO 37231 1793 48 act act VB 37231 1793 49 as as IN 37231 1793 50 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1793 51 did do VBD 37231 1793 52 , , , 37231 1793 53 having have VBG 37231 1793 54 found find VBN 37231 1793 55 her -PRON- PRP 37231 1793 56 within within IN 37231 1793 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1793 58 limits limit NNS 37231 1793 59 . . . 37231 1794 1 There there EX 37231 1794 2 was be VBD 37231 1794 3 another another DT 37231 1794 4 case case NN 37231 1794 5 , , , 37231 1794 6 also also RB 37231 1794 7 well well RB 37231 1794 8 known known JJ 37231 1794 9 , , , 37231 1794 10 of of IN 37231 1794 11 a a DT 37231 1794 12 woman woman NN 37231 1794 13 who who WP 37231 1794 14 , , , 37231 1794 15 at at IN 37231 1794 16 night night NN 37231 1794 17 , , , 37231 1794 18 after after IN 37231 1794 19 having have VBG 37231 1794 20 been be VBN 37231 1794 21 to to IN 37231 1794 22 a a DT 37231 1794 23 theatre theatre NN 37231 1794 24 , , , 37231 1794 25 had have VBD 37231 1794 26 a a DT 37231 1794 27 vision vision NN 37231 1794 28 of of IN 37231 1794 29 a a DT 37231 1794 30 { { -LRB- 37231 1794 31 127 127 CD 37231 1794 32 } } -RRB- 37231 1794 33 winding winding NN 37231 1794 34 sheet sheet NN 37231 1794 35 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1794 36 linteum linteum NNP 37231 1794 37 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1794 38 , , , 37231 1794 39 and and CC 37231 1794 40 heard hear VBD 37231 1794 41 the the DT 37231 1794 42 name name NN 37231 1794 43 of of IN 37231 1794 44 the the DT 37231 1794 45 tragedian tragedian NNP 37231 1794 46 whom whom WP 37231 1794 47 she -PRON- PRP 37231 1794 48 had have VBD 37231 1794 49 seen see VBN 37231 1794 50 mentioned mention VBN 37231 1794 51 with with IN 37231 1794 52 reprobation reprobation NN 37231 1794 53 and and CC 37231 1794 54 , , , 37231 1794 55 five five CD 37231 1794 56 days day NNS 37231 1794 57 after after RB 37231 1794 58 , , , 37231 1794 59 the the DT 37231 1794 60 woman woman NN 37231 1794 61 was be VBD 37231 1794 62 dead dead JJ 37231 1794 63 . . . 37231 1795 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1795 2 1 1 LS 37231 1795 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1795 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1795 5 attributes attribute VBZ 37231 1795 6 augury augury NN 37231 1795 7 and and CC 37231 1795 8 divination divination NN 37231 1795 9 through through IN 37231 1795 10 animals animal NNS 37231 1795 11 to to IN 37231 1795 12 demons demon NNS 37231 1795 13 . . . 37231 1796 1 In in IN 37231 1796 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1796 3 opinion opinion NN 37231 1796 4 certain certain JJ 37231 1796 5 demons demon NNS 37231 1796 6 , , , 37231 1796 7 offspring offspring NN 37231 1796 8 of of IN 37231 1796 9 the the DT 37231 1796 10 Titans Titans NNPS 37231 1796 11 or or CC 37231 1796 12 Giants Giants NNPS 37231 1796 13 , , , 37231 1796 14 who who WP 37231 1796 15 haunt haunt VBP 37231 1796 16 the the DT 37231 1796 17 grosser gross JJR 37231 1796 18 parts part NNS 37231 1796 19 of of IN 37231 1796 20 bodies body NNS 37231 1796 21 and and CC 37231 1796 22 the the DT 37231 1796 23 unclean unclean JJ 37231 1796 24 places place NNS 37231 1796 25 of of IN 37231 1796 26 the the DT 37231 1796 27 earth earth NN 37231 1796 28 , , , 37231 1796 29 and and CC 37231 1796 30 who who WP 37231 1796 31 , , , 37231 1796 32 from from IN 37231 1796 33 not not RB 37231 1796 34 having have VBG 37231 1796 35 earthly earthly JJ 37231 1796 36 bodies body NNS 37231 1796 37 , , , 37231 1796 38 have have VBP 37231 1796 39 some some DT 37231 1796 40 power power NN 37231 1796 41 of of IN 37231 1796 42 divining divine VBG 37231 1796 43 the the DT 37231 1796 44 future future NN 37231 1796 45 , , , 37231 1796 46 occupy occupy VB 37231 1796 47 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1796 48 with with IN 37231 1796 49 this this DT 37231 1796 50 . . . 37231 1797 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1797 2 secretly secretly RB 37231 1797 3 enter enter VBP 37231 1797 4 the the DT 37231 1797 5 bodies body NNS 37231 1797 6 of of IN 37231 1797 7 the the DT 37231 1797 8 more more RBR 37231 1797 9 brutal brutal JJ 37231 1797 10 and and CC 37231 1797 11 savage savage JJ 37231 1797 12 animals animal NNS 37231 1797 13 , , , 37231 1797 14 and and CC 37231 1797 15 force force VB 37231 1797 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1797 17 to to TO 37231 1797 18 make make VB 37231 1797 19 flights flight NNS 37231 1797 20 or or CC 37231 1797 21 indications indication NNS 37231 1797 22 of of IN 37231 1797 23 divination divination NN 37231 1797 24 to to TO 37231 1797 25 lead lead VB 37231 1797 26 men man NNS 37231 1797 27 away away RB 37231 1797 28 from from IN 37231 1797 29 God God NNP 37231 1797 30 . . . 37231 1798 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1798 2 have have VBP 37231 1798 3 a a DT 37231 1798 4 special special JJ 37231 1798 5 leaning leaning NN 37231 1798 6 to to IN 37231 1798 7 birds bird NNS 37231 1798 8 and and CC 37231 1798 9 serpents serpent NNS 37231 1798 10 , , , 37231 1798 11 and and CC 37231 1798 12 even even RB 37231 1798 13 to to IN 37231 1798 14 foxes fox NNS 37231 1798 15 and and CC 37231 1798 16 wolves wolf NNS 37231 1798 17 , , , 37231 1798 18 because because IN 37231 1798 19 the the DT 37231 1798 20 demons demon NNS 37231 1798 21 act act VBP 37231 1798 22 better well RBR 37231 1798 23 through through IN 37231 1798 24 these these DT 37231 1798 25 in in IN 37231 1798 26 consequence consequence NN 37231 1798 27 of of IN 37231 1798 28 an an DT 37231 1798 29 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1798 30 analogy analogy NN 37231 1798 31 in in IN 37231 1798 32 wickedness wickedness NN 37231 1798 33 between between IN 37231 1798 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1798 35 . . . 37231 1799 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1799 2 2 2 LS 37231 1799 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1799 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1799 5 is be VBZ 37231 1799 6 for for IN 37231 1799 7 this this DT 37231 1799 8 reason reason NN 37231 1799 9 that that IN 37231 1799 10 Moses Moses NNP 37231 1799 11 , , , 37231 1799 12 who who WP 37231 1799 13 had have VBD 37231 1799 14 either either CC 37231 1799 15 been be VBN 37231 1799 16 taught teach VBN 37231 1799 17 by by IN 37231 1799 18 God God NNP 37231 1799 19 what what WP 37231 1799 20 was be VBD 37231 1799 21 similar similar JJ 37231 1799 22 in in IN 37231 1799 23 the the DT 37231 1799 24 nature nature NN 37231 1799 25 of of IN 37231 1799 26 animals animal NNS 37231 1799 27 and and CC 37231 1799 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1799 29 kindred kindred JJ 37231 1799 30 demons demon NNS 37231 1799 31 , , , 37231 1799 32 or or CC 37231 1799 33 had have VBD 37231 1799 34 discovered discover VBN 37231 1799 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1799 36 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1799 37 , , , 37231 1799 38 prohibited prohibit VBD 37231 1799 39 as as IN 37231 1799 40 unclean unclean JJ 37231 1799 41 the the DT 37231 1799 42 particular particular JJ 37231 1799 43 birds bird NNS 37231 1799 44 and and CC 37231 1799 45 animals animal NNS 37231 1799 46 most most RBS 37231 1799 47 used use VBN 37231 1799 48 for for IN 37231 1799 49 divination divination NN 37231 1799 50 . . . 37231 1800 1 Therefore therefore RB 37231 1800 2 each each DT 37231 1800 3 kind kind NN 37231 1800 4 of of IN 37231 1800 5 demon demon NN 37231 1800 6 seems seem VBZ 37231 1800 7 to to TO 37231 1800 8 have have VB 37231 1800 9 an an DT 37231 1800 10 affinity affinity NN 37231 1800 11 with with IN 37231 1800 12 a a DT 37231 1800 13 certain certain JJ 37231 1800 14 kind kind NN 37231 1800 15 of of IN 37231 1800 16 animal animal NN 37231 1800 17 . . . 37231 1801 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1801 2 are be VBP 37231 1801 3 so so RB 37231 1801 4 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1801 5 that that IN 37231 1801 6 demons demon NNS 37231 1801 7 even even RB 37231 1801 8 assume assume VBP 37231 1801 9 the the DT 37231 1801 10 bodies body NNS 37231 1801 11 of of IN 37231 1801 12 weasels weasel NNS 37231 1801 13 to to TO 37231 1801 14 foretell foretell VB 37231 1801 15 the the DT 37231 1801 16 future future NN 37231 1801 17 . . . 37231 1802 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1802 2 3 3 LS 37231 1802 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1802 4 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1802 5 feed feed VBP 37231 1802 6 on on IN 37231 1802 7 the the DT 37231 1802 8 blood blood NN 37231 1802 9 and and CC 37231 1802 10 odour odour NN 37231 1802 11 of of IN 37231 1802 12 the the DT 37231 1802 13 victims victim NNS 37231 1802 14 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 37231 1802 15 in in IN 37231 1802 16 idol idol NN 37231 1802 17 temples temple NNS 37231 1802 18 . . . 37231 1803 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1803 2 4 4 LS 37231 1803 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1803 4 The the DT 37231 1803 5 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1803 6 of of IN 37231 1803 7 the the DT 37231 1803 8 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1803 9 dead dead JJ 37231 1803 10 wander wander NN 37231 1803 11 about about IN 37231 1803 12 sepulchres sepulchre NNS 37231 1803 13 and and CC 37231 1803 14 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1803 15 for for IN 37231 1803 16 ages age NNS 37231 1803 17 haunt haunt VBP 37231 1803 18 particular particular JJ 37231 1803 19 houses house NNS 37231 1803 20 , , , 37231 1803 21 and and CC 37231 1803 22 other other JJ 37231 1803 23 places place NNS 37231 1803 24 . . . 37231 1804 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1804 2 5 5 LS 37231 1804 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1804 4 The the DT 37231 1804 5 prayers prayer NNS 37231 1804 6 of of IN 37231 1804 7 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 1804 8 drive drive VBP 37231 1804 9 demons demon NNS 37231 1804 10 out out IN 37231 1804 11 of of IN 37231 1804 12 men man NNS 37231 1804 13 , , , 37231 1804 14 and and CC 37231 1804 15 from from IN 37231 1804 16 places place NNS 37231 1804 17 where where WRB 37231 1804 18 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1804 19 have have VBP 37231 1804 20 { { -LRB- 37231 1804 21 128 128 CD 37231 1804 22 } } -RRB- 37231 1804 23 taken take VBN 37231 1804 24 up up RP 37231 1804 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1804 26 abode abode NN 37231 1804 27 , , , 37231 1804 28 and and CC 37231 1804 29 even even RB 37231 1804 30 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1804 31 from from IN 37231 1804 32 the the DT 37231 1804 33 bodies body NNS 37231 1804 34 of of IN 37231 1804 35 animals animal NNS 37231 1804 36 , , , 37231 1804 37 which which WDT 37231 1804 38 are be VBP 37231 1804 39 frequently frequently RB 37231 1804 40 injured injure VBN 37231 1804 41 by by IN 37231 1804 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1804 43 . . . 37231 1805 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1805 2 1 1 LS 37231 1805 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1805 4 In in IN 37231 1805 5 reply reply NN 37231 1805 6 to to IN 37231 1805 7 a a DT 37231 1805 8 statement statement NN 37231 1805 9 of of IN 37231 1805 10 Celsus Celsus NNP 37231 1805 11 that that IN 37231 1805 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1805 13 can can MD 37231 1805 14 not not RB 37231 1805 15 eat eat VB 37231 1805 16 bread bread NN 37231 1805 17 or or CC 37231 1805 18 fruit fruit NN 37231 1805 19 , , , 37231 1805 20 or or CC 37231 1805 21 drink drink VB 37231 1805 22 wine wine NN 37231 1805 23 or or CC 37231 1805 24 even even RB 37231 1805 25 water water NN 37231 1805 26 without without IN 37231 1805 27 eating eat VBG 37231 1805 28 and and CC 37231 1805 29 drinking drink VBG 37231 1805 30 with with IN 37231 1805 31 demons demon NNS 37231 1805 32 , , , 37231 1805 33 and and CC 37231 1805 34 that that IN 37231 1805 35 the the DT 37231 1805 36 very very JJ 37231 1805 37 air air NN 37231 1805 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1805 39 breathe breathe VBP 37231 1805 40 is be VBZ 37231 1805 41 received receive VBN 37231 1805 42 from from IN 37231 1805 43 demons demon NNS 37231 1805 44 , , , 37231 1805 45 and and CC 37231 1805 46 that that IN 37231 1805 47 , , , 37231 1805 48 consequently consequently RB 37231 1805 49 , , , 37231 1805 50 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1805 51 can can MD 37231 1805 52 not not RB 37231 1805 53 inhale inhale VB 37231 1805 54 without without IN 37231 1805 55 receiving receive VBG 37231 1805 56 air air NN 37231 1805 57 from from IN 37231 1805 58 the the DT 37231 1805 59 demons demon NNS 37231 1805 60 who who WP 37231 1805 61 are be VBP 37231 1805 62 set set VBN 37231 1805 63 over over IN 37231 1805 64 the the DT 37231 1805 65 air,(2 air,(2 NNP 37231 1805 66 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1805 67 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1805 68 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 1805 69 , , , 37231 1805 70 on on IN 37231 1805 71 the the DT 37231 1805 72 contrary contrary NN 37231 1805 73 , , , 37231 1805 74 that that IN 37231 1805 75 the the DT 37231 1805 76 angels angel NNS 37231 1805 77 of of IN 37231 1805 78 God God NNP 37231 1805 79 , , , 37231 1805 80 and and CC 37231 1805 81 not not RB 37231 1805 82 demons demon NNS 37231 1805 83 , , , 37231 1805 84 have have VBP 37231 1805 85 the the DT 37231 1805 86 superintendence superintendence NN 37231 1805 87 of of IN 37231 1805 88 such such JJ 37231 1805 89 natural natural JJ 37231 1805 90 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1805 91 , , , 37231 1805 92 and and CC 37231 1805 93 have have VBP 37231 1805 94 been be VBN 37231 1805 95 appointed appoint VBN 37231 1805 96 to to TO 37231 1805 97 communicate communicate VB 37231 1805 98 all all PDT 37231 1805 99 these these DT 37231 1805 100 blessings blessing NNS 37231 1805 101 . . . 37231 1806 1 Not not RB 37231 1806 2 demons demon NNS 37231 1806 3 , , , 37231 1806 4 but but CC 37231 1806 5 angels angel NNS 37231 1806 6 , , , 37231 1806 7 have have VBP 37231 1806 8 been be VBN 37231 1806 9 set set VBN 37231 1806 10 over over IN 37231 1806 11 the the DT 37231 1806 12 fruits fruit NNS 37231 1806 13 of of IN 37231 1806 14 the the DT 37231 1806 15 earth earth NN 37231 1806 16 , , , 37231 1806 17 and and CC 37231 1806 18 over over IN 37231 1806 19 the the DT 37231 1806 20 birth birth NN 37231 1806 21 of of IN 37231 1806 22 animals animal NNS 37231 1806 23 , , , 37231 1806 24 and and CC 37231 1806 25 over over IN 37231 1806 26 all all DT 37231 1806 27 things thing NNS 37231 1806 28 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1806 29 for for IN 37231 1806 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1806 31 race race NN 37231 1806 32 . . . 37231 1807 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1807 2 3 3 LS 37231 1807 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1807 4 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1807 5 forbids forbid NNS 37231 1807 6 the the DT 37231 1807 7 eating eating NN 37231 1807 8 of of IN 37231 1807 9 things thing NNS 37231 1807 10 strangled strangle VBN 37231 1807 11 because because IN 37231 1807 12 the the DT 37231 1807 13 blood blood NN 37231 1807 14 is be VBZ 37231 1807 15 still still RB 37231 1807 16 in in IN 37231 1807 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1807 18 , , , 37231 1807 19 and and CC 37231 1807 20 blood blood NN 37231 1807 21 , , , 37231 1807 22 and and CC 37231 1807 23 more more RBR 37231 1807 24 especially especially RB 37231 1807 25 the the DT 37231 1807 26 fumes fume NNS 37231 1807 27 of of IN 37231 1807 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1807 29 , , , 37231 1807 30 is be VBZ 37231 1807 31 said say VBN 37231 1807 32 to to TO 37231 1807 33 be be VB 37231 1807 34 the the DT 37231 1807 35 food food NN 37231 1807 36 of of IN 37231 1807 37 demons demon NNS 37231 1807 38 . . . 37231 1808 1 If if IN 37231 1808 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1808 3 ate eat VBD 37231 1808 4 strangled strangle VBN 37231 1808 5 animals animal NNS 37231 1808 6 , , , 37231 1808 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1808 8 might may MD 37231 1808 9 have have VB 37231 1808 10 demons demon NNS 37231 1808 11 feeding feed VBG 37231 1808 12 with with IN 37231 1808 13 us,(4 us,(4 NN 37231 1808 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1808 15 but but CC 37231 1808 16 in in IN 37231 1808 17 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1808 18 's 's POS 37231 1808 19 opinion opinion NN 37231 1808 20 a a DT 37231 1808 21 man man NN 37231 1808 22 only only RB 37231 1808 23 eats eat VBZ 37231 1808 24 and and CC 37231 1808 25 drinks drink VBZ 37231 1808 26 with with IN 37231 1808 27 demons demon NNS 37231 1808 28 when when WRB 37231 1808 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1808 30 eats eat VBZ 37231 1808 31 the the DT 37231 1808 32 flesh flesh NN 37231 1808 33 of of IN 37231 1808 34 idol idol NN 37231 1808 35 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 37231 1808 36 , , , 37231 1808 37 and and CC 37231 1808 38 drinks drink VBZ 37231 1808 39 the the DT 37231 1808 40 wine wine NN 37231 1808 41 poured pour VBD 37231 1808 42 out out RP 37231 1808 43 in in IN 37231 1808 44 honour honour NN 37231 1808 45 of of IN 37231 1808 46 demons demon NNS 37231 1808 47 . . . 37231 1809 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1809 2 6 6 LS 37231 1809 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1809 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 1809 5 states state VBZ 37231 1809 6 the the DT 37231 1809 7 common common JJ 37231 1809 8 belief belief NN 37231 1809 9 that that IN 37231 1809 10 the the DT 37231 1809 11 air air NN 37231 1809 12 is be VBZ 37231 1809 13 filled fill VBN 37231 1809 14 with with IN 37231 1809 15 demons demon NNS 37231 1809 16 . . . 37231 1810 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1810 2 6 6 LS 37231 1810 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1810 4 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 37231 1810 5 says say VBZ 37231 1810 6 that that IN 37231 1810 7 angels angel NNS 37231 1810 8 are be VBP 37231 1810 9 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 1810 10 in in IN 37231 1810 11 the the DT 37231 1810 12 atmosphere atmosphere NN 37231 1810 13 . . . 37231 1811 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1811 2 7 7 LS 37231 1811 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1811 4 Not not RB 37231 1811 5 content content JJ 37231 1811 6 , , , 37231 1811 7 however however RB 37231 1811 8 , , , 37231 1811 9 with with IN 37231 1811 10 peopling people VBG 37231 1811 11 earth earth NN 37231 1811 12 and and CC 37231 1811 13 air air NN 37231 1811 14 with with IN 37231 1811 15 angels angel NNS 37231 1811 16 and and CC 37231 1811 17 demons demon NNS 37231 1811 18 , , , 37231 1811 19 the the DT 37231 1811 20 Fathers father NNS 37231 1811 21 also also RB 37231 1811 22 shared share VBD 37231 1811 23 the the DT 37231 1811 24 opinion opinion NN 37231 1811 25 common common JJ 37231 1811 26 to to IN 37231 1811 27 Jews(8 Jews(8 NNP 37231 1811 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1811 29 and and CC 37231 1811 30 heathen heathen NNP 37231 1811 31 philosophers philosopher NNS 37231 1811 32 , , , 37231 1811 33 that that IN 37231 1811 34 the the DT 37231 1811 35 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 1811 36 bodies body NNS 37231 1811 37 were be VBD 37231 1811 38 animated animate VBN 37231 1811 39 beings being NNS 37231 1811 40 . . . 37231 1812 1 After after IN 37231 1812 2 fully fully RB 37231 1812 3 discussing discuss VBG 37231 1812 4 the the DT 37231 1812 5 question question NN 37231 1812 6 , , , 37231 1812 7 with with IN 37231 1812 8 much much JJ 37231 1812 9 reference reference NN 37231 1812 10 to to IN 37231 1812 11 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1812 12 , , , 37231 1812 13 { { -LRB- 37231 1812 14 20 20 CD 37231 1812 15 } } -RRB- 37231 1812 16 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1812 17 determines determine VBZ 37231 1812 18 that that IN 37231 1812 19 sun sun NN 37231 1812 20 , , , 37231 1812 21 moon moon NN 37231 1812 22 , , , 37231 1812 23 and and CC 37231 1812 24 stars star NNS 37231 1812 25 are be VBP 37231 1812 26 living live VBG 37231 1812 27 and and CC 37231 1812 28 rational rational JJ 37231 1812 29 beings being NNS 37231 1812 30 , , , 37231 1812 31 illuminated illuminate VBN 37231 1812 32 with with IN 37231 1812 33 the the DT 37231 1812 34 light light NN 37231 1812 35 of of IN 37231 1812 36 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1812 37 by by IN 37231 1812 38 the the DT 37231 1812 39 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1812 40 which which WDT 37231 1812 41 is be VBZ 37231 1812 42 the the DT 37231 1812 43 reflection reflection NN 37231 1812 44 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1812 45 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1812 46 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1812 47 of of IN 37231 1812 48 eternal eternal JJ 37231 1812 49 light light NN 37231 1812 50 . . . 37231 1813 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1813 2 have have VBP 37231 1813 3 free free JJ 37231 1813 4 will will NN 37231 1813 5 , , , 37231 1813 6 and and CC 37231 1813 7 as as IN 37231 1813 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1813 9 would would MD 37231 1813 10 appear appear VB 37231 1813 11 from from IN 37231 1813 12 a a DT 37231 1813 13 passage passage NN 37231 1813 14 in in IN 37231 1813 15 Job Job NNP 37231 1813 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1813 17 xxv xxv NNP 37231 1813 18 . . . 37231 1814 1 5 5 LS 37231 1814 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1814 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1814 4 are be VBP 37231 1814 5 not not RB 37231 1814 6 only only RB 37231 1814 7 liable liable JJ 37231 1814 8 to to TO 37231 1814 9 sin sin VB 37231 1814 10 , , , 37231 1814 11 but but CC 37231 1814 12 actually actually RB 37231 1814 13 not not RB 37231 1814 14 pure pure JJ 37231 1814 15 from from IN 37231 1814 16 the the DT 37231 1814 17 uncleanness uncleanness NN 37231 1814 18 of of IN 37231 1814 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1814 20 . . . 37231 1815 1 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1815 2 is be VBZ 37231 1815 3 careful careful JJ 37231 1815 4 to to TO 37231 1815 5 explain explain VB 37231 1815 6 that that IN 37231 1815 7 this this DT 37231 1815 8 has have VBZ 37231 1815 9 not not RB 37231 1815 10 reference reference NN 37231 1815 11 merely merely RB 37231 1815 12 to to IN 37231 1815 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1815 14 physical physical JJ 37231 1815 15 part part NN 37231 1815 16 , , , 37231 1815 17 but but CC 37231 1815 18 to to IN 37231 1815 19 the the DT 37231 1815 20 spiritual spiritual NN 37231 1815 21 ; ; : 37231 1815 22 and and CC 37231 1815 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1815 24 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1815 25 to to TO 37231 1815 26 discuss discuss VB 37231 1815 27 whether whether IN 37231 1815 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1815 29 souls soul NNS 37231 1815 30 came come VBD 37231 1815 31 into into IN 37231 1815 32 existence existence NN 37231 1815 33 at at IN 37231 1815 34 the the DT 37231 1815 35 same same JJ 37231 1815 36 time time NN 37231 1815 37 with with IN 37231 1815 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1815 39 bodies body NNS 37231 1815 40 or or CC 37231 1815 41 existed exist VBD 37231 1815 42 previously previously RB 37231 1815 43 , , , 37231 1815 44 and and CC 37231 1815 45 whether whether IN 37231 1815 46 , , , 37231 1815 47 at at IN 37231 1815 48 the the DT 37231 1815 49 end end NN 37231 1815 50 of of IN 37231 1815 51 the the DT 37231 1815 52 world world NN 37231 1815 53 , , , 37231 1815 54 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1815 55 will will MD 37231 1815 56 be be VB 37231 1815 57 released release VBN 37231 1815 58 from from IN 37231 1815 59 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1815 60 bodies body NNS 37231 1815 61 or or CC 37231 1815 62 will will MD 37231 1815 63 cease cease VB 37231 1815 64 from from IN 37231 1815 65 giving give VBG 37231 1815 66 light light NN 37231 1815 67 to to IN 37231 1815 68 the the DT 37231 1815 69 world world NN 37231 1815 70 . . . 37231 1816 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1816 2 argues argue VBZ 37231 1816 3 that that IN 37231 1816 4 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1816 5 are be VBP 37231 1816 6 rational rational JJ 37231 1816 7 beings being NNS 37231 1816 8 because because IN 37231 1816 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1816 10 motions motion NNS 37231 1816 11 could could MD 37231 1816 12 not not RB 37231 1816 13 take take VB 37231 1816 14 place place NN 37231 1816 15 without without IN 37231 1816 16 a a DT 37231 1816 17 soul soul NN 37231 1816 18 . . . 37231 1817 1 " " `` 37231 1817 2 As as IN 37231 1817 3 the the DT 37231 1817 4 stars star NNS 37231 1817 5 move move VBP 37231 1817 6 with with IN 37231 1817 7 so so RB 37231 1817 8 much much JJ 37231 1817 9 order order NN 37231 1817 10 and and CC 37231 1817 11 method method NN 37231 1817 12 , , , 37231 1817 13 " " '' 37231 1817 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1817 15 says say VBZ 37231 1817 16 , , , 37231 1817 17 " " `` 37231 1817 18 that that IN 37231 1817 19 under under IN 37231 1817 20 no no DT 37231 1817 21 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 1817 22 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1817 23 does do VBZ 37231 1817 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1817 25 course course NN 37231 1817 26 seem seem VB 37231 1817 27 to to TO 37231 1817 28 be be VB 37231 1817 29 disturbed disturb VBN 37231 1817 30 , , , 37231 1817 31 is be VBZ 37231 1817 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1817 33 not not RB 37231 1817 34 the the DT 37231 1817 35 extreme extreme NN 37231 1817 36 of of IN 37231 1817 37 absurdity absurdity NN 37231 1817 38 to to TO 37231 1817 39 suppose suppose VB 37231 1817 40 that that DT 37231 1817 41 so so RB 37231 1817 42 much much JJ 37231 1817 43 order order NN 37231 1817 44 , , , 37231 1817 45 so so RB 37231 1817 46 much much JJ 37231 1817 47 observance observance NN 37231 1817 48 of of IN 37231 1817 49 discipline discipline NN 37231 1817 50 and and CC 37231 1817 51 method method NN 37231 1817 52 could could MD 37231 1817 53 be be VB 37231 1817 54 demanded demand VBN 37231 1817 55 from from IN 37231 1817 56 or or CC 37231 1817 57 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 1817 58 by by IN 37231 1817 59 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1817 60 beings being NNS 37231 1817 61 ? ? . 37231 1818 1 " " `` 37231 1818 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1818 3 1 1 LS 37231 1818 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1818 5 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1818 6 possess possess VBP 37231 1818 7 life life NN 37231 1818 8 and and CC 37231 1818 9 reason reason NN 37231 1818 10 , , , 37231 1818 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1818 12 decides decide VBZ 37231 1818 13 , , , 37231 1818 14 and and CC 37231 1818 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1818 16 proves prove VBZ 37231 1818 17 from from IN 37231 1818 18 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1818 19 that that IN 37231 1818 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1818 21 souls soul NNS 37231 1818 22 were be VBD 37231 1818 23 given give VBN 37231 1818 24 to to IN 37231 1818 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1818 26 not not RB 37231 1818 27 at at IN 37231 1818 28 the the DT 37231 1818 29 creation creation NN 37231 1818 30 of of IN 37231 1818 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1818 32 bodily bodily JJ 37231 1818 33 substance substance NN 37231 1818 34 , , , 37231 1818 35 but but CC 37231 1818 36 like like IN 37231 1818 37 those those DT 37231 1818 38 of of IN 37231 1818 39 men man NNS 37231 1818 40 implanted implant VBD 37231 1818 41 strictly strictly RB 37231 1818 42 from from IN 37231 1818 43 without without IN 37231 1818 44 , , , 37231 1818 45 after after IN 37231 1818 46 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1818 47 were be VBD 37231 1818 48 made make VBN 37231 1818 49 . . . 37231 1819 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1819 2 2 2 LS 37231 1819 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1819 4 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1819 5 are be VBP 37231 1819 6 " " `` 37231 1819 7 subject subject JJ 37231 1819 8 to to IN 37231 1819 9 vanity vanity NN 37231 1819 10 " " '' 37231 1819 11 with with IN 37231 1819 12 the the DT 37231 1819 13 rest rest NN 37231 1819 14 of of IN 37231 1819 15 the the DT 37231 1819 16 creatures creature NNS 37231 1819 17 , , , 37231 1819 18 and and CC 37231 1819 19 " " `` 37231 1819 20 wait wait VB 37231 1819 21 for for IN 37231 1819 22 the the DT 37231 1819 23 manifestation manifestation NN 37231 1819 24 of of IN 37231 1819 25 the the DT 37231 1819 26 sons son NNS 37231 1819 27 of of IN 37231 1819 28 God God NNP 37231 1819 29 . . . 37231 1820 1 " " `` 37231 1820 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1820 3 3 3 LS 37231 1820 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1820 5 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1820 6 is be VBZ 37231 1820 7 persuaded persuade VBN 37231 1820 8 { { -LRB- 37231 1820 9 130 130 CD 37231 1820 10 } } -RRB- 37231 1820 11 that that WDT 37231 1820 12 sun sun NN 37231 1820 13 , , , 37231 1820 14 moon moon NN 37231 1820 15 , , , 37231 1820 16 and and CC 37231 1820 17 stars star NNS 37231 1820 18 pray pray VBP 37231 1820 19 to to IN 37231 1820 20 the the DT 37231 1820 21 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 1820 22 Being be VBG 37231 1820 23 through through IN 37231 1820 24 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1820 25 only only JJ 37231 1820 26 begotten begotten JJ 37231 1820 27 Son Son NNP 37231 1820 28 . . . 37231 1821 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1821 2 1 1 LS 37231 1821 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1821 4 To to TO 37231 1821 5 return return VB 37231 1821 6 to to IN 37231 1821 7 angels angel NNS 37231 1821 8 , , , 37231 1821 9 however however RB 37231 1821 10 , , , 37231 1821 11 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1821 12 states state VBZ 37231 1821 13 that that IN 37231 1821 14 the the DT 37231 1821 15 angels angel NNS 37231 1821 16 are be VBP 37231 1821 17 not not RB 37231 1821 18 only only RB 37231 1821 19 of of IN 37231 1821 20 various various JJ 37231 1821 21 orders order NNS 37231 1821 22 of of IN 37231 1821 23 rank rank NN 37231 1821 24 , , , 37231 1821 25 but but CC 37231 1821 26 have have VBP 37231 1821 27 apportioned apportion VBN 37231 1821 28 to to IN 37231 1821 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1821 30 specific specific JJ 37231 1821 31 offices office NNS 37231 1821 32 and and CC 37231 1821 33 duties duty NNS 37231 1821 34 . . . 37231 1822 1 To to IN 37231 1822 2 Raphael Raphael NNP 37231 1822 3 , , , 37231 1822 4 for for IN 37231 1822 5 instance instance NN 37231 1822 6 , , , 37231 1822 7 is be VBZ 37231 1822 8 assigned assign VBN 37231 1822 9 the the DT 37231 1822 10 task task NN 37231 1822 11 of of IN 37231 1822 12 curing curing NN 37231 1822 13 and and CC 37231 1822 14 healing healing NN 37231 1822 15 ; ; : 37231 1822 16 to to IN 37231 1822 17 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 1822 18 the the DT 37231 1822 19 management management NN 37231 1822 20 of of IN 37231 1822 21 wars war NNS 37231 1822 22 ; ; : 37231 1822 23 to to IN 37231 1822 24 Michael Michael NNP 37231 1822 25 the the DT 37231 1822 26 duty duty NN 37231 1822 27 of of IN 37231 1822 28 receiving receive VBG 37231 1822 29 the the DT 37231 1822 30 prayers prayer NNS 37231 1822 31 and and CC 37231 1822 32 the the DT 37231 1822 33 supplications supplication NNS 37231 1822 34 of of IN 37231 1822 35 men man NNS 37231 1822 36 . . . 37231 1823 1 Angels angel NNS 37231 1823 2 are be VBP 37231 1823 3 set set VBN 37231 1823 4 over over IN 37231 1823 5 the the DT 37231 1823 6 different different JJ 37231 1823 7 churches church NNS 37231 1823 8 , , , 37231 1823 9 and and CC 37231 1823 10 have have VB 37231 1823 11 charge charge NN 37231 1823 12 even even RB 37231 1823 13 of of IN 37231 1823 14 the the DT 37231 1823 15 least least JJS 37231 1823 16 of of IN 37231 1823 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1823 18 members member NNS 37231 1823 19 . . . 37231 1824 1 These these DT 37231 1824 2 offices office NNS 37231 1824 3 were be VBD 37231 1824 4 assigned assign VBN 37231 1824 5 to to IN 37231 1824 6 the the DT 37231 1824 7 angels angel NNS 37231 1824 8 by by IN 37231 1824 9 God God NNP 37231 1824 10 agreeably agreeably RB 37231 1824 11 to to IN 37231 1824 12 the the DT 37231 1824 13 qualities quality NNS 37231 1824 14 displayed display VBN 37231 1824 15 by by IN 37231 1824 16 each each DT 37231 1824 17 . . . 37231 1825 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1825 2 2 2 LS 37231 1825 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1825 4 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 1825 5 , , , 37231 1825 6 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1825 7 explains explain VBZ 37231 1825 8 that that IN 37231 1825 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1825 10 is be VBZ 37231 1825 11 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1825 12 for for IN 37231 1825 13 this this DT 37231 1825 14 world world NN 37231 1825 15 that that IN 37231 1825 16 there there EX 37231 1825 17 should should MD 37231 1825 18 be be VB 37231 1825 19 angels angel NNS 37231 1825 20 set set VBN 37231 1825 21 over over IN 37231 1825 22 beasts beast NNS 37231 1825 23 and and CC 37231 1825 24 over over IN 37231 1825 25 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37231 1825 26 operations operation NNS 37231 1825 27 , , , 37231 1825 28 and and CC 37231 1825 29 also also RB 37231 1825 30 angels angel NNS 37231 1825 31 presiding preside VBG 37231 1825 32 over over IN 37231 1825 33 the the DT 37231 1825 34 birth birth NN 37231 1825 35 of of IN 37231 1825 36 animals animal NNS 37231 1825 37 , , , 37231 1825 38 and and CC 37231 1825 39 over over IN 37231 1825 40 the the DT 37231 1825 41 propagation propagation NN 37231 1825 42 and and CC 37231 1825 43 growth growth NN 37231 1825 44 of of IN 37231 1825 45 shrubs shrub NNS 37231 1825 46 , , , 37231 1825 47 and and CC 37231 1825 48 , , , 37231 1825 49 again again RB 37231 1825 50 , , , 37231 1825 51 angels angel NNS 37231 1825 52 over over IN 37231 1825 53 holy holy JJ 37231 1825 54 works work NNS 37231 1825 55 , , , 37231 1825 56 who who WP 37231 1825 57 eternally eternally RB 37231 1825 58 teach teach VBP 37231 1825 59 men man NNS 37231 1825 60 the the DT 37231 1825 61 perception perception NN 37231 1825 62 of of IN 37231 1825 63 the the DT 37231 1825 64 hidden hidden JJ 37231 1825 65 ways way NNS 37231 1825 66 of of IN 37231 1825 67 God God NNP 37231 1825 68 , , , 37231 1825 69 and and CC 37231 1825 70 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1825 71 of of IN 37231 1825 72 divine divine JJ 37231 1825 73 things thing NNS 37231 1825 74 ; ; : 37231 1825 75 and and CC 37231 1825 76 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1825 77 warns warn VBZ 37231 1825 78 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1825 79 not not RB 37231 1825 80 to to TO 37231 1825 81 bring bring VB 37231 1825 82 upon upon IN 37231 1825 83 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1825 84 those those DT 37231 1825 85 angels angel NNS 37231 1825 86 who who WP 37231 1825 87 are be VBP 37231 1825 88 set set VBN 37231 1825 89 over over IN 37231 1825 90 beasts beast NNS 37231 1825 91 , , , 37231 1825 92 by by IN 37231 1825 93 leading lead VBG 37231 1825 94 an an DT 37231 1825 95 animal animal NN 37231 1825 96 life life NN 37231 1825 97 , , , 37231 1825 98 nor nor CC 37231 1825 99 those those DT 37231 1825 100 which which WDT 37231 1825 101 preside preside VBP 37231 1825 102 over over IN 37231 1825 103 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37231 1825 104 works work NNS 37231 1825 105 , , , 37231 1825 106 by by IN 37231 1825 107 taking take VBG 37231 1825 108 delight delight NN 37231 1825 109 in in IN 37231 1825 110 fleshly fleshly RB 37231 1825 111 and and CC 37231 1825 112 mundane mundane JJ 37231 1825 113 things thing NNS 37231 1825 114 , , , 37231 1825 115 but but CC 37231 1825 116 rather rather RB 37231 1825 117 to to TO 37231 1825 118 study study VB 37231 1825 119 how how WRB 37231 1825 120 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1825 121 may may MD 37231 1825 122 approximate approximate VB 37231 1825 123 to to IN 37231 1825 124 the the DT 37231 1825 125 companionship companionship NN 37231 1825 126 of of IN 37231 1825 127 the the DT 37231 1825 128 Archangel Archangel NNP 37231 1825 129 Michael Michael NNP 37231 1825 130 , , , 37231 1825 131 to to IN 37231 1825 132 whose whose WP$ 37231 1825 133 duty duty NN 37231 1825 134 of of IN 37231 1825 135 presenting present VBG 37231 1825 136 the the DT 37231 1825 137 prayers prayer NNS 37231 1825 138 of of IN 37231 1825 139 the the DT 37231 1825 140 saints saint NNS 37231 1825 141 to to IN 37231 1825 142 God God NNP 37231 1825 143 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1825 144 here here RB 37231 1825 145 adds add VBZ 37231 1825 146 the the DT 37231 1825 147 office office NN 37231 1825 148 of of IN 37231 1825 149 presiding preside VBG 37231 1825 150 over over IN 37231 1825 151 medicine medicine NN 37231 1825 152 . . . 37231 1826 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1826 2 3 3 LS 37231 1826 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1826 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1826 5 is be VBZ 37231 1826 6 through through IN 37231 1826 7 the the DT 37231 1826 8 ministry ministry NNP 37231 1826 9 of of IN 37231 1826 10 angels angels NNPS 37231 1826 11 that that WDT 37231 1826 12 the the DT 37231 1826 13 water water NN 37231 1826 14 - - HYPH 37231 1826 15 springs spring NNS 37231 1826 16 in in IN 37231 1826 17 fountains fountain NNS 37231 1826 18 and and CC 37231 1826 19 running run VBG 37231 1826 20 streams stream NNS 37231 1826 21 refresh refresh VBP 37231 1826 22 the the DT 37231 1826 23 earth earth NN 37231 1826 24 , , , 37231 1826 25 and and CC 37231 1826 26 that that IN 37231 1826 27 the the DT 37231 1826 28 air air NN 37231 1826 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1826 30 breathe breathe VBP 37231 1826 31 is be VBZ 37231 1826 32 { { -LRB- 37231 1826 33 131 131 CD 37231 1826 34 } } -RRB- 37231 1826 35 kept keep VBN 37231 1826 36 pure pure JJ 37231 1826 37 . . . 37231 1827 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1827 2 1 1 LS 37231 1827 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1827 4 In in IN 37231 1827 5 the the DT 37231 1827 6 " " `` 37231 1827 7 Pastor Pastor NNP 37231 1827 8 " " '' 37231 1827 9 of of IN 37231 1827 10 Hermas Hermas NNP 37231 1827 11 , , , 37231 1827 12 a a DT 37231 1827 13 work work NN 37231 1827 14 quoted quote VBN 37231 1827 15 by by IN 37231 1827 16 the the DT 37231 1827 17 Fathers father NNS 37231 1827 18 as as IN 37231 1827 19 inspired inspire VBN 37231 1827 20 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 1827 21 , , , 37231 1827 22 which which WDT 37231 1827 23 was be VBD 37231 1827 24 publicly publicly RB 37231 1827 25 read read VBN 37231 1827 26 in in IN 37231 1827 27 the the DT 37231 1827 28 churches church NNS 37231 1827 29 , , , 37231 1827 30 which which WDT 37231 1827 31 almost almost RB 37231 1827 32 secured secure VBD 37231 1827 33 a a DT 37231 1827 34 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1827 35 place place NN 37231 1827 36 in in IN 37231 1827 37 the the DT 37231 1827 38 New New NNP 37231 1827 39 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1827 40 canon canon NN 37231 1827 41 , , , 37231 1827 42 and and CC 37231 1827 43 which which WDT 37231 1827 44 appears appear VBZ 37231 1827 45 after after IN 37231 1827 46 the the DT 37231 1827 47 canonical canonical JJ 37231 1827 48 books book NNS 37231 1827 49 in in IN 37231 1827 50 the the DT 37231 1827 51 Codex Codex NNP 37231 1827 52 Sinaiticus Sinaiticus NNP 37231 1827 53 , , , 37231 1827 54 the the DT 37231 1827 55 oldest old JJS 37231 1827 56 extant extant JJ 37231 1827 57 MS MS NNP 37231 1827 58 . . . 37231 1827 59 of of IN 37231 1827 60 the the DT 37231 1827 61 New New NNP 37231 1827 62 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1827 63 , , , 37231 1827 64 mention mention NN 37231 1827 65 is be VBZ 37231 1827 66 made make VBN 37231 1827 67 of of IN 37231 1827 68 an an DT 37231 1827 69 angel angel NN 37231 1827 70 who who WP 37231 1827 71 has have VBZ 37231 1827 72 rule rule NN 37231 1827 73 over over IN 37231 1827 74 beasts beast NNS 37231 1827 75 , , , 37231 1827 76 and and CC 37231 1827 77 whose whose WP$ 37231 1827 78 name name NN 37231 1827 79 is be VBZ 37231 1827 80 Hegrin Hegrin NNP 37231 1827 81 . . . 37231 1828 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1828 2 2 2 LS 37231 1828 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1828 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 1828 5 also also RB 37231 1828 6 quotes quote VBZ 37231 1828 7 an an DT 37231 1828 8 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 1828 9 work work NN 37231 1828 10 in in IN 37231 1828 11 which which WDT 37231 1828 12 an an DT 37231 1828 13 angel angel NN 37231 1828 14 of of IN 37231 1828 15 similar similar JJ 37231 1828 16 name name NN 37231 1828 17 is be VBZ 37231 1828 18 said say VBN 37231 1828 19 to to TO 37231 1828 20 be be VB 37231 1828 21 set set VBN 37231 1828 22 over over IN 37231 1828 23 reptiles reptile NNS 37231 1828 24 , , , 37231 1828 25 and and CC 37231 1828 26 in in IN 37231 1828 27 which which WDT 37231 1828 28 fishes fish NNS 37231 1828 29 , , , 37231 1828 30 trees tree NNS 37231 1828 31 , , , 37231 1828 32 and and CC 37231 1828 33 beasts beast NNS 37231 1828 34 are be VBP 37231 1828 35 assigned assign VBN 37231 1828 36 to to IN 37231 1828 37 the the DT 37231 1828 38 care care NN 37231 1828 39 of of IN 37231 1828 40 particular particular JJ 37231 1828 41 angels angel NNS 37231 1828 42 . . . 37231 1829 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1829 2 3 3 LS 37231 1829 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1829 4 Clement Clement NNP 37231 1829 5 of of IN 37231 1829 6 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 1829 7 mentions mention NNS 37231 1829 8 without without IN 37231 1829 9 dissent dissent NN 37231 1829 10 the the DT 37231 1829 11 prevailing prevail VBG 37231 1829 12 belief belief NN 37231 1829 13 that that IN 37231 1829 14 hail hail NN 37231 1829 15 - - HYPH 37231 1829 16 storms storm NNS 37231 1829 17 , , , 37231 1829 18 tempests tempest NNS 37231 1829 19 , , , 37231 1829 20 and and CC 37231 1829 21 similar similar JJ 37231 1829 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1829 23 do do VBP 37231 1829 24 not not RB 37231 1829 25 occur occur VB 37231 1829 26 merely merely RB 37231 1829 27 from from IN 37231 1829 28 material material JJ 37231 1829 29 disturbance disturbance NN 37231 1829 30 , , , 37231 1829 31 but but CC 37231 1829 32 also also RB 37231 1829 33 are be VBP 37231 1829 34 caused cause VBN 37231 1829 35 by by IN 37231 1829 36 the the DT 37231 1829 37 anger anger NN 37231 1829 38 of of IN 37231 1829 39 demons demon NNS 37231 1829 40 and and CC 37231 1829 41 evil evil JJ 37231 1829 42 angels angel NNS 37231 1829 43 . . . 37231 1830 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1830 2 4 4 LS 37231 1830 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1830 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1830 5 states state VBZ 37231 1830 6 that that IN 37231 1830 7 while while IN 37231 1830 8 angels angel NNS 37231 1830 9 superintend superintend VBP 37231 1830 10 all all PDT 37231 1830 11 the the DT 37231 1830 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1830 13 of of IN 37231 1830 14 nature nature NN 37231 1830 15 , , , 37231 1830 16 and and CC 37231 1830 17 control control VB 37231 1830 18 what what WP 37231 1830 19 is be VBZ 37231 1830 20 appointed appoint VBN 37231 1830 21 for for IN 37231 1830 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1830 23 good good JJ 37231 1830 24 , , , 37231 1830 25 famine famine NN 37231 1830 26 , , , 37231 1830 27 the the DT 37231 1830 28 blighting blighting NN 37231 1830 29 of of IN 37231 1830 30 vines vine NNS 37231 1830 31 and and CC 37231 1830 32 fruit fruit NN 37231 1830 33 trees tree NNS 37231 1830 34 , , , 37231 1830 35 and and CC 37231 1830 36 the the DT 37231 1830 37 destruction destruction NN 37231 1830 38 of of IN 37231 1830 39 beasts beast NNS 37231 1830 40 and and CC 37231 1830 41 of of IN 37231 1830 42 men man NNS 37231 1830 43 , , , 37231 1830 44 are be VBP 37231 1830 45 , , , 37231 1830 46 on on IN 37231 1830 47 the the DT 37231 1830 48 other other JJ 37231 1830 49 hand hand NN 37231 1830 50 , , , 37231 1830 51 the the DT 37231 1830 52 personal personal JJ 37231 1830 53 works(5 works(5 NN 37231 1830 54 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1830 55 of of IN 37231 1830 56 demons demon NNS 37231 1830 57 , , , 37231 1830 58 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1830 59 , , , 37231 1830 60 as as IN 37231 1830 61 public public JJ 37231 1830 62 executioners executioner NNS 37231 1830 63 , , , 37231 1830 64 receiving receive VBG 37231 1830 65 at at IN 37231 1830 66 certain certain JJ 37231 1830 67 times time NNS 37231 1830 68 authority authority NNP 37231 1830 69 to to TO 37231 1830 70 carry carry VB 37231 1830 71 into into IN 37231 1830 72 effect effect NN 37231 1830 73 divine divine JJ 37231 1830 74 decrees decree NNS 37231 1830 75 . . . 37231 1831 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1831 2 6 6 CD 37231 1831 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1831 4 " " `` 37231 1831 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1831 6 have have VBP 37231 1831 7 already already RB 37231 1831 8 quoted quote VBN 37231 1831 9 similar similar JJ 37231 1831 10 views view NNS 37231 1831 11 expressed express VBN 37231 1831 12 by by IN 37231 1831 13 Tertullian,(7 Tertullian,(7 NNS 37231 1831 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1831 15 and and CC 37231 1831 16 the the DT 37231 1831 17 universality universality NN 37231 1831 18 and and CC 37231 1831 19 permanence permanence NN 37231 1831 20 of of IN 37231 1831 21 such such JJ 37231 1831 22 opinions opinion NNS 37231 1831 23 may may MD 37231 1831 24 be be VB 37231 1831 25 illustrated illustrate VBN 37231 1831 26 by by IN 37231 1831 27 the the DT 37231 1831 28 fact fact NN 37231 1831 29 that that IN 37231 1831 30 , , , 37231 1831 31 after after IN 37231 1831 32 the the DT 37231 1831 33 lapse lapse NN 37231 1831 34 of of IN 37231 1831 35 many many JJ 37231 1831 36 centuries century NNS 37231 1831 37 , , , 37231 1831 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1831 39 find find VBP 37231 1831 40 St. St. NNP 37231 1831 41 Thomas Thomas NNP 37231 1831 42 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 37231 1831 43 as as IN 37231 1831 44 solemnly solemnly RB 37231 1831 45 affirming affirm VBG 37231 1831 46 that that DT 37231 1831 47 disease disease NN 37231 1831 48 and and CC 37231 1831 49 tempests tempest NNS 37231 1831 50 are be VBP 37231 1831 51 the the DT 37231 1831 52 direct direct JJ 37231 1831 53 work work NN 37231 1831 54 of of IN 37231 1831 55 the the DT 37231 1831 56 devil;(8 devil;(8 NNP 37231 1831 57 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1831 58 indeed indeed RB 37231 1831 59 , , , 37231 1831 60 this this DT 37231 1831 61 belief belief NN 37231 1831 62 prevailed prevail VBD 37231 1831 63 { { -LRB- 37231 1831 64 132 132 CD 37231 1831 65 } } -RRB- 37231 1831 66 throughout throughout IN 37231 1831 67 the the DT 37231 1831 68 middle middle JJ 37231 1831 69 ages age NNS 37231 1831 70 until until IN 37231 1831 71 very very RB 37231 1831 72 recent recent JJ 37231 1831 73 times time NNS 37231 1831 74 . . . 37231 1832 1 The the DT 37231 1832 2 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 1832 3 Peter Peter NNP 37231 1832 4 , , , 37231 1832 5 in in IN 37231 1832 6 the the DT 37231 1832 7 Recognitions Recognitions NNP 37231 1832 8 of of IN 37231 1832 9 Clement Clement NNP 37231 1832 10 , , , 37231 1832 11 informs inform VBZ 37231 1832 12 Clement clement NN 37231 1832 13 that that IN 37231 1832 14 when when WRB 37231 1832 15 God God NNP 37231 1832 16 made make VBD 37231 1832 17 the the DT 37231 1832 18 world world NN 37231 1832 19 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1832 20 appointed appoint VBD 37231 1832 21 chiefs chief NNS 37231 1832 22 over over IN 37231 1832 23 the the DT 37231 1832 24 various various JJ 37231 1832 25 creatures creature NNS 37231 1832 26 , , , 37231 1832 27 even even RB 37231 1832 28 over over IN 37231 1832 29 the the DT 37231 1832 30 trees tree NNS 37231 1832 31 and and CC 37231 1832 32 the the DT 37231 1832 33 mountains mountain NNS 37231 1832 34 and and CC 37231 1832 35 springs spring NNS 37231 1832 36 and and CC 37231 1832 37 rivers river NNS 37231 1832 38 , , , 37231 1832 39 and and CC 37231 1832 40 over over IN 37231 1832 41 everything everything NN 37231 1832 42 in in IN 37231 1832 43 the the DT 37231 1832 44 universe universe NN 37231 1832 45 . . . 37231 1833 1 An an DT 37231 1833 2 angel angel NN 37231 1833 3 was be VBD 37231 1833 4 set set VBN 37231 1833 5 over over IN 37231 1833 6 the the DT 37231 1833 7 angels angel NNS 37231 1833 8 , , , 37231 1833 9 a a DT 37231 1833 10 spirit spirit NN 37231 1833 11 over over IN 37231 1833 12 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1833 13 , , , 37231 1833 14 a a DT 37231 1833 15 star star NN 37231 1833 16 over over IN 37231 1833 17 the the DT 37231 1833 18 stars star NNS 37231 1833 19 , , , 37231 1833 20 a a DT 37231 1833 21 demon demon NN 37231 1833 22 over over IN 37231 1833 23 the the DT 37231 1833 24 demons demon NNS 37231 1833 25 , , , 37231 1833 26 and and CC 37231 1833 27 so so RB 37231 1833 28 on on RB 37231 1833 29 . . . 37231 1834 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1834 2 1 1 LS 37231 1834 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1834 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1834 5 provided provide VBD 37231 1834 6 different different JJ 37231 1834 7 offices office NNS 37231 1834 8 for for IN 37231 1834 9 all all PDT 37231 1834 10 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1834 11 creatures creature NNS 37231 1834 12 , , , 37231 1834 13 whether whether IN 37231 1834 14 good good JJ 37231 1834 15 or or CC 37231 1834 16 bad,(2 bad,(2 JJ 37231 1834 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1834 18 but but CC 37231 1834 19 certain certain JJ 37231 1834 20 angels angel NNS 37231 1834 21 having have VBG 37231 1834 22 left leave VBN 37231 1834 23 the the DT 37231 1834 24 course course NN 37231 1834 25 of of IN 37231 1834 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1834 27 proper proper JJ 37231 1834 28 order order NN 37231 1834 29 , , , 37231 1834 30 led lead VBN 37231 1834 31 men man NNS 37231 1834 32 into into IN 37231 1834 33 sin sin NN 37231 1834 34 and and CC 37231 1834 35 taught teach VBD 37231 1834 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1834 37 that that IN 37231 1834 38 demons demon NNS 37231 1834 39 could could MD 37231 1834 40 , , , 37231 1834 41 by by IN 37231 1834 42 magical magical JJ 37231 1834 43 invocations invocation NNS 37231 1834 44 , , , 37231 1834 45 be be VB 37231 1834 46 made make VBN 37231 1834 47 to to TO 37231 1834 48 obey obey VB 37231 1834 49 man man NN 37231 1834 50 . . . 37231 1835 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1835 2 3 3 LS 37231 1835 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1835 4 Ham Ham NNP 37231 1835 5 was be VBD 37231 1835 6 the the DT 37231 1835 7 discoverer discoverer NN 37231 1835 8 of of IN 37231 1835 9 the the DT 37231 1835 10 art art NN 37231 1835 11 of of IN 37231 1835 12 magic magic NN 37231 1835 13 . . . 37231 1836 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1836 2 4 4 LS 37231 1836 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1836 4 Astrologers astrologer NNS 37231 1836 5 suppose suppose VBP 37231 1836 6 that that IN 37231 1836 7 evils evil NNS 37231 1836 8 happen happen VBP 37231 1836 9 in in IN 37231 1836 10 consequence consequence NN 37231 1836 11 of of IN 37231 1836 12 the the DT 37231 1836 13 motions motion NNS 37231 1836 14 of of IN 37231 1836 15 the the DT 37231 1836 16 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 1836 17 bodies body NNS 37231 1836 18 , , , 37231 1836 19 and and CC 37231 1836 20 represent represent VB 37231 1836 21 certain certain JJ 37231 1836 22 climacteric climacteric NN 37231 1836 23 periods period NNS 37231 1836 24 as as IN 37231 1836 25 dangerous dangerous JJ 37231 1836 26 , , , 37231 1836 27 not not RB 37231 1836 28 knowing know VBG 37231 1836 29 that that IN 37231 1836 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1836 31 is be VBZ 37231 1836 32 not not RB 37231 1836 33 the the DT 37231 1836 34 course course NN 37231 1836 35 of of IN 37231 1836 36 the the DT 37231 1836 37 stars star NNS 37231 1836 38 , , , 37231 1836 39 but but CC 37231 1836 40 the the DT 37231 1836 41 action action NN 37231 1836 42 of of IN 37231 1836 43 demons demon NNS 37231 1836 44 that that WDT 37231 1836 45 regulates regulate VBZ 37231 1836 46 these these DT 37231 1836 47 things thing NNS 37231 1836 48 . . . 37231 1837 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1837 2 5 5 LS 37231 1837 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1837 4 God God NNP 37231 1837 5 has have VBZ 37231 1837 6 committed commit VBN 37231 1837 7 the the DT 37231 1837 8 superintendence superintendence NN 37231 1837 9 of of IN 37231 1837 10 the the DT 37231 1837 11 seventy seventy CD 37231 1837 12 - - HYPH 37231 1837 13 two two CD 37231 1837 14 nations nation NNS 37231 1837 15 into into IN 37231 1837 16 which which WDT 37231 1837 17 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1837 18 has have VBZ 37231 1837 19 divided divide VBN 37231 1837 20 the the DT 37231 1837 21 earth earth NN 37231 1837 22 to to IN 37231 1837 23 as as RB 37231 1837 24 many many JJ 37231 1837 25 angels angel NNS 37231 1837 26 . . . 37231 1838 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1838 2 6 6 CD 37231 1838 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1838 4 Demons demon NNS 37231 1838 5 insinuate insinuate VBP 37231 1838 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1838 7 into into IN 37231 1838 8 the the DT 37231 1838 9 bodies body NNS 37231 1838 10 of of IN 37231 1838 11 men man NNS 37231 1838 12 , , , 37231 1838 13 and and CC 37231 1838 14 force force VB 37231 1838 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1838 16 to to TO 37231 1838 17 fulfil fulfil VB 37231 1838 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1838 19 desires;(7 desires;(7 NN 37231 1838 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1838 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1838 22 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1838 23 appear appear VBP 37231 1838 24 visibly visibly RB 37231 1838 25 to to IN 37231 1838 26 men man NNS 37231 1838 27 , , , 37231 1838 28 and and CC 37231 1838 29 by by IN 37231 1838 30 threats threat NNS 37231 1838 31 or or CC 37231 1838 32 promises promise NNS 37231 1838 33 endeavour endeavour VBP 37231 1838 34 to to TO 37231 1838 35 lead lead VB 37231 1838 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1838 37 into into IN 37231 1838 38 error error NN 37231 1838 39 ; ; : 37231 1838 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1838 41 can can MD 37231 1838 42 transform transform VB 37231 1838 43 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1838 44 into into IN 37231 1838 45 whatever whatever WDT 37231 1838 46 forms form NNS 37231 1838 47 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1838 48 please please VBP 37231 1838 49 . . . 37231 1839 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1839 2 8) 8) CD 37231 1839 3 The the DT 37231 1839 4 distinction distinction NN 37231 1839 5 between between IN 37231 1839 6 what what WP 37231 1839 7 is be VBZ 37231 1839 8 spoken speak VBN 37231 1839 9 by by IN 37231 1839 10 the the DT 37231 1839 11 true true JJ 37231 1839 12 God God NNP 37231 1839 13 through through IN 37231 1839 14 the the DT 37231 1839 15 prophets prophet NNS 37231 1839 16 or or CC 37231 1839 17 by by IN 37231 1839 18 visions vision NNS 37231 1839 19 , , , 37231 1839 20 and and CC 37231 1839 21 that that IN 37231 1839 22 which which WDT 37231 1839 23 is be VBZ 37231 1839 24 delivered deliver VBN 37231 1839 25 by by IN 37231 1839 26 demons demon NNS 37231 1839 27 , , , 37231 1839 28 is be VBZ 37231 1839 29 this this DT 37231 1839 30 : : : 37231 1839 31 that that IN 37231 1839 32 what what WP 37231 1839 33 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1839 34 from from IN 37231 1839 35 the the DT 37231 1839 36 former former JJ 37231 1839 37 is be VBZ 37231 1839 38 always always RB 37231 1839 39 true true JJ 37231 1839 40 , , , 37231 1839 41 whereas whereas IN 37231 1839 42 that that DT 37231 1839 43 which which WDT 37231 1839 44 is be VBZ 37231 1839 45 foretold foretell VBN 37231 1839 46 by by IN 37231 1839 47 demons demon NNS 37231 1839 48 is be VBZ 37231 1839 49 not not RB 37231 1839 50 always always RB 37231 1839 51 true true JJ 37231 1839 52 . . . 37231 1840 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1840 2 9 9 CD 37231 1840 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1840 4 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 37231 1840 5 says say VBZ 37231 1840 6 that that IN 37231 1840 7 when when WRB 37231 1840 8 the the DT 37231 1840 9 { { -LRB- 37231 1840 10 133 133 CD 37231 1840 11 } } -RRB- 37231 1840 12 number number NN 37231 1840 13 of of IN 37231 1840 14 men man NNS 37231 1840 15 began begin VBD 37231 1840 16 to to TO 37231 1840 17 increase increase VB 37231 1840 18 , , , 37231 1840 19 fearing fear VBG 37231 1840 20 that that IN 37231 1840 21 the the DT 37231 1840 22 Devil Devil NNP 37231 1840 23 should should MD 37231 1840 24 corrupt corrupt VB 37231 1840 25 or or CC 37231 1840 26 destroy destroy VB 37231 1840 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1840 28 , , , 37231 1840 29 God God NNP 37231 1840 30 sent send VBD 37231 1840 31 angels angel NNS 37231 1840 32 to to TO 37231 1840 33 protect protect VB 37231 1840 34 and and CC 37231 1840 35 instruct instruct VB 37231 1840 36 the the DT 37231 1840 37 human human JJ 37231 1840 38 race race NN 37231 1840 39 , , , 37231 1840 40 but but CC 37231 1840 41 the the DT 37231 1840 42 angels angel NNS 37231 1840 43 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1840 44 fell fall VBD 37231 1840 45 beneath beneath IN 37231 1840 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1840 47 wiles wile NNS 37231 1840 48 , , , 37231 1840 49 and and CC 37231 1840 50 from from IN 37231 1840 51 being be VBG 37231 1840 52 angels angel NNS 37231 1840 53 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1840 54 became become VBD 37231 1840 55 the the DT 37231 1840 56 satellites satellite NNS 37231 1840 57 and and CC 37231 1840 58 ministers minister NNS 37231 1840 59 of of IN 37231 1840 60 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1840 61 . . . 37231 1841 1 The the DT 37231 1841 2 offspring offspring NN 37231 1841 3 of of IN 37231 1841 4 these these DT 37231 1841 5 fallen fall VBN 37231 1841 6 angels angel NNS 37231 1841 7 are be VBP 37231 1841 8 unclean unclean JJ 37231 1841 9 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1841 10 , , , 37231 1841 11 authors author NNS 37231 1841 12 of of IN 37231 1841 13 all all PDT 37231 1841 14 the the DT 37231 1841 15 evils evil NNS 37231 1841 16 which which WDT 37231 1841 17 are be VBP 37231 1841 18 done do VBN 37231 1841 19 , , , 37231 1841 20 and and CC 37231 1841 21 the the DT 37231 1841 22 Devil Devil NNP 37231 1841 23 is be VBZ 37231 1841 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1841 25 chief chief NN 37231 1841 26 . . . 37231 1842 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1842 2 are be VBP 37231 1842 3 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 1842 4 with with IN 37231 1842 5 the the DT 37231 1842 6 future future NN 37231 1842 7 , , , 37231 1842 8 but but CC 37231 1842 9 nob nob NNP 37231 1842 10 completely completely RB 37231 1842 11 . . . 37231 1843 1 The the DT 37231 1843 2 art art NN 37231 1843 3 of of IN 37231 1843 4 the the DT 37231 1843 5 magi magi NN 37231 1843 6 is be VBZ 37231 1843 7 altogether altogether RB 37231 1843 8 supported support VBN 37231 1843 9 by by IN 37231 1843 10 these these DT 37231 1843 11 demons demon NNS 37231 1843 12 , , , 37231 1843 13 and and CC 37231 1843 14 at at IN 37231 1843 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1843 16 invocation invocation NN 37231 1843 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1843 18 deceive deceive VBP 37231 1843 19 men man NNS 37231 1843 20 with with IN 37231 1843 21 lying lie VBG 37231 1843 22 tricks trick NNS 37231 1843 23 , , , 37231 1843 24 making make VBG 37231 1843 25 men man NNS 37231 1843 26 think think VB 37231 1843 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1843 28 see see VBP 37231 1843 29 things thing NNS 37231 1843 30 which which WDT 37231 1843 31 do do VBP 37231 1843 32 not not RB 37231 1843 33 exist exist VB 37231 1843 34 . . . 37231 1844 1 These these DT 37231 1844 2 contaminated contaminate VBN 37231 1844 3 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1844 4 wander wander VBP 37231 1844 5 over over IN 37231 1844 6 all all PDT 37231 1844 7 the the DT 37231 1844 8 earth earth NN 37231 1844 9 , , , 37231 1844 10 and and CC 37231 1844 11 console console VB 37231 1844 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1844 13 by by IN 37231 1844 14 the the DT 37231 1844 15 destruction destruction NN 37231 1844 16 of of IN 37231 1844 17 men man NNS 37231 1844 18 . . . 37231 1845 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1845 2 fill fill VBP 37231 1845 3 every every DT 37231 1845 4 place place NN 37231 1845 5 with with IN 37231 1845 6 frauds fraud NNS 37231 1845 7 and and CC 37231 1845 8 deceits deceit NNS 37231 1845 9 , , , 37231 1845 10 for for IN 37231 1845 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1845 12 adhere adhere VBP 37231 1845 13 to to IN 37231 1845 14 individuals individual NNS 37231 1845 15 , , , 37231 1845 16 and and CC 37231 1845 17 occupy occupy VB 37231 1845 18 whole whole JJ 37231 1845 19 houses house NNS 37231 1845 20 , , , 37231 1845 21 and and CC 37231 1845 22 assume assume VB 37231 1845 23 the the DT 37231 1845 24 name name NN 37231 1845 25 of of IN 37231 1845 26 genii genii NNP 37231 1845 27 , , , 37231 1845 28 as as IN 37231 1845 29 demons demon NNS 37231 1845 30 are be VBP 37231 1845 31 called call VBN 37231 1845 32 in in IN 37231 1845 33 the the DT 37231 1845 34 Latin latin JJ 37231 1845 35 language language NN 37231 1845 36 , , , 37231 1845 37 and and CC 37231 1845 38 make make VB 37231 1845 39 men man NNS 37231 1845 40 worship worship VB 37231 1845 41 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1845 42 . . . 37231 1846 1 On on IN 37231 1846 2 account account NN 37231 1846 3 of of IN 37231 1846 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1846 5 tenuity tenuity NN 37231 1846 6 and and CC 37231 1846 7 impalpability impalpability NN 37231 1846 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1846 9 insinuate insinuate VBP 37231 1846 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1846 11 into into IN 37231 1846 12 the the DT 37231 1846 13 bodies body NNS 37231 1846 14 of of IN 37231 1846 15 men man NNS 37231 1846 16 , , , 37231 1846 17 and and CC 37231 1846 18 through through IN 37231 1846 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1846 20 _ _ NNP 37231 1846 21 viscera viscera NN 37231 1846 22 _ _ NNP 37231 1846 23 injure injure VBP 37231 1846 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1846 25 health health NN 37231 1846 26 , , , 37231 1846 27 excite excite NN 37231 1846 28 diseases disease NNS 37231 1846 29 , , , 37231 1846 30 terrify terrify VB 37231 1846 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1846 32 souls soul NNS 37231 1846 33 with with IN 37231 1846 34 dreams dream NNS 37231 1846 35 , , , 37231 1846 36 agitate agitate VBP 37231 1846 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1846 38 minds mind NNS 37231 1846 39 with with IN 37231 1846 40 phrensies phrensie NNS 37231 1846 41 , , , 37231 1846 42 so so IN 37231 1846 43 that that IN 37231 1846 44 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1846 45 may may MD 37231 1846 46 by by IN 37231 1846 47 these these DT 37231 1846 48 evils evil NNS 37231 1846 49 drive drive VB 37231 1846 50 men man NNS 37231 1846 51 to to TO 37231 1846 52 seek seek VB 37231 1846 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1846 54 aid aid NN 37231 1846 55 . . . 37231 1847 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1847 2 1 1 LS 37231 1847 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1847 4 Being be VBG 37231 1847 5 adjured adjure VBN 37231 1847 6 in in IN 37231 1847 7 the the DT 37231 1847 8 name name NN 37231 1847 9 of of IN 37231 1847 10 God God NNP 37231 1847 11 , , , 37231 1847 12 however however RB 37231 1847 13 , , , 37231 1847 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1847 15 leave leave VBP 37231 1847 16 the the DT 37231 1847 17 bodies body NNS 37231 1847 18 of of IN 37231 1847 19 the the DT 37231 1847 20 possessed possessed JJ 37231 1847 21 , , , 37231 1847 22 uttering utter VBG 37231 1847 23 the the DT 37231 1847 24 greatest great JJS 37231 1847 25 howling howling NN 37231 1847 26 , , , 37231 1847 27 and and CC 37231 1847 28 crying cry VBG 37231 1847 29 out out RP 37231 1847 30 that that IN 37231 1847 31 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1847 32 are be VBP 37231 1847 33 beaten beat VBN 37231 1847 34 , , , 37231 1847 35 or or CC 37231 1847 36 are be VBP 37231 1847 37 on on IN 37231 1847 38 fire fire NN 37231 1847 39 . . . 37231 1848 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1848 2 2 2 LS 37231 1848 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1848 4 These these DT 37231 1848 5 demons demon NNS 37231 1848 6 are be VBP 37231 1848 7 the the DT 37231 1848 8 inventors inventor NNS 37231 1848 9 of of IN 37231 1848 10 astrology astrology NN 37231 1848 11 , , , 37231 1848 12 divination divination NN 37231 1848 13 , , , 37231 1848 14 oracles oracle NNS 37231 1848 15 , , , 37231 1848 16 necromancy necromancy NN 37231 1848 17 , , , 37231 1848 18 and and CC 37231 1848 19 the the DT 37231 1848 20 art art NN 37231 1848 21 of of IN 37231 1848 22 magic magic NN 37231 1848 23 . . . 37231 1849 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1849 2 3 3 LS 37231 1849 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1849 4 The the DT 37231 1849 5 universe universe NN 37231 1849 6 is be VBZ 37231 1849 7 governed govern VBN 37231 1849 8 by by IN 37231 1849 9 God God NNP 37231 1849 10 through through IN 37231 1849 11 the the DT 37231 1849 12 medium medium NN 37231 1849 13 of of IN 37231 1849 14 angels angel NNS 37231 1849 15 . . . 37231 1850 1 The the DT 37231 1850 2 demons demon NNS 37231 1850 3 have have VBP 37231 1850 4 a a DT 37231 1850 5 fore fore JJ 37231 1850 6 - - HYPH 37231 1850 7 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1850 8 of of IN 37231 1850 9 the the DT 37231 1850 10 purposes purpose NNS 37231 1850 11 of of IN 37231 1850 12 God God NNP 37231 1850 13 , , , 37231 1850 14 from from IN 37231 1850 15 having have VBG 37231 1850 16 been be VBN 37231 1850 17 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1850 18 { { -LRB- 37231 1850 19 134 134 CD 37231 1850 20 } } -RRB- 37231 1850 21 ministers minister NNS 37231 1850 22 , , , 37231 1850 23 and and CC 37231 1850 24 interposing interpose VBG 37231 1850 25 in in IN 37231 1850 26 what what WP 37231 1850 27 is be VBZ 37231 1850 28 being be VBG 37231 1850 29 done do VBN 37231 1850 30 , , , 37231 1850 31 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1850 32 ascribe ascribe VBP 37231 1850 33 the the DT 37231 1850 34 credit credit NN 37231 1850 35 to to IN 37231 1850 36 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1850 37 . . . 37231 1851 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1851 2 1 1 LS 37231 1851 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1851 4 The the DT 37231 1851 5 sign sign NN 37231 1851 6 of of IN 37231 1851 7 the the DT 37231 1851 8 cross cross NN 37231 1851 9 is be VBZ 37231 1851 10 a a DT 37231 1851 11 terror terror NN 37231 1851 12 to to IN 37231 1851 13 demons demon NNS 37231 1851 14 , , , 37231 1851 15 and and CC 37231 1851 16 at at IN 37231 1851 17 the the DT 37231 1851 18 sight sight NN 37231 1851 19 of of IN 37231 1851 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1851 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1851 22 flee flee VBP 37231 1851 23 from from IN 37231 1851 24 the the DT 37231 1851 25 bodies body NNS 37231 1851 26 of of IN 37231 1851 27 men man NNS 37231 1851 28 . . . 37231 1852 1 When when WRB 37231 1852 2 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 37231 1852 3 are be VBP 37231 1852 4 being be VBG 37231 1852 5 offered offer VBN 37231 1852 6 to to IN 37231 1852 7 the the DT 37231 1852 8 gods god NNS 37231 1852 9 , , , 37231 1852 10 if if IN 37231 1852 11 one one CD 37231 1852 12 be be VB 37231 1852 13 present present JJ 37231 1852 14 who who WP 37231 1852 15 bears bear VBZ 37231 1852 16 on on IN 37231 1852 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1852 18 forehead forehead NN 37231 1852 19 the the DT 37231 1852 20 sign sign NN 37231 1852 21 of of IN 37231 1852 22 the the DT 37231 1852 23 cross cross NN 37231 1852 24 , , , 37231 1852 25 the the DT 37231 1852 26 sacred sacred JJ 37231 1852 27 rites rite NNS 37231 1852 28 are be VBP 37231 1852 29 not not RB 37231 1852 30 propitious propitious JJ 37231 1852 31 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1852 32 _ _ NNP 37231 1852 33 sacra sacra NNP 37231 1852 34 nullo nullo NNP 37231 1852 35 modo modo NNP 37231 1852 36 litant litant NNP 37231 1852 37 _ _ NNP 37231 1852 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1852 39 , , , 37231 1852 40 and and CC 37231 1852 41 the the DT 37231 1852 42 oracle oracle NN 37231 1852 43 gives give VBZ 37231 1852 44 no no DT 37231 1852 45 reply reply NN 37231 1852 46 . . . 37231 1853 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1853 2 2 2 LS 37231 1853 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1853 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 1853 5 , , , 37231 1853 6 like like IN 37231 1853 7 all all PDT 37231 1853 8 the the DT 37231 1853 9 Fathers father NNS 37231 1853 10 , , , 37231 1853 11 represents represent VBZ 37231 1853 12 the the DT 37231 1853 13 gods god NNS 37231 1853 14 of of IN 37231 1853 15 the the DT 37231 1853 16 Greeks Greeks NNPS 37231 1853 17 and and CC 37231 1853 18 other other JJ 37231 1853 19 heathen heathen NNP 37231 1853 20 nations nation NNS 37231 1853 21 as as IN 37231 1853 22 merely merely RB 37231 1853 23 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1853 24 demons demon NNS 37231 1853 25 . . . 37231 1854 1 Demons demon NNS 37231 1854 2 , , , 37231 1854 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1854 4 says say VBZ 37231 1854 5 , , , 37231 1854 6 whether whether IN 37231 1854 7 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1854 8 circulate circulate VBP 37231 1854 9 in in IN 37231 1854 10 the the DT 37231 1854 11 dark dark JJ 37231 1854 12 and and CC 37231 1854 13 heavy heavy JJ 37231 1854 14 atmosphere atmosphere NN 37231 1854 15 which which WDT 37231 1854 16 encircles encircle VBZ 37231 1854 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1854 18 sphere sphere NN 37231 1854 19 , , , 37231 1854 20 or or CC 37231 1854 21 inhabit inhabit VB 37231 1854 22 the the DT 37231 1854 23 cavernous cavernous JJ 37231 1854 24 dwellings dwelling NNS 37231 1854 25 which which WDT 37231 1854 26 exist exist VBP 37231 1854 27 within within IN 37231 1854 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1854 29 , , , 37231 1854 30 find find VB 37231 1854 31 charms charm NNS 37231 1854 32 only only RB 37231 1854 33 in in IN 37231 1854 34 tombs tomb NNS 37231 1854 35 and and CC 37231 1854 36 in in IN 37231 1854 37 the the DT 37231 1854 38 sepulchres sepulchre NNS 37231 1854 39 of of IN 37231 1854 40 the the DT 37231 1854 41 dead dead JJ 37231 1854 42 , , , 37231 1854 43 and and CC 37231 1854 44 in in IN 37231 1854 45 impure impure NN 37231 1854 46 and and CC 37231 1854 47 unclean unclean JJ 37231 1854 48 places place NNS 37231 1854 49 . . . 37231 1855 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1855 2 delight delight VBP 37231 1855 3 in in IN 37231 1855 4 the the DT 37231 1855 5 blood blood NN 37231 1855 6 of of IN 37231 1855 7 animals animal NNS 37231 1855 8 , , , 37231 1855 9 and and CC 37231 1855 10 in in IN 37231 1855 11 the the DT 37231 1855 12 putrid putrid JJ 37231 1855 13 exhalations exhalation NNS 37231 1855 14 which which WDT 37231 1855 15 rise rise VBP 37231 1855 16 from from IN 37231 1855 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1855 18 bodies body NNS 37231 1855 19 , , , 37231 1855 20 as as RB 37231 1855 21 well well RB 37231 1855 22 as as IN 37231 1855 23 in in IN 37231 1855 24 earthly earthly JJ 37231 1855 25 vapours vapour NNS 37231 1855 26 . . . 37231 1856 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1856 2 leaders leader NNS 37231 1856 3 , , , 37231 1856 4 whether whether IN 37231 1856 5 as as IN 37231 1856 6 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 37231 1856 7 of of IN 37231 1856 8 the the DT 37231 1856 9 upper upper JJ 37231 1856 10 regions region NNS 37231 1856 11 of of IN 37231 1856 12 the the DT 37231 1856 13 atmosphere atmosphere NN 37231 1856 14 , , , 37231 1856 15 or or CC 37231 1856 16 plunged plunge VBN 37231 1856 17 in in IN 37231 1856 18 the the DT 37231 1856 19 abyss abyss NN 37231 1856 20 of of IN 37231 1856 21 hell hell NN 37231 1856 22 , , , 37231 1856 23 having have VBG 37231 1856 24 discovered discover VBN 37231 1856 25 that that IN 37231 1856 26 the the DT 37231 1856 27 human human JJ 37231 1856 28 race race NN 37231 1856 29 had have VBD 37231 1856 30 deified deify VBN 37231 1856 31 and and CC 37231 1856 32 offered offer VBN 37231 1856 33 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 37231 1856 34 to to IN 37231 1856 35 men man NNS 37231 1856 36 who who WP 37231 1856 37 were be VBD 37231 1856 38 dead dead JJ 37231 1856 39 , , , 37231 1856 40 promoted promote VBD 37231 1856 41 the the DT 37231 1856 42 delusion delusion NN 37231 1856 43 in in IN 37231 1856 44 order order NN 37231 1856 45 to to TO 37231 1856 46 savour savour VB 37231 1856 47 the the DT 37231 1856 48 blood blood NN 37231 1856 49 which which WDT 37231 1856 50 flowed.and flowed.and VBD 37231 1856 51 the the DT 37231 1856 52 fumes fume NNS 37231 1856 53 of of IN 37231 1856 54 the the DT 37231 1856 55 burning burn VBG 37231 1856 56 flesh flesh NN 37231 1856 57 . . . 37231 1857 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1857 2 deceived deceive VBD 37231 1857 3 men man NNS 37231 1857 4 by by IN 37231 1857 5 the the DT 37231 1857 6 motions motion NNS 37231 1857 7 conveyed convey VBN 37231 1857 8 to to IN 37231 1857 9 idols idol NNS 37231 1857 10 and and CC 37231 1857 11 statues statue NNS 37231 1857 12 , , , 37231 1857 13 by by IN 37231 1857 14 the the DT 37231 1857 15 oracles oracle NNS 37231 1857 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1857 17 delivered deliver VBD 37231 1857 18 , , , 37231 1857 19 and and CC 37231 1857 20 by by IN 37231 1857 21 healing heal VBG 37231 1857 22 diseases disease NNS 37231 1857 23 , , , 37231 1857 24 with with IN 37231 1857 25 which which WDT 37231 1857 26 , , , 37231 1857 27 by by IN 37231 1857 28 the the DT 37231 1857 29 power power NN 37231 1857 30 inherent inherent JJ 37231 1857 31 in in IN 37231 1857 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1857 33 nature nature NN 37231 1857 34 , , , 37231 1857 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1857 36 had have VBD 37231 1857 37 before before IN 37231 1857 38 invisibly invisibly JJ 37231 1857 39 smitten smitten NN 37231 1857 40 bodies body NNS 37231 1857 41 , , , 37231 1857 42 and and CC 37231 1857 43 which which WDT 37231 1857 44 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1857 45 removed remove VBD 37231 1857 46 by by IN 37231 1857 47 ceasing cease VBG 37231 1857 48 to to TO 37231 1857 49 torture torture VB 37231 1857 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1857 51 . . . 37231 1858 1 These these DT 37231 1858 2 demons demon NNS 37231 1858 3 first first RB 37231 1858 4 introduced introduce VBN 37231 1858 5 magic magic NN 37231 1858 6 amongst amongst IN 37231 1858 7 men man NNS 37231 1858 8 . . . 37231 1859 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1859 2 3 3 LS 37231 1859 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1859 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1859 5 may may MD 37231 1859 6 here here RB 37231 1859 7 refer refer VB 37231 1859 8 to to IN 37231 1859 9 the the DT 37231 1859 10 account account NN 37231 1859 11 of of IN 37231 1859 12 a a DT 37231 1859 13 miracle miracle NN 37231 1859 14 which which WDT 37231 1859 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 1859 16 seriously seriously RB 37231 1859 17 quotes quote VBZ 37231 1859 18 , , , 37231 1859 19 as as IN 37231 1859 20 exemplifying exemplify VBG 37231 1859 21 another another DT 37231 1859 22 occasional occasional JJ 37231 1859 23 { { -LRB- 37231 1859 24 135 135 CD 37231 1859 25 } } -RRB- 37231 1859 26 function function NN 37231 1859 27 of of IN 37231 1859 28 the the DT 37231 1859 29 angels angel NNS 37231 1859 30 . . . 37231 1860 1 The the DT 37231 1860 2 heretical heretical JJ 37231 1860 3 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 1860 4 Natalius Natalius NNP 37231 1860 5 having have VBG 37231 1860 6 in in IN 37231 1860 7 vain vain JJ 37231 1860 8 been be VBN 37231 1860 9 admonished admonish VBN 37231 1860 10 by by IN 37231 1860 11 God God NNP 37231 1860 12 in in IN 37231 1860 13 dreams dream NNS 37231 1860 14 , , , 37231 1860 15 was be VBD 37231 1860 16 at at IN 37231 1860 17 last last JJ 37231 1860 18 lashed lash VBD 37231 1860 19 through through IN 37231 1860 20 the the DT 37231 1860 21 whole whole NN 37231 1860 22 of of IN 37231 1860 23 a a DT 37231 1860 24 night night NN 37231 1860 25 by by IN 37231 1860 26 holy holy JJ 37231 1860 27 angels angel NNS 37231 1860 28 , , , 37231 1860 29 till till IN 37231 1860 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1860 31 was be VBD 37231 1860 32 brought bring VBN 37231 1860 33 to to IN 37231 1860 34 repentance repentance NN 37231 1860 35 , , , 37231 1860 36 and and CC 37231 1860 37 , , , 37231 1860 38 clad clothe VBN 37231 1860 39 in in IN 37231 1860 40 sackcloth sackcloth NN 37231 1860 41 and and CC 37231 1860 42 covered cover VBN 37231 1860 43 with with IN 37231 1860 44 ashes ashe NNS 37231 1860 45 , , , 37231 1860 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1860 47 at at IN 37231 1860 48 length length NN 37231 1860 49 threw throw VBD 37231 1860 50 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1860 51 at at IN 37231 1860 52 the the DT 37231 1860 53 feet foot NNS 37231 1860 54 of of IN 37231 1860 55 Zephyrinus Zephyrinus NNP 37231 1860 56 , , , 37231 1860 57 then then RB 37231 1860 58 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 1860 59 of of IN 37231 1860 60 Rome Rome NNP 37231 1860 61 , , , 37231 1860 62 pointing point VBG 37231 1860 63 to to IN 37231 1860 64 the the DT 37231 1860 65 marks mark NNS 37231 1860 66 of of IN 37231 1860 67 the the DT 37231 1860 68 scourges scourge NNS 37231 1860 69 which which WDT 37231 1860 70 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1860 71 had have VBD 37231 1860 72 received receive VBN 37231 1860 73 from from IN 37231 1860 74 the the DT 37231 1860 75 angels angel NNS 37231 1860 76 , , , 37231 1860 77 and and CC 37231 1860 78 implored implore VBN 37231 1860 79 to to TO 37231 1860 80 be be VB 37231 1860 81 again again RB 37231 1860 82 received receive VBN 37231 1860 83 into into IN 37231 1860 84 communion communion NN 37231 1860 85 with with IN 37231 1860 86 the the DT 37231 1860 87 Church Church NNP 37231 1860 88 . . . 37231 1861 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1861 2 1 1 LS 37231 1861 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1861 4 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 1861 5 says say VBZ 37231 1861 6 that that IN 37231 1861 7 demons demon NNS 37231 1861 8 inhabit inhabit VBP 37231 1861 9 the the DT 37231 1861 10 atmosphere atmosphere NN 37231 1861 11 as as IN 37231 1861 12 in in IN 37231 1861 13 a a DT 37231 1861 14 prison prison NN 37231 1861 15 , , , 37231 1861 16 and and CC 37231 1861 17 deceive deceive JJ 37231 1861 18 men man NNS 37231 1861 19 , , , 37231 1861 20 persuading persuade VBG 37231 1861 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1861 22 by by IN 37231 1861 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1861 24 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 1861 25 and and CC 37231 1861 26 false false JJ 37231 1861 27 signs sign NNS 37231 1861 28 , , , 37231 1861 29 or or CC 37231 1861 30 doings doing NNS 37231 1861 31 , , , 37231 1861 32 or or CC 37231 1861 33 predictions prediction NNS 37231 1861 34 , , , 37231 1861 35 that that IN 37231 1861 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1861 37 are be VBP 37231 1861 38 gods god NNS 37231 1861 39 . . . 37231 1862 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1862 2 2 2 LS 37231 1862 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1862 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1862 5 considers consider VBZ 37231 1862 6 the the DT 37231 1862 7 origin origin NN 37231 1862 8 of of IN 37231 1862 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1862 10 name name NN 37231 1862 11 in in IN 37231 1862 12 the the DT 37231 1862 13 sacred sacred JJ 37231 1862 14 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 37231 1862 15 worthy worthy JJ 37231 1862 16 of of IN 37231 1862 17 notice notice NN 37231 1862 18 : : : 37231 1862 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1862 20 are be VBP 37231 1862 21 called call VBN 37231 1862 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 1862 23 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 1862 24 ] ] -RRB- 37231 1862 25 in in IN 37231 1862 26 Greek Greek NNP 37231 1862 27 on on IN 37231 1862 28 account account NN 37231 1862 29 of of IN 37231 1862 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1862 31 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1862 32 . . . 37231 1863 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1863 2 3 3 LS 37231 1863 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1863 4 By by IN 37231 1863 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1863 6 experience experience NN 37231 1863 7 of of IN 37231 1863 8 certain certain JJ 37231 1863 9 signs sign NNS 37231 1863 10 which which WDT 37231 1863 11 are be VBP 37231 1863 12 hidden hide VBN 37231 1863 13 from from IN 37231 1863 14 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1863 15 , , , 37231 1863 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1863 17 can can MD 37231 1863 18 read read VB 37231 1863 19 much much RB 37231 1863 20 more more JJR 37231 1863 21 of of IN 37231 1863 22 the the DT 37231 1863 23 future future NN 37231 1863 24 , , , 37231 1863 25 and and CC 37231 1863 26 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1863 27 even even RB 37231 1863 28 announce announce VBP 37231 1863 29 beforehand beforehand RB 37231 1863 30 what what WP 37231 1863 31 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1863 32 intend intend VBP 37231 1863 33 to to TO 37231 1863 34 do do VB 37231 1863 35 . . . 37231 1864 1 Speaking speak VBG 37231 1864 2 of of IN 37231 1864 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1864 4 own own JJ 37231 1864 5 time time NN 37231 1864 6 , , , 37231 1864 7 and and CC 37231 1864 8 with with IN 37231 1864 9 strong strong JJ 37231 1864 10 expressions expression NNS 37231 1864 11 of of IN 37231 1864 12 assurance assurance NN 37231 1864 13 , , , 37231 1864 14 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 1864 15 says say VBZ 37231 1864 16 that that IN 37231 1864 17 not not RB 37231 1864 18 only only RB 37231 1864 19 Scripture scripture NN 37231 1864 20 testifies testifie NNS 37231 1864 21 that that IN 37231 1864 22 angels angel NNS 37231 1864 23 have have VBP 37231 1864 24 appeared appear VBN 37231 1864 25 to to IN 37231 1864 26 men man NNS 37231 1864 27 with with IN 37231 1864 28 bodies body NNS 37231 1864 29 which which WDT 37231 1864 30 could could MD 37231 1864 31 not not RB 37231 1864 32 only only RB 37231 1864 33 be be VB 37231 1864 34 seen see VBN 37231 1864 35 but but CC 37231 1864 36 felt feel VBN 37231 1864 37 , , , 37231 1864 38 but but CC 37231 1864 39 what what WP 37231 1864 40 is be VBZ 37231 1864 41 more more JJR 37231 1864 42 , , , 37231 1864 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1864 44 is be VBZ 37231 1864 45 a a DT 37231 1864 46 general general JJ 37231 1864 47 report report NN 37231 1864 48 , , , 37231 1864 49 and and CC 37231 1864 50 many many JJ 37231 1864 51 have have VBP 37231 1864 52 personal personal JJ 37231 1864 53 experience experience NN 37231 1864 54 of of IN 37231 1864 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1864 56 , , , 37231 1864 57 or or CC 37231 1864 58 have have VBP 37231 1864 59 learned learn VBN 37231 1864 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1864 61 from from IN 37231 1864 62 those those DT 37231 1864 63 who who WP 37231 1864 64 have have VBP 37231 1864 65 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1864 66 of of IN 37231 1864 67 the the DT 37231 1864 68 fact fact NN 37231 1864 69 , , , 37231 1864 70 and and CC 37231 1864 71 of of IN 37231 1864 72 whose whose WP$ 37231 1864 73 truth truth NN 37231 1864 74 there there EX 37231 1864 75 is be VBZ 37231 1864 76 no no DT 37231 1864 77 doubt doubt NN 37231 1864 78 , , , 37231 1864 79 that that WDT 37231 1864 80 satyrs satyrs NN 37231 1864 81 and and CC 37231 1864 82 fauns faun NNS 37231 1864 83 , , , 37231 1864 84 generally generally RB 37231 1864 85 called call VBN 37231 1864 86 " " `` 37231 1864 87 Incubi Incubi NNP 37231 1864 88 , , , 37231 1864 89 " " '' 37231 1864 90 have have VBP 37231 1864 91 frequently frequently RB 37231 1864 92 perpetrated perpetrate VBN 37231 1864 93 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1864 94 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 1864 95 wickedness;(4 wickedness;(4 NNP 37231 1864 96 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1864 97 and and CC 37231 1864 98 also also RB 37231 1864 99 that that IN 37231 1864 100 certain certain JJ 37231 1864 101 demons demon NNS 37231 1864 102 called call VBN 37231 1864 103 by by IN 37231 1864 104 the the DT 37231 1864 105 Gauls Gauls NNP 37231 1864 106 _ _ NNP 37231 1864 107 Dusii Dusii NNP 37231 1864 108 _ _ NNP 37231 1864 109 every every DT 37231 1864 110 day day NN 37231 1864 111 attempt attempt NN 37231 1864 112 and and CC 37231 1864 113 effect effect VB 37231 1864 114 the the DT 37231 1864 115 same same JJ 37231 1864 116 uncleanness uncleanness NN 37231 1864 117 , , , 37231 1864 118 as as IN 37231 1864 119 { { -LRB- 37231 1864 120 136 136 CD 37231 1864 121 } } -RRB- 37231 1864 122 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1864 123 equally equally RB 37231 1864 124 numerous numerous JJ 37231 1864 125 and and CC 37231 1864 126 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 37231 1864 127 assert assert NN 37231 1864 128 , , , 37231 1864 129 so so IN 37231 1864 130 that that IN 37231 1864 131 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1864 132 would would MD 37231 1864 133 be be VB 37231 1864 134 impertinence impertinence NN 37231 1864 135 to to TO 37231 1864 136 deny deny VB 37231 1864 137 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1864 138 . . . 37231 1865 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1865 2 1 1 LS 37231 1865 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1865 4 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 37231 1865 5 , , , 37231 1865 6 again again RB 37231 1865 7 , , , 37231 1865 8 ridicules ridicule VBZ 37231 1865 9 the the DT 37231 1865 10 idea idea NN 37231 1865 11 that that IN 37231 1865 12 there there EX 37231 1865 13 can can MD 37231 1865 14 be be VB 37231 1865 15 antipodes antipode NNS 37231 1865 16 , , , 37231 1865 17 and and CC 37231 1865 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1865 19 can can MD 37231 1865 20 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1865 21 credit credit VB 37231 1865 22 that that IN 37231 1865 23 there there EX 37231 1865 24 can can MD 37231 1865 25 be be VB 37231 1865 26 any any DT 37231 1865 27 one one NN 37231 1865 28 so so RB 37231 1865 29 silly silly JJ 37231 1865 30 as as IN 37231 1865 31 to to TO 37231 1865 32 believe believe VB 37231 1865 33 that that IN 37231 1865 34 there there EX 37231 1865 35 are be VBP 37231 1865 36 men man NNS 37231 1865 37 whose whose WP$ 37231 1865 38 feet foot NNS 37231 1865 39 are be VBP 37231 1865 40 higher high JJR 37231 1865 41 than than IN 37231 1865 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1865 43 heads head NNS 37231 1865 44 , , , 37231 1865 45 or or CC 37231 1865 46 that that DT 37231 1865 47 grain grain NN 37231 1865 48 and and CC 37231 1865 49 trees tree NNS 37231 1865 50 grow grow VBP 37231 1865 51 downwards downwards RB 37231 1865 52 , , , 37231 1865 53 and and CC 37231 1865 54 rain rain NN 37231 1865 55 , , , 37231 1865 56 snow snow NN 37231 1865 57 , , , 37231 1865 58 and and CC 37231 1865 59 hail hail NN 37231 1865 60 fall fall VBP 37231 1865 61 upwards upwards RB 37231 1865 62 to to IN 37231 1865 63 the the DT 37231 1865 64 earth earth NN 37231 1865 65 . . . 37231 1866 1 After after IN 37231 1866 2 jesting jest VBG 37231 1866 3 at at IN 37231 1866 4 those those DT 37231 1866 5 who who WP 37231 1866 6 hold hold VBP 37231 1866 7 such such JJ 37231 1866 8 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 37231 1866 9 views view NNS 37231 1866 10 , , , 37231 1866 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1866 12 points point VBZ 37231 1866 13 out out RP 37231 1866 14 that that IN 37231 1866 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1866 16 blunders blunder NNS 37231 1866 17 arise arise VBP 37231 1866 18 from from IN 37231 1866 19 supposing suppose VBG 37231 1866 20 that that IN 37231 1866 21 the the DT 37231 1866 22 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1866 23 is be VBZ 37231 1866 24 round round JJ 37231 1866 25 , , , 37231 1866 26 and and CC 37231 1866 27 the the DT 37231 1866 28 world world NN 37231 1866 29 , , , 37231 1866 30 consequently consequently RB 37231 1866 31 , , , 37231 1866 32 round round RB 37231 1866 33 like like IN 37231 1866 34 a a DT 37231 1866 35 ball ball NN 37231 1866 36 , , , 37231 1866 37 and and CC 37231 1866 38 enclosed enclose VBD 37231 1866 39 within within IN 37231 1866 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1866 41 . . . 37231 1867 1 But but CC 37231 1867 2 if if IN 37231 1867 3 that that DT 37231 1867 4 were be VBD 37231 1867 5 the the DT 37231 1867 6 case case NN 37231 1867 7 , , , 37231 1867 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1867 9 must must MD 37231 1867 10 present present VB 37231 1867 11 the the DT 37231 1867 12 same same JJ 37231 1867 13 appearance appearance NN 37231 1867 14 to to IN 37231 1867 15 all all DT 37231 1867 16 parts part NNS 37231 1867 17 of of IN 37231 1867 18 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1867 19 , , , 37231 1867 20 with with IN 37231 1867 21 mountains mountain NNS 37231 1867 22 , , , 37231 1867 23 plains plain NNS 37231 1867 24 , , , 37231 1867 25 and and CC 37231 1867 26 seas sea NNS 37231 1867 27 , , , 37231 1867 28 and and CC 37231 1867 29 consequently consequently RB 37231 1867 30 there there EX 37231 1867 31 would would MD 37231 1867 32 be be VB 37231 1867 33 no no DT 37231 1867 34 part part NN 37231 1867 35 of of IN 37231 1867 36 the the DT 37231 1867 37 earth earth NN 37231 1867 38 uninhabited uninhabite VBN 37231 1867 39 by by IN 37231 1867 40 men man NNS 37231 1867 41 and and CC 37231 1867 42 animals animal NNS 37231 1867 43 . . . 37231 1868 1 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 37231 1868 2 does do VBZ 37231 1868 3 not not RB 37231 1868 4 know know VB 37231 1868 5 what what WP 37231 1868 6 to to TO 37231 1868 7 say say VB 37231 1868 8 to to IN 37231 1868 9 those those DT 37231 1868 10 who who WP 37231 1868 11 , , , 37231 1868 12 having have VBG 37231 1868 13 fallen fall VBN 37231 1868 14 into into IN 37231 1868 15 such such PDT 37231 1868 16 an an DT 37231 1868 17 error error NN 37231 1868 18 , , , 37231 1868 19 persevere persevere RB 37231 1868 20 in in IN 37231 1868 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1868 22 folly folly NN 37231 1868 23 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1868 24 _ _ NNP 37231 1868 25 stultitia stultitia NN 37231 1868 26 _ _ NNP 37231 1868 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1868 28 , , , 37231 1868 29 and and CC 37231 1868 30 defend defend VB 37231 1868 31 one one CD 37231 1868 32 vain vain JJ 37231 1868 33 thing thing NN 37231 1868 34 by by IN 37231 1868 35 another another DT 37231 1868 36 , , , 37231 1868 37 but but CC 37231 1868 38 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1868 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1868 40 supposes suppose VBZ 37231 1868 41 that that IN 37231 1868 42 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1868 43 philosophize philosophize VBP 37231 1868 44 in in IN 37231 1868 45 jest jest RB 37231 1868 46 , , , 37231 1868 47 or or CC 37231 1868 48 knowingly knowingly RB 37231 1868 49 defend defend VB 37231 1868 50 falsehoods falsehood NNS 37231 1868 51 to to TO 37231 1868 52 display display VB 37231 1868 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1868 54 ingenuity ingenuity NN 37231 1868 55 . . . 37231 1869 1 Space space NN 37231 1869 2 alone alone RB 37231 1869 3 prevents prevent VBZ 37231 1869 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1869 5 proving proving NN 37231 1869 6 that that IN 37231 1869 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1869 8 is be VBZ 37231 1869 9 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1869 10 for for IN 37231 1869 11 heaven heaven NNP 37231 1869 12 to to TO 37231 1869 13 be be VB 37231 1869 14 below below IN 37231 1869 15 the the DT 37231 1869 16 earth earth NN 37231 1869 17 . . . 37231 1870 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1870 2 2 2 LS 37231 1870 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1870 4 St. St. NNP 37231 1870 5 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 1870 6 , , , 37231 1870 7 with with IN 37231 1870 8 equal equal JJ 37231 1870 9 boldness boldness NN 37231 1870 10 , , , 37231 1870 11 declares declare VBZ 37231 1870 12 that that IN 37231 1870 13 the the DT 37231 1870 14 stories story NNS 37231 1870 15 told tell VBD 37231 1870 16 about about IN 37231 1870 17 the the DT 37231 1870 18 antipodes antipode NNS 37231 1870 19 , , , 37231 1870 20 that that DT 37231 1870 21 is be VBZ 37231 1870 22 to to TO 37231 1870 23 say say VB 37231 1870 24 , , , 37231 1870 25 that that IN 37231 1870 26 there there EX 37231 1870 27 are be VBP 37231 1870 28 men man NNS 37231 1870 29 whose whose WP$ 37231 1870 30 feet foot NNS 37231 1870 31 are be VBP 37231 1870 32 against against IN 37231 1870 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1870 34 footsteps footstep NNS 37231 1870 35 , , , 37231 1870 36 and and CC 37231 1870 37 upon upon IN 37231 1870 38 whom whom WP 37231 1870 39 the the DT 37231 1870 40 sun sun NN 37231 1870 41 rises rise VBZ 37231 1870 42 when when WRB 37231 1870 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1870 44 sets set VBZ 37231 1870 45 to to IN 37231 1870 46 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1870 47 , , , 37231 1870 48 are be VBP 37231 1870 49 not not RB 37231 1870 50 to to TO 37231 1870 51 be be VB 37231 1870 52 believed believe VBN 37231 1870 53 . . . 37231 1871 1 Such such PDT 37231 1871 2 an an DT 37231 1871 3 assertion assertion NN 37231 1871 4 is be VBZ 37231 1871 5 not not RB 37231 1871 6 supported support VBN 37231 1871 7 by by IN 37231 1871 8 any any DT 37231 1871 9 historical historical JJ 37231 1871 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 1871 11 , , , 37231 1871 12 { { -LRB- 37231 1871 13 137 137 CD 37231 1871 14 } } -RRB- 37231 1871 15 but but CC 37231 1871 16 rests rest VBZ 37231 1871 17 upon upon IN 37231 1871 18 mere mere JJ 37231 1871 19 conjecture conjecture NN 37231 1871 20 based base VBN 37231 1871 21 on on IN 37231 1871 22 the the DT 37231 1871 23 rotundity rotundity NN 37231 1871 24 of of IN 37231 1871 25 the the DT 37231 1871 26 earth earth NN 37231 1871 27 . . . 37231 1872 1 But but CC 37231 1872 2 those those DT 37231 1872 3 who who WP 37231 1872 4 maintain maintain VBP 37231 1872 5 such such PDT 37231 1872 6 a a DT 37231 1872 7 theory theory NN 37231 1872 8 do do VBP 37231 1872 9 not not RB 37231 1872 10 consider consider VB 37231 1872 11 that that IN 37231 1872 12 even even RB 37231 1872 13 if if IN 37231 1872 14 the the DT 37231 1872 15 earth earth NN 37231 1872 16 be be VB 37231 1872 17 round round JJ 37231 1872 18 , , , 37231 1872 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1872 20 does do VBZ 37231 1872 21 not not RB 37231 1872 22 follow follow VB 37231 1872 23 that that IN 37231 1872 24 the the DT 37231 1872 25 opposite opposite JJ 37231 1872 26 side side NN 37231 1872 27 is be VBZ 37231 1872 28 not not RB 37231 1872 29 covered cover VBN 37231 1872 30 with with IN 37231 1872 31 water water NN 37231 1872 32 . . . 37231 1873 1 Besides besides IN 37231 1873 2 , , , 37231 1873 3 if if IN 37231 1873 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1873 5 be be VB 37231 1873 6 not not RB 37231 1873 7 , , , 37231 1873 8 why why WRB 37231 1873 9 should should MD 37231 1873 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1873 11 be be VB 37231 1873 12 inhabited inhabit VBN 37231 1873 13 , , , 37231 1873 14 seeing see VBG 37231 1873 15 that that DT 37231 1873 16 on on IN 37231 1873 17 the the DT 37231 1873 18 one one CD 37231 1873 19 hand hand NN 37231 1873 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1873 21 is be VBZ 37231 1873 22 in in IN 37231 1873 23 no no DT 37231 1873 24 way way NN 37231 1873 25 possible possible JJ 37231 1873 26 that that IN 37231 1873 27 the the DT 37231 1873 28 Scriptures scripture NNS 37231 1873 29 can can MD 37231 1873 30 lie lie VB 37231 1873 31 , , , 37231 1873 32 and and CC 37231 1873 33 on on IN 37231 1873 34 the the DT 37231 1873 35 other other JJ 37231 1873 36 , , , 37231 1873 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1873 38 is be VBZ 37231 1873 39 too too RB 37231 1873 40 absurd absurd JJ 37231 1873 41 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1873 42 _ _ NNP 37231 1873 43 nimisque nimisque JJ 37231 1873 44 absurdum absurdum NN 37231 1873 45 est est NNP 37231 1873 46 _ _ NNP 37231 1873 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1873 48 to to TO 37231 1873 49 affirm affirm VB 37231 1873 50 that that IN 37231 1873 51 any any DT 37231 1873 52 men man NNS 37231 1873 53 can can MD 37231 1873 54 have have VB 37231 1873 55 traversed traverse VBN 37231 1873 56 such such PDT 37231 1873 57 an an DT 37231 1873 58 immensity immensity NN 37231 1873 59 of of IN 37231 1873 60 ocean ocean NN 37231 1873 61 to to TO 37231 1873 62 establish establish VB 37231 1873 63 the the DT 37231 1873 64 human human JJ 37231 1873 65 race race NN 37231 1873 66 there there RB 37231 1873 67 from from IN 37231 1873 68 that that DT 37231 1873 69 one one CD 37231 1873 70 first first JJ 37231 1873 71 man man NN 37231 1873 72 Adam Adam NNP 37231 1873 73 . . . 37231 1874 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1874 2 1 1 LS 37231 1874 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1874 4 Clement Clement NNP 37231 1874 5 of of IN 37231 1874 6 Rome Rome NNP 37231 1874 7 had have VBD 37231 1874 8 no no DT 37231 1874 9 doubt doubt NN 37231 1874 10 of of IN 37231 1874 11 the the DT 37231 1874 12 truth truth NN 37231 1874 13 of of IN 37231 1874 14 the the DT 37231 1874 15 story story NN 37231 1874 16 of of IN 37231 1874 17 the the DT 37231 1874 18 Phoenix,(2 Phoenix,(2 NNP 37231 1874 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1874 20 that that DT 37231 1874 21 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 1874 22 bird bird NN 37231 1874 23 of of IN 37231 1874 24 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 1874 25 and and CC 37231 1874 26 the the DT 37231 1874 27 adjoining adjoin VBG 37231 1874 28 countries country NNS 37231 1874 29 , , , 37231 1874 30 which which WDT 37231 1874 31 lives live VBZ 37231 1874 32 500 500 CD 37231 1874 33 years year NNS 37231 1874 34 ; ; : 37231 1874 35 at at IN 37231 1874 36 the the DT 37231 1874 37 end end NN 37231 1874 38 of of IN 37231 1874 39 which which WDT 37231 1874 40 time time NN 37231 1874 41 , , , 37231 1874 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1874 43 dissolution dissolution NN 37231 1874 44 being be VBG 37231 1874 45 at at IN 37231 1874 46 hand hand NN 37231 1874 47 , , , 37231 1874 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1874 49 builds build VBZ 37231 1874 50 a a DT 37231 1874 51 nest nest NN 37231 1874 52 of of IN 37231 1874 53 spices spice NNS 37231 1874 54 , , , 37231 1874 55 in in IN 37231 1874 56 which which WDT 37231 1874 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1874 58 dies die VBZ 37231 1874 59 . . . 37231 1875 1 From from IN 37231 1875 2 the the DT 37231 1875 3 decaying decay VBG 37231 1875 4 flesh flesh NN 37231 1875 5 , , , 37231 1875 6 however however RB 37231 1875 7 , , , 37231 1875 8 a a DT 37231 1875 9 worm worm NN 37231 1875 10 is be VBZ 37231 1875 11 generated generate VBN 37231 1875 12 , , , 37231 1875 13 which which WDT 37231 1875 14 being be VBG 37231 1875 15 strengthened strengthen VBN 37231 1875 16 by by IN 37231 1875 17 the the DT 37231 1875 18 juices juice NNS 37231 1875 19 of of IN 37231 1875 20 the the DT 37231 1875 21 bird bird NN 37231 1875 22 , , , 37231 1875 23 produces produce VBZ 37231 1875 24 feathers feather NNS 37231 1875 25 and and CC 37231 1875 26 is be VBZ 37231 1875 27 transformed transform VBN 37231 1875 28 into into IN 37231 1875 29 a a DT 37231 1875 30 Phoenix Phoenix NNP 37231 1875 31 . . . 37231 1876 1 Clement clement NN 37231 1876 2 adds add VBZ 37231 1876 3 that that IN 37231 1876 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1876 5 then then RB 37231 1876 6 flies fly VBZ 37231 1876 7 away away RB 37231 1876 8 with with IN 37231 1876 9 the the DT 37231 1876 10 nest nest NN 37231 1876 11 containing contain VBG 37231 1876 12 the the DT 37231 1876 13 bones bone NNS 37231 1876 14 of of IN 37231 1876 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1876 16 defunct defunct JJ 37231 1876 17 parent parent NN 37231 1876 18 to to IN 37231 1876 19 the the DT 37231 1876 20 city city NN 37231 1876 21 of of IN 37231 1876 22 Heliopolis Heliopolis NNP 37231 1876 23 in in IN 37231 1876 24 Egypt Egypt NNP 37231 1876 25 , , , 37231 1876 26 and and CC 37231 1876 27 in in IN 37231 1876 28 full full JJ 37231 1876 29 daylight daylight NN 37231 1876 30 , , , 37231 1876 31 and and CC 37231 1876 32 in in IN 37231 1876 33 the the DT 37231 1876 34 sight sight NN 37231 1876 35 of of IN 37231 1876 36 all all DT 37231 1876 37 men man NNS 37231 1876 38 , , , 37231 1876 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1876 40 lays lay VBZ 37231 1876 41 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1876 42 on on IN 37231 1876 43 the the DT 37231 1876 44 altar altar NN 37231 1876 45 of of IN 37231 1876 46 the the DT 37231 1876 47 sun sun NN 37231 1876 48 . . . 37231 1877 1 On on IN 37231 1877 2 examining examine VBG 37231 1877 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1877 4 registers register NNS 37231 1877 5 , , , 37231 1877 6 the the DT 37231 1877 7 priests priest NNS 37231 1877 8 find find VBP 37231 1877 9 that that IN 37231 1877 10 the the DT 37231 1877 11 bird bird NN 37231 1877 12 has have VBZ 37231 1877 13 returned return VBN 37231 1877 14 precisely precisely RB 37231 1877 15 at at IN 37231 1877 16 the the DT 37231 1877 17 completion completion NN 37231 1877 18 of of IN 37231 1877 19 the the DT 37231 1877 20 500 500 CD 37231 1877 21 years year NNS 37231 1877 22 . . . 37231 1878 1 This this DT 37231 1878 2 bird bird NN 37231 1878 3 , , , 37231 1878 4 Clement Clement NNP 37231 1878 5 considers consider NNS 37231 1878 6 , , , 37231 1878 7 is be VBZ 37231 1878 8 an an DT 37231 1878 9 emblem emblem NN 37231 1878 10 of of IN 37231 1878 11 the the DT 37231 1878 12 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 1878 13 . . . 37231 1879 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1879 2 1 1 LS 37231 1879 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1879 4 So so RB 37231 1879 5 does do VBZ 37231 1879 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 1879 7 , , , 37231 1879 8 who who WP 37231 1879 9 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 1879 10 the the DT 37231 1879 11 story story NN 37231 1879 12 with with IN 37231 1879 13 equal equal JJ 37231 1879 14 confidence confidence NN 37231 1879 15 . . . 37231 1880 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1880 2 2 2 LS 37231 1880 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1880 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1880 5 is be VBZ 37231 1880 6 likewise likewise RB 37231 1880 7 referred refer VBN 37231 1880 8 to to IN 37231 1880 9 in in IN 37231 1880 10 the the DT 37231 1880 11 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 1880 12 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 37231 1880 13 . . . 37231 1881 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1881 2 3 3 LS 37231 1881 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1881 4 Celsus Celsus NNP 37231 1881 5 quotes quote VBZ 37231 1881 6 the the DT 37231 1881 7 narrative narrative NN 37231 1881 8 in in IN 37231 1881 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1881 10 work work NN 37231 1881 11 against against IN 37231 1881 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1881 13 as as IN 37231 1881 14 an an DT 37231 1881 15 instance instance NN 37231 1881 16 of of IN 37231 1881 17 the the DT 37231 1881 18 piety piety NN 37231 1881 19 of of IN 37231 1881 20 irrational irrational JJ 37231 1881 21 creatures creature NNS 37231 1881 22 , , , 37231 1881 23 and and CC 37231 1881 24 although although IN 37231 1881 25 Origen Origen NNP 37231 1881 26 , , , 37231 1881 27 in in IN 37231 1881 28 reply reply NN 37231 1881 29 , , , 37231 1881 30 while while IN 37231 1881 31 admitting admit VBG 37231 1881 32 that that IN 37231 1881 33 the the DT 37231 1881 34 story story NN 37231 1881 35 is be VBZ 37231 1881 36 indeed indeed RB 37231 1881 37 recorded record VBN 37231 1881 38 , , , 37231 1881 39 puts put VBZ 37231 1881 40 in in RP 37231 1881 41 a a DT 37231 1881 42 cautious cautious JJ 37231 1881 43 " " `` 37231 1881 44 if if IN 37231 1881 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1881 46 be be VBP 37231 1881 47 true true JJ 37231 1881 48 , , , 37231 1881 49 " " '' 37231 1881 50 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1881 51 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 1881 52 to to IN 37231 1881 53 account account VB 37231 1881 54 for for IN 37231 1881 55 the the DT 37231 1881 56 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 1881 57 on on IN 37231 1881 58 the the DT 37231 1881 59 ground ground NN 37231 1881 60 that that IN 37231 1881 61 God God NNP 37231 1881 62 may may MD 37231 1881 63 have have VB 37231 1881 64 made make VBN 37231 1881 65 this this DT 37231 1881 66 isolated isolated JJ 37231 1881 67 creature creature NN 37231 1881 68 , , , 37231 1881 69 in in IN 37231 1881 70 order order NN 37231 1881 71 that that IN 37231 1881 72 men man NNS 37231 1881 73 might may MD 37231 1881 74 admire admire VB 37231 1881 75 , , , 37231 1881 76 not not RB 37231 1881 77 the the DT 37231 1881 78 bird bird NN 37231 1881 79 , , , 37231 1881 80 but but CC 37231 1881 81 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1881 82 creator creator NN 37231 1881 83 . . . 37231 1882 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1882 2 4 4 LS 37231 1882 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1882 4 Cyril Cyril NNP 37231 1882 5 of of IN 37231 1882 6 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 1882 7 , , , 37231 1882 8 likewise likewise RB 37231 1882 9 , , , 37231 1882 10 quotes quote VBZ 37231 1882 11 the the DT 37231 1882 12 story story NN 37231 1882 13 from from IN 37231 1882 14 Clement Clement NNP 37231 1882 15 . . . 37231 1883 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1883 2 5 5 LS 37231 1883 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1883 4 The the DT 37231 1883 5 author author NN 37231 1883 6 of of IN 37231 1883 7 the the DT 37231 1883 8 almost almost RB 37231 1883 9 canonical canonical JJ 37231 1883 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 1883 11 of of IN 37231 1883 12 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 1883 13 , , , 37231 1883 14 explaining explain VBG 37231 1883 15 the the DT 37231 1883 16 typical typical JJ 37231 1883 17 meaning meaning NN 37231 1883 18 of of IN 37231 1883 19 the the DT 37231 1883 20 code code NN 37231 1883 21 of of IN 37231 1883 22 Moses Moses NNP 37231 1883 23 regarding regard VBG 37231 1883 24 clean clean JJ 37231 1883 25 and and CC 37231 1883 26 unclean unclean JJ 37231 1883 27 animals animal NNS 37231 1883 28 which which WDT 37231 1883 29 were be VBD 37231 1883 30 or or CC 37231 1883 31 were be VBD 37231 1883 32 not not RB 37231 1883 33 to to TO 37231 1883 34 be be VB 37231 1883 35 eaten eat VBN 37231 1883 36 , , , 37231 1883 37 states state NNS 37231 1883 38 as as IN 37231 1883 39 a a DT 37231 1883 40 fact fact NN 37231 1883 41 that that IN 37231 1883 42 the the DT 37231 1883 43 hare hare NN 37231 1883 44 annually annually RB 37231 1883 45 increases increase VBZ 37231 1883 46 the the DT 37231 1883 47 number number NN 37231 1883 48 of of IN 37231 1883 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1883 50 _ _ NNP 37231 1883 51 foramina foramina NN 37231 1883 52 _ _ NNP 37231 1883 53 , , , 37231 1883 54 for for IN 37231 1883 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1883 56 has have VBZ 37231 1883 57 as as RB 37231 1883 58 many many JJ 37231 1883 59 as as IN 37231 1883 60 the the DT 37231 1883 61 years year NNS 37231 1883 62 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1883 63 lives live VBZ 37231 1883 64 . . . 37231 1884 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1884 2 6 6 CD 37231 1884 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1884 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1884 5 also also RB 37231 1884 6 mentions mention VBZ 37231 1884 7 that that IN 37231 1884 8 the the DT 37231 1884 9 hyena hyena NN 37231 1884 10 changes change VBZ 37231 1884 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1884 12 sex sex NN 37231 1884 13 every every DT 37231 1884 14 year year NN 37231 1884 15 , , , 37231 1884 16 being be VBG 37231 1884 17 alternately alternately RB 37231 1884 18 male male JJ 37231 1884 19 and and CC 37231 1884 20 female female JJ 37231 1884 21 . . . 37231 1885 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1885 2 7 7 LS 37231 1885 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1885 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 1885 5 also also RB 37231 1885 6 points point VBZ 37231 1885 7 out out RP 37231 1885 8 as as IN 37231 1885 9 a a DT 37231 1885 10 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1885 11 fact fact NN 37231 1885 12 the the DT 37231 1885 13 annual annual JJ 37231 1885 14 change change NN 37231 1885 15 of of IN 37231 1885 16 sex sex NN 37231 1885 17 of of IN 37231 1885 18 the the DT 37231 1885 19 hyena hyena NN 37231 1885 20 , , , 37231 1885 21 and and CC 37231 1885 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1885 23 adds add VBZ 37231 1885 24 : : : 37231 1885 25 " " `` 37231 1885 26 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1885 27 do do VBP 37231 1885 28 not not RB 37231 1885 29 mention mention VB 37231 1885 30 the the DT 37231 1885 31 stag stag JJ 37231 1885 32 , , , 37231 1885 33 since since IN 37231 1885 34 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 1885 35 is be VBZ 37231 1885 36 the the DT 37231 1885 37 witness witness NN 37231 1885 38 of of IN 37231 1885 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1885 40 own own JJ 37231 1885 41 age age NN 37231 1885 42 ; ; , 37231 1885 43 feeding feed VBG 37231 1885 44 on on IN 37231 1885 45 the the DT 37231 1885 46 serpent serpent NN 37231 1885 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1885 48 languishes languish VBZ 37231 1885 49 into into IN 37231 1885 50 youth youth NN 37231 1885 51 from from IN 37231 1885 52 the the DT 37231 1885 53 working working NN 37231 1885 54 of of IN 37231 1885 55 the the DT 37231 1885 56 poison poison NN 37231 1885 57 . . . 37231 1886 1 " " `` 37231 1886 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1886 3 8 8 LS 37231 1886 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1886 5 The the DT 37231 1886 6 geocentric geocentric JJ 37231 1886 7 { { -LRB- 37231 1886 8 139 139 CD 37231 1886 9 } } -RRB- 37231 1886 10 theory theory NN 37231 1886 11 of of IN 37231 1886 12 the the DT 37231 1886 13 Church Church NNP 37231 1886 14 , , , 37231 1886 15 which which WDT 37231 1886 16 elevated elevate VBD 37231 1886 17 man man NN 37231 1886 18 into into IN 37231 1886 19 the the DT 37231 1886 20 supreme supreme NNP 37231 1886 21 place place NNP 37231 1886 22 in in IN 37231 1886 23 the the DT 37231 1886 24 universe universe NN 37231 1886 25 , , , 37231 1886 26 and and CC 37231 1886 27 considered consider VBN 37231 1886 28 creation creation NN 37231 1886 29 in in IN 37231 1886 30 general general JJ 37231 1886 31 to to TO 37231 1886 32 be be VB 37231 1886 33 solely solely RB 37231 1886 34 for for IN 37231 1886 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1886 36 use use NN 37231 1886 37 , , , 37231 1886 38 naturally naturally RB 37231 1886 39 led lead VBD 37231 1886 40 to to IN 37231 1886 41 the the DT 37231 1886 42 misinterpretation misinterpretation NN 37231 1886 43 of of IN 37231 1886 44 all all DT 37231 1886 45 cosmical cosmical JJ 37231 1886 46 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1886 47 . . . 37231 1887 1 Such such JJ 37231 1887 2 spectacles spectacle NNS 37231 1887 3 as as IN 37231 1887 4 eclipses eclipse NNS 37231 1887 5 and and CC 37231 1887 6 comets comet NNS 37231 1887 7 were be VBD 37231 1887 8 universally universally RB 37231 1887 9 regarded regard VBN 37231 1887 10 as as IN 37231 1887 11 awful awful JJ 37231 1887 12 portents portent NNS 37231 1887 13 of of IN 37231 1887 14 impending impending JJ 37231 1887 15 evil evil NN 37231 1887 16 , , , 37231 1887 17 signs sign NNS 37231 1887 18 of of IN 37231 1887 19 God God NNP 37231 1887 20 's 's POS 37231 1887 21 anger anger NN 37231 1887 22 , , , 37231 1887 23 and and CC 37231 1887 24 forerunners forerunner NNS 37231 1887 25 of of IN 37231 1887 26 national national JJ 37231 1887 27 calamities calamity NNS 37231 1887 28 . . . 37231 1888 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1888 2 1 1 LS 37231 1888 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1888 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1888 5 have have VBP 37231 1888 6 already already RB 37231 1888 7 referred refer VBN 37231 1888 8 to to IN 37231 1888 9 the the DT 37231 1888 10 account account NN 37231 1888 11 given give VBN 37231 1888 12 by by IN 37231 1888 13 Josephus Josephus NNP 37231 1888 14 of of IN 37231 1888 15 the the DT 37231 1888 16 portents portent NNS 37231 1888 17 which which WDT 37231 1888 18 were be VBD 37231 1888 19 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1888 20 to to TO 37231 1888 21 announce announce VB 37231 1888 22 the the DT 37231 1888 23 coming come VBG 37231 1888 24 destruction destruction NN 37231 1888 25 of of IN 37231 1888 26 the the DT 37231 1888 27 Holy Holy NNP 37231 1888 28 City City NNP 37231 1888 29 , , , 37231 1888 30 amongst amongst IN 37231 1888 31 which which WDT 37231 1888 32 were be VBD 37231 1888 33 a a DT 37231 1888 34 star star NN 37231 1888 35 shaped shape VBN 37231 1888 36 like like IN 37231 1888 37 a a DT 37231 1888 38 sword sword NN 37231 1888 39 , , , 37231 1888 40 a a DT 37231 1888 41 comet comet NN 37231 1888 42 , , , 37231 1888 43 and and CC 37231 1888 44 other other JJ 37231 1888 45 celestial celestial JJ 37231 1888 46 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1888 47 . . . 37231 1889 1 Volcanoes volcano NNS 37231 1889 2 were be VBD 37231 1889 3 considered consider VBN 37231 1889 4 openings opening NNS 37231 1889 5 into into IN 37231 1889 6 hell hell NNP 37231 1889 7 , , , 37231 1889 8 and and CC 37231 1889 9 not not RB 37231 1889 10 only only RB 37231 1889 11 does do VBZ 37231 1889 12 Ter Ter NNP 37231 1889 13 - - HYPH 37231 1889 14 tullian tullian NNP 37231 1889 15 hold hold VB 37231 1889 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1889 17 to to TO 37231 1889 18 be be VB 37231 1889 19 so so RB 37231 1889 20 , , , 37231 1889 21 but but CC 37231 1889 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1889 23 asks ask VBZ 37231 1889 24 who who WP 37231 1889 25 will will MD 37231 1889 26 not not RB 37231 1889 27 deem deem VB 37231 1889 28 these these DT 37231 1889 29 punishments punishment NNS 37231 1889 30 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 1889 31 inflicted inflict VBN 37231 1889 32 upon upon IN 37231 1889 33 mountains mountain NNS 37231 1889 34 as as IN 37231 1889 35 examples example NNS 37231 1889 36 of of IN 37231 1889 37 the the DT 37231 1889 38 judgments judgment NNS 37231 1889 39 which which WDT 37231 1889 40 menace menace VBP 37231 1889 41 the the DT 37231 1889 42 wicked wicked JJ 37231 1889 43 . . . 37231 1890 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1890 2 2 2 LS 37231 1890 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1890 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 1890 5 V. V. NNP 37231 1890 6 THE the DT 37231 1890 7 PERMANENT PERMANENT NNP 37231 1890 8 STREAM STREAM NNP 37231 1890 9 OF of IN 37231 1890 10 MIRACULOUS miraculous JJ 37231 1890 11 PRETENSION PRETENSION NNP 37231 1890 12 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1890 13 have have VBP 37231 1890 14 given give VBN 37231 1890 15 a a DT 37231 1890 16 most most RBS 37231 1890 17 imperfect imperfect JJ 37231 1890 18 sketch sketch NN 37231 1890 19 of of IN 37231 1890 20 some some DT 37231 1890 21 of of IN 37231 1890 22 the the DT 37231 1890 23 opinions opinion NNS 37231 1890 24 and and CC 37231 1890 25 superstitions superstition NNS 37231 1890 26 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 1890 27 at at IN 37231 1890 28 the the DT 37231 1890 29 time time NN 37231 1890 30 of of IN 37231 1890 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1890 32 , , , 37231 1890 33 and and CC 37231 1890 34 when when WRB 37231 1890 35 the the DT 37231 1890 36 books book NNS 37231 1890 37 of of IN 37231 1890 38 the the DT 37231 1890 39 New New NNP 37231 1890 40 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1890 41 were be VBD 37231 1890 42 written write VBN 37231 1890 43 . . . 37231 1891 1 These these DT 37231 1891 2 , , , 37231 1891 3 as as IN 37231 1891 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1891 5 have have VBP 37231 1891 6 seen see VBN 37231 1891 7 , , , 37231 1891 8 continued continue VBN 37231 1891 9 with with IN 37231 1891 10 little little JJ 37231 1891 11 or or CC 37231 1891 12 no no DT 37231 1891 13 modification modification NN 37231 1891 14 throughout throughout IN 37231 1891 15 the the DT 37231 1891 16 first first JJ 37231 1891 17 centuries century NNS 37231 1891 18 of of IN 37231 1891 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1891 20 era era NN 37231 1891 21 . . . 37231 1892 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1892 2 must must MD 37231 1892 3 , , , 37231 1892 4 however however RB 37231 1892 5 , , , 37231 1892 6 be be VB 37231 1892 7 remembered remember VBN 37231 1892 8 that that IN 37231 1892 9 the the DT 37231 1892 10 few few JJ 37231 1892 11 details detail NNS 37231 1892 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1892 13 have have VBP 37231 1892 14 given give VBN 37231 1892 15 , , , 37231 1892 16 omitting omit VBG 37231 1892 17 most most JJS 37231 1892 18 of of IN 37231 1892 19 the the DT 37231 1892 20 grosser gross JJR 37231 1892 21 particulars particular NNS 37231 1892 22 , , , 37231 1892 23 are be VBP 37231 1892 24 the the DT 37231 1892 25 views view NNS 37231 1892 26 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 1892 27 expressed express VBN 37231 1892 28 by by IN 37231 1892 29 the the DT 37231 1892 30 most most RBS 37231 1892 31 educated educated JJ 37231 1892 32 and and CC 37231 1892 33 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 1892 34 part part NN 37231 1892 35 of of IN 37231 1892 36 the the DT 37231 1892 37 community community NN 37231 1892 38 , , , 37231 1892 39 and and CC 37231 1892 40 that that IN 37231 1892 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1892 42 would would MD 37231 1892 43 have have VB 37231 1892 44 required require VBN 37231 1892 45 infinitely infinitely RB 37231 1892 46 darker dark JJR 37231 1892 47 colours colour NNS 37231 1892 48 adequately adequately RB 37231 1892 49 to to TO 37231 1892 50 have have VB 37231 1892 51 portrayed portray VBN 37231 1892 52 the the DT 37231 1892 53 dense dense JJ 37231 1892 54 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1892 55 and and CC 37231 1892 56 superstition superstition NN 37231 1892 57 of of IN 37231 1892 58 the the DT 37231 1892 59 mass mass NN 37231 1892 60 of of IN 37231 1892 61 the the DT 37231 1892 62 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1892 63 . . . 37231 1893 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1893 2 is be VBZ 37231 1893 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1893 4 to to TO 37231 1893 5 receive receive VB 37231 1893 6 the the DT 37231 1893 7 report report NN 37231 1893 8 of of IN 37231 1893 9 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1893 10 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 1893 11 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1893 12 from from IN 37231 1893 13 an an DT 37231 1893 14 age age NN 37231 1893 15 and and CC 37231 1893 16 people people NNS 37231 1893 17 like like IN 37231 1893 18 this this DT 37231 1893 19 without without IN 37231 1893 20 the the DT 37231 1893 21 gravest grave JJS 37231 1893 22 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 1893 23 . . . 37231 1894 1 Even even RB 37231 1894 2 so so RB 37231 1894 3 thorough thorough JJ 37231 1894 4 a a DT 37231 1894 5 defender defender NN 37231 1894 6 of of IN 37231 1894 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1894 8 as as IN 37231 1894 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1894 10 Newman Newman NNP 37231 1894 11 admits admit VBZ 37231 1894 12 that that IN 37231 1894 13 : : : 37231 1894 14 " " `` 37231 1894 15 Witnesses witness NNS 37231 1894 16 must must MD 37231 1894 17 be be VB 37231 1894 18 not not RB 37231 1894 19 only only RB 37231 1894 20 honest honest JJ 37231 1894 21 , , , 37231 1894 22 but but CC 37231 1894 23 competent competent JJ 37231 1894 24 also also RB 37231 1894 25 ; ; : 37231 1894 26 that that RB 37231 1894 27 is is RB 37231 1894 28 , , , 37231 1894 29 such such JJ 37231 1894 30 as as IN 37231 1894 31 have have VBP 37231 1894 32 ascertained ascertain VBN 37231 1894 33 the the DT 37231 1894 34 facts fact NNS 37231 1894 35 which which WDT 37231 1894 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1894 37 attest attest VBP 37231 1894 38 , , , 37231 1894 39 or or CC 37231 1894 40 who who WP 37231 1894 41 report report VBP 37231 1894 42 after after IN 37231 1894 43 examination;"l examination;"l NNS 37231 1894 44 and and CC 37231 1894 45 although although IN 37231 1894 46 the the DT 37231 1894 47 necessities necessity NNS 37231 1894 48 of of IN 37231 1894 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1894 50 case case NN 37231 1894 51 oblige oblige VB 37231 1894 52 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1894 53 to to TO 37231 1894 54 assert assert VB 37231 1894 55 that that IN 37231 1894 56 " " `` 37231 1894 57 the the DT 37231 1894 58 testimony testimony NN 37231 1894 59 of of IN 37231 1894 60 men man NNS 37231 1894 61 of of IN 37231 1894 62 science science NN 37231 1894 63 and and CC 37231 1894 64 general general JJ 37231 1894 65 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 1894 66 " " '' 37231 1894 67 must must MD 37231 1894 68 not not RB 37231 1894 69 be be VB 37231 1894 70 required require VBN 37231 1894 71 , , , 37231 1894 72 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1894 73 admits admit VBZ 37231 1894 74 , , , 37231 1894 75 under under IN 37231 1894 76 the the DT 37231 1894 77 head head NN 37231 1894 78 of of IN 37231 1894 79 " " `` 37231 1894 80 deficiency deficiency NN 37231 1894 81 of of IN 37231 1894 82 examination examination NN 37231 1894 83 , , , 37231 1894 84 " " '' 37231 1894 85 that--"Enthusiasm that--"enthusiasm NN 37231 1894 86 , , , 37231 1894 87 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1894 88 , , , 37231 1894 89 and and CC 37231 1894 90 habitual habitual JJ 37231 1894 91 credulity credulity NN 37231 1894 92 { { -LRB- 37231 1894 93 141 141 CD 37231 1894 94 } } -RRB- 37231 1894 95 are be VBP 37231 1894 96 defects defect NNS 37231 1894 97 which which WDT 37231 1894 98 no no DT 37231 1894 99 number number NN 37231 1894 100 of of IN 37231 1894 101 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1894 102 removes remove NNS 37231 1894 103 . . . 37231 1895 1 " " `` 37231 1895 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1895 3 1 1 LS 37231 1895 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1895 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1895 6 have have VBP 37231 1895 7 shown show VBN 37231 1895 8 how how WRB 37231 1895 9 rank rank NN 37231 1895 10 were be VBD 37231 1895 11 these these DT 37231 1895 12 " " `` 37231 1895 13 defects defect NNS 37231 1895 14 " " '' 37231 1895 15 at at IN 37231 1895 16 the the DT 37231 1895 17 commencement commencement NN 37231 1895 18 of of IN 37231 1895 19 the the DT 37231 1895 20 Christian christian JJ 37231 1895 21 era era NN 37231 1895 22 , , , 37231 1895 23 and and CC 37231 1895 24 among among IN 37231 1895 25 the the DT 37231 1895 26 chief chief JJ 37231 1895 27 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1895 28 for for IN 37231 1895 29 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1895 30 . . . 37231 1896 1 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 1896 2 which which WDT 37231 1896 3 spring spring VBP 37231 1896 4 from from IN 37231 1896 5 such such PDT 37231 1896 6 a a DT 37231 1896 7 hot hot JJ 37231 1896 8 - - HYPH 37231 1896 9 bed bed NN 37231 1896 10 of of IN 37231 1896 11 superstition superstition NN 37231 1896 12 are be VBP 37231 1896 13 too too RB 37231 1896 14 natural natural JJ 37231 1896 15 in in IN 37231 1896 16 such such PDT 37231 1896 17 a a DT 37231 1896 18 soil soil NN 37231 1896 19 to to TO 37231 1896 20 be be VB 37231 1896 21 objects object NNS 37231 1896 22 of of IN 37231 1896 23 surprise surprise NN 37231 1896 24 and and CC 37231 1896 25 , , , 37231 1896 26 in in IN 37231 1896 27 losing lose VBG 37231 1896 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1896 29 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 1896 30 character character NN 37231 1896 31 , , , 37231 1896 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1896 33 claims claim NNS 37231 1896 34 upon upon IN 37231 1896 35 attention attention NN 37231 1896 36 are be VBP 37231 1896 37 proportionately proportionately RB 37231 1896 38 weakened weaken VBN 37231 1896 39 if if IN 37231 1896 40 not not RB 37231 1896 41 altogether altogether RB 37231 1896 42 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 1896 43 . . . 37231 1897 1 Preternatural preternatural JJ 37231 1897 2 interference interference NN 37231 1897 3 with with IN 37231 1897 4 the the DT 37231 1897 5 affairs affair NNS 37231 1897 6 of of IN 37231 1897 7 life life NN 37231 1897 8 and and CC 37231 1897 9 the the DT 37231 1897 10 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 1897 11 of of IN 37231 1897 12 nature nature NN 37231 1897 13 was be VBD 37231 1897 14 the the DT 37231 1897 15 rule rule NN 37231 1897 16 in in IN 37231 1897 17 those those DT 37231 1897 18 days day NNS 37231 1897 19 , , , 37231 1897 20 not not RB 37231 1897 21 the the DT 37231 1897 22 exception exception NN 37231 1897 23 , , , 37231 1897 24 and and CC 37231 1897 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1897 26 , , , 37231 1897 27 in in IN 37231 1897 28 fact fact NN 37231 1897 29 , , , 37231 1897 30 had have VBD 37231 1897 31 lost lose VBN 37231 1897 32 all all DT 37231 1897 33 novelty novelty NN 37231 1897 34 , , , 37231 1897 35 and and CC 37231 1897 36 through through IN 37231 1897 37 familiarity familiarity NN 37231 1897 38 had have VBD 37231 1897 39 become become VBN 37231 1897 40 degraded degraded JJ 37231 1897 41 into into IN 37231 1897 42 mere mere JJ 37231 1897 43 commonplace commonplace NN 37231 1897 44 . . . 37231 1898 1 The the DT 37231 1898 2 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1898 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1898 4 were be VBD 37231 1898 5 not not RB 37231 1898 6 original original JJ 37231 1898 7 in in IN 37231 1898 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1898 9 character character NN 37231 1898 10 , , , 37231 1898 11 but but CC 37231 1898 12 were be VBD 37231 1898 13 substantially substantially RB 37231 1898 14 mere mere JJ 37231 1898 15 repetitions repetition NNS 37231 1898 16 of of IN 37231 1898 17 similar similar JJ 37231 1898 18 wonders wonder NNS 37231 1898 19 well well RB 37231 1898 20 known know VBN 37231 1898 21 amongst amongst IN 37231 1898 22 the the DT 37231 1898 23 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1898 24 , , , 37231 1898 25 or or CC 37231 1898 26 commonly commonly RB 37231 1898 27 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1898 28 to to TO 37231 1898 29 be be VB 37231 1898 30 of of IN 37231 1898 31 daily daily JJ 37231 1898 32 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1898 33 even even RB 37231 1898 34 at at IN 37231 1898 35 that that DT 37231 1898 36 time time NN 37231 1898 37 . . . 37231 1899 1 In in IN 37231 1899 2 fact fact NN 37231 1899 3 , , , 37231 1899 4 the the DT 37231 1899 5 idea idea NN 37231 1899 6 of of IN 37231 1899 7 such such JJ 37231 1899 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1899 9 , , , 37231 1899 10 in in IN 37231 1899 11 such such PDT 37231 1899 12 an an DT 37231 1899 13 age age NN 37231 1899 14 and and CC 37231 1899 15 performed perform VBN 37231 1899 16 amongst amongst IN 37231 1899 17 such such PDT 37231 1899 18 a a DT 37231 1899 19 people people NNS 37231 1899 20 , , , 37231 1899 21 as as IN 37231 1899 22 the the DT 37231 1899 23 attestation attestation NN 37231 1899 24 of of IN 37231 1899 25 a a DT 37231 1899 26 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1899 27 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1899 28 , , , 37231 1899 29 may may MD 37231 1899 30 with with IN 37231 1899 31 singular singular JJ 37231 1899 32 propriety propriety NN 37231 1899 33 be be VB 37231 1899 34 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1899 35 to to IN 37231 1899 36 the the DT 37231 1899 37 mind mind NN 37231 1899 38 of of IN 37231 1899 39 that that DT 37231 1899 40 period period NN 37231 1899 41 , , , 37231 1899 42 but but CC 37231 1899 43 can can MD 37231 1899 44 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1899 45 be be VB 37231 1899 46 said say VBN 37231 1899 47 to to TO 37231 1899 48 bear bear VB 37231 1899 49 any any DT 37231 1899 50 traces trace NNS 37231 1899 51 of of IN 37231 1899 52 the the DT 37231 1899 53 divine divine JJ 37231 1899 54 . . . 37231 1900 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 1900 2 , , , 37231 1900 3 anticipating anticipate VBG 37231 1900 4 for for IN 37231 1900 5 a a DT 37231 1900 6 moment moment NN 37231 1900 7 a a DT 37231 1900 8 part part NN 37231 1900 9 of of IN 37231 1900 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1900 11 subject subject NN 37231 1900 12 regarding regard VBG 37231 1900 13 which which WDT 37231 1900 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1900 15 shall shall MD 37231 1900 16 have have VB 37231 1900 17 more more JJR 37231 1900 18 to to TO 37231 1900 19 say say VB 37231 1900 20 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 1900 21 , , , 37231 1900 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1900 23 may may MD 37231 1900 24 remark remark VB 37231 1900 25 that that DT 37231 1900 26 , , , 37231 1900 27 so so RB 37231 1900 28 far far RB 37231 1900 29 from from IN 37231 1900 30 being be VBG 37231 1900 31 original original JJ 37231 1900 32 either either CC 37231 1900 33 in in IN 37231 1900 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1900 35 evidence evidence NN 37231 1900 36 or or CC 37231 1900 37 form form NN 37231 1900 38 , , , 37231 1900 39 almost almost RB 37231 1900 40 every every DT 37231 1900 41 religion religion NN 37231 1900 42 which which WDT 37231 1900 43 has have VBZ 37231 1900 44 been be VBN 37231 1900 45 taught teach VBN 37231 1900 46 in in IN 37231 1900 47 the the DT 37231 1900 48 world world NN 37231 1900 49 has have VBZ 37231 1900 50 claimed claim VBN 37231 1900 51 the the DT 37231 1900 52 same same JJ 37231 1900 53 divine divine JJ 37231 1900 54 character character NN 37231 1900 55 as as IN 37231 1900 56 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1900 57 , , , 37231 1900 58 and and CC 37231 1900 59 has have VBZ 37231 1900 60 surrounded surround VBN 37231 1900 61 the the DT 37231 1900 62 person person NN 37231 1900 63 and and CC 37231 1900 64 origin origin NN 37231 1900 65 of of IN 37231 1900 66 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1900 67 central central JJ 37231 1900 68 figure figure NN 37231 1900 69 with with IN 37231 1900 70 the the DT 37231 1900 71 same same JJ 37231 1900 72 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1900 73 mystery mystery NN 37231 1900 74 . . . 37231 1901 1 Even even RB 37231 1901 2 the the DT 37231 1901 3 great great JJ 37231 1901 4 heroes hero NNS 37231 1901 5 of of IN 37231 1901 6 history history NN 37231 1901 7 , , , 37231 1901 8 long long RB 37231 1901 9 before before IN 37231 1901 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1901 11 era era NN 37231 1901 12 , , , 37231 1901 13 had have VBD 37231 1901 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1901 15 immaculate immaculate JJ 37231 1901 16 conception conception NN 37231 1901 17 and and CC 37231 1901 18 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1901 19 birth birth NN 37231 1901 20 . . . 37231 1902 1 There there EX 37231 1902 2 can can MD 37231 1902 3 be be VB 37231 1902 4 no no DT 37231 1902 5 doubt doubt NN 37231 1902 6 that that IN 37231 1902 7 the the DT 37231 1902 8 writers writer NNS 37231 1902 9 of of IN 37231 1902 10 the the DT 37231 1902 11 New New NNP 37231 1902 12 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1902 13 shared share VBD 37231 1902 14 the the DT 37231 1902 15 popular popular JJ 37231 1902 16 superstitions superstition NNS 37231 1902 17 of of IN 37231 1902 18 the the DT 37231 1902 19 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1902 20 . . . 37231 1903 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1903 2 142 142 CD 37231 1903 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1903 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1903 5 have have VBP 37231 1903 6 already already RB 37231 1903 7 given give VBN 37231 1903 8 more more JJR 37231 1903 9 than than IN 37231 1903 10 one one CD 37231 1903 11 instance instance NN 37231 1903 12 of of IN 37231 1903 13 this this DT 37231 1903 14 , , , 37231 1903 15 and and CC 37231 1903 16 now now RB 37231 1903 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1903 18 have have VBP 37231 1903 19 only only RB 37231 1903 20 to to TO 37231 1903 21 refer refer VB 37231 1903 22 for for IN 37231 1903 23 a a DT 37231 1903 24 moment moment NN 37231 1903 25 to to IN 37231 1903 26 one one CD 37231 1903 27 class class NN 37231 1903 28 of of IN 37231 1903 29 these these DT 37231 1903 30 superstitions superstition NNS 37231 1903 31 , , , 37231 1903 32 the the DT 37231 1903 33 belief belief NN 37231 1903 34 in in IN 37231 1903 35 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1903 36 possession possession NN 37231 1903 37 and and CC 37231 1903 38 origin origin NN 37231 1903 39 of of IN 37231 1903 40 disease disease NNP 37231 1903 41 , , , 37231 1903 42 involving involve VBG 37231 1903 43 clearly clearly RB 37231 1903 44 both both CC 37231 1903 45 the the DT 37231 1903 46 existence existence NN 37231 1903 47 of of IN 37231 1903 48 demons demon NNS 37231 1903 49 and and CC 37231 1903 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1903 51 power power NN 37231 1903 52 over over IN 37231 1903 53 the the DT 37231 1903 54 human human JJ 37231 1903 55 race race NN 37231 1903 56 . . . 37231 1904 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1904 2 would would MD 37231 1904 3 be be VB 37231 1904 4 an an DT 37231 1904 5 insult insult NN 37231 1904 6 to to IN 37231 1904 7 the the DT 37231 1904 8 understanding understanding NN 37231 1904 9 of of IN 37231 1904 10 those those DT 37231 1904 11 who who WP 37231 1904 12 are be VBP 37231 1904 13 considering consider VBG 37231 1904 14 this this DT 37231 1904 15 question question NN 37231 1904 16 to to TO 37231 1904 17 pause pause VB 37231 1904 18 here here RB 37231 1904 19 to to TO 37231 1904 20 prove prove VB 37231 1904 21 that that IN 37231 1904 22 the the DT 37231 1904 23 historical historical JJ 37231 1904 24 books book NNS 37231 1904 25 of of IN 37231 1904 26 the the DT 37231 1904 27 New New NNP 37231 1904 28 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1904 29 speak speak NN 37231 1904 30 in in IN 37231 1904 31 the the DT 37231 1904 32 clearest clear JJS 37231 1904 33 and and CC 37231 1904 34 most most RBS 37231 1904 35 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 37231 1904 36 terms term NNS 37231 1904 37 of of IN 37231 1904 38 actual actual JJ 37231 1904 39 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1904 40 possession possession NN 37231 1904 41 . . . 37231 1905 1 Now now RB 37231 1905 2 , , , 37231 1905 3 what what WP 37231 1905 4 has have VBZ 37231 1905 5 become become VBN 37231 1905 6 of of IN 37231 1905 7 this this DT 37231 1905 8 theory theory NN 37231 1905 9 of of IN 37231 1905 10 disease disease NN 37231 1905 11 ? ? . 37231 1906 1 The the DT 37231 1906 2 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1906 3 of of IN 37231 1906 4 Dublin Dublin NNP 37231 1906 5 is be VBZ 37231 1906 6 probably probably RB 37231 1906 7 the the DT 37231 1906 8 only only JJ 37231 1906 9 one one CD 37231 1906 10 who who WP 37231 1906 11 asserts assert VBZ 37231 1906 12 the the DT 37231 1906 13 reality reality NN 37231 1906 14 of of IN 37231 1906 15 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1906 16 possession possession NN 37231 1906 17 formerly formerly RB 37231 1906 18 and and CC 37231 1906 19 at at IN 37231 1906 20 the the DT 37231 1906 21 present present JJ 37231 1906 22 day,(1 day,(1 NNP 37231 1906 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1906 24 and and CC 37231 1906 25 in in IN 37231 1906 26 this this DT 37231 1906 27 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1906 28 must must MD 37231 1906 29 say say VB 37231 1906 30 that that IN 37231 1906 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1906 32 is be VBZ 37231 1906 33 consistent consistent JJ 37231 1906 34 . . . 37231 1907 1 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1907 2 Milman Milman NNP 37231 1907 3 , , , 37231 1907 4 on on IN 37231 1907 5 the the DT 37231 1907 6 other other JJ 37231 1907 7 hand hand NN 37231 1907 8 , , , 37231 1907 9 who who WP 37231 1907 10 spoke speak VBD 37231 1907 11 with with IN 37231 1907 12 the the DT 37231 1907 13 enlightenment enlightenment NN 37231 1907 14 of of IN 37231 1907 15 the the DT 37231 1907 16 19th 19th JJ 37231 1907 17 century century NN 37231 1907 18 , , , 37231 1907 19 " " '' 37231 1907 20 has have VBZ 37231 1907 21 no no DT 37231 1907 22 scruple scruple NN 37231 1907 23 in in IN 37231 1907 24 avowing avow VBG 37231 1907 25 _ _ NNP 37231 1907 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1907 27 _ _ NNP 37231 1907 28 opinion opinion NN 37231 1907 29 on on IN 37231 1907 30 the the DT 37231 1907 31 subject subject NN 37231 1907 32 of of IN 37231 1907 33 demoniacs demoniac NNS 37231 1907 34 to to TO 37231 1907 35 be be VB 37231 1907 36 that that DT 37231 1907 37 of of IN 37231 1907 38 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 1907 39 Mede Mede NNP 37231 1907 40 , , , 37231 1907 41 Lardner Lardner NNP 37231 1907 42 , , , 37231 1907 43 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1907 44 Mead Mead NNP 37231 1907 45 , , , 37231 1907 46 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1907 47 , , , 37231 1907 48 and and CC 37231 1907 49 all all PDT 37231 1907 50 the the DT 37231 1907 51 learned learn VBN 37231 1907 52 modern modern JJ 37231 1907 53 writers writer NNS 37231 1907 54 . . . 37231 1908 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1908 2 was be VBD 37231 1908 3 a a DT 37231 1908 4 kind kind NN 37231 1908 5 of of IN 37231 1908 6 insanity insanity NN 37231 1908 7 .... .... NFP 37231 1908 8 and and CC 37231 1908 9 nothing nothing NN 37231 1908 10 was be VBD 37231 1908 11 more more RBR 37231 1908 12 probable probable JJ 37231 1908 13 than than IN 37231 1908 14 that that DT 37231 1908 15 lunacy lunacy NN 37231 1908 16 should should MD 37231 1908 17 take take VB 37231 1908 18 the the DT 37231 1908 19 turn turn NN 37231 1908 20 and and CC 37231 1908 21 speak speak VB 37231 1908 22 the the DT 37231 1908 23 language language NN 37231 1908 24 of of IN 37231 1908 25 the the DT 37231 1908 26 prevailing prevail VBG 37231 1908 27 superstition superstition NN 37231 1908 28 of of IN 37231 1908 29 the the DT 37231 1908 30 times time NNS 37231 1908 31 . . . 37231 1909 1 " " `` 37231 1909 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1909 3 2 2 LS 37231 1909 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1909 5 The the DT 37231 1909 6 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1909 7 , , , 37231 1909 8 as as RB 37231 1909 9 well well RB 37231 1909 10 as as IN 37231 1909 11 " " `` 37231 1909 12 all all PDT 37231 1909 13 the the DT 37231 1909 14 learned learn VBN 37231 1909 15 modern modern JJ 37231 1909 16 writers writer NNS 37231 1909 17 " " '' 37231 1909 18 to to TO 37231 1909 19 whom whom WP 37231 1909 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1909 21 refers refer VBZ 37231 1909 22 , , , 37231 1909 23 felt feel VBD 37231 1909 24 the the DT 37231 1909 25 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 1909 26 , , , 37231 1909 27 but but CC 37231 1909 28 in in IN 37231 1909 29 seeking seek VBG 37231 1909 30 to to TO 37231 1909 31 evade evade VB 37231 1909 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1909 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1909 34 sacrifice sacrifice VBP 37231 1909 35 the the DT 37231 1909 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1909 37 . . . 37231 1910 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1910 2 overlook overlook VBP 37231 1910 3 the the DT 37231 1910 4 fact fact NN 37231 1910 5 that that IN 37231 1910 6 the the DT 37231 1910 7 writers writer NNS 37231 1910 8 of of IN 37231 1910 9 these these DT 37231 1910 10 narratives narrative NNS 37231 1910 11 not not RB 37231 1910 12 only only RB 37231 1910 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 1910 14 adopt adopt VBP 37231 1910 15 " " `` 37231 1910 16 the the DT 37231 1910 17 prevailing prevail VBG 37231 1910 18 superstition superstition NN 37231 1910 19 of of IN 37231 1910 20 the the DT 37231 1910 21 times time NNS 37231 1910 22 , , , 37231 1910 23 " " '' 37231 1910 24 but but CC 37231 1910 25 represent represent VB 37231 1910 26 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1910 27 as as IN 37231 1910 28 doing do VBG 37231 1910 29 so so RB 37231 1910 30 with with IN 37231 1910 31 equal equal JJ 37231 1910 32 completeness completeness NN 37231 1910 33 . . . 37231 1911 1 There there EX 37231 1911 2 is be VBZ 37231 1911 3 no no DT 37231 1911 4 possibility possibility NN 37231 1911 5 , , , 37231 1911 6 for for IN 37231 1911 7 instance instance NN 37231 1911 8 , , , 37231 1911 9 of of IN 37231 1911 10 evading evade VBG 37231 1911 11 such such JJ 37231 1911 12 statements statement NNS 37231 1911 13 as as IN 37231 1911 14 those those DT 37231 1911 15 in in IN 37231 1911 16 the the DT 37231 1911 17 miracle miracle NN 37231 1911 18 of of IN 37231 1911 19 the the DT 37231 1911 20 country country NN 37231 1911 21 of of IN 37231 1911 22 the the DT 37231 1911 23 Gadarenes Gadarenes NNPS 37231 1911 24 , , , 37231 1911 25 where where WRB 37231 1911 26 the the DT 37231 1911 27 objectivity objectivity NN 37231 1911 28 of of IN 37231 1911 29 the the DT 37231 1911 30 demons demon NNS 37231 1911 31 is be VBZ 37231 1911 32 so so RB 37231 1911 33 fully fully RB 37231 1911 34 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1911 35 that that IN 37231 1911 36 , , , 37231 1911 37 { { -LRB- 37231 1911 38 143 143 CD 37231 1911 39 } } -RRB- 37231 1911 40 on on IN 37231 1911 41 being be VBG 37231 1911 42 cast cast VBN 37231 1911 43 out out IN 37231 1911 44 of of IN 37231 1911 45 the the DT 37231 1911 46 man man NN 37231 1911 47 , , , 37231 1911 48 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1911 49 are be VBP 37231 1911 50 represented represent VBN 37231 1911 51 as as IN 37231 1911 52 requesting request VBG 37231 1911 53 to to TO 37231 1911 54 be be VB 37231 1911 55 allowed allow VBN 37231 1911 56 to to TO 37231 1911 57 go go VB 37231 1911 58 into into IN 37231 1911 59 the the DT 37231 1911 60 herd herd NN 37231 1911 61 of of IN 37231 1911 62 swine swine NNS 37231 1911 63 , , , 37231 1911 64 and and CC 37231 1911 65 being be VBG 37231 1911 66 permitted permit VBN 37231 1911 67 by by IN 37231 1911 68 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1911 69 to to TO 37231 1911 70 do do VB 37231 1911 71 so so RB 37231 1911 72 , , , 37231 1911 73 the the DT 37231 1911 74 entry entry NN 37231 1911 75 of of IN 37231 1911 76 the the DT 37231 1911 77 demons demon NNS 37231 1911 78 into into IN 37231 1911 79 the the DT 37231 1911 80 swine swine NN 37231 1911 81 is be VBZ 37231 1911 82 at at IN 37231 1911 83 once once RB 37231 1911 84 signalized signalize VBN 37231 1911 85 by by IN 37231 1911 86 the the DT 37231 1911 87 herd herd NN 37231 1911 88 running run VBG 37231 1911 89 violently violently RB 37231 1911 90 down down IN 37231 1911 91 the the DT 37231 1911 92 cliff cliff NN 37231 1911 93 into into IN 37231 1911 94 the the DT 37231 1911 95 lake lake NN 37231 1911 96 , , , 37231 1911 97 and and CC 37231 1911 98 being be VBG 37231 1911 99 drowned drown VBN 37231 1911 100 . . . 37231 1912 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1912 2 1 1 LS 37231 1912 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1912 4 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1912 5 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1912 6 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 1912 7 no no DT 37231 1912 8 such such JJ 37231 1912 9 ineffectual ineffectual JJ 37231 1912 10 evasion evasion NN 37231 1912 11 , , , 37231 1912 12 but but CC 37231 1912 13 rightly rightly RB 37231 1912 14 objects object VBZ 37231 1912 15 : : : 37231 1912 16 " " `` 37231 1912 17 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1912 18 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1912 19 Himself -PRON- PRP 37231 1912 20 uses use VBZ 37231 1912 21 language language NN 37231 1912 22 which which WDT 37231 1912 23 is be VBZ 37231 1912 24 not not RB 37231 1912 25 reconcilable reconcilable JJ 37231 1912 26 with with IN 37231 1912 27 any any DT 37231 1912 28 such such JJ 37231 1912 29 explanation explanation NN 37231 1912 30 . . . 37231 1913 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 2 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 1913 3 speaks speak VBZ 37231 1913 4 of of IN 37231 1913 5 demoniacs demoniac NNS 37231 1913 6 not not RB 37231 1913 7 as as IN 37231 1913 8 persons person NNS 37231 1913 9 of of IN 37231 1913 10 disordered disorder VBN 37231 1913 11 intellects intellect NNS 37231 1913 12 , , , 37231 1913 13 but but CC 37231 1913 14 as as IN 37231 1913 15 subjects subject NNS 37231 1913 16 and and CC 37231 1913 17 thralls thrall NNS 37231 1913 18 of of IN 37231 1913 19 an an DT 37231 1913 20 alien alien JJ 37231 1913 21 spiritual spiritual JJ 37231 1913 22 might might NN 37231 1913 23 ; ; : 37231 1913 24 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 25 addresses address VBZ 37231 1913 26 the the DT 37231 1913 27 evil evil JJ 37231 1913 28 spirit spirit NN 37231 1913 29 as as IN 37231 1913 30 distinct distinct JJ 37231 1913 31 from from IN 37231 1913 32 the the DT 37231 1913 33 man man NN 37231 1913 34 : : : 37231 1913 35 ' ' '' 37231 1913 36 Hold hold VB 37231 1913 37 thy thy PRP$ 37231 1913 38 peace peace NN 37231 1913 39 and and CC 37231 1913 40 come come VB 37231 1913 41 out out IN 37231 1913 42 of of IN 37231 1913 43 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 44 ; ; : 37231 1913 45 ' ' '' 37231 1913 46 " " '' 37231 1913 47 and and CC 37231 1913 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 49 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 1913 50 that that IN 37231 1913 51 " " `` 37231 1913 52 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1913 53 idea idea NN 37231 1913 54 of of IN 37231 1913 55 Christ Christ NNP 37231 1913 56 's 's POS 37231 1913 57 absolute absolute JJ 37231 1913 58 veracity veracity NN 37231 1913 59 , , , 37231 1913 60 apart apart RB 37231 1913 61 from from IN 37231 1913 62 the the DT 37231 1913 63 value value NN 37231 1913 64 of of IN 37231 1913 65 the the DT 37231 1913 66 truth truth NN 37231 1913 67 which which WDT 37231 1913 68 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 69 communicated communicate VBD 37231 1913 70 , , , 37231 1913 71 forbids forbid VBZ 37231 1913 72 us -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 73 to to TO 37231 1913 74 suppose suppose VB 37231 1913 75 that that IN 37231 1913 76 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 77 could could MD 37231 1913 78 have have VB 37231 1913 79 spoken speak VBN 37231 1913 80 as as IN 37231 1913 81 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 82 did do VBD 37231 1913 83 , , , 37231 1913 84 being be VBG 37231 1913 85 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 1913 86 aware aware JJ 37231 1913 87 all all PDT 37231 1913 88 the the DT 37231 1913 89 while while NN 37231 1913 90 that that IN 37231 1913 91 there there EX 37231 1913 92 was be VBD 37231 1913 93 no no DT 37231 1913 94 corresponding corresponding JJ 37231 1913 95 reality reality NN 37231 1913 96 to to TO 37231 1913 97 justify justify VB 37231 1913 98 the the DT 37231 1913 99 language language NN 37231 1913 100 which which WDT 37231 1913 101 He -PRON- PRP 37231 1913 102 used use VBD 37231 1913 103 . . . 37231 1914 1 " " `` 37231 1914 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1914 3 2 2 LS 37231 1914 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1914 5 The the DT 37231 1914 6 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1914 7 , , , 37231 1914 8 on on IN 37231 1914 9 the the DT 37231 1914 10 other other JJ 37231 1914 11 hand hand NN 37231 1914 12 , , , 37231 1914 13 finds find VBZ 37231 1914 14 " " `` 37231 1914 15 a a DT 37231 1914 16 very very RB 37231 1914 17 strong strong JJ 37231 1914 18 reason reason NN 37231 1914 19 , , , 37231 1914 20 " " '' 37231 1914 21 which which WDT 37231 1914 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1914 23 does do VBZ 37231 1914 24 not not RB 37231 1914 25 remember remember VB 37231 1914 26 to to TO 37231 1914 27 have have VB 37231 1914 28 seen see VBN 37231 1914 29 urged urge VBN 37231 1914 30 with with IN 37231 1914 31 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 1914 32 force force NN 37231 1914 33 , , , 37231 1914 34 " " '' 37231 1914 35 which which WDT 37231 1914 36 may may MD 37231 1914 37 have have VB 37231 1914 38 contributed contribute VBN 37231 1914 39 to to TO 37231 1914 40 induce induce VB 37231 1914 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1914 42 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1914 43 to to TO 37231 1914 44 adopt adopt VB 37231 1914 45 the the DT 37231 1914 46 current current JJ 37231 1914 47 language language NN 37231 1914 48 on on IN 37231 1914 49 the the DT 37231 1914 50 point point NN 37231 1914 51 . . . 37231 1915 1 The the DT 37231 1915 2 disbelief disbelief NN 37231 1915 3 in in IN 37231 1915 4 these these DT 37231 1915 5 spiritual spiritual JJ 37231 1915 6 influences influence NNS 37231 1915 7 was be VBD 37231 1915 8 one one CD 37231 1915 9 of of IN 37231 1915 10 the the DT 37231 1915 11 characteristics characteristic NNS 37231 1915 12 of of IN 37231 1915 13 the the DT 37231 1915 14 unpopular unpopular JJ 37231 1915 15 sect sect NN 37231 1915 16 of of IN 37231 1915 17 the the DT 37231 1915 18 Sadducees Sadducees NNPS 37231 1915 19 . . . 37231 1916 1 A a DT 37231 1916 2 departure departure NN 37231 1916 3 from from IN 37231 1916 4 the the DT 37231 1916 5 common common JJ 37231 1916 6 language language NN 37231 1916 7 , , , 37231 1916 8 or or CC 37231 1916 9 the the DT 37231 1916 10 endeavour endeavour NN 37231 1916 11 to to TO 37231 1916 12 correct correct VB 37231 1916 13 this this DT 37231 1916 14 inveterate inveterate JJ 37231 1916 15 error error NN 37231 1916 16 , , , 37231 1916 17 would would MD 37231 1916 18 have have VB 37231 1916 19 raised raise VBN 37231 1916 20 an an DT 37231 1916 21 immediate immediate JJ 37231 1916 22 outcry outcry NN 37231 1916 23 against against IN 37231 1916 24 Him -PRON- PRP 37231 1916 25 from from IN 37231 1916 26 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1916 27 watchful watchful JJ 37231 1916 28 and and CC 37231 1916 29 malignant malignant JJ 37231 1916 30 adversaries adversary NNS 37231 1916 31 as as IN 37231 1916 32 an an DT 37231 1916 33 unbelieving unbelieving JJ 37231 1916 34 Sadducec Sadducec NNP 37231 1916 35 . . . 37231 1917 1 " " `` 37231 1917 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1917 3 3 3 LS 37231 1917 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1917 5 Such such JJ 37231 1917 6 ascription ascription NN 37231 1917 7 of of IN 37231 1917 8 politic politic JJ 37231 1917 9 { { -LRB- 37231 1917 10 144 144 CD 37231 1917 11 } } -RRB- 37231 1917 12 deception deception NN 37231 1917 13 for for IN 37231 1917 14 the the DT 37231 1917 15 sake sake NN 37231 1917 16 of of IN 37231 1917 17 popularity popularity NN 37231 1917 18 might may MD 37231 1917 19 be be VB 37231 1917 20 intelligible intelligible JJ 37231 1917 21 in in IN 37231 1917 22 an an DT 37231 1917 23 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 1917 24 case case NN 37231 1917 25 , , , 37231 1917 26 but but CC 37231 1917 27 when when WRB 37231 1917 28 referred refer VBD 37231 1917 29 to to IN 37231 1917 30 the the DT 37231 1917 31 central central JJ 37231 1917 32 personage personage NN 37231 1917 33 of of IN 37231 1917 34 a a DT 37231 1917 35 Divine Divine NNP 37231 1917 36 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 1917 37 , , , 37231 1917 38 who who WP 37231 1917 39 is be VBZ 37231 1917 40 said say VBN 37231 1917 41 to to TO 37231 1917 42 be be VB 37231 1917 43 God God NNP 37231 1917 44 incarnate incarnate JJ 37231 1917 45 , , , 37231 1917 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1917 47 is be VBZ 37231 1917 48 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 1917 49 astounding astounding JJ 37231 1917 50 . . . 37231 1918 1 The the DT 37231 1918 2 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1918 3 , , , 37231 1918 4 however however RB 37231 1918 5 , , , 37231 1918 6 rightly rightly RB 37231 1918 7 deems deem VBZ 37231 1918 8 that that IN 37231 1918 9 if if IN 37231 1918 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1918 11 knew know VBD 37231 1918 12 that that IN 37231 1918 13 the the DT 37231 1918 14 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1918 15 belief belief NN 37231 1918 16 in in IN 37231 1918 17 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1918 18 possession possession NN 37231 1918 19 was be VBD 37231 1918 20 baseless baseless JJ 37231 1918 21 , , , 37231 1918 22 and and CC 37231 1918 23 that that IN 37231 1918 24 Satan Satan NNP 37231 1918 25 did do VBD 37231 1918 26 not not RB 37231 1918 27 exercise exercise VB 37231 1918 28 such such JJ 37231 1918 29 power power NN 37231 1918 30 over over IN 37231 1918 31 the the DT 37231 1918 32 bodies body NNS 37231 1918 33 or or CC 37231 1918 34 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1918 35 of of IN 37231 1918 36 men man NNS 37231 1918 37 , , , 37231 1918 38 there there EX 37231 1918 39 would would MD 37231 1918 40 be be VB 37231 1918 41 in in IN 37231 1918 42 such such JJ 37231 1918 43 language language NN 37231 1918 44 " " `` 37231 1918 45 that that WDT 37231 1918 46 absence absence NN 37231 1918 47 of of IN 37231 1918 48 agreement agreement NN 37231 1918 49 between between IN 37231 1918 50 thoughts thought NNS 37231 1918 51 and and CC 37231 1918 52 words word NNS 37231 1918 53 in in IN 37231 1918 54 which which WDT 37231 1918 55 the the DT 37231 1918 56 essence essence NN 37231 1918 57 of of IN 37231 1918 58 a a DT 37231 1918 59 lie lie NN 37231 1918 60 consists consist VBZ 37231 1918 61 . . . 37231 1919 1 " " `` 37231 1919 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1919 3 1 1 LS 37231 1919 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1919 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1919 6 is be VBZ 37231 1919 7 difficult difficult JJ 37231 1919 8 to to TO 37231 1919 9 say say VB 37231 1919 10 whether whether IN 37231 1919 11 the the DT 37231 1919 12 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 1919 13 of of IN 37231 1919 14 the the DT 37231 1919 15 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1919 16 or or CC 37231 1919 17 of of IN 37231 1919 18 the the DT 37231 1919 19 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1919 20 is be VBZ 37231 1919 21 the the DT 37231 1919 22 greater,--the greater,--the NNP 37231 1919 23 one one CD 37231 1919 24 obliged oblige VBN 37231 1919 25 to to TO 37231 1919 26 sacrifice sacrifice VB 37231 1919 27 the the DT 37231 1919 28 moral moral JJ 37231 1919 29 character character NN 37231 1919 30 of of IN 37231 1919 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1919 32 , , , 37231 1919 33 in in IN 37231 1919 34 order order NN 37231 1919 35 to to TO 37231 1919 36 escape escape VB 37231 1919 37 the the DT 37231 1919 38 admission admission NN 37231 1919 39 for for IN 37231 1919 40 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1919 41 of of IN 37231 1919 42 untenable untenable JJ 37231 1919 43 superstition superstition NN 37231 1919 44 , , , 37231 1919 45 the the DT 37231 1919 46 other other JJ 37231 1919 47 obliged oblige VBD 37231 1919 48 to to TO 37231 1919 49 adopt adopt VB 37231 1919 50 the the DT 37231 1919 51 superstition superstition NN 37231 1919 52 in in IN 37231 1919 53 order order NN 37231 1919 54 to to TO 37231 1919 55 support support VB 37231 1919 56 the the DT 37231 1919 57 veracity veracity NN 37231 1919 58 of of IN 37231 1919 59 the the DT 37231 1919 60 language language NN 37231 1919 61 . . . 37231 1920 1 At at IN 37231 1920 2 least least JJS 37231 1920 3 the the DT 37231 1920 4 course course NN 37231 1920 5 of of IN 37231 1920 6 the the DT 37231 1920 7 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 1920 8 is be VBZ 37231 1920 9 consistent consistent JJ 37231 1920 10 and and CC 37231 1920 11 worthy worthy JJ 37231 1920 12 of of IN 37231 1920 13 respect respect NN 37231 1920 14 . . . 37231 1921 1 The the DT 37231 1921 2 attempt attempt NN 37231 1921 3 to to TO 37231 1921 4 eliminate eliminate VB 37231 1921 5 the the DT 37231 1921 6 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 1921 7 diagnosis diagnosis NN 37231 1921 8 of of IN 37231 1921 9 the the DT 37231 1921 10 disease disease NN 37231 1921 11 , , , 37231 1921 12 and and CC 37231 1921 13 yet yet RB 37231 1921 14 to to TO 37231 1921 15 preserve preserve VB 37231 1921 16 intact intact JJ 37231 1921 17 the the DT 37231 1921 18 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1921 19 cure cure NN 37231 1921 20 , , , 37231 1921 21 is be VBZ 37231 1921 22 quite quite RB 37231 1921 23 ineffectual ineffectual JJ 37231 1921 24 . . . 37231 1922 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1922 2 Trench Trench NNP 37231 1922 3 anticipates anticipate VBZ 37231 1922 4 the the DT 37231 1922 5 natural natural JJ 37231 1922 6 question question NN 37231 1922 7 , , , 37231 1922 8 why why WRB 37231 1922 9 there there EX 37231 1922 10 are be VBP 37231 1922 11 no no DT 37231 1922 12 demoniacs demoniacs NN 37231 1922 13 now now RB 37231 1922 14 , , , 37231 1922 15 if if IN 37231 1922 16 there there EX 37231 1922 17 were be VBD 37231 1922 18 so so RB 37231 1922 19 many many JJ 37231 1922 20 in in IN 37231 1922 21 those those DT 37231 1922 22 days,(2 days,(2 NNS 37231 1922 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1922 24 and and CC 37231 1922 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1922 26 is be VBZ 37231 1922 27 logically logically RB 37231 1922 28 compelled compel VBN 37231 1922 29 to to TO 37231 1922 30 maintain maintain VB 37231 1922 31 that that IN 37231 1922 32 there there EX 37231 1922 33 may may MD 37231 1922 34 still still RB 37231 1922 35 be be VB 37231 1922 36 persons person NNS 37231 1922 37 possessed possess VBN 37231 1922 38 . . . 37231 1923 1 " " `` 37231 1923 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1923 3 may may MD 37231 1923 4 well well RB 37231 1923 5 be be VB 37231 1923 6 a a DT 37231 1923 7 question question NN 37231 1923 8 , , , 37231 1923 9 moreover moreover RB 37231 1923 10 , , , 37231 1923 11 " " '' 37231 1923 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1923 13 says say VBZ 37231 1923 14 , , , 37231 1923 15 " " `` 37231 1923 16 if if IN 37231 1923 17 an an DT 37231 1923 18 apostle apostle NN 37231 1923 19 or or CC 37231 1923 20 one one CD 37231 1923 21 with with IN 37231 1923 22 apostolic apostolic JJ 37231 1923 23 discernment discernment NN 37231 1923 24 of of IN 37231 1923 25 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1923 26 were be VBD 37231 1923 27 to to TO 37231 1923 28 enter enter VB 37231 1923 29 into into IN 37231 1923 30 a a DT 37231 1923 31 mad mad JJ 37231 1923 32 - - HYPH 37231 1923 33 house house NN 37231 1923 34 now now RB 37231 1923 35 , , , 37231 1923 36 how how WRB 37231 1923 37 many many JJ 37231 1923 38 of of IN 37231 1923 39 the the DT 37231 1923 40 sufferers sufferer NNS 37231 1923 41 there there RB 37231 1923 42 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1923 43 might may MD 37231 1923 44 not not RB 37231 1923 45 recognize recognize VB 37231 1923 46 as as IN 37231 1923 47 possessed possess VBN 37231 1923 48 ? ? . 37231 1924 1 " " `` 37231 1924 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1924 3 3 3 LS 37231 1924 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1924 5 There there EX 37231 1924 6 can can MD 37231 1924 7 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 1924 8 be be VB 37231 1924 9 a a DT 37231 1924 10 question question NN 37231 1924 11 upon upon IN 37231 1924 12 the the DT 37231 1924 13 point point NN 37231 1924 14 at at RB 37231 1924 15 all all RB 37231 1924 16 , , , 37231 1924 17 for for IN 37231 1924 18 such such PDT 37231 1924 19 a a DT 37231 1924 20 person person NN 37231 1924 21 issuing issue VBG 37231 1924 22 direct direct JJ 37231 1924 23 { { -LRB- 37231 1924 24 145 145 CD 37231 1924 25 } } -RRB- 37231 1924 26 from from IN 37231 1924 27 that that DT 37231 1924 28 period period NN 37231 1924 29 , , , 37231 1924 30 without without IN 37231 1924 31 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 1924 32 scientific scientific JJ 37231 1924 33 enlightenment enlightenment NN 37231 1924 34 , , , 37231 1924 35 would would MD 37231 1924 36 most most RBS 37231 1924 37 certainly certainly RB 37231 1924 38 pronounce pronounce VB 37231 1924 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1924 40 all all DT 37231 1924 41 , , , 37231 1924 42 " " '' 37231 1924 43 possessed possess VBN 37231 1924 44 . . . 37231 1924 45 " " '' 37231 1925 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1925 2 did do VBD 37231 1925 3 not not RB 37231 1925 4 , , , 37231 1925 5 however however RB 37231 1925 6 , , , 37231 1925 7 require require VB 37231 1925 8 an an DT 37231 1925 9 apostle apostle NN 37231 1925 10 , , , 37231 1925 11 nor nor CC 37231 1925 12 even even RB 37231 1925 13 one one CD 37231 1925 14 with with IN 37231 1925 15 apostolic apostolic JJ 37231 1925 16 discernment discernment NN 37231 1925 17 of of IN 37231 1925 18 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1925 19 , , , 37231 1925 20 to to TO 37231 1925 21 recognize recognize VB 37231 1925 22 the the DT 37231 1925 23 possessed possess VBN 37231 1925 24 at at IN 37231 1925 25 that that DT 37231 1925 26 time time NN 37231 1925 27 . . . 37231 1926 1 All all PDT 37231 1926 2 those those DT 37231 1926 3 who who WP 37231 1926 4 are be VBP 37231 1926 5 represented represent VBN 37231 1926 6 as as IN 37231 1926 7 being be VBG 37231 1926 8 brought bring VBN 37231 1926 9 to to IN 37231 1926 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1926 11 to to TO 37231 1926 12 be be VB 37231 1926 13 healed heal VBN 37231 1926 14 are be VBP 37231 1926 15 described describe VBN 37231 1926 16 by by IN 37231 1926 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1926 18 friends friend NNS 37231 1926 19 as as IN 37231 1926 20 having have VBG 37231 1926 21 a a DT 37231 1926 22 devil devil NN 37231 1926 23 or or CC 37231 1926 24 being be VBG 37231 1926 25 possessed possess VBN 37231 1926 26 , , , 37231 1926 27 and and CC 37231 1926 28 there there EX 37231 1926 29 was be VBD 37231 1926 30 no no DT 37231 1926 31 form form NN 37231 1926 32 of of IN 37231 1926 33 disease disease NN 37231 1926 34 more more RBR 37231 1926 35 general general JJ 37231 1926 36 or or CC 37231 1926 37 more more RBR 37231 1926 38 commonly commonly RB 37231 1926 39 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1926 40 by by IN 37231 1926 41 the the DT 37231 1926 42 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1926 43 . . . 37231 1927 1 For for IN 37231 1927 2 what what WDT 37231 1927 3 reason reason NN 37231 1927 4 has have VBZ 37231 1927 5 the the DT 37231 1927 6 recognition recognition NN 37231 1927 7 of of IN 37231 1927 8 , , , 37231 1927 9 and and CC 37231 1927 10 belief belief NN 37231 1927 11 in in IN 37231 1927 12 , , , 37231 1927 13 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1927 14 possession possession NN 37231 1927 15 passed pass VBD 37231 1927 16 away away RP 37231 1927 17 with with IN 37231 1927 18 the the DT 37231 1927 19 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1927 20 and and CC 37231 1927 21 superstition superstition NN 37231 1927 22 which which WDT 37231 1927 23 were be VBD 37231 1927 24 then then RB 37231 1927 25 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 1927 26 ? ? . 37231 1928 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1928 2 is be VBZ 37231 1928 3 important important JJ 37231 1928 4 to to TO 37231 1928 5 remember remember VB 37231 1928 6 that that IN 37231 1928 7 the the DT 37231 1928 8 theory theory NN 37231 1928 9 of of IN 37231 1928 10 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1928 11 possession possession NN 37231 1928 12 , , , 37231 1928 13 and and CC 37231 1928 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1928 15 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1928 16 cure cure NN 37231 1928 17 by by IN 37231 1928 18 means mean NNS 37231 1928 19 of of IN 37231 1928 20 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1928 21 and and CC 37231 1928 22 invocations invocation NNS 37231 1928 23 , , , 37231 1928 24 was be VBD 37231 1928 25 most most RBS 37231 1928 26 common common JJ 37231 1928 27 among among IN 37231 1928 28 the the DT 37231 1928 29 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1928 30 long long RB 37231 1928 31 before before IN 37231 1928 32 the the DT 37231 1928 33 commencement commencement NN 37231 1928 34 of of IN 37231 1928 35 the the DT 37231 1928 36 Christian christian JJ 37231 1928 37 era era NN 37231 1928 38 . . . 37231 1929 1 As as IN 37231 1929 2 casting cast VBG 37231 1929 3 out out RP 37231 1929 4 devils devil NNS 37231 1929 5 was be VBD 37231 1929 6 the the DT 37231 1929 7 most most RBS 37231 1929 8 common common JJ 37231 1929 9 type type NN 37231 1929 10 of of IN 37231 1929 11 Christian christian JJ 37231 1929 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1929 13 , , , 37231 1929 14 so so CC 37231 1929 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1929 16 was be VBD 37231 1929 17 the the DT 37231 1929 18 commonest common JJS 37231 1929 19 belief belief NN 37231 1929 20 and and CC 37231 1929 21 practice practice NN 37231 1929 22 of of IN 37231 1929 23 the the DT 37231 1929 24 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 1929 25 nation nation NN 37231 1929 26 . . . 37231 1930 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1930 2 merely merely RB 37231 1930 3 shared share VBD 37231 1930 4 the the DT 37231 1930 5 national national JJ 37231 1930 6 superstition superstition NN 37231 1930 7 , , , 37231 1930 8 and and CC 37231 1930 9 changed change VBD 37231 1930 10 nothing nothing NN 37231 1930 11 but but IN 37231 1930 12 the the DT 37231 1930 13 form form NN 37231 1930 14 of of IN 37231 1930 15 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 1930 16 . . . 37231 1931 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1931 2 did do VBD 37231 1931 3 not not RB 37231 1931 4 through through IN 37231 1931 5 a a DT 37231 1931 6 " " `` 37231 1931 7 clearer clear JJR 37231 1931 8 perception perception NN 37231 1931 9 of of IN 37231 1931 10 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1931 11 , , , 37231 1931 12 " " '' 37231 1931 13 therefore therefore RB 37231 1931 14 , , , 37231 1931 15 originate originate VB 37231 1931 16 the the DT 37231 1931 17 belief belief NN 37231 1931 18 in in IN 37231 1931 19 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1931 20 possession possession NN 37231 1931 21 , , , 37231 1931 22 nor nor CC 37231 1931 23 first first RB 37231 1931 24 recognize recognize VB 37231 1931 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1931 26 victims victim NNS 37231 1931 27 ; ; : 37231 1931 28 nor nor CC 37231 1931 29 did do VBD 37231 1931 30 such such JJ 37231 1931 31 superior superior JJ 37231 1931 32 enlightenment enlightenment NN 37231 1931 33 accompany accompany VB 37231 1931 34 the the DT 37231 1931 35 superior superior JJ 37231 1931 36 morality morality NN 37231 1931 37 of of IN 37231 1931 38 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1931 39 as as IN 37231 1931 40 to to TO 37231 1931 41 detect detect VB 37231 1931 42 the the DT 37231 1931 43 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 1931 44 fallacy fallacy NN 37231 1931 45 . . . 37231 1932 1 In in IN 37231 1932 2 the the DT 37231 1932 3 Old Old NNP 37231 1932 4 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1932 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1932 6 find find VBP 37231 1932 7 the the DT 37231 1932 8 most most RBS 37231 1932 9 serious serious JJ 37231 1932 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 1932 11 of of IN 37231 1932 12 the the DT 37231 1932 13 belief belief NN 37231 1932 14 in in IN 37231 1932 15 demonology demonology NN 37231 1932 16 and and CC 37231 1932 17 witchcraft witchcraft NN 37231 1932 18 . . . 37231 1933 1 The the DT 37231 1933 2 laws law NNS 37231 1933 3 against against IN 37231 1933 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1933 5 set set VBD 37231 1933 6 the the DT 37231 1933 7 example example NN 37231 1933 8 of of IN 37231 1933 9 that that DT 37231 1933 10 unrelenting unrelenting JJ 37231 1933 11 severity severity NN 37231 1933 12 with with IN 37231 1933 13 which which WDT 37231 1933 14 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1933 15 was be VBD 37231 1933 16 treated treat VBN 37231 1933 17 for for IN 37231 1933 18 so so RB 37231 1933 19 many many JJ 37231 1933 20 centuries century NNS 37231 1933 21 . . . 37231 1934 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1934 2 read read VBP 37231 1934 3 in in IN 37231 1934 4 Exodus Exodus NNP 37231 1934 5 xxii xxii NN 37231 1934 6 . . . 37231 1935 1 18 18 CD 37231 1935 2 : : : 37231 1935 3 " " `` 37231 1935 4 Thou Thou NNP 37231 1935 5 shalt shalt NN 37231 1935 6 not not RB 37231 1935 7 suffer suffer VB 37231 1935 8 a a DT 37231 1935 9 witch witch NN 37231 1935 10 to to TO 37231 1935 11 live live VB 37231 1935 12 . . . 37231 1935 13 " " '' 37231 1936 1 Levit Levit NNP 37231 1936 2 . . . 37231 1937 1 xix xix NNP 37231 1937 2 . . . 37231 1938 1 31 31 CD 37231 1938 2 : : : 37231 1938 3 " " `` 37231 1938 4 Regard regard NN 37231 1938 5 not not RB 37231 1938 6 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1938 7 which which WDT 37231 1938 8 have have VBP 37231 1938 9 familiar familiar JJ 37231 1938 10 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1938 11 , , , 37231 1938 12 neither neither CC 37231 1938 13 { { -LRB- 37231 1938 14 146 146 CD 37231 1938 15 } } -RRB- 37231 1938 16 seek seek VBP 37231 1938 17 after after IN 37231 1938 18 wizards wizard NNS 37231 1938 19 , , , 37231 1938 20 to to TO 37231 1938 21 be be VB 37231 1938 22 defiled defile VBN 37231 1938 23 by by IN 37231 1938 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1938 25 . . . 37231 1938 26 " " '' 37231 1939 1 Levit Levit NNP 37231 1939 2 . . . 37231 1940 1 xx xx NNP 37231 1940 2 . . . 37231 1941 1 6 6 CD 37231 1941 2 : : : 37231 1941 3 " " `` 37231 1941 4 And and CC 37231 1941 5 the the DT 37231 1941 6 soul soul NN 37231 1941 7 that that WDT 37231 1941 8 turneth turneth VBP 37231 1941 9 after after IN 37231 1941 10 such such JJ 37231 1941 11 as as IN 37231 1941 12 have have VBP 37231 1941 13 familiar familiar JJ 37231 1941 14 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1941 15 , , , 37231 1941 16 and and CC 37231 1941 17 after after IN 37231 1941 18 wizards wizard NNS 37231 1941 19 to to TO 37231 1941 20 go go VB 37231 1941 21 a a DT 37231 1941 22 - - HYPH 37231 1941 23 whoring whoring NN 37231 1941 24 after after IN 37231 1941 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1941 26 , , , 37231 1941 27 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1941 28 will will MD 37231 1941 29 even even RB 37231 1941 30 set set VB 37231 1941 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1941 32 face face NN 37231 1941 33 against against IN 37231 1941 34 that that DT 37231 1941 35 soul soul NN 37231 1941 36 , , , 37231 1941 37 and and CC 37231 1941 38 cut cut VBD 37231 1941 39 him -PRON- PRP 37231 1941 40 off off RP 37231 1941 41 from from IN 37231 1941 42 among among IN 37231 1941 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1941 44 people people NNS 37231 1941 45 ; ; : 37231 1941 46 " " '' 37231 1941 47 and and CC 37231 1941 48 verse verse VB 37231 1941 49 27 27 CD 37231 1941 50 : : : 37231 1941 51 " " `` 37231 1941 52 A a DT 37231 1941 53 man man NN 37231 1941 54 also also RB 37231 1941 55 or or CC 37231 1941 56 a a DT 37231 1941 57 woman woman NN 37231 1941 58 that that WDT 37231 1941 59 hath hath VBP 37231 1941 60 a a DT 37231 1941 61 familiar familiar JJ 37231 1941 62 spirit spirit NN 37231 1941 63 , , , 37231 1941 64 or or CC 37231 1941 65 that that DT 37231 1941 66 is be VBZ 37231 1941 67 a a DT 37231 1941 68 wizard wizard NN 37231 1941 69 , , , 37231 1941 70 shall shall MD 37231 1941 71 surely surely RB 37231 1941 72 be be VB 37231 1941 73 put put VBN 37231 1941 74 to to IN 37231 1941 75 death death NN 37231 1941 76 ; ; : 37231 1941 77 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1941 78 shall shall MD 37231 1941 79 stone stone VB 37231 1941 80 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1941 81 with with IN 37231 1941 82 stones stone NNS 37231 1941 83 ; ; : 37231 1941 84 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1941 85 blood blood NN 37231 1941 86 shall shall MD 37231 1941 87 be be VB 37231 1941 88 upon upon IN 37231 1941 89 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1941 90 . . . 37231 1941 91 " " '' 37231 1942 1 Deut deut VB 37231 1942 2 . . . 37231 1943 1 xviii xviii NNP 37231 1943 2 . . . 37231 1944 1 10 10 CD 37231 1944 2 : : : 37231 1944 3 " " `` 37231 1944 4 There there EX 37231 1944 5 shall shall MD 37231 1944 6 not not RB 37231 1944 7 be be VB 37231 1944 8 found find VBN 37231 1944 9 among among IN 37231 1944 10 you -PRON- PRP 37231 1944 11 any any DT 37231 1944 12 one one NN 37231 1944 13 that that WDT 37231 1944 14 maketh maketh VBD 37231 1944 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1944 16 son son NN 37231 1944 17 or or CC 37231 1944 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1944 19 daughter daughter NN 37231 1944 20 to to TO 37231 1944 21 pass pass VB 37231 1944 22 through through IN 37231 1944 23 the the DT 37231 1944 24 fire fire NN 37231 1944 25 , , , 37231 1944 26 or or CC 37231 1944 27 an an DT 37231 1944 28 enchanter enchanter NN 37231 1944 29 , , , 37231 1944 30 or or CC 37231 1944 31 a a DT 37231 1944 32 witch witch NN 37231 1944 33 ; ; : 37231 1944 34 11 11 CD 37231 1944 35 . . . 37231 1945 1 Or or CC 37231 1945 2 a a DT 37231 1945 3 charmer charmer NN 37231 1945 4 , , , 37231 1945 5 or or CC 37231 1945 6 a a DT 37231 1945 7 consulter consulter NN 37231 1945 8 with with IN 37231 1945 9 familiar familiar JJ 37231 1945 10 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1945 11 , , , 37231 1945 12 or or CC 37231 1945 13 a a DT 37231 1945 14 wizard wizard NN 37231 1945 15 , , , 37231 1945 16 or or CC 37231 1945 17 a a DT 37231 1945 18 necromancer necromancer NN 37231 1945 19 ; ; : 37231 1945 20 12 12 CD 37231 1945 21 . . . 37231 1946 1 For for IN 37231 1946 2 all all DT 37231 1946 3 that that WDT 37231 1946 4 do do VBP 37231 1946 5 these these DT 37231 1946 6 things thing NNS 37231 1946 7 are be VBP 37231 1946 8 an an DT 37231 1946 9 abomination abomination NN 37231 1946 10 unto unto IN 37231 1946 11 the the DT 37231 1946 12 Lord Lord NNP 37231 1946 13 , , , 37231 1946 14 " " '' 37231 1946 15 & & CC 37231 1946 16 c. c. NNP 37231 1946 17 The the DT 37231 1946 18 passages passage NNS 37231 1946 19 which which WDT 37231 1946 20 assert assert VBP 37231 1946 21 the the DT 37231 1946 22 reality reality NN 37231 1946 23 of of IN 37231 1946 24 demonology demonology NN 37231 1946 25 and and CC 37231 1946 26 witchcraft witchcraft NN 37231 1946 27 , , , 37231 1946 28 however however RB 37231 1946 29 , , , 37231 1946 30 are be VBP 37231 1946 31 much much RB 37231 1946 32 too too RB 37231 1946 33 numerous numerous JJ 37231 1946 34 to to TO 37231 1946 35 permit permit VB 37231 1946 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1946 37 citation citation NN 37231 1946 38 here here RB 37231 1946 39 . . . 37231 1947 1 But but CC 37231 1947 2 not not RB 37231 1947 3 only only RB 37231 1947 4 did do VBD 37231 1947 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1947 6 thus thus RB 37231 1947 7 inherit inherit VB 37231 1947 8 the the DT 37231 1947 9 long long RB 37231 1947 10 - - HYPH 37231 1947 11 prevalent prevalent NN 37231 1947 12 superstition superstition NN 37231 1947 13 , , , 37231 1947 14 but but CC 37231 1947 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1947 16 transmitted transmit VBD 37231 1947 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1947 18 intact intact JJ 37231 1947 19 to to IN 37231 1947 20 succeeding succeed VBG 37231 1947 21 ages age NNS 37231 1947 22 ; ; : 37231 1947 23 and and CC 37231 1947 24 there there EX 37231 1947 25 can can MD 37231 1947 26 be be VB 37231 1947 27 no no DT 37231 1947 28 doubt doubt NN 37231 1947 29 that that IN 37231 1947 30 this this DT 37231 1947 31 demonology demonology NN 37231 1947 32 , , , 37231 1947 33 with with IN 37231 1947 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1947 35 consequent consequent JJ 37231 1947 36 and and CC 37231 1947 37 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 1947 38 belief belief NN 37231 1947 39 in in IN 37231 1947 40 witchcraft witchcraft NN 37231 1947 41 , , , 37231 1947 42 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1947 43 , , , 37231 1947 44 and and CC 37231 1947 45 magic magic NN 37231 1947 46 , , , 37231 1947 47 continued continue VBD 37231 1947 48 so so RB 37231 1947 49 long long RB 37231 1947 50 to to TO 37231 1947 51 prevail prevail VB 37231 1947 52 throughout throughout IN 37231 1947 53 Christendom Christendom NNP 37231 1947 54 , , , 37231 1947 55 as as RB 37231 1947 56 much much RB 37231 1947 57 through through IN 37231 1947 58 the the DT 37231 1947 59 authority authority NN 37231 1947 60 of of IN 37231 1947 61 the the DT 37231 1947 62 sacred sacred JJ 37231 1947 63 writings writing NNS 37231 1947 64 and and CC 37231 1947 65 the the DT 37231 1947 66 teaching teaching NN 37231 1947 67 of of IN 37231 1947 68 the the DT 37231 1947 69 Church Church NNP 37231 1947 70 as as IN 37231 1947 71 through through IN 37231 1947 72 the the DT 37231 1947 73 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 1947 74 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1947 75 of of IN 37231 1947 76 Europe Europe NNP 37231 1947 77 . . . 37231 1948 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1948 2 would would MD 37231 1948 3 be be VB 37231 1948 4 impossible impossible JJ 37231 1948 5 to to TO 37231 1948 6 select select VB 37231 1948 7 for for IN 37231 1948 8 illustration illustration NN 37231 1948 9 any any DT 37231 1948 10 type type NN 37231 1948 11 of of IN 37231 1948 12 the the DT 37231 1948 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1948 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1948 15 , , , 37231 1948 16 whose whose WP$ 37231 1948 17 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 1948 18 principle,--belief principle,--belief NNP 37231 1948 19 in in IN 37231 1948 20 the the DT 37231 1948 21 reality reality NN 37231 1948 22 , , , 37231 1948 23 malignant malignant JJ 37231 1948 24 action action NN 37231 1948 25 , , , 37231 1948 26 and and CC 37231 1948 27 power power NN 37231 1948 28 of of IN 37231 1948 29 demons demon NNS 37231 1948 30 , , , 37231 1948 31 and and CC 37231 1948 32 in in IN 37231 1948 33 the the DT 37231 1948 34 power power NN 37231 1948 35 of of IN 37231 1948 36 man man NN 37231 1948 37 to to TO 37231 1948 38 control control VB 37231 1948 39 them,--has them,--ha VBZ 37231 1948 40 received receive VBN 37231 1948 41 fuller full JJR 37231 1948 42 or or CC 37231 1948 43 more more RBR 37231 1948 44 permanent permanent JJ 37231 1948 45 living live VBG 37231 1948 46 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 1948 47 from from IN 37231 1948 48 posterity posterity NN 37231 1948 49 , , , 37231 1948 50 down down RB 37231 1948 51 to to IN 37231 1948 52 very very RB 37231 1948 53 recent recent JJ 37231 1948 54 times time NNS 37231 1948 55 , , , 37231 1948 56 than than IN 37231 1948 57 the the DT 37231 1948 58 cure cure NN 37231 1948 59 of of IN 37231 1948 60 disease disease NN 37231 1948 61 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1948 62 to to IN 37231 1948 63 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1948 64 influence influence NN 37231 1948 65 . . . 37231 1949 1 The the DT 37231 1949 2 writings writing NNS 37231 1949 3 of of IN 37231 1949 4 the the DT 37231 1949 5 Fathers father NNS 37231 1949 6 are be VBP 37231 1949 7 full full JJ 37231 1949 8 of of IN 37231 1949 9 the the DT 37231 1949 10 belief belief NN 37231 1949 11 ; ; : 37231 1949 12 the the DT 37231 1949 13 social social JJ 37231 1949 14 { { -LRB- 37231 1949 15 147 147 CD 37231 1949 16 } } -RRB- 37231 1949 17 history history NN 37231 1949 18 of of IN 37231 1949 19 Europe Europe NNP 37231 1949 20 teems teem VBZ 37231 1949 21 with with IN 37231 1949 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1949 23 . . . 37231 1950 1 The the DT 37231 1950 2 more more RBR 37231 1950 3 pious pious JJ 37231 1950 4 the the DT 37231 1950 5 people people NNS 37231 1950 6 , , , 37231 1950 7 the the DT 37231 1950 8 more more RBR 37231 1950 9 firm firm JJ 37231 1950 10 was be VBD 37231 1950 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1950 12 conviction conviction NN 37231 1950 13 of of IN 37231 1950 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1950 15 reality reality NN 37231 1950 16 . . . 37231 1951 1 From from IN 37231 1951 2 times time NNS 37231 1951 3 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 1951 4 to to IN 37231 1951 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 1951 6 , , , 37231 1951 7 until until IN 37231 1951 8 medical medical JJ 37231 1951 9 science science NN 37231 1951 10 slowly slowly RB 37231 1951 11 came come VBD 37231 1951 12 into into IN 37231 1951 13 existence existence NN 37231 1951 14 and and CC 37231 1951 15 displaced displaced JJ 37231 1951 16 miracle miracle NN 37231 1951 17 cures cure NNS 37231 1951 18 by by IN 37231 1951 19 the the DT 37231 1951 20 relics relic NNS 37231 1951 21 of of IN 37231 1951 22 saints saint NNS 37231 1951 23 , , , 37231 1951 24 every every DT 37231 1951 25 form form NN 37231 1951 26 of of IN 37231 1951 27 disease disease NN 37231 1951 28 was be VBD 37231 1951 29 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1951 30 to to IN 37231 1951 31 demons demon NNS 37231 1951 32 . . . 37231 1952 1 Madness Madness NNP 37231 1952 2 , , , 37231 1952 3 idiotcy idiotcy NN 37231 1952 4 , , , 37231 1952 5 epilepsy epilepsy NN 37231 1952 6 , , , 37231 1952 7 and and CC 37231 1952 8 every every DT 37231 1952 9 shape shape NN 37231 1952 10 of of IN 37231 1952 11 hysteria hysteria NN 37231 1952 12 were be VBD 37231 1952 13 the the DT 37231 1952 14 commonest common JJS 37231 1952 15 forms form NNS 37231 1952 16 of of IN 37231 1952 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1952 18 malignity malignity NN 37231 1952 19 ; ; : 37231 1952 20 and and CC 37231 1952 21 the the DT 37231 1952 22 blind blind JJ 37231 1952 23 , , , 37231 1952 24 the the DT 37231 1952 25 dumb dumb JJ 37231 1952 26 , , , 37231 1952 27 and and CC 37231 1952 28 the the DT 37231 1952 29 deformed deform VBN 37231 1952 30 were be VBD 37231 1952 31 regarded regard VBN 37231 1952 32 as as IN 37231 1952 33 unquestionable unquestionable JJ 37231 1952 34 victims victim NNS 37231 1952 35 of of IN 37231 1952 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1952 37 malice malice NN 37231 1952 38 . . . 37231 1953 1 Every every DT 37231 1953 2 domestic domestic JJ 37231 1953 3 calamity calamity NN 37231 1953 4 , , , 37231 1953 5 from from IN 37231 1953 6 the the DT 37231 1953 7 convulsions convulsion NNS 37231 1953 8 of of IN 37231 1953 9 a a DT 37231 1953 10 child child NN 37231 1953 11 to to IN 37231 1953 12 the the DT 37231 1953 13 death death NN 37231 1953 14 of of IN 37231 1953 15 a a DT 37231 1953 16 cow cow NN 37231 1953 17 , , , 37231 1953 18 was be VBD 37231 1953 19 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 37231 1953 20 attributed attribute VBN 37231 1953 21 to to IN 37231 1953 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1953 23 agency agency NN 37231 1953 24 . . . 37231 1954 1 The the DT 37231 1954 2 more more RBR 37231 1954 3 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 1954 4 the the DT 37231 1954 5 community community NN 37231 1954 6 , , , 37231 1954 7 the the DT 37231 1954 8 greater great JJR 37231 1954 9 the the DT 37231 1954 10 number number NN 37231 1954 11 of of IN 37231 1954 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1954 13 possessed possess VBN 37231 1954 14 . . . 37231 1955 1 Belief belief NN 37231 1955 2 in in IN 37231 1955 3 the the DT 37231 1955 4 power power NN 37231 1955 5 of of IN 37231 1955 6 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1955 7 , , , 37231 1955 8 witchcraft witchcraft NN 37231 1955 9 , , , 37231 1955 10 and and CC 37231 1955 11 magic magic NNP 37231 1955 12 was be VBD 37231 1955 13 inherent inherent JJ 37231 1955 14 in in IN 37231 1955 15 the the DT 37231 1955 16 superstition superstition NN 37231 1955 17 , , , 37231 1955 18 and and CC 37231 1955 19 the the DT 37231 1955 20 universal universal JJ 37231 1955 21 prevalence prevalence NN 37231 1955 22 shows show VBZ 37231 1955 23 how how WRB 37231 1955 24 catholic catholic JJ 37231 1955 25 was be VBD 37231 1955 26 the the DT 37231 1955 27 belief belief NN 37231 1955 28 in in IN 37231 1955 29 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1955 30 influence influence NN 37231 1955 31 . . . 37231 1956 1 The the DT 37231 1956 2 practice practice NN 37231 1956 3 of of IN 37231 1956 4 these these DT 37231 1956 5 arts art NNS 37231 1956 6 is be VBZ 37231 1956 7 solemnly solemnly RB 37231 1956 8 denounced denounce VBN 37231 1956 9 as as IN 37231 1956 10 sin sin NN 37231 1956 11 in in IN 37231 1956 12 the the DT 37231 1956 13 New New NNP 37231 1956 14 Testament Testament NNP 37231 1956 15 and and CC 37231 1956 16 throughout throughout IN 37231 1956 17 Patristic patristic JJ 37231 1956 18 literature literature NN 37231 1956 19 , , , 37231 1956 20 and and CC 37231 1956 21 the the DT 37231 1956 22 church church NN 37231 1956 23 has have VBZ 37231 1956 24 in in IN 37231 1956 25 all all DT 37231 1956 26 ages age NNS 37231 1956 27 fulminated fulminate VBN 37231 1956 28 against against IN 37231 1956 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1956 30 . . . 37231 1957 1 No no DT 37231 1957 2 accusation accusation NN 37231 1957 3 was be VBD 37231 1957 4 more more RBR 37231 1957 5 common common JJ 37231 1957 6 than than IN 37231 1957 7 that that DT 37231 1957 8 of of IN 37231 1957 9 practising practise VBG 37231 1957 10 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1957 11 , , , 37231 1957 12 and and CC 37231 1957 13 no no DT 37231 1957 14 class class NN 37231 1957 15 escaped escape VBD 37231 1957 16 from from IN 37231 1957 17 the the DT 37231 1957 18 fatal fatal JJ 37231 1957 19 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 1957 20 . . . 37231 1958 1 Popes pope NNS 37231 1958 2 were be VBD 37231 1958 3 charged charge VBN 37231 1958 4 with with IN 37231 1958 5 the the DT 37231 1958 6 crime crime NN 37231 1958 7 , , , 37231 1958 8 and and CC 37231 1958 9 bishops bishop NNS 37231 1958 10 were be VBD 37231 1958 11 found find VBN 37231 1958 12 guilty guilty JJ 37231 1958 13 of of IN 37231 1958 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1958 15 . . . 37231 1959 1 St. St. NNP 37231 1959 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 37231 1959 3 was be VBD 37231 1959 4 said say VBN 37231 1959 5 to to TO 37231 1959 6 have have VB 37231 1959 7 been be VBN 37231 1959 8 a a DT 37231 1959 9 magician magician NN 37231 1959 10 before before IN 37231 1959 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1959 12 became become VBD 37231 1959 13 a a DT 37231 1959 14 Christian Christian NNP 37231 1959 15 and and CC 37231 1959 16 a a DT 37231 1959 17 Father Father NNP 37231 1959 18 of of IN 37231 1959 19 the the DT 37231 1959 20 Church Church NNP 37231 1959 21 . . . 37231 1960 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1960 2 1 1 LS 37231 1960 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1960 4 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 1960 5 was be VBD 37231 1960 6 accused accuse VBN 37231 1960 7 of of IN 37231 1960 8 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1960 9 before before IN 37231 1960 10 the the DT 37231 1960 11 Synod Synod NNP 37231 1960 12 of of IN 37231 1960 13 Tyre Tyre NNP 37231 1960 14 . . . 37231 1961 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1961 2 2 2 LS 37231 1961 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1961 4 Not not RB 37231 1961 5 only only RB 37231 1961 6 the the DT 37231 1961 7 illiterate illiterate JJ 37231 1961 8 but but CC 37231 1961 9 even even RB 37231 1961 10 the the DT 37231 1961 11 learned learn VBN 37231 1961 12 , , , 37231 1961 13 in in IN 37231 1961 14 the the DT 37231 1961 15 estimation estimation NN 37231 1961 16 of of IN 37231 1961 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1961 18 age age NN 37231 1961 19 , , , 37231 1961 20 believed believe VBN 37231 1961 21 in in IN 37231 1961 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1961 23 . . . 37231 1962 1 No no DT 37231 1962 2 heresy heresy NN 37231 1962 3 was be VBD 37231 1962 4 ever ever RB 37231 1962 5 persecuted persecute VBN 37231 1962 6 with with IN 37231 1962 7 more more RBR 37231 1962 8 unrelenting unrelenting JJ 37231 1962 9 hatred hatred NN 37231 1962 10 . . . 37231 1963 1 Popes pope NNS 37231 1963 2 have have VBP 37231 1963 3 issued issue VBN 37231 1963 4 bulls bull NNS 37231 1963 5 vehemently vehemently RB 37231 1963 6 anathematising anathematise VBG 37231 1963 7 witches witch NNS 37231 1963 8 and and CC 37231 1963 9 sorcerers sorcerer NNS 37231 1963 10 , , , 37231 1963 11 councils council NNS 37231 1963 12 have have VBP 37231 1963 13 proscribed proscribe VBN 37231 1963 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1963 15 , , , 37231 1963 16 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 1963 17 { { -LRB- 37231 1963 18 148 148 CD 37231 1963 19 } } -RRB- 37231 1963 20 courts court NNS 37231 1963 21 have have VBP 37231 1963 22 consigned consign VBN 37231 1963 23 tens ten NNS 37231 1963 24 of of IN 37231 1963 25 thousands thousand NNS 37231 1963 26 of of IN 37231 1963 27 persons person NNS 37231 1963 28 suspected suspect VBN 37231 1963 29 of of IN 37231 1963 30 being be VBG 37231 1963 31 such such JJ 37231 1963 32 to to IN 37231 1963 33 the the DT 37231 1963 34 stake stake NN 37231 1963 35 , , , 37231 1963 36 monarchs monarch NNS 37231 1963 37 have have VBP 37231 1963 38 written write VBN 37231 1963 39 treatises treatise NNS 37231 1963 40 against against IN 37231 1963 41 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1963 42 and and CC 37231 1963 43 invented invent VBD 37231 1963 44 tortures torture NNS 37231 1963 45 for for IN 37231 1963 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1963 47 conviction conviction NN 37231 1963 48 , , , 37231 1963 49 and and CC 37231 1963 50 every every DT 37231 1963 51 nation nation NN 37231 1963 52 in in IN 37231 1963 53 Europe Europe NNP 37231 1963 54 and and CC 37231 1963 55 almost almost RB 37231 1963 56 every every DT 37231 1963 57 generation generation NN 37231 1963 58 have have VBP 37231 1963 59 passed pass VBN 37231 1963 60 the the DT 37231 1963 61 most most RBS 37231 1963 62 stringent stringent JJ 37231 1963 63 laws law NNS 37231 1963 64 against against IN 37231 1963 65 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1963 66 . . . 37231 1964 1 Upon upon IN 37231 1964 2 no no DT 37231 1964 3 point point NN 37231 1964 4 has have VBZ 37231 1964 5 there there EX 37231 1964 6 ever ever RB 37231 1964 7 been be VBN 37231 1964 8 greater great JJR 37231 1964 9 unanimity unanimity NN 37231 1964 10 of of IN 37231 1964 11 belief belief NN 37231 1964 12 . . . 37231 1965 1 Church Church NNP 37231 1965 2 and and CC 37231 1965 3 State State NNP 37231 1965 4 have have VBP 37231 1965 5 vied vie VBN 37231 1965 6 with with IN 37231 1965 7 each each DT 37231 1965 8 other other JJ 37231 1965 9 for for IN 37231 1965 10 the the DT 37231 1965 11 suppression suppression NN 37231 1965 12 of of IN 37231 1965 13 the the DT 37231 1965 14 abominable abominable JJ 37231 1965 15 crime crime NN 37231 1965 16 . . . 37231 1966 1 Every every DT 37231 1966 2 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 1966 3 of of IN 37231 1966 4 nature nature NN 37231 1966 5 , , , 37231 1966 6 every every DT 37231 1966 7 unwelcome unwelcome JJ 37231 1966 8 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 1966 9 of of IN 37231 1966 10 social social JJ 37231 1966 11 life life NN 37231 1966 12 , , , 37231 1966 13 as as RB 37231 1966 14 well well RB 37231 1966 15 as as IN 37231 1966 16 every every DT 37231 1966 17 natural natural JJ 37231 1966 18 disease disease NN 37231 1966 19 , , , 37231 1966 20 has have VBZ 37231 1966 21 been be VBN 37231 1966 22 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1966 23 to to IN 37231 1966 24 magic magic NN 37231 1966 25 and and CC 37231 1966 26 demons demon NNS 37231 1966 27 . . . 37231 1967 1 The the DT 37231 1967 2 historical historical JJ 37231 1967 3 records record NNS 37231 1967 4 of of IN 37231 1967 5 Europe Europe NNP 37231 1967 6 are be VBP 37231 1967 7 filled fill VBN 37231 1967 8 with with IN 37231 1967 9 the the DT 37231 1967 10 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 1967 11 trial trial NN 37231 1967 12 and and CC 37231 1967 13 conviction conviction NN 37231 1967 14 , , , 37231 1967 15 upon upon IN 37231 1967 16 what what WP 37231 1967 17 was be VBD 37231 1967 18 deemed deem VBN 37231 1967 19 evidence evidence NN 37231 1967 20 , , , 37231 1967 21 of of IN 37231 1967 22 thousands thousand NNS 37231 1967 23 of of IN 37231 1967 24 sorcerers sorcerer NNS 37231 1967 25 and and CC 37231 1967 26 witches witch NNS 37231 1967 27 . . . 37231 1968 1 Hundreds hundred NNS 37231 1968 2 have have VBP 37231 1968 3 been be VBN 37231 1968 4 found find VBN 37231 1968 5 guilty guilty JJ 37231 1968 6 of of IN 37231 1968 7 exercising exercise VBG 37231 1968 8 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1968 9 influence influence NN 37231 1968 10 over over IN 37231 1968 11 the the DT 37231 1968 12 elements element NNS 37231 1968 13 , , , 37231 1968 14 from from IN 37231 1968 15 Sopater sopater NN 37231 1968 16 the the DT 37231 1968 17 philosopher philosopher NN 37231 1968 18 , , , 37231 1968 19 executed execute VBN 37231 1968 20 under under IN 37231 1968 21 Constantino Constantino NNP 37231 1968 22 for for IN 37231 1968 23 preventing prevent VBG 37231 1968 24 , , , 37231 1968 25 by by IN 37231 1968 26 adverse adverse JJ 37231 1968 27 winds wind NNS 37231 1968 28 , , , 37231 1968 29 the the DT 37231 1968 30 arrival arrival NN 37231 1968 31 of of IN 37231 1968 32 corn corn NN 37231 1968 33 ships ship NNS 37231 1968 34 at at IN 37231 1968 35 Constantinople Constantinople NNP 37231 1968 36 , , , 37231 1968 37 to to IN 37231 1968 38 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1968 39 Fian Fian NNP 37231 1968 40 and and CC 37231 1968 41 other other JJ 37231 1968 42 witches witch VBZ 37231 1968 43 horribly horribly RB 37231 1968 44 tortured torture VBN 37231 1968 45 and and CC 37231 1968 46 burnt burn VBN 37231 1968 47 for for IN 37231 1968 48 causing cause VBG 37231 1968 49 a a DT 37231 1968 50 stormy stormy JJ 37231 1968 51 passage passage NN 37231 1968 52 on on IN 37231 1968 53 the the DT 37231 1968 54 return return NN 37231 1968 55 of of IN 37231 1968 56 James James NNP 37231 1968 57 I. I. NNP 37231 1968 58 from from IN 37231 1968 59 Denmark Denmark NNP 37231 1968 60 . . . 37231 1969 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1969 2 1 1 LS 37231 1969 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1969 4 Thousands thousand NNS 37231 1969 5 of of IN 37231 1969 6 men man NNS 37231 1969 7 and and CC 37231 1969 8 tens ten NNS 37231 1969 9 of of IN 37231 1969 10 thousands thousand NNS 37231 1969 11 of of IN 37231 1969 12 women woman NNS 37231 1969 13 have have VBP 37231 1969 14 been be VBN 37231 1969 15 done do VBN 37231 1969 16 to to IN 37231 1969 17 death death NN 37231 1969 18 by by IN 37231 1969 19 every every DT 37231 1969 20 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 1969 21 torment torment NN 37231 1969 22 for for IN 37231 1969 23 causing cause VBG 37231 1969 24 sickness sickness NN 37231 1969 25 or or CC 37231 1969 26 calamity calamity NN 37231 1969 27 by by IN 37231 1969 28 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1969 29 , , , 37231 1969 30 or or CC 37231 1969 31 for for IN 37231 1969 32 flying fly VBG 37231 1969 33 through through IN 37231 1969 34 the the DT 37231 1969 35 air air NN 37231 1969 36 to to TO 37231 1969 37 attend attend VB 37231 1969 38 the the DT 37231 1969 39 witches witch NNS 37231 1969 40 ' ' POS 37231 1969 41 sabbath sabbath NNP 37231 1969 42 . . . 37231 1970 1 When when WRB 37231 1970 2 scepticism scepticism NN 37231 1970 3 as as IN 37231 1970 4 to to IN 37231 1970 5 the the DT 37231 1970 6 reality reality NN 37231 1970 7 of of IN 37231 1970 8 the the DT 37231 1970 9 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1970 10 powers power NNS 37231 1970 11 of of IN 37231 1970 12 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1970 13 tardily tardily RB 37231 1970 14 began begin VBD 37231 1970 15 to to TO 37231 1970 16 arise arise VB 37231 1970 17 , , , 37231 1970 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1970 19 was be VBD 37231 1970 20 fiercely fiercely RB 37231 1970 21 reprobated reprobate VBN 37231 1970 22 by by IN 37231 1970 23 the the DT 37231 1970 24 Church Church NNP 37231 1970 25 as as IN 37231 1970 26 infidelity infidelity NN 37231 1970 27 . . . 37231 1971 1 Even even RB 37231 1971 2 so so RB 37231 1971 3 late late RB 37231 1971 4 as as IN 37231 1971 5 the the DT 37231 1971 6 17th 17th JJ 37231 1971 7 century century NN 37231 1971 8 , , , 37231 1971 9 a a DT 37231 1971 10 man man NN 37231 1971 11 like like IN 37231 1971 12 Sir Sir NNP 37231 1971 13 Thomas Thomas NNP 37231 1971 14 Browne Browne NNP 37231 1971 15 not not RB 37231 1971 16 only only RB 37231 1971 17 did do VBD 37231 1971 18 not not RB 37231 1971 19 include include VB 37231 1971 20 the the DT 37231 1971 21 belief belief NN 37231 1971 22 amongst amongst IN 37231 1971 23 the the DT 37231 1971 24 vulgar vulgar JJ 37231 1971 25 errors error NNS 37231 1971 26 which which WDT 37231 1971 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 1971 28 endeavoured endeavour VBD 37231 1971 29 to to TO 37231 1971 30 expose expose VB 37231 1971 31 , , , 37231 1971 32 but but CC 37231 1971 33 on on IN 37231 1971 34 the the DT 37231 1971 35 contrary contrary NN 37231 1971 36 wrote write VBD 37231 1971 37 : : : 37231 1971 38 " " `` 37231 1971 39 For for IN 37231 1971 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1971 41 part part NN 37231 1971 42 , , , 37231 1971 43 I -PRON- PRP 37231 1971 44 have have VBP 37231 1971 45 ever ever RB 37231 1971 46 believed believe VBN 37231 1971 47 , , , 37231 1971 48 and and CC 37231 1971 49 do do VB 37231 1971 50 now now RB 37231 1971 51 know know VB 37231 1971 52 that that IN 37231 1971 53 there there EX 37231 1971 54 are be VBP 37231 1971 55 1 1 CD 37231 1971 56 Pitcairn Pitcairn NNP 37231 1971 57 's 's POS 37231 1971 58 Criminal Criminal NNP 37231 1971 59 Trials Trials NNPS 37231 1971 60 of of IN 37231 1971 61 Scotland Scotland NNP 37231 1971 62 , , , 37231 1971 63 i. i. NNP 37231 1971 64 pp pp NNP 37231 1971 65 . . . 37231 1972 1 213 213 CD 37231 1972 2 , , , 37231 1972 3 223 223 CD 37231 1972 4 . . . 37231 1973 1 { { -LRB- 37231 1973 2 140 140 CD 37231 1973 3 } } -RRB- 37231 1973 4 witches witch NNS 37231 1973 5 . . . 37231 1974 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 1974 2 that that DT 37231 1974 3 doubt doubt NN 37231 1974 4 of of IN 37231 1974 5 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1974 6 , , , 37231 1974 7 do do VBP 37231 1974 8 not not RB 37231 1974 9 only only RB 37231 1974 10 deny deny VB 37231 1974 11 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1974 12 , , , 37231 1974 13 but but CC 37231 1974 14 spirits spirit NNS 37231 1974 15 ; ; : 37231 1974 16 and and CC 37231 1974 17 are be VBP 37231 1974 18 obliquely obliquely JJ 37231 1974 19 , , , 37231 1974 20 and and CC 37231 1974 21 upon upon IN 37231 1974 22 consequence consequence NN 37231 1974 23 , , , 37231 1974 24 a a DT 37231 1974 25 sort sort NN 37231 1974 26 not not RB 37231 1974 27 of of IN 37231 1974 28 infidels infidel NNS 37231 1974 29 , , , 37231 1974 30 but but CC 37231 1974 31 atheists atheist NNS 37231 1974 32 . . . 37231 1975 1 " " `` 37231 1975 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1975 3 1 1 CD 37231 1975 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1975 5 In in IN 37231 1975 6 1664 1664 CD 37231 1975 7 Sir Sir NNP 37231 1975 8 Thomas Thomas NNP 37231 1975 9 Hale Hale NNP 37231 1975 10 , , , 37231 1975 11 in in IN 37231 1975 12 passing pass VBG 37231 1975 13 sentence sentence NN 37231 1975 14 of of IN 37231 1975 15 death death NN 37231 1975 16 against against IN 37231 1975 17 two two CD 37231 1975 18 women woman NNS 37231 1975 19 convicted convict VBN 37231 1975 20 of of IN 37231 1975 21 being be VBG 37231 1975 22 witches witch NNS 37231 1975 23 , , , 37231 1975 24 declared declare VBD 37231 1975 25 that that IN 37231 1975 26 the the DT 37231 1975 27 reality reality NN 37231 1975 28 of of IN 37231 1975 29 witchcraft witchcraft NN 37231 1975 30 was be VBD 37231 1975 31 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 1975 32 , , , 37231 1975 33 because because IN 37231 1975 34 " " `` 37231 1975 35 first first RB 37231 1975 36 , , , 37231 1975 37 the the DT 37231 1975 38 Scriptures scripture NNS 37231 1975 39 had have VBD 37231 1975 40 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 1975 41 so so RB 37231 1975 42 much much RB 37231 1975 43 ; ; : 37231 1975 44 and and CC 37231 1975 45 secondly secondly RB 37231 1975 46 , , , 37231 1975 47 the the DT 37231 1975 48 wisdom wisdom NN 37231 1975 49 of of IN 37231 1975 50 all all DT 37231 1975 51 nations nation NNS 37231 1975 52 had have VBD 37231 1975 53 provided provide VBN 37231 1975 54 laws law NNS 37231 1975 55 against against IN 37231 1975 56 such such JJ 37231 1975 57 persons person NNS 37231 1975 58 , , , 37231 1975 59 which which WDT 37231 1975 60 is be VBZ 37231 1975 61 an an DT 37231 1975 62 argument argument NN 37231 1975 63 of of IN 37231 1975 64 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1975 65 confidence confidence NN 37231 1975 66 of of IN 37231 1975 67 such such PDT 37231 1975 68 a a DT 37231 1975 69 crime crime NN 37231 1975 70 . . . 37231 1976 1 " " `` 37231 1976 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1976 3 2 2 LS 37231 1976 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1976 5 Even even RB 37231 1976 6 the the DT 37231 1976 7 18th 18th JJ 37231 1976 8 century century NN 37231 1976 9 was be VBD 37231 1976 10 stained stain VBN 37231 1976 11 with with IN 37231 1976 12 the the DT 37231 1976 13 blood blood NN 37231 1976 14 of of IN 37231 1976 15 persons person NNS 37231 1976 16 tortured torture VBN 37231 1976 17 and and CC 37231 1976 18 executed execute VBN 37231 1976 19 for for IN 37231 1976 20 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1976 21 . . . 37231 1977 1 Notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 37231 1977 2 all all PDT 37231 1977 3 this this DT 37231 1977 4 persistent persistent JJ 37231 1977 5 and and CC 37231 1977 6 unanimous unanimous JJ 37231 1977 7 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 1977 8 , , , 37231 1977 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1977 10 ask ask VBP 37231 1977 11 again again RB 37231 1977 12 : : : 37231 1977 13 What what WP 37231 1977 14 has have VBZ 37231 1977 15 now now RB 37231 1977 16 become become VBN 37231 1977 17 of of IN 37231 1977 18 the the DT 37231 1977 19 belief belief NN 37231 1977 20 in in IN 37231 1977 21 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1977 22 possession possession NN 37231 1977 23 and and CC 37231 1977 24 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1977 25 ? ? . 37231 1978 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1978 2 has have VBZ 37231 1978 3 utterly utterly RB 37231 1978 4 disappeared disappear VBN 37231 1978 5 . . . 37231 1979 1 " " `` 37231 1979 2 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 1979 3 Mede Mede NNP 37231 1979 4 , , , 37231 1979 5 Lardner Lardner NNP 37231 1979 6 , , , 37231 1979 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 1979 8 Mead Mead NNP 37231 1979 9 , , , 37231 1979 10 Paley Paley NNP 37231 1979 11 , , , 37231 1979 12 and and CC 37231 1979 13 all all PDT 37231 1979 14 the the DT 37231 1979 15 learned learn VBN 37231 1979 16 modern modern JJ 37231 1979 17 writers writer NNS 37231 1979 18 " " '' 37231 1979 19 with with IN 37231 1979 20 Dean Dean NNP 37231 1979 21 Milinan Milinan NNP 37231 1979 22 , , , 37231 1979 23 as as IN 37231 1979 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 1979 25 have have VBP 37231 1979 26 seen see VBN 37231 1979 27 , , , 37231 1979 28 explain explain VB 37231 1979 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1979 30 away away RB 37231 1979 31 , , , 37231 1979 32 and and CC 37231 1979 33 such such PDT 37231 1979 34 a a DT 37231 1979 35 theory theory NN 37231 1979 36 of of IN 37231 1979 37 disease disease NN 37231 1979 38 and and CC 37231 1979 39 elemental elemental JJ 37231 1979 40 disturbance disturbance NN 37231 1979 41 is be VBZ 37231 1979 42 universally universally RB 37231 1979 43 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1979 44 to to TO 37231 1979 45 have have VB 37231 1979 46 been be VBN 37231 1979 47 a a DT 37231 1979 48 groundless groundless JJ 37231 1979 49 superstition superstition NN 37231 1979 50 . . . 37231 1980 1 The the DT 37231 1980 2 countless countless JJ 37231 1980 3 number number NN 37231 1980 4 of of IN 37231 1980 5 persons person NNS 37231 1980 6 tormented torment VBN 37231 1980 7 and and CC 37231 1980 8 put put VBN 37231 1980 9 to to IN 37231 1980 10 death death NN 37231 1980 11 for for IN 37231 1980 12 the the DT 37231 1980 13 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1980 14 crime crime NN 37231 1980 15 of of IN 37231 1980 16 witchcraft witchcraft NN 37231 1980 17 and and CC 37231 1980 18 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 1980 19 were be VBD 37231 1980 20 mere mere JJ 37231 1980 21 innocent innocent JJ 37231 1980 22 victims victim NNS 37231 1980 23 to to TO 37231 1980 24 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1980 25 and and CC 37231 1980 26 credulity credulity NN 37231 1980 27 . . . 37231 1981 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 1981 2 Buckle Buckle NNP 37231 1981 3 has have VBZ 37231 1981 4 collected collect VBN 37231 1981 5 a a DT 37231 1981 6 mass mass NN 37231 1981 7 of of IN 37231 1981 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 1981 9 to to TO 37231 1981 10 show show VB 37231 1981 11 that that IN 37231 1981 12 " " `` 37231 1981 13 there there EX 37231 1981 14 is be VBZ 37231 1981 15 in in IN 37231 1981 16 every every DT 37231 1981 17 part part NN 37231 1981 18 of of IN 37231 1981 19 the the DT 37231 1981 20 world world NN 37231 1981 21 an an DT 37231 1981 22 intimate intimate JJ 37231 1981 23 relation relation NN 37231 1981 24 between between IN 37231 1981 25 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1981 26 respecting respect VBG 37231 1981 27 the the DT 37231 1981 28 nature nature NN 37231 1981 29 and and CC 37231 1981 30 proper proper JJ 37231 1981 31 treating treating NN 37231 1981 32 of of IN 37231 1981 33 a a DT 37231 1981 34 disease disease NN 37231 1981 35 , , , 37231 1981 36 and and CC 37231 1981 37 { { -LRB- 37231 1981 38 150 150 CD 37231 1981 39 } } -RRB- 37231 1981 40 the the DT 37231 1981 41 belief belief NN 37231 1981 42 that that IN 37231 1981 43 such such JJ 37231 1981 44 disease disease NN 37231 1981 45 is be VBZ 37231 1981 46 caused cause VBN 37231 1981 47 by by IN 37231 1981 48 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1981 49 power power NN 37231 1981 50 , , , 37231 1981 51 and and CC 37231 1981 52 is be VBZ 37231 1981 53 to to TO 37231 1981 54 be be VB 37231 1981 55 cured cure VBN 37231 1981 56 by by IN 37231 1981 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1981 58 . . . 37231 1982 1 " " `` 37231 1982 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 1982 3 1 1 CD 37231 1982 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 1982 5 At at IN 37231 1982 6 the the DT 37231 1982 7 commencement commencement NN 37231 1982 8 of of IN 37231 1982 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1982 10 era era NN 37231 1982 11 every every DT 37231 1982 12 disease disease NN 37231 1982 13 was be VBD 37231 1982 14 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 1982 15 to to IN 37231 1982 16 the the DT 37231 1982 17 agency agency NN 37231 1982 18 of of IN 37231 1982 19 demons demon NNS 37231 1982 20 simply simply RB 37231 1982 21 because because IN 37231 1982 22 the the DT 37231 1982 23 nature nature NN 37231 1982 24 of of IN 37231 1982 25 disease disease NN 37231 1982 26 was be VBD 37231 1982 27 not not RB 37231 1982 28 understood understand VBN 37231 1982 29 , , , 37231 1982 30 and and CC 37231 1982 31 the the DT 37231 1982 32 writers writer NNS 37231 1982 33 of of IN 37231 1982 34 the the DT 37231 1982 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1982 36 were be VBD 37231 1982 37 not not RB 37231 1982 38 , , , 37231 1982 39 in in IN 37231 1982 40 this this DT 37231 1982 41 respect respect NN 37231 1982 42 , , , 37231 1982 43 one one CD 37231 1982 44 whit whit NN 37231 1982 45 more more RBR 37231 1982 46 enlightened enlighten VBN 37231 1982 47 than than IN 37231 1982 48 the the DT 37231 1982 49 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1982 50 . . . 37231 1983 1 The the DT 37231 1983 2 progress progress NN 37231 1983 3 of of IN 37231 1983 4 science science NN 37231 1983 5 , , , 37231 1983 6 however however RB 37231 1983 7 , , , 37231 1983 8 has have VBZ 37231 1983 9 not not RB 37231 1983 10 only only RB 37231 1983 11 dispelled dispel VBN 37231 1983 12 the the DT 37231 1983 13 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 1983 14 theory theory NN 37231 1983 15 as as IN 37231 1983 16 regards regard VBZ 37231 1983 17 disease disease NN 37231 1983 18 in in IN 37231 1983 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1983 20 time time NN 37231 1983 21 ; ; : 37231 1983 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1983 23 effects effect NNS 37231 1983 24 are be VBP 37231 1983 25 retrospective retrospective JJ 37231 1983 26 . . . 37231 1984 1 Science science NN 37231 1984 2 not not RB 37231 1984 3 only only RB 37231 1984 4 declares declare VBZ 37231 1984 5 the the DT 37231 1984 6 ascription ascription NN 37231 1984 7 of of IN 37231 1984 8 disease disease NN 37231 1984 9 to to IN 37231 1984 10 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1984 11 possession possession NN 37231 1984 12 or or CC 37231 1984 13 malignity malignity NN 37231 1984 14 to to TO 37231 1984 15 be be VB 37231 1984 16 an an DT 37231 1984 17 idle idle JJ 37231 1984 18 superstition superstition NN 37231 1984 19 now now RB 37231 1984 20 , , , 37231 1984 21 but but CC 37231 1984 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1984 23 equally equally RB 37231 1984 24 repudiates repudiate VBZ 37231 1984 25 the the DT 37231 1984 26 assumption assumption NN 37231 1984 27 of of IN 37231 1984 28 such such PDT 37231 1984 29 a a DT 37231 1984 30 cause cause NN 37231 1984 31 at at IN 37231 1984 32 any any DT 37231 1984 33 time time NN 37231 1984 34 . . . 37231 1985 1 The the DT 37231 1985 2 diseases disease NNS 37231 1985 3 referred refer VBN 37231 1985 4 by by IN 37231 1985 5 the the DT 37231 1985 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1985 7 , , , 37231 1985 8 and and CC 37231 1985 9 by by IN 37231 1985 10 the the DT 37231 1985 11 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 1985 12 of of IN 37231 1985 13 that that DT 37231 1985 14 time time NN 37231 1985 15 , , , 37231 1985 16 to to IN 37231 1985 17 the the DT 37231 1985 18 action action NN 37231 1985 19 of of IN 37231 1985 20 devils devil NNS 37231 1985 21 , , , 37231 1985 22 exist exist VBP 37231 1985 23 now now RB 37231 1985 24 , , , 37231 1985 25 but but CC 37231 1985 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1985 27 are be VBP 37231 1985 28 known know VBN 37231 1985 29 to to TO 37231 1985 30 proceed proceed VB 37231 1985 31 from from IN 37231 1985 32 purely purely RB 37231 1985 33 physical physical JJ 37231 1985 34 causes cause NNS 37231 1985 35 . . . 37231 1986 1 The the DT 37231 1986 2 same same JJ 37231 1986 3 superstition superstition NN 37231 1986 4 and and CC 37231 1986 5 medical medical JJ 37231 1986 6 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1986 7 would would MD 37231 1986 8 enunciate enunciate VB 37231 1986 9 the the DT 37231 1986 10 same same JJ 37231 1986 11 diagnosis diagnosis NN 37231 1986 12 at at IN 37231 1986 13 the the DT 37231 1986 14 present present JJ 37231 1986 15 day day NN 37231 1986 16 . . . 37231 1987 1 The the DT 37231 1987 2 superstition superstition NN 37231 1987 3 and and CC 37231 1987 4 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 1987 5 , , , 37231 1987 6 however however RB 37231 1987 7 , , , 37231 1987 8 have have VBP 37231 1987 9 passed pass VBN 37231 1987 10 away away RP 37231 1987 11 , , , 37231 1987 12 and and CC 37231 1987 13 with with IN 37231 1987 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1987 15 the the DT 37231 1987 16 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1987 17 theory theory NN 37231 1987 18 . . . 37231 1988 1 In in IN 37231 1988 2 that that DT 37231 1988 3 day day NN 37231 1988 4 the the DT 37231 1988 5 theory theory NN 37231 1988 6 was be VBD 37231 1988 7 as as RB 37231 1988 8 baseless baseless JJ 37231 1988 9 as as IN 37231 1988 10 in in IN 37231 1988 11 this this DT 37231 1988 12 . . . 37231 1989 1 This this DT 37231 1989 2 is be VBZ 37231 1989 3 the the DT 37231 1989 4 logical logical JJ 37231 1989 5 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 1989 6 of of IN 37231 1989 7 every every DT 37231 1989 8 educated educated JJ 37231 1989 9 man man NN 37231 1989 10 . . . 37231 1990 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1990 2 is be VBZ 37231 1990 3 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1990 4 that that IN 37231 1990 5 , , , 37231 1990 6 with with IN 37231 1990 7 the the DT 37231 1990 8 necessary necessary JJ 37231 1990 9 abandonment abandonment NN 37231 1990 10 of of IN 37231 1990 11 the the DT 37231 1990 12 theory theory NN 37231 1990 13 of of IN 37231 1990 14 " " `` 37231 1990 15 possession possession NN 37231 1990 16 " " '' 37231 1990 17 and and CC 37231 1990 18 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 1990 19 origin origin NN 37231 1990 20 of of IN 37231 1990 21 disease disease NNP 37231 1990 22 , , , 37231 1990 23 the the DT 37231 1990 24 largest large JJS 37231 1990 25 class class NN 37231 1990 26 of of IN 37231 1990 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1990 28 recorded record VBN 37231 1990 29 in in IN 37231 1990 30 the the DT 37231 1990 31 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1990 32 is be VBZ 37231 1990 33 at at IN 37231 1990 34 once once RB 37231 1990 35 exploded explode VBN 37231 1990 36 . . . 37231 1991 1 The the DT 37231 1991 2 asserted asserted JJ 37231 1991 3 cause cause NN 37231 1991 4 of of IN 37231 1991 5 the the DT 37231 1991 6 diseases disease NNS 37231 1991 7 of of IN 37231 1991 8 this this DT 37231 1991 9 class class NN 37231 1991 10 , , , 37231 1991 11 said say VBD 37231 1991 12 to to TO 37231 1991 13 have have VB 37231 1991 14 been be VBN 37231 1991 15 miraculously miraculously RB 37231 1991 16 healed heal VBN 37231 1991 17 , , , 37231 1991 18 must must MD 37231 1991 19 be be VB 37231 1991 20 recognized recognize VBN 37231 1991 21 to to TO 37231 1991 22 be be VB 37231 1991 23 a a DT 37231 1991 24 mere mere JJ 37231 1991 25 vulgar vulgar JJ 37231 1991 26 superstition superstition NN 37231 1991 27 , , , 37231 1991 28 and and CC 37231 1991 29 the the DT 37231 1991 30 narratives narrative NNS 37231 1991 31 of of IN 37231 1991 32 such such JJ 37231 1991 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1991 34 , , , 37231 1991 35 ascribing ascribe VBG 37231 1991 36 as as IN 37231 1991 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1991 38 do do VBP 37231 1991 39 in in IN 37231 1991 40 perfect perfect JJ 37231 1991 41 simplicity simplicity NN 37231 1991 42 distinct distinct JJ 37231 1991 43 objectivity objectivity NN 37231 1991 44 to to IN 37231 1991 45 the the DT 37231 1991 46 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1991 47 " " `` 37231 1991 48 possessing possess VBG 37231 1991 49 " " '' 37231 1991 50 demons demon NNS 37231 1991 51 , , , 37231 1991 52 and and CC 37231 1991 53 reporting report VBG 37231 1991 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1991 55 very very JJ 37231 1991 56 words word NNS 37231 1991 57 and and CC 37231 1991 58 actions action NNS 37231 1991 59 , , , 37231 1991 60 at at IN 37231 1991 61 once once RB 37231 1991 62 assume assume VB 37231 1991 63 the the DT 37231 1991 64 character character NN 37231 1991 65 of of IN 37231 1991 66 mere mere JJ 37231 1991 67 imaginative imaginative JJ 37231 1991 68 and and CC 37231 1991 69 fabulous fabulous JJ 37231 1991 70 writings writing NNS 37231 1991 71 based base VBN 37231 1991 72 upon upon IN 37231 1991 73 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 1991 74 { { -LRB- 37231 1991 75 151 151 CD 37231 1991 76 } } -RRB- 37231 1991 77 tradition tradition NN 37231 1991 78 , , , 37231 1991 79 and and CC 37231 1991 80 can can MD 37231 1991 81 not not RB 37231 1991 82 be be VB 37231 1991 83 accepted accept VBN 37231 1991 84 as as IN 37231 1991 85 the the DT 37231 1991 86 sober sober JJ 37231 1991 87 and and CC 37231 1991 88 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 1991 89 report report NN 37231 1991 90 of of IN 37231 1991 91 eye eye NN 37231 1991 92 - - HYPH 37231 1991 93 witnesses witness NNS 37231 1991 94 . . . 37231 1992 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1992 2 shall shall MD 37231 1992 3 presently presently RB 37231 1992 4 see see VB 37231 1992 5 how how WRB 37231 1992 6 far far RB 37231 1992 7 this.inference this.inference NN 37231 1992 8 is be VBZ 37231 1992 9 supported support VBN 37231 1992 10 by by IN 37231 1992 11 the the DT 37231 1992 12 literary literary JJ 37231 1992 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 1992 14 regarding regard VBG 37231 1992 15 the the DT 37231 1992 16 date date NN 37231 1992 17 and and CC 37231 1992 18 composition composition NN 37231 1992 19 of of IN 37231 1992 20 the the DT 37231 1992 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1992 22 . . . 37231 1993 1 The the DT 37231 1993 2 deduction deduction NN 37231 1993 3 , , , 37231 1993 4 however however RB 37231 1993 5 , , , 37231 1993 6 does do VBZ 37231 1993 7 not not RB 37231 1993 8 end end VB 37231 1993 9 here here RB 37231 1993 10 . . . 37231 1994 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 1994 2 is be VBZ 37231 1994 3 clear clear JJ 37231 1994 4 that that IN 37231 1994 5 , , , 37231 1994 6 this this DT 37231 1994 7 large large JJ 37231 1994 8 class class NN 37231 1994 9 of of IN 37231 1994 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1994 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1994 12 being be VBG 37231 1994 13 due due IN 37231 1994 14 to to IN 37231 1994 15 the the DT 37231 1994 16 superstition superstition NN 37231 1994 17 of of IN 37231 1994 18 an an DT 37231 1994 19 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 1994 20 and and CC 37231 1994 21 credulous credulous JJ 37231 1994 22 age age NN 37231 1994 23 , , , 37231 1994 24 the the DT 37231 1994 25 insufficiency insufficiency NN 37231 1994 26 of of IN 37231 1994 27 the the DT 37231 1994 28 evidence evidence NN 37231 1994 29 for for IN 37231 1994 30 any any DT 37231 1994 31 of of IN 37231 1994 32 the the DT 37231 1994 33 other other JJ 37231 1994 34 supposed suppose VBN 37231 1994 35 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 1994 36 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1994 37 narrated narrate VBN 37231 1994 38 in in IN 37231 1994 39 the the DT 37231 1994 40 same same JJ 37231 1994 41 documents document NNS 37231 1994 42 becomes become VBZ 37231 1994 43 at at IN 37231 1994 44 once once RB 37231 1994 45 apparent apparent JJ 37231 1994 46 . . . 37231 1995 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 1995 2 but but IN 37231 1995 3 the the DT 37231 1995 4 most most RBS 37231 1995 5 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 37231 1995 6 testimony testimony NN 37231 1995 7 could could MD 37231 1995 8 possibly possibly RB 37231 1995 9 warrant warrant VB 37231 1995 10 belief belief NN 37231 1995 11 in in IN 37231 1995 12 statements statement NNS 37231 1995 13 of of IN 37231 1995 14 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 1995 15 events event NNS 37231 1995 16 which which WDT 37231 1995 17 contradict contradict VBP 37231 1995 18 all all DT 37231 1995 19 experience experience NN 37231 1995 20 , , , 37231 1995 21 and and CC 37231 1995 22 are be VBP 37231 1995 23 opposed opposed JJ 37231 1995 24 to to IN 37231 1995 25 all all DT 37231 1995 26 science science NN 37231 1995 27 . . . 37231 1996 1 When when WRB 37231 1996 2 these these DT 37231 1996 3 statements statement NNS 37231 1996 4 , , , 37231 1996 5 however however RB 37231 1996 6 , , , 37231 1996 7 are be VBP 37231 1996 8 not not RB 37231 1996 9 only only RB 37231 1996 10 rendered render VBN 37231 1996 11 , , , 37231 1996 12 _ _ NNP 37231 1996 13 à à NNP 37231 1996 14 priori priori VBP 37231 1996 15 _ _ NNP 37231 1996 16 , , , 37231 1996 17 suspicious suspicious JJ 37231 1996 18 by by IN 37231 1996 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1996 20 proceeding proceeding NN 37231 1996 21 from from IN 37231 1996 22 a a DT 37231 1996 23 period period NN 37231 1996 24 of of IN 37231 1996 25 the the DT 37231 1996 26 grossest gross JJS 37231 1996 27 superstition superstition NN 37231 1996 28 and and CC 37231 1996 29 credulity credulity NN 37231 1996 30 , , , 37231 1996 31 but but CC 37231 1996 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1996 33 becomes become VBZ 37231 1996 34 evident evident JJ 37231 1996 35 that that IN 37231 1996 36 a a DT 37231 1996 37 considerable considerable JJ 37231 1996 38 part part NN 37231 1996 39 of of IN 37231 1996 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 1996 41 is be VBZ 37231 1996 42 due due JJ 37231 1996 43 solely solely RB 37231 1996 44 to to IN 37231 1996 45 that that DT 37231 1996 46 superstition superstition NN 37231 1996 47 and and CC 37231 1996 48 credulity credulity NN 37231 1996 49 , , , 37231 1996 50 by by IN 37231 1996 51 which which WDT 37231 1996 52 , , , 37231 1996 53 moreover moreover RB 37231 1996 54 , , , 37231 1996 55 the the DT 37231 1996 56 rest rest NN 37231 1996 57 may may MD 37231 1996 58 likewise likewise RB 37231 1996 59 be be VB 37231 1996 60 most most RBS 37231 1996 61 naturally naturally RB 37231 1996 62 explained explain VBN 37231 1996 63 , , , 37231 1996 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 1996 65 is be VBZ 37231 1996 66 obvious obvious JJ 37231 1996 67 that that IN 37231 1996 68 they -PRON- PRP 37231 1996 69 can can MD 37231 1996 70 not not RB 37231 1996 71 stand stand VB 37231 1996 72 against against IN 37231 1996 73 the the DT 37231 1996 74 opposing oppose VBG 37231 1996 75 conviction conviction NN 37231 1996 76 of of IN 37231 1996 77 invariable invariable JJ 37231 1996 78 experience experience NN 37231 1996 79 . . . 37231 1997 1 The the DT 37231 1997 2 force force NN 37231 1997 3 of of IN 37231 1997 4 the the DT 37231 1997 5 testimony testimony NN 37231 1997 6 is be VBZ 37231 1997 7 gone go VBN 37231 1997 8 . . . 37231 1998 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 1998 2 are be VBP 37231 1998 3 far far RB 37231 1998 4 from from IN 37231 1998 5 using use VBG 37231 1998 6 this this DT 37231 1998 7 language language NN 37231 1998 8 in in IN 37231 1998 9 an an DT 37231 1998 10 offensive offensive JJ 37231 1998 11 sense sense NN 37231 1998 12 concerning concern VBG 37231 1998 13 the the DT 37231 1998 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 1998 15 narratives narrative NNS 37231 1998 16 , , , 37231 1998 17 which which WDT 37231 1998 18 , , , 37231 1998 19 by by IN 37231 1998 20 the the DT 37231 1998 21 simple simple JJ 37231 1998 22 faith faith NN 37231 1998 23 of of IN 37231 1998 24 the the DT 37231 1998 25 writers writer NNS 37231 1998 26 , , , 37231 1998 27 present present VB 37231 1998 28 the the DT 37231 1998 29 most most RBS 37231 1998 30 noble noble JJ 37231 1998 31 aspect aspect NN 37231 1998 32 of of IN 37231 1998 33 the the DT 37231 1998 34 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 1998 35 of of IN 37231 1998 36 which which WDT 37231 1998 37 superstition superstition NN 37231 1998 38 is be VBZ 37231 1998 39 capable capable JJ 37231 1998 40 . . . 37231 1999 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 1999 2 , , , 37231 1999 3 viewed view VBD 37231 1999 4 as as IN 37231 1999 5 compositions composition NNS 37231 1999 6 gradually gradually RB 37231 1999 7 rising rise VBG 37231 1999 8 out out IN 37231 1999 9 of of IN 37231 1999 10 pious pious JJ 37231 1999 11 tradition tradition NN 37231 1999 12 , , , 37231 1999 13 and and CC 37231 1999 14 representing represent VBG 37231 1999 15 the the DT 37231 1999 16 best good JJS 37231 1999 17 spirit spirit NN 37231 1999 18 of of IN 37231 1999 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1999 20 times time NNS 37231 1999 21 , , , 37231 1999 22 the the DT 37231 1999 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 1999 24 , , , 37231 1999 25 even even RB 37231 1999 26 in in IN 37231 1999 27 ascribing ascribe VBG 37231 1999 28 such such JJ 37231 1999 29 miracles miracle NNS 37231 1999 30 to to IN 37231 1999 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 1999 32 , , , 37231 1999 33 are be VBP 37231 1999 34 a a DT 37231 1999 35 touching touching JJ 37231 1999 36 illustration illustration NN 37231 1999 37 of of IN 37231 1999 38 the the DT 37231 1999 39 veneration veneration NN 37231 1999 40 excited excite VBN 37231 1999 41 by by IN 37231 1999 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 1999 43 elevated elevated JJ 37231 1999 44 character character NN 37231 1999 45 . . . 37231 2000 1 Devout devout JJ 37231 2000 2 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 37231 2000 3 surrounded surround VBD 37231 2000 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2000 5 memory memory NN 37231 2000 6 with with IN 37231 2000 7 the the DT 37231 2000 8 tradition tradition NN 37231 2000 9 of of IN 37231 2000 10 the the DT 37231 2000 11 highest high JJS 37231 2000 12 exhibitions exhibition NNS 37231 2000 13 of of IN 37231 2000 14 power power NN 37231 2000 15 within within IN 37231 2000 16 the the DT 37231 2000 17 range range NN 37231 2000 18 of of IN 37231 2000 19 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 2000 20 imagination imagination NN 37231 2000 21 , , , 37231 2000 22 { { -LRB- 37231 2000 23 152 152 CD 37231 2000 24 } } -RRB- 37231 2000 25 and and CC 37231 2000 26 that that IN 37231 2000 27 these these DT 37231 2000 28 conceptions conception NNS 37231 2000 29 represent represent VBP 37231 2000 30 merely merely RB 37231 2000 31 an an DT 37231 2000 32 idealized idealize VBN 37231 2000 33 form form NN 37231 2000 34 of of IN 37231 2000 35 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 2000 36 superstition superstition NN 37231 2000 37 was be VBD 37231 2000 38 not not RB 37231 2000 39 only only RB 37231 2000 40 natural natural JJ 37231 2000 41 but but CC 37231 2000 42 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 2000 43 . . . 37231 2001 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2001 2 shall shall MD 37231 2001 3 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 2001 4 fully fully RB 37231 2001 5 examine examine VB 37231 2001 6 the the DT 37231 2001 7 character character NN 37231 2001 8 of of IN 37231 2001 9 the the DT 37231 2001 10 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2001 11 , , , 37231 2001 12 but but CC 37231 2001 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2001 14 will will MD 37231 2001 15 be be VB 37231 2001 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 2001 17 here here RB 37231 2001 18 to to TO 37231 2001 19 point point VB 37231 2001 20 out out RP 37231 2001 21 that that IN 37231 2001 22 none none NN 37231 2001 23 of of IN 37231 2001 24 these these DT 37231 2001 25 writings writing NNS 37231 2001 26 lays lays NNPS 37231 2001 27 claim claim NN 37231 2001 28 to to IN 37231 2001 29 any any DT 37231 2001 30 special special JJ 37231 2001 31 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 2001 32 , , , 37231 2001 33 or or CC 37231 2001 34 in in IN 37231 2001 35 the the DT 37231 2001 36 slightest slight JJS 37231 2001 37 degree degree NN 37231 2001 38 pretends pretend NNS 37231 2001 39 to to TO 37231 2001 40 be be VB 37231 2001 41 more more JJR 37231 2001 42 than than IN 37231 2001 43 a a DT 37231 2001 44 human human JJ 37231 2001 45 composition,(1 composition,(1 NN 37231 2001 46 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2001 47 and and CC 37231 2001 48 subject subject VB 37231 2001 49 to to IN 37231 2001 50 the the DT 37231 2001 51 errors error NNS 37231 2001 52 of of IN 37231 2001 53 human human JJ 37231 2001 54 history history NN 37231 2001 55 . . . 37231 2002 1 2 2 LS 37231 2002 2 . . . 37231 2003 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2003 2 have have VBP 37231 2003 3 seen see VBN 37231 2003 4 how how WRB 37231 2003 5 incompetent incompetent JJ 37231 2003 6 those those DT 37231 2003 7 who who WP 37231 2003 8 lived live VBD 37231 2003 9 at at IN 37231 2003 10 the the DT 37231 2003 11 time time NN 37231 2003 12 when when WRB 37231 2003 13 the the DT 37231 2003 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2003 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2003 16 are be VBP 37231 2003 17 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2003 18 to to TO 37231 2003 19 have have VB 37231 2003 20 taken take VBN 37231 2003 21 place place NN 37231 2003 22 were be VBD 37231 2003 23 to to TO 37231 2003 24 furnish furnish VB 37231 2003 25 reliable reliable JJ 37231 2003 26 testimony testimony NN 37231 2003 27 regarding regard VBG 37231 2003 28 such such JJ 37231 2003 29 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2003 30 ; ; : 37231 2003 31 and and CC 37231 2003 32 the the DT 37231 2003 33 gross gross JJ 37231 2003 34 mistake mistake NN 37231 2003 35 committed commit VBD 37231 2003 36 in in IN 37231 2003 37 regard regard NN 37231 2003 38 to to IN 37231 2003 39 the the DT 37231 2003 40 largest large JJS 37231 2003 41 class class NN 37231 2003 42 of of IN 37231 2003 43 these these DT 37231 2003 44 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2003 45 , , , 37231 2003 46 connected connect VBN 37231 2003 47 with with IN 37231 2003 48 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 2003 49 possession possession NN 37231 2003 50 , , , 37231 2003 51 seems seem VBZ 37231 2003 52 altogether altogether RB 37231 2003 53 to to TO 37231 2003 54 destroy destroy VB 37231 2003 55 the the DT 37231 2003 56 value value NN 37231 2003 57 of of IN 37231 2003 58 the the DT 37231 2003 59 evidence evidence NN 37231 2003 60 for for IN 37231 2003 61 the the DT 37231 2003 62 rest rest NN 37231 2003 63 , , , 37231 2003 64 and and CC 37231 2003 65 to to TO 37231 2003 66 connect connect VB 37231 2003 67 the the DT 37231 2003 68 whole whole NN 37231 2003 69 , , , 37231 2003 70 as as IN 37231 2003 71 might may MD 37231 2003 72 have have VB 37231 2003 73 been be VBN 37231 2003 74 expected expect VBN 37231 2003 75 , , , 37231 2003 76 with with IN 37231 2003 77 the the DT 37231 2003 78 general general JJ 37231 2003 79 superstition superstition NN 37231 2003 80 and and CC 37231 2003 81 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2003 82 of of IN 37231 2003 83 the the DT 37231 2003 84 period period NN 37231 2003 85 . . . 37231 2004 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2004 2 may may MD 37231 2004 3 be be VB 37231 2004 4 well well JJ 37231 2004 5 to to TO 37231 2004 6 inquire inquire VB 37231 2004 7 further far RBR 37231 2004 8 , , , 37231 2004 9 whether whether IN 37231 2004 10 there there EX 37231 2004 11 is be VBZ 37231 2004 12 any any DT 37231 2004 13 valid valid JJ 37231 2004 14 reason reason NN 37231 2004 15 for for IN 37231 2004 16 excepting except VBG 37231 2004 17 any any DT 37231 2004 18 of of IN 37231 2004 19 the the DT 37231 2004 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2004 21 of of IN 37231 2004 22 Scripture scripture NN 37231 2004 23 from from IN 37231 2004 24 the the DT 37231 2004 25 fate fate NN 37231 2004 26 of of IN 37231 2004 27 the the DT 37231 2004 28 rest rest NN 37231 2004 29 , , , 37231 2004 30 and and CC 37231 2004 31 whether whether IN 37231 2004 32 , , , 37231 2004 33 in in IN 37231 2004 34 fact fact NN 37231 2004 35 , , , 37231 2004 36 there there EX 37231 2004 37 was be VBD 37231 2004 38 any any DT 37231 2004 39 special special JJ 37231 2004 40 " " `` 37231 2004 41 Age Age NNP 37231 2004 42 of of IN 37231 2004 43 Miracles Miracles NNPS 37231 2004 44 " " '' 37231 2004 45 at at RB 37231 2004 46 all all RB 37231 2004 47 , , , 37231 2004 48 round round IN 37231 2004 49 which which WDT 37231 2004 50 a a DT 37231 2004 51 privileged privileged JJ 37231 2004 52 line line NN 37231 2004 53 can can MD 37231 2004 54 be be VB 37231 2004 55 drawn draw VBN 37231 2004 56 on on IN 37231 2004 57 any any DT 37231 2004 58 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 2004 59 ground ground NN 37231 2004 60 . . . 37231 2005 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2005 2 have have VBP 37231 2005 3 already already RB 37231 2005 4 pointed point VBN 37231 2005 5 out out RP 37231 2005 6 that that IN 37231 2005 7 the the DT 37231 2005 8 kind kind NN 37231 2005 9 of of IN 37231 2005 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 2005 11 which which WDT 37231 2005 12 is be VBZ 37231 2005 13 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2005 14 to to TO 37231 2005 15 attest attest VB 37231 2005 16 the the DT 37231 2005 17 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2005 18 revelation revelation NN 37231 2005 19 of of IN 37231 2005 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2005 21 , , , 37231 2005 22 so so RB 37231 2005 23 far far RB 37231 2005 24 from from IN 37231 2005 25 being be VBG 37231 2005 26 invented invent VBN 37231 2005 27 for for IN 37231 2005 28 the the DT 37231 2005 29 purpose purpose NN 37231 2005 30 , , , 37231 2005 31 was be VBD 37231 2005 32 so so RB 37231 2005 33 hackneyed hackneyed JJ 37231 2005 34 , , , 37231 2005 35 so so RB 37231 2005 36 to to TO 37231 2005 37 speak speak VB 37231 2005 38 , , , 37231 2005 39 as as RB 37231 2005 40 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2005 41 to to TO 37231 2005 42 attract attract VB 37231 2005 43 the the DT 37231 2005 44 { { -LRB- 37231 2005 45 153 153 CD 37231 2005 46 } } -RRB- 37231 2005 47 notice notice NN 37231 2005 48 of of IN 37231 2005 49 the the DT 37231 2005 50 nation nation NN 37231 2005 51 to to TO 37231 2005 52 which which WDT 37231 2005 53 the the DT 37231 2005 54 revelation revelation NN 37231 2005 55 was be VBD 37231 2005 56 , , , 37231 2005 57 in in IN 37231 2005 58 the the DT 37231 2005 59 first first JJ 37231 2005 60 instance instance NN 37231 2005 61 , , , 37231 2005 62 addressed address VBD 37231 2005 63 . . . 37231 2006 1 Not not RB 37231 2006 2 only only RB 37231 2006 3 did do VBD 37231 2006 4 the the DT 37231 2006 5 Old Old NNP 37231 2006 6 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2006 7 contain contain NN 37231 2006 8 accounts account NNS 37231 2006 9 of of IN 37231 2006 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2006 11 of of IN 37231 2006 12 every every DT 37231 2006 13 one one CD 37231 2006 14 of of IN 37231 2006 15 the the DT 37231 2006 16 types type NNS 37231 2006 17 related relate VBN 37231 2006 18 in in IN 37231 2006 19 the the DT 37231 2006 20 New New NNP 37231 2006 21 , , , 37231 2006 22 but but CC 37231 2006 23 most most JJS 37231 2006 24 of of IN 37231 2006 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2006 26 were be VBD 37231 2006 27 believed believe VBN 37231 2006 28 to to TO 37231 2006 29 be be VB 37231 2006 30 commonly commonly RB 37231 2006 31 performed perform VBN 37231 2006 32 both both DT 37231 2006 33 before before IN 37231 2006 34 and and CC 37231 2006 35 after after IN 37231 2006 36 the the DT 37231 2006 37 commencement commencement NN 37231 2006 38 of of IN 37231 2006 39 the the DT 37231 2006 40 Christian christian JJ 37231 2006 41 era era NN 37231 2006 42 . . . 37231 2007 1 That that IN 37231 2007 2 demons demon NNS 37231 2007 3 were be VBD 37231 2007 4 successfully successfully RB 37231 2007 5 exorcised exorcise VBN 37231 2007 6 , , , 37231 2007 7 and and CC 37231 2007 8 diseases disease NNS 37231 2007 9 cured cure VBN 37231 2007 10 , , , 37231 2007 11 by by IN 37231 2007 12 means mean NNS 37231 2007 13 of of IN 37231 2007 14 spells spell NNS 37231 2007 15 and and CC 37231 2007 16 incantations incantation NNS 37231 2007 17 , , , 37231 2007 18 was be VBD 37231 2007 19 never never RB 37231 2007 20 doubted doubt VBN 37231 2007 21 by by IN 37231 2007 22 the the DT 37231 2007 23 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 2007 24 nation nation NN 37231 2007 25 . . . 37231 2008 1 Satanic satanic JJ 37231 2008 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2008 3 , , , 37231 2008 4 moreover moreover RB 37231 2008 5 , , , 37231 2008 6 are be VBP 37231 2008 7 not not RB 37231 2008 8 only only RB 37231 2008 9 recognized recognize VBN 37231 2008 10 throughout throughout IN 37231 2008 11 the the DT 37231 2008 12 Old Old NNP 37231 2008 13 and and CC 37231 2008 14 New New NNP 37231 2008 15 Testaments Testaments NNPS 37231 2008 16 , , , 37231 2008 17 but but CC 37231 2008 18 formed form VBD 37231 2008 19 a a DT 37231 2008 20 leading lead VBG 37231 2008 21 feature feature NN 37231 2008 22 of of IN 37231 2008 23 the the DT 37231 2008 24 Patristic patristic JJ 37231 2008 25 creed creed NN 37231 2008 26 . . . 37231 2009 1 The the DT 37231 2009 2 early early JJ 37231 2009 3 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2009 4 were be VBD 37231 2009 5 not not RB 37231 2009 6 more more RBR 37231 2009 7 ready ready JJ 37231 2009 8 than than IN 37231 2009 9 the the DT 37231 2009 10 heathen heathen NNP 37231 2009 11 to to TO 37231 2009 12 ascribe ascribe VB 37231 2009 13 every every DT 37231 2009 14 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 37231 2009 15 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2009 16 to to IN 37231 2009 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2009 18 agency agency NN 37231 2009 19 , , , 37231 2009 20 and and CC 37231 2009 21 the the DT 37231 2009 22 only only JJ 37231 2009 23 difference difference NN 37231 2009 24 between between IN 37231 2009 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2009 26 was be VBD 37231 2009 27 as as IN 37231 2009 28 to to IN 37231 2009 29 the the DT 37231 2009 30 nature nature NN 37231 2009 31 of of IN 37231 2009 32 that that DT 37231 2009 33 agency agency NN 37231 2009 34 . . . 37231 2010 1 The the DT 37231 2010 2 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2010 3 and and CC 37231 2010 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2010 5 heathen heathen NN 37231 2010 6 neighbours neighbour NNS 37231 2010 7 were be VBD 37231 2010 8 too too RB 37231 2010 9 accustomed accustomed JJ 37231 2010 10 to to IN 37231 2010 11 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2010 12 preternatural preternatural JJ 37231 2010 13 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2010 14 to to TO 37231 2010 15 feel feel VB 37231 2010 16 much much JJ 37231 2010 17 surprise surprise NN 37231 2010 18 or or CC 37231 2010 19 incredulity incredulity NN 37231 2010 20 at at IN 37231 2010 21 the the DT 37231 2010 22 account account NN 37231 2010 23 of of IN 37231 2010 24 Christian christian JJ 37231 2010 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2010 26 ; ; : 37231 2010 27 and and CC 37231 2010 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2010 29 is be VBZ 37231 2010 30 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 2010 31 of of IN 37231 2010 32 the the DT 37231 2010 33 universal universal JJ 37231 2010 34 superstition superstition NN 37231 2010 35 of of IN 37231 2010 36 the the DT 37231 2010 37 period period NN 37231 2010 38 that that WDT 37231 2010 39 the the DT 37231 2010 40 Fathers father NNS 37231 2010 41 did do VBD 37231 2010 42 not not RB 37231 2010 43 dream dream VB 37231 2010 44 of of IN 37231 2010 45 denying deny VBG 37231 2010 46 the the DT 37231 2010 47 reality reality NN 37231 2010 48 of of IN 37231 2010 49 Pagan pagan JJ 37231 2010 50 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2010 51 , , , 37231 2010 52 but but CC 37231 2010 53 merely merely RB 37231 2010 54 attributed attribute VBD 37231 2010 55 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2010 56 to to IN 37231 2010 57 demons demon NNS 37231 2010 58 , , , 37231 2010 59 whilst whilst IN 37231 2010 60 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2010 61 asserted assert VBD 37231 2010 62 the the DT 37231 2010 63 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2010 64 origin origin NN 37231 2010 65 of of IN 37231 2010 66 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2010 67 own own JJ 37231 2010 68 . . . 37231 2011 1 The the DT 37231 2011 2 reality reality NN 37231 2011 3 of of IN 37231 2011 4 the the DT 37231 2011 5 powers power NNS 37231 2011 6 of of IN 37231 2011 7 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 2011 8 was be VBD 37231 2011 9 never never RB 37231 2011 10 questioned question VBN 37231 2011 11 . . . 37231 2012 1 Every every DT 37231 2012 2 marvel marvel NN 37231 2012 3 and and CC 37231 2012 4 every every DT 37231 2012 5 narrative narrative NN 37231 2012 6 of of IN 37231 2012 7 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2012 8 interference interference NN 37231 2012 9 with with IN 37231 2012 10 human human JJ 37231 2012 11 affairs affair NNS 37231 2012 12 seemed seem VBD 37231 2012 13 matter matter RB 37231 2012 14 of of RB 37231 2012 15 course course NN 37231 2012 16 to to IN 37231 2012 17 the the DT 37231 2012 18 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 2012 19 credulity credulity NN 37231 2012 20 of of IN 37231 2012 21 the the DT 37231 2012 22 age age NN 37231 2012 23 . . . 37231 2013 1 However however WRB 37231 2013 2 much much JJ 37231 2013 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2013 4 are be VBP 37231 2013 5 exceptions exception NNS 37231 2013 6 to to IN 37231 2013 7 the the DT 37231 2013 8 order order NN 37231 2013 9 of of IN 37231 2013 10 nature nature NN 37231 2013 11 , , , 37231 2013 12 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2013 13 have have VBP 37231 2013 14 always always RB 37231 2013 15 been be VBN 37231 2013 16 the the DT 37231 2013 17 rule rule NN 37231 2013 18 in in IN 37231 2013 19 the the DT 37231 2013 20 history history NN 37231 2013 21 of of IN 37231 2013 22 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2013 23 . . . 37231 2014 1 In in IN 37231 2014 2 fact fact NN 37231 2014 3 , , , 37231 2014 4 the the DT 37231 2014 5 excess excess NN 37231 2014 6 of of IN 37231 2014 7 belief belief NN 37231 2014 8 in in IN 37231 2014 9 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2014 10 throughout throughout IN 37231 2014 11 many many JJ 37231 2014 12 centuries century NNS 37231 2014 13 of of IN 37231 2014 14 darkness darkness NN 37231 2014 15 is be VBZ 37231 2014 16 fatal fatal JJ 37231 2014 17 to to IN 37231 2014 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2014 19 claims claim NNS 37231 2014 20 to to TO 37231 2014 21 credence credence VB 37231 2014 22 now now RB 37231 2014 23 . . . 37231 2015 1 The the DT 37231 2015 2 Christian christian JJ 37231 2015 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2015 4 are be VBP 37231 2015 5 rendered render VBN 37231 2015 6 almost almost RB 37231 2015 7 as as IN 37231 2015 8 suspicious suspicious JJ 37231 2015 9 from from IN 37231 2015 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2015 11 place place NN 37231 2015 12 in in IN 37231 2015 13 a a DT 37231 2015 14 long long JJ 37231 2015 15 sequence sequence NN 37231 2015 16 of of IN 37231 2015 17 similar similar JJ 37231 2015 18 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2015 19 , , , 37231 2015 20 as as IN 37231 2015 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2015 22 are be VBP 37231 2015 23 by by IN 37231 2015 24 being be VBG 37231 2015 25 exceptions exception NNS 37231 2015 26 { { -LRB- 37231 2015 27 154 154 CD 37231 2015 28 } } -RRB- 37231 2015 29 to to IN 37231 2015 30 the the DT 37231 2015 31 sequence sequence NN 37231 2015 32 of of IN 37231 2015 33 natural natural JJ 37231 2015 34 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2015 35 . . . 37231 2016 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2016 2 would would MD 37231 2016 3 indeed indeed RB 37231 2016 4 be be VB 37231 2016 5 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 2016 6 if if IN 37231 2016 7 whole whole JJ 37231 2016 8 cycles cycle NNS 37231 2016 9 of of IN 37231 2016 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2016 11 occurring occur VBG 37231 2016 12 before before RB 37231 2016 13 and and CC 37231 2016 14 since since IN 37231 2016 15 those those DT 37231 2016 16 of of IN 37231 2016 17 the the DT 37231 2016 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2016 19 , , , 37231 2016 20 and and CC 37231 2016 21 in in IN 37231 2016 22 connection connection NN 37231 2016 23 with with IN 37231 2016 24 every every DT 37231 2016 25 religion religion NN 37231 2016 26 , , , 37231 2016 27 could could MD 37231 2016 28 be be VB 37231 2016 29 repudiated repudiate VBN 37231 2016 30 as as IN 37231 2016 31 fables fable NNS 37231 2016 32 , , , 37231 2016 33 and and CC 37231 2016 34 those those DT 37231 2016 35 alone alone RB 37231 2016 36 maintained maintain VBD 37231 2016 37 as as IN 37231 2016 38 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2016 39 . . . 37231 2017 1 No no DT 37231 2017 2 attempt attempt NN 37231 2017 3 is be VBZ 37231 2017 4 made make VBN 37231 2017 5 to to TO 37231 2017 6 deny deny VB 37231 2017 7 the the DT 37231 2017 8 fact fact NN 37231 2017 9 that that IN 37231 2017 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2017 11 are be VBP 37231 2017 12 common common JJ 37231 2017 13 to to IN 37231 2017 14 all all DT 37231 2017 15 times time NNS 37231 2017 16 and and CC 37231 2017 17 to to IN 37231 2017 18 all all DT 37231 2017 19 religious religious JJ 37231 2017 20 creeds creed NNS 37231 2017 21 . . . 37231 2018 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2018 2 Newman Newman NNP 37231 2018 3 states state VBZ 37231 2018 4 amongst amongst IN 37231 2018 5 the the DT 37231 2018 6 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 2018 7 of of IN 37231 2018 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2018 9 essay essay NN 37231 2018 10 on on IN 37231 2018 11 the the DT 37231 2018 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2018 13 of of IN 37231 2018 14 early early JJ 37231 2018 15 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2018 16 history history NN 37231 2018 17 : : : 37231 2018 18 " " `` 37231 2018 19 That that IN 37231 2018 20 there there EX 37231 2018 21 was be VBD 37231 2018 22 no no DT 37231 2018 23 Age Age NNP 37231 2018 24 of of IN 37231 2018 25 Miracles Miracles NNPS 37231 2018 26 , , , 37231 2018 27 after after IN 37231 2018 28 which which WDT 37231 2018 29 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2018 30 ceased cease VBD 37231 2018 31 ; ; : 37231 2018 32 that that IN 37231 2018 33 there there EX 37231 2018 34 have have VBP 37231 2018 35 been be VBN 37231 2018 36 at at IN 37231 2018 37 all all DT 37231 2018 38 times time NNS 37231 2018 39 true true JJ 37231 2018 40 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2018 41 and and CC 37231 2018 42 false false JJ 37231 2018 43 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2018 44 , , , 37231 2018 45 true true JJ 37231 2018 46 accounts account NNS 37231 2018 47 and and CC 37231 2018 48 false false JJ 37231 2018 49 accounts account NNS 37231 2018 50 ; ; : 37231 2018 51 that that IN 37231 2018 52 no no DT 37231 2018 53 authoritative authoritative JJ 37231 2018 54 guide guide NN 37231 2018 55 is be VBZ 37231 2018 56 supplied supply VBN 37231 2018 57 to to IN 37231 2018 58 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2018 59 for for IN 37231 2018 60 drawing draw VBG 37231 2018 61 the the DT 37231 2018 62 line line NN 37231 2018 63 between between IN 37231 2018 64 the the DT 37231 2018 65 two two CD 37231 2018 66 . . . 37231 2019 1 " " `` 37231 2019 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2019 3 1 1 LS 37231 2019 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2019 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2019 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2019 7 also also RB 37231 2019 8 admits admit VBZ 37231 2019 9 that that IN 37231 2019 10 morbid morbid JJ 37231 2019 11 love love NN 37231 2019 12 of of IN 37231 2019 13 the the DT 37231 2019 14 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 2019 15 in in IN 37231 2019 16 the the DT 37231 2019 17 human human JJ 37231 2019 18 race race NN 37231 2019 19 " " '' 37231 2019 20 has have VBZ 37231 2019 21 produced produce VBN 37231 2019 22 a a DT 37231 2019 23 constant constant JJ 37231 2019 24 stream stream NN 37231 2019 25 of of IN 37231 2019 26 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2019 27 pretension pretension NN 37231 2019 28 in in IN 37231 2019 29 the the DT 37231 2019 30 world world NN 37231 2019 31 , , , 37231 2019 32 which which WDT 37231 2019 33 accompanies accompany VBZ 37231 2019 34 man man NN 37231 2019 35 wherever wherever WRB 37231 2019 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2019 37 is be VBZ 37231 2019 38 found find VBN 37231 2019 39 , , , 37231 2019 40 and and CC 37231 2019 41 is be VBZ 37231 2019 42 a a DT 37231 2019 43 part part NN 37231 2019 44 of of IN 37231 2019 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2019 46 mental mental JJ 37231 2019 47 and and CC 37231 2019 48 physical physical JJ 37231 2019 49 history history NN 37231 2019 50 . . . 37231 2020 1 " " `` 37231 2020 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2020 3 2 2 LS 37231 2020 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2020 5 Ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2020 6 and and CC 37231 2020 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2020 8 invariable invariable JJ 37231 2020 9 attendant attendant NN 37231 2020 10 , , , 37231 2020 11 superstition superstition NN 37231 2020 12 , , , 37231 2020 13 have have VBP 37231 2020 14 done do VBN 37231 2020 15 more more JJR 37231 2020 16 than than IN 37231 2020 17 mere mere JJ 37231 2020 18 love love NN 37231 2020 19 of of IN 37231 2020 20 the the DT 37231 2020 21 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 2020 22 to to TO 37231 2020 23 produce produce VB 37231 2020 24 and and CC 37231 2020 25 perpetuate perpetuate VB 37231 2020 26 belief belief NN 37231 2020 27 in in IN 37231 2020 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2020 29 , , , 37231 2020 30 and and CC 37231 2020 31 there there EX 37231 2020 32 can can MD 37231 2020 33 not not RB 37231 2020 34 be be VB 37231 2020 35 any any DT 37231 2020 36 doubt doubt NN 37231 2020 37 that that IN 37231 2020 38 the the DT 37231 2020 39 removal removal NN 37231 2020 40 of of IN 37231 2020 41 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2020 42 always always RB 37231 2020 43 leads lead VBZ 37231 2020 44 to to IN 37231 2020 45 the the DT 37231 2020 46 cessation cessation NN 37231 2020 47 of of IN 37231 2020 48 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2020 49 . . . 37231 2021 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2021 2 3 3 LS 37231 2021 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2021 4 The the DT 37231 2021 5 Bampton Bampton NNP 37231 2021 6 lecturer lecturer NN 37231 2021 7 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 2021 8 : : : 37231 2021 9 ' ' '' 37231 2021 10 Heathenism heathenism NN 37231 2021 11 had have VBD 37231 2021 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2021 13 running running NN 37231 2021 14 stream stream NN 37231 2021 15 of of IN 37231 2021 16 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2021 17 pretensions pretension NNS 37231 2021 18 in in IN 37231 2021 19 the the DT 37231 2021 20 shape shape NN 37231 2021 21 of of IN 37231 2021 22 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 2021 23 , , , 37231 2021 24 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 2021 25 , , , 37231 2021 26 and and CC 37231 2021 27 the the DT 37231 2021 28 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2021 29 cures cure NNS 37231 2021 30 of of IN 37231 2021 31 diseases disease NNS 37231 2021 32 , , , 37231 2021 33 which which WDT 37231 2021 34 the the DT 37231 2021 35 temples temple NNS 37231 2021 36 of of IN 37231 2021 37 Esculapius Esculapius NNP 37231 2021 38 recorded record VBN 37231 2021 39 with with IN 37231 2021 40 pompous pompous JJ 37231 2021 41 display display NN 37231 2021 42 . . . 37231 2022 1 " " `` 37231 2022 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2022 3 4 4 LS 37231 2022 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2022 5 So so RB 37231 2022 6 far far RB 37231 2022 7 from from IN 37231 2022 8 the the DT 37231 2022 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2022 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2022 11 being be VBG 37231 2022 12 original original JJ 37231 2022 13 , , , 37231 2022 14 and and CC 37231 2022 15 a a DT 37231 2022 16 presentation presentation NN 37231 2022 17 , , , 37231 2022 18 for for IN 37231 2022 19 the the DT 37231 2022 20 first first JJ 37231 2022 21 time time NN 37231 2022 22 , , , 37231 2022 23 of of IN 37231 2022 24 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2022 25 until until IN 37231 2022 26 then then RB 37231 2022 27 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2022 28 { { -LRB- 37231 2022 29 155 155 CD 37231 2022 30 } } -RRB- 37231 2022 31 and and CC 37231 2022 32 unlikely unlikely JJ 37231 2022 33 to to TO 37231 2022 34 suggest suggest VB 37231 2022 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2022 36 to to IN 37231 2022 37 the the DT 37231 2022 38 mind mind NN 37231 2022 39 , , , 37231 2022 40 " " '' 37231 2022 41 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 2022 42 supernaturalism supernaturalism NN 37231 2022 43 was be VBD 37231 2022 44 indeed indeed RB 37231 2022 45 going go VBG 37231 2022 46 on on IN 37231 2022 47 side side NN 37231 2022 48 by by IN 37231 2022 49 side side NN 37231 2022 50 with with IN 37231 2022 51 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2022 52 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2022 53 's 's POS 37231 2022 54 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2022 55 . . . 37231 2023 1 " " `` 37231 2023 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2023 3 1 1 LS 37231 2023 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2023 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2023 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2023 7 , , , 37231 2023 8 however however RB 37231 2023 9 , , , 37231 2023 10 rebuts rebut VBZ 37231 2023 11 the the DT 37231 2023 12 inference inference NN 37231 2023 13 which which WDT 37231 2023 14 has have VBZ 37231 2023 15 been be VBN 37231 2023 16 drawn draw VBN 37231 2023 17 from from IN 37231 2023 18 this this DT 37231 2023 19 : : : 37231 2023 20 " " `` 37231 2023 21 That that IN 37231 2023 22 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2023 23 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2023 24 could could MD 37231 2023 25 not not RB 37231 2023 26 , , , 37231 2023 27 in in IN 37231 2023 28 the the DT 37231 2023 29 very very JJ 37231 2023 30 nature nature NN 37231 2023 31 of of IN 37231 2023 32 the the DT 37231 2023 33 case case NN 37231 2023 34 , , , 37231 2023 35 be be VB 37231 2023 36 evidences evidence NNS 37231 2023 37 of of IN 37231 2023 38 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2023 39 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 2023 40 teaching teaching NN 37231 2023 41 and and CC 37231 2023 42 mission mission NN 37231 2023 43 , , , 37231 2023 44 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37231 2023 45 as as IN 37231 2023 46 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2023 47 were be VBD 37231 2023 48 common common JJ 37231 2023 49 to to IN 37231 2023 50 Himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2023 51 and and CC 37231 2023 52 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2023 53 opponents opponent NNS 37231 2023 54 , , , 37231 2023 55 " " '' 37231 2023 56 by by IN 37231 2023 57 the the DT 37231 2023 58 assertion assertion NN 37231 2023 59 that that IN 37231 2023 60 a a DT 37231 2023 61 very very RB 37231 2023 62 marked marked JJ 37231 2023 63 distinction distinction NN 37231 2023 64 exists exist VBZ 37231 2023 65 between between IN 37231 2023 66 the the DT 37231 2023 67 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2023 68 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2023 69 and and CC 37231 2023 70 all all DT 37231 2023 71 others other NNS 37231 2023 72 . . . 37231 2024 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2024 2 2 2 LS 37231 2024 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2024 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2024 5 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2024 6 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 2024 7 the the DT 37231 2024 8 consequence consequence NN 37231 2024 9 if if IN 37231 2024 10 such such PDT 37231 2024 11 a a DT 37231 2024 12 distinction distinction NN 37231 2024 13 can can MD 37231 2024 14 not not RB 37231 2024 15 be be VB 37231 2024 16 clearly clearly RB 37231 2024 17 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 2024 18 . . . 37231 2025 1 " " `` 37231 2025 2 The the DT 37231 2025 3 criticism criticism NN 37231 2025 4 , , , 37231 2025 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 2025 6 , , , 37231 2025 7 which which WDT 37231 2025 8 _ _ NNP 37231 2025 9 evidential evidential NN 37231 2025 10 _ _ NNP 37231 2025 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2025 12 , , , 37231 2025 13 or or CC 37231 2025 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2025 15 which which WDT 37231 2025 16 serve serve VBP 37231 2025 17 as as IN 37231 2025 18 evidence evidence NN 37231 2025 19 of of IN 37231 2025 20 a a DT 37231 2025 21 revelation revelation NN 37231 2025 22 , , , 37231 2025 23 must must MD 37231 2025 24 come come VB 37231 2025 25 up up RP 37231 2025 26 to to IN 37231 2025 27 , , , 37231 2025 28 if if IN 37231 2025 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2025 30 are be VBP 37231 2025 31 to to TO 37231 2025 32 accomplish accomplish VB 37231 2025 33 the the DT 37231 2025 34 object object NN 37231 2025 35 for for IN 37231 2025 36 which which WDT 37231 2025 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2025 38 are be VBP 37231 2025 39 designed design VBN 37231 2025 40 , , , 37231 2025 41 involves involve VBZ 37231 2025 42 at at IN 37231 2025 43 the the DT 37231 2025 44 outset outset NN 37231 2025 45 this this DT 37231 2025 46 condition,--that condition,--that . 37231 2025 47 the the DT 37231 2025 48 evidence evidence NN 37231 2025 49 of of IN 37231 2025 50 such such JJ 37231 2025 51 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2025 52 must must MD 37231 2025 53 be be VB 37231 2025 54 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 37231 2025 55 from from IN 37231 2025 56 the the DT 37231 2025 57 evidences evidence NNS 37231 2025 58 of of IN 37231 2025 59 this this DT 37231 2025 60 permanent permanent JJ 37231 2025 61 stream stream NN 37231 2025 62 of of IN 37231 2025 63 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2025 64 pretension pretension NN 37231 2025 65 in in IN 37231 2025 66 the the DT 37231 2025 67 world world NN 37231 2025 68 ; ; : 37231 2025 69 that that IN 37231 2025 70 such such JJ 37231 2025 71 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2025 72 must must MD 37231 2025 73 be be VB 37231 2025 74 separated separate VBN 37231 2025 75 by by IN 37231 2025 76 an an DT 37231 2025 77 interval interval NN 37231 2025 78 not not RB 37231 2025 79 only only RB 37231 2025 80 from from IN 37231 2025 81 the the DT 37231 2025 82 facts fact NNS 37231 2025 83 of of IN 37231 2025 84 the the DT 37231 2025 85 order order NN 37231 2025 86 of of IN 37231 2025 87 nature nature NN 37231 2025 88 , , , 37231 2025 89 but but CC 37231 2025 90 also also RB 37231 2025 91 from from IN 37231 2025 92 the the DT 37231 2025 93 common common JJ 37231 2025 94 running running NN 37231 2025 95 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2025 96 , , , 37231 2025 97 which which WDT 37231 2025 98 is be VBZ 37231 2025 99 the the DT 37231 2025 100 simple simple JJ 37231 2025 101 offshoot offshoot NN 37231 2025 102 of of IN 37231 2025 103 human human JJ 37231 2025 104 nature nature NN 37231 2025 105 . . . 37231 2026 1 Can Can MD 37231 2026 2 evidential evidential JJ 37231 2026 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2026 4 be be VB 37231 2026 5 inserted insert VBN 37231 2026 6 in in IN 37231 2026 7 this this DT 37231 2026 8 promiscuous promiscuous JJ 37231 2026 9 mass mass NN 37231 2026 10 , , , 37231 2026 11 so so IN 37231 2026 12 as as IN 37231 2026 13 not not RB 37231 2026 14 to to TO 37231 2026 15 be be VB 37231 2026 16 confounded confound VBN 37231 2026 17 with with IN 37231 2026 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2026 19 , , , 37231 2026 20 but but CC 37231 2026 21 to to TO 37231 2026 22 assert assert VB 37231 2026 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2026 24 own own JJ 37231 2026 25 truth truth NN 37231 2026 26 and and CC 37231 2026 27 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 2026 28 source source NN 37231 2026 29 ? ? . 37231 2027 1 If if IN 37231 2027 2 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2027 3 can can MD 37231 2027 4 not not RB 37231 2027 5 there there EX 37231 2027 6 is be VBZ 37231 2027 7 an an DT 37231 2027 8 end end NN 37231 2027 9 to to IN 37231 2027 10 the the DT 37231 2027 11 proof proof NN 37231 2027 12 of of IN 37231 2027 13 a a DT 37231 2027 14 revelation revelation NN 37231 2027 15 by by IN 37231 2027 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2027 17 : : : 37231 2027 18 if if IN 37231 2027 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2027 20 can can MD 37231 2027 21 , , , 37231 2027 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2027 23 remains remain VBZ 37231 2027 24 to to TO 37231 2027 25 see see VB 37231 2027 26 whether whether IN 37231 2027 27 the the DT 37231 2027 28 Christian christian JJ 37231 2027 29 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2027 30 are be VBP 37231 2027 31 thus thus RB 37231 2027 32 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 37231 2027 33 , , , 37231 2027 34 and and CC 37231 2027 35 whether whether IN 37231 2027 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2027 37 nature nature NN 37231 2027 38 , , , 37231 2027 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2027 40 object object NN 37231 2027 41 , , , 37231 2027 42 and and CC 37231 2027 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2027 44 evidence evidence NN 37231 2027 45 vindicate vindicate VBP 37231 2027 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2027 47 claim claim NN 37231 2027 48 to to IN 37231 2027 49 this this DT 37231 2027 50 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 2027 51 truth truth NN 37231 2027 52 and and CC 37231 2027 53 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2027 54 source source NN 37231 2027 55 . . . 37231 2028 1 " " `` 37231 2028 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2028 3 3 3 LS 37231 2028 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2028 5 Now now RB 37231 2028 6 , , , 37231 2028 7 regarding regard VBG 37231 2028 8 this this DT 37231 2028 9 distinction distinction NN 37231 2028 10 between between IN 37231 2028 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2028 12 and and CC 37231 2028 13 { { -LRB- 37231 2028 14 156 156 CD 37231 2028 15 } } -RRB- 37231 2028 16 other other JJ 37231 2028 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2028 18 , , , 37231 2028 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2028 20 must must MD 37231 2028 21 be be VB 37231 2028 22 observed observe VBN 37231 2028 23 that that IN 37231 2028 24 the the DT 37231 2028 25 religious religious JJ 37231 2028 26 feeling feeling NN 37231 2028 27 which which WDT 37231 2028 28 influenced influence VBD 37231 2028 29 the the DT 37231 2028 30 composition composition NN 37231 2028 31 of of IN 37231 2028 32 the the DT 37231 2028 33 Scripture scripture NN 37231 2028 34 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2028 35 of of IN 37231 2028 36 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2028 37 naturally naturally RB 37231 2028 38 led lead VBD 37231 2028 39 to to IN 37231 2028 40 the the DT 37231 2028 41 exclusion exclusion NN 37231 2028 42 of of IN 37231 2028 43 all all DT 37231 2028 44 that that WDT 37231 2028 45 was be VBD 37231 2028 46 puerile puerile JJ 37231 2028 47 or or CC 37231 2028 48 ignoble ignoble JJ 37231 2028 49 in in IN 37231 2028 50 the the DT 37231 2028 51 traditions tradition NNS 37231 2028 52 preserved preserve VBN 37231 2028 53 regarding regard VBG 37231 2028 54 the the DT 37231 2028 55 Great Great NNP 37231 2028 56 Master Master NNP 37231 2028 57 . . . 37231 2029 1 The the DT 37231 2029 2 elevated elevated JJ 37231 2029 3 character character NN 37231 2029 4 of of IN 37231 2029 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2029 6 afforded afford VBD 37231 2029 7 no no DT 37231 2029 8 basis basis NN 37231 2029 9 for for IN 37231 2029 10 what what WP 37231 2029 11 was be VBD 37231 2029 12 petty petty JJ 37231 2029 13 , , , 37231 2029 14 and and CC 37231 2029 15 the the DT 37231 2029 16 devotion devotion NN 37231 2029 17 with with IN 37231 2029 18 which which WDT 37231 2029 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2029 20 was be VBD 37231 2029 21 regarded regard VBN 37231 2029 22 when when WRB 37231 2029 23 the the DT 37231 2029 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2029 25 were be VBD 37231 2029 26 written write VBN 37231 2029 27 insured insure VBD 37231 2029 28 the the DT 37231 2029 29 noblest noble JJS 37231 2029 30 treatment treatment NN 37231 2029 31 of of IN 37231 2029 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2029 33 history history NN 37231 2029 34 within within IN 37231 2029 35 certain certain JJ 37231 2029 36 limits limit NNS 37231 2029 37 . . . 37231 2030 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2030 2 must must MD 37231 2030 3 , , , 37231 2030 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 2030 5 , , , 37231 2030 6 consider consider VB 37231 2030 7 the the DT 37231 2030 8 bare bare JJ 37231 2030 9 facts fact NNS 37231 2030 10 composing compose VBG 37231 2030 11 the the DT 37231 2030 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2030 13 rather rather RB 37231 2030 14 than than IN 37231 2030 15 the the DT 37231 2030 16 narrative narrative NN 37231 2030 17 of of IN 37231 2030 18 the the DT 37231 2030 19 manner manner NN 37231 2030 20 in in IN 37231 2030 21 which which WDT 37231 2030 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2030 23 are be VBP 37231 2030 24 said say VBN 37231 2030 25 to to TO 37231 2030 26 have have VB 37231 2030 27 been be VBN 37231 2030 28 produced produce VBN 37231 2030 29 , , , 37231 2030 30 in in IN 37231 2030 31 order order NN 37231 2030 32 rightly rightly RB 37231 2030 33 to to TO 37231 2030 34 judge judge VB 37231 2030 35 of of IN 37231 2030 36 the the DT 37231 2030 37 comparative comparative JJ 37231 2030 38 features feature NNS 37231 2030 39 of of IN 37231 2030 40 different different JJ 37231 2030 41 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2030 42 . . . 37231 2031 1 If if IN 37231 2031 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2031 3 take take VBP 37231 2031 4 the the DT 37231 2031 5 case case NN 37231 2031 6 of of IN 37231 2031 7 a a DT 37231 2031 8 person person NN 37231 2031 9 raised raise VBN 37231 2031 10 from from IN 37231 2031 11 the the DT 37231 2031 12 dead dead JJ 37231 2031 13 , , , 37231 2031 14 literary literary JJ 37231 2031 15 skill skill NN 37231 2031 16 may may MD 37231 2031 17 invest invest VB 37231 2031 18 the the DT 37231 2031 19 account account NN 37231 2031 20 with with IN 37231 2031 21 more more RBR 37231 2031 22 or or CC 37231 2031 23 less less JJR 37231 2031 24 of of IN 37231 2031 25 dramatic dramatic JJ 37231 2031 26 interest interest NN 37231 2031 27 and and CC 37231 2031 28 dignity dignity NN 37231 2031 29 , , , 37231 2031 30 but but CC 37231 2031 31 whether whether IN 37231 2031 32 the the DT 37231 2031 33 main main JJ 37231 2031 34 fact fact NN 37231 2031 35 be be VB 37231 2031 36 surrounded surround VBN 37231 2031 37 with with IN 37231 2031 38 pathetic pathetic JJ 37231 2031 39 and and CC 37231 2031 40 picturesque picturesque NN 37231 2031 41 details,.as details,.as NNPS 37231 2031 42 in in IN 37231 2031 43 the the DT 37231 2031 44 account account NN 37231 2031 45 of of IN 37231 2031 46 the the DT 37231 2031 47 raising raising NN 37231 2031 48 of of IN 37231 2031 49 Lazarus Lazarus NNP 37231 2031 50 in in IN 37231 2031 51 the the DT 37231 2031 52 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2031 53 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2031 54 , , , 37231 2031 55 or or CC 37231 2031 56 the the DT 37231 2031 57 person person NN 37231 2031 58 be be VB 37231 2031 59 simply simply RB 37231 2031 60 restored restore VBN 37231 2031 61 to to IN 37231 2031 62 life life NN 37231 2031 63 without without IN 37231 2031 64 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2031 65 , , , 37231 2031 66 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2031 67 is be VBZ 37231 2031 68 the the DT 37231 2031 69 fact fact NN 37231 2031 70 of of IN 37231 2031 71 the the DT 37231 2031 72 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 2031 73 which which WDT 37231 2031 74 constitutes constitute VBZ 37231 2031 75 the the DT 37231 2031 76 miracle miracle NN 37231 2031 77 , , , 37231 2031 78 and and CC 37231 2031 79 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2031 80 is be VBZ 37231 2031 81 in in IN 37231 2031 82 the the DT 37231 2031 83 facts fact NNS 37231 2031 84 alone alone RB 37231 2031 85 that that IN 37231 2031 86 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2031 87 must must MD 37231 2031 88 seek seek VB 37231 2031 89 distinction distinction NN 37231 2031 90 , , , 37231 2031 91 disregarding disregard VBG 37231 2031 92 and and CC 37231 2031 93 distrusting distrust VBG 37231 2031 94 the the DT 37231 2031 95 accessories accessory NNS 37231 2031 96 . . . 37231 2032 1 In in IN 37231 2032 2 the the DT 37231 2032 3 one one CD 37231 2032 4 case case NN 37231 2032 5 the the DT 37231 2032 6 effect effect NN 37231 2032 7 may may MD 37231 2032 8 be be VB 37231 2032 9 much much RB 37231 2032 10 more more RBR 37231 2032 11 impressive impressive JJ 37231 2032 12 , , , 37231 2032 13 but but CC 37231 2032 14 in in IN 37231 2032 15 the the DT 37231 2032 16 other other JJ 37231 2032 17 the the DT 37231 2032 18 bare bare JJ 37231 2032 19 raising raising NN 37231 2032 20 of of IN 37231 2032 21 the the DT 37231 2032 22 dead dead NN 37231 2032 23 is be VBZ 37231 2032 24 not not RB 37231 2032 25 a a DT 37231 2032 26 whit whit NN 37231 2032 27 less less RBR 37231 2032 28 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2032 29 . . . 37231 2033 1 " " `` 37231 2033 2 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2033 3 have have VBP 37231 2033 4 been be VBN 37231 2033 5 accustomed accustom VBN 37231 2033 6 to to TO 37231 2033 7 read read VB 37231 2033 8 the the DT 37231 2033 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2033 10 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2033 11 of of IN 37231 2033 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2033 13 with with IN 37231 2033 14 so so RB 37231 2033 15 much much JJ 37231 2033 16 special special JJ 37231 2033 17 veneration veneration NN 37231 2033 18 , , , 37231 2033 19 that that IN 37231 2033 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2033 21 is be VBZ 37231 2033 22 now now RB 37231 2033 23 difficult difficult JJ 37231 2033 24 to to TO 37231 2033 25 recognize recognize VB 37231 2033 26 how how WRB 37231 2033 27 much much JJ 37231 2033 28 of of IN 37231 2033 29 the the DT 37231 2033 30 distinction distinction NN 37231 2033 31 of of IN 37231 2033 32 these these DT 37231 2033 33 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2033 34 is be VBZ 37231 2033 35 due due JJ 37231 2033 36 to to IN 37231 2033 37 the the DT 37231 2033 38 composition composition NN 37231 2033 39 , , , 37231 2033 40 and and CC 37231 2033 41 to to IN 37231 2033 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2033 43 place place NN 37231 2033 44 in in IN 37231 2033 45 the the DT 37231 2033 46 history history NN 37231 2033 47 of of IN 37231 2033 48 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2033 49 . . . 37231 2034 1 No no DT 37231 2034 2 other other JJ 37231 2034 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2034 4 , , , 37231 2034 5 or or CC 37231 2034 6 account account NN 37231 2034 7 of of IN 37231 2034 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2034 9 , , , 37231 2034 10 ever ever RB 37231 2034 11 had have VBD 37231 2034 12 such such JJ 37231 2034 13 collateral collateral JJ 37231 2034 14 advantages advantage NNS 37231 2034 15 . . . 37231 2035 1 As as IN 37231 2035 2 works work NNS 37231 2035 3 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2035 4 to to IN 37231 2035 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2035 6 sublimest sublime JJS 37231 2035 7 Teacher teacher NN 37231 2035 8 , , , 37231 2035 9 described describe VBN 37231 2035 10 with with IN 37231 2035 11 simple simple JJ 37231 2035 12 eloquence eloquence NN 37231 2035 13 and and CC 37231 2035 14 , , , 37231 2035 15 especially especially RB 37231 2035 16 in in IN 37231 2035 17 the the DT 37231 2035 18 case case NN 37231 2035 19 of of IN 37231 2035 20 those those DT 37231 2035 21 in in IN 37231 2035 22 { { -LRB- 37231 2035 23 157 157 CD 37231 2035 24 } } -RRB- 37231 2035 25 the the DT 37231 2035 26 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2035 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2035 28 , , , 37231 2035 29 with with IN 37231 2035 30 artistic artistic JJ 37231 2035 31 perfection perfection NN 37231 2035 32 , , , 37231 2035 33 and and CC 37231 2035 34 read read VBD 37231 2035 35 generally generally RB 37231 2035 36 with with IN 37231 2035 37 reverential reverential JJ 37231 2035 38 wonder wonder NN 37231 2035 39 untempered untempere VBN 37231 2035 40 by by IN 37231 2035 41 a a DT 37231 2035 42 thought thought NN 37231 2035 43 of of IN 37231 2035 44 criticism criticism NN 37231 2035 45 , , , 37231 2035 46 these these DT 37231 2035 47 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2035 48 have have VBP 37231 2035 49 seemed seem VBN 37231 2035 50 to to TO 37231 2035 51 be be VB 37231 2035 52 surrounded surround VBN 37231 2035 53 by by IN 37231 2035 54 a a DT 37231 2035 55 mystic mystic JJ 37231 2035 56 halo halo NN 37231 2035 57 certainly certainly RB 37231 2035 58 not not RB 37231 2035 59 emanating emanate VBG 37231 2035 60 from from IN 37231 2035 61 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2035 62 . . . 37231 2036 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2036 2 must must MD 37231 2036 3 not not RB 37231 2036 4 be be VB 37231 2036 5 forgotten forget VBN 37231 2036 6 , , , 37231 2036 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 2036 8 , , , 37231 2036 9 that that IN 37231 2036 10 the the DT 37231 2036 11 miracle miracle NN 37231 2036 12 lies lie VBZ 37231 2036 13 in in IN 37231 2036 14 the the DT 37231 2036 15 bare bare JJ 37231 2036 16 act act NN 37231 2036 17 , , , 37231 2036 18 and and CC 37231 2036 19 not not RB 37231 2036 20 in in IN 37231 2036 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2036 22 dramatic dramatic JJ 37231 2036 23 arrangement arrangement NN 37231 2036 24 . . . 37231 2037 1 The the DT 37231 2037 2 restoration restoration NN 37231 2037 3 of of IN 37231 2037 4 life life NN 37231 2037 5 to to IN 37231 2037 6 a a DT 37231 2037 7 dead dead JJ 37231 2037 8 man man NN 37231 2037 9 is be VBZ 37231 2037 10 the the DT 37231 2037 11 very very RB 37231 2037 12 same same JJ 37231 2037 13 miracle miracle NN 37231 2037 14 whether whether IN 37231 2037 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2037 16 be be VB 37231 2037 17 effected effect VBN 37231 2037 18 by by IN 37231 2037 19 the the DT 37231 2037 20 relics relic NNS 37231 2037 21 of of IN 37231 2037 22 a a DT 37231 2037 23 saint saint NN 37231 2037 24 or or CC 37231 2037 25 by by IN 37231 2037 26 the the DT 37231 2037 27 word word NN 37231 2037 28 of of IN 37231 2037 29 an an DT 37231 2037 30 apostle apostle NN 37231 2037 31 . . . 37231 2038 1 A a DT 37231 2038 2 miracle miracle NN 37231 2038 3 is be VBZ 37231 2038 4 not not RB 37231 2038 5 antecedently antecedently RB 37231 2038 6 more more RBR 37231 2038 7 credible credible JJ 37231 2038 8 because because IN 37231 2038 9 of of IN 37231 2038 10 the the DT 37231 2038 11 outstretched outstretched JJ 37231 2038 12 arm arm NN 37231 2038 13 and and CC 37231 2038 14 word word NN 37231 2038 15 of of IN 37231 2038 16 command command NN 37231 2038 17 , , , 37231 2038 18 than than IN 37231 2038 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2038 20 is be VBZ 37231 2038 21 in in IN 37231 2038 22 the the DT 37231 2038 23 silence silence NN 37231 2038 24 of of IN 37231 2038 25 the the DT 37231 2038 26 shrine shrine NN 37231 2038 27 . . . 37231 2039 1 Being be VBG 37231 2039 2 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2039 3 , , , 37231 2039 4 the the DT 37231 2039 5 real real JJ 37231 2039 6 agency agency NN 37231 2039 7 is be VBZ 37231 2039 8 not not RB 37231 2039 9 seen see VBN 37231 2039 10 in in IN 37231 2039 11 either either DT 37231 2039 12 case case NN 37231 2039 13 , , , 37231 2039 14 although although IN 37231 2039 15 the the DT 37231 2039 16 human human JJ 37231 2039 17 mind mind NN 37231 2039 18 is be VBZ 37231 2039 19 more more RBR 37231 2039 20 satisfied satisfied JJ 37231 2039 21 by by IN 37231 2039 22 the the DT 37231 2039 23 presentation presentation NN 37231 2039 24 of of IN 37231 2039 25 an an DT 37231 2039 26 apparent apparent JJ 37231 2039 27 cause cause NN 37231 2039 28 in in IN 37231 2039 29 the the DT 37231 2039 30 one one CD 37231 2039 31 case case NN 37231 2039 32 , , , 37231 2039 33 which which WDT 37231 2039 34 seems seem VBZ 37231 2039 35 to to TO 37231 2039 36 be be VB 37231 2039 37 absent absent JJ 37231 2039 38 in in IN 37231 2039 39 the the DT 37231 2039 40 other other JJ 37231 2039 41 . . . 37231 2040 1 In in IN 37231 2040 2 preferring prefer VBG 37231 2040 3 the the DT 37231 2040 4 former former JJ 37231 2040 5 type type NN 37231 2040 6 , , , 37231 2040 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2040 8 are be VBP 37231 2040 9 not not RB 37231 2040 10 only only RB 37231 2040 11 influenced influence VBN 37231 2040 12 by by IN 37231 2040 13 a a DT 37231 2040 14 more more RBR 37231 2040 15 dramatic dramatic JJ 37231 2040 16 narrative narrative NN 37231 2040 17 , , , 37231 2040 18 but but CC 37231 2040 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2040 20 select select VBP 37231 2040 21 for for IN 37231 2040 22 belief belief NN 37231 2040 23 the the DT 37231 2040 24 miracle miracle NN 37231 2040 25 from from IN 37231 2040 26 which which WDT 37231 2040 27 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2040 28 can can MD 37231 2040 29 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 2040 30 eliminate eliminate VB 37231 2040 31 more more JJR 37231 2040 32 of of IN 37231 2040 33 the the DT 37231 2040 34 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2040 35 elements element NNS 37231 2040 36 , , , 37231 2040 37 by by IN 37231 2040 38 tracing trace VBG 37231 2040 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2040 40 to to IN 37231 2040 41 a a DT 37231 2040 42 visible visible JJ 37231 2040 43 natural natural JJ 37231 2040 44 cause cause NN 37231 2040 45 which which WDT 37231 2040 46 can can MD 37231 2040 47 not not RB 37231 2040 48 be be VB 37231 2040 49 seen see VBN 37231 2040 50 in in IN 37231 2040 51 the the DT 37231 2040 52 latter latter NN 37231 2040 53 . . . 37231 2041 1 The the DT 37231 2041 2 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 2041 3 incredibility incredibility NN 37231 2041 4 of of IN 37231 2041 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2041 6 , , , 37231 2041 7 however however RB 37231 2041 8 , , , 37231 2041 9 is be VBZ 37231 2041 10 not not RB 37231 2041 11 affected affect VBN 37231 2041 12 by by IN 37231 2041 13 literary literary JJ 37231 2041 14 skill skill NN 37231 2041 15 , , , 37231 2041 16 and and CC 37231 2041 17 is be VBZ 37231 2041 18 independent independent JJ 37231 2041 19 of of IN 37231 2041 20 scenic scenic JJ 37231 2041 21 effect effect NN 37231 2041 22 . . . 37231 2042 1 The the DT 37231 2042 2 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 2042 3 of of IN 37231 2042 4 Dublin Dublin NNP 37231 2042 5 says say VBZ 37231 2042 6 : : : 37231 2042 7 " " `` 37231 2042 8 Few few JJ 37231 2042 9 points point NNS 37231 2042 10 present present VBP 37231 2042 11 greater great JJR 37231 2042 12 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 2042 13 than than IN 37231 2042 14 the the DT 37231 2042 15 attempt attempt NN 37231 2042 16 to to TO 37231 2042 17 fix fix VB 37231 2042 18 accurately accurately RB 37231 2042 19 the the DT 37231 2042 20 moment moment NN 37231 2042 21 when when WRB 37231 2042 22 these these DT 37231 2042 23 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2042 24 powers power NNS 37231 2042 25 were be VBD 37231 2042 26 withdrawn withdraw VBN 37231 2042 27 from from IN 37231 2042 28 the the DT 37231 2042 29 Church Church NNP 37231 2042 30 ; ; : 37231 2042 31 " " '' 37231 2042 32 and and CC 37231 2042 33 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2042 34 argues argue VBZ 37231 2042 35 that that IN 37231 2042 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2042 37 were be VBD 37231 2042 38 withdrawn withdraw VBN 37231 2042 39 when when WRB 37231 2042 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2042 41 entered enter VBD 37231 2042 42 into into IN 37231 2042 43 what what WP 37231 2042 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2042 45 calls call VBZ 37231 2042 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2042 47 permanent permanent JJ 37231 2042 48 state state NN 37231 2042 49 , , , 37231 2042 50 and and CC 37231 2042 51 no no RB 37231 2042 52 longer long RBR 37231 2042 53 required require VBD 37231 2042 54 " " '' 37231 2042 55 these these DT 37231 2042 56 props prop NNS 37231 2042 57 and and CC 37231 2042 58 strengthenings strengthening NNS 37231 2042 59 of of IN 37231 2042 60 the the DT 37231 2042 61 infant infant NN 37231 2042 62 plant plant NN 37231 2042 63 . . . 37231 2043 1 " " `` 37231 2043 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2043 3 1 1 LS 37231 2043 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2043 5 That that IN 37231 2043 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2043 7 retrocession retrocession NN 37231 2043 8 was be VBD 37231 2043 9 gradual gradual JJ 37231 2043 10 , , , 37231 2043 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2043 12 considers consider VBZ 37231 2043 13 natural natural JJ 37231 2043 14 , , , 37231 2043 15 and and CC 37231 2043 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2043 17 imagines imagine VBZ 37231 2043 18 the the DT 37231 2043 19 fulness fulness NN 37231 2043 20 of of IN 37231 2043 21 Divine divine JJ 37231 2043 22 power power NN 37231 2043 23 as as IN 37231 2043 24 gradually gradually RB 37231 2043 25 waning wane VBG 37231 2043 26 as as IN 37231 2043 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2043 28 was be VBD 37231 2043 29 { { -LRB- 37231 2043 30 158 158 CD 37231 2043 31 } } -RRB- 37231 2043 32 subdivided subdivided JJ 37231 2043 33 , , , 37231 2043 34 first first RB 37231 2043 35 among among IN 37231 2043 36 the the DT 37231 2043 37 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 2043 38 , , , 37231 2043 39 and and CC 37231 2043 40 then then RB 37231 2043 41 amongst amongst IN 37231 2043 42 the the DT 37231 2043 43 ever ever RB 37231 2043 44 - - HYPH 37231 2043 45 multiplying multiply VBG 37231 2043 46 members member NNS 37231 2043 47 of of IN 37231 2043 48 the the DT 37231 2043 49 Church Church NNP 37231 2043 50 , , , 37231 2043 51 until until IN 37231 2043 52 by by IN 37231 2043 53 sub sub NN 37231 2043 54 - - NN 37231 2043 55 division division NN 37231 2043 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2043 57 became become VBD 37231 2043 58 virtually virtually RB 37231 2043 59 extinct extinct JJ 37231 2043 60 , , , 37231 2043 61 leaving leave VBG 37231 2043 62 as as IN 37231 2043 63 a a DT 37231 2043 64 substitute substitute NN 37231 2043 65 " " `` 37231 2043 66 the the DT 37231 2043 67 standing stand VBG 37231 2043 68 wonder wonder NN 37231 2043 69 of of IN 37231 2043 70 a a DT 37231 2043 71 Church Church NNP 37231 2043 72 . . . 37231 2044 1 " " `` 37231 2044 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2044 3 1 1 LS 37231 2044 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2044 5 This this DT 37231 2044 6 , , , 37231 2044 7 of of IN 37231 2044 8 course course NN 37231 2044 9 , , , 37231 2044 10 is be VBZ 37231 2044 11 not not RB 37231 2044 12 argument argument NN 37231 2044 13 , , , 37231 2044 14 but but CC 37231 2044 15 merely merely RB 37231 2044 16 the the DT 37231 2044 17 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 2044 18 's 's POS 37231 2044 19 fanciful fanciful JJ 37231 2044 20 explanation explanation NN 37231 2044 21 of of IN 37231 2044 22 a a DT 37231 2044 23 serious serious JJ 37231 2044 24 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 2044 25 . . . 37231 2045 1 The the DT 37231 2045 2 fact fact NN 37231 2045 3 is be VBZ 37231 2045 4 , , , 37231 2045 5 however however RB 37231 2045 6 , , , 37231 2045 7 that that IN 37231 2045 8 the the DT 37231 2045 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2045 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2045 11 were be VBD 37231 2045 12 preceded precede VBN 37231 2045 13 and and CC 37231 2045 14 accompanied accompany VBN 37231 2045 15 by by IN 37231 2045 16 others other NNS 37231 2045 17 of of IN 37231 2045 18 the the DT 37231 2045 19 same same JJ 37231 2045 20 type type NN 37231 2045 21 , , , 37231 2045 22 and and CC 37231 2045 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2045 24 may may MD 37231 2045 25 here here RB 37231 2045 26 merely merely RB 37231 2045 27 mention mention VB 37231 2045 28 exorcism exorcism NN 37231 2045 29 of of IN 37231 2045 30 demons demon NNS 37231 2045 31 , , , 37231 2045 32 and and CC 37231 2045 33 the the DT 37231 2045 34 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2045 35 cure cure NN 37231 2045 36 of of IN 37231 2045 37 disease disease NN 37231 2045 38 , , , 37231 2045 39 as as IN 37231 2045 40 popular popular JJ 37231 2045 41 instances instance NNS 37231 2045 42 ; ; : 37231 2045 43 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2045 44 were be VBD 37231 2045 45 also also RB 37231 2045 46 followed follow VBN 37231 2045 47 by by IN 37231 2045 48 a a DT 37231 2045 49 long long JJ 37231 2045 50 succession succession NN 37231 2045 51 of of IN 37231 2045 52 others other NNS 37231 2045 53 , , , 37231 2045 54 quite quite RB 37231 2045 55 as as RB 37231 2045 56 well well RB 37231 2045 57 authenticated authenticate VBN 37231 2045 58 , , , 37231 2045 59 whose whose WP$ 37231 2045 60 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2045 61 only only RB 37231 2045 62 became become VBD 37231 2045 63 less less RBR 37231 2045 64 frequent frequent JJ 37231 2045 65 in in IN 37231 2045 66 proportion proportion NN 37231 2045 67 as as IN 37231 2045 68 the the DT 37231 2045 69 diffusion diffusion NN 37231 2045 70 of of IN 37231 2045 71 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2045 72 dispelled dispel VBD 37231 2045 73 popular popular JJ 37231 2045 74 credulity credulity NN 37231 2045 75 . . . 37231 2046 1 Even even RB 37231 2046 2 at at IN 37231 2046 3 the the DT 37231 2046 4 present present JJ 37231 2046 5 day day NN 37231 2046 6 a a DT 37231 2046 7 stray stray JJ 37231 2046 8 miracle miracle NN 37231 2046 9 is be VBZ 37231 2046 10 from from IN 37231 2046 11 time time NN 37231 2046 12 to to IN 37231 2046 13 time time NN 37231 2046 14 reported report VBN 37231 2046 15 in in IN 37231 2046 16 outlying outlying JJ 37231 2046 17 districts district NNS 37231 2046 18 , , , 37231 2046 19 where where WRB 37231 2046 20 the the DT 37231 2046 21 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2046 22 and and CC 37231 2046 23 superstition superstition NN 37231 2046 24 which which WDT 37231 2046 25 formerly formerly RB 37231 2046 26 produced produce VBD 37231 2046 27 so so RB 37231 2046 28 abundant abundant JJ 37231 2046 29 a a DT 37231 2046 30 growth growth NN 37231 2046 31 of of IN 37231 2046 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2046 33 are be VBP 37231 2046 34 not not RB 37231 2046 35 yet yet RB 37231 2046 36 entirely entirely RB 37231 2046 37 dispelled dispel VBN 37231 2046 38 . . . 37231 2047 1 Papias Papias NNP 37231 2047 2 of of IN 37231 2047 3 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 37231 2047 4 narrates narrate VBZ 37231 2047 5 a a DT 37231 2047 6 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 2047 7 story story NN 37231 2047 8 , , , 37231 2047 9 according accord VBG 37231 2047 10 to to IN 37231 2047 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2047 12 , , , 37231 2047 13 which which WDT 37231 2047 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2047 15 had have VBD 37231 2047 16 heard hear VBN 37231 2047 17 from from IN 37231 2047 18 the the DT 37231 2047 19 daughters daughter NNS 37231 2047 20 of of IN 37231 2047 21 the the DT 37231 2047 22 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2047 23 Philip Philip NNP 37231 2047 24 , , , 37231 2047 25 who who WP 37231 2047 26 lived live VBD 37231 2047 27 at at IN 37231 2047 28 the the DT 37231 2047 29 same same JJ 37231 2047 30 time time NN 37231 2047 31 in in IN 37231 2047 32 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 37231 2047 33 : : : 37231 2047 34 " " `` 37231 2047 35 For for IN 37231 2047 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2047 37 relates relate VBZ 37231 2047 38 that that IN 37231 2047 39 a a DT 37231 2047 40 dead dead JJ 37231 2047 41 man man NN 37231 2047 42 was be VBD 37231 2047 43 restored restore VBN 37231 2047 44 to to IN 37231 2047 45 life life NN 37231 2047 46 in in IN 37231 2047 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2047 48 day day NN 37231 2047 49 . . . 37231 2048 1 " " `` 37231 2048 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2048 3 2 2 LS 37231 2048 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2048 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 2048 6 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 2048 7 , , , 37231 2048 8 speaking speak VBG 37231 2048 9 of of IN 37231 2048 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2048 11 own own JJ 37231 2048 12 time time NN 37231 2048 13 , , , 37231 2048 14 frequently frequently RB 37231 2048 15 asserts assert VBZ 37231 2048 16 that that IN 37231 2048 17 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2048 18 still still RB 37231 2048 19 receive receive VBP 37231 2048 20 the the DT 37231 2048 21 gift gift NN 37231 2048 22 of of IN 37231 2048 23 healing healing NN 37231 2048 24 , , , 37231 2048 25 of of IN 37231 2048 26 foreknowledge foreknowledge NN 37231 2048 27 , , , 37231 2048 28 and and CC 37231 2048 29 of of IN 37231 2048 30 prophecy,(3 prophecy,(3 NN 37231 2048 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2048 32 and and CC 37231 2048 33 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2048 34 points point VBZ 37231 2048 35 out out RP 37231 2048 36 to to IN 37231 2048 37 the the DT 37231 2048 38 Roman roman JJ 37231 2048 39 Senate Senate NNP 37231 2048 40 as as IN 37231 2048 41 a a DT 37231 2048 42 fact fact NN 37231 2048 43 happening happen VBG 37231 2048 44 under under IN 37231 2048 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2048 46 own own JJ 37231 2048 47 observation observation NN 37231 2048 48 , , , 37231 2048 49 that that IN 37231 2048 50 many many JJ 37231 2048 51 demoniacs demoniac NNS 37231 2048 52 throughout throughout IN 37231 2048 53 all all PDT 37231 2048 54 the the DT 37231 2048 55 world world NN 37231 2048 56 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2048 57 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2048 58 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2048 59 and and CC 37231 2048 60 in in IN 37231 2048 61 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2048 62 own own JJ 37231 2048 63 city city NN 37231 2048 64 have have VBP 37231 2048 65 { { -LRB- 37231 2048 66 159 159 CD 37231 2048 67 } } -RRB- 37231 2048 68 been be VBN 37231 2048 69 healed heal VBN 37231 2048 70 and and CC 37231 2048 71 are be VBP 37231 2048 72 healed heal VBN 37231 2048 73 , , , 37231 2048 74 many many JJ 37231 2048 75 of of IN 37231 2048 76 the the DT 37231 2048 77 Christian Christian NNP 37231 2048 78 ' ' POS 37231 2048 79 men man NNS 37231 2048 80 among among IN 37231 2048 81 is be VBZ 37231 2048 82 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2048 83 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 2048 84 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2048 85 exorcising exorcise VBG 37231 2048 86 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2048 87 in in IN 37231 2048 88 the the DT 37231 2048 89 name name NN 37231 2048 90 of of IN 37231 2048 91 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2048 92 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2048 93 , , , 37231 2048 94 subduing subdue VBG 37231 2048 95 and and CC 37231 2048 96 expelling expel VBG 37231 2048 97 the the DT 37231 2048 98 possessing possess VBG 37231 2048 99 demons demon NNS 37231 2048 100 out out IN 37231 2048 101 of of IN 37231 2048 102 the the DT 37231 2048 103 man man NN 37231 2048 104 , , , 37231 2048 105 although although IN 37231 2048 106 all all PDT 37231 2048 107 the the DT 37231 2048 108 other other JJ 37231 2048 109 exorcists exorcist NNS 37231 2048 110 with with IN 37231 2048 111 incantations incantation NNS 37231 2048 112 and and CC 37231 2048 113 spells spell NNS 37231 2048 114 had have VBD 37231 2048 115 failed fail VBN 37231 2048 116 to to TO 37231 2048 117 do do VB 37231 2048 118 so so RB 37231 2048 119 . . . 37231 2049 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2049 2 1 1 LS 37231 2049 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2049 4 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 37231 2049 5 of of IN 37231 2049 6 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 2049 7 likewise likewise RB 37231 2049 8 states state VBZ 37231 2049 9 that that IN 37231 2049 10 to to IN 37231 2049 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2049 12 day day NN 37231 2049 13 demons demon NNS 37231 2049 14 are be VBP 37231 2049 15 exorcised exorcise VBN 37231 2049 16 . . . 37231 2050 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2050 2 2 2 LS 37231 2050 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2050 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2050 5 in in IN 37231 2050 6 the the DT 37231 2050 7 clearest clear JJS 37231 2050 8 manner manner NN 37231 2050 9 claims claim VBZ 37231 2050 10 for for IN 37231 2050 11 the the DT 37231 2050 12 Church Church NNP 37231 2050 13 of of IN 37231 2050 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2050 15 time time NN 37231 2050 16 the the DT 37231 2050 17 continued continue VBN 37231 2050 18 possession possession NN 37231 2050 19 of of IN 37231 2050 20 the the DT 37231 2050 21 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2050 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2050 23 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2050 24 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2050 25 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2050 26 contrasts contrast VBZ 37231 2050 27 the the DT 37231 2050 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2050 29 of of IN 37231 2050 30 the the DT 37231 2050 31 followers follower NNS 37231 2050 32 of of IN 37231 2050 33 Simon Simon NNP 37231 2050 34 and and CC 37231 2050 35 Carpocrates Carpocrates NNPS 37231 2050 36 , , , 37231 2050 37 which which WDT 37231 2050 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2050 39 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 2050 40 to to IN 37231 2050 41 magical magical JJ 37231 2050 42 illusions illusion NNS 37231 2050 43 , , , 37231 2050 44 with with IN 37231 2050 45 those those DT 37231 2050 46 of of IN 37231 2050 47 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2050 48 . . . 37231 2051 1 " " `` 37231 2051 2 For for IN 37231 2051 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2051 4 can can MD 37231 2051 5 neither neither CC 37231 2051 6 give give VB 37231 2051 7 sight sight NN 37231 2051 8 to to IN 37231 2051 9 the the DT 37231 2051 10 blind blind JJ 37231 2051 11 , , , 37231 2051 12 " " '' 37231 2051 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2051 14 continues continue VBZ 37231 2051 15 , , , 37231 2051 16 " " `` 37231 2051 17 nor nor CC 37231 2051 18 to to IN 37231 2051 19 the the DT 37231 2051 20 deaf deaf JJ 37231 2051 21 hearing hearing NN 37231 2051 22 , , , 37231 2051 23 nor nor CC 37231 2051 24 cast cast VBN 37231 2051 25 out out RP 37231 2051 26 all all DT 37231 2051 27 demons demon NNS 37231 2051 28 , , , 37231 2051 29 but but CC 37231 2051 30 only only RB 37231 2051 31 those those DT 37231 2051 32 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2051 33 by by IN 37231 2051 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2051 35 , , , 37231 2051 36 if if IN 37231 2051 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2051 38 can can MD 37231 2051 39 even even RB 37231 2051 40 do do VB 37231 2051 41 that that DT 37231 2051 42 ; ; : 37231 2051 43 nor nor CC 37231 2051 44 heal heal VB 37231 2051 45 the the DT 37231 2051 46 sick sick JJ 37231 2051 47 , , , 37231 2051 48 the the DT 37231 2051 49 lame lame NN 37231 2051 50 , , , 37231 2051 51 the the DT 37231 2051 52 paralytic paralytic NN 37231 2051 53 , , , 37231 2051 54 nor nor CC 37231 2051 55 those those DT 37231 2051 56 afflicted afflict VBN 37231 2051 57 in in IN 37231 2051 58 other other JJ 37231 2051 59 parts part NNS 37231 2051 60 of of IN 37231 2051 61 the the DT 37231 2051 62 body body NN 37231 2051 63 , , , 37231 2051 64 as as IN 37231 2051 65 has have VBZ 37231 2051 66 been be VBN 37231 2051 67 often often RB 37231 2051 68 done do VBN 37231 2051 69 in in IN 37231 2051 70 regard regard NN 37231 2051 71 to to IN 37231 2051 72 bodily bodily JJ 37231 2051 73 infirmity infirmity NN 37231 2051 74 .... .... . 37231 2052 1 But but CC 37231 2052 2 so so RB 37231 2052 3 far far RB 37231 2052 4 are be VBP 37231 2052 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2052 6 from from IN 37231 2052 7 raising raise VBG 37231 2052 8 the the DT 37231 2052 9 dead,--as dead,--as NN 37231 2052 10 the the DT 37231 2052 11 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2052 12 raised raise VBD 37231 2052 13 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2052 14 and and CC 37231 2052 15 the the DT 37231 2052 16 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2052 17 by by IN 37231 2052 18 prayer prayer NN 37231 2052 19 , , , 37231 2052 20 and and CC 37231 2052 21 as as IN 37231 2052 22 frequently frequently RB 37231 2052 23 in in IN 37231 2052 24 the the DT 37231 2052 25 brotherhood brotherhood NNP 37231 2052 26 , , , 37231 2052 27 when when WRB 37231 2052 28 the the DT 37231 2052 29 whole whole JJ 37231 2052 30 Church Church NNP 37231 2052 31 in in IN 37231 2052 32 a a DT 37231 2052 33 place place NN 37231 2052 34 made make VBN 37231 2052 35 supplication supplication NN 37231 2052 36 with with IN 37231 2052 37 much much JJ 37231 2052 38 fasting fasting NN 37231 2052 39 and and CC 37231 2052 40 prayer prayer NN 37231 2052 41 , , , 37231 2052 42 the the DT 37231 2052 43 spirit spirit NN 37231 2052 44 of of IN 37231 2052 45 the the DT 37231 2052 46 dead dead JJ 37231 2052 47 was be VBD 37231 2052 48 constrained constrain VBN 37231 2052 49 to to TO 37231 2052 50 return return VB 37231 2052 51 , , , 37231 2052 52 and and CC 37231 2052 53 the the DT 37231 2052 54 man man NN 37231 2052 55 was be VBD 37231 2052 56 freely freely RB 37231 2052 57 restored restore VBN 37231 2052 58 in in IN 37231 2052 59 answer answer NN 37231 2052 60 to to IN 37231 2052 61 the the DT 37231 2052 62 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2052 63 of of IN 37231 2052 64 the the DT 37231 2052 65 saints saint NNS 37231 2052 66 -- -- : 37231 2052 67 that that IN 37231 2052 68 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2052 69 do do VBP 37231 2052 70 not not RB 37231 2052 71 believe believe VB 37231 2052 72 this this DT 37231 2052 73 can can MD 37231 2052 74 possibly possibly RB 37231 2052 75 be be VB 37231 2052 76 done do VBN 37231 2052 77 . . . 37231 2053 1 " " `` 37231 2053 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2053 3 3 3 LS 37231 2053 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2053 5 Canon Canon NNP 37231 2053 6 { { -LRB- 37231 2053 7 160 160 CD 37231 2053 8 } } -RRB- 37231 2053 9 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2053 10 , , , 37231 2053 11 who who WP 37231 2053 12 desires desire VBZ 37231 2053 13 for for IN 37231 2053 14 the the DT 37231 2053 15 purpose purpose NN 37231 2053 16 of of IN 37231 2053 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2053 18 argument argument NN 37231 2053 19 to to TO 37231 2053 20 weaken weaken VB 37231 2053 21 the the DT 37231 2053 22 evidence evidence NN 37231 2053 23 of of IN 37231 2053 24 patristic patristic JJ 37231 2053 25 belief belief NN 37231 2053 26 in in IN 37231 2053 27 the the DT 37231 2053 28 continuance continuance NN 37231 2053 29 of of IN 37231 2053 30 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2053 31 , , , 37231 2053 32 says say VBZ 37231 2053 33 regarding regard VBG 37231 2053 34 this this DT 37231 2053 35 last last JJ 37231 2053 36 passage passage NN 37231 2053 37 on on IN 37231 2053 38 raising raise VBG 37231 2053 39 the the DT 37231 2053 40 dead:--"But dead:--"But `` 37231 2053 41 the the DT 37231 2053 42 reference reference NN 37231 2053 43 is be VBZ 37231 2053 44 so so RB 37231 2053 45 vague vague JJ 37231 2053 46 that that IN 37231 2053 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2053 48 possesses possess VBZ 37231 2053 49 but but CC 37231 2053 50 little little JJ 37231 2053 51 weight weight NN 37231 2053 52 as as IN 37231 2053 53 testimony testimony NN 37231 2053 54 . . . 37231 2054 1 " " `` 37231 2054 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2054 3 1 1 LS 37231 2054 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2054 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2054 6 should should MD 37231 2054 7 be be VB 37231 2054 8 sorry sorry JJ 37231 2054 9 to to TO 37231 2054 10 think think VB 37231 2054 11 that that IN 37231 2054 12 the the DT 37231 2054 13 vice vice NN 37231 2054 14 , , , 37231 2054 15 which which WDT 37231 2054 16 seems seem VBZ 37231 2054 17 at at IN 37231 2054 18 present present JJ 37231 2054 19 to to TO 37231 2054 20 characterize characterize VB 37231 2054 21 the the DT 37231 2054 22 Church Church NNP 37231 2054 23 to to TO 37231 2054 24 which which WDT 37231 2054 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2054 26 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2054 27 belongs belong VBZ 37231 2054 28 , , , 37231 2054 29 of of IN 37231 2054 30 making make VBG 37231 2054 31 simple simple JJ 37231 2054 32 language language NN 37231 2054 33 mean mean VB 37231 2054 34 anything anything NN 37231 2054 35 or or CC 37231 2054 36 nothing nothing NN 37231 2054 37 just just RB 37231 2054 38 as as IN 37231 2054 39 any any DT 37231 2054 40 one one NN 37231 2054 41 happens happen VBZ 37231 2054 42 to to TO 37231 2054 43 wish wish VB 37231 2054 44 , , , 37231 2054 45 should should MD 37231 2054 46 be be VB 37231 2054 47 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2054 48 into into IN 37231 2054 49 critical critical JJ 37231 2054 50 or or CC 37231 2054 51 historical historical JJ 37231 2054 52 studies study NNS 37231 2054 53 . . . 37231 2055 1 The the DT 37231 2055 2 language language NN 37231 2055 3 of of IN 37231 2055 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2055 5 is be VBZ 37231 2055 6 vague vague JJ 37231 2055 7 only only RB 37231 2055 8 in in IN 37231 2055 9 so so RB 37231 2055 10 far far RB 37231 2055 11 as as IN 37231 2055 12 specific specific JJ 37231 2055 13 detailed detailed JJ 37231 2055 14 instances instance NNS 37231 2055 15 are be VBP 37231 2055 16 not not RB 37231 2055 17 given give VBN 37231 2055 18 of of IN 37231 2055 19 the the DT 37231 2055 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2055 21 referred refer VBN 37231 2055 22 to to IN 37231 2055 23 ; ; : 37231 2055 24 but but CC 37231 2055 25 no no DT 37231 2055 26 language language NN 37231 2055 27 could could MD 37231 2055 28 be be VB 37231 2055 29 more more RBR 37231 2055 30 definite definite JJ 37231 2055 31 or or CC 37231 2055 32 explicit explicit JJ 37231 2055 33 to to TO 37231 2055 34 express express VB 37231 2055 35 the the DT 37231 2055 36 meaning meaning NN 37231 2055 37 of of IN 37231 2055 38 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2055 39 , , , 37231 2055 40 namely namely RB 37231 2055 41 , , , 37231 2055 42 the the DT 37231 2055 43 assertion assertion NN 37231 2055 44 that that IN 37231 2055 45 the the DT 37231 2055 46 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2055 47 of of IN 37231 2055 48 Christian christian JJ 37231 2055 49 communities community NNS 37231 2055 50 had have VBD 37231 2055 51 frequently frequently RB 37231 2055 52 restored restore VBN 37231 2055 53 the the DT 37231 2055 54 dead dead NN 37231 2055 55 to to IN 37231 2055 56 life life NN 37231 2055 57 . . . 37231 2056 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 2056 2 , , , 37231 2056 3 who who WP 37231 2056 4 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2056 5 the the DT 37231 2056 6 passage passage NN 37231 2056 7 , , , 37231 2056 8 and and CC 37231 2056 9 who who WP 37231 2056 10 has have VBZ 37231 2056 11 preserved preserve VBN 37231 2056 12 to to IN 37231 2056 13 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2056 14 the the DT 37231 2056 15 original original JJ 37231 2056 16 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2056 17 , , , 37231 2056 18 clearly clearly RB 37231 2056 19 recognized recognize VBD 37231 2056 20 this this DT 37231 2056 21 . . . 37231 2057 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2057 2 says say VBZ 37231 2057 3 , , , 37231 2057 4 when when WRB 37231 2057 5 making make VBG 37231 2057 6 the the DT 37231 2057 7 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2057 8 : : : 37231 2057 9 " " `` 37231 2057 10 In in IN 37231 2057 11 the the DT 37231 2057 12 second second JJ 37231 2057 13 book book NN 37231 2057 14 of of IN 37231 2057 15 the the DT 37231 2057 16 same same JJ 37231 2057 17 work work NN 37231 2057 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2057 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2057 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2057 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2057 22 testifies testify VBZ 37231 2057 23 that that IN 37231 2057 24 up up IN 37231 2057 25 to to IN 37231 2057 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2057 27 time time NN 37231 2057 28 tokens token NNS 37231 2057 29 of of IN 37231 2057 30 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2057 31 and and CC 37231 2057 32 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2057 33 power power NN 37231 2057 34 remained remain VBD 37231 2057 35 in in IN 37231 2057 36 some some DT 37231 2057 37 Churches,"(2 churches,"(2 NN 37231 2057 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2057 39 In in IN 37231 2057 40 the the DT 37231 2057 41 next next JJ 37231 2057 42 chapter chapter NN 37231 2057 43 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2057 44 further further RB 37231 2057 45 says:--"On says:--"On NNS 37231 2057 46 which which WDT 37231 2057 47 account account NN 37231 2057 48 , , , 37231 2057 49 also also RB 37231 2057 50 , , , 37231 2057 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2057 52 true true JJ 37231 2057 53 disciples disciple NNS 37231 2057 54 receiving receive VBG 37231 2057 55 grace grace NN 37231 2057 56 from from IN 37231 2057 57 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2057 58 , , , 37231 2057 59 work work VB 37231 2057 60 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2057 61 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2057 62 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2057 63 in in IN 37231 2057 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2057 65 name name NN 37231 2057 66 for for IN 37231 2057 67 the the DT 37231 2057 68 benefit benefit NN 37231 2057 69 of of IN 37231 2057 70 the the DT 37231 2057 71 rest rest NN 37231 2057 72 of of IN 37231 2057 73 mankind mankind NN 37231 2057 74 , , , 37231 2057 75 according accord VBG 37231 2057 76 to to IN 37231 2057 77 the the DT 37231 2057 78 gift gift NN 37231 2057 79 received receive VBN 37231 2057 80 from from IN 37231 2057 81 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2057 82 by by IN 37231 2057 83 each each DT 37231 2057 84 of of IN 37231 2057 85 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2057 86 . . . 37231 2058 1 For for IN 37231 2058 2 some some DT 37231 2058 3 do do VBP 37231 2058 4 certainly certainly RB 37231 2058 5 and and CC 37231 2058 6 truly truly RB 37231 2058 7 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2058 8 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2058 9 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2058 10 cast cast VBN 37231 2058 11 out out RP 37231 2058 12 demons demon NNS 37231 2058 13 , , , 37231 2058 14 so so IN 37231 2058 15 that that IN 37231 2058 16 frequently frequently RB 37231 2058 17 those those DT 37231 2058 18 very very JJ 37231 2058 19 men man NNS 37231 2058 20 who who WP 37231 2058 21 have have VBP 37231 2058 22 thus thus RB 37231 2058 23 been be VBN 37231 2058 24 cleansed cleanse VBN 37231 2058 25 from from IN 37231 2058 26 the the DT 37231 2058 27 evil evil JJ 37231 2058 28 spirits spirit NNS 37231 2058 29 both both CC 37231 2058 30 { { -LRB- 37231 2058 31 161 161 CD 37231 2058 32 } } -RRB- 37231 2058 33 believe believe VBP 37231 2058 34 and and CC 37231 2058 35 are be VBP 37231 2058 36 now now RB 37231 2058 37 in in IN 37231 2058 38 the the DT 37231 2058 39 church church NN 37231 2058 40 . . . 37231 2059 1 And and CC 37231 2059 2 some some DT 37231 2059 3 have have VBP 37231 2059 4 foreknowledge foreknowledge NN 37231 2059 5 of of IN 37231 2059 6 future future JJ 37231 2059 7 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2059 8 , , , 37231 2059 9 and and CC 37231 2059 10 visions vision NNS 37231 2059 11 , , , 37231 2059 12 and and CC 37231 2059 13 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 2059 14 utterances utterance NNS 37231 2059 15 . . . 37231 2060 1 Others other NNS 37231 2060 2 heal heal VBP 37231 2060 3 the the DT 37231 2060 4 sick sick NN 37231 2060 5 by by IN 37231 2060 6 the the DT 37231 2060 7 imposition imposition NN 37231 2060 8 of of IN 37231 2060 9 hands hand NNS 37231 2060 10 and and CC 37231 2060 11 make make VB 37231 2060 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2060 13 whole whole JJ 37231 2060 14 . . . 37231 2061 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 2061 2 , , , 37231 2061 3 as as IN 37231 2061 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2061 5 have have VBP 37231 2061 6 already already RB 37231 2061 7 stated state VBN 37231 2061 8 , , , 37231 2061 9 even even RB 37231 2061 10 the the DT 37231 2061 11 dead dead NNS 37231 2061 12 have have VBP 37231 2061 13 been be VBN 37231 2061 14 raised raise VBN 37231 2061 15 up up RP 37231 2061 16 , , , 37231 2061 17 and and CC 37231 2061 18 have have VBP 37231 2061 19 remained remain VBN 37231 2061 20 with with IN 37231 2061 21 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2061 22 for for IN 37231 2061 23 many many JJ 37231 2061 24 years year NNS 37231 2061 25 . . . 37231 2062 1 And and CC 37231 2062 2 what what WDT 37231 2062 3 more more JJR 37231 2062 4 shall shall MD 37231 2062 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2062 6 say say VB 37231 2062 7 ? ? . 37231 2063 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2063 2 is be VBZ 37231 2063 3 not not RB 37231 2063 4 possible possible JJ 37231 2063 5 to to TO 37231 2063 6 state state VB 37231 2063 7 the the DT 37231 2063 8 number number NN 37231 2063 9 of of IN 37231 2063 10 the the DT 37231 2063 11 gifts gift NNS 37231 2063 12 which which WDT 37231 2063 13 the the DT 37231 2063 14 Church Church NNP 37231 2063 15 throughout throughout IN 37231 2063 16 the the DT 37231 2063 17 world world NN 37231 2063 18 has have VBZ 37231 2063 19 received receive VBN 37231 2063 20 from from IN 37231 2063 21 God God NNP 37231 2063 22 in in IN 37231 2063 23 the the DT 37231 2063 24 name name NN 37231 2063 25 of of IN 37231 2063 26 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2063 27 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2063 28 , , , 37231 2063 29 crucified crucify VBD 37231 2063 30 under under IN 37231 2063 31 Pontius Pontius NNP 37231 2063 32 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 2063 33 , , , 37231 2063 34 and and CC 37231 2063 35 which which WDT 37231 2063 36 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2063 37 each each DT 37231 2063 38 day day NN 37231 2063 39 employs employ VBZ 37231 2063 40 for for IN 37231 2063 41 the the DT 37231 2063 42 benefit benefit NN 37231 2063 43 of of IN 37231 2063 44 the the DT 37231 2063 45 heathen heathen NNP 37231 2063 46 , , , 37231 2063 47 " " '' 37231 2063 48 & & CC 37231 2063 49 c.(1 c.(1 NNP 37231 2063 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2063 51 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 2063 52 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2063 53 with with IN 37231 2063 54 the the DT 37231 2063 55 most most RBS 37231 2063 56 perfect perfect JJ 37231 2063 57 assurance assurance NN 37231 2063 58 of of IN 37231 2063 59 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2063 60 occurring occur VBG 37231 2063 61 in in IN 37231 2063 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2063 63 day day NN 37231 2063 64 , , , 37231 2063 65 and and CC 37231 2063 66 of of IN 37231 2063 67 the the DT 37231 2063 68 power power NN 37231 2063 69 of of IN 37231 2063 70 healing healing NN 37231 2063 71 and and CC 37231 2063 72 of of IN 37231 2063 73 casting cast VBG 37231 2063 74 out out RP 37231 2063 75 devils devil NNS 37231 2063 76 still still RB 37231 2063 77 possessed possess VBN 37231 2063 78 by by IN 37231 2063 79 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2063 80 . . . 37231 2064 1 In in IN 37231 2064 2 one one CD 37231 2064 3 place place NN 37231 2064 4 , , , 37231 2064 5 for for IN 37231 2064 6 iustance iustance NN 37231 2064 7 , , , 37231 2064 8 after after IN 37231 2064 9 asserting assert VBG 37231 2064 10 the the DT 37231 2064 11 power power NN 37231 2064 12 which which WDT 37231 2064 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2064 14 have have VBP 37231 2064 15 generally generally RB 37231 2064 16 over over IN 37231 2064 17 demons demon NNS 37231 2064 18 , , , 37231 2064 19 so so IN 37231 2064 20 that that IN 37231 2064 21 if if IN 37231 2064 22 a a DT 37231 2064 23 person person NN 37231 2064 24 possessed possess VBN 37231 2064 25 by by IN 37231 2064 26 a a DT 37231 2064 27 devil devil NN 37231 2064 28 be be VB 37231 2064 29 brought bring VBN 37231 2064 30 before before IN 37231 2064 31 one one CD 37231 2064 32 of of IN 37231 2064 33 the the DT 37231 2064 34 Roman roman JJ 37231 2064 35 tribunals tribunal NNS 37231 2064 36 , , , 37231 2064 37 a a DT 37231 2064 38 follower follower NN 37231 2064 39 of of IN 37231 2064 40 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2064 41 can can MD 37231 2064 42 at at IN 37231 2064 43 once once RB 37231 2064 44 compel compel VB 37231 2064 45 the the DT 37231 2064 46 wicked wicked JJ 37231 2064 47 spirit spirit NN 37231 2064 48 within within IN 37231 2064 49 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2064 50 to to TO 37231 2064 51 confess confess VB 37231 2064 52 that that IN 37231 2064 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2064 54 is be VBZ 37231 2064 55 a a DT 37231 2064 56 demon demon NN 37231 2064 57 , , , 37231 2064 58 even even RB 37231 2064 59 if if IN 37231 2064 60 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2064 61 had have VBD 37231 2064 62 before before RB 37231 2064 63 asserted assert VBN 37231 2064 64 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2064 65 to to TO 37231 2064 66 be be VB 37231 2064 67 a a DT 37231 2064 68 God God NNP 37231 2064 69 , , , 37231 2064 70 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2064 71 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 2064 72 to to TO 37231 2064 73 say say VB 37231 2064 74 : : : 37231 2064 75 " " `` 37231 2064 76 So so CC 37231 2064 77 at at IN 37231 2064 78 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2064 79 touch touch NN 37231 2064 80 and and CC 37231 2064 81 breathing breathing NN 37231 2064 82 , , , 37231 2064 83 violently violently RB 37231 2064 84 affected affect VBN 37231 2064 85 by by IN 37231 2064 86 the the DT 37231 2064 87 contemplation contemplation NN 37231 2064 88 and and CC 37231 2064 89 representation representation NN 37231 2064 90 of of IN 37231 2064 91 those those DT 37231 2064 92 fires fire NNS 37231 2064 93 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2064 94 of of IN 37231 2064 95 hell hell NN 37231 2064 96 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2064 97 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2064 98 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2064 99 demons demon NNS 37231 2064 100 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2064 101 also also RB 37231 2064 102 depart depart VBP 37231 2064 103 at at IN 37231 2064 104 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2064 105 command command NN 37231 2064 106 out out IN 37231 2064 107 of of IN 37231 2064 108 bodies body NNS 37231 2064 109 , , , 37231 2064 110 reluctant reluctant JJ 37231 2064 111 and and CC 37231 2064 112 complaining complain VBG 37231 2064 113 , , , 37231 2064 114 and and CC 37231 2064 115 put put VBD 37231 2064 116 to to IN 37231 2064 117 shame shame NN 37231 2064 118 { { -LRB- 37231 2064 119 162 162 CD 37231 2064 120 } } -RRB- 37231 2064 121 in in IN 37231 2064 122 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2064 123 presence presence NN 37231 2064 124 . . . 37231 2065 1 " " `` 37231 2065 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2065 3 1 1 LS 37231 2065 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2065 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2065 6 declares declare VBZ 37231 2065 7 that that IN 37231 2065 8 although although IN 37231 2065 9 dreams dream NNS 37231 2065 10 are be VBP 37231 2065 11 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 2065 12 inflicted inflict VBN 37231 2065 13 upon upon IN 37231 2065 14 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2065 15 by by IN 37231 2065 16 demons demon NNS 37231 2065 17 , , , 37231 2065 18 yet yet CC 37231 2065 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2065 20 are be VBP 37231 2065 21 also also RB 37231 2065 22 sent send VBN 37231 2065 23 by by IN 37231 2065 24 God God NNP 37231 2065 25 , , , 37231 2065 26 and and CC 37231 2065 27 indeed indeed RB 37231 2065 28 " " `` 37231 2065 29 almost almost RB 37231 2065 30 the the DT 37231 2065 31 greater great JJR 37231 2065 32 part part NN 37231 2065 33 of of IN 37231 2065 34 mankind mankind NN 37231 2065 35 derive derive VBP 37231 2065 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2065 37 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2065 38 concerning concern VBG 37231 2065 39 God God NNP 37231 2065 40 from from IN 37231 2065 41 visions vision NNS 37231 2065 42 . . . 37231 2066 1 " " `` 37231 2066 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2066 3 2 2 LS 37231 2066 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2066 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2066 6 , , , 37231 2066 7 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2066 8 , , , 37231 2066 9 states state VBZ 37231 2066 10 that that IN 37231 2066 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2066 12 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2066 13 knows know VBZ 37231 2066 14 that that IN 37231 2066 15 a a DT 37231 2066 16 brother brother NN 37231 2066 17 was be VBD 37231 2066 18 severely severely RB 37231 2066 19 castigated castigate VBN 37231 2066 20 by by IN 37231 2066 21 a a DT 37231 2066 22 vision vision NN 37231 2066 23 the the DT 37231 2066 24 same same JJ 37231 2066 25 night night NN 37231 2066 26 on on IN 37231 2066 27 which which WDT 37231 2066 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2066 29 slaves slave NNS 37231 2066 30 had have VBD 37231 2066 31 , , , 37231 2066 32 without without IN 37231 2066 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2066 34 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2066 35 , , , 37231 2066 36 done do VBN 37231 2066 37 something something NN 37231 2066 38 reprehensible reprehensible JJ 37231 2066 39 . . . 37231 2067 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2067 2 3 3 LS 37231 2067 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2067 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2067 5 narrates narrate VBZ 37231 2067 6 as as IN 37231 2067 7 an an DT 37231 2067 8 instance instance NN 37231 2067 9 of of IN 37231 2067 10 the the DT 37231 2067 11 continued continue VBN 37231 2067 12 possession possession NN 37231 2067 13 of of IN 37231 2067 14 spiritual spiritual JJ 37231 2067 15 _ _ NNP 37231 2067 16 charismata charismata NNP 37231 2067 17 _ _ NNP 37231 2067 18 by by IN 37231 2067 19 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2067 20 : : : 37231 2067 21 " " `` 37231 2067 22 There there EX 37231 2067 23 is be VBZ 37231 2067 24 at at IN 37231 2067 25 this this DT 37231 2067 26 day day NN 37231 2067 27 among among IN 37231 2067 28 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2067 29 a a DT 37231 2067 30 sister sister NN 37231 2067 31 who who WP 37231 2067 32 has have VBZ 37231 2067 33 the the DT 37231 2067 34 gift gift NN 37231 2067 35 of of IN 37231 2067 36 revelations revelation NNS 37231 2067 37 , , , 37231 2067 38 which which WDT 37231 2067 39 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2067 40 receives receive VBZ 37231 2067 41 in in IN 37231 2067 42 church church NN 37231 2067 43 amidst amidst IN 37231 2067 44 the the DT 37231 2067 45 solemnities solemnity NNS 37231 2067 46 of of IN 37231 2067 47 the the DT 37231 2067 48 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2067 49 's 's POS 37231 2067 50 day day NN 37231 2067 51 by by IN 37231 2067 52 ecstasy ecstasy NN 37231 2067 53 in in IN 37231 2067 54 the the DT 37231 2067 55 spirit spirit NNP 37231 2067 56 : : : 37231 2067 57 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2067 58 converses converse VBZ 37231 2067 59 with with IN 37231 2067 60 angels angel NNS 37231 2067 61 , , , 37231 2067 62 and and CC 37231 2067 63 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 2067 64 also also RB 37231 2067 65 with with IN 37231 2067 66 the the DT 37231 2067 67 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2067 68 , , , 37231 2067 69 and and CC 37231 2067 70 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2067 71 both both CC 37231 2067 72 hears hear VBZ 37231 2067 73 and and CC 37231 2067 74 sees see VBZ 37231 2067 75 mysteries mystery NNS 37231 2067 76 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2067 77 _ _ NNP 37231 2067 78 sacramenta sacramenta NNP 37231 2067 79 _ _ NNP 37231 2067 80 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2067 81 , , , 37231 2067 82 and and CC 37231 2067 83 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2067 84 reads read VBZ 37231 2067 85 the the DT 37231 2067 86 hearts heart NNS 37231 2067 87 of of IN 37231 2067 88 some some DT 37231 2067 89 men man NNS 37231 2067 90 , , , 37231 2067 91 and and CC 37231 2067 92 prescribes prescribe VBZ 37231 2067 93 medicines medicine NNS 37231 2067 94 to to IN 37231 2067 95 those those DT 37231 2067 96 who who WP 37231 2067 97 are be VBP 37231 2067 98 in in IN 37231 2067 99 need need NN 37231 2067 100 . . . 37231 2068 1 " " `` 37231 2068 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2068 3 4 4 LS 37231 2068 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2068 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 2068 6 goes go VBZ 37231 2068 7 on on RP 37231 2068 8 to to TO 37231 2068 9 say say VB 37231 2068 10 that that IN 37231 2068 11 , , , 37231 2068 12 after after IN 37231 2068 13 the the DT 37231 2068 14 people people NNS 37231 2068 15 were be VBD 37231 2068 16 dismissed dismiss VBN 37231 2068 17 from from IN 37231 2068 18 the the DT 37231 2068 19 Church Church NNP 37231 2068 20 , , , 37231 2068 21 this this DT 37231 2068 22 sister sister NN 37231 2068 23 was be VBD 37231 2068 24 in in IN 37231 2068 25 the the DT 37231 2068 26 regular regular JJ 37231 2068 27 habit habit NN 37231 2068 28 of of IN 37231 2068 29 reporting report VBG 37231 2068 30 what what WP 37231 2068 31 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2068 32 had have VBD 37231 2068 33 seen see VBN 37231 2068 34 , , , 37231 2068 35 and and CC 37231 2068 36 that that IN 37231 2068 37 most most RBS 37231 2068 38 diligent diligent JJ 37231 2068 39 inquiries inquiry NNS 37231 2068 40 were be VBD 37231 2068 41 made make VBN 37231 2068 42 in in IN 37231 2068 43 order order NN 37231 2068 44 to to TO 37231 2068 45 test test VB 37231 2068 46 the the DT 37231 2068 47 truth truth NN 37231 2068 48 of of IN 37231 2068 49 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2068 50 communications;(5 communications;(5 NNP 37231 2068 51 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2068 52 and and CC 37231 2068 53 after after IN 37231 2068 54 narrating narrate VBG 37231 2068 55 a a DT 37231 2068 56 vision vision NN 37231 2068 57 of of IN 37231 2068 58 a a DT 37231 2068 59 disembodied disembodied JJ 37231 2068 60 soul soul NN 37231 2068 61 vouchsafed vouchsafe VBN 37231 2068 62 to to IN 37231 2068 63 her -PRON- PRP 37231 2068 64 , , , 37231 2068 65 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2068 66 states state VBZ 37231 2068 67 : : : 37231 2068 68 " " `` 37231 2068 69 This this DT 37231 2068 70 is be VBZ 37231 2068 71 the the DT 37231 2068 72 vision vision NN 37231 2068 73 , , , 37231 2068 74 God God NNP 37231 2068 75 being be VBG 37231 2068 76 witness witness NN 37231 2068 77 , , , 37231 2068 78 and and CC 37231 2068 79 { { -LRB- 37231 2068 80 163 163 CD 37231 2068 81 } } -RRB- 37231 2068 82 the the DT 37231 2068 83 Apostle(1 apostle(1 NN 37231 2068 84 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2068 85 having have VBG 37231 2068 86 foretold foretold NN 37231 2068 87 that that IN 37231 2068 88 such such JJ 37231 2068 89 spiritual spiritual JJ 37231 2068 90 gifts gift NNS 37231 2068 91 should should MD 37231 2068 92 be be VB 37231 2068 93 in in IN 37231 2068 94 the the DT 37231 2068 95 Church Church NNP 37231 2068 96 . . . 37231 2069 1 " " `` 37231 2069 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2069 3 2 2 LS 37231 2069 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2069 5 Further further RB 37231 2069 6 on on IN 37231 2069 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 2069 8 relates relate VBZ 37231 2069 9 another another DT 37231 2069 10 story story NN 37231 2069 11 within within IN 37231 2069 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2069 13 own own JJ 37231 2069 14 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2069 15 : : : 37231 2069 16 " " `` 37231 2069 17 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2069 18 know know VBP 37231 2069 19 the the DT 37231 2069 20 case case NN 37231 2069 21 of of IN 37231 2069 22 a a DT 37231 2069 23 woman woman NN 37231 2069 24 , , , 37231 2069 25 born bear VBN 37231 2069 26 within within IN 37231 2069 27 the the DT 37231 2069 28 fold fold NN 37231 2069 29 of of IN 37231 2069 30 the the DT 37231 2069 31 Church Church NNP 37231 2069 32 , , , 37231 2069 33 who who WP 37231 2069 34 was be VBD 37231 2069 35 in in IN 37231 2069 36 the the DT 37231 2069 37 prime prime NN 37231 2069 38 of of IN 37231 2069 39 life life NN 37231 2069 40 and and CC 37231 2069 41 beauty beauty NN 37231 2069 42 . . . 37231 2070 1 After after IN 37231 2070 2 being be VBG 37231 2070 3 but but CC 37231 2070 4 once once RB 37231 2070 5 , , , 37231 2070 6 and and CC 37231 2070 7 only only RB 37231 2070 8 a a DT 37231 2070 9 short short JJ 37231 2070 10 time time NN 37231 2070 11 , , , 37231 2070 12 married married JJ 37231 2070 13 , , , 37231 2070 14 having have VBG 37231 2070 15 fallen fall VBN 37231 2070 16 asleep asleep JJ 37231 2070 17 in in IN 37231 2070 18 peace peace NN 37231 2070 19 , , , 37231 2070 20 in in IN 37231 2070 21 the the DT 37231 2070 22 interval interval NN 37231 2070 23 before before IN 37231 2070 24 interment interment NNP 37231 2070 25 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2070 26 sp sp NNP 37231 2070 27 . . . 37231 2070 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2071 1 when when WRB 37231 2071 2 the the DT 37231 2071 3 presbyter presbyter NN 37231 2071 4 began begin VBD 37231 2071 5 to to TO 37231 2071 6 pray pray VB 37231 2071 7 as as IN 37231 2071 8 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2071 9 was be VBD 37231 2071 10 being be VBG 37231 2071 11 made make VBN 37231 2071 12 ready ready JJ 37231 2071 13 for for IN 37231 2071 14 burial burial NN 37231 2071 15 , , , 37231 2071 16 at at IN 37231 2071 17 the the DT 37231 2071 18 first first JJ 37231 2071 19 breath breath NN 37231 2071 20 of of IN 37231 2071 21 prayer prayer NN 37231 2071 22 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2071 23 removed remove VBD 37231 2071 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2071 25 hands hand NNS 37231 2071 26 from from IN 37231 2071 27 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2071 28 sides side NNS 37231 2071 29 , , , 37231 2071 30 folded fold VBD 37231 2071 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2071 32 in in IN 37231 2071 33 the the DT 37231 2071 34 attitude attitude NN 37231 2071 35 of of IN 37231 2071 36 supplication supplication NN 37231 2071 37 , , , 37231 2071 38 and and CC 37231 2071 39 again again RB 37231 2071 40 , , , 37231 2071 41 when when WRB 37231 2071 42 the the DT 37231 2071 43 last last JJ 37231 2071 44 rites rite NNS 37231 2071 45 were be VBD 37231 2071 46 over over RB 37231 2071 47 , , , 37231 2071 48 restored restore VBD 37231 2071 49 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2071 50 to to IN 37231 2071 51 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2071 52 former former JJ 37231 2071 53 position position NN 37231 2071 54 . . . 37231 2072 1 " " `` 37231 2072 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2072 3 3 3 LS 37231 2072 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2072 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2072 6 then then RB 37231 2072 7 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2072 8 another another DT 37231 2072 9 story story NN 37231 2072 10 known know VBN 37231 2072 11 amongst amongst IN 37231 2072 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2072 13 : : : 37231 2072 14 that that IN 37231 2072 15 a a DT 37231 2072 16 dead dead JJ 37231 2072 17 body body NN 37231 2072 18 in in IN 37231 2072 19 a a DT 37231 2072 20 cemetery cemetery NN 37231 2072 21 moved move VBD 37231 2072 22 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2072 23 in in IN 37231 2072 24 order order NN 37231 2072 25 to to TO 37231 2072 26 make make VB 37231 2072 27 room room NN 37231 2072 28 beside beside IN 37231 2072 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2072 30 for for IN 37231 2072 31 another another DT 37231 2072 32 body;(4 body;(4 NNS 37231 2072 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2072 34 and and CC 37231 2072 35 then then RB 37231 2072 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2072 37 remarks remark VBZ 37231 2072 38 : : : 37231 2072 39 " " `` 37231 2072 40 If if IN 37231 2072 41 similar similar JJ 37231 2072 42 cases case NNS 37231 2072 43 are be VBP 37231 2072 44 also also RB 37231 2072 45 reported report VBN 37231 2072 46 amongst amongst IN 37231 2072 47 the the DT 37231 2072 48 heathen heathen NN 37231 2072 49 , , , 37231 2072 50 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2072 51 conclude conclude VBP 37231 2072 52 that that IN 37231 2072 53 God God NNP 37231 2072 54 displays display VBZ 37231 2072 55 signs sign NNS 37231 2072 56 of of IN 37231 2072 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2072 58 power power NN 37231 2072 59 for for IN 37231 2072 60 the the DT 37231 2072 61 consolation consolation NN 37231 2072 62 of of IN 37231 2072 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2072 64 own own JJ 37231 2072 65 people people NNS 37231 2072 66 , , , 37231 2072 67 and and CC 37231 2072 68 as as IN 37231 2072 69 a a DT 37231 2072 70 testimony testimony NN 37231 2072 71 to to IN 37231 2072 72 others other NNS 37231 2072 73 . . . 37231 2073 1 " " `` 37231 2073 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2073 3 5 5 CD 37231 2073 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2073 5 Again again RB 37231 2073 6 , , , 37231 2073 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2073 8 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2073 9 cases case NNS 37231 2073 10 where where WRB 37231 2073 11 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2073 12 had have VBD 37231 2073 13 cured cure VBN 37231 2073 14 persons person NNS 37231 2073 15 of of IN 37231 2073 16 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 2073 17 possession possession NN 37231 2073 18 , , , 37231 2073 19 and and CC 37231 2073 20 adds add VBZ 37231 2073 21 : : : 37231 2073 22 " " `` 37231 2073 23 And and CC 37231 2073 24 how how WRB 37231 2073 25 many many JJ 37231 2073 26 men man NNS 37231 2073 27 of of IN 37231 2073 28 position position NN 37231 2073 29 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2073 30 for for IN 37231 2073 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2073 32 do do VBP 37231 2073 33 not not RB 37231 2073 34 speak speak VB 37231 2073 35 of of IN 37231 2073 36 the the DT 37231 2073 37 vulgar vulgar NN 37231 2073 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2073 39 have have VBP 37231 2073 40 been be VBN 37231 2073 41 delivered deliver VBN 37231 2073 42 either either CC 37231 2073 43 from from IN 37231 2073 44 devils devil NNS 37231 2073 45 or or CC 37231 2073 46 from from IN 37231 2073 47 diseases disease NNS 37231 2073 48 . . . 37231 2074 1 " " `` 37231 2074 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2074 3 6 6 CD 37231 2074 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2074 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 2074 6 { { -LRB- 37231 2074 7 164 164 CD 37231 2074 8 } } -RRB- 37231 2074 9 in in IN 37231 2074 10 the the DT 37231 2074 11 same same JJ 37231 2074 12 place place NN 37231 2074 13 refers refer VBZ 37231 2074 14 to to IN 37231 2074 15 the the DT 37231 2074 16 miracle miracle NN 37231 2074 17 of of IN 37231 2074 18 the the DT 37231 2074 19 " " `` 37231 2074 20 Thundering thunder VBG 37231 2074 21 Legion,"(1 legion,"(1 RB 37231 2074 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2074 23 and and CC 37231 2074 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2074 25 exclaims exclaim VBZ 37231 2074 26 : : : 37231 2074 27 " " `` 37231 2074 28 When when WRB 37231 2074 29 indeed indeed RB 37231 2074 30 have have VBP 37231 2074 31 not not RB 37231 2074 32 droughts drought NNS 37231 2074 33 been be VBN 37231 2074 34 removed remove VBN 37231 2074 35 by by IN 37231 2074 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2074 37 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2074 38 and and CC 37231 2074 39 fastings fasting NNS 37231 2074 40 . . . 37231 2075 1 " " `` 37231 2075 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2075 3 2 2 LS 37231 2075 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2075 5 Minucius Minucius NNP 37231 2075 6 Felix Felix NNP 37231 2075 7 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2075 8 of of IN 37231 2075 9 the the DT 37231 2075 10 casting casting NN 37231 2075 11 out out IN 37231 2075 12 of of IN 37231 2075 13 devils devil NNS 37231 2075 14 from from IN 37231 2075 15 sick sick JJ 37231 2075 16 persons person NNS 37231 2075 17 by by IN 37231 2075 18 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2075 19 in in IN 37231 2075 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2075 21 own own JJ 37231 2075 22 day day NN 37231 2075 23 , , , 37231 2075 24 as as IN 37231 2075 25 a a DT 37231 2075 26 matter matter NN 37231 2075 27 of of IN 37231 2075 28 public public JJ 37231 2075 29 notoriety notoriety NN 37231 2075 30 even even RB 37231 2075 31 among among IN 37231 2075 32 Pagans Pagans NNPS 37231 2075 33 . . . 37231 2076 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2076 2 3 3 LS 37231 2076 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2076 4 St. St. NNP 37231 2076 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 37231 2076 6 echoes echo VBZ 37231 2076 7 the the DT 37231 2076 8 same same JJ 37231 2076 9 assertions assertion NNS 37231 2076 10 . . . 37231 2077 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2077 2 4 4 LS 37231 2077 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2077 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2077 5 likewise likewise RB 37231 2077 6 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2077 7 cases case NNS 37231 2077 8 of of IN 37231 2077 9 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2077 10 punishment punishment NN 37231 2077 11 inflicted inflict VBN 37231 2077 12 upon upon IN 37231 2077 13 persons person NNS 37231 2077 14 who who WP 37231 2077 15 had have VBD 37231 2077 16 lapsed lapse VBN 37231 2077 17 from from IN 37231 2077 18 the the DT 37231 2077 19 Christian christian JJ 37231 2077 20 faith faith NN 37231 2077 21 . . . 37231 2078 1 One one CD 37231 2078 2 of of IN 37231 2078 3 these these DT 37231 2078 4 , , , 37231 2078 5 who who WP 37231 2078 6 ascended ascend VBD 37231 2078 7 the the DT 37231 2078 8 Capitol Capitol NNP 37231 2078 9 to to TO 37231 2078 10 make make VB 37231 2078 11 denial denial NN 37231 2078 12 of of IN 37231 2078 13 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2078 14 , , , 37231 2078 15 suddenly suddenly RB 37231 2078 16 became become VBD 37231 2078 17 dumb dumb JJ 37231 2078 18 after after IN 37231 2078 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2078 20 had have VBD 37231 2078 21 spoken speak VBN 37231 2078 22 the the DT 37231 2078 23 words word NNS 37231 2078 24 . . . 37231 2079 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2079 2 6 6 LS 37231 2079 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2079 4 Another another DT 37231 2079 5 , , , 37231 2079 6 a a DT 37231 2079 7 woman woman NN 37231 2079 8 , , , 37231 2079 9 was be VBD 37231 2079 10 seized seize VBN 37231 2079 11 by by IN 37231 2079 12 an an DT 37231 2079 13 unclean unclean JJ 37231 2079 14 spirit spirit NN 37231 2079 15 even even RB 37231 2079 16 at at IN 37231 2079 17 the the DT 37231 2079 18 baths bath NNS 37231 2079 19 , , , 37231 2079 20 and and CC 37231 2079 21 bit bit VB 37231 2079 22 with with IN 37231 2079 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2079 24 own own JJ 37231 2079 25 teeth tooth NNS 37231 2079 26 the the DT 37231 2079 27 impious impious JJ 37231 2079 28 tongue tongue NN 37231 2079 29 which which WDT 37231 2079 30 had have VBD 37231 2079 31 eaten eat VBN 37231 2079 32 the the DT 37231 2079 33 idolatrous idolatrous JJ 37231 2079 34 food food NN 37231 2079 35 , , , 37231 2079 36 or or CC 37231 2079 37 spoken speak VBD 37231 2079 38 the the DT 37231 2079 39 words word NNS 37231 2079 40 , , , 37231 2079 41 and and CC 37231 2079 42 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2079 43 shortly shortly RB 37231 2079 44 expired expire VBD 37231 2079 45 in in IN 37231 2079 46 great great JJ 37231 2079 47 agony agony NN 37231 2079 48 . . . 37231 2080 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2080 2 6 6 CD 37231 2080 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2080 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2080 5 likewise likewise RB 37231 2080 6 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 2080 7 that that IN 37231 2080 8 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2080 9 are be VBP 37231 2080 10 admonished admonish VBN 37231 2080 11 by by IN 37231 2080 12 God God NNP 37231 2080 13 in in IN 37231 2080 14 dreams dream NNS 37231 2080 15 and and CC 37231 2080 16 by by IN 37231 2080 17 visions vision NNS 37231 2080 18 , , , 37231 2080 19 of of IN 37231 2080 20 which which WDT 37231 2080 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2080 22 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2080 23 instances instance NNS 37231 2080 24 . . . 37231 2081 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2081 2 7 7 LS 37231 2081 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2081 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2081 5 claims claim VBZ 37231 2081 6 for for IN 37231 2081 7 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2081 8 the the DT 37231 2081 9 power power NN 37231 2081 10 still still RB 37231 2081 11 to to TO 37231 2081 12 expel expel VB 37231 2081 13 demons demon NNS 37231 2081 14 , , , 37231 2081 15 and and CC 37231 2081 16 to to TO 37231 2081 17 heal heal VB 37231 2081 18 diseases disease NNS 37231 2081 19 in in IN 37231 2081 20 the the DT 37231 2081 21 name name NN 37231 2081 22 of of IN 37231 2081 23 Jesus,(8 jesus,(8 NN 37231 2081 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2081 25 and and CC 37231 2081 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2081 27 states state VBZ 37231 2081 28 that that IN 37231 2081 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2081 30 had have VBD 37231 2081 31 seen see VBN 37231 2081 32 many many JJ 37231 2081 33 persons person NNS 37231 2081 34 so so RB 37231 2081 35 cured cure VBN 37231 2081 36 of of IN 37231 2081 37 madness madness NN 37231 2081 38 and and CC 37231 2081 39 countless countless JJ 37231 2081 40 other other JJ 37231 2081 41 evils evil NNS 37231 2081 42 , , , 37231 2081 43 which which WDT 37231 2081 44 could could MD 37231 2081 45 not not RB 37231 2081 46 be be VB 37231 2081 47 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 2081 48 cured cure VBN 37231 2081 49 by by IN 37231 2081 50 men man NNS 37231 2081 51 or or CC 37231 2081 52 devils devil NNS 37231 2081 53 . . . 37231 2082 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2082 2 9 9 LS 37231 2082 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2082 4 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 37231 2082 5 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 2082 6 asserts assert VBZ 37231 2082 7 the the DT 37231 2082 8 power power NN 37231 2082 9 of of IN 37231 2082 10 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2082 11 over over IN 37231 2082 12 demons demon NNS 37231 2082 13 ; ; : 37231 2082 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2082 15 make make VBP 37231 2082 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2082 17 flee flee VB 37231 2082 18 from from IN 37231 2082 19 bodies body NNS 37231 2082 20 when when WRB 37231 2082 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2082 22 adjure adjure VBP 37231 2082 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2082 24 in in IN 37231 2082 25 the the DT 37231 2082 26 name name NN 37231 2082 27 of of IN 37231 2082 28 God God NNP 37231 2082 29 . . . 37231 2083 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2083 2 10 10 LS 37231 2083 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2083 4 Passing pass VBG 37231 2083 5 over over RP 37231 2083 6 the the DT 37231 2083 7 numerous numerous JJ 37231 2083 8 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2083 9 writings writing NNS 37231 2083 10 of of IN 37231 2083 11 the the DT 37231 2083 12 early early JJ 37231 2083 13 centuries century NNS 37231 2083 14 of of IN 37231 2083 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2083 16 era era NN 37231 2083 17 , , , 37231 2083 18 in in IN 37231 2083 19 which which WDT 37231 2083 20 many many JJ 37231 2083 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2083 22 are be VBP 37231 2083 23 { { -LRB- 37231 2083 24 165 165 CD 37231 2083 25 } } -RRB- 37231 2083 26 recorded record VBN 37231 2083 27 , , , 37231 2083 28 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2083 29 find find VBP 37231 2083 30 in in IN 37231 2083 31 the the DT 37231 2083 32 pages page NNS 37231 2083 33 of of IN 37231 2083 34 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2083 35 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2083 36 of of IN 37231 2083 37 many many JJ 37231 2083 38 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2083 39 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2083 40 . . . 37231 2084 1 Many many JJ 37231 2084 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2084 3 are be VBP 37231 2084 4 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2084 5 to to IN 37231 2084 6 Narcissus Narcissus NNP 37231 2084 7 , , , 37231 2084 8 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2084 9 of of IN 37231 2084 10 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 2084 11 , , , 37231 2084 12 of of IN 37231 2084 13 which which WDT 37231 2084 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2084 15 relates relate VBZ 37231 2084 16 several several JJ 37231 2084 17 . . . 37231 2085 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 2085 2 the the DT 37231 2085 3 vigils vigil NNS 37231 2085 4 of of IN 37231 2085 5 the the DT 37231 2085 6 great great JJ 37231 2085 7 watch watch NN 37231 2085 8 of of IN 37231 2085 9 the the DT 37231 2085 10 Passover Passover NNP 37231 2085 11 were be VBD 37231 2085 12 being be VBG 37231 2085 13 kept keep VBN 37231 2085 14 , , , 37231 2085 15 the the DT 37231 2085 16 oil oil NN 37231 2085 17 failed fail VBD 37231 2085 18 , , , 37231 2085 19 whereupon whereupon NNP 37231 2085 20 Narcissus Narcissus NNP 37231 2085 21 commanded command VBD 37231 2085 22 that that DT 37231 2085 23 water water NN 37231 2085 24 from from IN 37231 2085 25 the the DT 37231 2085 26 neighbouring neighbouring NN 37231 2085 27 well well RB 37231 2085 28 should should MD 37231 2085 29 be be VB 37231 2085 30 poured pour VBN 37231 2085 31 into into IN 37231 2085 32 the the DT 37231 2085 33 lamps lamp NNS 37231 2085 34 . . . 37231 2086 1 Having have VBG 37231 2086 2 prayed pray VBN 37231 2086 3 over over IN 37231 2086 4 the the DT 37231 2086 5 water water NN 37231 2086 6 , , , 37231 2086 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2086 8 was be VBD 37231 2086 9 changed change VBN 37231 2086 10 into into IN 37231 2086 11 oil oil NN 37231 2086 12 , , , 37231 2086 13 of of IN 37231 2086 14 which which WDT 37231 2086 15 a a DT 37231 2086 16 specimen speciman NNS 37231 2086 17 had have VBD 37231 2086 18 been be VBN 37231 2086 19 preserved preserve VBN 37231 2086 20 until until IN 37231 2086 21 that that DT 37231 2086 22 time time NN 37231 2086 23 . . . 37231 2087 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2087 2 1 1 LS 37231 2087 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2087 4 On on IN 37231 2087 5 another another DT 37231 2087 6 occasion occasion NN 37231 2087 7 , , , 37231 2087 8 three three CD 37231 2087 9 men man NNS 37231 2087 10 having have VBG 37231 2087 11 spread spread VBN 37231 2087 12 some some DT 37231 2087 13 vile vile NN 37231 2087 14 slanders slander NNS 37231 2087 15 against against IN 37231 2087 16 Narcissus Narcissus NNP 37231 2087 17 , , , 37231 2087 18 which which WDT 37231 2087 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2087 20 confirmed confirm VBD 37231 2087 21 by by IN 37231 2087 22 an an DT 37231 2087 23 oath oath NN 37231 2087 24 , , , 37231 2087 25 and and CC 37231 2087 26 with with IN 37231 2087 27 imprecations imprecation NNS 37231 2087 28 upon upon IN 37231 2087 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2087 30 of of IN 37231 2087 31 death death NN 37231 2087 32 by by IN 37231 2087 33 a a DT 37231 2087 34 miserable miserable JJ 37231 2087 35 disease disease NN 37231 2087 36 , , , 37231 2087 37 of of IN 37231 2087 38 death death NN 37231 2087 39 by by IN 37231 2087 40 fire fire NN 37231 2087 41 , , , 37231 2087 42 and and CC 37231 2087 43 of of IN 37231 2087 44 blindness blindness NN 37231 2087 45 , , , 37231 2087 46 respectively respectively RB 37231 2087 47 , , , 37231 2087 48 if if IN 37231 2087 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2087 50 statements statement NNS 37231 2087 51 were be VBD 37231 2087 52 not not RB 37231 2087 53 true true JJ 37231 2087 54 , , , 37231 2087 55 omnipotent omnipotent JJ 37231 2087 56 justice justice NN 37231 2087 57 in in IN 37231 2087 58 each each DT 37231 2087 59 case case NN 37231 2087 60 inflicted inflict VBN 37231 2087 61 upon upon IN 37231 2087 62 the the DT 37231 2087 63 wretches wretch NNS 37231 2087 64 the the DT 37231 2087 65 curse curse NN 37231 2087 66 which which WDT 37231 2087 67 each each DT 37231 2087 68 had have VBD 37231 2087 69 invoked invoke VBN 37231 2087 70 . . . 37231 2088 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2088 2 2 2 LS 37231 2088 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2088 4 The the DT 37231 2088 5 election election NN 37231 2088 6 of of IN 37231 2088 7 Fabianus Fabianus NNP 37231 2088 8 to to IN 37231 2088 9 the the DT 37231 2088 10 Episcopal episcopal JJ 37231 2088 11 chair chair NN 37231 2088 12 of of IN 37231 2088 13 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2088 14 was be VBD 37231 2088 15 marked mark VBN 37231 2088 16 by by IN 37231 2088 17 the the DT 37231 2088 18 descent descent NN 37231 2088 19 of of IN 37231 2088 20 a a DT 37231 2088 21 dove dove NN 37231 2088 22 from from IN 37231 2088 23 on on IN 37231 2088 24 high high JJ 37231 2088 25 , , , 37231 2088 26 which which WDT 37231 2088 27 rested rest VBD 37231 2088 28 upon upon IN 37231 2088 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2088 30 head head NN 37231 2088 31 , , , 37231 2088 32 as as IN 37231 2088 33 the the DT 37231 2088 34 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2088 35 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 2088 36 had have VBD 37231 2088 37 descended descend VBN 37231 2088 38 upon upon IN 37231 2088 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2088 40 Saviour Saviour NNP 37231 2088 41 . . . 37231 2089 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2089 2 3 3 LS 37231 2089 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2089 4 At at IN 37231 2089 5 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 37231 2089 6 Philippi Philippi NNP 37231 2089 7 there there EX 37231 2089 8 is be VBZ 37231 2089 9 a a DT 37231 2089 10 statue statue NN 37231 2089 11 of of IN 37231 2089 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2089 13 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2089 14 which which WDT 37231 2089 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2089 16 states state VBZ 37231 2089 17 that that IN 37231 2089 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2089 19 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2089 20 had have VBD 37231 2089 21 seen see VBN 37231 2089 22 , , , 37231 2089 23 said say VBD 37231 2089 24 to to TO 37231 2089 25 have have VB 37231 2089 26 been be VBN 37231 2089 27 erected erect VBN 37231 2089 28 by by IN 37231 2089 29 the the DT 37231 2089 30 woman woman NN 37231 2089 31 healed heal VBN 37231 2089 32 of of IN 37231 2089 33 the the DT 37231 2089 34 bloody bloody JJ 37231 2089 35 issue issue NN 37231 2089 36 , , , 37231 2089 37 and and CC 37231 2089 38 on on IN 37231 2089 39 the the DT 37231 2089 40 pedestal pedestal NN 37231 2089 41 grows grow VBZ 37231 2089 42 a a DT 37231 2089 43 strange strange JJ 37231 2089 44 plant plant NN 37231 2089 45 as as RB 37231 2089 46 high high RB 37231 2089 47 as as IN 37231 2089 48 the the DT 37231 2089 49 hem hem NN 37231 2089 50 of of IN 37231 2089 51 the the DT 37231 2089 52 brazen brazen NN 37231 2089 53 garment garment NN 37231 2089 54 , , , 37231 2089 55 which which WDT 37231 2089 56 is be VBZ 37231 2089 57 an an DT 37231 2089 58 antidote antidote NN 37231 2089 59 to to IN 37231 2089 60 all all DT 37231 2089 61 diseases disease NNS 37231 2089 62 . . . 37231 2090 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2090 2 4 4 LS 37231 2090 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2090 4 Great great JJ 37231 2090 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2090 6 are be VBP 37231 2090 7 recorded record VBN 37231 2090 8 as as IN 37231 2090 9 taking take VBG 37231 2090 10 place place NN 37231 2090 11 during during IN 37231 2090 12 the the DT 37231 2090 13 persecutions persecution NNS 37231 2090 14 in in IN 37231 2090 15 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 37231 2090 16 . . . 37231 2091 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2091 2 5 5 LS 37231 2091 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2091 4 Gregory Gregory NNP 37231 2091 5 of of IN 37231 2091 6 Nyssa Nyssa NNP 37231 2091 7 gives give VBZ 37231 2091 8 an an DT 37231 2091 9 account account NN 37231 2091 10 of of IN 37231 2091 11 many many JJ 37231 2091 12 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 2091 13 works work NNS 37231 2091 14 performed perform VBN 37231 2091 15 by by IN 37231 2091 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2091 17 namesake namesake NN 37231 2091 18 Gregory Gregory NNP 37231 2091 19 of of IN 37231 2091 20 Neo Neo NNP 37231 2091 21 - - HYPH 37231 2091 22 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 37231 2091 23 , , , 37231 2091 24 who who WP 37231 2091 25 was be VBD 37231 2091 26 called call VBN 37231 2091 27 _ _ NNP 37231 2091 28 Thaumaturgus Thaumaturgus NNP 37231 2091 29 _ _ NNP 37231 2091 30 from from IN 37231 2091 31 the the DT 37231 2091 32 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2091 33 power power NN 37231 2091 34 which which WDT 37231 2091 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2091 36 possessed possess VBD 37231 2091 37 and and CC 37231 2091 38 very very RB 37231 2091 39 freely freely RB 37231 2091 40 { { -LRB- 37231 2091 41 166 166 CD 37231 2091 42 } } -RRB- 37231 2091 43 exercised exercise VBD 37231 2091 44 . . . 37231 2092 1 The the DT 37231 2092 2 Virgin Virgin NNP 37231 2092 3 Mary Mary NNP 37231 2092 4 and and CC 37231 2092 5 the the DT 37231 2092 6 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2092 7 John John NNP 37231 2092 8 appeared appear VBD 37231 2092 9 to to IN 37231 2092 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2092 11 , , , 37231 2092 12 on on IN 37231 2092 13 one one CD 37231 2092 14 occasion occasion NN 37231 2092 15 , , , 37231 2092 16 when when WRB 37231 2092 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2092 18 was be VBD 37231 2092 19 in in IN 37231 2092 20 doubt doubt NN 37231 2092 21 as as IN 37231 2092 22 to to IN 37231 2092 23 the the DT 37231 2092 24 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 2092 25 which which WDT 37231 2092 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2092 27 ought ought MD 37231 2092 28 to to TO 37231 2092 29 preach preach VB 37231 2092 30 , , , 37231 2092 31 and and CC 37231 2092 32 , , , 37231 2092 33 at at IN 37231 2092 34 the the DT 37231 2092 35 request request NN 37231 2092 36 of of IN 37231 2092 37 Mary Mary NNP 37231 2092 38 , , , 37231 2092 39 the the DT 37231 2092 40 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2092 41 gave give VBD 37231 2092 42 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2092 43 all all DT 37231 2092 44 needful needful JJ 37231 2092 45 instructions instruction NNS 37231 2092 46 . . . 37231 2093 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2093 2 1 1 LS 37231 2093 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2093 4 If if IN 37231 2093 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2093 6 faith faith NN 37231 2093 7 did do VBD 37231 2093 8 not not RB 37231 2093 9 move move VB 37231 2093 10 mountains mountain NNS 37231 2093 11 , , , 37231 2093 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2093 13 moved move VBD 37231 2093 14 a a DT 37231 2093 15 huge huge JJ 37231 2093 16 rock rock NN 37231 2093 17 to to TO 37231 2093 18 convert convert VB 37231 2093 19 a a DT 37231 2093 20 pagan pagan JJ 37231 2093 21 priest priest NN 37231 2093 22 . . . 37231 2094 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2094 2 2 2 LS 37231 2094 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2094 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2094 5 drove drive VBD 37231 2094 6 a a DT 37231 2094 7 demon demon NN 37231 2094 8 out out IN 37231 2094 9 of of IN 37231 2094 10 a a DT 37231 2094 11 heathen heathen NNP 37231 2094 12 temple temple NN 37231 2094 13 in in IN 37231 2094 14 which which WDT 37231 2094 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2094 16 had have VBD 37231 2094 17 taken take VBN 37231 2094 18 refuge refuge NN 37231 2094 19 , , , 37231 2094 20 and and CC 37231 2094 21 the the DT 37231 2094 22 evil evil JJ 37231 2094 23 spirit spirit NN 37231 2094 24 could could MD 37231 2094 25 not not RB 37231 2094 26 re re VB 37231 2094 27 - - VB 37231 2094 28 enter enter VB 37231 2094 29 until until IN 37231 2094 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2094 31 gave give VBD 37231 2094 32 permission permission NN 37231 2094 33 . . . 37231 2095 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2095 2 3 3 LS 37231 2095 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2095 4 Nyssen Nyssen NNP 37231 2095 5 relates relate VBZ 37231 2095 6 how how WRB 37231 2095 7 St. St. NNP 37231 2095 8 Gregory Gregory NNP 37231 2095 9 averted avert VBD 37231 2095 10 an an DT 37231 2095 11 armed armed JJ 37231 2095 12 contest contest NN 37231 2095 13 of of IN 37231 2095 14 two two CD 37231 2095 15 brothers brother NNS 37231 2095 16 who who WP 37231 2095 17 quarrelled quarrel VBD 37231 2095 18 about about IN 37231 2095 19 the the DT 37231 2095 20 possession possession NN 37231 2095 21 of of IN 37231 2095 22 a a DT 37231 2095 23 lake lake NN 37231 2095 24 on on IN 37231 2095 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2095 26 father father NN 37231 2095 27 's 's POS 37231 2095 28 property property NN 37231 2095 29 . . . 37231 2096 1 The the DT 37231 2096 2 saint saint NN 37231 2096 3 passed pass VBD 37231 2096 4 the the DT 37231 2096 5 night night NN 37231 2096 6 in in IN 37231 2096 7 prayer prayer NN 37231 2096 8 beside beside IN 37231 2096 9 the the DT 37231 2096 10 lake lake NN 37231 2096 11 , , , 37231 2096 12 and and CC 37231 2096 13 in in IN 37231 2096 14 the the DT 37231 2096 15 morning morning NN 37231 2096 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2096 17 was be VBD 37231 2096 18 found find VBN 37231 2096 19 dried dry VBN 37231 2096 20 up up RP 37231 2096 21 . . . 37231 2097 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2097 2 4 4 LS 37231 2097 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2097 4 On on IN 37231 2097 5 another another DT 37231 2097 6 occasion occasion NN 37231 2097 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2097 8 rescued rescue VBD 37231 2097 9 the the DT 37231 2097 10 country country NN 37231 2097 11 from from IN 37231 2097 12 the the DT 37231 2097 13 devastation devastation NN 37231 2097 14 of of IN 37231 2097 15 a a DT 37231 2097 16 mountain mountain NN 37231 2097 17 stream stream NN 37231 2097 18 , , , 37231 2097 19 which which WDT 37231 2097 20 periodically periodically RB 37231 2097 21 burst burst VBD 37231 2097 22 the the DT 37231 2097 23 dykes dyke NNS 37231 2097 24 by by IN 37231 2097 25 which which WDT 37231 2097 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2097 27 was be VBD 37231 2097 28 restrained restrain VBN 37231 2097 29 and and CC 37231 2097 30 inundated inundate VBD 37231 2097 31 the the DT 37231 2097 32 plain plain NN 37231 2097 33 . . . 37231 2098 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2098 2 went go VBD 37231 2098 3 on on IN 37231 2098 4 foot foot NN 37231 2098 5 to to IN 37231 2098 6 the the DT 37231 2098 7 place place NN 37231 2098 8 , , , 37231 2098 9 and and CC 37231 2098 10 invoking invoke VBG 37231 2098 11 the the DT 37231 2098 12 name name NN 37231 2098 13 of of IN 37231 2098 14 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2098 15 , , , 37231 2098 16 fixed fix VBD 37231 2098 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2098 18 staff staff NN 37231 2098 19 in in IN 37231 2098 20 the the DT 37231 2098 21 earth earth NN 37231 2098 22 at at IN 37231 2098 23 the the DT 37231 2098 24 place place NN 37231 2098 25 where where WRB 37231 2098 26 the the DT 37231 2098 27 torrent torrent NN 37231 2098 28 had have VBD 37231 2098 29 broken break VBN 37231 2098 30 through through RP 37231 2098 31 . . . 37231 2099 1 The the DT 37231 2099 2 staff staff NN 37231 2099 3 took take VBD 37231 2099 4 root root NN 37231 2099 5 and and CC 37231 2099 6 became become VBD 37231 2099 7 a a DT 37231 2099 8 tree tree NN 37231 2099 9 , , , 37231 2099 10 and and CC 37231 2099 11 the the DT 37231 2099 12 stream stream NN 37231 2099 13 never never RB 37231 2099 14 again again RB 37231 2099 15 burst burst VBD 37231 2099 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2099 17 bounds bound NNS 37231 2099 18 . . . 37231 2100 1 The the DT 37231 2100 2 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 37231 2100 3 of of IN 37231 2100 4 the the DT 37231 2100 5 district district NN 37231 2100 6 were be VBD 37231 2100 7 converted convert VBN 37231 2100 8 to to IN 37231 2100 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2100 10 by by IN 37231 2100 11 this this DT 37231 2100 12 miracle miracle NN 37231 2100 13 . . . 37231 2101 1 The the DT 37231 2101 2 tree tree NN 37231 2101 3 was be VBD 37231 2101 4 still still RB 37231 2101 5 living live VBG 37231 2101 6 in in IN 37231 2101 7 Nyssen Nyssen NNP 37231 2101 8 's 's POS 37231 2101 9 time time NN 37231 2101 10 , , , 37231 2101 11 and and CC 37231 2101 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2101 13 had have VBD 37231 2101 14 seen see VBN 37231 2101 15 the the DT 37231 2101 16 bed bed NN 37231 2101 17 of of IN 37231 2101 18 the the DT 37231 2101 19 lake lake NN 37231 2101 20 covered cover VBN 37231 2101 21 with with IN 37231 2101 22 trees tree NNS 37231 2101 23 , , , 37231 2101 24 pastures pasture NNS 37231 2101 25 , , , 37231 2101 26 and and CC 37231 2101 27 cottages cottage NNS 37231 2101 28 . . . 37231 2102 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2102 2 5 5 CD 37231 2102 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2102 4 Two two CD 37231 2102 5 vagabond vagabond NN 37231 2102 6 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2102 7 once once RB 37231 2102 8 attempted attempt VBD 37231 2102 9 to to TO 37231 2102 10 deceive deceive VB 37231 2102 11 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2102 12 . . . 37231 2103 1 One one CD 37231 2103 2 of of IN 37231 2103 3 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2103 4 lay lie VBD 37231 2103 5 down down RP 37231 2103 6 and and CC 37231 2103 7 pretended pretend VBD 37231 2103 8 to to TO 37231 2103 9 be be VB 37231 2103 10 dead dead JJ 37231 2103 11 , , , 37231 2103 12 while while IN 37231 2103 13 the the DT 37231 2103 14 other other JJ 37231 2103 15 begged beg VBD 37231 2103 16 money money NN 37231 2103 17 from from IN 37231 2103 18 the the DT 37231 2103 19 saint saint NN 37231 2103 20 wherewith wherewith VBG 37231 2103 21 to to TO 37231 2103 22 buy buy VB 37231 2103 23 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2103 24 a a DT 37231 2103 25 shroud shroud NN 37231 2103 26 . . . 37231 2104 1 St. St. NNP 37231 2104 2 Gregory Gregory NNP 37231 2104 3 quietly quietly RB 37231 2104 4 took take VBD 37231 2104 5 off off RP 37231 2104 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2104 7 cloak cloak NN 37231 2104 8 and and CC 37231 2104 9 laid lay VBD 37231 2104 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2104 11 on on IN 37231 2104 12 the the DT 37231 2104 13 man man NN 37231 2104 14 , , , 37231 2104 15 and and CC 37231 2104 16 { { -LRB- 37231 2104 17 167 167 CD 37231 2104 18 } } -RRB- 37231 2104 19 walked walk VBD 37231 2104 20 away away RB 37231 2104 21 . . . 37231 2105 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2105 2 companion companion NN 37231 2105 3 found find VBD 37231 2105 4 that that IN 37231 2105 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2105 6 was be VBD 37231 2105 7 really really RB 37231 2105 8 dead dead JJ 37231 2105 9 . . . 37231 2106 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2106 2 1 1 LS 37231 2106 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2106 4 St. St. NNP 37231 2106 5 Gregory Gregory NNP 37231 2106 6 expelled expel VBD 37231 2106 7 demons demon NNS 37231 2106 8 from from IN 37231 2106 9 persons person NNS 37231 2106 10 possessed possess VBD 37231 2106 11 , , , 37231 2106 12 healed heal VBD 37231 2106 13 the the DT 37231 2106 14 sick sick JJ 37231 2106 15 and and CC 37231 2106 16 performed perform VBD 37231 2106 17 many many JJ 37231 2106 18 other other JJ 37231 2106 19 miracles;(2 miracles;(2 NNP 37231 2106 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2106 21 and and CC 37231 2106 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2106 23 signs sign NNS 37231 2106 24 and and CC 37231 2106 25 wonders wonder NNS 37231 2106 26 are be VBP 37231 2106 27 not not RB 37231 2106 28 only only RB 37231 2106 29 attested attest VBN 37231 2106 30 by by IN 37231 2106 31 Gregory Gregory NNP 37231 2106 32 of of IN 37231 2106 33 Nyssa Nyssa NNP 37231 2106 34 , , , 37231 2106 35 but but CC 37231 2106 36 by by IN 37231 2106 37 St. St. NNP 37231 2107 1 Basil,(3 basil,(3 NN 37231 2107 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2107 3 whose whose WP$ 37231 2107 4 grandmother grandmother NN 37231 2107 5 , , , 37231 2107 6 St. St. NNP 37231 2107 7 Macrina Macrina NNP 37231 2107 8 , , , 37231 2107 9 was be VBD 37231 2107 10 brought bring VBN 37231 2107 11 up up RP 37231 2107 12 at at IN 37231 2107 13 Neo Neo NNP 37231 2107 14 - - HYPH 37231 2107 15 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 37231 2107 16 by by IN 37231 2107 17 the the DT 37231 2107 18 immediate immediate JJ 37231 2107 19 followers follower NNS 37231 2107 20 of of IN 37231 2107 21 the the DT 37231 2107 22 saint saint NN 37231 2107 23 . . . 37231 2108 1 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 2108 2 , , , 37231 2108 3 in in IN 37231 2108 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2108 5 memoir memoir NN 37231 2108 6 of of IN 37231 2108 7 St. St. NNP 37231 2108 8 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2108 9 , , , 37231 2108 10 who who WP 37231 2108 11 began begin VBD 37231 2108 12 to to TO 37231 2108 13 lead lead VB 37231 2108 14 the the DT 37231 2108 15 life life NN 37231 2108 16 of of IN 37231 2108 17 a a DT 37231 2108 18 recluse recluse NN 37231 2108 19 about about IN 37231 2108 20 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2108 21 . . NNP 37231 2108 22 270 270 CD 37231 2108 23 , , , 37231 2108 24 gives give VBZ 37231 2108 25 particulars particular NNS 37231 2108 26 of of IN 37231 2108 27 many many JJ 37231 2108 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2108 29 performed perform VBN 37231 2108 30 by by IN 37231 2108 31 the the DT 37231 2108 32 saint saint NN 37231 2108 33 . . . 37231 2109 1 Although although IN 37231 2109 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2109 3 possessed possess VBD 37231 2109 4 great great JJ 37231 2109 5 power power NN 37231 2109 6 over over IN 37231 2109 7 demons demon NNS 37231 2109 8 , , , 37231 2109 9 and and CC 37231 2109 10 delivered deliver VBD 37231 2109 11 many many JJ 37231 2109 12 persons person NNS 37231 2109 13 possessed possess VBN 37231 2109 14 by by IN 37231 2109 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2109 16 , , , 37231 2109 17 Satan Satan NNP 37231 2109 18 tormented torment VBD 37231 2109 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2109 20 sadly sadly RB 37231 2109 21 , , , 37231 2109 22 and and CC 37231 2109 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2109 24 was be VBD 37231 2109 25 constantly constantly RB 37231 2109 26 beset beset VBN 37231 2109 27 by by IN 37231 2109 28 legions legion NNS 37231 2109 29 of of IN 37231 2109 30 devils devil NNS 37231 2109 31 . . . 37231 2110 1 One one CD 37231 2110 2 night night NN 37231 2110 3 Satan Satan NNP 37231 2110 4 with with IN 37231 2110 5 a a DT 37231 2110 6 troop troop NN 37231 2110 7 of of IN 37231 2110 8 evil evil JJ 37231 2110 9 spirits spirit NNS 37231 2110 10 so so RB 37231 2110 11 belaboured belabour VBD 37231 2110 12 the the DT 37231 2110 13 saint saint NN 37231 2110 14 that that WDT 37231 2110 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2110 16 lay lie VBD 37231 2110 17 on on IN 37231 2110 18 the the DT 37231 2110 19 ground ground NN 37231 2110 20 speechless speechless NN 37231 2110 21 and and CC 37231 2110 22 almost almost RB 37231 2110 23 dead dead JJ 37231 2110 24 from from IN 37231 2110 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2110 26 blows blow NNS 37231 2110 27 . . . 37231 2111 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2111 2 4 4 LS 37231 2111 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2111 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2111 5 have have VBP 37231 2111 6 already already RB 37231 2111 7 referred refer VBN 37231 2111 8 to to IN 37231 2111 9 the the DT 37231 2111 10 case case NN 37231 2111 11 of of IN 37231 2111 12 Natalius Natalius NNP 37231 2111 13 , , , 37231 2111 14 who who WP 37231 2111 15 was be VBD 37231 2111 16 scourged scourge VBN 37231 2111 17 by by IN 37231 2111 18 angels angel NNS 37231 2111 19 during during IN 37231 2111 20 a a DT 37231 2111 21 whole whole JJ 37231 2111 22 night night NN 37231 2111 23 , , , 37231 2111 24 till till IN 37231 2111 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2111 26 was be VBD 37231 2111 27 brought bring VBN 37231 2111 28 to to IN 37231 2111 29 repentance repentance NN 37231 2111 30 . . . 37231 2112 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2112 2 5 5 LS 37231 2112 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2112 4 Upon upon IN 37231 2112 5 one one CD 37231 2112 6 occasion occasion NN 37231 2112 7 when when WRB 37231 2112 8 St. St. NNP 37231 2112 9 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2112 10 had have VBD 37231 2112 11 retired retire VBN 37231 2112 12 to to IN 37231 2112 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2112 14 cell cell NN 37231 2112 15 resolved resolve VBN 37231 2112 16 to to TO 37231 2112 17 pass pass VB 37231 2112 18 a a DT 37231 2112 19 time time NN 37231 2112 20 in in IN 37231 2112 21 perfect perfect JJ 37231 2112 22 solitude solitude NNP 37231 2112 23 , , , 37231 2112 24 a a DT 37231 2112 25 certain certain JJ 37231 2112 26 soldier soldier NN 37231 2112 27 came come VBD 37231 2112 28 to to IN 37231 2112 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2112 30 door door NN 37231 2112 31 and and CC 37231 2112 32 remained remain VBD 37231 2112 33 long long RB 37231 2112 34 there there RB 37231 2112 35 knocking knock VBG 37231 2112 36 and and CC 37231 2112 37 supplicating supplicate VBG 37231 2112 38 the the DT 37231 2112 39 saint saint NN 37231 2112 40 to to TO 37231 2112 41 come come VB 37231 2112 42 and and CC 37231 2112 43 deliver deliver VB 37231 2112 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2112 45 daughter daughter NN 37231 2112 46 , , , 37231 2112 47 who who WP 37231 2112 48 was be VBD 37231 2112 49 tormented torment VBN 37231 2112 50 by by IN 37231 2112 51 a a DT 37231 2112 52 demon demon NN 37231 2112 53 . . . 37231 2113 1 At at IN 37231 2113 2 length length NN 37231 2113 3 St. St. NNP 37231 2113 4 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2113 5 addressed address VBD 37231 2113 6 the the DT 37231 2113 7 man man NN 37231 2113 8 and and CC 37231 2113 9 told tell VBD 37231 2113 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2113 11 to to TO 37231 2113 12 go go VB 37231 2113 13 , , , 37231 2113 14 and and CC 37231 2113 15 if if IN 37231 2113 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2113 17 believed believe VBD 37231 2113 18 in in IN 37231 2113 19 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2113 20 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2113 21 and and CC 37231 2113 22 prayed pray VBD 37231 2113 23 to to IN 37231 2113 24 God God NNP 37231 2113 25 , , , 37231 2113 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2113 27 prayer prayer NN 37231 2113 28 should should MD 37231 2113 29 { { -LRB- 37231 2113 30 168 168 CD 37231 2113 31 } } -RRB- 37231 2113 32 be be VB 37231 2113 33 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 2113 34 . . . 37231 2114 1 The the DT 37231 2114 2 man man NN 37231 2114 3 believed believe VBD 37231 2114 4 , , , 37231 2114 5 invoked invoke VBD 37231 2114 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2114 7 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2114 8 , , , 37231 2114 9 and and CC 37231 2114 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2114 11 daughter daughter NN 37231 2114 12 was be VBD 37231 2114 13 delivered deliver VBN 37231 2114 14 from from IN 37231 2114 15 the the DT 37231 2114 16 demon demon NN 37231 2114 17 . . . 37231 2115 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2115 2 1 1 LS 37231 2115 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2115 4 As as IN 37231 2115 5 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2115 6 was be VBD 37231 2115 7 once once RB 37231 2115 8 travelling travel VBG 37231 2115 9 across across IN 37231 2115 10 the the DT 37231 2115 11 desert desert NN 37231 2115 12 to to TO 37231 2115 13 visit visit VB 37231 2115 14 another another DT 37231 2115 15 monastery monastery NN 37231 2115 16 , , , 37231 2115 17 the the DT 37231 2115 18 water water NN 37231 2115 19 of of IN 37231 2115 20 the the DT 37231 2115 21 caravan caravan NN 37231 2115 22 failed fail VBD 37231 2115 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2115 24 , , , 37231 2115 25 and and CC 37231 2115 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2115 27 companions companion NNS 37231 2115 28 in in IN 37231 2115 29 despair despair NN 37231 2115 30 threw throw VBD 37231 2115 31 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2115 32 on on IN 37231 2115 33 the the DT 37231 2115 34 ground ground NN 37231 2115 35 . . . 37231 2116 1 St. St. NNP 37231 2116 2 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2116 3 , , , 37231 2116 4 however however RB 37231 2116 5 , , , 37231 2116 6 retired retire VBD 37231 2116 7 a a DT 37231 2116 8 little little JJ 37231 2116 9 apart apart RB 37231 2116 10 , , , 37231 2116 11 and and CC 37231 2116 12 in in IN 37231 2116 13 answer answer NN 37231 2116 14 to to IN 37231 2116 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2116 16 prayer prayer NN 37231 2116 17 a a DT 37231 2116 18 spring spring NN 37231 2116 19 of of IN 37231 2116 20 water water NN 37231 2116 21 issued issue VBN 37231 2116 22 at at IN 37231 2116 23 the the DT 37231 2116 24 place place NN 37231 2116 25 where where WRB 37231 2116 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2116 27 was be VBD 37231 2116 28 kneeling kneel VBG 37231 2116 29 . . . 37231 2117 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2117 2 2 2 LS 37231 2117 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2117 4 A a DT 37231 2117 5 man man NN 37231 2117 6 named name VBN 37231 2117 7 Fronto Fronto NNP 37231 2117 8 , , , 37231 2117 9 who who WP 37231 2117 10 was be VBD 37231 2117 11 afflicted afflict VBN 37231 2117 12 with with IN 37231 2117 13 leprosy leprosy NN 37231 2117 14 , , , 37231 2117 15 begged beg VBD 37231 2117 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2117 17 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2117 18 , , , 37231 2117 19 and and CC 37231 2117 20 was be VBD 37231 2117 21 ordered order VBN 37231 2117 22 by by IN 37231 2117 23 the the DT 37231 2117 24 saint saint NNP 37231 2117 25 to to TO 37231 2117 26 go go VB 37231 2117 27 into into IN 37231 2117 28 Egypt Egypt NNP 37231 2117 29 , , , 37231 2117 30 where where WRB 37231 2117 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2117 32 should should MD 37231 2117 33 be be VB 37231 2117 34 healed heal VBN 37231 2117 35 . . . 37231 2118 1 Fronto Fronto NNS 37231 2118 2 at at IN 37231 2118 3 first first RB 37231 2118 4 refused refuse VBD 37231 2118 5 , , , 37231 2118 6 but but CC 37231 2118 7 being be VBG 37231 2118 8 told tell VBN 37231 2118 9 that that IN 37231 2118 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2118 11 could could MD 37231 2118 12 not not RB 37231 2118 13 be be VB 37231 2118 14 healed heal VBN 37231 2118 15 if if IN 37231 2118 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2118 17 remained remain VBD 37231 2118 18 , , , 37231 2118 19 the the DT 37231 2118 20 sick sick JJ 37231 2118 21 man man NN 37231 2118 22 went go VBD 37231 2118 23 believing believe VBG 37231 2118 24 , , , 37231 2118 25 and and CC 37231 2118 26 as as RB 37231 2118 27 soon soon RB 37231 2118 28 as as IN 37231 2118 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2118 30 came come VBD 37231 2118 31 in in IN 37231 2118 32 sight sight NN 37231 2118 33 of of IN 37231 2118 34 Egypt Egypt NNP 37231 2118 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2118 36 was be VBD 37231 2118 37 made make VBN 37231 2118 38 whole whole JJ 37231 2118 39 . . . 37231 2119 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2119 2 3 3 LS 37231 2119 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2119 4 Another another DT 37231 2119 5 miracle miracle NN 37231 2119 6 was be VBD 37231 2119 7 performed perform VBN 37231 2119 8 by by IN 37231 2119 9 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2119 10 at at IN 37231 2119 11 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 2119 12 in in IN 37231 2119 13 the the DT 37231 2119 14 presence presence NN 37231 2119 15 of of IN 37231 2119 16 St. St. NNP 37231 2119 17 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 2119 18 . . . 37231 2120 1 As as IN 37231 2120 2 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2120 3 were be VBD 37231 2120 4 leaving leave VBG 37231 2120 5 the the DT 37231 2120 6 city city NN 37231 2120 7 a a DT 37231 2120 8 woman woman NN 37231 2120 9 cried cry VBD 37231 2120 10 after after IN 37231 2120 11 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2120 12 , , , 37231 2120 13 " " `` 37231 2120 14 Man man NN 37231 2120 15 of of IN 37231 2120 16 God God NNP 37231 2120 17 , , , 37231 2120 18 stay stay VB 37231 2120 19 ; ; : 37231 2120 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2120 21 daughter daughter NN 37231 2120 22 is be VBZ 37231 2120 23 cruelly cruelly RB 37231 2120 24 troubled trouble VBN 37231 2120 25 by by IN 37231 2120 26 a a DT 37231 2120 27 demon demon NN 37231 2120 28 ; ; : 37231 2120 29 " " '' 37231 2120 30 and and CC 37231 2120 31 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2120 32 entreated entreat VBD 37231 2120 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2120 34 to to TO 37231 2120 35 stop stop VB 37231 2120 36 lest lest IN 37231 2120 37 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2120 38 herself -PRON- PRP 37231 2120 39 should should MD 37231 2120 40 die die VB 37231 2120 41 in in IN 37231 2120 42 running run VBG 37231 2120 43 after after IN 37231 2120 44 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2120 45 . . . 37231 2121 1 At at IN 37231 2121 2 the the DT 37231 2121 3 request request NN 37231 2121 4 of of IN 37231 2121 5 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 2121 6 and and CC 37231 2121 7 the the DT 37231 2121 8 rest rest NN 37231 2121 9 , , , 37231 2121 10 the the DT 37231 2121 11 saint saint NN 37231 2121 12 paused pause VBD 37231 2121 13 , , , 37231 2121 14 and and CC 37231 2121 15 as as IN 37231 2121 16 the the DT 37231 2121 17 woman woman NN 37231 2121 18 came come VBD 37231 2121 19 up up RP 37231 2121 20 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2121 21 daughter daughter NN 37231 2121 22 fell fall VBD 37231 2121 23 on on IN 37231 2121 24 the the DT 37231 2121 25 ground ground NN 37231 2121 26 convulsed convulse VBN 37231 2121 27 . . . 37231 2122 1 St. St. NNP 37231 2122 2 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2122 3 prayed pray VBD 37231 2122 4 in in IN 37231 2122 5 the the DT 37231 2122 6 name name NN 37231 2122 7 of of IN 37231 2122 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2122 9 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2122 10 , , , 37231 2122 11 and and CC 37231 2122 12 immediately immediately RB 37231 2122 13 the the DT 37231 2122 14 girl girl NN 37231 2122 15 rose rise VBD 37231 2122 16 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2122 17 restored restore VBD 37231 2122 18 to to IN 37231 2122 19 health health NN 37231 2122 20 , , , 37231 2122 21 and and CC 37231 2122 22 delivered deliver VBN 37231 2122 23 from from IN 37231 2122 24 the the DT 37231 2122 25 evil evil JJ 37231 2122 26 spirit spirit NN 37231 2122 27 . . . 37231 2123 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2123 2 4 4 LS 37231 2123 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2123 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2123 5 astonished astonish VBD 37231 2123 6 a a DT 37231 2123 7 number number NN 37231 2123 8 of of IN 37231 2123 9 pagan pagan JJ 37231 2123 10 philosophers philosopher NNS 37231 2123 11 , , , 37231 2123 12 who who WP 37231 2123 13 had have VBD 37231 2123 14 come come VBN 37231 2123 15 to to TO 37231 2123 16 dispute dispute VB 37231 2123 17 with with IN 37231 2123 18 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2123 19 , , , 37231 2123 20 by by IN 37231 2123 21 delivering deliver VBG 37231 2123 22 several several JJ 37231 2123 23 demoniacs demoniac NNS 37231 2123 24 , , , 37231 2123 25 making make VBG 37231 2123 26 the the DT 37231 2123 27 sign sign NN 37231 2123 28 of of IN 37231 2123 29 the the DT 37231 2123 30 cross cross NN 37231 2123 31 over over IN 37231 2123 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2123 33 three three CD 37231 2123 34 times time NNS 37231 2123 35 , , , 37231 2123 36 and and CC 37231 2123 37 invoking invoke VBG 37231 2123 38 the the DT 37231 2123 39 name name NN 37231 2123 40 of of IN 37231 2123 41 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2123 42 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2123 43 . . . 37231 2124 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2124 2 5 5 LS 37231 2124 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2124 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2124 5 is be VBZ 37231 2124 6 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 2124 7 , , , 37231 2124 8 however however RB 37231 2124 9 , , , 37231 2124 10 to to TO 37231 2124 11 multiply multiply VB 37231 2124 12 instances instance NNS 37231 2124 13 of of IN 37231 2124 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2124 15 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2124 16 power power NN 37231 2124 17 to to TO 37231 2124 18 drive drive VB 37231 2124 19 out out RP 37231 2124 20 demons demon NNS 37231 2124 21 and and CC 37231 2124 22 heal heal VB 37231 2124 23 diseases,(6 diseases,(6 NNS 37231 2124 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2124 25 and and CC 37231 2124 26 to to TO 37231 2124 27 perform perform VB 37231 2124 28 other other JJ 37231 2124 29 { { -LRB- 37231 2124 30 169 169 CD 37231 2124 31 } } -RRB- 37231 2124 32 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 2124 33 works work NNS 37231 2124 34 . . . 37231 2125 1 St. St. NNP 37231 2125 2 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 2125 3 , , , 37231 2125 4 who who WP 37231 2125 5 was be VBD 37231 2125 6 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2125 7 for for IN 37231 2125 8 a a DT 37231 2125 9 long long JJ 37231 2125 10 time time NN 37231 2125 11 a a DT 37231 2125 12 personal personal JJ 37231 2125 13 follower follower NN 37231 2125 14 of of IN 37231 2125 15 St. St. NNP 37231 2125 16 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2125 17 , , , 37231 2125 18 protests protest NNS 37231 2125 19 in in IN 37231 2125 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2125 21 preface preface NN 37231 2125 22 to to IN 37231 2125 23 the the DT 37231 2125 24 biography biography NN 37231 2125 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2125 26 general general JJ 37231 2125 27 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2125 28 , , , 37231 2125 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2125 30 having have VBG 37231 2125 31 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 2125 32 been be VBN 37231 2125 33 mindful mindful JJ 37231 2125 34 of of IN 37231 2125 35 the the DT 37231 2125 36 truth truth NN 37231 2125 37 . . . 37231 2126 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2126 2 1 1 LS 37231 2126 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2126 4 Hilarion hilarion NN 37231 2126 5 , , , 37231 2126 6 again again RB 37231 2126 7 , , , 37231 2126 8 a a DT 37231 2126 9 disciple disciple NN 37231 2126 10 of of IN 37231 2126 11 St. St. NNP 37231 2126 12 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2126 13 , , , 37231 2126 14 performed perform VBD 37231 2126 15 many many JJ 37231 2126 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2126 17 , , , 37231 2126 18 an an DT 37231 2126 19 account account NN 37231 2126 20 of of IN 37231 2126 21 some some DT 37231 2126 22 of of IN 37231 2126 23 which which WDT 37231 2126 24 is be VBZ 37231 2126 25 given give VBN 37231 2126 26 by by IN 37231 2126 27 St. St. NNP 37231 2126 28 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2126 29 . . . 37231 2127 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2127 2 restored restore VBD 37231 2127 3 sight sight NN 37231 2127 4 to to IN 37231 2127 5 a a DT 37231 2127 6 woman woman NN 37231 2127 7 who who WP 37231 2127 8 had have VBD 37231 2127 9 been be VBN 37231 2127 10 blind blind JJ 37231 2127 11 for for IN 37231 2127 12 no no DT 37231 2127 13 less less JJR 37231 2127 14 than than IN 37231 2127 15 ten ten CD 37231 2127 16 years year NNS 37231 2127 17 ; ; : 37231 2127 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2127 19 cast cast VBD 37231 2127 20 out out RP 37231 2127 21 devils devil NNS 37231 2127 22 , , , 37231 2127 23 and and CC 37231 2127 24 miraculously miraculously RB 37231 2127 25 cured cure VBD 37231 2127 26 many many JJ 37231 2127 27 diseases disease NNS 37231 2127 28 . . . 37231 2128 1 Rain rain NN 37231 2128 2 fell fall VBD 37231 2128 3 in in IN 37231 2128 4 answer answer NN 37231 2128 5 to to IN 37231 2128 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2128 7 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2128 8 ; ; : 37231 2128 9 and and CC 37231 2128 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2128 11 further further RB 37231 2128 12 exhibited exhibit VBD 37231 2128 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2128 14 power power NN 37231 2128 15 over over IN 37231 2128 16 the the DT 37231 2128 17 elements element NNS 37231 2128 18 by by IN 37231 2128 19 calming calm VBG 37231 2128 20 a a DT 37231 2128 21 stormy stormy JJ 37231 2128 22 sea sea NN 37231 2128 23 . . . 37231 2129 1 When when WRB 37231 2129 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2129 3 was be VBD 37231 2129 4 buried bury VBN 37231 2129 5 , , , 37231 2129 6 ten ten CD 37231 2129 7 months month NNS 37231 2129 8 after after IN 37231 2129 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2129 10 death death NN 37231 2129 11 , , , 37231 2129 12 not not RB 37231 2129 13 only only RB 37231 2129 14 was be VBD 37231 2129 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2129 16 body body NN 37231 2129 17 as as RB 37231 2129 18 perfect perfect JJ 37231 2129 19 as as IN 37231 2129 20 though though IN 37231 2129 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2129 22 had have VBD 37231 2129 23 been be VBN 37231 2129 24 alive alive JJ 37231 2129 25 , , , 37231 2129 26 but but CC 37231 2129 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2129 28 emitted emit VBD 37231 2129 29 a a DT 37231 2129 30 delightful delightful JJ 37231 2129 31 perfume perfume NN 37231 2129 32 . . . 37231 2130 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2130 2 was be VBD 37231 2130 3 so so RB 37231 2130 4 favoured favoured JJ 37231 2130 5 of of IN 37231 2130 6 God God NNP 37231 2130 7 that that IN 37231 2130 8 , , , 37231 2130 9 long long RB 37231 2130 10 after after RB 37231 2130 11 , , , 37231 2130 12 diseases disease NNS 37231 2130 13 were be VBD 37231 2130 14 healed heal VBN 37231 2130 15 and and CC 37231 2130 16 demons demon NNS 37231 2130 17 expelled expel VBN 37231 2130 18 at at IN 37231 2130 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2130 20 tomb tomb NN 37231 2130 21 . . . 37231 2131 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2131 2 2 2 LS 37231 2131 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2131 4 St. St. NNP 37231 2131 5 Macarius Macarius NNP 37231 2131 6 , , , 37231 2131 7 the the DT 37231 2131 8 Egyptian Egyptian NNP 37231 2131 9 , , , 37231 2131 10 is be VBZ 37231 2131 11 said say VBN 37231 2131 12 to to TO 37231 2131 13 have have VB 37231 2131 14 restored restore VBN 37231 2131 15 a a DT 37231 2131 16 dead dead JJ 37231 2131 17 man man NN 37231 2131 18 to to IN 37231 2131 19 life life NN 37231 2131 20 in in IN 37231 2131 21 order order NN 37231 2131 22 to to TO 37231 2131 23 convince convince VB 37231 2131 24 an an DT 37231 2131 25 unbeliever unbeliever NN 37231 2131 26 of of IN 37231 2131 27 the the DT 37231 2131 28 truth truth NN 37231 2131 29 of of IN 37231 2131 30 the the DT 37231 2131 31 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 2131 32 . . . 37231 2132 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2132 2 3 3 LS 37231 2132 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2132 4 St. St. NNP 37231 2132 5 Martin Martin NNP 37231 2132 6 , , , 37231 2132 7 of of IN 37231 2132 8 Tours Tours NNPS 37231 2132 9 , , , 37231 2132 10 restored restore VBN 37231 2132 11 to to IN 37231 2132 12 life life NN 37231 2132 13 a a DT 37231 2132 14 certain certain JJ 37231 2132 15 catechumen catechuman NNS 37231 2132 16 who who WP 37231 2132 17 had have VBD 37231 2132 18 died die VBN 37231 2132 19 of of IN 37231 2132 20 a a DT 37231 2132 21 fever fever NN 37231 2132 22 , , , 37231 2132 23 and and CC 37231 2132 24 Sulpicius Sulpicius NNP 37231 2132 25 , , , 37231 2132 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2132 27 disciple disciple NN 37231 2132 28 , , , 37231 2132 29 states state VBZ 37231 2132 30 that that IN 37231 2132 31 the the DT 37231 2132 32 man man NN 37231 2132 33 , , , 37231 2132 34 who who WP 37231 2132 35 lived live VBD 37231 2132 36 for for IN 37231 2132 37 many many JJ 37231 2132 38 years year NNS 37231 2132 39 after after IN 37231 2132 40 , , , 37231 2132 41 was be VBD 37231 2132 42 known know VBN 37231 2132 43 to to IN 37231 2132 44 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2132 45 , , , 37231 2132 46 although although IN 37231 2132 47 not not RB 37231 2132 48 until until IN 37231 2132 49 after after IN 37231 2132 50 the the DT 37231 2132 51 miracle miracle NN 37231 2132 52 . . . 37231 2133 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2133 2 also also RB 37231 2133 3 restored restore VBD 37231 2133 4 to to IN 37231 2133 5 life life NN 37231 2133 6 a a DT 37231 2133 7 servant servant NN 37231 2133 8 who who WP 37231 2133 9 had have VBD 37231 2133 10 hung hang VBN 37231 2133 11 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2133 12 . . . 37231 2134 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2134 2 4 4 LS 37231 2134 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2134 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2134 5 performed perform VBD 37231 2134 6 a a DT 37231 2134 7 multitude multitude NN 37231 2134 8 of of IN 37231 2134 9 other other JJ 37231 2134 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2134 11 , , , 37231 2134 12 to to TO 37231 2134 13 which which WDT 37231 2134 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2134 15 need need VBP 37231 2134 16 not not RB 37231 2134 17 here here RB 37231 2134 18 more more RBR 37231 2134 19 minutely minutely RB 37231 2134 20 refer refer NN 37231 2134 21 . . . 37231 2135 1 The the DT 37231 2135 2 relics relic NNS 37231 2135 3 of of IN 37231 2135 4 the the DT 37231 2135 5 two two CD 37231 2135 6 martyrs martyr NNS 37231 2135 7 Protavius Protavius NNP 37231 2135 8 and and CC 37231 2135 9 Gervasius Gervasius NNP 37231 2135 10 , , , 37231 2135 11 whose whose WP$ 37231 2135 12 bones bone NNS 37231 2135 13 , , , 37231 2135 14 with with IN 37231 2135 15 much much JJ 37231 2135 16 fresh fresh JJ 37231 2135 17 blood blood NN 37231 2135 18 , , , 37231 2135 19 the the DT 37231 2135 20 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2135 21 evidence evidence NN 37231 2135 22 of of IN 37231 2135 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2135 24 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2135 25 and and CC 37231 2135 26 identity identity NN 37231 2135 27 , , , 37231 2135 28 were be VBD 37231 2135 29 discovered discover VBN 37231 2135 30 by by IN 37231 2135 31 St. St. NNP 37231 2135 32 Ambrose Ambrose NNP 37231 2135 33 , , , 37231 2135 34 worked work VBD 37231 2135 35 a a DT 37231 2135 36 { { -LRB- 37231 2135 37 170 170 CD 37231 2135 38 } } -RRB- 37231 2135 39 number number NN 37231 2135 40 of of IN 37231 2135 41 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2135 42 . . . 37231 2136 1 A a DT 37231 2136 2 man man NN 37231 2136 3 suffering suffer VBG 37231 2136 4 from from IN 37231 2136 5 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 2136 6 possession possession NN 37231 2136 7 indicated indicate VBD 37231 2136 8 the the DT 37231 2136 9 proximity proximity NN 37231 2136 10 of of IN 37231 2136 11 the the DT 37231 2136 12 relics relic NNS 37231 2136 13 by by IN 37231 2136 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2136 15 convulsions convulsion NNS 37231 2136 16 . . . 37231 2137 1 St. St. NNP 37231 2137 2 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2137 3 states state VBZ 37231 2137 4 that that IN 37231 2137 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2137 6 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2137 7 was be VBD 37231 2137 8 in in IN 37231 2137 9 Milan Milan NNP 37231 2137 10 when when WRB 37231 2137 11 a a DT 37231 2137 12 blind blind JJ 37231 2137 13 man man NN 37231 2137 14 , , , 37231 2137 15 who who WP 37231 2137 16 merely merely RB 37231 2137 17 touched touch VBD 37231 2137 18 the the DT 37231 2137 19 cloth cloth NN 37231 2137 20 which which WDT 37231 2137 21 covered cover VBD 37231 2137 22 the the DT 37231 2137 23 two two CD 37231 2137 24 bodies body NNS 37231 2137 25 as as IN 37231 2137 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2137 27 were be VBD 37231 2137 28 being be VBG 37231 2137 29 moved move VBN 37231 2137 30 to to IN 37231 2137 31 a a DT 37231 2137 32 neighbouring neighbour VBG 37231 2137 33 church church NN 37231 2137 34 , , , 37231 2137 35 regained regain VBD 37231 2137 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2137 37 sight sight NN 37231 2137 38 . . . 37231 2138 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2138 2 1 1 LS 37231 2138 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2138 4 Paulinus Paulinus NNP 37231 2138 5 relates relate VBZ 37231 2138 6 many many JJ 37231 2138 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2138 8 performed perform VBN 37231 2138 9 by by IN 37231 2138 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2138 11 master master NN 37231 2138 12 , , , 37231 2138 13 St. St. NNP 37231 2138 14 Ambrose Ambrose NNP 37231 2138 15 , , , 37231 2138 16 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2138 17 . . . 37231 2139 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2139 2 not not RB 37231 2139 3 only only RB 37231 2139 4 cast cast VBD 37231 2139 5 out out RP 37231 2139 6 many many JJ 37231 2139 7 demons demon NNS 37231 2139 8 and and CC 37231 2139 9 healed heal VBD 37231 2139 10 the the DT 37231 2139 11 sick,(2 sick,(2 NNP 37231 2139 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2139 13 but but CC 37231 2139 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2139 15 also also RB 37231 2139 16 raised raise VBD 37231 2139 17 the the DT 37231 2139 18 dead dead NN 37231 2139 19 . . . 37231 2140 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 2140 2 the the DT 37231 2140 3 saint saint NN 37231 2140 4 was be VBD 37231 2140 5 staying stay VBG 37231 2140 6 in in IN 37231 2140 7 the the DT 37231 2140 8 house house NN 37231 2140 9 of of IN 37231 2140 10 a a DT 37231 2140 11 distinguished distinguished JJ 37231 2140 12 Christian christian JJ 37231 2140 13 friend friend NN 37231 2140 14 , , , 37231 2140 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2140 16 child child NN 37231 2140 17 , , , 37231 2140 18 who who WP 37231 2140 19 , , , 37231 2140 20 a a DT 37231 2140 21 few few JJ 37231 2140 22 days day NNS 37231 2140 23 before before RB 37231 2140 24 , , , 37231 2140 25 had have VBD 37231 2140 26 been be VBN 37231 2140 27 delivered deliver VBN 37231 2140 28 from from IN 37231 2140 29 an an DT 37231 2140 30 unclean unclean JJ 37231 2140 31 spirit spirit NN 37231 2140 32 , , , 37231 2140 33 suddenly suddenly RB 37231 2140 34 expired expire VBD 37231 2140 35 . . . 37231 2141 1 The the DT 37231 2141 2 mother mother NN 37231 2141 3 , , , 37231 2141 4 an an DT 37231 2141 5 exceedingly exceedingly RB 37231 2141 6 religious religious JJ 37231 2141 7 woman woman NN 37231 2141 8 , , , 37231 2141 9 full full JJ 37231 2141 10 of of IN 37231 2141 11 faith faith NN 37231 2141 12 and and CC 37231 2141 13 the the DT 37231 2141 14 fear fear NN 37231 2141 15 of of IN 37231 2141 16 God God NNP 37231 2141 17 , , , 37231 2141 18 carried carry VBD 37231 2141 19 the the DT 37231 2141 20 dead dead JJ 37231 2141 21 boy boy NN 37231 2141 22 down down RP 37231 2141 23 and and CC 37231 2141 24 laid lay VBD 37231 2141 25 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2141 26 on on IN 37231 2141 27 the the DT 37231 2141 28 saint saint NN 37231 2141 29 's 's POS 37231 2141 30 bed bed NN 37231 2141 31 during during IN 37231 2141 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2141 33 absence absence NN 37231 2141 34 . . . 37231 2142 1 When when WRB 37231 2142 2 St. St. NNP 37231 2142 3 Ambrose Ambrose NNP 37231 2142 4 returned return VBD 37231 2142 5 , , , 37231 2142 6 filled fill VBN 37231 2142 7 with with IN 37231 2142 8 compassion compassion NN 37231 2142 9 for for IN 37231 2142 10 the the DT 37231 2142 11 mother mother NN 37231 2142 12 and and CC 37231 2142 13 struck strike VBN 37231 2142 14 by by IN 37231 2142 15 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2142 16 faith faith NN 37231 2142 17 , , , 37231 2142 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2142 19 stretched stretch VBD 37231 2142 20 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2142 21 , , , 37231 2142 22 like like IN 37231 2142 23 Elisha Elisha NNP 37231 2142 24 , , , 37231 2142 25 on on IN 37231 2142 26 the the DT 37231 2142 27 body body NN 37231 2142 28 of of IN 37231 2142 29 the the DT 37231 2142 30 child child NN 37231 2142 31 , , , 37231 2142 32 praying pray VBG 37231 2142 33 , , , 37231 2142 34 and and CC 37231 2142 35 restored restore VBD 37231 2142 36 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2142 37 living live VBG 37231 2142 38 to to IN 37231 2142 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2142 40 mother mother NN 37231 2142 41 . . . 37231 2143 1 Paulinus Paulinus NNP 37231 2143 2 relates relate VBZ 37231 2143 3 this this DT 37231 2143 4 miracle miracle NN 37231 2143 5 with with IN 37231 2143 6 minute minute JJ 37231 2143 7 particulars particular NNS 37231 2143 8 of of IN 37231 2143 9 name name NN 37231 2143 10 and and CC 37231 2143 11 address address NN 37231 2143 12 . . . 37231 2144 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2144 2 3 3 LS 37231 2144 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2144 4 St. St. NNP 37231 2144 5 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2144 6 asserts assert VBZ 37231 2144 7 that that IN 37231 2144 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2144 9 are be VBP 37231 2144 10 still still RB 37231 2144 11 performed perform VBN 37231 2144 12 in in IN 37231 2144 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2144 14 day day NN 37231 2144 15 in in IN 37231 2144 16 the the DT 37231 2144 17 name name NN 37231 2144 18 of of IN 37231 2144 19 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2144 20 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2144 21 , , , 37231 2144 22 either either CC 37231 2144 23 by by IN 37231 2144 24 means mean NNS 37231 2144 25 of of IN 37231 2144 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2144 27 sacraments sacrament NNS 37231 2144 28 or or CC 37231 2144 29 by by IN 37231 2144 30 the the DT 37231 2144 31 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2144 32 or or CC 37231 2144 33 relics relic NNS 37231 2144 34 of of IN 37231 2144 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2144 36 saints saint NNS 37231 2144 37 , , , 37231 2144 38 although although IN 37231 2144 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2144 40 are be VBP 37231 2144 41 not not RB 37231 2144 42 so so RB 37231 2144 43 well well RB 37231 2144 44 - - HYPH 37231 2144 45 known know VBN 37231 2144 46 as as IN 37231 2144 47 those those DT 37231 2144 48 of of IN 37231 2144 49 old old JJ 37231 2144 50 , , , 37231 2144 51 and and CC 37231 2144 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2144 53 gives give VBZ 37231 2144 54 an an DT 37231 2144 55 account account NN 37231 2144 56 of of IN 37231 2144 57 many many JJ 37231 2144 58 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2144 59 which which WDT 37231 2144 60 had have VBD 37231 2144 61 recently recently RB 37231 2144 62 taken take VBN 37231 2144 63 place place NN 37231 2144 64 . . . 37231 2145 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2145 2 4 4 LS 37231 2145 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2145 4 After after IN 37231 2145 5 referring refer VBG 37231 2145 6 to to IN 37231 2145 7 the the DT 37231 2145 8 miracle miracle NN 37231 2145 9 performed perform VBN 37231 2145 10 by by IN 37231 2145 11 the the DT 37231 2145 12 relics relic NNS 37231 2145 13 of of IN 37231 2145 14 the the DT 37231 2145 15 two two CD 37231 2145 16 martyrs martyr NNS 37231 2145 17 upon upon IN 37231 2145 18 the the DT 37231 2145 19 blind blind JJ 37231 2145 20 man man NN 37231 2145 21 in in IN 37231 2145 22 Milan Milan NNP 37231 2145 23 , , , 37231 2145 24 which which WDT 37231 2145 25 occurred occur VBD 37231 2145 26 when when WRB 37231 2145 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2145 28 was be VBD 37231 2145 29 there there RB 37231 2145 30 , , , 37231 2145 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2145 32 goes go VBZ 37231 2145 33 on on RP 37231 2145 34 to to TO 37231 2145 35 narrate narrate VB 37231 2145 36 the the DT 37231 2145 37 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2145 38 cure cure NN 37231 2145 39 of of IN 37231 2145 40 a a DT 37231 2145 41 friend friend NN 37231 2145 42 of of IN 37231 2145 43 { { -LRB- 37231 2145 44 171 171 CD 37231 2145 45 } } -RRB- 37231 2145 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2145 47 own own JJ 37231 2145 48 , , , 37231 2145 49 named name VBN 37231 2145 50 Innocent innocent JJ 37231 2145 51 , , , 37231 2145 52 formerly formerly RB 37231 2145 53 advocate advocate NN 37231 2145 54 of of IN 37231 2145 55 the the DT 37231 2145 56 prefecture prefecture NN 37231 2145 57 , , , 37231 2145 58 in in IN 37231 2145 59 Carthage carthage NN 37231 2145 60 , , , 37231 2145 61 where where WRB 37231 2145 62 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2145 63 was be VBD 37231 2145 64 , , , 37231 2145 65 and and CC 37231 2145 66 beheld beheld VB 37231 2145 67 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2145 68 with with IN 37231 2145 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2145 70 own own JJ 37231 2145 71 eyes eye NNS 37231 2145 72 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2145 73 _ _ NNP 37231 2145 74 ubi ubi VBP 37231 2145 75 nos nos NNP 37231 2145 76 interfuimus interfuimus NNP 37231 2145 77 et et NNP 37231 2145 78 oculis oculis NNP 37231 2145 79 aspeximus aspeximus NNP 37231 2145 80 nostris nostris NNP 37231 2145 81 _ _ NNP 37231 2145 82 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2145 83 . . . 37231 2146 1 A a DT 37231 2146 2 lady lady NN 37231 2146 3 of of IN 37231 2146 4 rank rank NN 37231 2146 5 in in IN 37231 2146 6 the the DT 37231 2146 7 same same JJ 37231 2146 8 city city NN 37231 2146 9 was be VBD 37231 2146 10 miraculously miraculously RB 37231 2146 11 healed heal VBN 37231 2146 12 of of IN 37231 2146 13 an an DT 37231 2146 14 incurable incurable JJ 37231 2146 15 cancer cancer NN 37231 2146 16 , , , 37231 2146 17 and and CC 37231 2146 18 St. St. NNP 37231 2146 19 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2146 20 is be VBZ 37231 2146 21 indignant indignant JJ 37231 2146 22 at at IN 37231 2146 23 the the DT 37231 2146 24 apathy apathy NN 37231 2146 25 of of IN 37231 2146 26 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2146 27 friends friend NNS 37231 2146 28 , , , 37231 2146 29 which which WDT 37231 2146 30 allowed allow VBD 37231 2146 31 so so RB 37231 2146 32 great great JJ 37231 2146 33 a a DT 37231 2146 34 miracle miracle NN 37231 2146 35 to to TO 37231 2146 36 be be VB 37231 2146 37 so so RB 37231 2146 38 little little RB 37231 2146 39 known know VBN 37231 2146 40 . . . 37231 2147 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2147 2 1 1 LS 37231 2147 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2147 4 An an DT 37231 2147 5 inhabitant inhabitant NN 37231 2147 6 of of IN 37231 2147 7 the the DT 37231 2147 8 neighbouring neighbouring NN 37231 2147 9 town town NN 37231 2147 10 of of IN 37231 2147 11 Curubis Curubis NNP 37231 2147 12 was be VBD 37231 2147 13 cured cure VBN 37231 2147 14 of of IN 37231 2147 15 paralysis paralysis NN 37231 2147 16 and and CC 37231 2147 17 other other JJ 37231 2147 18 ills ill NNS 37231 2147 19 by by IN 37231 2147 20 being be VBG 37231 2147 21 baptized baptize VBN 37231 2147 22 . . . 37231 2148 1 When when WRB 37231 2148 2 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2148 3 heard hear VBD 37231 2148 4 of of IN 37231 2148 5 this this DT 37231 2148 6 , , , 37231 2148 7 although although IN 37231 2148 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2148 9 was be VBD 37231 2148 10 reported report VBN 37231 2148 11 on on IN 37231 2148 12 very very RB 37231 2148 13 good good JJ 37231 2148 14 authority authority NN 37231 2148 15 , , , 37231 2148 16 the the DT 37231 2148 17 man man NN 37231 2148 18 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2148 19 was be VBD 37231 2148 20 brought bring VBN 37231 2148 21 to to IN 37231 2148 22 Carthage carthage NN 37231 2148 23 by by IN 37231 2148 24 order order NN 37231 2148 25 of of IN 37231 2148 26 the the DT 37231 2148 27 holy holy NNP 37231 2148 28 bishop bishop NNP 37231 2148 29 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 2148 30 , , , 37231 2148 31 in in IN 37231 2148 32 order order NN 37231 2148 33 that that IN 37231 2148 34 the the DT 37231 2148 35 truth truth NN 37231 2148 36 might may MD 37231 2148 37 be be VB 37231 2148 38 ascertained ascertain VBN 37231 2148 39 . . . 37231 2149 1 Augustine augustine JJ 37231 2149 2 states state NNS 37231 2149 3 that that IN 37231 2149 4 , , , 37231 2149 5 on on IN 37231 2149 6 one one CD 37231 2149 7 occasion occasion NN 37231 2149 8 during during IN 37231 2149 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2149 10 absence absence NN 37231 2149 11 , , , 37231 2149 12 a a DT 37231 2149 13 tribunitian tribunitian JJ 37231 2149 14 man man NN 37231 2149 15 amongst amongst IN 37231 2149 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2149 17 named name VBN 37231 2149 18 Hesperius Hesperius NNP 37231 2149 19 , , , 37231 2149 20 who who WP 37231 2149 21 had have VBD 37231 2149 22 a a DT 37231 2149 23 farm farm NN 37231 2149 24 close close RB 37231 2149 25 by by RB 37231 2149 26 , , , 37231 2149 27 called call VBN 37231 2149 28 Zubedi Zubedi NNP 37231 2149 29 , , , 37231 2149 30 in in IN 37231 2149 31 the the DT 37231 2149 32 Fussalian fussalian JJ 37231 2149 33 district district NN 37231 2149 34 , , , 37231 2149 35 begged beg VBD 37231 2149 36 one one CD 37231 2149 37 of of IN 37231 2149 38 the the DT 37231 2149 39 Christian christian JJ 37231 2149 40 presbyters presbyter NNS 37231 2149 41 to to TO 37231 2149 42 go go VB 37231 2149 43 and and CC 37231 2149 44 drive drive VB 37231 2149 45 away away RB 37231 2149 46 some some DT 37231 2149 47 evil evil JJ 37231 2149 48 spirits spirit NNS 37231 2149 49 whose whose WP$ 37231 2149 50 malice malice NN 37231 2149 51 sorely sorely RB 37231 2149 52 afflicted afflict VBD 37231 2149 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2149 54 servants servant NNS 37231 2149 55 and and CC 37231 2149 56 cattle cattle NNS 37231 2149 57 . . . 37231 2150 1 One one CD 37231 2150 2 of of IN 37231 2150 3 the the DT 37231 2150 4 presbyters presbyter NNS 37231 2150 5 accordingly accordingly RB 37231 2150 6 went go VBD 37231 2150 7 , , , 37231 2150 8 and and CC 37231 2150 9 offered offer VBD 37231 2150 10 the the DT 37231 2150 11 sacrifice sacrifice NN 37231 2150 12 of of IN 37231 2150 13 the the DT 37231 2150 14 body body NN 37231 2150 15 of of IN 37231 2150 16 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2150 17 with with IN 37231 2150 18 earnest earnest JJ 37231 2150 19 prayer prayer NN 37231 2150 20 , , , 37231 2150 21 and and CC 37231 2150 22 by by IN 37231 2150 23 the the DT 37231 2150 24 mercy mercy NN 37231 2150 25 of of IN 37231 2150 26 God God NNP 37231 2150 27 , , , 37231 2150 28 the the DT 37231 2150 29 evil evil NN 37231 2150 30 was be VBD 37231 2150 31 removed remove VBN 37231 2150 32 . . . 37231 2151 1 Now now RB 37231 2151 2 Hesperius Hesperius NNP 37231 2151 3 happened happen VBD 37231 2151 4 to to TO 37231 2151 5 have have VB 37231 2151 6 received receive VBN 37231 2151 7 from from IN 37231 2151 8 one one CD 37231 2151 9 of of IN 37231 2151 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2151 11 friends friend NNS 37231 2151 12 a a DT 37231 2151 13 piece piece NN 37231 2151 14 of of IN 37231 2151 15 the the DT 37231 2151 16 sacred sacred JJ 37231 2151 17 earth earth NN 37231 2151 18 of of IN 37231 2151 19 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 2151 20 , , , 37231 2151 21 where where WRB 37231 2151 22 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2151 23 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2151 24 was be VBD 37231 2151 25 buried bury VBN 37231 2151 26 and and CC 37231 2151 27 rose rise VBD 37231 2151 28 again again RB 37231 2151 29 the the DT 37231 2151 30 third third JJ 37231 2151 31 day day NN 37231 2151 32 , , , 37231 2151 33 and and CC 37231 2151 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2151 35 had have VBD 37231 2151 36 hung hang VBN 37231 2151 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2151 38 up up RP 37231 2151 39 in in IN 37231 2151 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2151 41 room room NN 37231 2151 42 to to TO 37231 2151 43 protect protect VB 37231 2151 44 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2151 45 from from IN 37231 2151 46 the the DT 37231 2151 47 evil evil JJ 37231 2151 48 spirits spirit NNS 37231 2151 49 . . . 37231 2152 1 When when WRB 37231 2152 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2152 3 house house NN 37231 2152 4 had have VBD 37231 2152 5 been be VBN 37231 2152 6 freed free VBN 37231 2152 7 from from IN 37231 2152 8 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2152 9 , , , 37231 2152 10 however however RB 37231 2152 11 , , , 37231 2152 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2152 13 begged beg VBD 37231 2152 14 St. St. NNP 37231 2152 15 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2152 16 and and CC 37231 2152 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2152 18 colleague colleague NN 37231 2152 19 Maximinus Maximinus NNP 37231 2152 20 , , , 37231 2152 21 who who WP 37231 2152 22 happened happen VBD 37231 2152 23 to to TO 37231 2152 24 be be VB 37231 2152 25 in in IN 37231 2152 26 that that DT 37231 2152 27 neighbourhood neighbourhood NN 37231 2152 28 , , , 37231 2152 29 to to TO 37231 2152 30 come come VB 37231 2152 31 to to IN 37231 2152 32 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2152 33 , , , 37231 2152 34 and and CC 37231 2152 35 after after IN 37231 2152 36 telling tell VBG 37231 2152 37 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2152 38 all all DT 37231 2152 39 that that WDT 37231 2152 40 had have VBD 37231 2152 41 happened happen VBN 37231 2152 42 , , , 37231 2152 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2152 44 prayed pray VBD 37231 2152 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2152 46 to to TO 37231 2152 47 bury bury VB 37231 2152 48 the the DT 37231 2152 49 piece piece NN 37231 2152 50 of of IN 37231 2152 51 earth earth NN 37231 2152 52 in in IN 37231 2152 53 some some DT 37231 2152 54 place place NN 37231 2152 55 where where WRB 37231 2152 56 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2152 57 could could MD 37231 2152 58 assemble assemble VB 37231 2152 59 for for IN 37231 2152 60 the the DT 37231 2152 61 worship worship NN 37231 2152 62 of of IN 37231 2152 63 God God NNP 37231 2152 64 . . . 37231 2153 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 2153 2 consented consent VBD 37231 2153 3 , , , 37231 2153 4 and and CC 37231 2153 5 did do VBD 37231 2153 6 as as IN 37231 2153 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2153 8 desired desire VBD 37231 2153 9 . . . 37231 2154 1 A a DT 37231 2154 2 young young JJ 37231 2154 3 peasant peasant NN 37231 2154 4 of of IN 37231 2154 5 the the DT 37231 2154 6 neighbourhood neighbourhood NN 37231 2154 7 , , , 37231 2154 8 who who WP 37231 2154 9 was be VBD 37231 2154 10 paralytic paralytic JJ 37231 2154 11 , , , 37231 2154 12 hearing hearing NN 37231 2154 13 of of IN 37231 2154 14 this this DT 37231 2154 15 , , , 37231 2154 16 begged beg VBD 37231 2154 17 that that IN 37231 2154 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2154 19 might may MD 37231 2154 20 be be VB 37231 2154 21 carried carry VBN 37231 2154 22 without without IN 37231 2154 23 delay delay NN 37231 2154 24 to to IN 37231 2154 25 the the DT 37231 2154 26 holy holy JJ 37231 2154 27 spot spot NN 37231 2154 28 , , , 37231 2154 29 where where WRB 37231 2154 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2154 31 offered offer VBD 37231 2154 32 up up RP 37231 2154 33 prayer prayer NN 37231 2154 34 , , , 37231 2154 35 and and CC 37231 2154 36 rose rise VBD 37231 2154 37 up up RP 37231 2154 38 and and CC 37231 2154 39 went go VBD 37231 2154 40 away away RB 37231 2154 41 on on IN 37231 2154 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2154 43 feet foot NNS 37231 2154 44 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2154 45 cured cure VBN 37231 2154 46 . . . 37231 2155 1 About about RB 37231 2155 2 thirty thirty CD 37231 2155 3 miles mile NNS 37231 2155 4 from from IN 37231 2155 5 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2155 6 , , , 37231 2155 7 at at IN 37231 2155 8 a a DT 37231 2155 9 farm farm NN 37231 2155 10 called call VBN 37231 2155 11 Victoriana Victoriana NNP 37231 2155 12 , , , 37231 2155 13 there there EX 37231 2155 14 was be VBD 37231 2155 15 a a DT 37231 2155 16 memorial memorial NN 37231 2155 17 to to IN 37231 2155 18 the the DT 37231 2155 19 two two CD 37231 2155 20 martyrs martyr NNS 37231 2155 21 Protavius Protavius NNP 37231 2155 22 and and CC 37231 2155 23 Gervasius Gervasius NNP 37231 2155 24 . . . 37231 2156 1 To to IN 37231 2156 2 this this DT 37231 2156 3 , , , 37231 2156 4 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2156 5 relates relate VBZ 37231 2156 6 , , , 37231 2156 7 was be VBD 37231 2156 8 brought bring VBN 37231 2156 9 a a DT 37231 2156 10 young young JJ 37231 2156 11 man man NN 37231 2156 12 who who WP 37231 2156 13 , , , 37231 2156 14 having have VBG 37231 2156 15 gone go VBN 37231 2156 16 one one CD 37231 2156 17 summer summer NN 37231 2156 18 day day NN 37231 2156 19 at at IN 37231 2156 20 noon noon NN 37231 2156 21 to to TO 37231 2156 22 water water VB 37231 2156 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2156 24 horse horse NN 37231 2156 25 in in IN 37231 2156 26 the the DT 37231 2156 27 river river NN 37231 2156 28 , , , 37231 2156 29 was be VBD 37231 2156 30 possessed possess VBN 37231 2156 31 by by IN 37231 2156 32 a a DT 37231 2156 33 demon demon NN 37231 2156 34 . . . 37231 2157 1 The the DT 37231 2157 2 lady lady NN 37231 2157 3 to to TO 37231 2157 4 whom whom WP 37231 2157 5 the the DT 37231 2157 6 place place NN 37231 2157 7 belonged belong VBD 37231 2157 8 came come VBD 37231 2157 9 according accord VBG 37231 2157 10 to to IN 37231 2157 11 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2157 12 custom custom NN 37231 2157 13 in in IN 37231 2157 14 the the DT 37231 2157 15 evening evening NN 37231 2157 16 , , , 37231 2157 17 with with IN 37231 2157 18 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2157 19 servants servant NNS 37231 2157 20 and and CC 37231 2157 21 some some DT 37231 2157 22 holy holy JJ 37231 2157 23 women woman NNS 37231 2157 24 to to TO 37231 2157 25 sing sing VB 37231 2157 26 hymns hymn NNS 37231 2157 27 and and CC 37231 2157 28 pray pray VB 37231 2157 29 . . . 37231 2158 1 On on IN 37231 2158 2 hearing hear VBG 37231 2158 3 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2158 4 the the DT 37231 2158 5 demoniac demoniac NN 37231 2158 6 started start VBD 37231 2158 7 up up RP 37231 2158 8 and and CC 37231 2158 9 seized seize VBD 37231 2158 10 the the DT 37231 2158 11 altar altar NN 37231 2158 12 with with IN 37231 2158 13 a a DT 37231 2158 14 terrible terrible JJ 37231 2158 15 shudder shudder NN 37231 2158 16 , , , 37231 2158 17 without without IN 37231 2158 18 daring dare VBG 37231 2158 19 to to TO 37231 2158 20 move move VB 37231 2158 21 , , , 37231 2158 22 and and CC 37231 2158 23 as as IN 37231 2158 24 if if IN 37231 2158 25 bound bind VBN 37231 2158 26 to to IN 37231 2158 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2158 28 , , , 37231 2158 29 and and CC 37231 2158 30 the the DT 37231 2158 31 demon demon NN 37231 2158 32 praying pray VBG 37231 2158 33 with with IN 37231 2158 34 a a DT 37231 2158 35 loud loud JJ 37231 2158 36 voice voice NN 37231 2158 37 for for IN 37231 2158 38 mercy mercy NN 37231 2158 39 confessed confess VBD 37231 2158 40 where where WRB 37231 2158 41 and and CC 37231 2158 42 when when WRB 37231 2158 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2158 44 had have VBD 37231 2158 45 entered enter VBN 37231 2158 46 into into IN 37231 2158 47 the the DT 37231 2158 48 young young JJ 37231 2158 49 man man NN 37231 2158 50 . . . 37231 2159 1 At at IN 37231 2159 2 last last JJ 37231 2159 3 the the DT 37231 2159 4 demon demon NN 37231 2159 5 named name VBN 37231 2159 6 all all PDT 37231 2159 7 the the DT 37231 2159 8 members member NNS 37231 2159 9 of of IN 37231 2159 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2159 11 body body NN 37231 2159 12 , , , 37231 2159 13 with with IN 37231 2159 14 threats threat NNS 37231 2159 15 to to TO 37231 2159 16 cut cut VB 37231 2159 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2159 18 off off RP 37231 2159 19 as as IN 37231 2159 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2159 21 made make VBD 37231 2159 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2159 23 exit exit NN 37231 2159 24 , , , 37231 2159 25 and and CC 37231 2159 26 , , , 37231 2159 27 saying say VBG 37231 2159 28 these these DT 37231 2159 29 words word NNS 37231 2159 30 , , , 37231 2159 31 came come VBD 37231 2159 32 out out IN 37231 2159 33 of of IN 37231 2159 34 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2159 35 . . . 37231 2160 1 In in IN 37231 2160 2 doing do VBG 37231 2160 3 so so RB 37231 2160 4 , , , 37231 2160 5 however however RB 37231 2160 6 , , , 37231 2160 7 the the DT 37231 2160 8 eye eye NN 37231 2160 9 of of IN 37231 2160 10 the the DT 37231 2160 11 youth youth NN 37231 2160 12 fell fall VBD 37231 2160 13 from from IN 37231 2160 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2160 15 socket socket NN 37231 2160 16 on on IN 37231 2160 17 to to IN 37231 2160 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2160 19 cheek cheek NN 37231 2160 20 , , , 37231 2160 21 retained retain VBN 37231 2160 22 only only RB 37231 2160 23 by by IN 37231 2160 24 a a DT 37231 2160 25 small small JJ 37231 2160 26 vein vein NN 37231 2160 27 as as IN 37231 2160 28 by by IN 37231 2160 29 a a DT 37231 2160 30 root root NN 37231 2160 31 , , , 37231 2160 32 whilst whilst IN 37231 2160 33 the the DT 37231 2160 34 pupil pupil NN 37231 2160 35 became become VBD 37231 2160 36 altogether altogether RB 37231 2160 37 white white JJ 37231 2160 38 . . . 37231 2161 1 Well well UH 37231 2161 2 pleased pleased JJ 37231 2161 3 , , , 37231 2161 4 however however RB 37231 2161 5 , , , 37231 2161 6 that that IN 37231 2161 7 the the DT 37231 2161 8 young young JJ 37231 2161 9 man man NN 37231 2161 10 had have VBD 37231 2161 11 been be VBN 37231 2161 12 freed free VBN 37231 2161 13 from from IN 37231 2161 14 the the DT 37231 2161 15 evil evil JJ 37231 2161 16 spirit spirit NN 37231 2161 17 , , , 37231 2161 18 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2161 19 returned return VBD 37231 2161 20 the the DT 37231 2161 21 eye eye NN 37231 2161 22 to to IN 37231 2161 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2161 24 place place NN 37231 2161 25 as as RB 37231 2161 26 well well RB 37231 2161 27 as as IN 37231 2161 28 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2161 29 could could MD 37231 2161 30 , , , 37231 2161 31 and and CC 37231 2161 32 bound bind VBD 37231 2161 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2161 34 up up RP 37231 2161 35 with with IN 37231 2161 36 a a DT 37231 2161 37 handkerchief handkerchief NN 37231 2161 38 , , , 37231 2161 39 praying pray VBG 37231 2161 40 fervently fervently RB 37231 2161 41 , , , 37231 2161 42 and and CC 37231 2161 43 one one CD 37231 2161 44 of of IN 37231 2161 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2161 46 relatives relative NNS 37231 2161 47 said say VBD 37231 2161 48 : : : 37231 2161 49 " " `` 37231 2161 50 God God NNP 37231 2161 51 who who WP 37231 2161 52 drove drive VBD 37231 2161 53 out out RP 37231 2161 54 the the DT 37231 2161 55 demon demon NN 37231 2161 56 at at IN 37231 2161 57 the the DT 37231 2161 58 prayer prayer NN 37231 2161 59 of of IN 37231 2161 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2161 61 saints saint NNS 37231 2161 62 can can MD 37231 2161 63 also also RB 37231 2161 64 restore restore VB 37231 2161 65 the the DT 37231 2161 66 sight sight NN 37231 2161 67 . . . 37231 2161 68 " " '' 37231 2162 1 On on IN 37231 2162 2 removing remove VBG 37231 2162 3 the the DT 37231 2162 4 bandage bandage NN 37231 2162 5 seven seven CD 37231 2162 6 days day NNS 37231 2162 7 after after RB 37231 2162 8 , , , 37231 2162 9 the the DT 37231 2162 10 eye eye NN 37231 2162 11 was be VBD 37231 2162 12 found find VBN 37231 2162 13 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2162 14 whole whole JJ 37231 2162 15 . . . 37231 2163 1 St. St. NNP 37231 2163 2 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2163 3 knew know VBD 37231 2163 4 a a DT 37231 2163 5 girl girl NN 37231 2163 6 of of IN 37231 2163 7 { { -LRB- 37231 2163 8 173 173 CD 37231 2163 9 } } -RRB- 37231 2163 10 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2163 11 who who WP 37231 2163 12 was be VBD 37231 2163 13 delivered deliver VBN 37231 2163 14 from from IN 37231 2163 15 a a DT 37231 2163 16 demon demon NN 37231 2163 17 by by IN 37231 2163 18 the the DT 37231 2163 19 application application NN 37231 2163 20 of of IN 37231 2163 21 oil oil NN 37231 2163 22 with with IN 37231 2163 23 which which WDT 37231 2163 24 had have VBD 37231 2163 25 mingled mingle VBN 37231 2163 26 the the DT 37231 2163 27 tears tear NNS 37231 2163 28 of of IN 37231 2163 29 the the DT 37231 2163 30 presbyter presbyter NN 37231 2163 31 who who WP 37231 2163 32 was be VBD 37231 2163 33 praying pray VBG 37231 2163 34 for for IN 37231 2163 35 her -PRON- PRP 37231 2163 36 . . . 37231 2164 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2164 2 also also RB 37231 2164 3 knew know VBD 37231 2164 4 a a DT 37231 2164 5 bishop bishop NN 37231 2164 6 who who WP 37231 2164 7 prayed pray VBD 37231 2164 8 for for IN 37231 2164 9 a a DT 37231 2164 10 youth youth NN 37231 2164 11 possessed possess VBN 37231 2164 12 by by IN 37231 2164 13 a a DT 37231 2164 14 demon demon NN 37231 2164 15 , , , 37231 2164 16 although although IN 37231 2164 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2164 18 had have VBD 37231 2164 19 not not RB 37231 2164 20 even even RB 37231 2164 21 seen see VBN 37231 2164 22 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2164 23 , , , 37231 2164 24 and and CC 37231 2164 25 the the DT 37231 2164 26 young young JJ 37231 2164 27 man man NN 37231 2164 28 was be VBD 37231 2164 29 at at IN 37231 2164 30 once once RB 37231 2164 31 cured cure VBN 37231 2164 32 . . . 37231 2165 1 Augustine augustine PRP$ 37231 2165 2 further further JJ 37231 2165 3 gives give VBZ 37231 2165 4 particulars particular NNS 37231 2165 5 of of IN 37231 2165 6 many many JJ 37231 2165 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2165 8 performed perform VBN 37231 2165 9 by by IN 37231 2165 10 the the DT 37231 2165 11 relics relic NNS 37231 2165 12 of of IN 37231 2165 13 the the DT 37231 2165 14 most most RBS 37231 2165 15 glorious glorious JJ 37231 2165 16 martyr martyr NN 37231 2165 17 Stephen Stephen NNP 37231 2165 18 . . . 37231 2166 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2166 2 1 1 LS 37231 2166 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2166 4 By by IN 37231 2166 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2166 6 virtue virtue NN 37231 2166 7 the the DT 37231 2166 8 blind blind NN 37231 2166 9 receive receive VBP 37231 2166 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2166 11 sight sight NN 37231 2166 12 , , , 37231 2166 13 the the DT 37231 2166 14 sick sick JJ 37231 2166 15 are be VBP 37231 2166 16 healed heal VBN 37231 2166 17 , , , 37231 2166 18 the the DT 37231 2166 19 impenitent impenitent NN 37231 2166 20 converted convert VBD 37231 2166 21 , , , 37231 2166 22 and and CC 37231 2166 23 the the DT 37231 2166 24 dead dead NNS 37231 2166 25 are be VBP 37231 2166 26 restored restore VBN 37231 2166 27 to to IN 37231 2166 28 life life NN 37231 2166 29 . . . 37231 2167 1 " " `` 37231 2167 2 Andurus Andurus NNP 37231 2167 3 is be VBZ 37231 2167 4 the the DT 37231 2167 5 name name NN 37231 2167 6 of of IN 37231 2167 7 an an DT 37231 2167 8 estate estate NN 37231 2167 9 , , , 37231 2167 10 " " '' 37231 2167 11 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2167 12 says say VBZ 37231 2167 13 , , , 37231 2167 14 " " `` 37231 2167 15 where where WRB 37231 2167 16 there there EX 37231 2167 17 is be VBZ 37231 2167 18 a a DT 37231 2167 19 church church NN 37231 2167 20 and and CC 37231 2167 21 in in IN 37231 2167 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2167 23 a a DT 37231 2167 24 shrine shrine NN 37231 2167 25 dedicated dedicate VBN 37231 2167 26 to to IN 37231 2167 27 the the DT 37231 2167 28 martyr martyr NN 37231 2167 29 Stephen Stephen NNP 37231 2167 30 . . . 37231 2168 1 A a DT 37231 2168 2 certain certain JJ 37231 2168 3 little little JJ 37231 2168 4 boy boy NN 37231 2168 5 was be VBD 37231 2168 6 playing play VBG 37231 2168 7 in in IN 37231 2168 8 the the DT 37231 2168 9 court court NN 37231 2168 10 , , , 37231 2168 11 when when WRB 37231 2168 12 unruly unruly JJ 37231 2168 13 bullocks bullock VBZ 37231 2168 14 drawing draw VBG 37231 2168 15 a a DT 37231 2168 16 waggon waggon NN 37231 2168 17 crushed crush VBD 37231 2168 18 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2168 19 with with IN 37231 2168 20 the the DT 37231 2168 21 wheel wheel NN 37231 2168 22 , , , 37231 2168 23 and and CC 37231 2168 24 immediately immediately RB 37231 2168 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2168 26 lay lie VBD 37231 2168 27 in in IN 37231 2168 28 the the DT 37231 2168 29 agonies agony NNS 37231 2168 30 of of IN 37231 2168 31 death death NN 37231 2168 32 . . . 37231 2169 1 Then then RB 37231 2169 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2169 3 mother mother NN 37231 2169 4 raised raise VBD 37231 2169 5 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2169 6 up up RP 37231 2169 7 , , , 37231 2169 8 and and CC 37231 2169 9 placed place VBD 37231 2169 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2169 11 at at IN 37231 2169 12 the the DT 37231 2169 13 shrine shrine NN 37231 2169 14 , , , 37231 2169 15 and and CC 37231 2169 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2169 17 not not RB 37231 2169 18 only only RB 37231 2169 19 came come VBD 37231 2169 20 to to IN 37231 2169 21 life life NN 37231 2169 22 again again RB 37231 2169 23 , , , 37231 2169 24 but but CC 37231 2169 25 had have VBD 37231 2169 26 manifestly manifestly RB 37231 2169 27 received receive VBN 37231 2169 28 no no DT 37231 2169 29 injury injury NN 37231 2169 30 . . . 37231 2170 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2170 2 2 2 LS 37231 2170 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2170 4 A a DT 37231 2170 5 certain certain JJ 37231 2170 6 religious religious JJ 37231 2170 7 woman woman NN 37231 2170 8 , , , 37231 2170 9 who who WP 37231 2170 10 lived live VBD 37231 2170 11 in in IN 37231 2170 12 a a DT 37231 2170 13 neighbouring neighbouring JJ 37231 2170 14 property property NN 37231 2170 15 called call VBN 37231 2170 16 Caspalianus Caspalianus NNP 37231 2170 17 , , , 37231 2170 18 being be VBG 37231 2170 19 dangerously dangerously RB 37231 2170 20 ill ill JJ 37231 2170 21 and and CC 37231 2170 22 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2170 23 life life NN 37231 2170 24 despaired despair VBN 37231 2170 25 of of IN 37231 2170 26 , , , 37231 2170 27 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2170 28 tunic tunic NNP 37231 2170 29 was be VBD 37231 2170 30 carried carry VBN 37231 2170 31 to to IN 37231 2170 32 the the DT 37231 2170 33 same same JJ 37231 2170 34 shrine shrine NN 37231 2170 35 , , , 37231 2170 36 but but CC 37231 2170 37 before before IN 37231 2170 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2170 39 was be VBD 37231 2170 40 brought bring VBN 37231 2170 41 back back RB 37231 2170 42 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2170 43 had have VBD 37231 2170 44 expired expire VBN 37231 2170 45 . . . 37231 2171 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 2171 2 , , , 37231 2171 3 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2171 4 relatives relative NNS 37231 2171 5 covered cover VBD 37231 2171 6 the the DT 37231 2171 7 body body NN 37231 2171 8 with with IN 37231 2171 9 this this DT 37231 2171 10 tunic tunic JJ 37231 2171 11 , , , 37231 2171 12 and and CC 37231 2171 13 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2171 14 received receive VBD 37231 2171 15 back back RB 37231 2171 16 the the DT 37231 2171 17 spirit spirit NN 37231 2171 18 and and CC 37231 2171 19 was be VBD 37231 2171 20 made make VBN 37231 2171 21 whole whole JJ 37231 2171 22 . . . 37231 2172 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2172 2 3 3 LS 37231 2172 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2172 4 At at IN 37231 2172 5 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2172 6 , , , 37231 2172 7 a a DT 37231 2172 8 certain certain JJ 37231 2172 9 man man NN 37231 2172 10 named name VBN 37231 2172 11 { { -LRB- 37231 2172 12 174 174 CD 37231 2172 13 } } -RRB- 37231 2172 14 Bassus Bassus NNP 37231 2172 15 , , , 37231 2172 16 a a DT 37231 2172 17 Syrian Syrian NNP 37231 2172 18 , , , 37231 2172 19 was be VBD 37231 2172 20 praying pray VBG 37231 2172 21 at at IN 37231 2172 22 the the DT 37231 2172 23 shrine shrine NN 37231 2172 24 of of IN 37231 2172 25 the the DT 37231 2172 26 same same JJ 37231 2172 27 martyr martyr NN 37231 2172 28 for for IN 37231 2172 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2172 30 daughter daughter NN 37231 2172 31 who who WP 37231 2172 32 was be VBD 37231 2172 33 sick sick JJ 37231 2172 34 and and CC 37231 2172 35 in in IN 37231 2172 36 great great JJ 37231 2172 37 peril peril NN 37231 2172 38 , , , 37231 2172 39 and and CC 37231 2172 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2172 41 had have VBD 37231 2172 42 brought bring VBN 37231 2172 43 her -PRON- PRP 37231 2172 44 dress dress NN 37231 2172 45 with with IN 37231 2172 46 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2172 47 ; ; : 37231 2172 48 when when WRB 37231 2172 49 lo lo NNP 37231 2172 50 ! ! . 37231 2173 1 some some DT 37231 2173 2 of of IN 37231 2173 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2173 4 household household NN 37231 2173 5 came come VBD 37231 2173 6 running run VBG 37231 2173 7 to to TO 37231 2173 8 announce announce VB 37231 2173 9 to to IN 37231 2173 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2173 11 that that IN 37231 2173 12 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2173 13 was be VBD 37231 2173 14 dead dead JJ 37231 2173 15 . . . 37231 2174 1 But but CC 37231 2174 2 as as IN 37231 2174 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2174 4 was be VBD 37231 2174 5 engaged engage VBN 37231 2174 6 in in IN 37231 2174 7 prayer prayer NN 37231 2174 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2174 9 were be VBD 37231 2174 10 stopped stop VBN 37231 2174 11 by by IN 37231 2174 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2174 13 friends friend NNS 37231 2174 14 , , , 37231 2174 15 who who WP 37231 2174 16 prevented prevent VBD 37231 2174 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2174 18 telling tell VBG 37231 2174 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2174 20 , , , 37231 2174 21 lest lest IN 37231 2174 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2174 23 should should MD 37231 2174 24 give give VB 37231 2174 25 way way NN 37231 2174 26 to to IN 37231 2174 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2174 28 grief grief NN 37231 2174 29 in in IN 37231 2174 30 public public NN 37231 2174 31 . . . 37231 2175 1 When when WRB 37231 2175 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2175 3 returned return VBD 37231 2175 4 to to IN 37231 2175 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2175 6 house house NN 37231 2175 7 , , , 37231 2175 8 which which WDT 37231 2175 9 already already RB 37231 2175 10 resounded resound VBD 37231 2175 11 with with IN 37231 2175 12 the the DT 37231 2175 13 wailing wailing NN 37231 2175 14 of of IN 37231 2175 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2175 16 household household NN 37231 2175 17 , , , 37231 2175 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2175 19 cast cast VBD 37231 2175 20 over over IN 37231 2175 21 the the DT 37231 2175 22 body body NN 37231 2175 23 of of IN 37231 2175 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2175 25 daughter daughter NN 37231 2175 26 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2175 27 mantle mantle NN 37231 2175 28 which which WDT 37231 2175 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2175 30 had have VBD 37231 2175 31 with with IN 37231 2175 32 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2175 33 , , , 37231 2175 34 and and CC 37231 2175 35 immediately immediately RB 37231 2175 36 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2175 37 was be VBD 37231 2175 38 restored restore VBN 37231 2175 39 to to IN 37231 2175 40 life life NN 37231 2175 41 . . . 37231 2176 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2176 2 1 1 LS 37231 2176 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2176 4 Again again RB 37231 2176 5 , , , 37231 2176 6 in in IN 37231 2176 7 the the DT 37231 2176 8 same same JJ 37231 2176 9 city city NN 37231 2176 10 , , , 37231 2176 11 the the DT 37231 2176 12 son son NN 37231 2176 13 of of IN 37231 2176 14 a a DT 37231 2176 15 certain certain JJ 37231 2176 16 man man NN 37231 2176 17 among among IN 37231 2176 18 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2176 19 named name VBN 37231 2176 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2176 21 , , , 37231 2176 22 a a DT 37231 2176 23 collector collector NN 37231 2176 24 of of IN 37231 2176 25 taxes taxis NNS 37231 2176 26 , , , 37231 2176 27 became become VBD 37231 2176 28 sick sick JJ 37231 2176 29 and and CC 37231 2176 30 died die VBD 37231 2176 31 . . . 37231 2177 1 As as IN 37231 2177 2 the the DT 37231 2177 3 dead dead JJ 37231 2177 4 body body NN 37231 2177 5 lay lie VBD 37231 2177 6 , , , 37231 2177 7 and and CC 37231 2177 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2177 9 were be VBD 37231 2177 10 preparing prepare VBG 37231 2177 11 with with IN 37231 2177 12 wailing wailing NN 37231 2177 13 and and CC 37231 2177 14 lamentation lamentation NN 37231 2177 15 to to TO 37231 2177 16 bury bury VB 37231 2177 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2177 18 , , , 37231 2177 19 one one CD 37231 2177 20 of of IN 37231 2177 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2177 22 friends friend NNS 37231 2177 23 consoling console VBG 37231 2177 24 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2177 25 suggested suggest VBD 37231 2177 26 that that IN 37231 2177 27 the the DT 37231 2177 28 body body NN 37231 2177 29 should should MD 37231 2177 30 be be VB 37231 2177 31 anointed anoint VBN 37231 2177 32 with with IN 37231 2177 33 oil oil NN 37231 2177 34 from from IN 37231 2177 35 the the DT 37231 2177 36 same same JJ 37231 2177 37 martyr martyr NN 37231 2177 38 . . . 37231 2178 1 This this DT 37231 2178 2 was be VBD 37231 2178 3 done do VBN 37231 2178 4 , , , 37231 2178 5 and and CC 37231 2178 6 the the DT 37231 2178 7 child child NN 37231 2178 8 came come VBD 37231 2178 9 to to IN 37231 2178 10 life life NN 37231 2178 11 again again RB 37231 2178 12 . . . 37231 2179 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2179 2 2 2 LS 37231 2179 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2179 4 In in IN 37231 2179 5 the the DT 37231 2179 6 same same JJ 37231 2179 7 way way NN 37231 2179 8 a a DT 37231 2179 9 man man NN 37231 2179 10 amongst amongst IN 37231 2179 11 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2179 12 named name VBN 37231 2179 13 Eleusinus Eleusinus NNP 37231 2179 14 , , , 37231 2179 15 formerly formerly RB 37231 2179 16 a a DT 37231 2179 17 tribune tribune NN 37231 2179 18 , , , 37231 2179 19 laid lay VBD 37231 2179 20 the the DT 37231 2179 21 body body NN 37231 2179 22 of of IN 37231 2179 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2179 24 child child NN 37231 2179 25 , , , 37231 2179 26 who who WP 37231 2179 27 had have VBD 37231 2179 28 died die VBN 37231 2179 29 from from IN 37231 2179 30 sickness sickness NN 37231 2179 31 , , , 37231 2179 32 on on IN 37231 2179 33 a a DT 37231 2179 34 memorial memorial NN 37231 2179 35 of of IN 37231 2179 36 the the DT 37231 2179 37 martyr martyr NN 37231 2179 38 which which WDT 37231 2179 39 is be VBZ 37231 2179 40 in in IN 37231 2179 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2179 42 villa villa NN 37231 2179 43 in in IN 37231 2179 44 the the DT 37231 2179 45 suburbs suburb NNS 37231 2179 46 , , , 37231 2179 47 and and CC 37231 2179 48 after after IN 37231 2179 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2179 50 had have VBD 37231 2179 51 prayed pray VBN 37231 2179 52 , , , 37231 2179 53 with with IN 37231 2179 54 many many JJ 37231 2179 55 tears tear NNS 37231 2179 56 , , , 37231 2179 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2179 58 took take VBD 37231 2179 59 up up RP 37231 2179 60 the the DT 37231 2179 61 child child NN 37231 2179 62 living live VBG 37231 2179 63 . . . 37231 2180 1 " " `` 37231 2180 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2180 3 3 3 LS 37231 2180 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2180 5 { { -LRB- 37231 2180 6 175 175 CD 37231 2180 7 } } -RRB- 37231 2180 8 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2180 9 shall shall MD 37231 2180 10 meet meet VB 37231 2180 11 with with IN 37231 2180 12 more more JJR 37231 2180 13 of of IN 37231 2180 14 these these DT 37231 2180 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2180 16 in in IN 37231 2180 17 considering consider VBG 37231 2180 18 the the DT 37231 2180 19 arguments argument NNS 37231 2180 20 of of IN 37231 2180 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2180 22 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2180 23 . . . 37231 2181 1 In in IN 37231 2181 2 a a DT 37231 2181 3 note note NN 37231 2181 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2181 5 says say VBZ 37231 2181 6 : : : 37231 2181 7 " " `` 37231 2181 8 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2181 9 again again RB 37231 2181 10 , , , 37231 2181 11 long long RB 37231 2181 12 after after RB 37231 2181 13 , , , 37231 2181 14 alludes allude NNS 37231 2181 15 in in IN 37231 2181 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2181 17 list list NN 37231 2181 18 of of IN 37231 2181 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2181 20 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2181 21 De De NNP 37231 2181 22 Civ Civ NNP 37231 2181 23 . . . 37231 2182 1 Dei Dei NNP 37231 2182 2 , , , 37231 2182 3 xxii xxii NNP 37231 2182 4 . . . 37231 2183 1 8 8 CD 37231 2183 2 , , , 37231 2183 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2183 4 to to IN 37231 2183 5 some some DT 37231 2183 6 cases case NNS 37231 2183 7 in in IN 37231 2183 8 which which WDT 37231 2183 9 persons person NNS 37231 2183 10 had have VBD 37231 2183 11 been be VBN 37231 2183 12 raised raise VBN 37231 2183 13 to to IN 37231 2183 14 life life NN 37231 2183 15 again again RB 37231 2183 16 by by IN 37231 2183 17 prayer prayer NN 37231 2183 18 and and CC 37231 2183 19 the the DT 37231 2183 20 intercession intercession NN 37231 2183 21 of of IN 37231 2183 22 martyrs martyr NNS 37231 2183 23 , , , 37231 2183 24 whose whose WP$ 37231 2183 25 relics relic NNS 37231 2183 26 were be VBD 37231 2183 27 applied apply VBN 37231 2183 28 . . . 37231 2184 1 But but CC 37231 2184 2 though though IN 37231 2184 3 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2184 4 relates relate VBZ 37231 2184 5 with with IN 37231 2184 6 great great JJ 37231 2184 7 particularity particularity NN 37231 2184 8 and and CC 37231 2184 9 length length NN 37231 2184 10 of of IN 37231 2184 11 detail detail NN 37231 2184 12 some some DT 37231 2184 13 cases case NNS 37231 2184 14 of of IN 37231 2184 15 recoveries recovery NNS 37231 2184 16 from from IN 37231 2184 17 complaints complaint NNS 37231 2184 18 in in IN 37231 2184 19 answer answer NN 37231 2184 20 to to IN 37231 2184 21 prayer prayer NN 37231 2184 22 , , , 37231 2184 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2184 24 notices notice NNS 37231 2184 25 of of IN 37231 2184 26 the the DT 37231 2184 27 cases case NNS 37231 2184 28 in in IN 37231 2184 29 which which WDT 37231 2184 30 persons person NNS 37231 2184 31 had have VBD 37231 2184 32 been be VBN 37231 2184 33 raised raise VBN 37231 2184 34 to to IN 37231 2184 35 life life NN 37231 2184 36 again again RB 37231 2184 37 , , , 37231 2184 38 are be VBP 37231 2184 39 so so RB 37231 2184 40 short short JJ 37231 2184 41 , , , 37231 2184 42 bare bare JJ 37231 2184 43 , , , 37231 2184 44 and and CC 37231 2184 45 summary summary NN 37231 2184 46 , , , 37231 2184 47 that that IN 37231 2184 48 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2184 49 evidently evidently RB 37231 2184 50 represent represent VBP 37231 2184 51 no no DT 37231 2184 52 more more JJR 37231 2184 53 than than IN 37231 2184 54 mere mere JJ 37231 2184 55 report report NN 37231 2184 56 , , , 37231 2184 57 and and CC 37231 2184 58 report report NN 37231 2184 59 of of IN 37231 2184 60 a a DT 37231 2184 61 very very RB 37231 2184 62 vague vague JJ 37231 2184 63 kind kind NN 37231 2184 64 . . . 37231 2185 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 2185 2 , , , 37231 2185 3 with with IN 37231 2185 4 the the DT 37231 2185 5 preface preface NN 37231 2185 6 which which WDT 37231 2185 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2185 8 prefixes prefix VBZ 37231 2185 9 to to IN 37231 2185 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2185 11 list list NN 37231 2185 12 , , , 37231 2185 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2185 14 can can MD 37231 2185 15 not not RB 37231 2185 16 be be VB 37231 2185 17 said say VBN 37231 2185 18 even even RB 37231 2185 19 to to IN 37231 2185 20 profess profess VB 37231 2185 21 to to TO 37231 2185 22 guarantee guarantee VB 37231 2185 23 the the DT 37231 2185 24 truth truth NN 37231 2185 25 or or CC 37231 2185 26 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2185 27 of of IN 37231 2185 28 the the DT 37231 2185 29 different different JJ 37231 2185 30 instances instance NNS 37231 2185 31 contained contain VBN 37231 2185 32 in in IN 37231 2185 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2185 34 . . . 37231 2186 1 ' ' `` 37231 2186 2 Hæc Hæc NNP 37231 2186 3 autem autem NN 37231 2186 4 , , , 37231 2186 5 ubicunque ubicunque NNP 37231 2186 6 fiunt fiunt NNP 37231 2186 7 , , , 37231 2186 8 ibi ibi NNP 37231 2186 9 sciuntur sciuntur NNP 37231 2186 10 vix vix NN 37231 2186 11 a a DT 37231 2186 12 tota tota NNP 37231 2186 13 ipsa ipsa NNP 37231 2186 14 civitate civitate NNP 37231 2186 15 vel vel NNP 37231 2186 16 quocumque quocumque NNP 37231 2186 17 commanentium commanentium NN 37231 2186 18 loco loco NNP 37231 2186 19 . . . 37231 2187 1 Nam Nam NNP 37231 2187 2 plerumque plerumque NNP 37231 2187 3 etiam etiam NNP 37231 2187 4 ibi ibi NNP 37231 2187 5 paucissimi paucissimi NNP 37231 2187 6 sciunt sciunt NNP 37231 2187 7 , , , 37231 2187 8 ignorantibus ignorantibus NNP 37231 2187 9 eseteris eseteris NNP 37231 2187 10 , , , 37231 2187 11 maxime maxime NNP 37231 2187 12 si si NN 37231 2187 13 magna magna NNS 37231 2187 14 sit sit VBP 37231 2187 15 civitas civita NNS 37231 2187 16 ; ; : 37231 2187 17 et et NNP 37231 2187 18 quando quando NNP 37231 2187 19 alibi alibi NNP 37231 2187 20 aliisque aliisque NNP 37231 2187 21 narrantur narrantur NNP 37231 2187 22 , , , 37231 2187 23 non non AFX 37231 2187 24 tantum tantum JJ 37231 2187 25 ea ea NNP 37231 2187 26 commendat commendat NNP 37231 2187 27 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 37231 2187 28 , , , 37231 2187 29 ut ut UH 37231 2187 30 sine sine NNP 37231 2187 31 difficultate difficultate NNP 37231 2187 32 vel vel NNP 37231 2187 33 dubitatione dubitatione NNP 37231 2187 34 credantur credantur NNP 37231 2187 35 , , , 37231 2187 36 quamvis quamvis FW 37231 2187 37 Christianis Christianis NNP 37231 2187 38 fidelibus fidelibus NN 37231 2187 39 a a DT 37231 2187 40 fidelibus fidelibus JJ 37231 2187 41 indicentur indicentur NN 37231 2187 42 . . . 37231 2187 43 ' ' '' 37231 2188 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2188 2 puts put VBZ 37231 2188 3 down down RP 37231 2188 4 the the DT 37231 2188 5 cases case NNS 37231 2188 6 as as IN 37231 2188 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2188 8 received receive VBD 37231 2188 9 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2188 10 , , , 37231 2188 11 then then RB 37231 2188 12 , , , 37231 2188 13 without without IN 37231 2188 14 pledging pledge VBG 37231 2188 15 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2188 16 to to IN 37231 2188 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2188 18 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2188 19 . . . 37231 2189 1 ' ' `` 37231 2189 2 Eucharius Eucharius NNP 37231 2189 3 presbyter presbyter NN 37231 2189 4 ... ... : 37231 2189 5 mortuus mortuus NNP 37231 2189 6 sic sic NNP 37231 2189 7 jacebat jacebat NNP 37231 2189 8 ut ut UH 37231 2189 9 ei ei NNP 37231 2189 10 jam jam NNP 37231 2189 11 pol pol NNP 37231 2189 12 - - HYPH 37231 2189 13 lices lices NNP 37231 2189 14 ligarentur ligarentur NN 37231 2189 15 : : : 37231 2189 16 opitulatione opitulatione NN 37231 2189 17 memorati memorati NNP 37231 2189 18 martyris martyris NNP 37231 2189 19 , , , 37231 2189 20 cum cum NNP 37231 2189 21 de de NNP 37231 2189 22 memoria memoria NNP 37231 2189 23 ejus ejus NNP 37231 2189 24 reportata reportata NNP 37231 2189 25 fuisset fuisset NNP 37231 2189 26 et et NNP 37231 2189 27 supra supra NNP 37231 2189 28 jacentis jacentis NNP 37231 2189 29 corpus corpus NNP 37231 2189 30 missa missa NNP 37231 2189 31 ipsius ipsius NNP 37231 2189 32 presbyteri presbyteri NNP 37231 2189 33 tunica tunica NNP 37231 2189 34 , , , 37231 2189 35 suscitatus suscitatus NNP 37231 2189 36 est est NNP 37231 2189 37 ... ... : 37231 2189 38 Andurus Andurus NNP 37231 2189 39 nomen noman NNS 37231 2189 40 est est NNP 37231 2189 41 & & CC 37231 2189 42 C.",(1 C.",(1 NNP 37231 2189 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2189 44 and and CC 37231 2189 45 then then RB 37231 2189 46 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2189 47 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2189 48 gives give VBZ 37231 2189 49 the the DT 37231 2189 50 passage passage NN 37231 2189 51 already already RB 37231 2189 52 quoted quote VBN 37231 2189 53 by by IN 37231 2189 54 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2189 55 . . . 37231 2190 1 Before before IN 37231 2190 2 continuing continue VBG 37231 2190 3 , , , 37231 2190 4 { { -LRB- 37231 2190 5 176 176 CD 37231 2190 6 } } -RRB- 37231 2190 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2190 8 must must MD 37231 2190 9 remark remark VB 37231 2190 10 with with IN 37231 2190 11 regard regard NN 37231 2190 12 to to IN 37231 2190 13 the the DT 37231 2190 14 passages passage NNS 37231 2190 15 just just RB 37231 2190 16 quoted quote VBN 37231 2190 17 , , , 37231 2190 18 that that IN 37231 2190 19 , , , 37231 2190 20 in in IN 37231 2190 21 the the DT 37231 2190 22 miracle miracle NN 37231 2190 23 of of IN 37231 2190 24 Eucharius Eucharius NNP 37231 2190 25 , , , 37231 2190 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2190 27 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2190 28 , , , 37231 2190 29 without without IN 37231 2190 30 explanation explanation NN 37231 2190 31 , , , 37231 2190 32 omits omit VBZ 37231 2190 33 details detail NNS 37231 2190 34 . . . 37231 2191 1 The the DT 37231 2191 2 whole whole JJ 37231 2191 3 passage passage NN 37231 2191 4 is be VBZ 37231 2191 5 as as IN 37231 2191 6 follows follow VBZ 37231 2191 7 : : : 37231 2191 8 " " `` 37231 2191 9 Eucharius Eucharius NNP 37231 2191 10 , , , 37231 2191 11 a a DT 37231 2191 12 presbyter presbyter NN 37231 2191 13 from from IN 37231 2191 14 Spain Spain NNP 37231 2191 15 , , , 37231 2191 16 resided reside VBD 37231 2191 17 at at IN 37231 2191 18 Calama Calama NNP 37231 2191 19 , , , 37231 2191 20 who who WP 37231 2191 21 had have VBD 37231 2191 22 for for IN 37231 2191 23 a a DT 37231 2191 24 long long JJ 37231 2191 25 time time NN 37231 2191 26 suffered suffer VBN 37231 2191 27 from from IN 37231 2191 28 stone stone NN 37231 2191 29 . . . 37231 2192 1 By by IN 37231 2192 2 the the DT 37231 2192 3 relics relic NNS 37231 2192 4 of of IN 37231 2192 5 the the DT 37231 2192 6 same same JJ 37231 2192 7 martyr martyr NN 37231 2192 8 , , , 37231 2192 9 which which WDT 37231 2192 10 the the DT 37231 2192 11 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2192 12 Possidius Possidius NNP 37231 2192 13 brought bring VBD 37231 2192 14 to to IN 37231 2192 15 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2192 16 , , , 37231 2192 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2192 18 was be VBD 37231 2192 19 made make VBN 37231 2192 20 whole whole JJ 37231 2192 21 . . . 37231 2193 1 The the DT 37231 2193 2 same same JJ 37231 2193 3 presbyter presbyter NN 37231 2193 4 , , , 37231 2193 5 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 2193 6 succumbing succumb VBG 37231 2193 7 to to IN 37231 2193 8 another another DT 37231 2193 9 disease disease NN 37231 2193 10 , , , 37231 2193 11 lay lie VBD 37231 2193 12 dead dead JJ 37231 2193 13 , , , 37231 2193 14 so so IN 37231 2193 15 that that IN 37231 2193 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2193 17 were be VBD 37231 2193 18 already already RB 37231 2193 19 binding bind VBG 37231 2193 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2193 21 hands hand NNS 37231 2193 22 . . . 37231 2194 1 Succour succour NN 37231 2194 2 came come VBD 37231 2194 3 from from IN 37231 2194 4 the the DT 37231 2194 5 relics relic NNS 37231 2194 6 of of IN 37231 2194 7 the the DT 37231 2194 8 martyr martyr NN 37231 2194 9 , , , 37231 2194 10 for for IN 37231 2194 11 the the DT 37231 2194 12 tunic tunic NN 37231 2194 13 of of IN 37231 2194 14 the the DT 37231 2194 15 presbyter presbyter NN 37231 2194 16 being be VBG 37231 2194 17 brought bring VBN 37231 2194 18 back back RB 37231 2194 19 from from IN 37231 2194 20 the the DT 37231 2194 21 relics relic NNS 37231 2194 22 and and CC 37231 2194 23 placed place VBN 37231 2194 24 upon upon IN 37231 2194 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2194 26 body body NN 37231 2194 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2194 28 revived revive VBD 37231 2194 29 . . . 37231 2195 1 " " `` 37231 2195 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2195 3 1 1 LS 37231 2195 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2195 5 A a DT 37231 2195 6 writer writer NN 37231 2195 7 who who WP 37231 2195 8 complains complain VBZ 37231 2195 9 of of IN 37231 2195 10 the the DT 37231 2195 11 bareness bareness NN 37231 2195 12 of of IN 37231 2195 13 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2195 14 , , , 37231 2195 15 should should MD 37231 2195 16 certainly certainly RB 37231 2195 17 not not RB 37231 2195 18 curtail curtail VB 37231 2195 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2195 20 statements statement NNS 37231 2195 21 . . . 37231 2196 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2196 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2196 3 continues continue VBZ 37231 2196 4 : : : 37231 2196 5 " " `` 37231 2196 6 There there EX 37231 2196 7 are be VBP 37231 2196 8 three three CD 37231 2196 9 other other JJ 37231 2196 10 cases case NNS 37231 2196 11 of of IN 37231 2196 12 the the DT 37231 2196 13 same same JJ 37231 2196 14 kind kind NN 37231 2196 15 , , , 37231 2196 16 in in IN 37231 2196 17 which which WDT 37231 2196 18 there there EX 37231 2196 19 is be VBZ 37231 2196 20 nothing nothing NN 37231 2196 21 to to TO 37231 2196 22 verify verify VB 37231 2196 23 the the DT 37231 2196 24 death death NN 37231 2196 25 from from IN 37231 2196 26 which which WDT 37231 2196 27 the the DT 37231 2196 28 return return NN 37231 2196 29 to to IN 37231 2196 30 life life NN 37231 2196 31 is be VBZ 37231 2196 32 said say VBN 37231 2196 33 to to TO 37231 2196 34 take take VB 37231 2196 35 place place NN 37231 2196 36 , , , 37231 2196 37 as as IN 37231 2196 38 being be VBG 37231 2196 39 more more JJR 37231 2196 40 than than IN 37231 2196 41 mere mere JJ 37231 2196 42 suspension suspension NN 37231 2196 43 of of IN 37231 2196 44 the the DT 37231 2196 45 vital vital JJ 37231 2196 46 powers power NNS 37231 2196 47 ; ; : 37231 2196 48 but but CC 37231 2196 49 the the DT 37231 2196 50 writer writer NN 37231 2196 51 does do VBZ 37231 2196 52 not not RB 37231 2196 53 go go VB 37231 2196 54 into into IN 37231 2196 55 particulars particular NNS 37231 2196 56 of of IN 37231 2196 57 description description NN 37231 2196 58 or or CC 37231 2196 59 proof proof NN 37231 2196 60 , , , 37231 2196 61 but but CC 37231 2196 62 simply simply RB 37231 2196 63 inserts insert VBZ 37231 2196 64 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2196 65 in in IN 37231 2196 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2196 67 list list NN 37231 2196 68 as as IN 37231 2196 69 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2196 70 have have VBP 37231 2196 71 been be VBN 37231 2196 72 reported report VBN 37231 2196 73 to to IN 37231 2196 74 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2196 75 . . . 37231 2197 1 " " `` 37231 2197 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2197 3 3 3 LS 37231 2197 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2197 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2197 6 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2197 7 is be VBZ 37231 2197 8 anxious anxious JJ 37231 2197 9 to to TO 37231 2197 10 detract detract VB 37231 2197 11 from from IN 37231 2197 12 the the DT 37231 2197 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2197 14 described describe VBN 37231 2197 15 by by IN 37231 2197 16 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2197 17 , , , 37231 2197 18 and and CC 37231 2197 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2197 20 regret regret VBP 37231 2197 21 to to TO 37231 2197 22 be be VB 37231 2197 23 obliged oblige VBN 37231 2197 24 to to TO 37231 2197 25 maintain maintain VB 37231 2197 26 that that DT 37231 2197 27 in in IN 37231 2197 28 order order NN 37231 2197 29 to to TO 37231 2197 30 do do VB 37231 2197 31 so so RB 37231 2197 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2197 33 misrepresents misrepresent VBZ 37231 2197 34 , , , 37231 2197 35 no no RB 37231 2197 36 doubt doubt RB 37231 2197 37 unintentionally unintentionally RB 37231 2197 38 , , , 37231 2197 39 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2197 40 's 's POS 37231 2197 41 statements statement NNS 37231 2197 42 , , , 37231 2197 43 and and CC 37231 2197 44 , , , 37231 2197 45 as as IN 37231 2197 46 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2197 47 think think VBP 37231 2197 48 , , , 37231 2197 49 also also RB 37231 2197 50 unduly unduly RB 37231 2197 51 depreciates depreciate VBZ 37231 2197 52 the the DT 37231 2197 53 comparative comparative JJ 37231 2197 54 value value NN 37231 2197 55 of of IN 37231 2197 56 the the DT 37231 2197 57 evidence evidence NN 37231 2197 58 . . . 37231 2198 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2198 2 shall shall MD 37231 2198 3 briefly briefly RB 37231 2198 4 refer refer VB 37231 2198 5 to to IN 37231 2198 6 the the DT 37231 2198 7 two two CD 37231 2198 8 points point NNS 37231 2198 9 in in IN 37231 2198 10 question question NN 37231 2198 11 . . . 37231 2199 1 I. I. NNP 37231 2200 1 That that IN 37231 2200 2 " " `` 37231 2200 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2200 4 notices notice NNS 37231 2200 5 of of IN 37231 2200 6 the the DT 37231 2200 7 cases case NNS 37231 2200 8 in in IN 37231 2200 9 which which WDT 37231 2200 10 persons person NNS 37231 2200 11 had have VBD 37231 2200 12 been be VBN 37231 2200 13 raised raise VBN 37231 2200 14 to to IN 37231 2200 15 life life NN 37231 2200 16 again again RB 37231 2200 17 are be VBP 37231 2200 18 so so RB 37231 2200 19 short short JJ 37231 2200 20 , , , 37231 2200 21 { { -LRB- 37231 2200 22 177 177 CD 37231 2200 23 } } -RRB- 37231 2200 24 bare bare JJ 37231 2200 25 , , , 37231 2200 26 and and CC 37231 2200 27 summary summary NN 37231 2200 28 that that IN 37231 2200 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2200 30 evidently evidently RB 37231 2200 31 represent represent VBP 37231 2200 32 no no DT 37231 2200 33 more more JJR 37231 2200 34 than than IN 37231 2200 35 mere mere JJ 37231 2200 36 report report NN 37231 2200 37 , , , 37231 2200 38 and and CC 37231 2200 39 report report NN 37231 2200 40 of of IN 37231 2200 41 a a DT 37231 2200 42 very very RB 37231 2200 43 vague vague JJ 37231 2200 44 kind kind NN 37231 2200 45 . . . 37231 2200 46 " " '' 37231 2201 1 II ii CD 37231 2201 2 . . . 37231 2202 1 " " `` 37231 2202 2 That that IN 37231 2202 3 with with IN 37231 2202 4 the the DT 37231 2202 5 preface preface NN 37231 2202 6 which which WDT 37231 2202 7 Augustine augustine JJ 37231 2202 8 prefixes prefix NNS 37231 2202 9 to to IN 37231 2202 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2202 11 list list NN 37231 2202 12 , , , 37231 2202 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2202 14 can can MD 37231 2202 15 not not RB 37231 2202 16 be be VB 37231 2202 17 said say VBN 37231 2202 18 even even RB 37231 2202 19 to to IN 37231 2202 20 profess profess VB 37231 2202 21 to to TO 37231 2202 22 guarantee guarantee VB 37231 2202 23 the the DT 37231 2202 24 truth truth NN 37231 2202 25 or or CC 37231 2202 26 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2202 27 of of IN 37231 2202 28 the the DT 37231 2202 29 different different JJ 37231 2202 30 instances instance NNS 37231 2202 31 contained contain VBN 37231 2202 32 in in IN 37231 2202 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2202 34 . . . 37231 2202 35 " " '' 37231 2203 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2203 2 is be VBZ 37231 2203 3 true true JJ 37231 2203 4 that that IN 37231 2203 5 in in IN 37231 2203 6 several several JJ 37231 2203 7 cases case NNS 37231 2203 8 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2203 9 gives give VBZ 37231 2203 10 the the DT 37231 2203 11 account account NN 37231 2203 12 of of IN 37231 2203 13 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2203 14 cures cure NNS 37231 2203 15 at at IN 37231 2203 16 greater great JJR 37231 2203 17 length length NN 37231 2203 18 than than IN 37231 2203 19 those those DT 37231 2203 20 of of IN 37231 2203 21 restoration restoration NN 37231 2203 22 to to IN 37231 2203 23 life life NN 37231 2203 24 . . . 37231 2204 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2204 2 seems seem VBZ 37231 2204 3 to to IN 37231 2204 4 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2204 5 that that IN 37231 2204 6 this this DT 37231 2204 7 is be VBZ 37231 2204 8 almost almost RB 37231 2204 9 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 2204 10 at at IN 37231 2204 11 all all DT 37231 2204 12 times time NNS 37231 2204 13 , , , 37231 2204 14 and and CC 37231 2204 15 that that IN 37231 2204 16 the the DT 37231 2204 17 reason reason NN 37231 2204 18 is be VBZ 37231 2204 19 obvious obvious JJ 37231 2204 20 . . . 37231 2205 1 Where where WRB 37231 2205 2 the the DT 37231 2205 3 miracle miracle NN 37231 2205 4 consists consist VBZ 37231 2205 5 merely merely RB 37231 2205 6 of of IN 37231 2205 7 the the DT 37231 2205 8 cure cure NN 37231 2205 9 of of IN 37231 2205 10 disease disease NN 37231 2205 11 , , , 37231 2205 12 details detail NNS 37231 2205 13 are be VBP 37231 2205 14 naturally naturally RB 37231 2205 15 given give VBN 37231 2205 16 to to TO 37231 2205 17 show show VB 37231 2205 18 the the DT 37231 2205 19 nature nature NN 37231 2205 20 and and CC 37231 2205 21 intensity intensity NN 37231 2205 22 of of IN 37231 2205 23 the the DT 37231 2205 24 sickness sickness NN 37231 2205 25 , , , 37231 2205 26 and and CC 37231 2205 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2205 28 are be VBP 37231 2205 29 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2205 30 not not RB 37231 2205 31 only only RB 37231 2205 32 for for IN 37231 2205 33 the the DT 37231 2205 34 comprehension comprehension NN 37231 2205 35 of of IN 37231 2205 36 the the DT 37231 2205 37 cure cure NN 37231 2205 38 but but CC 37231 2205 39 to to TO 37231 2205 40 show show VB 37231 2205 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2205 42 importance importance NN 37231 2205 43 . . . 37231 2206 1 In in IN 37231 2206 2 the the DT 37231 2206 3 case case NN 37231 2206 4 of of IN 37231 2206 5 restoration restoration NN 37231 2206 6 to to IN 37231 2206 7 life life NN 37231 2206 8 , , , 37231 2206 9 the the DT 37231 2206 10 mere mere JJ 37231 2206 11 statement statement NN 37231 2206 12 of of IN 37231 2206 13 the the DT 37231 2206 14 death death NN 37231 2206 15 and and CC 37231 2206 16 assertion assertion NN 37231 2206 17 of of IN 37231 2206 18 the the DT 37231 2206 19 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 2206 20 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 2206 21 exclude exclude VBP 37231 2206 22 all all DT 37231 2206 23 need need NN 37231 2206 24 of of IN 37231 2206 25 details detail NNS 37231 2206 26 . . . 37231 2207 1 The the DT 37231 2207 2 pithy pithy NN 37231 2207 3 _ _ NNP 37231 2207 4 reddita reddita NNP 37231 2207 5 est est NNP 37231 2207 6 vitæ vitæ NNP 37231 2207 7 _ _ NNP 37231 2207 8 , , , 37231 2207 9 or or CC 37231 2207 10 _ _ NNP 37231 2207 11 factum factum NN 37231 2207 12 est est NNP 37231 2207 13 et et NNP 37231 2207 14 revixit revixit NNP 37231 2207 15 _ _ NNP 37231 2207 16 is be VBZ 37231 2207 17 more more RBR 37231 2207 18 striking striking JJ 37231 2207 19 than than IN 37231 2207 20 any any DT 37231 2207 21 more more RBR 37231 2207 22 prolix prolix JJ 37231 2207 23 narrative narrative NN 37231 2207 24 . . . 37231 2208 1 In in IN 37231 2208 2 fact fact NN 37231 2208 3 , , , 37231 2208 4 the the DT 37231 2208 5 greater great JJR 37231 2208 6 the the DT 37231 2208 7 miracle miracle NN 37231 2208 8 the the DT 37231 2208 9 more more RBR 37231 2208 10 natural natural JJ 37231 2208 11 is be VBZ 37231 2208 12 conciseness conciseness NN 37231 2208 13 and and CC 37231 2208 14 simplicity simplicity NN 37231 2208 15 ; ; : 37231 2208 16 and and CC 37231 2208 17 practically practically RB 37231 2208 18 , , , 37231 2208 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2208 20 find find VBP 37231 2208 21 that that IN 37231 2208 22 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2208 23 gives give VBZ 37231 2208 24 a a DT 37231 2208 25 more more RBR 37231 2208 26 lengthy lengthy JJ 37231 2208 27 and and CC 37231 2208 28 verbose verbose VBP 37231 2208 29 report report NN 37231 2208 30 of of IN 37231 2208 31 trifling trifle VBG 37231 2208 32 cures cure NNS 37231 2208 33 , , , 37231 2208 34 whilst whilst IN 37231 2208 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2208 36 relates relate VBZ 37231 2208 37 the the DT 37231 2208 38 more more RBR 37231 2208 39 important important JJ 37231 2208 40 with with IN 37231 2208 41 greater great JJR 37231 2208 42 brevity brevity NN 37231 2208 43 and and CC 37231 2208 44 force force NN 37231 2208 45 . . . 37231 2209 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2209 2 narrates narrate VBZ 37231 2209 3 many many JJ 37231 2209 4 of of IN 37231 2209 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2209 6 cases case NNS 37231 2209 7 of of IN 37231 2209 8 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2209 9 cure cure NN 37231 2209 10 , , , 37231 2209 11 however however RB 37231 2209 12 , , , 37231 2209 13 as as RB 37231 2209 14 briefly briefly RB 37231 2209 15 as as IN 37231 2209 16 those those DT 37231 2209 17 in in IN 37231 2209 18 which which WDT 37231 2209 19 the the DT 37231 2209 20 dead dead NNS 37231 2209 21 are be VBP 37231 2209 22 raised raise VBN 37231 2209 23 . . . 37231 2210 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2210 2 have have VBP 37231 2210 3 quoted quote VBN 37231 2210 4 the the DT 37231 2210 5 latter latter JJ 37231 2210 6 , , , 37231 2210 7 and and CC 37231 2210 8 the the DT 37231 2210 9 reader reader NN 37231 2210 10 must must MD 37231 2210 11 judge judge VB 37231 2210 12 whether whether IN 37231 2210 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2210 14 are be VBP 37231 2210 15 unduly unduly RB 37231 2210 16 curt curt JJ 37231 2210 17 . . . 37231 2211 1 One one CD 37231 2211 2 thing thing NN 37231 2211 3 may may MD 37231 2211 4 be be VB 37231 2211 5 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 2211 6 , , , 37231 2211 7 that that IN 37231 2211 8 nothing nothing NN 37231 2211 9 of of IN 37231 2211 10 importance importance NN 37231 2211 11 is be VBZ 37231 2211 12 omitted omit VBN 37231 2211 13 , , , 37231 2211 14 and and CC 37231 2211 15 in in IN 37231 2211 16 regard regard NN 37231 2211 17 to to IN 37231 2211 18 essential essential JJ 37231 2211 19 details detail NNS 37231 2211 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2211 21 are be VBP 37231 2211 22 as as RB 37231 2211 23 explicit explicit JJ 37231 2211 24 as as IN 37231 2211 25 the the DT 37231 2211 26 mass mass NN 37231 2211 27 of of IN 37231 2211 28 other other JJ 37231 2211 29 cases case NNS 37231 2211 30 reported report VBN 37231 2211 31 . . . 37231 2212 1 In in IN 37231 2212 2 every every DT 37231 2212 3 instance instance NN 37231 2212 4 names name NNS 37231 2212 5 and and CC 37231 2212 6 addresses address NNS 37231 2212 7 are be VBP 37231 2212 8 stated state VBN 37231 2212 9 , , , 37231 2212 10 and and CC 37231 2212 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2212 12 will will MD 37231 2212 13 have have VB 37231 2212 14 been be VBN 37231 2212 15 observed observe VBN 37231 2212 16 that that IN 37231 2212 17 all all PDT 37231 2212 18 these these DT 37231 2212 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2212 20 occurred occur VBD 37231 2212 21 in in RB 37231 2212 22 , , , 37231 2212 23 or or CC 37231 2212 24 close close RB 37231 2212 25 to to IN 37231 2212 26 , , , 37231 2212 27 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2212 28 , , , 37231 2212 29 and and CC 37231 2212 30 in in IN 37231 2212 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2212 32 own own JJ 37231 2212 33 diocese diocese NN 37231 2212 34 . . . 37231 2213 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2213 2 is be VBZ 37231 2213 3 very very RB 37231 2213 4 certain certain JJ 37231 2213 5 that that IN 37231 2213 6 in in IN 37231 2213 7 { { -LRB- 37231 2213 8 178 178 CD 37231 2213 9 } } -RRB- 37231 2213 10 every every DT 37231 2213 11 case case NN 37231 2213 12 the the DT 37231 2213 13 fact fact NN 37231 2213 14 of of IN 37231 2213 15 the the DT 37231 2213 16 miracle miracle NN 37231 2213 17 is be VBZ 37231 2213 18 asserted assert VBN 37231 2213 19 in in IN 37231 2213 20 the the DT 37231 2213 21 most most RBS 37231 2213 22 direct direct JJ 37231 2213 23 and and CC 37231 2213 24 positive positive JJ 37231 2213 25 terms term NNS 37231 2213 26 . . . 37231 2214 1 There there EX 37231 2214 2 can can MD 37231 2214 3 be be VB 37231 2214 4 no no DT 37231 2214 5 mistake mistake NN 37231 2214 6 either either CC 37231 2214 7 as as IN 37231 2214 8 to to IN 37231 2214 9 the the DT 37231 2214 10 meaning meaning NN 37231 2214 11 or or CC 37231 2214 12 intention intention NN 37231 2214 13 of of IN 37231 2214 14 the the DT 37231 2214 15 narrative narrative NN 37231 2214 16 , , , 37231 2214 17 and and CC 37231 2214 18 there there EX 37231 2214 19 is be VBZ 37231 2214 20 no no DT 37231 2214 21 symptom symptom NN 37231 2214 22 whatever whatever WDT 37231 2214 23 of of IN 37231 2214 24 a a DT 37231 2214 25 thought thought NN 37231 2214 26 on on IN 37231 2214 27 the the DT 37231 2214 28 part part NN 37231 2214 29 of of IN 37231 2214 30 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2214 31 to to TO 37231 2214 32 avoid avoid VB 37231 2214 33 the the DT 37231 2214 34 responsibility responsibility NN 37231 2214 35 of of IN 37231 2214 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2214 37 statements statement NNS 37231 2214 38 , , , 37231 2214 39 or or CC 37231 2214 40 to to TO 37231 2214 41 give give VB 37231 2214 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2214 43 as as IN 37231 2214 44 mere mere JJ 37231 2214 45 vague vague JJ 37231 2214 46 report report NN 37231 2214 47 . . . 37231 2215 1 If if IN 37231 2215 2 wo wo MD 37231 2215 3 compare compare VB 37231 2215 4 these these DT 37231 2215 5 accounts account NNS 37231 2215 6 with with IN 37231 2215 7 those those DT 37231 2215 8 of of IN 37231 2215 9 the the DT 37231 2215 10 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2215 11 , , , 37231 2215 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2215 13 do do VBP 37231 2215 14 not not RB 37231 2215 15 find find VB 37231 2215 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2215 17 deficient deficient JJ 37231 2215 18 in in IN 37231 2215 19 any any DT 37231 2215 20 essential essential JJ 37231 2215 21 detail detail NN 37231 2215 22 common common JJ 37231 2215 23 to to IN 37231 2215 24 the the DT 37231 2215 25 latter latter JJ 37231 2215 26 . . . 37231 2216 1 There there EX 37231 2216 2 is be VBZ 37231 2216 3 in in IN 37231 2216 4 the the DT 37231 2216 5 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2216 6 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 2216 7 only only RB 37231 2216 8 one one CD 37231 2216 9 case case NN 37231 2216 10 in in IN 37231 2216 11 which which WDT 37231 2216 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2216 13 is be VBZ 37231 2216 14 said say VBN 37231 2216 15 to to TO 37231 2216 16 have have VB 37231 2216 17 raised raise VBN 37231 2216 18 the the DT 37231 2216 19 dead dead NN 37231 2216 20 . . . 37231 2217 1 The the DT 37231 2217 2 raising raising NN 37231 2217 3 of of IN 37231 2217 4 Jairus Jairus NNP 37231 2217 5 ' ' POS 37231 2217 6 daughter(1 daughter(1 NN 37231 2217 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2217 8 has have VBZ 37231 2217 9 long long RB 37231 2217 10 been be VBN 37231 2217 11 abandoned abandon VBN 37231 2217 12 , , , 37231 2217 13 as as IN 37231 2217 14 a a DT 37231 2217 15 case case NN 37231 2217 16 of of IN 37231 2217 17 restoration restoration NN 37231 2217 18 to to IN 37231 2217 19 life life NN 37231 2217 20 , , , 37231 2217 21 by by IN 37231 2217 22 all all DT 37231 2217 23 critics critic NNS 37231 2217 24 and and CC 37231 2217 25 theologians theologian NNS 37231 2217 26 , , , 37231 2217 27 except except IN 37231 2217 28 the the DT 37231 2217 29 few few JJ 37231 2217 30 who who WP 37231 2217 31 still still RB 37231 2217 32 persist persist VBP 37231 2217 33 in in IN 37231 2217 34 ignoring ignore VBG 37231 2217 35 the the DT 37231 2217 36 distinct distinct JJ 37231 2217 37 and and CC 37231 2217 38 positive positive JJ 37231 2217 39 declaration declaration NN 37231 2217 40 of of IN 37231 2217 41 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2217 42 , , , 37231 2217 43 " " `` 37231 2217 44 The the DT 37231 2217 45 damsel damsel NN 37231 2217 46 is be VBZ 37231 2217 47 not not RB 37231 2217 48 dead dead JJ 37231 2217 49 but but CC 37231 2217 50 sleepeth sleepeth JJ 37231 2217 51 . . . 37231 2217 52 " " '' 37231 2218 1 The the DT 37231 2218 2 only only JJ 37231 2218 3 case case NN 37231 2218 4 , , , 37231 2218 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 2218 6 , , , 37231 2218 7 in in IN 37231 2218 8 the the DT 37231 2218 9 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2218 10 is be VBZ 37231 2218 11 the the DT 37231 2218 12 account account NN 37231 2218 13 in in IN 37231 2218 14 the the DT 37231 2218 15 third third JJ 37231 2218 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2218 17 of of IN 37231 2218 18 the the DT 37231 2218 19 raising raising NN 37231 2218 20 of of IN 37231 2218 21 the the DT 37231 2218 22 widow widow NN 37231 2218 23 's 's POS 37231 2218 24 son,(3 son,(3 NNP 37231 2218 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2218 26 of of IN 37231 2218 27 which which WDT 37231 2218 28 , , , 37231 2218 29 strange strange JJ 37231 2218 30 to to TO 37231 2218 31 say say VB 37231 2218 32 , , , 37231 2218 33 the the DT 37231 2218 34 other other JJ 37231 2218 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2218 36 know know VBP 37231 2218 37 nothing nothing NN 37231 2218 38 . . . 37231 2219 1 Now now RB 37231 2219 2 , , , 37231 2219 3 although although IN 37231 2219 4 , , , 37231 2219 5 as as IN 37231 2219 6 might may MD 37231 2219 7 have have VB 37231 2219 8 been be VBN 37231 2219 9 expected expect VBN 37231 2219 10 , , , 37231 2219 11 this this DT 37231 2219 12 narrative narrative NN 37231 2219 13 is be VBZ 37231 2219 14 much much RB 37231 2219 15 more more RBR 37231 2219 16 highly highly RB 37231 2219 17 coloured coloured JJ 37231 2219 18 and and CC 37231 2219 19 picturesque picturesque NN 37231 2219 20 , , , 37231 2219 21 the the DT 37231 2219 22 difference difference NN 37231 2219 23 is be VBZ 37231 2219 24 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 2219 25 literary literary JJ 37231 2219 26 , , , 37231 2219 27 and and CC 37231 2219 28 , , , 37231 2219 29 indeed indeed RB 37231 2219 30 , , , 37231 2219 31 there there EX 37231 2219 32 are be VBP 37231 2219 33 really really RB 37231 2219 34 fewer fewer RBR 37231 2219 35 important important JJ 37231 2219 36 details detail NNS 37231 2219 37 given give VBN 37231 2219 38 than than IN 37231 2219 39 in in IN 37231 2219 40 the the DT 37231 2219 41 account account NN 37231 2219 42 by by IN 37231 2219 43 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2219 44 , , , 37231 2219 45 for for IN 37231 2219 46 instance instance NN 37231 2219 47 , , , 37231 2219 48 of of IN 37231 2219 49 the the DT 37231 2219 50 restoration restoration NN 37231 2219 51 to to IN 37231 2219 52 life life NN 37231 2219 53 of of IN 37231 2219 54 the the DT 37231 2219 55 daughter daughter NN 37231 2219 56 of of IN 37231 2219 57 Bassus Bassus NNP 37231 2219 58 the the DT 37231 2219 59 Syrian Syrian NNP 37231 2219 60 , , , 37231 2219 61 which which WDT 37231 2219 62 took take VBD 37231 2219 63 place place NN 37231 2219 64 at at IN 37231 2219 65 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2219 66 , , , 37231 2219 67 of of IN 37231 2219 68 which which WDT 37231 2219 69 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2219 70 was be VBD 37231 2219 71 bishop bishop NN 37231 2219 72 , , , 37231 2219 73 and and CC 37231 2219 74 where where WRB 37231 2219 75 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2219 76 actually actually RB 37231 2219 77 resided reside VBD 37231 2219 78 . . . 37231 2220 1 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2220 2 's 's POS 37231 2220 3 object object NN 37231 2220 4 in in IN 37231 2220 5 giving give VBG 37231 2220 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2220 7 list list NN 37231 2220 8 of of IN 37231 2220 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2220 10 did do VBD 37231 2220 11 not not RB 37231 2220 12 require require VB 37231 2220 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2220 14 to to TO 37231 2220 15 write write VB 37231 2220 16 picturesque picturesque NN 37231 2220 17 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2220 18 . . . 37231 2221 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2221 2 merely merely RB 37231 2221 3 desired desire VBD 37231 2221 4 to to IN 37231 2221 5 state state NN 37231 2221 6 bare bare JJ 37231 2221 7 facts fact NNS 37231 2221 8 , , , 37231 2221 9 whilst whilst IN 37231 2221 10 the the DT 37231 2221 11 authors author NNS 37231 2221 12 of of IN 37231 2221 13 the the DT 37231 2221 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2221 15 composed compose VBD 37231 2221 16 the the DT 37231 2221 17 Life Life NNP 37231 2221 18 of of IN 37231 2221 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2221 20 Master Master NNP 37231 2221 21 , , , 37231 2221 22 in in IN 37231 2221 23 which which WDT 37231 2221 24 interesting interesting JJ 37231 2221 25 details detail NNS 37231 2221 26 were be VBD 37231 2221 27 everything everything NN 37231 2221 28 . . . 37231 2222 1 For for IN 37231 2222 2 many many JJ 37231 2222 3 reasons reason NNS 37231 2222 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2222 5 refrain refrain VBP 37231 2222 6 here here RB 37231 2222 7 from from IN 37231 2222 8 alluding allude VBG 37231 2222 9 to to IN 37231 2222 10 the the DT 37231 2222 11 artistic artistic JJ 37231 2222 12 narrative narrative NN 37231 2222 13 of of IN 37231 2222 14 the the DT 37231 2222 15 raising raising NN 37231 2222 16 { { -LRB- 37231 2222 17 179 179 CD 37231 2222 18 } } -RRB- 37231 2222 19 of of IN 37231 2222 20 Lazarus Lazarus NNP 37231 2222 21 , , , 37231 2222 22 the the DT 37231 2222 23 greatest great JJS 37231 2222 24 miracle miracle NN 37231 2222 25 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2222 26 to to IN 37231 2222 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2222 28 , , , 37231 2222 29 yet yet CC 37231 2222 30 so so RB 37231 2222 31 singularly singularly RB 37231 2222 32 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2222 33 to to IN 37231 2222 34 the the DT 37231 2222 35 other other JJ 37231 2222 36 three three CD 37231 2222 37 Evangelists Evangelists NNPS 37231 2222 38 , , , 37231 2222 39 who who WP 37231 2222 40 , , , 37231 2222 41 so so RB 37231 2222 42 readily readily RB 37231 2222 43 repeating repeat VBG 37231 2222 44 the the DT 37231 2222 45 accounts account NNS 37231 2222 46 of of IN 37231 2222 47 trifling trifling NN 37231 2222 48 cures cure NNS 37231 2222 49 , , , 37231 2222 50 would would MD 37231 2222 51 most most RBS 37231 2222 52 certainly certainly RB 37231 2222 53 not not RB 37231 2222 54 have have VBP 37231 2222 55 neglected neglect VBN 37231 2222 56 this this DT 37231 2222 57 had have VBD 37231 2222 58 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2222 59 ever ever RB 37231 2222 60 heard hear VBD 37231 2222 61 of of IN 37231 2222 62 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2222 63 . . . 37231 2223 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2223 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2223 3 complains complain VBZ 37231 2223 4 of of IN 37231 2223 5 the the DT 37231 2223 6 absence absence NN 37231 2223 7 of of IN 37231 2223 8 verification verification NN 37231 2223 9 and and CC 37231 2223 10 proof proof NN 37231 2223 11 of of IN 37231 2223 12 actual actual JJ 37231 2223 13 death death NN 37231 2223 14 in in IN 37231 2223 15 these these DT 37231 2223 16 cases case NNS 37231 2223 17 , , , 37231 2223 18 or or CC 37231 2223 19 that that IN 37231 2223 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2223 21 were be VBD 37231 2223 22 more more JJR 37231 2223 23 than than IN 37231 2223 24 mere mere JJ 37231 2223 25 suspension suspension NN 37231 2223 26 of of IN 37231 2223 27 the the DT 37231 2223 28 vital vital JJ 37231 2223 29 powers power NNS 37231 2223 30 . . . 37231 2224 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2224 2 cordially cordially RB 37231 2224 3 agree agree VBP 37231 2224 4 with with IN 37231 2224 5 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2224 6 in in IN 37231 2224 7 the the DT 37231 2224 8 desire desire NN 37231 2224 9 for for IN 37231 2224 10 such such JJ 37231 2224 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 2224 12 , , , 37231 2224 13 not not RB 37231 2224 14 only only RB 37231 2224 15 in in IN 37231 2224 16 these these DT 37231 2224 17 , , , 37231 2224 18 but but CC 37231 2224 19 in in IN 37231 2224 20 all all DT 37231 2224 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2224 22 . . . 37231 2225 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2225 2 would would MD 37231 2225 3 ask ask VB 37231 2225 4 , , , 37231 2225 5 however however RB 37231 2225 6 , , , 37231 2225 7 what what WDT 37231 2225 8 verification verification NN 37231 2225 9 of of IN 37231 2225 10 the the DT 37231 2225 11 death death NN 37231 2225 12 have have VBP 37231 2225 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2225 14 in in IN 37231 2225 15 the the DT 37231 2225 16 case case NN 37231 2225 17 of of IN 37231 2225 18 the the DT 37231 2225 19 widow widow NN 37231 2225 20 's 's POS 37231 2225 21 son son NN 37231 2225 22 which which WDT 37231 2225 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2225 24 have have VBP 37231 2225 25 not not RB 37231 2225 26 here here RB 37231 2225 27 ? ? . 37231 2226 1 If if IN 37231 2226 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2226 3 apply apply VBP 37231 2226 4 such such PDT 37231 2226 5 a a DT 37231 2226 6 test test NN 37231 2226 7 to to IN 37231 2226 8 the the DT 37231 2226 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2226 10 of of IN 37231 2226 11 the the DT 37231 2226 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2226 13 , , , 37231 2226 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2226 15 must must MD 37231 2226 16 reject reject VB 37231 2226 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2226 18 as as RB 37231 2226 19 certainly certainly RB 37231 2226 20 as as IN 37231 2226 21 those those DT 37231 2226 22 of of IN 37231 2226 23 St. St. NNP 37231 2226 24 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2226 25 . . . 37231 2227 1 In in IN 37231 2227 2 neither neither DT 37231 2227 3 case case NN 37231 2227 4 have have VBP 37231 2227 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2227 6 more more JJR 37231 2227 7 than than IN 37231 2227 8 a a DT 37231 2227 9 mere mere JJ 37231 2227 10 statement statement NN 37231 2227 11 that that IN 37231 2227 12 the the DT 37231 2227 13 subjects subject NNS 37231 2227 14 of of IN 37231 2227 15 these these DT 37231 2227 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2227 17 were be VBD 37231 2227 18 dead dead JJ 37231 2227 19 or or CC 37231 2227 20 diseased disease VBN 37231 2227 21 . . . 37231 2228 1 So so RB 37231 2228 2 far far RB 37231 2228 3 are be VBP 37231 2228 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2228 5 from from IN 37231 2228 6 having have VBG 37231 2228 7 any any DT 37231 2228 8 competent competent JJ 37231 2228 9 medical medical JJ 37231 2228 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 2228 11 of of IN 37231 2228 12 the the DT 37231 2228 13 reality reality NN 37231 2228 14 of of IN 37231 2228 15 the the DT 37231 2228 16 death death NN 37231 2228 17 , , , 37231 2228 18 or or CC 37231 2228 19 of of IN 37231 2228 20 the the DT 37231 2228 21 disease disease NN 37231 2228 22 , , , 37231 2228 23 or or CC 37231 2228 24 of of IN 37231 2228 25 the the DT 37231 2228 26 permanence permanence NN 37231 2228 27 of of IN 37231 2228 28 the the DT 37231 2228 29 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2228 30 cures cure NNS 37231 2228 31 in in IN 37231 2228 32 the the DT 37231 2228 33 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2228 34 , , , 37231 2228 35 that that IN 37231 2228 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2228 37 have have VBP 37231 2228 38 little little RB 37231 2228 39 more more JJR 37231 2228 40 than than IN 37231 2228 41 the the DT 37231 2228 42 barest bare JJS 37231 2228 43 reports report NNS 37231 2228 44 of of IN 37231 2228 45 these these DT 37231 2228 46 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2228 47 by by IN 37231 2228 48 writers writer NNS 37231 2228 49 who who WP 37231 2228 50 , , , 37231 2228 51 even even RB 37231 2228 52 if if IN 37231 2228 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2228 54 identity identity NN 37231 2228 55 were be VBD 37231 2228 56 established establish VBN 37231 2228 57 , , , 37231 2228 58 were be VBD 37231 2228 59 not not RB 37231 2228 60 , , , 37231 2228 61 and and CC 37231 2228 62 do do VBP 37231 2228 63 not not RB 37231 2228 64 pretend pretend VB 37231 2228 65 to to TO 37231 2228 66 have have VB 37231 2228 67 been be VBN 37231 2228 68 , , , 37231 2228 69 eye eye NN 37231 2228 70 - - HYPH 37231 2228 71 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2228 72 of of IN 37231 2228 73 the the DT 37231 2228 74 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2228 75 which which WDT 37231 2228 76 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2228 77 relate relate VBP 37231 2228 78 . . . 37231 2229 1 Take take VB 37231 2229 2 , , , 37231 2229 3 for for IN 37231 2229 4 instance instance NN 37231 2229 5 , , , 37231 2229 6 this this DT 37231 2229 7 very very RB 37231 2229 8 raising raising NN 37231 2229 9 of of IN 37231 2229 10 the the DT 37231 2229 11 widow widow NN 37231 2229 12 's 's POS 37231 2229 13 son son NN 37231 2229 14 in in IN 37231 2229 15 the the DT 37231 2229 16 third third JJ 37231 2229 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2229 18 , , , 37231 2229 19 which which WDT 37231 2229 20 is be VBZ 37231 2229 21 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2229 22 to to IN 37231 2229 23 the the DT 37231 2229 24 other other JJ 37231 2229 25 Evangelists Evangelists NNPS 37231 2229 26 , , , 37231 2229 27 and and CC 37231 2229 28 the the DT 37231 2229 29 narrative narrative NN 37231 2229 30 of of IN 37231 2229 31 which which WDT 37231 2229 32 is be VBZ 37231 2229 33 given give VBN 37231 2229 34 only only RB 37231 2229 35 in in IN 37231 2229 36 a a DT 37231 2229 37 Gospel gospel NN 37231 2229 38 which which WDT 37231 2229 39 is be VBZ 37231 2229 40 not not RB 37231 2229 41 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2229 42 to to IN 37231 2229 43 a a DT 37231 2229 44 personal personal JJ 37231 2229 45 follower follower NN 37231 2229 46 of of IN 37231 2229 47 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2229 48 . . . 37231 2230 1 Now now RB 37231 2230 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2230 3 turn turn VBP 37231 2230 4 to to IN 37231 2230 5 the the DT 37231 2230 6 second second JJ 37231 2230 7 statement statement NN 37231 2230 8 of of IN 37231 2230 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2230 10 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2230 11 , , , 37231 2230 12 " " `` 37231 2230 13 that that IN 37231 2230 14 with with IN 37231 2230 15 the the DT 37231 2230 16 preface preface NN 37231 2230 17 which which WDT 37231 2230 18 Augustine augustine JJ 37231 2230 19 prefixes prefix NNS 37231 2230 20 to to IN 37231 2230 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2230 22 list list NN 37231 2230 23 , , , 37231 2230 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2230 25 can can MD 37231 2230 26 not not RB 37231 2230 27 be be VB 37231 2230 28 said say VBN 37231 2230 29 even even RB 37231 2230 30 to to IN 37231 2230 31 profess profess VB 37231 2230 32 to to TO 37231 2230 33 guarantee guarantee VB 37231 2230 34 the the DT 37231 2230 35 truth truth NN 37231 2230 36 or or CC 37231 2230 37 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2230 38 of of IN 37231 2230 39 the the DT 37231 2230 40 different different JJ 37231 2230 41 instances instance NNS 37231 2230 42 contained contain VBN 37231 2230 43 in in IN 37231 2230 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2230 45 . . . 37231 2230 46 " " '' 37231 2231 1 This this DT 37231 2231 2 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 2231 3 assertion assertion NN 37231 2231 4 is be VBZ 37231 2231 5 supported support VBN 37231 2231 6 by by IN 37231 2231 7 a a DT 37231 2231 8 quotation quotation NN 37231 2231 9 { { -LRB- 37231 2231 10 180 180 CD 37231 2231 11 } } -RRB- 37231 2231 12 given give VBN 37231 2231 13 above above RB 37231 2231 14 , , , 37231 2231 15 which which WDT 37231 2231 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2231 17 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2231 18 has have VBZ 37231 2231 19 separated separate VBN 37231 2231 20 from from IN 37231 2231 21 what what WP 37231 2231 22 precedes precede NNS 37231 2231 23 and and CC 37231 2231 24 follows follow VBZ 37231 2231 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2231 26 , , , 37231 2231 27 so so IN 37231 2231 28 that that IN 37231 2231 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2231 30 real real JJ 37231 2231 31 meaning meaning NN 37231 2231 32 is be VBZ 37231 2231 33 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2231 34 apparent apparent JJ 37231 2231 35 . . . 37231 2232 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2232 2 shall shall MD 37231 2232 3 as as RB 37231 2232 4 briefly briefly RB 37231 2232 5 as as IN 37231 2232 6 possible possible JJ 37231 2232 7 state state NN 37231 2232 8 what what WP 37231 2232 9 is be VBZ 37231 2232 10 actually actually RB 37231 2232 11 the the DT 37231 2232 12 " " `` 37231 2232 13 preface preface NN 37231 2232 14 " " '' 37231 2232 15 of of IN 37231 2232 16 St. St. NNP 37231 2232 17 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2232 18 to to IN 37231 2232 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2232 20 list list NN 37231 2232 21 of of IN 37231 2232 22 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2232 23 , , , 37231 2232 24 and and CC 37231 2232 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2232 26 avowed avowed JJ 37231 2232 27 object object NN 37231 2232 28 for for IN 37231 2232 29 giving give VBG 37231 2232 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2232 31 . . . 37231 2233 1 In in IN 37231 2233 2 the the DT 37231 2233 3 preceding precede VBG 37231 2233 4 chapter chapter NN 37231 2233 5 , , , 37231 2233 6 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2233 7 has have VBZ 37231 2233 8 been be VBN 37231 2233 9 arguing argue VBG 37231 2233 10 that that IN 37231 2233 11 the the DT 37231 2233 12 world world NN 37231 2233 13 believed believe VBD 37231 2233 14 in in IN 37231 2233 15 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2233 16 by by IN 37231 2233 17 virtue virtue NN 37231 2233 18 of of IN 37231 2233 19 divine divine JJ 37231 2233 20 influence influence NN 37231 2233 21 and and CC 37231 2233 22 not not RB 37231 2233 23 by by IN 37231 2233 24 human human JJ 37231 2233 25 persuasion persuasion NN 37231 2233 26 . . . 37231 2234 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2234 2 contends contend VBZ 37231 2234 3 that that IN 37231 2234 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2234 5 is be VBZ 37231 2234 6 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 37231 2234 7 to to TO 37231 2234 8 speak speak VB 37231 2234 9 of of IN 37231 2234 10 the the DT 37231 2234 11 false false JJ 37231 2234 12 divinity divinity NN 37231 2234 13 of of IN 37231 2234 14 Romulus Romulus NNP 37231 2234 15 when when WRB 37231 2234 16 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2234 17 speak speak VBP 37231 2234 18 of of IN 37231 2234 19 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2234 20 . . . 37231 2235 1 If if IN 37231 2235 2 , , , 37231 2235 3 in in IN 37231 2235 4 the the DT 37231 2235 5 time time NN 37231 2235 6 of of IN 37231 2235 7 Romulus Romulus NNP 37231 2235 8 , , , 37231 2235 9 some some DT 37231 2235 10 600 600 CD 37231 2235 11 years year NNS 37231 2235 12 before before IN 37231 2235 13 Cicero Cicero NNP 37231 2235 14 , , , 37231 2235 15 people people NNS 37231 2235 16 were be VBD 37231 2235 17 so so RB 37231 2235 18 enlightened enlighten VBN 37231 2235 19 that that IN 37231 2235 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2235 21 refused refuse VBD 37231 2235 22 to to TO 37231 2235 23 believe believe VB 37231 2235 24 anything anything NN 37231 2235 25 of of IN 37231 2235 26 which which WDT 37231 2235 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2235 28 had have VBD 37231 2235 29 not not RB 37231 2235 30 experience experience NN 37231 2235 31 , , , 37231 2235 32 how how WRB 37231 2235 33 much much RB 37231 2235 34 more more JJR 37231 2235 35 , , , 37231 2235 36 in in IN 37231 2235 37 the the DT 37231 2235 38 still still RB 37231 2235 39 more more RBR 37231 2235 40 enlightened enlightened JJ 37231 2235 41 days day NNS 37231 2235 42 of of IN 37231 2235 43 Cicero Cicero NNP 37231 2235 44 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2235 45 , , , 37231 2235 46 and and CC 37231 2235 47 notably notably RB 37231 2235 48 in in IN 37231 2235 49 the the DT 37231 2235 50 reigns reign NNS 37231 2235 51 of of IN 37231 2235 52 Augustus Augustus NNP 37231 2235 53 and and CC 37231 2235 54 Tiberius Tiberius NNP 37231 2235 55 , , , 37231 2235 56 would would MD 37231 2235 57 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2235 58 have have VB 37231 2235 59 rejected reject VBN 37231 2235 60 belief belief NN 37231 2235 61 in in IN 37231 2235 62 the the DT 37231 2235 63 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 2235 64 and and CC 37231 2235 65 ascension ascension NN 37231 2235 66 of of IN 37231 2235 67 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2235 68 , , , 37231 2235 69 if if IN 37231 2235 70 divine divine JJ 37231 2235 71 truth truth NN 37231 2235 72 and and CC 37231 2235 73 the the DT 37231 2235 74 testimony testimony NN 37231 2235 75 of of IN 37231 2235 76 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2235 77 had have VBD 37231 2235 78 not not RB 37231 2235 79 proved prove VBN 37231 2235 80 not not RB 37231 2235 81 only only RB 37231 2235 82 that that IN 37231 2235 83 such such JJ 37231 2235 84 things thing NNS 37231 2235 85 could could MD 37231 2235 86 take take VB 37231 2235 87 place place NN 37231 2235 88 , , , 37231 2235 89 but but CC 37231 2235 90 that that IN 37231 2235 91 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2235 92 had have VBD 37231 2235 93 actually actually RB 37231 2235 94 done do VBN 37231 2235 95 so so RB 37231 2235 96 . . . 37231 2236 1 When when WRB 37231 2236 2 the the DT 37231 2236 3 evidence evidence NN 37231 2236 4 of of IN 37231 2236 5 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 2236 6 joined join VBN 37231 2236 7 with with IN 37231 2236 8 that that DT 37231 2236 9 of of IN 37231 2236 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2236 11 , , , 37231 2236 12 and and CC 37231 2236 13 showed show VBD 37231 2236 14 that that IN 37231 2236 15 the the DT 37231 2236 16 new new JJ 37231 2236 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 2236 18 were be VBD 37231 2236 19 only only RB 37231 2236 20 contrary contrary JJ 37231 2236 21 to to TO 37231 2236 22 experience experience VB 37231 2236 23 and and CC 37231 2236 24 not not RB 37231 2236 25 contrary contrary JJ 37231 2236 26 to to IN 37231 2236 27 reason reason NN 37231 2236 28 , , , 37231 2236 29 the the DT 37231 2236 30 world world NN 37231 2236 31 embraced embrace VBD 37231 2236 32 the the DT 37231 2236 33 faith faith NN 37231 2236 34 . . . 37231 2237 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2237 2 1 1 LS 37231 2237 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2237 4 " " `` 37231 2237 5 Why why WRB 37231 2237 6 , , , 37231 2237 7 then then RB 37231 2237 8 , , , 37231 2237 9 say say VBP 37231 2237 10 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2237 11 , , , 37231 2237 12 do do VBP 37231 2237 13 these these DT 37231 2237 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2237 15 which which WDT 37231 2237 16 you -PRON- PRP 37231 2237 17 declare declare VBP 37231 2237 18 to to TO 37231 2237 19 have have VB 37231 2237 20 taken take VBN 37231 2237 21 place place NN 37231 2237 22 formerly formerly RB 37231 2237 23 , , , 37231 2237 24 not not RB 37231 2237 25 occur occur VB 37231 2237 26 now now RB 37231 2237 27 - - HYPH 37231 2237 28 a a DT 37231 2237 29 - - HYPH 37231 2237 30 days day NNS 37231 2237 31 ? ? . 37231 2237 32 " " '' 37231 2238 1 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2238 2 , , , 37231 2238 3 in in IN 37231 2238 4 replying reply VBG 37231 2238 5 , , , 37231 2238 6 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 2238 7 a a DT 37231 2238 8 common common JJ 37231 2238 9 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 37231 2238 10 device device NN 37231 2238 11 : : : 37231 2238 12 " " `` 37231 2238 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2238 14 might may MD 37231 2238 15 , , , 37231 2238 16 indeed indeed RB 37231 2238 17 , , , 37231 2238 18 answer answer VB 37231 2238 19 , , , 37231 2238 20 " " '' 37231 2238 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2238 22 says say VBZ 37231 2238 23 , , , 37231 2238 24 " " `` 37231 2238 25 that that IN 37231 2238 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2238 27 were be VBD 37231 2238 28 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2238 29 before before IN 37231 2238 30 the the DT 37231 2238 31 world world NN 37231 2238 32 believed believe VBD 37231 2238 33 , , , 37231 2238 34 in in IN 37231 2238 35 order order NN 37231 2238 36 that that IN 37231 2238 37 the the DT 37231 2238 38 world world NN 37231 2238 39 might may MD 37231 2238 40 believe believe VB 37231 2238 41 . . . 37231 2239 1 Any any DT 37231 2239 2 one one NN 37231 2239 3 who who WP 37231 2239 4 now now RB 37231 2239 5 requires require VBZ 37231 2239 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2239 7 in in IN 37231 2239 8 order order NN 37231 2239 9 that that IN 37231 2239 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2239 11 may may MD 37231 2239 12 believe believe VB 37231 2239 13 , , , 37231 2239 14 is be VBZ 37231 2239 15 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2239 16 a a DT 37231 2239 17 great great JJ 37231 2239 18 miracle miracle NN 37231 2239 19 in in IN 37231 2239 20 not not RB 37231 2239 21 believing believe VBG 37231 2239 22 what what WP 37231 2239 23 all all PDT 37231 2239 24 the the DT 37231 2239 25 world world NN 37231 2239 26 believes believe VBZ 37231 2239 27 . . . 37231 2240 1 But but CC 37231 2240 2 , , , 37231 2240 3 really really RB 37231 2240 4 , , , 37231 2240 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2240 6 say say VBP 37231 2240 7 this this DT 37231 2240 8 in in IN 37231 2240 9 order order NN 37231 2240 10 that that IN 37231 2240 11 even even RB 37231 2240 12 those those DT 37231 2240 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2240 14 should should MD 37231 2240 15 not not RB 37231 2240 16 be be VB 37231 2240 17 believed believe VBN 37231 2240 18 either either RB 37231 2240 19 . . . 37231 2240 20 " " '' 37231 2241 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2241 2 181 181 CD 37231 2241 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2241 4 And and CC 37231 2241 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2241 6 reduces reduce VBZ 37231 2241 7 what what WP 37231 2241 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2241 9 considers consider VBZ 37231 2241 10 to to TO 37231 2241 11 be be VB 37231 2241 12 the the DT 37231 2241 13 position position NN 37231 2241 14 of of IN 37231 2241 15 the the DT 37231 2241 16 world world NN 37231 2241 17 in in IN 37231 2241 18 regard regard NN 37231 2241 19 to to IN 37231 2241 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2241 21 and and CC 37231 2241 22 to to IN 37231 2241 23 the the DT 37231 2241 24 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2241 25 dogmas dogmas NN 37231 2241 26 of of IN 37231 2241 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2241 28 to to IN 37231 2241 29 the the DT 37231 2241 30 following follow VBG 37231 2241 31 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 2241 32 : : : 37231 2241 33 " " `` 37231 2241 34 Either either CC 37231 2241 35 things thing NNS 37231 2241 36 incredible incredible JJ 37231 2241 37 which which WDT 37231 2241 38 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 2241 39 occurred occur VBD 37231 2241 40 , , , 37231 2241 41 and and CC 37231 2241 42 were be VBD 37231 2241 43 seen see VBN 37231 2241 44 , , , 37231 2241 45 led lead VBN 37231 2241 46 to to IN 37231 2241 47 belief belief NN 37231 2241 48 in in IN 37231 2241 49 something something NN 37231 2241 50 else else RB 37231 2241 51 incredible incredible JJ 37231 2241 52 , , , 37231 2241 53 which which WDT 37231 2241 54 was be VBD 37231 2241 55 not not RB 37231 2241 56 seen see VBN 37231 2241 57 ; ; : 37231 2241 58 or or CC 37231 2241 59 that that DT 37231 2241 60 thing thing NN 37231 2241 61 was be VBD 37231 2241 62 in in IN 37231 2241 63 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2241 64 so so RB 37231 2241 65 credible credible JJ 37231 2241 66 that that IN 37231 2241 67 no no DT 37231 2241 68 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2241 69 were be VBD 37231 2241 70 required require VBN 37231 2241 71 to to TO 37231 2241 72 establish establish VB 37231 2241 73 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2241 74 , , , 37231 2241 75 and and CC 37231 2241 76 so so RB 37231 2241 77 much much RB 37231 2241 78 more more JJR 37231 2241 79 is be VBZ 37231 2241 80 the the DT 37231 2241 81 unbelief unbelief NN 37231 2241 82 of of IN 37231 2241 83 those those DT 37231 2241 84 who who WP 37231 2241 85 deny deny VBP 37231 2241 86 confuted confute VBN 37231 2241 87 . . . 37231 2242 1 This this DT 37231 2242 2 might may MD 37231 2242 3 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2242 4 say say VB 37231 2242 5 to to IN 37231 2242 6 these these DT 37231 2242 7 most most RBS 37231 2242 8 frivolous frivolous JJ 37231 2242 9 objectors objector NNS 37231 2242 10 . . . 37231 2242 11 " " '' 37231 2243 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2243 2 then then RB 37231 2243 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 2243 4 to to TO 37231 2243 5 affirm affirm VB 37231 2243 6 that that IN 37231 2243 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2243 8 can can MD 37231 2243 9 not not RB 37231 2243 10 be be VB 37231 2243 11 denied deny VBN 37231 2243 12 that that IN 37231 2243 13 many many JJ 37231 2243 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2243 15 attest attest VBP 37231 2243 16 the the DT 37231 2243 17 great great JJ 37231 2243 18 miracle miracle NN 37231 2243 19 of of IN 37231 2243 20 the the DT 37231 2243 21 ascension ascension NN 37231 2243 22 in in IN 37231 2243 23 the the DT 37231 2243 24 flesh flesh NN 37231 2243 25 of of IN 37231 2243 26 the the DT 37231 2243 27 risen rise VBN 37231 2243 28 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2243 29 , , , 37231 2243 30 and and CC 37231 2243 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2243 32 points point VBZ 37231 2243 33 out out RP 37231 2243 34 that that IN 37231 2243 35 the the DT 37231 2243 36 actual actual JJ 37231 2243 37 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2243 38 of of IN 37231 2243 39 all all PDT 37231 2243 40 these these DT 37231 2243 41 things thing NNS 37231 2243 42 is be VBZ 37231 2243 43 not not RB 37231 2243 44 only only RB 37231 2243 45 recorded record VBN 37231 2243 46 in in IN 37231 2243 47 the the DT 37231 2243 48 most most RBS 37231 2243 49 truthful truthful JJ 37231 2243 50 books book NNS 37231 2243 51 , , , 37231 2243 52 but but CC 37231 2243 53 the the DT 37231 2243 54 reasons reason NNS 37231 2243 55 also also RB 37231 2243 56 given give VBN 37231 2243 57 why why WRB 37231 2243 58 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2243 59 took take VBD 37231 2243 60 place place NN 37231 2243 61 . . . 37231 2244 1 These these DT 37231 2244 2 things thing NNS 37231 2244 3 have have VBP 37231 2244 4 become become VBN 37231 2244 5 known know VBN 37231 2244 6 that that IN 37231 2244 7 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2244 8 might may MD 37231 2244 9 create create VB 37231 2244 10 belief belief NN 37231 2244 11 ; ; : 37231 2244 12 these these DT 37231 2244 13 things thing NNS 37231 2244 14 by by IN 37231 2244 15 the the DT 37231 2244 16 belief belief NN 37231 2244 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2244 18 have have VBP 37231 2244 19 created create VBN 37231 2244 20 have have VBP 37231 2244 21 become become VBN 37231 2244 22 much much RB 37231 2244 23 more more RBR 37231 2244 24 clearly clearly RB 37231 2244 25 known know VBN 37231 2244 26 . . . 37231 2245 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 2245 2 are be VBP 37231 2245 3 read read VBN 37231 2245 4 to to IN 37231 2245 5 the the DT 37231 2245 6 people people NNS 37231 2245 7 , , , 37231 2245 8 indeed indeed RB 37231 2245 9 , , , 37231 2245 10 that that IN 37231 2245 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2245 12 may may MD 37231 2245 13 believe believe VB 37231 2245 14 ; ; : 37231 2245 15 yet yet CC 37231 2245 16 , , , 37231 2245 17 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 2245 18 , , , 37231 2245 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2245 20 would would MD 37231 2245 21 not not RB 37231 2245 22 be be VB 37231 2245 23 read read VBN 37231 2245 24 to to IN 37231 2245 25 the the DT 37231 2245 26 people people NNS 37231 2245 27 if if IN 37231 2245 28 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2245 29 had have VBD 37231 2245 30 not not RB 37231 2245 31 been be VBN 37231 2245 32 believed believe VBN 37231 2245 33 . . . 37231 2246 1 After after IN 37231 2246 2 thus thus RB 37231 2246 3 stating state VBG 37231 2246 4 the the DT 37231 2246 5 answer answer NN 37231 2246 6 which which WDT 37231 2246 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2246 8 might may MD 37231 2246 9 give give VB 37231 2246 10 , , , 37231 2246 11 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2246 12 now now RB 37231 2246 13 returns return VBZ 37231 2246 14 to to TO 37231 2246 15 answer answer VB 37231 2246 16 the the DT 37231 2246 17 question question NN 37231 2246 18 directly:--"But directly:--"But '' 37231 2246 19 , , , 37231 2246 20 furthermore furthermore RB 37231 2246 21 , , , 37231 2246 22 " " '' 37231 2246 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2246 24 continues continue VBZ 37231 2246 25 , , , 37231 2246 26 " " `` 37231 2246 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2246 28 are be VBP 37231 2246 29 performed perform VBN 37231 2246 30 now now RB 37231 2246 31 in in IN 37231 2246 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2246 33 name name NN 37231 2246 34 , , , 37231 2246 35 either either CC 37231 2246 36 by by IN 37231 2246 37 means mean NNS 37231 2246 38 of of IN 37231 2246 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2246 40 sacraments sacrament NNS 37231 2246 41 , , , 37231 2246 42 or or CC 37231 2246 43 by by IN 37231 2246 44 the the DT 37231 2246 45 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2246 46 or or CC 37231 2246 47 relics relic NNS 37231 2246 48 of of IN 37231 2246 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2246 50 saints saint NNS 37231 2246 51 , , , 37231 2246 52 but but CC 37231 2246 53 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2246 54 are be VBP 37231 2246 55 not not RB 37231 2246 56 brought bring VBN 37231 2246 57 under under IN 37231 2246 58 the the DT 37231 2246 59 same same JJ 37231 2246 60 strong strong JJ 37231 2246 61 light light NN 37231 2246 62 as as IN 37231 2246 63 caused cause VBD 37231 2246 64 the the DT 37231 2246 65 former former JJ 37231 2246 66 to to TO 37231 2246 67 be be VB 37231 2246 68 noised noise VBN 37231 2246 69 abroad abroad RB 37231 2246 70 with with IN 37231 2246 71 so so RB 37231 2246 72 much much JJ 37231 2246 73 glory glory NN 37231 2246 74 ; ; : 37231 2246 75 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37231 2246 76 as as IN 37231 2246 77 the the DT 37231 2246 78 canon canon NN 37231 2246 79 of of IN 37231 2246 80 sacred sacred JJ 37231 2246 81 scriptures scripture NNS 37231 2246 82 , , , 37231 2246 83 which which WDT 37231 2246 84 must must MD 37231 2246 85 be be VB 37231 2246 86 definite definite JJ 37231 2246 87 , , , 37231 2246 88 causes cause VBZ 37231 2246 89 those those DT 37231 2246 90 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2246 91 to to TO 37231 2246 92 be be VB 37231 2246 93 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 2246 94 publicly publicly RB 37231 2246 95 read read VBN 37231 2246 96 , , , 37231 2246 97 and and CC 37231 2246 98 become become VBP 37231 2246 99 firmly firmly RB 37231 2246 100 fixed fix VBN 37231 2246 101 in in IN 37231 2246 102 the the DT 37231 2246 103 memory memory NN 37231 2246 104 of of IN 37231 2246 105 all all DT 37231 2246 106 peoples;"(l peoples;"(l NN 37231 2246 107 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2246 108 and and CC 37231 2246 109 then then RB 37231 2246 110 follows follow VBZ 37231 2246 111 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2246 112 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2246 113 's 's POS 37231 2246 114 { { -LRB- 37231 2246 115 182 182 CD 37231 2246 116 } } -RRB- 37231 2246 117 quotation quotation NN 37231 2246 118 : : : 37231 2246 119 " " `` 37231 2246 120 but but CC 37231 2246 121 these these DT 37231 2246 122 are be VBP 37231 2246 123 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2246 124 known know VBN 37231 2246 125 to to IN 37231 2246 126 the the DT 37231 2246 127 whole whole NN 37231 2246 128 of of IN 37231 2246 129 a a DT 37231 2246 130 city city NN 37231 2246 131 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2246 132 in in IN 37231 2246 133 which which WDT 37231 2246 134 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2246 135 are be VBP 37231 2246 136 performed perform VBN 37231 2246 137 , , , 37231 2246 138 or or CC 37231 2246 139 to to IN 37231 2246 140 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2246 141 neighbourhood neighbourhood NN 37231 2246 142 . . . 37231 2247 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 2247 2 , , , 37231 2247 3 for for IN 37231 2247 4 the the DT 37231 2247 5 most most JJS 37231 2247 6 part part NN 37231 2247 7 , , , 37231 2247 8 even even RB 37231 2247 9 there there EX 37231 2247 10 very very RB 37231 2247 11 few few JJ 37231 2247 12 know know VBP 37231 2247 13 of of IN 37231 2247 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2247 15 , , , 37231 2247 16 and and CC 37231 2247 17 the the DT 37231 2247 18 rest rest NN 37231 2247 19 are be VBP 37231 2247 20 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 2247 21 , , , 37231 2247 22 more more RBR 37231 2247 23 especially especially RB 37231 2247 24 if if IN 37231 2247 25 the the DT 37231 2247 26 city city NN 37231 2247 27 be be VB 37231 2247 28 large large JJ 37231 2247 29 ; ; : 37231 2247 30 and and CC 37231 2247 31 when when WRB 37231 2247 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2247 33 are be VBP 37231 2247 34 related relate VBN 37231 2247 35 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2247 36 and and CC 37231 2247 37 to to IN 37231 2247 38 others other NNS 37231 2247 39 , , , 37231 2247 40 the the DT 37231 2247 41 authority authority NN 37231 2247 42 does do VBZ 37231 2247 43 not not RB 37231 2247 44 so so RB 37231 2247 45 commend commend VB 37231 2247 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2247 47 as as IN 37231 2247 48 to to TO 37231 2247 49 make make VB 37231 2247 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2247 51 be be VB 37231 2247 52 believed believe VBN 37231 2247 53 without without IN 37231 2247 54 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 2247 55 or or CC 37231 2247 56 doubt doubt NN 37231 2247 57 , , , 37231 2247 58 albeit albeit IN 37231 2247 59 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2247 60 are be VBP 37231 2247 61 reported report VBN 37231 2247 62 by by IN 37231 2247 63 faithful faithful JJ 37231 2247 64 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2247 65 to to IN 37231 2247 66 the the DT 37231 2247 67 faithful faithful JJ 37231 2247 68 . . . 37231 2247 69 " " '' 37231 2248 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2248 2 illustrates illustrate VBZ 37231 2248 3 this this DT 37231 2248 4 by by IN 37231 2248 5 pointing point VBG 37231 2248 6 out out RP 37231 2248 7 in in IN 37231 2248 8 immediate immediate JJ 37231 2248 9 continuation continuation NN 37231 2248 10 , , , 37231 2248 11 that that IN 37231 2248 12 the the DT 37231 2248 13 miracle miracle NN 37231 2248 14 in in IN 37231 2248 15 Milan Milan NNP 37231 2248 16 by by IN 37231 2248 17 the the DT 37231 2248 18 bodies body NNS 37231 2248 19 of of IN 37231 2248 20 the the DT 37231 2248 21 two two CD 37231 2248 22 martyrs martyr NNS 37231 2248 23 , , , 37231 2248 24 which which WDT 37231 2248 25 took take VBD 37231 2248 26 place place NN 37231 2248 27 when when WRB 37231 2248 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2248 29 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2248 30 was be VBD 37231 2248 31 there there RB 37231 2248 32 , , , 37231 2248 33 might may MD 37231 2248 34 reach reach VB 37231 2248 35 the the DT 37231 2248 36 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2248 37 of of IN 37231 2248 38 many many JJ 37231 2248 39 , , , 37231 2248 40 because because IN 37231 2248 41 the the DT 37231 2248 42 city city NN 37231 2248 43 is be VBZ 37231 2248 44 large large JJ 37231 2248 45 , , , 37231 2248 46 and and CC 37231 2248 47 the the DT 37231 2248 48 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 2248 49 and and CC 37231 2248 50 an an DT 37231 2248 51 immense immense JJ 37231 2248 52 crowd crowd NN 37231 2248 53 of of IN 37231 2248 54 people people NNS 37231 2248 55 witnessed witness VBD 37231 2248 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2248 57 , , , 37231 2248 58 but but CC 37231 2248 59 who who WP 37231 2248 60 knows know VBZ 37231 2248 61 of of IN 37231 2248 62 the the DT 37231 2248 63 miracle miracle NN 37231 2248 64 performed perform VBN 37231 2248 65 at at IN 37231 2248 66 Carthage carthage NN 37231 2248 67 upon upon IN 37231 2248 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2248 69 friend friend NN 37231 2248 70 Innocent Innocent NNP 37231 2248 71 , , , 37231 2248 72 when when WRB 37231 2248 73 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2248 74 was be VBD 37231 2248 75 there there RB 37231 2248 76 also also RB 37231 2248 77 , , , 37231 2248 78 and and CC 37231 2248 79 saw see VBD 37231 2248 80 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2248 81 with with IN 37231 2248 82 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2248 83 own own JJ 37231 2248 84 eyes eye NNS 37231 2248 85 ? ? . 37231 2249 1 Who who WP 37231 2249 2 knows know VBZ 37231 2249 3 of of IN 37231 2249 4 the the DT 37231 2249 5 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2249 6 cure cure NN 37231 2249 7 of of IN 37231 2249 8 cancer cancer NN 37231 2249 9 , , , 37231 2249 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2249 11 continues continue VBZ 37231 2249 12 , , , 37231 2249 13 in in IN 37231 2249 14 a a DT 37231 2249 15 lady lady NN 37231 2249 16 of of IN 37231 2249 17 rank rank NN 37231 2249 18 in in IN 37231 2249 19 the the DT 37231 2249 20 same same JJ 37231 2249 21 city city NN 37231 2249 22 ? ? . 37231 2250 1 at at IN 37231 2250 2 the the DT 37231 2250 3 silence silence NN 37231 2250 4 regarding regard VBG 37231 2250 5 which which WDT 37231 2250 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2250 7 is be VBZ 37231 2250 8 so so RB 37231 2250 9 indignant indignant JJ 37231 2250 10 . . . 37231 2251 1 Who who WP 37231 2251 2 knows know VBZ 37231 2251 3 of of IN 37231 2251 4 the the DT 37231 2251 5 next next JJ 37231 2251 6 case case NN 37231 2251 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2251 8 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2251 9 in in IN 37231 2251 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2251 11 list list NN 37231 2251 12 ? ? . 37231 2252 1 the the DT 37231 2252 2 cure cure NN 37231 2252 3 of of IN 37231 2252 4 a a DT 37231 2252 5 medical medical JJ 37231 2252 6 man man NN 37231 2252 7 of of IN 37231 2252 8 the the DT 37231 2252 9 same same JJ 37231 2252 10 town town NN 37231 2252 11 , , , 37231 2252 12 to to TO 37231 2252 13 which which WDT 37231 2252 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2252 15 adds add VBZ 37231 2252 16 : : : 37231 2252 17 " " `` 37231 2252 18 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2252 19 , , , 37231 2252 20 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 2252 21 , , , 37231 2252 22 do do VB 37231 2252 23 know know VB 37231 2252 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2252 25 , , , 37231 2252 26 and and CC 37231 2252 27 a a DT 37231 2252 28 few few JJ 37231 2252 29 brethren brother NNS 37231 2252 30 to to IN 37231 2252 31 whose whose WP$ 37231 2252 32 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2252 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2252 34 may may MD 37231 2252 35 have have VB 37231 2252 36 come come VBN 37231 2252 37 . . . 37231 2253 1 " " `` 37231 2253 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2253 3 1 1 LS 37231 2253 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2253 5 Who who WP 37231 2253 6 out out IN 37231 2253 7 of of IN 37231 2253 8 Curubus Curubus NNP 37231 2253 9 , , , 37231 2253 10 besides besides IN 37231 2253 11 the the DT 37231 2253 12 very very RB 37231 2253 13 few few JJ 37231 2253 14 who who WP 37231 2253 15 may may MD 37231 2253 16 have have VB 37231 2253 17 heard hear VBN 37231 2253 18 of of IN 37231 2253 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2253 20 , , , 37231 2253 21 knows know VBZ 37231 2253 22 of of IN 37231 2253 23 the the DT 37231 2253 24 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2253 25 cure cure NN 37231 2253 26 of of IN 37231 2253 27 the the DT 37231 2253 28 paralytic paralytic JJ 37231 2253 29 man man NN 37231 2253 30 , , , 37231 2253 31 whose whose WP$ 37231 2253 32 case case NN 37231 2253 33 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2253 34 personally personally RB 37231 2253 35 investigated investigate VBN 37231 2253 36 ? ? . 37231 2254 1 and and CC 37231 2254 2 so so RB 37231 2254 3 on on RB 37231 2254 4 . . . 37231 2255 1 Observe observe VB 37231 2255 2 that that IN 37231 2255 3 there there EX 37231 2255 4 is be VBZ 37231 2255 5 merely merely RB 37231 2255 6 a a DT 37231 2255 7 question question NN 37231 2255 8 of of IN 37231 2255 9 the the DT 37231 2255 10 comparative comparative JJ 37231 2255 11 notoriety notoriety NN 37231 2255 12 of of IN 37231 2255 13 the the DT 37231 2255 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2255 15 { { -LRB- 37231 2255 16 183 183 CD 37231 2255 17 } } -RRB- 37231 2255 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2255 19 and and CC 37231 2255 20 those those DT 37231 2255 21 of of IN 37231 2255 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2255 23 own own JJ 37231 2255 24 time time NN 37231 2255 25 , , , 37231 2255 26 not not RB 37231 2255 27 a a DT 37231 2255 28 doubt doubt NN 37231 2255 29 as as IN 37231 2255 30 to to IN 37231 2255 31 the the DT 37231 2255 32 reality reality NN 37231 2255 33 of of IN 37231 2255 34 the the DT 37231 2255 35 latter latter JJ 37231 2255 36 . . . 37231 2256 1 Again again RB 37231 2256 2 , , , 37231 2256 3 towards towards IN 37231 2256 4 the the DT 37231 2256 5 end end NN 37231 2256 6 of of IN 37231 2256 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2256 8 long long JJ 37231 2256 9 list list NN 37231 2256 10 , , , 37231 2256 11 immediately immediately RB 37231 2256 12 after after IN 37231 2256 13 the the DT 37231 2256 14 narrative narrative NN 37231 2256 15 of of IN 37231 2256 16 the the DT 37231 2256 17 restoration restoration NN 37231 2256 18 to to IN 37231 2256 19 life life NN 37231 2256 20 of of IN 37231 2256 21 the the DT 37231 2256 22 child child NN 37231 2256 23 of of IN 37231 2256 24 Eleusinus Eleusinus NNP 37231 2256 25 , , , 37231 2256 26 which which WDT 37231 2256 27 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2256 28 have have VBP 37231 2256 29 quoted quote VBN 37231 2256 30 , , , 37231 2256 31 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2256 32 says:--"What says:--"what NN 37231 2256 33 can can MD 37231 2256 34 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2256 35 do do VB 37231 2256 36 ? ? . 37231 2257 1 The the DT 37231 2257 2 promise promise NN 37231 2257 3 of of IN 37231 2257 4 the the DT 37231 2257 5 completion completion NN 37231 2257 6 of of IN 37231 2257 7 this this DT 37231 2257 8 work work NN 37231 2257 9 is be VBZ 37231 2257 10 pressing press VBG 37231 2257 11 , , , 37231 2257 12 so so IN 37231 2257 13 that that IN 37231 2257 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2257 15 can can MD 37231 2257 16 not not RB 37231 2257 17 here here RB 37231 2257 18 recount recount VB 37231 2257 19 all all DT 37231 2257 20 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2257 21 the the DT 37231 2257 22 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2257 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2257 24 that that WDT 37231 2257 25 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2257 26 know know VBP 37231 2257 27 ; ; : 37231 2257 28 and and CC 37231 2257 29 without without IN 37231 2257 30 doubt doubt RB 37231 2257 31 many many JJ 37231 2257 32 of of IN 37231 2257 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2257 34 brethren brother NNS 37231 2257 35 when when WRB 37231 2257 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2257 37 read read VBD 37231 2257 38 this this DT 37231 2257 39 work work NN 37231 2257 40 will will MD 37231 2257 41 be be VB 37231 2257 42 grieved grieve VBN 37231 2257 43 that that IN 37231 2257 44 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2257 45 have have VBP 37231 2257 46 omitted omit VBN 37231 2257 47 so so RB 37231 2257 48 very very RB 37231 2257 49 much much RB 37231 2257 50 , , , 37231 2257 51 which which WDT 37231 2257 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2257 53 know know VBP 37231 2257 54 as as RB 37231 2257 55 well well RB 37231 2257 56 as as IN 37231 2257 57 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2257 58 do do VBP 37231 2257 59 . . . 37231 2258 1 This this DT 37231 2258 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2258 3 even even RB 37231 2258 4 now now RB 37231 2258 5 beg beg VBP 37231 2258 6 that that IN 37231 2258 7 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2258 8 will will MD 37231 2258 9 pardon pardon VB 37231 2258 10 , , , 37231 2258 11 and and CC 37231 2258 12 consider consider VB 37231 2258 13 how how WRB 37231 2258 14 long long RB 37231 2258 15 would would MD 37231 2258 16 be be VB 37231 2258 17 the the DT 37231 2258 18 task task NN 37231 2258 19 of of IN 37231 2258 20 doing do VBG 37231 2258 21 that that DT 37231 2258 22 which which WDT 37231 2258 23 , , , 37231 2258 24 for for IN 37231 2258 25 the the DT 37231 2258 26 completion completion NN 37231 2258 27 of of IN 37231 2258 28 the the DT 37231 2258 29 work work NN 37231 2258 30 , , , 37231 2258 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2258 32 is be VBZ 37231 2258 33 thought think VBN 37231 2258 34 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2258 35 not not RB 37231 2258 36 to to TO 37231 2258 37 do do VB 37231 2258 38 . . . 37231 2259 1 For for IN 37231 2259 2 if if IN 37231 2259 3 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2259 4 desired desire VBD 37231 2259 5 to to TO 37231 2259 6 record record VB 37231 2259 7 merely merely RB 37231 2259 8 the the DT 37231 2259 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2259 10 of of IN 37231 2259 11 healing healing NN 37231 2259 12 , , , 37231 2259 13 without without IN 37231 2259 14 speaking speak VBG 37231 2259 15 of of IN 37231 2259 16 others other NNS 37231 2259 17 , , , 37231 2259 18 which which WDT 37231 2259 19 have have VBP 37231 2259 20 been be VBN 37231 2259 21 performed perform VBN 37231 2259 22 by by IN 37231 2259 23 this this DT 37231 2259 24 martyr martyr NN 37231 2259 25 , , , 37231 2259 26 that that DT 37231 2259 27 is be VBZ 37231 2259 28 to to TO 37231 2259 29 say say VB 37231 2259 30 , , , 37231 2259 31 the the DT 37231 2259 32 most most RBS 37231 2259 33 glorious glorious JJ 37231 2259 34 Stephen Stephen NNP 37231 2259 35 , , , 37231 2259 36 in in IN 37231 2259 37 the the DT 37231 2259 38 district district NN 37231 2259 39 of of IN 37231 2259 40 Calama Calama NNP 37231 2259 41 , , , 37231 2259 42 and and CC 37231 2259 43 in in IN 37231 2259 44 ours our NNS 37231 2259 45 of of IN 37231 2259 46 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2259 47 , , , 37231 2259 48 many many JJ 37231 2259 49 volumes volume NNS 37231 2259 50 must must MD 37231 2259 51 be be VB 37231 2259 52 composed compose VBN 37231 2259 53 , , , 37231 2259 54 yet yet CC 37231 2259 55 will will MD 37231 2259 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2259 57 not not RB 37231 2259 58 be be VB 37231 2259 59 possible possible JJ 37231 2259 60 to to TO 37231 2259 61 make make VB 37231 2259 62 a a DT 37231 2259 63 complete complete JJ 37231 2259 64 collection collection NN 37231 2259 65 of of IN 37231 2259 66 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2259 67 , , , 37231 2259 68 but but CC 37231 2259 69 only only RB 37231 2259 70 of of IN 37231 2259 71 such such JJ 37231 2259 72 as as IN 37231 2259 73 have have VBP 37231 2259 74 been be VBN 37231 2259 75 published publish VBN 37231 2259 76 for for IN 37231 2259 77 public public JJ 37231 2259 78 reading reading NN 37231 2259 79 . . . 37231 2260 1 For for IN 37231 2260 2 that that DT 37231 2260 3 was be VBD 37231 2260 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2260 5 object object NN 37231 2260 6 , , , 37231 2260 7 since since IN 37231 2260 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2260 9 saw see VBD 37231 2260 10 repeated repeat VBN 37231 2260 11 in in IN 37231 2260 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2260 13 time time NN 37231 2260 14 signs sign NNS 37231 2260 15 of of IN 37231 2260 16 divine divine JJ 37231 2260 17 power power NN 37231 2260 18 similar similar JJ 37231 2260 19 to to IN 37231 2260 20 those those DT 37231 2260 21 of of IN 37231 2260 22 old old JJ 37231 2260 23 , , , 37231 2260 24 deeming deem VBG 37231 2260 25 that that IN 37231 2260 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2260 27 ought ought MD 37231 2260 28 not not RB 37231 2260 29 to to TO 37231 2260 30 be be VB 37231 2260 31 lost lose VBN 37231 2260 32 to to IN 37231 2260 33 the the DT 37231 2260 34 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2260 35 of of IN 37231 2260 36 the the DT 37231 2260 37 multitude multitude NN 37231 2260 38 . . . 37231 2261 1 Now now RB 37231 2261 2 this this DT 37231 2261 3 relic relic NN 37231 2261 4 has have VBZ 37231 2261 5 not not RB 37231 2261 6 yet yet RB 37231 2261 7 been be VBN 37231 2261 8 two two CD 37231 2261 9 years year NNS 37231 2261 10 at at IN 37231 2261 11 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2261 12 - - HYPH 37231 2261 13 Regius Regius NNP 37231 2261 14 , , , 37231 2261 15 and and CC 37231 2261 16 accounts account NNS 37231 2261 17 of of IN 37231 2261 18 many many JJ 37231 2261 19 of of IN 37231 2261 20 the the DT 37231 2261 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2261 22 performed perform VBN 37231 2261 23 by by IN 37231 2261 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2261 25 have have VBP 37231 2261 26 not not RB 37231 2261 27 been be VBN 37231 2261 28 written write VBN 37231 2261 29 , , , 37231 2261 30 as as IN 37231 2261 31 is be VBZ 37231 2261 32 most most RBS 37231 2261 33 certainly certainly RB 37231 2261 34 known know VBN 37231 2261 35 to to IN 37231 2261 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2261 37 , , , 37231 2261 38 yet yet CC 37231 2261 39 the the DT 37231 2261 40 number number NN 37231 2261 41 of of IN 37231 2261 42 those those DT 37231 2261 43 which which WDT 37231 2261 44 have have VBP 37231 2261 45 been be VBN 37231 2261 46 published publish VBN 37231 2261 47 , , , 37231 2261 48 up up IN 37231 2261 49 to to IN 37231 2261 50 the the DT 37231 2261 51 time time NN 37231 2261 52 this this DT 37231 2261 53 is be VBZ 37231 2261 54 written write VBN 37231 2261 55 , , , 37231 2261 56 amounts amount VBZ 37231 2261 57 ta ta NNP 37231 2261 58 about about RB 37231 2261 59 seventy seventy CD 37231 2261 60 . . . 37231 2262 1 At at IN 37231 2262 2 Calama Calama NNP 37231 2262 3 , , , 37231 2262 4 however however RB 37231 2262 5 , , , 37231 2262 6 where where WRB 37231 2262 7 these these DT 37231 2262 8 relics relic NNS 37231 2262 9 have have VBP 37231 2262 10 been be VBN 37231 2262 11 longer long RBR 37231 2262 12 , , , 37231 2262 13 and and CC 37231 2262 14 more more JJR 37231 2262 15 of of IN 37231 2262 16 the the DT 37231 2262 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2262 18 were be VBD 37231 2262 19 recorded record VBN 37231 2262 20 , , , 37231 2262 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2262 22 incomparably incomparably RB 37231 2262 23 exceed exceed VBP 37231 2262 24 this this DT 37231 2262 25 number number NN 37231 2262 26 . . . 37231 2263 1 " " `` 37231 2263 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2263 3 1 1 CD 37231 2263 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2263 5 184 184 CD 37231 2263 6 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2263 7 goes go VBZ 37231 2263 8 on on RP 37231 2263 9 to to TO 37231 2263 10 say say VB 37231 2263 11 that that IN 37231 2263 12 , , , 37231 2263 13 to to IN 37231 2263 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2263 15 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2263 16 , , , 37231 2263 17 many many JJ 37231 2263 18 very very RB 37231 2263 19 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 2263 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2263 21 were be VBD 37231 2263 22 performed perform VBN 37231 2263 23 by by IN 37231 2263 24 the the DT 37231 2263 25 relics relic NNS 37231 2263 26 of of IN 37231 2263 27 the the DT 37231 2263 28 same same JJ 37231 2263 29 martyr martyr NN 37231 2263 30 also also RB 37231 2263 31 at at IN 37231 2263 32 Uzali Uzali NNP 37231 2263 33 , , , 37231 2263 34 a a DT 37231 2263 35 district district NN 37231 2263 36 near near RB 37231 2263 37 to to IN 37231 2263 38 Utica Utica NNP 37231 2263 39 , , , 37231 2263 40 and and CC 37231 2263 41 of of IN 37231 2263 42 one one CD 37231 2263 43 of of IN 37231 2263 44 these these DT 37231 2263 45 , , , 37231 2263 46 which which WDT 37231 2263 47 had have VBD 37231 2263 48 recently recently RB 37231 2263 49 taken take VBN 37231 2263 50 place place NN 37231 2263 51 when when WRB 37231 2263 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2263 53 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2263 54 was be VBD 37231 2263 55 there there RB 37231 2263 56 , , , 37231 2263 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2263 58 gives give VBZ 37231 2263 59 an an DT 37231 2263 60 account account NN 37231 2263 61 . . . 37231 2264 1 Then then RB 37231 2264 2 , , , 37231 2264 3 before before IN 37231 2264 4 closing close VBG 37231 2264 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2264 6 list list NN 37231 2264 7 with with IN 37231 2264 8 the the DT 37231 2264 9 narrative narrative NN 37231 2264 10 of of IN 37231 2264 11 a a DT 37231 2264 12 miracle miracle NN 37231 2264 13 which which WDT 37231 2264 14 took take VBD 37231 2264 15 place place NN 37231 2264 16 at at IN 37231 2264 17 Hippo Hippo NNP 37231 2264 18 , , , 37231 2264 19 in in IN 37231 2264 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2264 21 own own JJ 37231 2264 22 church church NN 37231 2264 23 , , , 37231 2264 24 in in IN 37231 2264 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2264 26 own own JJ 37231 2264 27 presence presence NN 37231 2264 28 , , , 37231 2264 29 and and CC 37231 2264 30 in in IN 37231 2264 31 the the DT 37231 2264 32 sight sight NN 37231 2264 33 of of IN 37231 2264 34 the the DT 37231 2264 35 whole whole JJ 37231 2264 36 congregation congregation NN 37231 2264 37 , , , 37231 2264 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 39 resumes resume VBZ 37231 2264 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2264 41 reply reply NN 37231 2264 42 to to IN 37231 2264 43 the the DT 37231 2264 44 opening open VBG 37231 2264 45 question:--"Many question:--"many DT 37231 2264 46 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2264 47 , , , 37231 2264 48 therefore therefore RB 37231 2264 49 , , , 37231 2264 50 " " '' 37231 2264 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 52 says say VBZ 37231 2264 53 , , , 37231 2264 54 " " `` 37231 2264 55 are be VBP 37231 2264 56 also also RB 37231 2264 57 performed perform VBN 37231 2264 58 now now RB 37231 2264 59 , , , 37231 2264 60 the the DT 37231 2264 61 same same JJ 37231 2264 62 God God NNP 37231 2264 63 who who WP 37231 2264 64 worked work VBD 37231 2264 65 those those DT 37231 2264 66 of of IN 37231 2264 67 which which WDT 37231 2264 68 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 69 read read VBP 37231 2264 70 , , , 37231 2264 71 performing perform VBG 37231 2264 72 these these DT 37231 2264 73 by by IN 37231 2264 74 whom whom WP 37231 2264 75 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 76 wills will VBZ 37231 2264 77 and and CC 37231 2264 78 as as IN 37231 2264 79 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 80 wills will VBZ 37231 2264 81 ; ; : 37231 2264 82 but but CC 37231 2264 83 these these DT 37231 2264 84 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2264 85 neither neither CC 37231 2264 86 become become VBP 37231 2264 87 similarly similarly RB 37231 2264 88 known know VBN 37231 2264 89 , , , 37231 2264 90 nor nor CC 37231 2264 91 , , , 37231 2264 92 that that IN 37231 2264 93 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 94 may may MD 37231 2264 95 not not RB 37231 2264 96 slip slip VB 37231 2264 97 out out IN 37231 2264 98 of of IN 37231 2264 99 mind mind NN 37231 2264 100 , , , 37231 2264 101 are be VBP 37231 2264 102 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 103 stamped stamp VBN 37231 2264 104 , , , 37231 2264 105 as as IN 37231 2264 106 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2264 107 were be VBD 37231 2264 108 like like IN 37231 2264 109 gravel gravel NN 37231 2264 110 , , , 37231 2264 111 into into IN 37231 2264 112 memory memory NN 37231 2264 113 , , , 37231 2264 114 by by IN 37231 2264 115 frequent frequent JJ 37231 2264 116 reading reading NN 37231 2264 117 . . . 37231 2265 1 For for IN 37231 2265 2 even even RB 37231 2265 3 in in IN 37231 2265 4 places place NNS 37231 2265 5 where where WRB 37231 2265 6 care care NN 37231 2265 7 is be VBZ 37231 2265 8 taken take VBN 37231 2265 9 , , , 37231 2265 10 as as IN 37231 2265 11 is be VBZ 37231 2265 12 now now RB 37231 2265 13 the the DT 37231 2265 14 case case NN 37231 2265 15 amongst amongst IN 37231 2265 16 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2265 17 , , , 37231 2265 18 that that WDT 37231 2265 19 accounts account VBZ 37231 2265 20 of of IN 37231 2265 21 those those DT 37231 2265 22 who who WP 37231 2265 23 receive receive VBP 37231 2265 24 benefit benefit NN 37231 2265 25 should should MD 37231 2265 26 be be VB 37231 2265 27 publicly publicly RB 37231 2265 28 read read VBN 37231 2265 29 , , , 37231 2265 30 those those DT 37231 2265 31 who who WP 37231 2265 32 are be VBP 37231 2265 33 present present JJ 37231 2265 34 hear hear VBP 37231 2265 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2265 36 only only RB 37231 2265 37 once once RB 37231 2265 38 , , , 37231 2265 39 and and CC 37231 2265 40 many many JJ 37231 2265 41 are be VBP 37231 2265 42 not not RB 37231 2265 43 present present JJ 37231 2265 44 at at RB 37231 2265 45 all all RB 37231 2265 46 , , , 37231 2265 47 so so IN 37231 2265 48 that that IN 37231 2265 49 those those DT 37231 2265 50 who who WP 37231 2265 51 were be VBD 37231 2265 52 present present JJ 37231 2265 53 do do VBP 37231 2265 54 not not RB 37231 2265 55 , , , 37231 2265 56 after after IN 37231 2265 57 a a DT 37231 2265 58 few few JJ 37231 2265 59 days day NNS 37231 2265 60 , , , 37231 2265 61 remember remember VB 37231 2265 62 { { -LRB- 37231 2265 63 185 185 CD 37231 2265 64 } } -RRB- 37231 2265 65 what what WP 37231 2265 66 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2265 67 heard hear VBD 37231 2265 68 , , , 37231 2265 69 and and CC 37231 2265 70 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2265 71 a a DT 37231 2265 72 single single JJ 37231 2265 73 person person NN 37231 2265 74 is be VBZ 37231 2265 75 met meet VBN 37231 2265 76 with with IN 37231 2265 77 who who WP 37231 2265 78 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 2265 79 what what WP 37231 2265 80 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2265 81 has have VBZ 37231 2265 82 heard hear VBN 37231 2265 83 to to IN 37231 2265 84 one one CD 37231 2265 85 whom whom WP 37231 2265 86 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2265 87 may may MD 37231 2265 88 have have VB 37231 2265 89 known know VBN 37231 2265 90 to to TO 37231 2265 91 have have VB 37231 2265 92 been be VBN 37231 2265 93 absent"(1 absent"(1 NNP 37231 2265 94 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2265 95 So so RB 37231 2265 96 far far RB 37231 2265 97 from from IN 37231 2265 98 casting cast VBG 37231 2265 99 doubt doubt NN 37231 2265 100 upon upon IN 37231 2265 101 the the DT 37231 2265 102 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2265 103 which which WDT 37231 2265 104 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2265 105 narrates narrate VBZ 37231 2265 106 , , , 37231 2265 107 the the DT 37231 2265 108 " " `` 37231 2265 109 Preface Preface NNP 37231 2265 110 " " '' 37231 2265 111 of of IN 37231 2265 112 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2265 113 is be VBZ 37231 2265 114 clearly clearly RB 37231 2265 115 intended intend VBN 37231 2265 116 to to TO 37231 2265 117 establish establish VB 37231 2265 118 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2265 119 . . . 37231 2266 1 These these DT 37231 2266 2 " " `` 37231 2266 3 signs sign NNS 37231 2266 4 of of IN 37231 2266 5 divine divine JJ 37231 2266 6 power power NN 37231 2266 7 similar similar JJ 37231 2266 8 to to IN 37231 2266 9 those those DT 37231 2266 10 of of IN 37231 2266 11 old old JJ 37231 2266 12 , , , 37231 2266 13 " " `` 37231 2266 14 are be VBP 37231 2266 15 not not RB 37231 2266 16 less less RBR 37231 2266 17 real real JJ 37231 2266 18 and and CC 37231 2266 19 important important JJ 37231 2266 20 , , , 37231 2266 21 but but CC 37231 2266 22 merely merely RB 37231 2266 23 less less RBR 37231 2266 24 known known JJ 37231 2266 25 , , , 37231 2266 26 because because IN 37231 2266 27 the the DT 37231 2266 28 eyes eye NNS 37231 2266 29 of of IN 37231 2266 30 the the DT 37231 2266 31 world world NN 37231 2266 32 are be VBP 37231 2266 33 not not RB 37231 2266 34 directed direct VBN 37231 2266 35 to to IN 37231 2266 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2266 37 , , , 37231 2266 38 and and CC 37231 2266 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2266 40 have have VBP 37231 2266 41 not not RB 37231 2266 42 the the DT 37231 2266 43 advantage advantage NN 37231 2266 44 of of IN 37231 2266 45 being be VBG 37231 2266 46 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 2266 47 published publish VBN 37231 2266 48 abroad abroad RB 37231 2266 49 by by IN 37231 2266 50 means mean NNS 37231 2266 51 of of IN 37231 2266 52 canonical canonical JJ 37231 2266 53 scriptures scripture NNS 37231 2266 54 constantly constantly RB 37231 2266 55 read read VBD 37231 2266 56 to to IN 37231 2266 57 the the DT 37231 2266 58 people people NNS 37231 2266 59 and and CC 37231 2266 60 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 37231 2266 61 as as IN 37231 2266 62 authoritative authoritative JJ 37231 2266 63 . . . 37231 2267 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2267 2 Mozleys Mozleys NNP 37231 2267 3 statement statement NN 37231 2267 4 is be VBZ 37231 2267 5 quite quite RB 37231 2267 6 unwarranted unwarranted JJ 37231 2267 7 , , , 37231 2267 8 and and CC 37231 2267 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2267 10 seems seem VBZ 37231 2267 11 to to IN 37231 2267 12 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2267 13 gratuitously gratuitously RB 37231 2267 14 injurious injurious JJ 37231 2267 15 to to IN 37231 2267 16 St. St. NNP 37231 2267 17 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2267 18 . . . 37231 2268 1 This this DT 37231 2268 2 Father Father NNP 37231 2268 3 of of IN 37231 2268 4 the the DT 37231 2268 5 Church Church NNP 37231 2268 6 and and CC 37231 2268 7 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2268 8 must must MD 37231 2268 9 have have VB 37231 2268 10 had have VBN 37231 2268 11 as as RB 37231 2268 12 little little JJ 37231 2268 13 good good JJ 37231 2268 14 faith faith NN 37231 2268 15 as as IN 37231 2268 16 good good JJ 37231 2268 17 sense sense NN 37231 2268 18 , , , 37231 2268 19 if if IN 37231 2268 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2268 21 did do VBD 37231 2268 22 what what WP 37231 2268 23 such such PDT 37231 2268 24 a a DT 37231 2268 25 statement statement NN 37231 2268 26 implies imply VBZ 37231 2268 27 . . . 37231 2269 1 In in IN 37231 2269 2 order order NN 37231 2269 3 to to TO 37231 2269 4 demonstate demonstate VB 37231 2269 5 the the DT 37231 2269 6 truth truth NN 37231 2269 7 of of IN 37231 2269 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2269 9 assertion assertion NN 37231 2269 10 that that IN 37231 2269 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2269 12 were be VBD 37231 2269 13 still still RB 37231 2269 14 performed perform VBN 37231 2269 15 in in IN 37231 2269 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2269 17 day day NN 37231 2269 18 , , , 37231 2269 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2269 20 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2269 21 represents represent VBZ 37231 2269 22 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2269 23 as as RB 37231 2269 24 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 2269 25 producing produce VBG 37231 2269 26 a a DT 37231 2269 27 long long JJ 37231 2269 28 list list NN 37231 2269 29 of of IN 37231 2269 30 instances instance NNS 37231 2269 31 of of IN 37231 2269 32 which which WDT 37231 2269 33 " " `` 37231 2269 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2269 35 can can MD 37231 2269 36 not not RB 37231 2269 37 even even RB 37231 2269 38 be be VB 37231 2269 39 said say VBN 37231 2269 40 to to TO 37231 2269 41 guarantee guarantee VB 37231 2269 42 the the DT 37231 2269 43 truth truth NN 37231 2269 44 , , , 37231 2269 45 " " '' 37231 2269 46 and and CC 37231 2269 47 the the DT 37231 2269 48 more more RBR 37231 2269 49 important important JJ 37231 2269 50 cases case NNS 37231 2269 51 in in IN 37231 2269 52 which which WDT 37231 2269 53 " " `` 37231 2269 54 evidently evidently RB 37231 2269 55 represent represent VBP 37231 2269 56 no no DT 37231 2269 57 more more JJR 37231 2269 58 than than IN 37231 2269 59 mere mere JJ 37231 2269 60 report report NN 37231 2269 61 , , , 37231 2269 62 and and CC 37231 2269 63 report report NN 37231 2269 64 of of IN 37231 2269 65 a a DT 37231 2269 66 very very RB 37231 2269 67 vague vague JJ 37231 2269 68 kind kind NN 37231 2269 69 . . . 37231 2269 70 " " '' 37231 2270 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2270 2 have have VBP 37231 2270 3 furnished furnish VBN 37231 2270 4 the the DT 37231 2270 5 reader reader NN 37231 2270 6 with with IN 37231 2270 7 the the DT 37231 2270 8 materials material NNS 37231 2270 9 for for IN 37231 2270 10 forming form VBG 37231 2270 11 an an DT 37231 2270 12 opinion opinion NN 37231 2270 13 on on IN 37231 2270 14 these these DT 37231 2270 15 points point NNS 37231 2270 16 . . . 37231 2271 1 The the DT 37231 2271 2 judgment judgment NN 37231 2271 3 of of IN 37231 2271 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2271 5 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2271 6 may may MD 37231 2271 7 with with IN 37231 2271 8 equal equal JJ 37231 2271 9 justice justice NN 37231 2271 10 be be VB 37231 2271 11 applied apply VBN 37231 2271 12 to to IN 37231 2271 13 { { -LRB- 37231 2271 14 186 186 CD 37231 2271 15 } } -RRB- 37231 2271 16 the the DT 37231 2271 17 authors author NNS 37231 2271 18 of of IN 37231 2271 19 the the DT 37231 2271 20 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2271 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2271 22 . . . 37231 2272 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 2272 2 certainly certainly RB 37231 2272 3 do do VBP 37231 2272 4 not not RB 37231 2272 5 guarantee guarantee VB 37231 2272 6 the the DT 37231 2272 7 truth truth NN 37231 2272 8 of of IN 37231 2272 9 the the DT 37231 2272 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2272 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2272 12 relate relate VBP 37231 2272 13 in in IN 37231 2272 14 any any DT 37231 2272 15 more more RBR 37231 2272 16 precise precise JJ 37231 2272 17 way way NN 37231 2272 18 than than IN 37231 2272 19 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2272 20 . . . 37231 2273 1 Like like IN 37231 2273 2 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2273 3 , , , 37231 2273 4 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2273 5 merely merely RB 37231 2273 6 narrate narrate VBP 37231 2273 7 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2273 8 as as IN 37231 2273 9 facts fact NNS 37231 2273 10 , , , 37231 2273 11 and and CC 37231 2273 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2273 13 as as RB 37231 2273 14 evidently evidently RB 37231 2273 15 believes believe VBZ 37231 2273 16 what what WP 37231 2273 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2273 18 states state VBZ 37231 2273 19 as as IN 37231 2273 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2273 21 do do VBP 37231 2273 22 . . . 37231 2274 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 2274 2 , , , 37231 2274 3 as as IN 37231 2274 4 regards regard VBZ 37231 2274 5 comparative comparative JJ 37231 2274 6 fulness fulness NN 37231 2274 7 of of IN 37231 2274 8 testimony testimony NN 37231 2274 9 , , , 37231 2274 10 the the DT 37231 2274 11 advantage advantage NN 37231 2274 12 is be VBZ 37231 2274 13 altogether altogether RB 37231 2274 14 on on IN 37231 2274 15 the the DT 37231 2274 16 side side NN 37231 2274 17 of of IN 37231 2274 18 the the DT 37231 2274 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2274 20 reported report VBN 37231 2274 21 by by IN 37231 2274 22 St. St. NNP 37231 2274 23 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2274 24 . . . 37231 2275 1 These these DT 37231 2275 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2275 3 occurred occur VBD 37231 2275 4 within within IN 37231 2275 5 two two CD 37231 2275 6 years year NNS 37231 2275 7 of of IN 37231 2275 8 the the DT 37231 2275 9 time time NN 37231 2275 10 at at IN 37231 2275 11 which which WDT 37231 2275 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 13 wrote write VBD 37231 2275 14 , , , 37231 2275 15 and and CC 37231 2275 16 were be VBD 37231 2275 17 at at IN 37231 2275 18 once once RB 37231 2275 19 recorded record VBN 37231 2275 20 with with IN 37231 2275 21 the the DT 37231 2275 22 names name NNS 37231 2275 23 of of IN 37231 2275 24 the the DT 37231 2275 25 subjects subject NNS 37231 2275 26 and and CC 37231 2275 27 of of IN 37231 2275 28 the the DT 37231 2275 29 places place NNS 37231 2275 30 at at IN 37231 2275 31 which which WDT 37231 2275 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 33 occurred occur VBD 37231 2275 34 ; ; : 37231 2275 35 most most JJS 37231 2275 36 of of IN 37231 2275 37 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 38 were be VBD 37231 2275 39 performed perform VBN 37231 2275 40 in in IN 37231 2275 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2275 42 own own JJ 37231 2275 43 diocese diocese NN 37231 2275 44 , , , 37231 2275 45 and and CC 37231 2275 46 several several JJ 37231 2275 47 of of IN 37231 2275 48 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 49 in in IN 37231 2275 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2275 51 own own JJ 37231 2275 52 presence presence NN 37231 2275 53 ; ; : 37231 2275 54 some some DT 37231 2275 55 , , , 37231 2275 56 of of IN 37231 2275 57 which which WDT 37231 2275 58 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 59 apparently apparently RB 37231 2275 60 did do VBD 37231 2275 61 not not RB 37231 2275 62 feel feel VB 37231 2275 63 sure sure JJ 37231 2275 64 , , , 37231 2275 65 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 66 personally personally RB 37231 2275 67 investigated investigate VBD 37231 2275 68 ; ; : 37231 2275 69 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 70 states state VBZ 37231 2275 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2275 72 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2275 73 of of IN 37231 2275 74 others other NNS 37231 2275 75 , , , 37231 2275 76 and and CC 37231 2275 77 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 78 narrates narrate VBZ 37231 2275 79 the the DT 37231 2275 80 whole whole NN 37231 2275 81 of of IN 37231 2275 82 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2275 83 with with IN 37231 2275 84 the the DT 37231 2275 85 most most RBS 37231 2275 86 direct direct JJ 37231 2275 87 and and CC 37231 2275 88 simple simple JJ 37231 2275 89 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 2275 90 of of IN 37231 2275 91 the the DT 37231 2275 92 facts fact NNS 37231 2275 93 , , , 37231 2275 94 without without IN 37231 2275 95 a a DT 37231 2275 96 single single JJ 37231 2275 97 word word NN 37231 2275 98 indicating indicate VBG 37231 2275 99 hesitation hesitation NN 37231 2275 100 , , , 37231 2275 101 or or CC 37231 2275 102 directly directly RB 37231 2275 103 or or CC 37231 2275 104 indirectly indirectly RB 37231 2275 105 attributing attribute VBG 37231 2275 106 the the DT 37231 2275 107 narrative narrative NN 37231 2275 108 to to IN 37231 2275 109 mere mere JJ 37231 2275 110 report report NN 37231 2275 111 . . . 37231 2276 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 2276 2 , , , 37231 2276 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2276 4 not not RB 37231 2276 5 only only RB 37231 2276 6 advances advance VBZ 37231 2276 7 these these DT 37231 2276 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2276 9 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 2276 10 and and CC 37231 2276 11 in in IN 37231 2276 12 writing writing NN 37231 2276 13 , , , 37231 2276 14 in in IN 37231 2276 15 support support NN 37231 2276 16 of of IN 37231 2276 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2276 18 positive positive JJ 37231 2276 19 assertion assertion NN 37231 2276 20 that that IN 37231 2276 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2276 22 were be VBD 37231 2276 23 still still RB 37231 2276 24 performed perform VBN 37231 2276 25 , , , 37231 2276 26 but but CC 37231 2276 27 these these DT 37231 2276 28 accounts account NNS 37231 2276 29 of of IN 37231 2276 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2276 31 had have VBD 37231 2276 32 in in IN 37231 2276 33 the the DT 37231 2276 34 first first JJ 37231 2276 35 instance instance NN 37231 2276 36 been be VBN 37231 2276 37 written write VBN 37231 2276 38 that that IN 37231 2276 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2276 40 might may MD 37231 2276 41 be be VB 37231 2276 42 publicly publicly RB 37231 2276 43 read read VBN 37231 2276 44 in in IN 37231 2276 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2276 46 own own JJ 37231 2276 47 church church NN 37231 2276 48 for for IN 37231 2276 49 the the DT 37231 2276 50 edification edification NN 37231 2276 51 of of IN 37231 2276 52 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2276 53 , , , 37231 2276 54 almost almost RB 37231 2276 55 on on IN 37231 2276 56 the the DT 37231 2276 57 very very JJ 37231 2276 58 spot spot NN 37231 2276 59 where where WRB 37231 2276 60 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2276 61 are be VBP 37231 2276 62 stated state VBN 37231 2276 63 to to TO 37231 2276 64 have have VB 37231 2276 65 occurred occur VBN 37231 2276 66 . . . 37231 2277 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 2 need need VBP 37231 2277 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2277 4 say say VB 37231 2277 5 that that IN 37231 2277 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 7 do do VBP 37231 2277 8 not not RB 37231 2277 9 advance advance VB 37231 2277 10 these these DT 37231 2277 11 reasons reason NNS 37231 2277 12 in in IN 37231 2277 13 order order NN 37231 2277 14 to to TO 37231 2277 15 argue argue VB 37231 2277 16 the the DT 37231 2277 17 reality reality NN 37231 2277 18 of of IN 37231 2277 19 the the DT 37231 2277 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2277 21 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 22 , , , 37231 2277 23 but but CC 37231 2277 24 simply simply RB 37231 2277 25 to to TO 37231 2277 26 maintain maintain VB 37231 2277 27 that that DT 37231 2277 28 , , , 37231 2277 29 so so RB 37231 2277 30 far far RB 37231 2277 31 from from IN 37231 2277 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2277 33 giving give VBG 37231 2277 34 the the DT 37231 2277 35 account account NN 37231 2277 36 of of IN 37231 2277 37 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 38 as as IN 37231 2277 39 mere mere JJ 37231 2277 40 report report NN 37231 2277 41 , , , 37231 2277 42 or or CC 37231 2277 43 not not RB 37231 2277 44 even even RB 37231 2277 45 professing profess VBG 37231 2277 46 to to IN 37231 2277 47 vouch vouch VB 37231 2277 48 for for IN 37231 2277 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2277 50 truth truth NN 37231 2277 51 , , , 37231 2277 52 St. St. NNP 37231 2277 53 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2277 54 both both DT 37231 2277 55 believed believe VBD 37231 2277 56 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 57 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 58 , , , 37231 2277 59 and and CC 37231 2277 60 asked ask VBD 37231 2277 61 others other NNS 37231 2277 62 to to TO 37231 2277 63 believe believe VB 37231 2277 64 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 65 as as IN 37231 2277 66 facts fact NNS 37231 2277 67 , , , 37231 2277 68 and and CC 37231 2277 69 that that IN 37231 2277 70 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2277 71 are be VBP 37231 2277 72 as as RB 37231 2277 73 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 37231 2277 74 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 2277 75 as as IN 37231 2277 76 any any DT 37231 2277 77 related related JJ 37231 2277 78 in in IN 37231 2277 79 the the DT 37231 2277 80 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2277 81 . . . 37231 2278 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2278 2 187 187 CD 37231 2278 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2278 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2278 5 shall shall MD 37231 2278 6 not not RB 37231 2278 7 attempt attempt VB 37231 2278 8 any any DT 37231 2278 9 further further RB 37231 2278 10 detailed detailed JJ 37231 2278 11 reference reference NN 37231 2278 12 to to IN 37231 2278 13 the the DT 37231 2278 14 myriads myriad NNS 37231 2278 15 of of IN 37231 2278 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2278 17 with with IN 37231 2278 18 which which WDT 37231 2278 19 the the DT 37231 2278 20 annals annal NNS 37231 2278 21 of of IN 37231 2278 22 the the DT 37231 2278 23 Church Church NNP 37231 2278 24 teem teem VBP 37231 2278 25 up up RP 37231 2278 26 to to IN 37231 2278 27 very very RB 37231 2278 28 recent recent JJ 37231 2278 29 times time NNS 37231 2278 30 . . . 37231 2279 1 The the DT 37231 2279 2 fact fact NN 37231 2279 3 is be VBZ 37231 2279 4 too too RB 37231 2279 5 well well RB 37231 2279 6 known known JJ 37231 2279 7 to to TO 37231 2279 8 require require VB 37231 2279 9 evidence evidence NN 37231 2279 10 . . . 37231 2280 1 The the DT 37231 2280 2 saints saint NNS 37231 2280 3 in in IN 37231 2280 4 the the DT 37231 2280 5 Calendar Calendar NNP 37231 2280 6 are be VBP 37231 2280 7 legion legion NNP 37231 2280 8 . . . 37231 2281 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2281 2 has have VBZ 37231 2281 3 been be VBN 37231 2281 4 computed compute VBN 37231 2281 5 that that IN 37231 2281 6 the the DT 37231 2281 7 number number NN 37231 2281 8 of of IN 37231 2281 9 those those DT 37231 2281 10 whose whose WP$ 37231 2281 11 lives life NNS 37231 2281 12 are be VBP 37231 2281 13 given give VBN 37231 2281 14 in in IN 37231 2281 15 the the DT 37231 2281 16 Bollandist Bollandist NNP 37231 2281 17 Collection(1 collection(1 NN 37231 2281 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2281 19 amounts amount VBZ 37231 2281 20 to to IN 37231 2281 21 upwards upward NNS 37231 2281 22 of of IN 37231 2281 23 25,000 25,000 CD 37231 2281 24 , , , 37231 2281 25 although although IN 37231 2281 26 , , , 37231 2281 27 the the DT 37231 2281 28 saints saint NNS 37231 2281 29 being be VBG 37231 2281 30 arranged arrange VBN 37231 2281 31 according accord VBG 37231 2281 32 to to IN 37231 2281 33 the the DT 37231 2281 34 Calendar Calendar NNP 37231 2281 35 , , , 37231 2281 36 the the DT 37231 2281 37 unfinished unfinished JJ 37231 2281 38 work work NN 37231 2281 39 only only RB 37231 2281 40 reaches reach VBZ 37231 2281 41 the the DT 37231 2281 42 twenty twenty CD 37231 2281 43 - - HYPH 37231 2281 44 fourth fourth NN 37231 2281 45 of of IN 37231 2281 46 October October NNP 37231 2281 47 . . . 37231 2282 1 When when WRB 37231 2282 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2282 3 is be VBZ 37231 2282 4 considered consider VBN 37231 2282 5 that that IN 37231 2282 6 all all PDT 37231 2282 7 those those DT 37231 2282 8 upon upon IN 37231 2282 9 whom whom WP 37231 2282 10 the the DT 37231 2282 11 honour honour NN 37231 2282 12 of of IN 37231 2282 13 canonization canonization NN 37231 2282 14 is be VBZ 37231 2282 15 conferred confer VBN 37231 2282 16 have have VBP 37231 2282 17 worked work VBN 37231 2282 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2282 19 , , , 37231 2282 20 many many JJ 37231 2282 21 of of IN 37231 2282 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2282 23 , , , 37231 2282 24 indeed indeed RB 37231 2282 25 , , , 37231 2282 26 almost almost RB 37231 2282 27 daily daily RB 37231 2282 28 performing perform VBG 37231 2282 29 such such JJ 37231 2282 30 wonders wonder NNS 37231 2282 31 , , , 37231 2282 32 some some DT 37231 2282 33 idea idea NN 37231 2282 34 may may MD 37231 2282 35 be be VB 37231 2282 36 formed form VBN 37231 2282 37 of of IN 37231 2282 38 the the DT 37231 2282 39 number number NN 37231 2282 40 of of IN 37231 2282 41 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2282 42 which which WDT 37231 2282 43 have have VBP 37231 2282 44 occurred occur VBN 37231 2282 45 in in IN 37231 2282 46 unbroken unbroken JJ 37231 2282 47 succession succession NN 37231 2282 48 from from IN 37231 2282 49 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 2282 50 days day NNS 37231 2282 51 , , , 37231 2282 52 and and CC 37231 2282 53 have have VBP 37231 2282 54 been be VBN 37231 2282 55 believed believe VBN 37231 2282 56 and and CC 37231 2282 57 recognized recognize VBN 37231 2282 58 by by IN 37231 2282 59 the the DT 37231 2282 60 Church Church NNP 37231 2282 61 . . . 37231 2283 1 Vast vast JJ 37231 2283 2 numbers number NNS 37231 2283 3 of of IN 37231 2283 4 these these DT 37231 2283 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2283 6 are be VBP 37231 2283 7 in in IN 37231 2283 8 all all DT 37231 2283 9 respects respect NNS 37231 2283 10 similar similar JJ 37231 2283 11 to to IN 37231 2283 12 those those DT 37231 2283 13 narrated narrate VBN 37231 2283 14 in in IN 37231 2283 15 the the DT 37231 2283 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2283 17 , , , 37231 2283 18 and and CC 37231 2283 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2283 20 comprise comprise VBP 37231 2283 21 hundreds hundred NNS 37231 2283 22 of of IN 37231 2283 23 cases case NNS 37231 2283 24 of of IN 37231 2283 25 restoration restoration NN 37231 2283 26 of of IN 37231 2283 27 the the DT 37231 2283 28 dead dead NN 37231 2283 29 to to IN 37231 2283 30 life life NN 37231 2283 31 . . . 37231 2284 1 If if IN 37231 2284 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2284 3 be be VBP 37231 2284 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2284 5 to to TO 37231 2284 6 point point VB 37231 2284 7 out out RP 37231 2284 8 instances instance NNS 37231 2284 9 in in IN 37231 2284 10 comparatively comparatively RB 37231 2284 11 recent recent JJ 37231 2284 12 times time NNS 37231 2284 13 , , , 37231 2284 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2284 15 may may MD 37231 2284 16 mention mention VB 37231 2284 17 the the DT 37231 2284 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2284 19 of of IN 37231 2284 20 this this DT 37231 2284 21 kind kind NN 37231 2284 22 liberally liberally RB 37231 2284 23 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2284 24 to to IN 37231 2284 25 St St NNP 37231 2284 26 Francis Francis NNP 37231 2284 27 of of IN 37231 2284 28 Assisi Assisi NNP 37231 2284 29 , , , 37231 2284 30 in in IN 37231 2284 31 the the DT 37231 2284 32 13th 13th JJ 37231 2284 33 century century NN 37231 2284 34 , , , 37231 2284 35 and and CC 37231 2284 36 to to IN 37231 2284 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2284 38 namesake namesake JJ 37231 2284 39 St. St. NNP 37231 2284 40 Francis Francis NNP 37231 2284 41 Xavier Xavier NNP 37231 2284 42 , , , 37231 2284 43 in in IN 37231 2284 44 the the DT 37231 2284 45 16th 16th NN 37231 2284 46 , , , 37231 2284 47 as as IN 37231 2284 48 pretty pretty RB 37231 2284 49 well well RB 37231 2284 50 known known JJ 37231 2284 51 to to IN 37231 2284 52 all all DT 37231 2284 53 , , , 37231 2284 54 although although IN 37231 2284 55 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2284 56 might may MD 37231 2284 57 refer refer VB 37231 2284 58 to to IN 37231 2284 59 much much RB 37231 2284 60 more more RBR 37231 2284 61 recent recent JJ 37231 2284 62 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2284 63 authenticated authenticate VBN 37231 2284 64 by by IN 37231 2284 65 the the DT 37231 2284 66 Church Church NNP 37231 2284 67 . . . 37231 2285 1 At at IN 37231 2285 2 the the DT 37231 2285 3 present present JJ 37231 2285 4 day day NN 37231 2285 5 such such JJ 37231 2285 6 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2285 7 have have VBP 37231 2285 8 almost almost RB 37231 2285 9 disappeared disappear VBN 37231 2285 10 , , , 37231 2285 11 and and CC 37231 2285 12 , , , 37231 2285 13 indeed indeed RB 37231 2285 14 , , , 37231 2285 15 with with IN 37231 2285 16 the the DT 37231 2285 17 exception exception NN 37231 2285 18 of of IN 37231 2285 19 an an DT 37231 2285 20 occasional occasional JJ 37231 2285 21 winking winking NN 37231 2285 22 picture picture NN 37231 2285 23 , , , 37231 2285 24 periodical periodical JJ 37231 2285 25 liquefaction liquefaction NN 37231 2285 26 of of IN 37231 2285 27 blood blood NN 37231 2285 28 , , , 37231 2285 29 or or CC 37231 2285 30 apparition apparition NN 37231 2285 31 of of IN 37231 2285 32 the the DT 37231 2285 33 Virgin Virgin NNP 37231 2285 34 , , , 37231 2285 35 confined confine VBN 37231 2285 36 to to IN 37231 2285 37 the the DT 37231 2285 38 still still RB 37231 2285 39 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 2285 40 and and CC 37231 2285 41 benighted benighted JJ 37231 2285 42 corners corner NNS 37231 2285 43 of of IN 37231 2285 44 the the DT 37231 2285 45 earth earth NN 37231 2285 46 , , , 37231 2285 47 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2285 48 are be VBP 37231 2285 49 extinct extinct JJ 37231 2285 50 . . . 37231 2286 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2286 2 188 188 CD 37231 2286 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2286 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 2286 5 VI VI NNP 37231 2286 6 . . . 37231 2287 1 MIRACLES miracle NNS 37231 2287 2 IN in IN 37231 2287 3 RELATION relation NN 37231 2287 4 TO to IN 37231 2287 5 IGNORANCE IGNORANCE NNP 37231 2287 6 AND and CC 37231 2287 7 SUPERSTITION SUPERSTITION NNP 37231 2287 8 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2287 9 have have VBP 37231 2287 10 maintained maintain VBN 37231 2287 11 that that IN 37231 2287 12 the the DT 37231 2287 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2287 14 which which WDT 37231 2287 15 are be VBP 37231 2287 16 reported report VBN 37231 2287 17 after after IN 37231 2287 18 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 2287 19 days day NNS 37231 2287 20 , , , 37231 2287 21 instead instead RB 37231 2287 22 of of IN 37231 2287 23 presenting present VBG 37231 2287 24 the the DT 37231 2287 25 enormous enormous JJ 37231 2287 26 distinction distinction NN 37231 2287 27 which which WDT 37231 2287 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2287 29 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2287 30 asserts assert VBZ 37231 2287 31 , , , 37231 2287 32 are be VBP 37231 2287 33 precisely precisely RB 37231 2287 34 of of IN 37231 2287 35 the the DT 37231 2287 36 same same JJ 37231 2287 37 types type NNS 37231 2287 38 in in IN 37231 2287 39 all all DT 37231 2287 40 material material JJ 37231 2287 41 points point NNS 37231 2287 42 as as IN 37231 2287 43 the the DT 37231 2287 44 earlier early JJR 37231 2287 45 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2287 46 . . . 37231 2288 1 Setting set VBG 37231 2288 2 aside aside RP 37231 2288 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2288 4 of of IN 37231 2288 5 a a DT 37231 2288 6 trivial trivial JJ 37231 2288 7 and and CC 37231 2288 8 unworthy unworthy JJ 37231 2288 9 character character NN 37231 2288 10 , , , 37231 2288 11 there there EX 37231 2288 12 remains remain VBZ 37231 2288 13 a a DT 37231 2288 14 countless countless JJ 37231 2288 15 number number NN 37231 2288 16 cast cast VBN 37231 2288 17 in in IN 37231 2288 18 the the DT 37231 2288 19 same same JJ 37231 2288 20 mould mould NN 37231 2288 21 as as IN 37231 2288 22 those those DT 37231 2288 23 of of IN 37231 2288 24 the the DT 37231 2288 25 Gospels,--miraculous gospels,--miraculous JJ 37231 2288 26 cure cure NN 37231 2288 27 of of IN 37231 2288 28 diseases disease NNS 37231 2288 29 , , , 37231 2288 30 expulsion expulsion NN 37231 2288 31 of of IN 37231 2288 32 demons demon NNS 37231 2288 33 , , , 37231 2288 34 transformation transformation NN 37231 2288 35 of of IN 37231 2288 36 elements element NNS 37231 2288 37 , , , 37231 2288 38 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2288 39 nourishment nourishment NN 37231 2288 40 , , , 37231 2288 41 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 2288 42 of of IN 37231 2288 43 dead dead JJ 37231 2288 44 -- -- : 37231 2288 45 of of IN 37231 2288 46 many many JJ 37231 2288 47 of of IN 37231 2288 48 which which WDT 37231 2288 49 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2288 50 have have VBP 37231 2288 51 quoted quote VBN 37231 2288 52 instances instance NNS 37231 2288 53 . . . 37231 2289 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2289 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2289 3 anticipates anticipate VBZ 37231 2289 4 an an DT 37231 2289 5 objection objection NN 37231 2289 6 and and CC 37231 2289 7 says say VBZ 37231 2289 8 : : : 37231 2289 9 " " `` 37231 2289 10 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2289 11 will will MD 37231 2289 12 be be VB 37231 2289 13 urged urge VBN 37231 2289 14 , , , 37231 2289 15 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 2289 16 , , , 37231 2289 17 that that IN 37231 2289 18 a a DT 37231 2289 19 large large JJ 37231 2289 20 portion portion NN 37231 2289 21 even even RB 37231 2289 22 of of IN 37231 2289 23 the the DT 37231 2289 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2289 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2289 26 are be VBP 37231 2289 27 of of IN 37231 2289 28 the the DT 37231 2289 29 class class NN 37231 2289 30 here here RB 37231 2289 31 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2289 32 as as IN 37231 2289 33 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 37231 2289 34 ; ; : 37231 2289 35 cures cure NNS 37231 2289 36 , , , 37231 2289 37 visions vision NNS 37231 2289 38 , , , 37231 2289 39 expulsions expulsion NNS 37231 2289 40 of of IN 37231 2289 41 evil evil JJ 37231 2289 42 spirits spirit NNS 37231 2289 43 ; ; : 37231 2289 44 but but CC 37231 2289 45 this this DT 37231 2289 46 observation observation NN 37231 2289 47 does do VBZ 37231 2289 48 not not RB 37231 2289 49 affect affect VB 37231 2289 50 the the DT 37231 2289 51 character character NN 37231 2289 52 of of IN 37231 2289 53 the the DT 37231 2289 54 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2289 55 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2289 56 as as IN 37231 2289 57 a a DT 37231 2289 58 body body NN 37231 2289 59 , , , 37231 2289 60 because because IN 37231 2289 61 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2289 62 judge judge VBP 37231 2289 63 of of IN 37231 2289 64 the the DT 37231 2289 65 body body NN 37231 2289 66 or or CC 37231 2289 67 whole whole NN 37231 2289 68 from from IN 37231 2289 69 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2289 70 highest high JJS 37231 2289 71 specimen speciman NNS 37231 2289 72 , , , 37231 2289 73 not not RB 37231 2289 74 from from IN 37231 2289 75 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2289 76 lowest low JJS 37231 2289 77 . . . 37231 2289 78 " " '' 37231 2290 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2290 2 takes take VBZ 37231 2290 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2290 4 stand stand NN 37231 2290 5 upon upon IN 37231 2290 6 , , , 37231 2290 7 " " '' 37231 2290 8 e.g. e.g. RB 37231 2291 1 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2291 2 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2291 3 's 's POS 37231 2291 4 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 2291 5 and and CC 37231 2291 6 Ascension ascension NN 37231 2291 7 . . . 37231 2292 1 " " `` 37231 2292 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2292 3 1 1 CD 37231 2292 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2292 5 Now now RB 37231 2292 6 , , , 37231 2292 7 without without IN 37231 2292 8 discussing discuss VBG 37231 2292 9 the the DT 37231 2292 10 principle principle NN 37231 2292 11 laid lay VBN 37231 2292 12 down down RP 37231 2292 13 here here RB 37231 2292 14 , , , 37231 2292 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2292 16 is be VBZ 37231 2292 17 evident evident JJ 37231 2292 18 that that IN 37231 2292 19 the the DT 37231 2292 20 great great JJ 37231 2292 21 distinction distinction NN 37231 2292 22 between between IN 37231 2292 23 the the DT 37231 2292 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2292 25 and and CC 37231 2292 26 other other JJ 37231 2292 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2292 28 is be VBZ 37231 2292 29 thus thus RB 37231 2292 30 narrowed narrow VBN 37231 2292 31 to to IN 37231 2292 32 a a DT 37231 2292 33 very very RB 37231 2292 34 small small JJ 37231 2292 35 compass compass NN 37231 2292 36 . . . 37231 2293 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2293 2 is be VBZ 37231 2293 3 admitted admit VBN 37231 2293 4 that that IN 37231 2293 5 the the DT 37231 2293 6 mass mass NN 37231 2293 7 of of IN 37231 2293 8 the the DT 37231 2293 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2293 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2293 11 are be VBP 37231 2293 12 of of IN 37231 2293 13 a a DT 37231 2293 14 class class NN 37231 2293 15 characterized characterize VBN 37231 2293 16 as as IN 37231 2293 17 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 37231 2293 18 , , , 37231 2293 19 because because IN 37231 2293 20 " " `` 37231 2293 21 the the DT 37231 2293 22 current current JJ 37231 2293 23 { { -LRB- 37231 2293 24 189 189 CD 37231 2293 25 } } -RRB- 37231 2293 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2293 27 of of IN 37231 2293 28 human human JJ 37231 2293 29 history history NN 37231 2293 30 " " '' 37231 2293 31 are be VBP 37231 2293 32 also also RB 37231 2293 33 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 2293 34 of of IN 37231 2293 35 the the DT 37231 2293 36 same same JJ 37231 2293 37 type type NN 37231 2293 38 , , , 37231 2293 39 and and CC 37231 2293 40 the the DT 37231 2293 41 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 2293 42 character character NN 37231 2293 43 is be VBZ 37231 2293 44 derived derive VBN 37231 2293 45 avowedly avowedly RB 37231 2293 46 only only RB 37231 2293 47 from from IN 37231 2293 48 a a DT 37231 2293 49 few few JJ 37231 2293 50 high high JJ 37231 2293 51 specimens specimen NNS 37231 2293 52 , , , 37231 2293 53 such such JJ 37231 2293 54 as as IN 37231 2293 55 the the DT 37231 2293 56 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 2293 57 . . . 37231 2294 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2294 2 have have VBP 37231 2294 3 already already RB 37231 2294 4 referred refer VBN 37231 2294 5 to to IN 37231 2294 6 the the DT 37231 2294 7 fact fact NN 37231 2294 8 that that IN 37231 2294 9 in in IN 37231 2294 10 the the DT 37231 2294 11 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2294 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2294 13 there there EX 37231 2294 14 is be VBZ 37231 2294 15 only only RB 37231 2294 16 one one CD 37231 2294 17 case case NN 37231 2294 18 , , , 37231 2294 19 reported report VBN 37231 2294 20 by by IN 37231 2294 21 the the DT 37231 2294 22 third third JJ 37231 2294 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2294 24 alone alone RB 37231 2294 25 , , , 37231 2294 26 in in IN 37231 2294 27 which which WDT 37231 2294 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2294 29 is be VBZ 37231 2294 30 said say VBN 37231 2294 31 to to TO 37231 2294 32 have have VB 37231 2294 33 raised raise VBN 37231 2294 34 the the DT 37231 2294 35 dead dead NN 37231 2294 36 . . . 37231 2295 1 St. St. NNP 37231 2295 2 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2295 3 alone alone RB 37231 2295 4 , , , 37231 2295 5 however however RB 37231 2295 6 , , , 37231 2295 7 chronicles chronicle VBZ 37231 2295 8 several several JJ 37231 2295 9 cases case NNS 37231 2295 10 in in IN 37231 2295 11 which which WDT 37231 2295 12 life life NN 37231 2295 13 was be VBD 37231 2295 14 restored restore VBN 37231 2295 15 to to IN 37231 2295 16 the the DT 37231 2295 17 dead dead NN 37231 2295 18 . . . 37231 2296 1 Post Post NNP 37231 2296 2 - - JJ 37231 2296 3 apostolic apostolic JJ 37231 2296 4 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2296 5 , , , 37231 2296 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 2296 7 , , , 37231 2296 8 are be VBP 37231 2296 9 far far RB 37231 2296 10 from from IN 37231 2296 11 lacking lack VBG 37231 2296 12 this this DT 37231 2296 13 ennobling ennobling JJ 37231 2296 14 type type NN 37231 2296 15 . . . 37231 2297 1 Observe observe VB 37231 2297 2 that that IN 37231 2297 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2297 4 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2297 5 is be VBZ 37231 2297 6 here here RB 37231 2297 7 not not RB 37231 2297 8 so so RB 37231 2297 9 much much RB 37231 2297 10 discussing discuss VBG 37231 2297 11 the the DT 37231 2297 12 reality reality NN 37231 2297 13 of of IN 37231 2297 14 the the DT 37231 2297 15 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 2297 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2297 17 of of IN 37231 2297 18 the the DT 37231 2297 19 Church Church NNP 37231 2297 20 , , , 37231 2297 21 as as IN 37231 2297 22 contrasting contrast VBG 37231 2297 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2297 24 and and CC 37231 2297 25 other other JJ 37231 2297 26 reputed repute VBN 37231 2297 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2297 28 with with IN 37231 2297 29 those those DT 37231 2297 30 of of IN 37231 2297 31 the the DT 37231 2297 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2297 33 , , , 37231 2297 34 and and CC 37231 2297 35 from from IN 37231 2297 36 this this DT 37231 2297 37 point point NN 37231 2297 38 of of IN 37231 2297 39 view view NN 37231 2297 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2297 41 is be VBZ 37231 2297 42 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2297 43 to to TO 37231 2297 44 maintain maintain VB 37231 2297 45 that that IN 37231 2297 46 the the DT 37231 2297 47 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2297 48 have have VBP 37231 2297 49 a a DT 37231 2297 50 monopoly monopoly NN 37231 2297 51 of of IN 37231 2297 52 the the DT 37231 2297 53 highest high JJS 37231 2297 54 class class NN 37231 2297 55 of of IN 37231 2297 56 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2297 57 . . . 37231 2298 1 Such such JJ 37231 2298 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2298 3 are be VBP 37231 2298 4 met meet VBN 37231 2298 5 with with IN 37231 2298 6 long long RB 37231 2298 7 before before RB 37231 2298 8 the the DT 37231 2298 9 dawn dawn NN 37231 2298 10 of of IN 37231 2298 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2298 12 , , , 37231 2298 13 and and CC 37231 2298 14 continued continue VBD 37231 2298 15 to to TO 37231 2298 16 occur occur VB 37231 2298 17 long long RB 37231 2298 18 after after IN 37231 2298 19 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 2298 20 times times NNP 37231 2298 21 . . . 37231 2299 1 Much much JJ 37231 2299 2 stress stress NN 37231 2299 3 is be VBZ 37231 2299 4 laid lay VBN 37231 2299 5 upon upon IN 37231 2299 6 the the DT 37231 2299 7 form form NN 37231 2299 8 of of IN 37231 2299 9 the the DT 37231 2299 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2299 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2299 12 ; ; : 37231 2299 13 but but CC 37231 2299 14 as as IN 37231 2299 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2299 16 have have VBP 37231 2299 17 already already RB 37231 2299 18 shown show VBN 37231 2299 19 , , , 37231 2299 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2299 21 is be VBZ 37231 2299 22 the the DT 37231 2299 23 actual actual JJ 37231 2299 24 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 2299 25 of of IN 37231 2299 26 the the DT 37231 2299 27 dead dead JJ 37231 2299 28 , , , 37231 2299 29 for for IN 37231 2299 30 instance instance NN 37231 2299 31 , , , 37231 2299 32 which which WDT 37231 2299 33 is be VBZ 37231 2299 34 the the DT 37231 2299 35 miracle miracle NN 37231 2299 36 , , , 37231 2299 37 and and CC 37231 2299 38 this this DT 37231 2299 39 is be VBZ 37231 2299 40 not not RB 37231 2299 41 affected affect VBN 37231 2299 42 by by IN 37231 2299 43 the the DT 37231 2299 44 more more RBR 37231 2299 45 or or CC 37231 2299 46 less less RBR 37231 2299 47 dramatic dramatic JJ 37231 2299 48 manner manner NN 37231 2299 49 in in IN 37231 2299 50 which which WDT 37231 2299 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2299 52 is be VBZ 37231 2299 53 said say VBN 37231 2299 54 to to TO 37231 2299 55 have have VB 37231 2299 56 been be VBN 37231 2299 57 effected effect VBN 37231 2299 58 , , , 37231 2299 59 or or CC 37231 2299 60 in in IN 37231 2299 61 which which WDT 37231 2299 62 the the DT 37231 2299 63 narrative narrative NN 37231 2299 64 of of IN 37231 2299 65 the the DT 37231 2299 66 event event NN 37231 2299 67 is be VBZ 37231 2299 68 composed compose VBN 37231 2299 69 . . . 37231 2300 1 Literary literary JJ 37231 2300 2 skill skill NN 37231 2300 3 , , , 37231 2300 4 and and CC 37231 2300 5 the the DT 37231 2300 6 judicious judicious JJ 37231 2300 7 management management NN 37231 2300 8 of of IN 37231 2300 9 details detail NNS 37231 2300 10 , , , 37231 2300 11 may may MD 37231 2300 12 make make VB 37231 2300 13 or or CC 37231 2300 14 mar mar VB 37231 2300 15 the the DT 37231 2300 16 form form NN 37231 2300 17 of of IN 37231 2300 18 any any DT 37231 2300 19 miracle miracle NN 37231 2300 20 . . . 37231 2301 1 The the DT 37231 2301 2 narrative narrative NN 37231 2301 3 of of IN 37231 2301 4 the the DT 37231 2301 5 restoration restoration NN 37231 2301 6 of of IN 37231 2301 7 the the DT 37231 2301 8 dead dead JJ 37231 2301 9 child child NN 37231 2301 10 to to IN 37231 2301 11 life life NN 37231 2301 12 by by IN 37231 2301 13 Elisha Elisha NNP 37231 2301 14 might may MD 37231 2301 15 have have VB 37231 2301 16 been be VBN 37231 2301 17 more more RBR 37231 2301 18 impressive impressive JJ 37231 2301 19 , , , 37231 2301 20 had have VBD 37231 2301 21 the the DT 37231 2301 22 writer writer NN 37231 2301 23 omitted omit VBD 37231 2301 24 the the DT 37231 2301 25 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 2301 26 that that WDT 37231 2301 27 the the DT 37231 2301 28 child child NN 37231 2301 29 sneezed sneeze VBD 37231 2301 30 seven seven CD 37231 2301 31 times time NNS 37231 2301 32 before before IN 37231 2301 33 opening open VBG 37231 2301 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2301 35 eyes eye NNS 37231 2301 36 , , , 37231 2301 37 and and CC 37231 2301 38 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2301 39 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2301 40 would would MD 37231 2301 41 probably probably RB 37231 2301 42 have have VB 37231 2301 43 considered consider VBN 37231 2301 44 the the DT 37231 2301 45 miracle miracle NN 37231 2301 46 greater great JJR 37231 2301 47 had have VBD 37231 2301 48 the the DT 37231 2301 49 prophet prophet NN 37231 2301 50 merely merely RB 37231 2301 51 said say VBD 37231 2301 52 to to IN 37231 2301 53 the the DT 37231 2301 54 child child NN 37231 2301 55 , , , 37231 2301 56 " " `` 37231 2301 57 Arise arise VB 37231 2301 58 ! ! . 37231 2301 59 " " '' 37231 2302 1 instead instead RB 37231 2302 2 of of IN 37231 2302 3 stretching stretch VBG 37231 2302 4 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2302 5 on on IN 37231 2302 6 the the DT 37231 2302 7 body body NN 37231 2302 8 ; ; : 37231 2302 9 but but CC 37231 2302 10 setting set VBG 37231 2302 11 aside aside RP 37231 2302 12 human human JJ 37231 2302 13 cravings craving NNS 37231 2302 14 { { -LRB- 37231 2302 15 190 190 CD 37231 2302 16 } } -RRB- 37231 2302 17 for for IN 37231 2302 18 the the DT 37231 2302 19 picturesque picturesque NN 37231 2302 20 and and CC 37231 2302 21 artistic artistic JJ 37231 2302 22 , , , 37231 2302 23 the the DT 37231 2302 24 essence essence NN 37231 2302 25 of of IN 37231 2302 26 the the DT 37231 2302 27 miracle miracle NN 37231 2302 28 would would MD 37231 2302 29 have have VB 37231 2302 30 remained remain VBN 37231 2302 31 the the DT 37231 2302 32 same same JJ 37231 2302 33 . . . 37231 2303 1 There there EX 37231 2303 2 is be VBZ 37231 2303 3 one one CD 37231 2303 4 point point NN 37231 2303 5 , , , 37231 2303 6 however however RB 37231 2303 7 , , , 37231 2303 8 regarding regard VBG 37231 2303 9 which which WDT 37231 2303 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2303 11 may may MD 37231 2303 12 be be VB 37231 2303 13 well well JJ 37231 2303 14 to to TO 37231 2303 15 make make VB 37231 2303 16 a a DT 37231 2303 17 few few JJ 37231 2303 18 remarks remark NNS 37231 2303 19 . . . 37231 2304 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 2304 2 a a DT 37231 2304 3 vast vast JJ 37231 2304 4 number number NN 37231 2304 5 of of IN 37231 2304 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2304 7 are be VBP 37231 2304 8 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2304 9 to to TO 37231 2304 10 direct direct VB 37231 2304 11 personal personal JJ 37231 2304 12 action action NN 37231 2304 13 of of IN 37231 2304 14 saints saint NNS 37231 2304 15 , , , 37231 2304 16 many many JJ 37231 2304 17 more more JJR 37231 2304 18 are be VBP 37231 2304 19 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2304 20 to to IN 37231 2304 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2304 22 relics relic NNS 37231 2304 23 . . . 37231 2305 1 Now now RB 37231 2305 2 this this DT 37231 2305 3 is be VBZ 37231 2305 4 no no DT 37231 2305 5 exclusive exclusive JJ 37231 2305 6 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 2305 7 of of IN 37231 2305 8 later later JJ 37231 2305 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2305 10 , , , 37231 2305 11 but but CC 37231 2305 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2305 13 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2305 14 shares share VBZ 37231 2305 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2305 16 with with IN 37231 2305 17 still still RB 37231 2305 18 earlier early JJR 37231 2305 19 times time NNS 37231 2305 20 . . . 37231 2306 1 The the DT 37231 2306 2 case case NN 37231 2306 3 in in IN 37231 2306 4 which which WDT 37231 2306 5 a a DT 37231 2306 6 dead dead JJ 37231 2306 7 body body NN 37231 2306 8 which which WDT 37231 2306 9 touched touch VBD 37231 2306 10 the the DT 37231 2306 11 bones bone NNS 37231 2306 12 of of IN 37231 2306 13 Elisha Elisha NNP 37231 2306 14 was be VBD 37231 2306 15 restored restore VBN 37231 2306 16 to to IN 37231 2306 17 life life NN 37231 2306 18 will will MD 37231 2306 19 occur occur VB 37231 2306 20 to to IN 37231 2306 21 every every DT 37231 2306 22 one one CD 37231 2306 23 . . . 37231 2307 1 " " `` 37231 2307 2 And and CC 37231 2307 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2307 4 came come VBD 37231 2307 5 to to TO 37231 2307 6 pass pass VB 37231 2307 7 , , , 37231 2307 8 as as IN 37231 2307 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2307 10 were be VBD 37231 2307 11 burying bury VBG 37231 2307 12 a a DT 37231 2307 13 man man NN 37231 2307 14 , , , 37231 2307 15 that that IN 37231 2307 16 , , , 37231 2307 17 behold behold NN 37231 2307 18 , , , 37231 2307 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2307 20 spied spy VBD 37231 2307 21 a a DT 37231 2307 22 band band NN 37231 2307 23 of of IN 37231 2307 24 Moabites Moabites NNPS 37231 2307 25 ; ; : 37231 2307 26 and and CC 37231 2307 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2307 28 cast cast VBD 37231 2307 29 the the DT 37231 2307 30 man man NN 37231 2307 31 into into IN 37231 2307 32 the the DT 37231 2307 33 sepulchre sepulchre NN 37231 2307 34 of of IN 37231 2307 35 Elisha Elisha NNP 37231 2307 36 : : : 37231 2307 37 and and CC 37231 2307 38 when when WRB 37231 2307 39 the the DT 37231 2307 40 man man NN 37231 2307 41 was be VBD 37231 2307 42 let let VBN 37231 2307 43 down down RP 37231 2307 44 , , , 37231 2307 45 and and CC 37231 2307 46 touched touch VBD 37231 2307 47 the the DT 37231 2307 48 bones bone NNS 37231 2307 49 of of IN 37231 2307 50 Elisha Elisha NNP 37231 2307 51 , , , 37231 2307 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2307 53 revived revive VBD 37231 2307 54 , , , 37231 2307 55 and and CC 37231 2307 56 stood stand VBD 37231 2307 57 up up RP 37231 2307 58 on on IN 37231 2307 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2307 60 feet foot NNS 37231 2307 61 . . . 37231 2308 1 " " `` 37231 2308 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2308 3 1 1 LS 37231 2308 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2308 5 The the DT 37231 2308 6 mantle mantle NN 37231 2308 7 of of IN 37231 2308 8 Elijah Elijah NNP 37231 2308 9 smiting smite VBG 37231 2308 10 asunder asunder IN 37231 2308 11 the the DT 37231 2308 12 waters water NNS 37231 2308 13 before before IN 37231 2308 14 Elisha Elisha NNP 37231 2308 15 may may MD 37231 2308 16 be be VB 37231 2308 17 cited cite VBN 37231 2308 18 as as IN 37231 2308 19 another another DT 37231 2308 20 instance instance NN 37231 2308 21 . . . 37231 2309 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2309 2 2 2 LS 37231 2309 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2309 4 The the DT 37231 2309 5 woman woman NN 37231 2309 6 who who WP 37231 2309 7 touches touch VBZ 37231 2309 8 the the DT 37231 2309 9 hem hem NN 37231 2309 10 of of IN 37231 2309 11 the the DT 37231 2309 12 garment garment NN 37231 2309 13 of of IN 37231 2309 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2309 15 in in IN 37231 2309 16 the the DT 37231 2309 17 crowd crowd NN 37231 2309 18 is be VBZ 37231 2309 19 made make VBN 37231 2309 20 whole,(3 whole,(3 JJ 37231 2309 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2309 22 and and CC 37231 2309 23 all all PDT 37231 2309 24 the the DT 37231 2309 25 sick sick JJ 37231 2309 26 and and CC 37231 2309 27 " " `` 37231 2309 28 possessed possessed JJ 37231 2309 29 " " '' 37231 2309 30 of of IN 37231 2309 31 the the DT 37231 2309 32 country country NN 37231 2309 33 are be VBP 37231 2309 34 represented represent VBN 37231 2309 35 as as IN 37231 2309 36 being be VBG 37231 2309 37 healed heal VBN 37231 2309 38 by by IN 37231 2309 39 touching touch VBG 37231 2309 40 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2309 41 , , , 37231 2309 42 or or CC 37231 2309 43 even even RB 37231 2309 44 the the DT 37231 2309 45 mere mere JJ 37231 2309 46 hem hem NN 37231 2309 47 of of IN 37231 2309 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2309 49 garment garment NN 37231 2309 50 . . . 37231 2310 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2310 2 4 4 LS 37231 2310 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2310 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2310 5 was be VBD 37231 2310 6 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2310 7 that that IN 37231 2310 8 the the DT 37231 2310 9 shadow shadow NN 37231 2310 10 of of IN 37231 2310 11 Peter Peter NNP 37231 2310 12 falling fall VBG 37231 2310 13 on on IN 37231 2310 14 the the DT 37231 2310 15 sick sick NN 37231 2310 16 as as IN 37231 2310 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2310 18 passed pass VBD 37231 2310 19 had have VBD 37231 2310 20 a a DT 37231 2310 21 curative curative JJ 37231 2310 22 effect,(5 effect,(5 NN 37231 2310 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2310 24 and and CC 37231 2310 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2310 26 is be VBZ 37231 2310 27 very very RB 37231 2310 28 positively positively RB 37231 2310 29 stated state VBN 37231 2310 30 : : : 37231 2310 31 " " `` 37231 2310 32 And and CC 37231 2310 33 God God NNP 37231 2310 34 wrought work VBD 37231 2310 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2310 36 of of IN 37231 2310 37 no no DT 37231 2310 38 common common JJ 37231 2310 39 kind kind NN 37231 2310 40 by by IN 37231 2310 41 the the DT 37231 2310 42 hands hand NNS 37231 2310 43 of of IN 37231 2310 44 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2310 45 ; ; : 37231 2310 46 so so IN 37231 2310 47 that that IN 37231 2310 48 from from IN 37231 2310 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2310 50 body body NN 37231 2310 51 were be VBD 37231 2310 52 brought bring VBN 37231 2310 53 unto unto IN 37231 2310 54 the the DT 37231 2310 55 sick sick JJ 37231 2310 56 handkerchiefs handkerchief NNS 37231 2310 57 or or CC 37231 2310 58 aprons apron NNS 37231 2310 59 , , , 37231 2310 60 and and CC 37231 2310 61 the the DT 37231 2310 62 diseases disease NNS 37231 2310 63 departed depart VBD 37231 2310 64 from from IN 37231 2310 65 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2310 66 , , , 37231 2310 67 and and CC 37231 2310 68 the the DT 37231 2310 69 evil evil JJ 37231 2310 70 spirits spirit NNS 37231 2310 71 went go VBD 37231 2310 72 out out IN 37231 2310 73 of of IN 37231 2310 74 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2310 75 . . . 37231 2310 76 " " '' 37231 2311 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2311 2 6 6 LS 37231 2311 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2311 4 The the DT 37231 2311 5 argument argument NN 37231 2311 6 which which WDT 37231 2311 7 assumes assume VBZ 37231 2311 8 an an DT 37231 2311 9 enormous enormous JJ 37231 2311 10 distinction distinction NN 37231 2311 11 { { -LRB- 37231 2311 12 191 191 CD 37231 2311 13 } } -RRB- 37231 2311 14 between between IN 37231 2311 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2311 16 and and CC 37231 2311 17 other other JJ 37231 2311 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2311 19 betrays betray VBZ 37231 2311 20 the the DT 37231 2311 21 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 2311 22 scepticism scepticism NN 37231 2311 23 , , , 37231 2311 24 even even RB 37231 2311 25 in in IN 37231 2311 26 the the DT 37231 2311 27 Church Church NNP 37231 2311 28 , , , 37231 2311 29 of of IN 37231 2311 30 all all DT 37231 2311 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2311 32 except except IN 37231 2311 33 those those DT 37231 2311 34 which which WDT 37231 2311 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2311 36 is be VBZ 37231 2311 37 considered consider VBN 37231 2311 38 an an DT 37231 2311 39 article article NN 37231 2311 40 of of IN 37231 2311 41 faith faith NN 37231 2311 42 to to TO 37231 2311 43 maintain maintain VB 37231 2311 44 . . . 37231 2312 1 If if IN 37231 2312 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2312 3 inquire inquire VBP 37231 2312 4 how how WRB 37231 2312 5 those those DT 37231 2312 6 think think VBP 37231 2312 7 who who WP 37231 2312 8 are be VBP 37231 2312 9 more more RBR 37231 2312 10 logical logical JJ 37231 2312 11 and and CC 37231 2312 12 thorough thorough JJ 37231 2312 13 in in IN 37231 2312 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2312 15 belief belief NN 37231 2312 16 in in IN 37231 2312 17 the the DT 37231 2312 18 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2312 19 , , , 37231 2312 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2312 21 find find VBP 37231 2312 22 the the DT 37231 2312 23 distinction distinction NN 37231 2312 24 denied deny VBN 37231 2312 25 . . . 37231 2313 1 " " `` 37231 2313 2 The the DT 37231 2313 3 question question NN 37231 2313 4 , , , 37231 2313 5 " " '' 37231 2313 6 says say VBZ 37231 2313 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2313 8 Newman Newman NNP 37231 2313 9 , , , 37231 2313 10 " " `` 37231 2313 11 has have VBZ 37231 2313 12 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 2313 13 been be VBN 37231 2313 14 argued argue VBN 37231 2313 15 on on IN 37231 2313 16 the the DT 37231 2313 17 admission admission NN 37231 2313 18 , , , 37231 2313 19 that that IN 37231 2313 20 a a DT 37231 2313 21 distinct distinct JJ 37231 2313 22 line line NN 37231 2313 23 can can MD 37231 2313 24 be be VB 37231 2313 25 drawn draw VBN 37231 2313 26 in in IN 37231 2313 27 point point NN 37231 2313 28 of of IN 37231 2313 29 character character NN 37231 2313 30 and and CC 37231 2313 31 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2313 32 , , , 37231 2313 33 between between IN 37231 2313 34 the the DT 37231 2313 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2313 36 of of IN 37231 2313 37 Scripture scripture NN 37231 2313 38 and and CC 37231 2313 39 those those DT 37231 2313 40 of of IN 37231 2313 41 Church Church NNP 37231 2313 42 history history NN 37231 2313 43 ; ; : 37231 2313 44 but but CC 37231 2313 45 this this DT 37231 2313 46 is be VBZ 37231 2313 47 by by IN 37231 2313 48 no no DT 37231 2313 49 means means NN 37231 2313 50 the the DT 37231 2313 51 case case NN 37231 2313 52 . . . 37231 2314 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2314 2 is be VBZ 37231 2314 3 true true JJ 37231 2314 4 , , , 37231 2314 5 indeed indeed RB 37231 2314 6 , , , 37231 2314 7 that that IN 37231 2314 8 the the DT 37231 2314 9 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2314 10 of of IN 37231 2314 11 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2314 12 , , , 37231 2314 13 viewed view VBD 37231 2314 14 as as IN 37231 2314 15 a a DT 37231 2314 16 whole whole NN 37231 2314 17 , , , 37231 2314 18 recommend recommend VB 37231 2314 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2314 20 to to IN 37231 2314 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2314 22 reason reason NN 37231 2314 23 , , , 37231 2314 24 and and CC 37231 2314 25 claim claim VBP 37231 2314 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2314 27 veneration veneration NN 37231 2314 28 beyond beyond IN 37231 2314 29 all all DT 37231 2314 30 others other NNS 37231 2314 31 , , , 37231 2314 32 by by IN 37231 2314 33 a a DT 37231 2314 34 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 2314 35 dignity dignity NN 37231 2314 36 and and CC 37231 2314 37 beauty beauty NN 37231 2314 38 ; ; : 37231 2314 39 but but CC 37231 2314 40 still still RB 37231 2314 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2314 42 is be VBZ 37231 2314 43 only only RB 37231 2314 44 as as IN 37231 2314 45 a a DT 37231 2314 46 whole whole NN 37231 2314 47 that that WDT 37231 2314 48 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2314 49 make make VBP 37231 2314 50 this this DT 37231 2314 51 impression impression NN 37231 2314 52 upon upon IN 37231 2314 53 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2314 54 . . . 37231 2315 1 Some some DT 37231 2315 2 of of IN 37231 2315 3 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2315 4 , , , 37231 2315 5 on on IN 37231 2315 6 the the DT 37231 2315 7 contrary contrary NN 37231 2315 8 , , , 37231 2315 9 fall fall VB 37231 2315 10 short short RB 37231 2315 11 of of IN 37231 2315 12 the the DT 37231 2315 13 attributes attribute NNS 37231 2315 14 which which WDT 37231 2315 15 attach attach VBP 37231 2315 16 to to IN 37231 2315 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2315 18 in in IN 37231 2315 19 general general JJ 37231 2315 20 ; ; : 37231 2315 21 nay nay NNP 37231 2315 22 , , , 37231 2315 23 are be VBP 37231 2315 24 inferior inferior JJ 37231 2315 25 in in IN 37231 2315 26 these these DT 37231 2315 27 respects respect NNS 37231 2315 28 to to IN 37231 2315 29 certain certain JJ 37231 2315 30 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2315 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2315 32 , , , 37231 2315 33 and and CC 37231 2315 34 are be VBP 37231 2315 35 received receive VBN 37231 2315 36 only only RB 37231 2315 37 on on IN 37231 2315 38 the the DT 37231 2315 39 credit credit NN 37231 2315 40 of of IN 37231 2315 41 the the DT 37231 2315 42 system system NN 37231 2315 43 of of IN 37231 2315 44 which which WDT 37231 2315 45 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2315 46 form form VBP 37231 2315 47 part part NN 37231 2315 48 . . . 37231 2316 1 Again again RB 37231 2316 2 , , , 37231 2316 3 specimens specimen NNS 37231 2316 4 are be VBP 37231 2316 5 not not RB 37231 2316 6 wanting want VBG 37231 2316 7 in in IN 37231 2316 8 the the DT 37231 2316 9 history history NN 37231 2316 10 of of IN 37231 2316 11 the the DT 37231 2316 12 Church Church NNP 37231 2316 13 , , , 37231 2316 14 of of IN 37231 2316 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2316 16 as as IN 37231 2316 17 awful awful JJ 37231 2316 18 in in IN 37231 2316 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2316 20 character character NN 37231 2316 21 , , , 37231 2316 22 and and CC 37231 2316 23 as as RB 37231 2316 24 momentous momentous JJ 37231 2316 25 in in IN 37231 2316 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2316 27 effects effect NNS 37231 2316 28 , , , 37231 2316 29 as as IN 37231 2316 30 those those DT 37231 2316 31 which which WDT 37231 2316 32 are be VBP 37231 2316 33 recorded record VBN 37231 2316 34 in in IN 37231 2316 35 Scripture scripture NN 37231 2316 36 . . . 37231 2317 1 " " `` 37231 2317 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2317 3 1 1 LS 37231 2317 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2317 5 Now now RB 37231 2317 6 here here RB 37231 2317 7 is be VBZ 37231 2317 8 one one CD 37231 2317 9 able able JJ 37231 2317 10 and and CC 37231 2317 11 thorough thorough JJ 37231 2317 12 supporter supporter NN 37231 2317 13 of of IN 37231 2317 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2317 15 denying deny VBG 37231 2317 16 the the DT 37231 2317 17 enormous enormous JJ 37231 2317 18 distinction distinction NN 37231 2317 19 between between IN 37231 2317 20 those those DT 37231 2317 21 of of IN 37231 2317 22 the the DT 37231 2317 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2317 24 and and CC 37231 2317 25 those those DT 37231 2317 26 of of IN 37231 2317 27 human human JJ 37231 2317 28 history history NN 37231 2317 29 , , , 37231 2317 30 which which WDT 37231 2317 31 another another DT 37231 2317 32 admits admit VBZ 37231 2317 33 to to TO 37231 2317 34 be be VB 37231 2317 35 essential essential JJ 37231 2317 36 to to IN 37231 2317 37 the the DT 37231 2317 38 former former JJ 37231 2317 39 as as IN 37231 2317 40 evidence evidence NN 37231 2317 41 of of IN 37231 2317 42 a a DT 37231 2317 43 revelation revelation NN 37231 2317 44 . . . 37231 2318 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2318 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2318 3 , , , 37231 2318 4 however however RB 37231 2318 5 , , , 37231 2318 6 meets meet VBZ 37231 2318 7 such such PDT 37231 2318 8 a a DT 37231 2318 9 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 2318 10 by by IN 37231 2318 11 asserting assert VBG 37231 2318 12 that that IN 37231 2318 13 there there EX 37231 2318 14 would would MD 37231 2318 15 be be VB 37231 2318 16 no no DT 37231 2318 17 disadvantage disadvantage NN 37231 2318 18 to to IN 37231 2318 19 the the DT 37231 2318 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2318 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2318 22 , , , 37231 2318 23 and and CC 37231 2318 24 no no RB 37231 2318 25 doubt doubt RB 37231 2318 26 regarding regard VBG 37231 2318 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2318 28 involved involve VBN 37231 2318 29 , , , 37231 2318 30 if if IN 37231 2318 31 for for IN 37231 2318 32 some some DT 37231 2318 33 later later JJ 37231 2318 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2318 35 there there EX 37231 2318 36 was be VBD 37231 2318 37 evidence evidence NN 37231 2318 38 as as RB 37231 2318 39 strong strong JJ 37231 2318 40 as as IN 37231 2318 41 for for IN 37231 2318 42 those those DT 37231 2318 43 of of IN 37231 2318 44 the the DT 37231 2318 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2318 46 . . . 37231 2319 1 " " `` 37231 2319 2 All all DT 37231 2319 3 the the DT 37231 2319 4 result result NN 37231 2319 5 would would MD 37231 2319 6 be be VB 37231 2319 7 , , , 37231 2319 8 " " '' 37231 2319 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2319 10 says say VBZ 37231 2319 11 , , , 37231 2319 12 { { -LRB- 37231 2319 13 192 192 CD 37231 2319 14 } } -RRB- 37231 2319 15 " " '' 37231 2319 16 that that IN 37231 2319 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2319 18 should should MD 37231 2319 19 admit admit VB 37231 2319 20 these these DT 37231 2319 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2319 22 over over RB 37231 2319 23 and and CC 37231 2319 24 above above IN 37231 2319 25 the the DT 37231 2319 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2319 27 ones one NNS 37231 2319 28 . . . 37231 2320 1 " " `` 37231 2320 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2320 3 1 1 LS 37231 2320 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2320 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2320 6 denies deny VBZ 37231 2320 7 the the DT 37231 2320 8 equality equality NN 37231 2320 9 of of IN 37231 2320 10 the the DT 37231 2320 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 2320 12 , , , 37231 2320 13 however however RB 37231 2320 14 , , , 37231 2320 15 in in IN 37231 2320 16 any any DT 37231 2320 17 case case NN 37231 2320 18 . . . 37231 2321 1 " " `` 37231 2321 2 Between between IN 37231 2321 3 the the DT 37231 2321 4 evidence evidence NN 37231 2321 5 , , , 37231 2321 6 then then RB 37231 2321 7 , , , 37231 2321 8 upon upon IN 37231 2321 9 which which WDT 37231 2321 10 the the DT 37231 2321 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2321 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2321 13 stand stand VBP 37231 2321 14 , , , 37231 2321 15 and and CC 37231 2321 16 that that IN 37231 2321 17 for for IN 37231 2321 18 later later JJ 37231 2321 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2321 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2321 21 see see VBP 37231 2321 22 a a DT 37231 2321 23 broad broad JJ 37231 2321 24 distinction distinction NN 37231 2321 25 arising arising NN 37231 2321 26 , , , 37231 2321 27 not not RB 37231 2321 28 to to TO 37231 2321 29 mention mention VB 37231 2321 30 again again RB 37231 2321 31 the the DT 37231 2321 32 nature nature NN 37231 2321 33 and and CC 37231 2321 34 type type NN 37231 2321 35 of of IN 37231 2321 36 the the DT 37231 2321 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2321 38 miracles miracle VBZ 37231 2321 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2321 40 -- -- : 37231 2321 41 from from IN 37231 2321 42 the the DT 37231 2321 43 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 37231 2321 44 date date NN 37231 2321 45 of of IN 37231 2321 46 the the DT 37231 2321 47 testimony testimony NN 37231 2321 48 to to IN 37231 2321 49 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2321 50 , , , 37231 2321 51 the the DT 37231 2321 52 character character NN 37231 2321 53 of of IN 37231 2321 54 the the DT 37231 2321 55 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2321 56 , , , 37231 2321 57 the the DT 37231 2321 58 probation probation NN 37231 2321 59 of of IN 37231 2321 60 the the DT 37231 2321 61 testimony testimony NN 37231 2321 62 ; ; : 37231 2321 63 especially especially RB 37231 2321 64 when when WRB 37231 2321 65 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2321 66 contrast contrast VBP 37231 2321 67 with with IN 37231 2321 68 these these DT 37231 2321 69 points point NNS 37231 2321 70 the the DT 37231 2321 71 false false JJ 37231 2321 72 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 2321 73 and and CC 37231 2321 74 audacious audacious JJ 37231 2321 75 fraud fraud NN 37231 2321 76 which which WDT 37231 2321 77 rose rise VBD 37231 2321 78 up up RP 37231 2321 79 in in IN 37231 2321 80 later later JJ 37231 2321 81 ages age NNS 37231 2321 82 , , , 37231 2321 83 and and CC 37231 2321 84 in in IN 37231 2321 85 connection connection NN 37231 2321 86 with with IN 37231 2321 87 which which WDT 37231 2321 88 so so RB 37231 2321 89 large large VBP 37231 2321 90 a a DT 37231 2321 91 portion portion NN 37231 2321 92 of of IN 37231 2321 93 the the DT 37231 2321 94 later later JJ 37231 2321 95 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2321 96 of of IN 37231 2321 97 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2321 98 made make VBD 37231 2321 99 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2321 100 appearance appearance NN 37231 2321 101 . . . 37231 2322 1 " " `` 37231 2322 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2322 3 2 2 LS 37231 2322 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2322 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2322 6 consider consider VBP 37231 2322 7 the the DT 37231 2322 8 point point NN 37231 2322 9 touching touch VBG 37231 2322 10 the the DT 37231 2322 11 type type NN 37231 2322 12 of of IN 37231 2322 13 the the DT 37231 2322 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2322 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2322 16 disposed dispose VBN 37231 2322 17 of of IN 37231 2322 18 , , , 37231 2322 19 and and CC 37231 2322 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2322 21 may may MD 37231 2322 22 , , , 37231 2322 23 therefore therefore RB 37231 2322 24 , , , 37231 2322 25 confine confine VB 37231 2322 26 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2322 27 to to IN 37231 2322 28 the the DT 37231 2322 29 rest rest NN 37231 2322 30 of of IN 37231 2322 31 this this DT 37231 2322 32 argument argument NN 37231 2322 33 . . . 37231 2323 1 If if IN 37231 2323 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2323 3 look look VBP 37231 2323 4 for for IN 37231 2323 5 any any DT 37231 2323 6 external external JJ 37231 2323 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 2323 8 of of IN 37231 2323 9 the the DT 37231 2323 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2323 11 of of IN 37231 2323 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2323 13 in in IN 37231 2323 14 any any DT 37231 2323 15 marked marked JJ 37231 2323 16 effect effect NN 37231 2323 17 produced produce VBN 37231 2323 18 by by IN 37231 2323 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2323 20 at at IN 37231 2323 21 the the DT 37231 2323 22 time time NN 37231 2323 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2323 24 are be VBP 37231 2323 25 said say VBN 37231 2323 26 to to TO 37231 2323 27 have have VB 37231 2323 28 occurred occur VBN 37231 2323 29 , , , 37231 2323 30 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2323 31 find find VBP 37231 2323 32 anything anything NN 37231 2323 33 but but IN 37231 2323 34 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 2323 35 of of IN 37231 2323 36 the the DT 37231 2323 37 statements statement NNS 37231 2323 38 of of IN 37231 2323 39 the the DT 37231 2323 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2323 41 . . . 37231 2324 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2324 2 is be VBZ 37231 2324 3 a a DT 37231 2324 4 notorious notorious JJ 37231 2324 5 fact fact NN 37231 2324 6 that that IN 37231 2324 7 , , , 37231 2324 8 in in IN 37231 2324 9 spite spite NN 37231 2324 10 of of IN 37231 2324 11 these these DT 37231 2324 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2324 13 , , , 37231 2324 14 very very RB 37231 2324 15 few few JJ 37231 2324 16 of of IN 37231 2324 17 the the DT 37231 2324 18 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2324 19 amongst amongst IN 37231 2324 20 whom whom WP 37231 2324 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2324 22 were be VBD 37231 2324 23 performed perform VBN 37231 2324 24 believed believe VBD 37231 2324 25 in in IN 37231 2324 26 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2324 27 , , , 37231 2324 28 and and CC 37231 2324 29 that that IN 37231 2324 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2324 31 made make VBD 37231 2324 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2324 33 chief chief JJ 37231 2324 34 converts convert NNS 37231 2324 35 not not RB 37231 2324 36 where where WRB 37231 2324 37 the the DT 37231 2324 38 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2324 39 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2324 40 took take VBD 37231 2324 41 place place NN 37231 2324 42 , , , 37231 2324 43 but but CC 37231 2324 44 where where WRB 37231 2324 45 an an DT 37231 2324 46 account account NN 37231 2324 47 of of IN 37231 2324 48 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2324 49 was be VBD 37231 2324 50 alone alone RB 37231 2324 51 given give VBN 37231 2324 52 by by IN 37231 2324 53 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 37231 2324 54 missionaries missionary NNS 37231 2324 55 . . . 37231 2325 1 Such such JJ 37231 2325 2 astounding astounding JJ 37231 2325 3 exhibitions exhibition NNS 37231 2325 4 of of IN 37231 2325 5 power power NN 37231 2325 6 as as IN 37231 2325 7 raising raise VBG 37231 2325 8 the the DT 37231 2325 9 dead dead JJ 37231 2325 10 , , , 37231 2325 11 giving give VBG 37231 2325 12 sight sight NN 37231 2325 13 to to IN 37231 2325 14 the the DT 37231 2325 15 blind blind JJ 37231 2325 16 , , , 37231 2325 17 walking walk VBG 37231 2325 18 on on IN 37231 2325 19 the the DT 37231 2325 20 sea sea NN 37231 2325 21 , , , 37231 2325 22 changing change VBG 37231 2325 23 water water NN 37231 2325 24 into into IN 37231 2325 25 wine wine NN 37231 2325 26 , , , 37231 2325 27 and and CC 37231 2325 28 indefinitely indefinitely RB 37231 2325 29 multiplying multiply VBG 37231 2325 30 a a DT 37231 2325 31 few few JJ 37231 2325 32 loaves loaf NNS 37231 2325 33 and and CC 37231 2325 34 fishes fish NNS 37231 2325 35 , , , 37231 2325 36 not not RB 37231 2325 37 only only RB 37231 2325 38 did do VBD 37231 2325 39 not not RB 37231 2325 40 make make VB 37231 2325 41 any any DT 37231 2325 42 impression impression NN 37231 2325 43 on on IN 37231 2325 44 the the DT 37231 2325 45 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2325 46 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2325 47 , , , 37231 2325 48 but but CC 37231 2325 49 were be VBD 37231 2325 50 never never RB 37231 2325 51 heard hear VBN 37231 2325 52 of of IN 37231 2325 53 out out IN 37231 2325 54 of of IN 37231 2325 55 Palestine Palestine NNP 37231 2325 56 until until IN 37231 2325 57 long long RB 37231 2325 58 after after IN 37231 2325 59 the the DT 37231 2325 60 events event NNS 37231 2325 61 are be VBP 37231 2325 62 said say VBN 37231 2325 63 to to TO 37231 2325 64 have have VB 37231 2325 65 occurred occur VBN 37231 2325 66 , , , 37231 2325 67 when when WRB 37231 2325 68 the the DT 37231 2325 69 narrative narrative NN 37231 2325 70 of of IN 37231 2325 71 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2325 72 was be VBD 37231 2325 73 slowly slowly RB 37231 2325 74 disseminated disseminate VBN 37231 2325 75 by by IN 37231 2325 76 Christian christian JJ 37231 2325 77 teachers teacher NNS 37231 2325 78 and and CC 37231 2325 79 writers writer NNS 37231 2325 80 . . . 37231 2326 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2326 2 193 193 CD 37231 2326 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2326 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2326 5 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2326 6 refers refer VBZ 37231 2326 7 to to IN 37231 2326 8 the the DT 37231 2326 9 contemporary contemporary JJ 37231 2326 10 testimony testimony NN 37231 2326 11 " " '' 37231 2326 12 for for IN 37231 2326 13 certain certain JJ 37231 2326 14 great great JJ 37231 2326 15 and and CC 37231 2326 16 cardinal cardinal JJ 37231 2326 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2326 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2326 19 which which WDT 37231 2326 20 , , , 37231 2326 21 if if IN 37231 2326 22 granted grant VBN 37231 2326 23 , , , 37231 2326 24 clear clear VB 37231 2326 25 away away RP 37231 2326 26 all all DT 37231 2326 27 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 2326 28 objection objection NN 37231 2326 29 to to IN 37231 2326 30 the the DT 37231 2326 31 reception reception NN 37231 2326 32 of of IN 37231 2326 33 the the DT 37231 2326 34 rest rest NN 37231 2326 35 , , , 37231 2326 36 " " '' 37231 2326 37 and and CC 37231 2326 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2326 39 says say VBZ 37231 2326 40 : : : 37231 2326 41 " " `` 37231 2326 42 That that IN 37231 2326 43 the the DT 37231 2326 44 first first JJ 37231 2326 45 promulgators promulgator NNS 37231 2326 46 of of IN 37231 2326 47 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2326 48 asserted assert VBD 37231 2326 49 , , , 37231 2326 50 as as IN 37231 2326 51 a a DT 37231 2326 52 fact fact NN 37231 2326 53 which which WDT 37231 2326 54 had have VBD 37231 2326 55 come come VBN 37231 2326 56 under under IN 37231 2326 57 the the DT 37231 2326 58 cognizance cognizance NN 37231 2326 59 of of IN 37231 2326 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2326 61 senses sense NNS 37231 2326 62 , , , 37231 2326 63 the the DT 37231 2326 64 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 2326 65 of of IN 37231 2326 66 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2326 67 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2326 68 from from IN 37231 2326 69 the the DT 37231 2326 70 dead dead NN 37231 2326 71 , , , 37231 2326 72 is be VBZ 37231 2326 73 as as RB 37231 2326 74 certain certain JJ 37231 2326 75 as as IN 37231 2326 76 anything anything NN 37231 2326 77 in in IN 37231 2326 78 history history NN 37231 2326 79 . . . 37231 2327 1 " " `` 37231 2327 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2327 3 1 1 LS 37231 2327 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2327 5 What what WP 37231 2327 6 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2327 7 really really RB 37231 2327 8 did do VBD 37231 2327 9 assert assert VB 37231 2327 10 , , , 37231 2327 11 so so RB 37231 2327 12 far far RB 37231 2327 13 from from IN 37231 2327 14 being be VBG 37231 2327 15 so so RB 37231 2327 16 certain certain JJ 37231 2327 17 as as IN 37231 2327 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2327 19 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2327 20 states state NNS 37231 2327 21 , , , 37231 2327 22 must must MD 37231 2327 23 , , , 37231 2327 24 as as IN 37231 2327 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2327 26 shall shall MD 37231 2327 27 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 2327 28 see see VB 37231 2327 29 , , , 37231 2327 30 be be VB 37231 2327 31 considered consider VBN 37231 2327 32 matter matter NN 37231 2327 33 of of IN 37231 2327 34 the the DT 37231 2327 35 greatest great JJS 37231 2327 36 doubt doubt NN 37231 2327 37 . . . 37231 2328 1 But but CC 37231 2328 2 if if IN 37231 2328 3 the the DT 37231 2328 4 general general JJ 37231 2328 5 statement statement NN 37231 2328 6 be be VB 37231 2328 7 taken take VBN 37231 2328 8 that that IN 37231 2328 9 the the DT 37231 2328 10 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 2328 11 , , , 37231 2328 12 for for IN 37231 2328 13 instance instance NN 37231 2328 14 , , , 37231 2328 15 was be VBD 37231 2328 16 promulgated promulgate VBN 37231 2328 17 as as IN 37231 2328 18 a a DT 37231 2328 19 fact fact NN 37231 2328 20 which which WDT 37231 2328 21 the the DT 37231 2328 22 early early JJ 37231 2328 23 preachers preacher NNS 37231 2328 24 of of IN 37231 2328 25 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2328 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2328 27 believed believe VBD 37231 2328 28 to to TO 37231 2328 29 have have VB 37231 2328 30 taken take VBN 37231 2328 31 place place NN 37231 2328 32 , , , 37231 2328 33 the the DT 37231 2328 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 2328 35 does do VBZ 37231 2328 36 not not RB 37231 2328 37 in in IN 37231 2328 38 that that DT 37231 2328 39 case case NN 37231 2328 40 present present VB 37231 2328 41 the the DT 37231 2328 42 broad broad JJ 37231 2328 43 distinction distinction NN 37231 2328 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2328 45 asserts assert VBZ 37231 2328 46 . . . 37231 2329 1 The the DT 37231 2329 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2329 3 recounted recount VBN 37231 2329 4 by by IN 37231 2329 5 St St NNP 37231 2329 6 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 2329 7 and and CC 37231 2329 8 St. St. NNP 37231 2329 9 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2329 10 , , , 37231 2329 11 for for IN 37231 2329 12 example example NN 37231 2329 13 , , , 37231 2329 14 were be VBD 37231 2329 15 likewise likewise RB 37231 2329 16 proclaimed proclaim VBN 37231 2329 17 with with IN 37231 2329 18 equal equal JJ 37231 2329 19 clearness clearness NN 37231 2329 20 , , , 37231 2329 21 and and CC 37231 2329 22 even even RB 37231 2329 23 greater great JJR 37231 2329 24 promptitude promptitude NN 37231 2329 25 and and CC 37231 2329 26 publicity publicity NN 37231 2329 27 at at IN 37231 2329 28 the the DT 37231 2329 29 very very JJ 37231 2329 30 spot spot NN 37231 2329 31 where where WRB 37231 2329 32 many many JJ 37231 2329 33 of of IN 37231 2329 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2329 35 were be VBD 37231 2329 36 said say VBN 37231 2329 37 to to TO 37231 2329 38 have have VB 37231 2329 39 been be VBN 37231 2329 40 performed perform VBN 37231 2329 41 , , , 37231 2329 42 and and CC 37231 2329 43 the the DT 37231 2329 44 details detail NNS 37231 2329 45 were be VBD 37231 2329 46 much much RB 37231 2329 47 more more RBR 37231 2329 48 immediately immediately RB 37231 2329 49 reduced reduce VBN 37231 2329 50 to to IN 37231 2329 51 writing write VBG 37231 2329 52 . . . 37231 2330 1 The the DT 37231 2330 2 mere mere JJ 37231 2330 3 assertion assertion NN 37231 2330 4 in in IN 37231 2330 5 neither neither DT 37231 2330 6 case case NN 37231 2330 7 goes go VBZ 37231 2330 8 for for RB 37231 2330 9 much much RB 37231 2330 10 as as IN 37231 2330 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 2330 12 , , , 37231 2330 13 but but CC 37231 2330 14 the the DT 37231 2330 15 fact fact NN 37231 2330 16 is be VBZ 37231 2330 17 that that IN 37231 2330 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2330 19 have have VBP 37231 2330 20 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 2330 21 no no DT 37231 2330 22 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 37231 2330 23 testimony testimony NN 37231 2330 24 at at RB 37231 2330 25 all all RB 37231 2330 26 as as IN 37231 2330 27 to to IN 37231 2330 28 what what WP 37231 2330 29 the the DT 37231 2330 30 first first JJ 37231 2330 31 promulgators promulgator NNS 37231 2330 32 of of IN 37231 2330 33 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2330 34 actually actually RB 37231 2330 35 asserted assert VBD 37231 2330 36 , , , 37231 2330 37 or or CC 37231 2330 38 as as IN 37231 2330 39 to to IN 37231 2330 40 the the DT 37231 2330 41 real real JJ 37231 2330 42 grounds ground NNS 37231 2330 43 upon upon IN 37231 2330 44 which which WDT 37231 2330 45 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2330 46 made make VBD 37231 2330 47 such such JJ 37231 2330 48 assertions assertion NNS 37231 2330 49 . . . 37231 2331 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2331 2 shall shall MD 37231 2331 3 presently presently RB 37231 2331 4 enter enter VB 37231 2331 5 upon upon IN 37231 2331 6 a a DT 37231 2331 7 thorough thorough JJ 37231 2331 8 examination examination NN 37231 2331 9 of of IN 37231 2331 10 the the DT 37231 2331 11 testimony testimony NN 37231 2331 12 for for IN 37231 2331 13 the the DT 37231 2331 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2331 15 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2331 16 , , , 37231 2331 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2331 18 authorship authorship NN 37231 2331 19 and and CC 37231 2331 20 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2331 21 , , , 37231 2331 22 but but CC 37231 2331 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2331 24 may may MD 37231 2331 25 here here RB 37231 2331 26 be be VB 37231 2331 27 permitted permit VBN 37231 2331 28 , , , 37231 2331 29 so so RB 37231 2331 30 far far RB 37231 2331 31 to to TO 37231 2331 32 anticipate anticipate VB 37231 2331 33 , , , 37231 2331 34 as as IN 37231 2331 35 to to TO 37231 2331 36 remark remark VB 37231 2331 37 that that IN 37231 2331 38 , , , 37231 2331 39 applied apply VBD 37231 2331 40 to to IN 37231 2331 41 documentary documentary JJ 37231 2331 42 evidence evidence NN 37231 2331 43 , , , 37231 2331 44 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2331 45 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2331 46 's 's POS 37231 2331 47 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 2331 48 from from IN 37231 2331 49 the the DT 37231 2331 50 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 37231 2331 51 date date NN 37231 2331 52 of of IN 37231 2331 53 the the DT 37231 2331 54 testimony testimony NN 37231 2331 55 , , , 37231 2331 56 and and CC 37231 2331 57 the the DT 37231 2331 58 character character NN 37231 2331 59 of of IN 37231 2331 60 { { -LRB- 37231 2331 61 194 194 CD 37231 2331 62 } } -RRB- 37231 2331 63 the the DT 37231 2331 64 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2331 65 , , , 37231 2331 66 is be VBZ 37231 2331 67 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 2331 68 by by IN 37231 2331 69 the the DT 37231 2331 70 whole whole JJ 37231 2331 71 history history NN 37231 2331 72 of of IN 37231 2331 73 New New NNP 37231 2331 74 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2331 75 literature literature NN 37231 2331 76 . . . 37231 2332 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 2332 2 the the DT 37231 2332 3 most most RBS 37231 2332 4 uncritically uncritically RB 37231 2332 5 zealous zealous JJ 37231 2332 6 assertors assertor NNS 37231 2332 7 of of IN 37231 2332 8 the the DT 37231 2332 9 antiquity antiquity NN 37231 2332 10 of of IN 37231 2332 11 the the DT 37231 2332 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2332 13 never never RB 37231 2332 14 venture venture VBP 37231 2332 15 to to IN 37231 2332 16 date date NN 37231 2332 17 the the DT 37231 2332 18 earliest early JJS 37231 2332 19 of of IN 37231 2332 20 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2332 21 within within IN 37231 2332 22 a a DT 37231 2332 23 quarter quarter NN 37231 2332 24 of of IN 37231 2332 25 a a DT 37231 2332 26 century century NN 37231 2332 27 from from IN 37231 2332 28 the the DT 37231 2332 29 death death NN 37231 2332 30 of of IN 37231 2332 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2332 32 , , , 37231 2332 33 every every DT 37231 2332 34 tyro tyro NN 37231 2332 35 is be VBZ 37231 2332 36 aware aware JJ 37231 2332 37 that that IN 37231 2332 38 there there EX 37231 2332 39 is be VBZ 37231 2332 40 not not RB 37231 2332 41 a a DT 37231 2332 42 particle particle NN 37231 2332 43 of of IN 37231 2332 44 evidence evidence NN 37231 2332 45 of of IN 37231 2332 46 the the DT 37231 2332 47 existence existence NN 37231 2332 48 of of IN 37231 2332 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2332 50 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2332 51 until until IN 37231 2332 52 very very RB 37231 2332 53 long long RB 37231 2332 54 after after IN 37231 2332 55 that that DT 37231 2332 56 interval,--hereafter interval,--hereafter NNP 37231 2332 57 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2332 58 shall shall MD 37231 2332 59 show show VB 37231 2332 60 how how WRB 37231 2332 61 long;--that long;--that CD 37231 2332 62 two two CD 37231 2332 63 of of IN 37231 2332 64 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2332 65 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2332 66 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2332 67 at at IN 37231 2332 68 least least JJS 37231 2332 69 were be VBD 37231 2332 70 not not RB 37231 2332 71 , , , 37231 2332 72 in in IN 37231 2332 73 any any DT 37231 2332 74 case case NN 37231 2332 75 , , , 37231 2332 76 composed compose VBN 37231 2332 77 in in IN 37231 2332 78 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2332 79 present present JJ 37231 2332 80 form form NN 37231 2332 81 by by IN 37231 2332 82 the the DT 37231 2332 83 writers writer NNS 37231 2332 84 to to IN 37231 2332 85 whom whom WP 37231 2332 86 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2332 87 are be VBP 37231 2332 88 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2332 89 ; ; : 37231 2332 90 that that IN 37231 2332 91 there there EX 37231 2332 92 is be VBZ 37231 2332 93 , , , 37231 2332 94 indeed indeed RB 37231 2332 95 , , , 37231 2332 96 nothing nothing NN 37231 2332 97 worthy worthy JJ 37231 2332 98 of of IN 37231 2332 99 the the DT 37231 2332 100 name name NN 37231 2332 101 of of IN 37231 2332 102 evidence evidence NN 37231 2332 103 that that IN 37231 2332 104 any any DT 37231 2332 105 one one CD 37231 2332 106 of of IN 37231 2332 107 these these DT 37231 2332 108 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2332 109 was be VBD 37231 2332 110 written write VBN 37231 2332 111 at at RB 37231 2332 112 all all RB 37231 2332 113 by by IN 37231 2332 114 the the DT 37231 2332 115 person person NN 37231 2332 116 whose whose WP$ 37231 2332 117 name name NN 37231 2332 118 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2332 119 bears bear VBZ 37231 2332 120 ; ; : 37231 2332 121 that that IN 37231 2332 122 the the DT 37231 2332 123 second second JJ 37231 2332 124 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2332 125 is be VBZ 37231 2332 126 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2332 127 to to IN 37231 2332 128 one one CD 37231 2332 129 who who WP 37231 2332 130 was be VBD 37231 2332 131 not not RB 37231 2332 132 an an DT 37231 2332 133 eye eye NN 37231 2332 134 - - HYPH 37231 2332 135 witness witness NN 37231 2332 136 , , , 37231 2332 137 and and CC 37231 2332 138 of of IN 37231 2332 139 whose whose WP$ 37231 2332 140 identity identity NN 37231 2332 141 there there EX 37231 2332 142 is be VBZ 37231 2332 143 the the DT 37231 2332 144 greatest great JJS 37231 2332 145 doubt doubt NN 37231 2332 146 even even RB 37231 2332 147 amongst amongst IN 37231 2332 148 those those DT 37231 2332 149 who who WP 37231 2332 150 assert assert VBP 37231 2332 151 the the DT 37231 2332 152 authorship authorship NN 37231 2332 153 of of IN 37231 2332 154 Mark Mark NNP 37231 2332 155 ; ; : 37231 2332 156 that that IN 37231 2332 157 the the DT 37231 2332 158 third third JJ 37231 2332 159 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2332 160 is be VBZ 37231 2332 161 an an DT 37231 2332 162 avowed avowed JJ 37231 2332 163 later later JJ 37231 2332 164 compilation,(1 compilation,(1 NNP 37231 2332 165 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2332 166 and and CC 37231 2332 167 likewise likewise RB 37231 2332 168 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2332 169 to to IN 37231 2332 170 one one CD 37231 2332 171 who who WP 37231 2332 172 was be VBD 37231 2332 173 not not RB 37231 2332 174 a a DT 37231 2332 175 follower follower NN 37231 2332 176 of of IN 37231 2332 177 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2332 178 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2332 179 ; ; : 37231 2332 180 and and CC 37231 2332 181 that that IN 37231 2332 182 the the DT 37231 2332 183 authorship authorship NN 37231 2332 184 of of IN 37231 2332 185 the the DT 37231 2332 186 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2332 187 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2332 188 and and CC 37231 2332 189 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2332 190 historical historical JJ 37231 2332 191 character character NN 37231 2332 192 are be VBP 37231 2332 193 amongst amongst IN 37231 2332 194 the the DT 37231 2332 195 most most RBS 37231 2332 196 unsettled unsettled JJ 37231 2332 197 questions question NNS 37231 2332 198 of of IN 37231 2332 199 criticism criticism NN 37231 2332 200 , , , 37231 2332 201 not not RB 37231 2332 202 to to TO 37231 2332 203 use use VB 37231 2332 204 here here RB 37231 2332 205 any any DT 37231 2332 206 more more RBR 37231 2332 207 definite definite JJ 37231 2332 208 terms term NNS 37231 2332 209 . . . 37231 2333 1 This this DT 37231 2333 2 being be VBG 37231 2333 3 the the DT 37231 2333 4 state state NN 37231 2333 5 of of IN 37231 2333 6 the the DT 37231 2333 7 case case NN 37231 2333 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2333 9 is be VBZ 37231 2333 10 absurd absurd JJ 37231 2333 11 to to TO 37231 2333 12 lay lay VB 37231 2333 13 such such JJ 37231 2333 14 emphasis emphasis NN 37231 2333 15 on on IN 37231 2333 16 the the DT 37231 2333 17 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 37231 2333 18 date date NN 37231 2333 19 of of IN 37231 2333 20 the the DT 37231 2333 21 testimony testimony NN 37231 2333 22 , , , 37231 2333 23 and and CC 37231 2333 24 on on IN 37231 2333 25 the the DT 37231 2333 26 character character NN 37231 2333 27 of of IN 37231 2333 28 the the DT 37231 2333 29 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2333 30 , , , 37231 2333 31 since since IN 37231 2333 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2333 33 has have VBZ 37231 2333 34 not not RB 37231 2333 35 even even RB 37231 2333 36 been be VBN 37231 2333 37 determined determine VBN 37231 2333 38 who who WP 37231 2333 39 those those DT 37231 2333 40 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2333 41 are be VBP 37231 2333 42 , , , 37231 2333 43 and and CC 37231 2333 44 two two CD 37231 2333 45 even even RB 37231 2333 46 of of IN 37231 2333 47 the the DT 37231 2333 48 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2333 49 evangelists evangelist NNS 37231 2333 50 were be VBD 37231 2333 51 not not RB 37231 2333 52 personal personal JJ 37231 2333 53 eye eye NN 37231 2333 54 - - : 37231 2333 55 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2333 56 at at RB 37231 2333 57 all all RB 37231 2333 58 . . . 37231 2334 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2334 2 2 2 LS 37231 2334 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2334 4 Surely surely RB 37231 2334 5 the the DT 37231 2334 6 testimony testimony NN 37231 2334 7 of of IN 37231 2334 8 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 2334 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 2334 10 the the DT 37231 2334 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2334 12 of of IN 37231 2334 13 St. St. NNP 37231 2334 14 Anthony Anthony NNP 37231 2334 15 , , , 37231 2334 16 and and CC 37231 2334 17 that that DT 37231 2334 18 of of IN 37231 2334 19 Augustine Augustine NNP 37231 2334 20 regarding regard VBG 37231 2334 21 1 1 CD 37231 2334 22 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2334 23 i. i. NNP 37231 2335 1 1 1 LS 37231 2335 2 - - HYPH 37231 2335 3 -4 -4 NN 37231 2335 4 . . . 37231 2336 1 2 2 LS 37231 2336 2 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2336 3 need need VBP 37231 2336 4 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2336 5 point point VB 37231 2336 6 out out RP 37231 2336 7 that that IN 37231 2336 8 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2336 9 , , , 37231 2336 10 to to IN 37231 2336 11 whom whom WP 37231 2336 12 so so RB 37231 2336 13 many many JJ 37231 2336 14 of of IN 37231 2336 15 the the DT 37231 2336 16 writings writing NNS 37231 2336 17 of of IN 37231 2336 18 the the DT 37231 2336 19 New New NNP 37231 2336 20 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2336 21 are be VBP 37231 2336 22 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2336 23 , , , 37231 2336 24 and and CC 37231 2336 25 who who WP 37231 2336 26 practically practically RB 37231 2336 27 is be VBZ 37231 2336 28 the the DT 37231 2336 29 author author NN 37231 2336 30 of of IN 37231 2336 31 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2336 32 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2336 33 , , , 37231 2336 34 not not RB 37231 2336 35 only only RB 37231 2336 36 was be VBD 37231 2336 37 not not RB 37231 2336 38 an an DT 37231 2336 39 eye eye NN 37231 2336 40 - - HYPH 37231 2336 41 witness witness NN 37231 2336 42 of of IN 37231 2336 43 the the DT 37231 2336 44 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2336 45 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2336 46 but but CC 37231 2336 47 never never RB 37231 2336 48 even even RB 37231 2336 49 saw see VBD 37231 2336 50 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2336 51 . . . 37231 2337 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2337 2 195 195 CD 37231 2337 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2337 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2337 5 list list NN 37231 2337 6 of of IN 37231 2337 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2337 8 occurring occur VBG 37231 2337 9 in in IN 37231 2337 10 or or CC 37231 2337 11 close close VB 37231 2337 12 to to IN 37231 2337 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2337 14 own own JJ 37231 2337 15 diocese diocese NN 37231 2337 16 , , , 37231 2337 17 within within IN 37231 2337 18 two two CD 37231 2337 19 years year NNS 37231 2337 20 of of IN 37231 2337 21 the the DT 37231 2337 22 time time NN 37231 2337 23 at at IN 37231 2337 24 which which WDT 37231 2337 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2337 26 writes write VBZ 37231 2337 27 , , , 37231 2337 28 or or CC 37231 2337 29 , , , 37231 2337 30 to to TO 37231 2337 31 refer refer VB 37231 2337 32 to to IN 37231 2337 33 more more JJR 37231 2337 34 recent recent JJ 37231 2337 35 times time NNS 37231 2337 36 , , , 37231 2337 37 the the DT 37231 2337 38 evidence evidence NN 37231 2337 39 of of IN 37231 2337 40 Pascal Pascal NNP 37231 2337 41 for for IN 37231 2337 42 the the DT 37231 2337 43 Port Port NNP 37231 2337 44 - - HYPH 37231 2337 45 Royal Royal NNP 37231 2337 46 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2337 47 , , , 37231 2337 48 must must MD 37231 2337 49 be be VB 37231 2337 50 admitted admit VBN 37231 2337 51 , , , 37231 2337 52 not not RB 37231 2337 53 only only RB 37231 2337 54 not not RB 37231 2337 55 to to TO 37231 2337 56 present present VB 37231 2337 57 the the DT 37231 2337 58 broad broad JJ 37231 2337 59 distinction distinction NN 37231 2337 60 of of IN 37231 2337 61 evidence evidence NN 37231 2337 62 of of IN 37231 2337 63 which which WDT 37231 2337 64 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2337 65 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2337 66 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2337 67 , , , 37231 2337 68 but but CC 37231 2337 69 on on IN 37231 2337 70 the the DT 37231 2337 71 contrary contrary NN 37231 2337 72 to to TO 37231 2337 73 be be VB 37231 2337 74 even even RB 37231 2337 75 more more RBR 37231 2337 76 unassailable unassailable JJ 37231 2337 77 than than IN 37231 2337 78 that that DT 37231 2337 79 of of IN 37231 2337 80 the the DT 37231 2337 81 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2337 82 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2337 83 . . . 37231 2338 1 The the DT 37231 2338 2 Church Church NNP 37231 2338 3 , , , 37231 2338 4 which which WDT 37231 2338 5 is be VBZ 37231 2338 6 the the DT 37231 2338 7 authority authority NN 37231 2338 8 for for IN 37231 2338 9 those those DT 37231 2338 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2338 11 , , , 37231 2338 12 is be VBZ 37231 2338 13 also also RB 37231 2338 14 the the DT 37231 2338 15 authority authority NN 37231 2338 16 for for IN 37231 2338 17 the the DT 37231 2338 18 long long JJ 37231 2338 19 succession succession NN 37231 2338 20 of of IN 37231 2338 21 such such JJ 37231 2338 22 works work NNS 37231 2338 23 wrought work VBN 37231 2338 24 by by IN 37231 2338 25 the the DT 37231 2338 26 saints saint NNS 37231 2338 27 . . . 37231 2339 1 The the DT 37231 2339 2 identity identity NN 37231 2339 3 of of IN 37231 2339 4 the the DT 37231 2339 5 writers writer NNS 37231 2339 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2339 7 have have VBP 37231 2339 8 instanced instance VBN 37231 2339 9 has have VBZ 37231 2339 10 never never RB 37231 2339 11 been be VBN 37231 2339 12 doubted doubt VBN 37231 2339 13 ; ; : 37231 2339 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2339 15 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 37231 2339 16 , , , 37231 2339 17 in in IN 37231 2339 18 so so RB 37231 2339 19 far far RB 37231 2339 20 as as IN 37231 2339 21 stating state VBG 37231 2339 22 what what WP 37231 2339 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2339 24 believe believe VBP 37231 2339 25 to to TO 37231 2339 26 be be VB 37231 2339 27 true true JJ 37231 2339 28 is be VBZ 37231 2339 29 concerned concern VBN 37231 2339 30 , , , 37231 2339 31 has have VBZ 37231 2339 32 never never RB 37231 2339 33 been be VBN 37231 2339 34 impugned impugn VBN 37231 2339 35 ; ; : 37231 2339 36 the the DT 37231 2339 37 same same JJ 37231 2339 38 could could MD 37231 2339 39 be be VB 37231 2339 40 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 2339 41 of of IN 37231 2339 42 writers writer NNS 37231 2339 43 in in IN 37231 2339 44 every every DT 37231 2339 45 age age NN 37231 2339 46 who who WP 37231 2339 47 record record VBP 37231 2339 48 such such JJ 37231 2339 49 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2339 50 . . . 37231 2340 1 The the DT 37231 2340 2 broad broad JJ 37231 2340 3 distinction distinction NN 37231 2340 4 of of IN 37231 2340 5 evidence evidence NN 37231 2340 6 for for IN 37231 2340 7 which which WDT 37231 2340 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2340 9 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2340 10 contends contend VBZ 37231 2340 11 , , , 37231 2340 12 does do VBZ 37231 2340 13 not not RB 37231 2340 14 exist exist VB 37231 2340 15 ; ; : 37231 2340 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2340 17 does do VBZ 37231 2340 18 not not RB 37231 2340 19 lie lie VB 37231 2340 20 within within IN 37231 2340 21 the the DT 37231 2340 22 scope scope NN 37231 2340 23 of of IN 37231 2340 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2340 25 lectures lecture NNS 37231 2340 26 either either CC 37231 2340 27 to to TO 37231 2340 28 define define VB 37231 2340 29 or or CC 37231 2340 30 prove prove VB 37231 2340 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2340 32 , , , 37231 2340 33 and and CC 37231 2340 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2340 35 does do VBZ 37231 2340 36 not not RB 37231 2340 37 of of RB 37231 2340 38 course course RB 37231 2340 39 commit commit VB 37231 2340 40 the the DT 37231 2340 41 error error NN 37231 2340 42 of of IN 37231 2340 43 assuming assume VBG 37231 2340 44 the the DT 37231 2340 45 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 2340 46 of of IN 37231 2340 47 the the DT 37231 2340 48 records record NNS 37231 2340 49 . . . 37231 2341 1 The the DT 37231 2341 2 fact fact NN 37231 2341 3 is be VBZ 37231 2341 4 that that IN 37231 2341 5 theologians theologian NNS 37231 2341 6 demand demand VBP 37231 2341 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 2341 8 for for IN 37231 2341 9 later later JJ 37231 2341 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2341 11 , , , 37231 2341 12 which which WDT 37231 2341 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2341 14 have have VBP 37231 2341 15 not not RB 37231 2341 16 for for IN 37231 2341 17 those those DT 37231 2341 18 of of IN 37231 2341 19 the the DT 37231 2341 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2341 21 , , , 37231 2341 22 and and CC 37231 2341 23 which which WDT 37231 2341 24 transmitted transmit VBD 37231 2341 25 reverence reverence NN 37231 2341 26 forbids forbid VBZ 37231 2341 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2341 28 requiring requiring NN 37231 2341 29 . . . 37231 2342 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 2342 2 strain strain VBP 37231 2342 3 out out RP 37231 2342 4 a a DT 37231 2342 5 gnat gnat NN 37231 2342 6 and and CC 37231 2342 7 swallow swallow VB 37231 2342 8 a a DT 37231 2342 9 camel camel NN 37231 2342 10 . . . 37231 2343 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2343 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2343 3 points point VBZ 37231 2343 4 to to IN 37231 2343 5 the the DT 37231 2343 6 life life NN 37231 2343 7 of of IN 37231 2343 8 sacrifice sacrifice NN 37231 2343 9 and and CC 37231 2343 10 suffering suffering NN 37231 2343 11 of of IN 37231 2343 12 the the DT 37231 2343 13 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2343 14 as as IN 37231 2343 15 a a DT 37231 2343 16 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 2343 17 and and CC 37231 2343 18 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 2343 19 testimony testimony NN 37231 2343 20 to to IN 37231 2343 21 the the DT 37231 2343 22 truth truth NN 37231 2343 23 of of IN 37231 2343 24 the the DT 37231 2343 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2343 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2343 27 , , , 37231 2343 28 and and CC 37231 2343 29 notably notably RB 37231 2343 30 of of IN 37231 2343 31 the the DT 37231 2343 32 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 2343 33 and and CC 37231 2343 34 Ascension Ascension NNP 37231 2343 35 . . . 37231 2344 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2344 2 1 1 LS 37231 2344 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2344 4 Without without IN 37231 2344 5 examining examine VBG 37231 2344 6 , , , 37231 2344 7 here here RB 37231 2344 8 , , , 37231 2344 9 how how WRB 37231 2344 10 much much RB 37231 2344 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2344 12 really really RB 37231 2344 13 know know VBP 37231 2344 14 of of IN 37231 2344 15 those those DT 37231 2344 16 lives life NNS 37231 2344 17 and and CC 37231 2344 18 sufferings suffering NNS 37231 2344 19 , , , 37231 2344 20 one one CD 37231 2344 21 thing thing NN 37231 2344 22 is be VBZ 37231 2344 23 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2344 24 evident evident JJ 37231 2344 25 : : : 37231 2344 26 that that DT 37231 2344 27 sacrifice sacrifice NN 37231 2344 28 , , , 37231 2344 29 suffering suffering NN 37231 2344 30 , , , 37231 2344 31 and and CC 37231 2344 32 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2344 33 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2344 34 are be VBP 37231 2344 35 evidence evidence NN 37231 2344 36 of of IN 37231 2344 37 nothing nothing NN 37231 2344 38 except except IN 37231 2344 39 of of IN 37231 2344 40 the the DT 37231 2344 41 personal personal JJ 37231 2344 42 belief belief NN 37231 2344 43 of of IN 37231 2344 44 the the DT 37231 2344 45 person person NN 37231 2344 46 enduring endure VBG 37231 2344 47 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2344 48 ; ; : 37231 2344 49 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2344 50 do do VBP 37231 2344 51 not not RB 37231 2344 52 prove prove VB 37231 2344 53 the the DT 37231 2344 54 truth truth NN 37231 2344 55 of of IN 37231 2344 56 the the DT 37231 2344 57 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 2344 58 believed believe VBN 37231 2344 59 . . . 37231 2345 1 No no DT 37231 2345 2 { { -LRB- 37231 2345 3 196 196 CD 37231 2345 4 } } -RRB- 37231 2345 5 one one CD 37231 2345 6 doubts doubt VBZ 37231 2345 7 the the DT 37231 2345 8 high high JJ 37231 2345 9 religious religious JJ 37231 2345 10 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 37231 2345 11 of of IN 37231 2345 12 the the DT 37231 2345 13 early early JJ 37231 2345 14 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2345 15 , , , 37231 2345 16 or or CC 37231 2345 17 the the DT 37231 2345 18 earnest earnest JJ 37231 2345 19 and and CC 37231 2345 20 fanatical fanatical JJ 37231 2345 21 zeal zeal NN 37231 2345 22 with with IN 37231 2345 23 which which WDT 37231 2345 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2345 25 courted court VBD 37231 2345 26 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2345 27 , , , 37231 2345 28 but but CC 37231 2345 29 this this DT 37231 2345 30 is be VBZ 37231 2345 31 no no DT 37231 2345 32 exclusive exclusive JJ 37231 2345 33 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 2345 34 of of IN 37231 2345 35 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2345 36 . . . 37231 2346 1 Every every DT 37231 2346 2 religion religion NN 37231 2346 3 has have VBZ 37231 2346 4 had have VBN 37231 2346 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2346 6 martyrs martyr NNS 37231 2346 7 , , , 37231 2346 8 every every DT 37231 2346 9 error error NN 37231 2346 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2346 11 devoted devoted JJ 37231 2346 12 victims victim NNS 37231 2346 13 . . . 37231 2347 1 Does do VBZ 37231 2347 2 the the DT 37231 2347 3 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 2347 4 endurance endurance NN 37231 2347 5 of of IN 37231 2347 6 the the DT 37231 2347 7 Hindoo Hindoo NNP 37231 2347 8 , , , 37231 2347 9 whose whose WP$ 37231 2347 10 limbs limb NNS 37231 2347 11 wither wither VBP 37231 2347 12 after after IN 37231 2347 13 years year NNS 37231 2347 14 of of IN 37231 2347 15 painful painful JJ 37231 2347 16 persistence persistence NN 37231 2347 17 in in IN 37231 2347 18 vows vow NNS 37231 2347 19 to to IN 37231 2347 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2347 21 Deity deity NN 37231 2347 22 , , , 37231 2347 23 prove prove VB 37231 2347 24 the the DT 37231 2347 25 truth truth NN 37231 2347 26 of of IN 37231 2347 27 Brahmanism Brahmanism NNP 37231 2347 28 ? ? . 37231 2348 1 or or CC 37231 2348 2 do do VB 37231 2348 3 the the DT 37231 2348 4 fanatical fanatical JJ 37231 2348 5 believers believer NNS 37231 2348 6 who who WP 37231 2348 7 cast cast VBD 37231 2348 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2348 9 under under IN 37231 2348 10 the the DT 37231 2348 11 wheels wheel NNS 37231 2348 12 of of IN 37231 2348 13 the the DT 37231 2348 14 car car NN 37231 2348 15 of of IN 37231 2348 16 Jagganath Jagganath NNP 37231 2348 17 establish establish VB 37231 2348 18 the the DT 37231 2348 19 soundness soundness NN 37231 2348 20 of of IN 37231 2348 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2348 22 creed creed NN 37231 2348 23 ? ? . 37231 2349 1 Do do VBP 37231 2349 2 the the DT 37231 2349 3 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2349 4 , , , 37231 2349 5 who who WP 37231 2349 6 for for IN 37231 2349 7 centuries century NNS 37231 2349 8 bore bear VBD 37231 2349 9 the the DT 37231 2349 10 fiercest fierce JJS 37231 2349 11 contumelies contumely NNS 37231 2349 12 of of IN 37231 2349 13 the the DT 37231 2349 14 world world NN 37231 2349 15 , , , 37231 2349 16 and and CC 37231 2349 17 were be VBD 37231 2349 18 persecuted persecute VBN 37231 2349 19 , , , 37231 2349 20 hunted hunt VBN 37231 2349 21 , , , 37231 2349 22 and and CC 37231 2349 23 done do VBN 37231 2349 24 to to IN 37231 2349 25 death death NN 37231 2349 26 by by IN 37231 2349 27 every every DT 37231 2349 28 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 2349 29 torture torture NN 37231 2349 30 for for IN 37231 2349 31 persisting persist VBG 37231 2349 32 in in IN 37231 2349 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2349 34 denial denial NN 37231 2349 35 of of IN 37231 2349 36 the the DT 37231 2349 37 truth truth NN 37231 2349 38 of of IN 37231 2349 39 the the DT 37231 2349 40 Incarnation Incarnation NNP 37231 2349 41 , , , 37231 2349 42 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 37231 2349 43 , , , 37231 2349 44 and and CC 37231 2349 45 Ascension ascension NN 37231 2349 46 , , , 37231 2349 47 and and CC 37231 2349 48 in in IN 37231 2349 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2349 50 rejection rejection NN 37231 2349 51 of of IN 37231 2349 52 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2349 53 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2349 54 , , , 37231 2349 55 do do VBP 37231 2349 56 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2349 57 thus thus RB 37231 2349 58 furnish furnish VB 37231 2349 59 a a DT 37231 2349 60 convincing convincing JJ 37231 2349 61 argument argument NN 37231 2349 62 for for IN 37231 2349 63 the the DT 37231 2349 64 truth truth NN 37231 2349 65 of of IN 37231 2349 66 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2349 67 belief belief NN 37231 2349 68 and and CC 37231 2349 69 the the DT 37231 2349 70 falsity falsity NN 37231 2349 71 of of IN 37231 2349 72 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2349 73 ? ? . 37231 2350 1 Or or CC 37231 2350 2 have have VB 37231 2350 3 the the DT 37231 2350 4 thousands thousand NNS 37231 2350 5 who who WP 37231 2350 6 have have VBP 37231 2350 7 been be VBN 37231 2350 8 consigned consign VBN 37231 2350 9 to to IN 37231 2350 10 the the DT 37231 2350 11 stake stake NN 37231 2350 12 by by IN 37231 2350 13 the the DT 37231 2350 14 Christian Christian NNP 37231 2350 15 Church Church NNP 37231 2350 16 herself -PRON- PRP 37231 2350 17 for for IN 37231 2350 18 persisting persist VBG 37231 2350 19 in in IN 37231 2350 20 asserting assert VBG 37231 2350 21 what what WP 37231 2350 22 she -PRON- PRP 37231 2350 23 has have VBZ 37231 2350 24 denounced denounce VBN 37231 2350 25 as as IN 37231 2350 26 damnable damnable JJ 37231 2350 27 heresy heresy NN 37231 2350 28 , , , 37231 2350 29 proved prove VBD 37231 2350 30 the the DT 37231 2350 31 correctness correctness NN 37231 2350 32 of of IN 37231 2350 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2350 34 views view NNS 37231 2350 35 by by IN 37231 2350 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2350 37 sufferings suffering NNS 37231 2350 38 and and CC 37231 2350 39 death death NN 37231 2350 40 ? ? . 37231 2351 1 History history NN 37231 2351 2 is be VBZ 37231 2351 3 full full JJ 37231 2351 4 of of IN 37231 2351 5 the the DT 37231 2351 6 records record NNS 37231 2351 7 of of IN 37231 2351 8 men man NNS 37231 2351 9 who who WP 37231 2351 10 have have VBP 37231 2351 11 honestly honestly RB 37231 2351 12 believed believe VBN 37231 2351 13 every every DT 37231 2351 14 kind kind NN 37231 2351 15 of of IN 37231 2351 16 error error NN 37231 2351 17 and and CC 37231 2351 18 heresy heresy NN 37231 2351 19 , , , 37231 2351 20 and and CC 37231 2351 21 have have VBP 37231 2351 22 been be VBN 37231 2351 23 stedfast stedfast VBN 37231 2351 24 to to IN 37231 2351 25 the the DT 37231 2351 26 death death NN 37231 2351 27 , , , 37231 2351 28 through through IN 37231 2351 29 persecution persecution NN 37231 2351 30 and and CC 37231 2351 31 torture torture NN 37231 2351 32 , , , 37231 2351 33 in in IN 37231 2351 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2351 35 mistaken mistaken JJ 37231 2351 36 belief belief NN 37231 2351 37 . . . 37231 2352 1 There there EX 37231 2352 2 is be VBZ 37231 2352 3 nothing nothing NN 37231 2352 4 so so RB 37231 2352 5 inflexible inflexible JJ 37231 2352 6 as as IN 37231 2352 7 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 2352 8 fanaticism fanaticism NN 37231 2352 9 , , , 37231 2352 10 and and CC 37231 2352 11 persecution persecution NN 37231 2352 12 , , , 37231 2352 13 instead instead RB 37231 2352 14 of of IN 37231 2352 15 extinguishing extinguish VBG 37231 2352 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2352 17 , , , 37231 2352 18 has have VBZ 37231 2352 19 invariably invariably RB 37231 2352 20 been be VBN 37231 2352 21 the the DT 37231 2352 22 most most RBS 37231 2352 23 certain certain JJ 37231 2352 24 means mean NNS 37231 2352 25 of of IN 37231 2352 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2352 27 propagation propagation NN 37231 2352 28 . . . 37231 2353 1 The the DT 37231 2353 2 sufferings suffering NNS 37231 2353 3 of of IN 37231 2353 4 the the DT 37231 2353 5 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 2353 6 , , , 37231 2353 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 2353 8 , , , 37231 2353 9 can can MD 37231 2353 10 not not RB 37231 2353 11 prove prove VB 37231 2353 12 anything anything NN 37231 2353 13 beyond beyond IN 37231 2353 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2353 15 own own JJ 37231 2353 16 belief belief NN 37231 2353 17 , , , 37231 2353 18 and and CC 37231 2353 19 the the DT 37231 2353 20 question question NN 37231 2353 21 what what WP 37231 2353 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2353 23 was be VBD 37231 2353 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2353 25 really really RB 37231 2353 26 did do VBD 37231 2353 27 believe believe VB 37231 2353 28 and and CC 37231 2353 29 suffered suffer VBD 37231 2353 30 for for IN 37231 2353 31 is be VBZ 37231 2353 32 by by IN 37231 2353 33 no no DT 37231 2353 34 means means NN 37231 2353 35 so so RB 37231 2353 36 simple simple JJ 37231 2353 37 as as IN 37231 2353 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2353 39 appears appear VBZ 37231 2353 40 . . . 37231 2354 1 Now now RB 37231 2354 2 the the DT 37231 2354 3 long long JJ 37231 2354 4 succession succession NN 37231 2354 5 of of IN 37231 2354 6 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2354 7 and and CC 37231 2354 8 other other JJ 37231 2354 9 { { -LRB- 37231 2354 10 197 197 CD 37231 2354 11 } } -RRB- 37231 2354 12 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2354 13 has have VBZ 37231 2354 14 an an DT 37231 2354 15 important important JJ 37231 2354 16 bearing bearing NN 37231 2354 17 upon upon IN 37231 2354 18 those those DT 37231 2354 19 of of IN 37231 2354 20 the the DT 37231 2354 21 New New NNP 37231 2354 22 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2354 23 , , , 37231 2354 24 whether whether IN 37231 2354 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2354 26 believe believe VBP 37231 2354 27 or or CC 37231 2354 28 deny deny VBP 37231 2354 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2354 30 reality reality NN 37231 2354 31 . . . 37231 2355 1 If if IN 37231 2355 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2355 3 regard regard VBP 37231 2355 4 the the DT 37231 2355 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2355 6 of of IN 37231 2355 7 Church church NN 37231 2355 8 history history NN 37231 2355 9 to to TO 37231 2355 10 be be VB 37231 2355 11 in in IN 37231 2355 12 the the DT 37231 2355 13 main main JJ 37231 2355 14 real real NN 37231 2355 15 , , , 37231 2355 16 the the DT 37231 2355 17 whole whole JJ 37231 2355 18 force force NN 37231 2355 19 of of IN 37231 2355 20 the the DT 37231 2355 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2355 22 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2355 23 , , , 37231 2355 24 as as IN 37231 2355 25 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 2355 26 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2355 27 evidence evidence NN 37231 2355 28 of of IN 37231 2355 29 a a DT 37231 2355 30 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2355 31 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 2355 32 , , , 37231 2355 33 is be VBZ 37231 2355 34 annihilated annihilate VBN 37231 2355 35 . . . 37231 2356 1 The the DT 37231 2356 2 " " `` 37231 2356 3 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2356 4 credentials credential NNS 37231 2356 5 of of IN 37231 2356 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2356 7 " " '' 37231 2356 8 assume assume VBP 37231 2356 9 a a DT 37231 2356 10 very very RB 37231 2356 11 different different JJ 37231 2356 12 aspect aspect NN 37231 2356 13 when when WRB 37231 2356 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2356 15 are be VBP 37231 2356 16 considered consider VBN 37231 2356 17 from from IN 37231 2356 18 such such PDT 37231 2356 19 a a DT 37231 2356 20 point point NN 37231 2356 21 of of IN 37231 2356 22 view view NN 37231 2356 23 . . . 37231 2357 1 Admitted admit VBN 37231 2357 2 to to TO 37231 2357 3 be be VB 37231 2357 4 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2357 5 recognizable recognizable JJ 37231 2357 6 from from IN 37231 2357 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2357 8 wrought work VBN 37231 2357 9 by by IN 37231 2357 10 Satanic satanic JJ 37231 2357 11 agency agency NN 37231 2357 12 , , , 37231 2357 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2357 14 are be VBP 37231 2357 15 seen see VBN 37231 2357 16 to to TO 37231 2357 17 be be VB 37231 2357 18 a a DT 37231 2357 19 continuation continuation NN 37231 2357 20 of of IN 37231 2357 21 wonders wonder NNS 37231 2357 22 recorded record VBN 37231 2357 23 in in IN 37231 2357 24 the the DT 37231 2357 25 Old Old NNP 37231 2357 26 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2357 27 , , , 37231 2357 28 to to TO 37231 2357 29 be be VB 37231 2357 30 preceded precede VBN 37231 2357 31 and and CC 37231 2357 32 accompanied accompany VBN 37231 2357 33 by by IN 37231 2357 34 pretension pretension NN 37231 2357 35 to to IN 37231 2357 36 similar similar JJ 37231 2357 37 power power NN 37231 2357 38 on on IN 37231 2357 39 the the DT 37231 2357 40 part part NN 37231 2357 41 of of IN 37231 2357 42 the the DT 37231 2357 43 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2357 44 and and CC 37231 2357 45 other other JJ 37231 2357 46 nations nation NNS 37231 2357 47 , , , 37231 2357 48 and and CC 37231 2357 49 to to TO 37231 2357 50 be be VB 37231 2357 51 succeeded succeed VBN 37231 2357 52 by by IN 37231 2357 53 cycles cycle NNS 37231 2357 54 of of IN 37231 2357 55 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2357 56 , , , 37231 2357 57 in in IN 37231 2357 58 all all DT 37231 2357 59 essential essential JJ 37231 2357 60 respects respect VBZ 37231 2357 61 the the DT 37231 2357 62 same same JJ 37231 2357 63 , , , 37231 2357 64 performed perform VBD 37231 2357 65 subsequently subsequently RB 37231 2357 66 for for IN 37231 2357 67 upwards upward NNS 37231 2357 68 of of IN 37231 2357 69 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 2357 70 hundred hundred CD 37231 2357 71 years year NNS 37231 2357 72 . . . 37231 2358 1 Supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2358 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 2358 3 of of IN 37231 2358 4 so so RB 37231 2358 5 common common JJ 37231 2358 6 and and CC 37231 2358 7 prodigal prodigal JJ 37231 2358 8 a a DT 37231 2358 9 nature nature NN 37231 2358 10 certainly certainly RB 37231 2358 11 betrays betray VBZ 37231 2358 12 a a DT 37231 2358 13 great great JJ 37231 2358 14 want want NN 37231 2358 15 of of IN 37231 2358 16 force force NN 37231 2358 17 and and CC 37231 2358 18 divine divine JJ 37231 2358 19 speciality speciality NN 37231 2358 20 . . . 37231 2359 1 How how WRB 37231 2359 2 could could MD 37231 2359 3 that that DT 37231 2359 4 be be VB 37231 2359 5 considered consider VBN 37231 2359 6 as as IN 37231 2359 7 express express JJ 37231 2359 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 2359 9 for for IN 37231 2359 10 a a DT 37231 2359 11 new new JJ 37231 2359 12 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2359 13 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 2359 14 which which WDT 37231 2359 15 was be VBD 37231 2359 16 already already RB 37231 2359 17 so so RB 37231 2359 18 well well RB 37231 2359 19 known known JJ 37231 2359 20 to to IN 37231 2359 21 the the DT 37231 2359 22 world world NN 37231 2359 23 , , , 37231 2359 24 and and CC 37231 2359 25 which which WDT 37231 2359 26 is be VBZ 37231 2359 27 scattered scatter VBN 37231 2359 28 broad broad RB 37231 2359 29 - - HYPH 37231 2359 30 cast cast VBN 37231 2359 31 over over IN 37231 2359 32 so so RB 37231 2359 33 many many JJ 37231 2359 34 centuries century NNS 37231 2359 35 , , , 37231 2359 36 as as RB 37231 2359 37 well well RB 37231 2359 38 as as IN 37231 2359 39 successfully successfully RB 37231 2359 40 simulated simulate VBN 37231 2359 41 by by IN 37231 2359 42 Satan Satan NNP 37231 2359 43 ? ? . 37231 2360 1 If if IN 37231 2360 2 , , , 37231 2360 3 on on IN 37231 2360 4 the the DT 37231 2360 5 other other JJ 37231 2360 6 hand hand NN 37231 2360 7 , , , 37231 2360 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2360 9 dismiss dismiss VBP 37231 2360 10 the the DT 37231 2360 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2360 12 of of IN 37231 2360 13 later later JJ 37231 2360 14 ages age NNS 37231 2360 15 as as IN 37231 2360 16 false false JJ 37231 2360 17 , , , 37231 2360 18 and and CC 37231 2360 19 as as IN 37231 2360 20 merely merely RB 37231 2360 21 the the DT 37231 2360 22 creations creation NNS 37231 2360 23 of of IN 37231 2360 24 superstition superstition NN 37231 2360 25 or or CC 37231 2360 26 pious pious JJ 37231 2360 27 imagination imagination NN 37231 2360 28 , , , 37231 2360 29 how how WRB 37231 2360 30 can can MD 37231 2360 31 the the DT 37231 2360 32 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2360 33 of of IN 37231 2360 34 the the DT 37231 2360 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2360 36 , , , 37231 2360 37 which which WDT 37231 2360 38 are be VBP 37231 2360 39 precisely precisely RB 37231 2360 40 the the DT 37231 2360 41 same same JJ 37231 2360 42 in in IN 37231 2360 43 type type NN 37231 2360 44 , , , 37231 2360 45 and and CC 37231 2360 46 not not RB 37231 2360 47 better better RB 37231 2360 48 established establish VBN 37231 2360 49 as as IN 37231 2360 50 facts fact NNS 37231 2360 51 , , , 37231 2360 52 remain remain VB 37231 2360 53 unshaken unshaken JJ 37231 2360 54 ? ? . 37231 2361 1 The the DT 37231 2361 2 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2361 3 and and CC 37231 2361 4 Evangelists Evangelists NNPS 37231 2361 5 were be VBD 37231 2361 6 men man NNS 37231 2361 7 of of IN 37231 2361 8 like like JJ 37231 2361 9 passions passion NNS 37231 2361 10 , , , 37231 2361 11 and and CC 37231 2361 12 also also RB 37231 2361 13 of of IN 37231 2361 14 like like JJ 37231 2361 15 superstitions superstition NNS 37231 2361 16 with with IN 37231 2361 17 others other NNS 37231 2361 18 of of IN 37231 2361 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2361 20 time time NN 37231 2361 21 , , , 37231 2361 22 and and CC 37231 2361 23 must must MD 37231 2361 24 be be VB 37231 2361 25 measured measure VBN 37231 2361 26 by by IN 37231 2361 27 the the DT 37231 2361 28 same same JJ 37231 2361 29 standard standard NN 37231 2361 30 . . . 37231 2362 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2362 2 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2362 3 will will MD 37231 2362 4 not not RB 37231 2362 5 admit admit VB 37231 2362 6 that that IN 37231 2362 7 , , , 37231 2362 8 even even RB 37231 2362 9 in in IN 37231 2362 10 such such PDT 37231 2362 11 a a DT 37231 2362 12 case case NN 37231 2362 13 , , , 37231 2362 14 the the DT 37231 2362 15 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 2362 16 of of IN 37231 2362 17 distinguishing distinguish VBG 37231 2362 18 the the DT 37231 2362 19 true true JJ 37231 2362 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2362 21 amongst amongst IN 37231 2362 22 the the DT 37231 2362 23 mass mass NN 37231 2362 24 of of IN 37231 2362 25 { { -LRB- 37231 2362 26 198 198 CD 37231 2362 27 } } -RRB- 37231 2362 28 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2362 29 justifies justifie NNS 37231 2362 30 the the DT 37231 2362 31 rejection rejection NN 37231 2362 32 of of IN 37231 2362 33 all all DT 37231 2362 34 , , , 37231 2362 35 and and CC 37231 2362 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2362 37 demands demand VBZ 37231 2362 38 a a DT 37231 2362 39 judicial judicial JJ 37231 2362 40 process process NN 37231 2362 41 in in IN 37231 2362 42 each each DT 37231 2362 43 case case NN 37231 2362 44 , , , 37231 2362 45 and and CC 37231 2362 46 settlement settlement NN 37231 2362 47 according accord VBG 37231 2362 48 to to IN 37231 2362 49 the the DT 37231 2362 50 evidence evidence NN 37231 2362 51 in in IN 37231 2362 52 that that DT 37231 2362 53 case case NN 37231 2362 54 . . . 37231 2363 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2363 2 1 1 LS 37231 2363 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2363 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2363 5 might may MD 37231 2363 6 reply reply VB 37231 2363 7 that that IN 37231 2363 8 if if IN 37231 2363 9 the the DT 37231 2363 10 great great JJ 37231 2363 11 mass mass NN 37231 2363 12 of of IN 37231 2363 13 asserted assert VBN 37231 2363 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2363 15 be be VB 37231 2363 16 determined determined JJ 37231 2363 17 to to TO 37231 2363 18 be be VB 37231 2363 19 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2363 20 , , , 37231 2363 21 there there EX 37231 2363 22 is be VBZ 37231 2363 23 no no DT 37231 2363 24 reason reason NN 37231 2363 25 shown show VBN 37231 2363 26 for for IN 37231 2363 27 entering enter VBG 37231 2363 28 upon upon IN 37231 2363 29 a a DT 37231 2363 30 more more RBR 37231 2363 31 minute minute JJ 37231 2363 32 consideration consideration NN 37231 2363 33 of of IN 37231 2363 34 pretensions pretension NNS 37231 2363 35 , , , 37231 2363 36 which which WDT 37231 2363 37 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2363 38 and and CC 37231 2363 39 experience experience NN 37231 2363 40 force force VBP 37231 2363 41 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2363 42 _ _ NNP 37231 2363 43 à à NNP 37231 2363 44 priori priori VBP 37231 2363 45 _ _ NNP 37231 2363 46 to to TO 37231 2363 47 regard regard VB 37231 2363 48 as as IN 37231 2363 49 incredible incredible JJ 37231 2363 50 , , , 37231 2363 51 and and CC 37231 2363 52 which which WDT 37231 2363 53 examination examination NN 37231 2363 54 , , , 37231 2363 55 in in IN 37231 2363 56 so so RB 37231 2363 57 many many JJ 37231 2363 58 cases case NNS 37231 2363 59 , , , 37231 2363 60 has have VBZ 37231 2363 61 proved prove VBN 37231 2363 62 to to TO 37231 2363 63 be be VB 37231 2363 64 delusion delusion NN 37231 2363 65 . . . 37231 2364 1 Even even RB 37231 2364 2 if if IN 37231 2364 3 the the DT 37231 2364 4 plea plea NN 37231 2364 5 , , , 37231 2364 6 that that IN 37231 2364 7 " " `` 37231 2364 8 the the DT 37231 2364 9 evidence evidence NN 37231 2364 10 of of IN 37231 2364 11 the the DT 37231 2364 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2364 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2364 14 is be VBZ 37231 2364 15 a a DT 37231 2364 16 special special JJ 37231 2364 17 case case NN 37231 2364 18 which which WDT 37231 2364 19 must must MD 37231 2364 20 be be VB 37231 2364 21 decided decide VBN 37231 2364 22 on on IN 37231 2364 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2364 24 own own JJ 37231 2364 25 grounds ground NNS 37231 2364 26 , , , 37231 2364 27 " " '' 37231 2364 28 be be VB 37231 2364 29 admitted admit VBN 37231 2364 30 , , , 37231 2364 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2364 32 must must MD 37231 2364 33 be be VB 37231 2364 34 apparent apparent JJ 37231 2364 35 that that IN 37231 2364 36 the the DT 37231 2364 37 rejection rejection NN 37231 2364 38 of of IN 37231 2364 39 the the DT 37231 2364 40 mass mass NN 37231 2364 41 of of IN 37231 2364 42 other other JJ 37231 2364 43 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2364 44 is be VBZ 37231 2364 45 serious serious JJ 37231 2364 46 presumptive presumptive JJ 37231 2364 47 evidence evidence NN 37231 2364 48 also also RB 37231 2364 49 against against IN 37231 2364 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2364 51 . . . 37231 2365 1 2 2 LS 37231 2365 2 . . . 37231 2366 1 The the DT 37231 2366 2 argument argument NN 37231 2366 3 for for IN 37231 2366 4 the the DT 37231 2366 5 reality reality NN 37231 2366 6 of of IN 37231 2366 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2366 8 receives receive VBZ 37231 2366 9 very very RB 37231 2366 10 little little JJ 37231 2366 11 strength strength NN 37231 2366 12 from from IN 37231 2366 13 the the DT 37231 2366 14 character character NN 37231 2366 15 of of IN 37231 2366 16 either either CC 37231 2366 17 the the DT 37231 2366 18 early early JJ 37231 2366 19 or or CC 37231 2366 20 the the DT 37231 2366 21 later later JJ 37231 2366 22 ages age NNS 37231 2366 23 of of IN 37231 2366 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2366 25 . . . 37231 2367 1 " " `` 37231 2367 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2367 3 is be VBZ 37231 2367 4 but but CC 37231 2367 5 too too RB 37231 2367 6 plain plain JJ 37231 2367 7 , , , 37231 2367 8 " " '' 37231 2367 9 says say VBZ 37231 2367 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2367 11 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2367 12 , , , 37231 2367 13 " " '' 37231 2367 14 in in IN 37231 2367 15 discussing discuss VBG 37231 2367 16 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2367 17 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2367 18 , , , 37231 2367 19 that that IN 37231 2367 20 in in IN 37231 2367 21 later later JJ 37231 2367 22 ages age NNS 37231 2367 23 , , , 37231 2367 24 as as IN 37231 2367 25 the the DT 37231 2367 26 Church Church NNP 37231 2367 27 advanced advance VBD 37231 2367 28 in in IN 37231 2367 29 worldly worldly JJ 37231 2367 30 power power NN 37231 2367 31 and and CC 37231 2367 32 position position NN 37231 2367 33 , , , 37231 2367 34 besides besides IN 37231 2367 35 the the DT 37231 2367 36 mistakes mistake NNS 37231 2367 37 of of IN 37231 2367 38 imagination imagination NN 37231 2367 39 and and CC 37231 2367 40 impression impression NN 37231 2367 41 , , , 37231 2367 42 a a DT 37231 2367 43 temper temper NN 37231 2367 44 of of IN 37231 2367 45 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 2367 46 and and CC 37231 2367 47 audacious audacious JJ 37231 2367 48 fraud fraud NN 37231 2367 49 set set VBD 37231 2367 50 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2367 51 in in IN 37231 2367 52 action action NN 37231 2367 53 for for IN 37231 2367 54 the the DT 37231 2367 55 spread spread NN 37231 2367 56 of of IN 37231 2367 57 certain certain JJ 37231 2367 58 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 2367 59 , , , 37231 2367 60 as as RB 37231 2367 61 well well RB 37231 2367 62 as as IN 37231 2367 63 for for IN 37231 2367 64 the the DT 37231 2367 65 great great JJ 37231 2367 66 object object NN 37231 2367 67 of of IN 37231 2367 68 the the DT 37231 2367 69 concentration concentration NN 37231 2367 70 of of IN 37231 2367 71 Church Church NNP 37231 2367 72 power power NN 37231 2367 73 in in IN 37231 2367 74 one one CD 37231 2367 75 absolute absolute JJ 37231 2367 76 monarchy monarchy NN 37231 2367 77 . . . 37231 2368 1 " " `` 37231 2368 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2368 3 2 2 LS 37231 2368 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2368 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2368 6 have have VBP 37231 2368 7 already already RB 37231 2368 8 quoted quote VBN 37231 2368 9 words word NNS 37231 2368 10 of of IN 37231 2368 11 Dean Dean NNP 37231 2368 12 Milman Milman NNP 37231 2368 13 regarding regard VBG 37231 2368 14 the the DT 37231 2368 15 frame frame NN 37231 2368 16 of of IN 37231 2368 17 mind mind NN 37231 2368 18 of of IN 37231 2368 19 the the DT 37231 2368 20 early early JJ 37231 2368 21 Church Church NNP 37231 2368 22 , , , 37231 2368 23 and and CC 37231 2368 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2368 25 may may MD 37231 2368 26 not not RB 37231 2368 27 be be VB 37231 2368 28 out out IN 37231 2368 29 of of IN 37231 2368 30 place place NN 37231 2368 31 to to TO 37231 2368 32 add add VB 37231 2368 33 a a DT 37231 2368 34 few few JJ 37231 2368 35 lines line NNS 37231 2368 36 from from IN 37231 2368 37 the the DT 37231 2368 38 same same JJ 37231 2368 39 writer writer NN 37231 2368 40 . . . 37231 2369 1 Speaking speak VBG 37231 2369 2 of of IN 37231 2369 3 the the DT 37231 2369 4 writings writing NNS 37231 2369 5 of of IN 37231 2369 6 the the DT 37231 2369 7 first first JJ 37231 2369 8 ages age NNS 37231 2369 9 of of IN 37231 2369 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2369 11 , , , 37231 2369 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2369 13 says say VBZ 37231 2369 14 : : : 37231 2369 15 " " `` 37231 2369 16 That that IN 37231 2369 17 some some DT 37231 2369 18 of of IN 37231 2369 19 the the DT 37231 2369 20 Christian christian JJ 37231 2369 21 legends legend NNS 37231 2369 22 were be VBD 37231 2369 23 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 2369 24 forgeries forgery NNS 37231 2369 25 can can MD 37231 2369 26 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2369 27 be be VB 37231 2369 28 questioned question VBN 37231 2369 29 ; ; : 37231 2369 30 the the DT 37231 2369 31 principle principle NN 37231 2369 32 of of IN 37231 2369 33 pious pious JJ 37231 2369 34 fraud fraud NN 37231 2369 35 { { -LRB- 37231 2369 36 199 199 CD 37231 2369 37 } } -RRB- 37231 2369 38 appeared appear VBD 37231 2369 39 to to TO 37231 2369 40 justify justify VB 37231 2369 41 this this DT 37231 2369 42 mode mode NN 37231 2369 43 of of IN 37231 2369 44 working work VBG 37231 2369 45 on on IN 37231 2369 46 the the DT 37231 2369 47 popular popular JJ 37231 2369 48 mind mind NN 37231 2369 49 ; ; : 37231 2369 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2369 51 was be VBD 37231 2369 52 admitted admit VBN 37231 2369 53 and and CC 37231 2369 54 avowed avow VBN 37231 2369 55 . . . 37231 2370 1 To to TO 37231 2370 2 deceive deceive VB 37231 2370 3 into into IN 37231 2370 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2370 5 was be VBD 37231 2370 6 so so RB 37231 2370 7 valuable valuable JJ 37231 2370 8 a a DT 37231 2370 9 service service NN 37231 2370 10 as as IN 37231 2370 11 to to TO 37231 2370 12 hallow hallow VB 37231 2370 13 deceit deceit NNP 37231 2370 14 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2370 15 . . . 37231 2371 1 But but CC 37231 2371 2 the the DT 37231 2371 3 largest large JJS 37231 2371 4 portion portion NN 37231 2371 5 was be VBD 37231 2371 6 probably probably RB 37231 2371 7 the the DT 37231 2371 8 natural natural JJ 37231 2371 9 birth birth NN 37231 2371 10 of of IN 37231 2371 11 that that DT 37231 2371 12 imaginative imaginative JJ 37231 2371 13 excitement excitement NN 37231 2371 14 which which WDT 37231 2371 15 quickens quicken VBZ 37231 2371 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2371 17 day day NN 37231 2371 18 - - HYPH 37231 2371 19 dreams dream NNS 37231 2371 20 and and CC 37231 2371 21 nightly nightly JJ 37231 2371 22 visions vision NNS 37231 2371 23 into into IN 37231 2371 24 reality reality NN 37231 2371 25 . . . 37231 2372 1 The the DT 37231 2372 2 Christian Christian NNP 37231 2372 3 lived live VBD 37231 2372 4 in in IN 37231 2372 5 a a DT 37231 2372 6 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2372 7 world world NN 37231 2372 8 ; ; , 37231 2372 9 the the DT 37231 2372 10 notion notion NN 37231 2372 11 of of IN 37231 2372 12 the the DT 37231 2372 13 divine divine JJ 37231 2372 14 power power NN 37231 2372 15 , , , 37231 2372 16 the the DT 37231 2372 17 perpetual perpetual JJ 37231 2372 18 interference interference NN 37231 2372 19 of of IN 37231 2372 20 the the DT 37231 2372 21 Deity Deity NNP 37231 2372 22 , , , 37231 2372 23 the the DT 37231 2372 24 agency agency NN 37231 2372 25 of of IN 37231 2372 26 the the DT 37231 2372 27 countless countless JJ 37231 2372 28 invisible invisible JJ 37231 2372 29 beings being NNS 37231 2372 30 which which WDT 37231 2372 31 hovered hover VBD 37231 2372 32 over over IN 37231 2372 33 mankind mankind NN 37231 2372 34 , , , 37231 2372 35 was be VBD 37231 2372 36 so so RB 37231 2372 37 strongly strongly RB 37231 2372 38 impressed impressed JJ 37231 2372 39 upon upon IN 37231 2372 40 the the DT 37231 2372 41 belief belief NN 37231 2372 42 , , , 37231 2372 43 that that IN 37231 2372 44 every every DT 37231 2372 45 extraordinary extraordinary NN 37231 2372 46 , , , 37231 2372 47 and and CC 37231 2372 48 almost almost RB 37231 2372 49 every every DT 37231 2372 50 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 2372 51 incident incident NN 37231 2372 52 became become VBD 37231 2372 53 a a DT 37231 2372 54 miracle miracle NN 37231 2372 55 , , , 37231 2372 56 every every DT 37231 2372 57 inward inward JJ 37231 2372 58 emotion emotion NN 37231 2372 59 a a DT 37231 2372 60 suggestion suggestion NN 37231 2372 61 either either CC 37231 2372 62 of of IN 37231 2372 63 a a DT 37231 2372 64 good good JJ 37231 2372 65 or or CC 37231 2372 66 an an DT 37231 2372 67 evil evil JJ 37231 2372 68 spirit spirit NN 37231 2372 69 . . . 37231 2373 1 A a DT 37231 2373 2 mythic mythic JJ 37231 2373 3 period period NN 37231 2373 4 was be VBD 37231 2373 5 thus thus RB 37231 2373 6 gradually gradually RB 37231 2373 7 formed form VBN 37231 2373 8 , , , 37231 2373 9 in in IN 37231 2373 10 which which WDT 37231 2373 11 reality reality NN 37231 2373 12 melted melt VBN 37231 2373 13 into into IN 37231 2373 14 fable fable JJ 37231 2373 15 , , , 37231 2373 16 and and CC 37231 2373 17 invention invention NN 37231 2373 18 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 2373 19 trespassed trespass VBD 37231 2373 20 on on IN 37231 2373 21 the the DT 37231 2373 22 province province NN 37231 2373 23 of of IN 37231 2373 24 history history NN 37231 2373 25 . . . 37231 2374 1 " " `` 37231 2374 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2374 3 1 1 LS 37231 2374 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2374 5 Whether whether IN 37231 2374 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2374 7 look look VBP 37231 2374 8 upon upon IN 37231 2374 9 this this DT 37231 2374 10 picture picture NN 37231 2374 11 or or CC 37231 2374 12 on on IN 37231 2374 13 that that DT 37231 2374 14 , , , 37231 2374 15 the the DT 37231 2374 16 result result NN 37231 2374 17 is be VBZ 37231 2374 18 equally equally RB 37231 2374 19 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 37231 2374 20 to to IN 37231 2374 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2374 22 , , , 37231 2374 23 and and CC 37231 2374 24 a a DT 37231 2374 25 ready ready JJ 37231 2374 26 explanation explanation NN 37231 2374 27 both both DT 37231 2374 28 of of IN 37231 2374 29 the the DT 37231 2374 30 earlier early JJR 37231 2374 31 and and CC 37231 2374 32 later later RB 37231 2374 33 instances instance NNS 37231 2374 34 is be VBZ 37231 2374 35 suggested suggest VBN 37231 2374 36 . . . 37231 2375 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2375 2 must must MD 37231 2375 3 , , , 37231 2375 4 however however RB 37231 2375 5 , , , 37231 2375 6 again again RB 37231 2375 7 recall recall VBP 37231 2375 8 the the DT 37231 2375 9 fact fact NN 37231 2375 10 that that IN 37231 2375 11 , , , 37231 2375 12 setting set VBG 37231 2375 13 aside aside RB 37231 2375 14 for for IN 37231 2375 15 the the DT 37231 2375 16 present present NN 37231 2375 17 the the DT 37231 2375 18 effect effect NN 37231 2375 19 of of IN 37231 2375 20 pious pious JJ 37231 2375 21 fraud fraud NN 37231 2375 22 , , , 37231 2375 23 this this DT 37231 2375 24 vivid vivid JJ 37231 2375 25 and and CC 37231 2375 26 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 2375 27 imagination imagination NN 37231 2375 28 , , , 37231 2375 29 which which WDT 37231 2375 30 so so RB 37231 2375 31 freely freely RB 37231 2375 32 created create VBD 37231 2375 33 for for IN 37231 2375 34 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2375 35 the the DT 37231 2375 36 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2375 37 , , , 37231 2375 38 was be VBD 37231 2375 39 not not RB 37231 2375 40 merely merely RB 37231 2375 41 developed develop VBN 37231 2375 42 by by IN 37231 2375 43 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2375 44 , , , 37231 2375 45 but but CC 37231 2375 46 was be VBD 37231 2375 47 equally equally RB 37231 2375 48 rampant rampant JJ 37231 2375 49 before before IN 37231 2375 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2375 51 , , , 37231 2375 52 and and CC 37231 2375 53 was be VBD 37231 2375 54 a a DT 37231 2375 55 marked mark VBN 37231 2375 56 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 2375 57 of of IN 37231 2375 58 the the DT 37231 2375 59 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2375 60 . . . 37231 2376 1 The the DT 37231 2376 2 same same JJ 37231 2376 3 writer writer NN 37231 2376 4 , , , 37231 2376 5 in in IN 37231 2376 6 a a DT 37231 2376 7 passage passage NN 37231 2376 8 already already RB 37231 2376 9 quoted quote VBN 37231 2376 10 , , , 37231 2376 11 says say VBZ 37231 2376 12 : : : 37231 2376 13 " " `` 37231 2376 14 During during IN 37231 2376 15 the the DT 37231 2376 16 whole whole JJ 37231 2376 17 life life NN 37231 2376 18 of of IN 37231 2376 19 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2376 20 , , , 37231 2376 21 and and CC 37231 2376 22 the the DT 37231 2376 23 early early JJ 37231 2376 24 propagation propagation NN 37231 2376 25 of of IN 37231 2376 26 the the DT 37231 2376 27 religion religion NN 37231 2376 28 , , , 37231 2376 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2376 30 must must MD 37231 2376 31 be be VB 37231 2376 32 borne bear VBN 37231 2376 33 in in IN 37231 2376 34 mind mind NN 37231 2376 35 that that IN 37231 2376 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2376 37 took take VBD 37231 2376 38 place place NN 37231 2376 39 in in IN 37231 2376 40 an an DT 37231 2376 41 age age NN 37231 2376 42 , , , 37231 2376 43 and and CC 37231 2376 44 among among IN 37231 2376 45 a a DT 37231 2376 46 people people NNS 37231 2376 47 which which WDT 37231 2376 48 superstition superstition NN 37231 2376 49 had have VBD 37231 2376 50 made make VBN 37231 2376 51 so so RB 37231 2376 52 familiar familiar JJ 37231 2376 53 with with IN 37231 2376 54 what what WP 37231 2376 55 were be VBD 37231 2376 56 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2376 57 to to TO 37231 2376 58 be be VB 37231 2376 59 preternatural preternatural JJ 37231 2376 60 events event NNS 37231 2376 61 , , , 37231 2376 62 that that WDT 37231 2376 63 wonders wonder NNS 37231 2376 64 awakened awaken VBD 37231 2376 65 no no DT 37231 2376 66 emotion emotion NN 37231 2376 67 , , , 37231 2376 68 or or CC 37231 2376 69 were be VBD 37231 2376 70 speedily speedily RB 37231 2376 71 superseded supersede VBN 37231 2376 72 by by IN 37231 2376 73 some some DT 37231 2376 74 new new JJ 37231 2376 75 demand demand NN 37231 2376 76 on on IN 37231 2376 77 the the DT 37231 2376 78 ever ever RB 37231 2376 79 { { -LRB- 37231 2376 80 200 200 CD 37231 2376 81 } } -RRB- 37231 2376 82 ready ready JJ 37231 2376 83 belief belief NN 37231 2376 84 . . . 37231 2377 1 The the DT 37231 2377 2 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2377 3 of of IN 37231 2377 4 that that DT 37231 2377 5 period period NN 37231 2377 6 not not RB 37231 2377 7 only only RB 37231 2377 8 believed believe VBD 37231 2377 9 that that IN 37231 2377 10 the the DT 37231 2377 11 Supreme Supreme NNP 37231 2377 12 Being Being NNP 37231 2377 13 had have VBD 37231 2377 14 the the DT 37231 2377 15 power power NN 37231 2377 16 of of IN 37231 2377 17 controlling control VBG 37231 2377 18 the the DT 37231 2377 19 course course NN 37231 2377 20 of of IN 37231 2377 21 nature nature NN 37231 2377 22 , , , 37231 2377 23 but but CC 37231 2377 24 that that IN 37231 2377 25 the the DT 37231 2377 26 same same JJ 37231 2377 27 influence influence NN 37231 2377 28 was be VBD 37231 2377 29 possessed possess VBN 37231 2377 30 by by IN 37231 2377 31 multitudes multitude NNS 37231 2377 32 of of IN 37231 2377 33 subordinate subordinate JJ 37231 2377 34 spirits spirit NNS 37231 2377 35 , , , 37231 2377 36 both both CC 37231 2377 37 good good JJ 37231 2377 38 and and CC 37231 2377 39 evil evil NN 37231 2377 40 . . . 37231 2378 1 " " `` 37231 2378 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2378 3 1 1 LS 37231 2378 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2378 5 Between between IN 37231 2378 6 the the DT 37231 2378 7 " " `` 37231 2378 8 superstition superstition NN 37231 2378 9 , , , 37231 2378 10 " " '' 37231 2378 11 " " `` 37231 2378 12 imaginative imaginative JJ 37231 2378 13 excitement excitement NN 37231 2378 14 , , , 37231 2378 15 " " '' 37231 2378 16 and and CC 37231 2378 17 " " `` 37231 2378 18 pious pious JJ 37231 2378 19 fraud fraud NN 37231 2378 20 " " '' 37231 2378 21 of of IN 37231 2378 22 the the DT 37231 2378 23 early early JJ 37231 2378 24 Church Church NNP 37231 2378 25 , , , 37231 2378 26 and and CC 37231 2378 27 the the DT 37231 2378 28 " " `` 37231 2378 29 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 2378 30 and and CC 37231 2378 31 audacious audacious JJ 37231 2378 32 fraud fraud NN 37231 2378 33 " " '' 37231 2378 34 of of IN 37231 2378 35 the the DT 37231 2378 36 later later JJ 37231 2378 37 , , , 37231 2378 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2378 39 have have VBP 37231 2378 40 abundant abundant JJ 37231 2378 41 material material NN 37231 2378 42 for for IN 37231 2378 43 the the DT 37231 2378 44 natural natural JJ 37231 2378 45 explanation explanation NN 37231 2378 46 of of IN 37231 2378 47 all all DT 37231 2378 48 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2378 49 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2378 50 , , , 37231 2378 51 without without IN 37231 2378 52 going go VBG 37231 2378 53 to to IN 37231 2378 54 such such PDT 37231 2378 55 an an DT 37231 2378 56 extreme extreme JJ 37231 2378 57 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 2378 58 as as IN 37231 2378 59 exceptions exception NNS 37231 2378 60 to to IN 37231 2378 61 the the DT 37231 2378 62 order order NN 37231 2378 63 of of IN 37231 2378 64 nature nature NN 37231 2378 65 , , , 37231 2378 66 or or CC 37231 2378 67 supposing suppose VBG 37231 2378 68 that that IN 37231 2378 69 a a DT 37231 2378 70 few few JJ 37231 2378 71 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2378 72 can can MD 37231 2378 73 be be VB 37231 2378 74 accepted accept VBN 37231 2378 75 as as IN 37231 2378 76 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2378 77 facts fact NNS 37231 2378 78 , , , 37231 2378 79 whilst whilst IN 37231 2378 80 all all PDT 37231 2378 81 the the DT 37231 2378 82 rest rest NN 37231 2378 83 must must MD 37231 2378 84 be be VB 37231 2378 85 discarded discard VBN 37231 2378 86 as as IN 37231 2378 87 human human JJ 37231 2378 88 fables fable NNS 37231 2378 89 . . . 37231 2379 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2379 2 is be VBZ 37231 2379 3 certain certain JJ 37231 2379 4 that that IN 37231 2379 5 throughout throughout IN 37231 2379 6 the the DT 37231 2379 7 whole whole JJ 37231 2379 8 period period NN 37231 2379 9 during during IN 37231 2379 10 which which WDT 37231 2379 11 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2379 12 are be VBP 37231 2379 13 said say VBN 37231 2379 14 to to TO 37231 2379 15 have have VB 37231 2379 16 been be VBN 37231 2379 17 performed perform VBN 37231 2379 18 , , , 37231 2379 19 gross gross JJ 37231 2379 20 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2379 21 and and CC 37231 2379 22 superstition superstition NN 37231 2379 23 prevailed prevail VBD 37231 2379 24 , , , 37231 2379 25 and and CC 37231 2379 26 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 2379 27 more more RBR 37231 2379 28 so so RB 37231 2379 29 than than IN 37231 2379 30 amongst amongst IN 37231 2379 31 the the DT 37231 2379 32 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2379 33 where where WRB 37231 2379 34 those those DT 37231 2379 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2379 36 occurred occur VBD 37231 2379 37 . . . 37231 2380 1 Almost almost RB 37231 2380 2 every every DT 37231 2380 3 operation operation NN 37231 2380 4 of of IN 37231 2380 5 nature nature NN 37231 2380 6 was be VBD 37231 2380 7 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 37231 2380 8 , , , 37231 2380 9 and and CC 37231 2380 10 everything everything NN 37231 2380 11 which which WDT 37231 2380 12 was be VBD 37231 2380 13 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 37231 2380 14 was be VBD 37231 2380 15 considered consider VBN 37231 2380 16 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2380 17 . . . 37231 2381 1 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 2381 2 seemed seem VBD 37231 2381 3 as as RB 37231 2381 4 credible credible JJ 37231 2381 5 to to IN 37231 2381 6 the the DT 37231 2381 7 mind mind NN 37231 2381 8 of of IN 37231 2381 9 that that DT 37231 2381 10 age age NN 37231 2381 11 as as IN 37231 2381 12 deviations deviation NNS 37231 2381 13 from from IN 37231 2381 14 the the DT 37231 2381 15 order order NN 37231 2381 16 of of IN 37231 2381 17 nature nature NN 37231 2381 18 seem seem VBP 37231 2381 19 incredible incredible JJ 37231 2381 20 in in IN 37231 2381 21 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 2381 22 . . . 37231 2382 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2382 2 is be VBZ 37231 2382 3 a a DT 37231 2382 4 suggestive suggestive JJ 37231 2382 5 fact fact NN 37231 2382 6 that that IN 37231 2382 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2382 8 are be VBP 37231 2382 9 limited limit VBN 37231 2382 10 to to IN 37231 2382 11 periods period NNS 37231 2382 12 when when WRB 37231 2382 13 almost almost RB 37231 2382 14 every every DT 37231 2382 15 common common JJ 37231 2382 16 incident incident NN 37231 2382 17 was be VBD 37231 2382 18 readily readily RB 37231 2382 19 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2382 20 to to IN 37231 2382 21 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2382 22 agency agency NN 37231 2382 23 . . . 37231 2383 1 There there EX 37231 2383 2 is be VBZ 37231 2383 3 , , , 37231 2383 4 however however RB 37231 2383 5 , , , 37231 2383 6 one one CD 37231 2383 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 2383 8 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 2383 9 which which WDT 37231 2383 10 casts cast VBZ 37231 2383 11 some some DT 37231 2383 12 light light NN 37231 2383 13 upon upon IN 37231 2383 14 the the DT 37231 2383 15 origin origin NN 37231 2383 16 of of IN 37231 2383 17 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2383 18 of of IN 37231 2383 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2383 20 . . . 37231 2384 1 Throughout throughout IN 37231 2384 2 the the DT 37231 2384 3 New New NNP 37231 2384 4 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2384 5 , , , 37231 2384 6 patristic patristic JJ 37231 2384 7 literature literature NN 37231 2384 8 , , , 37231 2384 9 and and CC 37231 2384 10 the the DT 37231 2384 11 records record NNS 37231 2384 12 of of IN 37231 2384 13 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2384 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2384 15 , , , 37231 2384 16 although although IN 37231 2384 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2384 18 have have VBP 37231 2384 19 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2384 20 of of IN 37231 2384 21 countless countless JJ 37231 2384 22 wonderful wonderful JJ 37231 2384 23 works work NNS 37231 2384 24 performed perform VBN 37231 2384 25 by by IN 37231 2384 26 others other NNS 37231 2384 27 than than IN 37231 2384 28 the the DT 37231 2384 29 writers writer NNS 37231 2384 30 , , , 37231 2384 31 and and CC 37231 2384 32 abundant abundant JJ 37231 2384 33 assertion assertion NN 37231 2384 34 of of IN 37231 2384 35 the the DT 37231 2384 36 possession possession NN 37231 2384 37 of of IN 37231 2384 38 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2384 39 power power NN 37231 2384 40 by by IN 37231 2384 41 the the DT 37231 2384 42 Church Church NNP 37231 2384 43 , , , 37231 2384 44 there there EX 37231 2384 45 is be VBZ 37231 2384 46 no no DT 37231 2384 47 instance instance NN 37231 2384 48 whatever whatever WDT 37231 2384 49 , , , 37231 2384 50 that that IN 37231 2384 51 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2384 52 can can MD 37231 2384 53 remember remember VB 37231 2384 54 , , , 37231 2384 55 in in IN 37231 2384 56 which which WDT 37231 2384 57 { { -LRB- 37231 2384 58 201 201 CD 37231 2384 59 } } -RRB- 37231 2384 60 a a DT 37231 2384 61 writer writer NN 37231 2384 62 claims claim VBZ 37231 2384 63 to to TO 37231 2384 64 have have VB 37231 2384 65 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2384 66 performed perform VBN 37231 2384 67 a a DT 37231 2384 68 miracle miracle NN 37231 2384 69 . . . 37231 2385 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2385 2 1 1 LS 37231 2385 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2385 4 Wherever wherever WRB 37231 2385 5 there there EX 37231 2385 6 has have VBZ 37231 2385 7 existed exist VBN 37231 2385 8 even even RB 37231 2385 9 the the DT 37231 2385 10 comparatively comparatively RB 37231 2385 11 accurate accurate JJ 37231 2385 12 means mean NNS 37231 2385 13 of of IN 37231 2385 14 information information NN 37231 2385 15 which which WDT 37231 2385 16 a a DT 37231 2385 17 person person NN 37231 2385 18 who who WP 37231 2385 19 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2385 20 performed perform VBD 37231 2385 21 a a DT 37231 2385 22 miracle miracle NN 37231 2385 23 might may MD 37231 2385 24 possess possess VB 37231 2385 25 , , , 37231 2385 26 the the DT 37231 2385 27 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2385 28 entirely entirely RB 37231 2385 29 fails fail VBZ 37231 2385 30 , , , 37231 2385 31 and and CC 37231 2385 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2385 33 is be VBZ 37231 2385 34 found find VBN 37231 2385 35 only only RB 37231 2385 36 where where WRB 37231 2385 37 faith faith NN 37231 2385 38 or or CC 37231 2385 39 credulity credulity NN 37231 2385 40 usurps usurp VBZ 37231 2385 41 the the DT 37231 2385 42 place place NN 37231 2385 43 of of IN 37231 2385 44 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2385 45 . . . 37231 2386 1 Pious pious JJ 37231 2386 2 men man NNS 37231 2386 3 were be VBD 37231 2386 4 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2386 5 ready ready JJ 37231 2386 6 to to TO 37231 2386 7 believe believe VB 37231 2386 8 the the DT 37231 2386 9 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2386 10 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2386 11 of of IN 37231 2386 12 others other NNS 37231 2386 13 , , , 37231 2386 14 and and CC 37231 2386 15 to to TO 37231 2386 16 report report VB 37231 2386 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2386 18 as as IN 37231 2386 19 facts fact NNS 37231 2386 20 , , , 37231 2386 21 who who WP 37231 2386 22 were be VBD 37231 2386 23 too too RB 37231 2386 24 veracious veracious JJ 37231 2386 25 to to TO 37231 2386 26 imagine imagine VB 37231 2386 27 any any DT 37231 2386 28 of of IN 37231 2386 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2386 30 own own JJ 37231 2386 31 . . . 37231 2387 1 Even even RB 37231 2387 2 if if IN 37231 2387 3 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2387 4 and and CC 37231 2387 5 Saints Saints NNPS 37231 2387 6 had have VBD 37231 2387 7 chronicled chronicle VBN 37231 2387 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2387 9 own own JJ 37231 2387 10 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2387 11 deeds deed NNS 37231 2387 12 , , , 37231 2387 13 the the DT 37231 2387 14 argument argument NN 37231 2387 15 for for IN 37231 2387 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2387 17 reality reality NN 37231 2387 18 would would MD 37231 2387 19 not not RB 37231 2387 20 have have VB 37231 2387 21 been be VBN 37231 2387 22 much much RB 37231 2387 23 advanced advanced JJ 37231 2387 24 ; ; : 37231 2387 25 but but CC 37231 2387 26 the the DT 37231 2387 27 uniform uniform JJ 37231 2387 28 absence absence NN 37231 2387 29 of of IN 37231 2387 30 such such JJ 37231 2387 31 personal personal JJ 37231 2387 32 pretension pretension NN 37231 2387 33 enables enable VBZ 37231 2387 34 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2387 35 more more RBR 37231 2387 36 clearly clearly RB 37231 2387 37 to to TO 37231 2387 38 trace trace VB 37231 2387 39 such such JJ 37231 2387 40 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2387 41 to to IN 37231 2387 42 pious pious JJ 37231 2387 43 credulity credulity NN 37231 2387 44 or or CC 37231 2387 45 superstition superstition NN 37231 2387 46 . . . 37231 2388 1 If if IN 37231 2388 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2388 3 consider consider VBP 37231 2388 4 the the DT 37231 2388 5 particular particular JJ 37231 2388 6 part part NN 37231 2388 7 which which WDT 37231 2388 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2388 9 have have VBP 37231 2388 10 played play VBN 37231 2388 11 in in IN 37231 2388 12 human human JJ 37231 2388 13 history history NN 37231 2388 14 , , , 37231 2388 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2388 16 find find VBP 37231 2388 17 precisely precisely RB 37231 2388 18 the the DT 37231 2388 19 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2388 20 which which WDT 37231 2388 21 might may MD 37231 2388 22 have have VB 37231 2388 23 been be VBN 37231 2388 24 expected expect VBN 37231 2388 25 if if IN 37231 2388 26 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2388 27 , , , 37231 2388 28 instead instead RB 37231 2388 29 of of IN 37231 2388 30 being be VBG 37231 2388 31 considered consider VBN 37231 2388 32 as as IN 37231 2388 33 real real JJ 37231 2388 34 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2388 35 , , , 37231 2388 36 were be VBD 37231 2388 37 recognized recognize VBN 37231 2388 38 as as IN 37231 2388 39 the the DT 37231 2388 40 mistakes mistake NNS 37231 2388 41 or or CC 37231 2388 42 creations creation NNS 37231 2388 43 of of IN 37231 2388 44 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2388 45 and and CC 37231 2388 46 superstition superstition NN 37231 2388 47 during during IN 37231 2388 48 that that DT 37231 2388 49 period period NN 37231 2388 50 in in IN 37231 2388 51 which which WDT 37231 2388 52 " " `` 37231 2388 53 reality reality NN 37231 2388 54 melted melt VBN 37231 2388 55 into into IN 37231 2388 56 fable fable JJ 37231 2388 57 , , , 37231 2388 58 and and CC 37231 2388 59 invention invention NN 37231 2388 60 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 2388 61 trespassed trespass VBD 37231 2388 62 on on IN 37231 2388 63 the the DT 37231 2388 64 province province NN 37231 2388 65 of of IN 37231 2388 66 history history NN 37231 2388 67 . . . 37231 2388 68 " " '' 37231 2389 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2389 2 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2389 3 is be VBZ 37231 2389 4 limited limit VBN 37231 2389 5 to to IN 37231 2389 6 ages age NNS 37231 2389 7 which which WDT 37231 2389 8 were be VBD 37231 2389 9 totally totally RB 37231 2389 10 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 2389 11 of of IN 37231 2389 12 physical physical JJ 37231 2389 13 laws law NNS 37231 2389 14 , , , 37231 2389 15 and and CC 37231 2389 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2389 17 have have VBP 37231 2389 18 been be VBN 37231 2389 19 numerous numerous JJ 37231 2389 20 or or CC 37231 2389 21 rare rare JJ 37231 2389 22 precisely precisely RB 37231 2389 23 in in IN 37231 2389 24 proportion proportion NN 37231 2389 25 to to IN 37231 2389 26 the the DT 37231 2389 27 degree degree NN 37231 2389 28 of of IN 37231 2389 29 imagination imagination NN 37231 2389 30 and and CC 37231 2389 31 love love NN 37231 2389 32 of of IN 37231 2389 33 the the DT 37231 2389 34 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 2389 35 characterizing characterize VBG 37231 2389 36 the the DT 37231 2389 37 people people NNS 37231 2389 38 amongst amongst IN 37231 2389 39 whom whom WP 37231 2389 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2389 41 are be VBP 37231 2389 42 said say VBN 37231 2389 43 to to TO 37231 2389 44 have have VB 37231 2389 45 occurred occur VBN 37231 2389 46 . . . 37231 2390 1 Instead instead RB 37231 2390 2 of of IN 37231 2390 3 a a DT 37231 2390 4 few few JJ 37231 2390 5 evidential evidential JJ 37231 2390 6 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2390 7 taking take VBG 37231 2390 8 place place NN 37231 2390 9 at at IN 37231 2390 10 one one CD 37231 2390 11 epoch epoch NN 37231 2390 12 of of IN 37231 2390 13 history history NN 37231 2390 14 , , , 37231 2390 15 and and CC 37231 2390 16 filling fill VBG 37231 2390 17 the the DT 37231 2390 18 world world NN 37231 2390 19 with with IN 37231 2390 20 surprise surprise NN 37231 2390 21 at at IN 37231 2390 22 such such JJ 37231 2390 23 novel novel NN 37231 2390 24 and and CC 37231 2390 25 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 2390 26 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2390 27 , , , 37231 2390 28 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2390 29 find find VBP 37231 2390 30 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2390 31 represented represent VBN 37231 2390 32 as as IN 37231 2390 33 taking take VBG 37231 2390 34 place place NN 37231 2390 35 in in IN 37231 2390 36 all all DT 37231 2390 37 ages age NNS 37231 2390 38 and and CC 37231 2390 39 in in IN 37231 2390 40 all all DT 37231 2390 41 countries country NNS 37231 2390 42 . . . 37231 2391 1 The the DT 37231 2391 2 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2391 3 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2391 4 are be VBP 37231 2391 5 set set VBN 37231 2391 6 in in IN 37231 2391 7 the the DT 37231 2391 8 midst midst NN 37231 2391 9 of of IN 37231 2391 10 a a DT 37231 2391 11 series series NN 37231 2391 12 of of IN 37231 2391 13 similar similar JJ 37231 2391 14 wonders wonder NNS 37231 2391 15 , , , 37231 2391 16 which which WDT 37231 2391 17 commenced commence VBD 37231 2391 18 1 1 CD 37231 2391 19 This this DT 37231 2391 20 is be VBZ 37231 2391 21 fully fully RB 37231 2391 22 discussed discuss VBN 37231 2391 23 in in IN 37231 2391 24 the the DT 37231 2391 25 third third JJ 37231 2391 26 volume volume NN 37231 2391 27 . . . 37231 2392 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2392 2 202 202 CD 37231 2392 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2392 4 many many JJ 37231 2392 5 centuries century NNS 37231 2392 6 before before IN 37231 2392 7 the the DT 37231 2392 8 dawn dawn NN 37231 2392 9 of of IN 37231 2392 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2392 11 and and CC 37231 2392 12 continued continue VBD 37231 2392 13 , , , 37231 2392 14 without without IN 37231 2392 15 interruption interruption NN 37231 2392 16 , , , 37231 2392 17 for for IN 37231 2392 18 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 2392 19 hundred hundred CD 37231 2392 20 years year NNS 37231 2392 21 after after IN 37231 2392 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2392 23 . . . 37231 2393 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 2393 2 did do VBD 37231 2393 3 not not RB 37231 2393 4 in in IN 37231 2393 5 the the DT 37231 2393 6 most most RBS 37231 2393 7 remote remote JJ 37231 2393 8 degree degree NN 37231 2393 9 originate originate VBP 37231 2393 10 the the DT 37231 2393 11 belief belief NN 37231 2393 12 in in IN 37231 2393 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2393 14 , , , 37231 2393 15 or or CC 37231 2393 16 give give VB 37231 2393 17 the the DT 37231 2393 18 first first JJ 37231 2393 19 suggestion suggestion NN 37231 2393 20 of of IN 37231 2393 21 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2393 22 imitation imitation NN 37231 2393 23 . . . 37231 2394 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2394 2 may may MD 37231 2394 3 , , , 37231 2394 4 on on IN 37231 2394 5 the the DT 37231 2394 6 contrary contrary NN 37231 2394 7 , , , 37231 2394 8 be be VB 37231 2394 9 much much RB 37231 2394 10 more more RBR 37231 2394 11 truly truly RB 37231 2394 12 said say VBD 37231 2394 13 that that IN 37231 2394 14 the the DT 37231 2394 15 already already RB 37231 2394 16 existing exist VBG 37231 2394 17 belief belief NN 37231 2394 18 created create VBD 37231 2394 19 these these DT 37231 2394 20 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2394 21 . . . 37231 2395 1 No no DT 37231 2395 2 divine divine JJ 37231 2395 3 originality originality NN 37231 2395 4 characterized characterize VBD 37231 2395 5 the the DT 37231 2395 6 evidence evidence NN 37231 2395 7 selected select VBN 37231 2395 8 to to TO 37231 2395 9 accredit accredit VB 37231 2395 10 the the DT 37231 2395 11 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2395 12 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 2395 13 . . . 37231 2396 1 The the DT 37231 2396 2 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2396 3 with with IN 37231 2396 4 which which WDT 37231 2396 5 the the DT 37231 2396 6 history history NN 37231 2396 7 of of IN 37231 2396 8 the the DT 37231 2396 9 world world NN 37231 2396 10 is be VBZ 37231 2396 11 full full JJ 37231 2396 12 occurred occur VBN 37231 2396 13 in in IN 37231 2396 14 ages age NNS 37231 2396 15 of of IN 37231 2396 16 darkness darkness NN 37231 2396 17 and and CC 37231 2396 18 superstition superstition NN 37231 2396 19 , , , 37231 2396 20 and and CC 37231 2396 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2396 22 gradually gradually RB 37231 2396 23 ceased cease VBD 37231 2396 24 when when WRB 37231 2396 25 enlightenment enlightenment NN 37231 2396 26 became become VBD 37231 2396 27 more more RBR 37231 2396 28 generally generally RB 37231 2396 29 diffused diffuse VBN 37231 2396 30 . . . 37231 2397 1 At at IN 37231 2397 2 the the DT 37231 2397 3 very very JJ 37231 2397 4 time time NN 37231 2397 5 when when WRB 37231 2397 6 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2397 7 of of IN 37231 2397 8 the the DT 37231 2397 9 laws law NNS 37231 2397 10 of of IN 37231 2397 11 nature nature NN 37231 2397 12 began begin VBD 37231 2397 13 to to TO 37231 2397 14 render render VB 37231 2397 15 men man NNS 37231 2397 16 capable capable JJ 37231 2397 17 of of IN 37231 2397 18 judging judging NN 37231 2397 19 of of IN 37231 2397 20 the the DT 37231 2397 21 reality reality NN 37231 2397 22 of of IN 37231 2397 23 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2397 24 , , , 37231 2397 25 these these DT 37231 2397 26 wonders wonder NNS 37231 2397 27 entirely entirely RB 37231 2397 28 failed fail VBD 37231 2397 29 . . . 37231 2398 1 This this DT 37231 2398 2 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 2398 3 cessation cessation NN 37231 2398 4 of of IN 37231 2398 5 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2398 6 , , , 37231 2398 7 precisely precisely RB 37231 2398 8 at at IN 37231 2398 9 the the DT 37231 2398 10 time time NN 37231 2398 11 when when WRB 37231 2398 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2398 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 2398 14 might may MD 37231 2398 15 have have VB 37231 2398 16 acquired acquire VBN 37231 2398 17 value value NN 37231 2398 18 by by IN 37231 2398 19 an an DT 37231 2398 20 appeal appeal NN 37231 2398 21 to to IN 37231 2398 22 persons person NNS 37231 2398 23 capable capable JJ 37231 2398 24 of of IN 37231 2398 25 appreciating appreciate VBG 37231 2398 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2398 27 , , , 37231 2398 28 is be VBZ 37231 2398 29 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2398 30 unintelligible unintelligible JJ 37231 2398 31 if if IN 37231 2398 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2398 33 be be VBP 37231 2398 34 viewed view VBN 37231 2398 35 as as IN 37231 2398 36 the the DT 37231 2398 37 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2398 38 credentials credential NNS 37231 2398 39 of of IN 37231 2398 40 a a DT 37231 2398 41 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2398 42 revelation revelation NN 37231 2398 43 . . . 37231 2399 1 If if IN 37231 2399 2 , , , 37231 2399 3 on on IN 37231 2399 4 the the DT 37231 2399 5 other other JJ 37231 2399 6 hand hand NN 37231 2399 7 , , , 37231 2399 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2399 9 be be VBP 37231 2399 10 regarded regard VBN 37231 2399 11 as as IN 37231 2399 12 the the DT 37231 2399 13 mistakes mistake NNS 37231 2399 14 of of IN 37231 2399 15 imaginative imaginative JJ 37231 2399 16 excitement excitement NN 37231 2399 17 and and CC 37231 2399 18 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2399 19 , , , 37231 2399 20 nothing nothing NN 37231 2399 21 is be VBZ 37231 2399 22 more more RBR 37231 2399 23 natural natural JJ 37231 2399 24 than than IN 37231 2399 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2399 26 extinction extinction NN 37231 2399 27 at at IN 37231 2399 28 the the DT 37231 2399 29 time time NN 37231 2399 30 when when WRB 37231 2399 31 the the DT 37231 2399 32 superstition superstition NN 37231 2399 33 which which WDT 37231 2399 34 created create VBD 37231 2399 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2399 36 gave give VBD 37231 2399 37 place place NN 37231 2399 38 to to IN 37231 2399 39 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2399 40 . . . 37231 2400 1 As as IN 37231 2400 2 a a DT 37231 2400 3 historical historical JJ 37231 2400 4 fact fact NN 37231 2400 5 , , , 37231 2400 6 there there EX 37231 2400 7 is be VBZ 37231 2400 8 nothing nothing NN 37231 2400 9 more more RBR 37231 2400 10 certain certain JJ 37231 2400 11 than than IN 37231 2400 12 that that DT 37231 2400 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2400 14 , , , 37231 2400 15 and and CC 37231 2400 16 the the DT 37231 2400 17 belief belief NN 37231 2400 18 in in IN 37231 2400 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2400 20 , , , 37231 2400 21 disappeared disappear VBD 37231 2400 22 exactly exactly RB 37231 2400 23 when when WRB 37231 2400 24 education education NN 37231 2400 25 and and CC 37231 2400 26 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2400 27 of of IN 37231 2400 28 the the DT 37231 2400 29 operation operation NN 37231 2400 30 of of IN 37231 2400 31 natural natural JJ 37231 2400 32 laws law NNS 37231 2400 33 became become VBD 37231 2400 34 diffused diffuse VBN 37231 2400 35 throughout throughout IN 37231 2400 36 Europe Europe NNP 37231 2400 37 , , , 37231 2400 38 and and CC 37231 2400 39 that that IN 37231 2400 40 the the DT 37231 2400 41 last last JJ 37231 2400 42 traces trace NNS 37231 2400 43 of of IN 37231 2400 44 belief belief NN 37231 2400 45 in in IN 37231 2400 46 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2400 47 interference interference NN 37231 2400 48 with with IN 37231 2400 49 the the DT 37231 2400 50 order order NN 37231 2400 51 of of IN 37231 2400 52 nature nature NN 37231 2400 53 are be VBP 37231 2400 54 only only RB 37231 2400 55 to to TO 37231 2400 56 be be VB 37231 2400 57 found find VBN 37231 2400 58 in in IN 37231 2400 59 localities locality NNS 37231 2400 60 where where WRB 37231 2400 61 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2400 62 and and CC 37231 2400 63 superstition superstition NN 37231 2400 64 still still RB 37231 2400 65 prevail prevail VBP 37231 2400 66 , , , 37231 2400 67 and and CC 37231 2400 68 render render VB 37231 2400 69 delusion delusion NN 37231 2400 70 or or CC 37231 2400 71 pious pious JJ 37231 2400 72 fraud fraud NN 37231 2400 73 of of IN 37231 2400 74 that that DT 37231 2400 75 description description NN 37231 2400 76 possible possible JJ 37231 2400 77 . . . 37231 2401 1 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 2401 2 are be VBP 37231 2401 3 now now RB 37231 2401 4 denied deny VBN 37231 2401 5 to to IN 37231 2401 6 places place NNS 37231 2401 7 more more JJR 37231 2401 8 enlightened enlighten VBN 37231 2401 9 { { -LRB- 37231 2401 10 203 203 CD 37231 2401 11 } } -RRB- 37231 2401 12 than than IN 37231 2401 13 Naples Naples NNP 37231 2401 14 or or CC 37231 2401 15 La La NNP 37231 2401 16 Salette Salette NNP 37231 2401 17 . . . 37231 2402 1 The the DT 37231 2402 2 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 2402 3 inference inference NN 37231 2402 4 from from IN 37231 2402 5 this this DT 37231 2402 6 fact fact NN 37231 2402 7 is be VBZ 37231 2402 8 fatal fatal JJ 37231 2402 9 to to IN 37231 2402 10 the the DT 37231 2402 11 mass mass NN 37231 2402 12 of of IN 37231 2402 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2402 14 , , , 37231 2402 15 and and CC 37231 2402 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2402 17 is be VBZ 37231 2402 18 not not RB 37231 2402 19 possible possible JJ 37231 2402 20 to to TO 37231 2402 21 protect protect VB 37231 2402 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2402 23 from from IN 37231 2402 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2402 25 . . . 37231 2403 1 Miracle miracle NN 37231 2403 2 cures cure VBZ 37231 2403 3 by by IN 37231 2403 4 the the DT 37231 2403 5 relics relic NNS 37231 2403 6 of of IN 37231 2403 7 saints saint NNS 37231 2403 8 , , , 37231 2403 9 upheld uphold VBN 37231 2403 10 for for IN 37231 2403 11 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 2403 12 centuries century NNS 37231 2403 13 by by IN 37231 2403 14 all all PDT 37231 2403 15 the the DT 37231 2403 16 power power NN 37231 2403 17 of of IN 37231 2403 18 the the DT 37231 2403 19 Church Church NNP 37231 2403 20 , , , 37231 2403 21 utterly utterly RB 37231 2403 22 failed fail VBD 37231 2403 23 when when WRB 37231 2403 24 medical medical JJ 37231 2403 25 science science NN 37231 2403 26 , , , 37231 2403 27 increasing increase VBG 37231 2403 28 in in IN 37231 2403 29 spite spite NN 37231 2403 30 of of IN 37231 2403 31 persecution persecution NN 37231 2403 32 , , , 37231 2403 33 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 37231 2403 34 the the DT 37231 2403 35 natural natural JJ 37231 2403 36 action action NN 37231 2403 37 of of IN 37231 2403 38 physiological physiological JJ 37231 2403 39 laws law NNS 37231 2403 40 . . . 37231 2404 1 The the DT 37231 2404 2 theory theory NN 37231 2404 3 of of IN 37231 2404 4 the the DT 37231 2404 5 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 37231 2404 6 origin origin NN 37231 2404 7 of of IN 37231 2404 8 disease disease NNP 37231 2404 9 has have VBZ 37231 2404 10 been be VBN 37231 2404 11 entirely entirely RB 37231 2404 12 and and CC 37231 2404 13 for for IN 37231 2404 14 ever ever RB 37231 2404 15 dispelled dispel VBN 37231 2404 16 , , , 37231 2404 17 and and CC 37231 2404 18 the the DT 37231 2404 19 host host NN 37231 2404 20 of of IN 37231 2404 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2404 22 in in IN 37231 2404 23 connection connection NN 37231 2404 24 with with IN 37231 2404 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2404 26 retrospectively retrospectively RB 37231 2404 27 exploded explode VBN 37231 2404 28 by by IN 37231 2404 29 the the DT 37231 2404 30 progress progress NN 37231 2404 31 of of IN 37231 2404 32 science science NN 37231 2404 33 . . . 37231 2405 1 Witchcraft witchcraft NN 37231 2405 2 and and CC 37231 2405 3 sorcery sorcery NN 37231 2405 4 , , , 37231 2405 5 the the DT 37231 2405 6 belief belief NN 37231 2405 7 in in IN 37231 2405 8 which which WDT 37231 2405 9 reigned reign VBD 37231 2405 10 supreme supreme RB 37231 2405 11 for for IN 37231 2405 12 so so RB 37231 2405 13 many many JJ 37231 2405 14 centuries century NNS 37231 2405 15 , , , 37231 2405 16 are be VBP 37231 2405 17 known know VBN 37231 2405 18 to to TO 37231 2405 19 have have VB 37231 2405 20 been be VBN 37231 2405 21 nothing nothing NN 37231 2405 22 but but IN 37231 2405 23 the the DT 37231 2405 24 delusions delusion NNS 37231 2405 25 of of IN 37231 2405 26 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 2405 27 superstition superstition NN 37231 2405 28 . . . 37231 2406 1 " " `` 37231 2406 2 A a DT 37231 2406 3 l'époque l'époque NN 37231 2406 4 où où NN 37231 2406 5 les les NNP 37231 2406 6 faits faits NNP 37231 2406 7 merveilleux merveilleux NNP 37231 2406 8 qui qui NN 37231 2406 9 s'y s'y RB 37231 2406 10 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2406 11 dans dan NNS 37231 2406 12 les les NNP 37231 2406 13 légendes légendes NNP 37231 2406 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2406 15 trouvent trouvent NNP 37231 2406 16 consignés consignés NNP 37231 2406 17 étaient étaient NNP 37231 2406 18 rapportés rapportés NNP 37231 2406 19 , , , 37231 2406 20 " " '' 37231 2406 21 asks ask VBZ 37231 2406 22 an an DT 37231 2406 23 able able JJ 37231 2406 24 French french JJ 37231 2406 25 writer writer NN 37231 2406 26 , , , 37231 2406 27 " " `` 37231 2406 28 possé possé NNP 37231 2406 29 dait dait NN 37231 2406 30 - - HYPH 37231 2406 31 on on RP 37231 2406 32 les les NNP 37231 2406 33 lumieres lumieres NNP 37231 2406 34 suffisantes suffisante VBZ 37231 2406 35 pour pour VBP 37231 2406 36 exercer exercer NNP 37231 2406 37 une une NNP 37231 2406 38 critique critique NNP 37231 2406 39 véritable véritable JJ 37231 2406 40 et et FW 37231 2406 41 sérieuse sérieuse NN 37231 2406 42 sur sur NNP 37231 2406 43 des des NNP 37231 2406 44 témoignages témoignage NNS 37231 2406 45 que que NNP 37231 2406 46 venaient venaient NN 37231 2406 47 affirmer affirmer NNP 37231 2406 48 des des NNP 37231 2406 49 faits fait VBZ 37231 2406 50 en en IN 37231 2406 51 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 2406 52 avec avec NN 37231 2406 53 nos nos NNP 37231 2406 54 connaissances connaissance NNS 37231 2406 55 ? ? . 37231 2407 1 Or or CC 37231 2407 2 , , , 37231 2407 3 on on IN 37231 2407 4 peut peut JJ 37231 2407 5 assurer assurer NN 37231 2407 6 hardiment hardiment NN 37231 2407 7 que que NNP 37231 2407 8 non non JJ 37231 2407 9 . . . 37231 2408 1 Au au IN 37231 2408 2 moyen moyen NN 37231 2408 3 - - HYPH 37231 2408 4 age age NN 37231 2408 5 , , , 37231 2408 6 l'intime l'intime NN 37231 2408 7 conviction conviction NN 37231 2408 8 que que NNP 37231 2408 9 la la NNP 37231 2408 10 nature nature NN 37231 2408 11 voit voit NNP 37231 2408 12 tres tre VBZ 37231 2408 13 fréquemment fréquemment NNP 37231 2408 14 ses se VBZ 37231 2408 15 lois lois NNP 37231 2408 16 interverties intervertie NNS 37231 2408 17 par par NNP 37231 2408 18 la la NNP 37231 2408 19 volonté volonté NNP 37231 2408 20 divine divine NNP 37231 2408 21 régnait régnait NNP 37231 2408 22 dans dan NNS 37231 2408 23 les les NNP 37231 2408 24 esprits esprit NNS 37231 2408 25 , , , 37231 2408 26 en en IN 37231 2408 27 sorte sorte NNP 37231 2408 28 que que NNP 37231 2408 29 pour pour NNP 37231 2408 30 peu peu NNP 37231 2408 31 qu'un qu'un NNP 37231 2408 32 fait fait NNP 37231 2408 33 se se FW 37231 2408 34 présentat présentat NNP 37231 2408 35 avec avec FW 37231 2408 36 des des FW 37231 2408 37 apparences apparence VBZ 37231 2408 38 extraordinaires extraordinaire NNS 37231 2408 39 , , , 37231 2408 40 on on IN 37231 2408 41 se se FW 37231 2408 42 hatait hatait FW 37231 2408 43 de de FW 37231 2408 44 le le NNP 37231 2408 45 regarder regarder NNP 37231 2408 46 comme comme NNP 37231 2408 47 un un NNP 37231 2408 48 miracle miracle NN 37231 2408 49 , , , 37231 2408 50 comme comme NNP 37231 2408 51 loeuvre loeuvre NNP 37231 2408 52 directe directe NNP 37231 2408 53 de de NNP 37231 2408 54 la la NNP 37231 2408 55 divinité divinité NNP 37231 2408 56 . . . 37231 2409 1 Aujourd'hui Aujourd'hui NNP 37231 2409 2 on on IN 37231 2409 3 cherche cherche NNP 37231 2409 4 au au NNP 37231 2409 5 contraire contraire VBP 37231 2409 6 à à NNP 37231 2409 7 tout tout NN 37231 2409 8 rapporter rapporter NNP 37231 2409 9 à à NNP 37231 2409 10 la la NNP 37231 2409 11 loi loi NNP 37231 2409 12 commune commune NNP 37231 2409 13 ; ; : 37231 2409 14 on on IN 37231 2409 15 est e JJS 37231 2409 16 tellement tellement JJ 37231 2409 17 sobre sobre NNP 37231 2409 18 de de FW 37231 2409 19 faits fait VBZ 37231 2409 20 miraculeux miraculeux NNP 37231 2409 21 , , , 37231 2409 22 que que NNP 37231 2409 23 ceux ceux NNP 37231 2409 24 qui qui NN 37231 2409 25 paraissent paraissent JJ 37231 2409 26 tels tel NNS 37231 2409 27 sont sont VBP 37231 2409 28 ^cartes ^cartes NNP 37231 2409 29 comme comme NNP 37231 2409 30 des des FW 37231 2409 31 fables fables FW 37231 2409 32 ou ou NNP 37231 2409 33 tonus tonus NN 37231 2409 34 pour pour VBP 37231 2409 35 des des FW 37231 2409 36 faits fait VBZ 37231 2409 37 ordinaires ordinaire VBZ 37231 2409 38 mal mal JJ 37231 2409 39 expliques explique NNS 37231 2409 40 . . . 37231 2410 1 La La NNP 37231 2410 2 foi foi NNP 37231 2410 3 aux aux JJ 37231 2410 4 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2410 5 a a DT 37231 2410 6 disparu disparu NN 37231 2410 7 . . . 37231 2411 1 En en IN 37231 2411 2 outre outre NN 37231 2411 3 , , , 37231 2411 4 au au NNP 37231 2411 5 moyen moyen NN 37231 2411 6 - - HYPH 37231 2411 7 age age NN 37231 2411 8 le le NNP 37231 2411 9 cercle cercle NNP 37231 2411 10 des des NNP 37231 2411 11 connaissances connaissances NNP 37231 2411 12 qu'on qu'on NNP 37231 2411 13 possédait possédait NNP 37231 2411 14 sur sur NNP 37231 2411 15 la la FW 37231 2411 16 nature nature NNP 37231 2411 17 était était VBP 37231 2411 18 fort fort NNP 37231 2411 19 restreint restreint NNP 37231 2411 20 , , , 37231 2411 21 et et NNP 37231 2411 22 tout tout NN 37231 2411 23 ce ce NNP 37231 2411 24 qui qui VBP 37231 2411 25 n'y n'y RB 37231 2411 26 rentrait rentrait VB 37231 2411 27 pas pas NNP 37231 2411 28 était était NNP 37231 2411 29 regardé regardé NNP 37231 2411 30 comme comme NNP 37231 2411 31 surnatural surnatural NNP 37231 2411 32 . . . 37231 2412 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2412 2 204 204 CD 37231 2412 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2412 4 Actuellement Actuellement NNP 37231 2412 5 ce ce NNP 37231 2412 6 cercle cercle NN 37231 2412 7 s'agrandit s'agrandit FW 37231 2412 8 sans sans NNP 37231 2412 9 cesse cesse NNP 37231 2412 10 ; ; : 37231 2412 11 et et NNP 37231 2412 12 loin loin NNP 37231 2412 13 d'en d'en NNP 37231 2412 14 avoir avoir NNP 37231 2412 15 arreté arreté NNP 37231 2412 16 définitivement définitivement NN 37231 2412 17 la la NNP 37231 2412 18 limite limite NNP 37231 2412 19 , , , 37231 2412 20 on on IN 37231 2412 21 le le NNP 37231 2412 22 déclare déclare NNP 37231 2412 23 infini infini NNP 37231 2412 24 . . . 37231 2412 25 " " '' 37231 2413 1 In in IN 37231 2413 2 a a DT 37231 2413 3 note note NN 37231 2413 4 the the DT 37231 2413 5 writer writer NN 37231 2413 6 adds add VBZ 37231 2413 7 : : : 37231 2413 8 " " `` 37231 2413 9 On on IN 37231 2413 10 voit voit NNP 37231 2413 11 par par NNP 37231 2413 12 la la NNP 37231 2413 13 que que NNP 37231 2413 14 le le NNP 37231 2413 15 nombre nombre NNP 37231 2413 16 des des NNP 37231 2413 17 miracles miracles NNP 37231 2413 18 doit doit NNP 37231 2413 19 etre etre NNP 37231 2413 20 en en IN 37231 2413 21 raison raison NNP 37231 2413 22 inverse inverse NNP 37231 2413 23 du du NNP 37231 2413 24 nombre nombre NNP 37231 2413 25 des des NNP 37231 2413 26 lois lois NNP 37231 2413 27 connues connue NNS 37231 2413 28 de de IN 37231 2413 29 la la NNP 37231 2413 30 nature nature NNP 37231 2413 31 , , , 37231 2413 32 et et FW 37231 2413 33 , , , 37231 2413 34 qu'a qu'a NNP 37231 2413 35 mesure mesure NN 37231 2413 36 que que NNP 37231 2413 37 celles celle NNS 37231 2413 38 - - : 37231 2413 39 ci ci NNP 37231 2413 40 nous nous JJ 37231 2413 41 sont sont NN 37231 2413 42 révélées révélées NN 37231 2413 43 , , , 37231 2413 44 les les NNP 37231 2413 45 faits fait VBZ 37231 2413 46 merveilleux merveilleux NNP 37231 2413 47 ou ou NNP 37231 2413 48 miraculeux miraculeux NNP 37231 2413 49 s'évanouissent s'évanouissent NNP 37231 2413 50 . . . 37231 2414 1 " " `` 37231 2414 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2414 3 1 1 LS 37231 2414 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2414 5 These these DT 37231 2414 6 remarks remark NNS 37231 2414 7 are be VBP 37231 2414 8 equally equally RB 37231 2414 9 applicable applicable JJ 37231 2414 10 to to IN 37231 2414 11 the the DT 37231 2414 12 commencement commencement NN 37231 2414 13 of of IN 37231 2414 14 the the DT 37231 2414 15 Christian christian JJ 37231 2414 16 era era NN 37231 2414 17 . . . 37231 2415 1 On on IN 37231 2415 2 the the DT 37231 2415 3 one one CD 37231 2415 4 hand hand NN 37231 2415 5 , , , 37231 2415 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2415 7 have have VBP 37231 2415 8 no no DT 37231 2415 9 other other JJ 37231 2415 10 testimony testimony NN 37231 2415 11 for for IN 37231 2415 12 the the DT 37231 2415 13 reality reality NN 37231 2415 14 of of IN 37231 2415 15 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2415 16 than than IN 37231 2415 17 that that DT 37231 2415 18 of of IN 37231 2415 19 ages age NNS 37231 2415 20 in in IN 37231 2415 21 which which WDT 37231 2415 22 not not RB 37231 2415 23 only only RB 37231 2415 24 the the DT 37231 2415 25 grossest gross JJS 37231 2415 26 superstition superstition NN 37231 2415 27 and and CC 37231 2415 28 credulity credulity NN 37231 2415 29 prevailed prevail VBD 37231 2415 30 , , , 37231 2415 31 but but CC 37231 2415 32 in in IN 37231 2415 33 which which WDT 37231 2415 34 there there EX 37231 2415 35 was be VBD 37231 2415 36 such such JJ 37231 2415 37 total total JJ 37231 2415 38 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2415 39 of of IN 37231 2415 40 natural natural JJ 37231 2415 41 laws law NNS 37231 2415 42 that that WDT 37231 2415 43 men man NNS 37231 2415 44 were be VBD 37231 2415 45 incapable incapable JJ 37231 2415 46 of of IN 37231 2415 47 judging judge VBG 37231 2415 48 of of IN 37231 2415 49 that that DT 37231 2415 50 reality reality NN 37231 2415 51 , , , 37231 2415 52 even even RB 37231 2415 53 if if IN 37231 2415 54 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2415 55 desired desire VBD 37231 2415 56 impartially impartially RB 37231 2415 57 to to TO 37231 2415 58 investigate investigate VB 37231 2415 59 such such JJ 37231 2415 60 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2415 61 , , , 37231 2415 62 which which WDT 37231 2415 63 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2415 64 did do VBD 37231 2415 65 not not RB 37231 2415 66 ; ; : 37231 2415 67 on on IN 37231 2415 68 the the DT 37231 2415 69 other other JJ 37231 2415 70 hand hand NN 37231 2415 71 , , , 37231 2415 72 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2415 73 have have VBP 37231 2415 74 the the DT 37231 2415 75 sober sober JJ 37231 2415 76 testimony testimony NN 37231 2415 77 of of IN 37231 2415 78 science science NN 37231 2415 79 declaring declare VBG 37231 2415 80 such such JJ 37231 2415 81 phenomena phenomena NN 37231 2415 82 violations violation NNS 37231 2415 83 of of IN 37231 2415 84 the the DT 37231 2415 85 invariable invariable JJ 37231 2415 86 laws law NNS 37231 2415 87 of of IN 37231 2415 88 nature nature NN 37231 2415 89 , , , 37231 2415 90 and and CC 37231 2415 91 experience experience NN 37231 2415 92 teaching teach VBG 37231 2415 93 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2415 94 a a DT 37231 2415 95 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2415 96 simple simple JJ 37231 2415 97 and and CC 37231 2415 98 natural natural JJ 37231 2415 99 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 2415 100 of of IN 37231 2415 101 the the DT 37231 2415 102 legends legend NNS 37231 2415 103 regarding regard VBG 37231 2415 104 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2415 105 . . . 37231 2416 1 Are be VBP 37231 2416 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2416 3 to to TO 37231 2416 4 believe believe VB 37231 2416 5 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2416 6 and and CC 37231 2416 7 superstition superstition NN 37231 2416 8 or or CC 37231 2416 9 science science NN 37231 2416 10 and and CC 37231 2416 11 unvarying unvarying NN 37231 2416 12 experience experience NN 37231 2416 13 ? ? . 37231 2417 1 Science science NN 37231 2417 2 has have VBZ 37231 2417 3 already already RB 37231 2417 4 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 2417 5 the the DT 37231 2417 6 delusion delusion NN 37231 2417 7 involved involve VBN 37231 2417 8 in in IN 37231 2417 9 the the DT 37231 2417 10 largest large JJS 37231 2417 11 class class NN 37231 2417 12 of of IN 37231 2417 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2417 14 , , , 37231 2417 15 and and CC 37231 2417 16 has have VBZ 37231 2417 17 so so RB 37231 2417 18 far far RB 37231 2417 19 established establish VBN 37231 2417 20 the the DT 37231 2417 21 superiority superiority NN 37231 2417 22 of of IN 37231 2417 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2417 24 testimony testimony NN 37231 2417 25 . . . 37231 2418 1 In in IN 37231 2418 2 an an DT 37231 2418 3 early early JJ 37231 2418 4 part part NN 37231 2418 5 of of IN 37231 2418 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2418 7 discussion discussion NN 37231 2418 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2418 9 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2418 10 argues argue VBZ 37231 2418 11 : : : 37231 2418 12 " " `` 37231 2418 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2418 14 is be VBZ 37231 2418 15 the the DT 37231 2418 16 religion religion NN 37231 2418 17 of of IN 37231 2418 18 the the DT 37231 2418 19 civilized civilized JJ 37231 2418 20 world world NN 37231 2418 21 , , , 37231 2418 22 and and CC 37231 2418 23 1 1 CD 37231 2418 24 L. L. NNP 37231 2418 25 F. F. NNP 37231 2418 26 Alfred Alfred NNP 37231 2418 27 Maury Maury NNP 37231 2418 28 . . . 37231 2419 1 Essai Essai NNP 37231 2419 2 sur sur NNP 37231 2419 3 los los NNP 37231 2419 4 Legendes Legendes NNP 37231 2419 5 pieuses pieuse NNS 37231 2419 6 du du NNP 37231 2419 7 Moyen Moyen NNP 37231 2419 8 - - HYPH 37231 2419 9 age age NN 37231 2419 10 , , , 37231 2419 11 1843 1843 CD 37231 2419 12 , , , 37231 2419 13 p. p. NN 37231 2419 14 234 234 CD 37231 2419 15 f. f. NN 37231 2419 16 , , , 37231 2419 17 and and CC 37231 2419 18 p. p. NN 37231 2419 19 233 233 CD 37231 2419 20 , , , 37231 2419 21 note note VB 37231 2419 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2419 23 1 1 CD 37231 2419 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2419 25 . . . 37231 2420 1 The the DT 37231 2420 2 same same JJ 37231 2420 3 arguments argument NNS 37231 2420 4 are be VBP 37231 2420 5 employed employ VBN 37231 2420 6 by by IN 37231 2420 7 the the DT 37231 2420 8 late late JJ 37231 2420 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 37231 2420 10 Buckle Buckle NNP 37231 2420 11 . . . 37231 2421 1 " " `` 37231 2421 2 Hence hence RB 37231 2421 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2421 4 is be VBZ 37231 2421 5 that that IN 37231 2421 6 , , , 37231 2421 7 supposing suppose VBG 37231 2421 8 other other JJ 37231 2421 9 things thing NNS 37231 2421 10 equal equal JJ 37231 2421 11 , , , 37231 2421 12 the the DT 37231 2421 13 superstition superstition NN 37231 2421 14 of of IN 37231 2421 15 a a DT 37231 2421 16 nation nation NN 37231 2421 17 must must MD 37231 2421 18 always always RB 37231 2421 19 bear bear VB 37231 2421 20 an an DT 37231 2421 21 exact exact JJ 37231 2421 22 proportion proportion NN 37231 2421 23 to to IN 37231 2421 24 the the DT 37231 2421 25 extent extent NN 37231 2421 26 of of IN 37231 2421 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2421 28 physical physical JJ 37231 2421 29 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2421 30 . . . 37231 2422 1 This this DT 37231 2422 2 may may MD 37231 2422 3 be be VB 37231 2422 4 in in IN 37231 2422 5 some some DT 37231 2422 6 degree degree NN 37231 2422 7 verified verify VBN 37231 2422 8 by by IN 37231 2422 9 the the DT 37231 2422 10 ordinary ordinary JJ 37231 2422 11 experience experience NN 37231 2422 12 of of IN 37231 2422 13 mankind mankind NN 37231 2422 14 . . . 37231 2423 1 For for CC 37231 2423 2 if if IN 37231 2423 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2423 4 compare compare VBP 37231 2423 5 the the DT 37231 2423 6 different different JJ 37231 2423 7 classes class NNS 37231 2423 8 of of IN 37231 2423 9 society society NN 37231 2423 10 , , , 37231 2423 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2423 12 shall shall MD 37231 2423 13 find find VB 37231 2423 14 that that IN 37231 2423 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2423 16 are be VBP 37231 2423 17 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 2423 18 in in IN 37231 2423 19 proportion proportion NN 37231 2423 20 as as IN 37231 2423 21 the the DT 37231 2423 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2423 23 with with IN 37231 2423 24 which which WDT 37231 2423 25 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2423 26 are be VBP 37231 2423 27 brought bring VBN 37231 2423 28 in in RP 37231 2423 29 contact contact NN 37231 2423 30 have have VBP 37231 2423 31 or or CC 37231 2423 32 have have VBP 37231 2423 33 not not RB 37231 2423 34 been be VBN 37231 2423 35 explained explain VBN 37231 2423 36 by by IN 37231 2423 37 natural natural JJ 37231 2423 38 laws law NNS 37231 2423 39 . . . 37231 2423 40 " " '' 37231 2424 1 Hist Hist NNP 37231 2424 2 , , , 37231 2424 3 of of IN 37231 2424 4 Civilization Civilization NNP 37231 2424 5 , , , 37231 2424 6 1867 1867 CD 37231 2424 7 , , , 37231 2424 8 i. i. NNP 37231 2424 9 p. p. NNP 37231 2424 10 373 373 CD 37231 2424 11 . . . 37231 2425 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2425 2 205 205 CD 37231 2425 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2425 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2425 5 is be VBZ 37231 2425 6 believed believe VBN 37231 2425 7 upon upon IN 37231 2425 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2425 9 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2425 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 2425 11 . . . 37231 2426 1 Now now RB 37231 2426 2 , , , 37231 2426 3 for for IN 37231 2426 4 a a DT 37231 2426 5 set set NN 37231 2426 6 of of IN 37231 2426 7 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2426 8 to to TO 37231 2426 9 be be VB 37231 2426 10 accepted accept VBN 37231 2426 11 in in IN 37231 2426 12 a a DT 37231 2426 13 rude rude JJ 37231 2426 14 age age NN 37231 2426 15 , , , 37231 2426 16 and and CC 37231 2426 17 to to TO 37231 2426 18 retain retain VB 37231 2426 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2426 20 authority authority NN 37231 2426 21 throughout throughout IN 37231 2426 22 a a DT 37231 2426 23 succession succession NN 37231 2426 24 of of IN 37231 2426 25 such such JJ 37231 2426 26 ages age NNS 37231 2426 27 , , , 37231 2426 28 and and CC 37231 2426 29 over over IN 37231 2426 30 the the DT 37231 2426 31 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 2426 32 and and CC 37231 2426 33 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 2426 34 part part NN 37231 2426 35 of of IN 37231 2426 36 mankind mankind NN 37231 2426 37 , , , 37231 2426 38 may may MD 37231 2426 39 be be VB 37231 2426 40 no no DT 37231 2426 41 such such JJ 37231 2426 42 great great JJ 37231 2426 43 result result NN 37231 2426 44 for for IN 37231 2426 45 the the DT 37231 2426 46 miracle miracle NN 37231 2426 47 to to TO 37231 2426 48 accomplish accomplish VB 37231 2426 49 , , , 37231 2426 50 because because IN 37231 2426 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2426 52 is be VBZ 37231 2426 53 easy easy JJ 37231 2426 54 to to TO 37231 2426 55 satisfy satisfy VB 37231 2426 56 those those DT 37231 2426 57 who who WP 37231 2426 58 do do VBP 37231 2426 59 not not RB 37231 2426 60 inquire inquire VB 37231 2426 61 . . . 37231 2427 1 But but CC 37231 2427 2 this this DT 37231 2427 3 is be VBZ 37231 2427 4 not not RB 37231 2427 5 the the DT 37231 2427 6 state state NN 37231 2427 7 of of IN 37231 2427 8 the the DT 37231 2427 9 case case NN 37231 2427 10 which which WDT 37231 2427 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2427 12 have have VBP 37231 2427 13 to to TO 37231 2427 14 meet meet VB 37231 2427 15 on on IN 37231 2427 16 the the DT 37231 2427 17 subject subject NN 37231 2427 18 of of IN 37231 2427 19 the the DT 37231 2427 20 Christian christian JJ 37231 2427 21 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2427 22 . . . 37231 2428 1 The the DT 37231 2428 2 Christian Christian NNP 37231 2428 3 being be VBG 37231 2428 4 the the DT 37231 2428 5 most most RBS 37231 2428 6 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 2428 7 , , , 37231 2428 8 the the DT 37231 2428 9 civilized civilized JJ 37231 2428 10 portion portion NN 37231 2428 11 of of IN 37231 2428 12 the the DT 37231 2428 13 world world NN 37231 2428 14 , , , 37231 2428 15 these these DT 37231 2428 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2428 17 are be VBP 37231 2428 18 accepted accept VBN 37231 2428 19 by by IN 37231 2428 20 the the DT 37231 2428 21 Christian christian JJ 37231 2428 22 body body NN 37231 2428 23 as as IN 37231 2428 24 a a DT 37231 2428 25 whole whole NN 37231 2428 26 , , , 37231 2428 27 by by IN 37231 2428 28 the the DT 37231 2428 29 thinking thinking NN 37231 2428 30 and and CC 37231 2428 31 educated educate VBD 37231 2428 32 as as RB 37231 2428 33 well well RB 37231 2428 34 as as IN 37231 2428 35 the the DT 37231 2428 36 uneducated uneducated JJ 37231 2428 37 part part NN 37231 2428 38 of of IN 37231 2428 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2428 40 , , , 37231 2428 41 and and CC 37231 2428 42 the the DT 37231 2428 43 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2428 44 is be VBZ 37231 2428 45 believed believe VBN 37231 2428 46 upon upon IN 37231 2428 47 that that DT 37231 2428 48 evidence evidence NN 37231 2428 49 . . . 37231 2429 1 " " `` 37231 2429 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2429 3 1 1 LS 37231 2429 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2429 5 The the DT 37231 2429 6 picture picture NN 37231 2429 7 of of IN 37231 2429 8 Christendom Christendom NNP 37231 2429 9 here here RB 37231 2429 10 suggested suggest VBD 37231 2429 11 is be VBZ 37231 2429 12 purely purely RB 37231 2429 13 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 2429 14 . . . 37231 2430 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2430 2 are be VBP 37231 2430 3 asked ask VBN 37231 2430 4 to to TO 37231 2430 5 believe believe VB 37231 2430 6 that that IN 37231 2430 7 succeeding succeed VBG 37231 2430 8 generations generation NNS 37231 2430 9 of of IN 37231 2430 10 thinking thinking NN 37231 2430 11 and and CC 37231 2430 12 educated educate VBD 37231 2430 13 as as RB 37231 2430 14 well well RB 37231 2430 15 as as IN 37231 2430 16 uneducated uneducated JJ 37231 2430 17 men man NNS 37231 2430 18 , , , 37231 2430 19 since since IN 37231 2430 20 the the DT 37231 2430 21 commencement commencement NN 37231 2430 22 of of IN 37231 2430 23 the the DT 37231 2430 24 period period NN 37231 2430 25 in in IN 37231 2430 26 which which WDT 37231 2430 27 the the DT 37231 2430 28 adequate adequate JJ 37231 2430 29 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2430 30 into into IN 37231 2430 31 the the DT 37231 2430 32 reality reality NN 37231 2430 33 of of IN 37231 2430 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2430 35 became become VBD 37231 2430 36 possible possible JJ 37231 2430 37 , , , 37231 2430 38 have have VBP 37231 2430 39 made make VBN 37231 2430 40 that that DT 37231 2430 41 adequate adequate JJ 37231 2430 42 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2430 43 , , , 37231 2430 44 and and CC 37231 2430 45 have have VBP 37231 2430 46 intelligently intelligently RB 37231 2430 47 and and CC 37231 2430 48 individually individually RB 37231 2430 49 accepted accept VBN 37231 2430 50 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2430 51 and and CC 37231 2430 52 believed believe VBD 37231 2430 53 the the DT 37231 2430 54 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2430 55 in in IN 37231 2430 56 consequence consequence NN 37231 2430 57 of of IN 37231 2430 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2430 59 attestation attestation NN 37231 2430 60 . . . 37231 2431 1 The the DT 37231 2431 2 fact fact NN 37231 2431 3 , , , 37231 2431 4 however however RB 37231 2431 5 , , , 37231 2431 6 is be VBZ 37231 2431 7 that that IN 37231 2431 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2431 9 became become VBD 37231 2431 10 the the DT 37231 2431 11 religion religion NN 37231 2431 12 of of IN 37231 2431 13 Europe Europe NNP 37231 2431 14 before before IN 37231 2431 15 men man NNS 37231 2431 16 either either CC 37231 2431 17 possessed possess VBD 37231 2431 18 the the DT 37231 2431 19 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2431 20 requisite requisite JJ 37231 2431 21 to to TO 37231 2431 22 appreciate appreciate VB 37231 2431 23 the the DT 37231 2431 24 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 2431 25 involved involve VBN 37231 2431 26 in in IN 37231 2431 27 the the DT 37231 2431 28 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 2431 29 of of IN 37231 2431 30 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2431 31 , , , 37231 2431 32 or or CC 37231 2431 33 minds mind NNS 37231 2431 34 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 2431 35 freed free VBN 37231 2431 36 from from IN 37231 2431 37 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 2431 38 superstition superstition NN 37231 2431 39 to to TO 37231 2431 40 question question VB 37231 2431 41 the the DT 37231 2431 42 reality reality NN 37231 2431 43 of of IN 37231 2431 44 the the DT 37231 2431 45 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2431 46 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2431 47 interference interference NN 37231 2431 48 with with IN 37231 2431 49 the the DT 37231 2431 50 order order NN 37231 2431 51 of of IN 37231 2431 52 nature nature NN 37231 2431 53 , , , 37231 2431 54 and and CC 37231 2431 55 belief belief NN 37231 2431 56 had have VBD 37231 2431 57 become become VBN 37231 2431 58 so so RB 37231 2431 59 much much RB 37231 2431 60 a a DT 37231 2431 61 matter matter NN 37231 2431 62 of of IN 37231 2431 63 habit habit NN 37231 2431 64 that that IN 37231 2431 65 , , , 37231 2431 66 in in IN 37231 2431 67 this this DT 37231 2431 68 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 37231 2431 69 century century NN 37231 2431 70 , , , 37231 2431 71 the the DT 37231 2431 72 great great JJ 37231 2431 73 majority majority NN 37231 2431 74 of of IN 37231 2431 75 men man NNS 37231 2431 76 have have VBP 37231 2431 77 professed profess VBN 37231 2431 78 belief belief NN 37231 2431 79 for for IN 37231 2431 80 no no DT 37231 2431 81 better well JJR 37231 2431 82 reason reason NN 37231 2431 83 than than IN 37231 2431 84 that that IN 37231 2431 85 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2431 86 fathers father NNS 37231 2431 87 believed believe VBD 37231 2431 88 before before IN 37231 2431 89 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2431 90 . . . 37231 2432 1 Belief belief NN 37231 2432 2 is be VBZ 37231 2432 3 now now RB 37231 2432 4 little little JJ 37231 2432 5 more more JJR 37231 2432 6 than than IN 37231 2432 7 a a DT 37231 2432 8 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 2432 9 quality quality NN 37231 2432 10 or or CC 37231 2432 11 hereditary hereditary JJ 37231 2432 12 custom custom NN 37231 2432 13 . . . 37231 2433 1 Few few JJ 37231 2433 2 men man NNS 37231 2433 3 , , , 37231 2433 4 even even RB 37231 2433 5 { { -LRB- 37231 2433 6 206 206 CD 37231 2433 7 } } -RRB- 37231 2433 8 now now RB 37231 2433 9 , , , 37231 2433 10 have have VBP 37231 2433 11 either either CC 37231 2433 12 the the DT 37231 2433 13 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2433 14 or or CC 37231 2433 15 the the DT 37231 2433 16 leisure leisure NN 37231 2433 17 requisite requisite JJ 37231 2433 18 to to TO 37231 2433 19 enable enable VB 37231 2433 20 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2433 21 to to TO 37231 2433 22 enter enter VB 37231 2433 23 upon upon IN 37231 2433 24 such such PDT 37231 2433 25 an an DT 37231 2433 26 examination examination NN 37231 2433 27 of of IN 37231 2433 28 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2433 29 as as IN 37231 2433 30 can can MD 37231 2433 31 entitle entitle VB 37231 2433 32 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2433 33 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2433 34 to to TO 37231 2433 35 affirm affirm VB 37231 2433 36 that that IN 37231 2433 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2433 38 intelligently intelligently RB 37231 2433 39 accept accept VBP 37231 2433 40 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2433 41 for for IN 37231 2433 42 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2433 43 . . . 37231 2434 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2434 2 have have VBP 37231 2434 3 shown show VBN 37231 2434 4 , , , 37231 2434 5 moreover moreover RB 37231 2434 6 , , , 37231 2434 7 that that IN 37231 2434 8 so so RB 37231 2434 9 loose loose JJ 37231 2434 10 are be VBP 37231 2434 11 the the DT 37231 2434 12 ideas idea NNS 37231 2434 13 even even RB 37231 2434 14 of of IN 37231 2434 15 the the DT 37231 2434 16 clergy clergy NNS 37231 2434 17 upon upon IN 37231 2434 18 the the DT 37231 2434 19 subject subject NN 37231 2434 20 , , , 37231 2434 21 that that IN 37231 2434 22 dignitaries dignitary NNS 37231 2434 23 of of IN 37231 2434 24 the the DT 37231 2434 25 church church NN 37231 2434 26 fail fail VBP 37231 2434 27 to to TO 37231 2434 28 see see VB 37231 2434 29 either either CC 37231 2434 30 the the DT 37231 2434 31 evidential evidential JJ 37231 2434 32 purpose purpose NN 37231 2434 33 of of IN 37231 2434 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2434 35 or or CC 37231 2434 36 the the DT 37231 2434 37 need need NN 37231 2434 38 for for IN 37231 2434 39 evidence evidence NN 37231 2434 40 at at RB 37231 2434 41 all all RB 37231 2434 42 , , , 37231 2434 43 and and CC 37231 2434 44 the the DT 37231 2434 45 first first JJ 37231 2434 46 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 2434 47 step step NN 37231 2434 48 towards towards IN 37231 2434 49 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2434 50 -- -- : 37231 2434 51 doubt doubt NN 37231 2434 52 -- -- : 37231 2434 53 has have VBZ 37231 2434 54 generally generally RB 37231 2434 55 been be VBN 37231 2434 56 stigmatized stigmatize VBN 37231 2434 57 almost almost RB 37231 2434 58 as as IN 37231 2434 59 a a DT 37231 2434 60 crime crime NN 37231 2434 61 . . . 37231 2435 1 So so RB 37231 2435 2 far far RB 37231 2435 3 from from IN 37231 2435 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2435 5 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2435 6 's 's POS 37231 2435 7 statement statement NN 37231 2435 8 being be VBG 37231 2435 9 correct correct JJ 37231 2435 10 , , , 37231 2435 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2435 12 is be VBZ 37231 2435 13 notorious notorious JJ 37231 2435 14 that that IN 37231 2435 15 the the DT 37231 2435 16 great great JJ 37231 2435 17 mass mass NN 37231 2435 18 of of IN 37231 2435 19 those those DT 37231 2435 20 who who WP 37231 2435 21 are be VBP 37231 2435 22 competent competent JJ 37231 2435 23 to to TO 37231 2435 24 examine examine VB 37231 2435 25 , , , 37231 2435 26 and and CC 37231 2435 27 who who WP 37231 2435 28 have have VBP 37231 2435 29 done do VBN 37231 2435 30 so so RB 37231 2435 31 , , , 37231 2435 32 altogether altogether RB 37231 2435 33 reject reject VBP 37231 2435 34 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2435 35 . . . 37231 2436 1 Instead instead RB 37231 2436 2 of of IN 37231 2436 3 the the DT 37231 2436 4 " " `` 37231 2436 5 thinking think VBG 37231 2436 6 and and CC 37231 2436 7 educated educate VBD 37231 2436 8 " " '' 37231 2436 9 men man NNS 37231 2436 10 of of IN 37231 2436 11 science science NN 37231 2436 12 accepting accept VBG 37231 2436 13 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2436 14 , , , 37231 2436 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2436 16 , , , 37231 2436 17 as as IN 37231 2436 18 a a DT 37231 2436 19 body body NN 37231 2436 20 , , , 37231 2436 21 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 2436 22 deny deny VB 37231 2436 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2436 24 , , , 37231 2436 25 and and CC 37231 2436 26 hence hence RB 37231 2436 27 the the DT 37231 2436 28 antagonism antagonism NN 37231 2436 29 between between IN 37231 2436 30 science science NN 37231 2436 31 and and CC 37231 2436 32 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2436 33 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2436 34 , , , 37231 2436 35 and and CC 37231 2436 36 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2436 37 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2436 38 surely surely RB 37231 2436 39 does do VBZ 37231 2436 40 not not RB 37231 2436 41 require require VB 37231 2436 42 to to TO 37231 2436 43 be be VB 37231 2436 44 told tell VBN 37231 2436 45 how how WRB 37231 2436 46 many many JJ 37231 2436 47 of of IN 37231 2436 48 the the DT 37231 2436 49 profoundest profoundest NN 37231 2436 50 critics critic NNS 37231 2436 51 and and CC 37231 2436 52 scholars scholar NNS 37231 2436 53 of of IN 37231 2436 54 Germany Germany NNP 37231 2436 55 , , , 37231 2436 56 and and CC 37231 2436 57 of of IN 37231 2436 58 all all DT 37231 2436 59 other other JJ 37231 2436 60 countries country NNS 37231 2436 61 in in IN 37231 2436 62 Europe Europe NNP 37231 2436 63 , , , 37231 2436 64 who who WP 37231 2436 65 have have VBP 37231 2436 66 turned turn VBN 37231 2436 67 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2436 68 attention attention NN 37231 2436 69 to to IN 37231 2436 70 Biblical biblical JJ 37231 2436 71 subjects subject NNS 37231 2436 72 , , , 37231 2436 73 have have VBP 37231 2436 74 long long RB 37231 2436 75 ago ago RB 37231 2436 76 rejected reject VBN 37231 2436 77 the the DT 37231 2436 78 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2436 79 elements element NNS 37231 2436 80 of of IN 37231 2436 81 the the DT 37231 2436 82 Christian christian JJ 37231 2436 83 religion religion NN 37231 2436 84 . . . 37231 2437 1 Such such JJ 37231 2437 2 being be VBG 37231 2437 3 the the DT 37231 2437 4 case case NN 37231 2437 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2437 6 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 2437 7 revert revert VBP 37231 2437 8 to to IN 37231 2437 9 the the DT 37231 2437 10 first first JJ 37231 2437 11 part part NN 37231 2437 12 of of IN 37231 2437 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2437 14 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2437 15 's 's POS 37231 2437 16 representation representation NN 37231 2437 17 , , , 37231 2437 18 and and CC 37231 2437 19 find find VB 37231 2437 20 with with IN 37231 2437 21 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2437 22 , , , 37231 2437 23 that that IN 37231 2437 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2437 25 is be VBZ 37231 2437 26 no no DT 37231 2437 27 great great JJ 37231 2437 28 result result NN 37231 2437 29 for for IN 37231 2437 30 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2437 31 to to TO 37231 2437 32 accomplish accomplish VB 37231 2437 33 , , , 37231 2437 34 merely merely RB 37231 2437 35 to to TO 37231 2437 36 be be VB 37231 2437 37 accepted accept VBN 37231 2437 38 by by IN 37231 2437 39 , , , 37231 2437 40 and and CC 37231 2437 41 retain retain VB 37231 2437 42 authority authority NN 37231 2437 43 over over RB 37231 2437 44 , , , 37231 2437 45 a a DT 37231 2437 46 succession succession NN 37231 2437 47 of of IN 37231 2437 48 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 2437 49 and and CC 37231 2437 50 superstitious superstitious JJ 37231 2437 51 ages age NNS 37231 2437 52 , , , 37231 2437 53 " " '' 37231 2437 54 because because IN 37231 2437 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2437 56 is be VBZ 37231 2437 57 easy easy JJ 37231 2437 58 to to TO 37231 2437 59 satisfy satisfy VB 37231 2437 60 those those DT 37231 2437 61 who who WP 37231 2437 62 do do VBP 37231 2437 63 not not RB 37231 2437 64 inquire inquire VB 37231 2437 65 . . . 37231 2437 66 " " '' 37231 2438 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2438 2 is be VBZ 37231 2438 3 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2438 4 that that IN 37231 2438 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2438 6 should should MD 37231 2438 7 now now RB 37231 2438 8 refer refer VB 37231 2438 9 to to IN 37231 2438 10 the the DT 37231 2438 11 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 2438 12 that that WDT 37231 2438 13 all all PDT 37231 2438 14 the the DT 37231 2438 15 arguments argument NNS 37231 2438 16 which which WDT 37231 2438 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2438 18 have have VBP 37231 2438 19 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 2438 20 considered consider VBN 37231 2438 21 in in IN 37231 2438 22 support support NN 37231 2438 23 of of IN 37231 2438 24 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2438 25 , , , 37231 2438 26 whether whether IN 37231 2438 27 to to TO 37231 2438 28 explain explain VB 37231 2438 29 or or CC 37231 2438 30 account account VB 37231 2438 31 for for IN 37231 2438 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2438 33 , , , 37231 2438 34 have have VBP 37231 2438 35 proceeded proceed VBN 37231 2438 36 upon upon IN 37231 2438 37 an an DT 37231 2438 38 assumption assumption NN 37231 2438 39 of of IN 37231 2438 40 the the DT 37231 2438 41 reality reality NN 37231 2438 42 of of IN 37231 2438 43 the the DT 37231 2438 44 alleged allege VBN 37231 2438 45 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2438 46 . . . 37231 2439 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2439 2 207 207 CD 37231 2439 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2439 4 Had have VBD 37231 2439 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2439 6 been be VBN 37231 2439 7 first first RB 37231 2439 8 requisite requisite JJ 37231 2439 9 to to TO 37231 2439 10 establish establish VB 37231 2439 11 the the DT 37231 2439 12 truth truth NN 37231 2439 13 of of IN 37231 2439 14 facts fact NNS 37231 2439 15 of of IN 37231 2439 16 such such PDT 37231 2439 17 an an DT 37231 2439 18 astounding astounding JJ 37231 2439 19 nature nature NN 37231 2439 20 , , , 37231 2439 21 the the DT 37231 2439 22 necessity necessity NN 37231 2439 23 of of IN 37231 2439 24 accounting account VBG 37231 2439 25 for for IN 37231 2439 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2439 27 might may MD 37231 2439 28 never never RB 37231 2439 29 have have VB 37231 2439 30 arisen arise VBN 37231 2439 31 . . . 37231 2440 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2440 2 is be VBZ 37231 2440 3 clear clear JJ 37231 2440 4 , , , 37231 2440 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 2440 6 , , , 37231 2440 7 that that IN 37231 2440 8 an an DT 37231 2440 9 assumption assumption NN 37231 2440 10 which which WDT 37231 2440 11 permits permit VBZ 37231 2440 12 the the DT 37231 2440 13 argument argument NN 37231 2440 14 to to TO 37231 2440 15 attain attain VB 37231 2440 16 any any DT 37231 2440 17 such such JJ 37231 2440 18 position position NN 37231 2440 19 begs beg VBZ 37231 2440 20 almost almost RB 37231 2440 21 the the DT 37231 2440 22 whole whole JJ 37231 2440 23 question question NN 37231 2440 24 . . . 37231 2441 1 Facts fact NNS 37231 2441 2 , , , 37231 2441 3 however however RB 37231 2441 4 astounding astounding JJ 37231 2441 5 , , , 37231 2441 6 which which WDT 37231 2441 7 , , , 37231 2441 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2441 9 is be VBZ 37231 2441 10 admitted admit VBN 37231 2441 11 , , , 37231 2441 12 did do VBD 37231 2441 13 actually actually RB 37231 2441 14 occur occur VB 37231 2441 15 , , , 37231 2441 16 claim claim VBP 37231 2441 17 a a DT 37231 2441 18 latitude latitude NN 37231 2441 19 of of IN 37231 2441 20 explanation explanation NN 37231 2441 21 , , , 37231 2441 22 which which WDT 37231 2441 23 a a DT 37231 2441 24 mere mere JJ 37231 2441 25 narrative narrative NN 37231 2441 26 of of IN 37231 2441 27 those those DT 37231 2441 28 alleged allege VBN 37231 2441 29 facts fact NNS 37231 2441 30 , , , 37231 2441 31 written write VBN 37231 2441 32 by by IN 37231 2441 33 an an DT 37231 2441 34 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2441 35 person person NN 37231 2441 36 some some DT 37231 2441 37 eighteen eighteen CD 37231 2441 38 centuries century NNS 37231 2441 39 ago ago RB 37231 2441 40 , , , 37231 2441 41 could could MD 37231 2441 42 not not RB 37231 2441 43 obtain obtain VB 37231 2441 44 . . . 37231 2442 1 If if IN 37231 2442 2 , , , 37231 2442 3 for for IN 37231 2442 4 instance instance NN 37231 2442 5 , , , 37231 2442 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2442 7 be be VB 37231 2442 8 once once RB 37231 2442 9 established establish VBN 37231 2442 10 as as IN 37231 2442 11 an an DT 37231 2442 12 absolute absolute JJ 37231 2442 13 fact fact NN 37231 2442 14 that that IN 37231 2442 15 a a DT 37231 2442 16 man man NN 37231 2442 17 actually actually RB 37231 2442 18 dead dead JJ 37231 2442 19 , , , 37231 2442 20 and and CC 37231 2442 21 some some DT 37231 2442 22 days day NNS 37231 2442 23 buried bury VBN 37231 2442 24 , , , 37231 2442 25 upon upon IN 37231 2442 26 whose whose WP$ 37231 2442 27 body body NN 37231 2442 28 decomposition decomposition NN 37231 2442 29 had have VBD 37231 2442 30 already already RB 37231 2442 31 made make VBN 37231 2442 32 some some DT 37231 2442 33 progress,(1 progress,(1 NN 37231 2442 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2442 35 had have VBD 37231 2442 36 been be VBN 37231 2442 37 restored restore VBN 37231 2442 38 to to IN 37231 2442 39 life life NN 37231 2442 40 , , , 37231 2442 41 the the DT 37231 2442 42 fact fact NN 37231 2442 43 of of IN 37231 2442 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2442 45 death death NN 37231 2442 46 and and CC 37231 2442 47 of of IN 37231 2442 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2442 49 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 2442 50 resuscitation resuscitation NN 37231 2442 51 being be VBG 37231 2442 52 so so RB 37231 2442 53 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 2442 54 proved prove VBN 37231 2442 55 that that IN 37231 2442 56 the the DT 37231 2442 57 possibility possibility NN 37231 2442 58 of of IN 37231 2442 59 deception deception NN 37231 2442 60 or or CC 37231 2442 61 of of IN 37231 2442 62 mistake mistake NN 37231 2442 63 on on IN 37231 2442 64 the the DT 37231 2442 65 part part NN 37231 2442 66 of of IN 37231 2442 67 the the DT 37231 2442 68 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2442 69 was be VBD 37231 2442 70 totally totally RB 37231 2442 71 excluded exclude VBN 37231 2442 72 -- -- : 37231 2442 73 if if IN 37231 2442 74 such such JJ 37231 2442 75 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 2442 76 evidence evidence NN 37231 2442 77 be be VB 37231 2442 78 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2442 79 possible possible JJ 37231 2442 80 in in IN 37231 2442 81 such such PDT 37231 2442 82 a a DT 37231 2442 83 case case NN 37231 2442 84 -- -- : 37231 2442 85 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2442 86 is be VBZ 37231 2442 87 clear clear JJ 37231 2442 88 that that IN 37231 2442 89 an an DT 37231 2442 90 argument argument NN 37231 2442 91 , , , 37231 2442 92 as as IN 37231 2442 93 to to IN 37231 2442 94 whether whether IN 37231 2442 95 such such PDT 37231 2442 96 an an DT 37231 2442 97 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2442 98 were be VBD 37231 2442 99 to to TO 37231 2442 100 be be VB 37231 2442 101 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2442 102 to to IN 37231 2442 103 known known JJ 37231 2442 104 or or CC 37231 2442 105 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2442 106 laws law NNS 37231 2442 107 , , , 37231 2442 108 would would MD 37231 2442 109 assume assume VB 37231 2442 110 a a DT 37231 2442 111 very very RB 37231 2442 112 different different JJ 37231 2442 113 character character NN 37231 2442 114 indeed indeed RB 37231 2442 115 from from IN 37231 2442 116 that that DT 37231 2442 117 which which WDT 37231 2442 118 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2442 119 would would MD 37231 2442 120 have have VB 37231 2442 121 borne bear VBN 37231 2442 122 if if IN 37231 2442 123 the the DT 37231 2442 124 argument argument NN 37231 2442 125 merely merely RB 37231 2442 126 sought seek VBD 37231 2442 127 to to TO 37231 2442 128 account account VB 37231 2442 129 for for IN 37231 2442 130 so so RB 37231 2442 131 astounding astounding JJ 37231 2442 132 a a DT 37231 2442 133 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 2442 134 of of IN 37231 2442 135 whose whose WP$ 37231 2442 136 actual actual JJ 37231 2442 137 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2442 138 there there EX 37231 2442 139 was be VBD 37231 2442 140 no no DT 37231 2442 141 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 2442 142 evidence evidence NN 37231 2442 143 . . . 37231 2443 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2443 2 must must MD 37231 2443 3 not not RB 37231 2443 4 be be VB 37231 2443 5 forgotten forget VBN 37231 2443 6 , , , 37231 2443 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 2443 8 , , , 37231 2443 9 that that IN 37231 2443 10 , , , 37231 2443 11 as as IN 37231 2443 12 the the DT 37231 2443 13 late late JJ 37231 2443 14 Professor Professor NNP 37231 2443 15 Baden Baden NNP 37231 2443 16 Powell Powell NNP 37231 2443 17 pointed point VBD 37231 2443 18 out out RP 37231 2443 19 : : : 37231 2443 20 " " `` 37231 2443 21 At at IN 37231 2443 22 the the DT 37231 2443 23 present present JJ 37231 2443 24 day day NN 37231 2443 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2443 26 is be VBZ 37231 2443 27 not not RB 37231 2443 28 _ _ NNP 37231 2443 29 a a DT 37231 2443 30 miracle miracle NN 37231 2443 31 _ _ NNP 37231 2443 32 , , , 37231 2443 33 but but CC 37231 2443 34 the the DT 37231 2443 35 _ _ NNP 37231 2443 36 narrative narrative NN 37231 2443 37 of of IN 37231 2443 38 a a DT 37231 2443 39 miracle miracle NN 37231 2443 40 _ _ NNP 37231 2443 41 , , , 37231 2443 42 to to TO 37231 2443 43 which which WDT 37231 2443 44 any any DT 37231 2443 45 argument argument NN 37231 2443 46 can can MD 37231 2443 47 refer refer VB 37231 2443 48 , , , 37231 2443 49 or or CC 37231 2443 50 to to TO 37231 2443 51 which which WDT 37231 2443 52 faith faith NN 37231 2443 53 is be VBZ 37231 2443 54 accorded accord VBN 37231 2443 55 . . . 37231 2444 1 " " `` 37231 2444 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2444 3 2 2 LS 37231 2444 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2444 5 The the DT 37231 2444 6 discussion discussion NN 37231 2444 7 of of IN 37231 2444 8 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2444 9 , , , 37231 2444 10 then then RB 37231 2444 11 , , , 37231 2444 12 is be VBZ 37231 2444 13 not not RB 37231 2444 14 one one CD 37231 2444 15 regarding regard VBG 37231 2444 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2444 17 actually actually RB 37231 2444 18 performed perform VBN 37231 2444 19 within within IN 37231 2444 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2444 21 own own JJ 37231 2444 22 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2444 23 , , , 37231 2444 24 but but CC 37231 2444 25 merely merely RB 37231 2444 26 regarding regard VBG 37231 2444 27 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2444 28 said say VBD 37231 2444 29 to to TO 37231 2444 30 have have VB 37231 2444 31 been be VBN 37231 2444 32 performed perform VBN 37231 2444 33 eighteen eighteen CD 37231 2444 34 hundred hundred CD 37231 2444 35 years year NNS 37231 2444 36 ago ago RB 37231 2444 37 , , , 37231 2444 38 the the DT 37231 2444 39 reality reality NN 37231 2444 40 of of IN 37231 2444 41 { { -LRB- 37231 2444 42 208 208 CD 37231 2444 43 } } -RRB- 37231 2444 44 which which WDT 37231 2444 45 was be VBD 37231 2444 46 not not RB 37231 2444 47 verified verify VBN 37231 2444 48 at at IN 37231 2444 49 the the DT 37231 2444 50 time time NN 37231 2444 51 by by IN 37231 2444 52 any any DT 37231 2444 53 scientific scientific JJ 37231 2444 54 examination examination NN 37231 2444 55 , , , 37231 2444 56 and and CC 37231 2444 57 whose whose WP$ 37231 2444 58 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2444 59 is be VBZ 37231 2444 60 merely merely RB 37231 2444 61 reported report VBN 37231 2444 62 in in IN 37231 2444 63 the the DT 37231 2444 64 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2444 65 . . . 37231 2445 1 Now now RB 37231 2445 2 , , , 37231 2445 3 although although IN 37231 2445 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2445 5 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2445 6 rightly rightly RB 37231 2445 7 and and CC 37231 2445 8 logically logically RB 37231 2445 9 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 2445 10 that that IN 37231 2445 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2445 12 requires require VBZ 37231 2445 13 , , , 37231 2445 14 and and CC 37231 2445 15 should should MD 37231 2445 16 be be VB 37231 2445 17 believed believe VBN 37231 2445 18 only only RB 37231 2445 19 upon upon IN 37231 2445 20 , , , 37231 2445 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2445 22 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2445 23 evidence evidence NN 37231 2445 24 , , , 37231 2445 25 the the DT 37231 2445 26 fact fact NN 37231 2445 27 is be VBZ 37231 2445 28 that that IN 37231 2445 29 popular popular JJ 37231 2445 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2445 31 is be VBZ 37231 2445 32 not not RB 37231 2445 33 believed believe VBN 37231 2445 34 because because IN 37231 2445 35 of of IN 37231 2445 36 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2445 37 , , , 37231 2445 38 but but CC 37231 2445 39 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2445 40 are be VBP 37231 2445 41 accepted accept VBN 37231 2445 42 because because IN 37231 2445 43 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2445 44 are be VBP 37231 2445 45 related relate VBN 37231 2445 46 in in IN 37231 2445 47 the the DT 37231 2445 48 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2445 49 which which WDT 37231 2445 50 are be VBP 37231 2445 51 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2445 52 to to TO 37231 2445 53 contain contain VB 37231 2445 54 the the DT 37231 2445 55 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 2445 56 of of IN 37231 2445 57 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2445 58 . . . 37231 2446 1 The the DT 37231 2446 2 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2446 3 have have VBP 37231 2446 4 for for IN 37231 2446 5 many many JJ 37231 2446 6 generations generation NNS 37231 2446 7 been be VBN 37231 2446 8 given give VBN 37231 2446 9 to to IN 37231 2446 10 the the DT 37231 2446 11 child child NN 37231 2446 12 as as IN 37231 2446 13 inspired inspire VBN 37231 2446 14 records record NNS 37231 2446 15 , , , 37231 2446 16 and and CC 37231 2446 17 doubt doubt NN 37231 2446 18 of of IN 37231 2446 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2446 20 has have VBZ 37231 2446 21 , , , 37231 2446 22 therefore therefore RB 37231 2446 23 , , , 37231 2446 24 either either CC 37231 2446 25 never never RB 37231 2446 26 arisen arise VBN 37231 2446 27 or or CC 37231 2446 28 has have VBZ 37231 2446 29 been be VBN 37231 2446 30 instantly instantly RB 37231 2446 31 suppressed suppress VBN 37231 2446 32 , , , 37231 2446 33 simply simply RB 37231 2446 34 because because IN 37231 2446 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2446 36 are be VBP 37231 2446 37 recorded record VBN 37231 2446 38 in in IN 37231 2446 39 the the DT 37231 2446 40 sacred sacred JJ 37231 2446 41 volume volume NN 37231 2446 42 . . . 37231 2447 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2447 2 could could MD 37231 2447 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2447 4 be be VB 37231 2447 5 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 2447 6 , , , 37231 2447 7 for for IN 37231 2447 8 in in IN 37231 2447 9 point point NN 37231 2447 10 of of IN 37231 2447 11 fact fact NN 37231 2447 12 the the DT 37231 2447 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2447 14 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2447 15 stand stand VBP 37231 2447 16 upon upon IN 37231 2447 17 no no DT 37231 2447 18 other other JJ 37231 2447 19 testimony testimony NN 37231 2447 20 . . . 37231 2448 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2448 2 are be VBP 37231 2448 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 2448 4 in in IN 37231 2448 5 this this DT 37231 2448 6 position position NN 37231 2448 7 : : : 37231 2448 8 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2448 9 are be VBP 37231 2448 10 asked ask VBN 37231 2448 11 to to TO 37231 2448 12 believe believe VB 37231 2448 13 astounding astounding JJ 37231 2448 14 announcements announcement NNS 37231 2448 15 beyond beyond IN 37231 2448 16 the the DT 37231 2448 17 limits limit NNS 37231 2448 18 of of IN 37231 2448 19 human human JJ 37231 2448 20 reason reason NN 37231 2448 21 , , , 37231 2448 22 which which WDT 37231 2448 23 , , , 37231 2448 24 as as IN 37231 2448 25 Br Br NNP 37231 2448 26 . . . 37231 2449 1 Mozley Mozley NNP 37231 2449 2 admits admit VBZ 37231 2449 3 , , , 37231 2449 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2449 5 could could MD 37231 2449 6 only only RB 37231 2449 7 be be VB 37231 2449 8 justified justify VBN 37231 2449 9 in in IN 37231 2449 10 believing believe VBG 37231 2449 11 upon upon IN 37231 2449 12 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2449 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 2449 14 , , , 37231 2449 15 upon upon IN 37231 2449 16 the the DT 37231 2449 17 testimony testimony NN 37231 2449 18 of of IN 37231 2449 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2449 20 which which WDT 37231 2449 21 are be VBP 37231 2449 22 only only RB 37231 2449 23 reported report VBN 37231 2449 24 by by IN 37231 2449 25 the the DT 37231 2449 26 records record NNS 37231 2449 27 which which WDT 37231 2449 28 also also RB 37231 2449 29 alone alone RB 37231 2449 30 convey convey VBP 37231 2449 31 the the DT 37231 2449 32 announcements announcement NNS 37231 2449 33 which which WDT 37231 2449 34 those those DT 37231 2449 35 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2449 36 were be VBD 37231 2449 37 intended intend VBN 37231 2449 38 to to TO 37231 2449 39 accredit accredit VB 37231 2449 40 . . . 37231 2450 1 There there EX 37231 2450 2 is be VBZ 37231 2450 3 no no DT 37231 2450 4 other other JJ 37231 2450 5 contemporary contemporary JJ 37231 2450 6 evidence evidence NN 37231 2450 7 whatever whatever WDT 37231 2450 8 . . . 37231 2451 1 The the DT 37231 2451 2 importance importance NN 37231 2451 3 of of IN 37231 2451 4 the the DT 37231 2451 5 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2451 6 , , , 37231 2451 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 2451 8 , , , 37231 2451 9 as as IN 37231 2451 10 the the DT 37231 2451 11 almost almost RB 37231 2451 12 solitary solitary JJ 37231 2451 13 testimony testimony NN 37231 2451 14 to to IN 37231 2451 15 the the DT 37231 2451 16 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2451 17 of of IN 37231 2451 18 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2451 19 can can MD 37231 2451 20 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2451 21 be be VB 37231 2451 22 exaggerated exaggerate VBN 37231 2451 23 . . . 37231 2452 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2452 2 1 1 LS 37231 2452 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2452 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2452 5 have have VBP 37231 2452 6 already already RB 37231 2452 7 1 1 CD 37231 2452 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2452 9 Farrar Farrar NNP 37231 2452 10 , , , 37231 2452 11 winding wind VBG 37231 2452 12 up up RP 37231 2452 13 the the DT 37231 2452 14 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 2452 15 discussion discussion NN 37231 2452 16 , , , 37231 2452 17 says say VBZ 37231 2452 18 : : : 37231 2452 19 " " `` 37231 2452 20 .... .... NFP 37231 2452 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2452 22 arrive arrive VBP 37231 2452 23 at at IN 37231 2452 24 this this DT 37231 2452 25 point point NN 37231 2452 26 -- -- : 37231 2452 27 that that IN 37231 2452 28 the the DT 37231 2452 29 credibility credibility NN 37231 2452 30 of of IN 37231 2452 31 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2452 32 is be VBZ 37231 2452 33 in in IN 37231 2452 34 each each DT 37231 2452 35 instance instance NN 37231 2452 36 simply simply RB 37231 2452 37 and and CC 37231 2452 38 solely solely RB 37231 2452 39 a a DT 37231 2452 40 question question NN 37231 2452 41 of of IN 37231 2452 42 evidence evidence NN 37231 2452 43 , , , 37231 2452 44 and and CC 37231 2452 45 consequently consequently RB 37231 2452 46 that that IN 37231 2452 47 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2452 48 belief belief NN 37231 2452 49 or or CC 37231 2452 50 rejection rejection NN 37231 2452 51 of of IN 37231 2452 52 the the DT 37231 2452 53 Christian christian JJ 37231 2452 54 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2452 55 must must MD 37231 2452 56 mainly mainly RB 37231 2452 57 depend depend VB 37231 2452 58 on on IN 37231 2452 59 the the DT 37231 2452 60 character character NN 37231 2452 61 of of IN 37231 2452 62 the the DT 37231 2452 63 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2452 64 in in IN 37231 2452 65 which which WDT 37231 2452 66 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2452 67 are be VBP 37231 2452 68 recorded record VBN 37231 2452 69 . . . 37231 2452 70 " " '' 37231 2453 1 The the DT 37231 2453 2 Witness Witness NNP 37231 2453 3 of of IN 37231 2453 4 History history NN 37231 2453 5 to to IN 37231 2453 6 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2453 7 , , , 37231 2453 8 1872 1872 CD 37231 2453 9 , , , 37231 2453 10 p. p. NN 37231 2453 11 51 51 CD 37231 2453 12 . . . 37231 2454 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2454 2 is be VBZ 37231 2454 3 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 2454 4 singular singular JJ 37231 2454 5 that that IN 37231 2454 6 after after IN 37231 2454 7 such such PDT 37231 2454 8 a a DT 37231 2454 9 declaration declaration NN 37231 2454 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2454 11 considers consider VBZ 37231 2454 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2454 13 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 2454 14 to to TO 37231 2454 15 enter enter VB 37231 2454 16 into into IN 37231 2454 17 the the DT 37231 2454 18 question question NN 37231 2454 19 of of IN 37231 2454 20 the the DT 37231 2454 21 genuineness genuineness NN 37231 2454 22 and and CC 37231 2454 23 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2454 24 of of IN 37231 2454 25 the the DT 37231 2454 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2454 27 , , , 37231 2454 28 deeming deem VBG 37231 2454 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2454 30 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 2454 31 for for IN 37231 2454 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2454 33 purpose purpose NN 37231 2454 34 , , , 37231 2454 35 that that IN 37231 2454 36 Strauss Strauss NNP 37231 2454 37 and and CC 37231 2454 38 Renan Renan NNP 37231 2454 39 admit admit VBP 37231 2454 40 that that IN 37231 2454 41 some some DT 37231 2454 42 portion portion NN 37231 2454 43 of of IN 37231 2454 44 these these DT 37231 2454 45 documents document NNS 37231 2454 46 existed exist VBD 37231 2454 47 at at IN 37231 2454 48 the the DT 37231 2454 49 beginning beginning NN 37231 2454 50 of of IN 37231 2454 51 the the DT 37231 2454 52 second second JJ 37231 2454 53 century century NN 37231 2454 54 , , , 37231 2454 55 or or CC 37231 2454 56 earlier early RBR 37231 2454 57 , , , 37231 2454 58 in in IN 37231 2454 59 the the DT 37231 2454 60 country country NN 37231 2454 61 where where WRB 37231 2454 62 the the DT 37231 2454 63 events event NNS 37231 2454 64 narrated narrate VBD 37231 2454 65 took take VBD 37231 2454 66 place place NN 37231 2454 67 . . . 37231 2455 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2455 2 209 209 CD 37231 2455 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2455 4 made make VBD 37231 2455 5 an an DT 37231 2455 6 anticipatory anticipatory JJ 37231 2455 7 remark remark NN 37231 2455 8 regarding regard VBG 37231 2455 9 the the DT 37231 2455 10 nature nature NN 37231 2455 11 of of IN 37231 2455 12 these these DT 37231 2455 13 documents document NNS 37231 2455 14 , , , 37231 2455 15 to to TO 37231 2455 16 which which WDT 37231 2455 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2455 18 may may MD 37231 2455 19 add add VB 37231 2455 20 that that IN 37231 2455 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2455 22 are be VBP 37231 2455 23 not not RB 37231 2455 24 the the DT 37231 2455 25 work work NN 37231 2455 26 of of IN 37231 2455 27 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2455 28 independent independent JJ 37231 2455 29 historians historian NNS 37231 2455 30 , , , 37231 2455 31 but but CC 37231 2455 32 of of IN 37231 2455 33 men man NNS 37231 2455 34 who who WP 37231 2455 35 were be VBD 37231 2455 36 engaged engage VBN 37231 2455 37 in in IN 37231 2455 38 disseminating disseminate VBG 37231 2455 39 the the DT 37231 2455 40 new new JJ 37231 2455 41 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 2455 42 , , , 37231 2455 43 and and CC 37231 2455 44 in in IN 37231 2455 45 saying say VBG 37231 2455 46 this this DT 37231 2455 47 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2455 48 have have VBP 37231 2455 49 no no DT 37231 2455 50 intention intention NN 37231 2455 51 of of IN 37231 2455 52 accusing accuse VBG 37231 2455 53 the the DT 37231 2455 54 writers writer NNS 37231 2455 55 of of IN 37231 2455 56 conscious conscious JJ 37231 2455 57 deception deception NN 37231 2455 58 ; ; : 37231 2455 59 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2455 60 is be VBZ 37231 2455 61 , , , 37231 2455 62 however however RB 37231 2455 63 , , , 37231 2455 64 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2455 65 to to TO 37231 2455 66 state state VB 37231 2455 67 the the DT 37231 2455 68 fact fact NN 37231 2455 69 in in IN 37231 2455 70 order order NN 37231 2455 71 that that IN 37231 2455 72 the the DT 37231 2455 73 value value NN 37231 2455 74 of of IN 37231 2455 75 the the DT 37231 2455 76 testimony testimony NN 37231 2455 77 may may MD 37231 2455 78 be be VB 37231 2455 79 fairly fairly RB 37231 2455 80 estimated estimate VBN 37231 2455 81 . . . 37231 2456 1 The the DT 37231 2456 2 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2456 3 of of IN 37231 2456 4 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2456 5 were be VBD 37231 2456 6 written write VBN 37231 2456 7 by by IN 37231 2456 8 ardent ardent JJ 37231 2456 9 partizans partizan NNS 37231 2456 10 , , , 37231 2456 11 with with IN 37231 2456 12 minds mind NNS 37231 2456 13 inflamed inflame VBN 37231 2456 14 by by IN 37231 2456 15 religious religious JJ 37231 2456 16 zeal zeal NN 37231 2456 17 and and CC 37231 2456 18 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 37231 2456 19 , , , 37231 2456 20 in in IN 37231 2456 21 an an DT 37231 2456 22 age age NN 37231 2456 23 of of IN 37231 2456 24 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2456 25 and and CC 37231 2456 26 superstition superstition NN 37231 2456 27 , , , 37231 2456 28 a a DT 37231 2456 29 considerable considerable JJ 37231 2456 30 time time NN 37231 2456 31 after after IN 37231 2456 32 the the DT 37231 2456 33 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2456 34 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 2456 35 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2456 36 had have VBD 37231 2456 37 taken take VBN 37231 2456 38 place place NN 37231 2456 39 . . . 37231 2457 1 All all DT 37231 2457 2 history history NN 37231 2457 3 shows show VBZ 37231 2457 4 how how WRB 37231 2457 5 rapidly rapidly RB 37231 2457 6 pious pious JJ 37231 2457 7 memory memory NN 37231 2457 8 exaggerates exaggerate NNS 37231 2457 9 and and CC 37231 2457 10 idealizes idealize VBZ 37231 2457 11 the the DT 37231 2457 12 traditions tradition NNS 37231 2457 13 of of IN 37231 2457 14 the the DT 37231 2457 15 past past NN 37231 2457 16 , , , 37231 2457 17 and and CC 37231 2457 18 simple simple JJ 37231 2457 19 actions action NNS 37231 2457 20 might may MD 37231 2457 21 readily readily RB 37231 2457 22 be be VB 37231 2457 23 transformed transform VBN 37231 2457 24 into into IN 37231 2457 25 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2457 26 , , , 37231 2457 27 as as IN 37231 2457 28 the the DT 37231 2457 29 narratives narrative NNS 37231 2457 30 circulated circulate VBD 37231 2457 31 , , , 37231 2457 32 in in IN 37231 2457 33 a a DT 37231 2457 34 period period NN 37231 2457 35 so so RB 37231 2457 36 prone prone JJ 37231 2457 37 to to IN 37231 2457 38 superstition superstition NN 37231 2457 39 and and CC 37231 2457 40 so so RB 37231 2457 41 characterized characterize VBN 37231 2457 42 by by IN 37231 2457 43 love love NN 37231 2457 44 of of IN 37231 2457 45 the the DT 37231 2457 46 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 2457 47 . . . 37231 2458 1 Religious religious JJ 37231 2458 2 excitement excitement NN 37231 2458 3 and and CC 37231 2458 4 reverence reverence NN 37231 2458 5 for for IN 37231 2458 6 the the DT 37231 2458 7 noblest noble JJS 37231 2458 8 of of IN 37231 2458 9 Teachers teacher NNS 37231 2458 10 could could MD 37231 2458 11 not not RB 37231 2458 12 , , , 37231 2458 13 under under IN 37231 2458 14 such such JJ 37231 2458 15 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2458 16 and and CC 37231 2458 17 in in IN 37231 2458 18 such such PDT 37231 2458 19 an an DT 37231 2458 20 age age NN 37231 2458 21 , , , 37231 2458 22 have have VBP 37231 2458 23 escaped escape VBN 37231 2458 24 this this DT 37231 2458 25 exaggeration exaggeration NN 37231 2458 26 . . . 37231 2459 1 How how WRB 37231 2459 2 few few JJ 37231 2459 3 men man NNS 37231 2459 4 in in IN 37231 2459 5 more more RBR 37231 2459 6 enlightened enlightened JJ 37231 2459 7 times time NNS 37231 2459 8 have have VBP 37231 2459 9 been be VBN 37231 2459 10 able able JJ 37231 2459 11 soberly soberly RB 37231 2459 12 to to TO 37231 2459 13 appreciate appreciate VB 37231 2459 14 , , , 37231 2459 15 and and CC 37231 2459 16 accurately accurately RB 37231 2459 17 to to TO 37231 2459 18 record record VB 37231 2459 19 exciting exciting JJ 37231 2459 20 experiences experience NNS 37231 2459 21 , , , 37231 2459 22 where where WRB 37231 2459 23 feeling feeling NN 37231 2459 24 and and CC 37231 2459 25 religious religious JJ 37231 2459 26 emotion emotion NN 37231 2459 27 have have VBP 37231 2459 28 been be VBN 37231 2459 29 concerned concern VBN 37231 2459 30 . . . 37231 2460 1 Prosaic prosaic JJ 37231 2460 2 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2460 3 of of IN 37231 2460 4 observation observation NN 37231 2460 5 and and CC 37231 2460 6 of of IN 37231 2460 7 language language NN 37231 2460 8 , , , 37231 2460 9 at at IN 37231 2460 10 all all DT 37231 2460 11 times time NNS 37231 2460 12 rare rare JJ 37231 2460 13 , , , 37231 2460 14 are be VBP 37231 2460 15 the the DT 37231 2460 16 last last JJ 37231 2460 17 qualities quality NNS 37231 2460 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2460 19 could could MD 37231 2460 20 expect expect VB 37231 2460 21 to to TO 37231 2460 22 find find VB 37231 2460 23 in in IN 37231 2460 24 the the DT 37231 2460 25 early early JJ 37231 2460 26 ages age NNS 37231 2460 27 of of IN 37231 2460 28 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2460 29 . . . 37231 2461 1 In in IN 37231 2461 2 the the DT 37231 2461 3 certain certain JJ 37231 2461 4 fact fact NN 37231 2461 5 that that IN 37231 2461 6 disputes dispute NNS 37231 2461 7 arose arise VBD 37231 2461 8 among among IN 37231 2461 9 the the DT 37231 2461 10 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2461 11 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2461 12 so so RB 37231 2461 13 shortly shortly RB 37231 2461 14 after after IN 37231 2461 15 the the DT 37231 2461 16 death death NN 37231 2461 17 of of IN 37231 2461 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2461 19 great great JJ 37231 2461 20 Master Master NNP 37231 2461 21 , , , 37231 2461 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2461 23 have have VBP 37231 2461 24 one one CD 37231 2461 25 proof proof NN 37231 2461 26 that that IN 37231 2461 27 even even RB 37231 2461 28 amongst amongst IN 37231 2461 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2461 30 there there EX 37231 2461 31 was be VBD 37231 2461 32 no no DT 37231 2461 33 accurate accurate JJ 37231 2461 34 appreciation appreciation NN 37231 2461 35 of of IN 37231 2461 36 the the DT 37231 2461 37 teaching teaching NN 37231 2461 38 of of IN 37231 2461 39 Jesus,(1 Jesus,(1 NNP 37231 2461 40 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2461 41 and and CC 37231 2461 42 the the DT 37231 2461 43 frequent frequent JJ 37231 2461 44 instances instance NNS 37231 2461 45 of of IN 37231 2461 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2461 47 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN 37231 2461 48 of of IN 37231 2461 49 very very RB 37231 2461 50 simple simple JJ 37231 2461 51 matters matter NNS 37231 2461 52 , , , 37231 2461 53 and and CC 37231 2461 54 of of IN 37231 2461 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2461 56 want want NN 37231 2461 57 of of IN 37231 2461 58 enlightenment enlightenment NN 37231 2461 59 , , , 37231 2461 60 which which WDT 37231 2461 61 occur occur VBP 37231 2461 62 throughout throughout IN 37231 2461 63 the the DT 37231 2461 64 { { -LRB- 37231 2461 65 210 210 CD 37231 2461 66 } } -RRB- 37231 2461 67 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 2461 68 are be VBP 37231 2461 69 certainly certainly RB 37231 2461 70 not not RB 37231 2461 71 calculated calculate VBN 37231 2461 72 to to TO 37231 2461 73 inspire inspire VB 37231 2461 74 much much JJ 37231 2461 75 confidence confidence NN 37231 2461 76 in in IN 37231 2461 77 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2461 78 intelligence intelligence NN 37231 2461 79 and and CC 37231 2461 80 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2461 81 of of IN 37231 2461 82 observation observation NN 37231 2461 83 . . . 37231 2462 1 Now now RB 37231 2462 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2462 3 is be VBZ 37231 2462 4 apparent apparent JJ 37231 2462 5 that that IN 37231 2462 6 the the DT 37231 2462 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 2462 8 for for IN 37231 2462 9 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 2462 10 requires require VBZ 37231 2462 11 to to TO 37231 2462 12 embrace embrace VB 37231 2462 13 two two CD 37231 2462 14 distinct distinct JJ 37231 2462 15 points point NNS 37231 2462 16 : : : 37231 2462 17 the the DT 37231 2462 18 reality reality NN 37231 2462 19 of of IN 37231 2462 20 the the DT 37231 2462 21 alleged allege VBN 37231 2462 22 facts fact NNS 37231 2462 23 , , , 37231 2462 24 and and CC 37231 2462 25 the the DT 37231 2462 26 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2462 27 of of IN 37231 2462 28 the the DT 37231 2462 29 inference inference NN 37231 2462 30 that that IN 37231 2462 31 the the DT 37231 2462 32 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2462 33 were be VBD 37231 2462 34 produced produce VBN 37231 2462 35 by by IN 37231 2462 36 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2462 37 Agency Agency NNP 37231 2462 38 . . . 37231 2463 1 The the DT 37231 2463 2 task task NN 37231 2463 3 would would MD 37231 2463 4 even even RB 37231 2463 5 then then RB 37231 2463 6 remain remain VB 37231 2463 7 of of IN 37231 2463 8 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 37231 2463 9 the the DT 37231 2463 10 particular particular JJ 37231 2463 11 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 2463 12 Being Being NNP 37231 2463 13 by by IN 37231 2463 14 whom whom WP 37231 2463 15 the the DT 37231 2463 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2463 17 were be VBD 37231 2463 18 performed perform VBN 37231 2463 19 , , , 37231 2463 20 which which WDT 37231 2463 21 is be VBZ 37231 2463 22 admitted admit VBN 37231 2463 23 to to TO 37231 2463 24 be be VB 37231 2463 25 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2463 26 . . . 37231 2464 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2464 2 have have VBP 37231 2464 3 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 2464 4 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 2464 5 confined confine VBN 37231 2464 6 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2464 7 to to IN 37231 2464 8 a a DT 37231 2464 9 consideration consideration NN 37231 2464 10 of of IN 37231 2464 11 the the DT 37231 2464 12 antecedent antecedent NN 37231 2464 13 credibility credibility NN 37231 2464 14 of of IN 37231 2464 15 such such JJ 37231 2464 16 events event NNS 37231 2464 17 , , , 37231 2464 18 and and CC 37231 2464 19 of of IN 37231 2464 20 the the DT 37231 2464 21 fitness fitness NN 37231 2464 22 of of IN 37231 2464 23 those those DT 37231 2464 24 who who WP 37231 2464 25 are be VBP 37231 2464 26 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2464 27 to to TO 37231 2464 28 have have VB 37231 2464 29 witnessed witness VBN 37231 2464 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2464 31 to to TO 37231 2464 32 draw draw VB 37231 2464 33 accurate accurate JJ 37231 2464 34 inferences inference NNS 37231 2464 35 from from IN 37231 2464 36 the the DT 37231 2464 37 alleged allege VBN 37231 2464 38 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2464 39 . . . 37231 2465 1 Those those DT 37231 2465 2 who who WP 37231 2465 3 have have VBP 37231 2465 4 formed form VBN 37231 2465 5 any any DT 37231 2465 6 adequate adequate JJ 37231 2465 7 conception conception NN 37231 2465 8 of of IN 37231 2465 9 the the DT 37231 2465 10 amount amount NN 37231 2465 11 of of IN 37231 2465 12 testimony testimony NN 37231 2465 13 which which WDT 37231 2465 14 would would MD 37231 2465 15 be be VB 37231 2465 16 requisite requisite JJ 37231 2465 17 in in IN 37231 2465 18 order order NN 37231 2465 19 to to TO 37231 2465 20 establish establish VB 37231 2465 21 the the DT 37231 2465 22 reality reality NN 37231 2465 23 of of IN 37231 2465 24 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 2465 25 in in IN 37231 2465 26 violation violation NN 37231 2465 27 of of IN 37231 2465 28 an an DT 37231 2465 29 order order NN 37231 2465 30 of of IN 37231 2465 31 Nature Nature NNP 37231 2465 32 , , , 37231 2465 33 which which WDT 37231 2465 34 is be VBZ 37231 2465 35 based base VBN 37231 2465 36 upon upon IN 37231 2465 37 universal universal JJ 37231 2465 38 and and CC 37231 2465 39 invariable invariable JJ 37231 2465 40 experience experience NN 37231 2465 41 , , , 37231 2465 42 must must MD 37231 2465 43 recognize recognize VB 37231 2465 44 that that DT 37231 2465 45 , , , 37231 2465 46 even even RB 37231 2465 47 if if IN 37231 2465 48 the the DT 37231 2465 49 earliest early JJS 37231 2465 50 asserted assert VBN 37231 2465 51 origin origin NN 37231 2465 52 of of IN 37231 2465 53 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2465 54 four four CD 37231 2465 55 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2465 56 could could MD 37231 2465 57 be be VB 37231 2465 58 established establish VBN 37231 2465 59 upon upon IN 37231 2465 60 the the DT 37231 2465 61 most most RBS 37231 2465 62 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 37231 2465 63 grounds ground NNS 37231 2465 64 , , , 37231 2465 65 the the DT 37231 2465 66 testimony testimony NN 37231 2465 67 of of IN 37231 2465 68 the the DT 37231 2465 69 writers writer NNS 37231 2465 70 -- -- : 37231 2465 71 men man NNS 37231 2465 72 of of IN 37231 2465 73 like like JJ 37231 2465 74 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 2465 75 with with IN 37231 2465 76 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2465 77 contemporaries contemporary NNS 37231 2465 78 , , , 37231 2465 79 men man NNS 37231 2465 80 of of IN 37231 2465 81 like like JJ 37231 2465 82 passions passion NNS 37231 2465 83 with with IN 37231 2465 84 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2465 85 -- -- : 37231 2465 86 would would MD 37231 2465 87 be be VB 37231 2465 88 utterly utterly RB 37231 2465 89 incompetentto incompetentto VBN 37231 2465 90 prove prove VB 37231 2465 91 the the DT 37231 2465 92 reality reality NN 37231 2465 93 of of IN 37231 2465 94 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 2465 95 . . . 37231 2466 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2466 2 have have VBP 37231 2466 3 already already RB 37231 2466 4 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 2466 5 discussed discuss VBN 37231 2466 6 this this DT 37231 2466 7 point point NN 37231 2466 8 , , , 37231 2466 9 more more RBR 37231 2466 10 especially especially RB 37231 2466 11 in in IN 37231 2466 12 connection connection NN 37231 2466 13 with with IN 37231 2466 14 Hume Hume NNP 37231 2466 15 's 's POS 37231 2466 16 argument argument NN 37231 2466 17 , , , 37231 2466 18 and and CC 37231 2466 19 need nee MD 37231 2466 20 not not RB 37231 2466 21 here here RB 37231 2466 22 resume resume VB 37231 2466 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2466 24 Every every DT 37231 2466 25 consideration consideration NN 37231 2466 26 , , , 37231 2466 27 historical historical JJ 37231 2466 28 and and CC 37231 2466 29 philosophical philosophical JJ 37231 2466 30 , , , 37231 2466 31 has have VBZ 37231 2466 32 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 2466 33 discredited discredit VBN 37231 2466 34 the the DT 37231 2466 35 whole whole JJ 37231 2466 36 theory theory NN 37231 2466 37 of of IN 37231 2466 38 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2466 39 , , , 37231 2466 40 and and CC 37231 2466 41 further further JJ 37231 2466 42 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2466 43 might may MD 37231 2466 44 be be VB 37231 2466 45 abandoned abandon VBN 37231 2466 46 as as IN 37231 2466 47 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 2466 48 . . . 37231 2467 1 In in IN 37231 2467 2 order order NN 37231 2467 3 , , , 37231 2467 4 however however RB 37231 2467 5 , , , 37231 2467 6 to to TO 37231 2467 7 render render VB 37231 2467 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2467 9 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2467 10 complete complete JJ 37231 2467 11 , , , 37231 2467 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2467 13 remains remain VBZ 37231 2467 14 for for IN 37231 2467 15 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2467 16 to to TO 37231 2467 17 see see VB 37231 2467 18 whether whether IN 37231 2467 19 , , , 37231 2467 20 as as IN 37231 2467 21 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 2467 22 , , , 37231 2467 23 there there EX 37231 2467 24 be be VB 37231 2467 25 any any DT 37231 2467 26 special special JJ 37231 2467 27 evidence evidence NN 37231 2467 28 regarding regard VBG 37231 2467 29 the the DT 37231 2467 30 alleged allege VBN 37231 2467 31 facts fact NNS 37231 2467 32 entitling entitle VBG 37231 2467 33 the the DT 37231 2467 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2467 35 Miracles Miracles NNPS 37231 2467 36 to to IN 37231 2467 37 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 2467 38 attention attention NN 37231 2467 39 . . . 37231 2468 1 If if IN 37231 2468 2 , , , 37231 2468 3 instead instead RB 37231 2468 4 of of IN 37231 2468 5 being be VBG 37231 2468 6 { { -LRB- 37231 2468 7 211 211 CD 37231 2468 8 } } -RRB- 37231 2468 9 clear clear JJ 37231 2468 10 , , , 37231 2468 11 direct direct JJ 37231 2468 12 , , , 37231 2468 13 the the DT 37231 2468 14 undoubted undoubted JJ 37231 2468 15 testimony testimony NN 37231 2468 16 of of IN 37231 2468 17 known know VBN 37231 2468 18 eyewitnesses eyewitness NNS 37231 2468 19 free free JJ 37231 2468 20 from from IN 37231 2468 21 superstition superstition NN 37231 2468 22 , , , 37231 2468 23 and and CC 37231 2468 24 capable capable JJ 37231 2468 25 , , , 37231 2468 26 through through IN 37231 2468 27 adequate adequate JJ 37231 2468 28 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2468 29 , , , 37231 2468 30 rightly rightly RB 37231 2468 31 to to TO 37231 2468 32 estimate estimate VB 37231 2468 33 the the DT 37231 2468 34 alleged alleged JJ 37231 2468 35 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 2468 36 , , , 37231 2468 37 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2468 38 find find VBP 37231 2468 39 that that IN 37231 2468 40 the the DT 37231 2468 41 actual actual JJ 37231 2468 42 accounts account NNS 37231 2468 43 have have VBP 37231 2468 44 none none NN 37231 2468 45 of of IN 37231 2468 46 these these DT 37231 2468 47 qualifications qualification NNS 37231 2468 48 , , , 37231 2468 49 the the DT 37231 2468 50 final final JJ 37231 2468 51 decision decision NN 37231 2468 52 with with IN 37231 2468 53 regard regard NN 37231 2468 54 to to IN 37231 2468 55 Miracles miracle NNS 37231 2468 56 and and CC 37231 2468 57 the the DT 37231 2468 58 reality reality NN 37231 2468 59 of of IN 37231 2468 60 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2468 61 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 2468 62 will will MD 37231 2468 63 be be VB 37231 2468 64 easy easy JJ 37231 2468 65 and and CC 37231 2468 66 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 2468 67 . . . 37231 2469 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2469 2 212 212 CD 37231 2469 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2469 4 PART PART NNP 37231 2469 5 II ii CD 37231 2469 6 . . . 37231 2470 1 THE the DT 37231 2470 2 SYNOPTIC SYNOPTIC NNP 37231 2470 3 GOSPELS gospel VBD 37231 2470 4 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 37231 2470 5 . . . 37231 2471 1 Before before IN 37231 2471 2 commencing commence VBG 37231 2471 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2471 4 examination examination NN 37231 2471 5 of of IN 37231 2471 6 the the DT 37231 2471 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 2471 8 as as IN 37231 2471 9 to to IN 37231 2471 10 the the DT 37231 2471 11 date date NN 37231 2471 12 , , , 37231 2471 13 authorship authorship NN 37231 2471 14 , , , 37231 2471 15 and and CC 37231 2471 16 character character NN 37231 2471 17 of of IN 37231 2471 18 the the DT 37231 2471 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2471 20 , , , 37231 2471 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2471 22 may may MD 37231 2471 23 be be VB 37231 2471 24 well well JJ 37231 2471 25 to to TO 37231 2471 26 make make VB 37231 2471 27 a a DT 37231 2471 28 few few JJ 37231 2471 29 preliminary preliminary JJ 37231 2471 30 remarks remark NNS 37231 2471 31 , , , 37231 2471 32 and and CC 37231 2471 33 clearly clearly RB 37231 2471 34 state state VB 37231 2471 35 certain certain JJ 37231 2471 36 canons canon NNS 37231 2471 37 of of IN 37231 2471 38 criticism criticism NN 37231 2471 39 . . . 37231 2472 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2472 2 shall shall MD 37231 2472 3 make make VB 37231 2472 4 no no DT 37231 2472 5 attempt attempt NN 37231 2472 6 to to TO 37231 2472 7 establish establish VB 37231 2472 8 any any DT 37231 2472 9 theory theory NN 37231 2472 10 as as IN 37231 2472 11 to to IN 37231 2472 12 the the DT 37231 2472 13 date date NN 37231 2472 14 at at IN 37231 2472 15 which which WDT 37231 2472 16 any any DT 37231 2472 17 of of IN 37231 2472 18 the the DT 37231 2472 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2472 20 was be VBD 37231 2472 21 actually actually RB 37231 2472 22 written write VBN 37231 2472 23 , , , 37231 2472 24 but but CC 37231 2472 25 simply simply RB 37231 2472 26 examine examine VB 37231 2472 27 all all PDT 37231 2472 28 the the DT 37231 2472 29 testimony testimony NN 37231 2472 30 which which WDT 37231 2472 31 is be VBZ 37231 2472 32 extant extant JJ 37231 2472 33 with with IN 37231 2472 34 the the DT 37231 2472 35 view view NN 37231 2472 36 of of IN 37231 2472 37 ascertaining ascertain VBG 37231 2472 38 what what WP 37231 2472 39 is be VBZ 37231 2472 40 known know VBN 37231 2472 41 of of IN 37231 2472 42 these these DT 37231 2472 43 works work NNS 37231 2472 44 and and CC 37231 2472 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2472 46 authors author NNS 37231 2472 47 , , , 37231 2472 48 certainly certainly RB 37231 2472 49 and and CC 37231 2472 50 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 2472 51 , , , 37231 2472 52 as as IN 37231 2472 53 distinguished distinguish VBN 37231 2472 54 from from IN 37231 2472 55 what what WP 37231 2472 56 is be VBZ 37231 2472 57 merely merely RB 37231 2472 58 conjectured conjecture VBN 37231 2472 59 or or CC 37231 2472 60 inferred infer VBN 37231 2472 61 . . . 37231 2473 1 Modern modern JJ 37231 2473 2 opinion opinion NN 37231 2473 3 , , , 37231 2473 4 in in IN 37231 2473 5 an an DT 37231 2473 6 Inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2473 7 like like IN 37231 2473 8 ours our NNS 37231 2473 9 , , , 37231 2473 10 must must MD 37231 2473 11 not not RB 37231 2473 12 be be VB 37231 2473 13 mistaken mistake VBN 37231 2473 14 for for IN 37231 2473 15 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2473 16 evidence evidence NN 37231 2473 17 . . . 37231 2474 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2474 2 propose propose VBP 37231 2474 3 , , , 37231 2474 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 2474 5 , , , 37231 2474 6 as as RB 37231 2474 7 exhaustively exhaustively RB 37231 2474 8 as as IN 37231 2474 9 possible possible JJ 37231 2474 10 to to TO 37231 2474 11 search search VB 37231 2474 12 all all PDT 37231 2474 13 the the DT 37231 2474 14 writings writing NNS 37231 2474 15 of of IN 37231 2474 16 the the DT 37231 2474 17 early early JJ 37231 2474 18 Church Church NNP 37231 2474 19 for for IN 37231 2474 20 information information NN 37231 2474 21 regarding regard VBG 37231 2474 22 the the DT 37231 2474 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2474 24 , , , 37231 2474 25 and and CC 37231 2474 26 to to TO 37231 2474 27 examine examine VB 37231 2474 28 even even RB 37231 2474 29 the the DT 37231 2474 30 alleged allege VBN 37231 2474 31 indications indication NNS 37231 2474 32 of of IN 37231 2474 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2474 34 use use NN 37231 2474 35 . . . 37231 2475 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2475 2 is be VBZ 37231 2475 3 very very RB 37231 2475 4 important important JJ 37231 2475 5 , , , 37231 2475 6 however however RB 37231 2475 7 , , , 37231 2475 8 that that IN 37231 2475 9 the the DT 37231 2475 10 silence silence NN 37231 2475 11 of of IN 37231 2475 12 early early JJ 37231 2475 13 writers writer NNS 37231 2475 14 should should MD 37231 2475 15 receive receive VB 37231 2475 16 as as RB 37231 2475 17 much much JJ 37231 2475 18 attention attention NN 37231 2475 19 as as IN 37231 2475 20 any any DT 37231 2475 21 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2475 22 allusions allusion NNS 37231 2475 23 to to IN 37231 2475 24 the the DT 37231 2475 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2475 26 . . . 37231 2476 1 When when WRB 37231 2476 2 such such JJ 37231 2476 3 writers writer NNS 37231 2476 4 , , , 37231 2476 5 quoting quote VBG 37231 2476 6 largely largely RB 37231 2476 7 from from IN 37231 2476 8 the the DT 37231 2476 9 Old Old NNP 37231 2476 10 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2476 11 and and CC 37231 2476 12 other other JJ 37231 2476 13 sources source NNS 37231 2476 14 , , , 37231 2476 15 deal deal NN 37231 2476 16 { { -LRB- 37231 2476 17 213 213 CD 37231 2476 18 } } -RRB- 37231 2476 19 with with IN 37231 2476 20 subjects subject NNS 37231 2476 21 which which WDT 37231 2476 22 would would MD 37231 2476 23 naturally naturally RB 37231 2476 24 be be VB 37231 2476 25 assisted assist VBN 37231 2476 26 by by IN 37231 2476 27 reference reference NN 37231 2476 28 to to IN 37231 2476 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2476 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2476 31 , , , 37231 2476 32 and and CC 37231 2476 33 still still RB 37231 2476 34 more more RBR 37231 2476 35 so so RB 37231 2476 36 by by IN 37231 2476 37 quoting quote VBG 37231 2476 38 such such JJ 37231 2476 39 works work NNS 37231 2476 40 as as IN 37231 2476 41 authoritative,--and authoritative,--and NNP 37231 2476 42 yet yet RB 37231 2476 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2476 44 find find VBP 37231 2476 45 that that IN 37231 2476 46 not not RB 37231 2476 47 only only RB 37231 2476 48 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2476 49 do do VBP 37231 2476 50 not not RB 37231 2476 51 show show VB 37231 2476 52 any any DT 37231 2476 53 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2476 54 of of IN 37231 2476 55 those those DT 37231 2476 56 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2476 57 , , , 37231 2476 58 but but CC 37231 2476 59 actually actually RB 37231 2476 60 quote quote VB 37231 2476 61 passages passage NNS 37231 2476 62 from from IN 37231 2476 63 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2476 64 sources source NNS 37231 2476 65 , , , 37231 2476 66 or or CC 37231 2476 67 sayings saying NNS 37231 2476 68 of of IN 37231 2476 69 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2476 70 derived derive VBD 37231 2476 71 from from IN 37231 2476 72 tradition,--the tradition,--the DT 37231 2476 73 inference inference NN 37231 2476 74 must must MD 37231 2476 75 be be VB 37231 2476 76 that that IN 37231 2476 77 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2476 78 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2476 79 were be VBD 37231 2476 80 either either CC 37231 2476 81 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2476 82 , , , 37231 2476 83 or or CC 37231 2476 84 not not RB 37231 2476 85 recognized recognize VBN 37231 2476 86 as as IN 37231 2476 87 works work NNS 37231 2476 88 of of IN 37231 2476 89 authority authority NN 37231 2476 90 at at IN 37231 2476 91 the the DT 37231 2476 92 time time NN 37231 2476 93 . . . 37231 2477 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2477 2 is be VBZ 37231 2477 3 still still RB 37231 2477 4 more more RBR 37231 2477 5 important important JJ 37231 2477 6 that that IN 37231 2477 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2477 8 should should MD 37231 2477 9 constantly constantly RB 37231 2477 10 bear bear VB 37231 2477 11 in in IN 37231 2477 12 mind mind NN 37231 2477 13 , , , 37231 2477 14 that that IN 37231 2477 15 a a DT 37231 2477 16 great great JJ 37231 2477 17 number number NN 37231 2477 18 of of IN 37231 2477 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2477 20 existed exist VBD 37231 2477 21 in in IN 37231 2477 22 the the DT 37231 2477 23 early early JJ 37231 2477 24 Church church NN 37231 2477 25 which which WDT 37231 2477 26 are be VBP 37231 2477 27 no no RB 37231 2477 28 longer long RBR 37231 2477 29 extant extant JJ 37231 2477 30 , , , 37231 2477 31 and and CC 37231 2477 32 of of IN 37231 2477 33 most most JJS 37231 2477 34 of of IN 37231 2477 35 which which WDT 37231 2477 36 even even RB 37231 2477 37 the the DT 37231 2477 38 names name NNS 37231 2477 39 are be VBP 37231 2477 40 lost lose VBN 37231 2477 41 . . . 37231 2478 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2478 2 need need VBP 37231 2478 3 not not RB 37231 2478 4 here here RB 37231 2478 5 do do VB 37231 2478 6 more more JJR 37231 2478 7 than than IN 37231 2478 8 refer refer VB 37231 2478 9 , , , 37231 2478 10 in in IN 37231 2478 11 corroboration corroboration NN 37231 2478 12 of of IN 37231 2478 13 this this DT 37231 2478 14 fact fact NN 37231 2478 15 , , , 37231 2478 16 to to IN 37231 2478 17 the the DT 37231 2478 18 preliminary preliminary JJ 37231 2478 19 statement statement NN 37231 2478 20 of of IN 37231 2478 21 the the DT 37231 2478 22 author author NN 37231 2478 23 of of IN 37231 2478 24 the the DT 37231 2478 25 third third JJ 37231 2478 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2478 27 : : : 37231 2478 28 " " `` 37231 2478 29 Forasmuch Forasmuch NNP 37231 2478 30 as as IN 37231 2478 31 many many JJ 37231 2478 32 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2478 33 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2478 34 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2478 35 took take VBD 37231 2478 36 in in IN 37231 2478 37 hand hand NN 37231 2478 38 to to TO 37231 2478 39 set set VB 37231 2478 40 forth forth RP 37231 2478 41 in in IN 37231 2478 42 order order NN 37231 2478 43 a a DT 37231 2478 44 declaration declaration NN 37231 2478 45 of of IN 37231 2478 46 the the DT 37231 2478 47 things thing NNS 37231 2478 48 which which WDT 37231 2478 49 have have VBP 37231 2478 50 been be VBN 37231 2478 51 accomplished accomplish VBN 37231 2478 52 among among IN 37231 2478 53 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2478 54 , , , 37231 2478 55 " " '' 37231 2478 56 & & CC 37231 2478 57 c.(1 c.(1 NNP 37231 2478 58 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2478 59 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2478 60 is be VBZ 37231 2478 61 therefore therefore RB 37231 2478 62 evident evident JJ 37231 2478 63 that that IN 37231 2478 64 before before IN 37231 2478 65 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2478 66 third third JJ 37231 2478 67 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2478 68 was be VBD 37231 2478 69 written write VBN 37231 2478 70 many many JJ 37231 2478 71 similar similar JJ 37231 2478 72 works work NNS 37231 2478 73 were be VBD 37231 2478 74 already already RB 37231 2478 75 in in IN 37231 2478 76 circulation circulation NN 37231 2478 77 . . . 37231 2479 1 Looking look VBG 37231 2479 2 at at IN 37231 2479 3 the the DT 37231 2479 4 close close JJ 37231 2479 5 similarity similarity NN 37231 2479 6 of of IN 37231 2479 7 large large JJ 37231 2479 8 portions portion NNS 37231 2479 9 of of IN 37231 2479 10 the the DT 37231 2479 11 three three CD 37231 2479 12 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2479 13 , , , 37231 2479 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2479 15 is be VBZ 37231 2479 16 almost almost RB 37231 2479 17 certain certain JJ 37231 2479 18 that that IN 37231 2479 19 many many JJ 37231 2479 20 of of IN 37231 2479 21 the the DT 37231 2479 22 writings writing NNS 37231 2479 23 here here RB 37231 2479 24 mentioned mention VBD 37231 2479 25 bore bear VBD 37231 2479 26 a a DT 37231 2479 27 close close JJ 37231 2479 28 analogy analogy NN 37231 2479 29 to to IN 37231 2479 30 each each DT 37231 2479 31 other other JJ 37231 2479 32 and and CC 37231 2479 33 to to IN 37231 2479 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2479 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2479 36 , , , 37231 2479 37 and and CC 37231 2479 38 this this DT 37231 2479 39 is be VBZ 37231 2479 40 known know VBN 37231 2479 41 to to TO 37231 2479 42 have have VB 37231 2479 43 been be VBN 37231 2479 44 the the DT 37231 2479 45 case case NN 37231 2479 46 , , , 37231 2479 47 for for IN 37231 2479 48 instance instance NN 37231 2479 49 , , , 37231 2479 50 amongst amongst IN 37231 2479 51 the the DT 37231 2479 52 various various JJ 37231 2479 53 forms form NNS 37231 2479 54 of of IN 37231 2479 55 the the DT 37231 2479 56 " " `` 37231 2479 57 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2479 58 according accord VBG 37231 2479 59 to to IN 37231 2479 60 the the DT 37231 2479 61 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 2479 62 . . . 37231 2479 63 " " '' 37231 2480 1 When when WRB 37231 2480 2 , , , 37231 2480 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 2480 4 , , , 37231 2480 5 in in IN 37231 2480 6 early early JJ 37231 2480 7 writings writing NNS 37231 2480 8 , , , 37231 2480 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2480 10 meet meet VBP 37231 2480 11 with with IN 37231 2480 12 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2480 13 closely closely RB 37231 2480 14 resembling resemble VBG 37231 2480 15 , , , 37231 2480 16 or or CC 37231 2480 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2480 18 may may MD 37231 2480 19 add add VB 37231 2480 20 , , , 37231 2480 21 even even RB 37231 2480 22 identical identical JJ 37231 2480 23 with with IN 37231 2480 24 passages passage NNS 37231 2480 25 which which WDT 37231 2480 26 are be VBP 37231 2480 27 found find VBN 37231 2480 28 in in IN 37231 2480 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2480 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2480 31 , , , 37231 2480 32 the the DT 37231 2480 33 source source NN 37231 2480 34 of of IN 37231 2480 35 which which WDT 37231 2480 36 , , , 37231 2480 37 however however RB 37231 2480 38 , , , 37231 2480 39 is be VBZ 37231 2480 40 not not RB 37231 2480 41 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2480 42 , , , 37231 2480 43 nor nor CC 37231 2480 44 is be VBZ 37231 2480 45 any any DT 37231 2480 46 author author NN 37231 2480 47 's 's POS 37231 2480 48 name name NN 37231 2480 49 indicated indicate VBD 37231 2480 50 , , , 37231 2480 51 the the DT 37231 2480 52 similarity similarity NN 37231 2480 53 or or CC 37231 2480 54 even even RB 37231 2480 55 identity identity NN 37231 2480 56 can can MD 37231 2480 57 not not RB 37231 2480 58 by by IN 37231 2480 59 any any DT 37231 2480 60 means mean NNS 37231 2480 61 be be VB 37231 2480 62 admitted admit VBN 37231 2480 63 as as IN 37231 2480 64 proof proof NN 37231 2480 65 that that IN 37231 2480 66 the the DT 37231 2480 67 quotation quotation NN 37231 2480 68 is be VBZ 37231 2480 69 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 2480 70 from from IN 37231 2480 71 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2480 72 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2480 73 , , , 37231 2480 74 and and CC 37231 2480 75 not not RB 37231 2480 76 from from IN 37231 2480 77 some some DT 37231 2480 78 other other JJ 37231 2480 79 similar similar JJ 37231 2480 80 work work NN 37231 2480 81 { { -LRB- 37231 2480 82 214 214 CD 37231 2480 83 } } -RRB- 37231 2480 84 now now RB 37231 2480 85 no no RB 37231 2480 86 longer long RBR 37231 2480 87 extant,(1 extant,(1 JJ 37231 2480 88 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2480 89 and and CC 37231 2480 90 more more RBR 37231 2480 91 especially especially RB 37231 2480 92 not not RB 37231 2480 93 when when WRB 37231 2480 94 , , , 37231 2480 95 in in IN 37231 2480 96 the the DT 37231 2480 97 same same JJ 37231 2480 98 writings writing NNS 37231 2480 99 , , , 37231 2480 100 there there EX 37231 2480 101 are be VBP 37231 2480 102 other other JJ 37231 2480 103 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2480 104 from from IN 37231 2480 105 sources source NNS 37231 2480 106 different different JJ 37231 2480 107 from from IN 37231 2480 108 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2480 109 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2480 110 . . . 37231 2481 1 Whether whether CC 37231 2481 2 regarded regard VBN 37231 2481 3 as as IN 37231 2481 4 historical historical JJ 37231 2481 5 records record NNS 37231 2481 6 or or CC 37231 2481 7 as as IN 37231 2481 8 writings writing NNS 37231 2481 9 embodying embody VBG 37231 2481 10 the the DT 37231 2481 11 mere mere JJ 37231 2481 12 tradition tradition NN 37231 2481 13 of of IN 37231 2481 14 the the DT 37231 2481 15 early early JJ 37231 2481 16 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2481 17 , , , 37231 2481 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2481 19 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 2481 20 can can MD 37231 2481 21 not not RB 37231 2481 22 be be VB 37231 2481 23 recognized recognize VBN 37231 2481 24 as as IN 37231 2481 25 the the DT 37231 2481 26 exclusive exclusive JJ 37231 2481 27 depositaries depositary NNS 37231 2481 28 of of IN 37231 2481 29 the the DT 37231 2481 30 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2481 31 sayings saying NNS 37231 2481 32 and and CC 37231 2481 33 doings doing NNS 37231 2481 34 of of IN 37231 2481 35 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2481 36 . . . 37231 2482 1 So so RB 37231 2482 2 far far RB 37231 2482 3 from from IN 37231 2482 4 the the DT 37231 2482 5 common common JJ 37231 2482 6 possession possession NN 37231 2482 7 by by IN 37231 2482 8 many many JJ 37231 2482 9 works work NNS 37231 2482 10 , , , 37231 2482 11 in in IN 37231 2482 12 early early JJ 37231 2482 13 times time NNS 37231 2482 14 , , , 37231 2482 15 of of IN 37231 2482 16 sayings saying NNS 37231 2482 17 of of IN 37231 2482 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2482 19 in in IN 37231 2482 20 closely closely RB 37231 2482 21 similar similar JJ 37231 2482 22 form form NN 37231 2482 23 being be VBG 37231 2482 24 either either CC 37231 2482 25 strange strange JJ 37231 2482 26 or or CC 37231 2482 27 improbable improbable JJ 37231 2482 28 , , , 37231 2482 29 the the DT 37231 2482 30 really really RB 37231 2482 31 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 2482 32 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 2482 33 is be VBZ 37231 2482 34 that that IN 37231 2482 35 such such JJ 37231 2482 36 material material NN 37231 2482 37 variation variation NN 37231 2482 38 in in IN 37231 2482 39 the the DT 37231 2482 40 report report NN 37231 2482 41 of of IN 37231 2482 42 the the DT 37231 2482 43 more more RBR 37231 2482 44 important important JJ 37231 2482 45 historical historical JJ 37231 2482 46 teaching teaching NN 37231 2482 47 should should MD 37231 2482 48 exist exist VB 37231 2482 49 amongst amongst IN 37231 2482 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2482 51 . . . 37231 2483 1 But but CC 37231 2483 2 whilst whilst IN 37231 2483 3 similarity similarity NN 37231 2483 4 to to IN 37231 2483 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2483 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2483 7 in in IN 37231 2483 8 passages passage NNS 37231 2483 9 quoted quote VBN 37231 2483 10 by by IN 37231 2483 11 early early JJ 37231 2483 12 writers writer NNS 37231 2483 13 from from IN 37231 2483 14 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 2483 15 sources source NNS 37231 2483 16 can can MD 37231 2483 17 not not RB 37231 2483 18 prove prove VB 37231 2483 19 the the DT 37231 2483 20 use use NN 37231 2483 21 of of IN 37231 2483 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2483 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2483 24 , , , 37231 2483 25 variation variation NN 37231 2483 26 from from IN 37231 2483 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2483 28 would would MD 37231 2483 29 suggest suggest VB 37231 2483 30 or or CC 37231 2483 31 prove prove VB 37231 2483 32 a a DT 37231 2483 33 different different JJ 37231 2483 34 origin origin NN 37231 2483 35 , , , 37231 2483 36 and and CC 37231 2483 37 at at IN 37231 2483 38 least least JJS 37231 2483 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2483 40 is be VBZ 37231 2483 41 obvious obvious JJ 37231 2483 42 that that IN 37231 2483 43 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 2483 44 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2483 45 which which WDT 37231 2483 46 do do VBP 37231 2483 47 not not RB 37231 2483 48 agree agree VB 37231 2483 49 with with IN 37231 2483 50 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2483 51 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2483 52 can can MD 37231 2483 53 not not RB 37231 2483 54 in in IN 37231 2483 55 any any DT 37231 2483 56 case case NN 37231 2483 57 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 2483 58 indicate indicate VBP 37231 2483 59 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2483 60 existence existence NN 37231 2483 61 . . . 37231 2484 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2484 2 shall shall MD 37231 2484 3 in in IN 37231 2484 4 the the DT 37231 2484 5 course course NN 37231 2484 6 of of IN 37231 2484 7 the the DT 37231 2484 8 following follow VBG 37231 2484 9 pages page NNS 37231 2484 10 more more RBR 37231 2484 11 fully fully RB 37231 2484 12 illustrate illustrate VBP 37231 2484 13 this this DT 37231 2484 14 , , , 37231 2484 15 but but CC 37231 2484 16 such such PDT 37231 2484 17 a a DT 37231 2484 18 statement statement NN 37231 2484 19 is be VBZ 37231 2484 20 requisite requisite JJ 37231 2484 21 at at IN 37231 2484 22 the the DT 37231 2484 23 very very JJ 37231 2484 24 outset outset NN 37231 2484 25 from from IN 37231 2484 26 the the DT 37231 2484 27 too too RB 37231 2484 28 general general JJ 37231 2484 29 practice practice NN 37231 2484 30 of of IN 37231 2484 31 referring refer VBG 37231 2484 32 every every DT 37231 2484 33 quotation quotation NN 37231 2484 34 of of IN 37231 2484 35 historical historical JJ 37231 2484 36 sayings saying NNS 37231 2484 37 of of IN 37231 2484 38 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2484 39 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 2484 40 to to IN 37231 2484 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2484 42 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2484 43 , , , 37231 2484 44 as as IN 37231 2484 45 though though IN 37231 2484 46 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2484 47 were be VBD 37231 2484 48 the the DT 37231 2484 49 only only JJ 37231 2484 50 sources source NNS 37231 2484 51 of of IN 37231 2484 52 such such JJ 37231 2484 53 matter matter NN 37231 2484 54 which which WDT 37231 2484 55 had have VBD 37231 2484 56 ever ever RB 37231 2484 57 existed exist VBN 37231 2484 58 . . . 37231 2485 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2485 2 is be VBZ 37231 2485 3 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 2485 4 to to TO 37231 2485 5 add add VB 37231 2485 6 that that DT 37231 2485 7 , , , 37231 2485 8 in in IN 37231 2485 9 proportion proportion NN 37231 2485 10 as as IN 37231 2485 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2485 12 remove remove VBP 37231 2485 13 from from IN 37231 2485 14 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 2485 15 times time NNS 37231 2485 16 without without IN 37231 2485 17 positive positive JJ 37231 2485 18 evidence evidence NN 37231 2485 19 of of IN 37231 2485 20 the the DT 37231 2485 21 existence existence NN 37231 2485 22 and and CC 37231 2485 23 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2485 24 of of IN 37231 2485 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2485 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2485 27 , , , 37231 2485 28 so so RB 37231 2485 29 does do VBZ 37231 2485 30 the the DT 37231 2485 31 value value NN 37231 2485 32 of of IN 37231 2485 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2485 34 testimony testimony NN 37231 2485 35 dwindle dwindle VB 37231 2485 36 away away RB 37231 2485 37 . . . 37231 2486 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 2486 2 , , , 37231 2486 3 requiring require VBG 37231 2486 4 as as IN 37231 2486 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2486 6 do do VBP 37231 2486 7 clear clear JJ 37231 2486 8 , , , 37231 2486 9 direct direct JJ 37231 2486 10 , , , 37231 2486 11 and and CC 37231 2486 12 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 37231 2486 13 evidence evidence NN 37231 2486 14 of of IN 37231 2486 15 the the DT 37231 2486 16 integrity integrity NN 37231 2486 17 , , , 37231 2486 18 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2486 19 , , , 37231 2486 20 and and CC 37231 2486 21 historical historical JJ 37231 2486 22 character character NN 37231 2486 23 of of IN 37231 2486 24 these these DT 37231 2486 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2486 26 , , , 37231 2486 27 doubt doubt NN 37231 2486 28 or or CC 37231 2486 29 obscurity obscurity NN 37231 2486 30 on on IN 37231 2486 31 these these DT 37231 2486 32 points point NNS 37231 2486 33 must must MD 37231 2486 34 inevitably inevitably RB 37231 2486 35 be be VB 37231 2486 36 fatal fatal JJ 37231 2486 37 to to IN 37231 2486 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2486 39 as as IN 37231 2486 40 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 2486 41 testimony,--if testimony,--if NN 37231 2486 42 { { -LRB- 37231 2486 43 215 215 CD 37231 2486 44 } } -RRB- 37231 2486 45 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2486 46 could could MD 37231 2486 47 , , , 37231 2486 48 under under IN 37231 2486 49 any any DT 37231 2486 50 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2486 51 be be VB 37231 2486 52 considered consider VBN 37231 2486 53 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 2486 54 testimony,--for testimony,--for NNP 37231 2486 55 miracles miracle NNS 37231 2486 56 and and CC 37231 2486 57 a a DT 37231 2486 58 direct direct JJ 37231 2486 59 Divine Divine NNP 37231 2486 60 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 2486 61 like like IN 37231 2486 62 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2486 63 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2486 64 . . . 37231 2487 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2487 2 propose propose VBP 37231 2487 3 to to TO 37231 2487 4 examine examine VB 37231 2487 5 first first RB 37231 2487 6 , , , 37231 2487 7 the the DT 37231 2487 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 2487 9 for for IN 37231 2487 10 the the DT 37231 2487 11 three three CD 37231 2487 12 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2487 13 and and CC 37231 2487 14 , , , 37231 2487 15 then then RB 37231 2487 16 , , , 37231 2487 17 separately separately RB 37231 2487 18 , , , 37231 2487 19 the the DT 37231 2487 20 testimony testimony NN 37231 2487 21 regarding regard VBG 37231 2487 22 the the DT 37231 2487 23 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2487 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2487 25 . . . 37231 2488 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2488 2 216 216 CD 37231 2488 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2488 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 2488 5 I. i. NN 37231 2488 6 CLEMENT CLEMENT NNP 37231 2488 7 OF of IN 37231 2488 8 ROME ROME NNP 37231 2488 9 -- -- : 37231 2488 10 THE the DT 37231 2488 11 EPISTLE EPISTLE NNP 37231 2488 12 OF of IN 37231 2488 13 BARNABAS BARNABAS NNP 37231 2488 14 -- -- : 37231 2488 15 THE the DT 37231 2488 16 PASTOR PASTOR NNS 37231 2488 17 OF of IN 37231 2488 18 HERMAS HERMAS NNP 37231 2488 19 . . . 37231 2489 1 The the DT 37231 2489 2 first first JJ 37231 2489 3 work work NN 37231 2489 4 which which WDT 37231 2489 5 presents present VBZ 37231 2489 6 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2489 7 for for IN 37231 2489 8 examination examination NN 37231 2489 9 is be VBZ 37231 2489 10 the the DT 37231 2489 11 so so RB 37231 2489 12 - - HYPH 37231 2489 13 called call VBN 37231 2489 14 first first JJ 37231 2489 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2489 16 of of IN 37231 2489 17 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2489 18 to to IN 37231 2489 19 the the DT 37231 2489 20 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2489 21 , , , 37231 2489 22 which which WDT 37231 2489 23 , , , 37231 2489 24 together together RB 37231 2489 25 with with IN 37231 2489 26 a a DT 37231 2489 27 second second JJ 37231 2489 28 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2489 29 to to IN 37231 2489 30 the the DT 37231 2489 31 same same JJ 37231 2489 32 community community NN 37231 2489 33 , , , 37231 2489 34 likewise likewise RB 37231 2489 35 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2489 36 to to IN 37231 2489 37 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2489 38 , , , 37231 2489 39 is be VBZ 37231 2489 40 preserved preserve VBN 37231 2489 41 to to IN 37231 2489 42 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2489 43 in in IN 37231 2489 44 the the DT 37231 2489 45 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2489 46 Alexandrinus,(1 alexandrinus,(1 NN 37231 2489 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2489 48 a a DT 37231 2489 49 MS MS NNP 37231 2489 50 . . . 37231 2489 51 assigned assign VBN 37231 2489 52 by by IN 37231 2489 53 the the DT 37231 2489 54 most most RBS 37231 2489 55 competent competent JJ 37231 2489 56 judges judge NNS 37231 2489 57 to to IN 37231 2489 58 the the DT 37231 2489 59 second second JJ 37231 2489 60 half half NN 37231 2489 61 of of IN 37231 2489 62 the the DT 37231 2489 63 fifth fifth JJ 37231 2489 64 , , , 37231 2489 65 or or CC 37231 2489 66 beginning beginning NN 37231 2489 67 of of IN 37231 2489 68 the the DT 37231 2489 69 sixth sixth JJ 37231 2489 70 century century NN 37231 2489 71 , , , 37231 2489 72 in in IN 37231 2489 73 which which WDT 37231 2489 74 these these DT 37231 2489 75 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2489 76 follow follow VBP 37231 2489 77 the the DT 37231 2489 78 books book NNS 37231 2489 79 of of IN 37231 2489 80 the the DT 37231 2489 81 New New NNP 37231 2489 82 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2489 83 . . . 37231 2490 1 The the DT 37231 2490 2 second second JJ 37231 2490 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2490 4 , , , 37231 2490 5 which which WDT 37231 2490 6 is be VBZ 37231 2490 7 evidently evidently RB 37231 2490 8 not not RB 37231 2490 9 epistolary epistolary JJ 37231 2490 10 , , , 37231 2490 11 but but CC 37231 2490 12 the the DT 37231 2490 13 fragment fragment NN 37231 2490 14 of of IN 37231 2490 15 a a DT 37231 2490 16 Homily,(2 homily,(2 NN 37231 2490 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2490 18 although although IN 37231 2490 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2490 20 thus thus RB 37231 2490 21 shares share VBZ 37231 2490 22 with with IN 37231 2490 23 the the DT 37231 2490 24 first first JJ 37231 2490 25 the the DT 37231 2490 26 honour honour NN 37231 2490 27 of of IN 37231 2490 28 a a DT 37231 2490 29 canonical canonical JJ 37231 2490 30 position position NN 37231 2490 31 in in IN 37231 2490 32 one one CD 37231 2490 33 of of IN 37231 2490 34 the the DT 37231 2490 35 most most RBS 37231 2490 36 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2490 37 codices codex NNS 37231 2490 38 of of IN 37231 2490 39 the the DT 37231 2490 40 New New NNP 37231 2490 41 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2490 42 , , , 37231 2490 43 is be VBZ 37231 2490 44 not not RB 37231 2490 45 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2490 46 at at RB 37231 2490 47 all all RB 37231 2490 48 by by IN 37231 2490 49 the the DT 37231 2490 50 earlier early JJR 37231 2490 51 fathers father NNS 37231 2490 52 who who WP 37231 2490 53 refer refer VBP 37231 2490 54 to to IN 37231 2490 55 the the DT 37231 2490 56 first;(3 first;(3 NNP 37231 2490 57 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2490 58 { { -LRB- 37231 2490 59 217 217 CD 37231 2490 60 } } -RRB- 37231 2490 61 and and CC 37231 2490 62 Eusebius,(1 eusebius,(1 FW 37231 2490 63 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2490 64 who who WP 37231 2490 65 is be VBZ 37231 2490 66 the the DT 37231 2490 67 first first JJ 37231 2490 68 writer writer NN 37231 2490 69 who who WP 37231 2490 70 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2490 71 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2490 72 , , , 37231 2490 73 expresses express VBZ 37231 2490 74 doubt doubt NN 37231 2490 75 regarding regard VBG 37231 2490 76 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2490 77 , , , 37231 2490 78 while while IN 37231 2490 79 Jerome(2 Jerome(2 NNP 37231 2490 80 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2490 81 and and CC 37231 2490 82 Photius(3 photius(3 JJ 37231 2490 83 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2490 84 state state NN 37231 2490 85 that that IN 37231 2490 86 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2490 87 was be VBD 37231 2490 88 rejected reject VBN 37231 2490 89 by by IN 37231 2490 90 the the DT 37231 2490 91 ancients ancient NNS 37231 2490 92 . . . 37231 2491 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2491 2 is be VBZ 37231 2491 3 now now RB 37231 2491 4 universally universally RB 37231 2491 5 regarded regard VBN 37231 2491 6 as as IN 37231 2491 7 spurious,(4 spurious,(4 NN 37231 2491 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2491 9 and and CC 37231 2491 10 dated date VBN 37231 2491 11 about about IN 37231 2491 12 the the DT 37231 2491 13 end end NN 37231 2491 14 of of IN 37231 2491 15 the the DT 37231 2491 16 second second JJ 37231 2491 17 century,(5 century,(5 NN 37231 2491 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2491 19 or or CC 37231 2491 20 later later RB 37231 2491 21 . . . 37231 2492 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2492 2 6 6 LS 37231 2492 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2492 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2492 5 shall shall MD 37231 2492 6 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 2492 7 see see VB 37231 2492 8 that that IN 37231 2492 9 many many JJ 37231 2492 10 other other JJ 37231 2492 11 pseudographs pseudograph NNS 37231 2492 12 were be VBD 37231 2492 13 circulated circulate VBN 37231 2492 14 in in IN 37231 2492 15 the the DT 37231 2492 16 name name NN 37231 2492 17 of of IN 37231 2492 18 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2492 19 , , , 37231 2492 20 to to IN 37231 2492 21 which which WDT 37231 2492 22 , , , 37231 2492 23 however however RB 37231 2492 24 , , , 37231 2492 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2492 26 need need VBP 37231 2492 27 not not RB 37231 2492 28 further further RB 37231 2492 29 allude allude NN 37231 2492 30 at at IN 37231 2492 31 present present NN 37231 2492 32 . . . 37231 2493 1 There there EX 37231 2493 2 has have VBZ 37231 2493 3 been be VBN 37231 2493 4 much much JJ 37231 2493 5 controversy controversy NN 37231 2493 6 as as IN 37231 2493 7 to to IN 37231 2493 8 the the DT 37231 2493 9 identity identity NN 37231 2493 10 of of IN 37231 2493 11 the the DT 37231 2493 12 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2493 13 to to IN 37231 2493 14 whom whom WP 37231 2493 15 the the DT 37231 2493 16 first first JJ 37231 2493 17 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2493 18 is be VBZ 37231 2493 19 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2493 20 . . . 37231 2494 1 In in IN 37231 2494 2 early early JJ 37231 2494 3 days day NNS 37231 2494 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2494 5 was be VBD 37231 2494 6 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2494 7 to to TO 37231 2494 8 be be VB 37231 2494 9 the the DT 37231 2494 10 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2494 11 { { -LRB- 37231 2494 12 218 218 CD 37231 2494 13 } } -RRB- 37231 2494 14 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2494 15 in in IN 37231 2494 16 the the DT 37231 2494 17 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2494 18 to to IN 37231 2494 19 the the DT 37231 2494 20 Philippians Philippians NNPS 37231 2494 21 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2494 22 iv iv UH 37231 2494 23 . . . 37231 2495 1 3)(1 3)(1 LS 37231 2495 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2495 3 , , , 37231 2495 4 but but CC 37231 2495 5 this this DT 37231 2495 6 is be VBZ 37231 2495 7 now now RB 37231 2495 8 generally generally RB 37231 2495 9 doubted doubt VBN 37231 2495 10 or or CC 37231 2495 11 abandoned,(2 abandoned,(2 NNS 37231 2495 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2495 13 and and CC 37231 2495 14 the the DT 37231 2495 15 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2495 16 of of IN 37231 2495 17 the the DT 37231 2495 18 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2495 19 has have VBZ 37231 2495 20 , , , 37231 2495 21 indeed indeed RB 37231 2495 22 , , , 37231 2495 23 been be VBN 37231 2495 24 called call VBN 37231 2495 25 in in IN 37231 2495 26 question question NN 37231 2495 27 both both CC 37231 2495 28 by by IN 37231 2495 29 earlier early RBR 37231 2495 30 and and CC 37231 2495 31 later later JJ 37231 2495 32 critics critic NNS 37231 2495 33 . . . 37231 2496 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2496 2 3 3 LS 37231 2496 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2496 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2496 5 is be VBZ 37231 2496 6 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 2496 7 to to TO 37231 2496 8 detail detail VB 37231 2496 9 the the DT 37231 2496 10 various various JJ 37231 2496 11 traditions tradition NNS 37231 2496 12 regarding regard VBG 37231 2496 13 the the DT 37231 2496 14 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2496 15 writer writer NN 37231 2496 16 , , , 37231 2496 17 but but CC 37231 2496 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2496 19 must must MD 37231 2496 20 point point VB 37231 2496 21 out out RP 37231 2496 22 that that IN 37231 2496 23 the the DT 37231 2496 24 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2496 25 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2496 26 makes make VBZ 37231 2496 27 no no DT 37231 2496 28 mention mention NN 37231 2496 29 of of IN 37231 2496 30 the the DT 37231 2496 31 author author NN 37231 2496 32 's 's POS 37231 2496 33 name name NN 37231 2496 34 . . . 37231 2497 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2497 2 merely merely RB 37231 2497 3 purports purport VBZ 37231 2497 4 to to TO 37231 2497 5 be be VB 37231 2497 6 addressed address VBN 37231 2497 7 by by IN 37231 2497 8 " " `` 37231 2497 9 The the DT 37231 2497 10 Church Church NNP 37231 2497 11 of of IN 37231 2497 12 God God NNP 37231 2497 13 which which WDT 37231 2497 14 sojourns sojourn VBZ 37231 2497 15 at at IN 37231 2497 16 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2497 17 to to IN 37231 2497 18 the the DT 37231 2497 19 Church Church NNP 37231 2497 20 of of IN 37231 2497 21 God God NNP 37231 2497 22 sojourning sojourn VBG 37231 2497 23 at at IN 37231 2497 24 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 2497 25 ; ; : 37231 2497 26 " " `` 37231 2497 27 but but CC 37231 2497 28 in in IN 37231 2497 29 the the DT 37231 2497 30 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2497 31 Alexandrinus Alexandrinus NNP 37231 2497 32 , , , 37231 2497 33 the the DT 37231 2497 34 title title NN 37231 2497 35 of of IN 37231 2497 36 " " `` 37231 2497 37 The the DT 37231 2497 38 first first JJ 37231 2497 39 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2497 40 of of IN 37231 2497 41 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2497 42 to to IN 37231 2497 43 the the DT 37231 2497 44 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2497 45 , , , 37231 2497 46 " " '' 37231 2497 47 is be VBZ 37231 2497 48 added add VBN 37231 2497 49 at at IN 37231 2497 50 the the DT 37231 2497 51 end end NN 37231 2497 52 . . . 37231 2498 1 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2498 2 of of IN 37231 2498 3 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 2498 4 calls call VBZ 37231 2498 5 the the DT 37231 2498 6 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2498 7 writer writer NN 37231 2498 8 the the DT 37231 2498 9 " " `` 37231 2498 10 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2498 11 Clement:"(4 clement:"(4 ADD 37231 2498 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2498 13 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2498 14 reports report VBZ 37231 2498 15 that that IN 37231 2498 16 many many DT 37231 2498 17 also also RB 37231 2498 18 ascribed ascribe VBD 37231 2498 19 to to IN 37231 2498 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2498 21 the the DT 37231 2498 22 authorship authorship NN 37231 2498 23 of of IN 37231 2498 24 the the DT 37231 2498 25 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2498 26 to to IN 37231 2498 27 the the DT 37231 2498 28 Hebrews;(5 Hebrews;(5 NNP 37231 2498 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2498 30 and and CC 37231 2498 31 Photius Photius NNP 37231 2498 32 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2498 33 that that IN 37231 2498 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2498 35 was be VBD 37231 2498 36 likewise likewise RB 37231 2498 37 said say VBN 37231 2498 38 to to TO 37231 2498 39 be be VB 37231 2498 40 the the DT 37231 2498 41 writer writer NN 37231 2498 42 of of IN 37231 2498 43 the the DT 37231 2498 44 Acts Acts NNPS 37231 2498 45 of of IN 37231 2498 46 the the DT 37231 2498 47 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2498 48 . . . 37231 2499 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2499 2 6 6 LS 37231 2499 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2499 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2499 5 know know VBP 37231 2499 6 that that IN 37231 2499 7 until until IN 37231 2499 8 a a DT 37231 2499 9 comparatively comparatively RB 37231 2499 10 late late JJ 37231 2499 11 date date NN 37231 2499 12 this this DT 37231 2499 13 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2499 14 was be VBD 37231 2499 15 quoted quote VBN 37231 2499 16 as as IN 37231 2499 17 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2499 18 Scripture,(7 Scripture,(7 NNS 37231 2499 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2499 20 and and CC 37231 2499 21 was be VBD 37231 2499 22 publicly publicly RB 37231 2499 23 read read VBN 37231 2499 24 in in IN 37231 2499 25 the the DT 37231 2499 26 churches church NNS 37231 2499 27 at at IN 37231 2499 28 the the DT 37231 2499 29 Sunday Sunday NNP 37231 2499 30 meetings meeting NNS 37231 2499 31 of of IN 37231 2499 32 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2499 33 . . . 37231 2500 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2500 2 8) 8) CD 37231 2500 3 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2500 4 has have VBZ 37231 2500 5 , , , 37231 2500 6 as as IN 37231 2500 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2500 8 have have VBP 37231 2500 9 seen see VBN 37231 2500 10 , , , 37231 2500 11 a a DT 37231 2500 12 place place NN 37231 2500 13 amongst amongst IN 37231 2500 14 { { -LRB- 37231 2500 15 219 219 CD 37231 2500 16 } } -RRB- 37231 2500 17 the the DT 37231 2500 18 canonical canonical JJ 37231 2500 19 books book NNS 37231 2500 20 of of IN 37231 2500 21 the the DT 37231 2500 22 New New NNP 37231 2500 23 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2500 24 in in IN 37231 2500 25 the the DT 37231 2500 26 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2500 27 Alexandrinus Alexandrinus NNP 37231 2500 28 , , , 37231 2500 29 but but CC 37231 2500 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2500 31 did do VBD 37231 2500 32 not not RB 37231 2500 33 long long RB 37231 2500 34 retain retain VB 37231 2500 35 that that DT 37231 2500 36 position position NN 37231 2500 37 in in IN 37231 2500 38 the the DT 37231 2500 39 canon canon NN 37231 2500 40 , , , 37231 2500 41 for for IN 37231 2500 42 although although IN 37231 2500 43 in in IN 37231 2500 44 the the DT 37231 2500 45 " " `` 37231 2500 46 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 2500 47 Canons"(1 Canons"(1 NNP 37231 2500 48 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2500 49 of of IN 37231 2500 50 the the DT 37231 2500 51 sixth sixth JJ 37231 2500 52 or or CC 37231 2500 53 seventh seventh JJ 37231 2500 54 century century NN 37231 2500 55 both both DT 37231 2500 56 Epistles epistle NNS 37231 2500 57 appear appear VBP 37231 2500 58 , , , 37231 2500 59 yet yet CC 37231 2500 60 in in IN 37231 2500 61 the the DT 37231 2500 62 Stichometry Stichometry NNP 37231 2500 63 of of IN 37231 2500 64 Nicephorus Nicephorus NNP 37231 2500 65 , , , 37231 2500 66 a a DT 37231 2500 67 work work NN 37231 2500 68 of of IN 37231 2500 69 the the DT 37231 2500 70 ninth ninth JJ 37231 2500 71 century century NN 37231 2500 72 , , , 37231 2500 73 derived derive VBN 37231 2500 74 , , , 37231 2500 75 however however RB 37231 2500 76 , , , 37231 2500 77 as as IN 37231 2500 78 Credner(2 Credner(2 NNP 37231 2500 79 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2500 80 has have VBZ 37231 2500 81 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 2500 82 , , , 37231 2500 83 from from IN 37231 2500 84 a a DT 37231 2500 85 Syrian syrian JJ 37231 2500 86 catalogue catalogue NN 37231 2500 87 of of IN 37231 2500 88 the the DT 37231 2500 89 fifth fifth JJ 37231 2500 90 century century NN 37231 2500 91 , , , 37231 2500 92 both both DT 37231 2500 93 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2500 94 are be VBP 37231 2500 95 classed class VBN 37231 2500 96 among among IN 37231 2500 97 the the DT 37231 2500 98 Apocrypha apocrypha NN 37231 2500 99 . . . 37231 2501 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2501 2 3 3 LS 37231 2501 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2501 4 Great great JJ 37231 2501 5 uncertainty uncertainty NN 37231 2501 6 prevails prevail VBZ 37231 2501 7 as as IN 37231 2501 8 to to IN 37231 2501 9 the the DT 37231 2501 10 date date NN 37231 2501 11 at at IN 37231 2501 12 which which WDT 37231 2501 13 the the DT 37231 2501 14 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2501 15 was be VBD 37231 2501 16 written write VBN 37231 2501 17 . . . 37231 2502 1 Reference reference NN 37231 2502 2 is be VBZ 37231 2502 3 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2502 4 to to TO 37231 2502 5 be be VB 37231 2502 6 made make VBN 37231 2502 7 to to IN 37231 2502 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2502 9 by by IN 37231 2502 10 the the DT 37231 2502 11 so so RB 37231 2502 12 - - HYPH 37231 2502 13 called call VBN 37231 2502 14 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2502 15 of of IN 37231 2502 16 Polycarp,(4 Polycarp,(4 NNP 37231 2502 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2502 18 but but CC 37231 2502 19 , , , 37231 2502 20 owing owe VBG 37231 2502 21 to to IN 37231 2502 22 the the DT 37231 2502 23 probable probable JJ 37231 2502 24 inauthenticity inauthenticity NN 37231 2502 25 of of IN 37231 2502 26 that that DT 37231 2502 27 work work NN 37231 2502 28 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2502 29 , , , 37231 2502 30 no no DT 37231 2502 31 weight weight NN 37231 2502 32 can can MD 37231 2502 33 be be VB 37231 2502 34 attached attach VBN 37231 2502 35 to to IN 37231 2502 36 this this DT 37231 2502 37 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 2502 38 . . . 37231 2503 1 The the DT 37231 2503 2 first first JJ 37231 2503 3 certain certain JJ 37231 2503 4 reference reference NN 37231 2503 5 to to IN 37231 2503 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2503 7 is be VBZ 37231 2503 8 by by IN 37231 2503 9 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 2503 10 , , , 37231 2503 11 in in IN 37231 2503 12 the the DT 37231 2503 13 second second JJ 37231 2503 14 half half NN 37231 2503 15 of of IN 37231 2503 16 the the DT 37231 2503 17 second second JJ 37231 2503 18 century century NN 37231 2503 19 , , , 37231 2503 20 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2503 21 by by IN 37231 2503 22 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2503 23 . . . 37231 2504 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2504 2 5 5 LS 37231 2504 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2504 4 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 2504 5 of of IN 37231 2504 6 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 2504 7 , , , 37231 2504 8 in in IN 37231 2504 9 a a DT 37231 2504 10 letter letter NN 37231 2504 11 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2504 12 to to IN 37231 2504 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2504 14 addressed address VBD 37231 2504 15 to to IN 37231 2504 16 Soter Soter NNP 37231 2504 17 , , , 37231 2504 18 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2504 19 of of IN 37231 2504 20 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2504 21 , , , 37231 2504 22 is be VBZ 37231 2504 23 the the DT 37231 2504 24 first first JJ 37231 2504 25 who who WP 37231 2504 26 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 2504 27 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2504 28 the the DT 37231 2504 29 name name NN 37231 2504 30 of of IN 37231 2504 31 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2504 32 as as IN 37231 2504 33 the the DT 37231 2504 34 author author NN 37231 2504 35 of of IN 37231 2504 36 the the DT 37231 2504 37 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2504 38 . . . 37231 2505 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2505 2 6 6 LS 37231 2505 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2505 4 There there EX 37231 2505 5 is be VBZ 37231 2505 6 some some DT 37231 2505 7 difference difference NN 37231 2505 8 of of IN 37231 2505 9 opinion opinion NN 37231 2505 10 as as IN 37231 2505 11 to to IN 37231 2505 12 the the DT 37231 2505 13 order order NN 37231 2505 14 of of IN 37231 2505 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2505 16 succession succession NN 37231 2505 17 to to IN 37231 2505 18 the the DT 37231 2505 19 Bishopric Bishopric NNP 37231 2505 20 of of IN 37231 2505 21 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2505 22 . . . 37231 2506 1 Irenæus(7 Irenæus(7 NNP 37231 2506 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2506 3 and and CC 37231 2506 4 Eusebius(8 eusebius(8 NN 37231 2506 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2506 6 say say VBP 37231 2506 7 that that IN 37231 2506 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2506 9 followed follow VBD 37231 2506 10 Anacletus Anacletus NNP 37231 2506 11 , , , 37231 2506 12 and and CC 37231 2506 13 the the DT 37231 2506 14 latter latter JJ 37231 2506 15 adds add VBZ 37231 2506 16 the the DT 37231 2506 17 date date NN 37231 2506 18 of of IN 37231 2506 19 the the DT 37231 2506 20 twelfth twelfth JJ 37231 2506 21 year year NN 37231 2506 22 of of IN 37231 2506 23 the the DT 37231 2506 24 reign reign NN 37231 2506 25 of of IN 37231 2506 26 Domitian Domitian NNP 37231 2506 27 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2506 28 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2506 29 . . NNP 37231 2506 30 91 91 CD 37231 2506 31 - - SYM 37231 2506 32 92 92 CD 37231 2506 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2506 34 , , , 37231 2506 35 and and CC 37231 2506 36 that that IN 37231 2506 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2506 38 died die VBD 37231 2506 39 nine nine CD 37231 2506 40 years year NNS 37231 2506 41 after after RB 37231 2506 42 , , , 37231 2506 43 in in IN 37231 2506 44 the the DT 37231 2506 45 third third JJ 37231 2506 46 year year NN 37231 2506 47 of of IN 37231 2506 48 Trajan Trajan NNP 37231 2506 49 's 's POS 37231 2506 50 reign reign NN 37231 2506 51 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2506 52 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2506 53 . . . 37231 2507 1 100 100 CD 37231 2507 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2507 3 . . . 37231 2508 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2508 2 9 9 LS 37231 2508 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2508 4 Internal Internal NNP 37231 2508 5 evidence(10 evidence(10 NNP 37231 2508 6 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2508 7 shows show VBZ 37231 2508 8 that that IN 37231 2508 9 the the DT 37231 2508 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2508 11 was be VBD 37231 2508 12 written write VBN 37231 2508 13 after after IN 37231 2508 14 some some DT 37231 2508 15 persecution persecution NN 37231 2508 16 { { -LRB- 37231 2508 17 220 220 CD 37231 2508 18 } } -RRB- 37231 2508 19 of of IN 37231 2508 20 the the DT 37231 2508 21 Roman Roman NNP 37231 2508 22 Church Church NNP 37231 2508 23 , , , 37231 2508 24 and and CC 37231 2508 25 the the DT 37231 2508 26 selection selection NN 37231 2508 27 lies lie VBZ 37231 2508 28 between between IN 37231 2508 29 the the DT 37231 2508 30 persecution persecution NN 37231 2508 31 under under IN 37231 2508 32 Nero Nero NNP 37231 2508 33 , , , 37231 2508 34 which which WDT 37231 2508 35 would would MD 37231 2508 36 suggest suggest VB 37231 2508 37 the the DT 37231 2508 38 date date NN 37231 2508 39 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2508 40 . . NNP 37231 2508 41 64 64 CD 37231 2508 42 - - SYM 37231 2508 43 70 70 CD 37231 2508 44 , , , 37231 2508 45 or or CC 37231 2508 46 that that IN 37231 2508 47 under under IN 37231 2508 48 Domitian Domitian NNP 37231 2508 49 , , , 37231 2508 50 which which WDT 37231 2508 51 would would MD 37231 2508 52 assign assign VB 37231 2508 53 the the DT 37231 2508 54 letter letter NN 37231 2508 55 to to IN 37231 2508 56 the the DT 37231 2508 57 end end NN 37231 2508 58 of of IN 37231 2508 59 the the DT 37231 2508 60 first first JJ 37231 2508 61 century century NN 37231 2508 62 , , , 37231 2508 63 or or CC 37231 2508 64 to to IN 37231 2508 65 the the DT 37231 2508 66 beginning beginning NN 37231 2508 67 of of IN 37231 2508 68 the the DT 37231 2508 69 second second JJ 37231 2508 70 . . . 37231 2509 1 Those those DT 37231 2509 2 who who WP 37231 2509 3 adhere adhere VBP 37231 2509 4 to to IN 37231 2509 5 the the DT 37231 2509 6 view view NN 37231 2509 7 that that IN 37231 2509 8 the the DT 37231 2509 9 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2509 10 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2509 11 in in IN 37231 2509 12 the the DT 37231 2509 13 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2509 14 to to IN 37231 2509 15 the the DT 37231 2509 16 Philippians Philippians NNPS 37231 2509 17 is be VBZ 37231 2509 18 the the DT 37231 2509 19 author author NN 37231 2509 20 , , , 37231 2509 21 maintain maintain VB 37231 2509 22 that that IN 37231 2509 23 the the DT 37231 2509 24 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2509 25 was be VBD 37231 2509 26 written write VBN 37231 2509 27 under under IN 37231 2509 28 Nero Nero NNP 37231 2509 29 . . . 37231 2510 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2510 2 1 1 LS 37231 2510 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2510 4 One one CD 37231 2510 5 of of IN 37231 2510 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2510 7 principal principal JJ 37231 2510 8 arguments argument NNS 37231 2510 9 for for IN 37231 2510 10 this this DT 37231 2510 11 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2510 12 is be VBZ 37231 2510 13 a a DT 37231 2510 14 remark remark NN 37231 2510 15 occurring occur VBG 37231 2510 16 in in IN 37231 2510 17 Chapter Chapter NNP 37231 2510 18 xli xli NNP 37231 2510 19 . . . 37231 2511 1 : : : 37231 2511 2 " " `` 37231 2511 3 Not not RB 37231 2511 4 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 2511 5 , , , 37231 2511 6 brethren brother NNS 37231 2511 7 , , , 37231 2511 8 are be VBP 37231 2511 9 the the DT 37231 2511 10 daily daily JJ 37231 2511 11 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 37231 2511 12 offered offer VBD 37231 2511 13 up up RP 37231 2511 14 , , , 37231 2511 15 or or CC 37231 2511 16 the the DT 37231 2511 17 votive votive JJ 37231 2511 18 offerings offering NNS 37231 2511 19 , , , 37231 2511 20 or or CC 37231 2511 21 the the DT 37231 2511 22 sin sin NN 37231 2511 23 - - HYPH 37231 2511 24 offerings offering NNS 37231 2511 25 and and CC 37231 2511 26 the the DT 37231 2511 27 trespass trespass NN 37231 2511 28 - - HYPH 37231 2511 29 offerings offering NNS 37231 2511 30 , , , 37231 2511 31 but but CC 37231 2511 32 only only RB 37231 2511 33 in in IN 37231 2511 34 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 2511 35 . . . 37231 2512 1 But but CC 37231 2512 2 even even RB 37231 2512 3 there there RB 37231 2512 4 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2512 5 are be VBP 37231 2512 6 not not RB 37231 2512 7 offered offer VBN 37231 2512 8 in in IN 37231 2512 9 every every DT 37231 2512 10 place place NN 37231 2512 11 , , , 37231 2512 12 but but CC 37231 2512 13 only only RB 37231 2512 14 at at IN 37231 2512 15 the the DT 37231 2512 16 altar altar NN 37231 2512 17 before before IN 37231 2512 18 the the DT 37231 2512 19 Sanctuary Sanctuary NNP 37231 2512 20 , , , 37231 2512 21 examination examination NN 37231 2512 22 of of IN 37231 2512 23 the the DT 37231 2512 24 sacrifice sacrifice NN 37231 2512 25 offered offer VBN 37231 2512 26 being be VBG 37231 2512 27 first first RB 37231 2512 28 made make VBN 37231 2512 29 by by IN 37231 2512 30 the the DT 37231 2512 31 High High NNP 37231 2512 32 Priest Priest NNP 37231 2512 33 and and CC 37231 2512 34 the the DT 37231 2512 35 ministers minister NNS 37231 2512 36 already already RB 37231 2512 37 mentioned mention VBD 37231 2512 38 . . . 37231 2513 1 " " `` 37231 2513 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2513 3 2 2 LS 37231 2513 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2513 5 From from IN 37231 2513 6 this this DT 37231 2513 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2513 8 is be VBZ 37231 2513 9 concluded conclude VBN 37231 2513 10 that that IN 37231 2513 11 the the DT 37231 2513 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2513 13 was be VBD 37231 2513 14 written write VBN 37231 2513 15 before before IN 37231 2513 16 the the DT 37231 2513 17 destruction destruction NN 37231 2513 18 of of IN 37231 2513 19 the the DT 37231 2513 20 Temple Temple NNP 37231 2513 21 . . . 37231 2514 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2514 2 has have VBZ 37231 2514 3 , , , 37231 2514 4 however however RB 37231 2514 5 , , , 37231 2514 6 been be VBN 37231 2514 7 shown show VBN 37231 2514 8 that that DT 37231 2514 9 Josephus,(3 josephus,(3 NN 37231 2514 10 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2514 11 the the DT 37231 2514 12 author author NN 37231 2514 13 of of IN 37231 2514 14 the the DT 37231 2514 15 " " `` 37231 2514 16 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2514 17 to to IN 37231 2514 18 Diognetus Diognetus NNP 37231 2514 19 " " '' 37231 2514 20 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2514 21 c. c. NNP 37231 2514 22 3 3 CD 37231 2514 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2514 24 , , , 37231 2514 25 and and CC 37231 2514 26 others other NNS 37231 2514 27 , , , 37231 2514 28 long long RB 37231 2514 29 after after IN 37231 2514 30 the the DT 37231 2514 31 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 2514 32 worship worship NN 37231 2514 33 of of IN 37231 2514 34 the the DT 37231 2514 35 Temple Temple NNP 37231 2514 36 was be VBD 37231 2514 37 at at IN 37231 2514 38 an an DT 37231 2514 39 end end NN 37231 2514 40 , , , 37231 2514 41 continually continually RB 37231 2514 42 speak speak VBP 37231 2514 43 in in IN 37231 2514 44 the the DT 37231 2514 45 present present JJ 37231 2514 46 tense tense NN 37231 2514 47 of of IN 37231 2514 48 the the DT 37231 2514 49 Temple Temple NNP 37231 2514 50 worship worship NN 37231 2514 51 in in IN 37231 2514 52 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 2514 53 ; ; : 37231 2514 54 and and CC 37231 2514 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2514 56 is be VBZ 37231 2514 57 evident evident JJ 37231 2514 58 , , , 37231 2514 59 as as IN 37231 2514 60 Cotelier Cotelier NNP 37231 2514 61 long long RB 37231 2514 62 ago ago RB 37231 2514 63 remarked remark VBD 37231 2514 64 , , , 37231 2514 65 that that IN 37231 2514 66 this this DT 37231 2514 67 may may MD 37231 2514 68 be be VB 37231 2514 69 done do VBN 37231 2514 70 with with IN 37231 2514 71 propriety propriety NN 37231 2514 72 even even RB 37231 2514 73 in in IN 37231 2514 74 the the DT 37231 2514 75 present present JJ 37231 2514 76 { { -LRB- 37231 2514 77 221 221 CD 37231 2514 78 } } -RRB- 37231 2514 79 day day NN 37231 2514 80 . . . 37231 2515 1 The the DT 37231 2515 2 argument argument NN 37231 2515 3 is be VBZ 37231 2515 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 2515 5 recognized recognize VBN 37231 2515 6 to to TO 37231 2515 7 be be VB 37231 2515 8 without without IN 37231 2515 9 value value NN 37231 2515 10 . . . 37231 2516 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2516 2 l l NN 37231 2516 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2516 4 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2516 5 , , , 37231 2516 6 who who WP 37231 2516 7 systematically systematically RB 37231 2516 8 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 2516 9 the the DT 37231 2516 10 earliest early JJS 37231 2516 11 possible possible JJ 37231 2516 12 or or CC 37231 2516 13 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2516 14 dates date NNS 37231 2516 15 for for IN 37231 2516 16 all all PDT 37231 2516 17 the the DT 37231 2516 18 writings writing NNS 37231 2516 19 of of IN 37231 2516 20 the the DT 37231 2516 21 first first JJ 37231 2516 22 two two CD 37231 2516 23 centuries century NNS 37231 2516 24 , , , 37231 2516 25 decides decide VBZ 37231 2516 26 , , , 37231 2516 27 without without IN 37231 2516 28 stating state VBG 37231 2516 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2516 30 reasons reason NNS 37231 2516 31 , , , 37231 2516 32 that that IN 37231 2516 33 the the DT 37231 2516 34 grounds ground NNS 37231 2516 35 for for IN 37231 2516 36 the the DT 37231 2516 37 earlier early JJR 37231 2516 38 date date NN 37231 2516 39 , , , 37231 2516 40 about about IN 37231 2516 41 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2516 42 . . NNP 37231 2516 43 69 69 CD 37231 2516 44 , , , 37231 2516 45 as as RB 37231 2516 46 well well RB 37231 2516 47 as as IN 37231 2516 48 for for IN 37231 2516 49 the the DT 37231 2516 50 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 2516 51 of of IN 37231 2516 52 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2516 53 from from IN 37231 2516 54 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2516 55 . . NNP 37231 2516 56 68 68 CD 37231 2516 57 - - SYM 37231 2516 58 77(2 77(2 CD 37231 2516 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2516 60 are be VBP 37231 2516 61 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 2516 62 ; ; : 37231 2516 63 but but CC 37231 2516 64 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2516 65 betrays betray VBZ 37231 2516 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2516 67 more more RBR 37231 2516 68 correct correct JJ 37231 2516 69 impression impression NN 37231 2516 70 by by IN 37231 2516 71 classing class VBG 37231 2516 72 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2516 73 , , , 37231 2516 74 in in IN 37231 2516 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2516 76 index index NN 37231 2516 77 , , , 37231 2516 78 along along IN 37231 2516 79 with with IN 37231 2516 80 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2516 81 and and CC 37231 2516 82 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2516 83 , , , 37231 2516 84 as as IN 37231 2516 85 representatives representative NNS 37231 2516 86 of of IN 37231 2516 87 the the DT 37231 2516 88 period period NN 37231 2516 89 : : : 37231 2516 90 " " `` 37231 2516 91 First first JJ 37231 2516 92 and and CC 37231 2516 93 second second JJ 37231 2516 94 quarters quarter NNS 37231 2516 95 of of IN 37231 2516 96 the the DT 37231 2516 97 second second JJ 37231 2516 98 century:"(3 century:"(3 FW 37231 2516 99 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2516 100 and and CC 37231 2516 101 in in IN 37231 2516 102 the the DT 37231 2516 103 Prolegomena Prolegomena NNP 37231 2516 104 to to IN 37231 2516 105 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2516 106 New New NNP 37231 2516 107 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2516 108 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2516 109 dates date VBZ 37231 2516 110 the the DT 37231 2516 111 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 2516 112 of of IN 37231 2516 113 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2516 114 " " '' 37231 2516 115 ab ab NNP 37231 2516 116 anno anno NNP 37231 2516 117 92 92 CD 37231 2516 118 usque usque NNP 37231 2516 119 102 102 CD 37231 2516 120 . . . 37231 2517 1 " " `` 37231 2517 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2517 3 4 4 LS 37231 2517 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2517 5 The the DT 37231 2517 6 earlier early JJR 37231 2517 7 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 2517 8 assigned assign VBN 37231 2517 9 to to IN 37231 2517 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2517 11 by by IN 37231 2517 12 Hefele Hefele NNP 37231 2517 13 upon upon IN 37231 2517 14 most most JJS 37231 2517 15 insufficient insufficient JJ 37231 2517 16 grounds ground NNS 37231 2517 17 is be VBZ 37231 2517 18 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 2517 19 by by IN 37231 2517 20 the the DT 37231 2517 21 direct direct JJ 37231 2517 22 statements statement NNS 37231 2517 23 of of IN 37231 2517 24 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2517 25 , , , 37231 2517 26 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2517 27 , , , 37231 2517 28 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2517 29 , , , 37231 2517 30 and and CC 37231 2517 31 others other NNS 37231 2517 32 who who WP 37231 2517 33 give give VBP 37231 2517 34 the the DT 37231 2517 35 earliest early JJS 37231 2517 36 lists list NNS 37231 2517 37 of of IN 37231 2517 38 Roman roman JJ 37231 2517 39 Bishops,(5 bishops,(5 NN 37231 2517 40 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2517 41 as as RB 37231 2517 42 wrell wrell RB 37231 2517 43 as as IN 37231 2517 44 by by IN 37231 2517 45 the the DT 37231 2517 46 internal internal JJ 37231 2517 47 evidence evidence NN 37231 2517 48 of of IN 37231 2517 49 the the DT 37231 2517 50 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2517 51 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2517 52 . . . 37231 2518 1 In in IN 37231 2518 2 Chapter Chapter NNP 37231 2518 3 xliv xliv NNP 37231 2518 4 . . . 37231 2519 1 the the DT 37231 2519 2 writer writer NN 37231 2519 3 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2519 4 of of IN 37231 2519 5 those those DT 37231 2519 6 appointed appoint VBN 37231 2519 7 by by IN 37231 2519 8 the the DT 37231 2519 9 apostles apostle NNS 37231 2519 10 to to IN 37231 2519 11 the the DT 37231 2519 12 oversight oversight NN 37231 2519 13 of of IN 37231 2519 14 the the DT 37231 2519 15 Church Church NNP 37231 2519 16 , , , 37231 2519 17 " " '' 37231 2519 18 or or CC 37231 2519 19 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 2519 20 by by IN 37231 2519 21 other other JJ 37231 2519 22 notable notable JJ 37231 2519 23 men man NNS 37231 2519 24 , , , 37231 2519 25 the the DT 37231 2519 26 whole whole JJ 37231 2519 27 Church Church NNP 37231 2519 28 consenting consent VBG 37231 2519 29 .... .... NFP 37231 2519 30 who who WP 37231 2519 31 have have VBP 37231 2519 32 for for IN 37231 2519 33 a a DT 37231 2519 34 long long JJ 37231 2519 35 time time NN 37231 2519 36 been be VBN 37231 2519 37 commended commend VBN 37231 2519 38 by by IN 37231 2519 39 all all DT 37231 2519 40 , , , 37231 2519 41 & & CC 37231 2519 42 c c NNP 37231 2519 43 . . . 37231 2519 44 ,"(6 ,"(6 , 37231 2519 45 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2519 46 which which WDT 37231 2519 47 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 2519 48 successions succession NNS 37231 2519 49 of of IN 37231 2519 50 Bishops Bishops NNPS 37231 2519 51 since since IN 37231 2519 52 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 2519 53 days day NNS 37231 2519 54 . . . 37231 2520 1 In in IN 37231 2520 2 another another DT 37231 2520 3 { { -LRB- 37231 2520 4 222 222 CD 37231 2520 5 } } -RRB- 37231 2520 6 place place NN 37231 2520 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2520 8 Chap Chap NNP 37231 2520 9 , , , 37231 2520 10 xlvii xlvii NN 37231 2520 11 . . . 37231 2520 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2521 1 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2521 2 refers refer VBZ 37231 2521 3 the the DT 37231 2521 4 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2521 5 to to IN 37231 2521 6 the the DT 37231 2521 7 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2521 8 addressed address VBD 37231 2521 9 to to IN 37231 2521 10 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2521 11 by by IN 37231 2521 12 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2521 13 " " '' 37231 2521 14 in in IN 37231 2521 15 the the DT 37231 2521 16 beginning beginning NN 37231 2521 17 of of IN 37231 2521 18 the the DT 37231 2521 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2521 20 " " '' 37231 2521 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2521 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2521 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2521 24 , , , 37231 2521 25 and and CC 37231 2521 26 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2521 27 of of IN 37231 2521 28 " " `` 37231 2521 29 the the DT 37231 2521 30 most most RBS 37231 2521 31 stedfast stedfast JJ 37231 2521 32 and and CC 37231 2521 33 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2521 34 Church Church NNP 37231 2521 35 of of IN 37231 2521 36 the the DT 37231 2521 37 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2521 38 " " '' 37231 2521 39 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2521 40 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2521 41 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2521 42 , , , 37231 2521 43 which which WDT 37231 2521 44 would would MD 37231 2521 45 be be VB 37231 2521 46 absurd absurd JJ 37231 2521 47 in in IN 37231 2521 48 an an DT 37231 2521 49 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2521 50 written write VBN 37231 2521 51 about about IN 37231 2521 52 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2521 53 . . NNP 37231 2521 54 69 69 CD 37231 2521 55 . . . 37231 2522 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 2522 2 , , , 37231 2522 3 an an DT 37231 2522 4 advanced advanced JJ 37231 2522 5 episcopal episcopal JJ 37231 2522 6 form form NN 37231 2522 7 of of IN 37231 2522 8 Church Church NNP 37231 2522 9 Government Government NNP 37231 2522 10 is be VBZ 37231 2522 11 indicated indicate VBN 37231 2522 12 throughout throughout IN 37231 2522 13 the the DT 37231 2522 14 letter letter NN 37231 2522 15 , , , 37231 2522 16 which which WDT 37231 2522 17 is be VBZ 37231 2522 18 quite quite RB 37231 2522 19 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37231 2522 20 with with IN 37231 2522 21 such such PDT 37231 2522 22 a a DT 37231 2522 23 date date NN 37231 2522 24 . . . 37231 2523 1 The the DT 37231 2523 2 great great JJ 37231 2523 3 mass mass NN 37231 2523 4 of of IN 37231 2523 5 critics critic NNS 37231 2523 6 , , , 37231 2523 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 2523 8 , , , 37231 2523 9 have have VBP 37231 2523 10 decided decide VBN 37231 2523 11 against against IN 37231 2523 12 the the DT 37231 2523 13 earlier early JJR 37231 2523 14 date date NN 37231 2523 15 of of IN 37231 2523 16 the the DT 37231 2523 17 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 2523 18 of of IN 37231 2523 19 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2523 20 , , , 37231 2523 21 and and CC 37231 2523 22 assign assign VB 37231 2523 23 the the DT 37231 2523 24 composition composition NN 37231 2523 25 of of IN 37231 2523 26 the the DT 37231 2523 27 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2523 28 to to IN 37231 2523 29 the the DT 37231 2523 30 end end NN 37231 2523 31 of of IN 37231 2523 32 the the DT 37231 2523 33 first first JJ 37231 2523 34 century century NN 37231 2523 35 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2523 36 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2523 37 . . . 37231 2524 1 95 95 CD 37231 2524 2 - - SYM 37231 2524 3 100 100 CD 37231 2524 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2524 5 . . . 37231 2525 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2525 2 1 1 LS 37231 2525 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2525 4 Others other NNS 37231 2525 5 , , , 37231 2525 6 however however RB 37231 2525 7 , , , 37231 2525 8 date date NN 37231 2525 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2525 10 still still RB 37231 2525 11 later later RB 37231 2525 12 . . . 37231 2526 1 There there EX 37231 2526 2 is be VBZ 37231 2526 3 no no DT 37231 2526 4 doubt doubt NN 37231 2526 5 that that IN 37231 2526 6 the the DT 37231 2526 7 great great JJ 37231 2526 8 number number NN 37231 2526 9 of of IN 37231 2526 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2526 11 and and CC 37231 2526 12 { { -LRB- 37231 2526 13 223 223 CD 37231 2526 14 } } -RRB- 37231 2526 15 other other JJ 37231 2526 16 writings writing NNS 37231 2526 17 falsely falsely RB 37231 2526 18 circulated circulate VBN 37231 2526 19 in in IN 37231 2526 20 the the DT 37231 2526 21 name name NN 37231 2526 22 of of IN 37231 2526 23 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2526 24 may may MD 37231 2526 25 well well RB 37231 2526 26 excite excite VB 37231 2526 27 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 2526 28 as as IN 37231 2526 29 to to IN 37231 2526 30 the the DT 37231 2526 31 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2526 32 of of IN 37231 2526 33 this this DT 37231 2526 34 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2526 35 also also RB 37231 2526 36 , , , 37231 2526 37 which which WDT 37231 2526 38 is be VBZ 37231 2526 39 far far RB 37231 2526 40 from from IN 37231 2526 41 unsupported unsupported JJ 37231 2526 42 by by IN 37231 2526 43 internal internal JJ 37231 2526 44 proofs proof NNS 37231 2526 45 . . . 37231 2527 1 Of of IN 37231 2527 2 these these DT 37231 2527 3 , , , 37231 2527 4 however however RB 37231 2527 5 , , , 37231 2527 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2527 7 shall shall MD 37231 2527 8 only only RB 37231 2527 9 mention mention VB 37231 2527 10 one one CD 37231 2527 11 . . . 37231 2528 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2528 2 have have VBP 37231 2528 3 already already RB 37231 2528 4 incidentally incidentally RB 37231 2528 5 remarked remark VBN 37231 2528 6 that that IN 37231 2528 7 the the DT 37231 2528 8 writer writer NN 37231 2528 9 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2528 10 the the DT 37231 2528 11 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2528 12 of of IN 37231 2528 13 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2528 14 to to IN 37231 2528 15 the the DT 37231 2528 16 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2528 17 , , , 37231 2528 18 the the DT 37231 2528 19 only only JJ 37231 2528 20 instance instance NN 37231 2528 21 in in IN 37231 2528 22 which which WDT 37231 2528 23 any any DT 37231 2528 24 New New NNP 37231 2528 25 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2528 26 writing writing NN 37231 2528 27 is be VBZ 37231 2528 28 referred refer VBN 37231 2528 29 to to IN 37231 2528 30 by by IN 37231 2528 31 name name NN 37231 2528 32 ; ; : 37231 2528 33 but but CC 37231 2528 34 along along IN 37231 2528 35 with with IN 37231 2528 36 the the DT 37231 2528 37 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2528 38 of of IN 37231 2528 39 the the DT 37231 2528 40 " " `` 37231 2528 41 blessed blessed JJ 37231 2528 42 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2528 43 " " '' 37231 2528 44 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2528 45 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2528 46 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2528 47 the the DT 37231 2528 48 author author NN 37231 2528 49 also also RB 37231 2528 50 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2528 51 of of IN 37231 2528 52 the the DT 37231 2528 53 " " `` 37231 2528 54 blessed blessed JJ 37231 2528 55 Judith Judith NNP 37231 2528 56 " " '' 37231 2528 57 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2528 58 --Greek--],(1 --Greek--],(1 NFP 37231 2528 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2528 60 and and CC 37231 2528 61 this this DT 37231 2528 62 leads lead VBZ 37231 2528 63 to to IN 37231 2528 64 the the DT 37231 2528 65 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2528 66 : : : 37231 2528 67 When when WRB 37231 2528 68 was be VBD 37231 2528 69 the the DT 37231 2528 70 Book Book NNP 37231 2528 71 of of IN 37231 2528 72 Judith Judith NNP 37231 2528 73 written write VBN 37231 2528 74 ? ? . 37231 2529 1 Hitzig Hitzig NNP 37231 2529 2 , , , 37231 2529 3 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 37231 2529 4 , , , 37231 2529 5 and and CC 37231 2529 6 others other NNS 37231 2529 7 contend contend VBP 37231 2529 8 that that IN 37231 2529 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2529 10 must must MD 37231 2529 11 be be VB 37231 2529 12 dated date VBN 37231 2529 13 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2529 14 . . NNP 37231 2529 15 117 117 CD 37231 2529 16 - - SYM 37231 2529 17 118,(3 118,(3 CD 37231 2529 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2529 19 and and CC 37231 2529 20 if if IN 37231 2529 21 this this DT 37231 2529 22 be be VB 37231 2529 23 admitted admit VBN 37231 2529 24 , , , 37231 2529 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2529 26 follows follow VBZ 37231 2529 27 of of IN 37231 2529 28 course course NN 37231 2529 29 that that IN 37231 2529 30 an an DT 37231 2529 31 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2529 32 which which WDT 37231 2529 33 already already RB 37231 2529 34 shows show VBZ 37231 2529 35 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 2529 36 with with IN 37231 2529 37 the the DT 37231 2529 38 Book Book NNP 37231 2529 39 of of IN 37231 2529 40 Judith Judith NNP 37231 2529 41 can can MD 37231 2529 42 not not RB 37231 2529 43 have have VB 37231 2529 44 been be VBN 37231 2529 45 written write VBN 37231 2529 46 before before IN 37231 2529 47 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2529 48 . . NNP 37231 2529 49 120 120 CD 37231 2529 50 - - SYM 37231 2529 51 125 125 CD 37231 2529 52 at at IN 37231 2529 53 the the DT 37231 2529 54 earliest early JJS 37231 2529 55 , , , 37231 2529 56 which which WDT 37231 2529 57 many many JJ 37231 2529 58 , , , 37231 2529 59 for for IN 37231 2529 60 this this DT 37231 2529 61 and and CC 37231 2529 62 other other JJ 37231 2529 63 reasons reason NNS 37231 2529 64 , , , 37231 2529 65 affirm affirm JJ 37231 2529 66 to to TO 37231 2529 67 be be VB 37231 2529 68 the the DT 37231 2529 69 case case NN 37231 2529 70 with with IN 37231 2529 71 the the DT 37231 2529 72 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2529 73 of of IN 37231 2529 74 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 2529 75 - - NNP 37231 2529 76 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2529 77 . . . 37231 2530 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2530 2 3 3 LS 37231 2530 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2530 4 Whatever whatever WDT 37231 2530 5 date date NN 37231 2530 6 be be VB 37231 2530 7 assigned assign VBN 37231 2530 8 to to IN 37231 2530 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2530 10 , , , 37231 2530 11 however however RB 37231 2530 12 , , , 37231 2530 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2530 14 is be VBZ 37231 2530 15 probable probable JJ 37231 2530 16 that that IN 37231 2530 17 the the DT 37231 2530 18 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2530 19 is be VBZ 37231 2530 20 interpolated,4 interpolated,4 NNP 37231 2530 21 although although IN 37231 2530 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2530 23 must must MD 37231 2530 24 be be VB 37231 2530 25 added add VBN 37231 2530 26 that that IN 37231 2530 27 this this DT 37231 2530 28 is be VBZ 37231 2530 29 not not RB 37231 2530 30 the the DT 37231 2530 31 view view NN 37231 2530 32 of of IN 37231 2530 33 the the DT 37231 2530 34 majority majority NN 37231 2530 35 of of IN 37231 2530 36 critics critic NNS 37231 2530 37 . . . 37231 2531 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2531 2 is be VBZ 37231 2531 3 important important JJ 37231 2531 4 to to TO 37231 2531 5 ascertain ascertain VB 37231 2531 6 whether whether IN 37231 2531 7 or or CC 37231 2531 8 not not RB 37231 2531 9 this this DT 37231 2531 10 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2531 11 christian christian NNP 37231 2531 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2531 13 affords afford VBZ 37231 2531 14 any any DT 37231 2531 15 evidence evidence NN 37231 2531 16 of of IN 37231 2531 17 the the DT 37231 2531 18 existence existence NN 37231 2531 19 of of IN 37231 2531 20 { { -LRB- 37231 2531 21 224 224 CD 37231 2531 22 } } -RRB- 37231 2531 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2531 24 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2531 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2531 26 at at IN 37231 2531 27 the the DT 37231 2531 28 time time NN 37231 2531 29 when when WRB 37231 2531 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2531 31 was be VBD 37231 2531 32 written write VBN 37231 2531 33 . . . 37231 2532 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2532 2 , , , 37231 2532 3 who who WP 37231 2532 4 is be VBZ 37231 2532 5 ever ever RB 37231 2532 6 ready ready JJ 37231 2532 7 to to TO 37231 2532 8 claim claim VB 37231 2532 9 the the DT 37231 2532 10 slightest slight JJS 37231 2532 11 resemblance resemblance NN 37231 2532 12 in in IN 37231 2532 13 language language NN 37231 2532 14 as as IN 37231 2532 15 a a DT 37231 2532 16 reference reference NN 37231 2532 17 to to IN 37231 2532 18 New New NNP 37231 2532 19 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2532 20 writings writing NNS 37231 2532 21 , , , 37231 2532 22 states state VBZ 37231 2532 23 that that IN 37231 2532 24 although although IN 37231 2532 25 this this DT 37231 2532 26 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2532 27 is be VBZ 37231 2532 28 rich rich JJ 37231 2532 29 in in IN 37231 2532 30 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2532 31 from from IN 37231 2532 32 the the DT 37231 2532 33 Old Old NNP 37231 2532 34 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2532 35 , , , 37231 2532 36 and and CC 37231 2532 37 that that IN 37231 2532 38 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2532 39 here here RB 37231 2532 40 and and CC 37231 2532 41 there there EX 37231 2532 42 also also RB 37231 2532 43 makes make VBZ 37231 2532 44 use use NN 37231 2532 45 of of IN 37231 2532 46 passages passage NNS 37231 2532 47 from from IN 37231 2532 48 Pauline Pauline NNP 37231 2532 49 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2532 50 , , , 37231 2532 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2532 52 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 2532 53 refers refer VBZ 37231 2532 54 to to IN 37231 2532 55 the the DT 37231 2532 56 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2532 57 . . . 37231 2533 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2533 2 1 1 LS 37231 2533 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2533 4 This this DT 37231 2533 5 is be VBZ 37231 2533 6 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2533 7 true true JJ 37231 2533 8 , , , 37231 2533 9 but but CC 37231 2533 10 several several JJ 37231 2533 11 passages passage NNS 37231 2533 12 occur occur VBP 37231 2533 13 in in IN 37231 2533 14 this this DT 37231 2533 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2533 16 which which WDT 37231 2533 17 are be VBP 37231 2533 18 either either CC 37231 2533 19 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2533 20 from from IN 37231 2533 21 Evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 2533 22 works work NNS 37231 2533 23 different different RB 37231 2533 24 from from IN 37231 2533 25 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 2533 26 , , , 37231 2533 27 or or CC 37231 2533 28 derived derive VBN 37231 2533 29 from from IN 37231 2533 30 tradition,(2 tradition,(2 NNP 37231 2533 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2533 32 and and CC 37231 2533 33 in in IN 37231 2533 34 either either DT 37231 2533 35 case case NN 37231 2533 36 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2533 37 have have VBP 37231 2533 38 a a DT 37231 2533 39 very very RB 37231 2533 40 important important JJ 37231 2533 41 bearing bearing NN 37231 2533 42 upon upon IN 37231 2533 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2533 44 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2533 45 . . . 37231 2534 1 The the DT 37231 2534 2 first first JJ 37231 2534 3 of of IN 37231 2534 4 these these DT 37231 2534 5 passages passage NNS 37231 2534 6 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2534 7 in in IN 37231 2534 8 Ch Ch NNP 37231 2534 9 . . . 37231 2535 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 2535 2 . . . 37231 2535 3 , , , 37231 2535 4 and and CC 37231 2535 5 for for IN 37231 2535 6 greater great JJR 37231 2535 7 facility facility NN 37231 2535 8 of of IN 37231 2535 9 comparison comparison NN 37231 2535 10 , , , 37231 2535 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2535 12 shall shall MD 37231 2535 13 at at IN 37231 2535 14 once once RB 37231 2535 15 place place VB 37231 2535 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2535 17 both both DT 37231 2535 18 in in IN 37231 2535 19 the the DT 37231 2535 20 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2535 21 and and CC 37231 2535 22 in in IN 37231 2535 23 translation translation NN 37231 2535 24 , , , 37231 2535 25 in in IN 37231 2535 26 juxta juxta NN 37231 2535 27 - - HYPH 37231 2535 28 position position NN 37231 2535 29 with with IN 37231 2535 30 the the DT 37231 2535 31 nearest near JJS 37231 2535 32 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2535 33 readings reading NNS 37231 2535 34 in in IN 37231 2535 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2535 36 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2535 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2535 38 ; ; : 37231 2535 39 and and CC 37231 2535 40 , , , 37231 2535 41 as as RB 37231 2535 42 far far RB 37231 2535 43 as as IN 37231 2535 44 may may MD 37231 2535 45 be be VB 37231 2535 46 , , , 37231 2535 47 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2535 48 shall shall MD 37231 2535 49 in in IN 37231 2535 50 the the DT 37231 2535 51 English english JJ 37231 2535 52 version version NN 37231 2535 53 indicate indicate VBP 37231 2535 54 differences difference NNS 37231 2535 55 existing exist VBG 37231 2535 56 in in IN 37231 2535 57 the the DT 37231 2535 58 original original JJ 37231 2535 59 texts text NNS 37231 2535 60 . . . 37231 2536 1 The the DT 37231 2536 2 passage passage NN 37231 2536 3 is be VBZ 37231 2536 4 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2536 5 thus thus RB 37231 2536 6 : : : 37231 2536 7 " " `` 37231 2536 8 Especially especially RB 37231 2536 9 remembering remember VBG 37231 2536 10 the the DT 37231 2536 11 words word NNS 37231 2536 12 of of IN 37231 2536 13 the the DT 37231 2536 14 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2536 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2536 16 , , , 37231 2536 17 which which WDT 37231 2536 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2536 19 spake spake VBD 37231 2536 20 teaching teaching NN 37231 2536 21 gentleness gentleness NN 37231 2536 22 and and CC 37231 2536 23 long long RB 37231 2536 24 - - HYPH 37231 2536 25 suffering suffering NN 37231 2536 26 . . . 37231 2537 1 For for IN 37231 2537 2 thus thus RB 37231 2537 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2537 4 said:"(3)-- said:"(3)-- VBD 37231 2537 5 { { -LRB- 37231 2537 6 225 225 CD 37231 2537 7 } } -RRB- 37231 2537 8 Of of RB 37231 2537 9 course course RB 37231 2537 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2537 11 is be VBZ 37231 2537 12 understood understand VBN 37231 2537 13 that that IN 37231 2537 14 , , , 37231 2537 15 although although IN 37231 2537 16 for for IN 37231 2537 17 convenience convenience NN 37231 2537 18 { { -LRB- 37231 2537 19 226 226 CD 37231 2537 20 } } -RRB- 37231 2537 21 of of IN 37231 2537 22 comparison comparison NN 37231 2537 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2537 24 have have VBP 37231 2537 25 broken break VBN 37231 2537 26 up up RP 37231 2537 27 this this DT 37231 2537 28 quotation quotation NN 37231 2537 29 into into IN 37231 2537 30 these these DT 37231 2537 31 phrases phrase NNS 37231 2537 32 , , , 37231 2537 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2537 34 is be VBZ 37231 2537 35 quite quite RB 37231 2537 36 continuous continuous JJ 37231 2537 37 in in IN 37231 2537 38 the the DT 37231 2537 39 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2537 40 . . . 37231 2538 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2538 2 must must MD 37231 2538 3 be be VB 37231 2538 4 evident evident JJ 37231 2538 5 to to IN 37231 2538 6 any any DT 37231 2538 7 one one NN 37231 2538 8 who who WP 37231 2538 9 carefully carefully RB 37231 2538 10 examines examine VBZ 37231 2538 11 the the DT 37231 2538 12 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2538 13 passages passage NNS 37231 2538 14 , , , 37231 2538 15 that that IN 37231 2538 16 " " `` 37231 2538 17 the the DT 37231 2538 18 words word NNS 37231 2538 19 of of IN 37231 2538 20 the the DT 37231 2538 21 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2538 22 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2538 23 " " '' 37231 2538 24 in in IN 37231 2538 25 the the DT 37231 2538 26 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2538 27 can can MD 37231 2538 28 not not RB 37231 2538 29 have have VB 37231 2538 30 been be VBN 37231 2538 31 derived derive VBN 37231 2538 32 from from IN 37231 2538 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2538 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2538 35 . . . 37231 2539 1 Not not RB 37231 2539 2 only only RB 37231 2539 3 is be VBZ 37231 2539 4 there there EX 37231 2539 5 no no DT 37231 2539 6 similar similar JJ 37231 2539 7 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 2539 8 discourse discourse NN 37231 2539 9 in in IN 37231 2539 10 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2539 11 , , , 37231 2539 12 but but CC 37231 2539 13 the the DT 37231 2539 14 scattered scatter VBN 37231 2539 15 phrases phrase NNS 37231 2539 16 which which WDT 37231 2539 17 are be VBP 37231 2539 18 pointed point VBN 37231 2539 19 out out RP 37231 2539 20 as as IN 37231 2539 21 presenting present VBG 37231 2539 22 superficial superficial JJ 37231 2539 23 similarity similarity NN 37231 2539 24 with with IN 37231 2539 25 the the DT 37231 2539 26 quotation quotation NN 37231 2539 27 are be VBP 37231 2539 28 markedly markedly RB 37231 2539 29 different different JJ 37231 2539 30 both both CC 37231 2539 31 in in IN 37231 2539 32 thought thought NN 37231 2539 33 and and CC 37231 2539 34 language language NN 37231 2539 35 . . . 37231 2540 1 In in IN 37231 2540 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2540 3 , , , 37231 2540 4 as as IN 37231 2540 5 in in IN 37231 2540 6 the the DT 37231 2540 7 " " `` 37231 2540 8 beatitudes beatitude NNS 37231 2540 9 " " '' 37231 2540 10 of of IN 37231 2540 11 the the DT 37231 2540 12 " " `` 37231 2540 13 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 2540 14 on on IN 37231 2540 15 the the DT 37231 2540 16 Mount Mount NNP 37231 2540 17 " " '' 37231 2540 18 in in IN 37231 2540 19 the the DT 37231 2540 20 first first JJ 37231 2540 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2540 22 , , , 37231 2540 23 the the DT 37231 2540 24 construction construction NN 37231 2540 25 is be VBZ 37231 2540 26 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 2540 27 and and CC 37231 2540 28 continuous continuous JJ 37231 2540 29 : : : 37231 2540 30 " " `` 37231 2540 31 Do do VB 37231 2540 32 this this DT 37231 2540 33 .... .... . 37231 2540 34 in in IN 37231 2540 35 order order NN 37231 2540 36 that that IN 37231 2540 37 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2540 38 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2540 39 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2540 40 " " '' 37231 2540 41 ; ; : 37231 2540 42 or or CC 37231 2540 43 , , , 37231 2540 44 " " `` 37231 2540 45 As as IN 37231 2540 46 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2540 47 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 2540 48 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2540 49 ... ... . 37231 2540 50 so so CC 37231 2540 51 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2540 52 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2540 53 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2540 54 " " `` 37231 2540 55 The the DT 37231 2540 56 theor theor NN 37231 2540 57 of of IN 37231 2540 58 a a DT 37231 2540 59 combination combination NN 37231 2540 60 of of IN 37231 2540 61 passages passage NNS 37231 2540 62 from from IN 37231 2540 63 memory memory NN 37231 2540 64 , , , 37231 2540 65 which which WDT 37231 2540 66 is be VBZ 37231 2540 67 usually usually RB 37231 2540 68 advanced advance VBN 37231 2540 69 to to TO 37231 2540 70 explain explain VB 37231 2540 71 such such JJ 37231 2540 72 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2540 73 , , , 37231 2540 74 can can MD 37231 2540 75 not not RB 37231 2540 76 serve serve VB 37231 2540 77 here here RB 37231 2540 78 , , , 37231 2540 79 for for IN 37231 2540 80 thoughts thought NNS 37231 2540 81 and and CC 37231 2540 82 expressions expression NNS 37231 2540 83 occur occur VBP 37231 2540 84 in in IN 37231 2540 85 the the DT 37231 2540 86 passage passage NN 37231 2540 87 in in IN 37231 2540 88 the the DT 37231 2540 89 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2540 90 which which WDT 37231 2540 91 have have VBP 37231 2540 92 no no DT 37231 2540 93 parallel parallel NN 37231 2540 94 at at RB 37231 2540 95 all all RB 37231 2540 96 in in IN 37231 2540 97 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2540 98 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2540 99 , , , 37231 2540 100 and and CC 37231 2540 101 such such JJ 37231 2540 102 dismembered dismembered JJ 37231 2540 103 phrases phrase NNS 37231 2540 104 as as IN 37231 2540 105 can can MD 37231 2540 106 be be VB 37231 2540 107 collected collect VBN 37231 2540 108 from from IN 37231 2540 109 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2540 110 first first JJ 37231 2540 111 and and CC 37231 2540 112 third third JJ 37231 2540 113 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2540 114 , , , 37231 2540 115 for for IN 37231 2540 116 comparison comparison NN 37231 2540 117 with with IN 37231 2540 118 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2540 119 , , , 37231 2540 120 follow follow VB 37231 2540 121 the the DT 37231 2540 122 course course NN 37231 2540 123 of of IN 37231 2540 124 the the DT 37231 2540 125 quotation quotation NN 37231 2540 126 in in IN 37231 2540 127 the the DT 37231 2540 128 ensuing ensue VBG 37231 2540 129 order order NN 37231 2540 130 : : : 37231 2540 131 Matt Matt NNP 37231 2540 132 . . . 37231 2541 1 v. v. CC 37231 2541 2 7 7 CD 37231 2541 3 , , , 37231 2541 4 vi vi NNP 37231 2541 5 . . . 37231 2542 1 14 14 CD 37231 2542 2 , , , 37231 2542 3 part part NN 37231 2542 4 of of IN 37231 2542 5 vii vii NN 37231 2542 6 . . . 37231 2543 1 12 12 CD 37231 2543 2 , , , 37231 2543 3 phrase phrase VB 37231 2543 4 without without IN 37231 2543 5 parallel parallel NN 37231 2543 6 , , , 37231 2543 7 first first JJ 37231 2543 8 part part NN 37231 2543 9 of of IN 37231 2543 10 vii vii NN 37231 2543 11 . . . 37231 2544 1 2 2 CD 37231 2544 2 , , , 37231 2544 3 phrase phrase VB 37231 2544 4 without without IN 37231 2544 5 parallel parallel NN 37231 2544 6 , , , 37231 2544 7 last last JJ 37231 2544 8 part part NN 37231 2544 9 of of IN 37231 2544 10 vii vii NN 37231 2544 11 . . . 37231 2545 1 2 2 LS 37231 2545 2 ; ; : 37231 2545 3 or or CC 37231 2545 4 , , , 37231 2545 5 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2545 6 vi vi NNP 37231 2545 7 . . . 37231 2546 1 36 36 CD 37231 2546 2 , , , 37231 2546 3 last last JJ 37231 2546 4 phrase phrase NN 37231 2546 5 of of IN 37231 2546 6 vi vi NNP 37231 2546 7 . . . 37231 2547 1 37 37 CD 37231 2547 2 , , , 37231 2547 3 vi vi NNP 37231 2547 4 . . . 37231 2548 1 31 31 CD 37231 2548 2 , , , 37231 2548 3 first first JJ 37231 2548 4 phrase phrase NN 37231 2548 5 of of IN 37231 2548 6 vi vi NNP 37231 2548 7 . . . 37231 2549 1 38 38 CD 37231 2549 2 , , , 37231 2549 3 first first JJ 37231 2549 4 phrase phrase NN 37231 2549 5 of of IN 37231 2549 6 vi vi NNP 37231 2549 7 . . . 37231 2550 1 37 37 CD 37231 2550 2 , , , 37231 2550 3 phrase phrase VB 37231 2550 4 without without IN 37231 2550 5 parallel parallel NN 37231 2550 6 , , , 37231 2550 7 last last JJ 37231 2550 8 phrase phrase NN 37231 2550 9 of of IN 37231 2550 10 vi vi NNP 37231 2550 11 . . . 37231 2551 1 38 38 CD 37231 2551 2 . . . 37231 2552 1 The the DT 37231 2552 2 only only JJ 37231 2552 3 question question NN 37231 2552 4 with with IN 37231 2552 5 regard regard NN 37231 2552 6 to to IN 37231 2552 7 this this DT 37231 2552 8 passage passage NN 37231 2552 9 , , , 37231 2552 10 therefore therefore RB 37231 2552 11 , , , 37231 2552 12 is be VBZ 37231 2552 13 whether whether IN 37231 2552 14 the the DT 37231 2552 15 writer writer NN 37231 2552 16 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2552 17 from from IN 37231 2552 18 an an DT 37231 2552 19 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2552 20 written write VBN 37231 2552 21 source source NN 37231 2552 22 or or CC 37231 2552 23 from from IN 37231 2552 24 tradition tradition NN 37231 2552 25 . . . 37231 2553 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2553 2 certainly certainly RB 37231 2553 3 merely merely RB 37231 2553 4 professes profess VBZ 37231 2553 5 to to TO 37231 2553 6 repeat repeat VB 37231 2553 7 " " `` 37231 2553 8 words word NNS 37231 2553 9 of of IN 37231 2553 10 the the DT 37231 2553 11 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2553 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2553 13 , , , 37231 2553 14 " " `` 37231 2553 15 and and CC 37231 2553 16 does do VBZ 37231 2553 17 not not RB 37231 2553 18 definitely definitely RB 37231 2553 19 indicate indicate VB 37231 2553 20 a a DT 37231 2553 21 written write VBN 37231 2553 22 record record NN 37231 2553 23 , , , 37231 2553 24 but but CC 37231 2553 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2553 26 is be VBZ 37231 2553 27 much much RB 37231 2553 28 more more RBR 37231 2553 29 probable probable JJ 37231 2553 30 , , , 37231 2553 31 from from IN 37231 2553 32 the the DT 37231 2553 33 context context NN 37231 2553 34 , , , 37231 2553 35 that that IN 37231 2553 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2553 37 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2553 38 from from IN 37231 2553 39 a a DT 37231 2553 40 gospel gospel NN 37231 2553 41 now now RB 37231 2553 42 no no RB 37231 2553 43 longer long RBR 37231 2553 44 extant extant JJ 37231 2553 45 than than IN 37231 2553 46 that that IN 37231 2553 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2553 48 derives derive VBZ 37231 2553 49 this this DT 37231 2553 50 teaching teaching NN 37231 2553 51 from from IN 37231 2553 52 oral oral JJ 37231 2553 53 tradition tradition NN 37231 2553 54 . . . 37231 2554 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 2 introduces introduce VBZ 37231 2554 3 the the DT 37231 2554 4 quotation quotation NN 37231 2554 5 { { -LRB- 37231 2554 6 227 227 CD 37231 2554 7 } } -RRB- 37231 2554 8 not not RB 37231 2554 9 only only RB 37231 2554 10 with with IN 37231 2554 11 a a DT 37231 2554 12 remark remark NN 37231 2554 13 implying imply VBG 37231 2554 14 a a DT 37231 2554 15 well well RB 37231 2554 16 - - HYPH 37231 2554 17 known know VBN 37231 2554 18 record record NN 37231 2554 19 : : : 37231 2554 20 " " `` 37231 2554 21 Remembering remember VBG 37231 2554 22 the the DT 37231 2554 23 words word NNS 37231 2554 24 of of IN 37231 2554 25 the the DT 37231 2554 26 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2554 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2554 28 which which WDT 37231 2554 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 30 spake spake VBD 37231 2554 31 , , , 37231 2554 32 teaching teaching NN 37231 2554 33 , , , 37231 2554 34 & & CC 37231 2554 35 c. c. NNP 37231 2554 36 " " '' 37231 2554 37 but but CC 37231 2554 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 39 reiterates reiterate VBZ 37231 2554 40 : : : 37231 2554 41 " " `` 37231 2554 42 For for IN 37231 2554 43 thus thus RB 37231 2554 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 45 said say VBD 37231 2554 46 , , , 37231 2554 47 " " `` 37231 2554 48 in in IN 37231 2554 49 a a DT 37231 2554 50 way way NN 37231 2554 51 suggesting suggest VBG 37231 2554 52 careful careful JJ 37231 2554 53 and and CC 37231 2554 54 precise precise JJ 37231 2554 55 quotation quotation NN 37231 2554 56 of of IN 37231 2554 57 the the DT 37231 2554 58 very very JJ 37231 2554 59 words word NNS 37231 2554 60 ; ; : 37231 2554 61 and and CC 37231 2554 62 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 63 adds add VBZ 37231 2554 64 at at IN 37231 2554 65 the the DT 37231 2554 66 end end NN 37231 2554 67 : : : 37231 2554 68 " " `` 37231 2554 69 By by IN 37231 2554 70 this this DT 37231 2554 71 injunction injunction NN 37231 2554 72 and and CC 37231 2554 73 by by IN 37231 2554 74 these these DT 37231 2554 75 instructions instruction NNS 37231 2554 76 let let VBP 37231 2554 77 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 78 establish establish VB 37231 2554 79 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 80 , , , 37231 2554 81 that that IN 37231 2554 82 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 83 may may MD 37231 2554 84 walk walk VB 37231 2554 85 in in IN 37231 2554 86 obedience obedience NN 37231 2554 87 to to IN 37231 2554 88 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2554 89 holy holy JJ 37231 2554 90 words word NNS 37231 2554 91 , , , 37231 2554 92 thinking think VBG 37231 2554 93 humbly humbly RB 37231 2554 94 of of IN 37231 2554 95 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2554 96 . . . 37231 2555 1 " " `` 37231 2555 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2555 3 1 1 LS 37231 2555 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2555 5 seems seem VBZ 37231 2555 6 improbable improbable JJ 37231 2555 7 that that IN 37231 2555 8 the the DT 37231 2555 9 writer writer NN 37231 2555 10 would would MD 37231 2555 11 so so RB 37231 2555 12 markedly markedly RB 37231 2555 13 have have VB 37231 2555 14 indicated indicate VBN 37231 2555 15 a a DT 37231 2555 16 precise precise JJ 37231 2555 17 quotation quotation NN 37231 2555 18 of of IN 37231 2555 19 words word NNS 37231 2555 20 of of IN 37231 2555 21 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2555 22 , , , 37231 2555 23 and and CC 37231 2555 24 would would MD 37231 2555 25 so so RB 37231 2555 26 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 2555 27 have have VB 37231 2555 28 commended commend VBN 37231 2555 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2555 30 as as IN 37231 2555 31 the the DT 37231 2555 32 rule rule NN 37231 2555 33 of of IN 37231 2555 34 life life NN 37231 2555 35 to to IN 37231 2555 36 the the DT 37231 2555 37 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2555 38 , , , 37231 2555 39 had have VBD 37231 2555 40 these these DT 37231 2555 41 precepts precept NNS 37231 2555 42 been be VBN 37231 2555 43 mere mere JJ 37231 2555 44 floating float VBG 37231 2555 45 tradition tradition NN 37231 2555 46 , , , 37231 2555 47 until until IN 37231 2555 48 then then RB 37231 2555 49 unstamped unstampe VBN 37231 2555 50 with with IN 37231 2555 51 written write VBN 37231 2555 52 permanence permanence NN 37231 2555 53 . . . 37231 2556 1 The the DT 37231 2556 2 phrase phrase NN 37231 2556 3 : : : 37231 2556 4 " " `` 37231 2556 5 As as IN 37231 2556 6 ye ye NNP 37231 2556 7 show show NN 37231 2556 8 kindness kindness NN 37231 2556 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2556 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2556 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2556 12 which which WDT 37231 2556 13 is be VBZ 37231 2556 14 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 2556 15 found find VBN 37231 2556 16 in in IN 37231 2556 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2556 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2556 19 , , , 37231 2556 20 recalls recall VBZ 37231 2556 21 an an DT 37231 2556 22 expression expression NN 37231 2556 23 quoted quote VBN 37231 2556 24 by by IN 37231 2556 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 2556 26 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 2556 27 apparently apparently RB 37231 2556 28 from from IN 37231 2556 29 a a DT 37231 2556 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2556 31 different different JJ 37231 2556 32 from from IN 37231 2556 33 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 2556 34 , , , 37231 2556 35 and and CC 37231 2556 36 frequently frequently RB 37231 2556 37 repeated repeat VBN 37231 2556 38 by by IN 37231 2556 39 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2556 40 in in IN 37231 2556 41 the the DT 37231 2556 42 same same JJ 37231 2556 43 form form NN 37231 2556 44 : : : 37231 2556 45 " " `` 37231 2556 46 Be be VB 37231 2556 47 ye ye PRP 37231 2556 48 kind kind JJ 37231 2556 49 and and CC 37231 2556 50 merciful merciful JJ 37231 2556 51 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2556 52 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2556 53 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2556 54 Father Father NNP 37231 2556 55 also also RB 37231 2556 56 is be VBZ 37231 2556 57 kind kind RB 37231 2556 58 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2556 59 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2556 60 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2556 61 and and CC 37231 2556 62 merciful merciful JJ 37231 2556 63 . . . 37231 2557 1 " " `` 37231 2557 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2557 3 2 2 LS 37231 2557 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2557 5 In in IN 37231 2557 6 the the DT 37231 2557 7 very very RB 37231 2557 8 next next JJ 37231 2557 9 chapter chapter NN 37231 2557 10 of of IN 37231 2557 11 the the DT 37231 2557 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2557 13 a a DT 37231 2557 14 similar similar JJ 37231 2557 15 reference reference NN 37231 2557 16 again again RB 37231 2557 17 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2557 18 : : : 37231 2557 19 " " `` 37231 2557 20 Let let VB 37231 2557 21 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2557 22 be be VB 37231 2557 23 kind kind JJ 37231 2557 24 to to IN 37231 2557 25 each each DT 37231 2557 26 other other JJ 37231 2557 27 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2557 28 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2557 29 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2557 30 according accord VBG 37231 2557 31 to to IN 37231 2557 32 the the DT 37231 2557 33 mercy mercy NN 37231 2557 34 and and CC 37231 2557 35 benignity benignity NN 37231 2557 36 of of IN 37231 2557 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2557 38 Creator creator NN 37231 2557 39 . . . 37231 2558 1 " " `` 37231 2558 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2558 3 3 3 LS 37231 2558 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2558 5 Without without IN 37231 2558 6 , , , 37231 2558 7 however however RB 37231 2558 8 , , , 37231 2558 9 going go VBG 37231 2558 10 more more RBR 37231 2558 11 minutely minutely RB 37231 2558 12 into into IN 37231 2558 13 this this DT 37231 2558 14 question question NN 37231 2558 15 , , , 37231 2558 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2558 17 is be VBZ 37231 2558 18 certain certain JJ 37231 2558 19 from from IN 37231 2558 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2558 21 essential essential JJ 37231 2558 22 variations variation NNS 37231 2558 23 in in IN 37231 2558 24 language language NN 37231 2558 25 , , , 37231 2558 26 thought thought NN 37231 2558 27 and and CC 37231 2558 28 order order NN 37231 2558 29 , , , 37231 2558 30 that that IN 37231 2558 31 the the DT 37231 2558 32 passage passage NN 37231 2558 33 in in IN 37231 2558 34 the the DT 37231 2558 35 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2558 36 can can MD 37231 2558 37 not not RB 37231 2558 38 be be VB 37231 2558 39 claimed claim VBN 37231 2558 40 as as IN 37231 2558 41 a a DT 37231 2558 42 compilation compilation NN 37231 2558 43 from from IN 37231 2558 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2558 45 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2558 46 ; ; : 37231 2558 47 and and CC 37231 2558 48 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2558 49 shall shall MD 37231 2558 50 presently presently RB 37231 2558 51 see see VB 37231 2558 52 that that IN 37231 2558 53 some some DT 37231 2558 54 of of IN 37231 2558 55 the the DT 37231 2558 56 expressions expression NNS 37231 2558 57 in in IN 37231 2558 58 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2558 59 which which WDT 37231 2558 60 are be VBP 37231 2558 61 foreign foreign JJ 37231 2558 62 to to IN 37231 2558 63 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2558 64 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2558 65 are be VBP 37231 2558 66 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2558 67 quoted quote VBN 37231 2558 68 by by IN 37231 2558 69 other other JJ 37231 2558 70 Fathers father NNS 37231 2558 71 , , , 37231 2558 72 and and CC 37231 2558 73 there there EX 37231 2558 74 is be VBZ 37231 2558 75 reason reason NN 37231 2558 76 to to TO 37231 2558 77 believe believe VB 37231 2558 78 that that IN 37231 2558 79 these these DT 37231 2558 80 " " `` 37231 2558 81 words word NNS 37231 2558 82 of of IN 37231 2558 83 the the DT 37231 2558 84 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2558 85 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2558 86 " " `` 37231 2558 87 were be VBD 37231 2558 88 not not RB 37231 2558 89 derived derive VBN 37231 2558 90 from from IN 37231 2558 91 tradition tradition NN 37231 2558 92 but but CC 37231 2558 93 { { -LRB- 37231 2558 94 228 228 CD 37231 2558 95 } } -RRB- 37231 2558 96 from from IN 37231 2558 97 a a DT 37231 2558 98 written write VBN 37231 2558 99 source source NN 37231 2558 100 different different JJ 37231 2558 101 from from IN 37231 2558 102 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2558 103 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2558 104 . . . 37231 2559 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2559 2 1 1 LS 37231 2559 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2559 4 When when WRB 37231 2559 5 the the DT 37231 2559 6 great great JJ 37231 2559 7 difference difference NN 37231 2559 8 which which WDT 37231 2559 9 exists exist VBZ 37231 2559 10 between between IN 37231 2559 11 the the DT 37231 2559 12 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2559 13 passages passage NNS 37231 2559 14 in in IN 37231 2559 15 the the DT 37231 2559 16 first first JJ 37231 2559 17 and and CC 37231 2559 18 third third JJ 37231 2559 19 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2559 20 , , , 37231 2559 21 and and CC 37231 2559 22 still still RB 37231 2559 23 more more JJR 37231 2559 24 between between IN 37231 2559 25 these these DT 37231 2559 26 and and CC 37231 2559 27 the the DT 37231 2559 28 second second JJ 37231 2559 29 , , , 37231 2559 30 is be VBZ 37231 2559 31 considered consider VBN 37231 2559 32 , , , 37231 2559 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2559 34 is be VBZ 37231 2559 35 easy easy JJ 37231 2559 36 to to TO 37231 2559 37 understand understand VB 37231 2559 38 that that IN 37231 2559 39 other other JJ 37231 2559 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2559 41 may may MD 37231 2559 42 have have VB 37231 2559 43 contained contain VBN 37231 2559 44 a a DT 37231 2559 45 version version NN 37231 2559 46 differing differ VBG 37231 2559 47 as as RB 37231 2559 48 much much JJ 37231 2559 49 from from IN 37231 2559 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2559 51 as as IN 37231 2559 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2559 53 do do VBP 37231 2559 54 from from IN 37231 2559 55 each each DT 37231 2559 56 other other JJ 37231 2559 57 . . . 37231 2560 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2560 2 likewise likewise RB 37231 2560 3 subjoin subjoin VBP 37231 2560 4 the the DT 37231 2560 5 next next JJ 37231 2560 6 passage passage NN 37231 2560 7 to to IN 37231 2560 8 which which WDT 37231 2560 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2560 10 must must MD 37231 2560 11 refer refer VB 37231 2560 12 , , , 37231 2560 13 with with IN 37231 2560 14 the the DT 37231 2560 15 nearest near JJS 37231 2560 16 parallels parallel NNS 37231 2560 17 in in IN 37231 2560 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2560 19 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2560 20 . . . 37231 2561 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2561 2 may may MD 37231 2561 3 explain explain VB 37231 2561 4 that that IN 37231 2561 5 the the DT 37231 2561 6 writer writer NN 37231 2561 7 of of IN 37231 2561 8 the the DT 37231 2561 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2561 10 is be VBZ 37231 2561 11 rebuking rebuke VBG 37231 2561 12 the the DT 37231 2561 13 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2561 14 for for IN 37231 2561 15 strifes strife NNS 37231 2561 16 and and CC 37231 2561 17 divisions division NNS 37231 2561 18 amongst amongst IN 37231 2561 19 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2561 20 , , , 37231 2561 21 and and CC 37231 2561 22 for for IN 37231 2561 23 forgetting forget VBG 37231 2561 24 that that IN 37231 2561 25 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2561 26 " " `` 37231 2561 27 are be VBP 37231 2561 28 members member NNS 37231 2561 29 one one CD 37231 2561 30 of of IN 37231 2561 31 another another DT 37231 2561 32 , , , 37231 2561 33 " " '' 37231 2561 34 and and CC 37231 2561 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2561 36 continues continue VBZ 37231 2561 37 : : : 37231 2561 38 " " `` 37231 2561 39 Remember remember VB 37231 2561 40 the the DT 37231 2561 41 words word NNS 37231 2561 42 of of IN 37231 2561 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2561 44 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2561 45 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2561 46 ; ; : 37231 2561 47 for for IN 37231 2561 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2561 49 said:"(2 said:"(2 : 37231 2561 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2561 51 { { -LRB- 37231 2561 52 229 229 CD 37231 2561 53 } } -RRB- 37231 2561 54 This this DT 37231 2561 55 quotation quotation NN 37231 2561 56 is be VBZ 37231 2561 57 clearly clearly RB 37231 2561 58 not not RB 37231 2561 59 from from IN 37231 2561 60 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2561 61 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2561 62 , , , 37231 2561 63 but but CC 37231 2561 64 must must MD 37231 2561 65 be be VB 37231 2561 66 assigned assign VBN 37231 2561 67 to to IN 37231 2561 68 a a DT 37231 2561 69 different different JJ 37231 2561 70 written write VBN 37231 2561 71 source source NN 37231 2561 72 . . . 37231 2562 1 The the DT 37231 2562 2 writer writer NN 37231 2562 3 would would MD 37231 2562 4 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2562 5 refer refer VB 37231 2562 6 the the DT 37231 2562 7 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2562 8 to to IN 37231 2562 9 such such JJ 37231 2562 10 words word NNS 37231 2562 11 of of IN 37231 2562 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2562 13 if if IN 37231 2562 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2562 15 were be VBD 37231 2562 16 merely merely RB 37231 2562 17 traditional traditional JJ 37231 2562 18 . . . 37231 2563 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2563 2 is be VBZ 37231 2563 3 neither neither CC 37231 2563 4 a a DT 37231 2563 5 combination combination NN 37231 2563 6 of of IN 37231 2563 7 texts text NNS 37231 2563 8 , , , 37231 2563 9 nor nor CC 37231 2563 10 a a DT 37231 2563 11 quotation quotation NN 37231 2563 12 from from IN 37231 2563 13 memory memory NN 37231 2563 14 . . . 37231 2564 1 The the DT 37231 2564 2 language language NN 37231 2564 3 throughout throughout IN 37231 2564 4 is be VBZ 37231 2564 5 markedly markedly RB 37231 2564 6 different different JJ 37231 2564 7 from from IN 37231 2564 8 any any DT 37231 2564 9 passage passage NN 37231 2564 10 in in IN 37231 2564 11 the the DT 37231 2564 12 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2564 13 , , , 37231 2564 14 and and CC 37231 2564 15 to to TO 37231 2564 16 present present VB 37231 2564 17 even even RB 37231 2564 18 a a DT 37231 2564 19 superficial superficial JJ 37231 2564 20 parallel parallel NN 37231 2564 21 , , , 37231 2564 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2564 23 is be VBZ 37231 2564 24 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2564 25 to to TO 37231 2564 26 take take VB 37231 2564 27 a a DT 37231 2564 28 fragment fragment NN 37231 2564 29 of of IN 37231 2564 30 the the DT 37231 2564 31 discourse discourse NN 37231 2564 32 of of IN 37231 2564 33 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2564 34 at at IN 37231 2564 35 the the DT 37231 2564 36 Last last JJ 37231 2564 37 Supper Supper NNP 37231 2564 38 regarding regard VBG 37231 2564 39 the the DT 37231 2564 40 traitor traitor NN 37231 2564 41 who who WP 37231 2564 42 should should MD 37231 2564 43 deliver deliver VB 37231 2564 44 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2564 45 up up RP 37231 2564 46 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2564 47 Matth Matth NNP 37231 2564 48 . . . 37231 2565 1 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 2565 2 . . . 37231 2566 1 24 24 CD 37231 2566 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2566 3 , , , 37231 2566 4 and and CC 37231 2566 5 join join VB 37231 2566 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2566 7 to to IN 37231 2566 8 a a DT 37231 2566 9 fragment fragment NN 37231 2566 10 of of IN 37231 2566 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2566 12 remarks remark NNS 37231 2566 13 in in IN 37231 2566 14 connection connection NN 37231 2566 15 with with IN 37231 2566 16 the the DT 37231 2566 17 little little JJ 37231 2566 18 child child NN 37231 2566 19 whom whom WP 37231 2566 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2566 21 set set VBD 37231 2566 22 in in IN 37231 2566 23 the the DT 37231 2566 24 midst midst NN 37231 2566 25 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2566 26 xviii xviii NN 37231 2566 27 . . . 37231 2567 1 6 6 LS 37231 2567 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2567 3 . . . 37231 2568 1 The the DT 37231 2568 2 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2568 3 passage passage NN 37231 2568 4 in in IN 37231 2568 5 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2568 6 has have VBZ 37231 2568 7 not not RB 37231 2568 8 { { -LRB- 37231 2568 9 230 230 CD 37231 2568 10 } } -RRB- 37231 2568 11 the the DT 37231 2568 12 opening opening NN 37231 2568 13 words word NNS 37231 2568 14 of of IN 37231 2568 15 the the DT 37231 2568 16 passage passage NN 37231 2568 17 in in IN 37231 2568 18 the the DT 37231 2568 19 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2568 20 at at RB 37231 2568 21 all all RB 37231 2568 22 , , , 37231 2568 23 and and CC 37231 2568 24 the the DT 37231 2568 25 portion portion NN 37231 2568 26 which which WDT 37231 2568 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2568 28 contains contain VBZ 37231 2568 29 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2568 30 xvii xvii NN 37231 2568 31 . . . 37231 2569 1 2 2 LS 37231 2569 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2569 3 , , , 37231 2569 4 is be VBZ 37231 2569 5 separated separate VBN 37231 2569 6 from from IN 37231 2569 7 the the DT 37231 2569 8 context context NN 37231 2569 9 in in IN 37231 2569 10 which which WDT 37231 2569 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2569 12 stands stand VBZ 37231 2569 13 in in IN 37231 2569 14 the the DT 37231 2569 15 first first JJ 37231 2569 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2569 17 , , , 37231 2569 18 and and CC 37231 2569 19 which which WDT 37231 2569 20 explains explain VBZ 37231 2569 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2569 22 meaning meaning NN 37231 2569 23 . . . 37231 2570 1 If if IN 37231 2570 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2570 3 contrast contrast VBP 37231 2570 4 the the DT 37231 2570 5 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2570 6 passages passage NNS 37231 2570 7 in in IN 37231 2570 8 the the DT 37231 2570 9 three three CD 37231 2570 10 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2570 11 , , , 37231 2570 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2570 13 differences difference NNS 37231 2570 14 of of IN 37231 2570 15 context context NN 37231 2570 16 are be VBP 37231 2570 17 very very RB 37231 2570 18 suggestive suggestive JJ 37231 2570 19 , , , 37231 2570 20 and and CC 37231 2570 21 without without IN 37231 2570 22 referring refer VBG 37231 2570 23 to to IN 37231 2570 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2570 25 numerous numerous JJ 37231 2570 26 and and CC 37231 2570 27 important important JJ 37231 2570 28 variations variation NNS 37231 2570 29 in in IN 37231 2570 30 detail detail NN 37231 2570 31 , , , 37231 2570 32 the the DT 37231 2570 33 confusion confusion NN 37231 2570 34 amongst amongst IN 37231 2570 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2570 36 is be VBZ 37231 2570 37 evidence evidence NN 37231 2570 38 of of IN 37231 2570 39 very very RB 37231 2570 40 varying varying JJ 37231 2570 41 tradition tradition NN 37231 2570 42 . . . 37231 2571 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2571 2 1 1 LS 37231 2571 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2571 4 This this DT 37231 2571 5 alone alone RB 37231 2571 6 would would MD 37231 2571 7 make make VB 37231 2571 8 the the DT 37231 2571 9 existence existence NN 37231 2571 10 of of IN 37231 2571 11 another another DT 37231 2571 12 form form NN 37231 2571 13 like like IN 37231 2571 14 that that DT 37231 2571 15 quoted quote VBD 37231 2571 16 in in IN 37231 2571 17 the the DT 37231 2571 18 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2571 19 before before IN 37231 2571 20 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2571 21 more more RBR 37231 2571 22 than than IN 37231 2571 23 probable probable JJ 37231 2571 24 . . . 37231 2572 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2572 2 , , , 37231 2572 3 in in IN 37231 2572 4 a a DT 37231 2572 5 note note NN 37231 2572 6 to to IN 37231 2572 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2572 8 statement statement NN 37231 2572 9 that that IN 37231 2572 10 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2572 11 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 2572 12 refers refer VBZ 37231 2572 13 to to IN 37231 2572 14 the the DT 37231 2572 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2572 16 , , , 37231 2572 17 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2572 18 the the DT 37231 2572 19 passage passage NN 37231 2572 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2572 21 are be VBP 37231 2572 22 now now RB 37231 2572 23 considering consider VBG 37231 2572 24 , , , 37231 2572 25 the the DT 37231 2572 26 only only JJ 37231 2572 27 one one CD 37231 2572 28 to to TO 37231 2572 29 which which WDT 37231 2572 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2572 31 alludes allude VBZ 37231 2572 32 , , , 37231 2572 33 and and CC 37231 2572 34 says say VBZ 37231 2572 35 : : : 37231 2572 36 " " `` 37231 2572 37 These these DT 37231 2572 38 words word NNS 37231 2572 39 are be VBP 37231 2572 40 expressly expressly RB 37231 2572 41 cited cite VBN 37231 2572 42 as as IN 37231 2572 43 ' ' `` 37231 2572 44 words word NNS 37231 2572 45 of of IN 37231 2572 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2572 47 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2572 48 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2572 49 ; ; : 37231 2572 50 ' ' '' 37231 2572 51 but but CC 37231 2572 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2572 53 denote denote VBP 37231 2572 54 much much RB 37231 2572 55 more more JJR 37231 2572 56 oral oral JJ 37231 2572 57 apostolic apostolic JJ 37231 2572 58 tradition tradition NN 37231 2572 59 than than IN 37231 2572 60 a a DT 37231 2572 61 use use NN 37231 2572 62 of of IN 37231 2572 63 the the DT 37231 2572 64 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2572 65 passages passage NNS 37231 2572 66 in in IN 37231 2572 67 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2572 68 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2572 69 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 2572 70 . . . 37231 2573 1 24 24 CD 37231 2573 2 , , , 37231 2573 3 xviii xviii NN 37231 2573 4 . . . 37231 2574 1 6 6 LS 37231 2574 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2574 3 and and CC 37231 2574 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2574 5 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2574 6 xvii xvii NN 37231 2574 7 . . . 37231 2575 1 2 2 LS 37231 2575 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2575 3 . . . 37231 2576 1 " " `` 37231 2576 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2576 3 2 2 LS 37231 2576 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2576 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2576 6 is be VBZ 37231 2576 7 now now RB 37231 2576 8 , , , 37231 2576 9 of of IN 37231 2576 10 course course NN 37231 2576 11 , , , 37231 2576 12 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2576 13 to to TO 37231 2576 14 determine determine VB 37231 2576 15 finally finally RB 37231 2576 16 whether whether IN 37231 2576 17 the the DT 37231 2576 18 passage passage NN 37231 2576 19 was be VBD 37231 2576 20 actually actually RB 37231 2576 21 derived derive VBN 37231 2576 22 from from IN 37231 2576 23 tradition tradition NN 37231 2576 24 or or CC 37231 2576 25 from from IN 37231 2576 26 a a DT 37231 2576 27 written write VBN 37231 2576 28 source source NN 37231 2576 29 different different JJ 37231 2576 30 from from IN 37231 2576 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2576 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2576 33 , , , 37231 2576 34 but but CC 37231 2576 35 in in IN 37231 2576 36 either either DT 37231 2576 37 case case NN 37231 2576 38 the the DT 37231 2576 39 fact fact NN 37231 2576 40 is be VBZ 37231 2576 41 , , , 37231 2576 42 that that IN 37231 2576 43 the the DT 37231 2576 44 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2576 45 not not RB 37231 2576 46 only only RB 37231 2576 47 does do VBZ 37231 2576 48 not not RB 37231 2576 49 afford afford VB 37231 2576 50 the the DT 37231 2576 51 slightest slight JJS 37231 2576 52 evidence evidence NN 37231 2576 53 for for IN 37231 2576 54 the the DT 37231 2576 55 existence existence NN 37231 2576 56 of of IN 37231 2576 57 any any DT 37231 2576 58 of of IN 37231 2576 59 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2576 60 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2576 61 , , , 37231 2576 62 but but CC 37231 2576 63 from from IN 37231 2576 64 only only RB 37231 2576 65 making make VBG 37231 2576 66 use use NN 37231 2576 67 of of IN 37231 2576 68 tradition tradition NN 37231 2576 69 or or CC 37231 2576 70 an an DT 37231 2576 71 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2576 72 work work NN 37231 2576 73 as as IN 37231 2576 74 the the DT 37231 2576 75 source source NN 37231 2576 76 of of IN 37231 2576 77 information information NN 37231 2576 78 regarding regard VBG 37231 2576 79 words word NNS 37231 2576 80 of of IN 37231 2576 81 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2576 82 , , , 37231 2576 83 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2576 84 is be VBZ 37231 2576 85 decidedly decidedly RB 37231 2576 86 opposed opposed JJ 37231 2576 87 to to IN 37231 2576 88 the the DT 37231 2576 89 pretensions pretension NNS 37231 2576 90 made make VBN 37231 2576 91 on on IN 37231 2576 92 behalf behalf NN 37231 2576 93 of of IN 37231 2576 94 the the DT 37231 2576 95 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2576 96 . . . 37231 2577 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2577 2 231 231 CD 37231 2577 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2577 4 Before before IN 37231 2577 5 passing pass VBG 37231 2577 6 on on RP 37231 2577 7 , , , 37231 2577 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2577 9 may may MD 37231 2577 10 , , , 37231 2577 11 in in IN 37231 2577 12 the the DT 37231 2577 13 briefest brief JJS 37231 2577 14 way way NN 37231 2577 15 possible possible JJ 37231 2577 16 , , , 37231 2577 17 refer refer VBP 37231 2577 18 to to IN 37231 2577 19 one one CD 37231 2577 20 or or CC 37231 2577 21 two two CD 37231 2577 22 other other JJ 37231 2577 23 passages passage NNS 37231 2577 24 , , , 37231 2577 25 with with IN 37231 2577 26 the the DT 37231 2577 27 view view NN 37231 2577 28 of of IN 37231 2577 29 further further RB 37231 2577 30 illustrating illustrate VBG 37231 2577 31 the the DT 37231 2577 32 character character NN 37231 2577 33 of of IN 37231 2577 34 the the DT 37231 2577 35 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2577 36 in in IN 37231 2577 37 this this DT 37231 2577 38 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2577 39 . . . 37231 2578 1 There there EX 37231 2578 2 are be VBP 37231 2578 3 many many JJ 37231 2578 4 passages passage NNS 37231 2578 5 cited cite VBN 37231 2578 6 which which WDT 37231 2578 7 are be VBP 37231 2578 8 not not RB 37231 2578 9 found find VBN 37231 2578 10 in in IN 37231 2578 11 the the DT 37231 2578 12 Old Old NNP 37231 2578 13 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2578 14 , , , 37231 2578 15 and and CC 37231 2578 16 others other NNS 37231 2578 17 which which WDT 37231 2578 18 have have VBP 37231 2578 19 no no DT 37231 2578 20 parallels parallel NNS 37231 2578 21 in in IN 37231 2578 22 the the DT 37231 2578 23 New New NNP 37231 2578 24 . . . 37231 2579 1 At at IN 37231 2579 2 the the DT 37231 2579 3 beginning beginning NN 37231 2579 4 of of IN 37231 2579 5 the the DT 37231 2579 6 very very JJ 37231 2579 7 chapter chapter NN 37231 2579 8 in in IN 37231 2579 9 which which WDT 37231 2579 10 the the DT 37231 2579 11 words word NNS 37231 2579 12 which which WDT 37231 2579 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2579 14 have have VBP 37231 2579 15 just just RB 37231 2579 16 been be VBN 37231 2579 17 considering consider VBG 37231 2579 18 occur occur VBP 37231 2579 19 , , , 37231 2579 20 there there EX 37231 2579 21 is be VBZ 37231 2579 22 the the DT 37231 2579 23 following following JJ 37231 2579 24 quotation quotation NN 37231 2579 25 : : : 37231 2579 26 " " `` 37231 2579 27 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2579 28 - - , 37231 2579 29 is be VBZ 37231 2579 30 written write VBN 37231 2579 31 : : : 37231 2579 32 Cleave cleave VB 37231 2579 33 to to IN 37231 2579 34 the the DT 37231 2579 35 holy holy JJ 37231 2579 36 , , , 37231 2579 37 for for IN 37231 2579 38 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2579 39 who who WP 37231 2579 40 cleave cleave VBP 37231 2579 41 to to IN 37231 2579 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2579 43 shall shall MD 37231 2579 44 be be VB 37231 2579 45 made make VBN 37231 2579 46 holy,"(1 holy,"(1 ADD 37231 2579 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2579 48 the the DT 37231 2579 49 source source NN 37231 2579 50 of of IN 37231 2579 51 which which WDT 37231 2579 52 is be VBZ 37231 2579 53 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2579 54 . . . 37231 2580 1 In in IN 37231 2580 2 a a DT 37231 2580 3 previous previous JJ 37231 2580 4 chapter chapter NN 37231 2580 5 the the DT 37231 2580 6 writer writer NN 37231 2580 7 says say VBZ 37231 2580 8 : : : 37231 2580 9 " " `` 37231 2580 10 And and CC 37231 2580 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2580 12 Apostles Apostles NNP 37231 2580 13 knew know VBD 37231 2580 14 , , , 37231 2580 15 through through IN 37231 2580 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2580 17 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2580 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2580 19 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2580 20 , , , 37231 2580 21 that that IN 37231 2580 22 there there EX 37231 2580 23 will will MD 37231 2580 24 be be VB 37231 2580 25 contention contention NN 37231 2580 26 regarding regard VBG 37231 2580 27 the the DT 37231 2580 28 name name NN 37231 2580 29 , , , 37231 2580 30 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2580 31 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2580 32 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2580 33 , , , 37231 2580 34 office office NN 37231 2580 35 , , , 37231 2580 36 dignity dignity NN 37231 2580 37 ? ? . 37231 2580 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2581 1 of of IN 37231 2581 2 the the DT 37231 2581 3 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 2581 4 . . . 37231 2582 1 " " `` 37231 2582 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2582 3 2 2 LS 37231 2582 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2582 5 What what WP 37231 2582 6 was be VBD 37231 2582 7 the the DT 37231 2582 8 writers writer NNS 37231 2582 9 authority authority NN 37231 2582 10 for for IN 37231 2582 11 this this DT 37231 2582 12 statement statement NN 37231 2582 13 ? ? . 37231 2583 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2583 2 find find VBP 37231 2583 3 Justin Justin NNP 37231 2583 4 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 2583 5 quoting quoting NN 37231 2583 6 , , , 37231 2583 7 as as IN 37231 2583 8 an an DT 37231 2583 9 express express JJ 37231 2583 10 prediction prediction NN 37231 2583 11 of of IN 37231 2583 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2583 13 : : : 37231 2583 14 " " `` 37231 2583 15 There there EX 37231 2583 16 shall shall MD 37231 2583 17 be be VB 37231 2583 18 schisms schism NNS 37231 2583 19 and and CC 37231 2583 20 heresies,"(3 heresies,"(3 ADD 37231 2583 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2583 22 which which WDT 37231 2583 23 is be VBZ 37231 2583 24 not not RB 37231 2583 25 contained contain VBN 37231 2583 26 in in IN 37231 2583 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2583 28 gospels gospel NNS 37231 2583 29 , , , 37231 2583 30 but but CC 37231 2583 31 evidently evidently RB 37231 2583 32 derived derive VBN 37231 2583 33 from from IN 37231 2583 34 an an DT 37231 2583 35 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 37231 2583 36 source,(4 source,(4 NN 37231 2583 37 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2583 38 a a DT 37231 2583 39 fact fact NN 37231 2583 40 rendered render VBD 37231 2583 41 more more RBR 37231 2583 42 apparent apparent JJ 37231 2583 43 by by IN 37231 2583 44 the the DT 37231 2583 45 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 2583 46 of of IN 37231 2583 47 a a DT 37231 2583 48 similar similar JJ 37231 2583 49 passage passage NN 37231 2583 50 in in IN 37231 2583 51 the the DT 37231 2583 52 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 2583 53 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 2583 54 , , , 37231 2583 55 still still RB 37231 2583 56 more more RBR 37231 2583 57 closely closely RB 37231 2583 58 bearing bear VBG 37231 2583 59 upon upon IN 37231 2583 60 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2583 61 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2583 62 : : : 37231 2583 63 " " `` 37231 2583 64 For for IN 37231 2583 65 there there EX 37231 2583 66 shall shall MD 37231 2583 67 be be VB 37231 2583 68 , , , 37231 2583 69 as as IN 37231 2583 70 the the DT 37231 2583 71 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2583 72 said say VBD 37231 2583 73 , , , 37231 2583 74 false false JJ 37231 2583 75 apostles apostle NNS 37231 2583 76 , , , 37231 2583 77 false false JJ 37231 2583 78 prophets prophet NNS 37231 2583 79 , , , 37231 2583 80 heresies heresy NNS 37231 2583 81 , , , 37231 2583 82 desires desire NNS 37231 2583 83 for for IN 37231 2583 84 supremacy supremacy NN 37231 2583 85 . . . 37231 2584 1 " " `` 37231 2584 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2584 3 5 5 LS 37231 2584 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2584 5 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 2584 6 also also RB 37231 2584 7 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2584 8 in in IN 37231 2584 9 a a DT 37231 2584 10 similar similar JJ 37231 2584 11 way way NN 37231 2584 12 : : : 37231 2584 13 " " `` 37231 2584 14 From from IN 37231 2584 15 these these DT 37231 2584 16 came come VBD 37231 2584 17 the the DT 37231 2584 18 { { -LRB- 37231 2584 19 232 232 CD 37231 2584 20 } } -RRB- 37231 2584 21 false false JJ 37231 2584 22 Christs Christs NNPS 37231 2584 23 , , , 37231 2584 24 false false JJ 37231 2584 25 prophets prophet NNS 37231 2584 26 , , , 37231 2584 27 false false JJ 37231 2584 28 apostles apostle NNS 37231 2584 29 who who WP 37231 2584 30 divided divide VBD 37231 2584 31 the the DT 37231 2584 32 unity unity NN 37231 2584 33 of of IN 37231 2584 34 the the DT 37231 2584 35 Church Church NNP 37231 2584 36 . . . 37231 2585 1 " " `` 37231 2585 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2585 3 l l NN 37231 2585 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2585 5 As as IN 37231 2585 6 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 2585 7 , , , 37231 2585 8 and and CC 37231 2585 9 in in IN 37231 2585 10 all all DT 37231 2585 11 probability probability NN 37231 2585 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 2585 13 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 2585 14 , , , 37231 2585 15 and and CC 37231 2585 16 the the DT 37231 2585 17 author author NN 37231 2585 18 of of IN 37231 2585 19 the the DT 37231 2585 20 Clementines Clementines NNPS 37231 2585 21 made make VBD 37231 2585 22 use use NN 37231 2585 23 of of IN 37231 2585 24 the the DT 37231 2585 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2585 26 according accord VBG 37231 2585 27 to to IN 37231 2585 28 the the DT 37231 2585 29 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 2585 30 , , , 37231 2585 31 or or CC 37231 2585 32 to to IN 37231 2585 33 Peter Peter NNP 37231 2585 34 , , , 37231 2585 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2585 36 is be VBZ 37231 2585 37 most most RBS 37231 2585 38 probable probable JJ 37231 2585 39 that that IN 37231 2585 40 these these DT 37231 2585 41 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2585 42 contained contain VBD 37231 2585 43 passages passage NNS 37231 2585 44 to to TO 37231 2585 45 which which WDT 37231 2585 46 the the DT 37231 2585 47 words word NNS 37231 2585 48 of of IN 37231 2585 49 the the DT 37231 2585 50 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2585 51 may may MD 37231 2585 52 refer refer VB 37231 2585 53 . . . 37231 2586 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2586 2 2 2 LS 37231 2586 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2586 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2586 5 may may MD 37231 2586 6 be be VB 37231 2586 7 well well JJ 37231 2586 8 to to TO 37231 2586 9 point point VB 37231 2586 10 out out RP 37231 2586 11 that that IN 37231 2586 12 the the DT 37231 2586 13 author author NN 37231 2586 14 also also RB 37231 2586 15 cites cite VBZ 37231 2586 16 a a DT 37231 2586 17 passage passage NN 37231 2586 18 from from IN 37231 2586 19 the the DT 37231 2586 20 Fourth Fourth NNP 37231 2586 21 Book Book NNP 37231 2586 22 of of IN 37231 2586 23 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2586 24 , , , 37231 2586 25 ii ii NNP 37231 2586 26 . . . 37231 2587 1 16:(3 16:(3 LS 37231 2587 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2587 3 " " `` 37231 2587 4 And and CC 37231 2587 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2587 6 shall shall MD 37231 2587 7 remember remember VB 37231 2587 8 the the DT 37231 2587 9 good good JJ 37231 2587 10 day day NN 37231 2587 11 , , , 37231 2587 12 and and CC 37231 2587 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2587 14 shall shall MD 37231 2587 15 raise raise VB 37231 2587 16 you -PRON- PRP 37231 2587 17 from from IN 37231 2587 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2587 19 tombs tomb NNS 37231 2587 20 . . . 37231 2588 1 " " `` 37231 2588 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2588 3 4 4 LS 37231 2588 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2588 5 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2588 6 reads read VBZ 37231 2588 7 : : : 37231 2588 8 " " `` 37231 2588 9 Et et NN 37231 2588 10 resuscitabo resuscitabo NNS 37231 2588 11 mor mor NN 37231 2588 12 - - HYPH 37231 2588 13 tuos tuos NNP 37231 2588 14 de de FW 37231 2588 15 locis locis NNP 37231 2588 16 suis suis NNP 37231 2588 17 et et NNP 37231 2588 18 de de NNP 37231 2588 19 monumentis monumentis NNP 37231 2588 20 educam educam NNP 37231 2588 21 illos illos NNP 37231 2588 22 , , , 37231 2588 23 " " '' 37231 2588 24 & & CC 37231 2588 25 c. c. NNP 37231 2588 26 The the DT 37231 2588 27 first first JJ 37231 2588 28 part part NN 37231 2588 29 of of IN 37231 2588 30 the the DT 37231 2588 31 quotation quotation NN 37231 2588 32 in in IN 37231 2588 33 the the DT 37231 2588 34 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2588 35 , , , 37231 2588 36 of of IN 37231 2588 37 which which WDT 37231 2588 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2588 39 have have VBP 37231 2588 40 only only RB 37231 2588 41 given give VBN 37231 2588 42 the the DT 37231 2588 43 latter latter JJ 37231 2588 44 clause clause NN 37231 2588 45 above above RB 37231 2588 46 , , , 37231 2588 47 is be VBZ 37231 2588 48 taken take VBN 37231 2588 49 from from IN 37231 2588 50 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 37231 2588 51 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 2588 52 . . . 37231 2589 1 20 20 CD 37231 2589 2 , , , 37231 2589 3 but but CC 37231 2589 4 there there EX 37231 2589 5 can can MD 37231 2589 6 be be VB 37231 2589 7 no no DT 37231 2589 8 doubt doubt NN 37231 2589 9 that that IN 37231 2589 10 the the DT 37231 2589 11 above above JJ 37231 2589 12 is be VBZ 37231 2589 13 from from IN 37231 2589 14 this this DT 37231 2589 15 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2589 16 book,(5 book,(5 NNP 37231 2589 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2589 18 which which WDT 37231 2589 19 , , , 37231 2589 20 as as IN 37231 2589 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2589 22 shall shall MD 37231 2589 23 see see VB 37231 2589 24 , , , 37231 2589 25 was be VBD 37231 2589 26 much much RB 37231 2589 27 used use VBN 37231 2589 28 in in IN 37231 2589 29 the the DT 37231 2589 30 early early JJ 37231 2589 31 Church Church NNP 37231 2589 32 . . . 37231 2590 1 2 2 LS 37231 2590 2 . . . 37231 2591 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2591 2 now now RB 37231 2591 3 turn turn VBP 37231 2591 4 to to IN 37231 2591 5 the the DT 37231 2591 6 so so RB 37231 2591 7 - - HYPH 37231 2591 8 called call VBN 37231 2591 9 " " `` 37231 2591 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2591 11 of of IN 37231 2591 12 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2591 13 , , , 37231 2591 14 " " '' 37231 2591 15 another another DT 37231 2591 16 interesting interesting JJ 37231 2591 17 relic relic NN 37231 2591 18 of of IN 37231 2591 19 the the DT 37231 2591 20 early early JJ 37231 2591 21 Church Church NNP 37231 2591 22 , , , 37231 2591 23 many many JJ 37231 2591 24 points point NNS 37231 2591 25 in in IN 37231 2591 26 whose whose WP$ 37231 2591 27 history history NN 37231 2591 28 have have VBP 37231 2591 29 considerable considerable JJ 37231 2591 30 analogy analogy NN 37231 2591 31 with with IN 37231 2591 32 that that DT 37231 2591 33 of of IN 37231 2591 34 the the DT 37231 2591 35 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2591 36 of of IN 37231 2591 37 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 2591 38 - - NNP 37231 2591 39 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2591 40 . . . 37231 2592 1 The the DT 37231 2592 2 letter letter NN 37231 2592 3 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2592 4 bears bear VBZ 37231 2592 5 no no DT 37231 2592 6 author author NN 37231 2592 7 's 's POS 37231 2592 8 name name NN 37231 2592 9 , , , 37231 2592 10 is be VBZ 37231 2592 11 not not RB 37231 2592 12 dated date VBN 37231 2592 13 from from IN 37231 2592 14 any any DT 37231 2592 15 place place NN 37231 2592 16 , , , 37231 2592 17 and and CC 37231 2592 18 is be VBZ 37231 2592 19 not not RB 37231 2592 20 addressed address VBN 37231 2592 21 to to IN 37231 2592 22 any any DT 37231 2592 23 special special JJ 37231 2592 24 community community NN 37231 2592 25 . . . 37231 2593 1 Towards towards IN 37231 2593 2 the the DT 37231 2593 3 { { -LRB- 37231 2593 4 233 233 CD 37231 2593 5 } } -RRB- 37231 2593 6 end end NN 37231 2593 7 of of IN 37231 2593 8 the the DT 37231 2593 9 second second JJ 37231 2593 10 century century NN 37231 2593 11 , , , 37231 2593 12 however however RB 37231 2593 13 , , , 37231 2593 14 tradition tradition NN 37231 2593 15 began begin VBD 37231 2593 16 to to TO 37231 2593 17 ascribe ascribe VB 37231 2593 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2593 19 to to IN 37231 2593 20 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2593 21 the the DT 37231 2593 22 companion companion NN 37231 2593 23 of of IN 37231 2593 24 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2593 25 . . . 37231 2594 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2594 2 1 1 LS 37231 2594 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2594 4 The the DT 37231 2594 5 first first JJ 37231 2594 6 writer writer NN 37231 2594 7 who who WP 37231 2594 8 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2594 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2594 10 is be VBZ 37231 2594 11 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2594 12 of of IN 37231 2594 13 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 2594 14 , , , 37231 2594 15 who who WP 37231 2594 16 calls call VBZ 37231 2594 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2594 18 author author NN 37231 2594 19 several several JJ 37231 2594 20 times time NNS 37231 2594 21 the the DT 37231 2594 22 " " `` 37231 2594 23 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2594 24 Barnabas;"(2 Barnabas;"(2 NNP 37231 2594 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2594 26 and and CC 37231 2594 27 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2594 28 says say VBZ 37231 2594 29 that that IN 37231 2594 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2594 31 gave give VBD 37231 2594 32 an an DT 37231 2594 33 account account NN 37231 2594 34 of of IN 37231 2594 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2594 36 in in IN 37231 2594 37 one one CD 37231 2594 38 of of IN 37231 2594 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2594 40 works work NNS 37231 2594 41 now now RB 37231 2594 42 no no RB 37231 2594 43 longer long RBR 37231 2594 44 extant extant JJ 37231 2594 45 . . . 37231 2595 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2595 2 3 3 LS 37231 2595 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2595 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2595 5 also also RB 37231 2595 6 refers refer VBZ 37231 2595 7 to to IN 37231 2595 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2595 9 , , , 37231 2595 10 calling call VBG 37231 2595 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2595 12 a a DT 37231 2595 13 " " `` 37231 2595 14 Catholic Catholic NNP 37231 2595 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2595 16 , , , 37231 2595 17 " " '' 37231 2595 18 and and CC 37231 2595 19 quoting quote VBG 37231 2595 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2595 21 as as IN 37231 2595 22 Scripture scripture NN 37231 2595 23 . . . 37231 2596 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2596 2 4 4 LS 37231 2596 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2596 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2596 5 have have VBP 37231 2596 6 already already RB 37231 2596 7 seen see VBN 37231 2596 8 in in IN 37231 2596 9 the the DT 37231 2596 10 case case NN 37231 2596 11 of of IN 37231 2596 12 the the DT 37231 2596 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2596 14 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2596 15 to to IN 37231 2596 16 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2596 17 of of IN 37231 2596 18 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2596 19 , , , 37231 2596 20 and and CC 37231 2596 21 , , , 37231 2596 22 as as IN 37231 2596 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2596 24 proceed proceed VBP 37231 2596 25 , , , 37231 2596 26 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2596 27 shall shall MD 37231 2596 28 become become VB 37231 2596 29 only only RB 37231 2596 30 too too RB 37231 2596 31 familiar familiar JJ 37231 2596 32 with with IN 37231 2596 33 the the DT 37231 2596 34 fact fact NN 37231 2596 35 , , , 37231 2596 36 the the DT 37231 2596 37 singular singular JJ 37231 2596 38 facility facility NN 37231 2596 39 with with IN 37231 2596 40 which which WDT 37231 2596 41 , , , 37231 2596 42 in in IN 37231 2596 43 the the DT 37231 2596 44 total total JJ 37231 2596 45 absence absence NN 37231 2596 46 of of IN 37231 2596 47 critical critical JJ 37231 2596 48 discrimination discrimination NN 37231 2596 49 , , , 37231 2596 50 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2596 51 writings writing NNS 37231 2596 52 were be VBD 37231 2596 53 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2596 54 by by IN 37231 2596 55 the the DT 37231 2596 56 Fathers father NNS 37231 2596 57 to to IN 37231 2596 58 Apostles Apostles NNP 37231 2596 59 and and CC 37231 2596 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2596 61 followers follower NNS 37231 2596 62 . . . 37231 2597 1 In in IN 37231 2597 2 many many JJ 37231 2597 3 cases case NNS 37231 2597 4 such such JJ 37231 2597 5 writings writing NNS 37231 2597 6 were be VBD 37231 2597 7 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 2597 8 inscribed inscribe VBN 37231 2597 9 with with IN 37231 2597 10 names name NNS 37231 2597 11 well well RB 37231 2597 12 known know VBN 37231 2597 13 in in IN 37231 2597 14 the the DT 37231 2597 15 Church Church NNP 37231 2597 16 , , , 37231 2597 17 but but CC 37231 2597 18 both both DT 37231 2597 19 in in IN 37231 2597 20 the the DT 37231 2597 21 case case NN 37231 2597 22 of of IN 37231 2597 23 the the DT 37231 2597 24 two two CD 37231 2597 25 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2597 26 to to IN 37231 2597 27 the the DT 37231 2597 28 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2597 29 , , , 37231 2597 30 and and CC 37231 2597 31 the the DT 37231 2597 32 letter letter NN 37231 2597 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2597 34 are be VBP 37231 2597 35 now now RB 37231 2597 36 considering consider VBG 37231 2597 37 , , , 37231 2597 38 no no DT 37231 2597 39 such such JJ 37231 2597 40 pious pious JJ 37231 2597 41 fraud fraud NN 37231 2597 42 was be VBD 37231 2597 43 attempted attempt VBN 37231 2597 44 , , , 37231 2597 45 nor nor CC 37231 2597 46 was be VBD 37231 2597 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2597 48 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2597 49 . . . 37231 2598 1 Credulous credulous JJ 37231 2598 2 piety piety NN 37231 2598 3 , , , 37231 2598 4 which which WDT 37231 2598 5 attributed attribute VBD 37231 2598 6 writings writing NNS 37231 2598 7 to to IN 37231 2598 8 every every DT 37231 2598 9 Apostle apostle NN 37231 2598 10 , , , 37231 2598 11 and and CC 37231 2598 12 even even RB 37231 2598 13 to to IN 37231 2598 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2598 15 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2598 16 , , , 37231 2598 17 soon soon RB 37231 2598 18 found find VBD 37231 2598 19 authors author NNS 37231 2598 20 for for IN 37231 2598 21 each each DT 37231 2598 22 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 2598 23 work work NN 37231 2598 24 of of IN 37231 2598 25 an an DT 37231 2598 26 edifying edifying NN 37231 2598 27 character character NN 37231 2598 28 . . . 37231 2599 1 To to IN 37231 2599 2 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2599 3 , , , 37231 2599 4 the the DT 37231 2599 5 friend friend NN 37231 2599 6 of of IN 37231 2599 7 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2599 8 , , , 37231 2599 9 not not RB 37231 2599 10 only only RB 37231 2599 11 this this DT 37231 2599 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2599 13 was be VBD 37231 2599 14 referred refer VBN 37231 2599 15 , , , 37231 2599 16 but but CC 37231 2599 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2599 18 was be VBD 37231 2599 19 also also RB 37231 2599 20 reported report VBN 37231 2599 21 by by IN 37231 2599 22 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 2599 23 and and CC 37231 2599 24 others other NNS 37231 2599 25 to to TO 37231 2599 26 be be VB 37231 2599 27 the the DT 37231 2599 28 author author NN 37231 2599 29 of of IN 37231 2599 30 the the DT 37231 2599 31 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2599 32 to to IN 37231 2599 33 the the DT 37231 2599 34 Hebrews;(5 Hebrews;(5 NNP 37231 2599 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2599 36 and and CC 37231 2599 37 an an DT 37231 2599 38 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2599 39 " " `` 37231 2599 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2599 41 according accord VBG 37231 2599 42 to to IN 37231 2599 43 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2599 44 , , , 37231 2599 45 " " '' 37231 2599 46 said say VBD 37231 2599 47 to to TO 37231 2599 48 have have VB 37231 2599 49 had have VBN 37231 2599 50 close close JJ 37231 2599 51 affinity affinity NN 37231 2599 52 with with IN 37231 2599 53 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2599 54 { { -LRB- 37231 2599 55 234 234 CD 37231 2599 56 } } -RRB- 37231 2599 57 first first JJ 37231 2599 58 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2599 59 , , , 37231 2599 60 is be VBZ 37231 2599 61 condemned condemn VBN 37231 2599 62 along along IN 37231 2599 63 with with IN 37231 2599 64 many many JJ 37231 2599 65 others other NNS 37231 2599 66 in in IN 37231 2599 67 the the DT 37231 2599 68 decretal decretal NN 37231 2599 69 of of IN 37231 2599 70 Gelasius Gelasius NNP 37231 2599 71 . . . 37231 2600 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2600 2 1 1 LS 37231 2600 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2600 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 2600 5 , , , 37231 2600 6 however however RB 37231 2600 7 , , , 37231 2600 8 classes class VBZ 37231 2600 9 the the DT 37231 2600 10 so so RB 37231 2600 11 - - HYPH 37231 2600 12 called call VBN 37231 2600 13 " " `` 37231 2600 14 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2600 15 of of IN 37231 2600 16 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2600 17 " " '' 37231 2600 18 amongst amongst IN 37231 2600 19 the the DT 37231 2600 20 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2600 21 books book NNS 37231 2600 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2600 23 --Greek--],(2 --Greek--],(2 NFP 37231 2600 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2600 25 and and CC 37231 2600 26 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2600 27 also also RB 37231 2600 28 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2600 29 of of IN 37231 2600 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2600 31 as as IN 37231 2600 32 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 37231 2600 33 . . . 37231 2601 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2601 2 3 3 LS 37231 2601 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2601 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2601 5 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2601 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2601 7 as as IN 37231 2601 8 read read VBN 37231 2601 9 amongst amongst IN 37231 2601 10 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2601 11 writings writing NNS 37231 2601 12 . . . 37231 2602 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2602 2 4 4 LS 37231 2602 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2602 4 Had have VBD 37231 2602 5 the the DT 37231 2602 6 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2602 7 been be VBN 37231 2602 8 seriously seriously RB 37231 2602 9 regarded regard VBN 37231 2602 10 as as IN 37231 2602 11 a a DT 37231 2602 12 work work NN 37231 2602 13 of of IN 37231 2602 14 the the DT 37231 2602 15 " " `` 37231 2602 16 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2602 17 " " '' 37231 2602 18 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2602 19 , , , 37231 2602 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2602 21 could could MD 37231 2602 22 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2602 23 have have VB 37231 2602 24 failed fail VBN 37231 2602 25 to to TO 37231 2602 26 attain attain VB 37231 2602 27 canonical canonical JJ 37231 2602 28 rank rank NN 37231 2602 29 . . . 37231 2603 1 That that IN 37231 2603 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2603 3 was be VBD 37231 2603 4 highly highly RB 37231 2603 5 valued value VBN 37231 2603 6 by by IN 37231 2603 7 the the DT 37231 2603 8 early early JJ 37231 2603 9 Church Church NNP 37231 2603 10 is be VBZ 37231 2603 11 shown show VBN 37231 2603 12 by by IN 37231 2603 13 the the DT 37231 2603 14 fact fact NN 37231 2603 15 that that IN 37231 2603 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2603 17 stands stand VBZ 37231 2603 18 , , , 37231 2603 19 along along IN 37231 2603 20 with with IN 37231 2603 21 the the DT 37231 2603 22 Pastor Pastor NNP 37231 2603 23 of of IN 37231 2603 24 Hermas Hermas NNP 37231 2603 25 , , , 37231 2603 26 after after IN 37231 2603 27 the the DT 37231 2603 28 Canonical canonical JJ 37231 2603 29 books book NNS 37231 2603 30 of of IN 37231 2603 31 the the DT 37231 2603 32 New New NNP 37231 2603 33 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2603 34 in in IN 37231 2603 35 the the DT 37231 2603 36 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2603 37 Sinaiticus Sinaiticus NNP 37231 2603 38 , , , 37231 2603 39 which which WDT 37231 2603 40 is be VBZ 37231 2603 41 probably probably RB 37231 2603 42 the the DT 37231 2603 43 most most RBS 37231 2603 44 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2603 45 MS MS NNP 37231 2603 46 . . . 37231 2603 47 of of IN 37231 2603 48 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2603 49 now now RB 37231 2603 50 known know VBN 37231 2603 51 . . . 37231 2604 1 In in IN 37231 2604 2 the the DT 37231 2604 3 earlier early JJR 37231 2604 4 days day NNS 37231 2604 5 of of IN 37231 2604 6 criticism criticism NN 37231 2604 7 , , , 37231 2604 8 some some DT 37231 2604 9 writers writer NNS 37231 2604 10 , , , 37231 2604 11 without without IN 37231 2604 12 much much JJ 37231 2604 13 question question NN 37231 2604 14 , , , 37231 2604 15 adopted adopt VBD 37231 2604 16 the the DT 37231 2604 17 traditional traditional JJ 37231 2604 18 view view NN 37231 2604 19 as as IN 37231 2604 20 to to IN 37231 2604 21 the the DT 37231 2604 22 authorship authorship NN 37231 2604 23 of of IN 37231 2604 24 the the DT 37231 2604 25 Epistle,(5 epistle,(5 NN 37231 2604 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2604 27 but but CC 37231 2604 28 the the DT 37231 2604 29 great great JJ 37231 2604 30 mass mass NN 37231 2604 31 of of IN 37231 2604 32 critics critic NNS 37231 2604 33 are be VBP 37231 2604 34 now now RB 37231 2604 35 agreed agree VBN 37231 2604 36 in in IN 37231 2604 37 asserting assert VBG 37231 2604 38 that that IN 37231 2604 39 the the DT 37231 2604 40 composition composition NN 37231 2604 41 , , , 37231 2604 42 which which WDT 37231 2604 43 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2604 44 is be VBZ 37231 2604 45 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2604 46 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 2604 47 , , , 37231 2604 48 can can MD 37231 2604 49 not not RB 37231 2604 50 be be VB 37231 2604 51 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2604 52 to to IN 37231 2604 53 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2604 54 the the DT 37231 2604 55 friend friend NN 37231 2604 56 and and CC 37231 2604 57 fellow fellow NN 37231 2604 58 - - HYPH 37231 2604 59 worker worker NN 37231 2604 60 of of IN 37231 2604 61 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2604 62 . . . 37231 2605 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2605 2 6 6 LS 37231 2605 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2605 4 Those those DT 37231 2605 5 who who WP 37231 2605 6 maintain maintain VBP 37231 2605 7 the the DT 37231 2605 8 former former JJ 37231 2605 9 opinion opinion NN 37231 2605 10 date date NN 37231 2605 11 { { -LRB- 37231 2605 12 235 235 CD 37231 2605 13 } } -RRB- 37231 2605 14 the the DT 37231 2605 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2605 16 about about IN 37231 2605 17 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2605 18 . . NNP 37231 2605 19 70 70 CD 37231 2605 20 - - HYPH 37231 2605 21 -73 -73 NNP 37231 2605 22 , , , 37231 2605 23 or or CC 37231 2605 24 even even RB 37231 2605 25 earlier early RBR 37231 2605 26 , , , 37231 2605 27 but but CC 37231 2605 28 this this DT 37231 2605 29 is be VBZ 37231 2605 30 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2605 31 the the DT 37231 2605 32 view view NN 37231 2605 33 of of IN 37231 2605 34 any any DT 37231 2605 35 living live VBG 37231 2605 36 critic critic NN 37231 2605 37 . . . 37231 2606 1 There there EX 37231 2606 2 are be VBP 37231 2606 3 many many JJ 37231 2606 4 indications indication NNS 37231 2606 5 in in IN 37231 2606 6 the the DT 37231 2606 7 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2606 8 which which WDT 37231 2606 9 render render VBP 37231 2606 10 such such PDT 37231 2606 11 a a DT 37231 2606 12 date date NN 37231 2606 13 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2606 14 , , , 37231 2606 15 but but CC 37231 2606 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2606 17 do do VBP 37231 2606 18 not not RB 37231 2606 19 propose propose VB 37231 2606 20 to to TO 37231 2606 21 go go VB 37231 2606 22 into into IN 37231 2606 23 the the DT 37231 2606 24 argument argument NN 37231 2606 25 minutely minutely RB 37231 2606 26 , , , 37231 2606 27 for for IN 37231 2606 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2606 29 is be VBZ 37231 2606 30 generally generally RB 37231 2606 31 admitted admit VBN 37231 2606 32 that that IN 37231 2606 33 , , , 37231 2606 34 whilst whilst IN 37231 2606 35 there there EX 37231 2606 36 is be VBZ 37231 2606 37 a a DT 37231 2606 38 clear clear JJ 37231 2606 39 limit limit NN 37231 2606 40 further further RB 37231 2606 41 back back RB 37231 2606 42 than than IN 37231 2606 43 which which WDT 37231 2606 44 the the DT 37231 2606 45 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2606 46 can can MD 37231 2606 47 not not RB 37231 2606 48 be be VB 37231 2606 49 set,(1 set,(1 CD 37231 2606 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2606 51 there there EX 37231 2606 52 is be VBZ 37231 2606 53 little little JJ 37231 2606 54 or or CC 37231 2606 55 no no DT 37231 2606 56 certainty certainty NN 37231 2606 57 how how WRB 37231 2606 58 far far RB 37231 2606 59 into into IN 37231 2606 60 the the DT 37231 2606 61 second second JJ 37231 2606 62 century century NN 37231 2606 63 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2606 64 composition composition NN 37231 2606 65 may may MD 37231 2606 66 not not RB 37231 2606 67 reasonably reasonably RB 37231 2606 68 be be VB 37231 2606 69 advanced advance VBN 37231 2606 70 . . . 37231 2607 1 Critics critic NNS 37231 2607 2 are be VBP 37231 2607 3 divided divide VBN 37231 2607 4 upon upon IN 37231 2607 5 the the DT 37231 2607 6 point point NN 37231 2607 7 ; ; : 37231 2607 8 a a DT 37231 2607 9 few few JJ 37231 2607 10 are be VBP 37231 2607 11 disposed dispose VBN 37231 2607 12 to to IN 37231 2607 13 date date NN 37231 2607 14 the the DT 37231 2607 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2607 16 about about IN 37231 2607 17 the the DT 37231 2607 18 end end NN 37231 2607 19 of of IN 37231 2607 20 the the DT 37231 2607 21 first first JJ 37231 2607 22 or or CC 37231 2607 23 beginning beginning NN 37231 2607 24 of of IN 37231 2607 25 the the DT 37231 2607 26 second second JJ 37231 2607 27 century century NN 37231 2607 28 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2607 29 2 2 CD 37231 2607 30 } } -RRB- 37231 2607 31 while while IN 37231 2607 32 a a DT 37231 2607 33 still still RB 37231 2607 34 greater great JJR 37231 2607 35 number number NN 37231 2607 36 assign assign VB 37231 2607 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2607 38 to to IN 37231 2607 39 the the DT 37231 2607 40 reign reign NN 37231 2607 41 of of IN 37231 2607 42 Hadrian Hadrian NNP 37231 2607 43 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2607 44 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2607 45 . . NNP 37231 2607 46 { { -LRB- 37231 2607 47 236 236 CD 37231 2607 48 } } -RRB- 37231 2607 49 117 117 CD 37231 2607 50 - - HYPH 37231 2607 51 -138);(1 -138);(1 NN 37231 2607 52 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2607 53 and and CC 37231 2607 54 others other NNS 37231 2607 55 , , , 37231 2607 56 not not RB 37231 2607 57 without without IN 37231 2607 58 reason reason NN 37231 2607 59 , , , 37231 2607 60 consider consider VB 37231 2607 61 that that IN 37231 2607 62 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2607 63 exhibits exhibit VBZ 37231 2607 64 marks mark NNS 37231 2607 65 of of IN 37231 2607 66 a a DT 37231 2607 67 still still RB 37231 2607 68 later later JJ 37231 2607 69 period period NN 37231 2607 70 . . . 37231 2608 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2608 2 2 2 LS 37231 2608 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2608 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2608 5 is be VBZ 37231 2608 6 probable probable JJ 37231 2608 7 that that IN 37231 2608 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2608 9 is be VBZ 37231 2608 10 more more RBR 37231 2608 11 or or CC 37231 2608 12 less less RBR 37231 2608 13 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 2608 14 . . . 37231 2609 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2609 2 3 3 LS 37231 2609 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2609 4 Until until IN 37231 2609 5 the the DT 37231 2609 6 discovery discovery NN 37231 2609 7 of of IN 37231 2609 8 the the DT 37231 2609 9 Sinaitic Sinaitic NNP 37231 2609 10 MS MS NNP 37231 2609 11 . . NNP 37231 2609 12 , , , 37231 2609 13 a a DT 37231 2609 14 portion portion NN 37231 2609 15 of of IN 37231 2609 16 the the DT 37231 2609 17 " " `` 37231 2609 18 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2609 19 of of IN 37231 2609 20 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2609 21 " " '' 37231 2609 22 was be VBD 37231 2609 23 only only RB 37231 2609 24 known know VBN 37231 2609 25 through through IN 37231 2609 26 an an DT 37231 2609 27 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2609 28 Latin Latin NNP 37231 2609 29 version version NN 37231 2609 30 , , , 37231 2609 31 the the DT 37231 2609 32 first first JJ 37231 2609 33 four four CD 37231 2609 34 and and CC 37231 2609 35 a a DT 37231 2609 36 half half NN 37231 2609 37 chapters chapter NNS 37231 2609 38 of of IN 37231 2609 39 the the DT 37231 2609 40 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2609 41 having have VBG 37231 2609 42 been be VBN 37231 2609 43 lost lose VBN 37231 2609 44 . . . 37231 2610 1 The the DT 37231 2610 2 Greek greek JJ 37231 2610 3 text text NN 37231 2610 4 , , , 37231 2610 5 however however RB 37231 2610 6 , , , 37231 2610 7 is be VBZ 37231 2610 8 now now RB 37231 2610 9 complete complete JJ 37231 2610 10 , , , 37231 2610 11 although although IN 37231 2610 12 often often RB 37231 2610 13 very very RB 37231 2610 14 corrupt corrupt JJ 37231 2610 15 . . . 37231 2611 1 The the DT 37231 2611 2 author author NN 37231 2611 3 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2611 4 largely largely RB 37231 2611 5 from from IN 37231 2611 6 the the DT 37231 2611 7 Old Old NNP 37231 2611 8 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2611 9 , , , 37231 2611 10 and and CC 37231 2611 11 also also RB 37231 2611 12 from from IN 37231 2611 13 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2611 14 works work NNS 37231 2611 15 . . . 37231 2612 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2612 2 4 4 LS 37231 2612 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2612 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2612 5 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 2612 6 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2612 7 any any DT 37231 2612 8 book book NN 37231 2612 9 or or CC 37231 2612 10 writer writer NN 37231 2612 11 of of IN 37231 2612 12 the the DT 37231 2612 13 New New NNP 37231 2612 14 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2612 15 , , , 37231 2612 16 and and CC 37231 2612 17 with with IN 37231 2612 18 one one CD 37231 2612 19 asserted assert VBN 37231 2612 20 exception exception NN 37231 2612 21 , , , 37231 2612 22 which which WDT 37231 2612 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2612 24 shall shall MD 37231 2612 25 presently presently RB 37231 2612 26 examine examine VB 37231 2612 27 , , , 37231 2612 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2612 29 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2612 30 no no DT 37231 2612 31 passage passage NN 37231 2612 32 agreeing agree VBG 37231 2612 33 with with IN 37231 2612 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2612 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2612 36 . . . 37231 2613 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2613 2 shall shall MD 37231 2613 3 refer refer VB 37231 2613 4 to to IN 37231 2613 5 these these DT 37231 2613 6 , , , 37231 2613 7 commencing commence VBG 37231 2613 8 at at IN 37231 2613 9 once once RB 37231 2613 10 with with IN 37231 2613 11 the the DT 37231 2613 12 most most RBS 37231 2613 13 important important JJ 37231 2613 14 . . . 37231 2614 1 In in IN 37231 2614 2 the the DT 37231 2614 3 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2614 4 Latin latin JJ 37231 2614 5 translation translation NN 37231 2614 6 of of IN 37231 2614 7 the the DT 37231 2614 8 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2614 9 , , , 37231 2614 10 the the DT 37231 2614 11 only only JJ 37231 2614 12 form form NN 37231 2614 13 , , , 37231 2614 14 as as IN 37231 2614 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2614 16 have have VBP 37231 2614 17 just just RB 37231 2614 18 said say VBN 37231 2614 19 , , , 37231 2614 20 in in IN 37231 2614 21 which which WDT 37231 2614 22 until until IN 37231 2614 23 the the DT 37231 2614 24 discovery discovery NN 37231 2614 25 { { -LRB- 37231 2614 26 237 237 CD 37231 2614 27 } } -RRB- 37231 2614 28 of of IN 37231 2614 29 the the DT 37231 2614 30 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2614 31 Sinaiticus Sinaiticus NNP 37231 2614 32 the the DT 37231 2614 33 first first JJ 37231 2614 34 four four CD 37231 2614 35 and and CC 37231 2614 36 a a DT 37231 2614 37 half half NN 37231 2614 38 chapters chapter NNS 37231 2614 39 were be VBD 37231 2614 40 extant extant JJ 37231 2614 41 , , , 37231 2614 42 the the DT 37231 2614 43 following follow VBG 37231 2614 44 passage passage NN 37231 2614 45 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2614 46 : : : 37231 2614 47 " " `` 37231 2614 48 Adtendamus Adtendamus NNP 37231 2614 49 ergo ergo NNP 37231 2614 50 , , , 37231 2614 51 ne ne NNP 37231 2614 52 forte forte NNP 37231 2614 53 , , , 37231 2614 54 sicut sicut NN 37231 2614 55 scriptum scriptum NN 37231 2614 56 est est NNP 37231 2614 57 , , , 37231 2614 58 multi multi JJ 37231 2614 59 vocati vocati NNP 37231 2614 60 pauci pauci NNP 37231 2614 61 electi electi VBP 37231 2614 62 inveniamur inveniamur RB 37231 2614 63 . . . 37231 2615 1 " " `` 37231 2615 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2615 3 l l NN 37231 2615 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2615 5 " " `` 37231 2615 6 Let let VB 37231 2615 7 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2615 8 , , , 37231 2615 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 2615 10 , , , 37231 2615 11 beware beware VBP 37231 2615 12 lest lest IN 37231 2615 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2615 14 should should MD 37231 2615 15 be be VB 37231 2615 16 found find VBN 37231 2615 17 , , , 37231 2615 18 as as IN 37231 2615 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2615 20 is be VBZ 37231 2615 21 written write VBN 37231 2615 22 : : : 37231 2615 23 Many many DT 37231 2615 24 are be VBP 37231 2615 25 called call VBN 37231 2615 26 , , , 37231 2615 27 few few JJ 37231 2615 28 are be VBP 37231 2615 29 chosen choose VBN 37231 2615 30 . . . 37231 2615 31 " " '' 37231 2616 1 These these DT 37231 2616 2 words word NNS 37231 2616 3 are be VBP 37231 2616 4 found find VBN 37231 2616 5 in in IN 37231 2616 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2616 7 first first JJ 37231 2616 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2616 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2616 10 xxii xxii NNP 37231 2616 11 . . . 37231 2617 1 14 14 CD 37231 2617 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2617 3 , , , 37231 2617 4 and and CC 37231 2617 5 as as IN 37231 2617 6 the the DT 37231 2617 7 formula formula NN 37231 2617 8 by by IN 37231 2617 9 which which WDT 37231 2617 10 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2617 11 are be VBP 37231 2617 12 here here RB 37231 2617 13 introduced--"it introduced--"it NNP 37231 2617 14 is be VBZ 37231 2617 15 written write VBN 37231 2617 16 , , , 37231 2617 17 " " `` 37231 2617 18 is be VBZ 37231 2617 19 generally generally RB 37231 2617 20 understood understand VBN 37231 2617 21 to to TO 37231 2617 22 indicate indicate VB 37231 2617 23 a a DT 37231 2617 24 quotation quotation NN 37231 2617 25 from from IN 37231 2617 26 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2617 27 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2617 28 , , , 37231 2617 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2617 30 was be VBD 37231 2617 31 and and CC 37231 2617 32 is be VBZ 37231 2617 33 argued argue VBN 37231 2617 34 by by IN 37231 2617 35 some some DT 37231 2617 36 that that IN 37231 2617 37 here here RB 37231 2617 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2617 39 have have VBP 37231 2617 40 a a DT 37231 2617 41 passage passage NN 37231 2617 42 from from IN 37231 2617 43 one one CD 37231 2617 44 of of IN 37231 2617 45 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2617 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2617 47 quoted quote VBN 37231 2617 48 in in IN 37231 2617 49 a a DT 37231 2617 50 manner manner NN 37231 2617 51 which which WDT 37231 2617 52 shows show VBZ 37231 2617 53 that that IN 37231 2617 54 , , , 37231 2617 55 at at IN 37231 2617 56 the the DT 37231 2617 57 time time NN 37231 2617 58 the the DT 37231 2617 59 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2617 60 of of IN 37231 2617 61 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2617 62 was be VBD 37231 2617 63 written write VBN 37231 2617 64 , , , 37231 2617 65 the the DT 37231 2617 66 " " `` 37231 2617 67 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2617 68 according accord VBG 37231 2617 69 to to IN 37231 2617 70 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2617 71 was be VBD 37231 2617 72 already already RB 37231 2617 73 considered consider VBN 37231 2617 74 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2617 75 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2617 76 . . . 37231 2618 1 " " `` 37231 2618 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2618 3 3 3 LS 37231 2618 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2618 5 Whilst whilst IN 37231 2618 6 this this DT 37231 2618 7 portion portion NN 37231 2618 8 of of IN 37231 2618 9 the the DT 37231 2618 10 text text NN 37231 2618 11 existed exist VBD 37231 2618 12 only only RB 37231 2618 13 in in IN 37231 2618 14 the the DT 37231 2618 15 Latin Latin NNP 37231 2618 16 version version NN 37231 2618 17 , , , 37231 2618 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2618 19 was be VBD 37231 2618 20 argued argue VBN 37231 2618 21 that that IN 37231 2618 22 the the DT 37231 2618 23 " " `` 37231 2618 24 sicut sicut NN 37231 2618 25 scriptum scriptum NN 37231 2618 26 est est NN 37231 2618 27 , , , 37231 2618 28 " " `` 37231 2618 29 at at IN 37231 2618 30 least least JJS 37231 2618 31 , , , 37231 2618 32 must must MD 37231 2618 33 be be VB 37231 2618 34 an an DT 37231 2618 35 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2618 36 , , , 37231 2618 37 and and CC 37231 2618 38 in in IN 37231 2618 39 any any DT 37231 2618 40 case case NN 37231 2618 41 that that IN 37231 2618 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2618 43 could could MD 37231 2618 44 not not RB 37231 2618 45 be be VB 37231 2618 46 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 2618 47 applied apply VBN 37231 2618 48 , , , 37231 2618 49 at at IN 37231 2618 50 that that DT 37231 2618 51 date date NN 37231 2618 52 , , , 37231 2618 53 to to IN 37231 2618 54 a a DT 37231 2618 55 passage passage NN 37231 2618 56 in in IN 37231 2618 57 any any DT 37231 2618 58 writings writing NNS 37231 2618 59 of of IN 37231 2618 60 the the DT 37231 2618 61 New New NNP 37231 2618 62 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2618 63 . . . 37231 2619 1 On on IN 37231 2619 2 the the DT 37231 2619 3 discovery discovery NN 37231 2619 4 of of IN 37231 2619 5 the the DT 37231 2619 6 Sinaitic Sinaitic NNP 37231 2619 7 MS MS NNP 37231 2619 8 . . NNP 37231 2619 9 , , , 37231 2619 10 however however RB 37231 2619 11 , , , 37231 2619 12 the the DT 37231 2619 13 words word NNS 37231 2619 14 were be VBD 37231 2619 15 found find VBN 37231 2619 16 in in IN 37231 2619 17 the the DT 37231 2619 18 Greek greek JJ 37231 2619 19 text text NN 37231 2619 20 in in IN 37231 2619 21 that that DT 37231 2619 22 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2619 23 : : : 37231 2619 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2619 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2619 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2619 27 . . . 37231 2620 1 The the DT 37231 2620 2 question question NN 37231 2620 3 , , , 37231 2620 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 2620 5 , , , 37231 2620 6 is be VBZ 37231 2620 7 so so RB 37231 2620 8 far far RB 37231 2620 9 modified modify VBN 37231 2620 10 that that IN 37231 2620 11 , , , 37231 2620 12 however however RB 37231 2620 13 much much RB 37231 2620 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2620 15 may may MD 37231 2620 16 suspect suspect VB 37231 2620 17 the the DT 37231 2620 18 Greek greek JJ 37231 2620 19 text text NN 37231 2620 20 of of IN 37231 2620 21 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2620 22 , , , 37231 2620 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2620 24 must must MD 37231 2620 25 be be VB 37231 2620 26 accepted accept VBN 37231 2620 27 as as IN 37231 2620 28 the the DT 37231 2620 29 basis basis NN 37231 2620 30 of of IN 37231 2620 31 discussion discussion NN 37231 2620 32 that that IN 37231 2620 33 this this DT 37231 2620 34 passage passage NN 37231 2620 35 , , , 37231 2620 36 whatever whatever WDT 37231 2620 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2620 38 value value NN 37231 2620 39 , , , 37231 2620 40 exists exist VBZ 37231 2620 41 in in IN 37231 2620 42 the the DT 37231 2620 43 oldest old JJS 37231 2620 44 , , , 37231 2620 45 and and CC 37231 2620 46 indeed indeed RB 37231 2620 47 only only RB 37231 2620 48 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2620 49 and and CC 37231 2620 50 this this DT 37231 2620 51 point point NN 37231 2620 52 must must MD 37231 2620 53 not not RB 37231 2620 54 be be VB 37231 2620 55 forgotten forget VBN 37231 2620 56 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2620 57 complete complete JJ 37231 2620 58 MS MS NNP 37231 2620 59 . . . 37231 2620 60 of of IN 37231 2620 61 the the DT 37231 2620 62 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2620 63 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2620 64 . . . 37231 2621 1 Now now RB 37231 2621 2 with with IN 37231 2621 3 regard regard NN 37231 2621 4 to to IN 37231 2621 5 the the DT 37231 2621 6 value value NN 37231 2621 7 of of IN 37231 2621 8 the the DT 37231 2621 9 expression expression NN 37231 2621 10 " " `` 37231 2621 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2621 12 is be VBZ 37231 2621 13 written write VBN 37231 2621 14 , , , 37231 2621 15 " " `` 37231 2621 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2621 17 may may MD 37231 2621 18 be be VB 37231 2621 19 remarked remark VBN 37231 2621 20 that that IN 37231 2621 21 in in IN 37231 2621 22 no no DT 37231 2621 23 case case NN 37231 2621 24 could could MD 37231 2621 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2621 26 use use NN 37231 2621 27 in in IN 37231 2621 28 the the DT 37231 2621 29 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2621 30 of of IN 37231 2621 31 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2621 32 indicate indicate VBP 37231 2621 33 more more JJR 37231 2621 34 than than IN 37231 2621 35 individual individual JJ 37231 2621 36 opinion opinion NN 37231 2621 37 , , , 37231 2621 38 and and CC 37231 2621 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2621 40 could could MD 37231 2621 41 not not RB 37231 2621 42 , , , 37231 2621 43 for for IN 37231 2621 44 reasons reason NNS 37231 2621 45 to to TO 37231 2621 46 be be VB 37231 2621 47 presently presently RB 37231 2621 48 given give VBN 37231 2621 49 , , , 37231 2621 50 be be VB 37231 2621 51 considered consider VBN 37231 2621 52 to to TO 37231 2621 53 represent represent VB 37231 2621 54 the the DT 37231 2621 55 decision decision NN 37231 2621 56 of of IN 37231 2621 57 the the DT 37231 2621 58 Church Church NNP 37231 2621 59 . . . 37231 2622 1 In in IN 37231 2622 2 the the DT 37231 2622 3 very very RB 37231 2622 4 same same JJ 37231 2622 5 chapter chapter NN 37231 2622 6 in in IN 37231 2622 7 which which WDT 37231 2622 8 the the DT 37231 2622 9 formula formula NN 37231 2622 10 is be VBZ 37231 2622 11 used use VBN 37231 2622 12 in in IN 37231 2622 13 connection connection NN 37231 2622 14 with with IN 37231 2622 15 the the DT 37231 2622 16 passage passage NN 37231 2622 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2622 18 are be VBP 37231 2622 19 considering consider VBG 37231 2622 20 , , , 37231 2622 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2622 22 is be VBZ 37231 2622 23 also also RB 37231 2622 24 employed employ VBN 37231 2622 25 to to TO 37231 2622 26 introduce introduce VB 37231 2622 27 a a DT 37231 2622 28 quotation quotation NN 37231 2622 29 from from IN 37231 2622 30 the the DT 37231 2622 31 Book Book NNP 37231 2622 32 of of IN 37231 2622 33 Enoch,(1 enoch,(1 NN 37231 2622 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2622 35 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2622 36 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2622 37 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2622 38 , , , 37231 2622 39 and and CC 37231 2622 40 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2622 41 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2622 42 c. c. NNP 37231 2623 1 xii xii NNP 37231 2623 2 . . . 37231 2623 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2624 1 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2624 2 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2624 3 from from IN 37231 2624 4 another another DT 37231 2624 5 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2624 6 book(2 book(2 PRP 37231 2624 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2624 8 as as IN 37231 2624 9 one one CD 37231 2624 10 of of IN 37231 2624 11 the the DT 37231 2624 12 prophets prophet NNS 37231 2624 13 . . . 37231 2625 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2625 2 3 3 LS 37231 2625 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2625 4 " " `` 37231 2625 5 Again again RB 37231 2625 6 , , , 37231 2625 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2625 8 refers refer VBZ 37231 2625 9 to to IN 37231 2625 10 the the DT 37231 2625 11 Cross Cross NNP 37231 2625 12 of of IN 37231 2625 13 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2625 14 in in IN 37231 2625 15 another another DT 37231 2625 16 prophet prophet NN 37231 2625 17 saying say VBG 37231 2625 18 : : : 37231 2625 19 ' ' '' 37231 2625 20 And and CC 37231 2625 21 when when WRB 37231 2625 22 shall shall MD 37231 2625 23 these these DT 37231 2625 24 things thing NNS 37231 2625 25 come come VB 37231 2625 26 to to TO 37231 2625 27 pass pass VB 37231 2625 28 ? ? . 37231 2626 1 and and CC 37231 2626 2 the the DT 37231 2626 3 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2626 4 saith saith NN 37231 2626 5 : : : 37231 2626 6 When when WRB 37231 2626 7 , , , 37231 2626 8 & & CC 37231 2626 9 c. c. NNP 37231 2626 10 ... ... NFP 37231 2626 11 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2626 12 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 2626 13 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2626 14 , , , 37231 2626 15 ....... ....... NFP 37231 2626 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2626 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 2626 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2626 19 . . . 37231 2626 20 " " '' 37231 2627 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2627 2 also also RB 37231 2627 3 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2627 4 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2627 5 ch ch NN 37231 2627 6 . . . 37231 2628 1 vi vi NNP 37231 2628 2 . . . 37231 2628 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2629 1 the the DT 37231 2629 2 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2629 3 " " `` 37231 2629 4 Book Book NNP 37231 2629 5 of of IN 37231 2629 6 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 37231 2629 7 " " '' 37231 2629 8 as as IN 37231 2629 9 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2629 10 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2629 11 , , , 37231 2629 12 and and CC 37231 2629 13 in in IN 37231 2629 14 like like JJ 37231 2629 15 manner manner NN 37231 2629 16 several several JJ 37231 2629 17 other other JJ 37231 2629 18 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2629 19 works work NNS 37231 2629 20 . . . 37231 2630 1 When when WRB 37231 2630 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2630 3 is be VBZ 37231 2630 4 remembered remember VBN 37231 2630 5 that that IN 37231 2630 6 the the DT 37231 2630 7 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2630 8 of of IN 37231 2630 9 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2630 10 to to IN 37231 2630 11 the the DT 37231 2630 12 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2630 13 , , , 37231 2630 14 the the DT 37231 2630 15 Pastor Pastor NNP 37231 2630 16 of of IN 37231 2630 17 Hennas Hennas NNP 37231 2630 18 , , , 37231 2630 19 the the DT 37231 2630 20 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2630 21 of of IN 37231 2630 22 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2630 23 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2630 24 , , , 37231 2630 25 and and CC 37231 2630 26 many many JJ 37231 2630 27 other other JJ 37231 2630 28 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2630 29 works work NNS 37231 2630 30 have have VBP 37231 2630 31 been be VBN 37231 2630 32 quoted quote VBN 37231 2630 33 by by IN 37231 2630 34 the the DT 37231 2630 35 Fathers father NNS 37231 2630 36 as as IN 37231 2630 37 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2630 38 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2630 39 , , , 37231 2630 40 the the DT 37231 2630 41 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 2630 42 value value NN 37231 2630 43 of of IN 37231 2630 44 such such PDT 37231 2630 45 an an DT 37231 2630 46 expression expression NN 37231 2630 47 may may MD 37231 2630 48 be be VB 37231 2630 49 understood understand VBN 37231 2630 50 . . . 37231 2631 1 With with IN 37231 2631 2 this this DT 37231 2631 3 passing pass VBG 37231 2631 4 remark remark NN 37231 2631 5 , , , 37231 2631 6 however however RB 37231 2631 7 , , , 37231 2631 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2631 9 proceed proceed VBP 37231 2631 10 to to TO 37231 2631 11 say say VB 37231 2631 12 that that IN 37231 2631 13 this this DT 37231 2631 14 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2631 15 quotation quotation NN 37231 2631 16 from from IN 37231 2631 17 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2631 18 as as IN 37231 2631 19 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2631 20 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2631 21 , , , 37231 2631 22 by by IN 37231 2631 23 proving prove VBG 37231 2631 24 too too RB 37231 2631 25 much much JJ 37231 2631 26 , , , 37231 2631 27 destroys destroy VBZ 37231 2631 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2631 29 own own JJ 37231 2631 30 value value NN 37231 2631 31 as as IN 37231 2631 32 evidence evidence NN 37231 2631 33 . . . 37231 2632 1 The the DT 37231 2632 2 generality generality NN 37231 2632 3 of of IN 37231 2632 4 competent competent NN 37231 2632 5 and and CC 37231 2632 6 { { -LRB- 37231 2632 7 239 239 CD 37231 2632 8 } } -RRB- 37231 2632 9 impartial impartial JJ 37231 2632 10 critics critic NNS 37231 2632 11 are be VBP 37231 2632 12 agreed agree VBN 37231 2632 13 , , , 37231 2632 14 that that IN 37231 2632 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2632 16 is be VBZ 37231 2632 17 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2632 18 to to TO 37231 2632 19 entertain entertain VB 37231 2632 20 the the DT 37231 2632 21 idea idea NN 37231 2632 22 that that IN 37231 2632 23 one one CD 37231 2632 24 of of IN 37231 2632 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2632 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2632 27 could could MD 37231 2632 28 have have VB 37231 2632 29 held hold VBN 37231 2632 30 the the DT 37231 2632 31 rank rank NN 37231 2632 32 of of IN 37231 2632 33 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2632 34 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2632 35 at at IN 37231 2632 36 the the DT 37231 2632 37 date date NN 37231 2632 38 of of IN 37231 2632 39 this this DT 37231 2632 40 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2632 41 , , , 37231 2632 42 seeing see VBG 37231 2632 43 that that IN 37231 2632 44 , , , 37231 2632 45 for for IN 37231 2632 46 more more JJR 37231 2632 47 than than IN 37231 2632 48 half half PDT 37231 2632 49 a a DT 37231 2632 50 century century NN 37231 2632 51 after after IN 37231 2632 52 , , , 37231 2632 53 the the DT 37231 2632 54 sharpest sharp JJS 37231 2632 55 line line NN 37231 2632 56 was be VBD 37231 2632 57 drawn draw VBN 37231 2632 58 between between IN 37231 2632 59 the the DT 37231 2632 60 writings writing NNS 37231 2632 61 of of IN 37231 2632 62 the the DT 37231 2632 63 Old Old NNP 37231 2632 64 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2632 65 and and CC 37231 2632 66 of of IN 37231 2632 67 the the DT 37231 2632 68 New New NNP 37231 2632 69 , , , 37231 2632 70 and and CC 37231 2632 71 the the DT 37231 2632 72 former former JJ 37231 2632 73 alone alone RB 37231 2632 74 quoted quote VBN 37231 2632 75 as as IN 37231 2632 76 , , , 37231 2632 77 or or CC 37231 2632 78 accorded accord VBD 37231 2632 79 the the DT 37231 2632 80 consideration consideration NN 37231 2632 81 of of IN 37231 2632 82 , , , 37231 2632 83 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2632 84 Scripture.1 Scripture.1 NNP 37231 2632 85 If if IN 37231 2632 86 this this DT 37231 2632 87 were be VBD 37231 2632 88 actually actually RB 37231 2632 89 a a DT 37231 2632 90 quotation quotation NN 37231 2632 91 from from IN 37231 2632 92 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2632 93 first first JJ 37231 2632 94 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2632 95 , , , 37231 2632 96 already already RB 37231 2632 97 in in IN 37231 2632 98 the the DT 37231 2632 99 position position NN 37231 2632 100 of of IN 37231 2632 101 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2632 102 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2632 103 , , , 37231 2632 104 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2632 105 would would MD 37231 2632 106 indeed indeed RB 37231 2632 107 be be VB 37231 2632 108 astonishing astonishing JJ 37231 2632 109 that that IN 37231 2632 110 the the DT 37231 2632 111 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2632 112 , , , 37231 2632 113 putting put VBG 37231 2632 114 out out IN 37231 2632 115 of of IN 37231 2632 116 the the DT 37231 2632 117 question question NN 37231 2632 118 other other JJ 37231 2632 119 Christian christian JJ 37231 2632 120 writings writing NNS 37231 2632 121 for for IN 37231 2632 122 half half PDT 37231 2632 123 a a DT 37231 2632 124 century century NN 37231 2632 125 after after IN 37231 2632 126 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2632 127 , , , 37231 2632 128 teeming teem VBG 37231 2632 129 as as IN 37231 2632 130 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2632 131 does do VBZ 37231 2632 132 with with IN 37231 2632 133 extracts extract NNS 37231 2632 134 from from IN 37231 2632 135 the the DT 37231 2632 136 Old Old NNP 37231 2632 137 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2632 138 , , , 37231 2632 139 and and CC 37231 2632 140 from from IN 37231 2632 141 known know VBN 37231 2632 142 , , , 37231 2632 143 and and CC 37231 2632 144 unknown unknown JJ 37231 2632 145 , , , 37231 2632 146 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2632 147 works work NNS 37231 2632 148 , , , 37231 2632 149 should should MD 37231 2632 150 thus thus RB 37231 2632 151 limit limit VB 37231 2632 152 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2632 153 use use NN 37231 2632 154 of of IN 37231 2632 155 the the DT 37231 2632 156 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2632 157 to to IN 37231 2632 158 a a DT 37231 2632 159 few few JJ 37231 2632 160 words word NNS 37231 2632 161 , , , 37231 2632 162 totally totally RB 37231 2632 163 neglecting neglect VBG 37231 2632 164 the the DT 37231 2632 165 rich rich JJ 37231 2632 166 store store NN 37231 2632 167 which which WDT 37231 2632 168 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2632 169 contains contain VBZ 37231 2632 170 , , , 37231 2632 171 and and CC 37231 2632 172 quoting quoting NN 37231 2632 173 , , , 37231 2632 174 on on IN 37231 2632 175 the the DT 37231 2632 176 other other JJ 37231 2632 177 hand hand NN 37231 2632 178 , , , 37231 2632 179 sayings saying NNS 37231 2632 180 of of IN 37231 2632 181 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2632 182 not not RB 37231 2632 183 recorded record VBD 37231 2632 184 at at RB 37231 2632 185 all all RB 37231 2632 186 in in IN 37231 2632 187 any any DT 37231 2632 188 of of IN 37231 2632 189 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2632 190 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2632 191 . . . 37231 2633 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2633 2 is be VBZ 37231 2633 3 most most RBS 37231 2633 4 improbable improbable JJ 37231 2633 5 that that IN 37231 2633 6 , , , 37231 2633 7 if if IN 37231 2633 8 the the DT 37231 2633 9 author author NN 37231 2633 10 of of IN 37231 2633 11 the the DT 37231 2633 12 " " `` 37231 2633 13 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2633 14 of of IN 37231 2633 15 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2633 16 " " '' 37231 2633 17 was be VBD 37231 2633 18 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 2633 19 with with IN 37231 2633 20 any any DT 37231 2633 21 one one CD 37231 2633 22 of of IN 37231 2633 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2633 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2633 25 , , , 37231 2633 26 and and CC 37231 2633 27 considered consider VBD 37231 2633 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2633 29 an an DT 37231 2633 30 inspired inspired JJ 37231 2633 31 and and CC 37231 2633 32 canonical canonical JJ 37231 2633 33 work work NN 37231 2633 34 , , , 37231 2633 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2633 36 could could MD 37231 2633 37 have have VB 37231 2633 38 neglected neglect VBN 37231 2633 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2633 40 in in IN 37231 2633 41 such such PDT 37231 2633 42 a a DT 37231 2633 43 manner manner NN 37231 2633 44 . . . 37231 2634 1 The the DT 37231 2634 2 peculiarity peculiarity NN 37231 2634 3 of of IN 37231 2634 4 the the DT 37231 2634 5 quotation quotation NN 37231 2634 6 which which WDT 37231 2634 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2634 8 is be VBZ 37231 2634 9 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2634 10 to to TO 37231 2634 11 make make VB 37231 2634 12 , , , 37231 2634 13 which which WDT 37231 2634 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2634 15 shall shall MD 37231 2634 16 presently presently RB 37231 2634 17 point point VB 37231 2634 18 out out RP 37231 2634 19 , , , 37231 2634 20 renders render VBZ 37231 2634 21 such such JJ 37231 2634 22 limitation limitation NN 37231 2634 23 to to IN 37231 2634 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2634 25 doubly doubly RB 37231 2634 26 singular singular JJ 37231 2634 27 upon upon IN 37231 2634 28 any any DT 37231 2634 29 such such JJ 37231 2634 30 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 2634 31 . . . 37231 2635 1 The the DT 37231 2635 2 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 2635 3 nature nature NN 37231 2635 4 of of IN 37231 2635 5 the the DT 37231 2635 6 assertion assertion NN 37231 2635 7 , , , 37231 2635 8 however however RB 37231 2635 9 , , , 37231 2635 10 will will MD 37231 2635 11 become become VB 37231 2635 12 more more RBR 37231 2635 13 apparent apparent JJ 37231 2635 14 as as IN 37231 2635 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2635 16 proceed proceed VBP 37231 2635 17 with with IN 37231 2635 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2635 19 examination examination NN 37231 2635 20 , , , 37231 2635 21 and and CC 37231 2635 22 perceive perceive VB 37231 2635 23 that that IN 37231 2635 24 none none NN 37231 2635 25 of of IN 37231 2635 26 the the DT 37231 2635 27 early early JJ 37231 2635 28 writers writer NNS 37231 2635 29 quote quote VBP 37231 2635 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2635 31 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2635 32 , , , 37231 2635 33 { { -LRB- 37231 2635 34 240 240 CD 37231 2635 35 } } -RRB- 37231 2635 36 if if IN 37231 2635 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2635 38 knew know VBD 37231 2635 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2635 40 at at RB 37231 2635 41 all all RB 37231 2635 42 , , , 37231 2635 43 but but CC 37231 2635 44 , , , 37231 2635 45 on on IN 37231 2635 46 the the DT 37231 2635 47 other other JJ 37231 2635 48 hand hand NN 37231 2635 49 , , , 37231 2635 50 make make VB 37231 2635 51 use use NN 37231 2635 52 of of IN 37231 2635 53 other other JJ 37231 2635 54 works work NNS 37231 2635 55 , , , 37231 2635 56 and and CC 37231 2635 57 that that IN 37231 2635 58 the the DT 37231 2635 59 inference inference NN 37231 2635 60 that that IN 37231 2635 61 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2635 62 was be VBD 37231 2635 63 considered consider VBN 37231 2635 64 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2635 65 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2635 66 , , , 37231 2635 67 therefore therefore RB 37231 2635 68 , , , 37231 2635 69 rests rest NNS 37231 2635 70 solely solely RB 37231 2635 71 upon upon IN 37231 2635 72 this this DT 37231 2635 73 quotation quotation NN 37231 2635 74 of of IN 37231 2635 75 half half PDT 37231 2635 76 a a DT 37231 2635 77 dozen dozen NN 37231 2635 78 words word NNS 37231 2635 79 . . . 37231 2636 1 The the DT 37231 2636 2 application application NN 37231 2636 3 of of IN 37231 2636 4 such such PDT 37231 2636 5 a a DT 37231 2636 6 formula formula NN 37231 2636 7 to to IN 37231 2636 8 a a DT 37231 2636 9 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2636 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 2636 11 from from IN 37231 2636 12 one one CD 37231 2636 13 of of IN 37231 2636 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2636 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2636 16 , , , 37231 2636 17 in in IN 37231 2636 18 so so RB 37231 2636 19 isolated isolate VBD 37231 2636 20 an an DT 37231 2636 21 instance instance NN 37231 2636 22 , , , 37231 2636 23 led lead VBD 37231 2636 24 to to IN 37231 2636 25 the the DT 37231 2636 26 belief belief NN 37231 2636 27 that that IN 37231 2636 28 , , , 37231 2636 29 even even RB 37231 2636 30 if if IN 37231 2636 31 the the DT 37231 2636 32 passage passage NN 37231 2636 33 were be VBD 37231 2636 34 taken take VBN 37231 2636 35 from from IN 37231 2636 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2636 37 first first JJ 37231 2636 38 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2636 39 , , , 37231 2636 40 the the DT 37231 2636 41 author author NN 37231 2636 42 of of IN 37231 2636 43 the the DT 37231 2636 44 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2636 45 in in IN 37231 2636 46 quoting quote VBG 37231 2636 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2636 48 laboured labour VBD 37231 2636 49 under under IN 37231 2636 50 the the DT 37231 2636 51 impression impression NN 37231 2636 52 that that IN 37231 2636 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2636 54 was be VBD 37231 2636 55 derived derive VBN 37231 2636 56 from from IN 37231 2636 57 some some DT 37231 2636 58 prophetical prophetical JJ 37231 2636 59 book book NN 37231 2636 60 . . . 37231 2637 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2637 2 1 1 LS 37231 2637 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2637 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2637 5 daily daily RB 37231 2637 6 see see VBP 37231 2637 7 how how WRB 37231 2637 8 difficult difficult JJ 37231 2637 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2637 10 is be VBZ 37231 2637 11 to to TO 37231 2637 12 trace trace VB 37231 2637 13 the the DT 37231 2637 14 source source NN 37231 2637 15 even even RB 37231 2637 16 of of IN 37231 2637 17 the the DT 37231 2637 18 most most RBS 37231 2637 19 familiar familiar JJ 37231 2637 20 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2637 21 . . . 37231 2638 1 Instances instance NNS 37231 2638 2 of of IN 37231 2638 3 such such JJ 37231 2638 4 confusion confusion NN 37231 2638 5 of of IN 37231 2638 6 memory memory NN 37231 2638 7 are be VBP 37231 2638 8 frequent frequent JJ 37231 2638 9 in in IN 37231 2638 10 the the DT 37231 2638 11 writings writing NNS 37231 2638 12 of of IN 37231 2638 13 the the DT 37231 2638 14 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 2638 15 , , , 37231 2638 16 and and CC 37231 2638 17 many many JJ 37231 2638 18 can can MD 37231 2638 19 be be VB 37231 2638 20 pointed point VBN 37231 2638 21 out out RP 37231 2638 22 in in IN 37231 2638 23 the the DT 37231 2638 24 New New NNP 37231 2638 25 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2638 26 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2638 27 . . . 37231 2639 1 For for IN 37231 2639 2 instance instance NN 37231 2639 3 , , , 37231 2639 4 in in IN 37231 2639 5 Matt Matt NNP 37231 2639 6 , , , 37231 2639 7 xxvii xxvii NN 37231 2639 8 . . . 37231 2640 1 9 9 CD 37231 2640 2 f. f. VBD 37231 2640 3 the the DT 37231 2640 4 passage passage NN 37231 2640 5 from from IN 37231 2640 6 Zechariah Zechariah NNP 37231 2640 7 xi xi NNP 37231 2640 8 . . . 37231 2641 1 12 12 CD 37231 2641 2 - - SYM 37231 2641 3 13 13 CD 37231 2641 4 is be VBZ 37231 2641 5 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2641 6 to to IN 37231 2641 7 Jeremiah Jeremiah NNP 37231 2641 8 ; ; : 37231 2641 9 in in IN 37231 2641 10 Mark Mark NNP 37231 2641 11 i. i. NNP 37231 2642 1 2 2 LS 37231 2642 2 , , , 37231 2642 3 a a DT 37231 2642 4 quotation quotation NN 37231 2642 5 from from IN 37231 2642 6 Malachi Malachi NNP 37231 2642 7 iii iii NNP 37231 2642 8 . . . 37231 2643 1 1 1 CD 37231 2643 2 is be VBZ 37231 2643 3 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2643 4 to to IN 37231 2643 5 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 37231 2643 6 . . . 37231 2644 1 In in IN 37231 2644 2 1 1 CD 37231 2644 3 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2644 4 ii ii CD 37231 2644 5 . . . 37231 2645 1 9 9 CD 37231 2645 2 , , , 37231 2645 3 a a DT 37231 2645 4 passage passage NN 37231 2645 5 is be VBZ 37231 2645 6 quoted quote VBN 37231 2645 7 as as IN 37231 2645 8 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2645 9 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2645 10 which which WDT 37231 2645 11 is be VBZ 37231 2645 12 not not RB 37231 2645 13 found find VBN 37231 2645 14 in in IN 37231 2645 15 the the DT 37231 2645 16 Old Old NNP 37231 2645 17 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2645 18 at at RB 37231 2645 19 all all RB 37231 2645 20 , , , 37231 2645 21 but but CC 37231 2645 22 which which WDT 37231 2645 23 is be VBZ 37231 2645 24 taken take VBN 37231 2645 25 , , , 37231 2645 26 as as IN 37231 2645 27 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2645 28 and and CC 37231 2645 29 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2645 30 state state NN 37231 2645 31 , , , 37231 2645 32 from from IN 37231 2645 33 an an DT 37231 2645 34 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2645 35 work work NN 37231 2645 36 , , , 37231 2645 37 " " `` 37231 2645 38 The the DT 37231 2645 39 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 2645 40 of of IN 37231 2645 41 Elias,"(2 Elias,"(2 NNP 37231 2645 42 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2645 43 and and CC 37231 2645 44 the the DT 37231 2645 45 passage passage NN 37231 2645 46 is be VBZ 37231 2645 47 similarly similarly RB 37231 2645 48 quoted quote VBN 37231 2645 49 by by IN 37231 2645 50 the the DT 37231 2645 51 so so RB 37231 2645 52 - - HYPH 37231 2645 53 called call VBN 37231 2645 54 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2645 55 of of IN 37231 2645 56 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2645 57 to to IN 37231 2645 58 the the DT 37231 2645 59 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2645 60 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2645 61 xxxiv xxxiv NNP 37231 2645 62 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2645 63 . . . 37231 2646 1 Then then RB 37231 2646 2 in in IN 37231 2646 3 what what WP 37231 2646 4 prophet prophet NN 37231 2646 5 did do VBD 37231 2646 6 the the DT 37231 2646 7 author author NN 37231 2646 8 of of IN 37231 2646 9 the the DT 37231 2646 10 first first JJ 37231 2646 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2646 12 find find VBP 37231 2646 13 the the DT 37231 2646 14 words word NNS 37231 2646 15 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2646 16 xiil xiil NNP 37231 2646 17 35 35 CD 37231 2646 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2646 19 : : : 37231 2646 20 " " `` 37231 2646 21 That that IN 37231 2646 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2646 23 might may MD 37231 2646 24 be be VB 37231 2646 25 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 2646 26 which which WDT 37231 2646 27 was be VBD 37231 2646 28 spoken speak VBN 37231 2646 29 by by IN 37231 2646 30 the the DT 37231 2646 31 prophet,(3 prophet,(3 NNP 37231 2646 32 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2646 33 saying say VBG 37231 2646 34 : : : 37231 2646 35 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2646 36 will will MD 37231 2646 37 open open VB 37231 2646 38 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2646 39 mouth mouth NN 37231 2646 40 in in IN 37231 2646 41 parables parable NNS 37231 2646 42 ; ; : 37231 2646 43 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2646 44 { { -LRB- 37231 2646 45 241 241 CD 37231 2646 46 } } -RRB- 37231 2646 47 will will MD 37231 2646 48 utter utter VB 37231 2646 49 things thing NNS 37231 2646 50 which which WDT 37231 2646 51 have have VBP 37231 2646 52 been be VBN 37231 2646 53 kept keep VBN 37231 2646 54 secret secret JJ 37231 2646 55 from from IN 37231 2646 56 the the DT 37231 2646 57 foundation foundation NN 37231 2646 58 of of IN 37231 2646 59 the the DT 37231 2646 60 world world NN 37231 2646 61 " " '' 37231 2646 62 ? ? . 37231 2647 1 Orelli,(1 Orelli,(1 NNP 37231 2647 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2647 3 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 2647 4 followed follow VBN 37231 2647 5 by by IN 37231 2647 6 many many JJ 37231 2647 7 others,(2 others,(2 NNP 37231 2647 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2647 9 suggested suggest VBD 37231 2647 10 that that IN 37231 2647 11 the the DT 37231 2647 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 2647 13 was be VBD 37231 2647 14 probably probably RB 37231 2647 15 intended intend VBN 37231 2647 16 for for IN 37231 2647 17 one one CD 37231 2647 18 in in IN 37231 2647 19 IV IV NNP 37231 2647 20 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2647 21 viii viii NN 37231 2647 22 . . . 37231 2648 1 3 3 LS 37231 2648 2 : : : 37231 2648 3 " " `` 37231 2648 4 Nam Nam NNP 37231 2648 5 multi multi JJ 37231 2648 6 creati creati NNS 37231 2648 7 sunt sunt NN 37231 2648 8 , , , 37231 2648 9 pauci pauci NNP 37231 2648 10 autem autem NNP 37231 2648 11 salvabuntur salvabuntur NNP 37231 2648 12 . . . 37231 2649 1 " " `` 37231 2649 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2649 3 3 3 LS 37231 2649 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2649 5 " " `` 37231 2649 6 For for IN 37231 2649 7 many many JJ 37231 2649 8 are be VBP 37231 2649 9 created create VBN 37231 2649 10 , , , 37231 2649 11 but but CC 37231 2649 12 few few JJ 37231 2649 13 shall shall MD 37231 2649 14 be be VB 37231 2649 15 saved save VBN 37231 2649 16 . . . 37231 2649 17 " " '' 37231 2650 1 Bretsclineider Bretsclineider NNP 37231 2650 2 proposed propose VBD 37231 2650 3 as as IN 37231 2650 4 an an DT 37231 2650 5 emendation emendation NN 37231 2650 6 of of IN 37231 2650 7 the the DT 37231 2650 8 passage passage NN 37231 2650 9 in in IN 37231 2650 10 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2650 11 the the DT 37231 2650 12 substitution substitution NN 37231 2650 13 of of IN 37231 2650 14 " " `` 37231 2650 15 _ _ NNP 37231 2650 16 vocati vocati NNS 37231 2650 17 _ _ NNP 37231 2650 18 " " '' 37231 2650 19 for for IN 37231 2650 20 " " `` 37231 2650 21 _ _ NNP 37231 2650 22 creati creati NNP 37231 2650 23 _ _ NNP 37231 2650 24 " " '' 37231 2650 25 but but CC 37231 2650 26 , , , 37231 2650 27 however however RB 37231 2650 28 plausible plausible JJ 37231 2650 29 , , , 37231 2650 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2650 31 argument argument NN 37231 2650 32 did do VBD 37231 2650 33 not not RB 37231 2650 34 meet meet VB 37231 2650 35 with with IN 37231 2650 36 much much JJ 37231 2650 37 favour favour NN 37231 2650 38 . . . 37231 2651 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2651 2 4 4 LS 37231 2651 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2651 4 Along along IN 37231 2651 5 with with IN 37231 2651 6 this this DT 37231 2651 7 passage passage NN 37231 2651 8 was be VBD 37231 2651 9 also also RB 37231 2651 10 suggested suggest VBN 37231 2651 11 a a DT 37231 2651 12 similar similar JJ 37231 2651 13 expression expression NN 37231 2651 14 in in IN 37231 2651 15 IV IV NNP 37231 2651 16 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2651 17 ix ix NNP 37231 2651 18 . . . 37231 2652 1 15 15 CD 37231 2652 2 : : : 37231 2652 3 " " `` 37231 2652 4 Plures plure NNS 37231 2652 5 sunt sunt NN 37231 2652 6 qui qui NNP 37231 2652 7 pereunt pereunt NNP 37231 2652 8 , , , 37231 2652 9 quam quam NNP 37231 2652 10 qui qui NNP 37231 2652 11 salvabuntur salvabuntur NNP 37231 2652 12 . . . 37231 2652 13 " " '' 37231 2653 1 " " `` 37231 2653 2 There there EX 37231 2653 3 are be VBP 37231 2653 4 more more RBR 37231 2653 5 who who WP 37231 2653 6 perish perish VBP 37231 2653 7 than than IN 37231 2653 8 who who WP 37231 2653 9 shall shall MD 37231 2653 10 be be VB 37231 2653 11 saved save VBN 37231 2653 12 . . . 37231 2654 1 " " `` 37231 2654 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2654 3 5 5 LS 37231 2654 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2654 5 The the DT 37231 2654 6 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2654 7 of of IN 37231 2654 8 the the DT 37231 2654 9 three three CD 37231 2654 10 passages passage NNS 37231 2654 11 may may MD 37231 2654 12 read read VB 37231 2654 13 as as IN 37231 2654 14 follows:-- follows:-- ADD 37231 2654 15 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2654 16 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2654 17 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2654 18 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2654 19 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2654 20 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2654 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2654 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 2654 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2654 24 There there EX 37231 2654 25 can can MD 37231 2654 26 be be VB 37231 2654 27 no no DT 37231 2654 28 doubt doubt NN 37231 2654 29 that that IN 37231 2654 30 the the DT 37231 2654 31 sense sense NN 37231 2654 32 of of IN 37231 2654 33 the the DT 37231 2654 34 reading reading NN 37231 2654 35 in in IN 37231 2654 36 IV IV NNP 37231 2654 37 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2654 38 is be VBZ 37231 2654 39 exactly exactly RB 37231 2654 40 that that DT 37231 2654 41 of of IN 37231 2654 42 the the DT 37231 2654 43 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2654 44 , , , 37231 2654 45 but but CC 37231 2654 46 the the DT 37231 2654 47 language language NN 37231 2654 48 is be VBZ 37231 2654 49 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 2654 50 different different JJ 37231 2654 51 . . . 37231 2655 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2655 2 must must MD 37231 2655 3 not not RB 37231 2655 4 forget forget VB 37231 2655 5 , , , 37231 2655 6 however however RB 37231 2655 7 , , , 37231 2655 8 that that IN 37231 2655 9 the the DT 37231 2655 10 original original JJ 37231 2655 11 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2655 12 of of IN 37231 2655 13 IV IV NNP 37231 2655 14 Ezra(6 Ezra(6 NNP 37231 2655 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2655 16 is be VBZ 37231 2655 17 lost lose VBN 37231 2655 18 , , , 37231 2655 19 and and CC 37231 2655 20 that that IN 37231 2655 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2655 22 are be VBP 37231 2655 23 wholly wholly RB 37231 2655 24 dependent dependent JJ 37231 2655 25 on on IN 37231 2655 26 the the DT 37231 2655 27 versions version NNS 37231 2655 28 and and CC 37231 2655 29 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2655 30 . . . 37231 2656 1 extant extant JJ 37231 2656 2 , , , 37231 2656 3 regarding regard VBG 37231 2656 4 whose whose WP$ 37231 2656 5 numerous numerous JJ 37231 2656 6 variations variation NNS 37231 2656 7 and and CC 37231 2656 8 great great JJ 37231 2656 9 { { -LRB- 37231 2656 10 242 242 CD 37231 2656 11 } } -RRB- 37231 2656 12 corruption corruption NN 37231 2656 13 there there EX 37231 2656 14 are be VBP 37231 2656 15 no no DT 37231 2656 16 differences difference NNS 37231 2656 17 of of IN 37231 2656 18 opinion opinion NN 37231 2656 19 . . . 37231 2657 1 Orelli Orelli NNP 37231 2657 2 's 's POS 37231 2657 3 theory theory NN 37231 2657 4 , , , 37231 2657 5 moreover moreover RB 37231 2657 6 , , , 37231 2657 7 is be VBZ 37231 2657 8 supported support VBN 37231 2657 9 by by IN 37231 2657 10 the the DT 37231 2657 11 fact fact NN 37231 2657 12 that that IN 37231 2657 13 the the DT 37231 2657 14 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2657 15 , , , 37231 2657 16 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2657 17 , , , 37231 2657 18 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2657 19 c. c. NNP 37231 2657 20 xii xii NNP 37231 2657 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2657 22 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2657 23 from from IN 37231 2657 24 IV IV NNP 37231 2657 25 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2657 26 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2657 27 iv iv UH 37231 2657 28 . . . 37231 2658 1 33 33 CD 37231 2658 2 , , , 37231 2658 3 v. v. CC 37231 2658 4 5 5 CD 37231 2658 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2658 6 . . . 37231 2659 1 On on IN 37231 2659 2 examining examine VBG 37231 2659 3 the the DT 37231 2659 4 passage passage NN 37231 2659 5 as as IN 37231 2659 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2659 7 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2659 8 in in IN 37231 2659 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2659 10 first first JJ 37231 2659 11 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2659 12 , , , 37231 2659 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2659 14 are be VBP 37231 2659 15 at at IN 37231 2659 16 the the DT 37231 2659 17 very very JJ 37231 2659 18 outset outset NN 37231 2659 19 struck strike VBN 37231 2659 20 by by IN 37231 2659 21 the the DT 37231 2659 22 singular singular JJ 37231 2659 23 fact fact NN 37231 2659 24 , , , 37231 2659 25 that that IN 37231 2659 26 this this DT 37231 2659 27 short short JJ 37231 2659 28 saying saying NN 37231 2659 29 appears appear VBZ 37231 2659 30 twice twice RB 37231 2659 31 in in IN 37231 2659 32 that that DT 37231 2659 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2659 34 with with IN 37231 2659 35 a a DT 37231 2659 36 different different JJ 37231 2659 37 context context NN 37231 2659 38 , , , 37231 2659 39 and and CC 37231 2659 40 in in IN 37231 2659 41 each each DT 37231 2659 42 case case NN 37231 2659 43 without without IN 37231 2659 44 any any DT 37231 2659 45 propriety propriety NN 37231 2659 46 of of IN 37231 2659 47 application application NN 37231 2659 48 to to IN 37231 2659 49 what what WP 37231 2659 50 precedes precede NNS 37231 2659 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2659 52 , , , 37231 2659 53 whilst whilst IN 37231 2659 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2659 55 is be VBZ 37231 2659 56 not not RB 37231 2659 57 found find VBN 37231 2659 58 at at RB 37231 2659 59 all all RB 37231 2659 60 in in IN 37231 2659 61 either either DT 37231 2659 62 of of IN 37231 2659 63 the the DT 37231 2659 64 other other JJ 37231 2659 65 two two CD 37231 2659 66 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2659 67 . . . 37231 2660 1 The the DT 37231 2660 2 first first JJ 37231 2660 3 time time NN 37231 2660 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2660 5 meet meet VBP 37231 2660 6 with with IN 37231 2660 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2660 8 is be VBZ 37231 2660 9 at at IN 37231 2660 10 the the DT 37231 2660 11 close close NN 37231 2660 12 of of IN 37231 2660 13 the the DT 37231 2660 14 parable parable NN 37231 2660 15 of of IN 37231 2660 16 the the DT 37231 2660 17 labourers labourer NNS 37231 2660 18 in in IN 37231 2660 19 the the DT 37231 2660 20 vineyard vineyard NN 37231 2660 21 . . . 37231 2661 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2661 2 1 1 LS 37231 2661 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2661 4 The the DT 37231 2661 5 householder householder NN 37231 2661 6 engages engage VBZ 37231 2661 7 the the DT 37231 2661 8 labourers labourer NNS 37231 2661 9 at at IN 37231 2661 10 different different JJ 37231 2661 11 hours hour NNS 37231 2661 12 of of IN 37231 2661 13 the the DT 37231 2661 14 day day NN 37231 2661 15 , , , 37231 2661 16 and and CC 37231 2661 17 pays pay VBZ 37231 2661 18 those those DT 37231 2661 19 who who WP 37231 2661 20 had have VBD 37231 2661 21 worked work VBN 37231 2661 22 but but CC 37231 2661 23 one one CD 37231 2661 24 hour hour NN 37231 2661 25 the the DT 37231 2661 26 same same JJ 37231 2661 27 wages wage NNS 37231 2661 28 as as IN 37231 2661 29 those those DT 37231 2661 30 who who WP 37231 2661 31 had have VBD 37231 2661 32 borne bear VBN 37231 2661 33 the the DT 37231 2661 34 burden burden NN 37231 2661 35 and and CC 37231 2661 36 heat heat NN 37231 2661 37 of of IN 37231 2661 38 the the DT 37231 2661 39 day day NN 37231 2661 40 , , , 37231 2661 41 and and CC 37231 2661 42 the the DT 37231 2661 43 reflection reflection NN 37231 2661 44 at at IN 37231 2661 45 the the DT 37231 2661 46 close close NN 37231 2661 47 is be VBZ 37231 2661 48 , , , 37231 2661 49 xx xx CD 37231 2661 50 . . . 37231 2662 1 16 16 CD 37231 2662 2 : : : 37231 2662 3 " " `` 37231 2662 4 Thus thus RB 37231 2662 5 the the DT 37231 2662 6 last last JJ 37231 2662 7 shall shall MD 37231 2662 8 be be VB 37231 2662 9 first first RB 37231 2662 10 and and CC 37231 2662 11 the the DT 37231 2662 12 first first JJ 37231 2662 13 last last JJ 37231 2662 14 ; ; : 37231 2662 15 for for IN 37231 2662 16 many many JJ 37231 2662 17 are be VBP 37231 2662 18 called call VBN 37231 2662 19 but but CC 37231 2662 20 few few JJ 37231 2662 21 chosen choose VBN 37231 2662 22 . . . 37231 2662 23 " " '' 37231 2663 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2663 2 is be VBZ 37231 2663 3 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 2663 4 evident evident JJ 37231 2663 5 that that IN 37231 2663 6 neither neither DT 37231 2663 7 of of IN 37231 2663 8 these these DT 37231 2663 9 sayings saying NNS 37231 2663 10 , , , 37231 2663 11 but but CC 37231 2663 12 especially especially RB 37231 2663 13 not not RB 37231 2663 14 that that DT 37231 2663 15 with with IN 37231 2663 16 which which WDT 37231 2663 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2663 18 are be VBP 37231 2663 19 concerned concern VBN 37231 2663 20 , , , 37231 2663 21 has have VBZ 37231 2663 22 any any DT 37231 2663 23 connection connection NN 37231 2663 24 with with IN 37231 2663 25 the the DT 37231 2663 26 parable parable JJ 37231 2663 27 at at RB 37231 2663 28 all all RB 37231 2663 29 . . . 37231 2664 1 There there EX 37231 2664 2 is be VBZ 37231 2664 3 no no DT 37231 2664 4 question question NN 37231 2664 5 of of IN 37231 2664 6 many many JJ 37231 2664 7 or or CC 37231 2664 8 few few JJ 37231 2664 9 , , , 37231 2664 10 or or CC 37231 2664 11 of of IN 37231 2664 12 selection selection NN 37231 2664 13 or or CC 37231 2664 14 rejection rejection NN 37231 2664 15 ; ; , 37231 2664 16 all all PDT 37231 2664 17 the the DT 37231 2664 18 labourers labourer NNS 37231 2664 19 are be VBP 37231 2664 20 engaged engage VBN 37231 2664 21 and and CC 37231 2664 22 paid pay VBN 37231 2664 23 alike alike RB 37231 2664 24 . . . 37231 2665 1 If if IN 37231 2665 2 there there EX 37231 2665 3 be be VB 37231 2665 4 a a DT 37231 2665 5 moral moral NN 37231 2665 6 at at RB 37231 2665 7 all all RB 37231 2665 8 to to IN 37231 2665 9 the the DT 37231 2665 10 parable parable JJ 37231 2665 11 , , , 37231 2665 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2665 13 is be VBZ 37231 2665 14 the the DT 37231 2665 15 justification justification NN 37231 2665 16 of of IN 37231 2665 17 the the DT 37231 2665 18 master master NN 37231 2665 19 : : : 37231 2665 20 " " `` 37231 2665 21 Is be VBZ 37231 2665 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2665 23 not not RB 37231 2665 24 lawful lawful JJ 37231 2665 25 for for IN 37231 2665 26 me -PRON- PRP 37231 2665 27 to to TO 37231 2665 28 do do VB 37231 2665 29 what what WP 37231 2665 30 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2665 31 will will MD 37231 2665 32 with with IN 37231 2665 33 mine mine JJ 37231 2665 34 own own JJ 37231 2665 35 ? ? . 37231 2665 36 " " '' 37231 2666 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2666 2 is be VBZ 37231 2666 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2666 4 to to TO 37231 2666 5 imagine imagine VB 37231 2666 6 a a DT 37231 2666 7 saying saying NN 37231 2666 8 more more RBR 37231 2666 9 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 37231 2666 10 to to IN 37231 2666 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2666 12 context context NN 37231 2666 13 than than IN 37231 2666 14 " " `` 37231 2666 15 many many JJ 37231 2666 16 are be VBP 37231 2666 17 called call VBN 37231 2666 18 but but CC 37231 2666 19 few few JJ 37231 2666 20 chosen choose VBN 37231 2666 21 , , , 37231 2666 22 " " '' 37231 2666 23 in in IN 37231 2666 24 such such PDT 37231 2666 25 a a DT 37231 2666 26 place place NN 37231 2666 27 . . . 37231 2667 1 The the DT 37231 2667 2 passage passage NN 37231 2667 3 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2667 4 again again RB 37231 2667 5 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2667 6 xxii xxii NNP 37231 2667 7 . . . 37231 2668 1 14 14 CD 37231 2668 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2668 3 in in IN 37231 2668 4 connection connection NN 37231 2668 5 with with IN 37231 2668 6 the the DT 37231 2668 7 parable parable NN 37231 2668 8 of of IN 37231 2668 9 the the DT 37231 2668 10 king king NN 37231 2668 11 who who WP 37231 2668 12 made make VBD 37231 2668 13 a a DT 37231 2668 14 marriage marriage NN 37231 2668 15 for for IN 37231 2668 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2668 17 son son NN 37231 2668 18 . . . 37231 2669 1 The the DT 37231 2669 2 guests guest NNS 37231 2669 3 who who WP 37231 2669 4 are be VBP 37231 2669 5 at at IN 37231 2669 6 first first RB 37231 2669 7 invited invite VBN 37231 2669 8 refuse refuse NN 37231 2669 9 to to TO 37231 2669 10 come come VB 37231 2669 11 , , , 37231 2669 12 and and CC 37231 2669 13 are be VBP 37231 2669 14 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 2669 15 by by IN 37231 2669 16 the the DT 37231 2669 17 king king NN 37231 2669 18 's 's POS 37231 2669 19 armies army NNS 37231 2669 20 ; ; : 37231 2669 21 but but CC 37231 2669 22 the the DT 37231 2669 23 wedding wedding NN 37231 2669 24 is be VBZ 37231 2669 25 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 2669 26 " " `` 37231 2669 27 furnished furnish VBN 37231 2669 28 { { -LRB- 37231 2669 29 243 243 CD 37231 2669 30 } } -RRB- 37231 2669 31 with with IN 37231 2669 32 guests guest NNS 37231 2669 33 " " '' 37231 2669 34 by by IN 37231 2669 35 gathering gather VBG 37231 2669 36 together together RB 37231 2669 37 as as RB 37231 2669 38 many many JJ 37231 2669 39 as as IN 37231 2669 40 are be VBP 37231 2669 41 found find VBN 37231 2669 42 in in IN 37231 2669 43 the the DT 37231 2669 44 highways highway NNS 37231 2669 45 . . . 37231 2670 1 A a DT 37231 2670 2 new new JJ 37231 2670 3 episode episode NN 37231 2670 4 commences commence VBZ 37231 2670 5 when when WRB 37231 2670 6 the the DT 37231 2670 7 king king NN 37231 2670 8 comes come VBZ 37231 2670 9 in in RP 37231 2670 10 to to TO 37231 2670 11 see see VB 37231 2670 12 the the DT 37231 2670 13 guests guest NNS 37231 2670 14 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2670 15 v. v. CC 37231 2670 16 11 11 CD 37231 2670 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2670 18 . . . 37231 2671 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2671 2 observes observe VBZ 37231 2671 3 a a DT 37231 2671 4 man man NN 37231 2671 5 there there RB 37231 2671 6 who who WP 37231 2671 7 has have VBZ 37231 2671 8 not not RB 37231 2671 9 on on IN 37231 2671 10 a a DT 37231 2671 11 wedding wedding NN 37231 2671 12 garment garment NN 37231 2671 13 , , , 37231 2671 14 and and CC 37231 2671 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2671 16 desires desire VBZ 37231 2671 17 the the DT 37231 2671 18 servants servant NNS 37231 2671 19 to to IN 37231 2671 20 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2671 21 v. v. CC 37231 2671 22 13 13 CD 37231 2671 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2671 24 " " `` 37231 2671 25 Bind bind VB 37231 2671 26 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2671 27 hand hand NN 37231 2671 28 and and CC 37231 2671 29 foot foot NN 37231 2671 30 , , , 37231 2671 31 and and CC 37231 2671 32 cast cast VBD 37231 2671 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2671 34 into into IN 37231 2671 35 the the DT 37231 2671 36 darkness darkness NN 37231 2671 37 without without IN 37231 2671 38 , , , 37231 2671 39 " " `` 37231 2671 40 where where WRB 37231 2671 41 " " `` 37231 2671 42 there there EX 37231 2671 43 shall shall MD 37231 2671 44 be be VB 37231 2671 45 weeping weep VBG 37231 2671 46 and and CC 37231 2671 47 gnashing gnashing NN 37231 2671 48 of of IN 37231 2671 49 teeth;"(1 teeth;"(1 NNP 37231 2671 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2671 51 and and CC 37231 2671 52 then then RB 37231 2671 53 comes come VBZ 37231 2671 54 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2671 55 passage passage NN 37231 2671 56 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2671 57 v. v. CC 37231 2671 58 14 14 CD 37231 2671 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2671 60 : : : 37231 2671 61 " " `` 37231 2671 62 For for IN 37231 2671 63 many many JJ 37231 2671 64 are be VBP 37231 2671 65 called call VBN 37231 2671 66 but but CC 37231 2671 67 few few JJ 37231 2671 68 chosen choose VBN 37231 2671 69 . . . 37231 2671 70 " " '' 37231 2672 1 Now now RB 37231 2672 2 , , , 37231 2672 3 whether whether IN 37231 2672 4 applied apply VBD 37231 2672 5 to to IN 37231 2672 6 the the DT 37231 2672 7 first first JJ 37231 2672 8 or or CC 37231 2672 9 to to IN 37231 2672 10 the the DT 37231 2672 11 latter latter JJ 37231 2672 12 part part NN 37231 2672 13 of of IN 37231 2672 14 the the DT 37231 2672 15 parable parable JJ 37231 2672 16 , , , 37231 2672 17 the the DT 37231 2672 18 saying saying NN 37231 2672 19 is be VBZ 37231 2672 20 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 37231 2672 21 . . . 37231 2673 1 The the DT 37231 2673 2 guests guest NNS 37231 2673 3 first first RB 37231 2673 4 called call VBN 37231 2673 5 were be VBD 37231 2673 6 in in IN 37231 2673 7 fact fact NN 37231 2673 8 chosen choose VBN 37231 2673 9 as as RB 37231 2673 10 much much RB 37231 2673 11 as as IN 37231 2673 12 the the DT 37231 2673 13 last last JJ 37231 2673 14 , , , 37231 2673 15 but but CC 37231 2673 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2673 17 refused refuse VBD 37231 2673 18 to to TO 37231 2673 19 come come VB 37231 2673 20 , , , 37231 2673 21 and and CC 37231 2673 22 of of IN 37231 2673 23 all all PDT 37231 2673 24 those those DT 37231 2673 25 who who WP 37231 2673 26 , , , 37231 2673 27 being be VBG 37231 2673 28 " " `` 37231 2673 29 called call VBN 37231 2673 30 " " '' 37231 2673 31 from from IN 37231 2673 32 the the DT 37231 2673 33 highways highway NNS 37231 2673 34 and and CC 37231 2673 35 byways byway NNS 37231 2673 36 , , , 37231 2673 37 ultimately ultimately RB 37231 2673 38 furnished furnish VBD 37231 2673 39 the the DT 37231 2673 40 wedding wedding NN 37231 2673 41 with with IN 37231 2673 42 guests guest NNS 37231 2673 43 in in IN 37231 2673 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2673 45 stead stead NN 37231 2673 46 , , , 37231 2673 47 only only RB 37231 2673 48 one one CD 37231 2673 49 was be VBD 37231 2673 50 rejected reject VBN 37231 2673 51 . . . 37231 2674 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2674 2 is be VBZ 37231 2674 3 clear clear JJ 37231 2674 4 that that IN 37231 2674 5 the the DT 37231 2674 6 facts fact NNS 37231 2674 7 here here RB 37231 2674 8 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 2674 9 contradict contradict VBP 37231 2674 10 the the DT 37231 2674 11 moral moral NN 37231 2674 12 that that IN 37231 2674 13 " " `` 37231 2674 14 few few JJ 37231 2674 15 are be VBP 37231 2674 16 chosen choose VBN 37231 2674 17 . . . 37231 2674 18 " " '' 37231 2675 1 In in IN 37231 2675 2 both both DT 37231 2675 3 places place NNS 37231 2675 4 the the DT 37231 2675 5 saying saying NN 37231 2675 6 is be VBZ 37231 2675 7 , , , 37231 2675 8 as as IN 37231 2675 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2675 10 were be VBD 37231 2675 11 , , , 37231 2675 12 " " '' 37231 2675 13 dragged drag VBN 37231 2675 14 in in RP 37231 2675 15 by by IN 37231 2675 16 the the DT 37231 2675 17 hair hair NN 37231 2675 18 . . . 37231 2675 19 " " '' 37231 2676 1 On on IN 37231 2676 2 examination examination NN 37231 2676 3 , , , 37231 2676 4 however however RB 37231 2676 5 , , , 37231 2676 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2676 7 find find VBP 37231 2676 8 that that IN 37231 2676 9 the the DT 37231 2676 10 oldest old JJS 37231 2676 11 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2676 12 . . . 37231 2677 1 of of IN 37231 2677 2 the the DT 37231 2677 3 New New NNP 37231 2677 4 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2677 5 omit omit NN 37231 2677 6 the the DT 37231 2677 7 sentence sentence NN 37231 2677 8 from from IN 37231 2677 9 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2677 10 xx xx NNP 37231 2677 11 . . . 37231 2678 1 16 16 CD 37231 2678 2 . . . 37231 2679 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2679 2 is be VBZ 37231 2679 3 neither neither RB 37231 2679 4 found find VBN 37231 2679 5 in in IN 37231 2679 6 the the DT 37231 2679 7 Sinaitic sinaitic JJ 37231 2679 8 nor nor CC 37231 2679 9 Vatican Vatican NNP 37231 2679 10 codices codex NNS 37231 2679 11 , , , 37231 2679 12 and and CC 37231 2679 13 whilst whilst IN 37231 2679 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2679 15 has have VBZ 37231 2679 16 not not RB 37231 2679 17 the the DT 37231 2679 18 support support NN 37231 2679 19 of of IN 37231 2679 20 the the DT 37231 2679 21 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2679 22 Alexandrinus Alexandrinus NNP 37231 2679 23 , , , 37231 2679 24 which which WDT 37231 2679 25 is be VBZ 37231 2679 26 defective defective JJ 37231 2679 27 at at IN 37231 2679 28 the the DT 37231 2679 29 part part NN 37231 2679 30 , , , 37231 2679 31 nor nor CC 37231 2679 32 of of IN 37231 2679 33 the the DT 37231 2679 34 Dublin Dublin NNP 37231 2679 35 rescript rescript NN 37231 2679 36 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2679 37 z z NNP 37231 2679 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2679 39 , , , 37231 2679 40 which which WDT 37231 2679 41 omits omit VBZ 37231 2679 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2679 43 , , , 37231 2679 44 many many JJ 37231 2679 45 other other JJ 37231 2679 46 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2679 47 . . . 37231 2680 1 are be VBP 37231 2680 2 also also RB 37231 2680 3 without without IN 37231 2680 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2680 5 . . . 37231 2681 1 The the DT 37231 2681 2 total total JJ 37231 2681 3 irrelevancy irrelevancy NN 37231 2681 4 of of IN 37231 2681 5 the the DT 37231 2681 6 saying saying NN 37231 2681 7 to to IN 37231 2681 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2681 9 context context NN 37231 2681 10 , , , 37231 2681 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2681 12 omission omission NN 37231 2681 13 by by IN 37231 2681 14 the the DT 37231 2681 15 oldest old JJS 37231 2681 16 authorities authority NNS 37231 2681 17 from from IN 37231 2681 18 Matth Matth NNP 37231 2681 19 . . . 37231 2682 1 xx xx NNP 37231 2682 2 . . . 37231 2683 1 16 16 CD 37231 2683 2 , , , 37231 2683 3 where where WRB 37231 2683 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2683 5 appears appear VBZ 37231 2683 6 in in IN 37231 2683 7 later later RB 37231 2683 8 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2683 9 . . . 37231 2683 10 , , , 37231 2683 11 and and CC 37231 2683 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2683 13 total total JJ 37231 2683 14 absence absence NN 37231 2683 15 from from IN 37231 2683 16 both both DT 37231 2683 17 of of IN 37231 2683 18 the the DT 37231 2683 19 other other JJ 37231 2683 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2683 21 , , , 37231 2683 22 must must MD 37231 2683 23 at at IN 37231 2683 24 once once RB 37231 2683 25 strike strike VB 37231 2683 26 every every DT 37231 2683 27 one one NN 37231 2683 28 as as RB 37231 2683 29 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 2683 30 , , , 37231 2683 31 and and CC 37231 2683 32 as as IN 37231 2683 33 very very RB 37231 2683 34 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 37231 2683 35 , , , 37231 2683 36 to to TO 37231 2683 37 say say VB 37231 2683 38 1 1 CD 37231 2683 39 This this DT 37231 2683 40 is be VBZ 37231 2683 41 not not RB 37231 2683 42 the the DT 37231 2683 43 place place NN 37231 2683 44 to to TO 37231 2683 45 criticize criticize VB 37231 2683 46 the the DT 37231 2683 47 expectation expectation NN 37231 2683 48 of of IN 37231 2683 49 finding find VBG 37231 2683 50 a a DT 37231 2683 51 wedding wedding NN 37231 2683 52 garment garment NN 37231 2683 53 on on IN 37231 2683 54 a a DT 37231 2683 55 guest guest NN 37231 2683 56 hurried hurry VBN 37231 2683 57 in in IN 37231 2683 58 from from IN 37231 2683 59 highways highway NNS 37231 2683 60 and and CC 37231 2683 61 byways byway NNS 37231 2683 62 , , , 37231 2683 63 or or CC 37231 2683 64 the the DT 37231 2683 65 punishment punishment NN 37231 2683 66 inflicted inflict VBN 37231 2683 67 for for IN 37231 2683 68 such such PDT 37231 2683 69 an an DT 37231 2683 70 offence offence NN 37231 2683 71 , , , 37231 2683 72 as as IN 37231 2683 73 questions question NNS 37231 2683 74 affecting affect VBG 37231 2683 75 the the DT 37231 2683 76 character character NN 37231 2683 77 of of IN 37231 2683 78 the the DT 37231 2683 79 parable parable JJ 37231 2683 80 . . . 37231 2684 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2684 2 244 244 CD 37231 2684 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2684 4 the the DT 37231 2684 5 least least JJS 37231 2684 6 of of IN 37231 2684 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2684 8 , , , 37231 2684 9 for for IN 37231 2684 10 those those DT 37231 2684 11 who who WP 37231 2684 12 make make VBP 37231 2684 13 extreme extreme JJ 37231 2684 14 assertions assertion NNS 37231 2684 15 with with IN 37231 2684 16 regard regard NN 37231 2684 17 to to IN 37231 2684 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2684 19 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2684 20 quotation quotation NN 37231 2684 21 by by IN 37231 2684 22 the the DT 37231 2684 23 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2684 24 of of IN 37231 2684 25 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2684 26 . . . 37231 2685 1 Weizsacker Weizsacker NNP 37231 2685 2 , , , 37231 2685 3 with with IN 37231 2685 4 great great JJ 37231 2685 5 probability probability NN 37231 2685 6 , , , 37231 2685 7 suggests suggest VBZ 37231 2685 8 that that IN 37231 2685 9 in in IN 37231 2685 10 this this DT 37231 2685 11 passage passage NN 37231 2685 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2685 13 have have VBP 37231 2685 14 merely merely RB 37231 2685 15 a a DT 37231 2685 16 well well RB 37231 2685 17 - - HYPH 37231 2685 18 known know VBN 37231 2685 19 proverb,(1 proverb,(1 NN 37231 2685 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2685 21 which which WDT 37231 2685 22 the the DT 37231 2685 23 author author NN 37231 2685 24 of of IN 37231 2685 25 the the DT 37231 2685 26 first first JJ 37231 2685 27 gospel gospel NN 37231 2685 28 has have VBZ 37231 2685 29 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2685 30 into into IN 37231 2685 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2685 32 work work NN 37231 2685 33 from from IN 37231 2685 34 some some DT 37231 2685 35 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 37231 2685 36 or or CC 37231 2685 37 other other JJ 37231 2685 38 source source NN 37231 2685 39 , , , 37231 2685 40 and and CC 37231 2685 41 placed place VBN 37231 2685 42 in in IN 37231 2685 43 the the DT 37231 2685 44 mouth mouth NN 37231 2685 45 of of IN 37231 2685 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2685 47 . . . 37231 2686 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2686 2 2 2 LS 37231 2686 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2686 4 Certainly certainly RB 37231 2686 5 under under IN 37231 2686 6 the the DT 37231 2686 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2686 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2686 9 can can MD 37231 2686 10 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2686 11 be be VB 37231 2686 12 maintained maintain VBN 37231 2686 13 in in IN 37231 2686 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2686 15 present present JJ 37231 2686 16 context context NN 37231 2686 17 as as IN 37231 2686 18 a a DT 37231 2686 19 historical historical JJ 37231 2686 20 saying saying NN 37231 2686 21 of of IN 37231 2686 22 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2686 23 . . . 37231 2687 1 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 2687 2 , , , 37231 2687 3 who who WP 37231 2687 4 naturally naturally RB 37231 2687 5 omits omit VBZ 37231 2687 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2687 7 from from IN 37231 2687 8 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2687 9 xx xx NNP 37231 2687 10 . . . 37231 2688 1 16 16 CD 37231 2688 2 , , , 37231 2688 3 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 2688 4 the the DT 37231 2688 5 parable parable JJ 37231 2688 6 xx xx NN 37231 2688 7 . . . 37231 2689 1 1 1 LS 37231 2689 2 - - HYPH 37231 2689 3 -16 -16 NNP 37231 2689 4 as as RB 37231 2689 5 well well RB 37231 2689 6 as as IN 37231 2689 7 that that DT 37231 2689 8 xxii xxii NNP 37231 2689 9 . . . 37231 2690 1 1 1 LS 37231 2690 2 - - HYPH 37231 2690 3 -14 -14 NNP 37231 2690 4 , , , 37231 2690 5 in in IN 37231 2690 6 which which WDT 37231 2690 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2690 8 stands stand VBZ 37231 2690 9 , , , 37231 2690 10 originally originally RB 37231 2690 11 to to IN 37231 2690 12 the the DT 37231 2690 13 Spruchsammlung(3 spruchsammlung(3 NN 37231 2690 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2690 15 or or CC 37231 2690 16 collection collection NN 37231 2690 17 of of IN 37231 2690 18 discourses discourse NNS 37231 2690 19 , , , 37231 2690 20 out out IN 37231 2690 21 of of IN 37231 2690 22 which which WDT 37231 2690 23 , , , 37231 2690 24 with with IN 37231 2690 25 intermediate intermediate JJ 37231 2690 26 works work NNS 37231 2690 27 , , , 37231 2690 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2690 29 considers consider VBZ 37231 2690 30 that that IN 37231 2690 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2690 32 first first JJ 37231 2690 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2690 34 was be VBD 37231 2690 35 composed compose VBN 37231 2690 36 . . . 37231 2691 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2691 2 4 4 LS 37231 2691 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2691 4 However however RB 37231 2691 5 this this DT 37231 2691 6 may may MD 37231 2691 7 be be VB 37231 2691 8 , , , 37231 2691 9 there there EX 37231 2691 10 is be VBZ 37231 2691 11 , , , 37231 2691 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2691 13 seems seem VBZ 37231 2691 14 to to IN 37231 2691 15 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2691 16 , , , 37231 2691 17 good good JJ 37231 2691 18 reason reason NN 37231 2691 19 for for IN 37231 2691 20 believing believe VBG 37231 2691 21 that that IN 37231 2691 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2691 23 was be VBD 37231 2691 24 not not RB 37231 2691 25 originally originally RB 37231 2691 26 a a DT 37231 2691 27 part part NN 37231 2691 28 of of IN 37231 2691 29 these these DT 37231 2691 30 parables parable NNS 37231 2691 31 , , , 37231 2691 32 and and CC 37231 2691 33 that that IN 37231 2691 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2691 35 is be VBZ 37231 2691 36 not not RB 37231 2691 37 in in IN 37231 2691 38 that that DT 37231 2691 39 sense sense NN 37231 2691 40 historical historical JJ 37231 2691 41 ; ; : 37231 2691 42 and and CC 37231 2691 43 there there EX 37231 2691 44 is be VBZ 37231 2691 45 , , , 37231 2691 46 therefore therefore RB 37231 2691 47 , , , 37231 2691 48 no no DT 37231 2691 49 ground ground NN 37231 2691 50 for for IN 37231 2691 51 asserting assert VBG 37231 2691 52 that that IN 37231 2691 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2691 54 may may MD 37231 2691 55 not not RB 37231 2691 56 have have VB 37231 2691 57 been be VBN 37231 2691 58 derived derive VBN 37231 2691 59 by by IN 37231 2691 60 the the DT 37231 2691 61 author author NN 37231 2691 62 of of IN 37231 2691 63 the the DT 37231 2691 64 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2691 65 from from IN 37231 2691 66 some some DT 37231 2691 67 older old JJR 37231 2691 68 work work NN 37231 2691 69 , , , 37231 2691 70 from from IN 37231 2691 71 which which WDT 37231 2691 72 also also RB 37231 2691 73 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2691 74 may may MD 37231 2691 75 have have VB 37231 2691 76 come come VBN 37231 2691 77 into into IN 37231 2691 78 the the DT 37231 2691 79 " " `` 37231 2691 80 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2691 81 of of IN 37231 2691 82 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2691 83 . . . 37231 2692 1 " " `` 37231 2692 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2692 3 5 5 CD 37231 2692 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2692 5 { { -LRB- 37231 2692 6 245 245 CD 37231 2692 7 } } -RRB- 37231 2692 8 There there RB 37231 2692 9 is be VBZ 37231 2692 10 , , , 37231 2692 11 however however RB 37231 2692 12 , , , 37231 2692 13 another another DT 37231 2692 14 passage passage NN 37231 2692 15 which which WDT 37231 2692 16 deserves deserve VBZ 37231 2692 17 to to TO 37231 2692 18 be be VB 37231 2692 19 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2692 20 . . . 37231 2693 1 The the DT 37231 2693 2 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2693 3 has have VBZ 37231 2693 4 the the DT 37231 2693 5 following following JJ 37231 2693 6 quotation quotation NN 37231 2693 7 : : : 37231 2693 8 " " `` 37231 2693 9 Again again RB 37231 2693 10 , , , 37231 2693 11 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2693 12 will will MD 37231 2693 13 show show VB 37231 2693 14 thee thee PRP 37231 2693 15 how how WRB 37231 2693 16 , , , 37231 2693 17 in in IN 37231 2693 18 regard regard NN 37231 2693 19 to to IN 37231 2693 20 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2693 21 , , , 37231 2693 22 the the DT 37231 2693 23 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2693 24 saith saith NN 37231 2693 25 , , , 37231 2693 26 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2693 27 made make VBD 37231 2693 28 a a DT 37231 2693 29 new new JJ 37231 2693 30 creation creation NN 37231 2693 31 in in IN 37231 2693 32 the the DT 37231 2693 33 last last JJ 37231 2693 34 times time NNS 37231 2693 35 . . . 37231 2694 1 The the DT 37231 2694 2 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2694 3 saith saith NN 37231 2694 4 : : : 37231 2694 5 Behold Behold NNP 37231 2694 6 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2694 7 make make VBP 37231 2694 8 the the DT 37231 2694 9 first first JJ 37231 2694 10 as as IN 37231 2694 11 the the DT 37231 2694 12 last last JJ 37231 2694 13 . . . 37231 2695 1 " " `` 37231 2695 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2695 3 l l NN 37231 2695 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2695 5 Even even RB 37231 2695 6 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2695 7 does do VBZ 37231 2695 8 not not RB 37231 2695 9 pretend pretend VB 37231 2695 10 that that IN 37231 2695 11 this this DT 37231 2695 12 is be VBZ 37231 2695 13 a a DT 37231 2695 14 quotation quotation NN 37231 2695 15 of of IN 37231 2695 16 Matth Matth NNP 37231 2695 17 . . . 37231 2696 1 xx xx NNP 37231 2696 2 . . . 37231 2697 1 16,(2 16,(2 LS 37231 2697 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2697 3 " " `` 37231 2697 4 Thus thus RB 37231 2697 5 the the DT 37231 2697 6 last last JJ 37231 2697 7 shall shall MD 37231 2697 8 be be VB 37231 2697 9 first first RB 37231 2697 10 and and CC 37231 2697 11 the the DT 37231 2697 12 first first JJ 37231 2697 13 last last JJ 37231 2697 14 , , , 37231 2697 15 " " '' 37231 2697 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2697 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2697 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2697 19 the the DT 37231 2697 20 sense sense NN 37231 2697 21 of of IN 37231 2697 22 which which WDT 37231 2697 23 is be VBZ 37231 2697 24 quite quite RB 37231 2697 25 different different JJ 37231 2697 26 . . . 37231 2698 1 The the DT 37231 2698 2 application application NN 37231 2698 3 of of IN 37231 2698 4 the the DT 37231 2698 5 saying saying NN 37231 2698 6 in in IN 37231 2698 7 this this DT 37231 2698 8 place place NN 37231 2698 9 in in IN 37231 2698 10 the the DT 37231 2698 11 first first JJ 37231 2698 12 , , , 37231 2698 13 and and CC 37231 2698 14 indeed indeed RB 37231 2698 15 in in IN 37231 2698 16 the the DT 37231 2698 17 other other JJ 37231 2698 18 , , , 37231 2698 19 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2698 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2698 21 is be VBZ 37231 2698 22 evidently evidently RB 37231 2698 23 quite quite RB 37231 2698 24 false false JJ 37231 2698 25 , , , 37231 2698 26 and and CC 37231 2698 27 depends depend VBZ 37231 2698 28 merely merely RB 37231 2698 29 on on IN 37231 2698 30 the the DT 37231 2698 31 ring ring NN 37231 2698 32 of of IN 37231 2698 33 words word NNS 37231 2698 34 and and CC 37231 2698 35 not not RB 37231 2698 36 of of IN 37231 2698 37 ideas idea NNS 37231 2698 38 . . . 37231 2699 1 In in IN 37231 2699 2 xix xix NN 37231 2699 3 . . . 37231 2700 1 30 30 CD 37231 2700 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2700 3 is be VBZ 37231 2700 4 quoted quote VBN 37231 2700 5 a a DT 37231 2700 6 second second JJ 37231 2700 7 time time NN 37231 2700 8 , , , 37231 2700 9 quite quite RB 37231 2700 10 irrelevantly irrelevantly RB 37231 2700 11 , , , 37231 2700 12 with with IN 37231 2700 13 some some DT 37231 2700 14 variation variation NN 37231 2700 15 : : : 37231 2700 16 " " `` 37231 2700 17 But but CC 37231 2700 18 many many JJ 37231 2700 19 first first JJ 37231 2700 20 shall shall MD 37231 2700 21 be be VB 37231 2700 22 last last JJ 37231 2700 23 and and CC 37231 2700 24 last last JJ 37231 2700 25 first first JJ 37231 2700 26 " " '' 37231 2700 27 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2700 28 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2700 29 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2700 30 . . . 37231 2701 1 Now now RB 37231 2701 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2701 3 will will MD 37231 2701 4 be be VB 37231 2701 5 remembered remember VBN 37231 2701 6 that that IN 37231 2701 7 at at IN 37231 2701 8 xx xx CD 37231 2701 9 . . . 37231 2702 1 16 16 CD 37231 2702 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2702 3 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2702 4 in in IN 37231 2702 5 several several JJ 37231 2702 6 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2702 7 . . . 37231 2703 1 in in IN 37231 2703 2 connection connection NN 37231 2703 3 with with IN 37231 2703 4 " " `` 37231 2703 5 Many many JJ 37231 2703 6 are be VBP 37231 2703 7 called call VBN 37231 2703 8 but but CC 37231 2703 9 few few JJ 37231 2703 10 are be VBP 37231 2703 11 chosen choose VBN 37231 2703 12 , , , 37231 2703 13 " " '' 37231 2703 14 although although IN 37231 2703 15 the the DT 37231 2703 16 oldest old JJS 37231 2703 17 codices codex NNS 37231 2703 18 omit omit VBP 37231 2703 19 the the DT 37231 2703 20 latter latter JJ 37231 2703 21 passage passage NN 37231 2703 22 , , , 37231 2703 23 and and CC 37231 2703 24 most most JJS 37231 2703 25 critics critic NNS 37231 2703 26 consider consider VBP 37231 2703 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2703 28 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 2703 29 . . . 37231 2704 1 The the DT 37231 2704 2 separate separate JJ 37231 2704 3 quotation quotation NN 37231 2704 4 of of IN 37231 2704 5 these these DT 37231 2704 6 two two CD 37231 2704 7 passages passage NNS 37231 2704 8 by by IN 37231 2704 9 the the DT 37231 2704 10 author author NN 37231 2704 11 of of IN 37231 2704 12 the the DT 37231 2704 13 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2704 14 , , , 37231 2704 15 with with IN 37231 2704 16 so so RB 37231 2704 17 marked mark VBN 37231 2704 18 a a DT 37231 2704 19 variation variation NN 37231 2704 20 in in IN 37231 2704 21 the the DT 37231 2704 22 second second JJ 37231 2704 23 , , , 37231 2704 24 renders render VBZ 37231 2704 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2704 26 most most RBS 37231 2704 27 probable probable JJ 37231 2704 28 that that IN 37231 2704 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2704 30 found find VBD 37231 2704 31 both both DT 37231 2704 32 in in IN 37231 2704 33 the the DT 37231 2704 34 source source NN 37231 2704 35 from from IN 37231 2704 36 which which WDT 37231 2704 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2704 38 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2704 39 . . . 37231 2705 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2705 2 have have VBP 37231 2705 3 , , , 37231 2705 4 however however RB 37231 2705 5 , , , 37231 2705 6 more more JJR 37231 2705 7 than than IN 37231 2705 8 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 2705 9 discussed discuss VBN 37231 2705 10 this this DT 37231 2705 11 passage passage NN 37231 2705 12 . . . 37231 2706 1 The the DT 37231 2706 2 author author NN 37231 2706 3 of of IN 37231 2706 4 the the DT 37231 2706 5 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2706 6 does do VBZ 37231 2706 7 not not RB 37231 2706 8 indicate indicate VB 37231 2706 9 any any DT 37231 2706 10 source source NN 37231 2706 11 from from IN 37231 2706 12 which which WDT 37231 2706 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2706 14 makes make VBZ 37231 2706 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2706 16 quotation quotation NN 37231 2706 17 ; ; : 37231 2706 18 and and CC 37231 2706 19 the the DT 37231 2706 20 mere mere JJ 37231 2706 21 existence existence NN 37231 2706 22 in in IN 37231 2706 23 the the DT 37231 2706 24 first first JJ 37231 2706 25 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2706 26 of of IN 37231 2706 27 a a DT 37231 2706 28 proverbial proverbial JJ 37231 2706 29 saying saying NN 37231 2706 30 { { -LRB- 37231 2706 31 246 246 CD 37231 2706 32 } } -RRB- 37231 2706 33 like like IN 37231 2706 34 this this DT 37231 2706 35 does do VBZ 37231 2706 36 not not RB 37231 2706 37 in in IN 37231 2706 38 the the DT 37231 2706 39 least least JJS 37231 2706 40 involve involve VBP 37231 2706 41 the the DT 37231 2706 42 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2706 43 that that IN 37231 2706 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2706 45 is be VBZ 37231 2706 46 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 2706 47 the the DT 37231 2706 48 writing writing NN 37231 2706 49 from from IN 37231 2706 50 which which WDT 37231 2706 51 the the DT 37231 2706 52 quotation quotation NN 37231 2706 53 was be VBD 37231 2706 54 derived derive VBN 37231 2706 55 , , , 37231 2706 56 more more RBR 37231 2706 57 especially especially RB 37231 2706 58 as as IN 37231 2706 59 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2706 60 works work NNS 37231 2706 61 are be VBP 37231 2706 62 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 2706 63 cited cite VBN 37231 2706 64 in in IN 37231 2706 65 the the DT 37231 2706 66 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2706 67 . . . 37231 2707 1 If if IN 37231 2707 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2707 3 be be VB 37231 2707 4 maintained maintain VBN 37231 2707 5 that that IN 37231 2707 6 the the DT 37231 2707 7 saying saying NN 37231 2707 8 is be VBZ 37231 2707 9 really really RB 37231 2707 10 historical historical JJ 37231 2707 11 , , , 37231 2707 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2707 13 is be VBZ 37231 2707 14 obvious obvious JJ 37231 2707 15 that that IN 37231 2707 16 the the DT 37231 2707 17 prescriptive prescriptive JJ 37231 2707 18 right right NN 37231 2707 19 of of IN 37231 2707 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2707 21 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2707 22 is be VBZ 37231 2707 23 at at IN 37231 2707 24 once once RB 37231 2707 25 excluded exclude VBN 37231 2707 26 , , , 37231 2707 27 and and CC 37231 2707 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2707 29 may may MD 37231 2707 30 have have VB 37231 2707 31 been be VBN 37231 2707 32 the the DT 37231 2707 33 common common JJ 37231 2707 34 property property NN 37231 2707 35 of of IN 37231 2707 36 a a DT 37231 2707 37 score score NN 37231 2707 38 of of IN 37231 2707 39 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 2707 40 works work NNS 37231 2707 41 . . . 37231 2708 1 There there EX 37231 2708 2 can can MD 37231 2708 3 be be VB 37231 2708 4 no no DT 37231 2708 5 doubt doubt NN 37231 2708 6 that that IN 37231 2708 7 many many JJ 37231 2708 8 Scriptural Scriptural NNP 37231 2708 9 texts text NNS 37231 2708 10 have have VBP 37231 2708 11 crept creep VBN 37231 2708 12 into into IN 37231 2708 13 early early JJ 37231 2708 14 Christian christian JJ 37231 2708 15 writings writing NNS 37231 2708 16 which which WDT 37231 2708 17 originally originally RB 37231 2708 18 had have VBD 37231 2708 19 no no DT 37231 2708 20 place place NN 37231 2708 21 there there RB 37231 2708 22 ; ; : 37231 2708 23 and and CC 37231 2708 24 where where WRB 37231 2708 25 attendant attendant JJ 37231 2708 26 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2708 27 are be VBP 37231 2708 28 suspicious suspicious JJ 37231 2708 29 , , , 37231 2708 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2708 31 is be VBZ 37231 2708 32 always always RB 37231 2708 33 well well JJ 37231 2708 34 to to TO 37231 2708 35 remember remember VB 37231 2708 36 the the DT 37231 2708 37 fact fact NN 37231 2708 38 . . . 37231 2709 1 An an DT 37231 2709 2 instance instance NN 37231 2709 3 of of IN 37231 2709 4 the the DT 37231 2709 5 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2709 6 of of IN 37231 2709 7 which which WDT 37231 2709 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2709 9 speak speak VBP 37231 2709 10 is be VBZ 37231 2709 11 found find VBN 37231 2709 12 in in IN 37231 2709 13 the the DT 37231 2709 14 " " `` 37231 2709 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2709 16 of of IN 37231 2709 17 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2709 18 . . . 37231 2709 19 " " '' 37231 2710 1 In in IN 37231 2710 2 one one CD 37231 2710 3 place place NN 37231 2710 4 the the DT 37231 2710 5 phrase phrase NN 37231 2710 6 : : : 37231 2710 7 " " `` 37231 2710 8 Give give VB 37231 2710 9 to to IN 37231 2710 10 every every DT 37231 2710 11 one one NN 37231 2710 12 that that WDT 37231 2710 13 asketh asketh NN 37231 2710 14 of of IN 37231 2710 15 thee thee NN 37231 2710 16 " " '' 37231 2710 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2710 18 --Greek--](1 --Greek--](1 NFP 37231 2710 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2710 20 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2710 21 , , , 37231 2710 22 not not RB 37231 2710 23 as as IN 37231 2710 24 a a DT 37231 2710 25 quotation quotation NN 37231 2710 26 , , , 37231 2710 27 but but CC 37231 2710 28 merely merely RB 37231 2710 29 woven weave VBN 37231 2710 30 into into IN 37231 2710 31 the the DT 37231 2710 32 Greek greek JJ 37231 2710 33 text text NN 37231 2710 34 as as IN 37231 2710 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2710 36 existed exist VBD 37231 2710 37 before before IN 37231 2710 38 the the DT 37231 2710 39 discovery discovery NN 37231 2710 40 of of IN 37231 2710 41 the the DT 37231 2710 42 Sinaitic Sinaitic NNP 37231 2710 43 MS MS NNP 37231 2710 44 . . . 37231 2711 1 This this DT 37231 2711 2 phrase phrase NN 37231 2711 3 is be VBZ 37231 2711 4 the the DT 37231 2711 5 same same JJ 37231 2711 6 as as IN 37231 2711 7 the the DT 37231 2711 8 precept precept NN 37231 2711 9 in in IN 37231 2711 10 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2711 11 vi vi NNP 37231 2711 12 . . . 37231 2712 1 30 30 CD 37231 2712 2 , , , 37231 2712 3 although although IN 37231 2712 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2712 5 was be VBD 37231 2712 6 argued argue VBN 37231 2712 7 by by IN 37231 2712 8 some some DT 37231 2712 9 that that DT 37231 2712 10 , , , 37231 2712 11 as as IN 37231 2712 12 no no DT 37231 2712 13 other other JJ 37231 2712 14 trace trace NN 37231 2712 15 of of IN 37231 2712 16 the the DT 37231 2712 17 third third JJ 37231 2712 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2712 19 existed exist VBD 37231 2712 20 in in IN 37231 2712 21 the the DT 37231 2712 22 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2712 23 , , , 37231 2712 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2712 25 was be VBD 37231 2712 26 more more RBR 37231 2712 27 probably probably RB 37231 2712 28 an an DT 37231 2712 29 alteration alteration NN 37231 2712 30 of of IN 37231 2712 31 the the DT 37231 2712 32 text text NN 37231 2712 33 of of IN 37231 2712 34 Matth Matth NNP 37231 2712 35 . . . 37231 2713 1 v. v. IN 37231 2713 2 42 42 CD 37231 2713 3 . . . 37231 2714 1 Omitting omit VBG 37231 2714 2 the the DT 37231 2714 3 phrase phrase NN 37231 2714 4 from from IN 37231 2714 5 the the DT 37231 2714 6 passage passage NN 37231 2714 7 in in IN 37231 2714 8 the the DT 37231 2714 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2714 10 , , , 37231 2714 11 the the DT 37231 2714 12 text text NN 37231 2714 13 read read VBD 37231 2714 14 as as IN 37231 2714 15 follows follow VBZ 37231 2714 16 : : : 37231 2714 17 " " `` 37231 2714 18 Thou Thou NNP 37231 2714 19 shalt shalt NN 37231 2714 20 not not RB 37231 2714 21 hesitate hesitate VB 37231 2714 22 to to TO 37231 2714 23 give give VB 37231 2714 24 , , , 37231 2714 25 neither neither CC 37231 2714 26 shalt shalt NN 37231 2714 27 thou thou NNP 37231 2714 28 murmur murmur NNP 37231 2714 29 when when WRB 37231 2714 30 thou thou NNP 37231 2714 31 givest giv JJS 37231 2714 32 ... ... . 37231 2714 33 so so CC 37231 2714 34 shalt shalt VB 37231 2714 35 thou thou NNP 37231 2714 36 know know VB 37231 2714 37 who who WP 37231 2714 38 is be VBZ 37231 2714 39 the the DT 37231 2714 40 good good JJ 37231 2714 41 Recompenser Recompenser NNP 37231 2714 42 of of IN 37231 2714 43 the the DT 37231 2714 44 reward reward NN 37231 2714 45 . . . 37231 2714 46 " " '' 37231 2715 1 The the DT 37231 2715 2 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2715 3 quotation quotation NN 37231 2715 4 , , , 37231 2715 5 inserted insert VBN 37231 2715 6 where where WRB 37231 2715 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2715 8 have have VBP 37231 2715 9 left leave VBN 37231 2715 10 a a DT 37231 2715 11 blank blank NN 37231 2715 12 , , , 37231 2715 13 really really RB 37231 2715 14 interrupted interrupt VBD 37231 2715 15 the the DT 37231 2715 16 sense sense NN 37231 2715 17 and and CC 37231 2715 18 repeated repeat VBD 37231 2715 19 the the DT 37231 2715 20 previous previous JJ 37231 2715 21 injunction injunction NN 37231 2715 22 . . . 37231 2716 1 The the DT 37231 2716 2 oldest old JJS 37231 2716 3 MS MS NNP 37231 2716 4 . . NNP 37231 2716 5 , , , 37231 2716 6 the the DT 37231 2716 7 " " `` 37231 2716 8 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2716 9 Sinaiticus Sinaiticus NNP 37231 2716 10 , , , 37231 2716 11 " " '' 37231 2716 12 omits omit VBZ 37231 2716 13 the the DT 37231 2716 14 quotation quotation NN 37231 2716 15 , , , 37231 2716 16 and and CC 37231 2716 17 so so RB 37231 2716 18 ends end VBZ 37231 2716 19 the the DT 37231 2716 20 question question NN 37231 2716 21 , , , 37231 2716 22 but but CC 37231 2716 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2716 24 is be VBZ 37231 2716 25 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 2716 26 inserted insert VBN 37231 2716 27 by by IN 37231 2716 28 another another DT 37231 2716 29 hand hand NN 37231 2716 30 . . . 37231 2717 1 Some some DT 37231 2717 2 pious pious JJ 37231 2717 3 scribe scribe NN 37231 2717 4 , , , 37231 2717 5 in in IN 37231 2717 6 fact fact NN 37231 2717 7 , , , 37231 2717 8 seeing see VBG 37231 2717 9 the the DT 37231 2717 10 relation relation NN 37231 2717 11 of of IN 37231 2717 12 the the DT 37231 2717 13 passage passage NN 37231 2717 14 to to IN 37231 2717 15 the the DT 37231 2717 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2717 17 , , , 37231 2717 18 had have VBD 37231 2717 19 added add VBN 37231 2717 20 the the DT 37231 2717 21 { { -LRB- 37231 2717 22 247 247 CD 37231 2717 23 } } -RRB- 37231 2717 24 words word NNS 37231 2717 25 in in IN 37231 2717 26 the the DT 37231 2717 27 margin margin NN 37231 2717 28 as as IN 37231 2717 29 a a DT 37231 2717 30 gloss gloss NN 37231 2717 31 , , , 37231 2717 32 and and CC 37231 2717 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2717 34 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 2717 35 found find VBD 37231 2717 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2717 37 way way NN 37231 2717 38 into into IN 37231 2717 39 the the DT 37231 2717 40 text text NN 37231 2717 41 In in IN 37231 2717 42 this this DT 37231 2717 43 manner manner NN 37231 2717 44 very very RB 37231 2717 45 many many JJ 37231 2717 46 similar similar JJ 37231 2717 47 glosses gloss NNS 37231 2717 48 have have VBP 37231 2717 49 crept creep VBN 37231 2717 50 into into IN 37231 2717 51 texts text NNS 37231 2717 52 which which WDT 37231 2717 53 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2717 54 were be VBD 37231 2717 55 originally originally RB 37231 2717 56 intended intend VBN 37231 2717 57 to to TO 37231 2717 58 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 2717 59 . . . 37231 2718 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2718 2 , , , 37231 2718 3 who who WP 37231 2718 4 does do VBZ 37231 2718 5 not not RB 37231 2718 6 allude allude VB 37231 2718 7 to to IN 37231 2718 8 this this DT 37231 2718 9 , , , 37231 2718 10 lays lay VBZ 37231 2718 11 much much JJ 37231 2718 12 stress stress NN 37231 2718 13 upon upon IN 37231 2718 14 the the DT 37231 2718 15 following follow VBG 37231 2718 16 passage passage NN 37231 2718 17 : : : 37231 2718 18 " " `` 37231 2718 19 But but CC 37231 2718 20 when when WRB 37231 2718 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2718 22 selected select VBD 37231 2718 23 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2718 24 own own JJ 37231 2718 25 apostles apostle NNS 37231 2718 26 , , , 37231 2718 27 who who WP 37231 2718 28 should should MD 37231 2718 29 preach preach VB 37231 2718 30 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2718 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2718 32 , , , 37231 2718 33 who who WP 37231 2718 34 were be VBD 37231 2718 35 sinners sinner NNS 37231 2718 36 above above IN 37231 2718 37 all all DT 37231 2718 38 sin sin VBP 37231 2718 39 , , , 37231 2718 40 in in IN 37231 2718 41 order order NN 37231 2718 42 that that IN 37231 2718 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2718 44 might may MD 37231 2718 45 show show VB 37231 2718 46 that that IN 37231 2718 47 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2718 48 came come VBD 37231 2718 49 not not RB 37231 2718 50 to to TO 37231 2718 51 call call VB 37231 2718 52 the the DT 37231 2718 53 righteous righteous JJ 37231 2718 54 but but CC 37231 2718 55 sinners sinner NNS 37231 2718 56 , , , 37231 2718 57 then then RB 37231 2718 58 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2718 59 manifested manifest VBD 37231 2718 60 Himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2718 61 to to TO 37231 2718 62 be be VB 37231 2718 63 the the DT 37231 2718 64 Son Son NNP 37231 2718 65 of of IN 37231 2718 66 God God NNP 37231 2718 67 . . . 37231 2719 1 " " `` 37231 2719 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2719 3 1 1 LS 37231 2719 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2719 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2719 6 may may MD 37231 2719 7 remark remark VB 37231 2719 8 that that IN 37231 2719 9 , , , 37231 2719 10 in in IN 37231 2719 11 the the DT 37231 2719 12 common common JJ 37231 2719 13 Greek greek JJ 37231 2719 14 text text NN 37231 2719 15 , , , 37231 2719 16 the the DT 37231 2719 17 words word NNS 37231 2719 18 " " `` 37231 2719 19 to to TO 37231 2719 20 repentance repentance NN 37231 2719 21 " " '' 37231 2719 22 were be VBD 37231 2719 23 inserted insert VBN 37231 2719 24 after after IN 37231 2719 25 " " `` 37231 2719 26 sinners sinner NNS 37231 2719 27 , , , 37231 2719 28 " " '' 37231 2719 29 but but CC 37231 2719 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2719 31 are be VBP 37231 2719 32 not not RB 37231 2719 33 found find VBN 37231 2719 34 in in IN 37231 2719 35 the the DT 37231 2719 36 Sinaitic Sinaitic NNP 37231 2719 37 MS MS NNP 37231 2719 38 . . . 37231 2720 1 In in IN 37231 2720 2 like like JJ 37231 2720 3 manner manner NN 37231 2720 4 many many JJ 37231 2720 5 Codices codex NNS 37231 2720 6 insert insert VBP 37231 2720 7 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2720 8 in in IN 37231 2720 9 Matth Matth NNP 37231 2720 10 , , , 37231 2720 11 ix ix NNP 37231 2720 12 . . . 37231 2721 1 13 13 CD 37231 2721 2 and and CC 37231 2721 3 Mark Mark NNP 37231 2721 4 ii ii NNP 37231 2721 5 . . . 37231 2722 1 17 17 CD 37231 2722 2 , , , 37231 2722 3 but but CC 37231 2722 4 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2722 5 are be VBP 37231 2722 6 not not RB 37231 2722 7 found find VBN 37231 2722 8 in in IN 37231 2722 9 some some DT 37231 2722 10 of of IN 37231 2722 11 the the DT 37231 2722 12 oldest old JJS 37231 2722 13 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2722 14 . . . 37231 2722 15 , , , 37231 2722 16 and and CC 37231 2722 17 are be VBP 37231 2722 18 generally generally RB 37231 2722 19 rejected reject VBN 37231 2722 20 . . . 37231 2723 1 Tischendorf tischendorf NN 37231 2723 2 considers consider VBZ 37231 2723 3 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2723 4 a a DT 37231 2723 5 later later JJ 37231 2723 6 addition addition NN 37231 2723 7 both both CC 37231 2723 8 to to IN 37231 2723 9 the the DT 37231 2723 10 text text NN 37231 2723 11 of of IN 37231 2723 12 the the DT 37231 2723 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2723 14 and and CC 37231 2723 15 of of IN 37231 2723 16 the the DT 37231 2723 17 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2723 18 . . . 37231 2724 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2724 2 3 3 LS 37231 2724 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2724 4 But but CC 37231 2724 5 this this DT 37231 2724 6 very very JJ 37231 2724 7 fact fact NN 37231 2724 8 is be VBZ 37231 2724 9 suggestive suggestive JJ 37231 2724 10 . . . 37231 2725 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2725 2 is be VBZ 37231 2725 3 clear clear JJ 37231 2725 4 that that IN 37231 2725 5 a a DT 37231 2725 6 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2725 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 2725 8 has have VBZ 37231 2725 9 been be VBN 37231 2725 10 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 2725 11 adjusted adjust VBN 37231 2725 12 to to IN 37231 2725 13 what what WP 37231 2725 14 was be VBD 37231 2725 15 considered consider VBN 37231 2725 16 to to TO 37231 2725 17 be be VB 37231 2725 18 the the DT 37231 2725 19 text text NN 37231 2725 20 of of IN 37231 2725 21 the the DT 37231 2725 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2725 23 . . . 37231 2726 1 Why why WRB 37231 2726 2 should should MD 37231 2726 3 the the DT 37231 2726 4 whole whole JJ 37231 2726 5 phrase phrase NN 37231 2726 6 not not RB 37231 2726 7 be be VB 37231 2726 8 equally equally RB 37231 2726 9 an an DT 37231 2726 10 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2726 11 ? ? . 37231 2727 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2727 2 shall shall MD 37231 2727 3 presently presently RB 37231 2727 4 see see VB 37231 2727 5 that that IN 37231 2727 6 there there EX 37231 2727 7 is be VBZ 37231 2727 8 reason reason NN 37231 2727 9 to to TO 37231 2727 10 think think VB 37231 2727 11 that that IN 37231 2727 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2727 13 is be VBZ 37231 2727 14 so so RB 37231 2727 15 . . . 37231 2728 1 Alhough Alhough NNP 37231 2728 2 there there EX 37231 2728 3 is be VBZ 37231 2728 4 no no DT 37231 2728 5 quotation quotation NN 37231 2728 6 in in IN 37231 2728 7 the the DT 37231 2728 8 passage passage NN 37231 2728 9 , , , 37231 2728 10 who who WP 37231 2728 11 , , , 37231 2728 12 asks ask VBZ 37231 2728 13 Tischendorf,(3 tischendorf,(3 NN 37231 2728 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2728 15 could could MD 37231 2728 16 mistake mistake VB 37231 2728 17 the the DT 37231 2728 18 words word NNS 37231 2728 19 as as IN 37231 2728 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2728 21 stand stand VBP 37231 2728 22 in in IN 37231 2728 23 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2728 24 , , , 37231 2728 25 ix ix IN 37231 2728 26 . . . 37231 2729 1 13 13 CD 37231 2729 2 , , , 37231 2729 3 " " `` 37231 2729 4 For for IN 37231 2729 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2729 6 came come VBD 37231 2729 7 not not RB 37231 2729 8 to to TO 37231 2729 9 call call VB 37231 2729 10 the the DT 37231 2729 11 righteous righteous JJ 37231 2729 12 but but CC 37231 2729 13 sinners sinner NNS 37231 2729 14 " " '' 37231 2729 15 ? ? . 37231 2730 1 Now now RB 37231 2730 2 this this DT 37231 2730 3 passage passage NN 37231 2730 4 is be VBZ 37231 2730 5 referred refer VBN 37231 2730 6 to to IN 37231 2730 7 by by IN 37231 2730 8 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2730 9 in in IN 37231 2730 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2730 11 work work NN 37231 2730 12 against against IN 37231 2730 13 Celsus Celsus NNP 37231 2730 14 , , , 37231 2730 15 in in IN 37231 2730 16 a a DT 37231 2730 17 way way NN 37231 2730 18 which which WDT 37231 2730 19 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 2730 20 that that IN 37231 2730 21 the the DT 37231 2730 22 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2730 23 quotation quotation NN 37231 2730 24 did do VBD 37231 2730 25 not not RB 37231 2730 26 exist exist VB 37231 2730 27 in in IN 37231 2730 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2730 29 copy copy NN 37231 2730 30 ; ; : 37231 2730 31 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2730 32 says say VBZ 37231 2730 33 : : : 37231 2730 34 " " `` 37231 2730 35 And and CC 37231 2730 36 as as IN 37231 2730 37 Celsus Celsus NNP 37231 2730 38 has have VBZ 37231 2730 39 called call VBN 37231 2730 40 { { -LRB- 37231 2730 41 248 248 CD 37231 2730 42 } } -RRB- 37231 2730 43 the the DT 37231 2730 44 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2730 45 of of IN 37231 2730 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2730 47 infamous infamous JJ 37231 2730 48 men man NNS 37231 2730 49 , , , 37231 2730 50 saying say VBG 37231 2730 51 that that IN 37231 2730 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2730 53 were be VBD 37231 2730 54 tax tax NN 37231 2730 55 - - HYPH 37231 2730 56 gatherers gatherer NNS 37231 2730 57 and and CC 37231 2730 58 worthless worthless JJ 37231 2730 59 sailors sailor NNS 37231 2730 60 , , , 37231 2730 61 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2730 62 have have VBP 37231 2730 63 to to TO 37231 2730 64 remark remark VB 37231 2730 65 on on IN 37231 2730 66 this this DT 37231 2730 67 , , , 37231 2730 68 that that DT 37231 2730 69 , , , 37231 2730 70 & & CC 37231 2730 71 c c NNP 37231 2730 72 .... .... . 37231 2730 73 Now now RB 37231 2730 74 in in IN 37231 2730 75 the the DT 37231 2730 76 Catholic Catholic NNP 37231 2730 77 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2730 78 of of IN 37231 2730 79 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2730 80 from from IN 37231 2730 81 which which WDT 37231 2730 82 , , , 37231 2730 83 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 2730 84 , , , 37231 2730 85 Celsus Celsus NNP 37231 2730 86 derived derive VBD 37231 2730 87 the the DT 37231 2730 88 statement statement NN 37231 2730 89 that that IN 37231 2730 90 the the DT 37231 2730 91 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 2730 92 were be VBD 37231 2730 93 infamous infamous JJ 37231 2730 94 and and CC 37231 2730 95 wicked wicked JJ 37231 2730 96 men man NNS 37231 2730 97 , , , 37231 2730 98 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2730 99 is be VBZ 37231 2730 100 written write VBN 37231 2730 101 that that IN 37231 2730 102 ' ' '' 37231 2730 103 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2730 104 selected select VBD 37231 2730 105 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2730 106 own own JJ 37231 2730 107 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2730 108 who who WP 37231 2730 109 were be VBD 37231 2730 110 sinners sinner NNS 37231 2730 111 above above IN 37231 2730 112 all all DT 37231 2730 113 sin,"(1)--and sin,"(1)--and : 37231 2730 114 then then RB 37231 2730 115 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2730 116 goes go VBZ 37231 2730 117 on on RP 37231 2730 118 to to TO 37231 2730 119 quote quote VB 37231 2730 120 the the DT 37231 2730 121 expression expression NN 37231 2730 122 of of IN 37231 2730 123 Peter Peter NNP 37231 2730 124 to to IN 37231 2730 125 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2730 126 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2730 127 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2730 128 v. v. IN 37231 2730 129 8) 8) CD 37231 2730 130 , , , 37231 2730 131 and and CC 37231 2730 132 then then RB 37231 2730 133 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2730 134 Timothy Timothy NNP 37231 2730 135 , , , 37231 2730 136 L L NNP 37231 2730 137 15 15 CD 37231 2730 138 , , , 37231 2730 139 but but CC 37231 2730 140 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2730 141 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 2730 142 refers refer VBZ 37231 2730 143 to to IN 37231 2730 144 the the DT 37231 2730 145 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2730 146 quotation quotation NN 37231 2730 147 in in IN 37231 2730 148 the the DT 37231 2730 149 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2730 150 . . . 37231 2731 1 Now now RB 37231 2731 2 , , , 37231 2731 3 if if IN 37231 2731 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2731 5 read read VBP 37231 2731 6 the the DT 37231 2731 7 passage passage NN 37231 2731 8 without without IN 37231 2731 9 the the DT 37231 2731 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 2731 11 , , , 37231 2731 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2731 13 have have VBP 37231 2731 14 : : : 37231 2731 15 " " `` 37231 2731 16 But but CC 37231 2731 17 when when WRB 37231 2731 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2731 19 selected select VBD 37231 2731 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2731 21 own own JJ 37231 2731 22 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 2731 23 who who WP 37231 2731 24 should should MD 37231 2731 25 preach preach VB 37231 2731 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2731 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2731 28 , , , 37231 2731 29 who who WP 37231 2731 30 were be VBD 37231 2731 31 sinners sinner NNS 37231 2731 32 above above IN 37231 2731 33 all all DT 37231 2731 34 sin sin NN 37231 2731 35 .... .... NFP 37231 2731 36 then then RB 37231 2731 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2731 38 manifested manifest VBD 37231 2731 39 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2731 40 to to TO 37231 2731 41 be be VB 37231 2731 42 the the DT 37231 2731 43 Son Son NNP 37231 2731 44 of of IN 37231 2731 45 God God NNP 37231 2731 46 . . . 37231 2731 47 " " '' 37231 2732 1 Here here RB 37231 2732 2 a a DT 37231 2732 3 pious pious JJ 37231 2732 4 scribe scribe NN 37231 2732 5 very very RB 37231 2732 6 probably probably RB 37231 2732 7 added add VBN 37231 2732 8 in in IN 37231 2732 9 the the DT 37231 2732 10 margin margin NN 37231 2732 11 the the DT 37231 2732 12 gloss gloss NN 37231 2732 13 : : : 37231 2732 14 " " `` 37231 2732 15 in in IN 37231 2732 16 order order NN 37231 2732 17 that that IN 37231 2732 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2732 19 might may MD 37231 2732 20 show show VB 37231 2732 21 that that IN 37231 2732 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2732 23 came come VBD 37231 2732 24 not not RB 37231 2732 25 to to TO 37231 2732 26 call call VB 37231 2732 27 the the DT 37231 2732 28 righteous righteous JJ 37231 2732 29 but but CC 37231 2732 30 sinners sinner NNS 37231 2732 31 , , , 37231 2732 32 " " '' 37231 2732 33 to to TO 37231 2732 34 explain explain VB 37231 2732 35 the the DT 37231 2732 36 passage passage NN 37231 2732 37 , , , 37231 2732 38 and and CC 37231 2732 39 as as IN 37231 2732 40 in in IN 37231 2732 41 the the DT 37231 2732 42 case case NN 37231 2732 43 of of IN 37231 2732 44 the the DT 37231 2732 45 phrase phrase NN 37231 2732 46 : : : 37231 2732 47 " " `` 37231 2732 48 Give give VB 37231 2732 49 to to IN 37231 2732 50 every every DT 37231 2732 51 one one NN 37231 2732 52 that that WDT 37231 2732 53 asketh asketh NN 37231 2732 54 of of IN 37231 2732 55 thee thee NN 37231 2732 56 , , , 37231 2732 57 " " '' 37231 2732 58 the the DT 37231 2732 59 gloss gloss NNP 37231 2732 60 became become VBD 37231 2732 61 subsequently subsequently RB 37231 2732 62 incorporated incorporate VBN 37231 2732 63 with with IN 37231 2732 64 the the DT 37231 2732 65 text text NN 37231 2732 66 . . . 37231 2733 1 The the DT 37231 2733 2 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2733 3 , , , 37231 2733 4 however however RB 37231 2733 5 , , , 37231 2733 6 goes go VBZ 37231 2733 7 on on RP 37231 2733 8 to to TO 37231 2733 9 give give VB 37231 2733 10 the the DT 37231 2733 11 only only JJ 37231 2733 12 explanation explanation NN 37231 2733 13 which which WDT 37231 2733 14 the the DT 37231 2733 15 author author NN 37231 2733 16 intended intend VBD 37231 2733 17 , , , 37231 2733 18 and and CC 37231 2733 19 which which WDT 37231 2733 20 clashes clash VBZ 37231 2733 21 with with IN 37231 2733 22 that that DT 37231 2733 23 of of IN 37231 2733 24 the the DT 37231 2733 25 scribe scribe NN 37231 2733 26 . . . 37231 2734 1 " " `` 37231 2734 2 For for IN 37231 2734 3 if if IN 37231 2734 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2734 5 had have VBD 37231 2734 6 not not RB 37231 2734 7 come come VBN 37231 2734 8 in in IN 37231 2734 9 the the DT 37231 2734 10 flesh flesh NN 37231 2734 11 , , , 37231 2734 12 how how WRB 37231 2734 13 could could MD 37231 2734 14 men man NNS 37231 2734 15 have have VB 37231 2734 16 been be VBN 37231 2734 17 saved save VBN 37231 2734 18 by by IN 37231 2734 19 beholding behold VBG 37231 2734 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2734 21 ? ? . 37231 2735 1 Seeing see VBG 37231 2735 2 that that IN 37231 2735 3 looking look VBG 37231 2735 4 on on IN 37231 2735 5 the the DT 37231 2735 6 sun sun NN 37231 2735 7 that that WDT 37231 2735 8 shall shall MD 37231 2735 9 cease cease VB 37231 2735 10 to to TO 37231 2735 11 be be VB 37231 2735 12 , , , 37231 2735 13 the the DT 37231 2735 14 work work NN 37231 2735 15 of of IN 37231 2735 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2735 17 hands hand NNS 37231 2735 18 , , , 37231 2735 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2735 20 have have VBP 37231 2735 21 not not RB 37231 2735 22 even even RB 37231 2735 23 power power NN 37231 2735 24 to to TO 37231 2735 25 endure endure VB 37231 2735 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2735 27 rays ray NNS 37231 2735 28 . . . 37231 2736 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 37231 2736 2 , , , 37231 2736 3 the the DT 37231 2736 4 Son Son NNP 37231 2736 5 of of IN 37231 2736 6 Man Man NNP 37231 2736 7 came come VBD 37231 2736 8 in in IN 37231 2736 9 the the DT 37231 2736 10 flesh flesh NN 37231 2736 11 for for IN 37231 2736 12 this this DT 37231 2736 13 , , , 37231 2736 14 that that IN 37231 2736 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2736 16 might may MD 37231 2736 17 bring bring VB 37231 2736 18 to to IN 37231 2736 19 a a DT 37231 2736 20 head head NN 37231 2736 21 the the DT 37231 2736 22 number number NN 37231 2736 23 of of IN 37231 2736 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2736 25 sins sin NNS 37231 2736 26 who who WP 37231 2736 27 had have VBD 37231 2736 28 persecuted persecute VBN 37231 2736 29 to to IN 37231 2736 30 death death NN 37231 2736 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2736 32 prophets prophet NNS 37231 2736 33 . . . 37231 2737 1 " " `` 37231 2737 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2737 3 2 2 LS 37231 2737 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2737 5 The the DT 37231 2737 6 argument argument NN 37231 2737 7 of of IN 37231 2737 8 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2737 9 bears bear VBZ 37231 2737 10 out out RP 37231 2737 11 this this DT 37231 2737 12 view view NN 37231 2737 13 , , , 37231 2737 14 for for IN 37231 2737 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2737 16 does do VBZ 37231 2737 17 not not RB 37231 2737 18 at at RB 37231 2737 19 all all RB 37231 2737 20 take take VB 37231 2737 21 the the DT 37231 2737 22 explanation explanation NN 37231 2737 23 of of IN 37231 2737 24 { { -LRB- 37231 2737 25 249 249 CD 37231 2737 26 } } -RRB- 37231 2737 27 the the DT 37231 2737 28 gloss gloss NN 37231 2737 29 as as IN 37231 2737 30 to to IN 37231 2737 31 why why WRB 37231 2737 32 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2737 33 chose choose VBD 37231 2737 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2737 35 disciples disciple NNS 37231 2737 36 from from IN 37231 2737 37 such such PDT 37231 2737 38 a a DT 37231 2737 39 class class NN 37231 2737 40 , , , 37231 2737 41 but but CC 37231 2737 42 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2737 43 reasons reason VBZ 37231 2737 44 : : : 37231 2737 45 " " `` 37231 2737 46 What what WP 37231 2737 47 is be VBZ 37231 2737 48 there there RB 37231 2737 49 strange strange JJ 37231 2737 50 , , , 37231 2737 51 therefore therefore RB 37231 2737 52 , , , 37231 2737 53 that that IN 37231 2737 54 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2737 55 being be VBG 37231 2737 56 minded minded JJ 37231 2737 57 to to TO 37231 2737 58 manifest manifest VB 37231 2737 59 to to IN 37231 2737 60 the the DT 37231 2737 61 race race NN 37231 2737 62 of of IN 37231 2737 63 men man NNS 37231 2737 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2737 65 power power NN 37231 2737 66 to to TO 37231 2737 67 heal heal VB 37231 2737 68 souls soul NNS 37231 2737 69 , , , 37231 2737 70 should should MD 37231 2737 71 have have VB 37231 2737 72 selected select VBN 37231 2737 73 infamous infamous JJ 37231 2737 74 and and CC 37231 2737 75 wicked wicked JJ 37231 2737 76 men man NNS 37231 2737 77 , , , 37231 2737 78 and and CC 37231 2737 79 should should MD 37231 2737 80 have have VB 37231 2737 81 elevated elevate VBN 37231 2737 82 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2737 83 so so RB 37231 2737 84 far far RB 37231 2737 85 , , , 37231 2737 86 that that IN 37231 2737 87 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2737 88 became become VBD 37231 2737 89 a a DT 37231 2737 90 pattern pattern NN 37231 2737 91 of of IN 37231 2737 92 the the DT 37231 2737 93 purest pure JJS 37231 2737 94 virtue virtue NN 37231 2737 95 to to IN 37231 2737 96 those those DT 37231 2737 97 who who WP 37231 2737 98 were be VBD 37231 2737 99 brought bring VBN 37231 2737 100 by by IN 37231 2737 101 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2737 102 persuasion persuasion NN 37231 2737 103 to to IN 37231 2737 104 the the DT 37231 2737 105 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2737 106 of of IN 37231 2737 107 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2737 108 . . . 37231 2738 1 " " `` 37231 2738 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2738 3 1 1 LS 37231 2738 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2738 5 The the DT 37231 2738 6 argument argument NN 37231 2738 7 , , , 37231 2738 8 both both DT 37231 2738 9 of of IN 37231 2738 10 the the DT 37231 2738 11 author author NN 37231 2738 12 of of IN 37231 2738 13 the the DT 37231 2738 14 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2738 15 and and CC 37231 2738 16 of of IN 37231 2738 17 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2738 18 , , , 37231 2738 19 is be VBZ 37231 2738 20 different different JJ 37231 2738 21 from from IN 37231 2738 22 that that DT 37231 2738 23 suggested suggest VBN 37231 2738 24 by by IN 37231 2738 25 the the DT 37231 2738 26 phrase phrase NN 37231 2738 27 under under IN 37231 2738 28 examination examination NN 37231 2738 29 , , , 37231 2738 30 and and CC 37231 2738 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2738 32 consider consider VBP 37231 2738 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2738 34 a a DT 37231 2738 35 mere mere JJ 37231 2738 36 gloss gloss NN 37231 2738 37 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2738 38 into into IN 37231 2738 39 the the DT 37231 2738 40 text text NN 37231 2738 41 ; ; : 37231 2738 42 which which WDT 37231 2738 43 , , , 37231 2738 44 as as IN 37231 2738 45 the the DT 37231 2738 46 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2738 47 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2738 48 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2738 49 shows show NNS 37231 2738 50 , , , 37231 2738 51 has have VBZ 37231 2738 52 , , , 37231 2738 53 in in IN 37231 2738 54 the the DT 37231 2738 55 estimation estimation NN 37231 2738 56 of of IN 37231 2738 57 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2738 58 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2738 59 , , , 37231 2738 60 been be VBN 37231 2738 61 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 2738 62 altered alter VBN 37231 2738 63 . . . 37231 2739 1 Even even RB 37231 2739 2 if if IN 37231 2739 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2739 4 originally originally RB 37231 2739 5 formed form VBD 37231 2739 6 part part NN 37231 2739 7 of of IN 37231 2739 8 the the DT 37231 2739 9 text text NN 37231 2739 10 , , , 37231 2739 11 however however RB 37231 2739 12 , , , 37231 2739 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2739 14 would would MD 37231 2739 15 be be VB 37231 2739 16 wrong wrong JJ 37231 2739 17 to to TO 37231 2739 18 affirm affirm VB 37231 2739 19 that that IN 37231 2739 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2739 21 affords afford VBZ 37231 2739 22 proof proof NN 37231 2739 23 of of IN 37231 2739 24 the the DT 37231 2739 25 use use NN 37231 2739 26 or or CC 37231 2739 27 existence existence NN 37231 2739 28 of of IN 37231 2739 29 the the DT 37231 2739 30 first first JJ 37231 2739 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2739 32 . . . 37231 2740 1 The the DT 37231 2740 2 words word NNS 37231 2740 3 of of IN 37231 2740 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2740 5 in in IN 37231 2740 6 Matt Matt NNP 37231 2740 7 . . . 37231 2741 1 ix ix IN 37231 2741 2 . . . 37231 2742 1 12 12 CD 37231 2742 2 - - HYPH 37231 2742 3 -14 -14 NN 37231 2742 4 , , , 37231 2742 5 evidently evidently RB 37231 2742 6 belong belong VB 37231 2742 7 to to IN 37231 2742 8 the the DT 37231 2742 9 oldest old JJS 37231 2742 10 tradition tradition NN 37231 2742 11 of of IN 37231 2742 12 the the DT 37231 2742 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2742 14 , , , 37231 2742 15 and and CC 37231 2742 16 , , , 37231 2742 17 in in IN 37231 2742 18 fact fact NN 37231 2742 19 , , , 37231 2742 20 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 2742 21 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 2742 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2742 23 , , , 37231 2742 24 apart apart RB 37231 2742 25 from from IN 37231 2742 26 the the DT 37231 2742 27 remainder remainder NN 37231 2742 28 of of IN 37231 2742 29 the the DT 37231 2742 30 chapter chapter NN 37231 2742 31 , , , 37231 2742 32 originally originally RB 37231 2742 33 to to IN 37231 2742 34 the the DT 37231 2742 35 Spruchsammlung Spruchsammlung NNP 37231 2742 36 , , , 37231 2742 37 from from IN 37231 2742 38 which which WDT 37231 2742 39 , , , 37231 2742 40 with with IN 37231 2742 41 two two CD 37231 2742 42 intermediate intermediate JJ 37231 2742 43 books book NNS 37231 2742 44 , , , 37231 2742 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2742 46 considers consider VBZ 37231 2742 47 that that IN 37231 2742 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2742 49 present present JJ 37231 2742 50 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2742 51 was be VBD 37231 2742 52 composed compose VBN 37231 2742 53 . . . 37231 2743 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2743 2 2 2 LS 37231 2743 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2743 4 Nothing nothing NN 37231 2743 5 can can MD 37231 2743 6 be be VB 37231 2743 7 more more RBR 37231 2743 8 certain certain JJ 37231 2743 9 than than IN 37231 2743 10 that that DT 37231 2743 11 such such JJ 37231 2743 12 sayings saying NNS 37231 2743 13 , , , 37231 2743 14 if if IN 37231 2743 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2743 16 be be VBP 37231 2743 17 admitted admit VBN 37231 2743 18 to to TO 37231 2743 19 be be VB 37231 2743 20 historical historical JJ 37231 2743 21 at at RB 37231 2743 22 all all RB 37231 2743 23 , , , 37231 2743 24 must must MD 37231 2743 25 have have VB 37231 2743 26 existed exist VBN 37231 2743 27 in in IN 37231 2743 28 many many JJ 37231 2743 29 other other JJ 37231 2743 30 works work NNS 37231 2743 31 , , , 37231 2743 32 and and CC 37231 2743 33 the the DT 37231 2743 34 mere mere JJ 37231 2743 35 fact fact NN 37231 2743 36 of of IN 37231 2743 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2743 38 happening happen VBG 37231 2743 39 to to TO 37231 2743 40 be be VB 37231 2743 41 also also RB 37231 2743 42 in in IN 37231 2743 43 one one CD 37231 2743 44 of of IN 37231 2743 45 the the DT 37231 2743 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2743 47 which which WDT 37231 2743 48 has have VBZ 37231 2743 49 survived survive VBN 37231 2743 50 , , , 37231 2743 51 can can MD 37231 2743 52 not not RB 37231 2743 53 prove prove VB 37231 2743 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2743 55 use use NN 37231 2743 56 , , , 37231 2743 57 or or CC 37231 2743 58 even even RB 37231 2743 59 { { -LRB- 37231 2743 60 250 250 CD 37231 2743 61 } } -RRB- 37231 2743 62 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2743 63 existence existence NN 37231 2743 64 at at IN 37231 2743 65 the the DT 37231 2743 66 time time NN 37231 2743 67 the the DT 37231 2743 68 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2743 69 of of IN 37231 2743 70 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2743 71 was be VBD 37231 2743 72 written write VBN 37231 2743 73 , , , 37231 2743 74 more more RBR 37231 2743 75 especially especially RB 37231 2743 76 as as IN 37231 2743 77 the the DT 37231 2743 78 phrase phrase NN 37231 2743 79 does do VBZ 37231 2743 80 not not RB 37231 2743 81 occur occur VB 37231 2743 82 as as IN 37231 2743 83 a a DT 37231 2743 84 quotation quotation NN 37231 2743 85 , , , 37231 2743 86 and and CC 37231 2743 87 there there EX 37231 2743 88 is be VBZ 37231 2743 89 no no DT 37231 2743 90 indication indication NN 37231 2743 91 of of IN 37231 2743 92 the the DT 37231 2743 93 source source NN 37231 2743 94 from from IN 37231 2743 95 which which WDT 37231 2743 96 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2743 97 was be VBD 37231 2743 98 derived derive VBN 37231 2743 99 . . . 37231 2744 1 Teschendorf teschendorf NN 37231 2744 2 , , , 37231 2744 3 however however RB 37231 2744 4 , , , 37231 2744 5 finds find VBZ 37231 2744 6 a a DT 37231 2744 7 further further JJ 37231 2744 8 analogy analogy NN 37231 2744 9 between between IN 37231 2744 10 the the DT 37231 2744 11 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2744 12 and and CC 37231 2744 13 the the DT 37231 2744 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2744 15 of of IN 37231 2744 16 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2744 17 , , , 37231 2744 18 in in IN 37231 2744 19 ch ch NN 37231 2744 20 . . . 37231 2745 1 xii xii NNP 37231 2745 2 . . . 37231 2746 1 " " `` 37231 2746 2 Since since IN 37231 2746 3 , , , 37231 2746 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 2746 5 , , , 37231 2746 6 in in IN 37231 2746 7 the the DT 37231 2746 8 future future NN 37231 2746 9 , , , 37231 2746 10 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2746 11 were be VBD 37231 2746 12 to to TO 37231 2746 13 say say VB 37231 2746 14 that that IN 37231 2746 15 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2746 16 is be VBZ 37231 2746 17 the the DT 37231 2746 18 son son NN 37231 2746 19 of of IN 37231 2746 20 David David NNP 37231 2746 21 , , , 37231 2746 22 fearing fear VBG 37231 2746 23 and and CC 37231 2746 24 perceiving perceiving NN 37231 2746 25 clearly clearly RB 37231 2746 26 the the DT 37231 2746 27 error error NN 37231 2746 28 of of IN 37231 2746 29 the the DT 37231 2746 30 wicked wicked JJ 37231 2746 31 , , , 37231 2746 32 David David NNP 37231 2746 33 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2746 34 prophesies--"The prophesies--"The NNP 37231 2746 35 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2746 36 said say VBD 37231 2746 37 unto unto IN 37231 2746 38 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2746 39 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2746 40 , , , 37231 2746 41 sit sit VBP 37231 2746 42 at at IN 37231 2746 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2746 44 right right JJ 37231 2746 45 hand hand NN 37231 2746 46 until until IN 37231 2746 47 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2746 48 make make VBP 37231 2746 49 thine thine NN 37231 2746 50 enemies enemy NNS 37231 2746 51 thy thy PRP$ 37231 2746 52 footstool footstool NN 37231 2746 53 . . . 37231 2747 1 " " `` 37231 2747 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2747 3 1 1 LS 37231 2747 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2747 5 Teschendorf teschendorf NN 37231 2747 6 upon upon IN 37231 2747 7 this this DT 37231 2747 8 inquires inquire NNS 37231 2747 9 : : : 37231 2747 10 " " `` 37231 2747 11 Could Could MD 37231 2747 12 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2747 13 so so RB 37231 2747 14 write write VB 37231 2747 15 without without IN 37231 2747 16 the the DT 37231 2747 17 supposition supposition NN 37231 2747 18 , , , 37231 2747 19 that that IN 37231 2747 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2747 21 readers reader NNS 37231 2747 22 had have VBD 37231 2747 23 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2747 24 , , , 37231 2747 25 xxii xxii NNP 37231 2747 26 . . . 37231 2748 1 41 41 CD 37231 2748 2 . . . 37231 2748 3 ff ff NNP 37231 2748 4 , , , 37231 2748 5 before before IN 37231 2748 6 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2748 7 , , , 37231 2748 8 and and CC 37231 2748 9 does do VBZ 37231 2748 10 not not RB 37231 2748 11 such such PDT 37231 2748 12 a a DT 37231 2748 13 supposition supposition NN 37231 2748 14 likewise likewise RB 37231 2748 15 infer infer VBP 37231 2748 16 the the DT 37231 2748 17 actual actual JJ 37231 2748 18 authority authority NN 37231 2748 19 of of IN 37231 2748 20 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2748 21 's 's POS 37231 2748 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2748 23 ? ? . 37231 2749 1 " " `` 37231 2749 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2749 3 2 2 LS 37231 2749 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2749 5 Such such JJ 37231 2749 6 rapid rapid JJ 37231 2749 7 argument argument NN 37231 2749 8 and and CC 37231 2749 9 extreme extreme JJ 37231 2749 10 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 2749 11 are be VBP 37231 2749 12 startling startle VBG 37231 2749 13 indeed indeed RB 37231 2749 14 , , , 37231 2749 15 but but CC 37231 2749 16 , , , 37231 2749 17 in in IN 37231 2749 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2749 19 haste haste NN 37231 2749 20 , , , 37231 2749 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2749 22 critic critic NN 37231 2749 23 has have VBZ 37231 2749 24 forgotten forget VBN 37231 2749 25 to to TO 37231 2749 26 state state VB 37231 2749 27 the the DT 37231 2749 28 whole whole JJ 37231 2749 29 case case NN 37231 2749 30 . . . 37231 2750 1 The the DT 37231 2750 2 author author NN 37231 2750 3 of of IN 37231 2750 4 the the DT 37231 2750 5 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2750 6 has have VBZ 37231 2750 7 been be VBN 37231 2750 8 elaborately elaborately RB 37231 2750 9 showing show VBG 37231 2750 10 that that IN 37231 2750 11 the the DT 37231 2750 12 Cross Cross NNP 37231 2750 13 of of IN 37231 2750 14 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2750 15 is be VBZ 37231 2750 16 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 2750 17 typified typify VBN 37231 2750 18 in in IN 37231 2750 19 the the DT 37231 2750 20 Old Old NNP 37231 2750 21 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2750 22 , , , 37231 2750 23 and and CC 37231 2750 24 at at IN 37231 2750 25 the the DT 37231 2750 26 commencement commencement NN 37231 2750 27 of of IN 37231 2750 28 the the DT 37231 2750 29 chapter chapter NN 37231 2750 30 , , , 37231 2750 31 after after IN 37231 2750 32 quoting quote VBG 37231 2750 33 the the DT 37231 2750 34 passage passage NN 37231 2750 35 from from IN 37231 2750 36 IV IV NNP 37231 2750 37 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2750 38 , , , 37231 2750 39 iv iv NNP 37231 2750 40 . . . 37231 2751 1 33 33 CD 37231 2751 2 , , , 37231 2751 3 v. v. CC 37231 2751 4 5 5 CD 37231 2751 5 , , , 37231 2751 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2751 7 points point VBZ 37231 2751 8 to to IN 37231 2751 9 the the DT 37231 2751 10 case case NN 37231 2751 11 of of IN 37231 2751 12 Moses Moses NNP 37231 2751 13 , , , 37231 2751 14 to to IN 37231 2751 15 whose whose WP$ 37231 2751 16 heart heart NN 37231 2751 17 " " `` 37231 2751 18 the the DT 37231 2751 19 spirit spirit NNP 37231 2751 20 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2751 21 that that IN 37231 2751 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2751 23 should should MD 37231 2751 24 make make VB 37231 2751 25 a a DT 37231 2751 26 form form NN 37231 2751 27 of of IN 37231 2751 28 the the DT 37231 2751 29 cross cross NN 37231 2751 30 , , , 37231 2751 31 " " '' 37231 2751 32 by by IN 37231 2751 33 stretching stretch VBG 37231 2751 34 forth forth RP 37231 2751 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2751 36 arms arm NNS 37231 2751 37 in in IN 37231 2751 38 supplication supplication NN 37231 2751 39 , , , 37231 2751 40 and and CC 37231 2751 41 so so RB 37231 2751 42 long long RB 37231 2751 43 as as IN 37231 2751 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2751 45 did do VBD 37231 2751 46 so so RB 37231 2751 47 Israel Israel NNP 37231 2751 48 prevailed prevail VBD 37231 2751 49 over over IN 37231 2751 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2751 51 enemies enemy NNS 37231 2751 52 ; ; : 37231 2751 53 and and CC 37231 2751 54 again again RB 37231 2751 55 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2751 56 typified typify VBD 37231 2751 57 the the DT 37231 2751 58 cross cross NN 37231 2751 59 , , , 37231 2751 60 when when WRB 37231 2751 61 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2751 62 set set VBD 37231 2751 63 up up RP 37231 2751 64 the the DT 37231 2751 65 brazen brazen NN 37231 2751 66 serpent serpent NN 37231 2751 67 upon upon IN 37231 2751 68 which which WDT 37231 2751 69 the the DT 37231 2751 70 people people NNS 37231 2751 71 might may MD 37231 2751 72 look look VB 37231 2751 73 and and CC 37231 2751 74 be be VB 37231 2751 75 healed heal VBN 37231 2751 76 . . . 37231 2752 1 Then then RB 37231 2752 2 that that DT 37231 2752 3 which which WDT 37231 2752 4 Moses Moses NNP 37231 2752 5 , , , 37231 2752 6 as as IN 37231 2752 7 a a DT 37231 2752 8 prophet prophet NN 37231 2752 9 , , , 37231 2752 10 said say VBD 37231 2752 11 to to IN 37231 2752 12 Joshua Joshua NNP 37231 2752 13 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2752 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2752 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2752 16 the the DT 37231 2752 17 son son NN 37231 2752 18 of of IN 37231 2752 19 Nave Nave NNP 37231 2752 20 , , , 37231 2752 21 when when WRB 37231 2752 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2752 23 gave give VBD 37231 2752 24 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2752 25 that that IN 37231 2752 26 { { -LRB- 37231 2752 27 251 251 CD 37231 2752 28 } } -RRB- 37231 2752 29 name name NN 37231 2752 30 , , , 37231 2752 31 was be VBD 37231 2752 32 solely solely RB 37231 2752 33 for for IN 37231 2752 34 the the DT 37231 2752 35 purpose purpose NN 37231 2752 36 that that IN 37231 2752 37 all all PDT 37231 2752 38 the the DT 37231 2752 39 people people NNS 37231 2752 40 might may MD 37231 2752 41 hear hear VB 37231 2752 42 that that IN 37231 2752 43 the the DT 37231 2752 44 Father Father NNP 37231 2752 45 would would MD 37231 2752 46 reveal reveal VB 37231 2752 47 all all DT 37231 2752 48 things thing NNS 37231 2752 49 regarding regard VBG 37231 2752 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2752 51 Son Son NNP 37231 2752 52 to to IN 37231 2752 53 the the DT 37231 2752 54 son son NN 37231 2752 55 of of IN 37231 2752 56 Nave Nave NNP 37231 2752 57 . . . 37231 2753 1 This this DT 37231 2753 2 name name NN 37231 2753 3 being be VBG 37231 2753 4 given give VBN 37231 2753 5 to to IN 37231 2753 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2753 7 when when WRB 37231 2753 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2753 9 was be VBD 37231 2753 10 sent send VBN 37231 2753 11 to to TO 37231 2753 12 spy spy VB 37231 2753 13 out out RP 37231 2753 14 the the DT 37231 2753 15 land land NN 37231 2753 16 , , , 37231 2753 17 Moses Moses NNP 37231 2753 18 said say VBD 37231 2753 19 : : : 37231 2753 20 " " `` 37231 2753 21 Take take VB 37231 2753 22 a a DT 37231 2753 23 book book NN 37231 2753 24 in in IN 37231 2753 25 thy thy PRP$ 37231 2753 26 hands hand NNS 37231 2753 27 , , , 37231 2753 28 and and CC 37231 2753 29 write write VB 37231 2753 30 what what WP 37231 2753 31 the the DT 37231 2753 32 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2753 33 saith saith NN 37231 2753 34 , , , 37231 2753 35 that that IN 37231 2753 36 the the DT 37231 2753 37 Son Son NNP 37231 2753 38 of of IN 37231 2753 39 God God NNP 37231 2753 40 will will MD 37231 2753 41 in in IN 37231 2753 42 the the DT 37231 2753 43 last last JJ 37231 2753 44 days day NNS 37231 2753 45 cut cut VBD 37231 2753 46 off off RP 37231 2753 47 by by IN 37231 2753 48 the the DT 37231 2753 49 roots root NNS 37231 2753 50 all all PDT 37231 2753 51 the the DT 37231 2753 52 house house NN 37231 2753 53 of of IN 37231 2753 54 Amalek Amalek NNP 37231 2753 55 . . . 37231 2753 56 " " '' 37231 2754 1 This this DT 37231 2754 2 , , , 37231 2754 3 of of IN 37231 2754 4 course course NN 37231 2754 5 , , , 37231 2754 6 is be VBZ 37231 2754 7 a a DT 37231 2754 8 falsification falsification NN 37231 2754 9 of of IN 37231 2754 10 the the DT 37231 2754 11 passage passage NN 37231 2754 12 , , , 37231 2754 13 Exodus Exodus NNP 37231 2754 14 , , , 37231 2754 15 xvii xvii NN 37231 2754 16 . . . 37231 2755 1 14 14 CD 37231 2755 2 , , , 37231 2755 3 for for IN 37231 2755 4 the the DT 37231 2755 5 purpose purpose NN 37231 2755 6 of of IN 37231 2755 7 making make VBG 37231 2755 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2755 9 declare declare VB 37231 2755 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2755 11 to to TO 37231 2755 12 be be VB 37231 2755 13 the the DT 37231 2755 14 " " `` 37231 2755 15 Son Son NNP 37231 2755 16 of of IN 37231 2755 17 God God NNP 37231 2755 18 . . . 37231 2755 19 " " '' 37231 2756 1 Then then RB 37231 2756 2 proceeding proceed VBG 37231 2756 3 in in IN 37231 2756 4 the the DT 37231 2756 5 same same JJ 37231 2756 6 strain strain NN 37231 2756 7 , , , 37231 2756 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2756 9 says say VBZ 37231 2756 10 : : : 37231 2756 11 " " `` 37231 2756 12 Behold Behold NNP 37231 2756 13 again again RB 37231 2756 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2756 15 is be VBZ 37231 2756 16 not not RB 37231 2756 17 the the DT 37231 2756 18 son son NN 37231 2756 19 of of IN 37231 2756 20 Man Man NNP 37231 2756 21 , , , 37231 2756 22 but but CC 37231 2756 23 the the DT 37231 2756 24 Son Son NNP 37231 2756 25 of of IN 37231 2756 26 God God NNP 37231 2756 27 , , , 37231 2756 28 manifested manifest VBN 37231 2756 29 in in IN 37231 2756 30 the the DT 37231 2756 31 type type NN 37231 2756 32 and and CC 37231 2756 33 in in IN 37231 2756 34 the the DT 37231 2756 35 flesh flesh NN 37231 2756 36 . . . 37231 2757 1 Since since IN 37231 2757 2 , , , 37231 2757 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 2757 4 , , , 37231 2757 5 in in IN 37231 2757 6 the the DT 37231 2757 7 future future NN 37231 2757 8 , , , 37231 2757 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2757 10 were be VBD 37231 2757 11 to to TO 37231 2757 12 say say VB 37231 2757 13 that that IN 37231 2757 14 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2757 15 is be VBZ 37231 2757 16 the the DT 37231 2757 17 son son NN 37231 2757 18 of of IN 37231 2757 19 David David NNP 37231 2757 20 , , , 37231 2757 21 " " '' 37231 2757 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2757 23 and and CC 37231 2757 24 here here RB 37231 2757 25 follows follow VBZ 37231 2757 26 the the DT 37231 2757 27 passage passage NN 37231 2757 28 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2757 29 are be VBP 37231 2757 30 discussing discuss VBG 37231 2757 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2757 32 " " `` 37231 2757 33 fearing fear VBG 37231 2757 34 and and CC 37231 2757 35 perceiving perceiving NN 37231 2757 36 clearly clearly RB 37231 2757 37 the the DT 37231 2757 38 error error NN 37231 2757 39 of of IN 37231 2757 40 the the DT 37231 2757 41 wicked wicked JJ 37231 2757 42 , , , 37231 2757 43 David David NNP 37231 2757 44 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2757 45 prophesied prophesy VBD 37231 2757 46 : : : 37231 2757 47 ' ' '' 37231 2757 48 The the DT 37231 2757 49 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2757 50 said say VBD 37231 2757 51 unto unto IN 37231 2757 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2757 53 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2757 54 , , , 37231 2757 55 sit sit VBP 37231 2757 56 at at IN 37231 2757 57 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2757 58 right right JJ 37231 2757 59 hand hand NN 37231 2757 60 until until IN 37231 2757 61 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2757 62 make make VBP 37231 2757 63 thine thine NN 37231 2757 64 enemies enemy NNS 37231 2757 65 thy thy PRP$ 37231 2757 66 footstool footstool NN 37231 2757 67 . . . 37231 2757 68 ' ' '' 37231 2758 1 And and CC 37231 2758 2 again again RB 37231 2758 3 , , , 37231 2758 4 thus thus RB 37231 2758 5 speaks speak VBZ 37231 2758 6 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 37231 2758 7 : : : 37231 2758 8 ' ' '' 37231 2758 9 The the DT 37231 2758 10 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2758 11 said say VBD 37231 2758 12 to to IN 37231 2758 13 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2758 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2758 15 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2758 16 , , , 37231 2758 17 whose whose WP$ 37231 2758 18 right right JJ 37231 2758 19 hand hand NN 37231 2758 20 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2758 21 have have VBP 37231 2758 22 held hold VBN 37231 2758 23 , , , 37231 2758 24 that that IN 37231 2758 25 the the DT 37231 2758 26 nations nation NNS 37231 2758 27 may may MD 37231 2758 28 obey obey VB 37231 2758 29 Him -PRON- PRP 37231 2758 30 , , , 37231 2758 31 and and CC 37231 2758 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2758 33 will will MD 37231 2758 34 break break VB 37231 2758 35 in in IN 37231 2758 36 pieces piece NNS 37231 2758 37 the the DT 37231 2758 38 strength strength NN 37231 2758 39 of of IN 37231 2758 40 kings king NNS 37231 2758 41 . . . 37231 2758 42 ' ' '' 37231 2759 1 Behold behold VB 37231 2759 2 how how WRB 37231 2759 3 David David NNP 37231 2759 4 calleth calleth VBZ 37231 2759 5 Him Him NNP 37231 2759 6 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2759 7 , , , 37231 2759 8 and and CC 37231 2759 9 the the DT 37231 2759 10 Son Son NNP 37231 2759 11 of of IN 37231 2759 12 God God NNP 37231 2759 13 . . . 37231 2759 14 " " '' 37231 2760 1 And and CC 37231 2760 2 here here RB 37231 2760 3 ends end VBZ 37231 2760 4 the the DT 37231 2760 5 chapter chapter NN 37231 2760 6 and and CC 37231 2760 7 the the DT 37231 2760 8 subject subject NN 37231 2760 9 . . . 37231 2761 1 Now now RB 37231 2761 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2761 3 is be VBZ 37231 2761 4 quite quite RB 37231 2761 5 clear clear JJ 37231 2761 6 that that IN 37231 2761 7 the the DT 37231 2761 8 passage passage NN 37231 2761 9 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2761 10 , , , 37231 2761 11 not not RB 37231 2761 12 as as IN 37231 2761 13 a a DT 37231 2761 14 reference reference NN 37231 2761 15 to to IN 37231 2761 16 any any DT 37231 2761 17 such such JJ 37231 2761 18 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 2761 19 as as IN 37231 2761 20 that that DT 37231 2761 21 in in IN 37231 2761 22 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2761 23 , , , 37231 2761 24 xxii xxii NNP 37231 2761 25 . . . 37231 2762 1 41 41 CD 37231 2762 2 ff ff NNP 37231 2762 3 . . NNP 37231 2762 4 , , , 37231 2762 5 but but CC 37231 2762 6 simply simply RB 37231 2762 7 as as IN 37231 2762 8 one one CD 37231 2762 9 of of IN 37231 2762 10 many many JJ 37231 2762 11 passages passage NNS 37231 2762 12 which which WDT 37231 2762 13 , , , 37231 2762 14 at at IN 37231 2762 15 the the DT 37231 2762 16 commencement commencement NN 37231 2762 17 of of IN 37231 2762 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2762 19 era era NN 37231 2762 20 , , , 37231 2762 21 were be VBD 37231 2762 22 considered consider VBN 37231 2762 23 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 2762 24 declarations declaration NNS 37231 2762 25 of of IN 37231 2762 26 the the DT 37231 2762 27 divinity divinity NN 37231 2762 28 of of IN 37231 2762 29 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2762 30 , , , 37231 2762 31 in in IN 37231 2762 32 opposition opposition NN 37231 2762 33 to to IN 37231 2762 34 the the DT 37231 2762 35 expectation expectation NN 37231 2762 36 of of IN 37231 2762 37 the the DT 37231 2762 38 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 2762 39 that that WDT 37231 2762 40 the the DT 37231 2762 41 Messiah Messiah NNP 37231 2762 42 was be VBD 37231 2762 43 to to TO 37231 2762 44 be be VB 37231 2762 45 the the DT 37231 2762 46 son son NN 37231 2762 47 of of IN 37231 2762 48 David,(1 David,(1 NNP 37231 2762 49 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2762 50 and and CC 37231 2762 51 , , , 37231 2762 52 as as IN 37231 2762 53 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2762 54 have have VBP 37231 2762 55 seen see VBN 37231 2762 56 , , , 37231 2762 57 in in IN 37231 2762 58 order order NN 37231 2762 59 to to TO 37231 2762 60 prove prove VB 37231 2762 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2762 62 point point NN 37231 2762 63 the the DT 37231 2762 64 author author NN 37231 2762 65 alters alter VBZ 37231 2762 66 the the DT 37231 2762 67 text text NN 37231 2762 68 . . . 37231 2763 1 To to TO 37231 2763 2 argue argue VB 37231 2763 3 that that IN 37231 2763 4 such such PDT 37231 2763 5 a a DT 37231 2763 6 passage passage NN 37231 2763 7 of of IN 37231 2763 8 a a DT 37231 2763 9 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 2763 10 , , , 37231 2763 11 quoted quote VBN 37231 2763 12 in in IN 37231 2763 13 such such PDT 37231 2763 14 a a DT 37231 2763 15 manner manner NN 37231 2763 16 in in IN 37231 2763 17 this this DT 37231 2763 18 { { -LRB- 37231 2763 19 252 252 CD 37231 2763 20 } } -RRB- 37231 2763 21 epistle epistle NN 37231 2763 22 , , , 37231 2763 23 proves prove VBZ 37231 2763 24 the the DT 37231 2763 25 use use NN 37231 2763 26 of of IN 37231 2763 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2763 28 first first JJ 37231 2763 29 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 2763 30 , , , 37231 2763 31 is be VBZ 37231 2763 32 in in IN 37231 2763 33 the the DT 37231 2763 34 highest high JJS 37231 2763 35 degree degree NN 37231 2763 36 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 2763 37 . . . 37231 2764 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2764 2 have have VBP 37231 2764 3 already already RB 37231 2764 4 pointed point VBN 37231 2764 5 out out RP 37231 2764 6 that that IN 37231 2764 7 the the DT 37231 2764 8 author author NN 37231 2764 9 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2764 10 apocryphal apocryphal VBP 37231 2764 11 works work NNS 37231 2764 12 as as IN 37231 2764 13 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2764 14 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2764 15 ; ; : 37231 2764 16 and and CC 37231 2764 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2764 18 may may MD 37231 2764 19 now now RB 37231 2764 20 add add VB 37231 2764 21 that that IN 37231 2764 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2764 23 likewise likewise RB 37231 2764 24 cites cite VBZ 37231 2764 25 words word NNS 37231 2764 26 of of IN 37231 2764 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2764 28 which which WDT 37231 2764 29 are be VBP 37231 2764 30 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 2764 31 found find VBN 37231 2764 32 in in IN 37231 2764 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2764 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2764 35 . . . 37231 2765 1 For for IN 37231 2765 2 instance instance NN 37231 2765 3 , , , 37231 2765 4 in in IN 37231 2765 5 ch ch NN 37231 2765 6 . . . 37231 2766 1 vii vii NN 37231 2766 2 . . . 37231 2767 1 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2767 2 meet meet VBP 37231 2767 3 with with IN 37231 2767 4 the the DT 37231 2767 5 folio folio NNP 37231 2767 6 wing wing NN 37231 2767 7 expressions expression NNS 37231 2767 8 directly directly RB 37231 2767 9 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2767 10 to to IN 37231 2767 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2767 12 . . . 37231 2768 1 " " `` 37231 2768 2 Thus thus RB 37231 2768 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2768 4 say say VBP 37231 2768 5 ' ' '' 37231 2768 6 : : : 37231 2768 7 ' ' '' 37231 2768 8 Those those DT 37231 2768 9 who who WP 37231 2768 10 desire desire VBP 37231 2768 11 to to TO 37231 2768 12 behold behold VB 37231 2768 13 me -PRON- PRP 37231 2768 14 , , , 37231 2768 15 and and CC 37231 2768 16 to to TO 37231 2768 17 attain attain VB 37231 2768 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2768 19 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 2768 20 , , , 37231 2768 21 must must MD 37231 2768 22 through through IN 37231 2768 23 tribulation tribulation NN 37231 2768 24 and and CC 37231 2768 25 suffering suffering NN 37231 2768 26 receive receive VB 37231 2768 27 me -PRON- PRP 37231 2768 28 . . . 37231 2769 1 ' ' '' 37231 2769 2 " " '' 37231 2769 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2769 4 1 1 LS 37231 2769 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2769 6 Hilgenfeld(2 hilgenfeld(2 NN 37231 2769 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2769 8 compares compare VBZ 37231 2769 9 this this DT 37231 2769 10 with with IN 37231 2769 11 another another DT 37231 2769 12 passage passage NN 37231 2769 13 , , , 37231 2769 14 similar similar JJ 37231 2769 15 in in IN 37231 2769 16 sense sense NN 37231 2769 17 , , , 37231 2769 18 in in IN 37231 2769 19 IV IV NNP 37231 2769 20 Ezra Ezra NNP 37231 2769 21 , , , 37231 2769 22 vii vii NN 37231 2769 23 . . . 37231 2770 1 14 14 CD 37231 2770 2 ; ; : 37231 2770 3 but but CC 37231 2770 4 in in IN 37231 2770 5 any any DT 37231 2770 6 case case NN 37231 2770 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2770 8 is be VBZ 37231 2770 9 not not RB 37231 2770 10 a a DT 37231 2770 11 quotation quotation NN 37231 2770 12 from from IN 37231 2770 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2770 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2770 15 ; ; : 37231 2770 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2770 17 3 3 LS 37231 2770 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2770 19 and and CC 37231 2770 20 with with IN 37231 2770 21 so so RB 37231 2770 22 many many JJ 37231 2770 23 passages passage NNS 37231 2770 24 in in IN 37231 2770 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2770 26 suitable suitable JJ 37231 2770 27 to to IN 37231 2770 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2770 29 purpose purpose NN 37231 2770 30 , , , 37231 2770 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2770 32 would would MD 37231 2770 33 be be VB 37231 2770 34 amazing amazing JJ 37231 2770 35 , , , 37231 2770 36 if if IN 37231 2770 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2770 38 knew know VBD 37231 2770 39 and and CC 37231 2770 40 held hold VBD 37231 2770 41 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2770 42 in in IN 37231 2770 43 the the DT 37231 2770 44 consideration consideration NN 37231 2770 45 which which WDT 37231 2770 46 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2770 47 asserts assert VBZ 37231 2770 48 , , , 37231 2770 49 that that IN 37231 2770 50 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2770 51 should should MD 37231 2770 52 neglect neglect VB 37231 2770 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2770 54 stores store NNS 37231 2770 55 , , , 37231 2770 56 and and CC 37231 2770 57 go go VB 37231 2770 58 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2770 59 for for IN 37231 2770 60 such such JJ 37231 2770 61 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2770 62 . . . 37231 2771 1 There there EX 37231 2771 2 is be VBZ 37231 2771 3 nothing nothing NN 37231 2771 4 in in IN 37231 2771 5 this this DT 37231 2771 6 epistle epistle NN 37231 2771 7 worthy worthy JJ 37231 2771 8 of of IN 37231 2771 9 the the DT 37231 2771 10 name name NN 37231 2771 11 of of IN 37231 2771 12 evidence evidence NN 37231 2771 13 even even RB 37231 2771 14 of of IN 37231 2771 15 the the DT 37231 2771 16 existence existence NN 37231 2771 17 of of IN 37231 2771 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2771 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2771 20 . . . 37231 2772 1 3 3 LS 37231 2772 2 . . . 37231 2773 1 The the DT 37231 2773 2 Pastor Pastor NNP 37231 2773 3 of of IN 37231 2773 4 Hennas Hennas NNP 37231 2773 5 is be VBZ 37231 2773 6 another another DT 37231 2773 7 work work NN 37231 2773 8 which which WDT 37231 2773 9 very very RB 37231 2773 10 nearly nearly RB 37231 2773 11 secured secure VBD 37231 2773 12 permanent permanent JJ 37231 2773 13 canonical canonical JJ 37231 2773 14 rank rank NN 37231 2773 15 with with IN 37231 2773 16 the the DT 37231 2773 17 writings writing NNS 37231 2773 18 of of IN 37231 2773 19 the the DT 37231 2773 20 New New NNP 37231 2773 21 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2773 22 . . . 37231 2774 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2774 2 was be VBD 37231 2774 3 quoted quote VBN 37231 2774 4 as as IN 37231 2774 5 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2774 6 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2774 7 by by IN 37231 2774 8 the the DT 37231 2774 9 Fathers father NNS 37231 2774 10 and and CC 37231 2774 11 held hold VBN 37231 2774 12 to to TO 37231 2774 13 be be VB 37231 2774 14 divinely divinely RB 37231 2774 15 inspired inspire VBN 37231 2774 16 , , , 37231 2774 17 and and CC 37231 2774 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2774 19 was be VBD 37231 2774 20 publicly publicly RB 37231 2774 21 read read VBN 37231 2774 22 in in IN 37231 2774 23 the the DT 37231 2774 24 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 2774 25 . . . 37231 2775 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2775 2 4 4 LS 37231 2775 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2775 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2775 5 has have VBZ 37231 2775 6 a a DT 37231 2775 7 { { -LRB- 37231 2775 8 253 253 CD 37231 2775 9 } } -RRB- 37231 2775 10 place place NN 37231 2775 11 , , , 37231 2775 12 with with IN 37231 2775 13 the the DT 37231 2775 14 " " `` 37231 2775 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2775 16 of of IN 37231 2775 17 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 37231 2775 18 , , , 37231 2775 19 " " `` 37231 2775 20 in in IN 37231 2775 21 the the DT 37231 2775 22 Sinaitic Sinaitic NNP 37231 2775 23 Codex Codex NNP 37231 2775 24 , , , 37231 2775 25 after after IN 37231 2775 26 the the DT 37231 2775 27 canonical canonical JJ 37231 2775 28 books book NNS 37231 2775 29 . . . 37231 2776 1 In in IN 37231 2776 2 early early JJ 37231 2776 3 times time NNS 37231 2776 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2776 5 was be VBD 37231 2776 6 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2776 7 to to IN 37231 2776 8 the the DT 37231 2776 9 Hermas Hermas NNP 37231 2776 10 who who WP 37231 2776 11 is be VBZ 37231 2776 12 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2776 13 in in IN 37231 2776 14 the the DT 37231 2776 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2776 16 to to IN 37231 2776 17 the the DT 37231 2776 18 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 2776 19 , , , 37231 2776 20 xiv xiv NN 37231 2776 21 . . . 37231 2777 1 14 14 CD 37231 2777 2 , , , 37231 2777 3 in in IN 37231 2777 4 consequence consequence NN 37231 2777 5 of of IN 37231 2777 6 a a DT 37231 2777 7 mere mere JJ 37231 2777 8 conjecture conjecture NN 37231 2777 9 to to IN 37231 2777 10 that that DT 37231 2777 11 effect effect NN 37231 2777 12 by by IN 37231 2777 13 Origen;(l Origen;(l NNP 37231 2777 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2777 15 but but CC 37231 2777 16 the the DT 37231 2777 17 Canon Canon NNP 37231 2777 18 of of IN 37231 2777 19 Muratori(2 muratori(2 NN 37231 2777 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2777 21 confidently confidently RB 37231 2777 22 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 2777 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2777 24 to to IN 37231 2777 25 a a DT 37231 2777 26 brother brother NN 37231 2777 27 of of IN 37231 2777 28 Pius Pius NNP 37231 2777 29 , , , 37231 2777 30 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2777 31 of of IN 37231 2777 32 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2777 33 , , , 37231 2777 34 and and CC 37231 2777 35 at at IN 37231 2777 36 least least JJS 37231 2777 37 there there EX 37231 2777 38 does do VBZ 37231 2777 39 not not RB 37231 2777 40 seem seem VB 37231 2777 41 any any DT 37231 2777 42 ground ground NN 37231 2777 43 for for IN 37231 2777 44 the the DT 37231 2777 45 statement statement NN 37231 2777 46 of of IN 37231 2777 47 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2777 48 . . . 37231 2778 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2778 2 3 3 LS 37231 2778 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2778 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2778 5 may may MD 37231 2778 6 have have VB 37231 2778 7 been be VBN 37231 2778 8 written write VBN 37231 2778 9 about about IN 37231 2778 10 the the DT 37231 2778 11 middle middle NN 37231 2778 12 of of IN 37231 2778 13 the the DT 37231 2778 14 second second JJ 37231 2778 15 century century NN 37231 2778 16 or or CC 37231 2778 17 a a DT 37231 2778 18 little little JJ 37231 2778 19 earlier early RBR 37231 2778 20 . . . 37231 2779 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2779 2 4 4 LS 37231 2779 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2779 4 { { -LRB- 37231 2779 5 254 254 CD 37231 2779 6 } } -RRB- 37231 2779 7 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2779 8 dismisses dismiss VBZ 37231 2779 9 this this DT 37231 2779 10 important important JJ 37231 2779 11 memorial memorial NN 37231 2779 12 of of IN 37231 2779 13 the the DT 37231 2779 14 early early JJ 37231 2779 15 Christian Christian NNP 37231 2779 16 Church Church NNP 37231 2779 17 with with IN 37231 2779 18 a a DT 37231 2779 19 note note NN 37231 2779 20 of of IN 37231 2779 21 two two CD 37231 2779 22 lines line NNS 37231 2779 23 , , , 37231 2779 24 for for IN 37231 2779 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2779 26 has have VBZ 37231 2779 27 no no DT 37231 2779 28 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2779 29 either either RB 37231 2779 30 from from IN 37231 2779 31 the the DT 37231 2779 32 Old Old NNP 37231 2779 33 or or CC 37231 2779 34 New New NNP 37231 2779 35 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2779 36 . . . 37231 2780 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2780 2 1 1 LS 37231 2780 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2780 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2780 5 does do VBZ 37231 2780 6 not not RB 37231 2780 7 even even RB 37231 2780 8 suggest suggest VB 37231 2780 9 that that IN 37231 2780 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2780 11 contains contain VBZ 37231 2780 12 any any DT 37231 2780 13 indications indication NNS 37231 2780 14 of of IN 37231 2780 15 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 2780 16 with with IN 37231 2780 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2780 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2780 19 . . . 37231 2781 1 The the DT 37231 2781 2 only only JJ 37231 2781 3 direct direct JJ 37231 2781 4 quotation quotation NN 37231 2781 5 in in IN 37231 2781 6 the the DT 37231 2781 7 " " `` 37231 2781 8 Pastor Pastor NNP 37231 2781 9 " " '' 37231 2781 10 is be VBZ 37231 2781 11 from from IN 37231 2781 12 an an DT 37231 2781 13 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2781 14 work work NN 37231 2781 15 which which WDT 37231 2781 16 is be VBZ 37231 2781 17 cited cite VBN 37231 2781 18 as as IN 37231 2781 19 Holy Holy NNP 37231 2781 20 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 2781 21 : : : 37231 2781 22 " " `` 37231 2781 23 The the DT 37231 2781 24 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2781 25 is be VBZ 37231 2781 26 nigh nigh NN 37231 2781 27 unto unto IN 37231 2781 28 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2781 29 who who WP 37231 2781 30 return return VBP 37231 2781 31 to to IN 37231 2781 32 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2781 33 , , , 37231 2781 34 as as IN 37231 2781 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2781 36 is be VBZ 37231 2781 37 written write VBN 37231 2781 38 in in IN 37231 2781 39 Eldad Eldad NNP 37231 2781 40 and and CC 37231 2781 41 Modat Modat NNP 37231 2781 42 , , , 37231 2781 43 who who WP 37231 2781 44 prophesied prophesy VBD 37231 2781 45 to to IN 37231 2781 46 the the DT 37231 2781 47 people people NNS 37231 2781 48 in in IN 37231 2781 49 the the DT 37231 2781 50 wilderness wilderness NN 37231 2781 51 . . . 37231 2782 1 " " `` 37231 2782 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2782 3 2 2 LS 37231 2782 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2782 5 This this DT 37231 2782 6 work work NN 37231 2782 7 , , , 37231 2782 8 which which WDT 37231 2782 9 appears appear VBZ 37231 2782 10 in in IN 37231 2782 11 the the DT 37231 2782 12 Stichometry Stichometry NNP 37231 2782 13 of of IN 37231 2782 14 Nicephorus Nicephorus NNP 37231 2782 15 amongst amongst IN 37231 2782 16 the the DT 37231 2782 17 apocrypha apocrypha NN 37231 2782 18 of of IN 37231 2782 19 the the DT 37231 2782 20 Old Old NNP 37231 2782 21 Testament Testament NNP 37231 2782 22 , , , 37231 2782 23 is be VBZ 37231 2782 24 no no DT 37231 2782 25 longer long RBR 37231 2782 26 extant extant JJ 37231 2782 27 . . . 37231 2783 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2783 2 3 3 LS 37231 2783 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2783 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 2783 5 II II NNP 37231 2783 6 . . . 37231 2784 1 THE the DT 37231 2784 2 EPISTLES epistle NNS 37231 2784 3 OF of IN 37231 2784 4 IGNATIUS IGNATIUS NNP 37231 2784 5 -- -- : 37231 2784 6 THE the DT 37231 2784 7 EPISTLE EPISTLE NNP 37231 2784 8 OF of IN 37231 2784 9 POLYCARP POLYCARP NNP 37231 2784 10 Although although IN 37231 2784 11 , , , 37231 2784 12 in in IN 37231 2784 13 reality reality NN 37231 2784 14 , , , 37231 2784 15 appertaining appertain VBG 37231 2784 16 to to IN 37231 2784 17 a a DT 37231 2784 18 very very RB 37231 2784 19 much much RB 37231 2784 20 later later JJ 37231 2784 21 period period NN 37231 2784 22 , , , 37231 2784 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2784 24 shall shall MD 37231 2784 25 here here RB 37231 2784 26 refer refer VB 37231 2784 27 to to IN 37231 2784 28 the the DT 37231 2784 29 so so RB 37231 2784 30 - - HYPH 37231 2784 31 called call VBN 37231 2784 32 " " `` 37231 2784 33 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2784 34 of of IN 37231 2784 35 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2784 36 , , , 37231 2784 37 " " '' 37231 2784 38 and and CC 37231 2784 39 examine examine VBP 37231 2784 40 any any DT 37231 2784 41 testimony testimony NN 37231 2784 42 which which WDT 37231 2784 43 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2784 44 afford afford VBP 37231 2784 45 regarding regard VBG 37231 2784 46 the the DT 37231 2784 47 date date NN 37231 2784 48 and and CC 37231 2784 49 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2784 50 of of IN 37231 2784 51 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2784 52 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2784 53 . . . 37231 2785 1 There there EX 37231 2785 2 are be VBP 37231 2785 3 in in IN 37231 2785 4 all all DT 37231 2785 5 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 2785 6 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2785 7 bearing bear VBG 37231 2785 8 the the DT 37231 2785 9 name name NN 37231 2785 10 of of IN 37231 2785 11 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2785 12 . . . 37231 2786 1 Three three CD 37231 2786 2 of of IN 37231 2786 3 these these DT 37231 2786 4 , , , 37231 2786 5 addressed address VBD 37231 2786 6 to to IN 37231 2786 7 the the DT 37231 2786 8 Virgin Virgin NNP 37231 2786 9 Mary Mary NNP 37231 2786 10 and and CC 37231 2786 11 the the DT 37231 2786 12 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2786 13 John John NNP 37231 2786 14 2 2 CD 37231 2786 15 , , , 37231 2786 16 exist exist VBP 37231 2786 17 only only RB 37231 2786 18 in in IN 37231 2786 19 a a DT 37231 2786 20 Latin Latin NNP 37231 2786 21 version version NN 37231 2786 22 , , , 37231 2786 23 and and CC 37231 2786 24 these these DT 37231 2786 25 , , , 37231 2786 26 together together RB 37231 2786 27 with with IN 37231 2786 28 five five CD 37231 2786 29 others other NNS 37231 2786 30 directed direct VBN 37231 2786 31 to to IN 37231 2786 32 Mary Mary NNP 37231 2786 33 of of IN 37231 2786 34 Cassobolita Cassobolita NNP 37231 2786 35 , , , 37231 2786 36 to to IN 37231 2786 37 the the DT 37231 2786 38 Tarsians Tarsians NNPS 37231 2786 39 , , , 37231 2786 40 to to IN 37231 2786 41 the the DT 37231 2786 42 Antiochans Antiochans NNPS 37231 2786 43 , , , 37231 2786 44 to to IN 37231 2786 45 Hero Hero NNP 37231 2786 46 of of IN 37231 2786 47 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 2786 48 , , , 37231 2786 49 and and CC 37231 2786 50 to to IN 37231 2786 51 the the DT 37231 2786 52 Philippians Philippians NNPS 37231 2786 53 , , , 37231 2786 54 of of IN 37231 2786 55 which which WDT 37231 2786 56 there there EX 37231 2786 57 are be VBP 37231 2786 58 versions version NNS 37231 2786 59 both both DT 37231 2786 60 in in IN 37231 2786 61 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2786 62 and and CC 37231 2786 63 Latin Latin NNP 37231 2786 64 , , , 37231 2786 65 are be VBP 37231 2786 66 universally universally RB 37231 2786 67 admitted admit VBN 37231 2786 68 to to TO 37231 2786 69 be be VB 37231 2786 70 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2786 71 , , , 37231 2786 72 and and CC 37231 2786 73 may may MD 37231 2786 74 , , , 37231 2786 75 so so RB 37231 2786 76 far far RB 37231 2786 77 as as IN 37231 2786 78 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2786 79 contents content NNS 37231 2786 80 are be VBP 37231 2786 81 concerned concern VBN 37231 2786 82 , , , 37231 2786 83 be be VB 37231 2786 84 at at IN 37231 2786 85 once once RB 37231 2786 86 dismissed dismiss VBN 37231 2786 87 from from IN 37231 2786 88 all all DT 37231 2786 89 consideration consideration NN 37231 2786 90 . . . 37231 2787 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2787 2 1 1 LS 37231 2787 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2787 4 They -PRON- PRP 37231 2787 5 are be VBP 37231 2787 6 not not RB 37231 2787 7 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2787 8 by by IN 37231 2787 9 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2787 10 , , , 37231 2787 11 nor nor CC 37231 2787 12 does do VBZ 37231 2787 13 any any DT 37231 2787 14 early early JJ 37231 2787 15 writer writer NN 37231 2787 16 refer refer NN 37231 2787 17 to to IN 37231 2787 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2787 19 . . . 37231 2788 1 Of of IN 37231 2788 2 the the DT 37231 2788 3 remaining remain VBG 37231 2788 4 seven seven CD 37231 2788 5 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2788 6 , , , 37231 2788 7 addressed address VBD 37231 2788 8 to to IN 37231 2788 9 the the DT 37231 2788 10 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 2788 11 , , , 37231 2788 12 Magnesians Magnesians NNPS 37231 2788 13 , , , 37231 2788 14 Trallians Trallians NNPS 37231 2788 15 , , , 37231 2788 16 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 2788 17 , , , 37231 2788 18 Philadelphians Philadelphians NNPS 37231 2788 19 , , , 37231 2788 20 Smyrnæans Smyrnæans NNPS 37231 2788 21 , , , 37231 2788 22 and and CC 37231 2788 23 to to IN 37231 2788 24 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2788 25 , , , 37231 2788 26 there there EX 37231 2788 27 are be VBP 37231 2788 28 two two CD 37231 2788 29 distinct distinct JJ 37231 2788 30 versions version NNS 37231 2788 31 extant extant JJ 37231 2788 32 , , , 37231 2788 33 one one CD 37231 2788 34 long long JJ 37231 2788 35 version version NN 37231 2788 36 , , , 37231 2788 37 of of IN 37231 2788 38 which which WDT 37231 2788 39 there there EX 37231 2788 40 are be VBP 37231 2788 41 both both DT 37231 2788 42 Greek greek JJ 37231 2788 43 and and CC 37231 2788 44 Latin latin JJ 37231 2788 45 texts text NNS 37231 2788 46 , , , 37231 2788 47 and and CC 37231 2788 48 another another DT 37231 2788 49 much much RB 37231 2788 50 shorter short JJR 37231 2788 51 , , , 37231 2788 52 and and CC 37231 2788 53 presenting present VBG 37231 2788 54 considerable considerable JJ 37231 2788 55 variations variation NNS 37231 2788 56 , , , 37231 2788 57 of of IN 37231 2788 58 which which WDT 37231 2788 59 there there EX 37231 2788 60 are be VBP 37231 2788 61 also also RB 37231 2788 62 both both DT 37231 2788 63 Greek greek JJ 37231 2788 64 and and CC 37231 2788 65 Latin latin JJ 37231 2788 66 texts text NNS 37231 2788 67 . . . 37231 2789 1 After after IN 37231 2789 2 a a DT 37231 2789 3 couple couple NN 37231 2789 4 of of IN 37231 2789 5 centuries century NNS 37231 2789 6 of of IN 37231 2789 7 discussion discussion NN 37231 2789 8 , , , 37231 2789 9 critics critic NNS 37231 2789 10 { { -LRB- 37231 2789 11 256 256 CD 37231 2789 12 } } -RRB- 37231 2789 13 almost almost RB 37231 2789 14 without without IN 37231 2789 15 exception exception NN 37231 2789 16 have have VBP 37231 2789 17 finally finally RB 37231 2789 18 agreed agree VBN 37231 2789 19 that that IN 37231 2789 20 the the DT 37231 2789 21 longer long JJR 37231 2789 22 version version NN 37231 2789 23 is be VBZ 37231 2789 24 nothing nothing NN 37231 2789 25 more more JJR 37231 2789 26 than than IN 37231 2789 27 an an DT 37231 2789 28 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 2789 29 version version NN 37231 2789 30 of of IN 37231 2789 31 the the DT 37231 2789 32 shorter short JJR 37231 2789 33 and and CC 37231 2789 34 more more JJR 37231 2789 35 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2789 36 form form NN 37231 2789 37 of of IN 37231 2789 38 the the DT 37231 2789 39 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2789 40 . . . 37231 2790 1 The the DT 37231 2790 2 question question NN 37231 2790 3 regarding regard VBG 37231 2790 4 the the DT 37231 2790 5 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2790 6 of of IN 37231 2790 7 the the DT 37231 2790 8 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 37231 2790 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2790 10 , , , 37231 2790 11 however however RB 37231 2790 12 , , , 37231 2790 13 was be VBD 37231 2790 14 re re VBN 37231 2790 15 - - VBN 37231 2790 16 opened opened JJ 37231 2790 17 and and CC 37231 2790 18 complicated complicate VBN 37231 2790 19 by by IN 37231 2790 20 the the DT 37231 2790 21 publication publication NN 37231 2790 22 , , , 37231 2790 23 in in IN 37231 2790 24 1845 1845 CD 37231 2790 25 , , , 37231 2790 26 by by IN 37231 2790 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2790 28 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 2790 29 , , , 37231 2790 30 of of IN 37231 2790 31 a a DT 37231 2790 32 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2790 33 version version NN 37231 2790 34 of of IN 37231 2790 35 three three CD 37231 2790 36 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2790 37 only only RB 37231 2790 38 -- -- : 37231 2790 39 to to IN 37231 2790 40 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2790 41 , , , 37231 2790 42 to to IN 37231 2790 43 the the DT 37231 2790 44 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 2790 45 , , , 37231 2790 46 and and CC 37231 2790 47 to to IN 37231 2790 48 the the DT 37231 2790 49 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 2790 50 -- -- : 37231 2790 51 in in IN 37231 2790 52 a a DT 37231 2790 53 still still RB 37231 2790 54 shorter short JJR 37231 2790 55 form form NN 37231 2790 56 , , , 37231 2790 57 discovered discover VBD 37231 2790 58 amongst amongst IN 37231 2790 59 a a DT 37231 2790 60 large large JJ 37231 2790 61 number number NN 37231 2790 62 of of IN 37231 2790 63 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2790 64 . . . 37231 2791 1 purchased purchase VBN 37231 2791 2 by by IN 37231 2791 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2791 4 Tattam Tattam NNP 37231 2791 5 from from IN 37231 2791 6 the the DT 37231 2791 7 monks monk NNS 37231 2791 8 of of IN 37231 2791 9 the the DT 37231 2791 10 Desert Desert NNP 37231 2791 11 of of IN 37231 2791 12 Nitria Nitria NNP 37231 2791 13 . . . 37231 2792 1 These these DT 37231 2792 2 three three CD 37231 2792 3 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2792 4 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2792 5 have have VBP 37231 2792 6 been be VBN 37231 2792 7 subjected subject VBN 37231 2792 8 to to IN 37231 2792 9 the the DT 37231 2792 10 severest severe JJS 37231 2792 11 scrutiny scrutiny NN 37231 2792 12 , , , 37231 2792 13 and and CC 37231 2792 14 many many JJ 37231 2792 15 of of IN 37231 2792 16 the the DT 37231 2792 17 ablest able JJS 37231 2792 18 critics critic NNS 37231 2792 19 have have VBP 37231 2792 20 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 2792 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2792 22 to to TO 37231 2792 23 be be VB 37231 2792 24 the the DT 37231 2792 25 only only JJ 37231 2792 26 authentic authentic JJ 37231 2792 27 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2792 28 of of IN 37231 2792 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2792 30 , , , 37231 2792 31 whilst whilst IN 37231 2792 32 others other NNS 37231 2792 33 , , , 37231 2792 34 who who WP 37231 2792 35 do do VBP 37231 2792 36 not not RB 37231 2792 37 admit admit VB 37231 2792 38 that that IN 37231 2792 39 even even RB 37231 2792 40 these these DT 37231 2792 41 are be VBP 37231 2792 42 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2792 43 letters letter NNS 37231 2792 44 emanating emanate VBG 37231 2792 45 from from IN 37231 2792 46 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2792 47 , , , 37231 2792 48 still still RB 37231 2792 49 prefer prefer VB 37231 2792 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2792 51 to to IN 37231 2792 52 the the DT 37231 2792 53 version version NN 37231 2792 54 of of IN 37231 2792 55 seven seven CD 37231 2792 56 Greek greek JJ 37231 2792 57 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2792 58 , , , 37231 2792 59 and and CC 37231 2792 60 consider consider VB 37231 2792 61 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2792 62 the the DT 37231 2792 63 most most RBS 37231 2792 64 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2792 65 form form NN 37231 2792 66 of of IN 37231 2792 67 the the DT 37231 2792 68 letters letter NNS 37231 2792 69 which which WDT 37231 2792 70 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2792 71 possess possess VBP 37231 2792 72 . . . 37231 2793 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2793 2 1 1 LS 37231 2793 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2793 4 As as RB 37231 2793 5 early early RB 37231 2793 6 as as IN 37231 2793 7 the the DT 37231 2793 8 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 37231 2793 9 century century NN 37231 2793 10 , , , 37231 2793 11 however however RB 37231 2793 12 , , , 37231 2793 13 the the DT 37231 2793 14 strongest strong JJS 37231 2793 15 doubts doubt NNS 37231 2793 16 were be VBD 37231 2793 17 expressed express VBN 37231 2793 18 regarding regard VBG 37231 2793 19 the the DT 37231 2793 20 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2793 21 of of IN 37231 2793 22 any any DT 37231 2793 23 of of IN 37231 2793 24 the the DT 37231 2793 25 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2793 26 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2793 27 to to IN 37231 2793 28 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2793 29 . . . 37231 2794 1 The the DT 37231 2794 2 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 37231 2794 3 { { -LRB- 37231 2794 4 257 257 CD 37231 2794 5 } } -RRB- 37231 2794 6 Centuriators Centuriators NNPS 37231 2794 7 first first RB 37231 2794 8 attacked attack VBD 37231 2794 9 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2794 10 , , , 37231 2794 11 and and CC 37231 2794 12 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 2794 13 declared declare VBD 37231 2794 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2794 15 to to TO 37231 2794 16 be be VB 37231 2794 17 spurious,(1 spurious,(1 NN 37231 2794 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2794 19 an an DT 37231 2794 20 opinion opinion NN 37231 2794 21 fully fully RB 37231 2794 22 shared share VBN 37231 2794 23 by by IN 37231 2794 24 Dallaeus Dallaeus NNP 37231 2794 25 , , , 37231 2794 26 and and CC 37231 2794 27 others other NNS 37231 2794 28 ; ; : 37231 2794 29 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 37231 2794 30 regarded regard VBD 37231 2794 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2794 32 with with IN 37231 2794 33 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 2794 34 ; ; : 37231 2794 35 and and CC 37231 2794 36 similar similar JJ 37231 2794 37 doubts doubt NNS 37231 2794 38 , , , 37231 2794 39 more more JJR 37231 2794 40 or or CC 37231 2794 41 lass lass VB 37231 2794 42 definite definite NNP 37231 2794 43 , , , 37231 2794 44 were be VBD 37231 2794 45 expressed express VBN 37231 2794 46 throughout throughout IN 37231 2794 47 the the DT 37231 2794 48 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 37231 2794 49 century,(2 century,(2 NNS 37231 2794 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2794 51 and and CC 37231 2794 52 onward onward RB 37231 2794 53 to to IN 37231 2794 54 comparatively comparatively RB 37231 2794 55 recent recent JJ 37231 2794 56 times,(3 times,(3 NN 37231 2794 57 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2794 58 although although IN 37231 2794 59 the the DT 37231 2794 60 means mean NNS 37231 2794 61 of of IN 37231 2794 62 forming form VBG 37231 2794 63 a a DT 37231 2794 64 judgment judgment NN 37231 2794 65 were be VBD 37231 2794 66 not not RB 37231 2794 67 then then RB 37231 2794 68 so so RB 37231 2794 69 complete complete JJ 37231 2794 70 as as IN 37231 2794 71 now now RB 37231 2794 72 . . . 37231 2795 1 That that IN 37231 2795 2 the the DT 37231 2795 3 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2795 4 were be VBD 37231 2795 5 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 2795 6 there there EX 37231 2795 7 was be VBD 37231 2795 8 no no DT 37231 2795 9 doubt doubt NN 37231 2795 10 . . . 37231 2796 1 Fuller full JJR 37231 2796 2 examination examination NN 37231 2796 3 and and CC 37231 2796 4 more more RBR 37231 2796 5 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 37231 2796 6 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 2796 7 of of IN 37231 2796 8 the the DT 37231 2796 9 subject subject NN 37231 2796 10 have have VBP 37231 2796 11 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 2796 12 earlier early JJR 37231 2796 13 doubts doubt NNS 37231 2796 14 , , , 37231 2796 15 and and CC 37231 2796 16 a a DT 37231 2796 17 large large JJ 37231 2796 18 mass mass NN 37231 2796 19 of of IN 37231 2796 20 critics critic NNS 37231 2796 21 either either CC 37231 2796 22 recognize recognize VBP 37231 2796 23 that that IN 37231 2796 24 the the DT 37231 2796 25 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2796 26 of of IN 37231 2796 27 none none NN 37231 2796 28 of of IN 37231 2796 29 these these DT 37231 2796 30 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2796 31 can can MD 37231 2796 32 be be VB 37231 2796 33 established establish VBN 37231 2796 34 , , , 37231 2796 35 or or CC 37231 2796 36 that that IN 37231 2796 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2796 38 { { -LRB- 37231 2796 39 258 258 CD 37231 2796 40 } } -RRB- 37231 2796 41 can can MD 37231 2796 42 only only RB 37231 2796 43 be be VB 37231 2796 44 considered consider VBN 37231 2796 45 later later RB 37231 2796 46 and and CC 37231 2796 47 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2796 48 compositions composition NNS 37231 2796 49 . . . 37231 2797 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2797 2 1 1 LS 37231 2797 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2797 4 Omitting omit VBG 37231 2797 5 for for IN 37231 2797 6 the the DT 37231 2797 7 present present NN 37231 2797 8 the the DT 37231 2797 9 so so RB 37231 2797 10 - - HYPH 37231 2797 11 called call VBN 37231 2797 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2797 13 of of IN 37231 2797 14 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2797 15 to to IN 37231 2797 16 the the DT 37231 2797 17 Philippians Philippians NNPS 37231 2797 18 , , , 37231 2797 19 the the DT 37231 2797 20 earliest early JJS 37231 2797 21 reference reference NN 37231 2797 22 to to IN 37231 2797 23 any any DT 37231 2797 24 of of IN 37231 2797 25 these these DT 37231 2797 26 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2797 27 , , , 37231 2797 28 or or CC 37231 2797 29 to to IN 37231 2797 30 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2797 31 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2797 32 , , , 37231 2797 33 is be VBZ 37231 2797 34 made make VBN 37231 2797 35 by by IN 37231 2797 36 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2797 37 , , , 37231 2797 38 who who WP 37231 2797 39 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2797 40 a a DT 37231 2797 41 passage passage NN 37231 2797 42 which which WDT 37231 2797 43 is be VBZ 37231 2797 44 found find VBN 37231 2797 45 in in IN 37231 2797 46 the the DT 37231 2797 47 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2797 48 to to IN 37231 2797 49 the the DT 37231 2797 50 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 2797 51 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2797 52 ch ch NN 37231 2797 53 . . . 37231 2798 1 iv iv XX 37231 2798 2 . . . 37231 2799 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2799 2 , , , 37231 2799 3 without without IN 37231 2799 4 , , , 37231 2799 5 however however RB 37231 2799 6 , , , 37231 2799 7 any any DT 37231 2799 8 mention mention NN 37231 2799 9 of of IN 37231 2799 10 name name NN 37231 2799 11 , , , 37231 2799 12 ' ' '' 37231 2799 13 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2799 14 by by IN 37231 2799 15 the the DT 37231 2799 16 following follow VBG 37231 2799 17 words word NNS 37231 2799 18 : : : 37231 2799 19 " " `` 37231 2799 20 As as IN 37231 2799 21 a a DT 37231 2799 22 certain certain JJ 37231 2799 23 man man NN 37231 2799 24 of of IN 37231 2799 25 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 2799 26 said say VBD 37231 2799 27 , , , 37231 2799 28 being be VBG 37231 2799 29 condemned condemn VBN 37231 2799 30 to to IN 37231 2799 31 the the DT 37231 2799 32 wild wild JJ 37231 2799 33 beasts beast NNS 37231 2799 34 on on IN 37231 2799 35 account account NN 37231 2799 36 of of IN 37231 2799 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2799 38 testimony testimony NN 37231 2799 39 to to IN 37231 2799 40 God God NNP 37231 2799 41 : : : 37231 2799 42 ' ' '' 37231 2799 43 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2799 44 am be VBP 37231 2799 45 the the DT 37231 2799 46 wheat wheat NN 37231 2799 47 of of IN 37231 2799 48 God God NNP 37231 2799 49 , , , 37231 2799 50 and and CC 37231 2799 51 by by IN 37231 2799 52 the the DT 37231 2799 53 teeth tooth NNS 37231 2799 54 of of IN 37231 2799 55 beasts beast NNS 37231 2799 56 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2799 57 am be VBP 37231 2799 58 ground ground NN 37231 2799 59 , , , 37231 2799 60 that that IN 37231 2799 61 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2799 62 may may MD 37231 2799 63 be be VB 37231 2799 64 found find VBN 37231 2799 65 pure pure JJ 37231 2799 66 { { -LRB- 37231 2799 67 259 259 CD 37231 2799 68 } } -RRB- 37231 2799 69 bread bread NN 37231 2799 70 . . . 37231 2800 1 " " `` 37231 2800 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2800 3 1 1 LS 37231 2800 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2800 5 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2800 6 likewise likewise RB 37231 2800 7 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2800 8 two two CD 37231 2800 9 brief brief JJ 37231 2800 10 sentences sentence NNS 37231 2800 11 which which WDT 37231 2800 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2800 13 refers refer VBZ 37231 2800 14 to to IN 37231 2800 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2800 16 . . . 37231 2801 1 The the DT 37231 2801 2 first first JJ 37231 2801 3 is be VBZ 37231 2801 4 merely merely RB 37231 2801 5 : : : 37231 2801 6 " " `` 37231 2801 7 But but CC 37231 2801 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2801 9 love love NN 37231 2801 10 is be VBZ 37231 2801 11 crucified,"(2 crucified,"(2 NFP 37231 2801 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2801 13 which which WDT 37231 2801 14 is be VBZ 37231 2801 15 likewise likewise RB 37231 2801 16 found find VBN 37231 2801 17 in in IN 37231 2801 18 the the DT 37231 2801 19 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2801 20 to to IN 37231 2801 21 the the DT 37231 2801 22 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 2801 23 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2801 24 ch ch NN 37231 2801 25 . . . 37231 2802 1 vii vii NN 37231 2802 2 . . . 37231 2803 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2803 2 ; ; : 37231 2803 3 and and CC 37231 2803 4 the the DT 37231 2803 5 other other JJ 37231 2803 6 quoted quote VBN 37231 2803 7 as as IN 37231 2803 8 " " `` 37231 2803 9 out out IN 37231 2803 10 of of IN 37231 2803 11 one one CD 37231 2803 12 of of IN 37231 2803 13 the the DT 37231 2803 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2803 15 " " '' 37231 2803 16 of of IN 37231 2803 17 the the DT 37231 2803 18 martyr martyr NN 37231 2803 19 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2803 20 : : : 37231 2803 21 " " `` 37231 2803 22 From from IN 37231 2803 23 the the DT 37231 2803 24 Prince Prince NNP 37231 2803 25 of of IN 37231 2803 26 this this DT 37231 2803 27 world world NN 37231 2803 28 was be VBD 37231 2803 29 concealed conceal VBN 37231 2803 30 the the DT 37231 2803 31 virginity virginity NN 37231 2803 32 of of IN 37231 2803 33 Mary,"(3 Mary,"(3 NNP 37231 2803 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2803 35 which which WDT 37231 2803 36 is be VBZ 37231 2803 37 found find VBN 37231 2803 38 in in IN 37231 2803 39 the the DT 37231 2803 40 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2803 41 to to IN 37231 2803 42 the the DT 37231 2803 43 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 2803 44 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2803 45 ch ch NN 37231 2803 46 . . . 37231 2804 1 xix xix NNP 37231 2804 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2804 3 . . . 37231 2805 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 2805 2 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2805 3 seven seven CD 37231 2805 4 epistles,(4 epistles,(4 NN 37231 2805 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2805 6 and and CC 37231 2805 7 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2805 8 one one CD 37231 2805 9 passage passage NN 37231 2805 10 from from IN 37231 2805 11 the the DT 37231 2805 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2805 13 to to IN 37231 2805 14 the the DT 37231 2805 15 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 2805 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2805 17 ch ch NN 37231 2805 18 . . . 37231 2806 1 v. v. NNP 37231 2806 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2806 3 , , , 37231 2806 4 and and CC 37231 2806 5 a a DT 37231 2806 6 few few JJ 37231 2806 7 words word NNS 37231 2806 8 from from IN 37231 2806 9 an an DT 37231 2806 10 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2806 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2806 12 contained contain VBN 37231 2806 13 in in IN 37231 2806 14 the the DT 37231 2806 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2806 16 to to IN 37231 2806 17 the the DT 37231 2806 18 Smyrnæans Smyrnæans NNPS 37231 2806 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2806 20 ch ch NN 37231 2806 21 . . . 37231 2807 1 iii iii NNP 37231 2807 2 . . . 37231 2808 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2808 2 , , , 37231 2808 3 the the DT 37231 2808 4 source source NN 37231 2808 5 of of IN 37231 2808 6 which which WDT 37231 2808 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2808 8 says say VBZ 37231 2808 9 that that IN 37231 2808 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2808 11 does do VBZ 37231 2808 12 not not RB 37231 2808 13 know know VB 37231 2808 14 , , , 37231 2808 15 and and CC 37231 2808 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2808 17 cites cite VBZ 37231 2808 18 from from IN 37231 2808 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2808 20 the the DT 37231 2808 21 brief brief JJ 37231 2808 22 quotation quotation NN 37231 2808 23 given give VBN 37231 2808 24 above above RB 37231 2808 25 , , , 37231 2808 26 and and CC 37231 2808 27 refers refer VBZ 37231 2808 28 to to IN 37231 2808 29 the the DT 37231 2808 30 mention mention NN 37231 2808 31 of of IN 37231 2808 32 the the DT 37231 2808 33 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2808 34 in in IN 37231 2808 35 the the DT 37231 2808 36 letter letter NN 37231 2808 37 of of IN 37231 2808 38 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2808 39 which which WDT 37231 2808 40 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2808 41 reserve reserve VBP 37231 2808 42 . . . 37231 2809 1 Elsewhere,(5 elsewhere,(5 NN 37231 2809 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2809 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2809 4 further further RB 37231 2809 5 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2809 6 a a DT 37231 2809 7 short short JJ 37231 2809 8 sentence sentence NN 37231 2809 9 found find VBN 37231 2809 10 in in IN 37231 2809 11 the the DT 37231 2809 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2809 13 to to IN 37231 2809 14 the the DT 37231 2809 15 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 2809 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2809 17 ch ch NN 37231 2809 18 . . . 37231 2810 1 xix xix NNP 37231 2810 2 . . . 37231 2811 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2811 2 , , , 37231 2811 3 part part NN 37231 2811 4 of of IN 37231 2811 5 which which WDT 37231 2811 6 had have VBD 37231 2811 7 previously previously RB 37231 2811 8 been be VBN 37231 2811 9 cited cite VBN 37231 2811 10 by by IN 37231 2811 11 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2811 12 . . . 37231 2812 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2812 2 will will MD 37231 2812 3 be be VB 37231 2812 4 observed observe VBN 37231 2812 5 that that IN 37231 2812 6 all all PDT 37231 2812 7 these these DT 37231 2812 8 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2812 9 , , , 37231 2812 10 with with IN 37231 2812 11 the the DT 37231 2812 12 exception exception NN 37231 2812 13 of of IN 37231 2812 14 that that DT 37231 2812 15 from from IN 37231 2812 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2812 17 , , , 37231 2812 18 are be VBP 37231 2812 19 taken take VBN 37231 2812 20 from from IN 37231 2812 21 the the DT 37231 2812 22 three three CD 37231 2812 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2812 24 which which WDT 37231 2812 25 exist exist VBP 37231 2812 26 in in IN 37231 2812 27 the the DT 37231 2812 28 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2812 29 translation translation NN 37231 2812 30 , , , 37231 2812 31 and and CC 37231 2812 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2812 33 are be VBP 37231 2812 34 found find VBN 37231 2812 35 in in IN 37231 2812 36 that that DT 37231 2812 37 version version NN 37231 2812 38 ; ; : 37231 2812 39 and and CC 37231 2812 40 the the DT 37231 2812 41 first first JJ 37231 2812 42 occasion occasion NN 37231 2812 43 on on IN 37231 2812 44 which which WDT 37231 2812 45 any any DT 37231 2812 46 passage passage NN 37231 2812 47 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2812 48 to to IN 37231 2812 49 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2812 50 is be VBZ 37231 2812 51 quoted quote VBN 37231 2812 52 which which WDT 37231 2812 53 is be VBZ 37231 2812 54 not not RB 37231 2812 55 in in IN 37231 2812 56 the the DT 37231 2812 57 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2812 58 version version NN 37231 2812 59 of of IN 37231 2812 60 the the DT 37231 2812 61 three three CD 37231 2812 62 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2812 63 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2812 64 in in IN 37231 2812 65 the the DT 37231 2812 66 second second JJ 37231 2812 67 half half NN 37231 2812 68 of of IN 37231 2812 69 the the DT 37231 2812 70 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2812 71 century century NN 37231 2812 72 , , , 37231 2812 73 when when WRB 37231 2812 74 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 37231 2812 75 , , , 37231 2812 76 in in IN 37231 2812 77 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2812 78 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2812 79 regarding regard VBG 37231 2812 80 the the DT 37231 2812 81 Synods Synods NNPS 37231 2812 82 of of IN 37231 2812 83 Ariminum Ariminum NNP 37231 2812 84 and and CC 37231 2812 85 Selucia,(6 Selucia,(6 NNP 37231 2812 86 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2812 87 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2812 88 a a DT 37231 2812 89 few few JJ 37231 2812 90 words word NNS 37231 2812 91 from from IN 37231 2812 92 the the DT 37231 2812 93 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2812 94 to to IN 37231 2812 95 the the DT 37231 2812 96 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 2812 97 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2812 98 ch ch NN 37231 2812 99 . . . 37231 2813 1 vii vii NN 37231 2813 2 . . . 37231 2814 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2814 2 ; ; : 37231 2814 3 but but CC 37231 2814 4 although although IN 37231 2814 5 foreign foreign NN 37231 2814 6 to to IN 37231 2814 7 the the DT 37231 2814 8 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2814 9 text text NN 37231 2814 10 , , , 37231 2814 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2814 12 is be VBZ 37231 2814 13 to to TO 37231 2814 14 be be VB 37231 2814 15 noted note VBN 37231 2814 16 that that IN 37231 2814 17 the the DT 37231 2814 18 words word NNS 37231 2814 19 are be VBP 37231 2814 20 { { -LRB- 37231 2814 21 260 260 CD 37231 2814 22 } } -RRB- 37231 2814 23 at at IN 37231 2814 24 least least JJS 37231 2814 25 from from IN 37231 2814 26 a a DT 37231 2814 27 form form NN 37231 2814 28 of of IN 37231 2814 29 one one CD 37231 2814 30 of of IN 37231 2814 31 the the DT 37231 2814 32 three three CD 37231 2814 33 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2814 34 which which WDT 37231 2814 35 exist exist VBP 37231 2814 36 in in IN 37231 2814 37 that that DT 37231 2814 38 version version NN 37231 2814 39 . . . 37231 2815 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2815 2 1 1 LS 37231 2815 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2815 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2815 5 is be VBZ 37231 2815 6 a a DT 37231 2815 7 fact fact NN 37231 2815 8 , , , 37231 2815 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 2815 10 , , , 37231 2815 11 that that IN 37231 2815 12 up up IN 37231 2815 13 to to IN 37231 2815 14 the the DT 37231 2815 15 second second JJ 37231 2815 16 half half NN 37231 2815 17 of of IN 37231 2815 18 the the DT 37231 2815 19 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2815 20 century century NN 37231 2815 21 no no DT 37231 2815 22 quotation quotation NN 37231 2815 23 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2815 24 to to IN 37231 2815 25 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2815 26 , , , 37231 2815 27 except except IN 37231 2815 28 one one CD 37231 2815 29 by by IN 37231 2815 30 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2815 31 , , , 37231 2815 32 exists exist VBZ 37231 2815 33 , , , 37231 2815 34 which which WDT 37231 2815 35 is be VBZ 37231 2815 36 not not RB 37231 2815 37 found find VBN 37231 2815 38 in in IN 37231 2815 39 the the DT 37231 2815 40 three three CD 37231 2815 41 short short JJ 37231 2815 42 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2815 43 letters letter NNS 37231 2815 44 . . . 37231 2816 1 As as IN 37231 2816 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2816 3 have have VBP 37231 2816 4 already already RB 37231 2816 5 remarked remark VBN 37231 2816 6 , , , 37231 2816 7 the the DT 37231 2816 8 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2816 9 version version NN 37231 2816 10 of of IN 37231 2816 11 the the DT 37231 2816 12 three three CD 37231 2816 13 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2816 14 is be VBZ 37231 2816 15 very very RB 37231 2816 16 much much RB 37231 2816 17 shorter short JJR 37231 2816 18 than than IN 37231 2816 19 the the DT 37231 2816 20 shorter short JJR 37231 2816 21 Greek greek JJ 37231 2816 22 version version NN 37231 2816 23 , , , 37231 2816 24 the the DT 37231 2816 25 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2816 26 to to IN 37231 2816 27 the the DT 37231 2816 28 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 2816 29 , , , 37231 2816 30 for for IN 37231 2816 31 instance instance NN 37231 2816 32 , , , 37231 2816 33 being be VBG 37231 2816 34 only only RB 37231 2816 35 about about RB 37231 2816 36 one one CD 37231 2816 37 - - HYPH 37231 2816 38 third third NN 37231 2816 39 of of IN 37231 2816 40 the the DT 37231 2816 41 length length NN 37231 2816 42 of of IN 37231 2816 43 the the DT 37231 2816 44 Greek greek JJ 37231 2816 45 text text NN 37231 2816 46 . . . 37231 2817 1 Those those DT 37231 2817 2 who who WP 37231 2817 3 still still RB 37231 2817 4 maintain maintain VBP 37231 2817 5 the the DT 37231 2817 6 superior superior JJ 37231 2817 7 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2817 8 of of IN 37231 2817 9 the the DT 37231 2817 10 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2817 11 shorter short JJR 37231 2817 12 version version NN 37231 2817 13 argue argue VBP 37231 2817 14 that that IN 37231 2817 15 the the DT 37231 2817 16 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2817 17 is be VBZ 37231 2817 18 an an DT 37231 2817 19 epitome epitome NN 37231 2817 20 of of IN 37231 2817 21 the the DT 37231 2817 22 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2817 23 . . . 37231 2818 1 This this DT 37231 2818 2 does do VBZ 37231 2818 3 not not RB 37231 2818 4 , , , 37231 2818 5 however however RB 37231 2818 6 , , , 37231 2818 7 seem seem VB 37231 2818 8 tenable tenable JJ 37231 2818 9 when when WRB 37231 2818 10 the the DT 37231 2818 11 matter matter NN 37231 2818 12 is be VBZ 37231 2818 13 carefully carefully RB 37231 2818 14 examined examine VBN 37231 2818 15 . . . 37231 2819 1 Although although IN 37231 2819 2 so so RB 37231 2819 3 much much JJ 37231 2819 4 is be VBZ 37231 2819 5 absent absent JJ 37231 2819 6 from from IN 37231 2819 7 the the DT 37231 2819 8 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2819 9 version version NN 37231 2819 10 , , , 37231 2819 11 not not RB 37231 2819 12 only only RB 37231 2819 13 is be VBZ 37231 2819 14 there there EX 37231 2819 15 no no DT 37231 2819 16 interruption interruption NN 37231 2819 17 of of IN 37231 2819 18 the the DT 37231 2819 19 sense sense NN 37231 2819 20 and and CC 37231 2819 21 no no DT 37231 2819 22 obscurity obscurity NN 37231 2819 23 or or CC 37231 2819 24 undue undue JJ 37231 2819 25 curtness curtness NN 37231 2819 26 in in IN 37231 2819 27 the the DT 37231 2819 28 style style NN 37231 2819 29 , , , 37231 2819 30 but but CC 37231 2819 31 the the DT 37231 2819 32 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2819 33 read read VBP 37231 2819 34 more more RBR 37231 2819 35 consecutively consecutively RB 37231 2819 36 , , , 37231 2819 37 without without IN 37231 2819 38 faults fault NNS 37231 2819 39 of of IN 37231 2819 40 construction construction NN 37231 2819 41 or or CC 37231 2819 42 grammar grammar NN 37231 2819 43 , , , 37231 2819 44 and and CC 37231 2819 45 passages passage NNS 37231 2819 46 which which WDT 37231 2819 47 in in IN 37231 2819 48 the the DT 37231 2819 49 Greek greek JJ 37231 2819 50 text text NN 37231 2819 51 were be VBD 37231 2819 52 confused confused JJ 37231 2819 53 and and CC 37231 2819 54 almost almost RB 37231 2819 55 unintelligible unintelligible JJ 37231 2819 56 have have VBP 37231 2819 57 become become VBN 37231 2819 58 quite quite RB 37231 2819 59 clear clear JJ 37231 2819 60 in in IN 37231 2819 61 the the DT 37231 2819 62 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2819 63 . . . 37231 2820 1 The the DT 37231 2820 2 interpolations interpolation NNS 37231 2820 3 of of IN 37231 2820 4 the the DT 37231 2820 5 text text NN 37231 2820 6 , , , 37231 2820 7 in in IN 37231 2820 8 fact fact NN 37231 2820 9 , , , 37231 2820 10 had have VBD 37231 2820 11 been be VBN 37231 2820 12 so so RB 37231 2820 13 clumsily clumsily RB 37231 2820 14 made make VBN 37231 2820 15 , , , 37231 2820 16 that that IN 37231 2820 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2820 18 had have VBD 37231 2820 19 obscured obscure VBN 37231 2820 20 the the DT 37231 2820 21 meaning meaning NN 37231 2820 22 , , , 37231 2820 23 and and CC 37231 2820 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2820 25 mere mere JJ 37231 2820 26 omission omission NN 37231 2820 27 , , , 37231 2820 28 without without IN 37231 2820 29 any any DT 37231 2820 30 other other JJ 37231 2820 31 alteration alteration NN 37231 2820 32 of of IN 37231 2820 33 grammatical grammatical JJ 37231 2820 34 construction construction NN 37231 2820 35 , , , 37231 2820 36 has have VBZ 37231 2820 37 restored restore VBN 37231 2820 38 the the DT 37231 2820 39 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2820 40 to to TO 37231 2820 41 clear clear VB 37231 2820 42 and and CC 37231 2820 43 simple simple JJ 37231 2820 44 order order NN 37231 2820 45 . . . 37231 2821 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2821 2 2 2 LS 37231 2821 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2821 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2821 5 is be VBZ 37231 2821 6 , , , 37231 2821 7 moreover moreover RB 37231 2821 8 , , , 37231 2821 9 a a DT 37231 2821 10 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 2821 11 fact fact NN 37231 2821 12 that that IN 37231 2821 13 the the DT 37231 2821 14 passages passage NNS 37231 2821 15 which which WDT 37231 2821 16 , , , 37231 2821 17 long long RB 37231 2821 18 before before IN 37231 2821 19 the the DT 37231 2821 20 discovery discovery NN 37231 2821 21 of of IN 37231 2821 22 the the DT 37231 2821 23 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2821 24 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2821 25 , , , 37231 2821 26 were be VBD 37231 2821 27 pointed point VBN 37231 2821 28 out out RP 37231 2821 29 as as IN 37231 2821 30 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 2821 31 determining determine VBG 37231 2821 32 that that IN 37231 2821 33 the the DT 37231 2821 34 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2821 35 were be VBD 37231 2821 36 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2821 37 , , , 37231 2821 38 are be VBP 37231 2821 39 not not RB 37231 2821 40 found find VBN 37231 2821 41 in in IN 37231 2821 42 the the DT 37231 2821 43 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2821 44 version version NN 37231 2821 45 at at IN 37231 2821 46 all.3 all.3 NFP 37231 2821 47 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 37231 2821 48 Usher Usher NNP 37231 2821 49 , , , 37231 2821 50 who who WP 37231 2821 51 only only RB 37231 2821 52 admitted admit VBD 37231 2821 53 the the DT 37231 2821 54 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2821 55 of of IN 37231 2821 56 six six CD 37231 2821 57 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2821 58 , , , 37231 2821 59 showed show VBD 37231 2821 60 that that IN 37231 2821 61 much much JJ 37231 2821 62 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2821 63 of of IN 37231 2821 64 these these DT 37231 2821 65 letters letter NNS 37231 2821 66 took take VBD 37231 2821 67 place place NN 37231 2821 68 in in IN 37231 2821 69 the the DT 37231 2821 70 { { -LRB- 37231 2821 71 261 261 CD 37231 2821 72 } } -RRB- 37231 2821 73 sixth sixth JJ 37231 2821 74 century,(1 century,(1 NN 37231 2821 75 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2821 76 but but CC 37231 2821 77 this this DT 37231 2821 78 very very JJ 37231 2821 79 fact fact NN 37231 2821 80 increases increase VBZ 37231 2821 81 the the DT 37231 2821 82 probability probability NN 37231 2821 83 of of IN 37231 2821 84 much much RB 37231 2821 85 earlier early JJR 37231 2821 86 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2821 87 also also RB 37231 2821 88 , , , 37231 2821 89 at at IN 37231 2821 90 which which WDT 37231 2821 91 the the DT 37231 2821 92 various various JJ 37231 2821 93 existing exist VBG 37231 2821 94 versions version NNS 37231 2821 95 most most RBS 37231 2821 96 clearly clearly RB 37231 2821 97 point point VBP 37231 2821 98 . . . 37231 2822 1 The the DT 37231 2822 2 interpolations interpolation NNS 37231 2822 3 can can MD 37231 2822 4 be be VB 37231 2822 5 explained explain VBN 37231 2822 6 upon upon IN 37231 2822 7 the the DT 37231 2822 8 most most RBS 37231 2822 9 palpable palpable JJ 37231 2822 10 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 2822 11 grounds ground NNS 37231 2822 12 , , , 37231 2822 13 but but CC 37231 2822 14 not not RB 37231 2822 15 so so RB 37231 2822 16 the the DT 37231 2822 17 omissions omission NNS 37231 2822 18 upon upon IN 37231 2822 19 the the DT 37231 2822 20 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 2822 21 that that WDT 37231 2822 22 the the DT 37231 2822 23 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2822 24 version version NN 37231 2822 25 is be VBZ 37231 2822 26 an an DT 37231 2822 27 abridgment abridgment NN 37231 2822 28 made make VBN 37231 2822 29 upon upon IN 37231 2822 30 any any DT 37231 2822 31 distinct distinct JJ 37231 2822 32 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 2822 33 principle principle NN 37231 2822 34 , , , 37231 2822 35 for for IN 37231 2822 36 that that DT 37231 2822 37 which which WDT 37231 2822 38 is be VBZ 37231 2822 39 allowed allow VBN 37231 2822 40 to to TO 37231 2822 41 remain remain VB 37231 2822 42 renders render NNS 37231 2822 43 the the DT 37231 2822 44 omissions omission NNS 37231 2822 45 ineffectual ineffectual JJ 37231 2822 46 for for IN 37231 2822 47 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 2822 48 reasons reason NNS 37231 2822 49 . . . 37231 2823 1 There there EX 37231 2823 2 is be VBZ 37231 2823 3 no no DT 37231 2823 4 ground ground NN 37231 2823 5 of of IN 37231 2823 6 interest interest NN 37231 2823 7 upon upon IN 37231 2823 8 which which WDT 37231 2823 9 the the DT 37231 2823 10 portions portion NNS 37231 2823 11 omitted omit VBD 37231 2823 12 and and CC 37231 2823 13 retained retain VBN 37231 2823 14 by by IN 37231 2823 15 the the DT 37231 2823 16 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2823 17 version version NN 37231 2823 18 can can MD 37231 2823 19 be be VB 37231 2823 20 intelligently intelligently RB 37231 2823 21 explained explain VBN 37231 2823 22 . . . 37231 2824 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2824 2 2 2 LS 37231 2824 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2824 4 Finally finally RB 37231 2824 5 , , , 37231 2824 6 here here RB 37231 2824 7 , , , 37231 2824 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2824 9 may may MD 37231 2824 10 mention mention VB 37231 2824 11 that that IN 37231 2824 12 the the DT 37231 2824 13 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2824 14 . . . 37231 2825 1 of of IN 37231 2825 2 the the DT 37231 2825 3 three three CD 37231 2825 4 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2825 5 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2825 6 are be VBP 37231 2825 7 more more RBR 37231 2825 8 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2825 9 by by IN 37231 2825 10 some some DT 37231 2825 11 centuries century NNS 37231 2825 12 than than IN 37231 2825 13 those those DT 37231 2825 14 of of IN 37231 2825 15 any any DT 37231 2825 16 of of IN 37231 2825 17 the the DT 37231 2825 18 Greek greek JJ 37231 2825 19 versions version NNS 37231 2825 20 of of IN 37231 2825 21 the the DT 37231 2825 22 Seven Seven NNP 37231 2825 23 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2825 24 . . . 37231 2826 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2826 2 3 3 LS 37231 2826 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2826 4 The the DT 37231 2826 5 strongest strong JJS 37231 2826 6 internal internal JJ 37231 2826 7 , , , 37231 2826 8 as as RB 37231 2826 9 well well RB 37231 2826 10 as as IN 37231 2826 11 other other JJ 37231 2826 12 evidence evidence NN 37231 2826 13 , , , 37231 2826 14 into into IN 37231 2826 15 which which WDT 37231 2826 16 space space NN 37231 2826 17 forbids forbid NNS 37231 2826 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2826 19 going go VBG 37231 2826 20 in in IN 37231 2826 21 detail detail NN 37231 2826 22 , , , 37231 2826 23 has have VBZ 37231 2826 24 led lead VBN 37231 2826 25 the the DT 37231 2826 26 majority majority NN 37231 2826 27 of of IN 37231 2826 28 critics critic NNS 37231 2826 29 to to TO 37231 2826 30 recognize recognize VB 37231 2826 31 the the DT 37231 2826 32 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2826 33 version version NN 37231 2826 34 as as IN 37231 2826 35 the the DT 37231 2826 36 most most RBS 37231 2826 37 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2826 38 form form NN 37231 2826 39 of of IN 37231 2826 40 the the DT 37231 2826 41 letters letter NNS 37231 2826 42 of of IN 37231 2826 43 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2826 44 extant extant JJ 37231 2826 45 , , , 37231 2826 46 and and CC 37231 2826 47 this this DT 37231 2826 48 is be VBZ 37231 2826 49 admitted admit VBN 37231 2826 50 by by IN 37231 2826 51 many many JJ 37231 2826 52 of of IN 37231 2826 53 those those DT 37231 2826 54 who who WP 37231 2826 55 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 2826 56 deny deny VBP 37231 2826 57 the the DT 37231 2826 58 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2826 59 of of IN 37231 2826 60 any any DT 37231 2826 61 of of IN 37231 2826 62 the the DT 37231 2826 63 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2826 64 . . . 37231 2827 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2827 2 4 4 LS 37231 2827 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2827 4 Seven seven CD 37231 2827 5 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2827 6 have have VBP 37231 2827 7 been be VBN 37231 2827 8 selected select VBN 37231 2827 9 out out IN 37231 2827 10 of of IN 37231 2827 11 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 2827 12 extant extant JJ 37231 2827 13 , , , 37231 2827 14 all all DT 37231 2827 15 equally equally RB 37231 2827 16 purporting purport VBG 37231 2827 17 to to TO 37231 2827 18 be be VB 37231 2827 19 by by IN 37231 2827 20 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2827 21 , , , 37231 2827 22 simply simply RB 37231 2827 23 because because IN 37231 2827 24 only only RB 37231 2827 25 that that DT 37231 2827 26 number number NN 37231 2827 27 was be VBD 37231 2827 28 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2827 29 by by IN 37231 2827 30 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2827 31 , , , 37231 2827 32 from from IN 37231 2827 33 whom whom WP 37231 2827 34 for for IN 37231 2827 35 the the DT 37231 2827 36 first first JJ 37231 2827 37 time time NN 37231 2827 38 , , , 37231 2827 39 in in IN 37231 2827 40 the the DT 37231 2827 41 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2827 42 century,--except century,--except NNP 37231 2827 43 the the DT 37231 2827 44 general general JJ 37231 2827 45 reference reference NN 37231 2827 46 in in IN 37231 2827 47 the the DT 37231 2827 48 so so RB 37231 2827 49 - - HYPH 37231 2827 50 called call VBN 37231 2827 51 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2827 52 of of IN 37231 2827 53 Poly Poly NNP 37231 2827 54 - - HYPH 37231 2827 55 carp carp NNP 37231 2827 56 , , , 37231 2827 57 to to TO 37231 2827 58 which which WDT 37231 2827 59 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2827 60 shall shall MD 37231 2827 61 presently presently RB 37231 2827 62 refer,--we refer,--we VB 37231 2827 63 hear hear VB 37231 2827 64 of of IN 37231 2827 65 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2827 66 . . . 37231 2828 1 Now now RB 37231 2828 2 neither neither CC 37231 2828 3 the the DT 37231 2828 4 silence silence NN 37231 2828 5 of of IN 37231 2828 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2828 7 regarding regard VBG 37231 2828 8 the the DT 37231 2828 9 eight eight CD 37231 2828 10 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2828 11 , , , 37231 2828 12 nor nor CC 37231 2828 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2828 14 mention mention NN 37231 2828 15 of of IN 37231 2828 16 the the DT 37231 2828 17 seven seven CD 37231 2828 18 , , , 37231 2828 19 can can MD 37231 2828 20 have have VB 37231 2828 21 much much JJ 37231 2828 22 weight weight NN 37231 2828 23 in in IN 37231 2828 24 deciding decide VBG 37231 2828 25 the the DT 37231 2828 26 question question NN 37231 2828 27 of of IN 37231 2828 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2828 29 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2828 30 . . . 37231 2829 1 The the DT 37231 2829 2 only only JJ 37231 2829 3 point point NN 37231 2829 4 which which WDT 37231 2829 5 is be VBZ 37231 2829 6 settled settle VBN 37231 2829 7 by by IN 37231 2829 8 the the DT 37231 2829 9 reference reference NN 37231 2829 10 { { -LRB- 37231 2829 11 262 262 CD 37231 2829 12 } } -RRB- 37231 2829 13 of of IN 37231 2829 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2829 15 is be VBZ 37231 2829 16 that that IN 37231 2829 17 , , , 37231 2829 18 at at IN 37231 2829 19 the the DT 37231 2829 20 date date NN 37231 2829 21 at at IN 37231 2829 22 which which WDT 37231 2829 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2829 24 wrote write VBD 37231 2829 25 , , , 37231 2829 26 seven seven CD 37231 2829 27 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2829 28 were be VBD 37231 2829 29 known know VBN 37231 2829 30 to to IN 37231 2829 31 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2829 32 which which WDT 37231 2829 33 were be VBD 37231 2829 34 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2829 35 to to IN 37231 2829 36 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2829 37 . . . 37231 2830 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2830 2 evidently evidently RB 37231 2830 3 knew know VBD 37231 2830 4 little little JJ 37231 2830 5 or or CC 37231 2830 6 nothing nothing NN 37231 2830 7 regarding regard VBG 37231 2830 8 the the DT 37231 2830 9 man man NN 37231 2830 10 or or CC 37231 2830 11 the the DT 37231 2830 12 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2830 13 , , , 37231 2830 14 beyond beyond IN 37231 2830 15 what what WP 37231 2830 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2830 17 had have VBD 37231 2830 18 learnt learn VBN 37231 2830 19 from from IN 37231 2830 20 themselves,(1 themselves,(1 NNP 37231 2830 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2830 22 and and CC 37231 2830 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2830 24 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2830 25 the the DT 37231 2830 26 martyr martyr NN 37231 2830 27 - - HYPH 37231 2830 28 journey journey NN 37231 2830 29 to to IN 37231 2830 30 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2830 31 as as IN 37231 2830 32 a a DT 37231 2830 33 mere mere JJ 37231 2830 34 report report NN 37231 2830 35 : : : 37231 2830 36 " " `` 37231 2830 37 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2830 38 is be VBZ 37231 2830 39 said say VBN 37231 2830 40 that that IN 37231 2830 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2830 42 was be VBD 37231 2830 43 conducted conduct VBN 37231 2830 44 from from IN 37231 2830 45 Syria Syria NNP 37231 2830 46 to to IN 37231 2830 47 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2830 48 to to TO 37231 2830 49 be be VB 37231 2830 50 cast cast VBN 37231 2830 51 to to IN 37231 2830 52 wild wild JJ 37231 2830 53 beasts beast NNS 37231 2830 54 on on IN 37231 2830 55 account account NN 37231 2830 56 of of IN 37231 2830 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2830 58 testimony testimony NN 37231 2830 59 to to IN 37231 2830 60 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2830 61 . . . 37231 2831 1 " " `` 37231 2831 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2831 3 2 2 LS 37231 2831 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2831 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2831 6 would would MD 37231 2831 7 be be VB 37231 2831 8 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 2831 9 to to TO 37231 2831 10 argue argue VB 37231 2831 11 that that IN 37231 2831 12 no no DT 37231 2831 13 other other JJ 37231 2831 14 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2831 15 existed exist VBD 37231 2831 16 simply simply RB 37231 2831 17 because because IN 37231 2831 18 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2831 19 did do VBD 37231 2831 20 not not RB 37231 2831 21 mention mention VB 37231 2831 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2831 23 ; ; : 37231 2831 24 and and CC 37231 2831 25 on on IN 37231 2831 26 the the DT 37231 2831 27 other other JJ 37231 2831 28 hand hand NN 37231 2831 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2831 30 would would MD 37231 2831 31 be be VB 37231 2831 32 still still RB 37231 2831 33 more more RBR 37231 2831 34 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 2831 35 to to TO 37231 2831 36 affirm affirm VB 37231 2831 37 that that IN 37231 2831 38 the the DT 37231 2831 39 seven seven CD 37231 2831 40 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2831 41 are be VBP 37231 2831 42 authentic authentic JJ 37231 2831 43 merely merely RB 37231 2831 44 because because IN 37231 2831 45 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2831 46 , , , 37231 2831 47 in in IN 37231 2831 48 the the DT 37231 2831 49 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2831 50 century,--that century,--that . 37231 2831 51 is be VBZ 37231 2831 52 to to TO 37231 2831 53 say say VB 37231 2831 54 , , , 37231 2831 55 some some DT 37231 2831 56 two two CD 37231 2831 57 centuries century NNS 37231 2831 58 after after IN 37231 2831 59 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2831 60 are be VBP 37231 2831 61 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2831 62 to to TO 37231 2831 63 have have VB 37231 2831 64 been be VBN 37231 2831 65 written,--had written,--had VBN 37231 2831 66 met meet VBN 37231 2831 67 with with IN 37231 2831 68 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2831 69 . . . 37231 2832 1 Does do VBZ 37231 2832 2 any any DT 37231 2832 3 one one NN 37231 2832 4 believe believe VB 37231 2832 5 the the DT 37231 2832 6 letter letter NN 37231 2832 7 of of IN 37231 2832 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2832 9 to to IN 37231 2832 10 Abgarus Abgarus NNP 37231 2832 11 Prince Prince NNP 37231 2832 12 of of IN 37231 2832 13 Edessa Edessa NNP 37231 2832 14 to to TO 37231 2832 15 be be VB 37231 2832 16 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2832 17 , , , 37231 2832 18 because because IN 37231 2832 19 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2832 20 inserts insert VBZ 37231 2832 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2832 22 in in IN 37231 2832 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2832 24 history(3 history(3 NN 37231 2832 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2832 26 as as IN 37231 2832 27 an an DT 37231 2832 28 authentic authentic JJ 37231 2832 29 document document NN 37231 2832 30 out out IN 37231 2832 31 of of IN 37231 2832 32 the the DT 37231 2832 33 public public JJ 37231 2832 34 records record NNS 37231 2832 35 of of IN 37231 2832 36 the the DT 37231 2832 37 city city NN 37231 2832 38 of of IN 37231 2832 39 Edessa Edessa NNP 37231 2832 40 \ \ NNP 37231 2832 41 There there EX 37231 2832 42 is be VBZ 37231 2832 43 , , , 37231 2832 44 in in IN 37231 2832 45 fact fact NN 37231 2832 46 , , , 37231 2832 47 no no DT 37231 2832 48 evidence evidence NN 37231 2832 49 that that IN 37231 2832 50 the the DT 37231 2832 51 brief brief JJ 37231 2832 52 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2832 53 of of IN 37231 2832 54 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2832 55 and and CC 37231 2832 56 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2832 57 are be VBP 37231 2832 58 taken take VBN 37231 2832 59 from from IN 37231 2832 60 either either DT 37231 2832 61 of of IN 37231 2832 62 the the DT 37231 2832 63 extant extant JJ 37231 2832 64 Greek greek JJ 37231 2832 65 versions version NNS 37231 2832 66 of of IN 37231 2832 67 the the DT 37231 2832 68 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2832 69 ; ; : 37231 2832 70 for for IN 37231 2832 71 , , , 37231 2832 72 as as IN 37231 2832 73 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2832 74 have have VBP 37231 2832 75 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2832 76 , , , 37231 2832 77 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2832 78 exist exist VBP 37231 2832 79 in in IN 37231 2832 80 the the DT 37231 2832 81 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2832 82 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2832 83 , , , 37231 2832 84 and and CC 37231 2832 85 there there EX 37231 2832 86 is be VBZ 37231 2832 87 nothing nothing NN 37231 2832 88 to to TO 37231 2832 89 show show VB 37231 2832 90 the the DT 37231 2832 91 original original JJ 37231 2832 92 state state NN 37231 2832 93 of of IN 37231 2832 94 the the DT 37231 2832 95 letters letter NNS 37231 2832 96 from from IN 37231 2832 97 which which WDT 37231 2832 98 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2832 99 were be VBD 37231 2832 100 derived derive VBN 37231 2832 101 . . . 37231 2833 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 2833 2 is be VBZ 37231 2833 3 more more RBR 37231 2833 4 certain certain JJ 37231 2833 5 than than IN 37231 2833 6 the the DT 37231 2833 7 fact fact NN 37231 2833 8 that that IN 37231 2833 9 , , , 37231 2833 10 if if IN 37231 2833 11 any any DT 37231 2833 12 writer writer NN 37231 2833 13 wished wish VBD 37231 2833 14 to to TO 37231 2833 15 circulate circulate VB 37231 2833 16 letters letter NNS 37231 2833 17 in in IN 37231 2833 18 the the DT 37231 2833 19 name name NN 37231 2833 20 of of IN 37231 2833 21 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2833 22 , , , 37231 2833 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2833 24 would would MD 37231 2833 25 insert insert VB 37231 2833 26 such such JJ 37231 2833 27 passages passage NNS 37231 2833 28 as as IN 37231 2833 29 were be VBD 37231 2833 30 said say VBN 37231 2833 31 to to TO 37231 2833 32 have have VB 37231 2833 33 been be VBN 37231 2833 34 quoted quote VBN 37231 2833 35 from from IN 37231 2833 36 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2833 37 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2833 38 of of IN 37231 2833 39 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2833 40 , , , 37231 2833 41 and and CC 37231 2833 42 supposing suppose VBG 37231 2833 43 those those DT 37231 2833 44 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2833 45 to to TO 37231 2833 46 be be VB 37231 2833 47 real real JJ 37231 2833 48 , , , 37231 2833 49 all all DT 37231 2833 50 that that WDT 37231 2833 51 could could MD 37231 2833 52 be be VB 37231 2833 53 said say VBN 37231 2833 54 on on IN 37231 2833 55 finding find VBG 37231 2833 56 such such JJ 37231 2833 57 passages passage NNS 37231 2833 58 would would MD 37231 2833 59 be be VB 37231 2833 60 that that IN 37231 2833 61 at at IN 37231 2833 62 least least JJS 37231 2833 63 so so RB 37231 2833 64 much much JJ 37231 2833 65 might may MD 37231 2833 66 be be VB 37231 2833 67 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2833 68 . . . 37231 2834 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2834 2 4 4 LS 37231 2834 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2834 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2834 5 is be VBZ 37231 2834 6 a a DT 37231 2834 7 total total JJ 37231 2834 8 { { -LRB- 37231 2834 9 263 263 CD 37231 2834 10 } } -RRB- 37231 2834 11 mistake mistake NN 37231 2834 12 to to TO 37231 2834 13 suppose suppose VB 37231 2834 14 that that IN 37231 2834 15 the the DT 37231 2834 16 seven seven CD 37231 2834 17 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2834 18 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2834 19 by by IN 37231 2834 20 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2834 21 have have VBP 37231 2834 22 been be VBN 37231 2834 23 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 2834 24 to to IN 37231 2834 25 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2834 26 in in IN 37231 2834 27 any any DT 37231 2834 28 special special JJ 37231 2834 29 way way NN 37231 2834 30 . . . 37231 2835 1 These these DT 37231 2835 2 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2835 3 are be VBP 37231 2835 4 mixed mix VBN 37231 2835 5 up up RP 37231 2835 6 in in IN 37231 2835 7 the the DT 37231 2835 8 Medicean Medicean NNP 37231 2835 9 and and CC 37231 2835 10 corresponding corresponding JJ 37231 2835 11 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2835 12 Latin Latin NNP 37231 2835 13 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2835 14 . . . 37231 2836 1 with with IN 37231 2836 2 the the DT 37231 2836 3 other other JJ 37231 2836 4 eight eight CD 37231 2836 5 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2836 6 , , , 37231 2836 7 universally universally RB 37231 2836 8 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 2836 9 to to TO 37231 2836 10 be be VB 37231 2836 11 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2836 12 , , , 37231 2836 13 without without IN 37231 2836 14 distinction distinction NN 37231 2836 15 of of IN 37231 2836 16 any any DT 37231 2836 17 kind kind NN 37231 2836 18 , , , 37231 2836 19 and and CC 37231 2836 20 all all DT 37231 2836 21 have have VBP 37231 2836 22 equal equal JJ 37231 2836 23 honour honour NN 37231 2836 24 . . . 37231 2837 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2837 2 1 1 LS 37231 2837 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2837 4 The the DT 37231 2837 5 recognition recognition NN 37231 2837 6 of of IN 37231 2837 7 the the DT 37231 2837 8 number number NN 37231 2837 9 seven seven CD 37231 2837 10 may may MD 37231 2837 11 , , , 37231 2837 12 therefore therefore RB 37231 2837 13 , , , 37231 2837 14 be be VB 37231 2837 15 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2837 16 simply simply RB 37231 2837 17 to to IN 37231 2837 18 the the DT 37231 2837 19 reference reference NN 37231 2837 20 to to IN 37231 2837 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2837 22 by by IN 37231 2837 23 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2837 24 , , , 37231 2837 25 and and CC 37231 2837 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2837 27 silence silence NN 37231 2837 28 regarding regard VBG 37231 2837 29 the the DT 37231 2837 30 rest rest NN 37231 2837 31 . . . 37231 2838 1 What what WP 37231 2838 2 , , , 37231 2838 3 then then RB 37231 2838 4 , , , 37231 2838 5 is be VBZ 37231 2838 6 the the DT 37231 2838 7 position position NN 37231 2838 8 of of IN 37231 2838 9 the the DT 37231 2838 10 so so RB 37231 2838 11 - - HYPH 37231 2838 12 called call VBN 37231 2838 13 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 2838 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2838 15 ? ? . 37231 2839 1 Towards towards IN 37231 2839 2 the the DT 37231 2839 3 end end NN 37231 2839 4 of of IN 37231 2839 5 the the DT 37231 2839 6 second second JJ 37231 2839 7 century century NN 37231 2839 8 , , , 37231 2839 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2839 10 makes make VBZ 37231 2839 11 a a DT 37231 2839 12 very very RB 37231 2839 13 short short JJ 37231 2839 14 quotation quotation NN 37231 2839 15 from from IN 37231 2839 16 a a DT 37231 2839 17 source source NN 37231 2839 18 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 2839 19 , , , 37231 2839 20 which which WDT 37231 2839 21 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2839 22 , , , 37231 2839 23 in in IN 37231 2839 24 the the DT 37231 2839 25 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2839 26 century century NN 37231 2839 27 , , , 37231 2839 28 finds find VBZ 37231 2839 29 in in IN 37231 2839 30 an an DT 37231 2839 31 epistle epistle NN 37231 2839 32 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2839 33 to to IN 37231 2839 34 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2839 35 . . . 37231 2840 1 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2840 2 , , , 37231 2840 3 in in IN 37231 2840 4 the the DT 37231 2840 5 third third JJ 37231 2840 6 century century NN 37231 2840 7 , , , 37231 2840 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2840 9 a a DT 37231 2840 10 very very RB 37231 2840 11 few few JJ 37231 2840 12 words word NNS 37231 2840 13 which which WDT 37231 2840 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2840 15 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 2840 16 to to IN 37231 2840 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2840 18 , , , 37231 2840 19 although although IN 37231 2840 20 without without IN 37231 2840 21 definite definite JJ 37231 2840 22 reference reference NN 37231 2840 23 to to IN 37231 2840 24 any any DT 37231 2840 25 particular particular JJ 37231 2840 26 epistle epistle NN 37231 2840 27 ; ; : 37231 2840 28 and and CC 37231 2840 29 , , , 37231 2840 30 in in IN 37231 2840 31 the the DT 37231 2840 32 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2840 33 century century NN 37231 2840 34 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2840 35 mentions mention VBZ 37231 2840 36 seven seven CD 37231 2840 37 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2840 38 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2840 39 to to IN 37231 2840 40 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2840 41 . . . 37231 2841 1 There there EX 37231 2841 2 is be VBZ 37231 2841 3 no no DT 37231 2841 4 other other JJ 37231 2841 5 evidence evidence NN 37231 2841 6 . . . 37231 2842 1 There there EX 37231 2842 2 are be VBP 37231 2842 3 , , , 37231 2842 4 however however RB 37231 2842 5 , , , 37231 2842 6 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 2842 7 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2842 8 extant extant JJ 37231 2842 9 , , , 37231 2842 10 all all DT 37231 2842 11 of of IN 37231 2842 12 which which WDT 37231 2842 13 are be VBP 37231 2842 14 attributed attribute VBN 37231 2842 15 to to IN 37231 2842 16 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2842 17 , , , 37231 2842 18 of of IN 37231 2842 19 all all DT 37231 2842 20 of of IN 37231 2842 21 which which WDT 37231 2842 22 , , , 37231 2842 23 with with IN 37231 2842 24 the the DT 37231 2842 25 exception exception NN 37231 2842 26 of of IN 37231 2842 27 three three CD 37231 2842 28 which which WDT 37231 2842 29 are be VBP 37231 2842 30 only only RB 37231 2842 31 known know VBN 37231 2842 32 in in IN 37231 2842 33 a a DT 37231 2842 34 Latin latin JJ 37231 2842 35 version version NN 37231 2842 36 , , , 37231 2842 37 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2842 38 possess possess VBP 37231 2842 39 both both DT 37231 2842 40 Greek greek JJ 37231 2842 41 and and CC 37231 2842 42 Latin latin JJ 37231 2842 43 versions version NNS 37231 2842 44 . . . 37231 2843 1 Of of IN 37231 2843 2 seven seven CD 37231 2843 3 of of IN 37231 2843 4 these these DT 37231 2843 5 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2843 6 -- -- : 37231 2843 7 and and CC 37231 2843 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2843 9 are be VBP 37231 2843 10 those those DT 37231 2843 11 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2843 12 by by IN 37231 2843 13 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2843 14 -- -- : 37231 2843 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2843 16 have have VBP 37231 2843 17 two two CD 37231 2843 18 Greek greek JJ 37231 2843 19 versions version NNS 37231 2843 20 , , , 37231 2843 21 one one CD 37231 2843 22 of of IN 37231 2843 23 which which WDT 37231 2843 24 is be VBZ 37231 2843 25 very very RB 37231 2843 26 much much RB 37231 2843 27 shorter short JJR 37231 2843 28 than than IN 37231 2843 29 the the DT 37231 2843 30 other other JJ 37231 2843 31 ; ; : 37231 2843 32 and and CC 37231 2843 33 finally finally RB 37231 2843 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2843 35 now now RB 37231 2843 36 possess possess VBP 37231 2843 37 a a DT 37231 2843 38 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2843 39 version version NN 37231 2843 40 of of IN 37231 2843 41 three three CD 37231 2843 42 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2843 43 only(2 only(2 IN 37231 2843 44 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2843 45 in in IN 37231 2843 46 a a DT 37231 2843 47 form form NN 37231 2843 48 still still RB 37231 2843 49 shorter short JJR 37231 2843 50 than than IN 37231 2843 51 the the DT 37231 2843 52 shorter short JJR 37231 2843 53 Greek greek JJ 37231 2843 54 version version NN 37231 2843 55 , , , 37231 2843 56 in in IN 37231 2843 57 which which WDT 37231 2843 58 are be VBP 37231 2843 59 found find VBN 37231 2843 60 all all PDT 37231 2843 61 the the DT 37231 2843 62 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2843 63 of of IN 37231 2843 64 the the DT 37231 2843 65 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 2843 66 , , , 37231 2843 67 without without IN 37231 2843 68 exception exception NN 37231 2843 69 , , , 37231 2843 70 up up IN 37231 2843 71 to to IN 37231 2843 72 the the DT 37231 2843 73 fourth fourth JJ 37231 2843 74 century century NN 37231 2843 75 . . . 37231 2844 1 Eight eight CD 37231 2844 2 of of IN 37231 2844 3 the the DT 37231 2844 4 fifteen fifteen CD 37231 2844 5 2 2 CD 37231 2844 6 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2844 7 is be VBZ 37231 2844 8 worthy worthy JJ 37231 2844 9 of of IN 37231 2844 10 remark remark NN 37231 2844 11 that that IN 37231 2844 12 at at IN 37231 2844 13 the the DT 37231 2844 14 end end NN 37231 2844 15 of of IN 37231 2844 16 the the DT 37231 2844 17 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2844 18 version version NN 37231 2844 19 the the DT 37231 2844 20 subscription subscription NN 37231 2844 21 is be VBZ 37231 2844 22 : : : 37231 2844 23 " " `` 37231 2844 24 Here here RB 37231 2844 25 end end VB 37231 2844 26 the the DT 37231 2844 27 three three CD 37231 2844 28 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2844 29 of of IN 37231 2844 30 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2844 31 , , , 37231 2844 32 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2844 33 and and CC 37231 2844 34 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 2844 35 ; ; : 37231 2844 36 " " `` 37231 2844 37 cf cf NN 37231 2844 38 . . . 37231 2845 1 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 2845 2 , , , 37231 2845 3 The the DT 37231 2845 4 Ancient Ancient NNP 37231 2845 5 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2845 6 Version Version NNP 37231 2845 7 , , , 37231 2845 8 & & CC 37231 2845 9 c c NNP 37231 2845 10 , , , 37231 2845 11 p. p. NN 37231 2845 12 25 25 CD 37231 2845 13 . . . 37231 2846 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2846 2 264 264 CD 37231 2846 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2846 4 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2846 5 are be VBP 37231 2846 6 universally universally RB 37231 2846 7 rejected reject VBN 37231 2846 8 as as RB 37231 2846 9 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2846 10 . . . 37231 2847 1 The the DT 37231 2847 2 longer long JJR 37231 2847 3 Greek greek JJ 37231 2847 4 version version NN 37231 2847 5 of of IN 37231 2847 6 the the DT 37231 2847 7 remaining remain VBG 37231 2847 8 seven seven CD 37231 2847 9 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2847 10 is be VBZ 37231 2847 11 almost almost RB 37231 2847 12 unanimously unanimously RB 37231 2847 13 condemned condemn VBN 37231 2847 14 as as IN 37231 2847 15 grossly grossly RB 37231 2847 16 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 2847 17 ; ; : 37231 2847 18 and and CC 37231 2847 19 the the DT 37231 2847 20 great great JJ 37231 2847 21 majority majority NN 37231 2847 22 of of IN 37231 2847 23 critics critic NNS 37231 2847 24 recognize recognize VBP 37231 2847 25 that that IN 37231 2847 26 the the DT 37231 2847 27 shorter short JJR 37231 2847 28 Greek greek JJ 37231 2847 29 version version NN 37231 2847 30 is be VBZ 37231 2847 31 also also RB 37231 2847 32 much much RB 37231 2847 33 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 2847 34 ; ; : 37231 2847 35 whilst whilst IN 37231 2847 36 the the DT 37231 2847 37 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2847 38 version version NN 37231 2847 39 , , , 37231 2847 40 which which WDT 37231 2847 41 so so RB 37231 2847 42 far far RB 37231 2847 43 as as IN 37231 2847 44 MSS MSS NNP 37231 2847 45 . . . 37231 2848 1 are be VBP 37231 2848 2 concerned concern VBN 37231 2848 3 is be VBZ 37231 2848 4 by by IN 37231 2848 5 far far RB 37231 2848 6 the the DT 37231 2848 7 most most RBS 37231 2848 8 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2848 9 text text NN 37231 2848 10 of of IN 37231 2848 11 any any DT 37231 2848 12 of of IN 37231 2848 13 the the DT 37231 2848 14 letters letter NNS 37231 2848 15 which which WDT 37231 2848 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2848 17 posses posse VBZ 37231 2848 18 , , , 37231 2848 19 reduces reduce VBZ 37231 2848 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2848 21 number number NN 37231 2848 22 to to IN 37231 2848 23 three three CD 37231 2848 24 , , , 37231 2848 25 and and CC 37231 2848 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2848 27 contents content NNS 37231 2848 28 to to IN 37231 2848 29 a a DT 37231 2848 30 very very RB 37231 2848 31 small small JJ 37231 2848 32 compass compass NN 37231 2848 33 indeed indeed RB 37231 2848 34 . . . 37231 2849 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2849 2 is be VBZ 37231 2849 3 not not RB 37231 2849 4 surprising surprising JJ 37231 2849 5 that that IN 37231 2849 6 the the DT 37231 2849 7 vast vast JJ 37231 2849 8 majority majority NN 37231 2849 9 of of IN 37231 2849 10 critics critic NNS 37231 2849 11 have have VBP 37231 2849 12 expressed express VBN 37231 2849 13 doubt doubt NN 37231 2849 14 more more RBR 37231 2849 15 or or CC 37231 2849 16 less less RBR 37231 2849 17 strong strong JJ 37231 2849 18 regarding regard VBG 37231 2849 19 the the DT 37231 2849 20 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2849 21 of of IN 37231 2849 22 all all DT 37231 2849 23 of of IN 37231 2849 24 these these DT 37231 2849 25 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2849 26 , , , 37231 2849 27 and and CC 37231 2849 28 that that IN 37231 2849 29 so so RB 37231 2849 30 large large VBP 37231 2849 31 a a DT 37231 2849 32 number number NN 37231 2849 33 have have VBP 37231 2849 34 repudiated repudiate VBN 37231 2849 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2849 36 altogether altogether RB 37231 2849 37 . . . 37231 2850 1 One one CD 37231 2850 2 thing thing NN 37231 2850 3 is be VBZ 37231 2850 4 quite quite RB 37231 2850 5 evident,--that evident,--that NNP 37231 2850 6 amidst amidst IN 37231 2850 7 such such PDT 37231 2850 8 a a DT 37231 2850 9 mass mass NN 37231 2850 10 of of IN 37231 2850 11 falsification falsification NN 37231 2850 12 , , , 37231 2850 13 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2850 14 , , , 37231 2850 15 and and CC 37231 2850 16 fraud fraud NN 37231 2850 17 , , , 37231 2850 18 the the DT 37231 2850 19 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 2850 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2850 21 can can MD 37231 2850 22 not not RB 37231 2850 23 in in IN 37231 2850 24 any any DT 37231 2850 25 form form NN 37231 2850 26 be be VB 37231 2850 27 considered consider VBN 37231 2850 28 evidence evidence NN 37231 2850 29 on on IN 37231 2850 30 any any DT 37231 2850 31 important important JJ 37231 2850 32 point point NN 37231 2850 33 . . . 37231 2851 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2851 2 1 1 LS 37231 2851 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2851 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2851 5 have have VBP 37231 2851 6 not not RB 37231 2851 7 , , , 37231 2851 8 however however RB 37231 2851 9 , , , 37231 2851 10 finished finish VBD 37231 2851 11 . . . 37231 2852 1 All all DT 37231 2852 2 of of IN 37231 2852 3 these these DT 37231 2852 4 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2852 5 , , , 37231 2852 6 including include VBG 37231 2852 7 the the DT 37231 2852 8 three three CD 37231 2852 9 of of IN 37231 2852 10 the the DT 37231 2852 11 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2852 12 recension recension NN 37231 2852 13 , , , 37231 2852 14 profess profess JJ 37231 2852 15 to to TO 37231 2852 16 have have VB 37231 2852 17 been be VBN 37231 2852 18 written write VBN 37231 2852 19 by by IN 37231 2852 20 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2852 21 during during IN 37231 2852 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2852 23 journey journey NN 37231 2852 24 from from IN 37231 2852 25 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 2852 26 to to IN 37231 2852 27 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2852 28 , , , 37231 2852 29 in in IN 37231 2852 30 the the DT 37231 2852 31 custody custody NN 37231 2852 32 of of IN 37231 2852 33 Roman roman JJ 37231 2852 34 soldiers soldier NNS 37231 2852 35 , , , 37231 2852 36 in in IN 37231 2852 37 order order NN 37231 2852 38 to to TO 37231 2852 39 be be VB 37231 2852 40 exposed expose VBN 37231 2852 41 to to IN 37231 2852 42 wild wild JJ 37231 2852 43 beasts beast NNS 37231 2852 44 , , , 37231 2852 45 the the DT 37231 2852 46 form form NN 37231 2852 47 of of IN 37231 2852 48 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2852 49 to to TO 37231 2852 50 which which WDT 37231 2852 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2852 52 had have VBD 37231 2852 53 been be VBN 37231 2852 54 condemned condemn VBN 37231 2852 55 . . . 37231 2853 1 The the DT 37231 2853 2 writer writer NN 37231 2853 3 describes describe VBZ 37231 2853 4 the the DT 37231 2853 5 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2853 6 of of IN 37231 2853 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2853 8 journey journey NN 37231 2853 9 as as IN 37231 2853 10 follows follow VBZ 37231 2853 11 : : : 37231 2853 12 " " `` 37231 2853 13 From from IN 37231 2853 14 Syria Syria NNP 37231 2853 15 even even RB 37231 2853 16 unto unto IN 37231 2853 17 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2853 18 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2853 19 fight fight VBP 37231 2853 20 with with IN 37231 2853 21 wild wild JJ 37231 2853 22 beasts beast NNS 37231 2853 23 , , , 37231 2853 24 by by IN 37231 2853 25 sea sea NN 37231 2853 26 and and CC 37231 2853 27 by by IN 37231 2853 28 land land NN 37231 2853 29 , , , 37231 2853 30 by by IN 37231 2853 31 night night NN 37231 2853 32 and and CC 37231 2853 33 day day NN 37231 2853 34 ; ; : 37231 2853 35 being be VBG 37231 2853 36 bound bind VBN 37231 2853 37 amongst amongst IN 37231 2853 38 ten ten CD 37231 2853 39 leopards leopard NNS 37231 2853 40 , , , 37231 2853 41 which which WDT 37231 2853 42 are be VBP 37231 2853 43 the the DT 37231 2853 44 band band NN 37231 2853 45 of of IN 37231 2853 46 soldiers soldier NNS 37231 2853 47 : : : 37231 2853 48 who who WP 37231 2853 49 even even RB 37231 2853 50 receiving receive VBG 37231 2853 51 benefits benefit NNS 37231 2853 52 become become VBP 37231 2853 53 worse bad JJR 37231 2853 54 . . . 37231 2854 1 " " `` 37231 2854 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2854 3 2 2 LS 37231 2854 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2854 5 Now now UH 37231 2854 6 if if IN 37231 2854 7 this this DT 37231 2854 8 account account NN 37231 2854 9 be be VBP 37231 2854 10 in in IN 37231 2854 11 the the DT 37231 2854 12 least least JJS 37231 2854 13 degree degree NN 37231 2854 14 true true JJ 37231 2854 15 , , , 37231 2854 16 how how WRB 37231 2854 17 is be VBZ 37231 2854 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2854 19 possible possible JJ 37231 2854 20 to to TO 37231 2854 21 suppose suppose VB 37231 2854 22 that that IN 37231 2854 23 the the DT 37231 2854 24 martyr martyr NN 37231 2854 25 could could MD 37231 2854 26 have have VB 37231 2854 27 found find VBN 37231 2854 28 means mean NNS 37231 2854 29 to to TO 37231 2854 30 write write VB 37231 2854 31 { { -LRB- 37231 2854 32 265 265 CD 37231 2854 33 } } -RRB- 37231 2854 34 so so RB 37231 2854 35 many many JJ 37231 2854 36 long long JJ 37231 2854 37 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2854 38 , , , 37231 2854 39 entering enter VBG 37231 2854 40 minutely minutely RB 37231 2854 41 into into IN 37231 2854 42 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 2854 43 teaching teaching NN 37231 2854 44 , , , 37231 2854 45 and and CC 37231 2854 46 expressing express VBG 37231 2854 47 the the DT 37231 2854 48 most most RBS 37231 2854 49 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 2854 50 and and CC 37231 2854 51 advanced advanced JJ 37231 2854 52 views view NNS 37231 2854 53 regarding regard VBG 37231 2854 54 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2854 55 government government NN 37231 2854 56 ? ? . 37231 2855 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 2855 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2855 3 may may MD 37231 2855 4 be be VB 37231 2855 5 asked ask VBN 37231 2855 6 why why WRB 37231 2855 7 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2855 8 should should MD 37231 2855 9 have have VB 37231 2855 10 considered consider VBN 37231 2855 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2855 12 necessary necessary JJ 37231 2855 13 in in IN 37231 2855 14 such such PDT 37231 2855 15 a a DT 37231 2855 16 journey journey NN 37231 2855 17 , , , 37231 2855 18 even even RB 37231 2855 19 if if IN 37231 2855 20 the the DT 37231 2855 21 possibility possibility NN 37231 2855 22 be be VBP 37231 2855 23 for for IN 37231 2855 24 a a DT 37231 2855 25 moment moment NN 37231 2855 26 conceded concede VBN 37231 2855 27 , , , 37231 2855 28 to to TO 37231 2855 29 address address VB 37231 2855 30 such such JJ 37231 2855 31 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2855 32 to to IN 37231 2855 33 communities community NNS 37231 2855 34 and and CC 37231 2855 35 individuals individual NNS 37231 2855 36 to to TO 37231 2855 37 whom whom WP 37231 2855 38 , , , 37231 2855 39 by by IN 37231 2855 40 the the DT 37231 2855 41 showing showing NN 37231 2855 42 of of IN 37231 2855 43 the the DT 37231 2855 44 letters letter NNS 37231 2855 45 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2855 46 , , , 37231 2855 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2855 48 had have VBD 37231 2855 49 just just RB 37231 2855 50 had have VBN 37231 2855 51 opportunities opportunity NNS 37231 2855 52 of of IN 37231 2855 53 addressing address VBG 37231 2855 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2855 55 counsels counsel NNS 37231 2855 56 in in IN 37231 2855 57 person person NN 37231 2855 58 . . . 37231 2856 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2856 2 1 1 LS 37231 2856 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2856 4 The the DT 37231 2856 5 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2856 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2856 7 bear bear VBP 37231 2856 8 none none NN 37231 2856 9 of of IN 37231 2856 10 the the DT 37231 2856 11 marks mark NNS 37231 2856 12 of of IN 37231 2856 13 composition composition NN 37231 2856 14 under under IN 37231 2856 15 such such JJ 37231 2856 16 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2856 17 , , , 37231 2856 18 and and CC 37231 2856 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2856 20 is be VBZ 37231 2856 21 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2856 22 to to TO 37231 2856 23 suppose suppose VB 37231 2856 24 that that IN 37231 2856 25 soldiers soldier NNS 37231 2856 26 such such JJ 37231 2856 27 as as IN 37231 2856 28 the the DT 37231 2856 29 quotation quotation NN 37231 2856 30 above above IN 37231 2856 31 describes describe NNS 37231 2856 32 would would MD 37231 2856 33 allow allow VB 37231 2856 34 a a DT 37231 2856 35 prisoner prisoner NN 37231 2856 36 , , , 37231 2856 37 condemned condemn VBN 37231 2856 38 to to IN 37231 2856 39 wild wild JJ 37231 2856 40 beasts beast NNS 37231 2856 41 for for IN 37231 2856 42 professing profess VBG 37231 2856 43 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 2856 44 , , , 37231 2856 45 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 2856 46 to to TO 37231 2856 47 write write VB 37231 2856 48 long long JJ 37231 2856 49 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2856 50 at at IN 37231 2856 51 every every DT 37231 2856 52 stage stage NN 37231 2856 53 of of IN 37231 2856 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2856 55 journey journey NN 37231 2856 56 , , , 37231 2856 57 promulgating promulgate VBG 37231 2856 58 the the DT 37231 2856 59 very very JJ 37231 2856 60 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 2856 61 for for IN 37231 2856 62 which which WDT 37231 2856 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2856 64 was be VBD 37231 2856 65 condemned condemn VBN 37231 2856 66 . . . 37231 2857 1 And and CC 37231 2857 2 not not RB 37231 2857 3 only only RB 37231 2857 4 this this DT 37231 2857 5 , , , 37231 2857 6 but but CC 37231 2857 7 on on IN 37231 2857 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2857 9 way way NN 37231 2857 10 to to IN 37231 2857 11 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2857 12 , , , 37231 2857 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2857 14 has have VBZ 37231 2857 15 , , , 37231 2857 16 according accord VBG 37231 2857 17 to to IN 37231 2857 18 the the DT 37231 2857 19 epistles,(2 epistles,(2 NNP 37231 2857 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2857 21 perfect perfect JJ 37231 2857 22 freedom freedom NN 37231 2857 23 to to TO 37231 2857 24 see see VB 37231 2857 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2857 26 friends friend NNS 37231 2857 27 . . . 37231 2858 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2858 2 receives receive VBZ 37231 2858 3 the the DT 37231 2858 4 bishops bishop NNS 37231 2858 5 , , , 37231 2858 6 deacons deacon NNS 37231 2858 7 , , , 37231 2858 8 and and CC 37231 2858 9 members member NNS 37231 2858 10 of of IN 37231 2858 11 various various JJ 37231 2858 12 Christian christian JJ 37231 2858 13 communities community NNS 37231 2858 14 , , , 37231 2858 15 who who WP 37231 2858 16 come come VBP 37231 2858 17 with with IN 37231 2858 18 greetings greeting NNS 37231 2858 19 to to IN 37231 2858 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2858 21 , , , 37231 2858 22 and and CC 37231 2858 23 devoted devote VBN 37231 2858 24 followers follower NNS 37231 2858 25 accompany accompany VBP 37231 2858 26 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2858 27 on on IN 37231 2858 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2858 29 journey journey NN 37231 2858 30 . . . 37231 2859 1 All all PDT 37231 2859 2 this this DT 37231 2859 3 without without IN 37231 2859 4 hindrance hindrance NN 37231 2859 5 from from IN 37231 2859 6 the the DT 37231 2859 7 " " `` 37231 2859 8 ten ten CD 37231 2859 9 leopards leopard NNS 37231 2859 10 , , , 37231 2859 11 " " '' 37231 2859 12 of of IN 37231 2859 13 whose whose WP$ 37231 2859 14 cruelty cruelty NN 37231 2859 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2859 16 complains complain VBZ 37231 2859 17 , , , 37231 2859 18 and and CC 37231 2859 19 without without IN 37231 2859 20 persecution persecution NN 37231 2859 21 or or CC 37231 2859 22 harm harm NN 37231 2859 23 to to IN 37231 2859 24 those those DT 37231 2859 25 who who WP 37231 2859 26 so so RB 37231 2859 27 openly openly RB 37231 2859 28 declare declare VBP 37231 2859 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2859 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2859 31 friends friend NNS 37231 2859 32 and and CC 37231 2859 33 fellow fellow JJ 37231 2859 34 believers believer NNS 37231 2859 35 . . . 37231 2860 1 The the DT 37231 2860 2 whole whole JJ 37231 2860 3 story story NN 37231 2860 4 is be VBZ 37231 2860 5 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 2860 6 incredible incredible JJ 37231 2860 7 . . . 37231 2861 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2861 2 3 3 LS 37231 2861 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2861 4 This this DT 37231 2861 5 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2861 6 , , , 37231 2861 7 irresistible irresistible JJ 37231 2861 8 in in IN 37231 2861 9 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2861 10 , , , 37231 2861 11 is be VBZ 37231 2861 12 , , , 37231 2861 13 however however RB 37231 2861 14 , , , 37231 2861 15 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 2861 16 by by IN 37231 2861 17 facte facte NNP 37231 2861 18 arrived arrive VBD 37231 2861 19 at at IN 37231 2861 20 from from IN 37231 2861 21 a a DT 37231 2861 22 totally totally RB 37231 2861 23 different different JJ 37231 2861 24 point point NN 37231 2861 25 of of IN 37231 2861 26 view view NN 37231 2861 27 . . . 37231 2862 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2862 2 266 266 CD 37231 2862 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2862 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2862 5 has have VBZ 37231 2862 6 been be VBN 37231 2862 7 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 2862 8 that that IN 37231 2862 9 , , , 37231 2862 10 most most RBS 37231 2862 11 probably probably RB 37231 2862 12 , , , 37231 2862 13 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2862 14 was be VBD 37231 2862 15 not not RB 37231 2862 16 sent send VBN 37231 2862 17 to to IN 37231 2862 18 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2862 19 at at RB 37231 2862 20 all all RB 37231 2862 21 , , , 37231 2862 22 but but CC 37231 2862 23 suffered suffer VBN 37231 2862 24 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2862 25 in in IN 37231 2862 26 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 2862 27 itself(l itself(l . 37231 2862 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2862 29 on on IN 37231 2862 30 the the DT 37231 2862 31 20th 20th JJ 37231 2862 32 December December NNP 37231 2862 33 , , , 37231 2862 34 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2862 35 . . NNP 37231 2862 36 115,(2 115,(2 CD 37231 2862 37 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2862 38 when when WRB 37231 2862 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2862 40 was be VBD 37231 2862 41 condemned condemn VBN 37231 2862 42 to to TO 37231 2862 43 be be VB 37231 2862 44 cast cast VBN 37231 2862 45 to to IN 37231 2862 46 wild wild JJ 37231 2862 47 beasts beast NNS 37231 2862 48 in in IN 37231 2862 49 the the DT 37231 2862 50 amphitheatre amphitheatre NNP 37231 2862 51 , , , 37231 2862 52 in in IN 37231 2862 53 consequence consequence NN 37231 2862 54 of of IN 37231 2862 55 the the DT 37231 2862 56 fanatical fanatical JJ 37231 2862 57 excitement excitement NN 37231 2862 58 produced produce VBN 37231 2862 59 by by IN 37231 2862 60 the the DT 37231 2862 61 earthquake earthquake NN 37231 2862 62 which which WDT 37231 2862 63 took take VBD 37231 2862 64 place place NN 37231 2862 65 on on IN 37231 2862 66 the the DT 37231 2862 67 13th 13th NN 37231 2862 68 of of IN 37231 2862 69 that that DT 37231 2862 70 month month NN 37231 2862 71 . . . 37231 2863 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2863 2 3 3 LS 37231 2863 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2863 4 There there EX 37231 2863 5 are be VBP 37231 2863 6 no no RB 37231 2863 7 less less JJR 37231 2863 8 than than IN 37231 2863 9 three three CD 37231 2863 10 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 37231 2863 11 of of IN 37231 2863 12 Ignatius,(4 Ignatius,(4 NNP 37231 2863 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2863 14 giving give VBG 37231 2863 15 an an DT 37231 2863 16 account account NN 37231 2863 17 of of IN 37231 2863 18 the the DT 37231 2863 19 martyr martyr NN 37231 2863 20 's 's POS 37231 2863 21 journey journey NN 37231 2863 22 from from IN 37231 2863 23 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 2863 24 to to IN 37231 2863 25 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2863 26 , , , 37231 2863 27 but but CC 37231 2863 28 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2863 29 are be VBP 37231 2863 30 all all RB 37231 2863 31 recognised recognise VBN 37231 2863 32 to to TO 37231 2863 33 be be VB 37231 2863 34 mere mere JJ 37231 2863 35 idle idle JJ 37231 2863 36 legends legend NNS 37231 2863 37 , , , 37231 2863 38 of of IN 37231 2863 39 whose whose WP$ 37231 2863 40 existence existence NN 37231 2863 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2863 42 do do VBP 37231 2863 43 not not RB 37231 2863 44 hear hear VB 37231 2863 45 till till IN 37231 2863 46 a a DT 37231 2863 47 very very RB 37231 2863 48 late late JJ 37231 2863 49 period period NN 37231 2863 50 . . . 37231 2864 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2864 2 5 5 LS 37231 2864 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2864 4 In in IN 37231 2864 5 fact fact NN 37231 2864 6 the the DT 37231 2864 7 whole whole NN 37231 2864 8 of of IN 37231 2864 9 the the DT 37231 2864 10 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 2864 11 literature literature NN 37231 2864 12 is be VBZ 37231 2864 13 a a DT 37231 2864 14 mass mass NN 37231 2864 15 of of IN 37231 2864 16 falsification falsification NN 37231 2864 17 and and CC 37231 2864 18 fraud fraud NN 37231 2864 19 . . . 37231 2865 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2865 2 might may MD 37231 2865 3 well well RB 37231 2865 4 spare spare VB 37231 2865 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2865 6 readers reader NNS 37231 2865 7 the the DT 37231 2865 8 trouble trouble NN 37231 2865 9 of of IN 37231 2865 10 examining examine VBG 37231 2865 11 further far RBR 37231 2865 12 the the DT 37231 2865 13 contents content NNS 37231 2865 14 of of IN 37231 2865 15 the the DT 37231 2865 16 epistles epistles NNPS 37231 2865 17 of of IN 37231 2865 18 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 2865 19 - - NNP 37231 2865 20 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2865 21 , , , 37231 2865 22 for for IN 37231 2865 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2865 24 is be VBZ 37231 2865 25 manifest manifest JJ 37231 2865 26 that that IN 37231 2865 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2865 28 can can MD 37231 2865 29 not not RB 37231 2865 30 afford afford VB 37231 2865 31 testimony testimony NN 37231 2865 32 { { -LRB- 37231 2865 33 267 267 CD 37231 2865 34 } } -RRB- 37231 2865 35 of of IN 37231 2865 36 any any DT 37231 2865 37 value value NN 37231 2865 38 on on IN 37231 2865 39 the the DT 37231 2865 40 subject subject NN 37231 2865 41 of of IN 37231 2865 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2865 43 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 2865 44 . . . 37231 2866 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2866 2 shall shall MD 37231 2866 3 , , , 37231 2866 4 however however RB 37231 2866 5 , , , 37231 2866 6 briefly briefly RB 37231 2866 7 point point VB 37231 2866 8 out out RP 37231 2866 9 all all PDT 37231 2866 10 the the DT 37231 2866 11 passages passage NNS 37231 2866 12 contained contain VBN 37231 2866 13 in in IN 37231 2866 14 the the DT 37231 2866 15 seven seven CD 37231 2866 16 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2866 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2866 18 which which WDT 37231 2866 19 have have VBP 37231 2866 20 any any DT 37231 2866 21 bearing bearing NN 37231 2866 22 upon upon IN 37231 2866 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2866 24 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2866 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2866 26 , , , 37231 2866 27 in in IN 37231 2866 28 order order NN 37231 2866 29 that that IN 37231 2866 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2866 31 exact exact JJ 37231 2866 32 position position NN 37231 2866 33 may may MD 37231 2866 34 be be VB 37231 2866 35 more more RBR 37231 2866 36 fully fully RB 37231 2866 37 appreciated appreciate VBN 37231 2866 38 . . . 37231 2867 1 Teschendorf(1 Teschendorf(1 NNP 37231 2867 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2867 3 refers refer VBZ 37231 2867 4 to to IN 37231 2867 5 a a DT 37231 2867 6 passage passage NN 37231 2867 7 in in IN 37231 2867 8 the the DT 37231 2867 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2867 10 to to IN 37231 2867 11 the the DT 37231 2867 12 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 2867 13 , , , 37231 2867 14 c. c. NNP 37231 2868 1 vi vi NNP 37231 2868 2 . . NNP 37231 2868 3 , , , 37231 2868 4 as as IN 37231 2868 5 a a DT 37231 2868 6 verbal verbal JJ 37231 2868 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 2868 8 of of IN 37231 2868 9 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2868 10 xvi xvi NNP 37231 2868 11 . . . 37231 2869 1 26 26 CD 37231 2869 2 , , , 37231 2869 3 but but CC 37231 2869 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2869 5 neither neither CC 37231 2869 6 gives give VBZ 37231 2869 7 the the DT 37231 2869 8 context context NN 37231 2869 9 nor nor CC 37231 2869 10 states state VBZ 37231 2869 11 the the DT 37231 2869 12 facts fact NNS 37231 2869 13 of of IN 37231 2869 14 the the DT 37231 2869 15 case case NN 37231 2869 16 . . . 37231 2870 1 The the DT 37231 2870 2 passage passage NN 37231 2870 3 reads read VBZ 37231 2870 4 as as IN 37231 2870 5 follows follow VBZ 37231 2870 6 : : : 37231 2870 7 " " `` 37231 2870 8 The the DT 37231 2870 9 pleasures pleasure NNS 37231 2870 10 of of IN 37231 2870 11 the the DT 37231 2870 12 world world NN 37231 2870 13 shall shall MD 37231 2870 14 profit profit VB 37231 2870 15 me -PRON- PRP 37231 2870 16 nothing nothing NN 37231 2870 17 , , , 37231 2870 18 nor nor CC 37231 2870 19 the the DT 37231 2870 20 kingdoms kingdom NNS 37231 2870 21 of of IN 37231 2870 22 this this DT 37231 2870 23 time time NN 37231 2870 24 ; ; : 37231 2870 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2870 26 is be VBZ 37231 2870 27 better well JJR 37231 2870 28 for for IN 37231 2870 29 me -PRON- PRP 37231 2870 30 to to TO 37231 2870 31 die die VB 37231 2870 32 for for IN 37231 2870 33 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2870 34 Christ Christ NNP 37231 2870 35 , , , 37231 2870 36 than than IN 37231 2870 37 to to TO 37231 2870 38 reign reign VB 37231 2870 39 over over IN 37231 2870 40 the the DT 37231 2870 41 ends end NNS 37231 2870 42 of of IN 37231 2870 43 the the DT 37231 2870 44 earth earth NN 37231 2870 45 . . . 37231 2871 1 For for IN 37231 2871 2 what what WP 37231 2871 3 is be VBZ 37231 2871 4 a a DT 37231 2871 5 man man NN 37231 2871 6 profited profit VBN 37231 2871 7 if if IN 37231 2871 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2871 9 gain gain VB 37231 2871 10 the the DT 37231 2871 11 whole whole JJ 37231 2871 12 world world NN 37231 2871 13 , , , 37231 2871 14 but but CC 37231 2871 15 lose lose VB 37231 2871 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2871 17 soul soul NN 37231 2871 18 . . . 37231 2872 1 " " `` 37231 2872 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2872 3 2 2 LS 37231 2872 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2872 5 Now now RB 37231 2872 6 this this DT 37231 2872 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 2872 8 not not RB 37231 2872 9 only only RB 37231 2872 10 is be VBZ 37231 2872 11 not not RB 37231 2872 12 found find VBN 37231 2872 13 in in IN 37231 2872 14 the the DT 37231 2872 15 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2872 16 version version NN 37231 2872 17 of of IN 37231 2872 18 the the DT 37231 2872 19 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2872 20 , , , 37231 2872 21 but but CC 37231 2872 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2872 23 is be VBZ 37231 2872 24 also also RB 37231 2872 25 omitted omit VBN 37231 2872 26 from from IN 37231 2872 27 the the DT 37231 2872 28 ancient ancient JJ 37231 2872 29 Latin latin JJ 37231 2872 30 version version NN 37231 2872 31 , , , 37231 2872 32 and and CC 37231 2872 33 is be VBZ 37231 2872 34 absent absent JJ 37231 2872 35 from from IN 37231 2872 36 the the DT 37231 2872 37 passage passage NN 37231 2872 38 in in IN 37231 2872 39 the the DT 37231 2872 40 work work NN 37231 2872 41 of of IN 37231 2872 42 Timotheus Timotheus NNP 37231 2872 43 of of IN 37231 2872 44 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 2872 45 against against IN 37231 2872 46 the the DT 37231 2872 47 Council Council NNP 37231 2872 48 of of IN 37231 2872 49 Chalcedon Chalcedon NNP 37231 2872 50 , , , 37231 2872 51 and and CC 37231 2872 52 from from IN 37231 2872 53 other other JJ 37231 2872 54 authorities authority NNS 37231 2872 55 . . . 37231 2873 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2873 2 is be VBZ 37231 2873 3 evidently evidently RB 37231 2873 4 a a DT 37231 2873 5 later later JJ 37231 2873 6 addition addition NN 37231 2873 7 , , , 37231 2873 8 and and CC 37231 2873 9 is be VBZ 37231 2873 10 recognized recognize VBN 37231 2873 11 as as IN 37231 2873 12 such such JJ 37231 2873 13 by by IN 37231 2873 14 most most JJS 37231 2873 15 critics critic NNS 37231 2873 16 . . . 37231 2874 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2874 2 3 3 LS 37231 2874 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2874 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2874 5 was be VBD 37231 2874 6 probably probably RB 37231 2874 7 a a DT 37231 2874 8 gloss gloss NN 37231 2874 9 , , , 37231 2874 10 which which WDT 37231 2874 11 subsequently subsequently RB 37231 2874 12 was be VBD 37231 2874 13 inserted insert VBN 37231 2874 14 in in IN 37231 2874 15 the the DT 37231 2874 16 text text NN 37231 2874 17 . . . 37231 2875 1 Of of IN 37231 2875 2 these these DT 37231 2875 3 facts fact NNS 37231 2875 4 , , , 37231 2875 5 however however RB 37231 2875 6 , , , 37231 2875 7 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 2875 8 does do VBZ 37231 2875 9 not not RB 37231 2875 10 say say VB 37231 2875 11 a a DT 37231 2875 12 word word NN 37231 2875 13 . . . 37231 2876 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2876 2 4 4 LS 37231 2876 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2876 4 The the DT 37231 2876 5 next next JJ 37231 2876 6 passage passage NN 37231 2876 7 to to IN 37231 2876 8 which which WDT 37231 2876 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2876 10 refers refer VBZ 37231 2876 11 is be VBZ 37231 2876 12 in in IN 37231 2876 13 the the DT 37231 2876 14 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2876 15 to to IN 37231 2876 16 the the DT 37231 2876 17 Smyrnæans Smyrnæans NNPS 37231 2876 18 , , , 37231 2876 19 c. c. NNP 37231 2876 20 i. i. NNP 37231 2876 21 , , , 37231 2876 22 where where WRB 37231 2876 23 the the DT 37231 2876 24 writer writer NN 37231 2876 25 says say VBZ 37231 2876 26 of of IN 37231 2876 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2876 28 : : : 37231 2876 29 " " `` 37231 2876 30 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2876 31 was be VBD 37231 2876 32 baptized baptize VBN 37231 2876 33 by by IN 37231 2876 34 John John NNP 37231 2876 35 in in IN 37231 2876 36 order order NN 37231 2876 37 that that IN 37231 2876 38 all all DT 37231 2876 39 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 2876 40 { { -LRB- 37231 2876 41 268 268 CD 37231 2876 42 } } -RRB- 37231 2876 43 might may MD 37231 2876 44 be be VB 37231 2876 45 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 2876 46 by by IN 37231 2876 47 Him,"(1)--which Him,"(1)--which NNP 37231 2876 48 Teschendorf Teschendorf NNP 37231 2876 49 considers consider VBZ 37231 2876 50 a a DT 37231 2876 51 reminiscence reminiscence NN 37231 2876 52 of of IN 37231 2876 53 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2876 54 iii iii NNP 37231 2876 55 . . . 37231 2877 1 15 15 CD 37231 2877 2 , , , 37231 2877 3 " " `` 37231 2877 4 For for IN 37231 2877 5 thus thus RB 37231 2877 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2877 7 becometh becometh VBZ 37231 2877 8 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2877 9 to to TO 37231 2877 10 fulfil fulfil VB 37231 2877 11 all all DT 37231 2877 12 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 2877 13 . . . 37231 2878 1 " " `` 37231 2878 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2878 3 2 2 LS 37231 2878 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2878 5 The the DT 37231 2878 6 phrase phrase NN 37231 2878 7 , , , 37231 2878 8 besides besides IN 37231 2878 9 being be VBG 37231 2878 10 no no DT 37231 2878 11 quotation quotation NN 37231 2878 12 , , , 37231 2878 13 has have VBZ 37231 2878 14 again again RB 37231 2878 15 all all PDT 37231 2878 16 the the DT 37231 2878 17 appearance appearance NN 37231 2878 18 of of IN 37231 2878 19 being be VBG 37231 2878 20 an an DT 37231 2878 21 addition addition NN 37231 2878 22 ; ; : 37231 2878 23 and and CC 37231 2878 24 when when WRB 37231 2878 25 in in IN 37231 2878 26 Ch Ch NNP 37231 2878 27 . . . 37231 2879 1 iii iii NNP 37231 2879 2 . . . 37231 2880 1 of of IN 37231 2880 2 the the DT 37231 2880 3 same same JJ 37231 2880 4 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2880 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2880 6 find find VBP 37231 2880 7 a a DT 37231 2880 8 palpable palpable JJ 37231 2880 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 2880 10 from from IN 37231 2880 11 an an DT 37231 2880 12 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2880 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2880 14 , , , 37231 2880 15 which which WDT 37231 2880 16 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2880 17 states state VBZ 37231 2880 18 to to TO 37231 2880 19 be be VB 37231 2880 20 the the DT 37231 2880 21 " " `` 37231 2880 22 Gospel gospel NN 37231 2880 23 according accord VBG 37231 2880 24 to to IN 37231 2880 25 the the DT 37231 2880 26 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 2880 27 , , , 37231 2880 28 " " '' 37231 2880 29 to to TO 37231 2880 30 which which WDT 37231 2880 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2880 32 shall shall MD 37231 2880 33 presently presently RB 37231 2880 34 refer refer VB 37231 2880 35 , , , 37231 2880 36 a a DT 37231 2880 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2880 38 which which WDT 37231 2880 39 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2880 40 know know VBP 37231 2880 41 to to TO 37231 2880 42 have have VB 37231 2880 43 contained contain VBN 37231 2880 44 the the DT 37231 2880 45 baptism baptism NN 37231 2880 46 of of IN 37231 2880 47 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2880 48 by by IN 37231 2880 49 John John NNP 37231 2880 50 , , , 37231 2880 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2880 52 is be VBZ 37231 2880 53 not not RB 37231 2880 54 possible possible JJ 37231 2880 55 , , , 37231 2880 56 even even RB 37231 2880 57 if if IN 37231 2880 58 the the DT 37231 2880 59 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2880 60 were be VBD 37231 2880 61 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2880 62 , , , 37231 2880 63 which which WDT 37231 2880 64 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2880 65 is be VBZ 37231 2880 66 not not RB 37231 2880 67 , , , 37231 2880 68 to to TO 37231 2880 69 base base VB 37231 2880 70 any any DT 37231 2880 71 such such JJ 37231 2880 72 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2880 73 upon upon IN 37231 2880 74 these these DT 37231 2880 75 words word NNS 37231 2880 76 . . . 37231 2881 1 There there EX 37231 2881 2 is be VBZ 37231 2881 3 not not RB 37231 2881 4 only only RB 37231 2881 5 the the DT 37231 2881 6 alternative alternative NN 37231 2881 7 of of IN 37231 2881 8 tradition tradition NN 37231 2881 9 , , , 37231 2881 10 but but CC 37231 2881 11 the the DT 37231 2881 12 use use NN 37231 2881 13 of of IN 37231 2881 14 the the DT 37231 2881 15 same same JJ 37231 2881 16 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2881 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2881 18 , , , 37231 2881 19 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 2881 20 quoted quote VBN 37231 2881 21 in in IN 37231 2881 22 the the DT 37231 2881 23 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2881 24 , , , 37231 2881 25 as as IN 37231 2881 26 the the DT 37231 2881 27 source source NN 37231 2881 28 of of IN 37231 2881 29 the the DT 37231 2881 30 reminiscence reminiscence NN 37231 2881 31 . . . 37231 2882 1 Tischendorf tischendorf NN 37231 2882 2 does do VBZ 37231 2882 3 not not RB 37231 2882 4 point point VB 37231 2882 5 out out RP 37231 2882 6 any any DT 37231 2882 7 more more RBR 37231 2882 8 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2882 9 references reference NNS 37231 2882 10 to to IN 37231 2882 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2882 12 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2882 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2882 14 , , , 37231 2882 15 but but CC 37231 2882 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2882 17 proceed proceed VBP 37231 2882 18 to to TO 37231 2882 19 notice notice VB 37231 2882 20 all all PDT 37231 2882 21 the the DT 37231 2882 22 other other JJ 37231 2882 23 passages passage NNS 37231 2882 24 which which WDT 37231 2882 25 have have VBP 37231 2882 26 been be VBN 37231 2882 27 indicated indicate VBN 37231 2882 28 by by IN 37231 2882 29 others other NNS 37231 2882 30 . . . 37231 2883 1 In in IN 37231 2883 2 the the DT 37231 2883 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2883 4 to to IN 37231 2883 5 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2883 6 , , , 37231 2883 7 c. c. NNP 37231 2884 1 ii ii NNP 37231 2884 2 . . NNP 37231 2884 3 , , , 37231 2884 4 the the DT 37231 2884 5 following follow VBG 37231 2884 6 sentence sentence NN 37231 2884 7 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2884 8 : : : 37231 2884 9 " " `` 37231 2884 10 Be be VB 37231 2884 11 thou thou NNP 37231 2884 12 wise wise JJ 37231 2884 13 as as IN 37231 2884 14 a a DT 37231 2884 15 serpent serpent NN 37231 2884 16 in in IN 37231 2884 17 everything everything NN 37231 2884 18 , , , 37231 2884 19 and and CC 37231 2884 20 harmless harmless JJ 37231 2884 21 as as IN 37231 2884 22 the the DT 37231 2884 23 dove dove NN 37231 2884 24 . . . 37231 2884 25 " " '' 37231 2885 1 This this DT 37231 2885 2 is be VBZ 37231 2885 3 , , , 37231 2885 4 of of IN 37231 2885 5 course course NN 37231 2885 6 , , , 37231 2885 7 compared compare VBN 37231 2885 8 with with IN 37231 2885 9 Matth Matth NNP 37231 2885 10 . . . 37231 2886 1 x. x. NNP 37231 2887 1 16 16 CD 37231 2887 2 , , , 37231 2887 3 " " `` 37231 2887 4 Be be VB 37231 2887 5 ye ye NNP 37231 2887 6 , , , 37231 2887 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 2887 8 , , , 37231 2887 9 wise wise JJ 37231 2887 10 as as IN 37231 2887 11 serpents serpent NNS 37231 2887 12 and and CC 37231 2887 13 innocent innocent JJ 37231 2887 14 as as IN 37231 2887 15 doves dove NNS 37231 2887 16 . . . 37231 2887 17 " " '' 37231 2888 1 The the DT 37231 2888 2 Greek Greek NNP 37231 2888 3 of of IN 37231 2888 4 both both DT 37231 2888 5 reads read NNS 37231 2888 6 as as IN 37231 2888 7 follows follow VBZ 37231 2888 8 : : : 37231 2888 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2888 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2888 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2888 12 In in IN 37231 2888 13 the the DT 37231 2888 14 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2888 15 version version NN 37231 2888 16 , , , 37231 2888 17 the the DT 37231 2888 18 passage passage NN 37231 2888 19 reads read VBZ 37231 2888 20 : : : 37231 2888 21 " " `` 37231 2888 22 Be be VB 37231 2888 23 thou thou NNP 37231 2888 24 wise wise JJ 37231 2888 25 as as IN 37231 2888 26 the the DT 37231 2888 27 serpent serpent NN 37231 2888 28 in in IN 37231 2888 29 everything everything NN 37231 2888 30 , , , 37231 2888 31 and and CC 37231 2888 32 harmless harmless JJ 37231 2888 33 as as IN 37231 2888 34 to to IN 37231 2888 35 those those DT 37231 2888 36 things thing NNS 37231 2888 37 which which WDT 37231 2888 38 are be VBP 37231 2888 39 requisite requisite JJ 37231 2888 40 as as IN 37231 2888 41 the the DT 37231 2888 42 dove dove NN 37231 2888 43 . . . 37231 2889 1 " " `` 37231 2889 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2889 3 4 4 LS 37231 2889 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2889 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2889 6 is be VBZ 37231 2889 7 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 2889 8 { { -LRB- 37231 2889 9 269 269 CD 37231 2889 10 } } -RRB- 37231 2889 11 to to TO 37231 2889 12 add add VB 37231 2889 13 that that IN 37231 2889 14 no no DT 37231 2889 15 source source NN 37231 2889 16 is be VBZ 37231 2889 17 indicated indicate VBN 37231 2889 18 for for IN 37231 2889 19 the the DT 37231 2889 20 reminiscence reminiscence NN 37231 2889 21 . . . 37231 2890 1 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 2890 2 assigns assign VBZ 37231 2890 3 this this DT 37231 2890 4 part part NN 37231 2890 5 of of IN 37231 2890 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2890 7 first first JJ 37231 2890 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2890 9 originally originally RB 37231 2890 10 to to IN 37231 2890 11 the the DT 37231 2890 12 Spruchsammlung,(1 spruchsammlung,(1 NN 37231 2890 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2890 14 and and CC 37231 2890 15 even even RB 37231 2890 16 apart apart RB 37231 2890 17 from from IN 37231 2890 18 the the DT 37231 2890 19 variations variation NNS 37231 2890 20 presented present VBN 37231 2890 21 in in IN 37231 2890 22 the the DT 37231 2890 23 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2890 24 there there EX 37231 2890 25 is be VBZ 37231 2890 26 nothing nothing NN 37231 2890 27 to to TO 37231 2890 28 warrant warrant VB 37231 2890 29 exclusive exclusive JJ 37231 2890 30 selection selection NN 37231 2890 31 of of IN 37231 2890 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2890 33 first first JJ 37231 2890 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2890 35 as as IN 37231 2890 36 the the DT 37231 2890 37 source source NN 37231 2890 38 of of IN 37231 2890 39 the the DT 37231 2890 40 saying saying NN 37231 2890 41 . . . 37231 2891 1 The the DT 37231 2891 2 remaining remain VBG 37231 2891 3 passages passage NNS 37231 2891 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2891 5 subjoin subjoin VBP 37231 2891 6 in in IN 37231 2891 7 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2891 8 columns column NNS 37231 2891 9 . . . 37231 2892 1 None none NN 37231 2892 2 of of IN 37231 2892 3 these these DT 37231 2892 4 passages passage NNS 37231 2892 5 are be VBP 37231 2892 6 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2892 7 , , , 37231 2892 8 and and CC 37231 2892 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2892 10 generally generally RB 37231 2892 11 present present VBP 37231 2892 12 such such JJ 37231 2892 13 marked mark VBN 37231 2892 14 linguistic linguistic JJ 37231 2892 15 variations variation NNS 37231 2892 16 from from IN 37231 2892 17 the the DT 37231 2892 18 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2892 19 { { -LRB- 37231 2892 20 270 270 CD 37231 2892 21 } } -RRB- 37231 2892 22 passages passage NNS 37231 2892 23 in in IN 37231 2892 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2892 25 first first JJ 37231 2892 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2892 27 , , , 37231 2892 28 that that IN 37231 2892 29 there there EX 37231 2892 30 is be VBZ 37231 2892 31 not not RB 37231 2892 32 the the DT 37231 2892 33 slightest slight JJS 37231 2892 34 ground ground NN 37231 2892 35 for for IN 37231 2892 36 specially specially RB 37231 2892 37 referring refer VBG 37231 2892 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2892 39 to to IN 37231 2892 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2892 41 . . . 37231 2893 1 The the DT 37231 2893 2 last last JJ 37231 2893 3 words word NNS 37231 2893 4 cited cite VBN 37231 2893 5 are be VBP 37231 2893 6 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2893 7 without without IN 37231 2893 8 any any DT 37231 2893 9 appropriate appropriate JJ 37231 2893 10 context context NN 37231 2893 11 . . . 37231 2894 1 In in IN 37231 2894 2 no no DT 37231 2894 3 case case NN 37231 2894 4 are be VBP 37231 2894 5 the the DT 37231 2894 6 expressions expression NNS 37231 2894 7 indicated indicate VBN 37231 2894 8 as as IN 37231 2894 9 quotations quotation NNS 37231 2894 10 from from IN 37231 2894 11 , , , 37231 2894 12 or or CC 37231 2894 13 references reference NNS 37231 2894 14 to to IN 37231 2894 15 , , , 37231 2894 16 any any DT 37231 2894 17 particular particular JJ 37231 2894 18 source source NN 37231 2894 19 . . . 37231 2895 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 2895 2 may may MD 37231 2895 3 either either CC 37231 2895 4 be be VB 37231 2895 5 traditional traditional JJ 37231 2895 6 , , , 37231 2895 7 or or CC 37231 2895 8 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 37231 2895 9 of of IN 37231 2895 10 some some DT 37231 2895 11 of of IN 37231 2895 12 the the DT 37231 2895 13 numerous numerous JJ 37231 2895 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2895 15 current current NN 37231 2895 16 in in IN 37231 2895 17 the the DT 37231 2895 18 early early JJ 37231 2895 19 Church Church NNP 37231 2895 20 , , , 37231 2895 21 such such JJ 37231 2895 22 as as IN 37231 2895 23 the the DT 37231 2895 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2895 25 according accord VBG 37231 2895 26 to to IN 37231 2895 27 the the DT 37231 2895 28 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 2895 29 . . . 37231 2896 1 That that IN 37231 2896 2 the the DT 37231 2896 3 writer writer NN 37231 2896 4 made make VBD 37231 2896 5 use use NN 37231 2896 6 of of IN 37231 2896 7 one one CD 37231 2896 8 of of IN 37231 2896 9 these these DT 37231 2896 10 can can MD 37231 2896 11 not not RB 37231 2896 12 be be VB 37231 2896 13 doubted doubt VBN 37231 2896 14 . . . 37231 2897 1 In in IN 37231 2897 2 the the DT 37231 2897 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2897 4 to to IN 37231 2897 5 the the DT 37231 2897 6 Smyrnaeans Smyrnaeans NNPS 37231 2897 7 , , , 37231 2897 8 c. c. NNP 37231 2898 1 iii iii NNP 37231 2898 2 . . NNP 37231 2898 3 , , , 37231 2898 4 there there EX 37231 2898 5 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2898 6 a a DT 37231 2898 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 2898 8 from from IN 37231 2898 9 an an DT 37231 2898 10 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2898 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2898 12 to to TO 37231 2898 13 which which WDT 37231 2898 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2898 15 have have VBP 37231 2898 16 already already RB 37231 2898 17 , , , 37231 2898 18 in in IN 37231 2898 19 passing pass VBG 37231 2898 20 , , , 37231 2898 21 referred refer VBD 37231 2898 22 : : : 37231 2898 23 " " `` 37231 2898 24 For for CC 37231 2898 25 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2898 26 know know VBP 37231 2898 27 that that IN 37231 2898 28 also also RB 37231 2898 29 after after IN 37231 2898 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2898 31 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 2898 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2898 33 was be VBD 37231 2898 34 in in IN 37231 2898 35 the the DT 37231 2898 36 flesh flesh NN 37231 2898 37 , , , 37231 2898 38 and and CC 37231 2898 39 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2898 40 believe believe VBP 37231 2898 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2898 42 is be VBZ 37231 2898 43 so so RB 37231 2898 44 now now RB 37231 2898 45 . . . 37231 2899 1 And and CC 37231 2899 2 when when WRB 37231 2899 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2899 4 came come VBD 37231 2899 5 to to IN 37231 2899 6 those those DT 37231 2899 7 who who WP 37231 2899 8 were be VBD 37231 2899 9 with with IN 37231 2899 10 Peter Peter NNP 37231 2899 11 , , , 37231 2899 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2899 13 said say VBD 37231 2899 14 to to IN 37231 2899 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2899 16 : : : 37231 2899 17 Lay Lay NNP 37231 2899 18 hold hold VB 37231 2899 19 , , , 37231 2899 20 handle handle VB 37231 2899 21 me -PRON- PRP 37231 2899 22 , , , 37231 2899 23 and and CC 37231 2899 24 see see VB 37231 2899 25 that that IN 37231 2899 26 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2899 27 am be VBP 37231 2899 28 not not RB 37231 2899 29 an an DT 37231 2899 30 incorporeal incorporeal JJ 37231 2899 31 spirit spirit NN 37231 2899 32 , , , 37231 2899 33 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2899 34 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2899 35 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2899 36 . . . 37231 2900 1 And and CC 37231 2900 2 immediately immediately RB 37231 2900 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2900 4 touched touch VBD 37231 2900 5 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2900 6 and and CC 37231 2900 7 believed believe VBD 37231 2900 8 , , , 37231 2900 9 being be VBG 37231 2900 10 convinced convince VBN 37231 2900 11 by by IN 37231 2900 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2900 13 flesh flesh NN 37231 2900 14 and and CC 37231 2900 15 spirit spirit NN 37231 2900 16 . . . 37231 2900 17 " " '' 37231 2901 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 2901 2 , , , 37231 2901 3 who who WP 37231 2901 4 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2901 5 this this DT 37231 2901 6 passage passage NN 37231 2901 7 , , , 37231 2901 8 says say VBZ 37231 2901 9 that that IN 37231 2901 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2901 11 does do VBZ 37231 2901 12 not not RB 37231 2901 13 know know VB 37231 2901 14 whence whence NN 37231 2901 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2901 16 is be VBZ 37231 2901 17 taken take VBN 37231 2901 18 . . . 37231 2902 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2902 2 2 2 LS 37231 2902 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2902 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 2902 5 , , , 37231 2902 6 however however RB 37231 2902 7 , , , 37231 2902 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 2902 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2902 10 from from IN 37231 2902 11 a a DT 37231 2902 12 work work NN 37231 2902 13 well well RB 37231 2902 14 known know VBN 37231 2902 15 in in IN 37231 2902 16 the the DT 37231 2902 17 early early JJ 37231 2902 18 Church Church NNP 37231 2902 19 , , , 37231 2902 20 called call VBN 37231 2902 21 " " `` 37231 2902 22 The the DT 37231 2902 23 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 37231 2902 24 of of IN 37231 2902 25 Peter Peter NNP 37231 2902 26 , , , 37231 2902 27 " " `` 37231 2902 28 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2902 29 --Greek--];(3 --Greek--];(3 NFP 37231 2902 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2902 31 and and CC 37231 2902 32 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2902 33 found find VBD 37231 2902 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2902 35 in in IN 37231 2902 36 the the DT 37231 2902 37 " " `` 37231 2902 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2902 39 according accord VBG 37231 2902 40 to to IN 37231 2902 41 the the DT 37231 2902 42 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 2902 43 , , , 37231 2902 44 " " '' 37231 2902 45 in in IN 37231 2902 46 use use NN 37231 2902 47 among among IN 37231 2902 48 the the DT 37231 2902 49 Nazarenes,(4 nazarenes,(4 NN 37231 2902 50 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2902 51 which which WDT 37231 2902 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2902 53 translated translate VBD 37231 2902 54 , , , 37231 2902 55 as as IN 37231 2902 56 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2902 57 shall shall MD 37231 2902 58 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 2902 59 sec sec NNP 37231 2902 60 . . . 37231 2903 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2903 2 was be VBD 37231 2903 3 , , , 37231 2903 4 no no RB 37231 2903 5 doubt doubt RB 37231 2903 6 , , , 37231 2903 7 in in IN 37231 2903 8 both both DT 37231 2903 9 of of IN 37231 2903 10 those those DT 37231 2903 11 works work NNS 37231 2903 12 . . . 37231 2904 1 The the DT 37231 2904 2 narrative narrative NN 37231 2904 3 , , , 37231 2904 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2904 5 xxiv xxiv NNP 37231 2904 6 . . . 37231 2905 1 39 39 CD 37231 2905 2 f. f. NNP 37231 2905 3 , , , 37231 2905 4 being be VBG 37231 2905 5 neglected neglect VBN 37231 2905 6 , , , 37231 2905 7 and and CC 37231 2905 8 an an DT 37231 2905 9 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 2905 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2905 11 used use VBD 37231 2905 12 here here RB 37231 2905 13 , , , 37231 2905 14 the the DT 37231 2905 15 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 2905 16 inference inference NN 37231 2905 17 is be VBZ 37231 2905 18 clear clear JJ 37231 2905 19 and and CC 37231 2905 20 very very RB 37231 2905 21 suggestive suggestive JJ 37231 2905 22 . . . 37231 2906 1 As as IN 37231 2906 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2906 3 is be VBZ 37231 2906 4 certain certain JJ 37231 2906 5 that that IN 37231 2906 6 this this DT 37231 2906 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 2906 8 was be VBD 37231 2906 9 taken take VBN 37231 2906 10 from from IN 37231 2906 11 a a DT 37231 2906 12 source source NN 37231 2906 13 { { -LRB- 37231 2906 14 271 271 CD 37231 2906 15 } } -RRB- 37231 2906 16 different different RB 37231 2906 17 from from IN 37231 2906 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2906 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2906 20 , , , 37231 2906 21 there there EX 37231 2906 22 is be VBZ 37231 2906 23 reason reason NN 37231 2906 24 to to TO 37231 2906 25 suppose suppose VB 37231 2906 26 that that IN 37231 2906 27 the the DT 37231 2906 28 other other JJ 37231 2906 29 passages passage NNS 37231 2906 30 which which WDT 37231 2906 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2906 32 have have VBP 37231 2906 33 cited cite VBN 37231 2906 34 are be VBP 37231 2906 35 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 37231 2906 36 of of IN 37231 2906 37 the the DT 37231 2906 38 same same JJ 37231 2906 39 work work NN 37231 2906 40 . . . 37231 2907 1 The the DT 37231 2907 2 passage passage NN 37231 2907 3 on on IN 37231 2907 4 the the DT 37231 2907 5 three three CD 37231 2907 6 mysteries mystery NNS 37231 2907 7 in in IN 37231 2907 8 the the DT 37231 2907 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2907 10 to to IN 37231 2907 11 the the DT 37231 2907 12 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 37231 2907 13 , , , 37231 2907 14 c. c. NN 37231 2908 1 xix xix NNP 37231 2908 2 . . NNP 37231 2908 3 , , , 37231 2908 4 is be VBZ 37231 2908 5 evidently evidently RB 37231 2908 6 another another DT 37231 2908 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 2908 8 from from IN 37231 2908 9 an an DT 37231 2908 10 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 37231 2908 11 source source NN 37231 2908 12 . . . 37231 2909 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2909 2 1 1 LS 37231 2909 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2909 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2909 5 must must MD 37231 2909 6 , , , 37231 2909 7 however however RB 37231 2909 8 , , , 37231 2909 9 again again RB 37231 2909 10 point point VB 37231 2909 11 out out RP 37231 2909 12 that that IN 37231 2909 13 , , , 37231 2909 14 with with IN 37231 2909 15 the the DT 37231 2909 16 single single JJ 37231 2909 17 exception exception NN 37231 2909 18 of of IN 37231 2909 19 the the DT 37231 2909 20 short short JJ 37231 2909 21 passage passage NN 37231 2909 22 in in IN 37231 2909 23 the the DT 37231 2909 24 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2909 25 to to IN 37231 2909 26 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2909 27 , , , 37231 2909 28 c. c. NNP 37231 2910 1 ii ii NNP 37231 2910 2 . . NNP 37231 2910 3 , , , 37231 2910 4 which which WDT 37231 2910 5 is be VBZ 37231 2910 6 not not RB 37231 2910 7 a a DT 37231 2910 8 quotation quotation NN 37231 2910 9 , , , 37231 2910 10 differs differ VBZ 37231 2910 11 from from IN 37231 2910 12 the the DT 37231 2910 13 reading reading NN 37231 2910 14 in in IN 37231 2910 15 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2910 16 , , , 37231 2910 17 and and CC 37231 2910 18 may may MD 37231 2910 19 well well RB 37231 2910 20 be be VB 37231 2910 21 from from IN 37231 2910 22 any any DT 37231 2910 23 other other JJ 37231 2910 24 source source NN 37231 2910 25 , , , 37231 2910 26 none none NN 37231 2910 27 of of IN 37231 2910 28 these these DT 37231 2910 29 supposed suppose VBN 37231 2910 30 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 37231 2910 31 of of IN 37231 2910 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2910 33 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2910 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2910 35 are be VBP 37231 2910 36 found find VBN 37231 2910 37 in in IN 37231 2910 38 the the DT 37231 2910 39 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2910 40 version version NN 37231 2910 41 of of IN 37231 2910 42 the the DT 37231 2910 43 three three CD 37231 2910 44 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2910 45 . . . 37231 2911 1 The the DT 37231 2911 2 evidential evidential JJ 37231 2911 3 value value NN 37231 2911 4 of of IN 37231 2911 5 the the DT 37231 2911 6 seven seven CD 37231 2911 7 Greek greek JJ 37231 2911 8 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2911 9 is be VBZ 37231 2911 10 clearly clearly RB 37231 2911 11 stated state VBN 37231 2911 12 by by IN 37231 2911 13 an an DT 37231 2911 14 English english JJ 37231 2911 15 historian historian NN 37231 2911 16 and and CC 37231 2911 17 divine divine JJ 37231 2911 18 : : : 37231 2911 19 " " `` 37231 2911 20 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2911 21 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2911 22 is be VBZ 37231 2911 23 , , , 37231 2911 24 that that IN 37231 2911 25 I -PRON- PRP 37231 2911 26 should should MD 37231 2911 27 be be VB 37231 2911 28 unwilling unwilling JJ 37231 2911 29 to to TO 37231 2911 30 claim claim VB 37231 2911 31 historical historical JJ 37231 2911 32 authority authority NN 37231 2911 33 for for IN 37231 2911 34 any any DT 37231 2911 35 passage passage NN 37231 2911 36 not not RB 37231 2911 37 contained contain VBN 37231 2911 38 in in IN 37231 2911 39 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 2911 40 Cureton Cureton NNP 37231 2911 41 's 's POS 37231 2911 42 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2911 43 reprint reprint NN 37231 2911 44 . . . 37231 2912 1 " " `` 37231 2912 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2912 3 3 3 LS 37231 2912 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2912 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2912 6 must must MD 37231 2912 7 , , , 37231 2912 8 however however RB 37231 2912 9 , , , 37231 2912 10 go go VB 37231 2912 11 much much RB 37231 2912 12 further further RB 37231 2912 13 , , , 37231 2912 14 and and CC 37231 2912 15 assert assert VB 37231 2912 16 that that IN 37231 2912 17 none none NN 37231 2912 18 of of IN 37231 2912 19 the the DT 37231 2912 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2912 21 have have VBP 37231 2912 22 any any DT 37231 2912 23 value value NN 37231 2912 24 as as IN 37231 2912 25 evidence evidence NN 37231 2912 26 for for IN 37231 2912 27 an an DT 37231 2912 28 earlier early JJR 37231 2912 29 period period NN 37231 2912 30 than than IN 37231 2912 31 the the DT 37231 2912 32 end end NN 37231 2912 33 of of IN 37231 2912 34 the the DT 37231 2912 35 second second JJ 37231 2912 36 or or CC 37231 2912 37 beginning beginning NN 37231 2912 38 of of IN 37231 2912 39 the the DT 37231 2912 40 third third JJ 37231 2912 41 century century NN 37231 2912 42 , , , 37231 2912 43 if if IN 37231 2912 44 indeed indeed RB 37231 2912 45 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2912 46 possess possess VBP 37231 2912 47 any any DT 37231 2912 48 value value NN 37231 2912 49 at at RB 37231 2912 50 all all RB 37231 2912 51 . . . 37231 2913 1 The the DT 37231 2913 2 whole whole NN 37231 2913 3 of of IN 37231 2913 4 the the DT 37231 2913 5 literature literature NN 37231 2913 6 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2913 7 to to IN 37231 2913 8 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2913 9 is be VBZ 37231 2913 10 , , , 37231 2913 11 in in IN 37231 2913 12 fact fact NN 37231 2913 13 , , , 37231 2913 14 such such PDT 37231 2913 15 a a DT 37231 2913 16 tissue tissue NN 37231 2913 17 of of IN 37231 2913 18 fraud fraud NN 37231 2913 19 and and CC 37231 2913 20 imposture imposture NN 37231 2913 21 , , , 37231 2913 22 and and CC 37231 2913 23 the the DT 37231 2913 24 successive successive JJ 37231 2913 25 versions version NNS 37231 2913 26 exhibit exhibit VBP 37231 2913 27 such such JJ 37231 2913 28 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 2913 29 marks mark NNS 37231 2913 30 of of IN 37231 2913 31 the the DT 37231 2913 32 grossest gross JJS 37231 2913 33 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 2913 34 , , , 37231 2913 35 that that IN 37231 2913 36 even even RB 37231 2913 37 if if IN 37231 2913 38 any any DT 37231 2913 39 small small JJ 37231 2913 40 original original JJ 37231 2913 41 element element NN 37231 2913 42 exist exist VBP 37231 2913 43 referrible referrible JJ 37231 2913 44 to to IN 37231 2913 45 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2913 46 , , , 37231 2913 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2913 48 is be VBZ 37231 2913 49 impossible impossible JJ 37231 2913 50 to to TO 37231 2913 51 define define VB 37231 2913 52 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2913 53 , , , 37231 2913 54 or or CC 37231 2913 55 to to TO 37231 2913 56 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 2913 57 with with IN 37231 2913 58 the the DT 37231 2913 59 slightest slight JJS 37231 2913 60 degree degree NN 37231 2913 61 of of IN 37231 2913 62 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 2913 63 between between IN 37231 2913 64 what what WP 37231 2913 65 is be VBZ 37231 2913 66 authentic authentic JJ 37231 2913 67 and and CC 37231 2913 68 what what WP 37231 2913 69 is be VBZ 37231 2913 70 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2913 71 . . . 37231 2914 1 The the DT 37231 2914 2 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2914 3 do do VBP 37231 2914 4 not not RB 37231 2914 5 , , , 37231 2914 6 however however RB 37231 2914 7 , , , 37231 2914 8 in in IN 37231 2914 9 any any DT 37231 2914 10 case case NN 37231 2914 11 afford afford VB 37231 2914 12 evidence evidence NN 37231 2914 13 even even RB 37231 2914 14 of of IN 37231 2914 15 the the DT 37231 2914 16 existence existence NN 37231 2914 17 of of IN 37231 2914 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2914 19 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2914 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2914 21 . . . 37231 2915 1 { { -LRB- 37231 2915 2 272 272 CD 37231 2915 3 } } -RRB- 37231 2915 4 2 2 CD 37231 2915 5 . . . 37231 2916 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2916 2 have have VBP 37231 2916 3 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 2916 4 deferred defer VBN 37231 2916 5 all all DT 37231 2916 6 consideration consideration NN 37231 2916 7 of of IN 37231 2916 8 the the DT 37231 2916 9 so so RB 37231 2916 10 - - HYPH 37231 2916 11 called call VBN 37231 2916 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2916 13 of of IN 37231 2916 14 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2916 15 to to IN 37231 2916 16 the the DT 37231 2916 17 Philippians Philippians NNPS 37231 2916 18 , , , 37231 2916 19 from from IN 37231 2916 20 the the DT 37231 2916 21 fact fact NN 37231 2916 22 that that IN 37231 2916 23 , , , 37231 2916 24 instead instead RB 37231 2916 25 of of IN 37231 2916 26 proving prove VBG 37231 2916 27 the the DT 37231 2916 28 existence existence NN 37231 2916 29 of of IN 37231 2916 30 the the DT 37231 2916 31 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2916 32 of of IN 37231 2916 33 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2916 34 , , , 37231 2916 35 with with IN 37231 2916 36 which which WDT 37231 2916 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2916 38 is be VBZ 37231 2916 39 intimately intimately RB 37231 2916 40 associated associate VBN 37231 2916 41 , , , 37231 2916 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2916 43 is be VBZ 37231 2916 44 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2916 45 discredited discredit VBN 37231 2916 46 in in IN 37231 2916 47 proportion proportion NN 37231 2916 48 as as IN 37231 2916 49 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2916 50 are be VBP 37231 2916 51 shown show VBN 37231 2916 52 to to TO 37231 2916 53 be be VB 37231 2916 54 in in IN 37231 2916 55 authentic authentic JJ 37231 2916 56 . . . 37231 2917 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2917 2 have have VBP 37231 2917 3 just just RB 37231 2917 4 seen see VBN 37231 2917 5 that that IN 37231 2917 6 the the DT 37231 2917 7 martyr martyr NN 37231 2917 8 - - HYPH 37231 2917 9 journey journey NN 37231 2917 10 of of IN 37231 2917 11 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2917 12 to to IN 37231 2917 13 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2917 14 is be VBZ 37231 2917 15 , , , 37231 2917 16 for for IN 37231 2917 17 cogent cogent NN 37231 2917 18 reasons reason NNS 37231 2917 19 , , , 37231 2917 20 declared declare VBD 37231 2917 21 to to TO 37231 2917 22 be be VB 37231 2917 23 wholly wholly RB 37231 2917 24 fabulous fabulous JJ 37231 2917 25 , , , 37231 2917 26 and and CC 37231 2917 27 the the DT 37231 2917 28 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2917 29 purporting purport VBG 37231 2917 30 to to TO 37231 2917 31 be be VB 37231 2917 32 written write VBN 37231 2917 33 during during IN 37231 2917 34 that that DT 37231 2917 35 journey journey NN 37231 2917 36 must must MD 37231 2917 37 be be VB 37231 2917 38 held hold VBN 37231 2917 39 to to TO 37231 2917 40 be be VB 37231 2917 41 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2917 42 . . . 37231 2918 1 The the DT 37231 2918 2 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2918 3 of of IN 37231 2918 4 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2918 5 , , , 37231 2918 6 however however RB 37231 2918 7 , , , 37231 2918 8 not not RB 37231 2918 9 only only RB 37231 2918 10 refers refer VBZ 37231 2918 11 to to IN 37231 2918 12 the the DT 37231 2918 13 martyr martyr NN 37231 2918 14 - - HYPH 37231 2918 15 journey journey NN 37231 2918 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2918 17 c. c. NNP 37231 2919 1 ix ix IN 37231 2919 2 . . . 37231 2920 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2920 2 , , , 37231 2920 3 but but CC 37231 2920 4 to to IN 37231 2920 5 the the DT 37231 2920 6 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 2920 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2920 8 which which WDT 37231 2920 9 are be VBP 37231 2920 10 inauthentic inauthentic JJ 37231 2920 11 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2920 12 c. c. NNP 37231 2921 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 2921 2 . . . 37231 2922 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2922 2 , , , 37231 2922 3 and and CC 37231 2922 4 the the DT 37231 2922 5 manifest manif JJS 37231 2922 6 inference inference NN 37231 2922 7 is be VBZ 37231 2922 8 that that IN 37231 2922 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2922 10 also also RB 37231 2922 11 is be VBZ 37231 2922 12 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2922 13 . . . 37231 2923 1 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2923 2 , , , 37231 2923 3 who who WP 37231 2923 4 is be VBZ 37231 2923 5 said say VBN 37231 2923 6 by by IN 37231 2923 7 Irenæus(1 Irenæus(1 NNP 37231 2923 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2923 9 to to TO 37231 2923 10 have have VB 37231 2923 11 been be VBN 37231 2923 12 in in IN 37231 2923 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2923 14 youth youth NN 37231 2923 15 a a DT 37231 2923 16 disciple disciple NN 37231 2923 17 of of IN 37231 2923 18 the the DT 37231 2923 19 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 2923 20 John John NNP 37231 2923 21 , , , 37231 2923 22 became become VBD 37231 2923 23 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2923 24 of of IN 37231 2923 25 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 37231 2923 26 , , , 37231 2923 27 and and CC 37231 2923 28 suffered suffer VBD 37231 2923 29 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2923 30 at at IN 37231 2923 31 a a DT 37231 2923 32 very very RB 37231 2923 33 advanced advanced JJ 37231 2923 34 age age NN 37231 2923 35 . . . 37231 2924 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2924 2 2 2 LS 37231 2924 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2924 4 On on IN 37231 2924 5 the the DT 37231 2924 6 authority authority NN 37231 2924 7 of of IN 37231 2924 8 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 2924 9 and and CC 37231 2924 10 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2924 11 , , , 37231 2924 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2924 13 has have VBZ 37231 2924 14 hitherto hitherto VBN 37231 2924 15 been be VBN 37231 2924 16 generally generally RB 37231 2924 17 believed believe VBN 37231 2924 18 that that IN 37231 2924 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2924 20 death death NN 37231 2924 21 took take VBD 37231 2924 22 place place NN 37231 2924 23 in in IN 37231 2924 24 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2924 25 . . NNP 37231 2924 26 166 166 CD 37231 2924 27 - - SYM 37231 2924 28 167 167 CD 37231 2924 29 . . . 37231 2925 1 In in IN 37231 2925 2 the the DT 37231 2925 3 account account NN 37231 2925 4 of of IN 37231 2925 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2925 6 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2925 7 , , , 37231 2925 8 which which WDT 37231 2925 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2925 10 possess possess VBP 37231 2925 11 in in IN 37231 2925 12 the the DT 37231 2925 13 shape shape NN 37231 2925 14 of of IN 37231 2925 15 a a DT 37231 2925 16 letter letter NN 37231 2925 17 from from IN 37231 2925 18 the the DT 37231 2925 19 Church Church NNP 37231 2925 20 of of IN 37231 2925 21 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 37231 2925 22 , , , 37231 2925 23 purporting purport VBG 37231 2925 24 to to TO 37231 2925 25 have have VB 37231 2925 26 been be VBN 37231 2925 27 written write VBN 37231 2925 28 by by IN 37231 2925 29 eye eye NN 37231 2925 30 - - HYPH 37231 2925 31 witnesses witness NNS 37231 2925 32 , , , 37231 2925 33 which which WDT 37231 2925 34 must must MD 37231 2925 35 be be VB 37231 2925 36 pronounced pronounce VBN 37231 2925 37 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2925 38 , , , 37231 2925 39 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2925 40 is be VBZ 37231 2925 41 said say VBN 37231 2925 42 to to TO 37231 2925 43 have have VB 37231 2925 44 died die VBN 37231 2925 45 under under IN 37231 2925 46 the the DT 37231 2925 47 Proconsul Proconsul NNP 37231 2925 48 Statius Statius NNP 37231 2925 49 Quadratus Quadratus NNP 37231 2925 50 . . . 37231 2926 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2926 2 3 3 LS 37231 2926 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2926 4 If if IN 37231 2926 5 this this DT 37231 2926 6 statement statement NN 37231 2926 7 be be VB 37231 2926 8 correct correct JJ 37231 2926 9 , , , 37231 2926 10 the the DT 37231 2926 11 date date NN 37231 2926 12 hitherto hitherto NNP 37231 2926 13 received receive VBD 37231 2926 14 can can MD 37231 2926 15 no no RB 37231 2926 16 longer longer RB 37231 2926 17 be be VB 37231 2926 18 maintained maintain VBN 37231 2926 19 , , , 37231 2926 20 for for IN 37231 2926 21 recent recent JJ 37231 2926 22 investigations investigation NNS 37231 2926 23 have have VBP 37231 2926 24 determined determine VBN 37231 2926 25 that that IN 37231 2926 26 Statius Statius NNP 37231 2926 27 Quadratus Quadratus NNP 37231 2926 28 was be VBD 37231 2926 29 proconsul proconsul NNP 37231 2926 30 in in IN 37231 2926 31 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2926 32 . . NNP 37231 2926 33 154 154 CD 37231 2926 34 - - SYM 37231 2926 35 5 5 CD 37231 2926 36 or or CC 37231 2926 37 155 155 CD 37231 2926 38 - - SYM 37231 2926 39 6 6 CD 37231 2926 40 . . . 37231 2927 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2927 2 4 4 LS 37231 2927 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2927 4 Some some DT 37231 2927 5 critics critic NNS 37231 2927 6 , , , 37231 2927 7 { { -LRB- 37231 2927 8 273 273 CD 37231 2927 9 } } -RRB- 37231 2927 10 who who WP 37231 2927 11 affirm affirm VBP 37231 2927 12 the the DT 37231 2927 13 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2927 14 of of IN 37231 2927 15 the the DT 37231 2927 16 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2927 17 attributed attribute VBD 37231 2927 18 to to IN 37231 2927 19 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2927 20 , , , 37231 2927 21 date date NN 37231 2927 22 the the DT 37231 2927 23 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2927 24 before before IN 37231 2927 25 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2927 26 . . NNP 37231 2927 27 120,(1 120,(1 NNP 37231 2927 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2927 29 but but CC 37231 2927 30 the the DT 37231 2927 31 preponderance preponderance NN 37231 2927 32 of of IN 37231 2927 33 opinion opinion NN 37231 2927 34 assigns assign VBZ 37231 2927 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2927 36 to to IN 37231 2927 37 a a DT 37231 2927 38 much much RB 37231 2927 39 later later JJ 37231 2927 40 period period NN 37231 2927 41 . . . 37231 2928 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2928 2 2 2 LS 37231 2928 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2928 4 Doubts doubt NNS 37231 2928 5 of of IN 37231 2928 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2928 7 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2928 8 , , , 37231 2928 9 and and CC 37231 2928 10 of of IN 37231 2928 11 the the DT 37231 2928 12 integrity integrity NN 37231 2928 13 of of IN 37231 2928 14 the the DT 37231 2928 15 text text NN 37231 2928 16 , , , 37231 2928 17 were be VBD 37231 2928 18 very very RB 37231 2928 19 early early RB 37231 2928 20 expressed,(3 expressed,(3 NN 37231 2928 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2928 22 and and CC 37231 2928 23 the the DT 37231 2928 24 close close JJ 37231 2928 25 scrutiny scrutiny NN 37231 2928 26 to to TO 37231 2928 27 which which WDT 37231 2928 28 later later RB 37231 2928 29 and and CC 37231 2928 30 more more RBR 37231 2928 31 competent competent JJ 37231 2928 32 criticism criticism NN 37231 2928 33 has have VBZ 37231 2928 34 subjected subject VBN 37231 2928 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2928 36 , , , 37231 2928 37 has have VBZ 37231 2928 38 led lead VBN 37231 2928 39 very very RB 37231 2928 40 many many JJ 37231 2928 41 to to IN 37231 2928 42 the the DT 37231 2928 43 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2928 44 that that IN 37231 2928 45 the the DT 37231 2928 46 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2928 47 is be VBZ 37231 2928 48 either either CC 37231 2928 49 largely largely RB 37231 2928 50 interpolated,(4 interpolated,(4 NNP 37231 2928 51 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2928 52 or or CC 37231 2928 53 altogether altogether RB 37231 2928 54 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2928 55 . . . 37231 2929 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2929 2 5 5 LS 37231 2929 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2929 4 The the DT 37231 2929 5 principal principal JJ 37231 2929 6 argument argument NN 37231 2929 7 in in IN 37231 2929 8 favour favour NN 37231 2929 9 { { -LRB- 37231 2929 10 274 274 CD 37231 2929 11 } } -RRB- 37231 2929 12 of of IN 37231 2929 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2929 14 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2929 15 is be VBZ 37231 2929 16 the the DT 37231 2929 17 fact fact NN 37231 2929 18 that that IN 37231 2929 19 the the DT 37231 2929 20 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2929 21 is be VBZ 37231 2929 22 mentioned mention VBN 37231 2929 23 by by IN 37231 2929 24 Irenæus,(1 Irenæus,(1 NNP 37231 2929 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2929 26 who who WP 37231 2929 27 in in IN 37231 2929 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2929 29 extreme extreme JJ 37231 2929 30 youth youth NN 37231 2929 31 was be VBD 37231 2929 32 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 2929 33 with with IN 37231 2929 34 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2929 35 . . . 37231 2930 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2930 2 2 2 LS 37231 2930 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2930 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2930 5 have have VBP 37231 2930 6 no no DT 37231 2930 7 very very RB 37231 2930 8 precise precise JJ 37231 2930 9 information information NN 37231 2930 10 regarding regard VBG 37231 2930 11 the the DT 37231 2930 12 age age NN 37231 2930 13 of of IN 37231 2930 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2930 15 , , , 37231 2930 16 but but CC 37231 2930 17 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 2930 18 states state VBZ 37231 2930 19 that that IN 37231 2930 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2930 21 flourished flourish VBD 37231 2930 22 under under IN 37231 2930 23 Commodus Commodus NNP 37231 2930 24 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2930 25 180 180 CD 37231 2930 26 - - SYM 37231 2930 27 192 192 CD 37231 2930 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2930 29 , , , 37231 2930 30 and and CC 37231 2930 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2930 32 may may MD 37231 2930 33 , , , 37231 2930 34 as as IN 37231 2930 35 a a DT 37231 2930 36 favourable favourable JJ 37231 2930 37 conjecture conjecture NN 37231 2930 38 , , , 37231 2930 39 suppose suppose VB 37231 2930 40 that that IN 37231 2930 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2930 42 was be VBD 37231 2930 43 then then RB 37231 2930 44 about about RB 37231 2930 45 35 35 CD 37231 2930 46 - - SYM 37231 2930 47 37 37 CD 37231 2930 48 . . . 37231 2931 1 In in IN 37231 2931 2 that that DT 37231 2931 3 case case NN 37231 2931 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2931 5 birth birth NN 37231 2931 6 must must MD 37231 2931 7 be be VB 37231 2931 8 dated date VBN 37231 2931 9 about about IN 37231 2931 10 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2931 11 . . NNP 37231 2931 12 145 145 CD 37231 2931 13 . . . 37231 2932 1 There there EX 37231 2932 2 is be VBZ 37231 2932 3 reason reason NN 37231 2932 4 to to TO 37231 2932 5 believe believe VB 37231 2932 6 that that IN 37231 2932 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2932 8 fell fall VBD 37231 2932 9 a a DT 37231 2932 10 victim victim NN 37231 2932 11 to to IN 37231 2932 12 persecution persecution NN 37231 2932 13 under under IN 37231 2932 14 Septimius Septimius NNP 37231 2932 15 Severus Severus NNP 37231 2932 16 , , , 37231 2932 17 and and CC 37231 2932 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2932 19 is be VBZ 37231 2932 20 only only RB 37231 2932 21 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 2932 22 whether whether IN 37231 2932 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2932 24 suffered suffer VBD 37231 2932 25 during during IN 37231 2932 26 the the DT 37231 2932 27 first first JJ 37231 2932 28 outbreak outbreak NN 37231 2932 29 in in IN 37231 2932 30 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2932 31 . . NNP 37231 2932 32 202 202 CD 37231 2932 33 , , , 37231 2932 34 or or CC 37231 2932 35 later later RB 37231 2932 36 . . . 37231 2933 1 According accord VBG 37231 2933 2 to to IN 37231 2933 3 this this DT 37231 2933 4 calculation calculation NN 37231 2933 5 , , , 37231 2933 6 the the DT 37231 2933 7 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2933 8 of of IN 37231 2933 9 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2933 10 , , , 37231 2933 11 in in IN 37231 2933 12 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2933 13 . . NNP 37231 2933 14 155 155 CD 37231 2933 15 - - SYM 37231 2933 16 156 156 CD 37231 2933 17 , , , 37231 2933 18 took take VBD 37231 2933 19 place place NN 37231 2933 20 when when WRB 37231 2933 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2933 22 was be VBD 37231 2933 23 ten ten CD 37231 2933 24 or or CC 37231 2933 25 eleven eleven CD 37231 2933 26 years year NNS 37231 2933 27 of of IN 37231 2933 28 age age NN 37231 2933 29 . . . 37231 2934 1 Even even RB 37231 2934 2 if if IN 37231 2934 3 a a DT 37231 2934 4 further further JJ 37231 2934 5 concession concession NN 37231 2934 6 be be VB 37231 2934 7 made make VBN 37231 2934 8 in in IN 37231 2934 9 regard regard NN 37231 2934 10 to to IN 37231 2934 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2934 12 age age NN 37231 2934 13 , , , 37231 2934 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2934 15 is be VBZ 37231 2934 16 evident evident JJ 37231 2934 17 that that IN 37231 2934 18 the the DT 37231 2934 19 intercourse intercourse NN 37231 2934 20 of of IN 37231 2934 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2934 22 with with IN 37231 2934 23 the the DT 37231 2934 24 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 2934 25 of of IN 37231 2934 26 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 37231 2934 27 must must MD 37231 2934 28 have have VB 37231 2934 29 been be VBN 37231 2934 30 confined confine VBN 37231 2934 31 to to IN 37231 2934 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2934 33 very very RB 37231 2934 34 earliest early JJS 37231 2934 35 years,(3 years,(3 NNP 37231 2934 36 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2934 37 a a DT 37231 2934 38 fact fact NN 37231 2934 39 which which WDT 37231 2934 40 is be VBZ 37231 2934 41 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 2934 42 by by IN 37231 2934 43 the the DT 37231 2934 44 almost almost RB 37231 2934 45 total total JJ 37231 2934 46 absence absence NN 37231 2934 47 of of IN 37231 2934 48 any any DT 37231 2934 49 record record NN 37231 2934 50 in in IN 37231 2934 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2934 52 writings writing NNS 37231 2934 53 of of IN 37231 2934 54 the the DT 37231 2934 55 communications communication NNS 37231 2934 56 of of IN 37231 2934 57 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2934 58 . . . 37231 2935 1 This this DT 37231 2935 2 certainly certainly RB 37231 2935 3 does do VBZ 37231 2935 4 not not RB 37231 2935 5 entitle entitle VB 37231 2935 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 2935 7 to to TO 37231 2935 8 speak speak VB 37231 2935 9 more more RBR 37231 2935 10 authoritatively authoritatively RB 37231 2935 11 of of IN 37231 2935 12 an an DT 37231 2935 13 epistle epistle NN 37231 2935 14 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2935 15 to to IN 37231 2935 16 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2935 17 , , , 37231 2935 18 than than IN 37231 2935 19 any any DT 37231 2935 20 one one CD 37231 2935 21 else else RB 37231 2935 22 of of IN 37231 2935 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2935 24 day day NN 37231 2935 25 . . . 37231 2936 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2936 2 4 4 LS 37231 2936 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2936 4 In in IN 37231 2936 5 the the DT 37231 2936 6 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2936 7 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2936 8 , , , 37231 2936 9 there there EX 37231 2936 10 are be VBP 37231 2936 11 several several JJ 37231 2936 12 anachronisms anachronism NNS 37231 2936 13 . . . 37231 2937 1 In in IN 37231 2937 2 ch ch NN 37231 2937 3 . . . 37231 2938 1 ix ix IN 37231 2938 2 . . . 37231 2939 1 the the DT 37231 2939 2 blessed blessed JJ 37231 2939 3 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2939 4 " " '' 37231 2939 5 is be VBZ 37231 2939 6 referred refer VBN 37231 2939 7 to to IN 37231 2939 8 as as RB 37231 2939 9 already already RB 37231 2939 10 dead dead JJ 37231 2939 11 , , , 37231 2939 12 and and CC 37231 2939 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2939 14 is be VBZ 37231 2939 15 held hold VBN 37231 2939 16 up up RP 37231 2939 17 with with IN 37231 2939 18 Zosimus Zosimus NNP 37231 2939 19 and and CC 37231 2939 20 Rufus Rufus NNP 37231 2939 21 , , , 37231 2939 22 and and CC 37231 2939 23 also also RB 37231 2939 24 with with IN 37231 2939 25 Paul Paul NNP 37231 2939 26 and and CC 37231 2939 27 the the DT 37231 2939 28 rest rest NN 37231 2939 29 of of IN 37231 2939 30 the the DT 37231 2939 31 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 2939 32 , , , 37231 2939 33 as as IN 37231 2939 34 examples example NNS 37231 2939 35 of of IN 37231 2939 36 patience patience NN 37231 2939 37 : : : 37231 2939 38 men man NNS 37231 2939 39 who who WP 37231 2939 40 have have VBP 37231 2939 41 not not RB 37231 2939 42 run run VBN 37231 2939 43 in in IN 37231 2939 44 vain vain JJ 37231 2939 45 , , , 37231 2939 46 but but CC 37231 2939 47 are be VBP 37231 2939 48 with with IN 37231 2939 49 the the DT 37231 2939 50 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2939 51 ; ; : 37231 2939 52 but but CC 37231 2939 53 in in IN 37231 2939 54 ch ch NN 37231 2939 55 . . . 37231 2940 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 2940 2 . . . 37231 2941 1 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2941 2 is be VBZ 37231 2941 3 spoken speak VBN 37231 2941 4 of of IN 37231 2941 5 as as IN 37231 2941 6 living living NN 37231 2941 7 , , , 37231 2941 8 and and CC 37231 2941 9 information information NN 37231 2941 10 is be VBZ 37231 2941 11 requested request VBN 37231 2941 12 regarding regard VBG 37231 2941 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2941 14 , , , 37231 2941 15 { { -LRB- 37231 2941 16 275 275 CD 37231 2941 17 } } -RRB- 37231 2941 18 " " '' 37231 2941 19 and and CC 37231 2941 20 those those DT 37231 2941 21 who who WP 37231 2941 22 are be VBP 37231 2941 23 with with IN 37231 2941 24 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2941 25 . . . 37231 2942 1 " " `` 37231 2942 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2942 3 1 1 LS 37231 2942 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2942 5 Yet yet CC 37231 2942 6 , , , 37231 2942 7 although although IN 37231 2942 8 thus thus RB 37231 2942 9 spoken speak VBN 37231 2942 10 of of IN 37231 2942 11 as as RB 37231 2942 12 alive alive JJ 37231 2942 13 , , , 37231 2942 14 the the DT 37231 2942 15 writer writer NN 37231 2942 16 already already RB 37231 2942 17 knows know VBZ 37231 2942 18 of of IN 37231 2942 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2942 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2942 21 , , , 37231 2942 22 and and CC 37231 2942 23 refers refer VBZ 37231 2942 24 , , , 37231 2942 25 in in IN 37231 2942 26 the the DT 37231 2942 27 plural plural NN 37231 2942 28 , , , 37231 2942 29 to to IN 37231 2942 30 those those DT 37231 2942 31 written write VBN 37231 2942 32 by by IN 37231 2942 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2942 34 " " `` 37231 2942 35 to to IN 37231 2942 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2942 37 , , , 37231 2942 38 and and CC 37231 2942 39 all all PDT 37231 2942 40 the the DT 37231 2942 41 rest rest NN 37231 2942 42 which which WDT 37231 2942 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2942 44 have have VBP 37231 2942 45 by by IN 37231 2942 46 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2942 47 . . . 37231 2943 1 " " `` 37231 2943 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2943 3 2 2 LS 37231 2943 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2943 5 The the DT 37231 2943 6 reference reference NN 37231 2943 7 here here RB 37231 2943 8 , , , 37231 2943 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2943 10 will will MD 37231 2943 11 be be VB 37231 2943 12 observed observe VBN 37231 2943 13 , , , 37231 2943 14 is be VBZ 37231 2943 15 not not RB 37231 2943 16 only only RB 37231 2943 17 to to IN 37231 2943 18 the the DT 37231 2943 19 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2943 20 to to IN 37231 2943 21 the the DT 37231 2943 22 Smyrnæans Smyrnæans NNPS 37231 2943 23 , , , 37231 2943 24 and and CC 37231 2943 25 to to IN 37231 2943 26 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2943 27 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2943 28 , , , 37231 2943 29 but but CC 37231 2943 30 to to IN 37231 2943 31 other other JJ 37231 2943 32 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2943 33 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2943 34 which which WDT 37231 2943 35 are be VBP 37231 2943 36 not not RB 37231 2943 37 included include VBN 37231 2943 38 in in IN 37231 2943 39 the the DT 37231 2943 40 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 2943 41 version version NN 37231 2943 42 . . . 37231 2944 1 Dallseus(3 Dallseus(3 NNP 37231 2944 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2944 3 pointed point VBD 37231 2944 4 out out RP 37231 2944 5 long long RB 37231 2944 6 ago ago RB 37231 2944 7 , , , 37231 2944 8 that that DT 37231 2944 9 ch ch NN 37231 2944 10 . . . 37231 2945 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 2945 2 . . . 37231 2946 1 abruptly abruptly RB 37231 2946 2 interrupts interrupt VBZ 37231 2946 3 the the DT 37231 2946 4 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 2946 5 of of IN 37231 2946 6 the the DT 37231 2946 7 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2946 8 , , , 37231 2946 9 and and CC 37231 2946 10 most most JJS 37231 2946 11 critics critic NNS 37231 2946 12 , , , 37231 2946 13 including include VBG 37231 2946 14 those those DT 37231 2946 15 who who WP 37231 2946 16 assert assert VBP 37231 2946 17 the the DT 37231 2946 18 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 2946 19 of of IN 37231 2946 20 the the DT 37231 2946 21 rest rest NN 37231 2946 22 of of IN 37231 2946 23 the the DT 37231 2946 24 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2946 25 , , , 37231 2946 26 reject reject VBP 37231 2946 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2946 28 at at IN 37231 2946 29 least least JJS 37231 2946 30 , , , 37231 2946 31 although although IN 37231 2946 32 many many JJ 37231 2946 33 of of IN 37231 2946 34 these these DT 37231 2946 35 likewise likewise JJ 37231 2946 36 repudiate repudiate VBP 37231 2946 37 ch ch NN 37231 2946 38 . . . 37231 2947 1 ix ix IN 37231 2947 2 . . . 37231 2948 1 as as IN 37231 2948 2 interpolated interpolate VBN 37231 2948 3 . . . 37231 2949 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2949 2 4 4 LS 37231 2949 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2949 4 Others other NNS 37231 2949 5 , , , 37231 2949 6 however however RB 37231 2949 7 , , , 37231 2949 8 consider consider VB 37231 2949 9 that that IN 37231 2949 10 the the DT 37231 2949 11 latter latter JJ 37231 2949 12 chapter chapter NN 37231 2949 13 is be VBZ 37231 2949 14 quite quite RB 37231 2949 15 consistent consistent JJ 37231 2949 16 with with IN 37231 2949 17 the the DT 37231 2949 18 later later JJ 37231 2949 19 date date NN 37231 2949 20 , , , 37231 2949 21 which which WDT 37231 2949 22 , , , 37231 2949 23 according accord VBG 37231 2949 24 to to IN 37231 2949 25 internal internal JJ 37231 2949 26 evidence evidence NN 37231 2949 27 , , , 37231 2949 28 must must MD 37231 2949 29 be be VB 37231 2949 30 assigned assign VBN 37231 2949 31 to to IN 37231 2949 32 the the DT 37231 2949 33 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2949 34 . . . 37231 2950 1 The the DT 37231 2950 2 writer writer NN 37231 2950 3 vehemently vehemently RB 37231 2950 4 denounces,(5 denounces,(5 VBD 37231 2950 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2950 6 as as IN 37231 2950 7 already already RB 37231 2950 8 widely widely RB 37231 2950 9 spread spread VBN 37231 2950 10 , , , 37231 2950 11 the the DT 37231 2950 12 Gnostic gnostic JJ 37231 2950 13 heresy heresy NN 37231 2950 14 and and CC 37231 2950 15 other other JJ 37231 2950 16 forms form NNS 37231 2950 17 of of IN 37231 2950 18 false false JJ 37231 2950 19 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 2950 20 which which WDT 37231 2950 21 did do VBD 37231 2950 22 not not RB 37231 2950 23 exist exist VB 37231 2950 24 until until IN 37231 2950 25 the the DT 37231 2950 26 time time NN 37231 2950 27 of of IN 37231 2950 28 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 2950 29 , , , 37231 2950 30 to to IN 37231 2950 31 whom whom WP 37231 2950 32 and and CC 37231 2950 33 to to IN 37231 2950 34 whose whose WP$ 37231 2950 35 followers follower NNS 37231 2950 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2950 37 refers refer VBZ 37231 2950 38 in in IN 37231 2950 39 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 37231 2950 40 terms term NNS 37231 2950 41 . . . 37231 2951 1 An an DT 37231 2951 2 expression expression NN 37231 2951 3 is be VBZ 37231 2951 4 used use VBN 37231 2951 5 in in IN 37231 2951 6 ch ch NN 37231 2951 7 . . . 37231 2952 1 vii vii NN 37231 2952 2 . . . 37231 2953 1 in in IN 37231 2953 2 speaking speak VBG 37231 2953 3 of of IN 37231 2953 4 these these DT 37231 2953 5 heretics heretic NNS 37231 2953 6 , , , 37231 2953 7 which which WDT 37231 2953 8 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2953 9 is be VBZ 37231 2953 10 reported report VBN 37231 2953 11 by by IN 37231 2953 12 Irenseus Irenseus NNP 37231 2953 13 to to TO 37231 2953 14 have have VB 37231 2953 15 actually actually RB 37231 2953 16 applied apply VBN 37231 2953 17 to to IN 37231 2953 18 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 2953 19 in in IN 37231 2953 20 person person NN 37231 2953 21 , , , 37231 2953 22 during during IN 37231 2953 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2953 24 visit visit NN 37231 2953 25 to to IN 37231 2953 26 Home home NN 37231 2953 27 . . . 37231 2954 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 2954 2 is be VBZ 37231 2954 3 said say VBN 37231 2954 4 to to TO 37231 2954 5 have have VB 37231 2954 6 called call VBN 37231 2954 7 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 2954 8 the the DT 37231 2954 9 " " `` 37231 2954 10 first first RB 37231 2954 11 - - HYPH 37231 2954 12 born bear VBN 37231 2954 13 of of IN 37231 2954 14 Satan Satan NNP 37231 2954 15 , , , 37231 2954 16 " " '' 37231 2954 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2954 18 --Greek--](6 --Greek--](6 NNP 37231 2954 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2954 20 and and CC 37231 2954 21 the the DT 37231 2954 22 same same JJ 37231 2954 23 term term NN 37231 2954 24 { { -LRB- 37231 2954 25 276 276 CD 37231 2954 26 } } -RRB- 37231 2954 27 is be VBZ 37231 2954 28 employed employ VBN 37231 2954 29 in in IN 37231 2954 30 this this DT 37231 2954 31 epistle epistle NN 37231 2954 32 with with IN 37231 2954 33 regard regard NN 37231 2954 34 to to IN 37231 2954 35 every every DT 37231 2954 36 one one NN 37231 2954 37 who who WP 37231 2954 38 holds hold VBZ 37231 2954 39 such such JJ 37231 2954 40 false false JJ 37231 2954 41 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 2954 42 . . . 37231 2955 1 The the DT 37231 2955 2 development development NN 37231 2955 3 of of IN 37231 2955 4 these these DT 37231 2955 5 heresies heresy NNS 37231 2955 6 , , , 37231 2955 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 2955 8 , , , 37231 2955 9 implies imply VBZ 37231 2955 10 a a DT 37231 2955 11 date date NN 37231 2955 12 for for IN 37231 2955 13 the the DT 37231 2955 14 composition composition NN 37231 2955 15 of of IN 37231 2955 16 the the DT 37231 2955 17 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2955 18 , , , 37231 2955 19 at at IN 37231 2955 20 earliest early JJS 37231 2955 21 , , , 37231 2955 22 after after IN 37231 2955 23 the the DT 37231 2955 24 middle middle NN 37231 2955 25 of of IN 37231 2955 26 the the DT 37231 2955 27 second second JJ 37231 2955 28 century century NN 37231 2955 29 , , , 37231 2955 30 a a DT 37231 2955 31 date date NN 37231 2955 32 which which WDT 37231 2955 33 is be VBZ 37231 2955 34 further further RB 37231 2955 35 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 2955 36 by by IN 37231 2955 37 other other JJ 37231 2955 38 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 2955 39 . . . 37231 2956 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2956 2 1 1 LS 37231 2956 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2956 4 The the DT 37231 2956 5 writer writer NN 37231 2956 6 of of IN 37231 2956 7 such such PDT 37231 2956 8 a a DT 37231 2956 9 letter letter NN 37231 2956 10 must must MD 37231 2956 11 have have VB 37231 2956 12 held hold VBN 37231 2956 13 a a DT 37231 2956 14 position position NN 37231 2956 15 in in IN 37231 2956 16 the the DT 37231 2956 17 Church Church NNP 37231 2956 18 , , , 37231 2956 19 to to TO 37231 2956 20 which which WDT 37231 2956 21 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2956 22 could could MD 37231 2956 23 only only RB 37231 2956 24 have have VB 37231 2956 25 attained attain VBN 37231 2956 26 in in IN 37231 2956 27 the the DT 37231 2956 28 latter latter JJ 37231 2956 29 part part NN 37231 2956 30 of of IN 37231 2956 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2956 32 life life NN 37231 2956 33 , , , 37231 2956 34 when when WRB 37231 2956 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2956 36 was be VBD 37231 2956 37 deputed depute VBN 37231 2956 38 to to IN 37231 2956 39 Rome Rome NNP 37231 2956 40 for for IN 37231 2956 41 the the DT 37231 2956 42 Paschal Paschal NNP 37231 2956 43 discussion discussion NN 37231 2956 44 , , , 37231 2956 45 and and CC 37231 2956 46 the the DT 37231 2956 47 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2956 48 depicts depict VBZ 37231 2956 49 the the DT 37231 2956 50 developed develop VBN 37231 2956 51 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 2956 52 organization organization NN 37231 2956 53 of of IN 37231 2956 54 a a DT 37231 2956 55 later later JJ 37231 2956 56 time time NN 37231 2956 57 . . . 37231 2957 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2957 2 2 2 LS 37231 2957 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2957 4 The the DT 37231 2957 5 earlier early JJR 37231 2957 6 date date NN 37231 2957 7 which which WDT 37231 2957 8 has have VBZ 37231 2957 9 now now RB 37231 2957 10 been be VBN 37231 2957 11 adopted adopt VBN 37231 2957 12 for for IN 37231 2957 13 the the DT 37231 2957 14 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2957 15 of of IN 37231 2957 16 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 2957 17 , , , 37231 2957 18 by by IN 37231 2957 19 limiting limit VBG 37231 2957 20 the the DT 37231 2957 21 period period NN 37231 2957 22 during during IN 37231 2957 23 which which WDT 37231 2957 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2957 25 is be VBZ 37231 2957 26 possible possible JJ 37231 2957 27 that that IN 37231 2957 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2957 29 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 2957 30 could could MD 37231 2957 31 have have VB 37231 2957 32 written write VBN 37231 2957 33 any any DT 37231 2957 34 portion portion NN 37231 2957 35 of of IN 37231 2957 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2957 37 , , , 37231 2957 38 only only RB 37231 2957 39 renders render VBZ 37231 2957 40 the the DT 37231 2957 41 inauthenticity inauthenticity NN 37231 2957 42 of of IN 37231 2957 43 the the DT 37231 2957 44 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2957 45 more more RBR 37231 2957 46 apparent apparent JJ 37231 2957 47 . . . 37231 2958 1 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 2958 2 has have VBZ 37231 2958 3 pointed point VBN 37231 2958 4 out out RP 37231 2958 5 , , , 37231 2958 6 as as IN 37231 2958 7 another another DT 37231 2958 8 indication indication NN 37231 2958 9 of of IN 37231 2958 10 the the DT 37231 2958 11 same same JJ 37231 2958 12 date date NN 37231 2958 13 , , , 37231 2958 14 the the DT 37231 2958 15 injunction injunction NN 37231 2958 16 " " `` 37231 2958 17 Pray pray VB 37231 2958 18 for for IN 37231 2958 19 the the DT 37231 2958 20 kings king NNS 37231 2958 21 " " '' 37231 2958 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2958 23 Orate orate VB 37231 2958 24 pro pro JJ 37231 2958 25 regibus regibus NN 37231 2958 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2958 27 , , , 37231 2958 28 which which WDT 37231 2958 29 , , , 37231 2958 30 in in IN 37231 2958 31 1 1 CD 37231 2958 32 Peter Peter NNP 37231 2958 33 ii ii NNP 37231 2958 34 . . . 37231 2959 1 17 17 CD 37231 2959 2 , , , 37231 2959 3 is be VBZ 37231 2959 4 " " `` 37231 2959 5 Honour Honour NNP 37231 2959 6 the the DT 37231 2959 7 king king NN 37231 2959 8 " " '' 37231 2959 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2959 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 2959 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2959 12 , , , 37231 2959 13 which which WDT 37231 2959 14 , , , 37231 2959 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2959 16 argues argue VBZ 37231 2959 17 , , , 37231 2959 18 accords accord NNS 37231 2959 19 with with IN 37231 2959 20 the the DT 37231 2959 21 period period NN 37231 2959 22 after after IN 37231 2959 23 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 37231 2959 24 Pius Pius NNP 37231 2959 25 had have VBD 37231 2959 26 elevated elevate VBN 37231 2959 27 Marcus Marcus NNP 37231 2959 28 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 2959 29 { { -LRB- 37231 2959 30 277 277 CD 37231 2959 31 } } -RRB- 37231 2959 32 to to IN 37231 2959 33 joint joint JJ 37231 2959 34 sovereignty sovereignty NN 37231 2959 35 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2959 36 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2959 37 . . NNP 37231 2959 38 147 147 CD 37231 2959 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2959 40 , , , 37231 2959 41 or or CC 37231 2959 42 better well RBR 37231 2959 43 still still RB 37231 2959 44 , , , 37231 2959 45 with with IN 37231 2959 46 that that DT 37231 2959 47 in in IN 37231 2959 48 which which WDT 37231 2959 49 Marcus Marcus NNP 37231 2959 50 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 2959 51 appointed appoint VBD 37231 2959 52 Lucius Lucius NNP 37231 2959 53 Verus Verus NNP 37231 2959 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2959 55 colleague colleague NN 37231 2959 56 , , , 37231 2959 57 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2959 58 . . NNP 37231 2959 59 161 161 CD 37231 2959 60 , , , 37231 2959 61 for for IN 37231 2959 62 to to IN 37231 2959 63 rulers ruler NNS 37231 2959 64 outside outside IN 37231 2959 65 of of IN 37231 2959 66 the the DT 37231 2959 67 Roman roman JJ 37231 2959 68 empire empire NN 37231 2959 69 there there EX 37231 2959 70 can can MD 37231 2959 71 be be VB 37231 2959 72 no no DT 37231 2959 73 reference reference NN 37231 2959 74 . . . 37231 2960 1 If if IN 37231 2960 2 authentic authentic JJ 37231 2960 3 , , , 37231 2960 4 however however RB 37231 2960 5 , , , 37231 2960 6 the the DT 37231 2960 7 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2960 8 must must MD 37231 2960 9 have have VB 37231 2960 10 been be VBN 37231 2960 11 written write VBN 37231 2960 12 , , , 37231 2960 13 at at IN 37231 2960 14 latest late JJS 37231 2960 15 , , , 37231 2960 16 shortly shortly RB 37231 2960 17 after after IN 37231 2960 18 the the DT 37231 2960 19 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 2960 20 of of IN 37231 2960 21 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2960 22 in in IN 37231 2960 23 a.d a.d NNP 37231 2960 24 . . NNP 37231 2960 25 115 115 CD 37231 2960 26 , , , 37231 2960 27 but but CC 37231 2960 28 , , , 37231 2960 29 as as IN 37231 2960 30 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2960 31 have have VBP 37231 2960 32 seen see VBN 37231 2960 33 , , , 37231 2960 34 there there EX 37231 2960 35 are be VBP 37231 2960 36 strong strong JJ 37231 2960 37 internal internal JJ 37231 2960 38 characteristics characteristic NNS 37231 2960 39 excluding exclude VBG 37231 2960 40 such such PDT 37231 2960 41 a a DT 37231 2960 42 supposition supposition NN 37231 2960 43 . . . 37231 2961 1 The the DT 37231 2961 2 reference reference NN 37231 2961 3 to to IN 37231 2961 4 the the DT 37231 2961 5 martyr martyr NN 37231 2961 6 - - HYPH 37231 2961 7 journey journey NN 37231 2961 8 of of IN 37231 2961 9 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 2961 10 and and CC 37231 2961 11 to to IN 37231 2961 12 the the DT 37231 2961 13 epistles epistle NNS 37231 2961 14 falsely falsely RB 37231 2961 15 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 2961 16 to to IN 37231 2961 17 him -PRON- PRP 37231 2961 18 , , , 37231 2961 19 is be VBZ 37231 2961 20 alone alone RB 37231 2961 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 2961 22 to to TO 37231 2961 23 betray betray VB 37231 2961 24 the the DT 37231 2961 25 spurious spurious JJ 37231 2961 26 nature nature NN 37231 2961 27 of of IN 37231 2961 28 the the DT 37231 2961 29 composition composition NN 37231 2961 30 , , , 37231 2961 31 and and CC 37231 2961 32 to to TO 37231 2961 33 class class VB 37231 2961 34 the the DT 37231 2961 35 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2961 36 with with IN 37231 2961 37 the the DT 37231 2961 38 rest rest NN 37231 2961 39 of of IN 37231 2961 40 the the DT 37231 2961 41 pseudo pseudo JJ 37231 2961 42 - - JJ 37231 2961 43 Ignatian ignatian JJ 37231 2961 44 literature literature NN 37231 2961 45 . . . 37231 2962 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2962 2 shall shall MD 37231 2962 3 now now RB 37231 2962 4 examine examine VB 37231 2962 5 all all PDT 37231 2962 6 the the DT 37231 2962 7 passages passage NNS 37231 2962 8 in in IN 37231 2962 9 this this DT 37231 2962 10 epistle epistle NN 37231 2962 11 which which WDT 37231 2962 12 are be VBP 37231 2962 13 pointed point VBN 37231 2962 14 out out RP 37231 2962 15 as as IN 37231 2962 16 indicating indicate VBG 37231 2962 17 any any DT 37231 2962 18 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 2962 19 with with IN 37231 2962 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2962 21 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2962 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2962 23 . . . 37231 2963 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2963 2 1 1 LS 37231 2963 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2963 4 The the DT 37231 2963 5 first first JJ 37231 2963 6 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2963 7 in in IN 37231 2963 8 ch ch NN 37231 2963 9 . . . 37231 2964 1 ii ii NNP 37231 2964 2 . . NNP 37231 2964 3 , , , 37231 2964 4 and and CC 37231 2964 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2964 6 subjoin subjoin VBP 37231 2964 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2964 8 in in IN 37231 2964 9 contrast contrast NN 37231 2964 10 with with IN 37231 2964 11 the the DT 37231 2964 12 nearest near JJS 37231 2964 13 parallel parallel JJ 37231 2964 14 passages passage NNS 37231 2964 15 of of IN 37231 2964 16 the the DT 37231 2964 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2964 18 , , , 37231 2964 19 but but CC 37231 2964 20 although although IN 37231 2964 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2964 22 break break VBP 37231 2964 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2964 24 up up RP 37231 2964 25 into into IN 37231 2964 26 paragraphs paragraph NNS 37231 2964 27 , , , 37231 2964 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2964 29 will will MD 37231 2964 30 , , , 37231 2964 31 of of IN 37231 2964 32 course course NN 37231 2964 33 , , , 37231 2964 34 be be VB 37231 2964 35 understood understand VBN 37231 2964 36 that that IN 37231 2964 37 the the DT 37231 2964 38 quotation quotation NN 37231 2964 39 is be VBZ 37231 2964 40 continuous continuous JJ 37231 2964 41 in in IN 37231 2964 42 the the DT 37231 2964 43 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2964 44 . . . 37231 2965 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 2965 2 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 2965 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 2965 4 { { -LRB- 37231 2965 5 278 278 CD 37231 2965 6 } } -RRB- 37231 2965 7 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2965 8 will will MD 37231 2965 9 be be VB 37231 2965 10 remembered remember VBN 37231 2965 11 that that IN 37231 2965 12 an an DT 37231 2965 13 almost almost RB 37231 2965 14 similar similar JJ 37231 2965 15 direct direct JJ 37231 2965 16 quotation quotation NN 37231 2965 17 of of IN 37231 2965 18 words word NNS 37231 2965 19 of of IN 37231 2965 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2965 21 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2965 22 in in IN 37231 2965 23 the the DT 37231 2965 24 so so RB 37231 2965 25 - - HYPH 37231 2965 26 called call VBN 37231 2965 27 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 2965 28 of of IN 37231 2965 29 Clement Clement NNP 37231 2965 30 to to IN 37231 2965 31 the the DT 37231 2965 32 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 2965 33 , , , 37231 2965 34 c. c. NNP 37231 2966 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 2966 2 . . . 37231 2966 3 , , , 37231 2966 4 which which WDT 37231 2966 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2966 6 have have VBP 37231 2966 7 already already RB 37231 2966 8 examined examine VBN 37231 2966 9 . . . 37231 2967 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2967 2 1 1 LS 37231 2967 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2967 4 There there RB 37231 2967 5 , , , 37231 2967 6 the the DT 37231 2967 7 passage passage NN 37231 2967 8 is be VBZ 37231 2967 9 introduced introduce VBN 37231 2967 10 by by IN 37231 2967 11 the the DT 37231 2967 12 same same JJ 37231 2967 13 words word NNS 37231 2967 14 , , , 37231 2967 15 and and CC 37231 2967 16 in in IN 37231 2967 17 the the DT 37231 2967 18 midst midst NN 37231 2967 19 of of IN 37231 2967 20 brief brief JJ 37231 2967 21 phrases phrase NNS 37231 2967 22 which which WDT 37231 2967 23 have have VBP 37231 2967 24 parallels parallel NNS 37231 2967 25 in in IN 37231 2967 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2967 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2967 28 there there EX 37231 2967 29 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2967 30 in in IN 37231 2967 31 both both DT 37231 2967 32 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 2967 33 the the DT 37231 2967 34 same same JJ 37231 2967 35 expression expression NN 37231 2967 36 , , , 37231 2967 37 " " `` 37231 2967 38 Be be VB 37231 2967 39 pitiful pitiful JJ 37231 2967 40 that that IN 37231 2967 41 ye ye NNP 37231 2967 42 may may MD 37231 2967 43 be be VB 37231 2967 44 pitied pity VBN 37231 2967 45 , , , 37231 2967 46 " " '' 37231 2967 47 which which WDT 37231 2967 48 is be VBZ 37231 2967 49 not not RB 37231 2967 50 found find VBN 37231 2967 51 in in IN 37231 2967 52 any any DT 37231 2967 53 of of IN 37231 2967 54 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2967 55 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2967 56 . . . 37231 2968 1 In in IN 37231 2968 2 order order NN 37231 2968 3 to to TO 37231 2968 4 find find VB 37231 2968 5 any any DT 37231 2968 6 parallels parallel NNS 37231 2968 7 for for IN 37231 2968 8 the the DT 37231 2968 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 2968 10 , , , 37231 2968 11 upon upon IN 37231 2968 12 the the DT 37231 2968 13 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 2968 14 of of IN 37231 2968 15 a a DT 37231 2968 16 combination combination NN 37231 2968 17 of of IN 37231 2968 18 texts text NNS 37231 2968 19 , , , 37231 2968 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2968 21 have have VBP 37231 2968 22 to to TO 37231 2968 23 add add VB 37231 2968 24 together together RB 37231 2968 25 portions portion NNS 37231 2968 26 of of IN 37231 2968 27 the the DT 37231 2968 28 following follow VBG 37231 2968 29 verses verse NNS 37231 2968 30 in in IN 37231 2968 31 the the DT 37231 2968 32 following follow VBG 37231 2968 33 order order NN 37231 2968 34 : : : 37231 2968 35 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2968 36 vii vii NN 37231 2968 37 . . . 37231 2969 1 1 1 CD 37231 2969 2 , , , 37231 2969 3 vi vi NNP 37231 2969 4 . . . 37231 2970 1 14 14 CD 37231 2970 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2970 3 although although IN 37231 2970 4 , , , 37231 2970 5 with with IN 37231 2970 6 complete complete JJ 37231 2970 7 linguistic linguistic JJ 37231 2970 8 variations variation NNS 37231 2970 9 , , , 37231 2970 10 the the DT 37231 2970 11 sense sense NN 37231 2970 12 of of IN 37231 2970 13 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2970 14 vi vi NNP 37231 2970 15 . . . 37231 2971 1 37 37 CD 37231 2971 2 is be VBZ 37231 2971 3 much much RB 37231 2971 4 closer close JJR 37231 2971 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2971 6 , , , 37231 2971 7 v. v. CC 37231 2971 8 7 7 CD 37231 2971 9 , , , 37231 2971 10 vii vii NN 37231 2971 11 . . . 37231 2972 1 2 2 CD 37231 2972 2 , , , 37231 2972 3 v. v. CC 37231 2972 4 3 3 CD 37231 2972 5 , , , 37231 2972 6 v. v. CC 37231 2972 7 10 10 CD 37231 2972 8 . . . 37231 2973 1 Such such JJ 37231 2973 2 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 37231 2973 3 compilation compilation NN 37231 2973 4 is be VBZ 37231 2973 5 in in IN 37231 2973 6 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 2973 7 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 2973 8 conceivable conceivable JJ 37231 2973 9 in in IN 37231 2973 10 an an DT 37231 2973 11 epistle epistle NN 37231 2973 12 of of IN 37231 2973 13 this this DT 37231 2973 14 kind kind NN 37231 2973 15 , , , 37231 2973 16 but but CC 37231 2973 17 when when WRB 37231 2973 18 in in IN 37231 2973 19 the the DT 37231 2973 20 midst midst NN 37231 2973 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2973 22 find find VBP 37231 2973 23 a a DT 37231 2973 24 passage passage NN 37231 2973 25 foreign foreign JJ 37231 2973 26 to to IN 37231 2973 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2973 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2973 29 , , , 37231 2973 30 but but CC 37231 2973 31 which which WDT 37231 2973 32 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2973 33 in in IN 37231 2973 34 another another DT 37231 2973 35 work work NN 37231 2973 36 in in IN 37231 2973 37 connection connection NN 37231 2973 38 with with IN 37231 2973 39 so so RB 37231 2973 40 similar similar JJ 37231 2973 41 a a DT 37231 2973 42 quotation quotation NN 37231 2973 43 , , , 37231 2973 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2973 45 is be VBZ 37231 2973 46 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 2973 47 to to TO 37231 2973 48 conclude conclude VB 37231 2973 49 that that IN 37231 2973 50 the the DT 37231 2973 51 whole whole NN 37231 2973 52 is be VBZ 37231 2973 53 derived derive VBN 37231 2973 54 from from IN 37231 2973 55 tradition tradition NN 37231 2973 56 or or CC 37231 2973 57 from from IN 37231 2973 58 a a DT 37231 2973 59 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2973 60 different different JJ 37231 2973 61 from from IN 37231 2973 62 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 2973 63 . . . 37231 2974 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2974 2 2 2 LS 37231 2974 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2974 4 In in IN 37231 2974 5 no no DT 37231 2974 6 case case NN 37231 2974 7 can can MD 37231 2974 8 such such JJ 37231 2974 9 { { -LRB- 37231 2974 10 279 279 CD 37231 2974 11 } } -RRB- 37231 2974 12 a a DT 37231 2974 13 passage passage NN 37231 2974 14 be be VB 37231 2974 15 considered consider VBN 37231 2974 16 material material JJ 37231 2974 17 evidence evidence NN 37231 2974 18 of of IN 37231 2974 19 the the DT 37231 2974 20 existence existence NN 37231 2974 21 of of IN 37231 2974 22 any any DT 37231 2974 23 one one CD 37231 2974 24 of of IN 37231 2974 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2974 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2974 27 . . . 37231 2975 1 Another another DT 37231 2975 2 expression expression NN 37231 2975 3 which which WDT 37231 2975 4 is be VBZ 37231 2975 5 pointed point VBN 37231 2975 6 out out RP 37231 2975 7 occurs occur VBZ 37231 2975 8 in in IN 37231 2975 9 ch ch NN 37231 2975 10 . . . 37231 2976 1 vii vii NNP 37231 2976 2 . . . 37231 2976 3 , , , 37231 2976 4 " " '' 37231 2976 5 beseeching beseech VBG 37231 2976 6 in in IN 37231 2976 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2976 8 prayers prayer NNS 37231 2976 9 the the DT 37231 2976 10 all all RB 37231 2976 11 - - HYPH 37231 2976 12 searching search VBG 37231 2976 13 God God NNP 37231 2976 14 not not RB 37231 2976 15 to to TO 37231 2976 16 lead lead VB 37231 2976 17 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2976 18 into into IN 37231 2976 19 temptation temptation NN 37231 2976 20 , , , 37231 2976 21 as as IN 37231 2976 22 the the DT 37231 2976 23 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2976 24 said say VBD 37231 2976 25 : : : 37231 2976 26 The the DT 37231 2976 27 spirit spirit NN 37231 2976 28 indeed indeed RB 37231 2976 29 is be VBZ 37231 2976 30 willing willing JJ 37231 2976 31 , , , 37231 2976 32 but but CC 37231 2976 33 the the DT 37231 2976 34 flesh flesh NN 37231 2976 35 is be VBZ 37231 2976 36 weak weak JJ 37231 2976 37 . . . 37231 2977 1 " " `` 37231 2977 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2977 3 1 1 LS 37231 2977 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2977 5 This this DT 37231 2977 6 is be VBZ 37231 2977 7 compared compare VBN 37231 2977 8 with with IN 37231 2977 9 the the DT 37231 2977 10 phrase phrase NN 37231 2977 11 in in IN 37231 2977 12 " " `` 37231 2977 13 the the DT 37231 2977 14 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2977 15 's 's POS 37231 2977 16 Prayer Prayer NNP 37231 2977 17 " " '' 37231 2977 18 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2977 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2977 20 vi vi NNP 37231 2977 21 . . . 37231 2978 1 13 13 CD 37231 2978 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2978 3 , , , 37231 2978 4 or or CC 37231 2978 5 the the DT 37231 2978 6 passage passage NN 37231 2978 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2978 8 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 2978 9 . . . 37231 2979 1 41 41 CD 37231 2979 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2979 3 : : : 37231 2979 4 " " `` 37231 2979 5 Watch watch VB 37231 2979 6 and and CC 37231 2979 7 pray pray VB 37231 2979 8 that that IN 37231 2979 9 ye ye NNP 37231 2979 10 enter enter VBP 37231 2979 11 not not RB 37231 2979 12 into into IN 37231 2979 13 temptation temptation NN 37231 2979 14 : : : 37231 2979 15 the the DT 37231 2979 16 spirit spirit NNP 37231 2979 17 indeed indeed RB 37231 2979 18 is be VBZ 37231 2979 19 willing willing JJ 37231 2979 20 , , , 37231 2979 21 but but CC 37231 2979 22 the the DT 37231 2979 23 flesh flesh NN 37231 2979 24 is be VBZ 37231 2979 25 weak weak JJ 37231 2979 26 . . . 37231 2980 1 " " `` 37231 2980 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2980 3 2 2 LS 37231 2980 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2980 5 The the DT 37231 2980 6 second second JJ 37231 2980 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2980 8 , , , 37231 2980 9 however however RB 37231 2980 10 , , , 37231 2980 11 equally equally RB 37231 2980 12 has have VBZ 37231 2980 13 the the DT 37231 2980 14 phrase phrase NN 37231 2980 15 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2980 16 xiv xiv NN 37231 2980 17 . . . 37231 2981 1 38 38 CD 37231 2981 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2981 3 , , , 37231 2981 4 and and CC 37231 2981 5 shows show VBZ 37231 2981 6 how how WRB 37231 2981 7 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 2981 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2981 9 is be VBZ 37231 2981 10 to to TO 37231 2981 11 limit limit VB 37231 2981 12 these these DT 37231 2981 13 historical historical JJ 37231 2981 14 sayings saying NNS 37231 2981 15 to to IN 37231 2981 16 a a DT 37231 2981 17 single single JJ 37231 2981 18 Gospel gospel NN 37231 2981 19 . . . 37231 2982 1 The the DT 37231 2982 2 next next JJ 37231 2982 3 passage passage NN 37231 2982 4 is be VBZ 37231 2982 5 of of IN 37231 2982 6 a a DT 37231 2982 7 similar similar JJ 37231 2982 8 nature nature NN 37231 2982 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2982 10 c. c. NNP 37231 2983 1 vi vi NNP 37231 2983 2 . . . 37231 2984 1 ): ): LS 37231 2984 2 " " `` 37231 2984 3 If if IN 37231 2984 4 , , , 37231 2984 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 2984 6 , , , 37231 2984 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2984 8 pray pray VBP 37231 2984 9 the the DT 37231 2984 10 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2984 11 that that IN 37231 2984 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2984 13 may may MD 37231 2984 14 forgive forgive VB 37231 2984 15 us -PRON- PRP 37231 2984 16 , , , 37231 2984 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2984 18 ought ought MD 37231 2984 19 also also RB 37231 2984 20 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2984 21 to to TO 37231 2984 22 forgive forgive VB 37231 2984 23 . . . 37231 2985 1 " " `` 37231 2985 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 2985 3 3 3 LS 37231 2985 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2985 5 The the DT 37231 2985 6 thought thought NN 37231 2985 7 but but CC 37231 2985 8 not not RB 37231 2985 9 the the DT 37231 2985 10 language language NN 37231 2985 11 of of IN 37231 2985 12 this this DT 37231 2985 13 passage passage NN 37231 2985 14 corresponds correspond NNS 37231 2985 15 with with IN 37231 2985 16 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2985 17 vi vi NNP 37231 2985 18 . . . 37231 2986 1 12 12 CD 37231 2986 2 - - HYPH 37231 2986 3 -14 -14 NN 37231 2986 4 , , , 37231 2986 5 but but CC 37231 2986 6 equally equally RB 37231 2986 7 so so IN 37231 2986 8 with with IN 37231 2986 9 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2986 10 xi xi NNP 37231 2986 11 . . . 37231 2987 1 4 4 LS 37231 2987 2 . . . 37231 2988 1 Now now RB 37231 2988 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 2988 3 must must MD 37231 2988 4 repeat repeat VB 37231 2988 5 that that IN 37231 2988 6 all all DT 37231 2988 7 such such JJ 37231 2988 8 sayings saying NNS 37231 2988 9 of of IN 37231 2988 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2988 11 were be VBD 37231 2988 12 the the DT 37231 2988 13 common common JJ 37231 2988 14 property property NN 37231 2988 15 of of IN 37231 2988 16 the the DT 37231 2988 17 early early JJ 37231 2988 18 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2988 19 -- -- : 37231 2988 20 were be VBD 37231 2988 21 no no RB 37231 2988 22 doubt doubt NN 37231 2988 23 orally orally RB 37231 2988 24 current current JJ 37231 2988 25 amongst amongst IN 37231 2988 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2988 27 , , , 37231 2988 28 and and CC 37231 2988 29 still still RB 37231 2988 30 more more RBR 37231 2988 31 certainly certainly RB 37231 2988 32 were be VBD 37231 2988 33 recorded record VBN 37231 2988 34 by by IN 37231 2988 35 many many JJ 37231 2988 36 of of IN 37231 2988 37 the the DT 37231 2988 38 numerous numerous JJ 37231 2988 39 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2988 40 then then RB 37231 2988 41 in in IN 37231 2988 42 circulation circulation NN 37231 2988 43 , , , 37231 2988 44 as as IN 37231 2988 45 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2988 46 are be VBP 37231 2988 47 by by IN 37231 2988 48 several several JJ 37231 2988 49 of of IN 37231 2988 50 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2988 51 own own JJ 37231 2988 52 . . . 37231 2989 1 In in IN 37231 2989 2 no no DT 37231 2989 3 case case NN 37231 2989 4 is be VBZ 37231 2989 5 there there EX 37231 2989 6 any any DT 37231 2989 7 written write VBN 37231 2989 8 source source NN 37231 2989 9 indicated indicate VBN 37231 2989 10 from from IN 37231 2989 11 which which WDT 37231 2989 12 these these DT 37231 2989 13 passages passage NNS 37231 2989 14 are be VBP 37231 2989 15 derived derive VBN 37231 2989 16 ; ; : 37231 2989 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2989 18 are be VBP 37231 2989 19 simply simply RB 37231 2989 20 quoted quote VBN 37231 2989 21 as as IN 37231 2989 22 words word NNS 37231 2989 23 of of IN 37231 2989 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2989 25 , , , 37231 2989 26 and and CC 37231 2989 27 being be VBG 37231 2989 28 all all DT 37231 2989 29 connected connect VBN 37231 2989 30 either either CC 37231 2989 31 with with IN 37231 2989 32 the the DT 37231 2989 33 " " `` 37231 2989 34 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 2989 35 on on IN 37231 2989 36 the the DT 37231 2989 37 Mount Mount NNP 37231 2989 38 " " '' 37231 2989 39 or or CC 37231 2989 40 the the DT 37231 2989 41 " " `` 37231 2989 42 Lord Lord NNP 37231 2989 43 's 's POS 37231 2989 44 Prayer Prayer NNP 37231 2989 45 , , , 37231 2989 46 " " '' 37231 2989 47 the the DT 37231 2989 48 two two CD 37231 2989 49 portions portion NNS 37231 2989 50 of of IN 37231 2989 51 the the DT 37231 2989 52 teaching teaching NN 37231 2989 53 of of IN 37231 2989 54 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2989 55 which which WDT 37231 2989 56 were be VBD 37231 2989 57 most most JJS 37231 2989 58 { { -LRB- 37231 2989 59 280 280 CD 37231 2989 60 } } -RRB- 37231 2989 61 popular popular JJ 37231 2989 62 , , , 37231 2989 63 widely widely RB 37231 2989 64 known know VBN 37231 2989 65 , , , 37231 2989 66 and and CC 37231 2989 67 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 2989 68 , , , 37231 2989 69 there there EX 37231 2989 70 can can MD 37231 2989 71 be be VB 37231 2989 72 no no DT 37231 2989 73 doubt doubt NN 37231 2989 74 that that IN 37231 2989 75 they -PRON- PRP 37231 2989 76 were be VBD 37231 2989 77 familiar familiar JJ 37231 2989 78 throughout throughout IN 37231 2989 79 the the DT 37231 2989 80 whole whole NN 37231 2989 81 of of IN 37231 2989 82 the the DT 37231 2989 83 early early JJ 37231 2989 84 Church Church NNP 37231 2989 85 , , , 37231 2989 86 and and CC 37231 2989 87 must must MD 37231 2989 88 have have VB 37231 2989 89 formed form VBN 37231 2989 90 a a DT 37231 2989 91 part part NN 37231 2989 92 of of IN 37231 2989 93 most most JJS 37231 2989 94 or or CC 37231 2989 95 all all DT 37231 2989 96 of of IN 37231 2989 97 the the DT 37231 2989 98 many many JJ 37231 2989 99 collections collection NNS 37231 2989 100 of of IN 37231 2989 101 the the DT 37231 2989 102 words word NNS 37231 2989 103 of of IN 37231 2989 104 the the DT 37231 2989 105 Master Master NNP 37231 2989 106 . . . 37231 2990 1 To to TO 37231 2990 2 limit limit VB 37231 2990 3 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2990 4 to to IN 37231 2990 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2990 6 actual actual JJ 37231 2990 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2990 8 , , , 37231 2990 9 which which WDT 37231 2990 10 alone alone RB 37231 2990 11 survive survive VBP 37231 2990 12 , , , 37231 2990 13 would would MD 37231 2990 14 be be VB 37231 2990 15 quite quite RB 37231 2990 16 unwarrantable unwarrantable JJ 37231 2990 17 , , , 37231 2990 18 and and CC 37231 2990 19 no no DT 37231 2990 20 reference reference NN 37231 2990 21 to to IN 37231 2990 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2990 23 , , , 37231 2990 24 without without IN 37231 2990 25 specification specification NN 37231 2990 26 of of IN 37231 2990 27 the the DT 37231 2990 28 source source NN 37231 2990 29 , , , 37231 2990 30 can can MD 37231 2990 31 be be VB 37231 2990 32 received receive VBN 37231 2990 33 as as IN 37231 2990 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 2990 35 even even RB 37231 2990 36 of of IN 37231 2990 37 the the DT 37231 2990 38 existence existence NN 37231 2990 39 of of IN 37231 2990 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2990 41 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2990 42 . . . 37231 2991 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 2991 2 may may MD 37231 2991 3 here here RB 37231 2991 4 briefly briefly RB 37231 2991 5 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 2991 6 the the DT 37231 2991 7 point point NN 37231 2991 8 from from IN 37231 2991 9 the the DT 37231 2991 10 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2991 11 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2991 12 . . . 37231 2992 1 Assuming assume VBG 37231 2992 2 the the DT 37231 2992 3 parable parable NN 37231 2992 4 of of IN 37231 2992 5 the the DT 37231 2992 6 Sower Sower NNP 37231 2992 7 to to TO 37231 2992 8 be be VB 37231 2992 9 a a DT 37231 2992 10 genuine genuine JJ 37231 2992 11 example example NN 37231 2992 12 of of IN 37231 2992 13 the the DT 37231 2992 14 teaching teaching NN 37231 2992 15 of of IN 37231 2992 16 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 2992 17 , , , 37231 2992 18 as as IN 37231 2992 19 there there EX 37231 2992 20 is be VBZ 37231 2992 21 every every DT 37231 2992 22 reason reason NN 37231 2992 23 to to TO 37231 2992 24 believe believe VB 37231 2992 25 , , , 37231 2992 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2992 27 may may MD 37231 2992 28 with with IN 37231 2992 29 certainty certainty NN 37231 2992 30 be be VB 37231 2992 31 asserted assert VBN 37231 2992 32 that that IN 37231 2992 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2992 34 must must MD 37231 2992 35 have have VB 37231 2992 36 been be VBN 37231 2992 37 included include VBN 37231 2992 38 in in IN 37231 2992 39 many many JJ 37231 2992 40 of of IN 37231 2992 41 the the DT 37231 2992 42 records record NNS 37231 2992 43 circulating circulate VBG 37231 2992 44 among among IN 37231 2992 45 early early JJ 37231 2992 46 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 2992 47 , , , 37231 2992 48 to to TO 37231 2992 49 which which WDT 37231 2992 50 reference reference NN 37231 2992 51 is be VBZ 37231 2992 52 made make VBN 37231 2992 53 in in IN 37231 2992 54 the the DT 37231 2992 55 prologue prologue NN 37231 2992 56 to to IN 37231 2992 57 the the DT 37231 2992 58 third third JJ 37231 2992 59 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2992 60 . . . 37231 2993 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 2993 2 would would MD 37231 2993 3 not not RB 37231 2993 4 be be VB 37231 2993 5 permissible permissible JJ 37231 2993 6 to to TO 37231 2993 7 affirm affirm VB 37231 2993 8 that that IN 37231 2993 9 no no DT 37231 2993 10 part part NN 37231 2993 11 of of IN 37231 2993 12 that that DT 37231 2993 13 parable parable JJ 37231 2993 14 could could MD 37231 2993 15 be be VB 37231 2993 16 referred refer VBN 37231 2993 17 to to IN 37231 2993 18 by by IN 37231 2993 19 an an DT 37231 2993 20 early early JJ 37231 2993 21 writer writer NN 37231 2993 22 without without IN 37231 2993 23 that that DT 37231 2993 24 reference reference NN 37231 2993 25 being be VBG 37231 2993 26 an an DT 37231 2993 27 indication indication NN 37231 2993 28 of of IN 37231 2993 29 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 2993 30 with with IN 37231 2993 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2993 32 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 2993 33 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 2993 34 . . . 37231 2994 1 The the DT 37231 2994 2 parable parable JJ 37231 2994 3 is be VBZ 37231 2994 4 reported report VBN 37231 2994 5 in in IN 37231 2994 6 closely closely RB 37231 2994 7 similar similar JJ 37231 2994 8 words word NNS 37231 2994 9 in in IN 37231 2994 10 each each DT 37231 2994 11 of of IN 37231 2994 12 those those DT 37231 2994 13 three three CD 37231 2994 14 Gospels,(1 Gospels,(1 NNS 37231 2994 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 2994 16 and and CC 37231 2994 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2994 18 may may MD 37231 2994 19 have have VB 37231 2994 20 been be VBN 37231 2994 21 , , , 37231 2994 22 and and CC 37231 2994 23 probably probably RB 37231 2994 24 was be VBD 37231 2994 25 , , , 37231 2994 26 recorded record VBN 37231 2994 27 similarly similarly RB 37231 2994 28 in in IN 37231 2994 29 a a DT 37231 2994 30 dozen dozen NN 37231 2994 31 more more JJR 37231 2994 32 . . . 37231 2995 1 Confining confine VBG 37231 2995 2 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 2995 3 , , , 37231 2995 4 however however RB 37231 2995 5 , , , 37231 2995 6 for for IN 37231 2995 7 a a DT 37231 2995 8 moment moment NN 37231 2995 9 to to IN 37231 2995 10 the the DT 37231 2995 11 three three CD 37231 2995 12 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 2995 13 : : : 37231 2995 14 what what WP 37231 2995 15 could could MD 37231 2995 16 a a DT 37231 2995 17 general general JJ 37231 2995 18 allusion allusion NN 37231 2995 19 to to IN 37231 2995 20 the the DT 37231 2995 21 parable parable NN 37231 2995 22 of of IN 37231 2995 23 the the DT 37231 2995 24 Sower Sower NNP 37231 2995 25 prove prove NN 37231 2995 26 regarding regard VBG 37231 2995 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 2995 28 existence existence NN 37231 2995 29 and and CC 37231 2995 30 use use NN 37231 2995 31 , , , 37231 2995 32 no no DT 37231 2995 33 mention mention NN 37231 2995 34 of of IN 37231 2995 35 a a DT 37231 2995 36 particular particular JJ 37231 2995 37 source source NN 37231 2995 38 being be VBG 37231 2995 39 made make VBN 37231 2995 40 ? ? . 37231 2996 1 Would Would MD 37231 2996 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2996 3 prove prove VB 37231 2996 4 that that IN 37231 2996 5 all all PDT 37231 2996 6 the the DT 37231 2996 7 three three CD 37231 2996 8 were be VBD 37231 2996 9 extant extant JJ 37231 2996 10 , , , 37231 2996 11 and and CC 37231 2996 12 that that IN 37231 2996 13 the the DT 37231 2996 14 writer writer NN 37231 2996 15 knew know VBD 37231 2996 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2996 17 all all DT 37231 2996 18 , , , 37231 2996 19 for for IN 37231 2996 20 each each DT 37231 2996 21 of of IN 37231 2996 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 2996 23 containing contain VBG 37231 2996 24 the the DT 37231 2996 25 parable parable JJ 37231 2996 26 would would MD 37231 2996 27 possess possess VB 37231 2996 28 an an DT 37231 2996 29 equal equal JJ 37231 2996 30 claim claim NN 37231 2996 31 to to IN 37231 2996 32 the the DT 37231 2996 33 reference reference NN 37231 2996 34 ? ? . 37231 2997 1 Could Could MD 37231 2997 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 2997 3 with with IN 37231 2997 4 any any DT 37231 2997 5 reason reason NN 37231 2997 6 be be VB 37231 2997 7 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 2997 8 that that IN 37231 2997 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 2997 10 was be VBD 37231 2997 11 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 2997 12 with with IN 37231 2997 13 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2997 14 and and CC 37231 2997 15 not not RB 37231 2997 16 with with IN 37231 2997 17 Mark Mark NNP 37231 2997 18 ? ? . 37231 2998 1 or or CC 37231 2998 2 with with IN 37231 2998 3 Mark Mark NNP 37231 2998 4 and and CC 37231 2998 5 not not RB 37231 2998 6 with with IN 37231 2998 7 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 2998 8 and and CC 37231 2998 9 Luke Luke NNP 37231 2998 10 ? ? . 37231 2999 1 or or CC 37231 2999 2 with with IN 37231 2999 3 the the DT 37231 2999 4 third third JJ 37231 2999 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 2999 6 and and CC 37231 2999 7 { { -LRB- 37231 2999 8 281 281 CD 37231 2999 9 } } -RRB- 37231 2999 10 not not RB 37231 2999 11 with with IN 37231 2999 12 either either DT 37231 2999 13 of of IN 37231 2999 14 the the DT 37231 2999 15 other other JJ 37231 2999 16 two two CD 37231 2999 17 ? ? . 37231 3000 1 The the DT 37231 3000 2 case case NN 37231 3000 3 is be VBZ 37231 3000 4 the the DT 37231 3000 5 very very RB 37231 3000 6 same same JJ 37231 3000 7 if if IN 37231 3000 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3000 9 extend extend VBP 37231 3000 10 the the DT 37231 3000 11 illustration illustration NN 37231 3000 12 , , , 37231 3000 13 and and CC 37231 3000 14 along along IN 37231 3000 15 with with IN 37231 3000 16 the the DT 37231 3000 17 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3000 18 include include VBP 37231 3000 19 the the DT 37231 3000 20 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3000 21 other other JJ 37231 3000 22 records record NNS 37231 3000 23 of of IN 37231 3000 24 the the DT 37231 3000 25 early early JJ 37231 3000 26 Church Church NNP 37231 3000 27 . . . 37231 3001 1 The the DT 37231 3001 2 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 3001 3 quotation quotation NN 37231 3001 4 of of IN 37231 3001 5 historical historical JJ 37231 3001 6 expressions expression NNS 37231 3001 7 of of IN 37231 3001 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3001 9 can can MD 37231 3001 10 not not RB 37231 3001 11 prove prove VB 37231 3001 12 the the DT 37231 3001 13 existence existence NN 37231 3001 14 of of IN 37231 3001 15 one one CD 37231 3001 16 special special JJ 37231 3001 17 document document NN 37231 3001 18 among among IN 37231 3001 19 many many JJ 37231 3001 20 to to TO 37231 3001 21 which which WDT 37231 3001 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3001 23 may may MD 37231 3001 24 choose choose VB 37231 3001 25 to to TO 37231 3001 26 trace trace VB 37231 3001 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3001 28 . . . 37231 3002 1 This this DT 37231 3002 2 is be VBZ 37231 3002 3 more more RBR 37231 3002 4 especially especially RB 37231 3002 5 to to TO 37231 3002 6 be be VB 37231 3002 7 insisted insist VBN 37231 3002 8 on on IN 37231 3002 9 from from IN 37231 3002 10 the the DT 37231 3002 11 fact fact NN 37231 3002 12 , , , 37231 3002 13 that that IN 37231 3002 14 hitherto hitherto UH 37231 3002 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3002 16 have have VBP 37231 3002 17 not not RB 37231 3002 18 met meet VBN 37231 3002 19 with with IN 37231 3002 20 any any DT 37231 3002 21 mention mention NN 37231 3002 22 of of IN 37231 3002 23 any any DT 37231 3002 24 one one CD 37231 3002 25 of of IN 37231 3002 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3002 27 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3002 28 , , , 37231 3002 29 and and CC 37231 3002 30 have have VBP 37231 3002 31 no no DT 37231 3002 32 right right NN 37231 3002 33 even even RB 37231 3002 34 to to TO 37231 3002 35 assume assume VB 37231 3002 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3002 37 existence existence NN 37231 3002 38 from from IN 37231 3002 39 any any DT 37231 3002 40 evidence evidence NN 37231 3002 41 which which WDT 37231 3002 42 has have VBZ 37231 3002 43 been be VBN 37231 3002 44 furnished furnish VBN 37231 3002 45 . . . 37231 3003 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 3003 2 III III NNP 37231 3003 3 . . . 37231 3004 1 JUSTIN JUSTIN NNP 37231 3004 2 MARTYR MARTYR NNP 37231 3004 3 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3004 4 shall shall MD 37231 3004 5 now now RB 37231 3004 6 consider consider VB 37231 3004 7 the the DT 37231 3004 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 3004 9 furnished furnish VBN 37231 3004 10 by by IN 37231 3004 11 the the DT 37231 3004 12 works work NNS 37231 3004 13 of of IN 37231 3004 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3004 15 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 3004 16 , , , 37231 3004 17 regarding regard VBG 37231 3004 18 the the DT 37231 3004 19 existence existence NN 37231 3004 20 of of IN 37231 3004 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3004 22 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 3004 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3004 24 at at IN 37231 3004 25 the the DT 37231 3004 26 middle middle NN 37231 3004 27 of of IN 37231 3004 28 the the DT 37231 3004 29 second second JJ 37231 3004 30 century century NN 37231 3004 31 , , , 37231 3004 32 and and CC 37231 3004 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3004 34 may may MD 37231 3004 35 remark remark VB 37231 3004 36 , , , 37231 3004 37 in in IN 37231 3004 38 anticipation anticipation NN 37231 3004 39 , , , 37231 3004 40 that that IN 37231 3004 41 whatever whatever WDT 37231 3004 42 differences difference NNS 37231 3004 43 of of IN 37231 3004 44 opinion opinion NN 37231 3004 45 may may MD 37231 3004 46 finally finally RB 37231 3004 47 exist exist VB 37231 3004 48 regarding regard VBG 37231 3004 49 the the DT 37231 3004 50 solution solution NN 37231 3004 51 of of IN 37231 3004 52 the the DT 37231 3004 53 problem problem NN 37231 3004 54 which which WDT 37231 3004 55 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3004 56 have have VBP 37231 3004 57 to to TO 37231 3004 58 examine examine VB 37231 3004 59 , , , 37231 3004 60 at at IN 37231 3004 61 least least JJS 37231 3004 62 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3004 63 is be VBZ 37231 3004 64 clear clear JJ 37231 3004 65 that that IN 37231 3004 66 the the DT 37231 3004 67 testimony testimony NN 37231 3004 68 of of IN 37231 3004 69 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3004 70 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 3004 71 is be VBZ 37231 3004 72 not not RB 37231 3004 73 of of IN 37231 3004 74 a a DT 37231 3004 75 nature nature NN 37231 3004 76 to to TO 37231 3004 77 establish establish VB 37231 3004 78 the the DT 37231 3004 79 date date NN 37231 3004 80 , , , 37231 3004 81 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 3004 82 , , , 37231 3004 83 and and CC 37231 3004 84 character character NN 37231 3004 85 of of IN 37231 3004 86 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3004 87 professing profess VBG 37231 3004 88 to to TO 37231 3004 89 communicate communicate VB 37231 3004 90 such such JJ 37231 3004 91 momentous momentous JJ 37231 3004 92 and and CC 37231 3004 93 astounding astounding JJ 37231 3004 94 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3004 95 . . . 37231 3005 1 The the DT 37231 3005 2 determination determination NN 37231 3005 3 of of IN 37231 3005 4 the the DT 37231 3005 5 source source NN 37231 3005 6 from from IN 37231 3005 7 which which WDT 37231 3005 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3005 9 derived derive VBD 37231 3005 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3005 11 facts fact NNS 37231 3005 12 of of IN 37231 3005 13 Christian christian JJ 37231 3005 14 history history NN 37231 3005 15 has have VBZ 37231 3005 16 for for IN 37231 3005 17 a a DT 37231 3005 18 century century NN 37231 3005 19 attracted attract VBD 37231 3005 20 more more JJR 37231 3005 21 attention attention NN 37231 3005 22 , , , 37231 3005 23 and and CC 37231 3005 24 excited excite VBD 37231 3005 25 more more JJR 37231 3005 26 controversy controversy NN 37231 3005 27 , , , 37231 3005 28 than than IN 37231 3005 29 almost almost RB 37231 3005 30 any any DT 37231 3005 31 other other JJ 37231 3005 32 similar similar JJ 37231 3005 33 question question NN 37231 3005 34 in in IN 37231 3005 35 connection connection NN 37231 3005 36 with with IN 37231 3005 37 patristic patristic JJ 37231 3005 38 literature literature NN 37231 3005 39 , , , 37231 3005 40 and and CC 37231 3005 41 upon upon IN 37231 3005 42 none none NN 37231 3005 43 have have VBP 37231 3005 44 more more RBR 37231 3005 45 divergent divergent JJ 37231 3005 46 opinions opinion NNS 37231 3005 47 been be VBN 37231 3005 48 expressed express VBN 37231 3005 49 . . . 37231 3006 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3006 2 , , , 37231 3006 3 who who WP 37231 3006 4 suffered suffer VBD 37231 3006 5 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 3006 6 about about IN 37231 3006 7 a.d a.d NNP 37231 3006 8 . . NNP 37231 3006 9 166 166 CD 37231 3006 10 - - HYPH 37231 3006 11 -167,(1 -167,(1 JJS 37231 3006 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3006 13 under under IN 37231 3006 14 Marcus Marcus NNP 37231 3006 15 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 3006 16 , , , 37231 3006 17 probably probably RB 37231 3006 18 at at IN 37231 3006 19 the the DT 37231 3006 20 instigation instigation NN 37231 3006 21 of of IN 37231 3006 22 the the DT 37231 3006 23 cynical cynical JJ 37231 3006 24 philosopher philosopher NN 37231 3006 25 , , , 37231 3006 26 Crescens Crescens NNP 37231 3006 27 , , , 37231 3006 28 was be VBD 37231 3006 29 born bear VBN 37231 3006 30 in in IN 37231 3006 31 the the DT 37231 3006 32 Greek Greek NNP 37231 3006 33 - - HYPH 37231 3006 34 Roman roman JJ 37231 3006 35 colony colony NN 37231 3006 36 , , , 37231 3006 37 Flavia Flavia NNP 37231 3006 38 Neapolis,(2 Neapolis,(2 VBD 37231 3006 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3006 40 established establish VBN 37231 3006 41 during during IN 37231 3006 42 the the DT 37231 3006 43 { { -LRB- 37231 3006 44 283 283 CD 37231 3006 45 } } -RRB- 37231 3006 46 reign reign NN 37231 3006 47 of of IN 37231 3006 48 Vespasian Vespasian NNP 37231 3006 49 , , , 37231 3006 50 near near IN 37231 3006 51 the the DT 37231 3006 52 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3006 53 Sichem Sichem NNP 37231 3006 54 in in IN 37231 3006 55 Samaria Samaria NNP 37231 3006 56 . . . 37231 3007 1 By by IN 37231 3007 2 descent descent NN 37231 3007 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3007 4 was be VBD 37231 3007 5 a a DT 37231 3007 6 Greek Greek NNP 37231 3007 7 , , , 37231 3007 8 and and CC 37231 3007 9 during during IN 37231 3007 10 the the DT 37231 3007 11 earlier early JJR 37231 3007 12 part part NN 37231 3007 13 of of IN 37231 3007 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3007 15 life life NN 37231 3007 16 a a DT 37231 3007 17 heathen heathen NN 37231 3007 18 , , , 37231 3007 19 but but CC 37231 3007 20 after after IN 37231 3007 21 long long JJ 37231 3007 22 and and CC 37231 3007 23 disappointed disappointed JJ 37231 3007 24 study study NN 37231 3007 25 of of IN 37231 3007 26 Greek greek JJ 37231 3007 27 philosophy philosophy NN 37231 3007 28 , , , 37231 3007 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3007 30 became become VBD 37231 3007 31 a a DT 37231 3007 32 convert convert NN 37231 3007 33 to to IN 37231 3007 34 Christianity(l Christianity(l NNP 37231 3007 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3007 36 strongly strongly RB 37231 3007 37 tinged tinge VBD 37231 3007 38 with with IN 37231 3007 39 Judaism Judaism NNP 37231 3007 40 . . . 37231 3008 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3008 2 is be VBZ 37231 3008 3 not not RB 37231 3008 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3008 5 to to TO 37231 3008 6 enter enter VB 37231 3008 7 into into IN 37231 3008 8 any any DT 37231 3008 9 discussion discussion NN 37231 3008 10 as as IN 37231 3008 11 to to IN 37231 3008 12 the the DT 37231 3008 13 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 3008 14 of of IN 37231 3008 15 the the DT 37231 3008 16 writings writing NNS 37231 3008 17 which which WDT 37231 3008 18 have have VBP 37231 3008 19 come come VBN 37231 3008 20 down down RP 37231 3008 21 to to IN 37231 3008 22 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3008 23 bearing bear VBG 37231 3008 24 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3008 25 's 's POS 37231 3008 26 name name NN 37231 3008 27 , , , 37231 3008 28 many many JJ 37231 3008 29 of of IN 37231 3008 30 which which WDT 37231 3008 31 are be VBP 37231 3008 32 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 37231 3008 33 spurious spurious JJ 37231 3008 34 , , , 37231 3008 35 for for IN 37231 3008 36 the the DT 37231 3008 37 two two CD 37231 3008 38 Apologies Apologies NNPS 37231 3008 39 and and CC 37231 3008 40 the the DT 37231 3008 41 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3008 42 with with IN 37231 3008 43 Trypho Trypho NNP 37231 3008 44 , , , 37231 3008 45 with with IN 37231 3008 46 which which WDT 37231 3008 47 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3008 48 have have VBP 37231 3008 49 almost almost RB 37231 3008 50 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 3008 51 to to TO 37231 3008 52 do do VB 37231 3008 53 , , , 37231 3008 54 are be VBP 37231 3008 55 generally generally RB 37231 3008 56 admitted admit VBN 37231 3008 57 to to TO 37231 3008 58 be be VB 37231 3008 59 genuine genuine JJ 37231 3008 60 . . . 37231 3009 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3009 2 is be VBZ 37231 3009 3 true true JJ 37231 3009 4 that that IN 37231 3009 5 there there EX 37231 3009 6 has have VBZ 37231 3009 7 been be VBN 37231 3009 8 a a DT 37231 3009 9 singular singular JJ 37231 3009 10 controversy controversy NN 37231 3009 11 regarding regard VBG 37231 3009 12 the the DT 37231 3009 13 precise precise JJ 37231 3009 14 relation relation NN 37231 3009 15 to to IN 37231 3009 16 each each DT 37231 3009 17 other other JJ 37231 3009 18 of of IN 37231 3009 19 the the DT 37231 3009 20 two two CD 37231 3009 21 Apologies Apologies NNPS 37231 3009 22 now now RB 37231 3009 23 extant extant JJ 37231 3009 24 , , , 37231 3009 25 the the DT 37231 3009 26 following follow VBG 37231 3009 27 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 3009 28 views view NNS 37231 3009 29 having have VBG 37231 3009 30 been be VBN 37231 3009 31 maintained maintain VBN 37231 3009 32 : : : 37231 3009 33 that that IN 37231 3009 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3009 35 are be VBP 37231 3009 36 the the DT 37231 3009 37 two two CD 37231 3009 38 Apologies Apologies NNPS 37231 3009 39 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3009 40 by by IN 37231 3009 41 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 3009 42 , , , 37231 3009 43 and and CC 37231 3009 44 in in IN 37231 3009 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3009 46 original original JJ 37231 3009 47 order order NN 37231 3009 48 ; ; : 37231 3009 49 that that IN 37231 3009 50 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3009 51 are be VBP 37231 3009 52 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3009 53 's 's POS 37231 3009 54 two two CD 37231 3009 55 Apologies Apologies NNPS 37231 3009 56 , , , 37231 3009 57 but but CC 37231 3009 58 that that IN 37231 3009 59 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 3009 60 was be VBD 37231 3009 61 wrong wrong JJ 37231 3009 62 in in IN 37231 3009 63 affirming affirming NN 37231 3009 64 that that IN 37231 3009 65 the the DT 37231 3009 66 second second JJ 37231 3009 67 was be VBD 37231 3009 68 addressed address VBN 37231 3009 69 to to IN 37231 3009 70 Marcus Marcus NNP 37231 3009 71 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 3009 72 ; ; : 37231 3009 73 that that IN 37231 3009 74 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3009 75 second second JJ 37231 3009 76 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3009 77 was be VBD 37231 3009 78 the the DT 37231 3009 79 preface preface NN 37231 3009 80 or or CC 37231 3009 81 appendix appendix NNP 37231 3009 82 to to IN 37231 3009 83 the the DT 37231 3009 84 first first JJ 37231 3009 85 , , , 37231 3009 86 and and CC 37231 3009 87 that that IN 37231 3009 88 the the DT 37231 3009 89 original original JJ 37231 3009 90 second second NN 37231 3009 91 is be VBZ 37231 3009 92 lost lose VBN 37231 3009 93 . . . 37231 3010 1 The the DT 37231 3010 2 shorter short JJR 37231 3010 3 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3010 4 contains contain VBZ 37231 3010 5 nothing nothing NN 37231 3010 6 of of IN 37231 3010 7 interest interest NN 37231 3010 8 connected connect VBN 37231 3010 9 with with IN 37231 3010 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3010 11 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 3010 12 . . . 37231 3011 1 There there EX 37231 3011 2 has have VBZ 37231 3011 3 been be VBN 37231 3011 4 much much JJ 37231 3011 5 controversy controversy NN 37231 3011 6 as as IN 37231 3011 7 to to IN 37231 3011 8 the the DT 37231 3011 9 date date NN 37231 3011 10 of of IN 37231 3011 11 the the DT 37231 3011 12 two two CD 37231 3011 13 Apologies Apologies NNPS 37231 3011 14 , , , 37231 3011 15 and and CC 37231 3011 16 much much JJ 37231 3011 17 difference difference NN 37231 3011 18 of of IN 37231 3011 19 opinion opinion NN 37231 3011 20 still still RB 37231 3011 21 exists exist VBZ 37231 3011 22 on on IN 37231 3011 23 the the DT 37231 3011 24 point point NN 37231 3011 25 . . . 37231 3012 1 Many many JJ 37231 3012 2 critics critic NNS 37231 3012 3 assign assign VBP 37231 3012 4 the the DT 37231 3012 5 larger large JJR 37231 3012 6 to to IN 37231 3012 7 about about IN 37231 3012 8 a.d a.d NNP 37231 3012 9 . . NNP 37231 3012 10 138 138 CD 37231 3012 11 - - HYPH 37231 3012 12 -140 -140 NN 37231 3012 13 , , , 37231 3012 14 and and CC 37231 3012 15 the the DT 37231 3012 16 shorter short JJR 37231 3012 17 to to IN 37231 3012 18 a.d a.d NNP 37231 3012 19 . . . 37231 3013 1 160 160 CD 37231 3013 2 - - HYPH 37231 3013 3 -161 -161 NN 37231 3013 4 . . . 37231 3014 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3014 2 2 2 LS 37231 3014 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3014 4 A a DT 37231 3014 5 passage passage NN 37231 3014 6 , , , 37231 3014 7 however however RB 37231 3014 8 , , , 37231 3014 9 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3014 10 in in IN 37231 3014 11 the the DT 37231 3014 12 longer long JJR 37231 3014 13 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3014 14 , , , 37231 3014 15 which which WDT 37231 3014 16 { { -LRB- 37231 3014 17 284 284 CD 37231 3014 18 } } -RRB- 37231 3014 19 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 3014 20 that that IN 37231 3014 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3014 22 must must MD 37231 3014 23 have have VB 37231 3014 24 been be VBN 37231 3014 25 written write VBN 37231 3014 26 about about IN 37231 3014 27 a a DT 37231 3014 28 century century NN 37231 3014 29 and and CC 37231 3014 30 a a DT 37231 3014 31 half half NN 37231 3014 32 after after IN 37231 3014 33 the the DT 37231 3014 34 commencement commencement NN 37231 3014 35 of of IN 37231 3014 36 the the DT 37231 3014 37 Christian christian JJ 37231 3014 38 era era NN 37231 3014 39 , , , 37231 3014 40 or or CC 37231 3014 41 , , , 37231 3014 42 according accord VBG 37231 3014 43 to to IN 37231 3014 44 accurate accurate JJ 37231 3014 45 reckoning reckoning NN 37231 3014 46 , , , 37231 3014 47 about about IN 37231 3014 48 a.d a.d NNP 37231 3014 49 . . NNP 37231 3014 50 147 147 CD 37231 3014 51 . . . 37231 3015 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3015 2 speaks speak VBZ 37231 3015 3 , , , 37231 3015 4 in in IN 37231 3015 5 one one CD 37231 3015 6 part part NN 37231 3015 7 of of IN 37231 3015 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3015 9 , , , 37231 3015 10 of of IN 37231 3015 11 perverted perverted JJ 37231 3015 12 deductions deduction NNS 37231 3015 13 being be VBG 37231 3015 14 drawn draw VBN 37231 3015 15 from from IN 37231 3015 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3015 17 teaching teaching NN 37231 3015 18 " " '' 37231 3015 19 that that IN 37231 3015 20 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3015 21 was be VBD 37231 3015 22 born bear VBN 37231 3015 23 150 150 CD 37231 3015 24 years year NNS 37231 3015 25 ago ago RB 37231 3015 26 under under IN 37231 3015 27 Cyrenius Cyrenius NNP 37231 3015 28 . . . 37231 3016 1 " " `` 37231 3016 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3016 3 l l NN 37231 3016 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3016 5 Those those DT 37231 3016 6 who who WP 37231 3016 7 contend contend VBP 37231 3016 8 for for IN 37231 3016 9 the the DT 37231 3016 10 earlier early JJR 37231 3016 11 date date NN 37231 3016 12 have have VBP 37231 3016 13 no no DT 37231 3016 14 stronger strong JJR 37231 3016 15 argument argument NN 37231 3016 16 against against IN 37231 3016 17 this this DT 37231 3016 18 statement statement NN 37231 3016 19 than than IN 37231 3016 20 the the DT 37231 3016 21 unsupported unsupported JJ 37231 3016 22 assertion assertion NN 37231 3016 23 , , , 37231 3016 24 that that IN 37231 3016 25 in in IN 37231 3016 26 this this DT 37231 3016 27 passage passage NN 37231 3016 28 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3016 29 merely merely RB 37231 3016 30 speaks speak VBZ 37231 3016 31 " " `` 37231 3016 32 in in IN 37231 3016 33 round round JJ 37231 3016 34 numbers number NNS 37231 3016 35 , , , 37231 3016 36 " " '' 37231 3016 37 but but CC 37231 3016 38 many many JJ 37231 3016 39 important important JJ 37231 3016 40 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3016 41 confirm confirm VBP 37231 3016 42 the the DT 37231 3016 43 date date NN 37231 3016 44 which which WDT 37231 3016 45 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3016 46 thus thus RB 37231 3016 47 gives give VBZ 37231 3016 48 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3016 49 . . . 37231 3017 1 In in IN 37231 3017 2 the the DT 37231 3017 3 superscription superscription NN 37231 3017 4 of of IN 37231 3017 5 the the DT 37231 3017 6 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3017 7 , , , 37231 3017 8 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 37231 3017 9 is be VBZ 37231 3017 10 called call VBN 37231 3017 11 " " `` 37231 3017 12 Pius Pius NNP 37231 3017 13 , , , 37231 3017 14 " " '' 37231 3017 15 a a DT 37231 3017 16 title title NN 37231 3017 17 which which WDT 37231 3017 18 was be VBD 37231 3017 19 first first RB 37231 3017 20 bestowed bestow VBN 37231 3017 21 upon upon IN 37231 3017 22 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3017 23 in in IN 37231 3017 24 the the DT 37231 3017 25 year year NN 37231 3017 26 139 139 CD 37231 3017 27 . . . 37231 3018 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3018 2 , , , 37231 3018 3 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3018 4 directly directly RB 37231 3018 5 refers refer VBZ 37231 3018 6 to to IN 37231 3018 7 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 3018 8 , , , 37231 3018 9 as as IN 37231 3018 10 a a DT 37231 3018 11 man man NN 37231 3018 12 " " `` 37231 3018 13 now now RB 37231 3018 14 living live VBG 37231 3018 15 and and CC 37231 3018 16 teaching teach VBG 37231 3018 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3018 18 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3018 19 .... .... NFP 37231 3018 20 and and CC 37231 3018 21 who who WP 37231 3018 22 has have VBZ 37231 3018 23 by by IN 37231 3018 24 the the DT 37231 3018 25 aid aid NN 37231 3018 26 of of IN 37231 3018 27 demons demon NNS 37231 3018 28 caused cause VBD 37231 3018 29 many many JJ 37231 3018 30 of of IN 37231 3018 31 all all DT 37231 3018 32 nations nation NNS 37231 3018 33 to to IN 37231 3018 34 utter utter JJ 37231 3018 35 blasphemies blasphemy NNS 37231 3018 36 , , , 37231 3018 37 " " '' 37231 3018 38 & & CC 37231 3018 39 c.(2 c.(2 NNP 37231 3018 40 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3018 41 Now now RB 37231 3018 42 the the DT 37231 3018 43 fact fact NN 37231 3018 44 has have VBZ 37231 3018 45 been be VBN 37231 3018 46 established establish VBN 37231 3018 47 that that IN 37231 3018 48 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 3018 49 did do VBD 37231 3018 50 not not RB 37231 3018 51 come come VB 37231 3018 52 to to IN 37231 3018 53 Rome Rome NNP 37231 3018 54 , , , 37231 3018 55 where where WRB 37231 3018 56 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3018 57 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3018 58 was be VBD 37231 3018 59 , , , 37231 3018 60 until until IN 37231 3018 61 a.d a.d NNP 37231 3018 62 . . NNP 37231 3018 63 139 139 CD 37231 3018 64 - - HYPH 37231 3018 65 -142,(3 -142,(3 NN 37231 3018 66 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3018 67 when when WRB 37231 3018 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3018 69 prominent prominent JJ 37231 3018 70 public public JJ 37231 3018 71 career career NN 37231 3018 72 commenced commence VBD 37231 3018 73 , , , 37231 3018 74 and and CC 37231 3018 75 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3018 76 is be VBZ 37231 3018 77 apparent apparent JJ 37231 3018 78 that that IN 37231 3018 79 the the DT 37231 3018 80 words word NNS 37231 3018 81 of of IN 37231 3018 82 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3018 83 indicate indicate VBP 37231 3018 84 a a DT 37231 3018 85 period period NN 37231 3018 86 when when WRB 37231 3018 87 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3018 88 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3018 89 had have VBD 37231 3018 90 already already RB 37231 3018 91 { { -LRB- 37231 3018 92 285 285 CD 37231 3018 93 } } -RRB- 37231 3018 94 become become VBP 37231 3018 95 widely widely RB 37231 3018 96 diffused diffused JJ 37231 3018 97 . . . 37231 3019 1 For for IN 37231 3019 2 these these DT 37231 3019 3 and and CC 37231 3019 4 many many JJ 37231 3019 5 other other JJ 37231 3019 6 strong strong JJ 37231 3019 7 reasons reason NNS 37231 3019 8 , , , 37231 3019 9 which which WDT 37231 3019 10 need need VBP 37231 3019 11 not not RB 37231 3019 12 here here RB 37231 3019 13 be be VB 37231 3019 14 detailed detail VBN 37231 3019 15 , , , 37231 3019 16 the the DT 37231 3019 17 majority majority NN 37231 3019 18 of of IN 37231 3019 19 competent competent JJ 37231 3019 20 critics critic NNS 37231 3019 21 agree agree VBP 37231 3019 22 in in IN 37231 3019 23 more more RBR 37231 3019 24 correctly correctly RB 37231 3019 25 assigning assign VBG 37231 3019 26 the the DT 37231 3019 27 first first JJ 37231 3019 28 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3019 29 to to IN 37231 3019 30 about about IN 37231 3019 31 a.d a.d NNP 37231 3019 32 . . . 37231 3020 1 147 147 CD 37231 3020 2 . . . 37231 3021 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3021 2 1 1 LS 37231 3021 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3021 4 The the DT 37231 3021 5 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3021 6 with with IN 37231 3021 7 Trypho Trypho NNP 37231 3021 8 , , , 37231 3021 9 as as IN 37231 3021 10 internal internal JJ 37231 3021 11 evidence evidence NN 37231 3021 12 shows,(2 shows,(2 NNP 37231 3021 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3021 14 was be VBD 37231 3021 15 written write VBN 37231 3021 16 after after IN 37231 3021 17 the the DT 37231 3021 18 longer long JJR 37231 3021 19 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3021 20 , , , 37231 3021 21 and and CC 37231 3021 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3021 23 is be VBZ 37231 3021 24 therefore therefore RB 37231 3021 25 generally generally RB 37231 3021 26 dated date VBN 37231 3021 27 some some DT 37231 3021 28 time time NN 37231 3021 29 within within IN 37231 3021 30 the the DT 37231 3021 31 first first JJ 37231 3021 32 decade decade NN 37231 3021 33 of of IN 37231 3021 34 the the DT 37231 3021 35 second second JJ 37231 3021 36 half half NN 37231 3021 37 of of IN 37231 3021 38 the the DT 37231 3021 39 second second JJ 37231 3021 40 century century NN 37231 3021 41 . . . 37231 3022 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3022 2 3 3 LS 37231 3022 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3022 4 In in IN 37231 3022 5 these these DT 37231 3022 6 writings writing NNS 37231 3022 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3022 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3022 9 very very RB 37231 3022 10 copiously copiously RB 37231 3022 11 from from IN 37231 3022 12 the the DT 37231 3022 13 Old Old NNP 37231 3022 14 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3022 15 , , , 37231 3022 16 and and CC 37231 3022 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3022 18 also also RB 37231 3022 19 very very RB 37231 3022 20 frequently frequently RB 37231 3022 21 refers refer VBZ 37231 3022 22 to to IN 37231 3022 23 facts fact NNS 37231 3022 24 of of IN 37231 3022 25 Christian christian JJ 37231 3022 26 history history NN 37231 3022 27 and and CC 37231 3022 28 to to IN 37231 3022 29 sayings saying NNS 37231 3022 30 of of IN 37231 3022 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3022 32 . . . 37231 3023 1 Of of IN 37231 3023 2 these these DT 37231 3023 3 references reference NNS 37231 3023 4 , , , 37231 3023 5 for for IN 37231 3023 6 instance instance NN 37231 3023 7 , , , 37231 3023 8 some some DT 37231 3023 9 fifty fifty CD 37231 3023 10 occur occur VBP 37231 3023 11 in in IN 37231 3023 12 the the DT 37231 3023 13 first first JJ 37231 3023 14 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3023 15 , , , 37231 3023 16 and and CC 37231 3023 17 upwards upward NNS 37231 3023 18 of of IN 37231 3023 19 seventy seventy CD 37231 3023 20 in in IN 37231 3023 21 the the DT 37231 3023 22 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3023 23 with with IN 37231 3023 24 Trypho Trypho NNP 37231 3023 25 , , , 37231 3023 26 a a DT 37231 3023 27 goodly goodly JJ 37231 3023 28 number number NN 37231 3023 29 , , , 37231 3023 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3023 31 will will MD 37231 3023 32 be be VB 37231 3023 33 admitted admit VBN 37231 3023 34 , , , 37231 3023 35 by by IN 37231 3023 36 means mean NNS 37231 3023 37 of of IN 37231 3023 38 which which WDT 37231 3023 39 to to TO 37231 3023 40 identify identify VB 37231 3023 41 the the DT 37231 3023 42 source source NN 37231 3023 43 from from IN 37231 3023 44 which which WDT 37231 3023 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3023 46 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3023 47 . . . 37231 3024 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3024 2 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3024 3 frequently frequently RB 37231 3024 4 and and CC 37231 3024 5 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3024 6 says say VBZ 37231 3024 7 that that IN 37231 3024 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3024 9 information information NN 37231 3024 10 and and CC 37231 3024 11 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3024 12 are be VBP 37231 3024 13 derived derive VBN 37231 3024 14 from from IN 37231 3024 15 the the DT 37231 3024 16 " " `` 37231 3024 17 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3024 18 of of IN 37231 3024 19 the the DT 37231 3024 20 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3024 21 " " '' 37231 3024 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3024 23 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3024 24 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3024 25 , , , 37231 3024 26 but but CC 37231 3024 27 except except IN 37231 3024 28 upon upon IN 37231 3024 29 one one CD 37231 3024 30 occasion occasion NN 37231 3024 31 , , , 37231 3024 32 which which WDT 37231 3024 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3024 34 shall shall MD 37231 3024 35 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 3024 36 consider consider VB 37231 3024 37 , , , 37231 3024 38 when when WRB 37231 3024 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3024 40 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 3024 41 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3024 42 , , , 37231 3024 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3024 44 never never RB 37231 3024 45 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3024 46 an an DT 37231 3024 47 author author NN 37231 3024 48 's 's POS 37231 3024 49 name name NN 37231 3024 50 . . . 37231 3025 1 Upon upon IN 37231 3025 2 examination examination NN 37231 3025 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3025 4 is be VBZ 37231 3025 5 found find VBN 37231 3025 6 that that IN 37231 3025 7 , , , 37231 3025 8 with with IN 37231 3025 9 only only RB 37231 3025 10 one one CD 37231 3025 11 or or CC 37231 3025 12 two two CD 37231 3025 13 brief brief JJ 37231 3025 14 exceptions exception NNS 37231 3025 15 , , , 37231 3025 16 the the DT 37231 3025 17 { { -LRB- 37231 3025 18 286 286 CD 37231 3025 19 } } -RRB- 37231 3025 20 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3025 21 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3025 22 from from IN 37231 3025 23 these these DT 37231 3025 24 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3025 25 differ differ VBP 37231 3025 26 more more RBR 37231 3025 27 or or CC 37231 3025 28 less less RBR 37231 3025 29 widely widely RB 37231 3025 30 from from IN 37231 3025 31 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3025 32 passages passage NNS 37231 3025 33 in in IN 37231 3025 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3025 35 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 3025 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3025 37 , , , 37231 3025 38 and and CC 37231 3025 39 in in IN 37231 3025 40 many many JJ 37231 3025 41 cases case NNS 37231 3025 42 differ differ VBP 37231 3025 43 in in IN 37231 3025 44 the the DT 37231 3025 45 same same JJ 37231 3025 46 respects respect NNS 37231 3025 47 as as IN 37231 3025 48 similar similar JJ 37231 3025 49 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3025 50 found find VBN 37231 3025 51 in in IN 37231 3025 52 other other JJ 37231 3025 53 writings writing NNS 37231 3025 54 of of IN 37231 3025 55 the the DT 37231 3025 56 second second JJ 37231 3025 57 century century NN 37231 3025 58 , , , 37231 3025 59 the the DT 37231 3025 60 writers writer NNS 37231 3025 61 of of IN 37231 3025 62 which which WDT 37231 3025 63 are be VBP 37231 3025 64 known know VBN 37231 3025 65 to to TO 37231 3025 66 have have VB 37231 3025 67 made make VBN 37231 3025 68 use use NN 37231 3025 69 of of IN 37231 3025 70 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 37231 3025 71 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3025 72 , , , 37231 3025 73 and and CC 37231 3025 74 further far RBR 37231 3025 75 , , , 37231 3025 76 that that IN 37231 3025 77 these these DT 37231 3025 78 passages passage NNS 37231 3025 79 are be VBP 37231 3025 80 quoted quote VBN 37231 3025 81 several several JJ 37231 3025 82 times time NNS 37231 3025 83 , , , 37231 3025 84 at at IN 37231 3025 85 intervals interval NNS 37231 3025 86 , , , 37231 3025 87 by by IN 37231 3025 88 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3025 89 with with IN 37231 3025 90 the the DT 37231 3025 91 same same JJ 37231 3025 92 variations variation NNS 37231 3025 93 . . . 37231 3026 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3026 2 , , , 37231 3026 3 sayings saying NNS 37231 3026 4 of of IN 37231 3026 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3026 6 are be VBP 37231 3026 7 quoted quote VBN 37231 3026 8 from from IN 37231 3026 9 these these DT 37231 3026 10 Memoirs memoir NNS 37231 3026 11 which which WDT 37231 3026 12 are be VBP 37231 3026 13 not not RB 37231 3026 14 found find VBN 37231 3026 15 in in IN 37231 3026 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3026 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3026 18 at at RB 37231 3026 19 all all RB 37231 3026 20 , , , 37231 3026 21 and and CC 37231 3026 22 facts fact NNS 37231 3026 23 in in IN 37231 3026 24 the the DT 37231 3026 25 life life NN 37231 3026 26 of of IN 37231 3026 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3026 28 and and CC 37231 3026 29 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3026 30 of of IN 37231 3026 31 Christian christian JJ 37231 3026 32 history history NN 37231 3026 33 derived derive VBN 37231 3026 34 from from IN 37231 3026 35 the the DT 37231 3026 36 same same JJ 37231 3026 37 source source NN 37231 3026 38 , , , 37231 3026 39 not not RB 37231 3026 40 only only RB 37231 3026 41 are be VBP 37231 3026 42 not not RB 37231 3026 43 found find VBN 37231 3026 44 in in IN 37231 3026 45 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3026 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3026 47 , , , 37231 3026 48 but but CC 37231 3026 49 are be VBP 37231 3026 50 in in IN 37231 3026 51 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 3026 52 with with IN 37231 3026 53 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3026 54 . . . 37231 3027 1 These these DT 37231 3027 2 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 37231 3027 3 have have VBP 37231 3027 4 , , , 37231 3027 5 as as IN 37231 3027 6 might may MD 37231 3027 7 have have VB 37231 3027 8 been be VBN 37231 3027 9 expected expect VBN 37231 3027 10 , , , 37231 3027 11 created create VBN 37231 3027 12 much much JJ 37231 3027 13 diversity diversity NN 37231 3027 14 of of IN 37231 3027 15 opinion opinion NN 37231 3027 16 regarding regard VBG 37231 3027 17 the the DT 37231 3027 18 nature nature NN 37231 3027 19 of of IN 37231 3027 20 the the DT 37231 3027 21 " " `` 37231 3027 22 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3027 23 of of IN 37231 3027 24 the the DT 37231 3027 25 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3027 26 . . . 37231 3027 27 " " '' 37231 3028 1 In in IN 37231 3028 2 the the DT 37231 3028 3 earlier early JJR 37231 3028 4 days day NNS 37231 3028 5 of of IN 37231 3028 6 New New NNP 37231 3028 7 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3028 8 criticism criticism NN 37231 3028 9 more more RBR 37231 3028 10 especially especially RB 37231 3028 11 , , , 37231 3028 12 many many JJ 37231 3028 13 of of IN 37231 3028 14 course course NN 37231 3028 15 at at IN 37231 3028 16 once once RB 37231 3028 17 identified identify VBN 37231 3028 18 the the DT 37231 3028 19 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3028 20 with with IN 37231 3028 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3028 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3028 23 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 3028 24 , , , 37231 3028 25 and and CC 37231 3028 26 the the DT 37231 3028 27 variations variation NNS 37231 3028 28 were be VBD 37231 3028 29 explained explain VBN 37231 3028 30 by by IN 37231 3028 31 conveniently conveniently RB 37231 3028 32 elastic elastic JJ 37231 3028 33 theories theory NNS 37231 3028 34 of of IN 37231 3028 35 free free JJ 37231 3028 36 quotation quotation NN 37231 3028 37 from from IN 37231 3028 38 memory memory NN 37231 3028 39 , , , 37231 3028 40 imperfect imperfect JJ 37231 3028 41 and and CC 37231 3028 42 varying varying JJ 37231 3028 43 MSS MSS NNP 37231 3028 44 . . NNP 37231 3028 45 , , , 37231 3028 46 combination combination NN 37231 3028 47 , , , 37231 3028 48 condensation condensation NN 37231 3028 49 and and CC 37231 3028 50 transposition transposition NN 37231 3028 51 of of IN 37231 3028 52 passages passage NNS 37231 3028 53 , , , 37231 3028 54 with with IN 37231 3028 55 slight slight JJ 37231 3028 56 additions addition NNS 37231 3028 57 from from IN 37231 3028 58 tradition tradition NN 37231 3028 59 , , , 37231 3028 60 or or CC 37231 3028 61 even even RB 37231 3028 62 from from IN 37231 3028 63 some some DT 37231 3028 64 other other JJ 37231 3028 65 written write VBN 37231 3028 66 source source NN 37231 3028 67 , , , 37231 3028 68 and and CC 37231 3028 69 so so RB 37231 3028 70 on on RB 37231 3028 71 . . . 37231 3029 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3029 2 1 1 LS 37231 3029 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3029 4 Others other NNS 37231 3029 5 endeavoured endeavour VBD 37231 3029 6 to to TO 37231 3029 7 explain explain VB 37231 3029 8 { { -LRB- 37231 3029 9 287 287 CD 37231 3029 10 } } -RRB- 37231 3029 11 away away RP 37231 3029 12 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 3029 13 by by IN 37231 3029 14 the the DT 37231 3029 15 supposition supposition NN 37231 3029 16 that that IN 37231 3029 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3029 18 were be VBD 37231 3029 19 a a DT 37231 3029 20 simple simple JJ 37231 3029 21 harmony harmony NN 37231 3029 22 of of IN 37231 3029 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3029 24 Gospels,(1 gospels,(1 NN 37231 3029 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3029 26 or or CC 37231 3029 27 a a DT 37231 3029 28 harmony harmony NN 37231 3029 29 of of IN 37231 3029 30 the the DT 37231 3029 31 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3029 32 , , , 37231 3029 33 with with IN 37231 3029 34 passages passage NNS 37231 3029 35 added add VBN 37231 3029 36 from from IN 37231 3029 37 some some DT 37231 3029 38 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3029 39 work work NN 37231 3029 40 . . . 37231 3030 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3030 2 2 2 LS 37231 3030 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3030 4 A a DT 37231 3030 5 much much RB 37231 3030 6 greater great JJR 37231 3030 7 number number NN 37231 3030 8 of of IN 37231 3030 9 critics critic NNS 37231 3030 10 , , , 37231 3030 11 however however RB 37231 3030 12 , , , 37231 3030 13 adopt adopt VB 37231 3030 14 the the DT 37231 3030 15 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3030 16 that that IN 37231 3030 17 , , , 37231 3030 18 along along IN 37231 3030 19 with with IN 37231 3030 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3030 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3030 22 , , , 37231 3030 23 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3030 24 made make VBD 37231 3030 25 use use NN 37231 3030 26 of of IN 37231 3030 27 one one CD 37231 3030 28 or or CC 37231 3030 29 more more JJR 37231 3030 30 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3030 31 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3030 32 , , , 37231 3030 33 and and CC 37231 3030 34 more more RBR 37231 3030 35 especially especially RB 37231 3030 36 of of IN 37231 3030 37 the the DT 37231 3030 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3030 39 according accord VBG 37231 3030 40 to to IN 37231 3030 41 the the DT 37231 3030 42 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3030 43 , , , 37231 3030 44 or or CC 37231 3030 45 according accord VBG 37231 3030 46 to to IN 37231 3030 47 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3030 48 , , , 37231 3030 49 and and CC 37231 3030 50 also also RB 37231 3030 51 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 3030 52 of of IN 37231 3030 53 tradition tradition NN 37231 3030 54 . . . 37231 3031 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3031 2 3 3 LS 37231 3031 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3031 4 Others other NNS 37231 3031 5 assert assert VBP 37231 3031 6 that that IN 37231 3031 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3031 8 made make VBD 37231 3031 9 use use NN 37231 3031 10 of of IN 37231 3031 11 a a DT 37231 3031 12 special special JJ 37231 3031 13 unknown unknown NN 37231 3031 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3031 15 , , , 37231 3031 16 or or CC 37231 3031 17 of of IN 37231 3031 18 the the DT 37231 3031 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3031 20 according accord VBG 37231 3031 21 to to IN 37231 3031 22 the the DT 37231 3031 23 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3031 24 or or CC 37231 3031 25 according accord VBG 37231 3031 26 to to IN 37231 3031 27 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3031 28 , , , 37231 3031 29 with with IN 37231 3031 30 a a DT 37231 3031 31 subsidiary subsidiary JJ 37231 3031 32 use use NN 37231 3031 33 of of IN 37231 3031 34 a a DT 37231 3031 35 version version NN 37231 3031 36 of of IN 37231 3031 37 one one CD 37231 3031 38 or or CC 37231 3031 39 two two CD 37231 3031 40 of of IN 37231 3031 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3031 42 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3031 43 to to TO 37231 3031 44 which which WDT 37231 3031 45 , , , 37231 3031 46 however however RB 37231 3031 47 , , , 37231 3031 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3031 49 did do VBD 37231 3031 50 not not RB 37231 3031 51 attach attach VB 37231 3031 52 much much JJ 37231 3031 53 importance importance NN 37231 3031 54 , , , 37231 3031 55 preferring prefer VBG 37231 3031 56 the the DT 37231 3031 57 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3031 58 work;(4 work;(4 VBN 37231 3031 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3031 60 whilst whilst IN 37231 3031 61 { { -LRB- 37231 3031 62 288 288 CD 37231 3031 63 } } -RRB- 37231 3031 64 others other NNS 37231 3031 65 have have VBP 37231 3031 66 concluded conclude VBN 37231 3031 67 that that IN 37231 3031 68 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3031 69 did do VBD 37231 3031 70 not not RB 37231 3031 71 make make VB 37231 3031 72 use use NN 37231 3031 73 of of IN 37231 3031 74 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3031 75 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3031 76 at at RB 37231 3031 77 all all RB 37231 3031 78 , , , 37231 3031 79 and and CC 37231 3031 80 that that IN 37231 3031 81 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3031 82 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3031 83 are be VBP 37231 3031 84 either either CC 37231 3031 85 from from IN 37231 3031 86 the the DT 37231 3031 87 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3031 88 according accord VBG 37231 3031 89 to to IN 37231 3031 90 the the DT 37231 3031 91 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3031 92 , , , 37231 3031 93 or or CC 37231 3031 94 according accord VBG 37231 3031 95 to to IN 37231 3031 96 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3031 97 , , , 37231 3031 98 or or CC 37231 3031 99 from from IN 37231 3031 100 some some DT 37231 3031 101 other other JJ 37231 3031 102 special special JJ 37231 3031 103 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3031 104 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3031 105 now now RB 37231 3031 106 no no RB 37231 3031 107 longer long RBR 37231 3031 108 extant extant JJ 37231 3031 109 . . . 37231 3032 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3032 2 1 1 LS 37231 3032 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3032 4 Evidence evidence NN 37231 3032 5 permitting permit VBG 37231 3032 6 of of IN 37231 3032 7 such such JJ 37231 3032 8 wide wide JJ 37231 3032 9 diversity diversity NN 37231 3032 10 of of IN 37231 3032 11 results result NNS 37231 3032 12 to to IN 37231 3032 13 serious serious JJ 37231 3032 14 and and CC 37231 3032 15 laborious laborious JJ 37231 3032 16 investigation investigation NN 37231 3032 17 of of IN 37231 3032 18 the the DT 37231 3032 19 identity identity NN 37231 3032 20 of of IN 37231 3032 21 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3032 22 's 's POS 37231 3032 23 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3032 24 of of IN 37231 3032 25 the the DT 37231 3032 26 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3032 27 , , , 37231 3032 28 can can MD 37231 3032 29 not not RB 37231 3032 30 be be VB 37231 3032 31 of of IN 37231 3032 32 much much JJ 37231 3032 33 value value NN 37231 3032 34 towards towards IN 37231 3032 35 establishing establish VBG 37231 3032 36 the the DT 37231 3032 37 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 3032 38 of of IN 37231 3032 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3032 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3032 41 , , , 37231 3032 42 and and CC 37231 3032 43 in in IN 37231 3032 44 the the DT 37231 3032 45 absence absence NN 37231 3032 46 of of IN 37231 3032 47 any any DT 37231 3032 48 specific specific JJ 37231 3032 49 mention mention NN 37231 3032 50 of of IN 37231 3032 51 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3032 52 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3032 53 any any DT 37231 3032 54 very very RB 37231 3032 55 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 3032 56 examination examination NN 37231 3032 57 of of IN 37231 3032 58 the the DT 37231 3032 59 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3032 60 might may MD 37231 3032 61 be be VB 37231 3032 62 considered consider VBN 37231 3032 63 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 3032 64 , , , 37231 3032 65 more more RBR 37231 3032 66 especially especially RB 37231 3032 67 as as IN 37231 3032 68 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3032 69 is be VBZ 37231 3032 70 admitted admit VBN 37231 3032 71 almost almost RB 37231 3032 72 universally universally RB 37231 3032 73 by by IN 37231 3032 74 competent competent JJ 37231 3032 75 critics critic NNS 37231 3032 76 , , , 37231 3032 77 that that IN 37231 3032 78 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3032 79 did do VBD 37231 3032 80 not not RB 37231 3032 81 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3032 82 consider consider VB 37231 3032 83 the the DT 37231 3032 84 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3032 85 of of IN 37231 3032 86 the the DT 37231 3032 87 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3032 88 inspired inspire VBD 37231 3032 89 , , , 37231 3032 90 or or CC 37231 3032 91 of of IN 37231 3032 92 any any DT 37231 3032 93 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 3032 94 authority authority NN 37231 3032 95 , , , 37231 3032 96 and and CC 37231 3032 97 had have VBD 37231 3032 98 no no DT 37231 3032 99 idea idea NN 37231 3032 100 of of IN 37231 3032 101 attributing attribute VBG 37231 3032 102 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3032 103 rank rank NN 37231 3032 104 to to IN 37231 3032 105 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3032 106 . . . 37231 3033 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3033 2 2 2 LS 37231 3033 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3033 4 In in IN 37231 3033 5 pursuance pursuance NN 37231 3033 6 of of IN 37231 3033 7 the the DT 37231 3033 8 system system NN 37231 3033 9 which which WDT 37231 3033 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3033 11 desire desire VBP 37231 3033 12 invariably invariably RB 37231 3033 13 to to TO 37231 3033 14 adopt adopt VB 37231 3033 15 of of IN 37231 3033 16 { { -LRB- 37231 3033 17 289 289 CD 37231 3033 18 } } -RRB- 37231 3033 19 enabling enable VBG 37231 3033 20 every every DT 37231 3033 21 reader reader NN 37231 3033 22 to to TO 37231 3033 23 form form VB 37231 3033 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3033 25 own own JJ 37231 3033 26 opinion opinion NN 37231 3033 27 , , , 37231 3033 28 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3033 29 shall shall MD 37231 3033 30 as as RB 37231 3033 31 briefly briefly RB 37231 3033 32 as as IN 37231 3033 33 possible possible JJ 37231 3033 34 state state NN 37231 3033 35 the the DT 37231 3033 36 facts fact NNS 37231 3033 37 of of IN 37231 3033 38 the the DT 37231 3033 39 case case NN 37231 3033 40 , , , 37231 3033 41 and and CC 37231 3033 42 furnish furnish JJ 37231 3033 43 materials material NNS 37231 3033 44 for for IN 37231 3033 45 a a DT 37231 3033 46 full full JJ 37231 3033 47 comprehension comprehension NN 37231 3033 48 of of IN 37231 3033 49 the the DT 37231 3033 50 subject subject NN 37231 3033 51 . . . 37231 3034 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3034 2 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3034 3 , , , 37231 3034 4 as as IN 37231 3034 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3034 6 have have VBP 37231 3034 7 already already RB 37231 3034 8 stated state VBN 37231 3034 9 , , , 37231 3034 10 frequently frequently RB 37231 3034 11 and and CC 37231 3034 12 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3034 13 states state VBZ 37231 3034 14 that that IN 37231 3034 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3034 16 information information NN 37231 3034 17 regarding regard VBG 37231 3034 18 Christian christian JJ 37231 3034 19 history history NN 37231 3034 20 and and CC 37231 3034 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3034 22 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3034 23 are be VBP 37231 3034 24 derived derive VBN 37231 3034 25 from from IN 37231 3034 26 the the DT 37231 3034 27 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3034 28 of of IN 37231 3034 29 the the DT 37231 3034 30 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3034 31 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3034 32 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3034 33 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3034 34 , , , 37231 3034 35 to to TO 37231 3034 36 adopt adopt VB 37231 3034 37 the the DT 37231 3034 38 usual usual JJ 37231 3034 39 translation translation NN 37231 3034 40 , , , 37231 3034 41 although although IN 37231 3034 42 the the DT 37231 3034 43 word word NN 37231 3034 44 might may MD 37231 3034 45 more more RBR 37231 3034 46 correctly correctly RB 37231 3034 47 be be VB 37231 3034 48 rendered render VBN 37231 3034 49 " " `` 37231 3034 50 Recollections Recollections NNPS 37231 3034 51 , , , 37231 3034 52 " " '' 37231 3034 53 or or CC 37231 3034 54 " " `` 37231 3034 55 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 37231 3034 56 . . . 37231 3034 57 " " '' 37231 3035 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3035 2 has have VBZ 37231 3035 3 frequently frequently RB 37231 3035 4 been be VBN 37231 3035 5 surmised surmise VBN 37231 3035 6 that that IN 37231 3035 7 this this DT 37231 3035 8 name name NN 37231 3035 9 was be VBD 37231 3035 10 suggested suggest VBN 37231 3035 11 by by IN 37231 3035 12 the the DT 37231 3035 13 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3035 14 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3035 15 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3035 16 of of IN 37231 3035 17 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 37231 3035 18 , , , 37231 3035 19 but but CC 37231 3035 20 , , , 37231 3035 21 as as IN 37231 3035 22 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3035 23 has have VBZ 37231 3035 24 pointed point VBN 37231 3035 25 out out RP 37231 3035 26 , , , 37231 3035 27 the the DT 37231 3035 28 similarity similarity NN 37231 3035 29 is be VBZ 37231 3035 30 purely purely RB 37231 3035 31 accidental accidental JJ 37231 3035 32 , , , 37231 3035 33 and and CC 37231 3035 34 to to TO 37231 3035 35 constitute constitute VB 37231 3035 36 a a DT 37231 3035 37 parallel parallel NN 37231 3035 38 the the DT 37231 3035 39 title title NN 37231 3035 40 should should MD 37231 3035 41 have have VB 37231 3035 42 been be VBN 37231 3035 43 " " `` 37231 3035 44 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3035 45 of of IN 37231 3035 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3035 47 . . . 37231 3036 1 " " `` 37231 3036 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3036 3 1 1 LS 37231 3036 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3036 5 The the DT 37231 3036 6 word word NN 37231 3036 7 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3036 8 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3036 9 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3036 10 is be VBZ 37231 3036 11 here here RB 37231 3036 12 evidently evidently RB 37231 3036 13 used use VBN 37231 3036 14 merely merely RB 37231 3036 15 in in IN 37231 3036 16 the the DT 37231 3036 17 sense sense NN 37231 3036 18 of of IN 37231 3036 19 records record NNS 37231 3036 20 written write VBN 37231 3036 21 from from IN 37231 3036 22 memory memory NN 37231 3036 23 , , , 37231 3036 24 and and CC 37231 3036 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3036 26 is be VBZ 37231 3036 27 so so RB 37231 3036 28 employed employ VBN 37231 3036 29 by by IN 37231 3036 30 Papias Papias NNP 37231 3036 31 in in IN 37231 3036 32 the the DT 37231 3036 33 passage passage NN 37231 3036 34 preserved preserve VBN 37231 3036 35 by by IN 37231 3036 36 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 3036 37 regarding regard VBG 37231 3036 38 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3036 39 , , , 37231 3036 40 who who WP 37231 3036 41 , , , 37231 3036 42 although although IN 37231 3036 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3036 44 had have VBD 37231 3036 45 not not RB 37231 3036 46 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3036 47 followed follow VBD 37231 3036 48 the the DT 37231 3036 49 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3036 50 , , , 37231 3036 51 yet yet RB 37231 3036 52 recorded record VBD 37231 3036 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3036 54 words word NNS 37231 3036 55 from from IN 37231 3036 56 what what WP 37231 3036 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3036 58 heard hear VBD 37231 3036 59 from from IN 37231 3036 60 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3036 61 , , , 37231 3036 62 and and CC 37231 3036 63 who who WP 37231 3036 64 , , , 37231 3036 65 having have VBG 37231 3036 66 done do VBN 37231 3036 67 so so RB 37231 3036 68 without without IN 37231 3036 69 order order NN 37231 3036 70 , , , 37231 3036 71 is be VBZ 37231 3036 72 still still RB 37231 3036 73 defended defend VBN 37231 3036 74 for for IN 37231 3036 75 " " `` 37231 3036 76 thus thus RB 37231 3036 77 writing write VBG 37231 3036 78 some some DT 37231 3036 79 things thing NNS 37231 3036 80 as as IN 37231 3036 81 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3036 82 remembered remember VBD 37231 3036 83 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3036 84 " " `` 37231 3036 85 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3036 86 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3036 87 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3036 88 . . . 37231 3037 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3037 2 2 2 LS 37231 3037 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3037 4 In in IN 37231 3037 5 the the DT 37231 3037 6 same same JJ 37231 3037 7 way way NN 37231 3037 8 Irenseus Irenseus NNP 37231 3037 9 refers refer VBZ 37231 3037 10 to to IN 37231 3037 11 the the DT 37231 3037 12 " " `` 37231 3037 13 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3037 14 of of IN 37231 3037 15 a a DT 37231 3037 16 certain certain JJ 37231 3037 17 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 3037 18 of of IN 37231 3037 19 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 3037 20 times times NNP 37231 3037 21 " " '' 37231 3037 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3037 23 --Greek--](3 --Greek--](3 NNP 37231 3037 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3037 25 whose whose WP$ 37231 3037 26 name name NN 37231 3037 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3037 28 does do VBZ 37231 3037 29 not not RB 37231 3037 30 mention mention VB 37231 3037 31 ; ; : 37231 3037 32 and and CC 37231 3037 33 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3037 34 still still RB 37231 3037 35 more more RBR 37231 3037 36 closely closely RB 37231 3037 37 approximates approximate NNS 37231 3037 38 to to IN 37231 3037 39 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3037 40 's 's POS 37231 3037 41 use use NN 37231 3037 42 of of IN 37231 3037 43 the the DT 37231 3037 44 word word NN 37231 3037 45 when when WRB 37231 3037 46 , , , 37231 3037 47 expressing express VBG 37231 3037 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3037 49 theory theory NN 37231 3037 50 regarding regard VBG 37231 3037 51 , , , 37231 3037 52 the the DT 37231 3037 53 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3037 54 to to IN 37231 3037 55 the the DT 37231 3037 56 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3037 57 , , , 37231 3037 58 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3037 59 says say VBZ 37231 3037 60 that that IN 37231 3037 61 the the DT 37231 3037 62 thoughts thought NNS 37231 3037 63 are be VBP 37231 3037 64 the the DT 37231 3037 65 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 3037 66 's 's POS 37231 3037 67 , , , 37231 3037 68 but but CC 37231 3037 69 the the DT 37231 3037 70 phraseology phraseology NN 37231 3037 71 and and CC 37231 3037 72 the the DT 37231 3037 73 composition composition NN 37231 3037 74 are be VBP 37231 3037 75 of of IN 37231 3037 76 one one CD 37231 3037 77 recording recording NN 37231 3037 78 from from IN 37231 3037 79 memory memory NN 37231 3037 80 { { -LRB- 37231 3037 81 290 290 CD 37231 3037 82 } } -RRB- 37231 3037 83 what what WP 37231 3037 84 the the DT 37231 3037 85 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 3037 86 said say VBD 37231 3037 87 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3037 88 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3037 89 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3037 90 , , , 37231 3037 91 and and CC 37231 3037 92 as as IN 37231 3037 93 of of IN 37231 3037 94 one one CD 37231 3037 95 writing writing NN 37231 3037 96 at at IN 37231 3037 97 leisure leisure NN 37231 3037 98 the the DT 37231 3037 99 dictation dictation NN 37231 3037 100 of of IN 37231 3037 101 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3037 102 master master NN 37231 3037 103 . . . 37231 3038 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3038 2 1 1 LS 37231 3038 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3038 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3038 5 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3038 6 speaks speak VBZ 37231 3038 7 of of IN 37231 3038 8 the the DT 37231 3038 9 authors author NNS 37231 3038 10 of of IN 37231 3038 11 the the DT 37231 3038 12 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3038 13 as as IN 37231 3038 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3038 15 --Greek--],(2 --Greek--],(2 NFP 37231 3038 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3038 17 and and CC 37231 3038 18 the the DT 37231 3038 19 expression expression NN 37231 3038 20 was be VBD 37231 3038 21 then then RB 37231 3038 22 and and CC 37231 3038 23 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 3038 24 constantly constantly RB 37231 3038 25 in in IN 37231 3038 26 use use NN 37231 3038 27 amongst amongst IN 37231 3038 28 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 3038 29 and and CC 37231 3038 30 other other JJ 37231 3038 31 writers writer NNS 37231 3038 32 . . . 37231 3039 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3039 2 3 3 LS 37231 3039 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3039 4 This this DT 37231 3039 5 title title NN 37231 3039 6 , , , 37231 3039 7 " " `` 37231 3039 8 Memoirs memoir NNS 37231 3039 9 of of IN 37231 3039 10 the the DT 37231 3039 11 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3039 12 , , , 37231 3039 13 " " '' 37231 3039 14 however however RB 37231 3039 15 , , , 37231 3039 16 although although IN 37231 3039 17 most most RBS 37231 3039 18 appropriate appropriate JJ 37231 3039 19 to to IN 37231 3039 20 mere mere JJ 37231 3039 21 recollections recollection NNS 37231 3039 22 of of IN 37231 3039 23 the the DT 37231 3039 24 life life NN 37231 3039 25 and and CC 37231 3039 26 teaching teaching NN 37231 3039 27 of of IN 37231 3039 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3039 29 , , , 37231 3039 30 evidently evidently RB 37231 3039 31 could could MD 37231 3039 32 not not RB 37231 3039 33 be be VB 37231 3039 34 applied apply VBN 37231 3039 35 to to IN 37231 3039 36 works work NNS 37231 3039 37 ranking rank VBG 37231 3039 38 as as IN 37231 3039 39 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3039 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3039 41 , , , 37231 3039 42 but but CC 37231 3039 43 in in IN 37231 3039 44 fact fact NN 37231 3039 45 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3039 46 such such PDT 37231 3039 47 an an DT 37231 3039 48 idea idea NN 37231 3039 49 ; ; : 37231 3039 50 and and CC 37231 3039 51 the the DT 37231 3039 52 whole whole NN 37231 3039 53 of of IN 37231 3039 54 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3039 55 's 's POS 37231 3039 56 views view NNS 37231 3039 57 regarding regard VBG 37231 3039 58 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3039 59 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 3039 60 , , , 37231 3039 61 prove prove VB 37231 3039 62 that that IN 37231 3039 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3039 64 saw see VBD 37231 3039 65 in in IN 37231 3039 66 the the DT 37231 3039 67 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3039 68 merely merely RB 37231 3039 69 records record VBZ 37231 3039 70 from from IN 37231 3039 71 memory memory NN 37231 3039 72 to to TO 37231 3039 73 assist assist VB 37231 3039 74 memory memory NN 37231 3039 75 . . . 37231 3040 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3040 2 4 4 LS 37231 3040 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3040 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3040 5 does do VBZ 37231 3040 6 not not RB 37231 3040 7 call call VB 37231 3040 8 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3040 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3040 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3040 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3040 12 , , , 37231 3040 13 but but CC 37231 3040 14 adheres adhere VBZ 37231 3040 15 always always RB 37231 3040 16 to to IN 37231 3040 17 the the DT 37231 3040 18 familiar familiar JJ 37231 3040 19 name name NN 37231 3040 20 of of IN 37231 3040 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3040 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3040 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3040 24 , , , 37231 3040 25 and and CC 37231 3040 26 whilst whilst IN 37231 3040 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3040 28 constant constant JJ 37231 3040 29 appeals appeal NNS 37231 3040 30 to to IN 37231 3040 31 a a DT 37231 3040 32 written write VBN 37231 3040 33 source source NN 37231 3040 34 show show NN 37231 3040 35 very very RB 37231 3040 36 clearly clearly RB 37231 3040 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3040 38 abandonment abandonment NN 37231 3040 39 of of IN 37231 3040 40 oral oral JJ 37231 3040 41 tradition tradition NN 37231 3040 42 , , , 37231 3040 43 there there EX 37231 3040 44 is be VBZ 37231 3040 45 nothing nothing NN 37231 3040 46 in in IN 37231 3040 47 the the DT 37231 3040 48 name name NN 37231 3040 49 of of IN 37231 3040 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3040 51 records record NNS 37231 3040 52 which which WDT 37231 3040 53 can can MD 37231 3040 54 identify identify VB 37231 3040 55 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3040 56 with with IN 37231 3040 57 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3040 58 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3040 59 . . . 37231 3041 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3041 2 designates designate VBZ 37231 3041 3 the the DT 37231 3041 4 source source NN 37231 3041 5 of of IN 37231 3041 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3041 7 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3041 8 ten ten CD 37231 3041 9 times time NNS 37231 3041 10 , , , 37231 3041 11 the the DT 37231 3041 12 " " `` 37231 3041 13 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3041 14 of of IN 37231 3041 15 the the DT 37231 3041 16 Apostles,"(5 apostles,"(5 NN 37231 3041 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3041 18 and and CC 37231 3041 19 five five CD 37231 3041 20 times time NNS 37231 3041 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3041 22 calls call VBZ 37231 3041 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3041 24 simply simply RB 37231 3041 25 the the DT 37231 3041 26 " " `` 37231 3041 27 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3041 28 . . . 37231 3042 1 " " `` 37231 3042 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3042 3 6 6 CD 37231 3042 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3042 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3042 6 says say VBZ 37231 3042 7 , , , 37231 3042 8 upon upon IN 37231 3042 9 one one CD 37231 3042 10 occasion occasion NN 37231 3042 11 , , , 37231 3042 12 that that IN 37231 3042 13 these these DT 37231 3042 14 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3042 15 were be VBD 37231 3042 16 composed compose VBN 37231 3042 17 " " '' 37231 3042 18 by by IN 37231 3042 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3042 20 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3042 21 and and CC 37231 3042 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3042 23 followers,"(7 followers,"(7 ADD 37231 3042 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3042 25 but but CC 37231 3042 26 except except IN 37231 3042 27 in in IN 37231 3042 28 one one CD 37231 3042 29 place place NN 37231 3042 30 , , , 37231 3042 31 { { -LRB- 37231 3042 32 291 291 CD 37231 3042 33 } } -RRB- 37231 3042 34 to to TO 37231 3042 35 which which WDT 37231 3042 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3042 37 have have VBP 37231 3042 38 already already RB 37231 3042 39 referred refer VBN 37231 3042 40 , , , 37231 3042 41 and and CC 37231 3042 42 which which WDT 37231 3042 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3042 44 shall shall MD 37231 3042 45 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 3042 46 fully fully RB 37231 3042 47 examine examine VB 37231 3042 48 , , , 37231 3042 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3042 50 never never RB 37231 3042 51 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3042 52 the the DT 37231 3042 53 author author NN 37231 3042 54 's 's POS 37231 3042 55 name name NN 37231 3042 56 , , , 37231 3042 57 nor nor CC 37231 3042 58 does do VBZ 37231 3042 59 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3042 60 ever ever RB 37231 3042 61 give give VB 37231 3042 62 any any DT 37231 3042 63 more more RBR 37231 3042 64 precise precise JJ 37231 3042 65 information information NN 37231 3042 66 regarding regard VBG 37231 3042 67 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3042 68 composition composition NN 37231 3042 69 . . . 37231 3043 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3043 2 has have VBZ 37231 3043 3 been be VBN 37231 3043 4 argued argue VBN 37231 3043 5 that that IN 37231 3043 6 , , , 37231 3043 7 in in IN 37231 3043 8 saying say VBG 37231 3043 9 that that IN 37231 3043 10 these these DT 37231 3043 11 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3043 12 were be VBD 37231 3043 13 recorded record VBN 37231 3043 14 by by IN 37231 3043 15 the the DT 37231 3043 16 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3043 17 and and CC 37231 3043 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3043 19 followers follower NNS 37231 3043 20 , , , 37231 3043 21 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3043 22 intentionally intentionally RB 37231 3043 23 and and CC 37231 3043 24 literally literally RB 37231 3043 25 described describe VBD 37231 3043 26 the the DT 37231 3043 27 four four CD 37231 3043 28 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3043 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3043 30 , , , 37231 3043 31 the the DT 37231 3043 32 first first JJ 37231 3043 33 and and CC 37231 3043 34 fourth fourth JJ 37231 3043 35 of of IN 37231 3043 36 which which WDT 37231 3043 37 are be VBP 37231 3043 38 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 3043 39 to to IN 37231 3043 40 Apostles Apostles NNP 37231 3043 41 , , , 37231 3043 42 and and CC 37231 3043 43 the the DT 37231 3043 44 other other JJ 37231 3043 45 two two CD 37231 3043 46 to to IN 37231 3043 47 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3043 48 and and CC 37231 3043 49 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3043 50 , , , 37231 3043 51 the the DT 37231 3043 52 followers follower NNS 37231 3043 53 of of IN 37231 3043 54 Apostles;(1 Apostles;(1 NNP 37231 3043 55 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3043 56 but but CC 37231 3043 57 such such PDT 37231 3043 58 an an DT 37231 3043 59 inference inference NN 37231 3043 60 is be VBZ 37231 3043 61 equally equally RB 37231 3043 62 forced force VBN 37231 3043 63 and and CC 37231 3043 64 unfounded unfounded JJ 37231 3043 65 . . . 37231 3044 1 The the DT 37231 3044 2 language language NN 37231 3044 3 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3044 4 forbids forbid VBZ 37231 3044 5 this this DT 37231 3044 6 explanation explanation NN 37231 3044 7 , , , 37231 3044 8 for for IN 37231 3044 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3044 10 does do VBZ 37231 3044 11 not not RB 37231 3044 12 speak speak VB 37231 3044 13 indefinitely indefinitely RB 37231 3044 14 of of IN 37231 3044 15 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3044 16 of of IN 37231 3044 17 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3044 18 and and CC 37231 3044 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3044 20 followers follower NNS 37231 3044 21 , , , 37231 3044 22 but but CC 37231 3044 23 of of IN 37231 3044 24 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3044 25 of of IN 37231 3044 26 the the DT 37231 3044 27 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3044 28 , , , 37231 3044 29 invariably invariably RB 37231 3044 30 using use VBG 37231 3044 31 the the DT 37231 3044 32 article article NN 37231 3044 33 , , , 37231 3044 34 which which WDT 37231 3044 35 refers refer VBZ 37231 3044 36 the the DT 37231 3044 37 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3044 38 to to IN 37231 3044 39 the the DT 37231 3044 40 collective collective JJ 37231 3044 41 body body NN 37231 3044 42 of of IN 37231 3044 43 the the DT 37231 3044 44 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3044 45 . . . 37231 3045 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3045 2 2 2 LS 37231 3045 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3045 4 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3045 5 , , , 37231 3045 6 the the DT 37231 3045 7 incorrectness incorrectness NN 37231 3045 8 of of IN 37231 3045 9 such such PDT 37231 3045 10 an an DT 37231 3045 11 inference inference NN 37231 3045 12 is be VBZ 37231 3045 13 manifest manif JJS 37231 3045 14 from from IN 37231 3045 15 the the DT 37231 3045 16 fact fact NN 37231 3045 17 that that IN 37231 3045 18 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3045 19 are be VBP 37231 3045 20 stated state VBN 37231 3045 21 by by IN 37231 3045 22 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3045 23 as as IN 37231 3045 24 derived derive VBN 37231 3045 25 from from IN 37231 3045 26 these these DT 37231 3045 27 Memoirs memoir NNS 37231 3045 28 , , , 37231 3045 29 which which WDT 37231 3045 30 do do VBP 37231 3045 31 not not RB 37231 3045 32 exist exist VB 37231 3045 33 in in IN 37231 3045 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3045 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3045 36 at at RB 37231 3045 37 all all RB 37231 3045 38 , , , 37231 3045 39 and and CC 37231 3045 40 which which WDT 37231 3045 41 , , , 37231 3045 42 indeed indeed RB 37231 3045 43 , , , 37231 3045 44 are be VBP 37231 3045 45 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 3045 46 to to IN 37231 3045 47 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3045 48 . . . 37231 3046 1 Vast vast JJ 37231 3046 2 numbers number NNS 37231 3046 3 of of IN 37231 3046 4 spurious spurious JJ 37231 3046 5 writings writing NNS 37231 3046 6 , , , 37231 3046 7 moreover moreover RB 37231 3046 8 , , , 37231 3046 9 bearing bear VBG 37231 3046 10 the the DT 37231 3046 11 names name NNS 37231 3046 12 of of IN 37231 3046 13 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3046 14 and and CC 37231 3046 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3046 16 followers follower NNS 37231 3046 17 , , , 37231 3046 18 and and CC 37231 3046 19 claiming claim VBG 37231 3046 20 more more RBR 37231 3046 21 or or CC 37231 3046 22 less less RBR 37231 3046 23 direct direct JJ 37231 3046 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 3046 25 authority authority NNP 37231 3046 26 , , , 37231 3046 27 were be VBD 37231 3046 28 in in IN 37231 3046 29 circulation circulation NN 37231 3046 30 in in IN 37231 3046 31 the the DT 37231 3046 32 early early JJ 37231 3046 33 Church church NN 37231 3046 34 : : : 37231 3046 35 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3046 36 according accord VBG 37231 3046 37 to to IN 37231 3046 38 Peter,(3 peter,(3 NN 37231 3046 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 40 to to IN 37231 3046 41 Thomas,(4 Thomas,(4 NNP 37231 3046 42 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 43 to to IN 37231 3046 44 James,(5 James,(5 NNP 37231 3046 45 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 46 to to IN 37231 3046 47 Judas,(6 Judas,(6 NNP 37231 3046 48 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 49 according accord VBG 37231 3046 50 to to IN 37231 3046 51 the the DT 37231 3046 52 { { -LRB- 37231 3046 53 292 292 CD 37231 3046 54 } } -RRB- 37231 3046 55 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3046 56 , , , 37231 3046 57 or or CC 37231 3046 58 according accord VBG 37231 3046 59 to to IN 37231 3046 60 the the DT 37231 3046 61 Twelve,(1 twelve,(1 NN 37231 3046 62 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 63 to to IN 37231 3046 64 Barnabas,(2 barnabas,(2 DT 37231 3046 65 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 66 to to TO 37231 3046 67 Matthias,(3 Matthias,(3 NNP 37231 3046 68 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 69 to to IN 37231 3046 70 Nicodemus,(4 Nicodemus,(4 NNP 37231 3046 71 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3046 72 & & CC 37231 3046 73 c. c. NNP 37231 3046 74 , , , 37231 3046 75 and and CC 37231 3046 76 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 3046 77 writers writer NNS 37231 3046 78 bear bear VBP 37231 3046 79 abundant abundant JJ 37231 3046 80 testimony testimony NN 37231 3046 81 to to IN 37231 3046 82 the the DT 37231 3046 83 early early JJ 37231 3046 84 and and CC 37231 3046 85 rapid rapid JJ 37231 3046 86 growth growth NN 37231 3046 87 of of IN 37231 3046 88 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3046 89 literature literature NN 37231 3046 90 . . . 37231 3047 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3047 2 5 5 LS 37231 3047 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3047 4 The the DT 37231 3047 5 very very JJ 37231 3047 6 names name NNS 37231 3047 7 of of IN 37231 3047 8 most most JJS 37231 3047 9 of of IN 37231 3047 10 such such JJ 37231 3047 11 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3047 12 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3047 13 are be VBP 37231 3047 14 lost lose VBN 37231 3047 15 , , , 37231 3047 16 whilst whilst IN 37231 3047 17 of of IN 37231 3047 18 others other NNS 37231 3047 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3047 20 possess possess VBP 37231 3047 21 considerable considerable JJ 37231 3047 22 information information NN 37231 3047 23 ; ; : 37231 3047 24 but but CC 37231 3047 25 nothing nothing NN 37231 3047 26 is be VBZ 37231 3047 27 more more RBR 37231 3047 28 certain certain JJ 37231 3047 29 than than IN 37231 3047 30 the the DT 37231 3047 31 fact fact NN 37231 3047 32 , , , 37231 3047 33 that that IN 37231 3047 34 there there EX 37231 3047 35 existed exist VBD 37231 3047 36 many many JJ 37231 3047 37 works work NNS 37231 3047 38 bearing bear VBG 37231 3047 39 names name NNS 37231 3047 40 which which WDT 37231 3047 41 render render VBP 37231 3047 42 the the DT 37231 3047 43 attempt attempt NN 37231 3047 44 to to TO 37231 3047 45 interpret interpret VB 37231 3047 46 the the DT 37231 3047 47 title title NN 37231 3047 48 of of IN 37231 3047 49 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3047 50 's 's POS 37231 3047 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3047 52 as as IN 37231 3047 53 a a DT 37231 3047 54 description description NN 37231 3047 55 of of IN 37231 3047 56 the the DT 37231 3047 57 four four CD 37231 3047 58 in in IN 37231 3047 59 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3047 60 canon canon NN 37231 3047 61 quite quite RB 37231 3047 62 unwarrantable unwarrantable JJ 37231 3047 63 . . . 37231 3048 1 The the DT 37231 3048 2 words word NNS 37231 3048 3 of of IN 37231 3048 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3048 5 evidently evidently RB 37231 3048 6 imply imply VBP 37231 3048 7 simply simply RB 37231 3048 8 that that IN 37231 3048 9 the the DT 37231 3048 10 source source NN 37231 3048 11 of of IN 37231 3048 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3048 13 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3048 14 is be VBZ 37231 3048 15 the the DT 37231 3048 16 collective collective JJ 37231 3048 17 recollections recollection NNS 37231 3048 18 of of IN 37231 3048 19 the the DT 37231 3048 20 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3048 21 , , , 37231 3048 22 and and CC 37231 3048 23 those those DT 37231 3048 24 who who WP 37231 3048 25 followed follow VBD 37231 3048 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3048 27 , , , 37231 3048 28 regarding regard VBG 37231 3048 29 the the DT 37231 3048 30 life life NN 37231 3048 31 and and CC 37231 3048 32 teaching teaching NN 37231 3048 33 of of IN 37231 3048 34 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3048 35 . . . 37231 3049 1 The the DT 37231 3049 2 title title NN 37231 3049 3 : : : 37231 3049 4 " " `` 37231 3049 5 Memoirs memoir NNS 37231 3049 6 of of IN 37231 3049 7 the the DT 37231 3049 8 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3049 9 " " '' 37231 3049 10 by by IN 37231 3049 11 no no DT 37231 3049 12 means means NN 37231 3049 13 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 3049 14 a a DT 37231 3049 15 plurality plurality NN 37231 3049 16 of of IN 37231 3049 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3049 18 . . . 37231 3050 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3050 2 6 6 LS 37231 3050 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3050 4 A a DT 37231 3050 5 single single JJ 37231 3050 6 passage passage NN 37231 3050 7 has have VBZ 37231 3050 8 been be VBN 37231 3050 9 pointed point VBN 37231 3050 10 out out RP 37231 3050 11 , , , 37231 3050 12 in in IN 37231 3050 13 which which WDT 37231 3050 14 the the DT 37231 3050 15 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3050 16 are be VBP 37231 3050 17 said say VBN 37231 3050 18 to to TO 37231 3050 19 have have VB 37231 3050 20 been be VBN 37231 3050 21 called call VBN 37231 3050 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3050 23 --Greek-- --Greek-- -RRB- 37231 3050 24 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3050 25 in in IN 37231 3050 26 the the DT 37231 3050 27 plural plural NN 37231 3050 28 : : : 37231 3050 29 " " `` 37231 3050 30 For for IN 37231 3050 31 the the DT 37231 3050 32 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3050 33 in in IN 37231 3050 34 the the DT 37231 3050 35 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3050 36 composed compose VBN 37231 3050 37 by by IN 37231 3050 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3050 39 , , , 37231 3050 40 which which WDT 37231 3050 41 are be VBP 37231 3050 42 called call VBN 37231 3050 43 { { -LRB- 37231 3050 44 293 293 CD 37231 3050 45 } } -RRB- 37231 3050 46 Gospels,"(1 Gospels,"(1 NNP 37231 3050 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3050 48 & & CC 37231 3050 49 c. c. NNP 37231 3050 50 The the DT 37231 3050 51 last last JJ 37231 3050 52 expression expression NN 37231 3050 53 , , , 37231 3050 54 a a DT 37231 3050 55 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3050 56 --Greek-- --Greek-- HYPH 37231 3050 57 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3050 58 , , , 37231 3050 59 as as IN 37231 3050 60 many many JJ 37231 3050 61 scholars scholar NNS 37231 3050 62 have have VBP 37231 3050 63 declared declare VBN 37231 3050 64 , , , 37231 3050 65 is be VBZ 37231 3050 66 probably probably RB 37231 3050 67 an an DT 37231 3050 68 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 3050 69 . . . 37231 3051 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3051 2 is be VBZ 37231 3051 3 , , , 37231 3051 4 in in IN 37231 3051 5 all all DT 37231 3051 6 likelihood likelihood NN 37231 3051 7 , , , 37231 3051 8 a a DT 37231 3051 9 gloss gloss NN 37231 3051 10 on on IN 37231 3051 11 the the DT 37231 3051 12 margin margin NN 37231 3051 13 of of IN 37231 3051 14 some some DT 37231 3051 15 old old JJ 37231 3051 16 MS MS NNP 37231 3051 17 . . . 37231 3051 18 which which WDT 37231 3051 19 some some DT 37231 3051 20 copyist copyist VBP 37231 3051 21 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 3051 22 inserted insert VBN 37231 3051 23 in in IN 37231 3051 24 the the DT 37231 3051 25 text text NN 37231 3051 26 . . . 37231 3052 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3052 2 2 2 LS 37231 3052 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3052 4 If if IN 37231 3052 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3052 6 really really RB 37231 3052 7 stated state VBD 37231 3052 8 that that IN 37231 3052 9 the the DT 37231 3052 10 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3052 11 were be VBD 37231 3052 12 called call VBN 37231 3052 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3052 14 , , , 37231 3052 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3052 16 seems seem VBZ 37231 3052 17 incomprehensible incomprehensible JJ 37231 3052 18 that that IN 37231 3052 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3052 20 should should MD 37231 3052 21 never never RB 37231 3052 22 call call VB 37231 3052 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3052 24 so so IN 37231 3052 25 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3052 26 . . . 37231 3053 1 In in IN 37231 3053 2 no no DT 37231 3053 3 other other JJ 37231 3053 4 place place NN 37231 3053 5 in in IN 37231 3053 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3053 7 writings writing NNS 37231 3053 8 does do VBZ 37231 3053 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3053 10 apply apply VB 37231 3053 11 the the DT 37231 3053 12 plural plural NN 37231 3053 13 to to IN 37231 3053 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3053 15 , , , 37231 3053 16 but but CC 37231 3053 17 , , , 37231 3053 18 on on IN 37231 3053 19 the the DT 37231 3053 20 contrary contrary NN 37231 3053 21 , , , 37231 3053 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3053 23 find find VBP 37231 3053 24 Trypho Trypho NNP 37231 3053 25 referring refer VBG 37231 3053 26 to to IN 37231 3053 27 the the DT 37231 3053 28 " " `` 37231 3053 29 so so RB 37231 3053 30 - - HYPH 37231 3053 31 called call VBN 37231 3053 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3053 33 , , , 37231 3053 34 " " '' 37231 3053 35 which which WDT 37231 3053 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3053 37 states state VBZ 37231 3053 38 that that IN 37231 3053 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3053 40 has have VBZ 37231 3053 41 carefully carefully RB 37231 3053 42 read,(3 read,(3 JJ 37231 3053 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3053 44 and and CC 37231 3053 45 which which WDT 37231 3053 46 , , , 37231 3053 47 of of IN 37231 3053 48 course course NN 37231 3053 49 , , , 37231 3053 50 can can MD 37231 3053 51 only only RB 37231 3053 52 be be VB 37231 3053 53 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3053 54 's 's POS 37231 3053 55 " " `` 37231 3053 56 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3053 57 ; ; : 37231 3053 58 " " '' 37231 3053 59 and and CC 37231 3053 60 again again RB 37231 3053 61 , , , 37231 3053 62 in in IN 37231 3053 63 another another DT 37231 3053 64 part part NN 37231 3053 65 of of IN 37231 3053 66 the the DT 37231 3053 67 same same JJ 37231 3053 68 dialogue dialogue NN 37231 3053 69 , , , 37231 3053 70 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3053 71 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3053 72 passages passage NNS 37231 3053 73 which which WDT 37231 3053 74 are be VBP 37231 3053 75 written write VBN 37231 3053 76 " " '' 37231 3053 77 in in IN 37231 3053 78 the the DT 37231 3053 79 Gospel"(4 Gospel"(4 NNP 37231 3053 80 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3053 81 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3053 82 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3053 83 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3053 84 . . . 37231 3054 1 The the DT 37231 3054 2 term term NN 37231 3054 3 " " `` 37231 3054 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3054 5 " " '' 37231 3054 6 is be VBZ 37231 3054 7 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 3054 8 else else RB 37231 3054 9 used use VBN 37231 3054 10 by by IN 37231 3054 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3054 12 in in IN 37231 3054 13 reference reference NN 37231 3054 14 to to IN 37231 3054 15 a a DT 37231 3054 16 written write VBN 37231 3054 17 record record NN 37231 3054 18 . . . 37231 3055 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3055 2 5 5 LS 37231 3055 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3055 4 In in IN 37231 3055 5 no no DT 37231 3055 6 case case NN 37231 3055 7 , , , 37231 3055 8 however however RB 37231 3055 9 , , , 37231 3055 10 considering consider VBG 37231 3055 11 the the DT 37231 3055 12 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3055 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3055 14 then then RB 37231 3055 15 in in IN 37231 3055 16 circulation circulation NN 37231 3055 17 , , , 37231 3055 18 and and CC 37231 3055 19 the the DT 37231 3055 20 fact fact NN 37231 3055 21 that that IN 37231 3055 22 many many JJ 37231 3055 23 of of IN 37231 3055 24 these these DT 37231 3055 25 , , , 37231 3055 26 different different JJ 37231 3055 27 from from IN 37231 3055 28 the the DT 37231 3055 29 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3055 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3055 31 , , , 37231 3055 32 are be VBP 37231 3055 33 known know VBN 37231 3055 34 to to TO 37231 3055 35 have have VB 37231 3055 36 been be VBN 37231 3055 37 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 3055 38 used use VBN 37231 3055 39 by by IN 37231 3055 40 distinguished distinguished JJ 37231 3055 41 contemporaries contemporary NNS 37231 3055 42 of of IN 37231 3055 43 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3055 44 , , , 37231 3055 45 and and CC 37231 3055 46 by by IN 37231 3055 47 various various JJ 37231 3055 48 communities community NNS 37231 3055 49 of of IN 37231 3055 50 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3055 51 in in IN 37231 3055 52 that that DT 37231 3055 53 day day NN 37231 3055 54 , , , 37231 3055 55 could could MD 37231 3055 56 such such PDT 37231 3055 57 an an DT 37231 3055 58 expression expression NN 37231 3055 59 be be VB 37231 3055 60 taken take VBN 37231 3055 61 as as IN 37231 3055 62 a a DT 37231 3055 63 special special JJ 37231 3055 64 indication indication NN 37231 3055 65 of of IN 37231 3055 66 the the DT 37231 3055 67 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3055 68 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3055 69 . . . 37231 3056 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3056 2 6 6 CD 37231 3056 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3056 4 { { -LRB- 37231 3056 5 294 294 CD 37231 3056 6 } } -RRB- 37231 3056 7 Describing describe VBG 37231 3056 8 the the DT 37231 3056 9 religious religious JJ 37231 3056 10 practices practice NNS 37231 3056 11 amongst amongst IN 37231 3056 12 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3056 13 , , , 37231 3056 14 in in IN 37231 3056 15 another another DT 37231 3056 16 place place NN 37231 3056 17 , , , 37231 3056 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3056 19 states state VBZ 37231 3056 20 that that IN 37231 3056 21 , , , 37231 3056 22 at at IN 37231 3056 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3056 24 assemblies assembly NNS 37231 3056 25 on on IN 37231 3056 26 Sundays sunday NNS 37231 3056 27 , , , 37231 3056 28 " " '' 37231 3056 29 the the DT 37231 3056 30 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3056 31 of of IN 37231 3056 32 the the DT 37231 3056 33 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3056 34 or or CC 37231 3056 35 the the DT 37231 3056 36 writings writing NNS 37231 3056 37 of of IN 37231 3056 38 the the DT 37231 3056 39 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3056 40 are be VBP 37231 3056 41 read read VBN 37231 3056 42 as as RB 37231 3056 43 long long RB 37231 3056 44 as as IN 37231 3056 45 time time NN 37231 3056 46 permits permit NNS 37231 3056 47 . . . 37231 3057 1 " " `` 37231 3057 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3057 3 1 1 CD 37231 3057 4 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3057 5 This this DT 37231 3057 6 , , , 37231 3057 7 however however RB 37231 3057 8 , , , 37231 3057 9 by by IN 37231 3057 10 no no DT 37231 3057 11 means means NN 37231 3057 12 identifies identify VBZ 37231 3057 13 the the DT 37231 3057 14 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3057 15 with with IN 37231 3057 16 the the DT 37231 3057 17 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3057 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3057 19 , , , 37231 3057 20 for for IN 37231 3057 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3057 22 is be VBZ 37231 3057 23 well well RB 37231 3057 24 known know VBN 37231 3057 25 that that IN 37231 3057 26 many many JJ 37231 3057 27 writings writing NNS 37231 3057 28 which which WDT 37231 3057 29 have have VBP 37231 3057 30 been be VBN 37231 3057 31 excluded exclude VBN 37231 3057 32 from from IN 37231 3057 33 the the DT 37231 3057 34 canon canon NN 37231 3057 35 were be VBD 37231 3057 36 publicly publicly RB 37231 3057 37 read read VBN 37231 3057 38 in in IN 37231 3057 39 the the DT 37231 3057 40 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 3057 41 , , , 37231 3057 42 until until IN 37231 3057 43 very very RB 37231 3057 44 long long RB 37231 3057 45 after after IN 37231 3057 46 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3057 47 's 's POS 37231 3057 48 day day NN 37231 3057 49 . . . 37231 3058 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3058 2 2 2 LS 37231 3058 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3058 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3058 5 have have VBP 37231 3058 6 already already RB 37231 3058 7 met meet VBN 37231 3058 8 with with IN 37231 3058 9 several several JJ 37231 3058 10 instances instance NNS 37231 3058 11 of of IN 37231 3058 12 this this DT 37231 3058 13 . . . 37231 3059 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 3059 2 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3059 3 that that IN 37231 3059 4 the the DT 37231 3059 5 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3059 6 of of IN 37231 3059 7 the the DT 37231 3059 8 Roman Roman NNP 37231 3059 9 Clement Clement NNP 37231 3059 10 was be VBD 37231 3059 11 publicly publicly RB 37231 3059 12 read read VBN 37231 3059 13 in in IN 37231 3059 14 Churches church NNS 37231 3059 15 in in IN 37231 3059 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3059 17 time,(3 time,(3 NN 37231 3059 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3059 19 and and CC 37231 3059 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3059 21 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3059 22 an an DT 37231 3059 23 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3059 24 of of IN 37231 3059 25 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 3059 26 of of IN 37231 3059 27 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 3059 28 to to IN 37231 3059 29 Soter Soter NNP 37231 3059 30 , , , 37231 3059 31 the the DT 37231 3059 32 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 3059 33 of of IN 37231 3059 34 Rome Rome NNP 37231 3059 35 , , , 37231 3059 36 which which WDT 37231 3059 37 states state VBZ 37231 3059 38 that that IN 37231 3059 39 fact fact NN 37231 3059 40 for for IN 37231 3059 41 the the DT 37231 3059 42 purpose purpose NN 37231 3059 43 of of IN 37231 3059 44 " " `` 37231 3059 45 showing show VBG 37231 3059 46 that that IN 37231 3059 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3059 48 was be VBD 37231 3059 49 the the DT 37231 3059 50 custom custom NN 37231 3059 51 to to TO 37231 3059 52 read read VB 37231 3059 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3059 54 in in IN 37231 3059 55 the the DT 37231 3059 56 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 3059 57 , , , 37231 3059 58 even even RB 37231 3059 59 from from IN 37231 3059 60 the the DT 37231 3059 61 earliest early JJS 37231 3059 62 times time NNS 37231 3059 63 . . . 37231 3060 1 " " `` 37231 3060 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3060 3 4 4 LS 37231 3060 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3060 5 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 37231 3060 6 likewise likewise RB 37231 3060 7 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3060 8 the the DT 37231 3060 9 public public JJ 37231 3060 10 reading reading NN 37231 3060 11 of of IN 37231 3060 12 the the DT 37231 3060 13 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3060 14 of of IN 37231 3060 15 Soter Soter NNP 37231 3060 16 to to IN 37231 3060 17 the the DT 37231 3060 18 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 3060 19 . . . 37231 3061 1 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3061 2 refers refer VBZ 37231 3061 3 to to IN 37231 3061 4 the the DT 37231 3061 5 reading reading NN 37231 3061 6 in in IN 37231 3061 7 the the DT 37231 3061 8 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 3061 9 of of IN 37231 3061 10 the the DT 37231 3061 11 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3061 12 of of IN 37231 3061 13 Clement,(5 Clement,(5 NNP 37231 3061 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3061 15 and and CC 37231 3061 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3061 17 continued continue VBD 37231 3061 18 to to TO 37231 3061 19 be be VB 37231 3061 20 so so RB 37231 3061 21 read read VBN 37231 3061 22 in in IN 37231 3061 23 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 3061 24 's 's POS 37231 3061 25 day day NN 37231 3061 26 . . . 37231 3062 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3062 2 6 6 CD 37231 3062 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3062 4 In in IN 37231 3062 5 like like JJ 37231 3062 6 manner manner NN 37231 3062 7 , , , 37231 3062 8 the the DT 37231 3062 9 " " `` 37231 3062 10 Pastor Pastor NNP 37231 3062 11 " " '' 37231 3062 12 of of IN 37231 3062 13 Hermas,(7 Hermas,(7 NNP 37231 3062 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3062 15 the the DT 37231 3062 16 " " `` 37231 3062 17 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 3062 18 of of IN 37231 3062 19 Peter,"(8 peter,"(8 NN 37231 3062 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3062 21 and and CC 37231 3062 22 other other JJ 37231 3062 23 works work NNS 37231 3062 24 excluded exclude VBN 37231 3062 25 from from IN 37231 3062 26 the the DT 37231 3062 27 canon canon NN 37231 3062 28 were be VBD 37231 3062 29 publicly publicly RB 37231 3062 30 read read VBN 37231 3062 31 in in IN 37231 3062 32 the the DT 37231 3062 33 Church Church NNP 37231 3062 34 in in IN 37231 3062 35 early early JJ 37231 3062 36 days day NNS 37231 3062 37 . . . 37231 3063 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3063 2 9 9 LS 37231 3063 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3063 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3063 5 is be VBZ 37231 3063 6 certain certain JJ 37231 3063 7 that that IN 37231 3063 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3063 9 which which WDT 37231 3063 10 { { -LRB- 37231 3063 11 295 295 CD 37231 3063 12 } } -RRB- 37231 3063 13 did do VBD 37231 3063 14 not not RB 37231 3063 15 permanently permanently RB 37231 3063 16 secure secure VB 37231 3063 17 a a DT 37231 3063 18 place place NN 37231 3063 19 in in IN 37231 3063 20 the the DT 37231 3063 21 canon canon NN 37231 3063 22 , , , 37231 3063 23 such such JJ 37231 3063 24 as as IN 37231 3063 25 the the DT 37231 3063 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3063 27 according accord VBG 37231 3063 28 to to IN 37231 3063 29 the the DT 37231 3063 30 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3063 31 , , , 37231 3063 32 the the DT 37231 3063 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3063 34 according accord VBG 37231 3063 35 to to IN 37231 3063 36 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3063 37 , , , 37231 3063 38 the the DT 37231 3063 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3063 40 of of IN 37231 3063 41 the the DT 37231 3063 42 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 3063 43 , , , 37231 3063 44 and and CC 37231 3063 45 many many JJ 37231 3063 46 kindred kindred JJ 37231 3063 47 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3063 48 , , , 37231 3063 49 which which WDT 37231 3063 50 in in IN 37231 3063 51 early early JJ 37231 3063 52 times time NNS 37231 3063 53 were be VBD 37231 3063 54 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 3063 55 used use VBN 37231 3063 56 by by IN 37231 3063 57 various various JJ 37231 3063 58 communities,(1 communities,(1 NN 37231 3063 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3063 60 must must MD 37231 3063 61 have have VB 37231 3063 62 been be VBN 37231 3063 63 read read VBN 37231 3063 64 at at IN 37231 3063 65 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3063 66 public public JJ 37231 3063 67 assemblies assembly NNS 37231 3063 68 . . . 37231 3064 1 The the DT 37231 3064 2 public public JJ 37231 3064 3 reading reading NN 37231 3064 4 of of IN 37231 3064 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3064 6 's 's POS 37231 3064 7 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3064 8 , , , 37231 3064 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 3064 10 , , , 37231 3064 11 does do VBZ 37231 3064 12 not not RB 37231 3064 13 prove prove VB 37231 3064 14 anything anything NN 37231 3064 15 , , , 37231 3064 16 for for IN 37231 3064 17 this this DT 37231 3064 18 practice practice NN 37231 3064 19 was be VBD 37231 3064 20 by by IN 37231 3064 21 no no DT 37231 3064 22 means means NN 37231 3064 23 limited limit VBN 37231 3064 24 to to IN 37231 3064 25 the the DT 37231 3064 26 works work NNS 37231 3064 27 now now RB 37231 3064 28 in in IN 37231 3064 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3064 30 canon canon NN 37231 3064 31 . . . 37231 3065 1 The the DT 37231 3065 2 idea idea NN 37231 3065 3 of of IN 37231 3065 4 attributing attribute VBG 37231 3065 5 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 3065 6 to to IN 37231 3065 7 the the DT 37231 3065 8 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3065 9 , , , 37231 3065 10 or or CC 37231 3065 11 to to IN 37231 3065 12 any any DT 37231 3065 13 other other JJ 37231 3065 14 work work NN 37231 3065 15 of of IN 37231 3065 16 the the DT 37231 3065 17 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3065 18 , , , 37231 3065 19 with with IN 37231 3065 20 the the DT 37231 3065 21 single single JJ 37231 3065 22 exception exception NN 37231 3065 23 , , , 37231 3065 24 as as IN 37231 3065 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3065 26 shall shall MD 37231 3065 27 presently presently RB 37231 3065 28 see see VB 37231 3065 29 , , , 37231 3065 30 of of IN 37231 3065 31 the the DT 37231 3065 32 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 3065 33 of of IN 37231 3065 34 John,(2 John,(2 NNP 37231 3065 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3065 36 which which WDT 37231 3065 37 , , , 37231 3065 38 as as IN 37231 3065 39 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 3065 40 , , , 37231 3065 41 entered enter VBD 37231 3065 42 within within IN 37231 3065 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3065 44 limits limit NNS 37231 3065 45 , , , 37231 3065 46 was be VBD 37231 3065 47 quite quite RB 37231 3065 48 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3065 49 to to IN 37231 3065 50 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3065 51 , , , 37231 3065 52 who who WP 37231 3065 53 recognized recognize VBD 37231 3065 54 the the DT 37231 3065 55 Old Old NNP 37231 3065 56 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3065 57 alone alone RB 37231 3065 58 as as IN 37231 3065 59 the the DT 37231 3065 60 inspired inspire VBN 37231 3065 61 word word NN 37231 3065 62 of of IN 37231 3065 63 God God NNP 37231 3065 64 . . . 37231 3066 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3066 2 3 3 LS 37231 3066 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3066 4 Indeed indeed RB 37231 3066 5 , , , 37231 3066 6 as as IN 37231 3066 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3066 8 { { -LRB- 37231 3066 9 296 296 CD 37231 3066 10 } } -RRB- 37231 3066 11 have have VBP 37231 3066 12 already already RB 37231 3066 13 said say VBN 37231 3066 14 , , , 37231 3066 15 the the DT 37231 3066 16 very very JJ 37231 3066 17 name name NN 37231 3066 18 " " `` 37231 3066 19 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3066 20 " " '' 37231 3066 21 in in IN 37231 3066 22 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3066 23 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3066 24 the the DT 37231 3066 25 thought thought NN 37231 3066 26 of of IN 37231 3066 27 inspiration,(1 inspiration,(1 NNP 37231 3066 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3066 29 which which WDT 37231 3066 30 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3066 31 attributed attribute VBD 37231 3066 32 only only RB 37231 3066 33 to to IN 37231 3066 34 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 3066 35 writings writing NNS 37231 3066 36 ; ; : 37231 3066 37 and and CC 37231 3066 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3066 39 could could MD 37231 3066 40 not not RB 37231 3066 41 in in IN 37231 3066 42 any any DT 37231 3066 43 way way NN 37231 3066 44 regard regard NN 37231 3066 45 as as IN 37231 3066 46 inspired inspire VBD 37231 3066 47 the the DT 37231 3066 48 written write VBN 37231 3066 49 tradition tradition NN 37231 3066 50 of of IN 37231 3066 51 the the DT 37231 3066 52 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3066 53 and and CC 37231 3066 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3066 55 followers follower NNS 37231 3066 56 , , , 37231 3066 57 or or CC 37231 3066 58 a a DT 37231 3066 59 mere mere JJ 37231 3066 60 record record NN 37231 3066 61 of of IN 37231 3066 62 the the DT 37231 3066 63 words word NNS 37231 3066 64 of of IN 37231 3066 65 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3066 66 . . . 37231 3067 1 On on IN 37231 3067 2 the the DT 37231 3067 3 contrary contrary NN 37231 3067 4 , , , 37231 3067 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3067 6 held hold VBD 37231 3067 7 the the DT 37231 3067 8 accounts account NNS 37231 3067 9 of of IN 37231 3067 10 the the DT 37231 3067 11 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3067 12 to to TO 37231 3067 13 be be VB 37231 3067 14 credible credible JJ 37231 3067 15 solely solely RB 37231 3067 16 from from IN 37231 3067 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3067 18 being be VBG 37231 3067 19 authenticated authenticate VBN 37231 3067 20 by by IN 37231 3067 21 the the DT 37231 3067 22 Old Old NNP 37231 3067 23 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3067 24 , , , 37231 3067 25 and and CC 37231 3067 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3067 27 clearly clearly RB 37231 3067 28 states state VBZ 37231 3067 29 that that IN 37231 3067 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3067 31 believes believe VBZ 37231 3067 32 the the DT 37231 3067 33 facts fact NNS 37231 3067 34 recorded record VBN 37231 3067 35 in in IN 37231 3067 36 the the DT 37231 3067 37 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3067 38 because because IN 37231 3067 39 the the DT 37231 3067 40 spirit spirit NN 37231 3067 41 of of IN 37231 3067 42 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 3067 43 had have VBD 37231 3067 44 already already RB 37231 3067 45 foretold foretell VBN 37231 3067 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3067 47 . . . 37231 3068 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3068 2 2 2 LS 37231 3068 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3068 4 According accord VBG 37231 3068 5 to to IN 37231 3068 6 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3068 7 , , , 37231 3068 8 the the DT 37231 3068 9 Old Old NNP 37231 3068 10 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3068 11 contained contain VBD 37231 3068 12 all all DT 37231 3068 13 that that WDT 37231 3068 14 was be VBD 37231 3068 15 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3068 16 for for IN 37231 3068 17 salvation salvation NN 37231 3068 18 , , , 37231 3068 19 and and CC 37231 3068 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3068 21 prophecies prophecy NNS 37231 3068 22 are be VBP 37231 3068 23 the the DT 37231 3068 24 sole sole JJ 37231 3068 25 criterion criterion NN 37231 3068 26 of of IN 37231 3068 27 truth truth NN 37231 3068 28 , , , 37231 3068 29 the the DT 37231 3068 30 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3068 31 , , , 37231 3068 32 and and CC 37231 3068 33 even even RB 37231 3068 34 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3068 35 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3068 36 , , , 37231 3068 37 being be VBG 37231 3068 38 merely merely RB 37231 3068 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3068 40 interpreters interpreter NNS 37231 3068 41 . . . 37231 3069 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3069 2 3 3 LS 37231 3069 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3069 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3069 5 says say VBZ 37231 3069 6 that that IN 37231 3069 7 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3069 8 commanded command VBD 37231 3069 9 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3069 10 not not RB 37231 3069 11 to to TO 37231 3069 12 put put VB 37231 3069 13 faith faith NN 37231 3069 14 in in IN 37231 3069 15 human human JJ 37231 3069 16 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3069 17 , , , 37231 3069 18 but but CC 37231 3069 19 in in IN 37231 3069 20 those those DT 37231 3069 21 proclaimed proclaim VBN 37231 3069 22 by by IN 37231 3069 23 the the DT 37231 3069 24 holy holy JJ 37231 3069 25 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3069 26 , , , 37231 3069 27 and and CC 37231 3069 28 taught teach VBN 37231 3069 29 by by IN 37231 3069 30 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3069 31 . . . 37231 3070 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3070 2 4 4 LS 37231 3070 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3070 4 Prophecy Prophecy NNP 37231 3070 5 and and CC 37231 3070 6 the the DT 37231 3070 7 words word NNS 37231 3070 8 of of IN 37231 3070 9 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3070 10 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3070 11 are be VBP 37231 3070 12 alone alone JJ 37231 3070 13 of of IN 37231 3070 14 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 3070 15 value value NN 37231 3070 16 , , , 37231 3070 17 all all DT 37231 3070 18 else else RB 37231 3070 19 is be VBZ 37231 3070 20 human human JJ 37231 3070 21 teaching teaching NN 37231 3070 22 . . . 37231 3071 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3071 2 5 5 LS 37231 3071 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3071 4 Indeed indeed RB 37231 3071 5 , , , 37231 3071 6 from from IN 37231 3071 7 a a DT 37231 3071 8 passage passage NN 37231 3071 9 quoted quote VBN 37231 3071 10 with with IN 37231 3071 11 approval approval NN 37231 3071 12 by by IN 37231 3071 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3071 14 , , , 37231 3071 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3071 16 , , , 37231 3071 17 in in IN 37231 3071 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3071 19 lost lost JJ 37231 3071 20 work work NN 37231 3071 21 against against IN 37231 3071 22 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 3071 23 , , , 37231 3071 24 said say VBD 37231 3071 25 : : : 37231 3071 26 " " `` 37231 3071 27 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3071 28 would would MD 37231 3071 29 not not RB 37231 3071 30 have have VB 37231 3071 31 believed believe VBN 37231 3071 32 the the DT 37231 3071 33 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3071 34 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3071 35 , , , 37231 3071 36 if if IN 37231 3071 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3071 38 had have VBD 37231 3071 39 proclaimed proclaim VBN 37231 3071 40 any any DT 37231 3071 41 other other JJ 37231 3071 42 God God NNP 37231 3071 43 than than IN 37231 3071 44 the the DT 37231 3071 45 Creator Creator NNP 37231 3071 46 ; ; : 37231 3071 47 " " `` 37231 3071 48 that that DT 37231 3071 49 is be VBZ 37231 3071 50 to to TO 37231 3071 51 say say VB 37231 3071 52 , , , 37231 3071 53 the the DT 37231 3071 54 God God NNP 37231 3071 55 of of IN 37231 3071 56 the the DT 37231 3071 57 Old Old NNP 37231 3071 58 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3071 59 . . . 37231 3072 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3072 2 6 6 CD 37231 3072 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3072 4 { { -LRB- 37231 3072 5 297 297 CD 37231 3072 6 } } -RRB- 37231 3072 7 That that IN 37231 3072 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3072 9 does do VBZ 37231 3072 10 not not RB 37231 3072 11 mention mention VB 37231 3072 12 the the DT 37231 3072 13 name name NN 37231 3072 14 of of IN 37231 3072 15 the the DT 37231 3072 16 author author NN 37231 3072 17 of of IN 37231 3072 18 the the DT 37231 3072 19 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3072 20 would would MD 37231 3072 21 in in IN 37231 3072 22 any any DT 37231 3072 23 case case NN 37231 3072 24 render render VB 37231 3072 25 any any DT 37231 3072 26 argument argument NN 37231 3072 27 as as IN 37231 3072 28 to to IN 37231 3072 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3072 30 identity identity NN 37231 3072 31 with with IN 37231 3072 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3072 33 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3072 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3072 35 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 37231 3072 36 ; ; : 37231 3072 37 but but CC 37231 3072 38 the the DT 37231 3072 39 total total JJ 37231 3072 40 omission omission NN 37231 3072 41 to to TO 37231 3072 42 do do VB 37231 3072 43 so so RB 37231 3072 44 is be VBZ 37231 3072 45 the the DT 37231 3072 46 more more RBR 37231 3072 47 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3072 48 from from IN 37231 3072 49 the the DT 37231 3072 50 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 3072 51 that that WDT 37231 3072 52 the the DT 37231 3072 53 names name NNS 37231 3072 54 of of IN 37231 3072 55 Old Old NNP 37231 3072 56 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3072 57 writers writer NNS 37231 3072 58 constantly constantly RB 37231 3072 59 occur occur VBP 37231 3072 60 in in IN 37231 3072 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3072 62 writings writing NNS 37231 3072 63 . . . 37231 3073 1 Semisch Semisch NNP 37231 3073 2 counts count VBZ 37231 3073 3 197 197 CD 37231 3073 4 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3073 5 of of IN 37231 3073 6 the the DT 37231 3073 7 Old Old NNP 37231 3073 8 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3073 9 , , , 37231 3073 10 in in IN 37231 3073 11 which which WDT 37231 3073 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3073 13 refers refer VBZ 37231 3073 14 to to IN 37231 3073 15 the the DT 37231 3073 16 author author NN 37231 3073 17 by by IN 37231 3073 18 name name NN 37231 3073 19 , , , 37231 3073 20 or or CC 37231 3073 21 to to IN 37231 3073 22 the the DT 37231 3073 23 book book NN 37231 3073 24 , , , 37231 3073 25 and and CC 37231 3073 26 only only RB 37231 3073 27 117 117 CD 37231 3073 28 in in IN 37231 3073 29 which which WDT 37231 3073 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3073 31 omits omit VBZ 37231 3073 32 to to TO 37231 3073 33 do do VB 37231 3073 34 so,(1 so,(1 NN 37231 3073 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3073 36 and and CC 37231 3073 37 the the DT 37231 3073 38 latter latter JJ 37231 3073 39 number number NN 37231 3073 40 might may MD 37231 3073 41 be be VB 37231 3073 42 reduced reduce VBN 37231 3073 43 by by IN 37231 3073 44 considering consider VBG 37231 3073 45 the the DT 37231 3073 46 nature nature NN 37231 3073 47 of of IN 37231 3073 48 the the DT 37231 3073 49 passages passage NNS 37231 3073 50 cited cite VBN 37231 3073 51 , , , 37231 3073 52 and and CC 37231 3073 53 the the DT 37231 3073 54 inutility inutility NN 37231 3073 55 of of IN 37231 3073 56 repeating repeat VBG 37231 3073 57 the the DT 37231 3073 58 reference reference NN 37231 3073 59 . . . 37231 3074 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3074 2 2 2 LS 37231 3074 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3074 4 When when WRB 37231 3074 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3074 6 is be VBZ 37231 3074 7 considered consider VBN 37231 3074 8 , , , 37231 3074 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 3074 10 , , , 37231 3074 11 that that IN 37231 3074 12 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 37231 3074 13 the the DT 37231 3074 14 extremely extremely RB 37231 3074 15 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3074 16 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3074 17 , , , 37231 3074 18 and and CC 37231 3074 19 references reference NNS 37231 3074 20 to to IN 37231 3074 21 facts fact NNS 37231 3074 22 of of IN 37231 3074 23 Christian christian JJ 37231 3074 24 history history NN 37231 3074 25 , , , 37231 3074 26 all all DT 37231 3074 27 purporting purport VBG 37231 3074 28 to to TO 37231 3074 29 be be VB 37231 3074 30 derived derive VBN 37231 3074 31 from from IN 37231 3074 32 the the DT 37231 3074 33 " " `` 37231 3074 34 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3074 35 , , , 37231 3074 36 " " '' 37231 3074 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3074 38 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 3074 39 never never RB 37231 3074 40 , , , 37231 3074 41 except except IN 37231 3074 42 in in IN 37231 3074 43 the the DT 37231 3074 44 one one CD 37231 3074 45 instance instance NN 37231 3074 46 referred refer VBD 37231 3074 47 to to IN 37231 3074 48 , , , 37231 3074 49 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3074 50 an an DT 37231 3074 51 author author NN 37231 3074 52 's 's POS 37231 3074 53 name name NN 37231 3074 54 , , , 37231 3074 55 or or CC 37231 3074 56 specifies specify VBZ 37231 3074 57 more more RBR 37231 3074 58 clearly clearly RB 37231 3074 59 the the DT 37231 3074 60 nature nature NN 37231 3074 61 of of IN 37231 3074 62 the the DT 37231 3074 63 source source NN 37231 3074 64 , , , 37231 3074 65 the the DT 37231 3074 66 inference inference NN 37231 3074 67 must must MD 37231 3074 68 not not RB 37231 3074 69 only only RB 37231 3074 70 be be VB 37231 3074 71 that that IN 37231 3074 72 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3074 73 attached attach VBD 37231 3074 74 small small JJ 37231 3074 75 importance importance NN 37231 3074 76 to to IN 37231 3074 77 the the DT 37231 3074 78 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3074 79 , , , 37231 3074 80 but but CC 37231 3074 81 also also RB 37231 3074 82 that that IN 37231 3074 83 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3074 84 was be VBD 37231 3074 85 actually actually RB 37231 3074 86 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 3074 87 of of IN 37231 3074 88 the the DT 37231 3074 89 author author NN 37231 3074 90 's 's POS 37231 3074 91 name name NN 37231 3074 92 , , , 37231 3074 93 and and CC 37231 3074 94 that that IN 37231 3074 95 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3074 96 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3074 97 had have VBD 37231 3074 98 no no DT 37231 3074 99 more more RBR 37231 3074 100 definite definite JJ 37231 3074 101 superscription superscription NN 37231 3074 102 . . . 37231 3075 1 Upon upon IN 37231 3075 2 the the DT 37231 3075 3 theory theory NN 37231 3075 4 that that IN 37231 3075 5 the the DT 37231 3075 6 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3075 7 of of IN 37231 3075 8 the the DT 37231 3075 9 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3075 10 were be VBD 37231 3075 11 simply simply RB 37231 3075 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3075 13 { { -LRB- 37231 3075 14 298 298 CD 37231 3075 15 } } -RRB- 37231 3075 16 four four CD 37231 3075 17 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3075 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3075 19 , , , 37231 3075 20 the the DT 37231 3075 21 singularity singularity NN 37231 3075 22 of of IN 37231 3075 23 the the DT 37231 3075 24 omission omission NN 37231 3075 25 is be VBZ 37231 3075 26 increased increase VBN 37231 3075 27 by by IN 37231 3075 28 the the DT 37231 3075 29 diversity diversity NN 37231 3075 30 of of IN 37231 3075 31 contents content NNS 37231 3075 32 and and CC 37231 3075 33 of of IN 37231 3075 34 authors author NNS 37231 3075 35 , , , 37231 3075 36 and and CC 37231 3075 37 the the DT 37231 3075 38 consequently consequently RB 37231 3075 39 greater great JJR 37231 3075 40 necessity necessity NN 37231 3075 41 and and CC 37231 3075 42 probability probability NN 37231 3075 43 that that WDT 37231 3075 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3075 45 should should MD 37231 3075 46 , , , 37231 3075 47 upon upon IN 37231 3075 48 certain certain JJ 37231 3075 49 occasions occasion NNS 37231 3075 50 , , , 37231 3075 51 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 3075 52 between between IN 37231 3075 53 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3075 54 . . . 37231 3076 1 The the DT 37231 3076 2 fact fact NN 37231 3076 3 is be VBZ 37231 3076 4 that that IN 37231 3076 5 the the DT 37231 3076 6 only only JJ 37231 3076 7 writing writing NN 37231 3076 8 of of IN 37231 3076 9 the the DT 37231 3076 10 New New NNP 37231 3076 11 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3076 12 to to TO 37231 3076 13 which which WDT 37231 3076 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3076 15 refers refer VBZ 37231 3076 16 by by IN 37231 3076 17 name name NN 37231 3076 18 is be VBZ 37231 3076 19 , , , 37231 3076 20 as as IN 37231 3076 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3076 22 have have VBP 37231 3076 23 already already RB 37231 3076 24 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3076 25 , , , 37231 3076 26 the the DT 37231 3076 27 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 3076 28 , , , 37231 3076 29 which which WDT 37231 3076 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3076 31 attributes attribute VBZ 37231 3076 32 to to IN 37231 3076 33 " " `` 37231 3076 34 a a DT 37231 3076 35 certain certain JJ 37231 3076 36 man man NN 37231 3076 37 whose whose WP$ 37231 3076 38 name name NN 37231 3076 39 was be VBD 37231 3076 40 John John NNP 37231 3076 41 , , , 37231 3076 42 one one CD 37231 3076 43 of of IN 37231 3076 44 the the DT 37231 3076 45 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3076 46 of of IN 37231 3076 47 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3076 48 , , , 37231 3076 49 who who WP 37231 3076 50 prophesied prophesy VBD 37231 3076 51 by by IN 37231 3076 52 a a DT 37231 3076 53 revelation revelation NN 37231 3076 54 made make VBN 37231 3076 55 to to IN 37231 3076 56 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3076 57 , , , 37231 3076 58 " " '' 37231 3076 59 & & CC 37231 3076 60 c.(1 c.(1 NNP 37231 3076 61 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3076 62 The the DT 37231 3076 63 manner manner NN 37231 3076 64 in in IN 37231 3076 65 which which WDT 37231 3076 66 John John NNP 37231 3076 67 is be VBZ 37231 3076 68 here here RB 37231 3076 69 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3076 70 , , , 37231 3076 71 after after IN 37231 3076 72 the the DT 37231 3076 73 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3076 74 had have VBD 37231 3076 75 been be VBN 37231 3076 76 so so RB 37231 3076 77 constantly constantly RB 37231 3076 78 indefinitely indefinitely RB 37231 3076 79 referred refer VBD 37231 3076 80 to to TO 37231 3076 81 , , , 37231 3076 82 clearly clearly RB 37231 3076 83 shows show VBZ 37231 3076 84 that that IN 37231 3076 85 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3076 86 did do VBD 37231 3076 87 not not RB 37231 3076 88 possess possess VB 37231 3076 89 any any DT 37231 3076 90 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3076 91 also also RB 37231 3076 92 attributed attribute VBD 37231 3076 93 to to IN 37231 3076 94 John John NNP 37231 3076 95 . . . 37231 3077 1 That that IN 37231 3077 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3077 3 does do VBZ 37231 3077 4 name name VB 37231 3077 5 John John NNP 37231 3077 6 , , , 37231 3077 7 however however RB 37231 3077 8 , , , 37231 3077 9 as as IN 37231 3077 10 author author NN 37231 3077 11 of of IN 37231 3077 12 the the DT 37231 3077 13 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 3077 14 and and CC 37231 3077 15 so so RB 37231 3077 16 frequently frequently RB 37231 3077 17 refers refer VBZ 37231 3077 18 to to IN 37231 3077 19 Old Old NNP 37231 3077 20 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3077 21 writers writer NNS 37231 3077 22 by by IN 37231 3077 23 name name NN 37231 3077 24 , , , 37231 3077 25 yet yet CC 37231 3077 26 never never RB 37231 3077 27 identifies identify VBZ 37231 3077 28 the the DT 37231 3077 29 author author NN 37231 3077 30 of of IN 37231 3077 31 the the DT 37231 3077 32 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3077 33 , , , 37231 3077 34 is be VBZ 37231 3077 35 quite quite RB 37231 3077 36 irreconcilable irreconcilable JJ 37231 3077 37 with with IN 37231 3077 38 the the DT 37231 3077 39 idea idea NN 37231 3077 40 that that IN 37231 3077 41 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3077 42 were be VBD 37231 3077 43 the the DT 37231 3077 44 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3077 45 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3077 46 . . . 37231 3078 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3078 2 2 2 LS 37231 3078 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3078 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3078 5 is be VBZ 37231 3078 6 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 3078 7 clear clear JJ 37231 3078 8 , , , 37231 3078 9 however however RB 37231 3078 10 , , , 37231 3078 11 and and CC 37231 3078 12 this this DT 37231 3078 13 is be VBZ 37231 3078 14 a a DT 37231 3078 15 point point NN 37231 3078 16 of of IN 37231 3078 17 very very RB 37231 3078 18 great great JJ 37231 3078 19 importance importance NN 37231 3078 20 upon upon IN 37231 3078 21 which which WDT 37231 3078 22 critics critic NNS 37231 3078 23 of of IN 37231 3078 24 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 3078 25 widely widely RB 37231 3078 26 diverging diverge VBG 37231 3078 27 views view NNS 37231 3078 28 are be VBP 37231 3078 29 agreed agree VBN 37231 3078 30 , , , 37231 3078 31 that that IN 37231 3078 32 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3078 33 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3078 34 from from IN 37231 3078 35 a a DT 37231 3078 36 _ _ NNP 37231 3078 37 written write VBN 37231 3078 38 _ _ NNP 37231 3078 39 source source NN 37231 3078 40 , , , 37231 3078 41 and and CC 37231 3078 42 that that IN 37231 3078 43 oral oral JJ 37231 3078 44 tradition tradition NN 37231 3078 45 is be VBZ 37231 3078 46 excluded exclude VBN 37231 3078 47 from from IN 37231 3078 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3078 49 system system NN 37231 3078 50 . . . 37231 3079 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3079 2 3 3 LS 37231 3079 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3079 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3079 5 not not RB 37231 3079 6 only only RB 37231 3079 7 does do VBZ 37231 3079 8 not not RB 37231 3079 9 , , , 37231 3079 10 like like IN 37231 3079 11 Papias Papias NNP 37231 3079 12 , , , 37231 3079 13 attach attach JJ 37231 3079 14 value value NN 37231 3079 15 to to IN 37231 3079 16 tradition tradition NN 37231 3079 17 , , , 37231 3079 18 but but CC 37231 3079 19 , , , 37231 3079 20 on on IN 37231 3079 21 the the DT 37231 3079 22 contrary contrary NN 37231 3079 23 , , , 37231 3079 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3079 25 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 3079 26 that that IN 37231 3079 27 in in IN 37231 3079 28 the the DT 37231 3079 29 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3079 30 is be VBZ 37231 3079 31 recorded record VBN 37231 3079 32 " " `` 37231 3079 33 everything everything NN 37231 3079 34 that that WDT 37231 3079 35 concerns concern VBZ 37231 3079 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3079 37 " " `` 37231 3079 38 Saviour Saviour NNP 37231 3079 39 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3079 40 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3079 41 . . . 37231 3079 42 ,,(4 ,,(4 NFP 37231 3079 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3079 44 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3079 45 constantly constantly RB 37231 3079 46 refers refer VBZ 37231 3079 47 to to IN 37231 3079 48 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3079 49 { { -LRB- 37231 3079 50 299 299 CD 37231 3079 51 } } -RRB- 37231 3079 52 directly directly RB 37231 3079 53 , , , 37231 3079 54 as as IN 37231 3079 55 the the DT 37231 3079 56 source source NN 37231 3079 57 of of IN 37231 3079 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3079 59 information information NN 37231 3079 60 regarding regard VBG 37231 3079 61 the the DT 37231 3079 62 history history NN 37231 3079 63 of of IN 37231 3079 64 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3079 65 , , , 37231 3079 66 and and CC 37231 3079 67 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3079 68 states state VBZ 37231 3079 69 that that IN 37231 3079 70 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3079 71 has have VBZ 37231 3079 72 derived derive VBN 37231 3079 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3079 74 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3079 75 from from IN 37231 3079 76 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3079 77 . . . 37231 3080 1 There there EX 37231 3080 2 is be VBZ 37231 3080 3 no no DT 37231 3080 4 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 3080 5 ground ground NN 37231 3080 6 whatever whatever WDT 37231 3080 7 for for IN 37231 3080 8 affirming affirm VBG 37231 3080 9 that that IN 37231 3080 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3080 11 supplemented supplement VBD 37231 3080 12 or or CC 37231 3080 13 modified modify VBD 37231 3080 14 the the DT 37231 3080 15 contents content NNS 37231 3080 16 of of IN 37231 3080 17 the the DT 37231 3080 18 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3080 19 by by IN 37231 3080 20 oral oral JJ 37231 3080 21 tradition tradition NN 37231 3080 22 . . . 37231 3081 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3081 2 must must MD 37231 3081 3 , , , 37231 3081 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 3081 5 , , , 37231 3081 6 be be VB 37231 3081 7 remembered remember VBN 37231 3081 8 , , , 37231 3081 9 in in IN 37231 3081 10 considering consider VBG 37231 3081 11 the the DT 37231 3081 12 nature nature NN 37231 3081 13 of of IN 37231 3081 14 these these DT 37231 3081 15 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3081 16 , , , 37231 3081 17 that that IN 37231 3081 18 the the DT 37231 3081 19 facts fact NNS 37231 3081 20 of of IN 37231 3081 21 Christian christian JJ 37231 3081 22 history history NN 37231 3081 23 and and CC 37231 3081 24 the the DT 37231 3081 25 sayings saying NNS 37231 3081 26 of of IN 37231 3081 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3081 28 are be VBP 37231 3081 29 derived derive VBN 37231 3081 30 from from IN 37231 3081 31 a a DT 37231 3081 32 determinate determinate NN 37231 3081 33 written write VBN 37231 3081 34 source source NN 37231 3081 35 , , , 37231 3081 36 and and CC 37231 3081 37 are be VBP 37231 3081 38 quoted quote VBN 37231 3081 39 as as IN 37231 3081 40 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3081 41 found find VBD 37231 3081 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3081 43 there there RB 37231 3081 44 . . . 37231 3082 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3082 2 1 1 LS 37231 3082 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3082 4 Those those DT 37231 3082 5 who who WP 37231 3082 6 attempt attempt VBP 37231 3082 7 to to TO 37231 3082 8 explain explain VB 37231 3082 9 the the DT 37231 3082 10 divergences divergence NNS 37231 3082 11 of of IN 37231 3082 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3082 13 's 's POS 37231 3082 14 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3082 15 from from IN 37231 3082 16 the the DT 37231 3082 17 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3082 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3082 19 , , , 37231 3082 20 which which WDT 37231 3082 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3082 22 still still RB 37231 3082 23 maintain maintain VBP 37231 3082 24 to to TO 37231 3082 25 have have VB 37231 3082 26 been be VBN 37231 3082 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3082 28 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3082 29 , , , 37231 3082 30 on on IN 37231 3082 31 the the DT 37231 3082 32 plea plea NN 37231 3082 33 of of IN 37231 3082 34 oral oral JJ 37231 3082 35 tradition tradition NN 37231 3082 36 , , , 37231 3082 37 defend defend VBP 37231 3082 38 the the DT 37231 3082 39 identity identity NN 37231 3082 40 at at IN 37231 3082 41 the the DT 37231 3082 42 expense expense NN 37231 3082 43 of of IN 37231 3082 44 the the DT 37231 3082 45 authority authority NN 37231 3082 46 of of IN 37231 3082 47 the the DT 37231 3082 48 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3082 49 . . . 37231 3083 1 For for IN 37231 3083 2 nothing nothing NN 37231 3083 3 could could MD 37231 3083 4 more more RBR 37231 3083 5 forcibly forcibly RB 37231 3083 6 show show VB 37231 3083 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3083 8 's 's POS 37231 3083 9 disregard disregard NN 37231 3083 10 and and CC 37231 3083 11 disrespect disrespect NN 37231 3083 12 for for IN 37231 3083 13 the the DT 37231 3083 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3083 15 , , , 37231 3083 16 than than IN 37231 3083 17 would would MD 37231 3083 18 the the DT 37231 3083 19 fact fact NN 37231 3083 20 that that IN 37231 3083 21 , , , 37231 3083 22 possessing possess VBG 37231 3083 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3083 24 , , , 37231 3083 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3083 26 not not RB 37231 3083 27 only only RB 37231 3083 28 never never RB 37231 3083 29 names name VBZ 37231 3083 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3083 31 authors author NNS 37231 3083 32 , , , 37231 3083 33 but but CC 37231 3083 34 considers consider VBZ 37231 3083 35 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3083 36 at at IN 37231 3083 37 liberty liberty NN 37231 3083 38 continually continually RB 37231 3083 39 to to TO 37231 3083 40 contradict contradict VB 37231 3083 41 , , , 37231 3083 42 modify modify VB 37231 3083 43 , , , 37231 3083 44 and and CC 37231 3083 45 revise revise VB 37231 3083 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3083 47 statements statement NNS 37231 3083 48 . . . 37231 3084 1 As as IN 37231 3084 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3084 3 have have VBP 37231 3084 4 already already RB 37231 3084 5 remarked remark VBN 37231 3084 6 , , , 37231 3084 7 when when WRB 37231 3084 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3084 9 examine examine VBP 37231 3084 10 the the DT 37231 3084 11 contents content NNS 37231 3084 12 of of IN 37231 3084 13 the the DT 37231 3084 14 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3084 15 of of IN 37231 3084 16 the the DT 37231 3084 17 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3084 18 , , , 37231 3084 19 through through IN 37231 3084 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3084 21 's 's POS 37231 3084 22 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3084 23 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3084 24 , , , 37231 3084 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3084 26 find find VBP 37231 3084 27 that that IN 37231 3084 28 many many JJ 37231 3084 29 parts part NNS 37231 3084 30 of of IN 37231 3084 31 the the DT 37231 3084 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3084 33 narratives narrative NNS 37231 3084 34 are be VBP 37231 3084 35 apparently apparently RB 37231 3084 36 quite quite RB 37231 3084 37 unknown unknown JJ 37231 3084 38 , , , 37231 3084 39 whilst whilst RB 37231 3084 40 , , , 37231 3084 41 on on IN 37231 3084 42 the the DT 37231 3084 43 other other JJ 37231 3084 44 hand hand NN 37231 3084 45 , , , 37231 3084 46 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3084 47 meet meet VBP 37231 3084 48 with with IN 37231 3084 49 facts fact NNS 37231 3084 50 of of IN 37231 3084 51 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 3084 52 history history NN 37231 3084 53 , , , 37231 3084 54 which which WDT 37231 3084 55 are be VBP 37231 3084 56 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3084 57 to to IN 37231 3084 58 the the DT 37231 3084 59 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3084 60 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3084 61 , , , 37231 3084 62 and and CC 37231 3084 63 others other NNS 37231 3084 64 which which WDT 37231 3084 65 are be VBP 37231 3084 66 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 3084 67 of of IN 37231 3084 68 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3084 69 statements statement NNS 37231 3084 70 . . . 37231 3085 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3085 2 's 's POS 37231 3085 3 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3085 4 , , , 37231 3085 5 almost almost RB 37231 3085 6 without without IN 37231 3085 7 exception exception NN 37231 3085 8 , , , 37231 3085 9 vary vary VBP 37231 3085 10 more more RBR 37231 3085 11 or or CC 37231 3085 12 less less RBR 37231 3085 13 from from IN 37231 3085 14 the the DT 37231 3085 15 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3085 16 in in IN 37231 3085 17 the the DT 37231 3085 18 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3085 19 text text NN 37231 3085 20 , , , 37231 3085 21 and and CC 37231 3085 22 often often RB 37231 3085 23 these these DT 37231 3085 24 variations variation NNS 37231 3085 25 are be VBP 37231 3085 26 consistently consistently RB 37231 3085 27 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3085 28 by by IN 37231 3085 29 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3085 30 , , , 37231 3085 31 and and CC 37231 3085 32 are be VBP 37231 3085 33 found find VBN 37231 3085 34 in in IN 37231 3085 35 other other JJ 37231 3085 36 works work NNS 37231 3085 37 about about IN 37231 3085 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3085 39 time time NN 37231 3085 40 . . . 37231 3086 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3086 2 , , , 37231 3086 3 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3086 4 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3086 5 expressions expression NNS 37231 3086 6 of of IN 37231 3086 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3086 8 , , , 37231 3086 9 which which WDT 37231 3086 10 are be VBP 37231 3086 11 not not RB 37231 3086 12 found find VBN 37231 3086 13 in in IN 37231 3086 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3086 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3086 16 at at RB 37231 3086 17 all all RB 37231 3086 18 . . . 37231 3087 1 The the DT 37231 3087 2 omissions omission NNS 37231 3087 3 , , , 37231 3087 4 though though IN 37231 3087 5 often often RB 37231 3087 6 very very RB 37231 3087 7 { { -LRB- 37231 3087 8 300 300 CD 37231 3087 9 } } -RRB- 37231 3087 10 singular singular JJ 37231 3087 11 , , , 37231 3087 12 supposing suppose VBG 37231 3087 13 the the DT 37231 3087 14 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3087 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3087 16 before before IN 37231 3087 17 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3087 18 , , , 37231 3087 19 and and CC 37231 3087 20 almost almost RB 37231 3087 21 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 37231 3087 22 when when WRB 37231 3087 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3087 24 is be VBZ 37231 3087 25 considered consider VBN 37231 3087 26 how how WRB 37231 3087 27 important important JJ 37231 3087 28 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3087 29 would would MD 37231 3087 30 often often RB 37231 3087 31 have have VB 37231 3087 32 been be VBN 37231 3087 33 to to IN 37231 3087 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3087 35 argument argument NN 37231 3087 36 , , , 37231 3087 37 need nee MD 37231 3087 38 not not RB 37231 3087 39 , , , 37231 3087 40 as as IN 37231 3087 41 merely merely RB 37231 3087 42 negative negative JJ 37231 3087 43 evidence evidence NN 37231 3087 44 , , , 37231 3087 45 be be VB 37231 3087 46 dwelt dwell VBN 37231 3087 47 on on RP 37231 3087 48 here here RB 37231 3087 49 , , , 37231 3087 50 but but CC 37231 3087 51 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3087 52 shall shall MD 37231 3087 53 briefly briefly RB 37231 3087 54 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 3087 55 the the DT 37231 3087 56 other other JJ 37231 3087 57 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 37231 3087 58 of of IN 37231 3087 59 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3087 60 's 's POS 37231 3087 61 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3087 62 . . . 37231 3088 1 The the DT 37231 3088 2 only only JJ 37231 3088 3 genealogy genealogy NN 37231 3088 4 of of IN 37231 3088 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3088 6 which which WDT 37231 3088 7 is be VBZ 37231 3088 8 recognized recognize VBN 37231 3088 9 by by IN 37231 3088 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3088 11 is be VBZ 37231 3088 12 traced trace VBN 37231 3088 13 through through IN 37231 3088 14 the the DT 37231 3088 15 Virgin Virgin NNP 37231 3088 16 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3088 17 . . . 37231 3089 1 She -PRON- PRP 37231 3089 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3089 3 is be VBZ 37231 3089 4 who who WP 37231 3089 5 is be VBZ 37231 3089 6 descended descend VBN 37231 3089 7 from from IN 37231 3089 8 Abraham Abraham NNP 37231 3089 9 , , , 37231 3089 10 Isaac Isaac NNP 37231 3089 11 , , , 37231 3089 12 and and CC 37231 3089 13 Jacob Jacob NNP 37231 3089 14 , , , 37231 3089 15 and and CC 37231 3089 16 from from IN 37231 3089 17 the the DT 37231 3089 18 house house NN 37231 3089 19 of of IN 37231 3089 20 David David NNP 37231 3089 21 , , , 37231 3089 22 and and CC 37231 3089 23 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3089 24 is be VBZ 37231 3089 25 completely completely RB 37231 3089 26 set set VBN 37231 3089 27 aside aside RB 37231 3089 28 . . . 37231 3090 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3090 2 1 1 LS 37231 3090 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3090 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3090 5 " " '' 37231 3090 6 was be VBD 37231 3090 7 born bear VBN 37231 3090 8 of of IN 37231 3090 9 a a DT 37231 3090 10 virgin virgin NN 37231 3090 11 of of IN 37231 3090 12 the the DT 37231 3090 13 lineage lineage NN 37231 3090 14 of of IN 37231 3090 15 Abraham Abraham NNP 37231 3090 16 and and CC 37231 3090 17 tribe tribe NN 37231 3090 18 of of IN 37231 3090 19 Judah Judah NNP 37231 3090 20 and and CC 37231 3090 21 of of IN 37231 3090 22 David David NNP 37231 3090 23 , , , 37231 3090 24 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3090 25 the the DT 37231 3090 26 Son Son NNP 37231 3090 27 of of IN 37231 3090 28 God God NNP 37231 3090 29 . . . 37231 3091 1 " " `` 37231 3091 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3091 3 2 2 LS 37231 3091 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3091 5 " " '' 37231 3091 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3091 7 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3091 8 the the DT 37231 3091 9 Son Son NNP 37231 3091 10 of of IN 37231 3091 11 God God NNP 37231 3091 12 has have VBZ 37231 3091 13 been be VBN 37231 3091 14 born bear VBN 37231 3091 15 without without IN 37231 3091 16 sin sin NN 37231 3091 17 of of IN 37231 3091 18 a a DT 37231 3091 19 virgin virgin NN 37231 3091 20 sprung spring VBN 37231 3091 21 from from IN 37231 3091 22 the the DT 37231 3091 23 lineage lineage NN 37231 3091 24 of of IN 37231 3091 25 Abraham Abraham NNP 37231 3091 26 . . . 37231 3092 1 " " `` 37231 3092 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3092 3 3 3 LS 37231 3092 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3092 5 " " `` 37231 3092 6 For for IN 37231 3092 7 of of IN 37231 3092 8 the the DT 37231 3092 9 virgin virgin NN 37231 3092 10 of of IN 37231 3092 11 the the DT 37231 3092 12 seed seed NN 37231 3092 13 of of IN 37231 3092 14 Jacob Jacob NNP 37231 3092 15 , , , 37231 3092 16 who who WP 37231 3092 17 was be VBD 37231 3092 18 the the DT 37231 3092 19 father father NN 37231 3092 20 of of IN 37231 3092 21 Judah Judah NNP 37231 3092 22 , , , 37231 3092 23 who who WP 37231 3092 24 , , , 37231 3092 25 as as IN 37231 3092 26 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3092 27 have have VBP 37231 3092 28 shown show VBN 37231 3092 29 , , , 37231 3092 30 was be VBD 37231 3092 31 the the DT 37231 3092 32 father father NN 37231 3092 33 of of IN 37231 3092 34 the the DT 37231 3092 35 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3092 36 , , , 37231 3092 37 by by IN 37231 3092 38 the the DT 37231 3092 39 power power NN 37231 3092 40 of of IN 37231 3092 41 God God NNP 37231 3092 42 was be VBD 37231 3092 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3092 44 conceived conceive VBD 37231 3092 45 ; ; : 37231 3092 46 and and CC 37231 3092 47 Jesse Jesse NNP 37231 3092 48 was be VBD 37231 3092 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3092 50 forefather forefather NN 37231 3092 51 according accord VBG 37231 3092 52 to to IN 37231 3092 53 the the DT 37231 3092 54 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 3092 55 , , , 37231 3092 56 and and CC 37231 3092 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3092 58 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3092 59 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3092 60 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3092 61 was be VBD 37231 3092 62 the the DT 37231 3092 63 son son NN 37231 3092 64 of of IN 37231 3092 65 Jacob Jacob NNP 37231 3092 66 and and CC 37231 3092 67 Judah Judah NNP 37231 3092 68 according accord VBG 37231 3092 69 to to IN 37231 3092 70 successive successive JJ 37231 3092 71 descent descent NN 37231 3092 72 . . . 37231 3093 1 " " `` 37231 3093 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3093 3 4 4 LS 37231 3093 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3093 5 The the DT 37231 3093 6 genealogy genealogy NN 37231 3093 7 of of IN 37231 3093 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3093 9 in in IN 37231 3093 10 the the DT 37231 3093 11 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3093 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3093 13 , , , 37231 3093 14 on on IN 37231 3093 15 the the DT 37231 3093 16 contrary contrary NN 37231 3093 17 , , , 37231 3093 18 is be VBZ 37231 3093 19 traced trace VBN 37231 3093 20 solely solely RB 37231 3093 21 through through IN 37231 3093 22 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3093 23 , , , 37231 3093 24 who who WP 37231 3093 25 alone alone RB 37231 3093 26 is be VBZ 37231 3093 27 stated state VBN 37231 3093 28 to to TO 37231 3093 29 be be VB 37231 3093 30 of of IN 37231 3093 31 the the DT 37231 3093 32 lineage lineage NN 37231 3093 33 of of IN 37231 3093 34 David David NNP 37231 3093 35 . . . 37231 3094 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3094 2 5 5 LS 37231 3094 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3094 4 The the DT 37231 3094 5 genealogies genealogy NNS 37231 3094 6 of of IN 37231 3094 7 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3094 8 and and CC 37231 3094 9 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3094 10 , , , 37231 3094 11 though though IN 37231 3094 12 differing differ VBG 37231 3094 13 in in IN 37231 3094 14 several several JJ 37231 3094 15 important important JJ 37231 3094 16 points point NNS 37231 3094 17 , , , 37231 3094 18 at at IN 37231 3094 19 least least JJS 37231 3094 20 agree agree VB 37231 3094 21 in in IN 37231 3094 22 excluding exclude VBG 37231 3094 23 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3094 24 . . . 37231 3095 1 That that DT 37231 3095 2 of of IN 37231 3095 3 the the DT 37231 3095 4 third third JJ 37231 3095 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3095 6 commences commence VBZ 37231 3095 7 with with IN 37231 3095 8 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3095 9 , , , 37231 3095 10 { { -LRB- 37231 3095 11 301 301 CD 37231 3095 12 } } -RRB- 37231 3095 13 and and CC 37231 3095 14 that that DT 37231 3095 15 of of IN 37231 3095 16 the the DT 37231 3095 17 first first JJ 37231 3095 18 ends end NNS 37231 3095 19 with with IN 37231 3095 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3095 21 : : : 37231 3095 22 " " `` 37231 3095 23 And and CC 37231 3095 24 Jacob Jacob NNP 37231 3095 25 begat beget VBZ 37231 3095 26 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3095 27 , , , 37231 3095 28 the the DT 37231 3095 29 husband husband NN 37231 3095 30 of of IN 37231 3095 31 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3095 32 , , , 37231 3095 33 of of IN 37231 3095 34 whom whom WP 37231 3095 35 was be VBD 37231 3095 36 born bear VBN 37231 3095 37 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3095 38 , , , 37231 3095 39 who who WP 37231 3095 40 is be VBZ 37231 3095 41 called call VBN 37231 3095 42 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3095 43 . . . 37231 3096 1 " " `` 37231 3096 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3096 3 1 1 LS 37231 3096 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3096 5 The the DT 37231 3096 6 angel angel NN 37231 3096 7 who who WP 37231 3096 8 warns warn VBZ 37231 3096 9 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3096 10 not not RB 37231 3096 11 to to TO 37231 3096 12 put put VB 37231 3096 13 away away RB 37231 3096 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3096 15 wife wife NN 37231 3096 16 , , , 37231 3096 17 addresses address VBZ 37231 3096 18 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3096 19 as as IN 37231 3096 20 " " `` 37231 3096 21 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3096 22 , , , 37231 3096 23 thou thou NNP 37231 3096 24 son son NN 37231 3096 25 of of IN 37231 3096 26 David,"(2 David,"(2 NNP 37231 3096 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3096 28 and and CC 37231 3096 29 the the DT 37231 3096 30 angel angel NN 37231 3096 31 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 3096 32 , , , 37231 3096 33 who who WP 37231 3096 34 , , , 37231 3096 35 according accord VBG 37231 3096 36 to to IN 37231 3096 37 the the DT 37231 3096 38 third third JJ 37231 3096 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3096 40 , , , 37231 3096 41 announces announce VBZ 37231 3096 42 to to IN 37231 3096 43 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3096 44 the the DT 37231 3096 45 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 3096 46 conception conception NN 37231 3096 47 , , , 37231 3096 48 is be VBZ 37231 3096 49 sent send VBN 37231 3096 50 " " '' 37231 3096 51 to to IN 37231 3096 52 a a DT 37231 3096 53 virgin virgin NN 37231 3096 54 espoused espouse VBN 37231 3096 55 to to IN 37231 3096 56 a a DT 37231 3096 57 man man NN 37231 3096 58 whose whose WP$ 37231 3096 59 name name NN 37231 3096 60 was be VBD 37231 3096 61 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3096 62 , , , 37231 3096 63 of of IN 37231 3096 64 the the DT 37231 3096 65 house house NN 37231 3096 66 of of IN 37231 3096 67 David David NNP 37231 3096 68 . . . 37231 3097 1 " " `` 37231 3097 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3097 3 3 3 LS 37231 3097 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3097 5 So so RB 37231 3097 6 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3097 7 , , , 37231 3097 8 however however RB 37231 3097 9 , , , 37231 3097 10 is be VBZ 37231 3097 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3097 12 in in IN 37231 3097 13 ignoring ignore VBG 37231 3097 14 this this DT 37231 3097 15 Davidic davidic JJ 37231 3097 16 descent descent NN 37231 3097 17 through through IN 37231 3097 18 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3097 19 , , , 37231 3097 20 that that IN 37231 3097 21 not not RB 37231 3097 22 only only RB 37231 3097 23 does do VBZ 37231 3097 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3097 25 at at IN 37231 3097 26 least least JJS 37231 3097 27 eleven eleven CD 37231 3097 28 times time NNS 37231 3097 29 trace trace VB 37231 3097 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3097 31 through through IN 37231 3097 32 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3097 33 , , , 37231 3097 34 but but CC 37231 3097 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3097 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3097 37 materially materially RB 37231 3097 38 differs differ VBZ 37231 3097 39 from from IN 37231 3097 40 the the DT 37231 3097 41 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3097 42 , , , 37231 3097 43 where where WRB 37231 3097 44 the the DT 37231 3097 45 descent descent NN 37231 3097 46 of of IN 37231 3097 47 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3097 48 from from IN 37231 3097 49 David David NNP 37231 3097 50 is be VBZ 37231 3097 51 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3097 52 by by IN 37231 3097 53 the the DT 37231 3097 54 latter latter JJ 37231 3097 55 . . . 37231 3098 1 In in IN 37231 3098 2 the the DT 37231 3098 3 third third JJ 37231 3098 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3098 5 , , , 37231 3098 6 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3098 7 goes go VBZ 37231 3098 8 to to IN 37231 3098 9 Judaea Judaea NNP 37231 3098 10 " " `` 37231 3098 11 unto unto IN 37231 3098 12 the the DT 37231 3098 13 city city NN 37231 3098 14 of of IN 37231 3098 15 David David NNP 37231 3098 16 , , , 37231 3098 17 which which WDT 37231 3098 18 is be VBZ 37231 3098 19 called call VBN 37231 3098 20 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3098 21 , , , 37231 3098 22 because because IN 37231 3098 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3098 24 was be VBD 37231 3098 25 of of IN 37231 3098 26 the the DT 37231 3098 27 house house NN 37231 3098 28 and and CC 37231 3098 29 lineage lineage NN 37231 3098 30 of of IN 37231 3098 31 David David NNP 37231 3098 32 . . . 37231 3099 1 " " `` 37231 3099 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3099 3 4 4 LS 37231 3099 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3099 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3099 6 , , , 37231 3099 7 however however RB 37231 3099 8 , , , 37231 3099 9 simply simply RB 37231 3099 10 states state VBZ 37231 3099 11 that that IN 37231 3099 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3099 13 went go VBD 37231 3099 14 " " `` 37231 3099 15 to to IN 37231 3099 16 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3099 17 ... ... NFP 37231 3099 18 for for IN 37231 3099 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3099 20 descent descent NN 37231 3099 21 was be VBD 37231 3099 22 from from IN 37231 3099 23 the the DT 37231 3099 24 tribe tribe NN 37231 3099 25 of of IN 37231 3099 26 Judah Judah NNP 37231 3099 27 , , , 37231 3099 28 which which WDT 37231 3099 29 inhabited inhabit VBD 37231 3099 30 that that IN 37231 3099 31 region region NN 37231 3099 32 . . . 37231 3100 1 " " `` 37231 3100 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3100 3 5 5 LS 37231 3100 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3100 5 There there EX 37231 3100 6 can can MD 37231 3100 7 be be VB 37231 3100 8 no no DT 37231 3100 9 doubt doubt NN 37231 3100 10 that that IN 37231 3100 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3100 12 not not RB 37231 3100 13 only only RB 37231 3100 14 did do VBD 37231 3100 15 not not RB 37231 3100 16 derive derive VB 37231 3100 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3100 18 genealogies genealogy NNS 37231 3100 19 from from IN 37231 3100 20 the the DT 37231 3100 21 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3100 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3100 23 , , , 37231 3100 24 but but CC 37231 3100 25 that that IN 37231 3100 26 on on IN 37231 3100 27 the the DT 37231 3100 28 contrary contrary NN 37231 3100 29 the the DT 37231 3100 30 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3100 31 , , , 37231 3100 32 from from IN 37231 3100 33 which which WDT 37231 3100 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3100 35 did do VBD 37231 3100 36 learn learn VB 37231 3100 37 the the DT 37231 3100 38 Davidic davidic JJ 37231 3100 39 descent descent NN 37231 3100 40 through through IN 37231 3100 41 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3100 42 only only RB 37231 3100 43 , , , 37231 3100 44 differed differ VBD 37231 3100 45 persistently persistently RB 37231 3100 46 and and CC 37231 3100 47 materially materially RB 37231 3100 48 from from IN 37231 3100 49 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3100 50 . . . 37231 3101 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3101 2 6 6 LS 37231 3101 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3101 4 Many many JJ 37231 3101 5 traces trace NNS 37231 3101 6 still still RB 37231 3101 7 exist exist VBP 37231 3101 8 to to TO 37231 3101 9 show show VB 37231 3101 10 that that IN 37231 3101 11 the the DT 37231 3101 12 view view NN 37231 3101 13 of of IN 37231 3101 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3101 15 's 's POS 37231 3101 16 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3101 17 of of IN 37231 3101 18 the the DT 37231 3101 19 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3101 20 of of IN 37231 3101 21 the the DT 37231 3101 22 Davidic davidic JJ 37231 3101 23 descent descent NN 37231 3101 24 of of IN 37231 3101 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3101 26 through through IN 37231 3101 27 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3101 28 instead instead RB 37231 3101 29 of of IN 37231 3101 30 through through IN 37231 3101 31 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3101 32 , , , 37231 3101 33 as as IN 37231 3101 34 the the DT 37231 3101 35 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3101 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3101 37 represent represent VBP 37231 3101 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3101 39 , , , 37231 3101 40 was be VBD 37231 3101 41 anciently anciently RB 37231 3101 42 held hold VBN 37231 3101 43 in in IN 37231 3101 44 the the DT 37231 3101 45 Church Church NNP 37231 3101 46 . . . 37231 3102 1 Apocryphal Apocryphal NNP 37231 3102 2 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3102 3 of of IN 37231 3102 4 early early JJ 37231 3102 5 date date NN 37231 3102 6 , , , 37231 3102 7 based base VBN 37231 3102 8 without without IN 37231 3102 9 doubt doubt NN 37231 3102 10 upon upon IN 37231 3102 11 more more RBR 37231 3102 12 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3102 13 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 3102 14 works work NNS 37231 3102 15 , , , 37231 3102 16 are be VBP 37231 3102 17 still still RB 37231 3102 18 extant extant JJ 37231 3102 19 , , , 37231 3102 20 in in IN 37231 3102 21 which which WDT 37231 3102 22 the the DT 37231 3102 23 genealogy genealogy NN 37231 3102 24 of of IN 37231 3102 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3102 26 is be VBZ 37231 3102 27 traced trace VBN 37231 3102 28 , , , 37231 3102 29 as as IN 37231 3102 30 in in IN 37231 3102 31 { { -LRB- 37231 3102 32 302 302 CD 37231 3102 33 } } -RRB- 37231 3102 34 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3102 35 's 's POS 37231 3102 36 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3102 37 , , , 37231 3102 38 through through IN 37231 3102 39 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3102 40 . . . 37231 3103 1 One one CD 37231 3103 2 of of IN 37231 3103 3 these these DT 37231 3103 4 is be VBZ 37231 3103 5 the the DT 37231 3103 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3103 7 of of IN 37231 3103 8 James James NNP 37231 3103 9 , , , 37231 3103 10 commonly commonly RB 37231 3103 11 called call VBD 37231 3103 12 the the DT 37231 3103 13 _ _ NNP 37231 3103 14 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3103 15 _ _ NNP 37231 3103 16 , , , 37231 3103 17 a a DT 37231 3103 18 work work NN 37231 3103 19 referred refer VBD 37231 3103 20 to to IN 37231 3103 21 by by IN 37231 3103 22 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 3103 23 writers writer NNS 37231 3103 24 of of IN 37231 3103 25 the the DT 37231 3103 26 third third JJ 37231 3103 27 and and CC 37231 3103 28 fourth fourth JJ 37231 3103 29 centuries,(1 centuries,(1 NN 37231 3103 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3103 31 and and CC 37231 3103 32 which which WDT 37231 3103 33 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3103 34 even even RB 37231 3103 35 ascribes ascribe VBZ 37231 3103 36 to to IN 37231 3103 37 the the DT 37231 3103 38 first first JJ 37231 3103 39 three three CD 37231 3103 40 decades decade NNS 37231 3103 41 of of IN 37231 3103 42 the the DT 37231 3103 43 second second JJ 37231 3103 44 century,(2 century,(2 NNS 37231 3103 45 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3103 46 in in IN 37231 3103 47 which which WDT 37231 3103 48 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3103 49 is be VBZ 37231 3103 50 stated state VBN 37231 3103 51 to to TO 37231 3103 52 be be VB 37231 3103 53 of of IN 37231 3103 54 the the DT 37231 3103 55 lineage lineage NN 37231 3103 56 of of IN 37231 3103 57 David David NNP 37231 3103 58 . . . 37231 3104 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3104 2 3 3 LS 37231 3104 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3104 4 She -PRON- PRP 37231 3104 5 is be VBZ 37231 3104 6 also also RB 37231 3104 7 described describe VBN 37231 3104 8 as as IN 37231 3104 9 of of IN 37231 3104 10 the the DT 37231 3104 11 royal royal JJ 37231 3104 12 race race NN 37231 3104 13 and and CC 37231 3104 14 family family NN 37231 3104 15 of of IN 37231 3104 16 David David NNP 37231 3104 17 in in IN 37231 3104 18 the the DT 37231 3104 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3104 20 of of IN 37231 3104 21 the the DT 37231 3104 22 Nativity Nativity NNP 37231 3104 23 of of IN 37231 3104 24 Mary,(4 Mary,(4 NNP 37231 3104 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3104 26 and and CC 37231 3104 27 in in IN 37231 3104 28 the the DT 37231 3104 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3104 30 of of IN 37231 3104 31 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 3104 32 - - : 37231 3104 33 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3104 34 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3104 35 Davidic davidic JJ 37231 3104 36 descent descent NN 37231 3104 37 is be VBZ 37231 3104 38 prominently prominently RB 37231 3104 39 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3104 40 . . . 37231 3105 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3105 2 5 5 LS 37231 3105 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3105 4 There there EX 37231 3105 5 can can MD 37231 3105 6 be be VB 37231 3105 7 no no DT 37231 3105 8 doubt doubt NN 37231 3105 9 that that IN 37231 3105 10 all all DT 37231 3105 11 of of IN 37231 3105 12 these these DT 37231 3105 13 works work NNS 37231 3105 14 are be VBP 37231 3105 15 based base VBN 37231 3105 16 upon upon IN 37231 3105 17 earlier early JJR 37231 3105 18 originals,(6 originals,(6 NNP 37231 3105 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3105 20 and and CC 37231 3105 21 there there EX 37231 3105 22 is be VBZ 37231 3105 23 no no DT 37231 3105 24 reason reason NN 37231 3105 25 why why WRB 37231 3105 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3105 27 may may MD 37231 3105 28 not not RB 37231 3105 29 have have VB 37231 3105 30 been be VBN 37231 3105 31 drawn draw VBN 37231 3105 32 from from IN 37231 3105 33 the the DT 37231 3105 34 same same JJ 37231 3105 35 source source NN 37231 3105 36 from from IN 37231 3105 37 which which WDT 37231 3105 38 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3105 39 derived derive VBD 37231 3105 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3105 41 version version NN 37231 3105 42 of of IN 37231 3105 43 the the DT 37231 3105 44 genealogy genealogy NN 37231 3105 45 in in IN 37231 3105 46 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 3105 47 to to IN 37231 3105 48 the the DT 37231 3105 49 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3105 50 . . . 37231 3106 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3106 2 7 7 LS 37231 3106 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3106 4 In in IN 37231 3106 5 the the DT 37231 3106 6 narrative narrative NN 37231 3106 7 of of IN 37231 3106 8 the the DT 37231 3106 9 events event NNS 37231 3106 10 which which WDT 37231 3106 11 preceded precede VBD 37231 3106 12 the the DT 37231 3106 13 { { -LRB- 37231 3106 14 303 303 CD 37231 3106 15 } } -RRB- 37231 3106 16 birth birth NN 37231 3106 17 of of IN 37231 3106 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3106 19 , , , 37231 3106 20 the the DT 37231 3106 21 first first JJ 37231 3106 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3106 23 describes describe VBZ 37231 3106 24 the the DT 37231 3106 25 angel angel NN 37231 3106 26 as as IN 37231 3106 27 appearing appear VBG 37231 3106 28 only only RB 37231 3106 29 to to IN 37231 3106 30 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3106 31 and and CC 37231 3106 32 explaining explain VBG 37231 3106 33 the the DT 37231 3106 34 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 3106 35 conception,(1 conception,(1 NN 37231 3106 36 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3106 37 and and CC 37231 3106 38 the the DT 37231 3106 39 author author NN 37231 3106 40 seems seem VBZ 37231 3106 41 to to TO 37231 3106 42 know know VB 37231 3106 43 nothing nothing NN 37231 3106 44 of of IN 37231 3106 45 any any DT 37231 3106 46 announcement announcement NN 37231 3106 47 to to IN 37231 3106 48 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3106 49 . . . 37231 3107 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3107 2 2 2 LS 37231 3107 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3107 4 The the DT 37231 3107 5 third third JJ 37231 3107 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3107 7 , , , 37231 3107 8 on on IN 37231 3107 9 the the DT 37231 3107 10 contrary contrary NN 37231 3107 11 , , , 37231 3107 12 does do VBZ 37231 3107 13 not not RB 37231 3107 14 mention mention VB 37231 3107 15 any any DT 37231 3107 16 such such JJ 37231 3107 17 angelic angelic JJ 37231 3107 18 appearance appearance NN 37231 3107 19 to to IN 37231 3107 20 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3107 21 , , , 37231 3107 22 but but CC 37231 3107 23 represents represent VBZ 37231 3107 24 the the DT 37231 3107 25 angel angel NN 37231 3107 26 as as IN 37231 3107 27 announcing announce VBG 37231 3107 28 the the DT 37231 3107 29 conception conception NN 37231 3107 30 to to IN 37231 3107 31 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3107 32 herself -PRON- PRP 37231 3107 33 alone alone JJ 37231 3107 34 . . . 37231 3108 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3108 2 3 3 LS 37231 3108 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3108 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3108 5 's 's POS 37231 3108 6 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3108 7 know know VBP 37231 3108 8 of of IN 37231 3108 9 the the DT 37231 3108 10 appearances appearance NNS 37231 3108 11 both both DT 37231 3108 12 to to IN 37231 3108 13 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3108 14 and and CC 37231 3108 15 to to IN 37231 3108 16 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3108 17 , , , 37231 3108 18 but but CC 37231 3108 19 the the DT 37231 3108 20 words word NNS 37231 3108 21 spoken speak VBN 37231 3108 22 by by IN 37231 3108 23 the the DT 37231 3108 24 angel angel NN 37231 3108 25 on on IN 37231 3108 26 each each DT 37231 3108 27 occasion occasion NN 37231 3108 28 differ differ VBP 37231 3108 29 materially materially RB 37231 3108 30 from from IN 37231 3108 31 those those DT 37231 3108 32 of of IN 37231 3108 33 both both DT 37231 3108 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3108 35 . . . 37231 3109 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3109 2 4 4 LS 37231 3109 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3109 4 In in IN 37231 3109 5 this this DT 37231 3109 6 place place NN 37231 3109 7 , , , 37231 3109 8 only only RB 37231 3109 9 one one CD 37231 3109 10 point point NN 37231 3109 11 , , , 37231 3109 12 however however RB 37231 3109 13 , , , 37231 3109 14 can can MD 37231 3109 15 be be VB 37231 3109 16 noticed notice VBN 37231 3109 17 . . . 37231 3110 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3110 2 describes describe VBZ 37231 3110 3 the the DT 37231 3110 4 angel angel NN 37231 3110 5 as as IN 37231 3110 6 saying say VBG 37231 3110 7 to to IN 37231 3110 8 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3110 9 : : : 37231 3110 10 " " `` 37231 3110 11 ' ' `` 37231 3110 12 Behold Behold NNP 37231 3110 13 , , , 37231 3110 14 thou thou NNP 37231 3110 15 shalt shalt NNP 37231 3110 16 conceive conceive NNP 37231 3110 17 of of IN 37231 3110 18 the the DT 37231 3110 19 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3110 20 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 3110 21 , , , 37231 3110 22 and and CC 37231 3110 23 shalt shalt NN 37231 3110 24 bear bear VB 37231 3110 25 a a DT 37231 3110 26 son son NN 37231 3110 27 , , , 37231 3110 28 and and CC 37231 3110 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3110 30 shall shall MD 37231 3110 31 be be VB 37231 3110 32 called call VBN 37231 3110 33 the the DT 37231 3110 34 Son Son NNP 37231 3110 35 of of IN 37231 3110 36 the the DT 37231 3110 37 Highest high JJS 37231 3110 38 , , , 37231 3110 39 and and CC 37231 3110 40 thou thou NNP 37231 3110 41 shalt shalt NNP 37231 3110 42 call call VB 37231 3110 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3110 44 name name NN 37231 3110 45 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3110 46 , , , 37231 3110 47 for for IN 37231 3110 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3110 49 shall shall MD 37231 3110 50 save save VB 37231 3110 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3110 52 people people NNS 37231 3110 53 from from IN 37231 3110 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3110 55 sins sin NNS 37231 3110 56 , , , 37231 3110 57 ' ' '' 37231 3110 58 as as IN 37231 3110 59 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3110 60 taught teach VBD 37231 3110 61 who who WP 37231 3110 62 recorded record VBD 37231 3110 63 everything everything NN 37231 3110 64 that that WDT 37231 3110 65 concerns concern VBZ 37231 3110 66 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3110 67 Saviour Saviour NNP 37231 3110 68 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3110 69 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3110 70 . . . 37231 3111 1 " " `` 37231 3111 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3111 3 5 5 CD 37231 3111 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3111 5 Now now UH 37231 3111 6 this this DT 37231 3111 7 is be VBZ 37231 3111 8 a a DT 37231 3111 9 clear clear JJ 37231 3111 10 and and CC 37231 3111 11 direct direct JJ 37231 3111 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3111 13 , , , 37231 3111 14 but but CC 37231 3111 15 besides besides IN 37231 3111 16 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3111 17 differing differ VBG 37231 3111 18 in in IN 37231 3111 19 form form NN 37231 3111 20 from from IN 37231 3111 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3111 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3111 23 , , , 37231 3111 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3111 25 presents present VBZ 37231 3111 26 the the DT 37231 3111 27 important important JJ 37231 3111 28 peculiarity peculiarity NN 37231 3111 29 that that WDT 37231 3111 30 the the DT 37231 3111 31 words word NNS 37231 3111 32 , , , 37231 3111 33 " " '' 37231 3111 34 for for IN 37231 3111 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3111 36 shall shall MD 37231 3111 37 save save VB 37231 3111 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3111 39 people people NNS 37231 3111 40 from from IN 37231 3111 41 { { -LRB- 37231 3111 42 304 304 CD 37231 3111 43 } } -RRB- 37231 3111 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3111 45 sins sin NNS 37231 3111 46 , , , 37231 3111 47 " " `` 37231 3111 48 are be VBP 37231 3111 49 not not RB 37231 3111 50 , , , 37231 3111 51 in in IN 37231 3111 52 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3111 53 , , , 37231 3111 54 addressed address VBD 37231 3111 55 to to IN 37231 3111 56 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3111 57 at at RB 37231 3111 58 all all RB 37231 3111 59 , , , 37231 3111 60 but but CC 37231 3111 61 that that IN 37231 3111 62 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3111 63 occur occur VBP 37231 3111 64 in in IN 37231 3111 65 the the DT 37231 3111 66 first first JJ 37231 3111 67 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3111 68 in in IN 37231 3111 69 the the DT 37231 3111 70 address address NN 37231 3111 71 of of IN 37231 3111 72 the the DT 37231 3111 73 angel angel NN 37231 3111 74 to to IN 37231 3111 75 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3111 76 . . . 37231 3112 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3112 2 1 1 LS 37231 3112 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3112 4 These these DT 37231 3112 5 words word NNS 37231 3112 6 , , , 37231 3112 7 however however RB 37231 3112 8 , , , 37231 3112 9 are be VBP 37231 3112 10 not not RB 37231 3112 11 accidentally accidentally RB 37231 3112 12 inserted insert VBN 37231 3112 13 in in IN 37231 3112 14 this this DT 37231 3112 15 place place NN 37231 3112 16 , , , 37231 3112 17 for for IN 37231 3112 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3112 19 find find VBP 37231 3112 20 that that IN 37231 3112 21 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3112 22 are be VBP 37231 3112 23 joined join VBN 37231 3112 24 in in IN 37231 3112 25 the the DT 37231 3112 26 same same JJ 37231 3112 27 manner manner NN 37231 3112 28 to to IN 37231 3112 29 the the DT 37231 3112 30 address address NN 37231 3112 31 of of IN 37231 3112 32 the the DT 37231 3112 33 angel angel NN 37231 3112 34 to to IN 37231 3112 35 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3112 36 in in IN 37231 3112 37 the the DT 37231 3112 38 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3112 39 of of IN 37231 3112 40 James James NNP 37231 3112 41 : : : 37231 3112 42 " " `` 37231 3112 43 For for IN 37231 3112 44 the the DT 37231 3112 45 power power NN 37231 3112 46 of of IN 37231 3112 47 the the DT 37231 3112 48 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3112 49 will will MD 37231 3112 50 overshadow overshadow VB 37231 3112 51 thee thee PRP 37231 3112 52 ; ; : 37231 3112 53 wherefore wherefore VBD 37231 3112 54 also also RB 37231 3112 55 that that DT 37231 3112 56 holy holy JJ 37231 3112 57 thing thing NN 37231 3112 58 which which WDT 37231 3112 59 is be VBZ 37231 3112 60 born bear VBN 37231 3112 61 of of IN 37231 3112 62 thee thee PRP 37231 3112 63 shall shall MD 37231 3112 64 be be VB 37231 3112 65 called call VBN 37231 3112 66 the the DT 37231 3112 67 Son Son NNP 37231 3112 68 of of IN 37231 3112 69 the the DT 37231 3112 70 Highest high JJS 37231 3112 71 , , , 37231 3112 72 and and CC 37231 3112 73 thou thou NNP 37231 3112 74 shalt shalt NNP 37231 3112 75 call call VB 37231 3112 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3112 77 name name NN 37231 3112 78 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3112 79 , , , 37231 3112 80 for for IN 37231 3112 81 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3112 82 shall shall MD 37231 3112 83 save save VB 37231 3112 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3112 85 people people NNS 37231 3112 86 from from IN 37231 3112 87 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3112 88 sins sin NNS 37231 3112 89 . . . 37231 3113 1 " " `` 37231 3113 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3113 3 2 2 LS 37231 3113 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3113 5 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3113 6 states state VBZ 37231 3113 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3113 8 own own JJ 37231 3113 9 opinion opinion NN 37231 3113 10 that that IN 37231 3113 11 this this DT 37231 3113 12 passage passage NN 37231 3113 13 is be VBZ 37231 3113 14 a a DT 37231 3113 15 recollection recollection NN 37231 3113 16 of of IN 37231 3113 17 the the DT 37231 3113 18 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3113 19 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 3113 20 added add VBN 37231 3113 21 by by IN 37231 3113 22 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3113 23 to to IN 37231 3113 24 the the DT 37231 3113 25 account account NN 37231 3113 26 in in IN 37231 3113 27 Luke,(3 Luke,(3 NNP 37231 3113 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3113 29 but but CC 37231 3113 30 the the DT 37231 3113 31 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 3113 32 nature nature NN 37231 3113 33 of of IN 37231 3113 34 the the DT 37231 3113 35 limitation limitation NN 37231 3113 36 " " `` 37231 3113 37 unconsciously unconsciously RB 37231 3113 38 " " '' 37231 3113 39 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3113 40 ohne ohne NNP 37231 3113 41 dass dass NNP 37231 3113 42 er er NNP 37231 3113 43 sich sich NNP 37231 3113 44 dessen dessen NNP 37231 3113 45 bewusst bewusst NNP 37231 3113 46 war war NNP 37231 3113 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3113 48 here here RB 37231 3113 49 is be VBZ 37231 3113 50 evident evident JJ 37231 3113 51 . . . 37231 3114 1 There there EX 37231 3114 2 is be VBZ 37231 3114 3 a a DT 37231 3114 4 point point NN 37231 3114 5 in in IN 37231 3114 6 connection connection NN 37231 3114 7 with with IN 37231 3114 8 this this DT 37231 3114 9 which which WDT 37231 3114 10 merits merit VBZ 37231 3114 11 a a DT 37231 3114 12 moment moment NN 37231 3114 13 's 's POS 37231 3114 14 attention attention NN 37231 3114 15 . . . 37231 3115 1 In in IN 37231 3115 2 the the DT 37231 3115 3 text text NN 37231 3115 4 of of IN 37231 3115 5 the the DT 37231 3115 6 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3115 7 , , , 37231 3115 8 edited edit VBN 37231 3115 9 by by IN 37231 3115 10 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3115 11 , , , 37231 3115 12 the the DT 37231 3115 13 angel angel NN 37231 3115 14 commences commence VBZ 37231 3115 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3115 16 address address NN 37231 3115 17 to to IN 37231 3115 18 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3115 19 by by IN 37231 3115 20 saying say VBG 37231 3115 21 : : : 37231 3115 22 " " `` 37231 3115 23 Fear fear VB 37231 3115 24 not not RB 37231 3115 25 , , , 37231 3115 26 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3115 27 , , , 37231 3115 28 for for IN 37231 3115 29 thou thou NNP 37231 3115 30 hast hast NNP 37231 3115 31 found find VBD 37231 3115 32 favour favour NN 37231 3115 33 before before IN 37231 3115 34 the the DT 37231 3115 35 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3115 36 , , , 37231 3115 37 and and CC 37231 3115 38 thou thou NNP 37231 3115 39 shalt shalt NNP 37231 3115 40 conceive conceive NNP 37231 3115 41 of of IN 37231 3115 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3115 43 Word Word NNP 37231 3115 44 " " '' 37231 3115 45 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3115 46 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3115 47 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3115 48 . . . 37231 3116 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3116 2 4 4 LS 37231 3116 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3116 4 Now now RB 37231 3116 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3116 6 , , , 37231 3116 7 after after IN 37231 3116 8 quoting quote VBG 37231 3116 9 the the DT 37231 3116 10 passage passage NN 37231 3116 11 above above RB 37231 3116 12 , , , 37231 3116 13 continues continue VBZ 37231 3116 14 to to TO 37231 3116 15 argue argue VB 37231 3116 16 that that IN 37231 3116 17 the the DT 37231 3116 18 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 3116 19 and and CC 37231 3116 20 the the DT 37231 3116 21 power power NN 37231 3116 22 of of IN 37231 3116 23 God God NNP 37231 3116 24 must must MD 37231 3116 25 not not RB 37231 3116 26 be be VB 37231 3116 27 misunderstood misunderstand VBN 37231 3116 28 to to TO 37231 3116 29 mean mean VB 37231 3116 30 anything anything NN 37231 3116 31 else else RB 37231 3116 32 than than IN 37231 3116 33 the the DT 37231 3116 34 Word Word NNP 37231 3116 35 , , , 37231 3116 36 who who WP 37231 3116 37 is be VBZ 37231 3116 38 also also RB 37231 3116 39 the the DT 37231 3116 40 first first JJ 37231 3116 41 born bear VBN 37231 3116 42 of of IN 37231 3116 43 God God NNP 37231 3116 44 as as IN 37231 3116 45 the the DT 37231 3116 46 prophet prophet NN 37231 3116 47 Moses Moses NNP 37231 3116 48 declared declare VBD 37231 3116 49 ; ; : 37231 3116 50 and and CC 37231 3116 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3116 52 was be VBD 37231 3116 53 this this DT 37231 3116 54 which which WDT 37231 3116 55 , , , 37231 3116 56 when when WRB 37231 3116 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3116 58 came come VBD 37231 3116 59 upon upon IN 37231 3116 60 the the DT 37231 3116 61 Virgin Virgin NNP 37231 3116 62 and and CC 37231 3116 63 overshadowed overshadow VBD 37231 3116 64 her -PRON- PRP 37231 3116 65 , , , 37231 3116 66 caused cause VBN 37231 3116 67 { { -LRB- 37231 3116 68 305 305 CD 37231 3116 69 } } -RRB- 37231 3116 70 her -PRON- PRP 37231 3116 71 to to TO 37231 3116 72 conceive conceive VB 37231 3116 73 . . . 37231 3117 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3117 2 1 1 LS 37231 3117 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3117 4 The the DT 37231 3117 5 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 3117 6 of of IN 37231 3117 7 the the DT 37231 3117 8 singular singular JJ 37231 3117 9 expression expression NN 37231 3117 10 in in IN 37231 3117 11 the the DT 37231 3117 12 Protovangelium Protovangelium NNP 37231 3117 13 and and CC 37231 3117 14 the the DT 37231 3117 15 similar similar JJ 37231 3117 16 explanation explanation NN 37231 3117 17 of of IN 37231 3117 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3117 19 immediately immediately RB 37231 3117 20 accompanying accompany VBG 37231 3117 21 a a DT 37231 3117 22 variation variation NN 37231 3117 23 from from IN 37231 3117 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3117 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3117 26 , , , 37231 3117 27 which which WDT 37231 3117 28 is be VBZ 37231 3117 29 equally equally RB 37231 3117 30 shared share VBN 37231 3117 31 by by IN 37231 3117 32 the the DT 37231 3117 33 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3117 34 work work NN 37231 3117 35 , , , 37231 3117 36 strengthens strengthen VBZ 37231 3117 37 the the DT 37231 3117 38 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 3117 39 of of IN 37231 3117 40 a a DT 37231 3117 41 similarity similarity NN 37231 3117 42 of of IN 37231 3117 43 origin origin NN 37231 3117 44 . . . 37231 3118 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3118 2 's 's POS 37231 3118 3 divergences divergence NNS 37231 3118 4 from from IN 37231 3118 5 the the DT 37231 3118 6 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3118 7 prevent prevent VB 37231 3118 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3118 9 supposing supposing NN 37231 3118 10 that that IN 37231 3118 11 , , , 37231 3118 12 in in IN 37231 3118 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3118 14 present present JJ 37231 3118 15 state state NN 37231 3118 16 , , , 37231 3118 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3118 18 could could MD 37231 3118 19 have have VB 37231 3118 20 been be VBN 37231 3118 21 the the DT 37231 3118 22 actual actual JJ 37231 3118 23 source source NN 37231 3118 24 of of IN 37231 3118 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3118 26 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3118 27 , , , 37231 3118 28 but but CC 37231 3118 29 the the DT 37231 3118 30 wide wide JJ 37231 3118 31 differences difference NNS 37231 3118 32 which which WDT 37231 3118 33 exist exist VBP 37231 3118 34 between between IN 37231 3118 35 the the DT 37231 3118 36 extant extant JJ 37231 3118 37 MSS mss NN 37231 3118 38 . . . 37231 3119 1 of of IN 37231 3119 2 the the DT 37231 3119 3 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3119 4 show show NN 37231 3119 5 that that IN 37231 3119 6 even even RB 37231 3119 7 the the DT 37231 3119 8 most most RBS 37231 3119 9 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3119 10 does do VBZ 37231 3119 11 not not RB 37231 3119 12 present present VB 37231 3119 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3119 14 in in IN 37231 3119 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3119 16 original original JJ 37231 3119 17 form form NN 37231 3119 18 . . . 37231 3120 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3120 2 is be VBZ 37231 3120 3 much much RB 37231 3120 4 more more RBR 37231 3120 5 probable probable JJ 37231 3120 6 that that IN 37231 3120 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3120 8 had have VBD 37231 3120 9 before before IN 37231 3120 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3120 11 a a DT 37231 3120 12 still still RB 37231 3120 13 older old JJR 37231 3120 14 work work NN 37231 3120 15 , , , 37231 3120 16 to to TO 37231 3120 17 which which WDT 37231 3120 18 both both DT 37231 3120 19 the the DT 37231 3120 20 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3120 21 and and CC 37231 3120 22 the the DT 37231 3120 23 third third JJ 37231 3120 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3120 25 were be VBD 37231 3120 26 indebted indebte VBN 37231 3120 27 . . . 37231 3121 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3121 2 2 2 LS 37231 3121 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3121 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3121 5 's 's POS 37231 3121 6 account account NN 37231 3121 7 of of IN 37231 3121 8 the the DT 37231 3121 9 removal removal NN 37231 3121 10 of of IN 37231 3121 11 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3121 12 to to IN 37231 3121 13 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3121 14 is be VBZ 37231 3121 15 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3121 16 , , , 37231 3121 17 and and CC 37231 3121 18 evidently evidently RB 37231 3121 19 is be VBZ 37231 3121 20 derived derive VBN 37231 3121 21 from from IN 37231 3121 22 a a DT 37231 3121 23 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3121 24 un un NNP 37231 3121 25 - - HYPH 37231 3121 26 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3121 27 source source NN 37231 3121 28 . . . 37231 3122 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3122 2 may may MD 37231 3122 3 be be VB 37231 3122 4 well well JJ 37231 3122 5 to to TO 37231 3122 6 present present VB 37231 3122 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3122 8 account account NN 37231 3122 9 and and CC 37231 3122 10 that that DT 37231 3122 11 of of IN 37231 3122 12 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3122 13 side side NN 37231 3122 14 by by IN 37231 3122 15 side side NN 37231 3122 16 : : : 37231 3122 17 { { -LRB- 37231 3122 18 306 306 CD 37231 3122 19 } } -RRB- 37231 3122 20 Attention attention NN 37231 3122 21 has have VBZ 37231 3122 22 already already RB 37231 3122 23 been be VBN 37231 3122 24 drawn draw VBN 37231 3122 25 to to IN 37231 3122 26 the the DT 37231 3122 27 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3122 28 manner manner NN 37231 3122 29 in in IN 37231 3122 30 which which WDT 37231 3122 31 the the DT 37231 3122 32 Davidic davidic JJ 37231 3122 33 descent descent NN 37231 3122 34 of of IN 37231 3122 35 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3122 36 is be VBZ 37231 3122 37 traced trace VBN 37231 3122 38 by by IN 37231 3122 39 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3122 40 through through IN 37231 3122 41 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3122 42 , , , 37231 3122 43 and and CC 37231 3122 44 to to IN 37231 3122 45 the the DT 37231 3122 46 suppression suppression NN 37231 3122 47 in in IN 37231 3122 48 this this DT 37231 3122 49 passage passage NN 37231 3122 50 of of IN 37231 3122 51 all all DT 37231 3122 52 that that WDT 37231 3122 53 might may MD 37231 3122 54 seem seem VB 37231 3122 55 to to TO 37231 3122 56 indicate indicate VB 37231 3122 57 a a DT 37231 3122 58 claim claim NN 37231 3122 59 of of IN 37231 3122 60 descent descent NN 37231 3122 61 through through IN 37231 3122 62 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3122 63 . . . 37231 3123 1 As as IN 37231 3123 2 the the DT 37231 3123 3 continuation continuation NN 37231 3123 4 of of IN 37231 3123 5 a a DT 37231 3123 6 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3123 7 representation representation NN 37231 3123 8 of of IN 37231 3123 9 the the DT 37231 3123 10 history history NN 37231 3123 11 of of IN 37231 3123 12 the the DT 37231 3123 13 infancy infancy NN 37231 3123 14 of of IN 37231 3123 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3123 16 , , , 37231 3123 17 differing differ VBG 37231 3123 18 materially materially RB 37231 3123 19 from from IN 37231 3123 20 that that DT 37231 3123 21 of of IN 37231 3123 22 the the DT 37231 3123 23 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3123 24 , , , 37231 3123 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3123 26 is be VBZ 37231 3123 27 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3123 28 to to TO 37231 3123 29 regard regard VB 37231 3123 30 this this DT 37231 3123 31 , , , 37231 3123 32 with with IN 37231 3123 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3123 34 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3123 35 variations variation NNS 37231 3123 36 , , , 37231 3123 37 as as IN 37231 3123 38 an an DT 37231 3123 39 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 3123 40 correction correction NN 37231 3123 41 by by IN 37231 3123 42 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3123 43 of of IN 37231 3123 44 the the DT 37231 3123 45 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3123 46 text text NN 37231 3123 47 , , , 37231 3123 48 and and CC 37231 3123 49 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3123 50 must must MD 37231 3123 51 hold hold VB 37231 3123 52 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3123 53 to to TO 37231 3123 54 be be VB 37231 3123 55 derived derive VBN 37231 3123 56 from from IN 37231 3123 57 a a DT 37231 3123 58 different different JJ 37231 3123 59 source source NN 37231 3123 60 , , , 37231 3123 61 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 3123 62 , , , 37231 3123 63 indeed indeed RB 37231 3123 64 , , , 37231 3123 65 one one CD 37231 3123 66 of of IN 37231 3123 67 those those DT 37231 3123 68 from from IN 37231 3123 69 which which WDT 37231 3123 70 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3123 71 's 's POS 37231 3123 72 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3123 73 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3123 74 first first RB 37231 3123 75 drew draw VBD 37231 3123 76 the the DT 37231 3123 77 elements element NNS 37231 3123 78 of of IN 37231 3123 79 the the DT 37231 3123 80 narrative narrative NN 37231 3123 81 , , , 37231 3123 82 and and CC 37231 3123 83 this this DT 37231 3123 84 persuasion persuasion NN 37231 3123 85 increases increase VBZ 37231 3123 86 as as IN 37231 3123 87 further further JJ 37231 3123 88 variations variation NNS 37231 3123 89 in in IN 37231 3123 90 the the DT 37231 3123 91 earlier early JJR 37231 3123 92 history history NN 37231 3123 93 , , , 37231 3123 94 presently presently RB 37231 3123 95 to to TO 37231 3123 96 be be VB 37231 3123 97 considered consider VBN 37231 3123 98 , , , 37231 3123 99 are be VBP 37231 3123 100 taken take VBN 37231 3123 101 into into IN 37231 3123 102 account account NN 37231 3123 103 . . . 37231 3124 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3124 2 is be VBZ 37231 3124 3 not not RB 37231 3124 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3124 5 to to TO 37231 3124 6 enter enter VB 37231 3124 7 into into IN 37231 3124 8 the the DT 37231 3124 9 question question NN 37231 3124 10 of of IN 37231 3124 11 the the DT 37231 3124 12 correctness correctness NN 37231 3124 13 of of IN 37231 3124 14 the the DT 37231 3124 15 date date NN 37231 3124 16 of of IN 37231 3124 17 this this DT 37231 3124 18 census census NN 37231 3124 19 , , , 37231 3124 20 but but CC 37231 3124 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3124 22 is be VBZ 37231 3124 23 evident evident JJ 37231 3124 24 that that IN 37231 3124 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3124 26 's 's POS 37231 3124 27 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3124 28 clearly clearly RB 37231 3124 29 and and CC 37231 3124 30 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 3124 31 modify modify VB 37231 3124 32 the the DT 37231 3124 33 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3124 34 narrative narrative NN 37231 3124 35 . . . 37231 3125 1 The the DT 37231 3125 2 limitation limitation NN 37231 3125 3 of of IN 37231 3125 4 the the DT 37231 3125 5 census census NN 37231 3125 6 to to IN 37231 3125 7 Judæa Judæa NNP 37231 3125 8 , , , 37231 3125 9 instead instead RB 37231 3125 10 of of IN 37231 3125 11 extending extend VBG 37231 3125 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3125 13 to to IN 37231 3125 14 the the DT 37231 3125 15 whole whole JJ 37231 3125 16 Roman Roman NNP 37231 3125 17 Empire Empire NNP 37231 3125 18 ; ; : 37231 3125 19 the the DT 37231 3125 20 designation designation NN 37231 3125 21 of of IN 37231 3125 22 Cyrenius Cyrenius NNP 37231 3125 23 as as IN 37231 3125 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3125 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3125 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3125 27 of of IN 37231 3125 28 Judaea Judaea NNP 37231 3125 29 instead instead RB 37231 3125 30 of of IN 37231 3125 31 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3125 32 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3125 33 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3125 34 of of IN 37231 3125 35 Syria Syria NNP 37231 3125 36 ; ; : 37231 3125 37 and and CC 37231 3125 38 the the DT 37231 3125 39 careful careful JJ 37231 3125 40 suppression suppression NN 37231 3125 41 of of IN 37231 3125 42 the the DT 37231 3125 43 Davidic davidic JJ 37231 3125 44 element element NN 37231 3125 45 in in IN 37231 3125 46 connection connection NN 37231 3125 47 with with IN 37231 3125 48 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3125 49 indicate indicate VBP 37231 3125 50 a a DT 37231 3125 51 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3125 52 written write VBN 37231 3125 53 source source NN 37231 3125 54 different different JJ 37231 3125 55 from from IN 37231 3125 56 the the DT 37231 3125 57 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3125 58 . . . 37231 3126 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3126 2 1 1 LS 37231 3126 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3126 4 Had have VBD 37231 3126 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3126 6 departed depart VBN 37231 3126 7 from from IN 37231 3126 8 the the DT 37231 3126 9 account account NN 37231 3126 10 in in IN 37231 3126 11 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3126 12 with with IN 37231 3126 13 the the DT 37231 3126 14 view view NN 37231 3126 15 of of IN 37231 3126 16 correcting correct VBG 37231 3126 17 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 37231 3126 18 statements statement NNS 37231 3126 19 , , , 37231 3126 20 the the DT 37231 3126 21 matter matter NN 37231 3126 22 might may MD 37231 3126 23 have have VB 37231 3126 24 seemed seem VBN 37231 3126 25 more more RBR 37231 3126 26 consistent consistent JJ 37231 3126 27 with with IN 37231 3126 28 the the DT 37231 3126 29 use use NN 37231 3126 30 of of IN 37231 3126 31 the the DT 37231 3126 32 third third JJ 37231 3126 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3126 34 , , , 37231 3126 35 although although IN 37231 3126 36 at at IN 37231 3126 37 the the DT 37231 3126 38 same same JJ 37231 3126 39 time time NN 37231 3126 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3126 41 might may MD 37231 3126 42 have have VB 37231 3126 43 evinced evince VBN 37231 3126 44 but but CC 37231 3126 45 little little JJ 37231 3126 46 reverence reverence NN 37231 3126 47 for for IN 37231 3126 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3126 49 as as IN 37231 3126 50 a a DT 37231 3126 51 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3126 52 { { -LRB- 37231 3126 53 307 307 CD 37231 3126 54 } } -RRB- 37231 3126 55 work work NN 37231 3126 56 . . . 37231 3127 1 On on IN 37231 3127 2 the the DT 37231 3127 3 contrary contrary NN 37231 3127 4 , , , 37231 3127 5 however however RB 37231 3127 6 , , , 37231 3127 7 the the DT 37231 3127 8 statements statement NNS 37231 3127 9 of of IN 37231 3127 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3127 11 are be VBP 37231 3127 12 still still RB 37231 3127 13 more more RBR 37231 3127 14 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37231 3127 15 with with IN 37231 3127 16 history history NN 37231 3127 17 than than IN 37231 3127 18 those those DT 37231 3127 19 in in IN 37231 3127 20 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3127 21 , , , 37231 3127 22 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37231 3127 23 as as IN 37231 3127 24 , , , 37231 3127 25 so so RB 37231 3127 26 far far RB 37231 3127 27 from from IN 37231 3127 28 being be VBG 37231 3127 29 the the DT 37231 3127 30 first first JJ 37231 3127 31 procurator procurator NN 37231 3127 32 of of IN 37231 3127 33 Judsea Judsea NNP 37231 3127 34 , , , 37231 3127 35 as as IN 37231 3127 36 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3127 37 's 's POS 37231 3127 38 narrative narrative JJ 37231 3127 39 states state NNS 37231 3127 40 in in IN 37231 3127 41 opposition opposition NN 37231 3127 42 to to IN 37231 3127 43 the the DT 37231 3127 44 third third JJ 37231 3127 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3127 46 , , , 37231 3127 47 Cyrenius Cyrenius NNP 37231 3127 48 never never RB 37231 3127 49 held hold VBD 37231 3127 50 that that DT 37231 3127 51 office office NN 37231 3127 52 , , , 37231 3127 53 but but CC 37231 3127 54 was be VBD 37231 3127 55 really really RB 37231 3127 56 , , , 37231 3127 57 later later RB 37231 3127 58 , , , 37231 3127 59 the the DT 37231 3127 60 imperial imperial JJ 37231 3127 61 proconsul proconsul NN 37231 3127 62 over over IN 37231 3127 63 Syria Syria NNP 37231 3127 64 , , , 37231 3127 65 and and CC 37231 3127 66 as as IN 37231 3127 67 such such JJ 37231 3127 68 , , , 37231 3127 69 when when WRB 37231 3127 70 Judaea Judaea NNP 37231 3127 71 became become VBD 37231 3127 72 a a DT 37231 3127 73 Roman roman JJ 37231 3127 74 province province NN 37231 3127 75 after after IN 37231 3127 76 the the DT 37231 3127 77 banishment banishment NN 37231 3127 78 of of IN 37231 3127 79 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 37231 3127 80 , , , 37231 3127 81 had have VBD 37231 3127 82 the the DT 37231 3127 83 power power NN 37231 3127 84 to to TO 37231 3127 85 enrol enrol VB 37231 3127 86 the the DT 37231 3127 87 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 37231 3127 88 , , , 37231 3127 89 and and CC 37231 3127 90 instituted institute VBN 37231 3127 91 Coponius Coponius NNP 37231 3127 92 as as IN 37231 3127 93 first first JJ 37231 3127 94 Procurator Procurator NNP 37231 3127 95 of of IN 37231 3127 96 Judaea Judaea NNP 37231 3127 97 . . . 37231 3128 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3128 2 's 's POS 37231 3128 3 statement statement NN 37231 3128 4 involves involve VBZ 37231 3128 5 the the DT 37231 3128 6 position position NN 37231 3128 7 that that IN 37231 3128 8 at at IN 37231 3128 9 one one CD 37231 3128 10 and and CC 37231 3128 11 the the DT 37231 3128 12 same same JJ 37231 3128 13 time time NN 37231 3128 14 Herod Herod NNP 37231 3128 15 was be VBD 37231 3128 16 the the DT 37231 3128 17 King King NNP 37231 3128 18 , , , 37231 3128 19 and and CC 37231 3128 20 Cyrenius Cyrenius NNP 37231 3128 21 the the DT 37231 3128 22 Roman Roman NNP 37231 3128 23 Procurator Procurator NNP 37231 3128 24 of of IN 37231 3128 25 Judsea Judsea NNP 37231 3128 26 . . . 37231 3129 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3129 2 1 1 LS 37231 3129 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3129 4 In in IN 37231 3129 5 the the DT 37231 3129 6 same same JJ 37231 3129 7 spirit spirit NN 37231 3129 8 , , , 37231 3129 9 and and CC 37231 3129 10 departing depart VBG 37231 3129 11 from from IN 37231 3129 12 the the DT 37231 3129 13 usual usual JJ 37231 3129 14 narrative narrative NN 37231 3129 15 of of IN 37231 3129 16 the the DT 37231 3129 17 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3129 18 , , , 37231 3129 19 which which WDT 37231 3129 20 couples couple VBZ 37231 3129 21 the the DT 37231 3129 22 birth birth NN 37231 3129 23 of of IN 37231 3129 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3129 25 with with IN 37231 3129 26 " " `` 37231 3129 27 the the DT 37231 3129 28 days day NNS 37231 3129 29 of of IN 37231 3129 30 Herod Herod NNP 37231 3129 31 the the DT 37231 3129 32 King king NN 37231 3129 33 , , , 37231 3129 34 " " '' 37231 3129 35 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3129 36 in in IN 37231 3129 37 another another DT 37231 3129 38 place place NN 37231 3129 39 states state NNS 37231 3129 40 that that WDT 37231 3129 41 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3129 42 was be VBD 37231 3129 43 born bear VBN 37231 3129 44 " " `` 37231 3129 45 under under IN 37231 3129 46 Cyrenius Cyrenius NNP 37231 3129 47 . . . 37231 3130 1 " " `` 37231 3130 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3130 3 2 2 LS 37231 3130 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3130 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3130 6 evidently evidently RB 37231 3130 7 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 3130 8 without without IN 37231 3130 9 criticism criticism NN 37231 3130 10 a a DT 37231 3130 11 narrative narrative NN 37231 3130 12 which which WDT 37231 3130 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3130 14 found find VBD 37231 3130 15 in in IN 37231 3130 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3130 17 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3130 18 , , , 37231 3130 19 and and CC 37231 3130 20 does do VBZ 37231 3130 21 not not RB 37231 3130 22 merely merely RB 37231 3130 23 correct correct JJ 37231 3130 24 and and CC 37231 3130 25 remodel remodel VB 37231 3130 26 a a DT 37231 3130 27 passage passage NN 37231 3130 28 of of IN 37231 3130 29 the the DT 37231 3130 30 third third JJ 37231 3130 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3130 32 , , , 37231 3130 33 but but CC 37231 3130 34 , , , 37231 3130 35 on on IN 37231 3130 36 the the DT 37231 3130 37 contrary contrary NN 37231 3130 38 , , , 37231 3130 39 seems seem VBZ 37231 3130 40 altogether altogether RB 37231 3130 41 ignorant ignorant JJ 37231 3130 42 of of IN 37231 3130 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3130 44 . . . 37231 3131 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3131 2 3 3 LS 37231 3131 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3131 4 The the DT 37231 3131 5 genealogies genealogy NNS 37231 3131 6 of of IN 37231 3131 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3131 8 in in IN 37231 3131 9 the the DT 37231 3131 10 first first JJ 37231 3131 11 and and CC 37231 3131 12 third third JJ 37231 3131 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3131 14 differ differ VBP 37231 3131 15 irreconcileably irreconcileably RB 37231 3131 16 from from IN 37231 3131 17 each each DT 37231 3131 18 other other JJ 37231 3131 19 . . . 37231 3132 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3132 2 differs differ VBZ 37231 3132 3 from from IN 37231 3132 4 both both DT 37231 3132 5 . . . 37231 3133 1 In in IN 37231 3133 2 this this DT 37231 3133 3 passage passage NN 37231 3133 4 another another DT 37231 3133 5 discrepancy discrepancy NN 37231 3133 6 arises arise VBZ 37231 3133 7 . . . 37231 3134 1 While while IN 37231 3134 2 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3134 3 seems seem VBZ 37231 3134 4 to to TO 37231 3134 5 represent represent VB 37231 3134 6 Nazareth Nazareth NNP 37231 3134 7 as as IN 37231 3134 8 the the DT 37231 3134 9 dwelling dwelling NN 37231 3134 10 - - HYPH 37231 3134 11 place place NN 37231 3134 12 of of IN 37231 3134 13 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3134 14 and and CC 37231 3134 15 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3134 16 , , , 37231 3134 17 and and CC 37231 3134 18 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3134 19 as as IN 37231 3134 20 the the DT 37231 3134 21 city city NN 37231 3134 22 to to TO 37231 3134 23 which which WDT 37231 3134 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3134 25 went go VBD 37231 3134 26 solely solely RB 37231 3134 27 on on IN 37231 3134 28 account account NN 37231 3134 29 of of IN 37231 3134 30 the the DT 37231 3134 31 census,(4 census,(4 NNP 37231 3134 32 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3134 33 { { -LRB- 37231 3134 34 308 308 CD 37231 3134 35 } } -RRB- 37231 3134 36 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3134 37 , , , 37231 3134 38 who who WP 37231 3134 39 seems seem VBZ 37231 3134 40 to to TO 37231 3134 41 know know VB 37231 3134 42 nothing nothing NN 37231 3134 43 of of IN 37231 3134 44 the the DT 37231 3134 45 census census NN 37231 3134 46 , , , 37231 3134 47 makes make VBZ 37231 3134 48 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3134 49 , , , 37231 3134 50 on on IN 37231 3134 51 the the DT 37231 3134 52 contrary contrary NN 37231 3134 53 , , , 37231 3134 54 the the DT 37231 3134 55 place place NN 37231 3134 56 of of IN 37231 3134 57 residence residence NN 37231 3134 58 of of IN 37231 3134 59 Joseph,(1 joseph,(1 NN 37231 3134 60 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3134 61 and and CC 37231 3134 62 on on IN 37231 3134 63 coming come VBG 37231 3134 64 back back RB 37231 3134 65 from from IN 37231 3134 66 Egypt Egypt NNP 37231 3134 67 , , , 37231 3134 68 with with IN 37231 3134 69 the the DT 37231 3134 70 evident evident JJ 37231 3134 71 intention intention NN 37231 3134 72 of of IN 37231 3134 73 returning return VBG 37231 3134 74 to to IN 37231 3134 75 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3134 76 , , , 37231 3134 77 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3134 78 is be VBZ 37231 3134 79 warned warn VBN 37231 3134 80 by by IN 37231 3134 81 a a DT 37231 3134 82 dream dream NN 37231 3134 83 to to TO 37231 3134 84 turn turn VB 37231 3134 85 aside aside RB 37231 3134 86 into into IN 37231 3134 87 Galilee Galilee NNP 37231 3134 88 , , , 37231 3134 89 and and CC 37231 3134 90 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3134 91 goes go VBZ 37231 3134 92 and and CC 37231 3134 93 dwells dwell VBZ 37231 3134 94 , , , 37231 3134 95 apparently apparently RB 37231 3134 96 for for IN 37231 3134 97 the the DT 37231 3134 98 first first JJ 37231 3134 99 time time NN 37231 3134 100 , , , 37231 3134 101 " " '' 37231 3134 102 in in IN 37231 3134 103 a a DT 37231 3134 104 city city NN 37231 3134 105 called call VBN 37231 3134 106 Nazareth Nazareth NNP 37231 3134 107 , , , 37231 3134 108 that that IN 37231 3134 109 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3134 110 might may MD 37231 3134 111 be be VB 37231 3134 112 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 3134 113 which which WDT 37231 3134 114 was be VBD 37231 3134 115 spoken speak VBN 37231 3134 116 by by IN 37231 3134 117 the the DT 37231 3134 118 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3134 119 : : : 37231 3134 120 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3134 121 shall shall MD 37231 3134 122 be be VB 37231 3134 123 called call VBN 37231 3134 124 a a DT 37231 3134 125 Nazarene Nazarene NNP 37231 3134 126 . . . 37231 3135 1 " " `` 37231 3135 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3135 3 2 2 LS 37231 3135 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3135 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3135 6 , , , 37231 3135 7 however however RB 37231 3135 8 , , , 37231 3135 9 goes go VBZ 37231 3135 10 still still RB 37231 3135 11 further further RB 37231 3135 12 than than IN 37231 3135 13 the the DT 37231 3135 14 third third JJ 37231 3135 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3135 16 in in IN 37231 3135 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3135 18 departure departure NN 37231 3135 19 from from IN 37231 3135 20 the the DT 37231 3135 21 data datum NNS 37231 3135 22 of of IN 37231 3135 23 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3135 24 , , , 37231 3135 25 and and CC 37231 3135 26 where where WRB 37231 3135 27 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3135 28 merely merely RB 37231 3135 29 infers infer VBZ 37231 3135 30 , , , 37231 3135 31 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3135 32 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3135 33 asserts assert VBZ 37231 3135 34 Nazareth Nazareth NNP 37231 3135 35 to to TO 37231 3135 36 have have VB 37231 3135 37 been be VBN 37231 3135 38 the the DT 37231 3135 39 dwelling dwelling NN 37231 3135 40 - - HYPH 37231 3135 41 place place NN 37231 3135 42 of of IN 37231 3135 43 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3135 44 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3135 45 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3135 46 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3135 47 , , , 37231 3135 48 and and CC 37231 3135 49 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3135 50 , , , 37231 3135 51 in in IN 37231 3135 52 contradistinction contradistinction NN 37231 3135 53 , , , 37231 3135 54 the the DT 37231 3135 55 place place NN 37231 3135 56 from from IN 37231 3135 57 which which WDT 37231 3135 58 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3135 59 derived derive VBD 37231 3135 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3135 61 origin origin NN 37231 3135 62 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3135 63 --Greek--].3 --Greek--].3 . 37231 3135 64 The the DT 37231 3135 65 same same JJ 37231 3135 66 view view NN 37231 3135 67 is be VBZ 37231 3135 68 to to TO 37231 3135 69 be be VB 37231 3135 70 found find VBN 37231 3135 71 in in IN 37231 3135 72 several several JJ 37231 3135 73 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3135 74 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3135 75 still still RB 37231 3135 76 extant extant JJ 37231 3135 77 . . . 37231 3136 1 In in IN 37231 3136 2 the the DT 37231 3136 3 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3136 4 of of IN 37231 3136 5 James James NNP 37231 3136 6 again again RB 37231 3136 7 , , , 37231 3136 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3136 9 find find VBP 37231 3136 10 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3136 11 journeying journey VBG 37231 3136 12 to to IN 37231 3136 13 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3136 14 with with IN 37231 3136 15 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3136 16 before before IN 37231 3136 17 the the DT 37231 3136 18 birth birth NN 37231 3136 19 of of IN 37231 3136 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3136 21 . . . 37231 3137 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3137 2 4 4 LS 37231 3137 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3137 4 The the DT 37231 3137 5 census census NN 37231 3137 6 here here RB 37231 3137 7 is be VBZ 37231 3137 8 ordered order VBN 37231 3137 9 by by IN 37231 3137 10 Augustus Augustus NNP 37231 3137 11 , , , 37231 3137 12 who who WP 37231 3137 13 commands command VBZ 37231 3137 14 : : : 37231 3137 15 " " `` 37231 3137 16 That that IN 37231 3137 17 all all DT 37231 3137 18 who who WP 37231 3137 19 were be VBD 37231 3137 20 in in IN 37231 3137 21 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3137 22 _ _ NNP 37231 3137 23 of of IN 37231 3137 24 Judeæ Judeæ NNP 37231 3137 25 _ _ NNP 37231 3137 26 , , , 37231 3137 27 should should MD 37231 3137 28 be be VB 37231 3137 29 enrolled enrol VBN 37231 3137 30 . . . 37231 3138 1 " " `` 37231 3138 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3138 3 5 5 LS 37231 3138 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3138 5 a a DT 37231 3138 6 limitation limitation NN 37231 3138 7 worthy worthy JJ 37231 3138 8 of of IN 37231 3138 9 notice notice NN 37231 3138 10 in in IN 37231 3138 11 comparison comparison NN 37231 3138 12 with with IN 37231 3138 13 that that DT 37231 3138 14 of of IN 37231 3138 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3138 16 . . . 37231 3139 1 In in IN 37231 3139 2 like like IN 37231 3139 3 manner manner NN 37231 3139 4 the the DT 37231 3139 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3139 6 of of IN 37231 3139 7 the the DT 37231 3139 8 Nativity Nativity NNP 37231 3139 9 . . . 37231 3140 1 This this DT 37231 3140 2 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3140 3 represents represent VBZ 37231 3140 4 the the DT 37231 3140 5 parents parent NNS 37231 3140 6 of of IN 37231 3140 7 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3140 8 as as IN 37231 3140 9 living live VBG 37231 3140 10 in in IN 37231 3140 11 Nazareth Nazareth NNP 37231 3140 12 , , , 37231 3140 13 in in IN 37231 3140 14 { { -LRB- 37231 3140 15 309 309 CD 37231 3140 16 } } -RRB- 37231 3140 17 which which WDT 37231 3140 18 place place NN 37231 3140 19 she -PRON- PRP 37231 3140 20 was be VBD 37231 3140 21 born,(1 born,(1 NN 37231 3140 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3140 23 and and CC 37231 3140 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3140 25 is be VBZ 37231 3140 26 here here RB 37231 3140 27 that that IN 37231 3140 28 the the DT 37231 3140 29 Angel Angel NNP 37231 3140 30 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 37231 3140 31 announces announce VBZ 37231 3140 32 to to IN 37231 3140 33 her -PRON- PRP 37231 3140 34 the the DT 37231 3140 35 supernatural supernatural JJ 37231 3140 36 conception conception NN 37231 3140 37 . . . 37231 3141 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3141 2 2 2 LS 37231 3141 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3141 4 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3141 5 goes go VBZ 37231 3141 6 to to IN 37231 3141 7 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3141 8 to to TO 37231 3141 9 set set VB 37231 3141 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3141 11 house house NN 37231 3141 12 in in IN 37231 3141 13 order order NN 37231 3141 14 and and CC 37231 3141 15 prepare prepare VB 37231 3141 16 what what WP 37231 3141 17 is be VBZ 37231 3141 18 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3141 19 for for IN 37231 3141 20 the the DT 37231 3141 21 marriage marriage NN 37231 3141 22 , , , 37231 3141 23 but but CC 37231 3141 24 then then RB 37231 3141 25 returns return VBZ 37231 3141 26 to to IN 37231 3141 27 Nazareth Nazareth NNP 37231 3141 28 , , , 37231 3141 29 where where WRB 37231 3141 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3141 31 remains remain VBZ 37231 3141 32 with with IN 37231 3141 33 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3141 34 until until IN 37231 3141 35 her -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3141 36 time time NN 37231 3141 37 was be VBD 37231 3141 38 nearly nearly RB 37231 3141 39 accomplished,(3 accomplished,(3 JJ 37231 3141 40 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3141 41 " " '' 37231 3141 42 when when WRB 37231 3141 43 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3141 44 having have VBG 37231 3141 45 taken take VBN 37231 3141 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3141 47 wife wife NN 37231 3141 48 with with IN 37231 3141 49 whatever whatever WDT 37231 3141 50 else else RB 37231 3141 51 was be VBD 37231 3141 52 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3141 53 went go VBD 37231 3141 54 to to IN 37231 3141 55 the the DT 37231 3141 56 city city NN 37231 3141 57 of of IN 37231 3141 58 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3141 59 , , , 37231 3141 60 whence whence IN 37231 3141 61 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3141 62 was be VBD 37231 3141 63 . . . 37231 3142 1 " " `` 37231 3142 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3142 3 4 4 LS 37231 3142 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3142 5 The the DT 37231 3142 6 phrase phrase NN 37231 3142 7 " " `` 37231 3142 8 _ _ NNP 37231 3142 9 unde unde JJ 37231 3142 10 ipse ipse NNP 37231 3142 11 erat erat NNP 37231 3142 12 _ _ NNP 37231 3142 13 " " `` 37231 3142 14 recalls recall VBZ 37231 3142 15 the the DT 37231 3142 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3142 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3142 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3142 19 of of IN 37231 3142 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3142 21 . . . 37231 3143 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3143 2 6 6 LS 37231 3143 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3143 4 As as IN 37231 3143 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3143 6 continue continue VBP 37231 3143 7 the the DT 37231 3143 8 narrative narrative NN 37231 3143 9 of of IN 37231 3143 10 the the DT 37231 3143 11 birth birth NN 37231 3143 12 and and CC 37231 3143 13 infancy infancy NN 37231 3143 14 of of IN 37231 3143 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3143 16 , , , 37231 3143 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3143 18 meet meet VBP 37231 3143 19 with with IN 37231 3143 20 further further JJ 37231 3143 21 variations variation NNS 37231 3143 22 from from IN 37231 3143 23 the the DT 37231 3143 24 account account NN 37231 3143 25 in in IN 37231 3143 26 the the DT 37231 3143 27 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3143 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3143 29 for for IN 37231 3143 30 which which WDT 37231 3143 31 the the DT 37231 3143 32 preceding precede VBG 37231 3143 33 have have VBP 37231 3143 34 prepared prepare VBN 37231 3143 35 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3143 36 , , , 37231 3143 37 and and CC 37231 3143 38 which which WDT 37231 3143 39 indicate indicate VBP 37231 3143 40 that that IN 37231 3143 41 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3143 42 's 's POS 37231 3143 43 Memorials Memorials NNPS 37231 3143 44 certainly certainly RB 37231 3143 45 differed differ VBD 37231 3143 46 from from IN 37231 3143 47 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3143 48 : : : 37231 3143 49 { { -LRB- 37231 3143 50 310 310 CD 37231 3143 51 } } -RRB- 37231 3143 52 At at RB 37231 3143 53 least least JJS 37231 3143 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3143 55 is be VBZ 37231 3143 56 clear clear JJ 37231 3143 57 that that IN 37231 3143 58 these these DT 37231 3143 59 particulars particular NNS 37231 3143 60 of of IN 37231 3143 61 the the DT 37231 3143 62 birth birth NN 37231 3143 63 of of IN 37231 3143 64 Jesus,--not Jesus,--not NNP 37231 3143 65 taking take VBG 37231 3143 66 place place NN 37231 3143 67 in in IN 37231 3143 68 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3143 69 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3143 70 but but CC 37231 3143 71 in in IN 37231 3143 72 a a DT 37231 3143 73 cave cave NN 37231 3143 74 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3143 75 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3143 76 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3143 77 near near IN 37231 3143 78 the the DT 37231 3143 79 village village NN 37231 3143 80 , , , 37231 3143 81 because because IN 37231 3143 82 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3143 83 could could MD 37231 3143 84 not not RB 37231 3143 85 find find VB 37231 3143 86 a a DT 37231 3143 87 lodging lodging NN 37231 3143 88 there,--are there,--are NN 37231 3143 89 not not RB 37231 3143 90 derived derive VBN 37231 3143 91 from from IN 37231 3143 92 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3143 93 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3143 94 , , , 37231 3143 95 and and CC 37231 3143 96 here here RB 37231 3143 97 even even RB 37231 3143 98 Scmisch(1 scmisch(1 NN 37231 3143 99 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3143 100 is be VBZ 37231 3143 101 forced force VBN 37231 3143 102 to to TO 37231 3143 103 abandon abandon VB 37231 3143 104 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3143 105 theory theory NN 37231 3143 106 that that IN 37231 3143 107 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3143 108 's 's POS 37231 3143 109 variations variation NNS 37231 3143 110 arise arise VBP 37231 3143 111 merely merely RB 37231 3143 112 from from IN 37231 3143 113 imperfectly imperfectly RB 37231 3143 114 quoting quote VBG 37231 3143 115 from from IN 37231 3143 116 memory memory NN 37231 3143 117 , , , 37231 3143 118 and and CC 37231 3143 119 to to TO 37231 3143 120 conjecture conjecture VB 37231 3143 121 that that IN 37231 3143 122 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3143 123 must must MD 37231 3143 124 have have VB 37231 3143 125 adopted adopt VBN 37231 3143 126 tradition tradition NN 37231 3143 127 . . . 37231 3144 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3144 2 has have VBZ 37231 3144 3 , , , 37231 3144 4 however however RB 37231 3144 5 , , , 37231 3144 6 been be VBN 37231 3144 7 shown show VBN 37231 3144 8 that that IN 37231 3144 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3144 10 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3144 11 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3144 12 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3144 13 tradition tradition NN 37231 3144 14 , , , 37231 3144 15 and and CC 37231 3144 16 in in IN 37231 3144 17 this this DT 37231 3144 18 case case NN 37231 3144 19 , , , 37231 3144 20 moreover moreover RB 37231 3144 21 , , , 37231 3144 22 there there EX 37231 3144 23 are be VBP 37231 3144 24 many many JJ 37231 3144 25 special special JJ 37231 3144 26 reasons reason NNS 37231 3144 27 for for IN 37231 3144 28 believing believe VBG 37231 3144 29 that that IN 37231 3144 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3144 31 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3144 32 from from IN 37231 3144 33 a a DT 37231 3144 34 written write VBN 37231 3144 35 source source NN 37231 3144 36 . . . 37231 3145 1 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 3145 2 rightly rightly RB 37231 3145 3 points point VBZ 37231 3145 4 out out RP 37231 3145 5 that that IN 37231 3145 6 here here RB 37231 3145 7 , , , 37231 3145 8 and and CC 37231 3145 9 in in IN 37231 3145 10 other other JJ 37231 3145 11 passages passage NNS 37231 3145 12 where where WRB 37231 3145 13 , , , 37231 3145 14 in in IN 37231 3145 15 common common JJ 37231 3145 16 with with IN 37231 3145 17 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3145 18 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 3145 19 writers writer NNS 37231 3145 20 , , , 37231 3145 21 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3145 22 departs depart VBZ 37231 3145 23 from from IN 37231 3145 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3145 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3145 26 , , , 37231 3145 27 the the DT 37231 3145 28 variation variation NN 37231 3145 29 can can MD 37231 3145 30 in in IN 37231 3145 31 no no DT 37231 3145 32 way way NN 37231 3145 33 be be VB 37231 3145 34 referred refer VBN 37231 3145 35 to to IN 37231 3145 36 oral oral JJ 37231 3145 37 tradition;(2 tradition;(2 NNP 37231 3145 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3145 39 and and CC 37231 3145 40 , , , 37231 3145 41 moreover moreover RB 37231 3145 42 , , , 37231 3145 43 that that IN 37231 3145 44 when when WRB 37231 3145 45 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3145 46 proves(3 proves(3 NN 37231 3145 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3145 48 from from IN 37231 3145 49 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 37231 3145 50 xxxiii xxxiii NN 37231 3145 51 . . . 37231 3146 1 16 16 CD 37231 3146 2 , , , 37231 3146 3 that that WDT 37231 3146 4 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3146 5 _ _ NNP 37231 3146 6 must must MD 37231 3146 7 _ _ NNP 37231 3146 8 be be VB 37231 3146 9 born bear VBN 37231 3146 10 in in IN 37231 3146 11 a a DT 37231 3146 12 cave cave NN 37231 3146 13 , , , 37231 3146 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3146 15 thereby thereby RB 37231 3146 16 shows show VBZ 37231 3146 17 how how WRB 37231 3146 18 certainly certainly RB 37231 3146 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3146 20 found find VBD 37231 3146 21 the the DT 37231 3146 22 fact fact NN 37231 3146 23 of of IN 37231 3146 24 the the DT 37231 3146 25 cave cave NN 37231 3146 26 in in IN 37231 3146 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3146 28 written write VBN 37231 3146 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3146 30 . . . 37231 3147 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3147 2 4 4 LS 37231 3147 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3147 4 The the DT 37231 3147 5 whole whole JJ 37231 3147 6 argument argument NN 37231 3147 7 of of IN 37231 3147 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3147 9 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3147 10 the the DT 37231 3147 11 idea idea NN 37231 3147 12 that that IN 37231 3147 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3147 14 could could MD 37231 3147 15 avail avail VB 37231 3147 16 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3147 17 of of IN 37231 3147 18 mere mere JJ 37231 3147 19 tradition tradition NN 37231 3147 20 . . . 37231 3148 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3148 2 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 3148 3 that that IN 37231 3148 4 everything everything NN 37231 3148 5 which which WDT 37231 3148 6 the the DT 37231 3148 7 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3148 8 had have VBD 37231 3148 9 foretold foretold NN 37231 3148 10 of of IN 37231 3148 11 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3148 12 had have VBD 37231 3148 13 actually actually RB 37231 3148 14 been be VBN 37231 3148 15 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 3148 16 , , , 37231 3148 17 and and CC 37231 3148 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3148 19 perpetually perpetually RB 37231 3148 20 refers refer VBZ 37231 3148 21 to to IN 37231 3148 22 the the DT 37231 3148 23 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3148 24 and and CC 37231 3148 25 other other JJ 37231 3148 26 written write VBN 37231 3148 27 documents document NNS 37231 3148 28 for for IN 37231 3148 29 the the DT 37231 3148 30 verification verification NN 37231 3148 31 of of IN 37231 3148 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3148 33 assertions assertion NNS 37231 3148 34 . . . 37231 3149 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3149 2 either either CC 37231 3149 3 refers refer VBZ 37231 3149 4 to to IN 37231 3149 5 the the DT 37231 3149 6 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3149 7 for for IN 37231 3149 8 the the DT 37231 3149 9 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 3149 10 of of IN 37231 3149 11 the the DT 37231 3149 12 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3149 13 , , , 37231 3149 14 or or CC 37231 3149 15 shows show VBZ 37231 3149 16 in in IN 37231 3149 17 the the DT 37231 3149 18 { { -LRB- 37231 3149 19 311 311 CD 37231 3149 20 } } -RRB- 37231 3149 21 Memoirs memoir NNS 37231 3149 22 the the DT 37231 3149 23 narrative narrative NN 37231 3149 24 of of IN 37231 3149 25 facts fact NNS 37231 3149 26 which which WDT 37231 3149 27 are be VBP 37231 3149 28 the the DT 37231 3149 29 accomplishment accomplishment NN 37231 3149 30 of of IN 37231 3149 31 prophecies prophecy NNS 37231 3149 32 , , , 37231 3149 33 but but CC 37231 3149 34 in in IN 37231 3149 35 both both DT 37231 3149 36 cases case NNS 37231 3149 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3149 38 is be VBZ 37231 3149 39 manifest manifest NN 37231 3149 40 that that IN 37231 3149 41 there there EX 37231 3149 42 must must MD 37231 3149 43 have have VB 37231 3149 44 been be VBN 37231 3149 45 a a DT 37231 3149 46 record record NN 37231 3149 47 of of IN 37231 3149 48 the the DT 37231 3149 49 facts fact NNS 37231 3149 50 which which WDT 37231 3149 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3149 52 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3149 53 . . . 37231 3150 1 There there EX 37231 3150 2 can can MD 37231 3150 3 be be VB 37231 3150 4 no no DT 37231 3150 5 doubt doubt NN 37231 3150 6 that that IN 37231 3150 7 the the DT 37231 3150 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3150 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3150 10 have have VBP 37231 3150 11 just just RB 37231 3150 12 quoted quote VBN 37231 3150 13 , , , 37231 3150 14 and and CC 37231 3150 15 which which WDT 37231 3150 16 are be VBP 37231 3150 17 not not RB 37231 3150 18 found find VBN 37231 3150 19 in in IN 37231 3150 20 the the DT 37231 3150 21 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3150 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3150 23 , , , 37231 3150 24 must must MD 37231 3150 25 have have VB 37231 3150 26 been be VBN 37231 3150 27 narrated narrate VBN 37231 3150 28 in in IN 37231 3150 29 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3150 30 's 's POS 37231 3150 31 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3150 32 . . . 37231 3151 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3151 2 find find VBP 37231 3151 3 , , , 37231 3151 4 again again RB 37231 3151 5 , , , 37231 3151 6 the the DT 37231 3151 7 same same JJ 37231 3151 8 variations variation NNS 37231 3151 9 as as IN 37231 3151 10 in in IN 37231 3151 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3151 12 in in IN 37231 3151 13 several several JJ 37231 3151 14 extant extant JJ 37231 3151 15 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3151 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3151 17 . . . 37231 3152 1 The the DT 37231 3152 2 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3152 3 of of IN 37231 3152 4 James James NNP 37231 3152 5 represents represent VBZ 37231 3152 6 the the DT 37231 3152 7 birth birth NN 37231 3152 8 of of IN 37231 3152 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3152 10 as as IN 37231 3152 11 taking take VBG 37231 3152 12 place place NN 37231 3152 13 in in IN 37231 3152 14 a a DT 37231 3152 15 cave;(1 cave;(1 NNP 37231 3152 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3152 17 so so RB 37231 3152 18 also also RB 37231 3152 19 the the DT 37231 3152 20 Arabic Arabic NNP 37231 3152 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3152 22 of of IN 37231 3152 23 the the DT 37231 3152 24 Infancy,(2 Infancy,(2 VBN 37231 3152 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3152 26 and and CC 37231 3152 27 several several JJ 37231 3152 28 others other NNS 37231 3152 29 . . . 37231 3153 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3153 2 3 3 LS 37231 3153 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3153 4 This this DT 37231 3153 5 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 37231 3153 6 detail detail NN 37231 3153 7 is be VBZ 37231 3153 8 also also RB 37231 3153 9 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3153 10 by by IN 37231 3153 11 several several JJ 37231 3153 12 of of IN 37231 3153 13 the the DT 37231 3153 14 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 3153 15 , , , 37231 3153 16 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3153 17 and and CC 37231 3153 18 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 3153 19 both both DT 37231 3153 20 stating state VBG 37231 3153 21 that that IN 37231 3153 22 the the DT 37231 3153 23 cave cave NN 37231 3153 24 and and CC 37231 3153 25 the the DT 37231 3153 26 manger manger NN 37231 3153 27 were be VBD 37231 3153 28 still still RB 37231 3153 29 shown show VBN 37231 3153 30 in in IN 37231 3153 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3153 32 day day NN 37231 3153 33 . . . 37231 3154 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3154 2 4 4 LS 37231 3154 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3154 4 Teschendorf teschendorf NN 37231 3154 5 does do VBZ 37231 3154 6 not not RB 37231 3154 7 hesitate hesitate VB 37231 3154 8 to to TO 37231 3154 9 affirm affirm VB 37231 3154 10 that that IN 37231 3154 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3154 12 derived derive VBD 37231 3154 13 this this DT 37231 3154 14 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 3154 15 from from IN 37231 3154 16 the the DT 37231 3154 17 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3154 18 . . . 37231 3155 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3155 2 5 5 LS 37231 3155 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3155 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3155 5 , , , 37231 3155 6 however however RB 37231 3155 7 , , , 37231 3155 8 does do VBZ 37231 3155 9 not not RB 37231 3155 10 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 3155 11 such such PDT 37231 3155 12 a a DT 37231 3155 13 source source NN 37231 3155 14 ; ; : 37231 3155 15 and and CC 37231 3155 16 the the DT 37231 3155 17 mere mere JJ 37231 3155 18 fact fact NN 37231 3155 19 that that IN 37231 3155 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3155 21 have have VBP 37231 3155 22 a a DT 37231 3155 23 form form NN 37231 3155 24 of of IN 37231 3155 25 that that DT 37231 3155 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3155 27 , , , 37231 3155 28 in in IN 37231 3155 29 which which WDT 37231 3155 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3155 31 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3155 32 , , , 37231 3155 33 still still RB 37231 3155 34 extant extant JJ 37231 3155 35 , , , 37231 3155 36 by by IN 37231 3155 37 no no DT 37231 3155 38 means means NN 37231 3155 39 justifies justifie NNS 37231 3155 40 such such PDT 37231 3155 41 a a DT 37231 3155 42 specific specific JJ 37231 3155 43 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3155 44 , , , 37231 3155 45 when when WRB 37231 3155 46 so so RB 37231 3155 47 many many JJ 37231 3155 48 other other JJ 37231 3155 49 works work NNS 37231 3155 50 , , , 37231 3155 51 now now RB 37231 3155 52 lost lose VBN 37231 3155 53 , , , 37231 3155 54 may may MD 37231 3155 55 equally equally RB 37231 3155 56 have have VB 37231 3155 57 contained contain VBN 37231 3155 58 { { -LRB- 37231 3155 59 312 312 CD 37231 3155 60 } } -RRB- 37231 3155 61 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3155 62 . . . 37231 3156 1 If if IN 37231 3156 2 the the DT 37231 3156 3 fact fact NN 37231 3156 4 be be VB 37231 3156 5 derived derive VBN 37231 3156 6 from from IN 37231 3156 7 the the DT 37231 3156 8 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3156 9 , , , 37231 3156 10 that that DT 37231 3156 11 work work NN 37231 3156 12 , , , 37231 3156 13 or or CC 37231 3156 14 whatever whatever WDT 37231 3156 15 other other JJ 37231 3156 16 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3156 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3156 18 may may MD 37231 3156 19 have have VB 37231 3156 20 supplied supply VBN 37231 3156 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3156 22 , , , 37231 3156 23 must must MD 37231 3156 24 be be VB 37231 3156 25 admitted admit VBN 37231 3156 26 to to TO 37231 3156 27 have have VB 37231 3156 28 at at IN 37231 3156 29 least least JJS 37231 3156 30 formed form VBN 37231 3156 31 part part NN 37231 3156 32 of of IN 37231 3156 33 the the DT 37231 3156 34 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3156 35 of of IN 37231 3156 36 the the DT 37231 3156 37 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3156 38 , , , 37231 3156 39 and and CC 37231 3156 40 with with IN 37231 3156 41 that that DT 37231 3156 42 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3156 43 admission admission NN 37231 3156 44 ends end VBZ 37231 3156 45 all all DT 37231 3156 46 special special JJ 37231 3156 47 identification identification NN 37231 3156 48 of of IN 37231 3156 49 the the DT 37231 3156 50 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3156 51 with with IN 37231 3156 52 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3156 53 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3156 54 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3156 55 . . . 37231 3157 1 Much much RB 37231 3157 2 more more RBR 37231 3157 3 probably probably RB 37231 3157 4 , , , 37231 3157 5 however however RB 37231 3157 6 , , , 37231 3157 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3157 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3157 9 from from IN 37231 3157 10 the the DT 37231 3157 11 more more RBR 37231 3157 12 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3157 13 source source NN 37231 3157 14 from from IN 37231 3157 15 which which WDT 37231 3157 16 the the DT 37231 3157 17 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 37231 3157 18 and and CC 37231 3157 19 , , , 37231 3157 20 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 3157 21 , , , 37231 3157 22 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3157 23 drew draw VBD 37231 3157 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3157 25 narrative narrative NN 37231 3157 26 . . . 37231 3158 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3158 2 1 1 LS 37231 3158 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3158 4 There there EX 37231 3158 5 can can MD 37231 3158 6 be be VB 37231 3158 7 very very RB 37231 3158 8 little little JJ 37231 3158 9 doubt doubt NN 37231 3158 10 that that IN 37231 3158 11 the the DT 37231 3158 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3158 13 according accord VBG 37231 3158 14 to to IN 37231 3158 15 the the DT 37231 3158 16 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3158 17 contained contain VBD 37231 3158 18 an an DT 37231 3158 19 account account NN 37231 3158 20 of of IN 37231 3158 21 the the DT 37231 3158 22 birth birth NN 37231 3158 23 in in IN 37231 3158 24 Bethlehem Bethlehem NNP 37231 3158 25 , , , 37231 3158 26 and and CC 37231 3158 27 as as IN 37231 3158 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3158 29 is be VBZ 37231 3158 30 , , , 37231 3158 31 at at IN 37231 3158 32 least least JJS 37231 3158 33 , , , 37231 3158 34 certain certain JJ 37231 3158 35 that that IN 37231 3158 36 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3158 37 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3158 38 other other JJ 37231 3158 39 particulars particular NNS 37231 3158 40 known know VBN 37231 3158 41 to to TO 37231 3158 42 have have VB 37231 3158 43 been be VBN 37231 3158 44 in in IN 37231 3158 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3158 46 , , , 37231 3158 47 there there EX 37231 3158 48 is be VBZ 37231 3158 49 fair fair JJ 37231 3158 50 reason reason NN 37231 3158 51 to to TO 37231 3158 52 suppose suppose VB 37231 3158 53 that that IN 37231 3158 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3158 55 likewise likewise RB 37231 3158 56 found find VBD 37231 3158 57 this this DT 37231 3158 58 fact fact NN 37231 3158 59 in in IN 37231 3158 60 that that DT 37231 3158 61 work work NN 37231 3158 62 . . . 37231 3159 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3159 2 2 2 LS 37231 3159 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3159 4 In in IN 37231 3159 5 any any DT 37231 3159 6 case case NN 37231 3159 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3159 8 is be VBZ 37231 3159 9 indisputable indisputable JJ 37231 3159 10 that that IN 37231 3159 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3159 12 derived derive VBD 37231 3159 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3159 14 from from IN 37231 3159 15 a a DT 37231 3159 16 source source NN 37231 3159 17 different different JJ 37231 3159 18 from from IN 37231 3159 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3159 20 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3159 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3159 22 . . . 37231 3160 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3160 2 3 3 LS 37231 3160 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3160 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3160 5 does do VBZ 37231 3160 6 not not RB 37231 3160 7 apparently apparently RB 37231 3160 8 know know VB 37231 3160 9 anything anything NN 37231 3160 10 of of IN 37231 3160 11 the the DT 37231 3160 12 episode episode NN 37231 3160 13 of of IN 37231 3160 14 the the DT 37231 3160 15 shepherds shepherd NNS 37231 3160 16 of of IN 37231 3160 17 the the DT 37231 3160 18 plain plain JJ 37231 3160 19 , , , 37231 3160 20 and and CC 37231 3160 21 the the DT 37231 3160 22 angelic angelic JJ 37231 3160 23 appearance appearance NN 37231 3160 24 to to IN 37231 3160 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3160 26 , , , 37231 3160 27 narrated narrate VBN 37231 3160 28 in in IN 37231 3160 29 the the DT 37231 3160 30 third third JJ 37231 3160 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3160 32 . . . 37231 3161 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3161 2 4 4 LS 37231 3161 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3161 4 To to IN 37231 3161 5 the the DT 37231 3161 6 cave cave NN 37231 3161 7 in in IN 37231 3161 8 which which WDT 37231 3161 9 the the DT 37231 3161 10 infant infant NN 37231 3161 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3161 12 is be VBZ 37231 3161 13 born bear VBN 37231 3161 14 came come VBD 37231 3161 15 the the DT 37231 3161 16 Magi Magi NNP 37231 3161 17 , , , 37231 3161 18 but but CC 37231 3161 19 instead instead RB 37231 3161 20 of of IN 37231 3161 21 employing employ VBG 37231 3161 22 the the DT 37231 3161 23 phrase phrase NN 37231 3161 24 used use VBN 37231 3161 25 by by IN 37231 3161 26 the the DT 37231 3161 27 first first JJ 37231 3161 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3161 29 , , , 37231 3161 30 " " `` 37231 3161 31 Magi magi NN 37231 3161 32 from from IN 37231 3161 33 the the DT 37231 3161 34 East,"(5 East,"(5 NNS 37231 3161 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3161 36 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3161 37 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3161 38 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3161 39 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3161 40 always always RB 37231 3161 41 describes describe VBZ 37231 3161 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3161 43 as as IN 37231 3161 44 " " `` 37231 3161 45 Magi Magi NNP 37231 3161 46 from from IN 37231 3161 47 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 3161 48 , , , 37231 3161 49 " " `` 37231 3161 50 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3161 51 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3161 52 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3161 53 . . . 37231 3162 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3162 2 is be VBZ 37231 3162 3 so so RB 37231 3162 4 punctilious punctilious JJ 37231 3162 5 that that IN 37231 3162 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3162 7 { { -LRB- 37231 3162 8 313 313 CD 37231 3162 9 } } -RRB- 37231 3162 10 never never RB 37231 3162 11 speaks speak VBZ 37231 3162 12 of of IN 37231 3162 13 these these DT 37231 3162 14 Magi Magi NNP 37231 3162 15 without without IN 37231 3162 16 adding add VBG 37231 3162 17 " " `` 37231 3162 18 from from IN 37231 3162 19 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 3162 20 , , , 37231 3162 21 " " `` 37231 3162 22 except except IN 37231 3162 23 twice twice RB 37231 3162 24 , , , 37231 3162 25 where where WRB 37231 3162 26 , , , 37231 3162 27 however however RB 37231 3162 28 , , , 37231 3162 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3162 30 immediately immediately RB 37231 3162 31 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3162 32 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 3162 33 as as IN 37231 3162 34 the the DT 37231 3162 35 point point NN 37231 3162 36 of of IN 37231 3162 37 the the DT 37231 3162 38 argument argument NN 37231 3162 39 for for IN 37231 3162 40 which which WDT 37231 3162 41 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3162 42 are be VBP 37231 3162 43 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3162 44 ; ; : 37231 3162 45 and and CC 37231 3162 46 in in IN 37231 3162 47 the the DT 37231 3162 48 same same JJ 37231 3162 49 chapter chapter NN 37231 3162 50 in in IN 37231 3162 51 which which WDT 37231 3162 52 this this DT 37231 3162 53 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3162 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3162 55 four four CD 37231 3162 56 times time NNS 37231 3162 57 calls call VBZ 37231 3162 58 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3162 59 directly directly RB 37231 3162 60 Magi Magi NNP 37231 3162 61 from from IN 37231 3162 62 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 3162 63 . . . 37231 3163 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3163 2 1 1 LS 37231 3163 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3163 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3163 5 uses use VBZ 37231 3163 6 this this DT 37231 3163 7 expression expression NN 37231 3163 8 not not RB 37231 3163 9 less less JJR 37231 3163 10 than than IN 37231 3163 11 nine nine CD 37231 3163 12 times time NNS 37231 3163 13 . . . 37231 3164 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3164 2 2 2 LS 37231 3164 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3164 4 That that IN 37231 3164 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3164 6 had have VBD 37231 3164 7 no no DT 37231 3164 8 objection objection NN 37231 3164 9 to to IN 37231 3164 10 the the DT 37231 3164 11 term term NN 37231 3164 12 " " `` 37231 3164 13 the the DT 37231 3164 14 East East NNP 37231 3164 15 , , , 37231 3164 16 " " '' 37231 3164 17 and and CC 37231 3164 18 that that IN 37231 3164 19 with with IN 37231 3164 20 a a DT 37231 3164 21 different different JJ 37231 3164 22 context context NN 37231 3164 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3164 24 was be VBD 37231 3164 25 common common JJ 37231 3164 26 to to IN 37231 3164 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3164 28 vocabulary vocabulary NN 37231 3164 29 , , , 37231 3164 30 is be VBZ 37231 3164 31 proved prove VBN 37231 3164 32 by by IN 37231 3164 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3164 34 use use NN 37231 3164 35 of of IN 37231 3164 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3164 37 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3164 38 . . . 37231 3165 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3165 2 3 3 LS 37231 3165 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3165 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3165 5 is be VBZ 37231 3165 6 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3165 7 to to TO 37231 3165 8 resist resist VB 37231 3165 9 the the DT 37231 3165 10 conviction conviction NN 37231 3165 11 that that IN 37231 3165 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3165 13 's 's POS 37231 3165 14 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3165 15 contained contain VBD 37231 3165 16 the the DT 37231 3165 17 phrase phrase NN 37231 3165 18 " " `` 37231 3165 19 Magi Magi NNP 37231 3165 20 from from IN 37231 3165 21 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 3165 22 , , , 37231 3165 23 " " `` 37231 3165 24 which which WDT 37231 3165 25 is be VBZ 37231 3165 26 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3165 27 to to IN 37231 3165 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3165 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3165 30 . . . 37231 3166 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3166 2 4 4 LS 37231 3166 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3166 4 Again again RB 37231 3166 5 , , , 37231 3166 6 according accord VBG 37231 3166 7 to to IN 37231 3166 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3166 9 , , , 37231 3166 10 the the DT 37231 3166 11 Magi Magi NNP 37231 3166 12 see see VBP 37231 3166 13 the the DT 37231 3166 14 star star NN 37231 3166 15 " " '' 37231 3166 16 in in IN 37231 3166 17 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3166 18 " " '' 37231 3166 19 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3166 20 --Greek--],(5 --greek--],(5 NN 37231 3166 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3166 22 and and CC 37231 3166 23 not not RB 37231 3166 24 " " `` 37231 3166 25 in in IN 37231 3166 26 the the DT 37231 3166 27 East East NNP 37231 3166 28 " " '' 37231 3166 29 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3166 30 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3166 31 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3166 32 as as IN 37231 3166 33 the the DT 37231 3166 34 first first JJ 37231 3166 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3166 36 has have VBZ 37231 3166 37 it:(6 it:(6 NN 37231 3166 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3166 39 " " `` 37231 3166 40 When when WRB 37231 3166 41 a a DT 37231 3166 42 star star NN 37231 3166 43 rose rise VBD 37231 3166 44 in in IN 37231 3166 45 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3166 46 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3166 47 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3166 48 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3166 49 at at IN 37231 3166 50 the the DT 37231 3166 51 time time NN 37231 3166 52 of of IN 37231 3166 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3166 54 birth birth NN 37231 3166 55 as as IN 37231 3166 56 is be VBZ 37231 3166 57 recorded record VBN 37231 3166 58 in in IN 37231 3166 59 the the DT 37231 3166 60 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3166 61 of of IN 37231 3166 62 the the DT 37231 3166 63 Apostle apostle NN 37231 3166 64 . . . 37231 3167 1 " " `` 37231 3167 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3167 3 7 7 LS 37231 3167 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3167 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3167 6 apparently apparently RB 37231 3167 7 knows know VBZ 37231 3167 8 nothing nothing NN 37231 3167 9 of of IN 37231 3167 10 the the DT 37231 3167 11 star star NN 37231 3167 12 guiding guide VBG 37231 3167 13 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3167 14 to to IN 37231 3167 15 the the DT 37231 3167 16 place place NN 37231 3167 17 where where WRB 37231 3167 18 the the DT 37231 3167 19 young young JJ 37231 3167 20 child child NN 37231 3167 21 was be VBD 37231 3167 22 . . . 37231 3168 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3168 2 8) 8) CD 37231 3168 3 Herod Herod NNP 37231 3168 4 , , , 37231 3168 5 moreover moreover RB 37231 3168 6 , , , 37231 3168 7 questions question NNS 37231 3168 8 the the DT 37231 3168 9 elders elder NNS 37231 3168 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3168 11 --Greek--](9 --Greek--](9 NFP 37231 3168 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3168 13 as as IN 37231 3168 14 to to IN 37231 3168 15 the the DT 37231 3168 16 place place NN 37231 3168 17 where where WRB 37231 3168 18 the the DT 37231 3168 19 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3168 20 should should MD 37231 3168 21 be be VB 37231 3168 22 born bear VBN 37231 3168 23 , , , 37231 3168 24 and and CC 37231 3168 25 not not RB 37231 3168 26 the the DT 37231 3168 27 " " `` 37231 3168 28 chief chief JJ 37231 3168 29 priests priest NNS 37231 3168 30 and and CC 37231 3168 31 scribes scribe NNS 37231 3168 32 of of IN 37231 3168 33 the the DT 37231 3168 34 people people NNS 37231 3168 35 " " '' 37231 3168 36 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3168 37 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3168 38 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3168 39 . . . 37231 3169 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3169 2 10 10 LS 37231 3169 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3169 4 These these DT 37231 3169 5 divergences divergence NNS 37231 3169 6 , , , 37231 3169 7 taken take VBN 37231 3169 8 in in IN 37231 3169 9 connection connection NN 37231 3169 10 with with IN 37231 3169 11 those those DT 37231 3169 12 which which WDT 37231 3169 13 are be VBP 37231 3169 14 interwoven interwoven JJ 37231 3169 15 with with IN 37231 3169 16 the the DT 37231 3169 17 whole whole JJ 37231 3169 18 narrative narrative NN 37231 3169 19 of of IN 37231 3169 20 the the DT 37231 3169 21 birth birth NN 37231 3169 22 , , , 37231 3169 23 can can MD 37231 3169 24 only only RB 37231 3169 25 proceed proceed VB 37231 3169 26 from from IN 37231 3169 27 the the DT 37231 3169 28 fact fact NN 37231 3169 29 that that IN 37231 3169 30 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3169 31 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3169 32 from from IN 37231 3169 33 a a DT 37231 3169 34 source source NN 37231 3169 35 different different JJ 37231 3169 36 from from IN 37231 3169 37 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 3169 38 . . . 37231 3170 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3170 2 11 11 LS 37231 3170 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3170 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3170 5 relates relate VBZ 37231 3170 6 that that IN 37231 3170 7 when when WRB 37231 3170 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3170 9 came come VBD 37231 3170 10 to to IN 37231 3170 11 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3170 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3170 13 was be VBD 37231 3170 14 { { -LRB- 37231 3170 15 314 314 CD 37231 3170 16 } } -RRB- 37231 3170 17 believed believe VBN 37231 3170 18 to to TO 37231 3170 19 be be VB 37231 3170 20 the the DT 37231 3170 21 son son NN 37231 3170 22 of of IN 37231 3170 23 Joseph Joseph NNP 37231 3170 24 the the DT 37231 3170 25 carpenter carpenter NN 37231 3170 26 , , , 37231 3170 27 and and CC 37231 3170 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3170 29 appeared appear VBD 37231 3170 30 without without IN 37231 3170 31 comeliness comeliness NN 37231 3170 32 , , , 37231 3170 33 as as IN 37231 3170 34 the the DT 37231 3170 35 Scriptures scripture NNS 37231 3170 36 announced announce VBD 37231 3170 37 ; ; : 37231 3170 38 " " `` 37231 3170 39 and and CC 37231 3170 40 being be VBG 37231 3170 41 considered consider VBN 37231 3170 42 a a DT 37231 3170 43 carpenter,--for carpenter,--for NN 37231 3170 44 , , , 37231 3170 45 when when WRB 37231 3170 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3170 47 was be VBD 37231 3170 48 amongst amongst IN 37231 3170 49 men man NNS 37231 3170 50 , , , 37231 3170 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3170 52 made make VBD 37231 3170 53 carpenter carpenter NN 37231 3170 54 's 's POS 37231 3170 55 works work NNS 37231 3170 56 , , , 37231 3170 57 ploughs plough NNS 37231 3170 58 and and CC 37231 3170 59 yokes yoke NNS 37231 3170 60 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3170 61 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3170 62 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3170 63 ; ; : 37231 3170 64 by by IN 37231 3170 65 these these DT 37231 3170 66 both both DT 37231 3170 67 teaching teach VBG 37231 3170 68 the the DT 37231 3170 69 symbols symbol NNS 37231 3170 70 of of IN 37231 3170 71 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 3170 72 and and CC 37231 3170 73 an an DT 37231 3170 74 active active JJ 37231 3170 75 life life NN 37231 3170 76 . . . 37231 3171 1 " " `` 37231 3171 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3171 3 1 1 LS 37231 3171 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3171 5 These these DT 37231 3171 6 details detail NNS 37231 3171 7 are be VBP 37231 3171 8 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3171 9 to to IN 37231 3171 10 the the DT 37231 3171 11 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3171 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3171 13 . . . 37231 3172 1 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3172 2 has have VBZ 37231 3172 3 the the DT 37231 3172 4 expression expression NN 37231 3172 5 : : : 37231 3172 6 " " `` 37231 3172 7 Is be VBZ 37231 3172 8 not not RB 37231 3172 9 this this DT 37231 3172 10 the the DT 37231 3172 11 carpenter carpenter NN 37231 3172 12 , , , 37231 3172 13 the the DT 37231 3172 14 son son NN 37231 3172 15 of of IN 37231 3172 16 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3172 17 ? ? . 37231 3173 1 " " `` 37231 3173 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3173 3 2 2 CD 37231 3173 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3173 5 but but CC 37231 3173 6 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3173 7 omits omit VBZ 37231 3173 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3173 9 altogether altogether RB 37231 3173 10 . . . 37231 3174 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3174 2 3 3 LS 37231 3174 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3174 4 The the DT 37231 3174 5 idea idea NN 37231 3174 6 that that IN 37231 3174 7 the the DT 37231 3174 8 Son Son NNP 37231 3174 9 of of IN 37231 3174 10 God God NNP 37231 3174 11 should should MD 37231 3174 12 do do VB 37231 3174 13 carpenter carpenter NN 37231 3174 14 's 's POS 37231 3174 15 work work NN 37231 3174 16 on on IN 37231 3174 17 earth earth NN 37231 3174 18 was be VBD 37231 3174 19 very very RB 37231 3174 20 displeasing displease VBG 37231 3174 21 to to IN 37231 3174 22 many many JJ 37231 3174 23 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3174 24 , , , 37231 3174 25 and and CC 37231 3174 26 attempts attempt NNS 37231 3174 27 to to TO 37231 3174 28 get get VB 37231 3174 29 rid rid VBN 37231 3174 30 of of IN 37231 3174 31 the the DT 37231 3174 32 obnoxious obnoxious JJ 37231 3174 33 phrase phrase NN 37231 3174 34 are be VBP 37231 3174 35 evident evident JJ 37231 3174 36 in in IN 37231 3174 37 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3174 38 . . . 37231 3175 1 Apparently apparently RB 37231 3175 2 the the DT 37231 3175 3 copy copy NN 37231 3175 4 which which WDT 37231 3175 5 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3175 6 used use VBD 37231 3175 7 had have VBD 37231 3175 8 omitted omit VBN 37231 3175 9 even even RB 37231 3175 10 the the DT 37231 3175 11 modified modify VBN 37231 3175 12 phrase phrase NN 37231 3175 13 , , , 37231 3175 14 for for IN 37231 3175 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3175 16 declares declare VBZ 37231 3175 17 that that IN 37231 3175 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3175 19 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3175 20 is be VBZ 37231 3175 21 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 3175 22 called call VBN 37231 3175 23 a a DT 37231 3175 24 carpenter carpenter NN 37231 3175 25 in in IN 37231 3175 26 the the DT 37231 3175 27 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3175 28 current current NN 37231 3175 29 in in IN 37231 3175 30 the the DT 37231 3175 31 Church Church NNP 37231 3175 32 . . . 37231 3176 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3176 2 4 4 LS 37231 3176 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3176 4 A a DT 37231 3176 5 few few JJ 37231 3176 6 MSS mss NN 37231 3176 7 . . . 37231 3177 1 still still RB 37231 3177 2 extant extant JJ 37231 3177 3 are be VBP 37231 3177 4 without without IN 37231 3177 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3177 6 , , , 37231 3177 7 although although IN 37231 3177 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3177 9 is be VBZ 37231 3177 10 found find VBN 37231 3177 11 in in IN 37231 3177 12 all all PDT 37231 3177 13 the the DT 37231 3177 14 more more RBR 37231 3177 15 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3177 16 Codices codex NNS 37231 3177 17 . . . 37231 3178 1 Traces trace NNS 37231 3178 2 of of IN 37231 3178 3 these these DT 37231 3178 4 details detail NNS 37231 3178 5 are be VBP 37231 3178 6 found find VBN 37231 3178 7 in in IN 37231 3178 8 several several JJ 37231 3178 9 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3178 10 works work NNS 37231 3178 11 , , , 37231 3178 12 especially especially RB 37231 3178 13 in in IN 37231 3178 14 the the DT 37231 3178 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3178 16 of of IN 37231 3178 17 Thomas Thomas NNP 37231 3178 18 , , , 37231 3178 19 where where WRB 37231 3178 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3178 21 is be VBZ 37231 3178 22 said say VBN 37231 3178 23 : : : 37231 3178 24 " " `` 37231 3178 25 Now now RB 37231 3178 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3178 27 father father NN 37231 3178 28 was be VBD 37231 3178 29 a a DT 37231 3178 30 carpenter carpenter NN 37231 3178 31 and and CC 37231 3178 32 made make VBN 37231 3178 33 at at IN 37231 3178 34 that that DT 37231 3178 35 time time NN 37231 3178 36 ploughs plough NNS 37231 3178 37 and and CC 37231 3178 38 yokes yoke NNS 37231 3178 39 " " '' 37231 3178 40 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3178 41 --Greek--](5 --Greek--](5 NNP 37231 3178 42 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3178 43 , , , 37231 3178 44 an an DT 37231 3178 45 account account NN 37231 3178 46 which which WDT 37231 3178 47 , , , 37231 3178 48 from from IN 37231 3178 49 the the DT 37231 3178 50 similarity similarity NN 37231 3178 51 of of IN 37231 3178 52 language language NN 37231 3178 53 , , , 37231 3178 54 was be VBD 37231 3178 55 in in IN 37231 3178 56 all all DT 37231 3178 57 { { -LRB- 37231 3178 58 315 315 CD 37231 3178 59 } } -RRB- 37231 3178 60 probability probability NN 37231 3178 61 derived derive VBN 37231 3178 62 from from IN 37231 3178 63 the the DT 37231 3178 64 same same JJ 37231 3178 65 source source NN 37231 3178 66 as as IN 37231 3178 67 that that DT 37231 3178 68 of of IN 37231 3178 69 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3178 70 . . . 37231 3179 1 The the DT 37231 3179 2 explanation explanation NN 37231 3179 3 which which WDT 37231 3179 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3179 5 adds add VBZ 37231 3179 6 : : : 37231 3179 7 " " `` 37231 3179 8 by by IN 37231 3179 9 which which WDT 37231 3179 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3179 11 taught teach VBD 37231 3179 12 the the DT 37231 3179 13 symbols symbol NNS 37231 3179 14 of of IN 37231 3179 15 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 3179 16 and and CC 37231 3179 17 an an DT 37231 3179 18 active active JJ 37231 3179 19 life life NN 37231 3179 20 , , , 37231 3179 21 " " '' 37231 3179 22 seems seem VBZ 37231 3179 23 to to TO 37231 3179 24 indicate indicate VB 37231 3179 25 that that IN 37231 3179 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3179 27 refers refer VBZ 37231 3179 28 to to IN 37231 3179 29 a a DT 37231 3179 30 written write VBN 37231 3179 31 narrative narrative NN 37231 3179 32 containing contain VBG 37231 3179 33 the the DT 37231 3179 34 detail detail NN 37231 3179 35 , , , 37231 3179 36 already already RB 37231 3179 37 , , , 37231 3179 38 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 3179 39 , , , 37231 3179 40 falling fall VBG 37231 3179 41 into into IN 37231 3179 42 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 3179 43 disfavour disfavour NN 37231 3179 44 to to TO 37231 3179 45 require require VB 37231 3179 46 the the DT 37231 3179 47 aid aid NN 37231 3179 48 of of IN 37231 3179 49 symbolical symbolical JJ 37231 3179 50 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 3179 51 . . . 37231 3180 1 In in IN 37231 3180 2 the the DT 37231 3180 3 narrative narrative NN 37231 3180 4 of of IN 37231 3180 5 the the DT 37231 3180 6 baptism baptism NN 37231 3180 7 there there EX 37231 3180 8 are be VBP 37231 3180 9 many many JJ 37231 3180 10 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 37231 3180 11 which which WDT 37231 3180 12 prove prove VBP 37231 3180 13 that that IN 37231 3180 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3180 15 did do VBD 37231 3180 16 not not RB 37231 3180 17 derive derive VB 37231 3180 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3180 19 from from IN 37231 3180 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3180 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3180 22 . . . 37231 3181 1 Thrice Thrice NNP 37231 3181 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3181 3 speaks speak VBZ 37231 3181 4 of of IN 37231 3181 5 John John NNP 37231 3181 6 sitting sit VBG 37231 3181 7 by by IN 37231 3181 8 the the DT 37231 3181 9 river river NN 37231 3181 10 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3181 11 : : : 37231 3181 12 " " `` 37231 3181 13 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3181 14 cried cry VBD 37231 3181 15 as as IN 37231 3181 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3181 17 sat sit VBD 37231 3181 18 by by IN 37231 3181 19 the the DT 37231 3181 20 river river NN 37231 3181 21 Jordan;"(1 Jordan;"(1 NNP 37231 3181 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3181 23 " " `` 37231 3181 24 While while IN 37231 3181 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3181 26 still still RB 37231 3181 27 sat sit VBD 37231 3181 28 by by IN 37231 3181 29 the the DT 37231 3181 30 river river NN 37231 3181 31 Jordan;"(2 Jordan;"(2 NNP 37231 3181 32 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3181 33 and and CC 37231 3181 34 " " `` 37231 3181 35 For for IN 37231 3181 36 when when WRB 37231 3181 37 John John NNP 37231 3181 38 sat sit VBD 37231 3181 39 by by IN 37231 3181 40 the the DT 37231 3181 41 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3181 42 . . . 37231 3182 1 " " `` 37231 3182 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3182 3 3 3 LS 37231 3182 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3182 5 This this DT 37231 3182 6 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3182 7 expression expression NN 37231 3182 8 so so RB 37231 3182 9 frequently frequently RB 37231 3182 10 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3182 11 must must MD 37231 3182 12 have have VB 37231 3182 13 been be VBN 37231 3182 14 derived derive VBN 37231 3182 15 from from IN 37231 3182 16 a a DT 37231 3182 17 written write VBN 37231 3182 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3182 19 . . . 37231 3183 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3183 2 4 4 LS 37231 3183 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3183 4 Then then RB 37231 3183 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3183 6 , , , 37231 3183 7 in in IN 37231 3183 8 proving prove VBG 37231 3183 9 that that IN 37231 3183 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3183 11 predicted predict VBD 37231 3183 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3183 13 second second JJ 37231 3183 14 coming coming NN 37231 3183 15 and and CC 37231 3183 16 the the DT 37231 3183 17 re re NN 37231 3183 18 - - NN 37231 3183 19 appearance appearance NN 37231 3183 20 of of IN 37231 3183 21 Elijah Elijah NNP 37231 3183 22 , , , 37231 3183 23 states state VBZ 37231 3183 24 : : : 37231 3183 25 " " `` 37231 3183 26 And and CC 37231 3183 27 therefore therefore RB 37231 3183 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3183 29 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3183 30 in in IN 37231 3183 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3183 32 teaching teaching NN 37231 3183 33 announced announce VBD 37231 3183 34 that that IN 37231 3183 35 this this DT 37231 3183 36 should should MD 37231 3183 37 take take VB 37231 3183 38 place place NN 37231 3183 39 , , , 37231 3183 40 saying say VBG 37231 3183 41 Elias elias PRP 37231 3183 42 also also RB 37231 3183 43 should should MD 37231 3183 44 come come VB 37231 3183 45 " " `` 37231 3183 46 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3183 47 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3183 48 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3183 49 . . . 37231 3184 1 A a DT 37231 3184 2 little little JJ 37231 3184 3 lower low JJR 37231 3184 4 down down IN 37231 3184 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3184 6 again again RB 37231 3184 7 expressly expressly RB 37231 3184 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3184 9 the the DT 37231 3184 10 words word NNS 37231 3184 11 of of IN 37231 3184 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3184 13 : : : 37231 3184 14 " " `` 37231 3184 15 For for IN 37231 3184 16 which which WDT 37231 3184 17 reason reason NN 37231 3184 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3184 19 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3184 20 declared declare VBD 37231 3184 21 on on IN 37231 3184 22 earth earth NN 37231 3184 23 to to IN 37231 3184 24 those those DT 37231 3184 25 who who WP 37231 3184 26 asserted assert VBD 37231 3184 27 that that IN 37231 3184 28 Elias elias PRP 37231 3184 29 must must MD 37231 3184 30 come come VB 37231 3184 31 before before IN 37231 3184 32 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3184 33 : : : 37231 3184 34 Elias elias RB 37231 3184 35 , , , 37231 3184 36 indeed indeed RB 37231 3184 37 , , , 37231 3184 38 shall shall MD 37231 3184 39 come come VB 37231 3184 40 , , , 37231 3184 41 " " '' 37231 3184 42 & & CC 37231 3184 43 c. c. NNP 37231 3185 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3185 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3185 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3185 4 . . . 37231 3186 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3186 2 5 5 LS 37231 3186 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3186 4 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3186 5 , , , 37231 3186 6 however however RB 37231 3186 7 , , , 37231 3186 8 reads read VBZ 37231 3186 9 : : : 37231 3186 10 " " `` 37231 3186 11 Elias elias PRP 37231 3186 12 indeed indeed RB 37231 3186 13 cometh cometh JJ 37231 3186 14 , , , 37231 3186 15 " " '' 37231 3186 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3186 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3186 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3186 19 . . . 37231 3187 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3187 2 6 6 CD 37231 3187 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3187 4 Now now RB 37231 3187 5 there there EX 37231 3187 6 is be VBZ 37231 3187 7 no no DT 37231 3187 8 version version NN 37231 3187 9 in in IN 37231 3187 10 which which WDT 37231 3187 11 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3187 12 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3187 13 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3187 14 is be VBZ 37231 3187 15 substituted substitute VBN 37231 3187 16 for for IN 37231 3187 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3187 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3187 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3187 20 as as IN 37231 3187 21 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3187 22 does do VBZ 37231 3187 23 , , , 37231 3187 24 but but CC 37231 3187 25 , , , 37231 3187 26 as as IN 37231 3187 27 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3187 28 has have VBZ 37231 3187 29 pointed point VBN 37231 3187 30 out,(7 out,(7 CD 37231 3187 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3187 32 the the DT 37231 3187 33 whole whole JJ 37231 3187 34 weight weight NN 37231 3187 35 of of IN 37231 3187 36 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3187 37 's 's POS 37231 3187 38 argument argument NN 37231 3187 39 lies lie VBZ 37231 3187 40 in in IN 37231 3187 41 the the DT 37231 3187 42 use use NN 37231 3187 43 of of IN 37231 3187 44 the the DT 37231 3187 45 future future JJ 37231 3187 46 tense tense NN 37231 3187 47 . . . 37231 3188 1 As as IN 37231 3188 2 there there EX 37231 3188 3 are be VBP 37231 3188 4 so so RB 37231 3188 5 many many JJ 37231 3188 6 other other JJ 37231 3188 7 variations variation NNS 37231 3188 8 { { -LRB- 37231 3188 9 316 316 CD 37231 3188 10 } } -RRB- 37231 3188 11 in in IN 37231 3188 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3188 13 's 's POS 37231 3188 14 context context NN 37231 3188 15 , , , 37231 3188 16 this this DT 37231 3188 17 likewise likewise RB 37231 3188 18 appears appear VBZ 37231 3188 19 to to TO 37231 3188 20 be be VB 37231 3188 21 derived derive VBN 37231 3188 22 from from IN 37231 3188 23 a a DT 37231 3188 24 source source NN 37231 3188 25 different different JJ 37231 3188 26 from from IN 37231 3188 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3188 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3188 29 . . . 37231 3189 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3189 2 1 1 LS 37231 3189 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3189 4 When when WRB 37231 3189 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3189 6 goes go VBZ 37231 3189 7 to to TO 37231 3189 8 be be VB 37231 3189 9 baptized baptize VBN 37231 3189 10 by by IN 37231 3189 11 John John NNP 37231 3189 12 many many JJ 37231 3189 13 - - HYPH 37231 3189 14 striking strike VBG 37231 3189 15 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 37231 3189 16 occur occur VBP 37231 3189 17 in in IN 37231 3189 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3189 19 's 's POS 37231 3189 20 narrative narrative NN 37231 3189 21 : : : 37231 3189 22 " " `` 37231 3189 23 As as IN 37231 3189 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3189 25 went go VBD 37231 3189 26 down down RP 37231 3189 27 to to IN 37231 3189 28 the the DT 37231 3189 29 water water NN 37231 3189 30 , , , 37231 3189 31 a a DT 37231 3189 32 fire fire NN 37231 3189 33 also also RB 37231 3189 34 was be VBD 37231 3189 35 kindled kindle VBN 37231 3189 36 in in IN 37231 3189 37 the the DT 37231 3189 38 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3189 39 ; ; : 37231 3189 40 and and CC 37231 3189 41 when when WRB 37231 3189 42 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3189 43 came come VBD 37231 3189 44 up up RP 37231 3189 45 from from IN 37231 3189 46 the the DT 37231 3189 47 water water NN 37231 3189 48 , , , 37231 3189 49 the the DT 37231 3189 50 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3189 51 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 3189 52 like like IN 37231 3189 53 a a DT 37231 3189 54 dove dove NN 37231 3189 55 fell fall VBD 37231 3189 56 upon upon IN 37231 3189 57 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3189 58 , , , 37231 3189 59 as as IN 37231 3189 60 the the DT 37231 3189 61 apostles apostle NNS 37231 3189 62 of of IN 37231 3189 63 this this DT 37231 3189 64 very very JJ 37231 3189 65 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3189 66 of of IN 37231 3189 67 ours our NNS 37231 3189 68 wrote write VBD 37231 3189 69 ... ... : 37231 3189 70 and and CC 37231 3189 71 at at IN 37231 3189 72 the the DT 37231 3189 73 same same JJ 37231 3189 74 time time NN 37231 3189 75 a a DT 37231 3189 76 voice voice NN 37231 3189 77 came come VBD 37231 3189 78 from from IN 37231 3189 79 the the DT 37231 3189 80 heavens heavens NNPS 37231 3189 81 ... ... : 37231 3189 82 Thou thou VB 37231 3189 83 art art NN 37231 3189 84 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3189 85 son son NN 37231 3189 86 , , , 37231 3189 87 this this DT 37231 3189 88 day day NN 37231 3189 89 have have VBP 37231 3189 90 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3189 91 begotten begotten VB 37231 3189 92 thee thee PRP 37231 3189 93 . . . 37231 3190 1 " " `` 37231 3190 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3190 3 2 2 LS 37231 3190 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3190 5 The the DT 37231 3190 6 incident incident NN 37231 3190 7 of of IN 37231 3190 8 the the DT 37231 3190 9 fire fire NN 37231 3190 10 in in IN 37231 3190 11 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3190 12 is be VBZ 37231 3190 13 of of IN 37231 3190 14 course course NN 37231 3190 15 quite quite RB 37231 3190 16 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3190 17 to to IN 37231 3190 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3190 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3190 20 , , , 37231 3190 21 and and CC 37231 3190 22 further further RB 37231 3190 23 the the DT 37231 3190 24 words word NNS 37231 3190 25 spoken speak VBN 37231 3190 26 by by IN 37231 3190 27 the the DT 37231 3190 28 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3190 29 voice voice NN 37231 3190 30 differ differ VBP 37231 3190 31 from from IN 37231 3190 32 those those DT 37231 3190 33 reported report VBN 37231 3190 34 by by IN 37231 3190 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3190 36 , , , 37231 3190 37 for for IN 37231 3190 38 instead instead RB 37231 3190 39 of of IN 37231 3190 40 the the DT 37231 3190 41 passage passage NN 37231 3190 42 from from IN 37231 3190 43 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 3190 44 ii ii NNP 37231 3190 45 . . . 37231 3191 1 7 7 LS 37231 3191 2 , , , 37231 3191 3 the the DT 37231 3191 4 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3191 5 have have VBP 37231 3191 6 : : : 37231 3191 7 " " `` 37231 3191 8 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3191 9 art art NN 37231 3191 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3191 11 beloved beloved JJ 37231 3191 12 son son NN 37231 3191 13 ; ; : 37231 3191 14 in in IN 37231 3191 15 thee thee NN 37231 3191 16 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3191 17 am be VBP 37231 3191 18 well well RB 37231 3191 19 pleased pleased JJ 37231 3191 20 . . . 37231 3192 1 " " `` 37231 3192 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3192 3 3 3 LS 37231 3192 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3192 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3192 6 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 3192 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3192 8 version version NN 37231 3192 9 a a DT 37231 3192 10 second second JJ 37231 3192 11 time time NN 37231 3192 12 in in IN 37231 3192 13 the the DT 37231 3192 14 same same JJ 37231 3192 15 chapter chapter NN 37231 3192 16 , , , 37231 3192 17 and and CC 37231 3192 18 again again RB 37231 3192 19 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3192 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 21 says say VBZ 37231 3192 22 regarding regard VBG 37231 3192 23 the the DT 37231 3192 24 temptation temptation NN 37231 3192 25 : : : 37231 3192 26 " " `` 37231 3192 27 For for IN 37231 3192 28 this this DT 37231 3192 29 devil devil NN 37231 3192 30 also also RB 37231 3192 31 at at IN 37231 3192 32 the the DT 37231 3192 33 time time NN 37231 3192 34 when when WRB 37231 3192 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 36 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3192 37 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3192 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3192 39 went go VBD 37231 3192 40 up up RP 37231 3192 41 from from IN 37231 3192 42 the the DT 37231 3192 43 river river NN 37231 3192 44 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3192 45 , , , 37231 3192 46 when when WRB 37231 3192 47 the the DT 37231 3192 48 voice voice NN 37231 3192 49 declared declare VBD 37231 3192 50 to to IN 37231 3192 51 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 52 : : : 37231 3192 53 ' ' `` 37231 3192 54 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3192 55 art art NN 37231 3192 56 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3192 57 son son NN 37231 3192 58 ; ; : 37231 3192 59 this this DT 37231 3192 60 day day NN 37231 3192 61 have have VBP 37231 3192 62 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 63 begotten begotten VB 37231 3192 64 thee thee PRP 37231 3192 65 , , , 37231 3192 66 ' ' '' 37231 3192 67 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 68 is be VBZ 37231 3192 69 written write VBN 37231 3192 70 in in IN 37231 3192 71 the the DT 37231 3192 72 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3192 73 of of IN 37231 3192 74 the the DT 37231 3192 75 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3192 76 , , , 37231 3192 77 came come VBD 37231 3192 78 to to IN 37231 3192 79 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 80 and and CC 37231 3192 81 tempted tempt VBD 37231 3192 82 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 83 , , , 37231 3192 84 " " '' 37231 3192 85 & & CC 37231 3192 86 c.(4 c.(4 NNP 37231 3192 87 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3192 88 In in IN 37231 3192 89 both both DT 37231 3192 90 of of IN 37231 3192 91 these these DT 37231 3192 92 passages passage NNS 37231 3192 93 , , , 37231 3192 94 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3192 95 will will MD 37231 3192 96 be be VB 37231 3192 97 perceived perceive VBN 37231 3192 98 that that IN 37231 3192 99 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3192 100 directly directly RB 37231 3192 101 refers refer VBZ 37231 3192 102 to to IN 37231 3192 103 the the DT 37231 3192 104 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3192 105 of of IN 37231 3192 106 the the DT 37231 3192 107 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3192 108 as as IN 37231 3192 109 the the DT 37231 3192 110 source source NN 37231 3192 111 of of IN 37231 3192 112 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3192 113 statements statement NNS 37231 3192 114 . . . 37231 3193 1 Some some DT 37231 3193 2 have have VBP 37231 3193 3 argued argue VBN 37231 3193 4 that that IN 37231 3193 5 { { -LRB- 37231 3193 6 317 317 CD 37231 3193 7 } } -RRB- 37231 3193 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3193 9 only only RB 37231 3193 10 appeals appeal VBZ 37231 3193 11 to to IN 37231 3193 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3193 13 for for IN 37231 3193 14 the the DT 37231 3193 15 fact fact NN 37231 3193 16 of of IN 37231 3193 17 the the DT 37231 3193 18 descent descent NN 37231 3193 19 of of IN 37231 3193 20 the the DT 37231 3193 21 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3193 22 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 3193 23 , , , 37231 3193 24 and and CC 37231 3193 25 not not RB 37231 3193 26 for for IN 37231 3193 27 the the DT 37231 3193 28 rest rest NN 37231 3193 29 of of IN 37231 3193 30 the the DT 37231 3193 31 narrative narrative NN 37231 3193 32 . . . 37231 3194 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3194 2 1 1 LS 37231 3194 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3194 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3194 5 has have VBZ 37231 3194 6 of of IN 37231 3194 7 course course NN 37231 3194 8 been be VBN 37231 3194 9 felt feel VBN 37231 3194 10 that that IN 37231 3194 11 , , , 37231 3194 12 if if IN 37231 3194 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3194 14 can can MD 37231 3194 15 be be VB 37231 3194 16 shown show VBN 37231 3194 17 that that IN 37231 3194 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3194 19 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3194 20 from from IN 37231 3194 21 the the DT 37231 3194 22 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3194 23 words word NNS 37231 3194 24 and and CC 37231 3194 25 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3194 26 which which WDT 37231 3194 27 are be VBP 37231 3194 28 not not RB 37231 3194 29 to to TO 37231 3194 30 be be VB 37231 3194 31 found find VBN 37231 3194 32 in in IN 37231 3194 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3194 34 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3194 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3194 36 , , , 37231 3194 37 the the DT 37231 3194 38 identity identity NN 37231 3194 39 of of IN 37231 3194 40 the the DT 37231 3194 41 two two CD 37231 3194 42 can can MD 37231 3194 43 no no RB 37231 3194 44 longer longer RB 37231 3194 45 be be VB 37231 3194 46 maintained maintain VBN 37231 3194 47 . . . 37231 3195 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3195 2 is be VBZ 37231 3195 3 , , , 37231 3195 4 however however RB 37231 3195 5 , , , 37231 3195 6 in in IN 37231 3195 7 the the DT 37231 3195 8 highest high JJS 37231 3195 9 degree degree NN 37231 3195 10 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 3195 11 to to TO 37231 3195 12 affirm affirm VB 37231 3195 13 that that IN 37231 3195 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3195 15 intends intend VBZ 37231 3195 16 to to TO 37231 3195 17 limit limit VB 37231 3195 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3195 19 appeal appeal NN 37231 3195 20 to to IN 37231 3195 21 the the DT 37231 3195 22 testimony testimony NN 37231 3195 23 of of IN 37231 3195 24 the the DT 37231 3195 25 apostles apostle NNS 37231 3195 26 to to IN 37231 3195 27 one one CD 37231 3195 28 - - HYPH 37231 3195 29 half half NN 37231 3195 30 of of IN 37231 3195 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3195 32 sentence sentence NN 37231 3195 33 . . . 37231 3196 1 To to TO 37231 3196 2 quote quote VB 37231 3196 3 authority authority NN 37231 3196 4 for for IN 37231 3196 5 one one CD 37231 3196 6 assertion assertion NN 37231 3196 7 and and CC 37231 3196 8 to to TO 37231 3196 9 leave leave VB 37231 3196 10 another another DT 37231 3196 11 in in IN 37231 3196 12 the the DT 37231 3196 13 same same JJ 37231 3196 14 sentence sentence NN 37231 3196 15 , , , 37231 3196 16 closely closely RB 37231 3196 17 connected connected JJ 37231 3196 18 with with IN 37231 3196 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3196 20 and and CC 37231 3196 21 part part NN 37231 3196 22 indeed indeed RB 37231 3196 23 of of IN 37231 3196 24 the the DT 37231 3196 25 very very RB 37231 3196 26 same same JJ 37231 3196 27 narrative narrative NN 37231 3196 28 , , , 37231 3196 29 not not RB 37231 3196 30 only only RB 37231 3196 31 unsupported unsupported JJ 37231 3196 32 , , , 37231 3196 33 but but CC 37231 3196 34 indeed indeed RB 37231 3196 35 weakened weaken VBN 37231 3196 36 by by IN 37231 3196 37 direct direct JJ 37231 3196 38 exclusion exclusion NN 37231 3196 39 , , , 37231 3196 40 would would MD 37231 3196 41 indeed indeed RB 37231 3196 42 be be VB 37231 3196 43 singular singular JJ 37231 3196 44 , , , 37231 3196 45 for for IN 37231 3196 46 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3196 47 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 3196 48 with with IN 37231 3196 49 equal equal JJ 37231 3196 50 directness directness NN 37231 3196 51 and and CC 37231 3196 52 confidence confidence VB 37231 3196 53 the the DT 37231 3196 54 fact fact NN 37231 3196 55 of of IN 37231 3196 56 the the DT 37231 3196 57 fire fire NN 37231 3196 58 in in IN 37231 3196 59 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3196 60 , , , 37231 3196 61 the the DT 37231 3196 62 descent descent NN 37231 3196 63 of of IN 37231 3196 64 the the DT 37231 3196 65 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3196 66 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 3196 67 , , , 37231 3196 68 and and CC 37231 3196 69 the the DT 37231 3196 70 words word NNS 37231 3196 71 spoken speak VBN 37231 3196 72 by by IN 37231 3196 73 the the DT 37231 3196 74 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3196 75 voice voice NN 37231 3196 76 . . . 37231 3197 1 If if IN 37231 3197 2 in in IN 37231 3197 3 the the DT 37231 3197 4 strictest strict JJS 37231 3197 5 grammatical grammatical JJ 37231 3197 6 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3197 7 there there EX 37231 3197 8 may may MD 37231 3197 9 be be VB 37231 3197 10 no no DT 37231 3197 11 absolute absolute JJ 37231 3197 12 necessity necessity NN 37231 3197 13 to to TO 37231 3197 14 include include VB 37231 3197 15 in in IN 37231 3197 16 that that DT 37231 3197 17 which which WDT 37231 3197 18 the the DT 37231 3197 19 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3197 20 wrote write VBD 37231 3197 21 more more JJR 37231 3197 22 than than IN 37231 3197 23 the the DT 37231 3197 24 phrase phrase NN 37231 3197 25 immediately immediately RB 37231 3197 26 preceding precede VBG 37231 3197 27 , , , 37231 3197 28 there there EX 37231 3197 29 is be VBZ 37231 3197 30 not not RB 37231 3197 31 , , , 37231 3197 32 on on IN 37231 3197 33 the the DT 37231 3197 34 other other JJ 37231 3197 35 hand hand NN 37231 3197 36 , , , 37231 3197 37 anything anything NN 37231 3197 38 which which WDT 37231 3197 39 requires require VBZ 37231 3197 40 or or CC 37231 3197 41 warrants warrant VBZ 37231 3197 42 the the DT 37231 3197 43 exclusion exclusion NN 37231 3197 44 of of IN 37231 3197 45 the the DT 37231 3197 46 former former JJ 37231 3197 47 part part NN 37231 3197 48 of of IN 37231 3197 49 the the DT 37231 3197 50 sentence sentence NN 37231 3197 51 . . . 37231 3198 1 The the DT 37231 3198 2 matter matter NN 37231 3198 3 must must MD 37231 3198 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 3198 5 be be VB 37231 3198 6 decided decide VBN 37231 3198 7 according accord VBG 37231 3198 8 to to IN 37231 3198 9 fair fair JJ 37231 3198 10 inference inference NN 37231 3198 11 and and CC 37231 3198 12 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 3198 13 probability probability NN 37231 3198 14 , , , 37231 3198 15 and and CC 37231 3198 16 not not RB 37231 3198 17 to to TO 37231 3198 18 suit suit VB 37231 3198 19 any any DT 37231 3198 20 foregone foregone JJ 37231 3198 21 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3198 22 , , , 37231 3198 23 and and CC 37231 3198 24 these these DT 37231 3198 25 as as RB 37231 3198 26 well well RB 37231 3198 27 as as IN 37231 3198 28 all all PDT 37231 3198 29 the the DT 37231 3198 30 evidence evidence NN 37231 3198 31 concerning concern VBG 37231 3198 32 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3198 33 's 's POS 37231 3198 34 use use NN 37231 3198 35 of of IN 37231 3198 36 the the DT 37231 3198 37 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3198 38 irresistibly irresistibly RB 37231 3198 39 point point VBP 37231 3198 40 to to IN 37231 3198 41 the the DT 37231 3198 42 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3198 43 that that IN 37231 3198 44 the the DT 37231 3198 45 whole whole JJ 37231 3198 46 passage passage NN 37231 3198 47 is be VBZ 37231 3198 48 derived derive VBN 37231 3198 49 from from IN 37231 3198 50 one one CD 37231 3198 51 source source NN 37231 3198 52 . . . 37231 3199 1 In in IN 37231 3199 2 the the DT 37231 3199 3 second second JJ 37231 3199 4 extract extract NN 37231 3199 5 given give VBN 37231 3199 6 above above RB 37231 3199 7 , , , 37231 3199 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3199 9 is be VBZ 37231 3199 10 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 3199 11 clear clear JJ 37231 3199 12 that that IN 37231 3199 13 the the DT 37231 3199 14 words word NNS 37231 3199 15 spoken speak VBN 37231 3199 16 by by IN 37231 3199 17 the the DT 37231 3199 18 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3199 19 voice voice NN 37231 3199 20 , , , 37231 3199 21 which which WDT 37231 3199 22 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3199 23 again again RB 37231 3199 24 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3199 25 , , , 37231 3199 26 and and CC 37231 3199 27 which which WDT 37231 3199 28 are be VBP 37231 3199 29 not not RB 37231 3199 30 in in IN 37231 3199 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3199 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3199 33 , , , 37231 3199 34 were be VBD 37231 3199 35 recorded record VBN 37231 3199 36 in in IN 37231 3199 37 the the DT 37231 3199 38 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3199 39 , , , 37231 3199 40 for for IN 37231 3199 41 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3199 42 could could MD 37231 3199 43 { { -LRB- 37231 3199 44 318 318 CD 37231 3199 45 } } -RRB- 37231 3199 46 not not RB 37231 3199 47 have have VBP 37231 3199 48 referred refer VBN 37231 3199 49 to to IN 37231 3199 50 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3199 51 for for IN 37231 3199 52 an an DT 37231 3199 53 account account NN 37231 3199 54 of of IN 37231 3199 55 the the DT 37231 3199 56 temptation temptation NN 37231 3199 57 at at IN 37231 3199 58 the the DT 37231 3199 59 time time NN 37231 3199 60 when when WRB 37231 3199 61 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3199 62 went go VBD 37231 3199 63 up up RP 37231 3199 64 from from IN 37231 3199 65 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3199 66 and and CC 37231 3199 67 the the DT 37231 3199 68 voice voice NN 37231 3199 69 said say VBD 37231 3199 70 to to IN 37231 3199 71 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3199 72 : : : 37231 3199 73 " " `` 37231 3199 74 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3199 75 art art NN 37231 3199 76 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3199 77 son son NN 37231 3199 78 ; ; : 37231 3199 79 this this DT 37231 3199 80 day day NN 37231 3199 81 have have VBP 37231 3199 82 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3199 83 begotten begotten VB 37231 3199 84 thee thee PRP 37231 3199 85 , , , 37231 3199 86 " " `` 37231 3199 87 if if IN 37231 3199 88 these these DT 37231 3199 89 facts fact NNS 37231 3199 90 and and CC 37231 3199 91 words word NNS 37231 3199 92 were be VBD 37231 3199 93 not not RB 37231 3199 94 recorded record VBN 37231 3199 95 in in IN 37231 3199 96 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3199 97 at at RB 37231 3199 98 all all RB 37231 3199 99 . . . 37231 3200 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3200 2 1 1 LS 37231 3200 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3200 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3200 5 is be VBZ 37231 3200 6 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3200 7 to to TO 37231 3200 8 doubt doubt VB 37231 3200 9 , , , 37231 3200 10 after after IN 37231 3200 11 impartial impartial JJ 37231 3200 12 consideration consideration NN 37231 3200 13 , , , 37231 3200 14 that that IN 37231 3200 15 the the DT 37231 3200 16 incident incident NN 37231 3200 17 of of IN 37231 3200 18 the the DT 37231 3200 19 fire fire NN 37231 3200 20 in in IN 37231 3200 21 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3200 22 , , , 37231 3200 23 the the DT 37231 3200 24 words word NNS 37231 3200 25 spoken speak VBN 37231 3200 26 by by IN 37231 3200 27 the the DT 37231 3200 28 voice voice NN 37231 3200 29 from from IN 37231 3200 30 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3200 31 , , , 37231 3200 32 and and CC 37231 3200 33 the the DT 37231 3200 34 temptation temptation NN 37231 3200 35 were be VBD 37231 3200 36 taken take VBN 37231 3200 37 from from IN 37231 3200 38 the the DT 37231 3200 39 same same JJ 37231 3200 40 source source NN 37231 3200 41 : : : 37231 3200 42 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3200 43 must must MD 37231 3200 44 collectively collectively RB 37231 3200 45 be be VB 37231 3200 46 referred refer VBN 37231 3200 47 to to IN 37231 3200 48 the the DT 37231 3200 49 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3200 50 . . . 37231 3201 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3201 2 2 2 LS 37231 3201 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3201 4 Of of IN 37231 3201 5 one one CD 37231 3201 6 thing thing NN 37231 3201 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3201 8 may may MD 37231 3201 9 be be VB 37231 3201 10 sure sure JJ 37231 3201 11 : : : 37231 3201 12 had have VBD 37231 3201 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3201 14 known know VBD 37231 3201 15 the the DT 37231 3201 16 form form NN 37231 3201 17 of of IN 37231 3201 18 words word NNS 37231 3201 19 used use VBN 37231 3201 20 by by IN 37231 3201 21 the the DT 37231 3201 22 voice voice NN 37231 3201 23 from from IN 37231 3201 24 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3201 25 according accord VBG 37231 3201 26 to to IN 37231 3201 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3201 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3201 29 , , , 37231 3201 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3201 31 would would MD 37231 3201 32 certainly certainly RB 37231 3201 33 have have VB 37231 3201 34 made make VBN 37231 3201 35 use use NN 37231 3201 36 of of IN 37231 3201 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3201 38 in in IN 37231 3201 39 preference preference NN 37231 3201 40 to to IN 37231 3201 41 that that DT 37231 3201 42 which which WDT 37231 3201 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3201 44 actually actually RB 37231 3201 45 found find VBD 37231 3201 46 in in IN 37231 3201 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3201 48 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3201 49 . . . 37231 3202 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 2 is be VBZ 37231 3202 3 arguing argue VBG 37231 3202 4 that that IN 37231 3202 5 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3202 6 is be VBZ 37231 3202 7 preexisting preexist VBG 37231 3202 8 God God NNP 37231 3202 9 , , , 37231 3202 10 become become VBN 37231 3202 11 incarnate incarnate JJ 37231 3202 12 by by IN 37231 3202 13 God God NNP 37231 3202 14 's 's POS 37231 3202 15 will will NN 37231 3202 16 through through IN 37231 3202 17 the the DT 37231 3202 18 Virgin Virgin NNP 37231 3202 19 Mary Mary NNP 37231 3202 20 , , , 37231 3202 21 and and CC 37231 3202 22 Trypho Trypho NNP 37231 3202 23 demands demand VBZ 37231 3202 24 how how WRB 37231 3202 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 26 can can MD 37231 3202 27 be be VB 37231 3202 28 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 3202 29 to to TO 37231 3202 30 have have VB 37231 3202 31 been be VBN 37231 3202 32 pre pre VBN 37231 3202 33 - - JJ 37231 3202 34 existent existent JJ 37231 3202 35 , , , 37231 3202 36 who who WP 37231 3202 37 is be VBZ 37231 3202 38 said say VBN 37231 3202 39 to to TO 37231 3202 40 be be VB 37231 3202 41 filled fill VBN 37231 3202 42 with with IN 37231 3202 43 the the DT 37231 3202 44 power power NN 37231 3202 45 of of IN 37231 3202 46 the the DT 37231 3202 47 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3202 48 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 3202 49 , , , 37231 3202 50 as as IN 37231 3202 51 though though IN 37231 3202 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 53 had have VBD 37231 3202 54 required require VBN 37231 3202 55 this this DT 37231 3202 56 , , , 37231 3202 57 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3202 58 replies reply VBZ 37231 3202 59 that that IN 37231 3202 60 these these DT 37231 3202 61 powers power NNS 37231 3202 62 of of IN 37231 3202 63 the the DT 37231 3202 64 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 3202 65 have have VBP 37231 3202 66 come come VBN 37231 3202 67 upon upon IN 37231 3202 68 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 69 not not RB 37231 3202 70 because because IN 37231 3202 71 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 72 had have VBD 37231 3202 73 need need NN 37231 3202 74 of of IN 37231 3202 75 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 76 , , , 37231 3202 77 but but CC 37231 3202 78 because because IN 37231 3202 79 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 80 would would MD 37231 3202 81 accomplish accomplish VB 37231 3202 82 Scripture Scripture NNP 37231 3202 83 , , , 37231 3202 84 which which WDT 37231 3202 85 declared declare VBD 37231 3202 86 that that IN 37231 3202 87 after after IN 37231 3202 88 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3202 89 there there EX 37231 3202 90 should should MD 37231 3202 91 be be VB 37231 3202 92 no no DT 37231 3202 93 prophet prophet NN 37231 3202 94 . . . 37231 3203 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3203 2 3 3 LS 37231 3203 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3203 4 The the DT 37231 3203 5 proof proof NN 37231 3203 6 of of IN 37231 3203 7 this this DT 37231 3203 8 , , , 37231 3203 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3203 10 continues continue VBZ 37231 3203 11 , , , 37231 3203 12 is be VBZ 37231 3203 13 that that DT 37231 3203 14 , , , 37231 3203 15 as as RB 37231 3203 16 soon soon RB 37231 3203 17 as as IN 37231 3203 18 the the DT 37231 3203 19 child child NN 37231 3203 20 was be VBD 37231 3203 21 born bear VBN 37231 3203 22 , , , 37231 3203 23 the the DT 37231 3203 24 Magi Magi NNP 37231 3203 25 from from IN 37231 3203 26 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 3203 27 came come VBD 37231 3203 28 to to TO 37231 3203 29 worship worship VB 37231 3203 30 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3203 31 , , , 37231 3203 32 because because IN 37231 3203 33 even even RB 37231 3203 34 at at IN 37231 3203 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3203 36 birth birth NN 37231 3203 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3203 38 was be VBD 37231 3203 39 in in IN 37231 3203 40 possession possession NN 37231 3203 41 of of IN 37231 3203 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3203 43 power,(4 power,(4 NN 37231 3203 44 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3203 45 and and CC 37231 3203 46 after after IN 37231 3203 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3203 48 had have VBD 37231 3203 49 grown grow VBN 37231 3203 50 up up RP 37231 3203 51 like like IN 37231 3203 52 other other JJ 37231 3203 53 men man NNS 37231 3203 54 by by IN 37231 3203 55 the the DT 37231 3203 56 use use NN 37231 3203 57 of of IN 37231 3203 58 suitable suitable JJ 37231 3203 59 means mean NNS 37231 3203 60 , , , 37231 3203 61 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3203 62 came come VBD 37231 3203 63 to to IN 37231 3203 64 { { -LRB- 37231 3203 65 319 319 CD 37231 3203 66 } } -RRB- 37231 3203 67 the the DT 37231 3203 68 river river NN 37231 3203 69 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3203 70 where where WRB 37231 3203 71 John John NNP 37231 3203 72 was be VBD 37231 3203 73 baptizing baptize VBG 37231 3203 74 , , , 37231 3203 75 and and CC 37231 3203 76 as as IN 37231 3203 77 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3203 78 went go VBD 37231 3203 79 into into IN 37231 3203 80 the the DT 37231 3203 81 water water NN 37231 3203 82 a a DT 37231 3203 83 fire fire NN 37231 3203 84 was be VBD 37231 3203 85 kindled kindle VBN 37231 3203 86 in in IN 37231 3203 87 the the DT 37231 3203 88 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3203 89 , , , 37231 3203 90 and and CC 37231 3203 91 the the DT 37231 3203 92 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3203 93 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 3203 94 descended descend VBD 37231 3203 95 like like IN 37231 3203 96 a a DT 37231 3203 97 dove dove NN 37231 3203 98 . . . 37231 3204 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3204 2 did do VBD 37231 3204 3 not not RB 37231 3204 4 go go VB 37231 3204 5 to to IN 37231 3204 6 the the DT 37231 3204 7 river river NN 37231 3204 8 because because IN 37231 3204 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3204 10 had have VBD 37231 3204 11 any any DT 37231 3204 12 need need NN 37231 3204 13 of of IN 37231 3204 14 baptism baptism NN 37231 3204 15 or or CC 37231 3204 16 of of IN 37231 3204 17 the the DT 37231 3204 18 descent descent NN 37231 3204 19 of of IN 37231 3204 20 the the DT 37231 3204 21 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 3204 22 , , , 37231 3204 23 but but CC 37231 3204 24 because because IN 37231 3204 25 of of IN 37231 3204 26 the the DT 37231 3204 27 human human JJ 37231 3204 28 race race NN 37231 3204 29 which which WDT 37231 3204 30 had have VBD 37231 3204 31 fallen fall VBN 37231 3204 32 under under IN 37231 3204 33 the the DT 37231 3204 34 power power NN 37231 3204 35 of of IN 37231 3204 36 death death NN 37231 3204 37 . . . 37231 3205 1 Now now RB 37231 3205 2 if if IN 37231 3205 3 , , , 37231 3205 4 instead instead RB 37231 3205 5 of of IN 37231 3205 6 the the DT 37231 3205 7 passage passage NN 37231 3205 8 actually actually RB 37231 3205 9 cited cite VBN 37231 3205 10 , , , 37231 3205 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3205 12 could could MD 37231 3205 13 have have VB 37231 3205 14 quoted quote VBN 37231 3205 15 the the DT 37231 3205 16 words word NNS 37231 3205 17 addressed address VBN 37231 3205 18 to to IN 37231 3205 19 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3205 20 by by IN 37231 3205 21 the the DT 37231 3205 22 voice voice NN 37231 3205 23 from from IN 37231 3205 24 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3205 25 according accord VBG 37231 3205 26 to to IN 37231 3205 27 the the DT 37231 3205 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3205 29 : : : 37231 3205 30 " " `` 37231 3205 31 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3205 32 art art NN 37231 3205 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3205 34 beloved beloved JJ 37231 3205 35 son son NN 37231 3205 36 ; ; : 37231 3205 37 in in IN 37231 3205 38 thee thee NN 37231 3205 39 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3205 40 am be VBP 37231 3205 41 well well RB 37231 3205 42 pleased pleased JJ 37231 3205 43 , , , 37231 3205 44 " " '' 37231 3205 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3205 46 argument argument NN 37231 3205 47 would would MD 37231 3205 48 have have VB 37231 3205 49 been be VBN 37231 3205 50 greatly greatly RB 37231 3205 51 strengthened strengthen VBN 37231 3205 52 by by IN 37231 3205 53 such such JJ 37231 3205 54 direct direct JJ 37231 3205 55 recognition recognition NN 37231 3205 56 of of IN 37231 3205 57 an an DT 37231 3205 58 already already RB 37231 3205 59 existing exist VBG 37231 3205 60 , , , 37231 3205 61 and and CC 37231 3205 62 , , , 37231 3205 63 as as IN 37231 3205 64 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3205 65 affirmed affirm VBD 37231 3205 66 , , , 37231 3205 67 pre pre JJ 37231 3205 68 - - JJ 37231 3205 69 existent existent JJ 37231 3205 70 divinity divinity NN 37231 3205 71 in in IN 37231 3205 72 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3205 73 . . . 37231 3206 1 Not not RB 37231 3206 2 having have VBG 37231 3206 3 these these DT 37231 3206 4 words word NNS 37231 3206 5 in in IN 37231 3206 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3206 7 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3206 8 of of IN 37231 3206 9 the the DT 37231 3206 10 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3206 11 , , , 37231 3206 12 however however RB 37231 3206 13 , , , 37231 3206 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3206 15 was be VBD 37231 3206 16 obliged oblige VBN 37231 3206 17 to to TO 37231 3206 18 be be VB 37231 3206 19 content content JJ 37231 3206 20 with with IN 37231 3206 21 those those DT 37231 3206 22 which which WDT 37231 3206 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3206 24 found find VBD 37231 3206 25 there there RB 37231 3206 26 : : : 37231 3206 27 " " `` 37231 3206 28 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3206 29 art art NN 37231 3206 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3206 31 son son NN 37231 3206 32 ; ; : 37231 3206 33 this this DT 37231 3206 34 day day NN 37231 3206 35 have have VBP 37231 3206 36 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3206 37 begotten begotten VB 37231 3206 38 thee;"--words thee;"--word NNS 37231 3206 39 which which WDT 37231 3206 40 , , , 37231 3206 41 in in IN 37231 3206 42 fact fact NN 37231 3206 43 , , , 37231 3206 44 in in IN 37231 3206 45 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3206 46 destroyed destroy VBD 37231 3206 47 the the DT 37231 3206 48 argument argument NN 37231 3206 49 for for IN 37231 3206 50 pre pre NN 37231 3206 51 - - NN 37231 3206 52 existence existence NN 37231 3206 53 , , , 37231 3206 54 and and CC 37231 3206 55 dated date VBD 37231 3206 56 the the DT 37231 3206 57 divine divine JJ 37231 3206 58 begetting begetting NN 37231 3206 59 of of IN 37231 3206 60 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3206 61 as as IN 37231 3206 62 the the DT 37231 3206 63 son son NN 37231 3206 64 of of IN 37231 3206 65 God God NNP 37231 3206 66 that that DT 37231 3206 67 very very JJ 37231 3206 68 day day NN 37231 3206 69 . . . 37231 3207 1 The the DT 37231 3207 2 passage passage NN 37231 3207 3 , , , 37231 3207 4 indeed indeed RB 37231 3207 5 , , , 37231 3207 6 supported support VBD 37231 3207 7 those those DT 37231 3207 8 who who WP 37231 3207 9 actually actually RB 37231 3207 10 asserted assert VBD 37231 3207 11 that that IN 37231 3207 12 the the DT 37231 3207 13 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3207 14 Ghost Ghost NNP 37231 3207 15 first first RB 37231 3207 16 entered enter VBD 37231 3207 17 into into IN 37231 3207 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3207 19 at at IN 37231 3207 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3207 21 baptism baptism NN 37231 3207 22 . . . 37231 3208 1 These these DT 37231 3208 2 considerations consideration NNS 37231 3208 3 , , , 37231 3208 4 and and CC 37231 3208 5 the the DT 37231 3208 6 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3208 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 3208 8 of of IN 37231 3208 9 the the DT 37231 3208 10 same same JJ 37231 3208 11 words word NNS 37231 3208 12 in in IN 37231 3208 13 the the DT 37231 3208 14 same same JJ 37231 3208 15 form form NN 37231 3208 16 , , , 37231 3208 17 make make VB 37231 3208 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3208 19 clear clear JJ 37231 3208 20 that that IN 37231 3208 21 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3208 22 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3208 23 from from IN 37231 3208 24 a a DT 37231 3208 25 source source NN 37231 3208 26 different different JJ 37231 3208 27 from from IN 37231 3208 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3208 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3208 30 . . . 37231 3209 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3209 2 1 1 LS 37231 3209 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3209 4 In in IN 37231 3209 5 the the DT 37231 3209 6 scanty scanty NN 37231 3209 7 fragments fragment NNS 37231 3209 8 of of IN 37231 3209 9 the the DT 37231 3209 10 " " `` 37231 3209 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3209 12 according accord VBG 37231 3209 13 to to IN 37231 3209 14 the the DT 37231 3209 15 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3209 16 " " '' 37231 3209 17 which which WDT 37231 3209 18 have have VBP 37231 3209 19 been be VBN 37231 3209 20 preserved preserve VBN 37231 3209 21 , , , 37231 3209 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3209 23 find find VBP 37231 3209 24 both both CC 37231 3209 25 the the DT 37231 3209 26 incident incident NN 37231 3209 27 of of IN 37231 3209 28 the the DT 37231 3209 29 fire fire NN 37231 3209 30 kindled kindle VBN 37231 3209 31 in in IN 37231 3209 32 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3209 33 and and CC 37231 3209 34 the the DT 37231 3209 35 words word NNS 37231 3209 36 { { -LRB- 37231 3209 37 320 320 CD 37231 3209 38 } } -RRB- 37231 3209 39 of of IN 37231 3209 40 the the DT 37231 3209 41 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3209 42 voice voice NN 37231 3209 43 as as IN 37231 3209 44 quoted quote VBN 37231 3209 45 by by IN 37231 3209 46 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3209 47 . . . 37231 3210 1 " " `` 37231 3210 2 And and CC 37231 3210 3 as as IN 37231 3210 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3210 5 went go VBD 37231 3210 6 up up RP 37231 3210 7 from from IN 37231 3210 8 the the DT 37231 3210 9 water water NN 37231 3210 10 , , , 37231 3210 11 the the DT 37231 3210 12 heavens heavens NNPS 37231 3210 13 were be VBD 37231 3210 14 opened open VBN 37231 3210 15 , , , 37231 3210 16 and and CC 37231 3210 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3210 18 saw see VBD 37231 3210 19 the the DT 37231 3210 20 Holy Holy NNP 37231 3210 21 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 3210 22 of of IN 37231 3210 23 God God NNP 37231 3210 24 in in IN 37231 3210 25 the the DT 37231 3210 26 form form NN 37231 3210 27 of of IN 37231 3210 28 a a DT 37231 3210 29 dove dove NN 37231 3210 30 which which WDT 37231 3210 31 came come VBD 37231 3210 32 down down RP 37231 3210 33 and and CC 37231 3210 34 entered enter VBD 37231 3210 35 into into IN 37231 3210 36 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3210 37 . . . 37231 3211 1 And and CC 37231 3211 2 a a DT 37231 3211 3 voice voice NN 37231 3211 4 came come VBD 37231 3211 5 from from IN 37231 3211 6 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3211 7 saying say VBG 37231 3211 8 : : : 37231 3211 9 ' ' `` 37231 3211 10 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3211 11 art art NN 37231 3211 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3211 13 beloved beloved JJ 37231 3211 14 son son NN 37231 3211 15 ; ; : 37231 3211 16 in in IN 37231 3211 17 thee thee NN 37231 3211 18 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3211 19 am be VBP 37231 3211 20 well well RB 37231 3211 21 pleased pleased JJ 37231 3211 22 ; ; : 37231 3211 23 ' ' '' 37231 3211 24 and and CC 37231 3211 25 again again RB 37231 3211 26 : : : 37231 3211 27 ' ' '' 37231 3211 28 This this DT 37231 3211 29 day day NN 37231 3211 30 have have VBP 37231 3211 31 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3211 32 begotten begotten VB 37231 3211 33 thee thee PRP 37231 3211 34 . . . 37231 3211 35 ' ' '' 37231 3212 1 And and CC 37231 3212 2 immediately immediately RB 37231 3212 3 a a DT 37231 3212 4 great great JJ 37231 3212 5 light light NN 37231 3212 6 shone shine VBN 37231 3212 7 round round RB 37231 3212 8 about about IN 37231 3212 9 the the DT 37231 3212 10 place place NN 37231 3212 11 . . . 37231 3213 1 " " `` 37231 3213 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3213 3 1 1 LS 37231 3213 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3213 5 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3213 6 extracts extract VBZ 37231 3213 7 this this DT 37231 3213 8 passage passage NN 37231 3213 9 from from IN 37231 3213 10 the the DT 37231 3213 11 version version NN 37231 3213 12 in in IN 37231 3213 13 use use NN 37231 3213 14 amongst amongst IN 37231 3213 15 the the DT 37231 3213 16 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 3213 17 , , , 37231 3213 18 but but CC 37231 3213 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3213 20 is be VBZ 37231 3213 21 well well RB 37231 3213 22 known know VBN 37231 3213 23 that that IN 37231 3213 24 there there EX 37231 3213 25 were be VBD 37231 3213 26 many many JJ 37231 3213 27 other other JJ 37231 3213 28 varying vary VBG 37231 3213 29 forms form NNS 37231 3213 30 of of IN 37231 3213 31 the the DT 37231 3213 32 same same JJ 37231 3213 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3213 34 ; ; : 37231 3213 35 and and CC 37231 3213 36 Hilgenfeld,(2 Hilgenfeld,(2 NNP 37231 3213 37 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3213 38 with with IN 37231 3213 39 all all DT 37231 3213 40 probability probability NN 37231 3213 41 , , , 37231 3213 42 conjectures conjecture VBZ 37231 3213 43 that that IN 37231 3213 44 the the DT 37231 3213 45 version version NN 37231 3213 46 known know VBN 37231 3213 47 to to IN 37231 3213 48 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3213 49 was be VBD 37231 3213 50 no no RB 37231 3213 51 longer long RBR 37231 3213 52 in in IN 37231 3213 53 the the DT 37231 3213 54 same same JJ 37231 3213 55 purity purity NN 37231 3213 56 as as IN 37231 3213 57 that that DT 37231 3213 58 used use VBN 37231 3213 59 by by IN 37231 3213 60 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3213 61 , , , 37231 3213 62 but but CC 37231 3213 63 represents represent VBZ 37231 3213 64 the the DT 37231 3213 65 transition transition NN 37231 3213 66 stage stage NN 37231 3213 67 to to IN 37231 3213 68 the the DT 37231 3213 69 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3213 70 Gospels,--adopting gospels,--adopting IN 37231 3213 71 the the DT 37231 3213 72 words word NNS 37231 3213 73 of of IN 37231 3213 74 the the DT 37231 3213 75 voice voice NN 37231 3213 76 which which WDT 37231 3213 77 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3213 78 give give VBP 37231 3213 79 without without IN 37231 3213 80 yet yet RB 37231 3213 81 discarding discard VBG 37231 3213 82 the the DT 37231 3213 83 older old JJR 37231 3213 84 form form NN 37231 3213 85 . . . 37231 3214 1 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 3214 2 gives give VBZ 37231 3214 3 another another DT 37231 3214 4 form form NN 37231 3214 5 of of IN 37231 3214 6 the the DT 37231 3214 7 words word NNS 37231 3214 8 from from IN 37231 3214 9 the the DT 37231 3214 10 version version NN 37231 3214 11 in in IN 37231 3214 12 use use NN 37231 3214 13 amongst amongst IN 37231 3214 14 the the DT 37231 3214 15 Nazarenes Nazarenes NNPS 37231 3214 16 : : : 37231 3214 17 " " `` 37231 3214 18 Factum factum RB 37231 3214 19 est est NNP 37231 3214 20 autem autem JJ 37231 3214 21 cum cum NNP 37231 3214 22 ascendisset ascendisset NN 37231 3214 23 Dominus Dominus NNP 37231 3214 24 de de IN 37231 3214 25 aqua aqua NNP 37231 3214 26 , , , 37231 3214 27 descendit descendit NN 37231 3214 28 fons fon NNS 37231 3214 29 omnis omnis NN 37231 3214 30 Spiritus Spiritus NNP 37231 3214 31 Sancti Sancti NNP 37231 3214 32 et et NNP 37231 3214 33 requievit requievit VBP 37231 3214 34 super super NNP 37231 3214 35 eum eum NNP 37231 3214 36 , , , 37231 3214 37 et et NN 37231 3214 38 dixit dixit NN 37231 3214 39 illi illi NNP 37231 3214 40 : : : 37231 3214 41 Fili Fili NNP 37231 3214 42 mi mi NNP 37231 3214 43 , , , 37231 3214 44 in in IN 37231 3214 45 omnibus omnibus JJ 37231 3214 46 Prophetis Prophetis NNP 37231 3214 47 expectabam expectabam NNP 37231 3214 48 te te NNP 37231 3214 49 ut ut NNP 37231 3214 50 venires venires NNP 37231 3214 51 et et NNP 37231 3214 52 requiescerem requiescerem NN 37231 3214 53 in in IN 37231 3214 54 te te NNP 37231 3214 55 , , , 37231 3214 56 tu tu NNP 37231 3214 57 es es NNP 37231 3214 58 enim enim NNP 37231 3214 59 requies requie VBZ 37231 3214 60 mea mea NNP 37231 3214 61 , , , 37231 3214 62 tu tu NNP 37231 3214 63 es es NNP 37231 3214 64 filius filius NNP 37231 3214 65 meus meus NNP 37231 3214 66 primo primo NNP 37231 3214 67 - - HYPH 37231 3214 68 genitus genitus NNP 37231 3214 69 qui qui NNP 37231 3214 70 regnas regnas NNPS 37231 3214 71 in in IN 37231 3214 72 sempiternum sempiternum NN 37231 3214 73 . . . 37231 3215 1 " " `` 37231 3215 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3215 3 3 3 LS 37231 3215 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3215 5 This this DT 37231 3215 6 supports support VBZ 37231 3215 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3215 8 's 's POS 37231 3215 9 reading reading NN 37231 3215 10 . . . 37231 3216 1 Regarding regard VBG 37231 3216 2 the the DT 37231 3216 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3216 4 according accord VBG 37231 3216 5 to to IN 37231 3216 6 the the DT 37231 3216 7 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3216 8 more more RBR 37231 3216 9 must must MD 37231 3216 10 be be VB 37231 3216 11 said say VBN 37231 3216 12 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 3216 13 , , , 37231 3216 14 but but CC 37231 3216 15 when when WRB 37231 3216 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 17 is be VBZ 37231 3216 18 remembered remember VBN 37231 3216 19 that that IN 37231 3216 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3216 21 , , , 37231 3216 22 a a DT 37231 3216 23 native native NN 37231 3216 24 of of IN 37231 3216 25 Samaria Samaria NNP 37231 3216 26 , , , 37231 3216 27 probably probably RB 37231 3216 28 first first RB 37231 3216 29 knew know VBD 37231 3216 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 3216 31 through through IN 37231 3216 32 believers believer NNS 37231 3216 33 in in IN 37231 3216 34 Syria Syria NNP 37231 3216 35 to to IN 37231 3216 36 whose whose WP$ 37231 3216 37 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 3216 38 view view NN 37231 3216 39 of of IN 37231 3216 40 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 3216 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 42 all all PDT 37231 3216 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3216 44 { { -LRB- 37231 3216 45 321 321 CD 37231 3216 46 } } -RRB- 37231 3216 47 life life NN 37231 3216 48 adhered adhere VBD 37231 3216 49 , , , 37231 3216 50 and and CC 37231 3216 51 that that IN 37231 3216 52 these these DT 37231 3216 53 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3216 54 almost almost RB 37231 3216 55 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 3216 56 used use VBD 37231 3216 57 this this DT 37231 3216 58 Gospel(1 gospel(1 NN 37231 3216 59 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3216 60 under under IN 37231 3216 61 various various JJ 37231 3216 62 forms form NNS 37231 3216 63 and and CC 37231 3216 64 names name NNS 37231 3216 65 , , , 37231 3216 66 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 67 is be VBZ 37231 3216 68 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 3216 69 to to TO 37231 3216 70 suppose suppose VB 37231 3216 71 that that IN 37231 3216 72 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 73 also also RB 37231 3216 74 like like IN 37231 3216 75 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 76 knew know VBD 37231 3216 77 and and CC 37231 3216 78 made make VBD 37231 3216 79 use use NN 37231 3216 80 of of IN 37231 3216 81 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 82 , , , 37231 3216 83 a a DT 37231 3216 84 supposition supposition NN 37231 3216 85 increased increase VBD 37231 3216 86 almost almost RB 37231 3216 87 to to TO 37231 3216 88 certainty certainty NN 37231 3216 89 when when WRB 37231 3216 90 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 91 is be VBZ 37231 3216 92 found find VBN 37231 3216 93 that that IN 37231 3216 94 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3216 95 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3216 96 words word NNS 37231 3216 97 and and CC 37231 3216 98 facts fact NNS 37231 3216 99 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3216 100 to to IN 37231 3216 101 the the DT 37231 3216 102 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3216 103 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3216 104 which which WDT 37231 3216 105 are be VBP 37231 3216 106 known know VBN 37231 3216 107 to to TO 37231 3216 108 have have VB 37231 3216 109 been be VBN 37231 3216 110 contained contain VBN 37231 3216 111 in in IN 37231 3216 112 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3216 113 . . . 37231 3217 1 The the DT 37231 3217 2 argument argument NN 37231 3217 3 of of IN 37231 3217 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3217 5 that that WDT 37231 3217 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3217 7 did do VBD 37231 3217 8 not not RB 37231 3217 9 need need VB 37231 3217 10 baptism baptism NN 37231 3217 11 may may MD 37231 3217 12 also also RB 37231 3217 13 be be VB 37231 3217 14 compared compare VBN 37231 3217 15 to to IN 37231 3217 16 another another DT 37231 3217 17 passage passage NN 37231 3217 18 of of IN 37231 3217 19 the the DT 37231 3217 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3217 21 according accord VBG 37231 3217 22 to to IN 37231 3217 23 the the DT 37231 3217 24 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3217 25 preserved preserve VBN 37231 3217 26 by by IN 37231 3217 27 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 3217 28 , , , 37231 3217 29 and and CC 37231 3217 30 which which WDT 37231 3217 31 preceded precede VBD 37231 3217 32 the the DT 37231 3217 33 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3217 34 narrated narrate VBN 37231 3217 35 above above RB 37231 3217 36 , , , 37231 3217 37 in in IN 37231 3217 38 which which WDT 37231 3217 39 the the DT 37231 3217 40 mother mother NN 37231 3217 41 and and CC 37231 3217 42 brethren brother NNS 37231 3217 43 of of IN 37231 3217 44 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3217 45 say say VBP 37231 3217 46 to to IN 37231 3217 47 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3217 48 that that IN 37231 3217 49 John John NNP 37231 3217 50 the the DT 37231 3217 51 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 3217 52 is be VBZ 37231 3217 53 baptizing baptize VBG 37231 3217 54 for for IN 37231 3217 55 the the DT 37231 3217 56 remission remission NN 37231 3217 57 of of IN 37231 3217 58 sins sin NNS 37231 3217 59 , , , 37231 3217 60 and and CC 37231 3217 61 propose propose VB 37231 3217 62 that that IN 37231 3217 63 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3217 64 should should MD 37231 3217 65 go go VB 37231 3217 66 to to TO 37231 3217 67 be be VB 37231 3217 68 baptized baptize VBN 37231 3217 69 by by IN 37231 3217 70 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3217 71 . . . 37231 3218 1 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3218 2 replies reply VBZ 37231 3218 3 , , , 37231 3218 4 " " `` 37231 3218 5 In in IN 37231 3218 6 what what WDT 37231 3218 7 way way NN 37231 3218 8 have have VBP 37231 3218 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3218 10 sinned sin VBN 37231 3218 11 that that IN 37231 3218 12 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3218 13 should should MD 37231 3218 14 go go VB 37231 3218 15 and and CC 37231 3218 16 be be VB 37231 3218 17 baptized baptize VBN 37231 3218 18 by by IN 37231 3218 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3218 20 ? ? . 37231 3219 1 " " `` 37231 3219 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3219 3 2 2 LS 37231 3219 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3219 5 The the DT 37231 3219 6 most most RBS 37231 3219 7 competent competent JJ 37231 3219 8 critics critic NNS 37231 3219 9 agree agree VBP 37231 3219 10 that that IN 37231 3219 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3219 12 derived derive VBD 37231 3219 13 the the DT 37231 3219 14 incidents incident NNS 37231 3219 15 of of IN 37231 3219 16 the the DT 37231 3219 17 fire fire NN 37231 3219 18 in in IN 37231 3219 19 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3219 20 and and CC 37231 3219 21 the the DT 37231 3219 22 words word NNS 37231 3219 23 spoken speak VBN 37231 3219 24 by by IN 37231 3219 25 the the DT 37231 3219 26 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3219 27 voice voice NN 37231 3219 28 from from IN 37231 3219 29 the the DT 37231 3219 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3219 31 according accord VBG 37231 3219 32 to to IN 37231 3219 33 the the DT 37231 3219 34 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3219 35 or or CC 37231 3219 36 some some DT 37231 3219 37 kindred kindred JJ 37231 3219 38 work,(3 work,(3 NN 37231 3219 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3219 40 and and CC 37231 3219 41 there there EX 37231 3219 42 is be VBZ 37231 3219 43 every every DT 37231 3219 44 probability probability NN 37231 3219 45 that that IN 37231 3219 46 the the DT 37231 3219 47 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3219 48 other other JJ 37231 3219 49 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3219 50 in in IN 37231 3219 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3219 52 works work NNS 37231 3219 53 differing differ VBG 37231 3219 54 from from IN 37231 3219 55 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3219 56 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3219 57 are be VBP 37231 3219 58 taken take VBN 37231 3219 59 from from IN 37231 3219 60 the the DT 37231 3219 61 same same JJ 37231 3219 62 source source NN 37231 3219 63 . . . 37231 3220 1 The the DT 37231 3220 2 incident incident NN 37231 3220 3 of of IN 37231 3220 4 the the DT 37231 3220 5 fire fire NN 37231 3220 6 in in IN 37231 3220 7 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3220 8 likewise likewise RB 37231 3220 9 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3220 10 in in IN 37231 3220 11 the the DT 37231 3220 12 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3220 13 work work NN 37231 3220 14 " " `` 37231 3220 15 Prædicatio Prædicatio NNP 37231 3220 16 Pauli,"(4 pauli,"(4 NN 37231 3220 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3220 18 coupled couple VBN 37231 3220 19 with with IN 37231 3220 20 a a DT 37231 3220 21 { { -LRB- 37231 3220 22 322 322 CD 37231 3220 23 } } -RRB- 37231 3220 24 context context NN 37231 3220 25 which which WDT 37231 3220 26 forcibly forcibly RB 37231 3220 27 recalls recall VBZ 37231 3220 28 the the DT 37231 3220 29 passage passage NN 37231 3220 30 of of IN 37231 3220 31 the the DT 37231 3220 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3220 33 according accord VBG 37231 3220 34 to to IN 37231 3220 35 the the DT 37231 3220 36 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3220 37 , , , 37231 3220 38 which which WDT 37231 3220 39 has have VBZ 37231 3220 40 just just RB 37231 3220 41 been be VBN 37231 3220 42 quoted quote VBN 37231 3220 43 , , , 37231 3220 44 and and CC 37231 3220 45 apparent apparent JJ 37231 3220 46 allusions allusion NNS 37231 3220 47 to to IN 37231 3220 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3220 49 are be VBP 37231 3220 50 found find VBN 37231 3220 51 in in IN 37231 3220 52 the the DT 37231 3220 53 Sibylline Sibylline NNP 37231 3220 54 Books Books NNPS 37231 3220 55 and and CC 37231 3220 56 early early JJ 37231 3220 57 Christian christian JJ 37231 3220 58 literature literature NN 37231 3220 59 . . . 37231 3221 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3221 2 1 1 LS 37231 3221 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3221 4 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3221 5 has have VBZ 37231 3221 6 pointed point VBN 37231 3221 7 out out RP 37231 3221 8 that that IN 37231 3221 9 the the DT 37231 3221 10 marked marked JJ 37231 3221 11 use use NN 37231 3221 12 which which WDT 37231 3221 13 was be VBD 37231 3221 14 made make VBN 37231 3221 15 of of IN 37231 3221 16 fire fire NN 37231 3221 17 or or CC 37231 3221 18 lights light NNS 37231 3221 19 at at IN 37231 3221 20 Baptism Baptism NNP 37231 3221 21 by by IN 37231 3221 22 the the DT 37231 3221 23 Church Church NNP 37231 3221 24 , , , 37231 3221 25 during during IN 37231 3221 26 early early JJ 37231 3221 27 times time NNS 37231 3221 28 , , , 37231 3221 29 probably probably RB 37231 3221 30 rose rise VBD 37231 3221 31 out out IN 37231 3221 32 of of IN 37231 3221 33 this this DT 37231 3221 34 tradition tradition NN 37231 3221 35 regarding regard VBG 37231 3221 36 the the DT 37231 3221 37 fire fire NN 37231 3221 38 which which WDT 37231 3221 39 appeared appear VBD 37231 3221 40 in in IN 37231 3221 41 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3221 42 at at IN 37231 3221 43 the the DT 37231 3221 44 baptism baptism NN 37231 3221 45 of of IN 37231 3221 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3221 47 . . . 37231 3222 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3222 2 2 2 LS 37231 3222 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3222 4 The the DT 37231 3222 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3222 6 form form NN 37231 3222 7 of of IN 37231 3222 8 words word NNS 37231 3222 9 used use VBN 37231 3222 10 by by IN 37231 3222 11 the the DT 37231 3222 12 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3222 13 voice voice NN 37231 3222 14 according accord VBG 37231 3222 15 to to IN 37231 3222 16 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3222 17 and and CC 37231 3222 18 to to IN 37231 3222 19 the the DT 37231 3222 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3222 21 according accord VBG 37231 3222 22 to to IN 37231 3222 23 the the DT 37231 3222 24 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3222 25 was be VBD 37231 3222 26 also also RB 37231 3222 27 known know VBN 37231 3222 28 to to IN 37231 3222 29 several several JJ 37231 3222 30 of of IN 37231 3222 31 the the DT 37231 3222 32 Fathers father NNS 37231 3222 33 . . . 37231 3223 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3223 2 3 3 LS 37231 3223 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3223 4 Augustine augustine JJ 37231 3223 5 mentions mention NNS 37231 3223 6 that that IN 37231 3223 7 some some DT 37231 3223 8 MSS MSS NNP 37231 3223 9 . . . 37231 3224 1 in in IN 37231 3224 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3224 3 time time NN 37231 3224 4 contained contain VBD 37231 3224 5 that that IN 37231 3224 6 reading read VBG 37231 3224 7 in in IN 37231 3224 8 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3224 9 iii iii NNP 37231 3224 10 . . . 37231 3225 1 22 22 CD 37231 3225 2 , , , 37231 3225 3 although although IN 37231 3225 4 without without IN 37231 3225 5 the the DT 37231 3225 6 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 3225 7 of of IN 37231 3225 8 more more RBR 37231 3225 9 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3225 10 Greek greek JJ 37231 3225 11 codices codex NNS 37231 3225 12 . . . 37231 3226 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3226 2 4 4 LS 37231 3226 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3226 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3226 5 is be VBZ 37231 3226 6 still still RB 37231 3226 7 extant extant JJ 37231 3226 8 in in IN 37231 3226 9 the the DT 37231 3226 10 Codex Codex NNP 37231 3226 11 Bezæ Bezæ NNP 37231 3226 12 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3226 13 D D NNP 37231 3226 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3226 15 . . . 37231 3227 1 The the DT 37231 3227 2 Itala Itala NNP 37231 3227 3 version version NN 37231 3227 4 adds add VBZ 37231 3227 5 to to IN 37231 3227 6 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3227 7 iii iii NNP 37231 3227 8 . . . 37231 3228 1 15 15 CD 37231 3228 2 : : : 37231 3228 3 " " `` 37231 3228 4 and and CC 37231 3228 5 when when WRB 37231 3228 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3228 7 was be VBD 37231 3228 8 baptized baptize VBN 37231 3228 9 a a DT 37231 3228 10 great great JJ 37231 3228 11 light light NN 37231 3228 12 shone shine VBN 37231 3228 13 round round RB 37231 3228 14 from from IN 37231 3228 15 the the DT 37231 3228 16 water water NN 37231 3228 17 , , , 37231 3228 18 so so IN 37231 3228 19 that that IN 37231 3228 20 all all DT 37231 3228 21 who who WP 37231 3228 22 had have VBD 37231 3228 23 come come VBN 37231 3228 24 were be VBD 37231 3228 25 afraid afraid JJ 37231 3228 26 " " '' 37231 3228 27 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3228 28 et et NNP 37231 3228 29 cum cum NNP 37231 3228 30 baptizaretur baptizaretur NNP 37231 3228 31 , , , 37231 3228 32 lumen lumen NNP 37231 3228 33 ingens ingens NNP 37231 3228 34 circumfulsit circumfulsit NNP 37231 3228 35 de de NNP 37231 3228 36 aqua aqua NNP 37231 3228 37 , , , 37231 3228 38 ita ita NNP 37231 3228 39 ut ut NNP 37231 3228 40 timerent timerent NNP 37231 3228 41 omnes omnes NNP 37231 3228 42 qui qui NNP 37231 3228 43 advenerant advenerant NNP 37231 3228 44 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3228 45 ; ; : 37231 3228 46 and and CC 37231 3228 47 again again RB 37231 3228 48 at at IN 37231 3228 49 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3228 50 iii iii NNP 37231 3228 51 . . . 37231 3229 1 22 22 CD 37231 3229 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3229 3 gives give VBZ 37231 3229 4 the the DT 37231 3229 5 words word NNS 37231 3229 6 of of IN 37231 3229 7 the the DT 37231 3229 8 voice voice NN 37231 3229 9 in in IN 37231 3229 10 a a DT 37231 3229 11 form form NN 37231 3229 12 agreeing agree VBG 37231 3229 13 at at IN 37231 3229 14 least least JJS 37231 3229 15 in in IN 37231 3229 16 sense sense NN 37231 3229 17 with with IN 37231 3229 18 those those DT 37231 3229 19 which which WDT 37231 3229 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3229 21 found find VBD 37231 3229 22 in in IN 37231 3229 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3229 24 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3229 25 of of IN 37231 3229 26 the the DT 37231 3229 27 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3229 28 . . . 37231 3230 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3230 2 323 323 CD 37231 3230 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3230 4 These these DT 37231 3230 5 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3230 6 point point VBP 37231 3230 7 with with IN 37231 3230 8 certainty certainty NN 37231 3230 9 to to IN 37231 3230 10 an an DT 37231 3230 11 earlier early RBR 37231 3230 12 original original JJ 37231 3230 13 corresponding corresponding NN 37231 3230 14 with with IN 37231 3230 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3230 16 , , , 37231 3230 17 in in IN 37231 3230 18 all all DT 37231 3230 19 probability probability NN 37231 3230 20 the the DT 37231 3230 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3230 22 according accord VBG 37231 3230 23 to to IN 37231 3230 24 the the DT 37231 3230 25 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3230 26 , , , 37231 3230 27 and and CC 37231 3230 28 to to IN 37231 3230 29 the the DT 37231 3230 30 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 3230 31 gradual gradual JJ 37231 3230 32 elimination elimination NN 37231 3230 33 of of IN 37231 3230 34 the the DT 37231 3230 35 passage passage NN 37231 3230 36 from from IN 37231 3230 37 the the DT 37231 3230 38 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3230 39 finally finally RB 37231 3230 40 adopted adopt VBN 37231 3230 41 by by IN 37231 3230 42 the the DT 37231 3230 43 Church Church NNP 37231 3230 44 for for IN 37231 3230 45 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 3230 46 reasons reason NNS 37231 3230 47 , , , 37231 3230 48 as as IN 37231 3230 49 various various JJ 37231 3230 50 sects sect NNS 37231 3230 51 based base VBN 37231 3230 52 on on IN 37231 3230 53 the the DT 37231 3230 54 words word NNS 37231 3230 55 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3230 56 which which WDT 37231 3230 57 were be VBD 37231 3230 58 at at IN 37231 3230 59 variance variance NN 37231 3230 60 with with IN 37231 3230 61 the the DT 37231 3230 62 ever ever RB 37231 3230 63 - - HYPH 37231 3230 64 enlarging enlarge VBG 37231 3230 65 belief belief NN 37231 3230 66 of of IN 37231 3230 67 the the DT 37231 3230 68 majority majority NN 37231 3230 69 . . . 37231 3231 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3231 2 1 1 LS 37231 3231 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3231 4 Then then RB 37231 3231 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3231 6 states state VBZ 37231 3231 7 that that IN 37231 3231 8 the the DT 37231 3231 9 men man NNS 37231 3231 10 of of IN 37231 3231 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3231 12 time time NN 37231 3231 13 asserted assert VBD 37231 3231 14 that that IN 37231 3231 15 the the DT 37231 3231 16 miracles miracle NNS 37231 3231 17 of of IN 37231 3231 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3231 19 were be VBD 37231 3231 20 performed perform VBN 37231 3231 21 by by IN 37231 3231 22 magical magical JJ 37231 3231 23 art art NN 37231 3231 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3231 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3231 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3231 27 , , , 37231 3231 28 " " `` 37231 3231 29 for for IN 37231 3231 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3231 31 ventured venture VBD 37231 3231 32 to to TO 37231 3231 33 call call VB 37231 3231 34 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3231 35 a a DT 37231 3231 36 magician magician NN 37231 3231 37 and and CC 37231 3231 38 deceiver deceiver NN 37231 3231 39 of of IN 37231 3231 40 the the DT 37231 3231 41 people people NNS 37231 3231 42 . . . 37231 3232 1 " " `` 37231 3232 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3232 3 2 2 LS 37231 3232 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3232 5 This this DT 37231 3232 6 can can MD 37231 3232 7 not not RB 37231 3232 8 be be VB 37231 3232 9 accepted accept VBN 37231 3232 10 as as IN 37231 3232 11 a a DT 37231 3232 12 mere mere JJ 37231 3232 13 version version NN 37231 3232 14 of of IN 37231 3232 15 the the DT 37231 3232 16 charge charge NN 37231 3232 17 that that IN 37231 3232 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3232 19 cast cast VBD 37231 3232 20 out out RP 37231 3232 21 demons demon NNS 37231 3232 22 by by IN 37231 3232 23 Beelzebub Beelzebub NNP 37231 3232 24 , , , 37231 3232 25 but but CC 37231 3232 26 must must MD 37231 3232 27 have have VB 37231 3232 28 been be VBN 37231 3232 29 found find VBN 37231 3232 30 by by IN 37231 3232 31 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3232 32 in in IN 37231 3232 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3232 34 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3232 35 . . . 37231 3233 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3233 2 3 3 LS 37231 3233 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3233 4 In in IN 37231 3233 5 the the DT 37231 3233 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3233 7 of of IN 37231 3233 8 Nicodemus Nicodemus NNP 37231 3233 9 or or CC 37231 3233 10 Acta Acta NNP 37231 3233 11 Pilati Pilati NNP 37231 3233 12 , , , 37231 3233 13 the the DT 37231 3233 14 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3233 15 accuse accuse VBP 37231 3233 16 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3233 17 before before IN 37231 3233 18 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3233 19 of of IN 37231 3233 20 being be VBG 37231 3233 21 a a DT 37231 3233 22 magician,(4 magician,(4 NNP 37231 3233 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3233 24 coupled couple VBN 37231 3233 25 with with IN 37231 3233 26 the the DT 37231 3233 27 assertion assertion NN 37231 3233 28 that that IN 37231 3233 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3233 30 casts cast VBZ 37231 3233 31 out out RP 37231 3233 32 demons demon NNS 37231 3233 33 through through IN 37231 3233 34 Beelzebub Beelzebub NNP 37231 3233 35 the the DT 37231 3233 36 prince prince NN 37231 3233 37 of of IN 37231 3233 38 the the DT 37231 3233 39 demons demon NNS 37231 3233 40 ; ; : 37231 3233 41 and and CC 37231 3233 42 again again RB 37231 3233 43 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3233 44 simply simply RB 37231 3233 45 say say VBP 37231 3233 46 : : : 37231 3233 47 " " `` 37231 3233 48 Did do VBD 37231 3233 49 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3233 50 not not RB 37231 3233 51 tell tell VB 37231 3233 52 thee thee PRP 37231 3233 53 that that IN 37231 3233 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3233 55 is be VBZ 37231 3233 56 a a DT 37231 3233 57 magician magician NN 37231 3233 58 ? ? . 37231 3234 1 " " `` 37231 3234 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3234 3 5 5 LS 37231 3234 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3234 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3234 6 shall shall MD 37231 3234 7 presently presently RB 37231 3234 8 see see VB 37231 3234 9 that that IN 37231 3234 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3234 11 actually actually RB 37231 3234 12 refers refer VBZ 37231 3234 13 to to IN 37231 3234 14 certain certain JJ 37231 3234 15 acts act NNS 37231 3234 16 of of IN 37231 3234 17 Pontius Pontius NNP 37231 3234 18 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3234 19 in in IN 37231 3234 20 justification justification NN 37231 3234 21 of of IN 37231 3234 22 other other JJ 37231 3234 23 assertions assertion NNS 37231 3234 24 regarding regard VBG 37231 3234 25 the the DT 37231 3234 26 trial trial NN 37231 3234 27 of of IN 37231 3234 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3234 29 . . . 37231 3235 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3235 2 6 6 CD 37231 3235 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3235 4 In in IN 37231 3235 5 the the DT 37231 3235 6 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 3235 7 Recognitions Recognitions NNP 37231 3235 8 , , , 37231 3235 9 moreover moreover RB 37231 3235 10 , , , 37231 3235 11 the the DT 37231 3235 12 same same JJ 37231 3235 13 charge charge NN 37231 3235 14 is be VBZ 37231 3235 15 made make VBN 37231 3235 16 by by IN 37231 3235 17 one one CD 37231 3235 18 of of IN 37231 3235 19 the the DT 37231 3235 20 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3235 21 , , , 37231 3235 22 who who WP 37231 3235 23 says say VBZ 37231 3235 24 that that IN 37231 3235 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3235 26 did do VBD 37231 3235 27 not not RB 37231 3235 28 perform perform VB 37231 3235 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3235 30 miracles miracle NNS 37231 3235 31 as as IN 37231 3235 32 a a DT 37231 3235 33 prophet prophet NN 37231 3235 34 , , , 37231 3235 35 but but CC 37231 3235 36 as as IN 37231 3235 37 a a DT 37231 3235 38 magician magician NN 37231 3235 39 . . . 37231 3236 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3236 2 7 7 LS 37231 3236 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3236 4 { { -LRB- 37231 3236 5 324 324 CD 37231 3236 6 } } -RRB- 37231 3236 7 Oelsus Oelsus NNP 37231 3236 8 makes make VBZ 37231 3236 9 a a DT 37231 3236 10 similar similar JJ 37231 3236 11 charge,(1 charge,(1 NN 37231 3236 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3236 13 and and CC 37231 3236 14 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 37231 3236 15 refers refer VBZ 37231 3236 16 to to IN 37231 3236 17 such such PDT 37231 3236 18 an an DT 37231 3236 19 opinion opinion NN 37231 3236 20 as as IN 37231 3236 21 prevalent prevalent JJ 37231 3236 22 among among IN 37231 3236 23 the the DT 37231 3236 24 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3236 25 at at IN 37231 3236 26 the the DT 37231 3236 27 time time NN 37231 3236 28 of of IN 37231 3236 29 Jesus,(2 Jesus,(2 NNP 37231 3236 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3236 31 which which WDT 37231 3236 32 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3236 33 find find VBP 37231 3236 34 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 3236 35 by by IN 37231 3236 36 many many JJ 37231 3236 37 passages passage NNS 37231 3236 38 in in IN 37231 3236 39 Talmudic talmudic JJ 37231 3236 40 literature literature NN 37231 3236 41 . . . 37231 3237 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3237 2 3 3 LS 37231 3237 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3237 4 There there EX 37231 3237 5 was be VBD 37231 3237 6 indeed indeed RB 37231 3237 7 a a DT 37231 3237 8 book book NN 37231 3237 9 called call VBN 37231 3237 10 " " `` 37231 3237 11 Magia Magia NNP 37231 3237 12 Jesu Jesu NNP 37231 3237 13 Christi Christi NNP 37231 3237 14 , , , 37231 3237 15 " " '' 37231 3237 16 of of IN 37231 3237 17 which which WDT 37231 3237 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3237 19 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3237 20 , , , 37231 3237 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3237 22 was be VBD 37231 3237 23 pretended pretend VBN 37231 3237 24 , , , 37231 3237 25 was be VBD 37231 3237 26 the the DT 37231 3237 27 author author NN 37231 3237 28 . . . 37231 3238 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3238 2 4 4 LS 37231 3238 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3238 4 In in IN 37231 3238 5 speaking speak VBG 37231 3238 6 of of IN 37231 3238 7 the the DT 37231 3238 8 trial trial NN 37231 3238 9 of of IN 37231 3238 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3238 11 , , , 37231 3238 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3238 13 says say VBZ 37231 3238 14 : : : 37231 3238 15 " " `` 37231 3238 16 For for IN 37231 3238 17 also also RB 37231 3238 18 as as IN 37231 3238 19 the the DT 37231 3238 20 prophet prophet NN 37231 3238 21 saith saith NNP 37231 3238 22 , , , 37231 3238 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3238 24 reviled revile VBD 37231 3238 25 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3238 26 and and CC 37231 3238 27 set set VBD 37231 3238 28 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3238 29 on on IN 37231 3238 30 the the DT 37231 3238 31 judgment judgment NN 37231 3238 32 seat seat NN 37231 3238 33 and and CC 37231 3238 34 said say VBD 37231 3238 35 : : : 37231 3238 36 Judge judge VB 37231 3238 37 for for IN 37231 3238 38 us,"(5 us,"(5 NN 37231 3238 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3238 40 a a DT 37231 3238 41 peculiarity peculiarity NN 37231 3238 42 which which WDT 37231 3238 43 is be VBZ 37231 3238 44 not not RB 37231 3238 45 found find VBN 37231 3238 46 in in IN 37231 3238 47 the the DT 37231 3238 48 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3238 49 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3238 50 . . . 37231 3239 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3239 2 had have VBD 37231 3239 3 just just RB 37231 3239 4 quoted quote VBN 37231 3239 5 the the DT 37231 3239 6 words word NNS 37231 3239 7 of of IN 37231 3239 8 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 37231 3239 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3239 10 lxv lxv NNP 37231 3239 11 . . . 37231 3240 1 2 2 LS 37231 3240 2 , , , 37231 3240 3 lviii lviii NNP 37231 3240 4 . . . 37231 3241 1 2 2 LS 37231 3241 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3241 3 ... ... : 37231 3241 4 " " `` 37231 3241 5 They -PRON- PRP 37231 3241 6 now now RB 37231 3241 7 ask ask VBP 37231 3241 8 of of IN 37231 3241 9 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3241 10 judgment judgment NN 37231 3241 11 and and CC 37231 3241 12 dare dare VBP 37231 3241 13 to to TO 37231 3241 14 draw draw VB 37231 3241 15 nigh nigh NN 37231 3241 16 to to IN 37231 3241 17 God God NNP 37231 3241 18 , , , 37231 3241 19 " " '' 37231 3241 20 and and CC 37231 3241 21 then then RB 37231 3241 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3241 23 cites cite VBZ 37231 3241 24 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 3241 25 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3241 26 . . . 37231 3242 1 16 16 CD 37231 3242 2 , , , 37231 3242 3 22 22 CD 37231 3242 4 : : : 37231 3242 5 " " `` 37231 3242 6 They -PRON- PRP 37231 3242 7 pierced pierce VBD 37231 3242 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3242 9 hands hand NNS 37231 3242 10 and and CC 37231 3242 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3242 12 feet foot NNS 37231 3242 13 , , , 37231 3242 14 and and CC 37231 3242 15 upon upon IN 37231 3242 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3242 17 vesture vesture NN 37231 3242 18 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3242 19 cast cast VBD 37231 3242 20 lots lot NNS 37231 3242 21 . . . 37231 3242 22 " " '' 37231 3243 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3243 2 says say VBZ 37231 3243 3 that that IN 37231 3243 4 this this DT 37231 3243 5 did do VBD 37231 3243 6 not not RB 37231 3243 7 happen happen VB 37231 3243 8 to to IN 37231 3243 9 David David NNP 37231 3243 10 , , , 37231 3243 11 but but CC 37231 3243 12 was be VBD 37231 3243 13 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 3243 14 in in IN 37231 3243 15 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3243 16 , , , 37231 3243 17 and and CC 37231 3243 18 the the DT 37231 3243 19 expression expression NN 37231 3243 20 regarding regard VBG 37231 3243 21 the the DT 37231 3243 22 piercing pierce VBG 37231 3243 23 the the DT 37231 3243 24 hands hand NNS 37231 3243 25 and and CC 37231 3243 26 feet foot NNS 37231 3243 27 referred refer VBN 37231 3243 28 to to IN 37231 3243 29 the the DT 37231 3243 30 nails nail NNS 37231 3243 31 of of IN 37231 3243 32 the the DT 37231 3243 33 cross cross NN 37231 3243 34 which which WDT 37231 3243 35 were be VBD 37231 3243 36 driven drive VBN 37231 3243 37 through through IN 37231 3243 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3243 39 hands hand NNS 37231 3243 40 and and CC 37231 3243 41 feet foot NNS 37231 3243 42 . . . 37231 3244 1 And and CC 37231 3244 2 after after IN 37231 3244 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3244 4 was be VBD 37231 3244 5 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3244 6 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3244 7 cast cast VBD 37231 3244 8 lots lot NNS 37231 3244 9 upon upon IN 37231 3244 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3244 11 vesture vesture NN 37231 3244 12 . . . 37231 3245 1 " " `` 37231 3245 2 And and CC 37231 3245 3 that that IN 37231 3245 4 these these DT 37231 3245 5 things thing NNS 37231 3245 6 occurred occur VBD 37231 3245 7 , , , 37231 3245 8 " " '' 37231 3245 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3245 10 continues continue VBZ 37231 3245 11 , , , 37231 3245 12 " " `` 37231 3245 13 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3245 14 may may MD 37231 3245 15 learn learn VB 37231 3245 16 from from IN 37231 3245 17 the the DT 37231 3245 18 Acts Acts NNPS 37231 3245 19 drawn draw VBN 37231 3245 20 up up RP 37231 3245 21 under under IN 37231 3245 22 Pontius Pontius NNP 37231 3245 23 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3245 24 . . . 37231 3246 1 " " `` 37231 3246 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3246 3 6 6 CD 37231 3246 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3246 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3246 6 likewise likewise RB 37231 3246 7 upon upon IN 37231 3246 8 another another DT 37231 3246 9 occasion occasion NN 37231 3246 10 refers refer VBZ 37231 3246 11 to to IN 37231 3246 12 the the DT 37231 3246 13 same same JJ 37231 3246 14 Acta Acta NNP 37231 3246 15 for for IN 37231 3246 16 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 3246 17 of of IN 37231 3246 18 statements statement NNS 37231 3246 19 . . . 37231 3247 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3247 2 7 7 LS 37231 3247 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3247 4 The the DT 37231 3247 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3247 6 of of IN 37231 3247 7 Nicodemus Nicodemus NNP 37231 3247 8 or or CC 37231 3247 9 Gesta Gesta NNP 37231 3247 10 { { -LRB- 37231 3247 11 325 325 CD 37231 3247 12 } } -RRB- 37231 3247 13 Pilati pilati RB 37231 3247 14 , , , 37231 3247 15 now now RB 37231 3247 16 extant extant JJ 37231 3247 17 , , , 37231 3247 18 does do VBZ 37231 3247 19 not not RB 37231 3247 20 contain contain VB 37231 3247 21 the the DT 37231 3247 22 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 3247 23 to to TO 37231 3247 24 which which WDT 37231 3247 25 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3247 26 are be VBP 37231 3247 27 now now RB 37231 3247 28 referring refer VBG 37231 3247 29 , , , 37231 3247 30 but but CC 37231 3247 31 in in IN 37231 3247 32 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 3247 33 to to IN 37231 3247 34 the the DT 37231 3247 35 statement statement NN 37231 3247 36 in in IN 37231 3247 37 the the DT 37231 3247 38 fourth fourth JJ 37231 3247 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3247 40 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3247 41 xviii xviii NN 37231 3247 42 . . . 37231 3248 1 28 28 CD 37231 3248 2 , , , 37231 3248 3 29 29 CD 37231 3248 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3248 5 the the DT 37231 3248 6 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3248 7 in in IN 37231 3248 8 this this DT 37231 3248 9 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3248 10 work work NN 37231 3248 11 freely freely RB 37231 3248 12 go go VB 37231 3248 13 into into IN 37231 3248 14 the the DT 37231 3248 15 very very JJ 37231 3248 16 judgment judgment NN 37231 3248 17 seat seat NN 37231 3248 18 of of IN 37231 3248 19 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3248 20 . . . 37231 3249 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3249 2 1 1 LS 37231 3249 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3249 4 Teschendorf teschendorf NN 37231 3249 5 maintains maintain VBZ 37231 3249 6 that that IN 37231 3249 7 the the DT 37231 3249 8 first first JJ 37231 3249 9 part part NN 37231 3249 10 of of IN 37231 3249 11 the the DT 37231 3249 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3249 13 of of IN 37231 3249 14 Nicodemus Nicodemus NNP 37231 3249 15 , , , 37231 3249 16 or or CC 37231 3249 17 Acta Acta NNP 37231 3249 18 Pilati Pilati NNP 37231 3249 19 , , , 37231 3249 20 still still RB 37231 3249 21 extant extant JJ 37231 3249 22 , , , 37231 3249 23 is be VBZ 37231 3249 24 the the DT 37231 3249 25 work work NN 37231 3249 26 , , , 37231 3249 27 with with IN 37231 3249 28 more more RBR 37231 3249 29 or or CC 37231 3249 30 less less JJR 37231 3249 31 of of IN 37231 3249 32 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 3249 33 , , , 37231 3249 34 which which WDT 37231 3249 35 , , , 37231 3249 36 existing exist VBG 37231 3249 37 in in IN 37231 3249 38 the the DT 37231 3249 39 second second JJ 37231 3249 40 century century NN 37231 3249 41 , , , 37231 3249 42 is be VBZ 37231 3249 43 referred refer VBN 37231 3249 44 to to IN 37231 3249 45 by by IN 37231 3249 46 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3249 47 . . . 37231 3250 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3250 2 2 2 LS 37231 3250 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3250 4 A a DT 37231 3250 5 few few JJ 37231 3250 6 reasons reason NNS 37231 3250 7 may may MD 37231 3250 8 here here RB 37231 3250 9 be be VB 37231 3250 10 given give VBN 37231 3250 11 against against IN 37231 3250 12 such such PDT 37231 3250 13 a a DT 37231 3250 14 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3250 15 . . . 37231 3251 1 The the DT 37231 3251 2 fact fact NN 37231 3251 3 of of IN 37231 3251 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3251 5 being be VBG 37231 3251 6 set set VBN 37231 3251 7 upon upon IN 37231 3251 8 the the DT 37231 3251 9 judgment judgment NN 37231 3251 10 seat seat NN 37231 3251 11 is be VBZ 37231 3251 12 not not RB 37231 3251 13 contained contain VBN 37231 3251 14 in in IN 37231 3251 15 the the DT 37231 3251 16 extant extant JJ 37231 3251 17 Acta Acta NNP 37231 3251 18 Pilati Pilati NNP 37231 3251 19 at at RB 37231 3251 20 all all RB 37231 3251 21 , , , 37231 3251 22 and and CC 37231 3251 23 therefore therefore RB 37231 3251 24 this this DT 37231 3251 25 work work NN 37231 3251 26 does do VBZ 37231 3251 27 not not RB 37231 3251 28 correspond correspond VB 37231 3251 29 with with IN 37231 3251 30 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3251 31 's 's POS 37231 3251 32 statement statement NN 37231 3251 33 . . . 37231 3252 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3252 2 seems seem VBZ 37231 3252 3 most most RBS 37231 3252 4 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 3252 5 to to TO 37231 3252 6 suppose suppose VB 37231 3252 7 that that IN 37231 3252 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3252 9 should should MD 37231 3252 10 seriously seriously RB 37231 3252 11 refer refer VB 37231 3252 12 Roman Roman NNP 37231 3252 13 Emperors Emperors NNPS 37231 3252 14 to to IN 37231 3252 15 a a DT 37231 3252 16 work work NN 37231 3252 17 of of IN 37231 3252 18 this this DT 37231 3252 19 description description NN 37231 3252 20 , , , 37231 3252 21 so so RB 37231 3252 22 manifestly manifestly RB 37231 3252 23 composed compose VBN 37231 3252 24 by by IN 37231 3252 25 a a DT 37231 3252 26 Christian Christian NNP 37231 3252 27 , , , 37231 3252 28 and and CC 37231 3252 29 the the DT 37231 3252 30 Acta Acta NNP 37231 3252 31 to to TO 37231 3252 32 which which WDT 37231 3252 33 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3252 34 directs direct VBZ 37231 3252 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3252 36 must must MD 37231 3252 37 have have VB 37231 3252 38 been be VBN 37231 3252 39 a a DT 37231 3252 40 presumed presume VBN 37231 3252 41 official official JJ 37231 3252 42 document document NN 37231 3252 43 , , , 37231 3252 44 to to TO 37231 3252 45 which which WDT 37231 3252 46 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3252 47 had have VBD 37231 3252 48 access access NN 37231 3252 49 , , , 37231 3252 50 as as IN 37231 3252 51 of of IN 37231 3252 52 course course NN 37231 3252 53 no no DT 37231 3252 54 other other JJ 37231 3252 55 evidence evidence NN 37231 3252 56 could could MD 37231 3252 57 be be VB 37231 3252 58 of of IN 37231 3252 59 any any DT 37231 3252 60 weight weight NN 37231 3252 61 with with IN 37231 3252 62 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3252 63 . . . 37231 3253 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3253 2 3 3 LS 37231 3253 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3253 4 The the DT 37231 3253 5 extant extant JJ 37231 3253 6 work work NN 37231 3253 7 neither neither CC 37231 3253 8 pretends pretend NNS 37231 3253 9 to to TO 37231 3253 10 be be VB 37231 3253 11 , , , 37231 3253 12 nor nor CC 37231 3253 13 has have VBZ 37231 3253 14 in in IN 37231 3253 15 the the DT 37231 3253 16 slightest slight JJS 37231 3253 17 degree degree NN 37231 3253 18 the the DT 37231 3253 19 form form NN 37231 3253 20 of of IN 37231 3253 21 , , , 37231 3253 22 an an DT 37231 3253 23 official official JJ 37231 3253 24 report report NN 37231 3253 25 . . . 37231 3254 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3254 2 , , , 37231 3254 3 the the DT 37231 3254 4 prologue prologue NN 37231 3254 5 attached attach VBD 37231 3254 6 to to IN 37231 3254 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3254 8 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3254 9 states state VBZ 37231 3254 10 that that IN 37231 3254 11 Ananias Ananias NNP 37231 3254 12 , , , 37231 3254 13 a a DT 37231 3254 14 provincial provincial JJ 37231 3254 15 warden warden NN 37231 3254 16 in in IN 37231 3254 17 the the DT 37231 3254 18 reign reign NN 37231 3254 19 of of IN 37231 3254 20 Flavius Flavius NNP 37231 3254 21 Theodosius Theodosius NNP 37231 3254 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3254 23 towards towards IN 37231 3254 24 the the DT 37231 3254 25 middle middle NN 37231 3254 26 of of IN 37231 3254 27 the the DT 37231 3254 28 fifth fifth JJ 37231 3254 29 century century NN 37231 3254 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3254 31 , , , 37231 3254 32 found find VBD 37231 3254 33 these these DT 37231 3254 34 Acts act NNS 37231 3254 35 written write VBN 37231 3254 36 in in IN 37231 3254 37 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 3254 38 by by IN 37231 3254 39 Nicodemus Nicodemus NNP 37231 3254 40 , , , 37231 3254 41 and and CC 37231 3254 42 that that IN 37231 3254 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3254 44 translated translate VBD 37231 3254 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3254 46 into into IN 37231 3254 47 Greek Greek NNP 37231 3254 48 . . . 37231 3255 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3255 2 4 4 LS 37231 3255 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3255 4 The the DT 37231 3255 5 work work NN 37231 3255 6 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3255 7 , , , 37231 3255 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 3255 9 , , , 37231 3255 10 only only RB 37231 3255 11 pretends pretend NNS 37231 3255 12 to to TO 37231 3255 13 be be VB 37231 3255 14 a a DT 37231 3255 15 private private JJ 37231 3255 16 composition composition NN 37231 3255 17 in in IN 37231 3255 18 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 3255 19 , , , 37231 3255 20 and and CC 37231 3255 21 does do VBZ 37231 3255 22 not not RB 37231 3255 23 claim claim VB 37231 3255 24 any any DT 37231 3255 25 relation relation NN 37231 3255 26 to to IN 37231 3255 27 Pontius Pontius NNP 37231 3255 28 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3255 29 . . . 37231 3256 1 The the DT 37231 3256 2 Greek Greek NNP 37231 3256 3 is be VBZ 37231 3256 4 very very RB 37231 3256 5 corrupt corrupt JJ 37231 3256 6 and and CC 37231 3256 7 { { -LRB- 37231 3256 8 326 326 CD 37231 3256 9 } } -RRB- 37231 3256 10 degraded degraded JJ 37231 3256 11 , , , 37231 3256 12 and and CC 37231 3256 13 considerations consideration NNS 37231 3256 14 of of IN 37231 3256 15 style style NN 37231 3256 16 alone alone RB 37231 3256 17 would would MD 37231 3256 18 assign assign VB 37231 3256 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3256 20 to to IN 37231 3256 21 the the DT 37231 3256 22 fifth fifth JJ 37231 3256 23 century century NN 37231 3256 24 , , , 37231 3256 25 as as IN 37231 3256 26 would would MD 37231 3256 27 still still RB 37231 3256 28 more more RBR 37231 3256 29 imperatively imperatively RB 37231 3256 30 the the DT 37231 3256 31 anachronisms anachronism NNS 37231 3256 32 with with IN 37231 3256 33 which which WDT 37231 3256 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3256 35 abounds.1 abounds.1 CC 37231 3256 36 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3256 37 considers consider VBZ 37231 3256 38 that that IN 37231 3256 39 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 3256 40 refers refer VBZ 37231 3256 41 to to IN 37231 3256 42 the the DT 37231 3256 43 same same JJ 37231 3256 44 work work NN 37231 3256 45 as as IN 37231 3256 46 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3256 47 , , , 37231 3256 48 but but CC 37231 3256 49 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3256 50 is be VBZ 37231 3256 51 evident evident JJ 37231 3256 52 that that IN 37231 3256 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3256 54 infers infer VBZ 37231 3256 55 an an DT 37231 3256 56 official official JJ 37231 3256 57 report report NN 37231 3256 58 , , , 37231 3256 59 for for IN 37231 3256 60 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3256 61 says say VBZ 37231 3256 62 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3256 63 , , , 37231 3256 64 after after IN 37231 3256 65 narrating narrate VBG 37231 3256 66 the the DT 37231 3256 67 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3256 68 of of IN 37231 3256 69 the the DT 37231 3256 70 crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 3256 71 and and CC 37231 3256 72 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 3256 73 : : : 37231 3256 74 " " `` 37231 3256 75 All all PDT 37231 3256 76 these these DT 37231 3256 77 facts fact NNS 37231 3256 78 regarding regard VBG 37231 3256 79 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3256 80 , , , 37231 3256 81 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3256 82 .... .... NFP 37231 3256 83 reported report VBD 37231 3256 84 to to IN 37231 3256 85 the the DT 37231 3256 86 reigning reign VBG 37231 3256 87 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 3256 88 Tiberius Tiberius NNP 37231 3256 89 . . . 37231 3257 1 " " `` 37231 3257 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3257 3 3 3 LS 37231 3257 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3257 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3257 6 is be VBZ 37231 3257 7 extremely extremely RB 37231 3257 8 probable probable JJ 37231 3257 9 that that IN 37231 3257 10 in in IN 37231 3257 11 saying say VBG 37231 3257 12 this this DT 37231 3257 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 3257 14 merely merely RB 37231 3257 15 extended extend VBD 37231 3257 16 the the DT 37231 3257 17 statement statement NN 37231 3257 18 of of IN 37231 3257 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3257 20 . . . 37231 3258 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3258 2 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 3258 3 states state VBZ 37231 3258 4 that that IN 37231 3258 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3258 6 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3258 7 had have VBD 37231 3258 8 seen see VBN 37231 3258 9 this this DT 37231 3258 10 report report NN 37231 3258 11 , , , 37231 3258 12 nor nor CC 37231 3258 13 does do VBZ 37231 3258 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3258 15 , , , 37231 3258 16 and and CC 37231 3258 17 as as IN 37231 3258 18 is be VBZ 37231 3258 19 the the DT 37231 3258 20 case case NN 37231 3258 21 with with IN 37231 3258 22 the the DT 37231 3258 23 latter latter JJ 37231 3258 24 , , , 37231 3258 25 some some DT 37231 3258 26 of of IN 37231 3258 27 the the DT 37231 3258 28 facts fact NNS 37231 3258 29 which which WDT 37231 3258 30 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 3258 31 supposes suppose VBZ 37231 3258 32 to to TO 37231 3258 33 be be VB 37231 3258 34 reported report VBN 37231 3258 35 by by IN 37231 3258 36 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3258 37 are be VBP 37231 3258 38 not not RB 37231 3258 39 contained contain VBN 37231 3258 40 in in IN 37231 3258 41 the the DT 37231 3258 42 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3258 43 work work NN 37231 3258 44 . . . 37231 3259 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3259 2 3 3 LS 37231 3259 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3259 4 There there EX 37231 3259 5 are be VBP 37231 3259 6 still still RB 37231 3259 7 extant extant JJ 37231 3259 8 some some DT 37231 3259 9 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3259 10 writings writing NNS 37231 3259 11 in in IN 37231 3259 12 the the DT 37231 3259 13 form form NN 37231 3259 14 of of IN 37231 3259 15 official official JJ 37231 3259 16 reports report NNS 37231 3259 17 made make VBN 37231 3259 18 by by IN 37231 3259 19 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3259 20 of of IN 37231 3259 21 the the DT 37231 3259 22 trial trial NN 37231 3259 23 , , , 37231 3259 24 crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 3259 25 , , , 37231 3259 26 and and CC 37231 3259 27 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 3259 28 of of IN 37231 3259 29 Jesus,(4 Jesus,(4 NNP 37231 3259 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3259 31 but but CC 37231 3259 32 none none NN 37231 3259 33 are be VBP 37231 3259 34 of of IN 37231 3259 35 very very RB 37231 3259 36 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3259 37 date date NN 37231 3259 38 . . . 37231 3260 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3260 2 is be VBZ 37231 3260 3 certain certain JJ 37231 3260 4 that that IN 37231 3260 5 , , , 37231 3260 6 on on IN 37231 3260 7 the the DT 37231 3260 8 supposition supposition NN 37231 3260 9 that that IN 37231 3260 10 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3260 11 may may MD 37231 3260 12 have have VB 37231 3260 13 made make VBN 37231 3260 14 an an DT 37231 3260 15 official official JJ 37231 3260 16 report report NN 37231 3260 17 of of IN 37231 3260 18 events event NNS 37231 3260 19 so so RB 37231 3260 20 important important JJ 37231 3260 21 in in IN 37231 3260 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3260 23 estimation estimation NN 37231 3260 24 , , , 37231 3260 25 Christian christian JJ 37231 3260 26 writers writer NNS 37231 3260 27 ; ; : 37231 3260 28 with with IN 37231 3260 29 greater great JJR 37231 3260 30 zeal zeal NN 37231 3260 31 than than IN 37231 3260 32 conscience conscience NN 37231 3260 33 , , , 37231 3260 34 composed compose VBN 37231 3260 35 fictitious fictitious JJ 37231 3260 36 reports report NNS 37231 3260 37 in in IN 37231 3260 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3260 39 name name NN 37231 3260 40 , , , 37231 3260 41 in in IN 37231 3260 42 the the DT 37231 3260 43 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3260 44 interest interest NN 37231 3260 45 of of IN 37231 3260 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3260 47 religion religion NN 37231 3260 48 , , , 37231 3260 49 and and CC 37231 3260 50 there there EX 37231 3260 51 was be VBD 37231 3260 52 in in IN 37231 3260 53 that that DT 37231 3260 54 day day NN 37231 3260 55 little little JJ 37231 3260 56 or or CC 37231 3260 57 no no DT 37231 3260 58 critical critical JJ 37231 3260 59 sense sense NN 37231 3260 60 to to TO 37231 3260 61 detect detect VB 37231 3260 62 and and CC 37231 3260 63 discredit discredit VB 37231 3260 64 such such JJ 37231 3260 65 forgeries forgery NNS 37231 3260 66 . . . 37231 3261 1 There there EX 37231 3261 2 is be VBZ 37231 3261 3 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 3261 4 no no DT 37231 3261 5 evidence evidence NN 37231 3261 6 to to TO 37231 3261 7 show show VB 37231 3261 8 that that IN 37231 3261 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3261 10 was be VBD 37231 3261 11 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 3261 12 with with IN 37231 3261 13 any any DT 37231 3261 14 official official JJ 37231 3261 15 report report NN 37231 3261 16 of of IN 37231 3261 17 Pilate Pilate NNP 37231 3261 18 to to IN 37231 3261 19 the the DT 37231 3261 20 Roman Roman NNP 37231 3261 21 Emperor Emperor NNP 37231 3261 22 , , , 37231 3261 23 nor nor CC 37231 3261 24 indeed indeed RB 37231 3261 25 is be VBZ 37231 3261 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3261 27 easy easy JJ 37231 3261 28 to to TO 37231 3261 29 understand understand VB 37231 3261 30 how how WRB 37231 3261 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3261 32 could could MD 37231 3261 33 possibly possibly RB 37231 3261 34 have have VB 37231 3261 35 been be VBN 37231 3261 36 , , , 37231 3261 37 even even RB 37231 3261 38 if if IN 37231 3261 39 such such PDT 37231 3261 40 a a DT 37231 3261 41 document document NN 37231 3261 42 existed exist VBN 37231 3261 43 , , , 37231 3261 44 and and CC 37231 3261 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3261 46 is be VBZ 37231 3261 47 most most RBS 37231 3261 48 probable probable JJ 37231 3261 49 , , , 37231 3261 50 as as IN 37231 3261 51 { { -LRB- 37231 3261 52 327 327 CD 37231 3261 53 } } -RRB- 37231 3261 54 Scholten Scholten NNP 37231 3261 55 conjectures conjecture NNS 37231 3261 56 , , , 37231 3261 57 that that IN 37231 3261 58 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3261 59 merely merely RB 37231 3261 60 referred refer VBD 37231 3261 61 to to IN 37231 3261 62 documents document NNS 37231 3261 63 which which WDT 37231 3261 64 tradition tradition NN 37231 3261 65 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3261 66 to to TO 37231 3261 67 have have VB 37231 3261 68 been be VBN 37231 3261 69 written write VBN 37231 3261 70 , , , 37231 3261 71 but but CC 37231 3261 72 of of IN 37231 3261 73 which which WDT 37231 3261 74 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3261 75 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3261 76 had have VBD 37231 3261 77 no no DT 37231 3261 78 personal personal JJ 37231 3261 79 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 3261 80 . . . 37231 3262 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3262 2 1 1 LS 37231 3262 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3262 4 Be be VB 37231 3262 5 this this DT 37231 3262 6 as as IN 37231 3262 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3262 8 may may MD 37231 3262 9 , , , 37231 3262 10 as as IN 37231 3262 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3262 12 considered consider VBD 37231 3262 13 the the DT 37231 3262 14 incident incident NN 37231 3262 15 of of IN 37231 3262 16 the the DT 37231 3262 17 judgment judgment NN 37231 3262 18 seat seat NN 37231 3262 19 a a DT 37231 3262 20 fulfilment fulfilment NN 37231 3262 21 of of IN 37231 3262 22 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 3262 23 , , , 37231 3262 24 there there EX 37231 3262 25 can can MD 37231 3262 26 be be VB 37231 3262 27 little little JJ 37231 3262 28 or or CC 37231 3262 29 no no RB 37231 3262 30 doubt doubt NN 37231 3262 31 that that IN 37231 3262 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3262 33 was be VBD 37231 3262 34 narrated narrate VBN 37231 3262 35 in in IN 37231 3262 36 the the DT 37231 3262 37 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3262 38 which which WDT 37231 3262 39 contained contain VBD 37231 3262 40 " " `` 37231 3262 41 everything everything NN 37231 3262 42 relating relate VBG 37231 3262 43 to to IN 37231 3262 44 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3262 45 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3262 46 , , , 37231 3262 47 " " '' 37231 3262 48 and and CC 37231 3262 49 finding find VBG 37231 3262 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3262 51 there there RB 37231 3262 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3262 53 all all PDT 37231 3262 54 the the DT 37231 3262 55 more more RBR 37231 3262 56 naturally naturally RB 37231 3262 57 assumed assume VBN 37231 3262 58 that that IN 37231 3262 59 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3262 60 must must MD 37231 3262 61 have have VB 37231 3262 62 been be VBN 37231 3262 63 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3262 64 in in IN 37231 3262 65 any any DT 37231 3262 66 official official JJ 37231 3262 67 report report NN 37231 3262 68 . . . 37231 3263 1 In in IN 37231 3263 2 narrating narrate VBG 37231 3263 3 the the DT 37231 3263 4 agony agony NN 37231 3263 5 in in IN 37231 3263 6 the the DT 37231 3263 7 Garden Garden NNP 37231 3263 8 , , , 37231 3263 9 there there EX 37231 3263 10 are be VBP 37231 3263 11 further further JJ 37231 3263 12 variations variation NNS 37231 3263 13 . . . 37231 3264 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3264 2 says say VBZ 37231 3264 3 : : : 37231 3264 4 " " `` 37231 3264 5 And and CC 37231 3264 6 the the DT 37231 3264 7 passage passage NN 37231 3264 8 : : : 37231 3264 9 ' ' '' 37231 3264 10 All all DT 37231 3264 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3264 12 bones bone NNS 37231 3264 13 are be VBP 37231 3264 14 poured pour VBN 37231 3264 15 out out RP 37231 3264 16 and and CC 37231 3264 17 dispersed disperse VBN 37231 3264 18 like like IN 37231 3264 19 water water NN 37231 3264 20 ; ; : 37231 3264 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3264 22 heart heart NN 37231 3264 23 has have VBZ 37231 3264 24 become become VBN 37231 3264 25 like like IN 37231 3264 26 wax wax NN 37231 3264 27 melting melt VBG 37231 3264 28 in in IN 37231 3264 29 the the DT 37231 3264 30 midst midst NN 37231 3264 31 of of IN 37231 3264 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3264 33 belly belly NN 37231 3264 34 , , , 37231 3264 35 ' ' '' 37231 3264 36 was be VBD 37231 3264 37 a a DT 37231 3264 38 prediction prediction NN 37231 3264 39 of of IN 37231 3264 40 that that DT 37231 3264 41 which which WDT 37231 3264 42 occurred occur VBD 37231 3264 43 to to IN 37231 3264 44 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3264 45 that that DT 37231 3264 46 night night NN 37231 3264 47 when when WRB 37231 3264 48 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3264 49 came come VBD 37231 3264 50 out out RP 37231 3264 51 against against IN 37231 3264 52 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3264 53 to to IN 37231 3264 54 the the DT 37231 3264 55 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3264 56 of of IN 37231 3264 57 Olives Olives NNPS 37231 3264 58 to to TO 37231 3264 59 seize seize VB 37231 3264 60 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3264 61 . . . 37231 3265 1 For for IN 37231 3265 2 in in IN 37231 3265 3 the the DT 37231 3265 4 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3265 5 composed compose VBN 37231 3265 6 , , , 37231 3265 7 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3265 8 say say VBP 37231 3265 9 , , , 37231 3265 10 by by IN 37231 3265 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3265 12 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3265 13 and and CC 37231 3265 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3265 15 followers follower NNS 37231 3265 16 , , , 37231 3265 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3265 18 is be VBZ 37231 3265 19 recorded record VBN 37231 3265 20 that that IN 37231 3265 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3265 22 sweat sweat NN 37231 3265 23 fell fall VBD 37231 3265 24 down down RP 37231 3265 25 like like IN 37231 3265 26 drops drop NNS 37231 3265 27 while while IN 37231 3265 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3265 29 prayed pray VBD 37231 3265 30 , , , 37231 3265 31 saying say VBG 37231 3265 32 : : : 37231 3265 33 ' ' `` 37231 3265 34 If if IN 37231 3265 35 possible possible JJ 37231 3265 36 , , , 37231 3265 37 let let VB 37231 3265 38 this this DT 37231 3265 39 cup cup NN 37231 3265 40 pass pass VB 37231 3265 41 . . . 37231 3266 1 ' ' `` 37231 3266 2 " " '' 37231 3266 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3266 4 2 2 LS 37231 3266 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3266 6 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3266 7 will will MD 37231 3266 8 be be VB 37231 3266 9 observed observe VBN 37231 3266 10 that that IN 37231 3266 11 this this DT 37231 3266 12 is be VBZ 37231 3266 13 a a DT 37231 3266 14 direct direct JJ 37231 3266 15 quotation quotation NN 37231 3266 16 from from IN 37231 3266 17 the the DT 37231 3266 18 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3266 19 , , , 37231 3266 20 but but CC 37231 3266 21 there there EX 37231 3266 22 is be VBZ 37231 3266 23 a a DT 37231 3266 24 material material JJ 37231 3266 25 difference difference NN 37231 3266 26 from from IN 37231 3266 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3266 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3266 29 . . . 37231 3267 1 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3267 2 is be VBZ 37231 3267 3 the the DT 37231 3267 4 only only JJ 37231 3267 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3267 6 which which WDT 37231 3267 7 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3267 8 the the DT 37231 3267 9 bloody bloody JJ 37231 3267 10 sweat sweat NN 37231 3267 11 , , , 37231 3267 12 and and CC 37231 3267 13 there there RB 37231 3267 14 the the DT 37231 3267 15 account account NN 37231 3267 16 reads read VBZ 37231 3267 17 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3267 18 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3267 19 . . . 37231 3268 1 44 44 CD 37231 3268 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3268 3 , , , 37231 3268 4 " " `` 37231 3268 5 as as IN 37231 3268 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3268 7 were be VBD 37231 3268 8 drops drop NNS 37231 3268 9 of of IN 37231 3268 10 blood blood NN 37231 3268 11 falling fall VBG 37231 3268 12 down down RP 37231 3268 13 to to IN 37231 3268 14 the the DT 37231 3268 15 ground ground NN 37231 3268 16 . . . 37231 3268 17 " " '' 37231 3269 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3269 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3269 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3269 4 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3269 5 --Greek-- --Greek-- -RRB- 37231 3269 6 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3269 7 In in IN 37231 3269 8 addition addition NN 37231 3269 9 to to IN 37231 3269 10 the the DT 37231 3269 11 other other JJ 37231 3269 12 linguistic linguistic JJ 37231 3269 13 differences difference NNS 37231 3269 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3269 15 omits omit VBZ 37231 3269 16 the the DT 37231 3269 17 emphatic emphatic JJ 37231 3269 18 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3269 19 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3269 20 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3269 21 which which WDT 37231 3269 22 gives give VBZ 37231 3269 23 the the DT 37231 3269 24 whole whole JJ 37231 3269 25 point point NN 37231 3269 26 to to IN 37231 3269 27 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3269 28 's 's POS 37231 3269 29 account account NN 37231 3269 30 , , , 37231 3269 31 and and CC 37231 3269 32 which which WDT 37231 3269 33 evidently evidently RB 37231 3269 34 could could MD 37231 3269 35 not not RB 37231 3269 36 have have VB 37231 3269 37 been be VBN 37231 3269 38 in in IN 37231 3269 39 the the DT 37231 3269 40 text text NN 37231 3269 41 of of IN 37231 3269 42 the the DT 37231 3269 43 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3269 44 . . . 37231 3270 1 Semisch Semisch NNP 37231 3270 2 argues argue VBZ 37231 3270 3 that that IN 37231 3270 4 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3270 5 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3270 6 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3270 7 alone alone RB 37231 3270 8 , , , 37231 3270 9 especially especially RB 37231 3270 10 in in IN 37231 3270 11 medical medical JJ 37231 3270 12 phraseology phraseology NN 37231 3270 13 , , , 37231 3270 14 meant mean VBD 37231 3270 15 { { -LRB- 37231 3270 16 328 328 CD 37231 3270 17 } } -RRB- 37231 3270 18 " " '' 37231 3270 19 drops drop NNS 37231 3270 20 of of IN 37231 3270 21 blood blood NN 37231 3270 22 , , , 37231 3270 23 " " '' 37231 3270 24 without without IN 37231 3270 25 the the DT 37231 3270 26 addition addition NN 37231 3270 27 of of IN 37231 3270 28 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3270 29 --Greek--];(l --Greek--];(l NNP 37231 3270 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3270 31 but but CC 37231 3270 32 the the DT 37231 3270 33 author author NN 37231 3270 34 of of IN 37231 3270 35 the the DT 37231 3270 36 third third JJ 37231 3270 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3270 38 did do VBD 37231 3270 39 not not RB 37231 3270 40 think think VB 37231 3270 41 so so RB 37231 3270 42 , , , 37231 3270 43 and and CC 37231 3270 44 undeniably undeniably RB 37231 3270 45 makes make VBZ 37231 3270 46 use use NN 37231 3270 47 of of IN 37231 3270 48 both both DT 37231 3270 49 , , , 37231 3270 50 and and CC 37231 3270 51 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3270 52 does do VBZ 37231 3270 53 not not RB 37231 3270 54 . . . 37231 3271 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3271 2 , , , 37231 3271 3 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3271 4 introduces introduce VBZ 37231 3271 5 the the DT 37231 3271 6 expression expression NN 37231 3271 7 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3271 8 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3271 9 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3271 10 to to TO 37231 3271 11 show show VB 37231 3271 12 the the DT 37231 3271 13 intensity intensity NN 37231 3271 14 of of IN 37231 3271 15 the the DT 37231 3271 16 agony agony NN 37231 3271 17 , , , 37231 3271 18 whereas whereas IN 37231 3271 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3271 20 evidently evidently RB 37231 3271 21 did do VBD 37231 3271 22 not not RB 37231 3271 23 mean mean VB 37231 3271 24 to to TO 37231 3271 25 express express VB 37231 3271 26 " " `` 37231 3271 27 drops drop NNS 37231 3271 28 of of IN 37231 3271 29 blood blood NN 37231 3271 30 " " '' 37231 3271 31 at at RB 37231 3271 32 all all RB 37231 3271 33 , , , 37231 3271 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3271 35 intention intention NN 37231 3271 36 in in IN 37231 3271 37 referring refer VBG 37231 3271 38 to to IN 37231 3271 39 the the DT 37231 3271 40 sweat sweat NN 37231 3271 41 being be VBG 37231 3271 42 to to TO 37231 3271 43 show show VB 37231 3271 44 that that IN 37231 3271 45 the the DT 37231 3271 46 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 3271 47 : : : 37231 3271 48 " " `` 37231 3271 49 All all DT 37231 3271 50 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3271 51 bones bone NNS 37231 3271 52 are be VBP 37231 3271 53 poured pour VBN 37231 3271 54 out out RP 37231 3271 55 , , , 37231 3271 56 & & CC 37231 3271 57 c c NNP 37231 3271 58 , , , 37231 3271 59 like like IN 37231 3271 60 water water NN 37231 3271 61 , , , 37231 3271 62 " " '' 37231 3271 63 had have VBD 37231 3271 64 been be VBN 37231 3271 65 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 3271 66 , , , 37231 3271 67 with with IN 37231 3271 68 which which WDT 37231 3271 69 the the DT 37231 3271 70 reading reading NN 37231 3271 71 in in IN 37231 3271 72 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3271 73 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3271 74 more more RBR 37231 3271 75 closely closely RB 37231 3271 76 corresponded correspond VBN 37231 3271 77 . . . 37231 3272 1 The the DT 37231 3272 2 prayer prayer NN 37231 3272 3 also also RB 37231 3272 4 so so RB 37231 3272 5 directly directly RB 37231 3272 6 quoted quote VBN 37231 3272 7 decidedly decidedly RB 37231 3272 8 varies vary VBZ 37231 3272 9 from from IN 37231 3272 10 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3272 11 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3272 12 . . . 37231 3273 1 42 42 CD 37231 3273 2 , , , 37231 3273 3 which which WDT 37231 3273 4 reads read VBZ 37231 3273 5 : : : 37231 3273 6 " " `` 37231 3273 7 Father Father NNP 37231 3273 8 , , , 37231 3273 9 if if IN 37231 3273 10 thou thou NNP 37231 3273 11 be be VB 37231 3273 12 willing willing JJ 37231 3273 13 to to TO 37231 3273 14 remove remove VB 37231 3273 15 this this DT 37231 3273 16 cup cup NN 37231 3273 17 from from IN 37231 3273 18 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3273 19 " " '' 37231 3273 20 : : : 37231 3273 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3273 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3273 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3273 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3273 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- -RRB- 37231 3273 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3273 27 In in IN 37231 3273 28 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3273 29 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 3273 30 . . . 37231 3274 1 39 39 CD 37231 3274 2 this this DT 37231 3274 3 part part NN 37231 3274 4 of of IN 37231 3274 5 the the DT 37231 3274 6 prayer prayer NN 37231 3274 7 is be VBZ 37231 3274 8 more more JJR 37231 3274 9 like like IN 37231 3274 10 the the DT 37231 3274 11 reading reading NN 37231 3274 12 of of IN 37231 3274 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3274 14 : : : 37231 3274 15 " " `` 37231 3274 16 Father Father NNP 37231 3274 17 , , , 37231 3274 18 if if IN 37231 3274 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3274 20 be be VB 37231 3274 21 possible possible JJ 37231 3274 22 let let VB 37231 3274 23 this this DT 37231 3274 24 cup cup NN 37231 3274 25 pass pass VB 37231 3274 26 from from IN 37231 3274 27 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3274 28 " " '' 37231 3274 29 --[--Greek-- --[--Greek-- . 37231 3274 30 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3274 31 but but CC 37231 3274 32 that that IN 37231 3274 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3274 34 has have VBZ 37231 3274 35 nothing nothing NN 37231 3274 36 of of IN 37231 3274 37 the the DT 37231 3274 38 sweat sweat NN 37231 3274 39 of of IN 37231 3274 40 agony agony NNP 37231 3274 41 , , , 37231 3274 42 which which WDT 37231 3274 43 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3274 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3274 45 from from IN 37231 3274 46 consideration consideration NN 37231 3274 47 . . . 37231 3275 1 In in IN 37231 3275 2 another another DT 37231 3275 3 place place NN 37231 3275 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3275 5 also also RB 37231 3275 6 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3275 7 the the DT 37231 3275 8 prayer prayer NN 37231 3275 9 in in IN 37231 3275 10 the the DT 37231 3275 11 Garden Garden NNP 37231 3275 12 as as IN 37231 3275 13 follows follow VBZ 37231 3275 14 : : : 37231 3275 15 " " `` 37231 3275 16 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3275 17 prayed pray VBD 37231 3275 18 , , , 37231 3275 19 saying say VBG 37231 3275 20 : : : 37231 3275 21 ' ' '' 37231 3275 22 Father Father NNP 37231 3275 23 , , , 37231 3275 24 if if IN 37231 3275 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3275 26 be be VB 37231 3275 27 possible possible JJ 37231 3275 28 , , , 37231 3275 29 let let VB 37231 3275 30 this this DT 37231 3275 31 cup cup NN 37231 3275 32 pass pass VB 37231 3275 33 from from IN 37231 3275 34 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3275 35 ; ; : 37231 3275 36 ' ' '' 37231 3275 37 and and CC 37231 3275 38 besides besides IN 37231 3275 39 this this DT 37231 3275 40 , , , 37231 3275 41 praying pray VBG 37231 3275 42 , , , 37231 3275 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3275 44 said say VBD 37231 3275 45 : : : 37231 3275 46 ' ' `` 37231 3275 47 Not not RB 37231 3275 48 as as IN 37231 3275 49 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3275 50 wish wish VBP 37231 3275 51 , , , 37231 3275 52 but but CC 37231 3275 53 as as IN 37231 3275 54 thou thou NNP 37231 3275 55 willest willest NNP 37231 3275 56 . . . 37231 3276 1 ' ' `` 37231 3276 2 " " '' 37231 3276 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3276 4 2 2 LS 37231 3276 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3276 6 The the DT 37231 3276 7 first first JJ 37231 3276 8 phrase phrase NN 37231 3276 9 in in IN 37231 3276 10 this this DT 37231 3276 11 place place NN 37231 3276 12 , , , 37231 3276 13 apart apart RB 37231 3276 14 from from IN 37231 3276 15 some some DT 37231 3276 16 transposition transposition NN 37231 3276 17 of of IN 37231 3276 18 words word NNS 37231 3276 19 , , , 37231 3276 20 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3276 21 with with IN 37231 3276 22 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3276 23 ; ; : 37231 3276 24 but but CC 37231 3276 25 even even RB 37231 3276 26 if if IN 37231 3276 27 this this DT 37231 3276 28 reading reading NN 37231 3276 29 be be VB 37231 3276 30 preferred prefer VBN 37231 3276 31 of of IN 37231 3276 32 the the DT 37231 3276 33 two two CD 37231 3276 34 , , , 37231 3276 35 the the DT 37231 3276 36 absence absence NN 37231 3276 37 of of IN 37231 3276 38 the the DT 37231 3276 39 incident incident NN 37231 3276 40 of of IN 37231 3276 41 the the DT 37231 3276 42 sweat sweat NN 37231 3276 43 of of IN 37231 3276 44 agony agony NNP 37231 3276 45 from from IN 37231 3276 46 the the DT 37231 3276 47 first first JJ 37231 3276 48 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3276 49 renders render VBZ 37231 3276 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3276 51 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3276 52 to to TO 37231 3276 53 regard regard VB 37231 3276 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3276 55 as as IN 37231 3276 56 the the DT 37231 3276 57 source source NN 37231 3276 58 ; ; : 37231 3276 59 and and CC 37231 3276 60 , , , 37231 3276 61 further far RBR 37231 3276 62 , , , 37231 3276 63 the the DT 37231 3276 64 second second JJ 37231 3276 65 part part NN 37231 3276 66 of of IN 37231 3276 67 the the DT 37231 3276 68 prayer prayer NN 37231 3276 69 which which WDT 37231 3276 70 is be VBZ 37231 3276 71 here here RB 37231 3276 72 { { -LRB- 37231 3276 73 329 329 CD 37231 3276 74 } } -RRB- 37231 3276 75 given give VBN 37231 3276 76 differs differ NNS 37231 3276 77 materially materially RB 37231 3276 78 both both CC 37231 3276 79 from from IN 37231 3276 80 the the DT 37231 3276 81 first first JJ 37231 3276 82 and and CC 37231 3276 83 third third JJ 37231 3276 84 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3276 85 . . . 37231 3277 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3277 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3277 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3277 4 The the DT 37231 3277 5 two two CD 37231 3277 6 parts part NNS 37231 3277 7 of of IN 37231 3277 8 this this DT 37231 3277 9 prayer prayer NN 37231 3277 10 , , , 37231 3277 11 moreover moreover RB 37231 3277 12 , , , 37231 3277 13 seem seem VBP 37231 3277 14 to to TO 37231 3277 15 have have VB 37231 3277 16 been be VBN 37231 3277 17 separate separate JJ 37231 3277 18 in in IN 37231 3277 19 the the DT 37231 3277 20 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3277 21 , , , 37231 3277 22 for for IN 37231 3277 23 not not RB 37231 3277 24 only only RB 37231 3277 25 does do VBZ 37231 3277 26 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3277 27 not not RB 37231 3277 28 quote quote VB 37231 3277 29 the the DT 37231 3277 30 latter latter JJ 37231 3277 31 portion portion NN 37231 3277 32 at at RB 37231 3277 33 all all RB 37231 3277 34 in in IN 37231 3277 35 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3277 36 . . . 37231 3278 1 103 103 CD 37231 3278 2 , , , 37231 3278 3 but but CC 37231 3278 4 here here RB 37231 3278 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3278 6 markedly markedly RB 37231 3278 7 divides divide VBZ 37231 3278 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3278 9 from from IN 37231 3278 10 the the DT 37231 3278 11 former former JJ 37231 3278 12 . . . 37231 3279 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3279 2 knows know VBZ 37231 3279 3 nothing nothing NN 37231 3279 4 of of IN 37231 3279 5 the the DT 37231 3279 6 episode episode NN 37231 3279 7 of of IN 37231 3279 8 the the DT 37231 3279 9 Angel Angel NNP 37231 3279 10 who who WP 37231 3279 11 strengthens strengthen VBZ 37231 3279 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3279 13 , , , 37231 3279 14 which which WDT 37231 3279 15 is be VBZ 37231 3279 16 related relate VBN 37231 3279 17 in in IN 37231 3279 18 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3279 19 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3279 20 . . . 37231 3280 1 43 43 CD 37231 3280 2 . . . 37231 3281 1 There there EX 37231 3281 2 is be VBZ 37231 3281 3 , , , 37231 3281 4 however however RB 37231 3281 5 , , , 37231 3281 6 a a DT 37231 3281 7 still still RB 37231 3281 8 more more RBR 37231 3281 9 important important JJ 37231 3281 10 point point NN 37231 3281 11 to to TO 37231 3281 12 mention mention VB 37231 3281 13 : : : 37231 3281 14 that that IN 37231 3281 15 although although IN 37231 3281 16 verses verses IN 37231 3281 17 43 43 CD 37231 3281 18 , , , 37231 3281 19 44 44 CD 37231 3281 20 with with IN 37231 3281 21 the the DT 37231 3281 22 incidents incident NNS 37231 3281 23 of of IN 37231 3281 24 the the DT 37231 3281 25 angel angel NN 37231 3281 26 and and CC 37231 3281 27 the the DT 37231 3281 28 bloody bloody JJ 37231 3281 29 sweat sweat NN 37231 3281 30 are be VBP 37231 3281 31 certainly certainly RB 37231 3281 32 in in IN 37231 3281 33 a a DT 37231 3281 34 great great JJ 37231 3281 35 number number NN 37231 3281 36 of of IN 37231 3281 37 MSS MSS NNP 37231 3281 38 . . . 37231 3281 39 , , , 37231 3281 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3281 41 are be VBP 37231 3281 42 omitted omit VBN 37231 3281 43 by by IN 37231 3281 44 some some DT 37231 3281 45 of of IN 37231 3281 46 the the DT 37231 3281 47 oldest old JJS 37231 3281 48 Codices codex NNS 37231 3281 49 , , , 37231 3281 50 as as IN 37231 3281 51 for for IN 37231 3281 52 instance instance NN 37231 3281 53 by by IN 37231 3281 54 the the DT 37231 3281 55 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 37231 3281 56 and and CC 37231 3281 57 Vatican Vatican NNP 37231 3281 58 MSS MSS NNP 37231 3281 59 . . . 37231 3282 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3282 2 1 1 LS 37231 3282 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3282 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3282 5 is be VBZ 37231 3282 6 evident evident JJ 37231 3282 7 that that IN 37231 3282 8 in in IN 37231 3282 9 this this DT 37231 3282 10 part part NN 37231 3282 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3282 12 's 's POS 37231 3282 13 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3282 14 differed differ VBD 37231 3282 15 from from IN 37231 3282 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3282 17 first first JJ 37231 3282 18 and and CC 37231 3282 19 third third JJ 37231 3282 20 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3282 21 much much RB 37231 3282 22 in in IN 37231 3282 23 the the DT 37231 3282 24 same same JJ 37231 3282 25 way way NN 37231 3282 26 that that WDT 37231 3282 27 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3282 28 do do VBP 37231 3282 29 from from IN 37231 3282 30 each each DT 37231 3282 31 other other JJ 37231 3282 32 . . . 37231 3283 1 In in IN 37231 3283 2 the the DT 37231 3283 3 same same JJ 37231 3283 4 chapter chapter NN 37231 3283 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3283 6 states state VBZ 37231 3283 7 that that IN 37231 3283 8 when when WRB 37231 3283 9 the the DT 37231 3283 10 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3283 11 went go VBD 37231 3283 12 out out RP 37231 3283 13 to to IN 37231 3283 14 the the DT 37231 3283 15 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3283 16 of of IN 37231 3283 17 Olives Olives NNPS 37231 3283 18 to to TO 37231 3283 19 take take VB 37231 3283 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3283 21 , , , 37231 3283 22 " " `` 37231 3283 23 there there EX 37231 3283 24 was be VBD 37231 3283 25 not not RB 37231 3283 26 even even RB 37231 3283 27 a a DT 37231 3283 28 single single JJ 37231 3283 29 man man NN 37231 3283 30 to to TO 37231 3283 31 run run VB 37231 3283 32 to to IN 37231 3283 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3283 34 help help NN 37231 3283 35 as as IN 37231 3283 36 a a DT 37231 3283 37 guiltless guiltless NN 37231 3283 38 person person NN 37231 3283 39 . . . 37231 3284 1 " " `` 37231 3284 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3284 3 2 2 LS 37231 3284 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3284 5 This this DT 37231 3284 6 is be VBZ 37231 3284 7 in in IN 37231 3284 8 direct direct JJ 37231 3284 9 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 3284 10 to to IN 37231 3284 11 all all PDT 37231 3284 12 the the DT 37231 3284 13 Gospels,(3 gospels,(3 NN 37231 3284 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3284 15 and and CC 37231 3284 16 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3284 17 not not RB 37231 3284 18 only only RB 37231 3284 19 completely completely RB 37231 3284 20 ignores ignore VBZ 37231 3284 21 the the DT 37231 3284 22 episode episode NN 37231 3284 23 of of IN 37231 3284 24 the the DT 37231 3284 25 ear ear NN 37231 3284 26 of of IN 37231 3284 27 Malchus Malchus NNP 37231 3284 28 , , , 37231 3284 29 but but CC 37231 3284 30 in in IN 37231 3284 31 this this DT 37231 3284 32 passage passage NN 37231 3284 33 1 1 CD 37231 3284 34 In in IN 37231 3284 35 the the DT 37231 3284 36 Sinaitic Sinaitic NNP 37231 3284 37 Codex Codex NNP 37231 3284 38 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3284 39 are be VBP 37231 3284 40 marked mark VBN 37231 3284 41 for for IN 37231 3284 42 omission omission NN 37231 3284 43 by by IN 37231 3284 44 a a DT 37231 3284 45 later later JJ 37231 3284 46 hand hand NN 37231 3284 47 . . . 37231 3285 1 Lachmann Lachmann NNP 37231 3285 2 brackets bracket NNS 37231 3285 3 , , , 37231 3285 4 and and CC 37231 3285 5 Drs Drs NNP 37231 3285 6 . . . 37231 3286 1 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3286 2 and and CC 37231 3286 3 Hort Hort NNP 37231 3286 4 double double JJ 37231 3286 5 - - HYPH 37231 3286 6 bracket bracket VB 37231 3286 7 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3286 8 . . . 37231 3287 1 The the DT 37231 3287 2 MS MS NNP 37231 3287 3 . . . 37231 3287 4 evidence evidence NN 37231 3287 5 may may MD 37231 3287 6 bo bo NNP 37231 3287 7 found find VBN 37231 3287 8 in in IN 37231 3287 9 detail detail NN 37231 3287 10 in in IN 37231 3287 11 Scrivener Scrivener NNP 37231 3287 12 's 's POS 37231 3287 13 Int Int NNP 37231 3287 14 . . . 37231 3288 1 to to IN 37231 3288 2 Crit Crit NNP 37231 3288 3 . . . 37231 3289 1 N. N. NNP 37231 3289 2 T. T. NNP 37231 3289 3 2nd 2nd JJ 37231 3289 4 ed ed NN 37231 3289 5 . . . 37231 3290 1 p. p. NN 37231 3290 2 521 521 CD 37231 3290 3 , , , 37231 3290 4 stated state VBN 37231 3290 5 in in IN 37231 3290 6 the the DT 37231 3290 7 way way NN 37231 3290 8 which which WDT 37231 3290 9 is be VBZ 37231 3290 10 most most RBS 37231 3290 11 favourable favourable JJ 37231 3290 12 for for IN 37231 3290 13 the the DT 37231 3290 14 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 3290 15 . . . 37231 3291 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3291 2 330 330 CD 37231 3291 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3291 4 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3291 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3291 6 , , , 37231 3291 7 and and CC 37231 3291 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3291 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3291 10 could could MD 37231 3291 11 not not RB 37231 3291 12 have have VB 37231 3291 13 contained contain VBN 37231 3291 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3291 15 . . . 37231 3292 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3292 2 1 1 LS 37231 3292 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3292 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3292 5 is be VBZ 37231 3292 6 specially specially RB 37231 3292 7 marked mark VBN 37231 3292 8 in in IN 37231 3292 9 generalizing generalize VBG 37231 3292 10 the the DT 37231 3292 11 resistance resistance NN 37231 3292 12 of of IN 37231 3292 13 those those DT 37231 3292 14 about about IN 37231 3292 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3292 16 to to IN 37231 3292 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3292 18 capture capture NN 37231 3292 19 : : : 37231 3292 20 " " `` 37231 3292 21 When when WRB 37231 3292 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3292 23 which which WDT 37231 3292 24 were be VBD 37231 3292 25 about about IN 37231 3292 26 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3292 27 saw see VBD 37231 3292 28 what what WP 37231 3292 29 would would MD 37231 3292 30 follow follow VB 37231 3292 31 , , , 37231 3292 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3292 33 said say VBD 37231 3292 34 unto unto IN 37231 3292 35 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3292 36 : : : 37231 3292 37 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3292 38 , , , 37231 3292 39 shall shall MD 37231 3292 40 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3292 41 smite smite VB 37231 3292 42 with with IN 37231 3292 43 the the DT 37231 3292 44 sword sword NN 37231 3292 45 ? ? . 37231 3293 1 And and CC 37231 3293 2 a a DT 37231 3293 3 certain certain JJ 37231 3293 4 one one CD 37231 3293 5 of of IN 37231 3293 6 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3293 7 smote smote VBP 37231 3293 8 the the DT 37231 3293 9 servant servant NN 37231 3293 10 of of IN 37231 3293 11 the the DT 37231 3293 12 high high JJ 37231 3293 13 priest priest NN 37231 3293 14 and and CC 37231 3293 15 cut cut VBD 37231 3293 16 off off RP 37231 3293 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3293 18 right right JJ 37231 3293 19 ear ear NN 37231 3293 20 . . . 37231 3294 1 " " `` 37231 3294 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3294 3 2 2 LS 37231 3294 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3294 5 As as IN 37231 3294 6 this this DT 37231 3294 7 episode episode NN 37231 3294 8 follows follow VBZ 37231 3294 9 immediately immediately RB 37231 3294 10 after after IN 37231 3294 11 the the DT 37231 3294 12 incident incident NN 37231 3294 13 of of IN 37231 3294 14 the the DT 37231 3294 15 bloody bloody JJ 37231 3294 16 sweat sweat NN 37231 3294 17 and and CC 37231 3294 18 prayer prayer NN 37231 3294 19 in in IN 37231 3294 20 the the DT 37231 3294 21 Garden Garden NNP 37231 3294 22 , , , 37231 3294 23 and and CC 37231 3294 24 the the DT 37231 3294 25 statement statement NN 37231 3294 26 of of IN 37231 3294 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3294 28 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3294 29 in in IN 37231 3294 30 the the DT 37231 3294 31 very very RB 37231 3294 32 same same JJ 37231 3294 33 chapter chapter NN 37231 3294 34 in in IN 37231 3294 35 which which WDT 37231 3294 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3294 37 refers refer VBZ 37231 3294 38 to to IN 37231 3294 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3294 40 , , , 37231 3294 41 this this DT 37231 3294 42 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 3294 43 further further RB 37231 3294 44 tends tend VBZ 37231 3294 45 to to TO 37231 3294 46 confirm confirm VB 37231 3294 47 the the DT 37231 3294 48 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3294 49 that that IN 37231 3294 50 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3294 51 employed employ VBD 37231 3294 52 a a DT 37231 3294 53 different different JJ 37231 3294 54 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3294 55 . . . 37231 3295 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 2 is be VBZ 37231 3295 3 quite quite RB 37231 3295 4 in in IN 37231 3295 5 harmony harmony NN 37231 3295 6 with with IN 37231 3295 7 the the DT 37231 3295 8 same same JJ 37231 3295 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3295 10 account account NN 37231 3295 11 that that IN 37231 3295 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3295 13 states state VBZ 37231 3295 14 that that IN 37231 3295 15 , , , 37231 3295 16 " " `` 37231 3295 17 after after IN 37231 3295 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3295 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3295 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3295 22 was be VBD 37231 3295 23 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3295 24 , , , 37231 3295 25 all all DT 37231 3295 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3295 27 friends friend NNS 37231 3295 28 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3295 29 the the DT 37231 3295 30 Apostles Apostles NNP 37231 3295 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3295 32 stood stand VBD 37231 3295 33 aloof aloof JJ 37231 3295 34 from from IN 37231 3295 35 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 36 , , , 37231 3295 37 having have VBG 37231 3295 38 denied deny VBN 37231 3295 39 him(3 him(3 ADD 37231 3295 40 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3295 41 .... .... . 37231 3295 42 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3295 43 who who WP 37231 3295 44 , , , 37231 3295 45 after after IN 37231 3295 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 47 rose rise VBD 37231 3295 48 from from IN 37231 3295 49 the the DT 37231 3295 50 dead dead NN 37231 3295 51 , , , 37231 3295 52 and and CC 37231 3295 53 after after IN 37231 3295 54 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 55 were be VBD 37231 3295 56 convinced convince VBN 37231 3295 57 by by IN 37231 3295 58 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 59 that that IN 37231 3295 60 before before IN 37231 3295 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3295 62 passion passion NN 37231 3295 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 64 had have VBD 37231 3295 65 told tell VBD 37231 3295 66 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 67 that that IN 37231 3295 68 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 69 must must MD 37231 3295 70 suffer suffer VB 37231 3295 71 these these DT 37231 3295 72 things thing NNS 37231 3295 73 , , , 37231 3295 74 and and CC 37231 3295 75 that that IN 37231 3295 76 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 77 were be VBD 37231 3295 78 foretold foretell VBN 37231 3295 79 by by IN 37231 3295 80 the the DT 37231 3295 81 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3295 82 , , , 37231 3295 83 repented repent VBN 37231 3295 84 of of IN 37231 3295 85 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3295 86 flight flight NN 37231 3295 87 from from IN 37231 3295 88 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 89 when when WRB 37231 3295 90 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 91 was be VBD 37231 3295 92 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3295 93 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3295 94 , , , 37231 3295 95 and and CC 37231 3295 96 while while IN 37231 3295 97 remaining remain VBG 37231 3295 98 among among IN 37231 3295 99 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 100 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3295 101 sang sing VBD 37231 3295 102 praises praise NNS 37231 3295 103 to to IN 37231 3295 104 God God NNP 37231 3295 105 , , , 37231 3295 106 as as IN 37231 3295 107 is be VBZ 37231 3295 108 made make VBN 37231 3295 109 evident evident JJ 37231 3295 110 in in IN 37231 3295 111 the the DT 37231 3295 112 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3295 113 of of IN 37231 3295 114 the the DT 37231 3295 115 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3295 116 . . . 37231 3296 1 " " `` 37231 3296 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3296 3 4 4 LS 37231 3296 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3296 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3296 6 , , , 37231 3296 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 3296 8 , , , 37231 3296 9 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 3296 10 asserts assert VBZ 37231 3296 11 that that IN 37231 3296 12 _ _ NNP 37231 3296 13 after after IN 37231 3296 14 _ _ NNP 37231 3296 15 the the DT 37231 3296 16 crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 3296 17 all all PDT 37231 3296 18 the the DT 37231 3296 19 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3296 20 forsook forsook VBP 37231 3296 21 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3296 22 , , , 37231 3296 23 and and CC 37231 3296 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3296 25 extends extend VBZ 37231 3296 26 the the DT 37231 3296 27 denial denial NN 37231 3296 28 of of IN 37231 3296 29 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3296 30 { { -LRB- 37231 3296 31 331 331 CD 37231 3296 32 } } -RRB- 37231 3296 33 to to IN 37231 3296 34 the the DT 37231 3296 35 whole whole NN 37231 3296 36 of of IN 37231 3296 37 the the DT 37231 3296 38 twelve twelve CD 37231 3296 39 . . . 37231 3297 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3297 2 is be VBZ 37231 3297 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3297 4 to to TO 37231 3297 5 consider consider VB 37231 3297 6 this this DT 37231 3297 7 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3297 8 and and CC 37231 3297 9 reiterated reiterate VBD 37231 3297 10 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 3297 11 a a DT 37231 3297 12 mere mere JJ 37231 3297 13 extension extension NN 37231 3297 14 of of IN 37231 3297 15 the the DT 37231 3297 16 passage passage NN 37231 3297 17 : : : 37231 3297 18 " " `` 37231 3297 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3297 20 all all DT 37231 3297 21 forsook forsook VBP 37231 3297 22 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3297 23 and and CC 37231 3297 24 fled flee VBD 37231 3297 25 " " '' 37231 3297 26 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3297 27 --Greek--],(1 --Greek--],(1 NFP 37231 3297 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3297 29 when when WRB 37231 3297 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3297 31 was be VBD 37231 3297 32 arrested arrest VBN 37231 3297 33 , , , 37231 3297 34 which which WDT 37231 3297 35 proceeded proceed VBD 37231 3297 36 mainly mainly RB 37231 3297 37 from from IN 37231 3297 38 momentary momentary JJ 37231 3297 39 fear fear NN 37231 3297 40 . . . 37231 3298 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3298 2 2 2 LS 37231 3298 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3298 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3298 5 seems seem VBZ 37231 3298 6 to to TO 37231 3298 7 indicate indicate VB 37231 3298 8 that that IN 37231 3298 9 the the DT 37231 3298 10 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3298 11 withdrew withdraw VBD 37231 3298 12 from from IN 37231 3298 13 and and CC 37231 3298 14 denied deny VBD 37231 3298 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3298 16 when when WRB 37231 3298 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3298 18 saw see VBD 37231 3298 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3298 20 crucified crucify VBD 37231 3298 21 , , , 37231 3298 22 from from IN 37231 3298 23 doubts doubt NNS 37231 3298 24 which which WDT 37231 3298 25 consequently consequently RB 37231 3298 26 arose arise VBD 37231 3298 27 as as IN 37231 3298 28 to to IN 37231 3298 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3298 30 Messianic Messianic NNP 37231 3298 31 character character NN 37231 3298 32 . . . 37231 3299 1 Now now RB 37231 3299 2 , , , 37231 3299 3 on on IN 37231 3299 4 the the DT 37231 3299 5 contrary contrary NN 37231 3299 6 , , , 37231 3299 7 the the DT 37231 3299 8 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3299 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3299 10 represent represent VBP 37231 3299 11 the the DT 37231 3299 12 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3299 13 as as IN 37231 3299 14 being be VBG 37231 3299 15 together together RB 37231 3299 16 after after IN 37231 3299 17 the the DT 37231 3299 18 Crucifixion Crucifixion NNP 37231 3299 19 . . . 37231 3300 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3300 2 3 3 LS 37231 3300 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3300 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3300 5 does do VBZ 37231 3300 6 not not RB 37231 3300 7 exhibit exhibit VB 37231 3300 8 any any DT 37231 3300 9 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 3300 10 of of IN 37231 3300 11 the the DT 37231 3300 12 explanation explanation NN 37231 3300 13 given give VBN 37231 3300 14 by by IN 37231 3300 15 the the DT 37231 3300 16 angels angel NNS 37231 3300 17 at at IN 37231 3300 18 the the DT 37231 3300 19 sepulchre sepulchre NN 37231 3300 20 as as IN 37231 3300 21 to to IN 37231 3300 22 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3300 23 's 's POS 37231 3300 24 having have VBG 37231 3300 25 foretold foretold NN 37231 3300 26 all all DT 37231 3300 27 that that WDT 37231 3300 28 had have VBD 37231 3300 29 happened,(4 happened,(4 NNP 37231 3300 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3300 31 but but CC 37231 3300 32 makes make VBZ 37231 3300 33 this this DT 37231 3300 34 proceed proceed NN 37231 3300 35 from from IN 37231 3300 36 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3300 37 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3300 38 . . . 37231 3301 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 3301 2 , , , 37231 3301 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3301 4 makes make VBZ 37231 3301 5 no no DT 37231 3301 6 mention mention NN 37231 3301 7 of of IN 37231 3301 8 these these DT 37231 3301 9 angels angel NNS 37231 3301 10 at at RB 37231 3301 11 all all RB 37231 3301 12 . . . 37231 3302 1 There there EX 37231 3302 2 are be VBP 37231 3302 3 some some DT 37231 3302 4 traces trace NNS 37231 3302 5 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3302 6 of of IN 37231 3302 7 the the DT 37231 3302 8 view view NN 37231 3302 9 that that IN 37231 3302 10 the the DT 37231 3302 11 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3302 12 were be VBD 37231 3302 13 offended offend VBN 37231 3302 14 after after IN 37231 3302 15 the the DT 37231 3302 16 Crucifixion Crucifixion NNP 37231 3302 17 . . . 37231 3303 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3303 2 5 5 LS 37231 3303 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3303 4 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 3303 5 points point VBZ 37231 3303 6 out out RP 37231 3303 7 the the DT 37231 3303 8 appearance appearance NN 37231 3303 9 of of IN 37231 3303 10 special special JJ 37231 3303 11 Petrine Petrine NNP 37231 3303 12 tendency tendency NN 37231 3303 13 in in IN 37231 3303 14 this this DT 37231 3303 15 passage passage NN 37231 3303 16 , , , 37231 3303 17 in in IN 37231 3303 18 the the DT 37231 3303 19 fact fact NN 37231 3303 20 that that IN 37231 3303 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3303 22 is be VBZ 37231 3303 23 not not RB 37231 3303 24 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3303 25 alone alone RB 37231 3303 26 , , , 37231 3303 27 but but CC 37231 3303 28 all all PDT 37231 3303 29 the the DT 37231 3303 30 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3303 31 , , , 37231 3303 32 who who WP 37231 3303 33 are be VBP 37231 3303 34 said say VBN 37231 3303 35 to to TO 37231 3303 36 deny deny VB 37231 3303 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3303 38 master master NN 37231 3303 39 ; ; : 37231 3303 40 and and CC 37231 3303 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3303 42 suggests suggest VBZ 37231 3303 43 that that IN 37231 3303 44 an an DT 37231 3303 45 indication indication NN 37231 3303 46 of of IN 37231 3303 47 the the DT 37231 3303 48 source source NN 37231 3303 49 from from IN 37231 3303 50 which which WDT 37231 3303 51 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3303 52 quoted quote VBD 37231 3303 53 may may MD 37231 3303 54 be be VB 37231 3303 55 obtained obtain VBN 37231 3303 56 from from IN 37231 3303 57 the the DT 37231 3303 58 kindred kindred JJ 37231 3303 59 quotation quotation NN 37231 3303 60 in in IN 37231 3303 61 the the DT 37231 3303 62 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3303 63 to to IN 37231 3303 64 the the DT 37231 3303 65 Smyrnæans Smyrnæans NNPS 37231 3303 66 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3303 67 iii iii CD 37231 3303 68 . . . 37231 3303 69 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3304 1 by by IN 37231 3304 2 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 3304 3 - - NNP 37231 3304 4 Ignatius ignatius NN 37231 3304 5 : : : 37231 3304 6 " " `` 37231 3304 7 For for CC 37231 3304 8 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3304 9 know know VBP 37231 3304 10 that that IN 37231 3304 11 also also RB 37231 3304 12 after after IN 37231 3304 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3304 14 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 3304 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3304 16 was be VBD 37231 3304 17 in in IN 37231 3304 18 the the DT 37231 3304 19 flesh flesh NN 37231 3304 20 , , , 37231 3304 21 and and CC 37231 3304 22 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3304 23 believe believe VBP 37231 3304 24 that that IN 37231 3304 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3304 26 is be VBZ 37231 3304 27 so so RB 37231 3304 28 now now RB 37231 3304 29 . . . 37231 3305 1 And and CC 37231 3305 2 when when WRB 37231 3305 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3305 4 came come VBD 37231 3305 5 to to IN 37231 3305 6 those those DT 37231 3305 7 that that WDT 37231 3305 8 were be VBD 37231 3305 9 with with IN 37231 3305 10 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3305 11 , , , 37231 3305 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3305 13 said say VBD 37231 3305 14 to to IN 37231 3305 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3305 16 : : : 37231 3305 17 Lay Lay NNP 37231 3305 18 hold hold VB 37231 3305 19 , , , 37231 3305 20 handle handle VB 37231 3305 21 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3305 22 , , , 37231 3305 23 and and CC 37231 3305 24 see see VB 37231 3305 25 that that IN 37231 3305 26 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3305 27 am be VBP 37231 3305 28 { { -LRB- 37231 3305 29 332 332 CD 37231 3305 30 } } -RRB- 37231 3305 31 not not RB 37231 3305 32 an an DT 37231 3305 33 incorporeal incorporeal JJ 37231 3305 34 spirit spirit NN 37231 3305 35 . . . 37231 3306 1 And and CC 37231 3306 2 immediately immediately RB 37231 3306 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3306 4 touched touch VBD 37231 3306 5 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3306 6 and and CC 37231 3306 7 believed believe VBD 37231 3306 8 , , , 37231 3306 9 being be VBG 37231 3306 10 convinced convince VBN 37231 3306 11 by by IN 37231 3306 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3306 13 flesh flesh NN 37231 3306 14 and and CC 37231 3306 15 spirit spirit NN 37231 3306 16 . . . 37231 3306 17 " " '' 37231 3307 1 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 3307 2 , , , 37231 3307 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3307 4 will will MD 37231 3307 5 be be VB 37231 3307 6 remembered remember VBN 37231 3307 7 , , , 37231 3307 8 found find VBD 37231 3307 9 this this DT 37231 3307 10 in in IN 37231 3307 11 the the DT 37231 3307 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3307 13 according accord VBG 37231 3307 14 to to IN 37231 3307 15 the the DT 37231 3307 16 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3307 17 used use VBN 37231 3307 18 by by IN 37231 3307 19 the the DT 37231 3307 20 Nazarenes Nazarenes NNPS 37231 3307 21 , , , 37231 3307 22 which which WDT 37231 3307 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3307 24 translated,(1 translated,(1 VBP 37231 3307 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3307 26 from from IN 37231 3307 27 which which WDT 37231 3307 28 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3307 29 have have VBP 37231 3307 30 seen see VBN 37231 3307 31 that that IN 37231 3307 32 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3307 33 in in IN 37231 3307 34 all all DT 37231 3307 35 probability probability NN 37231 3307 36 derived derive VBD 37231 3307 37 other other JJ 37231 3307 38 particulars particular NNS 37231 3307 39 differing differ VBG 37231 3307 40 from from IN 37231 3307 41 the the DT 37231 3307 42 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3307 43 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3307 44 , , , 37231 3307 45 and and CC 37231 3307 46 with with IN 37231 3307 47 which which WDT 37231 3307 48 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3307 49 shall shall MD 37231 3307 50 constantly constantly RB 37231 3307 51 meet meet VB 37231 3307 52 , , , 37231 3307 53 in in IN 37231 3307 54 a a DT 37231 3307 55 similar similar JJ 37231 3307 56 way way NN 37231 3307 57 , , , 37231 3307 58 in in IN 37231 3307 59 examining examine VBG 37231 3307 60 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3307 61 's 's POS 37231 3307 62 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3307 63 . . . 37231 3308 1 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3308 2 also also RB 37231 3308 3 found find VBD 37231 3308 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3308 5 in in IN 37231 3308 6 a a DT 37231 3308 7 work work NN 37231 3308 8 called call VBN 37231 3308 9 the the DT 37231 3308 10 " " `` 37231 3308 11 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 37231 3308 12 of of IN 37231 3308 13 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3308 14 " " '' 37231 3308 15 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3308 16 --Greek--],(2 --Greek--],(2 NFP 37231 3308 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3308 18 which which WDT 37231 3308 19 must must MD 37231 3308 20 have have VB 37231 3308 21 been be VBN 37231 3308 22 akin akin JJ 37231 3308 23 to to IN 37231 3308 24 the the DT 37231 3308 25 " " `` 37231 3308 26 Preaching Preaching NNP 37231 3308 27 of of IN 37231 3308 28 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3308 29 " " '' 37231 3308 30 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3308 31 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3308 32 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3308 33 . . . 37231 3309 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3309 2 3 3 LS 37231 3309 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3309 4 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 3309 5 suggests suggest VBZ 37231 3309 6 that that IN 37231 3309 7 , , , 37231 3309 8 in in IN 37231 3309 9 the the DT 37231 3309 10 absence absence NN 37231 3309 11 of of IN 37231 3309 12 more more RBR 37231 3309 13 certain certain JJ 37231 3309 14 information information NN 37231 3309 15 , , , 37231 3309 16 there there EX 37231 3309 17 is be VBZ 37231 3309 18 no no DT 37231 3309 19 more more RBR 37231 3309 20 probable probable JJ 37231 3309 21 source source NN 37231 3309 22 from from IN 37231 3309 23 which which WDT 37231 3309 24 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3309 25 may may MD 37231 3309 26 have have VB 37231 3309 27 derived derive VBN 37231 3309 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3309 29 statement statement NN 37231 3309 30 than than IN 37231 3309 31 the the DT 37231 3309 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3309 33 according accord VBG 37231 3309 34 to to IN 37231 3309 35 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3309 36 , , , 37231 3309 37 or or CC 37231 3309 38 the the DT 37231 3309 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3309 40 according accord VBG 37231 3309 41 to to IN 37231 3309 42 the the DT 37231 3309 43 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3309 44 , , , 37231 3309 45 which which WDT 37231 3309 46 is be VBZ 37231 3309 47 known know VBN 37231 3309 48 to to TO 37231 3309 49 have have VB 37231 3309 50 contained contain VBN 37231 3309 51 so so RB 37231 3309 52 much much JJ 37231 3309 53 in in IN 37231 3309 54 the the DT 37231 3309 55 same same JJ 37231 3309 56 spirit spirit NN 37231 3309 57 . . . 37231 3310 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3310 2 4 4 LS 37231 3310 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3310 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3310 5 may may MD 37231 3310 6 well well RB 37231 3310 7 be be VB 37231 3310 8 expected expect VBN 37231 3310 9 that that IN 37231 3310 10 , , , 37231 3310 11 at at IN 37231 3310 12 least least JJS 37231 3310 13 in in IN 37231 3310 14 touching touch VBG 37231 3310 15 such such JJ 37231 3310 16 serious serious JJ 37231 3310 17 matters matter NNS 37231 3310 18 as as IN 37231 3310 19 the the DT 37231 3310 20 Crucifixion Crucifixion NNP 37231 3310 21 and and CC 37231 3310 22 last last JJ 37231 3310 23 words word NNS 37231 3310 24 of of IN 37231 3310 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3310 26 , , , 37231 3310 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3310 28 must must MD 37231 3310 29 adhere adhere VB 37231 3310 30 with with IN 37231 3310 31 care care NN 37231 3310 32 to to IN 37231 3310 33 authentic authentic JJ 37231 3310 34 records record NNS 37231 3310 35 , , , 37231 3310 36 and and CC 37231 3310 37 not not RB 37231 3310 38 fall fall VB 37231 3310 39 into into IN 37231 3310 40 the the DT 37231 3310 41 faults fault NNS 37231 3310 42 of of IN 37231 3310 43 loose loose JJ 37231 3310 44 quotation quotation NN 37231 3310 45 from from IN 37231 3310 46 memory memory NN 37231 3310 47 , , , 37231 3310 48 free free JJ 37231 3310 49 handling handling NN 37231 3310 50 of of IN 37231 3310 51 texts text NNS 37231 3310 52 , , , 37231 3310 53 and and CC 37231 3310 54 careless careless JJ 37231 3310 55 omissions omission NNS 37231 3310 56 and and CC 37231 3310 57 additions addition NNS 37231 3310 58 , , , 37231 3310 59 by by IN 37231 3310 60 which which WDT 37231 3310 61 those those DT 37231 3310 62 who who WP 37231 3310 63 maintain maintain VBP 37231 3310 64 the the DT 37231 3310 65 identity identity NN 37231 3310 66 of of IN 37231 3310 67 the the DT 37231 3310 68 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3310 69 with with IN 37231 3310 70 the the DT 37231 3310 71 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3310 72 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3310 73 seek seek VBP 37231 3310 74 to to TO 37231 3310 75 explain explain VB 37231 3310 76 the the DT 37231 3310 77 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3310 78 variations variation NNS 37231 3310 79 of of IN 37231 3310 80 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3310 81 's 's POS 37231 3310 82 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3310 83 from from IN 37231 3310 84 the the DT 37231 3310 85 text text NN 37231 3310 86 of of IN 37231 3310 87 the the DT 37231 3310 88 latter latter JJ 37231 3310 89 . . . 37231 3311 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3311 2 will will MD 37231 3311 3 , , , 37231 3311 4 however however RB 37231 3311 5 , , , 37231 3311 6 be be VB 37231 3311 7 found find VBN 37231 3311 8 that that IN 37231 3311 9 here here RB 37231 3311 10 also also RB 37231 3311 11 marked mark VBD 37231 3311 12 discrepancies discrepancy NNS 37231 3311 13 occur occur VBP 37231 3311 14 . . . 37231 3312 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3312 2 says say VBZ 37231 3312 3 , , , 37231 3312 4 after after IN 37231 3312 5 referring refer VBG 37231 3312 6 to to IN 37231 3312 7 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3312 8 prophecies prophecy NNS 37231 3312 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 3312 10 the the DT 37231 3312 11 treatment treatment NN 37231 3312 12 of of IN 37231 3312 13 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3312 14 : : : 37231 3312 15 " " `` 37231 3312 16 And and CC 37231 3312 17 again again RB 37231 3312 18 , , , 37231 3312 19 when when WRB 37231 3312 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3312 21 says say VBZ 37231 3312 22 : : : 37231 3312 23 ' ' `` 37231 3312 24 They -PRON- PRP 37231 3312 25 spake spake VBP 37231 3312 26 with with IN 37231 3312 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3312 28 lips lip NNS 37231 3312 29 , , , 37231 3312 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3312 31 wagged wag VBD 37231 3312 32 the the DT 37231 3312 33 head head NN 37231 3312 34 , , , 37231 3312 35 saying say VBG 37231 3312 36 : : : 37231 3312 37 Let let VB 37231 3312 38 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3312 39 { { -LRB- 37231 3312 40 333 333 CD 37231 3312 41 } } -RRB- 37231 3312 42 deliver deliver VBP 37231 3312 43 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3312 44 . . . 37231 3312 45 ' ' '' 37231 3313 1 That that IN 37231 3313 2 all all PDT 37231 3313 3 these these DT 37231 3313 4 things thing NNS 37231 3313 5 happened happen VBD 37231 3313 6 to to IN 37231 3313 7 the the DT 37231 3313 8 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3313 9 from from IN 37231 3313 10 the the DT 37231 3313 11 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3313 12 , , , 37231 3313 13 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3313 14 can can MD 37231 3313 15 ascertain ascertain VB 37231 3313 16 . . . 37231 3314 1 For for IN 37231 3314 2 when when WRB 37231 3314 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3314 4 was be VBD 37231 3314 5 being be VBG 37231 3314 6 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3314 7 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3314 8 shot shoot VBD 37231 3314 9 out out RP 37231 3314 10 the the DT 37231 3314 11 lips lip NNS 37231 3314 12 , , , 37231 3314 13 and and CC 37231 3314 14 wagged wag VBD 37231 3314 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3314 16 heads head NNS 37231 3314 17 , , , 37231 3314 18 saying say VBG 37231 3314 19 : : : 37231 3314 20 ' ' `` 37231 3314 21 Let let VB 37231 3314 22 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3314 23 who who WP 37231 3314 24 raised raise VBD 37231 3314 25 the the DT 37231 3314 26 dead dead JJ 37231 3314 27 deliver deliver VB 37231 3314 28 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3314 29 . . . 37231 3315 1 ' ' '' 37231 3315 2 " " '' 37231 3315 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3315 4 1 1 CD 37231 3315 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3315 6 And and CC 37231 3315 7 in in IN 37231 3315 8 another another DT 37231 3315 9 place place NN 37231 3315 10 , , , 37231 3315 11 referring refer VBG 37231 3315 12 to to IN 37231 3315 13 the the DT 37231 3315 14 same same JJ 37231 3315 15 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 3315 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3315 17 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3315 18 . . . 37231 3315 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3316 1 as as IN 37231 3316 2 a a DT 37231 3316 3 prediction prediction NN 37231 3316 4 of of IN 37231 3316 5 what what WP 37231 3316 6 was be VBD 37231 3316 7 to to TO 37231 3316 8 happen happen VB 37231 3316 9 to to IN 37231 3316 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3316 11 , , , 37231 3316 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3316 13 says say VBZ 37231 3316 14 : : : 37231 3316 15 " " `` 37231 3316 16 For for IN 37231 3316 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 18 who who WP 37231 3316 19 saw see VBD 37231 3316 20 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 21 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3316 22 also also RB 37231 3316 23 wagged wag VBD 37231 3316 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3316 25 heads head NNS 37231 3316 26 , , , 37231 3316 27 each each DT 37231 3316 28 one one CD 37231 3316 29 of of IN 37231 3316 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 31 , , , 37231 3316 32 and and CC 37231 3316 33 distorted distort VBD 37231 3316 34 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3316 35 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3316 36 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3316 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3316 38 lips lip NNS 37231 3316 39 , , , 37231 3316 40 and and CC 37231 3316 41 sneeringly sneeringly RB 37231 3316 42 and and CC 37231 3316 43 in in IN 37231 3316 44 scornful scornful JJ 37231 3316 45 irony irony NN 37231 3316 46 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3316 47 among among IN 37231 3316 48 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 49 those those DT 37231 3316 50 words word NNS 37231 3316 51 which which WDT 37231 3316 52 are be VBP 37231 3316 53 also also RB 37231 3316 54 written write VBN 37231 3316 55 in in IN 37231 3316 56 the the DT 37231 3316 57 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3316 58 of of IN 37231 3316 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3316 60 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3316 61 : : : 37231 3316 62 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 63 declared declare VBD 37231 3316 64 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 65 the the DT 37231 3316 66 Son Son NNP 37231 3316 67 of of IN 37231 3316 68 God God NNP 37231 3316 69 ; ; : 37231 3316 70 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3316 71 let let VB 37231 3316 72 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 73 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3316 74 come come VB 37231 3316 75 down down RP 37231 3316 76 , , , 37231 3316 77 let let VB 37231 3316 78 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 79 walk walk VB 37231 3316 80 about about IN 37231 3316 81 ; ; : 37231 3316 82 let let VB 37231 3316 83 God God NNP 37231 3316 84 save save VB 37231 3316 85 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3316 86 . . . 37231 3317 1 " " `` 37231 3317 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3317 3 2 2 LS 37231 3317 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3317 5 In in IN 37231 3317 6 both both DT 37231 3317 7 of of IN 37231 3317 8 these these DT 37231 3317 9 passages passage NNS 37231 3317 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3317 11 directly directly RB 37231 3317 12 appeals appeal VBZ 37231 3317 13 to to IN 37231 3317 14 written write VBN 37231 3317 15 authority authority NN 37231 3317 16 . . . 37231 3318 1 The the DT 37231 3318 2 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3318 3 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3318 4 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3318 5 may may MD 37231 3318 6 leave leave VB 37231 3318 7 the the DT 37231 3318 8 source source NN 37231 3318 9 of of IN 37231 3318 10 the the DT 37231 3318 11 first first JJ 37231 3318 12 uncertain,(3 uncertain,(3 NNP 37231 3318 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3318 14 but but CC 37231 3318 15 the the DT 37231 3318 16 second second JJ 37231 3318 17 is be VBZ 37231 3318 18 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3318 19 stated state VBN 37231 3318 20 to to TO 37231 3318 21 contain contain VB 37231 3318 22 the the DT 37231 3318 23 actual actual JJ 37231 3318 24 words word NNS 37231 3318 25 " " `` 37231 3318 26 written write VBN 37231 3318 27 in in IN 37231 3318 28 the the DT 37231 3318 29 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3318 30 of of IN 37231 3318 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3318 32 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3318 33 , , , 37231 3318 34 " " '' 37231 3318 35 and and CC 37231 3318 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3318 37 seems seem VBZ 37231 3318 38 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 3318 39 to to TO 37231 3318 40 suppose suppose VB 37231 3318 41 that that IN 37231 3318 42 the the DT 37231 3318 43 former former JJ 37231 3318 44 passage passage NN 37231 3318 45 is be VBZ 37231 3318 46 also also RB 37231 3318 47 derived derive VBN 37231 3318 48 from from IN 37231 3318 49 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3318 50 . . . 37231 3319 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3319 2 is be VBZ 37231 3319 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 3319 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3319 5 to to TO 37231 3319 6 add add VB 37231 3319 7 that that IN 37231 3319 8 both both DT 37231 3319 9 differ differ VBP 37231 3319 10 very very RB 37231 3319 11 materially materially RB 37231 3319 12 from from IN 37231 3319 13 the the DT 37231 3319 14 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3319 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3319 16 . . . 37231 3320 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3320 2 4 4 LS 37231 3320 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3320 4 The the DT 37231 3320 5 taunt taunt NN 37231 3320 6 4 4 CD 37231 3320 7 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3320 8 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3320 9 admits admit VBZ 37231 3320 10 that that IN 37231 3320 11 in in IN 37231 3320 12 the the DT 37231 3320 13 latter latter JJ 37231 3320 14 passage passage NN 37231 3320 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3320 16 does do VBZ 37231 3320 17 profess profess NN 37231 3320 18 to to TO 37231 3320 19 give give VB 37231 3320 20 the the DT 37231 3320 21 exact exact JJ 37231 3320 22 words word NNS 37231 3320 23 which which WDT 37231 3320 24 were be VBD 37231 3320 25 recorded record VBN 37231 3320 26 in in IN 37231 3320 27 the the DT 37231 3320 28 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3320 29 , , , 37231 3320 30 and and CC 37231 3320 31 that that IN 37231 3320 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3320 33 are be VBP 37231 3320 34 not not RB 37231 3320 35 to to TO 37231 3320 36 be be VB 37231 3320 37 found find VBN 37231 3320 38 in in IN 37231 3320 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3320 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3320 41 ; ; : 37231 3320 42 " " '' 37231 3320 43 but but CC 37231 3320 44 , , , 37231 3320 45 " " '' 37231 3320 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3320 47 apologetically apologetically RB 37231 3320 48 adds add VBZ 37231 3320 49 , , , 37231 3320 50 " " `` 37231 3320 51 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3320 52 do do VBP 37231 3320 53 find find VB 37231 3320 54 these these DT 37231 3320 55 others other NNS 37231 3320 56 so so RB 37231 3320 57 closely closely RB 37231 3320 58 connected connected JJ 37231 3320 59 with with IN 37231 3320 60 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3320 61 that that IN 37231 3320 62 few few JJ 37231 3320 63 readers reader NNS 37231 3320 64 would would MD 37231 3320 65 feel feel VB 37231 3320 66 the the DT 37231 3320 67 difference difference NN 37231 3320 68 " " '' 37231 3320 69 ! ! . 37231 3321 1 This this DT 37231 3321 2 is be VBZ 37231 3321 3 a a DT 37231 3321 4 specimen speciman NNS 37231 3321 5 of of IN 37231 3321 6 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 3321 7 criticism criticism NN 37231 3321 8 . . . 37231 3322 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3322 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3322 3 goes go VBZ 37231 3322 4 on on RP 37231 3322 5 to to TO 37231 3322 6 say say VB 37231 3322 7 that that IN 37231 3322 8 as as IN 37231 3322 9 no no DT 37231 3322 10 MS MS NNP 37231 3322 11 . . . 37231 3322 12 or or CC 37231 3322 13 Father Father NNP 37231 3322 14 known know VBN 37231 3322 15 to to IN 37231 3322 16 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3322 17 has have VBZ 37231 3322 18 preserved preserve VBN 37231 3322 19 any any DT 37231 3322 20 reading reading NN 37231 3322 21 more more RBR 37231 3322 22 closely closely RB 37231 3322 23 resembling resemble VBG 37231 3322 24 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3322 25 's 's POS 37231 3322 26 , , , 37231 3322 27 " " `` 37231 3322 28 if if IN 37231 3322 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3322 30 appear appear VBP 37231 3322 31 not not RB 37231 3322 32 to to TO 37231 3322 33 be be VB 37231 3322 34 deducible deducible JJ 37231 3322 35 from from IN 37231 3322 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3322 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3322 38 , , , 37231 3322 39 due due JJ 37231 3322 40 allowance allowance NN 37231 3322 41 being be VBG 37231 3322 42 made make VBN 37231 3322 43 for for IN 37231 3322 44 the the DT 37231 3322 45 object object NN 37231 3322 46 which which WDT 37231 3322 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3322 48 had have VBD 37231 3322 49 in in IN 37231 3322 50 view view NN 37231 3322 51 , , , 37231 3322 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3322 53 source source NN 37231 3322 54 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3322 55 must must MD 37231 3322 56 remain remain VB 37231 3322 57 concealed conceal VBN 37231 3322 58 . . . 37231 3322 59 " " '' 37231 3323 1 On on IN 37231 3323 2 the the DT 37231 3323 3 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3323 4 , , , 37231 3323 5 p. p. NN 37231 3323 6 114 114 CD 37231 3323 7 f. f. NNP 37231 3323 8 Cf Cf NNP 37231 3323 9 . . . 37231 3324 1 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3324 2 , , , 37231 3324 3 xxvii xxvii NN 37231 3324 4 . . . 37231 3325 1 39 39 CD 37231 3325 2 - - HYPH 37231 3325 3 -43 -43 NNP 37231 3325 4 ; ; : 37231 3325 5 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3325 6 xv xv NNP 37231 3325 7 . . . 37231 3326 1 29 29 CD 37231 3326 2 - - HYPH 37231 3326 3 -32 -32 NN 37231 3326 4 ; ; : 37231 3326 5 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3326 6 xxiii xxiii NN 37231 3326 7 . . . 37231 3327 1 34 34 CD 37231 3327 2 - - HYPH 37231 3327 3 -37 -37 NN 37231 3327 4 . . . 37231 3328 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3328 2 334 334 CD 37231 3328 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3328 4 contained contain VBN 37231 3328 5 in in IN 37231 3328 6 the the DT 37231 3328 7 first first JJ 37231 3328 8 of of IN 37231 3328 9 these these DT 37231 3328 10 passages passage NNS 37231 3328 11 is be VBZ 37231 3328 12 altogether altogether RB 37231 3328 13 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3328 14 to to IN 37231 3328 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3328 16 : : : 37231 3328 17 " " `` 37231 3328 18 Let let VB 37231 3328 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3328 20 who who WP 37231 3328 21 raised raise VBD 37231 3328 22 the the DT 37231 3328 23 dead dead JJ 37231 3328 24 deliver deliver VB 37231 3328 25 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3328 26 " " '' 37231 3328 27 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3328 28 --Greek--];(1 --greek--];(1 NN 37231 3328 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3328 30 and and CC 37231 3328 31 even even RB 37231 3328 32 if if IN 37231 3328 33 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3328 34 did do VBD 37231 3328 35 not not RB 37231 3328 36 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3328 37 indicate indicate VB 37231 3328 38 a a DT 37231 3328 39 written write VBN 37231 3328 40 source source NN 37231 3328 41 , , , 37231 3328 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3328 43 would would MD 37231 3328 44 not not RB 37231 3328 45 be be VB 37231 3328 46 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 3328 47 to to TO 37231 3328 48 suppose suppose VB 37231 3328 49 that that IN 37231 3328 50 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3328 51 should should MD 37231 3328 52 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3328 53 for for IN 37231 3328 54 the the DT 37231 3328 55 first first JJ 37231 3328 56 time time NN 37231 3328 57 record record NN 37231 3328 58 words word NNS 37231 3328 59 to to TO 37231 3328 60 which which WDT 37231 3328 61 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3328 62 refers refer VBZ 37231 3328 63 as as IN 37231 3328 64 the the DT 37231 3328 65 fulfilment fulfilment NN 37231 3328 66 of of IN 37231 3328 67 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 3328 68 . . . 37231 3329 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3329 2 2 2 LS 37231 3329 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3329 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3329 5 would would MD 37231 3329 6 be be VB 37231 3329 7 still still RB 37231 3329 8 more more RBR 37231 3329 9 ineffectual ineffectual JJ 37231 3329 10 to to TO 37231 3329 11 endeavour endeavour VB 37231 3329 12 to to TO 37231 3329 13 remove remove VB 37231 3329 14 the the DT 37231 3329 15 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 3329 16 presented present VBN 37231 3329 17 by by IN 37231 3329 18 such such PDT 37231 3329 19 a a DT 37231 3329 20 variation variation NN 37231 3329 21 by by IN 37231 3329 22 attributing attribute VBG 37231 3329 23 the the DT 37231 3329 24 words word NNS 37231 3329 25 to to IN 37231 3329 26 tradition tradition NN 37231 3329 27 , , , 37231 3329 28 at at IN 37231 3329 29 the the DT 37231 3329 30 same same JJ 37231 3329 31 time time NN 37231 3329 32 that that IN 37231 3329 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3329 34 is be VBZ 37231 3329 35 asserted assert VBN 37231 3329 36 that that IN 37231 3329 37 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3329 38 's 's POS 37231 3329 39 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3329 40 were be VBD 37231 3329 41 actually actually RB 37231 3329 42 identical identical JJ 37231 3329 43 with with IN 37231 3329 44 the the DT 37231 3329 45 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3329 46 . . . 37231 3330 1 No no DT 37231 3330 2 aberration aberration NN 37231 3330 3 of of IN 37231 3330 4 memory memory NN 37231 3330 5 could could MD 37231 3330 6 account account VB 37231 3330 7 for for IN 37231 3330 8 such such PDT 37231 3330 9 a a DT 37231 3330 10 variation variation NN 37231 3330 11 , , , 37231 3330 12 and and CC 37231 3330 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3330 14 is be VBZ 37231 3330 15 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3330 16 that that IN 37231 3330 17 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3330 18 should should MD 37231 3330 19 prefer prefer VB 37231 3330 20 tradition tradition NN 37231 3330 21 regarding regard VBG 37231 3330 22 a a DT 37231 3330 23 form form NN 37231 3330 24 of of IN 37231 3330 25 words word NNS 37231 3330 26 , , , 37231 3330 27 so so RB 37231 3330 28 liable liable JJ 37231 3330 29 to to TO 37231 3330 30 error error NN 37231 3330 31 and and CC 37231 3330 32 alteration alteration NN 37231 3330 33 , , , 37231 3330 34 with with IN 37231 3330 35 written write VBN 37231 3330 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3330 37 within within IN 37231 3330 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3330 39 reach reach NN 37231 3330 40 . . . 37231 3331 1 Besides besides RB 37231 3331 2 , , , 37231 3331 3 to to TO 37231 3331 4 argue argue VB 37231 3331 5 that that IN 37231 3331 6 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3331 7 affirmed affirm VBD 37231 3331 8 that that IN 37231 3331 9 the the DT 37231 3331 10 truth truth NN 37231 3331 11 of of IN 37231 3331 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3331 13 statement statement NN 37231 3331 14 could could MD 37231 3331 15 be be VB 37231 3331 16 ascertained ascertain VBN 37231 3331 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3331 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3331 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3331 20 , , , 37231 3331 21 whilst whilst IN 37231 3331 22 the the DT 37231 3331 23 words word NNS 37231 3331 24 which which WDT 37231 3331 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3331 26 states state VBZ 37231 3331 27 to to TO 37231 3331 28 have have VB 37231 3331 29 been be VBN 37231 3331 30 spoken speak VBN 37231 3331 31 were be VBD 37231 3331 32 not not RB 37231 3331 33 actually actually RB 37231 3331 34 recorded record VBN 37231 3331 35 , , , 37231 3331 36 would would MD 37231 3331 37 be be VB 37231 3331 38 against against IN 37231 3331 39 all all DT 37231 3331 40 reason reason NN 37231 3331 41 . . . 37231 3332 1 The the DT 37231 3332 2 second second JJ 37231 3332 3 of of IN 37231 3332 4 the the DT 37231 3332 5 mocking mocking NN 37231 3332 6 speeches speech NNS 37231 3332 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3332 8 3 3 CD 37231 3332 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3332 10 of of IN 37231 3332 11 the the DT 37231 3332 12 lookers looker NNS 37231 3332 13 - - HYPH 37231 3332 14 on on RP 37231 3332 15 is be VBZ 37231 3332 16 referred refer VBN 37231 3332 17 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3332 18 to to IN 37231 3332 19 the the DT 37231 3332 20 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3332 21 of of IN 37231 3332 22 the the DT 37231 3332 23 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3332 24 , , , 37231 3332 25 but but CC 37231 3332 26 is be VBZ 37231 3332 27 also also RB 37231 3332 28 , , , 37231 3332 29 with with IN 37231 3332 30 the the DT 37231 3332 31 accompanying accompanying JJ 37231 3332 32 description description NN 37231 3332 33 , , , 37231 3332 34 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3332 35 1 1 CD 37231 3332 36 The the DT 37231 3332 37 nearest near JJS 37231 3332 38 parallel parallel NN 37231 3332 39 in in IN 37231 3332 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3332 41 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3332 42 is be VBZ 37231 3332 43 in in IN 37231 3332 44 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3332 45 xxiii xxiii NN 37231 3332 46 . . . 37231 3333 1 35 35 CD 37231 3333 2 . . . 37231 3334 1 " " `` 37231 3334 2 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3334 3 saved save VBD 37231 3334 4 others other NNS 37231 3334 5 , , , 37231 3334 6 let let VB 37231 3334 7 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3334 8 save save VB 37231 3334 9 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3334 10 if if IN 37231 3334 11 this this DT 37231 3334 12 man man NN 37231 3334 13 be be VB 37231 3334 14 the the DT 37231 3334 15 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3334 16 of of IN 37231 3334 17 God God NNP 37231 3334 18 , , , 37231 3334 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3334 20 chosen choose VBN 37231 3334 21 . . . 37231 3334 22 " " '' 37231 3335 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3335 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3335 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3335 4 3 3 CD 37231 3335 5 Semisch Semisch NNP 37231 3335 6 argues argue VBZ 37231 3335 7 that that IN 37231 3335 8 both both DT 37231 3335 9 forms form NNS 37231 3335 10 are be VBP 37231 3335 11 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3335 12 of of IN 37231 3335 13 the the DT 37231 3335 14 same same JJ 37231 3335 15 sentence sentence NN 37231 3335 16 , , , 37231 3335 17 and and CC 37231 3335 18 that that IN 37231 3335 19 there there EX 37231 3335 20 is be VBZ 37231 3335 21 consequently consequently RB 37231 3335 22 a a DT 37231 3335 23 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 3335 24 in in IN 37231 3335 25 the the DT 37231 3335 26 very very JJ 37231 3335 27 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3335 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3335 29 ; ; : 37231 3335 30 but but CC 37231 3335 31 there there EX 37231 3335 32 can can MD 37231 3335 33 be be VB 37231 3335 34 no no RB 37231 3335 35 doubt doubt RB 37231 3335 36 whatever whatever WDT 37231 3335 37 that that IN 37231 3335 38 the the DT 37231 3335 39 two two CD 37231 3335 40 phrases phrase NNS 37231 3335 41 are be VBP 37231 3335 42 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3335 43 parts part NNS 37231 3335 44 of of IN 37231 3335 45 the the DT 37231 3335 46 mockery mockery NN 37231 3335 47 , , , 37231 3335 48 and and CC 37231 3335 49 the the DT 37231 3335 50 very very RB 37231 3335 51 same same JJ 37231 3335 52 separation separation NN 37231 3335 53 and and CC 37231 3335 54 variation variation NN 37231 3335 55 occur occur VBP 37231 3335 56 in in IN 37231 3335 57 each each DT 37231 3335 58 of of IN 37231 3335 59 the the DT 37231 3335 60 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3335 61 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3335 62 . . . 37231 3336 1 Die Die NNP 37231 3336 2 ap ap NNP 37231 3336 3 . . . 37231 3337 1 Denkw Denkw NNP 37231 3337 2 . . . 37231 3338 1 Mart Mart NNP 37231 3338 2 . . . 37231 3339 1 Just just RB 37231 3339 2 . . . 37231 3339 3 , , , 37231 3339 4 p. p. NN 37231 3339 5 282 282 CD 37231 3339 6 ; ; : 37231 3339 7 cf cf NN 37231 3339 8 . . . 37231 3340 1 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 3340 2 , , , 37231 3340 3 Die die VB 37231 3340 4 Ew Ew NNP 37231 3340 5 . . . 37231 3341 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3341 2 's 's POS 37231 3341 3 , , , 37231 3341 4 p. p. NN 37231 3341 5 244 244 CD 37231 3341 6 . . . 37231 3342 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3342 2 335 335 CD 37231 3342 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3342 4 to to IN 37231 3342 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3342 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3342 7 . . . 37231 3343 1 The the DT 37231 3343 2 nearest near JJS 37231 3343 3 approach approach NN 37231 3343 4 to to IN 37231 3343 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3343 6 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3343 7 in in IN 37231 3343 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3343 9 first first JJ 37231 3343 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3343 11 , , , 37231 3343 12 and and CC 37231 3343 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3343 14 subjoin subjoin VBP 37231 3343 15 both both DT 37231 3343 16 passages passage NNS 37231 3343 17 for for IN 37231 3343 18 comparison comparison NN 37231 3343 19 : : : 37231 3343 20 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3343 21 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3343 22 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3343 23 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3343 24 is be VBZ 37231 3343 25 evident evident JJ 37231 3343 26 that that IN 37231 3343 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3343 28 's 's POS 37231 3343 29 version version NN 37231 3343 30 is be VBZ 37231 3343 31 quite quite RB 37231 3343 32 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3343 33 from from IN 37231 3343 34 this this DT 37231 3343 35 , , , 37231 3343 36 and and CC 37231 3343 37 can can MD 37231 3343 38 not not RB 37231 3343 39 have have VB 37231 3343 40 been be VBN 37231 3343 41 taken take VBN 37231 3343 42 from from IN 37231 3343 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3343 44 Gospels,(2 Gospels,(2 NNP 37231 3343 45 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3343 46 although although IN 37231 3343 47 professedly professedly RB 37231 3343 48 derived derive VBN 37231 3343 49 from from IN 37231 3343 50 the the DT 37231 3343 51 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3343 52 of of IN 37231 3343 53 the the DT 37231 3343 54 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3343 55 . . . 37231 3344 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3344 2 likewise likewise RB 37231 3344 3 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3344 4 the the DT 37231 3344 5 cry cry NN 37231 3344 6 of of IN 37231 3344 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3344 8 on on IN 37231 3344 9 the the DT 37231 3344 10 Cross Cross NNP 37231 3344 11 , , , 37231 3344 12 " " `` 37231 3344 13 O o UH 37231 3344 14 God God NNP 37231 3344 15 , , , 37231 3344 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3344 17 God God NNP 37231 3344 18 , , , 37231 3344 19 why why WRB 37231 3344 20 hast hast NNP 37231 3344 21 thou thou NNP 37231 3344 22 forsaken forsake VBD 37231 3344 23 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3344 24 ? ? . 37231 3344 25 " " '' 37231 3345 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3345 2 --Greek--];(3 --Greek--];(3 NFP 37231 3345 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3345 4 as as IN 37231 3345 5 a a DT 37231 3345 6 fulfilment fulfilment NN 37231 3345 7 of of IN 37231 3345 8 the the DT 37231 3345 9 words word NNS 37231 3345 10 of of IN 37231 3345 11 the the DT 37231 3345 12 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 3345 13 , , , 37231 3345 14 which which WDT 37231 3345 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3345 16 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3345 17 here here RB 37231 3345 18 , , , 37231 3345 19 and and CC 37231 3345 20 elsewhere,(4 elsewhere,(4 NNP 37231 3345 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3345 22 with with IN 37231 3345 23 the the DT 37231 3345 24 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3345 25 addition addition NN 37231 3345 26 of of IN 37231 3345 27 the the DT 37231 3345 28 Septuagint Septuagint NNP 37231 3345 29 version version NN 37231 3345 30 , , , 37231 3345 31 " " `` 37231 3345 32 attend attend VBP 37231 3345 33 to to IN 37231 3345 34 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3345 35 " " '' 37231 3345 36 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3345 37 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3345 38 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3345 39 , , , 37231 3345 40 which which WDT 37231 3345 41 , , , 37231 3345 42 however however RB 37231 3345 43 , , , 37231 3345 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3345 45 omits omit VBZ 37231 3345 46 when when WRB 37231 3345 47 giving give VBG 37231 3345 48 the the DT 37231 3345 49 cry cry NN 37231 3345 50 of of IN 37231 3345 51 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3345 52 , , , 37231 3345 53 thereby thereby RB 37231 3345 54 showing show VBG 37231 3345 55 that that IN 37231 3345 56 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3345 57 follows follow VBZ 37231 3345 58 a a DT 37231 3345 59 written write VBN 37231 3345 60 source source NN 37231 3345 61 which which WDT 37231 3345 62 did do VBD 37231 3345 63 not not RB 37231 3345 64 contain contain VB 37231 3345 65 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3345 66 , , , 37231 3345 67 for for IN 37231 3345 68 the the DT 37231 3345 69 quotation quotation NN 37231 3345 70 of of IN 37231 3345 71 the the DT 37231 3345 72 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 3345 73 , , , 37231 3345 74 and and CC 37231 3345 75 of of IN 37231 3345 76 { { -LRB- 37231 3345 77 336 336 CD 37231 3345 78 } } -RRB- 37231 3345 79 the the DT 37231 3345 80 cry cry NN 37231 3345 81 which which WDT 37231 3345 82 is be VBZ 37231 3345 83 cited cite VBN 37231 3345 84 to to TO 37231 3345 85 show show VB 37231 3345 86 that that IN 37231 3345 87 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3345 88 refers refer VBZ 37231 3345 89 to to IN 37231 3345 90 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3345 91 , , , 37231 3345 92 immediately immediately RB 37231 3345 93 follow follow VBP 37231 3345 94 each each DT 37231 3345 95 other other JJ 37231 3345 96 . . . 37231 3346 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3346 2 apparently apparently RB 37231 3346 3 knows know VBZ 37231 3346 4 nothing nothing NN 37231 3346 5 whatever whatever WDT 37231 3346 6 of of IN 37231 3346 7 the the DT 37231 3346 8 Chaldaic Chaldaic NNP 37231 3346 9 cry cry NN 37231 3346 10 , , , 37231 3346 11 " " '' 37231 3346 12 Eli eli FW 37231 3346 13 , , , 37231 3346 14 Eli Eli NNP 37231 3346 15 , , , 37231 3346 16 lama lama NNP 37231 3346 17 sabacthani sabacthani NNP 37231 3346 18 " " '' 37231 3346 19 of of IN 37231 3346 20 the the DT 37231 3346 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3346 22 . . . 37231 3347 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3347 2 1 1 LS 37231 3347 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3347 4 The the DT 37231 3347 5 first first JJ 37231 3347 6 and and CC 37231 3347 7 second second JJ 37231 3347 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3347 9 give give VBP 37231 3347 10 the the DT 37231 3347 11 words word NNS 37231 3347 12 of of IN 37231 3347 13 the the DT 37231 3347 14 cry cry NN 37231 3347 15 from from IN 37231 3347 16 the the DT 37231 3347 17 Chaldaic Chaldaic NNP 37231 3347 18 differently differently RB 37231 3347 19 from from IN 37231 3347 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3347 21 , , , 37231 3347 22 from from IN 37231 3347 23 the the DT 37231 3347 24 version version NN 37231 3347 25 of of IN 37231 3347 26 the the DT 37231 3347 27 LXX LXX NNP 37231 3347 28 . . . 37231 3347 29 , , , 37231 3347 30 and and CC 37231 3347 31 from from IN 37231 3347 32 each each DT 37231 3347 33 other other JJ 37231 3347 34 . . . 37231 3348 1 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3348 2 xxvii xxvii NN 37231 3348 3 . . . 37231 3349 1 46 46 CD 37231 3349 2 , , , 37231 3349 3 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3349 4 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3349 5 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3349 6 the the DT 37231 3349 7 third third JJ 37231 3349 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3349 9 makes make VBZ 37231 3349 10 no no DT 37231 3349 11 mention mention NN 37231 3349 12 at at RB 37231 3349 13 all all DT 37231 3349 14 of of IN 37231 3349 15 this this DT 37231 3349 16 cry cry NN 37231 3349 17 , , , 37231 3349 18 but but CC 37231 3349 19 instead instead RB 37231 3349 20 has have VBZ 37231 3349 21 one one CD 37231 3349 22 altogether altogether RB 37231 3349 23 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3349 24 to to IN 37231 3349 25 the the DT 37231 3349 26 other other JJ 37231 3349 27 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3349 28 : : : 37231 3349 29 " " `` 37231 3349 30 And and CC 37231 3349 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3349 32 cried cry VBD 37231 3349 33 with with IN 37231 3349 34 a a DT 37231 3349 35 loud loud JJ 37231 3349 36 voice voice NN 37231 3349 37 , , , 37231 3349 38 and and CC 37231 3349 39 said say VBD 37231 3349 40 : : : 37231 3349 41 Father Father NNP 37231 3349 42 , , , 37231 3349 43 into into IN 37231 3349 44 thy thy PRP$ 37231 3349 45 hands hand NNS 37231 3349 46 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3349 47 commend commend VBP 37231 3349 48 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3349 49 spirit spirit NN 37231 3349 50 : : : 37231 3349 51 and and CC 37231 3349 52 having have VBG 37231 3349 53 said say VBD 37231 3349 54 this this DT 37231 3349 55 , , , 37231 3349 56 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3349 57 expired expire VBD 37231 3349 58 . . . 37231 3350 1 " " `` 37231 3350 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3350 3 2 2 LS 37231 3350 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3350 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3350 6 has have VBZ 37231 3350 7 this this DT 37231 3350 8 cry cry NN 37231 3350 9 also also RB 37231 3350 10 , , , 37231 3350 11 and and CC 37231 3350 12 in in IN 37231 3350 13 the the DT 37231 3350 14 same same JJ 37231 3350 15 form form NN 37231 3350 16 as as IN 37231 3350 17 the the DT 37231 3350 18 third third JJ 37231 3350 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3350 20 . . . 37231 3351 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3351 2 says say VBZ 37231 3351 3 : : : 37231 3351 4 " " `` 37231 3351 5 For for IN 37231 3351 6 when when WRB 37231 3351 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3351 8 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3351 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3351 10 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3351 11 was be VBD 37231 3351 12 giving give VBG 37231 3351 13 up up RP 37231 3351 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3351 15 spirit spirit NN 37231 3351 16 on on IN 37231 3351 17 the the DT 37231 3351 18 cross cross NN 37231 3351 19 , , , 37231 3351 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3351 21 said say VBD 37231 3351 22 : : : 37231 3351 23 ' ' '' 37231 3351 24 Father Father NNP 37231 3351 25 , , , 37231 3351 26 into into IN 37231 3351 27 thy thy PRP$ 37231 3351 28 hands hand NNS 37231 3351 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3351 30 commend commend VBP 37231 3351 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3351 32 spirit spirit NN 37231 3351 33 , , , 37231 3351 34 ' ' '' 37231 3351 35 as as IN 37231 3351 36 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3351 37 have have VBP 37231 3351 38 also also RB 37231 3351 39 learned learn VBN 37231 3351 40 from from IN 37231 3351 41 the the DT 37231 3351 42 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3351 43 . . . 37231 3352 1 " " `` 37231 3352 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3352 3 3 3 LS 37231 3352 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3352 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3352 6 's 's POS 37231 3352 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3352 8 , , , 37231 3352 9 therefore therefore RB 37231 3352 10 , , , 37231 3352 11 contained contain VBD 37231 3352 12 both both DT 37231 3352 13 cries cry NNS 37231 3352 14 , , , 37231 3352 15 and and CC 37231 3352 16 as as IN 37231 3352 17 even even RB 37231 3352 18 the the DT 37231 3352 19 first first JJ 37231 3352 20 two two CD 37231 3352 21 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3352 22 mention mention VBP 37231 3352 23 a a DT 37231 3352 24 second second JJ 37231 3352 25 cry cry NN 37231 3352 26 of of IN 37231 3352 27 Jesus(4 jesus(4 NN 37231 3352 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3352 29 without without IN 37231 3352 30 , , , 37231 3352 31 however however RB 37231 3352 32 , , , 37231 3352 33 giving give VBG 37231 3352 34 the the DT 37231 3352 35 words word NNS 37231 3352 36 , , , 37231 3352 37 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3352 38 is be VBZ 37231 3352 39 not not RB 37231 3352 40 surprising surprising JJ 37231 3352 41 that that IN 37231 3352 42 other other JJ 37231 3352 43 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3352 44 should should MD 37231 3352 45 have have VB 37231 3352 46 existed exist VBN 37231 3352 47 which which WDT 37231 3352 48 included include VBD 37231 3352 49 both both DT 37231 3352 50 . . . 37231 3353 1 Even even RB 37231 3353 2 if if IN 37231 3353 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3353 4 had have VBD 37231 3353 5 no no DT 37231 3353 6 trace trace NN 37231 3353 7 of of IN 37231 3353 8 this this DT 37231 3353 9 cry cry NN 37231 3353 10 in in IN 37231 3353 11 any any DT 37231 3353 12 other other JJ 37231 3353 13 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3353 14 work work NN 37231 3353 15 , , , 37231 3353 16 there there EX 37231 3353 17 would would MD 37231 3353 18 be be VB 37231 3353 19 no no DT 37231 3353 20 ground ground NN 37231 3353 21 for for IN 37231 3353 22 asserting assert VBG 37231 3353 23 that that IN 37231 3353 24 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3353 25 must must MD 37231 3353 26 have have VB 37231 3353 27 derived derive VBN 37231 3353 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3353 29 from from IN 37231 3353 30 the the DT 37231 3353 31 third third JJ 37231 3353 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3353 33 , , , 37231 3353 34 for for IN 37231 3353 35 if if IN 37231 3353 36 there there EX 37231 3353 37 be be VB 37231 3353 38 any any DT 37231 3353 39 historical historical JJ 37231 3353 40 truth truth NN 37231 3353 41 in in IN 37231 3353 42 the the DT 37231 3353 43 statement statement NN 37231 3353 44 that that IN 37231 3353 45 these these DT 37231 3353 46 words word NNS 37231 3353 47 were be VBD 37231 3353 48 actually actually RB 37231 3353 49 spoken speak VBN 37231 3353 50 by by IN 37231 3353 51 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3353 52 , , , 37231 3353 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3353 54 follows follow VBZ 37231 3353 55 of of IN 37231 3353 56 course course NN 37231 3353 57 that that WDT 37231 3353 58 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3353 59 may may MD 37231 3353 60 have have VB 37231 3353 61 been be VBN 37231 3353 62 , , , 37231 3353 63 and and CC 37231 3353 64 probably probably RB 37231 3353 65 were be VBD 37231 3353 66 , , , 37231 3353 67 reported report VBN 37231 3353 68 in in IN 37231 3353 69 a a DT 37231 3353 70 dozen dozen NN 37231 3353 71 Christian christian JJ 37231 3353 72 writings writing NNS 37231 3353 73 now now RB 37231 3353 74 { { -LRB- 37231 3353 75 337 337 CD 37231 3353 76 } } -RRB- 37231 3353 77 no no RB 37231 3353 78 longer long RBR 37231 3353 79 extent extent NN 37231 3353 80 , , , 37231 3353 81 and and CC 37231 3353 82 in in IN 37231 3353 83 all all DT 37231 3353 84 probability probability NN 37231 3353 85 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3353 86 existed exist VBD 37231 3353 87 in in IN 37231 3353 88 some some DT 37231 3353 89 of of IN 37231 3353 90 the the DT 37231 3353 91 many many JJ 37231 3353 92 works work NNS 37231 3353 93 referred refer VBD 37231 3353 94 to to IN 37231 3353 95 in in IN 37231 3353 96 the the DT 37231 3353 97 prologue prologue NN 37231 3353 98 to to IN 37231 3353 99 the the DT 37231 3353 100 third third JJ 37231 3353 101 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3353 102 . . . 37231 3354 1 Both both DT 37231 3354 2 cries cry NNS 37231 3354 3 , , , 37231 3354 4 however however RB 37231 3354 5 , , , 37231 3354 6 are be VBP 37231 3354 7 given give VBN 37231 3354 8 in in IN 37231 3354 9 the the DT 37231 3354 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3354 11 of of IN 37231 3354 12 Nieodemus Nieodemus NNP 37231 3354 13 , , , 37231 3354 14 or or CC 37231 3354 15 Gesta Gesta NNP 37231 3354 16 Pilati Pilati NNP 37231 3354 17 , , , 37231 3354 18 to to TO 37231 3354 19 which which WDT 37231 3354 20 reference reference NN 37231 3354 21 has have VBZ 37231 3354 22 already already RB 37231 3354 23 so so RB 37231 3354 24 frequently frequently RB 37231 3354 25 been be VBN 37231 3354 26 made make VBN 37231 3354 27 . . . 37231 3355 1 In in IN 37231 3355 2 the the DT 37231 3355 3 Greek greek JJ 37231 3355 4 versions version NNS 37231 3355 5 edited edit VBN 37231 3355 6 by by IN 37231 3355 7 Teschendorf Teschendorf NNP 37231 3355 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3355 9 find find VBP 37231 3355 10 only only RB 37231 3355 11 the the DT 37231 3355 12 form form NN 37231 3355 13 contained contain VBN 37231 3355 14 in in IN 37231 3355 15 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3355 16 . . . 37231 3356 1 In in IN 37231 3356 2 the the DT 37231 3356 3 Codex Codex NNP 37231 3356 4 A A NNP 37231 3356 5 , , , 37231 3356 6 the the DT 37231 3356 7 passage passage NN 37231 3356 8 reads read VBZ 37231 3356 9 : : : 37231 3356 10 " " `` 37231 3356 11 And and CC 37231 3356 12 crying cry VBG 37231 3356 13 with with IN 37231 3356 14 a a DT 37231 3356 15 loud loud JJ 37231 3356 16 voice voice NN 37231 3356 17 , , , 37231 3356 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3356 19 said say VBD 37231 3356 20 : : : 37231 3356 21 Father Father NNP 37231 3356 22 , , , 37231 3356 23 Baddach Baddach NNP 37231 3356 24 ephkid ephkid VBD 37231 3356 25 rouchi rouchi NNP 37231 3356 26 , , , 37231 3356 27 that that RB 37231 3356 28 is is RB 37231 3356 29 , , , 37231 3356 30 interpreted interpret VBN 37231 3356 31 : : : 37231 3356 32 ' ' `` 37231 3356 33 into into IN 37231 3356 34 thy thy PRP$ 37231 3356 35 hands hand NNS 37231 3356 36 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3356 37 commend commend VBP 37231 3356 38 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3356 39 spirit spirit NN 37231 3356 40 ; ; : 37231 3356 41 ' ' '' 37231 3356 42 and and CC 37231 3356 43 having have VBG 37231 3356 44 said say VBD 37231 3356 45 this this DT 37231 3356 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3356 47 gave give VBD 37231 3356 48 up up RP 37231 3356 49 the the DT 37231 3356 50 ghost ghost NN 37231 3356 51 . . . 37231 3357 1 " " `` 37231 3357 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3357 3 l l NN 37231 3357 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3357 5 In in IN 37231 3357 6 the the DT 37231 3357 7 Codex Codex NNP 37231 3357 8 B B NNP 37231 3357 9 , , , 37231 3357 10 the the DT 37231 3357 11 text text NN 37231 3357 12 is be VBZ 37231 3357 13 : : : 37231 3357 14 " " `` 37231 3357 15 Then then RB 37231 3357 16 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3357 17 having have VBG 37231 3357 18 called call VBN 37231 3357 19 out out RP 37231 3357 20 with with IN 37231 3357 21 a a DT 37231 3357 22 loud loud JJ 37231 3357 23 voice voice NN 37231 3357 24 : : : 37231 3357 25 ' ' '' 37231 3357 26 Father Father NNP 37231 3357 27 , , , 37231 3357 28 into into IN 37231 3357 29 thy thy PRP$ 37231 3357 30 hands hand NNS 37231 3357 31 will will MD 37231 3357 32 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3357 33 commend commend VB 37231 3357 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3357 35 spirit spirit NN 37231 3357 36 , , , 37231 3357 37 ' ' '' 37231 3357 38 expired expire VBD 37231 3357 39 . . . 37231 3358 1 " " `` 37231 3358 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3358 3 2 2 LS 37231 3358 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3358 5 In in IN 37231 3358 6 the the DT 37231 3358 7 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3358 8 Latin latin JJ 37231 3358 9 version version NN 37231 3358 10 , , , 37231 3358 11 however however RB 37231 3358 12 , , , 37231 3358 13 both both DT 37231 3358 14 cries cry NNS 37231 3358 15 are be VBP 37231 3358 16 given give VBN 37231 3358 17 : : : 37231 3358 18 " " `` 37231 3358 19 And and CC 37231 3358 20 about about IN 37231 3358 21 the the DT 37231 3358 22 ninth ninth JJ 37231 3358 23 hour hour NN 37231 3358 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3358 25 cried cry VBD 37231 3358 26 with with IN 37231 3358 27 a a DT 37231 3358 28 loud loud JJ 37231 3358 29 voice voice NN 37231 3358 30 , , , 37231 3358 31 saying say VBG 37231 3358 32 , , , 37231 3358 33 Hely hely RB 37231 3358 34 , , , 37231 3358 35 Hely hely RB 37231 3358 36 , , , 37231 3358 37 lama lama NNP 37231 3358 38 zabacthani zabacthani NNP 37231 3358 39 , , , 37231 3358 40 which which WDT 37231 3358 41 interpreted interpret VBD 37231 3358 42 is be VBZ 37231 3358 43 : : : 37231 3358 44 ' ' `` 37231 3358 45 My -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3358 46 God God NNP 37231 3358 47 , , , 37231 3358 48 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3358 49 God God NNP 37231 3358 50 , , , 37231 3358 51 why why WRB 37231 3358 52 hast hast NNP 37231 3358 53 thou thou NNP 37231 3358 54 forsaken forsake VBD 37231 3358 55 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3358 56 . . . 37231 3358 57 ' ' '' 37231 3359 1 And and CC 37231 3359 2 after after IN 37231 3359 3 this this DT 37231 3359 4 , , , 37231 3359 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3359 6 said say VBD 37231 3359 7 : : : 37231 3359 8 ' ' '' 37231 3359 9 Father Father NNP 37231 3359 10 , , , 37231 3359 11 into into IN 37231 3359 12 thy thy PRP$ 37231 3359 13 hands hand NNS 37231 3359 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3359 15 commend commend VBP 37231 3359 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3359 17 spirit spirit NN 37231 3359 18 ' ' '' 37231 3359 19 : : : 37231 3359 20 and and CC 37231 3359 21 saying say VBG 37231 3359 22 this this DT 37231 3359 23 , , , 37231 3359 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3359 25 gave give VBD 37231 3359 26 up up RP 37231 3359 27 the the DT 37231 3359 28 ghost ghost NN 37231 3359 29 . . . 37231 3360 1 " " `` 37231 3360 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3360 3 3 3 CD 37231 3360 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3360 5 One one CD 37231 3360 6 of of IN 37231 3360 7 the the DT 37231 3360 8 Codices codex NNS 37231 3360 9 of of IN 37231 3360 10 the the DT 37231 3360 11 same same JJ 37231 3360 12 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3360 13 work work NN 37231 3360 14 likewise likewise RB 37231 3360 15 gives give VBZ 37231 3360 16 the the DT 37231 3360 17 taunting taunting NN 37231 3360 18 speeches speech NNS 37231 3360 19 of of IN 37231 3360 20 the the DT 37231 3360 21 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3360 22 in in IN 37231 3360 23 a a DT 37231 3360 24 form form NN 37231 3360 25 more more RBR 37231 3360 26 nearly nearly RB 37231 3360 27 approaching approach VBG 37231 3360 28 that that DT 37231 3360 29 of of IN 37231 3360 30 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3360 31 's 's POS 37231 3360 32 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3360 33 { { -LRB- 37231 3360 34 338 338 CD 37231 3360 35 } } -RRB- 37231 3360 36 than than IN 37231 3360 37 any any DT 37231 3360 38 found find VBN 37231 3360 39 in in IN 37231 3360 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3360 41 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3360 42 . . . 37231 3361 1 " " `` 37231 3361 2 And and CC 37231 3361 3 the the DT 37231 3361 4 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3361 5 that that WDT 37231 3361 6 stood stand VBD 37231 3361 7 and and CC 37231 3361 8 looked look VBD 37231 3361 9 ridiculed ridicule VBD 37231 3361 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3361 11 , , , 37231 3361 12 and and CC 37231 3361 13 said say VBD 37231 3361 14 : : : 37231 3361 15 If if IN 37231 3361 16 thou thou NNP 37231 3361 17 saidst saidst NNP 37231 3361 18 truly truly RB 37231 3361 19 that that WDT 37231 3361 20 thou thou NNP 37231 3361 21 art art NN 37231 3361 22 the the DT 37231 3361 23 Son Son NNP 37231 3361 24 of of IN 37231 3361 25 God God NNP 37231 3361 26 , , , 37231 3361 27 come come VB 37231 3361 28 down down RP 37231 3361 29 from from IN 37231 3361 30 the the DT 37231 3361 31 cross cross NN 37231 3361 32 , , , 37231 3361 33 and and CC 37231 3361 34 at at IN 37231 3361 35 once once RB 37231 3361 36 , , , 37231 3361 37 that that IN 37231 3361 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3361 39 may may MD 37231 3361 40 believe believe VB 37231 3361 41 in in IN 37231 3361 42 thee thee PRP 37231 3361 43 . . . 37231 3362 1 Others other NNS 37231 3362 2 ridiculing ridicule VBG 37231 3362 3 , , , 37231 3362 4 said say VBD 37231 3362 5 : : : 37231 3362 6 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3362 7 saved save VBD 37231 3362 8 others other NNS 37231 3362 9 , , , 37231 3362 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3362 11 healed heal VBD 37231 3362 12 others other NNS 37231 3362 13 , , , 37231 3362 14 and and CC 37231 3362 15 restored restore VBD 37231 3362 16 the the DT 37231 3362 17 sick sick JJ 37231 3362 18 , , , 37231 3362 19 the the DT 37231 3362 20 paralytic paralytic JJ 37231 3362 21 , , , 37231 3362 22 lepers leper NNS 37231 3362 23 , , , 37231 3362 24 demoniacs demoniacs NNP 37231 3362 25 , , , 37231 3362 26 the the DT 37231 3362 27 blind blind JJ 37231 3362 28 , , , 37231 3362 29 the the DT 37231 3362 30 lame lame NN 37231 3362 31 , , , 37231 3362 32 the the DT 37231 3362 33 dead dead JJ 37231 3362 34 , , , 37231 3362 35 and and CC 37231 3362 36 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3362 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3362 38 can can MD 37231 3362 39 not not RB 37231 3362 40 heal heal VB 37231 3362 41 . . . 37231 3363 1 " " `` 37231 3363 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3363 3 1 1 LS 37231 3363 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3363 5 The the DT 37231 3363 6 fact fact NN 37231 3363 7 that that IN 37231 3363 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3363 9 actually actually RB 37231 3363 10 refers refer VBZ 37231 3363 11 to to IN 37231 3363 12 certain certain JJ 37231 3363 13 Acta Acta NNP 37231 3363 14 Pilati Pilati NNP 37231 3363 15 in in IN 37231 3363 16 connection connection NN 37231 3363 17 with with IN 37231 3363 18 the the DT 37231 3363 19 Crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 3363 20 renders render VBZ 37231 3363 21 this this DT 37231 3363 22 coincidence coincidence NN 37231 3363 23 all all PDT 37231 3363 24 the the DT 37231 3363 25 more more RBR 37231 3363 26 important important JJ 37231 3363 27 . . . 37231 3364 1 Other other JJ 37231 3364 2 texts text NNS 37231 3364 3 of of IN 37231 3364 4 this this DT 37231 3364 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3364 6 read read VBD 37231 3364 7 : : : 37231 3364 8 " " `` 37231 3364 9 And and CC 37231 3364 10 the the DT 37231 3364 11 Chief Chief NNP 37231 3364 12 Priests Priests NNPS 37231 3364 13 , , , 37231 3364 14 and and CC 37231 3364 15 the the DT 37231 3364 16 rulers ruler NNS 37231 3364 17 with with IN 37231 3364 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3364 19 , , , 37231 3364 20 derided deride VBD 37231 3364 21 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3364 22 , , , 37231 3364 23 saying say VBG 37231 3364 24 : : : 37231 3364 25 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3364 26 saved save VBD 37231 3364 27 others other NNS 37231 3364 28 , , , 37231 3364 29 let let VB 37231 3364 30 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3364 31 save save VB 37231 3364 32 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3364 33 ; ; : 37231 3364 34 if if IN 37231 3364 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3364 36 is be VBZ 37231 3364 37 the the DT 37231 3364 38 Son Son NNP 37231 3364 39 of of IN 37231 3364 40 God God NNP 37231 3364 41 , , , 37231 3364 42 let let VB 37231 3364 43 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3364 44 come come VB 37231 3364 45 down down RP 37231 3364 46 from from IN 37231 3364 47 the the DT 37231 3364 48 cross cross NN 37231 3364 49 . . . 37231 3365 1 " " `` 37231 3365 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3365 3 2 2 LS 37231 3365 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3365 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3365 6 is be VBZ 37231 3365 7 clear clear JJ 37231 3365 8 from from IN 37231 3365 9 the the DT 37231 3365 10 whole whole NN 37231 3365 11 of of IN 37231 3365 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3365 13 's 's POS 37231 3365 14 treatment treatment NN 37231 3365 15 of of IN 37231 3365 16 the the DT 37231 3365 17 narrative narrative NN 37231 3365 18 , , , 37231 3365 19 that that IN 37231 3365 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3365 21 followed follow VBD 37231 3365 22 a a DT 37231 3365 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3365 24 adhering adhere VBG 37231 3365 25 more more RBR 37231 3365 26 closely closely RB 37231 3365 27 than than IN 37231 3365 28 the the DT 37231 3365 29 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3365 30 to to IN 37231 3365 31 the the DT 37231 3365 32 Psalm Psalm NNP 37231 3365 33 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3365 34 . . . 37231 3365 35 , , , 37231 3365 36 but but CC 37231 3365 37 yet yet RB 37231 3365 38 with with IN 37231 3365 39 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3365 40 variations variation NNS 37231 3365 41 from from IN 37231 3365 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3365 43 . . . 37231 3366 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3366 2 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3366 3 differ differ VBP 37231 3366 4 very very RB 37231 3366 5 much much RB 37231 3366 6 from from IN 37231 3366 7 each each DT 37231 3366 8 other other JJ 37231 3366 9 ; ; : 37231 3366 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3366 11 's 's POS 37231 3366 12 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3366 13 of of IN 37231 3366 14 the the DT 37231 3366 15 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3366 16 in in IN 37231 3366 17 like like JJ 37231 3366 18 manner manner NN 37231 3366 19 differed differ VBN 37231 3366 20 from from IN 37231 3366 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3366 22 . . . 37231 3367 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3367 2 had have VBD 37231 3367 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3367 4 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 3367 5 features feature NNS 37231 3367 6 clearly clearly RB 37231 3367 7 and and CC 37231 3367 8 sharply sharply RB 37231 3367 9 defined define VBN 37231 3367 10 . . . 37231 3368 1 In in IN 37231 3368 2 this this DT 37231 3368 3 way way NN 37231 3368 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3368 5 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3368 6 variations variation NNS 37231 3368 7 are be VBP 37231 3368 8 natural natural JJ 37231 3368 9 and and CC 37231 3368 10 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 3368 11 intelligible intelligible JJ 37231 3368 12 , , , 37231 3368 13 but but CC 37231 3368 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3368 15 become become VBP 37231 3368 16 totally totally RB 37231 3368 17 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 37231 3368 18 if if IN 37231 3368 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3368 20 be be VB 37231 3368 21 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3368 22 that that IN 37231 3368 23 , , , 37231 3368 24 having have VBG 37231 3368 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3368 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3368 27 for for IN 37231 3368 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3368 29 source source NN 37231 3368 30 , , , 37231 3368 31 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3368 32 thus thus RB 37231 3368 33 2 2 CD 37231 3368 34 Ev Ev NNP 37231 3368 35 . . . 37231 3369 1 Niood Niood NNP 37231 3369 2 . . . 37231 3369 3 , , , 37231 3369 4 Pars par NNS 37231 3369 5 . . . 37231 3370 1 I. I. NNP 37231 3371 1 A. A. NNP 37231 3371 2 x. x. NNP 37231 3371 3 ; ; : 37231 3371 4 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3371 5 Ev Ev NNP 37231 3371 6 . . . 37231 3372 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 37231 3372 2 . . . 37231 3372 3 , , , 37231 3372 4 p. p. NN 37231 3372 5 232 232 CD 37231 3372 6 ; ; : 37231 3372 7 cf cf NN 37231 3372 8 . . . 37231 3373 1 Thilo thilo JJ 37231 3373 2 . . . 37231 3374 1 Cod cod VB 37231 3374 2 . . . 37231 3375 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 37231 3375 2 . . . 37231 3376 1 N. N. NNP 37231 3376 2 T. T. NNP 37231 3376 3 , , , 37231 3376 4 p. p. NN 37231 3376 5 584 584 CD 37231 3376 6 ; ; : 37231 3376 7 Fabricius Fabricius NNP 37231 3376 8 , , , 37231 3376 9 Cod Cod NNP 37231 3376 10 . . . 37231 3377 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 37231 3377 2 . . . 37231 3378 1 N. N. NNP 37231 3378 2 T. T. NNP 37231 3378 3 , , , 37231 3378 4 i. i. NNP 37231 3378 5 p. p. NN 37231 3378 6 259 259 CD 37231 3378 7 ; ; : 37231 3378 8 Tiachendorf Tiachendorf NNP 37231 3378 9 ib ib IN 37231 3378 10 . . NNP 37231 3378 11 , , , 37231 3378 12 p. p. NN 37231 3378 13 340 340 CD 37231 3378 14 . . . 37231 3379 1 There there EX 37231 3379 2 are be VBP 37231 3379 3 differences difference NNS 37231 3379 4 between between IN 37231 3379 5 all all PDT 37231 3379 6 these these DT 37231 3379 7 texts text NNS 37231 3379 8 -- -- : 37231 3379 9 indeed indeed RB 37231 3379 10 there there EX 37231 3379 11 are be VBP 37231 3379 12 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 3379 13 two two CD 37231 3379 14 MSS MSS NNP 37231 3379 15 . . . 37231 3380 1 which which WDT 37231 3380 2 agree agree VBP 37231 3380 3 -- -- : 37231 3380 4 clearly clearly RB 37231 3380 5 indicating indicate VBG 37231 3380 6 that that WDT 37231 3380 7 wo wo MD 37231 3380 8 have have VB 37231 3380 9 now now RB 37231 3380 10 nothing nothing NN 37231 3380 11 but but IN 37231 3380 12 corrupt corrupt JJ 37231 3380 13 versions version NNS 37231 3380 14 of of IN 37231 3380 15 a a DT 37231 3380 16 more more RBR 37231 3380 17 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3380 18 text text NN 37231 3380 19 . . . 37231 3381 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3381 2 339 339 CD 37231 3381 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3381 4 persistently persistently RB 37231 3381 5 and and CC 37231 3381 6 in in IN 37231 3381 7 so so RB 37231 3381 8 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 3381 9 a a DT 37231 3381 10 way way NN 37231 3381 11 ignored ignore VBN 37231 3381 12 , , , 37231 3381 13 modified modify VBN 37231 3381 14 , , , 37231 3381 15 or or CC 37231 3381 16 contradicted contradict VBD 37231 3381 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3381 18 statements statement NNS 37231 3381 19 . . . 37231 3382 1 Upon upon IN 37231 3382 2 two two CD 37231 3382 3 occasions occasion NNS 37231 3382 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3382 5 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3382 6 states state VBZ 37231 3382 7 that that IN 37231 3382 8 the the DT 37231 3382 9 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3382 10 sent send VBD 37231 3382 11 persons person NNS 37231 3382 12 throughout throughout IN 37231 3382 13 the the DT 37231 3382 14 world world NN 37231 3382 15 to to TO 37231 3382 16 spread spread VB 37231 3382 17 calumnies calumny NNS 37231 3382 18 against against IN 37231 3382 19 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3382 20 . . . 37231 3383 1 " " `` 37231 3383 2 When when WRB 37231 3383 3 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 4 knew know VBD 37231 3383 5 that that IN 37231 3383 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 7 had have VBD 37231 3383 8 risen rise VBN 37231 3383 9 from from IN 37231 3383 10 the the DT 37231 3383 11 dead dead NN 37231 3383 12 , , , 37231 3383 13 and and CC 37231 3383 14 ascended ascend VBN 37231 3383 15 into into IN 37231 3383 16 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3383 17 , , , 37231 3383 18 as as IN 37231 3383 19 the the DT 37231 3383 20 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3383 21 had have VBD 37231 3383 22 foretold foretold NN 37231 3383 23 , , , 37231 3383 24 not not RB 37231 3383 25 only only RB 37231 3383 26 did do VBD 37231 3383 27 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 28 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3383 29 the the DT 37231 3383 30 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3383 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3383 32 not not RB 37231 3383 33 repent repent VB 37231 3383 34 of of IN 37231 3383 35 the the DT 37231 3383 36 wickedness wickedness NN 37231 3383 37 which which WDT 37231 3383 38 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 39 had have VBD 37231 3383 40 committed commit VBN 37231 3383 41 , , , 37231 3383 42 but but CC 37231 3383 43 at at IN 37231 3383 44 that that DT 37231 3383 45 time time NN 37231 3383 46 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 47 selected select VBD 37231 3383 48 and and CC 37231 3383 49 sent send VBD 37231 3383 50 forth forth RB 37231 3383 51 from from IN 37231 3383 52 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 3383 53 throughout throughout IN 37231 3383 54 the the DT 37231 3383 55 land land NN 37231 3383 56 chosen choose VBN 37231 3383 57 men man NNS 37231 3383 58 , , , 37231 3383 59 saying say VBG 37231 3383 60 that that IN 37231 3383 61 the the DT 37231 3383 62 atheistic atheistic JJ 37231 3383 63 heresy heresy NN 37231 3383 64 of of IN 37231 3383 65 the the DT 37231 3383 66 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3383 67 had have VBD 37231 3383 68 arisen/ arisen/ NN 37231 3383 69 ' ' POS 37231 3383 70 & & CC 37231 3383 71 c.(1 c.(1 NN 37231 3383 72 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3383 73 .... .... . 37231 3383 74 " " '' 37231 3383 75 from from IN 37231 3383 76 a a DT 37231 3383 77 certain certain JJ 37231 3383 78 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3383 79 , , , 37231 3383 80 a a DT 37231 3383 81 Galilrean galilrean JJ 37231 3383 82 impostor impostor NN 37231 3383 83 , , , 37231 3383 84 whom whom WP 37231 3383 85 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 86 crucified crucify VBD 37231 3383 87 , , , 37231 3383 88 but but CC 37231 3383 89 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3383 90 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3383 91 stole steal VBD 37231 3383 92 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 93 by by IN 37231 3383 94 night night NN 37231 3383 95 from from IN 37231 3383 96 the the DT 37231 3383 97 tomb tomb NN 37231 3383 98 where where WRB 37231 3383 99 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 100 had have VBD 37231 3383 101 been be VBN 37231 3383 102 laid lay VBN 37231 3383 103 when when WRB 37231 3383 104 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 105 was be VBD 37231 3383 106 unloosed unloose VBN 37231 3383 107 from from IN 37231 3383 108 the the DT 37231 3383 109 cross cross NN 37231 3383 110 , , , 37231 3383 111 and and CC 37231 3383 112 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 113 now now RB 37231 3383 114 deceive deceive VBP 37231 3383 115 men man NNS 37231 3383 116 , , , 37231 3383 117 saying say VBG 37231 3383 118 that that IN 37231 3383 119 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3383 120 has have VBZ 37231 3383 121 risen rise VBN 37231 3383 122 from from IN 37231 3383 123 the the DT 37231 3383 124 dead dead JJ 37231 3383 125 and and CC 37231 3383 126 ascended ascend VBN 37231 3383 127 into into IN 37231 3383 128 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3383 129 . . . 37231 3384 1 " " `` 37231 3384 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3384 3 2 2 LS 37231 3384 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3384 5 This this DT 37231 3384 6 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 3384 7 is be VBZ 37231 3384 8 not not RB 37231 3384 9 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3384 10 by by IN 37231 3384 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3384 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3384 13 , , , 37231 3384 14 but but CC 37231 3384 15 , , , 37231 3384 16 reiterated reiterate VBD 37231 3384 17 twice twice RB 37231 3384 18 by by IN 37231 3384 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3384 20 in in IN 37231 3384 21 almost almost RB 37231 3384 22 the the DT 37231 3384 23 same same JJ 37231 3384 24 words word NNS 37231 3384 25 , , , 37231 3384 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3384 27 was be VBD 37231 3384 28 in in IN 37231 3384 29 all all DT 37231 3384 30 probability probability NN 37231 3384 31 contained contain VBN 37231 3384 32 in in IN 37231 3384 33 the the DT 37231 3384 34 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3384 35 . . . 37231 3385 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 3385 2 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3385 3 the the DT 37231 3385 4 passage passage NN 37231 3385 5 from from IN 37231 3385 6 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3385 7 , , , 37231 3385 8 without without IN 37231 3385 9 comment comment NN 37231 3385 10 , , , 37231 3385 11 evidently evidently RB 37231 3385 12 on on IN 37231 3385 13 account account NN 37231 3385 14 of of IN 37231 3385 15 the the DT 37231 3385 16 information information NN 37231 3385 17 which which WDT 37231 3385 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3385 19 conveyed convey VBD 37231 3385 20 . . . 37231 3386 1 These these DT 37231 3386 2 instances instance NNS 37231 3386 3 , , , 37231 3386 4 which which WDT 37231 3386 5 , , , 37231 3386 6 although although IN 37231 3386 7 far far RB 37231 3386 8 from from IN 37231 3386 9 complete complete JJ 37231 3386 10 , , , 37231 3386 11 have have VBP 37231 3386 12 already already RB 37231 3386 13 occupied occupy VBN 37231 3386 14 too too RB 37231 3386 15 much much JJ 37231 3386 16 of of IN 37231 3386 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3386 18 space space NN 37231 3386 19 , , , 37231 3386 20 show show VBP 37231 3386 21 that that IN 37231 3386 22 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3386 23 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3386 24 from from IN 37231 3386 25 the the DT 37231 3386 26 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3386 27 of of IN 37231 3386 28 the the DT 37231 3386 29 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3386 30 many many JJ 37231 3386 31 statements statement NNS 37231 3386 32 and and CC 37231 3386 33 facts fact NNS 37231 3386 34 of of IN 37231 3386 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3386 36 history history NN 37231 3386 37 which which WDT 37231 3386 38 are be VBP 37231 3386 39 not not RB 37231 3386 40 only only RB 37231 3386 41 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3386 42 to to IN 37231 3386 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3386 44 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3386 45 , , , 37231 3386 46 but but CC 37231 3386 47 in in IN 37231 3386 48 some some DT 37231 3386 49 cases case NNS 37231 3386 50 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 3386 51 to to IN 37231 3386 52 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3386 53 , , , 37231 3386 54 whilst whilst IN 37231 3386 55 the the DT 37231 3386 56 narrative narrative NN 37231 3386 57 of of IN 37231 3386 58 the the DT 37231 3386 59 most most RBS 37231 3386 60 solemn solemn JJ 37231 3386 61 events event NNS 37231 3386 62 in in IN 37231 3386 63 the the DT 37231 3386 64 life life NN 37231 3386 65 of of IN 37231 3386 66 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3386 67 presents present VBZ 37231 3386 68 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3386 69 and and CC 37231 3386 70 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3386 71 variations variation NNS 37231 3386 72 from from IN 37231 3386 73 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3386 74 passages passage NNS 37231 3386 75 in in IN 37231 3386 76 the the DT 37231 3386 77 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3386 78 records record NNS 37231 3386 79 . . . 37231 3387 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3387 2 340 340 CD 37231 3387 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3387 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3387 5 will will MD 37231 3387 6 now now RB 37231 3387 7 be be VB 37231 3387 8 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3387 9 to to TO 37231 3387 10 compare compare VB 37231 3387 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3387 12 general general JJ 37231 3387 13 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3387 14 from from IN 37231 3387 15 the the DT 37231 3387 16 same same JJ 37231 3387 17 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3387 18 with with IN 37231 3387 19 the the DT 37231 3387 20 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3387 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3387 22 , , , 37231 3387 23 and and CC 37231 3387 24 here here RB 37231 3387 25 a a DT 37231 3387 26 very very RB 37231 3387 27 wide wide JJ 37231 3387 28 field field NN 37231 3387 29 opens open VBZ 37231 3387 30 before before IN 37231 3387 31 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3387 32 . . . 37231 3388 1 As as IN 37231 3388 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3388 3 have have VBP 37231 3388 4 already already RB 37231 3388 5 stated state VBN 37231 3388 6 , , , 37231 3388 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3388 8 's 's POS 37231 3388 9 works work NNS 37231 3388 10 teem teem VBP 37231 3388 11 with with IN 37231 3388 12 these these DT 37231 3388 13 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3388 14 , , , 37231 3388 15 and and CC 37231 3388 16 to to TO 37231 3388 17 take take VB 37231 3388 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3388 19 all all DT 37231 3388 20 in in IN 37231 3388 21 detail detail NN 37231 3388 22 would would MD 37231 3388 23 be be VB 37231 3388 24 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3388 25 within within IN 37231 3388 26 the the DT 37231 3388 27 limits limit NNS 37231 3388 28 of of IN 37231 3388 29 this this DT 37231 3388 30 work work NN 37231 3388 31 . . . 37231 3389 1 Such such PDT 37231 3389 2 a a DT 37231 3389 3 course course NN 37231 3389 4 , , , 37231 3389 5 moreover moreover RB 37231 3389 6 , , , 37231 3389 7 is be VBZ 37231 3389 8 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 3389 9 . . . 37231 3390 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3390 2 may may MD 37231 3390 3 be be VB 37231 3390 4 broadly broadly RB 37231 3390 5 stated state VBN 37231 3390 6 that that IN 37231 3390 7 even even RB 37231 3390 8 those those DT 37231 3390 9 who who WP 37231 3390 10 maintain maintain VBP 37231 3390 11 the the DT 37231 3390 12 use use NN 37231 3390 13 of of IN 37231 3390 14 the the DT 37231 3390 15 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3390 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3390 17 can can MD 37231 3390 18 only only RB 37231 3390 19 point point VB 37231 3390 20 out out RP 37231 3390 21 two two CD 37231 3390 22 or or CC 37231 3390 23 three three CD 37231 3390 24 passages passage NNS 37231 3390 25 out out IN 37231 3390 26 of of IN 37231 3390 27 this this DT 37231 3390 28 vast vast JJ 37231 3390 29 array array NN 37231 3390 30 which which WDT 37231 3390 31 verbally verbally RB 37231 3390 32 agree agree VBP 37231 3390 33 with with IN 37231 3390 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3390 35 . . . 37231 3391 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3391 2 1 1 LS 37231 3391 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3391 4 This this DT 37231 3391 5 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 3391 6 anomaly anomaly NNS 37231 3391 7 -- -- : 37231 3391 8 on on IN 37231 3391 9 the the DT 37231 3391 10 supposition supposition NN 37231 3391 11 that that IN 37231 3391 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3391 13 's 's POS 37231 3391 14 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3391 15 were be VBD 37231 3391 16 in in IN 37231 3391 17 fact fact NN 37231 3391 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3391 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3391 20 -- -- : 37231 3391 21 is be VBZ 37231 3391 22 , , , 37231 3391 23 as as IN 37231 3391 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3391 25 have have VBP 37231 3391 26 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3391 27 , , , 37231 3391 28 explained explain VBN 37231 3391 29 by by IN 37231 3391 30 the the DT 37231 3391 31 convenient convenient JJ 37231 3391 32 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 3391 33 that that WDT 37231 3391 34 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3391 35 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3391 36 imperfectly imperfectly RB 37231 3391 37 from from IN 37231 3391 38 memory memory NN 37231 3391 39 , , , 37231 3391 40 interweaves interweave NNS 37231 3391 41 and and CC 37231 3391 42 modifies modifie NNS 37231 3391 43 texts text NNS 37231 3391 44 , , , 37231 3391 45 and and CC 37231 3391 46 in in IN 37231 3391 47 short short JJ 37231 3391 48 freely freely RB 37231 3391 49 manipulates manipulate NNS 37231 3391 50 these these DT 37231 3391 51 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3391 52 according accord VBG 37231 3391 53 to to IN 37231 3391 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3391 55 argument argument NN 37231 3391 56 . . . 37231 3392 1 Even even RB 37231 3392 2 strained strained JJ 37231 3392 3 to to IN 37231 3392 4 the the DT 37231 3392 5 uttermost uttermost NN 37231 3392 6 , , , 37231 3392 7 however however RB 37231 3392 8 , , , 37231 3392 9 could could MD 37231 3392 10 this this DT 37231 3392 11 be be VB 37231 3392 12 accepted accept VBN 37231 3392 13 as as IN 37231 3392 14 a a DT 37231 3392 15 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 3392 16 explanation explanation NN 37231 3392 17 of of IN 37231 3392 18 such such JJ 37231 3392 19 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3392 20 variation variation NN 37231 3392 21 , , , 37231 3392 22 that that IN 37231 3392 23 only only RB 37231 3392 24 twice twice RB 37231 3392 25 or or CC 37231 3392 26 thrice thrice VBP 37231 3392 27 out out IN 37231 3392 28 of of IN 37231 3392 29 the the DT 37231 3392 30 vast vast JJ 37231 3392 31 number number NN 37231 3392 32 of of IN 37231 3392 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3392 34 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3392 35 does do VBZ 37231 3392 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3392 37 literally literally RB 37231 3392 38 agree agree VB 37231 3392 39 with with IN 37231 3392 40 passages passage NNS 37231 3392 41 in in IN 37231 3392 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3392 43 ? ? . 37231 3393 1 In in IN 37231 3393 2 order order NN 37231 3393 3 to to TO 37231 3393 4 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 3393 5 the the DT 37231 3393 6 case case NN 37231 3393 7 with with IN 37231 3393 8 absolute absolute JJ 37231 3393 9 impartiality impartiality NN 37231 3393 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3393 11 shall shall MD 37231 3393 12 first first RB 37231 3393 13 take take VB 37231 3393 14 the the DT 37231 3393 15 instances instance NNS 37231 3393 16 brought bring VBN 37231 3393 17 forward forward RB 37231 3393 18 as as IN 37231 3393 19 showing show VBG 37231 3393 20 agreement agreement NN 37231 3393 21 with with IN 37231 3393 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3393 23 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3393 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3393 25 . . . 37231 3394 1 Teschendorf teschendorf NN 37231 3394 2 only only RB 37231 3394 3 cites cite VBZ 37231 3394 4 two two CD 37231 3394 5 passages passage NNS 37231 3394 6 in in IN 37231 3394 7 support support NN 37231 3394 8 of of IN 37231 3394 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3394 10 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 3394 11 that that IN 37231 3394 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3394 13 makes make VBZ 37231 3394 14 use use NN 37231 3394 15 of of IN 37231 3394 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3394 17 first first JJ 37231 3394 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3394 19 . . . 37231 3395 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3395 2 2 2 LS 37231 3395 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3395 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3395 5 might may MD 37231 3395 6 be be VB 37231 3395 7 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3395 8 that that IN 37231 3395 9 , , , 37231 3395 10 in in IN 37231 3395 11 selecting select VBG 37231 3395 12 these these DT 37231 3395 13 , , , 37231 3395 14 at at RB 37231 3395 15 least least JJS 37231 3395 16 two two CD 37231 3395 17 might may MD 37231 3395 18 have have VB 37231 3395 19 been be VBN 37231 3395 20 produced produce VBN 37231 3395 21 literally literally RB 37231 3395 22 agreeing agree VBG 37231 3395 23 , , , 37231 3395 24 but but CC 37231 3395 25 this this DT 37231 3395 26 is be VBZ 37231 3395 27 { { -LRB- 37231 3395 28 341 341 CD 37231 3395 29 } } -RRB- 37231 3395 30 not not RB 37231 3395 31 the the DT 37231 3395 32 case case NN 37231 3395 33 , , , 37231 3395 34 and and CC 37231 3395 35 this this DT 37231 3395 36 may may MD 37231 3395 37 be be VB 37231 3395 38 taken take VBN 37231 3395 39 as as IN 37231 3395 40 an an DT 37231 3395 41 illustration illustration NN 37231 3395 42 of of IN 37231 3395 43 the the DT 37231 3395 44 almost almost RB 37231 3395 45 universal universal JJ 37231 3395 46 variation variation NN 37231 3395 47 of of IN 37231 3395 48 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3395 49 's 's POS 37231 3395 50 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3395 51 . . . 37231 3396 1 The the DT 37231 3396 2 first first JJ 37231 3396 3 of of IN 37231 3396 4 Teschendorf Teschendorf NNP 37231 3396 5 s s POS 37231 3396 6 examples example NNS 37231 3396 7 is be VBZ 37231 3396 8 the the DT 37231 3396 9 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3396 10 use use NN 37231 3396 11 of of IN 37231 3396 12 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3396 13 viii viii NNP 37231 3396 14 . . . 37231 3397 1 11 11 CD 37231 3397 2 , , , 37231 3397 3 12 12 CD 37231 3397 4 : : : 37231 3397 5 " " `` 37231 3397 6 Many many JJ 37231 3397 7 shall shall MD 37231 3397 8 come come VB 37231 3397 9 from from IN 37231 3397 10 the the DT 37231 3397 11 east east NN 37231 3397 12 and and CC 37231 3397 13 from from IN 37231 3397 14 the the DT 37231 3397 15 west west NN 37231 3397 16 , , , 37231 3397 17 and and CC 37231 3397 18 shall shall MD 37231 3397 19 sit sit VB 37231 3397 20 down down RP 37231 3397 21 , , , 37231 3397 22 " " '' 37231 3397 23 & & CC 37231 3397 24 c. c. NNP 37231 3397 25 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3397 26 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3397 27 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3397 28 . . . 37231 3398 1 Now now RB 37231 3398 2 this this DT 37231 3398 3 passage passage NN 37231 3398 4 is be VBZ 37231 3398 5 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3398 6 by by IN 37231 3398 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3398 8 no no DT 37231 3398 9 less less JJR 37231 3398 10 than than IN 37231 3398 11 three three CD 37231 3398 12 times time NNS 37231 3398 13 in in IN 37231 3398 14 three three CD 37231 3398 15 very very RB 37231 3398 16 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3398 17 parts part NNS 37231 3398 18 of of IN 37231 3398 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3398 20 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3398 21 with with IN 37231 3398 22 Trypho,(1 trypho,(1 NN 37231 3398 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3398 24 with with IN 37231 3398 25 a a DT 37231 3398 26 uniform uniform JJ 37231 3398 27 variation variation NN 37231 3398 28 from from IN 37231 3398 29 the the DT 37231 3398 30 text text NN 37231 3398 31 of of IN 37231 3398 32 Matthew--_They Matthew--_They NNP 37231 3398 33 _ _ NNP 37231 3398 34 shall shall MD 37231 3398 35 come come VB 37231 3398 36 from from IN 37231 3398 37 the the DT 37231 3398 38 _ _ NNP 37231 3398 39 west west NNP 37231 3398 40 _ _ NNP 37231 3398 41 and and CC 37231 3398 42 from from IN 37231 3398 43 the the DT 37231 3398 44 east east NNP 37231 3398 45 , , , 37231 3398 46 " " '' 37231 3398 47 & & CC 37231 3398 48 c. c. NNP 37231 3398 49 & & CC 37231 3398 50 c. c. NNP 37231 3398 51 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3398 52 --Greek--](2 --Greek--](2 NNP 37231 3398 53 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3398 54 That that IN 37231 3398 55 a a DT 37231 3398 56 historical historical JJ 37231 3398 57 saying saying NN 37231 3398 58 of of IN 37231 3398 59 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3398 60 should should MD 37231 3398 61 be be VB 37231 3398 62 reproduced reproduce VBN 37231 3398 63 in in IN 37231 3398 64 many many JJ 37231 3398 65 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3398 66 , , , 37231 3398 67 and and CC 37231 3398 68 that that IN 37231 3398 69 no no DT 37231 3398 70 particular particular JJ 37231 3398 71 work work NN 37231 3398 72 can can MD 37231 3398 73 have have VB 37231 3398 74 any any DT 37231 3398 75 prescriptive prescriptive JJ 37231 3398 76 right right NN 37231 3398 77 to to IN 37231 3398 78 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3398 79 , , , 37231 3398 80 must must MD 37231 3398 81 be be VB 37231 3398 82 admitted admit VBN 37231 3398 83 , , , 37231 3398 84 so so IN 37231 3398 85 that that IN 37231 3398 86 even even RB 37231 3398 87 if if IN 37231 3398 88 the the DT 37231 3398 89 passage passage NN 37231 3398 90 in in IN 37231 3398 91 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3398 92 agreed agree VBD 37231 3398 93 literally literally RB 37231 3398 94 with with IN 37231 3398 95 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3398 96 first first JJ 37231 3398 97 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3398 98 , , , 37231 3398 99 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3398 100 would would MD 37231 3398 101 not not RB 37231 3398 102 afford afford VB 37231 3398 103 any any DT 37231 3398 104 proof proof NN 37231 3398 105 of of IN 37231 3398 106 the the DT 37231 3398 107 actual actual JJ 37231 3398 108 use use NN 37231 3398 109 of of IN 37231 3398 110 that that DT 37231 3398 111 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3398 112 ; ; : 37231 3398 113 but but CC 37231 3398 114 when when WRB 37231 3398 115 on on IN 37231 3398 116 the the DT 37231 3398 117 contrary contrary JJ 37231 3398 118 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3398 119 upon upon IN 37231 3398 120 three three CD 37231 3398 121 several several JJ 37231 3398 122 occasions occasion NNS 37231 3398 123 , , , 37231 3398 124 and and CC 37231 3398 125 at at IN 37231 3398 126 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3398 127 intervals interval NNS 37231 3398 128 of of IN 37231 3398 129 time time NN 37231 3398 130 , , , 37231 3398 131 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 3398 132 the the DT 37231 3398 133 passage passage NN 37231 3398 134 with with IN 37231 3398 135 the the DT 37231 3398 136 same same JJ 37231 3398 137 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3398 138 variation variation NN 37231 3398 139 from from IN 37231 3398 140 the the DT 37231 3398 141 reading reading NN 37231 3398 142 in in IN 37231 3398 143 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3398 144 , , , 37231 3398 145 not not RB 37231 3398 146 only only RB 37231 3398 147 can can MD 37231 3398 148 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3398 149 not not RB 37231 3398 150 be be VB 37231 3398 151 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 3398 152 to to IN 37231 3398 153 that that DT 37231 3398 154 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3398 155 , , , 37231 3398 156 but but CC 37231 3398 157 there there EX 37231 3398 158 is be VBZ 37231 3398 159 reason reason NN 37231 3398 160 to to TO 37231 3398 161 conclude conclude VB 37231 3398 162 that that IN 37231 3398 163 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3398 164 derived derive VBD 37231 3398 165 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3398 166 from from IN 37231 3398 167 another another DT 37231 3398 168 source source NN 37231 3398 169 . . . 37231 3399 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3399 2 may may MD 37231 3399 3 be be VB 37231 3399 4 added add VBN 37231 3399 5 that that IN 37231 3399 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3399 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3399 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3399 9 is be VBZ 37231 3399 10 anything anything NN 37231 3399 11 but but IN 37231 3399 12 a a DT 37231 3399 13 word word NN 37231 3399 14 uncommon uncommon JJ 37231 3399 15 in in IN 37231 3399 16 the the DT 37231 3399 17 vocabulary vocabulary NN 37231 3399 18 of of IN 37231 3399 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3399 20 , , , 37231 3399 21 and and CC 37231 3399 22 that that IN 37231 3399 23 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3399 24 , , , 37231 3399 25 for for IN 37231 3399 26 instance instance NN 37231 3399 27 , , , 37231 3399 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3399 29 twice twice RB 37231 3399 30 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3399 31 a a DT 37231 3399 32 passage passage NN 37231 3399 33 similar similar JJ 37231 3399 34 to to IN 37231 3399 35 one one CD 37231 3399 36 in in IN 37231 3399 37 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3399 38 , , , 37231 3399 39 in in IN 37231 3399 40 which which WDT 37231 3399 41 , , , 37231 3399 42 amongst amongst IN 37231 3399 43 other other JJ 37231 3399 44 variations variation NNS 37231 3399 45 , , , 37231 3399 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3399 47 reads read VBZ 37231 3399 48 " " `` 37231 3399 49 _ _ NNP 37231 3399 50 Many Many NNP 37231 3399 51 _ _ NNP 37231 3399 52 shall shall MD 37231 3399 53 come come VB 37231 3399 54 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3399 55 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3399 56 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3399 57 , , , 37231 3399 58 " " '' 37231 3399 59 instead instead RB 37231 3399 60 of of IN 37231 3399 61 the the DT 37231 3399 62 phrase phrase NN 37231 3399 63 found find VBN 37231 3399 64 in in IN 37231 3399 65 that that DT 37231 3399 66 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3399 67 . . . 37231 3400 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3400 2 3 3 LS 37231 3400 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3400 4 The the DT 37231 3400 5 second second JJ 37231 3400 6 example example NN 37231 3400 7 adduced adduce VBN 37231 3400 8 by by IN 37231 3400 9 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3400 10 is be VBZ 37231 3400 11 the the DT 37231 3400 12 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3400 13 quotation quotation NN 37231 3400 14 of of IN 37231 3400 15 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3400 16 xii xii NNP 37231 3400 17 . . . 37231 3401 1 39 39 CD 37231 3401 2 ; ; : 37231 3401 3 but but CC 37231 3401 4 in in IN 37231 3401 5 order order NN 37231 3401 6 fully fully RB 37231 3401 7 { { -LRB- 37231 3401 8 342 342 CD 37231 3401 9 } } -RRB- 37231 3401 10 to to TO 37231 3401 11 comprehend comprehend VB 37231 3401 12 the the DT 37231 3401 13 nature nature NN 37231 3401 14 of of IN 37231 3401 15 the the DT 37231 3401 16 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 3401 17 , , , 37231 3401 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3401 19 quote quote VBP 37231 3401 20 the the DT 37231 3401 21 context context NN 37231 3401 22 of of IN 37231 3401 23 the the DT 37231 3401 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3401 25 and and CC 37231 3401 26 of of IN 37231 3401 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3401 28 in in IN 37231 3401 29 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3401 30 columns:-- columns:-- NN 37231 3401 31 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3401 32 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3401 33 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3401 34 Now now RB 37231 3401 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3401 36 is be VBZ 37231 3401 37 clear clear JJ 37231 3401 38 that that IN 37231 3401 39 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3401 40 here here RB 37231 3401 41 directly directly RB 37231 3401 42 professes profess VBZ 37231 3401 43 to to TO 37231 3401 44 quote quote VB 37231 3401 45 from from IN 37231 3401 46 the the DT 37231 3401 47 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3401 48 , , , 37231 3401 49 and and CC 37231 3401 50 consequently consequently RB 37231 3401 51 that that IN 37231 3401 52 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3401 53 may may MD 37231 3401 54 be be VB 37231 3401 55 expected expect VBN 37231 3401 56 ; ; : 37231 3401 57 but but CC 37231 3401 58 passing pass VBG 37231 3401 59 over over RP 37231 3401 60 the the DT 37231 3401 61 preliminary preliminary JJ 37231 3401 62 substitution substitution NN 37231 3401 63 of of IN 37231 3401 64 " " `` 37231 3401 65 some some DT 37231 3401 66 of of IN 37231 3401 67 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3401 68 nation nation NN 37231 3401 69 , , , 37231 3401 70 " " '' 37231 3401 71 for for IN 37231 3401 72 " " `` 37231 3401 73 certain certain JJ 37231 3401 74 of of IN 37231 3401 75 the the DT 37231 3401 76 scribes scribe NNS 37231 3401 77 and and CC 37231 3401 78 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3401 79 , , , 37231 3401 80 " " '' 37231 3401 81 although although IN 37231 3401 82 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3401 83 recalls recall VBZ 37231 3401 84 the the DT 37231 3401 85 " " `` 37231 3401 86 some some DT 37231 3401 87 of of IN 37231 3401 88 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3401 89 , , , 37231 3401 90 " " '' 37231 3401 91 and and CC 37231 3401 92 " " `` 37231 3401 93 others other NNS 37231 3401 94 , , , 37231 3401 95 " " '' 37231 3401 96 by by IN 37231 3401 97 which which WDT 37231 3401 98 the the DT 37231 3401 99 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3401 100 passage passage NN 37231 3401 101 , , , 37231 3401 102 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 3401 103 so so RB 37231 3401 104 different different JJ 37231 3401 105 , , , 37231 3401 106 is be VBZ 37231 3401 107 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3401 108 in in IN 37231 3401 109 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3401 110 xi xi NNP 37231 3401 111 . . . 37231 3402 1 15 15 CD 37231 3402 2 , , , 37231 3402 3 16 16 CD 37231 3402 4 , , , 37231 3402 5 29 29 CD 37231 3402 6 ff ff NN 37231 3402 7 . . NNP 37231 3402 8 ,(1 ,(1 , 37231 3402 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3402 10 the the DT 37231 3402 11 question question NN 37231 3402 12 of of IN 37231 3402 13 the the DT 37231 3402 14 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 3402 15 , , , 37231 3402 16 which which WDT 37231 3402 17 should should MD 37231 3402 18 be be VB 37231 3402 19 literal literal JJ 37231 3402 20 , , , 37231 3402 21 is be VBZ 37231 3402 22 quite quite RB 37231 3402 23 different different JJ 37231 3402 24 from from IN 37231 3402 25 that that DT 37231 3402 26 of of IN 37231 3402 27 the the DT 37231 3402 28 first first JJ 37231 3402 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3402 30 , , , 37231 3402 31 whilst whilst IN 37231 3402 32 there there EX 37231 3402 33 are be VBP 37231 3402 34 variations variation NNS 37231 3402 35 in in IN 37231 3402 36 the the DT 37231 3402 37 reply reply NN 37231 3402 38 of of IN 37231 3402 39 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3402 40 , , , 37231 3402 41 which which WDT 37231 3402 42 , , , 37231 3402 43 if if IN 37231 3402 44 not not RB 37231 3402 45 so so RB 37231 3402 46 important important JJ 37231 3402 47 , , , 37231 3402 48 are be VBP 37231 3402 49 still still RB 37231 3402 50 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 3402 51 . . . 37231 3403 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3403 2 can can MD 37231 3403 3 not not RB 37231 3403 4 compare compare VB 37231 3403 5 with with IN 37231 3403 6 the the DT 37231 3403 7 first first JJ 37231 3403 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3403 9 the the DT 37231 3403 10 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3403 11 passages passage NNS 37231 3403 12 in in IN 37231 3403 13 the the DT 37231 3403 14 second second JJ 37231 3403 15 and and CC 37231 3403 16 third third JJ 37231 3403 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3403 18 without without IN 37231 3403 19 recognizing recognize VBG 37231 3403 20 that that IN 37231 3403 21 other other JJ 37231 3403 22 works work NNS 37231 3403 23 may may MD 37231 3403 24 have have VB 37231 3403 25 narrated narrate VBN 37231 3403 26 the the DT 37231 3403 27 { { -LRB- 37231 3403 28 343 343 CD 37231 3403 29 } } -RRB- 37231 3403 30 same same JJ 37231 3403 31 episode episode NN 37231 3403 32 with with IN 37231 3403 33 similar similar JJ 37231 3403 34 variations variation NNS 37231 3403 35 , , , 37231 3403 36 and and CC 37231 3403 37 whilst whilst IN 37231 3403 38 the the DT 37231 3403 39 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3403 40 differences difference NNS 37231 3403 41 which which WDT 37231 3403 42 exist exist VBP 37231 3403 43 totally totally RB 37231 3403 44 exclude exclude VBP 37231 3403 45 the the DT 37231 3403 46 affirmation affirmation NN 37231 3403 47 that that IN 37231 3403 48 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3403 49 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3403 50 from from IN 37231 3403 51 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3403 52 , , , 37231 3403 53 everything everything NN 37231 3403 54 points point NNS 37231 3403 55 to to IN 37231 3403 56 the the DT 37231 3403 57 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3403 58 that that IN 37231 3403 59 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3403 60 makes make VBZ 37231 3403 61 use use NN 37231 3403 62 of of IN 37231 3403 63 another another DT 37231 3403 64 source source NN 37231 3403 65 . . . 37231 3404 1 This this DT 37231 3404 2 is be VBZ 37231 3404 3 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 3404 4 by by IN 37231 3404 5 another another DT 37231 3404 6 important important JJ 37231 3404 7 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 3404 8 . . . 37231 3405 1 After after IN 37231 3405 2 enlarging enlarge VBG 37231 3405 3 during during IN 37231 3405 4 the the DT 37231 3405 5 remainder remainder NN 37231 3405 6 of of IN 37231 3405 7 the the DT 37231 3405 8 chapter chapter NN 37231 3405 9 upon upon IN 37231 3405 10 the the DT 37231 3405 11 example example NN 37231 3405 12 of of IN 37231 3405 13 the the DT 37231 3405 14 people people NNS 37231 3405 15 of of IN 37231 3405 16 Nineveh Nineveh NNP 37231 3405 17 , , , 37231 3405 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3405 19 commences commence VBZ 37231 3405 20 the the DT 37231 3405 21 next next JJ 37231 3405 22 by by IN 37231 3405 23 returning return VBG 37231 3405 24 to to IN 37231 3405 25 the the DT 37231 3405 26 answer answer NN 37231 3405 27 of of IN 37231 3405 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3405 29 , , , 37231 3405 30 and and CC 37231 3405 31 making make VBG 37231 3405 32 the the DT 37231 3405 33 following follow VBG 37231 3405 34 statement statement NN 37231 3405 35 : : : 37231 3405 36 " " `` 37231 3405 37 And and CC 37231 3405 38 though though IN 37231 3405 39 all all DT 37231 3405 40 of of IN 37231 3405 41 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3405 42 nation nation NN 37231 3405 43 were be VBD 37231 3405 44 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 3405 45 with with IN 37231 3405 46 these these DT 37231 3405 47 things thing NNS 37231 3405 48 which which WDT 37231 3405 49 occurred occur VBD 37231 3405 50 to to IN 37231 3405 51 Jonah Jonah NNP 37231 3405 52 , , , 37231 3405 53 and and CC 37231 3405 54 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3405 55 proclaimed proclaim VBD 37231 3405 56 among among IN 37231 3405 57 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 58 , , , 37231 3405 59 that that IN 37231 3405 60 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 61 would would MD 37231 3405 62 give give VB 37231 3405 63 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 64 the the DT 37231 3405 65 sign sign NN 37231 3405 66 of of IN 37231 3405 67 Jonah Jonah NNP 37231 3405 68 , , , 37231 3405 69 exhorting exhort VBG 37231 3405 70 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 71 at at IN 37231 3405 72 least least JJS 37231 3405 73 after after IN 37231 3405 74 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3405 75 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 3405 76 from from IN 37231 3405 77 the the DT 37231 3405 78 dead dead NN 37231 3405 79 to to TO 37231 3405 80 repent repent VB 37231 3405 81 of of IN 37231 3405 82 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3405 83 evil evil JJ 37231 3405 84 deeds deed NNS 37231 3405 85 , , , 37231 3405 86 and and CC 37231 3405 87 like like IN 37231 3405 88 the the DT 37231 3405 89 Ninevites Ninevites NNPS 37231 3405 90 to to TO 37231 3405 91 supplicate supplicate VB 37231 3405 92 God God NNP 37231 3405 93 , , , 37231 3405 94 that that IN 37231 3405 95 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3405 96 nation nation NN 37231 3405 97 and and CC 37231 3405 98 city city NN 37231 3405 99 might may MD 37231 3405 100 not not RB 37231 3405 101 be be VB 37231 3405 102 captured capture VBN 37231 3405 103 and and CC 37231 3405 104 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 3405 105 as as IN 37231 3405 106 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 107 has have VBZ 37231 3405 108 been be VBN 37231 3405 109 destroyed destroy VBN 37231 3405 110 ; ; : 37231 3405 111 yet yet CC 37231 3405 112 not not RB 37231 3405 113 only only RB 37231 3405 114 have have VBP 37231 3405 115 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 116 not not RB 37231 3405 117 repented repent VBN 37231 3405 118 on on IN 37231 3405 119 learning learn VBG 37231 3405 120 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3405 121 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 3405 122 from from IN 37231 3405 123 the the DT 37231 3405 124 dead dead JJ 37231 3405 125 , , , 37231 3405 126 but but CC 37231 3405 127 as as IN 37231 3405 128 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 129 have have VBP 37231 3405 130 already already RB 37231 3405 131 said,(1 said,(1 XX 37231 3405 132 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3405 133 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 134 sent send VBD 37231 3405 135 chosen(2 chosen(2 NN 37231 3405 136 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3405 137 and and CC 37231 3405 138 select select VB 37231 3405 139 men man NNS 37231 3405 140 throughout throughout IN 37231 3405 141 all all PDT 37231 3405 142 the the DT 37231 3405 143 world world NN 37231 3405 144 , , , 37231 3405 145 proclaiming proclaim VBG 37231 3405 146 that that IN 37231 3405 147 an an DT 37231 3405 148 atheistic atheistic JJ 37231 3405 149 and and CC 37231 3405 150 impious impious JJ 37231 3405 151 heresy heresy NN 37231 3405 152 had have VBD 37231 3405 153 arisen arise VBN 37231 3405 154 from from IN 37231 3405 155 a a DT 37231 3405 156 certain certain JJ 37231 3405 157 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3405 158 , , , 37231 3405 159 a a DT 37231 3405 160 Galilaean galilaean JJ 37231 3405 161 impostor impostor NN 37231 3405 162 , , , 37231 3405 163 " " '' 37231 3405 164 & & CC 37231 3405 165 c. c. NNP 37231 3405 166 & & CC 37231 3405 167 c.(3 c.(3 NNP 37231 3405 168 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3405 169 Now now RB 37231 3405 170 not not RB 37231 3405 171 only only RB 37231 3405 172 do do VBP 37231 3405 173 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3405 174 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3405 175 not not RB 37231 3405 176 mention mention VB 37231 3405 177 this this DT 37231 3405 178 mission mission NN 37231 3405 179 , , , 37231 3405 180 as as IN 37231 3405 181 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 182 have have VBP 37231 3405 183 already already RB 37231 3405 184 pointed point VBN 37231 3405 185 out out RP 37231 3405 186 , , , 37231 3405 187 but but CC 37231 3405 188 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3405 189 do do VBP 37231 3405 190 not not RB 37231 3405 191 contain contain VB 37231 3405 192 the the DT 37231 3405 193 exhortation exhortation NN 37231 3405 194 to to TO 37231 3405 195 repent repent VB 37231 3405 196 at at IN 37231 3405 197 least least JJS 37231 3405 198 after after IN 37231 3405 199 the the DT 37231 3405 200 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 3405 201 of of IN 37231 3405 202 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3405 203 here here RB 37231 3405 204 referred refer VBD 37231 3405 205 to to IN 37231 3405 206 , , , 37231 3405 207 and and CC 37231 3405 208 which which WDT 37231 3405 209 evidently evidently RB 37231 3405 210 must must MD 37231 3405 211 have have VB 37231 3405 212 formed form VBN 37231 3405 213 part part NN 37231 3405 214 of of IN 37231 3405 215 the the DT 37231 3405 216 episode episode NN 37231 3405 217 in in IN 37231 3405 218 the the DT 37231 3405 219 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3405 220 . . . 37231 3406 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3406 2 does do VBZ 37231 3406 3 not not RB 37231 3406 4 produce produce VB 37231 3406 5 any any DT 37231 3406 6 other other JJ 37231 3406 7 instances instance NNS 37231 3406 8 of of IN 37231 3406 9 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3406 10 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3406 11 of of IN 37231 3406 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3406 13 from from IN 37231 3406 14 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3406 15 , , , 37231 3406 16 but but CC 37231 3406 17 rests rest VBZ 37231 3406 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3406 19 case case NN 37231 3406 20 upon upon IN 37231 3406 21 these these DT 37231 3406 22 . . . 37231 3407 1 As as IN 37231 3407 2 these these DT 37231 3407 3 are be VBP 37231 3407 4 the the DT 37231 3407 5 best good JJS 37231 3407 6 examples example NNS 37231 3407 7 apparently apparently RB 37231 3407 8 which which WDT 37231 3407 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3407 10 can can MD 37231 3407 11 point point VB 37231 3407 12 out out RP 37231 3407 13 , , , 37231 3407 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3407 15 may may MD 37231 3407 16 judge judge VB 37231 3407 17 of of IN 37231 3407 18 the the DT 37231 3407 19 { { -LRB- 37231 3407 20 344 344 CD 37231 3407 21 } } -RRB- 37231 3407 22 weakness weakness NN 37231 3407 23 of of IN 37231 3407 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3407 25 argument argument NN 37231 3407 26 . . . 37231 3408 1 Do do VBP 37231 3408 2 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3408 3 divides divide VBZ 37231 3408 4 the the DT 37231 3408 5 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3408 6 of of IN 37231 3408 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3408 8 which which WDT 37231 3408 9 may may MD 37231 3408 10 be be VB 37231 3408 11 compared compare VBN 37231 3408 12 with with IN 37231 3408 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3408 14 first first JJ 37231 3408 15 and and CC 37231 3408 16 third third JJ 37231 3408 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3408 18 into into IN 37231 3408 19 several several JJ 37231 3408 20 categories category NNS 37231 3408 21 . . . 37231 3409 1 Regarding regard VBG 37231 3409 2 the the DT 37231 3409 3 first first JJ 37231 3409 4 class class NN 37231 3409 5 , , , 37231 3409 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3409 7 says say VBZ 37231 3409 8 : : : 37231 3409 9 " " `` 37231 3409 10 Some some DT 37231 3409 11 agree agree VBP 37231 3409 12 quite quite RB 37231 3409 13 literally literally RB 37231 3409 14 , , , 37231 3409 15 which which WDT 37231 3409 16 , , , 37231 3409 17 however however RB 37231 3409 18 , , , 37231 3409 19 is be VBZ 37231 3409 20 seldom seldom RB 37231 3409 21 : : : 37231 3409 22 " " '' 37231 3409 23 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3409 24 1 1 CD 37231 3409 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3409 26 and and CC 37231 3409 27 under under IN 37231 3409 28 this this DT 37231 3409 29 head head NN 37231 3409 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3409 31 can can MD 37231 3409 32 only only RB 37231 3409 33 collect collect VB 37231 3409 34 three three CD 37231 3409 35 passages passage NNS 37231 3409 36 of of IN 37231 3409 37 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3409 38 and and CC 37231 3409 39 refer refer VB 37231 3409 40 to to IN 37231 3409 41 one one CD 37231 3409 42 of of IN 37231 3409 43 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3409 44 . . . 37231 3410 1 Of of IN 37231 3410 2 the the DT 37231 3410 3 three three CD 37231 3410 4 from from IN 37231 3410 5 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3410 6 the the DT 37231 3410 7 first first JJ 37231 3410 8 is be VBZ 37231 3410 9 that that IN 37231 3410 10 , , , 37231 3410 11 viii viii JJ 37231 3410 12 . . . 37231 3411 1 11 11 CD 37231 3411 2 , , , 37231 3411 3 12,(2 12,(2 NNP 37231 3411 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3411 5 also also RB 37231 3411 6 brought bring VBD 37231 3411 7 forward forward RP 37231 3411 8 by by IN 37231 3411 9 Teschendorf Teschendorf NNP 37231 3411 10 , , , 37231 3411 11 of of IN 37231 3411 12 which which WDT 37231 3411 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3411 14 have have VBP 37231 3411 15 already already RB 37231 3411 16 disposed dispose VBN 37231 3411 17 . . . 37231 3412 1 The the DT 37231 3412 2 second second JJ 37231 3412 3 is be VBZ 37231 3412 4 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3412 5 . . . 37231 3413 1 v. v. CC 37231 3413 2 20 20 CD 37231 3413 3 : : : 37231 3413 4 " " `` 37231 3413 5 For for IN 37231 3413 6 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3413 7 say say VBP 37231 3413 8 unto unto IN 37231 3413 9 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3413 10 , , , 37231 3413 11 that that IN 37231 3413 12 except except IN 37231 3413 13 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3413 14 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 3413 15 shall shall MD 37231 3413 16 exceed exceed VB 37231 3413 17 that that DT 37231 3413 18 of of IN 37231 3413 19 the the DT 37231 3413 20 scribes scribe NNS 37231 3413 21 and and CC 37231 3413 22 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3413 23 , , , 37231 3413 24 ye ye NNP 37231 3413 25 shall shall MD 37231 3413 26 not not RB 37231 3413 27 enter enter VB 37231 3413 28 into into IN 37231 3413 29 the the DT 37231 3413 30 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 3413 31 of of IN 37231 3413 32 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3413 33 . . . 37231 3413 34 " " '' 37231 3414 1 A a DT 37231 3414 2 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3414 3 passage passage NN 37231 3414 4 to to IN 37231 3414 5 this this DT 37231 3414 6 exists exist VBZ 37231 3414 7 in in IN 37231 3414 8 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3414 9 . . . 37231 3415 1 105 105 CD 37231 3415 2 , , , 37231 3415 3 a a DT 37231 3415 4 chapter chapter NN 37231 3415 5 in in IN 37231 3415 6 which which WDT 37231 3415 7 there there EX 37231 3415 8 are be VBP 37231 3415 9 several several JJ 37231 3415 10 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3415 11 not not RB 37231 3415 12 found find VBN 37231 3415 13 in in IN 37231 3415 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3415 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3415 16 at at RB 37231 3415 17 all all RB 37231 3415 18 , , , 37231 3415 19 with with IN 37231 3415 20 the the DT 37231 3415 21 exception exception NN 37231 3415 22 that that WDT 37231 3415 23 the the DT 37231 3415 24 first first JJ 37231 3415 25 words word NNS 37231 3415 26 , , , 37231 3415 27 " " `` 37231 3415 28 For for IN 37231 3415 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3415 30 say say VBP 37231 3415 31 unto unto IN 37231 3415 32 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3415 33 that that IN 37231 3415 34 , , , 37231 3415 35 " " `` 37231 3415 36 are be VBP 37231 3415 37 not not RB 37231 3415 38 in in IN 37231 3415 39 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3415 40 . . . 37231 3416 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3416 2 shall shall MD 37231 3416 3 speak speak VB 37231 3416 4 of of IN 37231 3416 5 this this DT 37231 3416 6 passage passage NN 37231 3416 7 presently presently RB 37231 3416 8 . . . 37231 3417 1 De De NNP 37231 3417 2 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3417 3 's 's POS 37231 3417 4 third third JJ 37231 3417 5 passage passage NN 37231 3417 6 is be VBZ 37231 3417 7 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3417 8 . . . 37231 3418 1 vii vii NN 37231 3418 2 . . . 37231 3419 1 19 19 CD 37231 3419 2 : : : 37231 3419 3 " " `` 37231 3419 4 Every every DT 37231 3419 5 tree tree NN 37231 3419 6 that that WDT 37231 3419 7 bringeth bringeth VBP 37231 3419 8 not not RB 37231 3419 9 forth forth RB 37231 3419 10 good good JJ 37231 3419 11 fruit fruit NN 37231 3419 12 is be VBZ 37231 3419 13 hewn hew VBN 37231 3419 14 down down RP 37231 3419 15 and and CC 37231 3419 16 cast cast VBD 37231 3419 17 into into IN 37231 3419 18 the the DT 37231 3419 19 fire fire NN 37231 3419 20 , , , 37231 3419 21 " " '' 37231 3419 22 which which WDT 37231 3419 23 , , , 37231 3419 24 with with IN 37231 3419 25 the the DT 37231 3419 26 exception exception NN 37231 3419 27 of of IN 37231 3419 28 one one CD 37231 3419 29 word word NN 37231 3419 30 , , , 37231 3419 31 " " '' 37231 3419 32 but but CC 37231 3419 33 , , , 37231 3419 34 " " '' 37231 3419 35 at at IN 37231 3419 36 the the DT 37231 3419 37 commencement commencement NN 37231 3419 38 of of IN 37231 3419 39 the the DT 37231 3419 40 sentence sentence NN 37231 3419 41 in in IN 37231 3419 42 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3419 43 , , , 37231 3419 44 also also RB 37231 3419 45 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3419 46 with with IN 37231 3419 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3419 48 quotation quotation NN 37231 3419 49 . . . 37231 3420 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3420 2 3 3 LS 37231 3420 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3420 4 In in IN 37231 3420 5 these these DT 37231 3420 6 two two CD 37231 3420 7 short short JJ 37231 3420 8 passages passage NNS 37231 3420 9 there there EX 37231 3420 10 are be VBP 37231 3420 11 no no DT 37231 3420 12 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 37231 3420 13 specially specially RB 37231 3420 14 pointing point VBG 37231 3420 15 to to IN 37231 3420 16 the the DT 37231 3420 17 first first JJ 37231 3420 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3420 19 as as IN 37231 3420 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3420 21 source source NN 37231 3420 22 , , , 37231 3420 23 and and CC 37231 3420 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3420 25 can can MD 37231 3420 26 not not RB 37231 3420 27 be be VB 37231 3420 28 too too RB 37231 3420 29 often often RB 37231 3420 30 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3420 31 that that IN 37231 3420 32 the the DT 37231 3420 33 mere mere JJ 37231 3420 34 coincidence coincidence NN 37231 3420 35 of of IN 37231 3420 36 short short JJ 37231 3420 37 historical historical JJ 37231 3420 38 sayings saying NNS 37231 3420 39 in in IN 37231 3420 40 two two CD 37231 3420 41 works work NNS 37231 3420 42 by by IN 37231 3420 43 no no DT 37231 3420 44 means means NN 37231 3420 45 warrants warrant NNS 37231 3420 46 the the DT 37231 3420 47 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3420 48 that that IN 37231 3420 49 the the DT 37231 3420 50 one one NN 37231 3420 51 is be VBZ 37231 3420 52 dependent dependent JJ 37231 3420 53 on on IN 37231 3420 54 the the DT 37231 3420 55 other other JJ 37231 3420 56 . . . 37231 3421 1 In in IN 37231 3421 2 order order NN 37231 3421 3 , , , 37231 3421 4 however however RB 37231 3421 5 , , , 37231 3421 6 to to TO 37231 3421 7 enable enable VB 37231 3421 8 the the DT 37231 3421 9 reader reader NN 37231 3421 10 to to TO 37231 3421 11 form form VB 37231 3421 12 a a DT 37231 3421 13 correct correct JJ 37231 3421 14 estimate estimate NN 37231 3421 15 of of IN 37231 3421 16 the the DT 37231 3421 17 value value NN 37231 3421 18 of of IN 37231 3421 19 the the DT 37231 3421 20 similarity similarity NN 37231 3421 21 of of IN 37231 3421 22 the the DT 37231 3421 23 two two CD 37231 3421 24 passages passage NNS 37231 3421 25 above above IN 37231 3421 26 noted note VBD 37231 3421 27 , , , 37231 3421 28 and and CC 37231 3421 29 also also RB 37231 3421 30 at at IN 37231 3421 31 the the DT 37231 3421 32 same same JJ 37231 3421 33 time time NN 37231 3421 34 to to TO 37231 3421 35 examine examine VB 37231 3421 36 a a DT 37231 3421 37 considerable considerable JJ 37231 3421 38 body body NN 37231 3421 39 of of IN 37231 3421 40 evidence evidence NN 37231 3421 41 , , , 37231 3421 42 selected select VBN 37231 3421 43 with with IN 37231 3421 44 { { -LRB- 37231 3421 45 315 315 CD 37231 3421 46 } } -RRB- 37231 3421 47 evident evident JJ 37231 3421 48 impartiality impartiality NN 37231 3421 49 , , , 37231 3421 50 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3421 51 propose propose VBP 37231 3421 52 to to TO 37231 3421 53 take take VB 37231 3421 54 all all DT 37231 3421 55 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3421 56 's 's POS 37231 3421 57 readings reading NNS 37231 3421 58 of of IN 37231 3421 59 the the DT 37231 3421 60 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3421 61 on on IN 37231 3421 62 the the DT 37231 3421 63 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3421 64 , , , 37231 3421 65 from from IN 37231 3421 66 which which WDT 37231 3421 67 the the DT 37231 3421 68 above above JJ 37231 3421 69 passages passage NNS 37231 3421 70 are be VBP 37231 3421 71 taken take VBN 37231 3421 72 , , , 37231 3421 73 and and CC 37231 3421 74 compare compare VB 37231 3421 75 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3421 76 with with IN 37231 3421 77 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3421 78 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3421 79 . . . 37231 3422 1 This this DT 37231 3422 2 should should MD 37231 3422 3 furnish furnish VB 37231 3422 4 a a DT 37231 3422 5 fair fair JJ 37231 3422 6 test test NN 37231 3422 7 of of IN 37231 3422 8 the the DT 37231 3422 9 composition composition NN 37231 3422 10 of of IN 37231 3422 11 the the DT 37231 3422 12 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3422 13 of of IN 37231 3422 14 the the DT 37231 3422 15 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3422 16 . . . 37231 3423 1 Taking take VBG 37231 3423 2 first first RB 37231 3423 3 , , , 37231 3423 4 for for IN 37231 3423 5 the the DT 37231 3423 6 sake sake NN 37231 3423 7 of of IN 37231 3423 8 continuity continuity NN 37231 3423 9 , , , 37231 3423 10 the the DT 37231 3423 11 first first JJ 37231 3423 12 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3423 13 , , , 37231 3423 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3423 15 find find VBP 37231 3423 16 that that IN 37231 3423 17 Chapters Chapters NNPS 37231 3423 18 xv xv NNP 37231 3423 19 . . NNP 37231 3423 20 , , , 37231 3423 21 xvi xvi NNP 37231 3423 22 . . NNP 37231 3423 23 , , , 37231 3423 24 xvii xvii NN 37231 3423 25 . . . 37231 3423 26 , , , 37231 3423 27 are be VBP 37231 3423 28 composed compose VBN 37231 3423 29 almost almost RB 37231 3423 30 entirely entirely RB 37231 3423 31 of of IN 37231 3423 32 examples example NNS 37231 3423 33 of of IN 37231 3423 34 what what WP 37231 3423 35 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3423 36 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3423 37 taught teach VBD 37231 3423 38 , , , 37231 3423 39 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3423 40 by by IN 37231 3423 41 the the DT 37231 3423 42 remark remark NN 37231 3423 43 with with IN 37231 3423 44 which which WDT 37231 3423 45 Chapter Chapter NNP 37231 3423 46 xiv xiv NN 37231 3423 47 . . . 37231 3424 1 closes close NNS 37231 3424 2 , , , 37231 3424 3 that that DT 37231 3424 4 : : : 37231 3424 5 " " `` 37231 3424 6 Brief brief NN 37231 3424 7 and and CC 37231 3424 8 concise concise JJ 37231 3424 9 sentences sentence NNS 37231 3424 10 were be VBD 37231 3424 11 uttered utter VBN 37231 3424 12 by by IN 37231 3424 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3424 14 , , , 37231 3424 15 for for IN 37231 3424 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3424 17 was be VBD 37231 3424 18 not not RB 37231 3424 19 a a DT 37231 3424 20 sophist sophist NN 37231 3424 21 , , , 37231 3424 22 but but CC 37231 3424 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3424 24 word word NN 37231 3424 25 was be VBD 37231 3424 26 the the DT 37231 3424 27 power power NN 37231 3424 28 of of IN 37231 3424 29 God God NNP 37231 3424 30 . . . 37231 3425 1 " " `` 37231 3425 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3425 3 1 1 LS 37231 3425 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3425 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3425 6 may may MD 37231 3425 7 broadly broadly RB 37231 3425 8 be be VB 37231 3425 9 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 3425 10 that that IN 37231 3425 11 , , , 37231 3425 12 with with IN 37231 3425 13 the the DT 37231 3425 14 exception exception NN 37231 3425 15 of of IN 37231 3425 16 the the DT 37231 3425 17 few few JJ 37231 3425 18 words word NNS 37231 3425 19 quoted quote VBN 37231 3425 20 above above RB 37231 3425 21 by by IN 37231 3425 22 De De NNP 37231 3425 23 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3425 24 , , , 37231 3425 25 not not RB 37231 3425 26 a a DT 37231 3425 27 single single JJ 37231 3425 28 quotation quotation NN 37231 3425 29 of of IN 37231 3425 30 the the DT 37231 3425 31 words word NNS 37231 3425 32 of of IN 37231 3425 33 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3425 34 in in IN 37231 3425 35 these these DT 37231 3425 36 three three CD 37231 3425 37 chapters chapter NNS 37231 3425 38 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3425 39 with with IN 37231 3425 40 the the DT 37231 3425 41 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3425 42 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3425 43 . . . 37231 3426 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3426 2 shall shall MD 37231 3426 3 however however RB 37231 3426 4 confine confine VB 37231 3426 5 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3426 6 at at IN 37231 3426 7 present present NN 37231 3426 8 to to IN 37231 3426 9 the the DT 37231 3426 10 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3426 11 on on IN 37231 3426 12 the the DT 37231 3426 13 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3426 14 . . . 37231 3427 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3427 2 must must MD 37231 3427 3 mention mention VB 37231 3427 4 that that IN 37231 3427 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3427 6 's 's POS 37231 3427 7 text text NN 37231 3427 8 is be VBZ 37231 3427 9 quite quite RB 37231 3427 10 continuous continuous JJ 37231 3427 11 , , , 37231 3427 12 except except IN 37231 3427 13 where where WRB 37231 3427 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3427 15 have have VBP 37231 3427 16 inserted insert VBN 37231 3427 17 asterisks asterisk NNS 37231 3427 18 . . . 37231 3428 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3428 2 subjoin subjoin VBP 37231 3428 3 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3428 4 's 's POS 37231 3428 5 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3428 6 , , , 37231 3428 7 together together RB 37231 3428 8 with with IN 37231 3428 9 ' ' '' 37231 3428 10 the the DT 37231 3428 11 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3428 12 passages passage NNS 37231 3428 13 in in IN 37231 3428 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3428 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3428 16 , , , 37231 3428 17 side side NN 37231 3428 18 by by IN 37231 3428 19 side side NN 37231 3428 20 , , , 37231 3428 21 for for IN 37231 3428 22 greater great JJR 37231 3428 23 facility facility NN 37231 3428 24 of of IN 37231 3428 25 comparison comparison NN 37231 3428 26 . . . 37231 3429 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3429 2 2 2 LS 37231 3429 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3429 4 1 1 CD 37231 3429 5 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3429 6 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3429 7 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3429 8 How how WRB 37231 3429 9 completely completely RB 37231 3429 10 this this DT 37231 3429 11 description description NN 37231 3429 12 contradicts contradict VBZ 37231 3429 13 the the DT 37231 3429 14 representation representation NN 37231 3429 15 of of IN 37231 3429 16 the the DT 37231 3429 17 fourth fourth JJ 37231 3429 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3429 19 of of IN 37231 3429 20 the the DT 37231 3429 21 discourses discourse NNS 37231 3429 22 of of IN 37231 3429 23 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3429 24 . . . 37231 3430 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3430 2 seems seem VBZ 37231 3430 3 clearly clearly RB 37231 3430 4 to to TO 37231 3430 5 indicate indicate VB 37231 3430 6 that that IN 37231 3430 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3430 8 had have VBD 37231 3430 9 no no DT 37231 3430 10 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 3430 11 of of IN 37231 3430 12 that that DT 37231 3430 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3430 14 . . . 37231 3431 1 2 2 LS 37231 3431 2 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3431 3 need nee MD 37231 3431 4 not not RB 37231 3431 5 be be VB 37231 3431 6 said say VBN 37231 3431 7 that that IN 37231 3431 8 the the DT 37231 3431 9 variations variation NNS 37231 3431 10 between between IN 37231 3431 11 the the DT 37231 3431 12 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3431 13 of of IN 37231 3431 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3431 15 and and CC 37231 3431 16 the the DT 37231 3431 17 text text NN 37231 3431 18 of of IN 37231 3431 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3431 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3431 21 must must MD 37231 3431 22 be be VB 37231 3431 23 looked look VBN 37231 3431 24 for for IN 37231 3431 25 only only RB 37231 3431 26 in in IN 37231 3431 27 the the DT 37231 3431 28 Greek Greek NNP 37231 3431 29 . . . 37231 3432 1 For for IN 37231 3432 2 the the DT 37231 3432 3 sake sake NN 37231 3432 4 of of IN 37231 3432 5 the the DT 37231 3432 6 reader reader NN 37231 3432 7 unacquainted unacquainte VBN 37231 3432 8 with with IN 37231 3432 9 Greok Greok NNP 37231 3432 10 , , , 37231 3432 11 however however RB 37231 3432 12 , , , 37231 3432 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3432 14 shall shall MD 37231 3432 15 endeavour endeavour VB 37231 3432 16 as as RB 37231 3432 17 far far RB 37231 3432 18 as as IN 37231 3432 19 possible possible JJ 37231 3432 20 to to TO 37231 3432 21 indicate indicate VB 37231 3432 22 in in IN 37231 3432 23 translation translation NN 37231 3432 24 where where WRB 37231 3432 25 differences difference NNS 37231 3432 26 exist exist VBP 37231 3432 27 , , , 37231 3432 28 although although IN 37231 3432 29 this this DT 37231 3432 30 can can MD 37231 3432 31 not not RB 37231 3432 32 of of RB 37231 3432 33 course course NN 37231 3432 34 be be VB 37231 3432 35 fully fully RB 37231 3432 36 done do VBN 37231 3432 37 , , , 37231 3432 38 nor nor CC 37231 3432 39 often often RB 37231 3432 40 , , , 37231 3432 41 without without IN 37231 3432 42 being be VBG 37231 3432 43 more more RBR 37231 3432 44 literal literal JJ 37231 3432 45 than than IN 37231 3432 46 is be VBZ 37231 3432 47 desirable desirable JJ 37231 3432 48 . . . 37231 3433 1 Whore whore WP 37231 3433 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3433 3 is be VBZ 37231 3433 4 not not RB 37231 3433 5 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3433 6 to to TO 37231 3433 7 amend amend VB 37231 3433 8 the the DT 37231 3433 9 authorized authorize VBN 37231 3433 10 version version NN 37231 3433 11 of of IN 37231 3433 12 the the DT 37231 3433 13 New New NNP 37231 3433 14 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3433 15 for for IN 37231 3433 16 the the DT 37231 3433 17 sake sake NN 37231 3433 18 of of IN 37231 3433 19 more more RBR 37231 3433 20 closely closely RB 37231 3433 21 following follow VBG 37231 3433 22 the the DT 37231 3433 23 text text NN 37231 3433 24 , , , 37231 3433 25 and and CC 37231 3433 26 marking mark VBG 37231 3433 27 differences difference NNS 37231 3433 28 from from IN 37231 3433 29 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3433 30 , , , 37231 3433 31 wo wo MD 37231 3433 32 shall shall MD 37231 3433 33 adopt adopt VB 37231 3433 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3433 35 . . . 37231 3434 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3434 2 divide divide VBP 37231 3434 3 the the DT 37231 3434 4 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3434 5 where where WRB 37231 3434 6 desirable desirable JJ 37231 3434 7 by by IN 37231 3434 8 initial initial JJ 37231 3434 9 letters letter NNS 37231 3434 10 , , , 37231 3434 11 in in IN 37231 3434 12 order order NN 37231 3434 13 to to TO 37231 3434 14 assist assist VB 37231 3434 15 reference reference NN 37231 3434 16 at at IN 37231 3434 17 the the DT 37231 3434 18 end end NN 37231 3434 19 of of IN 37231 3434 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3434 21 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3434 22 from from IN 37231 3434 23 the the DT 37231 3434 24 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3434 25 on on IN 37231 3434 26 the the DT 37231 3434 27 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3434 28 . . . 37231 3435 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3435 2 340 340 CD 37231 3435 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3435 4 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3435 5 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3435 6 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3435 7 4 4 CD 37231 3435 8 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3435 9 . . . 37231 3436 1 v. v. CC 37231 3436 2 29 29 CD 37231 3436 3 , , , 37231 3436 4 30 30 CD 37231 3436 5 , , , 37231 3436 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3436 7 will will MD 37231 3436 8 be be VB 37231 3436 9 remembered remember VBN 37231 3436 10 , , , 37231 3436 11 are be VBP 37231 3436 12 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3436 13 with with IN 37231 3436 14 some some DT 37231 3436 15 variation variation NN 37231 3436 16 and and CC 37231 3436 17 also also RB 37231 3436 18 reversed reverse VBN 37231 3436 19 in in IN 37231 3436 20 order order NN 37231 3436 21 , , , 37231 3436 22 and and CC 37231 3436 23 with with IN 37231 3436 24 a a DT 37231 3436 25 totally totally RB 37231 3436 26 different different JJ 37231 3436 27 context context NN 37231 3436 28 , , , 37231 3436 29 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3436 30 , , , 37231 3436 31 xviii xviii NN 37231 3436 32 . . . 37231 3437 1 8 8 CD 37231 3437 2 , , , 37231 3437 3 9 9 CD 37231 3437 4 . . . 37231 3438 1 The the DT 37231 3438 2 latter latter JJ 37231 3438 3 verse verse NN 37231 3438 4 , , , 37231 3438 5 the the DT 37231 3438 6 Greek Greek NNP 37231 3438 7 of of IN 37231 3438 8 the the DT 37231 3438 9 concluding concluding NN 37231 3438 10 part part NN 37231 3438 11 of of IN 37231 3438 12 which which WDT 37231 3438 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3438 14 give give VBP 37231 3438 15 above above RB 37231 3438 16 , , , 37231 3438 17 approximates approximate VBZ 37231 3438 18 more more RBR 37231 3438 19 nearly nearly RB 37231 3438 20 in in IN 37231 3438 21 form form NN 37231 3438 22 to to IN 37231 3438 23 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3438 24 's 's POS 37231 3438 25 , , , 37231 3438 26 but but CC 37231 3438 27 is be VBZ 37231 3438 28 still still RB 37231 3438 29 widely widely RB 37231 3438 30 different different JJ 37231 3438 31 . . . 37231 3439 1 " " `` 37231 3439 2 And and CC 37231 3439 3 if if IN 37231 3439 4 thine thine NN 37231 3439 5 eye eye NN 37231 3439 6 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3439 7 ' ' `` 37231 3439 8 right right UH 37231 3439 9 ' ' '' 37231 3439 10 omitted omit VBN 37231 3439 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3439 12 offend offend VB 37231 3439 13 thee thee NN 37231 3439 14 pluck pluck VBD 37231 3439 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3439 16 out out RP 37231 3439 17 and and CC 37231 3439 18 cast cast VBD 37231 3439 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3439 20 from from IN 37231 3439 21 theo theo NN 37231 3439 22 ; ; : 37231 3439 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3439 24 is be VBZ 37231 3439 25 good good JJ 37231 3439 26 for for IN 37231 3439 27 thee thee PRP 37231 3439 28 to to TO 37231 3439 29 enter enter VB 37231 3439 30 into into IN 37231 3439 31 life life NN 37231 3439 32 with with IN 37231 3439 33 one one CD 37231 3439 34 eye eye NN 37231 3439 35 , , , 37231 3439 36 rather rather RB 37231 3439 37 than than IN 37231 3439 38 having have VBG 37231 3439 39 two two CD 37231 3439 40 eyes eye NNS 37231 3439 41 to to TO 37231 3439 42 be be VB 37231 3439 43 cast cast VBN 37231 3439 44 into into IN 37231 3439 45 hell hell NNP 37231 3439 46 fire fire NN 37231 3439 47 . . . 37231 3439 48 " " '' 37231 3440 1 The the DT 37231 3440 2 sequence sequence NN 37231 3440 3 of of IN 37231 3440 4 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3440 5 . . . 37231 3441 1 v. v. CC 37231 3441 2 28 28 CD 37231 3441 3 , , , 37231 3441 4 29 29 CD 37231 3441 5 , , , 37231 3441 6 points point VBZ 37231 3441 7 specially specially RB 37231 3441 8 to to IN 37231 3441 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3441 10 . . . 37231 3442 1 The the DT 37231 3442 2 double double JJ 37231 3442 3 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 3442 4 of of IN 37231 3442 5 this this DT 37231 3442 6 passage passage NN 37231 3442 7 , , , 37231 3442 8 however however RB 37231 3442 9 , , , 37231 3442 10 with with IN 37231 3442 11 a a DT 37231 3442 12 different different JJ 37231 3442 13 context context NN 37231 3442 14 , , , 37231 3442 15 and and CC 37231 3442 16 with with IN 37231 3442 17 the the DT 37231 3442 18 order order NN 37231 3442 19 reversed reverse VBN 37231 3442 20 in in IN 37231 3442 21 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3442 22 , , , 37231 3442 23 renders render VBZ 37231 3442 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3442 25 almost almost RB 37231 3442 26 certain certain JJ 37231 3442 27 that that IN 37231 3442 28 the the DT 37231 3442 29 two two CD 37231 3442 30 passages passage NNS 37231 3442 31 A. A. NNP 37231 3442 32 and and CC 37231 3442 33 B. B. NNP 37231 3442 34 were be VBD 37231 3442 35 separate separate JJ 37231 3442 36 in in IN 37231 3442 37 the the DT 37231 3442 38 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3442 39 . . . 37231 3443 1 The the DT 37231 3443 2 reading reading NN 37231 3443 3 of of IN 37231 3443 4 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3443 5 ix ix NNP 37231 3443 6 . . . 37231 3444 1 47 47 CD 37231 3444 2 , , , 37231 3444 3 is be VBZ 37231 3444 4 equally equally RB 37231 3444 5 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3444 6 from from IN 37231 3444 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3444 8 's 's POS 37231 3444 9 : : : 37231 3444 10 And and CC 37231 3444 11 if if IN 37231 3444 12 thine thine NN 37231 3444 13 eye eye NNP 37231 3444 14 offend offend VBP 37231 3444 15 thee thee PRP 37231 3444 16 cast cast VBD 37231 3444 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3444 18 out out RP 37231 3444 19 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3444 20 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3444 21 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3444 22 ; ; : 37231 3444 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3444 24 is be VBZ 37231 3444 25 good good JJ 37231 3444 26 for for IN 37231 3444 27 thee thee PRP 37231 3444 28 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3444 29 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3444 30 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3444 31 to to TO 37231 3444 32 enter enter VB 37231 3444 33 into into IN 37231 3444 34 the the DT 37231 3444 35 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 3444 36 of of IN 37231 3444 37 God God NNP 37231 3444 38 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3444 39 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3444 40 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3444 41 with with IN 37231 3444 42 one one CD 37231 3444 43 eye eye NN 37231 3444 44 rather rather RB 37231 3444 45 than than IN 37231 3444 46 having have VBG 37231 3444 47 two two CD 37231 3444 48 eyes eye NNS 37231 3444 49 to to TO 37231 3444 50 be be VB 37231 3444 51 cast cast VBN 37231 3444 52 into into IN 37231 3444 53 hell hell NN 37231 3444 54 , , , 37231 3444 55 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3444 56 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3444 57 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3444 58 { { -LRB- 37231 3444 59 347 347 CD 37231 3444 60 } } -RRB- 37231 3444 61 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3444 62 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3444 63 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3444 64 { { -LRB- 37231 3444 65 348 348 CD 37231 3444 66 } } -RRB- 37231 3444 67 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3444 68 ---Greek--- ---greek--- NN 37231 3444 69 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3444 70 1 1 CD 37231 3444 71 In in IN 37231 3444 72 the the DT 37231 3444 73 first first JJ 37231 3444 74 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3444 75 the the DT 37231 3444 76 subject subject NN 37231 3444 77 breaks break VBZ 37231 3444 78 off off RP 37231 3444 79 at at IN 37231 3444 80 the the DT 37231 3444 81 end end NN 37231 3444 82 of of IN 37231 3444 83 v. v. IN 37231 3444 84 42 42 CD 37231 3444 85 . . . 37231 3444 86 v. v. CC 37231 3444 87 40 40 CD 37231 3444 88 may may MD 37231 3444 89 be be VB 37231 3444 90 compared compare VBN 37231 3444 91 with with IN 37231 3444 92 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3444 93 's 's POS 37231 3444 94 continuation continuation NN 37231 3444 95 , , , 37231 3444 96 but but CC 37231 3444 97 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3444 98 is be VBZ 37231 3444 99 fundamentally fundamentally RB 37231 3444 100 different different JJ 37231 3444 101 . . . 37231 3445 1 The the DT 37231 3445 2 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3445 3 passages passage NNS 37231 3445 4 in in IN 37231 3445 5 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3445 6 vi vi NNP 37231 3445 7 . . . 37231 3446 1 30 30 CD 37231 3446 2 , , , 37231 3446 3 34 34 CD 37231 3446 4 , , , 37231 3446 5 present present JJ 37231 3446 6 still still RB 37231 3446 7 greater great JJR 37231 3446 8 variations variation NNS 37231 3446 9 . . . 37231 3447 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3447 2 have have VBP 37231 3447 3 given give VBN 37231 3447 4 vi vi NNP 37231 3447 5 . . . 37231 3448 1 34 34 CD 37231 3448 2 above above RB 37231 3448 3 , , , 37231 3448 4 as as IN 37231 3448 5 nearer near JJR 37231 3448 6 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3448 7 than than IN 37231 3448 8 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3448 9 . . . 37231 3449 1 v. v. CC 37231 3449 2 46 46 CD 37231 3449 3 . . . 37231 3450 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3450 2 will will MD 37231 3450 3 be be VB 37231 3450 4 remarked remark VBN 37231 3450 5 that that DT 37231 3450 6 to to TO 37231 3450 7 find find VB 37231 3450 8 a a DT 37231 3450 9 parallel parallel NN 37231 3450 10 for for IN 37231 3450 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3450 12 's 's POS 37231 3450 13 continuation continuation NN 37231 3450 14 , , , 37231 3450 15 without without IN 37231 3450 16 break break NN 37231 3450 17 , , , 37231 3450 18 of of IN 37231 3450 19 the the DT 37231 3450 20 subject subject NN 37231 3450 21 , , , 37231 3450 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3450 23 must must MD 37231 3450 24 jump jump VB 37231 3450 25 from from IN 37231 3450 26 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3450 27 . . . 37231 3451 1 v. v. CC 37231 3451 2 42 42 CD 37231 3451 3 , , , 37231 3451 4 46 46 CD 37231 3451 5 , , , 37231 3451 6 to to IN 37231 3451 7 vi vi NNP 37231 3451 8 . . . 37231 3452 1 19 19 CD 37231 3452 2 , , , 37231 3452 3 20 20 CD 37231 3452 4 . . . 37231 3453 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3453 2 349 349 CD 37231 3453 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3453 4 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3453 5 ---Greek--- ---greek--- NN 37231 3453 6 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3453 7 1 1 CD 37231 3453 8 This this DT 37231 3453 9 phrase phrase NN 37231 3453 10 , , , 37231 3453 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3453 12 will will MD 37231 3453 13 bo bo NNP 37231 3453 14 observed observed JJ 37231 3453 15 , , , 37231 3453 16 is be VBZ 37231 3453 17 also also RB 37231 3453 18 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3453 19 higher higher RBR 37231 3453 20 up up RB 37231 3453 21 in in IN 37231 3453 22 the the DT 37231 3453 23 passage passage NN 37231 3453 24 , , , 37231 3453 25 and and CC 37231 3453 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3453 27 repetition repetition NN 37231 3453 28 in in IN 37231 3453 29 such such PDT 37231 3453 30 a a DT 37231 3453 31 manner manner NN 37231 3453 32 , , , 37231 3453 33 with with IN 37231 3453 34 the the DT 37231 3453 35 same same JJ 37231 3453 36 variations variation NNS 37231 3453 37 , , , 37231 3453 38 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 3453 39 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 37231 3453 40 the the DT 37231 3453 41 unity unity NN 37231 3453 42 of of IN 37231 3453 43 the the DT 37231 3453 44 whole whole JJ 37231 3453 45 quotation quotation NN 37231 3453 46 . . . 37231 3454 1 2 2 LS 37231 3454 2 There there EX 37231 3454 3 is be VBZ 37231 3454 4 no no DT 37231 3454 5 parallel parallel NN 37231 3454 6 to to IN 37231 3454 7 this this DT 37231 3454 8 in in IN 37231 3454 9 the the DT 37231 3454 10 first first JJ 37231 3454 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3454 12 . . . 37231 3455 1 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3455 2 . . . 37231 3456 1 v. v. CC 37231 3456 2 48 48 CD 37231 3456 3 , , , 37231 3456 4 is be VBZ 37231 3456 5 too too RB 37231 3456 6 remote remote JJ 37231 3456 7 in in IN 37231 3456 8 sense sense NN 37231 3456 9 as as RB 37231 3456 10 well well RB 37231 3456 11 as as IN 37231 3456 12 language language NN 37231 3456 13 . . . 37231 3457 1 3 3 CD 37231 3457 2 The the DT 37231 3457 3 first first JJ 37231 3457 4 part part NN 37231 3457 5 of of IN 37231 3457 6 v. v. IN 37231 3457 7 45 45 CD 37231 3457 8 is be VBZ 37231 3457 9 quite quite RB 37231 3457 10 different different JJ 37231 3457 11 from from IN 37231 3457 12 the the DT 37231 3457 13 context context NN 37231 3457 14 in in IN 37231 3457 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3457 16 : : : 37231 3457 17 " " `` 37231 3457 18 That that IN 37231 3457 19 ye ye NNP 37231 3457 20 may may MD 37231 3457 21 be be VB 37231 3457 22 sons son NNS 37231 3457 23 of of IN 37231 3457 24 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3457 25 Father Father NNP 37231 3457 26 which which WDT 37231 3457 27 is be VBZ 37231 3457 28 in in IN 37231 3457 29 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3457 30 : : : 37231 3457 31 for for IN 37231 3457 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3457 33 maketh maketh NNP 37231 3457 34 , , , 37231 3457 35 " " '' 37231 3457 36 & & CC 37231 3457 37 c c NNP 37231 3457 38 , , , 37231 3457 39 & & CC 37231 3457 40 c. c. NNP 37231 3457 41 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 42 350 350 CD 37231 3457 43 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 44 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 45 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 46 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 47 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 48 351 351 CD 37231 3457 49 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 50 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 51 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 52 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 53 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 54 352 352 CD 37231 3457 55 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 56 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 57 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 58 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 59 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 60 353 353 CD 37231 3457 61 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 62 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 63 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 64 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 65 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 66 354 354 CD 37231 3457 67 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 68 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 69 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 70 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 71 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 72 355 355 CD 37231 3457 73 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 74 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 75 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 76 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 77 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 78 356 356 CD 37231 3457 79 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 80 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 81 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 82 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 83 { { -LRB- 37231 3457 84 357 357 CD 37231 3457 85 } } -RRB- 37231 3457 86 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3457 87 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3457 88 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3457 89 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3457 90 have have VBP 37231 3457 91 taken take VBN 37231 3457 92 the the DT 37231 3457 93 whole whole NN 37231 3457 94 of of IN 37231 3457 95 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3457 96 's 's POS 37231 3457 97 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3457 98 from from IN 37231 3457 99 the the DT 37231 3457 100 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3457 101 on on IN 37231 3457 102 the the DT 37231 3457 103 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3457 104 not not RB 37231 3457 105 only only RB 37231 3457 106 because because IN 37231 3457 107 , , , 37231 3457 108 adopting adopt VBG 37231 3457 109 so so RB 37231 3457 110 large large JJ 37231 3457 111 a a DT 37231 3457 112 test test NN 37231 3457 113 , , , 37231 3457 114 there there EX 37231 3457 115 can can MD 37231 3457 116 be be VB 37231 3457 117 no no DT 37231 3457 118 suspicion suspicion NN 37231 3457 119 that that IN 37231 3457 120 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3457 121 select select VBP 37231 3457 122 passages passage NNS 37231 3457 123 for for IN 37231 3457 124 any any DT 37231 3457 125 special special JJ 37231 3457 126 purpose purpose NN 37231 3457 127 , , , 37231 3457 128 but but CC 37231 3457 129 also also RB 37231 3457 130 because because IN 37231 3457 131 , , , 37231 3457 132 on on IN 37231 3457 133 the the DT 37231 3457 134 contrary contrary NN 37231 3457 135 , , , 37231 3457 136 amongst amongst IN 37231 3457 137 these these DT 37231 3457 138 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3457 139 are be VBP 37231 3457 140 more more JJR 37231 3457 141 of of IN 37231 3457 142 the the DT 37231 3457 143 passages passage NNS 37231 3457 144 claimed claim VBD 37231 3457 145 as as IN 37231 3457 146 showing show VBG 37231 3457 147 the the DT 37231 3457 148 use use NN 37231 3457 149 of of IN 37231 3457 150 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3457 151 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3457 152 than than IN 37231 3457 153 any any DT 37231 3457 154 series series NN 37231 3457 155 which which WDT 37231 3457 156 could could MD 37231 3457 157 have have VB 37231 3457 158 been be VBN 37231 3457 159 selected select VBN 37231 3457 160 . . . 37231 3458 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3458 2 will will MD 37231 3458 3 have have VB 37231 3458 4 been be VBN 37231 3458 5 observed observe VBN 37231 3458 6 that that IN 37231 3458 7 most most JJS 37231 3458 8 of of IN 37231 3458 9 the the DT 37231 3458 10 passages passage NNS 37231 3458 11 follow follow VBP 37231 3458 12 each each DT 37231 3458 13 other other JJ 37231 3458 14 in in IN 37231 3458 15 unbroken unbroken JJ 37231 3458 16 sequence sequence NN 37231 3458 17 in in IN 37231 3458 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3458 19 , , , 37231 3458 20 for for IN 37231 3458 21 with with IN 37231 3458 22 the the DT 37231 3458 23 exception exception NN 37231 3458 24 of of IN 37231 3458 25 a a DT 37231 3458 26 short short JJ 37231 3458 27 break break NN 37231 3458 28 between between IN 37231 3458 29 y y NNP 37231 3458 30 and and CC 37231 3458 31 8 8 CD 37231 3458 32 the the DT 37231 3458 33 whole whole JJ 37231 3458 34 extract extract NN 37231 3458 35 down down RP 37231 3458 36 to to IN 37231 3458 37 the the DT 37231 3458 38 end end NN 37231 3458 39 of of IN 37231 3458 40 0 0 CD 37231 3458 41 is be VBZ 37231 3458 42 continuous continuous JJ 37231 3458 43 , , , 37231 3458 44 as as RB 37231 3458 45 indeed indeed RB 37231 3458 46 , , , 37231 3458 47 after after IN 37231 3458 48 another another DT 37231 3458 49 brief brief JJ 37231 3458 50 interruption interruption NN 37231 3458 51 at at IN 37231 3458 52 the the DT 37231 3458 53 end end NN 37231 3458 54 of of IN 37231 3458 55 i i PRP 37231 3458 56 , , , 37231 3458 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3458 58 is be VBZ 37231 3458 59 again again RB 37231 3458 60 to to IN 37231 3458 61 the the DT 37231 3458 62 close close NN 37231 3458 63 of of IN 37231 3458 64 the the DT 37231 3458 65 very very RB 37231 3458 66 long long JJ 37231 3458 67 and and CC 37231 3458 68 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3458 69 passage passage NN 37231 3458 70 k. k. NN 37231 3458 71 With with IN 37231 3458 72 two two CD 37231 3458 73 exceptions exception NNS 37231 3458 74 , , , 37231 3458 75 therefore therefore RB 37231 3458 76 , , , 37231 3458 77 the the DT 37231 3458 78 whole whole NN 37231 3458 79 of of IN 37231 3458 80 these these DT 37231 3458 81 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3458 82 from from IN 37231 3458 83 the the DT 37231 3458 84 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3458 85 on on IN 37231 3458 86 the the DT 37231 3458 87 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3458 88 occur occur VBP 37231 3458 89 consecutively consecutively RB 37231 3458 90 in in IN 37231 3458 91 two two CD 37231 3458 92 succeeding succeed VBG 37231 3458 93 chapters chapter NNS 37231 3458 94 of of IN 37231 3458 95 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3458 96 's 's POS 37231 3458 97 first first JJ 37231 3458 98 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3458 99 , , , 37231 3458 100 and and CC 37231 3458 101 one one CD 37231 3458 102 passage passage NN 37231 3458 103 follows follow VBZ 37231 3458 104 in in IN 37231 3458 105 the the DT 37231 3458 106 next next JJ 37231 3458 107 chapter chapter NN 37231 3458 108 . . . 37231 3459 1 Only only RB 37231 3459 2 a a DT 37231 3459 3 single single JJ 37231 3459 4 passage passage NN 37231 3459 5 comes come VBZ 37231 3459 6 from from IN 37231 3459 7 a a DT 37231 3459 8 distant distant JJ 37231 3459 9 part part NN 37231 3459 10 of of IN 37231 3459 11 the the DT 37231 3459 12 dialogue dialogue NN 37231 3459 13 with with IN 37231 3459 14 Trypho Trypho NNP 37231 3459 15 . . . 37231 3460 1 These these DT 37231 3460 2 passages passage NNS 37231 3460 3 are be VBP 37231 3460 4 bound bind VBN 37231 3460 5 together together RB 37231 3460 6 by by IN 37231 3460 7 clear clear JJ 37231 3460 8 unity unity NN 37231 3460 9 of of IN 37231 3460 10 idea idea NN 37231 3460 11 and and CC 37231 3460 12 context context NN 37231 3460 13 , , , 37231 3460 14 and and CC 37231 3460 15 as as IN 37231 3460 16 , , , 37231 3460 17 where where WRB 37231 3460 18 there there EX 37231 3460 19 is be VBZ 37231 3460 20 a a DT 37231 3460 21 separation separation NN 37231 3460 22 of of IN 37231 3460 23 sentences sentence NNS 37231 3460 24 in in IN 37231 3460 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3460 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3460 27 , , , 37231 3460 28 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3460 29 clearly clearly RB 37231 3460 30 marks mark VBZ 37231 3460 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3460 32 by by IN 37231 3460 33 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3460 34 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3460 35 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3460 36 , , , 37231 3460 37 there there EX 37231 3460 38 is be VBZ 37231 3460 39 every every DT 37231 3460 40 reason reason NN 37231 3460 41 to to TO 37231 3460 42 decide decide VB 37231 3460 43 that that IN 37231 3460 44 those those DT 37231 3460 45 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3460 46 which which WDT 37231 3460 47 are be VBP 37231 3460 48 continuous continuous JJ 37231 3460 49 in in IN 37231 3460 50 form form NN 37231 3460 51 and and CC 37231 3460 52 in in IN 37231 3460 53 argument argument NN 37231 3460 54 were be VBD 37231 3460 55 likewise likewise RB 37231 3460 56 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3460 57 in in IN 37231 3460 58 the the DT 37231 3460 59 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3460 60 . . . 37231 3461 1 Now now RB 37231 3461 2 the the DT 37231 3461 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 3461 4 that that WDT 37231 3461 5 these these DT 37231 3461 6 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3461 7 are be VBP 37231 3461 8 from from IN 37231 3461 9 the the DT 37231 3461 10 { { -LRB- 37231 3461 11 358 358 CD 37231 3461 12 } } -RRB- 37231 3461 13 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3461 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3461 15 requires require VBZ 37231 3461 16 the the DT 37231 3461 17 assumption assumption NN 37231 3461 18 of of IN 37231 3461 19 the the DT 37231 3461 20 fact fact NN 37231 3461 21 that that IN 37231 3461 22 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3461 23 , , , 37231 3461 24 with with IN 37231 3461 25 singular singular JJ 37231 3461 26 care care NN 37231 3461 27 , , , 37231 3461 28 collected collect VBN 37231 3461 29 from from IN 37231 3461 30 distant distant JJ 37231 3461 31 and and CC 37231 3461 32 scattered scatter VBN 37231 3461 33 portions portion NNS 37231 3461 34 of of IN 37231 3461 35 those those DT 37231 3461 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3461 37 a a DT 37231 3461 38 series series NN 37231 3461 39 of of IN 37231 3461 40 passages passage NNS 37231 3461 41 in in IN 37231 3461 42 close close JJ 37231 3461 43 sequence sequence NN 37231 3461 44 to to IN 37231 3461 45 each each DT 37231 3461 46 other other JJ 37231 3461 47 , , , 37231 3461 48 forming form VBG 37231 3461 49 a a DT 37231 3461 50 whole whole JJ 37231 3461 51 unknown unknown NN 37231 3461 52 to to IN 37231 3461 53 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3461 54 but but CC 37231 3461 55 complete complete JJ 37231 3461 56 in in IN 37231 3461 57 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3461 58 , , , 37231 3461 59 and and CC 37231 3461 60 yet yet RB 37231 3461 61 , , , 37231 3461 62 although although IN 37231 3461 63 this this DT 37231 3461 64 is be VBZ 37231 3461 65 carefully carefully RB 37231 3461 66 performed perform VBN 37231 3461 67 , , , 37231 3461 68 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3461 69 at at IN 37231 3461 70 the the DT 37231 3461 71 same same JJ 37231 3461 72 time time NN 37231 3461 73 with with IN 37231 3461 74 the the DT 37231 3461 75 most most RBS 37231 3461 76 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3461 77 carelessness carelessness NN 37231 3461 78 misquoted misquote VBN 37231 3461 79 and and CC 37231 3461 80 materially materially RB 37231 3461 81 altered alter VBN 37231 3461 82 almost almost RB 37231 3461 83 every every DT 37231 3461 84 precept precept NN 37231 3461 85 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3461 86 professes profess VBZ 37231 3461 87 to to TO 37231 3461 88 cite cite VB 37231 3461 89 . . . 37231 3462 1 The the DT 37231 3462 2 order order NN 37231 3462 3 of of IN 37231 3462 4 the the DT 37231 3462 5 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3462 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3462 7 is be VBZ 37231 3462 8 as as RB 37231 3462 9 entirely entirely RB 37231 3462 10 set set VBN 37231 3462 11 at at IN 37231 3462 12 naught naught JJ 37231 3462 13 as as IN 37231 3462 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3462 15 language language NN 37231 3462 16 is be VBZ 37231 3462 17 disregarded disregard VBN 37231 3462 18 . . . 37231 3463 1 As as IN 37231 3463 2 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 3463 3 has have VBZ 37231 3463 4 pointed point VBN 37231 3463 5 out out RP 37231 3463 6 , , , 37231 3463 7 throughout throughout IN 37231 3463 8 the the DT 37231 3463 9 whole whole NN 37231 3463 10 of of IN 37231 3463 11 this this DT 37231 3463 12 portion portion NN 37231 3463 13 of of IN 37231 3463 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3463 15 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3463 16 the the DT 37231 3463 17 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 3463 18 endeavour endeavour NN 37231 3463 19 after after IN 37231 3463 20 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3463 21 , , , 37231 3463 22 on on IN 37231 3463 23 the the DT 37231 3463 24 one one CD 37231 3463 25 hand hand NN 37231 3463 26 , , , 37231 3463 27 is be VBZ 37231 3463 28 in in IN 37231 3463 29 the the DT 37231 3463 30 most most RBS 37231 3463 31 glaring glaring JJ 37231 3463 32 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 3463 33 with with IN 37231 3463 34 the the DT 37231 3463 35 monstrous monstrous JJ 37231 3463 36 carelessness carelessness NN 37231 3463 37 on on IN 37231 3463 38 the the DT 37231 3463 39 other other JJ 37231 3463 40 , , , 37231 3463 41 if if IN 37231 3463 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3463 43 be be VB 37231 3463 44 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3463 45 that that IN 37231 3463 46 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3463 47 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3463 48 are be VBP 37231 3463 49 the the DT 37231 3463 50 source source NN 37231 3463 51 from from IN 37231 3463 52 which which WDT 37231 3463 53 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3463 54 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3463 55 . . . 37231 3464 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 3464 2 is be VBZ 37231 3464 3 more more RBR 37231 3464 4 improbable improbable JJ 37231 3464 5 than than IN 37231 3464 6 the the DT 37231 3464 7 conjecture conjecture NN 37231 3464 8 that that WDT 37231 3464 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3464 10 made make VBD 37231 3464 11 use use NN 37231 3464 12 of of IN 37231 3464 13 the the DT 37231 3464 14 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3464 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3464 16 , , , 37231 3464 17 and and CC 37231 3464 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3464 19 must must MD 37231 3464 20 accept accept VB 37231 3464 21 the the DT 37231 3464 22 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3464 23 that that IN 37231 3464 24 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3464 25 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3464 26 with with IN 37231 3464 27 substantial substantial JJ 37231 3464 28 correctness correctness NN 37231 3464 29 the the DT 37231 3464 30 expressions expression NNS 37231 3464 31 in in IN 37231 3464 32 the the DT 37231 3464 33 order order NN 37231 3464 34 in in IN 37231 3464 35 which which WDT 37231 3464 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3464 37 found find VBD 37231 3464 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3464 39 in in IN 37231 3464 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3464 41 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3464 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3464 43 . . . 37231 3465 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3465 2 1 1 LS 37231 3465 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3465 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3465 5 is be VBZ 37231 3465 6 a a DT 37231 3465 7 most most RBS 37231 3465 8 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 3465 9 proceeding proceeding NN 37231 3465 10 to to TO 37231 3465 11 dissect dissect VB 37231 3465 12 a a DT 37231 3465 13 passage passage NN 37231 3465 14 , , , 37231 3465 15 quoted quote VBN 37231 3465 16 by by IN 37231 3465 17 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3465 18 as as IN 37231 3465 19 a a DT 37231 3465 20 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3465 21 and and CC 37231 3465 22 harmonious harmonious JJ 37231 3465 23 whole whole NN 37231 3465 24 , , , 37231 3465 25 and and CC 37231 3465 26 finding finding NN 37231 3465 27 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3465 28 more more RBR 37231 3465 29 or or CC 37231 3465 30 less less RBR 37231 3465 31 approximate approximate JJ 37231 3465 32 to to IN 37231 3465 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3465 34 various various JJ 37231 3465 35 phrases phrase NNS 37231 3465 36 scattered scatter VBN 37231 3465 37 up up RB 37231 3465 38 and and CC 37231 3465 39 down down IN 37231 3465 40 distant distant JJ 37231 3465 41 parts part NNS 37231 3465 42 of of IN 37231 3465 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3465 44 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3465 45 , , , 37231 3465 46 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 3465 47 one one CD 37231 3465 48 of of IN 37231 3465 49 which which WDT 37231 3465 50 is be VBZ 37231 3465 51 not not RB 37231 3465 52 materially materially RB 37231 3465 53 different different JJ 37231 3465 54 from from IN 37231 3465 55 the the DT 37231 3465 56 reading reading NN 37231 3465 57 of of IN 37231 3465 58 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3465 59 , , , 37231 3465 60 to to TO 37231 3465 61 assert assert VB 37231 3465 62 that that IN 37231 3465 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3465 64 is be VBZ 37231 3465 65 quoting quote VBG 37231 3465 66 these these DT 37231 3465 67 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3465 68 freely freely RB 37231 3465 69 from from IN 37231 3465 70 memory memory NN 37231 3465 71 , , , 37231 3465 72 altering alter VBG 37231 3465 73 , , , 37231 3465 74 excising excise VBG 37231 3465 75 , , , 37231 3465 76 combining combine VBG 37231 3465 77 , , , 37231 3465 78 and and CC 37231 3465 79 interweaving interweave VBG 37231 3465 80 texts text NNS 37231 3465 81 , , , 37231 3465 82 and and CC 37231 3465 83 introverting introvert VBG 37231 3465 84 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3465 85 order order NN 37231 3465 86 , , , 37231 3465 87 but but CC 37231 3465 88 nevertheless nevertheless RB 37231 3465 89 making make VBG 37231 3465 90 use use NN 37231 3465 91 of of IN 37231 3465 92 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3465 93 and and CC 37231 3465 94 not not RB 37231 3465 95 of of IN 37231 3465 96 others other NNS 37231 3465 97 . . . 37231 3466 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3466 2 is be VBZ 37231 3466 3 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 3466 4 obvious obvious JJ 37231 3466 5 that that IN 37231 3466 6 such such PDT 37231 3466 7 an an DT 37231 3466 8 assertion assertion NN 37231 3466 9 is be VBZ 37231 3466 10 nothing nothing NN 37231 3466 11 but but IN 37231 3466 12 the the DT 37231 3466 13 merest mere JJS 37231 3466 14 assumption assumption NN 37231 3466 15 . . . 37231 3467 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3467 2 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3467 3 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3467 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3467 5 condemn condemn VBP 37231 3467 6 { { -LRB- 37231 3467 7 359 359 CD 37231 3467 8 } } -RRB- 37231 3467 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3467 10 utterly utterly RB 37231 3467 11 , , , 37231 3467 12 for for IN 37231 3467 13 precisely precisely RB 37231 3467 14 similar similar JJ 37231 3467 15 differences difference NNS 37231 3467 16 of of IN 37231 3467 17 order order NN 37231 3467 18 and and CC 37231 3467 19 language language NN 37231 3467 20 exist exist VBP 37231 3467 21 in in IN 37231 3467 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3467 23 and and CC 37231 3467 24 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 3467 25 between between IN 37231 3467 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3467 27 . . . 37231 3468 1 Not not RB 37231 3468 2 only only RB 37231 3468 3 the the DT 37231 3468 4 language language NN 37231 3468 5 but but CC 37231 3468 6 the the DT 37231 3468 7 order order NN 37231 3468 8 of of IN 37231 3468 9 a a DT 37231 3468 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 3468 11 must must MD 37231 3468 12 have have VB 37231 3468 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3468 14 due due JJ 37231 3468 15 weight weight NN 37231 3468 16 , , , 37231 3468 17 and and CC 37231 3468 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3468 19 have have VBP 37231 3468 20 no no DT 37231 3468 21 right right NN 37231 3468 22 to to TO 37231 3468 23 dismember dismember VB 37231 3468 24 a a DT 37231 3468 25 passage passage NN 37231 3468 26 and and CC 37231 3468 27 , , , 37231 3468 28 discovering discover VBG 37231 3468 29 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 37231 3468 30 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3468 31 in in IN 37231 3468 32 various various JJ 37231 3468 33 parts part NNS 37231 3468 34 of of IN 37231 3468 35 the the DT 37231 3468 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3468 37 , , , 37231 3468 38 to to TO 37231 3468 39 assert assert VB 37231 3468 40 that that IN 37231 3468 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3468 42 is be VBZ 37231 3468 43 compiled compile VBN 37231 3468 44 from from IN 37231 3468 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3468 46 and and CC 37231 3468 47 not not RB 37231 3468 48 derived derive VBN 37231 3468 49 , , , 37231 3468 50 as as IN 37231 3468 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3468 52 stands stand VBZ 37231 3468 53 , , , 37231 3468 54 from from IN 37231 3468 55 another another DT 37231 3468 56 source source NN 37231 3468 57 . . . 37231 3469 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3469 2 1 1 LS 37231 3469 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3469 4 As as IN 37231 3469 5 an an DT 37231 3469 6 illustration illustration NN 37231 3469 7 from from IN 37231 3469 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3469 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3469 10 , , , 37231 3469 11 let let VB 37231 3469 12 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3469 13 for for IN 37231 3469 14 a a DT 37231 3469 15 moment moment NN 37231 3469 16 suppose suppose VB 37231 3469 17 the the DT 37231 3469 18 " " `` 37231 3469 19 Gospel gospel NN 37231 3469 20 according accord VBG 37231 3469 21 to to IN 37231 3469 22 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3469 23 " " '' 37231 3469 24 to to TO 37231 3469 25 have have VB 37231 3469 26 been be VBN 37231 3469 27 lost lose VBN 37231 3469 28 , , , 37231 3469 29 like like IN 37231 3469 30 the the DT 37231 3469 31 " " `` 37231 3469 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3469 33 according accord VBG 37231 3469 34 to to IN 37231 3469 35 the the DT 37231 3469 36 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3469 37 " " '' 37231 3469 38 and and CC 37231 3469 39 so so RB 37231 3469 40 many many JJ 37231 3469 41 others other NNS 37231 3469 42 . . . 37231 3470 1 In in IN 37231 3470 2 the the DT 37231 3470 3 works work NNS 37231 3470 4 of of IN 37231 3470 5 one one CD 37231 3470 6 of of IN 37231 3470 7 the the DT 37231 3470 8 Fathers father NNS 37231 3470 9 , , , 37231 3470 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3470 11 discover discover VBP 37231 3470 12 the the DT 37231 3470 13 following follow VBG 37231 3470 14 quotation quotation NN 37231 3470 15 from from IN 37231 3470 16 an an DT 37231 3470 17 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 3470 18 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 3470 19 work work NN 37231 3470 20 : : : 37231 3470 21 " " `` 37231 3470 22 And and CC 37231 3470 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3470 24 said say VBD 37231 3470 25 unto unto IN 37231 3470 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3470 27 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3470 28 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3470 29 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3470 30 : : : 37231 3470 31 The the DT 37231 3470 32 harvest harvest NN 37231 3470 33 truly truly RB 37231 3470 34 is be VBZ 37231 3470 35 great great JJ 37231 3470 36 but but CC 37231 3470 37 the the DT 37231 3470 38 labourers labourer NNS 37231 3470 39 are be VBP 37231 3470 40 few few JJ 37231 3470 41 : : : 37231 3470 42 pray pray VB 37231 3470 43 ye ye NNP 37231 3470 44 therefore therefore RB 37231 3470 45 the the DT 37231 3470 46 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3470 47 of of IN 37231 3470 48 the the DT 37231 3470 49 harvest harvest NN 37231 3470 50 that that WDT 37231 3470 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3470 52 would would MD 37231 3470 53 send send VB 37231 3470 54 forth forth RB 37231 3470 55 labourers labourer NNS 37231 3470 56 into into IN 37231 3470 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3470 58 harvest harvest NN 37231 3470 59 . . . 37231 3471 1 Go go VB 37231 3471 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3471 3 ways way NNS 37231 3471 4 : : : 37231 3471 5 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3471 6 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3471 7 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3471 8 behold behold NN 37231 3471 9 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3471 10 send send VBP 37231 3471 11 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3471 12 forth forth RB 37231 3471 13 as as IN 37231 3471 14 lambs lamb NNS 37231 3471 15 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3471 16 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3471 17 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3471 18 in in IN 37231 3471 19 the the DT 37231 3471 20 midst midst NN 37231 3471 21 of of IN 37231 3471 22 wolves wolf NNS 37231 3471 23 . . . 37231 3471 24 " " '' 37231 3472 1 Following follow VBG 37231 3472 2 the the DT 37231 3472 3 system system NN 37231 3472 4 adopted adopt VBN 37231 3472 5 in in IN 37231 3472 6 regard regard NN 37231 3472 7 to to IN 37231 3472 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3472 9 , , , 37231 3472 10 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 3472 11 critics critic NNS 37231 3472 12 would would MD 37231 3472 13 of of IN 37231 3472 14 course course NN 37231 3472 15 maintain maintain VB 37231 3472 16 that that IN 37231 3472 17 this this DT 37231 3472 18 was be VBD 37231 3472 19 a a DT 37231 3472 20 compilation compilation NN 37231 3472 21 from from IN 37231 3472 22 memory memory NN 37231 3472 23 of of IN 37231 3472 24 passages passage NNS 37231 3472 25 quoted quote VBN 37231 3472 26 freely freely RB 37231 3472 27 from from IN 37231 3472 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3472 29 first first JJ 37231 3472 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3472 31 , , , 37231 3472 32 that that DT 37231 3472 33 is be VBZ 37231 3472 34 to to TO 37231 3472 35 say say VB 37231 3472 36 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3472 37 . . . 37231 3473 1 ix ix IN 37231 3473 2 . . . 37231 3474 1 37 37 CD 37231 3474 2 . . . 37231 3475 1 " " `` 37231 3475 2 Then then RB 37231 3475 3 saith saith VBZ 37231 3475 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3475 5 unto unto IN 37231 3475 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3475 7 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3475 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3475 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3475 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3475 11 the the DT 37231 3475 12 harvest harvest NN 37231 3475 13 , , , 37231 3475 14 " " '' 37231 3475 15 & & CC 37231 3475 16 c c NNP 37231 3475 17 , , , 37231 3475 18 and and CC 37231 3475 19 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3475 20 . . . 37231 3476 1 x. x. NNP 37231 3477 1 16 16 CD 37231 3477 2 , , , 37231 3477 3 " " `` 37231 3477 4 Behold Behold NNP 37231 3477 5 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3477 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3477 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3477 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3477 9 send send VB 37231 3477 10 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3477 11 forth forth RB 37231 3477 12 as as IN 37231 3477 13 sheep sheep NN 37231 3477 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3477 15 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3477 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3477 17 in in IN 37231 3477 18 the the DT 37231 3477 19 midst midst NN 37231 3477 20 of of IN 37231 3477 21 wolves wolf NNS 37231 3477 22 : : : 37231 3477 23 be be VB 37231 3477 24 ye ye NNP 37231 3477 25 therefore therefore RB 37231 3477 26 , , , 37231 3477 27 " " '' 37231 3477 28 & & CC 37231 3477 29 c c NNP 37231 3477 30 , , , 37231 3477 31 which which WDT 37231 3477 32 , , , 37231 3477 33 with with IN 37231 3477 34 the the DT 37231 3477 35 differences difference NNS 37231 3477 36 which which WDT 37231 3477 37 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3477 38 have have VBP 37231 3477 39 indicated indicate VBN 37231 3477 40 , , , 37231 3477 41 agree agree VBP 37231 3477 42 . . . 37231 3478 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3478 2 would would MD 37231 3478 3 probably probably RB 37231 3478 4 be be VB 37231 3478 5 in in IN 37231 3478 6 vain vain JJ 37231 3478 7 1 1 CD 37231 3478 8 For for IN 37231 3478 9 the the DT 37231 3478 10 arguments argument NNS 37231 3478 11 of of IN 37231 3478 12 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 3478 13 criticism criticism NN 37231 3478 14 , , , 37231 3478 15 the the DT 37231 3478 16 reader reader NN 37231 3478 17 may may MD 37231 3478 18 be be VB 37231 3478 19 referred refer VBN 37231 3478 20 to to IN 37231 3478 21 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3478 22 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3478 23 's 's POS 37231 3478 24 work work NN 37231 3478 25 On on IN 37231 3478 26 the the DT 37231 3478 27 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3478 28 , , , 37231 3478 29 p. p. NN 37231 3478 30 112 112 CD 37231 3478 31 - - HYPH 37231 3478 32 - - SYM 37231 3478 33 139 139 CD 37231 3478 34 . . . 37231 3479 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3479 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3479 3 does do VBZ 37231 3479 4 not not RB 37231 3479 5 , , , 37231 3479 6 of of IN 37231 3479 7 course course NN 37231 3479 8 , , , 37231 3479 9 deny deny VB 37231 3479 10 the the DT 37231 3479 11 fact fact NN 37231 3479 12 that that IN 37231 3479 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3479 14 's 's POS 37231 3479 15 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3479 16 are be VBP 37231 3479 17 different different JJ 37231 3479 18 from from IN 37231 3479 19 the the DT 37231 3479 20 text text NN 37231 3479 21 of of IN 37231 3479 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3479 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3479 24 , , , 37231 3479 25 but but CC 37231 3479 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3479 27 accounts account VBZ 37231 3479 28 for for IN 37231 3479 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3479 30 variations variation NNS 37231 3479 31 ou ou NNP 37231 3479 32 grounds ground NNS 37231 3479 33 which which WDT 37231 3479 34 seem seem VBP 37231 3479 35 to to IN 37231 3479 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3479 37 purely purely RB 37231 3479 38 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 3479 39 . . . 37231 3480 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3480 2 is be VBZ 37231 3480 3 evident evident JJ 37231 3480 4 that that IN 37231 3480 5 , , , 37231 3480 6 so so RB 37231 3480 7 long long RB 37231 3480 8 as as IN 37231 3480 9 there there EX 37231 3480 10 are be VBP 37231 3480 11 such such JJ 37231 3480 12 variations variation NNS 37231 3480 13 to to TO 37231 3480 14 be be VB 37231 3480 15 explained explain VBN 37231 3480 16 away away RP 37231 3480 17 , , , 37231 3480 18 at at IN 37231 3480 19 least least JJS 37231 3480 20 no no DT 37231 3480 21 proof proof NN 37231 3480 22 of of IN 37231 3480 23 identity identity NN 37231 3480 24 is be VBZ 37231 3480 25 possible possible JJ 37231 3480 26 . . . 37231 3481 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3481 2 360 360 CD 37231 3481 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3481 4 to to TO 37231 3481 5 argue argue VB 37231 3481 6 that that IN 37231 3481 7 the the DT 37231 3481 8 quotation quotation NN 37231 3481 9 indicated indicate VBD 37231 3481 10 a a DT 37231 3481 11 continuous continuous JJ 37231 3481 12 order order NN 37231 3481 13 , , , 37231 3481 14 and and CC 37231 3481 15 the the DT 37231 3481 16 variations variation NNS 37231 3481 17 combined combine VBN 37231 3481 18 to to TO 37231 3481 19 confirm confirm VB 37231 3481 20 the the DT 37231 3481 21 probability probability NN 37231 3481 22 of of IN 37231 3481 23 a a DT 37231 3481 24 different different JJ 37231 3481 25 source source NN 37231 3481 26 , , , 37231 3481 27 and and CC 37231 3481 28 still still RB 37231 3481 29 more more RBR 37231 3481 30 so so RB 37231 3481 31 to to TO 37231 3481 32 point point VB 37231 3481 33 out out RP 37231 3481 34 that that IN 37231 3481 35 , , , 37231 3481 36 although although IN 37231 3481 37 parts part NNS 37231 3481 38 of of IN 37231 3481 39 the the DT 37231 3481 40 quotation quotation NN 37231 3481 41 separated separate VBD 37231 3481 42 from from IN 37231 3481 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3481 44 context context NN 37231 3481 45 might may MD 37231 3481 46 to to IN 37231 3481 47 a a DT 37231 3481 48 certain certain JJ 37231 3481 49 extent extent NN 37231 3481 50 correspond correspond NN 37231 3481 51 with with IN 37231 3481 52 scattered scatter VBN 37231 3481 53 verses verse NNS 37231 3481 54 in in IN 37231 3481 55 the the DT 37231 3481 56 first first JJ 37231 3481 57 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3481 58 , , , 37231 3481 59 such such PDT 37231 3481 60 a a DT 37231 3481 61 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 3481 62 was be VBD 37231 3481 63 no no DT 37231 3481 64 proof proof NN 37231 3481 65 that that IN 37231 3481 66 the the DT 37231 3481 67 quotation quotation NN 37231 3481 68 was be VBD 37231 3481 69 taken take VBN 37231 3481 70 from from IN 37231 3481 71 that that DT 37231 3481 72 and and CC 37231 3481 73 from from IN 37231 3481 74 no no DT 37231 3481 75 other other JJ 37231 3481 76 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3481 77 . . . 37231 3482 1 The the DT 37231 3482 2 passage passage NN 37231 3482 3 , , , 37231 3482 4 however however RB 37231 3482 5 , , , 37231 3482 6 is be VBZ 37231 3482 7 a a DT 37231 3482 8 literal literal JJ 37231 3482 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 3482 10 from from IN 37231 3482 11 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3482 12 x. x. NNP 37231 3483 1 2 2 CD 37231 3483 2 , , , 37231 3483 3 3 3 CD 37231 3483 4 , , , 37231 3483 5 which which WDT 37231 3483 6 , , , 37231 3483 7 as as IN 37231 3483 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3483 9 have have VBP 37231 3483 10 assumed assume VBN 37231 3483 11 , , , 37231 3483 12 had have VBD 37231 3483 13 been be VBN 37231 3483 14 lost lose VBN 37231 3483 15 . . . 37231 3484 1 Again again RB 37231 3484 2 , , , 37231 3484 3 still still RB 37231 3484 4 supposing suppose VBG 37231 3484 5 the the DT 37231 3484 6 third third JJ 37231 3484 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3484 8 no no RB 37231 3484 9 longer long RBR 37231 3484 10 extant extant JJ 37231 3484 11 , , , 37231 3484 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3484 13 might may MD 37231 3484 14 find find VB 37231 3484 15 the the DT 37231 3484 16 following following JJ 37231 3484 17 quotation quotation NN 37231 3484 18 in in IN 37231 3484 19 a a DT 37231 3484 20 work work NN 37231 3484 21 of of IN 37231 3484 22 the the DT 37231 3484 23 Fathers father NNS 37231 3484 24 : : : 37231 3484 25 " " `` 37231 3484 26 Take take VB 37231 3484 27 heed heed NN 37231 3484 28 to to IN 37231 3484 29 yourselves yourself NNS 37231 3484 30 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3484 31 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3484 32 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3484 33 of of IN 37231 3484 34 the the DT 37231 3484 35 leaven leaven NN 37231 3484 36 of of IN 37231 3484 37 the the DT 37231 3484 38 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3484 39 , , , 37231 3484 40 which which WDT 37231 3484 41 is be VBZ 37231 3484 42 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 37231 3484 43 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3484 44 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3484 45 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3484 46 . . . 37231 3485 1 For for IN 37231 3485 2 there there EX 37231 3485 3 is be VBZ 37231 3485 4 nothing nothing NN 37231 3485 5 covered cover VBN 37231 3485 6 up up RP 37231 3485 7 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3485 8 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3485 9 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3485 10 which which WDT 37231 3485 11 shall shall MD 37231 3485 12 not not RB 37231 3485 13 be be VB 37231 3485 14 revealed reveal VBN 37231 3485 15 , , , 37231 3485 16 and and CC 37231 3485 17 hid hide VBD 37231 3485 18 which which WDT 37231 3485 19 shall shall MD 37231 3485 20 not not RB 37231 3485 21 be be VB 37231 3485 22 known know VBN 37231 3485 23 . . . 37231 3485 24 " " '' 37231 3486 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3486 2 would would MD 37231 3486 3 of of RB 37231 3486 4 course course NN 37231 3486 5 be be VB 37231 3486 6 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 3486 7 that that IN 37231 3486 8 this this DT 37231 3486 9 was be VBD 37231 3486 10 evidently evidently RB 37231 3486 11 a a DT 37231 3486 12 combination combination NN 37231 3486 13 of of IN 37231 3486 14 two two CD 37231 3486 15 verses verse NNS 37231 3486 16 of of IN 37231 3486 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3486 18 first first JJ 37231 3486 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3486 20 quoted quote VBD 37231 3486 21 almost almost RB 37231 3486 22 literally literally RB 37231 3486 23 , , , 37231 3486 24 with with IN 37231 3486 25 merely merely RB 37231 3486 26 a a DT 37231 3486 27 few few JJ 37231 3486 28 very very RB 37231 3486 29 immaterial immaterial JJ 37231 3486 30 slips slip NNS 37231 3486 31 of of IN 37231 3486 32 memory memory NN 37231 3486 33 in in IN 37231 3486 34 the the DT 37231 3486 35 parts part NNS 37231 3486 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3486 37 note note VBP 37231 3486 38 , , , 37231 3486 39 and and CC 37231 3486 40 the the DT 37231 3486 41 explanatory explanatory JJ 37231 3486 42 words word NNS 37231 3486 43 " " '' 37231 3486 44 which which WDT 37231 3486 45 is be VBZ 37231 3486 46 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 37231 3486 47 " " '' 37231 3486 48 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3486 49 by by IN 37231 3486 50 the the DT 37231 3486 51 Father Father NNP 37231 3486 52 , , , 37231 3486 53 and and CC 37231 3486 54 not not RB 37231 3486 55 a a DT 37231 3486 56 part part NN 37231 3486 57 of of IN 37231 3486 58 the the DT 37231 3486 59 quotation quotation NN 37231 3486 60 at at RB 37231 3486 61 all all RB 37231 3486 62 . . . 37231 3487 1 The the DT 37231 3487 2 two two CD 37231 3487 3 verses verse NNS 37231 3487 4 are be VBP 37231 3487 5 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3487 6 . . . 37231 3488 1 xvi xvi NNP 37231 3488 2 . . . 37231 3489 1 6 6 CD 37231 3489 2 : : : 37231 3489 3 " " `` 37231 3489 4 Beware beware VB 37231 3489 5 and and CC 37231 3489 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3489 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3489 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3489 9 take take VB 37231 3489 10 heed heed NN 37231 3489 11 of of IN 37231 3489 12 the the DT 37231 3489 13 leaven leaven NN 37231 3489 14 of of IN 37231 3489 15 the the DT 37231 3489 16 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3489 17 and and CC 37231 3489 18 Sadducees Sadducees NNPS 37231 3489 19 " " '' 37231 3489 20 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3489 21 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3489 22 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3489 23 and and CC 37231 3489 24 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3489 25 . . . 37231 3490 1 x. x. NNP 37231 3491 1 26 26 CD 37231 3491 2 .... .... . 37231 3491 3 " " '' 37231 3491 4 For for IN 37231 3491 5 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3491 6 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3491 7 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3491 8 there there EX 37231 3491 9 is be VBZ 37231 3491 10 nothing nothing NN 37231 3491 11 covered cover VBN 37231 3491 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3491 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3491 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3491 15 that that WDT 37231 3491 16 shall shall MD 37231 3491 17 not not RB 37231 3491 18 be be VB 37231 3491 19 revealed reveal VBN 37231 3491 20 , , , 37231 3491 21 and and CC 37231 3491 22 hid hide VBD 37231 3491 23 that that DT 37231 3491 24 shall shall MD 37231 3491 25 not not RB 37231 3491 26 be be VB 37231 3491 27 known know VBN 37231 3491 28 . . . 37231 3491 29 " " '' 37231 3492 1 The the DT 37231 3492 2 sentence sentence NN 37231 3492 3 would would MD 37231 3492 4 in in IN 37231 3492 5 fact fact NN 37231 3492 6 be be VB 37231 3492 7 divided divide VBN 37231 3492 8 as as IN 37231 3492 9 in in IN 37231 3492 10 the the DT 37231 3492 11 case case NN 37231 3492 12 of of IN 37231 3492 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3492 14 , , , 37231 3492 15 and and CC 37231 3492 16 each each DT 37231 3492 17 part part NN 37231 3492 18 would would MD 37231 3492 19 have have VB 37231 3492 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3492 21 parallel parallel NN 37231 3492 22 pointed point VBN 37231 3492 23 out out RP 37231 3492 24 in in IN 37231 3492 25 separate separate JJ 37231 3492 26 portions portion NNS 37231 3492 27 of of IN 37231 3492 28 the the DT 37231 3492 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3492 30 . . . 37231 3493 1 How how WRB 37231 3493 2 wrong wrong JJ 37231 3493 3 such such PDT 37231 3493 4 a a DT 37231 3493 5 system system NN 37231 3493 6 is be VBZ 37231 3493 7 -- -- : 37231 3493 8 and and CC 37231 3493 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3493 10 is be VBZ 37231 3493 11 precisely precisely RB 37231 3493 12 that that IN 37231 3493 13 which which WDT 37231 3493 14 is be VBZ 37231 3493 15 adopted adopt VBN 37231 3493 16 with with IN 37231 3493 17 regard regard NN 37231 3493 18 to to IN 37231 3493 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3493 20 -- -- : 37231 3493 21 is be VBZ 37231 3493 22 clearly clearly RB 37231 3493 23 established establish VBN 37231 3493 24 by by IN 37231 3493 25 the the DT 37231 3493 26 fact fact NN 37231 3493 27 that that IN 37231 3493 28 the the DT 37231 3493 29 quotation quotation NN 37231 3493 30 , , , 37231 3493 31 { { -LRB- 37231 3493 32 361 361 CD 37231 3493 33 } } -RRB- 37231 3493 34 instead instead RB 37231 3493 35 of of IN 37231 3493 36 being be VBG 37231 3493 37 such such PDT 37231 3493 38 a a DT 37231 3493 39 combination combination NN 37231 3493 40 , , , 37231 3493 41 is be VBZ 37231 3493 42 simply simply RB 37231 3493 43 taken take VBN 37231 3493 44 from from IN 37231 3493 45 the the DT 37231 3493 46 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3493 47 according accord VBG 37231 3493 48 to to IN 37231 3493 49 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3493 50 xii xii NNP 37231 3493 51 . . . 37231 3494 1 1 1 CD 37231 3494 2 , , , 37231 3494 3 2 2 CD 37231 3494 4 , , , 37231 3494 5 as as IN 37231 3494 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3494 7 stands stand VBZ 37231 3494 8 . . . 37231 3495 1 To to TO 37231 3495 2 give give VB 37231 3495 3 one one CD 37231 3495 4 more more JJR 37231 3495 5 example example NN 37231 3495 6 , , , 37231 3495 7 and and CC 37231 3495 8 such such JJ 37231 3495 9 might may MD 37231 3495 10 easily easily RB 37231 3495 11 be be VB 37231 3495 12 multiplied multiply VBN 37231 3495 13 , , , 37231 3495 14 if if IN 37231 3495 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3495 16 second second JJ 37231 3495 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3495 18 had have VBD 37231 3495 19 been be VBN 37231 3495 20 lost lose VBN 37231 3495 21 , , , 37231 3495 22 and and CC 37231 3495 23 the the DT 37231 3495 24 following follow VBG 37231 3495 25 passage passage NN 37231 3495 26 were be VBD 37231 3495 27 met meet VBN 37231 3495 28 with with IN 37231 3495 29 in in IN 37231 3495 30 one one CD 37231 3495 31 of of IN 37231 3495 32 the the DT 37231 3495 33 Fathers father NNS 37231 3495 34 without without IN 37231 3495 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3495 36 source source NN 37231 3495 37 being be VBG 37231 3495 38 indicated indicate VBN 37231 3495 39 , , , 37231 3495 40 what what WP 37231 3495 41 would would MD 37231 3495 42 be be VB 37231 3495 43 the the DT 37231 3495 44 argument argument NN 37231 3495 45 of of IN 37231 3495 46 those those DT 37231 3495 47 who who WP 37231 3495 48 insist insist VBP 37231 3495 49 that that IN 37231 3495 50 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3495 51 's 's POS 37231 3495 52 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3495 53 , , , 37231 3495 54 though though IN 37231 3495 55 differing differ VBG 37231 3495 56 from from IN 37231 3495 57 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3495 58 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3495 59 , , , 37231 3495 60 were be VBD 37231 3495 61 yet yet RB 37231 3495 62 taken take VBN 37231 3495 63 from from IN 37231 3495 64 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3495 65 ? ? . 37231 3496 1 " " `` 37231 3496 2 If if IN 37231 3496 3 any any DT 37231 3496 4 one one CD 37231 3496 5 have have VBP 37231 3496 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3496 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3496 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3496 9 ears ear NNS 37231 3496 10 to to TO 37231 3496 11 hear hear VB 37231 3496 12 let let VB 37231 3496 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3496 14 hear hear VB 37231 3496 15 . . . 37231 3497 1 And and CC 37231 3497 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3497 3 said say VBD 37231 3497 4 unto unto IN 37231 3497 5 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3497 6 : : : 37231 3497 7 Take take VB 37231 3497 8 heed heed NN 37231 3497 9 what what WP 37231 3497 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3497 11 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3497 12 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3497 13 ye ye NNP 37231 3497 14 hear hear VBP 37231 3497 15 : : : 37231 3497 16 with with IN 37231 3497 17 what what WDT 37231 3497 18 measure measure NN 37231 3497 19 ye ye NNP 37231 3497 20 mete mete NN 37231 3497 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3497 22 shall shall MD 37231 3497 23 be be VB 37231 3497 24 measured measure VBN 37231 3497 25 to to IN 37231 3497 26 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3497 27 : : : 37231 3497 28 and and CC 37231 3497 29 more more RBR 37231 3497 30 shall shall MD 37231 3497 31 be be VB 37231 3497 32 given give VBN 37231 3497 33 unto unto IN 37231 3497 34 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3497 35 . . . 37231 3498 1 For for IN 37231 3498 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3498 3 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3498 4 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3498 5 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3498 6 that that DT 37231 3498 7 hath hath NN 37231 3498 8 to to IN 37231 3498 9 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3498 10 shall shall MD 37231 3498 11 be be VB 37231 3498 12 given give VBN 37231 3498 13 , , , 37231 3498 14 and and CC 37231 3498 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3498 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3498 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3498 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3498 19 that that DT 37231 3498 20 hath hath NNP 37231 3498 21 not not RB 37231 3498 22 from from IN 37231 3498 23 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3498 24 shall shall MD 37231 3498 25 be be VB 37231 3498 26 taken take VBN 37231 3498 27 even even RB 37231 3498 28 that that DT 37231 3498 29 which which WDT 37231 3498 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3498 31 hath hath VBP 37231 3498 32 . . . 37231 3498 33 " " '' 37231 3499 1 Upon upon IN 37231 3499 2 the the DT 37231 3499 3 principle principle NN 37231 3499 4 on on IN 37231 3499 5 which which WDT 37231 3499 6 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3499 7 's 's POS 37231 3499 8 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3499 9 are be VBP 37231 3499 10 treated treat VBN 37231 3499 11 , , , 37231 3499 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3499 13 would would MD 37231 3499 14 certainly certainly RB 37231 3499 15 be be VB 37231 3499 16 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 3499 17 positively positively RB 37231 3499 18 that that IN 37231 3499 19 this this DT 37231 3499 20 passage passage NN 37231 3499 21 was be VBD 37231 3499 22 a a DT 37231 3499 23 quotation quotation NN 37231 3499 24 from from IN 37231 3499 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3499 26 first first JJ 37231 3499 27 and and CC 37231 3499 28 third third JJ 37231 3499 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3499 30 combined combine VBN 37231 3499 31 and and CC 37231 3499 32 made make VBN 37231 3499 33 from from IN 37231 3499 34 memory memory NN 37231 3499 35 . . . 37231 3500 1 The the DT 37231 3500 2 exigencies exigency NNS 37231 3500 3 of of IN 37231 3500 4 the the DT 37231 3500 5 occasion occasion NN 37231 3500 6 might may MD 37231 3500 7 probably probably RB 37231 3500 8 cause cause VB 37231 3500 9 the the DT 37231 3500 10 assertion assertion NN 37231 3500 11 to to TO 37231 3500 12 be be VB 37231 3500 13 made make VBN 37231 3500 14 that that IN 37231 3500 15 the the DT 37231 3500 16 words word NNS 37231 3500 17 : : : 37231 3500 18 " " `` 37231 3500 19 And and CC 37231 3500 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3500 21 said say VBD 37231 3500 22 to to IN 37231 3500 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3500 24 , , , 37231 3500 25 " " `` 37231 3500 26 really really RB 37231 3500 27 indicated indicate VBD 37231 3500 28 a a DT 37231 3500 29 separation separation NN 37231 3500 30 of of IN 37231 3500 31 the the DT 37231 3500 32 latter latter JJ 37231 3500 33 part part NN 37231 3500 34 of of IN 37231 3500 35 the the DT 37231 3500 36 quotation quotation NN 37231 3500 37 from from IN 37231 3500 38 the the DT 37231 3500 39 preceding preceding NN 37231 3500 40 , , , 37231 3500 41 and and CC 37231 3500 42 that that IN 37231 3500 43 the the DT 37231 3500 44 Father Father NNP 37231 3500 45 thus thus RB 37231 3500 46 showed show VBD 37231 3500 47 that that IN 37231 3500 48 the the DT 37231 3500 49 passage passage NN 37231 3500 50 was be VBD 37231 3500 51 not not RB 37231 3500 52 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3500 53 ; ; : 37231 3500 54 and and CC 37231 3500 55 as as IN 37231 3500 56 to to IN 37231 3500 57 the the DT 37231 3500 58 phrase phrase NN 37231 3500 59 : : : 37231 3500 60 " " `` 37231 3500 61 and and CC 37231 3500 62 more more JJR 37231 3500 63 shall shall MD 37231 3500 64 be be VB 37231 3500 65 given give VBN 37231 3500 66 unto unto IN 37231 3500 67 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3500 68 , , , 37231 3500 69 " " '' 37231 3500 70 that that IN 37231 3500 71 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3500 72 was be VBD 37231 3500 73 evidently evidently RB 37231 3500 74 an an DT 37231 3500 75 addition addition NN 37231 3500 76 of of IN 37231 3500 77 the the DT 37231 3500 78 Father Father NNP 37231 3500 79 . . . 37231 3501 1 The the DT 37231 3501 2 passage passage NN 37231 3501 3 would would MD 37231 3501 4 be be VB 37231 3501 5 dissected dissect VBN 37231 3501 6 , , , 37231 3501 7 and and CC 37231 3501 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3501 9 different different JJ 37231 3501 10 members member NNS 37231 3501 11 compared compare VBN 37231 3501 12 with with IN 37231 3501 13 scattered scatter VBN 37231 3501 14 sentences sentence NNS 37231 3501 15 , , , 37231 3501 16 and and CC 37231 3501 17 declared declare VBD 37231 3501 18 almost almost RB 37231 3501 19 literal literal JJ 37231 3501 20 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3501 21 from from IN 37231 3501 22 the the DT 37231 3501 23 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3501 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3501 25 : : : 37231 3501 26 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3501 27 . . . 37231 3502 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3502 2 . . . 37231 3503 1 0 0 NFP 37231 3503 2 . . . 37231 3504 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3504 2 that that IN 37231 3504 3 hath hath NNP 37231 3504 4 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3504 5 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3504 6 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3504 7 ears ear NNS 37231 3504 8 to to TO 37231 3504 9 hear hear VB 37231 3504 10 let let VB 37231 3504 11 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3504 12 hear hear VB 37231 3504 13 . . . 37231 3505 1 " " `` 37231 3505 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3505 3 l l NN 37231 3505 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3505 5 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3505 6 viii viii NN 37231 3505 7 . . . 37231 3506 1 18 18 CD 37231 3506 2 , , , 37231 3506 3 " " `` 37231 3506 4 Take take VB 37231 3506 5 heed heed NN 37231 3506 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 3506 7 how how WRB 37231 3506 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3506 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3506 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3506 11 ye ye NNP 37231 3506 12 hear hear VBP 37231 3506 13 . . . 37231 3506 14 " " '' 37231 3507 1 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3507 2 . . . 37231 3508 1 vii vii NN 37231 3508 2 . . . 37231 3509 1 2 2 LS 37231 3509 2 ... ... : 37231 3509 3 " " `` 37231 3509 4 with with IN 37231 3509 5 what what WDT 37231 3509 6 measure measure NN 37231 3509 7 ye ye NNP 37231 3509 8 { { -LRB- 37231 3509 9 362 362 CD 37231 3509 10 } } -RRB- 37231 3509 11 mete mete NN 37231 3509 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3509 13 shall shall MD 37231 3509 14 be be VB 37231 3509 15 measured measure VBN 37231 3509 16 to to IN 37231 3509 17 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3509 18 . . . 37231 3510 1 " " `` 37231 3510 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3510 3 1 1 LS 37231 3510 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3510 5 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3510 6 . . . 37231 3511 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3511 2 . . . 37231 3512 1 12 12 CD 37231 3512 2 : : : 37231 3512 3 " " `` 37231 3512 4 For for IN 37231 3512 5 whosoever whosoever NN 37231 3512 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3512 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3512 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3512 9 hath hath NNP 37231 3512 10 , , , 37231 3512 11 to to IN 37231 3512 12 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3512 13 shall shall MD 37231 3512 14 be be VB 37231 3512 15 given give VBN 37231 3512 16 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3512 17 and and CC 37231 3512 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3512 19 shall shall MD 37231 3512 20 have have VB 37231 3512 21 abundance abundance NN 37231 3512 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3512 23 ; ; : 37231 3512 24 but but CC 37231 3512 25 whosoever whosoever NN 37231 3512 26 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3512 27 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3512 28 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3512 29 hath hath NNP 37231 3512 30 not not RB 37231 3512 31 from from IN 37231 3512 32 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3512 33 shall shall MD 37231 3512 34 be be VB 37231 3512 35 taken take VBN 37231 3512 36 even even RB 37231 3512 37 that that DT 37231 3512 38 which which WDT 37231 3512 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3512 40 hath hath VBP 37231 3512 41 . . . 37231 3512 42 " " '' 37231 3513 1 a a LS 37231 3513 2 In in IN 37231 3513 3 spite spite NN 37231 3513 4 of of IN 37231 3513 5 these these DT 37231 3513 6 ingenious ingenious JJ 37231 3513 7 assertions assertion NNS 37231 3513 8 , , , 37231 3513 9 however however RB 37231 3513 10 , , , 37231 3513 11 the the DT 37231 3513 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3513 13 in in IN 37231 3513 14 reality reality NN 37231 3513 15 is be VBZ 37231 3513 16 literally literally RB 37231 3513 17 and and CC 37231 3513 18 consecutively consecutively RB 37231 3513 19 taken take VBN 37231 3513 20 from from IN 37231 3513 21 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3513 22 iv iv NNP 37231 3513 23 . . . 37231 3514 1 23 23 CD 37231 3514 2 - - HYPH 37231 3514 3 -25 -25 NN 37231 3514 4 . . . 37231 3515 1 These these DT 37231 3515 2 examples example NNS 37231 3515 3 may may MD 37231 3515 4 suffice suffice VB 37231 3515 5 to to TO 37231 3515 6 show show VB 37231 3515 7 that that IN 37231 3515 8 any any DT 37231 3515 9 argument argument NN 37231 3515 10 which which WDT 37231 3515 11 commences commence VBZ 37231 3515 12 by by IN 37231 3515 13 the the DT 37231 3515 14 assumption assumption NN 37231 3515 15 that that IN 37231 3515 16 the the DT 37231 3515 17 order order NN 37231 3515 18 of of IN 37231 3515 19 a a DT 37231 3515 20 passage passage NN 37231 3515 21 quoted quote VBN 37231 3515 22 may may MD 37231 3515 23 be be VB 37231 3515 24 entirely entirely RB 37231 3515 25 disregarded disregard VBN 37231 3515 26 , , , 37231 3515 27 and and CC 37231 3515 28 that that IN 37231 3515 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3515 30 is be VBZ 37231 3515 31 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 3515 32 to to TO 37231 3515 33 find find VB 37231 3515 34 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3515 35 scattered scatter VBN 37231 3515 36 irregularly irregularly RB 37231 3515 37 up up IN 37231 3515 38 and and CC 37231 3515 39 down down IN 37231 3515 40 the the DT 37231 3515 41 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3515 42 to to TO 37231 3515 43 warrant warrant VB 37231 3515 44 the the DT 37231 3515 45 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3515 46 that that IN 37231 3515 47 the the DT 37231 3515 48 passage passage NN 37231 3515 49 is be VBZ 37231 3515 50 compiled compile VBN 37231 3515 51 from from IN 37231 3515 52 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3515 53 , , , 37231 3515 54 and and CC 37231 3515 55 is be VBZ 37231 3515 56 not not RB 37231 3515 57 a a DT 37231 3515 58 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3515 59 quotation quotation NN 37231 3515 60 from from IN 37231 3515 61 some some DT 37231 3515 62 other other JJ 37231 3515 63 source source NN 37231 3515 64 , , , 37231 3515 65 is be VBZ 37231 3515 66 utterly utterly RB 37231 3515 67 unfounded unfounded JJ 37231 3515 68 and and CC 37231 3515 69 untenable untenable JJ 37231 3515 70 . . . 37231 3516 1 The the DT 37231 3516 2 supposition supposition NN 37231 3516 3 of of IN 37231 3516 4 a a DT 37231 3516 5 lost lost JJ 37231 3516 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3516 7 which which WDT 37231 3516 8 has have VBZ 37231 3516 9 just just RB 37231 3516 10 been be VBN 37231 3516 11 made make VBN 37231 3516 12 to to TO 37231 3516 13 illustrate illustrate VB 37231 3516 14 this this DT 37231 3516 15 argument argument NN 37231 3516 16 is be VBZ 37231 3516 17 , , , 37231 3516 18 however however RB 37231 3516 19 , , , 37231 3516 20 not not RB 37231 3516 21 a a DT 37231 3516 22 mere mere JJ 37231 3516 23 supposition supposition NN 37231 3516 24 as as IN 37231 3516 25 applied apply VBN 37231 3516 26 to to IN 37231 3516 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3516 28 but but CC 37231 3516 29 a a DT 37231 3516 30 fact fact NN 37231 3516 31 , , , 37231 3516 32 for for IN 37231 3516 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3516 34 no no RB 37231 3516 35 longer longer RB 37231 3516 36 have have VBP 37231 3516 37 the the DT 37231 3516 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3516 39 according accord VBG 37231 3516 40 to to IN 37231 3516 41 Peter Peter NNP 37231 3516 42 nor nor CC 37231 3516 43 that that IN 37231 3516 44 according accord VBG 37231 3516 45 to to IN 37231 3516 46 the the DT 37231 3516 47 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3516 48 , , , 37231 3516 49 not not RB 37231 3516 50 to to TO 37231 3516 51 mention mention VB 37231 3516 52 the the DT 37231 3516 53 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3516 54 other other JJ 37231 3516 55 works work NNS 37231 3516 56 in in IN 37231 3516 57 use use NN 37231 3516 58 in in IN 37231 3516 59 the the DT 37231 3516 60 early early JJ 37231 3516 61 Church Church NNP 37231 3516 62 . . . 37231 3517 1 The the DT 37231 3517 2 instances instance NNS 37231 3517 3 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3517 4 have have VBP 37231 3517 5 given give VBN 37231 3517 6 show show NN 37231 3517 7 the the DT 37231 3517 8 importance importance NN 37231 3517 9 of of IN 37231 3517 10 the the DT 37231 3517 11 order order NN 37231 3517 12 as as RB 37231 3517 13 well well RB 37231 3517 14 as as IN 37231 3517 15 the the DT 37231 3517 16 language language NN 37231 3517 17 of of IN 37231 3517 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3517 19 's 's POS 37231 3517 20 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3517 21 , , , 37231 3517 22 and and CC 37231 3517 23 while while IN 37231 3517 24 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3517 25 prove prove VBP 37231 3517 26 the the DT 37231 3517 27 impossibility impossibility NN 37231 3517 28 of of IN 37231 3517 29 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 37231 3517 30 that that IN 37231 3517 31 a a DT 37231 3517 32 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3517 33 passage passage NN 37231 3517 34 which which WDT 37231 3517 35 differs differ VBZ 37231 3517 36 not not RB 37231 3517 37 only only RB 37231 3517 38 in in IN 37231 3517 39 language language NN 37231 3517 40 but but CC 37231 3517 41 in in IN 37231 3517 42 order order NN 37231 3517 43 from from IN 37231 3517 44 the the DT 37231 3517 45 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3517 46 in in IN 37231 3517 47 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3517 48 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3517 49 must must MD 37231 3517 50 be be VB 37231 3517 51 derived derive VBN 37231 3517 52 from from IN 37231 3517 53 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3517 54 , , , 37231 3517 55 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3517 56 likewise likewise RB 37231 3517 57 prove prove VBP 37231 3517 58 the the DT 37231 3517 59 probability probability NN 37231 3517 60 that that IN 37231 3517 61 such such JJ 37231 3517 62 passages passage NNS 37231 3517 63 are be VBP 37231 3517 64 actually actually RB 37231 3517 65 quoted quote VBN 37231 3517 66 from from IN 37231 3517 67 a a DT 37231 3517 68 different different JJ 37231 3517 69 source source NN 37231 3517 70 . . . 37231 3518 1 If if IN 37231 3518 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3518 3 examine examine VBP 37231 3518 4 further further RB 37231 3518 5 , , , 37231 3518 6 however however RB 37231 3518 7 , , , 37231 3518 8 in in IN 37231 3518 9 the the DT 37231 3518 10 same same JJ 37231 3518 11 way way NN 37231 3518 12 , , , 37231 3518 13 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3518 14 which which WDT 37231 3518 15 differ differ VBP 37231 3518 16 merely merely RB 37231 3518 17 in in IN 37231 3518 18 language language NN 37231 3518 19 , , , 37231 3518 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3518 21 arrive arrive VBP 37231 3518 22 at at IN 37231 3518 23 the the DT 37231 3518 24 very very RB 37231 3518 25 same same JJ 37231 3518 26 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3518 27 . . . 37231 3519 1 Supposing suppose VBG 37231 3519 2 the the DT 37231 3519 3 third third JJ 37231 3519 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3519 5 to to TO 37231 3519 6 be be VB 37231 3519 7 lost lose VBN 37231 3519 8 , , , 37231 3519 9 what what WP 37231 3519 10 would would MD 37231 3519 11 be be VB 37231 3519 12 the the DT 37231 3519 13 source source NN 37231 3519 14 assigned assign VBN 37231 3519 15 to to IN 37231 3519 16 the the DT 37231 3519 17 { { -LRB- 37231 3519 18 363 363 CD 37231 3519 19 } } -RRB- 37231 3519 20 following follow VBG 37231 3519 21 quotation quotation NN 37231 3519 22 from from IN 37231 3519 23 an an DT 37231 3519 24 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 3519 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3519 26 in in IN 37231 3519 27 the the DT 37231 3519 28 work work NN 37231 3519 29 of of IN 37231 3519 30 one one CD 37231 3519 31 of of IN 37231 3519 32 the the DT 37231 3519 33 Fathers father NNS 37231 3519 34 ? ? . 37231 3520 1 " " `` 37231 3520 2 No no DT 37231 3520 3 servant servant NN 37231 3520 4 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3520 5 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3520 6 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3520 7 can can MD 37231 3520 8 serve serve VB 37231 3520 9 two two CD 37231 3520 10 lords lord NNS 37231 3520 11 , , , 37231 3520 12 for for IN 37231 3520 13 either either CC 37231 3520 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3520 15 will will MD 37231 3520 16 hate hate VB 37231 3520 17 the the DT 37231 3520 18 one one NN 37231 3520 19 , , , 37231 3520 20 and and CC 37231 3520 21 love love VB 37231 3520 22 the the DT 37231 3520 23 other other JJ 37231 3520 24 ; ; : 37231 3520 25 or or CC 37231 3520 26 else else RB 37231 3520 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3520 28 will will MD 37231 3520 29 hold hold VB 37231 3520 30 to to IN 37231 3520 31 the the DT 37231 3520 32 one one NN 37231 3520 33 and and CC 37231 3520 34 despise despise VB 37231 3520 35 the the DT 37231 3520 36 other other JJ 37231 3520 37 . . . 37231 3521 1 Ye Ye NNP 37231 3521 2 can can MD 37231 3521 3 not not RB 37231 3521 4 serve serve VB 37231 3521 5 God God NNP 37231 3521 6 and and CC 37231 3521 7 Mammon Mammon NNP 37231 3521 8 . . . 37231 3521 9 " " '' 37231 3522 1 Of of RB 37231 3522 2 course course RB 37231 3522 3 the the DT 37231 3522 4 passage passage NN 37231 3522 5 would would MD 37231 3522 6 be be VB 37231 3522 7 claimed claim VBN 37231 3522 8 as as IN 37231 3522 9 a a DT 37231 3522 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 3522 11 from from IN 37231 3522 12 memory memory NN 37231 3522 13 of of IN 37231 3522 14 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3522 15 . . . 37231 3523 1 vi vi NNP 37231 3523 2 . . . 37231 3524 1 24 24 CD 37231 3524 2 , , , 37231 3524 3 with with IN 37231 3524 4 which which WDT 37231 3524 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3524 6 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 3524 7 corresponds correspond VBZ 37231 3524 8 with with IN 37231 3524 9 the the DT 37231 3524 10 exception exception NN 37231 3524 11 of of IN 37231 3524 12 the the DT 37231 3524 13 addition addition NN 37231 3524 14 of of IN 37231 3524 15 the the DT 37231 3524 16 second second JJ 37231 3524 17 word word NN 37231 3524 18 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3524 19 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3524 20 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3524 21 , , , 37231 3524 22 which which WDT 37231 3524 23 , , , 37231 3524 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3524 25 would would MD 37231 3524 26 no no RB 37231 3524 27 doubt doubt RB 37231 3524 28 be be VB 37231 3524 29 argued argue VBN 37231 3524 30 , , , 37231 3524 31 is be VBZ 37231 3524 32 an an DT 37231 3524 33 evident evident JJ 37231 3524 34 and and CC 37231 3524 35 very very RB 37231 3524 36 natural natural JJ 37231 3524 37 amplification amplification NN 37231 3524 38 of of IN 37231 3524 39 the the DT 37231 3524 40 simple simple JJ 37231 3524 41 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3524 42 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3524 43 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3524 44 of of IN 37231 3524 45 the the DT 37231 3524 46 first first JJ 37231 3524 47 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3524 48 . . . 37231 3525 1 Yet yet RB 37231 3525 2 this this DT 37231 3525 3 passage passage NN 37231 3525 4 , , , 37231 3525 5 only only RB 37231 3525 6 differing differ VBG 37231 3525 7 by by IN 37231 3525 8 the the DT 37231 3525 9 single single JJ 37231 3525 10 word word NN 37231 3525 11 from from IN 37231 3525 12 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3525 13 , , , 37231 3525 14 is be VBZ 37231 3525 15 a a DT 37231 3525 16 literal literal JJ 37231 3525 17 quotation quotation NN 37231 3525 18 from from IN 37231 3525 19 the the DT 37231 3525 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3525 21 according accord VBG 37231 3525 22 to to IN 37231 3525 23 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3525 24 xvi xvi NNP 37231 3525 25 . . . 37231 3526 1 13 13 CD 37231 3526 2 . . . 37231 3527 1 Or or CC 37231 3527 2 , , , 37231 3527 3 to to TO 37231 3527 4 take take VB 37231 3527 5 another another DT 37231 3527 6 instance instance NN 37231 3527 7 , , , 37231 3527 8 supposing suppose VBG 37231 3527 9 the the DT 37231 3527 10 third third JJ 37231 3527 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3527 12 to to TO 37231 3527 13 be be VB 37231 3527 14 lost lose VBN 37231 3527 15 , , , 37231 3527 16 and and CC 37231 3527 17 the the DT 37231 3527 18 following follow VBG 37231 3527 19 passage passage NN 37231 3527 20 quoted quote VBD 37231 3527 21 , , , 37231 3527 22 from from IN 37231 3527 23 an an DT 37231 3527 24 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 3527 25 source source NN 37231 3527 26 , , , 37231 3527 27 by by IN 37231 3527 28 one one CD 37231 3527 29 of of IN 37231 3527 30 the the DT 37231 3527 31 Fathers father NNS 37231 3527 32 : : : 37231 3527 33 " " `` 37231 3527 34 Beware beware VB 37231 3527 35 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3527 36 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3527 37 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3527 38 of of IN 37231 3527 39 the the DT 37231 3527 40 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3527 41 which which WDT 37231 3527 42 desire desire VBP 37231 3527 43 to to TO 37231 3527 44 walk walk VB 37231 3527 45 in in IN 37231 3527 46 long long JJ 37231 3527 47 robes robe NNS 37231 3527 48 , , , 37231 3527 49 and and CC 37231 3527 50 love love NN 37231 3527 51 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3527 52 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3527 53 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3527 54 greetings greeting NNS 37231 3527 55 in in IN 37231 3527 56 the the DT 37231 3527 57 markets market NNS 37231 3527 58 , , , 37231 3527 59 and and CC 37231 3527 60 chief chief JJ 37231 3527 61 seats seat NNS 37231 3527 62 in in IN 37231 3527 63 the the DT 37231 3527 64 synagogues synagogue NNS 37231 3527 65 and and CC 37231 3527 66 uppermost uppermost JJ 37231 3527 67 places place NNS 37231 3527 68 at at IN 37231 3527 69 feasts feast NNS 37231 3527 70 ; ; : 37231 3527 71 which which WDT 37231 3527 72 devour devour NN 37231 3527 73 widows(1 widows(1 NN 37231 3527 74 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3527 75 houses house NNS 37231 3527 76 , , , 37231 3527 77 and and CC 37231 3527 78 for for IN 37231 3527 79 a a DT 37231 3527 80 pretence pretence NN 37231 3527 81 make make VBP 37231 3527 82 long long JJ 37231 3527 83 prayers prayer NNS 37231 3527 84 : : : 37231 3527 85 these these DT 37231 3527 86 shall shall MD 37231 3527 87 receive receive VB 37231 3527 88 greater great JJR 37231 3527 89 damnation damnation NN 37231 3527 90 . . . 37231 3527 91 " " '' 37231 3528 1 This this DT 37231 3528 2 would would MD 37231 3528 3 without without IN 37231 3528 4 hesitation hesitation NN 37231 3528 5 be be VB 37231 3528 6 declared declare VBN 37231 3528 7 a a DT 37231 3528 8 quotation quotation NN 37231 3528 9 from from IN 37231 3528 10 memory memory NN 37231 3528 11 of of IN 37231 3528 12 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3528 13 xii xii NNP 37231 3528 14 .. .. NFP 37231 3528 15 38 38 CD 37231 3528 16 - - SYM 37231 3528 17 40 40 CD 37231 3528 18 " " '' 37231 3528 19 .... .... . 37231 3528 20 Beware beware VB 37231 3528 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3528 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3528 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3528 24 of of IN 37231 3528 25 the the DT 37231 3528 26 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3528 27 which which WDT 37231 3528 28 desire desire VBP 37231 3528 29 to to TO 37231 3528 30 walk walk VB 37231 3528 31 in in IN 37231 3528 32 long long JJ 37231 3528 33 robes robe NNS 37231 3528 34 and and CC 37231 3528 35 greetings greeting NNS 37231 3528 36 in in IN 37231 3528 37 the the DT 37231 3528 38 markets market NNS 37231 3528 39 , , , 37231 3528 40 and and CC 37231 3528 41 chief chief JJ 37231 3528 42 seats seat NNS 37231 3528 43 in in IN 37231 3528 44 the the DT 37231 3528 45 synagogues synagogue NNS 37231 3528 46 and and CC 37231 3528 47 uppermost uppermost JJ 37231 3528 48 places place NNS 37231 3528 49 at at IN 37231 3528 50 feasts feast NNS 37231 3528 51 : : : 37231 3528 52 which which WDT 37231 3528 53 devour devour NN 37231 3528 54 widows widow NNS 37231 3528 55 ' ' POS 37231 3528 56 houses house NNS 37231 3528 57 , , , 37231 3528 58 and and CC 37231 3528 59 for for IN 37231 3528 60 a a DT 37231 3528 61 pretence pretence NN 37231 3528 62 make make VBP 37231 3528 63 long long JJ 37231 3528 64 prayers prayer NNS 37231 3528 65 : : : 37231 3528 66 these these DT 37231 3528 67 shall shall MD 37231 3528 68 receive receive VB 37231 3528 69 , , , 37231 3528 70 " " '' 37231 3528 71 & & CC 37231 3528 72 c. c. NNP 37231 3528 73 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3528 74 is be VBZ 37231 3528 75 however however RB 37231 3528 76 a a DT 37231 3528 77 literal literal JJ 37231 3528 78 quotation quotation NN 37231 3528 79 of of IN 37231 3528 80 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3528 81 xx xx CD 37231 3528 82 . . . 37231 3529 1 46 46 CD 37231 3529 2 , , , 37231 3529 3 47 47 CD 37231 3529 4 ; ; : 37231 3529 5 yet yet CC 37231 3529 6 probably probably RB 37231 3529 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3529 8 would would MD 37231 3529 9 be be VB 37231 3529 10 in in IN 37231 3529 11 vain vain JJ 37231 3529 12 to to TO 37231 3529 13 submit submit VB 37231 3529 14 to to IN 37231 3529 15 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 3529 16 critics critic NNS 37231 3529 17 that that WDT 37231 3529 18 possibly possibly RB 37231 3529 19 , , , 37231 3529 20 not not RB 37231 3529 21 to to TO 37231 3529 22 say say VB 37231 3529 23 probably probably RB 37231 3529 24 , , , 37231 3529 25 the the DT 37231 3529 26 passage passage NN 37231 3529 27 was be VBD 37231 3529 28 not not RB 37231 3529 29 derived derive VBN 37231 3529 30 from from IN 37231 3529 31 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3529 32 but but CC 37231 3529 33 from from IN 37231 3529 34 a a DT 37231 3529 35 lost lost JJ 37231 3529 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3529 37 . . . 37231 3530 1 To to TO 37231 3530 2 quote quote VB 37231 3530 3 one one CD 37231 3530 4 more more JJR 37231 3530 5 instance instance NN 37231 3530 6 , , , 37231 3530 7 let let VB 37231 3530 8 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3530 9 { { -LRB- 37231 3530 10 364 364 CD 37231 3530 11 } } -RRB- 37231 3530 12 suppose suppose VBP 37231 3530 13 the the DT 37231 3530 14 " " `` 37231 3530 15 Gospel gospel NN 37231 3530 16 according accord VBG 37231 3530 17 to to IN 37231 3530 18 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3530 19 " " `` 37231 3530 20 no no RB 37231 3530 21 longer long RBR 37231 3530 22 extant extant JJ 37231 3530 23 , , , 37231 3530 24 and and CC 37231 3530 25 that that IN 37231 3530 26 in in IN 37231 3530 27 some some DT 37231 3530 28 early early JJ 37231 3530 29 work work NN 37231 3530 30 there there EX 37231 3530 31 existed exist VBD 37231 3530 32 the the DT 37231 3530 33 following following JJ 37231 3530 34 quotation quotation NN 37231 3530 35 : : : 37231 3530 36 " " `` 37231 3530 37 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3530 38 is be VBZ 37231 3530 39 easier easy JJR 37231 3530 40 for for IN 37231 3530 41 a a DT 37231 3530 42 camel camel NN 37231 3530 43 to to TO 37231 3530 44 go go VB 37231 3530 45 through through IN 37231 3530 46 the the DT 37231 3530 47 eye eye NN 37231 3530 48 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3530 49 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3530 50 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3530 51 of of IN 37231 3530 52 a a DT 37231 3530 53 needle needle NN 37231 3530 54 , , , 37231 3530 55 than than IN 37231 3530 56 for for IN 37231 3530 57 a a DT 37231 3530 58 rich rich JJ 37231 3530 59 man man NN 37231 3530 60 to to TO 37231 3530 61 enter enter VB 37231 3530 62 into into IN 37231 3530 63 the the DT 37231 3530 64 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 3530 65 of of IN 37231 3530 66 God God NNP 37231 3530 67 . . . 37231 3530 68 " " '' 37231 3531 1 This this DT 37231 3531 2 would would MD 37231 3531 3 of of IN 37231 3531 4 course course NN 37231 3531 5 be be VB 37231 3531 6 claimed claim VBN 37231 3531 7 as as IN 37231 3531 8 a a DT 37231 3531 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 3531 10 from from IN 37231 3531 11 memory memory NN 37231 3531 12 of of IN 37231 3531 13 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3531 14 . . . 37231 3532 1 xix xix NNP 37231 3532 2 . . . 37231 3533 1 24,(1 24,(1 LS 37231 3533 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3533 3 with with IN 37231 3533 4 which which WDT 37231 3533 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3533 6 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3533 7 with with IN 37231 3533 8 the the DT 37231 3533 9 exception exception NN 37231 3533 10 of of IN 37231 3533 11 the the DT 37231 3533 12 substitution substitution NN 37231 3533 13 of of IN 37231 3533 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3533 15 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3533 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3533 17 for for IN 37231 3533 18 the the DT 37231 3533 19 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3533 20 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3533 21 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3533 22 . . . 37231 3534 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3534 2 would would MD 37231 3534 3 not not RB 37231 3534 4 the the DT 37231 3534 5 less less JJR 37231 3534 6 have have VBP 37231 3534 7 been be VBN 37231 3534 8 an an DT 37231 3534 9 exact exact JJ 37231 3534 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 3534 11 from from IN 37231 3534 12 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3534 13 x. x. NNP 37231 3535 1 25 25 CD 37231 3535 2 . . . 37231 3536 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3536 2 2 2 LS 37231 3536 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3536 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3536 5 have have VBP 37231 3536 6 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 3536 7 pointed point VBN 37231 3536 8 out out RP 37231 3536 9 that that IN 37231 3536 10 the the DT 37231 3536 11 actual actual JJ 37231 3536 12 agreement agreement NN 37231 3536 13 of of IN 37231 3536 14 any any DT 37231 3536 15 saying saying NN 37231 3536 16 of of IN 37231 3536 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3536 18 , , , 37231 3536 19 quoted quote VBN 37231 3536 20 by by IN 37231 3536 21 one one CD 37231 3536 22 of of IN 37231 3536 23 the the DT 37231 3536 24 early early JJ 37231 3536 25 Fathers father NNS 37231 3536 26 from from IN 37231 3536 27 an an DT 37231 3536 28 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 3536 29 source source NN 37231 3536 30 , , , 37231 3536 31 with with IN 37231 3536 32 a a DT 37231 3536 33 passage passage NN 37231 3536 34 in in IN 37231 3536 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3536 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3536 37 is be VBZ 37231 3536 38 by by IN 37231 3536 39 no no DT 37231 3536 40 means means NN 37231 3536 41 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 3536 42 evidence evidence NN 37231 3536 43 that that IN 37231 3536 44 the the DT 37231 3536 45 quotation quotation NN 37231 3536 46 was be VBD 37231 3536 47 actually actually RB 37231 3536 48 derived derive VBN 37231 3536 49 from from IN 37231 3536 50 that that DT 37231 3536 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3536 52 . . . 37231 3537 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3537 2 must must MD 37231 3537 3 be be VB 37231 3537 4 apparent apparent JJ 37231 3537 5 that that IN 37231 3537 6 literal literal JJ 37231 3537 7 agreement agreement NN 37231 3537 8 in in IN 37231 3537 9 reporting report VBG 37231 3537 10 short short JJ 37231 3537 11 and and CC 37231 3537 12 important important JJ 37231 3537 13 sayings saying NNS 37231 3537 14 is be VBZ 37231 3537 15 not not RB 37231 3537 16 in in IN 37231 3537 17 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3537 18 so so RB 37231 3537 19 surprising surprising JJ 37231 3537 20 as as IN 37231 3537 21 to to TO 37231 3537 22 constitute constitute VB 37231 3537 23 proof proof NN 37231 3537 24 that that IN 37231 3537 25 , , , 37231 3537 26 occurring occur VBG 37231 3537 27 in in IN 37231 3537 28 two two CD 37231 3537 29 histories history NNS 37231 3537 30 , , , 37231 3537 31 the the DT 37231 3537 32 one one NN 37231 3537 33 must must MD 37231 3537 34 have have VB 37231 3537 35 copied copy VBN 37231 3537 36 from from IN 37231 3537 37 the the DT 37231 3537 38 other other JJ 37231 3537 39 . . . 37231 3538 1 The the DT 37231 3538 2 only only JJ 37231 3538 3 thing thing NN 37231 3538 4 which which WDT 37231 3538 5 is be VBZ 37231 3538 6 surprising surprising JJ 37231 3538 7 is be VBZ 37231 3538 8 that that IN 37231 3538 9 such such JJ 37231 3538 10 frequent frequent JJ 37231 3538 11 inaccuracy inaccuracy NN 37231 3538 12 should should MD 37231 3538 13 occur occur VB 37231 3538 14 . . . 37231 3539 1 When when WRB 37231 3539 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3539 3 add add VBP 37231 3539 4 , , , 37231 3539 5 however however RB 37231 3539 6 , , , 37231 3539 7 the the DT 37231 3539 8 fact fact NN 37231 3539 9 that that IN 37231 3539 10 most most JJS 37231 3539 11 of of IN 37231 3539 12 the the DT 37231 3539 13 larger large JJR 37231 3539 14 early early JJ 37231 3539 15 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 3539 16 works work NNS 37231 3539 17 , , , 37231 3539 18 including include VBG 37231 3539 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3539 20 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3539 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3539 22 , , , 37231 3539 23 must must MD 37231 3539 24 have have VB 37231 3539 25 been be VBN 37231 3539 26 compiled compile VBN 37231 3539 27 out out IN 37231 3539 28 of of IN 37231 3539 29 the the DT 37231 3539 30 same same JJ 37231 3539 31 original original JJ 37231 3539 32 sources source NNS 37231 3539 33 , , , 37231 3539 34 and and CC 37231 3539 35 have have VBP 37231 3539 36 been be VBN 37231 3539 37 largely largely RB 37231 3539 38 indebted indebted JJ 37231 3539 39 to to IN 37231 3539 40 each each DT 37231 3539 41 other other JJ 37231 3539 42 , , , 37231 3539 43 the the DT 37231 3539 44 common common JJ 37231 3539 45 possession possession NN 37231 3539 46 of of IN 37231 3539 47 such such JJ 37231 3539 48 sayings saying NNS 37231 3539 49 becomes become VBZ 37231 3539 50 { { -LRB- 37231 3539 51 365 365 CD 37231 3539 52 } } -RRB- 37231 3539 53 a a DT 37231 3539 54 matter matter NN 37231 3539 55 of of IN 37231 3539 56 natural natural JJ 37231 3539 57 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 3539 58 . . . 37231 3540 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3540 2 , , , 37231 3540 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3540 4 must must MD 37231 3540 5 be be VB 37231 3540 6 admitted admit VBN 37231 3540 7 even even RB 37231 3540 8 by by IN 37231 3540 9 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 3540 10 critics critic NNS 37231 3540 11 that that WDT 37231 3540 12 , , , 37231 3540 13 in in IN 37231 3540 14 a a DT 37231 3540 15 case case NN 37231 3540 16 of of IN 37231 3540 17 such such JJ 37231 3540 18 vast vast JJ 37231 3540 19 importance importance NN 37231 3540 20 as as IN 37231 3540 21 the the DT 37231 3540 22 report report NN 37231 3540 23 of of IN 37231 3540 24 sayings saying NNS 37231 3540 25 of of IN 37231 3540 26 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3540 27 , , , 37231 3540 28 upon upon IN 37231 3540 29 the the DT 37231 3540 30 verbal verbal JJ 37231 3540 31 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3540 32 of of IN 37231 3540 33 which which WDT 37231 3540 34 the the DT 37231 3540 35 most most RBS 37231 3540 36 essential essential JJ 37231 3540 37 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3540 38 of of IN 37231 3540 39 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 3540 40 depend depend VB 37231 3540 41 , , , 37231 3540 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3540 43 can can MD 37231 3540 44 not not RB 37231 3540 45 be be VB 37231 3540 46 considered consider VBN 37231 3540 47 strange strange JJ 37231 3540 48 if if IN 37231 3540 49 various various JJ 37231 3540 50 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3540 51 report report VBP 37231 3540 52 the the DT 37231 3540 53 same same JJ 37231 3540 54 saying saying NN 37231 3540 55 in in IN 37231 3540 56 the the DT 37231 3540 57 same same JJ 37231 3540 58 words word NNS 37231 3540 59 . . . 37231 3541 1 Practically practically RB 37231 3541 2 , , , 37231 3541 3 the the DT 37231 3541 4 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3541 5 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3541 6 differ differ VBP 37231 3541 7 in in IN 37231 3541 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3541 9 reports report NNS 37231 3541 10 a a DT 37231 3541 11 great great JJ 37231 3541 12 deal deal NN 37231 3541 13 more more RBR 37231 3541 14 than than IN 37231 3541 15 is be VBZ 37231 3541 16 right right JJ 37231 3541 17 or or CC 37231 3541 18 desirable desirable JJ 37231 3541 19 ; ; : 37231 3541 20 but but CC 37231 3541 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3541 22 may may MD 37231 3541 23 take take VB 37231 3541 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3541 25 as as IN 37231 3541 26 an an DT 37231 3541 27 illustration illustration NN 37231 3541 28 of of IN 37231 3541 29 the the DT 37231 3541 30 fact fact NN 37231 3541 31 , , , 37231 3541 32 that that DT 37231 3541 33 identity identity NN 37231 3541 34 of of IN 37231 3541 35 passages passage NNS 37231 3541 36 , , , 37231 3541 37 where where WRB 37231 3541 38 the the DT 37231 3541 39 source source NN 37231 3541 40 is be VBZ 37231 3541 41 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 3541 42 , , , 37231 3541 43 by by IN 37231 3541 44 no no DT 37231 3541 45 means means NN 37231 3541 46 proves prove VBZ 37231 3541 47 that that IN 37231 3541 48 such such JJ 37231 3541 49 passages passage NNS 37231 3541 50 in in IN 37231 3541 51 a a DT 37231 3541 52 work work NN 37231 3541 53 of of IN 37231 3541 54 the the DT 37231 3541 55 early early JJ 37231 3541 56 Fathers father NNS 37231 3541 57 were be VBD 37231 3541 58 derived derive VBN 37231 3541 59 from from IN 37231 3541 60 one one CD 37231 3541 61 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3541 62 , , , 37231 3541 63 and and CC 37231 3541 64 not not RB 37231 3541 65 from from IN 37231 3541 66 any any DT 37231 3541 67 other other JJ 37231 3541 68 . . . 37231 3542 1 Let let VB 37231 3542 2 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3542 3 suppose suppose VB 37231 3542 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3542 5 first first JJ 37231 3542 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3542 7 to to TO 37231 3542 8 have have VB 37231 3542 9 been be VBN 37231 3542 10 lost lose VBN 37231 3542 11 , , , 37231 3542 12 and and CC 37231 3542 13 the the DT 37231 3542 14 following following JJ 37231 3542 15 quotation quotation NN 37231 3542 16 from from IN 37231 3542 17 an an DT 37231 3542 18 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 3542 19 source source NN 37231 3542 20 to to TO 37231 3542 21 be be VB 37231 3542 22 found find VBN 37231 3542 23 in in IN 37231 3542 24 an an DT 37231 3542 25 early early JJ 37231 3542 26 work work NN 37231 3542 27 : : : 37231 3542 28 " " `` 37231 3542 29 Every every DT 37231 3542 30 tree tree NN 37231 3542 31 that that WDT 37231 3542 32 bringeth bringeth VBP 37231 3542 33 not not RB 37231 3542 34 forth forth RB 37231 3542 35 good good JJ 37231 3542 36 fruit fruit NN 37231 3542 37 is be VBZ 37231 3542 38 hewn hew VBN 37231 3542 39 down down RP 37231 3542 40 , , , 37231 3542 41 and and CC 37231 3542 42 cast cast VBD 37231 3542 43 into into IN 37231 3542 44 the the DT 37231 3542 45 fire fire NN 37231 3542 46 . . . 37231 3542 47 " " '' 37231 3543 1 This this DT 37231 3543 2 being be VBG 37231 3543 3 in in IN 37231 3543 4 literal literal JJ 37231 3543 5 agreement agreement NN 37231 3543 6 with with IN 37231 3543 7 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3543 8 iii iii NNP 37231 3543 9 . . . 37231 3544 1 9 9 CD 37231 3544 2 , , , 37231 3544 3 would would MD 37231 3544 4 certainly certainly RB 37231 3544 5 be be VB 37231 3544 6 declared declare VBN 37231 3544 7 by by IN 37231 3544 8 modern modern JJ 37231 3544 9 apologists apologist NNS 37231 3544 10 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 3544 11 proof proof NN 37231 3544 12 that that IN 37231 3544 13 the the DT 37231 3544 14 Father Father NNP 37231 3544 15 was be VBD 37231 3544 16 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 3544 17 with with IN 37231 3544 18 that that DT 37231 3544 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3544 20 , , , 37231 3544 21 and and CC 37231 3544 22 although although IN 37231 3544 23 the the DT 37231 3544 24 context context NN 37231 3544 25 in in IN 37231 3544 26 the the DT 37231 3544 27 work work NN 37231 3544 28 of of IN 37231 3544 29 the the DT 37231 3544 30 Father Father NNP 37231 3544 31 might may MD 37231 3544 32 for for IN 37231 3544 33 instance instance NN 37231 3544 34 be be VB 37231 3544 35 : : : 37231 3544 36 " " `` 37231 3544 37 Ye Ye NNP 37231 3544 38 shall shall MD 37231 3544 39 know know VB 37231 3544 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3544 41 from from IN 37231 3544 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3544 43 works work NNS 37231 3544 44 , , , 37231 3544 45 and and CC 37231 3544 46 every every DT 37231 3544 47 tree tree NN 37231 3544 48 , , , 37231 3544 49 " " '' 37231 3544 50 & & CC 37231 3544 51 c c NNP 37231 3544 52 , , , 37231 3544 53 & & CC 37231 3544 54 c c NNP 37231 3544 55 , , , 37231 3544 56 and and CC 37231 3544 57 yet yet RB 37231 3544 58 in in IN 37231 3544 59 the the DT 37231 3544 60 third third JJ 37231 3544 61 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3544 62 , , , 37231 3544 63 the the DT 37231 3544 64 context context NN 37231 3544 65 is be VBZ 37231 3544 66 : : : 37231 3544 67 " " `` 37231 3544 68 And and CC 37231 3544 69 now now RB 37231 3544 70 also also RB 37231 3544 71 , , , 37231 3544 72 the the DT 37231 3544 73 axe axe NN 37231 3544 74 is be VBZ 37231 3544 75 laid lay VBN 37231 3544 76 unto unto IN 37231 3544 77 the the DT 37231 3544 78 root root NN 37231 3544 79 of of IN 37231 3544 80 the the DT 37231 3544 81 trees tree NNS 37231 3544 82 : : : 37231 3544 83 and and CC 37231 3544 84 every every DT 37231 3544 85 tree tree NN 37231 3544 86 , , , 37231 3544 87 " " '' 37231 3544 88 & & CC 37231 3544 89 c c NNP 37231 3544 90 , , , 37231 3544 91 that that WDT 37231 3544 92 would would MD 37231 3544 93 by by IN 37231 3544 94 no no DT 37231 3544 95 means means NN 37231 3544 96 give give VB 37231 3544 97 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3544 98 pause pause NN 37231 3544 99 . . . 37231 3545 1 The the DT 37231 3545 2 explanation explanation NN 37231 3545 3 of of IN 37231 3545 4 combination combination NN 37231 3545 5 of of IN 37231 3545 6 texts text NNS 37231 3545 7 , , , 37231 3545 8 and and CC 37231 3545 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 3545 10 from from IN 37231 3545 11 memory memory NN 37231 3545 12 , , , 37231 3545 13 is be VBZ 37231 3545 14 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 3545 15 elastic elastic JJ 37231 3545 16 for for IN 37231 3545 17 every every DT 37231 3545 18 emergency emergency NN 37231 3545 19 . . . 37231 3546 1 Now now RB 37231 3546 2 the the DT 37231 3546 3 words word NNS 37231 3546 4 in in IN 37231 3546 5 question question NN 37231 3546 6 might may MD 37231 3546 7 in in IN 37231 3546 8 reality reality NN 37231 3546 9 be be VB 37231 3546 10 a a DT 37231 3546 11 quotation quotation NN 37231 3546 12 from from IN 37231 3546 13 the the DT 37231 3546 14 lost lost JJ 37231 3546 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3546 16 according accord VBG 37231 3546 17 to to IN 37231 3546 18 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3546 19 , , , 37231 3546 20 in in IN 37231 3546 21 which which WDT 37231 3546 22 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3546 23 twice twice RB 37231 3546 24 occur occur VBP 37231 3546 25 , , , 37231 3546 26 so so IN 37231 3546 27 that that IN 37231 3546 28 here here RB 37231 3546 29 is be VBZ 37231 3546 30 a a DT 37231 3546 31 passage passage NN 37231 3546 32 which which WDT 37231 3546 33 is be VBZ 37231 3546 34 literally literally RB 37231 3546 35 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3546 36 three three CD 37231 3546 37 times time NNS 37231 3546 38 , , , 37231 3546 39 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3546 40 iii iii NNP 37231 3546 41 . . . 37231 3547 1 10 10 CD 37231 3547 2 , , , 37231 3547 3 vii vii NN 37231 3547 4 . . . 37231 3548 1 19 19 CD 37231 3548 2 , , , 37231 3548 3 and and CC 37231 3548 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3548 5 iii iii NNP 37231 3548 6 9 9 CD 37231 3548 7 . . . 37231 3549 1 In in IN 37231 3549 2 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3549 3 iii iii NNP 37231 3549 4 . . . 37231 3550 1 10 10 CD 37231 3550 2 , , , 37231 3550 3 and and CC 37231 3550 4 in in IN 37231 3550 5 the the DT 37231 3550 6 third third JJ 37231 3550 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3550 8 , , , 37231 3550 9 the the DT 37231 3550 10 words word NNS 37231 3550 11 are be VBP 37231 3550 12 part part NN 37231 3550 13 of of IN 37231 3550 14 a a DT 37231 3550 15 saying saying NN 37231 3550 16 of of IN 37231 3550 17 John John NNP 37231 3550 18 the the DT 37231 3550 19 { { -LRB- 37231 3550 20 366 366 CD 37231 3550 21 } } -RRB- 37231 3550 22 Baptist baptist NN 37231 3550 23 ; ; : 37231 3550 24 whilst whilst IN 37231 3550 25 in in IN 37231 3550 26 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3550 27 vii vii NN 37231 3550 28 . . . 37231 3551 1 19 19 CD 37231 3551 2 , , , 37231 3551 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3551 4 are be VBP 37231 3551 5 given give VBN 37231 3551 6 as as IN 37231 3551 7 part part NN 37231 3551 8 of of IN 37231 3551 9 the the DT 37231 3551 10 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3551 11 on on IN 37231 3551 12 the the DT 37231 3551 13 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3551 14 , , , 37231 3551 15 with with IN 37231 3551 16 a a DT 37231 3551 17 different different JJ 37231 3551 18 context context NN 37231 3551 19 , , , 37231 3551 20 This this DT 37231 3551 21 passage passage NN 37231 3551 22 is be VBZ 37231 3551 23 actually actually RB 37231 3551 24 quoted quote VBN 37231 3551 25 by by IN 37231 3551 26 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3551 27 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3551 28 k k NNP 37231 3551 29 8) 8) CD 37231 3551 30 , , , 37231 3551 31 with with IN 37231 3551 32 the the DT 37231 3551 33 context context NN 37231 3551 34 : : : 37231 3551 35 " " `` 37231 3551 36 Ye Ye NNP 37231 3551 37 shall shall MD 37231 3551 38 know know VB 37231 3551 39 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3551 40 from from IN 37231 3551 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3551 42 works work NNS 37231 3551 43 , , , 37231 3551 44 " " '' 37231 3551 45 which which WDT 37231 3551 46 is be VBZ 37231 3551 47 different different JJ 37231 3551 48 from from IN 37231 3551 49 that that DT 37231 3551 50 in in IN 37231 3551 51 any any DT 37231 3551 52 of of IN 37231 3551 53 the the DT 37231 3551 54 three three CD 37231 3551 55 places place NNS 37231 3551 56 in in IN 37231 3551 57 which which WDT 37231 3551 58 the the DT 37231 3551 59 words word NNS 37231 3551 60 occur occur VBP 37231 3551 61 in in IN 37231 3551 62 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3551 63 synoptics synoptic NNS 37231 3551 64 and and CC 37231 3551 65 , , , 37231 3551 66 on on IN 37231 3551 67 the the DT 37231 3551 68 grounds ground NNS 37231 3551 69 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3551 70 have have VBP 37231 3551 71 clearly clearly RB 37231 3551 72 established establish VBN 37231 3551 73 , , , 37231 3551 74 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3551 75 can can MD 37231 3551 76 not not RB 37231 3551 77 be be VB 37231 3551 78 considered consider VBN 37231 3551 79 in in IN 37231 3551 80 any any DT 37231 3551 81 case case NN 37231 3551 82 as as IN 37231 3551 83 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 3551 84 a a DT 37231 3551 85 quotation quotation NN 37231 3551 86 from from IN 37231 3551 87 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3551 88 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3551 89 , , , 37231 3551 90 but but CC 37231 3551 91 , , , 37231 3551 92 on on IN 37231 3551 93 the the DT 37231 3551 94 contrary contrary NN 37231 3551 95 , , , 37231 3551 96 there there EX 37231 3551 97 are be VBP 37231 3551 98 good good JJ 37231 3551 99 reasons reason NNS 37231 3551 100 for for IN 37231 3551 101 the the DT 37231 3551 102 very very RB 37231 3551 103 opposite opposite JJ 37231 3551 104 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3551 105 . . . 37231 3552 1 Another another DT 37231 3552 2 illustration illustration NN 37231 3552 3 of of IN 37231 3552 4 this this DT 37231 3552 5 may may MD 37231 3552 6 be be VB 37231 3552 7 given give VBN 37231 3552 8 , , , 37231 3552 9 by by IN 37231 3552 10 supposing suppose VBG 37231 3552 11 the the DT 37231 3552 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3552 13 of of IN 37231 3552 14 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3552 15 to to TO 37231 3552 16 be be VB 37231 3552 17 no no DT 37231 3552 18 longer long RBR 37231 3552 19 extant extant JJ 37231 3552 20 , , , 37231 3552 21 and and CC 37231 3552 22 the the DT 37231 3552 23 following follow VBG 37231 3552 24 sentence sentence NN 37231 3552 25 in in IN 37231 3552 26 one one CD 37231 3552 27 of of IN 37231 3552 28 the the DT 37231 3552 29 Fathers father NNS 37231 3552 30 : : : 37231 3552 31 " " '' 37231 3552 32 And and CC 37231 3552 33 ye ye NNP 37231 3552 34 shall shall MD 37231 3552 35 be be VB 37231 3552 36 hated hate VBN 37231 3552 37 by by IN 37231 3552 38 all all DT 37231 3552 39 men man NNS 37231 3552 40 , , , 37231 3552 41 for for IN 37231 3552 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3552 43 name name NN 37231 3552 44 's 's POS 37231 3552 45 sake sake NN 37231 3552 46 . . . 37231 3552 47 " " '' 37231 3553 1 These these DT 37231 3553 2 very very JJ 37231 3553 3 words word NNS 37231 3553 4 occur occur VBP 37231 3553 5 both both DT 37231 3553 6 in in IN 37231 3553 7 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3553 8 x. x. NNP 37231 3554 1 22 22 CD 37231 3554 2 , , , 37231 3554 3 and and CC 37231 3554 4 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3554 5 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3554 6 . . . 37231 3555 1 13 13 CD 37231 3555 2 , , , 37231 3555 3 in in IN 37231 3555 4 both both DT 37231 3555 5 of of IN 37231 3555 6 which which WDT 37231 3555 7 places place NNS 37231 3555 8 there there RB 37231 3555 9 follow follow VBP 37231 3555 10 the the DT 37231 3555 11 words word NNS 37231 3555 12 : : : 37231 3555 13 " " `` 37231 3555 14 but but CC 37231 3555 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3555 16 that that WDT 37231 3555 17 endureth endureth JJ 37231 3555 18 to to IN 37231 3555 19 the the DT 37231 3555 20 end end NN 37231 3555 21 , , , 37231 3555 22 the the DT 37231 3555 23 same same JJ 37231 3555 24 shall shall MD 37231 3555 25 be be VB 37231 3555 26 saved save VBN 37231 3555 27 . . . 37231 3555 28 " " '' 37231 3556 1 There there EX 37231 3556 2 might may MD 37231 3556 3 here here RB 37231 3556 4 have have VB 37231 3556 5 been be VBN 37231 3556 6 a a DT 37231 3556 7 doubt doubt NN 37231 3556 8 , , , 37231 3556 9 as as IN 37231 3556 10 to to IN 37231 3556 11 whether whether IN 37231 3556 12 the the DT 37231 3556 13 Father Father NNP 37231 3556 14 derived derive VBD 37231 3556 15 the the DT 37231 3556 16 words word NNS 37231 3556 17 from from IN 37231 3556 18 the the DT 37231 3556 19 first first JJ 37231 3556 20 or or CC 37231 3556 21 second second JJ 37231 3556 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3556 23 , , , 37231 3556 24 but but CC 37231 3556 25 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3556 26 would would MD 37231 3556 27 have have VB 37231 3556 28 been be VBN 37231 3556 29 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 3556 30 either either CC 37231 3556 31 to to IN 37231 3556 32 the the DT 37231 3556 33 one one NN 37231 3556 34 or or CC 37231 3556 35 to to IN 37231 3556 36 the the DT 37231 3556 37 other other JJ 37231 3556 38 , , , 37231 3556 39 whilst whilst IN 37231 3556 40 in in IN 37231 3556 41 reality reality NN 37231 3556 42 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3556 43 were be VBD 37231 3556 44 taken take VBN 37231 3556 45 from from IN 37231 3556 46 a a DT 37231 3556 47 different different JJ 37231 3556 48 work work NN 37231 3556 49 altogether altogether RB 37231 3556 50 , , , 37231 3556 51 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3556 52 xxi xxi NNP 37231 3556 53 . . . 37231 3557 1 17 17 CD 37231 3557 2 . . . 37231 3558 1 Here here RB 37231 3558 2 again again RB 37231 3558 3 , , , 37231 3558 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3558 5 have have VBP 37231 3558 6 the the DT 37231 3558 7 same same JJ 37231 3558 8 words word NNS 37231 3558 9 in in IN 37231 3558 10 three three CD 37231 3558 11 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3558 12 . . . 37231 3559 1 In in IN 37231 3559 2 how how WRB 37231 3559 3 many many JJ 37231 3559 4 more more JJR 37231 3559 5 may may MD 37231 3559 6 not not RB 37231 3559 7 the the DT 37231 3559 8 same same JJ 37231 3559 9 passage passage NN 37231 3559 10 have have VBP 37231 3559 11 been be VBN 37231 3559 12 found find VBN 37231 3559 13 ? ? . 37231 3560 1 One one CD 37231 3560 2 more more JJR 37231 3560 3 instance instance NN 37231 3560 4 to to TO 37231 3560 5 conclude conclude VB 37231 3560 6 . . . 37231 3561 1 The the DT 37231 3561 2 following follow VBG 37231 3561 3 passage passage NN 37231 3561 4 might may MD 37231 3561 5 be be VB 37231 3561 6 quoted quote VBN 37231 3561 7 from from IN 37231 3561 8 an an DT 37231 3561 9 unnamed unnamed JJ 37231 3561 10 source source NN 37231 3561 11 by by IN 37231 3561 12 one one CD 37231 3561 13 of of IN 37231 3561 14 the the DT 37231 3561 15 Fathers father NNS 37231 3561 16 : : : 37231 3561 17 " " `` 37231 3561 18 Heaven Heaven NNP 37231 3561 19 and and CC 37231 3561 20 earth earth NN 37231 3561 21 shall shall MD 37231 3561 22 pass pass VB 37231 3561 23 away away RB 37231 3561 24 , , , 37231 3561 25 but but CC 37231 3561 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3561 27 words word NNS 37231 3561 28 shall shall MD 37231 3561 29 not not RB 37231 3561 30 pass pass VB 37231 3561 31 away away RB 37231 3561 32 . . . 37231 3561 33 " " '' 37231 3562 1 If if IN 37231 3562 2 the the DT 37231 3562 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3562 4 according accord VBG 37231 3562 5 to to IN 37231 3562 6 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3562 7 were be VBD 37231 3562 8 no no RB 37231 3562 9 longer long RBR 37231 3562 10 extant extant JJ 37231 3562 11 , , , 37231 3562 12 this this DT 37231 3562 13 would would MD 37231 3562 14 be be VB 37231 3562 15 claimed claim VBN 37231 3562 16 as as IN 37231 3562 17 a a DT 37231 3562 18 quotation quotation NN 37231 3562 19 either either CC 37231 3562 20 from from IN 37231 3562 21 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3562 22 xxiv xxiv NNP 37231 3562 23 . . . 37231 3563 1 35 35 CD 37231 3563 2 , , , 37231 3563 3 or or CC 37231 3563 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3563 5 xxi xxi NNP 37231 3563 6 . . . 37231 3564 1 33 33 CD 37231 3564 2 , , , 37231 3564 3 in in IN 37231 3564 4 both both DT 37231 3564 5 of of IN 37231 3564 6 which which WDT 37231 3564 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3564 8 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3564 9 , , , 37231 3564 10 but but CC 37231 3564 11 , , , 37231 3564 12 notwithstanding notwithstanding RB 37231 3564 13 , , , 37231 3564 14 the the DT 37231 3564 15 Father Father NNP 37231 3564 16 might may MD 37231 3564 17 not not RB 37231 3564 18 have have VB 37231 3564 19 been be VBN 37231 3564 20 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 3564 21 with with IN 37231 3564 22 either either DT 37231 3564 23 of of IN 37231 3564 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3564 25 , , , 37231 3564 26 and and CC 37231 3564 27 simply simply RB 37231 3564 28 have have VB 37231 3564 29 quoted quote VBN 37231 3564 30 from from IN 37231 3564 31 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3564 32 { { -LRB- 37231 3564 33 367 367 CD 37231 3564 34 } } -RRB- 37231 3564 35 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3564 36 . . . 37231 3565 1 31.1 31.1 CD 37231 3565 2 And and CC 37231 3565 3 here here RB 37231 3565 4 again again RB 37231 3565 5 , , , 37231 3565 6 the the DT 37231 3565 7 three three CD 37231 3565 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3565 9 contain contain VBP 37231 3565 10 the the DT 37231 3565 11 same same JJ 37231 3565 12 passage passage NN 37231 3565 13 without without IN 37231 3565 14 variation variation NN 37231 3565 15 . . . 37231 3566 1 Now now RB 37231 3566 2 in in IN 37231 3566 3 all all PDT 37231 3566 4 these these DT 37231 3566 5 cases case NNS 37231 3566 6 , , , 37231 3566 7 not not RB 37231 3566 8 only only RB 37231 3566 9 is be VBZ 37231 3566 10 the the DT 37231 3566 11 selection selection NN 37231 3566 12 of of IN 37231 3566 13 the the DT 37231 3566 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3566 15 from from IN 37231 3566 16 which which WDT 37231 3566 17 the the DT 37231 3566 18 quotation quotation NN 37231 3566 19 was be VBD 37231 3566 20 actually actually RB 37231 3566 21 taken take VBN 37231 3566 22 completely completely RB 37231 3566 23 an an DT 37231 3566 24 open open JJ 37231 3566 25 question question NN 37231 3566 26 , , , 37231 3566 27 since since IN 37231 3566 28 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3566 29 all all DT 37231 3566 30 have have VBP 37231 3566 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3566 32 , , , 37231 3566 33 but but CC 37231 3566 34 still still RB 37231 3566 35 more more JJR 37231 3566 36 is be VBZ 37231 3566 37 the the DT 37231 3566 38 point point NN 37231 3566 39 uncertain uncertain JJ 37231 3566 40 , , , 37231 3566 41 when when WRB 37231 3566 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3566 43 is be VBZ 37231 3566 44 considered consider VBN 37231 3566 45 that that IN 37231 3566 46 many many JJ 37231 3566 47 other other JJ 37231 3566 48 works work NNS 37231 3566 49 may may MD 37231 3566 50 also also RB 37231 3566 51 have have VB 37231 3566 52 contained contain VBN 37231 3566 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3566 54 , , , 37231 3566 55 historical historical JJ 37231 3566 56 sayings saying NNS 37231 3566 57 being be VBG 37231 3566 58 naturally naturally RB 37231 3566 59 common common JJ 37231 3566 60 property property NN 37231 3566 61 . . . 37231 3567 1 Does do VBZ 37231 3567 2 the the DT 37231 3567 3 agreement agreement NN 37231 3567 4 of of IN 37231 3567 5 the the DT 37231 3567 6 quotation quotation NN 37231 3567 7 with with IN 37231 3567 8 a a DT 37231 3567 9 passage passage NN 37231 3567 10 which which WDT 37231 3567 11 is be VBZ 37231 3567 12 equally equally RB 37231 3567 13 found find VBN 37231 3567 14 in in IN 37231 3567 15 the the DT 37231 3567 16 three three CD 37231 3567 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3567 18 prove prove VBP 37231 3567 19 the the DT 37231 3567 20 existence existence NN 37231 3567 21 of of IN 37231 3567 22 all all DT 37231 3567 23 of of IN 37231 3567 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3567 25 ? ? . 37231 3568 1 and and CC 37231 3568 2 if if IN 37231 3568 3 not not RB 37231 3568 4 , , , 37231 3568 5 how how WRB 37231 3568 6 is be VBZ 37231 3568 7 the the DT 37231 3568 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3568 9 from from IN 37231 3568 10 which which WDT 37231 3568 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3568 12 was be VBD 37231 3568 13 actually actually RB 37231 3568 14 taken take VBN 37231 3568 15 to to TO 37231 3568 16 be be VB 37231 3568 17 distinguished distinguish VBN 37231 3568 18 ? ? . 37231 3569 1 If if IN 37231 3569 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3569 3 be be VB 37231 3569 4 difficult difficult JJ 37231 3569 5 to to TO 37231 3569 6 do do VB 37231 3569 7 so so RB 37231 3569 8 , , , 37231 3569 9 how how WRB 37231 3569 10 much much RB 37231 3569 11 more more JJR 37231 3569 12 when when WRB 37231 3569 13 the the DT 37231 3569 14 possibility possibility NN 37231 3569 15 and and CC 37231 3569 16 probability probability NN 37231 3569 17 , , , 37231 3569 18 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 3569 19 by by IN 37231 3569 20 the the DT 37231 3569 21 agreement agreement NN 37231 3569 22 of of IN 37231 3569 23 the the DT 37231 3569 24 three three CD 37231 3569 25 extant extant JJ 37231 3569 26 , , , 37231 3569 27 that that IN 37231 3569 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3569 29 might may MD 37231 3569 30 have have VB 37231 3569 31 formed form VBN 37231 3569 32 part part NN 37231 3569 33 of of IN 37231 3569 34 a a DT 37231 3569 35 dozen dozen NN 37231 3569 36 other other JJ 37231 3569 37 works work NNS 37231 3569 38 is be VBZ 37231 3569 39 taken take VBN 37231 3569 40 into into IN 37231 3569 41 account account NN 37231 3569 42 In in IN 37231 3569 43 the the DT 37231 3569 44 case case NN 37231 3569 45 of of IN 37231 3569 46 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3569 47 , , , 37231 3569 48 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3569 49 is be VBZ 37231 3569 50 simply simply RB 37231 3569 51 absurd absurd JJ 37231 3569 52 and and CC 37231 3569 53 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 3569 54 , , , 37231 3569 55 in in IN 37231 3569 56 the the DT 37231 3569 57 face face NN 37231 3569 58 of of IN 37231 3569 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3569 60 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3569 61 variation variation NN 37231 3569 62 from from IN 37231 3569 63 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3569 64 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3569 65 , , , 37231 3569 66 to to TO 37231 3569 67 assert assert VB 37231 3569 68 positively positively RB 37231 3569 69 that that IN 37231 3569 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3569 71 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3569 72 are be VBP 37231 3569 73 derived derive VBN 37231 3569 74 from from IN 37231 3569 75 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3569 76 . . . 37231 3570 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3570 2 must must MD 37231 3570 3 have have VB 37231 3570 4 been be VBN 37231 3570 5 apparent apparent JJ 37231 3570 6 to to IN 37231 3570 7 all all PDT 37231 3570 8 that that DT 37231 3570 9 , , , 37231 3570 10 throughout throughout IN 37231 3570 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3570 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3570 13 from from IN 37231 3570 14 the the DT 37231 3570 15 " " `` 37231 3570 16 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3570 17 on on IN 37231 3570 18 the the DT 37231 3570 19 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3570 20 , , , 37231 3570 21 " " `` 37231 3570 22 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3570 23 follows follow VBZ 37231 3570 24 an an DT 37231 3570 25 order order NN 37231 3570 26 which which WDT 37231 3570 27 is be VBZ 37231 3570 28 quite quite RB 37231 3570 29 different different JJ 37231 3570 30 from from IN 37231 3570 31 that that DT 37231 3570 32 in in IN 37231 3570 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3570 34 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3570 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3570 36 , , , 37231 3570 37 and and CC 37231 3570 38 as as IN 37231 3570 39 might may MD 37231 3570 40 have have VB 37231 3570 41 been be VBN 37231 3570 42 expected expect VBN 37231 3570 43 , , , 37231 3570 44 the the DT 37231 3570 45 inference inference NN 37231 3570 46 of of IN 37231 3570 47 a a DT 37231 3570 48 different different JJ 37231 3570 49 source source NN 37231 3570 50 , , , 37231 3570 51 which which WDT 37231 3570 52 is be VBZ 37231 3570 53 naturally naturally RB 37231 3570 54 suggested suggest VBN 37231 3570 55 by by IN 37231 3570 56 this this DT 37231 3570 57 variation variation NN 37231 3570 58 in in IN 37231 3570 59 order order NN 37231 3570 60 , , , 37231 3570 61 is be VBZ 37231 3570 62 more more RBR 37231 3570 63 than than IN 37231 3570 64 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 3570 65 by by IN 37231 3570 66 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3570 67 and and CC 37231 3570 68 continuous continuous JJ 37231 3570 69 variation variation NN 37231 3570 70 in in IN 37231 3570 71 language language NN 37231 3570 72 . . . 37231 3571 1 If if IN 37231 3571 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3571 3 be be VB 37231 3571 4 true true JJ 37231 3571 5 , , , 37231 3571 6 that that IN 37231 3571 7 examples example NNS 37231 3571 8 of of IN 37231 3571 9 confusion confusion NN 37231 3571 10 of of IN 37231 3571 11 quotation quotation NN 37231 3571 12 are be VBP 37231 3571 13 to to TO 37231 3571 14 be be VB 37231 3571 15 found find VBN 37231 3571 16 in in IN 37231 3571 17 the the DT 37231 3571 18 works work NNS 37231 3571 19 of of IN 37231 3571 20 Clement Clement NNP 37231 3571 21 of of IN 37231 3571 22 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 3571 23 , , , 37231 3571 24 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3571 25 , , , 37231 3571 26 and and CC 37231 3571 27 other other JJ 37231 3571 28 Fathers father NNS 37231 3571 29 , , , 37231 3571 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3571 31 must must MD 37231 3571 32 at at IN 37231 3571 33 the the DT 37231 3571 34 same same JJ 37231 3571 35 time time NN 37231 3571 36 be be VB 37231 3571 37 remembered remember VBN 37231 3571 38 , , , 37231 3571 39 that that IN 37231 3571 40 these these DT 37231 3571 41 are be VBP 37231 3571 42 quite quite RB 37231 3571 43 exceptional exceptional JJ 37231 3571 44 , , , 37231 3571 45 and and CC 37231 3571 46 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3571 47 are be VBP 37231 3571 48 { { -LRB- 37231 3571 49 368 368 CD 37231 3571 50 } } -RRB- 37231 3571 51 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 3571 52 in in IN 37231 3571 53 a a DT 37231 3571 54 position position NN 37231 3571 55 to to TO 37231 3571 56 judge judge VB 37231 3571 57 how how WRB 37231 3571 58 far far RB 37231 3571 59 confusion confusion NN 37231 3571 60 of of IN 37231 3571 61 memory memory NN 37231 3571 62 may may MD 37231 3571 63 not not RB 37231 3571 64 have have VB 37231 3571 65 arisen arise VBN 37231 3571 66 from from IN 37231 3571 67 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 37231 3571 68 of of IN 37231 3571 69 other other JJ 37231 3571 70 forms form NNS 37231 3571 71 of of IN 37231 3571 72 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 3571 73 expressions expression NNS 37231 3571 74 occurring occur VBG 37231 3571 75 in in IN 37231 3571 76 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3571 77 works work NNS 37231 3571 78 , , , 37231 3571 79 with with IN 37231 3571 80 which which WDT 37231 3571 81 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3571 82 know know VBP 37231 3571 83 the the DT 37231 3571 84 Fathers father NNS 37231 3571 85 to to TO 37231 3571 86 have have VB 37231 3571 87 been be VBN 37231 3571 88 well well RB 37231 3571 89 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 3571 90 . . . 37231 3572 1 The the DT 37231 3572 2 most most RBS 37231 3572 3 vehement vehement JJ 37231 3572 4 asserter asserter NN 37231 3572 5 of of IN 37231 3572 6 the the DT 37231 3572 7 identity identity NN 37231 3572 8 of of IN 37231 3572 9 the the DT 37231 3572 10 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3572 11 with with IN 37231 3572 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3572 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3572 14 , , , 37231 3572 15 however however RB 37231 3572 16 , , , 37231 3572 17 must must MD 37231 3572 18 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 3572 19 admit admit VB 37231 3572 20 as as IN 37231 3572 21 a a DT 37231 3572 22 fact fact NN 37231 3572 23 , , , 37231 3572 24 explain explain VB 37231 3572 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3572 26 as as IN 37231 3572 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3572 28 may may MD 37231 3572 29 , , , 37231 3572 30 that that DT 37231 3572 31 variation variation NN 37231 3572 32 from from IN 37231 3572 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3572 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3572 35 readings reading NNS 37231 3572 36 is be VBZ 37231 3572 37 the the DT 37231 3572 38 general general JJ 37231 3572 39 rule rule NN 37231 3572 40 in in IN 37231 3572 41 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3572 42 's 's POS 37231 3572 43 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3572 44 , , , 37231 3572 45 and and CC 37231 3572 46 agreement agreement NN 37231 3572 47 with with IN 37231 3572 48 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3572 49 the the DT 37231 3572 50 very very RB 37231 3572 51 rare rare JJ 37231 3572 52 exception.1 exception.1 NN 37231 3572 53 Now now RB 37231 3572 54 , , , 37231 3572 55 such such PDT 37231 3572 56 a a DT 37231 3572 57 phenomenon phenomenon NN 37231 3572 58 is be VBZ 37231 3572 59 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3572 60 unparalleled unparalleled JJ 37231 3572 61 in in IN 37231 3572 62 those those DT 37231 3572 63 times time NNS 37231 3572 64 , , , 37231 3572 65 when when WRB 37231 3572 66 memory memory NN 37231 3572 67 was be VBD 37231 3572 68 more more RBR 37231 3572 69 cultivated cultivate VBN 37231 3572 70 than than IN 37231 3572 71 with with IN 37231 3572 72 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3572 73 in in IN 37231 3572 74 these these DT 37231 3572 75 days day NNS 37231 3572 76 of of IN 37231 3572 77 cheap cheap JJ 37231 3572 78 printed print VBN 37231 3572 79 books book NNS 37231 3572 80 , , , 37231 3572 81 and and CC 37231 3572 82 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3572 83 is be VBZ 37231 3572 84 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 3572 85 to to TO 37231 3572 86 charge charge VB 37231 3572 87 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3572 88 with with IN 37231 3572 89 such such JJ 37231 3572 90 universal universal JJ 37231 3572 91 want want NN 37231 3572 92 of of IN 37231 3572 93 memory memory NN 37231 3572 94 and and CC 37231 3572 95 carelessness carelessness NN 37231 3572 96 about about IN 37231 3572 97 matters matter NNS 37231 3572 98 which which WDT 37231 3572 99 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3572 100 held hold VBD 37231 3572 101 so so RB 37231 3572 102 sacred sacred JJ 37231 3572 103 , , , 37231 3572 104 merely merely RB 37231 3572 105 to to TO 37231 3572 106 support support VB 37231 3572 107 a a DT 37231 3572 108 foregone foregone JJ 37231 3572 109 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3572 110 , , , 37231 3572 111 when when WRB 37231 3572 112 the the DT 37231 3572 113 recognition recognition NN 37231 3572 114 of of IN 37231 3572 115 a a DT 37231 3572 116 difference difference NN 37231 3572 117 of of IN 37231 3572 118 source source NN 37231 3572 119 , , , 37231 3572 120 indicated indicate VBN 37231 3572 121 in in IN 37231 3572 122 every every DT 37231 3572 123 direction direction NN 37231 3572 124 , , , 37231 3572 125 is be VBZ 37231 3572 126 so so RB 37231 3572 127 much much RB 37231 3572 128 more more RBR 37231 3572 129 simple simple JJ 37231 3572 130 , , , 37231 3572 131 natural natural JJ 37231 3572 132 , , , 37231 3572 133 and and CC 37231 3572 134 justifiable justifiable JJ 37231 3572 135 . . . 37231 3573 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3573 2 is be VBZ 37231 3573 3 argued argue VBN 37231 3573 4 that that IN 37231 3573 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3573 6 's 's POS 37231 3573 7 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3573 8 from from IN 37231 3573 9 the the DT 37231 3573 10 Old Old NNP 37231 3573 11 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3573 12 likewise likewise RB 37231 3573 13 present present VBP 37231 3573 14 constant constant JJ 37231 3573 15 variation variation NN 37231 3573 16 from from IN 37231 3573 17 the the DT 37231 3573 18 text text NN 37231 3573 19 . . . 37231 3574 1 This this DT 37231 3574 2 is be VBZ 37231 3574 3 true true JJ 37231 3574 4 to to IN 37231 3574 5 a a DT 37231 3574 6 considerable considerable JJ 37231 3574 7 extent extent NN 37231 3574 8 , , , 37231 3574 9 but but CC 37231 3574 10 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3574 11 are be VBP 37231 3574 12 not not RB 37231 3574 13 so so RB 37231 3574 14 persistently persistently RB 37231 3574 15 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 37231 3574 16 as as IN 37231 3574 17 the the DT 37231 3574 18 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3574 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3574 20 are be VBP 37231 3574 21 examining examine VBG 37231 3574 22 , , , 37231 3574 23 supposing suppose VBG 37231 3574 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3574 25 to to TO 37231 3574 26 be be VB 37231 3574 27 derived derive VBN 37231 3574 28 from from IN 37231 3574 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3574 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3574 31 . . . 37231 3575 1 This this DT 37231 3575 2 pica pica NN 37231 3575 3 , , , 37231 3575 4 however however RB 37231 3575 5 , , , 37231 3575 6 is be VBZ 37231 3575 7 of of IN 37231 3575 8 no no DT 37231 3575 9 avail avail NN 37231 3575 10 , , , 37231 3575 11 for for IN 37231 3575 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3575 13 is be VBZ 37231 3575 14 obvious obvious JJ 37231 3575 15 that that IN 37231 3575 16 the the DT 37231 3575 17 employment employment NN 37231 3575 18 of of IN 37231 3575 19 the the DT 37231 3575 20 Old Old NNP 37231 3575 21 Testament Testament NNP 37231 3575 22 is be VBZ 37231 3575 23 not not RB 37231 3575 24 established establish VBN 37231 3575 25 merely merely RB 37231 3575 26 by by IN 37231 3575 27 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 37231 3575 28 citations citation NNS 37231 3575 29 ; ; , 37231 3575 30 and and CC 37231 3575 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3575 32 is be VBZ 37231 3575 33 quite quite RB 37231 3575 34 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 3575 35 that that IN 37231 3575 36 the the DT 37231 3575 37 use use NN 37231 3575 38 of of IN 37231 3575 39 certain certain JJ 37231 3575 40 historical historical JJ 37231 3575 41 documents document NNS 37231 3575 42 out out IN 37231 3575 43 of of IN 37231 3575 44 many many JJ 37231 3575 45 of of IN 37231 3575 46 closely closely RB 37231 3575 47 similar similar JJ 37231 3575 48 , , , 37231 3575 49 and and CC 37231 3575 50 in in IN 37231 3575 51 many many JJ 37231 3575 52 parts part NNS 37231 3575 53 probably probably RB 37231 3575 54 identical identical JJ 37231 3575 55 , , , 37231 3575 56 character character NN 37231 3575 57 can can MD 37231 3575 58 not not RB 37231 3575 59 be be VB 37231 3575 60 proved prove VBN 37231 3575 61 by by IN 37231 3575 62 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 3575 63 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3575 64 differing differ VBG 37231 3575 65 from from IN 37231 3575 66 anything anything NN 37231 3575 67 actually actually RB 37231 3575 68 in in IN 37231 3575 69 these these DT 37231 3575 70 documents document NNS 37231 3575 71 . . . 37231 3576 1 There there EX 37231 3576 2 are be VBP 37231 3576 3 very very RB 37231 3576 4 many many JJ 37231 3576 5 of of IN 37231 3576 6 the the DT 37231 3576 7 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3576 8 of of IN 37231 3576 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3576 10 which which WDT 37231 3576 11 bear bear VBP 37231 3576 12 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 37231 3576 13 marks mark NNS 37231 3576 14 of of IN 37231 3576 15 exactness exactness NN 37231 3576 16 and and CC 37231 3576 17 verbal verbal JJ 37231 3576 18 { { -LRB- 37231 3576 19 369 369 CD 37231 3576 20 } } -RRB- 37231 3576 21 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3576 22 , , , 37231 3576 23 but but CC 37231 3576 24 which which WDT 37231 3576 25 yet yet RB 37231 3576 26 differ differ VBP 37231 3576 27 materially materially RB 37231 3576 28 from from IN 37231 3576 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3576 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3576 31 , , , 37231 3576 32 and and CC 37231 3576 33 most most JJS 37231 3576 34 of of IN 37231 3576 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3576 36 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3576 37 from from IN 37231 3576 38 the the DT 37231 3576 39 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3576 40 on on IN 37231 3576 41 the the DT 37231 3576 42 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3576 43 are be VBP 37231 3576 44 of of IN 37231 3576 45 this this DT 37231 3576 46 kind kind NN 37231 3576 47 . . . 37231 3577 1 For for IN 37231 3577 2 instance instance NN 37231 3577 3 , , , 37231 3577 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3577 5 introduces introduce VBZ 37231 3577 6 the the DT 37231 3577 7 passages passage NNS 37231 3577 8 which which WDT 37231 3577 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3577 10 have have VBP 37231 3577 11 marked mark VBN 37231 3577 12 a a DT 37231 3577 13 , , , 37231 3577 14 b b NN 37231 3577 15 , , , 37231 3577 16 c c NNP 37231 3577 17 , , , 37231 3577 18 with with IN 37231 3577 19 the the DT 37231 3577 20 words word NNS 37231 3577 21 : : : 37231 3577 22 " " `` 37231 3577 23 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3577 24 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3577 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3577 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3577 27 spoke speak VBD 37231 3577 28 thus thus RB 37231 3577 29 of of IN 37231 3577 30 Chastity,"(l Chastity,"(l NNP 37231 3577 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3577 32 and and CC 37231 3577 33 after after IN 37231 3577 34 giving give VBG 37231 3577 35 the the DT 37231 3577 36 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3577 37 , , , 37231 3577 38 a a NN 37231 3577 39 , , , 37231 3577 40 b b NN 37231 3577 41 , , , 37231 3577 42 and and CC 37231 3577 43 c c NNP 37231 3577 44 , , , 37231 3577 45 the the DT 37231 3577 46 first first JJ 37231 3577 47 two two CD 37231 3577 48 of of IN 37231 3577 49 which which WDT 37231 3577 50 , , , 37231 3577 51 although although IN 37231 3577 52 finding find VBG 37231 3577 53 a a DT 37231 3577 54 parallel parallel NN 37231 3577 55 in in IN 37231 3577 56 two two CD 37231 3577 57 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3577 58 verses verse NNS 37231 3577 59 , , , 37231 3577 60 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3577 61 v. v. CC 37231 3577 62 28 28 CD 37231 3577 63 , , , 37231 3577 64 29 29 CD 37231 3577 65 , , , 37231 3577 66 are be VBP 37231 3577 67 divided divide VBN 37231 3577 68 by by IN 37231 3577 69 the the DT 37231 3577 70 separating separating NN 37231 3577 71 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3577 72 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3577 73 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3577 74 , , , 37231 3577 75 and and CC 37231 3577 76 therefore therefore RB 37231 3577 77 do do VBP 37231 3577 78 not not RB 37231 3577 79 appear appear VB 37231 3577 80 to to TO 37231 3577 81 have have VB 37231 3577 82 been be VBN 37231 3577 83 united unite VBN 37231 3577 84 in in IN 37231 3577 85 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3577 86 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3577 87 , , , 37231 3577 88 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3577 89 continues continue VBZ 37231 3577 90 : : : 37231 3577 91 " " `` 37231 3577 92 Just just RB 37231 3577 93 as as IN 37231 3577 94 even even RB 37231 3577 95 those those DT 37231 3577 96 who who WP 37231 3577 97 with with IN 37231 3577 98 the the DT 37231 3577 99 sanction sanction NN 37231 3577 100 of of IN 37231 3577 101 human human JJ 37231 3577 102 law law NN 37231 3577 103 contract contract NN 37231 3577 104 a a DT 37231 3577 105 second second JJ 37231 3577 106 marriage marriage NN 37231 3577 107 are be VBP 37231 3577 108 sinners sinner NNS 37231 3577 109 in in IN 37231 3577 110 the the DT 37231 3577 111 eye eye NN 37231 3577 112 of of IN 37231 3577 113 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3577 114 Master Master NNP 37231 3577 115 , , , 37231 3577 116 so so RB 37231 3577 117 also also RB 37231 3577 118 are be VBP 37231 3577 119 those those DT 37231 3577 120 who who WP 37231 3577 121 look look VBP 37231 3577 122 upon upon IN 37231 3577 123 a a DT 37231 3577 124 woman woman NN 37231 3577 125 to to TO 37231 3577 126 lust lust VB 37231 3577 127 after after IN 37231 3577 128 her -PRON- PRP 37231 3577 129 . . . 37231 3578 1 For for IN 37231 3578 2 not not RB 37231 3578 3 only only RB 37231 3578 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3578 5 who who WP 37231 3578 6 actually actually RB 37231 3578 7 commits commit VBZ 37231 3578 8 adultery adultery NN 37231 3578 9 is be VBZ 37231 3578 10 rejected reject VBN 37231 3578 11 by by IN 37231 3578 12 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3578 13 , , , 37231 3578 14 but but CC 37231 3578 15 also also RB 37231 3578 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3578 17 who who WP 37231 3578 18 desires desire VBZ 37231 3578 19 to to TO 37231 3578 20 commit commit VB 37231 3578 21 adultery adultery NN 37231 3578 22 , , , 37231 3578 23 since since IN 37231 3578 24 not not RB 37231 3578 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3578 26 acts act NNS 37231 3578 27 alone alone RB 37231 3578 28 are be VBP 37231 3578 29 open open JJ 37231 3578 30 before before IN 37231 3578 31 God God NNP 37231 3578 32 , , , 37231 3578 33 but but CC 37231 3578 34 also also RB 37231 3578 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3578 36 thoughts thought NNS 37231 3578 37 . . . 37231 3579 1 " " `` 37231 3579 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3579 3 2 2 LS 37231 3579 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3579 5 Now now RB 37231 3579 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3579 7 is be VBZ 37231 3579 8 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 3579 9 clear clear JJ 37231 3579 10 that that IN 37231 3579 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3579 12 here here RB 37231 3579 13 professes profess VBZ 37231 3579 14 to to TO 37231 3579 15 give give VB 37231 3579 16 the the DT 37231 3579 17 actual actual JJ 37231 3579 18 words word NNS 37231 3579 19 of of IN 37231 3579 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3579 21 , , , 37231 3579 22 and and CC 37231 3579 23 then then RB 37231 3579 24 moralizes moralize VBZ 37231 3579 25 upon upon IN 37231 3579 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3579 27 ; ; : 37231 3579 28 and and CC 37231 3579 29 both both CC 37231 3579 30 the the DT 37231 3579 31 quotation quotation NN 37231 3579 32 and and CC 37231 3579 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3579 34 own own JJ 37231 3579 35 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 3579 36 paraphrase paraphrase NN 37231 3579 37 of of IN 37231 3579 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3579 39 lose lose VBP 37231 3579 40 all all DT 37231 3579 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3579 42 significance significance NN 37231 3579 43 , , , 37231 3579 44 if if IN 37231 3579 45 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3579 46 suppose suppose VBP 37231 3579 47 that that IN 37231 3579 48 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3579 49 did do VBD 37231 3579 50 not not RB 37231 3579 51 correctly correctly RB 37231 3579 52 quote quote VB 37231 3579 53 in in IN 37231 3579 54 the the DT 37231 3579 55 first first JJ 37231 3579 56 instance instance NN 37231 3579 57 , , , 37231 3579 58 but but CC 37231 3579 59 actually actually RB 37231 3579 60 commences commence VBZ 37231 3579 61 by by IN 37231 3579 62 altering alter VBG 37231 3579 63 the the DT 37231 3579 64 text text NN 37231 3579 65 . . . 37231 3580 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3580 2 3 3 LS 37231 3580 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3580 4 These these DT 37231 3580 5 passages passage NNS 37231 3580 6 a a DT 37231 3580 7 , , , 37231 3580 8 b b NN 37231 3580 9 , , , 37231 3580 10 and and CC 37231 3580 11 c c NNP 37231 3580 12 , , , 37231 3580 13 however however RB 37231 3580 14 , , , 37231 3580 15 have have VBP 37231 3580 16 all all DT 37231 3580 17 marked mark VBN 37231 3580 18 and and CC 37231 3580 19 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 3580 20 variations variation NNS 37231 3580 21 from from IN 37231 3580 22 the the DT 37231 3580 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3580 24 text text NN 37231 3580 25 , , , 37231 3580 26 but but CC 37231 3580 27 as as IN 37231 3580 28 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3580 29 have have VBP 37231 3580 30 already already RB 37231 3580 31 shown show VBN 37231 3580 32 , , , 37231 3580 33 there there EX 37231 3580 34 is be VBZ 37231 3580 35 no no DT 37231 3580 36 reason reason NN 37231 3580 37 for for IN 37231 3580 38 asserting assert VBG 37231 3580 39 that that IN 37231 3580 40 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3580 41 are be VBP 37231 3580 42 not not RB 37231 3580 43 accurate accurate JJ 37231 3580 44 verbal verbal JJ 37231 3580 45 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3580 46 from from IN 37231 3580 47 another another DT 37231 3580 48 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3580 49 . . . 37231 3581 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3581 2 370 370 CD 37231 3581 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3581 4 The the DT 37231 3581 5 passage passage NN 37231 3581 6 8 8 CD 37231 3581 7 is be VBZ 37231 3581 8 likewise likewise RB 37231 3581 9 a a DT 37231 3581 10 professed professed JJ 37231 3581 11 quotation,(1 quotation,(1 NNP 37231 3581 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3581 13 but but CC 37231 3581 14 not not RB 37231 3581 15 only only RB 37231 3581 16 does do VBZ 37231 3581 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3581 18 differ differ VB 37231 3581 19 in in IN 37231 3581 20 language language NN 37231 3581 21 , , , 37231 3581 22 but but CC 37231 3581 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3581 24 presents present VBZ 37231 3581 25 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 3581 26 transpositions transposition NNS 37231 3581 27 in in IN 37231 3581 28 order order NN 37231 3581 29 which which WDT 37231 3581 30 clearly clearly RB 37231 3581 31 indicate indicate VBP 37231 3581 32 that that IN 37231 3581 33 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3581 34 's 's POS 37231 3581 35 source source NN 37231 3581 36 was be VBD 37231 3581 37 not not RB 37231 3581 38 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3581 39 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3581 40 . . . 37231 3582 1 The the DT 37231 3582 2 nearest near JJS 37231 3582 3 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3582 4 in in IN 37231 3582 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3582 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3582 7 are be VBP 37231 3582 8 found find VBN 37231 3582 9 in in IN 37231 3582 10 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3582 11 v. v. CC 37231 3582 12 46 46 CD 37231 3582 13 , , , 37231 3582 14 followed follow VBN 37231 3582 15 by by IN 37231 3582 16 44 44 CD 37231 3582 17 . . . 37231 3583 1 The the DT 37231 3583 2 same same JJ 37231 3583 3 remarks remark NNS 37231 3583 4 apply apply VBP 37231 3583 5 to to IN 37231 3583 6 the the DT 37231 3583 7 next next JJ 37231 3583 8 passage passage NN 37231 3583 9 � � NNP 37231 3583 10 , , , 37231 3583 11 which which WDT 37231 3583 12 is be VBZ 37231 3583 13 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3583 14 as as IN 37231 3583 15 a a DT 37231 3583 16 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3583 17 quotation,(2 quotation,(2 NNP 37231 3583 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3583 19 but but CC 37231 3583 20 which which WDT 37231 3583 21 , , , 37231 3583 22 like like IN 37231 3583 23 the the DT 37231 3583 24 rest rest NN 37231 3583 25 , , , 37231 3583 26 differs differ VBZ 37231 3583 27 materially materially RB 37231 3583 28 , , , 37231 3583 29 linguistically linguistically RB 37231 3583 30 and and CC 37231 3583 31 in in IN 37231 3583 32 order order NN 37231 3583 33 , , , 37231 3583 34 from from IN 37231 3583 35 the the DT 37231 3583 36 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3583 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3583 38 . . . 37231 3584 1 The the DT 37231 3584 2 whole whole NN 37231 3584 3 of of IN 37231 3584 4 the the DT 37231 3584 5 passage passage NN 37231 3584 6 is be VBZ 37231 3584 7 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3584 8 , , , 37231 3584 9 and and CC 37231 3584 10 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3584 11 the the DT 37231 3584 12 explanation explanation NN 37231 3584 13 of of IN 37231 3584 14 a a DT 37231 3584 15 mere mere JJ 37231 3584 16 patchwork patchwork NN 37231 3584 17 of of IN 37231 3584 18 passages passage NNS 37231 3584 19 loosely loosely RB 37231 3584 20 put put VBP 37231 3584 21 together together RB 37231 3584 22 , , , 37231 3584 23 and and CC 37231 3584 24 very very RB 37231 3584 25 imperfectly imperfectly RB 37231 3584 26 quoted quote VBN 37231 3584 27 from from IN 37231 3584 28 memory memory NN 37231 3584 29 . . . 37231 3585 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3585 2 states state VBZ 37231 3585 3 that that IN 37231 3585 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3585 5 taught teach VBD 37231 3585 6 that that IN 37231 3585 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3585 8 should should MD 37231 3585 9 communicate communicate VB 37231 3585 10 to to IN 37231 3585 11 those those DT 37231 3585 12 who who WP 37231 3585 13 need need VBP 37231 3585 14 , , , 37231 3585 15 and and CC 37231 3585 16 do do VB 37231 3585 17 nothing nothing NN 37231 3585 18 for for IN 37231 3585 19 vain vain JJ 37231 3585 20 glory glory NN 37231 3585 21 , , , 37231 3585 22 and and CC 37231 3585 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3585 24 then then RB 37231 3585 25 gives give VBZ 37231 3585 26 the the DT 37231 3585 27 very very JJ 37231 3585 28 words word NNS 37231 3585 29 of of IN 37231 3585 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3585 31 in in IN 37231 3585 32 an an DT 37231 3585 33 unbroken unbroken JJ 37231 3585 34 and and CC 37231 3585 35 clearly clearly RB 37231 3585 36 continuous continuous JJ 37231 3585 37 discourse discourse NN 37231 3585 38 . . . 37231 3586 1 Christians christian NNS 37231 3586 2 are be VBP 37231 3586 3 to to TO 37231 3586 4 give give VB 37231 3586 5 to to IN 37231 3586 6 all all DT 37231 3586 7 who who WP 37231 3586 8 ask ask VBP 37231 3586 9 , , , 37231 3586 10 and and CC 37231 3586 11 not not RB 37231 3586 12 merely merely RB 37231 3586 13 to to IN 37231 3586 14 those those DT 37231 3586 15 from from IN 37231 3586 16 whom whom WP 37231 3586 17 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3586 18 hope hope VBP 37231 3586 19 to to TO 37231 3586 20 receive receive VB 37231 3586 21 again again RB 37231 3586 22 , , , 37231 3586 23 which which WDT 37231 3586 24 would would MD 37231 3586 25 be be VB 37231 3586 26 no no DT 37231 3586 27 new new JJ 37231 3586 28 thing thing NN 37231 3586 29 -- -- : 37231 3586 30 even even RB 37231 3586 31 the the DT 37231 3586 32 publicans publican NNS 37231 3586 33 do do VBP 37231 3586 34 that that DT 37231 3586 35 ; ; : 37231 3586 36 but but CC 37231 3586 37 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3586 38 must must MD 37231 3586 39 do do VB 37231 3586 40 more more JJR 37231 3586 41 . . . 37231 3587 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 3587 2 are be VBP 37231 3587 3 not not RB 37231 3587 4 to to TO 37231 3587 5 lay lay VB 37231 3587 6 up up RP 37231 3587 7 riches rich NNS 37231 3587 8 on on IN 37231 3587 9 earth earth NN 37231 3587 10 , , , 37231 3587 11 but but CC 37231 3587 12 in in IN 37231 3587 13 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3587 14 , , , 37231 3587 15 for for IN 37231 3587 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3587 17 would would MD 37231 3587 18 not not RB 37231 3587 19 profit profit VB 37231 3587 20 a a DT 37231 3587 21 man man NN 37231 3587 22 to to TO 37231 3587 23 gain gain VB 37231 3587 24 the the DT 37231 3587 25 whole whole JJ 37231 3587 26 world world NN 37231 3587 27 , , , 37231 3587 28 and and CC 37231 3587 29 lose lose VB 37231 3587 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3587 31 soul soul NN 37231 3587 32 ; ; : 37231 3587 33 therefore therefore RB 37231 3587 34 , , , 37231 3587 35 the the DT 37231 3587 36 Teacher teacher NN 37231 3587 37 a a DT 37231 3587 38 second second JJ 37231 3587 39 time time NN 37231 3587 40 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 3587 41 the the DT 37231 3587 42 injunction injunction NN 37231 3587 43 that that IN 37231 3587 44 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3587 45 should should MD 37231 3587 46 lay lay VB 37231 3587 47 up up RP 37231 3587 48 treasures treasure NNS 37231 3587 49 in in IN 37231 3587 50 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3587 51 . . . 37231 3588 1 If if IN 37231 3588 2 the the DT 37231 3588 3 unity unity NN 37231 3588 4 of of IN 37231 3588 5 thought thought NN 37231 3588 6 which which WDT 37231 3588 7 binds bind VBZ 37231 3588 8 this this DT 37231 3588 9 passage passage NN 37231 3588 10 so so RB 37231 3588 11 closely closely RB 37231 3588 12 together together RB 37231 3588 13 were be VBD 37231 3588 14 not not RB 37231 3588 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 3588 16 to to TO 37231 3588 17 prove prove VB 37231 3588 18 that that IN 37231 3588 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3588 20 stood stand VBD 37231 3588 21 in in IN 37231 3588 22 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3588 23 's 's POS 37231 3588 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3588 25 in in IN 37231 3588 26 the the DT 37231 3588 27 form form NN 37231 3588 28 and and CC 37231 3588 29 order order NN 37231 3588 30 in in IN 37231 3588 31 which which WDT 37231 3588 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3588 33 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3588 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3588 35 , , , 37231 3588 36 the the DT 37231 3588 37 requisite requisite JJ 37231 3588 38 evidence evidence NN 37231 3588 39 would would MD 37231 3588 40 be be VB 37231 3588 41 supplied supply VBN 37231 3588 42 by by IN 37231 3588 43 the the DT 37231 3588 44 repetition repetition NN 37231 3588 45 at at IN 37231 3588 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3588 47 close close NN 37231 3588 48 of of IN 37231 3588 49 the the DT 37231 3588 50 injunction injunction NN 37231 3588 51 : : : 37231 3588 52 " " `` 37231 3588 53 Lay lay VB 37231 3588 54 up up RP 37231 3588 55 , , , 37231 3588 56 therefore therefore RB 37231 3588 57 , , , 37231 3588 58 in in IN 37231 3588 59 the the DT 37231 3588 60 heavens heavens NNPS 37231 3588 61 , , , 37231 3588 62 " " '' 37231 3588 63 & & CC 37231 3588 64 c. c. NNP 37231 3588 65 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3588 66 is be VBZ 37231 3588 67 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3588 68 that that IN 37231 3588 69 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3588 70 should should MD 37231 3588 71 , , , 37231 3588 72 through through IN 37231 3588 73 defect defect NN 37231 3588 74 of of IN 37231 3588 75 memory memory NN 37231 3588 76 , , , 37231 3588 77 quote quote VB 37231 3588 78 a a DT 37231 3588 79 second second JJ 37231 3588 80 time time NN 37231 3588 81 in in IN 37231 3588 82 so so RB 37231 3588 83 short short JJ 37231 3588 84 a a DT 37231 3588 85 passage passage NN 37231 3588 86 the the DT 37231 3588 87 same same JJ 37231 3588 88 injunction injunction NN 37231 3588 89 , , , 37231 3588 90 if if IN 37231 3588 91 the the DT 37231 3588 92 passage passage NN 37231 3588 93 were be VBD 37231 3588 94 not not RB 37231 3588 95 thus thus RB 37231 3588 96 appropriately appropriately RB 37231 3588 97 terminated terminate VBN 37231 3588 98 in in IN 37231 3588 99 { { -LRB- 37231 3588 100 371 371 CD 37231 3588 101 } } -RRB- 37231 3588 102 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3588 103 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3588 104 . . . 37231 3589 1 The the DT 37231 3589 2 common common JJ 37231 3589 3 sense sense NN 37231 3589 4 of of IN 37231 3589 5 the the DT 37231 3589 6 reader reader NN 37231 3589 7 must must MD 37231 3589 8 at at IN 37231 3589 9 once once RB 37231 3589 10 perceive perceive JJ 37231 3589 11 that that IN 37231 3589 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3589 13 is be VBZ 37231 3589 14 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3589 15 that that IN 37231 3589 16 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3589 17 , , , 37231 3589 18 professedly professedly RB 37231 3589 19 quoting quote VBG 37231 3589 20 words word NNS 37231 3589 21 of of IN 37231 3589 22 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3589 23 , , , 37231 3589 24 should should MD 37231 3589 25 thus thus RB 37231 3589 26 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 3589 27 fabricate fabricate VB 37231 3589 28 a a DT 37231 3589 29 discourse discourse NN 37231 3589 30 rounded round VBN 37231 3589 31 off off RP 37231 3589 32 by by IN 37231 3589 33 the the DT 37231 3589 34 repetition repetition NN 37231 3589 35 of of IN 37231 3589 36 one one CD 37231 3589 37 of of IN 37231 3589 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3589 39 opening opening NN 37231 3589 40 admonitions admonition NNS 37231 3589 41 , , , 37231 3589 42 with with IN 37231 3589 43 the the DT 37231 3589 44 addition addition NN 37231 3589 45 of of IN 37231 3589 46 an an DT 37231 3589 47 argumentative argumentative NN 37231 3589 48 " " `` 37231 3589 49 therefore therefore RB 37231 3589 50 . . . 37231 3589 51 " " '' 37231 3590 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3590 2 must must MD 37231 3590 3 have have VB 37231 3590 4 found find VBN 37231 3590 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3590 6 so so RB 37231 3590 7 in in IN 37231 3590 8 the the DT 37231 3590 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3590 10 from from IN 37231 3590 11 which which WDT 37231 3590 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3590 13 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3590 14 . . . 37231 3591 1 Nothing nothing NN 37231 3591 2 indeed indeed RB 37231 3591 3 but but CC 37231 3591 4 the the DT 37231 3591 5 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 3591 6 of of IN 37231 3591 7 explaining explain VBG 37231 3591 8 the the DT 37231 3591 9 marked marked JJ 37231 3591 10 variations variation NNS 37231 3591 11 presented present VBN 37231 3591 12 by by IN 37231 3591 13 this this DT 37231 3591 14 passage passage NN 37231 3591 15 , , , 37231 3591 16 on on IN 37231 3591 17 the the DT 37231 3591 18 supposition supposition NN 37231 3591 19 that that IN 37231 3591 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3591 21 must must MD 37231 3591 22 quote quote VB 37231 3591 23 from from IN 37231 3591 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3591 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3591 26 , , , 37231 3591 27 could could MD 37231 3591 28 lead lead VB 37231 3591 29 apologists apologist NNS 37231 3591 30 to to TO 37231 3591 31 insinuate insinuate VB 37231 3591 32 such such PDT 37231 3591 33 a a DT 37231 3591 34 process process NN 37231 3591 35 of of IN 37231 3591 36 compilation compilation NN 37231 3591 37 , , , 37231 3591 38 or or CC 37231 3591 39 question question VB 37231 3591 40 the the DT 37231 3591 41 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3591 42 character character NN 37231 3591 43 of of IN 37231 3591 44 this this DT 37231 3591 45 passage passage NN 37231 3591 46 . . . 37231 3592 1 The the DT 37231 3592 2 nearest near JJS 37231 3592 3 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3592 4 to to IN 37231 3592 5 the the DT 37231 3592 6 dismembered dismember VBN 37231 3592 7 parts part NNS 37231 3592 8 of of IN 37231 3592 9 this this DT 37231 3592 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 3592 11 , , , 37231 3592 12 presenting present VBG 37231 3592 13 everywhere everywhere RB 37231 3592 14 serious serious JJ 37231 3592 15 variations variation NNS 37231 3592 16 , , , 37231 3592 17 however however RB 37231 3592 18 , , , 37231 3592 19 can can MD 37231 3592 20 only only RB 37231 3592 21 be be VB 37231 3592 22 found find VBN 37231 3592 23 in in IN 37231 3592 24 the the DT 37231 3592 25 following follow VBG 37231 3592 26 passages passage NNS 37231 3592 27 in in IN 37231 3592 28 the the DT 37231 3592 29 order order NN 37231 3592 30 in in IN 37231 3592 31 which which WDT 37231 3592 32 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3592 33 cite cite VBP 37231 3592 34 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3592 35 , , , 37231 3592 36 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3592 37 v. v. IN 37231 3592 38 42 42 CD 37231 3592 39 , , , 37231 3592 40 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3592 41 vi vi NNP 37231 3592 42 . . . 37231 3593 1 34 34 CD 37231 3593 2 , , , 37231 3593 3 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3593 4 vi vi NNP 37231 3593 5 . . . 37231 3594 1 19 19 CD 37231 3594 2 , , , 37231 3594 3 20 20 CD 37231 3594 4 , , , 37231 3594 5 xvi xvi NNP 37231 3594 6 . . . 37231 3595 1 26 26 CD 37231 3595 2 , , , 37231 3595 3 and and CC 37231 3595 4 a a DT 37231 3595 5 repetition repetition NN 37231 3595 6 of of IN 37231 3595 7 part part NN 37231 3595 8 of of IN 37231 3595 9 vi vi NNP 37231 3595 10 . . . 37231 3596 1 20 20 CD 37231 3596 2 , , , 37231 3596 3 with with IN 37231 3596 4 variations variation NNS 37231 3596 5 . . . 37231 3597 1 Moreover moreover RB 37231 3597 2 , , , 37231 3597 3 the the DT 37231 3597 4 expression expression NN 37231 3597 5 : : : 37231 3597 6 " " `` 37231 3597 7 What what WDT 37231 3597 8 new new JJ 37231 3597 9 thing thing NN 37231 3597 10 do do VBP 37231 3597 11 ye ye NNP 37231 3597 12 ? ? . 37231 3597 13 " " '' 37231 3598 1 is be VBZ 37231 3598 2 quite quite RB 37231 3598 3 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3598 4 to to IN 37231 3598 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3598 6 . . . 37231 3599 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3599 2 have have VBP 37231 3599 3 already already RB 37231 3599 4 met meet VBN 37231 3599 5 with with IN 37231 3599 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3599 7 in in IN 37231 3599 8 the the DT 37231 3599 9 preceding precede VBG 37231 3599 10 section section NN 37231 3599 11 8 8 CD 37231 3599 12 . . . 37231 3600 1 " " `` 37231 3600 2 If if IN 37231 3600 3 ye ye PRP 37231 3600 4 love love VBP 37231 3600 5 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3600 6 which which WDT 37231 3600 7 love love VBP 37231 3600 8 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3600 9 , , , 37231 3600 10 what what WP 37231 3600 11 _ _ NNP 37231 3600 12 new new JJ 37231 3600 13 _ _ NNP 37231 3600 14 thing thing NN 37231 3600 15 do do VBP 37231 3600 16 ye ye NNP 37231 3600 17 ? ? . 37231 3601 1 for for IN 37231 3601 2 even even RB 37231 3601 3 , , , 37231 3601 4 " " '' 37231 3601 5 & & CC 37231 3601 6 c. c. NNP 37231 3601 7 Here here RB 37231 3601 8 , , , 37231 3601 9 in in IN 37231 3601 10 the the DT 37231 3601 11 same same JJ 37231 3601 12 verse verse NN 37231 3601 13 , , , 37231 3601 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3601 15 have have VBP 37231 3601 16 : : : 37231 3601 17 " " `` 37231 3601 18 If if IN 37231 3601 19 ye ye PRP 37231 3601 20 lend lend VBP 37231 3601 21 to to IN 37231 3601 22 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3601 23 from from IN 37231 3601 24 whom whom WP 37231 3601 25 ye ye NNP 37231 3601 26 hope hope VBP 37231 3601 27 to to TO 37231 3601 28 receive receive VB 37231 3601 29 , , , 37231 3601 30 what what WP 37231 3601 31 _ _ NNP 37231 3601 32 new new JJ 37231 3601 33 _ _ NNP 37231 3601 34 thing thing NN 37231 3601 35 do do VBP 37231 3601 36 ye ye NNP 37231 3601 37 ? ? . 37231 3602 1 for for IN 37231 3602 2 even even RB 37231 3602 3 , , , 37231 3602 4 " " '' 37231 3602 5 & & CC 37231 3602 6 c. c. NNP 37231 3602 7 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3602 8 is be VBZ 37231 3602 9 evident evident JJ 37231 3602 10 , , , 37231 3602 11 both both DT 37231 3602 12 from from IN 37231 3602 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3602 14 repetition repetition NN 37231 3602 15 and and CC 37231 3602 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3602 17 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3602 18 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 3602 19 view view NN 37231 3602 20 of of IN 37231 3602 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 3602 22 as as IN 37231 3602 23 a a DT 37231 3602 24 new new JJ 37231 3602 25 teaching teaching NN 37231 3602 26 in in IN 37231 3602 27 contrast contrast NN 37231 3602 28 to to IN 37231 3602 29 the the DT 37231 3602 30 old old JJ 37231 3602 31 , , , 37231 3602 32 that that IN 37231 3602 33 this this DT 37231 3602 34 variation variation NN 37231 3602 35 can can MD 37231 3602 36 not not RB 37231 3602 37 have have VB 37231 3602 38 been be VBN 37231 3602 39 the the DT 37231 3602 40 result result NN 37231 3602 41 of of IN 37231 3602 42 defective defective JJ 37231 3602 43 memory memory NN 37231 3602 44 , , , 37231 3602 45 but but CC 37231 3602 46 must must MD 37231 3602 47 have have VB 37231 3602 48 been be VBN 37231 3602 49 the the DT 37231 3602 50 reading reading NN 37231 3602 51 of of IN 37231 3602 52 the the DT 37231 3602 53 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3602 54 , , , 37231 3602 55 and and CC 37231 3602 56 , , , 37231 3602 57 in in IN 37231 3602 58 all all DT 37231 3602 59 probability probability NN 37231 3602 60 , , , 37231 3602 61 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3602 62 was be VBD 37231 3602 63 the the DT 37231 3602 64 original original JJ 37231 3602 65 form form NN 37231 3602 66 of of IN 37231 3602 67 the the DT 37231 3602 68 teaching teaching NN 37231 3602 69 . . . 37231 3603 1 Such such JJ 37231 3603 2 antithetical antithetical JJ 37231 3603 3 treatment treatment NN 37231 3603 4 is be VBZ 37231 3603 5 clearly clearly RB 37231 3603 6 indicated indicate VBN 37231 3603 7 in in IN 37231 3603 8 many many JJ 37231 3603 9 parts part NNS 37231 3603 10 of of IN 37231 3603 11 the the DT 37231 3603 12 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3603 13 on on IN 37231 3603 14 the the DT 37231 3603 15 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3603 16 : : : 37231 3603 17 for for IN 37231 3603 18 instance instance NN 37231 3603 19 , , , 37231 3603 20 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3603 21 v. v. CC 37231 3603 22 21 21 CD 37231 3603 23 , , , 37231 3603 24 " " `` 37231 3603 25 Ye Ye NNP 37231 3603 26 have have VBP 37231 3603 27 heard hear VBN 37231 3603 28 that that IN 37231 3603 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3603 30 hath hath NNP 37231 3603 31 been be VBN 37231 3603 32 said say VBD 37231 3603 33 _ _ NNP 37231 3603 34 by by IN 37231 3603 35 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3603 36 of of IN 37231 3603 37 old old JJ 37231 3603 38 _ _ NNP 37231 3603 39 .... .... NFP 37231 3603 40 but but CC 37231 3603 41 _ _ NNP 37231 3603 42 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3603 43 _ _ NNP 37231 3603 44 say say VBP 37231 3603 45 unto unto IN 37231 3603 46 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3603 47 , , , 37231 3603 48 ' ' '' 37231 3603 49 & & CC 37231 3603 50 c c NNP 37231 3603 51 , , , 37231 3603 52 cf cf NNP 37231 3603 53 . . . 37231 3604 1 v. v. CC 37231 3604 2 33 33 CD 37231 3604 3 , , , 37231 3604 4 38 38 CD 37231 3604 5 , , , 37231 3604 6 43 43 CD 37231 3604 7 . . . 37231 3605 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3605 2 is be VBZ 37231 3605 3 certain certain JJ 37231 3605 4 that that IN 37231 3605 5 { { -LRB- 37231 3605 6 372 372 CD 37231 3605 7 } } -RRB- 37231 3605 8 the the DT 37231 3605 9 whole whole NN 37231 3605 10 of of IN 37231 3605 11 the the DT 37231 3605 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3605 13 E e NN 37231 3605 14 differs differ VBZ 37231 3605 15 very very RB 37231 3605 16 materially materially RB 37231 3605 17 from from IN 37231 3605 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3605 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3605 20 , , , 37231 3605 21 and and CC 37231 3605 22 there there EX 37231 3605 23 is be VBZ 37231 3605 24 every every DT 37231 3605 25 reason reason NN 37231 3605 26 to to TO 37231 3605 27 believe believe VB 37231 3605 28 that that IN 37231 3605 29 not not RB 37231 3605 30 only only RB 37231 3605 31 was be VBD 37231 3605 32 the the DT 37231 3605 33 passage passage NN 37231 3605 34 not not RB 37231 3605 35 derived derive VBN 37231 3605 36 from from IN 37231 3605 37 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3605 38 , , , 37231 3605 39 but but CC 37231 3605 40 that that IN 37231 3605 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3605 42 was be VBD 37231 3605 43 contained contain VBN 37231 3605 44 in in IN 37231 3605 45 the the DT 37231 3605 46 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3605 47 of of IN 37231 3605 48 the the DT 37231 3605 49 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3605 50 substantially substantially RB 37231 3605 51 in in IN 37231 3605 52 the the DT 37231 3605 53 form form NN 37231 3605 54 and and CC 37231 3605 55 order order NN 37231 3605 56 in in IN 37231 3605 57 which which WDT 37231 3605 58 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3605 59 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3605 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3605 61 . . . 37231 3606 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3606 2 1 1 LS 37231 3606 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3606 4 The the DT 37231 3606 5 next next JJ 37231 3606 6 passage passage NN 37231 3606 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3606 8 f)(2 f)(2 NNP 37231 3606 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3606 10 is be VBZ 37231 3606 11 separated separate VBN 37231 3606 12 from from IN 37231 3606 13 the the DT 37231 3606 14 preceding precede VBG 37231 3606 15 merely merely RB 37231 3606 16 by by IN 37231 3606 17 the the DT 37231 3606 18 usual usual JJ 37231 3606 19 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3606 20 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3606 21 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3606 22 and and CC 37231 3606 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3606 24 moves move VBZ 37231 3606 25 on on RP 37231 3606 26 to to IN 37231 3606 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3606 28 close close NN 37231 3606 29 with with IN 37231 3606 30 the the DT 37231 3606 31 same same JJ 37231 3606 32 continuity continuity NN 37231 3606 33 of of IN 37231 3606 34 thought thought NN 37231 3606 35 and and CC 37231 3606 36 the the DT 37231 3606 37 same same JJ 37231 3606 38 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 37231 3606 39 of of IN 37231 3606 40 construction construction NN 37231 3606 41 which which WDT 37231 3606 42 characterize characterize VBP 37231 3606 43 that that IN 37231 3606 44 which which WDT 37231 3606 45 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3606 46 have have VBP 37231 3606 47 just just RB 37231 3606 48 considered consider VBN 37231 3606 49 . . . 37231 3607 1 Christians christian NNS 37231 3607 2 are be VBP 37231 3607 3 to to TO 37231 3607 4 be be VB 37231 3607 5 kind kind JJ 37231 3607 6 and and CC 37231 3607 7 merciful merciful JJ 37231 3607 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3607 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3607 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3607 11 to to IN 37231 3607 12 all all DT 37231 3607 13 as as IN 37231 3607 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3607 15 Father Father NNP 37231 3607 16 is be VBZ 37231 3607 17 , , , 37231 3607 18 who who WP 37231 3607 19 makes make VBZ 37231 3607 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3607 21 sun sun NN 37231 3607 22 to to TO 37231 3607 23 shine shine VB 37231 3607 24 alike alike RB 37231 3607 25 on on IN 37231 3607 26 the the DT 37231 3607 27 good good JJ 37231 3607 28 and and CC 37231 3607 29 evil evil NN 37231 3607 30 , , , 37231 3607 31 and and CC 37231 3607 32 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3607 33 need nee MD 37231 3607 34 not not RB 37231 3607 35 be be VB 37231 3607 36 anxious anxious JJ 37231 3607 37 about about IN 37231 3607 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3607 39 own own JJ 37231 3607 40 temporal temporal JJ 37231 3607 41 necessities necessity NNS 37231 3607 42 : : : 37231 3607 43 what what WP 37231 3607 44 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3607 45 shall shall MD 37231 3607 46 eat eat VB 37231 3607 47 and and CC 37231 3607 48 what what WP 37231 3607 49 put put VBD 37231 3607 50 on on RP 37231 3607 51 ; ; : 37231 3607 52 are be VBP 37231 3607 53 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3607 54 not not RB 37231 3607 55 better well JJR 37231 3607 56 than than IN 37231 3607 57 the the DT 37231 3607 58 birds bird NNS 37231 3607 59 and and CC 37231 3607 60 beasts beast NNS 37231 3607 61 whom whom WP 37231 3607 62 God God NNP 37231 3607 63 feedeth feedeth VBP 37231 3607 64 ? ? . 37231 3608 1 therefore therefore RB 37231 3608 2 , , , 37231 3608 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3608 4 are be VBP 37231 3608 5 not not RB 37231 3608 6 to to TO 37231 3608 7 be be VB 37231 3608 8 careful careful JJ 37231 3608 9 about about IN 37231 3608 10 what what WP 37231 3608 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3608 12 are be VBP 37231 3608 13 to to TO 37231 3608 14 eat eat VB 37231 3608 15 and and CC 37231 3608 16 what what WP 37231 3608 17 put put VBD 37231 3608 18 on on RP 37231 3608 19 , , , 37231 3608 20 for for IN 37231 3608 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3608 22 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3608 23 Father Father NNP 37231 3608 24 knows know VBZ 37231 3608 25 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3608 26 have have VBP 37231 3608 27 need need NN 37231 3608 28 of of IN 37231 3608 29 these these DT 37231 3608 30 things thing NNS 37231 3608 31 ; ; : 37231 3608 32 but but CC 37231 3608 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3608 34 are be VBP 37231 3608 35 to to TO 37231 3608 36 seek seek VB 37231 3608 37 the the DT 37231 3608 38 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 3608 39 of of IN 37231 3608 40 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3608 41 , , , 37231 3608 42 and and CC 37231 3608 43 all all PDT 37231 3608 44 these these DT 37231 3608 45 things thing NNS 37231 3608 46 shall shall MD 37231 3608 47 be be VB 37231 3608 48 added add VBN 37231 3608 49 : : : 37231 3608 50 for for IN 37231 3608 51 where where WRB 37231 3608 52 the the DT 37231 3608 53 treasure treasure NN 37231 3608 54 is be VBZ 37231 3608 55 -- -- : 37231 3608 56 the the DT 37231 3608 57 thing thing NN 37231 3608 58 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3608 59 seeks seek VBZ 37231 3608 60 and and CC 37231 3608 61 is be VBZ 37231 3608 62 careful careful JJ 37231 3608 63 about about IN 37231 3608 64 -- -- : 37231 3608 65 there there EX 37231 3608 66 will will MD 37231 3608 67 also also RB 37231 3608 68 be be VB 37231 3608 69 the the DT 37231 3608 70 mind mind NN 37231 3608 71 of of IN 37231 3608 72 the the DT 37231 3608 73 man man NN 37231 3608 74 . . . 37231 3609 1 In in IN 37231 3609 2 fact fact NN 37231 3609 3 , , , 37231 3609 4 the the DT 37231 3609 5 passage passage NN 37231 3609 6 is be VBZ 37231 3609 7 a a DT 37231 3609 8 suitable suitable JJ 37231 3609 9 continuation continuation NN 37231 3609 10 of of IN 37231 3609 11 c c NNP 37231 3609 12 , , , 37231 3609 13 inculcating inculcating NN 37231 3609 14 , , , 37231 3609 15 like like IN 37231 3609 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3609 17 , , , 37231 3609 18 abstraction abstraction NN 37231 3609 19 from from IN 37231 3609 20 worldly worldly JJ 37231 3609 21 cares care NNS 37231 3609 22 and and CC 37231 3609 23 thoughts thought NNS 37231 3609 24 in in IN 37231 3609 25 reliance reliance NN 37231 3609 26 on on IN 37231 3609 27 the the DT 37231 3609 28 heavenly heavenly JJ 37231 3609 29 Father Father NNP 37231 3609 30 , , , 37231 3609 31 and and CC 37231 3609 32 the the DT 37231 3609 33 mere mere JJ 37231 3609 34 fact fact NN 37231 3609 35 that that IN 37231 3609 36 a a DT 37231 3609 37 separation separation NN 37231 3609 38 is be VBZ 37231 3609 39 made make VBN 37231 3609 40 where where WRB 37231 3609 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3609 42 is be VBZ 37231 3609 43 between between IN 37231 3609 44 the the DT 37231 3609 45 two two CD 37231 3609 46 passages passage NNS 37231 3609 47 c c NNP 37231 3609 48 and and CC 37231 3609 49 £ £ NN 37231 3609 50 shows show VBZ 37231 3609 51 further further RB 37231 3609 52 that that IN 37231 3609 53 each each DT 37231 3609 54 of of IN 37231 3609 55 those those DT 37231 3609 56 passages passage NNS 37231 3609 57 was be VBD 37231 3609 58 complete complete JJ 37231 3609 59 in in IN 37231 3609 60 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3609 61 . . . 37231 3610 1 There there EX 37231 3610 2 is be VBZ 37231 3610 3 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 3610 4 no no DT 37231 3610 5 reason reason NN 37231 3610 6 for for IN 37231 3610 7 the the DT 37231 3610 8 separating separating NN 37231 3610 9 /cat /cat CD 37231 3610 10 , , , 37231 3610 11 if if IN 37231 3610 12 these these DT 37231 3610 13 passages passage NNS 37231 3610 14 were be VBD 37231 3610 15 a a DT 37231 3610 16 mere mere JJ 37231 3610 17 combination combination NN 37231 3610 18 of of IN 37231 3610 19 scattered scatter VBN 37231 3610 20 verses verse NNS 37231 3610 21 . . . 37231 3611 1 This this DT 37231 3611 2 quotation quotation NN 37231 3611 3 , , , 37231 3611 4 however however RB 37231 3611 5 , , , 37231 3611 6 which which WDT 37231 3611 7 is be VBZ 37231 3611 8 so so RB 37231 3611 9 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3611 10 in in IN 37231 3611 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3611 12 , , , 37231 3611 13 can can MD 37231 3611 14 only only RB 37231 3611 15 find find VB 37231 3611 16 distant distant JJ 37231 3611 17 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3611 18 in in IN 37231 3611 19 passages passage NNS 37231 3611 20 widely widely RB 37231 3611 21 divided divide VBN 37231 3611 22 throughout throughout IN 37231 3611 23 the the DT 37231 3611 24 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3611 25 { { -LRB- 37231 3611 26 373 373 CD 37231 3611 27 } } -RRB- 37231 3611 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3611 29 , , , 37231 3611 30 which which WDT 37231 3611 31 have have VBP 37231 3611 32 to to TO 37231 3611 33 be be VB 37231 3611 34 arranged arrange VBN 37231 3611 35 in in IN 37231 3611 36 the the DT 37231 3611 37 following follow VBG 37231 3611 38 order order NN 37231 3611 39 : : : 37231 3611 40 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3611 41 vi vi NNP 37231 3611 42 . . . 37231 3612 1 36 36 CD 37231 3612 2 , , , 37231 3612 3 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3612 4 . . . 37231 3613 1 v. v. CC 37231 3613 2 45 45 CD 37231 3613 3 , , , 37231 3613 4 vi vi NNP 37231 3613 5 . . . 37231 3614 1 25 25 CD 37231 3614 2 , , , 37231 3614 3 26 26 CD 37231 3614 4 , , , 37231 3614 5 31 31 CD 37231 3614 6 , , , 37231 3614 7 32 32 CD 37231 3614 8 , , , 37231 3614 9 33 33 CD 37231 3614 10 , , , 37231 3614 11 vi vi NNP 37231 3614 12 . . . 37231 3615 1 21 21 CD 37231 3615 2 , , , 37231 3615 3 the the DT 37231 3615 4 whole whole NN 37231 3615 5 of of IN 37231 3615 6 which which WDT 37231 3615 7 present present JJ 37231 3615 8 striking striking JJ 37231 3615 9 differences difference NNS 37231 3615 10 from from IN 37231 3615 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3615 12 's 's POS 37231 3615 13 quotation quotation NN 37231 3615 14 . . . 37231 3616 1 The the DT 37231 3616 2 repetition repetition NN 37231 3616 3 of of IN 37231 3616 4 the the DT 37231 3616 5 injunction injunction NN 37231 3616 6 " " `` 37231 3616 7 be be VB 37231 3616 8 not not RB 37231 3616 9 careful careful JJ 37231 3616 10 " " '' 37231 3616 11 again again RB 37231 3616 12 with with IN 37231 3616 13 the the DT 37231 3616 14 illative illative JJ 37231 3616 15 " " `` 37231 3616 16 therefore therefore RB 37231 3616 17 " " '' 37231 3616 18 is be VBZ 37231 3616 19 quite quite RB 37231 3616 20 in in IN 37231 3616 21 the the DT 37231 3616 22 spirit spirit NN 37231 3616 23 of of IN 37231 3616 24 E. E. NNP 37231 3616 25 This this DT 37231 3616 26 admonition admonition NN 37231 3616 27 : : : 37231 3616 28 " " `` 37231 3616 29 Therefore therefore RB 37231 3616 30 , , , 37231 3616 31 be be VB 37231 3616 32 not not RB 37231 3616 33 careful careful JJ 37231 3616 34 , , , 37231 3616 35 " " '' 37231 3616 36 & & CC 37231 3616 37 c c NNP 37231 3616 38 , , , 37231 3616 39 is be VBZ 37231 3616 40 reiterated reiterate VBN 37231 3616 41 no no DT 37231 3616 42 less less JJR 37231 3616 43 than than IN 37231 3616 44 three three CD 37231 3616 45 times time NNS 37231 3616 46 in in IN 37231 3616 47 the the DT 37231 3616 48 first first JJ 37231 3616 49 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3616 50 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3616 51 vi vi NNP 37231 3616 52 25 25 CD 37231 3616 53 , , , 37231 3616 54 31 31 CD 37231 3616 55 , , , 37231 3616 56 34 34 CD 37231 3616 57 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3616 58 , , , 37231 3616 59 and and CC 37231 3616 60 confirms confirm VBZ 37231 3616 61 the the DT 37231 3616 62 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 3616 63 repetition repetition NN 37231 3616 64 of of IN 37231 3616 65 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3616 66 's 's POS 37231 3616 67 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3616 68 , , , 37231 3616 69 which which WDT 37231 3616 70 seems seem VBZ 37231 3616 71 to to TO 37231 3616 72 have have VB 37231 3616 73 held hold VBN 37231 3616 74 a a DT 37231 3616 75 middle middle JJ 37231 3616 76 course course NN 37231 3616 77 between between IN 37231 3616 78 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3616 79 and and CC 37231 3616 80 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3616 81 , , , 37231 3616 82 the the DT 37231 3616 83 latter latter JJ 37231 3616 84 of of IN 37231 3616 85 which which WDT 37231 3616 86 does do VBZ 37231 3616 87 not not RB 37231 3616 88 repeat repeat VB 37231 3616 89 the the DT 37231 3616 90 phrase phrase NN 37231 3616 91 , , , 37231 3616 92 although although IN 37231 3616 93 the the DT 37231 3616 94 injunction injunction NN 37231 3616 95 is be VBZ 37231 3616 96 made make VBN 37231 3616 97 a a DT 37231 3616 98 second second JJ 37231 3616 99 time time NN 37231 3616 100 in in IN 37231 3616 101 more more JJR 37231 3616 102 direct direct JJ 37231 3616 103 terms term NNS 37231 3616 104 . . . 37231 3617 1 The the DT 37231 3617 2 repetition repetition NN 37231 3617 3 of of IN 37231 3617 4 the the DT 37231 3617 5 passage passage NN 37231 3617 6 : : : 37231 3617 7 " " `` 37231 3617 8 Be be VB 37231 3617 9 ye ye NNP 37231 3617 10 kind kind JJ 37231 3617 11 and and CC 37231 3617 12 merciful merciful JJ 37231 3617 13 , , , 37231 3617 14 " " '' 37231 3617 15 & & CC 37231 3617 16 c c NNP 37231 3617 17 , , , 37231 3617 18 in in IN 37231 3617 19 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3617 20 . . . 37231 3618 1 96 96 CD 37231 3618 2 , , , 37231 3618 3 with with IN 37231 3618 4 the the DT 37231 3618 5 same same JJ 37231 3618 6 context context NN 37231 3618 7 and and CC 37231 3618 8 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 37231 3618 9 , , , 37231 3618 10 is be VBZ 37231 3618 11 a a DT 37231 3618 12 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3618 13 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 3618 14 of of IN 37231 3618 15 the the DT 37231 3618 16 natural natural JJ 37231 3618 17 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3618 18 that that WDT 37231 3618 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3618 20 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3618 21 the the DT 37231 3618 22 passage passage NN 37231 3618 23 from from IN 37231 3618 24 a a DT 37231 3618 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3618 26 different different JJ 37231 3618 27 from from IN 37231 3618 28 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 3618 29 . . . 37231 3619 1 The the DT 37231 3619 2 expression expression NN 37231 3619 3 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3619 4 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3619 5 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3619 6 thrice thrice NN 37231 3619 7 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3619 8 by by IN 37231 3619 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3619 10 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3619 11 , , , 37231 3619 12 and and CC 37231 3619 13 supported support VBN 37231 3619 14 by by IN 37231 3619 15 a a DT 37231 3619 16 similar similar JJ 37231 3619 17 duplication duplication NN 37231 3619 18 in in IN 37231 3619 19 the the DT 37231 3619 20 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 3619 21 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 3619 22 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3619 23 iii iii CD 37231 3619 24 . . . 37231 3620 1 57)(1 57)(1 LS 37231 3620 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3620 3 can can MD 37231 3620 4 not not RB 37231 3620 5 possibly possibly RB 37231 3620 6 be be VB 37231 3620 7 an an DT 37231 3620 8 accidental accidental JJ 37231 3620 9 departure departure NN 37231 3620 10 from from IN 37231 3620 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3620 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3620 13 . . . 37231 3621 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3621 2 2 2 LS 37231 3621 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3621 4 For for IN 37231 3621 5 the the DT 37231 3621 6 rest rest NN 37231 3621 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3621 8 is be VBZ 37231 3621 9 undeniable undeniable JJ 37231 3621 10 that that IN 37231 3621 11 the the DT 37231 3621 12 whole whole JJ 37231 3621 13 passage passage NN 37231 3621 14 £ £ NNP 37231 3621 15 differs differ VBZ 37231 3621 16 materially materially RB 37231 3621 17 both both CC 37231 3621 18 in in IN 37231 3621 19 order order NN 37231 3621 20 and and CC 37231 3621 21 language language NN 37231 3621 22 from from IN 37231 3621 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3621 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3621 25 , , , 37231 3621 26 from from IN 37231 3621 27 which which WDT 37231 3621 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3621 29 can can MD 37231 3621 30 not not RB 37231 3621 31 without without IN 37231 3621 32 unwarrantable unwarrantable JJ 37231 3621 33 assumption assumption NN 37231 3621 34 be be VB 37231 3621 35 maintained maintain VBN 37231 3621 36 to to TO 37231 3621 37 have have VB 37231 3621 38 been be VBN 37231 3621 39 taken take VBN 37231 3621 40 either either CC 37231 3621 41 collectively collectively RB 37231 3621 42 or or CC 37231 3621 43 in in IN 37231 3621 44 detail detail NN 37231 3621 45 , , , 37231 3621 46 and and CC 37231 3621 47 strong strong JJ 37231 3621 48 internal internal JJ 37231 3621 49 reasons reason NNS 37231 3621 50 lead lead VBP 37231 3621 51 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3621 52 to to TO 37231 3621 53 conclude conclude VB 37231 3621 54 that that IN 37231 3621 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3621 56 is be VBZ 37231 3621 57 quoted quote VBN 37231 3621 58 substantially substantially RB 37231 3621 59 as as IN 37231 3621 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3621 61 stands stand VBZ 37231 3621 62 from from IN 37231 3621 63 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3621 64 's 's POS 37231 3621 65 { { -LRB- 37231 3621 66 374 374 CD 37231 3621 67 } } -RRB- 37231 3621 68 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3621 69 , , , 37231 3621 70 which which WDT 37231 3621 71 must must MD 37231 3621 72 have have VB 37231 3621 73 been be VBN 37231 3621 74 different different JJ 37231 3621 75 from from IN 37231 3621 76 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3621 77 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3621 78 . . . 37231 3622 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3622 2 1 1 LS 37231 3622 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3622 4 In in IN 37231 3622 5 6 6 CD 37231 3622 6 again again RB 37231 3622 7 , , , 37231 3622 8 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3622 9 have have VBP 37231 3622 10 an an DT 37231 3622 11 express express JJ 37231 3622 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3622 13 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3622 14 by by IN 37231 3622 15 the the DT 37231 3622 16 words word NNS 37231 3622 17 : : : 37231 3622 18 " " `` 37231 3622 19 And and CC 37231 3622 20 regarding regard VBG 37231 3622 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3622 22 being be VBG 37231 3622 23 patient patient JJ 37231 3622 24 under under IN 37231 3622 25 injuries injury NNS 37231 3622 26 and and CC 37231 3622 27 ready ready JJ 37231 3622 28 to to TO 37231 3622 29 help help VB 37231 3622 30 all all DT 37231 3622 31 , , , 37231 3622 32 and and CC 37231 3622 33 free free JJ 37231 3622 34 from from IN 37231 3622 35 anger anger NN 37231 3622 36 , , , 37231 3622 37 this this DT 37231 3622 38 is be VBZ 37231 3622 39 what what WP 37231 3622 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3622 41 said say VBD 37231 3622 42 ; ; : 37231 3622 43 " " `` 37231 3622 44 and and CC 37231 3622 45 then then RB 37231 3622 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3622 47 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 3622 48 to to TO 37231 3622 49 give give VB 37231 3622 50 the the DT 37231 3622 51 actual actual JJ 37231 3622 52 words word NNS 37231 3622 53 . . . 37231 3623 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3623 2 2 2 LS 37231 3623 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3623 4 At at IN 37231 3623 5 the the DT 37231 3623 6 close close NN 37231 3623 7 of of IN 37231 3623 8 the the DT 37231 3623 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 3623 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 11 continues continue VBZ 37231 3623 12 : : : 37231 3623 13 " " `` 37231 3623 14 For for IN 37231 3623 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 16 ought ought MD 37231 3623 17 not not RB 37231 3623 18 to to TO 37231 3623 19 strive strive VB 37231 3623 20 , , , 37231 3623 21 neither neither CC 37231 3623 22 would would MD 37231 3623 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 24 have have VB 37231 3623 25 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 26 be be VB 37231 3623 27 imitators imitator NNS 37231 3623 28 of of IN 37231 3623 29 the the DT 37231 3623 30 wicked wicked JJ 37231 3623 31 , , , 37231 3623 32 but but CC 37231 3623 33 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 34 has have VBZ 37231 3623 35 exhorted exhort VBN 37231 3623 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 37 by by IN 37231 3623 38 patience patience NN 37231 3623 39 and and CC 37231 3623 40 gentleness gentleness NN 37231 3623 41 to to TO 37231 3623 42 lead lead VB 37231 3623 43 men man NNS 37231 3623 44 from from IN 37231 3623 45 shame shame NN 37231 3623 46 and and CC 37231 3623 47 the the DT 37231 3623 48 love love NN 37231 3623 49 of of IN 37231 3623 50 evil evil NN 37231 3623 51 , , , 37231 3623 52 " " '' 37231 3623 53 & & CC 37231 3623 54 c. c. NNP 37231 3623 55 , , , 37231 3623 56 & & CC 37231 3623 57 c.(3 c.(3 NNP 37231 3623 58 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3623 59 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 60 is be VBZ 37231 3623 61 evident evident JJ 37231 3623 62 that that IN 37231 3623 63 these these DT 37231 3623 64 observations observation NNS 37231 3623 65 , , , 37231 3623 66 which which WDT 37231 3623 67 are be VBP 37231 3623 68 a a DT 37231 3623 69 mere mere JJ 37231 3623 70 paraphrase paraphrase NN 37231 3623 71 of of IN 37231 3623 72 the the DT 37231 3623 73 text text NN 37231 3623 74 , , , 37231 3623 75 indicate indicate VBP 37231 3623 76 that that IN 37231 3623 77 the the DT 37231 3623 78 quotation quotation NN 37231 3623 79 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3623 80 is be VBZ 37231 3623 81 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 3623 82 and and CC 37231 3623 83 precise precise JJ 37231 3623 84 . . . 37231 3624 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3624 2 professes profess VBZ 37231 3624 3 first first RB 37231 3624 4 to to TO 37231 3624 5 quote quote VB 37231 3624 6 the the DT 37231 3624 7 actual actual JJ 37231 3624 8 teaching teaching NN 37231 3624 9 of of IN 37231 3624 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3624 11 , , , 37231 3624 12 and and CC 37231 3624 13 then then RB 37231 3624 14 makes make VBZ 37231 3624 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3624 16 own own JJ 37231 3624 17 comments comment NNS 37231 3624 18 ; ; : 37231 3624 19 but but CC 37231 3624 20 if if IN 37231 3624 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3624 22 be be VB 37231 3624 23 assumed assume VBN 37231 3624 24 that that IN 37231 3624 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3624 26 began begin VBD 37231 3624 27 by by IN 37231 3624 28 concocting concoct VBG 37231 3624 29 out out IN 37231 3624 30 of of IN 37231 3624 31 stray stray JJ 37231 3624 32 texts text NNS 37231 3624 33 , , , 37231 3624 34 altered alter VBN 37231 3624 35 to to TO 37231 3624 36 suit suit VB 37231 3624 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3624 38 purpose purpose NN 37231 3624 39 , , , 37231 3624 40 a a DT 37231 3624 41 continuous continuous JJ 37231 3624 42 discourse discourse NN 37231 3624 43 , , , 37231 3624 44 the the DT 37231 3624 45 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 3624 46 observations observation NNS 37231 3624 47 seem seem VBP 37231 3624 48 singularly singularly RB 37231 3624 49 useless useless JJ 37231 3624 50 and and CC 37231 3624 51 out out IN 37231 3624 52 of of IN 37231 3624 53 place place NN 37231 3624 54 . . . 37231 3625 1 Although although IN 37231 3625 2 the the DT 37231 3625 3 passage passage NN 37231 3625 4 forms form VBZ 37231 3625 5 a a DT 37231 3625 6 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3625 7 and and CC 37231 3625 8 harmonious harmonious JJ 37231 3625 9 discourse discourse NN 37231 3625 10 , , , 37231 3625 11 the the DT 37231 3625 12 nearest near JJS 37231 3625 13 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3625 14 in in IN 37231 3625 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3625 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3625 17 can can MD 37231 3625 18 only only RB 37231 3625 19 be be VB 37231 3625 20 found find VBN 37231 3625 21 by by IN 37231 3625 22 uniting unite VBG 37231 3625 23 parts part NNS 37231 3625 24 of of IN 37231 3625 25 the the DT 37231 3625 26 following follow VBG 37231 3625 27 scattered scatter VBN 37231 3625 28 verses verse NNS 37231 3625 29 : : : 37231 3625 30 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3625 31 v. v. CC 37231 3625 32 39 39 CD 37231 3625 33 , , , 37231 3625 34 40 40 CD 37231 3625 35 , , , 37231 3625 36 22 22 CD 37231 3625 37 , , , 37231 3625 38 41 41 CD 37231 3625 39 , , , 37231 3625 40 16 16 CD 37231 3625 41 . . . 37231 3626 1 The the DT 37231 3626 2 Christian Christian NNP 37231 3626 3 who who WP 37231 3626 4 is be VBZ 37231 3626 5 struck strike VBN 37231 3626 6 on on IN 37231 3626 7 one one CD 37231 3626 8 cheek cheek NN 37231 3626 9 is be VBZ 37231 3626 10 to to TO 37231 3626 11 turn turn VB 37231 3626 12 the the DT 37231 3626 13 other other JJ 37231 3626 14 , , , 37231 3626 15 and and CC 37231 3626 16 not not RB 37231 3626 17 to to TO 37231 3626 18 resist resist VB 37231 3626 19 those those DT 37231 3626 20 who who WP 37231 3626 21 would would MD 37231 3626 22 take take VB 37231 3626 23 away away RB 37231 3626 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3626 25 cloak cloak NN 37231 3626 26 or or CC 37231 3626 27 coat coat NN 37231 3626 28 ; ; : 37231 3626 29 but but CC 37231 3626 30 if if IN 37231 3626 31 , , , 37231 3626 32 on on IN 37231 3626 33 the the DT 37231 3626 34 contrary contrary NN 37231 3626 35 , , , 37231 3626 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3626 37 be be VB 37231 3626 38 angry angry JJ 37231 3626 39 , , , 37231 3626 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3626 41 is be VBZ 37231 3626 42 in in IN 37231 3626 43 danger danger NN 37231 3626 44 of of IN 37231 3626 45 fire fire NN 37231 3626 46 ; ; : 37231 3626 47 if if IN 37231 3626 48 , , , 37231 3626 49 then then RB 37231 3626 50 , , , 37231 3626 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3626 52 be be VB 37231 3626 53 compelled compel VBN 37231 3626 54 to to TO 37231 3626 55 go go VB 37231 3626 56 one one CD 37231 3626 57 mile mile NN 37231 3626 58 , , , 37231 3626 59 let let VB 37231 3626 60 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3626 61 show show VB 37231 3626 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3626 63 gentleness gentleness NN 37231 3626 64 by by IN 37231 3626 65 going go VBG 37231 3626 66 two two CD 37231 3626 67 , , , 37231 3626 68 and and CC 37231 3626 69 thus thus RB 37231 3626 70 let let VB 37231 3626 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3626 72 good good JJ 37231 3626 73 works work NNS 37231 3626 74 shine shine VB 37231 3626 75 before before IN 37231 3626 76 men man NNS 37231 3626 77 that that IN 37231 3626 78 , , , 37231 3626 79 seeing see VBG 37231 3626 80 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3626 81 , , , 37231 3626 82 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3626 83 may may MD 37231 3626 84 adore adore VB 37231 3626 85 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3626 86 Father Father NNP 37231 3626 87 which which WDT 37231 3626 88 is be VBZ 37231 3626 89 in in IN 37231 3626 90 heaven heaven NNP 37231 3626 91 . . . 37231 3627 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3627 2 is be VBZ 37231 3627 3 evident evident JJ 37231 3627 4 that that IN 37231 3627 5 the the DT 37231 3627 6 last last JJ 37231 3627 7 two two CD 37231 3627 8 sentences sentence NNS 37231 3627 9 , , , 37231 3627 10 which which WDT 37231 3627 11 find find VBP 37231 3627 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3627 13 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3627 14 in in IN 37231 3627 15 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3627 16 by by IN 37231 3627 17 putting put VBG 37231 3627 18 v. v. RP 37231 3627 19 16 16 CD 37231 3627 20 after after IN 37231 3627 21 41 41 CD 37231 3627 22 , , , 37231 3627 23 the the DT 37231 3627 24 former former JJ 37231 3627 25 verse verse NN 37231 3627 26 having have VBG 37231 3627 27 { { -LRB- 37231 3627 28 375 375 CD 37231 3627 29 } } -RRB- 37231 3627 30 quite quite PDT 37231 3627 31 a a DT 37231 3627 32 different different JJ 37231 3627 33 context context NN 37231 3627 34 in in IN 37231 3627 35 the the DT 37231 3627 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3627 37 , , , 37231 3627 38 must must MD 37231 3627 39 have have VB 37231 3627 40 so so RB 37231 3627 41 followed follow VBN 37231 3627 42 each each DT 37231 3627 43 other other JJ 37231 3627 44 in in IN 37231 3627 45 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3627 46 's 's POS 37231 3627 47 text text NN 37231 3627 48 . . . 37231 3628 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3628 2 purpose purpose NN 37231 3628 3 is be VBZ 37231 3628 4 to to TO 37231 3628 5 quote quote VB 37231 3628 6 the the DT 37231 3628 7 teaching teaching NN 37231 3628 8 of of IN 37231 3628 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3628 10 , , , 37231 3628 11 " " `` 37231 3628 12 regarding regard VBG 37231 3628 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3628 14 being be VBG 37231 3628 15 patient patient JJ 37231 3628 16 under under IN 37231 3628 17 injuries injury NNS 37231 3628 18 , , , 37231 3628 19 and and CC 37231 3628 20 ready ready JJ 37231 3628 21 to to TO 37231 3628 22 help help VB 37231 3628 23 all all DT 37231 3628 24 and and CC 37231 3628 25 free free JJ 37231 3628 26 from from IN 37231 3628 27 anger anger NN 37231 3628 28 , , , 37231 3628 29 " " `` 37231 3628 30 but but CC 37231 3628 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3628 32 quotation quotation NN 37231 3628 33 of of IN 37231 3628 34 " " `` 37231 3628 35 Let let VB 37231 3628 36 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3628 37 good good JJ 37231 3628 38 works work NNS 37231 3628 39 shine shine VB 37231 3628 40 before before IN 37231 3628 41 men man NNS 37231 3628 42 , , , 37231 3628 43 " " '' 37231 3628 44 & & CC 37231 3628 45 c c NNP 37231 3628 46 , , , 37231 3628 47 has have VBZ 37231 3628 48 no no DT 37231 3628 49 direct direct JJ 37231 3628 50 reference reference NN 37231 3628 51 to to IN 37231 3628 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3628 53 subject subject NN 37231 3628 54 , , , 37231 3628 55 and and CC 37231 3628 56 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3628 57 can can MD 37231 3628 58 not not RB 37231 3628 59 reasonably reasonably RB 37231 3628 60 be be VB 37231 3628 61 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3628 62 that that IN 37231 3628 63 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3628 64 would would MD 37231 3628 65 have have VB 37231 3628 66 selected select VBN 37231 3628 67 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3628 68 from from IN 37231 3628 69 a a DT 37231 3628 70 separate separate JJ 37231 3628 71 part part NN 37231 3628 72 of of IN 37231 3628 73 the the DT 37231 3628 74 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3628 75 . . . 37231 3629 1 Coming come VBG 37231 3629 2 as as IN 37231 3629 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3629 4 no no RB 37231 3629 5 doubt doubt RB 37231 3629 6 did do VBD 37231 3629 7 in in IN 37231 3629 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3629 9 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3629 10 in in IN 37231 3629 11 the the DT 37231 3629 12 order order NN 37231 3629 13 in in IN 37231 3629 14 which which WDT 37231 3629 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3629 16 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3629 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3629 18 , , , 37231 3629 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3629 20 is be VBZ 37231 3629 21 quite quite RB 37231 3629 22 appropriate appropriate JJ 37231 3629 23 to to IN 37231 3629 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3629 25 purpose purpose NN 37231 3629 26 . . . 37231 3630 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3630 2 is be VBZ 37231 3630 3 difficult difficult JJ 37231 3630 4 , , , 37231 3630 5 for for IN 37231 3630 6 instance instance NN 37231 3630 7 , , , 37231 3630 8 to to TO 37231 3630 9 imagine imagine VB 37231 3630 10 why why WRB 37231 3630 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3630 12 further further RB 37231 3630 13 omitted omit VBD 37231 3630 14 the the DT 37231 3630 15 injunction injunction NN 37231 3630 16 in in IN 37231 3630 17 the the DT 37231 3630 18 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3630 19 passage passage NN 37231 3630 20 , , , 37231 3630 21 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3630 22 v. v. CC 37231 3630 23 39 39 CD 37231 3630 24 , , , 37231 3630 25 " " '' 37231 3630 26 that that IN 37231 3630 27 ye ye NNP 37231 3630 28 resist resist VBP 37231 3630 29 not not RB 37231 3630 30 evil evil JJ 37231 3630 31 , , , 37231 3630 32 " " '' 37231 3630 33 when when WRB 37231 3630 34 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3630 35 to to TO 37231 3630 36 quote quote VB 37231 3630 37 the the DT 37231 3630 38 rest rest NN 37231 3630 39 of of IN 37231 3630 40 the the DT 37231 3630 41 verse verse NN 37231 3630 42 , , , 37231 3630 43 since since IN 37231 3630 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3630 45 express express JJ 37231 3630 46 object object NN 37231 3630 47 is be VBZ 37231 3630 48 to to TO 37231 3630 49 show show VB 37231 3630 50 that that IN 37231 3630 51 " " `` 37231 3630 52 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3630 53 ought ought MD 37231 3630 54 not not RB 37231 3630 55 to to TO 37231 3630 56 strive strive VB 37231 3630 57 , , , 37231 3630 58 " " '' 37231 3630 59 & & CC 37231 3630 60 c. c. NNP 37231 3630 61 The the DT 37231 3630 62 whole whole JJ 37231 3630 63 quotation quotation NN 37231 3630 64 presents present VBZ 37231 3630 65 the the DT 37231 3630 66 same same JJ 37231 3630 67 characteristics characteristic NNS 37231 3630 68 as as IN 37231 3630 69 those those DT 37231 3630 70 which which WDT 37231 3630 71 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3630 72 have have VBP 37231 3630 73 already already RB 37231 3630 74 examined examine VBN 37231 3630 75 , , , 37231 3630 76 and and CC 37231 3630 77 in in IN 37231 3630 78 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3630 79 continuity continuity NN 37231 3630 80 of of IN 37231 3630 81 thought thought NN 37231 3630 82 and and CC 37231 3630 83 wide wide JJ 37231 3630 84 variation variation NN 37231 3630 85 from from IN 37231 3630 86 the the DT 37231 3630 87 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3630 88 in in IN 37231 3630 89 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3630 90 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3630 91 , , , 37231 3630 92 both both CC 37231 3630 93 in in IN 37231 3630 94 order order NN 37231 3630 95 and and CC 37231 3630 96 language language NN 37231 3630 97 , , , 37231 3630 98 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3630 99 must must MD 37231 3630 100 recognize recognize VB 37231 3630 101 a a DT 37231 3630 102 different different JJ 37231 3630 103 and and CC 37231 3630 104 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3630 105 source source NN 37231 3630 106 . . . 37231 3631 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3631 2 1 1 LS 37231 3631 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3631 4 The the DT 37231 3631 5 passage passage NN 37231 3631 6 i i PRP 37231 3631 7 , , , 37231 3631 8 again again RB 37231 3631 9 , , , 37231 3631 10 is be VBZ 37231 3631 11 professedly professedly RB 37231 3631 12 a a DT 37231 3631 13 literal literal JJ 37231 3631 14 quotation quotation NN 37231 3631 15 , , , 37231 3631 16 for for IN 37231 3631 17 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3631 18 prefaces preface VBZ 37231 3631 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3631 20 with with IN 37231 3631 21 the the DT 37231 3631 22 words word NNS 37231 3631 23 : : : 37231 3631 24 " " `` 37231 3631 25 And and CC 37231 3631 26 regarding regard VBG 37231 3631 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3631 28 not not RB 37231 3631 29 swearing swear VBG 37231 3631 30 at at RB 37231 3631 31 all all RB 37231 3631 32 , , , 37231 3631 33 but but CC 37231 3631 34 ever ever RB 37231 3631 35 speaking speak VBG 37231 3631 36 the the DT 37231 3631 37 truth truth NN 37231 3631 38 , , , 37231 3631 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3631 40 taught teach VBD 37231 3631 41 thus thus RB 37231 3631 42 ; ; : 37231 3631 43 " " `` 37231 3631 44 and and CC 37231 3631 45 having have VBG 37231 3631 46 in in IN 37231 3631 47 these these DT 37231 3631 48 words word NNS 37231 3631 49 actually actually RB 37231 3631 50 stated state VBD 37231 3631 51 what what WP 37231 3631 52 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3631 53 did do VBD 37231 3631 54 teach teach VB 37231 3631 55 , , , 37231 3631 56 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3631 57 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 3631 58 to to TO 37231 3631 59 quote quote VB 37231 3631 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3631 61 very very JJ 37231 3631 62 words word NNS 37231 3631 63 . . . 37231 3632 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3632 2 2 2 LS 37231 3632 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3632 4 In in IN 37231 3632 5 the the DT 37231 3632 6 quotation quotation NN 37231 3632 7 there there EX 37231 3632 8 is be VBZ 37231 3632 9 a a DT 37231 3632 10 clear clear JJ 37231 3632 11 departure departure NN 37231 3632 12 from from IN 37231 3632 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3632 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3632 15 , , , 37231 3632 16 arising arise VBG 37231 3632 17 , , , 37231 3632 18 not not RB 37231 3632 19 from from IN 37231 3632 20 accidental accidental JJ 37231 3632 21 failure failure NN 37231 3632 22 - - : 37231 3632 23 of of IN 37231 3632 24 memory memory NN 37231 3632 25 , , , 37231 3632 26 but but CC 37231 3632 27 from from IN 37231 3632 28 difference difference NN 37231 3632 29 of of IN 37231 3632 30 source source NN 37231 3632 31 . . . 37231 3633 1 The the DT 37231 3633 2 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3633 3 passages passage NNS 37231 3633 4 in in IN 37231 3633 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3633 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3633 7 , , , 37231 3633 8 so so RB 37231 3633 9 far far RB 37231 3633 10 as as IN 37231 3633 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3633 12 exist exist VBP 37231 3633 13 at at RB 37231 3633 14 all all RB 37231 3633 15 , , , 37231 3633 16 can can MD 37231 3633 17 only only RB 37231 3633 18 be be VB 37231 3633 19 found find VBN 37231 3633 20 by by IN 37231 3633 21 taking take VBG 37231 3633 22 part part NN 37231 3633 23 of of IN 37231 3633 24 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3633 25 v. v. CC 37231 3633 26 34 34 CD 37231 3633 27 and and CC 37231 3633 28 joining join VBG 37231 3633 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3633 30 to to IN 37231 3633 31 v. v. IN 37231 3633 32 37 37 CD 37231 3633 33 , , , 37231 3633 34 omitting omit VBG 37231 3633 35 the the DT 37231 3633 36 intermediate intermediate JJ 37231 3633 37 verses verse NNS 37231 3633 38 . . . 37231 3634 1 The the DT 37231 3634 2 quotation quotation NN 37231 3634 3 in in IN 37231 3634 4 the the DT 37231 3634 5 { { -LRB- 37231 3634 6 376 376 CD 37231 3634 7 } } -RRB- 37231 3634 8 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3634 9 of of IN 37231 3634 10 James James NNP 37231 3634 11 v. v. CC 37231 3634 12 12 12 CD 37231 3634 13 , , , 37231 3634 14 which which WDT 37231 3634 15 is be VBZ 37231 3634 16 evidently evidently RB 37231 3634 17 derived derive VBN 37231 3634 18 from from IN 37231 3634 19 a a DT 37231 3634 20 source source NN 37231 3634 21 different different JJ 37231 3634 22 from from IN 37231 3634 23 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3634 24 , , , 37231 3634 25 supports support VBZ 37231 3634 26 the the DT 37231 3634 27 reading reading NN 37231 3634 28 of of IN 37231 3634 29 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3634 30 . . . 37231 3635 1 This this DT 37231 3635 2 , , , 37231 3635 3 with with IN 37231 3635 4 the the DT 37231 3635 5 passage passage NN 37231 3635 6 twice twice RB 37231 3635 7 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3635 8 in in IN 37231 3635 9 the the DT 37231 3635 10 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 3635 11 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 3635 12 in in IN 37231 3635 13 agreement agreement NN 37231 3635 14 with with IN 37231 3635 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3635 16 , , , 37231 3635 17 and and CC 37231 3635 18 , , , 37231 3635 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3635 20 may may MD 37231 3635 21 be be VB 37231 3635 22 added add VBN 37231 3635 23 , , , 37231 3635 24 the the DT 37231 3635 25 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3635 26 version version NN 37231 3635 27 found find VBD 37231 3635 28 in in IN 37231 3635 29 early early JJ 37231 3635 30 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 3635 31 writings,(1 writings,(1 NN 37231 3635 32 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3635 33 all all DT 37231 3635 34 tend tend VBP 37231 3635 35 to to TO 37231 3635 36 confirm confirm VB 37231 3635 37 the the DT 37231 3635 38 belief belief NN 37231 3635 39 that that IN 37231 3635 40 there there EX 37231 3635 41 existed exist VBD 37231 3635 42 a a DT 37231 3635 43 more more RBR 37231 3635 44 ancient ancient JJ 37231 3635 45 form form NN 37231 3635 46 of of IN 37231 3635 47 the the DT 37231 3635 48 injunction injunction NN 37231 3635 49 which which WDT 37231 3635 50 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3635 51 no no RB 37231 3635 52 doubt doubt RB 37231 3635 53 found find VBN 37231 3635 54 in in IN 37231 3635 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3635 56 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3635 57 . . . 37231 3636 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3636 2 2 2 LS 37231 3636 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3636 4 The the DT 37231 3636 5 precept precept NN 37231 3636 6 , , , 37231 3636 7 terse terse JJ 37231 3636 8 , , , 37231 3636 9 simple simple JJ 37231 3636 10 , , , 37231 3636 11 and and CC 37231 3636 12 direct direct JJ 37231 3636 13 , , , 37231 3636 14 as as IN 37231 3636 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3636 16 is be VBZ 37231 3636 17 here here RB 37231 3636 18 , , , 37231 3636 19 is be VBZ 37231 3636 20 much much RB 37231 3636 21 more more JJR 37231 3636 22 in in IN 37231 3636 23 accordance accordance NN 37231 3636 24 with with IN 37231 3636 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3636 26 's 's POS 37231 3636 27 own own JJ 37231 3636 28 description description NN 37231 3636 29 of of IN 37231 3636 30 the the DT 37231 3636 31 teaching teaching NN 37231 3636 32 of of IN 37231 3636 33 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3636 34 , , , 37231 3636 35 as as IN 37231 3636 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3636 37 evidently evidently RB 37231 3636 38 found find VBD 37231 3636 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3636 40 in in IN 37231 3636 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3636 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3636 43 , , , 37231 3636 44 than than IN 37231 3636 45 the the DT 37231 3636 46 diffused diffuse VBN 37231 3636 47 version version NN 37231 3636 48 contained contain VBN 37231 3636 49 in in IN 37231 3636 50 the the DT 37231 3636 51 first first JJ 37231 3636 52 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3636 53 , , , 37231 3636 54 v. v. CC 37231 3636 55 33 33 CD 37231 3636 56 - - HYPH 37231 3636 57 -37 -37 NNP 37231 3636 58 . . . 37231 3637 1 Another another DT 37231 3637 2 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3637 3 and and CC 37231 3637 4 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 3637 5 illustration illustration NN 37231 3637 6 of of IN 37231 3637 7 the the DT 37231 3637 8 peculiarity peculiarity NN 37231 3637 9 of of IN 37231 3637 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3637 11 's 's POS 37231 3637 12 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3637 13 is be VBZ 37231 3637 14 presented present VBN 37231 3637 15 by by IN 37231 3637 16 the the DT 37231 3637 17 long long JJ 37231 3637 18 passage passage NN 37231 3637 19 k k NNP 37231 3637 20 , , , 37231 3637 21 which which WDT 37231 3637 22 is be VBZ 37231 3637 23 also also RB 37231 3637 24 throughout throughout IN 37231 3637 25 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3637 26 and and CC 37231 3637 27 bound bind VBN 37231 3637 28 together together RB 37231 3637 29 by by IN 37231 3637 30 clear clear JJ 37231 3637 31 unity unity NN 37231 3637 32 of of IN 37231 3637 33 thought thought NN 37231 3637 34 . . . 37231 3638 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3638 2 3 3 LS 37231 3638 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3638 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3638 5 is be VBZ 37231 3638 6 presented present VBN 37231 3638 7 with with IN 37231 3638 8 the the DT 37231 3638 9 context context NN 37231 3638 10 : : : 37231 3638 11 " " `` 37231 3638 12 For for IN 37231 3638 13 not not RB 37231 3638 14 those those DT 37231 3638 15 who who WP 37231 3638 16 merely merely RB 37231 3638 17 make make VBP 37231 3638 18 professions profession NNS 37231 3638 19 but but CC 37231 3638 20 those those DT 37231 3638 21 who who WP 37231 3638 22 do do VBP 37231 3638 23 the the DT 37231 3638 24 works work NNS 37231 3638 25 , , , 37231 3638 26 as as IN 37231 3638 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3638 28 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3638 29 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3638 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3638 31 said say VBD 37231 3638 32 , , , 37231 3638 33 shall shall MD 37231 3638 34 be be VB 37231 3638 35 saved save VBN 37231 3638 36 . . . 37231 3639 1 For for IN 37231 3639 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3639 3 spake spake VBD 37231 3639 4 thus thus RB 37231 3639 5 . . . 37231 3639 6 " " '' 37231 3640 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3640 2 does do VBZ 37231 3640 3 not not RB 37231 3640 4 , , , 37231 3640 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 3640 6 , , , 37231 3640 7 seem seem VBP 37231 3640 8 possible possible JJ 37231 3640 9 to to TO 37231 3640 10 indicate indicate VB 37231 3640 11 more more RBR 37231 3640 12 clearly clearly RB 37231 3640 13 the the DT 37231 3640 14 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 3640 15 intention intention NN 37231 3640 16 to to TO 37231 3640 17 quote quote VB 37231 3640 18 the the DT 37231 3640 19 exact exact JJ 37231 3640 20 expressions expression NNS 37231 3640 21 of of IN 37231 3640 22 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3640 23 , , , 37231 3640 24 and and CC 37231 3640 25 yet yet RB 37231 3640 26 not not RB 37231 3640 27 only only RB 37231 3640 28 do do VBP 37231 3640 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3640 30 find find VB 37231 3640 31 material material NN 37231 3640 32 difference difference NN 37231 3640 33 from from IN 37231 3640 34 the the DT 37231 3640 35 language language NN 37231 3640 36 in in IN 37231 3640 37 the the DT 37231 3640 38 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3640 39 passages passage NNS 37231 3640 40 in in IN 37231 3640 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3640 42 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3640 43 , , , 37231 3640 44 but but CC 37231 3640 45 those those DT 37231 3640 46 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3640 47 , , , 37231 3640 48 such such JJ 37231 3640 49 as as IN 37231 3640 50 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3640 51 are be VBP 37231 3640 52 , , , 37231 3640 53 can can MD 37231 3640 54 only only RB 37231 3640 55 be be VB 37231 3640 56 made make VBN 37231 3640 57 by by IN 37231 3640 58 patching patch VBG 37231 3640 59 together together RB 37231 3640 60 the the DT 37231 3640 61 following follow VBG 37231 3640 62 verses verse NNS 37231 3640 63 in in IN 37231 3640 64 the the DT 37231 3640 65 order order NN 37231 3640 66 in in IN 37231 3640 67 { { -LRB- 37231 3640 68 377 377 CD 37231 3640 69 } } -RRB- 37231 3640 70 which which WDT 37231 3640 71 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3640 72 give give VBP 37231 3640 73 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3640 74 : : : 37231 3640 75 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3640 76 . . . 37231 3641 1 vii vii NN 37231 3641 2 . . . 37231 3642 1 21 21 CD 37231 3642 2 , , , 37231 3642 3 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3642 4 x. x. NNP 37231 3643 1 16 16 CD 37231 3643 2 , , , 37231 3643 3 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3643 4 . . . 37231 3644 1 vii vii NN 37231 3644 2 . . . 37231 3645 1 22 22 CD 37231 3645 2 , , , 37231 3645 3 23 23 CD 37231 3645 4 , , , 37231 3645 5 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3645 6 . . . 37231 3646 1 42 42 CD 37231 3646 2 , , , 37231 3646 3 43 43 CD 37231 3646 4 , , , 37231 3646 5 vii vii NN 37231 3646 6 . . . 37231 3647 1 15 15 CD 37231 3647 2 , , , 37231 3647 3 part part NN 37231 3647 4 of of IN 37231 3647 5 16 16 CD 37231 3647 6 , , , 37231 3647 7 19 19 CD 37231 3647 8 . . . 37231 3648 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3648 2 will will MD 37231 3648 3 be be VB 37231 3648 4 remarked remark VBN 37231 3648 5 that that IN 37231 3648 6 the the DT 37231 3648 7 passage passage NN 37231 3648 8 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3648 9 k k NNP 37231 3648 10 2 2 CD 37231 3648 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3648 12 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3648 13 x. x. NNP 37231 3649 1 16 16 CD 37231 3649 2 , , , 37231 3649 3 is be VBZ 37231 3649 4 thrust thrust VBN 37231 3649 5 in in IN 37231 3649 6 between between IN 37231 3649 7 two two CD 37231 3649 8 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 3649 9 verses verse NNS 37231 3649 10 in in IN 37231 3649 11 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3649 12 , , , 37231 3649 13 and and CC 37231 3649 14 taken take VBN 37231 3649 15 from from IN 37231 3649 16 a a DT 37231 3649 17 totally totally RB 37231 3649 18 different different JJ 37231 3649 19 context context NN 37231 3649 20 as as IN 37231 3649 21 the the DT 37231 3649 22 nearest near JJS 37231 3649 23 parallel parallel NN 37231 3649 24 to to IN 37231 3649 25 k k IN 37231 3649 26 2 2 CD 37231 3649 27 of of IN 37231 3649 28 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3649 29 , , , 37231 3649 30 although although IN 37231 3649 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3649 32 is be VBZ 37231 3649 33 widely widely RB 37231 3649 34 different different JJ 37231 3649 35 from from IN 37231 3649 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3649 37 , , , 37231 3649 38 omitting omit VBG 37231 3649 39 altogether altogether RB 37231 3649 40 the the DT 37231 3649 41 most most RBS 37231 3649 42 important important JJ 37231 3649 43 words word NNS 37231 3649 44 : : : 37231 3649 45 " " '' 37231 3649 46 and and CC 37231 3649 47 doeth doeth VB 37231 3649 48 what what WP 37231 3649 49 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3649 50 say say VBP 37231 3649 51 . . . 37231 3649 52 " " '' 37231 3650 1 The the DT 37231 3650 2 repetition repetition NN 37231 3650 3 of of IN 37231 3650 4 the the DT 37231 3650 5 same same JJ 37231 3650 6 phrase phrase NN 37231 3650 7 : : : 37231 3650 8 " " `` 37231 3650 9 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3650 10 that that IN 37231 3650 11 heareth heareth RB 37231 3650 12 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3650 13 heareth heareth VBD 37231 3650 14 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3650 15 that that WDT 37231 3650 16 sent send VBD 37231 3650 17 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3650 18 , , , 37231 3650 19 " " '' 37231 3650 20 in in IN 37231 3650 21 Apol Apol NNP 37231 3650 22 . . . 37231 3651 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3651 2 , , , 37231 3651 3 63,(1 63,(1 JJ 37231 3651 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3651 5 makes make VBZ 37231 3651 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3651 7 certain certain JJ 37231 3651 8 that that IN 37231 3651 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3651 10 accurately accurately RB 37231 3651 11 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3651 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3651 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3651 14 , , , 37231 3651 15 whilst whilst IN 37231 3651 16 the the DT 37231 3651 17 omission omission NN 37231 3651 18 of of IN 37231 3651 19 the the DT 37231 3651 20 words word NNS 37231 3651 21 in in IN 37231 3651 22 that that DT 37231 3651 23 place place NN 37231 3651 24 : : : 37231 3651 25 " " `` 37231 3651 26 and and CC 37231 3651 27 doeth doeth VB 37231 3651 28 what what WP 37231 3651 29 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3651 30 say say VBP 37231 3651 31 , , , 37231 3651 32 " " `` 37231 3651 33 evidently evidently RB 37231 3651 34 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 3651 35 from from IN 37231 3651 36 the the DT 37231 3651 37 fact fact NN 37231 3651 38 that that IN 37231 3651 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3651 40 are be VBP 37231 3651 41 an an DT 37231 3651 42 interruption interruption NN 37231 3651 43 of of IN 37231 3651 44 the the DT 37231 3651 45 phrase phrase NN 37231 3651 46 for for IN 37231 3651 47 which which WDT 37231 3651 48 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3651 49 makes make VBZ 37231 3651 50 the the DT 37231 3651 51 quotation quotation NN 37231 3651 52 , , , 37231 3651 53 namely namely RB 37231 3651 54 , , , 37231 3651 55 to to TO 37231 3651 56 prove prove VB 37231 3651 57 that that IN 37231 3651 58 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3651 59 is be VBZ 37231 3651 60 sent send VBN 37231 3651 61 forth forth RB 37231 3651 62 to to TO 37231 3651 63 reveal reveal VB 37231 3651 64 the the DT 37231 3651 65 Father Father NNP 37231 3651 66 . . . 37231 3652 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3652 2 2 2 LS 37231 3652 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3652 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3652 5 may may MD 37231 3652 6 be be VB 37231 3652 7 well well JJ 37231 3652 8 to to TO 37231 3652 9 compare compare VB 37231 3652 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3652 11 's 's POS 37231 3652 12 passage passage NN 37231 3652 13 , , , 37231 3652 14 k k NNP 37231 3652 15 1 1 CD 37231 3652 16 - - HYPH 37231 3652 17 -4 -4 NNP 37231 3652 18 , , , 37231 3652 19 with with IN 37231 3652 20 one one CD 37231 3652 21 occurring occur VBG 37231 3652 22 in in IN 37231 3652 23 the the DT 37231 3652 24 so so RB 37231 3652 25 - - HYPH 37231 3652 26 called call VBN 37231 3652 27 Second Second NNP 37231 3652 28 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3652 29 of of IN 37231 3652 30 Clement Clement NNP 37231 3652 31 to to IN 37231 3652 32 the the DT 37231 3652 33 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 3652 34 , , , 37231 3652 35 iv iv LS 37231 3652 36 . . . 37231 3653 1 " " `` 37231 3653 2 Let let VB 37231 3653 3 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3653 4 not not RB 37231 3653 5 , , , 37231 3653 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 3653 7 , , , 37231 3653 8 only only RB 37231 3653 9 call call VB 37231 3653 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3653 11 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3653 12 , , , 37231 3653 13 for for IN 37231 3653 14 that that DT 37231 3653 15 will will MD 37231 3653 16 not not RB 37231 3653 17 save save VB 37231 3653 18 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3653 19 . . . 37231 3654 1 For for IN 37231 3654 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3654 3 saith saith RB 37231 3654 4 : : : 37231 3654 5 ' ' `` 37231 3654 6 Not not RB 37231 3654 7 every every DT 37231 3654 8 one one NN 37231 3654 9 that that WDT 37231 3654 10 saith saith JJ 37231 3654 11 to to IN 37231 3654 12 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3654 13 , , , 37231 3654 14 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3654 15 , , , 37231 3654 16 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3654 17 , , , 37231 3654 18 shall shall MD 37231 3654 19 be be VB 37231 3654 20 saved save VBN 37231 3654 21 , , , 37231 3654 22 but but CC 37231 3654 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3654 24 that that IN 37231 3654 25 worketh worketh NNP 37231 3654 26 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 3654 27 . . . 37231 3654 28 ' ' '' 37231 3654 29 ... ... . 37231 3655 1 the the DT 37231 3655 2 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3655 3 said say VBD 37231 3655 4 : : : 37231 3655 5 ' ' `` 37231 3655 6 If if IN 37231 3655 7 ye ye NNP 37231 3655 8 be be VBP 37231 3655 9 with with IN 37231 3655 10 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 11 gathered gather VBD 37231 3655 12 together together RB 37231 3655 13 in in IN 37231 3655 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3655 15 bosom bosom NN 37231 3655 16 , , , 37231 3655 17 and and CC 37231 3655 18 do do VBP 37231 3655 19 not not RB 37231 3655 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3655 21 commandments commandment NNS 37231 3655 22 , , , 37231 3655 23 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 24 will will MD 37231 3655 25 cast cast VB 37231 3655 26 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 27 off off RP 37231 3655 28 and and CC 37231 3655 29 say say VB 37231 3655 30 to to IN 37231 3655 31 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 32 : : : 37231 3655 33 Depart Depart NNP 37231 3655 34 from from IN 37231 3655 35 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 36 ; ; : 37231 3655 37 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 38 know know VBP 37231 3655 39 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 40 not not RB 37231 3655 41 , , , 37231 3655 42 whence whence NN 37231 3655 43 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3655 44 are be VBP 37231 3655 45 , , , 37231 3655 46 workers worker NNS 37231 3655 47 of of IN 37231 3655 48 iniquity iniquity NN 37231 3655 49 . . . 37231 3656 1 ' ' '' 37231 3656 2 " " '' 37231 3656 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3656 4 3 3 LS 37231 3656 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3656 6 The the DT 37231 3656 7 expression expression NN 37231 3656 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3656 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3656 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3656 11 here here RB 37231 3656 12 strongly strongly RB 37231 3656 13 recalls recall VBZ 37231 3656 14 the the DT 37231 3656 15 reading reading NN 37231 3656 16 of of IN 37231 3656 17 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3656 18 . . . 37231 3657 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3657 2 4 4 LS 37231 3657 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3657 4 This this DT 37231 3657 5 passage passage NN 37231 3657 6 , , , 37231 3657 7 which which WDT 37231 3657 8 is be VBZ 37231 3657 9 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3657 10 to to IN 37231 3657 11 { { -LRB- 37231 3657 12 378 378 CD 37231 3657 13 } } -RRB- 37231 3657 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3657 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3657 16 , , , 37231 3657 17 at at IN 37231 3657 18 least least JJS 37231 3657 19 shows show VBZ 37231 3657 20 the the DT 37231 3657 21 existence existence NN 37231 3657 22 of of IN 37231 3657 23 others other NNS 37231 3657 24 containing contain VBG 37231 3657 25 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3657 26 discourses discourse NNS 37231 3657 27 with with IN 37231 3657 28 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3657 29 variations variation NNS 37231 3657 30 . . . 37231 3658 1 Some some DT 37231 3658 2 of of IN 37231 3658 3 the the DT 37231 3658 4 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3658 5 in in IN 37231 3658 6 this this DT 37231 3658 7 spurious spurious JJ 37231 3658 8 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 3658 9 are be VBP 37231 3658 10 stated state VBN 37231 3658 11 to to TO 37231 3658 12 be be VB 37231 3658 13 taken take VBN 37231 3658 14 from from IN 37231 3658 15 the the DT 37231 3658 16 " " `` 37231 3658 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3658 18 according accord VBG 37231 3658 19 to to IN 37231 3658 20 the the DT 37231 3658 21 Egyptians,"(1 egyptians,"(1 NN 37231 3658 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3658 23 which which WDT 37231 3658 24 was be VBD 37231 3658 25 in in IN 37231 3658 26 all all DT 37231 3658 27 probability probability NN 37231 3658 28 a a DT 37231 3658 29 version version NN 37231 3658 30 of of IN 37231 3658 31 the the DT 37231 3658 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3658 33 according accord VBG 37231 3658 34 to to IN 37231 3658 35 the the DT 37231 3658 36 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3658 37 . . . 37231 3659 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3659 2 2 2 LS 37231 3659 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3659 4 The the DT 37231 3659 5 variations variation NNS 37231 3659 6 which which WDT 37231 3659 7 occur occur VBP 37231 3659 8 in in IN 37231 3659 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3659 10 's 's POS 37231 3659 11 repetition repetition NN 37231 3659 12 , , , 37231 3659 13 in in IN 37231 3659 14 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3659 15 76 76 CD 37231 3659 16 , , , 37231 3659 17 of of IN 37231 3659 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3659 19 quotation quotation NN 37231 3659 20 k k NNP 37231 3659 21 3 3 CD 37231 3659 22 are be VBP 37231 3659 23 not not RB 37231 3659 24 important important JJ 37231 3659 25 , , , 37231 3659 26 because because IN 37231 3659 27 the the DT 37231 3659 28 more more RBR 37231 3659 29 weighty weighty JJ 37231 3659 30 departure departure NN 37231 3659 31 from from IN 37231 3659 32 the the DT 37231 3659 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3659 34 in in IN 37231 3659 35 the the DT 37231 3659 36 words word NNS 37231 3659 37 " " `` 37231 3659 38 did do VBD 37231 3659 39 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3659 40 not not RB 37231 3659 41 eat eat VB 37231 3659 42 and and CC 37231 3659 43 drink drink VB 37231 3659 44 in in IN 37231 3659 45 thy thy NN 37231 3659 46 name name NN 37231 3659 47 , , , 37231 3659 48 " " '' 37231 3659 49 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3659 50 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3659 51 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3659 52 is be VBZ 37231 3659 53 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 3659 54 repeated,(3 repeated,(3 JJ 37231 3659 55 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3659 56 and and CC 37231 3659 57 if if IN 37231 3659 58 , , , 37231 3659 59 therefore therefore RB 37231 3659 60 , , , 37231 3659 61 there there EX 37231 3659 62 be be VB 37231 3659 63 freedom freedom NN 37231 3659 64 of of IN 37231 3659 65 quotation quotation NN 37231 3659 66 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3659 67 is be VBZ 37231 3659 68 free free JJ 37231 3659 69 quotation quotation NN 37231 3659 70 not not RB 37231 3659 71 from from IN 37231 3659 72 the the DT 37231 3659 73 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3659 74 , , , 37231 3659 75 but but CC 37231 3659 76 from from IN 37231 3659 77 a a DT 37231 3659 78 different different JJ 37231 3659 79 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3659 80 . . . 37231 3660 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3660 2 4 4 LS 37231 3660 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3660 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3660 5 's 's POS 37231 3660 6 quotation(5 quotation(5 NN 37231 3660 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3660 8 does do VBZ 37231 3660 9 not not RB 37231 3660 10 affect affect VB 37231 3660 11 this this DT 37231 3660 12 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3660 13 , , , 37231 3660 14 for for IN 37231 3660 15 the the DT 37231 3660 16 repetition repetition NN 37231 3660 17 of of IN 37231 3660 18 the the DT 37231 3660 19 phrase phrase NN 37231 3660 20 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3660 21 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3660 22 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3660 23 has have VBZ 37231 3660 24 the the DT 37231 3660 25 form form NN 37231 3660 26 of of IN 37231 3660 27 the the DT 37231 3660 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3660 29 , , , 37231 3660 30 and and CC 37231 3660 31 besides besides RB 37231 3660 32 , , , 37231 3660 33 which which WDT 37231 3660 34 is be VBZ 37231 3660 35 much much RB 37231 3660 36 more more RBR 37231 3660 37 important important JJ 37231 3660 38 , , , 37231 3660 39 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3660 40 know know VBP 37231 3660 41 that that IN 37231 3660 42 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3660 43 was be VBD 37231 3660 44 well well RB 37231 3660 45 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 3660 46 with with IN 37231 3660 47 the the DT 37231 3660 48 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3660 49 according accord VBG 37231 3660 50 to to IN 37231 3660 51 the the DT 37231 3660 52 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3660 53 and and CC 37231 3660 54 other other JJ 37231 3660 55 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3660 56 works work VBZ 37231 3660 57 from from IN 37231 3660 58 which which WDT 37231 3660 59 this this DT 37231 3660 60 may may MD 37231 3660 61 have have VB 37231 3660 62 been be VBN 37231 3660 63 a a DT 37231 3660 64 reminiscence reminiscence NN 37231 3660 65 . . . 37231 3661 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3661 2 6 6 LS 37231 3661 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3661 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3661 5 must must MD 37231 3661 6 add add VB 37231 3661 7 , , , 37231 3661 8 moreover moreover RB 37231 3661 9 , , , 37231 3661 10 that that IN 37231 3661 11 the the DT 37231 3661 12 passage passage NN 37231 3661 13 in in IN 37231 3661 14 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3661 15 76 76 NNP 37231 3661 16 appears appear VBZ 37231 3661 17 in in IN 37231 3661 18 connection connection NN 37231 3661 19 with with IN 37231 3661 20 others other NNS 37231 3661 21 widely widely RB 37231 3661 22 differing differ VBG 37231 3661 23 from from IN 37231 3661 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3661 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3661 26 . . . 37231 3662 1 The the DT 37231 3662 2 passage passage NN 37231 3662 3 k k NN 37231 3662 4 5 5 CD 37231 3662 5 not not RB 37231 3662 6 only only RB 37231 3662 7 materially materially RB 37231 3662 8 varies vary VBZ 37231 3662 9 from from IN 37231 3662 10 the the DT 37231 3662 11 parallel parallel NN 37231 3662 12 in in IN 37231 3662 13 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3662 14 . . . 37231 3663 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3663 2 . . . 37231 3664 1 42 42 CD 37231 3664 2 , , , 37231 3664 3 43 43 CD 37231 3664 4 in in IN 37231 3664 5 language language NN 37231 3664 6 but but CC 37231 3664 7 in in IN 37231 3664 8 connection connection NN 37231 3664 9 of of IN 37231 3664 10 ideas idea NNS 37231 3664 11 . . . 37231 3665 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3665 2 7 7 LS 37231 3665 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3665 4 Here here RB 37231 3665 5 also also RB 37231 3665 6 , , , 37231 3665 7 upon upon IN 37231 3665 8 examination examination NN 37231 3665 9 , , , 37231 3665 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3665 11 must must MD 37231 3665 12 conclude conclude VB 37231 3665 13 that that IN 37231 3665 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3665 15 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3665 16 from from IN 37231 3665 17 a a DT 37231 3665 18 source source NN 37231 3665 19 different different JJ 37231 3665 20 from from IN 37231 3665 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3665 22 { { -LRB- 37231 3665 23 379 379 CD 37231 3665 24 } } -RRB- 37231 3665 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3665 26 , , , 37231 3665 27 and and CC 37231 3665 28 moreover moreover RB 37231 3665 29 , , , 37231 3665 30 that that IN 37231 3665 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3665 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3665 33 gives give VBZ 37231 3665 34 with with IN 37231 3665 35 greater great JJR 37231 3665 36 correctness correctness NN 37231 3665 37 the the DT 37231 3665 38 original original JJ 37231 3665 39 form form NN 37231 3665 40 of of IN 37231 3665 41 the the DT 37231 3665 42 passage passage NN 37231 3665 43 . . . 37231 3666 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3666 2 1 1 LS 37231 3666 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3666 4 The the DT 37231 3666 5 weeping weeping NN 37231 3666 6 and and CC 37231 3666 7 gnashing gnashing NN 37231 3666 8 of of IN 37231 3666 9 teeth tooth NNS 37231 3666 10 are be VBP 37231 3666 11 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3666 12 represented represent VBN 37231 3666 13 as as IN 37231 3666 14 the the DT 37231 3666 15 consequence consequence NN 37231 3666 16 when when WRB 37231 3666 17 the the DT 37231 3666 18 wicked wicke VBD 37231 3666 19 see see VBP 37231 3666 20 the the DT 37231 3666 21 bliss bliss NN 37231 3666 22 of of IN 37231 3666 23 the the DT 37231 3666 24 righteous righteous JJ 37231 3666 25 while while IN 37231 3666 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3666 27 are be VBP 37231 3666 28 sent send VBN 37231 3666 29 into into IN 37231 3666 30 everlasting everlasting JJ 37231 3666 31 fire fire NN 37231 3666 32 , , , 37231 3666 33 and and CC 37231 3666 34 not not RB 37231 3666 35 as as IN 37231 3666 36 the the DT 37231 3666 37 mere mere JJ 37231 3666 38 characteristics characteristic NNS 37231 3666 39 of of IN 37231 3666 40 hell hell NNP 37231 3666 41 . . . 37231 3667 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3667 2 will will MD 37231 3667 3 be be VB 37231 3667 4 observed observe VBN 37231 3667 5 that that IN 37231 3667 6 the the DT 37231 3667 7 preceding precede VBG 37231 3667 8 passages passage NNS 37231 3667 9 k k NNP 37231 3667 10 3 3 CD 37231 3667 11 and and CC 37231 3667 12 4 4 CD 37231 3667 13 , , , 37231 3667 14 find find VB 37231 3667 15 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3667 16 to to IN 37231 3667 17 a a DT 37231 3667 18 certain certain JJ 37231 3667 19 extent extent NN 37231 3667 20 in in IN 37231 3667 21 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3667 22 . . . 37231 3668 1 vii vii NN 37231 3668 2 . . . 37231 3669 1 22,23 22,23 CD 37231 3669 2 , , , 37231 3669 3 although although IN 37231 3669 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3669 5 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3669 6 . . . 37231 3670 1 26 26 CD 37231 3670 2 , , , 37231 3670 3 27 27 CD 37231 3670 4 , , , 37231 3670 5 is be VBZ 37231 3670 6 in in IN 37231 3670 7 some some DT 37231 3670 8 respects respect NNS 37231 3670 9 closer close RBR 37231 3670 10 to to IN 37231 3670 11 the the DT 37231 3670 12 reading reading NN 37231 3670 13 of of IN 37231 3670 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3670 15 k k NNP 37231 3670 16 5 5 CD 37231 3670 17 , , , 37231 3670 18 however however RB 37231 3670 19 , , , 37231 3670 20 finds find VBZ 37231 3670 21 no no DT 37231 3670 22 continuation continuation NN 37231 3670 23 of of IN 37231 3670 24 parallel parallel NN 37231 3670 25 in in IN 37231 3670 26 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3670 27 , , , 37231 3670 28 vii vii NN 37231 3670 29 . . . 37231 3670 30 , , , 37231 3670 31 from from IN 37231 3670 32 which which WDT 37231 3670 33 the the DT 37231 3670 34 context context NN 37231 3670 35 comes come VBZ 37231 3670 36 , , , 37231 3670 37 but but CC 37231 3670 38 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3670 39 have have VBP 37231 3670 40 to to TO 37231 3670 41 seek seek VB 37231 3670 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3670 43 in in IN 37231 3670 44 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3670 45 . . . 37231 3671 1 42 42 CD 37231 3671 2 , , , 37231 3671 3 43 43 CD 37231 3671 4 . . . 37231 3672 1 K K NNP 37231 3672 2 5 5 CD 37231 3672 3 , , , 37231 3672 4 however however RB 37231 3672 5 , , , 37231 3672 6 does do VBZ 37231 3672 7 find find VB 37231 3672 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3672 9 continuing continue VBG 37231 3672 10 parallel parallel NN 37231 3672 11 in in IN 37231 3672 12 the the DT 37231 3672 13 next next JJ 37231 3672 14 verse verse NN 37231 3672 15 in in IN 37231 3672 16 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3672 17 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3672 18 . . . 37231 3673 1 28 28 CD 37231 3673 2 , , , 37231 3673 3 where where WRB 37231 3673 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3673 5 have have VBP 37231 3673 6 " " `` 37231 3673 7 There there EX 37231 3673 8 shall shall MD 37231 3673 9 be be VB 37231 3673 10 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3673 11 the the DT 37231 3673 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3673 13 weeping weeping NN 37231 3673 14 and and CC 37231 3673 15 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3673 16 the the DT 37231 3673 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3673 18 gnashing gnashing NN 37231 3673 19 of of IN 37231 3673 20 teeth tooth NNS 37231 3673 21 when when WRB 37231 3673 22 ye ye NNP 37231 3673 23 shall shall MD 37231 3673 24 see see VB 37231 3673 25 Abraham Abraham NNP 37231 3673 26 , , , 37231 3673 27 " " '' 37231 3673 28 & & CC 37231 3673 29 c c NNP 37231 3673 30 There there EX 37231 3673 31 is be VBZ 37231 3673 32 here here RB 37231 3673 33 , , , 37231 3673 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3673 35 is be VBZ 37231 3673 36 evident evident JJ 37231 3673 37 , , , 37231 3673 38 the the DT 37231 3673 39 connection connection NN 37231 3673 40 of of IN 37231 3673 41 ideas idea NNS 37231 3673 42 which which WDT 37231 3673 43 is be VBZ 37231 3673 44 totally totally RB 37231 3673 45 lacking lack VBG 37231 3673 46 in in IN 37231 3673 47 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3673 48 . . . 37231 3674 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3674 2 . . . 37231 3675 1 42 42 CD 37231 3675 2 , , , 37231 3675 3 43 43 CD 37231 3675 4 , , , 37231 3675 5 where where WRB 37231 3675 6 the the DT 37231 3675 7 verses verse NNS 37231 3675 8 in in IN 37231 3675 9 question question NN 37231 3675 10 occur occur VBP 37231 3675 11 as as IN 37231 3675 12 the the DT 37231 3675 13 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3675 14 to to IN 37231 3675 15 the the DT 37231 3675 16 exposition exposition NN 37231 3675 17 of of IN 37231 3675 18 the the DT 37231 3675 19 Parable Parable NNP 37231 3675 20 of of IN 37231 3675 21 the the DT 37231 3675 22 Tares tare NNS 37231 3675 23 . . . 37231 3676 1 Now now RB 37231 3676 2 , , , 37231 3676 3 although although IN 37231 3676 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3676 5 is be VBZ 37231 3676 6 manifest manifest NN 37231 3676 7 that that IN 37231 3676 8 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3676 9 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3676 10 . . . 37231 3677 1 28 28 CD 37231 3677 2 , , , 37231 3677 3 can can MD 37231 3677 4 not not RB 37231 3677 5 possibly possibly RB 37231 3677 6 have have VB 37231 3677 7 been be VBN 37231 3677 8 the the DT 37231 3677 9 source source NN 37231 3677 10 from from IN 37231 3677 11 which which WDT 37231 3677 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3677 13 quotes quote NNS 37231 3677 14 , , , 37231 3677 15 still still RB 37231 3677 16 the the DT 37231 3677 17 opening open VBG 37231 3677 18 words word NNS 37231 3677 19 and and CC 37231 3677 20 the the DT 37231 3677 21 sequence sequence NN 37231 3677 22 of of IN 37231 3677 23 ideas idea NNS 37231 3677 24 demonstrate demonstrate VBP 37231 3677 25 the the DT 37231 3677 26 great great JJ 37231 3677 27 probability probability NN 37231 3677 28 that that IN 37231 3677 29 other other JJ 37231 3677 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3677 31 must must MD 37231 3677 32 have have VB 37231 3677 33 given give VBN 37231 3677 34 , , , 37231 3677 35 after after IN 37231 3677 36 k k NNP 37231 3677 37 4 4 CD 37231 3677 38 , , , 37231 3677 39 a a DT 37231 3677 40 continuation continuation NN 37231 3677 41 which which WDT 37231 3677 42 is be VBZ 37231 3677 43 wanting want VBG 37231 3677 44 after after IN 37231 3677 45 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3677 46 . . . 37231 3678 1 vii vii NN 37231 3678 2 . . . 37231 3679 1 23 23 CD 37231 3679 2 , , , 37231 3679 3 but but CC 37231 3679 4 which which WDT 37231 3679 5 is be VBZ 37231 3679 6 indicated indicate VBN 37231 3679 7 in in IN 37231 3679 8 the the DT 37231 3679 9 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3679 10 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3679 11 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3679 12 . . . 37231 3680 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3680 2 26 26 CD 37231 3680 3 , , , 37231 3680 4 27 27 CD 37231 3680 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3680 6 28 28 CD 37231 3680 7 , , , 37231 3680 8 and and CC 37231 3680 9 is be VBZ 37231 3680 10 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 3680 11 closely closely RB 37231 3680 12 followed follow VBN 37231 3680 13 in in IN 37231 3680 14 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3680 15 . . . 37231 3681 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3681 2 . . . 37231 3682 1 42 42 CD 37231 3682 2 , , , 37231 3682 3 43 43 CD 37231 3682 4 . . . 37231 3683 1 When when WRB 37231 3683 2 such such PDT 37231 3683 3 a a DT 37231 3683 4 sequence sequence NN 37231 3683 5 is be VBZ 37231 3683 6 found find VBN 37231 3683 7 in in IN 37231 3683 8 an an DT 37231 3683 9 avowed avow VBN 37231 3683 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 3683 11 from from IN 37231 3683 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3683 13 's 's POS 37231 3683 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3683 15 , , , 37231 3683 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3683 17 is be VBZ 37231 3683 18 certain certain JJ 37231 3683 19 that that IN 37231 3683 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3683 21 must must MD 37231 3683 22 have have VB 37231 3683 23 found find VBN 37231 3683 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3683 25 there there RB 37231 3683 26 substantially substantially RB 37231 3683 27 as as IN 37231 3683 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3683 29 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3683 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3683 31 . . . 37231 3684 1 The the DT 37231 3684 2 passage passage NN 37231 3684 3 k k NN 37231 3684 4 6,(2 6,(2 CD 37231 3684 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3684 6 " " '' 37231 3684 7 For for IN 37231 3684 8 many many JJ 37231 3684 9 shall shall MD 37231 3684 10 arrive arrive VB 37231 3684 11 , , , 37231 3684 12 " " '' 37231 3684 13 & & CC 37231 3684 14 c c NNP 37231 3684 15 , , , 37231 3684 16 is be VBZ 37231 3684 17 a a DT 37231 3684 18 very very RB 37231 3684 19 important important JJ 37231 3684 20 one one NN 37231 3684 21 , , , 37231 3684 22 and and CC 37231 3684 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3684 24 departs depart VBZ 37231 3684 25 { { -LRB- 37231 3684 26 380 380 CD 37231 3684 27 } } -RRB- 37231 3684 28 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 3684 29 from from IN 37231 3684 30 the the DT 37231 3684 31 parallel parallel NN 37231 3684 32 in in IN 37231 3684 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3684 34 first first JJ 37231 3684 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3684 36 . . . 37231 3685 1 Instead instead RB 37231 3685 2 of of IN 37231 3685 3 being be VBG 37231 3685 4 , , , 37231 3685 5 like like IN 37231 3685 6 the the DT 37231 3685 7 latter latter JJ 37231 3685 8 , , , 37231 3685 9 a a DT 37231 3685 10 warning warning NN 37231 3685 11 against against IN 37231 3685 12 false false JJ 37231 3685 13 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3685 14 , , , 37231 3685 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3685 16 is be VBZ 37231 3685 17 merely merely RB 37231 3685 18 the the DT 37231 3685 19 announcement announcement NN 37231 3685 20 that that IN 37231 3685 21 many many JJ 37231 3685 22 deceivers deceiver NNS 37231 3685 23 shall shall MD 37231 3685 24 come come VB 37231 3685 25 . . . 37231 3686 1 This this DT 37231 3686 2 passage passage NN 37231 3686 3 is be VBZ 37231 3686 4 rendered render VBN 37231 3686 5 more more RBR 37231 3686 6 weighty weighty JJ 37231 3686 7 by by IN 37231 3686 8 the the DT 37231 3686 9 fact fact NN 37231 3686 10 that that IN 37231 3686 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3686 12 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 3686 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3686 14 with with IN 37231 3686 15 little little JJ 37231 3686 16 variation variation NN 37231 3686 17 in in IN 37231 3686 18 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3686 19 . . . 37231 3687 1 35 35 CD 37231 3687 2 , , , 37231 3687 3 and and CC 37231 3687 4 immediately immediately RB 37231 3687 5 after after IN 37231 3687 6 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3687 7 a a DT 37231 3687 8 saying saying NN 37231 3687 9 of of IN 37231 3687 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3687 11 of of IN 37231 3687 12 only only RB 37231 3687 13 five five CD 37231 3687 14 words word NNS 37231 3687 15 which which WDT 37231 3687 16 is be VBZ 37231 3687 17 not not RB 37231 3687 18 found find VBN 37231 3687 19 in in IN 37231 3687 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3687 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3687 22 , , , 37231 3687 23 and and CC 37231 3687 24 then then RB 37231 3687 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3687 26 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 3687 27 a a DT 37231 3687 28 quotation quotation NN 37231 3687 29 to to IN 37231 3687 30 the the DT 37231 3687 31 same same JJ 37231 3687 32 effect effect NN 37231 3687 33 in in IN 37231 3687 34 the the DT 37231 3687 35 shape shape NN 37231 3687 36 of of IN 37231 3687 37 a a DT 37231 3687 38 warning warning NN 37231 3687 39 : : : 37231 3687 40 " " `` 37231 3687 41 Beware beware VB 37231 3687 42 of of IN 37231 3687 43 false false JJ 37231 3687 44 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3687 45 , , , 37231 3687 46 " " '' 37231 3687 47 & & CC 37231 3687 48 c c NNP 37231 3687 49 , , , 37231 3687 50 like like IN 37231 3687 51 that that DT 37231 3687 52 in in IN 37231 3687 53 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3687 54 . . . 37231 3688 1 vii vii NN 37231 3688 2 . . . 37231 3689 1 15 15 CD 37231 3689 2 , , , 37231 3689 3 but but CC 37231 3689 4 still still RB 37231 3689 5 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3689 6 differing differ VBG 37231 3689 7 from from IN 37231 3689 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3689 9 . . . 37231 3690 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3690 2 1 1 LS 37231 3690 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3690 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3690 5 is be VBZ 37231 3690 6 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 3690 7 clear clear JJ 37231 3690 8 that that IN 37231 3690 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3690 10 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3690 11 two two CD 37231 3690 12 separate separate JJ 37231 3690 13 passages passage NNS 37231 3690 14 . . . 37231 3691 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3691 2 2 2 LS 37231 3691 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3691 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3691 5 is be VBZ 37231 3691 6 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3691 7 that that IN 37231 3691 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3691 9 could could MD 37231 3691 10 intend intend VB 37231 3691 11 to to TO 37231 3691 12 repeat repeat VB 37231 3691 13 the the DT 37231 3691 14 same same JJ 37231 3691 15 quotation quotation NN 37231 3691 16 at at IN 37231 3691 17 an an DT 37231 3691 18 interval interval NN 37231 3691 19 of of IN 37231 3691 20 only only RB 37231 3691 21 five five CD 37231 3691 22 words word NNS 37231 3691 23 ; ; : 37231 3691 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3691 25 is be VBZ 37231 3691 26 equally equally RB 37231 3691 27 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3691 28 that that IN 37231 3691 29 , , , 37231 3691 30 having have VBG 37231 3691 31 quoted quote VBN 37231 3691 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3691 33 in in IN 37231 3691 34 the the DT 37231 3691 35 one one CD 37231 3691 36 form form NN 37231 3691 37 , , , 37231 3691 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3691 39 could could MD 37231 3691 40 so so RB 37231 3691 41 immediately immediately RB 37231 3691 42 quote quote VB 37231 3691 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3691 44 in in IN 37231 3691 45 the the DT 37231 3691 46 other other JJ 37231 3691 47 through through IN 37231 3691 48 error error NN 37231 3691 49 of of IN 37231 3691 50 memory memory NN 37231 3691 51 . . . 37231 3692 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3692 2 3 3 LS 37231 3692 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3692 4 The the DT 37231 3692 5 simple simple JJ 37231 3692 6 and and CC 37231 3692 7 very very RB 37231 3692 8 natural natural JJ 37231 3692 9 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3692 10 is be VBZ 37231 3692 11 that that IN 37231 3692 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3692 13 found find VBD 37231 3692 14 both both DT 37231 3692 15 passages passage NNS 37231 3692 16 in in IN 37231 3692 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3692 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3692 19 . . . 37231 3693 1 The the DT 37231 3693 2 object object NN 37231 3693 3 for for IN 37231 3693 4 which which WDT 37231 3693 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3693 6 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3693 7 would would MD 37231 3693 8 more more RBR 37231 3693 9 than than IN 37231 3693 10 justify justify VB 37231 3693 11 the the DT 37231 3693 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3693 13 of of IN 37231 3693 14 both both DT 37231 3693 15 passages passage NNS 37231 3693 16 , , , 37231 3693 17 the the DT 37231 3693 18 one one NN 37231 3693 19 referring refer VBG 37231 3693 20 to to IN 37231 3693 21 the the DT 37231 3693 22 many many JJ 37231 3693 23 false false JJ 37231 3693 24 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 3693 25 and and CC 37231 3693 26 the the DT 37231 3693 27 other other JJ 37231 3693 28 to to IN 37231 3693 29 the the DT 37231 3693 30 false false JJ 37231 3693 31 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3693 32 of of IN 37231 3693 33 whom whom WP 37231 3693 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3693 35 is be VBZ 37231 3693 36 speaking speak VBG 37231 3693 37 . . . 37231 3694 1 That that IN 37231 3694 2 two two CD 37231 3694 3 passages passage NNS 37231 3694 4 so so RB 37231 3694 5 closely closely RB 37231 3694 6 related related JJ 37231 3694 7 should should MD 37231 3694 8 be be VB 37231 3694 9 found find VBN 37231 3694 10 in in IN 37231 3694 11 the the DT 37231 3694 12 same same JJ 37231 3694 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3694 14 is be VBZ 37231 3694 15 not not RB 37231 3694 16 in in IN 37231 3694 17 the the DT 37231 3694 18 least least JJS 37231 3694 19 singular singular JJ 37231 3694 20 . . . 37231 3695 1 There there EX 37231 3695 2 are be VBP 37231 3695 3 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3695 4 instances instance NNS 37231 3695 5 of of IN 37231 3695 6 the the DT 37231 3695 7 same same JJ 37231 3695 8 in in IN 37231 3695 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3695 10 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3695 11 . . . 37231 3696 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3696 2 4 4 LS 37231 3696 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3696 4 The the DT 37231 3696 5 actual actual JJ 37231 3696 6 facts fact NNS 37231 3696 7 of of IN 37231 3696 8 the the DT 37231 3696 9 case case NN 37231 3696 10 then then RB 37231 3696 11 are be VBP 37231 3696 12 these these DT 37231 3696 13 : : : 37231 3696 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3696 15 quotes quote NNS 37231 3696 16 in in IN 37231 3696 17 the the DT 37231 3696 18 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3696 19 , , , 37231 3696 20 with with IN 37231 3696 21 the the DT 37231 3696 22 same same JJ 37231 3696 23 marked marked JJ 37231 3696 24 deviations deviation NNS 37231 3696 25 from from IN 37231 3696 26 the the DT 37231 3696 27 { { -LRB- 37231 3696 28 381 381 CD 37231 3696 29 } } -RRB- 37231 3696 30 parallel parallel NN 37231 3696 31 in in IN 37231 3696 32 the the DT 37231 3696 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3696 34 , , , 37231 3696 35 a a DT 37231 3696 36 passage passage NN 37231 3696 37 quoted quote VBN 37231 3696 38 by by IN 37231 3696 39 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3696 40 m m NNP 37231 3696 41 the the DT 37231 3696 42 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3696 43 , , , 37231 3696 44 and and CC 37231 3696 45 after after IN 37231 3696 46 an an DT 37231 3696 47 interval interval NN 37231 3696 48 of of IN 37231 3696 49 only only RB 37231 3696 50 five five CD 37231 3696 51 words word NNS 37231 3696 52 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3696 53 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3696 54 a a DT 37231 3696 55 second second JJ 37231 3696 56 passage passage NN 37231 3696 57 to to IN 37231 3696 58 the the DT 37231 3696 59 same same JJ 37231 3696 60 effect effect NN 37231 3696 61 , , , 37231 3696 62 though though RB 37231 3696 63 with with IN 37231 3696 64 very very RB 37231 3696 65 palpable palpable JJ 37231 3696 66 difference difference NN 37231 3696 67 in in IN 37231 3696 68 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3696 69 character character NN 37231 3696 70 , , , 37231 3696 71 which which WDT 37231 3696 72 likewise likewise RB 37231 3696 73 differs differ VBZ 37231 3696 74 from from IN 37231 3696 75 the the DT 37231 3696 76 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3696 77 , , , 37231 3696 78 in in IN 37231 3696 79 company company NN 37231 3696 80 with with IN 37231 3696 81 other other JJ 37231 3696 82 texts text NNS 37231 3696 83 which which WDT 37231 3696 84 still still RB 37231 3696 85 less less RBR 37231 3696 86 find find VBP 37231 3696 87 any any DT 37231 3696 88 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3696 89 in in IN 37231 3696 90 the the DT 37231 3696 91 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3696 92 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3696 93 . . . 37231 3697 1 The the DT 37231 3697 2 two two CD 37231 3697 3 passages passage NNS 37231 3697 4 , , , 37231 3697 5 by by IN 37231 3697 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3697 7 differences difference NNS 37231 3697 8 , , , 37231 3697 9 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 3697 10 each each DT 37231 3697 11 other other JJ 37231 3697 12 as as IN 37231 3697 13 separate separate JJ 37231 3697 14 , , , 37231 3697 15 whilst whilst RB 37231 3697 16 , , , 37231 3697 17 by by IN 37231 3697 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3697 19 agreement agreement NN 37231 3697 20 in in IN 37231 3697 21 common common JJ 37231 3697 22 variations variation NNS 37231 3697 23 from from IN 37231 3697 24 the the DT 37231 3697 25 parallel parallel NN 37231 3697 26 in in IN 37231 3697 27 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3697 28 , , , 37231 3697 29 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3697 30 declare declare VBP 37231 3697 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3697 32 common common JJ 37231 3697 33 origin origin NN 37231 3697 34 from from IN 37231 3697 35 a a DT 37231 3697 36 special special JJ 37231 3697 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3697 38 , , , 37231 3697 39 a a DT 37231 3697 40 result result NN 37231 3697 41 still still RB 37231 3697 42 further further RB 37231 3697 43 made make VBN 37231 3697 44 manifest manifest NN 37231 3697 45 by by IN 37231 3697 46 the the DT 37231 3697 47 agreement agreement NN 37231 3697 48 between between IN 37231 3697 49 the the DT 37231 3697 50 first first JJ 37231 3697 51 passage passage NN 37231 3697 52 in in IN 37231 3697 53 the the DT 37231 3697 54 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3697 55 and and CC 37231 3697 56 the the DT 37231 3697 57 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3697 58 in in IN 37231 3697 59 the the DT 37231 3697 60 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3697 61 . . . 37231 3698 1 In in IN 37231 3698 2 k k NNP 37231 3698 3 7,(1 7,(1 CD 37231 3698 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3698 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3698 6 's 's POS 37231 3698 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3698 8 substitutes substitute VBZ 37231 3698 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3698 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3698 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3698 12 for for IN 37231 3698 13 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3698 14 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3698 15 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3698 16 , , , 37231 3698 17 and and CC 37231 3698 18 is be VBZ 37231 3698 19 quite quite RB 37231 3698 20 in in IN 37231 3698 21 the the DT 37231 3698 22 spirit spirit NN 37231 3698 23 of of IN 37231 3698 24 the the DT 37231 3698 25 passage passage NN 37231 3698 26 O o UH 37231 3698 27 , , , 37231 3698 28 " " '' 37231 3698 29 Ye Ye NNP 37231 3698 30 shall shall MD 37231 3698 31 know know VB 37231 3698 32 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3698 33 from from IN 37231 3698 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3698 35 _ _ NNP 37231 3698 36 works work NNS 37231 3698 37 _ _ NNP 37231 3698 38 " " `` 37231 3698 39 is be VBZ 37231 3698 40 the the DT 37231 3698 41 natural natural JJ 37231 3698 42 reading reading NN 37231 3698 43 . . . 37231 3699 1 The the DT 37231 3699 2 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3699 3 version version NN 37231 3699 4 clearly clearly RB 37231 3699 5 introduces introduce VBZ 37231 3699 6 " " `` 37231 3699 7 fruit fruit NN 37231 3699 8 " " '' 37231 3699 9 prematurely prematurely RB 37231 3699 10 , , , 37231 3699 11 and and CC 37231 3699 12 weakens weaken VBZ 37231 3699 13 the the DT 37231 3699 14 force force NN 37231 3699 15 of of IN 37231 3699 16 the the DT 37231 3699 17 contrast contrast NN 37231 3699 18 which which WDT 37231 3699 19 follows follow VBZ 37231 3699 20 . . . 37231 3700 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3700 2 will will MD 37231 3700 3 be be VB 37231 3700 4 observed observe VBN 37231 3700 5 , , , 37231 3700 6 moreover moreover RB 37231 3700 7 , , , 37231 3700 8 that that IN 37231 3700 9 in in IN 37231 3700 10 order order NN 37231 3700 11 to to TO 37231 3700 12 find find VB 37231 3700 13 a a DT 37231 3700 14 parallel parallel NN 37231 3700 15 to to IN 37231 3700 16 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3700 17 's 's POS 37231 3700 18 passage passage NN 37231 3700 19 k k NNP 37231 3700 20 7 7 CD 37231 3700 21 , , , 37231 3700 22 8 8 CD 37231 3700 23 , , , 37231 3700 24 only only RB 37231 3700 25 the the DT 37231 3700 26 first first JJ 37231 3700 27 part part NN 37231 3700 28 of of IN 37231 3700 29 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3700 30 . . . 37231 3701 1 vii vii NN 37231 3701 2 . . . 37231 3702 1 16 16 CD 37231 3702 2 , , , 37231 3702 3 is be VBZ 37231 3702 4 taken take VBN 37231 3702 5 , , , 37231 3702 6 and and CC 37231 3702 7 the the DT 37231 3702 8 thread thread NN 37231 3702 9 is be VBZ 37231 3702 10 only only RB 37231 3702 11 caught catch VBN 37231 3702 12 again again RB 37231 3702 13 at at IN 37231 3702 14 vii vii NN 37231 3702 15 . . . 37231 3703 1 19 19 CD 37231 3703 2 , , , 37231 3703 3 k k NNP 37231 3703 4 8 8 CD 37231 3703 5 being be VBG 37231 3703 6 one one CD 37231 3703 7 of of IN 37231 3703 8 the the DT 37231 3703 9 two two CD 37231 3703 10 passages passage NNS 37231 3703 11 indicated indicate VBN 37231 3703 12 by by IN 37231 3703 13 de de NNP 37231 3703 14 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3703 15 which which WDT 37231 3703 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3703 17 are be VBP 37231 3703 18 considering consider VBG 37231 3703 19 , , , 37231 3703 20 and and CC 37231 3703 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3703 22 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3703 23 with with IN 37231 3703 24 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3703 25 . . . 37231 3704 1 vii vii NN 37231 3704 2 . . . 37231 3705 1 19 19 CD 37231 3705 2 , , , 37231 3705 3 with with IN 37231 3705 4 the the DT 37231 3705 5 exception exception NN 37231 3705 6 of of IN 37231 3705 7 the the DT 37231 3705 8 single single JJ 37231 3705 9 word word NN 37231 3705 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3705 11 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3705 12 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3705 13 . . . 37231 3706 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3706 2 must must MD 37231 3706 3 again again RB 37231 3706 4 point point VB 37231 3706 5 out out RP 37231 3706 6 , , , 37231 3706 7 however however RB 37231 3706 8 , , , 37231 3706 9 that that IN 37231 3706 10 this this DT 37231 3706 11 passage passage NN 37231 3706 12 in in IN 37231 3706 13 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3706 14 . . . 37231 3707 1 vii vii NN 37231 3707 2 . . . 37231 3708 1 19 19 CD 37231 3708 2 , , , 37231 3708 3 is be VBZ 37231 3708 4 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3708 5 no no RB 37231 3708 6 less less JJR 37231 3708 7 than than IN 37231 3708 8 three three CD 37231 3708 9 times time NNS 37231 3708 10 in in IN 37231 3708 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3708 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3708 13 , , , 37231 3708 14 a a DT 37231 3708 15 second second JJ 37231 3708 16 time time NN 37231 3708 17 in in IN 37231 3708 18 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3708 19 iii iii NNP 37231 3708 20 . . . 37231 3709 1 10 10 CD 37231 3709 2 , , , 37231 3709 3 and and CC 37231 3709 4 once once RB 37231 3709 5 in in IN 37231 3709 6 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3709 7 iii iii NNP 37231 3709 8 . . . 37231 3710 1 19 19 CD 37231 3710 2 . . . 37231 3711 1 Upon upon IN 37231 3711 2 two two CD 37231 3711 3 occasions occasion NNS 37231 3711 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3711 5 is be VBZ 37231 3711 6 placed place VBN 37231 3711 7 in in IN 37231 3711 8 the the DT 37231 3711 9 mouth mouth NN 37231 3711 10 of of IN 37231 3711 11 John John NNP 37231 3711 12 the the DT 37231 3711 13 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 3711 14 , , , 37231 3711 15 and and CC 37231 3711 16 forms form VBZ 37231 3711 17 the the DT 37231 3711 18 second second JJ 37231 3711 19 portion portion NN 37231 3711 20 of of IN 37231 3711 21 a a DT 37231 3711 22 sentence sentence NN 37231 3711 23 the the DT 37231 3711 24 whole whole NN 37231 3711 25 of of IN 37231 3711 26 which which WDT 37231 3711 27 is be VBZ 37231 3711 28 found find VBN 37231 3711 29 in in IN 37231 3711 30 literal literal JJ 37231 3711 31 agreement agreement NN 37231 3711 32 both both DT 37231 3711 33 in in IN 37231 3711 34 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3711 35 . . . 37231 3712 1 iii iii NNP 37231 3712 2 . . . 37231 3713 1 10 10 CD 37231 3713 2 , , , 37231 3713 3 and and CC 37231 3713 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3713 5 iii iii NNP 37231 3713 6 . . . 37231 3714 1 9 9 CD 37231 3714 2 , , , 37231 3714 3 " " `` 37231 3714 4 But but CC 37231 3714 5 now now RB 37231 3714 6 the the DT 37231 3714 7 axe axe NN 37231 3714 8 is be VBZ 37231 3714 9 laid lay VBN 37231 3714 10 unto unto IN 37231 3714 11 the the DT 37231 3714 12 root root NN 37231 3714 13 of of IN 37231 3714 14 the the DT 37231 3714 15 trees tree NNS 37231 3714 16 , , , 37231 3714 17 therefore therefore RB 37231 3714 18 every every DT 37231 3714 19 tree tree NN 37231 3714 20 , , , 37231 3714 21 " " '' 37231 3714 22 & & CC 37231 3714 23 c c NNP 37231 3714 24 , , , 37231 3714 25 & & CC 37231 3714 26 c. c. NNP 37231 3714 27 { { -LRB- 37231 3714 28 382 382 CD 37231 3714 29 } } -RRB- 37231 3714 30 The the DT 37231 3714 31 passage passage NN 37231 3714 32 pointed point VBD 37231 3714 33 out out RP 37231 3714 34 by by IN 37231 3714 35 de de NNP 37231 3714 36 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3714 37 as as IN 37231 3714 38 the the DT 37231 3714 39 parallel parallel NN 37231 3714 40 to to IN 37231 3714 41 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3714 42 's 's POS 37231 3714 43 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 3714 44 quotation quotation NN 37231 3714 45 , , , 37231 3714 46 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3714 47 . . . 37231 3715 1 vii vii NN 37231 3715 2 . . . 37231 3716 1 19 19 CD 37231 3716 2 - - HYPH 37231 3716 3 -a -a NN 37231 3716 4 selection selection NN 37231 3716 5 which which WDT 37231 3716 6 is be VBZ 37231 3716 7 of of IN 37231 3716 8 course course NN 37231 3716 9 obligatory obligatory NN 37231 3716 10 from from IN 37231 3716 11 the the DT 37231 3716 12 context context NN 37231 3716 13 -- -- : 37231 3716 14 is be VBZ 37231 3716 15 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 3716 16 a a DT 37231 3716 17 mere mere JJ 37231 3716 18 quotation quotation NN 37231 3716 19 by by IN 37231 3716 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3716 21 of of IN 37231 3716 22 part part NN 37231 3716 23 of of IN 37231 3716 24 the the DT 37231 3716 25 saying saying NN 37231 3716 26 of of IN 37231 3716 27 the the DT 37231 3716 28 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 3716 29 , , , 37231 3716 30 presenting present VBG 37231 3716 31 , , , 37231 3716 32 therefore therefore RB 37231 3716 33 , , , 37231 3716 34 double double JJ 37231 3716 35 probability probability NN 37231 3716 36 of of IN 37231 3716 37 being be VBG 37231 3716 38 well well RB 37231 3716 39 known known JJ 37231 3716 40 ; ; : 37231 3716 41 and and CC 37231 3716 42 as as IN 37231 3716 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3716 44 have have VBP 37231 3716 45 three three CD 37231 3716 46 instances instance NNS 37231 3716 47 of of IN 37231 3716 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3716 49 literal literal JJ 37231 3716 50 reproduction reproduction NN 37231 3716 51 in in IN 37231 3716 52 the the DT 37231 3716 53 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3716 54 , , , 37231 3716 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3716 56 would would MD 37231 3716 57 indeed indeed RB 37231 3716 58 be be VB 37231 3716 59 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 3716 60 to to TO 37231 3716 61 affirm affirm VB 37231 3716 62 that that IN 37231 3716 63 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3716 64 was be VBD 37231 3716 65 not not RB 37231 3716 66 likewise likewise RB 37231 3716 67 given give VBN 37231 3716 68 literally literally RB 37231 3716 69 in in IN 37231 3716 70 other other JJ 37231 3716 71 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3716 72 . . . 37231 3717 1 The the DT 37231 3717 2 passage passage NN 37231 3717 3 X(1 X(1 NNPS 37231 3717 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3717 5 is be VBZ 37231 3717 6 very very RB 37231 3717 7 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 3717 8 given give VBN 37231 3717 9 as as IN 37231 3717 10 a a DT 37231 3717 11 literal literal JJ 37231 3717 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3717 13 of of IN 37231 3717 14 the the DT 37231 3717 15 words word NNS 37231 3717 16 of of IN 37231 3717 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3717 18 , , , 37231 3717 19 for for IN 37231 3717 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3717 21 cites cite VBZ 37231 3717 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 23 directly directly RB 37231 3717 24 to to TO 37231 3717 25 authenticate authenticate VB 37231 3717 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3717 27 own own JJ 37231 3717 28 statements statement NNS 37231 3717 29 of of IN 37231 3717 30 Christian christian JJ 37231 3717 31 belief belief NN 37231 3717 32 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 33 says say VBZ 37231 3717 34 : : : 37231 3717 35 " " `` 37231 3717 36 But but CC 37231 3717 37 if if IN 37231 3717 38 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 39 disregard disregard VBP 37231 3717 40 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 41 both both CC 37231 3717 42 when when WRB 37231 3717 43 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 44 entreat entreat VBP 37231 3717 45 , , , 37231 3717 46 and and CC 37231 3717 47 when when WRB 37231 3717 48 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 49 set set VBP 37231 3717 50 all all DT 37231 3717 51 things thing NNS 37231 3717 52 openly openly RB 37231 3717 53 before before IN 37231 3717 54 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 55 , , , 37231 3717 56 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 57 shall shall MD 37231 3717 58 not not RB 37231 3717 59 suffer suffer VB 37231 3717 60 loss loss NN 37231 3717 61 , , , 37231 3717 62 believing believe VBG 37231 3717 63 , , , 37231 3717 64 or or CC 37231 3717 65 rather rather RB 37231 3717 66 being be VBG 37231 3717 67 fully fully RB 37231 3717 68 persuaded persuade VBN 37231 3717 69 , , , 37231 3717 70 that that IN 37231 3717 71 every every DT 37231 3717 72 one one NN 37231 3717 73 will will MD 37231 3717 74 be be VB 37231 3717 75 punished punish VBN 37231 3717 76 by by IN 37231 3717 77 eternal eternal JJ 37231 3717 78 fire fire NN 37231 3717 79 according accord VBG 37231 3717 80 to to IN 37231 3717 81 the the DT 37231 3717 82 desert desert NN 37231 3717 83 of of IN 37231 3717 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3717 85 deeds deed NNS 37231 3717 86 , , , 37231 3717 87 and and CC 37231 3717 88 in in IN 37231 3717 89 proportion proportion NN 37231 3717 90 to to IN 37231 3717 91 the the DT 37231 3717 92 faculties faculty NNS 37231 3717 93 which which WDT 37231 3717 94 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 95 received receive VBD 37231 3717 96 from from IN 37231 3717 97 God God NNP 37231 3717 98 will will MD 37231 3717 99 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3717 100 account account NN 37231 3717 101 be be VB 37231 3717 102 required require VBN 37231 3717 103 , , , 37231 3717 104 as as IN 37231 3717 105 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3717 106 declared declare VBD 37231 3717 107 when when WRB 37231 3717 108 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 109 said say VBD 37231 3717 110 : : : 37231 3717 111 To to TO 37231 3717 112 whom whom WP 37231 3717 113 God God NNP 37231 3717 114 gave give VBD 37231 3717 115 more more JJR 37231 3717 116 , , , 37231 3717 117 of of IN 37231 3717 118 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3717 119 shall shall MD 37231 3717 120 more more RBR 37231 3717 121 also also RB 37231 3717 122 be be VB 37231 3717 123 demanded demand VBN 37231 3717 124 again again RB 37231 3717 125 . . . 37231 3717 126 " " '' 37231 3718 1 This this DT 37231 3718 2 quotation quotation NN 37231 3718 3 has have VBZ 37231 3718 4 no no DT 37231 3718 5 parallel parallel NN 37231 3718 6 in in IN 37231 3718 7 the the DT 37231 3718 8 first first JJ 37231 3718 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3718 10 , , , 37231 3718 11 but but CC 37231 3718 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3718 13 add add VBP 37231 3718 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3718 15 here here RB 37231 3718 16 as as IN 37231 3718 17 part part NN 37231 3718 18 of of IN 37231 3718 19 the the DT 37231 3718 20 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3718 21 on on IN 37231 3718 22 the the DT 37231 3718 23 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3718 24 . . . 37231 3719 1 The the DT 37231 3719 2 passage passage NN 37231 3719 3 in in IN 37231 3719 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3719 5 xii xii NNP 37231 3719 6 . . . 37231 3720 1 48 48 CD 37231 3720 2 , , , 37231 3720 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3720 4 will will MD 37231 3720 5 be be VB 37231 3720 6 perceived perceive VBN 37231 3720 7 , , , 37231 3720 8 presents present VBZ 37231 3720 9 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3720 10 variation variation NN 37231 3720 11 from from IN 37231 3720 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3720 13 , , , 37231 3720 14 and and CC 37231 3720 15 that that IN 37231 3720 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3720 17 can can MD 37231 3720 18 not not RB 37231 3720 19 for for IN 37231 3720 20 a a DT 37231 3720 21 moment moment NN 37231 3720 22 be be VB 37231 3720 23 maintained maintain VBN 37231 3720 24 as as IN 37231 3720 25 the the DT 37231 3720 26 source source NN 37231 3720 27 of of IN 37231 3720 28 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3720 29 's 's POS 37231 3720 30 quotation quotation NN 37231 3720 31 . . . 37231 3721 1 The the DT 37231 3721 2 last last JJ 37231 3721 3 passage passage NN 37231 3721 4 , , , 37231 3721 5 ft,2 ft,2 : 37231 3721 6 is be VBZ 37231 3721 7 one one CD 37231 3721 8 of of IN 37231 3721 9 those those DT 37231 3721 10 advanced advance VBN 37231 3721 11 by by IN 37231 3721 12 de de NNP 37231 3721 13 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3721 14 which which WDT 37231 3721 15 led lead VBD 37231 3721 16 to to IN 37231 3721 17 this this DT 37231 3721 18 examination examination NN 37231 3721 19 . . . 37231 3722 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3722 2 3 3 LS 37231 3722 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3722 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3722 5 is be VBZ 37231 3722 6 likewise likewise RB 37231 3722 7 clearly clearly RB 37231 3722 8 a a DT 37231 3722 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 3722 10 , , , 37231 3722 11 but but CC 37231 3722 12 as as IN 37231 3722 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3722 14 have have VBP 37231 3722 15 already already RB 37231 3722 16 shown show VBN 37231 3722 17 , , , 37231 3722 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3722 19 agreement agreement NN 37231 3722 20 with with IN 37231 3722 21 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3722 22 v. v. CC 37231 3722 23 20 20 CD 37231 3722 24 , , , 37231 3722 25 is be VBZ 37231 3722 26 no no DT 37231 3722 27 evidence evidence NN 37231 3722 28 that that IN 37231 3722 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3722 30 was be VBD 37231 3722 31 actually actually RB 37231 3722 32 derived derive VBN 37231 3722 33 from from IN 37231 3722 34 that that DT 37231 3722 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3722 36 . . . 37231 3723 1 Occurring occur VBG 37231 3723 2 as as IN 37231 3723 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3723 4 does do VBZ 37231 3723 5 as as IN 37231 3723 6 one one CD 37231 3723 7 of of IN 37231 3723 8 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3723 9 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3723 10 from from IN 37231 3723 11 the the DT 37231 3723 12 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3723 13 on on IN 37231 3723 14 the the DT 37231 3723 15 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3723 16 , , , 37231 3723 17 whose whose WP$ 37231 3723 18 general general JJ 37231 3723 19 variation variation NN 37231 3723 20 both both CC 37231 3723 21 in in IN 37231 3723 22 order order NN 37231 3723 23 and and CC 37231 3723 24 { { -LRB- 37231 3723 25 383 383 CD 37231 3723 26 } } -RRB- 37231 3723 27 language language NN 37231 3723 28 from from IN 37231 3723 29 the the DT 37231 3723 30 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3723 31 in in IN 37231 3723 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3723 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3723 34 points point NNS 37231 3723 35 to to IN 37231 3723 36 the the DT 37231 3723 37 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 3723 38 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3723 39 that that IN 37231 3723 40 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3723 41 derived derive VBD 37231 3723 42 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3723 43 from from IN 37231 3723 44 a a DT 37231 3723 45 different different JJ 37231 3723 46 source source NN 37231 3723 47 , , , 37231 3723 48 there there EX 37231 3723 49 is be VBZ 37231 3723 50 no no DT 37231 3723 51 reason reason NN 37231 3723 52 for for IN 37231 3723 53 supposing suppose VBG 37231 3723 54 that that IN 37231 3723 55 this this DT 37231 3723 56 sentence sentence NN 37231 3723 57 also also RB 37231 3723 58 did do VBD 37231 3723 59 not not RB 37231 3723 60 come come VB 37231 3723 61 from from IN 37231 3723 62 the the DT 37231 3723 63 same same JJ 37231 3723 64 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3723 65 . . . 37231 3724 1 No no DT 37231 3724 2 one one NN 37231 3724 3 who who WP 37231 3724 4 has have VBZ 37231 3724 5 attentively attentively RB 37231 3724 6 considered consider VBN 37231 3724 7 the the DT 37231 3724 8 whole whole NN 37231 3724 9 of of IN 37231 3724 10 these these DT 37231 3724 11 passages passage NNS 37231 3724 12 from from IN 37231 3724 13 the the DT 37231 3724 14 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3724 15 on on IN 37231 3724 16 the the DT 37231 3724 17 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3724 18 , , , 37231 3724 19 and and CC 37231 3724 20 still still RB 37231 3724 21 less less RBR 37231 3724 22 those those DT 37231 3724 23 who who WP 37231 3724 24 are be VBP 37231 3724 25 aware aware JJ 37231 3724 26 of of IN 37231 3724 27 the the DT 37231 3724 28 general general JJ 37231 3724 29 rule rule NN 37231 3724 30 of of IN 37231 3724 31 variation variation NN 37231 3724 32 in in IN 37231 3724 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3724 34 mass mass NN 37231 3724 35 of of IN 37231 3724 36 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3724 37 as as IN 37231 3724 38 compared compare VBN 37231 3724 39 with with IN 37231 3724 40 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3724 41 in in IN 37231 3724 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3724 43 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3724 44 , , , 37231 3724 45 can can MD 37231 3724 46 fail fail VB 37231 3724 47 to to TO 37231 3724 48 be be VB 37231 3724 49 struck strike VBN 37231 3724 50 by by IN 37231 3724 51 the the DT 37231 3724 52 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3724 53 departure departure NN 37231 3724 54 from from IN 37231 3724 55 the the DT 37231 3724 56 order order NN 37231 3724 57 and and CC 37231 3724 58 language language NN 37231 3724 59 of of IN 37231 3724 60 the the DT 37231 3724 61 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3724 62 . . . 37231 3725 1 The the DT 37231 3725 2 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 3725 3 that that IN 37231 3725 4 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3725 5 are be VBP 37231 3725 6 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3725 7 from from IN 37231 3725 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3725 9 Gospels Gospels NNP 37231 3725 10 involves involve VBZ 37231 3725 11 the the DT 37231 3725 12 accusation accusation NN 37231 3725 13 against against IN 37231 3725 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3725 15 of of IN 37231 3725 16 an an DT 37231 3725 17 amount amount NN 37231 3725 18 of of IN 37231 3725 19 carelessness carelessness NN 37231 3725 20 and and CC 37231 3725 21 negligence negligence NN 37231 3725 22 which which WDT 37231 3725 23 is be VBZ 37231 3725 24 quite quite RB 37231 3725 25 unparalleled unparalleled JJ 37231 3725 26 in in IN 37231 3725 27 literature literature NN 37231 3725 28 . . . 37231 3726 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3726 2 's 's POS 37231 3726 3 character character NN 37231 3726 4 and and CC 37231 3726 5 training training NN 37231 3726 6 , , , 37231 3726 7 however however RB 37231 3726 8 , , , 37231 3726 9 by by IN 37231 3726 10 . . . 37231 3727 1 no no DT 37231 3727 2 means mean NNS 37231 3727 3 warrant warrant VBP 37231 3727 4 any any DT 37231 3727 5 such such JJ 37231 3727 6 aspersion,(1 aspersion,(1 JJ 37231 3727 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3727 8 and and CC 37231 3727 9 there there EX 37231 3727 10 are be VBP 37231 3727 11 no no DT 37231 3727 12 grounds ground NNS 37231 3727 13 for for IN 37231 3727 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3727 15 . . . 37231 3728 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 3728 2 , , , 37231 3728 3 but but CC 37231 3728 4 for for IN 37231 3728 5 the the DT 37231 3728 6 attempt attempt NN 37231 3728 7 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 37231 3728 8 to to TO 37231 3728 9 establish establish VB 37231 3728 10 the the DT 37231 3728 11 identity identity NN 37231 3728 12 of of IN 37231 3728 13 the the DT 37231 3728 14 " " `` 37231 3728 15 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3728 16 of of IN 37231 3728 17 the the DT 37231 3728 18 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3728 19 " " '' 37231 3728 20 with with IN 37231 3728 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3728 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3728 23 , , , 37231 3728 24 such such PDT 37231 3728 25 a a DT 37231 3728 26 charge charge NN 37231 3728 27 would would MD 37231 3728 28 never never RB 37231 3728 29 have have VB 37231 3728 30 been be VBN 37231 3728 31 thought think VBN 37231 3728 32 of of IN 37231 3728 33 . . . 37231 3729 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3729 2 is be VBZ 37231 3729 3 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 3729 4 to to TO 37231 3729 5 suppose suppose VB 37231 3729 6 that that IN 37231 3729 7 avowed avowed JJ 37231 3729 8 and and CC 37231 3729 9 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 3729 10 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3729 11 of of IN 37231 3729 12 sayings saying NNS 37231 3729 13 of of IN 37231 3729 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3729 15 , , , 37231 3729 16 made make VBN 37231 3729 17 for for IN 37231 3729 18 the the DT 37231 3729 19 express express JJ 37231 3729 20 purpose purpose NN 37231 3729 21 of of IN 37231 3729 22 furnishing furnish VBG 37231 3729 23 authentic authentic JJ 37231 3729 24 written write VBN 37231 3729 25 proof proof NN 37231 3729 26 of of IN 37231 3729 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3729 28 's 's POS 37231 3729 29 statements statement NNS 37231 3729 30 regarding regard VBG 37231 3729 31 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 3729 32 , , , 37231 3729 33 can can MD 37231 3729 34 as as IN 37231 3729 35 an an DT 37231 3729 36 almost almost RB 37231 3729 37 invariable invariable JJ 37231 3729 38 rule rule NN 37231 3729 39 be be VB 37231 3729 40 so so RB 37231 3729 41 singularly singularly RB 37231 3729 42 incorrect incorrect JJ 37231 3729 43 , , , 37231 3729 44 more more RBR 37231 3729 45 especially especially RB 37231 3729 46 when when WRB 37231 3729 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3729 48 is be VBZ 37231 3729 49 considered consider VBN 37231 3729 50 that that IN 37231 3729 51 these these DT 37231 3729 52 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3729 53 occur occur VBP 37231 3729 54 in in IN 37231 3729 55 an an DT 37231 3729 56 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 3729 57 apology apology NN 37231 3729 58 for for IN 37231 3729 59 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 3729 60 addressed address VBD 37231 3729 61 to to IN 37231 3729 62 the the DT 37231 3729 63 Roman roman JJ 37231 3729 64 emperors emperor NNS 37231 3729 65 , , , 37231 3729 66 and and CC 37231 3729 67 in in IN 37231 3729 68 a a DT 37231 3729 69 careful careful JJ 37231 3729 70 and and CC 37231 3729 71 studied studied JJ 37231 3729 72 controversy controversy NN 37231 3729 73 with with IN 37231 3729 74 a a DT 37231 3729 75 Jew Jew NNP 37231 3729 76 in in IN 37231 3729 77 defence defence NN 37231 3729 78 of of IN 37231 3729 79 the the DT 37231 3729 80 new new JJ 37231 3729 81 faith faith NN 37231 3729 82 . . . 37231 3730 1 The the DT 37231 3730 2 simple simple JJ 37231 3730 3 and and CC 37231 3730 4 natural natural JJ 37231 3730 5 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3730 6 , , , 37231 3730 7 supported support VBN 37231 3730 8 by by IN 37231 3730 9 many many JJ 37231 3730 10 strong strong JJ 37231 3730 11 reasons reason NNS 37231 3730 12 , , , 37231 3730 13 is be VBZ 37231 3730 14 that that IN 37231 3730 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3730 16 derived derive VBD 37231 3730 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3730 18 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3730 19 from from IN 37231 3730 20 a a DT 37231 3730 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3730 22 which which WDT 37231 3730 23 was be VBD 37231 3730 24 different different JJ 37231 3730 25 from from IN 37231 3730 26 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 3730 27 , , , 37231 3730 28 although although IN 37231 3730 29 naturally naturally RB 37231 3730 30 by by IN 37231 3730 31 subject subject NN 37231 3730 32 and and CC 37231 3730 33 design design NN 37231 3730 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3730 35 must must MD 37231 3730 36 have have VB 37231 3730 37 been be VBN 37231 3730 38 related relate VBN 37231 3730 39 to to IN 37231 3730 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3730 41 . . . 37231 3731 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3731 2 { { -LRB- 37231 3731 3 384 384 CD 37231 3731 4 } } -RRB- 37231 3731 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3731 6 , , , 37231 3731 7 in in IN 37231 3731 8 fact fact NN 37231 3731 9 , , , 37231 3731 10 differs differ NNS 37231 3731 11 from from IN 37231 3731 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3731 13 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3731 14 as as IN 37231 3731 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3731 16 differ differ VBP 37231 3731 17 from from IN 37231 3731 18 each each DT 37231 3731 19 other other JJ 37231 3731 20 . . . 37231 3732 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3732 2 now now RB 37231 3732 3 return return VBP 37231 3732 4 to to IN 37231 3732 5 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3732 6 's 's POS 37231 3732 7 statements statement NNS 37231 3732 8 with with IN 37231 3732 9 regard regard NN 37231 3732 10 to to IN 37231 3732 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3732 12 's 's POS 37231 3732 13 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 3732 14 with with IN 37231 3732 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3732 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3732 17 . . . 37231 3733 1 Having have VBG 37231 3733 2 examined examine VBN 37231 3733 3 the the DT 37231 3733 4 supposed suppose VBN 37231 3733 5 references reference NNS 37231 3733 6 to to IN 37231 3733 7 the the DT 37231 3733 8 first first JJ 37231 3733 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3733 10 , , , 37231 3733 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3733 12 find find VBP 37231 3733 13 that that IN 37231 3733 14 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3733 15 speaks speak VBZ 37231 3733 16 much much RB 37231 3733 17 less less RBR 37231 3733 18 positively positively RB 37231 3733 19 with with IN 37231 3733 20 regard regard NN 37231 3733 21 to to IN 37231 3733 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3733 23 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 3733 24 of of IN 37231 3733 25 the the DT 37231 3733 26 other other JJ 37231 3733 27 two two CD 37231 3733 28 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3733 29 . . . 37231 3734 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3734 2 says say VBZ 37231 3734 3 : : : 37231 3734 4 " " `` 37231 3734 5 There there EX 37231 3734 6 is be VBZ 37231 3734 7 the the DT 37231 3734 8 greatest great JJS 37231 3734 9 probability probability NN 37231 3734 10 that that IN 37231 3734 11 in in IN 37231 3734 12 several several JJ 37231 3734 13 passages passage NNS 37231 3734 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3734 15 also also RB 37231 3734 16 follows follow VBZ 37231 3734 17 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3734 18 and and CC 37231 3734 19 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3734 20 . . . 37231 3735 1 " " `` 37231 3735 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3735 3 1 1 LS 37231 3735 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3735 5 First first RB 37231 3735 6 taking take VBG 37231 3735 7 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3735 8 , , , 37231 3735 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3735 10 find find VBP 37231 3735 11 that that IN 37231 3735 12 the the DT 37231 3735 13 only only JJ 37231 3735 14 example example NN 37231 3735 15 which which WDT 37231 3735 16 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3735 17 gives give VBZ 37231 3735 18 is be VBZ 37231 3735 19 the the DT 37231 3735 20 following follow VBG 37231 3735 21 . . . 37231 3736 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3736 2 says say VBZ 37231 3736 3 : : : 37231 3736 4 " " `` 37231 3736 5 Twice twice RB 37231 3736 6 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3736 7 Dial dial NN 37231 3736 8 . . . 37231 3737 1 76 76 CD 37231 3737 2 and and CC 37231 3737 3 100 100 CD 37231 3737 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3737 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3737 6 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3737 7 as as IN 37231 3737 8 an an DT 37231 3737 9 expression expression NN 37231 3737 10 of of IN 37231 3737 11 the the DT 37231 3737 12 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3737 13 : : : 37231 3737 14 ' ' '' 37231 3737 15 The the DT 37231 3737 16 Son Son NNP 37231 3737 17 of of IN 37231 3737 18 Man Man NNP 37231 3737 19 must must MD 37231 3737 20 suffer suffer VB 37231 3737 21 many many JJ 37231 3737 22 things thing NNS 37231 3737 23 , , , 37231 3737 24 and and CC 37231 3737 25 be be VB 37231 3737 26 rejected reject VBN 37231 3737 27 by by IN 37231 3737 28 the the DT 37231 3737 29 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3737 30 and and CC 37231 3737 31 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3737 32 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3737 33 Ch Ch NNP 37231 3737 34 . . . 37231 3738 1 100 100 CD 37231 3738 2 by by IN 37231 3738 3 the the DT 37231 3738 4 ' ' `` 37231 3738 5 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3738 6 and and CC 37231 3738 7 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3738 8 ' ' POS 37231 3738 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3738 10 , , , 37231 3738 11 and and CC 37231 3738 12 be be VB 37231 3738 13 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3738 14 and and CC 37231 3738 15 the the DT 37231 3738 16 third third JJ 37231 3738 17 day day NN 37231 3738 18 rise rise VB 37231 3738 19 again again RB 37231 3738 20 . . . 37231 3739 1 ' ' `` 37231 3739 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3739 3 2 2 LS 37231 3739 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3739 5 This this DT 37231 3739 6 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3739 7 better well JJR 37231 3739 8 with with IN 37231 3739 9 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3739 10 viii viii NNP 37231 3739 11 . . . 37231 3740 1 31 31 CD 37231 3740 2 and and CC 37231 3740 3 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3740 4 ix ix NNP 37231 3740 5 . . . 37231 3741 1 22 22 CD 37231 3741 2 than than IN 37231 3741 3 with with IN 37231 3741 4 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3741 5 . . . 37231 3742 1 xvi xvi NNP 37231 3742 2 . . . 37231 3743 1 21 21 CD 37231 3743 2 , , , 37231 3743 3 only only RB 37231 3743 4 in in IN 37231 3743 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3743 6 the the DT 37231 3743 7 ' ' `` 37231 3743 8 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3743 9 ' ' '' 37231 3743 10 are be VBP 37231 3743 11 put put VBN 37231 3743 12 instead instead RB 37231 3743 13 of of IN 37231 3743 14 the the DT 37231 3743 15 ' ' '' 37231 3743 16 Elders Elders NNPS 37231 3743 17 and and CC 37231 3743 18 Chief Chief NNP 37231 3743 19 Priests Priests NNP 37231 3743 20 ' ' POS 37231 3743 21 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3743 22 so so RB 37231 3743 23 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3743 24 , , , 37231 3743 25 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3743 26 , , , 37231 3743 27 and and CC 37231 3743 28 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3743 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3743 30 , , , 37231 3743 31 likewise likewise RB 37231 3743 32 ' ' '' 37231 3743 33 be be VB 37231 3743 34 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3743 35 ' ' '' 37231 3743 36 instead instead RB 37231 3743 37 of of IN 37231 3743 38 ' ' '' 37231 3743 39 be be VB 37231 3743 40 killed kill VBN 37231 3743 41 . . . 37231 3744 1 " " `` 37231 3744 2 ' ' `` 37231 3744 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3744 4 3 3 LS 37231 3744 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3744 6 This this DT 37231 3744 7 is be VBZ 37231 3744 8 the the DT 37231 3744 9 only only JJ 37231 3744 10 instance instance NN 37231 3744 11 of of IN 37231 3744 12 similarity similarity NN 37231 3744 13 with with IN 37231 3744 14 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3744 15 that that IN 37231 3744 16 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3744 17 can can MD 37231 3744 18 produce produce VB 37231 3744 19 , , , 37231 3744 20 and and CC 37231 3744 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3744 22 have have VBP 37231 3744 23 given give VBN 37231 3744 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3744 25 own own JJ 37231 3744 26 remarks remark NNS 37231 3744 27 to to TO 37231 3744 28 show show VB 37231 3744 29 how how WRB 37231 3744 30 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 3744 31 weak weak JJ 37231 3744 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3744 33 case case NN 37231 3744 34 is be VBZ 37231 3744 35 . . . 37231 3745 1 The the DT 37231 3745 2 passage passage NN 37231 3745 3 in in IN 37231 3745 4 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3745 5 viii viii NNP 37231 3745 6 . . . 37231 3746 1 31 31 CD 37231 3746 2 , , , 37231 3746 3 reads read VBZ 37231 3746 4 : : : 37231 3746 5 " " `` 37231 3746 6 And and CC 37231 3746 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3746 8 began begin VBD 37231 3746 9 to to TO 37231 3746 10 teach teach VB 37231 3746 11 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3746 12 that that IN 37231 3746 13 the the DT 37231 3746 14 Son Son NNP 37231 3746 15 of of IN 37231 3746 16 Man Man NNP 37231 3746 17 must must MD 37231 3746 18 suffer suffer VB 37231 3746 19 many many JJ 37231 3746 20 things thing NNS 37231 3746 21 , , , 37231 3746 22 and and CC 37231 3746 23 be be VB 37231 3746 24 rejected reject VBN 37231 3746 25 by by IN 37231 3746 26 the the DT 37231 3746 27 Elders Elders NNPS 37231 3746 28 and and CC 37231 3746 29 the the DT 37231 3746 30 Chief Chief NNP 37231 3746 31 Priests Priests NNP 37231 3746 32 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3746 33 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3746 34 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3746 35 , , , 37231 3746 36 and and CC 37231 3746 37 the the DT 37231 3746 38 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3746 39 and and CC 37231 3746 40 be be VB 37231 3746 41 killed kill VBN 37231 3746 42 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3746 43 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3746 44 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3746 45 , , , 37231 3746 46 and and CC 37231 3746 47 after after IN 37231 3746 48 three three CD 37231 3746 49 days day NNS 37231 3746 50 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3746 51 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3746 52 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3746 53 { { -LRB- 37231 3746 54 385 385 CD 37231 3746 55 } } -RRB- 37231 3746 56 rise rise VBP 37231 3746 57 again again RB 37231 3746 58 . . . 37231 3746 59 " " '' 37231 3747 1 And and CC 37231 3747 2 the the DT 37231 3747 3 following follow VBG 37231 3747 4 is be VBZ 37231 3747 5 the the DT 37231 3747 6 reading reading NN 37231 3747 7 of of IN 37231 3747 8 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3747 9 ix ix NNP 37231 3747 10 . . . 37231 3748 1 22 22 CD 37231 3748 2 : : : 37231 3748 3 " " `` 37231 3748 4 Saying say VBG 37231 3748 5 that that IN 37231 3748 6 the the DT 37231 3748 7 Son Son NNP 37231 3748 8 of of IN 37231 3748 9 Man Man NNP 37231 3748 10 must must MD 37231 3748 11 suffer suffer VB 37231 3748 12 many many JJ 37231 3748 13 things thing NNS 37231 3748 14 , , , 37231 3748 15 and and CC 37231 3748 16 be be VB 37231 3748 17 rejected reject VBN 37231 3748 18 by by IN 37231 3748 19 the the DT 37231 3748 20 Elders Elders NNPS 37231 3748 21 and and CC 37231 3748 22 Chief Chief NNP 37231 3748 23 Priests Priests NNP 37231 3748 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3748 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3748 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3748 27 and and CC 37231 3748 28 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3748 29 and and CC 37231 3748 30 be be VB 37231 3748 31 killed kill VBN 37231 3748 32 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3748 33 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3748 34 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3748 35 , , , 37231 3748 36 and and CC 37231 3748 37 the the DT 37231 3748 38 third third JJ 37231 3748 39 day day NN 37231 3748 40 rise rise VB 37231 3748 41 again again RB 37231 3748 42 . . . 37231 3748 43 " " '' 37231 3749 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3749 2 will will MD 37231 3749 3 be be VB 37231 3749 4 perceived perceive VBN 37231 3749 5 that that IN 37231 3749 6 , , , 37231 3749 7 different different JJ 37231 3749 8 as as IN 37231 3749 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3749 10 also also RB 37231 3749 11 is be VBZ 37231 3749 12 , , , 37231 3749 13 the the DT 37231 3749 14 passage passage NN 37231 3749 15 in in IN 37231 3749 16 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3749 17 is be VBZ 37231 3749 18 nearer near JJR 37231 3749 19 than than IN 37231 3749 20 that that DT 37231 3749 21 of of IN 37231 3749 22 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3749 23 , , , 37231 3749 24 which which WDT 37231 3749 25 can can MD 37231 3749 26 not not RB 37231 3749 27 in in IN 37231 3749 28 any any DT 37231 3749 29 case case NN 37231 3749 30 have have VBP 37231 3749 31 been be VBN 37231 3749 32 the the DT 37231 3749 33 source source NN 37231 3749 34 of of IN 37231 3749 35 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3749 36 's 's POS 37231 3749 37 quotation quotation NN 37231 3749 38 . . . 37231 3750 1 Tischendorf tischendorf NN 37231 3750 2 , , , 37231 3750 3 however however RB 37231 3750 4 , , , 37231 3750 5 does do VBZ 37231 3750 6 not not RB 37231 3750 7 point point VB 37231 3750 8 out out RP 37231 3750 9 that that IN 37231 3750 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3750 11 , , , 37231 3750 12 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3750 13 , , , 37231 3750 14 a a DT 37231 3750 15 third third JJ 37231 3750 16 time time NN 37231 3750 17 refers refer VBZ 37231 3750 18 to to IN 37231 3750 19 this this DT 37231 3750 20 very very JJ 37231 3750 21 passage passage NN 37231 3750 22 in in IN 37231 3750 23 the the DT 37231 3750 24 very very RB 37231 3750 25 same same JJ 37231 3750 26 terms term NNS 37231 3750 27 . . . 37231 3751 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3751 2 says say VBZ 37231 3751 3 : : : 37231 3751 4 " " `` 37231 3751 5 And and CC 37231 3751 6 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3751 7 .... .... NFP 37231 3751 8 having have VBG 37231 3751 9 come come VBN 37231 3751 10 .... .... NFP 37231 3751 11 and and CC 37231 3751 12 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3751 13 also also RB 37231 3751 14 preached preach VBD 37231 3751 15 , , , 37231 3751 16 saying say VBG 37231 3751 17 .... .... NFP 37231 3751 18 that that IN 37231 3751 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3751 20 must must MD 37231 3751 21 suffer suffer VB 37231 3751 22 many many JJ 37231 3751 23 things thing NNS 37231 3751 24 from from IN 37231 3751 25 the the DT 37231 3751 26 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 3751 27 and and CC 37231 3751 28 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 3751 29 and and CC 37231 3751 30 be be VB 37231 3751 31 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3751 32 , , , 37231 3751 33 and and CC 37231 3751 34 the the DT 37231 3751 35 third third JJ 37231 3751 36 day day NN 37231 3751 37 rise rise VB 37231 3751 38 again again RB 37231 3751 39 . . . 37231 3752 1 " " `` 37231 3752 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3752 3 l l NN 37231 3752 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3752 5 Although although IN 37231 3752 6 this this DT 37231 3752 7 omits omit VBZ 37231 3752 8 the the DT 37231 3752 9 words word NNS 37231 3752 10 " " '' 37231 3752 11 and and CC 37231 3752 12 be be VB 37231 3752 13 rejected reject VBN 37231 3752 14 , , , 37231 3752 15 " " '' 37231 3752 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3752 17 gives give VBZ 37231 3752 18 the the DT 37231 3752 19 whole whole NN 37231 3752 20 of of IN 37231 3752 21 the the DT 37231 3752 22 passage passage NN 37231 3752 23 literally literally RB 37231 3752 24 as as IN 37231 3752 25 before before RB 37231 3752 26 . . . 37231 3753 1 And and CC 37231 3753 2 thus thus RB 37231 3753 3 there there EX 37231 3753 4 is be VBZ 37231 3753 5 the the DT 37231 3753 6 very very RB 37231 3753 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3753 8 testimony testimony NN 37231 3753 9 of of IN 37231 3753 10 a a DT 37231 3753 11 quotation quotation NN 37231 3753 12 three three CD 37231 3753 13 times time NNS 37231 3753 14 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3753 15 , , , 37231 3753 16 with with IN 37231 3753 17 the the DT 37231 3753 18 same same JJ 37231 3753 19 marked marked JJ 37231 3753 20 variations variation NNS 37231 3753 21 from from IN 37231 3753 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3753 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3753 24 , , , 37231 3753 25 to to TO 37231 3753 26 show show VB 37231 3753 27 that that IN 37231 3753 28 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3753 29 found find VBD 37231 3753 30 those those DT 37231 3753 31 very very JJ 37231 3753 32 words word NNS 37231 3753 33 in in IN 37231 3753 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3753 35 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3753 36 . . . 37231 3754 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3754 2 2 2 LS 37231 3754 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3754 4 The the DT 37231 3754 5 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3754 6 variation variation NN 37231 3754 7 clearly clearly RB 37231 3754 8 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 3754 9 a a DT 37231 3754 10 different different JJ 37231 3754 11 source source NN 37231 3754 12 from from IN 37231 3754 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3754 14 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3754 15 . . . 37231 3755 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3755 2 may may MD 37231 3755 3 , , , 37231 3755 4 in in IN 37231 3755 5 reference reference NN 37231 3755 6 to to IN 37231 3755 7 this this DT 37231 3755 8 reading reading NN 37231 3755 9 , , , 37231 3755 10 compare compare VB 37231 3755 11 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3755 12 xxiv xxiv NNP 37231 3755 13 . . . 37231 3756 1 6 6 CD 37231 3756 2 : : : 37231 3756 3 " " `` 37231 3756 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3756 5 is be VBZ 37231 3756 6 not not RB 37231 3756 7 here here RB 37231 3756 8 , , , 37231 3756 9 but but CC 37231 3756 10 is be VBZ 37231 3756 11 risen rise VBN 37231 3756 12 : : : 37231 3756 13 remember remember VB 37231 3756 14 how how WRB 37231 3756 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3756 16 spake spake VBD 37231 3756 17 unto unto IN 37231 3756 18 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3756 19 when when WRB 37231 3756 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3756 21 was be VBD 37231 3756 22 yet yet RB 37231 3756 23 in in IN 37231 3756 24 Galilee Galilee NNP 37231 3756 25 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3756 26 v. v. CC 37231 3756 27 7 7 CD 37231 3756 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3756 29 , , , 37231 3756 30 saying say VBG 37231 3756 31 that that IN 37231 3756 32 the the DT 37231 3756 33 Son Son NNP 37231 3756 34 of of IN 37231 3756 35 Man Man NNP 37231 3756 36 must must MD 37231 3756 37 be be VB 37231 3756 38 delivered deliver VBN 37231 3756 39 up up RP 37231 3756 40 into into IN 37231 3756 41 the the DT 37231 3756 42 hands hand NNS 37231 3756 43 of of IN 37231 3756 44 sinful sinful JJ 37231 3756 45 men man NNS 37231 3756 46 , , , 37231 3756 47 _ _ NNP 37231 3756 48 and and CC 37231 3756 49 be be VB 37231 3756 50 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3756 51 _ _ NNP 37231 3756 52 , , , 37231 3756 53 and and CC 37231 3756 54 the the DT 37231 3756 55 third third JJ 37231 3756 56 day day NN 37231 3756 57 rise rise VB 37231 3756 58 again again RB 37231 3756 59 . . . 37231 3756 60 " " '' 37231 3757 1 This this DT 37231 3757 2 reference reference NN 37231 3757 3 to to IN 37231 3757 4 words word NNS 37231 3757 5 of of IN 37231 3757 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3757 7 , , , 37231 3757 8 in in IN 37231 3757 9 which which WDT 37231 3757 10 the the DT 37231 3757 11 words word NNS 37231 3757 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3757 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3757 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3757 15 . . . 37231 3758 1 occurred occur VBD 37231 3758 2 , , , 37231 3758 3 as as IN 37231 3758 4 in in IN 37231 3758 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3758 6 , , , 37231 3758 7 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 3758 8 that that IN 37231 3758 9 although although IN 37231 3758 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3758 11 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3758 12 do do VBP 37231 3758 13 not not RB 37231 3758 14 contain contain VB 37231 3758 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3758 16 some some DT 37231 3758 17 others other NNS 37231 3758 18 may may MD 37231 3758 19 well well RB 37231 3758 20 have have VB 37231 3758 21 { { -LRB- 37231 3758 22 386 386 CD 37231 3758 23 } } -RRB- 37231 3758 24 done do VBN 37231 3758 25 so so RB 37231 3758 26 . . . 37231 3759 1 In in IN 37231 3759 2 one one CD 37231 3759 3 place place NN 37231 3759 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3759 5 introduces introduce VBZ 37231 3759 6 the the DT 37231 3759 7 saying saying NN 37231 3759 8 with with IN 37231 3759 9 the the DT 37231 3759 10 following follow VBG 37231 3759 11 words word NNS 37231 3759 12 : : : 37231 3759 13 " " `` 37231 3759 14 For for IN 37231 3759 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3759 16 exclaimed exclaim VBD 37231 3759 17 before before IN 37231 3759 18 the the DT 37231 3759 19 crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 3759 20 , , , 37231 3759 21 the the DT 37231 3759 22 Son Son NNP 37231 3759 23 of of IN 37231 3759 24 Man Man NNP 37231 3759 25 , , , 37231 3759 26 " " '' 37231 3759 27 & & CC 37231 3759 28 c c NNP 37231 3759 29 . . . 37231 3759 30 ,(1 ,(1 , 37231 3759 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3759 32 both both DT 37231 3759 33 indicating indicate VBG 37231 3759 34 a a DT 37231 3759 35 time time NN 37231 3759 36 for for IN 37231 3759 37 the the DT 37231 3759 38 discourse discourse NN 37231 3759 39 , , , 37231 3759 40 and and CC 37231 3759 41 also also RB 37231 3759 42 quoting quote VBG 37231 3759 43 a a DT 37231 3759 44 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3759 45 and and CC 37231 3759 46 definite definite JJ 37231 3759 47 saying say VBG 37231 3759 48 in in IN 37231 3759 49 contradistinction contradistinction NN 37231 3759 50 to to IN 37231 3759 51 this this DT 37231 3759 52 report report NN 37231 3759 53 of of IN 37231 3759 54 the the DT 37231 3759 55 matter matter NN 37231 3759 56 of of IN 37231 3759 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3759 58 teaching teaching NN 37231 3759 59 , , , 37231 3759 60 which which WDT 37231 3759 61 is be VBZ 37231 3759 62 the the DT 37231 3759 63 form form NN 37231 3759 64 in in IN 37231 3759 65 which which WDT 37231 3759 66 the the DT 37231 3759 67 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3759 68 passage passage NN 37231 3759 69 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3759 70 in in IN 37231 3759 71 the the DT 37231 3759 72 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3759 73 . . . 37231 3760 1 In in IN 37231 3760 2 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3760 3 's 's POS 37231 3760 4 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3760 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3760 6 no no RB 37231 3760 7 doubt doubt RB 37231 3760 8 existed exist VBD 37231 3760 9 as as IN 37231 3760 10 an an DT 37231 3760 11 actual actual JJ 37231 3760 12 discourse discourse NN 37231 3760 13 of of IN 37231 3760 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3760 15 , , , 37231 3760 16 which which WDT 37231 3760 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3760 18 verbally verbally RB 37231 3760 19 and and CC 37231 3760 20 accurately accurately RB 37231 3760 21 quoted quote VBN 37231 3760 22 . . . 37231 3761 1 With with IN 37231 3761 2 regard regard NN 37231 3761 3 to to IN 37231 3761 4 the the DT 37231 3761 5 third third JJ 37231 3761 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3761 7 , , , 37231 3761 8 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3761 9 says say VBZ 37231 3761 10 : : : 37231 3761 11 " " `` 37231 3761 12 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3761 13 is be VBZ 37231 3761 14 in in IN 37231 3761 15 reference reference NN 37231 3761 16 to to IN 37231 3761 17 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3761 18 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3761 19 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3761 20 . . . 37231 3762 1 44 44 CD 37231 3762 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3762 3 that that IN 37231 3762 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3762 5 recalls recall VBZ 37231 3762 6 in in IN 37231 3762 7 the the DT 37231 3762 8 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3762 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3762 10 103 103 CD 37231 3762 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3762 12 the the DT 37231 3762 13 falling fall VBG 37231 3762 14 drops drop NNS 37231 3762 15 of of IN 37231 3762 16 the the DT 37231 3762 17 sweat sweat NN 37231 3762 18 of of IN 37231 3762 19 agony agony NNP 37231 3762 20 on on IN 37231 3762 21 the the DT 37231 3762 22 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3762 23 of of IN 37231 3762 24 Olives Olives NNPS 37231 3762 25 , , , 37231 3762 26 and and CC 37231 3762 27 certainly certainly RB 37231 3762 28 with with IN 37231 3762 29 an an DT 37231 3762 30 express express JJ 37231 3762 31 appeal appeal NN 37231 3762 32 to to IN 37231 3762 33 the the DT 37231 3762 34 ' ' `` 37231 3762 35 Memoirs memoir NNS 37231 3762 36 composed compose VBN 37231 3762 37 by by IN 37231 3762 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3762 39 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3762 40 and and CC 37231 3762 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3762 42 followers,'"(2 followers,'"(2 NNS 37231 3762 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3762 44 Now now RB 37231 3762 45 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3762 46 have have VBP 37231 3762 47 already already RB 37231 3762 48 seen(3 seen(3 VBN 37231 3762 49 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3762 50 that that IN 37231 3762 51 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3762 52 , , , 37231 3762 53 in in IN 37231 3762 54 the the DT 37231 3762 55 passage passage NN 37231 3762 56 referred refer VBD 37231 3762 57 to to IN 37231 3762 58 , , , 37231 3762 59 does do VBZ 37231 3762 60 not not RB 37231 3762 61 make make VB 37231 3762 62 use use NN 37231 3762 63 of of IN 37231 3762 64 the the DT 37231 3762 65 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3762 66 expression expression NN 37231 3762 67 which which WDT 37231 3762 68 gives give VBZ 37231 3762 69 the the DT 37231 3762 70 whole whole NN 37231 3762 71 of of IN 37231 3762 72 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3762 73 character character NN 37231 3762 74 to to IN 37231 3762 75 the the DT 37231 3762 76 account account NN 37231 3762 77 in in IN 37231 3762 78 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3762 79 , , , 37231 3762 80 and and CC 37231 3762 81 that that IN 37231 3762 82 there there EX 37231 3762 83 is be VBZ 37231 3762 84 no no DT 37231 3762 85 ground ground NN 37231 3762 86 for for IN 37231 3762 87 affirming affirming NN 37231 3762 88 that that IN 37231 3762 89 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3762 90 derived derive VBD 37231 3762 91 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3762 92 information information NN 37231 3762 93 from from IN 37231 3762 94 that that DT 37231 3762 95 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3762 96 . . . 37231 3763 1 The the DT 37231 3763 2 only only JJ 37231 3763 3 other other JJ 37231 3763 4 reference reference NN 37231 3763 5 to to IN 37231 3763 6 passages passage NNS 37231 3763 7 proving prove VBG 37231 3763 8 the the DT 37231 3763 9 " " `` 37231 3763 10 probability probability NN 37231 3763 11 " " '' 37231 3763 12 of of IN 37231 3763 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3763 14 's 's POS 37231 3763 15 use use NN 37231 3763 16 of of IN 37231 3763 17 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3763 18 or or CC 37231 3763 19 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3763 20 is be VBZ 37231 3763 21 that that DT 37231 3763 22 which which WDT 37231 3763 23 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3763 24 have have VBP 37231 3763 25 just just RB 37231 3763 26 discussed--"The discussed--"The NNP 37231 3763 27 Son Son NNP 37231 3763 28 of of IN 37231 3763 29 Man Man NNP 37231 3763 30 must must MD 37231 3763 31 , , , 37231 3763 32 " " '' 37231 3763 33 & & CC 37231 3763 34 c. c. NNP 37231 3763 35 From from IN 37231 3763 36 this this DT 37231 3763 37 the the DT 37231 3763 38 character character NN 37231 3763 39 of of IN 37231 3763 40 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3763 41 's 's POS 37231 3763 42 assumptions assumption NNS 37231 3763 43 may may MD 37231 3763 44 be be VB 37231 3763 45 inferred infer VBN 37231 3763 46 . . . 37231 3764 1 De De NNP 37231 3764 2 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3764 3 does do VBZ 37231 3764 4 not not RB 37231 3764 5 advance advance VB 37231 3764 6 any any DT 37231 3764 7 instances instance NNS 37231 3764 8 of of IN 37231 3764 9 verbal verbal JJ 37231 3764 10 agreement agreement NN 37231 3764 11 either either CC 37231 3764 12 with with IN 37231 3764 13 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3764 14 or or CC 37231 3764 15 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3764 16 . . . 37231 3765 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3765 2 4 4 LS 37231 3765 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3765 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3765 5 says say VBZ 37231 3765 6 , , , 37231 3765 7 moreover moreover RB 37231 3765 8 : : : 37231 3765 9 " " `` 37231 3765 10 The the DT 37231 3765 11 historical historical JJ 37231 3765 12 references reference NNS 37231 3765 13 are be VBP 37231 3765 14 much much RB 37231 3765 15 freer free JJR 37231 3765 16 still still RB 37231 3765 17 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3765 18 than than IN 37231 3765 19 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3765 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3765 21 , , , 37231 3765 22 and and CC 37231 3765 23 combine combine VB 37231 3765 24 in in IN 37231 3765 25 part part NN 37231 3765 26 { { -LRB- 37231 3765 27 387 387 CD 37231 3765 28 } } -RRB- 37231 3765 29 the the DT 37231 3765 30 accounts account NNS 37231 3765 31 of of IN 37231 3765 32 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3765 33 and and CC 37231 3765 34 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3765 35 ; ; : 37231 3765 36 some some DT 37231 3765 37 of of IN 37231 3765 38 the the DT 37231 3765 39 kind kind NN 37231 3765 40 , , , 37231 3765 41 however however RB 37231 3765 42 , , , 37231 3765 43 are be VBP 37231 3765 44 not not RB 37231 3765 45 found find VBN 37231 3765 46 at at RB 37231 3765 47 all all RB 37231 3765 48 in in IN 37231 3765 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3765 50 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3765 51 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3765 52 . . . 37231 3766 1 " " `` 37231 3766 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3766 3 1 1 LS 37231 3766 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3766 5 This this DT 37231 3766 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3766 7 have have VBP 37231 3766 8 already already RB 37231 3766 9 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 3766 10 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 37231 3766 11 . . . 37231 3767 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3767 2 might may MD 37231 3767 3 now now RB 37231 3767 4 well well RB 37231 3767 5 terminate terminate VB 37231 3767 6 the the DT 37231 3767 7 examination examination NN 37231 3767 8 of of IN 37231 3767 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3767 10 's 's POS 37231 3767 11 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3767 12 , , , 37231 3767 13 which which WDT 37231 3767 14 has have VBZ 37231 3767 15 already already RB 37231 3767 16 taken take VBN 37231 3767 17 up up RP 37231 3767 18 too too RB 37231 3767 19 much much JJ 37231 3767 20 of of IN 37231 3767 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3767 22 space space NN 37231 3767 23 , , , 37231 3767 24 but but CC 37231 3767 25 before before IN 37231 3767 26 doing do VBG 37231 3767 27 so so RB 37231 3767 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3767 29 may may MD 37231 3767 30 be be VB 37231 3767 31 well well RB 37231 3767 32 very very RB 37231 3767 33 briefly briefly NN 37231 3767 34 to to TO 37231 3767 35 refer refer VB 37231 3767 36 to to IN 37231 3767 37 another another DT 37231 3767 38 point point NN 37231 3767 39 . . . 37231 3768 1 In in IN 37231 3768 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3768 3 work work NN 37231 3768 4 " " '' 37231 3768 5 On on IN 37231 3768 6 the the DT 37231 3768 7 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3768 8 , , , 37231 3768 9 " " '' 37231 3768 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3768 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3768 12 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 3768 13 a a DT 37231 3768 14 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 3768 15 singular singular JJ 37231 3768 16 course course NN 37231 3768 17 . . . 37231 3769 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3769 2 evidently evidently RB 37231 3769 3 feels feel VBZ 37231 3769 4 the the DT 37231 3769 5 very very RB 37231 3769 6 great great JJ 37231 3769 7 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 3769 8 in in IN 37231 3769 9 which which WDT 37231 3769 10 anyone anyone NN 37231 3769 11 who who WP 37231 3769 12 asserts assert VBZ 37231 3769 13 the the DT 37231 3769 14 identity identity NN 37231 3769 15 of of IN 37231 3769 16 the the DT 37231 3769 17 source source NN 37231 3769 18 of of IN 37231 3769 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3769 20 's 's POS 37231 3769 21 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3769 22 with with IN 37231 3769 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3769 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3769 25 is be VBZ 37231 3769 26 placed place VBN 37231 3769 27 by by IN 37231 3769 28 the the DT 37231 3769 29 fact fact NN 37231 3769 30 that that IN 37231 3769 31 , , , 37231 3769 32 as as IN 37231 3769 33 a a DT 37231 3769 34 rule rule NN 37231 3769 35 , , , 37231 3769 36 these these DT 37231 3769 37 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3769 38 differ differ VBP 37231 3769 39 from from IN 37231 3769 40 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3769 41 passages passage NNS 37231 3769 42 in in IN 37231 3769 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3769 44 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3769 45 ; ; : 37231 3769 46 and and CC 37231 3769 47 whilst whilst RB 37231 3769 48 on on IN 37231 3769 49 the the DT 37231 3769 50 one one CD 37231 3769 51 hand hand NN 37231 3769 52 maintaining maintain VBG 37231 3769 53 that that IN 37231 3769 54 the the DT 37231 3769 55 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3769 56 generally generally RB 37231 3769 57 are be VBP 37231 3769 58 from from IN 37231 3769 59 the the DT 37231 3769 60 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3769 61 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3769 62 , , , 37231 3769 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3769 64 on on IN 37231 3769 65 the the DT 37231 3769 66 other other JJ 37231 3769 67 endeavours endeavour NNS 37231 3769 68 to to TO 37231 3769 69 reduce reduce VB 37231 3769 70 the the DT 37231 3769 71 number number NN 37231 3769 72 of of IN 37231 3769 73 those those DT 37231 3769 74 which which WDT 37231 3769 75 profess profess JJ 37231 3769 76 to to TO 37231 3769 77 be be VB 37231 3769 78 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3769 79 at at RB 37231 3769 80 all all RB 37231 3769 81 . . . 37231 3770 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3770 2 says say VBZ 37231 3770 3 : : : 37231 3770 4 " " `` 37231 3770 5 To to TO 37231 3770 6 examine examine VB 37231 3770 7 in in IN 37231 3770 8 detail detail NN 37231 3770 9 the the DT 37231 3770 10 whole whole NN 37231 3770 11 of of IN 37231 3770 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3770 13 's 's POS 37231 3770 14 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3770 15 would would MD 37231 3770 16 be be VB 37231 3770 17 tedious tedious JJ 37231 3770 18 and and CC 37231 3770 19 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 37231 3770 20 . . . 37231 3771 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3771 2 will will MD 37231 3771 3 be be VB 37231 3771 4 enough enough JJ 37231 3771 5 to to TO 37231 3771 6 examine examine VB 37231 3771 7 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3771 8 1 1 LS 37231 3771 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3771 10 those those DT 37231 3771 11 which which WDT 37231 3771 12 are be VBP 37231 3771 13 alleged allege VBN 37231 3771 14 by by IN 37231 3771 15 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3771 16 as as IN 37231 3771 17 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3771 18 , , , 37231 3771 19 and and CC 37231 3771 20 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3771 21 2 2 LS 37231 3771 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3771 23 those those DT 37231 3771 24 also also RB 37231 3771 25 which which WDT 37231 3771 26 , , , 37231 3771 27 though though IN 37231 3771 28 anonymous anonymous NNP 37231 3771 29 , , , 37231 3771 30 are be VBP 37231 3771 31 yet yet RB 37231 3771 32 found find VBN 37231 3771 33 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3771 34 with with IN 37231 3771 35 the the DT 37231 3771 36 same same JJ 37231 3771 37 variations variation NNS 37231 3771 38 either either CC 37231 3771 39 in in IN 37231 3771 40 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3771 41 's 's POS 37231 3771 42 own own JJ 37231 3771 43 writings writing NNS 37231 3771 44 , , , 37231 3771 45 or or CC 37231 3771 46 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3771 47 3 3 CD 37231 3771 48 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3771 49 in in IN 37231 3771 50 heretical heretical JJ 37231 3771 51 works work NNS 37231 3771 52 . . . 37231 3772 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3772 2 is be VBZ 37231 3772 3 evidently evidently RB 37231 3772 4 on on IN 37231 3772 5 these these DT 37231 3772 6 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3772 7 that that IN 37231 3772 8 the the DT 37231 3772 9 decision decision NN 37231 3772 10 hangs hang VBZ 37231 3772 11 . . . 37231 3773 1 " " `` 37231 3773 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3773 3 2 2 LS 37231 3773 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3773 5 Now now RB 37231 3773 6 under under IN 37231 3773 7 the the DT 37231 3773 8 first first JJ 37231 3773 9 category category NN 37231 3773 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3773 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3773 12 finds find VBZ 37231 3773 13 very very RB 37231 3773 14 few few JJ 37231 3773 15 . . . 37231 3774 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3774 2 says say VBZ 37231 3774 3 : : : 37231 3774 4 " " `` 37231 3774 5 In in IN 37231 3774 6 seven seven CD 37231 3774 7 passages passage NNS 37231 3774 8 only only RB 37231 3774 9 , , , 37231 3774 10 as as RB 37231 3774 11 far far RB 37231 3774 12 as as IN 37231 3774 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3774 14 can can MD 37231 3774 15 discover discover VB 37231 3774 16 , , , 37231 3774 17 does do VBZ 37231 3774 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3774 19 profess profess JJ 37231 3774 20 to to TO 37231 3774 21 give give VB 37231 3774 22 the the DT 37231 3774 23 exact exact JJ 37231 3774 24 words word NNS 37231 3774 25 recorded record VBN 37231 3774 26 in in IN 37231 3774 27 the the DT 37231 3774 28 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3774 29 ; ; : 37231 3774 30 and and CC 37231 3774 31 in in IN 37231 3774 32 these these DT 37231 3774 33 , , , 37231 3774 34 if if IN 37231 3774 35 there there EX 37231 3774 36 be be VB 37231 3774 37 no no DT 37231 3774 38 reason reason NN 37231 3774 39 to to IN 37231 3774 40 the the DT 37231 3774 41 contrary contrary NN 37231 3774 42 , , , 37231 3774 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3774 44 is be VBZ 37231 3774 45 natural natural JJ 37231 3774 46 to to TO 37231 3774 47 expect expect VB 37231 3774 48 that that IN 37231 3774 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3774 50 will will MD 37231 3774 51 preserve preserve VB 37231 3774 52 the the DT 37231 3774 53 exact exact JJ 37231 3774 54 language language NN 37231 3774 55 of of IN 37231 3774 56 the the DT 37231 3774 57 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3774 58 which which WDT 37231 3774 59 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3774 60 used use VBD 37231 3774 61 , , , 37231 3774 62 just just RB 37231 3774 63 as as IN 37231 3774 64 in in IN 37231 3774 65 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 3774 66 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3774 67 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3774 68 may may MD 37231 3774 69 conclude conclude VB 37231 3774 70 that that IN 37231 3774 71 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3774 72 is be VBZ 37231 3774 73 trusting trust VBG 37231 3774 74 to to IN 37231 3774 75 memory memory NN 37231 3774 76 . . . 37231 3775 1 " " `` 37231 3775 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3775 3 3 3 LS 37231 3775 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3775 5 { { -LRB- 37231 3775 6 388 388 CD 37231 3775 7 } } -RRB- 37231 3775 8 Before before IN 37231 3775 9 proceeding proceed VBG 37231 3775 10 further further RB 37231 3775 11 , , , 37231 3775 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3775 13 may may MD 37231 3775 14 point point VB 37231 3775 15 out out RP 37231 3775 16 the the DT 37231 3775 17 straits strait NNS 37231 3775 18 to to TO 37231 3775 19 which which WDT 37231 3775 20 an an DT 37231 3775 21 apologist apologist NN 37231 3775 22 is be VBZ 37231 3775 23 reduced reduce VBN 37231 3775 24 who who WP 37231 3775 25 starts start VBZ 37231 3775 26 with with IN 37231 3775 27 a a DT 37231 3775 28 foregone foregone JJ 37231 3775 29 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3775 30 . . . 37231 3776 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3776 2 have have VBP 37231 3776 3 already already RB 37231 3776 4 seen see VBN 37231 3776 5 a a DT 37231 3776 6 number number NN 37231 3776 7 of of IN 37231 3776 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3776 9 's 's POS 37231 3776 10 professed professed JJ 37231 3776 11 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3776 12 ; ; : 37231 3776 13 but but CC 37231 3776 14 here here RB 37231 3776 15 , , , 37231 3776 16 after after IN 37231 3776 17 reducing reduce VBG 37231 3776 18 the the DT 37231 3776 19 number number NN 37231 3776 20 to to IN 37231 3776 21 seven seven CD 37231 3776 22 only only RB 37231 3776 23 , , , 37231 3776 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3776 25 critic critic NN 37231 3776 26 prepares prepare VBZ 37231 3776 27 a a DT 37231 3776 28 way way NN 37231 3776 29 of of IN 37231 3776 30 escape escape NN 37231 3776 31 even even RB 37231 3776 32 out out IN 37231 3776 33 of of IN 37231 3776 34 these these DT 37231 3776 35 . . . 37231 3777 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3777 2 is be VBZ 37231 3777 3 difficult difficult JJ 37231 3777 4 to to TO 37231 3777 5 understand understand VB 37231 3777 6 what what WP 37231 3777 7 " " `` 37231 3777 8 reason reason NN 37231 3777 9 to to IN 37231 3777 10 the the DT 37231 3777 11 contrary contrary NN 37231 3777 12 " " `` 37231 3777 13 can can MD 37231 3777 14 possibly possibly RB 37231 3777 15 justify justify VB 37231 3777 16 a a DT 37231 3777 17 man man NN 37231 3777 18 " " `` 37231 3777 19 who who WP 37231 3777 20 professes profess VBZ 37231 3777 21 to to TO 37231 3777 22 give give VB 37231 3777 23 the the DT 37231 3777 24 exact exact JJ 37231 3777 25 words word NNS 37231 3777 26 recorded record VBN 37231 3777 27 in in IN 37231 3777 28 the the DT 37231 3777 29 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3777 30 " " '' 37231 3777 31 for for IN 37231 3777 32 not not RB 37231 3777 33 doing do VBG 37231 3777 34 what what WP 37231 3777 35 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3777 36 professes profess VBZ 37231 3777 37 ; ; : 37231 3777 38 and and CC 37231 3777 39 further far RBR 37231 3777 40 , , , 37231 3777 41 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3777 42 passes pass VBZ 37231 3777 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3777 44 comprehension comprehension NN 37231 3777 45 to to TO 37231 3777 46 understand understand VB 37231 3777 47 why why WRB 37231 3777 48 , , , 37231 3777 49 in in IN 37231 3777 50 anonymous anonymous JJ 37231 3777 51 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3777 52 , , , 37231 3777 53 " " `` 37231 3777 54 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3777 55 may may MD 37231 3777 56 conclude conclude VB 37231 3777 57 that that IN 37231 3777 58 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3777 59 is be VBZ 37231 3777 60 trusting trust VBG 37231 3777 61 to to IN 37231 3777 62 memory memory NN 37231 3777 63 . . . 37231 3777 64 " " '' 37231 3778 1 The the DT 37231 3778 2 cautious cautious JJ 37231 3778 3 exception exception NN 37231 3778 4 is be VBZ 37231 3778 5 as as RB 37231 3778 6 untenable untenable JJ 37231 3778 7 as as IN 37231 3778 8 the the DT 37231 3778 9 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 37231 3778 10 assumption assumption NN 37231 3778 11 . . . 37231 3779 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3779 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3779 3 continues continue VBZ 37231 3779 4 as as IN 37231 3779 5 follows follow VBZ 37231 3779 6 the the DT 37231 3779 7 passage passage NN 37231 3779 8 which which WDT 37231 3779 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3779 10 have have VBP 37231 3779 11 just just RB 37231 3779 12 interrupted:--"The interrupted:--"The . 37231 3779 13 result result NN 37231 3779 14 of of IN 37231 3779 15 a a DT 37231 3779 16 first first JJ 37231 3779 17 view view NN 37231 3779 18 of of IN 37231 3779 19 the the DT 37231 3779 20 passages passage NNS 37231 3779 21 is be VBZ 37231 3779 22 striking striking JJ 37231 3779 23 . . . 37231 3780 1 Of of IN 37231 3780 2 the the DT 37231 3780 3 seven seven CD 37231 3780 4 , , , 37231 3780 5 five five CD 37231 3780 6 agree agree VBP 37231 3780 7 verbally verbally RB 37231 3780 8 with with IN 37231 3780 9 the the DT 37231 3780 10 text text NN 37231 3780 11 of of IN 37231 3780 12 St. St. NNP 37231 3780 13 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3780 14 or or CC 37231 3780 15 St. St. NNP 37231 3780 16 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3780 17 , , , 37231 3780 18 _ _ NNP 37231 3780 19 exhibiting exhibit VBG 37231 3780 20 indeed indeed RB 37231 3780 21 three three CD 37231 3780 22 slight slight JJ 37231 3780 23 various various JJ 37231 3780 24 readings reading NNS 37231 3780 25 not not RB 37231 3780 26 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3780 27 found find VBN 37231 3780 28 , , , 37231 3780 29 but but CC 37231 3780 30 such such JJ 37231 3780 31 as as IN 37231 3780 32 are be VBP 37231 3780 33 easily easily RB 37231 3780 34 explicable explicable JJ 37231 3780 35 _ _ NNP 37231 3780 36 ; ; : 37231 3780 37 the the DT 37231 3780 38 sixth sixth JJ 37231 3780 39 is be VBZ 37231 3780 40 a a DT 37231 3780 41 _ _ NNP 37231 3780 42 compound compound NN 37231 3780 43 summary summary NN 37231 3780 44 _ _ NNP 37231 3780 45 of of IN 37231 3780 46 words word NNS 37231 3780 47 related relate VBN 37231 3780 48 by by IN 37231 3780 49 St. St. NNP 37231 3780 50 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3780 51 ; ; : 37231 3780 52 the the DT 37231 3780 53 seventh seventh JJ 37231 3780 54 alone alone RB 37231 3780 55 _ _ NNP 37231 3780 56 presents present VBZ 37231 3780 57 an an DT 37231 3780 58 important important JJ 37231 3780 59 variation variation NN 37231 3780 60 in in IN 37231 3780 61 the the DT 37231 3780 62 text text NN 37231 3780 63 of of IN 37231 3780 64 a a DT 37231 3780 65 verse verse NN 37231 3780 66 _ _ NNP 37231 3780 67 , , , 37231 3780 68 which which WDT 37231 3780 69 is be VBZ 37231 3780 70 , , , 37231 3780 71 however however RB 37231 3780 72 , , , 37231 3780 73 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 3780 74 very very RB 37231 3780 75 uncertain uncertain JJ 37231 3780 76 . . . 37231 3781 1 " " `` 37231 3781 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3781 3 1 1 LS 37231 3781 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3781 5 The the DT 37231 3781 6 italics italic NNS 37231 3781 7 of of IN 37231 3781 8 course course NN 37231 3781 9 are be VBP 37231 3781 10 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 3781 11 . . . 37231 3782 1 The the DT 37231 3782 2 " " `` 37231 3782 3 first first JJ 37231 3782 4 view view NN 37231 3782 5 " " '' 37231 3782 6 of of IN 37231 3782 7 the the DT 37231 3782 8 passages passage NNS 37231 3782 9 and and CC 37231 3782 10 of of IN 37231 3782 11 the the DT 37231 3782 12 above above JJ 37231 3782 13 statement statement NN 37231 3782 14 is be VBZ 37231 3782 15 indeed indeed RB 37231 3782 16 striking striking JJ 37231 3782 17 . . . 37231 3783 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3783 2 is be VBZ 37231 3783 3 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3783 4 how how WRB 37231 3783 5 easily easily RB 37231 3783 6 difficulties difficulty NNS 37231 3783 7 are be VBP 37231 3783 8 overcome overcome VBN 37231 3783 9 under under IN 37231 3783 10 such such PDT 37231 3783 11 an an DT 37231 3783 12 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 3783 13 system system NN 37231 3783 14 . . . 37231 3784 1 The the DT 37231 3784 2 striking striking JJ 37231 3784 3 result result NN 37231 3784 4 , , , 37231 3784 5 to to TO 37231 3784 6 summarize summarize VB 37231 3784 7 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3784 8 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3784 9 's 's POS 37231 3784 10 own own JJ 37231 3784 11 words word NNS 37231 3784 12 , , , 37231 3784 13 is be VBZ 37231 3784 14 this this DT 37231 3784 15 : : : 37231 3784 16 out out IN 37231 3784 17 of of IN 37231 3784 18 seven seven CD 37231 3784 19 professed professed JJ 37231 3784 20 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3784 21 from from IN 37231 3784 22 the the DT 37231 3784 23 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3784 24 , , , 37231 3784 25 in in IN 37231 3784 26 which which WDT 37231 3784 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3784 28 admits admit VBZ 37231 3784 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3784 30 may may MD 37231 3784 31 expect expect VB 37231 3784 32 to to TO 37231 3784 33 find find VB 37231 3784 34 the the DT 37231 3784 35 exact exact JJ 37231 3784 36 language language NN 37231 3784 37 preserved preserve VBN 37231 3784 38 , , , 37231 3784 39 five five CD 37231 3784 40 present present JJ 37231 3784 41 three three CD 37231 3784 42 variations variation NNS 37231 3784 43 ; ; : 37231 3784 44 one one CD 37231 3784 45 is be VBZ 37231 3784 46 a a DT 37231 3784 47 compressed compressed JJ 37231 3784 48 summary summary NN 37231 3784 49 , , , 37231 3784 50 and and CC 37231 3784 51 does do VBZ 37231 3784 52 not not RB 37231 3784 53 agree agree VB 37231 3784 54 verbally verbally RB 37231 3784 55 at at RB 37231 3784 56 all all RB 37231 3784 57 ; ; : 37231 3784 58 and and CC 37231 3784 59 the the DT 37231 3784 60 seventh seventh JJ 37231 3784 61 presents present VBZ 37231 3784 62 an an DT 37231 3784 63 important important JJ 37231 3784 64 variation variation NN 37231 3784 65 . . . 37231 3785 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3785 2 { { -LRB- 37231 3785 3 389 389 CD 37231 3785 4 } } -RRB- 37231 3785 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3785 6 , , , 37231 3785 7 on on IN 37231 3785 8 the the DT 37231 3785 9 same same JJ 37231 3785 10 easy easy JJ 37231 3785 11 system system NN 37231 3785 12 , , , 37231 3785 13 continues continue VBZ 37231 3785 14 : : : 37231 3785 15 " " `` 37231 3785 16 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3785 17 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 3785 18 is be VBZ 37231 3785 19 thus thus RB 37231 3785 20 confined confine VBN 37231 3785 21 to to IN 37231 3785 22 the the DT 37231 3785 23 two two CD 37231 3785 24 last last JJ 37231 3785 25 instances instance NNS 37231 3785 26 ; ; : 37231 3785 27 and and CC 37231 3785 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3785 29 must must MD 37231 3785 30 be be VB 37231 3785 31 seen see VBN 37231 3785 32 whether whether IN 37231 3785 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3785 34 disagreement disagreement NN 37231 3785 35 from from IN 37231 3785 36 the the DT 37231 3785 37 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3785 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3785 39 is be VBZ 37231 3785 40 such such JJ 37231 3785 41 as as IN 37231 3785 42 to to TO 37231 3785 43 outweigh outweigh VB 37231 3785 44 the the DT 37231 3785 45 agreement agreement NN 37231 3785 46 of of IN 37231 3785 47 the the DT 37231 3785 48 remaining remain VBG 37231 3785 49 five five CD 37231 3785 50 . . . 37231 3786 1 " " `` 37231 3786 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3786 3 l l NN 37231 3786 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3786 5 Before before IN 37231 3786 6 proceeding proceed VBG 37231 3786 7 to to TO 37231 3786 8 consider consider VB 37231 3786 9 these these DT 37231 3786 10 seven seven CD 37231 3786 11 passages passage NNS 37231 3786 12 admitted admit VBN 37231 3786 13 by by IN 37231 3786 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3786 15 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3786 16 , , , 37231 3786 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3786 18 must must MD 37231 3786 19 point point VB 37231 3786 20 out out RP 37231 3786 21 that that IN 37231 3786 22 , , , 37231 3786 23 in in IN 37231 3786 24 a a DT 37231 3786 25 note note NN 37231 3786 26 to to IN 37231 3786 27 the the DT 37231 3786 28 statement statement NN 37231 3786 29 of of IN 37231 3786 30 the the DT 37231 3786 31 number number NN 37231 3786 32 , , , 37231 3786 33 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3786 34 mentions mention VBZ 37231 3786 35 that that IN 37231 3786 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3786 37 excludes exclude VBZ 37231 3786 38 other other JJ 37231 3786 39 two two CD 37231 3786 40 passages passage NNS 37231 3786 41 as as IN 37231 3786 42 " " `` 37231 3786 43 not not RB 37231 3786 44 merely merely RB 37231 3786 45 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3786 46 of of IN 37231 3786 47 words word NNS 37231 3786 48 , , , 37231 3786 49 but but CC 37231 3786 50 concise concise JJ 37231 3786 51 narratives narrative NNS 37231 3786 52 . . . 37231 3787 1 " " `` 37231 3787 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3787 3 2 2 LS 37231 3787 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3787 5 But but CC 37231 3787 6 surely surely RB 37231 3787 7 this this DT 37231 3787 8 is be VBZ 37231 3787 9 a a DT 37231 3787 10 most most RBS 37231 3787 11 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 37231 3787 12 reason reason NN 37231 3787 13 for for IN 37231 3787 14 omitting omit VBG 37231 3787 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3787 16 , , , 37231 3787 17 and and CC 37231 3787 18 one one CD 37231 3787 19 the the DT 37231 3787 20 validity validity NN 37231 3787 21 of of IN 37231 3787 22 which which WDT 37231 3787 23 can can MD 37231 3787 24 not not RB 37231 3787 25 be be VB 37231 3787 26 admitted admit VBN 37231 3787 27 . . . 37231 3788 1 As as IN 37231 3788 2 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3788 3 introduces introduce VBZ 37231 3788 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3788 5 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 3788 6 as as IN 37231 3788 7 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3788 8 , , , 37231 3788 9 why why WRB 37231 3788 10 should should MD 37231 3788 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3788 12 be be VB 37231 3788 13 excluded exclude VBN 37231 3788 14 simply simply RB 37231 3788 15 because because IN 37231 3788 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3788 17 are be VBP 37231 3788 18 combined combine VBN 37231 3788 19 with with IN 37231 3788 20 a a DT 37231 3788 21 historical historical JJ 37231 3788 22 statement statement NN 37231 3788 23 ? ? . 37231 3789 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3789 2 shall shall MD 37231 3789 3 produce produce VB 37231 3789 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3789 5 . . . 37231 3790 1 The the DT 37231 3790 2 first first JJ 37231 3790 3 is be VBZ 37231 3790 4 in in IN 37231 3790 5 Apol Apol NNP 37231 3790 6 . . . 37231 3791 1 i. i. NNP 37231 3792 1 66 66 CD 37231 3792 2 : : : 37231 3792 3 " " `` 37231 3792 4 For for IN 37231 3792 5 the the DT 37231 3792 6 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3792 7 , , , 37231 3792 8 in in IN 37231 3792 9 the the DT 37231 3792 10 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3792 11 composed compose VBN 37231 3792 12 by by IN 37231 3792 13 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3792 14 , , , 37231 3792 15 which which WDT 37231 3792 16 are be VBP 37231 3792 17 called call VBN 37231 3792 18 Gospels,(3 gospels,(3 NN 37231 3792 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3792 20 handed hand VBD 37231 3792 21 down down RP 37231 3792 22 that that IN 37231 3792 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3792 24 was be VBD 37231 3792 25 thus thus RB 37231 3792 26 enjoined enjoin VBN 37231 3792 27 on on IN 37231 3792 28 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3792 29 , , , 37231 3792 30 that that IN 37231 3792 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3792 32 , , , 37231 3792 33 having have VBG 37231 3792 34 taken take VBN 37231 3792 35 bread bread NN 37231 3792 36 and and CC 37231 3792 37 given give VBN 37231 3792 38 thanks thank NNS 37231 3792 39 , , , 37231 3792 40 said say VBD 37231 3792 41 : : : 37231 3792 42 ' ' `` 37231 3792 43 This this DT 37231 3792 44 do do VBP 37231 3792 45 in in IN 37231 3792 46 remembrance remembrance NN 37231 3792 47 of of IN 37231 3792 48 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3792 49 . . . 37231 3793 1 This this DT 37231 3793 2 is be VBZ 37231 3793 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3793 4 body body NN 37231 3793 5 . . . 37231 3793 6 ' ' '' 37231 3794 1 And and CC 37231 3794 2 similarly similarly RB 37231 3794 3 , , , 37231 3794 4 having have VBG 37231 3794 5 taken take VBN 37231 3794 6 the the DT 37231 3794 7 cup cup NN 37231 3794 8 and and CC 37231 3794 9 given give VBN 37231 3794 10 thanks thank NNS 37231 3794 11 , , , 37231 3794 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3794 13 said say VBD 37231 3794 14 : : : 37231 3794 15 ' ' `` 37231 3794 16 This this DT 37231 3794 17 is be VBZ 37231 3794 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3794 19 blood blood NN 37231 3794 20 , , , 37231 3794 21 ' ' '' 37231 3794 22 and and CC 37231 3794 23 delivered deliver VBD 37231 3794 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3794 25 to to IN 37231 3794 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3794 27 alone alone JJ 37231 3794 28 . . . 37231 3795 1 " " `` 37231 3795 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3795 3 4 4 LS 37231 3795 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3795 5 This this DT 37231 3795 6 passage passage NN 37231 3795 7 , , , 37231 3795 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3795 9 will will MD 37231 3795 10 be be VB 37231 3795 11 remembered remember VBN 37231 3795 12 , , , 37231 3795 13 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3795 14 in in IN 37231 3795 15 an an DT 37231 3795 16 elaborate elaborate JJ 37231 3795 17 apology apology NN 37231 3795 18 for for IN 37231 3795 19 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 3795 20 addressed address VBD 37231 3795 21 to to IN 37231 3795 22 the the DT 37231 3795 23 Roman roman JJ 37231 3795 24 emperors emperor NNS 37231 3795 25 , , , 37231 3795 26 and and CC 37231 3795 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3795 28 is be VBZ 37231 3795 29 giving give VBG 37231 3795 30 an an DT 37231 3795 31 account account NN 37231 3795 32 of of IN 37231 3795 33 the the DT 37231 3795 34 most most RBS 37231 3795 35 solemn solemn JJ 37231 3795 36 sacrament sacrament NN 37231 3795 37 of of IN 37231 3795 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3795 39 religion religion NN 37231 3795 40 . . . 37231 3796 1 Here here RB 37231 3796 2 , , , 37231 3796 3 if if IN 37231 3796 4 ever ever RB 37231 3796 5 , , , 37231 3796 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3796 7 might may MD 37231 3796 8 reasonably reasonably RB 37231 3796 9 expect expect VB 37231 3796 10 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3796 11 and and CC 37231 3796 12 care care NN 37231 3796 13 , , , 37231 3796 14 and and CC 37231 3796 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3796 16 , , , 37231 3796 17 in in IN 37231 3796 18 fact fact NN 37231 3796 19 , , , 37231 3796 20 carefully carefully RB 37231 3796 21 { { -LRB- 37231 3796 22 390 390 CD 37231 3796 23 } } -RRB- 37231 3796 24 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 3796 25 the the DT 37231 3796 26 source source NN 37231 3796 27 of of IN 37231 3796 28 the the DT 37231 3796 29 quotation quotation NN 37231 3796 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3796 31 is be VBZ 37231 3796 32 going go VBG 37231 3796 33 to to TO 37231 3796 34 make make VB 37231 3796 35 . . . 37231 3797 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3797 2 is be VBZ 37231 3797 3 difficult difficult JJ 37231 3797 4 to to TO 37231 3797 5 understand understand VB 37231 3797 6 any any DT 37231 3797 7 ground ground NN 37231 3797 8 upon upon IN 37231 3797 9 which which WDT 37231 3797 10 so so RB 37231 3797 11 direct direct VBP 37231 3797 12 a a DT 37231 3797 13 quotation quotation NN 37231 3797 14 from from IN 37231 3797 15 the the DT 37231 3797 16 " " `` 37231 3797 17 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3797 18 of of IN 37231 3797 19 the the DT 37231 3797 20 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3797 21 " " '' 37231 3797 22 could could MD 37231 3797 23 be be VB 37231 3797 24 set set VBN 37231 3797 25 aside aside RP 37231 3797 26 by by IN 37231 3797 27 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3797 28 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3797 29 . . . 37231 3798 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3798 2 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3798 3 states state VBZ 37231 3798 4 that that IN 37231 3798 5 the the DT 37231 3798 6 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3798 7 in in IN 37231 3798 8 these these DT 37231 3798 9 Memoirs memoir NNS 37231 3798 10 have have VBP 37231 3798 11 " " `` 37231 3798 12 thus thus RB 37231 3798 13 " " '' 37231 3798 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3798 15 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3798 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3798 17 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 3798 18 what what WP 37231 3798 19 was be VBD 37231 3798 20 enjoined enjoin VBN 37231 3798 21 on on IN 37231 3798 22 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3798 23 by by IN 37231 3798 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3798 25 , , , 37231 3798 26 and and CC 37231 3798 27 then then RB 37231 3798 28 gives give VBZ 37231 3798 29 the the DT 37231 3798 30 precise precise JJ 37231 3798 31 quotation quotation NN 37231 3798 32 . . . 37231 3799 1 Had have VBD 37231 3799 2 the the DT 37231 3799 3 quotation quotation NN 37231 3799 4 agreed agree VBD 37231 3799 5 with with IN 37231 3799 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3799 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3799 8 , , , 37231 3799 9 would would MD 37231 3799 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3799 11 not not RB 37231 3799 12 have have VB 37231 3799 13 been be VBN 37231 3799 14 claimed claim VBN 37231 3799 15 as as IN 37231 3799 16 a a DT 37231 3799 17 professedly professedly RB 37231 3799 18 accurate accurate JJ 37231 3799 19 quotation quotation NN 37231 3799 20 from from IN 37231 3799 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3799 22 ? ? . 37231 3800 1 Surely surely RB 37231 3800 2 no no DT 37231 3800 3 one one NN 37231 3800 4 can can MD 37231 3800 5 reasonably reasonably RB 37231 3800 6 pretend pretend VB 37231 3800 7 , , , 37231 3800 8 for for IN 37231 3800 9 instance instance NN 37231 3800 10 , , , 37231 3800 11 that that IN 37231 3800 12 when when WRB 37231 3800 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3800 14 , , , 37231 3800 15 after after IN 37231 3800 16 this this DT 37231 3800 17 preamble preamble NN 37231 3800 18 , , , 37231 3800 19 states state NNS 37231 3800 20 that that IN 37231 3800 21 having have VBG 37231 3800 22 taken take VBN 37231 3800 23 bread bread NN 37231 3800 24 , , , 37231 3800 25 & & CC 37231 3800 26 c. c. NNP 37231 3800 27 , , , 37231 3800 28 _ _ NNP 37231 3800 29 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3800 30 said say VBD 37231 3800 31 _ _ NNP 37231 3800 32 : : : 37231 3800 33 " " `` 37231 3800 34 This this DT 37231 3800 35 do do VBP 37231 3800 36 in in IN 37231 3800 37 remembrance remembrance NN 37231 3800 38 of of IN 37231 3800 39 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3800 40 : : : 37231 3800 41 this this DT 37231 3800 42 is be VBZ 37231 3800 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3800 44 body body NN 37231 3800 45 ; ; : 37231 3800 46 " " '' 37231 3800 47 or or CC 37231 3800 48 having have VBG 37231 3800 49 taken take VBN 37231 3800 50 the the DT 37231 3800 51 cup cup NN 37231 3800 52 , , , 37231 3800 53 & & CC 37231 3800 54 c c NNP 37231 3800 55 , , , 37231 3800 56 _ _ NNP 37231 3800 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3800 58 said say VBD 37231 3800 59 _ _ NNP 37231 3800 60 : : : 37231 3800 61 " " `` 37231 3800 62 This this DT 37231 3800 63 is be VBZ 37231 3800 64 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3800 65 blood"--Justin blood"--justin NN 37231 3800 66 does do VBZ 37231 3800 67 not not RB 37231 3800 68 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 3800 69 mean mean VB 37231 3800 70 to to TO 37231 3800 71 quote quote VB 37231 3800 72 what what WP 37231 3800 73 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3800 74 actually actually RB 37231 3800 75 did do VBD 37231 3800 76 say say VB 37231 3800 77 ? ? . 37231 3801 1 Now now RB 37231 3801 2 the the DT 37231 3801 3 account account NN 37231 3801 4 of of IN 37231 3801 5 the the DT 37231 3801 6 episode episode NN 37231 3801 7 in in IN 37231 3801 8 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3801 9 is be VBZ 37231 3801 10 as as IN 37231 3801 11 follows follow VBZ 37231 3801 12 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3801 13 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3801 14 . . . 37231 3802 1 17 17 CD 37231 3802 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3802 3 : : : 37231 3802 4 " " `` 37231 3802 5 And and CC 37231 3802 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3802 7 took take VBD 37231 3802 8 a a DT 37231 3802 9 cup cup NN 37231 3802 10 , , , 37231 3802 11 gave give VBD 37231 3802 12 thanks thank NNS 37231 3802 13 , , , 37231 3802 14 and and CC 37231 3802 15 said say VBD 37231 3802 16 : : : 37231 3802 17 Take take VB 37231 3802 18 this this DT 37231 3802 19 , , , 37231 3802 20 and and CC 37231 3802 21 divide divide VB 37231 3802 22 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3802 23 among among IN 37231 3802 24 yourselves yourself NNS 37231 3802 25 . . . 37231 3803 1 18 18 CD 37231 3803 2 . . . 37231 3804 1 For for IN 37231 3804 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3804 3 say say VBP 37231 3804 4 unto unto IN 37231 3804 5 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3804 6 , , , 37231 3804 7 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3804 8 will will MD 37231 3804 9 not not RB 37231 3804 10 drink drink VB 37231 3804 11 of of IN 37231 3804 12 the the DT 37231 3804 13 fruit fruit NN 37231 3804 14 of of IN 37231 3804 15 the the DT 37231 3804 16 vine vine NN 37231 3804 17 , , , 37231 3804 18 until until IN 37231 3804 19 the the DT 37231 3804 20 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 3804 21 of of IN 37231 3804 22 God God NNP 37231 3804 23 shall shall MD 37231 3804 24 come come VB 37231 3804 25 . . . 37231 3805 1 19 19 CD 37231 3805 2 . . . 37231 3806 1 And and CC 37231 3806 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3806 3 took take VBD 37231 3806 4 bread bread NN 37231 3806 5 , , , 37231 3806 6 gave give VBD 37231 3806 7 thanks thank NNS 37231 3806 8 , , , 37231 3806 9 brake brake VB 37231 3806 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3806 11 , , , 37231 3806 12 and and CC 37231 3806 13 gave give VBD 37231 3806 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3806 15 unto unto IN 37231 3806 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3806 17 , , , 37231 3806 18 saying say VBG 37231 3806 19 : : : 37231 3806 20 This this DT 37231 3806 21 is be VBZ 37231 3806 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3806 23 body body NN 37231 3806 24 which which WDT 37231 3806 25 is be VBZ 37231 3806 26 given give VBN 37231 3806 27 for for IN 37231 3806 28 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3806 29 : : : 37231 3806 30 this this DT 37231 3806 31 do do VB 37231 3806 32 in in IN 37231 3806 33 remembrance remembrance NN 37231 3806 34 of of IN 37231 3806 35 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3806 36 . . . 37231 3807 1 20 20 CD 37231 3807 2 . . . 37231 3808 1 And and CC 37231 3808 2 in in IN 37231 3808 3 like like JJ 37231 3808 4 manner manner NN 37231 3808 5 the the DT 37231 3808 6 cup cup NN 37231 3808 7 after after IN 37231 3808 8 supper supper NN 37231 3808 9 , , , 37231 3808 10 saying say VBG 37231 3808 11 : : : 37231 3808 12 This this DT 37231 3808 13 is be VBZ 37231 3808 14 the the DT 37231 3808 15 new new JJ 37231 3808 16 covenant covenant NN 37231 3808 17 in in IN 37231 3808 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3808 19 blood blood NN 37231 3808 20 , , , 37231 3808 21 which which WDT 37231 3808 22 is be VBZ 37231 3808 23 shed shed VBN 37231 3808 24 for for IN 37231 3808 25 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3808 26 . . . 37231 3809 1 " " `` 37231 3809 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3809 3 l l NN 37231 3809 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3809 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3809 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3809 7 of of IN 37231 3809 8 course course NN 37231 3809 9 only only RB 37231 3809 10 compares compare VBZ 37231 3809 11 this this DT 37231 3809 12 passage passage NN 37231 3809 13 of of IN 37231 3809 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3809 15 with with IN 37231 3809 16 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3809 17 , , , 37231 3809 18 to to IN 37231 3809 19 which which WDT 37231 3809 20 { { -LRB- 37231 3809 21 391 391 CD 37231 3809 22 } } -RRB- 37231 3809 23 and and CC 37231 3809 24 the the DT 37231 3809 25 parallel parallel NN 37231 3809 26 in in IN 37231 3809 27 1 1 CD 37231 3809 28 Cor Cor NNP 37231 3809 29 . . . 37231 3810 1 xi xi NNP 37231 3810 2 . . . 37231 3811 1 24 24 CD 37231 3811 2 , , , 37231 3811 3 wide wide JJ 37231 3811 4 as as IN 37231 3811 5 the the DT 37231 3811 6 difference difference NN 37231 3811 7 is be VBZ 37231 3811 8 , , , 37231 3811 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3811 10 is be VBZ 37231 3811 11 closer close JJR 37231 3811 12 than than IN 37231 3811 13 to to IN 37231 3811 14 the the DT 37231 3811 15 accounts account NNS 37231 3811 16 in in IN 37231 3811 17 the the DT 37231 3811 18 other other JJ 37231 3811 19 two two CD 37231 3811 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3811 21 . . . 37231 3812 1 That that IN 37231 3812 2 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3812 3 professedly professedly RB 37231 3812 4 quoted quote VBD 37231 3812 5 literally literally RB 37231 3812 6 from from IN 37231 3812 7 the the DT 37231 3812 8 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3812 9 is be VBZ 37231 3812 10 evident evident JJ 37231 3812 11 , , , 37231 3812 12 and and CC 37231 3812 13 is be VBZ 37231 3812 14 rendered render VBN 37231 3812 15 still still RB 37231 3812 16 more more RBR 37231 3812 17 clear clear JJ 37231 3812 18 by by IN 37231 3812 19 the the DT 37231 3812 20 serious serious JJ 37231 3812 21 context context NN 37231 3812 22 by by IN 37231 3812 23 which which WDT 37231 3812 24 the the DT 37231 3812 25 quotation quotation NN 37231 3812 26 is be VBZ 37231 3812 27 introduced introduce VBN 37231 3812 28 , , , 37231 3812 29 the the DT 37231 3812 30 quotation quotation NN 37231 3812 31 in in IN 37231 3812 32 fact fact NN 37231 3812 33 being be VBG 37231 3812 34 made make VBN 37231 3812 35 to to TO 37231 3812 36 authenticate authenticate VB 37231 3812 37 by by IN 37231 3812 38 actual actual JJ 37231 3812 39 written write VBN 37231 3812 40 testimony testimony NN 37231 3812 41 the the DT 37231 3812 42 explanations explanation NNS 37231 3812 43 of of IN 37231 3812 44 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3812 45 . . . 37231 3813 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3813 2 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 3813 3 views view NNS 37231 3813 4 , , , 37231 3813 5 moreover moreover RB 37231 3813 6 , , , 37231 3813 7 are be VBP 37231 3813 8 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 3813 9 drawn draw VBN 37231 3813 10 from from IN 37231 3813 11 a a DT 37231 3813 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3813 13 , , , 37231 3813 14 which which WDT 37231 3813 15 , , , 37231 3813 16 in in IN 37231 3813 17 a a DT 37231 3813 18 more more RBR 37231 3813 19 direct direct JJ 37231 3813 20 way way NN 37231 3813 21 than than IN 37231 3813 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3813 23 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3813 24 do do VBP 37231 3813 25 , , , 37231 3813 26 gave give VBD 37231 3813 27 the the DT 37231 3813 28 expressions expression NNS 37231 3813 29 : : : 37231 3813 30 " " `` 37231 3813 31 This this DT 37231 3813 32 is be VBZ 37231 3813 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3813 34 body body NN 37231 3813 35 , , , 37231 3813 36 " " '' 37231 3813 37 and and CC 37231 3813 38 " " `` 37231 3813 39 This this DT 37231 3813 40 is be VBZ 37231 3813 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3813 42 blood blood NN 37231 3813 43 , , , 37231 3813 44 " " '' 37231 3813 45 and and CC 37231 3813 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3813 47 must must MD 37231 3813 48 have have VB 37231 3813 49 been be VBN 37231 3813 50 observed observe VBN 37231 3813 51 that that IN 37231 3813 52 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3813 53 , , , 37231 3813 54 with with IN 37231 3813 55 which which WDT 37231 3813 56 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3813 57 's 's POS 37231 3813 58 reading reading NN 37231 3813 59 alone alone RB 37231 3813 60 is be VBZ 37231 3813 61 compared compare VBN 37231 3813 62 , , , 37231 3813 63 not not RB 37231 3813 64 only only RB 37231 3813 65 has have VBZ 37231 3813 66 not not RB 37231 3813 67 : : : 37231 3813 68 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3813 69 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3813 70 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3813 71 , , , 37231 3813 72 at at RB 37231 3813 73 all all RB 37231 3813 74 , , , 37231 3813 75 but but CC 37231 3813 76 instead instead RB 37231 3813 77 makes make VBZ 37231 3813 78 use use NN 37231 3813 79 of of IN 37231 3813 80 a a DT 37231 3813 81 totally totally RB 37231 3813 82 different different JJ 37231 3813 83 expression expression NN 37231 3813 84 : : : 37231 3813 85 " " `` 37231 3813 86 This this DT 37231 3813 87 cup cup NN 37231 3813 88 is be VBZ 37231 3813 89 the the DT 37231 3813 90 new new JJ 37231 3813 91 covenant covenant NN 37231 3813 92 in in IN 37231 3813 93 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3813 94 blood blood NN 37231 3813 95 , , , 37231 3813 96 which which WDT 37231 3813 97 is be VBZ 37231 3813 98 shed shed VBN 37231 3813 99 for for IN 37231 3813 100 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3813 101 . . . 37231 3813 102 " " '' 37231 3814 1 The the DT 37231 3814 2 second second JJ 37231 3814 3 quotation quotation NN 37231 3814 4 from from IN 37231 3814 5 the the DT 37231 3814 6 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3814 7 which which WDT 37231 3814 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3814 9 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3814 10 passes pass VBZ 37231 3814 11 over over RP 37231 3814 12 is be VBZ 37231 3814 13 that that DT 37231 3814 14 in in IN 37231 3814 15 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3814 16 . . . 37231 3815 1 103 103 CD 37231 3815 2 , , , 37231 3815 3 compared compare VBN 37231 3815 4 with with IN 37231 3815 5 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3815 6 xxii xxii NNP 37231 3815 7 . . . 37231 3816 1 42 42 CD 37231 3816 2 , , , 37231 3816 3 43,1 43,1 CD 37231 3816 4 on on IN 37231 3816 5 the the DT 37231 3816 6 Agony Agony NNP 37231 3816 7 in in IN 37231 3816 8 the the DT 37231 3816 9 Garden Garden NNP 37231 3816 10 , , , 37231 3816 11 which which WDT 37231 3816 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3816 13 have have VBP 37231 3816 14 already already RB 37231 3816 15 examined,(2 examined,(2 VBN 37231 3816 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3816 17 and and CC 37231 3816 18 found find VBN 37231 3816 19 at at IN 37231 3816 20 variance variance NN 37231 3816 21 with with IN 37231 3816 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3816 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3816 24 , , , 37231 3816 25 and and CC 37231 3816 26 without without IN 37231 3816 27 the the DT 37231 3816 28 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3816 29 and and CC 37231 3816 30 distinctive distinctive JJ 37231 3816 31 expressions expression NNS 37231 3816 32 of of IN 37231 3816 33 the the DT 37231 3816 34 latter latter JJ 37231 3816 35 . . . 37231 3817 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3817 2 now now RB 37231 3817 3 come come VBP 37231 3817 4 to to IN 37231 3817 5 the the DT 37231 3817 6 seven seven CD 37231 3817 7 passages passage NNS 37231 3817 8 which which WDT 37231 3817 9 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3817 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3817 11 admits admit VBZ 37231 3817 12 to to TO 37231 3817 13 be be VB 37231 3817 14 professed profess VBN 37231 3817 15 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3817 16 from from IN 37231 3817 17 the the DT 37231 3817 18 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3817 19 , , , 37231 3817 20 and and CC 37231 3817 21 in in IN 37231 3817 22 which which WDT 37231 3817 23 " " `` 37231 3817 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3817 25 is be VBZ 37231 3817 26 natural natural JJ 37231 3817 27 to to TO 37231 3817 28 expect expect VB 37231 3817 29 that that IN 37231 3817 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3817 31 will will MD 37231 3817 32 preserve preserve VB 37231 3817 33 the the DT 37231 3817 34 exact exact JJ 37231 3817 35 words word NNS 37231 3817 36 of of IN 37231 3817 37 the the DT 37231 3817 38 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3817 39 which which WDT 37231 3817 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3817 41 used use VBD 37231 3817 42 . . . 37231 3817 43 " " '' 37231 3818 1 The the DT 37231 3818 2 first first JJ 37231 3818 3 of of IN 37231 3818 4 these these DT 37231 3818 5 is be VBZ 37231 3818 6 a a DT 37231 3818 7 passage passage NN 37231 3818 8 in in IN 37231 3818 9 the the DT 37231 3818 10 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3818 11 , , , 37231 3818 12 part part NN 37231 3818 13 of of IN 37231 3818 14 which which WDT 37231 3818 15 has have VBZ 37231 3818 16 already already RB 37231 3818 17 been be VBN 37231 3818 18 discussed discuss VBN 37231 3818 19 in in IN 37231 3818 20 connection connection NN 37231 3818 21 with with IN 37231 3818 22 the the DT 37231 3818 23 fire fire NN 37231 3818 24 in in IN 37231 3818 25 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3818 26 and and CC 37231 3818 27 the the DT 37231 3818 28 voice voice NN 37231 3818 29 at at IN 37231 3818 30 the the DT 37231 3818 31 Baptism Baptism NNP 37231 3818 32 , , , 37231 3818 33 and and CC 37231 3818 34 found find VBD 37231 3818 35 to to TO 37231 3818 36 be be VB 37231 3818 37 from from IN 37231 3818 38 a a DT 37231 3818 39 source source NN 37231 3818 40 different different JJ 37231 3818 41 from from IN 37231 3818 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3818 43 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3818 44 . . . 37231 3819 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3819 2 3 3 LS 37231 3819 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3819 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3819 5 says say VBZ 37231 3819 6 : : : 37231 3819 7 " " `` 37231 3819 8 For for IN 37231 3819 9 even even RB 37231 3819 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 11 , , , 37231 3819 12 the the DT 37231 3819 13 devil devil NN 37231 3819 14 , , , 37231 3819 15 at at IN 37231 3819 16 the the DT 37231 3819 17 time time NN 37231 3819 18 when when WRB 37231 3819 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 20 also also RB 37231 3819 21 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3819 22 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3819 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3819 24 went go VBD 37231 3819 25 up up RP 37231 3819 26 from from IN 37231 3819 27 the the DT 37231 3819 28 river river NN 37231 3819 29 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3819 30 when when WRB 37231 3819 31 the the DT 37231 3819 32 voice voice NN 37231 3819 33 { { -LRB- 37231 3819 34 392 392 CD 37231 3819 35 } } -RRB- 37231 3819 36 said say VBD 37231 3819 37 to to IN 37231 3819 38 Him -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 39 : : : 37231 3819 40 ' ' `` 37231 3819 41 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3819 42 art art NN 37231 3819 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3819 44 Son Son NNP 37231 3819 45 , , , 37231 3819 46 this this DT 37231 3819 47 day day NN 37231 3819 48 have have VBP 37231 3819 49 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 50 begotten begotten VB 37231 3819 51 thee thee PRP 37231 3819 52 , , , 37231 3819 53 ' ' '' 37231 3819 54 is be VBZ 37231 3819 55 recorded record VBN 37231 3819 56 in in IN 37231 3819 57 the the DT 37231 3819 58 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3819 59 of of IN 37231 3819 60 the the DT 37231 3819 61 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3819 62 to to TO 37231 3819 63 have have VB 37231 3819 64 come come VBN 37231 3819 65 to to IN 37231 3819 66 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 67 and and CC 37231 3819 68 tempted tempt VBD 37231 3819 69 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 70 even even RB 37231 3819 71 so so RB 37231 3819 72 far far RB 37231 3819 73 as as IN 37231 3819 74 saying say VBG 37231 3819 75 to to IN 37231 3819 76 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 77 : : : 37231 3819 78 ' ' '' 37231 3819 79 Worship worship VB 37231 3819 80 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 81 ; ; : 37231 3819 82 ' ' '' 37231 3819 83 and and CC 37231 3819 84 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3819 85 answered answer VBD 37231 3819 86 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 87 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3819 88 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3819 89 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3819 90 , , , 37231 3819 91 ' ' `` 37231 3819 92 Get get VB 37231 3819 93 thee thee PRP 37231 3819 94 behind behind IN 37231 3819 95 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 96 , , , 37231 3819 97 Satan Satan NNP 37231 3819 98 ' ' POS 37231 3819 99 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3819 100 ---Greek--- ---greek--- NN 37231 3819 101 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3819 102 , , , 37231 3819 103 ' ' '' 37231 3819 104 thou thou NNP 37231 3819 105 shalt shalt NN 37231 3819 106 worship worship VB 37231 3819 107 the the DT 37231 3819 108 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3819 109 thy thy PRP$ 37231 3819 110 God God NNP 37231 3819 111 , , , 37231 3819 112 and and CC 37231 3819 113 Him -PRON- PRP 37231 3819 114 only only RB 37231 3819 115 shalt shalt NN 37231 3819 116 thou thou NNP 37231 3819 117 serve serve VB 37231 3819 118 . . . 37231 3820 1 ' ' '' 37231 3820 2 " " '' 37231 3820 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3820 4 1 1 LS 37231 3820 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3820 6 This this DT 37231 3820 7 passage passage NN 37231 3820 8 is be VBZ 37231 3820 9 compared compare VBN 37231 3820 10 with with IN 37231 3820 11 the the DT 37231 3820 12 account account NN 37231 3820 13 of of IN 37231 3820 14 the the DT 37231 3820 15 temptation temptation NN 37231 3820 16 in in IN 37231 3820 17 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3820 18 iv iv NNP 37231 3820 19 . . . 37231 3821 1 9 9 CD 37231 3821 2 , , , 37231 3821 3 10 10 CD 37231 3821 4 : : : 37231 3821 5 " " `` 37231 3821 6 And and CC 37231 3821 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3821 8 said say VBD 37231 3821 9 unto unto IN 37231 3821 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3821 11 , , , 37231 3821 12 All all PDT 37231 3821 13 these these DT 37231 3821 14 things thing NNS 37231 3821 15 will will MD 37231 3821 16 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3821 17 give give VB 37231 3821 18 thee thee PRP 37231 3821 19 , , , 37231 3821 20 if if IN 37231 3821 21 thou thou NNP 37231 3821 22 wilt wilt NNP 37231 3821 23 fall fall VBP 37231 3821 24 down down RP 37231 3821 25 and and CC 37231 3821 26 worship worship VB 37231 3821 27 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3821 28 . . . 37231 3822 1 10 10 CD 37231 3822 2 . . . 37231 3823 1 Then then RB 37231 3823 2 saith saith VBZ 37231 3823 3 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3823 4 unto unto IN 37231 3823 5 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3823 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3823 7 ---Greek--- ---Greek--- NFP 37231 3823 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3823 9 , , , 37231 3823 10 Get get VB 37231 3823 11 thee thee PRP 37231 3823 12 hence hence RB 37231 3823 13 , , , 37231 3823 14 Satan Satan NNP 37231 3823 15 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3823 16 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3823 17 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3823 18 : : : 37231 3823 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3823 20 is be VBZ 37231 3823 21 written write VBN 37231 3823 22 , , , 37231 3823 23 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3823 24 shalt shalt NN 37231 3823 25 worship worship NN 37231 3823 26 , , , 37231 3823 27 " " '' 37231 3823 28 & & CC 37231 3823 29 c c NNP 37231 3823 30 All all PDT 37231 3823 31 the the DT 37231 3823 32 oldest old JJS 37231 3823 33 Codices codex NNS 37231 3823 34 , , , 37231 3823 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3823 36 should should MD 37231 3823 37 be be VB 37231 3823 38 stated state VBN 37231 3823 39 , , , 37231 3823 40 omit omit VB 37231 3823 41 the the DT 37231 3823 42 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3823 43 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3823 44 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3823 45 , , , 37231 3823 46 as as IN 37231 3823 47 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3823 48 have have VBP 37231 3823 49 done do VBN 37231 3823 50 , , , 37231 3823 51 but but CC 37231 3823 52 Cod cod NN 37231 3823 53 . . . 37231 3824 1 D. D. NNP 37231 3824 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3824 3 Bezæ Bezæ NNP 37231 3824 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3824 5 and and CC 37231 3824 6 a a DT 37231 3824 7 few few JJ 37231 3824 8 others other NNS 37231 3824 9 of of IN 37231 3824 10 infirm infirm NN 37231 3824 11 authority authority NN 37231 3824 12 , , , 37231 3824 13 insert insert VB 37231 3824 14 these these DT 37231 3824 15 two two CD 37231 3824 16 words word NNS 37231 3824 17 . . . 37231 3825 1 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3825 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3825 3 , , , 37231 3825 4 however however RB 37231 3825 5 , , , 37231 3825 6 justly justly RB 37231 3825 7 admits admit VBZ 37231 3825 8 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3825 9 to to TO 37231 3825 10 be be VB 37231 3825 11 " " `` 37231 3825 12 probably probably RB 37231 3825 13 only only RB 37231 3825 14 a a DT 37231 3825 15 very very RB 37231 3825 16 early early JJ 37231 3825 17 interpolation interpolation NN 37231 3825 18 . . . 37231 3826 1 " " `` 37231 3826 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3826 3 2 2 LS 37231 3826 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3826 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3826 6 have have VBP 37231 3826 7 no no DT 37231 3826 8 reason reason NN 37231 3826 9 whatever whatever WDT 37231 3826 10 for for IN 37231 3826 11 supposing suppose VBG 37231 3826 12 that that IN 37231 3826 13 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3826 14 existed exist VBD 37231 3826 15 in in IN 37231 3826 16 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3826 17 during during IN 37231 3826 18 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3826 19 's 's POS 37231 3826 20 time time NN 37231 3826 21 . . . 37231 3827 1 The the DT 37231 3827 2 oldest old JJS 37231 3827 3 Codices codex NNS 37231 3827 4 omit omit VBP 37231 3827 5 the the DT 37231 3827 6 whole whole JJ 37231 3827 7 phrase phrase NN 37231 3827 8 from from IN 37231 3827 9 the the DT 37231 3827 10 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3827 11 passage passage NN 37231 3827 12 , , , 37231 3827 13 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3827 14 iv iv NNP 37231 3827 15 . . . 37231 3828 1 8 8 CD 37231 3828 2 , , , 37231 3828 3 but but CC 37231 3828 4 Cod cod NN 37231 3828 5 . . . 37231 3829 1 A. A. NNP 37231 3829 2 is be VBZ 37231 3829 3 an an DT 37231 3829 4 exception exception NN 37231 3829 5 , , , 37231 3829 6 and and CC 37231 3829 7 reads read VBZ 37231 3829 8 : : : 37231 3829 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3829 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3829 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3829 12 . . . 37231 3830 1 The the DT 37231 3830 2 best good JJS 37231 3830 3 modern modern JJ 37231 3830 4 editions edition NNS 37231 3830 5 , , , 37231 3830 6 however however RB 37231 3830 7 , , , 37231 3830 8 reject reject VBP 37231 3830 9 this this DT 37231 3830 10 as as IN 37231 3830 11 a a DT 37231 3830 12 mere mere JJ 37231 3830 13 recent recent JJ 37231 3830 14 addition addition NN 37231 3830 15 to to IN 37231 3830 16 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3830 17 . . . 37231 3831 1 A a DT 37231 3831 2 comparison comparison NN 37231 3831 3 of of IN 37231 3831 4 the the DT 37231 3831 5 first first JJ 37231 3831 6 and and CC 37231 3831 7 third third JJ 37231 3831 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3831 9 with with IN 37231 3831 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3831 11 clearly clearly RB 37231 3831 12 shows show VBZ 37231 3831 13 that that IN 37231 3831 14 the the DT 37231 3831 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3831 16 which which WDT 37231 3831 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3831 18 used use VBD 37231 3831 19 followed follow VBD 37231 3831 20 the the DT 37231 3831 21 former former JJ 37231 3831 22 more more RBR 37231 3831 23 closely closely RB 37231 3831 24 than than IN 37231 3831 25 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3831 26 . . . 37231 3832 1 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3832 2 makes make VBZ 37231 3832 3 the the DT 37231 3832 4 climax climax NN 37231 3832 5 of of IN 37231 3832 6 the the DT 37231 3832 7 temptation temptation NN 37231 3832 8 { { -LRB- 37231 3832 9 393 393 CD 37231 3832 10 } } -RRB- 37231 3832 11 the the DT 37231 3832 12 view view NN 37231 3832 13 of of IN 37231 3832 14 all all PDT 37231 3832 15 the the DT 37231 3832 16 kingdoms kingdom NNS 37231 3832 17 of of IN 37231 3832 18 the the DT 37231 3832 19 world world NN 37231 3832 20 , , , 37231 3832 21 and and CC 37231 3832 22 the the DT 37231 3832 23 offer offer NN 37231 3832 24 to to TO 37231 3832 25 give give VB 37231 3832 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3832 27 to to IN 37231 3832 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3832 29 if if IN 37231 3832 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3832 31 will will MD 37231 3832 32 fall fall VB 37231 3832 33 down down RP 37231 3832 34 and and CC 37231 3832 35 worship worship VB 37231 3832 36 Satan Satan NNP 37231 3832 37 . . . 37231 3833 1 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3833 2 , , , 37231 3833 3 on on IN 37231 3833 4 the the DT 37231 3833 5 contrary contrary NN 37231 3833 6 , , , 37231 3833 7 makes make VBZ 37231 3833 8 the the DT 37231 3833 9 final final JJ 37231 3833 10 temptation temptation NN 37231 3833 11 the the DT 37231 3833 12 suggestion suggestion NN 37231 3833 13 to to TO 37231 3833 14 throw throw VB 37231 3833 15 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3833 16 down down RP 37231 3833 17 from from IN 37231 3833 18 the the DT 37231 3833 19 pinnacle pinnacle NN 37231 3833 20 of of IN 37231 3833 21 the the DT 37231 3833 22 temple temple NNP 37231 3833 23 . . . 37231 3834 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3834 2 's 's POS 37231 3834 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3834 4 , , , 37231 3834 5 as as IN 37231 3834 6 the the DT 37231 3834 7 words word NNS 37231 3834 8 , , , 37231 3834 9 " " '' 37231 3834 10 so so RB 37231 3834 11 far far RB 37231 3834 12 as as IN 37231 3834 13 saying say VBG 37231 3834 14 to to IN 37231 3834 15 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3834 16 " " `` 37231 3834 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3834 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3834 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3834 20 , , , 37231 3834 21 & & CC 37231 3834 22 c. c. NNP 37231 3834 23 , , , 37231 3834 24 clearly clearly RB 37231 3834 25 indicate indicate VBP 37231 3834 26 , , , 37231 3834 27 had have VBD 37231 3834 28 the the DT 37231 3834 29 same same JJ 37231 3834 30 climax climax NN 37231 3834 31 as as IN 37231 3834 32 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3834 33 . . . 37231 3835 1 Now now RB 37231 3835 2 the the DT 37231 3835 3 following follow VBG 37231 3835 4 points point NNS 37231 3835 5 must must MD 37231 3835 6 be be VB 37231 3835 7 observed observe VBN 37231 3835 8 . . . 37231 3836 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3836 2 makes make VBZ 37231 3836 3 the the DT 37231 3836 4 words word NNS 37231 3836 5 of of IN 37231 3836 6 Satan Satan NNP 37231 3836 7 , , , 37231 3836 8 " " `` 37231 3836 9 Worship worship VB 37231 3836 10 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3836 11 " " '' 37231 3836 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3836 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3836 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3836 15 , , , 37231 3836 16 a a DT 37231 3836 17 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3836 18 quotation quotation NN 37231 3836 19 ; ; : 37231 3836 20 the the DT 37231 3836 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3836 22 makes make VBZ 37231 3836 23 Satan Satan NNP 37231 3836 24 offer offer VB 37231 3836 25 all all DT 37231 3836 26 that that WDT 37231 3836 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3836 28 has have VBZ 37231 3836 29 shown show VBN 37231 3836 30 " " '' 37231 3836 31 if if IN 37231 3836 32 thou thou NNP 37231 3836 33 wilt wilt NNP 37231 3836 34 fall fall VBP 37231 3836 35 down down RP 37231 3836 36 and and CC 37231 3836 37 worship worship VB 37231 3836 38 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3836 39 " " '' 37231 3836 40 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3836 41 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3836 42 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3836 43 . . . 37231 3837 1 Then then RB 37231 3837 2 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3837 3 's 's POS 37231 3837 4 quotation quotation NN 37231 3837 5 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 3837 6 : : : 37231 3837 7 " " `` 37231 3837 8 And and CC 37231 3837 9 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3837 10 answered answer VBD 37231 3837 11 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3837 12 " " `` 37231 3837 13 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3837 14 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3837 15 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3837 16 ; ; , 37231 3837 17 whilst whilst IN 37231 3837 18 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3837 19 has have VBZ 37231 3837 20 , , , 37231 3837 21 " " `` 37231 3837 22 Then then RB 37231 3837 23 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3837 24 saith saith JJ 37231 3837 25 to to IN 37231 3837 26 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3837 27 " " `` 37231 3837 28 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3837 29 ---Greek--- ---greek--- NN 37231 3837 30 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3837 31 , , , 37231 3837 32 which which WDT 37231 3837 33 is be VBZ 37231 3837 34 a a DT 37231 3837 35 marked marked JJ 37231 3837 36 variation variation NN 37231 3837 37 . . . 37231 3838 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3838 2 1 1 LS 37231 3838 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3838 4 The[--Greek-- the[--greek-- NN 37231 3838 5 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3838 6 of of IN 37231 3838 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3838 8 , , , 37231 3838 9 as as IN 37231 3838 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3838 11 have have VBP 37231 3838 12 already already RB 37231 3838 13 said say VBN 37231 3838 14 , , , 37231 3838 15 is be VBZ 37231 3838 16 not not RB 37231 3838 17 found find VBN 37231 3838 18 in in IN 37231 3838 19 any any DT 37231 3838 20 of of IN 37231 3838 21 the the DT 37231 3838 22 older old JJR 37231 3838 23 Codices codex NNS 37231 3838 24 of of IN 37231 3838 25 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3838 26 . . . 37231 3839 1 Then then RB 37231 3839 2 the the DT 37231 3839 3 words word NNS 37231 3839 4 : : : 37231 3839 5 " " `` 37231 3839 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3839 7 is be VBZ 37231 3839 8 written write VBN 37231 3839 9 , , , 37231 3839 10 " " '' 37231 3839 11 which which WDT 37231 3839 12 form form VBP 37231 3839 13 part part NN 37231 3839 14 of of IN 37231 3839 15 the the DT 37231 3839 16 reply reply NN 37231 3839 17 of of IN 37231 3839 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3839 19 in in IN 37231 3839 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3839 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3839 22 , , , 37231 3839 23 are be VBP 37231 3839 24 omitted omit VBN 37231 3839 25 in in IN 37231 3839 26 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3839 27 's 's POS 37231 3839 28 ; ; : 37231 3839 29 but but CC 37231 3839 30 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3839 31 must must MD 37231 3839 32 add add VB 37231 3839 33 that that DT 37231 3839 34 , , , 37231 3839 35 in in IN 37231 3839 36 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3839 37 125 125 CD 37231 3839 38 , , , 37231 3839 39 in in IN 37231 3839 40 again again RB 37231 3839 41 referring refer VBG 37231 3839 42 to to IN 37231 3839 43 the the DT 37231 3839 44 temptation temptation NN 37231 3839 45 , , , 37231 3839 46 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3839 47 adds add VBZ 37231 3839 48 , , , 37231 3839 49 " " `` 37231 3839 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3839 51 is be VBZ 37231 3839 52 written write VBN 37231 3839 53 . . . 37231 3839 54 " " '' 37231 3840 1 Still still RB 37231 3840 2 , , , 37231 3840 3 in in IN 37231 3840 4 that that DT 37231 3840 5 passage passage NN 37231 3840 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3840 7 also also RB 37231 3840 8 omits omit VBZ 37231 3840 9 the the DT 37231 3840 10 whole whole JJ 37231 3840 11 phrase phrase NN 37231 3840 12 , , , 37231 3840 13 " " `` 37231 3840 14 Get get VB 37231 3840 15 thee thee PRP 37231 3840 16 behind behind IN 37231 3840 17 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3840 18 , , , 37231 3840 19 Satan Satan NNP 37231 3840 20 , , , 37231 3840 21 " " '' 37231 3840 22 and and CC 37231 3840 23 commences commence VBZ 37231 3840 24 : : : 37231 3840 25 " " `` 37231 3840 26 For for IN 37231 3840 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3840 28 answered answer VBD 37231 3840 29 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3840 30 : : : 37231 3840 31 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3840 32 is be VBZ 37231 3840 33 written write VBN 37231 3840 34 , , , 37231 3840 35 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3840 36 shalt shalt NN 37231 3840 37 worship worship NN 37231 3840 38 , , , 37231 3840 39 " " '' 37231 3840 40 & & CC 37231 3840 41 c. c. NNP 37231 3840 42 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3840 43 must must MD 37231 3840 44 , , , 37231 3840 45 however however RB 37231 3840 46 , , , 37231 3840 47 again again RB 37231 3840 48 point point VB 37231 3840 49 out out RP 37231 3840 50 the the DT 37231 3840 51 most most RBS 37231 3840 52 important important JJ 37231 3840 53 fact fact NN 37231 3840 54 , , , 37231 3840 55 that that IN 37231 3840 56 this this DT 37231 3840 57 account account NN 37231 3840 58 of of IN 37231 3840 59 the the DT 37231 3840 60 temptation temptation NN 37231 3840 61 is be VBZ 37231 3840 62 directly directly RB 37231 3840 63 connected connect VBN 37231 3840 64 with with IN 37231 3840 65 another another DT 37231 3840 66 which which WDT 37231 3840 67 is be VBZ 37231 3840 68 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3840 69 to to IN 37231 3840 70 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3840 71 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3840 72 . . . 37231 3841 1 The the DT 37231 3841 2 Devil Devil NNP 37231 3841 3 is be VBZ 37231 3841 4 said say VBN 37231 3841 5 to to TO 37231 3841 6 come come VB 37231 3841 7 at at IN 37231 3841 8 the the DT 37231 3841 9 time time NN 37231 3841 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3841 11 went go VBD 37231 3841 12 up up RP 37231 3841 13 out out IN 37231 3841 14 of of IN 37231 3841 15 the the DT 37231 3841 16 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3841 17 and and CC 37231 3841 18 the the DT 37231 3841 19 voice voice NN 37231 3841 20 said say VBD 37231 3841 21 to to IN 37231 3841 22 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3841 23 : : : 37231 3841 24 " " `` 37231 3841 25 Thou Thou NNP 37231 3841 26 art art NN 37231 3841 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3841 28 son son NN 37231 3841 29 , , , 37231 3841 30 this this DT 37231 3841 31 day day NN 37231 3841 32 have have VBP 37231 3841 33 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3841 34 begotten begotten VBP 37231 3841 35 thee"--words thee"--word NNS 37231 3841 36 which which WDT 37231 3841 37 do do VBP 37231 3841 38 not not RB 37231 3841 39 occur occur VB 37231 3841 40 at at RB 37231 3841 41 all all RB 37231 3841 42 in in IN 37231 3841 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3841 44 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3841 45 , , , 37231 3841 46 and and CC 37231 3841 47 which which WDT 37231 3841 48 are be VBP 37231 3841 49 again again RB 37231 3841 50 bound bind VBN 37231 3841 51 up up RP 37231 3841 52 with with IN 37231 3841 53 the the DT 37231 3841 54 incident incident NN 37231 3841 55 of of IN 37231 3841 56 the the DT 37231 3841 57 fire fire NN 37231 3841 58 in in IN 37231 3841 59 Jordan Jordan NNP 37231 3841 60 . . . 37231 3842 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3842 2 is be VBZ 37231 3842 3 altogether altogether RB 37231 3842 4 { { -LRB- 37231 3842 5 394 394 CD 37231 3842 6 } } -RRB- 37231 3842 7 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 3842 8 to to TO 37231 3842 9 assert assert VB 37231 3842 10 that that IN 37231 3842 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3842 12 could could MD 37231 3842 13 have have VB 37231 3842 14 referred refer VBN 37231 3842 15 the the DT 37231 3842 16 fact fact NN 37231 3842 17 which which WDT 37231 3842 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3842 19 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 3842 20 to to TO 37231 3842 21 quote quote VB 37231 3842 22 from from IN 37231 3842 23 the the DT 37231 3842 24 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3842 25 , , , 37231 3842 26 to to IN 37231 3842 27 the the DT 37231 3842 28 time time NN 37231 3842 29 those those DT 37231 3842 30 words word NNS 37231 3842 31 were be VBD 37231 3842 32 uttered uttered JJ 37231 3842 33 , , , 37231 3842 34 if if IN 37231 3842 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3842 36 were be VBD 37231 3842 37 not not RB 37231 3842 38 to to TO 37231 3842 39 be be VB 37231 3842 40 found find VBN 37231 3842 41 in in IN 37231 3842 42 the the DT 37231 3842 43 same same JJ 37231 3842 44 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3842 45 . . . 37231 3843 1 The the DT 37231 3843 2 one one CD 37231 3843 3 incident incident NN 37231 3843 4 was be VBD 37231 3843 5 most most RBS 37231 3843 6 certainly certainly RB 37231 3843 7 not not RB 37231 3843 8 derived derive VBN 37231 3843 9 from from IN 37231 3843 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3843 11 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3843 12 , , , 37231 3843 13 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37231 3843 14 as as IN 37231 3843 15 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3843 16 do do VBP 37231 3843 17 not not RB 37231 3843 18 contain contain VB 37231 3843 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3843 20 , , , 37231 3843 21 and and CC 37231 3843 22 there there EX 37231 3843 23 are be VBP 37231 3843 24 the the DT 37231 3843 25 very very RB 37231 3843 26 strongest strong JJS 37231 3843 27 reasons reason NNS 37231 3843 28 for for IN 37231 3843 29 asserting assert VBG 37231 3843 30 that that IN 37231 3843 31 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3843 32 derived derive VBD 37231 3843 33 the the DT 37231 3843 34 account account NN 37231 3843 35 of of IN 37231 3843 36 the the DT 37231 3843 37 temptation temptation NN 37231 3843 38 from from IN 37231 3843 39 a a DT 37231 3843 40 source source NN 37231 3843 41 which which WDT 37231 3843 42 contained contain VBD 37231 3843 43 the the DT 37231 3843 44 other other JJ 37231 3843 45 . . . 37231 3844 1 Under under IN 37231 3844 2 these these DT 37231 3844 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 3844 4 , , , 37231 3844 5 every every DT 37231 3844 6 variation variation NN 37231 3844 7 is be VBZ 37231 3844 8 an an DT 37231 3844 9 indication indication NN 37231 3844 10 , , , 37231 3844 11 and and CC 37231 3844 12 those those DT 37231 3844 13 which which WDT 37231 3844 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3844 15 have have VBP 37231 3844 16 pointed point VBN 37231 3844 17 out out RP 37231 3844 18 are be VBP 37231 3844 19 not not RB 37231 3844 20 accidental accidental JJ 37231 3844 21 , , , 37231 3844 22 but but CC 37231 3844 23 clearly clearly RB 37231 3844 24 exclude exclude VB 37231 3844 25 the the DT 37231 3844 26 assertion assertion NN 37231 3844 27 that that IN 37231 3844 28 the the DT 37231 3844 29 quotation quotation NN 37231 3844 30 is be VBZ 37231 3844 31 from from IN 37231 3844 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3844 33 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3844 34 . . . 37231 3845 1 The the DT 37231 3845 2 second second JJ 37231 3845 3 of of IN 37231 3845 4 the the DT 37231 3845 5 seven seven CD 37231 3845 6 passages passage NNS 37231 3845 7 of of IN 37231 3845 8 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3845 9 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3845 10 is be VBZ 37231 3845 11 one one CD 37231 3845 12 of of IN 37231 3845 13 those those DT 37231 3845 14 from from IN 37231 3845 15 the the DT 37231 3845 16 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3845 17 on on IN 37231 3845 18 the the DT 37231 3845 19 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3845 20 , , , 37231 3845 21 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3845 22 . . . 37231 3846 1 105 105 CD 37231 3846 2 , , , 37231 3846 3 compared compare VBN 37231 3846 4 with with IN 37231 3846 5 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3846 6 v. v. CC 37231 3846 7 20 20 CD 37231 3846 8 , , , 37231 3846 9 adduced adduce VBN 37231 3846 10 by by IN 37231 3846 11 de de NNP 37231 3846 12 Wette Wette NNP 37231 3846 13 , , , 37231 3846 14 which which WDT 37231 3846 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3846 16 have have VBP 37231 3846 17 already already RB 37231 3846 18 considered consider VBN 37231 3846 19 . . . 37231 3847 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3847 2 1 1 LS 37231 3847 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3847 4 With with IN 37231 3847 5 the the DT 37231 3847 6 exception exception NN 37231 3847 7 of of IN 37231 3847 8 the the DT 37231 3847 9 opening opening NN 37231 3847 10 words word NNS 37231 3847 11 , , , 37231 3847 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3847 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3847 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3847 15 , , , 37231 3847 16 the the DT 37231 3847 17 two two CD 37231 3847 18 sentences sentence NNS 37231 3847 19 agree agree VBP 37231 3847 20 , , , 37231 3847 21 but but CC 37231 3847 22 this this DT 37231 3847 23 is be VBZ 37231 3847 24 no no DT 37231 3847 25 proof proof NN 37231 3847 26 that that IN 37231 3847 27 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3847 28 derived derive VBD 37231 3847 29 the the DT 37231 3847 30 passage passage NN 37231 3847 31 from from IN 37231 3847 32 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3847 33 ; ; : 37231 3847 34 while while IN 37231 3847 35 on on IN 37231 3847 36 the the DT 37231 3847 37 contrary contrary NN 37231 3847 38 , , , 37231 3847 39 the the DT 37231 3847 40 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3847 41 variation variation NN 37231 3847 42 of of IN 37231 3847 43 the the DT 37231 3847 44 rest rest NN 37231 3847 45 of of IN 37231 3847 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3847 47 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3847 48 from from IN 37231 3847 49 the the DT 37231 3847 50 Sermon Sermon NNP 37231 3847 51 on on IN 37231 3847 52 the the DT 37231 3847 53 Mount Mount NNP 37231 3847 54 , , , 37231 3847 55 both both CC 37231 3847 56 in in IN 37231 3847 57 order order NN 37231 3847 58 and and CC 37231 3847 59 language language NN 37231 3847 60 , , , 37231 3847 61 forces force NNS 37231 3847 62 upon upon IN 37231 3847 63 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3847 64 the the DT 37231 3847 65 conviction conviction NN 37231 3847 66 that that IN 37231 3847 67 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3847 68 derived derive VBD 37231 3847 69 the the DT 37231 3847 70 whole whole NN 37231 3847 71 from from IN 37231 3847 72 a a DT 37231 3847 73 source source NN 37231 3847 74 different different JJ 37231 3847 75 from from IN 37231 3847 76 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3847 77 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3847 78 . . . 37231 3848 1 The the DT 37231 3848 2 third third JJ 37231 3848 3 passage passage NN 37231 3848 4 of of IN 37231 3848 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3848 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3848 7 is be VBZ 37231 3848 8 that that IN 37231 3848 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 3848 10 the the DT 37231 3848 11 sign sign NN 37231 3848 12 of of IN 37231 3848 13 Jonas Jonas NNP 37231 3848 14 the the DT 37231 3848 15 prophet prophet NN 37231 3848 16 , , , 37231 3848 17 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3848 18 , , , 37231 3848 19 xii xii NNP 37231 3848 20 . . . 37231 3849 1 39 39 CD 37231 3849 2 , , , 37231 3849 3 compared compare VBN 37231 3849 4 with with IN 37231 3849 5 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3849 6 . . . 37231 3850 1 107 107 CD 37231 3850 2 , , , 37231 3850 3 which which WDT 37231 3850 4 was be VBD 37231 3850 5 the the DT 37231 3850 6 second second JJ 37231 3850 7 instance instance NN 37231 3850 8 adduced adduce VBN 37231 3850 9 by by IN 37231 3850 10 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 3850 11 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3850 12 have have VBP 37231 3850 13 already already RB 37231 3850 14 examined examine VBN 37231 3850 15 it,(2 it,(2 NN 37231 3850 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3850 17 and and CC 37231 3850 18 found find VBD 37231 3850 19 that that IN 37231 3850 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3850 21 presents present VBZ 37231 3850 22 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3850 23 variations variation NNS 37231 3850 24 from from IN 37231 3850 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3850 26 first first JJ 37231 3850 27 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3850 28 , , , 37231 3850 29 both both CC 37231 3850 30 linguistically linguistically RB 37231 3850 31 and and CC 37231 3850 32 otherwise otherwise RB 37231 3850 33 , , , 37231 3850 34 and and CC 37231 3850 35 that that IN 37231 3850 36 many many JJ 37231 3850 37 reasons reason NNS 37231 3850 38 lead lead VBP 37231 3850 39 to to IN 37231 3850 40 the the DT 37231 3850 41 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3850 42 that that IN 37231 3850 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3850 44 was be VBD 37231 3850 45 quoted quote VBN 37231 3850 46 from from IN 37231 3850 47 a a DT 37231 3850 48 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3850 49 different different JJ 37231 3850 50 from from IN 37231 3850 51 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 3850 52 . . . 37231 3851 1 The the DT 37231 3851 2 fourth fourth JJ 37231 3851 3 of of IN 37231 3851 4 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3851 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3851 6 's 's POS 37231 3851 7 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3851 8 is be VBZ 37231 3851 9 the the DT 37231 3851 10 { { -LRB- 37231 3851 11 395 395 CD 37231 3851 12 } } -RRB- 37231 3851 13 following follow VBG 37231 3851 14 , , , 37231 3851 15 to to IN 37231 3851 16 part part NN 37231 3851 17 of of IN 37231 3851 18 which which WDT 37231 3851 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3851 20 have have VBP 37231 3851 21 already already RB 37231 3851 22 had have VBN 37231 3851 23 occasion occasion NN 37231 3851 24 to to IN 37231 3851 25 refer:(l refer:(l VB 37231 3851 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3851 27 " " `` 37231 3851 28 For for IN 37231 3851 29 which which WDT 37231 3851 30 reason reason NN 37231 3851 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3851 32 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3851 33 declared declare VBD 37231 3851 34 on on IN 37231 3851 35 earth earth NN 37231 3851 36 to to IN 37231 3851 37 those those DT 37231 3851 38 who who WP 37231 3851 39 asserted assert VBD 37231 3851 40 that that IN 37231 3851 41 Elias elias PRP 37231 3851 42 must must MD 37231 3851 43 come come VB 37231 3851 44 before before IN 37231 3851 45 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3851 46 : : : 37231 3851 47 Elias elias PRP 37231 3851 48 indeed indeed RB 37231 3851 49 shall shall MD 37231 3851 50 come come VB 37231 3851 51 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3851 52 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3851 53 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3851 54 and and CC 37231 3851 55 shall shall MD 37231 3851 56 restore restore VB 37231 3851 57 all all DT 37231 3851 58 things thing NNS 37231 3851 59 : : : 37231 3851 60 but but CC 37231 3851 61 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3851 62 say say VBP 37231 3851 63 unto unto IN 37231 3851 64 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3851 65 that that IN 37231 3851 66 Elias Elias NNP 37231 3851 67 is be VBZ 37231 3851 68 come come VBN 37231 3851 69 already already RB 37231 3851 70 , , , 37231 3851 71 and and CC 37231 3851 72 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3851 73 knew know VBD 37231 3851 74 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3851 75 not not RB 37231 3851 76 , , , 37231 3851 77 but but CC 37231 3851 78 did do VBD 37231 3851 79 unto unto IN 37231 3851 80 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3851 81 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3851 82 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3851 83 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3851 84 whatsoever whatsoever RB 37231 3851 85 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3851 86 listed list VBD 37231 3851 87 . . . 37231 3852 1 And and CC 37231 3852 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3852 3 is be VBZ 37231 3852 4 written write VBN 37231 3852 5 that that IN 37231 3852 6 then then RB 37231 3852 7 the the DT 37231 3852 8 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3852 9 understood understand VBD 37231 3852 10 that that IN 37231 3852 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3852 12 spoke speak VBD 37231 3852 13 to to IN 37231 3852 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3852 15 of of IN 37231 3852 16 John John NNP 37231 3852 17 the the DT 37231 3852 18 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 3852 19 . . . 37231 3853 1 " " `` 37231 3853 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3853 3 2 2 LS 37231 3853 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3853 5 The the DT 37231 3853 6 express express JJ 37231 3853 7 quotation quotation NN 37231 3853 8 " " `` 37231 3853 9 in in IN 37231 3853 10 this this DT 37231 3853 11 passage passage NN 37231 3853 12 , , , 37231 3853 13 which which WDT 37231 3853 14 is be VBZ 37231 3853 15 compared compare VBN 37231 3853 16 with with IN 37231 3853 17 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3853 18 . . . 37231 3854 1 xvii xvii NN 37231 3854 2 . . . 37231 3855 1 11 11 CD 37231 3855 2 - - HYPH 37231 3855 3 -13 -13 NNP 37231 3855 4 , , , 37231 3855 5 is be VBZ 37231 3855 6 limited limit VBN 37231 3855 7 by by IN 37231 3855 8 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3855 9 " " `` 37231 3855 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3855 11 to to IN 37231 3855 12 the the DT 37231 3855 13 last last JJ 37231 3855 14 short short JJ 37231 3855 15 sentence(3 sentence(3 NN 37231 3855 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3855 17 corresponding correspond VBG 37231 3855 18 with with IN 37231 3855 19 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3855 20 xvii xvii NN 37231 3855 21 . . . 37231 3856 1 13 13 CD 37231 3856 2 , , , 37231 3856 3 and and CC 37231 3856 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3856 5 points point VBZ 37231 3856 6 out out RP 37231 3856 7 that that IN 37231 3856 8 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3856 9 admits admit VBZ 37231 3856 10 that that IN 37231 3856 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3856 12 must must MD 37231 3856 13 have have VB 37231 3856 14 been be VBN 37231 3856 15 taken take VBN 37231 3856 16 from from IN 37231 3856 17 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3856 18 . . . 37231 3857 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3857 2 is be VBZ 37231 3857 3 quite quite RB 37231 3857 4 true true JJ 37231 3857 5 that that IN 37231 3857 6 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3857 7 considers consider VBZ 37231 3857 8 that that IN 37231 3857 9 if if IN 37231 3857 10 any any DT 37231 3857 11 passage passage NN 37231 3857 12 of of IN 37231 3857 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3857 14 's 's POS 37231 3857 15 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3857 16 proves prove VBZ 37231 3857 17 a a DT 37231 3857 18 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3857 19 connection connection NN 37231 3857 20 between between IN 37231 3857 21 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3857 22 's 's POS 37231 3857 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3857 24 and and CC 37231 3857 25 the the DT 37231 3857 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3857 27 according accord VBG 37231 3857 28 to to IN 37231 3857 29 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3857 30 , , , 37231 3857 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3857 32 is be VBZ 37231 3857 33 this this DT 37231 3857 34 sentence sentence NN 37231 3857 35 : : : 37231 3857 36 " " `` 37231 3857 37 And and CC 37231 3857 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3857 39 is be VBZ 37231 3857 40 written write VBN 37231 3857 41 that that IN 37231 3857 42 then then RB 37231 3857 43 the the DT 37231 3857 44 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3857 45 , , , 37231 3857 46 & & CC 37231 3857 47 c. c. NNP 37231 3857 48 " " `` 37231 3857 49 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3857 50 explains explain VBZ 37231 3857 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3857 52 reason reason NN 37231 3857 53 for for IN 37231 3857 54 this this DT 37231 3857 55 opinion opinion NN 37231 3857 56 as as IN 37231 3857 57 follows follow VBZ 37231 3857 58 : : : 37231 3857 59 " " `` 37231 3857 60 These these DT 37231 3857 61 words word NNS 37231 3857 62 can can MD 37231 3857 63 only only RB 37231 3857 64 be be VB 37231 3857 65 derived derive VBN 37231 3857 66 from from IN 37231 3857 67 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3857 68 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3857 69 , , , 37231 3857 70 with with IN 37231 3857 71 which which WDT 37231 3857 72 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3857 73 literally literally RB 37231 3857 74 agree agree VBP 37231 3857 75 ; ; : 37231 3857 76 for for IN 37231 3857 77 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3857 78 is be VBZ 37231 3857 79 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 3857 80 improbable improbable JJ 37231 3857 81 that that IN 37231 3857 82 a a DT 37231 3857 83 remark remark NN 37231 3857 84 of of IN 37231 3857 85 so so RB 37231 3857 86 special special JJ 37231 3857 87 a a DT 37231 3857 88 description description NN 37231 3857 89 could could MD 37231 3857 90 have have VB 37231 3857 91 been be VBN 37231 3857 92 made make VBN 37231 3857 93 by by IN 37231 3857 94 two two CD 37231 3857 95 different different JJ 37231 3857 96 and and CC 37231 3857 97 independent independent JJ 37231 3857 98 individuals individual NNS 37231 3857 99 so so RB 37231 3857 100 completely completely RB 37231 3857 101 alike alike RB 37231 3857 102 . . . 37231 3858 1 " " `` 37231 3858 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3858 3 4 4 LS 37231 3858 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3858 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3858 6 totally totally RB 37231 3858 7 differ differ VBP 37231 3858 8 from from IN 37231 3858 9 this this DT 37231 3858 10 argument argument NN 37231 3858 11 , , , 37231 3858 12 { { -LRB- 37231 3858 13 396 396 CD 37231 3858 14 } } -RRB- 37231 3858 15 which which WDT 37231 3858 16 is be VBZ 37231 3858 17 singularly singularly RB 37231 3858 18 opposed opposed JJ 37231 3858 19 to to IN 37231 3858 20 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3858 21 's 's POS 37231 3858 22 usual usual JJ 37231 3858 23 clear clear JJ 37231 3858 24 and and CC 37231 3858 25 thoughtful thoughtful JJ 37231 3858 26 mode mode NN 37231 3858 27 of of IN 37231 3858 28 reasoning reasoning NN 37231 3858 29 . . . 37231 3859 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3859 2 1 1 LS 37231 3859 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3859 4 No no RB 37231 3859 5 doubt doubt RB 37231 3859 6 if if IN 37231 3859 7 such such JJ 37231 3859 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3859 9 could could MD 37231 3859 10 be be VB 37231 3859 11 considered consider VBN 37231 3859 12 to to TO 37231 3859 13 be be VB 37231 3859 14 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 3859 15 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3859 16 and and CC 37231 3859 17 independent independent JJ 37231 3859 18 works work NNS 37231 3859 19 , , , 37231 3859 20 deriving derive VBG 37231 3859 21 all all PDT 37231 3859 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3859 23 matter matter NN 37231 3859 24 from from IN 37231 3859 25 individual individual JJ 37231 3859 26 and and CC 37231 3859 27 separate separate JJ 37231 3859 28 observation observation NN 37231 3859 29 of of IN 37231 3859 30 the the DT 37231 3859 31 occurrences occurrence NNS 37231 3859 32 narrated narrate VBN 37231 3859 33 by by IN 37231 3859 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3859 35 authors author NNS 37231 3859 36 and and CC 37231 3859 37 personal personal JJ 37231 3859 38 report report NN 37231 3859 39 of of IN 37231 3859 40 the the DT 37231 3859 41 discourses discourse NNS 37231 3859 42 given give VBN 37231 3859 43 , , , 37231 3859 44 there there EX 37231 3859 45 might may MD 37231 3859 46 be be VB 37231 3859 47 greater great JJR 37231 3859 48 force force NN 37231 3859 49 in in IN 37231 3859 50 the the DT 37231 3859 51 argument argument NN 37231 3859 52 , , , 37231 3859 53 although although IN 37231 3859 54 even even RB 37231 3859 55 in in IN 37231 3859 56 that that DT 37231 3859 57 case case NN 37231 3859 58 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3859 59 would would MD 37231 3859 60 have have VB 37231 3859 61 been be VBN 37231 3859 62 far far RB 37231 3859 63 from from IN 37231 3859 64 conclusive conclusive JJ 37231 3859 65 here here RB 37231 3859 66 , , , 37231 3859 67 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37231 3859 68 as as IN 37231 3859 69 the the DT 37231 3859 70 observation observation NN 37231 3859 71 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3859 72 are be VBP 37231 3859 73 considering consider VBG 37231 3859 74 is be VBZ 37231 3859 75 the the DT 37231 3859 76 mere mere JJ 37231 3859 77 simple simple JJ 37231 3859 78 statement statement NN 37231 3859 79 of of IN 37231 3859 80 a a DT 37231 3859 81 fact fact NN 37231 3859 82 necessary necessary JJ 37231 3859 83 to to TO 37231 3859 84 complete complete VB 37231 3859 85 the the DT 37231 3859 86 episode episode NN 37231 3859 87 , , , 37231 3859 88 and and CC 37231 3859 89 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3859 90 might may MD 37231 3859 91 well well RB 37231 3859 92 have have VB 37231 3859 93 been be VBN 37231 3859 94 made make VBN 37231 3859 95 in in IN 37231 3859 96 the the DT 37231 3859 97 same same JJ 37231 3859 98 terms term NNS 37231 3859 99 by by IN 37231 3859 100 separate separate JJ 37231 3859 101 reporters reporter NNS 37231 3859 102 . . . 37231 3860 1 The the DT 37231 3860 2 fact fact NN 37231 3860 3 is be VBZ 37231 3860 4 , , , 37231 3860 5 however however RB 37231 3860 6 , , , 37231 3860 7 that that IN 37231 3860 8 the the DT 37231 3860 9 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3860 10 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3860 11 current current NN 37231 3860 12 in in IN 37231 3860 13 the the DT 37231 3860 14 early early JJ 37231 3860 15 Church Church NNP 37231 3860 16 can can MD 37231 3860 17 not not RB 37231 3860 18 have have VB 37231 3860 19 been be VBN 37231 3860 20 , , , 37231 3860 21 and and CC 37231 3860 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3860 23 synoptic synoptic JJ 37231 3860 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3860 25 most most RBS 37231 3860 26 certainly certainly RB 37231 3860 27 are be VBP 37231 3860 28 not not RB 37231 3860 29 , , , 37231 3860 30 independent independent JJ 37231 3860 31 works work NNS 37231 3860 32 , , , 37231 3860 33 but but CC 37231 3860 34 are be VBP 37231 3860 35 based base VBN 37231 3860 36 upon upon IN 37231 3860 37 earlier early JJR 37231 3860 38 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 3860 39 writings writing NNS 37231 3860 40 no no RB 37231 3860 41 longer long RBR 37231 3860 42 extant extant JJ 37231 3860 43 , , , 37231 3860 44 and and CC 37231 3860 45 have have VBP 37231 3860 46 borrowed borrow VBN 37231 3860 47 from from IN 37231 3860 48 each each DT 37231 3860 49 other other JJ 37231 3860 50 . . . 37231 3861 1 The the DT 37231 3861 2 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3861 3 did do VBD 37231 3861 4 not not RB 37231 3861 5 originate originate VB 37231 3861 6 full full JJ 37231 3861 7 fledged fledge VBN 37231 3861 8 as as IN 37231 3861 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3861 10 now now RB 37231 3861 11 have have VBP 37231 3861 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3861 13 , , , 37231 3861 14 but but CC 37231 3861 15 are be VBP 37231 3861 16 the the DT 37231 3861 17 result result NN 37231 3861 18 of of IN 37231 3861 19 many many JJ 37231 3861 20 revisions revision NNS 37231 3861 21 of of IN 37231 3861 22 previously previously RB 37231 3861 23 existing exist VBG 37231 3861 24 materials material NNS 37231 3861 25 . . . 37231 3862 1 Critics critic NNS 37231 3862 2 may may MD 37231 3862 3 differ differ VB 37231 3862 4 as as IN 37231 3862 5 to to IN 37231 3862 6 the the DT 37231 3862 7 relative relative JJ 37231 3862 8 ages age NNS 37231 3862 9 and and CC 37231 3862 10 order order NN 37231 3862 11 of of IN 37231 3862 12 the the DT 37231 3862 13 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3862 14 , , , 37231 3862 15 but but CC 37231 3862 16 almost almost RB 37231 3862 17 all all DT 37231 3862 18 are be VBP 37231 3862 19 agreed agree VBN 37231 3862 20 that that IN 37231 3862 21 in in IN 37231 3862 22 one one CD 37231 3862 23 order order NN 37231 3862 24 or or CC 37231 3862 25 another another DT 37231 3862 26 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3862 27 are be VBP 37231 3862 28 dependent dependent JJ 37231 3862 29 on on IN 37231 3862 30 each each DT 37231 3862 31 other other JJ 37231 3862 32 , , , 37231 3862 33 and and CC 37231 3862 34 on on IN 37231 3862 35 older old JJR 37231 3862 36 forms form NNS 37231 3862 37 of of IN 37231 3862 38 the the DT 37231 3862 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3862 40 . . . 37231 3863 1 Now now RB 37231 3863 2 such such PDT 37231 3863 3 an an DT 37231 3863 4 expression expression NN 37231 3863 5 as as IN 37231 3863 6 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3863 7 . . . 37231 3864 1 xvii xvii NN 37231 3864 2 . . . 37231 3865 1 13 13 CD 37231 3865 2 in in IN 37231 3865 3 some some DT 37231 3865 4 early early JJ 37231 3865 5 record record NN 37231 3865 6 of of IN 37231 3865 7 the the DT 37231 3865 8 discourse discourse NN 37231 3865 9 might may MD 37231 3865 10 have have VB 37231 3865 11 been be VBN 37231 3865 12 transferred transfer VBN 37231 3865 13 to to IN 37231 3865 14 a a DT 37231 3865 15 dozen dozen NN 37231 3865 16 of of IN 37231 3865 17 other other JJ 37231 3865 18 Christian christian JJ 37231 3865 19 writings writing NNS 37231 3865 20 . . . 37231 3866 1 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 3866 2 assigns assign VBZ 37231 3866 3 the the DT 37231 3866 4 passage passage NN 37231 3866 5 to to IN 37231 3866 6 the the DT 37231 3866 7 oldest old JJS 37231 3866 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3866 9 , , , 37231 3866 10 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3866 11 in in IN 37231 3866 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3866 13 present present JJ 37231 3866 14 form form NN 37231 3866 15 being be VBG 37231 3866 16 fifth fifth JJ 37231 3866 17 in in IN 37231 3866 18 descent descent NN 37231 3866 19 . . . 37231 3867 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3867 2 2 2 LS 37231 3867 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3867 4 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3867 5 three three CD 37231 3867 6 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3867 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3867 8 are be VBP 37231 3867 9 filled fill VBN 37231 3867 10 with with IN 37231 3867 11 instances instance NNS 37231 3867 12 in in IN 37231 3867 13 which which WDT 37231 3867 14 expressions expression NNS 37231 3867 15 still still RB 37231 3867 16 more more RBR 37231 3867 17 individual individual JJ 37231 3867 18 are be VBP 37231 3867 19 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3867 20 , , , 37231 3867 21 and and CC 37231 3867 22 these these DT 37231 3867 23 show show VBP 37231 3867 24 that that IN 37231 3867 25 such such JJ 37231 3867 26 phrases phrase NNS 37231 3867 27 can can MD 37231 3867 28 not not RB 37231 3867 29 be be VB 37231 3867 30 limited limit VBN 37231 3867 31 to to IN 37231 3867 32 { { -LRB- 37231 3867 33 397 397 CD 37231 3867 34 } } -RRB- 37231 3867 35 one one CD 37231 3867 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3867 37 , , , 37231 3867 38 but but CC 37231 3867 39 , , , 37231 3867 40 if if IN 37231 3867 41 confined confine VBN 37231 3867 42 in in IN 37231 3867 43 the the DT 37231 3867 44 first first JJ 37231 3867 45 instance instance NN 37231 3867 46 to to IN 37231 3867 47 one one CD 37231 3867 48 original original JJ 37231 3867 49 source source NN 37231 3867 50 , , , 37231 3867 51 may may MD 37231 3867 52 have have VB 37231 3867 53 been be VBN 37231 3867 54 transferred transfer VBN 37231 3867 55 to to IN 37231 3867 56 many many JJ 37231 3867 57 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 3867 58 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 3867 59 works work NNS 37231 3867 60 . . . 37231 3868 1 Take take VB 37231 3868 2 , , , 37231 3868 3 for for IN 37231 3868 4 instance instance NN 37231 3868 5 , , , 37231 3868 6 a a DT 37231 3868 7 passage passage NN 37231 3868 8 in in IN 37231 3868 9 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3868 10 . . . 37231 3869 1 vii vii NN 37231 3869 2 . . . 37231 3870 1 28 28 CD 37231 3870 2 , , , 37231 3870 3 29 29 CD 37231 3870 4 : : : 37231 3870 5 " " `` 37231 3870 6 .... .... NFP 37231 3870 7 the the DT 37231 3870 8 multitudes multitude NNS 37231 3870 9 were be VBD 37231 3870 10 astonished astonish VBN 37231 3870 11 at at IN 37231 3870 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3870 13 teaching teaching NN 37231 3870 14 : : : 37231 3870 15 for for IN 37231 3870 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3870 17 taught teach VBD 37231 3870 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3870 19 as as IN 37231 3870 20 having have VBG 37231 3870 21 authority authority NN 37231 3870 22 , , , 37231 3870 23 and and CC 37231 3870 24 not not RB 37231 3870 25 as as IN 37231 3870 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3870 27 scribes scribe NNS 37231 3870 28 . . . 37231 3871 1 " " `` 37231 3871 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3871 3 1 1 LS 37231 3871 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3871 5 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3871 6 i. i. NNP 37231 3872 1 22 22 CD 37231 3872 2 has have VBZ 37231 3872 3 the the DT 37231 3872 4 very very RB 37231 3872 5 same same JJ 37231 3872 6 passage,(2 passage,(2 NNP 37231 3872 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3872 8 with with IN 37231 3872 9 the the DT 37231 3872 10 mere mere JJ 37231 3872 11 omission omission NN 37231 3872 12 of of IN 37231 3872 13 " " `` 37231 3872 14 the the DT 37231 3872 15 multitudes multitude NNS 37231 3872 16 " " '' 37231 3872 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3872 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3872 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3872 20 , , , 37231 3872 21 which which WDT 37231 3872 22 does do VBZ 37231 3872 23 not not RB 37231 3872 24 in in IN 37231 3872 25 the the DT 37231 3872 26 least least JJS 37231 3872 27 affect affect VB 37231 3872 28 the the DT 37231 3872 29 argument argument NN 37231 3872 30 ; ; : 37231 3872 31 and and CC 37231 3872 32 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3872 33 iv iv NNP 37231 3872 34 . . . 37231 3873 1 32 32 CD 37231 3873 2 : : : 37231 3873 3 " " `` 37231 3873 4 And and CC 37231 3873 5 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3873 6 were be VBD 37231 3873 7 astonished astonish VBN 37231 3873 8 at at IN 37231 3873 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3873 10 teaching teaching NN 37231 3873 11 : : : 37231 3873 12 for for IN 37231 3873 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3873 14 word word NN 37231 3873 15 was be VBD 37231 3873 16 power power NN 37231 3873 17 . . . 37231 3874 1 " " `` 37231 3874 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3874 3 3 3 LS 37231 3874 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3874 5 Although although IN 37231 3874 6 the the DT 37231 3874 7 author author NN 37231 3874 8 of of IN 37231 3874 9 the the DT 37231 3874 10 third third JJ 37231 3874 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3874 12 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 3874 13 alters alter VBZ 37231 3874 14 the the DT 37231 3874 15 language language NN 37231 3874 16 , , , 37231 3874 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3874 18 is be VBZ 37231 3874 19 clear clear JJ 37231 3874 20 that that IN 37231 3874 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3874 22 follows follow VBZ 37231 3874 23 the the DT 37231 3874 24 same same JJ 37231 3874 25 original original JJ 37231 3874 26 , , , 37231 3874 27 and and CC 37231 3874 28 retains retain VBZ 37231 3874 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3874 30 in in IN 37231 3874 31 the the DT 37231 3874 32 same same JJ 37231 3874 33 context context NN 37231 3874 34 as as IN 37231 3874 35 the the DT 37231 3874 36 second second JJ 37231 3874 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3874 38 . . . 37231 3875 1 Now now RB 37231 3875 2 the the DT 37231 3875 3 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 3875 4 of of IN 37231 3875 5 such such PDT 37231 3875 6 a a DT 37231 3875 7 passage passage NN 37231 3875 8 as as IN 37231 3875 9 this this DT 37231 3875 10 in in IN 37231 3875 11 one one CD 37231 3875 12 of of IN 37231 3875 13 the the DT 37231 3875 14 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 3875 15 , , , 37231 3875 16 if if IN 37231 3875 17 either either CC 37231 3875 18 the the DT 37231 3875 19 first first JJ 37231 3875 20 or or CC 37231 3875 21 second second JJ 37231 3875 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3875 23 were be VBD 37231 3875 24 lost lose VBN 37231 3875 25 , , , 37231 3875 26 would would MD 37231 3875 27 , , , 37231 3875 28 on on IN 37231 3875 29 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3875 30 's 's POS 37231 3875 31 grounds ground NNS 37231 3875 32 , , , 37231 3875 33 be be VB 37231 3875 34 attributed attribute VBN 37231 3875 35 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 37231 3875 36 to to IN 37231 3875 37 the the DT 37231 3875 38 survivor survivor NN 37231 3875 39 , , , 37231 3875 40 although although IN 37231 3875 41 in in IN 37231 3875 42 reality reality NN 37231 3875 43 derived derive VBN 37231 3875 44 from from IN 37231 3875 45 the the DT 37231 3875 46 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3875 47 no no RB 37231 3875 48 longer long RBR 37231 3875 49 extant extant JJ 37231 3875 50 , , , 37231 3875 51 which which WDT 37231 3875 52 likewise likewise RB 37231 3875 53 contained contain VBD 37231 3875 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3875 55 . . . 37231 3876 1 Another another DT 37231 3876 2 example example NN 37231 3876 3 may may MD 37231 3876 4 be be VB 37231 3876 5 pointed point VBN 37231 3876 6 out out RP 37231 3876 7 in in IN 37231 3876 8 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3876 9 . . . 37231 3877 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 3877 2 . . . 37231 3878 1 34 34 CD 37231 3878 2 : : : 37231 3878 3 " " `` 37231 3878 4 All all PDT 37231 3878 5 these these DT 37231 3878 6 things thing NNS 37231 3878 7 spake spake VBP 37231 3878 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3878 9 unto unto IN 37231 3878 10 the the DT 37231 3878 11 multitudes multitude NNS 37231 3878 12 in in IN 37231 3878 13 parables parable NNS 37231 3878 14 ; ; : 37231 3878 15 and and CC 37231 3878 16 _ _ NNP 37231 3878 17 without without IN 37231 3878 18 a a DT 37231 3878 19 parable parable JJ 37231 3878 20 spake spake NN 37231 3878 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3878 22 not not RB 37231 3878 23 unto unto IN 37231 3878 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3878 25 _ _ RP 37231 3878 26 , , , 37231 3878 27 " " '' 37231 3878 28 compared compare VBN 37231 3878 29 with with IN 37231 3878 30 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3878 31 iv iv NNP 37231 3878 32 . . . 37231 3879 1 33 33 CD 37231 3879 2 , , , 37231 3879 3 34 34 CD 37231 3879 4 , , , 37231 3879 5 " " `` 37231 3879 6 And and CC 37231 3879 7 with with IN 37231 3879 8 many many JJ 37231 3879 9 such such JJ 37231 3879 10 parables parable NNS 37231 3879 11 spake spake VBP 37231 3879 12 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3879 13 the the DT 37231 3879 14 word word NN 37231 3879 15 unto unto IN 37231 3879 16 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3879 17 .... .... NFP 37231 3879 18 and and CC 37231 3879 19 without without IN 37231 3879 20 a a DT 37231 3879 21 parable parable JJ 37231 3879 22 spake spake NN 37231 3879 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3879 24 not not RB 37231 3879 25 unto unto IN 37231 3879 26 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3879 27 . . . 37231 3879 28 " " '' 37231 3880 1 The the DT 37231 3880 2 part part NN 37231 3880 3 of of IN 37231 3880 4 this this DT 37231 3880 5 very very JJ 37231 3880 6 individual individual JJ 37231 3880 7 remark remark NN 37231 3880 8 which which WDT 37231 3880 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3880 10 have have VBP 37231 3880 11 italicised italicise VBN 37231 3880 12 is be VBZ 37231 3880 13 literally literally RB 37231 3880 14 the the DT 37231 3880 15 same same JJ 37231 3880 16 in in IN 37231 3880 17 both both DT 37231 3880 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3880 19 , , , 37231 3880 20 as as IN 37231 3880 21 a a DT 37231 3880 22 personal personal JJ 37231 3880 23 comment comment NN 37231 3880 24 at at IN 37231 3880 25 the the DT 37231 3880 26 end end NN 37231 3880 27 of of IN 37231 3880 28 the the DT 37231 3880 29 parable parable NN 37231 3880 30 of of IN 37231 3880 31 the the DT 37231 3880 32 grain grain NN 37231 3880 33 of of IN 37231 3880 34 mustard mustard NN 37231 3880 35 seed seed NN 37231 3880 36 . . . 37231 3881 1 Then then RB 37231 3881 2 , , , 37231 3881 3 for for IN 37231 3881 4 instance instance NN 37231 3881 5 , , , 37231 3881 6 in in IN 37231 3881 7 the the DT 37231 3881 8 account account NN 37231 3881 9 { { -LRB- 37231 3881 10 398 398 CD 37231 3881 11 } } -RRB- 37231 3881 12 of of IN 37231 3881 13 the the DT 37231 3881 14 sleep sleep NN 37231 3881 15 of of IN 37231 3881 16 the the DT 37231 3881 17 three three CD 37231 3881 18 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3881 19 during during IN 37231 3881 20 the the DT 37231 3881 21 agony agony NN 37231 3881 22 in in IN 37231 3881 23 the the DT 37231 3881 24 Garden Garden NNP 37231 3881 25 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3881 26 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3881 27 . . . 37231 3882 1 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 3882 2 . . . 37231 3883 1 43 43 CD 37231 3883 2 , , , 37231 3883 3 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3883 4 xiv xiv NNP 37231 3883 5 . . . 37231 3884 1 40 40 CD 37231 3884 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3884 3 , , , 37231 3884 4 the the DT 37231 3884 5 expression expression NN 37231 3884 6 " " '' 37231 3884 7 and and CC 37231 3884 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3884 9 found find VBD 37231 3884 10 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3884 11 asleep asleep JJ 37231 3884 12 , , , 37231 3884 13 _ _ NNP 37231 3884 14 for for IN 37231 3884 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3884 16 eyes eye NNS 37231 3884 17 were be VBD 37231 3884 18 heavy heavy JJ 37231 3884 19 _ _ NNP 37231 3884 20 , , , 37231 3884 21 " " '' 37231 3884 22 which which WDT 37231 3884 23 is be VBZ 37231 3884 24 equally equally RB 37231 3884 25 individual individual JJ 37231 3884 26 , , , 37231 3884 27 is be VBZ 37231 3884 28 literally literally RB 37231 3884 29 the the DT 37231 3884 30 same same JJ 37231 3884 31 in in IN 37231 3884 32 the the DT 37231 3884 33 first first JJ 37231 3884 34 two two CD 37231 3884 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3884 36 . . . 37231 3885 1 Another another DT 37231 3885 2 special special JJ 37231 3885 3 remark remark NN 37231 3885 4 of of IN 37231 3885 5 a a DT 37231 3885 6 similar similar JJ 37231 3885 7 kind kind NN 37231 3885 8 regarding regard VBG 37231 3885 9 the the DT 37231 3885 10 rich rich JJ 37231 3885 11 young young JJ 37231 3885 12 man man NN 37231 3885 13 : : : 37231 3885 14 " " `` 37231 3885 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3885 16 went go VBD 37231 3885 17 away away RB 37231 3885 18 sorrowful sorrowful JJ 37231 3885 19 , , , 37231 3885 20 for for IN 37231 3885 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3885 22 had have VBD 37231 3885 23 great great JJ 37231 3885 24 possessions possession NNS 37231 3885 25 , , , 37231 3885 26 " " '' 37231 3885 27 is be VBZ 37231 3885 28 found find VBN 37231 3885 29 both both DT 37231 3885 30 in in IN 37231 3885 31 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3885 32 . . . 37231 3886 1 xix xix NNP 37231 3886 2 . . . 37231 3887 1 22 22 CD 37231 3887 2 and and CC 37231 3887 3 Mark Mark NNP 37231 3887 4 x. x. . 37231 3888 1 22 22 CD 37231 3888 2 . . . 37231 3889 1 Such such JJ 37231 3889 2 examples(1 examples(1 NN 37231 3889 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3889 4 might may MD 37231 3889 5 be be VB 37231 3889 6 multiplied multiply VBN 37231 3889 7 , , , 37231 3889 8 and and CC 37231 3889 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3889 10 show show VBP 37231 3889 11 that that IN 37231 3889 12 the the DT 37231 3889 13 occurrence occurrence NN 37231 3889 14 of of IN 37231 3889 15 passages passage NNS 37231 3889 16 of of IN 37231 3889 17 the the DT 37231 3889 18 most most RBS 37231 3889 19 individual individual JJ 37231 3889 20 character character NN 37231 3889 21 can can MD 37231 3889 22 not not RB 37231 3889 23 , , , 37231 3889 24 in in IN 37231 3889 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3889 26 's 's POS 37231 3889 27 time time NN 37231 3889 28 , , , 37231 3889 29 be be VB 37231 3889 30 limited limited JJ 37231 3889 31 to to IN 37231 3889 32 any any DT 37231 3889 33 single single JJ 37231 3889 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3889 35 . . . 37231 3890 1 Now now RB 37231 3890 2 the the DT 37231 3890 3 verse verse NN 37231 3890 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3890 5 are be VBP 37231 3890 6 discussing discuss VBG 37231 3890 7 , , , 37231 3890 8 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3890 9 xvii xvii NN 37231 3890 10 . . . 37231 3891 1 13 13 CD 37231 3891 2 , , , 37231 3891 3 in in IN 37231 3891 4 all all DT 37231 3891 5 probability probability NN 37231 3891 6 , , , 37231 3891 7 as as IN 37231 3891 8 Ewald Ewald NNP 37231 3891 9 supposes suppose VBZ 37231 3891 10 , , , 37231 3891 11 occurred occur VBD 37231 3891 12 in in IN 37231 3891 13 one one CD 37231 3891 14 or or CC 37231 3891 15 more more JJR 37231 3891 16 of of IN 37231 3891 17 the the DT 37231 3891 18 older old JJR 37231 3891 19 forms form NNS 37231 3891 20 of of IN 37231 3891 21 the the DT 37231 3891 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3891 23 from from IN 37231 3891 24 which which WDT 37231 3891 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3891 26 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 3891 27 and and CC 37231 3891 28 many many JJ 37231 3891 29 other other JJ 37231 3891 30 similar similar JJ 37231 3891 31 works work NNS 37231 3891 32 derived derive VBD 37231 3891 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3891 34 matter matter NN 37231 3891 35 , , , 37231 3891 36 and and CC 37231 3891 37 nothing nothing NN 37231 3891 38 is be VBZ 37231 3891 39 more more RBR 37231 3891 40 likely likely JJ 37231 3891 41 than than IN 37231 3891 42 that that DT 37231 3891 43 the the DT 37231 3891 44 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3891 45 according accord VBG 37231 3891 46 to to IN 37231 3891 47 the the DT 37231 3891 48 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 3891 49 , , , 37231 3891 50 which which WDT 37231 3891 51 in in IN 37231 3891 52 many many JJ 37231 3891 53 respects respect NNS 37231 3891 54 was be VBD 37231 3891 55 nearly nearly RB 37231 3891 56 related relate VBN 37231 3891 57 to to IN 37231 3891 58 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3891 59 , , , 37231 3891 60 may may MD 37231 3891 61 have have VB 37231 3891 62 contained contain VBN 37231 3891 63 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3891 64 . . . 37231 3892 1 At at IN 37231 3892 2 any any DT 37231 3892 3 rate rate NN 37231 3892 4 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3892 5 have have VBP 37231 3892 6 shown show VBN 37231 3892 7 that that IN 37231 3892 8 such such JJ 37231 3892 9 sayings saying NNS 37231 3892 10 can can MD 37231 3892 11 not not RB 37231 3892 12 , , , 37231 3892 13 however however RB 37231 3892 14 apparently apparently RB 37231 3892 15 individual individual JJ 37231 3892 16 , , , 37231 3892 17 be be VB 37231 3892 18 considered consider VBN 37231 3892 19 evidence evidence NN 37231 3892 20 of of IN 37231 3892 21 the the DT 37231 3892 22 use use NN 37231 3892 23 of of IN 37231 3892 24 a a DT 37231 3892 25 particular particular JJ 37231 3892 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3892 27 simply simply RB 37231 3892 28 because because IN 37231 3892 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3892 30 happens happen VBZ 37231 3892 31 to to TO 37231 3892 32 be be VB 37231 3892 33 the the DT 37231 3892 34 only only JJ 37231 3892 35 one one CD 37231 3892 36 now now RB 37231 3892 37 extant extant JJ 37231 3892 38 which which WDT 37231 3892 39 contains contain VBZ 37231 3892 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3892 41 . . . 37231 3893 1 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3893 2 , , , 37231 3893 3 however however RB 37231 3893 4 , , , 37231 3893 5 whilst whilst IN 37231 3893 6 expressing express VBG 37231 3893 7 the the DT 37231 3893 8 opinion opinion NN 37231 3893 9 which which WDT 37231 3893 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3893 11 have have VBP 37231 3893 12 quoted quote VBN 37231 3893 13 likewise likewise RB 37231 3893 14 adds add VBZ 37231 3893 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3893 16 belief belief NN 37231 3893 17 that that IN 37231 3893 18 by by IN 37231 3893 19 the the DT 37231 3893 20 expression expression NN 37231 3893 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3893 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3893 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3893 24 , , , 37231 3893 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3893 26 seems seem VBZ 37231 3893 27 expressly expressly RB 37231 3893 28 to to TO 37231 3893 29 indicate indicate VB 37231 3893 30 that that IN 37231 3893 31 this this DT 37231 3893 32 sentence sentence NN 37231 3893 33 is be VBZ 37231 3893 34 taken take VBN 37231 3893 35 from from IN 37231 3893 36 a a DT 37231 3893 37 different different JJ 37231 3893 38 work work NN 37231 3893 39 from from IN 37231 3893 40 what what WP 37231 3893 41 precedes precede NNS 37231 3893 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3893 43 , , , 37231 3893 44 and and CC 37231 3893 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3893 46 has have VBZ 37231 3893 47 proved prove VBN 37231 3893 48 that that IN 37231 3893 49 the the DT 37231 3893 50 preceding precede VBG 37231 3893 51 part part NN 37231 3893 52 of of IN 37231 3893 53 the the DT 37231 3893 54 quotation quotation NN 37231 3893 55 was be VBD 37231 3893 56 not not RB 37231 3893 57 derived derive VBN 37231 3893 58 from from IN 37231 3893 59 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3893 60 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3893 61 . . . 37231 3894 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3894 2 2 2 LS 37231 3894 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3894 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3894 5 can can MD 37231 3894 6 not not RB 37231 3894 7 , , , 37231 3894 8 however however RB 37231 3894 9 , , , 37231 3894 10 coincide coincide VB 37231 3894 11 with with IN 37231 3894 12 this this DT 37231 3894 13 opinion opinion NN 37231 3894 14 either either RB 37231 3894 15 . . . 37231 3895 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3895 2 seems seem VBZ 37231 3895 3 to to IN 37231 3895 4 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3895 5 that that IN 37231 3895 6 the the DT 37231 3895 7 expression expression NN 37231 3895 8 " " '' 37231 3895 9 and and CC 37231 3895 10 { { -LRB- 37231 3895 11 399 399 CD 37231 3895 12 } } -RRB- 37231 3895 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3895 14 is be VBZ 37231 3895 15 written write VBN 37231 3895 16 " " `` 37231 3895 17 simply simply RB 37231 3895 18 was be VBD 37231 3895 19 made make VBN 37231 3895 20 use use NN 37231 3895 21 of of IN 37231 3895 22 by by IN 37231 3895 23 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3895 24 to to TO 37231 3895 25 show show VB 37231 3895 26 that that IN 37231 3895 27 the the DT 37231 3895 28 identification identification NN 37231 3895 29 of of IN 37231 3895 30 Elias Elias NNP 37231 3895 31 with with IN 37231 3895 32 John John NNP 37231 3895 33 the the DT 37231 3895 34 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 3895 35 is be VBZ 37231 3895 36 not not RB 37231 3895 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3895 38 , , , 37231 3895 39 but but CC 37231 3895 40 was be VBD 37231 3895 41 the the DT 37231 3895 42 impression impression NN 37231 3895 43 conveyed convey VBN 37231 3895 44 at at IN 37231 3895 45 the the DT 37231 3895 46 time time NN 37231 3895 47 by by IN 37231 3895 48 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3895 49 to to IN 37231 3895 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3895 51 disciples disciple NNS 37231 3895 52 . . . 37231 3896 1 Now now RB 37231 3896 2 the the DT 37231 3896 3 whole whole JJ 37231 3896 4 narrative narrative NN 37231 3896 5 of of IN 37231 3896 6 the the DT 37231 3896 7 baptism baptism NN 37231 3896 8 of of IN 37231 3896 9 John John NNP 37231 3896 10 in in IN 37231 3896 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3896 12 bears bear VBZ 37231 3896 13 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 3896 14 marks mark NNS 37231 3896 15 of of IN 37231 3896 16 being be VBG 37231 3896 17 from from IN 37231 3896 18 a a DT 37231 3896 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3896 20 different different JJ 37231 3896 21 from from IN 37231 3896 22 ours,(1 ours,(1 NNP 37231 3896 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3896 24 and and CC 37231 3896 25 in in IN 37231 3896 26 the the DT 37231 3896 27 first first JJ 37231 3896 28 part part NN 37231 3896 29 of of IN 37231 3896 30 this this DT 37231 3896 31 very very JJ 37231 3896 32 quotation quotation NN 37231 3896 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3896 34 find find VBP 37231 3896 35 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3896 36 variation variation NN 37231 3896 37 . . . 37231 3897 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3897 2 first first JJ 37231 3897 3 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 3897 4 that that IN 37231 3897 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3897 6 in in IN 37231 3897 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3897 8 teaching teaching NN 37231 3897 9 had have VBD 37231 3897 10 proclaimed proclaim VBN 37231 3897 11 that that IN 37231 3897 12 Elias Elias NNP 37231 3897 13 should should MD 37231 3897 14 also also RB 37231 3897 15 come come VB 37231 3897 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3897 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3897 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3897 19 , , , 37231 3897 20 and and CC 37231 3897 21 then then RB 37231 3897 22 further further RB 37231 3897 23 on on RB 37231 3897 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3897 25 gives give VBZ 37231 3897 26 the the DT 37231 3897 27 actual actual JJ 37231 3897 28 words word NNS 37231 3897 29 of of IN 37231 3897 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3897 31 : : : 37231 3897 32 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3897 33 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3897 34 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3897 35 , , , 37231 3897 36 which which WDT 37231 3897 37 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3897 38 have have VBP 37231 3897 39 before before IN 37231 3897 40 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3897 41 , , , 37231 3897 42 whilst whilst IN 37231 3897 43 in in IN 37231 3897 44 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3897 45 the the DT 37231 3897 46 words word NNS 37231 3897 47 are be VBP 37231 3897 48 : : : 37231 3897 49 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3897 50 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3897 51 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3897 52 and and CC 37231 3897 53 there there EX 37231 3897 54 is be VBZ 37231 3897 55 no no DT 37231 3897 56 MS MS NNP 37231 3897 57 . . . 37231 3897 58 which which WDT 37231 3897 59 reads read VBZ 37231 3897 60 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3897 61 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3897 62 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3897 63 for for IN 37231 3897 64 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3897 65 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3897 66 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3897 67 , , , 37231 3897 68 and and CC 37231 3897 69 yet yet RB 37231 3897 70 , , , 37231 3897 71 as as IN 37231 3897 72 Credner Credner NNP 37231 3897 73 remarks remark VBZ 37231 3897 74 , , , 37231 3897 75 the the DT 37231 3897 76 whole whole JJ 37231 3897 77 force force NN 37231 3897 78 of of IN 37231 3897 79 the the DT 37231 3897 80 quotation quotation NN 37231 3897 81 rests rest VBZ 37231 3897 82 upon upon IN 37231 3897 83 the the DT 37231 3897 84 word word NN 37231 3897 85 , , , 37231 3897 86 and and CC 37231 3897 87 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3897 88 is be VBZ 37231 3897 89 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3897 90 in in IN 37231 3897 91 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3897 92 variation variation NN 37231 3897 93 from from IN 37231 3897 94 the the DT 37231 3897 95 text text NN 37231 3897 96 of of IN 37231 3897 97 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3897 98 first first JJ 37231 3897 99 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 3897 100 . . . 37231 3898 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3898 2 is be VBZ 37231 3898 3 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 3898 4 to to TO 37231 3898 5 say say VB 37231 3898 6 that that IN 37231 3898 7 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3898 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3898 9 loosely loosely RB 37231 3898 10 the the DT 37231 3898 11 important important JJ 37231 3898 12 part part NN 37231 3898 13 of of IN 37231 3898 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3898 15 passage passage NN 37231 3898 16 , , , 37231 3898 17 and and CC 37231 3898 18 then then RB 37231 3898 19 about about IN 37231 3898 20 a a DT 37231 3898 21 few few JJ 37231 3898 22 words word NNS 37231 3898 23 at at IN 37231 3898 24 the the DT 37231 3898 25 close close JJ 37231 3898 26 pretends pretend NNS 37231 3898 27 to to TO 37231 3898 28 be be VB 37231 3898 29 so so RB 37231 3898 30 particularly particularly RB 37231 3898 31 careful careful JJ 37231 3898 32 . . . 37231 3899 1 Considering consider VBG 37231 3899 2 all all PDT 37231 3899 3 the the DT 37231 3899 4 facts fact NNS 37231 3899 5 of of IN 37231 3899 6 the the DT 37231 3899 7 case case NN 37231 3899 8 , , , 37231 3899 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3899 10 must must MD 37231 3899 11 conclude conclude VB 37231 3899 12 that that IN 37231 3899 13 this this DT 37231 3899 14 quotation quotation NN 37231 3899 15 also also RB 37231 3899 16 is be VBZ 37231 3899 17 from from IN 37231 3899 18 a a DT 37231 3899 19 source source NN 37231 3899 20 different different JJ 37231 3899 21 from from IN 37231 3899 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3899 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3899 24 . . . 37231 3900 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3900 2 2 2 LS 37231 3900 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3900 4 Another another DT 37231 3900 5 point point NN 37231 3900 6 , , , 37231 3900 7 however however RB 37231 3900 8 , , , 37231 3900 9 must must MD 37231 3900 10 be be VB 37231 3900 11 noted note VBN 37231 3900 12 . . . 37231 3901 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3901 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3901 3 claims claim VBZ 37231 3901 4 this this DT 37231 3901 5 passage passage NN 37231 3901 6 as as IN 37231 3901 7 an an DT 37231 3901 8 express express JJ 37231 3901 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 3901 10 from from IN 37231 3901 11 the the DT 37231 3901 12 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3901 13 , , , 37231 3901 14 apparently apparently RB 37231 3901 15 for for IN 37231 3901 16 no no DT 37231 3901 17 other other JJ 37231 3901 18 reason reason NN 37231 3901 19 than than IN 37231 3901 20 that that IN 37231 3901 21 the the DT 37231 3901 22 few few JJ 37231 3901 23 words word NNS 37231 3901 24 happen happen VB 37231 3901 25 to to TO 37231 3901 26 agree agree VB 37231 3901 27 with with IN 37231 3901 28 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3901 29 . . . 37231 3902 1 xvii xvii NN 37231 3902 2 . . . 37231 3903 1 13 13 CD 37231 3903 2 , , , 37231 3903 3 and and CC 37231 3903 4 that that IN 37231 3903 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3903 6 wishes wish VBZ 37231 3903 7 to to TO 37231 3903 8 identify identify VB 37231 3903 9 the the DT 37231 3903 10 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3903 11 with with IN 37231 3903 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3903 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3903 14 . . . 37231 3904 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3904 2 , , , 37231 3904 3 however however RB 37231 3904 4 , , , 37231 3904 5 does do VBZ 37231 3904 6 not not RB 37231 3904 7 once once RB 37231 3904 8 mention mention VB 37231 3904 9 the the DT 37231 3904 10 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3904 11 in in IN 37231 3904 12 this this DT 37231 3904 13 chapter chapter NN 37231 3904 14 ; ; : 37231 3904 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3904 16 follows follow VBZ 37231 3904 17 , , , 37231 3904 18 therefore therefore RB 37231 3904 19 , , , 37231 3904 20 that that IN 37231 3904 21 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3904 22 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3904 23 who who WP 37231 3904 24 is be VBZ 37231 3904 25 so so RB 37231 3904 26 exceedingly exceedingly RB 37231 3904 27 strict strict JJ 37231 3904 28 in in IN 37231 3904 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3904 30 limitation limitation NN 37231 3904 31 of of IN 37231 3904 32 express express JJ 37231 3904 33 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3904 34 , , , 37231 3904 35 assumes assume VBZ 37231 3904 36 that that IN 37231 3904 37 all all DT 37231 3904 38 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3904 39 of of IN 37231 3904 40 Christian christian JJ 37231 3904 41 history history NN 37231 3904 42 and and CC 37231 3904 43 words word NNS 37231 3904 44 of of IN 37231 3904 45 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3904 46 in in IN 37231 3904 47 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3904 48 are be VBP 37231 3904 49 to to TO 37231 3904 50 be be VB 37231 3904 51 considered consider VBN 37231 3904 52 { { -LRB- 37231 3904 53 400 400 CD 37231 3904 54 } } -RRB- 37231 3904 55 as as IN 37231 3904 56 derived derive VBN 37231 3904 57 from from IN 37231 3904 58 the the DT 37231 3904 59 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3904 60 whether whether IN 37231 3904 61 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3904 62 be be VBP 37231 3904 63 mentioned mention VBN 37231 3904 64 by by IN 37231 3904 65 name name NN 37231 3904 66 or or CC 37231 3904 67 not not RB 37231 3904 68 . . . 37231 3905 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3905 2 have have VBP 37231 3905 3 already already RB 37231 3905 4 seen see VBN 37231 3905 5 that that IN 37231 3905 6 amongst amongst IN 37231 3905 7 these these DT 37231 3905 8 there there EX 37231 3905 9 are be VBP 37231 3905 10 not not RB 37231 3905 11 only only RB 37231 3905 12 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3905 13 differing differ VBG 37231 3905 14 from from IN 37231 3905 15 the the DT 37231 3905 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3905 17 , , , 37231 3905 18 and and CC 37231 3905 19 contradicting contradict VBG 37231 3905 20 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3905 21 , , , 37231 3905 22 but but CC 37231 3905 23 others other NNS 37231 3905 24 which which WDT 37231 3905 25 have have VBP 37231 3905 26 no no DT 37231 3905 27 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3905 28 at at RB 37231 3905 29 all all RB 37231 3905 30 in in IN 37231 3905 31 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3905 32 . . . 37231 3906 1 The the DT 37231 3906 2 fifth fifth NN 37231 3906 3 of of IN 37231 3906 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3906 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3906 6 's 's POS 37231 3906 7 express express JJ 37231 3906 8 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3906 9 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3906 10 in in IN 37231 3906 11 Dial Dial NNP 37231 3906 12 . . . 37231 3907 1 105 105 CD 37231 3907 2 , , , 37231 3907 3 where where WRB 37231 3907 4 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3907 5 says say VBZ 37231 3907 6 : : : 37231 3907 7 " " `` 37231 3907 8 For for IN 37231 3907 9 when when WRB 37231 3907 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3907 11 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3907 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3907 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3907 14 was be VBD 37231 3907 15 giving give VBG 37231 3907 16 up up RP 37231 3907 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3907 18 spirit spirit NN 37231 3907 19 on on IN 37231 3907 20 the the DT 37231 3907 21 cross cross NN 37231 3907 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3907 23 said say VBD 37231 3907 24 : : : 37231 3907 25 ' ' '' 37231 3907 26 Father Father NNP 37231 3907 27 , , , 37231 3907 28 into into IN 37231 3907 29 thy thy PRP$ 37231 3907 30 hands hand NNS 37231 3907 31 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3907 32 commend commend VBP 37231 3907 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3907 34 spirit spirit NN 37231 3907 35 , , , 37231 3907 36 ' ' '' 37231 3907 37 as as IN 37231 3907 38 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3907 39 have have VBP 37231 3907 40 also also RB 37231 3907 41 learned learn VBN 37231 3907 42 from from IN 37231 3907 43 the the DT 37231 3907 44 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3907 45 . . . 37231 3907 46 " " '' 37231 3908 1 This this DT 37231 3908 2 short short JJ 37231 3908 3 sentence sentence NN 37231 3908 4 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3908 5 with with IN 37231 3908 6 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3908 7 xxiii xxiii NN 37231 3908 8 . . . 37231 3909 1 46 46 CD 37231 3909 2 , , , 37231 3909 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3909 4 is be VBZ 37231 3909 5 true true JJ 37231 3909 6 , , , 37231 3909 7 but but CC 37231 3909 8 as as IN 37231 3909 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3909 10 have have VBP 37231 3909 11 already already RB 37231 3909 12 shown,1 shown,1 VBN 37231 3909 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3909 14 's 's POS 37231 3909 15 whole whole JJ 37231 3909 16 account account NN 37231 3909 17 of of IN 37231 3909 18 the the DT 37231 3909 19 Crucifixion Crucifixion NNP 37231 3909 20 differs differ NNS 37231 3909 21 so so RB 37231 3909 22 materially materially RB 37231 3909 23 from from IN 37231 3909 24 that that DT 37231 3909 25 in in IN 37231 3909 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3909 27 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3909 28 that that IN 37231 3909 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3909 30 can can MD 37231 3909 31 not not RB 37231 3909 32 have have VB 37231 3909 33 been be VBN 37231 3909 34 derived derive VBN 37231 3909 35 from from IN 37231 3909 36 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3909 37 . . . 37231 3910 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3910 2 see see VBP 37231 3910 3 this this DT 37231 3910 4 forcibly forcibly RB 37231 3910 5 in in IN 37231 3910 6 examining examine VBG 37231 3910 7 the the DT 37231 3910 8 sixth sixth JJ 37231 3910 9 of of IN 37231 3910 10 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3910 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3910 12 's 's POS 37231 3910 13 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3910 14 , , , 37231 3910 15 which which WDT 37231 3910 16 is be VBZ 37231 3910 17 likewise likewise RB 37231 3910 18 connected connect VBN 37231 3910 19 with with IN 37231 3910 20 the the DT 37231 3910 21 Crucifixion Crucifixion NNP 37231 3910 22 . . . 37231 3911 1 " " `` 37231 3911 2 For for IN 37231 3911 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 4 who who WP 37231 3911 5 saw see VBD 37231 3911 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 7 crucified crucify VBN 37231 3911 8 also also RB 37231 3911 9 wagged wag VBD 37231 3911 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3911 11 heads head NNS 37231 3911 12 each each DT 37231 3911 13 one one CD 37231 3911 14 of of IN 37231 3911 15 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 16 , , , 37231 3911 17 and and CC 37231 3911 18 distorted distort VBD 37231 3911 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3911 20 lips lip NNS 37231 3911 21 , , , 37231 3911 22 and and CC 37231 3911 23 sneeringly sneeringly RB 37231 3911 24 and and CC 37231 3911 25 in in IN 37231 3911 26 scornful scornful JJ 37231 3911 27 irony irony NN 37231 3911 28 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3911 29 among among IN 37231 3911 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 31 those those DT 37231 3911 32 words word NNS 37231 3911 33 which which WDT 37231 3911 34 are be VBP 37231 3911 35 also also RB 37231 3911 36 written write VBN 37231 3911 37 in in IN 37231 3911 38 the the DT 37231 3911 39 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3911 40 of of IN 37231 3911 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3911 42 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3911 43 : : : 37231 3911 44 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 45 declared declare VBD 37231 3911 46 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 47 the the DT 37231 3911 48 son son NN 37231 3911 49 of of IN 37231 3911 50 God God NNP 37231 3911 51 : : : 37231 3911 52 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3911 53 let let VB 37231 3911 54 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 55 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3911 56 come come VB 37231 3911 57 down down RP 37231 3911 58 , , , 37231 3911 59 let let VB 37231 3911 60 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 61 walk walk VB 37231 3911 62 about about IN 37231 3911 63 : : : 37231 3911 64 let let VB 37231 3911 65 God God NNP 37231 3911 66 save save VB 37231 3911 67 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3911 68 . . . 37231 3912 1 " " `` 37231 3912 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3912 3 2 2 LS 37231 3912 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3912 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3912 6 have have VBP 37231 3912 7 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3912 8 already already RB 37231 3912 9 quoted quote VBN 37231 3912 10 and and CC 37231 3912 11 discussed discuss VBN 37231 3912 12 this this DT 37231 3912 13 passage,(3 passage,(3 NN 37231 3912 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3912 15 and and CC 37231 3912 16 need need VBP 37231 3912 17 not not RB 37231 3912 18 further further RB 37231 3912 19 examine examine VB 37231 3912 20 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3912 21 here here RB 37231 3912 22 . . . 37231 3913 1 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3913 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3913 3 has have VBZ 37231 3913 4 nothing nothing NN 37231 3913 5 better well JJR 37231 3913 6 to to TO 37231 3913 7 say say VB 37231 3913 8 regarding regard VBG 37231 3913 9 this this DT 37231 3913 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 3913 11 , , , 37231 3913 12 in in IN 37231 3913 13 an an DT 37231 3913 14 examination examination NN 37231 3913 15 of of IN 37231 3913 16 the the DT 37231 3913 17 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3913 18 of of IN 37231 3913 19 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3913 20 passages passage NNS 37231 3913 21 , , , 37231 3913 22 than than IN 37231 3913 23 this this DT 37231 3913 24 : : : 37231 3913 25 " " `` 37231 3913 26 These these DT 37231 3913 27 exact exact JJ 37231 3913 28 words word NNS 37231 3913 29 do do VBP 37231 3913 30 not not RB 37231 3913 31 occur occur VB 37231 3913 32 in in IN 37231 3913 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3913 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3913 35 , , , 37231 3913 36 but but CC 37231 3913 37 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3913 38 do do VBP 37231 3913 39 find find VB 37231 3913 40 there there PRP$ 37231 3913 41 others other NNS 37231 3913 42 so so RB 37231 3913 43 closely closely RB 37231 3913 44 connected connected JJ 37231 3913 45 with with IN 37231 3913 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3913 47 that that IN 37231 3913 48 few few JJ 37231 3913 49 readers reader NNS 37231 3913 50 would would MD 37231 3913 51 feel feel VB 37231 3913 52 the the DT 37231 3913 53 difference difference NN 37231 3913 54 " " '' 37231 3913 55 ! ! . 37231 3914 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3914 2 4 4 LS 37231 3914 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3914 4 When when WRB 37231 3914 5 criticism criticism NN 37231 3914 6 descends descend VBZ 37231 3914 7 to to TO 37231 3914 8 language language VB 37231 3914 9 like like IN 37231 3914 10 this this DT 37231 3914 11 , , , 37231 3914 12 the the DT 37231 3914 13 case case NN 37231 3914 14 is be VBZ 37231 3914 15 indeed indeed RB 37231 3914 16 desperate desperate JJ 37231 3914 17 . . . 37231 3915 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3915 2 is be VBZ 37231 3915 3 clear clear JJ 37231 3915 4 that that IN 37231 3915 5 , , , 37231 3915 6 as as IN 37231 3915 7 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3915 8 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3915 9 admits admit VBZ 37231 3915 10 , , , 37231 3915 11 the the DT 37231 3915 12 words word NNS 37231 3915 13 are be VBP 37231 3915 14 expressly expressly RB 37231 3915 15 declared declare VBN 37231 3915 16 to to TO 37231 3915 17 be be VB 37231 3915 18 a a DT 37231 3915 19 { { -LRB- 37231 3915 20 401 401 CD 37231 3915 21 } } -RRB- 37231 3915 22 quotation quotation NN 37231 3915 23 from from IN 37231 3915 24 the the DT 37231 3915 25 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3915 26 of of IN 37231 3915 27 the the DT 37231 3915 28 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3915 29 , , , 37231 3915 30 but but CC 37231 3915 31 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3915 32 do do VBP 37231 3915 33 not not RB 37231 3915 34 exist exist VB 37231 3915 35 in in IN 37231 3915 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3915 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3915 38 , , , 37231 3915 39 and and CC 37231 3915 40 consequently consequently RB 37231 3915 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3915 42 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3915 43 are be VBP 37231 3915 44 not not RB 37231 3915 45 identical identical JJ 37231 3915 46 with with IN 37231 3915 47 the the DT 37231 3915 48 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3915 49 . . . 37231 3916 1 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3916 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3916 3 refers refer VBZ 37231 3916 4 to to IN 37231 3916 5 the the DT 37231 3916 6 taunts taunt NNS 37231 3916 7 in in IN 37231 3916 8 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3916 9 , , , 37231 3916 10 and and CC 37231 3916 11 then then RB 37231 3916 12 with with IN 37231 3916 13 commendable commendable JJ 37231 3916 14 candour candour NN 37231 3916 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3916 16 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 3916 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3916 18 examination examination NN 37231 3916 19 of of IN 37231 3916 20 the the DT 37231 3916 21 quotation quotation NN 37231 3916 22 with with IN 37231 3916 23 the the DT 37231 3916 24 following follow VBG 37231 3916 25 words word NNS 37231 3916 26 : : : 37231 3916 27 " " `` 37231 3916 28 No no DT 37231 3916 29 manuscript manuscript NN 37231 3916 30 or or CC 37231 3916 31 Father Father NNP 37231 3916 32 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3916 33 so so RB 37231 3916 34 far far RB 37231 3916 35 as as IN 37231 3916 36 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3916 37 know know VBP 37231 3916 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3916 39 has have VBZ 37231 3916 40 preserved preserve VBN 37231 3916 41 any any DT 37231 3916 42 reading reading NN 37231 3916 43 of of IN 37231 3916 44 the the DT 37231 3916 45 passage passage NN 37231 3916 46 more more RBR 37231 3916 47 closely closely RB 37231 3916 48 resembling resemble VBG 37231 3916 49 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3916 50 's 's POS 37231 3916 51 quotation quotation NN 37231 3916 52 ; ; : 37231 3916 53 and and CC 37231 3916 54 if if IN 37231 3916 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3916 56 appear appear VBP 37231 3916 57 not not RB 37231 3916 58 to to TO 37231 3916 59 be be VB 37231 3916 60 deducible deducible JJ 37231 3916 61 from from IN 37231 3916 62 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3916 63 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3916 64 , , , 37231 3916 65 due due JJ 37231 3916 66 allowance allowance NN 37231 3916 67 being be VBG 37231 3916 68 made make VBN 37231 3916 69 for for IN 37231 3916 70 the the DT 37231 3916 71 object object NN 37231 3916 72 which which WDT 37231 3916 73 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3916 74 had have VBD 37231 3916 75 in in IN 37231 3916 76 view view NN 37231 3916 77 , , , 37231 3916 78 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3916 79 source source NN 37231 3916 80 must must MD 37231 3916 81 remain remain VB 37231 3916 82 concealed conceal VBN 37231 3916 83 . . . 37231 3917 1 " " `` 37231 3917 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3917 3 1 1 LS 37231 3917 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3917 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3917 6 need need VBP 37231 3917 7 only only RB 37231 3917 8 add add VB 37231 3917 9 that that IN 37231 3917 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3917 11 is be VBZ 37231 3917 12 futile futile JJ 37231 3917 13 to to TO 37231 3917 14 talk talk VB 37231 3917 15 of of IN 37231 3917 16 making make VBG 37231 3917 17 " " `` 37231 3917 18 due due JJ 37231 3917 19 allowance allowance NN 37231 3917 20 " " '' 37231 3917 21 for for IN 37231 3917 22 the the DT 37231 3917 23 object object NN 37231 3917 24 which which WDT 37231 3917 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3917 26 had have VBD 37231 3917 27 in in IN 37231 3917 28 view view NN 37231 3917 29 . . . 37231 3918 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3918 2 immediate immediate JJ 37231 3918 3 object object NN 37231 3918 4 was be VBD 37231 3918 5 accurate accurate JJ 37231 3918 6 quotation quotation NN 37231 3918 7 , , , 37231 3918 8 and and CC 37231 3918 9 no no DT 37231 3918 10 allowance allowance NN 37231 3918 11 can can MD 37231 3918 12 account account VB 37231 3918 13 for for IN 37231 3918 14 such such JJ 37231 3918 15 variation variation NN 37231 3918 16 in in IN 37231 3918 17 language language NN 37231 3918 18 and and CC 37231 3918 19 thought think VBD 37231 3918 20 as as IN 37231 3918 21 is be VBZ 37231 3918 22 presented present VBN 37231 3918 23 in in IN 37231 3918 24 this this DT 37231 3918 25 passage passage NN 37231 3918 26 . . . 37231 3919 1 That that IN 37231 3919 2 this this DT 37231 3919 3 passage passage NN 37231 3919 4 , , , 37231 3919 5 though though IN 37231 3919 6 a a DT 37231 3919 7 professed profess VBN 37231 3919 8 quotation quotation NN 37231 3919 9 from from IN 37231 3919 10 the the DT 37231 3919 11 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 3919 12 , , , 37231 3919 13 is be VBZ 37231 3919 14 not not RB 37231 3919 15 taken take VBN 37231 3919 16 from from IN 37231 3919 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3919 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3919 19 is be VBZ 37231 3919 20 certain certain JJ 37231 3919 21 both both DT 37231 3919 22 from from IN 37231 3919 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3919 24 own own JJ 37231 3919 25 variations variation NNS 37231 3919 26 and and CC 37231 3919 27 the the DT 37231 3919 28 differences difference NNS 37231 3919 29 in in IN 37231 3919 30 other other JJ 37231 3919 31 parts part NNS 37231 3919 32 of of IN 37231 3919 33 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3919 34 's 's POS 37231 3919 35 account account NN 37231 3919 36 of of IN 37231 3919 37 the the DT 37231 3919 38 Crucifixion Crucifixion NNP 37231 3919 39 , , , 37231 3919 40 an an DT 37231 3919 41 event event NN 37231 3919 42 whose whose WP$ 37231 3919 43 solemnity solemnity NN 37231 3919 44 and and CC 37231 3919 45 importance importance NN 37231 3919 46 might may MD 37231 3919 47 well well RB 37231 3919 48 be be VB 37231 3919 49 expected expect VBN 37231 3919 50 to to TO 37231 3919 51 secure secure VB 37231 3919 52 reverential reverential JJ 37231 3919 53 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3919 54 . . . 37231 3920 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3920 2 is be VBZ 37231 3920 3 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3920 4 to to TO 37231 3920 5 avoid avoid VB 37231 3920 6 the the DT 37231 3920 7 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 3920 8 that that IN 37231 3920 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3920 10 's 's POS 37231 3920 11 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3920 12 of of IN 37231 3920 13 the the DT 37231 3920 14 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3920 15 were be VBD 37231 3920 16 not not RB 37231 3920 17 identical identical JJ 37231 3920 18 with with IN 37231 3920 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3920 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3920 21 , , , 37231 3920 22 and and CC 37231 3920 23 the the DT 37231 3920 24 systematic systematic JJ 37231 3920 25 variation variation NN 37231 3920 26 of of IN 37231 3920 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3920 28 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3920 29 thus thus RB 37231 3920 30 receives receive VBZ 37231 3920 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3920 32 natural natural JJ 37231 3920 33 and and CC 37231 3920 34 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 3920 35 explanation explanation NN 37231 3920 36 . . . 37231 3921 1 The the DT 37231 3921 2 seventh seventh JJ 37231 3921 3 and and CC 37231 3921 4 last last JJ 37231 3921 5 of of IN 37231 3921 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3921 7 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3921 8 's 's POS 37231 3921 9 express express JJ 37231 3921 10 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3921 11 is be VBZ 37231 3921 12 , , , 37231 3921 13 as as IN 37231 3921 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3921 15 states state VBZ 37231 3921 16 , , , 37231 3921 17 " " `` 37231 3921 18 more more RBR 37231 3921 19 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3921 20 . . . 37231 3921 21 " " '' 37231 3922 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3922 2 subjoin subjoin VBP 37231 3922 3 the the DT 37231 3922 4 passage passage NN 37231 3922 5 in in IN 37231 3922 6 contrast contrast NN 37231 3922 7 with with IN 37231 3922 8 the the DT 37231 3922 9 parallel parallel JJ 37231 3922 10 texts text NNS 37231 3922 11 of of IN 37231 3922 12 the the DT 37231 3922 13 first first JJ 37231 3922 14 and and CC 37231 3922 15 third third JJ 37231 3922 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3922 17 . . . 37231 3923 1 { { -LRB- 37231 3923 2 402 402 CD 37231 3923 3 } } -RRB- 37231 3923 4 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3923 5 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3923 6 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3923 7 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3923 8 is be VBZ 37231 3923 9 apparent apparent JJ 37231 3923 10 that that IN 37231 3923 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3923 12 's 's POS 37231 3923 13 quotation quotation NN 37231 3923 14 differs differ VBZ 37231 3923 15 very very RB 37231 3923 16 materially materially RB 37231 3923 17 from from IN 37231 3923 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3923 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3923 20 in in IN 37231 3923 21 language language NN 37231 3923 22 , , , 37231 3923 23 in in IN 37231 3923 24 construction construction NN 37231 3923 25 , , , 37231 3923 26 and and CC 37231 3923 27 in in IN 37231 3923 28 meaning meaning NN 37231 3923 29 . . . 37231 3924 1 These these DT 37231 3924 2 variations variation NNS 37231 3924 3 , , , 37231 3924 4 however however RB 37231 3924 5 , , , 37231 3924 6 acquire acquire VB 37231 3924 7 very very RB 37231 3924 8 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 3924 9 confirmation confirmation NN 37231 3924 10 and and CC 37231 3924 11 significance significance NN 37231 3924 12 from from IN 37231 3924 13 the the DT 37231 3924 14 fact fact NN 37231 3924 15 that that IN 37231 3924 16 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3924 17 in in IN 37231 3924 18 two two CD 37231 3924 19 other other JJ 37231 3924 20 places(3 places(3 NN 37231 3924 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3924 22 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3924 23 the the DT 37231 3924 24 latter latter JJ 37231 3924 25 and and CC 37231 3924 26 larger large JJR 37231 3924 27 part part NN 37231 3924 28 of of IN 37231 3924 29 the the DT 37231 3924 30 passage passage NN 37231 3924 31 from from IN 37231 3924 32 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3924 33 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3924 34 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3924 35 in in IN 37231 3924 36 precisely precisely RB 37231 3924 37 the the DT 37231 3924 38 same same JJ 37231 3924 39 way way NN 37231 3924 40 , , , 37231 3924 41 with with IN 37231 3924 42 the the DT 37231 3924 43 sole sole JJ 37231 3924 44 exception exception NN 37231 3924 45 that that WDT 37231 3924 46 , , , 37231 3924 47 in in IN 37231 3924 48 both both DT 37231 3924 49 of of IN 37231 3924 50 these these DT 37231 3924 51 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3924 52 , , , 37231 3924 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3924 54 uses use VBZ 37231 3924 55 the the DT 37231 3924 56 aorist aorist NN 37231 3924 57 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3924 58 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3924 59 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3924 60 instead instead RB 37231 3924 61 of of IN 37231 3924 62 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3924 63 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3924 64 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3924 65 . . . 37231 3925 1 This this DT 37231 3925 2 threefold threefold JJ 37231 3925 3 repetition repetition NN 37231 3925 4 in in IN 37231 3925 5 the the DT 37231 3925 6 same same JJ 37231 3925 7 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3925 8 form form NN 37231 3925 9 clearly clearly RB 37231 3925 10 stamps stamp VBZ 37231 3925 11 the the DT 37231 3925 12 passage passage NN 37231 3925 13 as as IN 37231 3925 14 being be VBG 37231 3925 15 a a DT 37231 3925 16 literal literal JJ 37231 3925 17 { { -LRB- 37231 3925 18 403 403 CD 37231 3925 19 } } -RRB- 37231 3925 20 quotation quotation NN 37231 3925 21 from from IN 37231 3925 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3925 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3925 24 , , , 37231 3925 25 and and CC 37231 3925 26 the the DT 37231 3925 27 one one CD 37231 3925 28 exception exception NN 37231 3925 29 to to IN 37231 3925 30 the the DT 37231 3925 31 verbal verbal JJ 37231 3925 32 agreement agreement NN 37231 3925 33 of of IN 37231 3925 34 the the DT 37231 3925 35 three three CD 37231 3925 36 passages passage NNS 37231 3925 37 , , , 37231 3925 38 in in IN 37231 3925 39 the the DT 37231 3925 40 substitution substitution NN 37231 3925 41 of of IN 37231 3925 42 the the DT 37231 3925 43 present present NN 37231 3925 44 for for IN 37231 3925 45 the the DT 37231 3925 46 aorist aorist NN 37231 3925 47 in in IN 37231 3925 48 the the DT 37231 3925 49 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 3925 50 , , , 37231 3925 51 does do VBZ 37231 3925 52 not not RB 37231 3925 53 in in IN 37231 3925 54 the the DT 37231 3925 55 least least JJS 37231 3925 56 remove remove VB 37231 3925 57 or or CC 37231 3925 58 lessen lessen VB 37231 3925 59 the the DT 37231 3925 60 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 3925 61 variation variation NN 37231 3925 62 of of IN 37231 3925 63 the the DT 37231 3925 64 passage passage NN 37231 3925 65 from from IN 37231 3925 66 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3925 67 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3925 68 . . . 37231 3926 1 As as IN 37231 3926 2 the the DT 37231 3926 3 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3926 4 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3926 5 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3926 6 is be VBZ 37231 3926 7 twice twice RB 37231 3926 8 repeated repeat VBN 37231 3926 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3926 10 was be VBD 37231 3926 11 probably probably RB 37231 3926 12 the the DT 37231 3926 13 reading reading NN 37231 3926 14 of of IN 37231 3926 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3926 16 text text NN 37231 3926 17 . . . 37231 3927 1 Now now RB 37231 3927 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3927 3 is be VBZ 37231 3927 4 well well RB 37231 3927 5 known know VBN 37231 3927 6 that that IN 37231 3927 7 the the DT 37231 3927 8 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3927 9 form form NN 37231 3927 10 of of IN 37231 3927 11 the the DT 37231 3927 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3927 13 in in IN 37231 3927 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3927 15 occurred occur VBD 37231 3927 16 in in IN 37231 3927 17 what what WP 37231 3927 18 came come VBD 37231 3927 19 to to TO 37231 3927 20 be be VB 37231 3927 21 considered consider VBN 37231 3927 22 heretical heretical JJ 37231 3927 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3927 24 , , , 37231 3927 25 and and CC 37231 3927 26 constituted constitute VBD 37231 3927 27 the the DT 37231 3927 28 basis basis NN 37231 3927 29 of of IN 37231 3927 30 important important JJ 37231 3927 31 Gnostic gnostic JJ 37231 3927 32 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3927 33 . . . 37231 3928 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3928 2 1 1 LS 37231 3928 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3928 4 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3928 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3928 6 speaks speak VBZ 37231 3928 7 of of IN 37231 3928 8 the the DT 37231 3928 9 use use NN 37231 3928 10 of of IN 37231 3928 11 this this DT 37231 3928 12 passage passage NN 37231 3928 13 by by IN 37231 3928 14 the the DT 37231 3928 15 Fathers Fathers NNP 37231 3928 16 in in IN 37231 3928 17 agreement agreement NN 37231 3928 18 with with IN 37231 3928 19 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3928 20 in in IN 37231 3928 21 a a DT 37231 3928 22 manner manner NN 37231 3928 23 which which WDT 37231 3928 24 , , , 37231 3928 25 unintentionally unintentionally RB 37231 3928 26 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3928 27 have have VBP 37231 3928 28 no no DT 37231 3928 29 doubt doubt RB 37231 3928 30 , , , 37231 3928 31 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 3928 32 misrepresents misrepresent VBZ 37231 3928 33 important important JJ 37231 3928 34 facts fact NNS 37231 3928 35 . . . 37231 3929 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3929 2 says say VBZ 37231 3929 3 : : : 37231 3929 4 " " `` 37231 3929 5 The the DT 37231 3929 6 transposition transposition NN 37231 3929 7 of of IN 37231 3929 8 the the DT 37231 3929 9 words word NNS 37231 3929 10 still still RB 37231 3929 11 remains remain VBZ 37231 3929 12 ; ; : 37231 3929 13 and and CC 37231 3929 14 how how WRB 37231 3929 15 little little JJ 37231 3929 16 weight weight NN 37231 3929 17 can can MD 37231 3929 18 be be VB 37231 3929 19 attached attach VBN 37231 3929 20 to to IN 37231 3929 21 that that DT 37231 3929 22 will will MD 37231 3929 23 appear appear VB 37231 3929 24 upon upon IN 37231 3929 25 an an DT 37231 3929 26 examination examination NN 37231 3929 27 of of IN 37231 3929 28 the the DT 37231 3929 29 various various JJ 37231 3929 30 forms form NNS 37231 3929 31 in in IN 37231 3929 32 which which WDT 37231 3929 33 the the DT 37231 3929 34 text text NN 37231 3929 35 is be VBZ 37231 3929 36 quoted quote VBN 37231 3929 37 by by IN 37231 3929 38 Fathers father NNS 37231 3929 39 like like IN 37231 3929 40 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3929 41 , , , 37231 3929 42 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3929 43 and and CC 37231 3929 44 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3929 45 , , , 37231 3929 46 who who WP 37231 3929 47 admitted admit VBD 37231 3929 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3929 49 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3929 50 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 3929 51 . . . 37231 3930 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3930 2 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3930 3 in in IN 37231 3930 4 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3930 5 as as IN 37231 3930 6 will will MD 37231 3930 7 be be VB 37231 3930 8 seen see VBN 37231 3930 9 from from IN 37231 3930 10 the the DT 37231 3930 11 table table NN 37231 3930 12 of of IN 37231 3930 13 readings[--Greek-- readings[--Greek-- NNP 37231 3930 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3930 15 with with IN 37231 3930 16 almost almost RB 37231 3930 17 every every DT 37231 3930 18 possible possible JJ 37231 3930 19 variation variation NN 37231 3930 20 . . . 37231 3931 1 Irenæus irenæus VB 37231 3931 2 in in IN 37231 3931 3 the the DT 37231 3931 4 course course NN 37231 3931 5 of of IN 37231 3931 6 one one CD 37231 3931 7 chapter chapter NN 37231 3931 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3931 9 the the DT 37231 3931 10 verse verse NN 37231 3931 11 first first RB 37231 3931 12 as as IN 37231 3931 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3931 14 stands stand VBZ 37231 3931 15 in in IN 37231 3931 16 the the DT 37231 3931 17 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3931 18 text text NN 37231 3931 19 ; ; : 37231 3931 20 then then RB 37231 3931 21 in in IN 37231 3931 22 the the DT 37231 3931 23 same same JJ 37231 3931 24 order order NN 37231 3931 25 , , , 37231 3931 26 but but CC 37231 3931 27 with with IN 37231 3931 28 the the DT 37231 3931 29 last last JJ 37231 3931 30 clause clause NN 37231 3931 31 like like IN 37231 3931 32 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3931 33 's 's POS 37231 3931 34 ; ; : 37231 3931 35 and and CC 37231 3931 36 once once RB 37231 3931 37 again again RB 37231 3931 38 altogether altogether RB 37231 3931 39 as as IN 37231 3931 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3931 41 has have VBZ 37231 3931 42 given give VBN 37231 3931 43 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3931 44 . . . 37231 3932 1 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3932 2 likewise likewise RB 37231 3932 3 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3932 4 the the DT 37231 3932 5 text text NN 37231 3932 6 seven seven CD 37231 3932 7 times time NNS 37231 3932 8 in in IN 37231 3932 9 the the DT 37231 3932 10 same same JJ 37231 3932 11 order order NN 37231 3932 12 as as IN 37231 3932 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3932 14 , , , 37231 3932 15 and and CC 37231 3932 16 four four CD 37231 3932 17 times time NNS 37231 3932 18 as as IN 37231 3932 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3932 20 stands stand VBZ 37231 3932 21 in in IN 37231 3932 22 the the DT 37231 3932 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3932 24 . . . 37231 3933 1 " " `` 37231 3933 2 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3933 3 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3933 4 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3933 5 Now now RB 37231 3933 6 in in IN 37231 3933 7 the the DT 37231 3933 8 chapter chapter NN 37231 3933 9 to to TO 37231 3933 10 which which WDT 37231 3933 11 reference reference NN 37231 3933 12 is be VBZ 37231 3933 13 made make VBN 37231 3933 14 in in IN 37231 3933 15 this this DT 37231 3933 16 sentence sentence NN 37231 3933 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3933 18 commences commence VBZ 37231 3933 19 by by IN 37231 3933 20 stating state VBG 37231 3933 21 that that IN 37231 3933 22 the the DT 37231 3933 23 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3933 24 had have VBD 37231 3933 25 declared declare VBN 37231 3933 26 : : : 37231 3933 27 " " `` 37231 3933 28 Nemo Nemo NNP 37231 3933 29 cognoscit cognoscit NN 37231 3933 30 Filium Filium NNP 37231 3933 31 nisi nisi NN 37231 3933 32 Pater Pater NNP 37231 3933 33 ; ; : 37231 3933 34 neque neque NNP 37231 3933 35 { { -LRB- 37231 3933 36 404 404 CD 37231 3933 37 } } -RRB- 37231 3933 38 Patrem Patrem NNP 37231 3933 39 quis quis NNP 37231 3933 40 cognoscit cognoscit NNP 37231 3933 41 nisi nisi NNP 37231 3933 42 Films Films NNP 37231 3933 43 , , , 37231 3933 44 et et NN 37231 3933 45 cui cui NN 37231 3933 46 voluerit voluerit NNP 37231 3933 47 Filius Filius NNP 37231 3933 48 revelare,"(1 revelare,"(1 ADD 37231 3933 49 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3933 50 as as IN 37231 3933 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3933 52 says say VBZ 37231 3933 53 , , , 37231 3933 54 " " `` 37231 3933 55 Thus thus RB 37231 3933 56 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3933 57 has have VBZ 37231 3933 58 set set VBN 37231 3933 59 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3933 60 down down RP 37231 3933 61 and and CC 37231 3933 62 Luke Luke NNP 37231 3933 63 similarly similarly RB 37231 3933 64 , , , 37231 3933 65 and and CC 37231 3933 66 Mark mark VB 37231 3933 67 the the DT 37231 3933 68 very very RB 37231 3933 69 same same JJ 37231 3933 70 . . . 37231 3934 1 " " `` 37231 3934 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3934 3 2 2 LS 37231 3934 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3934 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3934 6 goes go VBZ 37231 3934 7 on on IN 37231 3934 8 to to IN 37231 3934 9 state state NN 37231 3934 10 , , , 37231 3934 11 however however RB 37231 3934 12 , , , 37231 3934 13 that that IN 37231 3934 14 those those DT 37231 3934 15 who who WP 37231 3934 16 would would MD 37231 3934 17 be be VB 37231 3934 18 wiser wise JJR 37231 3934 19 than than IN 37231 3934 20 the the DT 37231 3934 21 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3934 22 write write VBP 37231 3934 23 this this DT 37231 3934 24 verse verse NN 37231 3934 25 as as IN 37231 3934 26 follows follow VBZ 37231 3934 27 : : : 37231 3934 28 " " `` 37231 3934 29 Nemo Nemo NNP 37231 3934 30 cognovit cognovit JJ 37231 3934 31 Patrem patrem NN 37231 3934 32 nisi nisi NN 37231 3934 33 Filius Filius NNP 37231 3934 34 ; ; : 37231 3934 35 nee nee NNP 37231 3934 36 Filium Filium NNP 37231 3934 37 nisi nisi NN 37231 3934 38 Pater Pater NNP 37231 3934 39 , , , 37231 3934 40 et et NN 37231 3934 41 cui cui NNP 37231 3934 42 voluerit voluerit NNP 37231 3934 43 Filius Filius NNP 37231 3934 44 revelare revelare NN 37231 3934 45 . . . 37231 3934 46 " " '' 37231 3935 1 And and CC 37231 3935 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3935 3 explains explain VBZ 37231 3935 4 : : : 37231 3935 5 " " `` 37231 3935 6 They -PRON- PRP 37231 3935 7 interpret interpret VBP 37231 3935 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3935 9 as as IN 37231 3935 10 though though IN 37231 3935 11 the the DT 37231 3935 12 true true JJ 37231 3935 13 God God NNP 37231 3935 14 was be VBD 37231 3935 15 known know VBN 37231 3935 16 to to IN 37231 3935 17 no no DT 37231 3935 18 man man NN 37231 3935 19 before before IN 37231 3935 20 the the DT 37231 3935 21 coming coming NN 37231 3935 22 of of IN 37231 3935 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3935 24 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3935 25 ; ; : 37231 3935 26 and and CC 37231 3935 27 that that IN 37231 3935 28 God God NNP 37231 3935 29 who who WP 37231 3935 30 was be VBD 37231 3935 31 announced announce VBN 37231 3935 32 by by IN 37231 3935 33 the the DT 37231 3935 34 Prophets prophet NNS 37231 3935 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3935 36 affirm affirm VBP 37231 3935 37 not not RB 37231 3935 38 to to TO 37231 3935 39 be be VB 37231 3935 40 the the DT 37231 3935 41 Father Father NNP 37231 3935 42 of of IN 37231 3935 43 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3935 44 . . . 37231 3936 1 " " `` 37231 3936 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3936 3 3 3 LS 37231 3936 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3936 5 Now now RB 37231 3936 6 in in IN 37231 3936 7 this this DT 37231 3936 8 passage passage NN 37231 3936 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3936 10 have have VBP 37231 3936 11 the the DT 37231 3936 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3936 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3936 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3936 15 of of IN 37231 3936 16 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3936 17 in in IN 37231 3936 18 the the DT 37231 3936 19 ' ' `` 37231 3936 20 cognovit cognovit NN 37231 3936 21 , , , 37231 3936 22 ' ' '' 37231 3936 23 in in IN 37231 3936 24 contradistinction contradistinction NN 37231 3936 25 to to IN 37231 3936 26 the the DT 37231 3936 27 ' ' `` 37231 3936 28 cognoscit cognoscit NN 37231 3936 29 ' ' '' 37231 3936 30 of of IN 37231 3936 31 the the DT 37231 3936 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3936 33 , , , 37231 3936 34 and and CC 37231 3936 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3936 36 transposition transposition NN 37231 3936 37 of of IN 37231 3936 38 order order NN 37231 3936 39 as as IN 37231 3936 40 not not RB 37231 3936 41 by by IN 37231 3936 42 any any DT 37231 3936 43 possibility possibility NN 37231 3936 44 an an DT 37231 3936 45 accidental accidental JJ 37231 3936 46 thing thing NN 37231 3936 47 , , , 37231 3936 48 but but CC 37231 3936 49 as as IN 37231 3936 50 the the DT 37231 3936 51 distinct distinct JJ 37231 3936 52 basis basis NN 37231 3936 53 of of IN 37231 3936 54 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3936 55 . . . 37231 3937 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3937 2 goes go VBZ 37231 3937 3 on on RP 37231 3937 4 to to TO 37231 3937 5 argue argue VB 37231 3937 6 that that IN 37231 3937 7 no no DT 37231 3937 8 one one NN 37231 3937 9 can can MD 37231 3937 10 know know VB 37231 3937 11 the the DT 37231 3937 12 Father Father NNP 37231 3937 13 unless unless IN 37231 3937 14 through through IN 37231 3937 15 the the DT 37231 3937 16 Word Word NNP 37231 3937 17 of of IN 37231 3937 18 God God NNP 37231 3937 19 , , , 37231 3937 20 that that DT 37231 3937 21 is be VBZ 37231 3937 22 through through IN 37231 3937 23 the the DT 37231 3937 24 Son Son NNP 37231 3937 25 , , , 37231 3937 26 and and CC 37231 3937 27 this this DT 37231 3937 28 is be VBZ 37231 3937 29 why why WRB 37231 3937 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3937 31 said say VBD 37231 3937 32 : : : 37231 3937 33 " " `` 37231 3937 34 ' ' `` 37231 3937 35 Nemo Nemo NNP 37231 3937 36 cognoscit cognoscit NN 37231 3937 37 Patrem Patrem NNP 37231 3937 38 nisi nisi NN 37231 3937 39 Filius Filius NNP 37231 3937 40 ; ; : 37231 3937 41 neque neque JJ 37231 3937 42 Filium Filium NNP 37231 3937 43 nisi nisi NN 37231 3937 44 Pater Pater NNP 37231 3937 45 , , , 37231 3937 46 et et FW 37231 3937 47 quibuscunque quibuscunque NNP 37231 3937 48 Filius Filius NNP 37231 3937 49 reve reve NN 37231 3937 50 - - HYPH 37231 3937 51 laverit laverit NN 37231 3937 52 . . . 37231 3937 53 ' ' '' 37231 3938 1 Thus thus RB 37231 3938 2 teaching teach VBG 37231 3938 3 that that IN 37231 3938 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3938 5 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3938 6 also also RB 37231 3938 7 is be VBZ 37231 3938 8 the the DT 37231 3938 9 Father Father NNP 37231 3938 10 , , , 37231 3938 11 as as IN 37231 3938 12 indeed indeed RB 37231 3938 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3938 14 is be VBZ 37231 3938 15 , , , 37231 3938 16 in in IN 37231 3938 17 order order NN 37231 3938 18 that that IN 37231 3938 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3938 20 may may MD 37231 3938 21 not not RB 37231 3938 22 receive receive VB 37231 3938 23 any any DT 37231 3938 24 other other JJ 37231 3938 25 Father Father NNP 37231 3938 26 except except IN 37231 3938 27 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3938 28 who who WP 37231 3938 29 is be VBZ 37231 3938 30 revealed reveal VBN 37231 3938 31 by by IN 37231 3938 32 the the DT 37231 3938 33 Son Son NNP 37231 3938 34 . . . 37231 3939 1 " " `` 37231 3939 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3939 3 4 4 LS 37231 3939 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3939 5 In in IN 37231 3939 6 this this DT 37231 3939 7 third third JJ 37231 3939 8 quotation quotation NN 37231 3939 9 Irenseus Irenseus NNP 37231 3939 10 alters alter VBZ 37231 3939 11 the the DT 37231 3939 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3939 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3939 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3939 15 into into IN 37231 3939 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3939 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3939 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3939 19 , , , 37231 3939 20 but but CC 37231 3939 21 retains retain VBZ 37231 3939 22 the the DT 37231 3939 23 form form NN 37231 3939 24 , , , 37231 3939 25 for for IN 37231 3939 26 the the DT 37231 3939 27 rest rest NN 37231 3939 28 , , , 37231 3939 29 of of IN 37231 3939 30 the the DT 37231 3939 31 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 37231 3939 32 and and CC 37231 3939 33 of of IN 37231 3939 34 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3939 35 , , , 37231 3939 36 and and CC 37231 3939 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3939 38 aim aim NN 37231 3939 39 apparently apparently RB 37231 3939 40 is be VBZ 37231 3939 41 to to TO 37231 3939 42 show show VB 37231 3939 43 that that IN 37231 3939 44 adopting adopt VBG 37231 3939 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3939 46 present present JJ 37231 3939 47 tense tense NN 37231 3939 48 instead instead RB 37231 3939 49 of of IN 37231 3939 50 the the DT 37231 3939 51 aorist aorist NN 37231 3939 52 the the DT 37231 3939 53 transposition transposition NN 37231 3939 54 { { -LRB- 37231 3939 55 405 405 CD 37231 3939 56 } } -RRB- 37231 3939 57 of of IN 37231 3939 58 words word NNS 37231 3939 59 is be VBZ 37231 3939 60 of of IN 37231 3939 61 no no DT 37231 3939 62 importance importance NN 37231 3939 63 . . . 37231 3940 1 A a DT 37231 3940 2 fourth fourth JJ 37231 3940 3 time time NN 37231 3940 4 , , , 37231 3940 5 however however RB 37231 3940 6 , , , 37231 3940 7 in in IN 37231 3940 8 the the DT 37231 3940 9 same same JJ 37231 3940 10 chapter chapter NN 37231 3940 11 , , , 37231 3940 12 which which WDT 37231 3940 13 in in IN 37231 3940 14 fact fact NN 37231 3940 15 is be VBZ 37231 3940 16 wholly wholly RB 37231 3940 17 dedicated dedicated JJ 37231 3940 18 to to IN 37231 3940 19 this this DT 37231 3940 20 passage passage NN 37231 3940 21 and and CC 37231 3940 22 to to IN 37231 3940 23 the the DT 37231 3940 24 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3940 25 based base VBN 37231 3940 26 upon upon IN 37231 3940 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3940 28 , , , 37231 3940 29 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3940 30 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3940 31 the the DT 37231 3940 32 saying saying NN 37231 3940 33 : : : 37231 3940 34 " " `` 37231 3940 35 Nemo Nemo NNP 37231 3940 36 cognoscit cognoscit NN 37231 3940 37 Filium Filium NNP 37231 3940 38 nisi nisi NN 37231 3940 39 Pater Pater NNP 37231 3940 40 ; ; : 37231 3940 41 neque neque NNP 37231 3940 42 Patrem Patrem NNP 37231 3940 43 nisi nisi NN 37231 3940 44 Filius Filius NNP 37231 3940 45 , , , 37231 3940 46 et et FW 37231 3940 47 quibuscunque quibuscunque NNP 37231 3940 48 Filius Filius NNP 37231 3940 49 reve reve NN 37231 3940 50 - - HYPH 37231 3940 51 laverit laverit NN 37231 3940 52 . . . 37231 3941 1 " " `` 37231 3941 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3941 3 1 1 LS 37231 3941 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3941 5 Here here RB 37231 3941 6 the the DT 37231 3941 7 language language NN 37231 3941 8 and and CC 37231 3941 9 order order NN 37231 3941 10 of of IN 37231 3941 11 the the DT 37231 3941 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3941 13 are be VBP 37231 3941 14 followed follow VBN 37231 3941 15 with with IN 37231 3941 16 the the DT 37231 3941 17 exception exception NN 37231 3941 18 that that WDT 37231 3941 19 ' ' `` 37231 3941 20 cui cui NNP 37231 3941 21 voluerit voluerit NNP 37231 3941 22 revelare revelare NNP 37231 3941 23 ' ' '' 37231 3941 24 is be VBZ 37231 3941 25 altered alter VBN 37231 3941 26 to to IN 37231 3941 27 the the DT 37231 3941 28 ' ' `` 37231 3941 29 quibuscunque quibuscunque NNP 37231 3941 30 revelaverit revelaverit NN 37231 3941 31 ' ' '' 37231 3941 32 of of IN 37231 3941 33 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3941 34 ; ; : 37231 3941 35 and and CC 37231 3941 36 that that IN 37231 3941 37 this this DT 37231 3941 38 is be VBZ 37231 3941 39 intentional intentional JJ 37231 3941 40 is be VBZ 37231 3941 41 made make VBN 37231 3941 42 clear clear JJ 37231 3941 43 by by IN 37231 3941 44 the the DT 37231 3941 45 continuation continuation NN 37231 3941 46 : : : 37231 3941 47 " " `` 37231 3941 48 For for IN 37231 3941 49 _ _ NNP 37231 3941 50 revelaverit revelaverit NN 37231 3941 51 _ _ NNP 37231 3941 52 was be VBD 37231 3941 53 said say VBN 37231 3941 54 not not RB 37231 3941 55 with with IN 37231 3941 56 reference reference NN 37231 3941 57 to to IN 37231 3941 58 the the DT 37231 3941 59 future future NN 37231 3941 60 alone,"(2 alone,"(2 , 37231 3941 61 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3941 62 & & CC 37231 3941 63 c. c. NNP 37231 3941 64 Now now RB 37231 3941 65 in in IN 37231 3941 66 this this DT 37231 3941 67 chapter chapter NN 37231 3941 68 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3941 69 learn learn VBP 37231 3941 70 very very RB 37231 3941 71 clearly clearly RB 37231 3941 72 that that IN 37231 3941 73 , , , 37231 3941 74 although although IN 37231 3941 75 the the DT 37231 3941 76 canonical canonical JJ 37231 3941 77 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3941 78 by by IN 37231 3941 79 the the DT 37231 3941 80 express express JJ 37231 3941 81 declaration declaration NN 37231 3941 82 of of IN 37231 3941 83 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3941 84 had have VBD 37231 3941 85 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3941 86 present present JJ 37231 3941 87 reading reading NN 37231 3941 88 of of IN 37231 3941 89 the the DT 37231 3941 90 passage passage NN 37231 3941 91 before before IN 37231 3941 92 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3941 93 , , , 37231 3941 94 other other JJ 37231 3941 95 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3941 96 of of IN 37231 3941 97 considerable considerable JJ 37231 3941 98 authority authority NN 37231 3941 99 even even RB 37231 3941 100 in in IN 37231 3941 101 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3941 102 time time NN 37231 3941 103 had have VBD 37231 3941 104 the the DT 37231 3941 105 form form NN 37231 3941 106 of of IN 37231 3941 107 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3941 108 , , , 37231 3941 109 for for IN 37231 3941 110 again again RB 37231 3941 111 in in IN 37231 3941 112 a a DT 37231 3941 113 fifth fifth JJ 37231 3941 114 passage passage NN 37231 3941 115 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3941 116 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3941 117 the the DT 37231 3941 118 opening opening NN 37231 3941 119 words word NNS 37231 3941 120 : : : 37231 3941 121 " " `` 37231 3941 122 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3941 123 who who WP 37231 3941 124 was be VBD 37231 3941 125 known know VBN 37231 3941 126 , , , 37231 3941 127 therefore therefore RB 37231 3941 128 , , , 37231 3941 129 was be VBD 37231 3941 130 not not RB 37231 3941 131 different different JJ 37231 3941 132 from from IN 37231 3941 133 him -PRON- PRP 37231 3941 134 who who WP 37231 3941 135 declared declare VBD 37231 3941 136 : : : 37231 3941 137 ' ' '' 37231 3941 138 No no DT 37231 3941 139 one one NN 37231 3941 140 knoweth knoweth NN 37231 3941 141 the the DT 37231 3941 142 Father Father NNP 37231 3941 143 , , , 37231 3941 144 ' ' '' 37231 3941 145 but but CC 37231 3941 146 one one CD 37231 3941 147 and and CC 37231 3941 148 the the DT 37231 3941 149 same same JJ 37231 3941 150 . . . 37231 3942 1 " " `` 37231 3942 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3942 3 3 3 LS 37231 3942 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3942 5 With with IN 37231 3942 6 the the DT 37231 3942 7 usual usual JJ 37231 3942 8 alteration alteration NN 37231 3942 9 of of IN 37231 3942 10 the the DT 37231 3942 11 verb verb NN 37231 3942 12 to to IN 37231 3942 13 the the DT 37231 3942 14 present present JJ 37231 3942 15 tense tense NN 37231 3942 16 , , , 37231 3942 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3942 18 in in IN 37231 3942 19 this this DT 37231 3942 20 and and CC 37231 3942 21 in in IN 37231 3942 22 one one CD 37231 3942 23 of of IN 37231 3942 24 the the DT 37231 3942 25 other other JJ 37231 3942 26 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3942 27 of of IN 37231 3942 28 this this DT 37231 3942 29 passage passage NN 37231 3942 30 just just RB 37231 3942 31 cited cite VBD 37231 3942 32 gives give VBZ 37231 3942 33 some some DT 37231 3942 34 authority authority NN 37231 3942 35 to to IN 37231 3942 36 the the DT 37231 3942 37 transposition transposition NN 37231 3942 38 of of IN 37231 3942 39 the the DT 37231 3942 40 words word NNS 37231 3942 41 " " `` 37231 3942 42 Father Father NNP 37231 3942 43 " " '' 37231 3942 44 and and CC 37231 3942 45 " " `` 37231 3942 46 Son Son NNP 37231 3942 47 , , , 37231 3942 48 " " '' 37231 3942 49 although although IN 37231 3942 50 the the DT 37231 3942 51 reading reading NN 37231 3942 52 was be VBD 37231 3942 53 opposed oppose VBN 37231 3942 54 to to IN 37231 3942 55 the the DT 37231 3942 56 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3942 57 , , , 37231 3942 58 but but CC 37231 3942 59 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3942 60 invariably invariably RB 37231 3942 61 adheres adhere VBZ 37231 3942 62 to to IN 37231 3942 63 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3942 64 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3942 65 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3942 66 and and CC 37231 3942 67 condemns condemn VBZ 37231 3942 68 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3942 69 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3942 70 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3942 71 , , , 37231 3942 72 the the DT 37231 3942 73 reading reading NN 37231 3942 74 maintained maintain VBD 37231 3942 75 by by IN 37231 3942 76 those those DT 37231 3942 77 who who WP 37231 3942 78 in in IN 37231 3942 79 the the DT 37231 3942 80 estimation estimation NN 37231 3942 81 of of IN 37231 3942 82 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3942 83 " " '' 37231 3942 84 would would MD 37231 3942 85 be be VB 37231 3942 86 wiser wise JJR 37231 3942 87 than than IN 37231 3942 88 the the DT 37231 3942 89 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3942 90 . . . 37231 3942 91 " " '' 37231 3943 1 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3943 2 , , , 37231 3943 3 descanting descant VBG 37231 3943 4 on on IN 37231 3943 5 { { -LRB- 37231 3943 6 406 406 CD 37231 3943 7 } } -RRB- 37231 3943 8 the the DT 37231 3943 9 passages passage NNS 37231 3943 10 of of IN 37231 3943 11 Scripture scripture NN 37231 3943 12 by by IN 37231 3943 13 which which WDT 37231 3943 14 heretics heretic NNS 37231 3943 15 attempt attempt VBP 37231 3943 16 to to TO 37231 3943 17 prove prove VB 37231 3943 18 that that IN 37231 3943 19 the the DT 37231 3943 20 Father Father NNP 37231 3943 21 was be VBD 37231 3943 22 unknown unknown JJ 37231 3943 23 before before IN 37231 3943 24 the the DT 37231 3943 25 advent advent NN 37231 3943 26 of of IN 37231 3943 27 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3943 28 , , , 37231 3943 29 Irenseus Irenseus NNP 37231 3943 30 , , , 37231 3943 31 after after IN 37231 3943 32 accusing accuse VBG 37231 3943 33 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3943 34 of of IN 37231 3943 35 garbling garble VBG 37231 3943 36 passages passage NNS 37231 3943 37 of of IN 37231 3943 38 Scripture,(1 scripture,(1 NN 37231 3943 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3943 40 goes go VBZ 37231 3943 41 on on RP 37231 3943 42 to to TO 37231 3943 43 say say VB 37231 3943 44 of of IN 37231 3943 45 the the DT 37231 3943 46 Marcosians Marcosians NNPS 37231 3943 47 and and CC 37231 3943 48 others other NNS 37231 3943 49 : : : 37231 3943 50 " " `` 37231 3943 51 Besides besides IN 37231 3943 52 these these DT 37231 3943 53 , , , 37231 3943 54 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3943 55 adduce adduce VBP 37231 3943 56 a a DT 37231 3943 57 countless countless JJ 37231 3943 58 number number NN 37231 3943 59 of of IN 37231 3943 60 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3943 61 and and CC 37231 3943 62 spurious spurious JJ 37231 3943 63 works work NNS 37231 3943 64 which which WDT 37231 3943 65 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3943 66 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 3943 67 have have VBP 37231 3943 68 forged forge VBN 37231 3943 69 to to IN 37231 3943 70 the the DT 37231 3943 71 bewilderment bewilderment NN 37231 3943 72 of of IN 37231 3943 73 the the DT 37231 3943 74 foolish foolish JJ 37231 3943 75 , , , 37231 3943 76 and and CC 37231 3943 77 of of IN 37231 3943 78 those those DT 37231 3943 79 who who WP 37231 3943 80 are be VBP 37231 3943 81 not not RB 37231 3943 82 versed verse VBN 37231 3943 83 in in IN 37231 3943 84 the the DT 37231 3943 85 Scriptures scripture NNS 37231 3943 86 of of IN 37231 3943 87 truth truth NN 37231 3943 88 . . . 37231 3944 1 " " `` 37231 3944 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3944 3 2 2 LS 37231 3944 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3944 5 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3944 6 also also RB 37231 3944 7 points point VBZ 37231 3944 8 out out RP 37231 3944 9 passages passage NNS 37231 3944 10 occurring occur VBG 37231 3944 11 in in IN 37231 3944 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3944 13 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 3944 14 to to TO 37231 3944 15 which which WDT 37231 3944 16 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3944 17 give give VBP 37231 3944 18 a a DT 37231 3944 19 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 3944 20 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 3944 21 and and CC 37231 3944 22 , , , 37231 3944 23 amongst amongst IN 37231 3944 24 these these DT 37231 3944 25 , , , 37231 3944 26 that that WDT 37231 3944 27 quoted quote VBN 37231 3944 28 by by IN 37231 3944 29 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3944 30 . . . 37231 3945 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3945 2 says say VBZ 37231 3945 3 : : : 37231 3945 4 " " `` 37231 3945 5 But but CC 37231 3945 6 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3945 7 adduce adduce VBP 37231 3945 8 as as IN 37231 3945 9 the the DT 37231 3945 10 highest high JJS 37231 3945 11 testimony testimony NN 37231 3945 12 , , , 37231 3945 13 and and CC 37231 3945 14 as as IN 37231 3945 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3945 16 were be VBD 37231 3945 17 the the DT 37231 3945 18 crown crown NN 37231 3945 19 of of IN 37231 3945 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3945 21 system system NN 37231 3945 22 , , , 37231 3945 23 the the DT 37231 3945 24 following follow VBG 37231 3945 25 passage passage NN 37231 3945 26 .... .... . 37231 3945 27 ' ' '' 37231 3945 28 All all DT 37231 3945 29 things thing NNS 37231 3945 30 were be VBD 37231 3945 31 delivered deliver VBN 37231 3945 32 to to IN 37231 3945 33 me -PRON- PRP 37231 3945 34 by by IN 37231 3945 35 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3945 36 Father Father NNP 37231 3945 37 , , , 37231 3945 38 and and CC 37231 3945 39 no no DT 37231 3945 40 one one NN 37231 3945 41 knew know VBD 37231 3945 42 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3945 43 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3945 44 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3945 45 the the DT 37231 3945 46 Father Father NNP 37231 3945 47 but but CC 37231 3945 48 the the DT 37231 3945 49 Son Son NNP 37231 3945 50 , , , 37231 3945 51 and and CC 37231 3945 52 the the DT 37231 3945 53 Son Son NNP 37231 3945 54 but but CC 37231 3945 55 the the DT 37231 3945 56 Father Father NNP 37231 3945 57 , , , 37231 3945 58 and and CC 37231 3945 59 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3945 60 to to IN 37231 3945 61 whomsoever whomsoever VB 37231 3945 62 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3945 63 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3945 64 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3945 65 the the DT 37231 3945 66 Son Son NNP 37231 3945 67 shall shall MD 37231 3945 68 reveal reveal VB 37231 3945 69 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3945 70 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3945 71 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3945 72 . . . 37231 3946 1 ' ' `` 37231 3946 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3946 3 3 3 LS 37231 3946 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3946 5 In in IN 37231 3946 6 these these DT 37231 3946 7 words word NNS 37231 3946 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3946 9 assert assert VBP 37231 3946 10 that that IN 37231 3946 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3946 12 clearly clearly RB 37231 3946 13 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 37231 3946 14 that that IN 37231 3946 15 the the DT 37231 3946 16 Father Father NNP 37231 3946 17 of of IN 37231 3946 18 truth truth NN 37231 3946 19 whom whom WP 37231 3946 20 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3946 21 have have VBP 37231 3946 22 invented invent VBN 37231 3946 23 was be VBD 37231 3946 24 known know VBN 37231 3946 25 to to IN 37231 3946 26 no no DT 37231 3946 27 one one NN 37231 3946 28 before before IN 37231 3946 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3946 30 coming coming NN 37231 3946 31 ; ; : 37231 3946 32 and and CC 37231 3946 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3946 34 desire desire VBP 37231 3946 35 to to TO 37231 3946 36 interpret interpret VB 37231 3946 37 the the DT 37231 3946 38 words word NNS 37231 3946 39 as as IN 37231 3946 40 though though IN 37231 3946 41 the the DT 37231 3946 42 Maker Maker NNP 37231 3946 43 and and CC 37231 3946 44 Creator Creator NNP 37231 3946 45 had have VBD 37231 3946 46 been be VBN 37231 3946 47 known know VBN 37231 3946 48 to to IN 37231 3946 49 all all DT 37231 3946 50 , , , 37231 3946 51 and and CC 37231 3946 52 the the DT 37231 3946 53 Lord Lord NNP 37231 3946 54 spoke speak VBD 37231 3946 55 these these DT 37231 3946 56 words word NNS 37231 3946 57 regarding regard VBG 37231 3946 58 the the DT 37231 3946 59 Father Father NNP 37231 3946 60 unknown unknown JJ 37231 3946 61 to to IN 37231 3946 62 all all DT 37231 3946 63 , , , 37231 3946 64 whom whom WP 37231 3946 65 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3946 66 proclaim proclaim VBP 37231 3946 67 . . . 37231 3947 1 " " `` 37231 3947 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3947 3 4 4 LS 37231 3947 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3947 5 Here here RB 37231 3947 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3947 7 have have VBP 37231 3947 8 the the DT 37231 3947 9 exact exact JJ 37231 3947 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 3947 11 twice twice RB 37231 3947 12 made make VBN 37231 3947 13 by by IN 37231 3947 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3947 15 , , , 37231 3947 16 with with IN 37231 3947 17 the the DT 37231 3947 18 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3947 19 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3947 20 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3947 21 and and CC 37231 3947 22 the the DT 37231 3947 23 same same JJ 37231 3947 24 order order NN 37231 3947 25 , , , 37231 3947 26 set set VBN 37231 3947 27 { { -LRB- 37231 3947 28 407 407 CD 37231 3947 29 } } -RRB- 37231 3947 30 forth forth RB 37231 3947 31 as as IN 37231 3947 32 the the DT 37231 3947 33 reading reading NN 37231 3947 34 of of IN 37231 3947 35 the the DT 37231 3947 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3947 37 of of IN 37231 3947 38 the the DT 37231 3947 39 Marcosians Marcosians NNPS 37231 3947 40 and and CC 37231 3947 41 other other JJ 37231 3947 42 sects sect NNS 37231 3947 43 , , , 37231 3947 44 and and CC 37231 3947 45 the the DT 37231 3947 46 highest high JJS 37231 3947 47 testimony testimony NN 37231 3947 48 to to IN 37231 3947 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3947 50 system system NN 37231 3947 51 . . . 37231 3948 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3948 2 is be VBZ 37231 3948 3 almost almost RB 37231 3948 4 impossible impossible JJ 37231 3948 5 that that IN 37231 3948 6 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3948 7 could could MD 37231 3948 8 have have VB 37231 3948 9 altered alter VBN 37231 3948 10 the the DT 37231 3948 11 passage passage NN 37231 3948 12 by by IN 37231 3948 13 an an DT 37231 3948 14 error error NN 37231 3948 15 of of IN 37231 3948 16 memory memory NN 37231 3948 17 to to IN 37231 3948 18 this this DT 37231 3948 19 precise precise JJ 37231 3948 20 form form NN 37231 3948 21 , , , 37231 3948 22 and and CC 37231 3948 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3948 24 must must MD 37231 3948 25 be be VB 37231 3948 26 regarded regard VBN 37231 3948 27 as as IN 37231 3948 28 the the DT 37231 3948 29 reading reading NN 37231 3948 30 of of IN 37231 3948 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3948 32 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3948 33 . . . 37231 3949 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3949 2 1 1 LS 37231 3949 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3949 4 The the DT 37231 3949 5 evidence evidence NN 37231 3949 6 of of IN 37231 3949 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3949 8 is be VBZ 37231 3949 9 clear clear JJ 37231 3949 10 : : : 37231 3949 11 The the DT 37231 3949 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3949 13 had have VBD 37231 3949 14 the the DT 37231 3949 15 reading reading NN 37231 3949 16 which which WDT 37231 3949 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3949 18 now now RB 37231 3949 19 find find VBP 37231 3949 20 in in IN 37231 3949 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3949 22 , , , 37231 3949 23 but but CC 37231 3949 24 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 3949 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3949 26 on on IN 37231 3949 27 the the DT 37231 3949 28 other other JJ 37231 3949 29 hand hand NN 37231 3949 30 had have VBD 37231 3949 31 that that DT 37231 3949 32 which which WDT 37231 3949 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3949 34 find find VBP 37231 3949 35 twice twice RB 37231 3949 36 quoted quote VBN 37231 3949 37 by by IN 37231 3949 38 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3949 39 , , , 37231 3949 40 and and CC 37231 3949 41 the the DT 37231 3949 42 passage passage NN 37231 3949 43 was be VBD 37231 3949 44 as as IN 37231 3949 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3949 46 were be VBD 37231 3949 47 the the DT 37231 3949 48 text text NN 37231 3949 49 upon upon IN 37231 3949 50 which which WDT 37231 3949 51 a a DT 37231 3949 52 large large JJ 37231 3949 53 sect sect NN 37231 3949 54 of of IN 37231 3949 55 the the DT 37231 3949 56 early early JJ 37231 3949 57 Church Church NNP 37231 3949 58 based base VBD 37231 3949 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3949 60 most most JJS 37231 3949 61 fundamental fundamental JJ 37231 3949 62 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 3949 63 . . . 37231 3950 1 The the DT 37231 3950 2 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3950 3 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3950 4 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3950 5 is be VBZ 37231 3950 6 invariably invariably RB 37231 3950 7 repudiated repudiate VBN 37231 3950 8 , , , 37231 3950 9 but but CC 37231 3950 10 the the DT 37231 3950 11 transposition transposition NN 37231 3950 12 of of IN 37231 3950 13 the the DT 37231 3950 14 words word NNS 37231 3950 15 " " `` 37231 3950 16 Father Father NNP 37231 3950 17 " " '' 37231 3950 18 and and CC 37231 3950 19 " " `` 37231 3950 20 Son Son NNP 37231 3950 21 " " '' 37231 3950 22 was be VBD 37231 3950 23 apparently apparently RB 37231 3950 24 admitted admit VBN 37231 3950 25 to to IN 37231 3950 26 a a DT 37231 3950 27 certain certain JJ 37231 3950 28 extent extent NN 37231 3950 29 , , , 37231 3950 30 although although IN 37231 3950 31 the the DT 37231 3950 32 authority authority NN 37231 3950 33 for for IN 37231 3950 34 this this DT 37231 3950 35 was be VBD 37231 3950 36 not not RB 37231 3950 37 derived derive VBN 37231 3950 38 from from IN 37231 3950 39 the the DT 37231 3950 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3950 41 recognized recognize VBN 37231 3950 42 by by IN 37231 3950 43 the the DT 37231 3950 44 Church Church NNP 37231 3950 45 which which WDT 37231 3950 46 contained contain VBD 37231 3950 47 the the DT 37231 3950 48 contrary contrary JJ 37231 3950 49 order order NN 37231 3950 50 . . . 37231 3951 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3951 2 must must MD 37231 3951 3 briefly briefly RB 37231 3951 4 refer refer VB 37231 3951 5 to to IN 37231 3951 6 the the DT 37231 3951 7 use use NN 37231 3951 8 of of IN 37231 3951 9 this this DT 37231 3951 10 passage passage NN 37231 3951 11 by by IN 37231 3951 12 Clement Clement NNP 37231 3951 13 of of IN 37231 3951 14 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 3951 15 . . . 37231 3952 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3952 2 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3952 3 portions portion NNS 37231 3952 4 of of IN 37231 3952 5 the the DT 37231 3952 6 text text NN 37231 3952 7 eight eight CD 37231 3952 8 times time NNS 37231 3952 9 , , , 37231 3952 10 and and CC 37231 3952 11 although although IN 37231 3952 12 with with IN 37231 3952 13 some some DT 37231 3952 14 variation variation NN 37231 3952 15 of of IN 37231 3952 16 terms term NNS 37231 3952 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3952 18 invariably invariably RB 37231 3952 19 follows follow VBZ 37231 3952 20 the the DT 37231 3952 21 order order NN 37231 3952 22 of of IN 37231 3952 23 the the DT 37231 3952 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3952 25 . . . 37231 3953 1 Six six CD 37231 3953 2 times time NNS 37231 3953 3 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3953 4 makes make VBZ 37231 3953 5 use use NN 37231 3953 6 of of IN 37231 3953 7 the the DT 37231 3953 8 aorist aorist NN 37231 3953 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3953 10 --Greek--],(2 --Greek--],(2 NFP 37231 3953 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3953 12 once once IN 37231 3953 13 of of IN 37231 3953 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3953 15 --Greek--],(3 --greek--],(3 NN 37231 3953 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3953 17 and and CC 37231 3953 18 once once RB 37231 3953 19 of of IN 37231 3953 20 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3953 21 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3953 22 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3953 23 . . . 37231 3954 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3954 2 4 4 LS 37231 3954 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3954 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3954 5 only only RB 37231 3954 6 once once RB 37231 3954 7 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3954 8 the the DT 37231 3954 9 whole whole JJ 37231 3954 10 passage,(5 passage,(5 NN 37231 3954 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3954 12 but but CC 37231 3954 13 on on IN 37231 3954 14 this this DT 37231 3954 15 occasion occasion NN 37231 3954 16 , , , 37231 3954 17 as as RB 37231 3954 18 well well RB 37231 3954 19 as as IN 37231 3954 20 six six CD 37231 3954 21 others other NNS 37231 3954 22 in in IN 37231 3954 23 which which WDT 37231 3954 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3954 25 only only RB 37231 3954 26 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3954 27 the the DT 37231 3954 28 latter latter JJ 37231 3954 29 part part NN 37231 3954 30 of of IN 37231 3954 31 the the DT 37231 3954 32 sentence,(6 sentence,(6 NNPS 37231 3954 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3954 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3954 35 omits omit VBZ 37231 3954 36 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3954 37 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3954 38 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3954 39 , , , 37231 3954 40 and and CC 37231 3954 41 reads read VBZ 37231 3954 42 " " '' 37231 3954 43 and and CC 37231 3954 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3954 45 to to TO 37231 3954 46 whom whom WP 37231 3954 47 the the DT 37231 3954 48 Son Son NNP 37231 3954 49 shall shall MD 37231 3954 50 reveal reveal VB 37231 3954 51 , , , 37231 3954 52 " " `` 37231 3954 53 thus thus RB 37231 3954 54 supporting support VBG 37231 3954 55 the the DT 37231 3954 56 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3954 57 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3954 58 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3954 59 { { -LRB- 37231 3954 60 408 408 CD 37231 3954 61 } } -RRB- 37231 3954 62 of of IN 37231 3954 63 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3954 64 . . . 37231 3955 1 Twice twice RB 37231 3955 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3955 3 has have VBZ 37231 3955 4 " " `` 37231 3955 5 God God NNP 37231 3955 6 " " '' 37231 3955 7 instead instead RB 37231 3955 8 of of IN 37231 3955 9 " " `` 37231 3955 10 Father,"(1 Father,"(1 NNP 37231 3955 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3955 12 and and CC 37231 3955 13 once once IN 37231 3955 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3955 15 substitutes substitute VBZ 37231 3955 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3955 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3955 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3955 19 for for IN 37231 3955 20 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3955 21 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3955 22 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3955 23 . . . 37231 3956 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3956 2 2 2 LS 37231 3956 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3956 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3956 5 is be VBZ 37231 3956 6 evident evident JJ 37231 3956 7 from from IN 37231 3956 8 the the DT 37231 3956 9 loose loose JJ 37231 3956 10 and and CC 37231 3956 11 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 37231 3956 12 way way NN 37231 3956 13 in in IN 37231 3956 14 which which WDT 37231 3956 15 Clement Clement NNP 37231 3956 16 interweaves interweave VBZ 37231 3956 17 the the DT 37231 3956 18 passage passage NN 37231 3956 19 with with IN 37231 3956 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3956 21 text text NN 37231 3956 22 , , , 37231 3956 23 that that IN 37231 3956 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3956 25 is be VBZ 37231 3956 26 more more RBR 37231 3956 27 concerned concerned JJ 37231 3956 28 with with IN 37231 3956 29 the the DT 37231 3956 30 sense sense NN 37231 3956 31 than than IN 37231 3956 32 the the DT 37231 3956 33 verbal verbal JJ 37231 3956 34 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 3956 35 of of IN 37231 3956 36 the the DT 37231 3956 37 quotation quotation NN 37231 3956 38 , , , 37231 3956 39 but but CC 37231 3956 40 the the DT 37231 3956 41 result result NN 37231 3956 42 of of IN 37231 3956 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3956 44 evidence evidence NN 37231 3956 45 is be VBZ 37231 3956 46 that that IN 37231 3956 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3956 48 never never RB 37231 3956 49 departs depart VBZ 37231 3956 50 from from IN 37231 3956 51 the the DT 37231 3956 52 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3956 53 order order NN 37231 3956 54 of of IN 37231 3956 55 " " `` 37231 3956 56 Father Father NNP 37231 3956 57 " " '' 37231 3956 58 and and CC 37231 3956 59 " " `` 37231 3956 60 Son Son NNP 37231 3956 61 , , , 37231 3956 62 " " '' 37231 3956 63 although although IN 37231 3956 64 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3956 65 frequently frequently RB 37231 3956 66 makes make VBZ 37231 3956 67 use use NN 37231 3956 68 of of IN 37231 3956 69 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3956 70 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3956 71 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3956 72 and and CC 37231 3956 73 also also RB 37231 3956 74 employs employ VBZ 37231 3956 75 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3956 76 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3956 77 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3956 78 in in IN 37231 3956 79 agreement agreement NN 37231 3956 80 with with IN 37231 3956 81 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3956 82 and and CC 37231 3956 83 , , , 37231 3956 84 therefore therefore RB 37231 3956 85 , , , 37231 3956 86 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3956 87 shows show VBZ 37231 3956 88 the the DT 37231 3956 89 prevalence prevalence NN 37231 3956 90 of of IN 37231 3956 91 forms form NNS 37231 3956 92 approximating approximate VBG 37231 3956 93 to to IN 37231 3956 94 , , , 37231 3956 95 though though IN 37231 3956 96 always always RB 37231 3956 97 presenting present VBG 37231 3956 98 material material NN 37231 3956 99 difference difference NN 37231 3956 100 from from IN 37231 3956 101 , , , 37231 3956 102 the the DT 37231 3956 103 reading reading NN 37231 3956 104 of of IN 37231 3956 105 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3956 106 . . . 37231 3957 1 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3957 2 refers refer VBZ 37231 3957 3 to to IN 37231 3957 4 this this DT 37231 3957 5 passage passage NN 37231 3957 6 no no RB 37231 3957 7 less less JJR 37231 3957 8 than than IN 37231 3957 9 ten ten CD 37231 3957 10 times,(3 times,(3 NN 37231 3957 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3957 12 but but CC 37231 3957 13 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3957 14 only only RB 37231 3957 15 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3957 16 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3957 17 fully fully RB 37231 3957 18 five five CD 37231 3957 19 times time NNS 37231 3957 20 , , , 37231 3957 21 and and CC 37231 3957 22 upon upon IN 37231 3957 23 each each DT 37231 3957 24 of of IN 37231 3957 25 these these DT 37231 3957 26 occasions occasion NNS 37231 3957 27 with with IN 37231 3957 28 variations variation NNS 37231 3957 29 . . . 37231 3958 1 Of of IN 37231 3958 2 the the DT 37231 3958 3 five five CD 37231 3958 4 times time NNS 37231 3958 5 to to TO 37231 3958 6 which which WDT 37231 3958 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3958 8 refer refer VBP 37231 3958 9 , , , 37231 3958 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3958 11 thrice thrice NN 37231 3958 12 follows follow VBZ 37231 3958 13 the the DT 37231 3958 14 order order NN 37231 3958 15 of of IN 37231 3958 16 the the DT 37231 3958 17 Gospels,(4 gospels,(4 NN 37231 3958 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3958 19 as as IN 37231 3958 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3958 21 does do VBZ 37231 3958 22 likewise likewise RB 37231 3958 23 in in IN 37231 3958 24 another another DT 37231 3958 25 place place NN 37231 3958 26 where where WRB 37231 3958 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3958 28 does do VBZ 37231 3958 29 not not RB 37231 3958 30 complete complete VB 37231 3958 31 the the DT 37231 3958 32 sentence sentence NN 37231 3958 33 . . . 37231 3959 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3959 2 5 5 LS 37231 3959 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3959 4 On on IN 37231 3959 5 the the DT 37231 3959 6 remaining remain VBG 37231 3959 7 two two CD 37231 3959 8 occasions occasion NNS 37231 3959 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3959 10 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 3959 11 the the DT 37231 3959 12 same same JJ 37231 3959 13 order order NN 37231 3959 14 as as IN 37231 3959 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3959 16 , , , 37231 3959 17 with with IN 37231 3959 18 variations variation NNS 37231 3959 19 from from IN 37231 3959 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3959 21 reading reading NN 37231 3959 22 , , , 37231 3959 23 however however RB 37231 3959 24 , , , 37231 3959 25 to to TO 37231 3959 26 which which WDT 37231 3959 27 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3959 28 shall shall MD 37231 3959 29 presently presently RB 37231 3959 30 refer;(6 refer;(6 VB 37231 3959 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3959 32 and and CC 37231 3959 33 where where WRB 37231 3959 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3959 35 only only RB 37231 3959 36 partially partially RB 37231 3959 37 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3959 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3959 39 follows follow VBZ 37231 3959 40 the the DT 37231 3959 41 same same JJ 37231 3959 42 order order NN 37231 3959 43 on on IN 37231 3959 44 other other JJ 37231 3959 45 three three CD 37231 3959 46 occasions,(7 occasions,(7 NNS 37231 3959 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3959 48 and and CC 37231 3959 49 in in IN 37231 3959 50 one one CD 37231 3959 51 other other JJ 37231 3959 52 place place NN 37231 3959 53 the the DT 37231 3959 54 quotation quotation NN 37231 3959 55 is be VBZ 37231 3959 56 too too RB 37231 3959 57 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 37231 3959 58 to to TO 37231 3959 59 allow allow VB 37231 3959 60 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3959 61 to to TO 37231 3959 62 distinguish distinguish VB 37231 3959 63 the the DT 37231 3959 64 order order NN 37231 3959 65 . . . 37231 3960 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3960 2 8) 8) CD 37231 3960 3 Now now RB 37231 3960 4 in in IN 37231 3960 5 all all DT 37231 3960 6 of of IN 37231 3960 7 these these DT 37231 3960 8 ten ten CD 37231 3960 9 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3960 10 , , , 37231 3960 11 with with IN 37231 3960 12 one one CD 37231 3960 13 exception exception NN 37231 3960 14 , , , 37231 3960 15 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3960 16 substitutes substitute VBZ 37231 3960 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3960 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3960 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3960 20 for for IN 37231 3960 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3960 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3960 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3960 24 at at IN 37231 3960 25 the the DT 37231 3960 26 commencement commencement NN 37231 3960 27 of of IN 37231 3960 28 the the DT 37231 3960 29 { { -LRB- 37231 3960 30 409 409 CD 37231 3960 31 } } -RRB- 37231 3960 32 passage passage NN 37231 3960 33 in in IN 37231 3960 34 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3960 35 , , , 37231 3960 36 and and CC 37231 3960 37 only only JJ 37231 3960 38 thrice thrice NN 37231 3960 39 does do VBZ 37231 3960 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3960 41 repeat repeat VB 37231 3960 42 the the DT 37231 3960 43 verb verb NN 37231 3960 44 in in IN 37231 3960 45 the the DT 37231 3960 46 second second JJ 37231 3960 47 clause clause NN 37231 3960 48 as as IN 37231 3960 49 in in IN 37231 3960 50 that that DT 37231 3960 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3960 52 , , , 37231 3960 53 and and CC 37231 3960 54 on on IN 37231 3960 55 these these DT 37231 3960 56 occasions occasion NNS 37231 3960 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3960 58 twice twice RB 37231 3960 59 makes make VBZ 37231 3960 60 use use NN 37231 3960 61 of of IN 37231 3960 62 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3960 63 --Greek--](1 --Greek--](1 NFP 37231 3960 64 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3960 65 and and CC 37231 3960 66 once once RB 37231 3960 67 of of IN 37231 3960 68 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3960 69 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3960 70 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3960 71 . . . 37231 3961 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3961 2 2 2 LS 37231 3961 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3961 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3961 5 once once RB 37231 3961 6 uses use VBZ 37231 3961 7 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3961 8 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3961 9 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3961 10 with with IN 37231 3961 11 the the DT 37231 3961 12 same same JJ 37231 3961 13 order order NN 37231 3961 14 as as IN 37231 3961 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3961 16 , , , 37231 3961 17 but but CC 37231 3961 18 does do VBZ 37231 3961 19 not not RB 37231 3961 20 complete complete VB 37231 3961 21 the the DT 37231 3961 22 sentence sentence NN 37231 3961 23 . . . 37231 3962 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3962 2 3 3 LS 37231 3962 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3962 4 Each each DT 37231 3962 5 time time NN 37231 3962 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3962 7 completes complete VBZ 37231 3962 8 the the DT 37231 3962 9 quotation quotation NN 37231 3962 10 , , , 37231 3962 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3962 12 uses use VBZ 37231 3962 13 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3962 14 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3962 15 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3962 16 with with IN 37231 3962 17 the the DT 37231 3962 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3962 19 , , , 37231 3962 20 and and CC 37231 3962 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3962 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3962 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3962 24 with with IN 37231 3962 25 Justin,(4 justin,(4 NN 37231 3962 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3962 27 but but CC 37231 3962 28 only only RB 37231 3962 29 once once RB 37231 3962 30 out out IN 37231 3962 31 of of IN 37231 3962 32 the the DT 37231 3962 33 five five CD 37231 3962 34 complete complete JJ 37231 3962 35 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3962 36 does do VBZ 37231 3962 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3962 38 insert insert VB 37231 3962 39 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3962 40 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3962 41 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3962 42 in in IN 37231 3962 43 the the DT 37231 3962 44 concluding concluding NN 37231 3962 45 phrase phrase NN 37231 3962 46 . . . 37231 3963 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3963 2 is be VBZ 37231 3963 3 evident evident JJ 37231 3963 4 from from IN 37231 3963 5 this this DT 37231 3963 6 examination examination NN 37231 3963 7 , , , 37231 3963 8 which which WDT 37231 3963 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3963 10 must must MD 37231 3963 11 not not RB 37231 3963 12 carry carry VB 37231 3963 13 further far RBR 37231 3963 14 , , , 37231 3963 15 that that IN 37231 3963 16 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 3963 17 never never RB 37231 3963 18 verbally verbally RB 37231 3963 19 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3963 20 with with IN 37231 3963 21 the the DT 37231 3963 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3963 23 in in IN 37231 3963 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3963 25 quotation quotation NN 37231 3963 26 of of IN 37231 3963 27 this this DT 37231 3963 28 passage passage NN 37231 3963 29 and and CC 37231 3963 30 never never RB 37231 3963 31 verbally verbally RB 37231 3963 32 with with IN 37231 3963 33 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3963 34 , , , 37231 3963 35 but but CC 37231 3963 36 mainly mainly RB 37231 3963 37 follows follow VBZ 37231 3963 38 a a DT 37231 3963 39 version version NN 37231 3963 40 different different JJ 37231 3963 41 from from IN 37231 3963 42 both both DT 37231 3963 43 . . . 37231 3964 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3964 2 must must MD 37231 3964 3 be be VB 37231 3964 4 remembered remember VBN 37231 3964 5 , , , 37231 3964 6 however however RB 37231 3964 7 , , , 37231 3964 8 that that IN 37231 3964 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3964 10 is be VBZ 37231 3964 11 writing write VBG 37231 3964 12 against against IN 37231 3964 13 various various JJ 37231 3964 14 heresies heresy NNS 37231 3964 15 , , , 37231 3964 16 and and CC 37231 3964 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3964 18 does do VBZ 37231 3964 19 not not RB 37231 3964 20 seem seem VB 37231 3964 21 to to IN 37231 3964 22 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3964 23 improbable improbable JJ 37231 3964 24 that that IN 37231 3964 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3964 26 reproduces reproduce VBZ 37231 3964 27 forms form NNS 37231 3964 28 of of IN 37231 3964 29 the the DT 37231 3964 30 passage passage NN 37231 3964 31 current current NN 37231 3964 32 amongst amongst IN 37231 3964 33 those those DT 37231 3964 34 sects sect NNS 37231 3964 35 . . . 37231 3965 1 In in IN 37231 3965 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3965 3 work work NN 37231 3965 4 against against IN 37231 3965 5 Marcion Marcion NNP 37231 3965 6 , , , 37231 3965 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 3965 8 says say VBZ 37231 3965 9 : : : 37231 3965 10 " " `` 37231 3965 11 With with IN 37231 3965 12 regard regard NN 37231 3965 13 to to IN 37231 3965 14 the the DT 37231 3965 15 Father Father NNP 37231 3965 16 , , , 37231 3965 17 however however RB 37231 3965 18 , , , 37231 3965 19 that that IN 37231 3965 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3965 21 was be VBD 37231 3965 22 never never RB 37231 3965 23 seen see VBN 37231 3965 24 , , , 37231 3965 25 the the DT 37231 3965 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3965 27 which which WDT 37231 3965 28 is be VBZ 37231 3965 29 common common JJ 37231 3965 30 to to IN 37231 3965 31 us -PRON- PRP 37231 3965 32 will will MD 37231 3965 33 testify testify VB 37231 3965 34 , , , 37231 3965 35 as as IN 37231 3965 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3965 37 was be VBD 37231 3965 38 said say VBN 37231 3965 39 by by IN 37231 3965 40 Christ Christ NNP 37231 3965 41 : : : 37231 3965 42 Nemo nemo NN 37231 3965 43 cognovit cognovit JJ 37231 3965 44 patrem patrem NN 37231 3965 45 nisi nisi NN 37231 3965 46 filius,"(5 filius,"(5 CD 37231 3965 47 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3965 48 but but CC 37231 3965 49 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3965 50 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3965 51 translates translate VBZ 37231 3965 52 " " `` 37231 3965 53 Nemo Nemo NNP 37231 3965 54 scit,"(6 scit,"(6 ADD 37231 3965 55 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3965 56 evidently evidently RB 37231 3965 57 not not RB 37231 3965 58 fully fully RB 37231 3965 59 appreciating appreciate VBG 37231 3965 60 the the DT 37231 3965 61 difference difference NN 37231 3965 62 of of IN 37231 3965 63 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3965 64 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3965 65 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3965 66 . . . 37231 3966 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3966 2 7 7 LS 37231 3966 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3966 4 The the DT 37231 3966 5 passage passage NN 37231 3966 6 in in IN 37231 3966 7 Mar Mar NNP 37231 3966 8 - - HYPH 37231 3966 9 cion cion NNP 37231 3966 10 's 's POS 37231 3966 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3966 12 reads read VBZ 37231 3966 13 like like IN 37231 3966 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3966 15 's 's POS 37231 3966 16 : : : 37231 3966 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3966 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3966 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3966 20 . . . 37231 3967 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3967 2 8) 8) CD 37231 3967 3 The the DT 37231 3967 4 use use NN 37231 3967 5 of of IN 37231 3967 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3967 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3967 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3967 9 as as IN 37231 3967 10 applied apply VBN 37231 3967 11 to to IN 37231 3967 12 the the DT 37231 3967 13 Father Father NNP 37231 3967 14 and and CC 37231 3967 15 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3967 16 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3967 17 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3967 18 as as IN 37231 3967 19 regards regard VBZ 37231 3967 20 the the DT 37231 3967 21 Son Son NNP 37231 3967 22 in in IN 37231 3967 23 this this DT 37231 3967 24 passage passage NN 37231 3967 25 is be VBZ 37231 3967 26 suggestive suggestive JJ 37231 3967 27 . . . 37231 3968 1 Origen Origen NNP 37231 3968 2 { { -LRB- 37231 3968 3 410 410 CD 37231 3968 4 } } -RRB- 37231 3968 5 almost almost RB 37231 3968 6 invariably invariably RB 37231 3968 7 uses use VBZ 37231 3968 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3968 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3968 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3968 11 , , , 37231 3968 12 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 3968 13 adopting adopt VBG 37231 3968 14 the the DT 37231 3968 15 order order NN 37231 3968 16 of of IN 37231 3968 17 the the DT 37231 3968 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3968 19 and and CC 37231 3968 20 sometimes sometimes RB 37231 3968 21 that that DT 37231 3968 22 of of IN 37231 3968 23 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3968 24 , , , 37231 3968 25 and and CC 37231 3968 26 always always RB 37231 3968 27 employing employ VBG 37231 3968 28 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3968 29 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3968 30 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3968 31 . . . 37231 3969 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3969 2 1 1 LS 37231 3969 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3969 4 The the DT 37231 3969 5 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 3969 6 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 3969 7 always always RB 37231 3969 8 read read VBP 37231 3969 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3969 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 3969 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3969 12 , , , 37231 3969 13 and and CC 37231 3969 14 always always RB 37231 3969 15 follow follow VB 37231 3969 16 the the DT 37231 3969 17 same same JJ 37231 3969 18 order order NN 37231 3969 19 as as IN 37231 3969 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3969 21 , , , 37231 3969 22 presenting present VBG 37231 3969 23 other other JJ 37231 3969 24 and and CC 37231 3969 25 persistent persistent JJ 37231 3969 26 variations variation NNS 37231 3969 27 from from IN 37231 3969 28 the the DT 37231 3969 29 form form NN 37231 3969 30 in in IN 37231 3969 31 the the DT 37231 3969 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3969 33 . . . 37231 3970 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3970 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3970 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3970 4 This this DT 37231 3970 5 reading reading NN 37231 3970 6 occurs occur VBZ 37231 3970 7 four four CD 37231 3970 8 times time NNS 37231 3970 9 . . . 37231 3971 1 The the DT 37231 3971 2 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 3971 3 Recognitions Recognitions NNP 37231 3971 4 have have VBP 37231 3971 5 the the DT 37231 3971 6 aorist aorist NN 37231 3971 7 with with IN 37231 3971 8 the the DT 37231 3971 9 order order NN 37231 3971 10 of of IN 37231 3971 11 the the DT 37231 3971 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3971 13 . . . 37231 3972 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3972 2 4 4 LS 37231 3972 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3972 4 There there RB 37231 3972 5 only only RB 37231 3972 6 remain remain VBP 37231 3972 7 a a DT 37231 3972 8 few few JJ 37231 3972 9 more more JJR 37231 3972 10 lines line NNS 37231 3972 11 to to TO 37231 3972 12 add add VB 37231 3972 13 to to IN 37231 3972 14 those those DT 37231 3972 15 already already RB 37231 3972 16 quoted quote VBN 37231 3972 17 to to TO 37231 3972 18 complete complete VB 37231 3972 19 the the DT 37231 3972 20 whole whole NN 37231 3972 21 of of IN 37231 3972 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 3972 23 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3972 24 's 's POS 37231 3972 25 argument argument NN 37231 3972 26 regarding regard VBG 37231 3972 27 this this DT 37231 3972 28 passage passage NN 37231 3972 29 . . . 37231 3973 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3973 2 continues continue VBZ 37231 3973 3 and and CC 37231 3973 4 concludes conclude VBZ 37231 3973 5 thus thus RB 37231 3973 6 : : : 37231 3973 7 " " `` 37231 3973 8 If if IN 37231 3973 9 , , , 37231 3973 10 indeed indeed RB 37231 3973 11 , , , 37231 3973 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3973 13 's 's POS 37231 3973 14 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3973 15 were be VBD 37231 3973 16 made make VBN 37231 3973 17 from from IN 37231 3973 18 memory memory NN 37231 3973 19 , , , 37231 3973 20 no no DT 37231 3973 21 transposition transposition NN 37231 3973 22 could could MD 37231 3973 23 be be VB 37231 3973 24 more more RBR 37231 3973 25 natural natural JJ 37231 3973 26 ; ; : 37231 3973 27 and and CC 37231 3973 28 if if IN 37231 3973 29 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3973 30 suppose suppose VBP 37231 3973 31 that that IN 37231 3973 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3973 33 copied copy VBD 37231 3973 34 the the DT 37231 3973 35 passage passage NN 37231 3973 36 directly directly RB 37231 3973 37 from from IN 37231 3973 38 a a DT 37231 3973 39 manuscript manuscript NN 37231 3973 40 , , , 37231 3973 41 there there EX 37231 3973 42 is be VBZ 37231 3973 43 no no DT 37231 3973 44 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 3973 45 in in IN 37231 3973 46 believing believe VBG 37231 3973 47 that that IN 37231 3973 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3973 49 found find VBD 37231 3973 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3973 51 so so RB 37231 3973 52 written write VBN 37231 3973 53 in in IN 37231 3973 54 a a DT 37231 3973 55 manuscript manuscript NN 37231 3973 56 of of IN 37231 3973 57 the the DT 37231 3973 58 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3973 59 St. St. NNP 37231 3973 60 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3973 61 , , , 37231 3973 62 since since IN 37231 3973 63 the the DT 37231 3973 64 variation variation NN 37231 3973 65 is be VBZ 37231 3973 66 excluded exclude VBN 37231 3973 67 by by IN 37231 3973 68 no no DT 37231 3973 69 internal internal JJ 37231 3973 70 improbability improbability NN 37231 3973 71 , , , 37231 3973 72 while while IN 37231 3973 73 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3973 74 is be VBZ 37231 3973 75 found find VBN 37231 3973 76 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 3973 77 , , , 37231 3973 78 and and CC 37231 3973 79 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3973 80 origin origin NN 37231 3973 81 is be VBZ 37231 3973 82 easily easily RB 37231 3973 83 explicable explicable JJ 37231 3973 84 . . . 37231 3974 1 " " `` 37231 3974 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3974 3 5 5 LS 37231 3974 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3974 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3974 6 will will MD 37231 3974 7 be be VB 37231 3974 8 observed observe VBN 37231 3974 9 that that IN 37231 3974 10 Canon Canon NNP 37231 3974 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 3974 12 does do VBZ 37231 3974 13 not not RB 37231 3974 14 attempt attempt VB 37231 3974 15 any any DT 37231 3974 16 argument argument NN 37231 3974 17 , , , 37231 3974 18 but but CC 37231 3974 19 simply simply RB 37231 3974 20 confines confine VBZ 37231 3974 21 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3974 22 to to IN 37231 3974 23 suppositions supposition NNS 37231 3974 24 . . . 37231 3975 1 If if IN 37231 3975 2 such such JJ 37231 3975 3 explanations explanation NNS 37231 3975 4 were be VBD 37231 3975 5 only only RB 37231 3975 6 valid valid JJ 37231 3975 7 , , , 37231 3975 8 there there EX 37231 3975 9 could could MD 37231 3975 10 be be VB 37231 3975 11 no no DT 37231 3975 12 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 3975 13 in in IN 37231 3975 14 believing believe VBG 37231 3975 15 anything anything NN 37231 3975 16 , , , 37231 3975 17 and and CC 37231 3975 18 every every DT 37231 3975 19 embarrassing embarrassing JJ 37231 3975 20 circumstance circumstance NN 37231 3975 21 would would MD 37231 3975 22 indeed indeed RB 37231 3975 23 be be VB 37231 3975 24 easily easily RB 37231 3975 25 explicable explicable JJ 37231 3975 26 . . . 37231 3976 1 The the DT 37231 3976 2 facts fact NNS 37231 3976 3 of of IN 37231 3976 4 the the DT 37231 3976 5 case case NN 37231 3976 6 may may MD 37231 3976 7 be be VB 37231 3976 8 briefly briefly RB 37231 3976 9 summed sum VBN 37231 3976 10 up up RP 37231 3976 11 as as IN 37231 3976 12 follows follow VBZ 37231 3976 13 : : : 37231 3976 14 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3976 15 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 3976 16 and and CC 37231 3976 17 expressly expressly RB 37231 3976 18 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3976 19 from from IN 37231 3976 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3976 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3976 22 , , , 37231 3976 23 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 3976 24 calling call VBG 37231 3976 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3976 26 " " `` 37231 3976 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3976 28 , , , 37231 3976 29 " " '' 37231 3976 30 be be VB 37231 3976 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3976 32 observed observe VBN 37231 3976 33 , , , 37231 3976 34 a a DT 37231 3976 35 { { -LRB- 37231 3976 36 411 411 CD 37231 3976 37 } } -RRB- 37231 3976 38 passage passage NN 37231 3976 39 whose whose WP$ 37231 3976 40 nearest near JJS 37231 3976 41 parallel parallel NN 37231 3976 42 in in IN 37231 3976 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3976 44 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3976 45 is be VBZ 37231 3976 46 Matt Matt NNP 37231 3976 47 . . . 37231 3977 1 xi xi NNP 37231 3977 2 . . . 37231 3978 1 27 27 CD 37231 3978 2 . . . 37231 3979 1 This this DT 37231 3979 2 quotation quotation NN 37231 3979 3 presents present VBZ 37231 3979 4 material material NN 37231 3979 5 variations variation NNS 37231 3979 6 from from IN 37231 3979 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3979 8 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3979 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3979 10 both both DT 37231 3979 11 in in IN 37231 3979 12 form form NN 37231 3979 13 and and CC 37231 3979 14 language language NN 37231 3979 15 . . . 37231 3980 1 The the DT 37231 3980 2 larger large JJR 37231 3980 3 part part NN 37231 3980 4 of of IN 37231 3980 5 the the DT 37231 3980 6 passage passage NN 37231 3980 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3980 8 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3980 9 twice twice RB 37231 3980 10 in in IN 37231 3980 11 a a DT 37231 3980 12 different different JJ 37231 3980 13 work work NN 37231 3980 14 , , , 37231 3980 15 written write VBN 37231 3980 16 years year NNS 37231 3980 17 before before RB 37231 3980 18 , , , 37231 3980 19 in in IN 37231 3980 20 precisely precisely RB 37231 3980 21 the the DT 37231 3980 22 same same JJ 37231 3980 23 words word NNS 37231 3980 24 as as IN 37231 3980 25 the the DT 37231 3980 26 third third JJ 37231 3980 27 quotation quotation NN 37231 3980 28 , , , 37231 3980 29 with with IN 37231 3980 30 the the DT 37231 3980 31 sole sole JJ 37231 3980 32 exception exception NN 37231 3980 33 that that WDT 37231 3980 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3980 35 uses use VBZ 37231 3980 36 the the DT 37231 3980 37 aorist aorist NN 37231 3980 38 instead instead RB 37231 3980 39 of of IN 37231 3980 40 the the DT 37231 3980 41 present present JJ 37231 3980 42 tense tense NN 37231 3980 43 of of IN 37231 3980 44 the the DT 37231 3980 45 verb verb NN 37231 3980 46 . . . 37231 3981 1 No no DT 37231 3981 2 MS MS NNP 37231 3981 3 . . NNP 37231 3981 4 of of IN 37231 3981 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3981 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3981 7 extant extant JJ 37231 3981 8 approximates approximate VBZ 37231 3981 9 to to IN 37231 3981 10 the the DT 37231 3981 11 reading reading NN 37231 3981 12 in in IN 37231 3981 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3981 14 , , , 37231 3981 15 and and CC 37231 3981 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3981 17 are be VBP 37231 3981 18 expressly expressly RB 37231 3981 19 told tell VBN 37231 3981 20 by by IN 37231 3981 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3981 22 that that IN 37231 3981 23 the the DT 37231 3981 24 present present JJ 37231 3981 25 reading reading NN 37231 3981 26 of of IN 37231 3981 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3981 28 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 3981 29 was be VBD 37231 3981 30 that that IN 37231 3981 31 existing exist VBG 37231 3981 32 in in IN 37231 3981 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3981 34 day day NN 37231 3981 35 . . . 37231 3982 1 On on IN 37231 3982 2 the the DT 37231 3982 3 other other JJ 37231 3982 4 hand hand NN 37231 3982 5 , , , 37231 3982 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 3982 7 states state VBZ 37231 3982 8 with with IN 37231 3982 9 equal equal JJ 37231 3982 10 distinctness distinctness NN 37231 3982 11 that that WDT 37231 3982 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3982 13 used use VBN 37231 3982 14 by by IN 37231 3982 15 Gnostic gnostic JJ 37231 3982 16 sects sect NNS 37231 3982 17 had have VBD 37231 3982 18 the the DT 37231 3982 19 reading reading NN 37231 3982 20 of of IN 37231 3982 21 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3982 22 , , , 37231 3982 23 and and CC 37231 3982 24 that that IN 37231 3982 25 the the DT 37231 3982 26 passage passage NN 37231 3982 27 was be VBD 37231 3982 28 " " `` 37231 3982 29 the the DT 37231 3982 30 crown crown NN 37231 3982 31 of of IN 37231 3982 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3982 33 system system NN 37231 3982 34 , , , 37231 3982 35 " " '' 37231 3982 36 and and CC 37231 3982 37 one one CD 37231 3982 38 upon upon IN 37231 3982 39 whose whose WP$ 37231 3982 40 testimony testimony NN 37231 3982 41 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3982 42 based base VBD 37231 3982 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3982 44 leading leading JJ 37231 3982 45 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3982 46 . . . 37231 3983 1 Here here RB 37231 3983 2 , , , 37231 3983 3 then then RB 37231 3983 4 , , , 37231 3983 5 is be VBZ 37231 3983 6 the the DT 37231 3983 7 clear clear JJ 37231 3983 8 statement statement NN 37231 3983 9 that that IN 37231 3983 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3983 11 's 's POS 37231 3983 12 quotation quotation NN 37231 3983 13 disagrees disagree VBZ 37231 3983 14 with with IN 37231 3983 15 the the DT 37231 3983 16 form form NN 37231 3983 17 in in IN 37231 3983 18 the the DT 37231 3983 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3983 20 , , , 37231 3983 21 and and CC 37231 3983 22 agrees agree VBZ 37231 3983 23 with with IN 37231 3983 24 that that DT 37231 3983 25 of of IN 37231 3983 26 other other JJ 37231 3983 27 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3983 28 . . . 37231 3984 1 The the DT 37231 3984 2 variations variation NNS 37231 3984 3 occurring occur VBG 37231 3984 4 in in IN 37231 3984 5 the the DT 37231 3984 6 numerous numerous JJ 37231 3984 7 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3984 8 of of IN 37231 3984 9 the the DT 37231 3984 10 same same JJ 37231 3984 11 passage passage NN 37231 3984 12 by by IN 37231 3984 13 the the DT 37231 3984 14 Fathers father NNS 37231 3984 15 , , , 37231 3984 16 which which WDT 37231 3984 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3984 18 have have VBP 37231 3984 19 analysed analyse VBN 37231 3984 20 , , , 37231 3984 21 show show VB 37231 3984 22 that that IN 37231 3984 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 3984 24 handled handle VBD 37231 3984 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3984 26 very very RB 37231 3984 27 loosely loosely RB 37231 3984 28 , , , 37231 3984 29 but but CC 37231 3984 30 also also RB 37231 3984 31 indicate indicate VBP 37231 3984 32 that that IN 37231 3984 33 there there EX 37231 3984 34 must must MD 37231 3984 35 have have VB 37231 3984 36 been be VBN 37231 3984 37 various various JJ 37231 3984 38 readings reading NNS 37231 3984 39 of of IN 37231 3984 40 considerable considerable JJ 37231 3984 41 authority authority NN 37231 3984 42 then then RB 37231 3984 43 current current JJ 37231 3984 44 . . . 37231 3985 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3985 2 has have VBZ 37231 3985 3 been be VBN 37231 3985 4 conjectured conjecture VBN 37231 3985 5 with with IN 37231 3985 6 much much JJ 37231 3985 7 probability probability NN 37231 3985 8 that that IN 37231 3985 9 the the DT 37231 3985 10 form form NN 37231 3985 11 in in IN 37231 3985 12 which which WDT 37231 3985 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3985 14 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3985 15 the the DT 37231 3985 16 passage passage NN 37231 3985 17 twice twice RB 37231 3985 18 in in IN 37231 3985 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3985 20 Apology Apology NNP 37231 3985 21 may may MD 37231 3985 22 have have VB 37231 3985 23 been be VBN 37231 3985 24 the the DT 37231 3985 25 reading reading NN 37231 3985 26 of of IN 37231 3985 27 older old JJR 37231 3985 28 Gospels Gospels NNP 37231 3985 29 , , , 37231 3985 30 and and CC 37231 3985 31 that that IN 37231 3985 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3985 33 was be VBD 37231 3985 34 gradually gradually RB 37231 3985 35 altered alter VBN 37231 3985 36 by by IN 37231 3985 37 the the DT 37231 3985 38 Church Church NNP 37231 3985 39 to to IN 37231 3985 40 the the DT 37231 3985 41 form form NN 37231 3985 42 in in IN 37231 3985 43 which which WDT 37231 3985 44 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3985 45 now now RB 37231 3985 46 have have VBP 37231 3985 47 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3985 48 , , , 37231 3985 49 for for IN 37231 3985 50 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 3985 51 reasons reason NNS 37231 3985 52 , , , 37231 3985 53 when when WRB 37231 3985 54 Gnostic gnostic JJ 37231 3985 55 sects sect NNS 37231 3985 56 began begin VBD 37231 3985 57 to to TO 37231 3985 58 base base VB 37231 3985 59 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 3985 60 upon upon IN 37231 3985 61 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3985 62 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37231 3985 63 with with IN 37231 3985 64 the the DT 37231 3985 65 prevailing prevail VBG 37231 3985 66 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 3985 67 . . . 37231 3986 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3986 2 1 1 LS 37231 3986 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3986 4 Be be VB 37231 3986 5 this this DT 37231 3986 6 as as IN 37231 3986 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3986 8 may may MD 37231 3986 9 , , , 37231 3986 10 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3986 11 's 's POS 37231 3986 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 3986 13 clearly clearly RB 37231 3986 14 had have VBD 37231 3986 15 a a DT 37231 3986 16 reading reading NN 37231 3986 17 different different JJ 37231 3986 18 from from IN 37231 3986 19 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 3986 20 , , , 37231 3986 21 but but CC 37231 3986 22 in in IN 37231 3986 23 unison unison NNP 37231 3986 24 with with IN 37231 3986 25 { { -LRB- 37231 3986 26 412 412 CD 37231 3986 27 } } -RRB- 37231 3986 28 that that WDT 37231 3986 29 known know VBN 37231 3986 30 to to TO 37231 3986 31 exist exist VB 37231 3986 32 in in IN 37231 3986 33 other other JJ 37231 3986 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3986 35 , , , 37231 3986 36 and and CC 37231 3986 37 this this DT 37231 3986 38 express express JJ 37231 3986 39 quotation quotation NN 37231 3986 40 only only RB 37231 3986 41 adds add VBZ 37231 3986 42 additional additional JJ 37231 3986 43 proof proof NN 37231 3986 44 to to IN 37231 3986 45 the the DT 37231 3986 46 mass mass NN 37231 3986 47 of of IN 37231 3986 48 evidence evidence NN 37231 3986 49 already already RB 37231 3986 50 adduced adduce VBD 37231 3986 51 that that IN 37231 3986 52 the the DT 37231 3986 53 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3986 54 of of IN 37231 3986 55 the the DT 37231 3986 56 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 3986 57 were be VBD 37231 3986 58 not not RB 37231 3986 59 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3986 60 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 3986 61 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3986 62 . . . 37231 3987 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3987 2 1 1 LS 37231 3987 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3987 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3987 5 have have VBP 37231 3987 6 already already RB 37231 3987 7 occupied occupy VBN 37231 3987 8 so so RB 37231 3987 9 much much JJ 37231 3987 10 space space NN 37231 3987 11 even even RB 37231 3987 12 with with IN 37231 3987 13 this this DT 37231 3987 14 cursory cursory JJ 37231 3987 15 examination examination NN 37231 3987 16 of of IN 37231 3987 17 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3987 18 's 's POS 37231 3987 19 quotations quotation NNS 37231 3987 20 , , , 37231 3987 21 that that IN 37231 3987 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3987 23 must must MD 37231 3987 24 pass pass VB 37231 3987 25 over over RP 37231 3987 26 in in IN 37231 3987 27 silence silence NN 37231 3987 28 passages passage NNS 37231 3987 29 which which WDT 37231 3987 30 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3987 31 quotes quote VBZ 37231 3987 32 from from IN 37231 3987 33 the the DT 37231 3987 34 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 3987 35 with with IN 37231 3987 36 variations variation NNS 37231 3987 37 from from IN 37231 3987 38 the the DT 37231 3987 39 parallels parallel NNS 37231 3987 40 in in IN 37231 3987 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3987 42 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3987 43 which which WDT 37231 3987 44 are be VBP 37231 3987 45 also also RB 37231 3987 46 found find VBN 37231 3987 47 in in IN 37231 3987 48 the the DT 37231 3987 49 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 3987 50 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 3987 51 and and CC 37231 3987 52 other other JJ 37231 3987 53 works work NNS 37231 3987 54 emanating emanate VBG 37231 3987 55 from from IN 37231 3987 56 circles circle NNS 37231 3987 57 in in IN 37231 3987 58 which which WDT 37231 3987 59 other other JJ 37231 3987 60 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3987 61 than than IN 37231 3987 62 ours our NNS 37231 3987 63 were be VBD 37231 3987 64 used use VBN 37231 3987 65 . . . 37231 3988 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 3988 2 shall shall MD 37231 3988 3 now now RB 37231 3988 4 only only RB 37231 3988 5 briefly briefly RB 37231 3988 6 refer refer VB 37231 3988 7 to to IN 37231 3988 8 a a DT 37231 3988 9 few few JJ 37231 3988 10 sayings saying NNS 37231 3988 11 of of IN 37231 3988 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3988 13 expressly expressly RB 37231 3988 14 quoted quote VBN 37231 3988 15 by by IN 37231 3988 16 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3988 17 , , , 37231 3988 18 which which WDT 37231 3988 19 are be VBP 37231 3988 20 altogether altogether RB 37231 3988 21 unknown unknown JJ 37231 3988 22 to to IN 37231 3988 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3988 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3988 25 . . . 37231 3989 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3989 2 says say VBZ 37231 3989 3 : : : 37231 3989 4 " " `` 37231 3989 5 For for IN 37231 3989 6 the the DT 37231 3989 7 things thing NNS 37231 3989 8 which which WDT 37231 3989 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3989 10 foretold foretell VBD 37231 3989 11 would would MD 37231 3989 12 take take VB 37231 3989 13 place place NN 37231 3989 14 in in IN 37231 3989 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3989 16 name name NN 37231 3989 17 , , , 37231 3989 18 these these DT 37231 3989 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 3989 20 see see VBP 37231 3989 21 actually actually RB 37231 3989 22 coming come VBG 37231 3989 23 to to TO 37231 3989 24 pass pass VB 37231 3989 25 in in RP 37231 3989 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3989 27 sight sight NN 37231 3989 28 . . . 37231 3990 1 For for IN 37231 3990 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 3990 3 said say VBD 37231 3990 4 : : : 37231 3990 5 ' ' `` 37231 3990 6 Many many JJ 37231 3990 7 shall shall MD 37231 3990 8 come come VB 37231 3990 9 , , , 37231 3990 10 ' ' '' 37231 3990 11 & & CC 37231 3990 12 c. c. NNP 37231 3990 13 , , , 37231 3990 14 & & CC 37231 3990 15 c c NNP 37231 3990 16 . . . 37231 3990 17 ,(2 ,(2 , 37231 3990 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3990 19 and and CC 37231 3990 20 ' ' `` 37231 3990 21 There there EX 37231 3990 22 shall shall MD 37231 3990 23 be be VB 37231 3990 24 schisms schism NNS 37231 3990 25 and and CC 37231 3990 26 heresies,'(3 heresies,'(3 NNP 37231 3990 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3990 28 and and CC 37231 3990 29 ' ' `` 37231 3990 30 Beware beware VB 37231 3990 31 of of IN 37231 3990 32 false false JJ 37231 3990 33 prophets,'(4 prophets,'(4 NNP 37231 3990 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3990 35 & & CC 37231 3990 36 c c NNP 37231 3990 37 , , , 37231 3990 38 and and CC 37231 3990 39 ' ' `` 37231 3990 40 Many many JJ 37231 3990 41 false false JJ 37231 3990 42 Christs Christs NNPS 37231 3990 43 and and CC 37231 3990 44 false false JJ 37231 3990 45 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 3990 46 shall shall MD 37231 3990 47 arise arise VB 37231 3990 48 and and CC 37231 3990 49 shall shall MD 37231 3990 50 deceive deceive VB 37231 3990 51 many many JJ 37231 3990 52 of of IN 37231 3990 53 the the DT 37231 3990 54 faithful faithful NN 37231 3990 55 . . . 37231 3991 1 ' ' '' 37231 3991 2 " " '' 37231 3991 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3991 4 5 5 LS 37231 3991 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3991 6 Neither neither DT 37231 3991 7 of of IN 37231 3991 8 the the DT 37231 3991 9 two two CD 37231 3991 10 prophecies prophecy NNS 37231 3991 11 here here RB 37231 3991 12 quoted quote VBN 37231 3991 13 are be VBP 37231 3991 14 to to TO 37231 3991 15 be be VB 37231 3991 16 found find VBN 37231 3991 17 anywhere anywhere RB 37231 3991 18 in in IN 37231 3991 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3991 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3991 21 , , , 37231 3991 22 and and CC 37231 3991 23 to to IN 37231 3991 24 the the DT 37231 3991 25 second second JJ 37231 3991 26 of of IN 37231 3991 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 3991 28 Justin Justin NNP 37231 3991 29 repeatedly repeatedly RB 37231 3991 30 refers refer VBZ 37231 3991 31 . . . 37231 3992 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 3992 2 says say VBZ 37231 3992 3 in in IN 37231 3992 4 one one CD 37231 3992 5 place place NN 37231 3992 6 that that WDT 37231 3992 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 3992 8 " " `` 37231 3992 9 foretold foretell VBD 37231 3992 10 that that IN 37231 3992 11 in in IN 37231 3992 12 the the DT 37231 3992 13 interval interval NN 37231 3992 14 of of IN 37231 3992 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3992 16 coming come VBG 37231 3992 17 , , , 37231 3992 18 as as IN 37231 3992 19 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3992 20 previously previously RB 37231 3992 21 said,(6 said,(6 VBZ 37231 3992 22 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3992 23 heresies heresy NNS 37231 3992 24 and and CC 37231 3992 25 false false JJ 37231 3992 26 prophets prophet NNS 37231 3992 27 would would MD 37231 3992 28 arise arise VB 37231 3992 29 in in IN 37231 3992 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3992 31 name name NN 37231 3992 32 . . . 37231 3993 1 " " `` 37231 3993 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3993 3 7 7 LS 37231 3993 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3993 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3993 6 is be VBZ 37231 3993 7 admitted admit VBN 37231 3993 8 that that IN 37231 3993 9 these these DT 37231 3993 10 { { -LRB- 37231 3993 11 413 413 CD 37231 3993 12 } } -RRB- 37231 3993 13 prophecies prophecy NNS 37231 3993 14 are be VBP 37231 3993 15 foreign foreign JJ 37231 3993 16 to to IN 37231 3993 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 3993 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 3993 19 . . . 37231 3994 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 3994 2 1 1 LS 37231 3994 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 3994 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 3994 5 is be VBZ 37231 3994 6 very very RB 37231 3994 7 probable probable JJ 37231 3994 8 that that IN 37231 3994 9 the the DT 37231 3994 10 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 3994 11 Paul Paul NNP 37231 3994 12 refers refer VBZ 37231 3994 13 to to IN 37231 3994 14 the the DT 37231 3994 15 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 3994 16 , , , 37231 3994 17 " " `` 37231 3994 18 There there EX 37231 3994 19 shall shall MD 37231 3994 20 be be VB 37231 3994 21 schisms schism NNS 37231 3994 22 and and CC 37231 3994 23 heresies heresy NNS 37231 3994 24 " " '' 37231 3994 25 in in IN 37231 3994 26 1 1 CD 37231 3994 27 Cor Cor NNP 37231 3994 28 . . . 37231 3995 1 xi xi NNP 37231 3995 2 . . . 37231 3996 1 18 18 CD 37231 3996 2 - - SYM 37231 3996 3 19 19 CD 37231 3996 4 , , , 37231 3996 5 where where WRB 37231 3996 6 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3996 7 is be VBZ 37231 3996 8 said say VBN 37231 3996 9 , , , 37231 3996 10 " " '' 37231 3996 11 .... .... . 37231 3997 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3997 2 hear hear VBP 37231 3997 3 that that IN 37231 3997 4 schisms schism NNS 37231 3997 5 exist exist VBP 37231 3997 6 amongst amongst IN 37231 3997 7 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3997 8 ; ; : 37231 3997 9 and and CC 37231 3997 10 I -PRON- PRP 37231 3997 11 partly partly RB 37231 3997 12 believe believe VBP 37231 3997 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 3997 14 . . . 37231 3998 1 For for IN 37231 3998 2 there there EX 37231 3998 3 must must MD 37231 3998 4 also also RB 37231 3998 5 be be VB 37231 3998 6 heresies heresy NNS 37231 3998 7 amongst amongst IN 37231 3998 8 you -PRON- PRP 37231 3998 9 , , , 37231 3998 10 " " '' 37231 3998 11 & & CC 37231 3998 12 c. c. NNP 37231 3999 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 3999 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 3999 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 3999 4 . . . 37231 4000 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4000 2 2 2 LS 37231 4000 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4000 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4000 5 find find VBP 37231 4000 6 also also RB 37231 4000 7 , , , 37231 4000 8 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 4000 9 , , , 37231 4000 10 traces trace VBZ 37231 4000 11 both both DT 37231 4000 12 of of IN 37231 4000 13 this this DT 37231 4000 14 saying saying NN 37231 4000 15 and and CC 37231 4000 16 that that IN 37231 4000 17 which which WDT 37231 4000 18 accompanies accompany VBZ 37231 4000 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4000 20 . . . 37231 4001 1 In in IN 37231 4001 2 the the DT 37231 4001 3 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4001 4 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 4001 5 , , , 37231 4001 6 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4001 7 is be VBZ 37231 4001 8 represented represent VBN 37231 4001 9 as as IN 37231 4001 10 stating state VBG 37231 4001 11 , , , 37231 4001 12 " " `` 37231 4001 13 For for IN 37231 4001 14 there there EX 37231 4001 15 shall shall MD 37231 4001 16 be be VB 37231 4001 17 , , , 37231 4001 18 as as IN 37231 4001 19 the the DT 37231 4001 20 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4001 21 said say VBD 37231 4001 22 , , , 37231 4001 23 _ _ NNP 37231 4001 24 false false JJ 37231 4001 25 apostles apostle NNS 37231 4001 26 _ _ NNP 37231 4001 27 , , , 37231 4001 28 false false JJ 37231 4001 29 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4001 30 , , , 37231 4001 31 _ _ NNP 37231 4001 32 heresies heresy NNS 37231 4001 33 _ _ NNP 37231 4001 34 , , , 37231 4001 35 desires desire NNS 37231 4001 36 for for IN 37231 4001 37 supremacy supremacy NN 37231 4001 38 , , , 37231 4001 39 " " '' 37231 4001 40 & & CC 37231 4001 41 c. c. NNP 37231 4001 42 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4001 43 --Greek--].3 --Greek--].3 : 37231 4001 44 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4001 45 are be VBP 37231 4001 46 likewise likewise RB 37231 4001 47 reminded remind VBN 37231 4001 48 of of IN 37231 4001 49 the the DT 37231 4001 50 passage passage NN 37231 4001 51 in in IN 37231 4001 52 the the DT 37231 4001 53 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 4001 54 attributed attribute VBD 37231 4001 55 to to IN 37231 4001 56 the the DT 37231 4001 57 Roman Roman NNP 37231 4001 58 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4001 59 , , , 37231 4001 60 xliv xliv NNP 37231 4001 61 . . . 37231 4002 1 : : : 37231 4002 2 " " `` 37231 4002 3 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4002 4 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4002 5 knew know VBD 37231 4002 6 through through IN 37231 4002 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4002 8 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4002 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4002 10 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4002 11 that that IN 37231 4002 12 there there EX 37231 4002 13 would would MD 37231 4002 14 be be VB 37231 4002 15 contention contention NN 37231 4002 16 regarding regard VBG 37231 4002 17 the the DT 37231 4002 18 dignity dignity NN 37231 4002 19 of of IN 37231 4002 20 the the DT 37231 4002 21 episcopate episcopate NN 37231 4002 22 . . . 37231 4003 1 " " `` 37231 4003 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4003 3 4 4 LS 37231 4003 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4003 5 In in IN 37231 4003 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4003 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4003 8 there there EX 37231 4003 9 is be VBZ 37231 4003 10 no no DT 37231 4003 11 reference reference NN 37231 4003 12 anywhere anywhere RB 37231 4003 13 to to IN 37231 4003 14 schisms schism NNS 37231 4003 15 and and CC 37231 4003 16 heresies heresy NNS 37231 4003 17 , , , 37231 4003 18 nor nor CC 37231 4003 19 are be VBP 37231 4003 20 false false JJ 37231 4003 21 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4003 22 once once RB 37231 4003 23 mentioned mention VBD 37231 4003 24 , , , 37231 4003 25 the the DT 37231 4003 26 reference reference NN 37231 4003 27 being be VBG 37231 4003 28 solely solely RB 37231 4003 29 to to IN 37231 4003 30 " " `` 37231 4003 31 false false JJ 37231 4003 32 Christs Christs NNPS 37231 4003 33 " " '' 37231 4003 34 and and CC 37231 4003 35 " " `` 37231 4003 36 false false JJ 37231 4003 37 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4003 38 . . . 37231 4003 39 " " '' 37231 4004 1 The the DT 37231 4004 2 recurrence recurrence NN 37231 4004 3 here here RB 37231 4004 4 and and CC 37231 4004 5 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 4004 6 of of IN 37231 4004 7 the the DT 37231 4004 8 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 4004 9 expression expression NN 37231 4004 10 " " `` 37231 4004 11 false false JJ 37231 4004 12 apostles apostle NNS 37231 4004 13 " " '' 37231 4004 14 is be VBZ 37231 4004 15 very very RB 37231 4004 16 striking,(5 striking,(5 JJ 37231 4004 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4004 18 and and CC 37231 4004 19 the the DT 37231 4004 20 evidence evidence NN 37231 4004 21 for for IN 37231 4004 22 the the DT 37231 4004 23 passage passage NN 37231 4004 24 as as IN 37231 4004 25 a a DT 37231 4004 26 saying saying NN 37231 4004 27 of of IN 37231 4004 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4004 29 is be VBZ 37231 4004 30 important important JJ 37231 4004 31 . . . 37231 4005 1 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4005 2 , , , 37231 4005 3 after after IN 37231 4005 4 enumerating enumerate VBG 37231 4005 5 a a DT 37231 4005 6 vast vast JJ 37231 4005 7 number number NN 37231 4005 8 of of IN 37231 4005 9 heretical heretical JJ 37231 4005 10 sects sect NNS 37231 4005 11 and and CC 37231 4005 12 teachers teacher NNS 37231 4005 13 , , , 37231 4005 14 continues continue VBZ 37231 4005 15 : : : 37231 4005 16 " " `` 37231 4005 17 From from IN 37231 4005 18 these these DT 37231 4005 19 sprang spring VBN 37231 4005 20 the the DT 37231 4005 21 false false JJ 37231 4005 22 Christs Christs NNPS 37231 4005 23 , , , 37231 4005 24 false false JJ 37231 4005 25 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4005 26 , , , 37231 4005 27 _ _ NNP 37231 4005 28 false false JJ 37231 4005 29 apostles apostle NNS 37231 4005 30 _ _ NNP 37231 4005 31 , , , 37231 4005 32 who who WP 37231 4005 33 divided divide VBD 37231 4005 34 the the DT 37231 4005 35 { { -LRB- 37231 4005 36 414 414 CD 37231 4005 37 } } -RRB- 37231 4005 38 union union NN 37231 4005 39 of of IN 37231 4005 40 the the DT 37231 4005 41 Church Church NNP 37231 4005 42 by by IN 37231 4005 43 corrupting corrupt VBG 37231 4005 44 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 4005 45 concerning concern VBG 37231 4005 46 God God NNP 37231 4005 47 and and CC 37231 4005 48 concerning concern VBG 37231 4005 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4005 50 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4005 51 . . . 37231 4006 1 " " `` 37231 4006 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4006 3 1 1 LS 37231 4006 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4006 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4006 6 will will MD 37231 4006 7 be be VB 37231 4006 8 remembered remember VBN 37231 4006 9 that that IN 37231 4006 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4006 11 made make VBD 37231 4006 12 use use NN 37231 4006 13 of of IN 37231 4006 14 the the DT 37231 4006 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4006 16 according accord VBG 37231 4006 17 to to IN 37231 4006 18 the the DT 37231 4006 19 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4006 20 , , , 37231 4006 21 and and CC 37231 4006 22 the the DT 37231 4006 23 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4006 24 literature literature NN 37231 4006 25 points point NNS 37231 4006 26 to to IN 37231 4006 27 the the DT 37231 4006 28 same same JJ 37231 4006 29 source source NN 37231 4006 30 . . . 37231 4007 1 In in IN 37231 4007 2 the the DT 37231 4007 3 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4007 4 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 37231 4007 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4007 6 read read VBP 37231 4007 7 : : : 37231 4007 8 " " `` 37231 4007 9 For for IN 37231 4007 10 these these DT 37231 4007 11 are be VBP 37231 4007 12 false false JJ 37231 4007 13 Christs Christs NNPS 37231 4007 14 and and CC 37231 4007 15 false false JJ 37231 4007 16 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4007 17 , , , 37231 4007 18 _ _ NNP 37231 4007 19 and and CC 37231 4007 20 false false JJ 37231 4007 21 apostles apostle NNS 37231 4007 22 _ _ NNP 37231 4007 23 , , , 37231 4007 24 deceivers deceiver NNS 37231 4007 25 , , , 37231 4007 26 and and CC 37231 4007 27 corrupters corrupter NNS 37231 4007 28 , , , 37231 4007 29 " " '' 37231 4007 30 & & CC 37231 4007 31 c c NNP 37231 4007 32 . . . 37231 4007 33 ,(2 ,(2 , 37231 4007 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4007 35 and and CC 37231 4007 36 in in IN 37231 4007 37 the the DT 37231 4007 38 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4007 39 Recognitions Recognitions NNP 37231 4007 40 the the DT 37231 4007 41 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4007 42 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4007 43 is be VBZ 37231 4007 44 represented represent VBN 37231 4007 45 as as IN 37231 4007 46 saying say VBG 37231 4007 47 that that IN 37231 4007 48 the the DT 37231 4007 49 Devil Devil NNP 37231 4007 50 , , , 37231 4007 51 after after IN 37231 4007 52 the the DT 37231 4007 53 temptation temptation NN 37231 4007 54 , , , 37231 4007 55 terrified terrify VBN 37231 4007 56 by by IN 37231 4007 57 the the DT 37231 4007 58 final final JJ 37231 4007 59 answer answer NN 37231 4007 60 of of IN 37231 4007 61 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4007 62 , , , 37231 4007 63 " " '' 37231 4007 64 hastened hasten VBD 37231 4007 65 immediately immediately RB 37231 4007 66 to to TO 37231 4007 67 send send VB 37231 4007 68 forth forth RB 37231 4007 69 into into IN 37231 4007 70 this this DT 37231 4007 71 world world NN 37231 4007 72 false false JJ 37231 4007 73 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4007 74 , , , 37231 4007 75 and and CC 37231 4007 76 _ _ NNP 37231 4007 77 false false JJ 37231 4007 78 apostles apostle NNS 37231 4007 79 _ _ NNP 37231 4007 80 , , , 37231 4007 81 and and CC 37231 4007 82 false false JJ 37231 4007 83 teachers teacher NNS 37231 4007 84 , , , 37231 4007 85 who who WP 37231 4007 86 should should MD 37231 4007 87 speak speak VB 37231 4007 88 in in IN 37231 4007 89 the the DT 37231 4007 90 name name NN 37231 4007 91 of of IN 37231 4007 92 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4007 93 indeed indeed RB 37231 4007 94 , , , 37231 4007 95 but but CC 37231 4007 96 should should MD 37231 4007 97 perform perform VB 37231 4007 98 the the DT 37231 4007 99 will will NN 37231 4007 100 of of IN 37231 4007 101 the the DT 37231 4007 102 demon demon NN 37231 4007 103 . . . 37231 4008 1 " " `` 37231 4008 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4008 3 3 3 LS 37231 4008 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4008 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4008 6 's 's POS 37231 4008 7 whole whole JJ 37231 4008 8 system system NN 37231 4008 9 forbids forbid VBZ 37231 4008 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4008 11 recognizing recognizing NN 37231 4008 12 in in IN 37231 4008 13 these these DT 37231 4008 14 two two CD 37231 4008 15 passages passage NNS 37231 4008 16 mere mere JJ 37231 4008 17 tradition tradition NN 37231 4008 18 , , , 37231 4008 19 and and CC 37231 4008 20 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4008 21 must must MD 37231 4008 22 hold hold VB 37231 4008 23 that that IN 37231 4008 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4008 25 have have VBP 37231 4008 26 here here RB 37231 4008 27 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4008 28 from from IN 37231 4008 29 a a DT 37231 4008 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4008 31 different different JJ 37231 4008 32 from from IN 37231 4008 33 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 4008 34 . . . 37231 4009 1 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 4009 2 , , , 37231 4009 3 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4009 4 says say VBZ 37231 4009 5 : : : 37231 4009 6 " " `` 37231 4009 7 Out out IN 37231 4009 8 of of IN 37231 4009 9 which which WDT 37231 4009 10 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4009 11 affliction affliction NN 37231 4009 12 and and CC 37231 4009 13 fiery fiery JJ 37231 4009 14 trial trial NN 37231 4009 15 of of IN 37231 4009 16 the the DT 37231 4009 17 Devil Devil NNP 37231 4009 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4009 19 again again RB 37231 4009 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4009 21 , , , 37231 4009 22 the the DT 37231 4009 23 Son Son NNP 37231 4009 24 of of IN 37231 4009 25 God God NNP 37231 4009 26 , , , 37231 4009 27 promised promise VBD 37231 4009 28 to to TO 37231 4009 29 deliver deliver VB 37231 4009 30 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4009 31 , , , 37231 4009 32 and and CC 37231 4009 33 to to TO 37231 4009 34 put put VB 37231 4009 35 on on IN 37231 4009 36 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4009 37 prepared prepared JJ 37231 4009 38 garments garment NNS 37231 4009 39 , , , 37231 4009 40 if if IN 37231 4009 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4009 42 do do VBP 37231 4009 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4009 44 commandments commandment NNS 37231 4009 45 , , , 37231 4009 46 and and CC 37231 4009 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4009 48 is be VBZ 37231 4009 49 proclaimed proclaim VBN 37231 4009 50 as as IN 37231 4009 51 having have VBG 37231 4009 52 provided provide VBN 37231 4009 53 an an DT 37231 4009 54 eternal eternal JJ 37231 4009 55 kingdom kingdom NN 37231 4009 56 for for IN 37231 4009 57 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4009 58 . . . 37231 4010 1 " " `` 37231 4010 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4010 3 4 4 LS 37231 4010 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4010 5 This this DT 37231 4010 6 promise promise NN 37231 4010 7 is be VBZ 37231 4010 8 nowhere nowhere RB 37231 4010 9 found find VBN 37231 4010 10 in in IN 37231 4010 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4010 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4010 13 . . . 37231 4011 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4011 2 5 5 LS 37231 4011 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4011 4 Immediately immediately RB 37231 4011 5 following follow VBG 37231 4011 6 the the DT 37231 4011 7 passage passage NN 37231 4011 8 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4011 9 k k NNP 37231 4011 10 3 3 CD 37231 4011 11 and and CC 37231 4011 12 4 4 CD 37231 4011 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4011 14 which which WDT 37231 4011 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 16 have have VBP 37231 4011 17 discussed(6 discussed(6 FW 37231 4011 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4011 19 as as IN 37231 4011 20 repeated repeat VBN 37231 4011 21 in in IN 37231 4011 22 the the DT 37231 4011 23 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 37231 4011 24 : : : 37231 4011 25 " " `` 37231 4011 26 Many many JJ 37231 4011 27 { { -LRB- 37231 4011 28 415 415 CD 37231 4011 29 } } -RRB- 37231 4011 30 shall shall MD 37231 4011 31 say say VB 37231 4011 32 to to IN 37231 4011 33 me -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 34 , , , 37231 4011 35 & & CC 37231 4011 36 c c NNP 37231 4011 37 , , , 37231 4011 38 & & CC 37231 4011 39 c c NNP 37231 4011 40 , , , 37231 4011 41 and and CC 37231 4011 42 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 43 will will MD 37231 4011 44 say say VB 37231 4011 45 to to IN 37231 4011 46 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 47 , , , 37231 4011 48 Depart Depart NNP 37231 4011 49 from from IN 37231 4011 50 me -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 51 , , , 37231 4011 52 " " `` 37231 4011 53 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4011 54 continues continue VBZ 37231 4011 55 : : : 37231 4011 56 " " `` 37231 4011 57 And and CC 37231 4011 58 in in IN 37231 4011 59 other other JJ 37231 4011 60 words word NNS 37231 4011 61 by by IN 37231 4011 62 which which WDT 37231 4011 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 64 will will MD 37231 4011 65 condemn condemn VB 37231 4011 66 those those DT 37231 4011 67 who who WP 37231 4011 68 are be VBP 37231 4011 69 unworthy unworthy JJ 37231 4011 70 to to TO 37231 4011 71 be be VB 37231 4011 72 saved save VBN 37231 4011 73 , , , 37231 4011 74 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 75 said say VBD 37231 4011 76 that that IN 37231 4011 77 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4011 78 will will MD 37231 4011 79 say say VB 37231 4011 80 : : : 37231 4011 81 Begone Begone VBN 37231 4011 82 into into IN 37231 4011 83 the the DT 37231 4011 84 darkness darkness NN 37231 4011 85 without without IN 37231 4011 86 , , , 37231 4011 87 which which WDT 37231 4011 88 the the DT 37231 4011 89 Father Father NNP 37231 4011 90 hath hath NNP 37231 4011 91 prepared prepare VBD 37231 4011 92 for for IN 37231 4011 93 Satan Satan NNP 37231 4011 94 and and CC 37231 4011 95 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4011 96 angels angel NNS 37231 4011 97 . . . 37231 4012 1 " " `` 37231 4012 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4012 3 1 1 LS 37231 4012 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4012 5 The the DT 37231 4012 6 nearest near JJS 37231 4012 7 parallel parallel NN 37231 4012 8 to to IN 37231 4012 9 this this DT 37231 4012 10 is be VBZ 37231 4012 11 in in IN 37231 4012 12 Matt Matt NNP 37231 4012 13 . . . 37231 4013 1 xxv xxv NNP 37231 4013 2 . . . 37231 4014 1 41 41 CD 37231 4014 2 : : : 37231 4014 3 " " `` 37231 4014 4 Then then RB 37231 4014 5 shall shall MD 37231 4014 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4014 7 say say VB 37231 4014 8 also also RB 37231 4014 9 unto unto IN 37231 4014 10 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4014 11 on on IN 37231 4014 12 the the DT 37231 4014 13 left left JJ 37231 4014 14 hand hand NN 37231 4014 15 : : : 37231 4014 16 Depart Depart NNP 37231 4014 17 from from IN 37231 4014 18 me -PRON- PRP 37231 4014 19 , , , 37231 4014 20 ye ye NNP 37231 4014 21 cursed curse VBD 37231 4014 22 , , , 37231 4014 23 into into IN 37231 4014 24 the the DT 37231 4014 25 eternal eternal JJ 37231 4014 26 fire fire NN 37231 4014 27 which which WDT 37231 4014 28 is be VBZ 37231 4014 29 prepared prepare VBN 37231 4014 30 for for IN 37231 4014 31 the the DT 37231 4014 32 devil devil NNP 37231 4014 33 and and CC 37231 4014 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4014 35 angels angel NNS 37231 4014 36 . . . 37231 4014 37 " " '' 37231 4015 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4015 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4015 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4015 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4015 5 is be VBZ 37231 4015 6 apparent apparent JJ 37231 4015 7 that that IN 37231 4015 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4015 9 's 's POS 37231 4015 10 quotation quotation NN 37231 4015 11 differs differ VBZ 37231 4015 12 very very RB 37231 4015 13 widely widely RB 37231 4015 14 from from IN 37231 4015 15 the the DT 37231 4015 16 reading reading NN 37231 4015 17 of of IN 37231 4015 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4015 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4015 20 . . . 37231 4016 1 The the DT 37231 4016 2 same same JJ 37231 4016 3 reading reading NN 37231 4016 4 , , , 37231 4016 5 with with IN 37231 4016 6 the the DT 37231 4016 7 exception exception NN 37231 4016 8 of of IN 37231 4016 9 a a DT 37231 4016 10 single single JJ 37231 4016 11 word word NN 37231 4016 12 , , , 37231 4016 13 is be VBZ 37231 4016 14 found find VBN 37231 4016 15 in in IN 37231 4016 16 the the DT 37231 4016 17 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4016 18 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 4016 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4016 20 xix xix NNP 37231 4016 21 . . . 37231 4017 1 2 2 LS 37231 4017 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4017 3 , , , 37231 4017 4 that that DT 37231 4017 5 is be VBZ 37231 4017 6 to to TO 37231 4017 7 say say VB 37231 4017 8 , , , 37231 4017 9 that that IN 37231 4017 10 " " `` 37231 4017 11 Devil Devil NNP 37231 4017 12 " " '' 37231 4017 13 is be VBZ 37231 4017 14 substituted substitute VBN 37231 4017 15 for for IN 37231 4017 16 " " `` 37231 4017 17 Satan Satan NNP 37231 4017 18 , , , 37231 4017 19 " " '' 37231 4017 20 and and CC 37231 4017 21 this this DT 37231 4017 22 variation variation NN 37231 4017 23 is be VBZ 37231 4017 24 not not RB 37231 4017 25 important important JJ 37231 4017 26 . . . 37231 4018 1 The the DT 37231 4018 2 agreement agreement NN 37231 4018 3 of of IN 37231 4018 4 the the DT 37231 4018 5 rest rest NN 37231 4018 6 , , , 37231 4018 7 on on IN 37231 4018 8 the the DT 37231 4018 9 other other JJ 37231 4018 10 hand hand NN 37231 4018 11 , , , 37231 4018 12 seems seem VBZ 37231 4018 13 to to TO 37231 4018 14 establish establish VB 37231 4018 15 the the DT 37231 4018 16 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4018 17 that that IN 37231 4018 18 the the DT 37231 4018 19 quotation quotation NN 37231 4018 20 is be VBZ 37231 4018 21 from from IN 37231 4018 22 a a DT 37231 4018 23 written write VBN 37231 4018 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4018 25 different different JJ 37231 4018 26 from from IN 37231 4018 27 ours,(2 ours,(2 NN 37231 4018 28 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4018 29 and and CC 37231 4018 30 here here RB 37231 4018 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4018 32 have have VBP 37231 4018 33 further further JJ 37231 4018 34 strong strong JJ 37231 4018 35 indications indication NNS 37231 4018 36 of of IN 37231 4018 37 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4018 38 's 's POS 37231 4018 39 use use NN 37231 4018 40 of of IN 37231 4018 41 the the DT 37231 4018 42 Ebionite Ebionite NNP 37231 4018 43 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4018 44 . . . 37231 4019 1 Another another DT 37231 4019 2 of of IN 37231 4019 3 the the DT 37231 4019 4 sayings saying NNS 37231 4019 5 of of IN 37231 4019 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4019 7 which which WDT 37231 4019 8 are be VBP 37231 4019 9 foreign foreign JJ 37231 4019 10 to to IN 37231 4019 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4019 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4019 13 is be VBZ 37231 4019 14 one one CD 37231 4019 15 in in IN 37231 4019 16 reference reference NN 37231 4019 17 to to IN 37231 4019 18 the the DT 37231 4019 19 man man NN 37231 4019 20 who who WP 37231 4019 21 falls fall VBZ 37231 4019 22 away away RB 37231 4019 23 from from IN 37231 4019 24 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 4019 25 into into IN 37231 4019 26 sin sin NN 37231 4019 27 , , , 37231 4019 28 of of IN 37231 4019 29 whom whom WP 37231 4019 30 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4019 31 says say VBZ 37231 4019 32 : : : 37231 4019 33 " " `` 37231 4019 34 Wherefore wherefore NN 37231 4019 35 also also RB 37231 4019 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4019 37 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4019 38 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4019 39 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4019 40 said say VBD 37231 4019 41 : : : 37231 4019 42 In in IN 37231 4019 43 whatsoever whatsoever JJ 37231 4019 44 things thing NNS 37231 4019 45 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4019 46 may may MD 37231 4019 47 find find VB 37231 4019 48 you -PRON- PRP 37231 4019 49 , , , 37231 4019 50 in in IN 37231 4019 51 these these DT 37231 4019 52 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4019 53 shall shall MD 37231 4019 54 also also RB 37231 4019 55 judge judge VB 37231 4019 56 you -PRON- PRP 37231 4019 57 . . . 37231 4020 1 " " `` 37231 4020 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4020 3 3 3 CD 37231 4020 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4020 5 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4020 6 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4020 7 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4020 8 { { -LRB- 37231 4020 9 416 416 CD 37231 4020 10 } } -RRB- 37231 4020 11 " " '' 37231 4020 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4020 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4020 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4020 15 " " `` 37231 4020 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4020 17 A a DT 37231 4020 18 similar similar JJ 37231 4020 19 expression expression NN 37231 4020 20 is be VBZ 37231 4020 21 used use VBN 37231 4020 22 by by IN 37231 4020 23 some some DT 37231 4020 24 of of IN 37231 4020 25 the the DT 37231 4020 26 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 4020 27 , , , 37231 4020 28 and and CC 37231 4020 29 in in IN 37231 4020 30 some some DT 37231 4020 31 cases case NNS 37231 4020 32 is be VBZ 37231 4020 33 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4020 34 to to IN 37231 4020 35 the the DT 37231 4020 36 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4020 37 . . . 37231 4021 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4021 2 1 1 LS 37231 4021 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4021 4 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4021 5 of of IN 37231 4021 6 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4021 7 has have VBZ 37231 4021 8 quoted quote VBN 37231 4021 9 a a DT 37231 4021 10 phrase phrase NN 37231 4021 11 closely closely RB 37231 4021 12 resembling resemble VBG 37231 4021 13 this this DT 37231 4021 14 without without IN 37231 4021 15 indicating indicate VBG 37231 4021 16 the the DT 37231 4021 17 source source NN 37231 4021 18 . . . 37231 4022 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4022 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4022 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4022 4 . . . 37231 4023 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4023 2 2 2 LS 37231 4023 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4023 4 Grabe Grabe NNP 37231 4023 5 was be VBD 37231 4023 6 of of IN 37231 4023 7 opinion opinion NN 37231 4023 8 that that IN 37231 4023 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4023 10 derived derive VBD 37231 4023 11 the the DT 37231 4023 12 passage passage NN 37231 4023 13 from from IN 37231 4023 14 the the DT 37231 4023 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4023 16 according accord VBG 37231 4023 17 to to IN 37231 4023 18 the the DT 37231 4023 19 Hebrews,(3 hebrews,(3 NN 37231 4023 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4023 21 an an DT 37231 4023 22 opinion opinion NN 37231 4023 23 shared share VBN 37231 4023 24 by by IN 37231 4023 25 the the DT 37231 4023 26 greater great JJR 37231 4023 27 number number NN 37231 4023 28 of of IN 37231 4023 29 modern modern JJ 37231 4023 30 critics critic NNS 37231 4023 31 , , , 37231 4023 32 and and CC 37231 4023 33 which which WDT 37231 4023 34 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4023 35 are be VBP 37231 4023 36 prepared prepared JJ 37231 4023 37 to to TO 37231 4023 38 accept accept VB 37231 4023 39 from from IN 37231 4023 40 many many JJ 37231 4023 41 previous previous JJ 37231 4023 42 instances instance NNS 37231 4023 43 of of IN 37231 4023 44 agreement agreement NN 37231 4023 45 . . . 37231 4024 1 Even even RB 37231 4024 2 the the DT 37231 4024 3 warmest warm JJS 37231 4024 4 asserters asserter NNS 37231 4024 5 of of IN 37231 4024 6 the the DT 37231 4024 7 theory theory NN 37231 4024 8 that that IN 37231 4024 9 the the DT 37231 4024 10 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4024 11 are be VBP 37231 4024 12 identical identical JJ 37231 4024 13 with with IN 37231 4024 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4024 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4024 16 are be VBP 37231 4024 17 obliged oblige VBN 37231 4024 18 to to TO 37231 4024 19 admit admit VB 37231 4024 20 that that IN 37231 4024 21 this this DT 37231 4024 22 saying saying NN 37231 4024 23 of of IN 37231 4024 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4024 25 is be VBZ 37231 4024 26 not not RB 37231 4024 27 contained contain VBN 37231 4024 28 in in IN 37231 4024 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4024 30 , , , 37231 4024 31 and and CC 37231 4024 32 that that IN 37231 4024 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4024 34 must must MD 37231 4024 35 have have VB 37231 4024 36 been be VBN 37231 4024 37 derived derive VBN 37231 4024 38 from from IN 37231 4024 39 an an DT 37231 4024 40 extra extra JJ 37231 4024 41 - - HYPH 37231 4024 42 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4024 43 source source NN 37231 4024 44 . . . 37231 4025 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4025 2 4 4 LS 37231 4025 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4025 4 Other other JJ 37231 4025 5 passages passage NNS 37231 4025 6 of of IN 37231 4025 7 a a DT 37231 4025 8 similar similar JJ 37231 4025 9 kind kind NN 37231 4025 10 might may MD 37231 4025 11 have have VB 37231 4025 12 been be VBN 37231 4025 13 pointed point VBN 37231 4025 14 out out RP 37231 4025 15 , , , 37231 4025 16 but but CC 37231 4025 17 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4025 18 have have VBP 37231 4025 19 already already RB 37231 4025 20 devoted devote VBN 37231 4025 21 too too RB 37231 4025 22 much much JJ 37231 4025 23 space space NN 37231 4025 24 to to IN 37231 4025 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4025 26 's 's POS 37231 4025 27 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4025 28 , , , 37231 4025 29 and and CC 37231 4025 30 must must MD 37231 4025 31 hasten hasten VB 37231 4025 32 to to IN 37231 4025 33 a a DT 37231 4025 34 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4025 35 . . . 37231 4026 1 There there EX 37231 4026 2 is be VBZ 37231 4026 3 one one CD 37231 4026 4 point point NN 37231 4026 5 , , , 37231 4026 6 however however RB 37231 4026 7 , , , 37231 4026 8 to to TO 37231 4026 9 which which WDT 37231 4026 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4026 11 must must MD 37231 4026 12 refer refer VB 37231 4026 13 . . . 37231 4027 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4027 2 have have VBP 37231 4027 3 more more JJR 37231 4027 4 than than IN 37231 4027 5 once once RB 37231 4027 6 alluded allude VBN 37231 4027 7 to to IN 37231 4027 8 the the DT 37231 4027 9 fact fact NN 37231 4027 10 that that IN 37231 4027 11 , , , 37231 4027 12 unless unless IN 37231 4027 13 in in IN 37231 4027 14 one one CD 37231 4027 15 place place NN 37231 4027 16 , , , 37231 4027 17 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4027 18 never never RB 37231 4027 19 mentions mention VBZ 37231 4027 20 an an DT 37231 4027 21 author author NN 37231 4027 22 's 's POS 37231 4027 23 name name NN 37231 4027 24 in in IN 37231 4027 25 connection connection NN 37231 4027 26 with with IN 37231 4027 27 the the DT 37231 4027 28 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4027 29 of of IN 37231 4027 30 the the DT 37231 4027 31 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4027 32 . . . 37231 4028 1 The the DT 37231 4028 2 exception exception NN 37231 4028 3 to to TO 37231 4028 4 which which WDT 37231 4028 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4028 6 referred refer VBD 37231 4028 7 is be VBZ 37231 4028 8 the the DT 37231 4028 9 following follow VBG 37231 4028 10 . . . 37231 4029 1 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4029 2 says say VBZ 37231 4029 3 : : : 37231 4029 4 " " `` 37231 4029 5 The the DT 37231 4029 6 statement statement NN 37231 4029 7 also also RB 37231 4029 8 that that IN 37231 4029 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4029 10 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4029 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4029 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4029 13 changed change VBD 37231 4029 14 the the DT 37231 4029 15 name name NN 37231 4029 16 of of IN 37231 4029 17 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4029 18 , , , 37231 4029 19 one one CD 37231 4029 20 of of IN 37231 4029 21 the the DT 37231 4029 22 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4029 23 , , , 37231 4029 24 and and CC 37231 4029 25 that that IN 37231 4029 26 this this DT 37231 4029 27 is be VBZ 37231 4029 28 also also RB 37231 4029 29 written write VBN 37231 4029 30 in in IN 37231 4029 31 _ _ NNP 37231 4029 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4029 33 _ _ NNP 37231 4029 34 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 4029 35 as as IN 37231 4029 36 having have VBG 37231 4029 37 been be VBN 37231 4029 38 done do VBN 37231 4029 39 , , , 37231 4029 40 { { -LRB- 37231 4029 41 417 417 CD 37231 4029 42 } } -RRB- 37231 4029 43 together together RB 37231 4029 44 with with IN 37231 4029 45 the the DT 37231 4029 46 fact fact NN 37231 4029 47 that that IN 37231 4029 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4029 49 also also RB 37231 4029 50 changed change VBD 37231 4029 51 the the DT 37231 4029 52 name name NN 37231 4029 53 of of IN 37231 4029 54 other other JJ 37231 4029 55 two two CD 37231 4029 56 brothers brother NNS 37231 4029 57 , , , 37231 4029 58 who who WP 37231 4029 59 were be VBD 37231 4029 60 sons son NNS 37231 4029 61 of of IN 37231 4029 62 Zebedee Zebedee NNP 37231 4029 63 , , , 37231 4029 64 to to IN 37231 4029 65 Boanerges Boanerges NNP 37231 4029 66 , , , 37231 4029 67 that that RB 37231 4029 68 is is RB 37231 4029 69 , , , 37231 4029 70 sons son NNS 37231 4029 71 of of IN 37231 4029 72 Thunder Thunder NNP 37231 4029 73 , , , 37231 4029 74 " " '' 37231 4029 75 & & CC 37231 4029 76 c.(1 c.(1 NNP 37231 4029 77 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4029 78 According accord VBG 37231 4029 79 to to IN 37231 4029 80 the the DT 37231 4029 81 usual usual JJ 37231 4029 82 language language NN 37231 4029 83 of of IN 37231 4029 84 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4029 85 , , , 37231 4029 86 and and CC 37231 4029 87 upon upon IN 37231 4029 88 strictly strictly RB 37231 4029 89 critical critical JJ 37231 4029 90 grounds ground NNS 37231 4029 91 , , , 37231 4029 92 the the DT 37231 4029 93 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4029 94 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4029 95 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4029 96 in in IN 37231 4029 97 this this DT 37231 4029 98 passage passage NN 37231 4029 99 must must MD 37231 4029 100 be be VB 37231 4029 101 referred refer VBN 37231 4029 102 to to IN 37231 4029 103 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4029 104 ; ; : 37231 4029 105 and and CC 37231 4029 106 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4029 107 , , , 37231 4029 108 therefore therefore RB 37231 4029 109 , , , 37231 4029 110 seems seem VBZ 37231 4029 111 to to TO 37231 4029 112 ascribe ascribe VB 37231 4029 113 the the DT 37231 4029 114 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4029 115 to to IN 37231 4029 116 that that DT 37231 4029 117 Apostle apostle NN 37231 4029 118 , , , 37231 4029 119 and and CC 37231 4029 120 to to TO 37231 4029 121 speak speak VB 37231 4029 122 of of IN 37231 4029 123 a a DT 37231 4029 124 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4029 125 of of IN 37231 4029 126 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4029 127 . . . 37231 4030 1 Some some DT 37231 4030 2 critics critic NNS 37231 4030 3 maintain maintain VBP 37231 4030 4 that that IN 37231 4030 5 the the DT 37231 4030 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4030 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4030 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4030 9 does do VBZ 37231 4030 10 not not RB 37231 4030 11 refer refer VB 37231 4030 12 to to IN 37231 4030 13 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4030 14 , , , 37231 4030 15 but but CC 37231 4030 16 to to IN 37231 4030 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4030 18 , , , 37231 4030 19 or or CC 37231 4030 20 , , , 37231 4030 21 more more RBR 37231 4030 22 probably probably RB 37231 4030 23 still still RB 37231 4030 24 , , , 37231 4030 25 that that IN 37231 4030 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4030 27 should should MD 37231 4030 28 be be VB 37231 4030 29 amended amend VBN 37231 4030 30 to to IN 37231 4030 31 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4030 32 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4030 33 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4030 34 , , , 37231 4030 35 and and CC 37231 4030 36 apply apply VB 37231 4030 37 to to IN 37231 4030 38 the the DT 37231 4030 39 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4030 40 . . . 37231 4031 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4031 2 3 3 LS 37231 4031 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4031 4 The the DT 37231 4031 5 great great JJ 37231 4031 6 majority majority NN 37231 4031 7 , , , 37231 4031 8 however however RB 37231 4031 9 , , , 37231 4031 10 are be VBP 37231 4031 11 forced force VBN 37231 4031 12 to to TO 37231 4031 13 admit admit VB 37231 4031 14 the the DT 37231 4031 15 reference reference NN 37231 4031 16 of of IN 37231 4031 17 the the DT 37231 4031 18 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4031 19 to to IN 37231 4031 20 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4031 21 , , , 37231 4031 22 although although IN 37231 4031 23 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4031 24 explain explain VBP 37231 4031 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4031 26 , , , 37231 4031 27 as as IN 37231 4031 28 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4031 29 shall shall MD 37231 4031 30 see see VB 37231 4031 31 , , , 37231 4031 32 in in IN 37231 4031 33 different different JJ 37231 4031 34 ways way NNS 37231 4031 35 . . . 37231 4032 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4032 2 is be VBZ 37231 4032 3 argued argue VBN 37231 4032 4 by by IN 37231 4032 5 some some DT 37231 4032 6 that that IN 37231 4032 7 this this DT 37231 4032 8 expression expression NN 37231 4032 9 is be VBZ 37231 4032 10 used use VBN 37231 4032 11 when when WRB 37231 4032 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4032 13 is be VBZ 37231 4032 14 alluding allude VBG 37231 4032 15 to to IN 37231 4032 16 the the DT 37231 4032 17 change change NN 37231 4032 18 of of IN 37231 4032 19 name name NN 37231 4032 20 not not RB 37231 4032 21 only only RB 37231 4032 22 of of IN 37231 4032 23 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4032 24 but but CC 37231 4032 25 of of IN 37231 4032 26 the the DT 37231 4032 27 sons son NNS 37231 4032 28 of of IN 37231 4032 29 Zebedee Zebedee NNP 37231 4032 30 , , , 37231 4032 31 the the DT 37231 4032 32 narrative narrative NN 37231 4032 33 of of IN 37231 4032 34 which which WDT 37231 4032 35 is be VBZ 37231 4032 36 only only RB 37231 4032 37 found find VBN 37231 4032 38 in in IN 37231 4032 39 the the DT 37231 4032 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4032 41 according accord VBG 37231 4032 42 to to IN 37231 4032 43 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4032 44 . . . 37231 4033 1 Now now RB 37231 4033 2 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4033 3 was be VBD 37231 4033 4 held hold VBN 37231 4033 5 by by IN 37231 4033 6 many many JJ 37231 4033 7 of of IN 37231 4033 8 the the DT 37231 4033 9 Fathers father NNS 37231 4033 10 to to TO 37231 4033 11 have have VB 37231 4033 12 been be VBN 37231 4033 13 the the DT 37231 4033 14 mere mere JJ 37231 4033 15 mouthpiece mouthpiece NN 37231 4033 16 of of IN 37231 4033 17 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4033 18 , , , 37231 4033 19 and and CC 37231 4033 20 to to TO 37231 4033 21 have have VB 37231 4033 22 written write VBN 37231 4033 23 at at IN 37231 4033 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4033 25 dictation;(3 dictation;(3 NN 37231 4033 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4033 27 so so IN 37231 4033 28 that that IN 37231 4033 29 , , , 37231 4033 30 in in IN 37231 4033 31 fact fact NN 37231 4033 32 , , , 37231 4033 33 in in IN 37231 4033 34 calling call VBG 37231 4033 35 the the DT 37231 4033 36 second second JJ 37231 4033 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4033 38 by by IN 37231 4033 39 the the DT 37231 4033 40 name name NN 37231 4033 41 of of IN 37231 4033 42 the the DT 37231 4033 43 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4033 44 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4033 45 , , , 37231 4033 46 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4033 47 argue argue VBP 37231 4033 48 , , , 37231 4033 49 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4033 50 merely merely RB 37231 4033 51 adopted adopt VBD 37231 4033 52 the the DT 37231 4033 53 tradition tradition NN 37231 4033 54 current current JJ 37231 4033 55 in in IN 37231 4033 56 the the DT 37231 4033 57 early early JJ 37231 4033 58 Church Church NNP 37231 4033 59 , , , 37231 4033 60 and and CC 37231 4033 61 referred refer VBD 37231 4033 62 to to IN 37231 4033 63 the the DT 37231 4033 64 { { -LRB- 37231 4033 65 418 418 CD 37231 4033 66 } } -RRB- 37231 4033 67 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4033 68 now now RB 37231 4033 69 known know VBN 37231 4033 70 as as IN 37231 4033 71 the the DT 37231 4033 72 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4033 73 according accord VBG 37231 4033 74 to to IN 37231 4033 75 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4033 76 . . . 37231 4034 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4034 2 1 1 LS 37231 4034 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4034 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4034 5 must must MD 37231 4034 6 be be VB 37231 4034 7 evident evident JJ 37231 4034 8 , , , 37231 4034 9 however however RB 37231 4034 10 , , , 37231 4034 11 that that IN 37231 4034 12 after after IN 37231 4034 13 admitting admit VBG 37231 4034 14 that that IN 37231 4034 15 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4034 16 speaks speak VBZ 37231 4034 17 of of IN 37231 4034 18 the the DT 37231 4034 19 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4034 20 of of IN 37231 4034 21 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4034 22 , , , 37231 4034 23 " " `` 37231 4034 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4034 25 is be VBZ 37231 4034 26 indeed indeed RB 37231 4034 27 hasty hasty JJ 37231 4034 28 in in IN 37231 4034 29 the the DT 37231 4034 30 extreme extreme NN 37231 4034 31 to to TO 37231 4034 32 conclude conclude VB 37231 4034 33 from from IN 37231 4034 34 the the DT 37231 4034 35 fact fact NN 37231 4034 36 that that IN 37231 4034 37 the the DT 37231 4034 38 mention mention NN 37231 4034 39 of of IN 37231 4034 40 the the DT 37231 4034 41 sons son NNS 37231 4034 42 of of IN 37231 4034 43 Zebedee Zebedee NNP 37231 4034 44 being be VBG 37231 4034 45 surnamed surname VBN 37231 4034 46 Boanerges Boanerges NNP 37231 4034 47 is be VBZ 37231 4034 48 only only RB 37231 4034 49 recorded record VBN 37231 4034 50 in in IN 37231 4034 51 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4034 52 iii iii NNP 37231 4034 53 . . . 37231 4035 1 17 17 CD 37231 4035 2 , , , 37231 4035 3 and and CC 37231 4035 4 not not RB 37231 4035 5 in in IN 37231 4035 6 the the DT 37231 4035 7 other other JJ 37231 4035 8 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4035 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4035 10 , , , 37231 4035 11 that that IN 37231 4035 12 therefore therefore RB 37231 4035 13 the the DT 37231 4035 14 " " `` 37231 4035 15 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 4035 16 of of IN 37231 4035 17 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4035 18 " " '' 37231 4035 19 and and CC 37231 4035 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4035 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4035 22 according accord VBG 37231 4035 23 to to IN 37231 4035 24 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4035 25 are be VBP 37231 4035 26 one one CD 37231 4035 27 and and CC 37231 4035 28 the the DT 37231 4035 29 same same JJ 37231 4035 30 . . . 37231 4036 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4036 2 shall shall MD 37231 4036 3 , , , 37231 4036 4 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 4036 5 , , , 37231 4036 6 in in IN 37231 4036 7 examining examine VBG 37231 4036 8 the the DT 37231 4036 9 testimony testimony NN 37231 4036 10 of of IN 37231 4036 11 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4036 12 , , , 37231 4036 13 see see VB 37231 4036 14 that that IN 37231 4036 15 the the DT 37231 4036 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4036 17 according accord VBG 37231 4036 18 to to IN 37231 4036 19 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4036 20 , , , 37231 4036 21 of of IN 37231 4036 22 which which WDT 37231 4036 23 the the DT 37231 4036 24 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4036 25 of of IN 37231 4036 26 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 37231 4036 27 speaks speak VBZ 37231 4036 28 , , , 37231 4036 29 was be VBD 37231 4036 30 not not RB 37231 4036 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4036 32 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4036 33 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4036 34 at at RB 37231 4036 35 all all RB 37231 4036 36 . . . 37231 4037 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4037 2 would would MD 37231 4037 3 be be VB 37231 4037 4 very very RB 37231 4037 5 singular singular JJ 37231 4037 6 indeed indeed RB 37231 4037 7 on on IN 37231 4037 8 this this DT 37231 4037 9 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37231 4037 10 that that IN 37231 4037 11 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4037 12 should should MD 37231 4037 13 not not RB 37231 4037 14 have have VB 37231 4037 15 quoted quote VBN 37231 4037 16 a a DT 37231 4037 17 single single JJ 37231 4037 18 passage passage NN 37231 4037 19 from from IN 37231 4037 20 the the DT 37231 4037 21 only only JJ 37231 4037 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4037 23 whose whose WP$ 37231 4037 24 author author NN 37231 4037 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4037 26 names name VBZ 37231 4037 27 , , , 37231 4037 28 and and CC 37231 4037 29 the the DT 37231 4037 30 number number NN 37231 4037 31 of of IN 37231 4037 32 times time NNS 37231 4037 33 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4037 34 seems seem VBZ 37231 4037 35 to to TO 37231 4037 36 quote quote VB 37231 4037 37 from from IN 37231 4037 38 a a DT 37231 4037 39 Petrine Petrine NNP 37231 4037 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4037 41 , , , 37231 4037 42 which which WDT 37231 4037 43 was be VBD 37231 4037 44 quite quite RB 37231 4037 45 different different JJ 37231 4037 46 from from IN 37231 4037 47 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4037 48 , , , 37231 4037 49 confirms confirm VBZ 37231 4037 50 the the DT 37231 4037 51 inference inference NN 37231 4037 52 that that IN 37231 4037 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4037 54 can can MD 37231 4037 55 not not RB 37231 4037 56 possibly possibly RB 37231 4037 57 here here RB 37231 4037 58 refer refer VB 37231 4037 59 to to IN 37231 4037 60 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4037 61 second second JJ 37231 4037 62 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4037 63 . . . 37231 4038 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4038 2 is be VBZ 37231 4038 3 maintained maintain VBN 37231 4038 4 , , , 37231 4038 5 therefore therefore RB 37231 4038 6 , , , 37231 4038 7 by by IN 37231 4038 8 numerous numerous JJ 37231 4038 9 other other JJ 37231 4038 10 critics critic NNS 37231 4038 11 that that WDT 37231 4038 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4038 13 refers refer VBZ 37231 4038 14 to to IN 37231 4038 15 a a DT 37231 4038 16 Gospel gospel NN 37231 4038 17 according accord VBG 37231 4038 18 to to IN 37231 4038 19 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4038 20 , , , 37231 4038 21 or or CC 37231 4038 22 according accord VBG 37231 4038 23 to to IN 37231 4038 24 the the DT 37231 4038 25 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4038 26 , , , 37231 4038 27 and and CC 37231 4038 28 not not RB 37231 4038 29 to to IN 37231 4038 30 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4038 31 . . . 37231 4039 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4039 2 3 3 LS 37231 4039 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4039 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4039 5 learn learn VBP 37231 4039 6 from from IN 37231 4039 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4039 8 that that IN 37231 4039 9 Serapion Serapion NNP 37231 4039 10 , , , 37231 4039 11 who who WP 37231 4039 12 became become VBD 37231 4039 13 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4039 14 of of IN 37231 4039 15 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 4039 16 about about IN 37231 4039 17 a.d a.d NNP 37231 4039 18 . . NNP 37231 4039 19 190 190 CD 37231 4039 20 , , , 37231 4039 21 composed compose VBD 37231 4039 22 a a DT 37231 4039 23 book book NN 37231 4039 24 on on IN 37231 4039 25 { { -LRB- 37231 4039 26 419 419 CD 37231 4039 27 } } -RRB- 37231 4039 28 the the DT 37231 4039 29 " " `` 37231 4039 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4039 31 according accord VBG 37231 4039 32 to to IN 37231 4039 33 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4039 34 " " '' 37231 4039 35 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4039 36 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4039 37 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4039 38 , , , 37231 4039 39 which which WDT 37231 4039 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4039 41 found find VBD 37231 4039 42 in in IN 37231 4039 43 circulation circulation NN 37231 4039 44 in in IN 37231 4039 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4039 46 diocese diocese NN 37231 4039 47 . . . 37231 4040 1 At at IN 37231 4040 2 first first JJ 37231 4040 3 Serapion Serapion NNP 37231 4040 4 had have VBD 37231 4040 5 permitted permit VBN 37231 4040 6 the the DT 37231 4040 7 use use NN 37231 4040 8 of of IN 37231 4040 9 this this DT 37231 4040 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4040 11 , , , 37231 4040 12 as as IN 37231 4040 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4040 14 evidently evidently RB 37231 4040 15 was be VBD 37231 4040 16 much much RB 37231 4040 17 prized prize VBN 37231 4040 18 , , , 37231 4040 19 but but CC 37231 4040 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4040 21 subsequently subsequently RB 37231 4040 22 condemned condemn VBD 37231 4040 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4040 24 as as IN 37231 4040 25 a a DT 37231 4040 26 work work NN 37231 4040 27 favouring favour VBG 37231 4040 28 Docetic docetic JJ 37231 4040 29 views view NNS 37231 4040 30 , , , 37231 4040 31 and and CC 37231 4040 32 containing contain VBG 37231 4040 33 many many JJ 37231 4040 34 things thing NNS 37231 4040 35 superadded superadde VBN 37231 4040 36 to to IN 37231 4040 37 the the DT 37231 4040 38 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 4040 39 of of IN 37231 4040 40 the the DT 37231 4040 41 Saviour Saviour NNP 37231 4040 42 . . . 37231 4041 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4041 2 1 1 LS 37231 4041 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4041 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 4041 5 likewise likewise RB 37231 4041 6 makes make VBZ 37231 4041 7 mention mention NN 37231 4041 8 of of IN 37231 4041 9 the the DT 37231 4041 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4041 11 according accord VBG 37231 4041 12 to to IN 37231 4041 13 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4041 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4041 15 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4041 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4041 17 as as IN 37231 4041 18 agreeing agree VBG 37231 4041 19 with with IN 37231 4041 20 the the DT 37231 4041 21 tradition tradition NN 37231 4041 22 of of IN 37231 4041 23 the the DT 37231 4041 24 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4041 25 . . . 37231 4042 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4042 2 3 3 LS 37231 4042 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4042 4 But but CC 37231 4042 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4042 6 relationship relationship NN 37231 4042 7 to to IN 37231 4042 8 the the DT 37231 4042 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4042 10 according accord VBG 37231 4042 11 to to IN 37231 4042 12 the the DT 37231 4042 13 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4042 14 becomes become VBZ 37231 4042 15 more more RBR 37231 4042 16 clear clear JJ 37231 4042 17 when when WRB 37231 4042 18 Theodoret theodoret JJ 37231 4042 19 states state VBZ 37231 4042 20 that that IN 37231 4042 21 the the DT 37231 4042 22 Nazarenes Nazarenes NNPS 37231 4042 23 made make VBD 37231 4042 24 use use NN 37231 4042 25 of of IN 37231 4042 26 the the DT 37231 4042 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4042 28 according accord VBG 37231 4042 29 to to IN 37231 4042 30 Peter,(3 peter,(3 NN 37231 4042 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4042 32 for for IN 37231 4042 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4042 34 know know VBP 37231 4042 35 by by IN 37231 4042 36 the the DT 37231 4042 37 testimony testimony NN 37231 4042 38 of of IN 37231 4042 39 the the DT 37231 4042 40 Fathers father NNS 37231 4042 41 generally generally RB 37231 4042 42 that that IN 37231 4042 43 the the DT 37231 4042 44 Nazarene Nazarene NNP 37231 4042 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4042 46 was be VBD 37231 4042 47 that that DT 37231 4042 48 commonly commonly RB 37231 4042 49 called call VBN 37231 4042 50 the the DT 37231 4042 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4042 52 according accord VBG 37231 4042 53 to to IN 37231 4042 54 the the DT 37231 4042 55 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4042 56 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4042 57 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4042 58 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4042 59 . . . 37231 4043 1 The the DT 37231 4043 2 same same JJ 37231 4043 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4043 4 was be VBD 37231 4043 5 in in IN 37231 4043 6 use use NN 37231 4043 7 amongst amongst IN 37231 4043 8 the the DT 37231 4043 9 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 4043 10 , , , 37231 4043 11 and and CC 37231 4043 12 in in IN 37231 4043 13 fact fact NN 37231 4043 14 , , , 37231 4043 15 as as IN 37231 4043 16 almost almost RB 37231 4043 17 all all DT 37231 4043 18 critics critic NNS 37231 4043 19 are be VBP 37231 4043 20 agreed agree VBN 37231 4043 21 , , , 37231 4043 22 the the DT 37231 4043 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4043 24 according accord VBG 37231 4043 25 to to IN 37231 4043 26 the the DT 37231 4043 27 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4043 28 , , , 37231 4043 29 under under IN 37231 4043 30 various various JJ 37231 4043 31 names name NNS 37231 4043 32 , , , 37231 4043 33 such such JJ 37231 4043 34 as as IN 37231 4043 35 the the DT 37231 4043 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4043 37 according accord VBG 37231 4043 38 to to IN 37231 4043 39 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4043 40 , , , 37231 4043 41 according accord VBG 37231 4043 42 to to IN 37231 4043 43 the the DT 37231 4043 44 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4043 45 , , , 37231 4043 46 the the DT 37231 4043 47 Nazarenes Nazarenes NNPS 37231 4043 48 , , , 37231 4043 49 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 4043 50 , , , 37231 4043 51 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 37231 4043 52 , , , 37231 4043 53 & & CC 37231 4043 54 c c NNP 37231 4043 55 , , , 37231 4043 56 with with IN 37231 4043 57 modifications modification NNS 37231 4043 58 certainly certainly RB 37231 4043 59 , , , 37231 4043 60 but but CC 37231 4043 61 substantially substantially RB 37231 4043 62 the the DT 37231 4043 63 same same JJ 37231 4043 64 work work NN 37231 4043 65 , , , 37231 4043 66 was be VBD 37231 4043 67 circulated circulate VBN 37231 4043 68 very very RB 37231 4043 69 widely widely RB 37231 4043 70 throughout throughout IN 37231 4043 71 the the DT 37231 4043 72 early early JJ 37231 4043 73 Church Church NNP 37231 4043 74 . . . 37231 4044 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4044 2 4 4 LS 37231 4044 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4044 4 A a DT 37231 4044 5 quotation quotation NN 37231 4044 6 occurs occur VBZ 37231 4044 7 in in IN 37231 4044 8 the the DT 37231 4044 9 { { -LRB- 37231 4044 10 420 420 CD 37231 4044 11 } } -RRB- 37231 4044 12 so so RB 37231 4044 13 - - HYPH 37231 4044 14 called call VBN 37231 4044 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 4044 16 of of IN 37231 4044 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 37231 4044 18 to to IN 37231 4044 19 the the DT 37231 4044 20 Smyrnaeans Smyrnaeans NNPS 37231 4044 21 , , , 37231 4044 22 to to TO 37231 4044 23 which which WDT 37231 4044 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4044 25 have have VBP 37231 4044 26 already already RB 37231 4044 27 referred refer VBN 37231 4044 28 , , , 37231 4044 29 which which WDT 37231 4044 30 is be VBZ 37231 4044 31 said say VBN 37231 4044 32 by by IN 37231 4044 33 Origen Origen NNP 37231 4044 34 to to TO 37231 4044 35 be be VB 37231 4044 36 in in IN 37231 4044 37 the the DT 37231 4044 38 work work NN 37231 4044 39 called call VBN 37231 4044 40 the the DT 37231 4044 41 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 4044 42 of of IN 37231 4044 43 Peter(l peter(l NN 37231 4044 44 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4044 45 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4044 46 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4044 47 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4044 48 , , , 37231 4044 49 but but CC 37231 4044 50 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4044 51 states state VBZ 37231 4044 52 that that IN 37231 4044 53 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4044 54 is be VBZ 37231 4044 55 taken take VBN 37231 4044 56 from from IN 37231 4044 57 the the DT 37231 4044 58 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4044 59 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4044 60 of of IN 37231 4044 61 the the DT 37231 4044 62 Nazarenes Nazarenes NNPS 37231 4044 63 . . . 37231 4045 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4045 2 2 2 LS 37231 4045 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4045 4 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 37231 4045 5 finds find VBZ 37231 4045 6 traces trace NNS 37231 4045 7 of of IN 37231 4045 8 the the DT 37231 4045 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4045 10 according accord VBG 37231 4045 11 to to IN 37231 4045 12 the the DT 37231 4045 13 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4045 14 before before IN 37231 4045 15 a.d a.d NNP 37231 4045 16 . . NNP 37231 4045 17 130 130 CD 37231 4045 18 in in IN 37231 4045 19 the the DT 37231 4045 20 Talmud Talmud NNP 37231 4045 21 . . . 37231 4046 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4046 2 3 3 LS 37231 4046 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4046 4 Eusebius(4 eusebius(4 NN 37231 4046 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4046 6 informs inform VBZ 37231 4046 7 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4046 8 that that IN 37231 4046 9 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4046 10 narrated narrate VBD 37231 4046 11 a a DT 37231 4046 12 story story NN 37231 4046 13 regarding regard VBG 37231 4046 14 a a DT 37231 4046 15 woman woman NN 37231 4046 16 accused accuse VBN 37231 4046 17 before before IN 37231 4046 18 the the DT 37231 4046 19 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4046 20 of of IN 37231 4046 21 many many JJ 37231 4046 22 sins sin NNS 37231 4046 23 which which WDT 37231 4046 24 was be VBD 37231 4046 25 contained contain VBN 37231 4046 26 in in IN 37231 4046 27 the the DT 37231 4046 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4046 29 according accord VBG 37231 4046 30 to to IN 37231 4046 31 the the DT 37231 4046 32 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4046 33 . . . 37231 4047 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4047 2 5 5 LS 37231 4047 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4047 4 The the DT 37231 4047 5 same same JJ 37231 4047 6 writer writer NN 37231 4047 7 likewise likewise RB 37231 4047 8 states state VBZ 37231 4047 9 that that IN 37231 4047 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4047 11 , , , 37231 4047 12 who who WP 37231 4047 13 came come VBD 37231 4047 14 to to IN 37231 4047 15 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4047 16 and and CC 37231 4047 17 commenced commence VBD 37231 4047 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4047 19 public public JJ 37231 4047 20 career career NN 37231 4047 21 under under IN 37231 4047 22 Anicetus Anicetus NNP 37231 4047 23 , , , 37231 4047 24 quoted quote VBN 37231 4047 25 from from IN 37231 4047 26 the the DT 37231 4047 27 same same JJ 37231 4047 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4047 29 . . . 37231 4048 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4048 2 6 6 LS 37231 4048 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4048 4 The the DT 37231 4048 5 evidence evidence NN 37231 4048 6 of of IN 37231 4048 7 this this DT 37231 4048 8 " " `` 37231 4048 9 ancient ancient JJ 37231 4048 10 and and CC 37231 4048 11 apostolic apostolic JJ 37231 4048 12 man man NN 37231 4048 13 is be VBZ 37231 4048 14 very very RB 37231 4048 15 important important JJ 37231 4048 16 , , , 37231 4048 17 for for IN 37231 4048 18 although although IN 37231 4048 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4048 20 evidently evidently RB 37231 4048 21 attaches attach VBZ 37231 4048 22 great great JJ 37231 4048 23 value value NN 37231 4048 24 to to IN 37231 4048 25 tradition tradition NN 37231 4048 26 , , , 37231 4048 27 does do VBZ 37231 4048 28 not not RB 37231 4048 29 seem seem VB 37231 4048 30 to to TO 37231 4048 31 know know VB 37231 4048 32 of of IN 37231 4048 33 any any DT 37231 4048 34 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4048 35 Scriptures scripture NNS 37231 4048 36 of of IN 37231 4048 37 the the DT 37231 4048 38 New New NNP 37231 4048 39 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4048 40 { { -LRB- 37231 4048 41 421 421 CD 37231 4048 42 } } -RRB- 37231 4048 43 and and CC 37231 4048 44 , , , 37231 4048 45 like like IN 37231 4048 46 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4048 47 , , , 37231 4048 48 apparently apparently RB 37231 4048 49 rejected reject VBD 37231 4048 50 the the DT 37231 4048 51 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4048 52 Paul,(1 Paul,(1 NNP 37231 4048 53 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4048 54 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4048 55 still still RB 37231 4048 56 regarded regard VBD 37231 4048 57 the the DT 37231 4048 58 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4048 59 according accord VBG 37231 4048 60 to to IN 37231 4048 61 the the DT 37231 4048 62 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4048 63 with with IN 37231 4048 64 respect respect NN 37231 4048 65 , , , 37231 4048 66 and and CC 37231 4048 67 probably probably RB 37231 4048 68 made make VBD 37231 4048 69 exclusive exclusive JJ 37231 4048 70 use use NN 37231 4048 71 of of IN 37231 4048 72 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4048 73 . . . 37231 4049 1 The the DT 37231 4049 2 best good JJS 37231 4049 3 critics critic NNS 37231 4049 4 consider consider VBP 37231 4049 5 that that IN 37231 4049 6 this this DT 37231 4049 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4049 8 was be VBD 37231 4049 9 the the DT 37231 4049 10 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 4049 11 work work NN 37231 4049 12 used use VBN 37231 4049 13 by by IN 37231 4049 14 the the DT 37231 4049 15 author author NN 37231 4049 16 of of IN 37231 4049 17 the the DT 37231 4049 18 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4049 19 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 4049 20 . . . 37231 4050 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4050 2 2 2 LS 37231 4050 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4050 4 Cerinthus Cerinthus NNP 37231 4050 5 and and CC 37231 4050 6 Carpocrates Carpocrates NNPS 37231 4050 7 made make VBD 37231 4050 8 use use NN 37231 4050 9 of of IN 37231 4050 10 a a DT 37231 4050 11 form form NN 37231 4050 12 of of IN 37231 4050 13 it,(3 it,(3 NN 37231 4050 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4050 15 and and CC 37231 4050 16 there there EX 37231 4050 17 is be VBZ 37231 4050 18 good good JJ 37231 4050 19 reason reason NN 37231 4050 20 to to TO 37231 4050 21 suppose suppose VB 37231 4050 22 that that IN 37231 4050 23 Tatian Tatian NNP 37231 4050 24 , , , 37231 4050 25 like like IN 37231 4050 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4050 27 master master NN 37231 4050 28 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4050 29 , , , 37231 4050 30 used use VBD 37231 4050 31 the the DT 37231 4050 32 same same JJ 37231 4050 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4050 34 : : : 37231 4050 35 indeed indeed RB 37231 4050 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4050 37 " " `` 37231 4050 38 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 37231 4050 39 , , , 37231 4050 40 " " '' 37231 4050 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4050 42 are be VBP 37231 4050 43 told tell VBN 37231 4050 44 , , , 37231 4050 45 was be VBD 37231 4050 46 by by IN 37231 4050 47 some some DT 37231 4050 48 called call VBN 37231 4050 49 the the DT 37231 4050 50 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4050 51 according accord VBG 37231 4050 52 to to IN 37231 4050 53 the the DT 37231 4050 54 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4050 55 . . . 37231 4051 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4051 2 4 4 LS 37231 4051 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4051 4 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4051 5 of of IN 37231 4051 6 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4051 7 quotes quote VBZ 37231 4051 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4051 9 as as IN 37231 4051 10 an an DT 37231 4051 11 authority authority NN 37231 4051 12 , , , 37231 4051 13 with with IN 37231 4051 14 quite quite PDT 37231 4051 15 the the DT 37231 4051 16 same same JJ 37231 4051 17 respect respect NN 37231 4051 18 as as IN 37231 4051 19 the the DT 37231 4051 20 other other JJ 37231 4051 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4051 22 . . . 37231 4052 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4052 2 says say VBZ 37231 4052 3 : : : 37231 4052 4 " " `` 37231 4052 5 So so RB 37231 4052 6 also also RB 37231 4052 7 in in IN 37231 4052 8 the the DT 37231 4052 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4052 10 according accord VBG 37231 4052 11 to to IN 37231 4052 12 the the DT 37231 4052 13 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4052 14 : : : 37231 4052 15 ' ' '' 37231 4052 16 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4052 17 who who WP 37231 4052 18 wonders wonder VBZ 37231 4052 19 shall shall MD 37231 4052 20 reign reign NN 37231 4052 21 , , , 37231 4052 22 ' ' '' 37231 4052 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4052 24 is be VBZ 37231 4052 25 written write VBN 37231 4052 26 , , , 37231 4052 27 ' ' '' 37231 4052 28 and and CC 37231 4052 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4052 30 who who WP 37231 4052 31 reigns reign VBZ 37231 4052 32 shall shall MD 37231 4052 33 rest rest VB 37231 4052 34 . . . 37231 4053 1 ' ' '' 37231 4053 2 " " '' 37231 4053 3 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4053 4 5 5 LS 37231 4053 5 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4053 6 A a DT 37231 4053 7 form form NN 37231 4053 8 of of IN 37231 4053 9 this this DT 37231 4053 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4053 11 , , , 37231 4053 12 " " '' 37231 4053 13 according accord VBG 37231 4053 14 to to IN 37231 4053 15 the the DT 37231 4053 16 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 37231 4053 17 , , , 37231 4053 18 " " '' 37231 4053 19 is be VBZ 37231 4053 20 quoted quote VBN 37231 4053 21 in in IN 37231 4053 22 the the DT 37231 4053 23 second second JJ 37231 4053 24 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 4053 25 of of IN 37231 4053 26 pseudo pseudo NNP 37231 4053 27 - - NNP 37231 4053 28 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4053 29 of of IN 37231 4053 30 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4053 31 , , , 37231 4053 32 as as IN 37231 4053 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4053 34 are be VBP 37231 4053 35 informed inform VBN 37231 4053 36 by by IN 37231 4053 37 the the DT 37231 4053 38 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 37231 4053 39 { { -LRB- 37231 4053 40 422 422 CD 37231 4053 41 } } -RRB- 37231 4053 42 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4053 43 , , , 37231 4053 44 who who WP 37231 4053 45 likewise likewise RB 37231 4053 46 quotes quote VBZ 37231 4053 47 the the DT 37231 4053 48 same same JJ 37231 4053 49 passage passage NN 37231 4053 50 . . . 37231 4054 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4054 2 1 1 LS 37231 4054 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4054 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 4054 5 frequently frequently RB 37231 4054 6 made make VBD 37231 4054 7 use use NN 37231 4054 8 of of IN 37231 4054 9 the the DT 37231 4054 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4054 11 according accord VBG 37231 4054 12 to to IN 37231 4054 13 the the DT 37231 4054 14 Hebrews,(2 Hebrews,(2 NNP 37231 4054 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4054 16 and and CC 37231 4054 17 that that IN 37231 4054 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4054 19 long long RB 37231 4054 20 enjoyed enjoy VBD 37231 4054 21 great great JJ 37231 4054 22 consideration consideration NN 37231 4054 23 in in IN 37231 4054 24 the the DT 37231 4054 25 Church Church NNP 37231 4054 26 is be VBZ 37231 4054 27 proved prove VBN 37231 4054 28 by by IN 37231 4054 29 the the DT 37231 4054 30 fact fact NN 37231 4054 31 that that IN 37231 4054 32 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 37231 4054 33 found find VBD 37231 4054 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4054 35 in in IN 37231 4054 36 circulation circulation NN 37231 4054 37 not not RB 37231 4054 38 only only RB 37231 4054 39 among among IN 37231 4054 40 heretics heretic NNS 37231 4054 41 , , , 37231 4054 42 but but CC 37231 4054 43 also also RB 37231 4054 44 amongst amongst IN 37231 4054 45 orthodox orthodox JJ 37231 4054 46 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4054 47 communities;(3 communities;(3 NNP 37231 4054 48 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4054 49 and and CC 37231 4054 50 even even RB 37231 4054 51 in in IN 37231 4054 52 the the DT 37231 4054 53 fourth fourth JJ 37231 4054 54 century century NN 37231 4054 55 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4054 56 records record VBZ 37231 4054 57 doubts doubt VBZ 37231 4054 58 as as IN 37231 4054 59 to to IN 37231 4054 60 the the DT 37231 4054 61 rank rank NN 37231 4054 62 of of IN 37231 4054 63 this this DT 37231 4054 64 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4054 65 amongst amongst IN 37231 4054 66 Christian christian JJ 37231 4054 67 books book NNS 37231 4054 68 , , , 37231 4054 69 speaking speak VBG 37231 4054 70 of of IN 37231 4054 71 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4054 72 under under IN 37231 4054 73 the the DT 37231 4054 74 second second JJ 37231 4054 75 class class NN 37231 4054 76 in in IN 37231 4054 77 which which WDT 37231 4054 78 some some DT 37231 4054 79 reckoned reckon VBD 37231 4054 80 the the DT 37231 4054 81 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 4054 82 of of IN 37231 4054 83 John John NNP 37231 4054 84 . . . 37231 4055 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4055 2 4 4 LS 37231 4055 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4055 4 Later later RB 37231 4055 5 still still RB 37231 4055 6 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4055 7 translated translate VBD 37231 4055 8 it;(5 it;(5 NNS 37231 4055 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4055 10 whilst whilst IN 37231 4055 11 Nicephorus Nicephorus NNP 37231 4055 12 inserts insert VBZ 37231 4055 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4055 14 , , , 37231 4055 15 in in IN 37231 4055 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4055 17 Stichometry Stichometry NNP 37231 4055 18 , , , 37231 4055 19 not not RB 37231 4055 20 amongst amongst IN 37231 4055 21 the the DT 37231 4055 22 Apocrypha apocrypha NN 37231 4055 23 , , , 37231 4055 24 but but CC 37231 4055 25 amongst amongst IN 37231 4055 26 the the DT 37231 4055 27 Antilegomena Antilegomena NNP 37231 4055 28 , , , 37231 4055 29 or or CC 37231 4055 30 merely merely RB 37231 4055 31 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 4055 32 books book NNS 37231 4055 33 of of IN 37231 4055 34 the the DT 37231 4055 35 New New NNP 37231 4055 36 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4055 37 , , , 37231 4055 38 along along IN 37231 4055 39 with with IN 37231 4055 40 the the DT 37231 4055 41 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 4055 42 of of IN 37231 4055 43 John John NNP 37231 4055 44 . . . 37231 4056 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4056 2 6 6 LS 37231 4056 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4056 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4056 5 bears bear VBZ 37231 4056 6 testimony testimony NN 37231 4056 7 to to IN 37231 4056 8 the the DT 37231 4056 9 value value NN 37231 4056 10 attached attach VBN 37231 4056 11 to to IN 37231 4056 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4056 13 by by IN 37231 4056 14 the the DT 37231 4056 15 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4056 16 Christians,(7 Christians,(7 NNS 37231 4056 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4056 18 and and CC 37231 4056 19 indeed indeed RB 37231 4056 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4056 21 says say VBZ 37231 4056 22 of of IN 37231 4056 23 the the DT 37231 4056 24 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 4056 25 that that IN 37231 4056 26 , , , 37231 4056 27 " " `` 37231 4056 28 making make VBG 37231 4056 29 use use NN 37231 4056 30 only only RB 37231 4056 31 of of IN 37231 4056 32 the the DT 37231 4056 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4056 34 according accord VBG 37231 4056 35 to to IN 37231 4056 36 the the DT 37231 4056 37 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4056 38 , , , 37231 4056 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4056 40 took take VBD 37231 4056 41 little little JJ 37231 4056 42 account account NN 37231 4056 43 of of IN 37231 4056 44 the the DT 37231 4056 45 rest rest NN 37231 4056 46 . . . 37231 4057 1 " " `` 37231 4057 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4057 3 8 8 CD 37231 4057 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4057 5 In in IN 37231 4057 6 such such JJ 37231 4057 7 repute repute NN 37231 4057 8 was be VBD 37231 4057 9 this this DT 37231 4057 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4057 11 amongst amongst IN 37231 4057 12 the the DT 37231 4057 13 earliest early JJS 37231 4057 14 Christian christian JJ 37231 4057 15 communities community NNS 37231 4057 16 , , , 37231 4057 17 that that IN 37231 4057 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4057 19 was be VBD 37231 4057 20 generally generally RB 37231 4057 21 believed believe VBN 37231 4057 22 to to TO 37231 4057 23 be be VB 37231 4057 24 the the DT 37231 4057 25 original original NN 37231 4057 26 of of IN 37231 4057 27 the the DT 37231 4057 28 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4057 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4057 30 of of IN 37231 4057 31 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4057 32 . . . 37231 4058 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4058 2 states state VBZ 37231 4058 3 that that IN 37231 4058 4 the the DT 37231 4058 5 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 4058 6 used use VBD 37231 4058 7 solely solely RB 37231 4058 8 the the DT 37231 4058 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4058 10 according accord VBG 37231 4058 11 to to IN 37231 4058 12 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4058 13 and and CC 37231 4058 14 reject reject VB 37231 4058 15 the the DT 37231 4058 16 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4058 17 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4058 18 , , , 37231 4058 19 asserting assert VBG 37231 4058 20 that that IN 37231 4058 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4058 22 was be VBD 37231 4058 23 an an DT 37231 4058 24 apostate apostate NN 37231 4058 25 from from IN 37231 4058 26 the the DT 37231 4058 27 law law NN 37231 4058 28 . . . 37231 4059 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4059 2 9 9 LS 37231 4059 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4059 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4059 5 know know VBP 37231 4059 6 from from IN 37231 4059 7 statements statement NNS 37231 4059 8 { { -LRB- 37231 4059 9 423 423 CD 37231 4059 10 } } -RRB- 37231 4059 11 regarding regard VBG 37231 4059 12 the the DT 37231 4059 13 Ebionites(1 ebionites(1 NN 37231 4059 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4059 15 that that IN 37231 4059 16 this this DT 37231 4059 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4059 18 could could MD 37231 4059 19 not not RB 37231 4059 20 have have VB 37231 4059 21 been be VBN 37231 4059 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4059 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4059 24 according accord VBG 37231 4059 25 to to IN 37231 4059 26 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4059 27 , , , 37231 4059 28 and and CC 37231 4059 29 besides besides RB 37231 4059 30 , , , 37231 4059 31 both both DT 37231 4059 32 Clement(2 clement(2 NN 37231 4059 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4059 34 of of IN 37231 4059 35 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4059 36 and and CC 37231 4059 37 Origen(3 origen(3 NN 37231 4059 38 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4059 39 call call VBP 37231 4059 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4059 41 the the DT 37231 4059 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4059 43 according accord VBG 37231 4059 44 to to IN 37231 4059 45 the the DT 37231 4059 46 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4059 47 . . . 37231 4060 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4060 2 , , , 37231 4060 3 however however RB 37231 4060 4 , , , 37231 4060 5 still still RB 37231 4060 6 more more RBR 37231 4060 7 clearly clearly RB 37231 4060 8 identifies identify VBZ 37231 4060 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4060 10 , , , 37231 4060 11 as as IN 37231 4060 12 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4060 13 have have VBP 37231 4060 14 seen see VBN 37231 4060 15 above above RB 37231 4060 16 . . . 37231 4061 1 Repeating repeat VBG 37231 4061 2 the the DT 37231 4061 3 statements statement NNS 37231 4061 4 of of IN 37231 4061 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4061 6 , , , 37231 4061 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4061 8 says say VBZ 37231 4061 9 : : : 37231 4061 10 " " `` 37231 4061 11 These these DT 37231 4061 12 indeed indeed RB 37231 4061 13 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4061 14 the the DT 37231 4061 15 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 4061 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4061 17 thought think VBD 37231 4061 18 that that IN 37231 4061 19 all all PDT 37231 4061 20 the the DT 37231 4061 21 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 4061 22 of of IN 37231 4061 23 the the DT 37231 4061 24 Apostle apostle JJ 37231 4061 25 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4061 26 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4061 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4061 28 should should MD 37231 4061 29 be be VB 37231 4061 30 rejected reject VBN 37231 4061 31 , , , 37231 4061 32 calling call VBG 37231 4061 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4061 34 an an DT 37231 4061 35 apostate apostate NN 37231 4061 36 from from IN 37231 4061 37 the the DT 37231 4061 38 law law NN 37231 4061 39 ; ; : 37231 4061 40 making make VBG 37231 4061 41 use use NN 37231 4061 42 only only RB 37231 4061 43 of of IN 37231 4061 44 the the DT 37231 4061 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4061 46 according accord VBG 37231 4061 47 to to IN 37231 4061 48 the the DT 37231 4061 49 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4061 50 , , , 37231 4061 51 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4061 52 took take VBD 37231 4061 53 little little JJ 37231 4061 54 account account NN 37231 4061 55 of of IN 37231 4061 56 the the DT 37231 4061 57 rest rest NN 37231 4061 58 . . . 37231 4062 1 " " `` 37231 4062 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4062 3 4 4 LS 37231 4062 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4062 5 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 4062 6 calls call VBZ 37231 4062 7 both both CC 37231 4062 8 the the DT 37231 4062 9 single single JJ 37231 4062 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4062 11 of of IN 37231 4062 12 the the DT 37231 4062 13 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 37231 4062 14 and and CC 37231 4062 15 of of IN 37231 4062 16 the the DT 37231 4062 17 Nazarenes Nazarenes NNPS 37231 4062 18 the the DT 37231 4062 19 " " `` 37231 4062 20 Gospel gospel NN 37231 4062 21 according accord VBG 37231 4062 22 to to IN 37231 4062 23 the the DT 37231 4062 24 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4062 25 , , , 37231 4062 26 " " '' 37231 4062 27 and and CC 37231 4062 28 also also RB 37231 4062 29 the the DT 37231 4062 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4062 31 according accord VBG 37231 4062 32 to to IN 37231 4062 33 Matthew,(5 Matthew,(5 NNP 37231 4062 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4062 35 as as IN 37231 4062 36 does do VBZ 37231 4062 37 also also RB 37231 4062 38 Theodoret(6 theodoret(6 VB 37231 4062 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4062 40 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4062 41 translated translate VBD 37231 4062 42 the the DT 37231 4062 43 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4062 44 according accord VBG 37231 4062 45 to to IN 37231 4062 46 the the DT 37231 4062 47 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4062 48 both both CC 37231 4062 49 into into IN 37231 4062 50 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4062 51 and and CC 37231 4062 52 Latin,(7 Latin,(7 NNS 37231 4062 53 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4062 54 and and CC 37231 4062 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4062 56 is be VBZ 37231 4062 57 clear clear JJ 37231 4062 58 that that IN 37231 4062 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4062 60 belief belief NN 37231 4062 61 was be VBD 37231 4062 62 that that IN 37231 4062 63 this this DT 37231 4062 64 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4062 65 , , , 37231 4062 66 a a DT 37231 4062 67 copy copy NN 37231 4062 68 of of IN 37231 4062 69 which which WDT 37231 4062 70 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4062 71 found find VBD 37231 4062 72 in in IN 37231 4062 73 the the DT 37231 4062 74 library library NN 37231 4062 75 collected collect VBN 37231 4062 76 at at IN 37231 4062 77 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 37231 4062 78 by by IN 37231 4062 79 the the DT 37231 4062 80 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 4062 81 Pamphilus Pamphilus NNP 37231 4062 82 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4062 83 f f NNP 37231 4062 84 309 309 CD 37231 4062 85 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4062 86 , , , 37231 4062 87 was be VBD 37231 4062 88 the the DT 37231 4062 89 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4062 90 original original NN 37231 4062 91 of of IN 37231 4062 92 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4062 93 ; ; : 37231 4062 94 and and CC 37231 4062 95 in in IN 37231 4062 96 support support NN 37231 4062 97 of of IN 37231 4062 98 this this DT 37231 4062 99 view view NN 37231 4062 100 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4062 101 points point VBZ 37231 4062 102 out out RP 37231 4062 103 that that IN 37231 4062 104 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4062 105 did do VBD 37231 4062 106 not not RB 37231 4062 107 follow follow VB 37231 4062 108 the the DT 37231 4062 109 version version NN 37231 4062 110 of of IN 37231 4062 111 the the DT 37231 4062 112 LXX LXX NNP 37231 4062 113 . . . 37231 4063 1 in in IN 37231 4063 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4063 3 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4063 4 from from IN 37231 4063 5 the the DT 37231 4063 6 Old Old NNP 37231 4063 7 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4063 8 , , , 37231 4063 9 but but CC 37231 4063 10 quoted quote VBD 37231 4063 11 directly directly RB 37231 4063 12 from from IN 37231 4063 13 the the DT 37231 4063 14 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4063 15 . . . 37231 4064 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4064 2 8 8 LS 37231 4064 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4064 4 An an DT 37231 4064 5 attempt attempt NN 37231 4064 6 has have VBZ 37231 4064 7 been be VBN 37231 4064 8 made make VBN 37231 4064 9 to to TO 37231 4064 10 argue argue VB 37231 4064 11 { { -LRB- 37231 4064 12 424 424 CD 37231 4064 13 } } -RRB- 37231 4064 14 that that IN 37231 4064 15 , , , 37231 4064 16 later later RB 37231 4064 17 , , , 37231 4064 18 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4064 19 became become VBD 37231 4064 20 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 4064 21 of of IN 37231 4064 22 this this DT 37231 4064 23 view view NN 37231 4064 24 , , , 37231 4064 25 but but CC 37231 4064 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4064 27 seems seem VBZ 37231 4064 28 to to IN 37231 4064 29 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4064 30 that that IN 37231 4064 31 this this DT 37231 4064 32 is be VBZ 37231 4064 33 not not RB 37231 4064 34 the the DT 37231 4064 35 case case NN 37231 4064 36 , , , 37231 4064 37 and and CC 37231 4064 38 certainly certainly RB 37231 4064 39 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4064 40 in in IN 37231 4064 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4064 42 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 4064 43 writings writing NNS 37231 4064 44 states state VBZ 37231 4064 45 that that IN 37231 4064 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4064 47 was be VBD 37231 4064 48 generally generally RB 37231 4064 49 held hold VBN 37231 4064 50 to to TO 37231 4064 51 be be VB 37231 4064 52 the the DT 37231 4064 53 original original NN 37231 4064 54 of of IN 37231 4064 55 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4064 56 . . . 37231 4065 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4065 2 1 1 LS 37231 4065 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4065 4 That that IN 37231 4065 5 this this DT 37231 4065 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4065 7 was be VBD 37231 4065 8 not not RB 37231 4065 9 identical identical JJ 37231 4065 10 with with IN 37231 4065 11 the the DT 37231 4065 12 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4065 13 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4065 14 is be VBZ 37231 4065 15 evident evident JJ 37231 4065 16 both both DT 37231 4065 17 from from IN 37231 4065 18 the the DT 37231 4065 19 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4065 20 of of IN 37231 4065 21 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4065 22 and and CC 37231 4065 23 others other NNS 37231 4065 24 , , , 37231 4065 25 and and CC 37231 4065 26 also also RB 37231 4065 27 from from IN 37231 4065 28 the the DT 37231 4065 29 fact fact NN 37231 4065 30 that that IN 37231 4065 31 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4065 32 considered consider VBD 37231 4065 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4065 34 worth worth JJ 37231 4065 35 while while IN 37231 4065 36 to to TO 37231 4065 37 translate translate VB 37231 4065 38 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4065 39 twice twice RB 37231 4065 40 . . . 37231 4066 1 If if IN 37231 4066 2 the the DT 37231 4066 3 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4066 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4066 5 had have VBD 37231 4066 6 been be VBN 37231 4066 7 an an DT 37231 4066 8 accurate accurate JJ 37231 4066 9 translation translation NN 37231 4066 10 of of IN 37231 4066 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4066 12 , , , 37231 4066 13 of of IN 37231 4066 14 course course NN 37231 4066 15 there there EX 37231 4066 16 could could MD 37231 4066 17 not not RB 37231 4066 18 have have VB 37231 4066 19 been be VBN 37231 4066 20 inducement inducement JJ 37231 4066 21 to to TO 37231 4066 22 make make VB 37231 4066 23 another another DT 37231 4066 24 . . . 37231 4067 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4067 2 2 2 LS 37231 4067 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4067 4 As as IN 37231 4067 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4067 6 shall shall MD 37231 4067 7 hereafter hereafter RB 37231 4067 8 see see VB 37231 4067 9 , , , 37231 4067 10 the the DT 37231 4067 11 belief belief NN 37231 4067 12 was be VBD 37231 4067 13 universal universal JJ 37231 4067 14 in in IN 37231 4067 15 the the DT 37231 4067 16 early early JJ 37231 4067 17 Church Church NNP 37231 4067 18 that that WDT 37231 4067 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4067 20 wrote write VBD 37231 4067 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4067 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4067 23 in in IN 37231 4067 24 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4067 25 . . . 37231 4068 1 Attempts attempt NNS 37231 4068 2 have have VBP 37231 4068 3 been be VBN 37231 4068 4 made make VBN 37231 4068 5 to to TO 37231 4068 6 argue argue VB 37231 4068 7 that that IN 37231 4068 8 the the DT 37231 4068 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4068 10 according accord VBG 37231 4068 11 to to IN 37231 4068 12 the the DT 37231 4068 13 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4068 14 was be VBD 37231 4068 15 first first RB 37231 4068 16 written write VBN 37231 4068 17 in in IN 37231 4068 18 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4068 19 and and CC 37231 4068 20 then then RB 37231 4068 21 translated translate VBD 37231 4068 22 into into IN 37231 4068 23 Hebrew,(3 hebrew,(3 NN 37231 4068 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4068 25 but but CC 37231 4068 26 the the DT 37231 4068 27 reasons reason NNS 37231 4068 28 advanced advance VBN 37231 4068 29 seem seem VBP 37231 4068 30 quite quite RB 37231 4068 31 insufficient insufficient JJ 37231 4068 32 and and CC 37231 4068 33 arbitrary,(4 arbitrary,(4 NN 37231 4068 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4068 35 and and CC 37231 4068 36 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4068 37 is be VBZ 37231 4068 38 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 4068 39 by by IN 37231 4068 40 the the DT 37231 4068 41 whole whole JJ 37231 4068 42 tradition tradition NN 37231 4068 43 of of IN 37231 4068 44 the the DT 37231 4068 45 Fathers father NNS 37231 4068 46 . . . 37231 4069 1 { { -LRB- 37231 4069 2 425 425 CD 37231 4069 3 } } -RRB- 37231 4069 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4069 5 is be VBZ 37231 4069 6 not not RB 37231 4069 7 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4069 8 for for IN 37231 4069 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4069 10 purpose purpose NN 37231 4069 11 to to TO 37231 4069 12 enter enter VB 37231 4069 13 fully fully RB 37231 4069 14 here here RB 37231 4069 15 into into IN 37231 4069 16 the the DT 37231 4069 17 question question NN 37231 4069 18 of of IN 37231 4069 19 the the DT 37231 4069 20 exact exact JJ 37231 4069 21 relation relation NN 37231 4069 22 of of IN 37231 4069 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4069 24 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4069 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4069 26 according accord VBG 37231 4069 27 to to IN 37231 4069 28 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4069 29 to to IN 37231 4069 30 the the DT 37231 4069 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4069 32 according accord VBG 37231 4069 33 to to IN 37231 4069 34 the the DT 37231 4069 35 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4069 36 . . . 37231 4070 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4070 2 is be VBZ 37231 4070 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 4070 4 for for IN 37231 4070 5 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4070 6 to to TO 37231 4070 7 point point VB 37231 4070 8 out out RP 37231 4070 9 that that IN 37231 4070 10 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4070 11 meet meet VBP 37231 4070 12 with with IN 37231 4070 13 the the DT 37231 4070 14 latter latter JJ 37231 4070 15 before before IN 37231 4070 16 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4070 17 's 's POS 37231 4070 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4070 19 , , , 37231 4070 20 and and CC 37231 4070 21 that that IN 37231 4070 22 the the DT 37231 4070 23 general general JJ 37231 4070 24 opinion opinion NN 37231 4070 25 of of IN 37231 4070 26 the the DT 37231 4070 27 early early JJ 37231 4070 28 church church NN 37231 4070 29 was be VBD 37231 4070 30 that that IN 37231 4070 31 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4070 32 was be VBD 37231 4070 33 the the DT 37231 4070 34 original original NN 37231 4070 35 of of IN 37231 4070 36 the the DT 37231 4070 37 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4070 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4070 39 This this DT 37231 4070 40 opinion opinion NN 37231 4070 41 , , , 37231 4070 42 as as IN 37231 4070 43 Schwegler(1 schwegler(1 JJ 37231 4070 44 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4070 45 remarks remark NNS 37231 4070 46 , , , 37231 4070 47 is be VBZ 37231 4070 48 supported support VBN 37231 4070 49 by by IN 37231 4070 50 the the DT 37231 4070 51 fact fact NN 37231 4070 52 that that IN 37231 4070 53 tradition tradition NN 37231 4070 54 assigns assign VBZ 37231 4070 55 the the DT 37231 4070 56 origin origin NN 37231 4070 57 of of IN 37231 4070 58 both both DT 37231 4070 59 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4070 60 to to IN 37231 4070 61 Palestine Palestine NNP 37231 4070 62 , , , 37231 4070 63 and and CC 37231 4070 64 that that IN 37231 4070 65 both both DT 37231 4070 66 were be VBD 37231 4070 67 intended intend VBN 37231 4070 68 for for IN 37231 4070 69 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4070 70 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 4070 71 and and CC 37231 4070 72 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 4070 73 used use VBN 37231 4070 74 by by IN 37231 4070 75 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4070 76 . . . 37231 4071 1 That that IN 37231 4071 2 the the DT 37231 4071 3 two two CD 37231 4071 4 works work NNS 37231 4071 5 , , , 37231 4071 6 however however RB 37231 4071 7 originally originally RB 37231 4071 8 related related JJ 37231 4071 9 , , , 37231 4071 10 had have VBN 37231 4071 11 by by IN 37231 4071 12 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 4071 13 manipulation manipulation NN 37231 4071 14 become become VBP 37231 4071 15 distinct distinct JJ 37231 4071 16 , , , 37231 4071 17 although although IN 37231 4071 18 still still RB 37231 4071 19 amidst amidst IN 37231 4071 20 much much JJ 37231 4071 21 variation variation NN 37231 4071 22 preserving preserve VBG 37231 4071 23 some some DT 37231 4071 24 substantial substantial JJ 37231 4071 25 affinity affinity NN 37231 4071 26 , , , 37231 4071 27 can can MD 37231 4071 28 not not RB 37231 4071 29 be be VB 37231 4071 30 doubted doubt VBN 37231 4071 31 , , , 37231 4071 32 and and CC 37231 4071 33 in in IN 37231 4071 34 addition addition NN 37231 4071 35 to to IN 37231 4071 36 evidence evidence NN 37231 4071 37 already already RB 37231 4071 38 cited cite VBN 37231 4071 39 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4071 40 may may MD 37231 4071 41 point point VB 37231 4071 42 out out RP 37231 4071 43 that that IN 37231 4071 44 in in IN 37231 4071 45 the the DT 37231 4071 46 Stichometry Stichometry NNP 37231 4071 47 of of IN 37231 4071 48 Nicephorus Nicephorus NNP 37231 4071 49 , , , 37231 4071 50 the the DT 37231 4071 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4071 52 according accord VBG 37231 4071 53 to to IN 37231 4071 54 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4071 55 is be VBZ 37231 4071 56 said say VBN 37231 4071 57 to to TO 37231 4071 58 have have VB 37231 4071 59 2500 2500 CD 37231 4071 60 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4071 61 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4071 62 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4071 63 , , , 37231 4071 64 whilst whilst IN 37231 4071 65 that that IN 37231 4071 66 according accord VBG 37231 4071 67 to to IN 37231 4071 68 the the DT 37231 4071 69 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4071 70 has have VBZ 37231 4071 71 only only RB 37231 4071 72 2200 2200 CD 37231 4071 73 . . . 37231 4072 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4072 2 2 2 LS 37231 4072 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4072 4 Whether whether IN 37231 4072 5 this this DT 37231 4072 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4072 7 formed form VBD 37231 4072 8 one one CD 37231 4072 9 of of IN 37231 4072 10 the the DT 37231 4072 11 writings writing NNS 37231 4072 12 of of IN 37231 4072 13 the the DT 37231 4072 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4072 15 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4072 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4072 17 of of IN 37231 4072 18 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4072 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4072 20 is be VBZ 37231 4072 21 not not RB 37231 4072 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4072 23 purpose purpose NN 37231 4072 24 to to TO 37231 4072 25 inquire inquire VB 37231 4072 26 , , , 37231 4072 27 but but CC 37231 4072 28 enough enough JJ 37231 4072 29 has have VBZ 37231 4072 30 been be VBN 37231 4072 31 said say VBN 37231 4072 32 to to TO 37231 4072 33 prove prove VB 37231 4072 34 that that IN 37231 4072 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4072 36 was be VBD 37231 4072 37 one one CD 37231 4072 38 of of IN 37231 4072 39 the the DT 37231 4072 40 most most JJS 37231 4072 41 ancient(3 ancient(3 JJ 37231 4072 42 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4072 43 { { -LRB- 37231 4072 44 426 426 CD 37231 4072 45 } } -RRB- 37231 4072 46 and and CC 37231 4072 47 most most RBS 37231 4072 48 valued value VBN 37231 4072 49 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 4072 50 works work NNS 37231 4072 51 , , , 37231 4072 52 and and CC 37231 4072 53 to to TO 37231 4072 54 show show VB 37231 4072 55 the the DT 37231 4072 56 probability probability NN 37231 4072 57 that that WDT 37231 4072 58 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4072 59 Martyr Martyr NNP 37231 4072 60 , , , 37231 4072 61 a a DT 37231 4072 62 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4072 63 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4072 64 living live VBG 37231 4072 65 amongst amongst IN 37231 4072 66 those those DT 37231 4072 67 who who WP 37231 4072 68 are be VBP 37231 4072 69 known know VBN 37231 4072 70 to to TO 37231 4072 71 have have VB 37231 4072 72 made make VBN 37231 4072 73 exclusive exclusive JJ 37231 4072 74 use use NN 37231 4072 75 of of IN 37231 4072 76 this this DT 37231 4072 77 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4072 78 , , , 37231 4072 79 may may MD 37231 4072 80 well well RB 37231 4072 81 , , , 37231 4072 82 like like IN 37231 4072 83 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4072 84 contemporary contemporary JJ 37231 4072 85 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4072 86 , , , 37231 4072 87 have have VBP 37231 4072 88 used use VBN 37231 4072 89 the the DT 37231 4072 90 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4072 91 according accord VBG 37231 4072 92 to to IN 37231 4072 93 the the DT 37231 4072 94 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4072 95 ; ; : 37231 4072 96 and and CC 37231 4072 97 this this DT 37231 4072 98 probability probability NN 37231 4072 99 is be VBZ 37231 4072 100 , , , 37231 4072 101 as as IN 37231 4072 102 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4072 103 have have VBP 37231 4072 104 seen see VBN 37231 4072 105 , , , 37231 4072 106 greatly greatly RB 37231 4072 107 strengthened strengthen VBN 37231 4072 108 by by IN 37231 4072 109 the the DT 37231 4072 110 fact fact NN 37231 4072 111 that that IN 37231 4072 112 many many JJ 37231 4072 113 of of IN 37231 4072 114 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4072 115 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4072 116 agree agree VBP 37231 4072 117 with with IN 37231 4072 118 passages passage NNS 37231 4072 119 which which WDT 37231 4072 120 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4072 121 know know VBP 37231 4072 122 to to TO 37231 4072 123 have have VB 37231 4072 124 been be VBN 37231 4072 125 contained contain VBN 37231 4072 126 in in IN 37231 4072 127 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4072 128 ; ; : 37231 4072 129 whilst whilst UH 37231 4072 130 , , , 37231 4072 131 on on IN 37231 4072 132 the the DT 37231 4072 133 other other JJ 37231 4072 134 hand hand NN 37231 4072 135 , , , 37231 4072 136 almost almost RB 37231 4072 137 all all DT 37231 4072 138 differ differ VBP 37231 4072 139 from from IN 37231 4072 140 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4072 141 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4072 142 , , , 37231 4072 143 presenting present VBG 37231 4072 144 generally generally RB 37231 4072 145 , , , 37231 4072 146 however however RB 37231 4072 147 , , , 37231 4072 148 a a DT 37231 4072 149 greater great JJR 37231 4072 150 affinity affinity NN 37231 4072 151 to to IN 37231 4072 152 the the DT 37231 4072 153 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4072 154 according accord VBG 37231 4072 155 to to IN 37231 4072 156 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4072 157 , , , 37231 4072 158 as as IN 37231 4072 159 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4072 160 might may MD 37231 4072 161 expect expect VB 37231 4072 162 , , , 37231 4072 163 than than IN 37231 4072 164 to to IN 37231 4072 165 the the DT 37231 4072 166 other other JJ 37231 4072 167 two two CD 37231 4072 168 . . . 37231 4073 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4073 2 is be VBZ 37231 4073 3 clear clear JJ 37231 4073 4 that that IN 37231 4073 5 the the DT 37231 4073 6 title title NN 37231 4073 7 " " `` 37231 4073 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4073 9 according accord VBG 37231 4073 10 to to IN 37231 4073 11 the the DT 37231 4073 12 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4073 13 " " `` 37231 4073 14 can can MD 37231 4073 15 not not RB 37231 4073 16 have have VB 37231 4073 17 been be VBN 37231 4073 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4073 19 actual actual JJ 37231 4073 20 superscription superscription NN 37231 4073 21 , , , 37231 4073 22 but but CC 37231 4073 23 merely merely RB 37231 4073 24 was be VBD 37231 4073 25 a a DT 37231 4073 26 name name NN 37231 4073 27 descriptive descriptive JJ 37231 4073 28 of of IN 37231 4073 29 the the DT 37231 4073 30 readers reader NNS 37231 4073 31 for for IN 37231 4073 32 whom whom WP 37231 4073 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4073 34 was be VBD 37231 4073 35 prepared prepare VBN 37231 4073 36 or or CC 37231 4073 37 amongst amongst IN 37231 4073 38 whom whom WP 37231 4073 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4073 40 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 4073 41 circulated circulate VBD 37231 4073 42 , , , 37231 4073 43 and and CC 37231 4073 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4073 45 is be VBZ 37231 4073 46 most most RBS 37231 4073 47 probable probable JJ 37231 4073 48 that that IN 37231 4073 49 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4073 50 originally originally RB 37231 4073 51 bore bear VBD 37231 4073 52 no no DT 37231 4073 53 other other JJ 37231 4073 54 title title NN 37231 4073 55 than than IN 37231 4073 56 " " `` 37231 4073 57 The the DT 37231 4073 58 Gospel gospel NN 37231 4073 59 " " '' 37231 4073 60 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4073 61 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4073 62 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4073 63 , , , 37231 4073 64 to to TO 37231 4073 65 which which WDT 37231 4073 66 were be VBD 37231 4073 67 added add VBN 37231 4073 68 the the DT 37231 4073 69 different different JJ 37231 4073 70 designations designation NNS 37231 4073 71 under under IN 37231 4073 72 which which WDT 37231 4073 73 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4073 74 find find VBP 37231 4073 75 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4073 76 known know VBN 37231 4073 77 amongst amongst IN 37231 4073 78 different different JJ 37231 4073 79 communities community NNS 37231 4073 80 . . . 37231 4074 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4074 2 1 1 LS 37231 4074 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4074 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4074 5 have have VBP 37231 4074 6 already already RB 37231 4074 7 seen see VBN 37231 4074 8 that that IN 37231 4074 9 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4074 10 speaks speak VBZ 37231 4074 11 of of IN 37231 4074 12 " " `` 37231 4074 13 The the DT 37231 4074 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4074 15 " " '' 37231 4074 16 and and CC 37231 4074 17 seems seem VBZ 37231 4074 18 to to TO 37231 4074 19 refer refer VB 37231 4074 20 to to IN 37231 4074 21 the the DT 37231 4074 22 " " `` 37231 4074 23 Memoirs Memoirs NNP 37231 4074 24 of of IN 37231 4074 25 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4074 26 , , , 37231 4074 27 " " `` 37231 4074 28 both both CC 37231 4074 29 distinguishing distinguish VBG 37231 4074 30 appellations appellation NNS 37231 4074 31 of of IN 37231 4074 32 this this DT 37231 4074 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4074 34 , , , 37231 4074 35 but but CC 37231 4074 36 there there EX 37231 4074 37 is be VBZ 37231 4074 38 another another DT 37231 4074 39 of of IN 37231 4074 40 the the DT 37231 4074 41 names name NNS 37231 4074 42 borne bear VBN 37231 4074 43 by by IN 37231 4074 44 the the DT 37231 4074 45 " " `` 37231 4074 46 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4074 47 according accord VBG 37231 4074 48 to to IN 37231 4074 49 the the DT 37231 4074 50 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4074 51 , , , 37231 4074 52 " " '' 37231 4074 53 which which WDT 37231 4074 54 singularly singularly RB 37231 4074 55 recalls recall VBZ 37231 4074 56 the the DT 37231 4074 57 " " `` 37231 4074 58 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4074 59 of of IN 37231 4074 60 the the DT 37231 4074 61 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4074 62 , , , 37231 4074 63 " " '' 37231 4074 64 by by IN 37231 4074 65 which which WDT 37231 4074 66 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4074 67 prefers prefer VBZ 37231 4074 68 to to TO 37231 4074 69 call call VB 37231 4074 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4074 71 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 4074 72 work work NN 37231 4074 73 . . . 37231 4075 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4075 2 was be VBD 37231 4075 3 called call VBN 37231 4075 4 the the DT 37231 4075 5 " " `` 37231 4075 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4075 7 according accord VBG 37231 4075 8 to to IN 37231 4075 9 the the DT 37231 4075 10 Apostles"(2 Apostles"(2 NNP 37231 4075 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4075 12 { { -LRB- 37231 4075 13 427 427 CD 37231 4075 14 } } -RRB- 37231 4075 15 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4075 16 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4075 17 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4075 18 , , , 37231 4075 19 and and CC 37231 4075 20 , , , 37231 4075 21 in in IN 37231 4075 22 short short JJ 37231 4075 23 , , , 37231 4075 24 comparing compare VBG 37231 4075 25 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4075 26 's 's POS 37231 4075 27 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4075 28 with with IN 37231 4075 29 this this DT 37231 4075 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4075 31 , , , 37231 4075 32 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4075 33 find find VBP 37231 4075 34 at at IN 37231 4075 35 once once IN 37231 4075 36 similarity similarity NN 37231 4075 37 of of IN 37231 4075 38 contents content NNS 37231 4075 39 and and CC 37231 4075 40 even even RB 37231 4075 41 of of IN 37231 4075 42 name name NN 37231 4075 43 . . . 37231 4076 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4076 2 1 1 LS 37231 4076 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4076 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4076 5 is be VBZ 37231 4076 6 not not RB 37231 4076 7 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4076 8 , , , 37231 4076 9 however however RB 37231 4076 10 , , , 37231 4076 11 for for IN 37231 4076 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4076 13 the the DT 37231 4076 14 purposes purpose NNS 37231 4076 15 of of IN 37231 4076 16 this this DT 37231 4076 17 examination examination NN 37231 4076 18 to to TO 37231 4076 19 dwell dwell VB 37231 4076 20 more more RBR 37231 4076 21 fully fully RB 37231 4076 22 upon upon IN 37231 4076 23 the the DT 37231 4076 24 question question NN 37231 4076 25 as as IN 37231 4076 26 to to IN 37231 4076 27 what what WP 37231 4076 28 specific specific JJ 37231 4076 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4076 30 now now RB 37231 4076 31 no no RB 37231 4076 32 longer long RBR 37231 4076 33 extant extant JJ 37231 4076 34 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4076 35 employed employ VBD 37231 4076 36 . . . 37231 4077 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4077 2 have have VBP 37231 4077 3 shown show VBN 37231 4077 4 that that IN 37231 4077 5 there there EX 37231 4077 6 is be VBZ 37231 4077 7 no no DT 37231 4077 8 evidence evidence NN 37231 4077 9 that that IN 37231 4077 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4077 11 made make VBD 37231 4077 12 use use NN 37231 4077 13 of of IN 37231 4077 14 any any DT 37231 4077 15 of of IN 37231 4077 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4077 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4077 18 , , , 37231 4077 19 and and CC 37231 4077 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4077 21 can can MD 37231 4077 22 not not RB 37231 4077 23 , , , 37231 4077 24 therefore therefore RB 37231 4077 25 , , , 37231 4077 26 be be VB 37231 4077 27 cited cite VBN 37231 4077 28 even even RB 37231 4077 29 to to TO 37231 4077 30 prove prove VB 37231 4077 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4077 32 existence existence NN 37231 4077 33 , , , 37231 4077 34 and and CC 37231 4077 35 much much RB 37231 4077 36 less less JJR 37231 4077 37 to to TO 37231 4077 38 attest attest VB 37231 4077 39 the the DT 37231 4077 40 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 4077 41 and and CC 37231 4077 42 character character NN 37231 4077 43 of of IN 37231 4077 44 records record NNS 37231 4077 45 whose whose WP$ 37231 4077 46 authors author NNS 37231 4077 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4077 48 does do VBZ 37231 4077 49 not not RB 37231 4077 50 once once RB 37231 4077 51 name name VB 37231 4077 52 . . . 37231 4078 1 On on IN 37231 4078 2 the the DT 37231 4078 3 other other JJ 37231 4078 4 hand hand NN 37231 4078 5 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4078 6 has have VBZ 37231 4078 7 been be VBN 37231 4078 8 made make VBN 37231 4078 9 evident evident JJ 37231 4078 10 that that IN 37231 4078 11 there there EX 37231 4078 12 were be VBD 37231 4078 13 other other JJ 37231 4078 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4078 15 , , , 37231 4078 16 now now RB 37231 4078 17 lost lose VBN 37231 4078 18 but but CC 37231 4078 19 which which WDT 37231 4078 20 then then RB 37231 4078 21 enjoyed enjoy VBD 37231 4078 22 the the DT 37231 4078 23 highest high JJS 37231 4078 24 consideration consideration NN 37231 4078 25 , , , 37231 4078 26 from from IN 37231 4078 27 which which WDT 37231 4078 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4078 29 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4078 30 might may MD 37231 4078 31 have have VB 37231 4078 32 been be VBN 37231 4078 33 , , , 37231 4078 34 and and CC 37231 4078 35 probably probably RB 37231 4078 36 were be VBD 37231 4078 37 , , , 37231 4078 38 taken take VBN 37231 4078 39 . . . 37231 4079 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4079 2 have have VBP 37231 4079 3 seen see VBN 37231 4079 4 that that IN 37231 4079 5 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4079 6 's 's POS 37231 4079 7 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4079 8 of of IN 37231 4079 9 the the DT 37231 4079 10 Apostles Apostles NNP 37231 4079 11 contained contain VBD 37231 4079 12 facts fact NNS 37231 4079 13 of of IN 37231 4079 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4079 15 history history NN 37231 4079 16 unknown unknown JJ 37231 4079 17 to to IN 37231 4079 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4079 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4079 20 , , , 37231 4079 21 which which WDT 37231 4079 22 were be VBD 37231 4079 23 contained contain VBN 37231 4079 24 in in IN 37231 4079 25 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 4079 26 works work NNS 37231 4079 27 and and CC 37231 4079 28 notably notably RB 37231 4079 29 in in IN 37231 4079 30 the the DT 37231 4079 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4079 32 according accord VBG 37231 4079 33 to to IN 37231 4079 34 the the DT 37231 4079 35 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4079 36 ; ; : 37231 4079 37 that that IN 37231 4079 38 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4079 39 further further RB 37231 4079 40 contained contain VBD 37231 4079 41 matter matter NN 37231 4079 42 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 4079 43 to to IN 37231 4079 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4079 45 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4079 46 , , , 37231 4079 47 and and CC 37231 4079 48 sayings saying NNS 37231 4079 49 of of IN 37231 4079 50 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4079 51 not not RB 37231 4079 52 contained contain VBN 37231 4079 53 in in IN 37231 4079 54 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4079 55 ; ; : 37231 4079 56 and and CC 37231 4079 57 that that IN 37231 4079 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4079 59 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4079 60 , , , 37231 4079 61 although although IN 37231 4079 62 so so RB 37231 4079 63 numerous numerous JJ 37231 4079 64 , , , 37231 4079 65 systematically systematically RB 37231 4079 66 vary vary VBP 37231 4079 67 from from IN 37231 4079 68 similar similar JJ 37231 4079 69 passages passage NNS 37231 4079 70 in in IN 37231 4079 71 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4079 72 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4079 73 . . . 37231 4080 1 No no DT 37231 4080 2 theory theory NN 37231 4080 3 of of IN 37231 4080 4 quotation quotation NN 37231 4080 5 from from IN 37231 4080 6 memory memory NN 37231 4080 7 can can MD 37231 4080 8 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 37231 4080 9 account account VB 37231 4080 10 for for IN 37231 4080 11 these these DT 37231 4080 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 37231 4080 13 , , , 37231 4080 14 and and CC 37231 4080 15 the the DT 37231 4080 16 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 4080 17 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4080 18 is be VBZ 37231 4080 19 that that IN 37231 4080 20 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4080 21 did do VBD 37231 4080 22 not not RB 37231 4080 23 make make VB 37231 4080 24 use use NN 37231 4080 25 of of IN 37231 4080 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4080 27 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4080 28 , , , 37231 4080 29 but but CC 37231 4080 30 quoted quote VBN 37231 4080 31 from from IN 37231 4080 32 another another DT 37231 4080 33 source source NN 37231 4080 34 . . . 37231 4081 1 In in IN 37231 4081 2 no no DT 37231 4081 3 case case NN 37231 4081 4 can can MD 37231 4081 5 the the DT 37231 4081 6 testimony testimony NN 37231 4081 7 of of IN 37231 4081 8 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4081 9 afford afford VB 37231 4081 10 the the DT 37231 4081 11 requisite requisite JJ 37231 4081 12 support support NN 37231 4081 13 to to IN 37231 4081 14 the the DT 37231 4081 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4081 16 as as IN 37231 4081 17 records record NNS 37231 4081 18 of of IN 37231 4081 19 miracles miracle NNS 37231 4081 20 and and CC 37231 4081 21 of of IN 37231 4081 22 a a DT 37231 4081 23 Divine Divine NNP 37231 4081 24 Revelation Revelation NNP 37231 4081 25 . . . 37231 4082 1 { { -LRB- 37231 4082 2 429 429 CD 37231 4082 3 } } -RRB- 37231 4082 4 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 37231 4082 5 IV IV NNP 37231 4082 6 . . . 37231 4083 1 HEGESIPPUS HEGESIPPUS NNP 37231 4083 2 -- -- : 37231 4083 3 PAPIAS PAPIAS NNP 37231 4083 4 OF of IN 37231 4083 5 HIERAPOLIS HIERAPOLIS NNP 37231 4083 6 . . . 37231 4084 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4084 2 now now RB 37231 4084 3 turn turn VBP 37231 4084 4 to to IN 37231 4084 5 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4084 6 , , , 37231 4084 7 one one CD 37231 4084 8 of of IN 37231 4084 9 the the DT 37231 4084 10 contemporaries contemporary NNS 37231 4084 11 of of IN 37231 4084 12 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4084 13 , , , 37231 4084 14 and and CC 37231 4084 15 , , , 37231 4084 16 like like IN 37231 4084 17 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4084 18 , , , 37231 4084 19 a a DT 37231 4084 20 Palestinian palestinian JJ 37231 4084 21 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4084 22 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4084 23 . . . 37231 4085 1 Most Most JJS 37231 4085 2 of of IN 37231 4085 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4085 4 information information NN 37231 4085 5 regarding regard VBG 37231 4085 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4085 7 is be VBZ 37231 4085 8 derived derive VBN 37231 4085 9 from from IN 37231 4085 10 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4085 11 , , , 37231 4085 12 who who WP 37231 4085 13 fortunately fortunately RB 37231 4085 14 gives give VBZ 37231 4085 15 rather rather RB 37231 4085 16 copious copious JJ 37231 4085 17 extracts extract NNS 37231 4085 18 from from IN 37231 4085 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4085 20 writings writing NNS 37231 4085 21 . . . 37231 4086 1 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4086 2 was be VBD 37231 4086 3 born bear VBN 37231 4086 4 in in IN 37231 4086 5 Palestine Palestine NNP 37231 4086 6 , , , 37231 4086 7 of of IN 37231 4086 8 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4086 9 parents,(l parents,(l NNP 37231 4086 10 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4086 11 and and CC 37231 4086 12 in in IN 37231 4086 13 all all DT 37231 4086 14 probability probability NN 37231 4086 15 belonged belong VBD 37231 4086 16 to to IN 37231 4086 17 the the DT 37231 4086 18 primitive primitive JJ 37231 4086 19 community community NN 37231 4086 20 of of IN 37231 4086 21 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 4086 22 . . . 37231 4087 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4087 2 2 2 LS 37231 4087 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4087 4 In in IN 37231 4087 5 order order NN 37231 4087 6 to to TO 37231 4087 7 make make VB 37231 4087 8 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4087 9 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 4087 10 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4087 11 with with IN 37231 4087 12 the the DT 37231 4087 13 state state NN 37231 4087 14 of of IN 37231 4087 15 the the DT 37231 4087 16 Church Church NNP 37231 4087 17 , , , 37231 4087 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4087 19 travelled travel VBD 37231 4087 20 widely widely RB 37231 4087 21 and and CC 37231 4087 22 came come VBD 37231 4087 23 to to IN 37231 4087 24 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4087 25 when when WRB 37231 4087 26 Anicetus Anicetus NNP 37231 4087 27 was be VBD 37231 4087 28 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4087 29 . . . 37231 4088 1 Subsequently subsequently RB 37231 4088 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4088 3 wrote write VBD 37231 4088 4 a a DT 37231 4088 5 work work NN 37231 4088 6 of of IN 37231 4088 7 historical historical JJ 37231 4088 8 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4088 9 , , , 37231 4088 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4088 11 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4088 12 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4088 13 , , , 37231 4088 14 in in IN 37231 4088 15 five five CD 37231 4088 16 books book NNS 37231 4088 17 , , , 37231 4088 18 and and CC 37231 4088 19 thus thus RB 37231 4088 20 became become VBD 37231 4088 21 the the DT 37231 4088 22 first first JJ 37231 4088 23 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 4088 24 historian historian NN 37231 4088 25 of of IN 37231 4088 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 4088 27 . . . 37231 4089 1 This this DT 37231 4089 2 work work NN 37231 4089 3 is be VBZ 37231 4089 4 lost lose VBN 37231 4089 5 , , , 37231 4089 6 but but CC 37231 4089 7 portions portion NNS 37231 4089 8 have have VBP 37231 4089 9 been be VBN 37231 4089 10 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4089 11 to to IN 37231 4089 12 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4089 13 by by IN 37231 4089 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4089 15 , , , 37231 4089 16 and and CC 37231 4089 17 one one CD 37231 4089 18 other other JJ 37231 4089 19 fragment fragment NN 37231 4089 20 is be VBZ 37231 4089 21 also also RB 37231 4089 22 extant extant JJ 37231 4089 23 . . . 37231 4090 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4090 2 must must MD 37231 4090 3 have have VB 37231 4090 4 been be VBN 37231 4090 5 , , , 37231 4090 6 in in IN 37231 4090 7 part part NN 37231 4090 8 at at IN 37231 4090 9 least least JJS 37231 4090 10 , , , 37231 4090 11 written write VBN 37231 4090 12 after after IN 37231 4090 13 the the DT 37231 4090 14 succession succession NN 37231 4090 15 of of IN 37231 4090 16 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 37231 4090 17 to to IN 37231 4090 18 the the DT 37231 4090 19 Roman roman JJ 37231 4090 20 bishopric bishopric NN 37231 4090 21 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4090 22 a.d a.d NNP 37231 4090 23 . . NNP 37231 4090 24 177 177 CD 37231 4090 25 - - SYM 37231 4090 26 193 193 CD 37231 4090 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4090 28 , , , 37231 4090 29 as as IN 37231 4090 30 that that DT 37231 4090 31 event event NN 37231 4090 32 is be VBZ 37231 4090 33 mentioned mention VBN 37231 4090 34 in in IN 37231 4090 35 the the DT 37231 4090 36 book book NN 37231 4090 37 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 4090 38 , , , 37231 4090 39 and and CC 37231 4090 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4090 41 testimony testimony NN 37231 4090 42 is be VBZ 37231 4090 43 allowed allow VBN 37231 4090 44 by by IN 37231 4090 45 all all DT 37231 4090 46 critics critic NNS 37231 4090 47 to to IN 37231 4090 48 date date NN 37231 4090 49 from from IN 37231 4090 50 an an DT 37231 4090 51 advanced advanced JJ 37231 4090 52 period period NN 37231 4090 53 of of IN 37231 4090 54 the the DT 37231 4090 55 second second JJ 37231 4090 56 half half NN 37231 4090 57 of of IN 37231 4090 58 the the DT 37231 4090 59 second second JJ 37231 4090 60 century century NN 37231 4090 61 . . . 37231 4091 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4091 2 3 3 LS 37231 4091 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4091 4 { { -LRB- 37231 4091 5 430 430 CD 37231 4091 6 } } -RRB- 37231 4091 7 The the DT 37231 4091 8 testimony testimony NN 37231 4091 9 of of IN 37231 4091 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4091 11 is be VBZ 37231 4091 12 of of IN 37231 4091 13 great great JJ 37231 4091 14 value value NN 37231 4091 15 , , , 37231 4091 16 not not RB 37231 4091 17 only only RB 37231 4091 18 as as IN 37231 4091 19 that that DT 37231 4091 20 of of IN 37231 4091 21 a a DT 37231 4091 22 man man NN 37231 4091 23 born bear VBN 37231 4091 24 near near IN 37231 4091 25 the the DT 37231 4091 26 primitive primitive JJ 37231 4091 27 Christian christian JJ 37231 4091 28 tradition tradition NN 37231 4091 29 , , , 37231 4091 30 but but CC 37231 4091 31 also also RB 37231 4091 32 as as IN 37231 4091 33 that that DT 37231 4091 34 of of IN 37231 4091 35 an an DT 37231 4091 36 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 4091 37 traveller traveller NN 37231 4091 38 amongst amongst IN 37231 4091 39 many many JJ 37231 4091 40 Christian christian JJ 37231 4091 41 communities community NNS 37231 4091 42 . . . 37231 4092 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4092 2 evidently evidently RB 37231 4092 3 held hold VBD 37231 4092 4 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4092 5 in in IN 37231 4092 6 high high JJ 37231 4092 7 estimation estimation NN 37231 4092 8 as as IN 37231 4092 9 recording record VBG 37231 4092 10 the the DT 37231 4092 11 unerring unerring JJ 37231 4092 12 tradition tradition NN 37231 4092 13 of of IN 37231 4092 14 the the DT 37231 4092 15 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4092 16 preaching preach VBG 37231 4092 17 in in IN 37231 4092 18 the the DT 37231 4092 19 most most RBS 37231 4092 20 simple simple JJ 37231 4092 21 style style NN 37231 4092 22 of of IN 37231 4092 23 composition,(1 composition,(1 NNP 37231 4092 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4092 25 and and CC 37231 4092 26 as as IN 37231 4092 27 a a DT 37231 4092 28 writer writer NN 37231 4092 29 of of IN 37231 4092 30 authority authority NN 37231 4092 31 who who WP 37231 4092 32 was be VBD 37231 4092 33 " " `` 37231 4092 34 contemporary contemporary JJ 37231 4092 35 with with IN 37231 4092 36 the the DT 37231 4092 37 first first JJ 37231 4092 38 successors successor NNS 37231 4092 39 of of IN 37231 4092 40 the the DT 37231 4092 41 Apostles"(2 Apostles"(2 NNP 37231 4092 42 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4092 43 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4092 44 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4092 45 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4092 46 . . . 37231 4093 1 Any any DT 37231 4093 2 indications indication NNS 37231 4093 3 , , , 37231 4093 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 4093 5 , , , 37231 4093 6 which which WDT 37231 4093 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4093 8 may may MD 37231 4093 9 derive derive VB 37231 4093 10 from from IN 37231 4093 11 information information NN 37231 4093 12 regarding regard VBG 37231 4093 13 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4093 14 , , , 37231 4093 15 and and CC 37231 4093 16 from from IN 37231 4093 17 the the DT 37231 4093 18 fragments fragment NNS 37231 4093 19 of of IN 37231 4093 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4093 21 writings writing NNS 37231 4093 22 which which WDT 37231 4093 23 survive survive VBP 37231 4093 24 , , , 37231 4093 25 must must MD 37231 4093 26 be be VB 37231 4093 27 of of IN 37231 4093 28 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 4093 29 importance importance NN 37231 4093 30 for for IN 37231 4093 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4093 32 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 4093 33 . . . 37231 4094 1 As as IN 37231 4094 2 might may MD 37231 4094 3 have have VB 37231 4094 4 been be VBN 37231 4094 5 expected expect VBN 37231 4094 6 from from IN 37231 4094 7 a a DT 37231 4094 8 convert convert NN 37231 4094 9 from from IN 37231 4094 10 Judaism(3 judaism(3 NN 37231 4094 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4094 12 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4094 13 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4094 14 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4094 15 , , , 37231 4094 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4094 17 find find VBP 37231 4094 18 in in IN 37231 4094 19 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4094 20 manifest manifest NN 37231 4094 21 evidences evidence NNS 37231 4094 22 of of IN 37231 4094 23 general general JJ 37231 4094 24 tendency tendency NN 37231 4094 25 to to IN 37231 4094 26 the the DT 37231 4094 27 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4094 28 side side NN 37231 4094 29 of of IN 37231 4094 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 4094 31 . . . 37231 4095 1 For for IN 37231 4095 2 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4095 3 , , , 37231 4095 4 " " '' 37231 4095 5 James James NNP 37231 4095 6 , , , 37231 4095 7 the the DT 37231 4095 8 brother brother NN 37231 4095 9 of of IN 37231 4095 10 the the DT 37231 4095 11 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4095 12 , , , 37231 4095 13 " " '' 37231 4095 14 was be VBD 37231 4095 15 the the DT 37231 4095 16 chief chief NN 37231 4095 17 of of IN 37231 4095 18 the the DT 37231 4095 19 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4095 20 , , , 37231 4095 21 and and CC 37231 4095 22 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4095 23 states state VBZ 37231 4095 24 that that IN 37231 4095 25 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4095 26 had have VBD 37231 4095 27 received receive VBN 37231 4095 28 the the DT 37231 4095 29 government government NN 37231 4095 30 of of IN 37231 4095 31 the the DT 37231 4095 32 Church Church NNP 37231 4095 33 after after IN 37231 4095 34 the the DT 37231 4095 35 death death NN 37231 4095 36 of of IN 37231 4095 37 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4095 38 . . . 37231 4096 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4096 2 4 4 LS 37231 4096 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4096 4 The the DT 37231 4096 5 account account NN 37231 4096 6 which which WDT 37231 4096 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4096 8 gives give VBZ 37231 4096 9 of of IN 37231 4096 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4096 11 is be VBZ 37231 4096 12 remarkable remarkable JJ 37231 4096 13 . . . 37231 4097 1 " " `` 37231 4097 2 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4097 3 was be VBD 37231 4097 4 holy holy JJ 37231 4097 5 from from IN 37231 4097 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4097 7 mothers mother NNS 37231 4097 8 womb womb NN 37231 4097 9 . . . 37231 4098 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4098 2 drank drink VBD 37231 4098 3 neither neither CC 37231 4098 4 wine wine NN 37231 4098 5 nor nor CC 37231 4098 6 strong strong JJ 37231 4098 7 drink drink NN 37231 4098 8 , , , 37231 4098 9 nor nor CC 37231 4098 10 ate eat VBD 37231 4098 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4098 12 any any DT 37231 4098 13 living live VBG 37231 4098 14 thing thing NN 37231 4098 15 . . . 37231 4099 1 A a DT 37231 4099 2 razor razor NN 37231 4099 3 never never RB 37231 4099 4 went go VBD 37231 4099 5 upon upon IN 37231 4099 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4099 7 head head NN 37231 4099 8 , , , 37231 4099 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4099 10 anointed anoint VBD 37231 4099 11 not not RB 37231 4099 12 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4099 13 with with IN 37231 4099 14 { { -LRB- 37231 4099 15 431 431 CD 37231 4099 16 } } -RRB- 37231 4099 17 oil oil NN 37231 4099 18 , , , 37231 4099 19 and and CC 37231 4099 20 did do VBD 37231 4099 21 not not RB 37231 4099 22 use use VB 37231 4099 23 a a DT 37231 4099 24 bath bath NN 37231 4099 25 . . . 37231 4100 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4100 2 alone alone RB 37231 4100 3 was be VBD 37231 4100 4 allowed allow VBN 37231 4100 5 to to TO 37231 4100 6 enter enter VB 37231 4100 7 into into IN 37231 4100 8 the the DT 37231 4100 9 Holies Holies NNPS 37231 4100 10 . . . 37231 4101 1 For for IN 37231 4101 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4101 3 did do VBD 37231 4101 4 not not RB 37231 4101 5 wear wear VB 37231 4101 6 woollen woollen JJ 37231 4101 7 garments garment NNS 37231 4101 8 , , , 37231 4101 9 but but CC 37231 4101 10 linen linen NN 37231 4101 11 . . . 37231 4102 1 And and CC 37231 4102 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4102 3 alone alone RB 37231 4102 4 entered enter VBD 37231 4102 5 into into IN 37231 4102 6 the the DT 37231 4102 7 Sanctuary Sanctuary NNP 37231 4102 8 and and CC 37231 4102 9 was be VBD 37231 4102 10 wo will MD 37231 4102 11 nt not RB 37231 4102 12 to to TO 37231 4102 13 be be VB 37231 4102 14 found find VBN 37231 4102 15 upon upon IN 37231 4102 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4102 17 knees knee NNS 37231 4102 18 seeking seek VBG 37231 4102 19 forgiveness forgiveness NN 37231 4102 20 on on IN 37231 4102 21 behalf behalf NN 37231 4102 22 of of IN 37231 4102 23 the the DT 37231 4102 24 people people NNS 37231 4102 25 ; ; : 37231 4102 26 so so IN 37231 4102 27 that that IN 37231 4102 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4102 29 knees knee NNS 37231 4102 30 became become VBD 37231 4102 31 hard hard JJ 37231 4102 32 like like IN 37231 4102 33 a a DT 37231 4102 34 camel camel NN 37231 4102 35 's 's POS 37231 4102 36 , , , 37231 4102 37 through through IN 37231 4102 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4102 39 constant constant JJ 37231 4102 40 kneeling kneeling NN 37231 4102 41 in in IN 37231 4102 42 supplication supplication NN 37231 4102 43 to to IN 37231 4102 44 God God NNP 37231 4102 45 , , , 37231 4102 46 and and CC 37231 4102 47 asking ask VBG 37231 4102 48 for for IN 37231 4102 49 forgiveness forgiveness NN 37231 4102 50 for for IN 37231 4102 51 the the DT 37231 4102 52 people people NNS 37231 4102 53 . . . 37231 4103 1 In in IN 37231 4103 2 consequence consequence NN 37231 4103 3 of of IN 37231 4103 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4103 5 exceeding exceed VBG 37231 4103 6 great great JJ 37231 4103 7 righteousness righteousness NN 37231 4103 8 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4103 9 was be VBD 37231 4103 10 called call VBN 37231 4103 11 Righteous Righteous NNP 37231 4103 12 and and CC 37231 4103 13 ' ' `` 37231 4103 14 Oblias Oblias NNP 37231 4103 15 , , , 37231 4103 16 ' ' '' 37231 4103 17 that that RB 37231 4103 18 is be VBZ 37231 4103 19 , , , 37231 4103 20 Protector Protector NNP 37231 4103 21 of of IN 37231 4103 22 the the DT 37231 4103 23 people people NNS 37231 4103 24 and and CC 37231 4103 25 Righteousness Righteousness NNP 37231 4103 26 , , , 37231 4103 27 as as IN 37231 4103 28 the the DT 37231 4103 29 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4103 30 declare declare VBP 37231 4103 31 concerning concern VBG 37231 4103 32 him,"(1 him,"(1 NNP 37231 4103 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4103 34 and and CC 37231 4103 35 so so RB 37231 4103 36 on on RB 37231 4103 37 . . . 37231 4104 1 Throughout throughout IN 37231 4104 2 the the DT 37231 4104 3 whole whole NN 37231 4104 4 of of IN 37231 4104 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4104 6 account account NN 37231 4104 7 of of IN 37231 4104 8 James James NNP 37231 4104 9 , , , 37231 4104 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4104 11 describes describe VBZ 37231 4104 12 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4104 13 as as IN 37231 4104 14 a a DT 37231 4104 15 mere mere JJ 37231 4104 16 Jew Jew NNP 37231 4104 17 , , , 37231 4104 18 and and CC 37231 4104 19 as as IN 37231 4104 20 frequenting frequent VBG 37231 4104 21 the the DT 37231 4104 22 temple temple NN 37231 4104 23 , , , 37231 4104 24 and and CC 37231 4104 25 even even RB 37231 4104 26 entering enter VBG 37231 4104 27 the the DT 37231 4104 28 Holy Holy NNP 37231 4104 29 of of IN 37231 4104 30 Holies Holies NNPS 37231 4104 31 as as IN 37231 4104 32 a a DT 37231 4104 33 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4104 34 High High NNP 37231 4104 35 Priest Priest NNP 37231 4104 36 . . . 37231 4105 1 Whether whether IN 37231 4105 2 the the DT 37231 4105 3 account account NN 37231 4105 4 be be VB 37231 4105 5 apocryphal apocryphal VBN 37231 4105 6 or or CC 37231 4105 7 not not RB 37231 4105 8 is be VBZ 37231 4105 9 of of IN 37231 4105 10 little little JJ 37231 4105 11 consequence consequence NN 37231 4105 12 here here RB 37231 4105 13 ; ; : 37231 4105 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4105 15 is be VBZ 37231 4105 16 clear clear JJ 37231 4105 17 that that IN 37231 4105 18 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4105 19 sees see VBZ 37231 4105 20 no no DT 37231 4105 21 incongruity incongruity NN 37231 4105 22 in in IN 37231 4105 23 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4105 24 , , , 37231 4105 25 and and CC 37231 4105 26 that that IN 37231 4105 27 the the DT 37231 4105 28 difference difference NN 37231 4105 29 between between IN 37231 4105 30 the the DT 37231 4105 31 Jew Jew NNP 37231 4105 32 and and CC 37231 4105 33 the the DT 37231 4105 34 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4105 35 was be VBD 37231 4105 36 extremely extremely RB 37231 4105 37 small small JJ 37231 4105 38 . . . 37231 4106 1 The the DT 37231 4106 2 head head NN 37231 4106 3 of of IN 37231 4106 4 the the DT 37231 4106 5 Christian christian JJ 37231 4106 6 community community NN 37231 4106 7 could could MD 37231 4106 8 assume assume VB 37231 4106 9 all all PDT 37231 4106 10 the the DT 37231 4106 11 duties duty NNS 37231 4106 12 of of IN 37231 4106 13 the the DT 37231 4106 14 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4106 15 High High NNP 37231 4106 16 - - HYPH 37231 4106 17 Priest,(2 Priest,(2 NNP 37231 4106 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4106 19 and and CC 37231 4106 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4106 21 Christian christian JJ 37231 4106 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 4106 23 did do VBD 37231 4106 24 not not RB 37231 4106 25 offend offend VB 37231 4106 26 more more JJR 37231 4106 27 than than IN 37231 4106 28 a a DT 37231 4106 29 small small JJ 37231 4106 30 party party NN 37231 4106 31 amongst amongst IN 37231 4106 32 the the DT 37231 4106 33 Jews Jews NNPS 37231 4106 34 . . . 37231 4107 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4107 2 3 3 LS 37231 4107 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4107 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4107 5 are be VBP 37231 4107 6 not not RB 37231 4107 7 , , , 37231 4107 8 therefore therefore RB 37231 4107 9 , , , 37231 4107 10 surprised surprise VBD 37231 4107 11 to to TO 37231 4107 12 find find VB 37231 4107 13 that that IN 37231 4107 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4107 15 rule rule NN 37231 4107 16 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4107 17 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4107 18 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4107 19 of of IN 37231 4107 20 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 37231 4107 21 in in IN 37231 4107 22 the the DT 37231 4107 23 Christian christian JJ 37231 4107 24 communities community NNS 37231 4107 25 { { -LRB- 37231 4107 26 432 432 CD 37231 4107 27 } } -RRB- 37231 4107 28 which which WDT 37231 4107 29 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4107 30 visited visit VBD 37231 4107 31 , , , 37231 4107 32 was be VBD 37231 4107 33 " " `` 37231 4107 34 the the DT 37231 4107 35 Law Law NNP 37231 4107 36 , , , 37231 4107 37 the the DT 37231 4107 38 Prophets Prophets NNPS 37231 4107 39 , , , 37231 4107 40 and and CC 37231 4107 41 the the DT 37231 4107 42 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4107 43 . . . 37231 4107 44 " " '' 37231 4108 1 Speaking speak VBG 37231 4108 2 of of IN 37231 4108 3 the the DT 37231 4108 4 result result NN 37231 4108 5 of of IN 37231 4108 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4108 7 observations observation NNS 37231 4108 8 during during IN 37231 4108 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4108 10 travels travel NNS 37231 4108 11 , , , 37231 4108 12 and and CC 37231 4108 13 of of IN 37231 4108 14 the the DT 37231 4108 15 succession succession NN 37231 4108 16 of of IN 37231 4108 17 Bishops Bishops NNPS 37231 4108 18 in in IN 37231 4108 19 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4108 20 , , , 37231 4108 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4108 22 says say VBZ 37231 4108 23 : : : 37231 4108 24 " " `` 37231 4108 25 The the DT 37231 4108 26 Corinthian Corinthian NNP 37231 4108 27 Church Church NNP 37231 4108 28 has have VBZ 37231 4108 29 continued continue VBN 37231 4108 30 in in IN 37231 4108 31 the the DT 37231 4108 32 true true JJ 37231 4108 33 faith faith NN 37231 4108 34 until until IN 37231 4108 35 Primus Primus NNP 37231 4108 36 , , , 37231 4108 37 now now RB 37231 4108 38 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4108 39 of of IN 37231 4108 40 Corinth Corinth NNP 37231 4108 41 . . . 37231 4109 1 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4109 2 conversed converse VBD 37231 4109 3 with with IN 37231 4109 4 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4109 5 on on IN 37231 4109 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4109 7 voyage voyage NN 37231 4109 8 to to IN 37231 4109 9 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4109 10 , , , 37231 4109 11 and and CC 37231 4109 12 stayed stay VBD 37231 4109 13 many many JJ 37231 4109 14 days day NNS 37231 4109 15 with with IN 37231 4109 16 the the DT 37231 4109 17 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 4109 18 , , , 37231 4109 19 during during IN 37231 4109 20 which which WDT 37231 4109 21 time time NN 37231 4109 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4109 23 were be VBD 37231 4109 24 refreshed refresh VBN 37231 4109 25 together together RB 37231 4109 26 with with IN 37231 4109 27 true true JJ 37231 4109 28 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 4109 29 . . . 37231 4110 1 Arrived arrive VBN 37231 4110 2 in in IN 37231 4110 3 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4110 4 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4110 5 composed compose VBD 37231 4110 6 the the DT 37231 4110 7 succession succession NN 37231 4110 8 until until IN 37231 4110 9 Anicetus Anicetus NNP 37231 4110 10 , , , 37231 4110 11 whose whose WP$ 37231 4110 12 deacon deacon NN 37231 4110 13 was be VBD 37231 4110 14 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 37231 4110 15 . . . 37231 4111 1 After after IN 37231 4111 2 Anicetus Anicetus NNP 37231 4111 3 succeeded succeed VBD 37231 4111 4 Soter Soter NNP 37231 4111 5 , , , 37231 4111 6 and and CC 37231 4111 7 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 4111 8 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 37231 4111 9 . . . 37231 4112 1 But but CC 37231 4112 2 with with IN 37231 4112 3 every every DT 37231 4112 4 succession succession NN 37231 4112 5 , , , 37231 4112 6 and and CC 37231 4112 7 in in IN 37231 4112 8 every every DT 37231 4112 9 city city NN 37231 4112 10 , , , 37231 4112 11 that that WDT 37231 4112 12 prevails prevail VBZ 37231 4112 13 which which WDT 37231 4112 14 the the DT 37231 4112 15 Law Law NNP 37231 4112 16 , , , 37231 4112 17 and and CC 37231 4112 18 the the DT 37231 4112 19 Prophets Prophets NNPS 37231 4112 20 , , , 37231 4112 21 and and CC 37231 4112 22 the the DT 37231 4112 23 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4112 24 enjoin enjoin NN 37231 4112 25 . . . 37231 4113 1 " " `` 37231 4113 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4113 3 1 1 LS 37231 4113 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4113 5 The the DT 37231 4113 6 test test NN 37231 4113 7 of of IN 37231 4113 8 true true JJ 37231 4113 9 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 4113 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4113 11 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4113 12 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4113 13 with with IN 37231 4113 14 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4113 15 as as IN 37231 4113 16 with with IN 37231 4113 17 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4113 18 , , , 37231 4113 19 therefore therefore RB 37231 4113 20 , , , 37231 4113 21 is be VBZ 37231 4113 22 no no DT 37231 4113 23 New New NNP 37231 4113 24 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4113 25 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4113 26 , , , 37231 4113 27 which which WDT 37231 4113 28 does do VBZ 37231 4113 29 not not RB 37231 4113 30 yet yet RB 37231 4113 31 exist exist VB 37231 4113 32 for for IN 37231 4113 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4113 34 , , , 37231 4113 35 but but CC 37231 4113 36 the the DT 37231 4113 37 Old Old NNP 37231 4113 38 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4113 39 , , , 37231 4113 40 the the DT 37231 4113 41 only only JJ 37231 4113 42 Holy Holy NNP 37231 4113 43 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 37231 4113 44 which which WDT 37231 4113 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4113 46 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 37231 4113 47 , , , 37231 4113 48 and and CC 37231 4113 49 the the DT 37231 4113 50 words word NNS 37231 4113 51 of of IN 37231 4113 52 the the DT 37231 4113 53 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4113 54 himself,(3 himself,(3 NN 37231 4113 55 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4113 56 which which WDT 37231 4113 57 , , , 37231 4113 58 as as IN 37231 4113 59 in in IN 37231 4113 60 the the DT 37231 4113 61 case case NN 37231 4113 62 of of IN 37231 4113 63 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4113 64 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 4113 65 like like IN 37231 4113 66 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4113 67 , , , 37231 4113 68 were be VBD 37231 4113 69 held hold VBN 37231 4113 70 to to TO 37231 4113 71 be be VB 37231 4113 72 established establish VBN 37231 4113 73 by by IN 37231 4113 74 , , , 37231 4113 75 and and CC 37231 4113 76 in in IN 37231 4113 77 direct direct JJ 37231 4113 78 conformity conformity NN 37231 4113 79 with with IN 37231 4113 80 , , , 37231 4113 81 the the DT 37231 4113 82 Old Old NNP 37231 4113 83 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4113 84 . . . 37231 4114 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4114 2 carefully carefully RB 37231 4114 3 transmits transmit VBZ 37231 4114 4 the the DT 37231 4114 5 unerring unerring JJ 37231 4114 6 tradition tradition NN 37231 4114 7 of of IN 37231 4114 8 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 4114 9 preaching preach VBG 37231 4114 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4114 11 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4114 12 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4114 13 , , , 37231 4114 14 but but CC 37231 4114 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4114 16 apparently apparently RB 37231 4114 17 knows know VBZ 37231 4114 18 nothing nothing NN 37231 4114 19 of of IN 37231 4114 20 any any DT 37231 4114 21 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4114 22 series series NN 37231 4114 23 even even RB 37231 4114 24 of of IN 37231 4114 25 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 4114 26 epistles epistle NNS 37231 4114 27 . . . 37231 4115 1 The the DT 37231 4115 2 care care NN 37231 4115 3 with with IN 37231 4115 4 which which WDT 37231 4115 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4115 6 searches search VBZ 37231 4115 7 for for IN 37231 4115 8 information information NN 37231 4115 9 regarding regard VBG 37231 4115 10 the the DT 37231 4115 11 books book NNS 37231 4115 12 of of IN 37231 4115 13 the the DT 37231 4115 14 New New NNP 37231 4115 15 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4115 16 in in IN 37231 4115 17 early early JJ 37231 4115 18 writers writer NNS 37231 4115 19 , , , 37231 4115 20 and and CC 37231 4115 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4115 22 anxiety anxiety NN 37231 4115 23 to to TO 37231 4115 24 produce produce VB 37231 4115 25 any any DT 37231 4115 26 evidence evidence NN 37231 4115 27 concerning concern VBG 37231 4115 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4115 29 composition composition NN 37231 4115 30 and and CC 37231 4115 31 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 4115 32 , , , 37231 4115 33 render render VB 37231 4115 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4115 35 silence silence NN 37231 4115 36 upon upon IN 37231 4115 37 the the DT 37231 4115 38 subject subject NN 37231 4115 39 almost almost RB 37231 4115 40 as as RB 37231 4115 41 important important JJ 37231 4115 42 as as IN 37231 4115 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4115 44 distinct distinct JJ 37231 4115 45 { { -LRB- 37231 4115 46 433 433 CD 37231 4115 47 } } -RRB- 37231 4115 48 utterance utterance NN 37231 4115 49 when when WRB 37231 4115 50 speaking speak VBG 37231 4115 51 of of IN 37231 4115 52 such such PDT 37231 4115 53 a a DT 37231 4115 54 man man NN 37231 4115 55 as as IN 37231 4115 56 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4115 57 . . . 37231 4116 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4116 2 1 1 LS 37231 4116 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4116 4 Now now RB 37231 4116 5 , , , 37231 4116 6 while while IN 37231 4116 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4116 8 does do VBZ 37231 4116 9 not not RB 37231 4116 10 mention mention VB 37231 4116 11 that that IN 37231 4116 12 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4116 13 refers refer VBZ 37231 4116 14 to to IN 37231 4116 15 any any DT 37231 4116 16 of of IN 37231 4116 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4116 18 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4116 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4116 20 or or CC 37231 4116 21 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 4116 22 , , , 37231 4116 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4116 24 very very RB 37231 4116 25 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 4116 26 states state VBZ 37231 4116 27 that that IN 37231 4116 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4116 29 made make VBD 37231 4116 30 use use NN 37231 4116 31 in in IN 37231 4116 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4116 33 writings writing NNS 37231 4116 34 of of IN 37231 4116 35 the the DT 37231 4116 36 " " `` 37231 4116 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4116 38 according accord VBG 37231 4116 39 to to IN 37231 4116 40 the the DT 37231 4116 41 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4116 42 " " '' 37231 4116 43 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4116 44 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4116 45 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4116 46 . . . 37231 4117 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4117 2 may may MD 37231 4117 3 be be VB 37231 4117 4 well well RB 37231 4117 5 , , , 37231 4117 6 however however RB 37231 4117 7 , , , 37231 4117 8 to to TO 37231 4117 9 give give VB 37231 4117 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4117 11 remarks remark NNS 37231 4117 12 in in IN 37231 4117 13 a a DT 37231 4117 14 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4117 15 form form NN 37231 4117 16 . . . 37231 4118 1 " " `` 37231 4118 2 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4118 3 sets set VBZ 37231 4118 4 forth forth RB 37231 4118 5 some some DT 37231 4118 6 matters matter NNS 37231 4118 7 from from IN 37231 4118 8 the the DT 37231 4118 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4118 10 according accord VBG 37231 4118 11 to to IN 37231 4118 12 the the DT 37231 4118 13 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4118 14 and and CC 37231 4118 15 the the DT 37231 4118 16 Syriac Syriac NNPS 37231 4118 17 , , , 37231 4118 18 and and CC 37231 4118 19 particularly particularly RB 37231 4118 20 from from IN 37231 4118 21 the the DT 37231 4118 22 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4118 23 language language NN 37231 4118 24 , , , 37231 4118 25 showing show VBG 37231 4118 26 that that IN 37231 4118 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4118 28 was be VBD 37231 4118 29 a a DT 37231 4118 30 convert convert NN 37231 4118 31 from from IN 37231 4118 32 among among IN 37231 4118 33 the the DT 37231 4118 34 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4118 35 , , , 37231 4118 36 and and CC 37231 4118 37 other other JJ 37231 4118 38 things thing NNS 37231 4118 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4118 40 records record VBZ 37231 4118 41 as as IN 37231 4118 42 from from IN 37231 4118 43 unwritten unwritten JJ 37231 4118 44 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4118 45 tradition tradition NN 37231 4118 46 . . . 37231 4119 1 And and CC 37231 4119 2 not not RB 37231 4119 3 only only RB 37231 4119 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4119 5 , , , 37231 4119 6 but but CC 37231 4119 7 also also RB 37231 4119 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4119 9 , , , 37231 4119 10 and and CC 37231 4119 11 the the DT 37231 4119 12 whole whole JJ 37231 4119 13 body body NN 37231 4119 14 of of IN 37231 4119 15 the the DT 37231 4119 16 ancients ancient NNS 37231 4119 17 , , , 37231 4119 18 called call VBN 37231 4119 19 the the DT 37231 4119 20 Proverbs Proverbs NNP 37231 4119 21 of of IN 37231 4119 22 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 4119 23 : : : 37231 4119 24 all all RB 37231 4119 25 - - HYPH 37231 4119 26 virtuous virtuous JJ 37231 4119 27 Wisdom wisdom NN 37231 4119 28 . . . 37231 4120 1 And and CC 37231 4120 2 regarding regard VBG 37231 4120 3 the the DT 37231 4120 4 so so RB 37231 4120 5 - - HYPH 37231 4120 6 called call VBN 37231 4120 7 Apocrypha Apocrypha NNP 37231 4120 8 , , , 37231 4120 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4120 10 states state VBZ 37231 4120 11 that that IN 37231 4120 12 some some DT 37231 4120 13 of of IN 37231 4120 14 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4120 15 had have VBD 37231 4120 16 been be VBN 37231 4120 17 forged forge VBN 37231 4120 18 in in IN 37231 4120 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4120 20 own own JJ 37231 4120 21 time time NN 37231 4120 22 by by IN 37231 4120 23 certain certain JJ 37231 4120 24 heretics heretic NNS 37231 4120 25 . . . 37231 4121 1 " " `` 37231 4121 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4121 3 2 2 LS 37231 4121 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4121 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4121 6 is be VBZ 37231 4121 7 certain certain JJ 37231 4121 8 that that IN 37231 4121 9 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4121 10 , , , 37231 4121 11 who who WP 37231 4121 12 quotes quote VBZ 37231 4121 13 with with IN 37231 4121 14 so so RB 37231 4121 15 much much JJ 37231 4121 16 care care VB 37231 4121 17 the the DT 37231 4121 18 testimony testimony NN 37231 4121 19 of of IN 37231 4121 20 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4121 21 , , , 37231 4121 22 a a DT 37231 4121 23 man man NN 37231 4121 24 of of IN 37231 4121 25 whom whom WP 37231 4121 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4121 27 speaks speak VBZ 37231 4121 28 disparagingly disparagingly RB 37231 4121 29 , , , 37231 4121 30 regarding regard VBG 37231 4121 31 the the DT 37231 4121 32 composition composition NN 37231 4121 33 of of IN 37231 4121 34 the the DT 37231 4121 35 first first JJ 37231 4121 36 two two CD 37231 4121 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4121 38 , , , 37231 4121 39 would would MD 37231 4121 40 not not RB 37231 4121 41 have have VB 37231 4121 42 neglected neglect VBN 37231 4121 43 to to TO 37231 4121 44 have have VB 37231 4121 45 availed avail VBN 37231 4121 46 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4121 47 of of IN 37231 4121 48 the the DT 37231 4121 49 evidence evidence NN 37231 4121 50 of of IN 37231 4121 51 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4121 52 , , , 37231 4121 53 for for IN 37231 4121 54 whom whom WP 37231 4121 55 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4121 56 has have VBZ 37231 4121 57 so so RB 37231 4121 58 much much JJ 37231 4121 59 respect respect NN 37231 4121 60 , , , 37231 4121 61 had have VBD 37231 4121 62 that that DT 37231 4121 63 writer writer NN 37231 4121 64 furnished furnish VBD 37231 4121 65 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4121 66 with with IN 37231 4121 67 any any DT 37231 4121 68 opportunity opportunity NN 37231 4121 69 , , , 37231 4121 70 and and CC 37231 4121 71 there there EX 37231 4121 72 can can MD 37231 4121 73 be be VB 37231 4121 74 no no DT 37231 4121 75 doubt doubt NN 37231 4121 76 that that IN 37231 4121 77 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4121 78 found find VBD 37231 4121 79 no no DT 37231 4121 80 facts fact NNS 37231 4121 81 concerning concern VBG 37231 4121 82 the the DT 37231 4121 83 origin origin NN 37231 4121 84 and and CC 37231 4121 85 authorship authorship NN 37231 4121 86 of of IN 37231 4121 87 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4121 88 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4121 89 in in IN 37231 4121 90 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4121 91 writings writing NNS 37231 4121 92 . . . 37231 4122 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4122 2 is be VBZ 37231 4122 3 , , , 37231 4122 4 on on IN 37231 4122 5 the the DT 37231 4122 6 other other JJ 37231 4122 7 hand hand NN 37231 4122 8 , , , 37231 4122 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 4122 10 to to TO 37231 4122 11 infer infer VB 37231 4122 12 that that IN 37231 4122 13 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4122 14 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 4122 15 made make VBD 37231 4122 16 use use NN 37231 4122 17 of of IN 37231 4122 18 the the DT 37231 4122 19 { { -LRB- 37231 4122 20 434 434 CD 37231 4122 21 } } -RRB- 37231 4122 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4122 23 according accord VBG 37231 4122 24 to to IN 37231 4122 25 the the DT 37231 4122 26 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4122 27 , , , 37231 4122 28 together together RB 37231 4122 29 with with IN 37231 4122 30 unwritten unwritten JJ 37231 4122 31 tradition tradition NN 37231 4122 32 . . . 37231 4123 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4123 2 1 1 LS 37231 4123 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4123 4 In in IN 37231 4123 5 the the DT 37231 4123 6 passage passage NN 37231 4123 7 regarding regard VBG 37231 4123 8 the the DT 37231 4123 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4123 10 according accord VBG 37231 4123 11 to to IN 37231 4123 12 the the DT 37231 4123 13 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4123 14 , , , 37231 4123 15 as as IN 37231 4123 16 even even RB 37231 4123 17 Lardner(2 lardner(2 JJ 37231 4123 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4123 19 conjectures conjecture NNS 37231 4123 20 , , , 37231 4123 21 the the DT 37231 4123 22 text text NN 37231 4123 23 of of IN 37231 4123 24 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4123 25 is be VBZ 37231 4123 26 in in IN 37231 4123 27 all all DT 37231 4123 28 probability probability NN 37231 4123 29 confused confuse VBN 37231 4123 30 , , , 37231 4123 31 and and CC 37231 4123 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4123 33 doubtless doubtless RB 37231 4123 34 said say VBD 37231 4123 35 what what WP 37231 4123 36 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4123 37 later later RB 37231 4123 38 found find VBD 37231 4123 39 to to TO 37231 4123 40 be be VB 37231 4123 41 the the DT 37231 4123 42 fact fact NN 37231 4123 43 , , , 37231 4123 44 that that IN 37231 4123 45 " " `` 37231 4123 46 the the DT 37231 4123 47 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4123 48 according accord VBG 37231 4123 49 to to IN 37231 4123 50 the the DT 37231 4123 51 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4123 52 is be VBZ 37231 4123 53 written write VBN 37231 4123 54 in in IN 37231 4123 55 the the DT 37231 4123 56 Chaldaic Chaldaic NNP 37231 4123 57 and and CC 37231 4123 58 Syriac Syriac NNP 37231 4123 59 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4123 60 or or CC 37231 4123 61 Syro Syro NNP 37231 4123 62 - - HYPH 37231 4123 63 Chaldaic Chaldaic NNP 37231 4123 64 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4123 65 language language NN 37231 4123 66 , , , 37231 4123 67 but but CC 37231 4123 68 with with IN 37231 4123 69 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4123 70 characters character NNS 37231 4123 71 . . . 37231 4124 1 " " `` 37231 4124 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4124 3 3 3 LS 37231 4124 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4124 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4124 6 is be VBZ 37231 4124 7 in in IN 37231 4124 8 this this DT 37231 4124 9 sense sense NN 37231 4124 10 that that IN 37231 4124 11 Rufinus Rufinus NNP 37231 4124 12 translates translate VBZ 37231 4124 13 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4124 14 . . . 37231 4125 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4125 2 may may MD 37231 4125 3 not not RB 37231 4125 4 be be VB 37231 4125 5 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 37231 4125 6 to to TO 37231 4125 7 point point VB 37231 4125 8 out out RP 37231 4125 9 that that IN 37231 4125 10 fragments fragment NNS 37231 4125 11 of of IN 37231 4125 12 the the DT 37231 4125 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4125 14 according accord VBG 37231 4125 15 to to IN 37231 4125 16 the the DT 37231 4125 17 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4125 18 , , , 37231 4125 19 which which WDT 37231 4125 20 have have VBP 37231 4125 21 been be VBN 37231 4125 22 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4125 23 , , , 37231 4125 24 show show VB 37231 4125 25 the the DT 37231 4125 26 same same JJ 37231 4125 27 tendency tendency NN 37231 4125 28 to to TO 37231 4125 29 give give VB 37231 4125 30 some some DT 37231 4125 31 pre pre NN 37231 4125 32 - - NN 37231 4125 33 eminence eminence NN 37231 4125 34 to to IN 37231 4125 35 James James NNP 37231 4125 36 amongst amongst IN 37231 4125 37 the the DT 37231 4125 38 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4125 39 which which WDT 37231 4125 40 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4125 41 observe observe VBP 37231 4125 42 in in IN 37231 4125 43 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4125 44 . . . 37231 4126 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4126 2 4 4 LS 37231 4126 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4126 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4126 5 has have VBZ 37231 4126 6 been be VBN 37231 4126 7 argued argue VBN 37231 4126 8 by by IN 37231 4126 9 a a DT 37231 4126 10 few few JJ 37231 4126 11 that that IN 37231 4126 12 the the DT 37231 4126 13 words word NNS 37231 4126 14 , , , 37231 4126 15 " " '' 37231 4126 16 and and CC 37231 4126 17 regarding regard VBG 37231 4126 18 the the DT 37231 4126 19 so so RB 37231 4126 20 - - HYPH 37231 4126 21 called call VBN 37231 4126 22 Apocrypha Apocrypha NNP 37231 4126 23 , , , 37231 4126 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4126 25 states state VBZ 37231 4126 26 that that IN 37231 4126 27 some some DT 37231 4126 28 of of IN 37231 4126 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4126 30 had have VBD 37231 4126 31 been be VBN 37231 4126 32 forged forge VBN 37231 4126 33 in in IN 37231 4126 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4126 35 own own JJ 37231 4126 36 times time NNS 37231 4126 37 by by IN 37231 4126 38 certain certain JJ 37231 4126 39 heretics heretic NNS 37231 4126 40 , , , 37231 4126 41 " " `` 37231 4126 42 are be VBP 37231 4126 43 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 4126 44 to to IN 37231 4126 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4126 46 attributing attribute VBG 37231 4126 47 authority authority NN 37231 4126 48 to to IN 37231 4126 49 the the DT 37231 4126 50 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4126 51 according accord VBG 37231 4126 52 to to IN 37231 4126 53 the the DT 37231 4126 54 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4126 55 , , , 37231 4126 56 or or CC 37231 4126 57 at at IN 37231 4126 58 least least JJS 37231 4126 59 that that IN 37231 4126 60 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4126 61 indicate indicate VBP 37231 4126 62 some some DT 37231 4126 63 distinction distinction NN 37231 4126 64 amongst amongst IN 37231 4126 65 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 4126 66 between between IN 37231 4126 67 recognized recognize VBN 37231 4126 68 and and CC 37231 4126 69 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 4126 70 works work NNS 37231 4126 71 . . . 37231 4127 1 The the DT 37231 4127 2 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 4127 3 works work VBZ 37231 4127 4 referred refer VBD 37231 4127 5 to to IN 37231 4127 6 , , , 37231 4127 7 however however RB 37231 4127 8 , , , 37231 4127 9 are be VBP 37231 4127 10 clearly clearly RB 37231 4127 11 Old Old NNP 37231 4127 12 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4127 13 Apocrypha apocrypha NN 37231 4127 14 . . . 37231 4128 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4128 2 5 5 LS 37231 4128 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4128 4 The the DT 37231 4128 5 words word NNS 37231 4128 6 are be VBP 37231 4128 7 introduced introduce VBN 37231 4128 8 by by IN 37231 4128 9 the the DT 37231 4128 10 statement statement NN 37231 4128 11 that that IN 37231 4128 12 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4128 13 records record VBZ 37231 4128 14 matters matter VBZ 37231 4128 15 " " '' 37231 4128 16 as as IN 37231 4128 17 from from IN 37231 4128 18 unwritten unwritten JJ 37231 4128 19 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4128 20 tradition tradition NN 37231 4128 21 , , , 37231 4128 22 " " '' 37231 4128 23 and and CC 37231 4128 24 then then RB 37231 4128 25 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 4128 26 , , , 37231 4128 27 " " `` 37231 4128 28 and and CC 37231 4128 29 { { -LRB- 37231 4128 30 435 435 CD 37231 4128 31 } } -RRB- 37231 4128 32 not not RB 37231 4128 33 only only RB 37231 4128 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4128 35 , , , 37231 4128 36 but but CC 37231 4128 37 also also RB 37231 4128 38 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4128 39 and and CC 37231 4128 40 the the DT 37231 4128 41 whole whole JJ 37231 4128 42 body body NN 37231 4128 43 of of IN 37231 4128 44 the the DT 37231 4128 45 ancients ancient NNS 37231 4128 46 , , , 37231 4128 47 called call VBN 37231 4128 48 the the DT 37231 4128 49 Proverbs Proverbs NNP 37231 4128 50 of of IN 37231 4128 51 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 4128 52 : : : 37231 4128 53 all all RB 37231 4128 54 - - HYPH 37231 4128 55 virtuous virtuous JJ 37231 4128 56 Wisdom wisdom NN 37231 4128 57 . . . 37231 4128 58 " " '' 37231 4129 1 Then then RB 37231 4129 2 follow follow VB 37231 4129 3 the the DT 37231 4129 4 words word NNS 37231 4129 5 , , , 37231 4129 6 " " '' 37231 4129 7 And and CC 37231 4129 8 with with IN 37231 4129 9 regard regard NN 37231 4129 10 to to IN 37231 4129 11 the the DT 37231 4129 12 _ _ NNP 37231 4129 13 so so RB 37231 4129 14 - - HYPH 37231 4129 15 called call VBN 37231 4129 16 _ _ NNP 37231 4129 17 Apocrypha Apocrypha NNP 37231 4129 18 , , , 37231 4129 19 " " '' 37231 4129 20 & & CC 37231 4129 21 c c NNP 37231 4129 22 , , , 37231 4129 23 & & CC 37231 4129 24 c c NNP 37231 4129 25 , , , 37231 4129 26 evidently evidently RB 37231 4129 27 passing pass VBG 37231 4129 28 from from IN 37231 4129 29 the the DT 37231 4129 30 work work NN 37231 4129 31 just just RB 37231 4129 32 mentioned mention VBD 37231 4129 33 to to IN 37231 4129 34 the the DT 37231 4129 35 Old Old NNP 37231 4129 36 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4129 37 Apocrypha Apocrypha NNP 37231 4129 38 , , , 37231 4129 39 several several JJ 37231 4129 40 of of IN 37231 4129 41 which which WDT 37231 4129 42 stand stand VBP 37231 4129 43 also also RB 37231 4129 44 in in IN 37231 4129 45 the the DT 37231 4129 46 name name NN 37231 4129 47 of of IN 37231 4129 48 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 4129 49 , , , 37231 4129 50 and and CC 37231 4129 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4129 52 is be VBZ 37231 4129 53 not not RB 37231 4129 54 improbable improbable JJ 37231 4129 55 that that IN 37231 4129 56 amongst amongst IN 37231 4129 57 these these DT 37231 4129 58 were be VBD 37231 4129 59 included include VBN 37231 4129 60 the the DT 37231 4129 61 _ _ NNP 37231 4129 62 Ascensio Ascensio NNP 37231 4129 63 Esaiæ Esaiæ NNP 37231 4129 64 _ _ NNP 37231 4129 65 and and CC 37231 4129 66 the the DT 37231 4129 67 _ _ NNP 37231 4129 68 Apocalypsis Apocalypsis NNP 37231 4129 69 Eliæ Eliæ NNP 37231 4129 70 _ _ NNP 37231 4129 71 , , , 37231 4129 72 to to TO 37231 4129 73 which which WDT 37231 4129 74 is be VBZ 37231 4129 75 referred refer VBN 37231 4129 76 a a DT 37231 4129 77 passage passage NN 37231 4129 78 which which WDT 37231 4129 79 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4129 80 , , , 37231 4129 81 in in IN 37231 4129 82 a a DT 37231 4129 83 fragment fragment NN 37231 4129 84 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4129 85 by by IN 37231 4129 86 Photius,(1 Photius,(1 NNP 37231 4129 87 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4129 88 strongly strongly RB 37231 4129 89 repudiates repudiate NNS 37231 4129 90 . . . 37231 4130 1 As as IN 37231 4130 2 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4130 3 does do VBZ 37231 4130 4 not not RB 37231 4130 5 , , , 37231 4130 6 so so RB 37231 4130 7 far far RB 37231 4130 8 as as IN 37231 4130 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4130 10 know know VBP 37231 4130 11 , , , 37231 4130 12 mention mention VBP 37231 4130 13 any any DT 37231 4130 14 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4130 15 work work NN 37231 4130 16 of of IN 37231 4130 17 the the DT 37231 4130 18 New New NNP 37231 4130 19 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4130 20 , , , 37231 4130 21 but but CC 37231 4130 22 takes take VBZ 37231 4130 23 as as IN 37231 4130 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4130 25 rule rule NN 37231 4130 26 of of IN 37231 4130 27 faith faith NN 37231 4130 28 the the DT 37231 4130 29 Law Law NNP 37231 4130 30 , , , 37231 4130 31 the the DT 37231 4130 32 Prophets Prophets NNPS 37231 4130 33 , , , 37231 4130 34 and and CC 37231 4130 35 the the DT 37231 4130 36 words word NNS 37231 4130 37 of of IN 37231 4130 38 the the DT 37231 4130 39 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4130 40 , , , 37231 4130 41 probably probably RB 37231 4130 42 as as IN 37231 4130 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4130 44 finds find VBZ 37231 4130 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4130 46 in in IN 37231 4130 47 the the DT 37231 4130 48 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4130 49 according accord VBG 37231 4130 50 to to IN 37231 4130 51 the the DT 37231 4130 52 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4130 53 , , , 37231 4130 54 quotes quote NNS 37231 4130 55 also also RB 37231 4130 56 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4130 57 tradition tradition NN 37231 4130 58 and and CC 37231 4130 59 discusses discuss VBZ 37231 4130 60 the the DT 37231 4130 61 Proverbs Proverbs NNPS 37231 4130 62 of of IN 37231 4130 63 Solomon Solomon NNP 37231 4130 64 , , , 37231 4130 65 the the DT 37231 4130 66 only only JJ 37231 4130 67 possible possible JJ 37231 4130 68 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4130 69 at at IN 37231 4130 70 which which WDT 37231 4130 71 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4130 72 can can MD 37231 4130 73 reasonably reasonably RB 37231 4130 74 arrive arrive VB 37231 4130 75 is be VBZ 37231 4130 76 that that IN 37231 4130 77 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4130 78 spoke speak VBD 37231 4130 79 of of IN 37231 4130 80 Old Old NNP 37231 4130 81 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4130 82 Apocrypha Apocrypha NNP 37231 4130 83 . . . 37231 4131 1 There there EX 37231 4131 2 can can MD 37231 4131 3 not not RB 37231 4131 4 be be VB 37231 4131 5 a a DT 37231 4131 6 doubt doubt NN 37231 4131 7 that that IN 37231 4131 8 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4131 9 would would MD 37231 4131 10 have have VB 37231 4131 11 recorded record VBN 37231 4131 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4131 13 repudiation repudiation NN 37231 4131 14 of of IN 37231 4131 15 New New NNP 37231 4131 16 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4131 17 " " '' 37231 4131 18 Apocrypha Apocrypha NNP 37231 4131 19 , , , 37231 4131 20 " " '' 37231 4131 21 regarding regard VBG 37231 4131 22 which which WDT 37231 4131 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4131 24 so so RB 37231 4131 25 carefully carefully RB 37231 4131 26 collects collect VBZ 37231 4131 27 information information NN 37231 4131 28 , , , 37231 4131 29 and and CC 37231 4131 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4131 31 consequent consequent JJ 37231 4131 32 recognition recognition NN 37231 4131 33 of of IN 37231 4131 34 New New NNP 37231 4131 35 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4131 36 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4131 37 works work NNS 37231 4131 38 implied imply VBN 37231 4131 39 in in IN 37231 4131 40 such such PDT 37231 4131 41 a a DT 37231 4131 42 distinction distinction NN 37231 4131 43 . . . 37231 4132 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4132 2 must must MD 37231 4132 3 now now RB 37231 4132 4 see see VB 37231 4132 5 how how WRB 37231 4132 6 far far RB 37231 4132 7 in in IN 37231 4132 8 the the DT 37231 4132 9 fragments fragment NNS 37231 4132 10 of of IN 37231 4132 11 the the DT 37231 4132 12 works work NNS 37231 4132 13 of of IN 37231 4132 14 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4132 15 which which WDT 37231 4132 16 have have VBP 37231 4132 17 been be VBN 37231 4132 18 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4132 19 to to IN 37231 4132 20 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4132 21 there there EX 37231 4132 22 are be VBP 37231 4132 23 references reference NNS 37231 4132 24 to to TO 37231 4132 25 assist assist VB 37231 4132 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4132 27 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 4132 28 . . . 37231 4133 1 In in IN 37231 4133 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4133 3 account account NN 37231 4133 4 of of IN 37231 4133 5 certain certain JJ 37231 4133 6 surviving survive VBG 37231 4133 7 members member NNS 37231 4133 8 of of IN 37231 4133 9 the the DT 37231 4133 10 family family NN 37231 4133 11 of of IN 37231 4133 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4133 13 , , , 37231 4133 14 who who WP 37231 4133 15 were be VBD 37231 4133 16 brought bring VBN 37231 4133 17 before before RB 37231 4133 18 Domitian Domitian NNP 37231 4133 19 , , , 37231 4133 20 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4133 21 says say VBZ 37231 4133 22 : : : 37231 4133 23 " " `` 37231 4133 24 For for IN 37231 4133 25 Domitian Domitian NNP 37231 4133 26 feared fear VBD 37231 4133 27 the the DT 37231 4133 28 appearing appearing NN 37231 4133 29 of of IN 37231 4133 30 the the DT 37231 4133 31 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4133 32 as as RB 37231 4133 33 much much RB 37231 4133 34 as as IN 37231 4133 35 Herod Herod NNP 37231 4133 36 . . . 37231 4134 1 " " `` 37231 4134 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4134 3 2 2 LS 37231 4134 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4134 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4134 6 has have VBZ 37231 4134 7 been be VBN 37231 4134 8 argued argue VBN 37231 4134 9 that that IN 37231 4134 10 this this DT 37231 4134 11 { { -LRB- 37231 4134 12 436 436 CD 37231 4134 13 } } -RRB- 37231 4134 14 may may MD 37231 4134 15 be be VB 37231 4134 16 an an DT 37231 4134 17 allusion allusion NN 37231 4134 18 to to IN 37231 4134 19 the the DT 37231 4134 20 massacre massacre NN 37231 4134 21 of of IN 37231 4134 22 the the DT 37231 4134 23 children child NNS 37231 4134 24 by by IN 37231 4134 25 Herod Herod NNP 37231 4134 26 related relate VBN 37231 4134 27 in in IN 37231 4134 28 Matt Matt NNP 37231 4134 29 ii ii NNP 37231 4134 30 . . . 37231 4134 31 , , , 37231 4134 32 more more RBR 37231 4134 33 especially especially RB 37231 4134 34 as as IN 37231 4134 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4134 36 is be VBZ 37231 4134 37 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 4134 38 that that IN 37231 4134 39 the the DT 37231 4134 40 parallel parallel JJ 37231 4134 41 account account NN 37231 4134 42 to to IN 37231 4134 43 that that DT 37231 4134 44 contained contain VBN 37231 4134 45 in in IN 37231 4134 46 the the DT 37231 4134 47 first first JJ 37231 4134 48 two two CD 37231 4134 49 chapters chapter NNS 37231 4134 50 of of IN 37231 4134 51 the the DT 37231 4134 52 first first JJ 37231 4134 53 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4134 54 existed exist VBD 37231 4134 55 in in IN 37231 4134 56 the the DT 37231 4134 57 oldest old JJS 37231 4134 58 forms form NNS 37231 4134 59 of of IN 37231 4134 60 the the DT 37231 4134 61 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4134 62 according accord VBG 37231 4134 63 to to IN 37231 4134 64 the the DT 37231 4134 65 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4134 66 . . . 37231 4135 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4135 2 1 1 LS 37231 4135 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4135 4 But but CC 37231 4135 5 the the DT 37231 4135 6 tradition tradition NN 37231 4135 7 which which WDT 37231 4135 8 has have VBZ 37231 4135 9 been be VBN 37231 4135 10 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4135 11 in in IN 37231 4135 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4135 13 first first JJ 37231 4135 14 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 4135 15 may may MD 37231 4135 16 have have VB 37231 4135 17 formed form VBN 37231 4135 18 part part NN 37231 4135 19 of of IN 37231 4135 20 many many JJ 37231 4135 21 other other JJ 37231 4135 22 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 4135 23 works work NNS 37231 4135 24 , , , 37231 4135 25 in in IN 37231 4135 26 one one CD 37231 4135 27 shape shape NN 37231 4135 28 or or CC 37231 4135 29 another another DT 37231 4135 30 , , , 37231 4135 31 and and CC 37231 4135 32 certainly certainly RB 37231 4135 33 can can MD 37231 4135 34 not not RB 37231 4135 35 be be VB 37231 4135 36 claimed claim VBN 37231 4135 37 with with IN 37231 4135 38 reason reason NN 37231 4135 39 exclusively exclusively RB 37231 4135 40 for for IN 37231 4135 41 that that DT 37231 4135 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4135 43 . . . 37231 4136 1 This this DT 37231 4136 2 argument argument NN 37231 4136 3 , , , 37231 4136 4 therefore therefore RB 37231 4136 5 , , , 37231 4136 6 has have VBZ 37231 4136 7 no no DT 37231 4136 8 weight weight NN 37231 4136 9 whatever whatever WDT 37231 4136 10 , , , 37231 4136 11 and and CC 37231 4136 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4136 13 obviously obviously RB 37231 4136 14 rests rest VBZ 37231 4136 15 upon upon IN 37231 4136 16 the the DT 37231 4136 17 vaguest vague JJS 37231 4136 18 conjecture conjecture NN 37231 4136 19 . . . 37231 4137 1 The the DT 37231 4137 2 principal principal JJ 37231 4137 3 passages passage NNS 37231 4137 4 which which WDT 37231 4137 5 apologists(2 apologists(2 VBP 37231 4137 6 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4137 7 adduce adduce VBP 37231 4137 8 as as IN 37231 4137 9 references reference NNS 37231 4137 10 to to IN 37231 4137 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4137 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4137 13 occur occur VBP 37231 4137 14 in in IN 37231 4137 15 the the DT 37231 4137 16 account account NN 37231 4137 17 which which WDT 37231 4137 18 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4137 19 gives give VBZ 37231 4137 20 of of IN 37231 4137 21 the the DT 37231 4137 22 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 4137 23 of of IN 37231 4137 24 James James NNP 37231 4137 25 the the DT 37231 4137 26 Just just RB 37231 4137 27 . . . 37231 4138 1 The the DT 37231 4138 2 first first JJ 37231 4138 3 of of IN 37231 4138 4 these these DT 37231 4138 5 is be VBZ 37231 4138 6 the the DT 37231 4138 7 reply reply NN 37231 4138 8 which which WDT 37231 4138 9 James James NNP 37231 4138 10 is be VBZ 37231 4138 11 said say VBN 37231 4138 12 to to TO 37231 4138 13 have have VB 37231 4138 14 given give VBN 37231 4138 15 to to IN 37231 4138 16 the the DT 37231 4138 17 Scribes Scribes NNPS 37231 4138 18 and and CC 37231 4138 19 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 37231 4138 20 : : : 37231 4138 21 " " `` 37231 4138 22 Why why WRB 37231 4138 23 do do VBP 37231 4138 24 ye ye PRP 37231 4138 25 ask ask VB 37231 4138 26 me -PRON- PRP 37231 4138 27 concerning concern VBG 37231 4138 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4138 29 the the DT 37231 4138 30 Son Son NNP 37231 4138 31 of of IN 37231 4138 32 Man Man NNP 37231 4138 33 ? ? . 37231 4139 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4139 2 sits sit VBZ 37231 4139 3 in in IN 37231 4139 4 heaven heaven NNP 37231 4139 5 on on IN 37231 4139 6 the the DT 37231 4139 7 right right JJ 37231 4139 8 hand hand NN 37231 4139 9 of of IN 37231 4139 10 great great JJ 37231 4139 11 power power NN 37231 4139 12 , , , 37231 4139 13 and and CC 37231 4139 14 is be VBZ 37231 4139 15 about about JJ 37231 4139 16 to to TO 37231 4139 17 come come VB 37231 4139 18 on on IN 37231 4139 19 the the DT 37231 4139 20 clouds cloud NNS 37231 4139 21 of of IN 37231 4139 22 heaven heaven NNP 37231 4139 23 . . . 37231 4140 1 " " `` 37231 4140 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4140 3 3 3 LS 37231 4140 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4140 5 This this DT 37231 4140 6 is be VBZ 37231 4140 7 compared compare VBN 37231 4140 8 with with IN 37231 4140 9 Matt Matt NNP 37231 4140 10 . . . 37231 4141 1 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 4141 2 . . . 37231 4142 1 64 64 CD 37231 4142 2 : : : 37231 4142 3 " " `` 37231 4142 4 From from IN 37231 4142 5 this this DT 37231 4142 6 time time NN 37231 4142 7 ye ye NNP 37231 4142 8 shall shall MD 37231 4142 9 see see VB 37231 4142 10 the the DT 37231 4142 11 Son Son NNP 37231 4142 12 of of IN 37231 4142 13 Man Man NNP 37231 4142 14 sitting sit VBG 37231 4142 15 on on IN 37231 4142 16 the the DT 37231 4142 17 right right JJ 37231 4142 18 hand hand NN 37231 4142 19 of of IN 37231 4142 20 power power NN 37231 4142 21 and and CC 37231 4142 22 coming come VBG 37231 4142 23 on on IN 37231 4142 24 the the DT 37231 4142 25 clouds cloud NNS 37231 4142 26 of of IN 37231 4142 27 heaven heaven NNP 37231 4142 28 . . . 37231 4143 1 " " `` 37231 4143 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4143 3 4 4 LS 37231 4143 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4143 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4143 6 is be VBZ 37231 4143 7 not not RB 37231 4143 8 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4143 9 to to TO 37231 4143 10 point point VB 37231 4143 11 out out RP 37231 4143 12 the the DT 37231 4143 13 variations variation NNS 37231 4143 14 between between IN 37231 4143 15 these these DT 37231 4143 16 two two CD 37231 4143 17 passages passage NNS 37231 4143 18 , , , 37231 4143 19 which which WDT 37231 4143 20 are be VBP 37231 4143 21 obvious obvious JJ 37231 4143 22 . . . 37231 4144 1 If if IN 37231 4144 2 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4144 3 had have VBD 37231 4144 4 not not RB 37231 4144 5 the the DT 37231 4144 6 direct direct JJ 37231 4144 7 intimation intimation NN 37231 4144 8 that that IN 37231 4144 9 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4144 10 made make VBD 37231 4144 11 use use NN 37231 4144 12 of of IN 37231 4144 13 the the DT 37231 4144 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4144 15 according accord VBG 37231 4144 16 to to IN 37231 4144 17 the the DT 37231 4144 18 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4144 19 , , , 37231 4144 20 which which WDT 37231 4144 21 no no RB 37231 4144 22 doubt doubt RB 37231 4144 23 contained contain VBD 37231 4144 24 this this DT 37231 4144 25 passage passage NN 37231 4144 26 , , , 37231 4144 27 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4144 28 would would MD 37231 4144 29 be be VB 37231 4144 30 apparent apparent JJ 37231 4144 31 that that IN 37231 4144 32 a a DT 37231 4144 33 man man NN 37231 4144 34 who who WP 37231 4144 35 valued value VBD 37231 4144 36 tradition tradition NN 37231 4144 37 { { -LRB- 37231 4144 38 437 437 CD 37231 4144 39 } } -RRB- 37231 4144 40 so so RB 37231 4144 41 highly highly RB 37231 4144 42 might may MD 37231 4144 43 well well RB 37231 4144 44 have have VB 37231 4144 45 derived derive VBN 37231 4144 46 this this DT 37231 4144 47 and and CC 37231 4144 48 other other JJ 37231 4144 49 passages passage NNS 37231 4144 50 from from IN 37231 4144 51 that that DT 37231 4144 52 source source NN 37231 4144 53 . . . 37231 4145 1 This this DT 37231 4145 2 is be VBZ 37231 4145 3 precisely precisely RB 37231 4145 4 one one CD 37231 4145 5 of of IN 37231 4145 6 those those DT 37231 4145 7 sayings saying NNS 37231 4145 8 which which WDT 37231 4145 9 were be VBD 37231 4145 10 most most RBS 37231 4145 11 current current JJ 37231 4145 12 in in IN 37231 4145 13 the the DT 37231 4145 14 early early JJ 37231 4145 15 Church Church NNP 37231 4145 16 , , , 37231 4145 17 whose whose WP$ 37231 4145 18 hope hope NN 37231 4145 19 and and CC 37231 4145 20 courage courage NN 37231 4145 21 were be VBD 37231 4145 22 sustained sustain VBN 37231 4145 23 amid amid IN 37231 4145 24 persecution persecution NN 37231 4145 25 and and CC 37231 4145 26 suffering suffering NN 37231 4145 27 by by IN 37231 4145 28 such such JJ 37231 4145 29 Chiliastic chiliastic JJ 37231 4145 30 expectations expectation NNS 37231 4145 31 , , , 37231 4145 32 with with IN 37231 4145 33 which which WDT 37231 4145 34 according accord VBG 37231 4145 35 to to IN 37231 4145 36 the the DT 37231 4145 37 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 4145 38 injunction injunction NN 37231 4145 39 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4145 40 comforted comfort VBD 37231 4145 41 each each DT 37231 4145 42 other other JJ 37231 4145 43 . . . 37231 4146 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4146 2 1 1 LS 37231 4146 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4146 4 In in IN 37231 4146 5 any any DT 37231 4146 6 case case NN 37231 4146 7 the the DT 37231 4146 8 words word NNS 37231 4146 9 do do VBP 37231 4146 10 not not RB 37231 4146 11 agree agree VB 37231 4146 12 with with IN 37231 4146 13 the the DT 37231 4146 14 passage passage NN 37231 4146 15 in in IN 37231 4146 16 the the DT 37231 4146 17 first first JJ 37231 4146 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4146 19 , , , 37231 4146 20 and and CC 37231 4146 21 as as IN 37231 4146 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4146 23 have have VBP 37231 4146 24 already already RB 37231 4146 25 established establish VBN 37231 4146 26 , , , 37231 4146 27 even even RB 37231 4146 28 perfect perfect JJ 37231 4146 29 agreement agreement NN 37231 4146 30 would would MD 37231 4146 31 not not RB 37231 4146 32 under under IN 37231 4146 33 the the DT 37231 4146 34 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 4146 35 be be VB 37231 4146 36 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 4146 37 evidence evidence NN 37231 4146 38 that that IN 37231 4146 39 the the DT 37231 4146 40 quotation quotation NN 37231 4146 41 is be VBZ 37231 4146 42 from from IN 37231 4146 43 that that DT 37231 4146 44 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4146 45 , , , 37231 4146 46 and and CC 37231 4146 47 not not RB 37231 4146 48 from from IN 37231 4146 49 another another DT 37231 4146 50 ; ; : 37231 4146 51 but but CC 37231 4146 52 with with IN 37231 4146 53 such such JJ 37231 4146 54 discrepancy discrepancy NN 37231 4146 55 , , , 37231 4146 56 without without IN 37231 4146 57 any any DT 37231 4146 58 evidence evidence NN 37231 4146 59 whatever whatever WDT 37231 4146 60 that that IN 37231 4146 61 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4146 62 knew know VBD 37231 4146 63 anything anything NN 37231 4146 64 of of IN 37231 4146 65 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4146 66 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4146 67 , , , 37231 4146 68 but but CC 37231 4146 69 , , , 37231 4146 70 on on IN 37231 4146 71 the the DT 37231 4146 72 contrary contrary NN 37231 4146 73 , , , 37231 4146 74 with with IN 37231 4146 75 the the DT 37231 4146 76 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 4146 77 that that WDT 37231 4146 78 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4146 79 made make VBD 37231 4146 80 use use NN 37231 4146 81 of of IN 37231 4146 82 the the DT 37231 4146 83 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4146 84 according accord VBG 37231 4146 85 to to IN 37231 4146 86 the the DT 37231 4146 87 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4146 88 , , , 37231 4146 89 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4146 90 must must MD 37231 4146 91 decide decide VB 37231 4146 92 that that IN 37231 4146 93 any any DT 37231 4146 94 such such JJ 37231 4146 95 passages passage NNS 37231 4146 96 must must MD 37231 4146 97 rather rather RB 37231 4146 98 be be VB 37231 4146 99 derived derive VBN 37231 4146 100 from from IN 37231 4146 101 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4146 102 than than IN 37231 4146 103 from from IN 37231 4146 104 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4146 105 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4146 106 . . . 37231 4147 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4147 2 is be VBZ 37231 4147 3 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 4147 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4147 5 to to TO 37231 4147 6 say say VB 37231 4147 7 anything anything NN 37231 4147 8 regarding regard VBG 37231 4147 9 the the DT 37231 4147 10 phrase phrase NN 37231 4147 11 : : : 37231 4147 12 " " `` 37231 4147 13 for for IN 37231 4147 14 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4147 15 and and CC 37231 4147 16 all all PDT 37231 4147 17 the the DT 37231 4147 18 people people NNS 37231 4147 19 testify testify VBP 37231 4147 20 to to IN 37231 4147 21 thee thee PRP 37231 4147 22 that that WDT 37231 4147 23 thou thou NNP 37231 4147 24 art art NNP 37231 4147 25 just just RB 37231 4147 26 and and CC 37231 4147 27 that that IN 37231 4147 28 thou thou NNP 37231 4147 29 respectest respectest NNP 37231 4147 30 not not RB 37231 4147 31 persons person NNS 37231 4147 32 . . . 37231 4148 1 " " `` 37231 4148 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4148 3 2 2 LS 37231 4148 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4148 5 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4148 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 4148 7 points point VBZ 37231 4148 8 out out RP 37231 4148 9 that that IN 37231 4148 10 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4148 11 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4148 12 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4148 13 only only RB 37231 4148 14 occurs occur VBZ 37231 4148 15 in in IN 37231 4148 16 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4148 17 xx xx CD 37231 4148 18 . . . 37231 4149 1 21 21 CD 37231 4149 2 , , , 37231 4149 3 and and CC 37231 4149 4 Galatians Galatians NNPS 37231 4149 5 ii ii PRP 37231 4149 6 . . . 37231 4150 1 6;(3 6;(3 LS 37231 4150 2 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4150 3 but but CC 37231 4150 4 the the DT 37231 4150 5 similarity similarity NN 37231 4150 6 of of IN 37231 4150 7 this this DT 37231 4150 8 single single JJ 37231 4150 9 phrase phrase NN 37231 4150 10 , , , 37231 4150 11 which which WDT 37231 4150 12 is be VBZ 37231 4150 13 not not RB 37231 4150 14 given give VBN 37231 4150 15 as as IN 37231 4150 16 a a DT 37231 4150 17 quotation quotation NN 37231 4150 18 , , , 37231 4150 19 but but CC 37231 4150 20 in in IN 37231 4150 21 a a DT 37231 4150 22 historical historical JJ 37231 4150 23 form form NN 37231 4150 24 put put VBN 37231 4150 25 into into IN 37231 4150 26 the the DT 37231 4150 27 mouth mouth NN 37231 4150 28 of of IN 37231 4150 29 those those DT 37231 4150 30 who who WP 37231 4150 31 are be VBP 37231 4150 32 addressing address VBG 37231 4150 33 James James NNP 37231 4150 34 , , , 37231 4150 35 can can MD 37231 4150 36 not not RB 37231 4150 37 for for IN 37231 4150 38 a a DT 37231 4150 39 moment moment NN 37231 4150 40 be be VB 37231 4150 41 accepted accept VBN 37231 4150 42 as as IN 37231 4150 43 evidence evidence NN 37231 4150 44 of of IN 37231 4150 45 a a DT 37231 4150 46 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 4150 47 of of IN 37231 4150 48 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4150 49 . . . 37231 4151 1 The the DT 37231 4151 2 episode episode NN 37231 4151 3 of of IN 37231 4151 4 the the DT 37231 4151 5 tribute tribute NN 37231 4151 6 money money NN 37231 4151 7 is be VBZ 37231 4151 8 generally generally RB 37231 4151 9 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4151 10 to to IN 37231 4151 11 the the DT 37231 4151 12 oldest old JJS 37231 4151 13 form form NN 37231 4151 14 of of IN 37231 4151 15 the the DT 37231 4151 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4151 17 history history NN 37231 4151 18 , , , 37231 4151 19 and and CC 37231 4151 20 although although IN 37231 4151 21 the the DT 37231 4151 22 other other JJ 37231 4151 23 two two CD 37231 4151 24 Synoptics(4 synoptics(4 NN 37231 4151 25 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4151 26 read read VB 37231 4151 27 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4151 28 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4151 29 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4151 30 for for IN 37231 4151 31 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4151 32 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4151 33 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4151 34 , , , 37231 4151 35 there there EX 37231 4151 36 is be VBZ 37231 4151 37 { { -LRB- 37231 4151 38 438 438 CD 37231 4151 39 } } -RRB- 37231 4151 40 no no DT 37231 4151 41 ground ground NN 37231 4151 42 for for IN 37231 4151 43 asserting assert VBG 37231 4151 44 that that IN 37231 4151 45 some some DT 37231 4151 46 of of IN 37231 4151 47 the the DT 37231 4151 48 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4151 49 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4151 50 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4151 51 who who WP 37231 4151 52 preceded precede VBD 37231 4151 53 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4151 54 did do VBD 37231 4151 55 not not RB 37231 4151 56 use use VB 37231 4151 57 the the DT 37231 4151 58 latter latter JJ 37231 4151 59 form form NN 37231 4151 60 , , , 37231 4151 61 and and CC 37231 4151 62 as as RB 37231 4151 63 little little JJ 37231 4151 64 for for IN 37231 4151 65 asserting assert VBG 37231 4151 66 that that IN 37231 4151 67 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4151 68 did do VBD 37231 4151 69 not not RB 37231 4151 70 so so RB 37231 4151 71 stand stand VB 37231 4151 72 , , , 37231 4151 73 for for IN 37231 4151 74 instance instance NN 37231 4151 75 , , , 37231 4151 76 in in IN 37231 4151 77 the the DT 37231 4151 78 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4151 79 according accord VBG 37231 4151 80 to to IN 37231 4151 81 the the DT 37231 4151 82 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4151 83 . . . 37231 4152 1 The the DT 37231 4152 2 employment employment NN 37231 4152 3 of of IN 37231 4152 4 the the DT 37231 4152 5 same same JJ 37231 4152 6 expression expression NN 37231 4152 7 in in IN 37231 4152 8 the the DT 37231 4152 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 4152 10 , , , 37231 4152 11 moreover moreover RB 37231 4152 12 , , , 37231 4152 13 at at IN 37231 4152 14 once once RB 37231 4152 15 deprives deprive VBZ 37231 4152 16 the the DT 37231 4152 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4152 18 of of IN 37231 4152 19 any any DT 37231 4152 20 individuality individuality NN 37231 4152 21 in in IN 37231 4152 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4152 23 use use NN 37231 4152 24 . . . 37231 4153 1 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4153 2 represents represent VBZ 37231 4153 3 the the DT 37231 4153 4 dying die VBG 37231 4153 5 James James NNP 37231 4153 6 as as IN 37231 4153 7 kneeling kneel VBG 37231 4153 8 down down RP 37231 4153 9 and and CC 37231 4153 10 praying pray VBG 37231 4153 11 for for IN 37231 4153 12 those those DT 37231 4153 13 who who WP 37231 4153 14 were be VBD 37231 4153 15 stoning stone VBG 37231 4153 16 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4153 17 : : : 37231 4153 18 " " `` 37231 4153 19 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4153 20 beseech beseech VBP 37231 4153 21 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4153 22 thee thee NN 37231 4153 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4153 24 , , , 37231 4153 25 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4153 26 God God NNP 37231 4153 27 Father Father NNP 37231 4153 28 , , , 37231 4153 29 forgive forgive VB 37231 4153 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4153 31 , , , 37231 4153 32 for for IN 37231 4153 33 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4153 34 know know VBP 37231 4153 35 not not RB 37231 4153 36 what what WP 37231 4153 37 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4153 38 do do VBP 37231 4153 39 " " '' 37231 4153 40 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4153 41 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4153 42 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4153 43 . . . 37231 4154 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4154 2 1 1 LS 37231 4154 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4154 4 This this DT 37231 4154 5 is be VBZ 37231 4154 6 compared compare VBN 37231 4154 7 with with IN 37231 4154 8 the the DT 37231 4154 9 prayer prayer NN 37231 4154 10 which which WDT 37231 4154 11 Luke(2 Luke(2 NNP 37231 4154 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4154 13 puts put VBZ 37231 4154 14 into into IN 37231 4154 15 the the DT 37231 4154 16 mouth mouth NN 37231 4154 17 of of IN 37231 4154 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4154 19 on on IN 37231 4154 20 the the DT 37231 4154 21 cross cross NN 37231 4154 22 : : : 37231 4154 23 " " `` 37231 4154 24 Father Father NNP 37231 4154 25 , , , 37231 4154 26 forgive forgive VB 37231 4154 27 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4154 28 , , , 37231 4154 29 for for IN 37231 4154 30 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4154 31 know know VBP 37231 4154 32 not not RB 37231 4154 33 what what WP 37231 4154 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4154 35 do do VBP 37231 4154 36 " " '' 37231 4154 37 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4154 38 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4154 39 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4154 40 , , , 37231 4154 41 and and CC 37231 4154 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4154 43 is be VBZ 37231 4154 44 assumed assume VBN 37231 4154 45 from from IN 37231 4154 46 this this DT 37231 4154 47 partial partial JJ 37231 4154 48 coincidence coincidence NN 37231 4154 49 that that IN 37231 4154 50 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4154 51 was be VBD 37231 4154 52 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4154 53 with with IN 37231 4154 54 the the DT 37231 4154 55 third third JJ 37231 4154 56 of of IN 37231 4154 57 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4154 58 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4154 59 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4154 60 . . . 37231 4155 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4155 2 are be VBP 37231 4155 3 surprised surprised JJ 37231 4155 4 to to TO 37231 4155 5 see see VB 37231 4155 6 an an DT 37231 4155 7 able able JJ 37231 4155 8 and and CC 37231 4155 9 accomplished accomplished JJ 37231 4155 10 critic critic NN 37231 4155 11 like like IN 37231 4155 12 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 37231 4155 13 adopting adopt VBG 37231 4155 14 such such PDT 37231 4155 15 a a DT 37231 4155 16 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4155 17 without without IN 37231 4155 18 either either DT 37231 4155 19 examination examination NN 37231 4155 20 or or CC 37231 4155 21 argument argument NN 37231 4155 22 of of IN 37231 4155 23 any any DT 37231 4155 24 kind kind NN 37231 4155 25 . . . 37231 4156 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4156 2 3 3 LS 37231 4156 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4156 4 Such such PDT 37231 4156 5 a a DT 37231 4156 6 deduction deduction NN 37231 4156 7 is be VBZ 37231 4156 8 totally totally RB 37231 4156 9 unwarranted unwarranted JJ 37231 4156 10 by by IN 37231 4156 11 the the DT 37231 4156 12 facts fact NNS 37231 4156 13 of of IN 37231 4156 14 the the DT 37231 4156 15 case case NN 37231 4156 16 , , , 37231 4156 17 and and CC 37231 4156 18 if if IN 37231 4156 19 the the DT 37231 4156 20 partial partial JJ 37231 4156 21 agreement agreement NN 37231 4156 22 of of IN 37231 4156 23 a a DT 37231 4156 24 passage passage NN 37231 4156 25 in in IN 37231 4156 26 such such PDT 37231 4156 27 a a DT 37231 4156 28 Father Father NNP 37231 4156 29 with with IN 37231 4156 30 a a DT 37231 4156 31 historical historical JJ 37231 4156 32 expression expression NN 37231 4156 33 in in IN 37231 4156 34 a a DT 37231 4156 35 Gospel gospel NN 37231 4156 36 which which WDT 37231 4156 37 , , , 37231 4156 38 alone alone RB 37231 4156 39 out out IN 37231 4156 40 of of IN 37231 4156 41 many many JJ 37231 4156 42 previously previously JJ 37231 4156 43 existent existent NN 37231 4156 44 , , , 37231 4156 45 has have VBZ 37231 4156 46 come come VBN 37231 4156 47 down down RP 37231 4156 48 to to IN 37231 4156 49 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4156 50 can can MD 37231 4156 51 be be VB 37231 4156 52 considered consider VBN 37231 4156 53 evidence evidence NN 37231 4156 54 of of IN 37231 4156 55 the the DT 37231 4156 56 acquaintance acquaintance NN 37231 4156 57 of of IN 37231 4156 58 the the DT 37231 4156 59 Father Father NNP 37231 4156 60 with with IN 37231 4156 61 that that DT 37231 4156 62 particular particular JJ 37231 4156 63 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4156 64 , , , 37231 4156 65 the the DT 37231 4156 66 function function NN 37231 4156 67 of of IN 37231 4156 68 criticism criticism NN 37231 4156 69 is be VBZ 37231 4156 70 at at IN 37231 4156 71 an an DT 37231 4156 72 end end NN 37231 4156 73 . . . 37231 4157 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4157 2 may may MD 37231 4157 3 here here RB 37231 4157 4 be be VB 37231 4157 5 observed observe VBN 37231 4157 6 that that IN 37231 4157 7 the the DT 37231 4157 8 above above JJ 37231 4157 9 passage passage NN 37231 4157 10 of of IN 37231 4157 11 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4157 12 xxiii xxiii NN 37231 4157 13 . . . 37231 4158 1 34 34 CD 37231 4158 2 is be VBZ 37231 4158 3 omitted omit VBN 37231 4158 4 altogether altogether RB 37231 4158 5 from from IN 37231 4158 6 the the DT 37231 4158 7 Vatican Vatican NNP 37231 4158 8 MS MS NNP 37231 4158 9 . . NNP 37231 4158 10 and and CC 37231 4158 11 Codex Codex NNP 37231 4158 12 D D NNP 37231 4158 13 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4158 14 Bezse Bezse NNP 37231 4158 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4158 16 , , , 37231 4158 17 and and CC 37231 4158 18 in in IN 37231 4158 19 the the DT 37231 4158 20 Codex Codex NNP 37231 4158 21 Sinaiticus Sinaiticus NNP 37231 4158 22 { { -LRB- 37231 4158 23 439 439 CD 37231 4158 24 } } -RRB- 37231 4158 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4158 26 position position NN 37231 4158 27 is be VBZ 37231 4158 28 of of IN 37231 4158 29 a a DT 37231 4158 30 very very RB 37231 4158 31 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 4158 32 character character NN 37231 4158 33 . . . 37231 4159 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4159 2 1 1 LS 37231 4159 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4159 4 The the DT 37231 4159 5 Codex Codex NNP 37231 4159 6 Alexandrinus Alexandrinus NNP 37231 4159 7 which which WDT 37231 4159 8 contains contain VBZ 37231 4159 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4159 10 omits omit VBZ 37231 4159 11 the the DT 37231 4159 12 word word NN 37231 4159 13 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4159 14 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4159 15 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4159 16 . . . 37231 4160 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4160 2 2 2 LS 37231 4160 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4160 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4160 5 's 's POS 37231 4160 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4160 7 was be VBD 37231 4160 8 avowedly avowedly RB 37231 4160 9 composed compose VBN 37231 4160 10 after after IN 37231 4160 11 many many JJ 37231 4160 12 other other JJ 37231 4160 13 similar similar JJ 37231 4160 14 works work NNS 37231 4160 15 were be VBD 37231 4160 16 already already RB 37231 4160 17 in in IN 37231 4160 18 existence existence NN 37231 4160 19 , , , 37231 4160 20 and and CC 37231 4160 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4160 22 know know VBP 37231 4160 23 from from IN 37231 4160 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4160 25 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 4160 26 how how WRB 37231 4160 27 closely closely RB 37231 4160 28 such such JJ 37231 4160 29 writings writing NNS 37231 4160 30 often often RB 37231 4160 31 followed follow VBD 37231 4160 32 each each DT 37231 4160 33 other other JJ 37231 4160 34 , , , 37231 4160 35 and and CC 37231 4160 36 drew draw VBD 37231 4160 37 from from IN 37231 4160 38 the the DT 37231 4160 39 same same JJ 37231 4160 40 sources source NNS 37231 4160 41 . . . 37231 4161 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4161 2 3 3 LS 37231 4161 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4161 4 If if IN 37231 4161 5 any any DT 37231 4161 6 historical historical JJ 37231 4161 7 character character NN 37231 4161 8 is be VBZ 37231 4161 9 conceded concede VBN 37231 4161 10 to to IN 37231 4161 11 this this DT 37231 4161 12 prayer prayer NN 37231 4161 13 of of IN 37231 4161 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4161 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4161 16 is be VBZ 37231 4161 17 natural natural JJ 37231 4161 18 to to TO 37231 4161 19 suppose suppose VB 37231 4161 20 that that IN 37231 4161 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4161 22 must must MD 37231 4161 23 have have VB 37231 4161 24 been be VBN 37231 4161 25 given give VBN 37231 4161 26 in in RP 37231 4161 27 at at IN 37231 4161 28 least least JJS 37231 4161 29 some some DT 37231 4161 30 of of IN 37231 4161 31 these these DT 37231 4161 32 numerous numerous JJ 37231 4161 33 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 4161 34 which which WDT 37231 4161 35 have have VBP 37231 4161 36 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37231 4161 37 perished perish VBN 37231 4161 38 . . . 37231 4162 1 No no DT 37231 4162 2 one one PRP 37231 4162 3 could could MD 37231 4162 4 reasonably reasonably RB 37231 4162 5 assert assert VB 37231 4162 6 that that IN 37231 4162 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4162 8 third third JJ 37231 4162 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4162 10 is be VBZ 37231 4162 11 the the DT 37231 4162 12 only only JJ 37231 4162 13 one one CD 37231 4162 14 which which WDT 37231 4162 15 ever ever RB 37231 4162 16 contained contain VBD 37231 4162 17 the the DT 37231 4162 18 passage passage NN 37231 4162 19 . . . 37231 4163 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4163 2 would would MD 37231 4163 3 be be VB 37231 4163 4 preposterous preposterous JJ 37231 4163 5 to to TO 37231 4163 6 affirm affirm VB 37231 4163 7 , , , 37231 4163 8 for for IN 37231 4163 9 instance instance NN 37231 4163 10 , , , 37231 4163 11 that that IN 37231 4163 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4163 13 did do VBD 37231 4163 14 not not RB 37231 4163 15 exist exist VB 37231 4163 16 in in IN 37231 4163 17 the the DT 37231 4163 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4163 19 according accord VBG 37231 4163 20 to to IN 37231 4163 21 the the DT 37231 4163 22 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4163 23 , , , 37231 4163 24 which which WDT 37231 4163 25 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4163 26 employed employ VBD 37231 4163 27 . . . 37231 4164 1 On on IN 37231 4164 2 the the DT 37231 4164 3 supposition supposition NN 37231 4164 4 that that IN 37231 4164 5 the the DT 37231 4164 6 passage passage NN 37231 4164 7 is be VBZ 37231 4164 8 historical historical JJ 37231 4164 9 , , , 37231 4164 10 which which WDT 37231 4164 11 apologists apologist VBZ 37231 4164 12 at at IN 37231 4164 13 least least JJS 37231 4164 14 will will MD 37231 4164 15 not not RB 37231 4164 16 dispute dispute VB 37231 4164 17 , , , 37231 4164 18 what what WP 37231 4164 19 could could MD 37231 4164 20 be be VB 37231 4164 21 more more RBR 37231 4164 22 natural natural JJ 37231 4164 23 or or CC 37231 4164 24 probable probable JJ 37231 4164 25 than than IN 37231 4164 26 that that DT 37231 4164 27 such such PDT 37231 4164 28 a a DT 37231 4164 29 prayer prayer NN 37231 4164 30 , , , 37231 4164 31 " " '' 37231 4164 32 emanating emanate VBG 37231 4164 33 from from IN 37231 4164 34 the the DT 37231 4164 35 innermost innermost JJS 37231 4164 36 soul soul NN 37231 4164 37 of of IN 37231 4164 38 Jesus,"(4 Jesus,"(4 NNP 37231 4164 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4164 40 should should MD 37231 4164 41 have have VB 37231 4164 42 been be VBN 37231 4164 43 adopted adopt VBN 37231 4164 44 under under IN 37231 4164 45 similar similar JJ 37231 4164 46 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 4164 47 by by IN 37231 4164 48 James James NNP 37231 4164 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4164 50 brother brother NN 37231 4164 51 and and CC 37231 4164 52 successor successor NN 37231 4164 53 , , , 37231 4164 54 who who WP 37231 4164 55 certainly certainly RB 37231 4164 56 could could MD 37231 4164 57 not not RB 37231 4164 58 have have VB 37231 4164 59 derived derive VBN 37231 4164 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4164 61 from from IN 37231 4164 62 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4164 63 . . . 37231 4165 1 The the DT 37231 4165 2 tradition tradition NN 37231 4165 3 of of IN 37231 4165 4 such such JJ 37231 4165 5 words word NNS 37231 4165 6 , , , 37231 4165 7 expressing express VBG 37231 4165 8 so so RB 37231 4165 9 much much JJ 37231 4165 10 of of IN 37231 4165 11 the the DT 37231 4165 12 original original JJ 37231 4165 13 spirit spirit NN 37231 4165 14 of of IN 37231 4165 15 Christianity Christianity NNP 37231 4165 16 , , , 37231 4165 17 setting set VBG 37231 4165 18 aside aside RB 37231 4165 19 for for IN 37231 4165 20 the the DT 37231 4165 21 moment moment NN 37231 4165 22 written write VBN 37231 4165 23 { { -LRB- 37231 4165 24 440 440 CD 37231 4165 25 } } -RRB- 37231 4165 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4165 27 , , , 37231 4165 28 could could MD 37231 4165 29 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 4165 30 fail fail VB 37231 4165 31 to to TO 37231 4165 32 have have VB 37231 4165 33 remained remain VBN 37231 4165 34 fresh fresh JJ 37231 4165 35 in in IN 37231 4165 36 the the DT 37231 4165 37 mind mind NN 37231 4165 38 of of IN 37231 4165 39 the the DT 37231 4165 40 early early JJ 37231 4165 41 Church Church NNP 37231 4165 42 , , , 37231 4165 43 and and CC 37231 4165 44 more more RBR 37231 4165 45 especially especially RB 37231 4165 46 in in IN 37231 4165 47 the the DT 37231 4165 48 primitive primitive JJ 37231 4165 49 community community NN 37231 4165 50 amongst amongst IN 37231 4165 51 whom whom WP 37231 4165 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4165 53 were be VBD 37231 4165 54 uttered uttered JJ 37231 4165 55 , , , 37231 4165 56 and and CC 37231 4165 57 of of IN 37231 4165 58 which which WDT 37231 4165 59 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4165 60 was be VBD 37231 4165 61 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4165 62 a a DT 37231 4165 63 later later JJ 37231 4165 64 member member NN 37231 4165 65 ; ; : 37231 4165 66 and and CC 37231 4165 67 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4165 68 would would MD 37231 4165 69 certainly certainly RB 37231 4165 70 have have VB 37231 4165 71 been be VBN 37231 4165 72 treasured treasure VBN 37231 4165 73 by by IN 37231 4165 74 one one CD 37231 4165 75 who who WP 37231 4165 76 was be VBD 37231 4165 77 so so RB 37231 4165 78 careful careful JJ 37231 4165 79 a a DT 37231 4165 80 collector collector NN 37231 4165 81 and and CC 37231 4165 82 transmitter transmitter NN 37231 4165 83 of of IN 37231 4165 84 " " `` 37231 4165 85 the the DT 37231 4165 86 unerring unerring JJ 37231 4165 87 tradition tradition NN 37231 4165 88 of of IN 37231 4165 89 the the DT 37231 4165 90 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 4165 91 preaching preaching NNP 37231 4165 92 . . . 37231 4165 93 " " '' 37231 4166 1 No no DT 37231 4166 2 saying say VBG 37231 4166 3 is be VBZ 37231 4166 4 more more RBR 37231 4166 5 likely likely JJ 37231 4166 6 to to TO 37231 4166 7 have have VB 37231 4166 8 been be VBN 37231 4166 9 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4166 10 by by IN 37231 4166 11 tradition tradition NN 37231 4166 12 , , , 37231 4166 13 both both CC 37231 4166 14 from from IN 37231 4166 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4166 16 own own JJ 37231 4166 17 character character NN 37231 4166 18 , , , 37231 4166 19 brevity brevity NN 37231 4166 20 , , , 37231 4166 21 and and CC 37231 4166 22 origin origin NN 37231 4166 23 , , , 37231 4166 24 and and CC 37231 4166 25 from from IN 37231 4166 26 the the DT 37231 4166 27 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 4166 28 under under IN 37231 4166 29 which which WDT 37231 4166 30 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4166 31 was be VBD 37231 4166 32 uttered uttered JJ 37231 4166 33 , , , 37231 4166 34 and and CC 37231 4166 35 there there EX 37231 4166 36 can can MD 37231 4166 37 be be VB 37231 4166 38 no no DT 37231 4166 39 reason reason NN 37231 4166 40 for for IN 37231 4166 41 limiting limit VBG 37231 4166 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4166 43 amongst amongst IN 37231 4166 44 written write VBN 37231 4166 45 records record NNS 37231 4166 46 to to IN 37231 4166 47 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4166 48 's 's POS 37231 4166 49 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4166 50 . . . 37231 4167 1 The the DT 37231 4167 2 omission omission NN 37231 4167 3 of of IN 37231 4167 4 the the DT 37231 4167 5 prayer prayer NN 37231 4167 6 from from IN 37231 4167 7 very very RB 37231 4167 8 important important JJ 37231 4167 9 codices codex NNS 37231 4167 10 of of IN 37231 4167 11 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4167 12 further further RB 37231 4167 13 weakens weaken VBZ 37231 4167 14 the the DT 37231 4167 15 claim claim NN 37231 4167 16 of of IN 37231 4167 17 that that DT 37231 4167 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4167 19 to to IN 37231 4167 20 the the DT 37231 4167 21 passage passage NN 37231 4167 22 . . . 37231 4168 1 Beyond beyond IN 37231 4168 2 these these DT 37231 4168 3 general general JJ 37231 4168 4 considerations consideration NNS 37231 4168 5 , , , 37231 4168 6 however however RB 37231 4168 7 , , , 37231 4168 8 there there EX 37231 4168 9 is be VBZ 37231 4168 10 the the DT 37231 4168 11 important important JJ 37231 4168 12 and and CC 37231 4168 13 undoubted undoubted JJ 37231 4168 14 fact fact NN 37231 4168 15 that that IN 37231 4168 16 the the DT 37231 4168 17 prayer prayer NN 37231 4168 18 which which WDT 37231 4168 19 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4168 20 represents represent VBZ 37231 4168 21 James James NNP 37231 4168 22 as as IN 37231 4168 23 uttering uttering NN 37231 4168 24 does do VBZ 37231 4168 25 not not RB 37231 4168 26 actually actually RB 37231 4168 27 agree agree VB 37231 4168 28 with with IN 37231 4168 29 the the DT 37231 4168 30 prayer prayer NN 37231 4168 31 of of IN 37231 4168 32 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4168 33 in in IN 37231 4168 34 the the DT 37231 4168 35 third third JJ 37231 4168 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4168 37 . . . 37231 4169 1 So so RB 37231 4169 2 far far RB 37231 4169 3 from from IN 37231 4169 4 proving prove VBG 37231 4169 5 the the DT 37231 4169 6 use use NN 37231 4169 7 of of IN 37231 4169 8 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4169 9 , , , 37231 4169 10 therefore therefore RB 37231 4169 11 , , , 37231 4169 12 this this DT 37231 4169 13 merely merely RB 37231 4169 14 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 37231 4169 15 and and CC 37231 4169 16 partial partial JJ 37231 4169 17 agreement agreement NN 37231 4169 18 , , , 37231 4169 19 on on IN 37231 4169 20 the the DT 37231 4169 21 contrary contrary NN 37231 4169 22 , , , 37231 4169 23 rather rather RB 37231 4169 24 proves prove VBZ 37231 4169 25 that that IN 37231 4169 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4169 27 did do VBD 37231 4169 28 not not RB 37231 4169 29 know know VB 37231 4169 30 that that IN 37231 4169 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4169 32 , , , 37231 4169 33 for for IN 37231 4169 34 on on IN 37231 4169 35 the the DT 37231 4169 36 supposition supposition NN 37231 4169 37 of of IN 37231 4169 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4169 39 making make VBG 37231 4169 40 use use NN 37231 4169 41 of of IN 37231 4169 42 the the DT 37231 4169 43 third third JJ 37231 4169 44 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 4169 45 at at RB 37231 4169 46 all all RB 37231 4169 47 for for IN 37231 4169 48 such such PDT 37231 4169 49 a a DT 37231 4169 50 purpose purpose NN 37231 4169 51 , , , 37231 4169 52 and and CC 37231 4169 53 not not RB 37231 4169 54 simply simply RB 37231 4169 55 giving give VBG 37231 4169 56 the the DT 37231 4169 57 prayer prayer NN 37231 4169 58 which which WDT 37231 4169 59 James James NNP 37231 4169 60 may may MD 37231 4169 61 in in IN 37231 4169 62 reality reality NN 37231 4169 63 have have VBP 37231 4169 64 uttered utter VBN 37231 4169 65 , , , 37231 4169 66 why why WRB 37231 4169 67 did do VBD 37231 4169 68 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4169 69 not not RB 37231 4169 70 quote quote VB 37231 4169 71 the the DT 37231 4169 72 prayer prayer NN 37231 4169 73 as as IN 37231 4169 74 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4169 75 actually actually RB 37231 4169 76 found find VBD 37231 4169 77 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4169 78 in in IN 37231 4169 79 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4169 80 ? ? . 37231 4170 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4170 2 have have VBP 37231 4170 3 still still RB 37231 4170 4 to to TO 37231 4170 5 consider consider VB 37231 4170 6 a a DT 37231 4170 7 fragment fragment NN 37231 4170 8 of of IN 37231 4170 9 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4170 10 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4170 11 to to IN 37231 4170 12 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4170 13 by by IN 37231 4170 14 Stephanus Stephanus NNP 37231 4170 15 Gobarus Gobarus NNP 37231 4170 16 , , , 37231 4170 17 a a DT 37231 4170 18 learned learn VBN 37231 4170 19 monophysite monophysite NN 37231 4170 20 of of IN 37231 4170 21 the the DT 37231 4170 22 sixth sixth JJ 37231 4170 23 century century NN 37231 4170 24 , , , 37231 4170 25 which which WDT 37231 4170 26 reads read VBZ 37231 4170 27 as as IN 37231 4170 28 follows follow VBZ 37231 4170 29 : : : 37231 4170 30 " " `` 37231 4170 31 That that IN 37231 4170 32 the the DT 37231 4170 33 good good JJ 37231 4170 34 things thing NNS 37231 4170 35 prepared prepare VBN 37231 4170 36 for for IN 37231 4170 37 the the DT 37231 4170 38 righteous righteous JJ 37231 4170 39 neither neither CC 37231 4170 40 eye eye NN 37231 4170 41 saw see VBD 37231 4170 42 , , , 37231 4170 43 nor nor CC 37231 4170 44 ear ear NN 37231 4170 45 heard hear VBD 37231 4170 46 , , , 37231 4170 47 nor nor CC 37231 4170 48 entered enter VBD 37231 4170 49 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4170 50 into into IN 37231 4170 51 the the DT 37231 4170 52 heart heart NN 37231 4170 53 of of IN 37231 4170 54 man man NN 37231 4170 55 . . . 37231 4171 1 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4171 2 , , , 37231 4171 3 however however RB 37231 4171 4 , , , 37231 4171 5 an an DT 37231 4171 6 ancient ancient JJ 37231 4171 7 and and CC 37231 4171 8 apostolic apostolic JJ 37231 4171 9 man man NN 37231 4171 10 , , , 37231 4171 11 how how WRB 37231 4171 12 moved move VBD 37231 4171 13 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4171 14 know know VBP 37231 4171 15 not not RB 37231 4171 16 , , , 37231 4171 17 says say VBZ 37231 4171 18 in in IN 37231 4171 19 the the DT 37231 4171 20 fifth fifth JJ 37231 4171 21 book book NN 37231 4171 22 of of IN 37231 4171 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4171 24 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 37231 4171 25 that that IN 37231 4171 26 these these DT 37231 4171 27 words word NNS 37231 4171 28 are be VBP 37231 4171 29 vainly vainly RB 37231 4171 30 { { -LRB- 37231 4171 31 441 441 CD 37231 4171 32 } } -RRB- 37231 4171 33 spoken speak VBN 37231 4171 34 , , , 37231 4171 35 and and CC 37231 4171 36 that that IN 37231 4171 37 those those DT 37231 4171 38 who who WP 37231 4171 39 say say VBP 37231 4171 40 these these DT 37231 4171 41 things thing NNS 37231 4171 42 give give VBP 37231 4171 43 the the DT 37231 4171 44 lie lie NN 37231 4171 45 to to IN 37231 4171 46 the the DT 37231 4171 47 divine divine JJ 37231 4171 48 writings writing NNS 37231 4171 49 and and CC 37231 4171 50 to to IN 37231 4171 51 the the DT 37231 4171 52 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4171 53 saying say VBG 37231 4171 54 : : : 37231 4171 55 ' ' `` 37231 4171 56 Blessed Blessed NNP 37231 4171 57 are be VBP 37231 4171 58 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4171 59 eyes eye NNS 37231 4171 60 that that WDT 37231 4171 61 see see VBP 37231 4171 62 , , , 37231 4171 63 and and CC 37231 4171 64 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4171 65 cars car NNS 37231 4171 66 that that WDT 37231 4171 67 hear hear VBP 37231 4171 68 , , , 37231 4171 69 ' ' '' 37231 4171 70 " " '' 37231 4171 71 & & CC 37231 4171 72 c. c. NNP 37231 4172 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4172 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4172 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4172 4 . . . 37231 4173 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4173 2 1 1 LS 37231 4173 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4173 4 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4173 5 believe believe VBP 37231 4173 6 that that IN 37231 4173 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4173 8 have have VBP 37231 4173 9 here here RB 37231 4173 10 an an DT 37231 4173 11 expression expression NN 37231 4173 12 of of IN 37231 4173 13 the the DT 37231 4173 14 strong strong JJ 37231 4173 15 prejudice prejudice NN 37231 4173 16 against against IN 37231 4173 17 the the DT 37231 4173 18 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4173 19 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4173 20 and and CC 37231 4173 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4173 22 teaching teaching NN 37231 4173 23 which which WDT 37231 4173 24 continued continue VBD 37231 4173 25 for for IN 37231 4173 26 so so RB 37231 4173 27 long long RB 37231 4173 28 to to TO 37231 4173 29 prevail prevail VB 37231 4173 30 amongst amongst IN 37231 4173 31 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4173 32 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 4173 33 , , , 37231 4173 34 and and CC 37231 4173 35 which which WDT 37231 4173 36 is be VBZ 37231 4173 37 apparent apparent JJ 37231 4173 38 in in IN 37231 4173 39 many many JJ 37231 4173 40 writings writing NNS 37231 4173 41 of of IN 37231 4173 42 that that DT 37231 4173 43 period period NN 37231 4173 44 . . . 37231 4174 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4174 2 2 2 LS 37231 4174 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4174 4 The the DT 37231 4174 5 quotation quotation NN 37231 4174 6 of of IN 37231 4174 7 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4174 8 , , , 37231 4174 9 1 1 CD 37231 4174 10 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 37231 4174 11 ii ii CD 37231 4174 12 . . . 37231 4175 1 9 9 CD 37231 4175 2 , , , 37231 4175 3 differs differ VBZ 37231 4175 4 materially materially RB 37231 4175 5 from from IN 37231 4175 6 the the DT 37231 4175 7 Septuagint Septuagint NNP 37231 4175 8 version version NN 37231 4175 9 of of IN 37231 4175 10 the the DT 37231 4175 11 passage passage NN 37231 4175 12 in in IN 37231 4175 13 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 37231 4175 14 lxiv lxiv NN 37231 4175 15 . . . 37231 4176 1 4 4 LS 37231 4176 2 , , , 37231 4176 3 and and CC 37231 4176 4 , , , 37231 4176 5 as as IN 37231 4176 6 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4176 7 have have VBP 37231 4176 8 seen see VBN 37231 4176 9 , , , 37231 4176 10 the the DT 37231 4176 11 same same JJ 37231 4176 12 passage passage NN 37231 4176 13 quoted quote VBN 37231 4176 14 by by IN 37231 4176 15 " " `` 37231 4176 16 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4176 17 of of IN 37231 4176 18 Rome,"(3 Rome,"(3 NNP 37231 4176 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4176 20 differs differ VBZ 37231 4176 21 both both DT 37231 4176 22 from from IN 37231 4176 23 the the DT 37231 4176 24 version version NN 37231 4176 25 of of IN 37231 4176 26 the the DT 37231 4176 27 LXX LXX NNP 37231 4176 28 ' ' '' 37231 4176 29 . . . 37231 4177 1 and and CC 37231 4177 2 from from IN 37231 4177 3 the the DT 37231 4177 4 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 4177 5 , , , 37231 4177 6 although although IN 37231 4177 7 closer close JJR 37231 4177 8 to to IN 37231 4177 9 the the DT 37231 4177 10 former former JJ 37231 4177 11 . . . 37231 4178 1 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4178 2 however however RB 37231 4178 3 found find VBD 37231 4178 4 the the DT 37231 4178 5 passage passage NN 37231 4178 6 in in IN 37231 4178 7 the the DT 37231 4178 8 apocryphal apocryphal NN 37231 4178 9 work work NN 37231 4178 10 called call VBN 37231 4178 11 " " `` 37231 4178 12 Ascensio Ascensio NNP 37231 4178 13 Isaiæ,"(4 isaiæ,"(4 NN 37231 4178 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4178 15 and and CC 37231 4178 16 Origen Origen NNP 37231 4178 17 , , , 37231 4178 18 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4178 19 , , , 37231 4178 20 and and CC 37231 4178 21 others other NNS 37231 4178 22 likewise likewise RB 37231 4178 23 ascribe ascribe VBP 37231 4178 24 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4178 25 to to IN 37231 4178 26 the the DT 37231 4178 27 " " `` 37231 4178 28 Apocalypsis Apocalypsis NNP 37231 4178 29 Eliæ Eliæ NNP 37231 4178 30 . . . 37231 4179 1 " " `` 37231 4179 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4179 3 5 5 LS 37231 4179 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4179 5 This this DT 37231 4179 6 , , , 37231 4179 7 however however RB 37231 4179 8 , , , 37231 4179 9 does do VBZ 37231 4179 10 not not RB 37231 4179 11 concern concern VB 37231 4179 12 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4179 13 here here RB 37231 4179 14 , , , 37231 4179 15 and and CC 37231 4179 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4179 17 have have VBP 37231 4179 18 merely merely RB 37231 4179 19 to to TO 37231 4179 20 examine examine VB 37231 4179 21 the the DT 37231 4179 22 " " `` 37231 4179 23 saying say VBG 37231 4179 24 of of IN 37231 4179 25 the the DT 37231 4179 26 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4179 27 , , , 37231 4179 28 " " '' 37231 4179 29 which which WDT 37231 4179 30 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4179 31 opposes oppose VBZ 37231 4179 32 to to IN 37231 4179 33 the the DT 37231 4179 34 passage passage NN 37231 4179 35 : : : 37231 4179 36 " " `` 37231 4179 37 Blessed bless VBN 37231 4179 38 are be VBP 37231 4179 39 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4179 40 eyes eye NNS 37231 4179 41 that that WDT 37231 4179 42 see see VBP 37231 4179 43 and and CC 37231 4179 44 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4179 45 ears ear NNS 37231 4179 46 that that WDT 37231 4179 47 hear hear VBP 37231 4179 48 . . . 37231 4179 49 " " '' 37231 4180 1 This this DT 37231 4180 2 is be VBZ 37231 4180 3 compared compare VBN 37231 4180 4 with with IN 37231 4180 5 Matt Matt NNP 37231 4180 6 . . . 37231 4181 1 xiii xiii NNP 37231 4181 2 . . . 37231 4182 1 16 16 CD 37231 4182 2 , , , 37231 4182 3 " " `` 37231 4182 4 But but CC 37231 4182 5 blessed bless VBN 37231 4182 6 are be VBP 37231 4182 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4182 8 eyes eye NNS 37231 4182 9 , , , 37231 4182 10 for for IN 37231 4182 11 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4182 12 see see VBP 37231 4182 13 , , , 37231 4182 14 and and CC 37231 4182 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4182 16 ears ear NNS 37231 4182 17 , , , 37231 4182 18 for for IN 37231 4182 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4182 20 hear hear VBP 37231 4182 21 " " '' 37231 4182 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4182 23 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4182 24 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4182 25 , , , 37231 4182 26 and and CC 37231 4182 27 also also RB 37231 4182 28 with with IN 37231 4182 29 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4182 30 x. x. NNP 37231 4183 1 23 23 CD 37231 4183 2 , , , 37231 4183 3 " " `` 37231 4183 4 Blessed bless VBN 37231 4183 5 are be VBP 37231 4183 6 the the DT 37231 4183 7 eyes eye NNS 37231 4183 8 which which WDT 37231 4183 9 see see VBP 37231 4183 10 the the DT 37231 4183 11 things thing NNS 37231 4183 12 that that WDT 37231 4183 13 ye ye NNP 37231 4183 14 see see VBP 37231 4183 15 , , , 37231 4183 16 " " '' 37231 4183 17 & & CC 37231 4183 18 c. c. NNP 37231 4183 19 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4183 20 need need VBP 37231 4183 21 not not RB 37231 4183 22 point point VB 37231 4183 23 out out RP 37231 4183 24 that that IN 37231 4183 25 the the DT 37231 4183 26 saying saying NN 37231 4183 27 referred refer VBD 37231 4183 28 to to IN 37231 4183 29 by by IN 37231 4183 30 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4183 31 , , , 37231 4183 32 whilst whilst IN 37231 4183 33 conveying convey VBG 37231 4183 34 the the DT 37231 4183 35 { { -LRB- 37231 4183 36 442 442 CD 37231 4183 37 } } -RRB- 37231 4183 38 same same JJ 37231 4183 39 sense sense NN 37231 4183 40 as as IN 37231 4183 41 that that DT 37231 4183 42 in in IN 37231 4183 43 the the DT 37231 4183 44 two two CD 37231 4183 45 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4183 46 , , , 37231 4183 47 differs differ VBZ 37231 4183 48 as as IN 37231 4183 49 materially materially RB 37231 4183 50 from from IN 37231 4183 51 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4183 52 both both DT 37231 4183 53 as as IN 37231 4183 54 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4183 55 do do VBP 37231 4183 56 from from IN 37231 4183 57 each each DT 37231 4183 58 other other JJ 37231 4183 59 , , , 37231 4183 60 and and CC 37231 4183 61 as as IN 37231 4183 62 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4183 63 might may MD 37231 4183 64 expect expect VB 37231 4183 65 a a DT 37231 4183 66 quotation quotation NN 37231 4183 67 taken take VBN 37231 4183 68 from from IN 37231 4183 69 a a DT 37231 4183 70 different different JJ 37231 4183 71 though though IN 37231 4183 72 kindred kindred JJ 37231 4183 73 source source NN 37231 4183 74 , , , 37231 4183 75 like like IN 37231 4183 76 the the DT 37231 4183 77 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4183 78 according accord VBG 37231 4183 79 to to IN 37231 4183 80 the the DT 37231 4183 81 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4183 82 , , , 37231 4183 83 to to TO 37231 4183 84 do do VB 37231 4183 85 . . . 37231 4184 1 The the DT 37231 4184 2 whole whole NN 37231 4184 3 of of IN 37231 4184 4 the the DT 37231 4184 5 passages passage NNS 37231 4184 6 which which WDT 37231 4184 7 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4184 8 have have VBP 37231 4184 9 examined examine VBN 37231 4184 10 , , , 37231 4184 11 indeed indeed RB 37231 4184 12 , , , 37231 4184 13 exhibit exhibit VB 37231 4184 14 the the DT 37231 4184 15 same same JJ 37231 4184 16 natural natural JJ 37231 4184 17 variation variation NN 37231 4184 18 . . . 37231 4185 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4185 2 have have VBP 37231 4185 3 already already RB 37231 4185 4 referred refer VBN 37231 4185 5 to to IN 37231 4185 6 the the DT 37231 4185 7 expressions expression NNS 37231 4185 8 of of IN 37231 4185 9 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4185 10 regarding regard VBG 37231 4185 11 the the DT 37231 4185 12 heresies heresy NNS 37231 4185 13 in in IN 37231 4185 14 the the DT 37231 4185 15 early early JJ 37231 4185 16 Church church NN 37231 4185 17 : : : 37231 4185 18 " " `` 37231 4185 19 From from IN 37231 4185 20 these these DT 37231 4185 21 sprang spring VBN 37231 4185 22 the the DT 37231 4185 23 false false JJ 37231 4185 24 Christs Christs NNPS 37231 4185 25 , , , 37231 4185 26 and and CC 37231 4185 27 false false JJ 37231 4185 28 prophets prophet NNS 37231 4185 29 , , , 37231 4185 30 and and CC 37231 4185 31 _ _ NNP 37231 4185 32 false false JJ 37231 4185 33 apostles apostle NNS 37231 4185 34 _ _ NNP 37231 4185 35 who who WP 37231 4185 36 divided divide VBD 37231 4185 37 the the DT 37231 4185 38 unity unity NN 37231 4185 39 of of IN 37231 4185 40 the the DT 37231 4185 41 Church Church NNP 37231 4185 42 by by IN 37231 4185 43 corrupting corrupt VBG 37231 4185 44 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 4185 45 concerning concern VBG 37231 4185 46 God God NNP 37231 4185 47 and and CC 37231 4185 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4185 49 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4185 50 . . . 37231 4186 1 " " `` 37231 4186 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4186 3 1 1 LS 37231 4186 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4186 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4186 6 have have VBP 37231 4186 7 shown show VBN 37231 4186 8 how how WRB 37231 4186 9 this this DT 37231 4186 10 recalls recall VBZ 37231 4186 11 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4186 12 in in IN 37231 4186 13 Justin Justin NNP 37231 4186 14 of of IN 37231 4186 15 sayings saying NNS 37231 4186 16 of of IN 37231 4186 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4186 18 foreign foreign JJ 37231 4186 19 to to IN 37231 4186 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4186 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4186 22 , , , 37231 4186 23 in in IN 37231 4186 24 common common JJ 37231 4186 25 with with IN 37231 4186 26 similar similar JJ 37231 4186 27 expressions expression NNS 37231 4186 28 in in IN 37231 4186 29 the the DT 37231 4186 30 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4186 31 Homilies,(2 homilies,(2 NN 37231 4186 32 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4186 33 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4186 34 Constitutions,(3 constitutions,(3 NN 37231 4186 35 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4186 36 and and CC 37231 4186 37 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4186 38 Recognitions,(4 recognitions,(4 NN 37231 4186 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4186 40 and and CC 37231 4186 41 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4186 42 need need VBP 37231 4186 43 not not RB 37231 4186 44 discuss discuss VB 37231 4186 45 the the DT 37231 4186 46 matter matter NN 37231 4186 47 further further RB 37231 4186 48 . . . 37231 4187 1 This this DT 37231 4187 2 community community NN 37231 4187 3 of of IN 37231 4187 4 reference reference NN 37231 4187 5 , , , 37231 4187 6 in in IN 37231 4187 7 a a DT 37231 4187 8 circle circle NN 37231 4187 9 known know VBN 37231 4187 10 to to TO 37231 4187 11 have have VB 37231 4187 12 made make VBN 37231 4187 13 use use NN 37231 4187 14 of of IN 37231 4187 15 the the DT 37231 4187 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4187 17 according accord VBG 37231 4187 18 to to IN 37231 4187 19 the the DT 37231 4187 20 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4187 21 , , , 37231 4187 22 to to IN 37231 4187 23 matters matter NNS 37231 4187 24 foreign foreign JJ 37231 4187 25 to to IN 37231 4187 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4187 27 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 4187 28 , , , 37231 4187 29 furnishes furnish VBZ 37231 4187 30 collateral collateral JJ 37231 4187 31 illustration illustration NN 37231 4187 32 of of IN 37231 4187 33 the the DT 37231 4187 34 influence influence NN 37231 4187 35 of of IN 37231 4187 36 that that DT 37231 4187 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4187 38 . . . 37231 4188 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 4188 2 , , , 37231 4188 3 who who WP 37231 4188 4 so so RB 37231 4188 5 eagerly eagerly RB 37231 4188 6 searches search NNS 37231 4188 7 for for IN 37231 4188 8 every every DT 37231 4188 9 trace trace NN 37231 4188 10 , , , 37231 4188 11 real real JJ 37231 4188 12 or or CC 37231 4188 13 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 4188 14 , , , 37231 4188 15 of of IN 37231 4188 16 the the DT 37231 4188 17 use use NN 37231 4188 18 of of IN 37231 4188 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4188 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4188 21 and and CC 37231 4188 22 of of IN 37231 4188 23 the the DT 37231 4188 24 existence existence NN 37231 4188 25 of of IN 37231 4188 26 a a DT 37231 4188 27 New New NNP 37231 4188 28 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4188 29 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4188 30 , , , 37231 4188 31 passes pass VBZ 37231 4188 32 over over RP 37231 4188 33 in in IN 37231 4188 34 silence silence NN 37231 4188 35 , , , 37231 4188 36 with with IN 37231 4188 37 the the DT 37231 4188 38 exception exception NN 37231 4188 39 of of IN 37231 4188 40 a a DT 37231 4188 41 short short JJ 37231 4188 42 note(5 note(5 NN 37231 4188 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4188 44 devoted devote VBN 37231 4188 45 to to IN 37231 4188 46 the the DT 37231 4188 47 denial denial NN 37231 4188 48 that that IN 37231 4188 49 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4188 50 was be VBD 37231 4188 51 opposed opposed JJ 37231 4188 52 to to IN 37231 4188 53 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4188 54 , , , 37231 4188 55 this this DT 37231 4188 56 first first JJ 37231 4188 57 writer writer NN 37231 4188 58 of of IN 37231 4188 59 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4188 60 Church Church NNP 37231 4188 61 history history NN 37231 4188 62 , , , 37231 4188 63 whose whose WP$ 37231 4188 64 evidence evidence NN 37231 4188 65 , , , 37231 4188 66 could could MD 37231 4188 67 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4188 68 have have VB 37231 4188 69 been be VBN 37231 4188 70 adduced adduce VBN 37231 4188 71 , , , 37231 4188 72 would would MD 37231 4188 73 have have VB 37231 4188 74 been be VBN 37231 4188 75 so so RB 37231 4188 76 valuable valuable JJ 37231 4188 77 . . . 37231 4189 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4189 2 does do VBZ 37231 4189 3 not not RB 37231 4189 4 pretend pretend VB 37231 4189 5 that that IN 37231 4189 6 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4189 7 made make VBD 37231 4189 8 use use NN 37231 4189 9 of of IN 37231 4189 10 the the DT 37231 4189 11 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4189 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4189 13 , , , 37231 4189 14 or or CC 37231 4189 15 knew know VBD 37231 4189 16 of of IN 37231 4189 17 any any DT 37231 4189 18 other other JJ 37231 4189 19 Holy Holy NNP 37231 4189 20 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 37231 4189 21 { { -LRB- 37231 4189 22 443 443 CD 37231 4189 23 } } -RRB- 37231 4189 24 than than IN 37231 4189 25 those those DT 37231 4189 26 of of IN 37231 4189 27 the the DT 37231 4189 28 Old Old NNP 37231 4189 29 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4189 30 , , , 37231 4189 31 but but CC 37231 4189 32 , , , 37231 4189 33 on on IN 37231 4189 34 the the DT 37231 4189 35 other other JJ 37231 4189 36 hand hand NN 37231 4189 37 , , , 37231 4189 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4189 39 does do VBZ 37231 4189 40 not not RB 37231 4189 41 mention mention VB 37231 4189 42 that that IN 37231 4189 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4189 44 possessed possess VBD 37231 4189 45 , , , 37231 4189 46 and and CC 37231 4189 47 quoted quote VBN 37231 4189 48 from from IN 37231 4189 49 , , , 37231 4189 50 the the DT 37231 4189 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4189 52 according accord VBG 37231 4189 53 to to IN 37231 4189 54 the the DT 37231 4189 55 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4189 56 . . . 37231 4190 1 There there EX 37231 4190 2 is be VBZ 37231 4190 3 no no DT 37231 4190 4 reason reason NN 37231 4190 5 for for IN 37231 4190 6 supposing suppose VBG 37231 4190 7 that that IN 37231 4190 8 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4190 9 found find VBD 37231 4190 10 a a DT 37231 4190 11 New New NNP 37231 4190 12 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4190 13 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4190 14 in in IN 37231 4190 15 any any DT 37231 4190 16 of of IN 37231 4190 17 the the DT 37231 4190 18 Christian christian JJ 37231 4190 19 communities community NNS 37231 4190 20 which which WDT 37231 4190 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4190 22 visited visit VBD 37231 4190 23 , , , 37231 4190 24 and and CC 37231 4190 25 such such PDT 37231 4190 26 a a DT 37231 4190 27 rule rule NN 37231 4190 28 of of IN 37231 4190 29 faith faith NN 37231 4190 30 certainly certainly RB 37231 4190 31 did do VBD 37231 4190 32 not not RB 37231 4190 33 yet yet RB 37231 4190 34 exist exist VB 37231 4190 35 in in IN 37231 4190 36 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4190 37 in in IN 37231 4190 38 a.d a.d NNP 37231 4190 39 . . . 37231 4191 1 160 160 CD 37231 4191 2 - - SYM 37231 4191 3 170 170 CD 37231 4191 4 . . . 37231 4192 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4192 2 1 1 LS 37231 4192 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4192 4 There there EX 37231 4192 5 is be VBZ 37231 4192 6 no no DT 37231 4192 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 4192 8 whatever whatever WDT 37231 4192 9 to to TO 37231 4192 10 show show VB 37231 4192 11 that that IN 37231 4192 12 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4192 13 recognized recognize VBD 37231 4192 14 any any DT 37231 4192 15 other other JJ 37231 4192 16 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 4192 17 work work NN 37231 4192 18 than than IN 37231 4192 19 the the DT 37231 4192 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4192 21 according accord VBG 37231 4192 22 to to IN 37231 4192 23 the the DT 37231 4192 24 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4192 25 , , , 37231 4192 26 as as IN 37231 4192 27 the the DT 37231 4192 28 written write VBN 37231 4192 29 source source NN 37231 4192 30 of of IN 37231 4192 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4192 32 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 4192 33 of of IN 37231 4192 34 the the DT 37231 4192 35 words word NNS 37231 4192 36 of of IN 37231 4192 37 the the DT 37231 4192 38 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4192 39 . . . 37231 4193 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4193 2 2 2 LS 37231 4193 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4193 4 2 2 CD 37231 4193 5 . . . 37231 4194 1 The the DT 37231 4194 2 testimony testimony NN 37231 4194 3 of of IN 37231 4194 4 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4194 5 is be VBZ 37231 4194 6 of of IN 37231 4194 7 great great JJ 37231 4194 8 interest interest NN 37231 4194 9 and and CC 37231 4194 10 importance importance NN 37231 4194 11 in in IN 37231 4194 12 connection connection NN 37231 4194 13 with with IN 37231 4194 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4194 15 inquiry inquiry NN 37231 4194 16 , , , 37231 4194 17 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 37231 4194 18 as as IN 37231 4194 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4194 20 is be VBZ 37231 4194 21 the the DT 37231 4194 22 first first JJ 37231 4194 23 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 4194 24 writer writer NN 37231 4194 25 who who WP 37231 4194 26 mentions mention VBZ 37231 4194 27 the the DT 37231 4194 28 tradition tradition NN 37231 4194 29 that that WDT 37231 4194 30 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4194 31 and and CC 37231 4194 32 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4194 33 composed compose VBD 37231 4194 34 written write VBN 37231 4194 35 records record NNS 37231 4194 36 of of IN 37231 4194 37 the the DT 37231 4194 38 life life NN 37231 4194 39 and and CC 37231 4194 40 teaching teaching NN 37231 4194 41 of of IN 37231 4194 42 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4194 43 ; ; : 37231 4194 44 but but CC 37231 4194 45 no no DT 37231 4194 46 question question NN 37231 4194 47 has have VBZ 37231 4194 48 been be VBN 37231 4194 49 more more RBR 37231 4194 50 continuously continuously RB 37231 4194 51 contested contest VBN 37231 4194 52 than than IN 37231 4194 53 that that DT 37231 4194 54 of of IN 37231 4194 55 the the DT 37231 4194 56 identity identity NN 37231 4194 57 of of IN 37231 4194 58 the the DT 37231 4194 59 works work NNS 37231 4194 60 to to TO 37231 4194 61 which which WDT 37231 4194 62 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4194 63 refers refer VBZ 37231 4194 64 with with IN 37231 4194 65 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4194 66 actual actual JJ 37231 4194 67 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4194 68 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4194 69 . . . 37231 4195 1 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4195 2 was be VBD 37231 4195 3 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4195 4 of of IN 37231 4195 5 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 37231 4195 6 , , , 37231 4195 7 in in IN 37231 4195 8 Phrygia,(3 phrygia,(3 NN 37231 4195 9 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4195 10 in in IN 37231 4195 11 the the DT 37231 4195 12 first first JJ 37231 4195 13 half half NN 37231 4195 14 of of IN 37231 4195 15 the the DT 37231 4195 16 second second JJ 37231 4195 17 century century NN 37231 4195 18 , , , 37231 4195 19 and and CC 37231 4195 20 is be VBZ 37231 4195 21 said say VBN 37231 4195 22 to to TO 37231 4195 23 have have VB 37231 4195 24 suffered suffer VBN 37231 4195 25 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 4195 26 under under IN 37231 4195 27 Marcus Marcus NNP 37231 4195 28 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 4195 29 about about IN 37231 4195 30 a.d a.d NNP 37231 4195 31 . . . 37231 4196 1 164 164 CD 37231 4196 2 - - SYM 37231 4196 3 167 167 CD 37231 4196 4 . . . 37231 4197 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4197 2 4 4 LS 37231 4197 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4197 4 About about IN 37231 4197 5 the the DT 37231 4197 6 middle middle NN 37231 4197 7 of of IN 37231 4197 8 the the DT 37231 4197 9 second second JJ 37231 4197 10 century(5)5 century(5)5 . 37231 4197 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4197 12 wrote write VBD 37231 4197 13 a a DT 37231 4197 14 work work NN 37231 4197 15 in in IN 37231 4197 16 five five CD 37231 4197 17 books book NNS 37231 4197 18 , , , 37231 4197 19 entitled entitle VBN 37231 4197 20 { { -LRB- 37231 4197 21 444 444 CD 37231 4197 22 } } -RRB- 37231 4197 23 " " `` 37231 4197 24 Exposition Exposition NNP 37231 4197 25 of of IN 37231 4197 26 the the DT 37231 4197 27 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4197 28 's 's POS 37231 4197 29 Oracles Oracles NNPS 37231 4197 30 " " '' 37231 4197 31 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4197 32 l l NN 37231 4197 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4197 34 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4197 35 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4197 36 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4197 37 , , , 37231 4197 38 which which WDT 37231 4197 39 , , , 37231 4197 40 with with IN 37231 4197 41 the the DT 37231 4197 42 exception exception NN 37231 4197 43 of of IN 37231 4197 44 a a DT 37231 4197 45 few few JJ 37231 4197 46 fragments fragment NNS 37231 4197 47 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4197 48 to to IN 37231 4197 49 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4197 50 chiefly chiefly RB 37231 4197 51 by by IN 37231 4197 52 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4197 53 and and CC 37231 4197 54 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4197 55 , , , 37231 4197 56 is be VBZ 37231 4197 57 unfortunately unfortunately RB 37231 4197 58 , , , 37231 4197 59 no no RB 37231 4197 60 longer long RBR 37231 4197 61 extant extant JJ 37231 4197 62 . . . 37231 4198 1 In in IN 37231 4198 2 the the DT 37231 4198 3 preface preface NN 37231 4198 4 to to IN 37231 4198 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4198 6 book book NN 37231 4198 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4198 8 stated state VBD 37231 4198 9 : : : 37231 4198 10 " " `` 37231 4198 11 But but CC 37231 4198 12 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4198 13 shall shall MD 37231 4198 14 not not RB 37231 4198 15 hesitate hesitate VB 37231 4198 16 also also RB 37231 4198 17 to to TO 37231 4198 18 set set VB 37231 4198 19 beside beside IN 37231 4198 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4198 21 interpretations interpretation NNS 37231 4198 22 all all DT 37231 4198 23 that that WDT 37231 4198 24 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4198 25 rightly rightly RB 37231 4198 26 learnt learn VBD 37231 4198 27 from from IN 37231 4198 28 the the DT 37231 4198 29 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 37231 4198 30 , , , 37231 4198 31 and and CC 37231 4198 32 rightly rightly RB 37231 4198 33 remembered remember VBD 37231 4198 34 , , , 37231 4198 35 earnestly earnestly RB 37231 4198 36 testifying testify VBG 37231 4198 37 to to IN 37231 4198 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4198 39 truth truth NN 37231 4198 40 . . . 37231 4199 1 For for IN 37231 4199 2 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4199 3 was be VBD 37231 4199 4 not not RB 37231 4199 5 , , , 37231 4199 6 like like IN 37231 4199 7 the the DT 37231 4199 8 multitude multitude NNP 37231 4199 9 , , , 37231 4199 10 taking take VBG 37231 4199 11 pleasure pleasure NN 37231 4199 12 in in IN 37231 4199 13 those those DT 37231 4199 14 who who WP 37231 4199 15 speak speak VBP 37231 4199 16 much much RB 37231 4199 17 , , , 37231 4199 18 but but CC 37231 4199 19 in in IN 37231 4199 20 those those DT 37231 4199 21 who who WP 37231 4199 22 teach teach VBP 37231 4199 23 the the DT 37231 4199 24 truth truth NN 37231 4199 25 , , , 37231 4199 26 nor nor CC 37231 4199 27 in in IN 37231 4199 28 those those DT 37231 4199 29 who who WP 37231 4199 30 relate relate VBP 37231 4199 31 alien alien JJ 37231 4199 32 commandments commandment NNS 37231 4199 33 , , , 37231 4199 34 but but CC 37231 4199 35 in in IN 37231 4199 36 those those DT 37231 4199 37 who who WP 37231 4199 38 record record VB 37231 4199 39 those those DT 37231 4199 40 delivered deliver VBN 37231 4199 41 by by IN 37231 4199 42 the the DT 37231 4199 43 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4199 44 to to IN 37231 4199 45 the the DT 37231 4199 46 faith faith NN 37231 4199 47 , , , 37231 4199 48 and and CC 37231 4199 49 which which WDT 37231 4199 50 come come VBP 37231 4199 51 from from IN 37231 4199 52 the the DT 37231 4199 53 truth truth NN 37231 4199 54 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 4199 55 . . . 37231 4200 1 If if IN 37231 4200 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4200 3 happened happen VBD 37231 4200 4 that that IN 37231 4200 5 any any DT 37231 4200 6 one one CD 37231 4200 7 came come VBD 37231 4200 8 who who WP 37231 4200 9 had have VBD 37231 4200 10 followed follow VBN 37231 4200 11 the the DT 37231 4200 12 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 37231 4200 13 , , , 37231 4200 14 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4200 15 inquired inquire VBD 37231 4200 16 minutely minutely RB 37231 4200 17 after after IN 37231 4200 18 the the DT 37231 4200 19 words word NNS 37231 4200 20 of of IN 37231 4200 21 the the DT 37231 4200 22 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 37231 4200 23 , , , 37231 4200 24 what what WP 37231 4200 25 Andrew Andrew NNP 37231 4200 26 or or CC 37231 4200 27 what what WP 37231 4200 28 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4200 29 said say VBD 37231 4200 30 , , , 37231 4200 31 or or CC 37231 4200 32 what what WP 37231 4200 33 Philip Philip NNP 37231 4200 34 or or CC 37231 4200 35 what what WP 37231 4200 36 Thomas Thomas NNP 37231 4200 37 or or CC 37231 4200 38 James James NNP 37231 4200 39 , , , 37231 4200 40 or or CC 37231 4200 41 what what WP 37231 4200 42 John John NNP 37231 4200 43 or or CC 37231 4200 44 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4200 45 , , , 37231 4200 46 or or CC 37231 4200 47 what what WP 37231 4200 48 any any DT 37231 4200 49 other other JJ 37231 4200 50 of of IN 37231 4200 51 the the DT 37231 4200 52 disciples disciple NNS 37231 4200 53 of of IN 37231 4200 54 the the DT 37231 4200 55 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4200 56 , , , 37231 4200 57 and and CC 37231 4200 58 what what WP 37231 4200 59 Aristion Aristion NNP 37231 4200 60 and and CC 37231 4200 61 the the DT 37231 4200 62 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4200 63 John John NNP 37231 4200 64 , , , 37231 4200 65 the the DT 37231 4200 66 disciples disciple NNS 37231 4200 67 of of IN 37231 4200 68 the the DT 37231 4200 69 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4200 70 , , , 37231 4200 71 say say VB 37231 4200 72 , , , 37231 4200 73 for for IN 37231 4200 74 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4200 75 held hold VBD 37231 4200 76 that that IN 37231 4200 77 what what WP 37231 4200 78 was be VBD 37231 4200 79 to to TO 37231 4200 80 be be VB 37231 4200 81 derived derive VBN 37231 4200 82 from from IN 37231 4200 83 books book NNS 37231 4200 84 did do VBD 37231 4200 85 not not RB 37231 4200 86 so so RB 37231 4200 87 profit profit VB 37231 4200 88 me -PRON- PRP 37231 4200 89 as as IN 37231 4200 90 that that DT 37231 4200 91 from from IN 37231 4200 92 the the DT 37231 4200 93 living live VBG 37231 4200 94 and and CC 37231 4200 95 abiding abide VBG 37231 4200 96 voice"(2 voice"(2 NNP 37231 4200 97 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4200 98 . . . 37231 4201 1 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4201 2 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4201 3 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4201 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4201 5 is be VBZ 37231 4201 6 clear clear JJ 37231 4201 7 from from IN 37231 4201 8 this this DT 37231 4201 9 that that IN 37231 4201 10 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4201 11 preferred prefer VBD 37231 4201 12 tradition tradition NN 37231 4201 13 to to IN 37231 4201 14 any any DT 37231 4201 15 written write VBN 37231 4201 16 works work NNS 37231 4201 17 with with IN 37231 4201 18 which which WDT 37231 4201 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4201 20 was be VBD 37231 4201 21 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4201 22 , , , 37231 4201 23 that that IN 37231 4201 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4201 25 attached attach VBD 37231 4201 26 little little JJ 37231 4201 27 or or CC 37231 4201 28 { { -LRB- 37231 4201 29 445 445 CD 37231 4201 30 } } -RRB- 37231 4201 31 no no DT 37231 4201 32 value value NN 37231 4201 33 to to IN 37231 4201 34 any any DT 37231 4201 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4201 36 with with IN 37231 4201 37 which which WDT 37231 4201 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4201 39 had have VBD 37231 4201 40 met,(1 met,(1 CD 37231 4201 41 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4201 42 and and CC 37231 4201 43 that that IN 37231 4201 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4201 45 knew know VBD 37231 4201 46 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 4201 47 nothing nothing NN 37231 4201 48 of of IN 37231 4201 49 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4201 50 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 37231 4201 51 of of IN 37231 4201 52 the the DT 37231 4201 53 New New NNP 37231 4201 54 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4201 55 . . . 37231 4202 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4202 2 2 2 LS 37231 4202 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4202 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4202 5 work work NN 37231 4202 6 was be VBD 37231 4202 7 evidently evidently RB 37231 4202 8 intended intend VBN 37231 4202 9 to to TO 37231 4202 10 furnish furnish VB 37231 4202 11 a a DT 37231 4202 12 collection collection NN 37231 4202 13 of of IN 37231 4202 14 the the DT 37231 4202 15 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4202 16 of of IN 37231 4202 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4202 18 completed complete VBD 37231 4202 19 from from IN 37231 4202 20 oral oral JJ 37231 4202 21 tradition tradition NN 37231 4202 22 , , , 37231 4202 23 with with IN 37231 4202 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4202 25 own own JJ 37231 4202 26 expositions exposition NNS 37231 4202 27 , , , 37231 4202 28 and and CC 37231 4202 29 this this DT 37231 4202 30 is be VBZ 37231 4202 31 plainly plainly RB 37231 4202 32 indicated indicate VBN 37231 4202 33 both both CC 37231 4202 34 by by IN 37231 4202 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4202 36 own own JJ 37231 4202 37 words word NNS 37231 4202 38 , , , 37231 4202 39 and and CC 37231 4202 40 by by IN 37231 4202 41 the the DT 37231 4202 42 statements statement NNS 37231 4202 43 of of IN 37231 4202 44 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4202 45 who who WP 37231 4202 46 , , , 37231 4202 47 amongst amongst IN 37231 4202 48 other other JJ 37231 4202 49 things thing NNS 37231 4202 50 , , , 37231 4202 51 mentions mention VBZ 37231 4202 52 that that IN 37231 4202 53 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4202 54 sets set VBZ 37231 4202 55 forth forth RB 37231 4202 56 strange strange JJ 37231 4202 57 parables parable NNS 37231 4202 58 of of IN 37231 4202 59 the the DT 37231 4202 60 Saviour Saviour NNP 37231 4202 61 and and CC 37231 4202 62 teachings teaching NNS 37231 4202 63 of of IN 37231 4202 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4202 65 from from IN 37231 4202 66 unwritten unwritten JJ 37231 4202 67 tradition tradition NN 37231 4202 68 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4202 69 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4202 70 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4202 71 . . . 37231 4203 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4203 2 3 3 LS 37231 4203 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4203 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4203 5 is be VBZ 37231 4203 6 not not RB 37231 4203 7 , , , 37231 4203 8 however however RB 37231 4203 9 , , , 37231 4203 10 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4203 11 to to TO 37231 4203 12 discuss discuss VB 37231 4203 13 more more RBR 37231 4203 14 closely closely RB 37231 4203 15 the the DT 37231 4203 16 nature nature NN 37231 4203 17 of of IN 37231 4203 18 the the DT 37231 4203 19 work work NN 37231 4203 20 , , , 37231 4203 21 for for IN 37231 4203 22 there there EX 37231 4203 23 is be VBZ 37231 4203 24 no no DT 37231 4203 25 doubt doubt NN 37231 4203 26 that that IN 37231 4203 27 written write VBN 37231 4203 28 collections collection NNS 37231 4203 29 of of IN 37231 4203 30 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4203 31 of of IN 37231 4203 32 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4203 33 existed exist VBD 37231 4203 34 before before IN 37231 4203 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4203 36 was be VBD 37231 4203 37 composed compose VBN 37231 4203 38 of of IN 37231 4203 39 which which WDT 37231 4203 40 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4203 41 is be VBZ 37231 4203 42 probable probable JJ 37231 4203 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4203 44 made make VBD 37231 4203 45 use use NN 37231 4203 46 . . . 37231 4204 1 The the DT 37231 4204 2 most most RBS 37231 4204 3 interesting interesting JJ 37231 4204 4 part part NN 37231 4204 5 of of IN 37231 4204 6 the the DT 37231 4204 7 work work NN 37231 4204 8 of of IN 37231 4204 9 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4204 10 which which WDT 37231 4204 11 is be VBZ 37231 4204 12 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4204 13 to to IN 37231 4204 14 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4204 15 is be VBZ 37231 4204 16 that that IN 37231 4204 17 relating relate VBG 37231 4204 18 to to IN 37231 4204 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4204 20 and and CC 37231 4204 21 1 1 CD 37231 4204 22 With with IN 37231 4204 23 reference reference NN 37231 4204 24 to to IN 37231 4204 25 the the DT 37231 4204 26 last last JJ 37231 4204 27 sentence sentence NN 37231 4204 28 of of IN 37231 4204 29 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4204 30 , , , 37231 4204 31 Teschendorf Teschendorf NNP 37231 4204 32 asks ask VBZ 37231 4204 33 : : : 37231 4204 34 " " `` 37231 4204 35 What what WP 37231 4204 36 books book NNS 37231 4204 37 does do VBZ 37231 4204 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4204 39 refer refer VB 37231 4204 40 to to IN 37231 4204 41 here here RB 37231 4204 42 , , , 37231 4204 43 perhaps perhaps RB 37231 4204 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4204 45 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 4204 46 ? ? . 37231 4205 1 According accord VBG 37231 4205 2 to to IN 37231 4205 3 the the DT 37231 4205 4 expression expression NN 37231 4205 5 this this DT 37231 4205 6 is be VBZ 37231 4205 7 not not RB 37231 4205 8 impossible impossible JJ 37231 4205 9 , , , 37231 4205 10 but but CC 37231 4205 11 from from IN 37231 4205 12 the the DT 37231 4205 13 whole whole JJ 37231 4205 14 character character NN 37231 4205 15 of of IN 37231 4205 16 the the DT 37231 4205 17 book book NN 37231 4205 18 in in IN 37231 4205 19 the the DT 37231 4205 20 highest high JJS 37231 4205 21 degree degree NN 37231 4205 22 improbable improbable JJ 37231 4205 23 . . . 37231 4205 24 " " '' 37231 4206 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4206 2 Wann Wann NNP 37231 4206 3 wurden wurden NNP 37231 4206 4 , , , 37231 4206 5 u. u. NNP 37231 4206 6 s. s. NNP 37231 4206 7 w.t w.t NNP 37231 4206 8 p. p. NNP 37231 4207 1 109 109 CD 37231 4207 2 . . . 37231 4207 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4208 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4208 2 know know VBP 37231 4208 3 little little JJ 37231 4208 4 or or CC 37231 4208 5 nothing nothing NN 37231 4208 6 of of IN 37231 4208 7 the the DT 37231 4208 8 " " `` 37231 4208 9 whole whole JJ 37231 4208 10 character character NN 37231 4208 11 " " '' 37231 4208 12 of of IN 37231 4208 13 the the DT 37231 4208 14 book book NN 37231 4208 15 , , , 37231 4208 16 and and CC 37231 4208 17 what what WP 37231 4208 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4208 19 do do VBP 37231 4208 20 know know VB 37231 4208 21 is be VBZ 37231 4208 22 contradictory contradictory JJ 37231 4208 23 to to IN 37231 4208 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4208 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4208 26 . . . 37231 4209 1 The the DT 37231 4209 2 natural natural JJ 37231 4209 3 and and CC 37231 4209 4 only only JJ 37231 4209 5 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 4209 6 course course NN 37231 4209 7 is be VBZ 37231 4209 8 to to TO 37231 4209 9 believe believe VB 37231 4209 10 the the DT 37231 4209 11 express express JJ 37231 4209 12 declaration declaration NN 37231 4209 13 of of IN 37231 4209 14 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4209 15 , , , 37231 4209 16 more more RBR 37231 4209 17 especially especially RB 37231 4209 18 as as IN 37231 4209 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4209 20 is be VBZ 37231 4209 21 made make VBN 37231 4209 22 , , , 37231 4209 23 in in IN 37231 4209 24 this this DT 37231 4209 25 instance instance NN 37231 4209 26 , , , 37231 4209 27 as as IN 37231 4209 28 a a DT 37231 4209 29 prefatory prefatory JJ 37231 4209 30 statement statement NN 37231 4209 31 of of IN 37231 4209 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4209 33 belief belief NN 37231 4209 34 . . . 37231 4210 1 { { -LRB- 37231 4210 2 446 446 CD 37231 4210 3 } } -RRB- 37231 4210 4 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4210 5 . . . 37231 4211 1 After after IN 37231 4211 2 stating state VBG 37231 4211 3 that that IN 37231 4211 4 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4211 5 had have VBD 37231 4211 6 inserted insert VBN 37231 4211 7 in in IN 37231 4211 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4211 9 book book NN 37231 4211 10 accounts account NNS 37231 4211 11 of of IN 37231 4211 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4211 13 given give VBN 37231 4211 14 by by IN 37231 4211 15 Aristion Aristion NNP 37231 4211 16 , , , 37231 4211 17 of of IN 37231 4211 18 whom whom WP 37231 4211 19 nothing nothing NN 37231 4211 20 is be VBZ 37231 4211 21 known know VBN 37231 4211 22 , , , 37231 4211 23 and and CC 37231 4211 24 by by IN 37231 4211 25 the the DT 37231 4211 26 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4211 27 John John NNP 37231 4211 28 , , , 37231 4211 29 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4211 30 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 4211 31 to to TO 37231 4211 32 extract extract VB 37231 4211 33 a a DT 37231 4211 34 tradition tradition NN 37231 4211 35 regarding regard VBG 37231 4211 36 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4211 37 communicated communicate VBN 37231 4211 38 by by IN 37231 4211 39 the the DT 37231 4211 40 latter latter JJ 37231 4211 41 . . . 37231 4212 1 There there EX 37231 4212 2 has have VBZ 37231 4212 3 been be VBN 37231 4212 4 much much JJ 37231 4212 5 controversy controversy NN 37231 4212 6 as as IN 37231 4212 7 to to IN 37231 4212 8 the the DT 37231 4212 9 identity identity NN 37231 4212 10 of of IN 37231 4212 11 the the DT 37231 4212 12 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4212 13 John John NNP 37231 4212 14 , , , 37231 4212 15 some some DT 37231 4212 16 affirming affirm VBG 37231 4212 17 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4212 18 to to TO 37231 4212 19 have have VB 37231 4212 20 been be VBN 37231 4212 21 the the DT 37231 4212 22 Apostle,(1 apostle,(1 NN 37231 4212 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4212 24 but but CC 37231 4212 25 the the DT 37231 4212 26 great great JJ 37231 4212 27 majority majority NN 37231 4212 28 of of IN 37231 4212 29 critics critic NNS 37231 4212 30 deciding decide VBG 37231 4212 31 that that IN 37231 4212 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4212 33 was be VBD 37231 4212 34 a a DT 37231 4212 35 totally totally RB 37231 4212 36 different different JJ 37231 4212 37 person person NN 37231 4212 38 . . . 37231 4213 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4213 2 2 2 LS 37231 4213 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4213 4 Irenseus Irenseus NNP 37231 4213 5 , , , 37231 4213 6 who who WP 37231 4213 7 , , , 37231 4213 8 sharing share VBG 37231 4213 9 the the DT 37231 4213 10 Chiliastic chiliastic JJ 37231 4213 11 opinions opinion NNS 37231 4213 12 of of IN 37231 4213 13 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4213 14 , , , 37231 4213 15 held hold VBD 37231 4213 16 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 17 in in IN 37231 4213 18 high high JJ 37231 4213 19 respect respect NN 37231 4213 20 , , , 37231 4213 21 boldly boldly RB 37231 4213 22 calls call VBZ 37231 4213 23 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 24 " " `` 37231 4213 25 the the DT 37231 4213 26 hearer hearer NN 37231 4213 27 of of IN 37231 4213 28 John John NNP 37231 4213 29 " " '' 37231 4213 30 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4213 31 meaning mean VBG 37231 4213 32 the the DT 37231 4213 33 Apostle apostle NN 37231 4213 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4213 35 " " '' 37231 4213 36 and and CC 37231 4213 37 a a DT 37231 4213 38 companion companion NN 37231 4213 39 of of IN 37231 4213 40 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 37231 4213 41 " " '' 37231 4213 42 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4213 43 --Greek--](3 --Greek--](3 NNP 37231 4213 44 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4213 45 but but CC 37231 4213 46 this this DT 37231 4213 47 is be VBZ 37231 4213 48 expressly expressly RB 37231 4213 49 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 4213 50 by by IN 37231 4213 51 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4213 52 , , , 37231 4213 53 who who WP 37231 4213 54 points point VBZ 37231 4213 55 out out RP 37231 4213 56 that that IN 37231 4213 57 , , , 37231 4213 58 in in IN 37231 4213 59 the the DT 37231 4213 60 preface preface NN 37231 4213 61 to to IN 37231 4213 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4213 63 book book NN 37231 4213 64 , , , 37231 4213 65 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4213 66 by by IN 37231 4213 67 no no DT 37231 4213 68 means means NN 37231 4213 69 asserts assert VBZ 37231 4213 70 that that IN 37231 4213 71 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 72 was be VBD 37231 4213 73 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 74 a a DT 37231 4213 75 hearer hearer NN 37231 4213 76 of of IN 37231 4213 77 the the DT 37231 4213 78 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4213 79 , , , 37231 4213 80 but but CC 37231 4213 81 merely merely RB 37231 4213 82 that that IN 37231 4213 83 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 84 received receive VBD 37231 4213 85 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4213 86 doctrines doctrine NNS 37231 4213 87 from from IN 37231 4213 88 those those DT 37231 4213 89 who who WP 37231 4213 90 had have VBD 37231 4213 91 personally personally RB 37231 4213 92 known know VBN 37231 4213 93 them;(3 them;(3 NN 37231 4213 94 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4213 95 and and CC 37231 4213 96 after after IN 37231 4213 97 making make VBG 37231 4213 98 the the DT 37231 4213 99 quotation quotation NN 37231 4213 100 from from IN 37231 4213 101 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4213 102 which which WDT 37231 4213 103 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 104 have have VBP 37231 4213 105 given give VBN 37231 4213 106 { { -LRB- 37231 4213 107 447 447 CD 37231 4213 108 } } -RRB- 37231 4213 109 above above RB 37231 4213 110 , , , 37231 4213 111 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 112 goes go VBZ 37231 4213 113 on on RP 37231 4213 114 to to TO 37231 4213 115 point point VB 37231 4213 116 out out RP 37231 4213 117 that that IN 37231 4213 118 the the DT 37231 4213 119 name name NN 37231 4213 120 of of IN 37231 4213 121 John John NNP 37231 4213 122 is be VBZ 37231 4213 123 twice twice RB 37231 4213 124 mentioned mention VBN 37231 4213 125 , , , 37231 4213 126 once once RB 37231 4213 127 together together RB 37231 4213 128 with with IN 37231 4213 129 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4213 130 , , , 37231 4213 131 James James NNP 37231 4213 132 , , , 37231 4213 133 and and CC 37231 4213 134 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4213 135 , , , 37231 4213 136 and and CC 37231 4213 137 the the DT 37231 4213 138 other other JJ 37231 4213 139 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4213 140 , , , 37231 4213 141 " " '' 37231 4213 142 evidently evidently RB 37231 4213 143 the the DT 37231 4213 144 Evangelist evangelist NN 37231 4213 145 , , , 37231 4213 146 " " '' 37231 4213 147 and and CC 37231 4213 148 the the DT 37231 4213 149 other other JJ 37231 4213 150 John John NNP 37231 4213 151 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 152 mentions mention VBZ 37231 4213 153 separately separately RB 37231 4213 154 , , , 37231 4213 155 ranking rank VBG 37231 4213 156 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 157 amongst amongst IN 37231 4213 158 those those DT 37231 4213 159 who who WP 37231 4213 160 are be VBP 37231 4213 161 not not RB 37231 4213 162 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4213 163 , , , 37231 4213 164 and and CC 37231 4213 165 placing place VBG 37231 4213 166 Aristion aristion NN 37231 4213 167 before before IN 37231 4213 168 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 169 , , , 37231 4213 170 distinguishing distinguish VBG 37231 4213 171 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4213 172 clearly clearly RB 37231 4213 173 by by IN 37231 4213 174 the the DT 37231 4213 175 name name NN 37231 4213 176 of of IN 37231 4213 177 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4213 178 . . . 37231 4214 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4214 2 1 1 LS 37231 4214 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4214 4 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4214 5 further further RB 37231 4214 6 refers refer VBZ 37231 4214 7 to to IN 37231 4214 8 the the DT 37231 4214 9 statement statement NN 37231 4214 10 of of IN 37231 4214 11 the the DT 37231 4214 12 great great JJ 37231 4214 13 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4214 14 of of IN 37231 4214 15 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4214 16 , , , 37231 4214 17 Dionysius,(2 Dionysius,(2 NNP 37231 4214 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4214 19 that that IN 37231 4214 20 at at IN 37231 4214 21 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 37231 4214 22 there there EX 37231 4214 23 were be VBD 37231 4214 24 two two CD 37231 4214 25 tombs tomb NNS 37231 4214 26 , , , 37231 4214 27 each each DT 37231 4214 28 bearing bear VBG 37231 4214 29 the the DT 37231 4214 30 name name NN 37231 4214 31 of of IN 37231 4214 32 John John NNP 37231 4214 33 , , , 37231 4214 34 thereby thereby RB 37231 4214 35 leading lead VBG 37231 4214 36 to to IN 37231 4214 37 the the DT 37231 4214 38 inference inference NN 37231 4214 39 that that IN 37231 4214 40 there there EX 37231 4214 41 were be VBD 37231 4214 42 two two CD 37231 4214 43 men man NNS 37231 4214 44 of of IN 37231 4214 45 the the DT 37231 4214 46 name name NN 37231 4214 47 . . . 37231 4215 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4215 2 3 3 LS 37231 4215 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4215 4 There there EX 37231 4215 5 can can MD 37231 4215 6 be be VB 37231 4215 7 no no DT 37231 4215 8 doubt doubt NN 37231 4215 9 that that IN 37231 4215 10 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4215 11 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4215 12 in in IN 37231 4215 13 the the DT 37231 4215 14 passage passage NN 37231 4215 15 quoted quote VBN 37231 4215 16 mentions mention NNS 37231 4215 17 two two CD 37231 4215 18 persons person NNS 37231 4215 19 of of IN 37231 4215 20 the the DT 37231 4215 21 name name NN 37231 4215 22 of of IN 37231 4215 23 John John NNP 37231 4215 24 , , , 37231 4215 25 distinguishing distinguish VBG 37231 4215 26 the the DT 37231 4215 27 one one NN 37231 4215 28 from from IN 37231 4215 29 the the DT 37231 4215 30 other other JJ 37231 4215 31 , , , 37231 4215 32 and and CC 37231 4215 33 classing class VBG 37231 4215 34 the the DT 37231 4215 35 one one NN 37231 4215 36 amongst amongst IN 37231 4215 37 the the DT 37231 4215 38 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4215 39 and and CC 37231 4215 40 the the DT 37231 4215 41 other other JJ 37231 4215 42 after after IN 37231 4215 43 Aristion Aristion NNP 37231 4215 44 , , , 37231 4215 45 an an DT 37231 4215 46 unknown unknown JJ 37231 4215 47 " " `` 37231 4215 48 disciple disciple NN 37231 4215 49 of of IN 37231 4215 50 the the DT 37231 4215 51 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4215 52 , , , 37231 4215 53 " " '' 37231 4215 54 and and CC 37231 4215 55 , , , 37231 4215 56 but but CC 37231 4215 57 for for IN 37231 4215 58 the the DT 37231 4215 59 phrase phrase NN 37231 4215 60 of of IN 37231 4215 61 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4215 62 , , , 37231 4215 63 so so RB 37231 4215 64 characteristically characteristically RB 37231 4215 65 uncritical uncritical JJ 37231 4215 66 and and CC 37231 4215 67 assumptive assumptive JJ 37231 4215 68 , , , 37231 4215 69 there there EX 37231 4215 70 probably probably RB 37231 4215 71 never never RB 37231 4215 72 would would MD 37231 4215 73 have have VB 37231 4215 74 been be VBN 37231 4215 75 any any DT 37231 4215 76 doubt doubt NN 37231 4215 77 raised raise VBN 37231 4215 78 as as IN 37231 4215 79 to to IN 37231 4215 80 the the DT 37231 4215 81 meaning meaning NN 37231 4215 82 of of IN 37231 4215 83 the the DT 37231 4215 84 passage passage NN 37231 4215 85 . . . 37231 4216 1 The the DT 37231 4216 2 question question NN 37231 4216 3 is be VBZ 37231 4216 4 not not RB 37231 4216 5 of of IN 37231 4216 6 importance importance NN 37231 4216 7 to to IN 37231 4216 8 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4216 9 , , , 37231 4216 10 and and CC 37231 4216 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4216 12 may may MD 37231 4216 13 leave leave VB 37231 4216 14 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4216 15 , , , 37231 4216 16 with with IN 37231 4216 17 the the DT 37231 4216 18 remark remark NN 37231 4216 19 that that IN 37231 4216 20 a a DT 37231 4216 21 writer writer NN 37231 4216 22 who who WP 37231 4216 23 suffered suffer VBD 37231 4216 24 martyrdom martyrdom NN 37231 4216 25 under under IN 37231 4216 26 Marcus Marcus NNP 37231 4216 27 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 37231 4216 28 , , , 37231 4216 29 c. c. NNP 37231 4216 30 a.d a.d NNP 37231 4216 31 . . NNP 37231 4216 32 165 165 CD 37231 4216 33 , , , 37231 4216 34 can can MD 37231 4216 35 scarcely scarcely RB 37231 4216 36 have have VB 37231 4216 37 been be VBN 37231 4216 38 a a DT 37231 4216 39 hearer hearer NN 37231 4216 40 of of IN 37231 4216 41 the the DT 37231 4216 42 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4216 43 . . . 37231 4217 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4217 2 4 4 LS 37231 4217 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4217 4 The the DT 37231 4217 5 account account NN 37231 4217 6 which which WDT 37231 4217 7 the the DT 37231 4217 8 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4217 9 John John NNP 37231 4217 10 is be VBZ 37231 4217 11 said say VBN 37231 4217 12 to to TO 37231 4217 13 have have VB 37231 4217 14 { { -LRB- 37231 4217 15 448 448 CD 37231 4217 16 } } -RRB- 37231 4217 17 given give VBN 37231 4217 18 of of IN 37231 4217 19 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4217 20 's 's POS 37231 4217 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4217 22 is be VBZ 37231 4217 23 as as IN 37231 4217 24 follows follow VBZ 37231 4217 25 : : : 37231 4217 26 " " `` 37231 4217 27 ' ' `` 37231 4217 28 This this DT 37231 4217 29 also also RB 37231 4217 30 the the DT 37231 4217 31 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4217 32 said say VBD 37231 4217 33 : : : 37231 4217 34 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4217 35 having have VBG 37231 4217 36 become become VBN 37231 4217 37 the the DT 37231 4217 38 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4217 39 of of IN 37231 4217 40 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4217 41 , , , 37231 4217 42 wrote write VBD 37231 4217 43 accurately accurately RB 37231 4217 44 whatever whatever WDT 37231 4217 45 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4217 46 remembered remember VBD 37231 4217 47 , , , 37231 4217 48 though though IN 37231 4217 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4217 50 did do VBD 37231 4217 51 not not RB 37231 4217 52 arrange arrange VB 37231 4217 53 in in IN 37231 4217 54 order order NN 37231 4217 55 the the DT 37231 4217 56 things thing NNS 37231 4217 57 which which WDT 37231 4217 58 were be VBD 37231 4217 59 either either CC 37231 4217 60 said say VBN 37231 4217 61 or or CC 37231 4217 62 done do VBN 37231 4217 63 by by IN 37231 4217 64 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4217 65 . . . 37231 4218 1 For for IN 37231 4218 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4218 3 neither neither CC 37231 4218 4 heard hear VBD 37231 4218 5 the the DT 37231 4218 6 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4218 7 , , , 37231 4218 8 nor nor CC 37231 4218 9 followed follow VBD 37231 4218 10 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4218 11 ; ; : 37231 4218 12 but but CC 37231 4218 13 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 4218 14 , , , 37231 4218 15 as as IN 37231 4218 16 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4218 17 said,(1 said,(1 VBP 37231 4218 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4218 19 accompanied accompany VBD 37231 4218 20 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4218 21 , , , 37231 4218 22 who who WP 37231 4218 23 adapted adapt VBD 37231 4218 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4218 25 teaching teaching NN 37231 4218 26 to to IN 37231 4218 27 the the DT 37231 4218 28 occasion occasion NN 37231 4218 29 , , , 37231 4218 30 and and CC 37231 4218 31 not not RB 37231 4218 32 as as IN 37231 4218 33 making make VBG 37231 4218 34 a a DT 37231 4218 35 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4218 36 record record NN 37231 4218 37 of of IN 37231 4218 38 the the DT 37231 4218 39 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4218 40 's 's POS 37231 4218 41 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4218 42 . . . 37231 4219 1 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4219 2 , , , 37231 4219 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 4219 4 , , , 37231 4219 5 committed commit VBD 37231 4219 6 no no DT 37231 4219 7 error error NN 37231 4219 8 in in IN 37231 4219 9 thus thus RB 37231 4219 10 writing write VBG 37231 4219 11 down down RP 37231 4219 12 some some DT 37231 4219 13 things thing NNS 37231 4219 14 as as IN 37231 4219 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4219 16 remembered remember VBD 37231 4219 17 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4219 18 . . . 37231 4220 1 For for IN 37231 4220 2 of of IN 37231 4220 3 one one CD 37231 4220 4 point point NN 37231 4220 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4220 6 was be VBD 37231 4220 7 careful careful JJ 37231 4220 8 , , , 37231 4220 9 to to TO 37231 4220 10 omit omit VB 37231 4220 11 none none NN 37231 4220 12 of of IN 37231 4220 13 the the DT 37231 4220 14 things thing NNS 37231 4220 15 which which WDT 37231 4220 16 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4220 17 heard hear VBD 37231 4220 18 , , , 37231 4220 19 and and CC 37231 4220 20 not not RB 37231 4220 21 to to TO 37231 4220 22 narrate narrate VB 37231 4220 23 any any DT 37231 4220 24 of of IN 37231 4220 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4220 26 falsely falsely RB 37231 4220 27 . . . 37231 4220 28 ' ' '' 37231 4221 1 These these DT 37231 4221 2 facts fact NNS 37231 4221 3 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4221 4 relates relate VBZ 37231 4221 5 concerning concern VBG 37231 4221 6 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4221 7 . . . 37231 4222 1 " " `` 37231 4222 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4222 3 2 2 LS 37231 4222 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4222 5 The the DT 37231 4222 6 question question NN 37231 4222 7 to to TO 37231 4222 8 decide decide VB 37231 4222 9 is be VBZ 37231 4222 10 , , , 37231 4222 11 whether whether IN 37231 4222 12 the the DT 37231 4222 13 work work NN 37231 4222 14 here here RB 37231 4222 15 described describe VBN 37231 4222 16 is be VBZ 37231 4222 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4222 18 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4222 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4222 20 or or CC 37231 4222 21 not not RB 37231 4222 22 . . . 37231 4223 1 The the DT 37231 4223 2 first first JJ 37231 4223 3 point point NN 37231 4223 4 in in IN 37231 4223 5 this this DT 37231 4223 6 account account NN 37231 4223 7 is be VBZ 37231 4223 8 the the DT 37231 4223 9 statement statement NN 37231 4223 10 that that IN 37231 4223 11 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4223 12 was be VBD 37231 4223 13 the the DT 37231 4223 14 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4223 15 of of IN 37231 4223 16 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4223 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4223 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4223 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4223 20 . . . 37231 4224 1 Was be VBD 37231 4224 2 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4224 3 merely merely RB 37231 4224 4 the the DT 37231 4224 5 secretary secretary NN 37231 4224 6 of of IN 37231 4224 7 the the DT 37231 4224 8 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4224 9 writing write VBG 37231 4224 10 in in IN 37231 4224 11 a a DT 37231 4224 12 manner manner NN 37231 4224 13 from from IN 37231 4224 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4224 15 dictation dictation NN 37231 4224 16 , , , 37231 4224 17 or or CC 37231 4224 18 does do VBZ 37231 4224 19 the the DT 37231 4224 20 passage passage NN 37231 4224 21 mean mean VB 37231 4224 22 that that IN 37231 4224 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4224 24 translated translate VBD 37231 4224 25 the the DT 37231 4224 26 Aramaic Aramaic NNP 37231 4224 27 narrative narrative NN 37231 4224 28 of of IN 37231 4224 29 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4224 30 into into IN 37231 4224 31 1 1 CD 37231 4224 32 Dr. Dr. NNP 37231 4224 33 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 37231 4224 34 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4224 35 Contemp Contemp NNP 37231 4224 36 . . . 37231 4225 1 Bev Bev NNP 37231 4225 2 . . NNP 37231 4225 3 , , , 37231 4225 4 1875 1875 CD 37231 4225 5 , , , 37231 4225 6 p. p. NN 37231 4225 7 842 842 CD 37231 4225 8 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4225 9 , , , 37231 4225 10 in in IN 37231 4225 11 the the DT 37231 4225 12 course course NN 37231 4225 13 of of IN 37231 4225 14 a a DT 37231 4225 15 highly highly RB 37231 4225 16 fanciful fanciful JJ 37231 4225 17 argument argument NN 37231 4225 18 says say VBZ 37231 4225 19 , , , 37231 4225 20 in in IN 37231 4225 21 reference reference NN 37231 4225 22 to to IN 37231 4225 23 this this DT 37231 4225 24 " " `` 37231 4225 25 as as IN 37231 4225 26 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4225 27 said say VBD 37231 4225 28 " " '' 37231 4225 29 : : : 37231 4225 30 " " `` 37231 4225 31 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4225 32 is be VBZ 37231 4225 33 quite quite RB 37231 4225 34 clear clear JJ 37231 4225 35 that that IN 37231 4225 36 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4225 37 had have VBD 37231 4225 38 already already RB 37231 4225 39 said say VBN 37231 4225 40 something something NN 37231 4225 41 of of IN 37231 4225 42 the the DT 37231 4225 43 relations relation NNS 37231 4225 44 existing exist VBG 37231 4225 45 between between IN 37231 4225 46 St. St. NNP 37231 4225 47 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4225 48 and and CC 37231 4225 49 St St NNP 37231 4225 50 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4225 51 previously previously RB 37231 4225 52 to to IN 37231 4225 53 the the DT 37231 4225 54 extract extract NN 37231 4225 55 which which WDT 37231 4225 56 gives give VBZ 37231 4225 57 an an DT 37231 4225 58 account account NN 37231 4225 59 of of IN 37231 4225 60 the the DT 37231 4225 61 Second Second NNP 37231 4225 62 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4225 63 , , , 37231 4225 64 for for IN 37231 4225 65 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4225 66 there there EX 37231 4225 67 refers refer VBZ 37231 4225 68 back back RB 37231 4225 69 to to IN 37231 4225 70 a a DT 37231 4225 71 preceding precede VBG 37231 4225 72 notice notice NN 37231 4225 73 . . . 37231 4225 74 " " '' 37231 4226 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4226 2 is be VBZ 37231 4226 3 quite quite RB 37231 4226 4 clear clear JJ 37231 4226 5 that that IN 37231 4226 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4226 7 refers refer VBZ 37231 4226 8 back back RB 37231 4226 9 , , , 37231 4226 10 but but CC 37231 4226 11 only only RB 37231 4226 12 to to IN 37231 4226 13 the the DT 37231 4226 14 preceding precede VBG 37231 4226 15 sentence sentence NN 37231 4226 16 in in IN 37231 4226 17 which which WDT 37231 4226 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4226 19 " " `` 37231 4226 20 had have VBD 37231 4226 21 already already RB 37231 4226 22 said say VBN 37231 4226 23 something something NN 37231 4226 24 of of IN 37231 4226 25 the the DT 37231 4226 26 relations relation NNS 37231 4226 27 " " '' 37231 4226 28 in in IN 37231 4226 29 stating state VBG 37231 4226 30 the the DT 37231 4226 31 fact fact NN 37231 4226 32 that that IN 37231 4226 33 : : : 37231 4226 34 " " `` 37231 4226 35 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4226 36 , , , 37231 4226 37 having have VBG 37231 4226 38 become become VBN 37231 4226 39 the the DT 37231 4226 40 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4226 41 of of IN 37231 4226 42 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4226 43 , , , 37231 4226 44 wrote write VBD 37231 4226 45 , , , 37231 4226 46 & & CC 37231 4226 47 c. c. NNP 37231 4226 48 " " `` 37231 4226 49 { { -LRB- 37231 4226 50 449 449 CD 37231 4226 51 } } -RRB- 37231 4226 52 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4226 53 ? ? . 37231 4227 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4227 2 1 1 LS 37231 4227 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4227 4 The the DT 37231 4227 5 former former JJ 37231 4227 6 is be VBZ 37231 4227 7 the the DT 37231 4227 8 more more RBR 37231 4227 9 probable probable JJ 37231 4227 10 supposition supposition NN 37231 4227 11 and and CC 37231 4227 12 that that IN 37231 4227 13 which which WDT 37231 4227 14 is be VBZ 37231 4227 15 most most RBS 37231 4227 16 generally generally RB 37231 4227 17 adopted adopt VBN 37231 4227 18 , , , 37231 4227 19 but but CC 37231 4227 20 the the DT 37231 4227 21 question question NN 37231 4227 22 is be VBZ 37231 4227 23 not not RB 37231 4227 24 material material JJ 37231 4227 25 here here RB 37231 4227 26 . . . 37231 4228 1 The the DT 37231 4228 2 connection connection NN 37231 4228 3 of of IN 37231 4228 4 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4228 5 with with IN 37231 4228 6 the the DT 37231 4228 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4228 8 according accord VBG 37231 4228 9 to to IN 37231 4228 10 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4228 11 was be VBD 37231 4228 12 generally generally RB 37231 4228 13 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 4228 14 in in IN 37231 4228 15 the the DT 37231 4228 16 early early JJ 37231 4228 17 Church Church NNP 37231 4228 18 , , , 37231 4228 19 as as IN 37231 4228 20 was be VBD 37231 4228 21 also also RB 37231 4228 22 that that DT 37231 4228 23 of of IN 37231 4228 24 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4228 25 with with IN 37231 4228 26 the the DT 37231 4228 27 third third JJ 37231 4228 28 Gospel,{2 Gospel,{2 NNP 37231 4228 29 } } -RRB- 37231 4228 30 with with IN 37231 4228 31 the the DT 37231 4228 32 evident evident JJ 37231 4228 33 purpose purpose NN 37231 4228 34 of of IN 37231 4228 35 claiming claim VBG 37231 4228 36 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 4228 37 origin origin NN 37231 4228 38 for for IN 37231 4228 39 all all PDT 37231 4228 40 the the DT 37231 4228 41 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4228 42 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4228 43 . . . 37231 4229 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4229 2 3 3 LS 37231 4229 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4229 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4229 5 says say VBZ 37231 4229 6 : : : 37231 4229 7 " " `` 37231 4229 8 After after IN 37231 4229 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4229 10 decease decease NN 37231 4229 11 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4229 12 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4229 13 and and CC 37231 4229 14 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4229 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4229 16 , , , 37231 4229 17 Mark mark VB 37231 4229 18 the the DT 37231 4229 19 disciple disciple NN 37231 4229 20 and and CC 37231 4229 21 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4229 22 of of IN 37231 4229 23 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4229 24 delivered deliver VBD 37231 4229 25 to to IN 37231 4229 26 , , , 37231 4229 27 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4229 28 in in IN 37231 4229 29 writing writing NN 37231 4229 30 that that WDT 37231 4229 31 which which WDT 37231 4229 32 had have VBD 37231 4229 33 been be VBN 37231 4229 34 preached preach VBN 37231 4229 35 by by IN 37231 4229 36 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4229 37 . . . 37231 4230 1 " " `` 37231 4230 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4230 3 4 4 LS 37231 4230 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4230 5 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4230 6 quotes quote VBZ 37231 4230 7 a a DT 37231 4230 8 similar similar JJ 37231 4230 9 tradition tradition NN 37231 4230 10 from from IN 37231 4230 11 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4230 12 of of IN 37231 4230 13 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4230 14 , , , 37231 4230 15 embellished embellish VBD 37231 4230 16 however however RB 37231 4230 17 with with IN 37231 4230 18 further further JJ 37231 4230 19 particulars particular NNS 37231 4230 20 . . . 37231 4231 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4231 2 says say VBZ 37231 4231 3 : : : 37231 4231 4 " " `` 37231 4231 5 ... ... . 37231 4232 1 The the DT 37231 4232 2 cause cause NN 37231 4232 3 for for IN 37231 4232 4 which which WDT 37231 4232 5 the the DT 37231 4232 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4232 7 according accord VBG 37231 4232 8 to to IN 37231 4232 9 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4232 10 was be VBD 37231 4232 11 written write VBN 37231 4232 12 was be VBD 37231 4232 13 this this DT 37231 4232 14 : : : 37231 4232 15 When when WRB 37231 4232 16 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4232 17 had have VBD 37231 4232 18 publicly publicly RB 37231 4232 19 preached preach VBN 37231 4232 20 the the DT 37231 4232 21 word word NN 37231 4232 22 at at IN 37231 4232 23 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4232 24 , , , 37231 4232 25 and and CC 37231 4232 26 proclaimed proclaim VBD 37231 4232 27 the the DT 37231 4232 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4232 29 by by IN 37231 4232 30 the the DT 37231 4232 31 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 4232 32 , , , 37231 4232 33 those those DT 37231 4232 34 who who WP 37231 4232 35 were be VBD 37231 4232 36 present present JJ 37231 4232 37 being be VBG 37231 4232 38 many many JJ 37231 4232 39 , , , 37231 4232 40 requested request VBN 37231 4232 41 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4232 42 , , , 37231 4232 43 as as IN 37231 4232 44 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 45 had have VBD 37231 4232 46 followed follow VBN 37231 4232 47 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 48 from from IN 37231 4232 49 afar afar RB 37231 4232 50 and and CC 37231 4232 51 remembered remember VBD 37231 4232 52 what what WP 37231 4232 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 54 had have VBD 37231 4232 55 said say VBN 37231 4232 56 , , , 37231 4232 57 to to TO 37231 4232 58 write write VB 37231 4232 59 down down RP 37231 4232 60 what what WP 37231 4232 61 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 62 had have VBD 37231 4232 63 spoken speak VBN 37231 4232 64 ; ; : 37231 4232 65 and and CC 37231 4232 66 when when WRB 37231 4232 67 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 68 had have VBD 37231 4232 69 composed compose VBN 37231 4232 70 the the DT 37231 4232 71 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4232 72 , , , 37231 4232 73 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 74 gave give VBD 37231 4232 75 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 76 to to IN 37231 4232 77 those those DT 37231 4232 78 who who WP 37231 4232 79 had have VBD 37231 4232 80 asked ask VBN 37231 4232 81 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 82 of of IN 37231 4232 83 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 84 ; ; : 37231 4232 85 which which WDT 37231 4232 86 when when WRB 37231 4232 87 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4232 88 knew know VBD 37231 4232 89 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4232 90 neither neither CC 37231 4232 91 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 4232 92 hindered hinder VBD 37231 4232 93 nor nor CC 37231 4232 94 encouraged encouraged JJ 37231 4232 95 it*"(5 it*"(5 UH 37231 4232 96 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4232 97 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 37231 4232 98 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 4232 99 the the DT 37231 4232 100 same same JJ 37231 4232 101 tradition tradition NN 37231 4232 102 . . . 37231 4233 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4233 2 says say VBZ 37231 4233 3 : : : 37231 4233 4 { { -LRB- 37231 4233 5 450 450 CD 37231 4233 6 } } -RRB- 37231 4233 7 " " '' 37231 4233 8 And and CC 37231 4233 9 the the DT 37231 4233 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4233 11 which which WDT 37231 4233 12 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4233 13 published publish VBN 37231 4233 14 may may MD 37231 4233 15 be be VB 37231 4233 16 affirmed affirm VBN 37231 4233 17 to to TO 37231 4233 18 be be VB 37231 4233 19 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4233 20 's 's POS 37231 4233 21 , , , 37231 4233 22 whose whose WP$ 37231 4233 23 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4233 24 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4233 25 was be VBD 37231 4233 26 .... .... . 37231 4233 27 for for IN 37231 4233 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4233 29 may may MD 37231 4233 30 rightly rightly RB 37231 4233 31 appear appear VB 37231 4233 32 that that IN 37231 4233 33 works work VBZ 37231 4233 34 which which WDT 37231 4233 35 disciples disciple VBZ 37231 4233 36 publish publish VBP 37231 4233 37 are be VBP 37231 4233 38 of of IN 37231 4233 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4233 40 masters master NNS 37231 4233 41 . . . 37231 4234 1 " " `` 37231 4234 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4234 3 l l NN 37231 4234 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4234 5 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4234 6 have have VBP 37231 4234 7 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4234 8 again again RB 37231 4234 9 from from IN 37231 4234 10 Origen Origen NNP 37231 4234 11 : : : 37231 4234 12 " " `` 37231 4234 13 The the DT 37231 4234 14 second second JJ 37231 4234 15 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4234 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4234 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4234 18 is be VBZ 37231 4234 19 according accord VBG 37231 4234 20 to to IN 37231 4234 21 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4234 22 , , , 37231 4234 23 written write VBN 37231 4234 24 as as IN 37231 4234 25 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4234 26 directed direct VBD 37231 4234 27 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4234 28 . . . 37231 4235 1 " " `` 37231 4235 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4235 3 2 2 LS 37231 4235 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4235 5 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4235 6 gives give VBZ 37231 4235 7 a a DT 37231 4235 8 more more RBR 37231 4235 9 detailed detailed JJ 37231 4235 10 and and CC 37231 4235 11 advanced advanced JJ 37231 4235 12 version version NN 37231 4235 13 of of IN 37231 4235 14 the the DT 37231 4235 15 same same JJ 37231 4235 16 tradition tradition NN 37231 4235 17 . . . 37231 4236 1 " " `` 37231 4236 2 So so RB 37231 4236 3 much much RB 37231 4236 4 , , , 37231 4236 5 however however RB 37231 4236 6 , , , 37231 4236 7 did do VBD 37231 4236 8 the the DT 37231 4236 9 effulgence effulgence NN 37231 4236 10 of of IN 37231 4236 11 piety piety NN 37231 4236 12 illuminate illuminate VB 37231 4236 13 the the DT 37231 4236 14 minds mind NNS 37231 4236 15 of of IN 37231 4236 16 those those DT 37231 4236 17 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4236 18 Romans Romans NNPS 37231 4236 19 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4236 20 who who WP 37231 4236 21 heard hear VBD 37231 4236 22 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4236 23 , , , 37231 4236 24 that that IN 37231 4236 25 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4236 26 did do VBD 37231 4236 27 not not RB 37231 4236 28 content content VB 37231 4236 29 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4236 30 to to TO 37231 4236 31 hear hear VB 37231 4236 32 but but CC 37231 4236 33 once once RB 37231 4236 34 , , , 37231 4236 35 nor nor CC 37231 4236 36 to to TO 37231 4236 37 receive receive VB 37231 4236 38 only only RB 37231 4236 39 the the DT 37231 4236 40 unwritten unwritten JJ 37231 4236 41 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 4236 42 of of IN 37231 4236 43 the the DT 37231 4236 44 divine divine JJ 37231 4236 45 teaching teaching NN 37231 4236 46 , , , 37231 4236 47 but but CC 37231 4236 48 with with IN 37231 4236 49 reiterated reiterate VBN 37231 4236 50 entreaties entreaty NNS 37231 4236 51 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4236 52 besought beseech VBD 37231 4236 53 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4236 54 , , , 37231 4236 55 to to TO 37231 4236 56 whom whom WP 37231 4236 57 the the DT 37231 4236 58 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4236 59 is be VBZ 37231 4236 60 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4236 61 , , , 37231 4236 62 as as IN 37231 4236 63 the the DT 37231 4236 64 companion companion NN 37231 4236 65 of of IN 37231 4236 66 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4236 67 , , , 37231 4236 68 that that IN 37231 4236 69 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4236 70 should should MD 37231 4236 71 leave leave VB 37231 4236 72 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4236 73 a a DT 37231 4236 74 written write VBN 37231 4236 75 record record NN 37231 4236 76 of of IN 37231 4236 77 the the DT 37231 4236 78 doctrine doctrine NN 37231 4236 79 thus thus RB 37231 4236 80 orally orally RB 37231 4236 81 conveyed convey VBN 37231 4236 82 . . . 37231 4237 1 Nor nor CC 37231 4237 2 did do VBD 37231 4237 3 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4237 4 cease cease VB 37231 4237 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4237 6 entreaties entreaty NNS 37231 4237 7 until until IN 37231 4237 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4237 9 had have VBD 37231 4237 10 persuaded persuade VBN 37231 4237 11 the the DT 37231 4237 12 man man NN 37231 4237 13 , , , 37231 4237 14 and and CC 37231 4237 15 thus thus RB 37231 4237 16 became become VBD 37231 4237 17 the the DT 37231 4237 18 cause cause NN 37231 4237 19 of of IN 37231 4237 20 the the DT 37231 4237 21 writing writing NN 37231 4237 22 of of IN 37231 4237 23 the the DT 37231 4237 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4237 25 called call VBD 37231 4237 26 according accord VBG 37231 4237 27 to to IN 37231 4237 28 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4237 29 . . . 37231 4238 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 4238 2 say say VBP 37231 4238 3 , , , 37231 4238 4 moreover moreover RB 37231 4238 5 , , , 37231 4238 6 that that IN 37231 4238 7 the the DT 37231 4238 8 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4238 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4238 10 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4238 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4238 12 having have VBG 37231 4238 13 become become VBN 37231 4238 14 aware aware JJ 37231 4238 15 , , , 37231 4238 16 through through IN 37231 4238 17 revelation revelation NN 37231 4238 18 to to IN 37231 4238 19 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4238 20 of of IN 37231 4238 21 the the DT 37231 4238 22 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 4238 23 , , , 37231 4238 24 of of IN 37231 4238 25 what what WP 37231 4238 26 had have VBD 37231 4238 27 been be VBN 37231 4238 28 done do VBN 37231 4238 29 , , , 37231 4238 30 was be VBD 37231 4238 31 delighted delight VBN 37231 4238 32 with with IN 37231 4238 33 the the DT 37231 4238 34 ardour ardour NN 37231 4238 35 of of IN 37231 4238 36 the the DT 37231 4238 37 men man NNS 37231 4238 38 , , , 37231 4238 39 and and CC 37231 4238 40 ratified ratify VBD 37231 4238 41 the the DT 37231 4238 42 work work NN 37231 4238 43 in in IN 37231 4238 44 order order NN 37231 4238 45 that that IN 37231 4238 46 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4238 47 might may MD 37231 4238 48 be be VB 37231 4238 49 read read VBN 37231 4238 50 in in IN 37231 4238 51 the the DT 37231 4238 52 churches church NNS 37231 4238 53 . . . 37231 4239 1 This this DT 37231 4239 2 narrative narrative NN 37231 4239 3 is be VBZ 37231 4239 4 given give VBN 37231 4239 5 by by IN 37231 4239 6 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4239 7 in in IN 37231 4239 8 the the DT 37231 4239 9 sixth sixth JJ 37231 4239 10 book book NN 37231 4239 11 of of IN 37231 4239 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4239 13 Institutions Institutions NNPS 37231 4239 14 , , , 37231 4239 15 whose whose WP$ 37231 4239 16 testimony testimony NN 37231 4239 17 is be VBZ 37231 4239 18 supported support VBN 37231 4239 19 by by IN 37231 4239 20 that that DT 37231 4239 21 of of IN 37231 4239 22 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4239 23 , , , 37231 4239 24 the the DT 37231 4239 25 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4239 26 of of IN 37231 4239 27 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 37231 4239 28 . . . 37231 4240 1 " " `` 37231 4240 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4240 3 3 3 LS 37231 4240 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4240 5 { { -LRB- 37231 4240 6 451 451 CD 37231 4240 7 } } -RRB- 37231 4240 8 The the DT 37231 4240 9 account account NN 37231 4240 10 given give VBN 37231 4240 11 by by IN 37231 4240 12 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4240 13 , , , 37231 4240 14 however however RB 37231 4240 15 , , , 37231 4240 16 by by IN 37231 4240 17 no no DT 37231 4240 18 means means NN 37231 4240 19 contained contain VBD 37231 4240 20 these these DT 37231 4240 21 details detail NNS 37231 4240 22 , , , 37231 4240 23 as as IN 37231 4240 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4240 25 have have VBP 37231 4240 26 seen see VBN 37231 4240 27 . . . 37231 4241 1 In in IN 37231 4241 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4241 3 " " `` 37231 4241 4 Demonstration Demonstration NNP 37231 4241 5 of of IN 37231 4241 6 the the DT 37231 4241 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4241 8 " " `` 37231 4241 9 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4241 10 , , , 37231 4241 11 referring refer VBG 37231 4241 12 to to IN 37231 4241 13 the the DT 37231 4241 14 same same JJ 37231 4241 15 tradition tradition NN 37231 4241 16 , , , 37231 4241 17 affirms affirm VBZ 37231 4241 18 that that IN 37231 4241 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4241 20 was be VBD 37231 4241 21 the the DT 37231 4241 22 modesty modesty NN 37231 4241 23 of of IN 37231 4241 24 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4241 25 which which WDT 37231 4241 26 prevented prevent VBD 37231 4241 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4241 28 writing writing NN 37231 4241 29 a a DT 37231 4241 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4241 31 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4241 32 . . . 37231 4242 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4242 2 1 1 LS 37231 4242 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4242 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4242 5 almost almost RB 37231 4242 6 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 4242 7 the the DT 37231 4242 8 preceding precede VBG 37231 4242 9 account account NN 37231 4242 10 of of IN 37231 4242 11 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4242 12 : : : 37231 4242 13 " " `` 37231 4242 14 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4242 15 , , , 37231 4242 16 the the DT 37231 4242 17 disciple disciple NN 37231 4242 18 and and CC 37231 4242 19 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4242 20 of of IN 37231 4242 21 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4242 22 , , , 37231 4242 23 being be VBG 37231 4242 24 entreated entreat VBN 37231 4242 25 by by IN 37231 4242 26 the the DT 37231 4242 27 brethren brother NNS 37231 4242 28 of of IN 37231 4242 29 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4242 30 , , , 37231 4242 31 wrote write VBD 37231 4242 32 a a DT 37231 4242 33 short short JJ 37231 4242 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4242 35 according accord VBG 37231 4242 36 to to IN 37231 4242 37 what what WP 37231 4242 38 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4242 39 had have VBD 37231 4242 40 received receive VBN 37231 4242 41 from from IN 37231 4242 42 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4242 43 , , , 37231 4242 44 which which WDT 37231 4242 45 when when WRB 37231 4242 46 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4242 47 heard hear VBD 37231 4242 48 , , , 37231 4242 49 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4242 50 approved approve VBD 37231 4242 51 , , , 37231 4242 52 and and CC 37231 4242 53 gave give VBD 37231 4242 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4242 55 authority authority NN 37231 4242 56 for for IN 37231 4242 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4242 58 being be VBG 37231 4242 59 read read VBN 37231 4242 60 in in IN 37231 4242 61 the the DT 37231 4242 62 Churches Churches NNPS 37231 4242 63 , , , 37231 4242 64 as as IN 37231 4242 65 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4242 66 writes write VBZ 37231 4242 67 in in IN 37231 4242 68 the the DT 37231 4242 69 sixth sixth JJ 37231 4242 70 book book NN 37231 4242 71 of of IN 37231 4242 72 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4242 73 Institutions,"(3 Institutions,"(3 NNP 37231 4242 74 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4242 75 & & CC 37231 4242 76 c. c. NNP 37231 4242 77 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4242 78 moreover moreover RB 37231 4242 79 says say VBZ 37231 4242 80 that that IN 37231 4242 81 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4242 82 had have VBD 37231 4242 83 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4242 84 for for IN 37231 4242 85 an an DT 37231 4242 86 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4242 87 , , , 37231 4242 88 " " '' 37231 4242 89 whose whose WP$ 37231 4242 90 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4242 91 was be VBD 37231 4242 92 composed compose VBN 37231 4242 93 : : : 37231 4242 94 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4242 95 narrating narrating NN 37231 4242 96 and and CC 37231 4242 97 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4242 98 writing write VBG 37231 4242 99 " " '' 37231 4242 100 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4242 101 cujus cujus NNP 37231 4242 102 evangelium evangelium NN 37231 4242 103 Petro Petro NNP 37231 4242 104 narrante narrante JJ 37231 4242 105 et et FW 37231 4242 106 illo illo NN 37231 4242 107 scribente scribente NNP 37231 4242 108 compositum compositum NN 37231 4242 109 est est NNP 37231 4242 110 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4242 111 . . . 37231 4243 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4243 2 3 3 LS 37231 4243 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4243 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4243 5 is be VBZ 37231 4243 6 evident evident JJ 37231 4243 7 that that IN 37231 4243 8 all all PDT 37231 4243 9 these these DT 37231 4243 10 writers writer NNS 37231 4243 11 merely merely RB 37231 4243 12 repeat repeat VBP 37231 4243 13 with with IN 37231 4243 14 variations variation NNS 37231 4243 15 the the DT 37231 4243 16 tradition tradition NN 37231 4243 17 regarding regard VBG 37231 4243 18 the the DT 37231 4243 19 first first JJ 37231 4243 20 two two CD 37231 4243 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4243 22 which which WDT 37231 4243 23 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4243 24 originated originate VBD 37231 4243 25 . . . 37231 4244 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4244 2 dates date VBZ 37231 4244 3 the the DT 37231 4244 4 writing writing NN 37231 4244 5 of of IN 37231 4244 6 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4244 7 after after IN 37231 4244 8 the the DT 37231 4244 9 death death NN 37231 4244 10 of of IN 37231 4244 11 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4244 12 and and CC 37231 4244 13 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4244 14 in in IN 37231 4244 15 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4244 16 . . . 37231 4245 1 Clement clement NN 37231 4245 2 describes describe VBZ 37231 4245 3 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4245 4 as as IN 37231 4245 5 writing writing NN 37231 4245 6 during during IN 37231 4245 7 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4245 8 's 's POS 37231 4245 9 life life NN 37231 4245 10 , , , 37231 4245 11 the the DT 37231 4245 12 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4245 13 preserving preserve VBG 37231 4245 14 absolute absolute JJ 37231 4245 15 neutrality neutrality NN 37231 4245 16 . . . 37231 4246 1 By by IN 37231 4246 2 the the DT 37231 4246 3 time time NN 37231 4246 4 of of IN 37231 4246 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4246 6 , , , 37231 4246 7 however however RB 37231 4246 8 , , , 37231 4246 9 the the DT 37231 4246 10 tradition tradition NN 37231 4246 11 has have VBZ 37231 4246 12 acquired acquire VBN 37231 4246 13 new new JJ 37231 4246 14 and and CC 37231 4246 15 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 4246 16 elements element NNS 37231 4246 17 and and CC 37231 4246 18 a a DT 37231 4246 19 more more RBR 37231 4246 20 decided decided JJ 37231 4246 21 character character NN 37231 4246 22 -- -- : 37231 4246 23 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4246 24 is be VBZ 37231 4246 25 made make VBN 37231 4246 26 aware aware JJ 37231 4246 27 of of IN 37231 4246 28 the the DT 37231 4246 29 undertaking undertaking NN 37231 4246 30 of of IN 37231 4246 31 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4246 32 through through IN 37231 4246 33 a a DT 37231 4246 34 revelation revelation NN 37231 4246 35 of of IN 37231 4246 36 the the DT 37231 4246 37 Spirit Spirit NNP 37231 4246 38 , , , 37231 4246 39 and and CC 37231 4246 40 instead instead RB 37231 4246 41 of of IN 37231 4246 42 being be VBG 37231 4246 43 neutral neutral JJ 37231 4246 44 is be VBZ 37231 4246 45 delighted delighted JJ 37231 4246 46 and and CC 37231 4246 47 lends lend VBZ 37231 4246 48 the the DT 37231 4246 49 work work NN 37231 4246 50 the the DT 37231 4246 51 weight weight NN 37231 4246 52 of of IN 37231 4246 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4246 54 authority authority NN 37231 4246 55 . . . 37231 4247 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4247 2 refers refer VBZ 37231 4247 3 to to IN 37231 4247 4 Clement Clement NNP 37231 4247 5 and and CC 37231 4247 6 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4247 7 as as IN 37231 4247 8 giving give VBG 37231 4247 9 the the DT 37231 4247 10 same same JJ 37231 4247 11 account account NN 37231 4247 12 , , , 37231 4247 13 which which WDT 37231 4247 14 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4247 15 do do VBP 37231 4247 16 { { -LRB- 37231 4247 17 452 452 CD 37231 4247 18 } } -RRB- 37231 4247 19 not not RB 37231 4247 20 , , , 37231 4247 21 however however RB 37231 4247 22 , , , 37231 4247 23 and and CC 37231 4247 24 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4247 25 merely merely RB 37231 4247 26 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 4247 27 the the DT 37231 4247 28 story story NN 37231 4247 29 of of IN 37231 4247 30 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4247 31 without without IN 37231 4247 32 naming name VBG 37231 4247 33 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4247 34 , , , 37231 4247 35 and and CC 37231 4247 36 the the DT 37231 4247 37 tradition tradition NN 37231 4247 38 which which WDT 37231 4247 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4247 40 had have VBD 37231 4247 41 embellished embellish VBN 37231 4247 42 thus thus RB 37231 4247 43 becomes become VBZ 37231 4247 44 endorsed endorse VBN 37231 4247 45 and and CC 37231 4247 46 perpetuated perpetuate VBN 37231 4247 47 . . . 37231 4248 1 Such such JJ 37231 4248 2 is be VBZ 37231 4248 3 the the DT 37231 4248 4 growth growth NN 37231 4248 5 of of IN 37231 4248 6 tradition;(l tradition;(l NN 37231 4248 7 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4248 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4248 9 is be VBZ 37231 4248 10 impossible impossible JJ 37231 4248 11 to to TO 37231 4248 12 overlook overlook VB 37231 4248 13 the the DT 37231 4248 14 mythical mythical JJ 37231 4248 15 character character NN 37231 4248 16 of of IN 37231 4248 17 the the DT 37231 4248 18 information information NN 37231 4248 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4248 20 possess possess VBP 37231 4248 21 as as IN 37231 4248 22 to to IN 37231 4248 23 the the DT 37231 4248 24 origin origin NN 37231 4248 25 of of IN 37231 4248 26 the the DT 37231 4248 27 second second JJ 37231 4248 28 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4248 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4248 30 . . . 37231 4249 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4249 2 2 2 LS 37231 4249 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4249 4 In in IN 37231 4249 5 a a DT 37231 4249 6 Gospel gospel NN 37231 4249 7 so so RB 37231 4249 8 completely completely RB 37231 4249 9 inspired inspire VBN 37231 4249 10 by by IN 37231 4249 11 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4249 12 as as IN 37231 4249 13 the the DT 37231 4249 14 tradition tradition NN 37231 4249 15 of of IN 37231 4249 16 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4249 17 and and CC 37231 4249 18 of of IN 37231 4249 19 the the DT 37231 4249 20 early early JJ 37231 4249 21 Church Church NNP 37231 4249 22 indicates indicate VBZ 37231 4249 23 , , , 37231 4249 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4249 25 may may MD 37231 4249 26 reasonably reasonably RB 37231 4249 27 expect expect VB 37231 4249 28 to to TO 37231 4249 29 find find VB 37231 4249 30 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 37231 4249 31 traces trace NNS 37231 4249 32 of of IN 37231 4249 33 Petrine Petrine NNP 37231 4249 34 influence influence NN 37231 4249 35 , , , 37231 4249 36 but but CC 37231 4249 37 on on IN 37231 4249 38 examination examination NN 37231 4249 39 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4249 40 will will MD 37231 4249 41 be be VB 37231 4249 42 seen see VBN 37231 4249 43 that that IN 37231 4249 44 these these DT 37231 4249 45 are be VBP 37231 4249 46 totally totally RB 37231 4249 47 wanting want VBG 37231 4249 48 . . . 37231 4250 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4250 2 3 3 LS 37231 4250 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4250 4 Some some DT 37231 4250 5 of of IN 37231 4250 6 the the DT 37231 4250 7 early early JJ 37231 4250 8 Church Church NNP 37231 4250 9 did do VBD 37231 4250 10 not not RB 37231 4250 11 fail fail VB 37231 4250 12 to to TO 37231 4250 13 remark remark VB 37231 4250 14 this this DT 37231 4250 15 singular singular JJ 37231 4250 16 discrepancy discrepancy NN 37231 4250 17 between between IN 37231 4250 18 the the DT 37231 4250 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4250 20 and and CC 37231 4250 21 the the DT 37231 4250 22 tradition tradition NN 37231 4250 23 of of IN 37231 4250 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4250 25 dependence dependence NN 37231 4250 26 on on IN 37231 4250 27 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4250 28 , , , 37231 4250 29 and and CC 37231 4250 30 in in IN 37231 4250 31 reply reply NN 37231 4250 32 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4250 33 adopts adopt VBZ 37231 4250 34 an an DT 37231 4250 35 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 4250 36 tone tone NN 37231 4250 37 . . . 37231 4251 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4251 2 4 4 LS 37231 4251 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4251 4 For for IN 37231 4251 5 instance instance NN 37231 4251 6 , , , 37231 4251 7 in in IN 37231 4251 8 the the DT 37231 4251 9 brief brief JJ 37231 4251 10 account account NN 37231 4251 11 of of IN 37231 4251 12 the the DT 37231 4251 13 calling calling NN 37231 4251 14 of of IN 37231 4251 15 Simon Simon NNP 37231 4251 16 in in IN 37231 4251 17 1 1 CD 37231 4251 18 A a DT 37231 4251 19 similar similar JJ 37231 4251 20 discrepancy discrepancy NN 37231 4251 21 of of IN 37231 4251 22 tradition tradition NN 37231 4251 23 is be VBZ 37231 4251 24 to to TO 37231 4251 25 be be VB 37231 4251 26 observed observe VBN 37231 4251 27 as as IN 37231 4251 28 to to IN 37231 4251 29 the the DT 37231 4251 30 place place NN 37231 4251 31 in in IN 37231 4251 32 which which WDT 37231 4251 33 the the DT 37231 4251 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4251 35 was be VBD 37231 4251 36 written write VBN 37231 4251 37 , , , 37231 4251 38 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4251 39 and and CC 37231 4251 40 others other NNS 37231 4251 41 dating date VBG 37231 4251 42 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4251 43 from from IN 37231 4251 44 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4251 45 , , , 37231 4251 46 and and CC 37231 4251 47 others other NNS 37231 4251 48 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4251 49 as as IN 37231 4251 50 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 37231 4251 51 , , , 37231 4251 52 in in IN 37231 4251 53 Matth Matth NNP 37231 4251 54 . . . 37231 4252 1 Homil Homil NNP 37231 4252 2 . . . 37231 4252 3 , , , 37231 4252 4 i. i. NNP 37231 4253 1 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4253 2 , , , 37231 4253 3 assigning assign VBG 37231 4253 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4253 5 to to IN 37231 4253 6 Egypt Egypt NNP 37231 4253 7 . . . 37231 4254 1 Indeed indeed RB 37231 4254 2 some some DT 37231 4254 3 MSS mss NN 37231 4254 4 . . . 37231 4255 1 of of IN 37231 4255 2 the the DT 37231 4255 3 second second JJ 37231 4255 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4255 5 have have VBP 37231 4255 6 the the DT 37231 4255 7 words word NNS 37231 4255 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4255 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4255 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4255 11 in in IN 37231 4255 12 accordance accordance NN 37231 4255 13 with with IN 37231 4255 14 this this DT 37231 4255 15 tradition tradition NN 37231 4255 16 as as IN 37231 4255 17 to to IN 37231 4255 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4255 19 origin origin NN 37231 4255 20 . . . 37231 4256 1 Cf cf NN 37231 4256 2 . . . 37231 4257 1 Scholz Scholz NNP 37231 4257 2 , , , 37231 4257 3 Einl Einl NNP 37231 4257 4 . . . 37231 4258 1 N. N. NNP 37231 4258 2 T. T. NNP 37231 4258 3 , , , 37231 4258 4 i. i. NNP 37231 4258 5 p. p. NN 37231 4258 6 201 201 CD 37231 4258 7 . . . 37231 4259 1 Various various JJ 37231 4259 2 critics critic NNS 37231 4259 3 have have VBP 37231 4259 4 argued argue VBN 37231 4259 5 for for IN 37231 4259 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4259 7 composition composition NN 37231 4259 8 at at IN 37231 4259 9 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4259 10 , , , 37231 4259 11 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4259 12 , , , 37231 4259 13 and and CC 37231 4259 14 Antioch Antioch NNP 37231 4259 15 . . . 37231 4260 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4260 2 do do VBP 37231 4260 3 not not RB 37231 4260 4 go go VB 37231 4260 5 into into IN 37231 4260 6 the the DT 37231 4260 7 discussion discussion NN 37231 4260 8 as as IN 37231 4260 9 to to IN 37231 4260 10 whether whether IN 37231 4260 11 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4260 12 ever ever RB 37231 4260 13 was be VBD 37231 4260 14 in in IN 37231 4260 15 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4260 16 . . . 37231 4261 1 { { -LRB- 37231 4261 2 453 453 CD 37231 4261 3 } } -RRB- 37231 4261 4 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4261 5 , , , 37231 4261 6 the the DT 37231 4261 7 distinguishing distinguish VBG 37231 4261 8 addition addition NN 37231 4261 9 : : : 37231 4261 10 " " `` 37231 4261 11 called call VBD 37231 4261 12 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4261 13 , , , 37231 4261 14 " " '' 37231 4261 15 of of IN 37231 4261 16 the the DT 37231 4261 17 first first JJ 37231 4261 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4261 19 is be VBZ 37231 4261 20 omitted,(1 omitted,(1 VBN 37231 4261 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4261 22 and and CC 37231 4261 23 still still RB 37231 4261 24 more more RBR 37231 4261 25 notably notably RB 37231 4261 26 the the DT 37231 4261 27 whole whole JJ 37231 4261 28 narrative narrative NN 37231 4261 29 of of IN 37231 4261 30 the the DT 37231 4261 31 miraculous miraculous JJ 37231 4261 32 draught draught NN 37231 4261 33 of of IN 37231 4261 34 fishes fish NNS 37231 4261 35 , , , 37231 4261 36 which which WDT 37231 4261 37 gives give VBZ 37231 4261 38 the the DT 37231 4261 39 event event NN 37231 4261 40 such such JJ 37231 4261 41 prominence prominence NN 37231 4261 42 in in IN 37231 4261 43 the the DT 37231 4261 44 third third JJ 37231 4261 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4261 46 . . . 37231 4262 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4262 2 2 2 LS 37231 4262 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4262 4 In in IN 37231 4262 5 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4262 6 , , , 37231 4262 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4262 8 goes go VBZ 37231 4262 9 into into IN 37231 4262 10 the the DT 37231 4262 11 house house NN 37231 4262 12 of of IN 37231 4262 13 " " `` 37231 4262 14 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4262 15 " " '' 37231 4262 16 to to TO 37231 4262 17 cure cure VB 37231 4262 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4262 19 wife wife NN 37231 4262 20 's 's POS 37231 4262 21 mother mother NN 37231 4262 22 of of IN 37231 4262 23 a a DT 37231 4262 24 fever fever NN 37231 4262 25 , , , 37231 4262 26 whilst whilst IN 37231 4262 27 in in IN 37231 4262 28 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4262 29 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4262 30 is be VBZ 37231 4262 31 " " `` 37231 4262 32 into into IN 37231 4262 33 the the DT 37231 4262 34 house house NN 37231 4262 35 of of IN 37231 4262 36 Simon Simon NNP 37231 4262 37 and and CC 37231 4262 38 Andrew Andrew NNP 37231 4262 39 , , , 37231 4262 40 " " `` 37231 4262 41 the the DT 37231 4262 42 less less RBR 37231 4262 43 honourable honourable JJ 37231 4262 44 name name NN 37231 4262 45 being be VBG 37231 4262 46 still still RB 37231 4262 47 continued continue VBN 37231 4262 48 . . . 37231 4263 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4263 2 3 3 LS 37231 4263 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4263 4 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4263 5 commences commence VBZ 37231 4263 6 the the DT 37231 4263 7 catalogue catalogue NN 37231 4263 8 of of IN 37231 4263 9 the the DT 37231 4263 10 twelve twelve CD 37231 4263 11 by by IN 37231 4263 12 the the DT 37231 4263 13 pointed pointed JJ 37231 4263 14 indication indication NN 37231 4263 15 : : : 37231 4263 16 " " `` 37231 4263 17 The the DT 37231 4263 18 first first JJ 37231 4263 19 , , , 37231 4263 20 Simon Simon NNP 37231 4263 21 , , , 37231 4263 22 who who WP 37231 4263 23 is be VBZ 37231 4263 24 called call VBN 37231 4263 25 Peter,"(4 Peter,"(4 NNP 37231 4263 26 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4263 27 thus thus RB 37231 4263 28 giving give VBG 37231 4263 29 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4263 30 precedence precedence NN 37231 4263 31 , , , 37231 4263 32 whilst whilst IN 37231 4263 33 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4263 34 merely merely RB 37231 4263 35 says say VBZ 37231 4263 36 : : : 37231 4263 37 " " `` 37231 4263 38 And and CC 37231 4263 39 Simon Simon NNP 37231 4263 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4263 41 surnamed surname VBD 37231 4263 42 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4263 43 . . . 37231 4264 1 " " `` 37231 4264 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4264 3 5 5 LS 37231 4264 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4264 5 The the DT 37231 4264 6 important important JJ 37231 4264 7 episode episode NN 37231 4264 8 of of IN 37231 4264 9 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4264 10 's 's POS 37231 4264 11 walking walking NN 37231 4264 12 on on IN 37231 4264 13 the the DT 37231 4264 14 sea sea NN 37231 4264 15 , , , 37231 4264 16 of of IN 37231 4264 17 the the DT 37231 4264 18 first first JJ 37231 4264 19 Gospel,(6 Gospel,(6 NNP 37231 4264 20 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4264 21 is be VBZ 37231 4264 22 altogether altogether RB 37231 4264 23 ignored ignore VBN 37231 4264 24 by by IN 37231 4264 25 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4264 26 . . . 37231 4265 1 The the DT 37231 4265 2 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 37231 4265 3 declaration declaration NN 37231 4265 4 of of IN 37231 4265 5 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4265 6 : : : 37231 4265 7 " " `` 37231 4265 8 Thou Thou NNP 37231 4265 9 art art NN 37231 4265 10 the the DT 37231 4265 11 Christ,"(7 christ,"(7 NN 37231 4265 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4265 13 is be VBZ 37231 4265 14 only only RB 37231 4265 15 followed follow VBN 37231 4265 16 by by IN 37231 4265 17 the the DT 37231 4265 18 chilling chilling JJ 37231 4265 19 injunction injunction NN 37231 4265 20 to to TO 37231 4265 21 tell tell VB 37231 4265 22 no no DT 37231 4265 23 one one NN 37231 4265 24 , , , 37231 4265 25 in in IN 37231 4265 26 the the DT 37231 4265 27 second second JJ 37231 4265 28 Gospel,(8 gospel,(8 NN 37231 4265 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4265 30 whilst whilst IN 37231 4265 31 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4265 32 not not RB 37231 4265 33 only only RB 37231 4265 34 gives give VBZ 37231 4265 35 greater great JJR 37231 4265 36 prominence prominence NN 37231 4265 37 to to IN 37231 4265 38 the the DT 37231 4265 39 declaration declaration NN 37231 4265 40 of of IN 37231 4265 41 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4265 42 , , , 37231 4265 43 but but CC 37231 4265 44 gives give VBZ 37231 4265 45 the the DT 37231 4265 46 reply reply NN 37231 4265 47 of of IN 37231 4265 48 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4265 49 : : : 37231 4265 50 " " `` 37231 4265 51 Blessed bless VBN 37231 4265 52 art art NN 37231 4265 53 thou thou NN 37231 4265 54 , , , 37231 4265 55 Simon Simon NNP 37231 4265 56 Bar Bar NNP 37231 4265 57 - - HYPH 37231 4265 58 jona jona NNP 37231 4265 59 , , , 37231 4265 60 " " '' 37231 4265 61 & & CC 37231 4265 62 c,--of c,--of VB 37231 4265 63 which which WDT 37231 4265 64 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4265 65 apparently apparently RB 37231 4265 66 knows know VBZ 37231 4265 67 nothing,--and nothing,--and NNP 37231 4265 68 then then RB 37231 4265 69 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 4265 70 to to IN 37231 4265 71 the the DT 37231 4265 72 most most RBS 37231 4265 73 important important JJ 37231 4265 74 episode episode NN 37231 4265 75 in in IN 37231 4265 76 the the DT 37231 4265 77 history history NN 37231 4265 78 of of IN 37231 4265 79 the the DT 37231 4265 80 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4265 81 , , , 37231 4265 82 the the DT 37231 4265 83 celebrated celebrate VBN 37231 4265 84 words word NNS 37231 4265 85 by by IN 37231 4265 86 which which WDT 37231 4265 87 the the DT 37231 4265 88 surname surname NN 37231 4265 89 of of IN 37231 4265 90 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4265 91 was be VBD 37231 4265 92 conferred confer VBN 37231 4265 93 upon upon IN 37231 4265 94 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4265 95 : : : 37231 4265 96 " " `` 37231 4265 97 And and CC 37231 4265 98 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4265 99 say say VBP 37231 4265 100 unto unto IN 37231 4265 101 thee thee PRP 37231 4265 102 , , , 37231 4265 103 that that WDT 37231 4265 104 thou thou NNP 37231 4265 105 art art NNP 37231 4265 106 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4265 107 , , , 37231 4265 108 and and CC 37231 4265 109 upon upon IN 37231 4265 110 this this DT 37231 4265 111 rock rock NN 37231 4265 112 will will MD 37231 4265 113 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4265 114 build build VB 37231 4265 115 my -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4265 116 Church Church NNP 37231 4265 117 , , , 37231 4265 118 " " '' 37231 4265 119 & & CC 37231 4265 120 c.(9 c.(9 NNP 37231 4265 121 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4265 122 The the DT 37231 4265 123 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4265 124 supposed suppose VBD 37231 4265 125 to to TO 37231 4265 126 be be VB 37231 4265 127 inspired inspire VBN 37231 4265 128 by by IN 37231 4265 129 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4265 130 , , , 37231 4265 131 however however RB 37231 4265 132 , , , 37231 4265 133 totally totally RB 37231 4265 134 omits omit VBZ 37231 4265 135 this this DT 37231 4265 136 most most RBS 37231 4265 137 important important JJ 37231 4265 138 passage passage NN 37231 4265 139 ; ; : 37231 4265 140 as as IN 37231 4265 141 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4265 142 also also RB 37231 4265 143 does do VBZ 37231 4265 144 the the DT 37231 4265 145 miracle miracle NN 37231 4265 146 of of IN 37231 4265 147 the the DT 37231 4265 148 finding finding NN 37231 4265 149 the the DT 37231 4265 150 tribute tribute NN 37231 4265 151 money money NN 37231 4265 152 in in IN 37231 4265 153 the the DT 37231 4265 154 fish fish NN 37231 4265 155 's 's POS 37231 4265 156 mouth mouth NN 37231 4265 157 , , , 37231 4265 158 narrated narrate VBN 37231 4265 159 by by IN 37231 4265 160 the the DT 37231 4265 161 first first JJ 37231 4265 162 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4265 163 . . . 37231 4266 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4266 2 10 10 LS 37231 4266 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4266 4 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4266 5 states state VBZ 37231 4266 6 that that IN 37231 4266 7 " " `` 37231 4266 8 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4266 9 { { -LRB- 37231 4266 10 454 454 CD 37231 4266 11 } } -RRB- 37231 4266 12 and and CC 37231 4266 13 John John NNP 37231 4266 14 " " '' 37231 4266 15 are be VBP 37231 4266 16 sent send VBN 37231 4266 17 to to TO 37231 4266 18 prepare prepare VB 37231 4266 19 the the DT 37231 4266 20 Passover Passover NNP 37231 4266 21 , , , 37231 4266 22 whilst whilst IN 37231 4266 23 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4266 24 has have VBZ 37231 4266 25 only only RB 37231 4266 26 " " `` 37231 4266 27 two two CD 37231 4266 28 disciples;"(1 disciples;"(1 RB 37231 4266 29 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4266 30 and and CC 37231 4266 31 in in IN 37231 4266 32 the the DT 37231 4266 33 account account NN 37231 4266 34 of of IN 37231 4266 35 the the DT 37231 4266 36 last last JJ 37231 4266 37 Supper Supper NNP 37231 4266 38 , , , 37231 4266 39 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4266 40 gives give VBZ 37231 4266 41 the the DT 37231 4266 42 address address NN 37231 4266 43 of of IN 37231 4266 44 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4266 45 to to IN 37231 4266 46 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4266 47 : : : 37231 4266 48 " " `` 37231 4266 49 Simon Simon NNP 37231 4266 50 , , , 37231 4266 51 Simon Simon NNP 37231 4266 52 , , , 37231 4266 53 behold behold NN 37231 4266 54 Satan Satan NNP 37231 4266 55 hath hath NN 37231 4266 56 desired desire VBN 37231 4266 57 to to TO 37231 4266 58 have have VB 37231 4266 59 you -PRON- PRP 37231 4266 60 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4266 61 all all DT 37231 4266 62 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4266 63 that that IN 37231 4266 64 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4266 65 may may MD 37231 4266 66 sift sift VB 37231 4266 67 you -PRON- PRP 37231 4266 68 as as IN 37231 4266 69 wheat wheat NN 37231 4266 70 ; ; : 37231 4266 71 but but CC 37231 4266 72 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4266 73 have have VBP 37231 4266 74 prayed pray VBN 37231 4266 75 for for IN 37231 4266 76 thee thee PRP 37231 4266 77 that that WDT 37231 4266 78 thy thy PRP$ 37231 4266 79 faith faith NN 37231 4266 80 fail fail VBP 37231 4266 81 not not RB 37231 4266 82 ; ; : 37231 4266 83 and and CC 37231 4266 84 when when WRB 37231 4266 85 thou thou NNP 37231 4266 86 art art NNP 37231 4266 87 converted convert VBD 37231 4266 88 , , , 37231 4266 89 strengthen strengthen VB 37231 4266 90 thy thy PRP$ 37231 4266 91 brethren brother NNS 37231 4266 92 . . . 37231 4267 1 " " `` 37231 4267 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4267 3 2 2 LS 37231 4267 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4267 5 Of of IN 37231 4267 6 this this DT 37231 4267 7 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4267 8 does do VBZ 37231 4267 9 not not RB 37231 4267 10 say say VB 37231 4267 11 a a DT 37231 4267 12 word word NN 37231 4267 13 . . . 37231 4268 1 Again again RB 37231 4268 2 , , , 37231 4268 3 after after IN 37231 4268 4 the the DT 37231 4268 5 denial denial NN 37231 4268 6 , , , 37231 4268 7 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4268 8 reads read VBZ 37231 4268 9 : : : 37231 4268 10 " " `` 37231 4268 11 And and CC 37231 4268 12 the the DT 37231 4268 13 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4268 14 turned turn VBD 37231 4268 15 and and CC 37231 4268 16 looked look VBD 37231 4268 17 upon upon IN 37231 4268 18 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4268 19 , , , 37231 4268 20 and and CC 37231 4268 21 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4268 22 remembered remember VBD 37231 4268 23 the the DT 37231 4268 24 word word NN 37231 4268 25 of of IN 37231 4268 26 the the DT 37231 4268 27 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4268 28 , , , 37231 4268 29 & & CC 37231 4268 30 c c NNP 37231 4268 31 , , , 37231 4268 32 and and CC 37231 4268 33 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4268 34 went go VBD 37231 4268 35 out out RP 37231 4268 36 and and CC 37231 4268 37 wept weep VBD 37231 4268 38 bitterly;"(3 bitterly;"(3 NNP 37231 4268 39 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4268 40 whereas whereas IN 37231 4268 41 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4268 42 omits omit VBZ 37231 4268 43 the the DT 37231 4268 44 reproachful reproachful JJ 37231 4268 45 look look NN 37231 4268 46 of of IN 37231 4268 47 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4268 48 , , , 37231 4268 49 and and CC 37231 4268 50 makes make VBZ 37231 4268 51 the the DT 37231 4268 52 penitence penitence NN 37231 4268 53 of of IN 37231 4268 54 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4268 55 depend depend VBP 37231 4268 56 merely merely RB 37231 4268 57 on on IN 37231 4268 58 the the DT 37231 4268 59 second second JJ 37231 4268 60 crowing crowing NN 37231 4268 61 of of IN 37231 4268 62 the the DT 37231 4268 63 cock cock NN 37231 4268 64 , , , 37231 4268 65 and and CC 37231 4268 66 further further JJ 37231 4268 67 modifies modify VBZ 37231 4268 68 the the DT 37231 4268 69 penitence penitence NN 37231 4268 70 by by IN 37231 4268 71 the the DT 37231 4268 72 omission omission NN 37231 4268 73 of of IN 37231 4268 74 " " `` 37231 4268 75 bitterl"-- bitterl"-- NNP 37231 4268 76 " " '' 37231 4268 77 And and CC 37231 4268 78 when when WRB 37231 4268 79 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4268 80 thought think VBD 37231 4268 81 thereon thereon NN 37231 4268 82 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4268 83 wept weep VBD 37231 4268 84 . . . 37231 4269 1 " " `` 37231 4269 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4269 3 4 4 LS 37231 4269 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4269 5 There there EX 37231 4269 6 are be VBP 37231 4269 7 other other JJ 37231 4269 8 instances instance NNS 37231 4269 9 to to TO 37231 4269 10 which which WDT 37231 4269 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4269 12 need need VBP 37231 4269 13 not not RB 37231 4269 14 refer refer VB 37231 4269 15 . . . 37231 4270 1 Not not RB 37231 4270 2 only only RB 37231 4270 3 are be VBP 37231 4270 4 some some DT 37231 4270 5 of of IN 37231 4270 6 the the DT 37231 4270 7 most most RBS 37231 4270 8 important important JJ 37231 4270 9 episodes episode NNS 37231 4270 10 in in IN 37231 4270 11 which which WDT 37231 4270 12 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4270 13 is be VBZ 37231 4270 14 represented represent VBN 37231 4270 15 by by IN 37231 4270 16 the the DT 37231 4270 17 other other JJ 37231 4270 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4270 19 as as IN 37231 4270 20 a a DT 37231 4270 21 principal principal JJ 37231 4270 22 actor actor NN 37231 4270 23 altogether altogether RB 37231 4270 24 omitted omit VBN 37231 4270 25 , , , 37231 4270 26 but but CC 37231 4270 27 throughout throughout IN 37231 4270 28 the the DT 37231 4270 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4270 30 there there EX 37231 4270 31 is be VBZ 37231 4270 32 the the DT 37231 4270 33 total total JJ 37231 4270 34 absence absence NN 37231 4270 35 of of IN 37231 4270 36 anything anything NN 37231 4270 37 which which WDT 37231 4270 38 is be VBZ 37231 4270 39 specially specially RB 37231 4270 40 characteristic characteristic JJ 37231 4270 41 of of IN 37231 4270 42 Petrine Petrine NNP 37231 4270 43 influence influence NN 37231 4270 44 and and CC 37231 4270 45 teaching teaching NN 37231 4270 46 . . . 37231 4271 1 The the DT 37231 4271 2 argument argument NN 37231 4271 3 that that IN 37231 4271 4 these these DT 37231 4271 5 omissions omission NNS 37231 4271 6 are be VBP 37231 4271 7 due due JJ 37231 4271 8 to to IN 37231 4271 9 the the DT 37231 4271 10 modesty modesty NN 37231 4271 11 of of IN 37231 4271 12 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4271 13 is be VBZ 37231 4271 14 quite quite RB 37231 4271 15 untenable untenable JJ 37231 4271 16 , , , 37231 4271 17 for for IN 37231 4271 18 not not RB 37231 4271 19 only only RB 37231 4271 20 does do VBZ 37231 4271 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4271 22 , , , 37231 4271 23 the the DT 37231 4271 24 most most RBS 37231 4271 25 ancient ancient JJ 37231 4271 26 authority authority NN 37231 4271 27 on on IN 37231 4271 28 the the DT 37231 4271 29 point point NN 37231 4271 30 , , , 37231 4271 31 state state NN 37231 4271 32 that that IN 37231 4271 33 this this DT 37231 4271 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4271 35 was be VBD 37231 4271 36 only only RB 37231 4271 37 written write VBN 37231 4271 38 after after IN 37231 4271 39 the the DT 37231 4271 40 death death NN 37231 4271 41 of of IN 37231 4271 42 Peter,(5 peter,(5 NN 37231 4271 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4271 44 but but CC 37231 4271 45 also also RB 37231 4271 46 there there EX 37231 4271 47 is be VBZ 37231 4271 48 no no DT 37231 4271 49 modesty modesty NN 37231 4271 50 in in IN 37231 4271 51 omitting omit VBG 37231 4271 52 passages passage NNS 37231 4271 53 of of IN 37231 4271 54 importance importance NN 37231 4271 55 in in IN 37231 4271 56 the the DT 37231 4271 57 history history NN 37231 4271 58 of of IN 37231 4271 59 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4271 60 , , , 37231 4271 61 simply simply RB 37231 4271 62 because because IN 37231 4271 63 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4271 64 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4271 65 was be VBD 37231 4271 66 in in IN 37231 4271 67 some some DT 37231 4271 68 way way NN 37231 4271 69 concerned concern VBN 37231 4271 70 in in IN 37231 4271 71 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4271 72 , , , 37231 4271 73 or or CC 37231 4271 74 , , , 37231 4271 75 for for IN 37231 4271 76 instance instance NN 37231 4271 77 , , , 37231 4271 78 in in IN 37231 4271 79 decreasing decrease VBG 37231 4271 80 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4271 81 penitence penitence NN 37231 4271 82 for for IN 37231 4271 83 such such PDT 37231 4271 84 a a DT 37231 4271 85 denial denial JJ 37231 4271 86 { { -LRB- 37231 4271 87 455 455 CD 37231 4271 88 } } -RRB- 37231 4271 89 of of IN 37231 4271 90 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4271 91 master master NN 37231 4271 92 , , , 37231 4271 93 which which WDT 37231 4271 94 could could MD 37231 4271 95 not not RB 37231 4271 96 but but CC 37231 4271 97 have have VBP 37231 4271 98 filled fill VBN 37231 4271 99 a a DT 37231 4271 100 sad sad JJ 37231 4271 101 place place NN 37231 4271 102 in in IN 37231 4271 103 the the DT 37231 4271 104 Apostle apostle NN 37231 4271 105 's 's POS 37231 4271 106 memory memory NN 37231 4271 107 . . . 37231 4272 1 On on IN 37231 4272 2 the the DT 37231 4272 3 other other JJ 37231 4272 4 hand hand NN 37231 4272 5 , , , 37231 4272 6 there there EX 37231 4272 7 is be VBZ 37231 4272 8 no no DT 37231 4272 9 adequate adequate JJ 37231 4272 10 record record NN 37231 4272 11 of of IN 37231 4272 12 special special JJ 37231 4272 13 matter matter NN 37231 4272 14 , , , 37231 4272 15 which which WDT 37231 4272 16 the the DT 37231 4272 17 intimate intimate JJ 37231 4272 18 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 4272 19 of of IN 37231 4272 20 the the DT 37231 4272 21 doings doing NNS 37231 4272 22 and and CC 37231 4272 23 sayings saying NNS 37231 4272 24 of of IN 37231 4272 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4272 26 possessed possess VBN 37231 4272 27 by by IN 37231 4272 28 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4272 29 might may MD 37231 4272 30 have have VB 37231 4272 31 supplied supply VBN 37231 4272 32 , , , 37231 4272 33 to to TO 37231 4272 34 counterbalance counterbalance VB 37231 4272 35 the the DT 37231 4272 36 singular singular JJ 37231 4272 37 omissions omission NNS 37231 4272 38 . . . 37231 4273 1 There there EX 37231 4273 2 is be VBZ 37231 4273 3 infinitely infinitely RB 37231 4273 4 more more JJR 37231 4273 5 of of IN 37231 4273 6 the the DT 37231 4273 7 spirit spirit NN 37231 4273 8 of of IN 37231 4273 9 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4273 10 in in IN 37231 4273 11 the the DT 37231 4273 12 first first JJ 37231 4273 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4273 14 than than IN 37231 4273 15 there there EX 37231 4273 16 is be VBZ 37231 4273 17 in in IN 37231 4273 18 the the DT 37231 4273 19 second second NN 37231 4273 20 . . . 37231 4274 1 The the DT 37231 4274 2 whole whole JJ 37231 4274 3 internal internal JJ 37231 4274 4 evidence evidence NN 37231 4274 5 , , , 37231 4274 6 therefore therefore RB 37231 4274 7 , , , 37231 4274 8 shows show VBZ 37231 4274 9 that that IN 37231 4274 10 this this DT 37231 4274 11 part part NN 37231 4274 12 of of IN 37231 4274 13 the the DT 37231 4274 14 tradition tradition NN 37231 4274 15 of of IN 37231 4274 16 the the DT 37231 4274 17 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4274 18 John John NNP 37231 4274 19 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 4274 20 by by IN 37231 4274 21 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4274 22 does do VBZ 37231 4274 23 not not RB 37231 4274 24 apply apply VB 37231 4274 25 to to IN 37231 4274 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4274 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4274 28 . . . 37231 4275 1 The the DT 37231 4275 2 discrepancy discrepancy NN 37231 4275 3 , , , 37231 4275 4 however however RB 37231 4275 5 , , , 37231 4275 6 is be VBZ 37231 4275 7 still still RB 37231 4275 8 more more RBR 37231 4275 9 marked marked JJ 37231 4275 10 when when WRB 37231 4275 11 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4275 12 compare compare VBP 37231 4275 13 with with IN 37231 4275 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4275 15 actual actual JJ 37231 4275 16 second second NN 37231 4275 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4275 18 the the DT 37231 4275 19 account account NN 37231 4275 20 of of IN 37231 4275 21 the the DT 37231 4275 22 work work NN 37231 4275 23 of of IN 37231 4275 24 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4275 25 which which WDT 37231 4275 26 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4275 27 received receive VBD 37231 4275 28 from from IN 37231 4275 29 the the DT 37231 4275 30 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4275 31 . . . 37231 4276 1 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4276 2 wrote write VBD 37231 4276 3 down down RP 37231 4276 4 from from IN 37231 4276 5 memory memory NN 37231 4276 6 some some DT 37231 4276 7 parts part NNS 37231 4276 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4276 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4276 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4276 11 of of IN 37231 4276 12 the the DT 37231 4276 13 teaching teaching NN 37231 4276 14 of of IN 37231 4276 15 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4276 16 regarding regard VBG 37231 4276 17 the the DT 37231 4276 18 life life NN 37231 4276 19 of of IN 37231 4276 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4276 21 , , , 37231 4276 22 but but CC 37231 4276 23 as as IN 37231 4276 24 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4276 25 adapted adapt VBD 37231 4276 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4276 27 instructions instruction NNS 37231 4276 28 to to IN 37231 4276 29 the the DT 37231 4276 30 actual actual JJ 37231 4276 31 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 4276 32 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4276 33 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4276 34 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4276 35 , , , 37231 4276 36 and and CC 37231 4276 37 did do VBD 37231 4276 38 not not RB 37231 4276 39 give give VB 37231 4276 40 a a DT 37231 4276 41 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4276 42 report report NN 37231 4276 43 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4276 44 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4276 45 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4276 46 of of IN 37231 4276 47 the the DT 37231 4276 48 sayings saying NNS 37231 4276 49 or or CC 37231 4276 50 doings doing NNS 37231 4276 51 of of IN 37231 4276 52 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4276 53 , , , 37231 4276 54 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4276 55 was be VBD 37231 4276 56 only only RB 37231 4276 57 careful careful JJ 37231 4276 58 to to TO 37231 4276 59 be be VB 37231 4276 60 accurate accurate JJ 37231 4276 61 , , , 37231 4276 62 and and CC 37231 4276 63 did do VBD 37231 4276 64 not not RB 37231 4276 65 trouble trouble VB 37231 4276 66 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4276 67 to to TO 37231 4276 68 arrange arrange VB 37231 4276 69 in in IN 37231 4276 70 historical historical JJ 37231 4276 71 order order NN 37231 4276 72 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4276 73 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4276 74 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4276 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4276 76 narrative narrative NN 37231 4276 77 of of IN 37231 4276 78 the the DT 37231 4276 79 things thing NNS 37231 4276 80 which which WDT 37231 4276 81 were be VBD 37231 4276 82 said say VBN 37231 4276 83 and and CC 37231 4276 84 done do VBN 37231 4276 85 by by IN 37231 4276 86 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4276 87 , , , 37231 4276 88 but but CC 37231 4276 89 merely merely RB 37231 4276 90 wrote write VBD 37231 4276 91 down down RP 37231 4276 92 facts fact NNS 37231 4276 93 as as IN 37231 4276 94 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4276 95 remembered remember VBD 37231 4276 96 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4276 97 . . . 37231 4277 1 This this DT 37231 4277 2 description description NN 37231 4277 3 would would MD 37231 4277 4 lead lead VB 37231 4277 5 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4277 6 to to TO 37231 4277 7 expect expect VB 37231 4277 8 a a DT 37231 4277 9 work work NN 37231 4277 10 composed compose VBN 37231 4277 11 of of IN 37231 4277 12 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 37231 4277 13 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 37231 4277 14 of of IN 37231 4277 15 the the DT 37231 4277 16 teaching teaching NN 37231 4277 17 of of IN 37231 4277 18 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4277 19 , , , 37231 4277 20 without without IN 37231 4277 21 regular regular JJ 37231 4277 22 sequence sequence NN 37231 4277 23 or or CC 37231 4277 24 connection connection NN 37231 4277 25 . . . 37231 4278 1 The the DT 37231 4278 2 absence absence NN 37231 4278 3 of of IN 37231 4278 4 orderly orderly JJ 37231 4278 5 arrangement arrangement NN 37231 4278 6 is be VBZ 37231 4278 7 the the DT 37231 4278 8 most most RBS 37231 4278 9 prominent prominent JJ 37231 4278 10 feature feature NN 37231 4278 11 in in IN 37231 4278 12 the the DT 37231 4278 13 description description NN 37231 4278 14 , , , 37231 4278 15 and and CC 37231 4278 16 forms form VBZ 37231 4278 17 the the DT 37231 4278 18 burden burden NN 37231 4278 19 of of IN 37231 4278 20 the the DT 37231 4278 21 whole whole NN 37231 4278 22 . . . 37231 4279 1 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4279 2 writes write VBZ 37231 4279 3 " " `` 37231 4279 4 what what WP 37231 4279 5 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4279 6 remembered remember VBD 37231 4279 7 ; ; : 37231 4279 8 " " `` 37231 4279 9 " " `` 37231 4279 10 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4279 11 did do VBD 37231 4279 12 not not RB 37231 4279 13 arrange arrange VB 37231 4279 14 in in IN 37231 4279 15 order order NN 37231 4279 16 the the DT 37231 4279 17 things thing NNS 37231 4279 18 that that WDT 37231 4279 19 were be VBD 37231 4279 20 either either CC 37231 4279 21 said say VBN 37231 4279 22 or or CC 37231 4279 23 done do VBN 37231 4279 24 by by IN 37231 4279 25 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4279 26 ; ; : 37231 4279 27 " " `` 37231 4279 28 and and CC 37231 4279 29 then then RB 37231 4279 30 follow follow VB 37231 4279 31 the the DT 37231 4279 32 apologetic apologetic JJ 37231 4279 33 expressions expression NNS 37231 4279 34 of of IN 37231 4279 35 explanation explanation NN 37231 4279 36 -- -- : 37231 4279 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4279 38 was be VBD 37231 4279 39 not not RB 37231 4279 40 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4279 41 a a DT 37231 4279 42 hearer hearer NN 37231 4279 43 or or CC 37231 4279 44 follower follower NN 37231 4279 45 of of IN 37231 4279 46 the the DT 37231 4279 47 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4279 48 , , , 37231 4279 49 but but CC 37231 4279 50 derived derive VBD 37231 4279 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4279 52 { { -LRB- 37231 4279 53 456 456 CD 37231 4279 54 } } -RRB- 37231 4279 55 information information NN 37231 4279 56 from from IN 37231 4279 57 the the DT 37231 4279 58 occasional occasional JJ 37231 4279 59 preaching preaching NN 37231 4279 60 of of IN 37231 4279 61 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4279 62 , , , 37231 4279 63 who who WP 37231 4279 64 did do VBD 37231 4279 65 not not RB 37231 4279 66 attempt attempt VB 37231 4279 67 to to TO 37231 4279 68 give give VB 37231 4279 69 a a DT 37231 4279 70 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4279 71 narrative narrative NN 37231 4279 72 . . . 37231 4280 1 Now now RB 37231 4280 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4280 3 is be VBZ 37231 4280 4 impossible impossible JJ 37231 4280 5 in in IN 37231 4280 6 the the DT 37231 4280 7 work work NN 37231 4280 8 of of IN 37231 4280 9 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4280 10 here here RB 37231 4280 11 described describe VBD 37231 4280 12 to to TO 37231 4280 13 recognize recognize VB 37231 4280 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4280 15 present present JJ 37231 4280 16 second second JJ 37231 4280 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4280 18 , , , 37231 4280 19 which which WDT 37231 4280 20 does do VBZ 37231 4280 21 not not RB 37231 4280 22 depart depart VB 37231 4280 23 in in IN 37231 4280 24 any any DT 37231 4280 25 important important JJ 37231 4280 26 degree degree NN 37231 4280 27 from from IN 37231 4280 28 the the DT 37231 4280 29 order order NN 37231 4280 30 of of IN 37231 4280 31 the the DT 37231 4280 32 other other JJ 37231 4280 33 two two CD 37231 4280 34 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 4280 35 , , , 37231 4280 36 and and CC 37231 4280 37 which which WDT 37231 4280 38 , , , 37231 4280 39 throughout throughout RB 37231 4280 40 , , , 37231 4280 41 has have VBZ 37231 4280 42 the the DT 37231 4280 43 most most RBS 37231 4280 44 evident evident JJ 37231 4280 45 character character NN 37231 4280 46 of of IN 37231 4280 47 orderly orderly JJ 37231 4280 48 arrangement arrangement NN 37231 4280 49 Each each DT 37231 4280 50 of of IN 37231 4280 51 the the DT 37231 4280 52 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 37231 4280 53 compared compare VBN 37231 4280 54 with with IN 37231 4280 55 the the DT 37231 4280 56 other other JJ 37231 4280 57 two two CD 37231 4280 58 would would MD 37231 4280 59 present present VB 37231 4280 60 a a DT 37231 4280 61 similar similar JJ 37231 4280 62 degree degree NN 37231 4280 63 of of IN 37231 4280 64 variation variation NN 37231 4280 65 , , , 37231 4280 66 but but CC 37231 4280 67 none none NN 37231 4280 68 of of IN 37231 4280 69 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4280 70 could could MD 37231 4280 71 justly justly RB 37231 4280 72 be be VB 37231 4280 73 described describe VBN 37231 4280 74 as as IN 37231 4280 75 not not RB 37231 4280 76 arranged arrange VBN 37231 4280 77 in in IN 37231 4280 78 order order NN 37231 4280 79 or or CC 37231 4280 80 as as IN 37231 4280 81 not not RB 37231 4280 82 being be VBG 37231 4280 83 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4280 84 . . . 37231 4281 1 The the DT 37231 4281 2 second second JJ 37231 4281 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4281 4 opens open VBZ 37231 4281 5 formally formally RB 37231 4281 6 , , , 37231 4281 7 and and CC 37231 4281 8 after after IN 37231 4281 9 presenting present VBG 37231 4281 10 John John NNP 37231 4281 11 the the DT 37231 4281 12 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 4281 13 as as IN 37231 4281 14 the the DT 37231 4281 15 messenger messenger NN 37231 4281 16 sent send VBD 37231 4281 17 to to TO 37231 4281 18 prepare prepare VB 37231 4281 19 the the DT 37231 4281 20 way way NN 37231 4281 21 of of IN 37231 4281 22 the the DT 37231 4281 23 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4281 24 , , , 37231 4281 25 proceeds proceed VBZ 37231 4281 26 to to IN 37231 4281 27 the the DT 37231 4281 28 baptism baptism NN 37231 4281 29 of of IN 37231 4281 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4281 31 , , , 37231 4281 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4281 33 temptation temptation NN 37231 4281 34 , , , 37231 4281 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4281 36 entry entry NN 37231 4281 37 upon upon IN 37231 4281 38 public public JJ 37231 4281 39 life life NN 37231 4281 40 , , , 37231 4281 41 and and CC 37231 4281 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4281 43 calling calling NN 37231 4281 44 of of IN 37231 4281 45 the the DT 37231 4281 46 disciples disciple NNS 37231 4281 47 . . . 37231 4282 1 Then then RB 37231 4282 2 , , , 37231 4282 3 after after IN 37231 4282 4 a a DT 37231 4282 5 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4282 6 narrative narrative NN 37231 4282 7 of of IN 37231 4282 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4282 9 teaching teaching NN 37231 4282 10 and and CC 37231 4282 11 works work NNS 37231 4282 12 , , , 37231 4282 13 the the DT 37231 4282 14 history history NN 37231 4282 15 ends end VBZ 37231 4282 16 with with IN 37231 4282 17 a a DT 37231 4282 18 full full JJ 37231 4282 19 and and CC 37231 4282 20 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4282 21 account account NN 37231 4282 22 of of IN 37231 4282 23 the the DT 37231 4282 24 last last JJ 37231 4282 25 events event NNS 37231 4282 26 in in IN 37231 4282 27 the the DT 37231 4282 28 life life NN 37231 4282 29 of of IN 37231 4282 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4282 31 , , , 37231 4282 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4282 33 trial trial NN 37231 4282 34 , , , 37231 4282 35 crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 4282 36 , , , 37231 4282 37 and and CC 37231 4282 38 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 4282 39 , , , 37231 4282 40 There there EX 37231 4282 41 is be VBZ 37231 4282 42 in in IN 37231 4282 43 the the DT 37231 4282 44 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4282 45 every every DT 37231 4282 46 characteristic characteristic NN 37231 4282 47 of of IN 37231 4282 48 artistic artistic JJ 37231 4282 49 and and CC 37231 4282 50 orderly orderly JJ 37231 4282 51 arrangement arrangement NN 37231 4282 52 , , , 37231 4282 53 from from IN 37231 4282 54 the the DT 37231 4282 55 striking strike VBG 37231 4282 56 introduction introduction NN 37231 4282 57 by by IN 37231 4282 58 the the DT 37231 4282 59 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 4282 60 voice voice NN 37231 4282 61 crying cry VBG 37231 4282 62 in in IN 37231 4282 63 the the DT 37231 4282 64 wilderness wilderness NN 37231 4282 65 to to IN 37231 4282 66 the the DT 37231 4282 67 solemn solemn JJ 37231 4282 68 close close NN 37231 4282 69 of of IN 37231 4282 70 the the DT 37231 4282 71 marvellous marvellous JJ 37231 4282 72 history history NN 37231 4282 73 . . . 37231 4283 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4283 2 1 1 LS 37231 4283 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4283 4 The the DT 37231 4283 5 great great JJ 37231 4283 6 majority majority NN 37231 4283 7 of of IN 37231 4283 8 critics critic NNS 37231 4283 9 , , , 37231 4283 10 therefore therefore RB 37231 4283 11 , , , 37231 4283 12 are be VBP 37231 4283 13 agreed agree VBN 37231 4283 14 in in IN 37231 4283 15 concluding conclude VBG 37231 4283 16 that that IN 37231 4283 17 the the DT 37231 4283 18 account account NN 37231 4283 19 of of IN 37231 4283 20 the the DT 37231 4283 21 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4283 22 John John NNP 37231 4283 23 recorded record VBN 37231 4283 24 by by IN 37231 4283 25 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4283 26 does do VBZ 37231 4283 27 not not RB 37231 4283 28 apply apply VB 37231 4283 29 to to IN 37231 4283 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4283 31 second second JJ 37231 4283 32 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4283 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4283 34 at at RB 37231 4283 35 all all RB 37231 4283 36 . . . 37231 4284 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4284 2 2 2 LS 37231 4284 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4284 4 Many many JJ 37231 4284 5 { { -LRB- 37231 4284 6 457 457 CD 37231 4284 7 } } -RRB- 37231 4284 8 of of IN 37231 4284 9 those those DT 37231 4284 10 who who WP 37231 4284 11 affirm affirm VBP 37231 4284 12 that that IN 37231 4284 13 the the DT 37231 4284 14 description description NN 37231 4284 15 of of IN 37231 4284 16 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4284 17 may may MD 37231 4284 18 apply apply VB 37231 4284 19 to to IN 37231 4284 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4284 21 second second JJ 37231 4284 22 Gospel(1 gospel(1 NN 37231 4284 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4284 24 do do VB 37231 4284 25 so so RB 37231 4284 26 with with IN 37231 4284 27 hesitation hesitation NN 37231 4284 28 , , , 37231 4284 29 and and CC 37231 4284 30 few few JJ 37231 4284 31 maintain maintain VBP 37231 4284 32 that that IN 37231 4284 33 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4284 34 now now RB 37231 4284 35 possess possess VBP 37231 4284 36 the the DT 37231 4284 37 original original JJ 37231 4284 38 work work NN 37231 4284 39 without without IN 37231 4284 40 considerable considerable JJ 37231 4284 41 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 4284 42 alteration alteration NN 37231 4284 43 . . . 37231 4285 1 Some some DT 37231 4285 2 of of IN 37231 4285 3 these these DT 37231 4285 4 critics critic NNS 37231 4285 5 , , , 37231 4285 6 however however RB 37231 4285 7 , , , 37231 4285 8 feeling feel VBG 37231 4285 9 the the DT 37231 4285 10 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 4285 11 of of IN 37231 4285 12 identifying identify VBG 37231 4285 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4285 14 second second JJ 37231 4285 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4285 16 with with IN 37231 4285 17 the the DT 37231 4285 18 work work NN 37231 4285 19 here here RB 37231 4285 20 described describe VBN 37231 4285 21 , , , 37231 4285 22 endeavour endeavour NN 37231 4285 23 { { -LRB- 37231 4285 24 458 458 CD 37231 4285 25 } } -RRB- 37231 4285 26 to to TO 37231 4285 27 reconcile reconcile VB 37231 4285 28 the the DT 37231 4285 29 discrepancy discrepancy NN 37231 4285 30 by by IN 37231 4285 31 a a DT 37231 4285 32 fanciful fanciful JJ 37231 4285 33 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 4285 34 of of IN 37231 4285 35 the the DT 37231 4285 36 account account NN 37231 4285 37 of of IN 37231 4285 38 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4285 39 . . . 37231 4286 1 They -PRON- PRP 37231 4286 2 suggest suggest VBP 37231 4286 3 that that IN 37231 4286 4 the the DT 37231 4286 5 first first JJ 37231 4286 6 part part NN 37231 4286 7 , , , 37231 4286 8 in in IN 37231 4286 9 which which WDT 37231 4286 10 the the DT 37231 4286 11 want want NN 37231 4286 12 of of IN 37231 4286 13 chronological chronological JJ 37231 4286 14 order order NN 37231 4286 15 is be VBZ 37231 4286 16 pointed point VBN 37231 4286 17 out out RP 37231 4286 18 , , , 37231 4286 19 refers refer VBZ 37231 4286 20 to to IN 37231 4286 21 the the DT 37231 4286 22 rough rough JJ 37231 4286 23 notes note NNS 37231 4286 24 which which WDT 37231 4286 25 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4286 26 made make VBN 37231 4286 27 during during IN 37231 4286 28 the the DT 37231 4286 29 actual actual JJ 37231 4286 30 preaching preaching NN 37231 4286 31 and and CC 37231 4286 32 lifetime lifetime NN 37231 4286 33 of of IN 37231 4286 34 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4286 35 , , , 37231 4286 36 and and CC 37231 4286 37 that that IN 37231 4286 38 the the DT 37231 4286 39 latter latter JJ 37231 4286 40 part part NN 37231 4286 41 applies apply VBZ 37231 4286 42 to to IN 37231 4286 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4286 44 present present JJ 37231 4286 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4286 46 , , , 37231 4286 47 which which WDT 37231 4286 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4286 49 later later RB 37231 4286 50 remodelled remodelle VBD 37231 4286 51 into into IN 37231 4286 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4286 53 present present JJ 37231 4286 54 shape shape NN 37231 4286 55 . . . 37231 4287 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4287 2 1 1 LS 37231 4287 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4287 4 This this DT 37231 4287 5 most most RBS 37231 4287 6 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 37231 4287 7 and and CC 37231 4287 8 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 4287 9 application application NN 37231 4287 10 of of IN 37231 4287 11 the the DT 37231 4287 12 words word NNS 37231 4287 13 of of IN 37231 4287 14 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4287 15 is be VBZ 37231 4287 16 denounced denounce VBN 37231 4287 17 even even RB 37231 4287 18 by by IN 37231 4287 19 apologists apologist NNS 37231 4287 20 . . . 37231 4288 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4288 2 2 2 LS 37231 4288 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4288 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4288 5 has have VBZ 37231 4288 6 been be VBN 37231 4288 7 well well RB 37231 4288 8 argued argue VBN 37231 4288 9 that that IN 37231 4288 10 the the DT 37231 4288 11 work work NN 37231 4288 12 here here RB 37231 4288 13 described describe VBD 37231 4288 14 as as IN 37231 4288 15 produced produce VBN 37231 4288 16 by by IN 37231 4288 17 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4288 18 in in IN 37231 4288 19 the the DT 37231 4288 20 character character NN 37231 4288 21 of of IN 37231 4288 22 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4288 23 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4288 24 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4288 25 is be VBZ 37231 4288 26 much much RB 37231 4288 27 more more JJR 37231 4288 28 one one CD 37231 4288 29 of of IN 37231 4288 30 the the DT 37231 4288 31 same same JJ 37231 4288 32 family family NN 37231 4288 33 as as IN 37231 4288 34 the the DT 37231 4288 35 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4288 36 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 4288 37 than than IN 37231 4288 38 of of IN 37231 4288 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4288 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4288 41 . . . 37231 4289 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4289 2 3 3 LS 37231 4289 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4289 4 The the DT 37231 4289 5 work work NN 37231 4289 6 was be VBD 37231 4289 7 no no DT 37231 4289 8 systematic systematic JJ 37231 4289 9 narrative narrative NN 37231 4289 10 of of IN 37231 4289 11 the the DT 37231 4289 12 history history NN 37231 4289 13 of of IN 37231 4289 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4289 15 , , , 37231 4289 16 nor nor CC 37231 4289 17 report report NN 37231 4289 18 of of IN 37231 4289 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4289 20 teaching teaching NN 37231 4289 21 , , , 37231 4289 22 but but CC 37231 4289 23 the the DT 37231 4289 24 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 4289 25 preaching preaching NN 37231 4289 26 of of IN 37231 4289 27 the the DT 37231 4289 28 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4289 29 , , , 37231 4289 30 illustrated illustrate VBN 37231 4289 31 and and CC 37231 4289 32 interspersed intersperse VBN 37231 4289 33 with with IN 37231 4289 34 passages passage NNS 37231 4289 35 from from IN 37231 4289 36 the the DT 37231 4289 37 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4289 38 of of IN 37231 4289 39 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4289 40 or or CC 37231 4289 41 facts fact NNS 37231 4289 42 from from IN 37231 4289 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4289 44 life life NN 37231 4289 45 . . . 37231 4290 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4290 2 4 4 LS 37231 4290 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4290 4 Of of IN 37231 4290 5 this this DT 37231 4290 6 character character NN 37231 4290 7 seems seem VBZ 37231 4290 8 actually actually RB 37231 4290 9 to to TO 37231 4290 10 have have VB 37231 4290 11 been be VBN 37231 4290 12 that that DT 37231 4290 13 ancient ancient JJ 37231 4290 14 work work NN 37231 4290 15 " " `` 37231 4290 16 The the DT 37231 4290 17 Preaching Preaching NNP 37231 4290 18 of of IN 37231 4290 19 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4290 20 " " '' 37231 4290 21 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4290 22 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4290 23 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4290 24 , , , 37231 4290 25 which which WDT 37231 4290 26 was be VBD 37231 4290 27 used use VBN 37231 4290 28 by by IN 37231 4290 29 Heracleon,(5 heracleon,(5 NN 37231 4290 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4290 31 and and CC 37231 4290 32 by by IN 37231 4290 33 Clement(6 clement(6 NN 37231 4290 34 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4290 35 of of IN 37231 4290 36 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4290 37 as as IN 37231 4290 38 an an DT 37231 4290 39 authentic authentic JJ 37231 4290 40 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4290 41 work,(7 work,(7 NNS 37231 4290 42 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4290 43 denounced denounce VBN 37231 4290 44 by by IN 37231 4290 45 Origen(8 origen(8 NN 37231 4290 46 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4290 47 { { -LRB- 37231 4290 48 459 459 CD 37231 4290 49 } } -RRB- 37231 4290 50 on on IN 37231 4290 51 account account NN 37231 4290 52 of of IN 37231 4290 53 the the DT 37231 4290 54 consideration consideration NN 37231 4290 55 in in IN 37231 4290 56 which which WDT 37231 4290 57 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4290 58 was be VBD 37231 4290 59 held hold VBN 37231 4290 60 by by IN 37231 4290 61 - - HYPH 37231 4290 62 many many JJ 37231 4290 63 , , , 37231 4290 64 but but CC 37231 4290 65 still still RB 37231 4290 66 quoted quote VBN 37231 4290 67 with with IN 37231 4290 68 respect respect NN 37231 4290 69 by by IN 37231 4290 70 Gregory Gregory NNP 37231 4290 71 of of IN 37231 4290 72 Nazianzum Nazianzum NNP 37231 4290 73 . . . 37231 4291 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4291 2 1 1 LS 37231 4291 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4291 4 There there EX 37231 4291 5 can can MD 37231 4291 6 be be VB 37231 4291 7 no no DT 37231 4291 8 doubt doubt NN 37231 4291 9 that that IN 37231 4291 10 the the DT 37231 4291 11 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4291 12 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4291 13 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4291 14 although although IN 37231 4291 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4291 16 failed fail VBD 37231 4291 17 to to TO 37231 4291 18 obtain obtain VB 37231 4291 19 a a DT 37231 4291 20 permanent permanent JJ 37231 4291 21 place place NN 37231 4291 22 in in IN 37231 4291 23 the the DT 37231 4291 24 canon canon NN 37231 4291 25 , , , 37231 4291 26 was be VBD 37231 4291 27 one one CD 37231 4291 28 of of IN 37231 4291 29 the the DT 37231 4291 30 most most RBS 37231 4291 31 ancient ancient JJ 37231 4291 32 works work NNS 37231 4291 33 of of IN 37231 4291 34 the the DT 37231 4291 35 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4291 36 Church Church NNP 37231 4291 37 , , , 37231 4291 38 dating date VBG 37231 4291 39 probably probably RB 37231 4291 40 from from IN 37231 4291 41 the the DT 37231 4291 42 first first JJ 37231 4291 43 century century NN 37231 4291 44 , , , 37231 4291 45 from from IN 37231 4291 46 which which WDT 37231 4291 47 indeed indeed RB 37231 4291 48 the the DT 37231 4291 49 Clementine Clementine NNP 37231 4291 50 Homilies Homilies NNPS 37231 4291 51 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 4291 52 were be VBD 37231 4291 53 in in IN 37231 4291 54 all all DT 37231 4291 55 likelihood likelihood NN 37231 4291 56 produced,(2 produced,(2 NNP 37231 4291 57 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4291 58 and and CC 37231 4291 59 , , , 37231 4291 60 like like IN 37231 4291 61 the the DT 37231 4291 62 work work NN 37231 4291 63 described describe VBN 37231 4291 64 by by IN 37231 4291 65 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4291 66 , , , 37231 4291 67 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4291 68 also also RB 37231 4291 69 was be VBD 37231 4291 70 held hold VBN 37231 4291 71 to to TO 37231 4291 72 have have VB 37231 4291 73 been be VBN 37231 4291 74 composed compose VBN 37231 4291 75 in in IN 37231 4291 76 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4291 77 in in IN 37231 4291 78 connection connection NN 37231 4291 79 with with IN 37231 4291 80 the the DT 37231 4291 81 preaching preaching NN 37231 4291 82 there there RB 37231 4291 83 of of IN 37231 4291 84 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4291 85 and and CC 37231 4291 86 Paul.3 Paul.3 NNP 37231 4291 87 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4291 88 must must MD 37231 4291 89 be be VB 37231 4291 90 noted note VBN 37231 4291 91 , , , 37231 4291 92 moreover moreover RB 37231 4291 93 , , , 37231 4291 94 that that IN 37231 4291 95 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4291 96 does do VBZ 37231 4291 97 not not RB 37231 4291 98 call call VB 37231 4291 99 the the DT 37231 4291 100 work work NN 37231 4291 101 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4291 102 to to IN 37231 4291 103 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4291 104 a a DT 37231 4291 105 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4291 106 , , , 37231 4291 107 but but CC 37231 4291 108 merely merely RB 37231 4291 109 a a DT 37231 4291 110 record record NN 37231 4291 111 of of IN 37231 4291 112 the the DT 37231 4291 113 preaching preaching NN 37231 4291 114 of of IN 37231 4291 115 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4291 116 . . . 37231 4292 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4292 2 is be VBZ 37231 4292 3 not not RB 37231 4292 4 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4292 5 for for IN 37231 4292 6 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4292 7 to to TO 37231 4292 8 account account VB 37231 4292 9 for for IN 37231 4292 10 the the DT 37231 4292 11 manner manner NN 37231 4292 12 in in IN 37231 4292 13 which which WDT 37231 4292 14 the the DT 37231 4292 15 work work NN 37231 4292 16 referred refer VBD 37231 4292 17 to to IN 37231 4292 18 by by IN 37231 4292 19 the the DT 37231 4292 20 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4292 21 John John NNP 37231 4292 22 disappeared disappear VBD 37231 4292 23 , , , 37231 4292 24 and and CC 37231 4292 25 the the DT 37231 4292 26 present present JJ 37231 4292 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4292 28 according accord VBG 37231 4292 29 to to IN 37231 4292 30 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4292 31 became become VBD 37231 4292 32 substituted substituted JJ 37231 4292 33 for for IN 37231 4292 34 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4292 35 . . . 37231 4293 1 The the DT 37231 4293 2 merely merely RB 37231 4293 3 negative negative JJ 37231 4293 4 evidence evidence NN 37231 4293 5 that that IN 37231 4293 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4293 7 actual actual JJ 37231 4293 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4293 9 is be VBZ 37231 4293 10 not not RB 37231 4293 11 the the DT 37231 4293 12 work work NN 37231 4293 13 described describe VBN 37231 4293 14 by by IN 37231 4293 15 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4293 16 is be VBZ 37231 4293 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 4293 18 for for IN 37231 4293 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4293 20 purpose purpose NN 37231 4293 21 . . . 37231 4294 1 Any any DT 37231 4294 2 one one NN 37231 4294 3 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4294 4 with with IN 37231 4294 5 the the DT 37231 4294 6 thoroughly thoroughly RB 37231 4294 7 uncritical uncritical JJ 37231 4294 8 character character NN 37231 4294 9 of of IN 37231 4294 10 the the DT 37231 4294 11 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 4294 12 , , , 37231 4294 13 and and CC 37231 4294 14 with with IN 37231 4294 15 the the DT 37231 4294 16 literary literary JJ 37231 4294 17 history history NN 37231 4294 18 of of IN 37231 4294 19 the the DT 37231 4294 20 early early JJ 37231 4294 21 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4294 22 Church Church NNP 37231 4294 23 , , , 37231 4294 24 will will MD 37231 4294 25 readily readily RB 37231 4294 26 conceive conceive VB 37231 4294 27 the the DT 37231 4294 28 facility facility NN 37231 4294 29 with with IN 37231 4294 30 which which WDT 37231 4294 31 this this DT 37231 4294 32 can can MD 37231 4294 33 have have VB 37231 4294 34 been be VBN 37231 4294 35 accomplished accomplish VBN 37231 4294 36 . . . 37231 4295 1 The the DT 37231 4295 2 great great JJ 37231 4295 3 mass mass NN 37231 4295 4 of of IN 37231 4295 5 intelligent intelligent JJ 37231 4295 6 critics critic NNS 37231 4295 7 are be VBP 37231 4295 8 agreed agree VBN 37231 4295 9 that that IN 37231 4295 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4295 11 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 37231 4295 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4295 13 have have VBP 37231 4295 14 assumed assume VBN 37231 4295 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4295 16 present present JJ 37231 4295 17 form form NN 37231 4295 18 only only RB 37231 4295 19 after after IN 37231 4295 20 repeated repeat VBN 37231 4295 21 modifications modification NNS 37231 4295 22 by by IN 37231 4295 23 various various JJ 37231 4295 24 editors editor NNS 37231 4295 25 of of IN 37231 4295 26 earlier early JJR 37231 4295 27 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 4295 28 works work NNS 37231 4295 29 . . . 37231 4296 1 These these DT 37231 4296 2 changes change NNS 37231 4296 3 have have VBP 37231 4296 4 not not RB 37231 4296 5 been be VBN 37231 4296 6 effected effect VBN 37231 4296 7 without without IN 37231 4296 8 traces trace NNS 37231 4296 9 { { -LRB- 37231 4296 10 460 460 CD 37231 4296 11 } } -RRB- 37231 4296 12 being be VBG 37231 4296 13 left leave VBN 37231 4296 14 by by IN 37231 4296 15 which which WDT 37231 4296 16 the the DT 37231 4296 17 various various JJ 37231 4296 18 materials material NNS 37231 4296 19 may may MD 37231 4296 20 be be VB 37231 4296 21 separated separate VBN 37231 4296 22 and and CC 37231 4296 23 distinguished distinguish VBN 37231 4296 24 , , , 37231 4296 25 but but CC 37231 4296 26 the the DT 37231 4296 27 more more RBR 37231 4296 28 primitive primitive JJ 37231 4296 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4296 30 have have VBP 37231 4296 31 entirely entirely RB 37231 4296 32 disappeared disappear VBN 37231 4296 33 , , , 37231 4296 34 naturally naturally RB 37231 4296 35 supplanted supplant VBN 37231 4296 36 by by IN 37231 4296 37 the the DT 37231 4296 38 later later JJ 37231 4296 39 and and CC 37231 4296 40 amplified amplify VBD 37231 4296 41 versions version NNS 37231 4296 42 . . . 37231 4297 1 The the DT 37231 4297 2 critic critic NN 37231 4297 3 , , , 37231 4297 4 however however RB 37231 4297 5 , , , 37231 4297 6 who who WP 37231 4297 7 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 37231 4297 8 between between IN 37231 4297 9 the the DT 37231 4297 10 earlier early JJR 37231 4297 11 and and CC 37231 4297 12 later later RB 37231 4297 13 matter matter NN 37231 4297 14 is be VBZ 37231 4297 15 not not RB 37231 4297 16 bound bind VBN 37231 4297 17 to to TO 37231 4297 18 perform perform VB 37231 4297 19 the the DT 37231 4297 20 now now RB 37231 4297 21 impossible impossible JJ 37231 4297 22 feat feat NN 37231 4297 23 of of IN 37231 4297 24 producing produce VBG 37231 4297 25 the the DT 37231 4297 26 originals original NNS 37231 4297 27 , , , 37231 4297 28 or or CC 37231 4297 29 accounting account VBG 37231 4297 30 in in IN 37231 4297 31 any any DT 37231 4297 32 but but IN 37231 4297 33 a a DT 37231 4297 34 general general JJ 37231 4297 35 way way NN 37231 4297 36 for for IN 37231 4297 37 the the DT 37231 4297 38 disappearance disappearance NN 37231 4297 39 of of IN 37231 4297 40 the the DT 37231 4297 41 primitive primitive JJ 37231 4297 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4297 43 . . . 37231 4298 1 Teschendorf teschendorf NN 37231 4298 2 asks ask VBZ 37231 4298 3 : : : 37231 4298 4 " " `` 37231 4298 5 How how WRB 37231 4298 6 then then RB 37231 4298 7 has have VBZ 37231 4298 8 neither neither DT 37231 4298 9 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4298 10 nor nor CC 37231 4298 11 any any DT 37231 4298 12 other other JJ 37231 4298 13 theologian theologian NN 37231 4298 14 of of IN 37231 4298 15 Christian christian JJ 37231 4298 16 antiquity antiquity NN 37231 4298 17 thought think VBD 37231 4298 18 that that IN 37231 4298 19 the the DT 37231 4298 20 expressions expression NNS 37231 4298 21 of of IN 37231 4298 22 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4298 23 were be VBD 37231 4298 24 in in IN 37231 4298 25 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 4298 26 with with IN 37231 4298 27 the the DT 37231 4298 28 two two CD 37231 4298 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4298 30 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4298 31 Mt. Mount NNP 37231 4299 1 and and CC 37231 4299 2 Mk Mk NNP 37231 4299 3 . . . 37231 4299 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4299 5 ? ? . 37231 4300 1 " " `` 37231 4300 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4300 3 1 1 LS 37231 4300 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4300 5 The the DT 37231 4300 6 absolute absolute JJ 37231 4300 7 credulity credulity NN 37231 4300 8 with with IN 37231 4300 9 which which WDT 37231 4300 10 those those DT 37231 4300 11 theologians theologian NNS 37231 4300 12 accepted accept VBD 37231 4300 13 any any DT 37231 4300 14 fiction fiction NN 37231 4300 15 , , , 37231 4300 16 however however RB 37231 4300 17 childish childish JJ 37231 4300 18 , , , 37231 4300 19 which which WDT 37231 4300 20 had have VBD 37231 4300 21 a a DT 37231 4300 22 pious pious JJ 37231 4300 23 tendency tendency NN 37231 4300 24 , , , 37231 4300 25 and and CC 37231 4300 26 the the DT 37231 4300 27 frivolous frivolous JJ 37231 4300 28 character character NN 37231 4300 29 of of IN 37231 4300 30 the the DT 37231 4300 31 only only JJ 37231 4300 32 criticism criticism NN 37231 4300 33 in in IN 37231 4300 34 which which WDT 37231 4300 35 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4300 36 indulged indulge VBD 37231 4300 37 , , , 37231 4300 38 render render VB 37231 4300 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4300 40 unquestioning unquestioning JJ 37231 4300 41 application application NN 37231 4300 42 of of IN 37231 4300 43 the the DT 37231 4300 44 tradition tradition NN 37231 4300 45 of of IN 37231 4300 46 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4300 47 to to IN 37231 4300 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4300 49 Gospels Gospels NNP 37231 4300 50 anything anything NN 37231 4300 51 but but IN 37231 4300 52 singular singular JJ 37231 4300 53 , , , 37231 4300 54 and and CC 37231 4300 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4300 56 is be VBZ 37231 4300 57 only only RB 37231 4300 58 surprising surprising JJ 37231 4300 59 to to TO 37231 4300 60 find find VB 37231 4300 61 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4300 62 silent silent JJ 37231 4300 63 acquiescence acquiescence NN 37231 4300 64 elevated elevate VBN 37231 4300 65 into into IN 37231 4300 66 an an DT 37231 4300 67 argument argument NN 37231 4300 68 . . . 37231 4301 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4301 2 have have VBP 37231 4301 3 already already RB 37231 4301 4 in in IN 37231 4301 5 the the DT 37231 4301 6 course course NN 37231 4301 7 of of IN 37231 4301 8 these these DT 37231 4301 9 pages page NNS 37231 4301 10 seen see VBN 37231 4301 11 something something NN 37231 4301 12 of of IN 37231 4301 13 the the DT 37231 4301 14 singularly singularly RB 37231 4301 15 credulous credulous JJ 37231 4301 16 and and CC 37231 4301 17 uncritical uncritical JJ 37231 4301 18 character character NN 37231 4301 19 of of IN 37231 4301 20 the the DT 37231 4301 21 Fathers Fathers NNPS 37231 4301 22 , , , 37231 4301 23 and and CC 37231 4301 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4301 25 can can MD 37231 4301 26 not not RB 37231 4301 27 afford afford VB 37231 4301 28 space space NN 37231 4301 29 to to TO 37231 4301 30 give give VB 37231 4301 31 instances instance NNS 37231 4301 32 of of IN 37231 4301 33 the the DT 37231 4301 34 absurdities absurdity NNS 37231 4301 35 with with IN 37231 4301 36 which which WDT 37231 4301 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4301 38 writings writing NNS 37231 4301 39 abound abound VBP 37231 4301 40 . . . 37231 4302 1 No no DT 37231 4302 2 fable fable NN 37231 4302 3 could could MD 37231 4302 4 be be VB 37231 4302 5 too too RB 37231 4302 6 gross gross JJ 37231 4302 7 , , , 37231 4302 8 no no DT 37231 4302 9 invention invention NN 37231 4302 10 too too RB 37231 4302 11 transparent transparent JJ 37231 4302 12 , , , 37231 4302 13 for for IN 37231 4302 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4302 15 unsuspicious unsuspicious JJ 37231 4302 16 acceptance acceptance NN 37231 4302 17 , , , 37231 4302 18 if if IN 37231 4302 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4302 20 assumed assume VBD 37231 4302 21 a a DT 37231 4302 22 pious pious JJ 37231 4302 23 form form NN 37231 4302 24 or or CC 37231 4302 25 tended tend VBD 37231 4302 26 to to IN 37231 4302 27 edification edification NN 37231 4302 28 . . . 37231 4303 1 No no DT 37231 4303 2 period period NN 37231 4303 3 in in IN 37231 4303 4 the the DT 37231 4303 5 history history NN 37231 4303 6 of of IN 37231 4303 7 the the DT 37231 4303 8 world world NN 37231 4303 9 ever ever RB 37231 4303 10 produced produce VBD 37231 4303 11 so so RB 37231 4303 12 many many JJ 37231 4303 13 spurious spurious JJ 37231 4303 14 works work NNS 37231 4303 15 as as IN 37231 4303 16 the the DT 37231 4303 17 first first JJ 37231 4303 18 two two CD 37231 4303 19 or or CC 37231 4303 20 three three CD 37231 4303 21 centuries century NNS 37231 4303 22 of of IN 37231 4303 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4303 24 era era NN 37231 4303 25 . . . 37231 4304 1 The the DT 37231 4304 2 name name NN 37231 4304 3 of of IN 37231 4304 4 every every DT 37231 4304 5 Apostle apostle NN 37231 4304 6 , , , 37231 4304 7 or or CC 37231 4304 8 Christian christian JJ 37231 4304 9 teacher teacher NN 37231 4304 10 , , , 37231 4304 11 not not RB 37231 4304 12 excepting except VBG 37231 4304 13 that that DT 37231 4304 14 of of IN 37231 4304 15 the the DT 37231 4304 16 great great JJ 37231 4304 17 Master Master NNP 37231 4304 18 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4304 19 , , , 37231 4304 20 was be VBD 37231 4304 21 freely freely RB 37231 4304 22 attached attach VBN 37231 4304 23 to to IN 37231 4304 24 every every DT 37231 4304 25 description description NN 37231 4304 26 of of IN 37231 4304 27 religious religious JJ 37231 4304 28 forgery forgery NN 37231 4304 29 . . . 37231 4305 1 False false JJ 37231 4305 2 gospels gospel NNS 37231 4305 3 , , , 37231 4305 4 epistles epistle NNS 37231 4305 5 , , , 37231 4305 6 acts act NNS 37231 4305 7 , , , 37231 4305 8 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 37231 4305 9 , , , 37231 4305 10 were be VBD 37231 4305 11 unscrupulously unscrupulously RB 37231 4305 12 { { -LRB- 37231 4305 13 461 461 CD 37231 4305 14 } } -RRB- 37231 4305 15 circulated circulate VBN 37231 4305 16 , , , 37231 4305 17 and and CC 37231 4305 18 such such JJ 37231 4305 19 pious pious JJ 37231 4305 20 falsification falsification NN 37231 4305 21 was be VBD 37231 4305 22 not not RB 37231 4305 23 even even RB 37231 4305 24 intended intend VBN 37231 4305 25 or or CC 37231 4305 26 regarded regard VBN 37231 4305 27 as as IN 37231 4305 28 a a DT 37231 4305 29 crime crime NN 37231 4305 30 , , , 37231 4305 31 but but CC 37231 4305 32 perpetrated perpetrate VBN 37231 4305 33 for for IN 37231 4305 34 the the DT 37231 4305 35 sake sake NN 37231 4305 36 of of IN 37231 4305 37 edification edification NN 37231 4305 38 . . . 37231 4306 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4306 2 was be VBD 37231 4306 3 only only RB 37231 4306 4 slowly slowly RB 37231 4306 5 and and CC 37231 4306 6 after after IN 37231 4306 7 some some DT 37231 4306 8 centuries century NNS 37231 4306 9 that that IN 37231 4306 10 many many JJ 37231 4306 11 of of IN 37231 4306 12 these these DT 37231 4306 13 works work NNS 37231 4306 14 , , , 37231 4306 15 once once RB 37231 4306 16 , , , 37231 4306 17 as as IN 37231 4306 18 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4306 19 have have VBP 37231 4306 20 seen see VBN 37231 4306 21 , , , 37231 4306 22 regarded regard VBN 37231 4306 23 with with IN 37231 4306 24 pious pious JJ 37231 4306 25 veneration veneration NN 37231 4306 26 , , , 37231 4306 27 were be VBD 37231 4306 28 excluded exclude VBN 37231 4306 29 from from IN 37231 4306 30 the the DT 37231 4306 31 canon canon NN 37231 4306 32 ; ; : 37231 4306 33 and and CC 37231 4306 34 that that IN 37231 4306 35 genuine genuine JJ 37231 4306 36 works work NNS 37231 4306 37 shared share VBD 37231 4306 38 this this DT 37231 4306 39 fate fate NN 37231 4306 40 , , , 37231 4306 41 whilst whilst IN 37231 4306 42 spurious spurious JJ 37231 4306 43 ones one NNS 37231 4306 44 usurped usurp VBD 37231 4306 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4306 46 places place NNS 37231 4306 47 , , , 37231 4306 48 is be VBZ 37231 4306 49 one one CD 37231 4306 50 of of IN 37231 4306 51 the the DT 37231 4306 52 surest sure JJS 37231 4306 53 results result NNS 37231 4306 54 of of IN 37231 4306 55 criticism criticism NN 37231 4306 56 . . . 37231 4307 1 The the DT 37231 4307 2 Fathers father NNS 37231 4307 3 omitted omit VBD 37231 4307 4 to to TO 37231 4307 5 inquire inquire VB 37231 4307 6 critically critically RB 37231 4307 7 when when WRB 37231 4307 8 such such JJ 37231 4307 9 investigation investigation NN 37231 4307 10 might may MD 37231 4307 11 have have VB 37231 4307 12 been be VBN 37231 4307 13 of of IN 37231 4307 14 value value NN 37231 4307 15 , , , 37231 4307 16 and and CC 37231 4307 17 mere mere JJ 37231 4307 18 tradition tradition NN 37231 4307 19 credulously credulously RB 37231 4307 20 accepted accept VBD 37231 4307 21 and and CC 37231 4307 22 transmitted transmit VBN 37231 4307 23 is be VBZ 37231 4307 24 of of IN 37231 4307 25 no no DT 37231 4307 26 critical critical JJ 37231 4307 27 value value NN 37231 4307 28 . . . 37231 4308 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4308 2 1 1 LS 37231 4308 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4308 4 In in IN 37231 4308 5 an an DT 37231 4308 6 age age NN 37231 4308 7 - - : 37231 4308 8 when when WRB 37231 4308 9 the the DT 37231 4308 10 multiplication multiplication NN 37231 4308 11 of of IN 37231 4308 12 copies copy NNS 37231 4308 13 of of IN 37231 4308 14 any any DT 37231 4308 15 work work NN 37231 4308 16 was be VBD 37231 4308 17 a a DT 37231 4308 18 slow slow JJ 37231 4308 19 process process NN 37231 4308 20 , , , 37231 4308 21 and and CC 37231 4308 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4308 23 dissemination dissemination NN 37231 4308 24 a a DT 37231 4308 25 matter matter NN 37231 4308 26 of of IN 37231 4308 27 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 4308 28 and and CC 37231 4308 29 even even RB 37231 4308 30 danger danger NN 37231 4308 31 , , , 37231 4308 32 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4308 33 is be VBZ 37231 4308 34 easy easy JJ 37231 4308 35 to to TO 37231 4308 36 understand understand VB 37231 4308 37 with with IN 37231 4308 38 what what WDT 37231 4308 39 facility facility NN 37231 4308 40 the the DT 37231 4308 41 more more RBR 37231 4308 42 complete complete JJ 37231 4308 43 and and CC 37231 4308 44 artistic artistic JJ 37231 4308 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4308 46 could could MD 37231 4308 47 take take VB 37231 4308 48 the the DT 37231 4308 49 place place NN 37231 4308 50 of of IN 37231 4308 51 the the DT 37231 4308 52 original original JJ 37231 4308 53 notes note NNS 37231 4308 54 as as IN 37231 4308 55 the the DT 37231 4308 56 work work NN 37231 4308 57 of of IN 37231 4308 58 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4308 59 . . . 37231 4309 1 The the DT 37231 4309 2 account account NN 37231 4309 3 given give VBN 37231 4309 4 by by IN 37231 4309 5 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4309 6 of of IN 37231 4309 7 the the DT 37231 4309 8 work work NN 37231 4309 9 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4309 10 to to IN 37231 4309 11 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4309 12 is be VBZ 37231 4309 13 as as IN 37231 4309 14 follows follow VBZ 37231 4309 15 : : : 37231 4309 16 " " `` 37231 4309 17 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4309 18 composed compose VBD 37231 4309 19 the the DT 37231 4309 20 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4309 21 in in IN 37231 4309 22 the the DT 37231 4309 23 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4309 24 dialect dialect NN 37231 4309 25 , , , 37231 4309 26 and and CC 37231 4309 27 every every DT 37231 4309 28 one one NN 37231 4309 29 interpreted interpret VBD 37231 4309 30 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4309 31 as as IN 37231 4309 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4309 33 was be VBD 37231 4309 34 able able JJ 37231 4309 35 . . . 37231 4310 1 " " `` 37231 4310 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4310 3 2 2 LS 37231 4310 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4310 5 Critics critic NNS 37231 4310 6 are be VBP 37231 4310 7 divided divide VBN 37231 4310 8 in in IN 37231 4310 9 opinion opinion NN 37231 4310 10 as as IN 37231 4310 11 to to IN 37231 4310 12 whether whether IN 37231 4310 13 this this DT 37231 4310 14 tradition tradition NN 37231 4310 15 was be VBD 37231 4310 16 , , , 37231 4310 17 like like IN 37231 4310 18 that that DT 37231 4310 19 regarding regard VBG 37231 4310 20 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4310 21 , , , 37231 4310 22 derived derive VBN 37231 4310 23 from from IN 37231 4310 24 the the DT 37231 4310 25 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4310 26 John,(3 John,(3 NNP 37231 4310 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4310 28 or or CC 37231 4310 29 is be VBZ 37231 4310 30 given give VBN 37231 4310 31 merely merely RB 37231 4310 32 on on IN 37231 4310 33 1 1 CD 37231 4310 34 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4310 35 Westcott Westcott NNP 37231 4310 36 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4310 37 admits admit VBZ 37231 4310 38 that that IN 37231 4310 39 " " `` 37231 4310 40 the the DT 37231 4310 41 proof proof NN 37231 4310 42 of of IN 37231 4310 43 the the DT 37231 4310 44 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4310 45 is be VBZ 37231 4310 46 rendered render VBN 37231 4310 47 more more RBR 37231 4310 48 difficult difficult JJ 37231 4310 49 by by IN 37231 4310 50 the the DT 37231 4310 51 uncritical uncritical JJ 37231 4310 52 character character NN 37231 4310 53 of of IN 37231 4310 54 the the DT 37231 4310 55 first first JJ 37231 4310 56 two two CD 37231 4310 57 centuries century NNS 37231 4310 58 . . . 37231 4310 59 " " '' 37231 4311 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4311 2 says say VBZ 37231 4311 3 : : : 37231 4311 4 " " `` 37231 4311 5 The the DT 37231 4311 6 spirit spirit NN 37231 4311 7 of of IN 37231 4311 8 the the DT 37231 4311 9 ancient ancient JJ 37231 4311 10 world world NN 37231 4311 11 was be VBD 37231 4311 12 essentially essentially RB 37231 4311 13 uncritical uncritical JJ 37231 4311 14 . . . 37231 4311 15 " " '' 37231 4312 1 On on IN 37231 4312 2 the the DT 37231 4312 3 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4312 4 , , , 37231 4312 5 p. p. NN 37231 4312 6 7 7 CD 37231 4312 7 f. f. NNS 37231 4312 8 { { -LRB- 37231 4312 9 462 462 CD 37231 4312 10 } } -RRB- 37231 4312 11 the the DT 37231 4312 12 authority authority NN 37231 4312 13 of of IN 37231 4312 14 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4312 15 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4312 16 . . . 37231 4313 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4313 2 1 1 LS 37231 4313 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4313 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4313 5 joins join VBZ 37231 4313 6 the the DT 37231 4313 7 account account NN 37231 4313 8 of of IN 37231 4313 9 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4313 10 to to IN 37231 4313 11 that that DT 37231 4313 12 given give VBN 37231 4313 13 by by IN 37231 4313 14 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4313 15 merely merely RB 37231 4313 16 by by IN 37231 4313 17 the the DT 37231 4313 18 following follow VBG 37231 4313 19 words word NNS 37231 4313 20 : : : 37231 4313 21 " " `` 37231 4313 22 These these DT 37231 4313 23 facts fact NNS 37231 4313 24 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4313 25 relates relate VBZ 37231 4313 26 concerning concern VBG 37231 4313 27 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4313 28 ; ; : 37231 4313 29 but but CC 37231 4313 30 regarding regard VBG 37231 4313 31 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4313 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4313 33 has have VBZ 37231 4313 34 said say VBN 37231 4313 35 as as IN 37231 4313 36 follows:"(2 follows:"(2 ADD 37231 4313 37 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4313 38 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4313 39 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 4313 40 states state VBZ 37231 4313 41 that that IN 37231 4313 42 the the DT 37231 4313 43 account account NN 37231 4313 44 regarding regard VBG 37231 4313 45 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4313 46 is be VBZ 37231 4313 47 derived derive VBN 37231 4313 48 from from IN 37231 4313 49 the the DT 37231 4313 50 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4313 51 , , , 37231 4313 52 and and CC 37231 4313 53 the the DT 37231 4313 54 only only JJ 37231 4313 55 reason reason NN 37231 4313 56 for for IN 37231 4313 57 ascribing ascribe VBG 37231 4313 58 to to IN 37231 4313 59 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4313 60 also also RB 37231 4313 61 that that IN 37231 4313 62 concerning concern VBG 37231 4313 63 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4313 64 is be VBZ 37231 4313 65 that that IN 37231 4313 66 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4313 67 is be VBZ 37231 4313 68 not not RB 37231 4313 69 excluded exclude VBN 37231 4313 70 by by IN 37231 4313 71 the the DT 37231 4313 72 phraseology phraseology NN 37231 4313 73 of of IN 37231 4313 74 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4313 75 , , , 37231 4313 76 and and CC 37231 4313 77 the the DT 37231 4313 78 two two CD 37231 4313 79 passages passage NNS 37231 4313 80 being be VBG 37231 4313 81 given give VBN 37231 4313 82 by by IN 37231 4313 83 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4313 84 consecutively consecutively RB 37231 4313 85 -- -- : 37231 4313 86 however however RB 37231 4313 87 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4313 88 may may MD 37231 4313 89 have have VB 37231 4313 90 stood stand VBN 37231 4313 91 in in IN 37231 4313 92 the the DT 37231 4313 93 work work NN 37231 4313 94 of of IN 37231 4313 95 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4313 96 -- -- : 37231 4313 97 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4313 98 is be VBZ 37231 4313 99 reasonable reasonable JJ 37231 4313 100 enough enough RB 37231 4313 101 to to TO 37231 4313 102 suppose suppose VB 37231 4313 103 that that IN 37231 4313 104 the the DT 37231 4313 105 information information NN 37231 4313 106 was be VBD 37231 4313 107 derived derive VBN 37231 4313 108 from from IN 37231 4313 109 the the DT 37231 4313 110 same same JJ 37231 4313 111 source source NN 37231 4313 112 . . . 37231 4314 1 The the DT 37231 4314 2 point point NN 37231 4314 3 is be VBZ 37231 4314 4 not not RB 37231 4314 5 of of IN 37231 4314 6 much much JJ 37231 4314 7 importance importance NN 37231 4314 8 , , , 37231 4314 9 but but CC 37231 4314 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4314 11 is be VBZ 37231 4314 12 clear clear JJ 37231 4314 13 that that IN 37231 4314 14 there there EX 37231 4314 15 is be VBZ 37231 4314 16 no no DT 37231 4314 17 absolute absolute JJ 37231 4314 18 right right NN 37231 4314 19 to to TO 37231 4314 20 trace trace VB 37231 4314 21 this this DT 37231 4314 22 statement statement NN 37231 4314 23 to to IN 37231 4314 24 the the DT 37231 4314 25 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4314 26 John John NNP 37231 4314 27 , , , 37231 4314 28 as as IN 37231 4314 29 there there EX 37231 4314 30 is be VBZ 37231 4314 31 in in IN 37231 4314 32 the the DT 37231 4314 33 case case NN 37231 4314 34 of of IN 37231 4314 35 the the DT 37231 4314 36 tradition tradition NN 37231 4314 37 about about IN 37231 4314 38 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4314 39 . . . 37231 4315 1 This this DT 37231 4315 2 passage passage NN 37231 4315 3 has have VBZ 37231 4315 4 excited excite VBN 37231 4315 5 even even RB 37231 4315 6 more more JJR 37231 4315 7 controversy controversy NN 37231 4315 8 than than IN 37231 4315 9 that that DT 37231 4315 10 regarding regard VBG 37231 4315 11 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4315 12 , , , 37231 4315 13 and and CC 37231 4315 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4315 15 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 4315 16 and and CC 37231 4315 17 application application NN 37231 4315 18 are be VBP 37231 4315 19 still still RB 37231 4315 20 keenly keenly RB 37231 4315 21 debated debate VBN 37231 4315 22 . . . 37231 4316 1 The the DT 37231 4316 2 intricacy intricacy NN 37231 4316 3 and and CC 37231 4316 4 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 4316 5 of of IN 37231 4316 6 the the DT 37231 4316 7 questions question NNS 37231 4316 8 which which WDT 37231 4316 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4316 10 raises raise VBZ 37231 4316 11 are be VBP 37231 4316 12 freely freely RB 37231 4316 13 admitted admit VBN 37231 4316 14 by by IN 37231 4316 15 some some DT 37231 4316 16 of of IN 37231 4316 17 the the DT 37231 4316 18 most most RBS 37231 4316 19 earnest earnest JJ 37231 4316 20 defenders defender NNS 37231 4316 21 of of IN 37231 4316 22 the the DT 37231 4316 23 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4316 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4316 25 , , , 37231 4316 26 but but CC 37231 4316 27 the the DT 37231 4316 28 problem problem NN 37231 4316 29 , , , 37231 4316 30 so so RB 37231 4316 31 far far RB 37231 4316 32 as as IN 37231 4316 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4316 34 examination examination NN 37231 4316 35 is be VBZ 37231 4316 36 concerned concern VBN 37231 4316 37 , , , 37231 4316 38 can can MD 37231 4316 39 be be VB 37231 4316 40 solved solve VBN 37231 4316 41 without without IN 37231 4316 42 much much JJ 37231 4316 43 trouble trouble NN 37231 4316 44 . . . 37231 4317 1 The the DT 37231 4317 2 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 4317 3 in in IN 37231 4317 4 which which WDT 37231 4317 5 apologists apologist NNS 37231 4317 6 find find VBP 37231 4317 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 37231 4317 8 when when WRB 37231 4317 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4317 10 attempt attempt VBP 37231 4317 11 closely closely RB 37231 4317 12 to to TO 37231 4317 13 apply apply VB 37231 4317 14 the the DT 37231 4317 15 description description NN 37231 4317 16 of of IN 37231 4317 17 this this DT 37231 4317 18 work work NN 37231 4317 19 given give VBN 37231 4317 20 by by IN 37231 4317 21 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4317 22 to to IN 37231 4317 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4317 24 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4317 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4317 26 is be VBZ 37231 4317 27 the the DT 37231 4317 28 great great JJ 37231 4317 29 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 4317 30 which which WDT 37231 4317 31 complicates complicate VBZ 37231 4317 32 the the DT 37231 4317 33 matter matter NN 37231 4317 34 and and CC 37231 4317 35 prevents prevent VBZ 37231 4317 36 a a DT 37231 4317 37 { { -LRB- 37231 4317 38 463 463 CD 37231 4317 39 } } -RRB- 37231 4317 40 clear clear JJ 37231 4317 41 and and CC 37231 4317 42 distinct distinct JJ 37231 4317 43 solution solution NN 37231 4317 44 of of IN 37231 4317 45 the the DT 37231 4317 46 question question NN 37231 4317 47 . . . 37231 4318 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4318 2 shall shall MD 37231 4318 3 avoid avoid VB 37231 4318 4 minute minute JJ 37231 4318 5 discussion discussion NN 37231 4318 6 of of IN 37231 4318 7 details detail NNS 37231 4318 8 , , , 37231 4318 9 contenting content VBG 37231 4318 10 ourselves -PRON- PRP 37231 4318 11 with with IN 37231 4318 12 the the DT 37231 4318 13 broader broad JJR 37231 4318 14 features feature NNS 37231 4318 15 of of IN 37231 4318 16 the the DT 37231 4318 17 argument argument NN 37231 4318 18 , , , 37231 4318 19 and and CC 37231 4318 20 seeking seek VBG 37231 4318 21 only only RB 37231 4318 22 to to TO 37231 4318 23 arrive arrive VB 37231 4318 24 at at IN 37231 4318 25 a a DT 37231 4318 26 just just JJ 37231 4318 27 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4318 28 as as IN 37231 4318 29 to to IN 37231 4318 30 the the DT 37231 4318 31 bearing bearing NN 37231 4318 32 of of IN 37231 4318 33 the the DT 37231 4318 34 evidence evidence NN 37231 4318 35 of of IN 37231 4318 36 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4318 37 upon upon IN 37231 4318 38 the the DT 37231 4318 39 claim claim NN 37231 4318 40 to to IN 37231 4318 41 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 4318 42 of of IN 37231 4318 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4318 44 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4318 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4318 46 . . . 37231 4319 1 The the DT 37231 4319 2 first first JJ 37231 4319 3 point point NN 37231 4319 4 which which WDT 37231 4319 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4319 6 have have VBP 37231 4319 7 to to TO 37231 4319 8 consider consider VB 37231 4319 9 is be VBZ 37231 4319 10 the the DT 37231 4319 11 nature nature NN 37231 4319 12 of of IN 37231 4319 13 the the DT 37231 4319 14 work work NN 37231 4319 15 which which WDT 37231 4319 16 is be VBZ 37231 4319 17 here here RB 37231 4319 18 described describe VBN 37231 4319 19 . . . 37231 4320 1 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4320 2 is be VBZ 37231 4320 3 said say VBN 37231 4320 4 to to TO 37231 4320 5 have have VB 37231 4320 6 composed compose VBN 37231 4320 7 the the DT 37231 4320 8 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4320 9 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4320 10 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4320 11 or or CC 37231 4320 12 Oracles Oracles NNP 37231 4320 13 , , , 37231 4320 14 and and CC 37231 4320 15 there there EX 37231 4320 16 can can MD 37231 4320 17 be be VB 37231 4320 18 little little JJ 37231 4320 19 doubt doubt NN 37231 4320 20 from from IN 37231 4320 21 the the DT 37231 4320 22 title title NN 37231 4320 23 of of IN 37231 4320 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4320 25 own own JJ 37231 4320 26 book book NN 37231 4320 27 : : : 37231 4320 28 " " `` 37231 4320 29 Exposition Exposition NNP 37231 4320 30 of of IN 37231 4320 31 the the DT 37231 4320 32 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4320 33 's 's POS 37231 4320 34 Oracles oracle NNS 37231 4320 35 " " '' 37231 4320 36 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4320 37 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4320 38 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4320 39 , , , 37231 4320 40 that that IN 37231 4320 41 these these DT 37231 4320 42 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4320 43 referred refer VBD 37231 4320 44 to to IN 37231 4320 45 by by IN 37231 4320 46 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4320 47 were be VBD 37231 4320 48 the the DT 37231 4320 49 Discourses discourse NNS 37231 4320 50 of of IN 37231 4320 51 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4320 52 . . . 37231 4321 1 Does do VBZ 37231 4321 2 the the DT 37231 4321 3 word word NN 37231 4321 4 Xoyta xoyta NN 37231 4321 5 , , , 37231 4321 6 however however RB 37231 4321 7 , , , 37231 4321 8 mean mean VB 37231 4321 9 strictly strictly RB 37231 4321 10 Oracles oracle NNS 37231 4321 11 or or CC 37231 4321 12 discourses discourse VBZ 37231 4321 13 alone alone RB 37231 4321 14 , , , 37231 4321 15 or or CC 37231 4321 16 does do VBZ 37231 4321 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4321 18 include include VB 37231 4321 19 within within IN 37231 4321 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4321 21 fair fair JJ 37231 4321 22 signification signification NN 37231 4321 23 also also RB 37231 4321 24 historical historical JJ 37231 4321 25 narrative narrative NN 37231 4321 26 ? ? . 37231 4322 1 " " `` 37231 4322 2 Were be VBD 37231 4322 3 the the DT 37231 4322 4 " " `` 37231 4322 5 Xoyta xoyta NN 37231 4322 6 " " '' 37231 4322 7 here here RB 37231 4322 8 referred refer VBD 37231 4322 9 to to IN 37231 4322 10 a a DT 37231 4322 11 simple simple JJ 37231 4322 12 collection collection NN 37231 4322 13 of of IN 37231 4322 14 the the DT 37231 4322 15 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4322 16 of of IN 37231 4322 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4322 18 , , , 37231 4322 19 or or CC 37231 4322 20 a a DT 37231 4322 21 complete complete JJ 37231 4322 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4322 23 like like IN 37231 4322 24 that that DT 37231 4322 25 in in IN 37231 4322 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4322 27 Canon Canon NNP 37231 4322 28 bearing bear VBG 37231 4322 29 the the DT 37231 4322 30 name name NN 37231 4322 31 of of IN 37231 4322 32 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4322 33 ? ? . 37231 4323 1 That that IN 37231 4323 2 the the DT 37231 4323 3 natural natural JJ 37231 4323 4 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 4323 5 of of IN 37231 4323 6 the the DT 37231 4323 7 word word NN 37231 4323 8 is be VBZ 37231 4323 9 merely merely RB 37231 4323 10 " " `` 37231 4323 11 Oracles Oracles NNP 37231 4323 12 " " '' 37231 4323 13 is be VBZ 37231 4323 14 indirectly indirectly RB 37231 4323 15 admitted admit VBN 37231 4323 16 , , , 37231 4323 17 even even RB 37231 4323 18 by by IN 37231 4323 19 the the DT 37231 4323 20 most most RBS 37231 4323 21 thorough thorough JJ 37231 4323 22 apologists apologist NNS 37231 4323 23 , , , 37231 4323 24 when when WRB 37231 4323 25 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4323 26 confess confess VBP 37231 4323 27 the the DT 37231 4323 28 obscurity obscurity NN 37231 4323 29 of of IN 37231 4323 30 the the DT 37231 4323 31 expression expression NN 37231 4323 32 -- -- : 37231 4323 33 obscurity obscurity NN 37231 4323 34 , , , 37231 4323 35 however however RB 37231 4323 36 , , , 37231 4323 37 which which WDT 37231 4323 38 simply simply RB 37231 4323 39 appears appear VBZ 37231 4323 40 to to TO 37231 4323 41 exist exist VB 37231 4323 42 from from IN 37231 4323 43 the the DT 37231 4323 44 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 4323 45 of of IN 37231 4323 46 straining strain VBG 37231 4323 47 the the DT 37231 4323 48 word word NN 37231 4323 49 to to TO 37231 4323 50 make make VB 37231 4323 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4323 52 apply apply VB 37231 4323 53 to to IN 37231 4323 54 the the DT 37231 4323 55 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4323 56 . . . 37231 4324 1 " " `` 37231 4324 2 In in IN 37231 4324 3 these these DT 37231 4324 4 sentences sentence NNS 37231 4324 5 , , , 37231 4324 6 " " '' 37231 4324 7 says say VBZ 37231 4324 8 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 4324 9 , , , 37231 4324 10 referring refer VBG 37231 4324 11 to to IN 37231 4324 12 the the DT 37231 4324 13 passage passage NN 37231 4324 14 about about IN 37231 4324 15 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4324 16 , , , 37231 4324 17 " " `` 37231 4324 18 there there EX 37231 4324 19 is be VBZ 37231 4324 20 much much JJ 37231 4324 21 obscurity obscurity NN 37231 4324 22 ; ; : 37231 4324 23 for for IN 37231 4324 24 instance instance NN 37231 4324 25 , , , 37231 4324 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4324 27 is be VBZ 37231 4324 28 doubtful doubtful JJ 37231 4324 29 whether whether IN 37231 4324 30 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4324 31 have have VBP 37231 4324 32 rightly rightly RB 37231 4324 33 translated translate VBN 37231 4324 34 ' ' '' 37231 4324 35 Discourses discourse NNS 37231 4324 36 of of IN 37231 4324 37 the the DT 37231 4324 38 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4324 39 , , , 37231 4324 40 ' ' '' 37231 4324 41 " " '' 37231 4324 42 and and CC 37231 4324 43 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4324 44 can can MD 37231 4324 45 only only RB 37231 4324 46 extend extend VB 37231 4324 47 the the DT 37231 4324 48 meaning meaning NN 37231 4324 49 to to TO 37231 4324 50 include include VB 37231 4324 51 historical historical JJ 37231 4324 52 narrative narrative NN 37231 4324 53 by by IN 37231 4324 54 leaving leave VBG 37231 4324 55 the the DT 37231 4324 56 real real JJ 37231 4324 57 meaning meaning NN 37231 4324 58 of of IN 37231 4324 59 the the DT 37231 4324 60 word word NN 37231 4324 61 and and CC 37231 4324 62 interpreting interpret VBG 37231 4324 63 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4324 64 by by IN 37231 4324 65 supposed suppose VBN 37231 4324 66 analogy analogy NN 37231 4324 67 . . . 37231 4325 1 There there EX 37231 4325 2 can can MD 37231 4325 3 be be VB 37231 4325 4 no no DT 37231 4325 5 doubt doubt NN 37231 4325 6 that that IN 37231 4325 7 the the DT 37231 4325 8 direct direct JJ 37231 4325 9 meaning meaning NN 37231 4325 10 of of IN 37231 4325 11 the the DT 37231 4325 12 word word NN 37231 4325 13 Xoyta xoyta NN 37231 4325 14 anciently anciently RB 37231 4325 15 and and CC 37231 4325 16 at at IN 37231 4325 17 the the DT 37231 4325 18 time time NN 37231 4325 19 of of IN 37231 4325 20 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4325 21 was be VBD 37231 4325 22 { { -LRB- 37231 4325 23 464 464 CD 37231 4325 24 } } -RRB- 37231 4325 25 simply simply RB 37231 4325 26 : : : 37231 4325 27 words word NNS 37231 4325 28 or or CC 37231 4325 29 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4325 30 of of IN 37231 4325 31 a a DT 37231 4325 32 sacred sacred JJ 37231 4325 33 character character NN 37231 4325 34 , , , 37231 4325 35 and and CC 37231 4325 36 however however RB 37231 4325 37 much much JJ 37231 4325 38 the the DT 37231 4325 39 signification signification NN 37231 4325 40 became become VBD 37231 4325 41 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 4325 42 extended extend VBN 37231 4325 43 , , , 37231 4325 44 that that IN 37231 4325 45 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4325 46 was be VBD 37231 4325 47 not not RB 37231 4325 48 then then RB 37231 4325 49 at at RB 37231 4325 50 all all RB 37231 4325 51 applied apply VBD 37231 4325 52 to to IN 37231 4325 53 doings doing NNS 37231 4325 54 as as RB 37231 4325 55 well well RB 37231 4325 56 as as IN 37231 4325 57 sayings saying NNS 37231 4325 58 . . . 37231 4326 1 There there EX 37231 4326 2 are be VBP 37231 4326 3 many many JJ 37231 4326 4 instances instance NNS 37231 4326 5 of of IN 37231 4326 6 this this DT 37231 4326 7 original original JJ 37231 4326 8 and and CC 37231 4326 9 limited limited JJ 37231 4326 10 signification signification NN 37231 4326 11 in in IN 37231 4326 12 the the DT 37231 4326 13 New New NNP 37231 4326 14 Testament;(1 Testament;(1 NNP 37231 4326 15 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4326 16 and and CC 37231 4326 17 there there EX 37231 4326 18 is be VBZ 37231 4326 19 no no DT 37231 4326 20 linguistic linguistic JJ 37231 4326 21 precedent precedent NN 37231 4326 22 for for IN 37231 4326 23 straining strain VBG 37231 4326 24 the the DT 37231 4326 25 expression expression NN 37231 4326 26 , , , 37231 4326 27 used use VBN 37231 4326 28 at at IN 37231 4326 29 that that DT 37231 4326 30 period period NN 37231 4326 31 , , , 37231 4326 32 to to TO 37231 4326 33 mean mean VB 37231 4326 34 anything anything NN 37231 4326 35 beyond beyond IN 37231 4326 36 a a DT 37231 4326 37 collection collection NN 37231 4326 38 of of IN 37231 4326 39 sayings saying NNS 37231 4326 40 of of IN 37231 4326 41 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4326 42 which which WDT 37231 4326 43 were be VBD 37231 4326 44 estimated estimate VBN 37231 4326 45 as as IN 37231 4326 46 oracular oracular JJ 37231 4326 47 or or CC 37231 4326 48 divine divine JJ 37231 4326 49 , , , 37231 4326 50 nor nor CC 37231 4326 51 is be VBZ 37231 4326 52 there there EX 37231 4326 53 any any DT 37231 4326 54 reason reason NN 37231 4326 55 for for IN 37231 4326 56 thinking think VBG 37231 4326 57 that that IN 37231 4326 58 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4326 59 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4326 60 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4326 61 was be VBD 37231 4326 62 here here RB 37231 4326 63 used use VBN 37231 4326 64 in in IN 37231 4326 65 any any DT 37231 4326 66 other other JJ 37231 4326 67 sense sense NN 37231 4326 68 . . . 37231 4327 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4327 2 2 2 LS 37231 4327 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4327 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4327 5 is be VBZ 37231 4327 6 argued argue VBN 37231 4327 7 { { -LRB- 37231 4327 8 465 465 CD 37231 4327 9 } } -RRB- 37231 4327 10 on on IN 37231 4327 11 the the DT 37231 4327 12 other other JJ 37231 4327 13 hand hand NN 37231 4327 14 , , , 37231 4327 15 that that IN 37231 4327 16 in in IN 37231 4327 17 the the DT 37231 4327 18 preceding precede VBG 37231 4327 19 passage passage NN 37231 4327 20 upon upon IN 37231 4327 21 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4327 22 , , , 37231 4327 23 a a DT 37231 4327 24 more more RBR 37231 4327 25 extended extended JJ 37231 4327 26 meaning meaning NN 37231 4327 27 of of IN 37231 4327 28 the the DT 37231 4327 29 word word NN 37231 4327 30 is be VBZ 37231 4327 31 indicated indicate VBN 37231 4327 32 . . . 37231 4328 1 The the DT 37231 4328 2 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4328 3 John John NNP 37231 4328 4 says say VBZ 37231 4328 5 that that IN 37231 4328 6 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4328 7 , , , 37231 4328 8 as as IN 37231 4328 9 the the DT 37231 4328 10 interpreter interpreter NN 37231 4328 11 of of IN 37231 4328 12 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4328 13 , , , 37231 4328 14 wrote write VBD 37231 4328 15 without without IN 37231 4328 16 order order NN 37231 4328 17 " " `` 37231 4328 18 the the DT 37231 4328 19 things thing NNS 37231 4328 20 which which WDT 37231 4328 21 were be VBD 37231 4328 22 either either CC 37231 4328 23 said say VBN 37231 4328 24 or or CC 37231 4328 25 done do VBN 37231 4328 26 by by IN 37231 4328 27 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4328 28 " " '' 37231 4328 29 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4328 30 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4328 31 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4328 32 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4328 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4328 34 , , , 37231 4328 35 and and CC 37231 4328 36 then then RB 37231 4328 37 , , , 37231 4328 38 apologizing apologize VBG 37231 4328 39 for for IN 37231 4328 40 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4328 41 , , , 37231 4328 42 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4328 43 goes go VBZ 37231 4328 44 on on RP 37231 4328 45 to to TO 37231 4328 46 say say VB 37231 4328 47 that that IN 37231 4328 48 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4328 49 , , , 37231 4328 50 whom whom WP 37231 4328 51 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4328 52 followed follow VBD 37231 4328 53 , , , 37231 4328 54 adapted adapt VBD 37231 4328 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4328 56 teaching teaching NN 37231 4328 57 to to IN 37231 4328 58 the the DT 37231 4328 59 occasion occasion NN 37231 4328 60 , , , 37231 4328 61 " " '' 37231 4328 62 and and CC 37231 4328 63 not not RB 37231 4328 64 as as IN 37231 4328 65 making make VBG 37231 4328 66 a a DT 37231 4328 67 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4328 68 record record NN 37231 4328 69 of of IN 37231 4328 70 the the DT 37231 4328 71 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4328 72 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4328 73 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4328 74 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4328 75 of of IN 37231 4328 76 the the DT 37231 4328 77 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4328 78 . . . 37231 4328 79 " " '' 37231 4329 1 Here here RB 37231 4329 2 , , , 37231 4329 3 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4329 4 is be VBZ 37231 4329 5 said say VBN 37231 4329 6 , , , 37231 4329 7 the the DT 37231 4329 8 word word NN 37231 4329 9 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4329 10 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4329 11 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4329 12 is be VBZ 37231 4329 13 used use VBN 37231 4329 14 in in IN 37231 4329 15 reference reference NN 37231 4329 16 both both CC 37231 4329 17 to to IN 37231 4329 18 sayings saying NNS 37231 4329 19 and and CC 37231 4329 20 doings doing NNS 37231 4329 21 , , , 37231 4329 22 and and CC 37231 4329 23 therefore therefore RB 37231 4329 24 in in IN 37231 4329 25 the the DT 37231 4329 26 passage passage NN 37231 4329 27 on on IN 37231 4329 28 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4329 29 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4329 30 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4329 31 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4329 32 must must MD 37231 4329 33 not not RB 37231 4329 34 be be VB 37231 4329 35 understood understand VBN 37231 4329 36 to to TO 37231 4329 37 mean mean VB 37231 4329 38 only only RB 37231 4329 39 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4329 40 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4329 41 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4329 42 , , , 37231 4329 43 but but CC 37231 4329 44 also also RB 37231 4329 45 includes include VBZ 37231 4329 46 , , , 37231 4329 47 as as IN 37231 4329 48 in in IN 37231 4329 49 the the DT 37231 4329 50 former former JJ 37231 4329 51 case case NN 37231 4329 52 , , , 37231 4329 53 the the DT 37231 4329 54 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4329 55 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4329 56 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4329 57 . . . 37231 4330 1 For for IN 37231 4330 2 these these DT 37231 4330 3 and and CC 37231 4330 4 similar similar JJ 37231 4330 5 reasons,--in reasons,--in NNP 37231 4330 6 very very RB 37231 4330 7 many many JJ 37231 4330 8 cases case NNS 37231 4330 9 largely largely RB 37231 4330 10 influenced influence VBN 37231 4330 11 by by IN 37231 4330 12 the the DT 37231 4330 13 desire desire NN 37231 4330 14 to to TO 37231 4330 15 see see VB 37231 4330 16 in in IN 37231 4330 17 these these DT 37231 4330 18 Xoyta Xoyta NNP 37231 4330 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4330 20 actual actual JJ 37231 4330 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4330 22 according accord VBG 37231 4330 23 to to IN 37231 4330 24 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4330 25 -- -- : 37231 4330 26 many many JJ 37231 4330 27 critics critic NNS 37231 4330 28 have have VBP 37231 4330 29 maintained maintain VBN 37231 4330 30 that that IN 37231 4330 31 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4330 32 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4330 33 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4330 34 in in IN 37231 4330 35 this this DT 37231 4330 36 place place NN 37231 4330 37 may may MD 37231 4330 38 be be VB 37231 4330 39 understood understand VBN 37231 4330 40 to to TO 37231 4330 41 include include VB 37231 4330 42 historical historical JJ 37231 4330 43 narrative narrative NN 37231 4330 44 as as RB 37231 4330 45 well well RB 37231 4330 46 as as IN 37231 4330 47 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4330 48 . . . 37231 4331 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4331 2 1 1 LS 37231 4331 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4331 4 The the DT 37231 4331 5 arguments argument NNS 37231 4331 6 by by IN 37231 4331 7 which which WDT 37231 4331 8 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4331 9 arrive arrive VBP 37231 4331 10 at at IN 37231 4331 11 this this DT 37231 4331 12 { { -LRB- 37231 4331 13 466 466 CD 37231 4331 14 } } -RRB- 37231 4331 15 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4331 16 , , , 37231 4331 17 however however RB 37231 4331 18 , , , 37231 4331 19 seem seem VBP 37231 4331 20 to to IN 37231 4331 21 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4331 22 to to TO 37231 4331 23 be be VB 37231 4331 24 based base VBN 37231 4331 25 upon upon IN 37231 4331 26 thorough thorough JJ 37231 4331 27 misconception misconception NN 37231 4331 28 of of IN 37231 4331 29 the the DT 37231 4331 30 direct direct JJ 37231 4331 31 meaning meaning NN 37231 4331 32 of of IN 37231 4331 33 the the DT 37231 4331 34 passage passage NN 37231 4331 35 . . . 37231 4332 1 Few few JJ 37231 4332 2 or or CC 37231 4332 3 none none NN 37231 4332 4 of of IN 37231 4332 5 these these DT 37231 4332 6 critics critic NNS 37231 4332 7 would would MD 37231 4332 8 deny deny VB 37231 4332 9 that that IN 37231 4332 10 the the DT 37231 4332 11 simple simple JJ 37231 4332 12 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 4332 13 of of IN 37231 4332 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4332 15 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4332 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4332 17 , , , 37231 4332 18 at at IN 37231 4332 19 that that DT 37231 4332 20 period period NN 37231 4332 21 , , , 37231 4332 22 was be VBD 37231 4332 23 oracular oracular JJ 37231 4332 24 sayings saying NNS 37231 4332 25 . . . 37231 4333 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4333 2 1 1 LS 37231 4333 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4333 4 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4333 5 shows show VBZ 37231 4333 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4333 7 preference preference NN 37231 4333 8 for for IN 37231 4333 9 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4333 10 in in IN 37231 4333 11 the the DT 37231 4333 12 very very JJ 37231 4333 13 title title NN 37231 4333 14 of of IN 37231 4333 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4333 16 lost lose VBN 37231 4333 17 book book NN 37231 4333 18 , , , 37231 4333 19 " " `` 37231 4333 20 Exposition exposition NN 37231 4333 21 of of IN 37231 4333 22 the the DT 37231 4333 23 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4333 24 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4333 25 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4333 26 of of IN 37231 4333 27 the the DT 37231 4333 28 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4333 29 , , , 37231 4333 30 " " '' 37231 4333 31 and and CC 37231 4333 32 in in IN 37231 4333 33 the the DT 37231 4333 34 account account NN 37231 4333 35 which which WDT 37231 4333 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4333 37 gives give VBZ 37231 4333 38 of of IN 37231 4333 39 the the DT 37231 4333 40 works work NNS 37231 4333 41 attributed attribute VBN 37231 4333 42 to to IN 37231 4333 43 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4333 44 and and CC 37231 4333 45 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4333 46 , , , 37231 4333 47 the the DT 37231 4333 48 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4333 49 evidently evidently RB 37231 4333 50 attracted attract VBD 37231 4333 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4333 52 chief chief JJ 37231 4333 53 interest interest NN 37231 4333 54 . . . 37231 4334 1 Now now RB 37231 4334 2 , , , 37231 4334 3 in in IN 37231 4334 4 the the DT 37231 4334 5 passage passage NN 37231 4334 6 regarding regard VBG 37231 4334 7 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4334 8 , , , 37231 4334 9 instead instead RB 37231 4334 10 of of IN 37231 4334 11 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4334 12 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4334 13 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4334 14 being be VBG 37231 4334 15 made make VBN 37231 4334 16 the the DT 37231 4334 17 equivalent equivalent NN 37231 4334 18 of of IN 37231 4334 19 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4334 20 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4334 21 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4334 22 and and CC 37231 4334 23 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4334 24 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4334 25 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4334 26 , , , 37231 4334 27 the the DT 37231 4334 28 very very RB 37231 4334 29 reverse reverse NN 37231 4334 30 is be VBZ 37231 4334 31 the the DT 37231 4334 32 fact fact NN 37231 4334 33 . . . 37231 4335 1 The the DT 37231 4335 2 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4335 3 says say VBZ 37231 4335 4 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4335 5 wrote write VBD 37231 4335 6 what what WP 37231 4335 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4335 8 remembered remember VBD 37231 4335 9 of of IN 37231 4335 10 the the DT 37231 4335 11 things thing NNS 37231 4335 12 which which WDT 37231 4335 13 were be VBD 37231 4335 14 said say VBN 37231 4335 15 or or CC 37231 4335 16 done do VBN 37231 4335 17 by by IN 37231 4335 18 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4335 19 , , , 37231 4335 20 although although IN 37231 4335 21 not not RB 37231 4335 22 in in IN 37231 4335 23 order order NN 37231 4335 24 , , , 37231 4335 25 and and CC 37231 4335 26 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4335 27 apologizes apologize VBZ 37231 4335 28 for for IN 37231 4335 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4335 30 doing do VBG 37231 4335 31 this this DT 37231 4335 32 on on IN 37231 4335 33 the the DT 37231 4335 34 ground ground NN 37231 4335 35 that that IN 37231 4335 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4335 37 had have VBD 37231 4335 38 not not RB 37231 4335 39 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4335 40 been be VBN 37231 4335 41 a a DT 37231 4335 42 _ _ NNP 37231 4335 43 hearer hearer NN 37231 4335 44 _ _ NNP 37231 4335 45 of of IN 37231 4335 46 the the DT 37231 4335 47 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4335 48 , , , 37231 4335 49 but but CC 37231 4335 50 merely merely RB 37231 4335 51 reported report VBD 37231 4335 52 what what WP 37231 4335 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4335 54 had have VBD 37231 4335 55 heard hear VBN 37231 4335 56 from from IN 37231 4335 57 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4335 58 , , , 37231 4335 59 who who WP 37231 4335 60 adapted adapt VBD 37231 4335 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4335 62 teaching teaching NN 37231 4335 63 to to IN 37231 4335 64 the the DT 37231 4335 65 occasion occasion NN 37231 4335 66 , , , 37231 4335 67 and and CC 37231 4335 68 did do VBD 37231 4335 69 _ _ NNP 37231 4335 70 not not RB 37231 4335 71 _ _ NNP 37231 4335 72 attempt attempt NN 37231 4335 73 to to TO 37231 4335 74 give give VB 37231 4335 75 a a DT 37231 4335 76 consecutive consecutive JJ 37231 4335 77 record record NN 37231 4335 78 of of IN 37231 4335 79 the the DT 37231 4335 80 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4335 81 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4335 82 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4335 83 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4335 84 of of IN 37231 4335 85 the the DT 37231 4335 86 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4335 87 . . . 37231 4336 1 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4336 2 , , , 37231 4336 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 4336 4 , , , 37231 4336 5 could could MD 37231 4336 6 not not RB 37231 4336 7 do do VB 37231 4336 8 so so RB 37231 4336 9 either either RB 37231 4336 10 . . . 37231 4337 1 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4337 2 , , , 37231 4337 3 on on IN 37231 4337 4 the the DT 37231 4337 5 contrary contrary NN 37231 4337 6 , , , 37231 4337 7 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4337 8 states state VBZ 37231 4337 9 , , , 37231 4337 10 did do VBD 37231 4337 11 compose compose VB 37231 4337 12 the the DT 37231 4337 13 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4337 14 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4337 15 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4337 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4337 17 . . . 37231 4338 1 There there EX 37231 4338 2 is be VBZ 37231 4338 3 an an DT 37231 4338 4 evident evident JJ 37231 4338 5 contrast contrast NN 37231 4338 6 made make VBN 37231 4338 7 : : : 37231 4338 8 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4338 9 { { -LRB- 37231 4338 10 467 467 CD 37231 4338 11 } } -RRB- 37231 4338 12 wrote write VBD 37231 4338 13 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4338 14 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4338 15 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4338 16 because because IN 37231 4338 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4338 18 had have VBD 37231 4338 19 not not RB 37231 4338 20 the the DT 37231 4338 21 means mean NNS 37231 4338 22 of of IN 37231 4338 23 writing write VBG 37231 4338 24 the the DT 37231 4338 25 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4338 26 , , , 37231 4338 27 but but CC 37231 4338 28 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4338 29 composed compose VBD 37231 4338 30 the the DT 37231 4338 31 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4338 32 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4338 33 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4338 34 . . . 37231 4339 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4339 2 1 1 LS 37231 4339 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4339 4 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4339 5 clearly clearly RB 37231 4339 6 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 37231 4339 7 the the DT 37231 4339 8 work work NN 37231 4339 9 of of IN 37231 4339 10 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4339 11 , , , 37231 4339 12 who who WP 37231 4339 13 had have VBD 37231 4339 14 written write VBN 37231 4339 15 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 37231 4339 16 of of IN 37231 4339 17 what what WP 37231 4339 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4339 19 had have VBD 37231 4339 20 said say VBD 37231 4339 21 and and CC 37231 4339 22 done do VBN 37231 4339 23 , , , 37231 4339 24 from from IN 37231 4339 25 that that DT 37231 4339 26 of of IN 37231 4339 27 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4339 28 , , , 37231 4339 29 who who WP 37231 4339 30 had have VBD 37231 4339 31 made make VBN 37231 4339 32 a a DT 37231 4339 33 collection collection NN 37231 4339 34 of of IN 37231 4339 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4339 36 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4339 37 . . . 37231 4340 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4340 2 2 2 LS 37231 4340 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4340 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4340 5 is be VBZ 37231 4340 6 impossible impossible JJ 37231 4340 7 upon upon IN 37231 4340 8 any any DT 37231 4340 9 but but CC 37231 4340 10 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 4340 11 grounds ground NNS 37231 4340 12 , , , 37231 4340 13 and and CC 37231 4340 14 from from IN 37231 4340 15 a a DT 37231 4340 16 foregone foregone JJ 37231 4340 17 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4340 18 , , , 37231 4340 19 to to TO 37231 4340 20 maintain maintain VB 37231 4340 21 that that IN 37231 4340 22 a a DT 37231 4340 23 work work NN 37231 4340 24 commencing commence VBG 37231 4340 25 with with IN 37231 4340 26 a a DT 37231 4340 27 detailed detailed JJ 37231 4340 28 history history NN 37231 4340 29 of of IN 37231 4340 30 the the DT 37231 4340 31 birth birth NN 37231 4340 32 and and CC 37231 4340 33 infancy infancy NN 37231 4340 34 of of IN 37231 4340 35 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4340 36 , , , 37231 4340 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4340 38 genealogy genealogy NN 37231 4340 39 , , , 37231 4340 40 and and CC 37231 4340 41 the the DT 37231 4340 42 preaching preaching NN 37231 4340 43 of of IN 37231 4340 44 John John NNP 37231 4340 45 the the DT 37231 4340 46 Baptist Baptist NNP 37231 4340 47 , , , 37231 4340 48 and and CC 37231 4340 49 concluding conclude VBG 37231 4340 50 with with IN 37231 4340 51 an an DT 37231 4340 52 equally equally RB 37231 4340 53 minute minute JJ 37231 4340 54 history history NN 37231 4340 55 of of IN 37231 4340 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4340 57 betrayal betrayal NN 37231 4340 58 , , , 37231 4340 59 trial trial NN 37231 4340 60 , , , 37231 4340 61 crucifixion crucifixion NN 37231 4340 62 , , , 37231 4340 63 and and CC 37231 4340 64 resurrection resurrection NN 37231 4340 65 , , , 37231 4340 66 and and CC 37231 4340 67 which which WDT 37231 4340 68 relates relate VBZ 37231 4340 69 all all PDT 37231 4340 70 the the DT 37231 4340 71 miracles miracle NNS 37231 4340 72 and and CC 37231 4340 73 has have VBZ 37231 4340 74 for for IN 37231 4340 75 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4340 76 evident evident JJ 37231 4340 77 aim aim NN 37231 4340 78 throughout throughout IN 37231 4340 79 the the DT 37231 4340 80 demonstration demonstration NN 37231 4340 81 that that IN 37231 4340 82 Messianic Messianic NNP 37231 4340 83 prophecy prophecy NN 37231 4340 84 was be VBD 37231 4340 85 fulfilled fulfil VBN 37231 4340 86 in in IN 37231 4340 87 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4340 88 , , , 37231 4340 89 could could MD 37231 4340 90 be be VB 37231 4340 91 entitled entitle VBN 37231 4340 92 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4340 93 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4340 94 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4340 95 : : : 37231 4340 96 the the DT 37231 4340 97 oracles oracle NNS 37231 4340 98 or or CC 37231 4340 99 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4340 100 of of IN 37231 4340 101 the the DT 37231 4340 102 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4340 103 . . . 37231 4341 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4341 2 3 3 LS 37231 4341 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4341 4 Partly partly RB 37231 4341 5 for for IN 37231 4341 6 these these DT 37231 4341 7 , , , 37231 4341 8 but but CC 37231 4341 9 also also RB 37231 4341 10 for for IN 37231 4341 11 other other JJ 37231 4341 12 important important JJ 37231 4341 13 reasons reason NNS 37231 4341 14 , , , 37231 4341 15 some some DT 37231 4341 16 of of IN 37231 4341 17 which which WDT 37231 4341 18 shall shall MD 37231 4341 19 presently presently RB 37231 4341 20 be be VB 37231 4341 21 referred refer VBN 37231 4341 22 to to IN 37231 4341 23 , , , 37231 4341 24 the the DT 37231 4341 25 great great JJ 37231 4341 26 majority majority NN 37231 4341 27 of of IN 37231 4341 28 critics critic NNS 37231 4341 29 deny deny VBP 37231 4341 30 that that IN 37231 4341 31 the the DT 37231 4341 32 work work NN 37231 4341 33 described describe VBN 37231 4341 34 by by IN 37231 4341 35 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4341 36 can can MD 37231 4341 37 be be VB 37231 4341 38 the the DT 37231 4341 39 same same JJ 37231 4341 40 as as IN 37231 4341 41 the the DT 37231 4341 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4341 43 in in IN 37231 4341 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4341 45 canon canon NN 37231 4341 46 bearing bear VBG 37231 4341 47 the the DT 37231 4341 48 name name NN 37231 4341 49 of of IN 37231 4341 50 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4341 51 . . . 37231 4342 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4342 2 4 4 LS 37231 4342 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4342 4 Whilst whilst IN 37231 4342 5 of of IN 37231 4342 6 those those DT 37231 4342 7 who who WP 37231 4342 8 { { -LRB- 37231 4342 9 468 468 CD 37231 4342 10 } } -RRB- 37231 4342 11 suppose suppose VBP 37231 4342 12 that that IN 37231 4342 13 the the DT 37231 4342 14 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4342 15 Aramaic Aramaic NNP 37231 4342 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4342 17 original original JJ 37231 4342 18 of of IN 37231 4342 19 which which WDT 37231 4342 20 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4342 21 speaks speak VBZ 37231 4342 22 may may MD 37231 4342 23 have have VB 37231 4342 24 been be VBN 37231 4342 25 substantially substantially RB 37231 4342 26 similar similar JJ 37231 4342 27 to to IN 37231 4342 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4342 29 in in IN 37231 4342 30 construction construction NN 37231 4342 31 , , , 37231 4342 32 very very RB 37231 4342 33 few few JJ 37231 4342 34 affirm affirm NN 37231 4342 35 that that IN 37231 4342 36 the the DT 37231 4342 37 work work NN 37231 4342 38 did do VBD 37231 4342 39 not not RB 37231 4342 40 receive receive VB 37231 4342 41 much much JJ 37231 4342 42 subsequent subsequent JJ 37231 4342 43 manipulation manipulation NN 37231 4342 44 , , , 37231 4342 45 addition addition NN 37231 4342 46 , , , 37231 4342 47 and and CC 37231 4342 48 alteration alteration NN 37231 4342 49 , , , 37231 4342 50 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 4342 51 including include VBG 37231 4342 52 translation translation NN 37231 4342 53 , , , 37231 4342 54 before before IN 37231 4342 55 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4342 56 assumed assume VBD 37231 4342 57 the the DT 37231 4342 58 form form NN 37231 4342 59 in in IN 37231 4342 60 which which WDT 37231 4342 61 the the DT 37231 4342 62 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4342 63 now now RB 37231 4342 64 lies lie VBZ 37231 4342 65 before before IN 37231 4342 66 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4342 67 , , , 37231 4342 68 and and CC 37231 4342 69 many many JJ 37231 4342 70 of of IN 37231 4342 71 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4342 72 altogether altogether RB 37231 4342 73 deny deny VBP 37231 4342 74 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4342 75 actual actual JJ 37231 4342 76 apostolic apostolic NNP 37231 4342 77 origin origin NN 37231 4342 78 . . . 37231 4343 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4343 2 1 1 LS 37231 4343 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4343 4 The the DT 37231 4343 5 next next RB 37231 4343 6 most most RBS 37231 4343 7 important important JJ 37231 4343 8 and and CC 37231 4343 9 obvious obvious JJ 37231 4343 10 point point NN 37231 4343 11 is be VBZ 37231 4343 12 that that IN 37231 4343 13 the the DT 37231 4343 14 work work NN 37231 4343 15 described describe VBN 37231 4343 16 in in IN 37231 4343 17 this this DT 37231 4343 18 passage passage NN 37231 4343 19 was be VBD 37231 4343 20 written write VBN 37231 4343 21 by by IN 37231 4343 22 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4343 23 { { -LRB- 37231 4343 24 469 469 CD 37231 4343 25 } } -RRB- 37231 4343 26 in in IN 37231 4343 27 the the DT 37231 4343 28 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4343 29 or or CC 37231 4343 30 Aramaic Aramaic NNP 37231 4343 31 dialect dialect VB 37231 4343 32 , , , 37231 4343 33 and and CC 37231 4343 34 each each DT 37231 4343 35 one one NN 37231 4343 36 who who WP 37231 4343 37 did do VBD 37231 4343 38 not not RB 37231 4343 39 understand understand VB 37231 4343 40 that that DT 37231 4343 41 dialect dialect NN 37231 4343 42 was be VBD 37231 4343 43 obliged oblige VBN 37231 4343 44 to to TO 37231 4343 45 translate translate VB 37231 4343 46 as as IN 37231 4343 47 best best RB 37231 4343 48 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4343 49 could could MD 37231 4343 50 . . . 37231 4344 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4344 2 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4344 3 according accord VBG 37231 4344 4 to to IN 37231 4344 5 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4344 6 , , , 37231 4344 7 however however RB 37231 4344 8 , , , 37231 4344 9 is be VBZ 37231 4344 10 in in IN 37231 4344 11 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4344 12 . . . 37231 4345 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 4345 2 , , , 37231 4345 3 who who WP 37231 4345 4 is be VBZ 37231 4345 5 obliged oblige VBN 37231 4345 6 to to TO 37231 4345 7 acknowledge acknowledge VB 37231 4345 8 the the DT 37231 4345 9 Greek greek JJ 37231 4345 10 originality originality NN 37231 4345 11 of of IN 37231 4345 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4345 13 actual actual JJ 37231 4345 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4345 15 , , , 37231 4345 16 and and CC 37231 4345 17 that that IN 37231 4345 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4345 19 is be VBZ 37231 4345 20 not not RB 37231 4345 21 a a DT 37231 4345 22 translation translation NN 37231 4345 23 from from IN 37231 4345 24 another another DT 37231 4345 25 language language NN 37231 4345 26 , , , 37231 4345 27 recognizes recognize VBZ 37231 4345 28 the the DT 37231 4345 29 inevitable inevitable JJ 37231 4345 30 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 4345 31 in in IN 37231 4345 32 which which WDT 37231 4345 33 this this DT 37231 4345 34 fact fact NN 37231 4345 35 places place VBZ 37231 4345 36 apologists apologist NNS 37231 4345 37 , , , 37231 4345 38 and and CC 37231 4345 39 has have VBZ 37231 4345 40 , , , 37231 4345 41 with with IN 37231 4345 42 a a DT 37231 4345 43 few few JJ 37231 4345 44 other other JJ 37231 4345 45 critics critic NNS 37231 4345 46 , , , 37231 4345 47 no no DT 37231 4345 48 better well JJR 37231 4345 49 argument argument NN 37231 4345 50 with with IN 37231 4345 51 which which WDT 37231 4345 52 to to TO 37231 4345 53 meet meet VB 37231 4345 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4345 55 than than IN 37231 4345 56 the the DT 37231 4345 57 simple simple JJ 37231 4345 58 suggestion suggestion NN 37231 4345 59 that that IN 37231 4345 60 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4345 61 must must MD 37231 4345 62 have have VB 37231 4345 63 been be VBN 37231 4345 64 mistaken mistake VBN 37231 4345 65 in in IN 37231 4345 66 saying say VBG 37231 4345 67 that that IN 37231 4345 68 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4345 69 wrote write VBD 37231 4345 70 in in IN 37231 4345 71 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4345 72 . . . 37231 4346 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4346 2 1 1 LS 37231 4346 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4346 4 Just just RB 37231 4346 5 as as RB 37231 4346 6 much much JJ 37231 4346 7 of of IN 37231 4346 8 the the DT 37231 4346 9 testimony testimony NN 37231 4346 10 as as IN 37231 4346 11 is be VBZ 37231 4346 12 convenient convenient JJ 37231 4346 13 or or CC 37231 4346 14 favourable favourable JJ 37231 4346 15 is be VBZ 37231 4346 16 eagerly eagerly RB 37231 4346 17 claimed claim VBN 37231 4346 18 by by IN 37231 4346 19 such such JJ 37231 4346 20 apologists apologist NNS 37231 4346 21 , , , 37231 4346 22 and and CC 37231 4346 23 the the DT 37231 4346 24 rest rest NN 37231 4346 25 , , , 37231 4346 26 which which WDT 37231 4346 27 destroys destroy VBZ 37231 4346 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4346 29 applicability applicability NN 37231 4346 30 to to IN 37231 4346 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4346 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4346 33 , , , 37231 4346 34 is be VBZ 37231 4346 35 set set VBN 37231 4346 36 aside aside RB 37231 4346 37 as as IN 37231 4346 38 a a DT 37231 4346 39 mistake mistake NN 37231 4346 40 . . . 37231 4347 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 4347 2 perceives perceive VBZ 37231 4347 3 the the DT 37231 4347 4 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 4347 5 , , , 37231 4347 6 but but CC 37231 4347 7 not not RB 37231 4347 8 having have VBG 37231 4347 9 arguments argument NNS 37231 4347 10 to to TO 37231 4347 11 meet meet VB 37231 4347 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4347 13 , , , 37231 4347 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4347 15 takes take VBZ 37231 4347 16 refuge refuge NN 37231 4347 17 in in IN 37231 4347 18 feeling feeling NN 37231 4347 19 . . . 37231 4348 1 " " `` 37231 4348 2 In in IN 37231 4348 3 this this DT 37231 4348 4 , , , 37231 4348 5 " " '' 37231 4348 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4348 7 says say VBZ 37231 4348 8 , , , 37231 4348 9 " " `` 37231 4348 10 there there EX 37231 4348 11 lies lie VBZ 37231 4348 12 before before IN 37231 4348 13 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4348 14 one one CD 37231 4348 15 of of IN 37231 4348 16 the the DT 37231 4348 17 most most RBS 37231 4348 18 complicated complicated JJ 37231 4348 19 questions question NNS 37231 4348 20 , , , 37231 4348 21 whose whose WP$ 37231 4348 22 detailed detailed JJ 37231 4348 23 treatment treatment NN 37231 4348 24 would would MD 37231 4348 25 here here RB 37231 4348 26 not not RB 37231 4348 27 be be VB 37231 4348 28 in in IN 37231 4348 29 place place NN 37231 4348 30 . . . 37231 4349 1 For for IN 37231 4349 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4349 3 part part NN 37231 4349 4 , , , 37231 4349 5 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4349 6 are be VBP 37231 4349 7 fully fully RB 37231 4349 8 at at IN 37231 4349 9 rest rest NN 37231 4349 10 concerning concern VBG 37231 4349 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4349 12 , , , 37231 4349 13 in in IN 37231 4349 14 the the DT 37231 4349 15 conviction conviction NN 37231 4349 16 that that IN 37231 4349 17 the the DT 37231 4349 18 assumption assumption NN 37231 4349 19 by by IN 37231 4349 20 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4349 21 of of IN 37231 4349 22 a a DT 37231 4349 23 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4349 24 original original JJ 37231 4349 25 text text NN 37231 4349 26 of of IN 37231 4349 27 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4349 28 , , , 37231 4349 29 which which WDT 37231 4349 30 already already RB 37231 4349 31 in in IN 37231 4349 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4349 33 time time NN 37231 4349 34 can can MD 37231 4349 35 not not RB 37231 4349 36 have have VB 37231 4349 37 been be VBN 37231 4349 38 limited limit VBN 37231 4349 39 to to IN 37231 4349 40 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4349 41 and and CC 37231 4349 42 was be VBD 37231 4349 43 soon soon RB 37231 4349 44 repeated repeat VBN 37231 4349 45 by by IN 37231 4349 46 other other JJ 37231 4349 47 men man NNS 37231 4349 48 , , , 37231 4349 49 arises arise VBZ 37231 4349 50 only only RB 37231 4349 51 from from IN 37231 4349 52 a a DT 37231 4349 53 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN 37231 4349 54 . . . 37231 4350 1 " " `` 37231 4350 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4350 3 3 3 LS 37231 4350 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4350 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4350 6 is be VBZ 37231 4350 7 difficult difficult JJ 37231 4350 8 to to TO 37231 4350 9 comprehend comprehend VB 37231 4350 10 why why WRB 37231 4350 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4350 12 should should MD 37231 4350 13 be be VB 37231 4350 14 considered consider VBN 37231 4350 15 out out IN 37231 4350 16 of of IN 37231 4350 17 place place NN 37231 4350 18 in in IN 37231 4350 19 a a DT 37231 4350 20 work work NN 37231 4350 21 specially specially RB 37231 4350 22 written write VBN 37231 4350 23 to to TO 37231 4350 24 establish establish VB 37231 4350 25 the the DT 37231 4350 26 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 4350 27 of of IN 37231 4350 28 the the DT 37231 4350 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4350 30 to to TO 37231 4350 31 discuss discuss VB 37231 4350 32 fully fully RB 37231 4350 33 so so RB 37231 4350 34 vital vital JJ 37231 4350 35 a a DT 37231 4350 36 point point NN 37231 4350 37 , , , 37231 4350 38 and and CC 37231 4350 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4350 40 deliberate deliberate JJ 37231 4350 41 evasion evasion NN 37231 4350 42 in in IN 37231 4350 43 such such PDT 37231 4350 44 a a DT 37231 4350 45 manner manner NN 37231 4350 46 alone alone RB 37231 4350 47 can can MD 37231 4350 48 be be VB 37231 4350 49 deemed deem VBN 37231 4350 50 out out IN 37231 4350 51 of of IN 37231 4350 52 place place NN 37231 4350 53 on on IN 37231 4350 54 such such PDT 37231 4350 55 an an DT 37231 4350 56 occasion occasion NN 37231 4350 57 . . . 37231 4351 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4351 2 3 3 LS 37231 4351 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4351 4 { { -LRB- 37231 4351 5 470 470 CD 37231 4351 6 } } -RRB- 37231 4351 7 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4351 8 may may MD 37231 4351 9 here here RB 37231 4351 10 briefly briefly RB 37231 4351 11 remark remark VB 37231 4351 12 that that DT 37231 4351 13 Teschendorf Teschendorf NNP 37231 4351 14 and and CC 37231 4351 15 others(1 others(1 NN 37231 4351 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4351 17 repeat repeat NN 37231 4351 18 with with IN 37231 4351 19 approval approval NN 37231 4351 20 the the DT 37231 4351 21 disparaging disparage VBG 37231 4351 22 expressions expression NNS 37231 4351 23 against against IN 37231 4351 24 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4351 25 which which WDT 37231 4351 26 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4351 27 , , , 37231 4351 28 for for IN 37231 4351 29 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 4351 30 reasons reason NNS 37231 4351 31 , , , 37231 4351 32 did do VBD 37231 4351 33 not not RB 37231 4351 34 scruple scruple JJ 37231 4351 35 to to TO 37231 4351 36 use use VB 37231 4351 37 , , , 37231 4351 38 and and CC 37231 4351 39 in in IN 37231 4351 40 this this DT 37231 4351 41 way way NN 37231 4351 42 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4351 43 seek seek VBP 37231 4351 44 somewhat somewhat RB 37231 4351 45 to to TO 37231 4351 46 depreciate depreciate VB 37231 4351 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4351 48 testimony testimony NN 37231 4351 49 , , , 37231 4351 50 or or CC 37231 4351 51 at at IN 37231 4351 52 least least JJS 37231 4351 53 indirectly indirectly RB 37231 4351 54 to to TO 37231 4351 55 warrant warrant VB 37231 4351 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4351 57 free free JJ 37231 4351 58 handling handling NN 37231 4351 59 of of IN 37231 4351 60 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4351 61 . . . 37231 4352 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4352 2 is be VBZ 37231 4352 3 true true JJ 37231 4352 4 that that IN 37231 4352 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4352 6 says say VBZ 37231 4352 7 that that IN 37231 4352 8 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4352 9 was be VBD 37231 4352 10 a a DT 37231 4352 11 man man NN 37231 4352 12 of of IN 37231 4352 13 very very RB 37231 4352 14 limited limited JJ 37231 4352 15 comprehension(2 comprehension(2 JJ 37231 4352 16 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4352 17 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4352 18 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4352 19 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4352 20 , , , 37231 4352 21 but but CC 37231 4352 22 this this DT 37231 4352 23 is be VBZ 37231 4352 24 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 37231 4352 25 to to TO 37231 4352 26 be be VB 37231 4352 27 on on IN 37231 4352 28 account account NN 37231 4352 29 of of IN 37231 4352 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4352 31 Millenarian Millenarian NNP 37231 4352 32 opinions,(3 opinions,(3 NN 37231 4352 33 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4352 34 to to TO 37231 4352 35 which which WDT 37231 4352 36 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4352 37 was be VBD 37231 4352 38 vehemently vehemently RB 37231 4352 39 opposed oppose VBN 37231 4352 40 . . . 37231 4353 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4353 2 must must MD 37231 4353 3 be be VB 37231 4353 4 borne bear VBN 37231 4353 5 in in IN 37231 4353 6 mind mind NN 37231 4353 7 , , , 37231 4353 8 however however RB 37231 4353 9 , , , 37231 4353 10 that that IN 37231 4353 11 the the DT 37231 4353 12 Chiliastic chiliastic JJ 37231 4353 13 passage passage NN 37231 4353 14 from from IN 37231 4353 15 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4353 16 quoted quote VBN 37231 4353 17 by by IN 37231 4353 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4353 19 , , , 37231 4353 20 and and CC 37231 4353 21 in in IN 37231 4353 22 which which WDT 37231 4353 23 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4353 24 certainly certainly RB 37231 4353 25 saw see VBD 37231 4353 26 nothing nothing NN 37231 4353 27 foolish foolish JJ 37231 4353 28 , , , 37231 4353 29 is be VBZ 37231 4353 30 given give VBN 37231 4353 31 on on IN 37231 4353 32 the the DT 37231 4353 33 authority authority NN 37231 4353 34 of of IN 37231 4353 35 the the DT 37231 4353 36 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4353 37 John John NNP 37231 4353 38 , , , 37231 4353 39 to to IN 37231 4353 40 whom whom WP 37231 4353 41 , , , 37231 4353 42 and and CC 37231 4353 43 not not RB 37231 4353 44 to to IN 37231 4353 45 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4353 46 , , , 37231 4353 47 any any DT 37231 4353 48 criticism criticism NN 37231 4353 49 upon upon IN 37231 4353 50 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4353 51 must must MD 37231 4353 52 be be VB 37231 4353 53 referred refer VBN 37231 4353 54 . . . 37231 4354 1 If if IN 37231 4354 2 the the DT 37231 4354 3 passage passage NN 37231 4354 4 be be VBP 37231 4354 5 not not RB 37231 4354 6 of of IN 37231 4354 7 a a DT 37231 4354 8 very very RB 37231 4354 9 elevated elevated JJ 37231 4354 10 character character NN 37231 4354 11 , , , 37231 4354 12 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4354 13 is be VBZ 37231 4354 14 quite quite RB 37231 4354 15 in in IN 37231 4354 16 the the DT 37231 4354 17 spirit spirit NN 37231 4354 18 of of IN 37231 4354 19 that that DT 37231 4354 20 age age NN 37231 4354 21 . . . 37231 4355 1 The the DT 37231 4355 2 main main JJ 37231 4355 3 point point NN 37231 4355 4 , , , 37231 4355 5 however however RB 37231 4355 6 , , , 37231 4355 7 is be VBZ 37231 4355 8 that that IN 37231 4355 9 in in IN 37231 4355 10 regard regard NN 37231 4355 11 to to IN 37231 4355 12 the the DT 37231 4355 13 testimony testimony NN 37231 4355 14 of of IN 37231 4355 15 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4355 16 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4355 17 have have VBP 37231 4355 18 little little JJ 37231 4355 19 to to IN 37231 4355 20 { { -LRB- 37231 4355 21 471 471 CD 37231 4355 22 } } -RRB- 37231 4355 23 do do VB 37231 4355 24 with with IN 37231 4355 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4355 26 general general JJ 37231 4355 27 ability ability NN 37231 4355 28 , , , 37231 4355 29 for for IN 37231 4355 30 all all DT 37231 4355 31 that that WDT 37231 4355 32 was be VBD 37231 4355 33 requisite requisite JJ 37231 4355 34 was be VBD 37231 4355 35 the the DT 37231 4355 36 power power NN 37231 4355 37 to to TO 37231 4355 38 see see VB 37231 4355 39 , , , 37231 4355 40 hear hear VB 37231 4355 41 , , , 37231 4355 42 and and CC 37231 4355 43 accurately accurately RB 37231 4355 44 state state VBP 37231 4355 45 very very RB 37231 4355 46 simple simple JJ 37231 4355 47 facts fact NNS 37231 4355 48 . . . 37231 4356 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4356 2 repeats repeat VBZ 37231 4356 3 what what WP 37231 4356 4 is be VBZ 37231 4356 5 told tell VBN 37231 4356 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4356 7 by by IN 37231 4356 8 the the DT 37231 4356 9 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4356 10 , , , 37231 4356 11 and and CC 37231 4356 12 in in IN 37231 4356 13 such such JJ 37231 4356 14 matters matter NNS 37231 4356 15 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4356 16 presume presume VBP 37231 4356 17 that that IN 37231 4356 18 the the DT 37231 4356 19 Bishop Bishop NNP 37231 4356 20 of of IN 37231 4356 21 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 37231 4356 22 must must MD 37231 4356 23 be be VB 37231 4356 24 admitted admit VBN 37231 4356 25 to to TO 37231 4356 26 have have VB 37231 4356 27 been be VBN 37231 4356 28 competent competent JJ 37231 4356 29 . . . 37231 4357 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4357 2 1 1 LS 37231 4357 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4357 4 There there EX 37231 4357 5 is be VBZ 37231 4357 6 no no DT 37231 4357 7 point point NN 37231 4357 8 , , , 37231 4357 9 however however RB 37231 4357 10 , , , 37231 4357 11 on on IN 37231 4357 12 which which WDT 37231 4357 13 the the DT 37231 4357 14 testimony testimony NN 37231 4357 15 of of IN 37231 4357 16 the the DT 37231 4357 17 Fathers father NNS 37231 4357 18 is be VBZ 37231 4357 19 more more RBR 37231 4357 20 invariable invariable JJ 37231 4357 21 and and CC 37231 4357 22 complete complete JJ 37231 4357 23 than than IN 37231 4357 24 that that IN 37231 4357 25 the the DT 37231 4357 26 work work NN 37231 4357 27 of of IN 37231 4357 28 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4357 29 was be VBD 37231 4357 30 written write VBN 37231 4357 31 in in IN 37231 4357 32 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4357 33 or or CC 37231 4357 34 Aramaic Aramaic NNP 37231 4357 35 . . . 37231 4358 1 The the DT 37231 4358 2 first first JJ 37231 4358 3 mention mention NN 37231 4358 4 of of IN 37231 4358 5 any any DT 37231 4358 6 work work NN 37231 4358 7 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4358 8 to to IN 37231 4358 9 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4358 10 occurs occur VBZ 37231 4358 11 in in IN 37231 4358 12 the the DT 37231 4358 13 account account NN 37231 4358 14 communicated communicate VBN 37231 4358 15 by by IN 37231 4358 16 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4358 17 , , , 37231 4358 18 in in IN 37231 4358 19 which which WDT 37231 4358 20 , , , 37231 4358 21 as as IN 37231 4358 22 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4358 23 have have VBP 37231 4358 24 seen see VBN 37231 4358 25 , , , 37231 4358 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4358 27 is be VBZ 37231 4358 28 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 4358 29 said say VBN 37231 4358 30 that that IN 37231 4358 31 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4358 32 wrote write VBD 37231 4358 33 " " `` 37231 4358 34 in in IN 37231 4358 35 the the DT 37231 4358 36 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4358 37 dialect dialect NN 37231 4358 38 . . . 37231 4358 39 " " '' 37231 4359 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 37231 4359 2 , , , 37231 4359 3 the the DT 37231 4359 4 next next JJ 37231 4359 5 writer writer NN 37231 4359 6 who who WP 37231 4359 7 refers refer VBZ 37231 4359 8 to to IN 37231 4359 9 the the DT 37231 4359 10 point point NN 37231 4359 11 , , , 37231 4359 12 says say VBZ 37231 4359 13 : : : 37231 4359 14 " " `` 37231 4359 15 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4359 16 also also RB 37231 4359 17 produced produce VBD 37231 4359 18 a a DT 37231 4359 19 written write VBN 37231 4359 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4359 21 amongst amongst IN 37231 4359 22 the the DT 37231 4359 23 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4359 24 in in IN 37231 4359 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4359 26 own own JJ 37231 4359 27 dialect dialect NN 37231 4359 28 , , , 37231 4359 29 " " '' 37231 4359 30 and and CC 37231 4359 31 that that IN 37231 4359 32 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4359 33 did do VBD 37231 4359 34 not not RB 37231 4359 35 derive derive VB 37231 4359 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4359 37 information information NN 37231 4359 38 solely solely RB 37231 4359 39 from from IN 37231 4359 40 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4359 41 may may MD 37231 4359 42 be be VB 37231 4359 43 inferred infer VBN 37231 4359 44 from from IN 37231 4359 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4359 46 going go VBG 37231 4359 47 on on RP 37231 4359 48 to to TO 37231 4359 49 state state VB 37231 4359 50 the the DT 37231 4359 51 epoch epoch NN 37231 4359 52 of of IN 37231 4359 53 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4359 54 's 's POS 37231 4359 55 writings writing NNS 37231 4359 56 : : : 37231 4359 57 " " `` 37231 4359 58 when when WRB 37231 4359 59 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4359 60 and and CC 37231 4359 61 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4359 62 were be VBD 37231 4359 63 preaching preach VBG 37231 4359 64 and and CC 37231 4359 65 founding found VBG 37231 4359 66 the the DT 37231 4359 67 Church Church NNP 37231 4359 68 in in IN 37231 4359 69 Rome Rome NNP 37231 4359 70 . . . 37231 4360 1 " " `` 37231 4360 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4360 3 2 2 LS 37231 4360 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4360 5 The the DT 37231 4360 6 evidence evidence NN 37231 4360 7 furnished furnish VBN 37231 4360 8 by by IN 37231 4360 9 Pantænus Pantænus NNP 37231 4360 10 is be VBZ 37231 4360 11 certainly certainly RB 37231 4360 12 independent independent JJ 37231 4360 13 of of IN 37231 4360 14 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4360 15 . . . 37231 4361 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4361 2 states state VBZ 37231 4361 3 with with IN 37231 4361 4 regard regard NN 37231 4361 5 to to IN 37231 4361 6 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4361 7 : : : 37231 4361 8 " " `` 37231 4361 9 Of of IN 37231 4361 10 these these DT 37231 4361 11 Pantænus Pantænus NNP 37231 4361 12 is be VBZ 37231 4361 13 said say VBN 37231 4361 14 to to TO 37231 4361 15 have have VB 37231 4361 16 been be VBN 37231 4361 17 one one CD 37231 4361 18 , , , 37231 4361 19 and and CC 37231 4361 20 to to TO 37231 4361 21 have have VB 37231 4361 22 penetrated penetrate VBN 37231 4361 23 as as RB 37231 4361 24 far far RB 37231 4361 25 as as IN 37231 4361 26 India India NNP 37231 4361 27 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4361 28 Southern Southern NNP 37231 4361 29 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 4361 30 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4361 31 , , , 37231 4361 32 where where WRB 37231 4361 33 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4361 34 is be VBZ 37231 4361 35 reported report VBN 37231 4361 36 that that IN 37231 4361 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4361 38 found find VBD 37231 4361 39 the the DT 37231 4361 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4361 41 according accord VBG 37231 4361 42 to to IN 37231 4361 43 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4361 44 , , , 37231 4361 45 which which WDT 37231 4361 46 had have VBD 37231 4361 47 been be VBN 37231 4361 48 delivered deliver VBN 37231 4361 49 before before IN 37231 4361 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4361 51 arrival arrival NN 37231 4361 52 to to IN 37231 4361 53 some some DT 37231 4361 54 who who WP 37231 4361 55 had have VBD 37231 4361 56 the the DT 37231 4361 57 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 4361 58 of of IN 37231 4361 59 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4361 60 , , , 37231 4361 61 to to IN 37231 4361 62 whom whom WP 37231 4361 63 Bartholomew Bartholomew NNP 37231 4361 64 , , , 37231 4361 65 one one CD 37231 4361 66 of of IN 37231 4361 67 the the DT 37231 4361 68 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4361 69 , , , 37231 4361 70 as as IN 37231 4361 71 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4361 72 is be VBZ 37231 4361 73 said say VBN 37231 4361 74 , , , 37231 4361 75 had have VBD 37231 4361 76 preached preach VBN 37231 4361 77 , , , 37231 4361 78 and and CC 37231 4361 79 left leave VBD 37231 4361 80 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4361 81 that that IN 37231 4361 82 writing writing NN 37231 4361 83 of of IN 37231 4361 84 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4361 85 in in IN 37231 4361 86 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4361 87 letters letter NNS 37231 4361 88 " " '' 37231 4361 89 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4361 90 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4361 91 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4361 92 { { -LRB- 37231 4361 93 472 472 CD 37231 4361 94 } } -RRB- 37231 4361 95 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4361 96 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4361 97 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4361 98 . . . 37231 4362 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4362 2 1 1 LS 37231 4362 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4362 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4362 5 gives give VBZ 37231 4362 6 a a DT 37231 4362 7 still still RB 37231 4362 8 more more RBR 37231 4362 9 circumstantial circumstantial JJ 37231 4362 10 account account NN 37231 4362 11 of of IN 37231 4362 12 this this DT 37231 4362 13 . . . 37231 4363 1 " " `` 37231 4363 2 Pantaenus Pantaenus NNP 37231 4363 3 found find VBD 37231 4363 4 that that IN 37231 4363 5 Bartholomew Bartholomew NNP 37231 4363 6 , , , 37231 4363 7 one one CD 37231 4363 8 of of IN 37231 4363 9 the the DT 37231 4363 10 twelve twelve CD 37231 4363 11 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4363 12 , , , 37231 4363 13 had have VBD 37231 4363 14 there there RB 37231 4363 15 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4363 16 in in IN 37231 4363 17 India India NNP 37231 4363 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4363 19 preached preach VBD 37231 4363 20 the the DT 37231 4363 21 advent advent NN 37231 4363 22 of of IN 37231 4363 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4363 24 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4363 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4363 26 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4363 27 according accord VBG 37231 4363 28 to to IN 37231 4363 29 the the DT 37231 4363 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4363 31 of of IN 37231 4363 32 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4363 33 , , , 37231 4363 34 which which WDT 37231 4363 35 was be VBD 37231 4363 36 written write VBN 37231 4363 37 in in IN 37231 4363 38 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4363 39 letters letter NNS 37231 4363 40 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4363 41 quod quod NN 37231 4363 42 Hebraicis Hebraicis NNP 37231 4363 43 Uteris Uteris NNP 37231 4363 44 scriptum scriptum NN 37231 4363 45 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4363 46 , , , 37231 4363 47 and and CC 37231 4363 48 which which WDT 37231 4363 49 on on IN 37231 4363 50 returning return VBG 37231 4363 51 to to IN 37231 4363 52 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 37231 4363 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4363 54 brought bring VBD 37231 4363 55 with with IN 37231 4363 56 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4363 57 . . . 37231 4364 1 " " `` 37231 4364 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4364 3 2 2 LS 37231 4364 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4364 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4364 6 is be VBZ 37231 4364 7 quite quite RB 37231 4364 8 clear clear JJ 37231 4364 9 that that IN 37231 4364 10 this this DT 37231 4364 11 was be VBD 37231 4364 12 no no DT 37231 4364 13 version version NN 37231 4364 14 specially specially RB 37231 4364 15 made make VBN 37231 4364 16 by by IN 37231 4364 17 Bartholomew Bartholomew NNP 37231 4364 18 , , , 37231 4364 19 for for IN 37231 4364 20 had have VBD 37231 4364 21 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4364 22 translated translate VBN 37231 4364 23 the the DT 37231 4364 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4364 25 according accord VBG 37231 4364 26 to to IN 37231 4364 27 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4364 28 from from IN 37231 4364 29 the the DT 37231 4364 30 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4364 31 , , , 37231 4364 32 for for IN 37231 4364 33 the the DT 37231 4364 34 use use NN 37231 4364 35 of of IN 37231 4364 36 persons person NNS 37231 4364 37 in in IN 37231 4364 38 Arabia Arabia NNP 37231 4364 39 , , , 37231 4364 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4364 41 certainly certainly RB 37231 4364 42 would would MD 37231 4364 43 not not RB 37231 4364 44 have have VB 37231 4364 45 done do VBN 37231 4364 46 so so RB 37231 4364 47 into into IN 37231 4364 48 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4364 49 . . . 37231 4365 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4365 2 3 3 LS 37231 4365 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4365 4 Origen Origen NNP 37231 4365 5 , , , 37231 4365 6 according accord VBG 37231 4365 7 to to IN 37231 4365 8 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4365 9 , , , 37231 4365 10 " " '' 37231 4365 11 following follow VBG 37231 4365 12 the the DT 37231 4365 13 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 37231 4365 14 canon canon NN 37231 4365 15 , , , 37231 4365 16 " " '' 37231 4365 17 states state VBZ 37231 4365 18 what what WP 37231 4365 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4365 20 has have VBZ 37231 4365 21 understood understand VBN 37231 4365 22 from from IN 37231 4365 23 tradition tradition NN 37231 4365 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4365 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4365 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4365 27 of of IN 37231 4365 28 the the DT 37231 4365 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4365 30 , , , 37231 4365 31 and and CC 37231 4365 32 says say VBZ 37231 4365 33 : : : 37231 4365 34 " " `` 37231 4365 35 The the DT 37231 4365 36 first first JJ 37231 4365 37 written write VBN 37231 4365 38 was be VBD 37231 4365 39 that that IN 37231 4365 40 according accord VBG 37231 4365 41 to to IN 37231 4365 42 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4365 43 , , , 37231 4365 44 once once RB 37231 4365 45 a a DT 37231 4365 46 publican publican NN 37231 4365 47 , , , 37231 4365 48 but but CC 37231 4365 49 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 4365 50 an an DT 37231 4365 51 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4365 52 of of IN 37231 4365 53 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4365 54 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4365 55 , , , 37231 4365 56 who who WP 37231 4365 57 delivered deliver VBD 37231 4365 58 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4365 59 to to IN 37231 4365 60 the the DT 37231 4365 61 Jewish jewish JJ 37231 4365 62 believers believer NNS 37231 4365 63 , , , 37231 4365 64 composed compose VBN 37231 4365 65 in in IN 37231 4365 66 the the DT 37231 4365 67 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4365 68 language language NN 37231 4365 69 . . . 37231 4366 1 " " `` 37231 4366 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4366 3 4 4 LS 37231 4366 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4366 5 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4366 6 in in IN 37231 4366 7 another another DT 37231 4366 8 place place NN 37231 4366 9 makes make VBZ 37231 4366 10 a a DT 37231 4366 11 similar similar JJ 37231 4366 12 statement statement NN 37231 4366 13 in in IN 37231 4366 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4366 15 own own JJ 37231 4366 16 name name NN 37231 4366 17 : : : 37231 4366 18 " " `` 37231 4366 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4366 20 having have VBG 37231 4366 21 first first RB 37231 4366 22 preached preach VBN 37231 4366 23 to to IN 37231 4366 24 the the DT 37231 4366 25 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4366 26 when when WRB 37231 4366 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4366 28 was be VBD 37231 4366 29 about about JJ 37231 4366 30 to to TO 37231 4366 31 go go VB 37231 4366 32 also also RB 37231 4366 33 to to IN 37231 4366 34 others other NNS 37231 4366 35 , , , 37231 4366 36 delivered deliver VBN 37231 4366 37 to to IN 37231 4366 38 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4366 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4366 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4366 41 written write VBN 37231 4366 42 in in IN 37231 4366 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4366 44 native native JJ 37231 4366 45 language language NN 37231 4366 46 , , , 37231 4366 47 and and CC 37231 4366 48 thus thus RB 37231 4366 49 compensated compensate VBD 37231 4366 50 those those DT 37231 4366 51 from from IN 37231 4366 52 whom whom WP 37231 4366 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4366 54 was be VBD 37231 4366 55 departing depart VBG 37231 4366 56 for for IN 37231 4366 57 the the DT 37231 4366 58 want want NN 37231 4366 59 of of IN 37231 4366 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4366 61 presence presence NN 37231 4366 62 by by IN 37231 4366 63 the the DT 37231 4366 64 writing writing NN 37231 4366 65 . . . 37231 4367 1 " " `` 37231 4367 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4367 3 5 5 LS 37231 4367 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4367 5 Cyril Cyril NNP 37231 4367 6 of of IN 37231 4367 7 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 37231 4367 8 says say VBZ 37231 4367 9 : : : 37231 4367 10 " " `` 37231 4367 11 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4367 12 , , , 37231 4367 13 who who WP 37231 4367 14 wrote write VBD 37231 4367 15 the the DT 37231 4367 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4367 17 , , , 37231 4367 18 wrote write VBD 37231 4367 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4367 20 in in IN 37231 4367 21 the the DT 37231 4367 22 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4367 23 language language NN 37231 4367 24 . . . 37231 4368 1 " " `` 37231 4368 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4368 3 6 6 CD 37231 4368 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4368 5 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 37231 4368 6 , , , 37231 4368 7 referring refer VBG 37231 4368 8 to to IN 37231 4368 9 the the DT 37231 4368 10 fact fact NN 37231 4368 11 that that IN 37231 4368 12 the the DT 37231 4368 13 Nazarenes Nazarenes NNPS 37231 4368 14 called call VBD 37231 4368 15 the the DT 37231 4368 16 only only JJ 37231 4368 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4368 18 which which WDT 37231 4368 19 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4368 20 { { -LRB- 37231 4368 21 473 473 CD 37231 4368 22 } } -RRB- 37231 4368 23 recognized recognize VBD 37231 4368 24 the the DT 37231 4368 25 " " `` 37231 4368 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4368 27 according accord VBG 37231 4368 28 to to IN 37231 4368 29 the the DT 37231 4368 30 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4368 31 , , , 37231 4368 32 " " '' 37231 4368 33 continues continue VBZ 37231 4368 34 : : : 37231 4368 35 " " `` 37231 4368 36 As as IN 37231 4368 37 in in IN 37231 4368 38 very very JJ 37231 4368 39 truth truth NN 37231 4368 40 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4368 41 can can MD 37231 4368 42 affirm affirm VB 37231 4368 43 that that IN 37231 4368 44 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4368 45 alone alone RB 37231 4368 46 in in IN 37231 4368 47 the the DT 37231 4368 48 New New NNP 37231 4368 49 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4368 50 set set VBD 37231 4368 51 forth forth RP 37231 4368 52 and and CC 37231 4368 53 proclaimed proclaim VBD 37231 4368 54 the the DT 37231 4368 55 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4368 56 in in IN 37231 4368 57 the the DT 37231 4368 58 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4368 59 language language NN 37231 4368 60 and and CC 37231 4368 61 in in IN 37231 4368 62 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4368 63 characters;"(1 characters;"(1 NNP 37231 4368 64 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4368 65 and and CC 37231 4368 66 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 4368 67 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4368 68 states state VBZ 37231 4368 69 that that IN 37231 4368 70 " " `` 37231 4368 71 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4368 72 wrote write VBD 37231 4368 73 the the DT 37231 4368 74 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4368 75 in in IN 37231 4368 76 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4368 77 . . . 37231 4369 1 " " `` 37231 4369 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4369 3 2 2 LS 37231 4369 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4369 5 The the DT 37231 4369 6 same same JJ 37231 4369 7 tradition tradition NN 37231 4369 8 is be VBZ 37231 4369 9 repeated repeat VBN 37231 4369 10 by by IN 37231 4369 11 Chrysostom,(3 chrysostom,(3 NN 37231 4369 12 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4369 13 Augustine,(4 augustine,(4 NN 37231 4369 14 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4369 15 and and CC 37231 4369 16 others other NNS 37231 4369 17 . . . 37231 4370 1 Whilst whilst IN 37231 4370 2 the the DT 37231 4370 3 testimony testimony NN 37231 4370 4 of of IN 37231 4370 5 the the DT 37231 4370 6 Fathers father NNS 37231 4370 7 was be VBD 37231 4370 8 thus thus RB 37231 4370 9 unanimous unanimous JJ 37231 4370 10 as as IN 37231 4370 11 to to IN 37231 4370 12 the the DT 37231 4370 13 fact fact NN 37231 4370 14 that that IN 37231 4370 15 the the DT 37231 4370 16 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4370 17 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4370 18 to to IN 37231 4370 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4370 20 was be VBD 37231 4370 21 originally originally RB 37231 4370 22 written write VBN 37231 4370 23 in in IN 37231 4370 24 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4370 25 , , , 37231 4370 26 no no DT 37231 4370 27 question question NN 37231 4370 28 ever ever RB 37231 4370 29 seems seem VBZ 37231 4370 30 to to TO 37231 4370 31 have have VB 37231 4370 32 arisen arise VBN 37231 4370 33 in in IN 37231 4370 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4370 35 minds mind NNS 37231 4370 36 as as IN 37231 4370 37 to to IN 37231 4370 38 the the DT 37231 4370 39 character character NN 37231 4370 40 of of IN 37231 4370 41 the the DT 37231 4370 42 Greek greek JJ 37231 4370 43 version version NN 37231 4370 44 ; ; : 37231 4370 45 much much RB 37231 4370 46 less less RBR 37231 4370 47 was be VBD 37231 4370 48 any any DT 37231 4370 49 examination examination NN 37231 4370 50 made make VBN 37231 4370 51 with with IN 37231 4370 52 the the DT 37231 4370 53 view view NN 37231 4370 54 of of IN 37231 4370 55 testing test VBG 37231 4370 56 the the DT 37231 4370 57 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 4370 58 of of IN 37231 4370 59 the the DT 37231 4370 60 translation translation NN 37231 4370 61 . . . 37231 4371 1 " " `` 37231 4371 2 Such such JJ 37231 4371 3 inquiries inquiry NNS 37231 4371 4 were be VBD 37231 4371 5 not not RB 37231 4371 6 in in IN 37231 4371 7 the the DT 37231 4371 8 spirit spirit NN 37231 4371 9 of of IN 37231 4371 10 Christian Christian NNP 37231 4371 11 learned learn VBN 37231 4371 12 men man NNS 37231 4371 13 generally generally RB 37231 4371 14 of of IN 37231 4371 15 that that DT 37231 4371 16 time,"(5 time,"(5 . 37231 4371 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4371 18 as as IN 37231 4371 19 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 37231 4371 20 remarks remark VBZ 37231 4371 21 in in IN 37231 4371 22 connection connection NN 37231 4371 23 with with IN 37231 4371 24 the the DT 37231 4371 25 belief belief NN 37231 4371 26 current current NN 37231 4371 27 in in IN 37231 4371 28 the the DT 37231 4371 29 early early JJ 37231 4371 30 Church Church NNP 37231 4371 31 , , , 37231 4371 32 and and CC 37231 4371 33 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 4371 34 shared share VBN 37231 4371 35 by by IN 37231 4371 36 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4371 37 , , , 37231 4371 38 that that IN 37231 4371 39 the the DT 37231 4371 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4371 41 according accord VBG 37231 4371 42 to to IN 37231 4371 43 the the DT 37231 4371 44 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4371 45 was be VBD 37231 4371 46 the the DT 37231 4371 47 original original NN 37231 4371 48 of of IN 37231 4371 49 the the DT 37231 4371 50 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4371 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4371 52 according accord VBG 37231 4371 53 to to IN 37231 4371 54 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4371 55 . . . 37231 4372 1 The the DT 37231 4372 2 first first JJ 37231 4372 3 who who WP 37231 4372 4 directly directly RB 37231 4372 5 refers refer VBZ 37231 4372 6 to to IN 37231 4372 7 the the DT 37231 4372 8 point point NN 37231 4372 9 , , , 37231 4372 10 frankly frankly RB 37231 4372 11 confessing confess VBG 37231 4372 12 the the DT 37231 4372 13 total total JJ 37231 4372 14 ignorance ignorance NN 37231 4372 15 which which WDT 37231 4372 16 generally generally RB 37231 4372 17 prevailed prevail VBD 37231 4372 18 , , , 37231 4372 19 was be VBD 37231 4372 20 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4372 21 . . . 37231 4373 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4373 2 states state VBZ 37231 4373 3 : : : 37231 4373 4 " " `` 37231 4373 5 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4373 6 , , , 37231 4373 7 who who WP 37231 4373 8 was be VBD 37231 4373 9 also also RB 37231 4373 10 called call VBN 37231 4373 11 Levi Levi NNP 37231 4373 12 , , , 37231 4373 13 who who WP 37231 4373 14 from from IN 37231 4373 15 a a DT 37231 4373 16 publican publican NN 37231 4373 17 became become VBD 37231 4373 18 an an DT 37231 4373 19 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4373 20 , , , 37231 4373 21 was be VBD 37231 4373 22 the the DT 37231 4373 23 first first JJ 37231 4373 24 who who WP 37231 4373 25 wrote write VBD 37231 4373 26 a a DT 37231 4373 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4373 28 of of IN 37231 4373 29 Christ Christ NNP 37231 4373 30 in in IN 37231 4373 31 Judæa Judæa NNP 37231 4373 32 in in IN 37231 4373 33 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4373 34 language language NN 37231 4373 35 and and CC 37231 4373 36 letters letter NNS 37231 4373 37 , , , 37231 4373 38 on on IN 37231 4373 39 account account NN 37231 4373 40 of of IN 37231 4373 41 those those DT 37231 4373 42 from from IN 37231 4373 43 amongst amongst IN 37231 4373 44 the the DT 37231 4373 45 circumcision circumcision NN 37231 4373 46 who who WP 37231 4373 47 had have VBD 37231 4373 48 believed believe VBN 37231 4373 49 ; ; : 37231 4373 50 but but CC 37231 4373 51 who who WP 37231 4373 52 afterwards afterwards RB 37231 4373 53 translated translate VBD 37231 4373 54 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4373 55 into into IN 37231 4373 56 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4373 57 is be VBZ 37231 4373 58 not not RB 37231 4373 59 { { -LRB- 37231 4373 60 474 474 CD 37231 4373 61 } } -RRB- 37231 4373 62 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37231 4373 63 certain certain JJ 37231 4373 64 . . . 37231 4374 1 " " `` 37231 4374 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4374 3 1 1 LS 37231 4374 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4374 5 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4374 6 was be VBD 37231 4374 7 only only RB 37231 4374 8 at at IN 37231 4374 9 a a DT 37231 4374 10 much much RB 37231 4374 11 later later JJ 37231 4374 12 period period NN 37231 4374 13 , , , 37231 4374 14 when when WRB 37231 4374 15 doubt doubt NN 37231 4374 16 began begin VBD 37231 4374 17 to to TO 37231 4374 18 arise arise VB 37231 4374 19 , , , 37231 4374 20 that that IN 37231 4374 21 the the DT 37231 4374 22 translation translation NN 37231 4374 23 was be VBD 37231 4374 24 wildly wildly RB 37231 4374 25 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4374 26 to to IN 37231 4374 27 the the DT 37231 4374 28 Apostles Apostles NNP 37231 4374 29 John John NNP 37231 4374 30 , , , 37231 4374 31 James James NNP 37231 4374 32 , , , 37231 4374 33 and and CC 37231 4374 34 others other NNS 37231 4374 35 . . . 37231 4375 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4375 2 3 3 LS 37231 4375 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4375 4 The the DT 37231 4375 5 expression expression NN 37231 4375 6 in in IN 37231 4375 7 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4375 8 that that IN 37231 4375 9 " " `` 37231 4375 10 everyone everyone NN 37231 4375 11 interpreted interpret VBD 37231 4375 12 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4375 13 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4375 14 the the DT 37231 4375 15 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4375 16 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4375 17 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4375 18 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4375 19 as as IN 37231 4375 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4375 21 was be VBD 37231 4375 22 able able JJ 37231 4375 23 " " `` 37231 4375 24 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4375 25 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4375 26 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4375 27 has have VBZ 37231 4375 28 been be VBN 37231 4375 29 variously variously RB 37231 4375 30 interpreted interpret VBN 37231 4375 31 by by IN 37231 4375 32 different different JJ 37231 4375 33 critics critic NNS 37231 4375 34 , , , 37231 4375 35 like like IN 37231 4375 36 the the DT 37231 4375 37 rest rest NN 37231 4375 38 of of IN 37231 4375 39 the the DT 37231 4375 40 account account NN 37231 4375 41 . . . 37231 4376 1 Schleier schlei JJR 37231 4376 2 - - : 37231 4376 3 macher macher RB 37231 4376 4 explained explain VBD 37231 4376 5 the the DT 37231 4376 6 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4376 7 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4376 8 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4376 9 as as IN 37231 4376 10 translation translation NN 37231 4376 11 by by IN 37231 4376 12 enlargement enlargement NN 37231 4376 13 : : : 37231 4376 14 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4376 15 merely merely RB 37231 4376 16 collected collect VBD 37231 4376 17 the the DT 37231 4376 18 Xoyta Xoyta NNP 37231 4376 19 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4376 20 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4376 21 --Greek-- --Greek-- NFP 37231 4376 22 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4376 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4376 24 , , , 37231 4376 25 and and CC 37231 4376 26 everyone everyone NN 37231 4376 27 added add VBD 37231 4376 28 the the DT 37231 4376 29 explanatory explanatory JJ 37231 4376 30 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 4376 31 of of IN 37231 4376 32 time time NN 37231 4376 33 and and CC 37231 4376 34 occasion occasion NN 37231 4376 35 as as RB 37231 4376 36 best best RB 37231 4376 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4376 38 could could MD 37231 4376 39 . . . 37231 4377 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4377 2 3 3 LS 37231 4377 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4377 4 This this DT 37231 4377 5 view view NN 37231 4377 6 , , , 37231 4377 7 however however RB 37231 4377 8 , , , 37231 4377 9 has have VBZ 37231 4377 10 not not RB 37231 4377 11 been be VBN 37231 4377 12 largely largely RB 37231 4377 13 adopted adopt VBN 37231 4377 14 . . . 37231 4378 1 Others other NNS 37231 4378 2 consider consider VBP 37231 4378 3 that that IN 37231 4378 4 the the DT 37231 4378 5 expression expression NN 37231 4378 6 refers refer VBZ 37231 4378 7 to to IN 37231 4378 8 the the DT 37231 4378 9 interpretation interpretation NN 37231 4378 10 which which WDT 37231 4378 11 was be VBD 37231 4378 12 given give VBN 37231 4378 13 on on IN 37231 4378 14 reading read VBG 37231 4378 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4378 16 at at IN 37231 4378 17 the the DT 37231 4378 18 public public JJ 37231 4378 19 meetings meeting NNS 37231 4378 20 of of IN 37231 4378 21 Christians Christians NNPS 37231 4378 22 for for IN 37231 4378 23 worship,(4 worship,(4 NN 37231 4378 24 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4378 25 but but CC 37231 4378 26 there there EX 37231 4378 27 can can MD 37231 4378 28 be be VB 37231 4378 29 no no DT 37231 4378 30 doubt doubt NN 37231 4378 31 that that IN 37231 4378 32 , , , 37231 4378 33 coming come VBG 37231 4378 34 after after IN 37231 4378 35 the the DT 37231 4378 36 statement statement NN 37231 4378 37 that that IN 37231 4378 38 the the DT 37231 4378 39 work work NN 37231 4378 40 was be VBD 37231 4378 41 written write VBN 37231 4378 42 in in IN 37231 4378 43 the the DT 37231 4378 44 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4378 45 dialect dialect NN 37231 4378 46 , , , 37231 4378 47 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4378 48 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4378 49 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4378 50 can can MD 37231 4378 51 only only RB 37231 4378 52 mean mean VB 37231 4378 53 simple simple JJ 37231 4378 54 translation translation NN 37231 4378 55 . . . 37231 4379 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4379 2 5 5 LS 37231 4379 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4379 4 Some some DT 37231 4379 5 maintain maintain VBP 37231 4379 6 that that IN 37231 4379 7 the the DT 37231 4379 8 passage passage NN 37231 4379 9 infers infer VBZ 37231 4379 10 the the DT 37231 4379 11 existence existence NN 37231 4379 12 of of IN 37231 4379 13 many many JJ 37231 4379 14 written write VBN 37231 4379 15 translations translation NNS 37231 4379 16 , , , 37231 4379 17 amongst amongst IN 37231 4379 18 which which WDT 37231 4379 19 very very RB 37231 4379 20 probably probably RB 37231 4379 21 was be VBD 37231 4379 22 ours;(6 ours;(6 NNP 37231 4379 23 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4379 24 whilst whilst IN 37231 4379 25 others other NNS 37231 4379 26 affirm affirm VBP 37231 4379 27 that that IN 37231 4379 28 the the DT 37231 4379 29 phrase phrase NN 37231 4379 30 merely merely RB 37231 4379 31 signifies signify VBZ 37231 4379 32 that that IN 37231 4379 33 as as IN 37231 4379 34 there there EX 37231 4379 35 was be VBD 37231 4379 36 no no DT 37231 4379 37 recognized recognize VBN 37231 4379 38 { { -LRB- 37231 4379 39 475 475 CD 37231 4379 40 } } -RRB- 37231 4379 41 translation translation NN 37231 4379 42 , , , 37231 4379 43 each each DT 37231 4379 44 one one NN 37231 4379 45 who who WP 37231 4379 46 had have VBD 37231 4379 47 but but CC 37231 4379 48 an an DT 37231 4379 49 imperfect imperfect JJ 37231 4379 50 knowledge knowledge NN 37231 4379 51 of of IN 37231 4379 52 the the DT 37231 4379 53 language language NN 37231 4379 54 , , , 37231 4379 55 yet yet RB 37231 4379 56 wished wish VBD 37231 4379 57 to to TO 37231 4379 58 read read VB 37231 4379 59 the the DT 37231 4379 60 work work NN 37231 4379 61 , , , 37231 4379 62 translated translate VBD 37231 4379 63 the the DT 37231 4379 64 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4379 65 for for IN 37231 4379 66 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4379 67 orally orally RB 37231 4379 68 as as RB 37231 4379 69 best best RB 37231 4379 70 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4379 71 could could MD 37231 4379 72 . . . 37231 4380 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4380 2 1 1 LS 37231 4380 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4380 4 Some some DT 37231 4380 5 consider consider VBP 37231 4380 6 that that IN 37231 4380 7 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4380 8 or or CC 37231 4380 9 the the DT 37231 4380 10 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 37231 4380 11 use use VBP 37231 4380 12 the the DT 37231 4380 13 verb verb NN 37231 4380 14 in in IN 37231 4380 15 the the DT 37231 4380 16 past past JJ 37231 4380 17 tense tense JJ 37231 4380 18 , , , 37231 4380 19 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4380 20 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4380 21 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4380 22 , , , 37231 4380 23 as as IN 37231 4380 24 contrasting contrast VBG 37231 4380 25 the the DT 37231 4380 26 time time NN 37231 4380 27 when when WRB 37231 4380 28 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4380 29 was be VBD 37231 4380 30 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4380 31 for for IN 37231 4380 32 each each DT 37231 4380 33 to to TO 37231 4380 34 interpret interpret VB 37231 4380 35 as as RB 37231 4380 36 best best RB 37231 4380 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4380 38 could could MD 37231 4380 39 with with IN 37231 4380 40 the the DT 37231 4380 41 period period NN 37231 4380 42 when when WRB 37231 4380 43 , , , 37231 4380 44 from from IN 37231 4380 45 the the DT 37231 4380 46 existence existence NN 37231 4380 47 of of IN 37231 4380 48 a a DT 37231 4380 49 recognized recognize VBN 37231 4380 50 translation translation NN 37231 4380 51 , , , 37231 4380 52 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4380 53 was be VBD 37231 4380 54 no no DT 37231 4380 55 longer long RBR 37231 4380 56 necessary necessary JJ 37231 4380 57 for for IN 37231 4380 58 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4380 59 to to TO 37231 4380 60 do do VB 37231 4380 61 so;(2 so;(2 . 37231 4380 62 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4380 63 whilst whilst IN 37231 4380 64 others other NNS 37231 4380 65 deny deny VBP 37231 4380 66 that that IN 37231 4380 67 any any DT 37231 4380 68 written write VBN 37231 4380 69 translation translation NN 37231 4380 70 of of IN 37231 4380 71 an an DT 37231 4380 72 authentic authentic JJ 37231 4380 73 character character NN 37231 4380 74 was be VBD 37231 4380 75 known know VBN 37231 4380 76 to to IN 37231 4380 77 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4380 78 at at RB 37231 4380 79 all all RB 37231 4380 80 . . . 37231 4381 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4381 2 3 3 LS 37231 4381 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4381 4 Now now RB 37231 4381 5 the the DT 37231 4381 6 words word NNS 37231 4381 7 in in IN 37231 4381 8 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4381 9 are be VBP 37231 4381 10 merely merely RB 37231 4381 11 : : : 37231 4381 12 " " `` 37231 4381 13 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4381 14 composed compose VBD 37231 4381 15 the the DT 37231 4381 16 Xoyta Xoyta NNP 37231 4381 17 in in IN 37231 4381 18 the the DT 37231 4381 19 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4381 20 dialect,(4 dialect,(4 NN 37231 4381 21 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4381 22 and and CC 37231 4381 23 everyone everyone NN 37231 4381 24 interpreted interpret VBD 37231 4381 25 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4381 26 as as IN 37231 4381 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4381 28 was be VBD 37231 4381 29 able able JJ 37231 4381 30 . . . 37231 4381 31 " " '' 37231 4382 1 The the DT 37231 4382 2 statement statement NN 37231 4382 3 is be VBZ 37231 4382 4 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 4382 5 simple simple JJ 37231 4382 6 and and CC 37231 4382 7 direct direct JJ 37231 4382 8 , , , 37231 4382 9 and and CC 37231 4382 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4382 11 is be VBZ 37231 4382 12 at at IN 37231 4382 13 least least JJS 37231 4382 14 quite quite RB 37231 4382 15 clear clear JJ 37231 4382 16 that that IN 37231 4382 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4382 18 conveys convey VBZ 37231 4382 19 the the DT 37231 4382 20 fact fact NN 37231 4382 21 that that IN 37231 4382 22 when when WRB 37231 4382 23 the the DT 37231 4382 24 work work NN 37231 4382 25 was be VBD 37231 4382 26 composed compose VBN 37231 4382 27 , , , 37231 4382 28 translation translation NN 37231 4382 29 was be VBD 37231 4382 30 requisite requisite JJ 37231 4382 31 , , , 37231 4382 32 and and CC 37231 4382 33 as as IN 37231 4382 34 each each DT 37231 4382 35 one one CD 37231 4382 36 translated translate VBN 37231 4382 37 " " '' 37231 4382 38 as as IN 37231 4382 39 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4382 40 was be VBD 37231 4382 41 able able JJ 37231 4382 42 , , , 37231 4382 43 " " '' 37231 4382 44 that that IN 37231 4382 45 no no DT 37231 4382 46 recognized recognize VBN 37231 4382 47 translation translation NN 37231 4382 48 existed exist VBD 37231 4382 49 to to TO 37231 4382 50 which which WDT 37231 4382 51 all all DT 37231 4382 52 might may MD 37231 4382 53 have have VB 37231 4382 54 recourse recourse VBN 37231 4382 55 . . . 37231 4383 1 There there EX 37231 4383 2 is be VBZ 37231 4383 3 no no DT 37231 4383 4 contrast contrast NN 37231 4383 5 either either CC 37231 4383 6 necessarily necessarily RB 37231 4383 7 or or CC 37231 4383 8 , , , 37231 4383 9 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4383 10 think think VBP 37231 4383 11 , , , 37231 4383 12 probably probably RB 37231 4383 13 implied imply VBN 37231 4383 14 in in IN 37231 4383 15 the the DT 37231 4383 16 use use NN 37231 4383 17 of of IN 37231 4383 18 the the DT 37231 4383 19 past past JJ 37231 4383 20 tense tense NN 37231 4383 21 . . . 37231 4384 1 The the DT 37231 4384 2 composition composition NN 37231 4384 3 of of IN 37231 4384 4 the the DT 37231 4384 5 Xoyta Xoyta NNP 37231 4384 6 being be VBG 37231 4384 7 of of RB 37231 4384 8 course course NN 37231 4384 9 referred refer VBN 37231 4384 10 to to IN 37231 4384 11 in in IN 37231 4384 12 the the DT 37231 4384 13 4 4 CD 37231 4384 14 In in IN 37231 4384 15 connection connection NN 37231 4384 16 with with IN 37231 4384 17 this this DT 37231 4384 18 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4384 19 may may MD 37231 4384 20 be be VB 37231 4384 21 of of IN 37231 4384 22 interest interest NN 37231 4384 23 to to TO 37231 4384 24 remember remember VB 37231 4384 25 that that IN 37231 4384 26 , , , 37231 4384 27 in in IN 37231 4384 28 the the DT 37231 4384 29 account account NN 37231 4384 30 of of IN 37231 4384 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4384 32 conversion conversion NN 37231 4384 33 and and CC 37231 4384 34 the the DT 37231 4384 35 vision vision NN 37231 4384 36 which which WDT 37231 4384 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4384 38 saw see VBD 37231 4384 39 on on IN 37231 4384 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4384 41 way way NN 37231 4384 42 to to IN 37231 4384 43 Damascus Damascus NNP 37231 4384 44 which which WDT 37231 4384 45 Paul Paul NNP 37231 4384 46 gives give VBZ 37231 4384 47 to to IN 37231 4384 48 King King NNP 37231 4384 49 Agrippa Agrippa NNP 37231 4384 50 in in IN 37231 4384 51 the the DT 37231 4384 52 Acts act NNS 37231 4384 53 of of IN 37231 4384 54 the the DT 37231 4384 55 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4384 56 , , , 37231 4384 57 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4384 58 states state VBZ 37231 4384 59 that that IN 37231 4384 60 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4384 61 spoke speak VBD 37231 4384 62 to to IN 37231 4384 63 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4384 64 " " `` 37231 4384 65 in in IN 37231 4384 66 the the DT 37231 4384 67 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4384 68 dialect dialect NN 37231 4384 69 " " '' 37231 4384 70 [ [ -LRB- 37231 4384 71 --Greek-- --Greek-- , 37231 4384 72 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4384 73 , , , 37231 4384 74 Acts Acts NNP 37231 4384 75 xxvi xxvi NNP 37231 4384 76 . . . 37231 4385 1 14 14 CD 37231 4385 2 . . . 37231 4386 1 { { -LRB- 37231 4386 2 476 476 CD 37231 4386 3 } } -RRB- 37231 4386 4 past past JJ 37231 4386 5 tense tense JJ 37231 4386 6 , , , 37231 4386 7 the the DT 37231 4386 8 same same JJ 37231 4386 9 tense tense NN 37231 4386 10 is be VBZ 37231 4386 11 simply simply RB 37231 4386 12 continued continue VBN 37231 4386 13 in in IN 37231 4386 14 completing complete VBG 37231 4386 15 the the DT 37231 4386 16 sentence sentence NN 37231 4386 17 . . . 37231 4387 1 The the DT 37231 4387 2 purpose purpose NN 37231 4387 3 is be VBZ 37231 4387 4 obviously obviously RB 37231 4387 5 to to TO 37231 4387 6 convey convey VB 37231 4387 7 the the DT 37231 4387 8 fact fact NN 37231 4387 9 that that IN 37231 4387 10 the the DT 37231 4387 11 work work NN 37231 4387 12 was be VBD 37231 4387 13 composed compose VBN 37231 4387 14 in in IN 37231 4387 15 the the DT 37231 4387 16 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4387 17 language language NN 37231 4387 18 . . . 37231 4388 1 But but CC 37231 4388 2 even even RB 37231 4388 3 if if IN 37231 4388 4 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4388 5 be be VB 37231 4388 6 taken take VBN 37231 4388 7 that that IN 37231 4388 8 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4388 9 intentionally intentionally RB 37231 4388 10 uses use VBZ 37231 4388 11 the the DT 37231 4388 12 past past JJ 37231 4388 13 tense tense NN 37231 4388 14 in in IN 37231 4388 15 reference reference NN 37231 4388 16 to to IN 37231 4388 17 the the DT 37231 4388 18 time time NN 37231 4388 19 when when WRB 37231 4388 20 translations translation NNS 37231 4388 21 did do VBD 37231 4388 22 not not RB 37231 4388 23 exist exist VB 37231 4388 24 , , , 37231 4388 25 nothing nothing NN 37231 4388 26 is be VBZ 37231 4388 27 gained gain VBN 37231 4388 28 , , , 37231 4388 29 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4388 30 may may MD 37231 4388 31 have have VB 37231 4388 32 known know VBN 37231 4388 33 of of IN 37231 4388 34 many many JJ 37231 4388 35 translations translation NNS 37231 4388 36 , , , 37231 4388 37 but but CC 37231 4388 38 there there EX 37231 4388 39 is be VBZ 37231 4388 40 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 4388 41 not not RB 37231 4388 42 a a DT 37231 4388 43 syllable syllable NN 37231 4388 44 which which WDT 37231 4388 45 warrants warrant VBZ 37231 4388 46 the the DT 37231 4388 47 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4388 48 that that IN 37231 4388 49 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4388 50 was be VBD 37231 4388 51 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4388 52 with with IN 37231 4388 53 an an DT 37231 4388 54 authentic authentic JJ 37231 4388 55 Greek greek JJ 37231 4388 56 version version NN 37231 4388 57 , , , 37231 4388 58 although although IN 37231 4388 59 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4388 60 is be VBZ 37231 4388 61 possible possible JJ 37231 4388 62 that that IN 37231 4388 63 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4388 64 may may MD 37231 4388 65 have have VB 37231 4388 66 known know VBN 37231 4388 67 of of IN 37231 4388 68 the the DT 37231 4388 69 existence existence NN 37231 4388 70 of of IN 37231 4388 71 some some DT 37231 4388 72 Greek greek JJ 37231 4388 73 translations translation NNS 37231 4388 74 of of IN 37231 4388 75 no no DT 37231 4388 76 authority authority NN 37231 4388 77 . . . 37231 4389 1 The the DT 37231 4389 2 words word NNS 37231 4389 3 used use VBN 37231 4389 4 , , , 37231 4389 5 however however RB 37231 4389 6 , , , 37231 4389 7 imply imply VB 37231 4389 8 that that IN 37231 4389 9 , , , 37231 4389 10 if if IN 37231 4389 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4389 12 did do VBD 37231 4389 13 , , , 37231 4389 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4389 15 had have VBD 37231 4389 16 no no DT 37231 4389 17 respect respect NN 37231 4389 18 for for IN 37231 4389 19 any any DT 37231 4389 20 of of IN 37231 4389 21 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4389 22 . . . 37231 4390 1 Thus thus RB 37231 4390 2 the the DT 37231 4390 3 account account NN 37231 4390 4 of of IN 37231 4390 5 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4390 6 , , , 37231 4390 7 supported support VBN 37231 4390 8 by by IN 37231 4390 9 the the DT 37231 4390 10 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 4390 11 unanimous unanimous JJ 37231 4390 12 testimony testimony NN 37231 4390 13 of of IN 37231 4390 14 the the DT 37231 4390 15 Fathers Fathers NNP 37231 4390 16 , , , 37231 4390 17 declares declare VBZ 37231 4390 18 that that IN 37231 4390 19 the the DT 37231 4390 20 work work NN 37231 4390 21 composed compose VBN 37231 4390 22 by by IN 37231 4390 23 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4390 24 was be VBD 37231 4390 25 written write VBN 37231 4390 26 in in IN 37231 4390 27 the the DT 37231 4390 28 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4390 29 or or CC 37231 4390 30 Aramaic Aramaic NNP 37231 4390 31 dialect dialect NN 37231 4390 32 . . . 37231 4391 1 The the DT 37231 4391 2 only only JJ 37231 4391 3 evidence evidence NN 37231 4391 4 which which WDT 37231 4391 5 asserts assert VBZ 37231 4391 6 that that IN 37231 4391 7 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4391 8 wrote write VBD 37231 4391 9 any any DT 37231 4391 10 work work NN 37231 4391 11 at at RB 37231 4391 12 all all RB 37231 4391 13 , , , 37231 4391 14 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 4391 15 asserts assert VBZ 37231 4391 16 that that IN 37231 4391 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4391 18 wrote write VBD 37231 4391 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4391 20 in in IN 37231 4391 21 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4391 22 . . . 37231 4392 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4392 2 is be VBZ 37231 4392 3 quite quite RB 37231 4392 4 impossible impossible JJ 37231 4392 5 to to TO 37231 4392 6 separate separate VB 37231 4392 7 the the DT 37231 4392 8 statement statement NN 37231 4392 9 of of IN 37231 4392 10 the the DT 37231 4392 11 authorship authorship NN 37231 4392 12 from from IN 37231 4392 13 the the DT 37231 4392 14 language language NN 37231 4392 15 . . . 37231 4393 1 The the DT 37231 4393 2 two two CD 37231 4393 3 points point NNS 37231 4393 4 are be VBP 37231 4393 5 so so RB 37231 4393 6 indissolubly indissolubly RB 37231 4393 7 united united JJ 37231 4393 8 that that IN 37231 4393 9 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4393 10 stand stand VBP 37231 4393 11 or or CC 37231 4393 12 fall fall VBP 37231 4393 13 together together RB 37231 4393 14 . . . 37231 4394 1 If if IN 37231 4394 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4394 3 be be VB 37231 4394 4 denied deny VBN 37231 4394 5 that that IN 37231 4394 6 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4394 7 wrote write VBD 37231 4394 8 in in IN 37231 4394 9 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4394 10 , , , 37231 4394 11 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4394 12 can can MD 37231 4394 13 not not RB 37231 4394 14 be be VB 37231 4394 15 asserted assert VBN 37231 4394 16 that that IN 37231 4394 17 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4394 18 wrote write VBD 37231 4394 19 at at RB 37231 4394 20 all all RB 37231 4394 21 . . . 37231 4395 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4395 2 is be VBZ 37231 4395 3 therefore therefore RB 37231 4395 4 perfectly perfectly RB 37231 4395 5 certain certain JJ 37231 4395 6 from from IN 37231 4395 7 this this DT 37231 4395 8 testimony testimony NN 37231 4395 9 that that WDT 37231 4395 10 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4395 11 can can MD 37231 4395 12 not not RB 37231 4395 13 be be VB 37231 4395 14 declared declare VBN 37231 4395 15 the the DT 37231 4395 16 direct direct JJ 37231 4395 17 author author NN 37231 4395 18 of of IN 37231 4395 19 the the DT 37231 4395 20 Greek greek JJ 37231 4395 21 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4395 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4395 23 bearing bear VBG 37231 4395 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4395 25 name name NN 37231 4395 26 . . . 37231 4396 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4396 2 1 1 LS 37231 4396 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4396 4 At at IN 37231 4396 5 the the DT 37231 4396 6 very very RB 37231 4396 7 best good JJS 37231 4396 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4396 9 can can MD 37231 4396 10 only only RB 37231 4396 11 be be VB 37231 4396 12 a a DT 37231 4396 13 translation translation NN 37231 4396 14 , , , 37231 4396 15 by by IN 37231 4396 16 an an DT 37231 4396 17 unknown unknown JJ 37231 4396 18 hand hand NN 37231 4396 19 , , , 37231 4396 20 of of IN 37231 4396 21 a a DT 37231 4396 22 work work NN 37231 4396 23 the the DT 37231 4396 24 original original NN 37231 4396 25 of of IN 37231 4396 26 which which WDT 37231 4396 27 was be VBD 37231 4396 28 early early RB 37231 4396 29 lost lose VBN 37231 4396 30 . . . 37231 4397 1 None none NN 37231 4397 2 of of IN 37231 4397 3 the the DT 37231 4397 4 earlier early JJR 37231 4397 5 Fathers father NNS 37231 4397 6 ever ever RB 37231 4397 7 ventured venture VBD 37231 4397 8 a a DT 37231 4397 9 conjecture conjecture NN 37231 4397 10 as as IN 37231 4397 11 to to IN 37231 4397 12 how how WRB 37231 4397 13 , , , 37231 4397 14 when when WRB 37231 4397 15 , , , 37231 4397 16 or or CC 37231 4397 17 by by IN 37231 4397 18 whom whom WP 37231 4397 19 the the DT 37231 4397 20 translation translation NN 37231 4397 21 was be VBD 37231 4397 22 effected effect VBN 37231 4397 23 . . . 37231 4398 1 Jerome Jerome NNP 37231 4398 2 explicitly explicitly RB 37231 4398 3 states state VBZ 37231 4398 4 that that IN 37231 4398 5 the the DT 37231 4398 6 translator translator NN 37231 4398 7 of of IN 37231 4398 8 the the DT 37231 4398 9 work work NN 37231 4398 10 was be VBD 37231 4398 11 unknown unknown JJ 37231 4398 12 . . . 37231 4399 1 The the DT 37231 4399 2 { { -LRB- 37231 4399 3 477 477 CD 37231 4399 4 } } -RRB- 37231 4399 5 deduction deduction NN 37231 4399 6 is be VBZ 37231 4399 7 clear clear JJ 37231 4399 8 : : : 37231 4399 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4399 10 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4399 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4399 12 , , , 37231 4399 13 in in IN 37231 4399 14 so so RB 37231 4399 15 far far RB 37231 4399 16 as as IN 37231 4399 17 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4399 18 is be VBZ 37231 4399 19 associated associate VBN 37231 4399 20 with with IN 37231 4399 21 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4399 22 at at RB 37231 4399 23 all all RB 37231 4399 24 , , , 37231 4399 25 can can MD 37231 4399 26 not not RB 37231 4399 27 at at IN 37231 4399 28 the the DT 37231 4399 29 utmost utmost NN 37231 4399 30 be be VB 37231 4399 31 more more JJR 37231 4399 32 than than IN 37231 4399 33 a a DT 37231 4399 34 translation translation NN 37231 4399 35 , , , 37231 4399 36 but but CC 37231 4399 37 as as IN 37231 4399 38 the the DT 37231 4399 39 work work NN 37231 4399 40 of of IN 37231 4399 41 an an DT 37231 4399 42 unknown unknown JJ 37231 4399 43 translator translator NN 37231 4399 44 , , , 37231 4399 45 there there EX 37231 4399 46 can can MD 37231 4399 47 not not RB 37231 4399 48 , , , 37231 4399 49 in in IN 37231 4399 50 the the DT 37231 4399 51 absence absence NN 37231 4399 52 of of IN 37231 4399 53 the the DT 37231 4399 54 original original JJ 37231 4399 55 , , , 37231 4399 56 or or CC 37231 4399 57 of of IN 37231 4399 58 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 37231 4399 59 testimony testimony NN 37231 4399 60 of of IN 37231 4399 61 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4399 62 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 4399 63 , , , 37231 4399 64 bo bo NNP 37231 4399 65 any any DT 37231 4399 66 assurance assurance NN 37231 4399 67 that that IN 37231 4399 68 the the DT 37231 4399 69 translation translation NN 37231 4399 70 faithfully faithfully RB 37231 4399 71 renders render VBZ 37231 4399 72 the the DT 37231 4399 73 work work NN 37231 4399 74 of of IN 37231 4399 75 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4399 76 , , , 37231 4399 77 or or CC 37231 4399 78 accurately accurately RB 37231 4399 79 conveys convey VBZ 37231 4399 80 the the DT 37231 4399 81 sense sense NN 37231 4399 82 of of IN 37231 4399 83 the the DT 37231 4399 84 original original NN 37231 4399 85 . . . 37231 4400 1 All all PDT 37231 4400 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4400 3 Apostolical Apostolical NNP 37231 4400 4 authority authority NN 37231 4400 5 is be VBZ 37231 4400 6 gone go VBN 37231 4400 7 . . . 37231 4401 1 Even even RB 37231 4401 2 Michaelis Michaelis NNP 37231 4401 3 long long RB 37231 4401 4 ago ago RB 37231 4401 5 recognized recognize VBD 37231 4401 6 this this DT 37231 4401 7 : : : 37231 4401 8 " " `` 37231 4401 9 If if IN 37231 4401 10 the the DT 37231 4401 11 original original JJ 37231 4401 12 text text NN 37231 4401 13 of of IN 37231 4401 14 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4401 15 be be VB 37231 4401 16 lost lose VBN 37231 4401 17 , , , 37231 4401 18 and and CC 37231 4401 19 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4401 20 have have VBP 37231 4401 21 nothing nothing NN 37231 4401 22 but but IN 37231 4401 23 a a DT 37231 4401 24 Greek greek JJ 37231 4401 25 translation translation NN 37231 4401 26 : : : 37231 4401 27 then then RB 37231 4401 28 , , , 37231 4401 29 frankly frankly RB 37231 4401 30 , , , 37231 4401 31 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4401 32 can can MD 37231 4401 33 not not RB 37231 4401 34 ascribe ascribe VB 37231 4401 35 any any DT 37231 4401 36 divine divine JJ 37231 4401 37 inspiration inspiration NN 37231 4401 38 to to IN 37231 4401 39 the the DT 37231 4401 40 words word NNS 37231 4401 41 : : : 37231 4401 42 yea yea NNP 37231 4401 43 , , , 37231 4401 44 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4401 45 is be VBZ 37231 4401 46 possible possible JJ 37231 4401 47 that that IN 37231 4401 48 in in IN 37231 4401 49 various various JJ 37231 4401 50 places place NNS 37231 4401 51 the the DT 37231 4401 52 true true JJ 37231 4401 53 meaning meaning NN 37231 4401 54 of of IN 37231 4401 55 the the DT 37231 4401 56 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4401 57 has have VBZ 37231 4401 58 been be VBN 37231 4401 59 missed miss VBN 37231 4401 60 by by IN 37231 4401 61 the the DT 37231 4401 62 translator translator NN 37231 4401 63 . . . 37231 4402 1 " " `` 37231 4402 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4402 3 1 1 LS 37231 4402 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4402 5 This this DT 37231 4402 6 was be VBD 37231 4402 7 felt feel VBN 37231 4402 8 and and CC 37231 4402 9 argued argue VBN 37231 4402 10 by by IN 37231 4402 11 the the DT 37231 4402 12 Manicheans Manicheans NNPS 37231 4402 13 in in IN 37231 4402 14 the the DT 37231 4402 15 fourth fourth JJ 37231 4402 16 century,(2 century,(2 NNS 37231 4402 17 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4402 18 and and CC 37231 4402 19 by by IN 37231 4402 20 the the DT 37231 4402 21 Anabaptists Anabaptists NNPS 37231 4402 22 at at IN 37231 4402 23 the the DT 37231 4402 24 time time NN 37231 4402 25 of of IN 37231 4402 26 the the DT 37231 4402 27 Reformation Reformation NNP 37231 4402 28 . . . 37231 4403 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4403 2 3 3 LS 37231 4403 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4403 4 A a DT 37231 4403 5 wide wide JJ 37231 4403 6 argument argument NN 37231 4403 7 might may MD 37231 4403 8 be be VB 37231 4403 9 opened open VBN 37231 4403 10 out out RP 37231 4403 11 as as IN 37231 4403 12 to to IN 37231 4403 13 the the DT 37231 4403 14 dependence dependence NN 37231 4403 15 of of IN 37231 4403 16 the the DT 37231 4403 17 other other JJ 37231 4403 18 two two CD 37231 4403 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4403 20 on on IN 37231 4403 21 this this DT 37231 4403 22 unauthenticated unauthenticated JJ 37231 4403 23 work work NN 37231 4403 24 . . . 37231 4404 1 The the DT 37231 4404 2 dilemma dilemma NN 37231 4404 3 , , , 37231 4404 4 however however RB 37231 4404 5 , , , 37231 4404 6 is be VBZ 37231 4404 7 not not RB 37231 4404 8 yet yet RB 37231 4404 9 complete complete JJ 37231 4404 10 . . . 37231 4405 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4405 2 was be VBD 37231 4405 3 early early RB 37231 4405 4 remarked remark VBN 37231 4405 5 that that IN 37231 4405 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4405 7 first first JJ 37231 4405 8 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4405 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4405 10 bore bear VBD 37231 4405 11 no no DT 37231 4405 12 real real JJ 37231 4405 13 marks mark NNS 37231 4405 14 of of IN 37231 4405 15 being be VBG 37231 4405 16 a a DT 37231 4405 17 translation translation NN 37231 4405 18 at at RB 37231 4405 19 all all RB 37231 4405 20 , , , 37231 4405 21 but but CC 37231 4405 22 is be VBZ 37231 4405 23 evidently evidently RB 37231 4405 24 an an DT 37231 4405 25 original original JJ 37231 4405 26 independent independent JJ 37231 4405 27 Greek greek JJ 37231 4405 28 work work NN 37231 4405 29 . . . 37231 4406 1 Even even RB 37231 4406 2 men man NNS 37231 4406 3 like like IN 37231 4406 4 Erasmus Erasmus NNP 37231 4406 5 , , , 37231 4406 6 Calvin Calvin NNP 37231 4406 7 , , , 37231 4406 8 Cajctan Cajctan NNP 37231 4406 9 , , , 37231 4406 10 and and CC 37231 4406 11 Oecolampadius Oecolampadius NNP 37231 4406 12 , , , 37231 4406 13 began begin VBD 37231 4406 14 to to TO 37231 4406 15 deny deny VB 37231 4406 16 the the DT 37231 4406 17 statement statement NN 37231 4406 18 that that IN 37231 4406 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4406 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4406 21 showed show VBD 37231 4406 22 any any DT 37231 4406 23 traces trace NNS 37231 4406 24 of of IN 37231 4406 25 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4406 26 origin origin NN 37231 4406 27 , , , 37231 4406 28 and and CC 37231 4406 29 the the DT 37231 4406 30 researches research NNS 37231 4406 31 of of IN 37231 4406 32 later later JJ 37231 4406 33 scholars scholar NNS 37231 4406 34 have have VBP 37231 4406 35 so so RB 37231 4406 36 fully fully RB 37231 4406 37 confirmed confirm VBN 37231 4406 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4406 39 doubts doubt NNS 37231 4406 40 that that IN 37231 4406 41 few few JJ 37231 4406 42 now now RB 37231 4406 43 maintain maintain VBP 37231 4406 44 the the DT 37231 4406 45 primitive primitive JJ 37231 4406 46 belief belief NN 37231 4406 47 in in IN 37231 4406 48 a a DT 37231 4406 49 translation translation NN 37231 4406 50 . . . 37231 4407 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4407 2 do do VBP 37231 4407 3 not not RB 37231 4407 4 propose propose VB 37231 4407 5 here here RB 37231 4407 6 to to TO 37231 4407 7 enter enter VB 37231 4407 8 fully fully RB 37231 4407 9 into into IN 37231 4407 10 this this DT 37231 4407 11 argument argument NN 37231 4407 12 . . . 37231 4408 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4408 2 is be VBZ 37231 4408 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 37231 4408 4 to to TO 37231 4408 5 say say VB 37231 4408 6 that that IN 37231 4408 7 the the DT 37231 4408 8 great great JJ 37231 4408 9 majority majority NN 37231 4408 10 of of IN 37231 4408 11 competent competent JJ 37231 4408 12 critics critic NNS 37231 4408 13 declare declare VBP 37231 4408 14 that that IN 37231 4408 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4408 16 first first JJ 37231 4408 17 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4408 18 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4408 19 is be VBZ 37231 4408 20 no no DT 37231 4408 21 translation translation NN 37231 4408 22 , , , 37231 4408 23 but but CC 37231 4408 24 an an DT 37231 4408 25 { { -LRB- 37231 4408 26 478 478 CD 37231 4408 27 } } -RRB- 37231 4408 28 original original JJ 37231 4408 29 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4408 30 text;(1 text;(1 NNP 37231 4408 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4408 32 whilst whilst IN 37231 4408 33 of of IN 37231 4408 34 those those DT 37231 4408 35 who who WP 37231 4408 36 consider consider VBP 37231 4408 37 that that IN 37231 4408 38 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4408 39 find find VBP 37231 4408 40 traces trace NNS 37231 4408 41 of of IN 37231 4408 42 translation translation NN 37231 4408 43 and and CC 37231 4408 44 of of IN 37231 4408 45 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4408 46 origin origin NN 37231 4408 47 , , , 37231 4408 48 { { -LRB- 37231 4408 49 479 479 CD 37231 4408 50 } } -RRB- 37231 4408 51 some some DT 37231 4408 52 barely barely RB 37231 4408 53 deny deny VBP 37231 4408 54 the the DT 37231 4408 55 independent independent JJ 37231 4408 56 originality originality NN 37231 4408 57 of of IN 37231 4408 58 the the DT 37231 4408 59 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4408 60 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4408 61 , , , 37231 4408 62 and and CC 37231 4408 63 few few JJ 37231 4408 64 assert assert VBP 37231 4408 65 more more JJR 37231 4408 66 than than IN 37231 4408 67 substantial substantial JJ 37231 4408 68 agreement agreement NN 37231 4408 69 with with IN 37231 4408 70 the the DT 37231 4408 71 original original JJ 37231 4408 72 , , , 37231 4408 73 with with IN 37231 4408 74 more more JJR 37231 4408 75 or or CC 37231 4408 76 less less JJR 37231 4408 77 variation variation NN 37231 4408 78 and and CC 37231 4408 79 addition addition NN 37231 4408 80 often often RB 37231 4408 81 of of IN 37231 4408 82 a a DT 37231 4408 83 very very RB 37231 4408 84 decided decide VBN 37231 4408 85 character character NN 37231 4408 86 . . . 37231 4409 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4409 2 1 1 LS 37231 4409 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4409 4 The the DT 37231 4409 5 case case NN 37231 4409 6 , , , 37231 4409 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 4409 8 , , , 37231 4409 9 stands stand VBZ 37231 4409 10 thus thus RB 37231 4409 11 : : : 37231 4409 12 The the DT 37231 4409 13 whole whole NN 37231 4409 14 of of IN 37231 4409 15 the the DT 37231 4409 16 evidence evidence NN 37231 4409 17 which which WDT 37231 4409 18 warrants warrant VBZ 37231 4409 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4409 20 believing believe VBG 37231 4409 21 that that IN 37231 4409 22 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4409 23 wrote write VBD 37231 4409 24 any any DT 37231 4409 25 { { -LRB- 37231 4409 26 480 480 CD 37231 4409 27 } } -RRB- 37231 4409 28 work work NN 37231 4409 29 at at RB 37231 4409 30 all all RB 37231 4409 31 , , , 37231 4409 32 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 4409 33 , , , 37231 4409 34 invariably invariably RB 37231 4409 35 , , , 37231 4409 36 and and CC 37231 4409 37 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 4409 38 asserts assert VBZ 37231 4409 39 that that IN 37231 4409 40 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4409 41 wrote write VBD 37231 4409 42 that that IN 37231 4409 43 work work NN 37231 4409 44 in in IN 37231 4409 45 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4409 46 or or CC 37231 4409 47 Aramaic Aramaic NNP 37231 4409 48 ; ; : 37231 4409 49 a a DT 37231 4409 50 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4409 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4409 52 , , , 37231 4409 53 therefore therefore RB 37231 4409 54 , , , 37231 4409 55 as as IN 37231 4409 56 connected connect VBN 37231 4409 57 with with IN 37231 4409 58 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4409 59 , , , 37231 4409 60 can can MD 37231 4409 61 only only RB 37231 4409 62 be be VB 37231 4409 63 a a DT 37231 4409 64 translation translation NN 37231 4409 65 by by IN 37231 4409 66 an an DT 37231 4409 67 unknown unknown JJ 37231 4409 68 hand hand NN 37231 4409 69 , , , 37231 4409 70 whose whose WP$ 37231 4409 71 accuracy accuracy NN 37231 4409 72 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4409 73 have have VBP 37231 4409 74 not not RB 37231 4409 75 , , , 37231 4409 76 and and CC 37231 4409 77 never never RB 37231 4409 78 have have VB 37231 4409 79 had have VBN 37231 4409 80 , , , 37231 4409 81 the the DT 37231 4409 82 means mean NNS 37231 4409 83 of of IN 37231 4409 84 verifying verifying NN 37231 4409 85 . . . 37231 4410 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4410 2 Greek Greek NNP 37231 4410 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4410 4 , , , 37231 4410 5 however however RB 37231 4410 6 , , , 37231 4410 7 being be VBG 37231 4410 8 an an DT 37231 4410 9 independent independent JJ 37231 4410 10 original original JJ 37231 4410 11 Greek greek JJ 37231 4410 12 text text NN 37231 4410 13 , , , 37231 4410 14 there there EX 37231 4410 15 is be VBZ 37231 4410 16 no no DT 37231 4410 17 ground ground NN 37231 4410 18 whatever whatever WDT 37231 4410 19 for for IN 37231 4410 20 ascribing ascribe VBG 37231 4410 21 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4410 22 even even RB 37231 4410 23 indirectly indirectly RB 37231 4410 24 to to IN 37231 4410 25 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4410 26 at at RB 37231 4410 27 all all RB 37231 4410 28 , , , 37231 4410 29 the the DT 37231 4410 30 whole whole JJ 37231 4410 31 evidence evidence NN 37231 4410 32 of of IN 37231 4410 33 antiquity antiquity NN 37231 4410 34 being be VBG 37231 4410 35 emphatically emphatically RB 37231 4410 36 opposed oppose VBN 37231 4410 37 , , , 37231 4410 38 and and CC 37231 4410 39 the the DT 37231 4410 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4410 41 itself -PRON- PRP 37231 4410 42 laying lay VBG 37231 4410 43 no no DT 37231 4410 44 claim claim NN 37231 4410 45 , , , 37231 4410 46 to to IN 37231 4410 47 such such JJ 37231 4410 48 authorship authorship NN 37231 4410 49 . . . 37231 4411 1 One one CD 37231 4411 2 or or CC 37231 4411 3 other other JJ 37231 4411 4 of of IN 37231 4411 5 these these DT 37231 4411 6 alternatives alternative NNS 37231 4411 7 must must MD 37231 4411 8 be be VB 37231 4411 9 adopted adopt VBN 37231 4411 10 for for IN 37231 4411 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4411 12 first first JJ 37231 4411 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4411 14 , , , 37231 4411 15 and and CC 37231 4411 16 either either RB 37231 4411 17 is be VBZ 37231 4411 18 absolutely absolutely RB 37231 4411 19 fatal fatal JJ 37231 4411 20 to to IN 37231 4411 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4411 22 direct direct JJ 37231 4411 23 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4411 24 origin origin NN 37231 4411 25 . . . 37231 4412 1 Neither neither CC 37231 4412 2 as as IN 37231 4412 3 a a DT 37231 4412 4 translation translation NN 37231 4412 5 from from IN 37231 4412 6 the the DT 37231 4412 7 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4412 8 nor nor CC 37231 4412 9 as as IN 37231 4412 10 an an DT 37231 4412 11 original original JJ 37231 4412 12 Greek greek JJ 37231 4412 13 text text NN 37231 4412 14 can can MD 37231 4412 15 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4412 16 claim claim VB 37231 4412 17 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4412 18 authority authority NN 37231 4412 19 . . . 37231 4413 1 This this DT 37231 4413 2 has have VBZ 37231 4413 3 been be VBN 37231 4413 4 so so RB 37231 4413 5 well well RB 37231 4413 6 recognized recognize VBN 37231 4413 7 , , , 37231 4413 8 if if IN 37231 4413 9 not not RB 37231 4413 10 admitted admit VBN 37231 4413 11 , , , 37231 4413 12 that that IN 37231 4413 13 some some DT 37231 4413 14 writers writer NNS 37231 4413 15 , , , 37231 4413 16 with with IN 37231 4413 17 greater great JJR 37231 4413 18 zeal zeal NN 37231 4413 19 than than IN 37231 4413 20 discretion discretion NN 37231 4413 21 , , , 37231 4413 22 have have VBP 37231 4413 23 devised devise VBN 37231 4413 24 fanciful fanciful JJ 37231 4413 25 theories theory NNS 37231 4413 26 to to TO 37231 4413 27 obviate obviate VB 37231 4413 28 the the DT 37231 4413 29 difficulty difficulty NN 37231 4413 30 . . . 37231 4414 1 These these DT 37231 4414 2 maintain maintain VBP 37231 4414 3 that that IN 37231 4414 4 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4414 5 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4414 6 wrote write VBD 37231 4414 7 both both DT 37231 4414 8 in in IN 37231 4414 9 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 37231 4414 10 and and CC 37231 4414 11 in in IN 37231 4414 12 Greek,(1 greek,(1 NN 37231 4414 13 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4414 14 or or CC 37231 4414 15 at at IN 37231 4414 16 least least JJS 37231 4414 17 that that IN 37231 4414 18 the the DT 37231 4414 19 translation translation NN 37231 4414 20 was be VBD 37231 4414 21 made make VBN 37231 4414 22 during during IN 37231 4414 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4414 24 own own JJ 37231 4414 25 lifetime lifetime NN 37231 4414 26 and and CC 37231 4414 27 under under IN 37231 4414 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4414 29 own own JJ 37231 4414 30 eye,(2 eye,(2 NN 37231 4414 31 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4414 32 and and CC 37231 4414 33 so so RB 37231 4414 34 on on RB 37231 4414 35 . . . 37231 4415 1 There there EX 37231 4415 2 is be VBZ 37231 4415 3 not not RB 37231 4415 4 , , , 37231 4415 5 however however RB 37231 4415 6 , , , 37231 4415 7 a a DT 37231 4415 8 particle particle NN 37231 4415 9 of of IN 37231 4415 10 evidence evidence NN 37231 4415 11 for for IN 37231 4415 12 any any DT 37231 4415 13 of of IN 37231 4415 14 these these DT 37231 4415 15 assertions assertion NNS 37231 4415 16 , , , 37231 4415 17 which which WDT 37231 4415 18 { { -LRB- 37231 4415 19 481 481 CD 37231 4415 20 } } -RRB- 37231 4415 21 are be VBP 37231 4415 22 merely merely RB 37231 4415 23 the the DT 37231 4415 24 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 37231 4415 25 and and CC 37231 4415 26 groundless groundless JJ 37231 4415 27 conjectures conjecture NNS 37231 4415 28 of of IN 37231 4415 29 embarrassed embarrassed JJ 37231 4415 30 apologists apologist NNS 37231 4415 31 . . . 37231 4416 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4416 2 is be VBZ 37231 4416 3 manifest manifest JJ 37231 4416 4 that that IN 37231 4416 5 upon upon IN 37231 4416 6 this this DT 37231 4416 7 evidence evidence NN 37231 4416 8 both both CC 37231 4416 9 those those DT 37231 4416 10 who who WP 37231 4416 11 assert assert VBP 37231 4416 12 the the DT 37231 4416 13 Hebrew hebrew JJ 37231 4416 14 original original NN 37231 4416 15 of of IN 37231 4416 16 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4416 17 's 's POS 37231 4416 18 work work NN 37231 4416 19 and and CC 37231 4416 20 those those DT 37231 4416 21 who who WP 37231 4416 22 maintain maintain VBP 37231 4416 23 that that IN 37231 4416 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4416 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4416 26 is be VBZ 37231 4416 27 not not RB 37231 4416 28 a a DT 37231 4416 29 translation translation NN 37231 4416 30 but but CC 37231 4416 31 an an DT 37231 4416 32 original original JJ 37231 4416 33 Greek greek JJ 37231 4416 34 composition composition NN 37231 4416 35 , , , 37231 4416 36 should should MD 37231 4416 37 logically logically RB 37231 4416 38 deny deny VB 37231 4416 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4416 40 apostolicity apostolicity NN 37231 4416 41 . . . 37231 4417 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4417 2 need need VBP 37231 4417 3 not not RB 37231 4417 4 say say VB 37231 4417 5 that that IN 37231 4417 6 this this DT 37231 4417 7 is be VBZ 37231 4417 8 not not RB 37231 4417 9 done do VBN 37231 4417 10 , , , 37231 4417 11 and and CC 37231 4417 12 that that IN 37231 4417 13 for for IN 37231 4417 14 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 37231 4417 15 and and CC 37231 4417 16 other other JJ 37231 4417 17 foregone foregone JJ 37231 4417 18 conclusions conclusion NNS 37231 4417 19 many many JJ 37231 4417 20 profess profess JJ 37231 4417 21 belief belief NN 37231 4417 22 in in IN 37231 4417 23 the the DT 37231 4417 24 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4417 25 authorship authorship NN 37231 4417 26 of of IN 37231 4417 27 the the DT 37231 4417 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4417 29 , , , 37231 4417 30 although although IN 37231 4417 31 in in IN 37231 4417 32 doing do VBG 37231 4417 33 so so RB 37231 4417 34 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4417 35 wilfully wilfully RB 37231 4417 36 ignore ignore VBP 37231 4417 37 the the DT 37231 4417 38 facts fact NNS 37231 4417 39 , , , 37231 4417 40 and and CC 37231 4417 41 in in IN 37231 4417 42 many many JJ 37231 4417 43 cases case NNS 37231 4417 44 merely merely RB 37231 4417 45 claim claim VBP 37231 4417 46 a a DT 37231 4417 47 substantial substantial JJ 37231 4417 48 but but CC 37231 4417 49 not not RB 37231 4417 50 absolute absolute JJ 37231 4417 51 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4417 52 origin origin NN 37231 4417 53 for for IN 37231 4417 54 the the DT 37231 4417 55 work work NN 37231 4417 56 . . . 37231 4418 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4418 2 1 1 LS 37231 4418 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4418 4 A a DT 37231 4418 5 much much RB 37231 4418 6 greater great JJR 37231 4418 7 number number NN 37231 4418 8 of of IN 37231 4418 9 the the DT 37231 4418 10 most most RBS 37231 4418 11 able able JJ 37231 4418 12 and and CC 37231 4418 13 learned learn VBD 37231 4418 14 critics critic NNS 37231 4418 15 , , , 37231 4418 16 however however RB 37231 4418 17 , , , 37231 4418 18 both both CC 37231 4418 19 from from IN 37231 4418 20 external external JJ 37231 4418 21 and and CC 37231 4418 22 internal internal JJ 37231 4418 23 evidence evidence NN 37231 4418 24 deny deny VBP 37231 4418 25 the the DT 37231 4418 26 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4418 27 origin origin NN 37231 4418 28 of of IN 37231 4418 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4418 30 first first JJ 37231 4418 31 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4418 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4418 33 . . . 37231 4419 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4419 2 3 3 LS 37231 4419 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4419 4 { { -LRB- 37231 4419 5 482 482 CD 37231 4419 6 } } -RRB- 37231 4419 7 There there EX 37231 4419 8 is be VBZ 37231 4419 9 another another DT 37231 4419 10 fact fact NN 37231 4419 11 to to TO 37231 4419 12 which which WDT 37231 4419 13 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4419 14 may may MD 37231 4419 15 briefly briefly RB 37231 4419 16 refer refer VB 37231 4419 17 , , , 37231 4419 18 which which WDT 37231 4419 19 from from IN 37231 4419 20 another another DT 37231 4419 21 side side NN 37231 4419 22 shows show VBZ 37231 4419 23 that that IN 37231 4419 24 the the DT 37231 4419 25 work work NN 37231 4419 26 of of IN 37231 4419 27 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4419 28 { { -LRB- 37231 4419 29 483 483 CD 37231 4419 30 } } -RRB- 37231 4419 31 with with IN 37231 4419 32 which which WDT 37231 4419 33 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4419 34 was be VBD 37231 4419 35 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4419 36 was be VBD 37231 4419 37 different different JJ 37231 4419 38 from from IN 37231 4419 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4419 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4419 41 . . . 37231 4420 1 In in IN 37231 4420 2 a a DT 37231 4420 3 fragment fragment NN 37231 4420 4 from from IN 37231 4420 5 the the DT 37231 4420 6 fourth fourth JJ 37231 4420 7 book book NN 37231 4420 8 of of IN 37231 4420 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4420 10 lost lost JJ 37231 4420 11 work work NN 37231 4420 12 which which WDT 37231 4420 13 is be VBZ 37231 4420 14 preserved preserve VBN 37231 4420 15 to to IN 37231 4420 16 us -PRON- PRP 37231 4420 17 by by IN 37231 4420 18 Oecumenius Oecumenius NNP 37231 4420 19 and and CC 37231 4420 20 Theophylact Theophylact NNP 37231 4420 21 , , , 37231 4420 22 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4420 23 relates relate VBZ 37231 4420 24 the the DT 37231 4420 25 circumstances circumstance NNS 37231 4420 26 of of IN 37231 4420 27 the the DT 37231 4420 28 death death NN 37231 4420 29 of of IN 37231 4420 30 Judas Judas NNP 37231 4420 31 Iscariot Iscariot NNP 37231 4420 32 in in IN 37231 4420 33 a a DT 37231 4420 34 manner manner NN 37231 4420 35 which which WDT 37231 4420 36 is be VBZ 37231 4420 37 in in IN 37231 4420 38 contradiction contradiction NN 37231 4420 39 to to IN 37231 4420 40 the the DT 37231 4420 41 account account NN 37231 4420 42 in in IN 37231 4420 43 the the DT 37231 4420 44 first first JJ 37231 4420 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4420 46 . . . 37231 4421 1 In in IN 37231 4421 2 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4421 3 xxvii xxvii NN 37231 4421 4 . . . 37231 4422 1 5 5 CD 37231 4422 2 , , , 37231 4422 3 the the DT 37231 4422 4 death death NN 37231 4422 5 of of IN 37231 4422 6 the the DT 37231 4422 7 traitor traitor NN 37231 4422 8 is be VBZ 37231 4422 9 thus thus RB 37231 4422 10 related relate VBN 37231 4422 11 : : : 37231 4422 12 " " `` 37231 4422 13 And and CC 37231 4422 14 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4422 15 cast cast VBD 37231 4422 16 down down RP 37231 4422 17 the the DT 37231 4422 18 pieces piece NNS 37231 4422 19 of of IN 37231 4422 20 silver silver NN 37231 4422 21 in in IN 37231 4422 22 the the DT 37231 4422 23 temple temple NN 37231 4422 24 and and CC 37231 4422 25 departed depart VBD 37231 4422 26 and and CC 37231 4422 27 went go VBD 37231 4422 28 and and CC 37231 4422 29 hanged hang VBD 37231 4422 30 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4422 31 . . . 37231 4423 1 " " `` 37231 4423 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4423 3 1 1 LS 37231 4423 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4423 5 The the DT 37231 4423 6 narrative narrative NN 37231 4423 7 in in IN 37231 4423 8 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4423 9 is be VBZ 37231 4423 10 as as IN 37231 4423 11 follows follow VBZ 37231 4423 12 : : : 37231 4423 13 " " `` 37231 4423 14 Judas Judas NNP 37231 4423 15 walked walk VBD 37231 4423 16 about about IN 37231 4423 17 in in IN 37231 4423 18 this this DT 37231 4423 19 world world NN 37231 4423 20 a a DT 37231 4423 21 great great JJ 37231 4423 22 example example NN 37231 4423 23 of of IN 37231 4423 24 impiety impiety NNP 37231 4423 25 ; ; : 37231 4423 26 for for IN 37231 4423 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4423 28 body body NN 37231 4423 29 having have VBG 37231 4423 30 swollen swell VBN 37231 4423 31 so so IN 37231 4423 32 that that IN 37231 4423 33 , , , 37231 4423 34 on on IN 37231 4423 35 an an DT 37231 4423 36 occasion occasion NN 37231 4423 37 , , , 37231 4423 38 when when WRB 37231 4423 39 a a DT 37231 4423 40 waggon waggon NN 37231 4423 41 was be VBD 37231 4423 42 moving move VBG 37231 4423 43 on on IN 37231 4423 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4423 45 way way NN 37231 4423 46 , , , 37231 4423 47 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4423 48 could could MD 37231 4423 49 not not RB 37231 4423 50 pass pass VB 37231 4423 51 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4423 52 , , , 37231 4423 53 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4423 54 was be VBD 37231 4423 55 crushed crush VBN 37231 4423 56 by by IN 37231 4423 57 the the DT 37231 4423 58 waggon waggon NN 37231 4423 59 and and CC 37231 4423 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4423 61 bowels bowel NNS 37231 4423 62 gushed gush VBD 37231 4423 63 out out RP 37231 4423 64 . . . 37231 4424 1 " " `` 37231 4424 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4424 3 2 2 LS 37231 4424 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4424 5 Theophylact Theophylact NNP 37231 4424 6 , , , 37231 4424 7 in in IN 37231 4424 8 connection connection NN 37231 4424 9 with with IN 37231 4424 10 this this DT 37231 4424 11 passage passage NN 37231 4424 12 , , , 37231 4424 13 adds add VBZ 37231 4424 14 other other JJ 37231 4424 15 details detail NNS 37231 4424 16 also also RB 37231 4424 17 apparently apparently RB 37231 4424 18 taken take VBN 37231 4424 19 from from IN 37231 4424 20 the the DT 37231 4424 21 work work NN 37231 4424 22 of of IN 37231 4424 23 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4424 24 , , , 37231 4424 25 as as IN 37231 4424 26 for for IN 37231 4424 27 instance instance NN 37231 4424 28 that that IN 37231 4424 29 , , , 37231 4424 30 from from IN 37231 4424 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4424 32 excessive excessive JJ 37231 4424 33 corpulency corpulency NN 37231 4424 34 , , , 37231 4424 35 the the DT 37231 4424 36 eyes eye NNS 37231 4424 37 of of IN 37231 4424 38 Judas Judas NNP 37231 4424 39 were be VBD 37231 4424 40 so so RB 37231 4424 41 swollen swollen JJ 37231 4424 42 that that IN 37231 4424 43 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4424 44 could could MD 37231 4424 45 not not RB 37231 4424 46 see see VB 37231 4424 47 , , , 37231 4424 48 and and CC 37231 4424 49 so so RB 37231 4424 50 sunk sink VBN 37231 4424 51 in in IN 37231 4424 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4424 53 head head NN 37231 4424 54 that that IN 37231 4424 55 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4424 56 could could MD 37231 4424 57 not not RB 37231 4424 58 be be VB 37231 4424 59 perceived perceive VBN 37231 4424 60 even even RB 37231 4424 61 by by IN 37231 4424 62 the the DT 37231 4424 63 aid aid NN 37231 4424 64 of of IN 37231 4424 65 the the DT 37231 4424 66 optical optical JJ 37231 4424 67 instruments instrument NNS 37231 4424 68 of of IN 37231 4424 69 physicians physician NNS 37231 4424 70 ; ; : 37231 4424 71 and and CC 37231 4424 72 that that IN 37231 4424 73 the the DT 37231 4424 74 rest rest NN 37231 4424 75 of of IN 37231 4424 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4424 77 body body NN 37231 4424 78 was be VBD 37231 4424 79 covered cover VBN 37231 4424 80 with with IN 37231 4424 81 running run VBG 37231 4424 82 sores sore NNS 37231 4424 83 and and CC 37231 4424 84 maggots maggot NNS 37231 4424 85 , , , 37231 4424 86 and and CC 37231 4424 87 so so RB 37231 4424 88 on on RB 37231 4424 89 in in IN 37231 4424 90 the the DT 37231 4424 91 manner manner NN 37231 4424 92 of of IN 37231 4424 93 the the DT 37231 4424 94 early early JJ 37231 4424 95 Christian christian JJ 37231 4424 96 ages age NNS 37231 4424 97 , , , 37231 4424 98 whose whose WP$ 37231 4424 99 imagination imagination NN 37231 4424 100 conjured conjure VBD 37231 4424 101 up up IN 37231 4424 102 the the DT 37231 4424 103 wildest wild JJS 37231 4424 104 " " `` 37231 4424 105 special special JJ 37231 4424 106 { { -LRB- 37231 4424 107 484 484 CD 37231 4424 108 } } -RRB- 37231 4424 109 providences providence NNS 37231 4424 110 " " '' 37231 4424 111 to to TO 37231 4424 112 punish punish VB 37231 4424 113 the the DT 37231 4424 114 enemies enemy NNS 37231 4424 115 of of IN 37231 4424 116 the the DT 37231 4424 117 faith faith NN 37231 4424 118 . . . 37231 4425 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4425 2 1 1 LS 37231 4425 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4425 4 As as IN 37231 4425 5 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4425 6 expressly expressly RB 37231 4425 7 states state VBZ 37231 4425 8 that that IN 37231 4425 9 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4425 10 eagerly eagerly RB 37231 4425 11 inquired inquire VBD 37231 4425 12 what what WP 37231 4425 13 the the DT 37231 4425 14 Apostles Apostles NNPS 37231 4425 15 , , , 37231 4425 16 and and CC 37231 4425 17 amongst amongst IN 37231 4425 18 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4425 19 what what WP 37231 4425 20 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4425 21 , , , 37231 4425 22 said say VBD 37231 4425 23 , , , 37231 4425 24 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4425 25 may may MD 37231 4425 26 conclude conclude VB 37231 4425 27 that that IN 37231 4425 28 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4425 29 would would MD 37231 4425 30 not not RB 37231 4425 31 have have VB 37231 4425 32 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 4425 33 contradicted contradict VBN 37231 4425 34 the the DT 37231 4425 35 account account NN 37231 4425 36 given give VBN 37231 4425 37 by by IN 37231 4425 38 that that DT 37231 4425 39 Apostle Apostle NNP 37231 4425 40 had have VBD 37231 4425 41 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4425 42 been be VBN 37231 4425 43 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4425 44 with with IN 37231 4425 45 any any DT 37231 4425 46 work work NN 37231 4425 47 attributed attribute VBN 37231 4425 48 to to IN 37231 4425 49 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4425 50 which which WDT 37231 4425 51 contained contain VBD 37231 4425 52 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4425 53 . . . 37231 4426 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4426 2 2 2 LS 37231 4426 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4426 4 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4426 5 has have VBZ 37231 4426 6 been be VBN 37231 4426 7 argued argue VBN 37231 4426 8 , , , 37231 4426 9 from from IN 37231 4426 10 some some DT 37231 4426 11 very very RB 37231 4426 12 remote remote JJ 37231 4426 13 and and CC 37231 4426 14 imaginary imaginary JJ 37231 4426 15 resemblance resemblance NN 37231 4426 16 between between IN 37231 4426 17 the the DT 37231 4426 18 passage passage NN 37231 4426 19 from from IN 37231 4426 20 the the DT 37231 4426 21 preface preface NN 37231 4426 22 to to IN 37231 4426 23 the the DT 37231 4426 24 work work NN 37231 4426 25 of of IN 37231 4426 26 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4426 27 quoted quote VBN 37231 4426 28 by by IN 37231 4426 29 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4426 30 with with IN 37231 4426 31 the the DT 37231 4426 32 prologue prologue NN 37231 4426 33 to to IN 37231 4426 34 Luke Luke NNP 37231 4426 35 , , , 37231 4426 36 that that IN 37231 4426 37 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4426 38 was be VBD 37231 4426 39 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4426 40 with with IN 37231 4426 41 that that DT 37231 4426 42 Gospel;(3 gospel;(3 NN 37231 4426 43 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4426 44 but but CC 37231 4426 45 nothing nothing NN 37231 4426 46 could could MD 37231 4426 47 be be VB 37231 4426 48 more more RBR 37231 4426 49 groundless groundless JJ 37231 4426 50 than than IN 37231 4426 51 such such PDT 37231 4426 52 a a DT 37231 4426 53 conclusion conclusion NN 37231 4426 54 based base VBN 37231 4426 55 upon upon IN 37231 4426 56 such such JJ 37231 4426 57 evidence evidence NN 37231 4426 58 , , , 37231 4426 59 and and CC 37231 4426 60 there there EX 37231 4426 61 is be VBZ 37231 4426 62 not not RB 37231 4426 63 a a DT 37231 4426 64 word word NN 37231 4426 65 in in IN 37231 4426 66 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4426 67 fragments fragment NNS 37231 4426 68 of of IN 37231 4426 69 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4426 70 which which WDT 37231 4426 71 warrants warrant VBZ 37231 4426 72 such such PDT 37231 4426 73 an an DT 37231 4426 74 assertion assertion NN 37231 4426 75 . . . 37231 4427 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4427 2 4 4 LS 37231 4427 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4427 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4427 5 , , , 37231 4427 6 who who WP 37231 4427 7 never never RB 37231 4427 8 fails fail VBZ 37231 4427 9 to to TO 37231 4427 10 state state VB 37231 4427 11 what what WP 37231 4427 12 the the DT 37231 4427 13 Fathers father NNS 37231 4427 14 say say VBP 37231 4427 15 about about IN 37231 4427 16 the the DT 37231 4427 17 works work NNS 37231 4427 18 of of IN 37231 4427 19 the the DT 37231 4427 20 New New NNP 37231 4427 21 Testament Testament NNP 37231 4427 22 , , , 37231 4427 23 does do VBZ 37231 4427 24 not not RB 37231 4427 25 mention mention VB 37231 4427 26 that that IN 37231 4427 27 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4427 28 knew know VBD 37231 4427 29 either either CC 37231 4427 30 the the DT 37231 4427 31 third third JJ 37231 4427 32 or or CC 37231 4427 33 fourth fourth JJ 37231 4427 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4427 35 . . . 37231 4428 1 Is be VBZ 37231 4428 2 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4428 3 possible possible JJ 37231 4428 4 to to TO 37231 4428 5 suppose suppose VB 37231 4428 6 that that IN 37231 4428 7 if if IN 37231 4428 8 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4428 9 had have VBD 37231 4428 10 been be VBN 37231 4428 11 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4428 12 with with IN 37231 4428 13 those those DT 37231 4428 14 Gospels gospel NNS 37231 4428 15 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4428 16 would would MD 37231 4428 17 not not RB 37231 4428 18 have have VB 37231 4428 19 asked ask VBN 37231 4428 20 for for IN 37231 4428 21 information information NN 37231 4428 22 about about IN 37231 4428 23 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4428 24 from from IN 37231 4428 25 the the DT 37231 4428 26 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 37231 4428 27 , , , 37231 4428 28 or or CC 37231 4428 29 that that IN 37231 4428 30 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4428 31 would would MD 37231 4428 32 not not RB 37231 4428 33 have have VB 37231 4428 34 recorded record VBN 37231 4428 35 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4428 36 as as IN 37231 4428 37 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4428 38 did do VBD 37231 4428 39 that that IN 37231 4428 40 regarding regard VBG 37231 4428 41 the the DT 37231 4428 42 works work NNS 37231 4428 43 ascribed ascribe VBN 37231 4428 44 to to IN 37231 4428 45 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4428 46 and and CC 37231 4428 47 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4428 48 ? ? . 37231 4429 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4429 2 states state NNS 37231 4429 3 , , , 37231 4429 4 however however RB 37231 4429 5 , , , 37231 4429 6 that that IN 37231 4429 7 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4429 8 " " `` 37231 4429 9 made make VBD 37231 4429 10 use use NN 37231 4429 11 of of IN 37231 4429 12 testimonies testimony NNS 37231 4429 13 from from IN 37231 4429 14 the the DT 37231 4429 15 first first JJ 37231 4429 16 Epistle Epistle NNP 37231 4429 17 of of IN 37231 4429 18 John John NNP 37231 4429 19 and and CC 37231 4429 20 , , , 37231 4429 21 likewise likewise RB 37231 4429 22 , , , 37231 4429 23 from from IN 37231 4429 24 that that DT 37231 4429 25 of of IN 37231 4429 26 Peter Peter NNP 37231 4429 27 . . . 37231 4430 1 " " `` 37231 4430 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4430 3 5 5 CD 37231 4430 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4430 5 As as IN 37231 4430 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4430 7 , , , 37231 4430 8 { { -LRB- 37231 4430 9 485 485 CD 37231 4430 10 } } -RRB- 37231 4430 11 however however RB 37231 4430 12 , , , 37231 4430 13 does do VBZ 37231 4430 14 not not RB 37231 4430 15 quote quote VB 37231 4430 16 the the DT 37231 4430 17 passages passage NNS 37231 4430 18 from from IN 37231 4430 19 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4430 20 , , , 37231 4430 21 we -PRON- PRP 37231 4430 22 must must MD 37231 4430 23 remain remain VB 37231 4430 24 in in IN 37231 4430 25 doubt doubt NN 37231 4430 26 whether whether IN 37231 4430 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4430 28 did do VBD 37231 4430 29 not not RB 37231 4430 30 , , , 37231 4430 31 as as RB 37231 4430 32 elsewhere elsewhere RB 37231 4430 33 , , , 37231 4430 34 assume assume VBP 37231 4430 35 from from IN 37231 4430 36 some some DT 37231 4430 37 similarity similarity NN 37231 4430 38 of of IN 37231 4430 39 wording wording NN 37231 4430 40 that that IN 37231 4430 41 the the DT 37231 4430 42 passages passage NNS 37231 4430 43 were be VBD 37231 4430 44 quotations quotation NNS 37231 4430 45 from from IN 37231 4430 46 these these DT 37231 4430 47 Epistles Epistles NNPS 37231 4430 48 , , , 37231 4430 49 whilst whilst IN 37231 4430 50 in in IN 37231 4430 51 reality reality NN 37231 4430 52 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4430 53 might may MD 37231 4430 54 not not RB 37231 4430 55 be be VB 37231 4430 56 . . . 37231 4431 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 37231 4431 2 , , , 37231 4431 3 a a DT 37231 4431 4 Cappadocian cappadocian JJ 37231 4431 5 bishop bishop NN 37231 4431 6 of of IN 37231 4431 7 the the DT 37231 4431 8 fifth fifth JJ 37231 4431 9 century century NN 37231 4431 10 , , , 37231 4431 11 mentions mention VBZ 37231 4431 12 that that IN 37231 4431 13 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4431 14 , , , 37231 4431 15 amongst amongst IN 37231 4431 16 others other NNS 37231 4431 17 of of IN 37231 4431 18 the the DT 37231 4431 19 Fathers father NNS 37231 4431 20 , , , 37231 4431 21 considered consider VBD 37231 4431 22 the the DT 37231 4431 23 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 4431 24 inspired inspire VBN 37231 4431 25 . . . 37231 4432 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4432 2 1 1 LS 37231 4432 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4432 4 No no DT 37231 4432 5 reference reference NN 37231 4432 6 is be VBZ 37231 4432 7 made make VBN 37231 4432 8 to to IN 37231 4432 9 this this DT 37231 4432 10 by by IN 37231 4432 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 37231 4432 12 , , , 37231 4432 13 but but CC 37231 4432 14 although although IN 37231 4432 15 from from IN 37231 4432 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4432 17 Millenarian millenarian JJ 37231 4432 18 tendencies tendency NNS 37231 4432 19 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4432 20 is be VBZ 37231 4432 21 very very RB 37231 4432 22 probable probable JJ 37231 4432 23 that that IN 37231 4432 24 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4432 25 regarded regard VBD 37231 4432 26 the the DT 37231 4432 27 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 37231 4432 28 with with IN 37231 4432 29 peculiar peculiar JJ 37231 4432 30 veneration veneration NN 37231 4432 31 as as IN 37231 4432 32 a a DT 37231 4432 33 prophetic prophetic JJ 37231 4432 34 book book NN 37231 4432 35 , , , 37231 4432 36 this this DT 37231 4432 37 evidence evidence NN 37231 4432 38 is be VBZ 37231 4432 39 too too RB 37231 4432 40 vague vague JJ 37231 4432 41 and and CC 37231 4432 42 isolated isolate VBN 37231 4432 43 to to TO 37231 4432 44 be be VB 37231 4432 45 of of IN 37231 4432 46 much much JJ 37231 4432 47 value value NN 37231 4432 48 . . . 37231 4433 1 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4433 2 find find VBP 37231 4433 3 , , , 37231 4433 4 however however RB 37231 4433 5 , , , 37231 4433 6 that that IN 37231 4433 7 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4433 8 , , , 37231 4433 9 like like IN 37231 4433 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 37231 4433 11 and and CC 37231 4433 12 others other NNS 37231 4433 13 of of IN 37231 4433 14 the the DT 37231 4433 15 Fathers Fathers NNP 37231 4433 16 , , , 37231 4433 17 was be VBD 37231 4433 18 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4433 19 with with IN 37231 4433 20 the the DT 37231 4433 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4433 22 according accord VBG 37231 4433 23 to to IN 37231 4433 24 the the DT 37231 4433 25 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4433 26 . . . 37231 4434 1 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4434 2 2 2 LS 37231 4434 3 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4434 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 37231 4434 5 says say VBZ 37231 4434 6 : : : 37231 4434 7 " " `` 37231 4434 8 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4434 9 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4434 10 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4434 11 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4434 12 has have VBZ 37231 4434 13 likewise likewise RB 37231 4434 14 related relate VBN 37231 4434 15 another another DT 37231 4434 16 history history NN 37231 4434 17 of of IN 37231 4434 18 a a DT 37231 4434 19 woman woman NN 37231 4434 20 accused accuse VBN 37231 4434 21 of of IN 37231 4434 22 many many JJ 37231 4434 23 sins sin NNS 37231 4434 24 before before IN 37231 4434 25 the the DT 37231 4434 26 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4434 27 , , , 37231 4434 28 which which WDT 37231 4434 29 is be VBZ 37231 4434 30 contained contain VBN 37231 4434 31 in in IN 37231 4434 32 the the DT 37231 4434 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4434 34 according accord VBG 37231 4434 35 to to IN 37231 4434 36 the the DT 37231 4434 37 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 37231 4434 38 . . . 37231 4435 1 " " `` 37231 4435 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4435 3 3 3 LS 37231 4435 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4435 5 This this DT 37231 4435 6 is be VBZ 37231 4435 7 generally generally RB 37231 4435 8 believed believe VBN 37231 4435 9 to to TO 37231 4435 10 be be VB 37231 4435 11 the the DT 37231 4435 12 episode episode NN 37231 4435 13 inserted insert VBN 37231 4435 14 in in IN 37231 4435 15 the the DT 37231 4435 16 later later JJ 37231 4435 17 MSS MSS NNP 37231 4435 18 . . . 37231 4436 1 of of IN 37231 4436 2 the the DT 37231 4436 3 fourth fourth JJ 37231 4436 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 37231 4436 5 , , , 37231 4436 6 viii viii JJ 37231 4436 7 . . . 37231 4437 1 1 1 LS 37231 4437 2 - - HYPH 37231 4437 3 -11 -11 NN 37231 4437 4 . . . 37231 4438 1 Whatever whatever WDT 37231 4438 2 books book NNS 37231 4438 3 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4438 4 knew know VBD 37231 4438 5 , , , 37231 4438 6 however however RB 37231 4438 7 , , , 37231 4438 8 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4438 9 is be VBZ 37231 4438 10 certain certain JJ 37231 4438 11 , , , 37231 4438 12 from from IN 37231 4438 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4438 14 own own JJ 37231 4438 15 express express JJ 37231 4438 16 declaration declaration NN 37231 4438 17 , , , 37231 4438 18 that that IN 37231 4438 19 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4438 20 ascribed ascribe VBD 37231 4438 21 little little JJ 37231 4438 22 importance importance NN 37231 4438 23 to to IN 37231 4438 24 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4438 25 , , , 37231 4438 26 and and CC 37231 4438 27 preferred preferred JJ 37231 4438 28 tradition tradition NN 37231 4438 29 as as IN 37231 4438 30 a a DT 37231 4438 31 more more RBR 37231 4438 32 beneficial beneficial JJ 37231 4438 33 source source NN 37231 4438 34 of of IN 37231 4438 35 information information NN 37231 4438 36 regarding regard VBG 37231 4438 37 evangelical evangelical JJ 37231 4438 38 history history NN 37231 4438 39 . . . 37231 4439 1 " " `` 37231 4439 2 For for IN 37231 4439 3 I -PRON- PRP 37231 4439 4 held hold VBD 37231 4439 5 that that IN 37231 4439 6 what what WP 37231 4439 7 was be VBD 37231 4439 8 to to TO 37231 4439 9 be be VB 37231 4439 10 derived derive VBN 37231 4439 11 from from IN 37231 4439 12 { { -LRB- 37231 4439 13 486 486 CD 37231 4439 14 } } -RRB- 37231 4439 15 books book NNS 37231 4439 16 , , , 37231 4439 17 " " '' 37231 4439 18 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4439 19 says say VBZ 37231 4439 20 , , , 37231 4439 21 " " `` 37231 4439 22 did do VBD 37231 4439 23 not not RB 37231 4439 24 so so RB 37231 4439 25 profit profit VB 37231 4439 26 me -PRON- PRP 37231 4439 27 as as IN 37231 4439 28 that that DT 37231 4439 29 from from IN 37231 4439 30 the the DT 37231 4439 31 living live VBG 37231 4439 32 and and CC 37231 4439 33 abiding abide VBG 37231 4439 34 voice voice NN 37231 4439 35 . . . 37231 4440 1 " " `` 37231 4440 2 ( ( -LRB- 37231 4440 3 1 1 LS 37231 4440 4 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4440 5 If if IN 37231 4440 6 , , , 37231 4440 7 therefore therefore RB 37231 4440 8 , , , 37231 4440 9 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4440 10 could could MD 37231 4440 11 even even RB 37231 4440 12 have have VB 37231 4440 13 been be VBN 37231 4440 14 shown show VBN 37231 4440 15 that that IN 37231 4440 16 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4440 17 was be VBD 37231 4440 18 acquainted acquaint VBN 37231 4440 19 with with IN 37231 4440 20 any any DT 37231 4440 21 of of IN 37231 4440 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4440 23 Canonical Canonical NNP 37231 4440 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4440 25 , , , 37231 4440 26 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4440 27 must must MD 37231 4440 28 at at IN 37231 4440 29 the the DT 37231 4440 30 same same JJ 37231 4440 31 time time NN 37231 4440 32 have have VBP 37231 4440 33 been be VBN 37231 4440 34 admitted admit VBN 37231 4440 35 that that IN 37231 4440 36 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4440 37 did do VBD 37231 4440 38 not not RB 37231 4440 39 recognize recognize VB 37231 4440 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4440 41 as as IN 37231 4440 42 authoritative authoritative JJ 37231 4440 43 documents document NNS 37231 4440 44 . . . 37231 4441 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4441 2 is be VBZ 37231 4441 3 manifest manif JJS 37231 4441 4 from from IN 37231 4441 5 the the DT 37231 4441 6 evidence evidence NN 37231 4441 7 adduced adduce VBN 37231 4441 8 , , , 37231 4441 9 however however RB 37231 4441 10 , , , 37231 4441 11 that that IN 37231 4441 12 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4441 13 did do VBD 37231 4441 14 not not RB 37231 4441 15 know know VB 37231 4441 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4441 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4441 18 . . . 37231 4442 1 It -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 2 is be VBZ 37231 4442 3 not not RB 37231 4442 4 possible possible JJ 37231 4442 5 that that IN 37231 4442 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 7 could could MD 37231 4442 8 have have VB 37231 4442 9 found find VBN 37231 4442 10 it -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 11 better well JJR 37231 4442 12 to to TO 37231 4442 13 inquire inquire VB 37231 4442 14 " " '' 37231 4442 15 what what WP 37231 4442 16 John John NNP 37231 4442 17 or or CC 37231 4442 18 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4442 19 , , , 37231 4442 20 or or CC 37231 4442 21 what what WP 37231 4442 22 any any DT 37231 4442 23 other other JJ 37231 4442 24 of of IN 37231 4442 25 the the DT 37231 4442 26 disciples disciple NNS 37231 4442 27 of of IN 37231 4442 28 the the DT 37231 4442 29 Lord Lord NNP 37231 4442 30 ... ... NFP 37231 4442 31 say say VBP 37231 4442 32 " " `` 37231 4442 33 if if IN 37231 4442 34 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 35 had have VBD 37231 4442 36 known know VBN 37231 4442 37 of of IN 37231 4442 38 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4442 39 such such JJ 37231 4442 40 as as IN 37231 4442 41 ours -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 42 , , , 37231 4442 43 and and CC 37231 4442 44 believed believe VBD 37231 4442 45 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 46 to to TO 37231 4442 47 have have VB 37231 4442 48 been be VBN 37231 4442 49 actually actually RB 37231 4442 50 written write VBN 37231 4442 51 by by IN 37231 4442 52 those those DT 37231 4442 53 Apostles apostle NNS 37231 4442 54 , , , 37231 4442 55 deliberately deliberately RB 37231 4442 56 telling tell VBG 37231 4442 57 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 58 what what WP 37231 4442 59 they -PRON- PRP 37231 4442 60 had have VBD 37231 4442 61 to to TO 37231 4442 62 say say VB 37231 4442 63 . . . 37231 4443 1 The the DT 37231 4443 2 work work NN 37231 4443 3 of of IN 37231 4443 4 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4443 5 which which WDT 37231 4443 6 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4443 7 mentions mention VBZ 37231 4443 8 being be VBG 37231 4443 9 , , , 37231 4443 10 however however RB 37231 4443 11 , , , 37231 4443 12 a a DT 37231 4443 13 mere mere JJ 37231 4443 14 collection collection NN 37231 4443 15 of of IN 37231 4443 16 discourses discourse NNS 37231 4443 17 of of IN 37231 4443 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 37231 4443 19 , , , 37231 4443 20 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4443 21 might may MD 37231 4443 22 naturally naturally RB 37231 4443 23 inquire inquire VB 37231 4443 24 what what WP 37231 4443 25 the the DT 37231 4443 26 Apostle(2 apostle(2 NN 37231 4443 27 ) ) -RRB- 37231 4443 28 himself -PRON- PRP 37231 4443 29 said say VBD 37231 4443 30 of of IN 37231 4443 31 the the DT 37231 4443 32 history history NN 37231 4443 33 and and CC 37231 4443 34 teaching teaching NN 37231 4443 35 of of IN 37231 4443 36 the the DT 37231 4443 37 Master Master NNP 37231 4443 38 . . . 37231 4444 1 The the DT 37231 4444 2 evidence evidence NN 37231 4444 3 of of IN 37231 4444 4 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4444 5 is be VBZ 37231 4444 6 in in IN 37231 4444 7 every every DT 37231 4444 8 respect respect NN 37231 4444 9 most most RBS 37231 4444 10 important important JJ 37231 4444 11 . . . 37231 4445 1 He -PRON- PRP 37231 4445 2 is be VBZ 37231 4445 3 the the DT 37231 4445 4 first first JJ 37231 4445 5 writer writer NN 37231 4445 6 who who WP 37231 4445 7 mentions mention VBZ 37231 4445 8 that that IN 37231 4445 9 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4445 10 and and CC 37231 4445 11 Mark Mark NNP 37231 4445 12 were be VBD 37231 4445 13 believed believe VBN 37231 4445 14 to to TO 37231 4445 15 have have VB 37231 4445 16 written write VBN 37231 4445 17 any any DT 37231 4445 18 works work NNS 37231 4445 19 at at RB 37231 4445 20 all all RB 37231 4445 21 ; ; : 37231 4445 22 but but CC 37231 4445 23 whilst whilst IN 37231 4445 24 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4445 25 shows show VBZ 37231 4445 26 that that IN 37231 4445 27 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4445 28 does do VBZ 37231 4445 29 not not RB 37231 4445 30 accord accord VB 37231 4445 31 any any DT 37231 4445 32 canonical canonical JJ 37231 4445 33 authority authority NN 37231 4445 34 even even RB 37231 4445 35 to to IN 37231 4445 36 the the DT 37231 4445 37 works work NNS 37231 4445 38 attributed attribute VBN 37231 4445 39 to to IN 37231 4445 40 them -PRON- PRP 37231 4445 41 , , , 37231 4445 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4445 43 description description NN 37231 4445 44 of of IN 37231 4445 45 those those DT 37231 4445 46 works work NNS 37231 4445 47 and and CC 37231 4445 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4445 49 general general JJ 37231 4445 50 testimony testimony NN 37231 4445 51 comes come VBZ 37231 4445 52 with with IN 37231 4445 53 crushing crush VBG 37231 4445 54 force force NN 37231 4445 55 against against IN 37231 4445 56 the the DT 37231 4445 57 pretensions pretension NNS 37231 4445 58 made make VBN 37231 4445 59 on on IN 37231 4445 60 behalf behalf NN 37231 4445 61 of of IN 37231 4445 62 our -PRON- PRP$ 37231 4445 63 Gospels Gospels NNPS 37231 4445 64 to to IN 37231 4445 65 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 37231 4445 66 origin origin NN 37231 4445 67 and and CC 37231 4445 68 authenticity authenticity NN 37231 4445 69 . . . 37231 4446 1 2 2 LS 37231 4446 2 We -PRON- PRP 37231 4446 3 may may MD 37231 4446 4 merely merely RB 37231 4446 5 remark remark VB 37231 4446 6 that that IN 37231 4446 7 Papias Papias NNP 37231 4446 8 does do VBZ 37231 4446 9 not not RB 37231 4446 10 call call VB 37231 4446 11 the the DT 37231 4446 12 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4446 13 who who WP 37231 4446 14 wrote write VBD 37231 4446 15 the[--Greek-- the[--greek-- NN 37231 4446 16 ] ] -RRB- 37231 4446 17 an an DT 37231 4446 18 Apostle apostle NN 37231 4446 19 . . . 37231 4447 1 In in IN 37231 4447 2 this this DT 37231 4447 3 passage passage NN 37231 4447 4 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4447 5 speaks speak VBZ 37231 4447 6 of of IN 37231 4447 7 the the DT 37231 4447 8 Apostle apostle NN 37231 4447 9 , , , 37231 4447 10 but but CC 37231 4447 11 he -PRON- PRP 37231 4447 12 does do VBZ 37231 4447 13 not not RB 37231 4447 14 distinctly distinctly RB 37231 4447 15 identify identify VB 37231 4447 16 him -PRON- PRP 37231 4447 17 with with IN 37231 4447 18 the the DT 37231 4447 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 37231 4447 20 of of IN 37231 4447 21 the the DT 37231 4447 22 other other JJ 37231 4447 23 passage passage NN 37231 4447 24 . . . 37231 4448 1 END END NNP 37231 4448 2 OF of IN 37231 4448 3 VOL VOL NNP 37231 4448 4 . . . 37231 4449 1 I. I. NNP